Selbstsein und Anerkennung: Theologisch-philosophische Erkundungsgänge im Spannungsfeld von Ich, Wir und Gott 9783161616952, 9783161618697, 3161616952
115 102 4MB
German Pages 449 [450] Year 2022
Cover
Titel
Vorwort
Inhaltsverzeichnis
Einleitung: Gott zwischen Ich und Wir
1. Selbstsein und Anerkennung - philosophisch
2. Selbstsein und Anerkennung - theologisch
3. Theologisch-philosophische Erkundungsgänge: zum Aufbau der Arbeit
A. Gott zwischen lch und Wir - theologische Perspektiven auf das Verhältnis von Selbstsein und Anerkennung
Einleitung: Theologische Perspektiven
A.1 Der Mensch zwischen göttlicher und sozialer Anerkennung: Eberhard Jungels Reformulierung des Rechtfertigungsartikels
Einleitung
1. Widersprüche: menschliches Anerkennungsstreben und göttliche Anerkennung
1.1 Personsein und Anerkennung
1.1.1 Geschöpflichkeit: Die Konstitution der Person durch Gott
1.1.2 Die Herkunft des Selbstverhaltnisses aus dem Weltverhältnis
1.1.3 Zur Differenz von Welt- und Gottesverhältnis
1.2 Selbstverwirklichung und Sünde
1.2.1 Selbstverwirklichung als neuzeitliches ldeal
1.2.2 Selbstverwirklichung als Sünde
2. Zuspruch: Rechtfertigung als definitive Anerkennung des Menschen durch Gott
2.1 Rechtfertigung als Definition Gottes und des Menschen
2.2 Aspekte rechtfertigender Anerkennung: die reformatorischen Exklusivpartikel
2.2.1 Solus Christus, oder: der definitive Charakter göttlicher Anerkennung
2.2.2 Sola gratia, oder: der bedingungslose Charakter göttlicher Anerkennung
2.2.3 Solo verbo, oder: die Externitat göttlicher Anerkennung
2.2.4 Sola fide, oder: die Anerkennung göttlicher Anerkennung
2.3 Yom Glauben zum Handeln aus Anerkennung: Innerer und äußerer Mensch
3. Entsprechungen: Göttliche Anerkennung - menschliche Anerkennung
3.1 Der Gottesdienst: Institutionalisierte Unterbrechung menschlichen Anerkennungsdrangs und Ort der Erschließung definitiver Anerkennung
3.2 Der Primat des Personseins vor den Werken als sozialethische Konsequenz des Rechtfertigungsglaubens
3.2.1 Anerkennung in Staat und Recht: theologische Zumutungen an den Gesetzgeber
3.2.2 Bioethische Grundfragen: Zur Anerkennung des Noch-Nicht- und Nicht-mehr-leistungsfähigen Lebens
3.2.3 Arbeit und Wirtschaft: Anerkennung diesseits von Lebensleistungen
4. Fazit
Obergang: Wagner vs. Jüngel - oder: warum Freiheit nicht (nur) aus Gott sein kann
1. Die Passivitätszumutungen der christlichen Freiheit
1.1 Göttliche Aktivität vs menschliche Passivität
1.2 Innere vs äußere Freiheit
2. ,,Noch nicht der christliche Gott": Wagners Kritik an Jüngels Gottesbegriff
A.2 Gott als Prädikat gelingender Zwischenmenschlichkeit: Falk Wagners Theologie der Anerkennung
Einleitung
1. Revolutionen: Göttliche Anerkennung und menschliche Freiheit
1.1 Das Scheitern des unmittelbar selbstmächtig-selbständigen Gottes
1.1.1 Bestimmte Selbstbestimmung: die Möglichkeit der Wirklichkeit
1.1.2 Yon der Asymmetrie zur Symmetrie: die Relationalität der Wirklichkeit
1.2 Auswege aus dem Scheitern Gottes
1.2.1 Retheologisierung: der trinitätstheologische Ausweg
1.2.2 Enttheologisierung: der anerkennungslogische Ausweg
1.3 Revolutionierte Freiheit
2. Konfrontationen: Göttliche Anerkennung und moderne Gesellschaft
2.1 In ,gottloser' Gesellschaft: Folgen der Sakularisierung
2.1.1 Gottesverlust: die Revolutionen der Moderne
2.1.2 Bindungsverlust: die Freiheit zur (Nicht-)Religion
2.1.3 Der Verlust als Gewinn
2.2 In ,weltloser' Gemeinschaft: Konsequenzen der Wort-Gottes- Theologie
2.2.1 Ausstieg aus der Modernisierung
2.2.2 Rückkehr zum Gehorsam
2.3 In zweideutigen Verhältnissen: Ambivalenzen des modernen Freiheitsideals
2.3.1 Ambivalente Moderne
2.3.2 Ambivalente Individualitätskultur
2.4 In kontrafaktischen Sphären: Möglichkeiten der (christlichen) Religion
3. Übersetzungen: Göttliche und soziale Anerkennung
3.1 Recht: geordnete Freiheit zwischen Anerkennung und Zwang
3.1.1 Das Verhältnis von Recht und (christlicher) Religion
3.1.2 Das Beispiel des Schwangerschaftsabbruchs
3.2 Wirtschaft: Der Gott des Geldes gegen den Gott der Anerkennung
3.3 Kirche: Vom geistlichen zum alltäglichen Gottesdienst
4. Fazit
Übergang: Koch vs. Wagner - oder: warum Anerkennung nicht das Absolute ist
1. Warum Anerkennung nicht das Absolute ist...
2. .und wie stattdessen das Absolute zu denken ist
A.3 Unbedingtes Selbstsein und unverfugbare Anerkennung: Traugott Kochs Begrundung einer frei gewollten Sozialität
Einleitung
1. Gott und Mensch: Einheit in Verschiedenheit - Verschiedenheit ohne Einheit
1.1 Religion: Sich-Bestimmen-Lassen
1.1.1 Freiheit jenseits von totalem Bestimmen und absolutem Bestimmtwerden
1.1.2 Das Subjekt zwischen Absolutheit und Selbstverabsolutierung
1.1.3 Gott zwischen den Menschen
1.1.4 Bleibende Differenzen
1.1.5 Der Mensch zwischen Stünde und Gottebenbildlichkeit
1.2 Gott: Für sich und unter uns
1.2.1 Gott selbst: Die Allmacht des Guten, der Liebe und der Wahrheit
1.2.2 Gott und Mensch: Kooperation mit dem Absoluten im Endlichen
1.2.3 Gott als Subjekt: Reminiszenzen eines vorkritischen Theismus?
1.2.4 Gottes Reich: Das Unbedingte im Bedingten
2. Mensch und Mensch: Freiheit durch Anerkennung - Anerkennung aus Freiheit
2.1 Zwischen Anerkennung und Freiheit
2.2 Recht: Zwischen Formalität und Inhaltlichkeit
2.2.1 Menschenwürde: Freiheit um ihrer selbst willen
2.2.2 Die Unabdingbarkeit rechtlich gesicherter Anerkennung
2.2.3 Der richtige Umgang mit dem Recht
2.3 Familie und Ehe
2.3.1 Familie: Zwischen Eltern und Kindern
2.3.2 Ehe: Fragile Gemeinsamkeit
2.4 Wirtschaft: Zwischen Eigennutz und Gemeinsinn
2.5 Staat und Politik: Zwischen Ermöglichung und Zwang
2.6 Kirche: Zwischen Institution und Gewissen
3. Fazit
B. Ich oder Wir? - Philosophische Perspektiven auf das Verhältnis von Selbstsein und Anerkennung
Einleitung: Ich oder Wir?
1. Der Primat des Wir: Axel Honneths Kritische Theorie der Anerkennung
2. Die Unangepasstheit des Ich: Joel Whitebooks Kritik des Intersubjektivismus
3. Zur Gliederung des Kapitels
B.1 Honneth vs. Whitebook I: Von Hobbes zu Hegel und zurük
Einleitung: Hobbes und Hegel
1. Vorgängige Intersubjektivität: Honneths anerkennungstheoretische Hegeldeutung
2. Ursprüngliche Unverbundenheit: Whitebooks hobbesianistische Hegeldeutung
3. Jenseits von Selbstgewinn und Selbstverlust: ein Seitenblick auf Judith Butler
4. Gott als Geheimnis des Selbst - Theologische Reflexionen im Gespraäch mit Eberhard Jüngel
B.2 Honneth vs. Whitebook II: Von Freud zu Winnicott und zurück
Einleitung: Omnipotence or fusion?
1. Verschmelzungssehnsüchte: Honneths intersubjektivistische Winnicottdeutung
1.1 Trennungsschmerzen: von der Abhängigkeit zur Unabhängigkeit
1.2 Fusionsbedürfnisse: die bleibende Abhängigkeit von der primären Intersubjektivität
1.2.1 Alleinseinkönnen: im Schutze einer gefühlten Intersubjektivität
1.2.2 Die Ich-Grenzen aufheben: Vergegenwartigungen erfüllter Intersubjektivität
2. Allmachtsfantasien: Whitebooks hobbesianistische Winnicott-Deutung
2.1 ,,The dark side of Winnicott": die antisoziale Tendenz des Subjekts
2.2 Zwischen Destruktion und Innovation: die Ambivalenz der Allmacht
3. Innerweltliche Transzendenz: das strittige Kriterium kritischer Gesellschaftstheorie
4. Gott zwischen Immanenz und Transzendenz - theologische Reflexionen
B.3 Honneth vs. Whitebook III: Von der Subjektphilosophie zur Intersubjektivitatstheorie und zuruck
Einleitung: Hobbes und Habermas
1. Abschied vom Subjekt: Habermas, Honneth und die kommunikative Wende
1.1 Mead-Rezeption I: Das Selbst als Produkt sozialer Interaktion
1.2 Mead-Rezeption II: Das widerständige Ich und die kontrafaktische Intersubjektivität
2. Ausgang beim Subjekt: Whitebooks Widerruf der kommunikativen Wende
2.1 Vorgangige Selbstvertrautheit: mit Henrich gegen den Intersubjektivismus
2.2 AuBersoziale Kritikinstanz: mit Sacks gegen den Intersubjektivismus
3. Soziale Bedingungen der Autonomie? Beate Rösslers Kritik an Honneth
4. Gott in Gewissen und Gemeinsamkeit - theologische Reflexionen
C. Subjekte von heute zwischen Ich, Wir und Gott - Gegenwartsdiagnostische Perspektiven auf das Verhältnis von Selbstsein und Anerkennung
Einleitung: Subjekte von heute zwischen Selbstsein und Anerkennung
1. Gegenwartdiagnostische Grundthese: Das Anerkennungsvakuum
2. Zum Aufbau des Kapitels
C.1 Ausgebrannt und fertig mit sich selbst? Das erschöpfte Subjekt zwischen Selbstsein, Anerkennung und Gott
1. Erschopfungsgefühle - zwischen Empirie und Empfinden
2. Stabilitätsverlust - vom sicheren Anerkanntsein zum Dauerwettkampf um Anerkennung
3. Burnout - zwischen erschöpfendem Anerkennungsverlangen und kompensatorischer Ersatzanerkennung
4. Vorsorge - zwischen Entlastung und (Zusatz-)Belastung
5. Erlosungshoffnungen - zwischen Schwäche und Stärke
C.2 Bin ich, was wir sind? Das identitätspolitische Subjekt zwischen Selbstsein, Anerkennung und Gott
1. Allgemeinheitsbezug und Besonderungswille: Die Crux mit der Identitätspolitik
2. Von konstruktiv bis fundamentalistisch: Ursachen und Typen der Identitätspolitik
3. Das Partikulare auf Kosten des Allgemeinen: zur Kritik linker Identitätspolitik
4. Das Kollektive und das Individuelle die fingierte Identität der Identitätspolitik
5. Jenseits des (anti-)identitätspolitischen Wir - theologische Reflexionen
C.3 Ich werde geliebt, also bin ich? Das amourose Subjekt zwischen Selbstsein, Anerkennung und Gott
1. Die ambivalente Macht der Liebe
2. Das verunsicherte Begehren
3. Zwischen Autonomiebedürfnis und Anerkennungsverlangen
4. Mit Gott lieben: Zwischen Alleinsein und Zusammensein
Epilog
Literaturverzeichnis
Namensregister
Sachregister
Recommend Papers
![Intermedialität und Kulturaustausch: Beobachtungen im Spannungsfeld von Künsten und Medien [1. Aufl.]
9783839411001](https://ebin.pub/img/200x200/intermedialitt-und-kulturaustausch-beobachtungen-im-spannungsfeld-von-knsten-und-medien-1-aufl-9783839411001.jpg)
- Author / Uploaded
- Karl Tetzlaff
File loading please wait...
Citation preview
Dogmatik in der Moderne Herausgegeben von
Christian Danz, Jörg Dierken, Hans-Peter Großhans und Friederike Nüssel
39
Karl Tetzlaff
Selbstsein und Anerkennung Theologisch-philosophische Erkundungsgänge im Spannungsfeld von Ich, Wir und Gott
Mohr Siebeck
Karl Tetzlaff, geboren 1987; 2008 − 2016 Studium der Ev. Theologie in Berlin, Prag und Halle; 2022 Promotion, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg; seit 2021 wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg. orcid.org / 0000-0001-6667-1040
ISBN 978-3-16-161695-2 / eISBN 978-3-16-161869-7 DOI 10.1628/978-3-16-161869-7 ISSN 1869-3962 / eISSN 2569-3913 (Dogmatik in der Moderne) Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Natio nalbibliographie; detaillierte bibliographische Daten sind über http://dnb.dnb.de abrufbar. © 2022 Mohr Siebeck Tübingen. www.mohrsiebeck.com Das Werk einschließlich aller seiner Teile ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Jede Verwertung außerhalb der engen Grenzen des Urheberrechtsgesetzes ist ohne Zustimmung des Verlags unzulässig und strafbar. Das gilt insbesondere für die Verbreitung, Vervielfältigung, Übersetzung und die Einspeicherung und Verarbeitung in elektronischen Systemen. Das Buch wurde von Laupp & Göbel in Gomaringen auf alterungsbeständiges Werkdruckpapier gedruckt und von der Buchbinderei Nädele in Nehren gebunden. Printed in Germany.
«ZLUN|QQHQ]ZDUGLH1DWLRQHQDXIKHEHQ DEHUQLFKWGDV%HIUHPGHQZHQQ]ZHL0HQVFKHQDXIHLQDQGHUWUHIIHQ« 1RUD%RVVRQJ6FKXW]]RQH
9RUZRUW $P6LOYHVWHUDEHQGNRQIURQWLHUWHPLFKHLQ*OFNVNHNVPLWGHUIROJHQGHQ DXVVLFKWVUHLFKHQ%RWVFKDIW Ä6LHZHUGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJILQGHQ³)UGHQ9HUIDV VHUHLQHUDXIGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIIRNXVVLHUWHQ$UEHLWZDUGDVDXIPHKUHUOHL :HLVHHLQHJXWH1DFKULFKW6LHNQGLJWHQLFKWQXUGLHVFKOXVVHQGOLFKJHOLQJHQGH %HZlOWLJXQJGHVWUDNWLHUWHQ7KHPDVDQVRQGHUQOLHVLFKDXFKDOVHLQ9RUYHU ZHLV DXI GLH ILQDOH 9HUOHLKXQJ GHV 'RNWRUWLWHOV OHVHQ 0LWKLQ VWHOOWH GLH LP *OFNVNHNVHQWKDOWHQH%RWVFKDIWHLQPDOPHKUGLHVWDUNH5HOHYDQ]GHVJHZl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lW GHU 0DUWLQ/XWKHU 8QLYHUVLWlW+DOOH:LWWHQEHUJDQJHQRPPHQXQGHEHQGRUWDP-DQXDU HUIROJUHLFKYHUWHLGLJWZXUGH,QLKUHP)DOOKDWVLFKGLH9RUKHUVDJHYRPHUZlKQ WHQ6LOYHVWHUDEHQGIUPLFKDOVRHUIOOWZDVNHLQHVZHJVQXUGDV(UJHEQLVHLJH QHU/HLVWXQJHQGDUVWHOOW9LHOPHKUKDEHLFKDXIGHP:HJKLQ]XGLHVHPJOFNOL FKHQ(QGHYRQGHQ,PSXOVHQYRQGHU8QWHUVWW]XQJXQGYRP=XWUDXHQYLHOHU 0HQVFKHQJHOHEWGHQHQQXQ]XGDQNHQLVW $QHUVWHU6WHOOHLVWKLHUPHLQ'RNWRUYDWHU3URI'U-|UJ'LHUNHQ]XQHQQHQ ,KPYHUGDQNHLFKLQVEHVRQGHUHGLHSUlJHQGH(LQVLFKWGDVV*RWWXQG5HOLJLRQ DXVJHKHQGYRP6SDQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWXQG,QWHUVXEMHNWLYL WlW]XEHJUHLIHQVLQG,QVHLQHUQRUGGHXWVFKHQ/LEHUDOLWlWKDWHUPLFKHEHQVR]XP XQDEKlQJLJHQ6HOEVWGHQNHQHUPXWLJWZLHPHLQH$XVIKUXQJHQLQKRKHU=XYHU OlVVLJNHLWPLWVWHWVJHZLQQEULQJHQGHQ.RPPHQWDUHQYHUVHKHQZHQQHVJHZROOW ZDU$XIVHLQHQJXWHQ5DWXQGVHLQHWlWLJH+LOIHNRQQWHXQGNDQQLFKLPPHU ]lKOHQ1LFKW]XOHW]WKDWHUDXFKGLH0KHQGHV(UVWJXWDFKWHQVDXIVLFKJHQRP PHQ)UDOOGDVVHLLKPKHU]OLFKJHGDQNW
'HUXUVSUQJOLFKH7LWHOGHU'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWODXWHWH *RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU7KHR ORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH(UNXQGXQJVJlQJHLPVR]LDOHQ6SDQQXQJVIHOGYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHU NHQQXQJ
9,,,
9RUZRUW
3URI'U'LUN(YHUVGDQNHLFKIUGLH9HUIHUWLJXQJGHV=ZHLWJXWDFKWHQV 0LW3URI'U1RWJHU6OHQF]NDGHUGDQNHQVZHUWHU:HLVHDOVPHLQ=ZHLWEH WUHXHU IXQJLHUW XQG GDV DXHUIDNXOWlUH 'ULWWJXWDFKWHQ YHUIDVVW KDW YHUELQGHQ PLFKGLH-DKUHPHLQHU%HUOLQHU6WXGLHQ]HLW%HLLKPKDEHLFKQHEHQYLHOHPDQ GHUHQJHOHUQWGDVV*RWWXQG*ODXEHÃ]XKDXIHJHK|UHQµ /XWKHU XQGDOOH*H JHQVWlQGHGHV*ODXEHQVDOVVXEMHNWLYH6HOEVWDXVVDJHQ]XGHFKLIIULHUHQVLQG 0HLQ'DQNJLOWDXFKDOOMHQHQGXUFKGHUHQ%LOGXQJVDQJHERWHLFKQHEHQGHQ VRHEHQ*HQDQQWHQLP/DXIHGHU6FKXO]HLWXQGGHV6WXGLXPVQDFKKDOWLJH,PSXO VHHUIDKUHQKDEH 3URI'U8OULFK%DUWK3URI'U9RONHU*HUKDUGW3URI'U (LOHUW+HUPV5HJLQH+XSSHQEDXHU.UDXVH3URI'U:LOKHOP*UlE'U'RUR WKHD1RRUGYHOG/RUHQ]'U3HWHU0RUpH3''U0DJQXV6FKOHWWH3''U$Q GUHDV6WHJPDQQ0LFKDHO:DOWHU3URI'U'RURWKHD:HQGHERXUJ3URI'U 0DUNXV:LWWH)DON=HQNHU3URI'U&KULVWRSKHU=DUQRZ 'DVVGLHLPNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ$XVWDXVFKPLWDQGHUHQYRQVWDWWHQJHKHQGH%LO GXQJGHUMHHLJHQHQWKHRORJLVFKHQ,GHQWLWlWDXFKQDFKGHP6WXGLXPQLFKWDE EULFKW KDEH LFK LP 5DKPHQ GHU %HUOLQHU XQG +DOOHQVHU 'RNWRUDQGHQNUHLVH GDQNEDUHUIDKUHQGUIHQ8QWHUGHQYLHOHQ*HVSUlFKVSDUWQHULQQHQXQGSDUWQHUQ YRQ GHUHQ %HLWUlJHQ LFK QLFKW QXU LQ GLHVHP .RQWH[W VHKU SURILWLHUW KDEH P|FKWHLFKGUHL*HGDQNHQIUHXQGHEHVRQGHUVKHUYRUKHEHQ &KULVWLQH6HHEHUJ 'U-DQ.LQJUHHQXQG'U&RQVWDQWLQ3ODXO )UWDWNUlIWLJH8QWHUVWW]XQJEHLGHQ.RUUHNWXUDUEHLWHQDQPHLQHU'LVVHUWDWL RQVVFKULIWXQGEHLGHU9RUEHUHLWXQJDXIGHUHQ9HUWHLGLJXQJGDQNHLFKDOOHQYR UDQPHLQHU6FKZHVWHU'U$QQD0DULD.ODVVHQVRZLH6WHSKDQLH)UDQN'U-DQ .LQJUHHQ'U&RQVWDQWLQ3ODXO6LPRQH6FKW]-XGLWK7HW]ODIIXQG'U0LULDP :RMDNRZVND.DUVWHQ3DKOVGDQNHLFKIUVHLQH8QWHUVWW]XQJEHLGHU6FKOXVV NRUUHNWXUXQGGHU5HJLVWHUHUVWHOOXQJ 'LH6WXGLHQVWLIWXQJGHV'HXWVFKHQ9RONHVKDWGLH9HUIHUWLJXQJGLHVHU$UEHLW GXUFKGLH*HZlKUXQJHLQHV3URPRWLRQVVWLSHQGLXPVHUP|JOLFKW6WHOOYHUWUHWHQG IUGLHJUR]JLJHLGHHOOHXQGILQDQ]LHOOH)|UGHUXQJGDQNHLFK'U.DWKDULQD .QlSSHU)UGLH*HZlKUXQJYRQ'UXFNNRVWHQ]XVFKVVHQGDQNHLFKGHU9HUHL QLJWHQ (YDQJHOLVFK/XWKHULVFKH .LUFKH 'HXWVFKODQGV GHU (YDQJHOLVFK /XWKHULVFKHQ.LUFKHLQ1RUGGHXWVFKODQGXQGGHU(YDQJHOLVFKHQ.LUFKHLQ0LW WHOGHXWVFKODQG'HP9HUODJ0RKU6LHEHFNLQVEHVRQGHUH'U+HQQLQJ=LHEULW]NL XQG'U.DWKDULQD*XWHNXQVWGDQNHLFKIUGLHYHUOHJHULVFKH%HWUHXXQJ)UGLH $XIQDKPHGLHVHU8QWHUVXFKXQJLQGLH5HLKH'RJPDWLNLQGHU0RGHUQHGDQNH LFKGHQ]XVWlQGLJHQ+HUDXVJHEHULQQHQXQG+HUDXVJHEHUQ 0HLQOHW]WHU'DQNJLOWPHLQHU)DPLOLHXQGPHLQHQ)UHXQGHQIUDOOH8QWHU VWW]XQJLQVEHVRQGHUHDEHUPHLQHU)UDX-XGLWK,KU$QWHLOGDUDQGDVVGLHYRU OLHJHQGH$UEHLW±QLFKWQXUWURW]/RFNGRZQVXQGJHVFKORVVHQHU.LWDV±IHUWLJ JHZRUGHQLVWOlVVWVLFKNDXPLQ:RUWHIDVVHQ %HUOLQDPQHXQWHQ6RQQWDJQDFK7ULQLWDWLV
.DUO7HW]ODII
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV ,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
9RUZRUW9 (LQOHLWXQJ *RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU 6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ±SKLORVRSKLVFK 6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ±WKHRORJLVFK 7KHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH(UNXQGXQJVJlQJH ]XP$XIEDXGHU$UEHLW
$*RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU±WKHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQDXI GDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ (LQOHLWXQJ 7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ $ 'HU0HQVFK]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJ (EHUKDUG-QJHOV5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDUWLNHOV (LQOHLWXQJ :LGHUVSUFKH PHQVFKOLFKHV$QHUNHQQXQJVVWUHEHQXQGJ|WWOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ 3HUVRQVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ *HVFK|SIOLFKNHLW 'LH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHU3HUVRQGXUFK*RWW 'LH+HUNXQIWGHV6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVVHVDXVGHP:HOWYHUKlOWQLV =XU'LIIHUHQ]YRQ:HOWXQG*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLV 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJXQG6QGH 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDOVQHX]HLWOLFKHV,GHDO 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDOV6QGH =XVSUXFK 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDOVGHILQLWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ GXUFK*RWW 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDOV'HILQLWLRQ*RWWHVXQGGHV0HQVFKHQ $VSHNWHUHFKWIHUWLJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ GLHUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ([NOXVLYSDUWLNHO
;
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
6ROXV&KULVWXVRGHU GHUGHILQLWLYH&KDUDNWHUJ|WWOLFKHU $QHUNHQQXQJ 6RODJUDWLDRGHU GHUEHGLQJXQJVORVH&KDUDNWHUJ|WWOLFKHU $QHUNHQQXQJ 6RORYHUERRGHU GLH([WHUQLWlWJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 6RODILGHRGHU GLH$QHUNHQQXQJJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 9RP*ODXEHQ]XP+DQGHOQDXV$QHUNHQQXQJ ,QQHUHUXQGlXHUHU0HQVFK (QWVSUHFKXQJHQ *|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJ±PHQVFKOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJ 'HU*RWWHVGLHQVW ,QVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWH8QWHUEUHFKXQJPHQVFKOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVGUDQJVXQG2UWGHU(UVFKOLHXQJGHILQLWLYHU $QHUNHQQXQJ 'HU3ULPDWGHV3HUVRQVHLQVYRUGHQ:HUNHQDOVVR]LDOHWKLVFKH .RQVHTXHQ]GHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJODXEHQV $QHUNHQQXQJLQ6WDDWXQG5HFKW WKHRORJLVFKH=XPXWXQJHQDQ GHQ*HVHW]JHEHU %LRHWKLVFKH*UXQGIUDJHQ =XU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV1RFK1LFKW XQG1LFKWPHKUOHLVWXQJVIlKLJHQ/HEHQV $UEHLWXQG:LUWVFKDIW $QHUNHQQXQJGLHVVHLWVYRQ /HEHQVOHLVWXQJHQ )D]LW hEHUJDQJ :DJQHUYV-QJHO±RGHU ZDUXP)UHLKHLWQLFKW QXU DXV*RWW VHLQNDQQ 'LH3DVVLYLWlWV]XPXWXQJHQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLW *|WWOLFKH$NWLYLWlWYVPHQVFKOLFKH3DVVLYLWlW ,QQHUHYVlXHUH)UHLKHLW Ä1RFKQLFKWGHUFKULVWOLFKH*RWW³ :DJQHUV.ULWLNDQ-QJHOV*RWWHVEHJULII $ *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKNHLW )DON:DJQHUV7KHRORJLHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ (LQOHLWXQJ 5HYROXWLRQHQ *|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJXQGPHQVFKOLFKH)UHLKHLW 'DV6FKHLWHUQGHVXQPLWWHOEDUVHOEVWPlFKWLJVHOEVWlQGLJHQ *RWWHV %HVWLPPWH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ GLH0|JOLFKNHLW GHU:LUNOLFKNHLW 9RQGHU$V\PPHWULH]XU6\PPHWULH GLH5HODWLRQDOLWlWGHU :LUNOLFKNHLW $XVZHJHDXVGHP6FKHLWHUQ*RWWHV 5HWKHRORJLVLHUXQJ GHUWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKH$XVZHJ
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
;,
(QWWKHRORJLVLHUXQJ GHUDQHUNHQQXQJVORJLVFKH$XVZHJ 5HYROXWLRQLHUWH)UHLKHLW .RQIURQWDWLRQHQ *|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJXQGPRGHUQH*HVHOOVFKDIW ,QÃJRWWORVHUµ*HVHOOVFKDIW )ROJHQGHU6lNXODULVLHUXQJ *RWWHVYHUOXVW GLH5HYROXWLRQHQGHU0RGHUQH %LQGXQJVYHUOXVW GLH)UHLKHLW]XU 1LFKW 5HOLJLRQ 'HU9HUOXVWDOV*HZLQQ ,QÃZHOWORVHUµ*HPHLQVFKDIW .RQVHTXHQ]HQGHU:RUW*RWWHV 7KHRORJLH $XVVWLHJDXVGHU0RGHUQLVLHUXQJ 5FNNHKU]XP*HKRUVDP ,Q]ZHLGHXWLJHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ $PELYDOHQ]HQGHVPRGHUQHQ )UHLKHLWVLGHDOV $PELYDOHQWH0RGHUQH $PELYDOHQWH,QGLYLGXDOLWlWVNXOWXU ,QNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ6SKlUHQ 0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU FKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQ hEHUVHW]XQJHQ *|WWOLFKHXQGVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJ 5HFKW JHRUGQHWH)UHLKHLW]ZLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG=ZDQJ 'DV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ5HFKWXQG FKULVWOLFKHU 5HOLJLRQ 'DV%HLVSLHOGHV6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKV :LUWVFKDIW 'HU*RWWGHV*HOGHVJHJHQGHQ*RWW GHU$QHUNHQQXQJ .LUFKH 9RPJHLVWOLFKHQ]XPDOOWlJOLFKHQ*RWWHVGLHQVW )D]LW hEHUJDQJ .RFKYV:DJQHU±RGHU ZDUXP$QHUNHQQXQJQLFKW GDV$EVROXWHLVW :DUXP$QHUNHQQXQJQLFKWGDV$EVROXWHLVW« «XQGZLHVWDWWGHVVHQGDV$EVROXWH]XGHQNHQLVW $ 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ 7UDXJRWW.RFKV%HJUQGXQJHLQHUIUHLJHZROOWHQ6R]LDOLWlW (LQOHLWXQJ *RWWXQG0HQVFK (LQKHLWLQ9HUVFKLHGHQKHLW±9HUVFKLHGHQKHLWRKQH (LQKHLW 5HOLJLRQ 6LFK%HVWLPPHQ/DVVHQ )UHLKHLWMHQVHLWVYRQWRWDOHP%HVWLPPHQXQGDEVROXWHP %HVWLPPWZHUGHQ 'DV6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ$EVROXWKHLW XQG6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJ *RWW]ZLVFKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQ
;,,
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
%OHLEHQGH'LIIHUHQ]HQ 'HU0HQVFK]ZLVFKHQ6QGHXQG*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLW *RWW )UVLFKXQGXQWHUXQV *RWWVHOEVW 'LH$OOPDFKWGHV*XWHQGHU/LHEH XQGGHU:DKUKHLW *RWWXQG0HQVFK .RRSHUDWLRQPLWGHP$EVROXWHQ LP(QGOLFKHQ *RWWDOV6XEMHNW 5HPLQLV]HQ]HQHLQHV YRUNULWLVFKHQ7KHLVPXV" *RWWHV5HLFK 'DV8QEHGLQJWHLP%HGLQJWHQ 0HQVFKXQG0HQVFK )UHLKHLWGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJ± $QHUNHQQXQJDXV)UHLKHLW =ZLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG)UHLKHLW 5HFKW =ZLVFKHQ)RUPDOLWlWXQG,QKDOWOLFKNHLW 0HQVFKHQZUGH )UHLKHLWXPLKUHUVHOEVWZLOOHQ 'LH8QDEGLQJEDUNHLWUHFKWOLFKJHVLFKHUWHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'HUULFKWLJH8PJDQJPLWGHP5HFKW )DPLOLHXQG(KH )DPLOLH =ZLVFKHQ(OWHUQXQG.LQGHUQ (KH )UDJLOH*HPHLQVDPNHLW :LUWVFKDIW =ZLVFKHQ(LJHQQXW]XQG*HPHLQVLQQ 6WDDWXQG3ROLWLN =ZLVFKHQ(UP|JOLFKXQJXQG=ZDQJ .LUFKH =ZLVFKHQ,QVWLWXWLRQXQG*HZLVVHQ )D]LW
%,FKRGHU:LU"±3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQDXIGDV 9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ (LQOHLWXQJ ,FKRGHU:LU" 'HU3ULPDWGHV:LU $[HO+RQQHWKV.ULWLVFKH7KHRULH GHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'LH8QDQJHSDVVWKHLWGHV,FK -RHO:KLWHERRNV.ULWLNGHV ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV =XU*OLHGHUXQJGHV.DSLWHOV %+RQQHWKYV:KLWHERRN, 9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN (LQOHLWXQJ +REEHVXQG+HJHO 9RUJlQJLJH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW +RQQHWKVDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH +HJHOGHXWXQJ
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
;,,,
8UVSUQJOLFKH8QYHUEXQGHQKHLW :KLWHERRNVKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKH +HJHOGHXWXQJ -HQVHLWVYRQ6HOEVWJHZLQQXQG6HOEVWYHUOXVW HLQ6HLWHQEOLFN DXI-XGLWK%XWOHU *RWWDOV*HKHLPQLVGHV6HOEVW±7KHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQ % +RQQHWKYV:KLWHERRN,, 9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN (LQOHLWXQJ 2PQLSRWHQFHRUIXVLRQ" 9HUVFKPHO]XQJVVHKQVFKWH +RQQHWKVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKH :LQQLFRWWGHXWXQJ 7UHQQXQJVVFKPHU]HQ YRQGHU$EKlQJLJNHLW ]XU8QDEKlQJLJNHLW )XVLRQVEHGUIQLVVH GLHEOHLEHQGH$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQGHU SULPlUHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW $OOHLQVHLQN|QQHQ LP6FKXW]HHLQHU JHIKOWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW 'LH,FK*UHQ]HQDXIKHEHQ 9HUJHJHQZlUWLJXQJHQHUIOOWHU ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW $OOPDFKWVIDQWDVLHQ :KLWHERRNVKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKH :LQQLFRWW'HXWXQJ Ä7KHGDUNVLGHRI:LQQLFRWW³ GLHDQWLVR]LDOH7HQGHQ] GHV6XEMHNWV =ZLVFKHQ'HVWUXNWLRQXQG,QQRYDWLRQ GLH$PELYDOHQ] GHU$OOPDFKW ,QQHUZHOWOLFKH7UDQV]HQGHQ] GDVVWULWWLJH.ULWHULXPNULWLVFKHU *HVHOOVFKDIWVWKHRULH *RWW]ZLVFKHQ,PPDQHQ]XQG7UDQV]HQGHQ]± WKHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQ % +RQQHWKYV:KLWHERRN,,, 9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRULHXQG]XUFN (LQOHLWXQJ +REEHVXQG+DEHUPDV $EVFKLHGYRP6XEMHNW +DEHUPDV+RQQHWKXQGGLHNRPPXQLNDWLYH :HQGH 0HDG5H]HSWLRQ, 'DV6HOEVWDOV3URGXNWVR]LDOHU,QWHUDNWLRQ 0HDG5H]HSWLRQ,, 'DVZLGHUVWlQGLJH,FK XQGGLHNRQWUDIDNWLVFKH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW $XVJDQJEHLP6XEMHNW :KLWHERRNV:LGHUUXIGHU NRPPXQLNDWLYHQ:HQGH 9RUJlQJLJH6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLW PLW+HQULFKJHJHQ GHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV
;,9
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
$XHUVR]LDOH.ULWLNLQVWDQ] PLW6DFNVJHJHQ GHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV 6R]LDOH%HGLQJXQJHQGHU$XWRQRPLH" %HDWH5|VVOHUV.ULWLNDQ+RQQHWK *RWWLQ*HZLVVHQXQG*HPHLQVDPNHLW±WKHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQ
& 6XEMHNWHYRQKHXWH]ZLVFKHQ,FK:LUXQG*RWW± *HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQDXIGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ 6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ (LQOHLWXQJ 6XEMHNWHYRQKHXWH]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ *HJHQZDUWGLDJQRVWLVFKH*UXQGWKHVH 'DV$QHUNHQQXQJVYDNXXP =XP$XIEDXGHV.DSLWHOV & $XVJHEUDQQWXQGIHUWLJPLWVLFKVHOEVW"'DVHUVFK|SIWH6XEMHNW ]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW (UVFK|SIXQJVJHIKOH±]ZLVFKHQ(PSLULHXQG(PSILQGHQ 6WDELOLWlWVYHUOXVW±YRPVLFKHUHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQ]XP'DXHUZHWWNDPSI XP$QHUNHQQXQJ %XUQRXW±]ZLVFKHQHUVFK|SIHQGHP$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUODQJHQ XQGNRPSHQVDWRULVFKHU(UVDW]DQHUNHQQXQJ 9RUVRUJH±]ZLVFKHQ(QWODVWXQJXQG =XVDW] %HODVWXQJ (UO|VXQJVKRIIQXQJHQ±]ZLVFKHQ6FKZlFKHXQG6WlUNH & %LQLFKZDVZLUVLQG"'DVLGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ 6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW $OOJHPHLQKHLWVEH]XJXQG%HVRQGHUXQJVZLOOH 'LH&UX[PLWGHU ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN 9RQNRQVWUXNWLYELVIXQGDPHQWDOLVWLVFK 8UVDFKHQXQG7\SHQGHU ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN 'DV3DUWLNXODUHDXI.RVWHQGHV$OOJHPHLQHQ ]XU.ULWLNOLQNHU ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN 'DV.ROOHNWLYHXQGGDV,QGLYLGXHOOHGLHILQJLHUWH,GHQWLWlWGHU ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN -HQVHLWVGHV DQWL LGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKHQ:LU± WKHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQ & ,FKZHUGHJHOLHEWDOVRELQLFK"'DVDPRXU|VH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ 6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW
,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV
;9
'LHDPELYDOHQWH0DFKWGHU/LHEH 'DVYHUXQVLFKHUWH%HJHKUHQ =ZLVFKHQ$XWRQRPLHEHGUIQLVXQG$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUODQJHQ 0LW*RWWOLHEHQ =ZLVFKHQ$OOHLQVHLQXQG=XVDPPHQVHLQ
(SLORJ
/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV 1DPHQVUHJLVWHU 6DFKUHJLVWHU
(LQOHLWXQJ *RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU (LQOHLWXQJ
'HQQMHGHV:LUVLQGYLHOH,FKV
=ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LULVWYLHO3ODW]IU.RQIOLNWH9RPJHPHLQVFKDIWVIHLQGOL FKHQ(JRLVPXVELV]XPNROOHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ$QSDVVXQJV]ZDQJVLQGGDEHLXQWHU VFKLHGOLFKVWH([WUHPELOGXQJHQP|JOLFK:RKOZHJHQVROFKHU.RQIURQWDWLRQHQ JHK|UWÄ>G@DV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ,FKXQG:LU³ZLHHVEHL8ZH-XVWXV:HQ]HOKHLW Ä]XPEHLQDKH]HLWORVHQ]HQWUDOHQ3UREOHPEHVWDQGDOOHVHUQVWOLFKHQ1DFKGHQNHQV EHUGDV6R]LDOH³$XV:HQ]HOV6LFKWPXVVPDQDEHUÄ]XJXWHU/HW]WGRFK+H JHOUHFKW>«@JHEHQ³GHVVHQÄ%HJULIIGHV*HLVWHV>«@XQEHUELHWEDUHOHPHQWDU VRJHIDVVW³LVWGDVVGXUFKLKQHLQYHUV|KQOLFKHV(QGHLQGHQ%OLFNNRPPW Ä,FK GDV:LUXQG:LUGDV,FKLVW³*HJHQGLHVHSRVLWLYH$XVVLFKWHLQHVEHIULHGHWHQ ,FK:LU9HUKlOWQLVVHVGHPQDFKGDVHLQ]HOQH6XEMHNWLP0LWHLQDQGHUPLW$QGH UHQ]XVLFKILQGHWXQGXPJHNHKUWOlVVWVLFKZHQLJHLQZHQGHQ'LH)UDJHLVWQXU REXQGZLHPDQVLH±JDUGDXHUKDIW±LQVR]LDOH:LUNOLFKNHLW]XEHUIKUHQYHU PDJ 'LHVHV3UREOHPGUlQJWVLFKDOOHPDOGDQQDXIÄZHQQGLHYRUKHUUVFKHQGH0HQ WDOLWlWHLQHU*HVHOOVFKDIWLQLKUH([WUHPH]X]HUIDOOHQGURKW³ZLH5RVPDULH%DU ZLQVNLXQG2OLYHU&KULVWHQQLFKWQXUKLHU]XODQGHGLH6WLPPXQJDQJHVLFKWVGHU &RURQD3DQGHPLHXQWHUGHUHQ%HGLQJXQJHQJURH7HLOHGLHVHU$UEHLWHQWVWDQ GHQVLQGHLQVFKlW]HQ(LQHPÄÃ,FKGDVNHLQ:LULVWµ³XQGGDVVLFKLQHLQHP
'LH=HLOHHQWVWDPPWGHP6RQJÄ:DJHQEXUJ³GHU+DPEXUJHU%DQG.HWWFDUGHUDOV7LWHO VRQJLKUHVHUVFKLHQHQ$OEXPVÄ,FKYV:LU³JHOWHQNDQQ YJO.HWWFDU Ä:DJHQ EXUJ³LVWHLQHZDKUH)XQGJUXEHZDVGLH6SDQQXQJHQLP,FK:LU9HUKlOWQLVDQJHKWZDVQXU DQKDQGGHUHUVWHQ6WURSKHLOOXVWULHUWZHUGHQVROO Ä(LQ,FKVFKUHLEWRQOLQH.RPPHQWDUH8QG WUlXPWYRQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ(LQ:LUJHKWUDXVUDXVDXIGLH6WUDH8QGWUlXPWYRQ 6HOEVWHUPlFKWLJXQJ(LQ,FKLVWYROONRPPHQHUKDEHQhEHUNROOHNWLYH=ZlQJH+HUNXQIW XQG 0LOLHX ,Q )RUP YRQ ILHVHQ 0HQVFKHQPHQJHQ (LQ :LU LVW 6WXUP DXI GLH %DVWLOOH .RPPW]XVDPPHQÃ)LJKWWKHSRZHUµ(LQ:LUWUlXPWHLQH8WRSLH(LQ:LUOLHJWVWlQGLJDXI GHU/DXHU(LQ,FKVDJWRIWÃ*XWPHQVFKHQWXPµ(LQ:LUZLOODXFKPDOHWZDVWXQ8QGVLFK GDEHLGDQQVWlUNHUIKOHQ(LQ,FKZLOOQXUVLFKRSWLPLHUHQ(LQ:LUNHQQW6ROLGDULWlW(LQ ,FKLVWLPPHU(LQ]HONULHJHU(LQ:LUVFKUHLWODXWÃ,FKELQGDV9RONµ0RQWDJVPDUVFK 3HJLGD³ :(1=(/ :(1=(/ %$5:,16.,&+5,67(19JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2I
(LQOHLWXQJ
XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKDXVJHOHEWHQ5FN]XJDXIGLHMHHLJHQHQ%HGUIQLVVH,QWHUHVVHQ XQG3UREOHPHDXVGUFNWVHKHQVLHÄHLQÃ:LUGDVNHLQ,FKLVWµ³JHJHQEHUVWH KHQ/HW]WHUHVÄ:LU³VFKODJHVLFKLQHLQHUÄPLVVDFKWHQGH>Q@+DOWXQJ³JHJHQEHU GHQHQQLHGHUGLHÄGXUFKGLHDXIJUXQGGHU3DQGHPLHHLQJHIKUWHQ5HJHOXQJHQLQ >«@ 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ JHUDWHQ VLQG³ VLFK DEHU PLW LKUHQ /HLGHQVHUIDKUXQJHQ Ä]XP YHUPHLQWOLFKHQ :RKO GHU $OOJHPHLQKHLW DXVJHJUHQ]W³ ILQGHQ Ä%HLGH ([WUHPH³VFKUHLEHQ%DUZLQVNLXQG&KULVWHQÄEHGLQJHQVLFKJHJHQVHLWLJ³ZDV ]XUGULQJHQG]XEHDQWZRUWHQGHQ)UDJHIKUWZLHGLH]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGHÄ3RODUL VLHUXQJ >«@ ]ZLVFKHQ .ROOHNWLYHP XQG ,QGLYLGXHOOHP DXIJHKREHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ³ 'DVLVWNHLQHQHXH)UDJHXQGVLHZLUGDXFKQLFKWPLWGHU%HZlOWLJXQJGHU&R URQD.ULVH]XPDOWHQ(LVHQJHOHJWZHUGHQ2EHVXPSROLWLVFKH0DQDKPHQLP %HUHLFKYRQ)OXFKWXQG0LJUDWLRQJHKWXPGLH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP .OLPDZDQGHORGHUGLHLGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKHQ.lPSIHGHU*HJHQZDUW±VWHWVJHKW HV DXI YLHOIDFKH :HLVH DXFK GDUXP LQGLYLGXHOOEHVRQGHUH %HGUIQLV XQG ,QWHUHVVHQODJHQPLWGHPDE]XJOHLFKHQZDVDOVÃ:RKOGHU$OOJHPHLQKHLWµEH ]HLFKQHW ]X ZHUGHQ YHUGLHQW RKQH GDVV VLFK EHU GLHVHV $OOJHPHLQH LPPHU VFKRQDOOHHLQLJZlUHQ=ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LULVWHEHQYLHO3ODW]IU.RQIOLNWH GLHVLFKDOOHUGLQJVQLFKWDOOHLQDXIGDV)HOGGHV3ROLWLVFKHQLPHQJHUHQ6LQQH EHVFKUlQNHQ $XFK Ä>G@LH 3ULYDWVSKlUH OHEW YRQ >«@ :LU(LQVWHOOXQJHQ³ OlVVW VLFK PLW $[HO+RQQHWKVDJHQDXFKÄ)DPLOLH>Q@/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHQ³XQGÄ)UHXQGVFKDI WHQ³N|QQHQQXUJHOLQJHQZHQQGLHLQVLHHLQEH]RJHQHQÄ3HUVRQHQZLHHVEHL +HJHOKHLWZHFKVHOVHLWLJ(LQVFKUlQNXQJHQLKUHU(JR]HQWULN³]XJXQVWHQGHU MHZHLOVDQGHUHQYROO]LHKHQ Ä,Q)UHXQGVFKDIWHQ³VRPDFKWHUH[HPSODULVFKNODU ÄELQLFK³GDQQÄXPQRFKHLQPDO+HJHO]X]LWLHUHQEHLPLUVHOEVWLPDQGHUHQ XQGGDGXUFKDXIHLQHPLFKJHUDGH]XHUZHLWHUQGH:HLVHIUHL³'RFK)UHXQG VFKDIWHQN|QQHQHQGHQVHLHVDXIJUXQGHLQHVNRQNUHWHQ=HUZUIQLVVHVRGHUZHLO PDQVLFKVWLOOVFKZHLJHQGDXVHLQDQGHUJHOHEWKDW:HQQVLHHQGHQOlXIWMHGHQ IDOOVDXFKGLHDXIV=XVDPPHQVHLQPLWGHUEHIUHXQGHWHQ3HUVRQDXVJHULFKWHWH Ã:LU(LQVWHOOXQJµGHV,FKDXV'HUHQ8QVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKNHLWNRPPWPLWKLQ QLFKW HUVW LP 6FKHLWHUQ GHU %H]LHKXQJ DQV /LFKW 6FKRQ GHQ %HJLQQ HLQHU )UHXQGVFKDIWYHUPDJQLHPDQGLPVWDUNHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHVHLQIDFK]XLQLWLLHUHQ :HUVLHZLOOLVWGDUDXIDQJHZLHVHQGDVVGDVMHZHLOLJH*HJHQEHUVLHHEHQVR ZLOOXQG]ZDUEOHLEHQGÄ'LH)UHXQGVFKDIW³VFKUHLEW+HQQLQJ5LWWHUÄEHUXKWDXI GHUYHUPXWHWHQ%HVWlQGLJNHLWXQG(FKWKHLWGHVDQGHUHQ³ZDVVLFKLPPHUDXFK
$D2 (EG (EG (EG +211(7+12/7( (EG 5,77(5
(LQOHLWXQJ
DOVHLQH)HKOHLQVFKlW]XQJHQWSXSSHQNDQQ.XU]XQGJXW (U]ZLQJHQOlVVWVLFK HLQHVHOEVWEHUVFKUHLWHQGHÃ:LU(LQVWHOOXQJµMHGHQIDOOVEHLNHLQHUDQGHU)UHXQG VFKDIWEHWHLOLJWHQ3HUVRQHEHQVRZHQLJZLHGHUGDXHUKDIWH=XVDPPHQKDOWLQ HLQHU)DPLOLHRGHUGDV=XVDPPHQEOHLEHQHLQHV/LHEHVSDDUVJHVHW]OLFKUHJHOEDU VLQG *OHLFKHV JLOW DXFK MHQVHLWV GHU 3ULYDWVSKlUH LP 3ULQ]LS IU DOOHV ZDV LP ZDKUVWHQ 6LQQH GHV :RUWHV GXUFK 5HFKW XQG *HVHW] JHUHJHOW ZLUG Ä>(@V EUDXFKW³ZLH7KRPDVGH0DL]LpUHPLW%H]XJDXIGHQREHQDQJHGHXWHWHQÃ8Q ZLOOHQ]XP:LUµLQ=HLWHQGHU&RURQD.ULVHDQPHUNW HLQHQIUHLZLOOLJHQ5HFKWVJHKRUVDPVRQHQQHQZLU-XULVWHQGDVGHUGHP5HFKW8QWHUZRUIHQHQ :HQQGDVQLFKWVWDWWILQGHWJLEWHVHLQHFKWHV3UREOHP>«@>:@HQQ6LH$XVJDQJVEHVFKUlQ NXQJHQRGHU.RQWDNWYHUERWHYHUKlQJHQLVWGDVIOlFKHQGHFNHQGQLFKWNRQWUROOLHUEDUVRQGHUQ HVVHW]WYRUDXVGDVVGLHPHLVWHQ0HQVFKHQVLFKDXV9HUQXQIWGDUDQKDOWHQ6RODQJHHVQXUHLQ SDDU$XVUHLHUJLEWNDQQGLH3ROL]HLGDPLWXPJHKHQ:HUGHQHV]XYLHOHLVWGHU6WDDWPDFKW ORV'LHVHV9HUKlOWQLVVWHKWLQGHU'HPRNUDWLHLPPHUXQWHU6SDQQXQJ
'LHGHPQDFKXQEHUZLQGOLFKH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHQIUÃXQVDOOHµJHOWHQGHQ 5HJHOQGHV=XVDPPHQOHEHQVXQGLKUHUMHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ%HIUZRUWXQJE]Z%H IROJXQJOlVVWVLFKDEHUDXFKDXIGHU(EHQHGHUÃ3ULYDWVSKlUHµRGHUGHVVR]LDOHQ 1DKEHUHLFKVJHOWHQGPDFKHQ+LHULVWGDQQHWZDYRQGHPGLH5HGHZDVPDQ ÃYRQHLQHU)UHXQGVFKDIWRGHUHLQHU/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHUZDUWHWµRKQHGDEHLMHGRFK GLHDQGHUH3HUVRQ]XUEORHQ(UIOOXQJVJHKLOILQGHUHLJHQHQ(UZDUWXQJHQPD FKHQ]XN|QQHQ6ROOVLHZDKUKDIWDOVRDXVHLJHQHP:LOOHQPLWPLUEHIUHXQGHW VHLQRGHUPLFKOLHEHQZROOHQLVWGDULQPHLQHP9HUIJHQEHUVLHHLQH*UHQ]H JHVHW]W =ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LUVROlVVWVLFKIHVWKDOWHQEHVWHKWNHLQHVLFKHUH9HUELQ GXQJZHLOGDV,FKLPPHUDXFKXQGLPPHUZLHGHUDXVGHQ9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHQGHV :LU DXV]XVFKHUHQ YHUPDJ RKQH MHPDOV VFKOLFKWZHJ LQ VLH KLQHLQJH]ZXQJHQ ZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQ'LHVJLOWZRKOJHPHUNWXQEHVFKDGHWGHU7DWVDFKHGDVVGDV :LUGDV(LQJHEXQGHQVHLQLQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHYRQLPPHQVHU%HGHXWXQJIUGLH ,FKZHUGXQJGHV6XEMHNWVLVW *RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU±GHU7LWHOGLHVHV(LQOHLWXQJVNDSLWHOVHUKHEWHEHQ MHQHIUGLHVR]LDOH6SKlUHLQVJHVDPWSUlJHQGH6SDQQXQJ]XHLQHPWKHRORJL VFKHQ7KHPD'DULQVFKHLQWGLH7KHVHHQWKDOWHQ]XVHLQGDVVVLFKJOHLFKVDPPLW *RWWHV+LOIHGLHXQVLFKHUH9HUELQGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LUGRFKQRFKVLFKHUV WHOOHQOlVVW'DVDEHUZlUHVFKRQDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKW]XHLQIDFKJHGDFKW 0DFKWPDQVLFKQlPOLFKNODUGDVVEHLGHJXWOXWKHULVFKJHVDJWÄ]XKDXIH>JHK| UHQ@*ODXEHXQG*RWW³XQGEHJUHLIWPDQ]XGHPGHQ*ODXEHQDOVHLQHQXQYHUW UHWEDULQGLYLGXHOOHQ9ROO]XJGDQQJHK|UW*RWW]XQlFKVWHLQPDOGHXWOLFKDXIGLH 6HLWH GHV,FK 'HP XQYHUWUHWEDU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ *ODXEHQVYROO]XJ GHV 6XEMHNWV HQWVSULFKW PLWKLQHLQIUHLKHLWVWLIWHQGHV%HZXVVWVHLQMHHLJHQHU8QEHGLQJWKHLW
+,/'(%5$1'7:(),1* /87+(5
(LQOHLWXQJ
DOOHQLQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ,QVWDQ]HQJHJHQEHUGLHGRUWZRHVPLUVHOEVWXP*RWW XQG*|WWOLFKHVJHKWQLFKWVPLW]XUHGHQKDEHQ'DVVGDV,FKQLFKWLP:LUVR]LDOHU %H]LHKXQJHQDXIJHKWVRQGHUQGD]X±LP*ODXEHQLQ*HGDQNHQLP*HZLVVHQ± DXI'LVWDQ]]XJHKHQYHUPDJLVWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGEHGHQNHQORV]XXQWHU VWUHLFKHQ 'RFKZLHVFKRQ/XWKHUEHWRQWODNRQLVFKIRUPXOLHUWPXVVDXFKZHUÄGXUFK GHQ*ODXEHQ>«@DOOHVKDWZDVHUKDEHQVROO³XQZHLJHUOLFKÄPLW/HXWHQXPJH KHQ³:DVDEHUIROJWDXVGHUÄ*RWWHVIUHLKHLWGHV,FK³IUGLHVHQXQZHLJHUOL FKHQÃ8PJDQJPLW/HXWHQµGHUVLFKVWHWVLQQHUKDOEYRQVR]LDOHQ:LU%H]JHQ± )DPLOLH/LHEH)UHXQGVFKDIW6FKXOH8QLYHUVLWlW$UEHLWVVWHOOH6WDDW.LUFKH HWF±PLWLKUHQMHVSH]LILVFKHQ(UZDUWXQJHQXQG9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHQDEVSLHOW" :HOFKHV9HUKlOWQLV]XUVR]LDOHQ:LU6SKlUHLQGLHVLFKHLQJHEXQGHQ]XZLVVHQ HEHQVRDOVHUIOOHQGZLHDOVEHJUHQ]HQGHUIDKUHQZHUGHQNDQQLVWPLWGHUUHOLJL |VHQ*HZLVVKHLWYHUNQSIWYRQ*RWWKHULQVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHU:HLVH,FK ]XVHLQ" 8PGLHVHKLHU]XQlFKVWLQDOOHU2IIHQKHLWJHVWHOOWHQ)UDJHQNUHLVWGLHYRUOLH JHQGH$UEHLW'DEHLVWHKWHLQVR]LDOWKHRUHWLVFKHU*UXQGEHJULIILP=HQWUXPDXI GHVVHQ )XQGDPHQW VLFK GDV VNL]]LHUWH 6SDQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV YRQ ,FK XQG :LU DXVJH]HLFKQHWGLVNXWLHUHQOlVVW $QHUNHQQXQJ6HLWDOWHUVQlPOLFKYHUELQGHWVLFK PLWGLHVHU.DWHJRULHGHU$QVSUXFKDXI]XZHLVHQGDVVXQGLQZLHIHUQÄ6WUXNWXUHQ YRQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW³±PDQK|UH VR]LDOH:LU%H]JH±ÄNRQVWLWXWLYXQGUHJX ODWLYDXIGLH(QWZLFNOXQJYRQ6XEMHNWLYLWlW³±GDV,FK±ÄEH]RJHQVLQG³9RU GHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHV*HVDJWHQDEHUPXVVGHUNRQVWLWXWLYHXQGUHJXODWLYH&KD UDNWHUGHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVVWUXNWXUHQIUGLH6XEMHNWZHUGXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ KDEHQDOVSULQ]LSLHOOEHJUHQ]WEHXUWHLOWZHUGHQ0DJHVDXFKZLH$[HO+RQQHWK VFKUHLEWHLQHÄKHXWHIUXQVVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKH>@9RUVWHOOXQJ³VHLQÄGDVVGDV 9HUKlOWQLVGHU6XEMHNWHXQWHUHLQDQGHUGXUFKHLQHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$EKlQJLJNHLW YRQGHU:HUWVFKlW]XQJRGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKGHQRGHUGLHMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ JHSUlJWLVW³%HDQWZRUWHWZLUGGDPLWQRFKQLFKWZDVJHQDXÄHVIUXQV0HQ VFKHQKHLWYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKDQGHUH6XEMHNWHDEKlQJLJ]XVHLQ³±
/87+(5 ,PGHXWVFKVSUDFKLJHQ2ULJLQDOWH[WKHLWHV Ä2EZROGHUPHQVFK \QZHQGLJQDFKGHUVHHOHQGXUFKGHQJODXEHQJQXJVDPUHFKWIHUWLJLVWXQGDOOHVKDWWZDVHU KDEHQVROORQGDVGHUVHOEJODXEXQGJQXJGHPX\PHU]XQHKPHQEL\QQ\KHQHVOHEHQ6R EOH\EWHUGRFKQRFK\QQGLHPOH\SOLFKHQOHEHQQDXIIHUGHQQXQGPXVH\QHQH\JHQOH\S UHJLHUQXQGPLWOHXWKHQXPEJDKHQ³ '(56 E 0$11 'LH)RUPXOLHUXQJDXV7KRPDV0DQQV-RVHSKXQGVHLQH%UGHUZLUG YRQ7UDXJRWW.RFK]LWLHUWXPÄGLH)UHLKHLWGHV*ODXEHQV³]XEH]HLFKQHQ ÄHLQH)UHLKHLWGLH PLFKQLFKWIHVWOHJWDXIGDVZDVLFKELQQLFKWDXIJHKHQOlWLQGHU9RUVWHOOXQJGLHLFKXQG DQGHUHYRQPLUKDEHQ³VRQGHUQÄPLUQHXH&KDQFHQLKUHUVHOEVW>«@HU|IIQHW³ .2&+ E =851 +211(7+ $D2
(LQOHLWXQJ
ZHQQGHQQJLOWGDVVDOOHLPPHUDXFKDQGHUVN|QQHQDOVVLHVROOHQ,P5DKPHQ GHUYRUOLHJHQGHQ$UEHLWZLUGMHGHQIDOOVYRQHLQHUVR]LDOQLFKWYROOHQGVHLQ]XKH JHQGHQ'LPHQVLRQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQVDXVJHJDQJHQGLHDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU 6LFKWJOHLFKVDPGDV*|WWOLFKHLP0HQVFKOLFKHQZLGHUVSLHJHOWXQG]XUÃ$EKlQ JLJNHLWYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK$QGHUHµLQHLQHPVSDQQXQJVYROOHQDEHU± ZLHJHVDJW±ZHLWHU]XNOlUHQGHQ9HUKlOWQLVVWHKW7KHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH (UNXQGXQJVJlQJHLP6SDQQXQJVIHOGYRQ,FK:LUXQG*RWWNQGLJWGHVKDOELKU 8QWHUWLWHODQ %HYRUGLH:HJVWUHFNHGLHVHU(UNXQGXQJVJlQJHLP)ROJHQGHQHLQPDOEHU EOLFNVPlLJ DEJHVFKULWWHQ ZLUG VROO YHUGHXWOLFKW ZHUGHQ LQZLHIHUQ GDV 6SDQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJLQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ XQGWKHRORJLVFKHQ $UEHLWHQWKHPDWLVLHUWZLUG
6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ±SKLORVRSKLVFK 'HU$XVGUXFNÄÃ$QHUNHQQXQJµ³VROlVVWVLFKYRQ9RONHU*HUKDUGWOHUQHQÄEH UXKWDXIGHP:RUWVWDPPYRQÃNHQQHQµ³XQG JHK|UW LQ HLQH )DPLOLH PLW ÃHUNHQQHQµ ÃEHNHQQHQµ RGHU Ã.HQQWQLVµ >«@ ,QGHP LFK HWZDV DQHUNHQQHJHVWHKHLFK]XGDHVVRLVWZLHLFKHVHUNHQQH$QHUNHQQXQJLVWGHU$NWGHU %HVWlWLJXQJHLQHV:LVVHQVGXUFKGHQMHQLJHQGHUGLHVHV:LVVHQKDW
$QHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQKHLWGHPQDFK]XQlFKVWHLQPDOGDVVPLUGXUFK$QGHUH ]XJHVWDQGHQXQGEHVWlWLJWZLUGGHUMHQLJH]XVHLQDOVGHQVLHPLFKHUNHQQHQ 6FKRQGDULQVWHFNWVWHOOWPDQGLH*HJHQIUDJHHWZDV6SDQQXQJVYROOHV %LQLFK GHQQGHUMHQLJHDOVGHQGLH$QGHUHQPLFKDXIJUXQGLKUHV:LVVHQVYRQPLUHU NHQQHQXQGPLULP$NWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XVHLQ]XJHVWHKHQ"$XVJHKHQGYRQ GLHVHU)UDJHOlVVWVLFK]XQlFKVWGHU%OLFN]XUFNDXIGLH$QIlQJHSKLORVRSKL VFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVGHQNHQVULFKWHQ D XPGDQQ]XHLQVFKOlJLJHQ3RVLWLRQHQ GHUMQJHUHQ*HJHQZDUWEHU]XJHKHQ E D 'LHDQJHVSURFKHQH8QJHZLVVKHLWREPDQVLFKYHUWUDXWPDQDXIGHQ%OLFN GHU0LWPHQVFKHQZDKUKDIWVHOEVWHUNHQQWRGHUQLFKWYLHOPHKUVHOEVWIUHPGZLUG QLPPWLP'HQNHQ-HDQ-DFTXHV5RXVVHDXVHLQH]HQWUDOH6WHOOXQJHLQ/DXW)UH GHULFN1HXKRXVHUNDQQGHULP)UDQNUHLFKGHV-DKUKXQGHUWVZLUNHQGH3KLOR VRSKDOVÄHUVWH>U@'HQNHULQGHU*HVFKLFKWHGHU3KLORVRSKLH³JHOWHQÄGHUGDV 6WUHEHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK$QGHUHLP,QQHUVWHQGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXU ORNDOLVLHUWXQGHVGDPLW]XHLQHP]HQWUDOHQ7KHPDGHU0RUDO6R]LDOXQGSROL WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHPDFKW³5RXVVHDXDEHUJHKWQLFKWQXUGDYRQDXVGDVVHV
*(5+$5'7 1(8+286(5 9JO]XP6WHOOHQZHUWGHV$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDVEHL5RXVVHDXGLH $XVIKUXQJHQLQ DD2 II'HU$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIVHOEVWEHJHJQHWEHL5RXVVHDXQRFK QLFKW-HGRFKODVVHQVLFKVR1HXKRXVHUGLHÄ$QVLFKWHQ>«@DOOHUVSlWHUHQ7KHRUHWLNHUGHU
(LQOHLWXQJ
IUGHQ0HQVFKHQYRQIXQGDPHQWDOHU:LFKWLJNHLWLVWVLFKVHOEVWGXUFKDQGHUH EHVWlWLJW]XILQGHQ(UZHLVWLP'LVNXUVEHUGLH8QJOHLFKKHLW DXFKDXI GDV5LVLNRHLQHU]XVWDUNHQ$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJKLQ 'HU 0HQVFKODXIHGDQQ*HIDKUÄLPPHUDXHUVLFKQXULQGHU0HLQXQJGHU$QGHUHQ ]XOHEHQ>«@XQGVR]XVDJHQDXVLKUHP8UWHLODOOHLQ>«@GDV*HIKOVHLQHUHLJH QHQ([LVWHQ]³]XEH]LHKHQ%HGURKOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHUHQWIDOWHWHLQGHUDUWPDVVL YHV6FKLHOHQGDUDXIZLHPDQVR]LDOZDKUJHQRPPHQZLUGYRUDOOHPGHVKDOE ZHLOGDVIUHPGH%LOGYRQPLULPPHUDXFKQHJDWLYMDLPZDKUVWHQ6LQQHGHV :RUWHVYHUQLFKWHQGDXVIDOOHQNDQQ,FKELQGDQQGHUZLOONUOLFKYHUWHLOWHQ*XQVW RGHU8QJXQVWPHLQHU0LWPHQVFKHQYROOHQGVDXVJHVHW]W$QJHVLFKWVGHVVHQZlUH ZLH1HXKRXVHULP5DKPHQVHLQHU5RXVVHDX,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGUDVWLVFKIRUPXOLHUW ÄGLHHLJHQH([LVWHQ]>«@VRLQVWDELO>«@ZLHGLHYHUEUDQQWHQhEHUUHVWHHLQHV +RO]VFKHLWVGLHGXUFKHLQHHLQ]LJH%HUKUXQJYRQDXHQ]X$VFKH]HUIDOOHQ³ 'DYRUJHIHLWVHL5RXVVHDX]XIROJHQXUZHUEHUÄLQWHUQH5HVVRXUFHQ]XU6HOEVW EHVWlWLJXQJ³RGHUÄ4XHOOHQVHLQHV'DVHLQVLQVLFK³YHUIJHXQGLQVRIHUQQLFKW ÄDXVVFKOLHOLFKLQGHU0HLQXQJ$QGHUHU³OHEH 'HUGDPLWDQYLVLHUWHQSDUWLHOOHQ8QDEKlQJLJNHLWLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQVJH JHQEHUGHQ8UWHLOHQVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJWUlJW±FXPJUDQRVDOLV±,PPDQXHO .DQWV$FKWXQJVEHJULIIDXVGHU*UXQGOHJXQJ]XU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQ 5HFKQXQJ)U.DQWGHUÄDOV:HJEHUHLWHU]XP$QHUNHQQXQJVGHQNHQ)LFKWHV XQG+HJHOV³JHOWHQNDQQLVWÄ$FKWXQJ>«@GLH9RUVWHOOXQJYRQHLQHP:HUWH GHUPHLQHU6HOEVWOLHEH$EEUXFKWXW³Ä$OOH$FKWXQJIUHLQH3HUVRQ³DEHUVHL ÄHLJHQWOLFKQXU$FKWXQJIUGDV*HVHW]³ZRYRQGLHEHWUHIIHQGH3HUVRQÄXQVGDV %HLVSLHOOLHIHUW³(LQH3HUVRQ]XDFKWHQKHLWGHPQDFKLKUGLH)lKLJNHLW]X HLQHPDQGHU9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJVUHJHOGHV.DWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVRULHQWLHU WHQXQGLQVRIHUQIUGDVPRUDOLVFKH6LWWHQJHVHW]EHLVSLHOKDIWHQ+DQGHOQ]X]X $QHUNHQQXQJ >«@ DOV :HLWHUHQWZLFNOXQJHQ RGHU 5HYLVLRQHQ GHU 5RXVVHDXVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQ EHJUHLIHQGLHVLFKLQQHUKDOEHLQHVJUXQGOHJHQGHQ5DKPHQVEHZHJHQGHULP'LVNXUVEHUGLH 8QJOHLFKKHLWLP(PLOHXQGLP*HVHOOVFKDIWVYHUWUDJDEJHVWHFNWZLUG³ DD2 'HUGDV YRQ5RXVVHDXDXIJHGHFNWH$QHUNHQQXQJVVWUHEHQGHV0HQVFKHQEH]HLFKQHQGH%HJULIIODXWHW Ä/¶DPRXUSURSUH³ZRUXQWHUHUÄHLQUHODWLYHVNQVWOLFKHVXQGLQGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWHQWVWDQGHQHV *HIKO³YHUVWHKWÄGDVMHGHV,QGLYLGXXPGD]XYHUDQODWVLFKVHOEVWK|KHU]XVFKlW]HQDOV MHGHQDQGHUHQGDVGHQ0HQVFKHQDOOGLHhEHOHLQJLEWGLHVLHVLFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJDQWXQXQG GDV GLH ZDKUKDIWH 4XHOOH GHU (KUH LVW³ 52866($8 9JO ]X 5RXVVHDX DXFK +211(7+II 52866($8 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQGLH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQEHL 1(8+286(5 II 1(8+286(5 $D2 +211(7+$QP9JO]XUIROJHQGHQ$XVOHJXQJ DD2II$OOHUGLQJV QHLJW+RQQHWKGD]XGLHLQVHLQHQ$XJHQEHL.DQW]XHQWGHFNHQGHÄLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHDQGLH %HJHJQXQJPLWGHP0LWPHQVFKHQJHNQSIWH7HQGHQ]³ DD2$QP EHU]XEHWRQHQ .$17 D$QP>%$@ (EG
(LQOHLWXQJ
JHVWHKHQ:DVÃPHLQHU6HOEVWOLHEH$EEUXFKWXWµLVWDOVRGLHÃ9RUVWHOOXQJµYRP KRKHQÃ:HUWµGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVGDVLPGHVKDOEXQEHGLQJWDQ]XHUNHQQHQGHQ $XWRQRPLHYHUP|JHQHLQHVMHGHQ6XEMHNWV±IU.DQW,QEHJULII PHQVFKOLFKHU :UGH±H[HPSODULVFK]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPWRKQHGDVVGLHVHV9HUP|JHQDEHU DXIVR]LDOH=XJHVWlQGQLVVH]XUFN]XIKUHQZlUH(VIXQJLHUWYLHOPHKUVR9RO NHU*HUKDUGWDOV4XHOOHHLQHUÄ6HOEVWDFKWXQJGHV,QGLYLGXXPV³GLHÄGHU$QHU NHQQXQJGHUDQGHUHQYRUDXV>JHKW@³XQG]ZDUVRZRKOGHUVHOEVWJHWlWLJWHQDOV DXFKGHUHLJHQVHPSIDQJHQHQ 1DFK-RKDQQ*RWWOLHE)LFKWHV*UXQGODJHGHV1DWXUUHFKWV EHGDUIDEHU GLH(QWIDOWXQJGHVGHP6XEMHNWHLJQHQGHQ3RWHQ]LDOVÄ]XU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³ ZHQLJVWHQVÄHLQH>U@$XIIRUGHUXQJDQGDVVHOEHVLFK]XHLQHU:LUNVDPNHLW]X HQWVFKOLHHQ³'LHVH$XIIRUGHUXQJZLUGLKPGDGXUFK]XWHLOGDVVHVVLFKLP 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVDOVIUHLKHLWVIlKLJDQHUNDQQWILQGHW(VIROJWLKULQGHPHVVHLQ IUHLHV6HOEVWVHLQSUDNWLVFKYROO]LHKWGDVLQLKPVFKRQDQJHOHJWLVWXQGSHU$QHU NHQQXQJQXUSURYR]LHUWZLUGÄÃ(U]LHKXQJµXQGÃ(LQZLUNXQJGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWµ³ VR(GLWK'VLQJÄVLQGIU)LFKWHQLFKWYRQVLFKKHUTXDOLIL]LHUWGD]XGLHLQQHUH 6XEVWDQ]GHV6HOEVWKHUYRU]XEULQJHQVRQGHUQVLQG&KDQFHQGLHGHQ)UHLKHLWV JHEUDXFKDQEDKQHQ³RKQHLKQHLJHQVKHUYRU]XEULQJHQ 5HIOHNWLHUWGDV6XEMHNW DEHUDXIGLHVR]LDOHQ%HGLQJXQJHQVHLQHV6HOEVWVHLQVGDVHVDXIJUXQGGHULKP ]XWHLOJHZRUGHQHQÄ$XIIRUGHUXQJ]XUIUHLHQ6HOEVWWlWLJNHLW³RGHUÄGDVZDVPDQ (U]LHKXQJ QHQQW³ EHUKDXSW HUVW LQ GLH HLJHQH +DQG JHQRPPHQ KDW YHU VFKUHLEWHVVLFKGHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ'HQQÄPHLQH)UHLKHLW³VR )LFKWHÄLVW>«@QXUGDGXUFKP|JOLFKGDGHUDQGHUHLQQHUKDOEVHLQHU6SKlUH EOHLEH³XQGXPJHNHKUW6LHVHW]WDOVREHLEHLGHQYRQXQVHLQHÄ%HVFKUlQNXQJ GXUFKVLFKVHOEVW³]XJXQVWHQGHVIUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGHUMHZHLOVDQGHUHQ6HLWH± DOVR UH]LSURNH$QHUNHQQXQJ±YRUDXV :lKUHQG)LFKWHV$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHÄLP:HVHQWOLFKHQDXI5HFKWVYHUKlOW QLVVHXQG%H]LHKXQJHQJHJHQVHLWLJHUPRUDOLVFKHU$FKWXQJEHVFKUlQNW³EOHLEW NRQ]LSLHUW*HRUJ:LOKHOP)ULHGULFK+HJHOLKQZHLWHUGHQNHQGVR/XGZLJ6LHS HLQH7KHRULHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOVHLQHUÃ%HZHJXQJµGLHHLQH5HLKHYRQ6WXIHQVRZRKOGHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ%HZXVVWVHLQVELOGXQJZLHGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ.XOWXUJHVFKLFKWHXPIDVVW(VKDQGHOW VLFKXPHLQHQWHOHRORJLVFKHQ3UR]HVVGHUEHLXQJHVW|UWHP9HUODXIHLQ,QGLYLGXXP]XP%H
*(5+$5'79JODXFKDD2II ),&+7( 9JO]X)LFKWHV$QHUNHQQXQJVOHKUHLP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW 'h6,1* ± 'h6,1*I ),&+7( $D2 (EG9JODD2I
(LQOHLWXQJ
ZXVVWVHLQVHLQHUYHUQQIWLJHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWXQGVHLQHU6WHOOXQJLQHLQHUYHUQQIWLJYHUIDVVWHQ 5HFKWV6WDDWVXQG.XOWXUJHPHLQVFKDIWEULQJHQNDQQ
'LHÄ%HZHJXQJGHV$QHUNHQQHQV³YRQGHULQ+HJHOV3KlQRPHQRORJLHGHV *HLVWHV GLH5HGHLVWIKUWÄEHUYHUVFKLHGHQH6WDWLRQHQGHV6FKHLWHUQV XQGGHUGDGXUFKDXVJHO|VWHQGLDOHNWLVFKHQ(UIDKUXQJHQ]XUUHDOLVLHUWHQ$QHU NHQQXQJLP*HLVW³:DVIU+HJHOÄGHU*HLVWLVW³ZXUGHLPYRUKHULJHQ$E VFKQLWWEHUHLWVHUZlKQW Ä,FKGDV:LUXQG:LUGDV,FKLVW³RGHUDXFKÄGLHVH DEVROXWH6XEVWDQ]ZHOFKHLQGHUYROONRPPHQHQ)UHLKHLWXQG6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW LKUHV*HJHQVDW]HVQlPOLFKYHUVFKLHGHQHUIUVLFKVHLHQGHU6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ>H@ GLH(LQKHLWGHUVHOEHQLVW³'DVDQYLVLHUWH=XVDPPHQILQGHQGHUÄJHJHQVHLWLJ VLFKDQHUNHQQHQG>HQ@³6XEMHNWHLP:LUGHV*HLVWHVZLHHVLQGHQVLWWOLFKHQ 2UGQXQJHQREMHNWLYLHUWZXUGHVROODOVRQLFKWDXI.RVWHQ LKUHUÃ)UHLKHLWXQG 6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWµJHKHQVRQGHUQGLHVHJHUDGH]XHUIOOHQGHU*HOWXQJEULQJHQ,FK ZLOOGDQQXPDXIGLHHLQJDQJVIRUPXOLHUWH)UDJH]XUFN]XNRPPHQJDQ]GHUMH QLJHVHLQDOVGHQGLH$QGHUHQPLFKDXIJUXQGLKUHV:LVVHQVYRQPLUHUNHQQHQ XQGPLULP$NWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XVHLQ]XJHVWHKHQ'HU9HUV|KQXQJYRQ,FK XQG:LUHQWVSULFKWGDVZHFKVHOVHLWLJH6LFK)LQGHQLP$QHUNDQQW:HUGHQGXUFK GHQMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ:LHHLQGHUDUWLJHV0LWHLQDQGHUJHOLQJHQNDQQXQGREGDV EHUKDXSWP|JOLFKRGHUJDUZQVFKHQVZHUWZlUHVLQG)UDJHQGLHMQJHUH7KHR ULHELOGXQJHQLQ6DFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ]XP7KHPDPDFKHQ E 5DKHO-DHJJLXQWHUVFKHLGHWLQGHUDNWXHOOHQ VR]LDO SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ7KHR ULHODQGVFKDIWÄSRVLWLYH³XQGÄQHJDWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHQ³GLHVLFKGLUHNW DXI PDQFKH GHU VRHEHQ GDUJHVWHOOWHQ NODVVLVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ ]XUFNEH]LHKHQ %HLGHJHKHQGDYRQDXVÄGDVVZLUDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJ$QGHUHUDQJHZLHVHQ VLQGXPXQVLQXQVHUHP6HOEVWEH]XJNRQVWLWXLHUHQ]XN|QQHQ³Ä>V@LHXQWHU VFKHLGHQVLFKDOOHUGLQJVGDULQZLHVLHGLHVHQ8PVWDQGGHXWHQXQGEHZHUWHQ³ :lKUHQGGDVÃSRVLWLYHµ/DJHUDQJHVLFKWVGLHVHV8PVWDQGVEHUGLHJHVHOOVFKDIW OLFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJQDFKGHQNWJLEWHVIUGDVÃQHJD WLYHµ/DJHULP*UXQGHEHUKDXSWQXUPLVVOLQJHQGHGDV6XEMHNWYRQVLFKVHOEVW HQWIUHPGHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJ (LQH[HPSODULVFKHU9HUWUHWHUGHVÃSRVLWLYHQµ7KHRULHODJHUVLVWHWZDGHUNDQD GLVFKH3KLORVRSK&KDUOHV7D\ORUGHULQVHLQHP SXEOL]LHUWHQ(VVD\Ä7KH SROLWLFVRIUHFRJQLWLRQ³GDVÄ9HUODQJHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJ³DOVÄHLQPHQVFKOL FKHV*UXQGEHGUIQLV³HLQIKUW'XUFKÄGLH8PJHEXQJRGHUGLH*HVHOOVFKDIW
6,(3 'LH$XVIKUXQJHQ]X+HJHOEOHLEHQDQGLHVHU6WHOOHDEVLFKWOLFKNQDSS 6HLQH3RVLWLRQZLUGLP/DXIHGHU$UEHLWLPPHUZLHGHUHLQJHKHQGHUOlXWHUW +(*(/ 6,(3 +(*(/ $D2 -$(**,9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH HEG (EG 7$JH@VSLHJHOW³]XEHNRPPHQGDVN|QQHQlPOLFKDXIVHLWHQGHUEHWURIIHQHQ 3HUVRQHQÄZLUNOLFKHQ6FKDGHQ>«@HLQHZLUNOLFKH'HIRUPDWLRQ³MDÄOlKPHQGHQ 6HOEVWKD³KHUYRUUXIHQ)UGLH0RGHUQHDEHULVWHVDXV7D\ORUV6LFKWJHUDGH]X W\SLVFKÄLQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ>]X@OHEHQLQGHQHQGDV6WUHEHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJ VFKHLWHUQNDQQ³ZHLOGLH,GHQWLWlWGHU6XEMHNWHQLFKWPHKUZLHÄ>L@QYRUPRGHU QHU =HLW³ ÄDXI JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ .DWHJRULHQ EHUXKW>@ GLH QLHPDQG DQ]ZHL IHOW>@³:DVGHU0HQVFKLVWXQGVHLQZLOOVHLYLHOPHKU]XHLQHUÄXQYHUZHFKVHO EDUSHUV|QOLFKH>Q@³$QJHOHJHQKHLWJHZRUGHQXQGVRZDFKVHGDV5LVLNRVLFK VR]LDOYHUNDQQW]XILQGHQ%H]HLFKQHQGHUZHLVHWKHPDWLVLHUW7D\ORUGLH3UREOH PDWLNJUDVVLHUHQGHUÄ1LFKW$QHUNHQQXQJRGHU9HUNHQQXQJ³DOOHUGLQJVDQKDQG GHUNROOHNWLYHQ:LU,GHQWLWlWHQNXOWXUHOOHU0LQGHUKHLWHQGLHLP.RQWH[WHLQHU ÃIUHPGHQµ0HKUKHLWVNXOWXUXPGHQ)RUWEHVWDQGLKUHULGHQWLWlWVEHVWLPPHQGHQ %HVRQGHUKHLWHQIUFKWHQPVVHQ6FKOLHOLFKKlOWHUHLQ3OlGR\HUIUÄ>H@LQH *HVHOOVFKDIW³GLHÄLPVWDQGH>LVW@9LHOIDOW]XUHVSHNWLHUHQYRUDOOHPLP8PJDQJ PLWGHQHQGLHLKUHQNROOHNWLYHQ=LHOHQQLFKWIROJHQP|JHQ³XQGGHQQRFKGLH $QHUNHQQXQJGHUMHHLJHQHQXQYHUZHFKVHOEDUEHVRQGHUHQNXOWXUHOOHQ,GHQWLWlW YHUGLHQHQ 'DVVZLH7D\ORUYRUDXVVHW]WGHUÄ3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVYHUOXVW>@³GURKWZHQQÄHL QHU3HUVRQGLHYHUGLHQWH$QHUNHQQXQJYHUZHLJHUWZLUG³LVWDXFKGLH$QQDKPH GHV6R]LDOSKLORVRSKHQ$[HO+RQQHWKGHUHEHQIDOOVGHPÃSRVLWLYHQµ7KHRULHODJHU ]X]XRUGQHQLVWÄ>'@LHPHQVFKOLFKH/HEHQVIRUP³VRKHLWHVEHLLKPVHLÄLP JDQ]HQGXUFKGLH7DWVDFKHJHSUlJW>«@GD,QGLYLGXHQQXUGXUFKZHFKVHOVHLWL JH$QHUNHQQXQJ]XVR]LDOHU0LWJOLHGVFKDIWXQGGDPLW]XHLQHUSRVLWLYHQ6HOEVW EH]LHKXQJJHODQJHQ³0LWGHPEHUGHQHQJHUHQ3UREOHPKRUL]RQWGHV0XOWL NXOWXUDOLVPXVZHLWKLQDXVJHKHQGHQ$QVSUXFKÄHLQHUQRUPDWLYJHKDOWYROOHQ*H VHOOVFKDIWVWKHRULH³ HUNXQGHW+RQQHWKVHLWVHLQHU YHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ+DELOLWD WLRQVVFKULIW.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGGLH%HUHLFKHYRQ
$D2I $D29JO]XUJUXQGOHJHQGHUHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPD DD2± (EG $D2 9JOGD]X $D2II7D\ORUV%HLVSLHOLVWGLHIUDQ]|VLVFKH0LQGHUKHLWLPNDQDGLVFKHQ 4XHEHFPLWLKUHP.DPSIXPLKUHNXOWXUHOOH,GHQWLWlWHUKDOWHQGH6RQGHUUHFKWH:HOFKXQWHU JHRUGQHWH5ROOHGDVLQGLYLGXHOOH6XEMHNWLQGLHVHUDXIV.ROOHNWLYHNRQ]HQWULHUWHQ3ROLWLNVSLHOW ZLUGGHXWOLFKZHQQ7D\ORUVFKUHLEWVLHVHLÄDNWLYEHVWUHEW$QJHK|ULJH³LKUHUHLJHQHQÄ*UXS SH]XHU]HXJHQLQGHPVLH]XP%HLVSLHOGDIUVRUJWGDVLFKDXFKNQIWLJH*HQHUDWLRQHQDOV )UDQNRSKRQHLGHQWLIL]LHUHQ³ DD2 $D29JODD2II +211(7+E9JO]XUQlKHUHQ'DUVWHOOXQJ+RQQHWKVGLH$XVIKUXQJHQLP7HLO %GLHVHU$UEHLW +211(7+F +211(7+G
(LQOHLWXQJ
)DPLOLH/LHEHXQG)UHXQGVFKDIW5HFKW6WDDW:LUWVFKDIWXQG$UEHLWXYDP 'DEHLEULQJWHUMHZHLOVEHUHLFKVVSH]LILVFKOlQJVWHWDEOLHUWHÄ$QHUNHQQXQJVSULQ ]LSLHQ³]XP9RUVFKHLQÄLQGHUHQ/LFKWGLH6XEMHNWHVSH]LILVFKH(UIDKUXQJHQ XQEHJUQGHWHU>«@0LDFKWXQJJHOWHQGPDFKHQN|QQHQXQGGDKHU*UQGHIU HLQHHUZHLWHUWH$UWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJYRU]XEULQJHQYHUP|JHQ³9RQGHUPDQ JHOKDIWHQKLQ]XUHUIOOHQGHQÃ$UWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJµGLHGHQ,QGLYLGXHQÃVR]LDOH 0LWJOLHGVFKDIWµXQGHLQHÃSRVLWLYH6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJµYHUVFKDIIHQZUGHIKUHQ EHL+RQQHWKDXVGHUXQEHUHFKWLJWHQ1RWJHERUHQHVR]LDOH.lPSIH$Q0RWLYH +HJHOVDQNQSIHQGPDFKWHULPÄ$QVSUXFKGHU,QGLYLGXHQDXIGLHLQWHUVXEMHNWL YH$QHUNHQQXQJLKUHU,GHQWLWlW>«@HLQHPRUDOLVFKH6SDQQXQJ³DXVGLHLQQHU KDOEGHVÄJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQ>V@>«@DXIGHPQHJDWLYHQ:HJHLQHVVLFK VWXIHQZHLVHZLHGHUKROHQGHQ.RQIOLNWHVDOOPlKOLFK]XHLQHP=XVWDQGNRPPXQL NDWLYJHOHEWHU)UHLKHLWIKUW³ :lKUHQGHVEHL7D\ORUZLHEHL+RQQHWKPLWGHPVSDQQXQJVYROOHQ9HUKlOWQLV YRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJHLQYHUV|KQOLFKHV(QGHQLPPWRGHUZHQLJVWHQV QHKPHQNDQQVLHKWGDVÃQHJDWLYHµ7KHRULHODJHUGLHVEH]JOLFKVFKZDU] Ä,FKH[LVWLHUHHQWIUHPGHWXQGLFKODVVHPLFKGXUFKPHLQ'UDXHQOHKUHQZDV LFKVHLQVROO³PVVWHQDFK-HDQ3DXO6DUWUHV'DV6HLQXQGGDV1LFKWV GLH 6HOEVWEHVFKUHLEXQJ GHVVHQ ODXWHQ GHU QDFK HUIOOWHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK VHLQH0LWPHQVFKHQVWUHEW6HLQH1HJDWLYSHUVSHNWLYHZHLVWLKQDOV(UEHQ5RXV VHDXVDXVRE]ZDUHUGLH6LWXDWLRQGHVEHU*HEKUDQHUNHQQXQJVEHGUIWLJHQ 0HQVFKHQGHUÃQXULQGHU0HLQXQJGHU$QGHUHQOHEWµJOHLFKVDP]XP1RUPDO IDOOHUNOlUW6DUWUHV/DQGVPDQQ/RXLV$OWKXVVHUVWHKWLKPGDEHLLQQLFKWVQDFK Ä'LH,GHRORJLHUXIW>«@GLH,QGLYLGXHQDOV6XEMHNWHDQ³ODXWHW$OWKXVVHUV'LN WXPDXVGHP-DKUH Ä1RFKEHYRUGDV.LQGJHERUHQLVW³VFKUHLEWHUÄLVWHV LPPHUVFKRQ6XEMHNWZHLOHVLQXQGGXUFKGLHVSH]LILVFKHIDPLOLDOHLGHRORJLVFKH .RQILJXUDWLRQLQGHUHVQDFKGHU=HXJXQJÃHUZDUWHWµ ZLUG]XP6XEMHNWEH VWLPPWLVW³ZRULQGLHGDVVR]LDOH/HEHQLQVJHVDPWGXUFKZDOWHQGHÄLGHRORJL VFKH>@:LHGHUHUNHQQXQJ$QHUNHQQXQJ>UHFRQQDLVVDQFH@LKUHQ$XVGUXFN³ILQ GHW,PGLUHNWHQ$QVFKOXVVDQ$OWKXVVHUEHVFKUHLEW-XGLWK%XWOHULQLKUHU6WXGLH 3V\FKHGHU0DFKW ÄGDV6XEMHNW³DOVHLQÄ:HVHQ>«@GDVNUDIWVHLQHU )RUPLHUXQJ XQWHUMRFKW³ ZLUG(VVHL QlPOLFK ÄJHQ|WLJW QDFK $QHUNHQQXQJ VHLQHUHLJHQHQ([LVWHQ]LQ.DWHJRULHQ%HJULIIHQXQG1DPHQ]XWUDFKWHQGLHHV
+211(7+F +211(7+G 6$575( 9JO ]XU LP )ROJHQGHQ GDUJHVWHOOWHQ /LQLH 5RXVVHDX6DUWUH $OWKXVVHU%XWOHU +211(7+II IIII $/7+866(5 $OWKXVVHUZLHDXFKLP)ROJHQGHQ-XGLWK%XWOHUYHUZHQGHQGHQ 6XEMHNWEHJULII YRU GHP +LQWHUJUXQG GHU 'RSSHOEHGHXWXQJ GLH GDV IUDQ]|VLVFKH 9HUEXP ÄÃDVVXMHWWLUµ³LPSOL]LHUWGDV]XJOHLFKÄÃXQWHUZHUIHQµXQGÃ]XP6XEMHNWPDFKHQµ³EHGHXWHW DD2$QPGhEHUV YJOXD%87/(5 $D2 %87/(5 9JO]X-XGLWK%XWOHUGLH$XVIKUXQJHQXQWHQLQ %
(LQOHLWXQJ
QLFKWVHOEVWKHUYRUJHEUDFKWKDW³VRGDVVHVÄGDV=HLFKHQVHLQHU([LVWHQ]DXHU KDOEVHLQHUVHOEVW³VXFKHQPVVH 'LHVHQ)DGHQJUHLIWLQMQJHUHU=HLWLQVEHVRQGHUH7KRPDV%HGRUIDXIGHULQ VHLQHU+DELOLWDWLRQVVFKULIW9HUNHQQHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJ GLH7KHVHYHUWULWW ÄGDVV$QHUNHQQXQJ³]ZDUÄHLQHQRWZHQGLJH.RQVWLWXWLRQVIRUPGHV6R]LDOHQLVW DEHUGDVVVLHHEHQVRQRWZHQGLJVWHWVPLVVOLQJW³'HQQQLHÄZHUGHLFK>«@DOV LFKVHOEVW³DQHUNDQQWVRQGHUQVWHWVÄDOVMHPDQG%HVWLPPWH>V@>«@ GKLP +RUL]RQWHLQHV$QHUNHQQXQJVPHGLXPV DIILUPLHUW³ VRDEHUVHLÄ]ZLVFKHQGHP MHQLJHQGHURGHUGLHDQHUNDQQWZLUGXQGGHPDOVZDVHURGHUVLHDQHUNDQQW ZLUG>]X@XQWHUVFKHLGHQ³$QVWDWWGHQREGLHVHU'LIIHUHQ]SULQ]LSLHOONRQIOLNW JHSUlJWHQÄ3UR]HVVGHV$QHUNHQQHQV³DEHUYHUPLWWHOVGHUÄ3RVLWLRQLHUXQJHLQHU IL[LHUWHQ,GHQWLWlW³LPYHUPHLQWOLFKYHUV|KQWHQ0LWHLQDQGHUVWLOO]XVWHOOHQZLOO %HGRUIGHVVHQÄXQDEVFKOLHEDUHQ³ &KDUDNWHUZDKUHQ=ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG $QHUNHQQXQJREZDOWHWGHPQDFKHLQHEOHLEHQGH6SDQQXQJGLHGDUDXVUHVXOWLHUW ÄGDVVPDQVHOEVWLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]LHKXQJQLHPDOVJDQ]GHUMHQLJHLVW³ DOVGHUPDQGDULQHUVFKHLQW(LQVROFKHV0RPHQWGHUVR]LDOHQ8QYHUUHFKHQEDU NHLWGHV,FKZROOHQ±PLWXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKVWDUNHP$N]HQW±DXFKGLHDQGHUHQ 3RVLWLRQHQGHVÃQHJDWLYHQµ7KHRULHODJHUVVWDUNPDFKHQ 6DUWUHJHKWHVGDUXP GDVVÄLFKPLFKZLHGHU>JHZLQQH@³JHJHQEHUGHPÄEORH>Q@%LOGYRQPLULP Ã%HZXWVHLQµGHV$QGHUQ³ $OWKXVVHU]LHOWZHQLJVWHQVDXIGLHÄ(UNHQQWQLVGHV 0HFKDQLVPXV³ GHU PLFK ÃLPPHUVFKRQµ MHPDQG %HVWLPPWHV VHLQ OlVVW EHL %XWOHULVWYRQÄHLQH>P@hEHUVFKXVVXQGHLQH>U@8QGXUFKVLFKWLJNHLW³GHV6HOEVW
$D2 %('25)9JO'(56'HU(UWUDJVHLQHU$UEHLWZLUGLP]LWLHUWHQ$XIVDW] WKHVHQDUWLJ]XVDPPHQJHIDVVW YJO]XP)ROJHQGHQ'(56II1HEHQ%HGRUIODVVHQ VLFKDQGLHVHU6WHOOH]%DXVGHP86DPHULNDQLVFKHQ.RQWH[W3DWFKHQ0DUNHOOXQG.HOO\ 2OLYHUQHQQHQGLHHEHQIDOOVÃQHJDWLYHµ$QHUNHQQXQJHWKHRULHQHQWZLFNHOQ0DUNHOOVFKUHLEWLQ %RXQGE\UHFRJQLWLRQ Ä,IUHFRJQLWLRQPDNHVWKHVRFLDOZRUOGLQWHOOLJLEOHLWRIWHQGRHVVRE\ VWUDWLI\LQJ LW VXERUGLQDWLQJ VRPH SHRSOH DQG HOHYDWLQJ RWKHUVWR SRVLWLRQV RI SULYLOHJH RU GRPLQDQFH³ 0$5.(// I ,Q2OLYHUV6WXGLH:LWQHVVLQJ%H\RQG5HFRJQLWLRQKHLW HV Ä>W@KDWVWUXJJOHVIRUUHFRJQLWLRQDQGWKHRULHVWKDWHPEUDFHWKRVHVWUXJJOHVPD\LQGHHG SUHVXSSRVHDQGWKHUHE\SHUSHWXDWHWKHYHU\KLHUDUFKLHVGRPLQDWLRQDQGLQMXVWLFHWKDWWKH\ DWWHPSWWRRYHUFRPH³ 2/,9(5 %('25) $D2 $D2 6$575( $/7+866(5 $XFKZHQQÄ$OWKXVVHU³ZLH+RQQHWKVFKUHLEWÄGHQ6XEMHNWHQ QLFKWGLH&KDQFH³HLQUlXPWÄHLQHQK|KHUHQ*UDGDQ$XWRQRPLHLQLKUHQ+DQGOXQJVYROO]JHQ XQG/HEHQVHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ]XJHZLQQHQ³ZHLOVLHÄGXUFK|IIHQWOLFKH$GUHVVLHUXQJHLQHP 1HW]YRQVR]LDOHU5HJHOQXQWHUZRUIHQZHUGHQGDVNHLQH9DULDWLRQVVSLHOUlXPHLQEH]XJDXI GLHLQGLYLGXHOOH$XWRQRPLHEHVLW]HQNDQQ³ +211(7+D$QP EOHLEWMDGLH )UDJHZLHMHPDQGEHUKDXSWLQGHU/DJHVHLQVROOGLHVH(UNHQQWQLV]XYROO]LHKHQGLHMDHLQH 'LVWDQ]LHUXQJJHJHQEHUGHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVPHFKDQLVPHQEHGHXWHW
(LQOHLWXQJ
GLH5HGHGLHÄDXHUKDOEGHU.DWHJRULHQGHU,GHQWLWlW³OLHJHQXQGGHUÄ$QHUNHQ QXQJ>«@*UHQ]HQ³VHW]HQ 3DXO5LF°XUZLUIWLQVHLQHPSRVWXPHUVFKLHQHQHQ:HUN:HJHGHU$QHU NHQQXQJGLH)UDJHDXIÄ>Z@DQQ>«@VLFKHLQ,QGLYLGXXPIUDQHUNDQQWKDOWHQ³ NDQQ,P6LQQHGHUÃSRVLWLYHQµ$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHZlUHKLHUDXIGLHHQWVSUH FKHQGH(LQULFKWXQJGHU6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVH]XYHUZHLVHQZlKUHQGGDVÃQHJDWLYHµ *HJHQODJHUGLH8QHUUHLFKEDUNHLWHLQHVVROFKHQ=XVWDQGV±MHQVHLWVLGHRORJLVFKHU 6HOEVWWlXVFKXQJ±XQWHUVWUHLFKHQZUGH5LF°XUDEHUNHQQWEHLGHV HUEHVFKZ|UW MHQHÄEHIULHGHWHQ(UIDKUXQJHQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³ZLHVLHVLFKHWZD LQ/LHEHXQG)UHXQGVFKDIWRGHULP6FKHQNHQXQG9HU]HLKHQUHDOLVLHUHQN|QQHQ 'RFK VFKUHLEW HU GHQHQ GLH ÄYHUORFNW³ GXUFK ÄGDV /RE GHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ³DOO]XEHUVFKZlQJOLFK]XZHUGHQXQGLQGLHÄ)DOOHQGHU9HU VFKPHO]XQJVHLQKHLW³]XWDSSHQGURKHQHLQHQGHXWOLFKHQ6DW]LQV6WDPPEXFK Ä'HUHLQHLVWQLFKWGHUDQGHUH³'LHVH'LIIHUHQ]Ä]ZLVFKHQPLUXQGGHPDQGH UHQ³GLHÄQLFKWDXHU.UDIW]XVHW]HQ³LVWVFKOLHW]ZDUQLFKWDXVGDVVZLULQ ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XVDPPHQILQGHQ'RFKLVWGDVQLFKWJHVHW]WZHLO ZLU EHLGH QLFKW JlQ]OLFK LP ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ DXIJHKHQ VRQGHUQ LPPHU QRFK HLQPDOGDYRQXQWHUVFKLHGHQVLQG8PGLHVH'LPHQVLRQVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ 6HOEVWVHLQVGLHVLFKHEHQVRSRVLWLYZLHQHJDWLYDXVZLUNHQNDQQJHKWHVDXFKLP =XVDPPHQKDQJWKHRORJLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVGHQNHQV
6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ±WKHRORJLVFK Ä'LH*HVFKLFKWHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ>«@EHJLQQW>«@QLFKWPLW.DQW)LFKWHRGHU +HJHOVRQGHUQPLWbJ\SWHQ0HVRSRWDPLHQXQG,VUDHOZRVLH]XGHQ*UXQGEH GLQJXQJHQGHVJHOXQJHQHQ/HEHQVJHK|UW³ZHL%HUQG-DQRZVNL]XVDJHQ Ä9RQKLHUDXV³VHLÄGDV(WKRVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJPLWGHU]ZHLJHWHLOWHQFKULVWOL FKHQ%LEHODXIGHQ:HJJHEUDFKWZRUGHQ³ 'LHVHP+LQZHLVZLUGLP)ROJHQ GHQ]XQlFKVWLQDOWXQGQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHQDFKJHJDQJHQ D XP GDQQDXIDNWXHOOHV\VWHPDWLVFKWKHRORJLVFKRULHQWLHUWH$UEHLWHQHLQ]XJHKHQ E
%87/(5 5,&¯85 $D29JODD2II $D2I $D2 -$12:6.,I9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGHLQVJHVDPW DD2IIXQG'(56 II'LHIROJHQGHQhEHUVHW]XQJHQGHU3VDOPWH[WHVLQG-DQRZVNLV3XEOLNDWLRQHQHQWQRPPHQ -$12:6., 9JO]XUWKHRORJLVFKHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIDXFKGLH%HL WUlJHLQGHUYRQ,VROGH.DUOHYHUDQWZRUWHWHQ$XVJDEHGHU=HLWVFKULIW(YDQJHOLVFKH7KHRORJLH GLHXQWHUGHP7LWHOÄ'LH6XFKHQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJ±WKHRORJLVFKHXQGVR]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH 3HUVSHNWLYHQ³HUVFKLHQHQLVW .$5/( VRZLH*(5%(52+/«@XPGHQ0HQVFKHQLQVHLQHU6HOEVWEH]JOLFKNHLWVRQGHUQXP GLH5HODWLRQYRQ6FK|SIHUXQG*HVFK|SI³QXULQQHUKDOEGHUHUGHU0HQVFKDOV HKUZUGLJSUDFKWYROOMDIDVWJRWWJOHLFKJHOWHXQGDQHUNDQQWVHL'LHVYHUGHXW OLFKWHUDQKDQGGHU9HUZHQGXQJGHV$XVGUXFNVÃ(KUHµGHPÄ=HQWUDOEHJULIIGHV $OWHQ7HVWDPHQWVIUVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJ³LQGHQYRUKHUJHKHQGHQ3VDOPWH[ WHQGLHPLW3VLQHLQHPNRPSRVLWRULVFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJVWHKHQ1LFKWQXULVW GRUWGDYRQGLH5HGHGDVV*RWWÄPHLQH(KUH³LVWÄXQGGHUGHUPHLQ+DXSWHU KHEW³ 3V VRQGHUQHVJHKWLPPHUZLHGHUDXFKXPGHQÄGXUFKGLH)HLQGHLQ VHLQHUVR]LDOHQ([LVWHQ]EHGURKWHQ%HWHU³GHVVHQÄ(KUH]XU6FKPDFK³ 3V JHPDFKWRGHUÄLQGHQ6WDXE³JHOHJW 3V ZLUG/HW]WHUHÄ7H[WH³YHUPLWWHOQ QDFK-DQRZVNL/HVDUWÄGDV7RGHVELOGGHUVR]LDOHQ0LDFKWXQJXQGYLDQHJDWLR QLVGDV/HEHQVELOGGHUVR]LDOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³ZRQDFKÄHLQHUDOOHLQJDUQLFKW OHEHQVIlKLJXQGGHVKDOEDXFKQLFKWLPYROOHQ6LQQOHEHQGLJ³VHL9LHOPHKU PVVHIUGHQ0HQVFKHQGHP]XIROJHÄHLQHUGDVHLQ>«@GHULKQLQVHLQHP/H EHQJHOHLWHWGHUVLFKXPLKQNPPHUWXQGGDIUVRUJWGDVHLQH(KUH>«@QLFKW ÃLQGHQ6WDXEµJHOHJWZLUG³*RWWNRPPWVRJHZLVVHUPDHQDOV:RKHUHLQHU XQYHUEUFKOLFKHQ(KUHE]Z$QHUNHQQXQJ]XVWHKHQGLHPLU±NRQWUDIDNWLVFK± DXFKGDQQQRFK]XNRPPWZHQQPLFKVR]LDOQXU0LVVDFKWXQJWULIIW'HPHQW VSULFKWGLHHWZDLQ3VDXVJHGUFNWHÄ*HZLKHLWGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$XIPHUNVDP
-$12:6.,9JOIUGHQ%H]XJDXI.DQW '(56 I(UEH]LHKWVLFK GDEHLDXIGLHDQ3VHULQQHUQGH3DVVDJHDXVGHU.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWZRGHU ÄEHVWLUQWH+LPPHOEHUPLUXQGGDVPRUDOLVFKH*HVHW]LQPLU³]XP$QVDW]SXQNWXQWHUVFKLHG OLFKHU(KUIXUFKWVHPSILQGXQJHQZHUGHQ :lKUHQGGHUÄ$QEOLFNHLQHU]DKOORVHQ:HOWHQPHQJH >«@JOHLFKVDPPHLQH:LFKWLJNHLWDOVHLQHVWLHULVFKHQ*HVFK|SIV³YHUQLFKWHWÄHUKHEW³GLH (QWGHFNXQJGHVÃPRUDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]HVLQPLUµÄGDJHJHQPHLQHQ:HUWDOVHLQHU,QWHOOLJHQ] XQHQGOLFK³ .$17 E>$I@ 0LWEHUGLH7H[WH[HJHVHGHXWOLFKKLQDXVJHKHQGHP NULWLVFKHP,PSHWXVVFKUHLEW-DQRZVNLEHL.DQWZHUGHÄGLH:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQPLWVHLQHQ JHLVWLJHQ)lKLJNHLWHQJOHLFKJHVHW]W³ZDVÄDXI.RVWHQHLQHVMHGHQÃ%H]XJVQDFKDXHQµ³JHKH ZRKLQJHJHQPLW3VÄGDV:HVHQGHV0HQVFKHQ>«@QLFKWGHUYHUQXQIWEHVWLPPWH6HOEVWEH ]XJVRQGHUQGHU6DFKYHUKDOW³VHLÄGDPHQVFKOLFKHV/HEHQ/HEHQLQ%H]LHKXQJHQLVWXQG ]ZDULQ%H]LHKXQJHQGLHYRP6FK|SIHUJRWWJHVWLIWHWZHUGHQ³ -$12:6., 'DVV GLHVHV.DQW%LOGXQ]XWUHIIHQGLVWOlVVWVLFKXQWHQLQ%QDFKOHVHQ -$12:6., 9JODD2 II -$12:6., -$12:6., (UEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLDXVGUFNOLFKDXI+RQQHWKV$QHUNHQQXQJV WKHRULH]XUFN YJODD2 I $D2
(LQOHLWXQJ
NHLWXQG)UVRUJH³'DUEHUKLQDXVVLHKW-DQRZVNLÄGLHVHELEOLVFKH7UDGLWLRQV OLQLHDXIÃHLQ(WKRV³]XODXIHQÄLQGHPGDV$QVHKHQGHVDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQYRU 9HUOHXPGXQJJHVFKW]Wµ³ZLUGXQGGDVLQVRIHUQÄÃHLQDNWLYHV%HPKHQXPHLQH .XOWXUGHU$QHUNHQQXQJHLQVFKOLHWµ³:LHPDQDEHUYRQGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ Ã*HZLVVKHLWJ|WWOLFKHU$XIPHUNVDPNHLWXQG)UVRUJHµ]XGHQ3UD[LVYROO]JHQ HLQHUVROFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVNXOWXUJHODQJWGLH-DQRZVNLDXIGHQ%HJULIIGHV Ä)UHLQDQGHU+DQGHOQV³EULQJWEOHLEWXQNODU 'HU*HGDQNHHLQHVVROFKHQLPJ|WWOLFKHQ+HLOVKDQGHOQ JUQGHQGHQ(WKRV OlVVWVLFKDXFKLQQHUKDOEGHV1HXHQ7HVWDPHQWVLQVEHVRQGHUHEHL3DXOXVHQWGH FNHQ'HVVHQ%ULHIHVR0LFKDHO:ROWHUVLQGDQ6WHOOHQZRGLHMHZHLOVDGUHV VLHUWHQ*HPHLQGHQHWKLVFKHUPDKQWZHUGHQKlXILJYRPDXFKLQDQGHUHQQHXWHV WDPHQWOLFKHQ7H[WHQEHJHJQHQGHQÄ3ULQ]LSGHUHJDOLWlUHQ5H]LSUR]LWlWJHOHL WHW³ (VÄKDQGHOW>«@VLFKGDEHLXP:HLVXQJHQGLHPLW+LOIHGHVUH]LSURNHQ 3URQRPHQVÃHLQDQGHUµRGHUÃZHFKVHOVHLWLJµ>«@JHELOGHWZHUGHQ³DOVRÄV\P PHWULVFKNRQ]LSLHUWVLQG³XQGÄLPPHUIUEHLGH6HLWHQJOHLFKHUPDHQ³JHOWHQ Ä6HLGVROFKHGLH>«@DQ(KUHHLQDQGHUGHQ9RU]XJJHEHQ³KHLWHVHWZDLQ 5|PXQGGLH*HPHLQGHLQ3KLOLSSLZLUGDXIJHIRUGHUWÄHLQDQGHULQ'HPXW IUEHGHXWVDPHU]XKDOWHQDOVVLFKVHOEVW³ 3KLO :RUDXI3DXOXVPLWGLHVHQ )RUGHUXQJHQKLQDXVZLOOLVWIU:ROWHU JXWYHUVWlQGOLFK 6R]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVROOPDQQLFKWIUVLFKVHOEVWEHDQVSUXFKHQVRQGHUQ GHQDQGHUHQ]XZHQGHQ>«@-HGHULVWJHKDOWHQMHGHP$QHUNHQQXQJ]XWHLOZHUGHQ]XODVVHQ± XQGXPJHNHKUW>«@&KULVWHQVROOHQVLFKLP8PJDQJPLWHLQDQGHUGDYRQOHLWHQODVVHQGDVV GDVZDVMHGHQHLQ]HOQHQDXV]HLFKQHWDOOHJOHLFKPDFKW GLH%HVWLPPWKHLWLKUHU,GHQWLWlWGXUFK &KULVWXV'DUXPKDWNHLQHUGHPDQGHUHQHWZDVYRUDXV'HUHLQHLVWVRÃHKUZUGLJµZLHGHU DQGHUH
,P+LQWHUJUXQGVWHKWGHUHWZDLQ*DOIRUPXOLHUWH*UXQGJHGDQNHSDXOLQL VFKHU(NNOHVLRORJLHZRQDFKÄÃLQ&KULVWXVµGLHDOOWDJVZHOWOLFKHQ6WDWXV]XVFKUHL EXQJHQ³±-XGH*ULHFKH6NODYH)UHLHU0DQQ)UDX±ÄDXIJHKREHQVLQGXQG >«@DOOHGLHDQ&KULVWXVJODXEHQXQGDXILKQJHWDXIWVLQG(LQHUVLQG³6WHOOW PDQLQ5HFKQXQJGDVVGLHÃDOOWDJVZHOWOLFKHQ6WDWXV]XVFKUHLEXQJHQµ±EHVRQGHUV
$D2 -$12:6.,(U]LWLHUWGDEHL*581' -$12:6., $OV]HQWUDOHQ%HOHJWH[WIKUW-DQRZVNL0L±DQZRGDV*RW WHVYHUKlOWQLVPLWHLQHU3UD[LVGHV6LFK+LQJHEHQVIUGDV5HFKWGHV$QGHUHQYHUNRSSHOWZLUG YJODD2 II :2/7(59JOGD]X DD2±9JO]XHLQHUQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKHQ$XVHL QDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW GHU $QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLN DXFK 7KRPDV 3RSSV DXI GHQ 3HWUXVEULHI NRQ]HQWULHUWH6WXGLH'LH.XQVWGHU.RQYLYHQ] 3233 :2/7(59JO]XP)ROJHQGHQGLH$XVOHJXQJYRQ5|PLQ GHUV II :2/7(5I :2/7(5
(LQOHLWXQJ
GHXWOLFKLP)DOOHGHV6NODYHQ±DXHUKDOEGHVLP5DXPGHUHNNOHVLDLGHDOHU ZHLVHJHOHEWHQ(WKRVZHFKVHOVHLWLJHJDOLWlUHU$QHUNHQQXQJZHLWHUJHOWHQZLUG DXFKKLHUHLQHNRQWUDIDNWLVFKH'LPHQVLRQXQYHUEUFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWXQG$QHU NDQQWVHLQVVWDUNJHPDFKW:LHREHQLQ3VHUVFKHLQWGLHVHUDOOHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOL FKHQ(KUYRUVWHOOXQJHQHQW]RJHQH(KUHQWLWHODEHUDEKlQJLJYRP9HUKlOWQLV]X *RWWGDVEHL3DXOXVGXUFKGHQ&KULVWXVJODXEHQTXDOLIL]LHUWZLUG'DVVDXIGHV VHQ*UXQGODJHGLHÃDOOWDJVZHOWOLFKHQ6WDWXV]XVFKUHLEXQJHQµUHODWLYLHUWZHUGHQ LVWDXV:ROWHUV6LFKWDXFKGLHÄ=HQWUDOWKHVH³GHUSDXOLQLVFKHQÄ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV OHKUH³GLHDOOHUGLQJVNRQWH[WXHOODXIGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ-XGHQXQG1LFKWMXGHQ IRNXVVLHUWVHLÄ:HURGHUZDVGLH0HQVFKHQZLUNOLFKVLQG³ÄEHUGLHZDKUH ,GHQWLWlWGHU0HQVFKHQ³GDVDOOHUGLQJVJLOWQDFK:ROWHUIU3DXOXVJHQHUHOO ÄEHVWLPPWDOOHLQ*RWWXQGGHU&KULVWXV*ODXEHJHKWGDYRQDXVGDVVGLHVH:LUN OLFKNHLWGXUFKGLH2IIHQEDUXQJYRQ*RWWHV+HLOLQ-HVXV&KULVWXVJHVFKDIIHQ ZXUGH³ $XV-DQRZVNLVXQG:ROWHUVH[HJHWLVFKHQ%HIXQGHQZLUG]XPHLQHQGHXWOLFK GDVVGLHWKHRORJLVFKH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDQLFKW QXUDXIGHQV\VWHPDWLVFKWKHRORJLVFKHQ%HUHLFKEHVFKUlQNWLVWGHULP)ROJHQGHQ LP=HQWUXPVWHKW=XPDQGHUHQOHJWHVVLFKGHPQDFKVFKRQYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQG ELEOLVFKHU7H[WH QDKH GLH DXI *RWW EH]RJHQH *ODXEHQVJHZLVVKHLW PLW HLQHP %HZXVVWVHLQXQEHGLQJWHQ6HOEVWXQG$QHUNDQQWVHLQVYHUEXQGHQ]XVHKHQ'D GXUFKZLUGHEHQVRGLH0DFKWGHUEHVWHKHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVRGHU(KURUGQXQJ EHJUHQ]W]XGHUPHQVFKOLFKHV6HOEVWVHLQÃYRU*RWWµLQHLQHPVSDQQXQJVYROOHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVWHKWZLHQDFKGDUDXV±ZLHDXFKLPPHU±UHVXOWLHUHQGHQJHOLQJHQGHQ )RUPHQVR]LDOHQ0LWHLQDQGHUVJHIUDJWZLUG'LHEHLGHQVFKRQLP]XUFNOLHJHQ GHQ$EVFKQLWWKHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWHQ$VSHNWHWUHWHQVRHLQPDOPHKU YRU$XJHQ ZRUDQQXQDQ]XNQSIHQLVW E Ä'LHQHX]HLWOLFKH%HJULIIVJHVFKLFKWHYRQÃ$QHUNHQQXQJµ³VFKUHLEW5LVWR 6DDULQHQÄLVW>«@DXFK7KHRORJLHJHVFKLFKWH³ZHVKDOE 7KHRORJHQ>«@QLFKWQXU+RQQHWKXQG5LFRHXUVRQGHUQDXFKXQGSULPlU0DUWLQ/XWKHUXQG -RKDQQHV&DOYLQ-RKDQQ-RDFKLP6SDOGLQJXQG)ULHGULFK'DQLHO(UQVW6FKOHLHUPDFKHU5XGROI %XOWPDQQXQG.DUO%DUWKVWXGLHUHQPVVHQXPGDVWKHRORJLVFKH3RWHQWLDOGHV$QHUNHQQXQJV EHJULIIVDQJHPHVVHQ]XYHUVWHKHQ
:ROWHUEHPHUNW]XPKLHUHLQVFKOlJLJHQ3KLOHPRQEULHI Ä5HFKWOLFKJHVHKHQEOHLEWHU>VF GHU6NODYH2QHVLPXV .7@6NODYHGRFKYHUODQJW3DXOXVYRQVHLQHP+HUUQGDVVGLHVHULKQ DXFKLPKlXVOLFKHQ$OOWDJ ÃLP)OHLVFKµ DOVHLQHQÃ%UXGHUµXQGÃ3DUWQHUµEHKDQGHOW 3KOP ± XQGGDPLWVHLQHV6NODYHQFKULVWOLFKH,GHQWLWlWEHUGLHDOOWDJVZHOWOLFKHGRPLQLHUHQ OlVVW³ DD2I $D29JOGD]X DD2 II $D2I9JOGD]XDD2IIII 6$$5,1(16DDULQHQV6WXGLHQJHK|UHQLQGHQ.RQWH[WGHVLQGHU$FDGHP\RI )LQODQG¶V&HQWUHRI([FHOOHQFHDQJHVLHGHOWHQ)RUVFKXQJVQHW]ZHUNV5HDVRQDQG5HOLJLRXV 5HFRJQLWLRQ9JO]XGHVVHQ(UJHEQLVVHQDXFKGHQIROJHQGHQ6DPPHOEDQG .$+/26XD
(LQOHLWXQJ
,QVHLQHUKLVWRULVFKV\VWHPDWLVFKHQ6WXGLH5HFRJQLWLRQDQG5HOLJLRQ JHKW HUVRJDUQRFKZHLWHU]XUFNXQGHU]lKOWZDVVHLQHVJOHLFKHQVXFKWGLHWKHRORJL VFKH*HVFKLFKWHGHV$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIVYRQGHQQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKHQ$QIlQ JHQDQ:DVGDV:HUNYRQGDEHLNRQVXOWLHUWHQ'HQNHUQZLH$XJXVWLQXV%HUQ KDUGYRQ&ODLUYDX[7KRPDVYRQ$TXLQXQG0DUVLOLR)LFLQRELVKLQ]XGHQVR HEHQDXIJH]lKOWHQUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQE]ZQHX]HLWOLFKHQ7KHRORJHQGXUFK]LHKW LVWDXV6DDULQHQV6LFKWHLQHVSH]LILVFKUHOLJL|VH$QHUNHQQXQJVNRQ]HSWLRQGLH HLQHQ GHXWOLFK DQGHUHQ $N]HQW DOV GLH ZLUNPlFKWLJHQ VR]LDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQHQGHU*HJHQZDUWHWZD+RQQHWKVXQG7D\ORUVVHW]W :KLOHPRGHUQVHFXODUWKHRULHVRIUHFRJQLWLRQRIWHQIRFXVRQWKHHPHUJHQFHDQGFRQVWLWXWLRQRI WKHUHFRJQL]HHUHOLJLRXVYLHZVSXWDGLVWLQFWHPSKDVLVRQWKHSHUIRUPDWLYHVWDWXVDQGLGHQWLW\ RIWKHUHFRJQL]HU
,P=HQWUXPVWHKWDOVRZHQLJHUGDVDQHUNDQQWHDOVYLHOPHKUGDVDQHUNHQQHQGH 6XEMHNWZREHLÄGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQ³VR6DDULQHQÄLQGHUFKULVWOL FKHQ7KHRORJLHWUDGLWLRQHOODOV.RQYHUVLRQXQG1HXRULHQWLHUXQJGHV$QHUNHQ QHQGHQNRQ]LSLHUW³ ZLUG6HLQ$XVJDQJVSXQNWELOGHQLPODWHLQLVFKHQ6FKULIW WXP]%EHL$XJXVWLQXVKlXILJEHJHJQHQGH7HUPLQLÄZLHDJQLWLRYHULWDWLVE]Z DJQLWLR'HL³ 6LHEH]HLFKQHQHLQGXUFKGLH.RQIURQWDWLRQPLW*RWWRGHUGHU J|WWOLFKHQ:DKUKHLWDXVJHO|VWHVDIILUPDWLYHV(UNHQQHQGKHLQ$Q(UNHQQHQ GDVDXIVHLWHQGHVEHWURIIHQHQ6XEMHNWVXQZHLJHUOLFK]XHLQHUÃ.RQYHUVLRQXQG 1HXRULHQWLHUXQJµLP6LQQHGHV DQ HUNDQQWHQ2EMHNWVIKUW6RZLUGHWZDEHL .DUO %DUWK ÄGHU FKULVWOLFKH *ODXEH³ DOV ÄHLQ $QHUNHQQHQ³ EH]HLFKQHW ZREHL XQWHUÄ$QHUNHQQXQJ³QLFKWRKQH6SDQQXQJHQ]XPHJDOLWlUHQ*HKDOWGHUVR]LDO SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ.DWHJRULHÄHLQHIROJXQGIJVDPHHLQHVLFKEHXJHQGHVLFK XQWHURUGQHQGH .HQQWQLVQDKPH³ YHUVWDQGHQ ZLUG $XFK Ä6SDOGLQJ XQG 6FKOHLHUPDFKHU³VFKUHLEW6DDULQHQÄVHW]HQGLHDOWHODWHLQLVFKH%HJULIIOLFKNHLW >«@DXIHLJHQVWlQGLJH:HLVHIRUWLQGHPVLHOHKUHQGDVVGLHUHOLJL|VH(UNHQQWQLV HUVWLP5DKPHQHLQHUDSULRULVFKHQH[LVWHQWLHOOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³LKUHV*HJHQ VWDQGHVÄRUGHQWOLFKHQWVWHKW³XQGÄQLFKWDOVREMHNWLYHV:LVVHQRGHUWKHRUHWLVFKH /HKUHDXIJHIDVVWZHUGHQ³NDQQ 'HUWKHRORJLVFKH$N]HQWDXIGHPMHHLJHQHQ 9JOGHQKLVWRULVFKHQ7HLOGHU6WXGLH 6$$5,1(1±9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQVHL QHHLJHQH=XVDPPHQIDVVXQJGHU+DXSWWKHVHQLQ GHUVDI 6$$5,1(1 6$$5,1(1D9JOGD]XGHQ6FKOXVVWHLOGHV%XFKHVGHVVHQ+DXSWDQOLHJHQLP ]LWLHUWHQ6DW]DXIGHQ3XQNWNRPPW '(56II 6$$5,1(1D9JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ '(56I II %$57+ I9JOGD]X 6$$5,1(1I II 6$$5,1(19JOGD]X '(56II=HQWUDOLVWIU6DDULQHQ6SDOGLQJV 6FKULIW5HOLJLRQHLQH$QJHOHJHQKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ LQGHUÄ5HOLJLRQ³DOVGLHÄ$QHU NHQQXQJHLQHVK|FKVWYROONRPPHQHQ:HOWUHJLHUHUVLQVHLQHU%H]LHKXQJDXIXQV³EH]HLFKQHW ZLUG 63$/',1* ,P%OLFNDXI6FKOHLHUPDFKHU]LWLHUWHUGHQ/HLWVDW]YRQGHU *ODXEHQVOHKUH Ä'LH$QHUNHQQXQJGDGLHVHVVFKOHFKWKLQQLJH$EKlQJLJNHLWVJHIKO LQGHPGDULQXQVHU6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQGLH(QGOLFKNHLWGHV6HLQVLPDOOJHPHLQHQYHUWULWW>«@
(LQOHLWXQJ
H[LVWHQ]LHOOHQ(UJULIIHQVHLQGDVPLWGHUZDKUKDIWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ*RWWHVDOV *RWWÃIUPLFKµXQZHLJHUOLFKHLQKHUJHKWPDFKWDXVVHLQHU6LFKWDXFKHWZDVDQ VR]LDOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]JHQGHXWOLFK Ä,QVXP³VFKUHLEWHU WKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWWKHRORJLFDOFULWHULRQLQRXUUHFRJQLWLRQRIRWKHUVLVRXURZQRSHQQHVVDQG UHDGLQHVVWRFKDQJH2QO\VXFKSHRSOHZKRFDQSUDFWLFHPHWDQRLDZLWKUHJDUGWRWKHPVHOYHV DUHFDSDEOHRIUHFRJQL]LQJRWKHUSHRSOHDQGEHFRPHUHFRJQL]HGE\WKHP>«@,Q/XWKHUDQ WKHRORJ\RXUWUXVWLQ*RGLVWKHVRXUFHRIRXURZQRSHQQHVV
8PHLQHDQGHUH3HUVRQZLUNOLFKDOVVLHVHOEVWLQLKUHU$QGHUVKHLWDQ]XHUNHQQHQ EHGDUIHVGHPQDFKEHLGHUDQHUNHQQHQGHQ3HUVRQ2IIHQKHLWIUGLH(LJHQDUWGHV *HJHQEHUVXQG9HUlQGHUXQJVEHUHLWVFKDIWLP%OLFNDXIVLFK6DDULQHQOlVVWVLFK KLHUHLQHUVHLWVVRYHUVWHKHQGDVVGHUFKULVWOLFKH*RWWHVJODXEHWKHRORJLVFKDOV HLQHP|JOLFKH4XHOOHGHVGDIUQ|WLJHQ9HUWUDXHQVQDPKDIWJHPDFKWZHUGHQ VROOWH $QGHUHUVHLWV VWUHLFKW HU GDPLW DXFK GLH 8QYHUIJEDUNHLW JHOLQJHQGHQ $QHUNHQQHQVKHUDXVLQVRIHUQGLHH[LVWHQ]LHOOH%HWURIIHQKHLWGXUFKXQGGDV6LFK (LQODVVHQDXIGLHMHZHLOVDQGHUH3HUVRQHEHQVRZHQLJZLH*ODXEHRGHU5HOLJLRQ GXUFKLUJHQGZHQVFKOLFKWZHJ]XHU]HXJHQVLQG6DDULQHQEULQJWVRGDV6SDQ QXQJVYHUKlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQGHPVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQGVR]LDOHU $QHUNHQQXQJWKHRORJLVFK]XU*HOWXQJXQGIUDJW]XJOHLFKQDFKGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQ JHOLQJHQGHU=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKNHLW $OOHUGLQJVZHLVW6DDULQHQVHOEVWDXIHLQHQÄODFNRIHTXDOLW\³ LQVHLQHP.RQ ]HSWUHOLJL|VHU$QHUNHQQXQJKLQGHUEHUHLWVLP%OLFNDXI.DUO%DUWKV5HGHYRQ GHUÃIROJXQGIJVDPHQVLFKEHXJHQGHQVLFKXQWHURUGQHQGHQ.HQQWQLVQDKPHµ *RWWHVGXUFKGDV6XEMHNWGHV*ODXEHQVDQJHPHUNWZXUGH'HU6DFKHQDFKEH JHJQHWHGLHVHU0DQJHODXFKEHUHLWVLQGHQREHQEHKDQGHOWHQELEOLVFKHQ7H[WHQ GLHGDV6HOEVWVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQXPHVGHQ8QZlJEDUNHLWHQGHVVR]LDOHQ/H EHQV]XHQW]LHKHQDOOHLQYRQGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ9HUIJXQJVPDFKWDEKlQJLJVHLQ OLHHQ'DVGDUDXVLGHDOLWHUUHVXOWLHUHQGH(WKRVÃHJDOLWlUHU5H]LSUR]LWlWµLP]ZL VFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ%HUHLFKVWHKW]XPDV\PPHWULVFKHQ*RWW0HQVFK9HUKlOWQLV LQVFKDUIHP.RQWUDVWVRGDVVDXFKDXIGLHVHU(EHQHXQNODUEOHLEWZDUXPGDV HLQHDXVGHPDQGHUHQIROJHQVROO'LHVVHW]WVLFKLQHLQHPJHJHQZlUWLJKlXILJ EHPKWHQ0RWLYIRUWGDV6DDULQHQEHL6FKOHLHUPDFKHU]XHUVWYHUZHQGHWVLHKW,Q GHVVHQ *ODXEHQVOHKUH KHLW HV Ä'D *RWW GHQ VLFK %HNHKUHQGHQ UHFKWIHUWLJWVFKOLHWLQVLFKGDHULKPGLH6QGHQYHUJLHEWXQGLKQDOVHLQ .LQG*RWWHVDQHUNHQQW³ QLFKWHWZDV=XIlOOLJHVLVWQRFKDXFKHWZDVSHUV|QOLFKYHUVFKLHGHQHVVRQGHUQHLQDOOJHPHLQHV /HEHQVHOHPHQWHUVHW]WIUGLH*ODXEHQVOHKUHYROOVWlQGLJDOOHVRJHQDQQWHQ%HZHLVHIUGDV 'DVHLQ*RWWHV³ 6&+/(,(50$&+(5 DI 6$$5,1(1E 6$$5,1(1 6&+/(,(50$&+(5 D 9JOGD]X 6$$5,1(1II
(LQOHLWXQJ
$QGHUVLFKEHL6FKOHLHUPDFKHUEHUHLWVQLHGHUVFKODJHQGHQ9HUNQSIXQJYRQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQG$QHUNHQQXQJLQGHP6LQQHGDVVGHU0HQVFKLP*ODXEHQ QLFKWQXU*RWWDQHUNHQQWVRQGHUQDXFKGXUFK*RWWDQHUNDQQWZLUGKDEHQLQVEH VRQGHUH$OEUHFKW5LWVFKOXQG.DUO+ROOZHLWHUJHDUEHLWHW(VLVWVR8OULFK%DUWK LKUHÄJURH/HLVWXQJ>«@GHQIRUHQVLVFKHQ5DKPHQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH GXUFKGDV0RGHOOGHU$QHUNHQQXQJHUVHW]W]XKDEHQ³ ±HLQPRGHUQLWlWVDIILQHU 8PIRUPXQJVYHUVXFKGHUVLFKDXFKLQMQJHUHU=HLWVWDUNHU5HVRQDQ]HUIUHXW6R EHGHXWHWGXUFK*RWWÄ>J@HUHFKWIHUWLJW>]X@VHLQ³HWZDQDFK(EHUKDUG-QJHOV± ZLH6DDULQHQVFKUHLEW±ÄLQIOXHQWLDOWUHDWLVHRQMXVWLILFDWLRQ³ DXVGHP-DKUH QLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVÄHLQHXQZLGHUUXIOLFKDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQ>]X@VHLQ³ Ä$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKPHQVFKOLFKH3HUVRQHQ³VHLKLQJHJHQÄUHYR]LHUEDU³ Ä9RQ DQGHUHQXQPLWWHOEDUDOV0HQVFKDQHUNDQQWXQGUHVSHNWLHUW]XZHUGHQLVWMHGHP XQGMHGHUHLQH[LVWHQ]LHOOHV%HGUIQLV³KHLWHVHQWVSUHFKHQGLP*UXQGODJHQ WH[WGHU(YDQJHOLVFKHQ.LUFKHLQ'HXWVFKODQG]XP5HIRUPDWLRQVMXELOlXP Ä'LHVH ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH (UIDKUXQJ YRQ $QHUNHQQXQJ³ DEHU VHL lXHUVW ÄVHOWHQ³ZHVKDOEGDVFKULVWOLFKH$QJHERWHLQHUYRUEHKDOWORVHQGHP(LQ]HOQHQ GLHVVHLWVHLJHQHU/HLVWXQJHQXQGVR]LDOHU=XVFKUHLEXQJHQ]XNRPPHQGHQÄ$QHU NHQQXQJGXUFK*RWW³JHJHQZlUWLJJURH5HOHYDQ]HQWIDOWHQN|QQH 'RFKZLHGHUNLUFKOLFKH*UXQGODJHQWH[WPLWWHOVGHUUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJL VFKHQ%RWVFKDIWYRQGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJQRUPDWLYIHVWKDOWHQZLOOGDVV GLHÄ)UHLKHLWQLFKWLP0HQVFKHQVHOEVWLKUHOHW]WH%HJUQGXQJILQGHW³GLHQW VLHDXFKEHL-QJHO]XU*UXQGVDW]NULWLNGHVÄGXUFKVHLQH7DWEHUVLFKVHOEVW HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ 6XEMHNW>V@³ 'HU YRQ 6DDULQHQ QDPKDIW JHPDFKWH ÃODFN RI HTXDOLW\µVHW]WVLFKLQVROFKHQ5HGHZHLVHQLQGHQHQGHUDOV(QWODVWXQJHLQJH
%$57+ ([HPSODULVFKOlVVWVLFK5LWVFKOV$XVVDJHDXV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQG 9HUV|KQXQJ DQIKUHQ GLH Ä$QZHQGXQJ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ³ VWHOOH ÄHLQ HLJHQWKPOLFKHV 6HOEVWJHIKOLQGHP0HQVFKHQIHVWGDVVLFKLQGHU+RIIQXQJDXIGLHGDXHUQGH$QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK*RWWLQGHU*HGXOGLP/HLGHQNXQGJLHEWXQGHLQH.UDIWHLQVFKOLHVVWZHOFKHDOOHQ .UlIWHQXQG2UGQXQJHQGHU:HOWEHUOHJHQLVW³ 5,76&+/ %HL+ROOILQGHWVLFKGHU PDUNDQWH6DW] Ä5HFKWIHUWLJXQJEHGHXWHWGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWW³ +2// 6$$5,1(16DDULQHQEHJLQQWVHLQH6WXGLHPLWHLQHUNXU]HQ'DUVWHOOXQJYRQ-Q JHOV3RVLWLRQ YJODD2II'LH:LUNPlFKWLJNHLWYRQ-QJHOV SXEOL]LHUWHU6WXGLH'DV (YDQJHOLXPYRQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHV*RWWORVHQDOV=HQWUXPGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQVOlVVW VLFKDXFKGDUDQEHPHVVHQGDVVVLHXQWHUGHVVHQLQGHU$XIODJH HUVFKLHQHQLVW'LH 6SXUHQVHLQHV$QVDW]HVODVVHQVLFKELVLQGLHLP)ROJHQGHQ]LWLHUWH(.'6FKULIWYHUIROJHQ -h1*(/ D1HEHQ-QJHOODVVHQVLFKDXVMQJHUHU=HLWIUGHQ7KHPHQEHUHLFK Ã5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQG$QHUNHQQXQJµQRFKQHQQHQ 02;7(5 +b5/( *5b%D .256&+ 0226II 6/(1&=.$ -h1*(/L .LUFKHQDPWGHU(.' (EG $D2 -h1*(/F
(LQOHLWXQJ
IKUWH =XVSUXFK HLQHQ PLW PRUDOLVFKHQ (UZDUWXQJHQ EHODVWHQGHQ $QVSUXFK HQWKlOWGHXWOLFKIRUW*HJHQGLHDXWRQRPLHNULWLVFKHQ2IIHUWHQVROFKHV5HFKWIHU WLJXQJVGHQNHQVKlOW)DON:DJQHULQGHVVHQ:HUNHLQHUHJHOUHFKWHÄ7KHRORJLH GHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³HQWIDOWHWZLUGHWZDV*UXQGVlW]OLFKHVIHVW GDVVLPPHUQRFK YRPÄ0HQVFKHQ>«@DNWLY>«@DQJHHLJQHWZHUGHQPX³ZDVLKPYRQJ|WWOL FKHU6HLWHKHU]XNRPPHQVROO'LHVDEHUVHW]HÄ)UHLKHLWEHLPHUJUHLIHQGHQ 6XEMHNW³YRUDXV'DULQSIOLFKWHWLKP7UDXJRWW.RFKLP5DKPHQHLQHUWKHROR JLVFKHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIEHL Ä)UHLKHLWEHUXKW QLFKW DXI $QHUNHQQXQJ³ VFKUHLEW HU Ä$QHUNHQQXQJ LVW QlPOLFK LPPHU HLQH %HVWlWLJXQJXQG(LQVHW]XQJGHVVHQZDVVLHDQHUNHQQW³QLFKWDEHUGHVVHQ+HU YRUEULQJXQJ:DVEHLGHPLWLP'HWDLOGDQQVHKUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ)ROJHUXQ JHQJHPHLQVDPHLQIRUGHUQOlVVWVLFKVRDXIGHQ3XQNWEULQJHQ $XFKLP9HU KlOWQLV]X*RWWPXVVJHOWHQZDVLPVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVJHOWHQVROO±GDVVGDV 6XEMHNWQLFKWQXULVWZDVDQGHUHRE*RWWRGHU0HQVFKHQLKPDQHUNHQQHQG ]XJHVWHKHQ(VLVWZLH:DJQHUVFKUHLEWHEHQVRZHQLJDOVHLQÄEORH>V@$QKlQJ VHO GHV *HVHOOVFKDIWVV\VWHPV³ ZLH DOV HLQ ÄDN]LGHQWHOOH>V@ $QKlQJVHO³ YRQ Ä*RWWHV VRXYHUlQHU 6HOEVWGDUVWHOOXQJ³ ]X YHUVWHKHQ VRQGHUQ VR .RFK DOV ÄVHOEVWHWZDVXQGDOVRHWZDVXQDXVWDXVFKEDU(LJHQHV³'LH6SDQQXQJ]ZL VFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJLVWDQGHUVJHVDJWDXFKIUGDV*RWWHVYHU KlOWQLVJHOWHQG]XPDFKHQZHQQYRQJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJEHU]HXJHQGGLH 5HGHVHLQVROO 0LWGHUVRHEHQHU|IIQHWHQ'LVNXVVLRQ]ZLVFKHQ-QJHO:DJQHUXQG.RFKLVW XQWHUGHU+DQGEHUHLWVGHUhEHUJDQJLQGHQHUVWHQ+DXSWWHLOGLHVHU$UEHLWDQJH EDKQWZRUGHQ%HYRUGHUHQ$XIEDXXQGGDVZHLWHUH9RUJHKHQ]XU'DUVWHOOXQJ NRPPHQLVWDOOHUGLQJVQRFKLQDOOHU.U]HHLQ%OLFNDXIZHLWHUHV\VWHPDWLVFK WKHRORJLVFKRULHQWLHUWH$UEHLWHQ]XP$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDDXVMQJHUHU=HLW]X ZHUIHQ 8QWHUGHP7LWHO5HOLJLRQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJYHUVXFKWGHUSUDNWLVFKH7KHRORJH 7RELDV%UDXQH.ULFNDXLQVHLQHUSXEOL]LHUWHQ'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWDQJH
%$57+ :$*1(5 E :$*1(5N .2&+D :$*1(5 E :$*1(5 .2&+ D ,FKIKUHLP)ROJHQGHQQXUVROFKHWKHRORJLVFKHQ$UEHLWHQDXVMQJHUHU=HLWDXIGLHVLFK DXVGUFNOLFK XQG ]HQWUDO PLW GHU $QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLN EHIDVVHQ 9HUQDFKOlVVLJW ZHUGHQ GDPLWQLFKWQXU$UEHLWHQGLHQXUDP5DQGHGDUDXIUHNXUULHUHQVRQGHUQDXFK$XVHLQDQGHUVHW ]XQJHQPLWGHUÃ3KLORVRSKLHGHU*DEHµGLH]ZDUYHUPLWWHOWGXUFK5LF°XUDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHR UHWLVFKDQVFKOXVVIlKLJLVWDEHUHLQHQHLJHQVWlQGLJHQ'LVNXUVGDUVWHOOW 9JOGD]XGLH$UEHLWHQ YRQ+2))0$11XQG0,(61(5VRZLHGLH%HLWUlJHGHV6DPPHOEDQGV+2))0$11 XD
(LQOHLWXQJ
VLFKWVGHUPRGHUQHQÄ6lNXODULVLHUXQJGHV+HOIHQV³FKULVWOLFKH'LDNRQLHDOV2UW UHOLJL|VHU (UIDKUXQJ YHUVWlQGOLFK ]X PDFKHQ 6HLQ $QVDW]SXQNW LVW HLQ LP *HVSUlFK PLW $[HO +RQQHWK KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWHV %LOG GLDNRQLVFKHU Ä3UD[LV³ GHPQDFKHVGLHGDULQ7lWLJHQÄLQEHVRQGHUHU:HLVHPLWJHOHEWHUXQGYHUZHKUWHU $QHUNHQQXQJ]XWXQ³KDEHQ'DVVGLHV(UIDKUXQJVNRQVWHOODWLRQHQVLQGGLH]X ÄHLQH>U@UHOLJL|VH6HOEVWGHXWXQJGHU+DQGHOQGHQ³LQQHUKDOEGHU6R]LDOIUVRUJH HLQODGHQPDFKWHUXQWHUXDXQWHU5HNXUVDXI)DON:DJQHUGHXWOLFK'HVVHQ WKHRORJLVFKHU$QVDW]EHLPÄXQYHUV|KQWHQ=XVWDQGYRQ3HUVRQDOLWlWXQG6R]LDOL WlW³IKUHÄGLUHNWDXI)UDJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOV=HQWUXPLQGLYLGXHOOUHOLJL|VHU 'HXWXQJVNXOWXU³HEHQVRZLHVLFKVHLQH/HVDUWGHUÄ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH>«@ RKQHDOO]XJURH8PVWlQGHDOVHLQH7KHRULHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ GXUFK*RWWXQGGDPLW]XJOHLFKDOV0RYHQVDXFK]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKJHOHEWHU $QHUNHQQXQJ³HWZDLQGHQ%H]JHQGLDNRQLVFKHQ+DQGHOQVEHJUHLIHQODVVH (EHQIDOOVDXI$[HO+RQQHWKVWW]WVLFKGHUNDWKROLVFKH)XQGDPHQWDOWKHRORJH 0DUNXV.QDSSLQVHLQHPHUVFKLHQHQHP%XFK:HOWEH]LHKXQJXQG*RWWHVEH ]LHKXQJÄ>8@QWHU%H]XJQDKPHDXIGLHSKLORVRSKLVFKH$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULH³ GHUHQÄHODERULHUWHVWH>U@$QVDW]³LQVHLQHQ $XJHQHEHQYRQ+RQQHWKVWDPPW YHUVXFKWHUÄ]X]HLJHQXQG]XEHJUQGHQ³GDVVHV >D@XFKLP.RQWH[WHLQHUVlNXODUHQ0RGHUQH>«@P|JOLFK>EOHLEW@GHQFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVEH ]XJXQGGHQGDULQLPSOL]LHUWHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVR]XHUOlXWHUQGDVVHUQLFKWXQYHUHLQEDUPLW HLQHUVlNXODUHQ:HOWLVWVRQGHUQVLFKDOV0|JOLFKNHLWHUZHLVWGLH0RGHUQHDQGHUVEHVVHU]X YHUVWHKHQ
'DEHLNRPPWHVLKP]XSDVVGDVVVLFKZLHHUVFKUHLEWÄGLH]HQWUDOH,QWXLWLRQ GHU$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULH>«@PLWGHP>EHUKUW@ZDVGLH7KHRORJLHDOVFKULVWOL FKH*ODXEHQVZDKUKHLW]XYHUWUHWHQKDW³*HPHLQWLVWÄGLHLQMHGHP0HQVFKHQ DQ]XWUHIIHQGH 6HKQVXFKW QDFK HLQHP XQEHGLQJWHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQ³ DXI GLH GLUHNW EH]RJHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQH ÄZLH *RWW VLFK QDFK GHP ELEOLVFKHQ =HXJQLV VHOEVW]XHUNHQQHQJLEW³ ÄQlPOLFKDOVOLHEHQGHU]XJHZDQGWHU*RWW³GHUÄGHQ 0HQVFKHQDOVVHLQ*HVFK|SIXQEHGLQJW³DQHUNHQQHDXIGDVVÄGLHVHUVHLQ'DVHLQ LQIUHLHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJJHVWDOWH>@XQGGDEHL]XUHQGJOWLJHQ6LQQHUIOOXQJ GLHVHV'DVHLQVILQGH>@³ .QDSSV)RUPXOLHUXQJ]HLFKQHWGHQ/DXIVHLQHV*H GDQNHQJDQJVYRUGHUYRQGHUÄ6FK|SIXQJ³DOVÄYRQ*RWWXQEHGLQJWDQHUNDQQ 9JO %5$81(.5,&.$8 9JO ]XP 6WLFKZRUW Ä6lNXODULVLHUXQJ GHV +HOIHQV³ DD2II $D29JO]XU+RQQHWK,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ DD2II $D2 $D29JO]X:DJQHULQVJHVDPW DD2II1HEHQ:DJQHUZHUGHQGLHDQHU NHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKDOOHUGLQJVZHQLJHUHLQVFKOlJLJHQ$XWRUHQ+HQQLQJ/XWKHU.DUO5DKQHU 7UXW]5HQGWRUIIXQG:ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJUH]LSLHUW .1$33I $D2 $D2 $D2I
(LQOHLWXQJ
WH>U@:LUNOLFKNHLW³]XUÄ9ROOHQGXQJGHU6FK|SIXQJDOVHQGJOWLJH>U@9HUZLUNOL FKXQJZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³GLHYHUPLWWHOVGHV*RWWHUJHEHQHQIUHLHQ +DQGHOQVGHV0HQVFKHQDQYLVLHUWZLUGIRUWVFKUHLWHW 'DVVÄHVGDV6WUHEHQGHV0HQVFKHQLVWXQEHGLQJWDQHUNDQQWXQGEHMDKWXQG DOOHLQXPVHLQHUVHOEVWZLOOHQJHOLHEW]XZHUGHQ³LVWDXFKGLHGXUFKSKLORVRSKL VFKH7KHRULHQJHIHVWLJWH7KHVHGHVNDWKROLVFKHQ)XQGDPHQWDOWKHRORJHQ&KULV WRSK%|WWLJKHLPHU3DVVHQGGD]XYHUKHLHÄGHUFKULVWOLFKH*ODXEH>«@HLQH XQEHGLQJWH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWW³,QVHLQHU6WXGLH YHU|IIHQWOLFKHQ6WXGLH%HGLQJXQJVORVDQHUNDQQWGLHGHQ%HLWUDJGHV*ODXEHQV ]XU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVELOGXQJHUIRUVFKW]LHOWDXFKHUGDUDXIGHQÄ*HKDOWFKULVWOL FKHU+HLOVXQG(UO|VXQJVERWVFKDIW>«@PLWWHOVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHLQGHU KHXWLJHQ=HLWYHUVWlQGOLFK³]XPDFKHQ'DEHLHQWGHFNW%|WWLJKHLPHULQGHU GXUFKGHQ*ODXEHQHU|IIQHWHQÄ0|JOLFKNHLWVLFKYRQ*RWWXQEHGLQJWDQHUNDQQW ]XZLVVHQ³GDV3RWHQ]LDOVLFKWURW]GHUHLJHQHQ0lQJHOVHOEVW]XEHMDKHQXQG VRÄHLQH3HUV|QOLFKNHLWDXV]XELOGHQGLHLKUHUVHLWVIlKLJLVWDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ HQWJHJHQ]XEULQJHQ³ 'HQQ ÄGHU PLW )UHLKHLW DXVJHVWDWWHWH 0HQVFK³QHLJHREZRKOHUÄGXUFKXQGGXUFKHLQ%H]LHKXQJVZHVHQ³VHLÄLPPHU ZLHGHUGD]XYRQVHLQHU)UHLKHLWHLJHQPlFKWLJXQGHJRLVWLVFK*HEUDXFK]XPD FKHQ³ )UHLQH.XOWXUGHU$QHUNHQQXQJLQGHUDOOHVLFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJDOV*OHLFKEH UHFKWLJWHDN]HSWLHUHQXQGQLHPDQGEHVFKlPWRGHUPLVVDFKWHWZLUGSOlGLHUWDQD ORJGD]XGHUHYDQJHOLVFKH7KHRORJHXQG3V\FKRORJH6WHIDQ6HLGHOLQVHLQHP JOHLFKQDPLJHQ%XFKDXVGHP-DKUHÄ,GHQWLWlW³LP6LQQHHLQHVSRVLWLYHQ 6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVVHVQlPOLFKVHLÄQLFKWRKQHGLH$QHUNHQQXQJDQGHUHU]XKDEHQ³ ZLH HU XQWHU +HUDQ]LHKXQJ VR]LDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHU ± XD +RQQHWK %XWOHU XQG 7D\ORU ± VRZLH SV\FKRORJLVFKHU 7KHRULHQ KHUDXVDUEHLWHW Ä'LH 5HOLJLRQ³ YHUVWHKWPDQVLHÄDOVHLQH$UWPHQWDOHVXQGVR]LDOHV$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV³ HQWKlOWVR6HLGHOV7KHVH3RWHQ]LDOGLH .XOWLYLHUXQJGHUQRWZHQGLJHQÃ'RSSHO+HOL[µGHU$QHUNHQQXQJXQWHUVWW]HQ±EHVWHKHQGDXV HLJHQHU$QHUNHQQXQJXQGGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDQGHUHU1lPOLFKLQGHPGLH5HOLJLRQGHP0HQ VFKHQHLQHUVHLWVKLOIWHLQHQHLJHQHQ'HXWXQJVXQG%H]LHKXQJVUDKPHQ]XKDEHQXQGDQGHUHU VHLWVHLQ%HZXVVWVHLQVWLIWHWGDVVPDQQLFKWDOOHLQDXVVLFKVHOEVWKHUDXVOHEWVRQGHUQDXV HLQHPJU|HUHQ J|WWOLFKHQXQGVR]LDOHQ $QHUNHQQXQJV]XVDPPHQKDQJ
6RGLH7LWHOGHUEHLGHQ+DXSWNDSLWHO $D2II %g77,*+(,0(5 (EG $D2 $D2 (EG 6(,'(/ $D2
(LQOHLWXQJ
5HVVRXUFHQ]XU%HI|UGHUXQJHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJVNXOWXUNRPPHQLQ6HLGHOV$X JHQGHUÄMGLVFKFKULVWOLFKH>Q@5HOLJLRQ³LQVEHVRQGHUHZHJHQLKUHVVSH]LILVFKHQ *RWWHVELOGV]X *RWWGHILQLHUHVLFKGHPQDFKHUVWHQVJHUDGHZHJVÄGXUFKGLHDXI $QHUNHQQXQJ XQGDXI6ROLGDULWlWEHUXKHQGHQ%H]LHKXQJHQGHU0HQVFKHQ]X LKUHU0LWZHOW³=ZHLWHQVDEHUVHL*RWWLPPHUDXFKÄJDQ]DQGHUV>«@DOVHV VLFKGHU0HQVFKYRUVWHOOW³ZDVLKQÄJOHLFKVDP³]XPÄJURH>Q@3ODW]KDOWHUIU GDV$QGHUHXQG)UHPGHDQVLFK³ZHUGHQODVVHÄLQGHPHULPPHUHLQHQ3ODW] MHQVHLWVGHV(LJHQHQEHVHW]WXQGGLHVHQ2UWXQGGLHVHV5HFKWGHVDQGHUHQGDXHU KDIWSUlVHQWKlOW³ 9RUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGVHLÄ>H@LJHQWOLFK>«@JDUNHLQ$XV VFKOXVVDQGHUHUNHLQH0LVVDFKWXQJRGHU(QWZHUWXQJ)UHPGHUP|JOLFK³GHQQ ÄGDVNlPHOHW]WOLFKHLQHU9HUQHLQXQJ*RWWHVJOHLFK>«@±HVZlUHHLQH9HUZHL JHUXQJYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHV>VLF@DXVGHQHQKHUDXVPDQGRFKVHOEVW OHEW³ $OVHLQZHLWHUHVPLWGHP*HVDJWHQHQJ]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGHV3RWHQ]LDOGHU ÄMGLVFKFKULVWOLFKH>Q@5HOLJLRQVWUDGLWLRQ>«@IUGLH)|UGHUXQJHLQHU.XOWXUGHU $QHUNHQQXQJ³QHQQW6HLGHOGLHÄ9RUVWHOOXQJYRP0HQVFKHQDOV*RWWHV(EHQ ELOG³'HUHQ$NWXDOLWlWVSRWHQ]LDOKHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQLVWGDV$QOLHJHQGHU'LV VHUWDWLRQGHVNDWKROLVFKHQ7KHRORJHQ%HUQKDUG.RKOGLHXQWHUGHP7LWHO 'LH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV9HUOHW]EDUHQHUVFKLHQHQLVW.RKOYHUVWHKWGHQ0HQ VFKHQDXIJUXQGH[HJHWLVFKHU%HIXQGHDOVÄGDVELOGORVH%LOG*RWWHV³GDVÄQLFKW LQ%LOGHUQIL[LHUWZHUGHQNDQQXQGGDUI³YRQZRDXVHULP$QVFKOXVVDQ+RQ QHWK%XWOHUXQG(GZDUG6FKLOOHEHHFN[HLQH$UWQHJDWLYH7KHRORJLHGHU$QHU NHQQXQJHQWZLUIW=ZDUEHGUIHÄMHGHU0HQVFKJHZLVVHU$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOW QLVVH>«@XP>«@VHLQH6XEMHNWLYLWlWDXVELOGHQ]XN|QQHQ³GRFKNRPPHHVLP =XJHGHVVHQÄLPPHUDXFK]XUÃ$Q9HUNHQQXQJµGHV$QHUNDQQWHQ³GHUVWHWVÄÃDOV HWZDVµ³DQHUNDQQWZHUGH6ROFKHÃ$Q9HUNHQQXQJµZHUGHDOV9HUOHW]XQJHUIDK UHQGLHGHQHLQ]LJOHJLWLPHQQHJDWLYHQ$QVDW]SXQNWHLQHUSRVLWLYHQ%HVWLP PXQJ GHVVHQ ELHWH ZDV GHU 0HQVFK LVW XQG ZLH HU EHKDQGHOW ZHUGHQ VROOWH Ä,GHQWLWlW³LVWQDFK.RKOVWKHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKHUhEHU]HXJXQJÄQXUEHU GLH YLD QHJDWLYD ]X VXFKHQ XQG LQ GHU 'HQXQ]LDWLRQ GHV8QPHQVFKOLFKHQ ]X ILQGHQ³GDVLQ3KlQRPHQHQYHUOHW]WHQ6HOEVWVHLQV]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPWXQG GHQ:HJ]XHLQHPKXPDQHUHQ8PJDQJPLWHLQDQGHUZHLVW :DVGLHGDUJHVWHOOWHQV\VWHPDWLVFKWKHRORJLVFKE]ZIXQGDPHQWDOWKHRORJLVFK RULHQWLHUWHQ$UEHLWHQ]XU$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLNYHUHLQWLVWGHU9HUVXFKGLH
$D2I $D2 (EG $D2 .2+/D .2+/E,FKRULHQWLHUHPLFKLP)ROJHQGHQDQGLHVHP,QWHUYLHZLQGHP.RKOGLH 7KHVHQVHLQHU$UEHLWNXU]XQGNQDSS]XP$XVGUXFNJHEUDFKWKDW (EG .2+/
(LQOHLWXQJ
*HJHQZDUWVUHOHYDQ]FKULVWOLFKHU5HOLJLRQE]ZFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQVXQWHU%H ]XJDXIHLQVFKOlJLJH VR]LDO SKLORVRSKLVFKH3RVLWLRQHQDXV]XZHLVHQ'DEHL ZLUGÃ*RWWµLQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU:HLVHPLW(UIDKUXQJHQYHUZHLJHUWHUYHUNHQ QHQGHURGHUHLQIDFKPDQJHOKDIWEOHLEHQGHUVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJYHUNQSIWXQG DOV*UXQGHLQHV6HOEVWVHLQVQDPKDIWJHPDFKWYRQGHPKHUVROFKHQ1HJDWLYHU IDKUXQJHQHWZDVHQWJHJHQJHVHW]W]XZHUGHQYHUPDJ'DVJHVFKLHKWZLHGHUXP YHUPLWWHOVVR]LDOHU3UD[LVYROO]JHLQGHQHQGDV:RKOGHUDQHUNHQQXQJVEHGUI WLJHQ$QGHUHQ]XVXFKHQPDQVLFKYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGJOHLFKVDPYRQ*RWW KHUPRWLYLHUWEHIlKLJWRGHUDXFKGLUHNWYHUSIOLFKWHWZHL$XIGHQGDPLWEH KDXSWHWHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJ]ZLVFKHQGHUVRZXUGHHVREHQEHUHLWVJHQDQQWWKHR ORJLVFKJHOWHQG]XPDFKHQGHQÃ*RWWHVIUHLKHLWGHV,FKµXQGGHQ:LU%H]JHQGHU UH]LSURNHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHLVWDXFKGLHYRUOLHJHQGH$UEHLWIRNXVVLHUW 6LHIROJWPLWKLQHEHQIDOOVGHP9HUVXFKGHUDQJHIKUWHQ6WXGLHQ$QVFKOXVVSR WHQ]LDOH]ZLVFKHQWKHRORJLVFKHQXQGSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQDXIGDV9HU KlOWQLVYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG6HOEVWVHLQDXI]X]HLJHQ'RFKZLUGGDEHLHLQVWlU NHUHU$N]HQWDXIGLHEOHLEHQGHQ6SDQQXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LUJHOHJWGHUHQ 'LVNUHSDQ]QLFKWQXUDXVHLQHP0DQJHODQMHLQGLYLGXHOOHUIDKUHQHURGHUSUDNWL ]LHUWHU$QHUNHQQXQJKHUYRUJHKWGHUGDQQGXUFKHQWVSUHFKHQGH0DQDKPHQ]X EHUZLQGHQZlUH9LHOPHKUEOHLEWGDV,FKREVHLQHVVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ 9HUP|JHQVVLFK]XVLFKVHOEVWXQG]X$QGHUHPLQV9HUKlOWQLV]XVHW]HQVWHWV Ã6WDFKHOLP)OHLVFKµGHUHVLQVLFKEHJUHLIHQGHQ6R]LDOEH]LHKXQJHQ±XQGGDULQ LVWHVQLFKWYRQYRUQKHUHLQDOVHJRLVWLVFKRGHUJHPHLQVFKDIWVIHLQGOLFK]XEUDQG PDUNHQÄ'LH/HJHQGHGHUJXWHQ*HPHLQVFKDIW³VFKUHLEW:ROI/RWWHUÄLVWGHV KDOEXQDXVURWWEDUZHLOPDQVLFKXP>«@GLHXQDQJHQHKPH:DKUKHLWVFKOHFKWKLQ GUFNW (VJHKWXPSHUV|QOLFKH9HUDQWZRUWXQJ'DVLVWGHU-REGHV,FKLQGHU *HPHLQVFKDIWXQGGDVLVWGLH*UXQGODJHYRQDOOHP:LU³GHVVHQ9HUKDOWHQV HUZDUWXQJHQDQGDV,FKVR]XJOHLFK*UHQ]HQJHVHW]WVLQG'LHGDUDXVUHVXOWLHUHQ GHQ 6SDQQXQJHQ XQG LKUH WKHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH %HDUEHLWXQJ VLQG GDV 7KHPDGHUIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ =ZLVFKHQ*RWWHV XQG6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVR ZLUGLP=XJH GHVWKHRORJLVFK SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ*HVSUlFKVGHXWOLFKZHUGHQODVVHQVLFKDXIXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH :HLVH3DUDOOHOHQXQG'LIIHUHQ]HQDXVPDFKHQ%HLGHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQNDQQZDV *HJHQVWDQGGHU.ULWLNVHLQZLUGXQWHU5HNXUVDXIGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIHLQ IUVLQGLYLGXHOOH6HOEVWVHLQVFKOHFKWKLQNRQVWLWXWLYHU&KDUDNWHU]XJHVFKULHEHQ ZHUGHQ=XJOHLFKLVWGHU*RWWHVEH]XJGHV0HQVFKHQHWZDVGDVLKQQRFKHLQPDO YRQDOOHQLQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ%H]JHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW ZRUDXV VLFK $IILQLWlWHQ]X EHVWLPPWHQVXEMHNWSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ$QVlW]HQHUJHEHQ6FKOLHOLFKDEHULVWGLH )UDJHZLHVLFKGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]GHV*RWWHV]XP6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVZLHGHUXPLQ GLH XQHQWULQQEDUH %HVWLPPWKHLW GHV 6XEMHNWV GXUFK VR]LDOH :LU%H]JH HLQ ]HLFKQHWZRPLWZLHGHUXP3DUDOOHOHQ]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQHLQKHUJHKHQ
/277(5
(LQOHLWXQJ
7KHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH(UNXQGXQJVJlQJH± ]XP$XIEDXGHU$UEHLW 7KHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH(UNXQGXQJVJlQJHLP6SDQQXQJVIHOGYRQ,FK:LU XQG*RWWNQGLJWGHU8QWHUWLWHOGLHVHU$UEHLWDQ'UHLHEHQVRMHIUVLFKVWHKHQGH ZLHPLWHLQDQGHUYHUEXQGHQH+DXSWWHLOHZHUGHQGDEHLGXUFKVFKULWWHQ HLQWKHROR JLVFKHLQSKLORVRSKLVFKXQGHLQJHJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKRULHQWLHUWHU$EVFKQLWW ZREHLGLHWKHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHDXFKLQGHQDQGHUHQEHLGHQ7HLOHQHLQJH VSLHOWZLUG 'HQ$XVJDQJVSXQNWELOGHWGLH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWJHQXLQWKHRORJLVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ±(EHUKDUG-QJHO)DON:DJQHUXQG7UDXJRWW.RFK±GLHYRUGHP +LQWHUJUXQGGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HGHYRQ*RWWHLQDQGHUZLGHUVWUHLWHQGH3HUVSHNWL YHQDXIGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQPHQVFKOLFKHP6HOEVWVHLQXQGVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJ ZHUIHQ $ -HGHUGHUXQWHUGHUhEHUVFKULIW*RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LUVWHKHQGHQ 8QWHUNDSLWHOVFKOLHWPLWHLQHPH[HPSODULVFKHQ$XVEOLFNDXIGLHÃVR]LDOHQ)RO JHQµGLHVLFKDXVGHQMHZHLOLJHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQHUJHEHQ'HQhEHUJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ GHQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ$XWRUHQYHUPLWWHOQ$EVFKQLWWHLQGHQHQGHUMHZHLOVQlFKVWH LQGHU5HLKHDOV.ULWLNHUGHVYRUKHULJHQQDPKDIWJHPDFKWZLUG (VIROJWHLQHSKLORVRSKLVFKH(UNXQGXQJGHVEHVDJWHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHVGLHXQWHU GHP7LWHO,FKRGHU:LU"DP/HLWIDGHQGHU'HEDWWH]ZLVFKHQ$[HO+RQQHWKÄPLW GHVVHQ1DPHQVLFK³VR]HLJWHVDXFKGLHGDUJHOHJWHWKHRORJLVFKH5H]HSWLRQ ÄGHU%HJULIIGHU$QHUNHQQXQJLQGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'LVNXVVLRQ XQWUHQQEDU YHUELQGHW³ XQG GHP 86DPHULNDQLVFKHQ 3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHU XQG 3KLORVRSKHQ-RHO:KLWHERRNGXUFKJHIKUWZLUG % 'DEHLZLUGDXFKDXIDQGHUH WHLOVGXUFK:KLWHERRNXQG+RQQHWKLQGLH'HEDWWHHLQJHEUDFKWHWHLOVJXWGDUDQ DQVFKOLHEDUH3RVLWLRQHQXDYRQ-XGLWK%XWOHU%HDWH5|VVOHU'LHWHU+HQULFK XQG-UJHQ+DEHUPDVUHNXUULHUW$P(QGHHLQHVMHGHQGHUGUHL$EVFKQLWWHGLH GHQWKHPDWLVFKHQ6FKZHUSXQNWHQGHU'HEDWWHIROJHQZLUGMHHLQHUGHUWKHRORJL VFKHQ$XWRUHQDXVGHPHUVWHQ+DXSWWHLOPLWGHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQ LQV*HVSUlFKJHEUDFKW 'HUGULWWHXQGOHW]WH+DXSWWHLOQLPPWVFKOLHOLFKGLH$UEHLWEQGHOQGXQGDE VFKOLHHQG XQWHU GHP 7LWHO 6XEMHNWH YRQ KHXWH ]ZLVFKHQ ,FK :LU XQG *RWW H[HPSODULVFKH JHJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH 3HUVSHNWLYHQ DXI GDV 9HUKlOWQLV YRQ 6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJHLQ & $XFKKLHUZHUGHQZLHGHU-QJHO:DJQHU XQG.RFKLQV*HVSUlFKJHEUDFKWZREHLHVHUVWHQVXPGLHYRUDOOHPLQGHU$U EHLWVZHOWYHUDQNHUWH7KHPDWLNYRQ%XUQRXWXQG(UVFK|SIXQJJHKW]ZHLWHQVXP GLHJHJHQZlUWLJJUDVVLHUHQGHQ'HEDWWHQEHU OLQNH ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNXQGGULW WHQVXPGLHDPELYDOHQWH(LJHQDUWKHXWLJHU/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHQ
+2567(5
7HLO$
*RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU±WKHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ DXIGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ $7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
(LQOHLWXQJ 7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ 'DV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ,FKXQG:LUVRLVWLP5DKPHQGHV(LQOHLWXQJVNDSLWHOGHXW OLFKJHZRUGHQ]HLJWVLFKGXUFKHOHPHQWDUH6SDQQXQJHQEHVWLPPW(VLVWQLFKW VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKGDVVHV]XHLQHU:LU(LQVWHOOXQJGHV,FKNRPPWXQGDXFKGLH VR]LDOHQ:LU%H]JHVLQGQLFKWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKHU:HLVHRIIHQIUDEZHLFKHQ GH,FK3HUVSHNWLYHQ*RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU±GHU DXFK EHUGHPIROJHQGHQ .DSLWHOVWHKHQGH7LWHOUHNODPLHUWWKHRORJLVFKH'HXWXQJVNRPSHWHQ]IUGHQ8P JDQJPLWGLHVHQ6SDQQXQJHQ'HPQDFK]LHOWGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWHLQHUVHLWVDXI HLQH'LPHQVLRQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGLHHVXQDEKlQJLJVHLQOlVVWYRQGHQ LKPNUDIWVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XNRPPHQGHQ%HVWLPPWKHLWHQ$QGHUHUVHLWV LPSOL]LHUWVLHHLQHGLHVHU8QEHGLQJWKHLWGHV6HOEVWJHOLQJHQGHQIDOOVHQWVSUHFKHQ GH)RUPGHV6R]LDOHQ ,QZLHIHUQGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWGLHVH'RSSHOSHUVSHNWLYHDXIGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ ,FKXQG:LU6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJHU|IIQHWHUDUEHLWHLFKLP=XJHGHU IROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQDQKDQGYRQH[HPSODULVFKHQWKHRORJLVFKHQ$QVlW]HQ 'LHPHKURGHUZHQLJHUNULWLVFKH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHQDXIGDV$QHUNHQ QXQJVWKHPDKLQIRNXVVLHUWHQ3RVLWLRQHQ(EHUKDUG-QJHOV $ )DON:DJQHUV $ XQG7UDXJRWW.RFKV $ JHVFKLHKWGDEHLHLQHUVHLWVVRGDVVLKUH$QVlW]H MHIUVLFKEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQ9HUPLWWHOQGHhEHUOHLWXQJVNDSLWHOVRUJHQDQGHUVHLWV GDIUGDVVVLFK]ZLVFKHQGHQHLQ]HOQHQ$EVFKQLWWHQHLQIRUWODXIHQGHU*HGDQ NHQJDQJHUJLEW'DEHLZLUGHEHQVR:DJQHUDOV.ULWLNHU-QJHOVZLH.RFKDOV .ULWLNHU:DJQHUVVWDUNJHPDFKWVRGDVVLP5FNEOLFNDXIGHQMHZHLOVYRUDQJH JDQJHQHQ $EVFKQLWW QRFK HLQPDO SUREOHPDWLVFKH 3XQNWH DQ GHU GRUW UHNRQV WUXLHUWHQ3RVLWLRQYRU$XJHQWUHWHQ,QVLFKVLQGGLHHLQ]HOQHQ$EVFKQLWWHVR DXIJHEDXWGDVV]XQlFKVWGLHMHZHLOLJH6LFKWDXIGDV*RWW0HQVFK9HUKlOWQLV H[SOL]LHUWZLUGXPGDQQGHVVHQ%HZDQGWQLVIUGDV6R]LDOOHEHQKHUDXV]XVWHOOHQ 'DVVÃ*RWWµHEHQVRDQGDV,FKGHVUHOLJL|VHQJODXEHQGHQ6XEMHNWVJHNQSIW LVWZLHHUPLWGHP:LUVR]LDOHU9HUKlOWQLVVHYHUEXQGHQZHUGHQNDQQ±GLHVH VSDQQXQJVYROOH'RSSHOSHUVSHNWLYHGLHVLFKLP7LWHOGHVIROJHQGHQ.DSLWHOVXQG GHUYRUOLHJHQGHQ$UEHLWDXVGUFNWOlVVWVLFKEHLDOOHQGUHLQXQ]X:RUWNRP PHQGHQ'HQNHUQDXIVHKUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH:HLVHDXVILQGLJPDFKHQ$P(QGH GHV$EVFKQLWWV]X7UDXJRWW.RFKVROOGLHVQRFKHLQPDOLQNRQ]HQWULHUWHU)RUP DXIGHQ3XQNWJHEUDFKWZHUGHQ
$'HU0HQVFK]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGVR]LDOHU $QHUNHQQXQJ (EHUKDUG-QJHOV5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDUWLNHOV (LQOHLWXQJ Ä:LUVXFKHQXQVHUH$QHUNHQQXQJXQWHUXQVHUHVJOHLFKHQ'DVLVWHLQHLQWHUVXE MHNWLYHVR]LDOH.DWHJRULH'LH6XFKH QDFK $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK*RWWLVWNHLQ *HGDQNHGHUVLFKYRQVHOEVWQDKHOHJW³0LWGLHVHQ:RUWHQHUWHLOW8OULFK%DUWK LQHLQHPDP5HIRUPDWLRQVWDJSXEOL]LHUWHQ)$=,QWHUYLHZSURPLQHQWHQ Ä9HUVXFKH>Q@GLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHIUGLH0RGHUQH]XHUVFKOLHHQ³HLQH DXVGUFNOLFKH $EVDJH :HQQJOHLFK HU GDEHL DXI $XWRUHQ DQVSLHOW GLH ÄXP ³GHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIHQWVSUHFKHQGYHUZHQGHWKDEHQ±JHPHLQWVLQG $OEUHFKW5LWVFKOXQG.DUO+ROO±OLHHVLFK%DUWKVNULWLVFKHV9RWXPHEHQVRJXW JHJHQEHU(EHUKDUG-QJHOHUKHEHQ%HL-QJHOQlPOLFKWULWWGLH*UXQGDXVVDJH SDXOLQLVFKOXWKHULVFKHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLHGHU]XIROJHGHU0HQVFKDOOHLQ DXV*ODXEHQXQGQLFKWGXUFK:HUNHGHV*HVHW]HVYRU*RWWJHUHFKWZHUGHJHUQ LQDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHP*HZDQGDXIÄ>'@HU0HQVFK³VRKHLWHVGDQQ LVWÄGDGXUFKHLQ0HQVFK>«@GDHUVLFKYRQ*RWW>«@XQZLGHUUXIOLFKDQHU NDQQWZHL³QLFKWDEHULQGHPHUVLFKXQWHUVHLQHVJOHLFKHQÄVHOEHUGHILQLWLYH $QHUNHQQXQJ]XYHUVFKDIIHQ³YHUVXFKW:DV%DUWKIUXQSODXVLEHOKlOWGDVV
%,1*(1(57HLOHGLHVHV.DSLWHOVZXUGHQEHUHLWVYHU|IIHQWOLFKWLQ 7(7=/$)) D$XVJHKHQGYRQ8OULFK%DUWKVNULWLVFKHU,QWHUYLHZlXHUXQJVXFKWDXFK:LOOKHOP*UlE LQHLQHP$XIVDW]KHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQGDVVPDQÄGHQVHLW.DUO+ROO>«@LPPHUZLHGHUXQWHU QRPPHQHQ9HUVXFKHQGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHDXIGHP:HJHGHU$XIGHFNXQJGHUUHOLJL|VHQ ,PSOLNDWLRQHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVHUIDKUXQJDXFKGHPPRGHUQHQ0HQVFKHQQDKH]XEULQJHQ >«@HLQVHKUYLHOJU|HUHV3RWHQWLDO]X]XVFKUHLEHQKDW³ *5b%D 'DGXUFKGDVVHU GLHVHV3RWHQ]LDOLQHLQHPGXUFKJ|WWOLFKH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHU|IIQHWHQOHEHQVGLHQOLFKHQ8PJDQJ PLW6FKXOGHUIDKUXQJHQDXVPDFKWYRQGHQHQHVLQQHUKDOEVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]LHKXQJHQ NHLQH (UO|VXQJ JHEH EOHLEW HU DEHU ± HQWJHJHQ VHLQHU HLJHQHQ 3UlPLVVHQ ± OHW]WOLFK HLQHU QHJDWLYJHVWLPPWHQ6LFKWGHV0HQVFKHQYHUKDIWHWGHPÄHLQDOOHLQLQ*RWWJUQGHQGHVSRVLWL YHV6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLV³ DD2 ]XJHVDJWZLUG %,1*(1(5 9JOGD]XGHQ+LQZHLV%DUWKVLQ %$57+ -h1*(/F 9JO]XGLHVHP0RWLYDXFKXD '(56 I D H H M J I L I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VLFKGDVLP =ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQYHURUWHWH6WUHEHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJDXI *RWW EH]LHKHQ OlVVW ZLUG DOVR YRQ-QJHO JHUDGH VWDUN JHPDFKW 'DEHL ]LHKW -QJHODEHU]ZLVFKHQVR]LDOHUXQGJ|WWOLFKHU'LPHQVLRQVR]HLJWHVVHLQHJHUDGH ]LWLHUWH9DULDQWHGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVIRUPHOHLQHGHXWOLFKH'LIIHUHQ]HLQGLHGHU SDXOLQLVFKOXWKHULVFKHQ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYRQ*ODXEHQXQG:HUNHQE]Z(YDQJH OLXPXQG*HVHW]HQWVSUHFKHQVROO8QZLGHUUXIOLFKRGHUGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQW]X ZHUGHQ±GDVLVWGHPQDFKQLFKWVZDVXQWHU0HQVFKHQHUVFKZLQJOLFKLVWVRVHKU GHU(LQ]HOQHVLFKDXFKZHUNWlWLJGDUXPEHPKW1XUEHL*RWWYHUPDJHUGLHVH XQEHGLQJWH$IILUPDWLRQVHLQHUVHOEVW]XILQGHQZDV3URSULXPGHVGHQ:HUNHQ DEVFKZ|UHQGHQ*ODXEHQVLVW +DWGLH5HGHYRQHLQHU J|WWOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKGLHVHJOHLFK]HLWLJH 9HUDQNHUXQJLQXQG$EVHW]XQJYRQ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ(UIDKUXQJVEH]JHQ HQWJHJHQ8OULFK%DUWKVNULWLVFKHU(LQODVVXQJGRFKHWZDV3ODXVLEOHV"'LHVH)UDJH VROOHQGLHIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]X(EHUKDUG-QJHOV9HUVLRQGHVUHIRUPDWR ULVFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHGDQNHQVEHDQWZRUWHQ'LH$QWZRUWVRYLHOLVWYRUZHJ ]XVFKLFNHQZLUGJHPLVFKWDXVIDOOHQ=XPHLQHQQlPOLFKYHUPDJPLW-QJHOGLH DPELYDOHQWH 6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJ GHV LQ GHU QLH DXVJHPDFKWHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU $QGHUHQQDFKVLFKVHOEVWVXFKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQWKHRORJLVFKVRDXVJHGHXWHW]X ZHUGHQGDVVGHUGDULQODXWZHUGHQGHÄ:XQVFKJDQ]]XVHLQ³EHL*RWWNRQWUD IDNWLVFKH(UIOOXQJILQGHW9HUPLWWHOVGHVGLHVHNRQWUDIDNWLVFKH6HOEVWHUIOOXQJ EHL*RWWJHZLVVPDFKHQGHQ*ODXEHQVYHUIJWPDQGHPQDFKEHUÄLQWHUQH5HV VRXUFHQ]XU6HOEVWEHVWlWLJXQJ³RGHUÄ4XHOOHQVHLQHV'DVHLQVLQVLFK³XQGOHEW LQVRIHUQQLFKWÄDXVVFKOLHOLFKLQGHU0HLQXQJ$QGHUHU³$OOHUGLQJVLVW-QJHOV $QVDW] ± ]XP DQGHUHQ ± LQVRIHUQ SUREOHPDWLVFK DOV HU GDV *RWW0HQVFK 9HUKlOWQLVEHWRQWDV\PPHWULVFKIDVVW GLHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ VFK|SIWLPZDKUVWHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHVDXVGHP1LFKWVZHQQVLHGHQ0HQVFKHQ XQDEKlQJLJYRQÃGHU0HLQXQJ$QGHUHUµDOV0HQVFKHQDQHUNDQQWVHLQOlVVW
6g//( Ä*DQ]]XVHLQGDQDFKVHKQWVLFKGHU0HQVFK³KHLWHVDQDORJGD]XEHL -QJHO -h1*(/J,; $EHUVRIKUWHUIRUWÄ>G@HU0HQVFKPXYRU*RWWHUVFKHLQHQXP HUVHOEVWXPJDQ]HUVHOEVW]XVHLQ'LH*DQ]KHLWGHV0HQVFKHQEDXWVLFKGHPQDFKDXHUKDOE VHLQHUDXI,QGLH6LWXDWLRQYRU*RWWH[LVWHQWLHOOYHUVHW]W]XZHUGHQXQGGDPLW]XVHLQHU*DQ] KHLW]XJHODQJHQ±GDVYHUPDJGHU0HQVFKHQLQGHVVHQDOOHLQGDGXUFKGDHUJODXEW8QWHU *ODXEHQLVWGDEHLLP6LQQHGHUUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ7KHRORJLHMHQHILGHVHNVWDWLFD]XYHUVWHKHQ GLHGHQLPPHUVFKRQÃ]HUVWUHXWµH[LVWLHUHQGHQLPPHUVFKRQXPVHLQH*DQ]KHLWJHEUDFKWHQ 0HQVFKHQVRDXVVLFKKHUDXVVHW]WGDHULQGDV=XVDPPHQVHLQPLW*RWWYHUVHW]WZLUG³ZDV JOHLFKEHGHXWHQGGDPLWLVWÄGDHUGXUFK*ODXEHQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWZLUG³ '(56GI (V VLQGVROFKH6WHOOHQGLHIUDJHQODVVHQZDUXP-QJHOZLHQRFKGHXWOLFKZHUGHQZLUGGHUDUW VFKDUI EHWRQW GDVV GHU J|WWOLFKH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDNW LP 0HQVFKHQ ÄDQ QLFKWV DQNQSIHQ³ '(56 D N|QQHZRGRFKJHUDGHVROFKH6HKQVXFKWVPRWLYHGLHXQWHUGHUhEHUVFKULIW Ã(UO|VXQJVEHGUIWLJNHLWµDOV0RPHQWHDNWLYHU(PSIlQJOLFKNHLW]XOHVHQZlUHQ$QNQSIXQJV SXQNWHE|WHQ YJO]XP7KHPDÃ(UO|VXQJVEHGUIWLJNHLWµGHQJOlQ]HQGHQ$XIVDW]YRQ&KULVWR SKHU=DUQRZ '(56 1(8+286(5
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
=ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ*HVLFKWVSXQNWHQEHVWHKWHLQGHXWOLFKHU:LGHUVSUXFKGHULQ -QJHOV QHX]HLW NULWLVFKHP9RUEHKDOWLQ%H]XJDXIÄMHQH>@5HIOH[LYLWlWGHVVLFK GHUHLJHQHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWYHUVLFKHUQGHQJODXEHQGHQ,FK³ JUQGHQGUIWHGLH DXFKEHLLKPXQWHUGHP XQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWHQ 9HUGDFKWVWHKWÄGLHJ|WWOLFKH3HU VRQQXUQRFKDOVÃHLQ0LWWHO]XGLHVHU6HOEVWYHUVLFKHUXQJµ³]XLQVWUXPHQWDOLVLH UHQ'LHGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ3UREOHPHZHUGHQLP/DXIHGHUIROJHQGHQ$XV IKUXQJHQLPPHUZLHGHUEHJHJQHQ%HYRUGHUHQ$XIEDXYRUJHVWHOOWZLUG E LVW QXQHLQNXU]HU%OLFNDXIGHQ6WHOOHQZHUWGHVGDEHLUHNRQVWUXLHUWHQ5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVGHQNHQVLQ-QJHOVWKHRORJLVFKHP:HUN]XZHUIHQ D D :LH&KULVWLDQH6FKXEHUWDQPHUNWEHVWHKWÄ-QJHOVKRFKZHUWLJHU%HLWUDJ ]XU7KHRORJLHGHV-DKUKXQGHUWVQLFKWLQHUVWHU/LQLHLQVHLQHUSRLQWLHUWHQ 'DUVWHOOXQJ GHU SURWHVWDQWLVFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH³ MD HV VHL QDFKJHUDGH ÄEHPHUNHQVZHUWGDVVVLFKLQGHUODQJHQ/LVWHVHLQHU9HU|IIHQWOLFKXQJHQQXU HLQHHLQ]LJH0RQRJUDSKLHH[SOL]LWPLWGLHVHU7KHPDWLNEHIDVVW³%HPHUNHQVZHUW LVWGLHVYRUDOOHPGHVKDOEZHLO-QJHOLP7LWHOGHUHUZlKQWHQ0RQRJUDILHDXV GHP-DKUH GLHLQGHQ.RQWH[WGHU'HEDWWHQXPGLHÄ*HPHLQVDPH(UNOl UXQJ]XU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH³JHK|UWGDV(YDQJHOLXPYRQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ GHV*RWWORVHQDOV=HQWUXPGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQVEH]HLFKQHW :DVDEHUQDFK HLJHQHUhEHU]HXJXQJGDV=HQWUXPRGHUJDUGDVÄ=HQWUXPLP=HQWUXPGHVFKULVW OLFKHQ*ODXEHQV³GDUVWHOOWPVVWHHLJHQWOLFKIUVHLJHQHWKHRORJLVFKH'HQNHQ LQVJHVDPW]HQWUDOVHLQ,Q-QJHOV6WXGLH*RWWDOV*HKHLPQLVGHU:HOW GLHÄXQVWULWWLJDOVVHLQ+DXSWZHUN³ILUPLHUWILQGHQVLFKMHGRFKQXUVSlUOLFKH $XVIKUXQJHQ ]XU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHPDWLN ZHQQJOHLFK DQ HLQHU 6WHOOH PLW 1DFKGUXFNYRQGHUÄLP7RGHGHV0HQVFKHQ-HVXVJHVFKHKHQH>Q@5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ
-h1*(/M-QJHOEH]LHKWVLFKDQGLHVHU6WHOOHDXIGLH.ULWLN3DXO+DFNHUVDQ /XWKHUV7KHRORJLHGLHGHP5HIRUPDWRUHLQHHEHQVROFKH6XEMHNWEH]RJHQKHLW]XP9RUZXUI PDFKWZRKLQJHJHQ-QJHOIHVWVWHOOWGDVVQDFK/XWKHUÄ>L@P*ODXEHQ>«@GLHVFKRQJHVFKHKH QHJ|WWOLFKH=XZHQGXQJGHU:DKUKHLW]XP0HQVFKHQYHULIL]LHUW³ZLUG Ä'HU*ODXEHNRQVWL WXLHUWQLFKWVRQGHUQHUUH]LSLHUWXQGUDWLIL]LHUW³ZDV*RWWLQ&KULVWXVJHWDQKDW DD2 $XFK&KULVWLDQH6FKXEHUWPRQLHUWLQLKUHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW-QJHOV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV WKHRORJLHGDVVHUZHQQJOHLFKHUYRUDXVVHW]WÄGDVV]XP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQLPPHU DXFKGLHXQYHUWUHWEDUHLJHQH$QWZRUWGHV0HQVFKHQJHK|UW³GLHÄGD]XQRWZHQGLJH)UHLKHLW GHV 0HQVFKHQDXFK JHJHQEHU *RWW HLJHQV ]XDQDO\VLHUHQ XQG ]XEHQHQQHQ³VLFK ZHLJHUW 6&+8%(57 0LWKLQVHLÄ-QJHOV)RNXVVLHUXQJDXIGDVSDVVLYH%HWURIIHQVHLQGHV 0HQVFKHQLP*QDGHQJHVFKHKHQ>«@XQWUHQQEDUYHUEXQGHQPLWHLQHUVLFKGXUFKVHLQJHVDPWHV :HUNGXUFK]LHKHQGHQ.ULWLNDPQHX]HLWOLFKHQ6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVGHV0HQVFKHQDOVYHUQXQIW EHJDEWHPKDQGHOQGHP6XEMHNW³ HEG 9JO]XP)UHLKHLWYHUVWlQGQLVE]Z]XP9HUKlOWQLVYRQ 6HOEVWXQG)UHPGEHVWLPPXQJEHL-QJHODXFKGLHDIILUPDWLYJHKDOWHQHQ$QDO\VHQLQ +(5%67 II '52%(II 6&+8%(579JO]X-QJHOV7KHRORJLHLQVJHVDPWGLH%HLWUlJHGHV%DQGHV (9(56.5h*(5 9JO]XP'HEDWWHQNRQWH[WGLH(LQOHLWXQJLQ -h1*(/;,II -h1*(/ D .5h*(5
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWW³GLH5HGHLVWÄ*RWW³VRKHLWHVGRUWZHLWHUJHEH ÄLQGHPHUGHQ0HQVFKHQUHFKWIHUWLJW]XHUNHQQHQ>«@ZHUHUHLJHQWOLFKLVW³ ZREHLJLOW Ä5HFKWIHUWLJXQJLPSOL]LHUW$QHUNHQQXQJ³/lVVWVLFKDOVRGLH)UD JHÄZHURGHUZDV*RWWLVW³IU-QJHOQXUDQKDQGGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKH KHQVEHDQWZRUWHQXQGLVWGLHVPLWKLQDOVHLQÄ(UHLJQLVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³DXV ]XEXFKVWDELHUHQ GDQQ VWHKW ]X YHUPXWHQ GDVV GLH IROJHQGHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ PHKUDOVHLQHQ7HLODVSHNWVHLQHU7KHRORJLH]XP7KHPDKDEHQ8PGHQ=XVDP PHQKDQJYRQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQG$QHUNHQQXQJLQ-QJHOV'HQNHQ]XHUKHOOHQ NDQQVRJHVHKHQXQGVRZLUGHVDXFKJHVFKHKHQDXI7H[WHDXVVHLQHP:HUN ]XUFNJHJULIIHQZHUGHQGLHREHUIOlFKOLFKEHWUDFKWHWDQGHUHVIRNXVVLHUHQ'HQ +DXSWUHIHUHQ]SXQNWDEHUELOGHQGLHHUZlKQWH6WXGLHYRQ XQGHLQH5HLKH HLQVFKOlJLJHU$XIVlW]HDXVVHLQHU)HGHU 'LH7KHVHHLQHUUHFKWIHUWLJXQJV XQGVRDXFKDQHUNHQQXQJV WKHRORJLVFKHQ ,PSUlJQLHUXQJYRQ-QJHOV'HQNHQGDV-DQ5RKOVWUHIIHQGDOVÄKHUPHQHXWL VFKH>Q@ %DUWKLDQLVPXV³ FKDUDNWHULVLHUW HUKlUWHW VLFK ZHLWHU ZHQQ PDQ GHQ %OLFNDXIGHUHQ$QIlQJHULFKWHW-QJHOVQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKH'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIW 3DXOXVXQG-HVXV HQWVWDQGHQXQWHUGHUbJLGHGHVKHUPHQHXWLVFKHQ7KHR ORJHQ(UQVW)XFKV ZLGPHWVLFKÄGHP9HUKlOWQLVGHUSDXOLQLVFKHQ5HFKIHUWL JXQJVOHKUH]XU9HUNQGLJXQJ-HVX³:DVÄEHLGH6SUDFKHUHLJQLVVH³YHUHLQW VFKUHLEWHUDP(QGHLVWLKU9HUZHLVÄDXIGDVHVFKDWRORJLVFKH-D*RWWHV]XP 0HQVFKHQ³ LQ &KULVWXV ZRULQ VLFK ÄXQV *RWWHV 6HLQ >RIIHQEDUW@³ XQG ÄVHLQH *|WWOLFKNHLWHUZHLVW³ZHLOÄ*RWW³GDULQ]XJOHLFKÄ-D]XVLFKVHOEVWVDJW³'XUFK VHLQHQÄJURHQ/HKUHU³.DUO%DUWKGHPHUPLW*RWWHV6HLQLVWLP:HUGHQ HLQHDXVIKUOLFKH6WXGLHJHZLGPHWKDWZXUGHHUQDFKHLJHQHP%HNXQGHQZLHGH UXPDQJHUHJW
-h1*(/ $D2I $D2 9JOGLH$QJDEHQREHQ$QP 52+/6 9JO ]X -QJHOV :HUGHJDQJ -h1*(/ E ± -2&.(/ 1,(0(&.:LHEDUWKVFKH2IIHQEDUXQJVWKHRORJLHXQGEXOWPDQQVFKHKHLGGHJHUVFKH([LV WHQ]KHUPHQHXWLNEHL-QJHO]XVDPPHQNRPPHQEULQJW0DOWH'RPLQLN.UJHULQHLQHU,QWHU SUHWDWLRQYRQ*RWWDOV*HKHLPQLVGHU:HOWVRDXIGHQ3XQNW Ä+HUPHQHXWLVFKVHW]W-QJHO± DQVWHOOHGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWPLWLKUHU6HOEVWVLFKHUXQJ±DXIHLQLQGHU0HWDSKRULN HUVFKORVVHQHV9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ6SUDFKHLQGHPGLH:LUNOLFKNHLWDXIGHQ0HQVFKHQ]XNRPPW XQGLKQVRDXVVLFKKHUDXVUXIWGDVVHUZDKUKDIWHUVHOEVWZLUG8QGWKHRORJLVFKVHW]W-QJHO± DQVWHOOHGHVPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ7KHLVPXVXQGVHLQHU9ROOHQGXQJLP$WKHLVPXV±DXIHLQHLP *ODXEHQHUVFKORVVHQH7ULQLWlWVOHKUHZRQDFK*RWWDOV/LHEHGDV*HKHLPQLVGHU:HOWLVW'HU KHUPHQHXWLVFKH XQG WKHRORJLVFKH $QVDW] EHL -QJHO HQWVSUHFKHQ HLQDQGHU VLH VLQG LQ GHU 6HOEVWLGHQWLILNDWLRQ*RWWHVPLWGHP*HNUHX]LJWHQLQGHVVHQ$XIHUZHFNXQJDOVGHUVSUDFKOL FKHQ6HOEVWGHILQLWLRQ*RWWHVYHUDQNHUW³ .5h*(5 -h1*(/ $D2I
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
*RWWYRP(UHLJQLVVHLQHU2IIHQEDUXQJGDVKHLWYRP(UHLJQLVVHLQHV=XU:HOW.RPPHQVKHU ]XGHQNHQ >«@DOVHLQHQ*RWWGHPQLFKWV0HQVFKOLFKHVIUHPGLVWXQGGHUGHU0HQVFKKHLWLQ -HVXVQlKHUJHNRPPHQLVWDOVGLH0HQVFKKHLWVLFKVHOEHUQDKH]XVHLQYHUPDJ
%HLGH$XVVDJHQNRPPHQ]XVDPPHQZHQQ-QJHOGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHHLQH ÄKHUPHQHXWLVFKH%HGHXWXQJIUGDV*DQ]HGHUWKHRORJLVFKHQ(UNHQQWQLV³]X ZHLVWZHLOHVLQLKUXPQLFKWVZHQLJHUJHKHDOVXPÄGDVUHFKWH5HGHQYRQ*RWW XQGYRP0HQVFKHQ³:LHYRP0HQVFKHQQXUVRUHFKWJHUHGHWZLUGGDVVPDQ LKQDOVGXUFK*RWWLQ&KULVWXVXQZLGHUUXIOLFKÄEHMDKWXQGDQHUNDQQW³WKHPD WLVFKPDFKWVSULFKWDXFKQXUYRQ*RWWDOV*RWWZHULKQPLWGLHVHPVHLQHPÃ-D ]XP0HQVFKHQµLGHQWLIL]LHUW±ZREHLHV-QJHOZLHQRFK]X]HLJHQVHLQZLUG VHKUGDUXP]XWXQLVWMHGHP9HUGDFKWHLQHUGDUDXV]XVFKOXVVIROJHUQGHQ$EKlQ JLJNHLW*RWWHVYRQGHU=XZHQGXQJ]XP0HQVFKHQ]XZHKUHQ'LHNXU]H,QYHQ WXUYRQ-QJHOV7KHRORJLHOlVVWMHGHQIDOOVIUGDV)ROJHQGHHLQ9RUJHKHQOHJLWLP HUVFKHLQHQ GDV GHP 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV XQG VR DXFK $QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPD HLQH ]HQWUDOH6WHOOXQJLQVHLQHP'HQNHQHLQUlXPW E =XQlFKVWZLUGLQGLHVHP.DSLWHOGDV$XJHQPHUNGDUDXIJHOHJWZLH-QJHO GLHPHQVFKOLFKH$QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXI$QHUNHQQXQJXQGGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQVR]LD OHUXQGJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJJHQDXHUIDVVW 'DQQJHKWHVXPGLHGDEHL YRQ-QJHODXIJHGHFNWH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHUJHVFK|SIOLFKHQ%HVWLPPXQJGHV 0HQVFKVHLQVXQGLKUHUVQGKDIWHQ9HUIHKOXQJIUGLHGHU]HLWGLDJQRVWLVFKDN ]HQWXLHUWH%HJULIIGHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVWHKW (VIROJWHLQH$XVHLQDQ GHUVHW]XQJ PLW GHP 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ VHOEVW GDV -QJHO PLWWHOV GHU UHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ([NOXVLYSDUWLNHOXQWHUYHUVFKLHGHQHQ$VSHNWHQLQGHQ%OLFN QLPPWGLHDOOHVDPWDXFKHWZDVDPGDULQLPSOL]LHUWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVDNWGHXWOLFK PDFKHQ $P(QGHGHV.DSLWHOVVWHKWHLQHH[HPSODULVFKJHKDOWHQH(UNXQGXQJ GHU.RQVHTXHQ]HQGLHVLFKKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU%HXUWHLOXQJXQG*HVWDOWXQJJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKHU9HUKlOWQLVVH±5HFKW6WDDW8PJDQJPLW/HEHQXQG7RG:LUWVFKDIW ±DXVGHP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJODXEHQIU-QJHOHUJHEHQ
:LGHUVSUFKH PHQVFKOLFKHV$QHUNHQQXQJVVWUHEHQXQG J|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJ 3HUVRQVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ :HUQDFKGHUDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ5HOHYDQ]YRQ$QHUNHQQXQJVHUIDKUXQJHQIUDJW ILQGHWEHL(EHUKDUG-QJHOHLQHGHXWOLFKH$QWZRUW Ä(VLVWGHP0HQVFKHQZH VHQWOLFKDQHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQ6HLQ3HUVRQVHLQKlQJWGDYRQDE'HQQDOV3HUVRQ
-h1*(/ E -h1*(/ D -h1*(/L
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
HUKHLVFKWGHU0HQVFKGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVHLQHUVHOEVW³-QJHOSRVWXOLHUWKLHUHLQ H[LVWHQ]LHOOHV*UXQGEHGUIQLVGDVPLWGHPSHUVRQDOHQ&KDUDNWHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ 'DVHLQVHLQKHUJHKW6HOEVW%HVWlWLJXQJ]XILQGHQGDVEHWULIIWGHQ0HQVFKHQ GHPQDFKLPLQQHUVWHQ:HVHQZHVKDOEHUDXIHQWVSUHFKHQGHVR]LDOH%H]XJQDK PHQ]XWLHIVWDQJHZLHVHQLVWÄ3HUVRQVHLQ³VRZHL-QJHOPLWKLQ]XVDJHQÄLVW QDFK*HRUJ:LOKHOP)ULHGULFK+HJHOJHUDGH]XGHILQLHUWGXUFKGLH$XIIRUGHUXQJ DQDQGHUH3HUVRQHQYRQLKQHQDQHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQ³'DVVGLHVHUDSSHOODWLYH &KDUDNWHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ3HUVRQVHLQVDEHUK|FKVWNRQIOLNWWUlFKWLJLVWOlVVWVLFK VFKRQEHLPEHQDQQWHQ+HJHOQDFKOHVHQ(UVLHKWGHQXQUHJXOLHUWHQÄ7ULHEVLFK DOVIUHLHV6HOEVW>«@]HLJHQXQGIUGHQ$QGHUHQDOVVROFKHVGD>«@VHLQ³]X ZROOHQLQHLQHQÄ.DPSIGHV$QHUNHQQHQV³HLQPQGHQGHUÄDXI/HEHQXQG7RG³ JHKW$XFKIU-QJHOVWHFNWLPPHQVFKOLFKHQ6WUHEHQGDQDFKDQHUNDQQW]X ZHUGHQHLQGHVWUXNWLYHV3RWHQ]LDO(VULFKWHWVLFKJHJHQGLH$OWHULWlWVEH]LHKXQ JHQDXIGLHGDVEHVDJWH%HJHKUHQXPVHLQHU(UIOOXQJZLOOHQHLJHQWOLFKDQJH ZLHVHQLVWÄ*HUDGHGLHVHVHLQH0HQVFKOLFKNHLWNRQVWLWXLHUHQGHQ9HUKlOWQLVVH³ VRKHLWHVGHPJHPlEHL-QJHO GURKWGDV,FK>«@]X]HUVW|UHQZHQQHVVLFKVHOEVW$QHUNHQQXQJYHUVFKDIIHQZLOO(VEH]LHKW VLFKGDQQQlPOLFKLQDOOHPZDVHVWXWDXIVLFKVHOEVW]XUFNXQGZLUGUFNVLFKWVORVJHJHQ EHUGHP$QGHUHQDXIGHQHVVLFKGRFKJHUDGHEH]LHKW
6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJQHQQW-QJHOGLHVHVYRQLKPIUDVR]LDOEHIXQGHQH6WUH EHQ GDV DXV GHP PHQVFKOLFKHQ *UXQGEHGUIQLV QDFK VR]LDOHU $QHUNHQQXQJ HUZlFKVW'DVVGHU0HQVFKDEHUHLJHQWOLFKHLQGXUFKXQGGXUFKUHODWLRQDOYHU IDVVWHV:HVHQLVWVWHKWGDEHLDOVQRUPDWLYH$QQDKPHLP+LQWHUJUXQG*HQDX GDVQlPOLFKPDFKWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQGHU3HUVRQEHJULIIQDPKDIW'LHVHUZLUG QDFKVHLQHUKlXILJHUNOlUWHQhEHU]HXJXQJDXVVFKOLHOLFKÄDOV5HODWLRQVEHJULII³ RGHUZLHHUHLQHP'LNWXP/XWKHUVIROJHQGIRUPXOLHUWÄLQSUDHGLFDPHQWRUHOD WLRQLV³UHFKWHUIDVVW0LWGLHVHU6LFKWYHUELQGHWVLFKQHEHQGHP$EZHLVGHVYRQ %RHWKLXVEHJUQGHWHQVXEVWDQ]PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ3HUVRQDOLWlWVNRQ]HSWVHLQQHX ]HLWNULWLVFKHU,PSHWXV Ä'DVDOVVROLWDULXPEHJULIIHQH,QGLYLGXXP³KHLWHVGDQQ HWZDÄLVW>«@HLQPHQVFKOLFKHU7RUVR³ZlKUHQGÄ>H@LQDXIVLFKVHOEVWUHGX -h1*(/ DI9JODXFKGLH]7IDVWZRUWJOHLFKHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJHQLQ'(56H I JI F -h1*(/H YJO]X-QJHOV%H]XJDXI+HJHOV3HUVRQEHJULIIDXFK '(56F (LQHWLHIJHKHQGHUH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJJLEWHVEHLLKPDOOHUGLQJVQLFKW +(*(/ I9JO]XGLHVHP0RWLYXQWHQ % -h1*(/F I 9JO]X-QJHOVUHODWLRQDOHP3HUVRQEHJULIIDXFK '$/)(57+-h1*(/ ± -h1*(/JI -QJHO]LWLHUWGDVEHL/XWKHUYHUVFKLHGHQWOLFKYHUZHQGHWH'LNWXP XDLQGHU9RUOHVXQJ ]XP3VDOPYRQ>/87+(5 DI@ LP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU(QWIDOWXQJVHLQHV UHODWLRQDOHQ3HUVRQEHJULIIVXDDQIROJHQGHQ6WHOOHQ -h1*(/L F G K -h1*(/G
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
]LHUWHU0HQVFK>«@QLFKWVDQGHUHV>ZlUH@DOV±HLQH/HLFKH³ *HJHQVROFKHQ 5HGXNWLRQLVPXV GHQ HU SDXVFKDOHUZHLVH DXINOlUHULVFKHQ E]Z LGHDOLVWLVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ]XVFKUHLEWEULQJW-QJHOGLHÄFKULVWOLFKH>@(LQVLFKWLQGLHIXQGD PHQWDOH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ3HUVRQHLQHUVHLWVXQG,QGLYLGXXP6XEMHNWRGHU,FK DQGHUHUVHLWV³LQ$QVFKODJ'HP]XIROJHNRPPHQGLHOHW]WHUHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQ DOV Ä)ROJHSKlQRPHQH>@³ GHUHUVWHUHQ ]X VWHKHQ 'HQ 3ULPDW DEHU VR ODXWHW MHGHQIDOOVGLHYRQ-QJHOQDPKDIWJHPDFKWH7KHVHFKULVWOLFKHU$QWKURSRORJLH KDWGDV3HUVRQVHLQLQQHZHQQHVXPGDV:HVHQGHV0HQVFKHQJHKWÄ(LQH3HU VRQVHLQ³KHLWIULKQNXU]JHVDJW ÄYRQ$QGHUHQKHUXQGDXI$QGHUHKLQH[LV WLHUHQ XQG LQ VROFKHU (NVLVWHQ] DE DOLLV XQG DG DOLRV EHMDKW XQG DQHUNDQQW VHLQ³'HPQDFKLVWGHU0HQVFKZDVHULVWXQGZLHHUVLFKVHOEVWYHUVWHKWQXU DXIJUXQGYRQXQGLQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW$OWHULWlWVYHUKlOWQLVVHQLQGHQHQHU OHEW GDVVLQGVHLQH%H]LHKXQJ]X*RWWXQG]XU:HOWE]Z]XDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQ *HVFK|SIOLFKNHLW 'LH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHU3HUVRQGXUFK*RWW 'DVVGDVÃYRQ$QGHUHQKHUµ6HLQXQGGDPLWHLQHIXQGDPHQWDOH3DVVLYLWlWIUGHQ 0HQVFKHQ SULPlU LVW PDFKW -QJHO ]XQlFKVW DQKDQG GHV*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVVHV GHXWOLFK'LHVHVQlPOLFKEHJUHLIWHUDXVGUFNOLFKDOVYRQ*RWWDXVJHKHQGH5HOD WLRQGLHIUGLH5HODWLRQDOLWlWPHQVFKOLFKHQ3HUVRQVHLQVLQVJHVDPWNRQVWLWXWLY LVW6REH]HLFKQHW-QJHOGHQ0HQVFKHQDOV ÄGDVMHQLJH:HVHQGDVDXIJUXQG HLQHVXQYHUZHFKVHOEDUHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHV*RWWHV]XLKPHLQ6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVLVWLQ HLQHP:HOWYHUKlOWQLVVWHKWXQGHLQ*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVKDW³(UVWGLHGXUFK*RWW HU|IIQHWHVFK|SIHULVFKH%H]LHKXQJPDFKWHVLKPDOVREHUKDXSWP|JOLFK]X HWZDVRGHUMHPDQGHP±VLFKVHOEVWHLQJHVFKORVVHQ±LP9HUKlOWQLV]XVWHKHQXQG LQV9HUKlOWQLV]XWUHWHQ'LHVRDN]HQWXLHUWH*HVFK|SIOLFKNHLWEHVWLPPW-QJHO DOV*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWQlKHU0LWGLHVHP$XVGUXFNKDWHUDOVÄHOHPHQWDUVWHQ 7DWEHVWDQG³LP%OLFNGDVVGHUSHUVRQDOYHUIDVVWH0HQVFK ZLHHUDQ0DUWLQ %XEHUHULQQHUQGIRUPXOLHUWLPPHUVFKRQÄDOV,FKHLQHV³±QlPOLFKSULPlUGHV J|WWOLFKHQ±Ä'XGDLVW³'LH)ROJHUXQJGDVVGHPQDFKÄVRHWZDVZLH6ROLSVLV PXVHLQHJRWWHVOlVWHUOLFKH7KHRULH³GDUVWHOOWHQWKOOWGHQQRUPDWLYHQ&KDUDNWHU GHU*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWVEHVWLPPXQJ$XILKUHP+LQWHUJUXQGEHGHXWHW3HUVRQ ]XVHLQIUGHQ0HQVFKHQÄQLFKWQXU$XV]HLFKQXQJVRQGHUQ]XJOHLFKDXFK$Q
-h1*(/L 9JODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ '$/)(57+-h1*(/ ±± $D2 $D2 -h1*(/L '$/)(57+-h1*(/ 9JO]X-QJHOV%HJULIIGHU*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWLQVJHVDPW DD2II -h1*(/H0DUWLQ%XEHUVLQ,FKXQG'X HQWIDOWHWHUGLDORJLVFKHU3HUVR QDOLVPXVKDWLQVJHVDPWVWDUNLQVEHVRQGHUHDXIGLHSURWHVWDQWLVFKH7KHRORJLHGHV-DKUKXQ GHUWJHZLUNW 9JOGD]X672&. I -h1*(/H
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VSUXFK³1LFKWQXUDOVRLVWHUÄGXUFKVHLQ3HUVRQVHLQGDV:HVHQGHU0|JOLFK NHLWHQ³DXVGHQHQVHOEVWEHVWLPPWZlKOHQ]XN|QQHQLKQÄLP8QWHUVFKLHG]X DOOHQDQGHUHQ*HVFK|SIHQDOV0HQVFKHQ³ DXV]HLFKQHW$XFKHQWKlOWVHLQH3HU VRQDOLWlWGLH9HUSIOLFKWXQJVLFKGDEHL*RWWJHPl]XYHUKDOWHQZDVDOOJHPHLQ JHVDJWGLH$EVDJHDQHLQHVHOEVWEH]RJHQHVLFKQLFKWDOVH[WHUQNRQVWLWXLHUWYHU VWHKHQGH/HEHQVZHLVHPHLQW'HUJRWWHEHQELOGOLFKH0HQVFK±GDVLVWIROJOLFKLQ -QJHOV'LNWLRQÄGHU*RWW>E]ZGHPJ|WWOLFKHQ=XVSUXFKXQG$QVSUXFKDQLKQ .7@HQWVSUHFKHQGH0HQVFK³$XIZHOFKH:HLVHGLHVH(QWVSUHFKXQJGXUFK *RWWHEHQVRHUP|JOLFKWZLHYHUIJWZLUGVXFKW-QJHOLQHLQHUÄDXIGDV3KlQR PHQGHUÃ$QUHGHµNRQ]HQWULHUWH>Q@:HLWHUIKUXQJ³GHULKUHUVHLWVGLDORJSKLORVR SKLVFKLQVSLULHUWHQ$QWKURSRORJLH.DUO%DUWKVGDU]XWXQ 'HU$XVGUXFN$QUHGHVROOGDEHLLP8QWHUVFKLHG]XU5HGHGLHÄGHQ5HGHQ GHQQXUDOV,FKJHJHQEHUHLQHPDQGHUHQSURILOLHUWRKQHGLHVHVLQ'XRGHU(V]X GLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ³HLQH$UWGHUVSUDFKOLFKHQ%H]LHKXQJVDXIQDKPHNHQQ]HLFKQHQ LQGHUYRPÄ*HJHQEHU>«@HLQH$QWZRUWHUZDUWHW³ZLUG'LHVH(UZDUWXQJ DEHUXQWHUVWHOOWGHPMHZHLOV$QJHUHGHWHQÄVHOEVWVSUHFKHQ]XN|QQHQXQGGDPLW HLQ,FK]XVHLQGDVGHUDQJHWUDJHQHQ%H]LHKXQJ]XHQWVSUHFKHQ³XQGLKU]X JOHLFKDXFK]XZLGHUVSUHFKHQYHUPDJ'LH$QUHGHLPSOL]LHUWDOVRGLH$QHUNHQ QXQJGHV$QGHUHQDOVYRPVSUHFKHQGHQ,FKGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHV'XGDVLQIROJHGHV VHQDOOHUHUVW]XPVHOEVWlQGLJHQ,FK6DJHQXQG]XP(LQJHKHQDXIGLHHU|IIQHWH %H]LHKXQJLQVWDQGJHVHW]WXQGEHIlKLJWZLUGÄ>,@QVHLQHPJHVFK|SIOLFKHQ$Q GHUVVHLQJHJHQEHUGHP6FK|SIHUYRQGLHVHPXQZLGHUUXIOLFKEHMDKW³±RGHUZLH -QJHOHEHQIDOOVVFKUHLEHQNDQQ ÄXQZLGHUUXIOLFKDQHUNDQQW³±ÄXQGGDGXUFK ]XU6HOEVWEHMDKXQJOHJLWLPLHUW³VROOGHU0HQVFKGHPQDFKQLFKWEHLVLFKVHOEVW YHUEOHLEHQ6WDWWGHVVHQLVWHUÄRKQH(QGHDXVVLFKKHUDXV]XJHKHQDXIJHUXIHQ³ 'LHVHU QRUPDWLYH $QVSUXFK HUJLEW VLFK DXV GHU H[WHUQHQ .RQVWLWXWLRQ VHLQHV SHUVRQDOYHUIDVVWHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGDVLKQÄQXUDXHUKDOEVHLQHUVHOEVW>«@]XVLFK VHOEVW³NRPPHQOlVVW$OWHUQDWLYH9HUVXFKHGDVMHHLJHQH,FKVDJHQ.|QQHQ ]XYHUZLUNOLFKHQZLGHUVSUHFKHQVRPLWDXIOHW]WOLFKVHOEVW]HUVW|UHULVFKH:HLVH
'$/)(57+-h1*(/ $D2 6RLP7LWHOGHUJUXQGOHJHQGHQDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ6WXGLH-QJHOVGLHVLFKDQHLQHU9HU JHJHQZlUWLJXQJGHU*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWVYRUVWHOOXQJYHUVXFKW -h1*(/H 672&. 'DVV.DUO%DUWKVWKHRORJLVFKHU%HJULIIGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ3HUVRQE]Z VHLQH:HVHQVEHVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQZLH6WRFNKHUYRUKHEWJURH1lKH]XPGLDORJLVFKHQ 3HUVRQDOLVPXVDXIZHLVWOlVVWVLFKEHVRQGHUVHLQGUFNOLFKQDFKOHVHQLQ %$57+ ± 'LHVHU$EVFKQLWWGHU6FK|SIXQJVOHKUHLVWLP*UXQGHHLQH$XVOHJXQJGHU7KHVH Ä,FKELQ LQGHP'XELVW³ DD2 '$/)(57+-h1*(/ $D2 -h1*(/ D -h1*(/L9JO'(56JI -h1*(/J -h1*(/F
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GHQVRLVWIHVW]XKDOWHQRQWRORJLVFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQXQWHUGHQHQHVVWHKW=X GLHVHQ%HGLQJXQJHQJHK|UWDXFKGDV:HOWE]ZGDV6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVGHVVHQ *HOLQJHQDEHUVHLQHUVHLWVYRPÄJHOLQJHQGHQ=XVDPPHQVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQPLW *RWW³DEKlQJW)UDQGHUH0HQVFKHQDQVSUHFKEDURGHU±ZLHPDQEHUVHW]HQ NDQQ±]XVR]LDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQIlKLJLVWGHU0HQVFKDOVRQXUZHLOHUVLFKDOV *HVFK|SIHLQHPH[WHUQHQ.RQVWLWXWLRQVDNW±GHUVFK|SIHULVFKHQEHUKDXSWHUVW LQV6HLQUXIHQGHQ$QUHGHGXUFK*RWW±YHUGDQNW'LHÄYRQ*RWWLPPHUVFKRQ NRQVWLWXLHUWH>@ 5HODWLRQ³ ]XP 0HQVFKHQ VR OlVVW VLFK PLW )RONDUW :LWWHNLQG VDJHQLVWIU-QJHOÄGLH(UP|JOLFKXQJYRQ5HODWLRQDOLWlWEHUKDXSW³ (UVW GDGXUFKGDVVHUVFKOLHOLFKDXFKGXUFKVHLQHVJOHLFKHQDXIVLFKVHOEVWDQJHVSUR FKHQZLUGE]ZGDVVPDQVLFKDXILKQEH]LHKWWULWWHUVFKOLHOLFKLQHLQ9HUKlOW QLV]XVLFKVHOEVWXQGLVWHU]X(LJHQDNWLYLWlWEHIlKLJW:LHGDV*RWWHVLVWDOVR DXFKGDV:HOWRGHU6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVGHV0HQVFKHQYRQHLQHUSULPlUHQ$V\P PHWULHJHSUlJWLQVRIHUQHV]XQlFKVWHLQ9HUKlOWQLVGHU$QGHUHQ]XPLULPSOL ]LHUW]XGHPLFKPLFKGDGXUFKPHLQHUVHLWVLQV9HUKlOWQLV]XVHW]HQLQGLH/DJH YHUVHW]WELQ'DV*RWWHVXQGGDV6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVJHUDWHQGDGXUFKEHL-QJHO SKlQRPHQDOLQHLQHJURH1lKH]XHLQDQGHUZLHQRFK]X]HLJHQVHLQZLUG 'LH+HUNXQIWGHV6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVVHVDXVGHP:HOWYHUKlOWQLV 'DVVDXFK:HOWXQG6HOEVWNHLQHVZHJVLQHLQHP9HUKlOWQLVGHU*OHLFKXUVSUQJ OLFKNHLW]XHLQDQGHUVWHKHQVRQGHUQHEHQIDOOVYRQHLQHUSULPlUHQ$V\PPHWULH JHSUlJWVLQGDUEHLWHW-QJHOLQHLQHUJHPHLQVDPPLW,QJROI'DOIHUWKYHUIDVVWHQ NULWLVFKHQ6LFKWXQJGHV6XEMHNWEHJULIIVKHUDXV'HUDXINOlUHULVFKHQLGHDOLVWL VFKHQXQGH[LVWHQ]LDOLVWLVFKHQ3RVLWLRQHQJOHLFKHUPDHQ]XJHVFKULHEHQHQ9RU RUGQXQJGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWYRUGDV:HOWYHUKlOWQLVZLUGGRUWDQKDQG HQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHU(LQVLFKWHQLQGLH*HQHVHGHV6XEMHNWVZLGHUVSUR FKHQÄ=XVLFKVWHKWGHU0HQVFKQXULP9HUKlOWQLVZHLOHU]XDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQ LP 9HUKlOWQLV VWHKW³ ODXWHW GDV )D]LW GLHVHU (UNXQGXQJHQ GHVVHQ ORJLVFKH $EIROJHDOVXQXPNHKUEDUDQJHVHKHQZLUG'HQQQLFKWQXUJHVFKLHKWGLH(QW ZLFNOXQJGHV6XEMHNWVLQVWHWHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWYRUILQGOLFKHQ8PZHOW JHJHEHQKHLWHQXQGLVWVFKRQYRQGDKHUNHLQHVZHJVDXIÄ$NWLRQHQHLQHVOHHUHQ ,FK³RGHUÄHLQVDPHQ6XEMHNWV³]XUFN]XIKUHQ9LHOPHKUZLUGGDV(UZDFKHQ GHVVLFK]XU8PZHOWGLIIHUHQWVHW]HQGHQ,FK%HZXVVWVHLQVVR-QJHO XQG'DO IHUWK LP $QVFKOXVVDQ7KHRULHQ0DUWLQ%XEHUVXQG*HRUJH+HUEHUW0HDGV DOOHUHUVWDXIJUXQGGHU,QWHUDNWLRQPLW$QGHUHQHUP|JOLFKW'HPQDFKVLQGHVGLH GHQ0HQVFKHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUH[SOL]LWDOV'XDQVSUHFKHQGHQÄ(LQVFKlW]XQ JHQ>«@GXUFKVHLQHVR]LDOH8PJHEXQJ³E]ZÄ6SLHJHOXQJHQLQVHLQHQ0LWPHQ
-h1*(/G :,77(.,1' 9JODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ '$/)(57+-h1*(/ ±± $D2 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VFKHQ³YHUPLWWHOVGHUHUHUVFKOLHOLFKLQHLQUHIOH[LYHV9HUKlOWQLV]XVLFKVHOEVW WULWW$XVGHQIUHPGHQ%HXUWHLOXQJHQHQWZLFNHOWVLFKVXN]HVVLYHHLQ6HOEVWELOG LQ'LIIHUHQ]]XGHPGHU(LQ]HOQHVLFKDOVYRQGHQ$QVSUFKHQ$QGHUHUXQWHU VFKLHGHQHV,FKJHZDKUZLUG/HW]WHUHVDEHUGDUDXIZLOOGHU$UJXPHQWDWLRQVJDQJ KLQDXVJHVFKLHKWLQ$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQGHQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQLQGHQHQGHUVLFK HUVW]XP6XEMHNWHQWZLFNHOQGH0HQVFKDOV3HUVRQYRQ$QIDQJDQVWHKW,PPHU VFKRQÄH[LVWLHUW>HU@LQHLQHP*HIOHFKWYRQ%H]LHKXQJHQGXUFKGLHHUEHLDQGH UHP6HLHQGHQHUVFKHLQWXQGGRUW>«@]XVLFKVHOEVWNRPPW³ZLH-QJHOVHLQH (LQVLFKWHQ]XUVR]LDOHQ*HQHVHGHV6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVVHVDQGHURUWV]XVDPPHQIDVVW 'LHVHVIUGHQ0HQVFKHQÄZHVHQWOLFK>H@³(UVFKHLQHQEHLRGHUÄYRUHLQHP DQGHUHQ³ HQWVSULFKW HEHQMHQHP %HZHUWHW RGHU *HVSLHJHOWZHUGHQ YRQ GHP JHUDGHJHKDQGHOWZXUGH-QJHOEULQJWHVDOV$QHUNHQQXQJVHUIDKUXQJDXIGHQ %HJULIIGHUGHU(LQ]HOQHXPVHLQHUVHOEVWZLOOHQEHGDUI'DVVGHUSHUVRQDOYHU IDVVWH0HQVFKVWHWVÄ0HQVFKLQ%H]LHKXQJ]X«³LVWZLUGKLHUGXUFKGLH$XVVD JHNRQNUHWLVLHUWHUVHLGDEHLLPPHUDXFKÄ0HQVFKYRU«³XQGLQVRIHUQÄDXI $QHUNHQQXQJDQJHZLHVHQ³'LHGDUDQDQNQSIHQGH)RUPXOLHUXQJÄ>D@QHUNDQQW ZHUGH³PDQÄLPPHUYRUHLQHP)RUXP³PDFKWYROOHQGVGHXWOLFKGDVVHV-Q JHOKLHUXPHLQH5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHULQVEHVRQGHUHGXUFK*HUKDUG(EHOLQJV/X WKHUVWXGLHQJHSUlJWHQ5HGHYRQGHQÄFRUDP5HODWLRQHQ³JHKW'DV6HOEVWELOG GHV0HQVFKHQKlQJWDOVRQDFK-QJHOIXQGDPHQWDOGDYRQDEZLHHUVLFKGXUFK $QGHUHEHXUWHLOWXQGDQJHVHKHQHUIlKUW:HOWXQG*RWWELOGHQGLHEHLGHQ)RUHQ YRUGHQHQGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ]XU9HUKDQGOXQJVWHKW'DEHLJHKWHV VWHWVXPQLFKWVZHQLJHUDOVXPÄGDVZDKUH6HLQGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ3HUVRQ³ XP GLH%HDQWZRUWXQJGHU)UDJHQDFKGHUHQ:HVHQRGHU,GHQWLWlW'LHVPDFKWDEHU NOlUXQJVEHGUIWLJZRULQGHQQGHU8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQ*RWWHVXQG:HOWYHU KlOWQLVEHVWHKWGLHQDFKGHPELVODQJ*HVDJWHQ]LHPOLFKVWUXNWXUlTXLYDOHQWHU VFKHLQHQ =XU'LIIHUHQ]YRQ:HOWXQG*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLV $XIGLHEHVDJWH)UDJHJLEW-QJHOLP5DKPHQVHLQHUNULWLVFKHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW ]XQJPLWGHP8QWHUQHKPHQHLQHUQDWUOLFKHQ7KHRORJLHHLQHUHFKWIHUWLJXQJV
$D2 -h1*(/F 9JOGLHVH6WHOOHDXFKIUGLHIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XP$QHU NHQQXQJVWKHPD (EG (EG -h1*(/ DI 9JOHWZD(%(/,1* ± -h1*(/F 9JOQHEHQGHPLP)ROJHQGHQ]LWLHUWHQ$XIVDW]GHUHLQH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW.DUO 5DKQHUV7KHVHVYRP7KHVHYRPVRJÄDQRQ\PHQ&KULVWHQWXP³LVWYRUDOOHPGLH$XVHLQDQGHU VHW]XQJ-QJHOVPLW:ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJV3URMHNWHLQHU1DWUOLFKHQ7KHRORJLHLQ -h1*(/ E9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQGHQKHUYRUUDJHQGHQ$XIVDW]YRQ+HUPDQQ)LVFKHUGHUQDFK
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
WKHRORJLVFKlXHUVWDXIVFKOXVVUHLFKH$QWZRUW'RUWKHLWHVGLH$XVNXQIWGDVV ÄGHU0HQVFKDOVHLQYRQ*RWW$QJHVSURFKHQHU$QHUNDQQWHUXQGDXVVLFK+H UDXVJHUXIHQHULVWZDVHULVW³ODVVHVLFKDXFKÄRKQH*RWW]XQHQQHQ>«@YHU VWlQGOLFK³PDFKHQ6LHEHVDJWGDQQVFKOLFKWXQGHLQIDFKÄGDGHU0HQVFKDOV 0HQVFKDXI$QUHGHXQG$QHUNHQQXQJDQJHZLHVHQLVWXQGGDHURKQH(QGHDXV VLFKKHUDXV]XJHKHQDXIJHUXIHQLVW³:DVEHLPhEHUVHW]XQJVYRUJDQJMHGRFK DXIGHU6WUHFNHEOHLEWLVWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQÄ>G@DVVSH]LILVFKH3OXVDXIGDVHV GHP*ODXEHQJHUDGHDQNRPPW³QlPOLFKGHUHLQGHXWLJKHLOYROOH6LQQGHV*H VDJWHQ6RZLUGGLH)HVWVWHOOXQJGDVVDQHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQXQGGHVKDOEDXVVLFK KHUDXV]XJHKHQIUGHQ0HQVFKHQXQDEGLQJEDULVWÄYRQHLQHP6DW]GHV(YDQJH OLXPV]XHLQHP6DW]GHV*HVHW]HVYRQHLQHPHLQGHXWLJZRKOWXHQGHQ6DW]]X HLQHPDPELYDOHQWHQ6DW]³ 'LHVH=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWKlQJWJDQ]RIIHQVLFKWOLFKPLWGHP:HJIDOOGHVHLQHQ VLFKDOVOLHEHYROOHUVFKORVVHQHQ*HJHQEHUV]XVDPPHQ]XGHPQXQDOOHXQG MHGHUZHUGHQN|QQHQ9RQZHVVHQDQHUNHQQHQGHQ=XVFKUHLEXQJHQVLFKGHU(LQ ]HOQHOHLWHQOlVVWZRXQGZLHHU]XVLFKVHOEVWJHODQJWZLUGVRXQNODU=XGHP JLOW Ä$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKPHQVFKOLFKH3HUVRQHQLVW>«@UHYR]LHUEDU³GDVVVLH ]XWHLOZLUGLVWQLHDXVJHPDFKWVRQGHUQDXV6LFKWGHUEHWURIIHQHQ3HUVRQHQHLQH NRQWLQJHQWH $QJHOHJHQKHLW 'HPJHPl ODXWHW -QJHOV 'LDJQRVH GDVV GHU 0HQVFKDQGHUVDOVYRU*RWWEHLGHPVWDWWZLOONUOLFKHQ:HFKVHOIlOOHQYHUOlVVOL FKH(LQGHXWLJNHLWYRUKHUUVFKWÄLP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU:HOWGHU$PELYDOHQ] DXVJHVHW]WLVWPHQVFKOLFKRGHUXQPHQVFKOLFK]XVHLQPLWKLQGLH:DKUKHLWVHL QHV6HLQV]X ILQGHQRGHU]XYHUIHKOHQ³'DVVHUDEHUGHQQRFKQLFKWDQGHUV NDQQDOVGLH$QHUNHQQXQJXQWHUVHLQHVJOHLFKHQ]XVXFKHQPDFKWLKQLQ-QJHOV $XJHQWUDGLWLRQHOOJHVDJW]XP6NODYHQGHVXQDXIK|UOLFKIRUGHUQGHQ*HVHW]HV $OOHLQGLHVHPDXVJHVHW]WYHUIlOOWGHU0HQVFKGHP]ZDQJKDIWHQ'UDQJVLFK ÄVHOEHUGHILQLWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJ]XYHUVFKDIIHQ³±HLQH+DQGOXQJVZHLVHGLH -QJHOPLWGHP$XVGUXFN6QGHLGHQWLIL]LHUWXQGGLHVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVZLHQXQ ]X]HLJHQLVWLPQHX]HLWOLFKHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVLGHDO]XDXHURUGHQWOLFKHU NXOWXUHOOHU:LUNPDFKWJHIXQGHQKDW DXVIKUOLFKHU ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ YRQ -QJHOV LP )ROJHQGHQ ]LWLHUWHQ $XIVlW]HQ ]XP 6FKOXVV NRPPWÄGDEHLDOOHU'LIIHUHQ]LPPHWKRGLVFKHQ3UR]HGLHUHQGDVDFKOLFKH,QWHUHVVH-QJHOV YRQGHP%UXQQHUV³GHUVHLQHU]HLW.DUO%DUWKVODXWVWDUNHVÃ1HLQµKDWHLQVWHFNHQPVVHQÄVR ZHLWQLFKWHQWIHUQWLVW³ ),6&+(5 YJODXFKDD2 II -h1*(/J 9JOHEG]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ*RWW XQG:HOWEHWUHIIHQG (EG (EG (EG -h1*(/L -h1*(/F $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJXQG6QGH Ä'LHKHXWHVRXQHLQJHVFKUlQNWSRVLWLYYHUZHQGHWH.DWHJRULHGHU6HOEVWYHUZLUN OLFKXQJ³VRODXWHW-QJHOVPRGHUQLWlWVNULWLVFKH=HQWUDOWKHVHÄJOHLFKWQDFKELEOL VFKHP9HUVWlQGQLVHKHUGHP,QEHJULIIYRQ6QGH³)UHLQHQ'HQNHUGHP ÄGRJPDWLVFKH7KHRORJLHLP*UXQGHQLFKWVDQGHUHVLVWDOV>HLQH@NRQVHTXHQWH ([HJHVH³GLHÄGHQ:DKUKHLWVDQVSUXFKGHUELEOLVFKHQ7H[WHLP+RUL]RQWGHV :DKUKHLWVEHZXVVWVHLQVGHU*HJHQZDUW³]XYHUDQWZRUWHQKDW YHUELHWHWVLFKVR JHVHKHQHLQDIILUPDWLYHU*HEUDXFKGHVEHVDJWHQ$XVGUXFNVJHUDGHZHJVÄ:HLO GHU0HQVFKQLHPDOVGDV(UJHEQLVVHLQHV:LUNHQVVHLQNDQQ³VRIDVVW-QJHO VHLQHLQGHQ6FKULIWHQGHV$OWHQXQG1HXHQ7HVWDPHQWVEHJUQGHWH6LFKW]X VDPPHQNRPPWÄGLH>«@.DWHJRULHGHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJQXUSHUQHIDVLQ %HWUDFKW³0LWLKUVLHKWHUGHPQDFKGHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ$QVSUXFKYHUEXQGHQ DXVVFKOLHOLFK*HVFK|SIHLJHQHU7lWLJNHLW]XVHLQZRGXUFKHEHQVRZLGHUUHFKW OLFKZLHIROJHQVFKZHULQGHQJHQXLQJ|WWOLFKHQ=XVWlQGLJNHLWVEHUHLFKHLQJHJULI IHQZLUGÄ'HQQGHU0HQVFK³VROLHVWHV-QJHOLPGXUFK*HUKDUGYRQ5DGDXV JHOHJWHQ$OWHQ7HVWDPHQWÄNDQQQXULQGHULKPYRQ-DKZHJHZlKUWHQ*HPHLQ VFKDIWOHEHQ HUNDQQQXUDOVYRQ*RWW$QHUNDQQWHUOHEHQ³XQGVROOGDUDXIKLQ GLHVHP ÄLKP >«@ LPPHU ]XYRUNRPPHQGHQ >«@ $QHUNDQQWVHLQ GXUFK *RWW³ PLWWHOV JHPHLQVFKDIWVJHPlHP 9HUKDOWHQ HQWVSUHFKHQ :HU VLFK KLQJHJHQ ÄVHOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKHQZLOOGHUZLUGVHLQ/HEHQYHUZLUNHQ³PDKQWGHUPDUNLQL VFKH-HVXVGLH6HLQHQDXVGHU6LFKWGHVNRQVHTXHQWHQ([HJHWHQ Ä:HUVLFKMH GRFKKLQJLEWGHU ZLUGVHLQ /HEHQUHWWHQ³'HQQVRIJW-QJHODQGHUQRUWV KLQ]XÄ>V@LFKVHOEVW]XYHUZLUNOLFKHQKHLW VLFK$QHUNHQQXQJYHUVFKDIIHQ³RGHU ZLHÄ3DXOXV>GDV@QHQQW>«@ VHLQHHLJHQH*HUHFKWLJNHLWDXIULFKWHQZROOHQ³ 'HQSDXOLQLVFKHQ$EZHLVHLQHVZHUNWlWLJJHQHULHUWHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ*HUHFKW VHLQVYRU*RWWJUHLIWHULQGHU/HVDUW0DUWLQ/XWKHUVDXIGHUGDPLWJHJHQGLH 7KHVHGHV$ULVWRWHOHVDQJLQJPDQN|QQHHEHQVRÄGXUFKJHUHFKWHV+DQGHOQJH UHFKW³ZHUGHQZLHGXUFKÄ&LWKHUVSLHOHQHLQ&LWKHUVSLHOHU³:lKUHQG/XWKHU KLHUGLHVFKRODVWLVFKH7KHRORJLHWUDGLWLRQYRU$XJHQKDWWHZHLWHW-QJHOGHVVHQ ELEOLVFKLQVSLULHUWH6LFKW]XHLQHU)XQGDPHQWDONULWLNGHU1HX]HLWDXV:DVÄYRQ $ULVWRWHOHVNODVVLVFKIRUPXOLHUWZXUGH³ LVWQlPOLFKVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVHUVWLP
$D29JO]XU1HX]HLWNULWLN-QJHOVXQGLKUHU,QVSLUDWLRQXDGXUFK0DUWLQ+HL GHJJHU +(5%67II 6&+8/= II -h1*(/D -h1*(/M -h1*(/ D -h1*(/I -h1*(/F $ULVWRWHOHV DE-QJHOUHNXUULHUWKlXILJDXI/XWKHUVHWZDLQGHU'LVSXWDWLRQ JHJHQGLHVFKRODVWLVFKH7KHRORJLHYRQ /87+(5 HUKREHQH$ULVWRWHOHVNULWLN XDXQGLQNOXVLYHGHU$QJDEHZHLWHUHU4XHOOHQLQ '$/)(57+-h1*(/ -h1*(/ D± FI '(56I±
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
9HUODXIHGLHVHU(SRFKHÄ]XIDVWXQHLQJHVFKUlQNWHU*HOWXQJJHODQJW³6RNDQQ -QJHOGLHDQJHIKUWHQ%HLVSLHOHKDEHQHVDQJHGHXWHWHEHQ]LHPOLFKXQXPZXQ GHQELEOLVFKHE]ZUHIRUPDWRULVFKH(LQVLFKWHQDOVDQGLHHLJHQH*HJHQZDUWJH ULFKWHWHQRUPDWLYH2IIHUWHQOHVHQ$XILKUHP+LQWHUJUXQGDEHUZLUGÄGDVPLWXQ WHUYHUVFKZLHJHQHLQGHU5HJHODEHUGHXWOLFKDXVJHVSURFKHQHQHX]HLWOLFKH,GHDO GHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ0HQVFKHQ³IU-QJHOQRWZHQGLJ]XP*HJHQVWDQGGHU.ULWLN Ä+HUUVHLQHUVHOEVW]XZHUGHQXQG]ZDUGXUFKVHLQHHLJHQH7DW³ 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDOVQHX]HLWOLFKHV,GHDO -QJHOVWDXWRORJLVFKDQPXWHQGH5HGHYRPQHX]HLWOLFKHQ,GHDOGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ 0HQVFKHQVROOXQWHUVWUHLFKHQGDVVHVKLHUXPHLQHHUVWQRFK]XUHDOLVLHUHQGH :HVHQVEHVWLPPXQJJHKW:LH$QVSUXFKXQG:LUNOLFKNHLWN|QQHQGHPHQWVSUH FKHQGÄ0HQVFKVHLQXQG0HQVFKOLFKNHLW>«@DEJUQGLJDXVHLQDQGHUNODIIHQ³ ZDVVWHWVHLQH)UDJHGHV]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGHQ+XPDQLWlWVEHJULIIVLVW'HVVHQVSH ]LILVFKQHX]HLWOLFKH6LJQDWXUNRPPWIU-QJHOJHUDGHLQGHU9HUDEVFKLHGXQJ HLQGHXWLJHUDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ:HVHQVEHVWLPPXQJHQ]XP$XVGUXFN:DVGHU 0HQVFKLVWOlVVWVLFKGHPQDFKHEHQVRZHQLJPHKUDEVFKOLHHQGVDJHQZLHGLH $OWHQHLQHOHW]WJOWLJH'HILQLWLRQ*RWWHVDQ]XJHEHQZXVVWHQ(LQLJNHLWEHVWHKW ZLH-QJHOPLW9HUZHLVDXIGLHÄPHKURGHUZHQLJHUGLVSDUDWH>@3OXUDOLWlW³KX PDQZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHU(UNHQQWQLVVHIHVWVWHOOWDOOHQIDOOVLQGHU7KHVHHLQHUÄUD GLNDOH>Q@ )UDJOLFKNHLW GHV 0HQVFKVHLQV³ DQ GHU DOOH DXIV *DQ]H JHKHQGHQ $QWZRUWHQVRIRUW]HUVFKHOOHQ'HP$EVFKLHGYRPREMHNWLYIHVWVWHOOEDUHQ:HVHQ HQWVSULFKW]XGHPHLQHH[WUHPH$XIZHUWXQJGHUVXEMHNWLYHQ7DWGXUFKGLHGHU 0HQVFK ÄKDQGHOQ ZLUNHQG DUEHLWHQG >«@ VRZRKO LP |NRQRPLVFKHQ ZLH LP PRUDOLVFKHQ6LQQ+HUUVHLQHUVHOEVW³ZLUG'DVVVLFKZDVGLHVHULVWQLFKWPHKU GHILQLHUHQOlVVWVFKOlJWVLFKGHPQDFKLQHLQHUhEHUEHWRQXQJVHLQHUVFKLHUJUHQ ]HQORVHQ (LJHQDNWLYLWlW QLHGHU 'DULQ ZXU]HOW LQ -QJHOV $XJHQ GLH ]HQWUDOH QHX]HLWOLFKH,GHDOYRUVWHOOXQJÄGDGHU0HQVFKVLFKLQVHLQHP:LUNHQ±ZLH PDQKHXWH]XVDJHQSIOHJW±VHOEHUYHUZLUNOLFKW³ZRPLWGHU$QVSUXFKHLQKHU
-h1*(/F $D2 $D2 9JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJGLHVHV$VSHNWV -h1*(/H ± F ± -h1*(/F-QJHOUHNXUULHUWKLHULQVEHVRQGHUHDXIGLHPLWGHQDQWKURSRORJL VFKHQ=HQWUDOEHJULIIHQGHUÄ:HOWRIIHQKHLW³EHL0D[6FKHOHUXQGGHUÄH[]HQWULVFKHQ3RVLWLRQD OLWlW³EHL+HOPXWK3OHVVQHU±FXPJUDQRVDOLV±DXVJHVSURFKHQHQ%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ DOVHLQHVQLFKWLQVLFKUXKHQGHQVRQGHUQVLFKVHOEVWVWlQGLJDXI$QGHUHXQG$QGHUHVKLQEHU VFKUHLWHQGHQ:HVHQV9JO]XEHLGHQ$XWRUHQEHUEOLFNVPlLJGLH'DUVWHOOXQJLQ 3$11(1 %(5* ± -h1*(/F
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JHKWÄQLFKWQXU]XP0DDOOHU'LQJH>«@VRQGHUQ>«@JHUDGH]X]XUHQWVFKHL GHQGHQ,QVWDQ]DOOHU'LQJHJHZRUGHQ³]XVHLQ 'LHVHUGHPQHX]HLWOLFKHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVVWUHEHQLQQHZRKQHQGH$Q VSUXFKKDW)ROJHQIUGLH%H]LHKXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ]XVLFKVHOEVWXQG]XU:HOW GLH-QJHOXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKEHXUWHLOW*HJHQEHUGHUQDWUOLFKHQ:HOWHQWZLFNHOW VLFKHLQGXUFKWHFKQLVFKH)RUWVFKULWWHVWlQGLJDQZDFKVHQGHV+HUUVFKDIWVYHUKlOW QLVKHUDXVGDVGLHVHGXUFK]XQHKPHQGH.XOWLYLHUXQJLPPHUPHKU]XP3URGXNW PHQVFKOLFKHU7lWLJNHLWZHUGHQOlVVW'DULQHQWGHFNW-QJHOHLQHSULQ]LSLHOOOHJL WLPH.RQVHTXHQ]DXVGHPJ|WWOLFKHQ$XIWUDJ]XPGRPLQLXPWHUUDH *HQ GHVVHQ3HUYHUVLRQ]XPLPSHULXPWHUUDHPDQZLHGHUXPDXFKQXUGXUFK.XOWXU OHLVWXQJHQ+HUU]XZHUGHQYHUPDJ5LJRURVHUDEHUEHZHUWHWHURKQHGDIUZHL WHUJHKHQGH*UQGHDQ]XJHEHQGLH)ROJHQIUGDV9HUKlOWQLVGHV0HQVFKHQ]X VLFKVHOEVW'DVVGLHVHUVLFKDXFKKLHUÄJDQ]XQGJDUQDFKGHP0RGHOOVHLQHV :HOWYHUKlOWQLVVHV>YHUVWHKW@ QlPOLFKDOVHLQGXUFKVHLQH7DWEHUVLFKVHOEVW HQWVFKHLGHQGHV6XEMHNW³VWHOOWGHPQDFKHLQHUHLQH)HKOHQWZLFNOXQJGDU6LH IKUWLQGLH$SRULHHLQHVGLHHLJHQHQ%HGLQJXQJHQQHJLHUHQGHQZHLOVLFKVHOEVW DQVWHOOHGHV$QGHUHQ]XP*UXQGGHVHLJHQHQ'DVHLQVHUKHEHQGHQ/HEHQVYROO ]XJV*HQDXGLHVHÄ7HQGHQ]GHV0HQVFKHQ]XU6HOEVWEHJUQGXQJ³YHUVWHKW-Q JHO ]XIROJH Ä>G@HUFKULVWOLFKH *ODXEH >«@DOV 6QGH³ XQG VRPLW LP :LGHU VSUXFKJHJHQGDVODQGOlXILJH6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVGHU1HX]HLWDOV9HUIHKOXQJGHU 0HQVFKOLFKNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDOV6QGH 'LH6LWXDWLRQGHV6QGHUVGDVZXUGHEHUHLWVDQJHVSURFKHQLVWQDFK-QJHOYRQ HLQHU WLHIJUHLIHQGHQ $PELYDOHQ] JHNHQQ]HLFKQHW LQ GHU LKP VHLQH SHUVRQDOH $QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXI$QHUNHQQXQJ]XHLQHU*HVHW]HVDQJHOHJHQKHLWZLUG)UGHQ JHUDGHVNL]]LHUWHQQHX]HLWOLFKHQ7DWPHQVFKHQNOLQJWGDVZLHIROJW Ä'XUFK7DWHQ EHZLUNWHUVHLQH$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK8QWDWHQYHUZLUNWHUVLH RSXVIDFLWSHUVR QDP³'LHVLVWGHPQDFKGLHXQWHUGHP*HVHW]E]ZYRUGHU:HOWJHOWHQGH/R JLNGDVVÄGLHPHQVFKOLFKH3HUVRQ]XU6XPPHLKUHU7DWHQ³ZLUGRKQHGDGXUFK DEHUMHPDOV]XVLFKVHOEVW]XJHODQJHQ-HGHJHVHW]HVZLGULJH+DQGOXQJQlPOLFK
$D2 9JO]XEHLGHQLP)ROJHQGHQGDUJHVWHOOWHQ$VSHNWHQ -h1*(/FII9JO]XU VSUDFKWKHRUHWLVFKHQ9DULDQWHGLHVHUNULWLVFKHQ'LDJQRVH -h1*(/H± -h1*(/F -h1*(/H 9JO]X-QJHOV6QGHQEHJULIIJUXQGOHJHQG '(56 II :,77(.,1'EHV II)RONDUW:LWWHNLQGGHU-QJHOVQGHQWKHRORJLVFK]ZLVFKHQ.DUO %DUWKXQG+HLQULFK9RJHOYHURUWHWVLHKWLQGHUÄPHKURGHUZHQLJHUPRUDOLVFKH>Q@:HUWXQJGHU PRGHUQHQ)UHLKHLWVEHDQVSUXFKXQJDOV6QGH³GXUFK-QJHOÄ>+HLQULFK@9RJHOVDQWLPRGHUQH %HVWLPPXQJGHU6QGHDOV$XWRQRPLHEHDQVSUXFKXQJ 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ6HOEVWEHJUQ GXQJ6HOEVWEHVLW] GHV0HQVFKHQDXIJHQRPPHQ³ DD2 -h1*(/ D $D2
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
HQWIHUQWVLHZHLWHUYRQGLHVHP=LHO=XJOHLFKMHGRFKNHQQWGHU0HQVFKDQJH VLFKWVGHVQRUPDWLYHQ$QVSUXFKVGHUXQHQWULQQEDUDQLKQHUJHKWNHLQH$OWHUQD WLYHXPVHLQHUVHOEVWJHZLVV]XZHUGHQÄ'DHUDOOGDVPXZDVHUQLFKWZLOO ZHLOHUZLOOZDVHUNHLQHVZHJVZROOHQPXXQGDXINHLQHQ)DOOZROOHQVROOWH± GDVPDFKW³QDFK-QJHOÄVHLQHQ6HOEVWZLGHUVSUXFKDXV³,QLKQYHUIlOOWGHU 0HQVFKDOV6QGHUIROJWHUGRFKGHU,OOXVLRQGXUFKWlWLJH0KHQVFKOLHOLFK JXWXQGDQHUNHQQHQVZHUWZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQ6LHHQWVSULFKW-QJHO]XIROJHGHU IUGDVPRGHUQH6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVVWUHEHQJUXQGOHJHQGHQ1RUPÄ0HQVFK VHLQKHLW7lWHUVHLQ³GDVGDPLW]XUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ6SLHODUWHLQHUDP*HVHW] RULHQWLHUWHQ/HEHQVZHLVHZLUG9RP6QGHQEHJULIIKHUGHUUHFKWYHUVWDQGHQQLH QXUHLQDNWLYHV(UJHKHQVRQGHUQLPPHUDXFKHLQXQHQWULQQEDUHV9HUKlQJQLV EH]HLFKQHWQLPPWHUGLHVH7DWIL[LHUXQJ]XJOHLFKNULWLVFKLQGHQ%OLFN'LHHEHQ ZHLOVLHLQGLYLGXHOOH=XUHFKQXQJVIlKLJNHLWDXVVFKOLHWLQGHU1HX]HLWZHLWKLQ XQJHOLHEWH.DWHJRULHGHU(UEVQGHZLUGYRQ-QJHOGHPJHPlIUXQYHU]LFKWEDU HUNOlUW6LH]LHOWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQGDUDXIÄ>G@LH8QZDKUKHLWGHU6QGH³DOVHLQHQ Ä9HUEOHQGXQJV]XVDPPHQKDQJ³]XFKDUDNWHULVLHUHQÄGHUMHGHQHLQ]HOQHQ0HQ VFKHQ>«@LPPHUVFKRQHUZDUWHW³³XQGLKQÄLQ=ZlQJHKLQHLQJHERUHQ³ VHLQ OlVVW 8P7DWXQG9HUKlQJQLVFKDUDNWHUGHU6QGHJOHLFKHUPDHQ]XEHWRQHQVXFKW -QJHOVLHEHUGDV3KlQRPHQGHU/HEHQVOJH]XYHUGHXWOLFKHQ'DPLWLVWHLQ LGHRORJLVFKHV.RQVWUXNWJHPHLQWGDVGLHMHZHLOV%HWURIIHQHQHLQHULKUJDQ]HV 'DVHLQEHWUHIIHQGHQ6HOEVWWlXVFKXQJDXIVLW]HQOlVVWXQGGDVVLHXQZLVVHQGHU :HLVHVWlQGLJDNWLYSHUSHWXLHUHQ Ä6ROFKH/HEHQVOJHQKDEHQ³ZLH-QJHO]X VDJHQZHLÄLQGLYLGXHOOHXQGNROOHNWLYHSURIDQHXQGUHOLJL|VHSROLWLVFKHXQG |NRQRPLVFKH*HVWDOW³ 'RFKLVWÄ>G@LHHLJHQWOLFKH/HEHQVOJH>«@GHU8QJODX EH³ 'DUXQWHU YHUVWHKW -QJHO HLQH GHQ 0HQVFKHQ JDQ]KHLWOLFK EHWUHIIHQGH +DOWXQJGHV0LVVWUDXHQVJHJHQEHU*RWWGHUVHLQHUVHLWVDOV,QEHJULIIDOOHV*XWHQ HLQJHIKUWZLUG'DVVQGLJH:LH*RWWVHLQ:ROOHQELOGHWGLHUDGLNDOH*HJHQ EHZHJXQJ]XPJOlXELJHQ6LFK9HUVWHKHQRGHU6LFK(PSIDQJHQDXV*RWWDOV MHQHP$QGHUHQGHUGHU3HUVRQHLJHQWOLFKNRQVWLWXWLY]X*UXQGHOLHJWÄ6RZLH GHU*ODXEHGHQ0HQVFKHQLPEHVWHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHVHN]HQWULVFKPDFKWVR PDFKWGHU8QJODXEHGHQ0HQVFKHQLPVFKOLPPVWHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHVVHOEVWEH ]RJHQ³ IDVVW -QJHO GLHVHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG ]XVDPPHQ 'LH 6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLW NRPPWGDEHLQlPOLFKDOV$EZHLVGHVÄ=XVDPPHQVHLQ>V@PLW*RWW³]XVWHKHQDQ GHVVHQ6WHOOHGLHIlOVFKOLFKHUZHLVHIUGDVÄÃK|FKVWH>@*XWµ³XQGÄGLHJ|WWOLFKH
$D2 $D2 $D2 9JOGD]XDD2I $D2 $D29JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XP8QJODXEHQ DD2± $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
([LVWHQ]GHVJ|WWOLFKHQ:HVHQV³JHKDOWHQHÄHLQVDPH>@([LVWHQ]HLQHVVHOEVW VFKWLJHQ:HVHQV³ UFNW 'DVVVRPLWDXFKGLHVR]LDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQGXUFKMHQH$EZHQGXQJYRQ*RWW EHWURIIHQVLQGRIIHQEDUWHLQZHLWHUHVQRFKHOHPHQWDUHUHV0HUNPDOGDV-QJHO GHU6QGH]XVFKUHLEW'HPQDFKZRKQWLKUHLQVlPWOLFKH5HODWLRQHQEHWUHIIHQGHU Ä=ZDQJ]XP'UDQJLQGLH%H]LHKXQJVXQG9HUKlOWQLVORVLJNHLW³ LQQHGHUDO OHUGLQJVEH]HLFKQHQGHUZHLVHQLFKWGDV6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVEHWULIIW(UVFKOlJWVLFK QlPOLFKJHUDGHGDULQQLHGHUGDVVVLFKÄGDV,FK>«@LQDOOHPZDVHVWXWDXIVLFK VHOEVW]XUFN³EH]LHKWXQGGDEHLÄUFNVLFKWVORV>ZLUG@JHJHQEHUGHP$QGHUHQ DXIGHQHVVLFKGRFKJHUDGHEH]LHKW³ $P*UXQGHGLHVHV'UDQJVLQGLHVHOEVW EH]RJHQH9HUKlOWQLVORVLJNHLWGHPGHU0HQVFKPHKUXQGPHKUDOVHLQHP=ZDQJ XQWHUOLHJWDEHUVWHKWHEHQVHLQ:LGHUVSUXFKGDJHJHQPLW*RWW]XVDPPHQ]X VHLQÄ(UZLOOIUVLFKVHOEHUHWZDVVHLQ³ZHVKDOEHUÄ*RWWQLFKWIULKQGHQ 0HQVFKHQGDVHLQ³ODVVHQÄVLFKQLFKWYRQ*RWWKHUVWlQGLJQHXHPSIDQJHQ VRQGHUQDXVVLFKVHOEVWHNVLVWLHUHQ³ZLOO 2GHUDQGHUVIRUPXOLHUW (UZLOOVLFK QLFKWGXUFK*RWWDQHUNHQQHQODVVHQVRQGHUQVHLQH$QHUNHQQXQJVHOEVWLQV:HUN VHW]HQZRIUQXQDXFKVHLQHVR]LDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQPHKUXQGPHKULQVWUXPHQWD OLVLHUWZHUGHQ $OOHUGLQJVVLQGHVGLH]XUHLJHQHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDXVJHQXW]WHQ6R]LDO YHUKlOWQLVVH YRQ ZRKHU ]XJOHLFK GHU =ZDQJ ]XP 6LFK$QHUNHQQXQJ 9HUVFKDIIHQ:ROOHQDXVJHKW'DVVÄGHU0HQVFK>«@GXUFKVHLQHLJHQHV7XQ]X VLFKVHOEVWNRPPHQ³N|QQHEH]HLFKQHW-QJHODOVHLQHÄ/HEHQVOJHLQGHUHQ %DQQLQVEHVRQGHUHGLHHXURSlLVFKH*HVHOOVFKDIWOHEWGLHVLFKMDQLFKW]XIlOOLJ DOV/HLVWXQJVJHVHOOVFKDIWYHUVWHKW³ 'DVHUEVQGHQKDIWH9HUKlQJQLVLQGLHVH *HVHOOVFKDIWPLWLKUHQ/HLVWXQJV]ZlQJHQKLQHLQJHERUHQZRUGHQ]XVHLQVRNDQQ XQWHU$XIQDKPHGHVREHQ*HVDJWHQIRUPXOLHUWZHUGHQOlVVWLP*UXQGHNHLQH DQGHUH :DKO DOV GXUFK GHU HLJHQHQ +lQGH :HUN QDFK VR]LDOHU 6HOEVW %HVWlWLJXQJ]XVWUHEHQ.RPPWDXFKGDULQDEHU]XP$XVGUXFNÄGDGHU0HQVFK DOV0HQVFKDXI>«@$QHUNHQQXQJDQJHZLHVHQLVW³ZRULQVLFKQDFK-QJHOGLH 5HGHYRQGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQDOOJHPHLQYHUVWlQGOLFKDEHU RKQH Ä>G@DV VSH]LILVFKH3OXV >«@ GH>V@ *ODXEHQ>V@³ EHUVHW]HQ OlVVW GDQQ VWHOOWVLFKHLQPDOPHKUGLH)UDJHZRULQGLHVHVÃ3OXVµJHQDXEHVWHKWÄ(VYHUVL FKHUWPLU³VDJW-QJHOEHUGDVUHFKWIHUWLJHQGH(YDQJHOLXP
$D2 $D2 -h1*(/F -h1*(/ D -h1*(/D -h1*(/J
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GDLFKPLFKXPPHLQH$QHUNHQQXQJQLFKWPHKU]XVRUJHQEUDXFKHZHLOLFKEHUHLWVHLQHYRQ *RWWGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQELQ>«@0DQPXGDQQDXVVLFKVHOEHUQLFKWVPHKUPDFKHQ 0DQLVWMDVFKRQHWZDV
:lKUHQGPDQDOVRXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHUOHLVWXQJVRULHQWLHUHQ$QHUNHQ QXQJVRUGQXQJGLHHUHWZDGHUÃHXURSlLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWµ]XVFKUHLEWHWZDV ÃDXVVLFKVHOEHUPDFKHQPXVVµRKQHMHPDOVEHLVLFKDQ]XNRPPHQLVWPDQYRU *RWWÃVFKRQHWZDVµXQGVRYRQGHUÃ6RUJHXP$QHUNHQQXQJµEHIUHLW,P%OLFN DXIGLHVHVÃHWZDVµGDVPDQÃVFKRQLVWµEHYRUPDQVHOEVWRGHU$QGHUHHWZDVDXV HLQHP PDFKHQ DEHU IXQJLHUW GHU 0HQVFK Ä*RWW JHJHQEHU >«@ QXU >DOV@ HLQ (PSIDQJHQGHU³ZLH-QJHOVLFKDXVGUFNW*HQDXGDVVRZXUGHREHQDXVJH IKUWHQWVSULFKWGHU3HUVRQJDQ]JUXQGVlW]OLFK HLQYRQDQGHUZlUWVKHUNRQVWL WXLHUWHV*HVFK|SI]XVHLQGDVGLHVHVHLQHURQWRORJLVFKHQ9HUIDVVWKHLWHQWVSULFKW ZHQQHVVLFKDXI*RWWVHLQHQ6FK|SIHUYHUOlVVWXQGVLFKGDEHLJOHLFKVDPVHOEVW ORVOlVVW'HU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJODXEHYHUVHW]WGDV6XEMHNWZLHQXQ]X]HLJHQVHLQ ZLUGLQGLHGDPLWVNL]]LHUWH+DOWXQJGHVÃ*RWWHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQµXQG VWDWWHW HV PLW HLQHP NRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ 9HUWUDXHQ GDUDXI DXV GDVV GDV HLJHQH 6HOEVWXQG$QHUNDQQWVHLQYRQ*RWWKHUQLFKWPHKUDXIJUXQGVlW]OLFKH:HLVHLP VR]LDOHQ.RQWH[WHUUXQJHQZHUGHQPXVV 'DVÃ3OXVGHV*ODXEHQVµVRLVWDQGLHVHU6WHOOHNULWLVFKDQ]XPHUNHQDEHUHU ZHLVWVLFKEHLQlKHUHP+LQVHKHQ]XJOHLFKDOVHLQÃ0LQXVµ(VLVWQlPOLFKGXUFK HLQDV\PPHWULVFKHV*HIlOOH]ZLVFKHQ*RWWXQG0HQVFKHUNDXIWGDVOHW]WHUHQ]XU 3DVVLYLWlWYHUGDPPWXQGLKPQLFKWV(LJHQHV]XVHLQHUODXEW0DQLVWMDVFKRQ HWZDVµDEHUQXUDXIJUXQGXQGLQEOHLEHQGHU$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQGHUXQJHVFKXOGH WHQIUHLVRXYHUlQVLFKGD]XHQWVFKOLHHQGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ*QDGH:HUGHPJHJHQ EHUÄIUVLFKVHOEHUHWZDVVHLQ³ZLOOGHUXQWHUOLHJWEHL-QJHOGHUVNL]]LHUWHQ ÄPHKURGHUZHQLJHUPRUDOLVFKH>Q@:HUWXQJGHUPRGHUQHQ)UHLKHLWVEHDQVSUX FKXQJDOV6QGH³)RONDUW:LWWHNLQGVWHOOWKLHUGLHEHUHFKWLJWH)UDJHZDUXP GLH J|WWOLFKH Ä:DKUKHLW ZHQQ VLH GHQQ GLH(UP|JOLFKXQJ YRQ 5HODWLRQDOLWlW EHUKDXSWLVWGXUFKHLQHQ6HOEVWEH]XJGHVJHVHW]WHQ5HODWHVJHIlKUGHWZHUGHQ N|QQWH³$XVGHURQWRORJLVLHUWHQXQGDV\PPHWULVFKHQ8UVSUXQJVUHODWLRQ*RW WHV]XP0HQVFKHQGHGX]LHUW-QJHOGLUHNWHQRUPDWLYH9HUSIOLFKWXQJHQZDVGHQ HLJHQHQ)UHLKHLWVJHEUDXFKDQJHKW 'DV6FKLFNVDOGHVLQVLFKVHOEVWYHUNUPPWHQ0HQVFKHQDEHUZLH-QJHOGDV VQGLJH6XEMHNWPLW/XWKHUWLWXOLHUWVWHKWIHVW Ä'HU7RG>«@LVWGDV)D]LW³VHL QHV Ä'UDQJHV LQ GLH 9HUKlOWQLVORVLJNHLW³ LQ GHP VLFK QXU YROOHQGHW ZDV LP
)$&,867(6.( (EG -h1*(/ D :,77(.,1' $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
/HEHQEHUHLWVEHJLQQWÄ>'@DV(QGHGHU/HEHQV]HLWLVWGDQQGLH.RQIURQWDWLRQ GHVDXIVLFKVHOEVWIL[LHUWHQ,FKPLWGHP1LFKWV³ZRGXUFKDEHUQXUÄGLH1LFK WLJNHLWHLQHVVROFKHQ/HEHQV³GDVDQVWDWWVLFKDXIÄDQGHUH0HQVFKHQ³HLQ]XODV VHQÄDOV3ULYDWEHVLW]YHUEUDXFKW³ZRUGHQLVWYRU$XJHQWULWW*HJHQGLHVHQ XQKHLOYROOHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJIKUW-QJHOGDV+HLOVYHUVSUHFKHQGHV5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVDUWLNHOVLQV)HOGYRQGHP/XWKHUJHVDJWKDWRKQHLKQVHLÄGLH:HOWQLFKWV DOV7RGXQG)LQVWHUQLV³
=XVSUXFK 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDOVGHILQLWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV 0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWW 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDOV'HILQLWLRQ*RWWHVXQGGHV0HQVFKHQ -QJHO VFKUHLEW GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH ZLH HLQOHLWHQG EHUHLWV JHVDJW HLQH ÄKHUPHQHXWLVFKH%HGHXWXQJIUGDV*DQ]HGHUWKHRORJLVFKHQ(UNHQQWQLV³]X ZHLOHVLQLKUXPQLFKWVZHQLJHUJHKWDOVXPÄGDVUHFKWH5HGHQYRQ*RWWXQG YRP 0HQVFKHQ³ %HLGHV PDFKW VLH JOHLFKHUPDHQ ]XP 7KHPD (LQHUVHLWV NRPPWUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFK]XU*HOWXQJGDVVÄGHU0HQVFKDOVHLQYRQ *RWW>«@$QHUNDQQWHU>«@LVWZDVHULVW³ $QGHUHUVHLWVHQWKlOWÄGLHLP7RGH GHV0HQVFKHQ-HVXVJHVFKHKHQH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWW³DXFK HLQHGHILQLWLYH$XVVDJHGDUEHUÄZHURGHUZDV*RWWLVW³6RQVWN|QQWHZLH -QJHOHLQVFKlUIWGLHVEH]JOLFKJDUQLFKWYRQHLQHP$QHUNHQQXQJVJHVFKHKHQ JHVSURFKHQZHUGHQ,VWHVGDIUQlPOLFKNRQVWLWXWLYGDVVGLHDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQ GLHLKU]XWHLOJHZRUGHQH$QHUNHQQXQJDXFKDN]HSWLHUWPXVVVLHGHQDQHUNHQQHQ GHQ$QGHUHQDOVYHUOlVVOLFKHV*HJHQEHULGHQWLIL]LHUHQN|QQHQ1XUVRZLUG VFKOLHOLFKNODUREGLHIUHPGH=XVFKUHLEXQJYHUWUDXHQVZUGLJLVWXQGLFKPLFK DXIVLHHLQODVVHQNDQQRGHUREVLHQXUHLQHKRKOH3KUDVHGDUVWHOOWÄ9RQHLQHP VFKOHFKWKLQ8QEHNDQQWHQDEHUDXFKYRQHLQHPQXUPHKURGHUZHQLJHU%HNDQQ WHQNDQQVLFKQLHPDQGDQHUNHQQHQODVVHQ³IDVVW-QJHOVHLQH6LFKW]XVDPPHQ +LHU]XOlVVWVLFKEHPHUNHQGDVVPDQHVLPJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ8PJDQJWDJWlJ
-h1*(/ 9JO]XP9HUVWlQGQLVGHV7RGHVDOV.RQVHTXHQ]GHU6QGHGDV-Q JHODXVDOWWHVWDPHQWOLFKHQXQGQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKHQ0RWLYHQGHVWLOOLHUW DD2 ±± ± ±±9JO]XU9HUELQGXQJGHVKRPRLQFXUYDWXVLQVHLSVXP0RWLYV PLWGHU7RGHVWKHPDWLN '(56 DI F I -h1*(/ I (LQH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGLHVHU)RUPHO/XWKHUVJLEW-QJHOLQ -h1*(/ D±%HL/X WKHUIlOOWVLHLQGHU3URPRWLRQVGLVSXWDWLRQYRQ3DOODGLXVXQG7LHGHPDQQYRQ /87+(5 D -h1*(/ D -h1*(/J -h1*(/ 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2I $D2
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
OLFKPLWÃPHKURGHUZHQLJHU%HNDQQWHQµ]XWXQKDWDXIGHUHQKRIIHQWOLFKZRKO PHLQHQGHDEHUNRQWLQJHQWXQGXQDXVJHPDFKWEOHLEHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJWURW]GHP JHZLVVHUPDHQEOLQGYHUWUDXWZHUGHQPXVV'LHVHUDPELYDOHQWH&KDUDNWHU]ZL VFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHU%H]LHKXQJHQELOGHWHEHQGHQ+LQWHUJUXQGYRUGHP-QJHO GLH(LQGHXWLJNHLWJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XP6WUDKOHQEULQJW*LEWÄ*RWWLQ GHPHUGHQ0HQVFKHQUHFKWIHUWLJW]XHUNHQQHQ>«@ZHUHUHLJHQWOLFKLVW³KDW GHU0HQVFKLQLKPVRQDFKHLQXQEHGLQJWYHUWUDXHQVZUGLJHV*HJHQEHUYRQ GHPHUVLFKYRUEHKDOWORVDQHUNHQQHQODVVHQNDQQ Ä6LFKDQHUNHQQHQODVVHQ³±GDVNOLQJW]XQlFKVWVRDOVZUGH-QJHOGHP 0HQVFKHQHLQH%HWHLOLJXQJDP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ]XJHVWHKHQ'RFKZLOO HUGDPLWQXUÄGDV(UHLJQLVGHU(UNHQQWQLVGHV$QHUNHQQHQGHQGXUFKGHQ$QHU NDQQWHQ³IHVWJHKDOWHQZLVVHQGLHLQGLHVHPLKUHPHUHLJQLVKDIWHQ&KDUDNWHU VFKOHFKWKLQXQYHUIJEDU]XWHLOZLUGÄ-QJHOEHWRQW³QDFK5DOI6WROLQDV/HVDUW ÄGDGLH(UNHQQWQLV*RWWHVLP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ>«@JDQ]GHU6RXYHUl QLWlW*RWWHVXQWHUOLHJWXQGNHLQHQ=XJULIIGHV0HQVFKHQHUODXEW *RWWLVWHVGHU VLFK]XHUNHQQHQJLEWXQGVLFKDQHUNHQQHQOlW³1LFKWQXUYRQ)HUQHHULQQHUW GLHVDQ.DUO%DUWKV5HGHYRQGHULPÄFKULVWOLFKH>Q@*ODXEH>Q@³LPSOL]LHUWHQ Ä$QHUNHQQXQJ³*RWWHVDOVÄHLQH>U@IROJXQGIJVDPH>Q@HLQH>U@VLFKEHXJHQ GH>Q@VLFKXQWHURUGQHQGH>Q@.HQQWQLVQDKPH³$XFKZHUVLFKXQWHURUGQHWLVW GDEHLDNWLY-QJHODEHUGDVZLUGLP)ROJHQGHQQRFK]XGLVNXWLHUHQVHLQVHW]W JDQ]DXIGHQSDVVLYLVFKHQ:LGHUIDKUQLVFKDUDNWHUJ|WWOLFKHQ6LFK]X(UNHQQHQ *HEHQVXQGGHVGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQGHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ%HVWLPPWZHUGHQV'LHV KlQJWQLFKW]XOHW]WGDPLW]XVDPPHQGDVVGDV%HVWLPPWZHUGHQGHV0HQVFKHQ GXUFKJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJJHZLVVHUPDHQDXIV*DQ]HJHKW (EHQVRZHQLJQlPOLFKZLH*RWWVLFKLQGLHVHP*HVFKHKHQQXUPHKURGHU ZHQLJHUEHNDQQWPDFKWZLUGGHU0HQVFKGDULQQXULQHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ+LQVLFKW WKHPDWLVFK6FKRQ/XWKHUZXVVWHLQGHU'LVSXWDWLRGHKRPLQH]XVDJHQGDVVGLH SDXOLQLVFKH5HGHYRQGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDXV*ODXEHQHLQHÄEUHYLWHU KRPLQLVGHILQLWLRQHP³EHLQKDOWH-QJHOPDFKWVLFKGLHVH)RUPHODXIVHLQH$UW ]XHLJHQ=XUREHQEHUHLWVVNL]]LHUWHQ(LQVLFKWÄGHUQHXHUHQ$QWKURSRORJLH>«@ GDVVGHU0HQVFKHLQH)UDJHVHLDXIGLHZLUGLH$QWZRUWQLFKWNHQQHQ³WULWWHU GDEHLLQHQHUJLVFKHQ:LGHUVSUXFK6HLQH$XVNXQIWÄGDVVGHU0HQVFK>«@HLQH YRQ*RWWJHJHEHQH$QWZRUWLVW]XGHUZLUGLH)UDJHQRFKQLFKWKLQUHLFKHQG NHQQHQ³ NHKUWGDV%HJUQGXQJVYHUKlOWQLVXP'LHH[]HQWULVFKH:HOWRIIHQKHLW
$D2I $D2 (EG 672/,1$ %$57+ I9JOGD]X 6$$5,1(1I II /87+(5 E±-QJHO]LWLHUW/XWKHUV)RUPHOXDLQ -h1*(/H G F -h1*(/M $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
PHQVFKOLFKHU([LVWHQ]LVWGHPQDFKNHLQHVZHJV PLWHLQHU8QEHVWLPPWKHLW]X YHUZHFKVHOQGLHHUVWQRFKGXUFKHLJHQH7DWHQPLW,QKDOW]XIOOHQZlUH9LHO PHKUYHUZHLVHQGLHVH6WUXNWXUPHUNPDOHEHUHLWVDXIGLHDOOHP+DQGHOQYRUJHJH EHQHRQWRORJLVFKYHUDQNHUWH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKVHLQV :DKUKDIW]XVLFK VHOEVWJHODQJWQLHPDQGDXVVLFKVHOEVWVRQGHUQNRPPWHLQMHGHUQXUDXHUKDOE VHLQHUVHOEVWÄ'LHVHV([WUDQRV³ZLH-QJHOXQWHU9HUZHQGXQJ/XWKHUVFKHU 7HUPLQRORJLHVFKUHLEWLVWDEHU IUGLHGHQ*ODXEHQDXVOHJHQGH7KHRORJLHQLFKWHLQXQEHVWLPPWHVÃ'UDXHQµVRQGHUQGHU]XU :HOWNRPPHQGHXQGLQGHP0HQVFKHQ-HVXVGHILQLWLY]XU:HOWJHNRPPHQH*RWW,QGHPGHU 0HQVFKYRQGLHVHP([WUDQRVKHUH[LVWLHUWZLUGHUHLQJDQ]HU0HQVFK
:LHGHU0HQVFKÄGXUFKGLHLQGHU3HUVRQ-HVX&KULVWLJHVFKHKHQH%HJHJQXQJ *RWWHVPLWGHP0HQVFKHQJHVFKOHFKWGHILQLHUW³XQGGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWZLUG VRDXFK*RWWGHUVLFKDOOHUGLQJVHEHQGDULQVHOEVWDXV)UHLKHLWGHILQLHUW 'LH3DVVLYLWlWVXQG$NWLYLWlWVDQWHLOHDQGLHVHP*HVFKHKHQVLQGVRPLWNODU YHUWHLOW 'HPPHQVFKOLFKHQ'HILQLHUWRGHU$QHUNDQQWZHUGHQVWHKWGLHJ|WWOLFKH 6HOEVWGHILQLWLRQJHJHQEHU6RNRPPWHVVFKOLHOLFKQLFKWHWZD]XHLQHU9HU J|WWOLFKXQJGHV0HQVFKHQRGHU9HUPHQVFKOLFKXQJ*RWWHV9LHOPHKUEHKDXSWHW -QJHOÄ>G@D*RWWLQ-HVXV&KULVWXV0HQVFKZXUGHXP*RWWXQG0HQVFKIU LPPHUGHILQLWLY]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ³'LHVHV'LIIHUHQ]YHUKlOWQLVDEHUSUlJWGDV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQLQVJHVDPWLQGHP-QJHOGHP0HQVFKHQVFKOHFKWKLQ GHQSDVVLYHQ3DUW]XZHLVW'DVVXQGLQZLHIHUQDOOHLQ*RWWGDULQWlWLJLVWPDFKHQ VHLQHV(UDFKWHQVGLHÄUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ([NOXVLYSDUWLNHO>«@VROXV&KULVWXV± VRODJUDWLD±VRORYHUER±VRODILGH>«@WKHPDWLVFK³6RJHEHQVLHDQXQWHU ZHOFKHQ$VSHNWHQÄ>G@HU0HQVFK>«@DXVJHVFKORVVHQZHUGHQVROOZHQQHVXP VHLQH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJJHKW³DEHUHEHQPLWGHPHUNOlUWHQÄ=LHOGDHULQUHFKWHU :HLVHHLQEH]RJHQZLUG³$QLKQHQVROOQXQGDUJHOHJWZHUGHQZLHGDV5HFK WIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ GHU GDULQ LPSOL]LHUWH $QHUNHQQXQJVDNW XQG GDV GDIU JUXQGOHJHQGH*RWW0HQVFK9HUKlOWQLVYRQ-QJHOJHQDXHUEHVWLPPWZHUGHQ
$D2 -h1*(/ 9JODD2 $D2 -h1*(/ D9JO]X-QJHOV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHU([NOXVLYSDUWLNHO 6&+8%(57 II -h1*(/ D
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
$VSHNWHUHFKWIHUWLJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ GLHUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ ([NOXVLYSDUWLNHO 6ROXV&KULVWXVRGHU GHUGHILQLWLYH&KDUDNWHUJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'HPVROXV&KULVWXVNRPPWXQWHUGHQVRJ([NOXVLYSDUWLNHOQLQ-QJHOV$XJHQ HLQHYRUUDQJLJH%HGHXWXQJ]X,QLKULVWGHPQDFKHLJHQWOLFKDOOHVJHVDJWZlK UHQGGHQEULJHQGUHL%HVWLPPXQJHQQXUGLH)XQNWLRQGHU6LFKHUXQJLKUHV$XV VDJHJHKDOWHV]XNRPPW'LHVHQEULQJW-QJHODXIGLHNQDSSH)RUPHO Ä&KULVWXV DOOHLQZHLO*RWWDOOHLQ³'D*RWWVLFKH[NOXVLYLP/HEHQXQG6WHUEHQ-HVX &KULVWLDOOHQ0HQVFKHQKHLOYROO]XHUNHQQHQJHJHEHQKDWLVWQLUJHQGVVRQVWLQ NHLQHUDQGHUHQJHLVWOLFKHQRGHUZHOWOLFKHQ,QVWDQ]GDV+HLO]XILQGHQDOVHLQ]LJ LQLKP/LHJWKLHULQJHZLVVHUPDHQGHUGHILQLWLYH&KDUDNWHUJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQ QXQJEHJUQGHWGDQQDXFKGHVKDOEZHLOLQ&KULVWXVJHZLVVHUPDHQNODUH)DN WHQ JHVFKDIIHQ ZHUGHQ DQ GHQHQ VLFK GXUFK GLH LQGLYLGXHOOH $QHLJQXQJ LP *ODXEHQRGHU$EOHKQXQJLP8QJODXEHQQLFKWVlQGHUW'LH6KQRSIHUFKULVWRORJLH KDWJHUDGHGHVKDOEIU-QJHOKRKHQ=XVWLPPXQJVZHUW :HOFKHEDKQEUHFKHQGH9HUlQGHUXQJPLWGHU([NOXVLYLWlWJ|WWOLFKHQ+HLOVLQ &KULVWRDXVJHVDJWZLUGPDFKW-QJHODQKDQGGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ8PGHXWXQJGHV DOWWHVWDPHQWOLFKHQ6KQRSIHUVGHXWOLFK'HPJHJHQEHUQlPOLFKHUJHEHQVLFK GUHLJHZLFKWLJH,QQRYDWLRQHQ(UVWHQVZLUGGDVZHLOHVQLHHLQHGHILQLWLYH9HU V|KQXQJ*RWWHVPLWGHQ0HQVFKHQEHZLUNWQRWZHQGLJDXI:LHGHUKROXQJDQJH ZLHVHQH 6KQRSIHULQVWLWXW GXUFK GDV HLQ IU DOOH PDO HUIROJWH VDFUDPHQWXP &KULVWL XQGGDPLW*RWWHV VFKOHFKWKLQEHUERWHQ'DEHLDEHUNHKUWVLFK]ZHLWHQV GLH/RJLNGHVXUVSUQJOLFKHQ6KQRSIHULQVWLWXWVUHJHOUHFKWXP1LFKWPHKUGLHQW GLH+LQJDEHHLQHVGXUFK6FKXOGXQKHLOLJJHZRUGHQHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQVGLH GXUFK 6XEMHNWEHUWUDJXQJ DXI GDV VFKOLHOLFK JHW|WHWH 2SIHUWLHU HUVDW]ZHLVH JHVFKLHKWGHVVHQHQWVKQHQGHU:LHGHUDXIQDKPHLQ*RWWHV+HLOLJNHLW9LHOPHKU VWHKWOHW]WHUHDQHUVWHU6WHOOHÄ>$@P.UHX]&KULVWLYROO]LHKW*RWWGLH,QNRUSRUD WLRQGHUVQGLJHQ0HQVFKKHLWLQVHLQHLJHQHV/HEHQ³DXIDOOHPPHQVFKOLFKHQ +DQGHOQ]XYRUNRPPHQGHXQGVWHOOYHUWUHWHQGH:HLVH(UVWGDUDXIKLQHUIROJWGLH hEHUWUDJXQJGHU,GHQWLWlWLQGHPVLFKGHUHLQ]HOQH0HQVFKLP*ODXEHQÄPLWGHP *HVFKLFN-HVXVRLGHQWLIL]LHUWGDHUVLFKLQLKPJHVWRUEHQXQGLQLKPYRQGHQ 7RWHQDXIHUZHFNWZHL³ $XFKLP%OLFNDXIGLHVHV6LFK,GHQWLIL]LHUW:LVVHQ DEHUZLUGGULWWHQV*RWWDOVGDVDOOHLQLJH+DQGOXQJVVXEMHNWQDPKDIWJHPDFKW 1LFKWQXULQ&KULVWXVZLUNWHUDQVWHOOHGHV0HQVFKHQVRQGHUQDXFKÄLP0HQ VFKHQLQVRIHUQHU*ODXEHQHUZHFNWXQGHEHQGDGXUFKGHQ*ODXEHQGHQLKUHQHXH ,GHQWLWlWDOV+HLOLJH>«@JHZlKUW³'LH)UDJHREGDEHLQLFKW]XPLQGHVWHLQ
9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPWDD2± $D2 $D2 $D2 (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:LVVHQ.|QQHQDXIVHLWHQGHV0HQVFKHQYRUDXVJHVHW]WZHUGHQPXVVVWHOOWVLFK IU-QJHORIIHQVLFKWOLFKQLFKW6HLQ$N]HQWOLHJWZLH&KULVWLDQH6FKXEHUWIHVW KlOWGDUDXIÄZDVGHQHLJHQHQ*ODXEHQPRWLYLHUW³DXIÄGHQXQYHUIJEDUHQ(U IDKUXQJHQXQG%HJHJQXQJHQGHQHQHU]XQlFKVWSDVVLYDXVJHVHW]WLVWXQGDXV GHQHQKHUDXVVLFKGHU*ODXEHEHJUQGHW³$OOHUGLQJVLVWVFKRQGLH5HLKHQIROJH Ã]XQlFKVWSDVVLYDXVJHVHW]WµGDQQÃDNWLYDQJHHLJQHWµOHLFKWDOVHLQH.RQVWUXNWL RQ ]X GXUFKVFKDXHQ GLH YRP 6WDWXV HUIROJWHU $QHLJQXQJ DXV YRUJHQRPPHQ ZLUGZHLOGLHYHUPHLQWOLFKÃSDVVLYHµ$XVJDQJVVLWXDWLRQJDUNHLQHUGLVWDQ]LHUWHQ %HWUDFKWXQJ]XJlQJOLFKZlUH 'DV,GHQWLIL]LHUWZHUGHQPLWGHP*HVWRUEHQHQXQG$XIHUVWDQGHQHQVWHOOWMH GHQIDOOVHEHQMHQHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVDNWGDUDXIGHQ-QJHOGDV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJH VFKHKHQ]LHOHQVLHKW'HUHEHQIDOOVGXUFK*RWWLQLWLLHUWH9ROO]XJGHV*ODXEHQVLVW GDQQ GDV REHQ HUZlKQWH Ä6LFK$QHUNHQQHQ/DVVHQ³ GXUFK GLH LQ &KULVWXV JHVFKHKHQH XQEHGLQJWH $QHUNHQQXQJ GHV 0HQVFKHQ 6LH YHUVHW]W LKQ LQ HLQ Ä6HLQLP)ULHGHQPLW*RWW³±HLQH.DUO%DUWKHQWOHKQWH)RUPHOLQGHU-QJHO ÄGDV=LHOXQGGLH)UXFKWGHV6KQRSIHUWRGHV-HVX&KULVWLVDFKOLFKDQJHPHV VHQ³DXVJHGUFNWILQGHW:DVGDPLWJHPHLQWLVWPDFKWHULQQHJDWLYHUXQG SRVLWLYHU +LQVLFKW XQWHU 5HNXUV DXI /XWKHUV 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ YRQ DOWHP XQG QHXHP0HQVFKHQGHXWOLFK1HJDWLYPDFKWVLHDXIGLH.RQVHTXHQ]GHV*HVWRU EHQVHLQVHLQHVMHGHQ0HQVFKHQDP.UHX]DXIPHUNVDP (VEHGHXWHWGDV(QGHGHV DOWHQGHU6QGHYHUKDIWHWHQ0HQVFKHQGHU)ULHGHPLW*RWWHEHQJHQDXGDQQKDW ZHQQHUYHUJHKW'LHSRVLWLYH.HKUVHLWHGHVVHQDEHULVWGLH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV QHXHQ0HQVFKHQLP(UHLJQLVGHU$XIHUVWHKXQJ+LHUPHLQWGHU%HJULIIGHV)ULH GHQVZLH-QJHOHVPLW+HQULN6WHIIHQVDXVGUFNWGLHÄXQPLWWHOEDUH>@*HJHQ ZDUWGHVJDQ]HQXQJHWHLOWHQ'DVHLQV³$QJHVLFKWVGHV=ZLHVSDOWVLQGLHGHU VQGLJH0HQVFKPLWVLFKVHOEVWGHU:HOWXQG*RWWJHUlWJHZlKUWLKPDOVRGDV 6KQRSIHU&KULVWLGLHIULKQXQHUUHLFKEDUHXQGPLWKLQLP]XP6FKHLWHUQYHUXU WHLOWHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVVWUHEHQDQYLVLHUWH*DQ]KHLWVHLQHV'DVHLQV'LHVHV *DQ]XQG+HLOVHLQNRPPWGHUJHUHFKWIHUWLJWHQ3HUVRQDOOHUGLQJVQXUÃLQ&KULV WXVµ ]X ZDV VLH LQ GHQ VFK|SIXQJVPlLJ YRUJHVHKHQHQ ([WHUQLWlWVEH]XJ GHV 6LFK(PSIDQJHQVYRQ*RWWYHUVHW]W,Q&KULVWL7RGXQG$XIHUVWHKXQJVHW]WVLFK QDFK-QJHOGLHÄ6WUXNWXUUHODWLRQDOHU6HOEVWNRQVWLWXWLRQLQ*RWW>«@DOVDOOXP IDVVHQGGXUFK³DXIJUXQGGHUHUGHU0HQVFKLVWZDVHULVW6LFKGDVÄJHIDOOHQ >]X@ODVVHQ³DOVRGLHGDULQDXVJHVSURFKHQHXQEHGLQJWH$QHUNHQQXQJGHVMHHL JHQHQ6HOEVWVHLQVDQ]XQHKPHQÄGDVKHLWDXV*ODXEHQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWZHUGHQ XQGGHVKDOE)ULHGHQKDEHQ³:LH-QJHODEHUVFKOLHOLFKGHXWOLFKPDFKWEH
6&+8%(57 -h1*(/ 'LHVHU=XVDPPHQKDQJZLUGDQGLHVHU6WHOOHH[SOL]LWKHUJHVWHOOW -h1*(/ D $D2 :,77(.,1' -h1*(/ D
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
NRPPWGXUFKGDV(QGHGHVNXOWLVFKHQ2SIHULQVWLWXWVLP&KULVWHQWXPGHU2SIHU EHJULII HLQHQ ÄPHWDSKRULVFKHQ 6LQQ³ ZRGXUFK PLW LKP GDV ÄFKULVWOLFKH /H EHQ³DOVVLFK*RWWKLQJHEHQGHU*RWWHVGLHQVWFKDUDNWHULVLHUEDUZLUG:LHDXFK YHUVFKLHGHQHQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKH)RUPXOLHUXQJHQQDKHOHJHQLVWGDEHLDQ]ZHLHU OHL]XGHQNHQ 'HU*RWWHV+LQJDEHDQGHQ0HQVFKHQHQWVSUHFKHQGHPHQVFKOLFKH *RWWHVGLHQVWZLUGVRZRKOLPVRQQWlJOLFKHQ/RESUHLVYROO]RJHQZLHLPDOOWlJOL FKHQ(LQVDW]IU$QGHUH 6RODJUDWLDRGHU GHUEHGLQJXQJVORVH&KDUDNWHUJ|WWOLFKHU $QHUNHQQXQJ 'LHSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQGHVDOOHLQGXUFK&KULVWXVLQLWLLHUWHQ5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVJHVFKHKHQVZHUGHQDEHUGXUFKGLHVRODJUDWLD3DUWLNHOLQLKUH*UHQ]HQ YHUZLHVHQ 6R EULQJW GLHVH %HVWLPPXQJ LQ -QJHOV $XJHQ ]XP 7UDJHQ GDVV ÄDOOHVZDV*RWWGHU0HQVFKKHLWLQ-HVXV&KULVWXVGXUFKLKQXQGXPVHLQHWZLOOHQ ]XJHZHQGHWXQGDQJHWDQKDWHLQEHGLQJXQJVORVHVJ|WWOLFKHV*HVFKHQN³ LVW (LQH.RQGLWLRQLHUXQJGHV+HLOVGXUFKLUJHQGZHOFKHYRP0HQVFKHQHUZRUEHQHQ (LJHQVFKDIWHQRGHU]XHUEULQJHQGHQ/HLVWXQJHQZLUGVRULJRURVDXVJHVFKORVVHQ XQG GLH VRXYHUlQH $OOHLQZLUNVDPNHLW *RWWHV HLQPDO PHKU XQWHUVWULFKHQ ,P 8QWHUVFKLHGHWZD]XPSUlVLGLDODXVJHEWHQ*QDGHQUHFKWGDVDXFKGLHNRQWUD IDNWLVFKH*HUHFKWVSUHFKXQJHLQHV]XUHFKW9HUXUWHLOWHQEHLQKDOWHWNRPPWGLH J|WWOLFKH%HJQDGLJXQJGHV6QGHUVDEHUQLFKWDOV(UJHEQLVGLVWDQ]LHUWHU$EZl JXQJVSUR]HVVH]XVWHKHQ9LHOPHKULVWÄ*QDGHLPWKHRORJLVFKHQ6LQQHGHV:RU WHV>«@QLFKWQXUHLQHGHQ(PSIlQJHUGHU*QDGHJDQ]XQGJDUEHVWLPPHQGHVLH LVW DXFK HLQH GHQ %HJQDGLJHQGHQ LP =HQWUXP VHLQHU ([LVWHQ] NRQNXUUHQ]ORV EHZHJHQGH*U|H³'DVVGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDOOHLQDXV*QDGHHUIROJWEHGHX WHWDOVRGHQ$XVVFKOXVVLKUHU%HGLQJWKHLWGXUFKGHQ0HQVFKHQHEHQVRZLHGXUFK DQGHUHJ|WWOLFKH%HZHJJUQGHDOVQXUGLHVHQ0HQVFKOLFKH$NWLYLWlWHQMHGZHGHU $UWVSLHOHQGDIUNHLQH5ROOHZDVEHUHLWVDOVSUREOHPDWLVFKLGHQWLIL]LHUWZXUGH *RWWKDQGHOWY|OOLJYRUDXVVHW]XQJVORV'HQQÄ>H@VLVW³ZLH-QJHOKHUDXVVWHOOW ÄVFKOHFKWHUGLQJVQLFKWVÃ*XWHVLP6QGHUµDQ]XHUNHQQHQZDV]XP5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVJHVFKHKHQ HLQHQ %HLWUDJ ]X OHLVWHQ YHUPDJ³ XQG ZRGXUFK HU ÄVHLQH $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK *RWW³ EHZHUNVWHOOLJHQ N|QQWH 'LH %HKDXSWXQJ GDVV ÃQLFKWV*XWHVLP6QGHUDQ]XHUNHQQHQµLVWYHUQHLQWQHEHQGHU%HWHLOLJXQJGHV 6XEMHNWVDP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQLP*UXQGHDXFKGLHPLW1RWJHU6OHQF]ND ÄLP6LQQHHLQHUSUDHDPEXODILGHL³]XVWHOOHQGH)UDJHGDQDFK
(EG 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XUGLHVHP3XQNWLQVJHVDPW $D2± $D2 $D2 -h1*(/ DI -h1*(/ D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
REHVQLFKW,QGL]LHQGHV0HQVFKVHLQVJLEWLQGHQHQGDV$QJHOHJWVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQDXIGDV (YDQJHOLXPXQGGLH9HUIHKOXQJGHU%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQVLFKPHOGHWVRQlPOLFKPHO GHWGDGHU0HQVFKDXHUKDOEGHVVHQXQIlKLJLVWPLWVLFKLQV5HLQH]XNRPPHQ
%HL-QJHOGHULQJXWEDUWKLDQLVFKHU7UDGLWLRQGDYRQDXVJHKWGDVVÄGLH6QGH QLFKWRKQHGDV(YDQJHOLXPHUNHQQEDU³LVWODVVHQVLFKDEHULQGHUREHQDQJH IKUWHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHU1DWUOLFKHQ7KHRORJLHGRFKDXFK9HUZHLVH DXIÃ,QGL]LHQGHV0HQVFKVHLQVLQGHQHQGDV$QJHOHJWVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQDXIGDV (YDQJHOLXPVLFKPHOGHWµHQWGHFNHQ6ROLHVLFKGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWLQGLH$XV VDJHEHUVHW]HQÄGDGHU0HQVFKDOV0HQVFKDXI$QUHGHXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ DQJHZLHVHQLVW³ZREHLGLHVH$QJHZLHVHQKHLWHEHQÃRKQH*RWWµ]XHLQHUDPEL YDOHQ]EHKDIWHWHQ$QJHOHJHQKHLWZLUG*DQ]VRXQYHUPLWWHOWZLHHVGLH)RUPX OLHUXQJQLFKWV*XWHVVHLLP6QGHUDQ]XHUNHQQHQQDKHOHJWWULIIWGHQ0HQVFKHQ GDV Ã(YDQJHOLXP YRQ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJµ VR JHVHKHQ DXFK EHL -QJHO QLFKW ZHQQJOHLFKHUGHUDUWULJRURVDUJXPHQWLHUW 'LH5LJRURVLWlWGHV$XVVFKOXVVHVDEHUHUNOlUWVLFKGDKHUGDVV-QJHOGLH6RX YHUlQLWlW*RWWHVLP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQXQEHGLQJWJHZDKUWZLVVHQP|FK WH*RWWKDQGHOWGDULQJlQ]OLFKEHGLQJXQJVORV:HGHUOlVVWHUDXVQDKPVZHLVH *QDGHYRU5HFKWHUJHKHQQRFKEHGDUIHUGHV0HQVFKHQXPVLFKDOVJQlGLJ HUZHLVHQ]XN|QQHQ*RWWPXVVYLHOPHKUZLH-QJHOHLQVFKlUIWEHUHLWVÄIUVLFK VHOEVW³VHLQÄZDVHULQVHLQHP9HUKlOWQLV]XU:HOWGDQQXQGGDUDXIKLQDXFKIU XQVVHLQZLOO³ZHQQVHLQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLOQLFKWGXUFKLUJHQGHWZDVUHODWL YLHUWZHUGHQVROO:HLOVLHGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWHEHQVRGHVJ|WWOLFKHQ*QDGHQKDQ GHOQVZLH*RWWHVVHOEVWDEVLFKHUWEH]HLFKQHWHUPLW.DUO%DUWKGLHÄWULQLWDULVFKH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJGHV*RWWVHLQV*RWWHV³DOVÄGDVWKHRORJLVFKH>«@5FNJUDWGHV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQV³ D 'DVWULQLWDULVFKH5FNJUDWGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQV :LUGGDV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ±ZRULQ-QJHOHLQHVHLW0HODQFKWKRQZDKU QHKPEDUH7HQGHQ]HYDQJHOLVFKHU7KHRORJLHHQWGHFNW±DXIGLHGHP0HQVFKHQ ]XWHLOZHUGHQGHQ:RKOWDWHQUHGX]LHUWEOHLEWJOHLFKVDP*RWWHV5ROOHLQGLHVHP +HLOVYRUJDQJXQEHVWLPPW:HLWUHLFKHQGHQ0LVVYHUVWlQGQLVVHQVLHKW-QJHOVR YRUJHDUEHLWHW(LQHUVHLWVN|QQWHGLHJ|WWOLFKH*HUHFKWVSUHFKXQJGHV6QGHUVYRU GLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGDOVHLQK|FKVWULFKWHUOLFKHV+DQGHOQDQJHVHKHQZHUGHQGDV
6/(1&=.$ -h1*(/ D -h1*(/J 9JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'HXWXQJHLQPDOPHKUGLH$XVIKUXQJHQ+HU PDQQ)LVFKHUV ),6&+(5 II -h1*(/F 9JO]X-QJHOVDQ.DUO%DUWKDQVFKOLHHQGH)DVVXQJGHU7ULQLWlWVOHKUHLQVJHVDPW -h1 *(/ ± D9JOIUGLHIROJHQGH'DUVWHOOXQJ '(56I± %HL%DUWKEHJHJQHWGLHVH)RUPXOLHUXQJLQ%$57+ I9JO]XU7ULQLWlWVOHKUH -QJHOVDXFK.5h*(5II
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
HQWJHJHQVRQVWLJHUhEOLFKNHLWHQHLQPDO0LOGHZDOWHQOlVVW'DPLWDEHUVWHKW DQGHUHUVHLWVLQ)UDJHZHOFKHQ,QWHQWLRQHQ*RWWMHQVHLWVVROFKHUDXVQDKPVZHLVH YROO]RJHQHQ*QDGHQDNWHIROJWÄ>/@DXHUW³HUGRUWDOVMHQHVYRQ/XGZLJ)HXHU EDFKEHVFKULHEHQHÄ6XEMHNWGDVDXFKRKQH/LHEHQRFK(WZDVIUVLFKLVW>DOV@ HLQOLHEORVHV8QJHKHXHUHLQGlPRQLVFKHV:HVHQGHVVHQYRQGHU/LHEHXQWHU VFKHLGEDUHXQGZLUNOLFKXQWHUVFKLHGQH3HUV|QOLFKNHLWDQGHP%OXWHGHU.HW]HU XQG8QJOlXELJHQVLFKHUJ|W]W³"-QJHOMHGHQIDOOVIROJHUWDXV)HXHUEDFKVFKULV WHQWXPVNULWLVFKHP9HUGLNWGDVVLP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQDXFKGDV:HVHQ *RWWHVHLQIUDOOHPDODXIGHQ%HJULIINRPPHQPXVVZHQQGLHGDULQHUIROJHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQQLFKWLKUHQGHILQLWLYHQ&KDUDNWHUHLQEHQVROO0LW GHU)UDJHÄQDFK*RWWVHOEVWLQVHLQHQ7DWHQ³ ZLUGVRQDFK]XP7KHPDZDUXP HVGHP:HVHQ*RWWHV]XWLHIVWHQWVSULFKWGHQ8QJHUHFKWHQQLFKWYHUGLHQWHUPD HQPLWHZLJHU9HUGDPPQLV]XVWUDIHQ'LHVH$XHUNUDIWVHW]XQJGHVWUDGLWLRQHO OHQ*HUHFKWLJNHLWVJUXQGVDW]HVÃ-HGHPGDV6HLQHµGDUIDEHUDQNHLQHQEORZLOO NUOLFKHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVDNW JHEXQGHQ ZHUGHQ EHU GHQ KLQDXV QRFK DQGHUH *HVHW]HJHOWHQN|QQWHQ9LHOPHKULVWVLHDOVHLQ,GHQWLWlWVHUZHLV]XYHUVWHKHQLQ GHP]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPWZDVIU*RWWXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHQNRQNUHWHQ+HLOV ZLUNXQJHQDP0HQVFKHQLPPHUVFKRQEHVWLPPHQGLVW*HQDXGLHVH[SOL]LHUWLQ -QJHOV$XJHQGLH7ULQLWlWVOHKUH Ä*RWW>LVW@QLFKWHUVWLP9HUKlOWQLV]XVHLQHP *HVFK|SIVRQGHUQVFKRQLQVHLQHP9HUKlOWQLV]XVLFKVHOEVW³LQGHP6LQQHJH UHFKWGDVVLQVHLQHUWULQLWDULVFKVWUXNWXULHUWHQ6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJÄ$QGHUVKHLWLVW XQG EHMDKW ZLUG³ 'DEHL VFKOLHW HU VLFK ]ZDU DXVGUFNOLFK GHP ÄÃ*UXQG D[LRPµ>«@.DUO5DKQHUV³DQ Ä'LHÃ|NRQRPLVFKHµ7ULQLWlWLVWGLHÃLPPDQHQWHµ 7ULQLWlWXQGXPJHNHKUW³-HGRFKZHLVWHU]XJOHLFKDXIGLH*HIDKUHLQHUY|OOL JHQ*OHLFKVHW]XQJGHURSHUDWULQLWDWLVDGLQWUDXQGDGH[WUDKLQRKQHGHUHQ EOHLEHQGH'LIIHUHQ]ÄGLH)UHLKHLWXQGXQJHVFKXOGHWH*QDGHGHU6HOEVWPLWWHLOXQJ *RWWHVXQGDOVRGHUHQ(UHLJQLVKDIWLJNHLWXQGHQNEDUZLUG³ (VLVW-QJHODOVRGDUXP]XWXQGLH*RWWNODVVLVFKHUZHLVH]XJHVFKULHEHQH $VHLWlWVHLQ$XVVLFKVHOEVW6HLQXQGGLHIUHLKHLWOLFKVRXYHUlQH(LJHQDUWVHLQHV 2IIHQEDUXQJVKDQGHOQVHEHQVR]XZDKUHQZLHHUGHQ(LQGUXFNWLOJHQZLOOPDQ KDEH HV KLHU PLW HLQHP HJR]HQWULVFKHQ :LOONUKHUUVFKHU ]X VFKDIIHQ Ä*RWW NRPPWYRQ*RWW³XQGÄ*RWWLVW/LHEH³ODXWHQGLHEHLGHQVRQDFK]XYHUPLW WHOQGHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQDOVGHUHQPLVVLQJOLQNGLHWULQLWDULVFKH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ *RWWHVIXQJLHUW,QGHP-QJHOGDEHLGLH7ULQLWlW]XUÄ*HPHLQVFKDIWJHJHQVHLWL
'LH :RUWH /XGZLJ )HXHUEDFKV DXV 'DV :HVHQ GHV &KULVWHQWXPV ZHUGHQ ]LWLHUW LQ -h1*(/ -h1*(/I -h1*(/ D -h1*(/F $D2 -h1*(/ $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JHQ$QGHUVVHLQV³HUNOlUWVROO*RWWVFKRQLQVLFKVHOEVWGLHJHOLQJHQGH$QHU NHQQXQJYRQ$QGHUVKHLWSUDNWL]LHUHQZDVHUGDQQLP%OLFNDXIGHQ0HQVFKHQ ZHQQJOHLFKLQH[WUHPHU:HLVHQXUZLHGHUKROWÄ>'@D*RWWDXFKLQPLWWHQGHU PD[LPHFRQWUDULDGHU+HUUGHU*HJHQVlW]HLVWXQGEOHLEW³ZLUGGDQQFKULVWR ORJLVFKQXUDIILUPLHUWRKQHGDVVGLHV)ROJHQIUGDVJ|WWOLFKH:HVHQVHOEVWKlW WH:DV-QJHODOV*UXQGD[LRPYRQ.DUO%DUWKV.LUFKOLFKHU'RJPDWLNKHUDXV VWHOOWIXQGLHUWGHPQDFKDXFKVHLQHHLJHQH6LFKW Ä*RWWHQWVSULFKWVLFK³=XP Ã+HUUQGHU*HJHQVlW]HµZLUGHUQLFKWHUVWGXUFKGLHUHWWHQGH=XZHQGXQJ]XP 0HQVFKHQLQ&KULVWRDXFKZHQQGLHVH±ZLH-QJHOLPPHUZLHGHUJHJHQEHU MHGZHGHUQDWUOLFKHU7KHRORJLHHLQVFKlUIW±DOVVHLQHH[NOXVLYH2IIHQEDUXQJVWDW GHUHLQ]LJH(UNHQQWQLVJUXQGVHLQHV:HVHQVLVW9LHOPHKUÄ>HQWVSULFKW@*RWWHV 6HLQDGH[WUDZHVHQWOLFKVHLQHP6HLQDGLQWUDLQGHPHVEHJUQGHWXQGYRUJH ELOGHWLVW³2GHUZLH-QJHOHVDQGHUQRUWVDXVGUFNW Ä*RWWNRPPWYRQ*RWW DEHUHUZLOOQLFKWRKQHXQV]XVLFKVHOEVWNRPPHQ³ *RWWHVFKULVWRORJLVFK DN]HQWXLHUWHV)U$QGHUH6HLQVROOGDPLWDOV,PSOLNDWVHLQHVXQEHGLQJWHQ$XV VLFKVHOEVW6HLQVVHLQHUIUHLKHLWOLFKVRXYHUlQHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJYHUGHXWOLFKW ZHUGHQ1LFKWVDQGHUHVEHVDJW-QJHO]XIROJHGLHMRKDQQHLVFKH,GHQWLILNDWLRQ YRQ*RWWXQG/LHEH/LHEHQlPOLFKLVWQDFKVHLQHU'HILQLWLRQGDVÄ(UHLJQLVHLQHU LQPLWWHQ>«@QRFKVRJURHU6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLWLPPHUQRFKJU|HUHQ6HOEVWOR VLJNHLW³,QGHU+LQJDEHDQGHQ$QGHUHQGLH(UIOOXQJGHVHLJHQHQ6HOEVWVHLQV ]XILQGHQ±GDVDEHUSUlJWEHUHLWVGDVWULQLWDULVFKYHUIDVVWHJ|WWOLFKH)U6LFK 6HLQGDVLQGHU0HQVFKZHUGXQJÄDXFKZHQQHVHLQHH[WUHPH6SDQQXQJLPSOL ]LHUW³XPVRJU|HUH(QWVSUHFKXQJILQGHW 0LW-|UJ'LHUNHQOlVVWVLFKDOOHUGLQJVNULWLVFKIUDJHQRE*RWWLQGLHVHPVHL QHPÄXQJHEURFKHQH>Q@GXUFKDOOH1HJDWLRQOHW]WOLFKNRQWLQXLHUWH>Q@6HOEVWVHLQ QLFKWDP(QGHMHQHUÃ9HUKlOWQLVORVLJNHLWµDOO]XQDKHNRPPW³GLH-QJHOIUGDV 'DVHLQGHV6QGHUUHVHUYLHUWKDW)RONDUW:LWWHNLQGlXHUWGHQLQGLHJOHLFKH 5LFKWXQJJHKHQGHQÄ9HUGDFKW³GDVV >Z@HQQ*RWWH[LVWLHUWLQGHPVHLQH/LHEHDOOHQ:LGHUVWDQGEHUZLQGHW>«@GLHVHU:LGHUVWDQG VHOEVWQXUHLQQRWZHQGLJHV0RPHQWIUGHQ3UR]HVVLVWPLWGHP*RWWVLFKLQ(ZLJNHLWGXUFK 6FK|SIXQJ6QGHXQG(VFKDWRQKLQGXUFKVHOEVWHQWVSULFKW
+LQ]XNRPPWGDVVDXFKZHQQ-QJHOÄ*RWW³GDVEHU.RQWLQJHQ]XQG1RWZHQ GLJNHLWHUKDEHQH3UlGLNDWÄPHKUDOVQRWZHQGLJ³]XVFKUHLEWGLHÄH[NOXVLYH
-h1*(/F $D2 -h1*(/ $D2 -h1*(/ $D2 -h1*(/F ',(5.(1 :,77(.,1'
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
6HOEVWRIIHQEDUXQJ*RWWHVLQ-HVXV³EHLLKPÄDOVNRQWLQJHQWYHUVWDQGHQ³ZHUGHQ PXVVZLH0LFKDHO0XUUPDQQ.DKOIHVWKlOW±DOVNRQWLQJHQWLQGHP6LQQHGDVV Ä>G@LHVH(QWVFKHLGXQJ>«@DQVLFKIU*RWWVHOEVWQLFKWQRWZHQGLJ³JHZHVHQ ZlUH$OOGLHV]XVDPPHQ GDVVGHU0HQVFKHLQ*RWWLP*UXQGHQXUDN]LGHQ]L HOODEHUNHLQHVIDOOVVXEVWDQ]LHOOEHWUHIIHQGHV*HJHQEHUGDUVWHOOWZHLO*RWWLQ VLFKVHOEVWVFKRQDQGHUVJHQXJLVW GDVVGHU0HQVFKQXUHLQ0RPHQWLP3UR]HVV YRQ*RWWHV=XVLFKVHOEVW.RPPHQGDUVWHOOW XQGGDVV*RWWHVXUVlFKOLFKHÃ+HLOV WDWµDP(QGHGRFKDXFKNRQWLQJHQ]EHKDIWHWLVW±DOOGLHV]XVDPPHQJHQRPPHQ OlVVWGLH)UDJHDXINRPPHQREGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWWZLUN OLFKKlOWZDVVLHYHUVSULFKW6LHWULWWDQDXVGHUDPELYDOHQWHQ6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJ ]XEHIUHLHQGHUGHU0HQVFKDQJHVLFKWVGHVQLHDXVJHPDFKWHQ=XWHLOZHUGHQV HUVWUHEWHUVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJDXVJHVHW]WLVW$EHUVLHOlVVWYRUGHP+LQWHU JUXQGYRQ-QJHOV*RWWHVEHJULIIEHWUDFKWHWGHQ0HQVFKHQHEHQVRZHQLJHWZDV 6HOEVWlQGLJ(LJHQHVVHLQZLHVLHEHUMHGHQ9HUGDFKWYRQ:LOONUHUKDEHQLVW E 'LH3DVVLYLWlWGHV0HQVFKHQLP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ 'HUDQGHUH$VSHNWGHQ-QJHOLQGHUVRODJUDWLD3DUWLNHOLPSOL]LHUWVLHKWLVWGHU GDVVVLHÄGHQ0HQVFKHQLQSRLQWLHUWH:HLVHDOVHLQHDNWLYDQVHLQHU5HFKWIHUWL JXQJEHWHLOLJWH*U|H³DXVVFKOLHWZHLOGHUDOOHLQZLUNVDPH*RWWEHLLKPÄDQ QLFKWVDQNQSIHQ>NDQQ@>«@DOVDOOHLQDQVHLQH6QGH³'LHDXVVHLQHU6LFKW RKQH*RWWYRUKHUUVFKHQGHDPELYDOHQWH6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJGHUNRQWLQJHQW]XWHLO ZHUGHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ$QGHUHUDXI*HGHLKXQG9HUGHUEDXVJHVHW]W]XVHLQ OlVVWVLFKGRFKDEHUZLHJHVDJWVHKUJXWDOVHLQ$QNQSIXQJVSXQNWIUGLHJ|WW OLFKH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJLQWHUSUHWLHUHQ1XUGXUFK*RWWVHOEVWNDQQGDV*RWWHVYHU KlOWQLVGHV0HQVFKHQ±XQGGDVEHGHXWHWIU-QJHOHEHQLPPHU]XJOHLFK VHLQ 6HOEVWXQG:HOWYHUKlOWQLV±]XUHFKWJHEUDFKWZHUGHQÄ'HU0HQVFKKLQJHJHQ³ LVWLP6LQQHGHVVRODJUDWLDÄWDWVlFKOLFKUHLQSDVVLY PHUHSDVVLYH DQVHLQHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJEHWHLOLJW³(UVFKHLQWHVDEHUQLFKWK|FKVWZLGHUVSUFKOLFKYRQ %HWHLOLJWVHLQ]XUHGHQZRDXVVFKOLHOLFK3DVVLYLWlWDQJHVDJWLVW"Ä(VJLEWK|FKVW XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH :HLVHQ YRQ 3DVVLYLWlW³ UlXPW -QJHO HLQ XP VRJOHLFK GLH Ä3DVVLYLWlWWRWHQ0DWHULDOV³DOVGLHLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJJHPHLQWH9DULDQWH DXV]XVFKOLHHQ:RUDXIHUKLQDXVZLOOVROOYLHOPHKUGHU$XVGUXFNÄNUHDWLYH>@ 3DVVLYLWlW³ ]XU6SUDFKHEULQJHQ'DPLWVLQGZLH-QJHODQGHUQRUWVDXVIKUW (UIDKUXQJHQTXDOLIL]LHUWLQGHQHQÄLFKGHVVHQLQQHZHUGHGDLFKPLFKVHOEHU HPSIDQJHGDLFKHLQPLWPLUVHOEVW%HJDEWHUELQ³ZDVHLQHP%HZXVVWZHUGHQ
9JO-h1*(/ II 08550$11.$+/ -h1*(/ D $D2$QP9JOGLHVH6WHOOHLQVJHVDPW]XU3DVVLYLWlWVWKHPDWLN (EG (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHUHLJHQHQ*HVFK|SIOLFKNHLWJOHLFKNRPPW'LHGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH$XVVDJH Ä>G@DGHU0HQVFKSULPlU>DOV@YRQVHLQHP6FK|SIHU>«@DQHUNDQQWHV*HVFK|SI H[LVWLHUW³ZRUDXVVLFKIULKQGDV5HFKWHUJLEWÄGLHVHVVHLQ>«@$QHUNDQQWVHLQ LQVHLQHP9HUKlOWQLV]XVLFKVHOEVWQDFK]XYROO]LHKHQ³YHUZHLVWDXIGHQNUHD WLYHQ&KDUDNWHUGHUJHPHLQWHQ3DVVLYLWlW$XVGHP%HZXVVWVHLQRKQHHLJHQHV =XWXQ UHLQ SDVVLY DOV 0HQVFK DQHUNDQQW ]X VHLQ VROO GDQQ GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHV GHPHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ /HEHQVYROO]XJV HUZDFKVHQ GHU HEHQ QLFKW DXI GLH .RQVWLWXWLRQGHVHLJHQHQ0HQVFKVVHLQVDE]LHOWZHLOPDQÃMDVFKRQHWZDVµLVW .UHDWLYH3DVVLYLWlWPHLQWDOVRHLQH$UWYRQ3DVVLYLWlWGLH$NWLYLWlWVSRWHQ]LDOH IUHLVHW]WDEHUHEHQ]XQlFKVWHLQPDOUHLQH3DVVLYLWlWLVW :DUXP]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHU$NWLYLWlWXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU3DVVLYLWlWLP5HFK WIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQGHXWOLFK]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQLVWPDFKW-QJHODQGHU'LIIH UHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ GHP UHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ XQG GHP WULGHQWLVFKHQ E]Z U|PLVFK NDWKROLVFKHQ*QDGHQXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVYHUVWlQGQLVGHXWOLFK6ROODXVGHULP 6LQQHGHU5HIRUPDWRUHQ]XEHVWUHLWHQGHQ6LFKWÄGHP0HQVFKHQHLQHIUHLHZLO OHQWOLFKH $QQDKPH GHU *QDGH >«@ P|JOLFK VHLQ³ JLOW -QJHO ]XIROJH VFKRQ ÄQDFKELEOLVFKHU(LQVLFKW>«@GD)UHLKHLWDQWKURSRORJLVFKQXUGXUFK%HIUHLXQJ HLQIKUEDULVW³(UVWGLHJQDGHQYROOH=XZHQGXQJ*RWWHV]XP0HQVFKHQO|VW GLHVHQDOVRDXVGHU.QHFKWVFKDIWGHU6QGHGLHHVLKPXQP|JOLFKPDFKWLQ HLJHQVWlQGLJHU)UHLKHLWGDV9HUKlOWQLV]X*RWW]XU:HOWXQG]XVLFKVHOEVWLQ 2UGQXQJ]XEULQJHQ1LFKWHLQhEHUEOHLEVHOYRQ6FK|SIXQJVJQDGHGDVVLFKLQ HLQHP5HVWYRQ:LOOHQVIUHLKHLWQLHGHUVFKOlJWLVWGHU$QNQSIXQJVSXQNWJ|WWOL FKHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJQDGHVRQGHUQGLHVHWULIIWGHQ0HQVFKHQÄDOVJUDWLDH[WHU QD³'HQQRFKWULIIWVLHLKQZLH-QJHOIRUWIKUWÄLP=HQWUXPVHLQHU([LV WHQ]³ ZHLO VLH ÄLKP >«@ QlKHU NRPPW DOV HU VLFK VHOEHU QDFK ]X VHLQ YHU PDJ³ZDVGRFKHLQPDOPHKUQDFKYRUDXV]XVHW]HQGHQ(UIDKUXQJHQHLQHV0LW VLFKLP8QUHLQHQ6HLQVIUDJHQOlVVW'DVVDXVWULGHQWLQLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHGLH J|WWOLFKH*QDGHHUVWGDZLUNOLFK]XP=XJHNRPPW ZRVLHVLFKLQ7DWHQGHU /LHEHPDQLIHVWLHUWJLEWLKU-QJHO]XIROJHHLQHJURH$IILQLWlW]XPWDWIL[LHUWHQ 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVGHVQHX]HLWOLFKHQ0HQVFKHQ'LHÄELEOLVFKH>@%HKDXSWXQJGHU 0HQVFKVHL*RWWJHJHQEHUHLQ1LFKWKDQGHOQGHU³VW|WGHVKDOEZHLWHQWHLOVDXI WDXEH2KUHQZHVKDOEGDV:RUWYRQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJLPPHUZLHGHUQHX]X *HK|U]XEULQJHQLVW
-h1*(/L $D2 -h1*(/ D $D2 (EG $D2
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
6RORYHUERRGHU 'LH([WHUQLWlWJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'LH([NOXVLYSDUWLNHOVRORYHUEREULQJWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQGHQEOHLEHQGHQÄ([ WHUQLWlWVEH]XJGHVJHUHFKWIHUWLJWHQ6QGHUV]X*HOWXQJ³(VLVWHLQLKPYRQ DXHQ]XNRPPHQGHV8UWHLOGDV]XGHPQLFKWVHLQHUHLJHQHQ*HUHFKWLJNHLWVRQ GHUQGHUHLQHVDQGHUHQQlPOLFK&KULVWLJLOWZRGXUFKHULQGHQ6WDWXVGHV*H UHFKWHQHUKREHQZLUG-QJHOPDFKWVLFKKLHUGLHUHIRUPDWRULVFKHEHVRQGHUV GXUFK0HODQFKWKRQIRUFLHUWH$XIIDVVXQJGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDOVHLQHVIRUHQVLVFK LPSXWDWLYHQ$NWHV]XHLJHQGLHHEHQZLHYRU*HULFKWGHQ6QGHUJHUHFKWVSULFKW LQGHPVLHLKPGLH*HUHFKWLJNHLW&KULVWL]XVSULFKWRGHUDQUHFKQHW:DVGDPLWLQ -QJHOV$XJHQ]XUHFKWDXVJHVFKORVVHQZLUGLVWQHEHQGHU$NWLYLWlWGHV0HQ VFKHQYRUDOOHPVHLQ9HUP|JHQVLFKGLHLXVWLWLDDOLHQDYROONRPPHQDQ]XHLJQHQ 'LHVDEHUEHVWLPPWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQMHGZHGH)RUPYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJGLHVWHWV GLH%H]LHKXQJ]XHLQHP$QGHUHQYRUDXVVHW]WXQGÄGHVKDOEQLHPDOVYRQGHP >«@$QHUNDQQWHQDOV%HVLW]ÃJHKDEWµZHUGHQ³NDQQ9LHOPHKUÃKDWµHUVLHQXU LQGHPHUHLQHGHPMHZHLOLJHQ9HUKlOWQLVJHPlH$QWZRUWJLEWGLHLP)DOOHGHV JHUHFKWIHUWLJWHQ6QGHUVHEHQJHUDGHGDULQEHVWHKWVLFKDXIGLHLKQRQWRORJLVFK EHVWLPPHQGH5HODWLRQGLH5HODWLRQ*RWWHV]XLKPKLQ]XEHUVFKUHLWHQÄ'HU 6QGHULVWDXHUKDOEVHLQHUVHOEVWJHUHFKW³ ]LWLHUW-QJHO/XWKHUV5|PHUEULHI YRUOHVXQJ'RFKYHUZLUIWHUGLH$QQDKPHHVKLHUPLWHLQHPGHP0HQVFKHQUHLQ lXHUOLFKHQ *HVFKHKHQ ]X WXQ ]X KDEHQ 9LHOPHKU LVW GLH *HUHFKWVSUHFKXQJ ]XJOHLFKHIIHNWLY Ä,VWGHU6QGHUGXUFK*RWWHV>«@:RUW>«@DOV*HUHFKWHU DQHUNDQQW GDQQ JLOW HU QLFKW QXU DOV JHUHFKW VRQGHUQ GDQQ LVW HU DXFK JH UHFKW³'LH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWWKDWDOVRHLQHHIIHNWLYH E]ZNRQVWLWXLHUHQGH:LUNXQJ 6LHEHVWlWLJWDP0HQVFKHQZDVVLHVHOEVWKHU YRUEULQJWRGHUKHUYRUJHEUDFKWKDW6LHLVWZLH-QJHOPLW$OEUHFKW5LWVFKO KHUDXVVWHOOWHLQV\QWKHWLVFKHV8UWHLOGDVGHP6QGHUHLQ3UlGLNDW]XVSULFKWGDV LP%HJULIIYRQLKPQRFKQLFKWHQWKDOWHQLVW D 'LH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJGHVQHXHQYRPDOWHQ0HQVFKHQ (IIHNWLYLVWGLHVLPJ|WWOLFKHQ:RUWHUJHKHQGH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLOGHVKDOE ZHLOHVGHQ0HQVFKHQVRÄDXI-HVXV&KULVWXV³EH]LHKWGDVVHUÄDQGHVVHQ*H VFKLFKWH$QWHLOEHNRPPWXQG]ZDUVRZRKODQVHLQHP7RGDOVDXFKDQVHLQHU $XIHUVWHKXQJ³'LHVHV,GHQWLIL]LHUWZHUGHQPLWGHP*HNUHX]LJWHQXQG$XIHU
9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPWDD2 ± $D2 (EG /87+(5 I -h1*(/ D 9JO ]XU ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GHV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLOV DOV HLQHV V\QWKHWLVFKHQ 8UWHLOV 5,76&+/ -h1*(/ DI
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VWDQGHQHQKDWGHQ&KDUDNWHUHLQHUFUHDWLRH[QLKLORZHLOGLH.RQWLQXLWlW]ZL VFKHQEHLGHQ6WDWXVQXUGXUFK*RWWDXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQ ZLUG6REHZLUNW Ä>G@DV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLO>«@HLQHWLHIJUHLIHQGH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ 6HLQV LQDOWHQXQGQHXHQ0HQVFKHQlXHUHQXQGLQQHUHQ0HQVFKHQ)OHLVFK XQG*HLVW([LVWHQ]XQWHUGHP*HVHW]XQGXQWHUGHU*QDGHHWF³'DVOXWKHU VFKHVLPXOLXVWXVHWSHFFDWRUEULQJWGDEHL]XP$XVGUXFNGDVVGHU0HQVFKVWHWV EHLGHV]XJOHLFKLVWZDV-QJHOWHPSRUDOLQWHUSUHWLHUW:DVHLQDQGHUHQWJHJHQJH VHW]WZLUGLVWDOVRMHZHLOVGDVGXUFKGLH9HUJDQJHQKHLWXQGGDVGXUFKGLH=X NXQIWEHVWLPPWH6HLQGHV0HQVFKHQÄ9RQVHLQHU9HUJDQJHQKHLWEHVWLPPWZHU GHQKHLW³IU-QJHO Ä,FKELQGDQQJHQDXHEHQGDVZDVLFKXQGZDVDQGHUH PLWLKUHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ DXVPLUJHPDFKWKDEHQ LFKELQZDVLFK±XQGQLFKWQXU LFK±WDW³'HPJHJHQEHUEHGHXWHWHV >Y@RQGHU=XNXQIWDXV*RWWEHVWLPPWZHUGHQ>«@ ,FKELQ>«@JHQDXGDVZDV*RWWHV:RUW DXVPLUPDFKW,FKELQ>«@LQPLWWHQGHVXQO|VEDUHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJVYRQ3HUVRQXQG:HUN YRQDOOHQPHLQHQ:HUNHQXQGYRQDOOHQ:HUNHQXQG:LUNXQJHQDQGHUHU0HQVFKHQ0HQ VFKHQJUXSSHQXQGLKUHU,QVWLWXWLRQHQGHUDUWXQWHUVFKLHGHQGDQLFKWPHKUGDV:HUNGLH3HU VRQNRQVWLWXLHUWVRQGHUQGLH3HUVRQIUHLZLUG]XPYHUDQWZRUWOLFKHQ7XQ
'RFKLVWGHU0HQVFKHEHQLPPHUEHLGHV 6QGHUXQG*HUHFKWHUDOWHUXQGQHXHU LQZHQGLJHUXQGlXHUHU0HQVFKZDVVHLQ'DVHLQLQHLQHSURGXNWLYH6SDQQXQJ YHUVHW]W GLH VFKOLHOLFK DXFK SUDNWLVFKH .RQVHTXHQ]HQ ]HLWLJW 'LH J|WWOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJXQWHUVFKHLGHWLKQYRQGHPZDVHUVHOEVWXQGDQGHUHDXVLKPPD FKHQXQGJHPDFKWKDEHQE]ZZDVHULP5DKPHQVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJLVWXQG VHLQVROO'HQQRFKEOHLEWHUGDULQDOVÃDOWHU0HQVFKµHLQJHEXQGHQZDVGHPPLW *RWWYHUEXQGHQHQ6HOEVWVHLQHLQNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHV*HSUlJHJLEW E 'LH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJGHVDQJHVSURFKHQHQYRPDXVVDJHQGHQ0HQVFKHQ 'LHVH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQDOWHPXQGQHXHP0HQVFKHQNDQQ-QJHOJDQ]LP 6LQQHGHVVRORYHUERDXFKLQHLQHUPHKUVSUDFKWKHRUHWLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHH[SOL ]LHUHQ'HPQDFKLVWGHU0HQVFKÄVRZRKOHLQDQJHVSURFKHQHVDOVDXFKHLQDXV VDJHQGHV:HVHQ³$OVDXVVDJHQGHV:HVHQGLHQWLKPGLH6SUDFKHÄ]XU9HUDU EHLWXQJGHU:HOWGXUFK$EELOGXQJGHU:LUNOLFKNHLWLQ=HLFKHQ³6LHJHZLQQW GDEHLKHUUVFKDIWOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHUZHLOVLHGDV'HQNHQ]XPGHILQLWRULVFKHQ$XI GHQ%HJULII%ULQJHQRGHUWKHRUHWLVFKHQ'XUFKVFKDXHQDOOHVZHOWKDIW%HJHJQHQ GHQDQOHLWHW'DUDXVZLHGHUXPHUZlFKVWÄGLHPHQVFKOLFKH7DW³ DOV9HUZLUNOL
'HUFUHDWLRH[QLKLOR*HGDQNHLVWIU-QJHOGDVRQWRORJLVFKH.HUQVWFNGHU5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVOHKUH 9JO-h1*(/G± -h1*(/ D (EG $D2 I -h1*(/H9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2± $D2 (EG
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
FKXQJGHULP=XVDPPHQVSLHOYRQ6SUDFKHXQG'HQNHQEHJULIIOLFKHQWZRUIHQHQ :HOW'LHVHU]XVROFKPDFKWYROOHP7XQIKUHQGH$XVVDJHFKDUDNWHUPHQVFKOL FKHU6SUDFKHLVWDXV-QJHOV6LFKWQLFKWSHUVH]XYHUXUWHLOHQVRQGHUQWKHROR JLVFKDOV,PSOLNDWGHU*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQDQ]XVHKHQ-HGRFK PDFKWHUDXI]ZHLSRWHQ]LHOOH*HIDKUHQDXIPHUNVDPGHUHQ(LQWUHWHQOHJLWLPH +HUUVFKDIW]XUVHOEVW]HUVW|UHULVFKHQ+\EULVZHUGHQOlVVW'DLVWHLQHUVHLWVÄGLHLQ GHU$XVVDJHVWUXNWXUGHU6SUDFKHDQJHOHJWH7HQGHQ]]XUWRWDOHQ9HUDUEHLWXQJGHU :HOW³]XQHQQHQGLHGDQQÄJDQ]XQGJDU]XHLQHP:HUNGHV0HQVFKHQ]XULQ MHGHU+LQVLFKWKHUJHVWHOOWHQ]XUNQVWOLFKHQ:HOW³ ZLUG-QJHOIJWLP%OLFN DXIGLHHLJHQH*HJHQZDUWKLQ]X Ä>:@HLWKLQOHEHQZLUEHUHLWVLQHLQHU:HOWDXI GHP:HJHGRUWKLQ³ 1HEHQGLHVHUGHVWUXNWLYHQ)ROJHLP%H]XJDXIGLH:HOW ]XGHUVLFKGHUDXVVDJHQGH0HQVFKYHUKlOWOlVVWVLFKDQGHUHUVHLWVHLQHIUGLHVHQ VHOEVWJHIlKUOLFKH7HQGHQ]DQ]HLJHQÄ'HUGHPKHUUVFKDIWOLFKHQ*UXQG]XJGHU 6SUDFKHIROJHQGH0HQVFKPXWlWLJZHUGHQ³]XPDODOV7HLOGHUÄLQGHU6SUDFKH VR]LDOLVLHUWH>Q@0HQVFKKHLW³ 'LHVHUVFKLHUXQHQWULQQEDUH=ZDQJDEHUVFKOlJW DXILKQ]XUFNXQGEHJLQQWGLHZHOWEHKHUUVFKHQGH0HQVFKKHLWVHOEVW]XEHKHUU VFKHQ$XVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWJHVFKLHKWGDULQGDVZDVGLHKDUPDWLRORJLVFKHQ $XVIKUXQJHQEHUHLWVJH]HLJWKDEHQ 'XUFKGHQ=ZDQJ]XP3URGX]LHUHQZHUGHQ GLH:HUNHGHV0HQVFKHQ]XPDOOHVHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ0DVWDEDQGHPVLFK:HUW RGHU8QZHUWVHLQHUVHOEVWEHPHVVHQ $QGLHVHU6WHOOHZRGHU$XVVDJHFKDUDNWHUPHQVFKOLFKHU6SUDFKHYHUDEVROX WLHUW]XZHUGHQGURKWEULQJW-QJHOGHVVHQDQGHUHV6WUXNWXUPHUNPDOGDV$Q JHVSURFKHQVHLQ]XP7UDJHQ$XVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWNRPPWHVIULKQGDUDXI DQGDVVWHWHÄ=XJOHLFKGLHVHUEHLGHQ*UXQG]JHLPVSUDFKOLFKHQ:HVHQGHV 0HQVFKHQ³ QLFKWPLWLKUHU*OHLFKXUVSUQJOLFKNHLW]XYHUZHFKVHOQ9LHOPHKU LVW GDV $QJHVSURFKHQVHLQ HEHQVR DOV 0|JOLFKNHLWVEHGLQJXQJ GHV $XVVDJHQV DQ]XVHKHQZLHDXVVHLQHPSULPlUHQ&KDUDNWHUGDV3RWHQ]LDOHUZlFKVWGHQHEHQ EHVFKULHEHQHQ GHVWUXNWLYHQ 7HQGHQ]HQ ]X WURW]HQ :LH -QJHO QlPOLFK HLQ VFKlUIWLVWÄ>G@HU0HQVFK>«@HLQGXUFKGDV:RUWNRQVWLWXLHUWHVXQGRUJDQLVLHU WHV:HVHQ³GDVQXUZHLOHVÄK|UHQNDQQ>«@]XVSUHFKHQ]XGHQNHQ]XKDQ GHOQXQGGDULQPHQVFKOLFK]XVHLQ³YHUPDJ 1RFKWKHRORJLVFKHUDXVJHGUFNW Ä>'@HU0HQVFK>LVW@SULPlUGDVYRQ*RWWDQJHVSURFKHQH:HVHQ³ 'DVVGDV 9HUKlOWQLV *RWWHV ]XP 0HQVFKHQ -QJHO ]XIROJH DOOHP PHQVFKOLFKHQ ,QV 9HUKlOWQLV7UHWHQYRUDXVJHKWZXUGHEHUHLWVLP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU6FK|SIXQJV WKHPDWLNGHXWOLFK6HLQUHODWLRQDOHU3HUVRQEHJULIIOLHDQDORJGD]XGDV6HOEVW YHUKlOWQLV DXV GHP :HOWYHUKlOWQLV KHUYRUJHKHQ 'DVV GHU 0HQVFK YRU DOOHP
$D2 (EG $D2 $D2 $D2 I $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$XVVDJHQHLQ$QJHVSURFKHQHULVWEHNRPPWEHL-QJHOHEHQIDOOVHLQHVR]LDO E]ZVR]LDOLVDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKH3RLQWHZHQQHUVFKUHLEW Ä.HLQ0HQVFKNDQQ YRQVLFKDXVVSUHFKHQ(UPX]XYRUK|UHQXQGDOVREHYRUHUVHQGHWVHOEHU HPSIDQJHQ³ %LOGHW 6SUDFKIlKLJNHLW VLFK LQ 3UR]HVVHQ VR]LDOHU ,QWHUDNWLRQ DOOHUHUVWKHUDXVNRPPWGLH$NWLRQVDUWGHV$XVVDJHQVDOVHWZDV6HNXQGlUHV]X VWHKHQ6LHLVWVRJHVHKHQLQLKUHU*HQHVHGDYRQDEKlQJLJGDVVÄVLFK0HQVFKHQ DOV$QJHUHGHWHZDKUQHKPHQ³ XQGHVLP:LVVHQXPLKUH$QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXI HLQVROFKHV*HJHQEHUNRPPXQLNDWLYGDUDXIDQOHJHQGHQMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ]XP HLJHQHQ6SUHFKHQ]XEHIlKLJHQ-QJHOVLHKWLQGLHVHUGHUVSUDFKOLFKHQ,QWHUDNWL RQHLJQHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVVWUXNWXUGDV,GHDOHLQHUÄ6SUDFKHGHU/LHEH³ DQJH OHJW GLHHLQ SRWHQ]LHOOHV :LGHUODJHU JHJHQ 7RWDOLVLHUXQJHQ GHV DXVVDJHQGHQ :HOWEH]XJVELOGHW$OOHUGLQJVVWHKWGHPGLHOlQJVW5HDOLWlWJHZRUGHQH*HIDKU HQWJHJHQ ÄGD GHU 0HQVFK VLFK QLFKW PHKU DXV GHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ VHLQHU :HUNH GHU3URGXNWLRQ O|VHQNDQQ³ XQGPLWGHQ5HVXOWDWHQVHLQHUVSUDFKOLFK JHVWHXHUWHQ :LUNOLFKNHLWVYHUDUEHLWXQJ LGHQWLVFK ZLUG :DV EHGHXWHW HV ZLH -QJHOHLQHUDP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHGDQNHQRULHQWLHUWHQ7KHRORJLHDEIRUGHUWDQ GLHVHU6WHOOHÄGDUDQ]XHULQQHUQGDGHU0HQVFKSULPlUGDVYRQ*RWWDQJHVSUR FKHQH:HVHQLVW³" (ULQQHUW ZHUGHQ VROO GDGXUFK GLH LP VHOEVWLVFKHQ 'UDQJ ]XU :HOWEHKHUU VFKXQJYHUVFKWWJHKHQGH$QJHZLHVHQKHLWGHU3HUVRQDXIGDV$QGHUHLKUHUVHOEVW XQWHUGHVVHQ$XVVFKOXVVVLHVLFKYHUIHKOW*RWWJHZLVVHUPDHQDOV,QEHJULIIHLQHV VROFKHV$QGHUHQYRUVWHOOLJ]XPDFKHQLVWGLH,QWHQWLRQGHVÄ:RUW>V@GHU5HFK WIHUWLJXQJ³(VÄJLEWGHP0HQVFKHQHLQLKQDQUHGHQGHV*HJHQEHU³GDVLKQ ÄLQPLWWHQGHVXQDXIO|VOLFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJVYRQ3HUVRQXQG:HUNYRQ3HUVRQ XQG3URGXNWLRQQRFKHLQPDODOVHLQ,FK6HOEVWXQWHUVFKHLGHW³XQGGDPLWÄWURW] VHLQHU:HUNHDOV3HUVRQ>«@DQHUNHQQWXQGJHOWHQOlW³5HVXOWDWGLHVHUJ|WW OLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJLVWMHGRFKQLFKWGLH$XIKHEXQJGHVÄ=XVDPPHQKDQJVYRQ 3HUVRQXQG:HUN³VRQGHUQGDV(QGHGHUÄ+HUUVFKDIWGHV:HUNHVEHUGLH3HU VRQ³9RQVLFKVHOEVWDOVGXUFKVHLQHWlWLJHQbXHUXQJHQDXFKZHLWHUKLQLGHQ WLIL]LHUEDUH3HUVRQQRFKHLQPDOXQWHUVFKLHGHQZLUGGHU0HQVFKDOVRLQPLWWHQ GLHVHVVHLQHVIDNWLVFKHQ6RVHLQVLQHLQGHPJHJHQEHUIUHLHVNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHV $QGHUVVHLQYRU*RWWYHUVHW]W'LHVHU*HGDQNHLVWGDVJURH3OXVYRQ-QJHOV 3RVLWLRQGHUHQ]XJOHLFKSUREOHPDWLVFKHU&KDUDNWHUDEHULP)ROJHQGHQZLHGHUDQ GLH2EHUIOlFKHWULWW
-h1*(/F -h1*(/H (EG (EG (EG (EG (EG (EG
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
6RODILGHRGHU 'LH$QHUNHQQXQJJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'XUFKGDVVRODILGHVLHKW-QJHOIHVWJHKDOWHQZLHGHUELVODQJDOVUHLQSDVVLY± ÄPHUHSDVVLYH³±HUVFKLHQHQH0HQVFKDXFKDNWLYDP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ SDUWL]LSLHUW:LHDEHULVWGLHVYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHV*HVDJWHQEHUKDXSWP|J OLFK"=XJODXEHQVRZXUGHEHUHLWVGHXWOLFKEHGHXWHWIU-QJHOQLFKWVDQGHUVDOV VLFKDQHUNHQQHQ]XODVVHQGDVJ|WWOLFKH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLODOVRLQVHLJHQH 6HOEVWXUWHLO]XEHUQHKPHQZREHLDEHUJLOW Ä*RWWLVWHVGHUVLFK]XHUNHQQHQ JLEWXQGVLFKDQHUNHQQHQOlW³:RGLHVGHQ0HQVFKHQHUIDVVWGDNRPPWHV ]XPÄ*ODXEH>Q@³DOVGHPÄ-DGHV0HQVFKHQ>«@]XGHULKPLP(UHLJQLVVHLQHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJZLGHUIDKUHQGHQGHILQLWLYHQ%HMDKXQJGXUFK*RWWXQG]XVHLQHU XPGLHVHUVHLQHUGHILQLWLYHQ%HMDKXQJZLOOHQLQ-HVXV&KULVWLDXVJHVSURFKHQHQ XQGYROOVWUHFNWHQ9HUQHLQXQJGXUFK*RWW³ D 'HU*ODXEHDOV%HMDKXQJYRUJlQJLJHQ%HMDKWVHLQV 6LFKEHMDKHQDOVGHILQLWLYEHMDKWZLHHVDQ3DXO7LOOLFKHULQQHUQGIRUPXOLHUW ZHUGHQNDQQRGHUVLFKDQHUNHQQHQDOVGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQW±GDVLVWGHUVXEMHNWL YH9ROO]XJGHQ-QJHOYRU$XJHQKDWZHQQHVXPGHQ*ODXEHQJHKW+LQ]X NRPPWDEHUVHLQ+LQZHLVGDUDXIGDVVGLHGDV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLOVLFK]XHL JHQPDFKHQGH6HOEVWDIILUPDWLRQGHV*ODXEHQGHQ]XJOHLFKHLQH6HOEVWQHJDWLRQ LVW/HW]WHUHEHWULIIWGHQ0HQVFKHQDOV6QGHU]XGHVVHQ(LJHQDUWHVLQVEHVRQGH UHJHK|UWVLFKDQGHU%HJUQGXQJVHLQHUVHOEVW]XYHUVXFKHQ9RUGLHVHP+LQ WHUJUXQG YHUELHWHW HV VLFK IU -QJHO JHUDGH]X ÄGHQ *ODXEHQ DOV *UXQGDNW PHQVFKOLFKHU )UHLKHLW³ ]X EHJUHLIHQ RGHU DOV ÄGLHMHQLJH PHQVFKOLFKH (QW VFKHLGXQJVWDW>]X@YHUVWHKHQ>«@LQGHUGDVQHXH,FKDQVWHOOHGHVDOWHQVLFK NRQVWLWXLHUW³ 9LHOPHKULQWHUSUHWLHUWÄ>Z@HUVRIRUPXOLHUW>«@GHQ5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVJODXEHQLP6FKHPDGHVWUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ,GHDOLVPXV.DQWVXQG)LFKWHV XQGYHUIHKOWGDPLWHLQZHVHQWOLFKHV0HUNPDOGHVUHFKWIHUWLJHQGHQ*ODXEHQV³ ,VW GLHVHU QlPOLFK GLH PHQVFKOLFKH =XVWLPPXQJ ]XP J|WWOLFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVXUWHLONDQQHUQXUDOVH[LVWHQ]LHOOHU1DFKYROO]XJGHULQ&KULVWXVOlQJVW JHVFKHKHQHQ1HXNRQVWLWXWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQGLHGDPLWGHP 9ROO]XJGHV*ODXEHQVYRUJlQJLJLVW(UÄLVWLQVRIHUQGLH6HOEVWHQWGHFNXQJXQG 6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJGHV=XU)UHLKHLWEHIUHLWZRUGHQ6HLQV³XQGNHLQYRUDXVVHW ]XQJVORVHU$NWGHU)UHLKHLWGHUXQDEKlQJLJYRP%HVWLPPWVHLQGXUFK*RWWEHU
9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPW -h1*(/ D± 672/,1$ -h1*(/ D 'HQ*ODXEHQEH]HLFKQHW3DXO7LOOLFKLQ'HU0XW]XP6HLQDOVÄ0XWVLFK]XEHMDKHQDOV EHMDKW³ YJO7,//,&+ ± -h1*(/ D $D2 (EG $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHVVHQ8UWHLOHLQH(QWVFKHLGXQJIlOOHQN|QQWH6RDEHUZLUGGHU$NWGHU$QHLJ QXQJGHUHLQ6LFK$QHLJQHQ.|QQHQLPSOL]LHUWOHW]WHQ(QGHV]XPEORHQ9H KLNHOJ|WWOLFKHQ7XQV Ä'HU*ODXEHHUNHQQWDOVRDQGDEHUGDV6HLQGHV0HQVFKHQLQGHU3HUVRQ -HVX&KULVWLVFKRQHQWVFKLHGHQZRUGHQLVW³±DQGLHVHU(QWVFKHLGXQJLVWHU DEHULQNHLQHU:HLVHEHWHLOLJWVRQGHUQVLHLVWEHUKDXSWHUVWGLH(UP|JOLFKXQJ HLQHU2IIHQKHLWGHVDXIVLFKVHOEVWEH]RJHQHQVQGLJHQ0HQVFKHQIU*RWW6R LVWGDV-DGHV0HQVFKHQ]X*RWW]XJOHLFKGDV(LQJHVWlQGQLVÄGDHU]XVHLQHP -DDOOHUHUVWEHIUHLWZHUGHQPXWHXQGEHIUHLWZRUGHQLVW³±HLQ(LQJHVWlQGQLV GDVIUHLOLFKHLQHQUHWURVSHNWLYHQ'HXWXQJVDNWGDUVWHOOWKLQWHUGHQVFKOHFKWHU GLQJVQLFKW]XUFNJHJDQJHQZHUGHQNDQQ'LH1HJDWLRQGHVYRUKHUJHKHQGHQDOV VQGLJTXDOLIL]LHUWHQ6HLQVEULQJW-QJHODXFKGDGXUFK]XP$XVGUXFNGDVVHU GHQ *ODXEHQ DOV Ä8UDNW HLQHU DXVJHVSURFKHQ HN]HQWULVFKHQ ([LVWHQ]³ EH JUHLIW'HUEHMDKHQGH1DFKYROO]XJVHLQHV.RQVWLWXLHUWZHUGHQVGXUFKJ|WWOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJEHNRPPWGDEHLGHQ&KDUDNWHUHLQHUUHJHOUHFKWHQ6HOEVWEHUZLQ GXQJGLHVLFKÄLQ.RQIRUPLWlW]XGHULKPJHOWHQGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJ³ YROO]LHKW'LHVHGHUSHUVRQDOHQ9HUIDVVWKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQHQWVSUHFKHQGH([WHU QLWlWVEH]RJHQKHLWZLUGGXUFK*RWWHUP|JOLFKWGHUGHP0HQVFKHQDOVHLQYHU WUDXHQVYROOHV*HJHQEHUPLWHLQGHXWLJSRVLWLYHQ,QWHQWLRQHQJHJHQEHUWULWWXQG VR9HUWUDXHQXQG+HLOVJHZLVVKHLWVWLIWHWZDVMHJOLFKHÄ9HUZHUIXQJVVNUXSHO³ DXVVFKOLHW'HQQGLHLKP]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGHXQGYRQLKPEHMDKWH$QHUNHQ QXQJGXUFK*RWWHQWKlOWHEHQÄGLH*HZLKHLWYRQ*RWWLQV5HFKWJHVHW]WZRUGHQ ]XVHLQ LQGDV5HFKWDOV.LQGPLW*RWWDOV9DWHUXQYHUEUFKOLFK]XVDPPHQ]X VHLQ³'LHVHV=XVDPPHQVHLQLVWZLH-QJHOPLW%DUWKIHVWKlOWYRQHLQHUJH ZLVVHQ:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLWJHSUlJW 'HPQDFKKDWGHU0HQVFKÄ*RWWJHJHQEHULP JOHLFKHQ6LQQ.LQGHVUHFKWZLH*RWWLKPJHJHQEHU9DWHUUHFKWKDW³GKHULVW SHUJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJGD]XOHJLWLPLHUWÄ$OOHVGHVVHQHUEHGDUIYRQLKP ]XHUZDUWHQXQG]XHUELWWHQ³'HQXQZLGHUUXIOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHUÄ>G@LHVHV.LQ GHVUHFKW>V@³GDV%DUWKDQGHUYRQ-QJHO]XVWLPPHQG]LWLHUWHQ6WHOOHDOVÄ,QEH JULIIDOOHV0HQVFKHQUHFKWHV³ EH]HLFKQHWEULQJWGHU.LUFKOLFKH'RJPDWLNHU DQGHUQRUWVVRDXIGHQ3XQNW >'@DV5HFKW]XLKP]XVFKUHLHQ Ã$EED9DWHUµ *DO5|P GDVLVWGDV8QEHZHJOL FKHDQGDV>«@NHLQH3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJGXUFK8PVWlQGHXQG9HUKlOWQLVVHGXUFKGDV8UWHLO
(EG (EG (EG (EG $D2 -h1*(/ D %$57+ (EG
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
DQGHUHU0HQVFKHQRGHUDXFKGXUFKXQVHUHHLJHQHQ8QVLFKHUKHLWHQXQG=ZHLIHO>«@DXFKQXU KHUDQNRPPHQNDQQ
'DVXQVLFKHUPDFKHQGHÃ8UWHLODQGHUHU0HQVFKHQµXQG%HVWLPPWZHUGHQGXUFK Ã8PVWlQGHXQG9HUKlOWQLVVHµZLUGDOVRNUDIWXQEHGLQJWHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOV.LQG *RWWHVJUXQGVlW]OLFKUHODWLYLHUW E 'HU9HUSIOLFKWXQJVFKDUDNWHUGHV*ODXEHQV (LQHGXUFKQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQGHQEHLUUEDUH*HZLVVKHLWVROOGHPQDFKGHUJ|WWOL FKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQNRUUHVSRQGLHUHQGLHDEHUZLH-QJHOQXQ ZLHGHU HLQVFKlUIW QLFKW PLW HLQHU ÄVXEMHNWLYH>Q@ 6HOEVWYHUJHZLVVHUXQJ XQG 6HOEVWVLFKHUXQJ³]XYHUZHFKVHOQLVW8QWHU5HNXUVDXIGLHOXWKHUVFKH8QWHU VFKHLGXQJ YRQ DXI *RWW VHW]HQGHU FHUWLWXGR XQG QXU VLFK VHOEVW YHUWUDXHQGHU VHFXULWDV YHUZHLVW -QJHO HLQPDO PHKU DXI GHQ H[]HQWULVFKHQ &KDUDNWHU GHV *ODXEHQVGXUFKGHQGHU*ODXEHQGHÄIUHLYRQVLFKVHOEVWXQGLQVRIHUQVHOEVWYHU JHVVHQ³ZLUG'DVGHP0HQVFKHQ]XJHVWDQGHQH.LQGHVUHFKWHQWKlOWVRQDFK QLFKWQXUGLH%HIUHLXQJYRQKDXVJHPDFKWHQRGHUIUHPGLQGX]LHUWHQ6HOEVW]ZHL IHOQVRQGHUQJHZLVVHUPDHQDXFKGLH9HUSIOLFKWXQJ]XP*HKRUVDPJHJHQEHU GHP9DWHUGHUVHLQHUVHLWVVHLQHQ3IOLFKWHQQDFKJHNRPPHQLVW'LHVHUIOOWVLFK GXUFKGHQ*ODXEHQÄZHLOGHU*ODXEH*RWW*RWWVHLQXQGDOVR*RWWHV:LUNHQ]XU *HOWXQJ NRPPHQOlW³*RWWHV:LUNHQDEHUEHWULIIWQLFKWV ZHQLJHUDOVGLH .RQVWLWXWLRQGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ3HUVRQVHLQVDQGHUGHU*ODXEHÄQLFKWXQPLWWHO EDU³VRQGHUQÄQXULQVRIHUQPLWWHOEDU³EHWHLOLJWLVWDOVHUZLHGHUXPLQLWLLHUW GXUFK *RWW LKUHP ,PPHUVFKRQ*HVFKHKHQVHLQ ]XVWLPPW 'LHV JHVFKLHKW LP 6LQQHHLQHUÄZHFKVHOVHLWLJH>Q@9HULILNDWLRQ³ 'HUÄPHQVFKOLFKHQ(KUHUNOlUXQJ IUGHQZDKUKDIWLJHQ*RWW³HQWVSULFKWÄGLHJ|WWOLFKH(KUHUNOlUXQJIUGHQZDKU KDIWLJHQ0HQVFKHQ³XQGXPJHNHKUW'DEHLLVWHVGDVZLH-QJHOHVEH]HLFK QHQGHUZHLVHQHQQWÄH[NOXVLYH*RWWHVSUlGLNDWGHU)UHLKHLW³GDVMHW]WÄDOV$XV ]HLFKXQJGHV&KULVWHQPHQVFKHQEHDQVSUXFKWZHUGHQNDQQXQGPX³:LHVLFK GLHVHUJ|WWOLFKOHJLWLPLHUWH)UHLKHLWVDQVSUXFK]XUÄPRGHUQHQ)UHLKHLWVEHDQVSUX FKXQJ³YHUKlOWGLH-QJHOÄPHKURGHUZHQLJHUPRUDOLVFK>@>«@DOV6QGH³ ZHUWHWEOHLEWXQJHNOlUW 'LHVHJOlXELJH%HMDKXQJGHVLQ&KULVWXV*HVFKHKHQHQYROO]LHKWVLFKZLHJH VDJWLQ-QJHOV $XJHQDOVHLQ$NWGHU6HOEVWEHUZLQGXQJDOVHLQ$XVVLFK +HUDXVJHKHQGDVGLHH[WHUQH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHVHLJHQHQ'DVHLQVUDWLIL]LHUW%OHLEW
$D2 -h1*(/ D $D2 (EG (EG -h1*(/M $D2 I :,77(.,1'
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHU0HQVFKGDEHLDEHULPPHUQRFKGHUDOWHRGHUlXHUOLFKH0HQVFKZLUGHU ZLHDP(QGHGHVYRUKHULJHQ$EVFKQLWWVVFKRQDQJHGHXWHWLQHLQHSURGXNWLYH 'LIIHUHQ]YHUVHW]W $OV YRP :RUW *RWWHV XQPLWWHOEDU $QJHVSURFKHQHU LVW HU GDV :HVHQ GHU :HQGH GDV GD]X EHVWLPPWLVWLP*ODXEHQDQ-HVXV&KULVWXVDXFKVHLQHUVHLWVHLQQHXHU0HQVFK]XZHUGHQGHU QXUQRFKJHJHQGDVLKQXQPLWWHOEDUXQGXQEHGLQJWDQVSUHFKHQGXQGDQJHKHQGH:RUW*RWWHV HLQDOWHUVHLQH,QZHQGLJNHLWYRQLQQHQKHUDXVYHUIlOVFKHQGHU0HQVFKVHLQNDQQ
6HLQH[WHUQLQLWLLHUWHV1HXZHUGHQLP,QQHUHQPXVVVLFKDEHUDXFKLPbXHUHQ JHQDXHU LQ SUDNWLVFKHQ )ROJHQ ZLGHUVSLHJHOQ ZHQQ HV QLFKW GHQ &KDUDNWHU HLQHUEORHQ%HKDXSWXQJKDEHQVROO'DVGDPLWDXIJHZRUIHQHXQGYLHOGLVNXWLHUWH 3UREOHPLQZLHIHUQGHUSULQ]LSLHOOZHUNORVH*ODXEHQGRFKZLHGHUDOVZHUNWlWLJ EHVFKUHLEEDULVWVXFKW-QJHOLP5HNXUVDXI/XWKHUV9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJYRQ LQQHUHPXQGlXHUHP0HQVFKHQ]XNOlUHQ 9RP*ODXEHQ]XP+DQGHOQDXV$QHUNHQQXQJ ,QQHUHUXQGlXHUHU 0HQVFK 'LH6SDQQXQJLQGHUVQGLJH0HQVFKGXUFKGLHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJDOV*H UHFKWHUYHUVHW]WZLUGVSLHJHOWVLFKLPNRQIOLNWX|VHQ9HUKlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQLQQH UHPXQGlXHUHP0HQVFKHQZLGHU$QVHLQHP$XVJDQJHQWVFKHLGHWVLFKGLH )UHLKHLWXQG8QIUHLKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQZLH-QJHOLQVHLQHU]XHUVW YHU|I IHQWOLFKWHQÄ(ULQQHUXQJDQ/XWKHUV6FKULIW³ 9RQGHU)UHLKHLWHLQHV&KULVWHQ PHQVFKHQKHUDXVDUEHLWHW2EGHU0HQVFKEHLVLFKVHOEVWYHUEOHLEWRGHUREHUEHU VLFKKLQDXVJHKW]X*RWWÄXPDXVGHU)UHLKHLW*RWWHVLQGHQ'LHQVWGHV1lFKVWHQ ]XWUHWHQ³LVWGDEHLGLHHQWVFKHLGHQGH)UDJH:HLOGLHLQGHU6HOEVWEHUVFKUHL WXQJDXIGHQ$QGHUHQKLQVLFKYROO]LHKHQGHÄ/LHEHVHOEVWQRWZHQGLJLQ7lWLJNHL WHQ³]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPWJHODQJWPLWLKUGLH)UDJHQDFKGHP9HUKlOWQLVYRQ 3HUVRQXQG:HUNHLQPDOPHKUDXIV7DEOHDX'DEHLDEHUZLUGGHVVHQ%HVWLP PXQJLP6LQQHHLQHUGDVMHZHLOV$QGHUHDXVVFKOLHHQGHQ2SSRVLWLRQZDVGLH .RQVWLWXWLRQE]ZGDV*DQ]ZHUGHQGHV3HUVRQVHLQVDQJHKWHLQH$OWHUQDWLYH]XU 6HLWHJHVWHOOW)ROJHQGLH:HUNHQLFKWPHKUGHP$QVSUXFKGDV$QHUNDQQWVHLQ GHV0HQVFKHQHLJHQV]XJHQLHUHQVRQGHUQVXFKHQVLHGLHVHVDOVOlQJVWJHVFKH KHQ]XU*HOWXQJEULQJHQVLQGVLHSRVLWLY]XEHXUWHLOHQ(VEHMDKWGDQQZLH-Q JHOIHVWKlOWÄGHU0HQVFKVHLQHSDVVLYH%HMDKWKHLWGXUFK*RWW³VHLQHUVHLWVGHUDUW GDVVHUVLHÄDOVVFK|SIHULVFKH.UDIWIUGLH(QWVWHKXQJ$XVULFKWXQJXQG9HU DQWZRUWXQJDOOHUZHLWHUHQ$NWLYLWlWIUXFKWEDUZHUGHQOlW³:LHGLHVYRU]XVWHO
-h1*(/M 6RODXWHWHGHU8QWHUWLWHOYRQ -h1*(/M9JOGD]X /87+(5 E -h1*(/M $D2 -h1*(/J
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
OHQLVWPDFKW-QJHODQKDQGGHU/XWKHUVFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJYRQLQQH UHPXQGlXHUHP0HQVFKHQGHXWOLFK )U/XWKHULVWVRQDFKÄGLHÃ3HUVRQ>«@LGHQWLVFKPLWGHPÃLQZHQGLJHQ0HQ VFKHQµIUGHQHQWVFKHLGHQGLVWGDVVHUVLFKQLFKWVHOEVWNRQVWLWXLHUW³VRQGHUQ ÄGXUFKGDV:RUW*RWWHVXQGGXUFKGLHLKPHQWVSUHFKHQGHRGHUDEHUZLGHUVSUH FKHQGH(QWVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ*ODXEHQXQG8QJODXEHQ³NRQVWLWXLHUWZLUG 'HUlXHUH0HQVFKKLQJHJHQLVWGDV0HGLXPLQGHPGLH3HUVRQVLFKDOVIUHL RGHUXQIUHL]XP$XVGUXFNEULQJW8QIUHLLVWVLHHEHQGDQQZHQQVLHVLFKYRP (LJHQZLOOHQGHVlXHUHQ0HQVFKHQUHJLHUHQOlVVWXQGVLFKDQGLH:HOWYHUOLHUW LQGLHVHLlXHUOLFKHLQJHEXQGHQLVW)UHLLVWVLHZHQQVLHVLFKGXUFK*RWWUHJLH UHQOlVVWZDVVLFKDEHUDXFKLPbXHUHQZLGHUVSLHJHOQPXVV6RÄJHK|UW>HV@ JHUDGH]X]XU)XQNWLRQGHVLQZHQGLJHQ0HQVFKHQGHQlXHUHQ]XUHJLHUHQXQG ]XHLQHU7lWLJNHLWDQ]XKDOWHQGLHGHP*ODXEHQGHVLQZHQGLJHQ0HQVFKHQHQW VSULFKW³ 8PDXI]X]HLJHQZLHVLFKGHULQQHUH0HQVFKLQUHFKWHU:HLVHDXIGHQlXH UHQ0HQVFKHQEH]LHKWVLHKW-QJHOEHL/XWKHUHLQÄGRSSHOWH>V@(QWVSUHFKXQJV YHUKlOWQLV³LQ$QVFKODJJHEUDFKW ÄHVVROOVLFKYHUKDOWHQGHUlXHUH0HQVFK]XP LQQHUHQ0HQVFKHQZLHGHULQQHUH0HQVFK]X*RWW³%HLGHDXI.RQIRUPLWlW RGHU(QWVSUHFKXQJDXVJHULFKWHWHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHVLQGDEHUFKULVWRORJLVFKEHGLQJW ,P)DOOGHV9HUKlOWQLVVHV*RWWHV]XPLQQHUHQ0HQVFKHQÄZLUNW-HVXV&KULVWXV RKQHMHGHPHQVFKOLFKH=XWDW³GDVVÄGHULQQHUH0HQVFKGHPIUHLHQ*RWWNRQ IRUP³ZLUGZlKUHQGGHU0HQVFKÄQXUDOV1HKPHQGH>U@>DJLHUW@GHU*RWWQLFKWV DQGHUHV]XJHEHQYHUPDJDOVGLH(KUHVLFKVHOEVWYRQLKPDOOHUHUVW]XHPSIDQ JHQ³ 1HEHQ GLHVHU VDNUDPHQWDOHQ NRPPW -HVXV &KULVWXV DEHU DXFK HLQH H[HPSODULVFKH%HGHXWXQJ]X (UUXIWÄGHQEHIUHLWHQ0HQVFKHQLQGLH1DFKIROJH³ XQGÄ>G@D]XPXGLHVHUQXQVHLQHUVHLWVWlWLJ>ZHUGHQ@PXGHU+|UHUGHV:RU WHV*RWWHV]XP7lWHUGHV:RUWHVPXVHLQ*ODXEHLQGHU/LHEHZHUNWlWLJZHU GHQ³ =ZHL)XQNWLRQHQVFKUHLEW-QJHOGHU5HJHQWVFKDIWGHVLQQHUHQEHUGHQlX HUHQGHQ0HQVFKHQ]X 6LH]LHOWDXIGDVUHFKWH9HUKlOWQLVGHV0HQVFKHQ]XVLFK VHOEVWXQGDXIGDVUHFKWHÄ9HUKlOWQLV]XDOOHQDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQDXI(UGHQ>«@ ]XGHUHQ*XQVWHQVLFKGHU*ODXEHPLW/XVWXQG/LHEHLQV:HUNVHW]W±LQGDV :HUN IUHLHVWHU .QHFKWVFKDIW³ -QJHO XQWHUVWUHLFKW GDEHL GDVV /XWKHU Ä>N@HLQHP ,QGLYLGXDOLVPXV GHV FKULVWOLFKHQ /HEHQV VRQGHUQ GHU VR]LHWlUHQ 6WUXNWXUGHUYLWDFKULVWLDQD>«@GDV:RUW>UHGHW@³ 'LH(LQKHLWYRQLQQHUHP XQGlXHUHP0HQVFKHQLP6LQQHHLQHV+DQGHOQVDXV1lFKVWHQOLHEHGDVGHU
-h1*(/M9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2± -h1*(/M $D2 (EG (EG -h1*(/M9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2± $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DQHUNHQQHQGHQ/LHEH*RWWHV]XP0HQVFKHQHQWVSULFKWLVWMHGRFKQXUGRUWUHFKW YROO]RJHQZRLKUHIXQGDPHQWDOH'LIIHUHQ]QLFKWDXVJHEOHQGHWZLUG'DEHLVLQG QDFK-QJHO]ZHL+LQVLFKWHQJHOWHQG]XPDFKHQ 'LHEOHLEHQGHÄ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ >EHZDKUW@YRUHLQHUGHQ:LGHUVWDQGJHJHQ*RWWHVJXWHQ:LOOHQEHUVSLHOHQGHQ ,GHQWLILNDWLRQGHV5HLFKHVGHU*QDGHXQG)UHLKHLWPLWGHP%HUHLFKGHU:HOW³ XQGVLHÄ>P@DFKW>«@GHQ0HQVFKHQDOVYHUDQWZRUWOLFKHV6XEMHNWVHLQHU7DWHQ WKHPDWLVFK³LQVRIHUQHVLKPGDUXPJHKHQPXVVÄGXUFKGDV+DQGHOQGHQlXH UHQ0HQVFKHQLQVHLQHPXQHLQJHVFKUlQNWHQ:HOWEH]XJGHPLQQHUHQ0HQVFKHQ XQG GDPLW >«@ *RWW VHOEVW ]XU (QWVSUHFKXQJ ]X EULQJHQ³ (QWJHJHQ HLQHU 5HGXNWLRQGHU6QGHDXIHLQWlWLJ]XEHKHEHQGHVPRUDOLVFKHV'HIL]LWZLUGDOVR GLHEOHLEHQGH1LFKWLGHQWLWlWYRQ5HLFK*RWWHV LQQHUHP0HQVFKHQ XQG5HLFK GHU:HOW lXHUHP0HQVFKHQ EHWRQW:LGHUHLQHQSUDNWLVFKIROJHQORVHQ*ODX EHQDEHUZLUGGLH,QGLHQVWVWHOOXQJGHVlXHUOLFKHQGXUFKGHQLQZHQGLJHQ0HQ VFKHQIUGDV+DQGHOQDN]HQWXLHUWÄ1LFKWHLQHP'XDOLVPXVDEHUHEHQDXFK NHLQHU,GHQWLWlW³ZLUGKLHUGDV:RUWJHUHGHW9LHOPHKUVROOYRQ/XWKHUV8QWHU VFKHLGXQJHLQH1|WLJXQJÄ]XP+DQGHOQLQGHUDOWEOHLEHQGHQ:HOW³DXVJHKHQ GDVÄGLHVHLQLKUHUDXFKLQPLWWHQDOOHU9HUlQGHUXQJDOWEOHLEHQGHQ6HLQVZHLVH ZHQLJVWHQV]XP$QVDW]HLQHV*OHLFKQLVVHVIUGDV5HLFKGHU)UHLKHLW³ZHUGHQ OlVVWÄ:RGLHVJHVFKLHKW³ZHL-QJHO]XVDJHQ IlOOWDXIGLH.RQIRUPLWlWGHVlXHUHQPLWGHPLQQHUHQ0HQVFKHQYRQGHU.RQIRUPLWlWGHV LQQHUHQ0HQVFKHQPLW*RWWKHUGDV/LFKWGHU9HUKHLXQJGDVGDVJDQ]H(QWVSUHFKXQJVYHU KlOWQLVDOVHLQHLQPLWWHQQRFKVRJURHQ:LGHUVSUXFKVLPPHUQRFKJU|HUH(QWVSUHFKXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ0HQVFKXQG*RWW]XYHUVWHKHQHUODXEW
6ROFKH(QWVSUHFKXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQ0HQVFKOLFKHPXQG*|WWOLFKHPGLH-QJHODXI GHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQVDXV]XPDFKHQYHUPDJVROOHQ QXQ]XU'DUVWHOOXQJNRPPHQ
(QWVSUHFKXQJHQ *|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJ±PHQVFKOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ Ä2KQH$QDORJLHNHLQH7KHRORJLH³UXIW-QJHOLP9RUZRUWGHV]ZHLWHQ%DQ GHVVHLQHU7KHRORJLVFKHQ(U|UWHUXQJHQDXV2KQHDXIGLHLQGHVVHQ7LWHODQJH
$D2 $D2 (EG (EG -h1*(/I9JO]X-QJHOVHWKLVFKHP$QVDW]LQVJHVDPWGLH(LQVFKlW]XQJEHL 3)/(,'(5(5 Ä:LHEHLVHLQHP/HKUHU.DUO%DUWKOLHJHQDXFKEHL-QJHO'RJPDWLN XQG(WKLNHQJYHUNQSIWLQHLQDQGHU KLHUZLHGRUWUHVXOWLHUWDXVGHP)KUXQJVDQVSUXFKGHU 'RJPDWLN]XJOHLFKHLQHIXQGDPHQWDOH$EZHUWXQJZLHDXFKZLHGHUXPHLQHVXEOLPH$XIZHU WXQJGHU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWGHV(WKLVFKHQ GHQQGRUWZLHKLHUZLUG7KHRORJLHDOVJHGDQNOLFKHU
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
]HLJWHQ(QWVSUHFKXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQ*|WWOLFKHPXQG0HQVFKOLFKHPUHNXUULHUHQ ]XN|QQHQEOLHEHMHGHQIDOOVWKHRORJLVFKQLFKWV3RVLWLYHVEHUGLH:HOW]XVDJHQ (LQHPVFKOLFKWHQ'XDOLVPXV]ZLVFKHQGHUREHQDOVDPELYDOHQWJHVFKLOGHUWHQ LUGLVFKHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWXQGGHUGXUFKHLQGHXWLJHQ+HLOV]XVDJHQDXVJH]HLFKQHWHQ J|WWOLFKHQ,QVWDQ]P|FKWH-QJHOMHGRFKHUNOlUWHUPDHQQLFKWGHQ%RGHQEHUHL WHQ(UVFKOLHWGHVKDOEDQ.DUO%DUWKV'HQNILJXUGHUÄDQDORJLDILGHL³DQPLWGHU GLHVHUÄLP$XVJDQJYRQGHU2IIHQEDUXQJ XQGGDVKHLW YRP%XQG*RWWHVPLW GHP0HQVFKHQ&KULVWXV 6WUXNWXUHQLQGHUHPSLULVFKJHJHEHQHQ:LUNOLFKNHLW]X LGHQWLIL]LHUHQ³ZHLÄLQGHUGLHVHXQEHVFKDGHWLKUHU$ENHKUYRQ*RWWHV2IIHQ EDUXQJ GLHVHU 2IIHQEDUXQJ XQHQWULQQEDU HQWVSULFKW³ 'HU $XIZHLV VROFKHU (QWVSUHFKXQJHQJHKWGDEHLVWHWVPLWQRUPDWLYHQ,PSOLNDWLRQHQHLQKHULQVRIHUQ VRLQPLWWHQGHUEOHLEHQGDPELYDOHQWHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWQDPKDIWJHPDFKWZLUGZLH GLHVHHLJHQWOLFKVHLQVROOWHÄ'HU*RWWHQWVSUHFKHQGH0HQVFK³VREULQJW-QJHO HVHLQPDODXIGHQ3XQNWÄLVWDOOHVDQGHUHDOVHLQVLFKVHOEVWKDEHQGHVVLFKVHOEVW EHVLW]HQGHV,FK³HQWVSULFKWHUGRFKÄGHPGUHLHLQLJHQ*RWWQXULQGHU*HPHLQ VFKDIWOLFKNHLW]XPLQGHVW]ZHLHUÃ:LUµVDJHQGHU0HQVFKHQ³ 'LHLQQHUJ|WWOLFKH*HPHLQVFKDIWJHJHQVHLWLJHQ$QGHUVVHLQVGLHIU-QJHO GHQXQEHGLQJWHQ*UXQGMHQHUGHILQLWLYHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQLP5HFKW IHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ ELOGHW KDW GHPQDFK HLQH $QDORJLH LQ GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 6R]LDOLWlW,KU]XHQWVSUHFKHQEHGHXWHWVRJHVHKHQVLFKHQWJHJHQHLQHUSULYDWLVWL VFKHQ 6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLW DXI GLH GDV HLJHQH SHUVRQDOH 'DVHLQ EHVWLPPHQGHQ VR]LDOHQ5HODWLRQHQKDQGHOQGHLQ]XODVVHQRGHU 9RP,FK]XP:LUEHU]XJHKHQ Ä>$@XVGHP,QGLNDWLYGHV>«@)UXQV6HLQV>«@*RWWHV³GDVLQVHLQHPK|FKVW VR]LDODXVJHULFKWHWHQ)UVLFK6HLQXQEHGLQJWHQ*UXQGKDWIROJWVRQDFKÄGHUDQ GLH&KULVWHQJHULFKWHWH,PSHUDWLYQXQDXFKLKUHUVHLWVIUDQGHUH0HQVFKHQGD]X VHLQ³'DULQKDWGDV/HEHQDXVJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJJHZLVVHUPDHQVHLQH VSH]LILVFKH.RQWXU,Q-QJHOV$XJHQDEHUNDQQDOOHVÄWlWLJH>@%HPKHQ XP ZHOWOLFKH*HUHFKWLJNHLW>«@GHPJ|WWOLFKHQ+DQGHOQLPPHUQXUPLWWHOEDUHQW VSUHFKHQ³GHQQÄ>]@XXQVHUHP7XQ³GDVYHUQHLQWDXFKHUQLFKWÄEHVWLPPHQZLU XQVVHOEVW³ 'DVHLJHQH+DQGHOQÄDOVHLQH$UW3URORQJDWXUGHVJ|WWOLFKHQ+DQ GHOQV³DQ]XVHKHQZUGHGHPQDFKÄGDV(YDQJHOLXPLQHLQQHXHV*HVHW]YHUNHK 1DFKYROO]XJGHU6HOEVWEHZHJXQJ*RWWHV]XP0HQVFKHQXPGHV0HQVFKHQZLOOHQYHUVWDQGHQ GHUVHLQHUVHLWVDOVGHUIXQGDPHQWDOHWKLVFKH9RUJDQJNDW¶H[RFKHQ]XYHUVWHKHQVHL'HULP 2IIHQEDUXQJVE]Z5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQYRQ*RWWVHOEVWJHEWHQ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJVNXQVW KDW GLH WKHRORJLVFKH 'HQNEHZHJXQJ DQDORJ ]X IROJHQ 6LH KDW GDULQ LKUH ± HWKLVFKH ± *UXQGQRUP³ 'HU7LWHOGHV%DQGHVODXWHW (QWVSUHFKXQJHQ *RWW±:DKUKHLW±0HQVFK 6/(1&=.$ 6OHQF]NDYHUZHLVWGDEHLDXI.DUO%DUWKV6FK|SIXQJVOHKUHXQGVRJ Ä/LFKWHUOHKUH³)U-QJHOV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW%DUWKV$QDORJLHEHJULIIDXIGHVVHQ5H ]HSWLRQGXUFK-QJHO6OHQF]NDHEHQIDOOVKLQZHLVW 9JO-h1*(/ D -h1*(/ -h1*(/F -h1*(/ D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
UHQ³(V]LHOWHGDVVHOEVWEHVWLPPHQGH7XQGDQQZLHGHUXPDXIGHQ(UZHUE UHVSHNWLYH (UZHLV GHV HLJHQHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQV XQG ZLGHUVSUlFKH VRPLW GHP EHGLQJXQJVORVHQ$QJHERWGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ'DVV*RWWHV)UXQV6HLQLQXQVH UHP)U$QGHUH6HLQHQWVSURFKHQZLUGIKUWIU-QJHOGHVKDOEQLH]XHLQHU ,GHQWLILNDWLRQEHLGHU(EHQHQZHLOOHW]WHUHVQLHPDOVDQGLH6WHOOHGHVHUVWHUHQ WUHWHQNDQQ9LHOPHKUEOHLEWHVEHLP9HUVXFKHLQHUXQHQGOLFKHQ$QQlKHUXQJDQ GDVDOOHP+DQGHOQYRUDXVOLHJHQGH$QHUNDQQWVHLQGXUFK*RWW:HOFKH(QWVSUH FKXQJHQGLHVHVGHQQRFKLPVR]LDOHQ/HEHQILQGHWKDW-QJHODQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ 2UWHQJH]HLJW'DEHLLVW]XHUVWDQGLH.LUFKHE]ZGHQJHLVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVGLHQVW ]XGHQNHQDQGHPVLFKGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWWLPPHUZLH GHUQHXHUVFKOLHWXQGHUVFKOLHHQPXVV 9RQGDDXVDEHUHUJHEHQVLFK 3HUVSHNWLYHQIUGHQ*RWWHVGLHQVWLP$OOWDJGHU:HOWGHUVLFKLQGHQ,QVWLWXWLR QHQYRQ6WDDWXQG5HFKWDEVSLHOW YRQ'HEDWWHQEHU:HUWXQG8QZHUW GHV/HEHQVJHSUlJWLVW XQGGHP(LQ]HOQHQ]XUDUEHLWVDPHQ(UZLUWVFKDI WXQJYRQ*HZLQQYHUSIOLFKWHW 'LHLQ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWHQQDP KDIWJHPDFKWHQ3UREOHPHXQG3RWHQ]LDOHZHUGHQGDEHLHUQHXWYRU$XJHQWUHWHQ 'HU*RWWHVGLHQVW ,QVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWH8QWHUEUHFKXQJPHQVFKOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVGUDQJVXQG2UWGHU(UVFKOLHXQJGHILQLWLYHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'HU *RWWHVGLHQVW LVW IU -QJHO LP *UXQGH JHQRPPHQ GLH LQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWH 8QWHUEUHFKXQJPHQVFKOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVGUDQJHVXQGGHU2UWDQGHPVLFK GHP 0HQVFKHQ GDV GHILQLWLYH $QHUNDQQWVHLQ GXUFK *RWW HUVFKOLHW (U LVW LQ VHLQHQ$XJHQGLH HLQH,QVWLWXWLRQGLHXQVXQHQWZHJWWlWLJHGLH:HOWEHDUEHLWHQGHXQG]XPEORHQ0DWHULDO KHUDEVHW]HQGH0HQVFKHQLQXQVHUHP7lWLJVHLQ$UEHLWHQ/HLVWHQXQGDXFKLQXQVHUHUPRUDOL VFKHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJHOHPHQWDU]XXQWHUEUHFKHQXQGLQV6WDXQHQ]XYHUVHW]HQYHUPDJ >«@LQGHUZLUXQVVHOEVWDOV(PSIDQJHQGHXQG*RWWDOVGHQ*HEHQGHQHQWGHFNHQ>«@
'RUWÄZHUGHQZLUDXIXQVVHOEVWDOV3HUVRQHQDQJHVSURFKHQGLHPHKUVLQGDOV GLH6XPPHLKUHU7DWHQ³'DPLWJHKWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQHLQH3HUVSHNWLYHQYHU VFKLHEXQJHLQKHUGLHGDV:HOWXQG6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVYRP*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVKHU EHVWLPPWVHLQOlVVWJHQDXHUJHVDJWYRQGHU8UVSUXQJVUHODWLRQ*RWWHV]XP0HQ VFKHQ6RNRPPWGDVHLJHQHXQGDOOHVDQGHUH/HEHQDOVJ|WWOLFKHV*HVFKHQNLQ GHQ%OLFNGHP]XDOOHUHUVW'DQNXQG/REXQGGDQQHUVW(LJHQDNWLYLWlWNRUUHV SRQGLHUHQVROO=XJOHLFKÄHQWGHFNHQZLUXQVDOVYRQXQVHUHUHLJHQHQ9HUJDQ JHQKHLW%HIUHLWH³LQVRIHUQGDVHLJHQH3HUVRQVHLQDXIVHLQHQDOOHP7XQLPPHU VFKRQYRUDXVOLHJHQGHQXQGGDGXUFKXQDQWDVWEDUHQJ|WWOLFKHQ*UXQG]XUFNJH IKUWZLUG'RFKNDQQGLHÄ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHV6QGHUVQLFKWOLWXUJLVFKOLPLWLHUW
(EG -h1*(/I (EG (EG
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
ZHUGHQ³VRQGHUQÄZLOODXFKLPDOOWlJOLFKHQ/HEHQJHOHEWZHUGHQ³ZLHQRFK ]X]HLJHQLVW 'HUÄHQWVFKHLGHQGH>@:HVHQV]XJGHVLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ*RWWHVGLHQVWHV³DEHU EHVWHKWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQGDULQÄ)HLHU]XVHLQ³0LWGLHVHU)HVWVWHOOXQJZLOOHU VLFKGHXWOLFKYRQHLQHUVLWWOLFKHQ9HU]ZHFNXQJGHV*RWWHVGLHQVWHV]XJXQVWHQ VHLQHU SUDNWLVFKDOOWlJOLFKHQ )ROJHQ GLVWDQ]LHUHQ XQG GLHVHP HLQH SULPlUH 6HOEVW]ZHFNKDIWLJNHLW ]XVFKUHLEHQ 0LW )ULHGULFK 6FKOHLHUPDFKHU GHU GHQ *RWWHVGLHQVWGHPJHPlDOVGDUVWHOOHQGHV+DQGHOQLP*HJHQVDW]]XPZLUNVDPHQ +DQGHOQHWZDGHUDOOWlJOLFKHQ%HUXIVDUEHLWYHUVWHKWVSULFKW-QJHOYRPÄ*RW WHVGLHQVWLPHQJHUHQ6LQQ>«@DOV8QWHUEUHFKXQJ³'LHVHU8QWHUEUHFKXQJV FKDUDNWHUDEHUHLJQHWGHP*RWWHVGLHQVWZHLOXQGLQVRIHUQLQLKP±VRGLHWUDGL WLRQHOOHUHIRUPDWRULVFKH)RUPHO±GDV(YDQJHOLXPYHUNQGHWZLUGE]ZHLQMHGHU VLFKGXUFKGDV(YDQJHOLXPLP%OLFNDXIVLFKVHOEVWDQJHVSURFKHQHUIlKUWZDVLQ ]ZHLIDFKHU:HLVHJHVFKLHKW(UVWHQVYROO]LHKWHVVLFKDOVEHIUHLHQGHÄ8QWHUEUH FKXQJGHVLQGLYLGXHOOHQ/HEHQV]XVDPPHQKDQJV³LQGHPÄGDVPHQVFKOLFKH,FK >«@DXIGHQIUDOOHJHVWRUEHQHQ&KULVWXV³VRDQJHVSURFKHQ ZLUGGDVVHV GDULQDXIQHXH:HLVH]XVLFKVHOEVWNRPPW'LHVKDWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQHLQHQ VR]LDOLVLHUHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUZHLOGLHHLQHPMHGHQ]XJHVSURFKHQH%HIUHLXQJYRQ GHU]XP7RGHYHUXUWHLOWHQ([LVWHQ]GHU6QGHDOOHQ*ODXEHQGHQJOHLFKHUPDHQ JLOWÄ'HPJHPlLVWGHUGXUFKVROFKH6SUDFKHZLUNHQGH*HLVWGHU)UHLKHLW*H PHLQJHLVW³ YHUELQGHWHUGRFKDOOHLP*RWWHVGLHQVW9HUVDPPHOWHQDOVLQHLQ XQGGHPVHOEHQ*HVFKHKHQ(UO|VWHPLWHLQDQGHUXQGOlVVWVLHLKUH6HOEVWEH]RJHQ KHLWZHQLJVWHQV]HLWZHLVHEHUZLQGHQ=ZHLWHQVJHVFKLHKWGDVEHVDJWHÄ$QJHUH GHW:HUGHQGXUFKGDV(YDQJHOLXP³DEHUVRGDVVGHU$QJHUHGHWHÄDOVGLHYRQ LKUHQ7DWHQXQG:HUNHQXQWHUVFKLHGHQH3HUVRQ]XU*HOWXQJ³NRPPW(UYHU PDJGHPZDVLKP]XJHVSURFKHQZLUGGHPLQ-HVXV&KULVWXVZLUNOLFKJHZRUGH QHQ+HLOGHPQDFKQLFKWVKLQ]X]XWXQZHLOHVGLHGHILQLWLYHÄ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQG +HLOLJXQJGHV*RWWORVHQSURNODPLHUW³'LHVHUJHJHQEHULVWDOOHVJRWWHVGLHQVW OLFKH+DQGHOQQXU7HVWDPHQWZLH-QJHOPLW%H]XJDXI/XWKHUVDJWRGHUHEHQ
(EG -h1*(/ E 9JO IU GLH IROJHQGHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ ]XP *RWWHVGLHQVWWKHPD DD2 ± -QJHOEH]LHKWVLFKLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJDXIGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQLQ 6FKOHLHUPDFKHUV&KULVWOLFKHU6LWWH YJO6&+/(,(50$&+(5 E± XQGLQGHQ9RUOH VXQJHQ]XU3UDNWLVFKHQ7KHRORJLH YJO'(56EHV I (LQHHLJHQVWlQGLJH$XVHLQDQ GHUVHW]XQJPLW6FKOHLHUPDFKHUV*RWWHVGLHQVWYHUVWlQGQLVWUlJW-QJHOYRULQ -h1*(/E -h1*(/E 9JOGD]X02;7(5IIÄ(LQHGHURSHUDWLYHQ/HLWPHWDSKHUQ -QJHOV³VFKUHLEW0R[WHUÄLVWGLHGHUIXQGDPHQWDOHQ8QWHUEUHFKXQJ³GLHHUÄLQ6FKOHLHUPD FKHUV*RWWHVGLHQVWOHKUH ZLHGHU ³ILQGHW DD2I -h1*(/E (EG $D2 (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
PLW6FKOHLHUPDFKHUGDUVWHOOHQGHV+DQGHOQXQGDOVRVROFKHVÄGLH8QWHUEUHFKXQJ GHVYHUZLUNOLFKHQGHQ+DQGHOQV³'DPLWVWHOOWVLFK-QJHOQLFKWQXUJHJHQGDV NDWKROLVFKH0HVVYHUVWlQGQLVGDVÄELVKHXWHDPRSXV&KDUDNWHUXQGDPVDFULIL FLXP&KDUDNWHUGHUVDFUD/LWXUJLDIHVWJHKDOWHQ³KDW$XFKPRQLHUWHUHLQHLP 3URWHVWDQWLVPXVYRUKHUUVFKHQGH7HQGHQ]HEHQVR]XU9HU]ZHFNXQJZLH]XU.D WHFKLVLHUXQJ GHV *RWWHVGLHQVWHV GLH ]XXQJXQVWHQ VHLQHV )HVWFKDUDNWHUV JHKW +LHUNRPPW-QJHOVQHX]HLWEH]RJHQH.ULWLNDPXPVHLQH6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ WlWLJEHPKWHQ0HQVFKHQHUQHXWGHXWOLFK]XP9RUVFKHLQGLHVLFKDXFKDXIEH VWLPPWH)RUPHQGHV*RWWHVGLHQVWHVEH]LHKHQNDQQ'DEHLDEHUEHJHJQHWMHQH VWDUNH'LIIHUHQ]YRQJ|WWOLFKHU$NWLYLWlWXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU3DVVLYLWlWZLHGHUGLH LP*RWWHVGLHQVWSDUDGLJPDWLVFKGHXWOLFKZHUGHQVROO'HU]LWLHUWH6FKOHLHUPD FKHUDEHUZXVVWH]XVDJHQGDVVÄMHGHVGDUVWHOOHQGH+DQGHOQ>«@HLQZLUNVDPHV (OHPHQWKDEHQ³PXVVÄXQGXPJHNHKUW³ 'HUYRQ-QJHODN]HQWXLHUWH)HVWFKDUDNWHUGHV*RWWHVGLHQVWHVNRPPWEHVRQ GHUVGHXWOLFKLQGHQÄEHLGHQVDNUDPHQWDOHQ)HLHUQGHU7DXIHXQGGHV$EHQGPDK OHV³]XP$XVGUXFN'DV$EHQGPDKODOVWHVWDPHQWXPFKULVWLYHUVWDQGHQEH ]LHKWVLFKGDQQDXIHWZDVOlQJVW*HVFKHKHQVGHVVHQ9HUJHJHQZlUWLJXQJQLFKW GHU0HQVFKVRQGHUQ*RWWEHZLUNWÄ'HQQGDV7HVWDPHQWPDFKWGLH*ODXEHQGHQ ]X(UEHQXQG(PSIlQJHUQ³GDVÄVLHGXUFKGLHJRWWHVGLHQVWOLFKH+DQGOXQJ>«@ ]X(KUHQ³EULQJHQZRGXUFKVLHÄDOV+DQGHOQGH]XJOHLFKHPLQHQWSDVVLYHEHQ (PSIDQJHQGH VLQG³ )U -QJHO PDFKW Ä>G@LHVH XUVSUQJOLFKH (LQKHLW YRQ +DQGHOQXQGKLQQHKPHQGHU3DVVLYLWlW>«@GDV:HVHQGHV)HVWHVXQGGDPLWGHQ )HVWFKDUDNWHUGHV*RWWHVGLHQVWHVDXV³'DUDXVVROOHQVLFKJHZLVVHUPDHQYRQ VHOEVWDOVRRKQH$XVULFKWXQJDXIHLQHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH)XQNWLRQ*HVWDOWXQJV SHUVSHNWLYHQIUGDV/HEHQLQGHU:HOWHUJHEHQ 'HU3ULPDWGHV3HUVRQVHLQVYRUGHQ:HUNHQDOVVR]LDOHWKLVFKH .RQVHTXHQ]GHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJODXEHQV :DVDXVGHP3HUVSHNWLYZHFKVHOGHVVRQQWlJOLFKHQ*RWWHVGLHQVWHVIUGDVDOOWlJ OLFKH/HEHQIROJWLVWODXW-QJHOHLQÄ9HUKDOWHQ³GDVHVGDUDXIDQOHJWÄGHQ XQEHGLQJWHQ9RUUDQJGHU3HUVRQYRULKUHQ:HUNHQ>«@LQMHGHU+LQVLFKW>]X@ EHMDKHQXQG]XU*HOWXQJ>]X@EULQJHQ³:HUGDUXPZHLGDVVHURKQHHLJHQHV =XWXQGXUFK*RWWDQHUNDQQWLVW
$D2 $D2 6&+/(,(50$&+(5 E%HLODJH$>@ -h1*(/E $D2 (EG -h1*(/ D
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GHUZLUG>«@DXFKLPDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQHLQHYRQ*RWWXQZLGHUUXIOLFKDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQ UHVSHNWLHUHQ DOOHQ LKUHQ P|JOLFKHQ /HLVWXQJHQ XQG (UIROJHQ ]XYRUNRPPHQG DOOHQ LKUHQ IDNWLVFKHQ)HKOOHLVWXQJHQXQG0LHUIROJHQ]XP7URW]
'LHVHU,PSHUDWLY]XPGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQHQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ+DQGHOQDEHUIROJWDXVGHP,QGLNDWLYGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVXUWHLOVZLH-QJHO LP5HNXUVDXIHLQH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ%XOWPDQQVKHUDXVVWHOOW'LHGDPLWDXV JHVSURFKHQH'HILQLWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQKDWVRPLWQLFKWQXUZLUNOLFKNHLWVVHW]HQGHQ &KDUDNWHUVRQGHUQEULQJW]XJOHLFKÄHLQHQHXH0|JOLFKNHLWHQHU|IIQHQGH:LUN OLFKNHLW³KHUYRU=XGLHVHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQJHK|UWDXFKHLQ+DQGHOQGDVQLFKW DXI6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDXVLVWVRQGHUQGHU9HUGDQNWKHLWGHVHLJHQHQ'DVHLQV $XVGUXFNYHUOHLKWÄ'DGDVJ|WWOLFKH+DQGHOQQLFKWXQPLWWHOEDULQXQVHUZHOWOL FKHV+DQGHOQEHUJHKHQNDQQ³GDVÄLQNHLQHU:HLVHLUJHQGHLQH)RUWVHW]XQJGHV J|WWOLFKHQ+DQGHOQV³]XVHLQYHUPDJGDYRQDEHUKDWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQÄMHGH HYDQJHOLVFKH(WKLNGLHGLHVHQ1DPHQYHUGLHQWDXV]XJHKHQ³(VEOHLEWHLQH 'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ+DQGOXQJVP|JOLFKNHLWHQHU|IIQHQGHP,QGLNDWLYXQG+DQG OXQJV]LHOHYRUVFKUHLEHQGHP,PSHUDWLY.HLQPHQVFKOLFKHV7XQNDQQHLQKROHQ ZDV LKP DQ J|WWOLFKHU $NWLYLWlW YRUDXVJHJDQJHQ LVW 'HQQRFK NDQQ Ä>X@QVHU WlWLJHV%HPKHQXPZHOWOLFKH*HUHFKWLJNHLW>«@GHPJ|WWOLFKHQ+DQGHOQ>«@ PLWWHOEDUHQWVSUHFKHQ³:LHDEHUVHKHQGLHVHZHQLJVWHQVPLWWHOEDUHQ(QWVSUH FKXQJHQDXV" $QHUNHQQXQJLQ6WDDWXQG5HFKW 7KHRORJLVFKH=XPXWXQJHQDQGHQ *HVHW]JHEHU D 'LHWKHRORJLVFKH%HJUQGXQJGHU0HQVFKHQZUGH :DVÄLPWKHRORJLVFKHQ9HUVWlQGQLVGHV%HJULIIHVGLH:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQLVW³ VLHKW-QJHOGXUFKGLH.HUQDXVVDJHGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDUWLNHOV]XP$XVGUXFN JHEUDFKW ÄGDGHU0HQVFKHLQHLXUHGLYLQRXQGHEHQGHVKDOEGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQ WH3HUVRQLVW³'HPZHLWHQWHLOVDOVSUlVNULSWLYHQ6DW]JHZHUWHWHQ8QDQWDVW EDUNHLWVSRVWXODWGHV*UXQGJHVHW]HVVROOVRHLQGHVNULSWLYHU6LQQ]XZDFKVHQ 'DVVYRQGHU$XVVDJHÄ'LH:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQLVWXQDQWDVWEDU³HLQXQEHGLQJW
$D2 %XOWPDQQVEHUKPWH )RUPHO Ä'HU ,QGLNDWLY EHJUQGHW GHQ ,PSHUDWLY³ %8/70$11 VROOHLQHIXQGDPHQWDOH9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJSDXOLQLVFKHU(WKLNDXIGHQ3XQNW EULQJHQ'DVGXUFKGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDNWEHUGHQ0HQVFKHQJHVSURFKHQH8UWHLO GHPHULP*ODXEHQWHLOKDIWLJZLUGNRPPWGHPQDFKDXFKLQHLQHPGHP*XWHQYHUSIOLFKWHWHQ /HEHQVZDQGHO]XP$XVGUXFNGHUDEHULPPHUQXU)ROJHQLH*UXQGGHV8UWHLOVZLUG -h1*(/ D $D2 (EG -h1*(/J9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2± -QJHOUHNXUULHUWGDEHLDXIYHUIDVVXQJVUHFKWOLFKH'HEDWWHQ]XU%HJUQGXQJGHV0HQ VFKHQZUGHJHGDQNHQVLQGHQ HUXQG HU-DKUHQ9JO-h1*(/J$QP
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
YHUSIOLFKWHQGHUPRUDOLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYDXVJHKWOlVVWVLFKGHPQDFKQLFKWDXILKUH UHFKWOLFKH.RGLIL]LHUXQJXQGGDGXUFKOHJLWLPLHUWHLQGLYLGXHOOH%HDQVSUXFKXQJ ]XUFNIKUHQ'LHVZUGHQlPOLFKGLH*HOWXQJGHUEHVDJWHQ8QYHUOHW]OLFKNHLWDQ GLHMHZHLOLJHQSROLWLVFKHQ8PVWlQGHNQSIHQ6RELOGHWHJHUDGHGLH(UIDKUXQJ MHQHUWLHIJUHLIHQGHQ0LVVDFKWXQJPHQVFKOLFKHU:UGHXQWHUGHU16'LNWDWXUGHQ (QWVWHKXQJVKLQWHUJUXQGYRQ$UW**ZHVKDOEDOOHVVWDDWOLFKH+DQGHOQXQWHU GHVVHQQRUPDWLYHQ$QVSUXFKJHVWHOOWZXUGH6ROOGDV8QDQWDVWEDUNHLWVSRVWXODW DEHUPHKUVHLQDOVGDV(UJHEQLVHLQHVKLVWRULVFKUHODWLYEDUHQ5HFKWVVHW]XQJVDN WHVLVWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQÄIUGDV,PSHUDWLYLVFKHGHU1RUPHLQXQEH]ZHLIHOEDUHU ,QGLNDWLY>«@GLH]ZLQJHQGH9RUDXVVHW]XQJ³+LHUEULQJWHUGLHUHFKWIHUWL JXQJVWKHRORJLVFKH (LQVLFKW LQV 6SLHO GDVV PHQVFKOLFKHV 3HUVRQVHLQ SULPlU GXUFKJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJNRQVWLWXLHUWLVWZRGXUFKLKPXQDEKlQJLJYRQDOOHQ VR]LDOHQ =XVFKUHLEXQJHQ XQG MHGZHGHU (LJHQDNWLYLWlW HLQ ÄXQEHGLQJWH>U@ Ã6HOEVWZHUWµ³RGHUHLQÄLQGLNDWLYLVFKH>U@FKDUDFWHULQGHOHELOLV³]XNRPPW 6R LVW GLH :UGH GHV 0HQVFKHQ ÄMHGHP PHQVFKOLFKHQ =XJULII HQW]RJHQ XQG JHUDGHVR>«@LQMHGHP,QGLYLGXXP$FKWXQJJHELHWHQGSUlVHQW³ RKQHGXUFK GHQLPPHUP|JOLFKHQ(QW]XJVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJJUXQGVlW]OLFKDQJHWDVWHW ZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQ(ULQQHUW-QJHOV5HGHYRPXQEHGLQJWHQ6HOEVWZHUWGHU3HU VRQQRFKDQ.DQWV%HJULIIGHU0HQVFKHQZUGHZHLVWHUGLHVEH]JOLFKMHJOLFKHQ 5HNXUVDXIÄÃGLHQDWUOLFKH$XVVWDWWXQJ³GHV0HQVFKHQHWZDÄPLW9HUQXQIW³ XQGHLQHGDUDXVHUZDFKVHQGHÄPRUDOLVFKH$QVWUHQJXQJ³DXVGUFNOLFKDE'DV H[WHUQH*HVFKHKHQJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJNHQQWHEHQQDFK-QJHONHLQHLQWHU QHQ DOVR LKUHP 2EMHNW VFKRQ HLJQHQGHQ $QNQSIXQJVSXQNWH VRQGHUQ LVW VFKOHFKWKLQYRUDXVVHW]XQJVORV6R]LHOWGHUPLWLKUHLQKHUJHKHQGH:UGHWLWHOGHU *RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWHEHQQLFKWDXIÄGLH$XV]HLFKQXQJHLQHUXQYHUOHW]EDUHQGHU 6LQQOLFKNHLWEHUOHJHQHQ XQGEHUDOOHV(OHQGHUKDEHQHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ9HU QXQIW³VRQGHUQJLOWJHUDGHGHPÄYHUOHW]EDUHQXQGEHGURKWHQ>«@0HQVFKHQ³ GHUÄHLQEHGUIWLJHV,FKLVWGDVGHV5HFKWHVEHGDUI5HFKWH]XKDEHQ³:LH GHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDNWGHP6QGHUNRQWUDIDNWLVFK*HUHFKWLJNHLW]XVSULFKWJLOW DXFKGLHDXVLKPUHVXOWLHUHQGH0HQVFKHQZUGHGHP0HQVFKHQRKQH$QKDOWDQ HPSLULVFKHQ*HJHEHQKHLWHQ:DVLKUDEHUQDFK-QJHO]XJUXQGHOLHJWLVWGLHRQ WRORJLVLHUWHXQGDV\PPHWULVFKH$XVJDQJVUHODWLRQ*RWWHV]XXQV0HQVFKHQYRU GHUHQ+LQWHUJUXQGGHU0HQVFKHEHQYRUDOOHPDOVÃEHGUIWLJHV,FKµHUVFKHLQWXQG QLFKWZLHHWZDEHL.DQWDOV6XEMHNWHLQHVVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ$XWRQRPLH YHUP|JHQV$XFKOHW]WHUHVLVWHEHQNHLQHPSLULVFKHV)DNWXPZlKUHQGGLHJ|WWOL FKH8UVSUXQJVUHODWLRQLQLKUHURQWRORJLVFKHQ9RUDXVJHVHW]WKHLWGXUFKDXV=JH
-h1*(/J -h1*(/F -h1*(/J (EG (EG9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ-QJHOV0HQVFKUHFKWVYHUVWlQGQLVEHWUHIIHQG DD2 ± -h1*(/
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GHV)DNWLVFKHQWUlJW'LHVJLOWDOOHPDOGDQQZHQQPDQIUDJWREGDVJODXEHQGH 6LFK(PSIDQJHQDXVJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJLQNOXVLYHGHUGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQ GHQQRUPDWLYHQ$QVSUFKHVRQLFKWXQWHU+DQG]XU%HGLQJXQJGHVPHQVFKOL FKHQ:UGHWLWHOVZLUG+DWGLHVHUQlPOLFKVHLQHQJOHLFKVDPREMHNWLYHQGK GXUFKJ|WWOLFKH2IIHQEDUXQJJHVHW]WHQ*UXQGIU-QJHOHLQ]LJLQ-HVXV&KULVWXV NDQQLKPNHLQPHQVFKOLFKHV9HUP|JHQYRUDXVJHKHQ'DVVÄJHUDGHGHU0HQVFK LQVHLQHU6FKZlFKHHLQHYRQ*RWWGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQLVWXQGDOVR:UGH KDW³VWHOOWIU-QJHOYLHOPHKUGHQ$QVDW]SXQNWDOOHUWKHRORJLVFKHQ=XPXWXQ JHQDQ3ROLWLNXQG*HVHOOVFKDIWGDU'DVLVWDEHUGRFKDXFKHLQHYRUGHP+LQWHU JUXQG GHU DOOHLQ *RWW ]XNRPPHQGHQ 6WlUNH XQG 0DFKW DXVJHVDJWH 6LFKW GHV 0HQVFKHQ E 'LH9HUDQNHUXQJGHU0HQVFKHQUHFKWHLPFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQ 'HUWKHRORJLVFKH%HJULIIGHU0HQVFKHQZUGHLPSOL]LHUW-QJHO]XIROJHDXFKHLQ EHVRQGHUHV3RWHQ]LDO]XU%HJUQGXQJYRQ0HQVFKHQUHFKWHQ'LHVHZHUGHQGDQQ VHLQHV(UDFKWHQVDOOHPYHUJDQJHQHPÄ:LGHUVWDQGGHU*URNLUFKHQJHJHQGHQ 0HQVFKHQUHFKWVJHGDQNHQ³]XP7URW]DOVZDVQlKHUEHWUDFKWHWNHLQHKLVWRULVFKH $XVVDJH GDUVWHOOW ÄLP FKULVWOLFKHQ *ODXEHQ YHUDQNHUW³ HLQVLFKWLJ (V VLQG JHQDXHUKLQÄ)UHLKHLWVUHFKWH*OHLFKKHLWVUHFKWHXQG3DUWL]LSDWLRQVUHFKWH³GLHPLW WKHRORJLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVDQVSUFKHQDXV]XVWDWWHQ-QJHOVLFKDXIJUXQGYRQ ÄELEOLVFKHQ7H[WHQXQGEHVWLPPWHQGRJPDWLVFKHQ/HKUHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ³OHJLWL PLHUWVLHKW(UZLOOVLHGDGXUFKLQVEHVRQGHUHXQGEHULKUHEORH$EZHKUIXQN WLRQKLQDXVLQLKUHUJHVHOOVFKDIWVJHVWDOWHQGHQ(LJHQDUW]XU*HOWXQJEULQJHQXP GDV&KULVWHQWXPDOVNULWLVFKNRQVWUXNWLYHV*HJHQEHUGHV6WDDWHV]XSURILOLHUHQ 'LH DXV GHP 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDUWLNHO ]X JHZLQQHQGH (LQVLFKW GDVV Ä>G@LH :UGHGHV0HQVFKHQ>«@GDULQ>EHVWHKW@HLQHLXUHGLYLQRGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWH 3HUVRQ]XVHLQ³KDWODXW-QJHOXQPLWWHOEDUHXQGPLWWHOEDUH)ROJHQIUGLH %HJUQGXQJYRQ0HQVFKHQUHFKWHQ,KUHHUVWHXQPLWWHOEDUH.RQVHTXHQ]LVW ÄGDV0HQVFKHQUHFKWDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJDOV3HUVRQXQWHUDOOHQ8PVWlQGHQ³ ,QEHVWLPPWHQ6LWXDWLRQHQHWZD]XJXQVWHQYHUPHLQWOLFKK|KHUHURGHUNROOHNWLYHU =ZHFNHÄ]ZLVFKHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUZUGLJHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUPHQVFKOL FKHQ0HQVFKHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ³LVWVRPLWDXVJHVFKORVVHQ'HQGDPLWDQYL VLHUWHQ*UXQGVDW]HLQHUDOOJHPHLQHQ*OHLFKKHLWGHU3HUVRQHQEHJUQGHW-QJHO FKULVWRORJLVFK :HLOÄGHUHZLJH6RKQ*RWWHVVLFKLP(UHLJQLVGHU,QNDUQDWLRQ
-h1*(/L -h1*(/+HUYRUKG9HUI $D2 $D2 9JO]XGHQ XQPLWWHOEDUHQXQG PLWWHOEDUHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQGLH =XVDPPHQIDVVXQJLQ DD2I $D2 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
PLWGHP0HQVFKVHLQDOOHU0HQVFKHQXQZLGHUUXIOLFKXQGXQDXIO|VEDUYHUHLQLJW KDW³ NDQQHVKLQVLFKWOLFKGHUGDPLWYHUEXQGHQHQXQZLGHUUXIOLFKHQ:UGH]X VFKUHLEXQJGLHDOOHUGLQJVQXUÃLQ&KULVWXVµJLOWNHLQH8QWHUVFKLHGHJHEHQ $XVLKUIROJW]ZHLWHQVGDVÄ0HQVFKHQUHFKWDXIGLH8QYHUIJEDUNHLWGHUHLJH QHQ3HUVRQ³ 6LFKQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQGHPJDQ]XQGJDUDXVVHW]HQ]XPVVHQ HWZDGXUFKGHQ(LQVDW]GHV/HEHQVRGHUSHU8QWHUZHUIXQJXQWHUWRWDOH+HUU VFKDIWVDPELWLRQHQIROJWGHPQDFKDOVOHJLWLPHU$QVSUXFKDXVGHP*HGDQNHQ HLQHU J|WWOLFKHQ .RQVWLWXWLRQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ 3HUVRQVHLQV 'DVV ÄGDV 6HLQ GHU 3HUVRQ>«@DOOHQLUGLVFKHQ3HUVRQHQXQG,QVWDQ]HQHQW]RJHQ³LVWJLOW]XJOHLFK DXFKIUGHUHQ9HUKlOWQLV]XVLFKVHOEVW ZHVKDOEHVVLFKQDFK-QJHOV/RJLN HLJHQWOLFKJDUQLFKWJlQ]OLFKYHUIJEDUPDFKHQODVVHQGUIWH)KUWHUGULWWHQV ÄGDV*HERW³DQÄGLHPHQVFKOLFKH3HUVRQYRQLKUHQ7DWHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ³ ZLUGQRFKGHXWOLFKHUZRUDXIHUKLQDXVZLOO6RIROJHUWHUDQDQGHUHU6WHOOHÄDXV GHPGHP6QGHUZLGHUIDKUHQGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ)UHLVSUXFK>«@GDGLHOHEHQVOlQJ OLFKH)UHLKHLWVVWUDIHHLQHGHU:UGHGHU3HUVRQ ZLGHUVSUHFKHQGH0DQDKPH LVW³ 9HUPDJVLFKGRFKZHU]XOHEHQVODQJHU+DIWYHUXUWHLOWLVWZHLOHUJlQ] OLFKDXIJUXQGVHLQHU7DWHQEHXUWHLOWZLUGÄLQNHLQHU:HLVHPHKUDOVHLQHYRQ GLHVHU*HVHOOVFKDIWDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQZDKU]XQHKPHQ³ /lVVWVLFKDXFKEHU GDVJ|WWOLFKHNRQVWLWXLHUWH3HUVRQVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQQLFKWYHUIJHQ±MHVWlUNHU HUGXUFKVLFKXQGRGHUGXUFKDQGHUHPLWVHLQHQ )HKO /HLVWXQJHQLGHQWLIL]LHUW ZLUGGHVWRPHKUVFKZLQGHWYHUKlQJQLVYROOHUZHLVHVHLQ:UGHE]Z3HUVRQDOL WlWVEHZXVVWVHLQ1XUDXVGLHVHPDEHUNDQQ]%GHU6FKXOGLJJHZRUGHQH.UDIW ]XU9HUlQGHUXQJVFK|SIHQZHLOHUVLFKVRQRFKHLQPDODQGHUVLQGHQ%OLFNEH NRPPW=XP0HQVFKHQUHFKWDXIGLH8QYHUIJEDUNHLWGHUHLJHQHQ3HUVRQJHK|UW IU-QJHOVRJHVHKHQDXFKGDV5HFKWGLHVHU8QYHUIJEDUNHLWJHZDKUZHUGHQ]X N|QQHQLQGHPHLQMHGHUDXFKXQDEKlQJLJYRQVHLQHQ7DWHQVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJ ILQGHW'HUKLHU]XHQWGHFNHQGHVWDUNH$N]HQWDXIGHUEHZXVVWHQ$QHLJQXQJ XQEHGLQJWHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQV EHL *RWW OlVVW IUDJHQ ZDUXP GLHVHV 0RPHQW LQ VHLQHU%HGHXWXQJEHL-QJHODQVRQVWHQVRVWDUNDEJHVFKZlFKWZLUG *DQ]LQGLHVHP6LQQHIKUWHUDOVYLHUWHXQPLWWHOEDUH)ROJHUXQJDXVGHPGH ILQLWLYHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWWÄGDV5HFKWDXI*HZLVVHQV IUHLKHLW³DQZHLOÄQXUHLQHVLFKDOVGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWZLVVHQGH3HUVRQ>«@HLQ IUHLHV*HZLVVHQKDEHQ³ NDQQ'LH=XELOOLJXQJHLQHVIUHLHQ*HZLVVHQVGHU 0|JOLFKNHLWDOVRlXHUOLFKXQJHEXQGHQEHUVLFKVHOEVWXQGGLHHLJHQHQ%HODQ JH]XHQWVFKHLGHQVHW]WGHPQDFKDXIVHLWHQLKUHV$GUHVVDWHQHLQ:LVVHQÄXP
(EG $D2 -h1*(/F -h1*(/ -h1*(/ D (EG+HUYRUKG9HUI 9JO]X GHQ IROJHQGHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ -QJHOV *HZLVVHQVEHJULIIEHWUHIIHQG -h1*(/ F ± K±
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
>«@ YRUJlQJLJH %HMDKWKHLW³ YRUDXV 6RQVW JHUlW GHVVHQ GLH HLJHQHQ 7DWHQ EHWUHIIHQGHV 6HOEVWXUWHLO LP )DOOH GHV 6FKHLWHUQV DQ GHQ VR]LDO YHUPLWWHOWHQ +DQGOXQJVQRUPHQ]XHLQHUJlQ]OLFKHQ9HUXUWHLOXQJVHLQHUVHOEVW:HUVLFKKLQ JHJHQLP*ODXEHQGXUFK*RWWGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWZHLHUIDVVWVLFKQRFKHLQPDO LQ'LIIHUHQ]]XGLHVHP±LPPHUDXFKIUHPGLQGX]LHUWHQ±6HOEVWXUWHLOXQGKDW GDULQGDV9HUP|JHQEHUVHLQHLP*HZLVVHQDXIJHGHFNWHQ9HUIHKOXQJHQKL QDXV]XJHKHQÄ)UHLKHLWGHV*HZLVVHQV³KHLWGDQQDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWZLH -QJHOPLW5HNXUVDXI/XWKHUHLQVFKlUIWYRUDOOHPÄ)UHLKHLWYRP*HZLVVHQ³ DOVHLQHUGHQ7lWHULQVHLQHP3HUVRQVHLQYHUXUWHLOHQGHQ,QVWDQ] 'DVVGLHVDEHU]XP5HFKWHLQHVMHGHQ0HQVFKHQZLUGKlQJWDXFKDQGHU 5HDOLVDWLRQGHVVHQZDV-QJHODOVPLWWHOEDUH)ROJHQÄ>D@XVGHPPLWGHP3HU VRQVHLQ>«@LXUHGLYLQRJHVHW]WHQGHILQLWLYHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQ³ GHGX]LHUW(U VSULFKWKLHUYRPÄ0HQVFKHQUHFKWDXIXQEHVFKlGLJWHV=XVDPPHQOHEHQ³GDVHU DOVHLQGXUFKYRUEHKDOWORVHJHJHQVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJJHSUlJWHVÄ=XVDPPHQOH EHQLQ)UHLKHLW³ QlKHUEHVWLPPW'HQELEOLVFKHQ+LQWHUJUXQGGLHVHV6R]LDO LGHDOVELOGHWGDVSDXOLQLVFKH0RWLYGHVÄLQ&KULVWR³6HLQV *DO± PLW GHPGLH$XIKHEXQJDOOHUZHOWOLFKUHOLJL|VHQ8QWHUVFKLHGH]XJXQVWHQHLQHUSR WHQ]LHOODOOHQRIIHQVWHKHQGHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHLQKHUJHKHQVROO)U-QJHOIROJW GDUDXVGHU$QVSUXFKDXIGLHXQLYHUVDOH'XUFKVHW]XQJYRQ0HQVFKHQUHFKWHQDQ GHQHQ]XSDUWL]LSLHUHQHEHQVRHLQMHGHUGDV5HFKWKDEHQVROOWHZLHDQGHQ(QW ZLFNOXQJVFKDQFHQGLHVLFKDXVGHQÄNXOWXUHOOHQVR]LDOHQXQGVLWWOLFKHQÃ)RUW VFKULWWHQµGHU0HQVFKKHLW³HUJHEHQ'DVVÄGLH)UHLKHLW]XP:RUW³LQVHLQHQ $XJHQHOHPHQWDUH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHLQHVVROFKHQIUHLKHLWVI|UGHUOLFKHQ=XVDP PHQOHEHQVLVW±ZREHLGHU$NWGHU$QUHGHIU-QJHOHUNOlUWHUPDHQGLH$QHU NHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQDOVDQWZRUWIlKLJHV:HVHQLPSOL]LHUW±JLOWLQVEHVRQGHUH GHU)UHLKHLW]XUGHPÄJ|WWOLFKHQ:RUW³YHUSIOLFKWHWHQ5HGH1XUZHQQVLHJH ZlKUOHLVWHWLVWNDQQDXFKGLHFKULVWOLFKH6LFKWGHU0HQVFKHQUHFKWHHLQHNULWLVFK NRQVWUXNWLYH)XQNWLRQIUGLH*HVWDOWXQJJHJHQZlUWLJHU*HVHOOVFKDIWHQHQWIDOWHQ 9RUDXVVHW]XQJGDIULVWDXFKGDVVVLHQLFKWQXUGHQ*ODXEHQGHQHWZDVVDJW VRQGHUQVLFKDXFKÄLQHLQHPVDNXOlULVLHUWHQPRGXVORTXHQGLGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ 9HUQXQIW³]XLPSRQLHUHQYHUPDJ:LHDOOHUGLQJVEHUHLWVREHQPDUNLHUWLVWGLH 5HLFKZHLWHHLQHUVROFKHQhEHUVHW]XQJVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVEHJUHQ]WZHLOVLHGHQ HLQGHXWLJKHLOYROOHQ6LQQYRQ*ODXEHQVDXVVDJHQQLH]XYHUPLWWHOQYHUPDJ6R EOHLEHQDOOHFKULVWOLFKHUVHLWVHLQ]XIRUGHUQGHQSROLWLVFKHQ0DQDKPHQGHU$PEL YDOHQ]YHUKDIWHWLKUHUVHLWV]XPEORHQPRUDOLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLY]XZHUGHQXQG LQVRIHUQEOHLEWVWHWVHLQH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ:HOWOLFKHPXQG*|WWOLFKHP
-h1*(/K -h1*(/ D -h1*(/ (EG $D2 $D2 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
F 'LH$IILQLWlWYRQ&KULVWHQWXPXQG'HPRNUDWLH $OOHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQ]XP7URW]DEHUKlOW-QJHOÄHLQH>@EHVRQGHUH$IILQLWlWGHV FKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQV]XU6WDDWVIRUPGHU'HPRNUDWLH³E]ZGHUÄSDUODPHQWD ULVFKH>Q@'HPRNUDWLH³IUDXVZHLVEDU/HW]WHUHQlPOLFKLVWGLHMHQLJHÄ>X@QWHU GHQUHDOH[LVWLHUHQGHQ6WDDWVIRUPHQ>«@GLHGHQ³FKULVWOLFKHUVHLWVJHJHQEHU 6WDDWHQLP$OOJHPHLQHQ]XIRUPXOLHUHQGHQÄ=XPXWXQJHQPHKUDOVMHGHDQGHUH HQWVSULFKW³'DVVVROFKH$QIRUGHUXQJHQEHUKDXSWOHJLWLPHU:HLVHJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQN|QQHQEHJUQGHW-QJHOPLWbKQOLFKNHLWHQ]ZLVFKHQGHUGHPFKULVWOL FKHQ*ODXEHQJHPlHQ6R]LDOVWUXNWXU±GHU.LUFKH±XQGGHUVWDDWOLFKHQ+DQG OXQJVVSKlUH:LHHULP5HNXUVDXI5|PXQGGLH%DUPHU7KHRORJLVFKH(UNOl UXQJKHUDXVVWUHLFKWVWHOOHQEHLGHQlPOLFK$QDORJLHQGHVDXVVWHKHQGHQ*RWWHV UHLFKVLPLUGLVFKHQGOLFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJGDUZRULQLKUHEHLDOOHQ8QWHUVFKLH GHQ]XNRQVWDWLHUHQGHQ*HPHLQVDPNHLWHQIXHQ'LHVEHVWLPPWVLHDOVÄ,QVWLWX WLRQHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ*RWWHVGLHQVWHV³ZDVVLH]XZHOWOLFKHQ2UWHQPDFKWDQ GHQHQDXIGLIIHUHQWH:HLVHGDVJ|WWOLFKH6R]LDOLGHDOHLQHV=XVDPPHQEHVWHKHQV YRQ*HUHFKWLJNHLWXQG)ULHGHQLQVWHWVJHEURFKHQHU:HLVHDQWL]LSLHUWZLUG:lK UHQGGHU6WDDWKLHUGHPLPSHUDWLYLVFKHQ$QVSUXFKDXIGLH'XUFKVHW]XQJUHFKW PlLJIULHGYROOHU 9HUKlOWQLVVH DXVJHVHW]W LVW GHP HU QRWIDOOV PLW *HZDOW ]X IROJHQVXFKWOHEWGLH.LUFKHYRPLQGLNDWLYLVFKHQ=XVSUXFKHLQHVOlQJVWZLUNOLFK JHZRUGHQHQ+HLOVHLQV$XIJUXQGGLHVHUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ3UlVHQ]GHVKLPPOL VFKHQ,GHDO]XVWDQGVVLQGEHLGH6SKlUHQQLFKWXQPLWWHOEDULQHLQDQGHUEHUVHW] EDURKQHGDPLWHLQGHP(YDQJHOLXPZLGHUVSUHFKHQGHV=ZDQJVV\VWHP]XVFKDI IHQ'HP6WDDWÄGLH6RUJHIUGLHVDOXVSXEOLFDDXI]XJHEHQ ZLHHVELVLQGDV -DKUKXQGHUWJHVFKHKHQLVWXQGLQLVODPLVFKHQ6WDDWHQELVKHXWHJHVFKLHKW ³LVW YRQGDKHUIU-QJHODXVFKULVWOLFKHU6LFKWNHLQH2SWLRQ'DPLWDEHULVWVFKRQ HLQJHZLFKWLJHV.ULWHULXPIRUPXOLHUWGDVÄ]ZLVFKHQEHVVHUHQXQGVFKOHFKWHUHQ 6WDDWVIRUPHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ³ HUODXEW -HGHXWOLFKHUVWDDWOLFKH0DFKWYHUVXFKWZDVDOOHQZRKOWXWXQGZRUDQVLHLKU /HEHQRULHQWLHUHQVROOHQDXV]XEXFKVWDELHUHQGHVWRVFKOHFKWHUIlOOWGHPQDFKGDV 8UWHLO EHU VLH DXV Ä1LFKW GHP 6WDDW VRQGHUQ *RWW JHEKUW GHU JDQ]H 0HQVFK³VFKlUIW-QJHOLQGHVVHQHLQ(UEULQJWGDPLWHLQ&KDUDNWHULVWLNXP ]XP7UDJHQLQ%H]XJDXIGDVGLH.LUFKHLUGLVFKHV$QDORJRQGHVKLPPOLVFKHQ *RWWHVUHLFKHVLVW 1lPOLFKGDGXUFK
-h1*(/H $D29JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 -QJHOZLGPHWGHPHWKLVFKSROLWLVFKHQ*HKDOWGHU%DUPHU7KHRORJLVFKHQ(UNOlUXQJHL QHHLQJHKHQGH8QWHUVXFKXQJLQ -h1*(/K -h1*(/H (EG (EG -h1*(/H
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GDVLHDOVGLH*HPHLQGHJHUHFKWIHUWLJWHU6QGHUGLH*HPHLQVFKDIWGHU>«@YRQ*RWWDOVVHLQH (EHQELOGHUGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWHQ3HUVRQHQLVWGHUHQJDQ]HV/HEHQQXUYRQGHPJDQ]EHDQV SUXFKWZHUGHQGDUIGHUGLHVHV/HEHQJDQ]]XPDFKHQYHUPDJ
'HQ6WDDWEHLVHLQHUHLJHQHQ5HLFK*RWWHVbKQOLFKNHLW]XEHKDIWHQEHGHXWHWLQ GLHVHU+LQVLFKWLKPGLH$FKWXQJGHVXQEHGLQJWHQJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQGHU 3HUVRQDE]XIRUGHUQ'LHV]LHOWDXIGLHEHVDJWH%HJUHQ]XQJVWDDWOLFKHU0DFKWDQ VSUFKH ]XJXQVWHQ GHV 6FKXW]HV GHU 0HQVFKHQZUGH XQG GHU (UP|JOLFKXQJ HLQHVPHQVFKHQZUGLJHQDOVRVHOEVWlQGLJJHIKUWHQ/HEHQV'LHVH6HOEVWlQ GLJNHLWLPSOL]LHUWIUHLH(QWVFKHLGXQJVIlKLJNHLW'DEHLLVWGLH)UHLVHW]XQJGHV *HZLVVHQVLP%OLFNGDVLP.RQWH[WGHU*HPHLQVFKDIWGHU*ODXEHQGHQHLQ]LJHU 2UW HLQHU OHJLWLPHQ 9HUSIOLFKWXQJ GHV (LQ]HOQHQ LVW GHU QXU DEHU GDV HEHQ VFKRQGXUFK*RWWÃJDQ]EHDQVSUXFKWZHUGHQGDUIµ9RQKLHUDXVHUJHKWGLH=X PXWXQJDQGHQ6WDDW*HZLVVHQVIUHLKHLW]XJHZlKUHQVRGDVVGLHlXHUOLFKXQ JH]ZXQJHQH 8QWHURUGQXQJ XQWHU LKQ XQG VHLQ %HVWUHEHQ ]XU 6LFKHUXQJ YRQ 5HFKWXQG)ULHGHQP|JOLFKLVWGLHVLFKDEHUYRQ*RWWKHUQDKHOHJW$XVGHP GHILQLWLYHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQGHU3HUVRQIROJW]XGHPLP.RQWH[WGHU.LUFKHÄGDV JOHLFKH$QVHKHQDOOHU3HUVRQHQ³GLHLKUH8QWHUVFKLHGOLFKNHLWLQGHQ'LHQVW GHV*DQ]HQVWHOOHQVRGDVVNHLQHJUXQGVlW]OLFKHQ+LHUDUFKLHQYRUKHUUVFKHQ9RQ KLHUDXVZLUGGHU6WDDWDXIHLQH*OHLFKKHLWYRUGHP*HVHW]VR]LDOH*HUHFKWLJNHLW XQG0LQGHUKHLWHQVFKXW]YHUSIOLFKWHW$XVGHP%HNHQQWQLV]XPWULQLWDULVFKHQ *RWWUHVXOWLHUWIU-QJHOLQQHUKDOEGHU.LUFKHGLH9HUSIOLFKWXQJ]XJHWHLOWHU 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ9RUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGKDWÄMHGHU6WDDWGHU³±XQGGDVLVWLKP DXFKDXVFKULVWOLFKHU6LFKWDE]XIRUGHUQ± VLFK VHOEVW VR GHILQLHUW GD HU VHLQH +HUUVFKDIW DXI GHU YHUDQWZRUWOLFKHQ %HWlWLJXQJ DOOHU VHLQHU%UJHUDXIEDXWXQGVHLQHHLJHQHQ2UJDQHQLFKWZHQLJHUDQ5HFKWXQG*HVHW]ELQGHWDOV MHGHQVHLQHU%UJHU>«@HLQH$IILQLWlW]XPFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQ
,VWGLH.LUFKHÄHLQHXP9HUJHEXQJLKUHU6FKXOGELWWHQGH*HPHLQVFKDIWYRQDXI LKUH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGXUFK*RWWYHUWUDXHQGHQ6QGHUQ³VROOWHDXFKGHU6WDDW ÄVHLQHXQGVHLQHUPLQLVWUL)HKOHUKDIWLJNHLWXQG6HOEVWJHIlKUGXQJVFKRQLQVHLQHU 6HOEVWGHILQLWLRQ³HLQJHVWHKHQÄXQGVHLQHIDNWLVFKHQ)HKOHUXQG'XPPKHLWHQ]X EHMDKHQXQG]XNRUULJLHUHQEHUHLW³VHLQ³ $OOGLHVHYRQ-QJHOIRUPXOLHUWHQ=XPXWXQJHQDQGHQJHVHW]JHEHQGHQ6WDDW DEHUZHUGHQHEHQVRGHQ%UJHULQQHQXQG%UJHUQDEYHUODQJWGLHGHQ6WDDWLQ GLHVHU:HLVHEHJUHLIHQ]XVHLQHU9HUEHVVHUXQJEHLWUDJHQDEHUDXFKEHMDKHQ VROOHQ'DEHLJHKWHVVWHWVGDUXPZLH*HRUJ3IOHLGHUHU]XVDPPHQIDVVWÄGHQ 6WDDW³ZLHGLHLQLKPOHEHQGHQ3HUVRQHQDQGLHMHHLJHQHÄRQWRORJLVFKH%HVWLP PXQJ]XÃHULQQHUQµ³GLHDXVGHU8UVSUXQJVUHODWLRQ*RWWHV]XP0HQVFKHQIROJW
(EG $D2 $D2 $D2 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
ZDVOHW]WOLFKDXIGLHÄ$EZHLVXQJYRQ7RWDOLVLHUXQJVWHQGHQ]HQ³MHGZHGHU$UW KLQDXVOlXIW'HQQQXUÄ*RWWJHEKUWGHUJDQ]H0HQVFK³ZREHLGLH)UDJHLVW REGLHVHU*RWW]XJHVWDQGHQH7RWDOLWlWVDQVSUXFKGDYRUJHIHLWLVWDOVHLQUHDNWLR QlUHV*HJHQPRGHOO]XP|JOLFKHQSROLWLVFKHQ$EVROXWLVPHQHQWODUYW]XZHUGHQ %LRHWKLVFKH*UXQGIUDJHQ =XU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV1RFK1LFKWXQG1LFKW PHKUOHLVWXQJVIlKLJHQ/HEHQV $XVGHUUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKHQ(LQVLFKWGDVVHVÄJHUDGHGDVYRU*RWWXQG 0HQVFKHQVFKXOGLJJHZRUGHQHXQGLPPHUZLHGHUVFKXOGLJZHUGHQGH,FK>LVW@ GDVGXUFKGDVJ|WWOLFKH5HFKWGHU*QDGHDOV3HUVRQGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWZRUGHQ LVW XQG DOVR LP 6LQQH HLQHV XQ]HUVW|UEDUHQ ,QGLNDWLYV XQDQWDVWEDUH :UGH KDW³IROJHQIU-QJHODXFK.RQVHTXHQ]HQIUGHQ8PJDQJPLWEHVWLPPWHQ ELRHWKLVFKHQ*UXQGIUDJHQ,P%OLFNLVWGDEHLGDV3UREOHPZDQQHLJHQWOLFKPHQ VFKHQZUGLJHV/HEHQEHJLQQWXQGZDQQHVHQGHW.DQQHLQ5HNXUVDXIPHQ VFKOLFKH+DQGOXQJVP|JOLFKNHLWHQIUGLHDOOHLQJ|WWOLFKEHJUQGHWH:UGHGHU 3HUVRQDXV-QJHOV6LFKWNHLQHUOHL5HOHYDQ]KDEHQJLOWGLHVLQVEHVRQGHUHDXFK IUGHUHQ(UPDQJHOXQJDP/HEHQVDQIDQJXQGDP/HEHQVHQGH:RHLQ6LFKYHU ZLUNOLFKHQGXUFKVHLJHQH7XQQRFKQLFKWRGHUQLFKWPHKU]XU2SWLRQZHUGHQ NDQQVLHKWHUGHQ9RUUDQJGHUGHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWHQ3HUVRQYRULKUHQ:HUNHQ VRJDUDXINRQ]HQWULHUWH:HLVHHUNHQQEDUZHUGHQ ,QVRIHUQVLQGÄ*HEXUWXQG 7RG>«@NRQVWLWXWLYH(OHPHQWHGHU:UGHGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ3HUVRQ³ZHLOVLH DOV%HJUHQ]XQJHQGHUÄ]ZLVFKHQ/HEHQVDQIDQJXQG/HEHQVHQGHVLFKHUHLJQHQ GHQ/HEHQVJHVFKLFKWH³GHUHQDOOHP+DQGHOQOHW]WOLFKXQYHUIJEDUH+HUNXQIW XQG=XNXQIWDQ]HLJHQ'DV%HVRQGHUHGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQVEHVWHKWJHUDGH GDULQ GLHVH (LQVFKUlQNXQJ GHU HLJHQHQ 6FKDIIHQVNUDIW QLFKW DOV %HGURKXQJ GXUFK GLH GDULQ DXIVFKHLQHQGH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLJHQHQ 1LFKWVHLQV DQ]XVHKHQ $XVVFKODJJHEHQGGDIULVWGHVVHQÄ*HZLKHLW>«@GDGHU0HQVFK>«@YRQ HLQHPLKQXPVHLQHUVHOEVWZLOOHQZROOHQGHQXQGEHMDKHQGHQ6FK|SIHUEHJUHQ]W LVW³ 6LFK GXUFK *RWW XQG GHVKDOE GHILQLWLY DQHUNDQQW ]X ZLVVHQ EHGHXWHW GHPQDFKGLHHLJHQH(QGOLFKNHLWDOVJHZLFKWLJHQ7HLOGHUHLJHQHQ,GHQWLWlWDQ ]XQHKPHQGHULKUDOOHUHUVWÄGLHNRQNUHWH%HVWLPPWKHLWHLQHUHLQPDOLJHQXQG XQYHUZHFKVHOEDUHQ*HOHJHQKHLW³YHUOHLKW6LH]XHUJUHLIHQEHGHXWHWGDQQGDV $QHUNDQQWVHLQGXUFK*RWWVHLQHUVHLWV]XEHMDKHQXQGHWZDVQlPOLFKHLQHLQGLYL
3)/(,'(5(5 -h1*(/H -h1*(/J 'LHVLVWVHLQHLPPHUZLHGHUDOVVR]LDOHWKLVFKH.RQVHTXHQ]GHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVDUWLNHOV IRUPXOLHUWH$QVLFKW YJOXD-h1*(/ D F I -h1*(/J $D2 (EG (EG
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GXHOOH/HEHQVJHVFKLFKWHGDUDXV]XPDFKHQRKQHVLFKGDGXUFKDEHULP*DQ]HQ VHOEVWÄPDFKHQ³]XN|QQHQ/HW]WHUHVZlUHKLQJHJHQHLQGLHHLJHQHQ*UHQ]HQ JHUDGHQLFKWDQQHKPHQGHUXQGJHJHQ*RWWHVUHODWLRQVRQWRORJLVFKJUXQGJHOHJWHQ $QVSUXFKYHUVWRHQGHU9HUVXFKVLFKJHZLVVHUPDHQ]X=LHOXQG+HUNXQIWVHL QHUVHOEVW]XHUKHEHQ-QJHOVHW]WVLFKGDEHLPLW3RVLWLRQHQDXVHLQDQGHUGLH ÄXQWHU%HUXIXQJDXIGLH:UGH>«@GHU3HUVRQGDVEHIULVWHWH/HEHQGHV0HQ VFKHQGXUFKPHQVFKOLFKH(QWVFKHLGXQJ]XYHUNU]HQIRUGHUQ³±XQG]ZDULP %OLFNDXIGHQZHUGHQGHQ0HQVFKHQ D XQGLP%OLFNDXIGHQDOWHQ0HQVFKHQ E D 'HUZHUGHQGH0HQVFK ,P %OLFN DXI GHQ /HEHQVDQIDQJ LVW GLHV 3HWHU 6LQJHU EHL GHP GDV XQHLQJH VFKUlQNWH'DVHLQVUHFKWYRQ6lXJOLQJHQXQGGDPLWGLH8QUHFKWPlLJNHLWYRQ 6lXJOLQJVW|WXQJHQLQ)UDJHJHVWHOOWZLUG:DV-QJHODQGHUYLHOGLVNXWLHUWHQ 7KHVH GHV DXVWUDOLVFKHQ 0RUDOSKLORVRSKHQ NULWLVFK KHUYRUKHEW LVW GHU GDIU PDJHEOLFKH3HUVRQEHJULII3HUVRQDOLWlWNRPPWIUGHQDXI-RKQ/RFNHUHNXUULH UHQGHQ6LQJHUQXUUDWLRQDOHQXQGPLWHLQHP%HZXVVWVHLQLKUHUVHOEVWXQGLQVEH VRQGHUH LKUHU *HVFKLFKWOLFKNHLW DXVJHVWDWWHWHQ :HVHQ ]X1XU ZHU LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH3HUVRQLVWYHUIJWGHPQDFKEHUHLQXQEHVFKUlQNWHV/HEHQVUHFKWRGHU YHUN|USHUWHLQHQ]XDFKWHQGHQ:HUWZRIUHEHQGLHUHLQH=XJHK|ULJNHLW]XU PHQVFKOLFKHQ6SH]LHVQLFKWDXVUHLFKW,VWDEHUZLH-QJHOGHPHQWJHJHQVWHOOW GDVPHQVFKOLFKH3HUVRQVHLQDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWH[WHUQGKGXUFKJ|WWOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJNRQVWLWXLHUWXQGKlQJWGLHGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQGH:UGHVRQDFK QLFKWDQGHPRQVWULHUEDUHQ)lKLJNHLWHQNDQQGHUHQ(LQ]XJVEHUHLFKNHLQHVIDOOV GHUDUWOLPLWLHUWZHUGHQ9LHOPHKU YHUELHWHWHVVLFK>«@GHQ%HJULIIGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQVXQWHUGHQ%HJULIIGHV:HUWHV]X VXEVXPLHUHQXQGGHPHQWVSUHFKHQG]ZLVFKHQPHKUXQGZHQLJHUOHEHQVZHUWHP0HQVFKHQOHEHQ RGHUJDU]ZLVFKHQOHEHQVZHUWHPXQGOHEHQVXQZHUWHP/HEHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ
-QJHONHKUW6LQJHUV%HJUQGXQJVORJLN JHUDGH]XXP ZHQQHUGHQ:HUWGHV /HEHQVQLFKWDQKDQGGHUHUEHXUWHLOWZLVVHQZLOOGLHQRFKHWZDVZROOHQXQGN|Q QHQVRQGHUQGLHMHQLJHQ]XP0DVWDEHUKHEWGLHÄZLH.OHLQNLQGHU8UDOWHDEHU DXFK'HELOH³HLQH0HQVFKOLFKNHLWÄRKQHMHGHQW]OLFKH(LJHQVFKDIW³YHUN|U SHUQ 'DVVGHU3HUVRQEHJULIIDOV5HODWLRQVEHJULII]XGHQNHQXQGGHUSHUVRQDOYHU IDVVWH0HQVFKGHPQDFKGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJHUVHOEVWLVWKDWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQ ÄZHLWUHLFKHQGH)ROJHQ³LP%OLFNDXIÄGLH)UDJHQDFKGHP6WDWXVGHVPHQVFKOL
$D2 9JO6,1*(5EHVII -h1*(/J $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
FKHQ(PEU\RV³,QWHUHVVDQWHUZHLVHDUJXPHQWLHUWHUDQGLHVHU6WHOOHDEHUQLFKW VFK|SIXQJVWKHRORJLVFKVRQGHUQHUKHEWGLH'LPHQVLRQGHV6R]LDOHQ]XPHQW VFKHLGHQGHQ)DNWRU%HGDUIQlPOLFKÄ>G@LHEHIUXFKWHWH(L]HOOH>«@GHU0XWWHU XPVLFK]XHLQHP0HQVFKHQHQWZLFNHOQ]XN|QQHQ³LQVRIHUQÄHUVWQDFK:RFKHQ HQJVWHU:HFKVHOZLUNXQJPLWGHPPWWHUOLFKHQ2UJDQLVPXVHLQEHUOHEHQVIlKL JHU0HQVFKJHERUHQZLUG³HUVFKHLQW-QJHOGLH$QVLFKWÄGDVPHQVFKOLFKH/H EHQ VHL YRP =HLWSXQNW GHU %HIUXFKWXQJ DQ ÃHLQ HPEU\RQDOHU 0HQVFKµ >«@ K|FKVWSUREOHPDWLVFK³ (UVWDOVRZRPDQPLW)XJXQG5HFKWYRQHLQHPZHU GHQGHQ0HQVFKHQVSUHFKHQNDQQLVWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQDXFKGLH.DWHJRULHGHU 0HQVFKHQZUGHLQGHQ0XQG]XQHKPHQ,QGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJYHUZHLVWHU DXIVHLQHQ6FKOHU-RKDQQHV)LVFKHUGHUGHP(PEU\R6FKXW]ZUGLJNHLWYRP DQWL]LSLHUWHQ(QGHKHU]XVFKUHLEW :DVGDVÄÃ(WZDVµGHV(PEU\RV>PLW@GH>P@DQ GLHVHP VHOEVW QLFKW DXIZHLVEDUHQ Ã-HPDQGµ GHU>«@ PLW GHU *HEXUW >«@ DOV 3HUVRQLQQHUKDOEGHU*HPHLQVFKDIWH[LVWLHUHQGHU3HUVRQHQLQ(UVFKHLQXQJWUHWHQ ZLUG³ YHUELQGHW LVW GHPQDFK GDV YRUZHJJHQRPPHQH (QGH GLHVHU (QWZLFN OXQJ'LHVHVLVWDEHUQXUGDQQVLQQYROO]XDQWL]LSLHUHQZRVHLQ(LQWUHWHQQLFKW Y|OOLJXQZDKUVFKHLQOLFKLVWZRYRQHEHQÄ>E@HLGHU0HKU]DKOGHU(PEU\RQHQ GLH GLH 1DWXU YHUVFKZHQGHULVFK HQWVWHKHQ OlVVW >«@ QLFKW GLH 5HGH VHLQ³ NDQQ,P%OLFNDXI-QJHOV3RVLWLRQ]HLJWVLFKKLHUDEHUHLQHGHXWOLFKH6SDQ QXQJ HLQHUVHLWVZLUGGHUhEHUJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ(WZDVXQG-HPDQGDQHLQHUVR]LD OHQ=XVFKUHLEXQJIHVWJHPDFKWGLHVLFKYRQQDWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHU(UNHQQWQLV EHUGLH0|JOLFKNHLWGDVVDXVGHPHWZDVDXFKMHPDQGZLUGOHLWHQOlVVW DXIGHU DQGHUHQ6HLWHVWHKWGHU$QVSUXFKGDVVÄGLH3HUVRQ>«@GDGXUFKNRQVWLWXLHUW >ZLUG@GDGHU0HQVFK³RKQHLUJHQGZHOFKHHPSLULVFKHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQÄGDV YRQ*RWWDQJHVSURFKHQHXQG>«@GHILQLWLYDQHUNDQQWH/HEHZHVHQLVW³ 6RJHKW-QJHOLQVHLQHP%LRHWKLVFKH$SRULHQEHUVFKULHEHQHQ%HLWUDJ]XP 3UREOHPGHU3UlLPSODQWDWLRQVGLDJQRVWLNXQG6WDPP]HOOIRUVFKXQJEHUGLH%H VFKUHLEXQJ HEHQVROFKHU $SRULHQ LQ GLH MHGH HLQGHXWLJ SRVLWLYH XQG QHJDWLYH 3RVLWLRQLHUXQJ]XGHQEHQDQQWHQ)RUVFKXQJVIHOGHUQIKUHQDXFKJDUQLFKWKL QDXV9LHOPHKUGLHQWGLHWKHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHDXIGLH:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQ KLHUOHW]WOLFKQXUGHP(LQVFKlUIHQVHOEVWHLQUHODWLRQDOHV:HVHQ]XVHLQGDV ÄPHQVFKOLFKHV/HEHQQLFKWIUDQGHUHV/HEHQLQVWUXPHQWDOLVLHUHQ³VROO:DQQ GLH9HUGLQJOLFKXQJ$QGHUHUEHJLQQWOlVVWVLFKDEHUDQVFKHLQHQGQLFKWIUMHGH /HEHQVODJHDXVGHU7KHVHDEOHLWHQGHU0HQVFKVHLGXUFK*RWWNRQVWLWXLHUW
-h1*(/L $D2 ),6&+(5)LVFKHUQLPPWKLHU)RUPXOLHUXQJHQDXVHLQHPIUKHUHQ$XIVDW]ZLH GHUDXIGHULQ-h1*(/L$QP]LWLHUWZLUG ),6&+(5 -h1*(/D $D2
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
E 'HUDOWH0HQVFK 1HEHQ GHP /HEHQVDQIDQJ LVW DXFK GDV 7KHPD GHV /HEHQVHQGHV DXV -QJHOV UHFKWVIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWYRQJURHU5HOHYDQ]'DEHLJHKWHVQLFKW QXUXPGLH)UDJHGHU6WHUEHKLOIHE]ZGHVDVVLVWLHUWHQ6XL]LGVVRQGHUQLPDOO JHPHLQHUHQXPGHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ8PJDQJPLWlOWHUZHUGHQGHQXQGVRXQ ZHLJHUOLFKLQLKUHU/HLVWXQJVNUDIWDEQHKPHQGHQ0HQVFKHQ Ä'HUDOWH0HQVFK³VREHPHUNW-QJHONULWLVFKÄLVW>«@LQGHU/HLVWXQJVJH VHOOVFKDIW GHU QLFKW DQHUNDQQWH 0HQVFK³ $QHUNHQQXQJ LP 6LQQH VR]LDOHU :HUWVFKlW]XQJZLUGGRUWQlPOLFKVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVYRUDOOHPGHQHQ]XWHLOGLH HLQHQ%HLWUDJ]XU9HUEHVVHUXQJGHUDOOJHPHLQHQ/HEHQVEHGLQJXQJHQ]XWlWLJHQ YHUP|JHQÄ2KQH/HLVWXQJVVWHLJHUXQJNHLQH6WHLJHUXQJGHU/HEHQVTXDOLWlW³ ODXWHWGDVGLHIRUWVFKUHLWHQGH(QWZLFNOXQJGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWDQ WUHLEHQGH *HVHW] 'RFK ]HLWLJW GLHVHU ÄJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH>@ =ZDQJ ]XU /HLV WXQJ³ GHVVHQ KHKUHV =LHO -QJHO DXVGUFNOLFK QLFKW DEVWUHLWHQ ZLOO VHLQHU JXWHQ,QWHQWLRQZLGHUVSUHFKHQGH5HVXOWDWH(LQHUVHLWVGHQNWHUKLHUDQGLHXQ JOHLFKH9HUWHLOXQJYRQ]XQHKPHQGHQ/HLVWXQJVDQIRUGHUXQJHQXQGGDGXUFKHUDU EHLWHWHP*HZLQQGLHHUDEHUIUSROLWLVFKZHLWJHKHQGO|VEDUKlOW6FKZHUZLH JHQGHUHUVFKHLQWLKPDQGHUHUVHLWVGHULQGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ6WHLJHUXQJVORJLN LPSOL]LHUWH:HUWPDVWDEGHP]XIROJHGLH*WHPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQVDQGHVVHQ 2SWLPLHUXQJVSRWHQ]LDOKlQJW6RDEHUJHUlWGDVPLWGHPXQHQWULQQEDUHQ$EEDX YRQ /HLVWXQJVIlKLJNHLW HLQKHUJHKHQGH $OWHU DXV GHP 6LFKWIHOG GHU VR]LDOHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVRSWLN$QGLHVHU6WHOOHLVWLQ-QJHOV$XJHQÄGLHFKULVWOLFKH:DKU KHLWEHUGHQ0HQVFKHQDOVNULWLVFKH=XPXWXQJDQ.LUFKHXQG*HVHOOVFKDIWHLQ VLFKWLJXQGSUDNWL]LHUEDU³]XPDFKHQ 'LHVH=XPXWXQJNDQQHUJDQ]DOOJHPHLQVR]XP$XVGUXFNEULQJHQGDVVGLH 5HGHYRQHLQHU4XDOLWlWGHV/HEHQV]XHUVWHLQHGLHVHPVHOEVW]XNRPPHQGH(L JHQVFKDIWLVW:RPDQVLHDNWLY]XVWHLJHUQYHUVXFKWZLUGGHPQDFKVFKRQYRP MHHLJHQHQ$P/HEHQ6HLQ*HEUDXFKJHPDFKW(VZHUGHQGDQQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQ YHUZLUNOLFKWGLHGHP/HEHQVHOEVWLQQHZRKQHQ'HUHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJEHVFKUHLEW -QJHODOVOHJLWLPHQ9HUVXFKGHV0HQVFKHQVLFKPLWVHLQHU/HEHQGLJNHLW]X LGHQWLIL]LHUHQXPVLH]XHLQHUPHQVFKOLFKHQDOVRVHLQHUHLJHQHQ$QJHOHJHQKHLW ]XPDFKHQ'RFKÄ>JHOLQJW@GLH,GHQWLWlWYRQ/HEHQGLJNHLWXQG0HQVFKOLFKNHLW³ QXUZHQQVLHÄDXFKGDV$OWHUDOV%HVFKUlQNXQJGHU/HEHQGLJNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ XQGGH>Q@7RGDOVGDV]HLWOLFKH(QGHGHU/HEHQGLJNHLW³HLQEHJUHLIW 'LHVHVLFKWEDUHQ$Q]HLFKHQHLQHUIXQGDPHQWDOHQ%HJUHQ]WKHLWPHQVFKOLFKHU 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVP|JOLFKNHLWHQDOVVROFKHLQV$XJH]XIDVVHQ±JHQDXGDV ZLUGGHU/HLVWXQJVJHVHOOVFKDIWGXUFKGHQFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQ]XJHPXWHW'LH
-h1*(/G 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGHLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 $D2 $D2 I $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VHUQlPOLFKUHGHWÄYRQ*RWWVR>«@GDVHLQH0HQVFKZHUGXQJ±ELVKLQ]XP 7RGHDP.UHX]±DOV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHVVHLQ0HQVFKVHLQYHUIHKOHQGHQ0HQ VFKHQ]XU*HOWXQJJHEUDFKWZLUG³ 'DPLWDEHULVWIU-QJHOEHNDQQWOLFKQLFKWV DQGHUHVJHVDJWDOVÄGDGHU0HQVFKLQVHLQHP0HQVFKVHLQYRU*RWWDQHUNDQQW LVWRKQHGDIUHWZDVWXQ]XPVVHQRGHUDXFKQXUWXQ]XN|QQHQ³:DVGHP QDFKIUDOOHXQGMHGHQJLOWZLUGJHUDGHDPDOWHQ0HQVFKHQSDUVSURWRWRVLFKW EDU ,Q VHLQHP ZDFKVHQGHQ 8QYHUP|JHQ GLH HLJHQH /HEHQVTXDOLWlW DNWLY ]X YHUPHKUHQ]HLFKQHWVLFKGLHPLWGHP7RGHQGJOWLJHUUHLFKWH*UHQ]HKXPDQHU 2SWLPLHUXQJVIlKLJNHLWEHUHLWVDE:RVLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFK]XJXQVWHQGHV,GHDOV XQEHJUHQ]WHU4XDOLWlWVVWHLJHUXQJDXVJHEOHQGHWZLUGJHUlWVRQDFKHLQZHVHQWOL FKHV'HILQLWLRQVPHUNPDOGHV0HQVFKHQDXVGHP%OLFN 'DVVHUEHUGDV)DNWXP VHLQHU/HEHQGLJNHLWHEHQVRZHQLJYHUIJHQNDQQZLHHUVLFKVHLQHUGDPLWJHVHW] WHQ%HVFKUlQNWKHLW]XHQWOHGLJHQYHUPDJÄ'HUFKULVWOLFKH*ODXEH³VRIROJHUW -QJHOÄZLUGGHVKDOEJHUDGHZHLOHUGLH6WHLJHUXQJGHU4XDOLWlWPHQVFKOLFKHQ /HEHQV]XHLQHPLPPHUQRFKPHQVFKOLFKHUHQ/HEHQEHMDKWGDUDXIEHVWHKHQ GD0HQVFKHQQLFKWHUVWGXUFKLKUH/HLVWXQJHQPHQVFKOLFKZHUGHQ³9LHOPHKU VLQGVLHGLHVDXFKXQGLPPHUVFKRQZRVLHQRFKQLFKWVRGHUQLFKWVPHKUWXQ N|QQHQ±GDIUVWHKWGLHFKULVWOLFKNRPPXQL]LHUWH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ GXUFK*RWW$XVLKUHP$QVSUXFKUHVXOWLHUWGDVVÄ/HLVWXQJVVWHLJHUXQJ>«@QXU GDQQDOVPHQVFKOLFKEHXUWHLOWZHUGHQ>NDQQ@ZHQQVLHHLQVFKOLHWGDGHUOHLV WXQJVXQIlKLJH0HQVFKLQJOHLFKHU:HLVHDQHUNDQQWZLUGZLHGHUIUGLH9HUEHV VHUXQJGHU/HEHQVTXDOLWlW$UEHLWHQGH³'DQQDEHULVWVR]LDOH:HUWVFKlW]XQJ LQ-QJHOV$XJHQHEHQIDOOVLP.ULWHULXPHLQHV%HLWUDJV]XPJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ )RUWNRPPHQYHUDQNHUW-HGRFKZLUGÄGHUDOWH0HQVFKJHUDGHGDGXUFKGDHU SULPlUDOV1HKPHQGHU5HSUlVHQWDQWGHU0HQVFKHQZUGHLVWLPHPLQHQWHQ6LQQH HLQ*HEHQGHU³LQVRIHUQHUÄGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWGXUFKVHLQEORHV'DVHLQ]XYHUVWH KHQ³JLEWÄGDGHU0HQVFKHEHQLQVHLQHPEORHQ'DVHLQEHUHLWVHLQ*HEHQGHU LVW³(UHULQQHUWGDQQGDUDQGDVVGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQDOVPHQ VFKOLFKQLFKWYRQGHVVHQ7DWHQDEKlQJWXQGDEKlQJHQGDUIVRQGHUQLKPXQDE KlQJLJGDYRQ]XNRPPW±ZHLOVLHYRQ*RWWNRPPW /DUV&KDUERQQLHUDEHUZHLVWWUHIIHQGDXIHLQH$PELYDOHQ]YRQ-QJHOV'HX WXQJ GHV DOWHQ 0HQVFKHQ DOV Ã5HSUlVHQWDQW GHU 0HQVFKHQZUGHµ KLQ GLHVHU ZHUGHVREHLDOOHPZDVHUDXFKGDGXUFK]XJHEHQKDWDXIVHLQHSDUDGLJPDWL VFKHÄ([LVWHQ]DOV1HKPHQGHU>«@IHVWJHVFKULHEHQ³ZREHLVLFKGLH)UDJHVWHOOH REGDVHLQÄDOWH0HQVFKHQ>«@LQLKUHP/HEHQVZHUWJHIKOVWHLJHUQGHV6HOEVW ELOG³VHL6HLQH$QIUDJHEHWULIIWMHQVHLWVGHVNRQNUHWHQ%HLVSLHOVGDVIU-Q
$D2 (EG (EG (EG $D2I &+$5%211,(5
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
JHOQLFKWRKQH*UXQGUHSUlVHQWDWLYH)XQNWLRQKDWDEHUHLJHQWOLFKGLHDV\PPHWUL VFKH.RQVWHOODWLRQLP*RWW0HQVFK9HUKlOWQLVPLWLKUHUVWDUNHQ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ$NWLYLWlWXQG3DVVLYLWlW 0LWGHPDXFKGDV/HEHQVHQGHEHWUHIIHQGHQ7KHPDGHUDNWLYHQ6WHUEHKLOIH VHW]WVLFK-QJHOXQWHUGHUDOOJHPHLQHUHQ)UDJHVWHOOXQJDXVHLQDQGHUZDVHLQ ÄÃPHQVFKHQZUGLJH>V@6WHUEHQµ³RGHUHLQÄÃPHQVFKHQZUGLJH>U@8PJDQJPLW GHP6WHUEHQµ³VHLQN|QQWH'DEHLXQWHUVFKHLGHWHU]ZLVFKHQÄGHPHWKLVFKHQ 9HUERWHLQHQ0HQVFKHQJHZDOWVDPDP6WHUEHQ]XKLQGHUQ³XQGGHPYRQ$XWR UHQZLH:DOWHU-HQVXQG+DQV.QJ±VHLQHV(UDFKWHQVIlOVFKOLFKHUZHLVH±LP 1DPHQGHU0HQVFKHQZUGHHUKREHQHQÄ*HERW>«@GHU±RIWJHQXJHUElUPOL FKHQ±3KDVHGHV6WHUEHQVGDGXUFK]XYRU]XNRPPHQGDPDQGLHVH3KDVHLP 1DPHQGHU+XPDQLWlWJHZDOWVDPDENU]W³/HEHQVHUKDOWHQGH0DQDKPHQ DE]XVWHOOHQRGHUVLFKHLQHUPHGL]LQLVFKHQ%HKDQGOXQJ]XHQW]LHKHQQlPOLFKLVW -QJHO]XIROJHHWZDVNDWHJRULDODQGHUHVDOVHLQHJH]LHOWH7|WXQJDXI9HUODQJHQ RGHUGHUDVVLVWLHUWH6XL]LG(LQHJHZDOWVDPHDOVRGHQ%HWURIIHQHQEHUJHKHQGH 9HUVFKOHSSXQJGHV/HEHQVHQGHVKLQJHJHQQLPPWVLFKHEHQVRHWKLVFKEHGHQNOLFK DXV ZLHGHVVHQ)RUFLHUXQJ]XJXQVWHQHLQHV YHUPHLQWOLFKHQ Ä5HFKW>V@GDUDXI XQEHVFKlGLJW]X(QGH]XJHKHQ³$XIHLQVROFKHV5HFKWDEHUSRFKHQVR-Q JHOGLH%HIUZRUWHUDNWLYHU6WHUEHKLOIHXQGEHUXIHQVLFKGDIUDXIGLH:UGH GHV0HQVFKHQZRGXUFKVLH]XJOHLFKHLQ8UWHLOEHUGHUHQ5HLFKZHLWHIlOOHQ $P*UDGVHLQHU%HVFKlGLJXQJRGHUDP0DVHLQHU(UWUlJOLFKNHLWDEHUOlVVWVLFK GHUPHQVFKHQZUGLJH&KDUDNWHUHLQHV/HEHQVQLFKWWD[LHUHQÄ,P*HJHQWHLO ZHU GDVEHVFKlGLJWHPHQVFKOLFKH/HEHQQLFKWHUWUlJWGHUHUWUlJWLQ:DKUKHLWGLH :UGHQLFKWGLHGHU0HQVFKDXFKLQGHQHUElUPOLFKVWHQ/HEHQVXPVWlQGHQXQ ZLGHUUXIOLFKKDW³'LHVHÃXQZLGHUUXIOLFKH:UGHµHQWKlOWVRJHVHKHQ]XJOHLFK GLHQLFKW]XZLGHUUXIHQGH9HUSIOLFKWXQJDXFKDQJHVLFKWVHLJHQHU%HVFKlGLJXQ JHQGDVHLJHQH/HEHQJOHLFKVDPGDQNEDUDXV*RWWHV+DQGHQWJHJHQ]XQHKPHQ XQGQLFKWEHUHVYHUIJHQ]XZROOHQ,QOHW]WHU.RQVHTXHQ]ZUGHGLHVDXIHLQH $UWYRQ/HLGHQVSIOLFKWKLQDXVODXIHQ 'DVV-QJHOLQEHVRQGHUHGHQ1RFKQLFKWRGHU1LFKWPHKUOHLVWXQJVIlKLJHQ 0HQVFKHQDOV5HSUlVHQWDQWHQGHULQJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJEHJUQGHWHQ0HQ VFKHQZUGHKHUDXVVWHOOWKDWDXFK)ROJHQIUVHLQH%HXUWHLOXQJGHUDXI$UEHLW XQG/HLVWXQJVHW]HQGHQ:LUWVFKDIWVVSKlUH
-h1*(/J $D2-QJHOEH]LHKWVLFKKLHUDXIGDVVHLQHU]HLWDXINRQWURYHUVH'HEDWWHQJHVWRH QH*HPHLQVFKDIWVZHUNYRQ:DOWHU-HQVXQG+DQV.QJPLWGHP7LWHO0HQVFKHQZUGLJ6WHU EHQ YJO-(16.h1* -h1*(/J (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$UEHLWXQG:LUWVFKDIW $QHUNHQQXQJGLHVVHLWVYRQ/HEHQVOHLVWXQJHQ *HZLQQLP+LPPHOXQGDXI(UGHQ±VRODXWHWGHU7LWHOHLQHU6WXGLH(EHUKDUG -QJHOVGLHGHP)UXQG:LGHU|NRQRPLVFKHQ3URILWVWUHEHQVDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYHQDFKJHKW :LHGLHYRQLKPJHZlKOWHhEHUVFKULIWEHUHLWVDQGHXWHW VWHKWHVIU-QJHODXHU)UDJHGDVVÄGDV(PSIDQJHQLUGLVFKHU*WHUXQGGDV (PSIDQJHQHZLJHQ/HEHQVGXUFKDXVDXFKSDUDOOHO]XVWHKHQNRPPHQ>NDQQ@³ =XP%HOHJIKUWHUXDGLHGXUFKGHQ*HEUDXFK|NRQRPLVFKHU0HWDSKHUQJH SUlJWHQ*OHLFKQLVVH-HVXHWZDYRPXQJHUHFKWHQ+DXVKDOWHUDQÄ*HZLQQVWUH EHQGDVODVVHQGLHVH³XQGYLHOHDQGHUHELEOLVFKH7H[WHLQ-QJHOV$XJHQÄXQ PLYHUVWlQGOLFKHUNHQQHQLVWPHQVFKOLFK³OlVVWVLFKDOVRQLFKWSHUVHGLVNUH GLWLHUHQ-HGRFKÄNRPPWHV>«@GDUDXIDQQDFKGHPUHFKWHQ*HZLQQ]XVWUH EHQ³ZDVNRQNUHWEHGHXWHWÄEHLPLUGLVFKHQ*HZLQQVWUHEHQGHQ*HZLQQHZLJHQ /HEHQVQLFKWDXIV6SLHO]XVHW]HQ³'DVWLWHOJHEHQGH(QWVSUHFKXQJVYHUKlOWQLV JLOWGHPQDFKQXUVRODQJHGHU9RURUGQXQJGHUKLPPOLVFKHQYRUGLHLUGLVFKHQ 'LQJHLPZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ+DQGHOQHQWVSURFKHQZLUG'DEHLZHLVLFK-QJHO HLQLJPLWGHQ5HIRUPDWRUHQ/XWKHUXQG&DOYLQGLHXQEHVFKDGHWLKUHUGLIIHUHQ WHQ%HXUWHLOXQJGHV=LQVQHKPHQVGHPJHJHQEHUGHU*HQIHU5HIRUPDWRUZHLW DXVRIIHQHUHLQJHVWHOOWZDUDOVVHLQ:LWWHQEHUJHU.ROOHJHGRFKLQHLQHUJUXQG VlW]OLFKHQhEHU]HXJXQJ]XVDPPHQNRPPHQ 'DVVGLHFKULVWOLFKH)UHLKHLWDXFK LP|NRQRPLVFKHQ%HUHLFKDOOHLQYHUPLWWHOVGHVOLHEHYROOHQ'LHQVWHVDP1lFK VWHQ]XZDKUHU(UIOOXQJNRPPW6FKRQGDV$OWH7HVWDPHQWZRÄGHP*H ZLQQVWUHEHQVRIHUQHVDXI.RVWHQDQGHUHUJHVFKLHKWVWUHQJH*UHQ]HQ³JH]R JHQVLQGVLHKW-QJHOZLUWVFKDIWVHWKLVFKDXIGLHVHU/LQLH6RIXHQGHVVHQ%H VWLPPXQJHQ]XP=LQVYHUERW]XP6FKXOGHQHUODVVXQG]XU6NODYHQIUHLODVVXQJLQ GHU Ä*RWWHVEH]LHKXQJ³ GLH ÄKLHU GHXWOLFK VR]LDO JHIDW >LVW@ VLH VFKOLHW GLH %H]LHKXQJ]XP SROLWLVFKXQGWKHRORJLVFKGHILQLHUWHQ 1lFKVWHQE]Z]XÃJDQ] ,VUDHOµHLQ³$XFKEHL-HVXVXQG3DXOXVHQWVFKHLGHWZLH-QJHOIHVWKlOWGLH MHZHLOVDXVVFKODJJHEHQGH±UHOLJL|VHXQGGDULQVR]LDOH±*UXQGHLQVWHOOXQJEHU GLH /HJLWLPLWlW JHZLQQRULHQWLHUWHQ |NRQRPLVFKHQ +DQGHOQV 'DIU VWHKW GLH MHVXDQLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ*RWWHV XQG0DPPRQVGLHQVW PLWGHUVHLQHV (UDFKWHQVQLFKWQXUDOWHUQDWLYH+HU]HQVDXVULFKWXQJHQVRQGHUQYRUDOOHPHLQDQ GHUZLGHUVWUHLWHQGH*OHLFKKHLWVSULQ]LSLHQYRUVWHOOLJJHPDFKWZHUGHQÄ'LHELEOL VFKH:DKUKHLWGDHVYRU*RWWNHLQ$QVHKHQGHU3HUVRQJLEWJHZLQQWLQGHU HPSLULVFKHQ:DKUKHLWGDHVDXFKYRUGHP*HOGNHLQ$QVHKHQGHU3HUVRQJLEW
9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQZHQQQLFKWDQGHUVDQJHJHEHQLQVJHVDPW -h1*(/I± 'LH$XVIKUXQJHQZXUGHQWHLOZHLVHEHUHLWVYHU|IIHQWOLFKWLQ 7(7=/$))D $D2 $D2 (EG 9JO]X-QJHOV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW/XWKHUXQG&DOYLQDD2± $D2 (EG
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
HLQH NRQNXUULHUHQGH 3DUDOOHOH³ VFKUHLEW -QJHO XQG UHNXUULHUW GDPLW VWLOO VFKZHLJHQGDXIHLQH7KHVH0D[:HEHUV)U:HEHUQlPOLFKIROJWDXVGHUJHJHQ PRUDOLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHLPPXQLVLHUHQGHQÄ(LJHQJHVHW]OLFKNHLW³GHVNDSLWDOLVWL VFKHQ0DUNWHVGDVVGLHVHUÄQXU$QVHKHQGHU6DFKHNHLQ$QVHKHQGHU3HUVRQ NHLQH%UGHUOLFKNHLWVXQG3LHWlWVSIOLFKWHQ³NHQQWZHLOVHLQH$NWHXUHDOOHLQYRQ ÄUDWLRQDOH>Q@ =ZHFNLQWHUHVVHQ³ JHOHLWHW VLQG 'D]X JHK|UW ]XY|UGHUVW GDV ,QWHUHVVH DQ *HZLQQPD[LPLHUXQJ DXI GHVVHQ *UXQGODJH GHU 0HQVFK OHW]WHQ (QGHVRKQH%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJVHLQHUGDUEHUKLQDXVJHKHQGHQ(LJHQDUWHQWZHGHU DOV SUREDWHV 0LWWHO RGHU DOV DXV]XVFKDOWHQGHV +LQGHUQLV HUVFKHLQW :DV DEHU EHGHXWHWGHPJHJHQEHUGLH(LQVLFKWYRU*RWWJHEHHVNHLQ$QVHKHQGHU3HUVRQ" =XU%HDQWZRUWXQJGLHVHU)UDJHORKQWGHU%OLFNDXI-QJHOVDQGHUQRUWVJHWlWLJWH $XVIKUXQJHQ]XP7KHPDGHUPRGHUQHQ(UZHUEVDUEHLW ,QGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJEH]LHKWVLFK-QJHODXIGHQGXUFK**QWHU9R XQG+DQV-3RQJUDW]GLDJQRVWL]LHUWHQ:DQGHOKLQ]XHLQHPQHXHQÄ/HLWW\SXV YRQ$UEHLWVNUDIWIUGHQJOREDOLVLHUWHQ1HRNDSLWDOLVPXV³ GHPÄ$UEHLWVNUDIWXQ WHUQHKPHU³ ,PPHUZHQLJHUVRGLHHUVWPDOV IRUPXOLHUWH7KHVHGHUEHL GHQ 6R]LRORJHQ LVW GLH $UEHLWVSUD[LV GXUFK NRQNUHWH EHWULHEOLFKH 9RUJDEHQ EHVWLPPW0HKUXQGPHKUVLQGHVKLQJHJHQGLH%HVFKlIWLJWHQVHOEVWDQGHQHQHV KlQJWZLHJHQDXVLHLKUH$UEHLWVNUDIWLQGHQMHZHLOLJHQ8QWHUQHKPHQV]LHOHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGH/HLVWXQJHQXPVHW]HQ'LHVHU$XWRQRPLHJHZLQQKDW]XU.HKUVHL WHGDVGHP(LQ]HOQHQLQ]XQHKPHQGHQ0DHGLH.RQWUROOHXQGgNRQRPLVLHUXQJ VHLQHUVHOEVWVRZLHGLH$XVULFKWXQJDXFKVHLQHUQLFKWEHUXIOLFKHQ/HEHQV]XVDP PHQKlQJHDXIGHQ*HOGHUZHUEKLQDEJHIRUGHUWZLUG -QJHOQLPPWGDVPLWGHU5HGHYRP$UEHLWVNUDIWXQWHUQHKPHUYHUEXQGHQH )UHLKHLWVYHUVSUHFKHQNULWLVFKLQGHQ%OLFN:DVHUDEVFKOlJLJEHXUWHLOWLVWGDVV Ä>G@LH $UEHLW >«@ VWDWW GHP (UZHUE GHV /HEHQVXQWHUKDOWHV ]X GLHQHQ ]XP 0HGLXP PHQVFKOLFKHU 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ³ ZLUG 'HQQ GDQQ PHLQW ÄGDV PHQVFKOLFKH,FK>«@VLFKGXUFK$UEHLWGLHMHQLJH$QHUNHQQXQJYHUVFKDIIHQ]X VROOHQGLH>«@GDV3HUVRQVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQNRQVWLWXLHUW³$OVVQGLJHV:LH *RWWVHLQ:ROOHQEUDQGPDUNW-QJHOGHQ9HUVXFKVROFKHLQHUWlWLJHQ6HOEVWEH JUQGXQJ$QDORJ]XWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQJ|WWOLFKHU$OOPDFKW ZlKQW VLFKGHU0HQVFKQlPOLFKVRÄGXUFKQLFKWVYRUKHUEHVWLPPW>«@DOVDOOHLQGXUFK GLHPLWGHUHLJHQHQ$UEHLWVNUDIWJHJHEHQHXQEHJUHQ]WH0|JOLFKNHLWVLFKVHOEHU ]XEHVWLPPHQ³'DULQDEHUNRPPWQXUGHUYRQ-QJHOKHUDXVJHVWHOOWH&KDUDN WHUGHU6QGHDOVHLQHUGHQ0HQVFKHQLQLGHRORJLVFKH/HEHQVOJHQYHUVWULFNHQ
$D2 :(%(5 9JODEHU]X-QJHOV'DUVWHOOXQJYRQ:HEHUVVRJ.DSLWDOLVPXVWKH VH -h1*(/I± 9JO]XGLHVHP3XQNWLQVJHVDPW -h1*(/ 321*5$7=92 9JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJ DD2± -h1*(/I $D2 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHQ0DFKW]XP7UDJHQ$OV8QWHUQHKPHUVHLQHUVHOEVWQlPOLFKLVWGHU0HQVFK ÄVRZRKO+HUUDOVDXFK.QHFKWVHLQHUVHOEVW³RKQHVHLQHHLJHQH.QHFKWVFKDIW ]XGXUFKVFKDXHQ,QGHPVHLQJDQ]HV/HEHQGHP=ZHFNGHU(UZHUEVDUEHLWXQWHU JHRUGQHWZLUGJHUlWGHUHQ(UIROJRGHU0LVVHUIROJ]XPHLQ]LJHQ0DVWDEDQ GHPVLFK:HUWRGHU8QZHUWGLHVHV/HEHQVEHXUWHLOHQODVVHQ$QJHVLFKWVGLHVHU $PELYDOHQ]EULQJW-QJHOÄ>G@DVGHQ0HQVFKHQYRU*RWWGHILQLWLYDQHUNHQQHQGH (YDQJHOLXPYRQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ³LQV6SLHOGDVÄGLHSHUVRQNRQVWLXLHUHQGH )XQNWLRQYRQ$UEHLWEHVWUHLWHW³ 'LH 5LJRURVLWlW GHU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ Ã6LFK$QHUNHQQXQJ 9HUVFKDIIHQGXUFK$UEHLWµDXIGHUHLQHQXQGÃGXUFK*RWWDQHUNDQQWZHUGHQµDXI GHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHOlVVWGDQDFKIUDJHQRE%HUXIVDUEHLWIU-QJHOQXU0LWWHO]XP =ZHFNVHLQGDUI'HPN|QQWHPDQGLH7KHVHGHVV\VWHPLVFKHQ%HUDWHUV0DUNXV +lQVHOJHJHQEHUVWHOOHQDXVGHVVHQ6LFKWHVVLFKÄIDWDOIUHLQJDQ]KHLWOLFKHV 9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ6LQQHUIOOXQJ³DXVQLPPWÄ$UEHLWDXIGLHPDWHULHOOH%HGUIQLV EHIULHGLJXQJ]XUHGX]LHUHQ³ $QGHUHPLWLKUHEHQIDOOVYHUNQSIEDUHÄ%HGUIQLV VH³ZLHHWZDÄQDFKVR]LDOHP.RQWDNW$QHUNHQQXQJXQG6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ³ ZUGHQVRQlPOLFKÄDXVJHVSDUW³(VEOHLEWDEHUXQNODUREXQGLQZLHIHUQVLFK VROFKH%HGUIQLVVHQDFKVLQQHUIOOHQGHU$UEHLWYRQ-QJHOV$QVDW]KHUZUGLJHQ ODVVHQGHUHLQ]LJXQGDOOHLQGDUDXIIRNXVVLHUWLVWGHQJDQ]KHLWOLFKHQ$QVSUXFK GHU$UEHLWDXIGHQ0HQVFKHQLQIUDJH]XVWHOOHQ'RFKQDFKVHLQHP'DIUKDOWHQ EDXWVLFKÄ>G@LH*DQ]KHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ>«@DXHUKDOEVHLQHUDXI³XQGÄ>L@QGLH 6LWXDWLRQYRU*RWWH[LVWHQWLHOOYHUVHW]W]XZHUGHQXQGGDPLW]XVHLQHU*DQ]KHLW ]XJHODQJHQ±GDVYHUPDJGHU0HQVFKHQLQGHVVHQDOOHLQGDGXUFKGDHUJODXEW³ XQGGXUFKVROFKHQÄ*ODXEHQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWZLUG³'DVVPDQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWXQG DOVRGHILQLWLYYRQ*RWWDQHUNDQQWLVWGDVHUVFKOLHWVLFKDEHUVR-QJHOLQPLWWHQ GHUSHUPDQHQWWlWLJHQ$UEHLWVXQG/HLVWXQJVJHVHOOVFKDIWQLFKWYRQVHOEVW'D]X EHGDUIHVYLHOPHKUMHQHUÄHOHPHQWDUH>Q@8QWHUEUHFKXQJGHU$UEHLWV]HLW³GLH YHUPLWWHOVGHU)HLHUWDJVKHLOLJXQJYROO]RJHQZLUG6RQQWDJVWULWWDOVRJHZLVVHU PDHQGDVYRU$XJHQZDVLPDUEHLWVDPHQ$OOWDJYHUJHVVHQ]XZHUGHQGURKW 'DVVGDVMHHLJHQH6HOEVWVHLQVHLQHQ*UXQGXQGVHLQH*DQ]KHLWDXHUKDOEVHLQHU VHOEVWQlPOLFKLQ*RWWKDWXQGSULQ]LSLHOODOOHP+DQGHOQZLHDOOHUGDIUJHZlKU WHQRGHUYHUZHKUWHQVR]LDOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJHQW]RJHQLVW:LHÄGLH$UEHLWVZRFKH YRP6RQQWDJKHUNRPPWXQGDXFKZLHGHU]XLKP]XUFNNHKUW³PXVVGHVKDOE DXFKGHUDXILUGLVFKHQ*HZLQQDXVJHULFKWHWH0HQVFKLPPHUZLHGHUQHXVHLQHU $QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK*RWWJHZLVVZHUGHQ
$D2 I $D2 +b16(/ -h1*(/GI -h1*(/ -h1*(/ D
$(EHUKDUG-QJHO ]ZLVFKHQJ|WWOLFKHUXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
)D]LW 8OULFK %DUWKV NULWLVFKHU +LQZHLV GDVV GLH UHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFK KlXILJ EHVFKZRUHQHÄ6XFKHQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK*RWW>«@NHLQ*HGDQNHLVWGHU VLFKYRQVHOEVWQDKHOHJW³ ZHLO$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHLP=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ EHKHLPDWHWH.DWHJRULHLVWVWDQGDP$QIDQJPHLQHU$XVIKUXQJHQ'LH)UDJH RE-QJHOVDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJH GDQNHQVGLHVHP9RUZXUIHQWJHKHQNDQQVRZXUGHHLQJDQJVHEHQIDOOVIHVWJHV WHOOWZUGHHLQHJHPLVFKWH$QWZRUWILQGHQ'LHVKDWVLFKLP=XJHGHU]XUFNOLH JHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQEHZDKUKHLWHW %HLP'XUFKJDQJGXUFK-QJHOV%HLWUlJH]XP7KHPDLVWYRUDOOHPVHLQH9HU KlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJYRQVR]LDOHUXQGGLYLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOV]XVWLPPXQJVIlKLJ YRU $XJHQ JHWUHWHQ 'LH DPELYDOHQWH 6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJ GHP NRQWLQJHQW ZLOONUOLFKHQ:HFKVHO]ZLVFKHQJHZlKUWHUXQGYHUZHKUWHU$QHUNHQQXQJXQWHU VHLQHVJOHLFKHQDXVJHVHW]W]XVHLQVHW]WGHQ0HQVFKHQWHQGHQ]LHOOXQWHU'UXFN VLFKXQDXIK|UOLFKDOVZHUWYROOHUZHLVHQ]XPVVHQ'DEHLPDFKW-QJHOJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKZLUNPlFKWLJH/HLVWXQJVPDVWlEHDXVGHQHQVWHWVXQGVWlQGLJJHUHFKW ZHUGHQ]XPVVHQHLQHQGORVHV$QHUNHQQXQJVXQG6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVVWUH EHQDQIHXHUW$P*UXQGHGLHVHV6WUHEHQVDEHUOLHJWGHU:XQVFK]XVLFKVHOEVW ]XJHODQJHQGHULPJODXEHQGHQ%H]XJDXI*RWWVRN|QQWHPDQ-QJHOPRGLIL ]LHUWYHUVWHKHQNRQWUDIDNWLVFKH(UIOOXQJILQGHQNDQQ0DQLVWGDQQLQPLWWHQGHU VR]LDOHQ%H]JHGLHHLQHQZHLWHUKLQEHVWLPPHQÃVFKRQHWZDVµXQGZLUGGD GXUFKZLHGLH$XVIKUXQJHQ]XU%H]LHKXQJ]ZLVFKHQLQQHUHPXQGlXHUHP 0HQVFKHQJH]HLJWKDEHQ]XLKQHQLQHLQSURGXNWLYHV6SDQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVHLQ JHVHW]WGDV+DQGOXQJVRSWLRQHQMHQVHLWVGHVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFK(UZDUWHWHQIUHLVHW]W $XVGHU'LIIHUHQ]LQGLHGHU0HQVFKGDGXUFKGDVVHUYRU*RWWÃVFKRQHWZDVLVWµ ]XGHPYHUVHW]WZLUGZDVHULQQHUKDOEGHU6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHVHLQVROOZlFKVW LKPGLH)UHLKHLW]XHWZDV(LJHQHV]XVHLQ 'LHYRQ-QJHOQDPKDIWJHPDFKWHQVR]LDOHQ)ROJHQGLHVHUJ|WWOLFKEHJUQGH WHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVHUIDKUXQJDEHUJHKHQZLHJHVHKHQQLFKWGDUEHUKLQDXVLP PHUZLHGHUGLH%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJHEHQGLHVHUXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ'LPHQVLRQPHQ VFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVHLQ]XIRUGHUQ VHLHVLP%OLFNDXIGLHKLVWRULVFKNRQWLQJHQ WHQ5HFKWVVHW]XQJHQ]XHQWQHKPHQGH0HQVFKZUGHLGHHLP%OLFNDXIGHQ8P JDQJPLW$OWHQXQG6WHUEHQGHQRGHULQGHQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHQGHU%HUXIVDUEHLW 'LHVKlQJWVRKDWVLFKJH]HLJW]XY|UGHUVWGDPLW]XVDPPHQGDVV-QJHOGHQ 0HQVFKHQDOV3HUVRQNRQVWLWXWLYDXVGHURQWRORJLVLHUWHQXQGDV\PPHWULVFKHQ $XVJDQJVUHODWLRQ*RWWHV]XLKPKHUYRUJHKHQVLHKWÃ6FKRQHWZDVµ]XVHLQEHGHX WHWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQG]ZDUÃQLFKWVPHKUDXVVLFKPDFKHQ]XPVVHQµDEHU HVOHW]WHQGOLFKDXFKQLFKW]XGUIHQ'DVHUKHOOWDXVVHLQHUSDXVFKDOHQÄPRUDOL VFKH>Q@:HUWXQJGHUPRGHUQHQ)UHLKHLWVEHDQVSUXFKXQJDOV6QGH³HEHQVRZLH
%,1*(1(5 :,77(.,1'
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DXVGHUELV]XU8QNHQQWOLFKNHLWUHGX]LHUWHQ$NWLYLWlWGHV0HQVFKHQLP5HFKWIHU WLJXQJVJHVFKHKHQ'DV6LFK$QHUNHQQHQ/DVVHQGXUFK*RWWGDV6LFK,GHQWLVFK :LVVHQ PLW &KULVWXV GLH 6HOEVW]XUHFKQXQJ GHV IUHPGHQ 8UWHLOV GDV 6LFK %HMDKHQDOVEHMDKWHWFZHUGHQVWHWVDOOHLQDXIJ|WWOLFKH,QLWLDWLYH]XUFNJHIKUW XPGHQ0HQVFKHQDOVUHLQSDVVLYGDU]XVWHOOHQ*OHLFKHVJLOWIUGHQULJRURVHQ $XVVFKOXVVHLQHVJ|WWOLFKHQ$QNQSIXQJVSXQNWHVLP0HQVFKHQGHUVLFKGRFKLQ GHUDPELYDOHQWHQ6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJGHVQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJVWUHEHQGHQ6XEMHNWV ILQGHQOLHH'RFK-QJHOEHVFKUHLEWGLHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ DOVHLQHÃFUHDWLRH[QLKLORµGLHHEHQDXVMHQHP1LFKWVVFK|SIWGDVGHU6QGHU IUGLHGDUVWHOOW6RDEHUNHKUWZRUDXVJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJEHIUHLHQVROOGDVV PDQ VLFK JDQ] XQG JDU YRQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ XQWHU VHLQHVJOHLFKHQ DEKlQJLJ PDFKWZLGHUVSUFKOLFKHU:HLVHLP*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVZLHGHUÄ>:@DVHULVW³LVW ÄGHU0HQVFKDOVHLQYRQ*RWW>«@$QHUNDQQWHU³XQGGLHVH$QHUNHQQXQJOHJW LKQGDUDXIIHVWVLFKDOV(PSIDQJHQGHU]XYHUVWHKHQZDVZLHJHVHKHQHWZDDP /HEHQVHQGHPLWGHXWOLFKHQQRUPDWLYHQ9HUSIOLFKWXQJHQHLQKHUJHKW 6HLQHQOHW]WHQ*UXQGKDWGLHVHDV\PPHWULVFKH*RWW0HQVFK.RQVWHOODWLRQ ZLHDEVFKOLHHQGQRFK]XVDJHQLVWLQ-QJHOV(QWVFKHLGXQJIU*RWWJHQDXGDV YRU]XEHKDOWHQZDVGHP0HQVFKHQYRUHQWKDOWHQZLUG 'LH)UHLKHLWGHVDVHGHV $XVVLFKVHOEVWVHLQV6LHVROOVRZXUGHLP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU7ULQLWlWVOHKUH GHXWOLFKGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWUHFKWIHUWLJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDEVWW]HQZHLO*RWW GXUFKVLHLQVHLQHP+HLOVKDQGHOQQLFKWYRQlXHUHQ%HGLQJXQJHQDEKlQJLJLVW =XJOHLFKZLUG*RWWDOV/LHEHEHVWLPPWGLHVLFKSULPlULQGHULQQHUWULQLWDULVFKHQ Ã*HPHLQVFKDIWJHJHQVHLWLJHQ$QGHUVVHLQVµUHDOLVLHUWXPLKQDOVRIIHQIUGDV $QGHUVVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQ]XHU]HLJHQ6LFKGHP/HW]WHUHQLQ-HVXV&KULVWXV DXV]XVHW]HQDEHUEOHLEWIU*RWWOHW]WOLFKHLQHSHULSKHUH$QJHOHJHQKHLWZHLOHU VLFKLP*UXQGHVHOEVWVFKRQDQGHUVJHQXJLVW'LHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJVR N|QQWHPDQIROJHUQJLOWDOVRHLJHQWOLFKQLFKWGHQ0HQVFKHQDOVVROFKHPVRQ GHUQGLHVHULVWQXUHLQH'XUFKJDQJVVWDWLRQJ|WWOLFKHQ6LFK6HOEVW(QWVSUHFKHQV 9RUGLHVHPJ|WWOLFKHQ+LQWHUJUXQGQLPPW-QJHOVUHVHUYLHUWHUELVDEOHKQHQGHU 8PJDQJPLWGHUÃPRGHUQHQ)UHLKHLWVEHDQVSUXFKXQJµQLFKWZXQGHU%HL)DON :DJQHUGHVVHQ$QVDW]LPQlFKVWHQ.DSLWHOLP=HQWUXPVWHKWILQGHWVLFKHLQ DOWHUQDWLYHUWKHRORJLVFKHU=XJDQJ]XU$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLNGHUGLH)UHLKHLW GHV6XEMHNWVDXVGUFNOLFKLQV=HQWUXPVWHOOWXQGVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVHUIDKUXQ JHQVWlUNHU]XZUGLJHQZHL6HLQH3RVLWLRQOlVVWVLFKJXWLP.RQWUDVW]X-Q JHOV'HQNHQDXIGDVHUELVZHLOHQDXVGUFNOLFKNULWLVFKHQ%H]XJJHQRPPHQKDW ZLHQXQEHUOHLWHQGGHXWOLFKZHUGHQZLUG
-h1*(/J
hEHUJDQJ :DJQHUYV-QJHORGHU ZDUXP)UHLKHLW QLFKW QXU DXV*RWWVHLQNDQQ Ä/DVVWXQVXPNHKUHQ:HQGHWHXFKZHJYRQGHUIDOVFKHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJXQG VXFKWHXUH+RIIQXQJLP9HUWUDXHQDXI*RWW³:LHHLQDOWWHVWDPHQWOLFKHU3UR SKHWPVVWHLQ)DON:DJQHUV$XJHQUHGHQZHUGHQLQ/XWKHUV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV OHKUH LPSOL]LHUWHQ )UHLKHLWVEHJULII XQYHUPLWWHOW XQG GLUHNW ]XP QRUPDWLYHQ 0DVWDEPRGHUQHU/HEHQVIKUXQJHUKHEHQZROOWH'LHVHUÄN|QQWHGDQQQXUDOV 3URWHVWJHJHQGLHIUHLH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJXQGDOV$EVDJHDQGLHPHQVFKOLFKH 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJ UHOHYDQW ZHUGHQ³ 'RFK YHUKDOOWH GLH 6WLPPH HLQHV VROFK HLQVDPHQ5XIHUVLQGHU DQJHEOLFK LQGLYLGXDOLVWLVFKHQ:VWHGHU0RGHUQHZHLW KLQ UHVRQDQ]ORV GHQQ Ä:HU VLFK DXIJUXQG YRQ 6HOEVWJHVHW]JHEXQJ JHVHOO VFKDIWOLFK|NRQRPLVFKHU (LJHQJHVHW]OLFKNHLW XQG VHOEVWJHJHEHQHU SROLWLVFKHU 9HUIDVVXQJDOVVHOEVWEHVWLPPHQGHV6XEMHNWHUIDWNDQQVLFKQLFKWHLQH)UHLKHLW DOV*HVFKHQN>«@DQGHPRQVWULHUHQODVVHQ³'DUDXIDEHUKHEW0DUWLQ/XWKHUV H[NOXVLYH%LQGXQJPHQVFKOLFKHQ)UHLVHLQVDQGDVUHFKWIHUWLJHQGH:RUW*RWWHV DEZHVKDOE:DJQHUGLHJHJHQZlUWLJH$QVFKOXVVIlKLJNHLWGLHVHVXQWHUYRUQHX ]HLWOLFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQIRUPXOLHUWHQ*HGDQNHQVPLWHLQHPJURHQ)UDJH]HLFKHQ YHUVLHKWÄ,VWGDV7KHPDGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH GLHGXUFK*RWWJHVFKHQNWH )UHLKHLW³QLFKWYLHOPHKUÄLQGHU0RGHUQHRUWORVJHZRUGHQ"³0LWVHLQHQ%HP KXQJHQXPHLQHGLIIHUHQ]LHUWH$QWZRUWJHKW:DJQHUDXIGHXWOLFKH'LVWDQ]]X HLQHUZLUNPlFKWLJHQ/LQLHGHU/XWKHUUH]HSWLRQGLHVLFKGXUFKGHQ:LWWHQEHUJHU 5HIRUPDWRUJHUDGH]XU.ULWLNGHVQHX]HLWOLFKPRGHUQHQ3ULQ]LSVGHU6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJDQJHVWDFKHOWVLHKW±XQGUHNXUULHUWLP=XJHGHVVHQELVZHLOHQDXFK GLUHNWDXI(EHUKDUG-QJHOVHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ9HUVXFK
:$*1(5N7HLOHGLHVHV$EVFKQLWWVZXUGHQEHUHLWVYHU|IIHQWOLFKLQ 7(7=/$)) 6&+(,:,//(57(7=/$)) 7(7=/$))D :$*1(5N (EG (EG 9JO]XUQHX]HLWE]ZIUHLKHLWVNULWLVFKHQ7UDGLWLRQVOLQLHGHU/XWKHUGHXWXQJLQGLHVLFK QHEHQ(EHUKDUG-QJHOXDVRXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH$XWRUHQZLH)ULHGULFK*RJDUWHQ:HUQHU(OHUW (PDQXHO+LUVFKXQG2VZDOG%D\HUHLQRUGQHQODVVHQ 6/(1&=.$±9JO]X:DJ QHUVH[SOL]LWHQ%H]XJDXI-QJHOJHQDXHUJHVDJWDXI-QJHOVPLW$NWXDOLWlWVDQVSUXFKYRUJHW UDJHQH$XVOHJXQJYRQ/XWKHUV)UHLKHLWVVFKULIWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJ :$*1(5I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:DVEHLGH-QJHOXQG:DJQHUKLQJHJHQZHQLJVWHQVREHUIOlFKOLFKEHVHKHQ PLWHLQDQGHUYHUELQGHWLVWGHUDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH=XJULIIDXIGDV5HFKW IHUWLJXQJVWKHPD:DJQHUVGLHVEH]JOLFKH6LFKWZLUGLP)ROJHQGHQNXU]VNL] ]LHUWXPVHLQHQ±GDUDXIKLQDXVIKUOLFKXQGEHUGHQUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJL VFKHQ.RQWH[WKLQDXVJHKHQGGDU]XOHJHQGHQ±$QVDW]LQHLQHUHUVWHQ$QQlKHUXQJ JHJHQEHU-QJHOV3RVLWLRQ]XSURILOLHUHQ'DEHLOLHJWGHU)RNXVDXIGHQNULWL VFKHQ3XQNWHQGLH:DJQHU]XIROJHHLQHXQPLWWHOEDUH$NWXDOLVLHUXQJGHU/XWKHU VFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHE]ZLKUHV)UHLKHLWVEHJULIIVYHUXQP|JOLFKHQ 'LHV VLQG LQVEHVRQGHUH ]ZHL GDULQ LPSOL]LHUWHDEHU XQWHU PRGHUQHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ QLFKWNRPPXQL]LHUEDUH3DVVLYLWlWV]XPXWXQJHQ +DEHQGLHOHW]WHUHQLKUHQ *UXQGDXV:DJQHUV6LFKWLPUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKYRUDXVJHVHW]WHQ*RWWHV JHGDQNHQOLHJWHVQDKHLQHLQHP]ZHLWHQ6FKULWWHLQHLPDQGHUHQ.RQWH[WYRU JHWUDJHQH.ULWLN:DJQHUVDQ-QJHOV*RWWHVEHJULIIHLQ]XVSLHOHQ %HLGH3XQN WHZHLVHQLQLKUHPJHGDQNOLFKHQ*HKDOWEHUHLWVDXIGDVIROJHQGH:DJQHU.DSLWHO YRUDXVXQGDXFKDXIPDQFKHVDXVGHPYRUDQJHJDQJHQHQ-QJHO.DSLWHO]XUFN
'LH3DVVLYLWlWV]XPXWXQJHQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLW 'LHÄ*UXQGHLQVLFKWGHU5HIRUPDWLRQ³VSULFKWVLFKIU:DJQHULQGHU/XWKHUVFKHQ )RUPHOYRQGHUÄ)UHLKHLWHLQHV&KULVWHQPHQVFKHQ³DXV'HPQDFKJUQGHWGLH ÄSULQ]LSLHOODOOHQ0HQVFKHQ]XUHFKHQEDUHFKULVWOLFKH)UHLKHLWHLQ]LJXQGDOOHLQLQ GHUHQGLUHNWHU%H]LHKXQJ]XGHP*RWWGXUFKGHQVLFKMHGHU0HQVFKEHGLQJXQJV ORVDQHUNDQQWZHL³'LHGDUDXVIROJHQGHÄ8QDEKlQJLJNHLWGHVÃLQQHUHQµ0HQ VFKHQYRQMHGHULQ3ROLWLN*HVHOOVFKDIWXQG5HOLJLRQDXIWUHWHQGHQ$XWRULWlW³LVW LQ VHLQHQ $XJHQ HLQ ,QLWLDO GHV DP Ä%HJULII GHU XQPLWWHOEDUHQ 6HOEVWEHVWLP PXQJ³RULHQWLHUWHQ)UHLKHLWVYHUVWlQGQLVVHVGHU0RGHUQH'RFKUHGHW:DJQHU KLHUNHLQHUEUXFKORVHQ.RQWLQXLWlWGDV:RUW6RXQDEKlQJLJQlPOLFKGHU(LQ]HO QHEHL/XWKHUYRQGHQZHOWOLFKHQ0lFKWHQLVWVRDEKlQJLJEOHLEWHUYRQ*RWW 'LHVHVÄH[WUDQRVGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ*HUHFKWLJNHLWXQG)UHLKHLW³YHUOLHUWDEHUGRUW VHLQH%HZDQGWQLVZRHLQHUÄVLFKXQGVHLQ/HEHQLQ*HVHOOVFKDIWXQG3ROLWLNDXV XQGGXUFKVLFKVHOEVW³ NRQVWLWXLHUWZHL$XIGHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHU5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVOHKUHZlUHHVGHVKDOEQXUIROJHULFKWLJ]XXUWHLOHQGDVVÄGHUQHX]HLWOLFK PRGHUQH0HQVFK>«@GHP9HUVXFKGHU6HOEVWUHFKWIHUWLJXQJYHUIDOOHQ³VHLXQG VHLQH )UHLKHLW ÄDXI ÃJHVHW]OLFKHUµ 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJ DXI GHP Ã,QVLFK
:$*1(5 E (EG :$*1(5N $D2 (EG
hEHUJDQJ :DJQHUYV-QJHO
9HUNUPPWVHLQµGHV0HQVFKHQDXIVHLQHU6QGHDOV6HOEVWVXFKWXQG(JR]HQWULN EDVLHUWH³ (QWJHJHQGLHVHU6LFKWGLHKRKH$IILQLWlWHQ]X-QJHOVUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHROR JLVFKLQVSLULHUWHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVNULWLNDXIZHLVWYHUWHLOW:DJQHUDEHUGLH %HJUQGXQJVODVWJHQDXDQGHUVKHUXP1LFKWGDV,GHDOIUHLHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ PXVVVLFKDXIVHLQH/HJLWLPLWlWKLQEHIUDJHQODVVHQVRQGHUQGLH3ODXVLELOLWlW HLQHUGDUDXIIXQGLHUHQGEH]RJHQHQ5HGHYRQ*RWWLVW]XHUZHLVHQ'HUHQ3ODXVL ELOLWlWVLHKW:DJQHUHLQHGRSSHOWH3DVVLYLWlWV]XPXWXQJGHU/XWKHUVFKHQ.RQ]HS WLRQHQWJHJHQVWHKHQ HLQHUVHLWVZHLOVLHEHLGHU.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQDOV IUHLHV6XEMHNWDOOHLQ*RWWDP:HUNVHLQOlVVW DQGHUHUVHLWV ZHLOVLHGDV SUDNWLVFKH:LUNOLFKZHUGHQGHU)UHLKHLWPLWXQEHUHFKWLJWHQ5HVWULNWLRQHQYHU VLHKW *|WWOLFKH$NWLYLWlWYVPHQVFKOLFKH3DVVLYLWlW 'DVDXFKIUGLH*HJHQZDUWlXHUVWUHOHYDQWH7KHPDGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUH LVW:DJQHU]XIROJHÄGLH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ)UHLKHLW³GHPVLHLQQHU KDOEGHU.RRUGLQDWHQYRQ*HVHW]XQG(YDQJHOLXPQDFKJHKW,P*HJHQEHUGHU EHLGHQ3ROHGHV+HLOVYRUJDQJVVLHKWHUÄGLH]ZHLP|JOLFKHQXQGLQVRIHUQVLFK GLVMXQNWLYDXVVFKOLHHQGHQ.RQVWLWXWLRQVZHLVHQYRQ)UHLKHLW³DQJH]HLJW (QWZH GHUJUQGHWVLHLQPHQVFKOLFKHU6HOEVWWlWLJNHLWRGHUJHKWDXIJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQ QXQJ ]XUFN 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ KHLW VR JHVHKHQ QLFKWV DQGHUHV DOV GDVV GHU 0HQVFKÄYRQGHUIDOVFKHQ]XUZDKUHQ)UHLKHLWEHIUHLW³ZLUG0DJHUDXFK]X QlFKVWXQG]XPHLVWDXIGLHHLJHQH+DQGOXQJVPDFKWYHUWUDXHQYHUGDQNHVLFK GRFKÄVHLQH)UHLKHLWGHPJ|WWOLFKHQ*HVFKHQNVRGDLKPVHLQH)UHLKHLWSDVVLY ]XJHUHFKQHWZHUGH³±HLQH7KHVHGLHDXV:DJQHUV6LFKWDEHUHLQHP'HQNIHKOHU DXIVLW]W,QLKUQlPOLFKZLUGDXVJHEOHQGHWGDVVÄYRQGHPVHOEHQ0HQVFKHQ ]XJOHLFKDNWLY>«@DQJHHLJQHWZHUGHQPX³ZDVLKPRKQHHLJHQHV=XWXQ]X NRPPHQVROO6SULFKWVFKRQ/XWKHUVHOEVWYRP(UJUHLIHQGHUIUHPGHQ*HUHFK WLJNHLW&KULVWLLP*ODXEHQVWHOOWVLFKIU:DJQHUGLH)UDJHREGDVGDULQDXV JHVSURFKHQHÄ(UJUHLIHQGHUJHVFKHQNWHQ)UHLKHLWQLFKWVFKRQ)UHLKHLWEHLPHU JUHLIHQGHQ6XEMHNW³YRUDXVVHW]W 'LHWUDGLWLRQHOOH/RVXQJHVVHLHEHQGHU*ODXEHGHUDOVYRQ*RWWÄJHVFKHQNWH %HUHLWVFKDIWVLFKEHVFKHQNHQ]XODVVHQ³GLHVHUDNWLYHQ$QHLJQXQJYRUDXVJHKH HUVFKHLQWLKPDOVHLQHEORH3UREOHPYHUODJHUXQJ6FKOLHOLFKVHW]WDXFKÄGDV
:$*1(5I :$*1(5N9JODXFKDD2±XQG'(56I± (EG $D2 :$*1(5 E (EG :$*1(5N :$*1(5I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
*HVFKHQNGHU%HUHLWVFKDIWVLFKEHVFKHQNHQ]XODVVHQ>«@YRQ6HLWHQGHV%H VFKHQNWHQGLH)lKLJNHLWXQG%HUHLWVFKDIW]XU$QQDKPHXQG]XP(PSIDQJGHV *HVFKHQNVYRUDXV³ :lKUHQG/XWKHUGHQWlWLJHQ3DUWLPhEHUJDQJYRQGHU 6QGH]XP+HLOQRFK*RWWDOOHLQEHUODVVHQNRQQWHVWHKWIU:DJQHUIHVW +LQ WHUGDVXQDEOHLWEDUH)DNWXPGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ)UHLKHLWJHODQJWGLH7KHRORJLHLQ GHU0RGHUQHQLFKWPHKU]XUFN:HUMHQHVDOOHQEHQHQQEDUHQ.DXVDOLWlWHQ DEKROGHÄ9HUP|JHQHLQHQ=XVWDQGYRQVHOEVWDQ]XIDQJHQ³GXUFKZHOFKH%H KHOIVNRQVWUXNWLRQHQ DXFK LPPHU DXI HLQH K|KHUH $EKlQJLJNHLW ]XUFNIKUHQ ZROOWHYHUVWULFNWHVLFKLQ$SRULHQ,QGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJUHNXUULHUWHUGLUHNW DXI-QJHOV+LQZHLVHVZDOWHHEHQ]ZLVFKHQGHPÄDOWHQXQGQHXHQ0HQVFKHQ >«@NHLQHDQGHUH.RQWLQXLWlW>«@DOVGLHGHVDXVGHP1LFKWVVFKDIIHQGHQ:RU WHV*RWWHV³'DVVGLHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJLP6LQQHHLQHUFUHDWLRH[QLKLOR DP0HQVFKHQDOOHUHUVWKHUYRUEULQJWZDVVLHDQLKPDQHUNHQQWXQGGHU0HQVFK DQGLHVHP9RUJDQJLQNHLQHU:HLVHEHWHLOLJWVHLQVROO±GLHVHYRQ-QJHOPLW $NWXDOLWlWVDQVSUXFKYHUWUHWHQH6LFKWZHLVW:DJQHUDE'HUUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHR ORJLVFKDQJH]HLJWH±XQGLP6LQQHGHVÄVLPXOLXVWXVHWSHFFDWRU³LPPHUZLHGHU ]XYROO]LHKHQGH±:HFKVHOYRQGHUÄIDOVFKHQ³]XUÄZDKUHQ³)UHLKHLWPXVVVLFK VHLQHV(UDFKWHQVYLHOPHKUVREHVFKUHLEHQODVVHQZLHHUÄDP2UWGHVPHQVFKOL FKHQ6XEMHNWVVHOEHU³EHJDQJHQZLUG'HVVHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVIlKLJNHLWZLUG GDQQLP5HNXUVDXI*RWWQLFKWÄGHPHQWLHUWRGHUJDUZHJHUNOlUWVRQGHUQJDQ]LP *HJHQWHLOUHNRQVWUXLHUW³ ,QQHUHYVlXHUH)UHLKHLW (QJYHUEXQGHQPLWGHPVRHEHQ'DUJHVWHOOWHQLVWHLQDQGHUHV3UREOHPDQGHP :DJQHU]XIROJHÄGLHSURWHVWDQWLVFKH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHNUDQNW³ Ä$XV)XUFKW GHQ SDVVLYHQ *HVFKHQNFKDUDNWHU GHU )UHLKHLW ]X JHIlKUGHQ EOHLEW GLH DNWLYH 5HDOLVLHUXQJDOO]XRIWDXIGHU6WUHFNH³=ZDUVLHKWHUEHL/XWKHUNHLQHVZHJV HLQHUSUDNWLVFKHQ)ROJHQORVLJNHLWGHV*ODXEHQVGDV:RUWJHUHGHWVRQGHUQÄGDV 7XQJXWHU:HUNHGH>Q@9ROO]XJGHU/LHEH³LQQHUKDOEGHUYRUJHJHEHQHQ/HEHQV RUGQXQJHQÄ)DPLOLH*HVHOOVFKDIWXQG6WDDW³]XUXQPLWWHOEDUHQÄ.RQVHTXHQ]GHV $QJHQRPPHQVHLQV>«@GXUFK*RWW³HUKREHQ$QGLH6WHOOHVQGKDIWHU6HOEVW EH]RJHQKHLWWULWWHEHQGLH+LQZHQGXQJ]XP$QGHUHQ'RFKPDFKWGHU:LWWHQ EHUJHU5HIRUPDWRULQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJ]XJOHLFKGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQLQQH
$D2 9JODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ :$*1(5 E± N± I± .$17 F>%@,P2ULJLQDOWHLOVJHVSHUUW -h1*(/M$XIGLHVH3DVVDJHDXV-QJHOVPLW$NWXDOLWlWVDQVSUXFKYRUJHWUDJH QHU$XVOHJXQJYRQ/XWKHUV)UHLKHLWVVFKULIWYHUZHLVW:DJQHULQ :$*1(5I :$*1(5I :$*1(5 E :$*1(5F :$*1(5N
hEHUJDQJ :DJQHUYV-QJHO
UHPXQGlXHUHP0HQVFKHQYRQGHUDOOHLQÄFRUDP'HR³H[LVWLHUHQGHQ3HUVRQ XQGGHUHQQXUÄFRUDPKRPLQLEXV³JHOWHQGHQ:HUNHQQDPKDIW2EJOHLFKGHU &KULVWVHLQHQZHOWOLFKHQ%HUXIDOV5HDOLVDWLRQVRUWVHLQHUJHLVWOLFKHQ%HUXIXQJ EHJUHLIHQ XQG GDULQ ]XP DOOWlJOLFKHQ *RWWHVGLHQVW GHU 1lFKVWHQOLHEH YRUDQ VFKUHLWHQVROOEOHLEWHUGHQVR]LRSROLWLVFKHQ*HJHEHQKHLWHQGDEHLIUDJORVXQWHU JHRUGQHW(EHQVRIUHLJHJHQEHUGHU:HOWXQGÄQLHPDQGXQWHUWDQ³LVWHUYRU *RWWZLHHUVLFKJDQ]ÄGLHQVWEDUHU.QHFKWXQGMHGHUPDQQXQWHUWDQ³ LQVVR]LDOH /HEHQ±HWZD GHU6WlQGHXQG2UGQXQJHQ±]XVFKLFNHQKDWÄ'HUGHQ,QGLYL GXHQLP%LQQHQUDXPGHU.LUFKHÃ]XJHVSURFKHQHQµLQQHUHQ)UHLKHLWNRUUHVSRQ GLHUWDOVRNHLQZLUNOLFKUHDOLVLHUWHV'DVHLQGHUlXHUHQ)UHLKHLW³IROJHUW:DJ QHUNULWLVFK:DVDOV$EVLFKHUXQJJHJHQGHQKHLOVLUUHOHYDQWHQ9HUGLHQVWXQG /HLVWXQJVJODXEHQ±EHL-QJHO GDV6LFK$QHUNHQQXQJ9HUVFKDIIHQ±JHPHLQW LVWIKUWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQ]XHLQHUZLGHUVSUFKOLFKHQ+DOEKHLW6REOHLEWQlPOLFK GLHÄFKULVWOLFKH)UHLKHLW>«@HLQOHHUHV9HUVSUHFKHQZHQQVLHQLFKWGLHLKUHQW VSUHFKHQGH*HVWDOWZHUGXQJDXVVLFKHQWOlW³'LHVDEHUEHGHXWHWHLKUHQÄ=X VDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP'DVHLQGHUlXHUHQ)UHLKHLWLQ3ROLWLN:LUWVFKDIW5HFKW (U]LHKXQJHWF>«@VLFKWEDUXQGNRQNUHWIDEDU³ZHUGHQ]XODVVHQ:DVEHL *RWWXQEHGLQJWH$QHUNHQQXQJILQGHWPXVVDOVRDXFK]ZLVFKHQ0HQVFKHQE]Z LQQHUKDOEGHUVR]LDOHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQOHEHQGLJZHUGHQ :lKUHQGGLHUHIRUPDWRULVFKH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVIUHLKHLWÄ*HIDKU>OlXIW@PLWHL QHUÃ8QWHUWDQHQPRUDOYHUZHFKVHOW]XZHUGHQGXUFKGLHGLH]XJ|WWOLFKHQ2UG 9JOHWZD:$*1(5I I'LH]HQWUDOH3DVVDJHEHL/XWKHUILQGHWVLFKLQGHU6FKULIW 9RQZHOWOLFKHU2EULJNHLWZLHZHLWPDQLKU*HKRUVDPVHL Ä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³ /87+(5 *HUKDUG(EHOLQJKDWGLHIXQGPHQWDOH%HGHX WXQJGLHVHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYLHOIDFKKHUDXVJHVWHOOWXQGDXFKIUVHLQHHLJHQH7KHRORJLHEHU QRPPHQ YJOHWZD(%(/,1* $OV EHVRQGHUV HLQVFKOlJLJ IU GLH OXWKHUVFKH %HUXIVNRQ]HSWLRQ NDQQ GLH 6FKULIW 2E .ULHJVOHXWHDXFKLQVHOLJHP6WDQGHVHLQN|QQHQ /87+(5 JHOWHQ'DVVQDFK *RWWHV:LOOHQÄREHQXQGXQWHQVWHQGHVHLQ>PVVHQ@LQGLHVHPOHEHQ³ '(56 ZDU IU GHQ 5HIRUPDWRU NODU JHVHW]W :DJQHU EH]LHKW VLFK DXI GLHVH .RQ]HSWLRQ LQ NULWLVFK DIILUPDWLYHU:HLVHHWZDLQ:$*1(5 EIXQGLQVHLQHP/H[LNRQDUWLNHO]XP%HUX IXQJVEHJULII '(56 /87+(5 ,PGHXWVFKVSUDFKLJHQ2ULJLQDOODXWHWGLHEHUKPWH'RSSHOIRUPHO Ä(\Q&KULVWHQPHQVFKLVWH\QIUH\HUKHUUEHUDOOHGLQJXQGQLHPDQGWXQWHUWKDQ(\Q&KULVWHQ PHQVFKLVWH\QGLHQVWSDUNQHFKWDOOHUGLQJXQG\GHUPDQXQWHUWKDQ³ '(56 E :$*1(5 E :$*1(5F :$*1(5K
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
QXQJHQ HUNOlUWHQ VR]LRSROLWLVFKHQ *HJHEHQKHLWHQ >«@ ]HPHQWLHUW ZHUGHQ³ LQVLVWLHUW:DJQHUGDUDXIGDVVVLFKPLWLKULQGLYLGXHOOHZLHVR]LDOH3UD[LVEH]JH YHUELQGHQÄ'HQQHUVWGHU=XVDPPHQKDQJ]ZLVFKHQLQQHUHUXQGlXHUHU)UHLKHLW OlWGLHFKULVWOLFKH)UHLKHLW]XU:LUNOLFKNHLWZHUGHQ³'HULKU]XJUXQGHOLHJHQ GH:HFKVHOYRQGHUXQPLWWHOEDUDXVVLFKVHOEVWKHUYRUJHKHQGHQ]XUGXUFKJ|WWOL FKH$QHUNHQQXQJJHVFKHQNWHQ)UHLKHLWLVWDOVRHLQPDOPHKUVHLQHVVFKOHFKWKLQ QLJHQ3DVVLYLWlWVFKDUDNWHUV]XHQWOHGLJHQ1LFKWQXULVWGDVDXWRQRPH0LWVLFK VHOEVW$QIDQJHQGHV0HQVFKHQYRUDXV]XVHW]HQDXFKKDWGHVVHQPLWWHOVGHU5HGH YRQ*RWWDQJH]LHOWH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ$NWLYLWlWVSRWHQ]LDOHIUGDV/HEHQLQQHUKDOE GHUPRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW]XHU|IIQHQ'LHOHW]WHUH)RUGHUXQJWULIIWYRUGHUJUQ GLJEHWUDFKWHWDXFKEHL-QJHODXI5HVRQDQ]HQ-HGRFKJHKWHV:DJQHUPLWVHL QHU%HWRQXQJGHVSUDNWLVFKHQ5HDOZHUGHQVMHQHU)UHLKHLWDXVJ|WWOLFKHU$QHU NHQQXQJXPHLQHVR]LDOHWKLVFKH8PIRUPXQJGHV&KULVWHQWXPVGLHLQLKUHQOHW]W OLFKUDGLNDOHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQZHLWEHU-QJHOVVWULNWH%HJUHQ]XQJPHQVFKOLFKHQ +DQGOXQJVYHUP|JHQVKLQDXVJHKHQ 'HU HLJHQWOLFKH *UXQG GHU DXIJH]HLJWHQ 'LIIHUHQ]HQ ]ZLVFKHQ -QJHO XQG :DJQHUGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU)UHLKHLW EHWUHIIHQGDEHUOLHJWLQLKUHUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ)DVVXQJGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHV JHGDQNHQVEHJUQGHW'DEHLJHKWHVLQVEHVRQGHUHXPGLHWKHRORJLVFKH%HGHX WXQJGHV.UHX]HVWRGHV-HVXZLHHLQHIUKHDP(QGHGHU HU-DKUHYHUIDVVWH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ:DJQHUVPLW-QJHO]HLJW
Ä1RFKQLFKWGHUFKULVWOLFKH*RWW³±:DJQHUV.ULWLNDQ-QJHOV *RWWHVEHJULII ,PEHVDJWHQ7H[WVXFKW:DJQHULP$QVFKOXVVDQHLQHlXHUVWNULWLVFKH$QDO\VH GHUÄ:RUW*RWWHV7KHRORJLH³.DUO%DUWKVXQG5XGROI%XOWPDQQVÄGLH%HGLQ JXQJHQ]XHUJUQGHQXQWHUGHQHQHVDXIGHP%RGHQQHX]HLWOLFKHQ'HQNHQV EHUKDXSWP|JOLFKLVWYRQ*RWW]XVSUHFKHQ³=ZHL%HGLQJXQJHQVR:DJQHUV YRUOlXILJHV(UJHEQLVVLQGGDIU]XHUIOOHQ*RWWPXVVÄUHODWLY]XUPHQVFKOL FKHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlW³E]ZÄ]XGHUHQ'HQNHQ:ROOHQRGHU)KOHQ³HUIDVVEDUVHLQ XQGÄ]XJOHLFKVRJHGDFKW>ZHUGHQN|QQHQ@GDHUVLFKDOV*UXQGXQG8UVSUXQJ GHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWHUZHLVW³(UIOOWVLQGEHLGH%HGLQJXQJHQDEHU QXUZHQQ*RWWHEHQVRZHQLJ]XP3URGXNWPHQVFKOLFKHQ'HQNHQV:ROOHQVRGHU
:$*1(5 E :$*1(5K 9JO:$*1(5J ± 9JO]XUIROJHQGHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ:DJQHUVPLW-Q JHOGLHNULWLVFKH-QJHO5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ0LFKDHO0XUUPDQQ.DKOVLQGHUHLQLJH$UJXPHQWH :DJQHUVQHXLQV)HOGJHIKUWZHUGHQ 08550$11.$+/ :$*1(5J 9JOGD]X DD2 ± $D29JO]XGLHVHPZHLWHUHQ5DKPHQLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2II
hEHUJDQJ :DJQHUYV-QJHO
)KOHQVYHUHQGOLFKWZLH]XHLQHUGLH)UHLKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVOHW]WOLFKYHUHLWHOQGHQ DEVROXWHQ0DFKWLQVWDQ]YHUHZLJWZLUG*URHV3RWHQ]LDOIUGLHJOHLFKPlLJH (LQO|VXQJGHUEHVDJWHQ.ULWHULHQVFKUHLEW:DJQHUGHULQGHQ HU-DKUHQlX HUVWYLHOVWLPPLJHQÄ5HGHYRP7RG*RWWHV³]X,QGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJ QLPPWHU%H]XJDXI-QJHOGHUVLFK LQHLQHP9RP7RGGHVOHEHQGLJHQ *RWWHV EHUVFKULHEHQHQ %HLWUDJ JHUDGH GLHVHP LQ *RWW DOV *HKHLPQLV GHU :HOWVSlWHUQRFKDXVIKUOLFKHUEHKDQGHOWHQ7KHPD]XJHZHQGHWKDWWH 3RVLWLYEHXUWHLOW:DJQHU]XQlFKVWGDVV-QJHO±PLW5HNXUVDXI+HJHOVSKLOR VRSKLVFKHWKHRORJLDFUXFLV±GHP.UHX]HVWRG-HVXHLQHQGDV6HLQ*RWWHVXQEH GLQJWEHWUHIIHQGHQ&KDUDNWHU]XVFKUHLEW'RFKPRQLHUWHUVRJOHLFKGLH)ROJHQOR VLJNHLWGLHVHU(LQVLFKWIU-QJHOVHLJHQH.RQ]HSWLRQ'RUWQlPOLFKVRKHEW :DJQHU PLW SROHPLVFKHP 8QWHUWRQ KHUYRU ZLUG ÄDXV GHU WLHIHQ FKULVWOLFKHQ (LQVLFKWGD*RWWDOV-HVXVVHOEVWJHVWRUEHQLVWHLQHHUEDXOLFKH3KUDVHGLHLP *UXQGHQXUGD]XGLHQW*RWWDOVDFWXVSXULVVLPXVXPVRGHXWOLFKHUKHUYRUWUHWHQ ]XODVVHQ³0DFKWHV-QJHOVLFKHUNOlUWHUPDHQ]XP=LHOPLWNUHX]HVWKHROR JLVFKHQ0LWWHOQWUDGLWLRQHOOH$WWULEXWHGHVPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVZLH 8QYHUlQGHUOLFKNHLWXQG/HLGHQVXQIlKLJNHLW]XEHUZLQGHQNRPPWHUGDEHLVR :DJQHUEHU$QNQGLJXQJHQQLFKWKLQDXVÄ>'@HQQIU-QJHOJLOW>@GHUQLFKW ZHLWHUGLVNXWLHUWH*UXQGVDW]GDGHU7RG*RWWHVQLFKWGHU9HUOXVW*RWWHVVHLQ GDUI³'HPHQWVSUHFKHQGLVWÄ*RWWHV/HEHQYRQYRUQKHUHLQVRHLQJHULFKWHWGD HVDXFKQRFKGHQ7RGYHUWUlJWRKQHGDGLHVHVGDGXUFKXPVHLQH/HEHQGLJNHLW JHEUDFKWZLUG³'HUH[WUHPHQ6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ7RGXQG/HEHQVR:DJQHU OHLVWHWGLHVNDXP*HQJH6LHZLUGYLHOPHKUPLWWHOVGHUDUJXPHQWDWLYXQDXVJH ZLHVHQHQ%HKDXSWXQJHLQHUDOOHVLPPHUVFKRQEHUVWUDKOHQGHQ/HEHQGLJNHLW *RWWHVNDVVLHUW'HU7RGEHGHXWHWGDQQIU*RWWQXUHLQHÄSDUWLHOOH>@1HJDWLRQ³ GLHHLQHPÄ6FKHLQJHIHFKW³JOHLFKNRPPW±ÄGHQQ*RWWYHUPLWWHOWVLFKPLWHWZDV VFKRQ9HUPLWWHOWHP(LJQHPQLFKW PHKU)UHPGHQ³GHPJHJHQEHUÄVLFKGDV 6HLQ*RWWHVDEVWUDNWGXUFKKDOWHQ³NDQQ:DV:DJQHUNULWLVLHUWOlVVWVLFKRKQH :HLWHUHVDXIGLHLPYRUKHULJHQ.DSLWHOKHUDXVJHVWHOOWH7HQGHQ]LQ-QJHOV*RW WHVOHKUHDQZHQGHQ*RWWLQVHLQHPLQQHUWULQLWDULVFKHQ)UVLFK6HLQYRPFKULVWR ORJLVFKIXQGLHUWHQ)UXQV6HLQDE]XNRSSHOQVRGDVVHVLKPLP%H]XJDXIGHQ 0HQVFKHQQXUXPVHLQUHLQHV6LFK(QWVSUHFKHQJHKW ,P%OLFNDXIGLHYRQ:DJQHUIRUPXOLHUWHQ%HGLQJXQJHQPRGHUQHQ5HGHQV YRQ*RWWZLUGVR]ZDUGLH8QHQGOLFKNHLW*RWWHV]XEHZDKUHQYHUVXFKWGHVVHQ :HVHQ YRP (LQWULWW LQV (QGOLFKH OHW]WOLFK XQEHUKUW EOHLEW 'LH )UHLKHLW GHV
$D29JOGD]XLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2II 9JO-h1*(/L 9JO-h1*(/ EHV± :$*1(5J (EG (EG $D2I9JO]XULP)ROJHQGHQQXUNXU]GDUJHVWHOOWHQ$OWHUQDWLYSRVLWLRQ:DJQHUV DD2±
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
0HQVFKHQNRPPWMHGRFKLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQXQWHUGLH5lGHUZHQQGHU.UHX]HV WRGQXUGLH$EVROXWKHLWHLQHUVLFKLPPHUVFKRQJHJHQDOOHV:LGHUVWlQGLJHEH KDXSWHQGHQ/HEHQVPDFKWGRNXPHQWLHUW(LQVHOEVWlQGLJHV$QGHUHVJHJHQEHU *RWWQlPOLFKLVWQDFKGLHVHU/RJLNQLFKWGHQNEDUZDVDXFKIUGHQ0HQVFKHQ DOVDXWRQRPHV:HVHQJLOWÄ'LH5HGHYRP7RG*RWWHV³VRVFKlUIW:DJQHUGHV KDOEJHJHQEHU-QJHOHLQPXVVÄZHQQVLHQLFKWQXUHLQH)ORVNHOVHLQVROO>«@ ZLUNOLFKGHQ9HUOXVW*RWWHVPHLQHQ³6RQVWMHGHQIDOOVZlUHÄ*RWWLPPHUQRFK QLFKWDOVGHUFKULVWOLFKH*RWW³JHGDFKWÄGHUDP.UHX]ZLUNOLFKJHVWRUEHQLVW³ VRQGHUQÄDOV*RWWGHUPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ7UDGLWLRQGLH*RWWDOVDFWXVSXUXVXQG VRPLWOHLGHQVORVEHVWLPPW³'HUÄFKULVWOLFKH*RWW³DEHULVWDOVPHQVFKJHZRU GHQHUÄ*RWW>«@QLFKWOlQJHU+HUU ORJLVFK 6XEVWDQ] GHVVHQ0DFKWVLFKLQGHU 2KQPDFKWGHU0HQVFKHQ ORJLVFK $N]LGHQ]HQ PDQLIHVWLHUW³6HLQH$EVROXW KHLWPDQLIHVWLHUWVLFKYLHOPHKUTXDÄ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQDOVIUHLHU6XE MHNWLYLWlW³GLHVLFKGXUFK0HQVFKZHUGXQJ7RGXQG$XIHUVWHKXQJLKUHULQWHU VXEMHNWLYHQ(UP|JOLFKXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQJHZDKUZLUGXPVFKOLHOLFKVHOEVWDOV $QHUNHQQXQJDQGHUHUIUHLHU6XEMHNWLYLWlWSUDNWL]LHUW]XZHUGHQÄ'HU0HQVFK GHUVHLQH)UHLKHLWLQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHVDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQUHDOLVLHUW³VRKHLWHV LP6FKOXVVDEVFKQLWWYRQ:DJQHUVLQGHU)UK]HLWVHLQHVWKHRORJLVFKHQ6FKDIIHQV IRUPXOLHUWHQ$XVIKUXQJHQUHDOLVLHUWLQGHU.RQVHTXHQ]GHVÄ&KULVWXVJHVFKH KHQ>V@>«@GHQ+HLOLJHQ*HLVWDOVGLHORJLVFKH6WUXNWXUGHV,P$QGHUVVHLQEHL VLFKVHOEHUVHLQ³ :DV:DJQHUKLHUDP(QGHGHU HU-DKUHQRFKYRU(UVFKHLQHQVHLQHUDP /HKUVWXKO:ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJVHQWVWDQGHQHQ'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIW]X3DSLHU JHEUDFKWKDWHQWKlOWVFKRQLQQXFHZRUXPHVLKP±SULQ]LSLHOO±=HLWVHLQHV /HEHQVWKHRORJLVFKJLQJ'DYRQLVWQXQ]XKDQGHOQXQG]ZDUDXFKXQWHUGHP *HVLFKWVSXQNWRE:DJQHUVDOV*HJHQSRVLWLRQ QLFKWQXU ]X-QJHO]XSURILOLH UHQGHU$QVDW]HLQHK|KHUH3ODXVLELOLWlWIUVLFK]XEHDQVSUXFKHQYHUPDJ
$D2 (EG (EG $D2 $D2 9JO:$*1(5
$*RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU =ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKNHLW )DON:DJQHUV7KHRORJLHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ (LQOHLWXQJ ,KUHQUDGLNDOVWHQ$XVGUXFNILQGHW)DON:DJQHUVÄ7KHRORJLHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³ LQHLQHU)RUGHUXQJGLHVHLQHPOHW]WHQHUVWSRVWXPYHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ%XFK0HWD PRUSKRVHQGHVPRGHUQHQ3URWHVWDQWLVPXV]XHQWQHKPHQLVWÄ'HUVXEVWDQWLDOLV WLVFKH*RWWHVJHGDQNH³VRKHLWHVGRUWLVWÄGXUFKSHUVRQDOHXQGVR]LDOH$QHU NHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVH³]XHUVHW]HQÄGLHVLFKXQWHUGHU%HGLQJXQJLKUHV*HOLQ JHQVDOVÃJ|WWOLFKµSUlGL]LHUHQODVVHQ³ 5DGLNDOLVWGLHVHbXHUXQJ:DJQHUVZHLOVLHNHLQHSULQ]LSLHOOH'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ*RWWXQG:HOWPHKU]XODVVHQZLOO:RSHUVRQDOHXQGVR]LDOH$QHUNHQ QXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHJHOLQJHQLVWYLHOPHKUDXFKGLHDOVJ|WWOLFKWLWXOLHUEDUH:LUN OLFKNHLWUHDOLVLHUW$XV:DJQHUV6LFKWNRPPWGLH%H]LHKXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQ]HOQHQ ,QGLYLGXHQHEHQVRZLHGLH]ZLVFKHQ,QGLYLGXXPXQG*HVHOOVFKDIWJHQDXGDQQ ]XU(UIOOXQJZHQQVLHLQV\PPHWULVFKHU:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLWJHOHEWZLUG$XI QLFKWVDQGHUHVGUlQJWGHPQDFKGLHFKULVWOLFKH5HOLJLRQGHUHQ5HGHYRQ*RWWHLQ QRUPDWLYHV6ROOHQHQWKlOWGDV]XJOHLFK]XLGHQWLIL]LHUHQHUODXEWZDVQLFKWVHLQ VROOÄ*RWW³PDUNLHUWGDQQQXUVRODQJHQRFKHLQH'LIIHUHQ]]XULUGLVFKHQ5HDOL WlWZLHGDVZDVLP6LQQHGHVLQGLHVHP:RUWDXVJHGUFNWHQ6R]LDOLGHDOVVHLQ VROOQRFKXQHUIOOWEOHLEW 'DIUVSUHFKHQDXFK:DJQHUVNXUVRULVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQ]XHLQHUGHQWUDGLWLR QHOOHQ$XIHUVWHKXQJVJODXEHQEHHUEHQGHQÄ*HJHQZDUWVHVFKDWRORJLH³,QGHUHQ =HQWUXPQlPOLFKVWHKWGDVÄDXIGLHHQGJOWLJH9ROOVWlQGLJNHLWXQG9ROONRP PHQKHLWHLQHUUHOLJL|VHQ9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJ³]LHOHQGHÄ5HLFK*RWWHV³YRQGHP JLOW (VÄVROOGXUFKGDVLQWHUDJLHUHQGH+DQGHOQGHU,QGLYLGXHQ>«@UHDOLVLHUW ZHUGHQ³VRGDVVÄVFKOLHOLFKDOOH,QGLYLGXHQVLFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJLKUH3HUV|QOLFK
%$57+$QGHUVDOVHV%DUWKDQJLEWOlVVWVLFKGLHVH(WLNHWWLHUXQJDOOHUVWDUNHQ 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ]XP7URW]DEHUDXI:DJQHUVWKHRORJLVFKHV6FKDIIHQLP*DQ]HQEH]LHKHQ 7HLOHGHVIROJHQGHQ.DSLWHOVZXUGHQEHUHLWVYHU|IIHQWOLFKLQ 7(7=/$)) 6&+(,:,//(5 7(7=/$)) 7(7=/$))D :$*1(5 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
NHLW]XUHFKQHQGLHVLHGRFKIDNWLVFKZHGHUKDEHQQRFKVLQG³)ULQQHUZHOWOL FKH9HUKlOWQLVVHLQGHQHQGLHVHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH=XUHFKQXQJYRQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLW E]ZUH]LSURNH$QHUNHQQXQJDOV3HUVRQHQSUDNWL]LHUWZLUGKDW:DJQHUGHPJH PlGDV*|WWOLFKNHLWVSUlGLNDWUHVHUYLHUW6HLQ+LQZHLVGDVVQLHPDQGHV3HUV|Q OLFKNHLWLP)DNWLVFKHQDXIJHKWPDFKWDEHUGHXWOLFKGDVVGLHGDPLWQRUPDWLY DXVJH]HLFKQHWHVR]LDOH)RUPDWLRQNHLQHQVWDWLVFKHQVRQGHUQHLQHQG\QDPLVFKHQ &KDUDNWHUDXIZHLVW'DVHQWVFKHLGHQGH6WLFKZRUWKLQVLFKWOLFKGLHVHU(QWZLFN OXQJVRIIHQKHLWYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQODXWHW LPPDQHQWH7UDQV]HQGHQ] 'LHHLQJDQJV]LWLHUWH)RUGHUXQJ:DJQHUVLVWDEHUDXFKLQVRIHUQUDGLNDODOV VLFKLQLKUGDV5HVXOWDWHLQHU]XQHKPHQGHQ5DGLNDOLVLHUXQJVHLQHUHLJHQHQ3RVL WLRQGLH%HGHXWXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVEHWUHIIHQGQLHGHUVFKOlJW1LFKWHUVWDQ GHUHQ.XOPLQDWLRQVSXQNWDEHUVWHKWGLH(LQVLFKWGDVVLPFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJH GDQNHQ GLH ORJLVFKH 6WUXNWXU YRQ $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ LPSOL]LHUW LVW %HUHLWVGHULPYRUKHULJHQ$EVFKQLWWDQJHIKUWH7H[WDXV:DJQHUV)UK]HLWZDU YRQGLHVHU7KHVHEHVWLPPW(QWVSUHFKHQGUHVPLHUWHULQHLQHPDXWRELRJUDIL VFKHQ5FNEOLFNGHU LP-DKUHVHLQHV7RGHVHUVFKLHQHQLVWQLFKWQXUGLH ÄWLHIJUHLIHQGH>Q@9HUlQGHUXQJHQJHLVWLJHU$UW³GLHVHLQHGHQNHULVFKH(QWZLFN OXQJIUDJORVJHSUlJWKDEHQ9LHOPHKUÄKDWVLFK³ZLHHVGRUWKHLWÄDXFKHWZDV GXUFKJHKDOWHQ QlPOLFKGLHVHGRFKOHW]WHQ(QGHVVR]LDOHWKLVFKPRWLYLHUWH=LHO VHW]XQJGHV&KULVWHQWXPV³GLHVLFKLPDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ)RNXVVHLQHV 'HQNHQVQLHGHUVFKOlJW'DVV)UHLKHLWQXUDXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJDOVÄVR ]LDOH)UHLKHLW³OHEEDULVWZHLOVLHVRQVWLQHLQHUVHOEVW]HUVW|UHULVFKHQ/RJLNGHU *HZDOW PQGHW LVW QDFK :DJQHUV 9HUVWlQGQLV GLH 3RLQWH GHV YRQ LKP ]XU Ä4XLQWHVVHQ]GHV&KULVWHQWXPV³HUNOlUWHQÄ'RSSHOJHERW>V@GHU/LHEH³ 8QEH VFKDGHWGLHVHU.RQWLQXLWlWLQGHUVLFKDXFKGDVDOVMXJHQGOLFKHU3IDGILQGHUNHQ QHQJHOHUQWH Ä&KULVWHQWXP >«@ GHU 7DW³ QLHGHUVFKODJHQ PDJ DEHU KDW VHLQ 'HQNHQHLQHQWLHIJUHLIHQGHQ8PEUXFKHUIDKUHQ 'LHEHVDJWH8PZlO]XQJEHWULIIWGLH]HQWUDOH0D[LPHGHVGXUFK*HOHKUWHZLH :ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJ7KHRGRU:$GRUQR:ROIJDQJ&UDPHUXQG%UXQR/LHE UXFNVJHSUlJWHQÄ+HJHOLDQHU>V@PLW+DXWXQG+DDUHQ³ Ä>'@DV$EVROXWHPX
(EG 9JO]XUWKHRORJLHJHVFKLFKWOLFKHQ(LQRUGQXQJXQG]XP:HUGHJDQJ:DJQHUVVRZLH]X GHQ 8PEUFKHQ LQ VHLQHP 'HQNHQ ),6&+(5 ± %$57+ 0(77( II ',(5.(132/.(II ',(5.(1II :$*1(5 E 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ HEG (EG $D2 $D2 $D2 %$57+9JO]XGHQ3UlJXQJHQ:DJQHUVGXUFKWKHRORJLVFKH/HKUHUXQGLQVEH VRQGHUH]XPVSDQQXQJVUHLFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVGDVLKQPLWVHLQHP'RNWRUYDWHUHEHQVRYHUEDQG ZLHYRQLKPHQW]ZHLWH 52+/6EHVII :(1= II
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
JHGDFKWZHUGHQ³*LQJGLHVHU/HLWVDW]]XQlFKVWPLWGHP$QVSUXFKHLQHUYRP IURPPHQ6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQDEVWUDKLHUHQGHQ%HJUQGXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV LP6LQQHHLQHU7KHRULHGHVVLFKVHOEVWDXVOHJHQGHQ$EVROXWHQHLQKHUNDP:DJ QHUVFKOLHOLFK]XHLQHUDOWHUQDWLYHQ(LQVLFKW 'HUÄ*HGDQNHGHV$EVROXWHQOlVVW VLFK GXUFK HLQH 7KHRULH VHLQHU $XVOHJXQJ QXU LQ VHLQHP 6FKHLWHUQ UHWWHQ³ %LRJUDILVFKIlOOWGLHVHU:DQGHOPLW:DJQHUV:HFKVHOYRQGHU0QFKQHU ± DQGLH:LHQHU(YDQJHOLVFK7KHRORJLVFKH)DNXOWlW ± ZRVLFK VHLQH3RVLWLRQVXN]HVVLYHYHUlQGHUWH]XVDPPHQ'HUGDUDXVUHVXOWLHUHQGHQ$E ZHUWXQJGHVHQWVXEVWDQ]LDOLVLHUWHQ*|WWOLFK$EVROXWHQ]XP3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHNRUUHVSRQGLHUWHLQH$XIZHUWXQJLQGLYLGXHOOJHOHEWHU 5HOLJLRVLWlW=HQWUDOHV.ULWHULXPIUGLH:DKUKHLWVIlKLJNHLWWKHRORJLVFKHU$XV VDJHQLVWGHPQDFKZHQLJHULKUHREMHNWLYH%HJUQGEDUNHLWDOVYLHOPHKUGLH)UDJH REVLHGHQÄ7HVWLKUHUhEHUVHW]EDUNHLWLQ%HODQJHGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQGKSHUVRQDO XQG VR]LDO RULHQWLHUWHQ /HEHQVIKUXQJ³ EHVWHKHQ 'DVV DXI GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 5HOHYDQ]GHV&KULVWHQWXPVLQ:DJQHUVVSlWHU6FKDIIHQVSKDVHGDV+DXSWDXJHQ PHUNOLHJWZHVKDOEHUDXFKYRQHLQHUÄHPSLULVFKKLVWRULVFKH>Q@:HQGH³VHLQHV 'HQNHQVVSULFKWLVWZLHJHVDJWMHGRFKQLFKWRKQH$QDORJLHQLP)UKZHUN$XFK ZHLWHUKLQEOHLEWGDVPLWGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HGHYRQ*RWWIRNXVVLHUWH$QHUNHQ QXQJVWKHPDIU:DJQHUHQWVFKHLGHQG1RFKHLQPDOUDGLNDOLVLHUWDEHUZHUGHQ JHZLVVHUPDHQGLHVFKRQ-QJHOJHJHQEHUHLQJHIRUGHUWHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQGLH GHU7RG*RWWHVIU*RWWVHOEVWKDW2EHUGLHVHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQLQVHLQHU)UK]HLW VRJHVHKHQEHUKDXSWYROOXPIlQJOLFKJHUHFKWJHZRUGHQLVWOlVVWVLFKGDQQDEHU HEHQVRIUDJHQZLHGHUVSlWH:DJQHUPLWHLQHUNULWLVFKHQ$QPHUNXQJ+HUPDQQ
%$57+ :$*1(5 $D2 :$*1(5 E 9JOGD]XGLHVWHOOHQZHLVHGLIIHULHUHQGHQ(LQVFKlW]XQJHQGLHVHU 6HOEVW]XVFKUHLEXQJ YRQ %$57+ II ',(5.(1 II 0(77( II 08550$11.$+/9JO]XHLQHUSUDNWLVFKWKHRORJLVFKHQ(LQRUGQXQJ *5b%E 0DWWKLDV6FKQXUUHQEHUJHUYHUVXFKWGHQWLHIJUHLIHQGHQÄ9HUVFKLHEXQJHQLQ:DJQHUV7KHROR JLH³VR]XEHJHJQHQGDVVHUÄ:DJQHUV7H[WH>«@V\QFKURQOLHVW³VRGDVVVLFKDP(QGHGRFK ÄHLQVFKOVVLJHV*HVDPWELOGVHLQHU7KHRORJLH³HUJLEW 6&+1855(1%(5*(5 I ±GLHVH /HVDUWDEHUJHKWEHL6FKQXUUHQEHUJHUGHXWOLFK]X8QJXQVWHQGHVÃVSlWHQµ:DJQHUXQGVHLQHU UHOLJLRQVWKHRORJLVFKHQ$UEHLWHQDXVGLHEHLLKPQXUHLQH$UW$SSHQGL[ELOGHQ'DVV:DJQHU ZLHHU&KULVWLDQ'DQ]µ:DJQHU/HNWUHYRUKlOWÄGLH5HOLJLRQGHU,QGLYLGXHQQLFKWQXUSRVLWLY VLHKW³VRQGHUQLQLKUZLHHUPLW9HUZHLVDXI&KULVWLQH$[W3LVFDODUVFKUHLEWÄYRUDOOHPDXFK >@HLQ.ULVHQV\PSWRPGHUPRGHUQHQ:HOW³HQWGHFNWVFKHLQWHUPLW1DFKGUXFNDXI]HLJHQ]X ZROOHQ DD2 Ä:DJQHULVW2IIHQEDUXQJVWKHRORJH³HUGHQNH.DUO%DUWKJOHLFKÄYRQGHU 6HOEVWRIIHQEDUXQJ*RWWHVKHU³ DD2 KHLWHVDP(QGHGHU$UEHLW]XVDPPHQIDVVHQG XQG]ZDULP%OLFNDXIGDV*HVDPWZHUN 0LFKDHO0XUUPDQQ.DKOPDFKWKLQJHJHQDXIEHU]HXJHQGH:HLVHNODUGDVVÄ:DJQHUVHL QH7KHRORJLHHLQHUVHLWVWDWVlFKOLFKÃUDGLNDOµXPRULHQWLHUWXQGDQGHUHUVHLWVVWHWVDXIEHVWLPPWH 7HLOHGHU+HJHOVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHUHNXUULHUWKDW±XQGGDV]XDOOHQ=HLWHQDEHUHEHQLQXQWHU VFKLHGOLFKHU:HLVH³ 08550$11.$+/
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
)LVFKHUV]XNRQIURQWLHUHQLVW ÄZDUXPHVIUGHQ3UR]HZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHU NHQQXQJXQWHUYHUQQIWLJHQ6XEMHNWHQEHUKDXSWQRFKGHU*RWWHVLGHHEHGDUI³ 'LHIROJHQGH'DUVWHOOXQJYRQ:DJQHUV$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRORJLHPXVVGLHVHP 8PEUXFKLP%HJUQGXQJV]XVDPPHQKDQJVHLQHU3RVLWLRQXQGGHQGLHVEH]JOLFK DXIJHZRUIHQHQ)UDJHQ5HFKQXQJWUDJHQ'LHVJLOWLQVEHVRQGHUHIUGHQHUVWHQ $EVFKQLWWGHU]XP7KHPDKDWZLH:DJQHUGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLNDXVGHP *RWWHVJHGDQNHQKHUDXVHQWZLFNHOW(QWVFKHLGHQGLVWGDIUHLQHYRQLKPDOVGDV VSH]LILVFK&KULVWOLFKHKHUDXVJHVWHOOWHÄ5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV³ GLH.RQVHTXHQ]HQIUGLHPHQVFKOLFKH)UHLKHLWVSUD[LVKDW 'DUDXIKLQDEHU YHUODJHUWVLFKGHU6FKZHUSXQNWDXI(LQVLFKWHQGHVÄVSlWHQ³:DJQHUKLQVLFKWOLFK GHUVR]LDOHQ)XQNWLRQGHV&KULVWHQWXPVLP.RQWH[WGHU0RGHUQH'HQ%H]XJV SXQNWELOGHWKLHUHLQHK|FKVWDPELYDOHQWH$QHUNHQQXQJVE]Z)UHLKHLWVHUIDK UXQJGHUGLH,QGLYLGXHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKDXVJHVHW]WVLQG 6FKOLHOLFKNRP PHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQLQGHQ%OLFNGLHGHUQRUPDWLYH*HKDOWGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*RW WHVJHGDQNHQVE]ZGLHGDULQLPSOL]LHUWH$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNIUGLH%HXUWHLOXQJ XQG*HVWDOWXQJVR]LDOHU,QVWLWXWLRQHQ±JHQDXHU GHV5HFKWVGHUgNRQRPLHXQG GHU.LUFKH±KDW
5HYROXWLRQHQ *|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJXQGPHQVFKOLFKH )UHLKHLW Ä'LH5HGHYRP7RG*RWWHV³VRKDWWH:DJQHULP=XJHVHLQHU.ULWLNDQ-QJHOV 3RVLWLRQ HLQJHVFKlUIW PXVV ÄZHQQ VLH QLFKW QXU HLQH )ORVNHO VHLQ VROO >«@ ZLUNOLFKGHQ9HUOXVW*RWWHVPHLQHQ³6RQVWIKUWVLH]XMHQHPIUHLKHLWVWKHRUH WLVFKHQ'HIL]LWGDVQLFKWQXUGLHPLWHLQHUGRSSHOWHQ3DVVLYLWlWV]XPXWXQJEHKDI WHWH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHLP.RQWH[WGHU0RGHUQHXQYHUPLWWHOEDUZHUGHQOlVVW :HOFKHNULVHQKDIWHQ)ROJHQHLQ)HVWKDOWHQDQWUDGLWLRQHOOPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ*RW WHVYRUVWHOOXQJHQYLHOPHKUIU.LUFKHXQG7KHRORJLHLQVJHVDPWKDW]HLJHQ:DJ QHUVGUDVWLVFKH'LDJQRVHQ=XUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ/DJHGHV3URWHVWDQWLVPXVDXVGHU 0LWWHGHU HU-DKUH'DVVZLHHUGRUWVFKUHLEWÄGHQULWXDOLVLHUWHQ'DXHUUHGHQ YRQ*RWWLQQHUKDOEGHU*UHQ]HQGHUNLUFKOLFKHQ5HOLJLRQGDVHEHQVRJHZ|KQOL FKH ZLH EHUHGWH 6FKZHLJHQ YRQ *RWW DXHUKDOE GLHVHU *UHQ]HQ JHJHQEHU VWHKW³KDWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQDXFKHLQIHKOJHOHLWHWHVWKHRORJLVFKHV'HQNHQ]XU 8UVDFKH'HVVHQ0DQJHOEHVWHKWHEHQGDULQGLHFKULVWOLFKH=HQWUDOPRWLYHGHU
),6&+(5 :$*1(5J :$*1(5 D'HU+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJGDVVÄ>L@P%HUHLFKGHV'HQNHQVGHU3KLORVR SKLHXQGGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ>«@YRQ*RWWJHVFKZLHJHQ³ZLUGNRQQWH:DJQHUDEHUDXFK VFKRQ PLWGHU)RUGHUXQJEHJHJQHQGLHÄ(QWJHJHQVHW]XQJYRQXQHQGOLFKDOOPlFKWLJHQ :HVHQ*RWWHVXQGGHU(QGOLFKNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ³]XEHUZLQGHQZHLOVLHÄVRHWZDVZLH PHQVFKOLFKH)UHLKHLW³]XGHQNHQYHUXQP|JOLFKW '(56E
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
0HQVFKZHUGXQJ*RWWHVXQGGHV*RWWHVWRGHVLKUHUHLJHQWOLFKWLHIJUHLIHQGHQ.RQ VHTXHQ]HQ]XEHUDXEHQ:DJQHU]XIROJHEHGHXWHQVLHUHFKWYHUVWDQGHQ QLFKW ZHQLJHUDOVHLQHÄ5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV³ GLHGHQÄVSH]LILVFK >«@QHXHQ*HKDOW³GHV&KULVWHQWXPVDXVPDFKW(VLVWGLH)LJXUGHVDXIXQPLW WHOEDUH :HLVH VHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ XQG VHOEVWlQGLJHQ +HUUVFKHUJRWWV GHP DOOHLQ PHQVFKOLFKH 2KQPDFKW HQWVSULFKW GLH GDEHL YRP 6RFNHO JHVWRHQ ZLUG ,KU (QGHZLUG]XP$XVJDQJVSXQNWHLQHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ9HUKlOWQLVZHLVHGLHDQ VWHOOH HLQVHLWLJ PDFKYROOHU 6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJ DXI GLH ZHFKVHOVHLWLJ V\PPHWULVFKH$QHUNHQQXQJVXEMHNWLYHU)UHLKHLW]LHOW 'HUGDPLWHLJHQWOLFKEHUZXQGHQH*RWWHVJHGDQNHDEHUKDWLP&KULVWHQWXP ZLH:DJQHULPPHUZLHGHUPRQLHUWHLQ)RUWOHEHQLQYLHOHUOHL*HVWDOWJHIXQGHQ (UH[LVWLHUWZHLWHULQGHUUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKYRUDXVJHVHW]WHQ$OOHLQZLUN VDPNHLWGHV6FK|SIHUV+LPPHOVXQGGHU(UGHQEHLPhEHUJDQJYRP6QGHU]XP *HUHFKWHQ(UZLUGSHUSHWXLHUWZRPDQHLQHUÄ9HUNQSIXQJGHVDOWWHVWDPHQW OLFKIUKMGLVFKHQ*RWWHVYHUVWlQGQLVVHVPLWGHPFKULVWOLFKQHXWHVWDPHQWOLFKHQ³ GDV:RUWUHGHWRGHUGHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQÄ*UXQGJHGDQNHQGHVDEVROXWVHOEVWlQ GLJHQ DOOPlFKWLJHQ *RWWHV³ DXIJUHLIW ,QVEHVRQGHUH ÄGLH :RUW*RWWHV 7KHRORJLHGHV=ZDQ]LJVWHQ-DKUKXQGHUWVQDPHQWOLFKGHUEDUWKVFKHQ*HVWDOWXQG GHUVHLQHU6FKOHUXQG(QNHO³VLHKW:DJQHUDXIXQEHLUUEDUH:HLVHDP*HGDQNHQ HLQHUÄXQEHGLQJWH>Q@+HUUVFKDIW*RWWHV³IHVWKDOWHQ:RGLHZHVHQWOLFKFKULVWOL FKH5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVDEHUDXVEOHLEWZLUGGLHVHULQNRPSD WLEHO PLW GHU )UHLKHLW GHV 0HQVFKHQ MD HU EHGHXWHW GDQQ GHUHQ 1LFKW $QHUNHQQXQJXQG1HJDWLRQ'LH)ROJHLVWHLQWLHIJUHLIHQGHU3ODXVLELOLWlWVXQG 5HOHYDQ]YHUOXVWGHV&KULVWHQWXPVLQGHU0RGHUQHGLHHLJHQWOLFKGHQ)UHLKHLWV JHKDOWGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HOLJLRQQ|WLJKlWWH ,P+LQWHUJUXQGGHUNULWLVFKHQ$EZHQGXQJGLH:DJQHUPLWVHLQHU3URJUDPP IRUPHOYRQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQÃ5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVµJHJHQEHU GHQHUZlKQWHQWKHRORJLVFKSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ6LFKWZHLVHQYROO]LHKWVWHKHQ9RU EHKDOWHORJLVFKNDWHJRULDOHU$UW6LHJHKHQDXIGLHHLQJHKHQGH/HNWUHYRQ+H JHOV:LVVHQVFKDIWGHU/RJLN]XUFN,QVEHVRQGHUHDQGHPGHUÄ:LUNOLFKNHLW³ JHZLGPHWHQ 6FKOXVVDEVFKQLWW GHU :HVHQVORJLN KDW VLFK :DJQHUV NULWLVFK NRQVWUXNWLYH 3RVLWLRQ JHELOGHW :HU DXI GHVVHQ +LQWHUJUXQG *RWW E]Z GDV $EVROXWH DOV HLQH XQPLWWHOEDU VHOEVWPlFKWLJVHOEVWlQGLJH ,QVWDQ] ]X GHQNHQ YHUVXFKW ZLUG VHLQHV (UDFKWHQV XQZHLJHUOLFK ÄGXUFK GHV *HGDQNHQV HLJHQH
'LHVH)RUPHOGLH]XJHJHEHQHUPDHQHUVWLP6SlWZHUN]HQWUDOHQ*HEUDXFKILQGHWEH JHJQHWDEHUQLFKWQXULKUHP6DFKJHKDOWQDFKVRQGHUQDXFKZRUWZ|UWOLFKLQIUKHQ$XIVlW]HQ :DJQHUV 9RQ HLQHU Ä5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJ *RWWHV³ VFKUHLEW HWZD VFKRQ YJO :$*1(5 M :$*1(5Y $XVGUFNOLFKVWHOOW:DJQHUGLHVHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJKHULQ :$*1(5 E± :$*1(5 E $D2 9JO+(*(/ ±
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
,QNRQVLVWHQ]JH]ZXQJHQ>«@GHP*HGDQNHQHLQHQHXHVHLQH%HVWLPPWKHLWXQG ,QNRQVLVWHQ]O|VHQGH)RUP]XJHEHQ³%H]JOLFKGHU)UDJHZRULQGHPQDFKGLH ]X EHUZLQGHQGH $SRULH GHV *RWWHVJHGDQNHQV EHVWHKW LVW :DJQHU VLFK =HLW VHLQHV/HEHQVWUHXJHEOLHEHQ9HUlQGHUWKDWVLFKKLQJHJHQVHLQ%OLFNGDUDXI ZHOFKHGLHVHÃ,QNRQVLVWHQ]O|VHQGHQHXH)RUPµGHP*RWWHVJHGDQNHQJHJHEHQ ZHUGHQPXVV'LHDXV:DJQHUV6LFKW]ZLQJHQGHQ$UJXPHQWHIUGHVVHQORJL VFKHV6FKHLWHUQVLQGGHVKDOELP)ROJHQGHQHEHQVRQDFK]XYROO]LHKHQ ZLH VHLQHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ/|VXQJVZHJHQQDFK]XJHKHQLVW 6WHKWVFKOLHOLFK YRU$XJHQZLH:DJQHUDXV5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVVHLQH$QHU NHQQXQJVWKHRORJLH HQWZLFNHOW ZLUG UHVPLHUW ZDV GLHV IU GLH PHQVFKOLFKH )UHLKHLWVSUD[LVEHGHXWHW 'DV6FKHLWHUQGHVXQPLWWHOEDUVHOEVWPlFKWLJVHOEVWlQGLJHQ*RWWHV 'HU*RWWGHU6HOEVWPDFKW6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJXQG6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWÃVFKHLWHUWµ(U ÃVFKHLWHUWµDQGHUHLJHQHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHLQH'LIIHUHQ]PDFKHQ]XPVVHQGLH QXUGDQQDXIJHKREHQZHUGHQNDQQZHQQGHU8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQGHQLQ'LIIH UHQ]VWHKHQGHQ0RPHQWHQ±>«@6HW]HQXQG*HVHW]WVHLQ±DXIJHKREHQZLUG :DJQHUV:RUWHGLHVHLQHU DOV9RUOHVXQJJHKDOWHQHQ(LQOHLWXQJLQGLHWKHR ORJLVFKH7KHRORJLHHQWVWDPPHQGUFNHQGDV5HVXOWDWHLQHVOlQJHUHQ*HGDQNHQ JDQJVDXV'HUIRUPXOLHUWHQ(LQVLFKWLQV6FKHLWHUQGHVÃ*RWWHVGHU6HOEVWPDFKW 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJXQG6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWµJHKWGLHDXVIKUOLFKH5HYLVLRQGLHVHV *HGDQNHQVDP/HLWIDGHQMHQHVEHUHLWVHUZlKQWHQGULWWHQ$EVFKQLWWVGHUKHJHO VFKHQ:HVHQVORJLNYRUDXV$XIMHGHU6WXIHGHVGDEHLGXUFKVFKULWWHQHQVWUXNWXU JHQHWLVFKHQ .RQWLQXXPV WULWW LPPHU ZLHGHU GLH VFKOLHOLFK ]XP J|WWOLFKHQ 6FKHLWHUQIKUHQGHÃ'LIIHUHQ]YRQ6HW]HQXQG*HVHW]WVHLQµ±RGHUDXFK%HVWLP PHQXQG%HVWLPPWKHLW$NWLYLWlWXQG3DVVLYLWlW0DFKWXQG2KQPDFKWHWF± KHUYRU.DQQGHUHQHLQHQGH$XIKHEXQJZLHHVLP(LQJDQJV]LWDWDQNOLQJWQXU GXUFK$XIKHEXQJGHVPLWLKUHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ8QWHUVFKLHGVJHOLQJHQLVWLQIROJH GHVVHQZHGHUHLQHDEVROXWH6HOEVWPDFKW6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJXQG6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW QRFKGHUHQ*HJHQWHLOGHQNEDU7KHRORJLVFKHUZHLVWVLFKGLHVHUORJLVFKH6FKOXVV DOVK|FKVWIROJHQUHLFKZLH:DJQHUQRFKNQDSS]ZDQ]LJ-DKUHQDFKGHUHUZlKQ WHQ9RUOHVXQJGDUOHJW Ä'DV6FKHLWHUQGHV*HGDQNHQVGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ6HOEVWXQG $OOPDFKW ]LHKW >«@ GLH 5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJ GHV *RWWHVJHGDQNHQV QDFK VLFK³ =HQWUDOH:HVHQVPHUNPDOHGHVWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVQlPOLFKZHUGHQ VRQRWZHQGLJHU:HLVHYHUDEVFKLHGHW
:$*1(5Q 0LWGLHVHU)RUPXOLHUXQJIDVVW:DJQHUGDVPHWKRGLVFKH9RUJHKHQ +HJHOVLQGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWGHU/RJLN]XVDPPHQ :$*1(5M'LHVH)RUPXOLHUXQJLVWJHZLVVHUPDHQHLQH$QZHQGXQJGHU]XYRU DXIORJLVFKNDWHJRULDOHU (EHQH JHZRQQHQHQ XQG IDVW LGHQWLVFKIRUPXOLHUWHQ (LQVLFKW GDVV Ä>G@LHVLFKPDQLIHVWLHUHQGH6HOEVWPDFKWXQG6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJÃVFKHLWHUWµ³DXIGHQ*RWWHVJH GDQNHQ DD2 :$*1(5
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
8PGLHVH.RQVHTXHQ]LP%OLFN]XEHKDOWHQZLUG:DJQHUV]XLKUKLQIKUHQGHU *HGDQNHQJDQJQXQDXVJHKHQGYRQVHLQHU.ULWLNHLQHUlXHUVWJHOlXILJHQWKHROR JLVFKHQ 5HGHQVDUW QDFKJH]HLFKQHW *HPHLQW LVW GLH 'HILQLWLRQ *RWWHVDOV GHU Ä$OOHV EHVWLPPHQGHQ :LUNOLFKNHLW³ ZLH VLH ± 5XGROI %XOWPDQQ EHHUEHQG ± LQVEHVRQGHUH YRQ :ROIKDUW 3DQQHQEHUJ YHUWUHWHQ ZXUGH 'LHVHU $XVJDQJV SXQNWOLHJWQLFKWQXUGHVKDOEQDKHZHLOGLHEHVDJWH)RUPHOJHUDGHDXIHLQH$N WXDOLVLHUXQJGHV$OOPDFKWVJHGDQNHQVDXVLVWVRQGHUQDXFKLKUHU9HUZHQGXQJ GHU:LUNOLFKNHLWVNDWHJRULHZHJHQ8POHW]WHUHJHKWHVLQGHQZHVHQVORJLVFKHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ+HJHOVDXIGLHVLFK:DJQHUYRUDOOHPEH]LHKW1DFKVHLQHU/HVDUW ZLUG Ã:LUNOLFKNHLWµ GDEHL ]XQlFKVW LP HQJHUHQ 6LQQH GK DOV 0RGDOLWlWVEH VWLPPXQJ XQGKHUQDFKLQHLQHPZHLWHUHQ6LQQHDOVUHODWLRQDOH.DWHJR ULH WKHPDWLVLHUW %HVWLPPWH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ±GLH0|JOLFKNHLWGHU:LUNOLFKNHLW :HUDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGVHLQVROOVRKHEW:DJQHUVHUVWHU+DXSWHLQZDQGJHJHQGLH EHVDJWHWKHRORJLVFKH)RUPHODQPXVVDXFKLP%OLFNDXIVLFKVHOEVWDOVGHUHLQ ]LJ %HVWLPPHQGH JHOWHQ N|QQHQ (LQHP LQ ZHOFKHU +LQVLFKW DXFK LPPHU IUHPGEHVWLPPWHQ*RWWZLUGVROFKHDEVROXWH:LUNPlFKWLJNHLWGDQQ]X8QUHFKW ]XJHVFKULHEHQ$XIHLQHQWVSUHFKHQGHV0RPHQWYRQ$EKlQJLJNHLWDEHUVW|WLQ :DJQHUV$XJHQ ZHUJDQ]DOOJHPHLQGLH6WUXNWXUGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJEH GHQNW'HPQDFKLVWÄGDV6LFKVHOEVWEHVWLPPHQ>«@VHOEVWGDULQEHVWLPPW6LFK VHOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ ]X VHLQ³ :HQLJVWHQV GLHVH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ PXVV GLH IU VFKOHFKWKLQYRUDXVVHW]XQJVORVHUNOlUWHJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWH:LUNOLFKNHLWDOVRPD FKHQ hEHUKDXSWVHLQ]XN|QQHQDOVZDVVLHVLFKPDQLIHVWLHUW0RGDOORJLVFK IRUPXOLHUW 6LHEHDQVSUXFKWGLHÄ0|JOLFKNHLW:LUNOLFKNHLW]XVHLQ³XPVLFKDOV Ä:LUNOLFKNHLWLKUHUVHOEVW³]XHUZHLVHQ,P$NWGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJPDFKW VLHDOVR*HEUDXFKYRQHLQHP6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVSRWHQ]LDOGDVVLHIUGHVVHQ
9JO]XGLHVHU)RUPHO 3$11(1%(5* II %8/70$11 E9JO]X:DJ QHUVLP )ROJHQGHQ HQWIDOWHWHU .ULWLN DQ GHUEHVDJWHQ )RUPHO :$*1(5 QII 'LH :LUNPlFKWLJNHLWGHU5HGHYRQ*RWWDOVGHUDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWOlVVWVLFKHWZDDQ :LOIULHG+lUOHV'RJPDWLNDEOHVHQGLHVFKRQVHLWOlQJHUHPDOV6WDQGDUGZHUNIUGLH9RUEHUHL WXQJ]XPWKHRORJLVFKHQ([DPHQ JLOW+lUOHVSULFKWGLHVEH]JOLFKYRPÄDQJHPHVVHQVWH>Q@ Ã'HILQLWRQVYRUVFKODJµGHQHV]XU=HLWIUGHQ%HJULIIÃ*RWWµJLEW³ +b5/( 9JO:$*1(5M,P)ROJHQGHQZLUG:DJQHUV7KHVHGHVDQVLFKVHOEVWVFKHL WHUQGHQ*RWWHVYRUDOOHPDQKDQG]ZHLHU7H[WHDXVVHLQHUIUKHQVHLQHU0QFKQHU=HLWUHNRQV WUXLHUWGLHVLFKDOVDXVGUFNOLFKH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHQGHV:LUNOLFKNHLWVNDSLWHOVDXV+HJHOV:LV VHQVFKDIWGHU/RJLNYHUVWHKHQ2KQHGLHVHQVWDUNHQ7H[WEH]XJDEHUPLWGHQJOHLFKHQ$UJX PHQWHQEHJUQGHWGHUÄVSlWH³:DJQHUVHLQH7KHVHLQ GHUV D± ± 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPWGLH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQEHL ',(5.(1II 9JO]XPIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWW :$*1(5M± Q ± 9JOGD ]X +(*(/ ± :$*1(5Q $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
9ROO]XJLPPHUVFKRQYRUDXVVHW]HQPXVVZHQQJOHLFKHVQXUIUGLHVHQLVW'LH J|WWOLFKDEVROXWH:LUNOLFKNHLWLVWKLHULP%H]XJDXIVLFKVHOEVWPLWHLQHUÄQRW ZHQGLJDXIWUHWHQGH>Q@'LIIHUHQ]³NRQIURQWLHUWYRQGHUEHUHLWVGLH5HGHZDU 6LH EHVWHKW ]ZLVFKHQ DNWLYHP 6HW]HQ XQG SDVVLYHP 9RUDXVVHW]HQ PVVHQ *HVHW]WVHLQ:HJHQLKUHU8QKLQWHUJHKEDUNHLWIUMHGHV:LUNHQOlVVWVLH VLFK QLFKW HLQVHLWLJ DNWLY HLQKROHQ ZDV GHQ *HGDQNHQ HLQHU VHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJNRQWHUNDULHUW8PÄGLH)UDJH³]XEHDQWZRUWHQÄREGLHIUGLH 0DQLIHVWDWLRQLKUHUVHOEVWEHDQVSUXFKWH'LIIHUHQ]DXVGHU6WUXNWXUGHUDEVROXWHQ :LUNOLFKNHLWVHOEVWHUNOlUWZHUGHQNDQQ³PXVVGLHVHGHVKDOEÄLQLKUHU6LFKDXV OHJXQJDOVDEVROXWHV9HUKlOWQLVH[SOL]LHUW³ZHUGHQ:DJQHUV)ROJHUXQJPDU NLHUWGHQhEHUJDQJ]XUUHODWLRQDOHQ)DVVXQJGHU:LUNOLFKNHLWVNDWHJRULHLQGHUHQ 5DKPHQVLHDOV6XEVWDQWLDOLWlWV.DXVDOLWlWVXQG:HFKVHOZLUNXQJVEH]LHKXQJ WKHPDWLVLHUWZLUG0LWGHU(LQVLFKWLQGLHXQHQWULQQEDUH%H]LHKXQJVKDIWLJNHLWGHV $EVROXWHQJHKWWKHRORJLVFKJHVSURFKHQGLH.RQVHTXHQ]HLQKHUGDVV*RWWQLFKW RKQHGLH:HOWE]ZGHQ0HQVFKHQ]XGHQNHQLVW 9RQGHU$V\PPHWULH]XU6\PPHWULH±GLH5HODWLRQDOLWlWGHU:LUNOLFKNHLW $QGLHVHU6WHOOHNRPPWHLQ]ZHLWHU(LQZDQGJHJHQGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWDOVGHU Ä$OOHV EHVWLPPHQGHQ :LUNOLFKNHLW³ ]XP 7UDJHQ :LH GDV GDULQ DQYLVLHUWH ÄÃ>$@OOHVµLPPHUDXFKNRQ]LSLHUWZHUGHQPDJ>«@VLFKHULVW³DXV:DJQHUV6LFKW ZHQLJVWHQVHLQHV ÄGDÃDOOHVµLP+LQEOLFNDXI*RWW>«@DOVGDV0RPHQWGHV SDVVLY%HVWLPPWHQIXQJLHUW³'LH%H]LHKXQJ]ZLVFKHQ*RWWXQG0HQVFK:HOW ZLUGVRLP6LQQHHLQHV0DFKW2KQPDFKW9HUKlOWQLVVHVEHJULIIHQ'DEHLVWHKW :DJQHUÄGLHZHVHQVORJLVFKH*UXQGNRQVWHOODWLRQHLQHU$V\PPHWULHYRQ6HLQXQG 6FKHLQ³YRU$XJHQÄLQGHUGHU6FKHLQDOV0DQLIHVWDWLRQVIROLHGHV6HLQV]XGHV VHQ1HJDWLYHPKHUDEJHVWXIWZLUG³ZDVHUPLW+HJHODOVHLQHLQVWDELOH%H]LH KXQJVZHLVHDXVZHLVW (LQHVROFKDV\PPHWULVFKH5HODWLRQ]ZLVFKHQHLQHUDNWLYEHVWLPPHQGHQXQG HLQHUSDVVLYEHVWLPPWHQ*U|HNDQQQlPOLFKQLFKWGHU:HLVKHLWOHW]WHU6FKOXVV VHLQ9LHOPHKUGUlQJWGDVQXUYHUPHLQWOLFKDEVROXWHHLQVHLWLJH0DFKWYHUKlOWQLV DXIHLQHV\PPHWULVFKH*OHLFKJOWLJNHLWVHLQHU5HODWHKLQZHLOGLHVHUHFKWYHU VWDQGHQQXUYHUPLWWHOVGHVMHZHLOVDQGHUHQVLHVHOEVWVHLQN|QQHQ'DULQYHU VFKDIIWVLFKODXW:DJQHUVFKOLHOLFKGLHZLHQRFKGHXWOLFKZHUGHQZLUGXQEHU ELHWEDUH /RJLN GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ LKUH VFKOHFKWKLQQLJH *HOWXQJ 6HLQ YRQ GHU
:$*1(5T :$*1(5Q +HUYRUKHEXQJY.7 :$*1(5 I 9JO]XPIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWW :$*1(5Q ±± M± 9JOGD]X +(*(/ ± :$*1(5Q ',(5.(1
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
$V\PPHWULHGHU0DFKW]XU6\PPHWULHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJIKUHQGHU*HGDQNHQ JDQJDEHUVHW]W]XQlFKVWEHLP6XEVWDQWLDOLWlWVYHUKlOWQLVHLQ 'LHGDPLWDXIJHUXIHQH5HODWLRQYRQ6XEVWDQ]XQG$N]LGHQ]PDUNLHUWJHZLV VHUPDHQGHQ)DOOJU|WP|JOLFKHU8QJOHLFKKHLW6RLVWGHU8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQ EHLGHQ6HLWHQÄEORHLQ8QWHUVFKLHGGHV$XVOHJHQVXQG6FKHLQHQV³ 'DVVGLH SHUGHILQLWLRQHPDEVROXWVHOEVWPlFKWLJH6XEVWDQ]VLFK]XP(UZHLVLKUHU6XEV WDQWLDOLWlWDOVHLQHVROFKHYRUDXVVHW]HQPXVVDOVRGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ%HVWLPPHQ XQG%HVWLPPWKHLW]XPDFKHQJHQ|WLJWLVWEHUKUWVLHGHPQDFKQLFKWZHVHQWOLFK 9LHOPHKUKDWGLHSDUWLHOOH2KQPDFKWLQGLHVLHGDGXUFKYHUIlOOWQXUDN]LGHQWLHO OHQ&KDUDNWHUGKGLH6XEVWDQ]EOHLEWGDULQEHKDUUOLFKZDVVLHLPPHUVFKRQLVW 0LWKLQKDEHQÄLKUH([WUHPH³±GLHVXEVWDQWLHOOH0DFKWVLFK]XEHVWLPPHQXQG GLHDN]LGHQWLHOOH2KQPDFKWEHVWLPPW]XVHLQ±ZLH+HJHOVFKUHLEWÄNHLQHLJHQ WPOLFKHV%HVWHKHQ³6LHIXQJLHUHQDXVVFKOLHOLFKDOV'XUFKJDQJVPRPHQWHGHV VHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGHU6XEVWDQ]9RQVROFKHU6WHULOLWlWJHJHQEHUMHG ZHGHU9HUlQGHUXQJVLHKW:DJQHUHWZDDXFK-QJHOVXQEHJUQGHWHV)HVWKDOWHQ DQ HLQHU DOOH ([WUHPH LPPHU VFKRQ EHUZLQGHQGHQ /HEHQGLJNHLW *RWWHV EH VWLPPW:DVKLHUÄ>N@DWHJRULDO>«@DOV6XEVWDQ]JHIDW³ZLUGLVWIU:DJQHU WKHRORJLVFKJHZHQGHWVRDXFKQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVGHU*HGDQNHHLQHUDOOHVEH VWLPPHQGHQÄ$OOPDFKW*RWWHV³'RFKHEHQVRZLHQDFKVFK|SIXQJVWKHRORJL VFKHU7UDGLWLRQÄ*RWWQLFKWEORDOV6HOEVWPDFKW 6XEVWDQ] VRQGHUQDOVXUVlFK OLFKH0DFKWE]ZDOV8UVDFKHEHUKDXSWJHGDFKWZLUG³PXVVDXFKDXINDWHJR ULDOHU(EHQH]XP9HUKlOWQLVGHU.DXVDOLWlWIRUWJHVFKULWWHQZHUGHQ 'LHVHUhEHUJDQJ]XP.DXVDOLWlWVYHUKlOWQLVHUJLEWVLFKDXVGHP8PVWDQG GDVV GLH 6XEVWDQ] LP PDFKWYROOHQ %HKDUUHQ DXI VLFK GDV ]XPLQGHVW SDUWLHOOH $QGHUVVHLQLKUHUYRQ2KQPDFKWJHSUlJWHQ$N]LGHQ]HQQHJLHUW'DGXUFKDEHU ZHUGHQOHW]WHUHDOVDXVLKUHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJKHUYRUJHKHQGH:LUNXQJHQEH VWLPPWGHQHQJHJHQEHUVLH]XU8UVDFKHZLUG'HPLP6XEVWDQ]$N]LGHQ] 9HUKlOWQLV LPSOL]LHUWHQ 8UVDFKH:LUNXQJV9HUKlOWQLV NRPPW GDEHL ]XQlFKVW HLQHUHLQVHOEVWUHIHUHQWLHOOH(LJHQDUW]X 'LH8UVDFKHEHZLUNWQXUZDVVLHOlQJVW VFKRQLVW'DPLWZLUGLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVGLH*UXQGWKHVHHLQHV ÄNRQVHTXHQWHQ3DQWKHLVPXV³HUUHLFKWGHU*RWWDOVFDXVDVXLPLWGHU:HOWLGHQ WLIL]LHUWXQGLKUNHLQHUOHL6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW]XELOOLJW'RFKVROFKHV(LQKHLWVGHQNHQ LPPXQLVLHUWVLFKJHJHQGLHLP9HUKlOWQLVYRQ8UVDFKHXQG:LUNXQJ]XJOHLFK REZDOWHQGHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQ6ROOHQ]ZDUEHLGH5HODWHQXUIRUPDOH%HVWLPPWKHLWV ZHLVHQHLQHVXQGGHVVHOEHQ,QKDOWHVVHLQ±GHUDEVROXWVHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ6XEVWDQ] ±VRYHUOHLKHQVLHGLHVHPDEHU]XJOHLFKDXI]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQGH:HLVH$XV
:$*1(5Q +(*(/ 9JO:$*1(5JZRHVKHLW-QJHOGHQNHÄGHQ7RG*RWWHVQDFKGHP6FKHPD :HVHQ±(UVFKHLQXQJ³ :$*1(5W $D2 :$*1(5Q
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GUXFN(LQH8UVDFKHLVWHEHQVRQRWZHQGLJDNWLYH8UVDFKHYRQHWZDVZLHHLQH :LUNXQJVWHWVSDVVLYH:LUNXQJYRQHWZDVLVW:HUDEHUVDJWGLH8UVDFKHGHU DEVROXWHQ6XEVWDQ]VHLLKUHHLJHQH:LUNXQJJHODQJWLQHLQHQLQILQLWHQSURJUHVV E]ZUHJUHVVKLQHLQGHULPPHUZLHGHU:LUNXQJHQDXI8UVDFKHQXQG8UVDFKHQ DXI:LUNXQJHQ]XUFNIKUW .DQQGLH%H]LHKXQJEHLGHU5HODWHDOVRQLFKWHLQVHLWLJDXIJHKREHQZHUGHQLVW VLHÄDOV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ:LUNXQJXQG*HJHQZLUNXQJ³]ZHLHUUHODWLYHLJHQVWlQGL JHU*U|HQ]XH[SOL]LHUHQ Ä'LHDNWLYHVHW]WVLFKGLHSDVVLYH6XEVWDQ]YRUDXV XQGGHUSDVVLYHQZLUGGLHDNWLYH6XEVWDQ]YRUDXVJHVHW]W³ZDVVFKOLHOLFK]XU $XIKHEXQJGHVÄ8QWHUVFKLHG>V@]ZLVFKHQ$NWLYLWlWXQG3DVVLYLWlW³IKUW'HQQ ]ZDUVHW]WVLFKGLHDOV8UVDFKHZLUNHQGHDNWLYH6XEVWDQ]GLHSDVVLYH6XEVWDQ] QXUIULKUYHUXUVDFKHQGHV7XQYRUDXV'LHV*HVHW]WZHUGHQDEHUOlVVW]XJOHLFK GLHSDVVLYH6XEVWDQ]VHLQZDVLKUHU'HILQLWLRQHQWVSULFKW JHVHW]WXQGQLFKWVLFK VHOEVWVHW]HQG]XVHLQ6RJHVHKHQLVWZLH:DJQHUPLW+HJHOVFKUHLEWÄ>Z@DVVLH DOVHLQ)UHPGHVHUKlOWQlPOLFKDOV*HVHW]WVHLQEHVWLPPW]XZHUGHQ>«@LKUH HLJHQH %HVWLPPXQJ³ XQG NHLQH EORH )UHPGEHVWLPPXQJ 6LH GLH SDVVLYH 6XEVWDQ]NRPPWJHUDGHGDULQEHVWLPPW]XZHUGHQ]XVLFKVHOEVWZRGXUFKLKU HLQH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW]XZlFKVWGLHVLFKSRWHQ]LHOOJHJHQGLHDNWLYH6XEVWDQ] ULFKWHW/HW]WHUHQlPOLFKPXVVGLH%HVWLPPEDUNHLWGHUHUVWHUHQIULKU7XQEH UHLWVYRUDXVVHW]HQZDVP|JOLFKH*HJHQZLUNXQJHQLPSOL]LHUW 1LFKWRKQH*UXQGUHNXUULHUW:DJQHUDXVGUFNOLFKDXI+HJHOVLQGLHVHP=X VDPPHQKDQJYRUJHQRPPHQH5HIOH[LRQHQ]XU6WUXNWXUYRQ0DFKWE]Z*H ZDOWYHUKlOWQLVVHQ 'HUHQ DSRUHWLVFKH 9HUIDVVWKHLW EHWULIIW LQ VHLQHQ $XJHQ XQPLWWHOEDUGHQWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ*HGDQNHQHLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$OOPDFKW6LH]HLJW VLFKGDULQGDVVMHGZHGHVÄ*HZDOWYHUKlOWQLVHLQHUVHLWVDXIGHU8QJOHLFKKHLWXQG $V\PPHWULH]ZLVFKHQ$NWLYLWlWXQG3DVVLYLWlW0DFKWXQG2KQPDFKW³ EHUXKW DQGHUHUVHLWVDEHUGLHVH$V\PPHWULHHLQHLQQHUH3DUDGR[LHDXIZHLVW6RÄNDQQ >«@GLH*HZDOWGHUDNWLYHQ6XEVWDQ]VLFKQXUGDGXUFKPDQLIHVWLHUHQGDVLH VLFKQLFKWHLQHEORH3DVVLYLWlWVRQGHUQZHVHQWOLFKHLQHSDVVLYH6XEVWDQ]YRU DXVVHW]WGLHSRWHQWLHOOVHOEVWlQGLJXQGVHOEVWPlFKWLJLVW³$QDORJGD]XEHGDUI *RWWHLQHV$QGHUHQ±GHU:HOWGHV0HQVFKHQ±XPVHLQHXQEHGLQJWH0DFKW]X UHDOLVLHUHQGDVGDPLWDEHUDOVHLQ]XEHKHUUVFKHQGHV$QGHUHVEHVWLPPEDUVHLQ PXVV$XVGLHVHUXQHLQKROEDUHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJÄHQWVWHKWLKU>VFGHU*HZDOW@ ]XJOHLFKGLH*HJHQJHZDOW³:DJQHU]XIROJHVSUHFKHQGLHELEOLVFKHQ6FKULIWHQ GLHVEH]JOLFK%lQGH =ZDUVWHKWGRUWDXHU)UDJHGDVVÄGDVJ|WWOLFKH6XEMHNW >«@EHUHLQHQLFKWEHJUHQ]EDUH0DFKWIOOH³YHUIJWGRFKILQGHWGLHVHLPPHU
$D2 $D2 +(*(/ 9JO:$*1(5M 9JO+(*(/ I :$*1(5M (EG (EG
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
ZLHGHU GDULQ LKUH *UHQ]H GDVV GLH 0HQVFKHQ ÄGDXHUKDIW GDPLW EHVFKlIWLJW >VLQG@ GHQ $XIVWDQG JHJHQ *RWW ]X SUREHQ³ ± ZDV ZLHGHUXP HQWVSUHFKHQGH 5HDNWLRQHQQDFKVLFK]LHKW(LQHHLQVHLWLJH$XIKHEXQJGLHVHV'LIIHUHQ]YHU KlOWQLVVHVHWZDGXUFKGLHJ|WWOLFKH9HUQLFKWXQJGHU0HQVFKKHLWPDFKWHGHQ *HGDQNHQHLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$OOPDFKW±LPZDKUVWHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHV±JHJHQ VWDQGVORV,QHLQHORJLVFKNRQVLVWHQWH5HODWLRQODVVHQVLFKEHLGH6HLWHQYLHOPHKU QXUGDGXUFKEULQJHQGDVVVLHLKUHU%HGLQJWKHLWGXUFKGLHMHZHLOVDQGHUHLQQH ZHUGHQ'DVDEHUEHGHXWHWHGLH$XIKHEXQJGHURKQHKLQKDOWORVHQ8QWHUVFKHL GXQJ]ZLVFKHQ0DFKWXQG2KQPDFKW$NWLYLWlWXQG3DVVLYLWlWHWF (VIROJWGDUDXVGHUhEHUVFKULWW]XP9HUKlOWQLVGHU:HFKVHOZLUNXQJ)UGLH VHVJLOWSULQ]LSLHOO Ä-HGH6HLWHLVWGXUFKGLHDQGHUHEHGLQJW³XQGEHLGHVLQGÄPLW GHP9HUKlOWQLVLQGHPVLHVWHKHQLGHQWLVFK³ZHLOVLHVLFK]XJOHLFKDOVLKU MHZHLOV$QGHUHVGDUVWHOOHQ'LH0DFKWEHGDUIGHU2KQPDFKWXQGLVWGDULQVHOEVW RKQPlFKWLJZlKUHQGGLH2KQPDFKWVRLKUHUVHLWV0DFKWEHUGLHQXUYHUPHLQWOL FKH0DFKWHUODQJWQXUXPVLFKGLHVHVHOEVWZLHGHUDOV2KQPDFKWYRUDXV]XVHW]HQ HWF6RDEHULVWGHUHLQHDV\PPHWULVFKH5HODWLRQEH]HLFKQHQGHÄ8QWHUVFKLHG³ ]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ6HLWHQÄ]XU,QGLIIHUHQ]JHZRUGHQ³GHVVHQVRHUUHLFKWH$XIKH EXQJGDPLWGHQÄ8QWHUJDQJGHVVHQ³EHGHXWHWZRIUHUÄYRUDXVJHVHW]WZLUG³ GHQ8QWHUJDQJGHUDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGHQ:LUNOLFKNHLW'LHJ|WWOLFKHÄ6HOEVWPDFKW XQG6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJÃVFKHLWHUWµ³GHPQDFK ÄDQGHUHLJHQHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJ HLQH'LIIHUHQ]PDFKHQ]XPVVHQ³GLHQXU]XLKUHQ8QJXQVWHQHLQJHKROWZHU GHQNDQQ'DVDV\PPHWULVFKH0DFKWJHIlOOHGHVVHQVLHXPLKUHU6HOEVWGDUVWHO OXQJZLOOHQEHGDUINHKUWVLFKZHJHQGHUGDULQLPSOL]LHUWHQ$QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXI HLQ]XEHPlFKWLJHQGHV$QGHUHVJHJHQVLH$XVGLHVHUEHLGVHLWLJJHOWHQGHQ$E KlQJLJNHLWUHVXOWLHUWHLQ9HUKlOWQLVV\PPHWULVFKHU*OHLFKJOWLJNHLWLQGHP$N WLYLWlWLPPHUDXFK3DVVLYLWlWEHLQKDOWHWXQGXPJHNHKUW'DPLWDEHUZLUGZLH :DJQHUIHVWKlOWEHUÄGLHZHFKVHOZLUNHQGHQ:LUNOLFKHQQXUQHJDWLYDXVJHVDJW GDVLH>«@RKQH'LIIHUHQ]VLQG³*HQDXGLHVLVWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQ]XQlFKVW DXFK GLH ÄUHYROXWLRQlUH>@³ 3RLQWH GHU FKULVWOLFKHQ =HQWUDOYRUVWHOOXQJ YRP PHQVFKJHZRUGHQHQXQGJHVWRUEHQHQ*RWW Ä*RWWLVWQXU*RWWDOV0HQVFKXQGGHU 0HQVFKLVWQXU0HQVFKDOV*RWW³'RFKOlVVWVLFKGDV6FKHLWHUQGHUJ|WWOLFK DEVROXWHQ6HOEVWXQG$OOPDFKWXQGLKUH$XIKHEXQJ]XJXQVWHQHLQHUV\PPHWUL VFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVZHLVHÄDXFKDIILUPDWLYHUIDVVHQ³6LHHQWKlOWGDQQHLQHQQHXHQ *HGDQNHQEH]JOLFKGHU5HGHYRQ*RWWGLHHLQHQ$XVZHJDXVGHUHQORJLVFKHU
:$*1(5 9JOGD]X:DJQHUV YHUIDVVWH$XVIKUXQJHQXQWHUGHUhEHU VFKULIWÄ'HUJHZDOWLJH*RWW³LQ '(56W ±=ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ7H[WHEHVWHKHQGHXW OLFKH.RQWLQXLWlWHQ :$*1(5MI $D2 (EG (EG :$*1(5M :$*1(5M
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
,QNRQVLVWHQ]ELHWHW*HQDXDQGLHVHU6WHOOHDEHULVWMHQHUVWDUNH%UXFKLQ:DJ QHUV'HQNHQ]XYHU]HLFKQHQYRQGHPHLQOHLWHQGGLH5HGHZDU $XVZHJHDXVGHP6FKHLWHUQ*RWWHV Ä'DV6FKHLWHUQGHV*HGDQNHQV>«@GHVVXEVWDQWLHOOHQ6HOEVWXQG$OOPDFKWVJRW WHV³VRKHLWHVLQHLQHPVSlWHQ7H[W:DJQHUVVHW]WÄHLQHQQHXHQ*HGDQNHQ ]XP%HJUHLIHQGHVZHOWKDIWPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJV³DXVVLFK KHUDXV Ä'LHVHUQHXH*HGDQNH³GHQNWGLHPLWGHVVHQ6FKHLWHUQHLQKHUJHKHQGH Ä5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV³UDGLNDO]X(QGH 'HU UHYROXWLRQLHUWH *RWWHVJHGDQNH ZLUG VRQDFK GXUFK HLQH GHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ 6HOEVW XQG :HOWXPJDQJ EHVWLPPHQGH /RJLN GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ DEJHO|VW GLH VLFK GHP .ULWHULXP GHU V\PPHWULVFKHQ.RUUHVSRQGHQ]YRQVHOEVWlQGLJHP6HOEVWVHLQXQGVHOEVWlQGLJHP$QGHUVVHLQ YHUSIOLFKWHWZHL
'DVVDXVÄGHP6FKHLWHUQGHV6XEVWDQ]JRWWHV>«@GHUQHXH*HGDQNHGHU$QHU NHQQXQJVORJLNUHVXOWLHUW³JLEWXQWHUZLHQRFK]X]HLJHQLVWYHUlQGHUWHQ9RU ]HLFKHQZLHGHUZDVDXFKGHUIUKH:DJQHUVFKRQYHUWUHWHQKDW'RFKLVWLKP GHUÃWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKH$XVZHJµDXVGHPÃ6FKHLWHUQ*RWWHVµGHQHULQVHLQHU )UK]HLWDQ+HJHOV%HJULIIVORJLNDQNQSIHQGEHVFKULWWHQKDW VSlWHUQLFKW PHKUSODXVLEHOHUVFKLHQHQZDV]XU5DGLNDOLVLHUXQJVHLQHV3URJUDPPVJHIKUW KDW %HLGHÃ$XVZHJHµZHUGHQQXQQDFKHLQDQGHUGDUJHVWHOOW 5HWKHRORJLVLHUXQJ±GHUWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKH$XVZHJ :RULQEHVWHKWDOVRGLHSRVLWLYH.RQVHTXHQ]MHQHVLQGLIIHUHQWHQ:HFKVHOZLU NXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHVLQGDV YHUPHLQWOLFKDOOHV EHVWLPPHQGH$NWLYLWlWXQGEH VWLPPWH3DVVLYLWlWJHUDWHQVLQG"6LHVFKOlJWVLFKGDULQQLHGHUGDVVGDGXUFK HEHQQLFKWQXU±QHJDWLY±GLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ6HLWHQDXIJHKREHQLVW 9LHOPHKUJLEWGDV:HFKVHOZLUNXQJVYHUKlOWQLV]XJOHLFKDQZLHGLHVHHLQ]LJ]X VLFKVHOEVWJHODQJHQ5HFKWYHUVWDQGHQUHDOLVLHUHQVLHGXUFKLKUUH]LSURNHVhEHU JHKHQLQV*HJHQWHLOQXU±XQGGDUDXINRPPWHV:DJQHUDQ±ÄZDVVLHLKUHP
:$*1(5 D9JO]XGHQ]ZHL$XVZHJHQDXVGHP6FKHLWHUQ*RWWHVGLH,QWHUSUH WDWLRQ0LFKDHO0XUUPDQQ.DKOVGHP]XIROJHÄGHUYRP0QFKHQHU:DJQHUNRQ]LSLHUWH:HJ YRP(QGHGHU:HVHQVLQGLH%HJULIIVORJLNGDVKHLWGLH$XIKHEXQJGHUDEVROXWHQ:LUNOLFK NHLWXQGGHU:HFKVHOZLUNXQJGHU6XEVWDQ]HQLQGLH6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$Q GHUVVHLQVGHILQLWLYDEJHVFKQLWWHQLVW9LHOPHKUZLUGDXVGHUEOHLEHQGHQ$QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXI GLHlXHUH PHQVFKOLFKH 5HIOH[LRQGHV$EVROXWHQGLH6FKOXVVIROJHUXQJJH]RJHQGDVVVLFK ÃGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQJ|WWOLFKHP6HOEVWVHLQXQGZHOWKDIWPHQVFKOLFKHP$QGHUVVHLQQXUDOVHLQ V\PPHWULVFKHV9HUKlOWQLVHJDOLWlUJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWHU5HODWHµIDVVHQOlVVW>«@'DPLWZLUGDEHU GDV(UJHEQLVGHU:HVHQVORJLN+HJHOVDOVXQDXIKHEEDUHU6FKOXVVSXQNWGHUORJLVFKHQ(QWZLFN OXQJLPJHUDGHQ*HJHQVDW]]X+HJHOVHOEVWIHVWJHVFKULHEHQ³ 08550$11.$+/I :$*1(5 D (EG 9JO]XPIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWW :$*1(5MI QI
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
%HJULIIQDFKVLQG³±HWZDHLQHPDFKWYROOH6XEVWDQ]GLHDEHU]XU0DQLIHVWDWLRQ LKUHU0DFKWHLQHVRKQPlFKWLJHQ$QGHUHQEHGDUIHWF6RJHVHKHQDEHUJLOW Ä'D MHGH%HVWLPPXQJGDV*HJHQWHLOLKUHUVHOEVWZLUGEOHLEWMHGH]XJOHLFKLQLKUHP DXIJHKREHQHQ *HJHQWHLO PLW VLFK LGHQWLVFK³ %HLGH YROO]LHKHQ VLH GDGXUFK QlPOLFKZDVVLHMHZHLOVVHOEVWLP*UXQGHVLQG GDV$QGHUHLKUHUVHOEVW,KUH 'LIIHUHQ]KHEWVLFKPLWGLHVHU(LQVLFKWDXILQHLQHLKUVHOEVWlQGLJHV(LJHQVHLQ EHUHLWVIXQGLHUHQGH(LQKHLW PLWGHUIU:DJQHUGLH ZDKUKDIW ÄDEVROXWH(LQ KHLW³HUUHLFKWLVW Ä6LFKVHOEVWH[SOL]LHUHQDQGHU6WHOOHGHVDQGHUHQ³Ä%HLVLFKVHOEVWVHLQLP$Q GHUVVHLQRGHU6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQLPDQGHUHQ³ODXWHQ:DJQHUV6WUXNWXUIRUPHOQIU GLHVH ZHFKVHOVHLWLJV\PPHWULVFKH %H]LHKXQJVZHLVH 6LH PDUNLHUW LQ VHLQHQ $XJHQGLHÄ/RJL]LWlW>«@YRQ)UHLKHLW³±HLQHU)UHLKHLWLQGHUÄGLH$OWHUQDWLYH YRQ6HOEVWXQG)UHPGEHVWLPPXQJDXIJHKREHQ³LVW*HQDXHUJHVDJW (LQHU )UHLKHLWGLHVLFKDXIJUXQGYRQXQGYHUPLWWHOWGXUFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ UHDOLVLHUW*HQDXXPVLHJHKWHVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQZHQQ+HJHOGHQhEHUJDQJYRQ GHU:HVHQV]XU%HJULIIVORJLNPLWGHP6DW]HLQOlXWHW Ä'LHVLVWGHU%HJULIIGDV 5HLFKGHU6XEMHNWLYLWlWRGHUGHU)UHLKHLW³,QV5HLFKVXEMHNWLYHU)UHLKHLWWULWW JOHLFKVDPQXUHLQZHUQLFKWGHP,UUWXPHLQHUQXUVFKHLQEDUHQGLHLKQHLJHQWOLFK UHODWLYLHUHQGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQDXVEOHQGHQGHQ$EVROXWKHLWHUOLHJWÄ>'@LHWKHR ORJLVFKH,QWHQWLRQ*RWWDOVGLH:LUNOLFKNHLW]XGHQNHQGXUFKGLHDOOHVEHVWLPPW ZLUG³VRODXWHW:DJQHUVHQWVSUHFKHQGH.RQVHTXHQ] NDQQQXUGDQQLQJHGDQNOLFKNDWHJRULDOHU+LQVLFKWDQJHPHVVHQVWUXNWXULHUW ZHUGHQZHQQGLHVLFKLP9HUKlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQ$NWLYLWlWXQG3DVVLYLWlW%HVWLP PHQXQG%HVWLPPWZHUGHQ6LFKVHW]HQXQG6LFKYRUDXVVHW]HQDXVOHJHQGHDEVROX WH:LUNOLFKNHLWLQGLH:LUNOLFKNHLWDOV%HJULIIGHU6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQLPDQGHUHQ EHUIKUWZLUG $QLKUH6WHOOHWULWWGHVKDOEGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWDOVÄ0DFKWGHU/LHEHXQG)UHL KHLW³GLHGDULQ]XU(UIOOXQJJHODQJWÄGD*RWWVLFKDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$QGHUV VHLQVH[SOL]LHUW³)U*RWWZLUGVRHLQ)UHLKHLWVYROO]XJUHNODPLHUWGHUHEHQMH QHU /RJLN GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ IROJHQG GLH $EKlQJLJNHLW YRP $QGHUHQ ± :HOW0HQVFK±LQVLFKEHJUHLIWXQGGLHVHPVRHEHQIDOOV)UHLKHLWHLQUlXPW'LH VHUDXVGHU(LJHQORJLNGHV$EVROXWHQVHOEVWUHVXOWLHUHQGH0DFKWYHUOXVWLVWIU :DJQHUÄDOV$QIDQJGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ7KHRORJLH]XEHJUHLIHQ³DOVÄGLHLQGHQ
:$*1(5Q $D2 (EG (EG,P2ULJLQDOWHLOVNXUVLY (EG +(*(/ :$*1(5Q (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
9RUVWHOOXQJHQYRQ0HQVFKZHUGXQJ7RGXQG$XIHUVWHKXQJHUIROJHQGH.RQVWLWX WLRQ*RWWHVDOV*HLVW³ (VVSULFKWVLFKLQGHQEHVDJWHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQGHPQDFKQLFKWQXUHLQH9HU JOHLFKJOWLJXQJ*RWWHVXQGGHV0HQVFKHQDXV9LHOPHKUNRPPHQEHLGHGDULQ DXIGHQLKQHQHLQ]LJHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ%HJULIIÄ*RWWLVWQXU*RWWDOV0HQVFKXQG GHU0HQVFKLVWQXU0HQVFKDOV*RWW³±GLHEHUHLWV]LWLHUWH)RUPHOGUFNWPLW LKUHP]ZHLIDFKHPÃQXUµGLHVHQ$XVVFKOLHOLFKNHLWVDQVSUXFKDXV:DJQHUVSULFKW GHPJHPlYRQGHUÄ6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$QGHUVVHLQV³DOVGHU ÄÃDEVROXWHQ 'LPHQVLRQµ³ GLH GLH XQEHGLQJWH %HGLQJXQJ DOOHU VXEMHNWLY VHOEVWlQGLJHQ)UHLKHLWVDXVEXQJGDUVWHOOW*RWWLVWLKUHEHQVRXQWHUZRUIHQZLH GHU0HQVFKGHVVHQ6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJVLFKDP$QVSUXFKGHUDEVROXWHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVORJLN]X PHVVHQKDW'RFKGLHVH ÄSULQ]LSLHOOH%HGHXWXQJ³GHV %HLVLFKVHOEVWHLQVLP$QGHUHQUHVXOWLHUWGDUDXVGDVVVLHÄQLFKWDQHLQHPEHOLHEL JHQ6DFKYHUKDOW³VRQGHUQÄDXIXQEHGLQJWH:HLVH³XQGÄDEVWUDKLHUWYRQDOOHQ P|JOLFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHU:HOWHUIDKUXQJ³QlPOLFKLQ*RWWVHOEVW%HJUQGXQJ ILQGHW%HL:DJQHULVWGHPJHPlYRPÄQRUPDWLYDSULRULVFKH>Q@%HJUQGXQJV ]XVDPPHQKDQJGHU7ULQLWlWXQG&KULVWRORJLH³GLH5HGHGHUDOV.RUUHNWLY]XU ÄGHIL]LHQWHQ)DNWL]LWlW³LUGLVFKHU9HUKlOWQLVVHVWHWVÄDQVLFKVHOEVW]XHUIDVVHQ>@³ VHL =ZDU GUlQJHQ ÄÃ>D@EVWUDNWHµ *RWWHVOHKUH XQG &KULVWRORJLH >«@ DXI GLH 0DQLIHVWDWLRQ*RWWHVDOV*HLVW³DOVGHUHUÄLQDOOHQ%HUHLFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ =XVDPPHQOHEHQV³SUlVHQWLVW$EHUGLHVHSQHXPDWRORJLVFKH=LHOVWHOOXQJGHU ]XIROJHGHUJ|WWOLFKH*HLVWGLHQRUPDWLYH+LQWHUJUXQGVWUXNWXUVR]LDOHU9HUKlOW QLVVHUHSUlVHQWLHUWEHGDUILQ:DJQHUV$XJHQHLQHVREMHNWLYHQ5FNKDOWHVLQ Ã*RWW VHOEVWµ 'DPLW ZLOO HU NHLQHVIDOOV HLQHU 5HSULVWLQDWLRQ YRUQHX]HLWOLFKHU 6XEVWDQ]PHWDSK\VLNGDV:RUWUHGHQ 'DVVGHUÄ*HGDQNH>@*RWW>«@QXU>LVW@ LQVRIHUQHUJHGDFKWZLUG³VWHOOWIULKQYLHOPHKUÄGLHXQDXIKHEEDUH'HQNDUWGHU 0RGHUQH³GDU$EHUHVVWHOOWVLFKGHQQRFKGLH±LP(LQOHLWXQJVWHLODXIJHZRUIH QH±)UDJHRE:DJQHUV3UlPLVVHGHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQLQHLQHÄhEHUHLQVWLP
:$*1(5M :$*1(5M :$*1(5M $D2 $D2 9JOGD]XGLH9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQHPÄQHJDWLYHQ%HJUQ GXQJVJDQJ³LQ:DJQHUV%HJUQGXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVGHUGXUFKGLH9RUVWHOOXQJVNRPSOH [HYRQÄ0HQVFKZHUGXQJ7RGXQG$XIHUVWHKXQJ³IKUWXQGGHQÄÃ(UNHQQWQLVJUXQGµIUGDV QHXHFKULVWOLFKH*RWWHVYHUVWlQGQLV³ELOGHXQGHLQHPÄSRVLWLYHQ%HJUQGXQJVJDQJ³GHUEHU 7ULQLWlWVOHKUHXQG&KULVWRORJLHIKUHXQGÄGLH)UDJHQDFKGHPÃ6HLQVRGHU(UP|JOLFKXQJV JUXQGµGHV,QNDUQDWLRQVJHVFKHKHQV³EHDQWZRUWH 6&+1855(1%(5*(5 YJOIU HLQH DXVIKUOLFKH 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ YRQ 7ULQLWlWVOHKUH XQG &KULVWRORJLH DD2 II 'LH 3QHXPDWRORJLHZLUGYRQ6FKQXUUHQEHUJHUDEHUDQGLHVHU6WHOOHHLJHQWPOLFKHU:HLVHQLFKW GLUHNWHQWIDOWHW :$*1(5M I $D2
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
PXQJPLWVLFKVHOEVW³EULQJHQ]XN|QQHQVRGDVVHUVFKOLHOLFKGRFKDOVDXV VLFKVHOEVWVHLHQG JHGDFKW]XZHUGHQYHUPDJGHUHLQJHIRUGHUWHQ5DGLNDOLWlW GHVORJLVFK]XYHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQGHQ*RWWHVWRGHVJHUHFKWZLUG'LHWULQLWlWVWKHR ORJLVFKHQ D FKULVWRORJLVFKHQ E XQGSQHXPDWRORJLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVJlQJH F PLWGHQHQGHUIUKH:DJQHUGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNGHU6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQ LP$QGHUHQLQLKUHUDEVROXWHQ*HOWXQJ]XEHJUQGHQYHUVXFKWVSUHFKHQMHGHQ IDOOVHLQHDQGHUH6SUDFKH D *RWWDOV7ULQLWlW±YRP$OOJHPHLQHQ]XP%HVRQGHUHQXQG]XUFN Ä'HUGUHLHLQLJH*RWW³VRZHL:DJQHUQlPOLFK]XVDJHQÄO|VWGLHDEVROXWHXQG DEVWUDNWH$OOPDFKWGXUFKGLH0DFKWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDEGLHGLH0DFKWGHU /LHEHXQG)UHLKHLWLVW³:LUG*RWWWULQLWDULVFKJHGDFKWNRPPWDOVRDQLKP VHOEVWGDV5HVXOWDWVHLQHV6FKHLWHUQVDOVXQPLWWHOEDUVHOEVWPlFKWLJH,QVWDQ]]XP 7UDJHQ0LWKLQVWHOOWÄ>G@LH7ULQLWlW*RWWHV³IU:DJQHUÄGLH7KHRULHGHU6HOEVW H[SOLNDWLRQ XQG 6XEMHNWLYLWlW EHUKDXSW GK GHU DOOJHPHLQHQ 6XEMHNWLYLWlW GDU³6XEMHNWLYLWlWOlVVWVLFKGHPQDFKSULQ]LSLHOOQXUDXVVLFKVHOEVWHUNOlUHQ RKQHDEHUGHVKDOEPLWEORHU6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLWYHUZHFKVHOWZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQ 6RHUIDVVWVLFK*RWWDXVWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWVHOEVWLQGHPHUVLFKYRQVLFK VHOEVWXQWHUVFKHLGHW8QWHU5HNXUVDXI+HJHOVEHJULIIVE]ZVXEMHNWLYLWlWVORJL VFKHQ'UHLNODQJÃ$OOJHPHLQKHLW±%HVRQGHUKHLW±(LQ]HOKHLWµEULQJW:DJQHUGLHV DQGHU%H]LHKXQJYRQ9DWHU6RKQXQG*HLVWDXIGHQ3XQNW
$D2 'HUGDULQDXIVFKHLQHQGHÄGHQNRGHULGHHQRQWRORJLVFKH=XJ:DJQHUVHQWKlOW³ZLH-|UJ 'LHUNHQIHVWKlOWÄ&UDPHUVFKHV(UEHLQVRIHUQ&UDPHUEHPKWZDU*RWWDOV*RWWLP'HQNYROO ]XJDXVLKPVHOEVWKHUDXVLQGHU*HQHWLVLHUXQJYRQ%HVWLPPWKHLWEHUKDXSWJHJHQEHU8QEH VWLPPWKHLW]XH[SOL]LHUHQ³ ',(5.(1 'DVV:DJQHUDXVGHQ%DKQHQGHV'HQNHQV VHLQHV)UDQNIXUWHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ/HKUHUV:ROIJDQJ&UDPHUVFKOLHOLFKKHUDXVJHWUHWHQLVW ]HLJWVLFKH[HPSODULVFKDQ]ZHL7H[WVWHOOHQ ,QHLQHP7H[WDXVGHP-DKUH EH]LHKWHUVLFK LQGHP6LQQH]XVWLPPHQGDXI&UDPHUDOVHUGHVVHQ$QOLHJHQDXVGUFNOLFKIROJWÄ*RWWGDV $EVROXWH>«@DEVROXW³XQGQLFKWÄLQVHLQHU5HODWLYLWlWDXI]XEHVWLPPHQGH'LQJH³ :$*1(5 T ]XGHQNHQVRQGHUQVRGDVVHVDQJHVLFKWVGHUÄ'LIIHUHQ]YRQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPHQ XQG>«@%HVWLPPWVHLQ>«@DXVVLFKVHOEVWDOVDEVROXWTXDOLIL]LHUWZHUGHQNDQQ³ DD2 YJODEHUDXFKKLHUGLH.ULWLN&UDPHUVHW]HÄGDVDEVROXWH9HUKlOWQLV³HLQIDFKDOVÄTXDVLJHJH EHQHQQLFKWZHLWHUUHGX]LHUEDUHQ$XVJDQJVSXQNW³>HEG@ 9LHU]HKQ-DKUHVSlWHUKHLWHVGDQQ DXVGUFNOLFK Ä'HU9HUVXFKGLH5HGHYRP7RG*RWWHVEHLP:RUW]XQHKPHQGUIWHPLWGHQ 0LWWHOQGHU&UDPHUVFKHQ7KHRORJLHGHV$EVROXWHQQLFKWGXUFKIKUEDUVHLQ³ ZHLOVLHÄGHU PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ$XIIDVVXQJGHV$EVROXWHQYHUKDIWHW³EOHLEH '(56D $QJHVLFKWV VROFKHUVHOEVWNULWLVFKHQ(UNHQQWQLVVHGLH:DJQHU]XIROJHDXFKGXUFK'LVNXVVLRQHQPLWGHP 6R]LRORJHQ*QWKHU'X[DQJHUHJWZXUGHQ YJO'(56 E NRPPWHV]XGHQNRQ]HSWLRQHO OHQ1HXDXIEUFKHQGHU HU-DKUHQ :$*1(5H :$*1(5M 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ DD2 ± XQG'(56Q±
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
'HU9DWHUVWHKWGDEHLIUGLHLP6XEMHNWLYLWlWVEHJULIILPSOL]LHUWH$OOJHPHLQ KHLWGHU6HOEVWLGHQWLWlW XQWHUDOOHQ8PVWlQGHQÄLPDQGHUHQVHLQHUVHOEVWVLFKDXI VLFKVHOEVW]XEH]LHKHQXQGLGHQWLVFKPLWVLFK]XVHLQ³'XUFKGHQ6RKQZLUG GDVGLHVHQJOHLFKEOHLEHQGHQ6HOEVWEH]XJDOWHULHUHQGH0RPHQWGHU%HVRQGHUKHLW PDUNLHUW 6R HUZHLVW VLFK GDV DOOJHPHLQH 6XEMHNW LQ VHLQHU Ä*OHLFKKHLW PLW VLFK³GDGXUFKDOVEHVWLPPWGDVVHVQLFKWXPKLQNDQQVLFKDXIVLFKVHOEVW]X EH]LHKHQ'LH8QEHOLHELJNHLWGHU6HOEVWUHIHUHQ]ÄYHUEHVRQGHUW³GDV$OOJHPHLQH QRWZHQGLJ2KQHGLHVH%HVWLPPWKHLWMHXQGMH]XYROO]LHKHQEOLHEHGHVVHQVWHWH ,GHQWLWlWPLWVLFKVHOEVWQlPOLFKHLQHEORH7DXWRORJLH:RVLHDEHUYROO]RJHQ ZLUGNRPPWHV]XU'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQDOOJHPHLQHP6LFKJOHLFK%OHLEHQXQG NRQNUHWEHVRQGHUHP6HOEVWEH]XJ'HU*HLVWVWHKWVFKOLHOLFKIUGDVGLHVH'LIIH UHQ]O|VHQGH0RPHQWGHU(LQ]HOKHLWÄ,VWGLH%HVRQGHUKHLWDOVEHVWLPPWH$OOJH PHLQKHLWGDV$QGHUHGHU$OOJHPHLQKHLWVRLVWGLH(LQ]HOKHLWDOVGDV$QGHUHGHU %HVRQGHUKHLWGDV$QGHUHGHV$QGHUHQGLHDEVROXWH1HJDWLRQGHU1HJDWLRQ³ 6LHKHEWGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ$OOJHPHLQHPXQG%HVRQGHUHPDXIZHLOPLWLKUIRO JHQGHVEHJULIIOLFKHLQJHKROWZLUG 1XUYHUPLWWHOVGHV%HVRQGHUHQGKGXUFK NRQNUHWHQ%H]XJDXIVLFKVHOEVWNDQQGDV$OOJHPHLQHVLFKDOVDOOJHPHLQGKDOV VLFKJOHLFKEOHLEHQGHUIDVVHQ(UIDVVWHVVLFKDEHUVRYHUOLHUWGDV%HVRQGHUH VHLQHQQHJDWLYHQ&KDUDNWHUXQGJHUHLFKWGHP$OOJHPHLQHQ]XU([SOLNDWLRQVHL QHUVHOEVW7ULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKOlVVWVLFKVRPLWEHJUQGHQÄGD*RWWVLFKLPPHU VFKRQ LQ GHU (LQKHLW PLW VHLQHP $QGHUVVHLQ 8QWHUVFKLHG %HVWLPPWKHLW HU IDW³2GHUZLH:DJQHUHVDXFKIRUPXOLHUHQNDQQ Ä'HUGUHLHLQLJH*RWWLVWGHU *RWWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³WHLOWGRFKÄ*RWWGHU9DWHU>«@VHLQ6HOEVWVHLQPLWGHP $QGHUVVHLQGHV6RKQHVXQGGHV*HLVWHV³1XUYHUPLWWHOVGHU%HVRQGHUKHLWGHV 6RKQHVXQGGHU(LQ]HOKHLWGHV*HLVWHVYHUPDJGHU9DWHUVFKOLHOLFKGLH$OOJH PHLQKHLWVHLQHVVXEMHNWLYHQ6HOEVWVWDQGHV]XEHZDKUHQXQG]XEHZlKUHQ E &KULVWRORJLH±GDV6HOEVWVHLQDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$QGHUVVHLQVGHQNHQ $QJHVLFKWVGHVELVODQJ$XVJHIKUWHQN|QQWHVLFKDEHUGHU(LQGUXFNDXIGUlQJHQ GHP$QGHUHQGHV$OOJHPHLQHQNlPH±ZLH)DOOHGHVZHVHQVORJLVFKHQ9HUKlOW QLVVHVYRQ6XEVWDQ]XQG$N]LGHQ]±QXUHLQHVFKHLQEDUHOHW]WOLFKWDXWRORJLVFKH $QGHUVKHLW]X8PGHU/RJLNGHU6XEMHNWLYLWlWJHUHFKW]XZHUGHQLVWGHVKDOE ZLH :DJQHU HLQVFKlUIW ÄGLH 6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQ DQ GHU 6WHOOH GHV $QGHUVVHLQV H[SOL]LWDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$QGHUVVHLQV]XHQWZLFNHOQ³*HQDXGLHVLVWLQVHLQHQ
$D2 (EG $D2 $D2 :$*1(5H :$*1(5MI9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQFKULVWRORJLVFKHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ DD2 ± XQG'(56G ±,FKYHU]LFKWHLP)ROJHQGHQDXIGLH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQYRQ
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
$XJHQGDV7KHPDGHU&KULVWRORJLHGXUFKGLHDOOHUHUVWÄGLH7ULQLWlW]XU9ROO VWUXNWXU³ZLUG+DOELHUWEOLHEHOHW]WHUHGHPQDFKZHQQVLHJHZLVVHUPDHQQXU DXVGHU6LFKWGHV$OOJHPHLQHQE]ZGHV9DWHUVNRQVWUXLHUWZUGH6RJHKWHVLQ GHU&KULVWRORJLHGDUXPÄYRQGHU%HVWLPPKHLW>%HVRQGHUKHLW6RKQ@DOVVROFKHU ]X]HLJHQGDVLHDQLKUHU6WHOOHGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQHQWVSUHFKHQ NDQQ³ 1LFKWQXUYRQGHU0HQVFKZHUGXQJ*RWWHVLVW:DJQHU]XIROJH]XKDQ GHOQVRQGHUQDQDORJDXFKYRQGHU*RWWZHUGXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ-HVXV&KULVWXV IXQJLHUWGDEHLÄDOVH[HPSODULVFKHV6XEMHNW³ )UGLHVHVJLOWGDVVQLFKWZLHLP )DOOHGHU7ULQLWlWGLH6HOEVWHUIDVVXQJGHU5DKPHQLVWLQGHPVHLQH6HOEVWXQWHU VFKHLGXQJVLFKYROO]LHKW9LHOPHKUJHVFKLHKWDQGHU6WHOOHGHV%HVRQGHUHQÄ>G@LH 6HOEVWGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ >«@ DOV 6HOEVWHUIDVVXQJ³ ,QGHP GDV H[HPSODULVFKH FKULVWRORJLVFKH6XEMHNWVLFKYRQVLFKVHOEVWLQVHLQHU%HVRQGHUKHLWXQWHUVFKHLGHW HUIDVVWHVVLFKVHOEVWLVWHVJ|WWOLFKDOOJHPHLQ'DPLWHQWVSULFKWHVDQVHLQHP2UW GHU6WUXNWXUGHU6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQLP$QGHUHQZHLOHVQLFKWJHJHQGDV$OOJH PHLQHJHJHQ*RWWDQVHLQHU%HVWLPPWKHLWIHVWKlOWVRQGHUQEHUVLHVLFKYHUDOO JHPHLQHUQGKLQDXVJHKW*HQDXGLHVH6HOEVWEHUVFKUHLWXQJYROO]LHKWVLFK±UH ]LSURN]XUJ|WWOLFKHQ6HOEVWHQWlXHUXQJ±DXIVHLWHQGHVÃEHVRQGHUHQµ0HQVFKHQ -HVXV&KULVWXVYRUVWHOOXQJVKDIWJHVDJWLP.UHX]HVWRG'DV$OOJHPHLQH*RWW EULQJWVLFKDQGHU6WHOOHGHV%HVRQGHUHQXQGGDV%HVRQGHUH0HQVFKDQGHU 6WHOOHGHV$OOJHPHLQHQ]XP$XVGUXFNÄ*RWWXQG0HQVFKVWHKHQVRLP9HUKlOW QLVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³GHQQVLHÄJHZLQQHQVLFKDOOHLQLP%HVFKUHLWHQGHV8P ZHJHVGHUVLHEHULKU*HJHQWHLOIKUW³ 'LHFKULVWRORJLVFKEHJUQGHWH*RWW 0HQVFK%H]LHKXQJGLHHLQHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJVXEMHNWLYHU)UHLKHLW EHGHXWHWEOHLEWDEHUVRODQJHDXIHLQHUDEVWUDNWHQ(EHQHEHKDIWHWZLHVLHQLFKW DXFKQRFKDQGHU6WHOOHGHV*HLVWHVHQWZLFNHOWZLUGÄ>(@UVWDXIGHP%RGHQGHV *HLVWHV³QlPOLFKVRIRUPXOLHUW:DJQHUÄJHZLQQW>«@GLHFKULVWOLFKH7KHRORJLH GLH.RQNUHWLRQIUGHQMHZHLOLJHQ:HOWXPJDQJGHV0HQVFKHQ³ F 3QHXPDWRORJLH±GLH5HDOLVLHUXQJ*RWWHVDP2UWHGHV0HQVFKHQ Ä>0@LWWHOVGHU0HWDSKHUGHU$XIHUVWHKXQJ³ZLUGGHU5HIOH[LRQVVFKULWWYRQGHU &KULVWRORJLH]XU3QHXPDWRORJLHYRUVWHOOXQJVKDIW]XP$XVGUXFNJHEUDFKW :LH :DJQHUEHWRQWPDUNLHUWVLHÄVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKQLFKWGLH:LHGHUNHKUGHVDOWHQ :DJQHUV5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHUNODVVLVFKHQbPWHUOHKUHYJOGD]X6&+1855(1%(5*(5 II :$*1(5M (EG (EG $D2 (EG $D2 :$*1(5F 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQSQHXPDWRORJLVFKHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ '(56 M ±
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
*RWWHVGHUVHOEVWEHVWLPPHQGHQ$OOPDFKW³VRQGHUQ±LQ$QOHKQXQJDQ+HJHO DXVJHGUFNW±ÄGLH1HXNRQVWLWXWLRQ*RWWHVDOV*HLVWGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ*HPHLQ GH³ (VVLQGGDPLWDOVRVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVVHLP%OLFNLQGHQHQVLFKUHDOYROO ]LHKWZDVWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKXQGFKULVWRORJLVFKDXINDWHJRULDOHU(EHQHH[SOL ]LHUWZXUGH1LFKWDQGHUVQlPOLFKLVWÄIRUPHOKDIW³DXVJHGUFNWÄ6WUXNWXUXQG ,QKDOWGHV*HLVWHV³DOVÄGLH6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$QGHUVVHLQV *RWW VWHOOWVLFKLPDQHUNDQQWHQDQGHUHQGHP0HQVFKHQXQGGHU0HQVFKVWHOOWVLFKLQ GHU$QHUNHQQXQJVHLQHV$QHUNDQQWVHLQV±LQ*RWWGDU³ ,QGHPGHU0HQVFKVHLQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQGXUFK*RWWDQHUNHQQWDIILUPLHUWHUGLHLKPGDULQ]XWHLOJHZRUGHQH $OOJHPHLQKHLWZDVHLQHhEHUVFKUHLWXQJVHLQHU%HVRQGHUKHLWEHGHXWHWÄ/LHEH XQG)UHLKHLW³VLQGGLHGDIUHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ6WLFKZRUWH /LHEHGLHLQGHU+LQJDEHDQDQGHUHV±3HUVRQHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQXQG6DFKYHUKDOWH>@±]XVLFK VHOEVWNRPPWXQG)UHLKHLWGLHGLHQLFKWKDOWEDUH$OWHUQDWLYHYRQ6HOEVWXQG)UHPGEHVWLP PXQJGXUFK6HOEVWGDUVWHOOXQJLP)UHPGHQEHUZLQGHQ
'LHLQEHLGHQ+LQVLFKWHQDQYLVLHUWHhEHUVFKUHLWXQJGHUMHHLJHQHQ%HVRQGHU KHLWDXIV$OOJHPHLQHVR]LDOHU%H]LHKXQJHQKLQLVWGDVQRUPDWLYH,PSOLNDWGHU J|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJQDFK:DJQHU'LH5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQ NHQVVROOJHUDGHQLFKWGDUDXIKLQDXVODXIHQGDVVGHU0HQVFKÄVLFKDQGLH6WHOOH GHVYRUPDOVVHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ*RWWHV³ VHW]W9LHOPHKULVWPLWLKUGLH(LQVLFKWLQ GDVJHQHUHOOH6FKHLWHUQHLQHV9HUVWlQGQLVVHVYRQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWXQG)UHLKHLWYHU EXQGHQGDVYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQPHLQWDEVWUDKLHUHQ]XN|QQHQ Ä'HU0HQVFKZHL³DXV:DJQHUV6LFKWHLJHQWOLFKOlQJVWÄZDV*RWWDOV*HLVW LVW³ ZHLOGHVVHQ/RJLNGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOOHQLQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ LPPDQHQWLVW5HDOLVLHUWHUVHLQH)UHLKHLWLP6LQQHHLQHULKPXQPLWWHOEDU]XVWH KHQGHQ6HOEVWPDFKWNRPPWGLHVHLQHP6HOEVWPLVVYHUVWlQGQLVJOHLFKGDV:DJ QHUVQGHQWKHRORJLVFKDXV]XGHXWHQYHUPDJ=XJOHLFKDEHULVWÄ*RWWDOV*HLVW³ QLFKW HLQIDFK LPPHU VFKRQ UHDOLVLHUW VRQGHUQGHVVHQ 9HUZLUNOLFKXQJ ÄEOHLEW $XIJDEHGHV0HQVFKHQLQGHUMHZHLOLJHQ*HJHQZDUW³ $QGLHVHU6WHOOHNRPPWGHPUHOLJL|VHQ%HZXVVWVHLQ]HQWUDOH%HGHXWXQJ]X LQVRIHUQ HV DOV Ä'LIIHUHQ]EHZXWVHLQ³ GDV :LVVHQ GDUXP IHVWKlOW ÄGD *RWW QRFKQLFKWÃDOOHVLQDOOHPµLVW³ZHLOGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJYRQGHVVHQ6HOEVWH[SOL NDWLRQDP2UWHGHV0HQVFKHQHEHQGRUWQRFKDXVVWHKW(VLVWÄ3ODW]KDOWHUGHU 'LIIHUHQ]XQGVR3ODW]KDOWHUGHU)DNWL]LWlWGHVÃVLPXOLXVWXVHWSHFFDWRUµ³LQVR IHUQHVVLFKLQPLWWHQGHUQRFKXQHUO|VWHQLUGLVFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHÄDXI*RWW³DOV
:$*1(5F I :$*1(5M (EG (EG (EG (EG $D2 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XPUHOLJL|VHQ%HZXVVWVHLQ DD2 ±
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
ÄÃ,QVWDQ]µGLHGDV/HLGHQO|VW³EH]RJHQZHL'RFKVHW]WGLHVHV'LIIHUHQ] EHZXVVWVHLQHLQÄ:LVVHQXPGDVZDVUHDOLVLHUWZHUGHQNDQQ³XQGVROOYRU DXV )ROJWGLHVHV:LVVHQXPGDVZDVVHLQNDQQXQGVHLQVROOQXUDXVGHPUHOLJL| VHQ%HZXVVWVHLQVHOEVWKlWWHHVHLQHQSURMHNWLYHQ&KDUDNWHU(VZlUHYRQHLQHU ,OOXVLRQQLFKW]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQXQGN|QQWHVHLQHQ$QVSUXFKDXI$OOJHPHLQKHLW DXIDEVROXWH*HOWXQJQLFKWYHUEUJHQ'HVKDOEEHGDUIHVLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQGHU Ä7KHR/RJLH³DOVHLQHUXQDEKlQJLJYRPUHOLJL|VHQ*RWWHVEHZXVVWVHLQYRUJH QRPPHQHQ%HJUQGXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVGHULP'HQNHQDOVDXVVLFKVHOEVW DEVROXWEHJUHLIOLFKZLUG'LHVHUEOHLEWGDQQDEHUYRQHLQHU]XPLQGHVWLP'HQNHQ DXVZHLVEDUHQ6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWJHSUlJWGLHIUDJHQOlVVWREÄ>G@LH5HGHYRP7RG *RWWHV³VRJHVHKHQZLUNOLFKÄGHQ9HUOXVW*RWWHV³PHLQW%OHLEHQGJHJHQZlU WLJLVW*RWWMHGHQIDOOVQRFKDOVGLHDQVLFKVHOEVW±WULQLWDULVFK±]XH[SOL]LHUHQGH ÄÃDEVROXWH>@'LPHQVLRQµ>«@GHU6HOEVWH[SOLNDWLRQDQGHU6WHOOHGHV$QGHUV VHLQV³]XGHUGLHYRQ$V\PPHWULHQJHSUlJWHQUHDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHLP:LGHU VSUXFKVWHKHQRKQHLKUHWZDVDQKDEHQ]XN|QQHQ'LHVH]XPLQGHVWVSUDFKOLFK PDQLIHVWHQ+\SRVWDVLHUXQJVWHQGHQ]HQVWHKHQLQ6SDQQXQJ]X:DJQHUVVFKDUIHU .ULWLNHWZDDQ-QJHOV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQ:DJQHUKDWYRQLKQHQLQVHLQHU6SlW SKDVHQLFKWQXU$EVWDQGJHQRPPHQVRQGHUQHUKDWVLFKYRQGHQWULQLWDULVFK FKULVWRORJLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVJlQJHQLQVJHVDPWGLVWDQ]LHUW'DPLW]LHKWHUDEHU LP*UXQGHQXUOHW]WH.RQVHTXHQ]HQDXVVHLQHU)RUGHUXQJGHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQ ]XUHYROXWLRQLHUHQ (QWWKHRORJLVLHUXQJ±GHUDQHUNHQQXQJVORJLVFKH$XVZHJ 'DVVDXVÄGHP6FKHLWHUQGHV6XEVWDQ]JRWWHV>«@GHUQHXH*HGDQNHGHU$QHU NHQQXQJVORJLNUHVXOWLHUW³VWHKWZLHVFKRQJHVDJWDXFKIUGHQVSlWHQ:DJ QHUDXHU)UDJH(LQH'LVWDQ]QDKPHJHJHQEHUVHLQHUIUKHUHQ3RVLWLRQPDUNLHUW DOOHUGLQJVEHUHLWVGLHUHYROXWLRQlUH5KHWRULNGHV%UXFKVPLWGHUHUVHLQH6LFKW YRUWUlJW9RQHLQHUY|OOLJHQÃ$EO|VXQJµXQGÃ(UVHW]XQJµGHV$OWHQGXUFKGDV 1HXHLVWGLH5HGHYRQÃ(QWWKHRORJLVLHUXQJµXQGÃ(QWVXEVWDQ]LDOLVLHUXQJµ'LH VLFK GDULQ DXVVSUHFKHQGH (UVFKWWHUXQJ EHWULIIW GDV DEVROXWKHLWVWKHRUHWLVFKH )XQGDPHQW YRQ :DJQHUV 'HQNHQ VHOEVW 'DVV QlPOLFK GLH DV\PPHWULVFKH
$D2 (EG (EG :$*1(5J :$*1(5M :$*1(5 D 9JOQXUGLHbXHUXQJHQLQ :$*1(5 I 9JOGD]XLP)ROJHQGHQ :$*1(5 DII D± ± ± ±9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQDXHUGHPGLH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ-|UJ'LHUNHQV ',(5.(1 II
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
'LIIHUHQ]EH]LHKXQJ YRQ J|WWOLFKDEVROXWHU 0DFKW XQG ZHOWOLFKPHQVFKOLFKHU 2KQPDFKWLQHLQ9HUKlOWQLVGHU,QGLIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ6HLWHQDXI]XKHEHQ LVWPXVVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQDXFKDXIHUNHQQWQLVWKHRUHWLVFKHU(EHQHJHOWHQ 'LH1RWGHVH[WHUQHQ6WDQGSXQNWHVDXVGHPKHUDXVVLFKMHGHU9HUVXFKGDV $EVROXWH]XGHQNHQXQZHLJHUOLFKYROO]LHKWJHUlWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGJHUD GHZHJV]XU7XJHQG(LQHUVHLWVZLUG:DJQHUVODQJMlKULJHPHWKRGLVFKH0D[LPH GLHÄ$XVOHJXQJ³GHV$EVROXWHQÄDQGLH)RUPVHLQHU6HOEVWDXVOHJXQJ]XELQGHQ³ YRQLKPVHOEVWDOVXQHUVFKZLQJOLFKIUMHGHÄQRFKVRKRFKNDUlWLJH7KHRULHGHV $EVROXWHQ³EH]HLFKQHWÄ(LQH7KHRULHGHV$EVROXWHQNDQQVLFKQlPOLFKQXU DQGHQ*HGDQNHQGHV$EVROXWHQKDOWHQ³$QGHUHUVHLWVZLUGÄGLHVHFXPJUDQR VDOLV NULWL]LVWLVFKH(LQVLFKW³LQGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ*HGDQNHXQG*HGDFKWHP QLFKWHLQIDFKGHNUHWLHUWVRQGHUQHLJHQVDEVROXWKHLWVWKHRUHWLVFKEHJUQGHW'HP QDFKLVWGLHXQHQWULQQEDUHÄbXHUOLFKNHLWGHUlXHUHQ5HIOH[LRQ³GHPDOVVHOE VWlQGLJH0DFKWJHGDFKWHQ$EVROXWHQLQVRIHUQDQJHPHVVHQDOVGLHVHV]XVHLQHP 6HOEVWHUZHLVÄDXIHLQlXHUHV$QGHUVVHLQDQJHZLHVHQ³LVW,P'HQNHQDEHU OlVVWHVVLFKGDQQQXUQRFKÄLQGHU:HLVHVHLQHV6FKHLWHUQV³YHUJHJHQZlUWL JHQZHLOYRQGHU±HQGOLFKHQ±3RVLWLRQGHV'HQNHQGHQQLFKWPHKUDEVWUDKLHUW ]XZHUGHQYHUPDJ:DVGHQ$XVZHJDXVGLHVHP6FKHLWHUQZHLVWLVWNHLQH$XI KHEXQJGHVVHOEVWlQGLJVHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ$EVROXWHQLQHLQDEVROXWHV9HUKlOWQLV GDVWULQLWlWVWKHRORJLVFKFKULVWRORJLVFKXQGSQHXPDWRORJLVFKDXV]XEXFKVWDELHUHQ ZlUH9LHOPHKUOlVVWVLFKGHU*RWWHVJHGDQNHIU:DJQHUÄQXULQGHU)RUPHLQHU QHJDWLYHQ7KHRORJLHEHZDKUHQXQGEHZlKUHQ³ D 1HJDWLYH7KHRORJLH±GLHGHILQLWLYH9HUQLFKWXQJ*RWWHV 'LHDXJHQIlOOLJVWH)ROJHGLHVHU+LQZHQGXQJ]XHLQHUÃQHJDWLYHQ7KHRORJLHµLVW GDV$XVEOHLEHQGHU$XIHUVWHKXQJ*RWWHVÄDOV7UlJHURGHU5HSUlVHQWDQWGHU6XE MHNWLYLWlWVVWUXNWXU³ZDV]XYRUSQHXPDWRORJLVFKUHIOHNWLHUWZXUGH'HU7RG *RWWHVZLUGVWDWWGHVVHQVRUDGLNDOLVLHUWGDVVÄGDVJ|WWOLFKH6XEMHNWVHLQHUGHILQL WLYHQ9HUQLFKWXQJSUHLVJHJHEHQ³ZLUG'DULQYHUVFKDIIWVLFKGLH(LQVLFKWLQ GLH8QGHQNEDUNHLWMHGZHGHUXQDEKlQJLJHQJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWHQ6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW $XVGUXFN$OOHUGLQJVZHLVW:DJQHUGDVP|JOLFKH0LVVYHUVWlQGQLV]XUFNGXUFK
:$*1(5 D (EG ',(5.(1 9JODXFK0LFKDHO0XUUPDQQ.DKO Ä>'@HU/HLWIDGHQGHUVSlWHQ +HJHOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ³:DJQHUVVWHOOWÄGLHXQKLQWHUJHKEDUH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHU6HOEVWDXVOH JXQJGHV$EVROXWHQXQGGHP*HGDQNHQGLHVHU6HOEVWDXVOHJXQJ³GDUZRPLWHLQ*UXQGJHGDQNH GHVÄVSlWHQ)LFKWHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWVOHKUHYRQ³VHLQH/HNWUHOHLWH 08550$11.$+/ I :$*1(5 :$*1(5 D (EG ',(5.(1 :$*1(5
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GHQGHILQLWLYHQ7RG*RWWHVZUGHGHU0HQVFKHQGOLFKLQGLH/DJHYHUVHW]WVHLQH ELVODQJXQWHUGUFNWH(LJHQPDFKWYROO]XHQWIDOWHQ9LHOPHKUKlWWHPDQVRGHQ IUGDV6FKHLWHUQJ|WWOLFKHU0DFKWDXVVFKODJJHEHQGHQ6DFKYHUKDOWEHUVHKHQ QlPOLFKGHUHQ,QGLIIHUHQ]JHJHQEHUGHUDOVYHUPHLQWOLFKH2KQPDFKWYRUDXVJH VHW]WHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ *HJHQPDFKW Ä'LHVH 8QWHUVFKLHGVORVLJNHLW EHVDJW GD MHGHU9HUVXFKHLQHXQPLWWHOEDUXUVSUQJOLFKH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW 6XEVWDQWLDOLWlW ZHOFKHU6XEMHNWHDXFKLPPHU]XEHKDXSWHQ]XP6FKHLWHUQYHUXUWHLOWLVW³ :DJQHUV QXU LQ $QVlW]HQ DXVJHDUEHLWHWH QHJDWLYH7KHRORJLH ]LHOWGHPQDFK GDUDXIGLH3RVLWLRQGHV$EVROXWHQDOVSULQ]LSLHOOXQHUVFKZLQJOLFKDXV]XZHLVHQ %OHLEWGDV'HQNHQZDVHUIUKHUXPVFKLIIHQ]XN|QQHQJODXEWHVWHWVGHU'LIIH UHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHP*HGDQNHQGHU6HOEVWDXVOHJXQJGHV$EVROXWHQXQGGLHVHU VHOEVWYHUKDIWHWNDQQVLFKQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQGDQVHLQH6WHOOHVHW]HQ9LHOPHKU VLQGYRQGDKHUÄ>D@OOH9HUVXFKH]XU(UQHXHUXQJYRQ$QVSUFKHQDXI$EVROXW KHLWVLQVWDQ]HQSHUVRQDOHUVR]LDOHU|NRQRPLVFKHU$UW>«@LPPHUQHX]XNULWLVLH UHQ³,QGHU)lKLJNHLW]XVROFKHU.ULWLNYRQ$EVROXWLVPHQMHGZHGHU$UWVROO HUNOlUWHUPDHQGLHÄJUXQGVlW]OLFKH5HOHYDQ]³YRQ:DJQHUVQHJDWLYHU7KHRORJLH ÄIUGLH*HVWDOWXQJGHVSUDNWLVFKHQ6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJV³OLHJHQ6LH HUVFK|SIW VLFK DOOHUGLQJV QLFKW LP 1HJDWLYHQ VRQGHUQ KDW DXFK HLQH SRVLWLYH .HKUVHLWH6REHUQLPPWÄ>G@LH/RJLNGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ>«@GLH)XQNWLRQGHVLQ VHLQHU*HOWXQJQHJLHUWHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV³ E )XQNWLRQVZHFKVHO±YRQ*RWW]XUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ 'LH)XQNWLRQGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVOLHJW:DJQHU]XIROJHGDULQGHQÄZHOWHQWKR EHQHQ*UXQGGHVZHOWKDIWHQDEHUIUHLHQ'DVHLQVGHV0HQVFKHQ³QDPKDIW]X PDFKHQ:LHVFKRQGHUIUKH:DJQHU]XVDJHQZXVVWHGLHQWHUGHUÄ%HJUQ GXQJGHVVLFKQLFKWVHOEVWEHJUQGHQN|QQHQGHQ6XEMHNWV³'RFKIlOOWGDPLW GLH0|JOLFKNHLWZHJYRQGHU+HUDXIIKUXQJGLHVHVJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWHQ*UXQGHV GXUFKGDVYRUDXVVHW]HQGH7XQGHVHQGOLFKHQ6XEMHNWVVR]XDEVWUDKLHUHQGDVV DXIGLHÄ6HOEVWHQWIDOWXQJGHVDEVROXWHQ6XEMHNWV³]XUFNJHJDQJHQZLUG6LQG DOVRÄNHLQHVWLFKKDOWLJHQ$UJXPHQWHLQ6LFKW>«@GXUFKGLHGLH*HOWXQJGHV *RWWHVEHZXWVHLQVXQGGHVDQVLFKVHOEVWDXVJHOHJWHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVEHJUQ GHWZHUGHQN|QQWH³EOHLEWDEHULQ:DJQHUV$XJHQGLH(UIOOXQJYRQGHVVHQ DQJHVWDPPWHU)XQNWLRQXQHQWEHKUOLFK'LH)UDJHQDFKGHP*UXQGGHVMHHLJHQHQ
9JOGD]X :$*1(5 ± $D2+HUYRUKG9HUI $D2 (EG $D2 $D2 :$*1(5M $D2 :$*1(5
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
IUHLHQ'DVHLQVLVW±NXU]JHVDJW±ZHLWHUKLQ]XEHDQWZRUWHQ'LHVH)XQNWLRQVROO GLH/RJLNGHU$QHUNHQQXQJEHUQHKPHQGLHEHVDJW Ä)UHLKHLWNDQQDOVVR]LDOH 9HUKlOWQLVZHLVHQXUGDQQDXI'DXHUYHUZLUNOLFKWZHUGHQZHQQVLHDXIGHU(LQ VLFKWIXWGDGHUIUHLHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJHLQHV6HOEVWVHLQVGLHVHLQHV$QGHUV VHLQVNRUUHVSRQGLHUHQPX³0LWGLHVHUSUDNWLVFKHQ(LQVLFKWGLHGXUFKÄGH>Q@ =ZDQJ>«@HU]ZXQJHQZLUG³ÄGHUGDQQQRWZHQGLJZLUGZHQQ)UHLKHLWQLFKWLQ )RUPYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQUHDOLVLHUWZLUG³LVWDOVRIUGHQVSlWHQ :DJQHUGLH)UDJHQDFKGHP*UXQGGHUMHHLJHQHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWEHDQWZRUWHW(U OLHJWLQGHQVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQVHOEVWGLHLQVRIHUQÄJ|WWOLFK³RGHUÄDEVROXW³ VLQGDOVVLHDXIGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ)UHLKHLW]LHOHQ :HLWHUKLQYHUN|USHUWGLHDXVGHP6FKHLWHUQ*RWWHVUHVXOWLHUHQGH6WUXNWXUGHU 6HOEVWHQWIDOWXQJLP$QGHUHQQDFK:DJQHUV$QVSUXFKÄJOHLFKVDPGDVZDVGLH :HOWÃLP,QQHUVWHQ]XVDPPHQKlOWµ³XQGÄLPSOL]LHUW>«@HLQLQQHUHV*HIlOOH]XP QRUPDWLYHQ6ROOHQZHOFKHVDOOHP6HLHQGHQXQGGHQZHOWKDIWHQ6WUXNWXUHQDOV HLJHQHV 5HDOLVLHUXQJVSULQ]LS LPPDQHQW LVW³ 'LHVH PRUDOLVFKH =LHOEHVWLP PXQJGLHVHV6ROOHQDEHULVWQLFKWLPPHUVFKRQUHDOLVLHUWVRQGHUQHVKDW]X JOHLFKHLQHQNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ&KDUDNWHUGHQ:DJQHUQXQVWlUNHUZUGLJW(U VSULFKWKLHUYRQHLQHUÄLPPDQHQWHQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]VR]LDOHU)UHLKHLWVYHUKlOWQLV VH³ ,VW GDPLW HLQHUVHLWV LP %OLFN GDVV GLHVH HLQH SHUPDQHQWH 6HOEVWEHU VFKUHLWXQJGHUDQLKQHQ%HWHLOLJWHQLPSOL]LHUHQJHKWHVKLHUDQGHUHUVHLWVXP Ä8QWHUEUHFKXQJHQGHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ6HOEVWEHUVFKUHLWXQJGHV3HUVRQDOHQXQG GHV 6R]LDOHQ³ 6RZRKO DXIVHLWHQ LQGLYLGXHOOHU 3HUVRQHQ DOV DXFK DXIVHLWHQ VR]LDOHU,QVWLWXWLRQHQNRPPWHVGDQQ]XÄ9HUVXFKH>Q@>«@GHUHLJHQHQ3RVLWLRQ GLH :HLKHQ XQG GHQ 6FKHLQ HLQHV YHUDEVROXWLHUWHQ 6HOEVWDEVFKOXVVHV ]X JH EHQ³'LHJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWH$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNHQWIDOWHWLQGLHVHP)DOOGHQ &KDUDNWHUHLQHVQRUPDWLYHQhEHUVFKXVVHVXQGGUlQJWLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQJHUDGH ]XDXI5HDOLVLHUXQJDQJHVLFKWVLKUZLGHUVSUHFKHQGHU9HUKlOWQLVVH (LQHQWWKHRORJLVLHUWHV*RWWGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJHUVHW]HQGHV&KULVWHQWXPKDW YRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQG]ZHLHUOHL]XWKHPDWLVLHUHQ 'LH(LQVLFKWGDVV)UHLKHLW QXULQVR]LDOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQUHDOLVLHUEDULVWYHUODQJWHEHQVRVLFK GLHVHQKLQ]XJHEHQZLHDPPLWGHP)UHLKHLWVEHGUIQLVHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ$QVSUXFK DXIZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJQRWIDOOVJHJHQGLHIDNWLVFKH5HDOLWlWGHV6R]LD
$D2I $D2 9JOHWZD $D2± ',(5.(1 9JOGD]X:DJQHUV0LWWHGHU HU-DKUHJHEUDXFKWHQ:RUWH Ä'LH FKULVWOLFKH5HOLJLRQHQWVSULFKWLKUHPHLJHQHQ%HJULIIXQG6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVQXUGDQQZHQQ YRQMHGHP6HOEVWVHLQ]ZLVFKHQ+LPPHOXQG(UGHJLOWGDHVVHLQ6HOEVWVHLQDOOHLQDXIGHP 8PZHJEHUVHLQ$QGHUVVHLQGKLQ%H]LHKXQJXQG6HOEVWXQWHUVFKHLGXQJ]XGHPVHOEHQ]X EHVWLPPHQXQG]XSUDNWL]LHUHQYHUPDJ³ :$*1(5 :$*1(5 (EG $D2
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
OHQIHVW]XKDOWHQ0LWLKUHU.RQ]HQWUDWLRQDXIGLH0HQVFKZHUGXQJXQGGHQ 7RG*RWWHVHQWKlOWGLHÄFKULVWOLFKH5HOLJLRQ³LQ:DJQHUV$XJHQÄ'HXWXQJVSR WHQWLDOH³QLFKWQXUXPLKUHQ6\PEROKDXVKDOWYRQ*RWWDXI$QHUNHQQXQJXP]X VWHOOHQVRQGHUQDXFKXPEHLGH+LQVLFKWHQ]XP7KHPD]XPDFKHQ'HQQGDV 6FKHLWHUQGHVVHOEVWXQGDOOPlFKWLJHQ*RWWHVIKUWGLH8QKLQWHUJHKEDUNHLWYRQ $QHUNHQQXQJ IU GLH 9HUZLUNOLFKXQJ VHOEVWlQGLJHU 6XEMHNWLYLWlW YRU $XJHQ 'HUHQ QRUPDWLYH /HW]WJHOWXQJ DEHU ]HLJW VLFK LQ GHQ VR]LDOHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQ VHOEVWGLHDOVDEVROXWE]ZJ|WWOLFK]XSUlGL]LHUHQVLQGZHQQVLHHLQHUZHFKVHO VHLWLJHJDOLWlUHQ)UHLKHLWVHUP|JOLFKXQJGHQ%RGHQEHUHLWHQ'LHVHVÄSUlGLNDWLYH $EVROXWH³DOVGDVGLH/RJLNGHU$QHUNHQQXQJIXQJLHUWZLUGYHUIHKOWZRHVLQ ZHOFKHU)RUPDXFKLPPHU]XPVHOEVWlQGLJHQ6XEMHNWJHPDFKWZLUG(VOlVVW VLFKQLFKWÄ]XHLQHUGULWWHQ*U|HYHUVHOEVWlQGLJHQ³DOVGHULPÄJHJHQVHLWLJH>Q@ $QHUNHQQHQSUlVHQWHDEVROXWH*HLVWNRPPW>HV@]XGLHVHP$QHUNHQQHQQLFKW VHNXQGlU KLQ]X³ 9LHOPHKU PDQLIHVWLHUW VLFK GDV SUlGLNDWLYH $EVROXWH IU :DJQHUJHUDGHLQGHUSHUPDQHQWHQhEHUVFKUHLWXQJVROFKHU6XEVWDQ]LDOLVLHUXQJ VYHUVXFKHDOVRJHUDGHGDULQVLFKQLFKWDOVHVVHOEVW]XPDQLIHVWLHUHQ:HUYHU PLWWHOVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHVMHZHLOLJHQ$QGHUHQVHLQ6HOEVWVHLQYHUZLUNOLFKW ÄRIIHQEDUW³±VRNDQQDXFKGHUVSlWH:DJQHUQRFKIRUPXOLHUHQ±ÄGHQDEVROXWHQ *HLVW DOV JHJHQZlUWLJ³ 'LHVH *HLVWHVJHJHQZDUW LVW DEHU YRP SUDNWLVFKHQ 9ROO]XJQLFKWPHKU]XWUHQQHQGHUDXIHLQHGH]LGLHUWH5HODWLYLHUXQJMHGZHGHU DOVVHOEVWlQGLJYRUJHVWHOOWHQ$EVROXWKHLW]LHOWXQGGDULQGDV6FKHLWHUQGHV*|WW OLFK$EVROXWHQYROO]LHKW*|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJJLSIHOWVRLQHLQHUPHQVFKOL FKHQ )UHLKHLWVSUD[LV GLH DXI :HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLW LQ V\PPHWULVFKHU *OHLFKKHLW DXVJHULFKWHWLVWLQGHPGHUHLQHGLH)UHLKHLWGHVE]ZGHU$QGHUHQDFKWHWXQG XPJHNHKUW 'LHGXUFKÄGH>Q@=ZDQJ³GHUVRQVWÄQRWZHQGLJZLUG>«@HU]ZXQJHQH(LQ VLFKW³GDVVÄ)UHLKHLW³QXUÄDOVVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVZHLVH>«@DXI'DXHUYHUZLUN OLFKWZHUGHQ³NDQQ VWHKWLP=HQWUXPHLQHUFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VHQ/HEHQVSUD[LV PLWHEHQVRPRUDOLVWLVFKHPZLHLQWHOOHNWXDOLVWLVFKHP*HSUlJH'DEHLVROOGLH Ä5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV³LQ)RUPHLQHUÄ5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHU )UHLKHLW³DP2UWHGHVLQGLYLGXHOOHQXQGVR]LDOHQ/HEHQV5HDOLWlWJHZLQQHQ ZREHLGLH)UDJHRIIHQEOHLEWZLHGDVZDVQDFKÃJ|WWOLFKHPµ0DVWDEVHLQVROO VLFKDXV:DJQHUV6LFKWHLJHQWOLFKGXUFKVHW]WE]ZGXUFKVHW]HQOlVVW2GHUPXVV PDQGDIUQXUMHQHQÃ=ZDQJµGHUEHL1LFKWEHIROJXQJÃQRWZHQGLJ ZLUGµLQV %HZXVVWVHLQUXIHQ"'DVÄ&KULVWHQWXPQLFKWGHVVFK|QHQ5HGHQVVRQGHUQGHU
9JOHWZD:$*1(5PI :$*1(5 9JOGD]X $D2 I $D2 I $D2 $D2 :$*1(5 F X
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
7DW³LQGDV:DJQHUQDFKHLJHQHU$XVNXQIWZlKUHQGVHLQHU-XJHQG]HLWLQHLQHU VROGDWLVFKSLHWLVWLVFK JHSUlJWHQ 3IDGILQGHUVFKDIW KLQHLQVR]LDOLVLHUW ZXUGH VFKHLQWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHXWOLFKGXUFK'LHULJRULVWLVFKHXQGVWUHQJH 6FKODJVHLWHVHLQHVDXIHLQHÄQFKWHUQXQGOHEHQVSUDNWLVFKRULHQWLHUWH>@)U|P PLJNHLW>@³KLQDXVODXIHQGHQ5HOLJLRQVE]Z&KULVWHQWXPVYHUVWlQGQLVVHVZLUG LP)ROJHQGHQLPPHUZLHGHULQLKUHQ*UHQ]HQYRU$XJHQWUHWHQ 5HYROXWLRQLHUWH)UHLKHLW .RQWXUJHZLQQWGLHPLWGHU5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVHLQKHUJHKHQ GHUHYROXWLRQLHUWH)RUPYRQ)UHLKHLWZHQQPDQVLFKLKU*HJHQWHLOLQ(ULQQHUXQJ UXIW'HUHQ6WUXNWXUVWHOOWIU:DJQHUHLQZHLWHUHV$UJXPHQWJHJHQGHQÄYRUUH YROXWLRQlUHQ³*RWWHVJHGDQNHQGDU:LGHUVSUFKOLFKHU:HLVHZLUGQlPOLFKLP &KULVWHQWXPHLQPHQVFKOLFKHU)UHLKHLWVYROO]XJDOV6QGHTXDOLIL]LHUWGHUDXI HLQHUVLFK]XTXDVLJ|WWOLFKHU+\EULVDXIVFKZLQJHQGHQÄH[NOXVLYHQ6HOEVWEH KDXSWXQJ³EHUXKWGLHPDQDEHUGHPPLWDEVROXWHU6HOEVWPlFKWLJNHLWDXVJHVWDWWH WHQ*RWW]XJHVWHKW'LHVKDWGHQ3UHLVGDVV*RWWÄVHOEHU]XP3URWRW\SGHV %|VHQ XQG GHU 6QGH³ ZLUG :DV :DJQHU GDUDQ PRQLHUW LVW GDV IHKOHQGH .ULWHULXP]XUÄ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQHUÃJXWHQµXQGHLQHUÃE|VHQµ6HOEVW EHVWLPPXQJ³GLHVLFKKLHUHLQ]LJQDFKGHUDPRUDOLVFKHQ/RJLNHLQHVÄ4XRG OLFHW ,RYL QRQ OLFHW ERYL³ ]X EHPHVVHQ VFKHLQW 'LHVHV DEHU VLHKW HU PLW 0HQVFKZHUGXQJ XQG 7RGGHV $OOPDFKWVJRWWHV JHJHEHQ (LQHUVHLWV HQGHW GLH HLQVHLWLJH$EKlQJLJNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ]XJXQVWHQVHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOVVHOEVW lQGLJ$QGHUHPZRGXUFKHULQV5HFKWJHVHW]WZLUGVHLQH)UHLKHLW]XYROO]LHKHQ $QGHUHUVHLWVZLUG]XJOHLFKÄGLHDOVXQPLWWHOEDUH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJDXVJHOHJWH )UHLKHLW>«@IUSULQ]LSLHOOJHVFKHLWHUWHUNOlUW³ZDVLKQGD]XDQKlOWVHLQHDQHU NDQQWH (LJHQVWlQGLJNHLW HEHQIDOOV XQWHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHV IUHLHQ 6HOEVWVHLQV $QGHUHUDOVRDXIYHUPLWWHOWH:HLVH]XUHDOLVLHUHQ :LUGGLHVHU=XVDPPHQKDQJYRQ)UHLKHLWXQG$QHUNHQQXQJWKHRORJLVFKUHI OHNWLHUWVLHKW:DJQHUGLHVR]LDOSUDNWLVFKH)ROJHQORVLJNHLWHWZDHLQHULP%DQQH GHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVOHKUHVWHKHQGHQ7KHRORJLHEHUZXQGHQ :LHQlPOLFKÄ*RWW VHOEVW>«@QXUIUHL>LVW@ZHLOHUVLFKDQGHU6WHOOHGHV0HQVFKHQH[SOL]LHUW³LVW DXFKÄGHU0HQVFK>«@QXUIUHLLQVRIHUQHUVLFKDXIDQGHUH0HQVFKHQDXIGLH
:$*1(5 E :$*1(5 E6RFKDUDNWHULVLHUW:DJQHUGLH)U|PPLJNHLWGHUKHVVLVFKHQ+H OLDQG3IDGILQGHUVFKDIWGHUHULQGHQ HU-DKUHQDQJHK|UWH(UIJWDEHUNULWLVFKKLQ]XGDVV GHUEHVDJWH)U|PPLJNHLWVVWLOÄGXUFKHLQVHLWLJH%HWRQXQJHQXQG,QV]HQLHUXQJHQYRQ)KUXQJ 2UGQXQJ5HLQKHLWXQG([NOXVLYLWlW³LPPHUZLHGHUDXFKÄLQ)UDJHJHVWHOOW³ZXUGH HEG :$*1(5X (EG9JO]XGLHVHP3XQNWLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 $D29JO'(56 :$*1(5X9JODD2±
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
,QVWLWXWLRQHQLQ*HVHOOVFKDIWXQG6WDDWHLQOlW³(VLVWVRPLWXQP|JOLFKJH ZRUGHQ ÄGLH .RQVWLWXWLRQ GHU )UHLKHLW >«@ YRQ LKUHU 5HDOLVLHUXQJ³ ]X WUHQ QHQ :DV EHL /XWKHU HLQVHLWLJ GHP J|WWOLFKHQ *HVFKHQN GHU *QDGH ]XJH VFKULHEHQZLUGNRPPWDOOHLQTXDWlWLJHP9ROO]XJDOV$QHUNHQQXQJ±6HOEVWHQW IDOWXQJ LP $QGHUHQ ± DP 2UWH GHV PHQVFKOLFKHQ 'DVHLQV ]XU :LUNOLFKNHLW 'HQQ Ä$QHUNHQQXQJNDQQQXUGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJJHOHEWZHUGHQ³:HUGLH IUHLH6XEMHNWLYLWlWGHV$QGHUHQQLFKWDIILUPLHUWZLGHUVSULFKWGHPQDFKDXFKGHP HLJHQHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQDOVIUHLHV6XEMHNW%HLGHVLVWQXU]XVDPPHQ]XKDEHQ 'DVVGLHVHVQRUPDWLYH)UHLKHLWVSULQ]LSDOVYHUPLWWHOWH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJYHU ZLUNOLFKW ZLUGLVWDOOHUGLQJVVR ZXUGHREHQEHUHLWVDQJHPHUNWNHLQH6DFKH HLQHVlXHUHQ=ZDQJVVRQGHUQGHUIUHLHQ(LQVLFKWLQGDVDOOHUGLQJVDXVGUFNOLFK Ã]ZLQJHQGHµ6FKHLWHUQLKUHV*HJHQVDW]HV 'HQQRFKPXVVZLH:DJQHUEHWRQWÄQDFK0LWWHOQXQG:HJHQ³JHVXFKWZHU GHQZLHGLH5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVDOV5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHU )UHLKHLWJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKQDPKDIWJHPDFKW]XZHUGHQYHUPDJGDPLWÄGLHLQGLYL GXHOOHPLWGHUDOOJHPHLQHQ)UHLKHLWVREHUHLQVWLPPHQNDQQGDVLFK]XJOHLFK GLHDOOJHPHLQH)UHLKHLWIUGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLKHLW|IIQHW³ 'LHLQGLHVHU$XIJDEHQVWHOOXQJDXVJHVSURFKHQH3UREOHPDQ]HLJHEHWULIIWHLQH )HKOHQWZLFNOXQJLP3UR]HVVGHU0RGHUQH]XGHUHQ%HDUEHLWXQJ:DJQHULQVEH VRQGHUHGDVSURWHVWDQWLVFKH&KULVWHQWXP±ZHQQHVVLFKGHQQLQVHLQHP6LQQH YHUVWHKWXQGDXVOHJW±EHIlKLJWVLHKW+HUPDQQ)LVFKHUVNULWLVFKJHJHQ:DJQHU JHULFKWHWH)UDJHÄZDUXPHVIUGHQ3UR]HZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJXQWHU YHUQQIWLJHQ6XEMHNWHQEHUKDXSWQRFKGHU*RWWHVLGHHEHGDUI³HUKlOWKLHU HLQH$QWZRUW(VEHGDUILKUHUQRFKZHLOGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJHhEHUVFKUHLWXQJGHV MHHLJHQHQIUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQVLPPHUZLHGHUGXUFKHLQVHLWLJH6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJV YHUVXFKHGXUFKEURFKHQZLUG'DVVGLHVHDEHU]XP6FKHLWHUQYHUXUWHLOWVLQGZHLO )UHLKHLWQXUDXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJUHDOLVLHUEDULVWVWHOOWQDFK:DJQHUGDV ]HQWUDOH7KHPDGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVGDU*RWWVWHKWGDPLWLP*UXQ GHIUGXUFKUHOLJL|VH.RPPXQLNDWLRQ]XYHUJHZLVVHUQGHQRUPDWLYH/HW]WJHO WXQJYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHUHQ9HUJHZLVVHUXQJGLHVR]LDOH*HJHQZDUWVODJHWUDQV ]HQGLHUW6RODQJHGLHVPLWLKPYHUEXQGHQH7KHPDGDVQLFKWH[NOXVLYDQLKQ JHEXQGHQLVWUHOHYDQWEOHLEWLVWDXFKYRQ*RWWNLUFKOLFKWKHRORJLVFKQLFKW]X VFKZHLJHQ:DJQHUV6LFKWDXIGLHÄ*HJHQZDUWGHU0RGHUQH³VR]HLJHQGLH
:$*1(5N 'HU]LWLHUWH7H[WHQWVWDPPW:DJQHUVÃ9RU:HQGH=HLWµLVWDEHU GHU6DFKHQDFKDXFKLQGLH.RRUGLQDWHQVHLQHV6SlWZHUNV]XEHUVHW]HQ :$*1(5N (EG 9JOHWZD:$*1(5 I :$*1(5F ),6&+(5 :$*1(5F,QGLHVHU)RUPXOLHUXQJGHXWHWVLFK:DJQHUVDXVGUFNOLFKH$EQHL JXQJJHJHQGHQ%HJULIIGHU3RVWPRGHUQHDQLQGHPVLFKLQVHLQHQ$XJHQQXUHLQHEHVWLPPWH 5HDNWLRQDXIGHQ5DWLRQDOLVLHUXQJVGUXFNGHU0RGHUQHDXVVSULFKWPLWGHP=LHOVLFKDQJHVLFKWV
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
IROJHQGHQ.DSLWHODEHUVFKOLHWGLH0|JOLFKNHLWHLQHUYROOVWlQGLJHQVR]LDOHQ 5HDOLVLHUXQJ GHV ,GHDOV YHUPLWWHOWHU 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ ]XPLQGHVW QLFKW DXV :UGHVLH:LUNOLFKNHLWEUlXFKWHHVDXVVHLQHU6LFKWZRKODXFKNHLQHV*RWWHVJH GDQNHQVPHKU'RFKZLH:DJQHUJHUQPLW%UHFKWVDJWÄGLH9HUKlOWQLVVHGLH VLQGQLFKWVR³±XQGHVLVWGLH)UDJHREVHLQDXIVLGHDOHUZHLVH*HVROOWHDEVWHO OHQGHVWKHRORJLVFKHV'HQNHQGLHVHLPPHUZLHGHUDXINRPPHQGH6SDQQXQJ]ZL VFKHQ$QVSUXFKXQG:LUNOLFKNHLWEHUKDXSWQRFKHLJHQV]XZUGLJHQZHL
.RQIURQWDWLRQHQ *|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJXQGPRGHUQH *HVHOOVFKDIW &KULVWHQWXPXQG0RGHUQH±VRODXWHWGHUSURJUDPPDWLVFKH7LWHOYRQ:DJQHUV DQ GHU 8QLYHUVLWlW :LHQ JHKDOWHQHQ $QWULWWVYRUOHVXQJ 6LH VFKOLHW PLW HLQHP9HUZHLVDXIGLHÄLPPHUQRFKRIIHQH>@)UDJH)ULHGULFK6FKOHLHUPDFKHUV³ QDFKGHPILQDOHQ$XVHLQDQGHUJHKHQGHVÄ.QRWHQ>V@GHU*HVFKLFKWH³:DJQHUV 5H]HSWXPGLHVEH]JOLFKQLFKW]XHLQHPXQYHUV|KQOLFKHQ(QGH]XJHODQJHQDQ GHP HLQ DXV PRGHUQHU 6LFKW EDUEDULVFKHV &KULVWHQWXP HLQHU DXV FKULVWOLFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH XQJOlXELJHQ 0RGHUQH JHJHQEHUVWHKW ODXWHW Ä'HQ $QIDQJ GHV &KULVWHQWXPVQHXEHJUHLIHQ³ :DVGDPLWJHPHLQWLVWKDWGDVYRUKHUJHKHQGH.DSLWHOJH]HLJW(VJHKW:DJ QHUXPGLHDXVGHPW|GOLFKHQ6FKHLWHUQGHV$OOPDFKWVJRWWHVUHVXOWLHUHQGH$QHU NHQQXQJVORJLN)UGLHPLWLKUDQYLVLHUWHÄYHUPLWWHOWH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³DOV GHP Ä3ULQ]LS FKULVWOLFKHU )UHLKHLW³ E]Z GHP ÄSURWHVWDQWLVFKH>Q@ 3ULQ]LS³ EHDQVSUXFKWHUQlPOLFKHLQH5HOHYDQ]LP%OLFNDXIVlPWOLFKH6SKlUHQGHVJH VHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQVÄ(VVLQG>«@NHLQSHUV|QOLFKHUXQGNHLQVR]LDOHU%H UHLFKGHQNEDULQGHQVLHQLFKWEHUVHW]EDUZlUH³ 6LFKHLQHUGHPJHPlHQ hEHUVHW]XQJVDUEHLW]XZLGPHQVRUJWHQLFKWQXUGDIUGDVVGDV&KULVWHQWXP VHLQHVSH]LILVFKPRGHUQH5DQGVWHOOXQJEHUZLQGHQN|QQWH$XFKZUGHHLQH PRGHUQH*HVHOOVFKDIWGDYRQSURILWLHUHQGHUHQ]HQWUDOHV)UHLKHLWVYHUVSUHFKHQ QRFKLPPHUVHLQHUYROOVWlQGLJHQ(LQO|VXQJKDUUWÄ'HUKDOELHUWHQ0RGHUQH³VR IRUPXOLHUWHV:DJQHUÄGUIWHGLH0RELOLVLHUXQJGHVSURWHVWDQLWVFKHQ>VLF@3ULQ ÄGHU$XVZHJORVLJNHLWGHV:HOWODXIVDXILUJHQGHLQH,QVHOGHU6HOLJHQ³]XUFN]X]LHKHQ DD2 6WDWWGHVVHQZLOO:DJQHUGHQÄQLFKWRGHUQXUXQ]XUHLFKHQGUHDOLVLHUWHQ,GHHQHLQHUIUHLHQ +XPDQLWlW³]XU9HUZLUNOLFKXQJ]XYHUKHOIHQ HEG :$*1(5 F :$*1(5F 6RODXWHWGLHhEHUVFKULIWGHV6FKOXVVDEVFKQLWWVLQGHP:DJQHUQDFKHLQHPOlQJHUHQ ]HLWGLDJQRVWLVFKHQ(UNXQGXQJVJDQJVHLQHHLJHQWOLFKH.RQ]HSWLRQSUlVHQWLHUW 9JO$D2± $D2 (EG
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
]LSVHEHQVRI|UGHUOLFKVHLQZLHVLHHLQHPKDOELHUWHQ3URWHVWDQWLVPXV]XU5HDOL VLHUXQJGHUJDQ]HQFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLWYHUKHOIHQNDQQ³ :RKHUGLHVHDXV:DJQHUV6LFKW]XEHUZLQGHQGHQ+DOEKHLWHQMHZHLOVUKUHQ LVWGDV7KHPDGHVIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWV'DEHLZHQGHWVLFKGHU%OLFNZHJYRQ GHQ8PEUFKHQLQ:DJQHUV'HQNHQGDVQXQVWlUNHUYRQVHLQHU6SlWSKDVHKHU SURILOLHUWZLUG'HP&KULVWHQWXPE]ZGHP3URWHVWDQWLVPXVVWHOOWHULP=XJH GHVVHQGLH'LDJQRVHHLQHVWLHIJUHLIHQGHQVR]LDOHQ5HOHYDQ]YHUOXVWHVGHUHEHQVR HLQ5HVXOWDWGHVPRGHUQHQ6lNXODULVLHUXQJVSUR]HVVHVLVW ZLHHUHLQKDXV JHPDFKWHV3UREOHPGDUVWHOOW 'LHPRGHUQH*HVHOOVFKDIWKLQJHJHQLVWGXUFK HLQHIXQGDPHQWDOH$PELYDOHQ]JHSUlJW 'LHGHQ,QGLYLGXHQ]XHUNDQQWH)UHLKHLW ZLUGGXUFKDXIUHLQH6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJDEVWHOOHQGHVR]LDOH6\VWHPHGHUDUWNRQWHU NDULHUWGDVVLKUH5HDOLVLHUXQJ]XPLQGHVWEHGURKWLVW+LHUN|QQWHGLHFKULVWOLFKH 5HOLJLRQLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQÄHLQ*HJHQJHZLFKWVFKDIIHQ³ZHQQVLHGLHJ|WWOL FKH$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNHQWVSUHFKHQG]XPRELOLVLHUHQYHUPDJ ,QÃJRWWORVHUµ*HVHOOVFKDIW±)ROJHQGHU6lNXODULVLHUXQJ 1DFK1LNODV/XKPDQQVlXHUVWSRLQWLHUWHU'LDJQRVHNDQQPDQKHXW]XWDJHÄJH ERUHQ ZHUGHQ OHEHQ XQG VWHUEHQ RKQH DQ 5HOLJLRQ WHLO]XQHKPHQ XQG DXFK ZHQQGLH5HOLJLRQVDJHQZLUGGDVVGLHVDOOHVLQ*RWWHV:HOWJHVFKLHKWNDQQGHU (LQ]HOQHGLHVVFKDGORVLJQRULHUHQ³'LHOlQJVWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKJHZRUGHQH Ä0|JOLFKNHLWUHOLJLRQVIUHLHU/HEHQVIKUXQJ³OlVVWVLFKDOV5HVXOWDWGHVPR GHUQHQ6lNXODULVLHUXQJVSUR]HVVHVQDPKDIWPDFKHQ1DFK/XKPDQQVVR]LRORJL VFKHU/HVDUWGHUVLFK:DJQHUDQVFKOLHWEHVFKUHLEWGHU6lNXODULVLHUXQJVEHJULII HLQH.RQVHTXHQ]MHQHUIXQNWLRQDOHQ'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJGHUVR]LDOHQ:LUNOLFKNHLW ZLHVLHHLQ]LJÄLQGHUYRQ(XURSDDXVJHKHQGHQPRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW³UHDOL VLHUWZXUGH'HPQDFKNRPPWHVVHLWGHP0LWWHODOWHUGDVGXUFKHLQHVWUDWLILND WRULVFKH±GKKLHUDUFKLVFKVWlQGLVFKH±6R]LDOVWUXNWXUEHVWLPPWZDU]XULPPHU ZHLWHUHQ9HUVHOEVWlQGLJXQJHLQ]HOQHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU7HLOEHUHLFKHGLHHLQHMH VSH]LILVFKH3ULPlUIXQNWLRQ]XQHKPHQGDXWRQRPXQGHLQHUHLJHQHQ6DFKORJLN IROJHQGDXVEHQ $XFKGLH5HOLJLRQ]XY|UGHUVWLVWDQJHVLFKWVGHVHXURSlLVFKHQ.RQWH[WHVDQ GDV&KULVWHQWXPYHUVFKLHGHQHUNRQIHVVLRQHOOHU3UlJXQJ]XGHQNHQJHULQQWLQ IROJHGLHVHU(QWZLFNOXQJ]XHLQHPVR]LDOHQ6XEV\VWHPPLWRULJLQlUHUJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKHU3ULPlUIXQNWLRQ6LHWULIIW±ZLH:DJQHULP$QVFKOXVVDQ/XKPDQQ
(EG $D2 /8+0$11 :DJQHU]LWLHUW/XKPDQQV'LDJQRVHLQ :$*1(5 D /8+0$11 /8+0$11 9JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ /8+0$11 II9JOIUGLHIROJHQGHQ/XK PDQQ'DUVWHOOXQJHQDXFK:DJQHUVHLJHQH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQLQ :$*1(5 II 9JO/8+0$11 II I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
IRUPXOLHUW±DXIGLHHLJHQJHVHW]OLFKYHUIDVVWHQÄVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPHIU:LUWVFKDIW 3ROLWLN5HFKW(U]LHKXQJ*HVXQGKHLW:LVVHQVFKDIWXQG.XQVW³YRQGHQHQÄLQ GHU5HJHONHLQHUHOLJL|VHQRGHUWKHRORJLVFKHQ)XQNWLRQHQ³ZDKUJHQRPPHQ ZHUGHQ'LHVHUHSUlVHQWLHUHQHLQHLQQHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH8PZHOWGLHRELKUHU ]XYHU]HLFKQHQGHQ5HOLJLRQVORVLJNHLWHLQ]LJDXVGHUUHOLJLRQVV\VWHPVSH]LILVFKHQ 6LFKWGHVNRQIHVVLRQHOOVHJPHQWLHUWHQ&KULVWHQWXPVDOVÃVlNXODULVLHUWµHUVFKHLQW 'DGXUFKZLUG]XJOHLFK]XP$XVGUXFNJHEUDFKWGDVVVR/XKPDQQGHVVHQÄHL JHQH6WUXNWXUHQ>«@QLFKWPHKUGXUFKJHVDPWJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH6HOEVWYHUVWlQG OLFKNHLWHQRGHU,VRPRUSKLHQJHGHFNW³VLQG )UGLHFKULVWOLFKH5HOLJLRQEHGHX WHW Ã6lNXODULVLHUXQJµ LQ :DJQHUV $XJHQ GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG NHLQHQ 9HUZHOWOL FKXQJVVFKXEVRQGHUQHLQHQLPPHQVHQÄ:HOWYHUOXVW³6LHYHUOLHUWNXU]JH VDJWGHQ6WDWXVÄIUGLH(UNOlUXQJGHU1DWXUZHOWXQGGLHSROLWLVFKUHFKWOLFKH XQGZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHU6R]LDOZHOWGLUHNWYHUDQWZRUWOLFK]XVHLQ³ +LVWRULVFKYHUPLWWHOWZLUGGLHVHUÄ6FKZXQGFKULVWOLFKHU6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKNHL WHQ³GXUFKMHQHGLH0RGHUQHDOV(SRFKHÄVLFKEHVFKOHXQLJHQGH>U@9HUlQGH UXQJHQXQG1HXDQIlQJH³FKDUDNWHULVLHUHQGHQ5HYROXWLRQHQQDWXUZLVVHQVFKDIW OLFKSKLORVRSKLVFKHUSROLWLVFKHUXQGLQGXVWULHOOHU$UWYRQGHQHQLQVEHVRQGHUH HLQXPIDVVHQGHU%HGHXWXQJVUFNJDQJGHU*RWWHVYRUVWHOOXQJDXVJHKW *RWWHVYHUOXVW±GLH5HYROXWLRQHQGHU0RGHUQH Ä(VN|QQWH>«@VHLQ³KHLWHVEHL:DJQHULPEHZXVVWHQ.RQMXQNWLYÄGDHUVW GDV%HZXWVHLQGHU0RGHUQH*RWWVHLWRWGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ7KHRORJLHGLH$XJHQ |IIQHWIUGLH%HVRQGHUKHLWLKUHVHLJHQHQ$QIDQJV³9RQGHQ5HYROXWLRQHQ GLHGDVEHVDJWH%HZXVVWVHLQKLVWRULVFKDQJHVWRHQKDEHQJLQJHGDQQHLQSUR GXNWLYHV3RWHQ]LDODXVXPGHU5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVDOV8U VSUXQJ GHV &KULVWHQWXPV DQVLFKWLJ ]X ZHUGHQ (QWVSUHFKHQG IKUHQ VLH QDFK :DJQHUV/HVDUWDOOHVDPW]XUUDGLNDOHQ,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJYRQ*RWWHVYRUVWHOOXQJHQ GLHHUFKULVWOLFKHUVHLWVRKQHKLQYRQMHKHUIUEHUZXQGHQKlOW'DPLWDEHUZLUG JHZLVVHUPDHQGLH.ULVH]XU&KDQFH 6RVHW]WVLFKPLWGHULP-DKUKXQGHUWEHJLQQHQGHQ9HUNQSIXQJPDWKHPD WLVFKHU*HVHW]PlLJNHLWHQXQGHPSLULVFKH[SHULPHQWHOOHU9HUIDKUHQEHL1LNR ODXV.RSHUQLNXVXQG*DOLOHR*DOLOHLHLQGLHWUDGLWLRQHOOH.RVPRORJLHLQ]XQHK
:$*1(5 9JO/8+0$11 II 9JODD2 :$*1(5 D (EG '(/(.$7 :$*1(5F $D2 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQEH]JOLFKGLHVHU5HYROXWLRQHQ :$*1(5 D II II F II
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
PHQGHQ0DHHUVFKWWHUQGHV:HOWELOGGXUFK(V]LHKWÄGLHVRZRKOZLVVHQVFKDIW OLFKHDOVDXFKWHFKQLVFKLQGXVWULHOOH(QWEHKUOLFKNHLWDOOHUUHOLJL|VHQXQGWKHROR JLVFKHQ:HOWVFK|SIXQJVXQG:HOWHUKDOWXQJVYRUVWHOOXQJHQQDFKVLFK³,PPD QXHO.DQWVGDUDQDQVFKOLHHQGHÄ5HYROXWLRQGHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'HQNDUW³ QHJLHUWGDUEHUKLQDXVDOOH9HUVXFKHHLQHJHJHQVWlQGOLFKIDVVEDUH5HDOLWlW*RW WHV]XEHKDXSWHQ'LHVHUIlKUWHLQHUVHLWVGXUFKGLH3URMHNWLRQVWKHVHGHUUDGLNDO JHQHWLVFKHQ5HOLJLRQVNULWLNQDFK)HXHUEDFK1LHW]VFKH0DU[)UHXGHWFHLQH GHVWUXNWLYH6WHLJHUXQJ$QGHUHUVHLWVIKUWHV]XU9HUEDQQXQJ*RWWHVDXVÄDOOHQ HUNHQQWQLVJHOHLWHWHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQGLHDXIGHQ(UZHUEHPSLULVFKJHVlWWLJWHQ :LVVHQV]LHOHQ³]XJXQVWHQHLQHVÄPHWKRGRORJLVFKHQ$WKHLVPXV³'LH)UXFKW GLHVHV8PEUXFKVLVW:DJQHU]XIROJHQLFKWQXUHLQH+DOWXQJYRQÄ9HUGDFKWXQG 0LDFKWXQJ³ JHJHQEHUGHU*RWWHVYRUVWHOOXQJ(VIROJWGDUDXV]XY|UGHUVWHLQH ÄJHOHEWH,QGLIIHUHQ]>«@GXUFKGLHGHU*RWWHVJODXEH]XGHQ'LQJHQJHUHFKQHW ZLUGGLHIUGHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVW XQG:HOWXPJDQJ PHKURGHU ZHQLJHU EHODQJORVHUVFKHLQHQ³'HPNRUUHVSRQGLHUWHLQXPIDVVHQGHUÄ$WKHLVPXVGHU VLWWOLFKHQ :HOW³ GHQ GLH DP (QGH GHV -DKUKXQGHUWV YRQ )UDQNUHLFK XQG 1RUGDPHULNDDXVJHKHQGHSROLWLVFKH5HYROXWLRQJOHLFKVDPHUNlPSIWKDW(U VSLHJHOWVLFKLPJUXQGVlW]OLFKHQ$EZHLVMHGZHGHQ$QVSUXFKVDXIHLQHDOOJH PHLQJOWLJHWKHRQRPH%HJUQGXQJSROLWLVFKHU0DFKWRGHUVWDDWOLFKHQ5HFKWVLP 6LQQHGHVWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ1DWXUUHFKWVZLGHU%HLGHSUR]HGLHUHQDOOHLQQDFKÄ3ULQ ]LSLHQGHVDXWRQRPHQ9HUQXQIWUHFKWV³XQGÄVRPLWDWKHLVWLVFK³6FKOLHOLFK HUZlFKVWDXVGHULP/DXIHGHV -DKUKXQGHUWVYRUDQVFKUHLWHQGHQLQGXVWULHOOHQ 5HYROXWLRQLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQHLQHGH]LGLHUWHÄ5HOLJLRQVXQG0RUDOIHUQHGHU :LUWVFKDIW³ 0LW LKU QlPOLFK JHKW GLH hEHUIKUXQJ GHU ÄDOWHXURSlLVFKH>Q@ %HGDUIVGHFNXQJVZLUWVFKDIWLQGHQGXUFK3URGXNWLYLWlWVXQG3URILWVWHLJHUXQJ JHOHLWHWHQ,QGXVWULHNDSLWDOLVPXV³HLQKHUGHUHLQ]LJYRP=LHOGHU.DSLWDOYHU PHKUXQJJHOHLWHWLVW'LHVDEHUVFKOLHWHVJUXQGVlW]OLFKDXVPRUDOLVFKHE]Z UHOLJL|VH3ULQ]LSLHQ]XEHUFNVLFKWLJHQ5HVXOWLHUHQDXVGHQDQGHUHQ8PZlO]XQ JHQVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVGLHEHQDQQWHQ$WKHLVPHQJHODQJWIU:DJQHULQIROJHGHU
:$*1(5 :$*1(5 D :$*1(5 I :$*1(5 D $D2I:DJQHUEHVFKUHLEWGLHVH[SOL]LWDOV5HVXOWDWÄGHUHUVWHQ .DQWXQGGLH)RO JHQ XQGGHU]ZHLWHQ$XINOlUXQJ )HXHUEDFK0DU[1LHW]VFKH)UHXG ³XQGGHUHQ.ULWLNDP *RWWHVJHGDQNHQ HEG 9JO]XGLHVHP3XQNWDXFKLQGHUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJ :$*1(5 ± :$*1(5 DI 9JO]XGLHVHP3XQNWDXFKLQGHUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJ :$*1(5 ± :$*1(5 D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
LQGXVWULHOOHQ5HYROXWLRQHLQÄLUGLVFKH>U@*RWWGHV*HOGHV³]XU+HUUVFKDIWGHU JHZLVVHUPDHQGHQDQJHVWDPPWHQ2UWGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVHLQJHQRPPHQKDW 'LHGHUDUWKLVWRULVFKYHUPLWWHOWHIXQNWLRQDOH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJGHUPRGHUQHQ *HVHOOVFKDIWHUVFKHLQWDOVRLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQDOV6lNXODULVLHUXQJVYRUJDQJZHLO VLHDXV6LFKWGHV&KULVWHQWXPVHLQH5HOLJLRQVXQGÄ*RWWORVLJNHLW³GHUVRQVWL JHQVR]LDOHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQPLWVLFKEULQJWGLHQDFKHLJHQHQ3ULQ]LSLHQRSHULHUHQ 'LHVH(QWZLFNOXQJDEHUVFKOlJWVLFKVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVDXFKDXISHUVRQDOHU(EHQH QLHGHULQGHPZLHHUZLHGHUXPOXKPDQQVFKH*HGDQNHQDXIQHKPHQGKHUDXV VWHOOWÄGLH5HOLJLRQDOV3ULYDWDQJHOHJHQKHLWVLQJXOlUHU6XEMHNWHJHOHEWZLUG³ %LQGXQJVYHUOXVW±GLH)UHLKHLW]XU 1LFKW 5HOLJLRQ 'DIULVWGLHÄVSH]LILVFKH$UWGHU3DUWL]LSDWLRQYRQ,QGLYLGXHQDQGHU*HVHOO VFKDIWXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQIXQNWLRQDOHU$XVGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ³ DXVVFKODJJH EHQGGLH/XKPDQQPLWWHOVGHV6WLFKZRUWVÃ,QNOXVLRQµQDPKDIWPDFKW :lK UHQGGLH6WHOOXQJGHV,QGLYLGXXPVLQQHUKDOEGHUVWUDWLILNDWRULVFKHQ6R]LDOVWUXN WXU GHV 0LWWHODOWHUV GXUFK GHVVHQ =XJHK|ULJNHLW ]X HLQHP EHVWLPPWHQ 6WDQG %DXHU$GHO.OHUXV YRQYRUQKHUHLQIHVWJHOHJWZDUNDQQGLHVLQGHU0RGHUQH HLQ]LJWHLOV\VWHPVSH]LILVFKJHUHJHOWZHUGHQ'HPQDFKHUKlOWÄMHGH3HUVRQ=X JDQJ]XMHGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ)XQNWLRQ³LQGHPVLHVLFKYRUJHJHEHQHVR]LDOHQ 5ROOHQGXUFKGLHVLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKDOVHWZDVMHVSH]LILVFK%HVWLPPWHVDQHU NDQQWLVWVHOEVWlQGLJDQHLJQHW =XJOHLFKDEHUZLUGHVREGHU]XQHKPHQGHQ 6SH]LDOLVLHUXQJGHUHLQ]HOQHQ7HLOV\VWHPHÄLPPHUZHQLJHUP|JOLFKGDMHGHU PDQQMHGH)XQNWLRQVDFKOLFKNRPSHWHQWXQG]HLWOLFKDXVUHLFKHQGODQJIULVWLJ³ ZDKU]XQHKPHQYHUPDJ'HVKDOEELOGHQVLFKXPHLQHIOlFKHQGHFNHQGH,QNOXVLRQ ]XJHZlKUOHLVWHQQHEHQGHQÄRUJDQLVDWRULVFKJHQDXXPULVVHQH%HUXIVUROOH>Q@ >«@ PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU YDULDEOH .RPSOHPHQWlUUROOHQ³ KHUDXV 3ROLWLNHU :lKOHU8QWHUQHKPHU.RQVXPHQWHWF :DJQHUPDFKWGLHVEH]JOLFKHLQHÄ]XPLQGHVWLP)DOOGHVSURWHVWDQWLVFKHQ &KULVWHQWXPV³JHJHEHQH%HVRQGHUKHLWGHV5HOLJLRQVV\VWHPVJHOWHQG 'LH'LIIH UHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ ÄJHRUGQHWH>P@ $PW³ XQG Ä3ULHVWHUWXP DOOHU *OlXELJHQ³ NDQQ
:$*1(5 9JOJUXQGOHJHQG '(56 IIII'LHVH7KHVHVWHKWIUHL OLFKLQJHZLVVHP:LGHUVSUXFK]XUHUZlKQWHQ5HOLJLRQVIHUQHGHUNDSLWDOLVWLVFKRUJDQLVLHUWHQ gNRQRPLHZDVGDIUVSULFKWGDVV:DJQHUV5HOLJLRQVEHJULIIYRQYRUQKHUHLQQRUPDWLYHWKLVFK EHVHW]WLVW :DJQHUVWHOOWGLHVHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJKHUHWZDLQ :$*1(5FII :$*1(5 D :$*1(5U %$57+9JOHEGDXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH 9JO/8+0$11 II $D2 (EG %$57+ 9JO/8+0$11 I
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
NHLQHUÄIL[LHUEDUHQ7UHQQXQJYRQ%HUXIVXQG.RPSOHPHQWlUUROOHQ³HQWVSUH FKHQZHVKDOE,QNOXVLRQKLHUEHUGLHÄ3ULYDWLVLHUXQJGHVUHOLJL|VHQ(QWVFKHL GHQV³HUIROJW :DVEHL/XKPDQQ]XQlFKVWHLQPDODOOH)XQNWLRQVEHUHLFKHDQEH ODQJWQlPOLFKGDVVVLFKGLHSULYDWLVLHUWHQ3DUWL]LSDWLRQVPRWLYHLKUHU7HLOQHKPHU GXUFKÄQRUPLHUWH9HUKDOWHQVFRGHVQLFKWDXVUHLFKHQGNRQWUROOLHUHQ³ODVVHQ UHNODPLHUW:DJQHUH[NOXVLYIUGHQ%HUHLFKGHU5HOLJLRQ'HVVHQ=XJDQJVDUWLVW VHLQHV(UDFKWHQVQLFKWZLHLP)DOOHÄGHUVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPHYRQ:LUWVFKDIW3ROL WLN5HFKW(U]LHKXQJHWF>«@DQ]ZHFNUDWLRQDOHQ(UIRUGHUQLVVHQGLHYRUDOOHP PLW5ROOHQXQG.DUULHUHHUZDUWXQJHQYHUEXQGHQVLQG³RULHQWLHUWVRQGHUQEH WULIIWÄGLH,QGLYLGXHQDOVVROFKH³ :lKUHQGVLFKDOVRGLH7HLOQDKPHDQGHQ DQGHUHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ )XQNWLRQHQ QDFK 1RWZHQGLJNHLWVJHVLFKWVSXQNWHQ ULFKWHWZLUGLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQGLHXQWHUPRGHUQHQ%HGLQJXQJHQÄÃSULYDWLVLHUWHµ 5HOLJLRQ]XHLQHPNRQWLQJHQWHQ6DFKYHUKDOW³GHPDQVWHOOHREMHNWLYHU(UZDU WXQJVPXVWHUUHLQLQGLYLGXHOOH0RWLYHNRUUHVSRQGLHUHQ 3DUDOOHO]XUÃVlNXODUL VLHUHQGHQµ$ENRSSOXQJGHUQLFKWUHOLJL|VHQ7HLOV\VWHPHYRQGLUHNWHUUHOLJL|VHU =XVWlQGLJNHLWYROO]LHKWVLFKVRJHVHKHQDXFKGLHWHLOV\VWHPVSH]LILVFKH5ROOHQ DXVEXQJGHU,QGLYLGXHQRKQHGDVVGDEHLGLH5HOLJLRQV QLFKW ]XJHK|ULJNHLW XQGGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH(LQVWHOOXQJHQYRQXQPLWWHOEDUHP%HODQJZlUHQ%HLGHU 9HUKlOWQLVLVWVRJDUÄDOVXPJHNHKUWSURSRUWLRQDO]XNHQQ]HLFKQHQ³ZLH:DJQHU XQWHU5HNXUVDXI0D[:HEHUYHUGHXWOLFKW 'LHVHUVSULFKWYRQHLQHUÄ(LJHQJH VHW]OLFKNHLW³GLHPRGHUQHVSH]LILVFKLQGHQVR]LDOHQ7HLOEHUHLFKHQ(LQ]XJKlOW VRGDVVHWZDGHU0DUNWÄQXU$QVHKHQGHU6DFKHNHLQ$QVHKHQGHU3HUVRQNHLQH %UGHUOLFKNHLWV XQG 3LHWlWVSIOLFKWHQ³ NHQQW ZHLO HU QXU YRQ ÄUDWLRQDOH>Q@ =ZHFNLQWHUHVVHQ³JHOHLWHWLVW+LVWRULVFKEHWUDFKWHWHQWVSULFKWHLQHUVROFKHQ 7UHQQXQJ]XGHPGLHUHFKWOLFKH'XUFKVHW]XQJYRQ5HOLJLRQVXQG*ODXEHQVIUHL KHLWLQIROJHGHUPRGHUQHQSROLWLVFKHQ5HYROXWLRQ'HUHQ*DUDQWLHVR:DJQHU VHW]WYRUDXVGDVV
'(56:$*1(5U 9JO/8+0$11 II)UGDV=LWDW DD2)U/XKPDQQLVWGLHÄ3ULYD WLVLHUXQJUHOLJL|VHQ(QWVFKHLGHQV³ DD2 HLQ(SLSKlQRPHQGHUDOOJHPHLQEHREDFKWEDUHQ Ä3ULYDWLVLHUXQJGHV(QWVFKHLGHQV³GLHGDUDXIDEKHEWGDVVHWZDLJH=XVDPPHQKlQJHGLHDXI LQGLYLGXHOOHU(EHQH]ZLVFKHQGHQ.RPSOHPHQWlUUROOHQKHUJHVWHOOWZHUGHQQXUIUGLHÄ3HUVRQ XQGLKUH0LNUR0RWLYH³JHOWHQRKQHGDVVVLHLQGHQWHLOV\VWHPVSH]LILVFKHQ9HUKDOWHQVHUZDU WXQJHQEHUFNVLFKWLJWZUGHQ DD2I 'LHVHSULYDWLVLHUWHQ3DUWL]LSDWLRQVPRWLYHVWHOOHQ HLQ5LVLNRGDUGDVPDQDXIWHLOV\VWHPVSH]LILVFKHU(EHQHÄZHGHUNRQWUROOLHUHQQRFKYHUDQW ZRUWHQVRQGHUQDOOHQIDOOVDOV3UREOHPHQWGHFNHQXQG]XNRUULJLHUHQYHUVXFKHQNDQQ³ DD2 9JO:$*1(5 D 9JO',(5.(1E GHUDQGLHVHU6WHOOH6SDQQXQJHQ]XU6\VWHPWKHRULHDXVPDFKW GLHGDULQOLHJHQÄGDVVPLWGHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYRQ.RQWLQJHQ]XQG1RWZHQGLJNHLWLP%OLFN DXI5HOLJLRQXQGVR]LDOH6\VWHPHHLQHZHLWHUHVNRQ]HSWXHOOHV3ULQ]LSQDPKDIWJHPDFKWZLUG³ DD2$QP :$*1(5 D 9JO:(%(5 II)UGDV=LWDW
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GLHLQGLYLGXHOOPRWLYLHUWH(QWVFKHLGXQJIURGHUJHJHQHLQH5HOLJLRQZHOFKHU$UWDXFKLPPHU QLFKWYRQ0RWLYHQEHUODJHUWZLUGGXUFKGLHGHUDOOHQ,QGLYLGXHQJOHLFKHUPDHQRIIHQVWHKHQ GH=XJDQJ]XU3ROLWLN]XU:LUWVFKDIWXQG]XU:LVVHQVFKDIWHUOHLFKWHUWRGHUHUVFKZHUWZLUG
'HU9HUOXVWDOV*HZLQQ 1HJDWLYEHWUDFKWHWEHGHXWHQGLHYRQ:DJQHUJHVFKLOGHUWHQ(QWZLFNOXQJHQDXI VR]LDOHUXQGSHUVRQDOHU(EHQHIUGDVLQGHU*HJHQZDUWGHU0RGHUQHVLWXLHUWH &KULVWHQWXPHLQHQLUUHYHUVLEOHQ9HUOXVWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKHU5HOHYDQ]1XUXQWHU ,QNDXIQDKPH VFKLHU XQEH]DKOEDUHU Ä.RVWHQ LQ *HVWDOW HLQHU =ZDQJVNXOWXU³ N|QQWHPDQDXIHLQHRKQHKLQÄDOOHQIDOOVLQSURSKHWLVFKHP*HVWXVEHVFKZ|UED UH>@(LQKHLWVNXOWXU³XQWHUFKULVWOLFKHU+HJHPRQLH]XUFNJHKHQ=XGHPDEHU HUZHLVWVLFKGHU*HOWXQJVYHUOXVWIUGDV&KULVWHQWXPDXFKDOV*HZLQQ6RVLQG ÄGLHFKULVWOLFKHQ.LUFKHQXQGLQ6RQGHUKHLWLKUH7KHRORJLHQ³XQWHUPRGHUQHQ %HGLQJXQJHQYRQGHU/DVWEHIUHLWÄ]XJOHLFKIUGLH(LQKHLWXQGGDV*DQ]HGHU *HVHOOVFKDIW]XVWlQGLJ]XVHLQ³'DVKHLW 6LHN|QQHQVLFKGDUDXINRQ]HQWULH UHQÄGLH*UXQGDXVVDJHQGHV&KULVWHQWXPVDXIVDFKOLFKEHU]HXJHQGH:HLVH]X *HK|U]XEULQJHQ³RKQHGDEHLYRQYRUQKHUHLQDXIÄP|JOLFKH>@5HVRQDQ]LQGHQ DQGHUHQVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPHQ³]XEDXHQ9HUPDJSRVLWLYHUZHLVHÄGLH5HOLJLRQ HLQ]LJ XPLKUHUVHOEVW ZLOOHQ>]X@LQWHUHVVLHUHQ³VWHOOWVLFKGDPLWDEHUGLH )UDJHQDFKLKUHPJHQXLQHQ7KHPDLP.RQWH[WGHU0RGHUQHGDVIU:DJQHU GRFKHLQÃGDV*DQ]HGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWµDQYLVLHUHQGHVLVW $QVlW]H]XHLQHU$QWZRUWOLHJHQVFKRQLQGHUDXIJH]HLJWHQ'LIIHUHQ]]XGHQ DQGHUHQVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPHQ :lKUHQGOHW]WHUH=XVWlQGLJNHLWIUGLHXQDEZHLVOL FKHQÄ=ZHFNVHW]XQJHQGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ/HEHQVHUKDOWXQJ³EHDQVSUXFKHQEH ]LHKWVLFKGLHYRQELRJUDILVFKHQ.RQWLQJHQ]HQEHVWLPPWH7HLOQDKPHDQ5HOLJLRQ ÄDXIGLH,QGLYLGXHQDOVVROFKH³XQG]ZDUXQWHU$EVHKXQJYRQNRQNUHWHQ5ROOHQ HUZDUWXQJHQE]Z$QHUNHQQXQJVPXVWHUQ'LHVHQWVSULFKWDXFKGHUÄJHLVWOLFK VDFKOLFKHQ (LJHQDUW GHUFKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQ³ GLH YRQMHKHU Ä=XJHK|ULJNHLW XQDEKlQJLJYRQELRORJLVFKJHVFKOHFKWOLFKHQUDVVLVFKHQQDWLRQDOHQXQGVR]LDOHQ =XUHFKQXQJHQ³DXVVSULFKW:HQLJVWHQVÄGHP$QVSUXFKQDFK³JHKWVLHGDYRQ DXVÄGDYRU*RWWDOOH0HQVFKHQJOHLFK³VLQGÄ'HU0HQVFKDOV0HQVFK³VR NDQQVLFK:DJQHUDXFKPLWUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKHP.ODQJDXVGUFNHQLVW YRU*RWWÄDOVXQHQGOLFKXQYHUOLHUEDUH3HUVRQDQHUNDQQW±XQDEKlQJLJYRQ/HLV WXQJXQG+DEHQ³
:$*1(5 D :$*1(5K :$*1(5F (EG (EG :$*1(5 :$*1(5F :$*1(5S :$*1(5
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
:LUGDOVRGLHVR]LDOHQ5ROOHQHUZDUWXQJHQWUDQV]HQGLHUHQGH,QGLYLGXDOLWlWGHU ,QGLYLGXHQ]XPJHQXLQHQ7KHPDPRGHUQHU5HOLJLRQEHVWHKWGLH$XIJDEHYRQ GHVVHQNLUFKOLFKWKHRORJLVFKLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHU5HIOH[LRQMHGRFKQLFKWGDULQ HLQHU(LQNHUNHUXQJGHV,QGLYLGXHOOHQLQHLQHPÄ6RQQXQG)HLHUWDJVKHLOLJWXP³ 9RUVFKXE]XOHLVWHQ ÄGDVVLFKGHPVR]LDOXQGSHUVRQDOJHOHEWHQ$OOWDJYHU VFKOLHW³9LHOPHKUJHUlWYHUPLWWHOVGHUUHOLJL|VHQ7KHPDWLVLHUXQJYRQ,QGLYL GXDOLWlWGLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH:LUNOLFKNHLWGHU0RGHUQHGDUDXIKLQLQGHQ%OLFN REVLHGDVDOOHQ]XJHVDJWH9HUVSUHFKHQIUHLHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJHLQ]XKDOWHQ YHUPDJ(LQHDXIGDVJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJVLGHDOVHW]HQGH.LUFKHXQG7KHROR JLHKlWWHKLHU]XLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQYLHOEHL]XWUDJHQ9RQGHQPRGHUQHQ5HYROX WLRQHQQDWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKSKLORVRSKLVFKHUUHFKWOLFKSROLWLVFKHUXQGLQGXVW ULHOOHU$UWN|QQWHVLHVLFKPLWKLQGD]XDQKDOWHQODVVHQGHQUDGLNDOHQ.RQVH TXHQ]HQGHV7RGHV*RWWHVQHX$XVGUXFN]XYHUOHLKHQ,QGLHVHP5HOHYDQ]DQ VSUXFKVWHFNW]XJOHLFKDXFKHLQHIHVW]XKDOWHQGH6SDQQXQJLQ:DJQHUV3RVLWLRQ (LQHUVHLWVEHWRQWHUGLHPLWGHP3UR]HVVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJXQG VRDXFK6lNXODULVLHUXQJHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ9HUOXVWHDXIFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VHU6HLWH VHKUVWDUNDQGHUHUVHLWVYHUPDJHUDEHUGHP&KULVWHQWXPZHQQHVGHQQUHFKW YHUVWDQGHQZLUGLPPHUQRFKHLQHSRWHQ]LHOOJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKDOOJHPHLQH%HGHX WXQJ]X]XVFKUHLEHQ 'DV]XU$XVVFK|SIXQJGLHVHV3RWHQ]LDOVQ|WLJHVHOEVWNULWLVFKH6LFK(LQODVVHQ DXIGLH+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJHQPRGHUQHU)UHLKHLWVSUD[LVPXVVVLFK:DJQHU]XIROJH MHGRFKLQQHUSURWHVWDQWLVFKVWDUNHP*HJHQZLQGDXVVHW]HQ,QVHLQHQ/DJHGHXWXQ JHQDXVGHQ HU-DKUHQHUVFKHLQWLKPGHU*HJHQZDUWVSURWHVWDQWLVPXVGXUFK HLQHQH[SOL]LWÄDQWLPRGHUQH>Q@(LQGHXWLJNHLWVDQVSUXFK³GRPLQLHUWGHQHUDXV GHU:RUW*RWWHV7KHRORJLHEDUWKVFKHU3UlJXQJUHVXOWLHUHQVLHKW6R]LRORJLVFK EHWUDFKWHWIKUWGDVVR:DJQHUVVFKDUIH'LDJQRVH]XHLQHUÄVHOEVWJHQJVDPHQ 6HOEVWLVROLHUXQJGHUHYDQJHOLVFKHQ7KHRORJLHGLHVLFKYRQHLQHUVHNWLHUHULVFKHQ *HWWRPHQWDOLWlWNDXPQRFKXQWHUVFKHLGHQOlW³'LHVH]XEHUZLQGHQZLUG IU LKQ JHUDGHZHJV ]XU 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ HLQHV )RUWOHEHQV GHV SURWHVWDQWLVFKHQ &KULVWHQWXPV 6R EHU]RJHQ GDV (PSILQGHQ HLQHU RIIHQEDUXQJVWKHRORJLVFKHQ 'RPLQDQ] DXFKVFKRQ]XGDPDOLJHU=HLWJHZHVHQVHLQPDJXQGVRVHKU:DJQHUVÄ(UZl JXQJHQ³DXFKZLH+HUPDQQ)LVFKHUDQPHUNWÄPLWXQJHEUHPVWHQhEHU]HLFK QXQJHQVFKLHIHQ$OWHUQDWLYHQXQGKlPLVFKHU>«@YRU3ULPLWLYLVPHQQLFKW]X UFNVFKHXHQGHU.ULWLN³HLQKHUJHKHQ Ä(UIRUPXOLHUW³GDULQVR)LVFKHUZHLWHU
:$*1(5 E 9JOGD]X :$*1(5 ±=XGHQDQJHVSURFKHQHQ/DJHGLDJQRVHQYJOGLHEHL GHQ0RQRJUDILHQ '(56 G :$*1(5
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GRFKÄEHUHFKWLJWHNULWLVFKH$QIUDJHQJHJHQEHU)HKOHQWZLFNOXQJHQLQGHUSUR WHVWDQWLVFKHQ7KHRORJLH³GHQHQQXQQDFK]XJHKHQLVW ,QÃZHOWORVHUµ*HPHLQVFKDIW±.RQVHTXHQ]HQGHU:RUW*RWWHV7KHRORJLH 'DVVÄGLHULWXDOLVLHUWHQ'DXHUUHGHQYRQ*RWWLQQHUKDOEGHU*UHQ]HQGHUNLUFKOL FKHQ5HOLJLRQ³XQHQWZHJWZHLWHUODXIHQREZRKOVLHQDFKDXHQKLQJOHLFKVDP UHVRQDQ]ORVYHUKDOOHQLVWIU:DJQHUNODUHU$XVGUXFNHLQHUWKHRORJLHJHVFKLFKW OLFKHQ)HKOHQWZLFNOXQJLP/DXIHGHV-DKUKXQGHUW6RVLHKWHUHVDOVHLQH XQEHVWUHLWEDUH7DWVDFKHDQGDVVGHUDNWXHOOH5HOHYDQ]YHUOXVWGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQQLFKWQXUDXVGHQÄUHOLJLRQVH[WHUQHQ9HUlQGHUXQJHQLP=XJHGHUVLFK VlNXODULVLHUHQGHQ PRGHUQHQ *HVHOOVFKDIW³ UHVXOWLHUW (U IROJW HEHQVR DXV ÄGH>Q@ UHOLJLRQVNXOWXUHOOHQ 9HUZVWXQJHQ³ PLW GHQHQ ÄGLH QHXHYDQJHOLVFKH :HQGHWKHRORJLHGHV:RUWHV*RWWHVGHQGHXWVFKVSUDFKLJHQ3URWHVWDQWLVPXVEHU ]RJHQKDW³'DEHLLVWYRUDOOHP.DUO%DUWKLP%OLFNGHVVHQVFKXOELOGHQGHV 'HQNHQVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVQDFK LQQHUSURWHVWDQWLVFKÄ]XUKHUUVFKHQGHQ0HL QXQJ³DYDQFLHUWLVWGLHQXQPHKUDXIDOOVHLWVÄEHUHLWZLOOLJDN]HSWLHUWH6WLPPIK UHUVFKDIW³WULIIW:DV:DJQHUGXUFKGHQ$XVGUXFNÃ:HQGHµDSRVWURSKLHUWLVW GHULP6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV%DUWKVXQGGHUIUKHQÃGLDOHNWLVFKHQµ%HZHJXQJWLHI YHUDQNHUWH$QVSUXFKPLWGHUOLEHUDONXOWXUSURWHVWDQWLVFKHQ7KHRORJLHWUDGLWLRQ GHV -DKUKXQGHUWVDXIUDGLNDOH:HLVH]XEUHFKHQZHLOVLHZLH5XGROI %XOWPDQQHV]XVDPPHQIDVVWHÄQLFKWYRQ*RWWVRQGHUQYRQ0HQVFKHQJHKDQ GHOW³ KDEH 'LH JHJHQZlUWLJH )UXFKW GLHVHU WKHRORJLVFKHQ :HQGH YHURUWHW :DJQHULQHLQHPJUXQGVlW]OLFKHQVDFKOLFKHQXQGVR]LDOHQ%UXFK]ZLVFKHQGHP NHU\JPDWLVFKGRJPDWLVFKHQ9HUNQGLJXQJVDQVSUXFKGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ.LUFKHQ XQGGHUVLFKEHVFKOHXQLJHQGHQ0RGHUQLVLHUXQJGHVLQGLYLGXHOOHQXQGGHVVR]LD OHQ6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJV 'LHVH.OXIW]ZLVFKHQ&KULVWHQWXPXQG0RGHUQHZLUGGXUFKGLHHUNOlUWH'LV WDQ]]XGHQ$QOLHJHQGHU9RUJlQJHUJHQHUDWLRQHQ]HPHQWLHUW0LWGHUIUGLH 'LDOHNWLVFKH7KHRORJLHLGHQWLWlWVVWLIWHQGHQ$EZHQGXQJQlPOLFKJHKWGDV(QGH GHV YRQ -RKDQQ 6DORPR 6HPOHU EHU )ULHGULFK 6FKOHLHUPDFKHU ELV ]X (UQVW
),6&+(5 6RODXWHW)LVFKHUV)HVWVWHOOXQJLQVHLQHU5H]HQVLRQYRQ:DJQHUV =XUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ/DJHGHV3URWHVWDQWLVPXV :$*1(5 D 9JO]XULP)ROJHQGHQUHNRQVWUXLHUWHQÄ$EUHFKQXQJ³PLWGHU:RUW*RWWHV7KHRORJLH LQVEHVRQGHUHEDUWKVFKHU3URYHQLHQ]LQVJHVDPW :$*1(5 E± E± ± :$*1(5 (EG :$*1(5 E %8/70$11 D9JOGD]XXD :$*1(5 E :$*1(5
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
7URHOWVFKLQWHQGLHUWHQ3URMHNWVHLQHUhEHUVHW]XQJGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HOLJLRQLQ GLHVLFKYHUlQGHUQGHQVR]LRNXOWXUHOOHQ.RQWH[WHGHU0RGHUQHHLQKHU $XVVWLHJDXVGHU0RGHUQLVLHUXQJ =ZHLHUOHLVLHKW:DJQHUGXUFKOHW]WHUH±XQGDXFKGLHEULJHQ±9HUWUHWHUGHV VRJ1HXSURWHVWDQWLVPXVGLHVEH]JOLFKJHOHLVWHW (LQHUVHLWVKDEHQVLHGHPSULYD WLVLHUWHQ&KDUDNWHUPRGHUQHU5HOLJLRQGXUFKGLH%HWRQXQJGHUUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ *UXQGHLQVLFKWLQGLH)UHLKHLWGHVEHGLQJXQJVORVGXUFK*RWWDQHUNDQQWHQ0HQ VFKHQYRQNOHULNDOHQRGHUOHKUDPWOLFKHQ$XWRULWlWHQ5HFKQXQJJHWUDJHQ'DIU VWHKWGLH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYRQ5HOLJLRQXQG7KHRORJLH'HU7KHRORJHLVWGHP]X IROJHQLFKWPHKU6DFKZDOWHUGHVREMHNWLYHQ*ODXEHQVZLVVHQVVRQGHUQVHLQ7XQ LVWIXQNWLRQDOGDUDXIJHULFKWHWGLHSULYDWLQGLYLGXHOOH$QHLJQXQJGHUEHUNRP PHQHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJVJHKDOWH ]X HUP|JOLFKHQ (U EHPKW VLFK GDQQ ZLH ]% 6FKOHLHUPDFKHUXPGLHÄGXUFKJHKHQGH>@hEHUVHW]XQJDOOHUWUDGLHUWHQFKULVWOL FKHQ*HKDOWHLQ$XVVDJHQGLHVLFKDXIVSUDFKOLFKDUWLNXOLHUWH$XVGUXFNVSKlQR PHQHGHV*HIKOVGHUFKULVWOLFKIURPPHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlW]XUFNIKUHQODVVHQ³ $QGHUHUVHLWVKDWGHU1HXSURWHVWDQWLVPXV:DJQHU]XIROJHGHPVLFKDQJHVLFKWV GHU5HOLJLRQVXQG*RWWORVLJNHLWGHUDXHUUHOLJL|VHQVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPHVWHOOHQGHQ 9HUPLWWOXQJVSUREOHPDXVGUFNOLFK5HFKQXQJJHWUDJHQ'LHVJHVFKDKGXUFKHLQH DNWXDOLVLHUHQGH)RUWVFKUHLEXQJMHQHUQXUWHLOZHLVHYHUZLUNOLFKWHQ,QWHQWLRQGHU ÄOXWKHULVFKH>Q@5HIRUPDWLRQ>«@GLHLQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJEHJUQGHWHDOOJH PHLQHÃ%HUXIXQJµLQGLH9ROO]JHGHUEHVRQGHUHQVR]LDOHQ%HUXIH]XEHUVHW ]HQ³6HLQ*HZlKUVPDQQLVWKLHULQVEHVRQGHUH*HRUJ)ULHGULFK:LOKHOP+H JHOQDFKGHVVHQ9HUVWlQGQLVLP3URWHVWDQWLVPXVGLH%HZlKUXQJLQQHUKDOEGHU JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQDQGLH6WHOOHHLQHUPRQDVWLVFKZHOWORVHQ6RQ GHUPRUDOWULWW,QIROJHGHVVHQJLOWHWZDÄVWDWWGHV*HOEGHVGHU$UPXW>«@GLH 7lWLJNHLWGHV6HOEVWHUZHUEVGXUFK9HUVWDQGXQG)OHLXQGGLH5HFKWVFKDIIHQKHLW LQGLHVHP9HUNHKUXQG*HEUDXFKGHV9HUP|JHQVGLH6LWWOLFKNHLWLQGHUEUJHUOL FKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW³DOVÃ*RWWHVGLHQVWLP$OOWDJGHU:HOWµ 'RFKKDWLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQÄGLHQHXHYDQJHOLVFKH:HQGHWKHRORJLHGHQWHQ GHQ]LHOOHQ$XVVWLHJDXVGHU0RGHUQLVLHUXQJGHV3URWHVWDQWLVPXVGXUFKJHVHW]W³ XQGGDGXUFKGHVVHQJHJHQZlUWLJHÄ5HOHYDQ]XQG)XQNWLRQVNULVH³PLWYHUXU VDFKW'LHVHU$XVVWLHJEHJLQQWVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVPLWGHPSROHPLVFKHQ$EZHLV GHVQHXSURWHVWDQWLVFKIRNXVVLHUWHQ%HJULIIVGHU5HOLJLRQ GLHYRQ.DUO%DUWK XQWHU5FNJULIIDXIGLHUHOLJLRQVNULWLVFKH3URMHNWLRQVWKHVHJHUDGHZHJV]XUKlUH
9JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ :$*1(5 E± F ± ± :$*1(5 :DJQHUEH]LHKWVLFKGDPLWDXI6FKOHLHUPDFKHUV9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLP PXQJYRQ'RJPDWLNXQG)U|PPLJNHLWLQGHQIILQGHU*ODXEHQVOHKUH :$*1(5 E +(*(/ >@9JOGD]XXD:$*1(5 E :$*1(5 :$*1(5 E
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
WLVFKHQÄ$QJHOHJHQKHLWGHVJRWWORVHQ0HQVFKHQ³HUNOlUWZXUGH6RJHODQJWGLH J|WWOLFKH6HOEVWPLWWHLOXQJPLWWHOVHLQHVÄ6XEMHNWWDXVFK>V@>«@DQGLH6WHOOHGHV 0HQVFKHQ GHU DOV UHOLJL|VHV 6XEMHNW YRQ *RWW UHGHW³ =ZDU YHUGDQNW VLFK VROFKHV,QVLVWLHUHQDXIGHUVRXYHUlQHQ2IIHQEDUXQJ*RWWHVLP:RUW]XXQJXQVWHQ HLQHUDOVLOOXVLRQlUDEJHOHKQWHQ5HOLJLRQZLH:DJQHUYLHOIDFKEHWRQWÄHLQHP WULYLDOHQ'HQNIHKOHU³ RGHUÄHLQHPHUNHQQWQLVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ)HKOJULII³ZHLO DXFKÄGDVVRJHQDQQWH:RUW*RWWHV³QXUGDGXUFK]XJlQJOLFKLVWÄGDYRQGHP VHOEHQDXIPHQVFKOLFKH:HLVHJHUHGHWZLUG³'HQQRFKNRQQWHVLFKGLHVH3RVL WLRQLQZLUNPlFKWLJHU:HLVHEHKDXSWHQ:LFKWLJHUDEHULVWLKPHLQH]HQWUDOH .RQVHTXHQ]GLHVHUWKHRULHLQWHUQHQ8PVWHOOXQJYRQDOO]XPHQVFKOLFKHU5HOLJLRQ DXIJ|WWOLFKH2IIHQEDUXQJ (EHQVRZLHOHW]WHUH]XPSULPlUHQ*HJHQVWDQGGHU 7KHRORJLHZLUGLVWYRP0HQVFKHQQXUQRFKÄLQVHNXQGlUHUXQGDEJHOHLWHWHU :HLVH]XVSUHFKHQ³QlPOLFKXQWHUGHP*HVLFKWVSXQNWVHLQHVJOlXELJHQ*HKRU VDPVRGHU8QJHKRUVDPVJHJHQEHUGHP*RWWGHUVLFKLP:RUWDOV+HUURIIHQ EDUWKDW'DPLWEH]LHKWHUVLFKDXIGLHYRQ%DUWKLQQHUKDOEGHU.LUFKOLFKHQ 'RJPDWLNDXVJHIKUWH&KULVWRORJLHGHUHUVFKRQDP$QIDQJVHLQHVWKHRORJL VFKHQ6FKDIIHQVHLQHXPVWULWWHQH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQJHZLGPHWKDW 5FNNHKU]XP*HKRUVDP 'RUWZLUGGLH0HQVFKZHUGXQJ*RWWHVVRH[SOL]LHUWGDVVGLHVHUNUDIWVHLQHVVRX YHUlQÄIUHLH>Q@9HUIJHQ>V@³DOV6RKQDQGHU6WHOOHGHV0HQVFKHQ-HVXVÄVHLQ HLJHQHU3DUWQHU³LVWÄGHUGHU%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ]XP+HLOGHUZLUDOOH ZLGHUVSUHFKHQLQIUHLHP*HKRUVDPJHUHFKWZLUGXQGVRDXFKXQVJHQXJ³ :DJQHUVLHKWGDVVLFKGDULQDQGHXWHQGHÄ9HUKlOWQLVGHU+HUUVFKDIW*RWWHV]XP *HKRUVDPVHLQHV6RKQHV>«@GXUFKGLH/RJLNGHU*OHLFKRGHU3DUDOOHOVFKDOWXQJ JHUHJHOW³'HPQDFKNDQQLKUHLQ]LJHLQPHQVFKOLFKHV$QGHUVVHLQHQWVSUHFKHQ
%$57+ :$*1(5 E :$*1(5 E :$*1(5 E $D2 :$*1(5V %$57+ I'DVLVWIUHLOLFKQXUHLQHYHUNU]WH$QJDEH:LFKWLJLVWDEHU]XEHWR QHQGDVV*RWWEHL%DUWKRKQH9HUOXVWVHLQHU$OOPDFKWDQGHU6WHOOHGHV6RKQHV]XPVLFK JHKRUVDPHQ 0HQVFKHQ ZLUG ZHLO HU GDPLW YRQ HLQHUÄLQVHLQHP :HVHQ>«@EHJUQGHWHQ 0|JOLFKNHLW*HEUDXFKPDFKW³ DD2 9JOGD]X .5g7.( :$*1(5 E:DJQHUEH]LHKWVLFKKLHUDXIGLH]HQWUDOH7KHVHDXVGHUEHQDQQWHQ IUKHQ%DUWK'HXWXQJ 9JO '(56VII:DJQHUPDFKWGDULQ6WUXNWXUlTXLYDOHQ]HQ ]ZLVFKHQ%DUWVFKHU7KHRORJLHXQGIDVFKLVWLVFKHU,GHRORJLHDXV'LHVLVWQLFKWXQZLGHUVSUR FKHQJHEOLHEHQXQGHWZDGXUFK:ROI.U|WNHDOVÄ%DUWKVHLJHQH$XVIKUXQJHQLQV*HJHQWHLO YHUNHKUHQGH %HKDXSWXQJ³ EH]HLFKQHW ZRUGHQ YJO .5g7.( (EHUKDUG -QJHO KLQJHJHQKDWVLHRKQHZHLWHUHDUJXPHQWDWLYH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJDOVÄ6QGHZLGHUGHQJXWHQ *HVFKPDFN³EH]HLFKQHW -h1*(/ E
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
ÄGDVDXIVHLQHU>VLF@(LJHQVWlQGLJNHLW]XJXQVWHQVHLQHUJHKRUVDPHQ8QWHUZHU IXQJXQWHUGDV+HUUVHLQ*RWWHVYHU]LFKWHW³'LH)ROJHLVWHLQDV\PPHWULVFKHV 9HUKlOWQLVGDVPLWDOOGHQLP.DSLWHOKHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWHQ$SRULHQEHODVWHWLVW XQGLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQGHPFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQIXQGDPHQWDOZLGHU VSULFKW 'LHVH GLH $QHUNHQQXQJ PHQVFKOLFKHU )UHLKHLW YHUZHLJHUQGH +HUU VFKDIWVVWUXNWXUZLHGHUKROWVLFKVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVDXFKGDQQZHQQ%DUWKXQWHUGHU hEHUVFKULIWÄ-HVXV&KULVWXVGHUZDKUKDIWH=HXJH³GDUDXI]XVSUHFKHQNRPPW ZLHVLFKGDV9HUV|KQXQJVJHVFKHKHQGHP0HQVFKHQOHW]WOLFKHUVFKOLHHQVROO 'LH GDIU DXVVFKODJJHEHQGH NLUFKOLFKH (YDQJHOLXPVYHUNQGLJXQJ VWHKW LQ %DUWKV$XJHQQlPOLFKXQWHUHLQHUVWlQGLJHQ*HIDKU 'LH*HPHLQGHNDQQEHLGHU 9HUNQGLJXQJGHV(YDQJHOLXPVDQGHULKUYRUJHJHEHQHQ6DFKHYRUEHLUHGHQMD HLQÄDQGHUHV(YDQJHOLXP³EH]HXJHQZHQQVLHGLHÄ.RQVWDQ]³YHUNHQQWÄLQ GHUHVDOV:RUWLKUHVHLQHQ+HUUQ]XMHGHU=HLWHLQHVXQGGDVVHOEHLVW³'D]X NRPPWHVVR%DUWKEHLMHGHP9HUVXFKGDV(YDQJHOLXPÄGHQ(UIRUGHUQLVVHQGHU MHZHLOLJHQDOOJHPHLQHQJHLVWHVJHVFKLFKWOLFKHQXQGVRQVWLJHQ/DJHHQWVSUHFKHQG LQGLH6SUDFKHXQG%HJULIIOLFKNHLWLQGLH$QVFKDXXQJVXQG/HEHQVZHOWGLHVHU *HJHQZDUW]XEHUVHW]HQ³±ZDVVLFKDQGHQÄ9HUIlOVFKXQJHQGHV,QKDOWVGHV GHU*HPHLQGHDQYHUWUDXWHQ$XIWUDJVLQGHQJURHQ+lUHVLHQDOOHU=HLWHQ³HLQ GUXFNVYROOVWXGLHUHQOlVVW 'DPLWZLUGLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQHLQHhEHUVHW]XQJ GHUFKULVWOLFKHQ%RWVFKDIWLQVLFKYHUlQGHUQGH.RQWH[WHRGHUÄLQGLHVDFKOLFK ]HLWOLFKXQGVR]LDOEHGLQJWH6SUDFKHGHV$QGHUVVHLQV³LKUHU$GUHVVDWHQ]XP KlUHWLVFKHQ9HUJHKHQDQLKUHU6XEVWDQ]HUNOlUW'LHVDEHUVWHOOWIU:DJQHUQXU GLH.RQVHTXHQ]GHVYRUDXVJHVHW]WHQVRXYHUlQHQ+HUU6HLQV*RWWHVGDUGHVVHQ *HKRUVDPVIRUGHUXQJJDUNHLQHLJHQVWlQGLJHV$QGHUVVHLQ]XOlVVW$QDORJGD]X QlPOLFK NDQQ GLH FKULVWOLFKH *HPHLQGH QDFK %DUWK ÄEHU GLH GDV QLFKW FKULVWOLFKH0HQVFKHQYRONYRQLKUVHOEVWDOVGHPHUZlKOWHQXQGEHUXIHQGHQ9RON *RWWHVXQWHUVFKHLGHQGH*UHQ]HKLQDXV³DOOH0HQVFKHQLPPHUVFKRQRKQH1RW DOVÄ9RONGHUFKULVWLDQLGHVLJQDWL³DQVSUHFKHQ $XIJUXQGVHLQHU6LFKWGHVPRGHUQHQ6lNXODULVLHUXQJVSUR]HVVHVYHUPDJ:DJ QHULQGLHVHU+DOWXQJGLHGLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH8PZHOWDXVELQQHQWKHRORJLVFKHU E]ZNLUFKOLFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHXQPLWWHOEDUIUVLFKLQ%HVFKODJ]XQHKPHQN|Q QHQPHLQWQXUHLQH,PPXQLVLHUXQJVVWUDWHJLHHQWGHFNHQ1RFKVFKZHUHUDEHU ZLHJW GHU LKU ]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGH *RWWHVEHJULII GHU JHJHQ GLH )UHLKHLW GHV PHQVFKOLFKHQ6XEMHNWVDXVJHVSLHOWZLUGDQVWDWWDXIGHUHQ$QHUNHQQXQJDE]X]LH
:$*1(5 E 6RGLHhEHUVFKULIWGHULQ%$57+ HQWIDOWHWHQ3DUDJUDSKHQ9JO]XULP)ROJHQGHQ GDUJHVWHOOWHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ:DJQHUVPLWGLHVHP3XQNW :$*1(5 %$57+ $D2 I $D2 9JOGD]X DD2 II :$*1(5 I9JOGD]X'(56 F$QEHLGHQ6WHOOHQVLQGMHZHLOVGLUHNWH %H]JHDXIGLHVRHEHQ]LWLHUWHQ%DUWK6WHOOHQJHJHEHQ %$57+ 9JODXFK DD2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
OHQ6RUFNWVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVLP$EZHLVGHVQHXSURWHVWDQWLVFKHQ$XWRQRPLH LGHDOVÄGLHDOV+HUUVFKDIWDXVJHVDJWH)UHLKHLW³*RWWHVLQV=HQWUXPJHJHQEHU GHVVHQ*HJHQZDUWLPDOOHU]HLWXQGUlXPOLFKHQ%HGLQJWKHLWHQWOHGLJWHQ2IIHQ EDUXQJVZRUWHLQ]LJGHV*OlXELJHQÄ*HKRUVDPXQG%HNHQQWQLVJHIUDJW³VHLHQ 'LHVNRPPWQDFK:DJQHUV%HREDFKWXQJLQYHUVFKLHGHQHQUHDNWLRQlUHQ(UVFKHL QXQJHQ]XP$XVGUXFN 5HOLJLRQXQG7KHRORJLHZHUGHQZHLWHVWJHKHQGHQWGLIIH UHQ]LHUWXPGLHGRJPDWLVFKELEOLVFKH.RUUHNWKHLWGHV*ODXEHQVYROO]XJVGXUFK EHUXIVWKHRORJLVFKH.RQWUROOHDE]XVLFKHUQ 5HULWXDOLVLHUXQJVXQG5HVDNUDPHQWD OLVLHUXQJVYHUVXFKHGHJUDGLHUHQGLHVRQQWlJOLFKH3UHGLJW]XHLQHP5DQGJHVFKH KHQGHUHQYRUQHKPVWH$XIJDEHHVZDUÄGLH$XVVDJHQHLQHVVR]LRNXOWXUHOOXQG UDXP]HLWOLFKDEVWlQGLJHQ7H[WHVLQGLH(UIDKUXQJVKRUL]RQWHGHVJHJHQZlUWLJHQ 6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJV]XEHUVHW]HQ³ GLHH[HJHWLVFKH)RUVFKXQJGHJHQHULHUW ]XPÄ,QVWUXPHQWGHUWKHRORJLVFKHQ+\JLHQHLP,QWHUHVVHGHU5HLQKHLWGHV:RU WHV*RWWHV³GHVVHQVWHWVNRQWH[WXHOOH%HGLQJWKHLWKLVWRULVFKNULWLVFKDXI]XGH FNHQHLQVWLKUH(SRFKHQZLUNXQJDXVPDFKWH LQVJHVDPWZLUGGDVUHOLJL|VH6XE MHNWDXIHLQHQÄZHOWXQGVHOEVWORVH>Q@:RUWXQG7H[WJODXEH>Q@³UHGX]LHUWGHU NHLQHQ%H]XJ]XPÄSHUVRQDOXQGVR]LDOJHOHEWHQ$OOWDJ³DXIZHLVW$OOGLHVHLQ VHLQHQ $XJHQ GXUFK GLH :RUW*RWWHV7KHRORJLH DXVJHO|VWHQ LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ 9HUlQGHUXQJHQVLHKWHULP'LHQVWHLQHUUHLQVDFKRULHQWLHUWHQ%HVLW]VWDQGVZDK UXQJVWHKHQGLHRKQH5FNVLFKWDXIGLHVR]LRNXOWXUHOOHQ7UDQVIRUPDWLRQVSUR]HV VHGHU0RGHUQHHUIROJWXQGVRGHQ5FN]XJLQHLQHZHOWORVH*HPHLQVFKDIWDOV (PLJUDWLRQDXVGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWEHI|UGHUW 'LHVHPÄLQVHLQELQQHQNLUFKOLFKHV6HOEVWVHLQHLQJHKDXVWH>Q@3URWHVWDQWLVPXV³ DEHUZLOO:DJQHU]XU:DKUQHKPXQJGHUÄEUDFKOLHJHQGHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQVHLQHV 6HOEVWVHLQV³EULQJHQLQGHPHUIUHLQH)RUWVHW]XQJGHVÄQHXSURWHVWDQWLVFKLQ WHQGLHUWHQ3URMHNW>V@GHUhEHUVHW]XQJGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLWGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ 6XEMHNWV³SOlGLHUW'DEHLLVWHVLKPQLFKWYRUUDQJLJXPHLQNLUFKHQIOOHQGHV Ä0LVVLRQVNRQ]HSW³]XWXQVRQGHUQHVN|QQWHGDGXUFKHLQLQGHUPRGHUQHQ *HVHOOVFKDIWQHJDWLYHUZHLVHIHKOHQGHUVR]LDOHU2UW]XU7KHPDWLVLHUXQJGHUDOV EHGURKWHUVFKHLQHQGHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLKHLWEHVHW]WZHUGHQ'DIUDEHUPVVWH GHU$QHUNHQQXQJVJHKDOWGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQIRNXVVLHUWZHUGHQ
:$*1(5 E 9JO:$*1(5 EII)UGLH=LWDWH DD2 :$*1(5 E± 'LHVEHKDXSWHWPLW%OLFNDXI:DJQHU %(5*(5 ZDVLQVRIHUQVHLQ5HFKWKDW GDVV:DJQHUGLH.ULWLNDQ7KHRORJLHXQG.LUFKHPLWGHP=LHOYHUELQGHWFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VH .RPPXQLNDWLRQDOVÄ(LQODGXQJ]XULQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWUHIOH[LRQ³ HEG GHXWOLFKZHUGHQ]X ODVVHQ'LH,QWHQWLRQULFKWHWVLFKDEHUDXIGLH/|VXQJHLQHVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKGLDJQRVWL]LHUWHQ 3UREOHPVXQGGLHQWNHLQHPEORHQ6HOEVW]ZHFN
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
,Q]ZHLGHXWLJHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ $PELYDOHQ]HQGHVPRGHUQHQ )UHLKHLWVLGHDOV :DJQHUV9HUVWlQGQLVGHU0RGHUQHDOVHLQHVWLHIJUHLIHQGHQKLVWRULVFKHSRFKDOHQ (LQVFKQLWWVEHPLVVWVLFKZLHJHVHKHQ DQGHQÄVHLWGHU0LWWHGHV-DKU KXQGHUWV³EHREDFKWEDUHQ8PEUFKHQSROLWLVFKHU|NRQRPLVFKHUNXOWXUHOOHUXQG JHLVWLJHU$UWGLHÄVR]LDOJHVFKLFKWOLFKGXUFKGLHSROLWLVFKHQXQGLQGXVWULHOOHQ 5HYROXWLRQHQXQGNXOWXUXQGJHLVWHVJHVFKLFKWOLFKGXUFKGLH,GHHQGHUHUVWHQ XQG]ZHLWHQ$XINOlUXQJ³EHGLQJWVLQG-HGRFKEHOlVVWHUHVQLFKWEHLHLQHU EORHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJGHUGDPLWYHUEXQGHQHQ7UDQVIRUPDWLRQVYRUJlQJHYLHO PHKUEH]LHKWHUDXFKZHUWHQGH3RVLWLRQJHJHQEHUGHQDQJH]HLJWHQ9HUlQGHUXQ JHQ6HLQH'LDJQRVHGHFNWHLQHVLFKJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKQLHGHUVFKODJHQGH$PELYD OHQ]LPPRGHUQHQ)UHLKHLWVLGHDODXI $PELYDOHQWH0RGHUQH 6RLVWGLH0RGHUQHIU:DJQHUYRQXQEHVWUHLWEDUSRVLWLYHQ)RUWVFKULWWVLPSXOVHQ JHSUlJW (LQHUVHLWVKDEHQGLHÄZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQWHFKQLVFKHQXQGZLUWVFKDIW OLFKLQGXVWULHOOHQ5HYROXWLRQHQ]XU(UOHLFKWHUXQJXQG9HUEHVVHUXQJGHUDOOJH PHLQHQXQGLQGLYLGXHOOHQ/HEHQVXQG'DVHLQVEHZlOWLJXQJEHLJHWUDJHQ³,Q SROLWLVFKHU ZLH JHLVWLJNXOWXUHOOHU +LQVLFKW LVW DQGHUHUVHLWV HLQ )RUWVFKULWW LP )UHLKHLWVEHZXVVWVHLQ ]X YHU]HLFKQHQ 'LHVHU VFKOlJW VLFK LQVEHVRQGHUH GDULQ QLHGHUGDVVGLHHUVWPDOVDXVJHELOGHWHQ5HFKWVXQG9HUIDVVXQJVVWDDWHQQLFKWQXU ÄGHU(LQKDOWXQJIRUPDOHU5HFKWVXQG9HUIDKUHQVUHJHOQ³)ROJHOHLVWHQVRQGHUQ HEHQVRÄIUGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJVXEMHNWLYHU)UHLKHLWVUHFKWH³HLQWUHWHQ'DVGXUFK ZHFKVHOVHLWLJH)|UGHUXQJEHVWLPPWH1HEHQHLQDQGHUGHUEHLGHQDOVSURJUHVVLY EHXUWHLOWHQ(QWZLFNOXQJHQLVWDEHULQ:DJQHUV$XJHQPHKUXQGPHKU]XHLQHP 1HJDWLYIROJHQ]HLWLJHQGHQ*HJHQHLQDQGHUJHUDWHQGHPÄHLQVWHWLJ]XQHKPHQGHV %HZXWVHLQGHU=ZHLGHXWLJNHLW³ NRUUHVSRQGLHUW'LHVLOOXVWULHUWHUDQGHUUH GXNWLYHQ8PGHXWXQJGLHGHQ/HLWZRUWHQGHU)UDQ]|VLVFKHQ5HYROXWLRQ±)UHL KHLW*OHLFKKHLW%UGHUOLFKNHLW±PLWGHP$XINRPPHQGHVPRGHUQHQ,QGXVWULH NDSLWDOLVPXVVWLOOVFKZHLJHQG]XWHLOJHZRUGHQLVW,P=XJHGHVVHQQlPOLFKZLUG GHQ,GHDOHQGHUÄ)UHLKHLWXQG*OHLFKKHLWHLQ5LFKWXQJVVLQQ³YHUOLHKHQÄGXUFK GHQGLHÃ%UGHUOLFKNHLWµYRQYRUQKHUHLQDXIGHU6WUHFNHEOHLEW³(VVLQGGHP HQWVSUHFKHQG]ZHLZLGHUVWUHLWHQGH)UHLKHLWVXQGGDULQLQEHJULIIHQDXFK*OHLFK KHLWVSULQ]LSLHQGLHHULQGHQKLVWRULVFKHQ8PEUFKHQGHU0RGHUQH]XQRUPDWL YHU*HOWXQJJHODQJHQVLHKW9RQLKQHQZDUEHUHLWVPHKUIDFKGLH5HGH
:$*1(5F9JO]XULP)ROJHQGHQGDUJHVWHOOWHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJGHU0RGHUQH XQGLKUHU$PELYDOHQ]HQ :$*1(5 D I D± ± F ± :$*1(5F $D2 :$*1(5F :$*1(5 D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
'D LVW HLQHUVHLWV GLH VLFK LQIROJH GHU |NRQRPLVFKWHFKQLVFKHQ 5HYROXWLRQ GXUFKVHW]HQGH )UHLKHLW DOV ÄXQPLWWHOEDUH>@ 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ GLH DOV GLUHNWH 6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJVLQJXOlUHUXQGEHULQGLYLGXHOOHU6XEMHNWH 6\VWHPH >«@ DXVJHEWZLUG³ZDVOHW]WOLFKLPXQEUGHUOLFKHQ.DPSIDOOHUJHJHQDOOHUJLS IHOW6LHNRPPW:DJQHU]XIROJHYRUDOOHPLQHLQHUJHVWHLJHUWHQ(LJHQG\QDPLN GHU JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ )XQNWLRQVV\VWHPH ]XP $XVGUXFN GLH ÄGDV SHUVRQDOH 6HOEVWVHLQGHU,QGLYLGXHQLPPHUZLHGHUDOVEORHV0LWWHOYHUUHFKQHQXQGYHU EUDXFKHQ³'DULQVHW]WVLFKHLQÄDOOHVGXUFKGULQJHQGH>V@0XVWHUGHU=ZHFNUD WLRQDOLWlW³GXUFKGDVHLQ]LJDQV\VWHPLVFKHU6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJPLWWHOVWHFKQLVFK HIIL]LHQWHU=LHOYHUZLUNOLFKXQJGXUFKRSWLPDOH0LWWHOZDKOLQWHUHVVLHUWLVW'HULQ GHU7KHRORJLHIRUWOHEHQGHVHOEVWPlFKWLJVHOEVWlQGLJH*RWWILQGHWZLUNXQJVYROOH VR]LDOH(QWVSUHFKXQJHQLQ*HVWDOWGHU+HUUVFKDIWVIUHLKHLWYRUKHUUVFKHQGHU6\V WHPORJLNHQ,KUVWHKW±DQGHUHUVHLWV±GLHDP.ULWHULXPGHV=XVDPPHQEHVWHKHQ .|QQHQV YRQ LQGLYLGXHOOHU XQG DOOJHPHLQHU )UHLKHLW RULHQWLHUWH Ä)UHLKHLW DOV )RUPYHUPLWWHOWHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³DOV)UHLKHLWDXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQ QXQJJHJHQEHU$XIGHPLGHHOOHQ+LQWHUJUXQGGHU3KLORVRSKLHQ.DQWVXQG +HJHOVKDWVLHLQIROJHGHUUHYROXWLRQlUHQ9HUZLUNOLFKXQJYRQ0HQVFKHQXQG *UXQGUHFKWHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH5HDOLWlWHUODQJW+LHUILQGHWLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQ GLH PLW GHU 5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJ GHV *RWWHVJHGDQNHQV HLQKHUJHKHQGH $QHUNHQ QXQJVORJLNLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHQ$XVGUXFN $QJHVLFKWVGLHVHUZLGHUVSUHFKHQGHQ)UHLKHLWVEHJULIIHHUZHLVWVLFKGLHJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKH5HDOLWlWGHU0RGHUQHDOV]ZHLGHXWLJXQGKDOELHUWZDVIU:DJQHU HLQH%HVWlWLJXQJGHUÄYRQ$GRUQRXQG+RUNKHLPHUH[SOL]LWJHPDFKWH>Q@Ã'LD OHNWLNGHU$XINOlUXQJµ³GDUVWHOOW Ä'LHV\VWHPLVFKIXQNWLRQDOH5DWLRQDOLWlWGHU EURNUDWLVFKYHUZDOWHWHQXQG|NRQRPLVFKYHUZHUWHWHQ:HOWVHW]WLKUH6HOEVW HUKDOWXQJRKQH5FNVLFKWDXIGLH)UHLKHLWXQG6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJGHU,QGLYLGXHQ GXUFK³$XVGHUDPELYDOHQWHQ(UIDKUXQJGLHGDUDXVIUGLH,QGLYLGXHQUHVXO WLHUW VLHKWHUVFKOLHOLFKVLFKUHOLJL|VDUWLNXOLHUHQGH6HKQVFKWHHUZDFK VHQDQGLHYRQVHLWHQGHVSURWHVWDQWLVFKHQ&KULVWHQWXPVGXUFKhEHUVHW]XQJVDU EHLW]XP=ZHFNHHLQHU5HIOH[LRQGHVLKQHQ]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGHQ3UREOHPVDQJH NQSIWZHUGHQN|QQWH
:$*1(5 $D2 :$*1(5 :$*1(5 (UEH]LHKWVLFKDQGLHVHU6WHOOHDXIIROJHQGH3DVVDJHDXV.DQWV0H WDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQ Ä)UHLKHLW 8QDEKlQJLJNHLWYRQHLQHVDQGHUHQQ|WLJHQGHU:LOONU VRIHUQ VLHPLWMHGHVDQGHUHQ)UHLKHLWQDFKHLQHPDOOJHPHLQHQ*HVHW]]XVDPPHQEHVWHKHQNDQQLVW GLHVHVHLQ]LJHXUVSUQJOLFKHMHGHP0HQVFKHQNUDIWVHLQHU0HQVFKKHLW]XVWHKHQGH5HFKW³ DD2 :$*1(5F
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
$PELYDOHQWH,QGLYLGXDOLWlWVNXOWXU Ä.XOWXUKHXWHVFKOlJWDOOHVPLWbKQOLFKNHLW³ODXWHWGDV HUVWPDOVDXV JHVSURFKHQH8UWHLO0D[+RUNKHLPHUVXQG7KHRGRU:$GRUQRV(VULFKWHWVLFK JHJHQ GLH %HKDXSWXQJ LQ GHU NXOWXUHOOHQ 6SKlUH VHL QDFKGHP VLFK MHJOLFKH ÄYRUNDSLWDOLVWLVFKHQ5HVLGXHQ³DXIJHO|VWVRZLHÄGLHWHFKQLVFKHXQGVR]LDOH'LI IHUHQ]LHUXQJXQGGDV6SH]LDOLVWHQWXP³JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKGXUFKJHVHW]WKlWWHQQRFK HLQOHW]WHU5FN]XJVRUWGHV,QGLYLGXHOOHQDXV]XPDFKHQ:DVGLHEHLGHQNULWL VFKHQ7KHRUHWLNHUGHU0RGHUQHHWZDLQGHQILOPLVFKHQPXVLNDOLVFKHQRGHUOLWH UDULVFKHQ$UWHIDNWHQLKUHU*HJHQZDUWVHKHQVLQGYLHOPHKUVWDQGDUGLVLHUWHÄ9RU ELOGHUIUGLH0HQVFKHQGLHVLFKVHOEVW]XGHPPDFKHQVROOHQZR]XGDV6\VWHP VLHEULFKW³6LHVSUHFKHQGHVKDOEYRQHLQHUDOVEORHÄ$SRORJLHGHU*HVHOO VFKDIW³QDFKGHP0RWWRÄ9HUJQJWVHLQKHLW(LQYHUVWDQGHQVHLQ³ IXQJLHUHQGHQ Ä.XOWXULQGXVWULH³LQGHUVLFKGLHUHJUHVVLYHQ7HQGHQ]HQGHUÄ$XINOlUXQJDOV 0DVVHQEHWUXJ³IRUWVHW]HQ'DVDXINOlUHULVFKH3URMHNWHLQHUÄ%HIUHLXQJGHV 0HQVFKHQ DXV VHLQHU VHOEVWYHUVFKXOGHWHQ 8QPQGLJNHLW³ QlPOLFK KDW VLFK QDFK+RUNKHLPHUXQG$GRUQR]ZDUGHVVHQ(PDQ]LSDWLRQYRQZHOWOLFKHQXQG UHOLJL|VHQ$XWRULWlWHQVRZLHYRQGHU%HKHUUVFKXQJGXUFKHLQHXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUH 1DWXU YHUVFKULHEHQ (V LVW DEHU VFKOLHOLFK LQ GHQ SHUYHUWLHUWHQ 3RVLWLYLVPXV HLQHU GXUFKZHJ UDWLRQDOLVLHUEDUHQ :HOW HLQJHPQGHW LQ GLH GHU 0HQVFK DOV Ä6XEMHNW2EMHNWGHU5HSUHVVLRQ³VHOEVWHLQJHJOLHGHUWZLUGXP]XPHQWLQGLYL GXDOLVLHUWHQ0LWWHOGHVPLW)UHLKHLWYHUZHFKVHOWHQÄ%HWULHE>V@GHU6HOEVWHUKDO WXQJ³]XGHJHQHULHUHQ1LFKWQXUZHUGHQYRQLKPLPÄVWDKOKDUWHQ*HKlXVH³ GHUGXUFKHLQHEURNUDWLVFKNDSLWDOLVWLVFKH5HFKHQKDIWLJNHLWEHVWLPPWHQVR]LD OHQ6\VWHPHHLQ]LJÄJHQRUPWH>@9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQ³HUZDUWHWGHUHQÄ0DVWDE >«@GLH6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJGLHJHOXQJHQHRGHUPLOXQJHQH$QJOHLFKXQJDQGLH 2EMHNWLYLWlWVHLQHU)XQNWLRQ³GDUVWHOOW$XFKELHWHQGLH3URGXNWHGHU.XOWXULQ GXVWULH GHP 0HQVFKHQ QXU HLQH VFKDEORQLVLHUWH Ä3VHXGR,QGLYLGXDOLWlW³ ]XP 9HUNDXIDQXPLQ*HVWDOWHLQHVHLJHQWOLFKHUVHW]XQGDXVWDXVFKEDUHQ.RQVX PHQWHQLOOXVLRQlUHUZHLVHÄDOV3DUDGLHVGHQVHOEHQ$OOWDJ³]XHUOHEHQ
+25.+(,0(5$'25129JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJ +(7=(/ $D2 $D2 $D2 'LHEHLGHQ=LWDWHEH]LHKHQVLFKDXI7LWHOXQG8QWHUWLWHOGHV%H]XJVNDSLWHOVLQDD2 .$17 9JO+25.+(,0(5$'2512 II)UGLH=LWDWH DD2 9JO$D2IIII)UGLH=LWDWH DD2'LH5HGHYRPÄVWDKOKDU WHQ *HKlXVH³ VWDPPW IUHLOLFK YRQ 0D[ :HEHU GHVVHQ 5DWLRQDOLVLHUXQJVWKHVH +RUNKHL PHU$GRUQRDXIJUHLIHQ YJO+(7=(/I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:DJQHUNQSIWDQ+RUNKHLPHUVXQG$GRUQRV'LDJQRVHDQZHQQHUYRQHLQHU Ä=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWGHUPRGHUQHQ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWVNXOWXU³VSULFKW'DPLWLVWHLQH 3DWKRORJLHLP%OLFNGLHDXVGHU'LIIHUHQ]YRQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOL FKXQJVDQVSUFKHQXQGGHUHQVR]LDOHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJVFKDQFHQUHVXOWLHUW(UVWHUH HUVFKHLQHQLQVEHVRQGHUHGXUFKMHQHSROLWLVFKUHFKWOLFKH'XUFKVHW]XQJYRQ0HQ VFKHQXQG*UXQGUHFKWHQLQGHU0RGHUQHOHJLWLPLHUWGLHHVGHQ(LQ]HOQHQJDUDQ WLHUWÄDOVIUHLHXQGDXWRQRPHVHOEVWEHVWLPPHQGHXQGVHOEVW]ZHFNOLFKH3HUVRQHQ DQHUNDQQW]XVHLQ³'LHVLFKDXVGLHVHP$QHUNDQQWVHLQVSHLVHQGHQLQGLYLGXHO OHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHSUDOOHQMHGRFKDQGHQ]ZHFNUDWLRQDOHQ5RO OHQHUZDUWXQJHQGHUVR]LDOHQ)XQNWLRQVV\VWHPH±LQVEHVRQGHUHYRQ:LUWVFKDIW XQG%URNUDWLH±DE6LHZHUGHQGHVKDOELQGLHREMHNWLYH,QGLYLGXDOLWlWVNXOWXU HLQHUYLHOJHVWDOWLJHQ)UHL]HLW8UODXEVXQG(UOHEQLVZHOWDXVJHODJHUWRKQHGD PLWHLQHQYRQGHQ|NRQRPLVFKEURNUDWLVFKHQ0HFKDQLVPHQDEJHWUHQQWHQJH VHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ$XHQEHUHLFK]XEHWUHWHQ9LHOPHKUWUHIIHQGLH,QGLYLGXHQKLHU DXI MHQHQ YRQ +RUNKHLPHU XQG $GRUQR KHUDXVJHVWHOOWHQ NXOWXULQGXVWULHOOHQ .RPSOH[GHU:DJQHU]XIROJHDXFKQRFKGLHOHW]WHQ1LVFKHQGHV3ULYDWOHEHQV ÄGXUFK9HUPDUNWXQJVPHFKDQLVPHQHEHQVR>«@ZLHGXUFK7HQGHQ]HQGHU9HU UHFKWOLFKXQJXQG%URNUDWLVLHUXQJ³GRPLQLHUWVHLQOlVVW 'LHVIKUW]XGHU LKUHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 8QYHUZHFKVHOEDUNHLW ZLGHUVSUHFKHQGHQ (UIDKUXQJ ÄPLW MHGHPDQGHUHQ,QGLYLGXXPLKUHDOOJHPHLQH$XVWDXVFKXQG(UVHW]EDUNHLW³]X WHLOHQLQGHPVLHDXFKKLHUÄDOV1XPPHUQXQG)lOOHYHUZDOWHWXQGDOV]DKOXQJV IlKLJH.RQVXPHQWHQYHUPDUNWHWXQGYHUZHUWHW³ZHUGHQ'DVVGHPQDFKDXV GHQNXOWXUHOODUWLNXOLHUWHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHQGHU,QGLYLGXHQ(U ZDUWXQJVEHUVFKVVHKHUYRUJHKHQGLHRELKUHU*HJHQOlXILJNHLW]XGHQDOOHLQGHU HLJHQHQ 6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJ GLHQHQGHQ VR]LDOHQ 6\VWHPORJLNHQ XQHUIOOW EOHLEHQ PVVHQPDUNLHUWGHQGLHVEH]JOLFKGXUFK:DJQHUQDPKDIWJHPDFKWHQ=ZHLGHX WLJNHLWVFKDUDNWHU :LHHUPLWNULWLVFKHP5HNXUVDXI/XKPDQQYRUEULQJWOLHHVLFKGLHVH$PEL YDOHQ]VRDXIO|VHQGDVVPDQÄGLHQLFKWV\VWHPLVFKLQWHJULHUEDUHIUHLH6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJGHU,QGLYLGXHQ]XP9RUXUWHLOHLQHVDOWHXURSlLVFKHQ7UDGLWLRQVUHOLNWV HUNOlUW³XPÄGLHV\VWHPLVFKH6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJDXIGLH,QGLYLGXHQEUXFKORV³DXV ]XGHKQHQXQGGHUHQJHJHQOlXILJH0RWLYHVRJHVHKHQIULOOHJLWLP]XHUNOlUHQ 'RFKYHUVWXPPHQGLHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLKHLWVHUZDUWXQJHQE]Z$QHUNHQQXQJV DQVSUFKHDQJHVLFKWVGHULKQHQJHJHQEHURKQHKLQUFNVLFKWVORVHQJHVHOOVFKDIW OLFKHQ0HFKDQLVPHQQLFKW$QLKQHQZLUGÄYLHOPHKUNRQWUDIDNWLVFK³GDGXUFK 'LHVHU =XVDPPHQKDQJ ZLUG XD DXVGUFNOLFK JHPDFKW LQ :$*1(5 D II E 9JO]X:DJQHUV'LDJQRVHHLQHU=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWRGHU$PELYDOHQ]GHUPRGHUQHQ ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWVNXOWXUGLHLP)ROJHQGHQHQWIDOWHWZLUGLQVJHVDPW :$*1(5 ± D± ±± 9JODXFK'(56 ± :$*1(5 (EG (EG :$*1(5F9JO'(56 DI
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
IHVWJHKDOWHQÄGDVLHYHUODJHUWZHUGHQ³ ±ZDVVLFK:DJQHU]XIROJHLQVEHVRQ GHUHLQHLQHUVHLWGHP$QIDQJGHU HU-DKUHYLHOIlOWLJEHREDFKWHWHQÃ:LHGHU NHKUGHU5HOLJLRQµZLGHUVSLHJHOW$OVJOHLFKVDPUHOLJL|VSURGXNWLYHUZHLVW VLFK KLHU MHQH ÄLPPDQHQWH 7UDQV]HQGHQ]³ GLH :DJQHU VR]LDOHQ $QHUNHQ QXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ]XVFKUHLEW'DVVGLHVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPHGHUHQV\PPHWULVFKHU :HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLWZLGHUVSUHFKHQLQGHPVLHGDVIUHLH6HOEVWVHLQGHU,QGLYLGXHQ ]XJXQVWHQLKUHUHLJHQHQ6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJPLVVDFKWHQVHW]W(UZDUWXQJVEHU VFKVVHIUHL'LHVHEHUVFKUHLWHQGLHJHJHQZlUWLJH:LUNOLFKNHLWDXIHLQP|JOL FKHV$QGHUVVHLQKLQLQGHPGLHV\PPHWULVFKH:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLWYRQ$QHUNHQ QXQJGHUGDV3UlGLNDWÃJ|WWOLFKµ]XNRPPWUHDOLVLHUWZlUH'DIUGDVVHEHQGDULQ GLHNLUFKOLFKWKHRORJLVFKDXV]XVFK|SIHQGH*HJHQZDUWVUHOHYDQ]GHV&KULVWHQ WXPVEHVWHKWVSUHFKHQLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQDXFKGLHXQWHUGHUhEHUVFKULIWÃ:LH GHUNHKUGHU5HOLJLRQµYHUVDPPHOWHQ3KlQRPHQH ,QNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ6SKlUHQ±0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU FKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQ 0LWGHULQGHQ HU-DKUHQDXIJHNRPPHQHQ5HGHYRQHLQHUÃ:LHGHUNHKUGHU 5HOLJLRQµJHKWELVKHXWHGLH.ULWLNDQJHJHQWHLOLJHQYRUDOOHPDQGHQ6lNXODUL VLHUXQJVEHJULIIJHNQSIWHQ(UZDUWXQJHQKLQVLFKWOLFKLKUHU9LWDOLWlWHLQKHU )ROJWPDQ:DJQHUVGLHVEH]JOLFKVNHSWLVFKHU6LFKWVFKHLQWGLHVR]LDOH6LWXLH UXQJGHUVHLQHU]HLWGDPLWDQJHVSURFKHQHQ3KlQRPHQHMHGRFKGHQ6lNXODULVLH UXQJVEHIXQGHKHU]XEHVWlWLJHQ'HUHQ6SDQQZHLWHUHLFKWYRQGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6LQQXQG*DQ]KHLWVVXFKHELV]XU0DJLHXQG]XP6FKDPDQHQWXPYRQHPRWLR QDOHQXQGN|USHUQDKHQ*HERUJHQKHLWVVHKQVFKWHQELV]X|VWOLFKHQ0HGLWDWLRQV WHFKQLNHQXQG5HLQNDUQDWLRQVYRUVWHOOXQJHQYRQVHNWLHUHULVFKHQ*UXSSHQELOGXQ JHQELV]XHUQHXHUWHQ)XQGDPHQWDOLVPHQWUDGLWLRQHOOHU5HOLJLRQHQ 'RFKVRYLHOIlOWLJGLHVH3KlQRPHQHLQHUÃQHXHQ5HOLJLRVLWlWµDXFKVHLQP| JHQ LKUH5HVRQDQ]LQGHQVlNXODULVLHUWHQ7HLOV\VWHPHQGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWOLHJWLQ :DJQHUV$XJHQHLQ]LJGDULQGDVVVLHZLHGHUXPDOVNXOWXULQGXVWULHOOYHUZHUWEDUH 0LWWHO IXQJLHUHQ $OOH GDUEHU KLQDXVJHKHQGHQ LQGLYLGXHOOHQ Ä0RWLYH>@ XQG ,QWHUHVVHQ³ZHUGHQÄYRQGHQ]ZHFNUDWLRQDOHQ0HFKDQLVPHQDOVQLFKWYHUZHUWED UH6FKODFNHQGHV,UUDWLRQDOHQ]XUFNJHODVVHQ³ZDVGHPSULYDWLVLHUWHQ&KDUDN WHUPRGHUQHU5HOLJLRQ$XVGUXFNYHUOHLKW,QVRIHUQVWHOOHQGLHDQJHVSURFKHQHQ ÄUHOLJL|VHQ6HKQVFKWHXQG1HXEHOHEXQJHQ³IU:DJQHUQLFKWHWZD$Q]HLFKHQ HLQHU ÄhEHUZLQGXQJ GHUDOOJHJHQZlUWLJHQ =ZHFNUDWLRQDOLWlW VRQGHUQ JHUDGH
:$*1(5 9JODXFK DD2 (EG9JODD2XQGDXFKVFKRQ'(56 9JO]XGLHVHP0RWLY :$*1(5 P± 9JOGD]XGLH%HLWUlJHLQ2(/0h//(5%$80*$571(5 )UGLH*HJHQZDUWLVW HWZDDQGLH3XEOLNDWLRQHQ)ULHGULFK:LOKHOP*UDIV]XHULQQHUQ9JO]X:DJQHUV'HXWXQJ GLHVHU(QWZLFNOXQJ :$*1(5 ± D± ± :$*1(5 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$XVGUXFN XQG 5HIOH[YRQGHUHQXQJHEURFKHQHU:LUNVDPNHLW³GDU-HGRFK DUWLNXOLHUHQVLHGLHVH:LUNVDPNHLWLP0RGXVHLQHUNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQÄ+RIIQXQJ DXIHLQQLFKW]ZHFNUDWLRQDOLVLHUWHV$QGHUVVHLQ³ (VVLQGVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVMHQHDXVGHU=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWGHUPRGHUQHQ,QGLYLGXD OLWlWVNXOWXU KHUYRUJHKHQGHQ (UZDUWXQJVEHUVFKVVH GLH KLHU HLQHQ 9HUODJH UXQJVSXQNWILQGHQ'LHYLHOIlOWLJHQ3UDNWLNHQUHOLJL|VWUDGLWLRQHOOHQXQGRGHU V\QNUHWLVWLVFKHQ8UVSUXQJVHUVFKHLQHQLKPPLW.DUO0DU[JHVSURFKHQHEHQVR DOV6SUDFKURKUGHV(OHQGVHQWWlXVFKWHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHZLHGHV 3URWHVWV JHJHQ GHQ GDKLQWHUVWHKHQGHQ VR]LDOHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVPDQJHO 'HU SULYDWLVLHUWH&KDUDNWHUPRGHUQHU5HOLJLRQGHQ:DJQHU]XGHUHQ 6SH]LILNXP JHJHQEHUGHQDXHUUHOLJL|VHQ7HLOV\VWHPHQHUNOlUWJHZLQQWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHU JUXQG±QLFKWRKQH6SDQQXQJHQZLHJHVDJW]XUVWDUNHQ6lNXODULVLHUXQJVWKHVH± JHVDPWJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH5HOHYDQ] *HKWHVLQGHUSULYDWLVLHUWHQ5HOLJLRQXPÄGDV,QGLYLGXXPDOVVROFKHV>«@ HLQVFKOLHOLFKVHLQHULKP]XUHFKHQEDUHQ0RWLYH%HGUIQLVVHXQG,QWHUHVVHQ³ GLHDEHULPPHUDXFKÄYRQ(UZDUWXQJHQXQG,QIRUPDWLRQHQGHUVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPH ]XPDOGHU:LUWVFKDIWXQG3ROLWLN³EHGLQJWVLQGELHWHWVLHVLFKDQGDVNRQ IOLNWKDIWH9HUKlOWQLVEHLGHU'DVHLQVDVSHNWH]XWKHPDWLVLHUHQ'LH5HOLJLRQHU VFKHLQWGDQQÄDOVOHEHQVZHOWOLFKXQGVR]LRNXOWXUHOOEHGLQJWHU2UWGHU5HIOH[LRQ GHV9HUKlOWQLVVHVYRQ,QGLYLGXXPXQG*HVHOOVFKDIW³DQGHPGLHÄDXIJUXQGGHU EHUGHKQWHQ0HFKDQLVPHQGHUVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPH QLFKWUHDOLVLHUEDUHQ(UZDU WXQJVEHUVFKVVHGHUPRGHUQHQ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWVNXOWXU%HDUEHLWXQJILQGHQN|Q QHQ (LQVFKUlQNHQGEHPHUNW:DJQHUDEHULQ5LFKWXQJGHULQLKUHPSOXUDOHQ&KD UDNWHU GLIIXV EOHLEHQGHQ ÃZLHGHUJHNHKUWHQ 5HOLJLRQµ GDVV GDEHL ZHGHU HLQHU RSLDWLVFKHQ9HUWU|VWXQJHQWWlXVFKWHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHQRFKHL QHPUHYROXWLRQlUÄGLUHNWHQ(LQJULII>@LQGLH$XWRQRPLHVR]LDOHU6\VWHPH³GDV :RUWJHUHGHWZHUGHQVROOWHÄ9LHOPHKUYHUEOHLEWDXFKGDVLPPDQHQWH7UDQV]HQ GLHUHQ³GHVDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVHLQHU)UHLKHLWDXVJHULFKWHWHQUHOLJL|VHQ%H ZXVVWVHLQVÄLQQHUKDOEGHU,PPDQHQ]VR]LDOHU=ZHFNVHW]XQJHQXQGLKUHUOHEHQV GLHQOLFKHQXQGOHEHQVHUKDOWHQGHQ)XQNWLRQ³,KUNDQQHVHEHQVRZHQLJHQWULQ QHQZLHHVVLH]XHQWEHKUHQYHUPDJ
$D2 (EG :DJQHUEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLDXI.DUO0DU[µ6LFKWHLQHVHEHQVRNRPSHQVDWRULVFKHQZLH JHVHOOVFKDIWVNULWLVFKHQ&KDUDNWHUVYRQ5HOLJLRQ Ä'DVUHOLJL|VH(OHQGLVWLQHLQHPGHU$XV GUXFN GHV ZLUNOLFKHQ (OHQGHV XQG LQ HLQHP GLH 3URWHVWDWLRQ JHJHQ GDV ZLUNOLFKH (OHQG³ 0$5; :$*1(5 (EG :$*1(5 E :$*1(5P9JOIUGLHIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ DD2±
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
'RFKVRVHKUÄGLHDXILKU6XEMHNW GDVUHOLJL|VH%HZXWVHLQ]HQWULHUWH5HOLJL RQ>«@GLH1RWZHQGLJNHLWGHUOHEHQVHUKDOWHQGHQ=ZHFNVHW]XQJHQ³DXFKLP $XJHEHKlOWVRVHKUKlOWVLHDXFKGLH'LIIHUHQ]GLHVHVLKUHV6XEMHNWHVJHJHQEHU MHGZHGHUVR]LDOHQ%HVWLPPWKHLWIHVW'LHVWXWVLHÄLP,QWHUHVVHGHU.RQVWLWXWLRQ XQGGHU(UKDOWXQJVHOEVW]ZHFNKDIWIUHLHU3HUVRQDOLWlW³GXUFK7UDQV]HQGLHUXQJ GHUGLHVHLPPHUZLHGHUQLFKWDQHUNHQQHQGHQVRQGHUQYHU]ZHFNHQGHQJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKHQ)XQNWLRQVEHUHLFKH=LHOWGLHFKULVWOLFKH5HOLJLRQGDPLWDXIGLHÄDOO VHLWLJH>@%LOGXQJHLQHVVR]LDOHQ)UHLKHLWVEHZXWVHLQV³LVWIU:DJQHUMHGZH GH(LQVHLWLJNHLW]XYHUPHLGHQ'DVEHGHXWHW :LHVLFKÄGLH)UHLKHLWSHUVRQDOHQ 6HOEVWVHLQVQXUDXIGHP8PZHJEHUGDVVR]LDOH$QGHUVVHLQUHDOLVLHUHQ³OlVVW NDQQÄDXFKGDVVR]LDOH6HOEVWVHLQVHLQHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]QXULQVHLQHU$XIVFKOLH EDUNHLWIUGLH%HODQJHGHVSHUVRQDOHQ$QGHUVVHLQVQDFKNRPPHQ³ 'LHH[WUHPHQ$OWHUQDWLYHQ±NRPSHQVDWRULVFKH9HUWU|VWXQJRGHUUHYROXWLRQl UHU8PVWXU]±OHLVWHWHQKLQJHJHQQXUHLQHU)RUWVHW]XQJGHU]XP*UXQGEHOGHU *HVDPWVLWXDWLRQHUNOlUWHQXQPLWWHOEDUHQ6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJE]ZEHVWLPPXQJYRQ LQGLYLGXHOOHUE]ZJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU6HLWHKHU9RUVFKXE$QGHUHQ6FKHLWHUQ]X HULQQHUQDEHULVWDXV:DJQHUV6LFKWJHUDGHGDV=LHOGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HGHYRP PHQVFKJHZRUGHQHQXQGJHVWRUEHQHQ*RWWGLHLP8PNHKUVFKOXVVMHQHÃJ|WWOL FKHµ$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNDOVXQKLQWHUJHKEDUHQ5DKPHQMHGZHGHUIUHLHQ6HOEVW HQWIDOWXQJHUVFKOLHW'LH.ULWLNMHJOLFKHU$EVROXWKHLWVDQVSUFKH±LQNOXVLYHGHU HLJHQHQ±JHKWGDEHL+DQGLQ+DQGPLWGHU]XPLQGHVWDQYLVLHUWHQ.RUUHNWXU DV\PPHWULVFKHU9HUKlOWQLVVH]XJXQVWHQHLQHU*OHLFK*OWLJNHLWYRQLQGLYLGXHO OHP6HOEVWXQGVR]LDOHP$QGHUVVHLQYRQ,QGLYLGXHOO%HVRQGHUHPXQG*HVHOO VFKDIWOLFK$OOJHPHLQHP$XIGLHÄYRQ)DOO]X)DOO³XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKDN]HQ WXLHUWH'LIIHUHQ]HUIDKUXQJKLQGDVVVLFK)UHLKHLWVDQVSUFKHXQGGHUHQ5HDOLVLH UXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQ DOV QLFKW SDVVIlKLJ HUZHLVHQ KDW MHGH FKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VH .RPPXQLNDWLRQLKUH$XVVDJHQ]XEH]LHKHQ'XUFKVROFKHhEHUVHW]XQJHQVROOHQ HEHQVRGHPOHLGYROOHQ$XVGUXFNGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKZDOWHQGHQÄ$EKlQJLJNHL WHQZLHGH>P@P|JOLFKH>Q@3URWHVWJHJHQVLH³0LWWHODQGLH+DQGJHJHEHQ ZHUGHQ±RKQHGHUHQHQGJOWLJH%HVHLWLJXQJ]XEHVFKZ|UHQDEHULP%HZXVV WVHLQLKUHUSULQ]LSLHOOHQ9HUlQGHUEDUNHLW:DJQHU]LHOWVRZRKOGDUDXIGHQÄ(QW GLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJVWHQGHQ]HQ³VR]LDOHU6\VWHPHHQWJHJHQ]XZLUNHQDOVDXFKÄGHQ LQGLYLGXHOOHQ(QWWlXVFKXQJHQ³$UWLNXODWLRQVP|JOLFKNHLWHQ]XHU|IIQHQÄGLHDXV
$D2 $D2 $D2 (EG :$*1(5 E'DPLWVROODQJH]HLJWZHUGHQGDVVGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ,QGLYLGXXP XQG*HVHOOVFKDIWQLFKWÄVWDWLVFKIL[LHUW³ HEG LVWVRQGHUQVLWXDWLRQVJHEXQGHQE]ZWHLOV\V WHPVSH]LILVFKXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH)RUPHQDQQHKPHQNDQQ :$*1(5
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
QLFKWUHDOLVLHUEDUHQZHLOEHUVWHLJHUWHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHQUHVXO WLHUHQN|QQHQ³ )UGLHVH$XIJDEHHPSILHKOWVLFKGDV SURWHVWDQWLVFKH &KULVWHQWXPEHVRQ GHUVZHLOGLHKLHULQIUDJHVWHKHQGHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLKHLWVUHFKWHLQ:DJQHUV $XJHQ±XQEHVFKDGHW]HLWZHLOLJHUKLVWRULVFKHU*HJQHUVFKDIWHQ±ÄDOVREMHNWLYH 9HUZLUNOLFKXQJGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLW³ EHJULIIHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ (LQH ÄVRYHUVWDQGHQH5HOLJLRQ³ZHLVLFKDXVGUFNOLFKÄGHP3URMHNWGHU0RGHUQH YHUSIOLFKWHW³GDVLQÄGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ,GHHGHU)UHLKHLW³DXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQ QXQJ VHLQ QRUPDWLYHV =HQWUXP KDW 7UHWHQ DEHU LP =XJH GHU 5HDOLVLHUXQJ GLHVHV3URMHNWHVLPPHUZLHGHUJHJHQOlXILJH(QWZLFNOXQJHQDXIPDQJHOWHVGHP &KULVWHQWXPQLFKWDQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQVHLQ3RWHQ]LDODXV]XVSLHOHQ'DIUDEHUVLQG Ä>G@LHELEOLVFKXQGGRJPDWLVFKWKHRORJLVFKHQ*HKDOWHVR]XUHNRQVWUXLHUHQGD VLHGHQ7HVWLKUHUhEHUVHW]EDUNHLWLQ%HODQJHGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQGKSHUVRQDO XQGVR]LDORULHQWLHUWHQ/HEHQVIKUXQJEHVWHKHQ³ :LHGLHVHhEHUVHW]XQJEHL:DJQHUYRQVWDWWHQJHKWVROOQXQDQDXVJHZlKOWHQ %HLVSLHOHQ]XU6SUDFKHNRPPHQ'DEHLZHUGHQDXFKGLH*UHQ]HQVHLQHVDXIGLH ]ZLQJHQGH(LQVLFKWGHVYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH*HVROOWHQDOO]XVHKUNDSUL]LHUWHQ5H OLJLRQVYHUVWlQGQLVVHVYRU$XJHQWUHWHQ
hEHUVHW]XQJHQ *|WWOLFKHXQGVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJ :DJQHUVWKHRORJLVFKHVhEHUVHW]XQJVSURJUDPP]LHOWDXIGLHÄ5HDOLVLHUXQJGHU JDQ]HQFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLW³XPGDGXUFKOHW]WOLFKÄGLHDXIGHU6WUHFNHJHEOLH EHQHDQGHUH+lOIWHGHUKDOELHUWHQ0RGHUQHQHX]XEHOHEHQ³ 'LHVHV9RUKDEHQ YHUPDJQlPOLFKVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVQXU]XJHOLQJHQZHQQGLHJOHLFKVDPÃDQGHQ +LPPHOYHUVFKOHXGHUWHQ6FKlW]Hµ GHV&KULVWHQWXPVLQGLHVR]LRNXOWXUHOOHQ =XVDPPHQKlQJHGHUPRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWKHUDEJHKROWZHUGHQZDVVLHDEHU GLHVVHLWVLKUHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQNLUFKOLFKWKHRORJLVFKHQ9HUEUlPXQJDXFKLPSOL ]LHUHQÄ*HKDOWHDQGHQHQ,QGLYLGXHQLQWHUHVVLHUWVHLQN|QQHQ³HUZDFKVHQVR JHVHKHQNHLQHUÄGRJPDWLVFKQRUPDWLYH>Q@$XVOHJXQJGHV&KULVWHQWXPV³]XP =ZHFNH GHU %HI|UGHUXQJ ÄHLQHV UHOLJL|VHQ 9LUWXRVHQWXPV³ VRQGHUQ PVVHQ
:$*1(5 :$*1(5F 9JO]XGLHVHU7KHVHQlKHU :$*1(5 E I ± :$*1(5 $D2 :$*1(5F 9JO+(*(/ Ä$XHUIUKHUHQ9HUVXFKHQEOLHEHVXQVHUHQ7DJHQYRU]JOLFK DXIEHKDOWHQGLH6FKlW]HGLHDQGHQ+LPPHOYHUVFKOHXGHUWZRUGHQVLQGDOV(LJHQWXPGHU 0HQVFKHQZHQLJVWHQVLQGHU7KHRULH]XYLQGLFLHUHQDEHUZHOFKHV=HLWDOWHUZLUGGLH.UDIW KDEHQGLHVHV5HFKWJHOWHQG]XPDFKHQXPVLFKLQGHQ%HVLW]]XVHW]HQ"³
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
ÄUHFKWOLFKXQGPRUDOLVFKYHUDOOJHPHLQHUEDU>@³XQGSUDNWLVFKUHDOLVLHUEDUVHLQ 9RQGLHVHPHWKLVFKHQ)RNXV]HLJWVLFK:DJQHUV)DVVXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV QLFKWQXULQLKUHUUDGLNDOLVLHUWHQ9HUVLRQJHOHLWHW'LHPLWGHU5HGHYRQ*RWW HLQKHUJHKHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNVWHOOWIULKQGDV+HU]VWFNGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQGDU6LHHQWKlOWZHQQVLHDP2UWHGHULQVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQYHUZL FNHOWHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ/HEHQVIKUXQJQDPKDIWJHPDFKWZLUGHLQHXQEHVWUHLWEDUH $NWXDOLWlW6LHYHUPDJGDQQÄGHP*HJHQZDUWVEHZXWVHLQGHU,QGLYLGXHQ³]XU 7UDQV]HQGLHUXQJGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKÄIL[LHUWH>Q@'LIIHUHQ]³]ZLVFKHQLQGLYL GXHOOHQÄ(UZDUWXQJVEHUVFKVVHQ³XQGÄEHUGHKQWHQV\VWHPLVFKVR]LDOHQ0H FKDQLVPHQ³ GLHQOLFKVHLQ Ä(LQPHUNZUGLJHU.RQWUDVW³OlVVWVLFKPLW-|UJ'LHUNHQGDULQHQWGHFNHQ ÄGDVV:DJQHUGHQ$N]HQWDXIGLHLQGLYLGXHOOSUDNWL]LHUWH5HOLJLRQXQGLKUH6R ]LDOGLPHQVLRQHQOHJWDEHUGHUHQ$UWLNXODWLRQVXQG/HEHQVIRUPHQNDXPWKHPD WLVLHUW³ (VEOHLEWPLWKLQXQGHXWOLFKZLHGDVWKHRUHWLVFKDOVEHUVHW]EDUDXV JHZLHVHQH &KULVWHQWXP VLFK SUDNWLVFK LQ GLH 'DVHLQVYROO]JH GHV (LQ]HOQHQ EHUVHW]HQODVVHQVROO(LQH$XVQDKPHDEHUELOGHW]%PDQFKKRFKVFKlW]HQGHV :RUW :DJQHUV ]XU JRWWHVGLHQVWOLFKHQ 3UHGLJW XQG LKUHU P|JOLFKHQ :LUNXQJ 8QNODUEOHLEWZHLWHUKLQ ZLH:DJQHUGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJVFKDQFHQGHUFKULVWOLFK NRPPXQL]LHUWHQ)UHLKHLWVLGHHOHW]WHQ(QGHVHLQVFKlW]W,VWGHU*RWWHVJHGDQNH QXUHLQ3ODW]KDOWHUIUGHUHQQRFKQLFKWHUUHLFKWHDEHUHUUHLFKEDUH$OOJHJHQZDUW RGHUUHFKQHW:DJQHUPLWHLQHUEOHLEHQGHQ'LIIHUHQ]YRQ$QVSUXFKXQG:LUN OLFKNHLWGLHP|JOLFKHUZHLVHVRJDUHLJHQV]XZROOHQLVW"Ä>8@QGVHL¶VDXFKNRQW UDIDNWLVFK³ IRUPXOLHUW:DJQHUELVZHLOHQZHQQHVXP:LGULJNHLWHQLP5HDO ZHUGHQGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNJHKW'DVVVLFKGLHLPPDQHQWH7UDQV ]HQGHQ]YRQVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ±GKLKUHUHOLJL|VH'LPHQVLRQ±DXFKGRUW QLHGHUVFKOlJWZRPDQHQWJHJHQLKUHUIDNWLVFKHQ9HUIDVVWKHLWDP$QVSUXFKDXI $QHUNHQQXQJGHVMHHLJHQHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLVHLQVIHVWKlOWZLUGMHGRFKVR]XP QRWZHQGLJHQhEHOHUNOlUW6WDWWGHVVHQOLHJW:DJQHUV$N]HQW]XPLQGHVWWHQGHQ ]LHOODXIGHPDXVFKULVWOLFKHU6LFKW*HVROOWHQXQGGHVVHQDOOJHPHLQHUZLHLQGL YLGXHOOHU5HDOLVLHUXQJÄ'LHYROOHQGHWH3UlVHQ]³GHUÄSHUVRQDOH>Q@XQGVR]LD OH>Q@+DQGOXQJVSUD[LVUH]LSURNHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³KlQJWQlPOLFKDXVVHLQHU6LFKW LP*UXQGHQXUQRFKÄYRQGHU%HUHLWVFKDIWDE³GDVVDOOHXQGMHGHUÄGHQ6DW] SUDNWLVFK>«@EHIROJHQ Ã*HKKLQXQGWXGHVJOHLFKHQµ³ $QJHVLFKWVGHUKH UDXVJHDUEHLWHWHQ$V\PPHWULHQXQG6SDQQXQJHQGXUFKGLHHUGDVJHVHOOVFKDIWOL FKH/HEHQJHSUlJWVLHKWVFKHLQWGDVÃ7XQGHVJOHLFKHQµDEHUNHLQHLQIDFKHV8Q WHUIDQJHQVRQGHUQYLHOPHKUK|FKVWVFKHLWHUQVDQIlOOLJ]XVHLQ
:$*1(5 I :$*1(5 ',(5.(1 :$*1(5P U :$*1(5
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
([HPSODULVFKVROOQXQDQ]ZHLVR]LDOHQ7HLOEHUHLFKHQYRUJHIKUWZHUGHQZLH :DJQHUGDVFKULVWOLFKH3ULQ]LSGHU)UHLKHLWLQGLHVR]LDOH8PZHOWGHU5HOLJLRQ ]XEHUVHW]HQVLFKYRUVWHOOW:lKUHQGGDV5HFKW GDIUZLHREHQVFKRQ HUZlKQW HLQH JURH 2IIHQKHLW DXIZHLVW QLPPW VLFK GLH :LUWVFKDIW DOV JUXQGVlW]OLFKVSU|GHDXV(VIROJWGLH.LUFKHDOVSRWHQ]LHOOHU2UWGHU9HUPLWW OXQJFKULVWOLFKHU7UDGLWLRQVJHKDOWH 5HFKW±JHRUGQHWH)UHLKHLW]ZLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG=ZDQJ 'DV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ5HFKWXQG FKULVWOLFKHU 5HOLJLRQ 'DV5HFKWDOVVR]LDOHV7HLOV\VWHPVWHOOWLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQHLQHÄGXUFKJHKHQGH 6WUXNWXUGHU*HVHOOVFKDIW³GDU$OOH,QGLYLGXHQSDUWL]LSLHUHQDOVRDXILUJHQGHL QH:HLVHDQGHQJHQHUDOLVLHUWHQ5ROOHQLPSHUDWLYHQGLHYRQGLHVHPDXVJHKHQRE EHLGHU8QWHU]HLFKQXQJHLQHV0LHWYHUWUDJVRGHUGHP1DFKEDUVFKDIWVVWUHLWGHULQ HLQHU$QNODJHHQGHW'DEHLVLQGÄQRUPDWLYH9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQRGHU9HUKDO WHQVJHERWH³LP6SLHOGLHELVZHLOHQDXFKJHJHQGHQ:LOOHQ(LQ]HOQHUVDQNWLR QLHUWZHUGHQN|QQHQRKQHGDVVGDV5HFKWDEHUGHVKDOEZLH:DJQHUPLW/XK PDQQ EHWRQW ÄSULPlU HLQH =ZDQJVRUGQXQJ³ ZlUH *DQ] LP *HJHQWHLO HU VFKHLQWHVLKPKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU$UWXQG:HLVHUHFKWOLFKHU*HOWXQJVEHJUQGXQJ ZLHHUVLHDP%HLVSLHOGHVGHXWVFKHQ*UXQGJHVHW]HVDXVPDFKWSDVVHQGHUJHZLV VHUPDHQYRQHLQHUSULPlUHQ)UHLKHLWVRUGQXQJ]XVSUHFKHQ(UEH]LHKWVLFKKLHU DXI GLH 0HQVFKHQ XQG *UXQGUHFKWH GHQHQ HU GHQ 6WDWXV HLQHV ÄIRUPDOH>Q@ 5HFKWVDSULRUL³LP6LQQH.DQWV]XVFKUHLEWZDVGLHVHIUGLHlXHUH:DKUXQJGHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ )UHLKHLW HLQHV -HGHQ ]XVWlQGLJ VHLQ OlVVW ÄVRIHUQ VLH PLW MHGHV DQGHUHQ )UHLKHLW QDFK HLQHP DOOJHPHLQHQ *HVHW] ]XVDPPHQ EHVWHKHQ N|Q QHQ³(QWJHJHQUHFKWVSRVLWLYLVWLVFKHU$QVlW]HVLHKW:DJQHUGHPQDFKLQGHU GHXWVFKHQ9HUIDVVXQJHLQHXQPLWWHOEDUJHOWHQGHÄQRUPDQRUPDQV³YRUDXVJH VHW]WDQGHUVLFKDOOHNRQNUHWHQ9HUIDKUHQDXV]XULFKWHQKDEHQXQGGLHVHLQHV (UDFKWHQVPLWGHPÄWKHRORJLVFKH>Q@.ULWHULXP>«@GHU)UHLKHLWDOVYHUPLWWHOWHU 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³SULQ]LSLHOOEHUHLQVWLPPW'LHhEHUVHW]XQJGHUFKULVWOL FKHQ5HGHYRQ*RWWJHOLQJWDOVRDXIGLHVHU(EHQHJHZLVVHUPDHQUHLEXQJVORV ZHLO GLH UHFKWOLFKH *UXQGQRUP LKUHU $QHUNHQQXQJVORJLN HQWVSULFKW XQG VR JOHLFKVDPÄ*HLVWYRPFKULVWOLFKHQÃ*HLVWµ³DWPHW,P$UWLNHOGHV*UXQGJH VHW]HVHWZDGHUDOOHQÄIUHLH6HOEVWHQWIDOWXQJ³JDUDQWLHUWVRIHUQVLHGDEHLÄQLFKW GLH5HFKWHDQGHUHU³YHUOHW]HQLVWIU:DJQHUÄGHUJ|WWOLFKH*HLVWGHU6HOEVW H[SOLNDWLRQLPDQGHUHQSUlVHQWXQGPDQLIHVW³ZHLOKLHUGLH$QHUNHQQXQJIUHP
:$*1(5U9JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJ DD2± $D2 .$17 :$*1(5U 9JO:$*1(5 'HXWVFKHU%XQGHVWDJ
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
GHQ 6HOEVWVHLQV LQ GHQ LQGLYLGXHOOHQ )UHLKHLWVYROO]XJ NRQVWLWXWLY HLQJHODVVHQ LVW 'LIIHUHQ]HQ NRPPHQ DOOHUGLQJV GDQQ DXI ZHQQ SRVLWLY JHOWHQGHV 5HFKW GXUFKJHVHW]WXQGJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKZLUNVDPZHUGHQVROOZHLOVLFKKLHUGRFKGHV VHQDOVVHNXQGlUDQJHVHKHQHU=ZDQJVFKDUDNWHURIIHQEDUW %HL9HUVXFKHQYRQ Ä,QGLYLGXHQ VR]LDOH>Q@ *UXSSHQ RGHU DXFK VR]LDOH 6\VWHPH LKUH EHVRQGHUHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ³DXI.RVWHQ$QGHUHUGXUFK]XVHW]HQJUHLIWGHU5HFKWV]ZDQJXPYHU PLWWHOVÄ6WUDIDQGURKXQJRGHUIDNWLVFKYHUKlQJWH>Q@6WUDIHQ³GLHJHVW|UWH2UG QXQJ ZLHGHU KHU]XVWHOOHQ $XI EHLGHQ 6HLWHQ LGHQWLIL]LHUW :DJQHU GDV GHP ÃFKULVWOLFKHQµHQWJHJHQJHVHW]WH)UHLKHLWVSULQ]LSXQPLWWHOEDUHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ XQG6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJGHVDEJHGDQNWHQ+HUUVFKHUJRWWHVZDVGDV5HFKWLQ]HLW ZHLOLJHQ:LGHUVSUXFK]XGHQHVEHJUQGHQGHQ1RUPHQYHUVHW]W*OHLFKHVJLOW IUGLHYRQLKPGLDJQRVWL]LHUWHQ9HUUHFKWOLFKXQJVWHQGHQ]HQLQQHUKDOEGHU*H VHOOVFKDIWDOVHLQHVGLH,QGLYLGXDOLWlWGHU,QGLYLGXHQQLYHOOLHUHQGHQ]ZHFNUDWLR QDOHQ0HFKDQLVPXVV\VWHPLVFKHU6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJ:DJQHUSOlGLHUWGDIUVLFK VHLWHQVGHU7KHRORJLHEHUGLHVH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ$QVSUXFKXQG:LUNOLFKNHLW ZHGHUVFKZlUPHULVFKKLQZHJ]XVHW]HQQRFKVLHDOVÄXQEHUVFKUHLWEDUH>@*HJH EHQKHLW³]XIL[LHUHQVRQGHUQYLHOPHKUGDVHLJHQH3RWHQ]LDOÄLP8PJDQJPLW 'LIIHUHQ]HUIDKUXQJHQ³ QXW]EDU]XPDFKHQ'LHVEHWULIIWGLHGHPFKULVWOLFK UHOLJL|VHQ%HZXVVWVHLQHLJQHQGH(LQVLFKWLQGHQSULQ]LSLHOOHQ8QWHUVFKLHGYRQ XQPLWWHOEDUHUXQGYHUPLWWHOWHU)UHLKHLWGHUHVDXIJUXQGYRQJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNHQ QXQJWHLOKDIWLJJHZRUGHQLVWZHVKDOEHVDXFKXPGHUHQ8QHU]ZLQJEDUNHLWZHL 6HLQHWKHRORJLVFKEHJUQGHWH(LQVLFKWLQGLH=XVDPPHQKlQJHGHV5HFKWV]X EHUVHW]HQJHVWDOWHWVLFKGDQQVROlVVWVLFK:DJQHUYHUVWHKHQDXIGLHVHU(EHQH LPPDU[VFKHQ'XDOYRQ(OHQGVDXVGUXFNXQG3URWHVW (LQHUVHLWVVROOHQGLHQRU PDWLYHQ:LGHUVSUFKHGHU5HFKWVYHUOHW]XQJXQGGHV5HFKWV]ZDQJVDOV0DQLIHV WDWLRQHQGHUÄ%UFKLJNHLW³RGHUÄGHU=ZLVFKHQODJHPHQVFKOLFKHQ'DVHLQV³ $UWLNXODWLRQILQGHQ$QGHUVHLWVLVWLKQHQYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHVPLWGHQUHFKW OLFKHQ*UXQGQRUPHQEHUHLQVWLPPHQGHQFKULVWOLFKHQ)UHLKHLWVSULQ]LSVÄLP%H ZXWVHLQLKUHUSULQ]LSLHOOHQhEHUVFKUHLWEDUNHLW]XEHJHJQHQ³,QVJHVDPWJHKW HVGDEHLDEHUGDUXPÄGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJGHUYHUPLWWHOWHQ]XXQJXQVWHQGHUXQPLW WHOEDUHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ]XI|UGHUQ³ZRIU:DJQHUGHP5HFKWHLQH]HQWUD OH%HGHXWXQJ]XPLVVWGDVLQGLHVHP6LQQHFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VHE]ZNLUFKOLFK WKHRORJLVFKH8QWHUVWW]XQJHUIDKUHQVROO
:$*1(5N :$*1(5UI 9JO:$*1(5 II $D2 (EG (EG (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
'DV%HLVSLHOGHV6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKV %HLVSLHOKDIWNDQQGDIU:DJQHUV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHUHEHQVRPRUDOLVFK ZLHUHFKWOLFKXPVWULWWHQHQ)UDJHGHV6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKVKHUDQJH]RJHQ ZHUGHQ ,P 6LQQH GHU FKULVWOLFKHQ )UHLKHLW DOV HLQHU YHUPLWWHOWHQ DXV XQG GXUFK $QHUNHQQXQJ VLFK UHDOLVLHUHQGHQ 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ LVW GLHVEH]JOLFK ÄZHGHUGDV6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVUHFKWGHU)UDXQRFKGDV/HEHQVUHFKWGHVXQJHER UHQHQ/HEHQV QDVFLWXUXV HLQVHLWLJ>]X@IDYRULVLHUHQ³6SUlFKHPDQGHPQDFK HLQJHQHUHOOHV9HUERWGHV6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKVDXVZUGHGDV5HFKWGHV QDVFLWXUXVEHYRU]XJWEHKDQGHOW,P+LQWHUJUXQGHLQHUVROFKHQ$XIIDVVXQJVWHKW LQ:DJQHUV$XJHQ]XGHPVWLOOVFKZHLJHQGGLH7KHVHHLQHVÄ9RUUDQJ>V@GHV*DW WXQJVOHEHQVEHUGDV/HEHQGHV,QGLYLGXXPV³:HLOPHQVFKOLFKHV/HEHQLP $OOJHPHLQHQ]XVFKW]HQLVWNDQQHVLPLQGLYLGXHOOHQ(LQ]HOIDOONHLQH$XVQDK PHJHEHQ±GLHVH/RJLNOHXFKWHWVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVDQJHVLFKWVGHUIUGHQ0HQ VFKHQVSH]LILVFKHQEHZXVVWHQ*HVWDOWXQJVHLQHV'DVHLQVMHGRFKQLFKWHLQ,KU]X IROJHQN|QQWHQlPOLFKQXUGXUFKHLQHÄ,QVWDQ]EHDQVSUXFKW>@³ZHUGHQGLHÄGDV DEVWUDNWH ZHLO XQPLWWHOEDUH 5HFKW GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ *DWWXQJ IU VLFK³ ]X UHNODPLHUHQ YHUPRFKWH (LQH VROFKH DOOJHPHLQJOWLJH E]Z DEVROXWH3RVLWLRQ DEHULVWGXUFKQLHPDQGHQHLQQHKPEDUZHLOMHGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGH9HUVXFKLPPHU VFKRQHLQHQ$XVGUXFNEHZXVVWHUGLH8QPLWWHOEDUNHLWEORHQ/HEHQVDXIKHEHQ GHU /HEHQVJHVWDOWXQJ GDUVWHOOWH 0HKU QRFK (V ZUGH GDQQ HLQH EHVWLPPWH QLFKWSHUVHDOOJHPHLQH1RUPLP1DPHQGHU0HQVFKKHLWJHJHQGDV6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJVUHFKWGHU)UDXGXUFKJHVHW]W$XV:DJQHUVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWHQW VSUlFKHGLHVGHULP7RG*RWWHVEHUZXQGHQHQ)UHLKHLWDOVXQPLWWHOEDUHU6HOEVW EHKDXSWXQJGLHKLHULQ*HVWDOWGHV+XPDQHQDXIWULWW'DVVGHUHQXQHQWULQQEDUHV 6FKHLWHUQHLQHDXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQ]XUHDOLVLHUHQGH)UHLKHLW QDKHOHJWQLPPWDEHUXPJHNHKUWDXFKGLHZHUGHQGH0XWWHULQGLH3IOLFKW(EHQ VRZHQLJZLHLP)DOOHGHVÄPHQVFKOLFKHQ*DWWXQJVOHEHQV³GDUILKUHÄ6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJ >«@ DXI XQPLWWHOEDUH :HLVH ]XP =XJH JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ³ 6LQG EHLGHU$QVSUFKHDOVR]XJXQVWHQGHVE]ZGHUMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ]XUHODWLYLHUHQ EOHLEWLPPHUQRFKXQHUNOlUWZLHDQJHVLFKWVHLQHVP|JOLFKHQ6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWV DEEUXFKV]XHQWVFKHLGHQLVW :DJQHUIRUPXOLHUWVHLQ/|VXQJVDQJHERWDOV)UDJH Ä6LQGGLHYRUDXVVHKEDUHQ REMHNWLYHQ%HGLQJXQJHQVRJHDUWHWGDGDV/HEHQGHVQDVFLWXUXVXQGGDVGHU )UDXDOVVHOEVWJHVWDOWHWHV/HEHQJHPlGHP3ULQ]LSYHUPLWWHOWHU6HOEVWEHVWLP PXQJNRQVWLWXLHUWN|QQHQ"³2EGLHV]XEHMDKHQRGHU]XYHUQHLQHQLVWXQGVR JHJHQRGHUIUGLH(LQUlXPXQJHLQHV6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKVYRWLHUWZLUG
9JO]XGLHVHP$EVFKQLWWLQVJHVDPW :$*1(5 FII $D2 $D2 (EG (EG $D2
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
HQWVFKHLGHWDQGHUVJHVDJWGLH]XNQIWLJHÄ$QHUNHQQXQJVIlKLJNHLW³EHLGHUÄDOV PHQVFKOLFKH,QGLYLGXHQ³ ,VWGDYRQDXV]XJHKHQGDVVVLHQDFKHUIROJWHU*H EXUWDXI%HGLQJXQJHQWUHIIHQZUGHQGLHHLQHÄVHOEVWlQGLJIUHLH>@/HEHQVJHVWDO WXQJ³IUPLQGHVWHQVHLQH Q YRQLKQHQYHUXQP|JOLFKWHQGDUIDXV:DJQHUV 3HUVSHNWLYHNHLQ=ZDQJ]XP$XVWUDJHQGHVQDVFLWXUXVGHNUHWLHUWZHUGHQÄ:HU DXIJUXQGHLQHVPRUDOLVFKUHOLJL|VHQ*HVLQQXQJVULJRULVPXVJODXEWMHGHQP|JOL FKHQ6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKUHFKWOLFKYHUELHWHQ]XVROOHQ³WULIIWKLQJHJHQ DXI:DJQHUVHQWVFKLHGHQHQ:LGHUVSUXFK(LQHVROFKH6LFKWPLVVDFKWHWGLH)UHL KHLWHEHQVRGHUZHUGHQGHQ0XWWHUZLHGHVHQWVWHKHQGHQ.LQGHVZHLOVLHGHUHQ ]XNQIWLJH $QHUNHQQXQJVIlKLJNHLW QLFKW EHUFNVLFKWLJW DOVR QLFKW QDFK GHQ ÄSHUVRQDOHQVR]LDOHQXQGZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ8PVWlQGHQ³IUDJWXQWHUGHQHQGDV .LQGVFKOLHOLFKDXVJHWUDJHQZLUG:LGHUVSULFKWGLHVDEHUGHP3ULQ]LSGHUYHU PLWWHOWHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ ZHLOGHPDOOJHPHLQHQ5HFKWGHV/HEHQVVR]XU XQPLWWHOEDUHQ6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJYHUKROIHQZLUGLVWIU:DJQHUHLQHUHFKWOLFKH /HJDOLVLHUXQJGHV6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVDEEUXFKVWKHRORJLVFK]XXQWHUVWW]HQ (VEOHLEWMHGRFKHLQH)UDJHGHU±YRQ:DJQHULQLKUHULQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ9HUIDK UHQVZHLVHDXFKQLFKWZHLWHUH[SOL]LHUWHQ±$EZlJXQJZLHGLHDQWL]LSLHUWHQ =XNXQIWVEHGLQJXQJHQVLFKLP%OLFNDXIHLQHIUHLH'DVHLQVJHVWDOWXQJDXVQHKPHQ ZHUGHQ'HUFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VDUWLNXOLHUEDUH3URWHVWHLQHVGLHLPPDQHQWHQ9HU KlOWQLVVH WUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHQ 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVDQVSUXFKV JHJHQ GLH VR]LDOH UHVSHNWLYHQDWUOLFKH=XPXWXQJXQEHGLQJWJHElUHQ]XPVVHQNDQQVLFKDXFK DOVREMHNWLYXQEHJUQGHWHUZHLVHQ-HGHQIDOOVPVVWHLP6LQQH:DJQHUVGLH]X HUZDUWHQGH)UHLKHLWVXQI|UGHUOLFKNHLWGHUNRPPHQGHQ8PVWlQGH±]%GXUFK PHGL]LQLVFKH7HVWVHWF±DOOJHPHLQQDFKYROO]LHKEDUJHPDFKWZHUGHQN|QQHQ ZHQQVLHQLFKWQXUYRPLQGLYLGXHOOHQ(PSILQGHQGHU%HWURIIHQHQDEKlQJLJJH PDFKWZHUGHQVROO$QJHVLFKWVGHUGDPLWSRWHQ]LHOOHLQKHUJHKHQGHQUHFKWOLFKHQ %HVFKUlQNXQJGHV6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVDQVSUXFKVGHU0XWWHUNRPPWGHU5HOLJLRQ QRFKHLQHZHLWHUSRWHQ]LHOOH%HGHXWXQJ]X6LHN|QQWHGHU%HDUEHLWXQJHLQHV XQDElQGHUOLFKHQ/HLGHQVDQGHUVR]LDOHQ%HJUHQ]WKHLWGHVHLJHQHQ)UHLKHLWVZLO OHQVGLHQHQ'LHVHLPZHLWHVWHQ6LQQHÃVHHOVRUJOLFKHµ'LPHQVLRQGHV7KHPDV DEHUVSLHOWEHL:DJQHUK|FKVWHQVDP5DQGHHLQH5ROOH6HLQ,QWHUHVVHJLOWYLHO PHKUGHU)UDJHZLHUHOLJL|VE]ZWKHRORJLVFKGLH|IIHQWOLFKUHFKWOLFKH9HUZLUN OLFKXQJGHU)UHLKHLWDXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJXQWHUVWW]WZHUGHQNDQQ 'DVV GLHVH ÄLPPHU ZLHGHU LQ LKUHU XQDEVFKOLHEDUHQ 5HDOLVLHUXQJ DXIJHKDO WHQ³ ZLUG KlQJW DXV :DJQHUV GXUFK GLH /HNWUH $GRUQRV JHSUlJWHQ 6LFKW
$D2 $D2 $D2 (EG 'HVZHLWHUHQZLUGYRQ:DJQHURIIHQJHODVVHQELV]XZHOFKHP6FKZDQJHUVFKDIWVPRQDW HLQH$EWUHLEXQJP|JOLFKVHLQN|QQHQVROOWH=ZDUEH]LHKWHUVLFKDQIDQJVDXIGLHVHLQHU]HLWLQ gVWHUUHLFKJHOWHQGH)ULVWHQO|VXQJHQWKlOWVLFKDEHUHLQHU.OlUXQJLQGLHVHU)UDJH :$*1(5
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
LQVEHVRQGHUHPLWGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ:LUNPDFKWGHUNDSLWDOLVWLVFKHQgNRQR PLH]XVDPPHQ :LUWVFKDIW 'HU*RWWGHV*HOGHVJHJHQGHQ*RWWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 'LHÄNDSLWDOLVWLVFKRUJDQLVLHUWH0DUNWZLUWVFKDIW³VRODXWHW:DJQHUVEHUHLWV]L WLHUWH 7KHVH Ä]HLFKQHW VLFK GXUFK LKUH EHVRQGHUH (QWIHUQXQJ YRQ UHOLJL|VHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQXQGPRUDOLVFKHQ3ULQ]LSLHQDXV³:DVGLHVHQlPOLFKYRQLKUHQ 7HLOQHKPHUQHUZDUWHWPDQLIHVWLHUWVLFKVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVLP%HJULIIGHVKRPR RHFRQRPLFXV HLQHV HLQ]LJ DP 1XW]HQNDONO HIIL]LHQWHU *HZLQQRSWLPLHUXQJ RULHQWLHUWHQ(JRLVWHQ'LHVHUZHLEHWULHEOLFKH$UEHLWVNUDIWXQGJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH 1DFKIUDJH HUIROJUHLFK LQ GLH (UODQJXQJ HLQHV JUXQGVlW]OLFK XQHUUHLFKEDUHQ /HW]W]LHOVHLQ]XVSDQQHQ Ä+DQGOHVRGDGXDXVZHQLJHUPHKU.DSLWDOXQGDXV PHKUQRFKPHKU.DSLWDOPDFKVW³:HUGHQGDPLW]ZDULP%HUHLFKGHU:LUW VFKDIWÄDXV/DVWHUQ>«@7XJHQGHQXQGDXV7XJHQGHQ/DVWHU³VHW]WVLHGRFK ZLHDPÄ)UHLKHLWVSDWKRVGHUIUHLHQ0DUNWZLUWVFKDIW³HUNHQQEDUGLH6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJVWlWLJNHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQYRUDXV6RJHVHKHQHUZHLVWVLHVLFK]XQlFKVW HLQPDODOVRIIHQIUGLHDXIHEHQGHUHQ%HJUQGXQJ]LHOHQGHhEHUVHW]XQJGHV FKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV)U:DJQHULVWHVMHGRFKEHUGHXWOLFKGDVVGHU YRP:LUWVFKDIWVV\VWHPEHI|UGHUWHÄJHOGJHSUlJWH:HOWXPJDQJZHLWJHKHQGGHP 3ULQ]LSXQPLWWHOEDUHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJIROJW³ GKGHU/RJLNGHVJHVFKHLWHU WHQÃ$OOPDFKWVJRWWHVµYHUKDIWHWLVW'LHVEULQJWHU]XPHLQHQIUGDVDV\PPHWUL VFKH9HUKlOWQLVYRQXQWHUQHKPHULVFKHU.DSLWDODNNXPXODWLRQXQG]XGHUHQEOR HP9HUZHUWXQJVPLWWHOGHJUDGLHUWHU$UEHLWVRZLHIUGLH'LVNUHSDQ]]ZLVFKHQ ÄSULYDWHU*HZLQQPD[LPLHUXQJ³XQGÄDOOJHPHLQH>U@%HGUIQLVEHIULHGLJXQJ³LQ $QVFKODJ=XPDQGHUHQDEHUGLDJQRVWL]LHUW:DJQHUYRP:LUWVFKDIWVV\VWHP DXVJHKHQGH(QWGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJVWHQGHQ]HQ hEHUGDV)DNWXPKLQDXVGDVVMHGHU RKQHKLQILQDQ]LHOOH7UDQVDNWLRQHQ]XWlWLJHQKDWZHUGHQDXFKLQGHQDQGHUHQ 7HLOV\VWHPHQ ]XQHKPHQG Ä.RPPXQLNDWLRQVYROO]JH +DQGOXQJHQ XQG (QW VFKHLGXQJHQ>«@GXUFKZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH*HVLFKWVSXQNWHEHVWLPPWRGHUJDUGRPL QLHUW³'HJHQHULHUWDEHUGLHPHQVFKOLFKH/HEHQVZHOW]XUÃ.RORQLHµ|NRQRPL VFKHU)XQNWLRQHQZLH:DJQHUPLW+DEHUPDVKHUDXVVWHOOWJHUlW]XJOHLFKGDV
$D29JO]XPIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWLQVJHVDPW DD2±± '(56 OII IIIIII7HLOGLHVHV$EVFKQLWWHZXUGHQEHUHLWVYHU|IIHQWOLFKWLQ 7(7=/$)) :$*1(5 9JO'(56 DII $D2 $D2 $D2I9JOGD]XLQVEHVRQGHUH '(56 II :$*1(5 D :$*1(5 D9JODXFK'(56OII 9JO]X-UJHQ+DEHUPDVµ'LDJQRVHHLQHUÄ.RORQLDOLVLHUXQJGHU/HEHQVZHOW³ +$%(5 0$6 E II:DJQHUUHNXUULHUWGDUDXIRKQHVLFKGHU+DEHUPDVVFKHQ.RPPXQLNDWLRQV XQG*HVHOOVFKDIWVWKHRULHDQ]XVFKOLHHQLQ :$*1(5 II
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
*HOG]XP/HLWPHGLXPGHV6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJV,KPHLJQHWGDQQGDV9HU P|JHQÄDOOHVZDVGXUFKHVNRPPXQL]LHUWZLUGPLGDVDUWLJVRLQVHLQHQ%DQQ³ ]X]LHKHQÄGDHV]XPEHXQGYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ0LWWHO³HLQHUDOOJHJHQZlUWLJHQ 9HUZHUWXQJVORJLNZLUG 'DV5HVXOWDWLVWHLQHXPVLFKJUHLIHQGH9HUJOHLFKJOWLJXQJGHUVSH]LILVFKHQ (LJHQDUWYRQ,QKDOWHQXQG3HUVRQHQQDFKGHP*HVLFKWVSXQNWYRQ(IIL]LHQ]XQG 9HUNDXIEDUNHLW 3ROLWLVFKH %RWVFKDIWHQ NQVWOHULVFKNXOWXUHOOH 6FK|SIXQJHQ UHOLJL|VH ZLH PRUDOLVFKH :HUWH ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH (UNHQQWQLVVH VSRUWOLFKH :HWWNlPSIHZHUGHQHEHQVRDXVWDXVFKEDUZLHLKUH3URGX]HQWHQXQG.RQVXPHQ WHQ'LH%HGUIQLVVHXQG%HODQJHYRQ,QGLYLGXHQZHUGHQGXUFKGLHÄ3DUROH GHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ³DOVHJDOLVLHUWH0LWWHO]XP=ZHFNHGHUJHZLQQWUlFK WLJHQ$EVHW]XQJVWlQGLJPRGLVFKDXIJHKEVFKWHU1HXKHLWHQYHUZHUWHW=XJOHLFK DEHUILQGHQVLFKGLH,QGLYLGXHQYRQGHUIXQGDPHQWDOHQÄ8QJOHLFKZHUWLJNHLW³ EHVWLPPWGDVVÄZHUQLFKWWDXVFKXQG]DKOXQJVIlKLJLVW>«@YRQGHU.RPPX QLNDWLRQGHV*HOGHVDXVJHVFKORVVHQ³XQGVRLQVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH$EVHLWVYHU EDQQWZLUG:DJQHUIKUWGLHVH1HJDWLYVLWXDWLRQMHGRFKQLFKWHWZDDXIGLH]X ZHLVEDUH HJRLVWLVFKH 3URILWJLHU HLQHU KHUUVFKHQGHQ .ODVVH ]XUFN 9LHOPHKU HQWGHFNWHULQLKUHLQHQÄREMHNWLYHQ:HOW]XVWDQGIUGHQNHLQHLQ]HOQHUYHUDQW ZRUWOLFKLVWGHPDEHUDXFKNHLQHLQ]HOQHUGXUFKGLHLQGLYLGXHOOH(QWVFKHLGXQJV DNWHPRUDOLVFKHURGHUUHOLJL|VHU$UWRKQHZHLWHUHVHQWNRPPHQNDQQ³ ,QGLHVHP6LQQHUHJLHUWGDV*HOGVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVDOVÄLUGLVFKH>U@*RWW³GLH :HOW 'HUGLHVHPHLJQHQGH9HUZHUWXQJVPHFKDQLVPXVKDWVLFK]XHLQHPVlPW OLFK/HEHQVEHUHLFKHGRPLQLHUHQGHQ3ULQ]LSYHUVHOEVWlQGLJWGDVNHLQ$QGHUVVHLQ ]XOlVVWVRQGHUQDOOHVXQGMHGHQ]XP0LWWHOVHLQHUDEVROXWHQ6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJ ZHUGHQ OlVVW 1XQ NDQQ LQ :DJQHUV $XJHQ Ä>G@LH FKULVWOLFKH 7KHRORJLH>«@ DQJHVLFKWVGLHVHU6LWXDWLRQQLFKWWULXPSKLHUHQ³KDWVLHGRFKÄ*RWWMDKUKXQGHUWH ODQJDOVXQPLWWHOEDUVHOEVWXQGDOOPlFKWLJHV:HVHQJHIDW³ 8PGHU+HUU VFKDIW GHV *HOGHV ]XJXQVWHQ GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ )UHLKHLW NRPPXQLNDWLY HWZDV HQWJHJHQVHW]HQ]XN|QQHQEHGDUIVLHYLHOPHKUHLQHV%HJULIIVYRQ*RWWGHUQLFKW PLWGHUPRQHWlUHQ9HUZHUWXQJVORJLNYHUZHFKVHOEDULVW'LH.ULWLNGHVPLW7RWD OLWlWVDQVSUXFKDXIWUHWHQGHQ*HOGPHFKDQLVPXVIKUWQRWZHQGLJ]XHLQHUWKHRORJL VFKHQ6HOEVWNULWLNGLHDXIGDVNRQVHTXHQWH'XUFKGHQNHQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HYR OXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVSRFKW'DGXUFKHUVWNDQQGLHDXIGHUXQPLWWHO EDUHQ6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJGHV(LJHQHQEHKDUUHQGH/RJLNGHV*HOGHVDXIHLQH YHUlQGHUWH*HVWDOWGHV6R]LDOHQKLQEHUVFKULWWHQZHUGHQ:LHDQJHVLFKWVGHV
9JO:$*1(5O 9JODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ :$*1(5OII II :$*1(5O :$*1(5 $D29JO'(56 II :$*1(5 9JO'(56O IIII IIIIII :$*1(5 9JO ]XP )ROJHQGHQ PHLQH $XVIKUXQJHQ LQ 6&+(,:,//(5 7(7=/$)) ±
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
*RWWHVGHU6HOEVWXQG$OOPDFKWOlVVWVLFKQlPOLFKDXFKÄXQWHUGHU%HGLQJXQJ GHUJHOGJHVWHXHUWHQ*HZLQQPD[LPLHUXQJ>«@GLHVHOEVW]ZHFNKDIWH)UHLKHLWGHU ,QGLYLGXHQQLFKWDGlTXDWUHDOLVLHUHQ³'D]XPVVWHHUVWHUHVLFKOHW]WHUHUÄ|II QHQXQGIUVLHDXIJHVFKORVVHQ³VHLQGKGHU)UHLKHLWDOVYHUPLWWHOWHU6HOEVW EHVWLPPXQJHQWVSUHFKHQ(LQHhEHUVHW]XQJGHVGLHVHUYHUSIOLFKWHWHQ*RWWHVJH GDQNHQVLQGLH=XVDPPHQKlQJHGHU:LUWVFKDIWGLHQWGDQQLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQ GHUÄ(ULQQHUXQJDQGLHSUDNWLVFKH)UHLKHLWVLGHH³6LHVWHOOWGLH)UDJHÄQDFK GHQ%HGLQJXQJHQ>«@GLHHVGHQ,QGLYLGXHQHUP|JOLFKHQGDLKUH%HODQJHXQG %HGUIQLVVHQLFKWEORQDFK:HUWVWHLJHUXQJVJHVLFKWVSXQNWHQYHUUHFKQHWZHU GHQ³:LHGLHVLQQHUKDOEGHVUHDOH[LVWLHUHQGHQ.DSLWDOLVPXVDXV:DJQHUV 6LFKWEHUKDXSWP|JOLFKVHLQVROOOlVVWVLFKDQJHVLFKWVVHLQHUGUDVWLVFKHQ1HJD WLYGLDJQRVHNDXPDEVHKHQ(LQH$IILUPDWLRQGHVgNRQRPLVFKHQEHUGLH]lK QHNQLUVFKHQGH)HVWVWHOOXQJKLQDXVGDVVPHQVFKOLFKH6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJHEHQQLFKW RKQH]ZHFNUDWLRQDOH+DQGOXQJVPXVWHUEHZHUNVWHOOLJWZHUGHQNDQQILQGHWVLFK EHL:DJQHUQLFKW5HOLJL|VZLUGGHQLPPHUDXFK|NRQRPLVFKEHVWLPPWHQ,QGL YLGXHQYLHOPHKUHLQH6HOEVWWKHPDWLVLHUXQJHUP|JOLFKWGLHHLQH7UDQV]HQGLHUXQJ GHUJHOGEHVWLPPWHQXQGVLHQLFKWDQHUNHQQHQGHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHLQLWLLHUW:HOFKH VR]LDOHQ)RUPDWLRQHQGDEHLLQGHQ%OLFNNRPPHQEOHLEWXQNODUXQG5HOLJLRQ ZLUGVRWHQGHQ]LHOOHLQH)RUPYRQ9HUWU|VWXQJ'HXWOLFKLVWDEHUZRUDXIVLFK GLHNLUFKOLFKLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHUHOLJL|VH.RPPXQLNDWLRQLQ:DJQHUV$XJHQ DXVULFKWHQVROOWH .LUFKH 9RPJHLVWOLFKHQ]XPDOOWlJOLFKHQ*RWWHVGLHQVW :DJQHUV9HUKlOWQLV]XU,QVWLWXWLRQGHV*RWWHVGLHQVWHVLVWDOVNULWLVFKNRQVWUXNWLY ]XEHXUWHLOHQ6RZHQGHWHUVLFKLQVFKDUIHU:HLVHJHJHQGLH/LWXUJLH]HQWULHUWKHLW GHU]HLWJHQ|VVLVFKHQNLUFKOLFKHQ3UD[LVZHLOGHUHQÄDXI:LHGHUKROXQJXQG5RX WLQHDEJHVWHOOWH>@OLWXUJLVFKHQ.UHLVOlXIH³GHP$QVSUXFKDEKROGZUGHQÄ9HU NQGLJXQJYRQÃ1HXHPµ]XVHLQ³XQGVWDWWGHVVHQLQVSU|GHÄ6HOEVWJHQJVDP NHLW³YHUILHOHQ,QVJHVDPWHQWGHFNWHUGDULQHLQHGUHLIDFKH(QWGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ZHUWYROOHU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJHQ 6DFKOLFK JHVHKHQ GRPLQLHUW HLQH ELEOLVFK GRJPDWLVFKHÄ)RUPHOVSUDFKHLQGHUVLFK=LWDWHDXI=LWDWHEH]LHKHQ³REGHUHQ REMHNWLYHP&KDUDNWHUGDVLUUHGX]LEOH0RPHQWLQGLYLGXHOOHU$QHLJQXQJZHJIlOOW 6R]LDOEHWUDFKWHWZLUGGHPÄSURSDJLHUWH>Q@DOOJHPHLQH>Q@3ULHVWHUWXP³GXUFK GLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQZLVVHQGHP3IDUUHUXQGXQZLVVHQGHQ/DLHQZLGHUVSUR FKHQ=HLWOLFKJHZHQGHWUHGHWPDQVRHLQHUÄHQWGLIIHUHQ]LHUWH>Q@'DXHUJHJHQ
:$*1(5 $D2 (EG (EG :$*1(5 E9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2± :$*1(5 EI (EG
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
ZlUWLJNHLW³GHVLPPHU*OHLFKHQGDV:RUWRKQHHLQHQ%H]XJGHUKLVWRULVFK EHUNRPPHQHQ7UDGLWLRQVJHKDOWH]XU*HJHQZDUWKHU]XVWHOOHQ'LHLQIROJHGLHVHU (QWGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJIHKOHQGHÃ1HXKHLWµPHLQWDEHUQLFKWQXUHLQHPDQJHOKDIWH $SSOLNDWLRQELEOLVFKHU7H[WHDXIDNWXHOOH6LWXDWLRQHQYLHOPHKUPRQLHUW:DJQHU GDVVÄGLHÃ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQµGHUGHUJHLVWOLFKH*RWWHVGLHQVWGLHQHQ VROO>«@RKQHVHOEVWlQGLJHXQGVHOEVWWlWLJH%HWHLOLJXQJGHU%HWURIIHQHQGXUFK JHIKUW³ZLUG 0LWGHP6WLFKZRUWÄ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQ³VSULFKWHUMHQHÄZHVHQW OLFKGXUFKGLH0RPHQWHGHUPRUWLILFDWLRXQGYLYLILFDWLR³EHVWLPPWHÄ.RQVWLWXWL RQGHV&KULVWVHLQV³DQGLHWUDGLWLRQHOOHWZDDOV%HNHKUXQJRGHU%HUXIXQJEH ]HLFKQHWZLUG 'HQGDPLWDQYLVLHUWHQhEHUJDQJGHVÃDOWHQµ]XPÃQHXHQµ0HQ VFKHQ±YRQGHU6QGH]XP+HLO±YHUVWHKW:DJQHUIUHLOLFKLQQHUKDOEGHU.RRU GLQDWHQ VHLQHV 0RGHOOV (U EHVFKUHLEW GDQQ GLH $EO|VXQJ GHU XQPLWWHOEDUHQ 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJGXUFKÄGLH)UHLKHLWDXVXQGDXIJUXQGYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³GLH HLQ]LJGDGXUFK5HDOLWlWZLUGÄGDVLH>VLFK@LPPHU]XJOHLFKDOV)UHLKHLWGHU DQGHUHQ³YROO]LHKW/HW]WHUHVEHWULIIWGLHPDQJHOQGH%HWHLOLJXQJGHU*HPHLQ GHGHUHQ5HNODPDWLRQDOVRGDUDXI]LHOWLPÄJHLVWOLFKUHOLJL|VH>Q@*RWWHVGLHQVW >«@(UZDUWXQJHQ>]X@HUZHFNHQGLHVLFKLQGLH(UIDKUXQJHQGHUSHUVRQDOHQXQG VR]LDOHQ /HEHQVIKUXQJ GHU ,QGLYLGXHQ EHUVHW]HQ ODVVHQ³ 'HU ÃJHLVWOLFK UHOLJL|VH*RWWHVGLHQVWµVROODOVRDQEDKQHQGDVVGLH,QGLYLGXHQLQQHUKDOELKUHU /HEHQVSUD[LVZLOOHQWOLFKYHUZLUNOLFKHQZDVVLHZROOHQVROOHQZRULQVLFK:DJ QHUVÄ&KULVWHQWXPQLFKWGHVVFK|QHQ5HGHQVVRQGHUQGHU7DW³HLQPDOPHKU %DKQEULFKW 9RQ*RWWGHVVHQ0HQVFKZHUGXQJXQG7RGGHQJHGDQNOLFKHQ*UXQGGHU(LQ VLFKWLQGLHUHYROXWLRQLHUWH)RUPYRQ)UHLKHLWELOGHQLVWGDQQLQEHUVHW]WHU:HL VH]XVSUHFKHQ(UPXVVÄDXVGHPLPDJLQlUHQ-HQVHLWVVHLQHUYHUPHLQWOLFKHQ VXSUDQDWXUDOHQ6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWLQGHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWXQG:HOWXPJDQJ KHUDEJHKROW>ZHUGHQ@XPLKQGRUWDOV*HLVWGHU)UHLKHLWLQPLWWHQSHUVRQDOHUXQG VR]LDOHU 9HUKlOWQLVVH SUlVHQW >«@ KDOWHQ³ ]X N|QQHQ 'DPLW VROO GDQQ IU :DJQHUJHZlKUOHLVWHWVHLQGDVVGLHVLFKLQQHUKDOEGHUPRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWDQ GLH,QGLYLGXHQDOVVROFKHULFKWHQGHFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VH.RPPXQLNDWLRQDXFKIU GHUHQYLHOIlOWLJHV(LQJHEXQGHQVHLQLQGLHIXQNWLRQDOHQ5ROOHQHUZDUWXQJHQDQGH UHU7HLOV\VWHPH5HOHYDQ]HQWIDOWHW'LHNRQNUHWH(QWIDOWXQJGHVMHZHLOLJHQLQGL YLGXHOOHQ 6HOEVWVHLQV LP $QGHUVVHLQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU =XVDPPHQKlQJH EH ]HLFKQHW HU PLW GHP WUDGLWLRQHOOHQ $XVGUXFN Ä*RWWHVGLHQVW LP $OOWDJ GHU
(EG $D2 :$*1(5R 9JO]XGLHVHP7RSRVDXFK:DJQHUVHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ75($UWLNHO '(56 :$*1(5R I9JODXFK '(56 EI :$*1(5 E :$*1(5 E :$*1(5 E
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:HOW³ 'LHVHQ YHUVWHKW HU LP $QVFKOXVV DQ GLH QHXSURWHVWDQWLVFKH %HUXIV IU|PPLJNHLW LP 6LQQH HLQHV 9HUVXFKV GLH FKULVWOLFKH )UHLKHLW LQQHUKDOE GHU VLWWOLFKHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQPLWJHVWDOWHQG]XEHZlKUHQ'DEHLJHKWHV:DJQHUQLFKW YRUUDQJLJXPGLH)RUPXOLHUXQJHLQHVÄ3URJUDPP>V@]XUGLUHNWHQ6R]LDOJHVWDO WXQJGHU:HOW³VRQGHUQGDUXPGLHÄ'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQQRUPDWLYHU)UHLKHLWV HUZDUWXQJXQGOHUQEHUHLWHU)UHLKHLWVHUIDKUXQJ³LQQHUKDOEGHUVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPH ZHQLJVWHQVIU7UDQV]HQGLHUXQJHQRIIHQ]XKDOWHQ 'HPÃJHLVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVGLHQVWµNRPPWGDEHLGLH$XIJDEH]XGXUFKVDFKJH UHFKWHhEHUVHW]XQJHQFKULVWOLFKHU,QKDOWHGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]HUIDKUXQJSURGXNWLY]X EHDUEHLWHQ:lKUHQG:DJQHUZLHVFKRQJHVDJWGHPÄIHLHUOLFKH>Q@.XOWXVGHV NLUFKOLFKHQ*QDGHQVFKDW]HV³HKHUDEOHKQHQGJHJHQEHUVWHKWHQWGHFNWHUGRFK 3RWHQ]LDOLQGHU3UHGLJW'LHVHVROOWHLQVHLQHQ$XJHQÄGDVGHQJDQ]HQ*RWWHV GLHQVWEHVWLPPHQGH0RPHQW>«@VHLQ³ZHLOVLHÄ]XPLQGHVWGHU,QWHQWLRQ³QDFK GHQ9HUVXFKGDUVWHOOWÄGLH$XVVDJHQHLQHVVR]LRNXOWXUHOOXQGUDXP]HLWOLFKDE VWlQGLJHQ 7H[WHV LQ GLH (UIDKUXQJVKRUL]RQWH GHV JHJHQZlUWLJHQ 6HOEVW XQG :HOWXPJDQJV]XEHUVHW]HQ³.RQNUHWPVVWHHVLQÄMHGH>U@QDFKYROO]LHKED UH>Q@6RQQWDJVSUHGLJW³GDUXPJHKHQÄGLH6WHOOXQJGHU,QGLYLGXHQLQGHUPRGHU QHQ>«@>*@HVHOOVFKDIW³]XU6SUDFKH]XEULQJHQDOVRGHUHQÄXQHQGOLFKH:UGH³ ]XWKHPDWLVLHUHQXQGÄ(LQVHLWLJNHLWHQ]XNULWLVLHUHQXQGDE]XEDXHQ³GLHVLFK GLHVEH]JOLFKDXVLKUHU9HUIORFKWHQKHLWLQVR]LDOH%H]JHHUJHEHQ :DJQHUV JRWWHVGLHQVWOLFKIRNXVVLHUWHVÃ&KULVWHQWXPGHU7DWµKDWHLQHUNHQQEDULQWHOOHNWXD OLVWLVFKHV*HSUlJH(UVHW]WNDXPDXIGLH'LPHQVLRQDIIHNWLYHQ(UOHEHQVVRQ GHUQDXIHLQHÄQFKWHUQ>H@XQGOHEHQVSUDNWLVFKRULHQWLHUWH>@)U|PPLJNHLW>@³ PLWNODUHUVLWWOLFKHU$E]ZHFNXQJ'LHVOlVVWVLFKDXFKDQKDQGVHLQHU3UHGLJWHQ YHUGHXWOLFKHQGLHVR]LDOH6FKLHIODJHQGLUHNWDQVSUHFKHQXQGPLWWHOVPRUDOLVFKHU :LU$SSHOOHGHUHQhEHUZLQGXQJDQ]XEDKQHQYHUVXFKHQ Ä)UHLKHLWGLH%HVWDQGKDWZHLOVLHYRU*RWWJLOWNDQQQXUGLH)UHLKHLWDXV $QHUNHQQXQJVHLQ³KHLWHVHWZDLQHLQHU JHKDOWHQHQ3UHGLJW]X*HQ LQGHUGLHNRQWLQXLWlWVVWLIWHQGHQ*UXQGOLQLHQ YRQ:DJQHUV'HQNHQDE VFKOLHHQGQRFKHLQPDOSRLQWLHUW]XVDPPHQNRPPHQÄ)UHLKHLWGLHLQ6HOEVWEH KDXSWXQJJUQGHWHUVSDUWVLFK³KLQJHJHQGHQ8PZHJGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ$EHU DXFKGLHVH(UVSDUQLVLVWRKQH.RVWHQQLFKW]XKDEHQZLHGHU%OLFNDXIGLH)RO JHQHLQHUYRQ'XUFKVHW]XQJHJRLVWLVFKHU,QWHUHVVHQRULHQWLHUWHQ:LUWVFKDIWGHXW OLFKJHQXJ]HLJW'LHJHVFKXQGHQH1DWXUXQGGHU0HQVFKDOVGLHYHUEUDXFKWH
9JODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ :$*1(5 EI 9JODD2'RUWDXFKGDV=LWDW 9JODD2± $D2 $D2 :$*1(5 E :$*1(5 E6RODXWHW:DJQHUVREHQEHUHLWV]LWLHUWH&KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJGHU+H OLDQG)U|PPLJNHLW :$*1(5
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
:DUH$UEHLWVNUDIWZHUGHQ]XVLFKWEDUHQ=HLFKHQGDGHU8PZHJGHU$QHUNHQ QXQJQLFKWDQJHWUHWHQZRUGHQLVW>«@$OVVFKRQ$QHUNDQQWHZHUGHQZLUXQVHUH )UHLKHLWQXUEHZlKUHQZRZLUGHP(JRLVPXVGHU6HOEVWVXFKWXQGGHU$XVEHX WXQJYRQ0HQVFKXQG1DWXU(LQKDOWJHELHWHQ'DQQNRPPWYLHOOHLFKWGLHÃEHVVH UH=HLWµLQGHUZLUDOOHXQVHUHK|KHUHQ)lKLJNHLWHQRGHU)HUWLJNHLWHQLQ.XQVW 5HOLJLRQ:LVVHQVFKDIWRGHUZRLPPHUDXVEHQN|QQHQZHLOZLUQLFKWPHKU XQVHUHHLJHQHQ6NODYHQVHLQPVVHQ>«@2KQHGLH0KVDOGHV8PGHQNHQVXQG 8POHUQHQVZLUGDXFKGLHVHEHVVHUH=HLWQLFKWDXVNRPPHQN|QQHQ$EHUHVLVW ]XJOHLFKGLH0KVDOGHV8PZHJHVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDXVGHUZLUDOOHU:LGHU VWlQGH]XP7URW]VFKRQOHEHQ
)D]LW Ä:UGHHVGHP3URWHVWDQWLVPXVJHOLQJHQVLFKDOVVR]LDOHU2UW]XHPSIHKOHQDQ GHPGDV%HZXWVHLQGHU6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQSHUVRQDOHUXQGVR]LDOHU)UHLKHLW JHSIOHJWZHUGHQNDQQ³VRODXWHW:DJQHUVHLJHQHV)D]LWÄVRZlUHLKPGLH6RUJH XPVHLQH=XNXQIWDEJHQRPPHQ³'LH:DKOGHV.RQMXQNWLYVYHUOHLKWVHLQHU 'LDJQRVH$XVGUXFNGDVVGHU(QWIDOWXQJGLHVHV5HOHYDQ]SRWHQ]LDOVHLQLJH%DU ULHUHQLP:HJHVWHKHQ,QVEHVRQGHUHGDV)HVWKDOWHQDQHLQHP*RWWHVJHGDQNHQ GHUDXIHLQHUDV\PPHWULVFKHQ9HUWHLOXQJ YRQ0DFKWXQG2KQPDFKWDXIEDXW HUZHLVWVLFKKLHUDOV+HPPVFKXK*HJHQEHU-QJHOVUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVXQGNUHX ]HVWKHRORJLVFKHP 'HQNHQ GDV LQ GLHVHP %H]LHKXQJVJHIlOOH YHUKDIWHW LVW VR ZXUGHVFKRQLPhEHUJDQJVNDSLWHOGHXWOLFKHUZHLVWVLFK:DJQHUV3RVLWLRQDEHU DOVSODXVLEOH$OWHUQDWLYH 'LHWKHRORJLVFKH5HGHYRQHLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQDOV HLQHVVHOEVWlQGLJIUHLHQ6XEMHNWVNDQQGHPQDFKQLFKWVRYHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ GDVVGHU0HQVFKLQVFKOHFKWKLQQLJHU3DVVLYLWlWHLQHPLKQEHVWLPPHQGHQ$QGH UHQDXVJHVHW]WLVW9LHOPHKUEHGDUIDXFKHLQHQRFKVRDOOPlFKWLJH,QVWDQ]HLQHV *HJHQEHUVDQGHPVLHLKUH$OOPDFKW]XU'DUVWHOOXQJ]XEULQJHQYHUPDJXQG YRQGHPVLHVRVHOEVWDEKlQJLJLVW:DJQHUVLP$QVFKOXVVDQ+HJHOYRUJHQRP PHQH5HIOH[LRQHQ]XP9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWXQG)UHPGEHVWLPPXQJ KDEHQ GHVVHQ P|JOLFKHU 9HUHLQVHLWLJXQJ LKUHU ORJLVFKHQ 8QP|JOLFKNHLW EHUIKUW 'DIUVWHKWGLHFKULVWOLFKH=HQWUDOYRUVWHOOXQJYRP*RWWHVWRGLQGHUMHQH/RJLN GHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPWGHU]XIROJHMHGHV6HOEVWVHLQLPPHU VFKRQHLQ$QGHUVVHLQYRUDXVVHW]WDXIGHVVHQ$N]HSWDQ]KLQVLFKWOLFKGHUHLJHQHQ )UHLKHLWHVQXU]lKOHQNDQQZHQQHVLKPGLHVHHEHQIDOOV]XELOOLJW 'DVVLQQHUKDOEGHU7KHRORJLHHWZDEDUWKVFKHU3UlJXQJDQ*RWWHVEHJULIIHQ IHVWJHKDOWHQZLUGGLHVLFKEHUGLHVHORJLVFK]ZLQJHQGH(LQVLFKWPLWWHOVHLQHU ZRKHUDXFKLPPHUJHZRQQHQHQK|KHUHQ9HUQXQIWJODXEHQKLQZHJVHW]HQ]X
$D2II :$*1(5 E
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
N|QQHQ JHKW LQ :DJQHUV $XJHQ DXI .RVWHQ GHU PRGHUQHQ 9HUPLWWHOEDUNHLW FKULVWOLFKHU7UDGLWLRQVJHKDOWH:LH]XOHVHQZDUEHWUDIVHLQH.ULWLNDEHUVFKOLH OLFK DXFK GLH HLJHQH 3RVLWLRQ GHUHQ DEVROXWKHLWVWKHRUHWLVFKH )XQGLHUXQJ ]X QlFKVWQRFKGHP9HUVXFKJDOW*RWWDOVDXVVLFKVHOEVWVHLHQG]XGHQNHQ:DJ QHUVUDGLNDOH:HQGHPDFKWGDQQ(UQVWPLWGHUYRQLKPDXVJHUXIHQHQ5HYROXWLR QLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV*RWWZLUG]XP3UlGLNDWYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHU KlOWQLVVHQLQGHQHQMHGH$QPXWXQJDQGHQ6XEMHNWUHVSHNWLYH6XEVWDQ]FKDUDN WHU GHV $EVROXWHQ GDGXUFK JHWLOJW LVW GDVV 6HOEVW XQG $QGHUVVHLQ VLFK LKUHU NRQVWLWXWLYHQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ5HODWLYLWlWEHZXVVWJHZRUGHQVLQG ,QQHUKDOEGHUGXUFK6lNXODULVLHUXQJVSUR]HVVHYRQUHOLJL|VHU%HYRUPXQGXQJ EHIUHLWHQ0RGHUQHNDQQHLQYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGYHUVWDQGHQHV&KULVWHQWXP LQ:DJQHUV$XJHQVHLQHLQJDQJVEHQDQQWHV5HOHYDQ]SRWHQ]LDOHQWIDOWHQXQG]X QHXHU *HOWXQJ JHODQJHQ 'LH YRQ LKP KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWH VSH]LILVFK PRGHUQH $PELYDOHQ]VLFKHLQHUVHLWVDOVIUHLHV,QGLYLGXXPDQHUNDQQWZLVVHQ]XN|QQHQ XQGDQGHUHUVHLWVEHLP9HUVXFKGLHVHV$QHUNDQQWVHLQOHEHQVSUDNWLVFK]XUHDOL VLHUHQDXIGLHQRUPDWLYHQ(UZDUWXQJVPXVWHUVR]LDOHU)XQNWLRQVV\VWHPH]XWUHI IHQZLUGGDEHL]XPUHOLJL|VHQ7KHPDVFKOHFKWKLQ'LH5HGHYRQ*RWWGLHQWVR GHP%HZXVVWZHUGHQGHUZHVHQWOLFKHQ5HODWLYLWlWDOOHUQXUYHUPHLQWOLFKHQ$EVR OXWLVPHQLQNOXVLYHGHUHLJHQHQ9HUVXFKHHLQHDEVROXWH3RVLWLRQDXI]XEDXHQ ,PPDQHQWH7UDQV]HQGHQ]HQHUJHEHQVLFKZHQQGHQHLJHQHQ)UHLKHLWVDQVSU FKHQGLH$QHUNHQQXQJYHUZHLJHUWZLUGREZRKOVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVVHDXIGHUHQ JOHLFKPlLJH(LQUlXPXQJDQJHOHJWVLQG6LHN|QQHQVLFKUHOLJL|VDUWLNXOLHUHQ ZHQQGDIUGLH0LWWHOEHUHLWVWHKHQ HWZDYHUPLWWHOVGHU5HGHYRQGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ Ä$QHUNHQQXQJDXVGHUZLUDOOHU:LGHUVWlQGH]XP7URW]VFKRQOHEHQ³(LQ NRQWUDIDNWLVFKHV)HVWKDOWHQDQGHQHLJHQHQ(UZDUWXQJHQLP9HUWUDXHQDXIP|J OLFKH9HUlQGHUXQJHQYHUPDJGDGXUFKHEHQVRLQLWLLHUW]XZHUGHQZLHGLH(LQ VLFKWLQGLH1RWZHQGLJNHLWGDVV)UHLKHLWVR]LDOH*UHQ]HQKDWZHLOVLHQXU]X VDPPHQPLWGHU)UHLKHLWGHU$QGHUHQDXVXQGGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJUHDOLVLHUEDU LVW ,QGLHVHU)XQNWLRQV]XVFKUHLEXQJDQGLH5HOLJLRQOLHJWQHEHQGHPGDIUJUXQG OHJHQGHQ0RWLYGHU5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVGDVJURH3RWHQ]LDO YRQ:DJQHUV7KHRORJLHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ(VZLUGDEHU]XP7HLOGDGXUFKYHU VSLHOWGDVVGHU$N]HQWZLHEHUHLWVLP/DXIHGHV.DSLWHOVDQJHNOXQJHQLVWVHKU GHXWOLFKDXIGHU±LGHDOHUZHLVHHUIOOWHQ±VR]LDOHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVORJLN OLHJW 5HOLJLRQ ZLUG GDEHL WHQGHQ]LHOO DXI GDV (LQVHKHQ ]ZLQJHQGHUORJLVFKHU(LQVLFKWHQUHGX]LHUWGLHGDV6XEMHNW]XHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ /HEHQVSUD[LVDQKDOWHQGHUHQ=LHOGLHÄÃEHVVHUH=HLWµ³YHUV|KQWHU$QHUNHQ QXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHLVW6ROFKHV3HUIHNWLELOLWlWVGHQNHQDEHUYHUOLHUWWHQGHQ]LHOOGLH (UIDKUXQJHQGHV1LFKW*HOLQJHQVXQGGLH.RQIURQWDWLRQPLWGHP1LFKWVHLQ 6ROOHQGHQLQLKUHU(LJHQKHLWDXVGHP%OLFN'LHVHDXVGHU(QGOLFKNHLWPHQVFKOL
:$*1(5 (EG
$)DON:DJQHU *RWWDOV3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ
FKHQ/HEHQVUHVXOWLHUHQGHQ3KlQRPHQHZHUGHQGDQQLQLKUHPGLHIDNWLVFKH/DJH WUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUWHQGHQ]LHOO]XEORHQ3ODW]KDOWHUQHLQHVQRFKQLFKW HUUHLFKWHQ DEHU GXUFK SUDNWLVFKH $QVWUHQJXQJHQ HUUHLFKEDUHQ ,GHDO]XVWDQGV 0LWKLQZLUGÃ*RWWµVR]XP,QEHJULIIHLQHVQRUPDWLYHQ6ROOHQVHUNOlUWGDVGHQ 6XEMHNWHQGLHhEHUZLQGXQJHJRLVWLVFKHQ6LFK%HKDXSWHQV]XJXQVWHQGHU$QHU NHQQXQJ $QGHUHU DEYHUODQJW ZREHL VLH LP 6FKHLWHUQ GDUDQ JOHLFKVDP DOOHLQ JHODVVHQZHUGHQ'LH)UHLKHLWLKUHV6HOEVWVHLQVUHGX]LHUWVLFKIU:DJQHUDP (QGHGRFKZLHGHUGDUDXIGHUDEVROXWJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVORJLNLQGHU9HU EXQGHQKHLWPLW$QGHUHQ]XU5HDOLVLHUXQJ]XYHUKHOIHQZREHLGLH)UDJHLVWZDV VLHGD]XEHUKDXSWPRWLYLHUWXQGLQVWDQGVHW]WZHQQHVQLFKW=ZDQJVHLQVROO Ä*HKKLQXQGWXGHVJOHLFKHQ³±GHUYRQ:DJQHU]LWLHUWHMHVXDQLVFKH$XVVSUXFK ]%/N VSULFKWQLFKWQXUDQZDVGLHÄYROOHQGHWH3UlVHQ]³HLQHUÄYHUV|K QHQGHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ³ P|JOLFK PDFKW VRQGHUQ DXFK ZR DQJHVLFKWV GHU $V\PPHWULHQVR]LDOHQ/HEHQVGLH*UHQ]HQYRQGHUHQ5HDOLVLHUEDUNHLWOLHJHQ 9RUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGLVWGLH)UDJH]XVWHOOHQREGLHLPPHUZLHGHUVLFKHLQ VWHOOHQGHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQ]ZLVFKHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVDQVSUFKHQXQG GHUHQVR]LDOHU(UIOOXQJEHUKDXSWLQ*lQ]H]XEHUZLQGHQVLQG:HUVLHYHU QHLQW PVVWH VWlUNHU QRFK DOV :DJQHU GLH Ä=ZLVFKHQODJH PHQVFKOLFKHQ 'D VHLQV³]XP$XVJDQJVSXQNWVHLQHV'HQNHQVPDFKHQ'DVEHGHXWHWGLHVR]LDOH 1LFKW(QWVSUHFKXQJGHV6XEMHNWVDOVJHQXLQH(UIDKUXQJYRQ)UHLKHLW]XZUGL JHQXQGGDQDFK]XIUDJHQZDVHV]XU6HOEVWEHUVFKUHLWXQJLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ $QGHUHUEHUKDXSWPRWLYLHUW*HQDXGLHVNDQQDOVHLQH%HVRQGHUKHLWGHU3RVLWLRQ 7UDXJRWW.RFKVDQJHVHKHQZHUGHQGLHLP)ROJHQGHQ]XQlFKVWLP.RQWUDVW]X :DJQHU]XP7KHPDZLUG
:$*1(5 :$*1(5
hEHUJDQJ .RFKYV:DJQHURGHU ZDUXP $QHUNHQQXQJQLFKWGDV$EVROXWHLVW Ä.RUUHVSRQGHQ]YHUKlOWQLVVH>Q@ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ³ MHGHQIDOOV ÄVRIHUQ VLH GHU V\PPHWULVFKHQ 6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW YRQ 6HOEVWVHLQ XQG $QGHUVVHLQ YHUSIOLFKWHW VLQG³LVWQDFK)DON:DJQHUV IRUPXOLHUWHUhEHU]HXJXQJÄGDV3UlGLNDWÃDE VROXWµYRUEHKDOWHQ³0LWGHPJHJHQEHUVNHSWLVFKHP7RQIUDJW7UDXJRWW.RFK LP7LWHOHLQHVLPJOHLFKHQ-DKUJHKDOWHQHQ9RUWUDJV $QHUNHQQXQJ±GDV$EVROX WH"=XHLQHPVHLQHU]HLWLQ:LHQDOVRDQ:DJQHUVGDPDOLJHU:LUNXQJVVWlWWH YHUDQVWDOWHWHQ6\PSRVLXPGDVLQWHUGLV]LSOLQlUHQ'LPHQVLRQHQGHV$QHUNHQ QXQJVEHJULIIVJHZLGPHWZDUVWHXHUWH.RFKXQWHUGLHVHUhEHUVFKULIWGLHWKHROR JLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHEHL,P=XJHGHVVHQEH]RJHUVLFKNULWLVFKDXIGHQ.ROOHJHQ GHULKPVHLWGHUJHPHLQVDPHQ=HLWDP0DLQ]HUXQG0QFKQHU/HKUVWXKO:ROI KDUW3DQQHQEHUJVEHNDQQWZDUZRVLHEHLGHLQGHQ HU-DKUHQPLW'LVVHUWD WLRQHQ]XP'HQNHQ+HJHOVUHVVLHUWHQ .RFKJHKWHVZLHHUJOHLFK]X$QIDQJVHLQHV%HLWUDJVNODUPDFKWDXVGUFN OLFKGDUXPGLHXDYRQ:DJQHUHUKREHQHÄ7KHVH>]X@EHVWUHLWHQGDVVÃ$QHU NHQQXQJµHLQRGHUGHU%HJULIIGHV$EVROXWHQLVW³XQGÄGDJHJHQ]X]HLJHQ>«@ DOV ZDVGDV $EVROXWH³HLJHQWOLFKÄ]XGHQNHQLVW³%HYRU.RFKV3RVLWLRQLP IROJHQGHQ.DSLWHODXVIKUOLFKJHZUGLJWZLUGWULWWVLHDXVJHKHQGYRQGLHVHP 7H[WVFKRQHLQPDODP/HLWIDGHQLKUHVNULWLVFKHQ%H]XJVDXI:DJQHUYRU$XJHQ 1DFKGHP GDUJHOHJW ZXUGH ZDUXP DXV VHLQHU 6LFKW ÄUH]LSURNH $QHUNHQQXQJ QLFKWGDV$EVROXWHLVW³ ULFKWHWVLFKGHU%OLFNGDUDXIZLHGHQQ.RFK]XIROJH VWDWWGHVVHQÃGDV$EVROXWH]XGHQNHQLVWµ
:$*1(5 ,QGHQIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWVLQGZ|UWOLFKH$XV]JHHLQJHJDQJHQ DXV 7(7=/$))E 9JO.2&+D'HU$XIVDW]LVWXUVSUQJOLFKYHU|IIHQWOLFKWZRUGHQLPYRQ:ROIJDQJ 6FKLOG KHUDXVJHJHEHQHQ 7DJXQJVEDQG ]XU LP )ROJHQGHQ HUZlKQWHQ 7DJXQJ Ä]XP 7KHPD Ã$QHUNHQQXQJDOVUHFKWOLFKHVSKLORVRSKLVFKHVXQGWKHRORJLVFKHV3UREOHP³GLHVRGHU+H UDXVJHEHU:ROIJDQJ6FKLOGÄYRQ(GLWK'VLQJ7UDXJRWW.RFKXQGPLUYRUEHUHLWHW>@XQGYRP ± LQ:LHQGXUFKJHIKUW>@³ZXUGH 6&+,/' YJO]X.RFKV%HLWUDJ DD2 ± .2&+D $XVGUFNOLFKHNULWLVFKH%H]JHDXI:DJQHUILQGHQVLFK DD2 $QPXQGI $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:DUXP$QHUNHQQXQJQLFKWGDV$EVROXWHLVW« (VOlJHLKPÄJlQ]OLFKIHUQ³VFKUHLEW.RFK GHQHLQVFKQHLGHQGHQ)RUWVFKULWW]XYHUNHQQHQGHQ:DJQHUV.RQ]HSWLRQLQLKUHU:HLVHZLH GHUJLEW GDVV*RWWGDV$EVROXWHJHGDFKWZLUGDOVIUHLYRQ0DFKWXQG+HUUVFKDIWXQGGDVVHV JHGDFKWZLUGÃDP2UWGHV$QGHUVVHLQVµVHLQH$EVROXWKHLWDOVREHJULIIHQZLUGDOVHLQ=XJOHLFK %HLP$QGHUHQ6HLQ
'HU*UXQGJHGDQNHMHQHUÃ5HYROXWLRQLHUXQJGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVµGHPQDFKGDV DV\PPHWULVFKH *HIlOOH ]ZLVFKHQ DOOPlFKWLJHP +HUUJRWW XQG RKQPlFKWLJHP 0HQVFKHQ]XJXQVWHQHLQHVV\PPHWULVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHV]XEHU ZLQGHQLVWOHXFKWHWLKP]XGHVVHQZLFKWLJVWHQ5HIHUHQ]DXWRUHQ+HJHO]lKOW DOVRGXUFKDXVHLQ6RVHW]WDXFKHUVLFKDXVGUFNOLFKYRQ7UDGLWLRQHQDEGLHGHQ Ä*ODXEHQDQ*RWW>«@DOVHLQ$EKlQJLJNHLWVYHUKlOWQLV³NHQQ]HLFKQHQÄGDVPDQ XP GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 2KQPDFKW ZLOOHQ Q|WLJ KDEH³ 'HP JHJHQEHU ODXWHW .RFKV/RVXQJ ÄZHQQ*ODXEHGDQQIUHLHU*ODXEH³RGHUDXFKÄZLVVHQWOLFKHU ZLOOHQWOLFKHU*ODXEH³*HPHLQWLVWHLQÄEHZXVVWH>U@9ROO]XJ³ LQGHPHLQHU ZHLZDVHUWXWZHLOHUGDULQXPVLFKVHOEVWZHL8QZHLJHUOLFKZRKQWGLHVHU 6HOEVWEH]XJZLH.RFKEHWRQWMHJOLFKHU%H]RJHQKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVDXI$QGHUH XQG$QGHUHVLQQH'DGXUFKYHUPDJHV]XDOOHPXQGMHGHPDXI'LVWDQ]]XJHKHQ XQGVLFKQRFKHLQPDOLQV9HUKlOWQLV]XVHW]HQRKQHGXUFKLUJHQGHWZDVRGHU LUJHQGZHQDEVROXWEHDQVSUXFKWZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQÄ6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQLVW³VR KlOW.RFKSRLQWLHUWIHVWÄGLH)lKLJNHLW]XZLVVHQGDPDQLQDOOHPZDVPDQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKXQGSULYDWLVWXQGWXWVHOEVWHWZDVXQGDOVRHWZDVXQDXVWDXVFK EDU(LJHQHVLVW³,QGLHVHPDXINHLQHQÄ8UVSUXQJVHLQHUMHQVHLWVVHLQHUVHOEVW³ ]XUFN]XIKUHQGHQ XQG LQVRIHUQ ÄXQDEOHLWEDU>HQ@³ RGHU ÄDQ VLFK DEVROXWH>Q@ 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ³HQWGHFNWHUGHQXQEHGLQJWHQ*UXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU)UHLKHLW ,P %OLFN GDUDXI LVW GHU 0HQVFK ÄDOV VHOEVW HWZDV *|WWOLFKHV 8QEHGLQJWHV³ DQ]XHUNHQQHQZREHLVROFKHÄ$QHUNHQQXQJ>«@LPPHU³QXUÄHLQH%HVWlWLJXQJ XQG(LQVHW]XQJGHVVHQ>LVW@ZDVVLHDQHUNHQQW³QLFKWDEHUGHVVHQ+HUYRUEULQ JXQJ:RGLHVHJ|WWOLFKXQEHGLQJWH'LPHQVLRQIUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGHP0HQ VFKHQVR]LDOQLFKW]XJHVWDQGHQZLUGVLHKW.RFKDXFKGHVVHQ:UGHPLVVDFKWHW 'DVEHWULIIWVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVVHLQGHQHQ±DQGHUVDOVLPIU.RFKQLHKRFK JHQXJ]XVFKlW]HQGHQIUHLKHLWOLFKGHPRNUDWLVFKHQ5HFKWVVWDDW±GLH6SKlUHGHV
$D2 .2&+ E $D2 $D2I $D2 .2&+ D (EG .2&+P .2&+D
hEHUJDQJ .RFKYV:DJQHU
*HZLVVHQVLQKDOWOLFK]XUHJOHPHQWLHUHQYHUVXFKWZLUG$XFKLVWGDEHLDEHUHLQH Ä7KHRORJLH³LP%OLFNGLH GHQ*HGDQNHQGHU$XWRQRPLHDOV6FKODJZRUWEHQXW]WXP]XXQWHUVWHOOHQLQDOOHP'HQNHQ GDVGLH$EVROXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWV>«@GHQNWWUHLEHQXUGLHDOWH8UVQGHGHV0HQVFKHQGLH +\EULVDOV6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJXQG6HOEVWYHUJ|WWOLFKXQJLKU8QZHVHQ
6RVHKUHVLKPDEHUDXFKGLH)URQWVWHOOXQJJHJHQVROFKHWKHRORJLVFKHQ5HVHUYHQ LP%OLFNDXIGLH)UHLKHLWXQG$XWRQRPLHPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVPLW:DJQHU JHPHLQVDPLVW .RFKZLGHUVSULFKWHQHUJLVFKGHVVHQ UDGLNDOLVLHUWHP %HJULIIGHV ÄDEVROXWH>Q@*HLVW>HV@³GK*RWWHVDOVÄ>L@QGHUVR]LDOHQ3UD[LV³JHOLQJHQGHU ÄZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³PDQLIHVWHPÄ*HLVWGHUYHUV|KQHQGHQ$QHUNHQ QXQJ³IUGHVVHQ5HDOLVDWLRQHVQXUQRFKHLQHQWVSUHFKHQGHLQVLFKWLJHV+DQ GHOQ QDFK GHP MHVXDQLVFKHQ 0RWWR Ä*HK KLQ XQG WX GHVJOHLFKHQ³ EUDXFKH :RUWZ|UWOLFKPRQLHUWHUGDVVEHL:DJQHU EHUGLHJHLVWLJH3UD[LVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOV3UR]HVVGHVZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQHQVXQG $QHUNDQQWVHLQVKLQDXVQLFKWGHU*HLVWDQVLFKVHOEHUJHGDFKW>ZLUG@GHU8QWHUVFKLHGHQHGLH VLFKJHJHQVHLWLJDQHUNHQQHQXQGDFKWHQPLWHLQDQGHUYHUELQGHWYHUHLQWXQGPLWVLFKVHOEVW YHUV|KQW
'DEHLOLHJWGHU$N]HQW]XQlFKVWHLQPDOGDUDXIGDVVHVHEHQVWHWVXQWHUVFKLHGOL FKH6XEMHNWHVLQGGLHVLFKLQVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQDXIHLQDQGHUEH]LHKHQ,KUH 'LIIHUHQ]LQGHUVLHJUXQGVlW]OLFK]XHLQDQGHUVWHKHQZLUG.RFK]XIROJHQLFKW VFKRQGXUFKGLHJHJHQVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJDOVMHZHLOVLUJHQGZLH%HVWLPPWH± ]%DOV)UHXQGLQ(KHSDUWQHU)DPLOLHQPLWJOLHG6WDDWVEUJHULQ0DUNWWHLOQHK PHU±EHUEUFNW9LHOPHKUUHODWLYLHUWVLFKMHJOLFKHGHP6XEMHNWLQ$QHUNHQ QXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ]XNRPPHQGH%HVWLPPWKHLWLQVRIHUQDOVEHUGHVVHQZLH JHVDJWXQKLQWHUJHKEDUHV6HOEVWXQG(LJHQVHLQYRQDQGHUZlUWVKHUQLFKWYHUIJW ]XZHUGHQYHUPDJ'HVKDOEDOVRLVWLQ.RFKV$XJHQÄUH]LSURNH$QHUNHQQXQJ QLFKWGDV$EVROXWH³ZHLOGDEHLNHLQHVZHJVVLFKHULVWREXQGZLHGLH%HWHLOLJ WHQVLFKGDVLKQHQLP6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLV=XJHVFKULHEHQHXQGYRQLKQHQ(UZDUWHWH MHZHLOVVHOEVWDQHLJQHQ$QGHUVJHVDJW 2EPHLQ*HJHQEHUÃKLQJHKWXQGGHVJ OHLFKHQWXWµLVWQLFKWVZDVLQPHLQHU+DQGOLHJWXQGXPJHNHKUW:LUN|QQHQXQV QXUGLHKLHUIUHQWVFKHLGHQGH)UHLKHLWZHFKVHOVHLWLJJHZlKUHQXQGDXIGDVEOHL EHQGXQDXVJHPDFKWH*HOLQJHQXQVHUHVGDPLWDQJHEDKQWHQ=XVDPPHQILQGHQV YHUWUDXHQ:RPDQGLHVGLHMHZHLOV$QGHUHQDQHUNHQQHQGXQGIUHLODVVHQGWXW DEHUNRPPWIU.RFKDOOHUHUVWGDV$EVROXWHNRPPW*RWWLQV6SLHO DOVGDVÄZDV .2&+ E I ,P %OLFN LVW ]% HLQPDO PHKU .DUO %DUWK GHVVHQ WKHRORJLVFKH $QWKURSRORJLHODXW.RFKDPZLGHUVSUFKOLFKHQ9HUVXFKNUDQNWÄGHQ0HQVFKHQDOV6XEMHNW]X GHQNHQXQGLKQGRFKXQGLQMHGHP 6LQQH]XÃHQWPlFKWLJHQµLKQWRWDO*RWW]XXQWHUVWHOOHQ³ DD2 :$*1(5 $D2 .2&+D+HUYRUKG9HUI $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH6XEMHNWHHLQWRGHUYHUELQGHW±VRHLQWGDVVMHGHVGDULQVLFK VHOEVWDOVYHUVWDQGHQHUIDKUHQNDQQ³DOVLKUNRQWLQJHQWVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGHUQLFKW HU]ZLQJEDUHUVRQGHUQQXU]XHUKRIIHQGHUÄ*HLVWGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLW³ :lKUHQGIU:DJQHUÄGHU*HGDQNHGHU6\PPHWULHVWDWWGHVDOWHQGHU$V\P PHWULHDOOHLQGLHWKHRORJLVFKH3RLQWH³]XVHLQVFKHLQWLVWIU.RFKDOVRPLW GHPZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ6LFK=XJHVWHKHQYRQ)UHLKHLWLP$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV QRFKOlQJVWNHLQYHUV|KQOLFKHV(QGHHUUHLFKW=ZDULVWGDVTXDVDQNWLRQVEHZHKU WHPÄ5HFKW³UHODWLYVLFKHUJHVWHOOWH$QHUNDQQWZHUGHQGXUFK$QGHUHÄGLHlXHUH (UP|JOLFKXQJVROFKHU)UHLKHLW³GLHVLFKGHPÄYHUV|KQHQGH>P@*HLVW³|IIQHW ZHVKDOE HU GDV 5HFKW ZLH QRFK GHXWOLFK ZHUGHQ ZLUG QLFKW K|KHU VFKlW]HQ N|QQWH'RFKJLOWQDFK.RFKHEHQHLQVFKUlQNHQG Ä5HFKWVFKDIIWQLFKW)UHLKHLW EULQJWVLHQLFKWKHUYRU³VRQGHUQÄUlXPWVLHHLQ³RKQHGDPLWGHUHQLQQHUHYRQ DXHQKHUXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUHZHLOXQEHGLQJWH'LPHQVLRQHLQIUDOOHPDOQRUPD WLYLQGLH3IOLFKWQHKPHQ]XN|QQHQ(UVWZRGLHVJHVFKLHKWZRDOVRGLHVLFK ZHFKVHOVHLWLJDQHUNHQQHQGHQ6XEMHNWHGLH9HUEXQGHQKHLWXQG*HPHLQVDPNHLW PLWGHPMHZHLOVDQGHUHQZDKUKDIWVHOEVWZROOHQXQGIUVLFKYHUELQGOLFKVHLQ ODVVHQPDQLIHVWLHUWVLFKQDFK.RFKGHUÄDEVROXWH*HLVW³DOVR*RWWÄ>L@QGHU VR]LDOHQ3UD[LV³DOVÄ*HLVWGHUYHUV|KQHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³6HLQH)RUGH UXQJGLHVHUÄ*HLVW³VHLÄEHUGHQ3UR]HVVGHVZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQHQVXQG $QHUNDQQWVHLQVKLQDXV>«@DQVLFKVHOEHU³]XGHQNHQPDFKWDEHUNODUGDVVHU LKQQLFKWZLH:DJQHU]XPLQGHVWWHQGHQ]LHOOIUYROOHQGVLQV6R]LDOHHLQKROEDU KlOW$PXQDEOHLWEDUXQEHGLQJWHQÄ6HOEVWVHLQ>«@GHV0HQVFKHQ³KDWYLHOPHKU ÄGLHWKHRORJLVFKH7KHVHGD*RWW³±RGHUGLHÃJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJµ±DOOHVLQ DOOHP>«@VHLQZLUG>«@LKUH*UHQ]H³GLHDOOHUGLQJVLP*HOLQJHQMHQHUHLJHQV JHZROOWHQ*HPHLQVDPNHLWMHXQGMHEHUVFKULWWHQZLUG =ZLVFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]XQG9HUV|KQXQJVRGHU7LWHOYRQ.RFKV HLQJHUHLFK WHU'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWGLHGHU7KHRORJLH*:)+HJHOVQDFKVHLQHU:LVVHQ VFKDIWGHU/RJLNJHZLGPHWLVWEHVWHKWGHPQDFKHLQEOHLEHQGHV6SDQQXQJVYHU KlOWQLV $QKDQGGLHVHU$UEHLWGLHDP $QIDQJVHLQHVWKHRORJLVFKHQ'HQNHQV VWHKWVROOQXQQRFKNODUHUNRQWXULHUWZHUGHQZLHDXVVHLQHUYRQ:DJQHUDEZHL FKHQGHQ6LFKWGDV$EVROXWH]XGHQNHQLVW
$D2 I $D2 $D2 .2&+P :$*1(5 (EG9RQ*RWWDOVÄ*HLVWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³NDQQLQGLHVHP6LQQHDXFK.RFKVSUHFKHQ YJO.2&+ D D .2&+D+HUYRK.7 .2&+G
hEHUJDQJ .RFKYV:DJQHU
«XQGZLHVWDWWGHVVHQGDV$EVROXWH]XGHQNHQLVW %HUHLWVLPHUVWHQ6DW]VHLQHUGXUFK:ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJEHWUHXWHQ'LVVHUWDWL RQVVFKULIWPDUNLHUW7UDXJRWW.RFKGLHJURH+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJYRUGHUHUMHGHQ 9HUVXFK GHQ FKULVWOLFKHQ *RWWHVJHGDQNHQ ]X HUIDVVHQ XQZHLJHUOLFK VWHKHQ VLHKW=ZHLHLQDQGHUZLGHUVWUHLWHQGH%HVWLPPXQJHQVLQGGDEHLQlPOLFK]XYHU PLWWHOQ ÄGLH7UDQV]HQGHQ]*RWWHVXQGGLH)UHLJDEHVHLQHU(UNHQQWQLVGXUFKGHQ 0HQVFKHQ³ 7UDGLWLRQHOOHUZHLVH XPZHKW *RWW HEHQVR GDV *HKHLPQLV HLQHU OHW]WHQ8QEHJUHLIOLFKNHLWZLHHUVLFKSHU2IIHQEDUXQJPHQVFKOLFKHP9HUVWHKHQ JHJHQEHURIIHQ]HLJW:LUGEHLGHQ$VSHNWHQQLFKWJOHLFKHUPDHQ5HFKQXQJ JHWUDJHQIKUWGLHVLQ.RFKV$XJHQ]XVFKOXVVHQGOLFKIDWDOHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQ (QWZHGHUGUlQJWPDQ*RWWVRLQHLQZHOWDEJHZDQGWHV-HQVHLWVDEXQGHQWOHGLJW LKQDOOHU%HGHXWXQJIULUGLVFKH=XVDPPHQKlQJHRGHU*RWWGURKWXQWHU9HUOXVW VHLQHUVHOEVWHLQHUJlQ]OLFKHQ9HUGLHVVHLWLJXQJ]XYHUIDOOHQ ,P$QOLHJHQGLHVHU8QYHUV|KQOLFKNHLWQLFKWGDVOHW]WH:RUW]XODVVHQHQW GHFNW.RFKGHQ.HUQYRQ+HJHOVSKLORVRSKLVFKHU$UEHLW:DV.DQWV0HWDSK\ VLNNULWLNDXVVLFKKHUDXVJHVHW]WKDWWHHLQHQÄVWDUUHQ'XDOLVPXVGHU*RWWYRQ GHU:HOWXQGGLH:HOWYRQ*RWWDEWUHQQW³ZROOWHVLHGHPQDFKEHUZLQGHQ $OV +HJHOV$XIJHERWJHJHQVROFK]HPHQWLHUWH*HJHQVlW]HIKUW.RFKGHVVHQJUXQG OHJHQGH(LQVLFKWYRU$XJHQGDVV'LIIHUHQ]HQEHUKDXSWQXULP+RUL]RQWYRU JlQJLJHU,GHQWLWlWGHQNEDUVLQG'LH8QWHUVFKLHGHQHQN|QQHQVLFKLKUHU8QWHU VFKLHGHQKHLW RKQH HLQDQGHU JDU QLFKW JHZDKU ZHUGHQ ZRGXUFK LKQHQ LPPHU VFKRQHLQ0RPHQWYRQ(LQKHLWHLJQHWDXIGHUHQ+LQWHUJUXQGVLHDOOHUHUVWDOV MHZHLOV%HVWLPPWHHUVFKHLQHQÄ'LHVÃ+HLOµGLHVHVLQQVWLIWHQGH0LWWHGLHDOOHV 'LIIHUHQWHEHUJUHLIW³VRVFKUHLEW.RFKÄLVWIU+HJHO *RWW³:RHUVLFKDOV GDV$EVROXWHGLHDOOHVXPIDVVHQGH(LQKHLWGHPVLFKLQVHLQHQ*HJHQVWDQGYHU VHQNHQGHQ 'HQNHQ HUVFKOLHW LVW GHU *HJHQVDW] YRQ 'HQNHQ XQG 6HLQ YRQ :DKUKHLWXQG:LUNOLFKNHLWYRQ6XEMHNWLYHPXQG2EMHNWLYHPYRQ*RWWXQG :HOW(QGOLFKHPXQG8QHQGOLFKHPEHUZXQGHQ 'RFKGDVVHEHQGLHVHUUHLFKEDULVWEH]ZHLIHOW.RFKXQGEHVFKHLQLJW+HJHOLQ VHLQHU:LVVHQVFKDIWGHU/RJLN]ZDUÄGLHUHFKWH$XIJDEHHUJULIIHQDEHU>«@VLH
9JO]XP(LQIOXVVYRQ3DQQHQEHUJV+HJHOUH]HSWLRQDXIV.RFKV$UEHLW :(1= II:DV:HQ]XQWHUVFKOlJWLVWMHGRFK.RFKVVSlWHUDXVGUFNOLFKJHlXHUWH.ULWLNHUVWHQVDQ 3DQQHQEHUJV*HVFKLFKWVWKHRORJLHGHUHUDQDORJ]XUKLHUGDUJHVWHOOWHQ+HJHO.ULWLNHLQ9HU VFKOHLIHQPLWGHU5HDOLWlWGHV%|VHQHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQYRUZLUIW YJOGD]X.2&+ GII =ZHLWHQVKDW.RFKDQ3DQQHQEHUJVGLHJ|WWOLFKH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ HVFKDWRORJLVLHUHQGHU$QWKURSRORJLHGHXWOLFKH.ULWLNJHEW YJO'(56 E± .2&+ 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGHHEG $D29JO]XPLP)ROJHQGHQDXIJH]HLJWHQKHJHOVFKHQ*HGDQNHQHLQHUGDV'LIIH UHQWHLPPHUVFKRQXPJUHLIHQGHQ,GHQWLWlW DD2± ± ±XD $D29JO]X+HJHOV%HJULIIGHV'HQNHQV DD2 ±
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
]XJOHLFKWRWDOYHUIHKOW³]XKDEHQ.ULWLVFKHQ$QVWRQLPPWHUDQGHUGRUWDXV VHLQHU 6LFKW YRUDXVJHVHW]WHQ XQG GHP $QVSUXFK QDFK HUZLHVHQHQ 7KHVH GLH J|WWOLFKH ,GHQWLWlW GDV $EVROXWH N|QQH DOV OHW]WJOWLJH $XIKHEXQJ GHU VWHWV GXUFK'LIIHUHQ]HQEHVWLPPWHQ(QGOLFKNHLWJHGDFKWZHUGHQ=ZDUYHUPDJGDV 'HQNHQDXFK.RFK]XIROJHQLFKWEHLGHQ*HJHQVlW]HQHQGOLFKHQ/HEHQVVWHKHQ ]XEOHLEHQXQGLVWHVJHQ|WLJW]XULKQHQ]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGHQ(LQKHLWIRUW]XVWUH EHQ'RFKIKUWGDV(UIDVVHQGHUEHVDJWHQ(LQKHLW]XJOHLFK]XGHUHQNDWHJRULDOHU 1lKHUEHVWLPPXQJ *HK|UW ÄNRQVWLWXWLY GLH %H]LHKXQJ DXI DQGHUHV ]X GLHVHQ 1lKHUEHVWLPPXQJHQVRLVWPLWLKQHQGDV'HQNHQLQGLH(QGOLFKNHLW]XUFNJH IDOOHQ³.RFKEH]HLFKQHWGLHVHLP%HJUHLIHQGHV$EVROXWHQ±DOVR*RWWHV± ÄVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGH'LIIHUHQ]³]ZLVFKHQ'HQNHQE]Z*HGDQNHQXQG*HGDFKWHP ÄDOVQRWZHQGLJHV*HVFKLFNXQVHUHVHQGOLFKHQ5HGHQVXQG'HQNHQV³GDVÄVFKRQ EHLPHUVWHQ:RUWGDVZLUVDJHQ>«@XQDXVZHLFKOLFK³VLFKDXIGUlQJW'LH HLQKHLWVVWLIWHQGH0LWWH]ZLVFKHQGHQ*HJHQVlW]HQLVWZHQQVLHJHGDQNOLFKHU IDVVWZLUGVFKRQZLHGHULQQHXH3RODULWlWHQ]HUIDOOHQ,QLKUHUXQDEZHQGEDUHQ 9HUNHKUXQJLQV(QGOLFKHÄ]HLJW>VLH@VLFKDOVÃJHEURFKHQµ³ 0LWGLHVHU+HJHO.ULWLNGLHHUDQYHUVFKLHGHQ$EVFKQLWWHQGHU:LVVHQVFKDIW GHU/RJLNGXUFKVSLHOWZLOO.RFKDEHUNHLQHVZHJVHLQHJlQ]OLFKH8QEHJUHLIOLFK NHLW*RWWHVEHKDXSWHQ9LHOPHKUJHKWHVLKPGDUXP]XYHUGHXWOLFKHQZLHVLFK ÄLQGLHVHP9HUOXVW>GHUDEVROXWHQ(LQKHLW@JHUDGHGLHJ|WWOLFKH$EVROXWKHLWGHU XQHQGOLFKHQ(LQKHLWHUZHLVW³'DPLWVROOHQGLHREHQEHQDQQWHQ.ULWHULHQGHV FKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVHUIOOWVHLQ'HUHQHUVWHGLH:DKUXQJHLQHUPHQ VFKOLFKHV (UNHQQHQ EHUVWHLJHQGHQ 7UDQV]HQGHQ] ILQGHW EHL .RFK GHXWOLFKH %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ,QZLHIHUQLVWVHLQH3RVLWLRQDEHUGDYRUJHIHLWÄLQHLQDWKHLVWL VFKHV>«@9HUJOHLFKJOWLJHQ*RWWHVXP]XVFKODJHQ³XQGHLQIUZHOWOLFKH=X VDPPHQKlQJHOHW]WOLFKLUUHOHYDQWHV-HQVHLWV]XNRQVWUXLHUHQ"=ZHLPLWHLQDQGHU NRUUHVSRQGLHUHQGH 3HUVSHNWLYHQ GLH LUGLVFKH %HGHXWVDPNHLW MHQHU ÄOHW]WH>Q@
$D29JO]XULP)ROJHQGHQGDUJHOHJWHQ.ULWLN.RFKVDQ+HJHOXD DD2± ±±.RFKV+HJHO.ULWLNKDWGHQHUNOlUWHQ:LGHUVSUXFKSKLORVRSKLVFKHU+HJHO )RUVFKHUQDFKVLFKJH]RJHQ 9JOHWZD.,00(5/( ±GHU.RFKPLWVHLQHU.ULWLN DP9HUVXFKGDV$EVROXWHGHQNHQG]XHUIDVVHQDP(QGHÄZLHGHUEHL.DQW³DQJHNRPPHQ VLHKWÄIUGHQGLH,GHH]XGHQNHQDXIJHJHEHQDEHULQGHQ)RUPHQGHVHQGOLFKHQ'HQNHQV GRFKXQGHQNEDULVW³ 9JO]XGHP7+(81,66(1 ±EHLGHP.RFK]XP$GHSWHQ DGRUQLWLVFKHU9RUXUWHLOHJHJHQ+HJHODOVGLIIHUHQ]YHUJHVVHQHP'HQNHUHUNOlUWZLUG .2&+ $D2 $D2 .RFKYHUZHLVWKLHU-DQYDQGHU0HXOHQV$UEHLW+HJHO'LHJHEURFKHQH0LWWH YJO YG 0HXOHQ GHUHQÄNULWLVFKHQ (LQVLFKWHQ³ VHLQH 'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWÄZHLWKLQ YHUSIOLFKWHW³VHL HEG$QP 'HU8QWHUWLWHOZHLVWDXFKYRUDXVDXIGLHVR]LDOWKHRUHWLVFKHQ $QQDKPHQ.RFKV $D2 $D2
hEHUJDQJ .RFKYV:DJQHU
'LIIHUHQ]³]ZLVFKHQGHU(UNHQQWQLV*RWWHVXQG*RWWVHOEVWEHWUHIIHQGODVVHQ VLFKDXV.RFKV'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWJHZLQQHQ =XPHLQHQEHGHXWHWVRJHVHKHQÄÃ9HUV|KQXQJµ³QLFKWGDV(QGHDOOHU*HJHQ VlW]H]XJXQVWHQHLQHUDOOXPIDVVHQGHQ(LQKHLWVRQGHUQGLHMHQLJHÄ:LUNOLFKNHLW GHV$EVROXWHQ>«@GLHGDV'LIIHUHQWHVHLQOlW³'LHVEHLQKDOWHWIU.RFKHLQH $XV]HLFKQXQJGHVÄ%HVRQGHUHQXQG(LQ]HOQHQ³GDVGDQQQLFKWZLHHU+HJHO YRUZLUIW LP 6LQQH HLQHU 3ULRULWlW GHV $OOJHPHLQHQ JHZDOWWlWLJ EHUJDQJHQ ZLUG *RWWDOVGLHÄHLQHXQGHLQLJHQGH:DKUKHLW³LVWHEHQQXUÄLQ'LIIHUHQ]]X HUNHQQHQXQGDXVLKU]XHUKHEHQ³±HLQH3HUVSHNWLYHGLHSULQ]LSLHOOQLFKWEHU VFKULWWHQZHUGHQNDQQ,QHLQHPVSlWHUHQ7H[WLQGHPHU]HQWUDOH7KHVHQVHLQHU 'RNWRUDUEHLWHUQHXWDXIJUHLIWVSULFKWHUGLHVEH]JOLFKYRPÄÃ.UHX]µGHV'HQ NHQVXQGXQVHUH>U@$XV]HLFKQXQJDOVLQGLYLGXHOOEHVRQGHUH6XEMHNWH]XJOHLFK³ 'DVVÄGLHDEVROXWH:DKUKHLW>«@GLHGDV+|FKVWHXQG*|WWOLFKH³GDUVWHOOWÄQXU IUDJPHQWDULVFKXQGHQGOLFKUHODWLYLQJHVFKLFKWOLFKJHZRUGHQHQYHUJlQJOLFKHQ :RUWHQEHJULIIHQ³ZHUGHQNDQQDGHOWGHPQDFKGDVVLFKGHQNHQGDXIVLHEH ]LHKHQGH6XEMHNW'HQQHVLVW JHUDGHGDQQZHQQHVVLFKDXIGHQ%HJULIIGHU6DFKHVHOEVWHLQOlWK|FKVWLQGLYLGXHOOYRP $QGHUHQDXFK XQWHUVFKLHGHQGHQNHQGHV6XEMHNW'D:DKUKHLWVLFKLKP±LKPLQVHLQHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ(LJHQDUWXQGDOVRJDQ]VXEMHNWLY±HUVFKOLHWGDVLVWVHLQH:UGHLP'HQNHQ >«@
8PGLHVHUÃ:UGHµZLOOHQGLHGHP6XEMHNW]XNRPPWZHLOÄGLHDQXQGIUVLFK DOOJHPHLQH:DKUKHLW³ZHLO*RWWEHUKDXSWQXUYHUPLWWHOVÄVHLQHUUHODWLYHQ%H VRQGHUKHLWHUIDW³ZHUGHQNDQQHUVFKHLQWHLQHRKQHKLQXQHUVFKZLQJOLFKHÄÃUHLQH (LQKHLWµYRQGHQNHQGHP6XEMHNWXQGDQIUVLFK$OOJHPHLQHQ³.RFKDXFKÄJDU QLFKWHUVWUHEHQVZHUW³ Ä'HQQGDQQZlUHGDV$OOJHPHLQHQXUXPGHQÃ3UHLVµGHV ,QGLYLGXHOOHQQXULQGHVVHQ7RG³ 'DVVVLHHLQ]LJLQÃUHODWLYHU%HVRQGHUKHLWµHUIDVVW]XZHUGHQYHUPDJDEHUEH GHXWHWIU.RFKDQGHUHUVHLWVDXFKQLFKWGDVVPDQGLHÄDOOHYHUELQGHQGHDEVROX WH:DKUKHLW³QLFKWPHKUÄLQWHQGLHUHQ³VROOWH6RQVWJlEHPDQQlPOLFKÄGHQ *HGDQNHQGHU:DKUKHLWSUHLV³XQGHUJLQJHÄVLFKQXULQ6XEMHNWLYLVPHQ³'LH DXV6LFKWGHV6XEMHNWVXQEHUZLQGOLFKHQ*HJHQVlW]H±HWZD]ZLVFKHQVHLQHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ:DKUKHLWVHLQVLFKWXQGGHUÃDOOHYHUELQGHQGHQDEVROXWHQ:DKUKHLWµ
$D2 $D2 $D2 $D2 .2&+ G9JO]X.RFKV5HNXUVDXIVHLQH'LVVHUWDWLRQVWKHVHQ]X+HJHODXFK DD2IXQG'(56UI .2&+ G (EG (EG (EG (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
±ZLOODXFK.RFKQLFKWGHUDUW]HPHQWLHUHQGDVVJOHLFKVDPDOOHVUHODWLYVHL1XU ZHQQGHUGHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQLQQHZRKQHQGHQ1|WLJXQJ]XPhEHUVLH+LQDXVJHKHQ )ROJHJHOHLVWHWZLUGLQGHPPDQ]%$QGHUHPLWGHUHLJHQHQ:DKUKHLWVEHU]HX JXQJ]XEHU]HXJHQYHUVXFKWWUHWHQVLHEHUKDXSWHUVWLQLKUHUOHW]WKLQVLFKWOL FKHQ 8QEHUZLQGOLFKNHLW YRU $XJHQ Ä,Q GLHVHU 1|WLJXQJ PDFKW VLFK QLFKWV DQGHUHVDOVGLHDEVROXWH(LQKHLWVHOEVWJHOWHQG³GLHDXIVHLWHQGHU'LIIHUHQWHQHLQ ÄXQEHIULHGLJWHVXQJHVlWWLJWHV9HUODQJHQQDFK:DKUKHLW QDFKGHU$XIKHEXQJ LKUHU(LQVHLWLJNHLW³LQHLQHVLHXPJUHLIHQGHÄ*HPHLQVDPNHLW³HU]HXJW:RZLU GHPMHHLJHQHQ:DKUKHLWVYHUODQJHQIROJHQ]HLJHQZLUXQVGHPQDFKEHVWLPPW GXUFKGLHÄHLQHLGHQWLVFKHXQVXQHUUHLFKEDUH>@:DKUKHLW*RWWHVGLHQLFKWZLU VHOEVW>«@VLQG³XQGGLHXQVHUHPGDEHLHUKREHQHQ$QVSUXFK]XJUXQGHOLHJWGDVV ÄGLH*HEURFKHQKHLWGHV(QGOLFKHQ³QLFKWDOOHVLVW9RQLKUNDQQVLFKÄXPJULI IHQXQGJHKDOWHQ³ZLVVHQZHULP'HQNHQ±XQGDXFKGDUEHUKLQDXV±GLH(U IDKUXQJGHVÄ1LFKWJHOLQJHQV³ PDFKW 'LHVHLPXQEHGLQJWH9HUODQJHQQDFK:DKUKHLWGDVEHUGLHHQGOLFKHQ%HGLQ JXQJHQGHV'HQNHQVKLQDXVVWUHEWLPPHUVFKRQYRUDXVJHVHW]WHÄHLQH>@LGHQWL VFKHXQVXQHUUHLFKEDUH>@:DKUKHLW*RWWHV>«@DOVGDVXQV8QEHJUHLIEDUH]X GHQNHQXQG]XGHQNHQGHU(UIDKUXQJ]XEULQJHQ±GDULQPHLQHLFK³VRKHLWHV LPOHW]WHQ6DW]YRQ.RFKV'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWÄEHVWHKWGLHNRQNUHWH6DFKHGHU 7KHRORJLH³ ,QJHZLVVHUhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJPLWGHPÃVSlWHQµ:DJQHUJHODQJWDOVRDXFK .RFKLQVHLQHU+HJHO/HNWUH]XHLQHUQHJDWLYWKHRORJLVFKHQ.RQ]HSWLRQ%HLGH YHUWUHWHQVLHGLH7KHVHGDVVVLFKGDV*|WWOLFK$EVROXWHQLFKWGHQNHQGHLQKROHQ OlVVWZHLOVLFK]ZLVFKHQGHP*HGDQNHQGHV$EVROXWHQXQGGHPGDGXUFKJH GDFKWHQ$EVROXWHQVHOEVWEHL/LFKWHEHWUDFKWHWHLQHXQEHUZLQGOLFKHDXVGHU HQGOLFKHQ3RVLWLRQGHV'HQNHQVUHVXOWLHUHQGH'LIIHUHQ]DXIWXW:lKUHQG:DJQHU MHGRFKGDUDXVGDV6FKHLWHUQGHV*HGDQNHQVGHV$EVROXWHQEHUKDXSWIROJHUWGDV QXU QRFK YLD QHJDWLRQLV LQ WUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHU .ULWLN XQG .RUUHNWXU MHGZHGHU 6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJVEHVWUHEXQJHQ]XJXQVWHQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHJDOLWlUHU$QHU NHQQXQJVSUD[LVLPPDQHQWH5HDOLWlWJHZLQQWEHKDUUW.RFKDXIGHP±IUHLOLFK QLFKWÄVHSDULHUWJHVRQGHUWYRUJHVWHOOWHQ³±WUDQV]HQGHQWHQ(LJHQVHLQ*RWWHV 1XUZHQQÄ*RWWVHOEVW>«@LQNHLQHUHQGOLFKHQ%HVWLPPXQJXQG(UIDKUXQJYRQ LKPDXIJHKW³VRQGHUQLQVHLQHUÄ8QEHGLQJWKHLW³LPPHUQRFKHWZDV$QGHUHVLVW JHKWIU.RFKDXFKÄGDV(QGOLFKH>«@QLFKWDXI>@LQGHPZDVHVQXQPDOVR LVW³2GHUGDVVRHEHQ$XVJHIKUWHDXIJUHLIHQGJHVDJW 'DVVMHGHÃ%HVWLPPXQJ XQG(UIDKUXQJ*RWWHVµDQGLHÃK|FKVWLQGLYLGXHOOHµ3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHV6XEMHNWV
.2&+ $D2 (EG (EG $D2 .2&+
hEHUJDQJ .RFKYV:DJQHU
JHNQSIWLVWZHLVWGHPOHW]WHUHQHLQHXQYHU]LFKWEDUH%HGHXWXQJ]XGLHHVÃYRP $QGHUHQXQWHUVFKLHGHQµVHLQ OlVVWXQGLQGHUVHLQHXQEHGLQJWHÃ:UGHµ]XP $XVGUXFNNRPPW,QVHLQHP9HUP|JHQGDV*|WWOLFK$EVROXWH±GHQNHQGXQG HUIDKUHQG±]XLQWHQGLHUHQÃJHKWµGDV6XEMHNWDOVRÃQLFKWDXILQGHPµZDVLP 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVÃQXQPDOVRLVWµVRQGHUQJHKWHVLQPLWWHQGLIIHUHQ]EHVWLPPWHU (QGOLFKNHLW]XJOHLFKEHUGLHVHKLQDXV :RUDXI:DJQHULQ.RFKV$XJHQNHLQH$QWZRUWJLEWGLH)UDJHQlPOLFKZDV GLHDXIJUXQGGLHVHVLKUHVÃK|FKVWLQGLYLGXHOOHQµ6HOEVWVHLQVYRQHLQDQGHUÄ8QWHU VFKLHGHQH>Q@³HLJHQWOLFKÄPLWHLQDQGHUYHUELQGHW³OlVVWVLFKKLHUQRFKHLQPDO VWHOOHQ'DVVVLHÄVLFKJHJHQVHLWLJDQHUNHQQHQ³LVWHVQDFKVHLQHP'DIUKDOWHQ QLFKW'DPLWJHVWHKHQVLHVLFKQXUUH]LSURNLKUIUHLHV6HOEVWVHLQ]XXQGHQWODVVHQ GHQMHZHLOVÄ$QGHUHQLQGHVVHQLQGLYLGXHOOHVYRQNHLQHP$QGHUHQZLVVEDUHV³ HLQ]LJÄJHDKQWHUKRIIWHV>«@*XWVHLQKLQHLQ³'HQQRFKVREHVDJWHGLH]ZHLWH DXV.RFKV'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWHUKREHQHQ3HUVSHNWLYHGLHLUGLVFKH%HGHXWVDP NHLWMHQHUÃOHW]WHQ'LIIHUHQ]µ]ZLVFKHQGHU(UNHQQWQLV*RWWHVXQG*RWWVHOEVW EHWUHIIHQG (VZLGHUVSUlFKHGHUHLJHQHQ,QWHQWLRQIUV$EVROXWHGHQ*HJHQVDW] ]ZLVFKHQGHUHLJHQHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ:DKUKHLWVHLQVLFKWXQGGHUÃDOOHYHUELQGHQ GHQDEVROXWHQ:DKUKHLWµLQUHODWLYLVWLVFKHU0DQLHU]X]HPHQWLHUHQ'DVVOHW]WH UHUHLQ0RPHQWXQIDVVOLFKHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]HLJQHWLVWHLQH(LQVLFKWGLH.RFK ]XIROJHJHUDGHGDV1LFKWJHOLQJHQLPLQGLYLGXHOOHQ$XVVHLQDXIGLHÃDOOHYHUELQ GHQGHDEVROXWH:DKUKHLWµDXV]XKDOWHQHUODXEWZHLOGLHVGHUHQÃ:DKUKHLWµGDQQ QLFKWJlQ]OLFKLQIUDJH]XVWHOOHQYHUPDJ$QGHUVJHVDJW 'DVVVLFK]ZLVFKHQGHQ DXIJUXQGLKUHVÃK|FKVWLQGLYLGXHOOHQµ6HOEVWVHLQVYRQHLQDQGHUÃ8QWHUVFKLHGHQHQµ LPPHUZLHGHUNHLQH9HUEXQGHQKHLWHWZDLP6LQQHHLQHUJHPHLQVDPJHWHLOWHQ hEHU]HXJXQJDXIWXWVWHOOWQLFKWGLH0|JOLFKNHLWVROFKHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWEHU KDXSWLQIUDJH$QLKUHUSULQ]LSLHOOHQ0|JOLFKNHLWOlVVWVLFKVRIHVWKDOWHQREZRKO VLHLQGLYLGXHOOXQHUVFKZLQJOLFKHUVFKHLQW'DV$XINRPPHQ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOL FKHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWHWZDLPhEHU]HXJWVHLQYRQHWZDVHUZHLVWVLFKQlPOLFK DQJHVLFKWVVHLQHVXQDXVJHPDFKWHQ&KDUDNWHUVVHOEVWLQGHP6LQQHDOVXQIDVVEDU GDVVHVMHQVHLWVGHVLQGLYLGXHOO0DFKEDUHQOLHJWÄ'DV$EVROXWH³VRVFKUHLEW .RFKGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGÄLVWGHUXQHUVFK|SIOLFKH*HLVW³VROFKHUÄYHUV|KQHQGHQ *HPHLQVDPNHLW³XQGGDPLWGDVMHQVHLWVGHV0DFKXQG(UIDVVEDUHQOLHJHQGH ZDVYRQHLQDQGHUÄ8QWHUVFKLHGHQHGLHVLFKJHJHQVHLWLJDQHUNHQQHQ³ZHQQHV GHQQ GD]X NRPPW ÄPLWHLQDQGHU YHUELQGHW³ 'DVV HV LPPHU ZLHGHU GD]X NRPPWXQGNRPPHQNDQQLVWJOHLFKVDPGLH+RIIQXQJVSHUVSHNWLYHGHVFKULVWOL FKHQ*RWWHVJODXEHQVGLHGDPLWQRFKHLQPDODXIDQGHUH:HLVHGDUDXIVHW]WGDVV
.2&+D (EG $D2 $D2I $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
ZHLO*RWWQLFKWLP(QGOLFKHQDXIJHKWDXFKÄGDV(QGOLFKH>«@QLFKWDXIJHKWLQ GHPZDVHVQXQPDOVRLVW³QlPOLFKLPPHUQXUXQYHUV|KQW =ZLVFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]XQG9HUV|KQXQJMHLQGLYLGXHOOHU8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWXQG GHP6LFK=XVDPPHQILQGHQLQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWEHVWHKWDOVRQDFK .RFKNHLQXQEHUZLQGOLFKHU*HJHQVDW]DEHUHLQ6SDQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVGDVVLFK QXU]XODVWHQGHV6XEMHNWV]XJXQVWHQYROOHQGVÄYHUV|KQHQGH>U@$QHUNHQQXQJ³ DXIO|VHQOlVVW'LHVHULQ.RFKV'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWEHUHLWVJUXQGJHOHJWHQ6LFKW GLHVHLQHQ%OLFNDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLNOHLWHWLVWQXQLPZHLWHUHQ5DK PHQVHLQHVWKHRORJLVFKHQ'HQNHQVQDFK]XJHKHQ
.2&+ :$*1(5
$8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH $QHUNHQQXQJ 7UDXJRWW.RFKVWKHRORJLVFKH %HJUQGXQJHLQHUIUHLJHZROOWHQ6R]LDOLWlW (LQOHLWXQJ Ä>*@HJHQVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ³VRODXWHW7UDXJRWW.RFKVIUGHQ=XVDPPHQ KDQJGLHVHU$UEHLW]HQWUDOH7KHVH JHOLQJWZRKOQXUDOV]XWUDXHQGHV)UHLODVVHQGHVMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ8QGGDULQVHW]WMHGHUGHUGDV WXWDXIHLQHKRIIHQWOLFKZLHGHUVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGH*HPHLQVDPNHLWGLHGHQ$QGHUHQXQGLKQ YHUHLQW
:HLOGDVLP$QHUNHQQXQJVDNWLPSOL]LHUWHÄ)UHLODVVHQGHV$QGHUHQ³GLHVHQLQ VHLQÄLQGLYLGXHOOHVYRQNHLQHP$QGHUHQZLVVEDUHV>«@*XWVHLQKLQHLQ³HQW OlVVWLVWQLHDXVJHPDFKWREHV]ZLVFKHQ0HQVFKHQDP(QGHDXFKZLUNOLFKJXW DXVJHKWÄ$Q*RWW>]X@JODXEHQ³DEHUKHLWDXV.RFKV6LFKWQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOV ÄGDUDXI>]X@YHUWUDXHQZDVLP0LWHLQDQGHUYRQ0HQVFKHQ³GHQQRFKÄP|JOLFK ZHUGHQNDQQ³'DEHLKDWHUHEHQ(UIDKUXQJHQÃVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGHU*HPHLQVDP NHLWµLP%OLFNLQGHQHQVLFKZLHHUVFKUHLEWÄ*RWWXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQ³YHU JHJHQZlUWLJW .RFKGHQNWKLHUHWZDDQGLH/LHEHGLH:DKUKHLWXQGGDV*XWHDQV9HUVWHKHQ XQG9HUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ$OOGLHVH3KlQRPHQHGLHLQYLHOHQVHLQHU9HU|IIHQWOL FKXQJHQEHJHJQHQNRQIURQWLHUHQGHQ0HQVFKHQQlPOLFKXQZHLJHUOLFKGDPLW GDVVHUQLFKWRKQHGLH$QGHUHQ]XVHLQYHUPDJZDVHUDXVVLFKVHOEVWKHUDXVVHLQ ZLOO2EHVXPGHQ/LHEHVZXQVFKJHKWGLH:DKUKHLWVEHU]HXJXQJGDVKDQGHOQG LQWHQGLHUWH*XWHRGHUEHUKDXSWQXUXPGDV9HUODQJHQYHUVWDQGHQ]XZHUGHQ± VWHWVLVWGDULQHLQ$XVJULIIDXIGLHXQYHUIJEDUH3HUVSHNWLYH$QGHUHUHQWKDOWHQ 6LHVROOHQPHLQH/LHEHHUZLGHUQPHLQHhEHU]HXJXQJWHLOHQPHLQ*XWHVDXI
.2&+D 7HLOHGHVIROJHQGHQ.DSLWHOV$ZXUGHQEHUHLWVYHU|IIHQWOLFKWLQ 7(7=/$))D '(56E .2&+D .2&+ E .2&+J 9JOH[HPSODULVFK]XGHQEHVDJWHQ3KlQRPHQHQXQGLKUHULQWHUQHQ6SDQQXQJ .2&+ E±± E ±±± ±I± LQNO $QP
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
QHKPHQGHQ6LQQ PHLQHU:RUWHEHJUHLIHQXQGWXQHVGRFKQXU ZHQQVLHHV VHOEVWZROOHQÄ'LH&KDQFH]XU*HPHLQVDPNHLWXQGVR]XP:HLWHUNRPPHQLVW GLH:UGHGLH)UHLKHLWGHV$QGHUHQ$EHUGLHVHLVWLPPHUDXFKPHLQH2KQ PDFKW³VFKUHLEW.RFK]XVDPPHQIDVVHQGÄ:DVGHQ0HQVFKHQDXV]HLFKQHW³VR NDQQHUJDQ]lKQOLFKIRUPXOLHUHQÄLVW]XJOHLFKVHLQNDUGLQDOHV3UREOHP³ ÄGLH )lKLJNHLWYRQDOOHPZDVLKPEHZXWZLUGVLFKGLVWDQ]LHUHQ]XN|QQHQXQG GDPLWGLH)UHLKHLWQLFKWIHVWJHOHJW]XVHLQ³'LHVH$PELYDOHQ]PHQVFKOLFKHU :UGHXQG)UHLKHLWUHVXOWLHUWGDUDXVGDVVÄNHLQHLQ]HOQHUMHQXUHUVHOEVWLVROLHUW XQGEH]LHKXQJVORVIUVLFKDOOHLQ³LVW,QVHLQHPXQZHLJHUOLFKHQ(LQJHEXQGHQ VHLQLQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHZLUGGDV6XEMHNWQlPOLFKZLHDQGHQH[HPSODULVFKHQ 3KlQRPHQHQNODUJHPDFKWZXUGHLPPHUZLHGHUGDPLWNRQIURQWLHUWQLFKWRKQH GLH$QGHUHQVHLQ]XN|QQHQZDVHVDXVVLFKVHOEVWKHUDXVVHLQZLOO6RDEHU VWHKWHVYRUGHU)UDJHZLHHVGHQQRFKE]ZJHUDGHGHUDUWGDV]XVHLQYHUPDJDOV ZDVHVVLFKLQXQEHGLQJWHU)UHLKHLWEHZXVVWLVW HWZDVXQDXVWDXVFKEDU(LJHQHV 6LHHQWKlOWGLH=XPXWXQJDQGHQ0HQVFKHQXQGVHLQH)UHLKHLWQLFKWDXI'LVWDQ] ]XEOHLEHQJHJHQEHUGHQLKQEHVWLPPHQGHQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQVRQGHUQGDULQ ]XVLFK]XNRPPHQ %HLGHU%HZlOWLJXQJHEHQGLHVHUVSDQQXQJVYROOHQ/HEHQVDXIJDEHKLOIWQDFK .RFKV 'DIUKDOWHQ GHU *ODXEHGHU LQ LKU VHLQ H[LVWHQ]LHOOHV %H]XJVSUREOHP ILQGHWÄ1LFKWXPHLQHÃ3IOHJHGHU,QQHUOLFKNHLWµ³JHKWHVLQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQQlPOLFKLQVHLQHQ$XJHQÄVRQGHUQXPHLQ/HEHQLQGHQVR]LDOHQ%H ]JHQDXVGHP,QQHUVWHQGHV(LQ]HOQHQVHLQHP*RWWHVJODXEHQKHUDXV³ 'LHVHV Ã/HEHQLQGHQVR]LDOHQ%H]JHQµNDQQ.RFKDXFKVREHVFKUHLEHQGDVVÄMHGHU (LQ]HOQHDOV6XEMHNW>«@LQYLHOIlOWLJHU:HLVHLQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQGHU$QHUNHQ QXQJ³VWHKWZHLOHUÄLQHLQHUPLW$QGHUHQJHWHLOWHQ/HEHQVZHOWLVW³ :DVHV.RFK]XIROJHEHGHXWHWDOVLQYLHOIlOWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ HLQJHEXQGHQHV6XEMHNWÃDXVGHP,QQHUVWHQGHV*RWWHVJODXEHQVKHUDXVµ]XOHEHQ ZHUGHQGLHIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQJHQDXHU]HLJHQ'DVVGDPLWHLQ]HQWUDOHV 7KHPDVHLQHVQDFKHLJHQHU$XVNXQIWQHEHQ+HJHOYRUDOOHPGXUFK/XWKHUXQG .LHUNHJDDUGJHSUlJWHQ'HQNHQVYRU$XJHQVWHKWKDWVLFKEHUHLWVLQGHQ]X UFNOLHJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQDQJHGHXWHW,P%OLFNDXI.RFKVWKHRORJLVFKH%LR JUDILHGLHLKQQDFKODQJHQ-DKUHQDOV$VVLVWHQW:ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJVEHUGLH HUVWH3URIHVVXULQ5HJHQVEXUJVFKOLHOLFKDQGLH8QLYHUVLWlW+DPEXUJIKUWHLVW
.2&+ E .2&+ D (EG .2&+ E .2&+D .2&+ E 9JO ]X HLQHU DXVIKUOLFKHQ 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ YRQ .RFKV WKHRORJLVFKHP :HUGHJDQJ 7(7=/$))E±9JO]X.RFKV$QVDW]DXFK-|UJ'LHUNHQV:UGLJXQJVHLQHV:HUNV ',(5.(1
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
DQGLHVHU6WHOOHDEHUQRFKHLQHLQVFKQHLGHQGHU8PEUXFK]XHUZlKQHQ D 'DUDXI IROJWHLQhEHUEOLFNEHUGHQ$XIEDXGHV.DSLWHOV E D HUHLOWH7UDXJRWW.RFKHLQHVFKZHUH(UNUDQNXQJGLHHLQHQJHZLVVHQ :DQGHOLP6WLOVHLQHV'HQNHQVPLWVLFKEUDFKWH6HLQEHUHLWVLP5DKPHQGHU +HJHO'LVVHUWDWLRQODXWJHZRUGHQHV,QVLVWLHUHQDXIGHU'LIIHUHQ]GHUQXU]XXQ JXQVWHQGHUIUHLHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWGHV(LQ]HOQHQPLWDEVWUDNWHQ9HUV|KQXQJVEH JULIIHQ]XEHJHJQHQLVWZXUGHGDGXUFKIULKQJOHLFKVDPYRQHLQHUWKHRUHWL VFKHQ]XHLQHUH[LVWHQ]LHOOHQ$QJHOHJHQKHLW'LHUHOLJL|VH6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJXQG GHUHLJHQH*RWWHVEH]XJHQWZLFNHOWHQVLFK]XPYRUUDQJLJHQ$XVJDQJVSXQNWWKHR ORJLVFKHQ$UEHLWHQV±QLFKWLP6WLOGLVWDQ]ORVHU1DEHOVFKDXXQGIU|PPHOQGHU /HEHQVEHLFKWH,QGHQQDFKZLHYRUYRQEHJULIIOLFKHU6WUHQJHJHSUlJWHQ7H[WHQ VFKOXJ VLFK LQIROJH GHU .UDQNKHLW YLHOPHKU YHUVWlUNW HLQ HUEDXOLFK VHHOVRUJHUOLFKHVDXIGHQH[LVWHQ]LHOOHQ1DFKYROO]XJGHU/HVHQGHQDXVJHULFKWH WHV,QWHUHVVHQLHGHU$PGHXWOLFKVWHQOlVVWVLFKGHUEHVDJWH:DQGHOVHLQHP%XFK 0LW*RWWOHEHQDEOHVHQGDV.RFKVHOEVWDOVVHLQZLFKWLJVWHV:HUNDQVDK$Q .RFKV HUVFKLHQHQHU%HVLQQXQJDXIGHQ*ODXEHQZLUGPLWKLQGHXWOLFKLQ ZLHIHUQHUVLFK]XJOHLFKGXUFK+HJHO/XWKHUXQG.LHUNHJDDUGGHUHUVWVHLWGHQ HU-DKUHQIULKQ]XHLQHU]HQWUDOHQ)LJXUZXUGHJHSUlJW]HLJW Ä'LHHLQH)UDJHZLHGHU*ODXEHDQ*RWWJHOHEWZHUGHQNDQQEHVFKlIWLJWGLH VHV%XFK³VWHOOW.RFKDP$QIDQJYRQ0LW*RWWOHEHQKHUDXVÄ$OVRZLOOLFK³ KHLWHVZHLWHUÄDXVIKUHQZDVHLQ(LQ]HOQHUZLHLFKHVELQJODXEW>«@XQG LQHLQVGDPLW ZLHLFK]XOHEHQVXFKH ZDVLFKJODXEHZHLOHVIUPLFK ZDKU LVW³'DEHL]LHOW.RFKQDFKGUFNOLFKGDUDXIGDVVGLH/HVHQGHQÄVHOEVWYHUVWH KH>Q@ZDVHVPLWGHP*RWWHVJODXEHQDXIVLFKKDW³'HXWOLFKZLUGGHUOHEHQV SUDNWLVFKH%H]XJVHLQHUKLHUSUlVHQWLHUWHQ7KHRORJLHGLH$QGHUHQDXIJUXQGGHU HLJHQVHLQJHVHKHQHQ*ODXEHQVZDKUKHLWGD]XYHUKHOIHQZLOOVLFKEHULKUVHOEVW JHOHEWHV*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVNODUHU]XZHUGHQ'RFKNDQQÄGLH(UIDKUXQJGHV9HU VWHKHQV³ZLH.RFKHLQVFKUlQNHQGIRUPXOLHUWQXUÄ>G@HU(LQ]HOQH>@VHOEVWPD FKHQ³ZlKUHQGÄHLQ$QGHUHU>«@LKQGD]XEHVWHQIDOOVDQUHJHQ³NDQQ±JDQ] JUXQGOHJHQG]HLJWVLFKDXFKKLHUGLHEHUHLWVVNL]]LHUWH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ'LIIH UHQ] XQG 9HUV|KQXQJ MH LQGLYLGXHOOHU 8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLW XQG GHP 6LFK =XVDPPHQILQGHQLQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWLP9HUKlOWQLVYRQ$XWRU XQG /HVHUVFKDIW Ä0HWKRGLVFK JHVHKHQ KHLW GDV³ ZLH HU DQGHUQRUWV VHLQHQ 7KHRORJLHEHJULIIDXIGHQ3XQNWEULQJWÄGDGLH:DKUKHLW±GLH:DKUKHLWGLHDOV *RWWDXVJHVDJWZLUG±QLFKW>«@JHGDFKWZHUGHQNDQQRKQHGLH:DKUKDIWLJNHLW GHV(LQ]HOQHQLP9HUKlOWQLV]XVLFKVHOEVW]XEHGHQNHQ³XQGGLHHLJHQHQ$XV VDJHQGHVVHQXQHU]ZLQJEDUHP6LFKVHOEVWYHUVWHKHQDXV]XVHW]HQ
.2&+ E (EG $D2 $D2 .2&+K
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$XI0DUWLQ/XWKHUUHNXUULHUW.RFKDXVGUFNOLFKLQGHQ3DVVDJHQYRQ0LW*RWW OHEHQ ZR HV XP GHQ *ODXEHQVEHJULII JHKW *ODXEH LVW GHPQDFK Ä>G@DV YHU WUDXHQGH6LFKJUQGHQDXI*RWW³DOVGHQXQEHGLQJWHQ*UXQGDOOHV*XWHQVHLHV LQ6LWXDWLRQHQGHU)UHXGHRGHUGHV/HLGHQV%HLGHQ3KlQRPHQHQZLGPHW.RFK± PLWGHXWOLFKHP6FKZHUSXQNWDXIGHUDXWRELRJUDILVFKHLQJHIlUEWHQ)UDJHQDFK GHP%HVWHKHQN|QQHQGHV/HLGHQV±HLJHQH.DSLWHO 1LFKWQXULQGLHVHQOlVVWHU LPPHUZLHGHU6¡UHQ.LHUNHJDDUG]X:RUWNRPPHQÄ,P$XIEUXFKDXVGHU9HU ORUHQKHLWKHUDXVOHXFKWHWHLQZDVGLH+LOIH*RWWHVLP/HLGHQLVW 6LHLVWDQGHUV JHNRPPHQDOVHUZDUWHW³VFKUHLEWHUHWZDXQG]LWLHUW.LHUNHJDDUGV(LQEXQJLP &KULVWHQWXP ÄDEHUGLHhEHUUDVFKXQJEHUGDV.|QQHQGUFNWVLFKGDGXUFKDXV GDGHU0HQVFK*RWWGDIUGDQNW³ 'HUGlQLVFKH([LVWHQ]GHQNHUZXUGH.RFK±YHUPLWWHOWXDGXUFKGLH6FKULIWHQ (PDQXHO+LUVFKVGHVVHQ'HQNHQQXQHEHQIDOOVGXUFKVHLQH6FKULIWHQKLQGXUFK VFKHLQW±QDFKGHUHLJHQHQ.ULVHQHUIDKUXQJ]XPZLFKWLJHQ*HVSUlFKVSDUWQHU 'DV]HLJWVLFKHEHQIDOOVLQGHQIUVHLQH3RVLWLRQlXHUVWDXIVFKOXVVUHLFKHQ75( $UWLNHOQ ]XP 6WLFKZRUW Ä0HQVFK³ LQ GHVVHQ WKHRORJLHJHVFKLFKWOLFKHP $E VFKQLWW.LHUNHJDDUG±QHEHQGHP+HJHOLDQHU3KLOLSS0DUKHLQHNHEULJHQV±DOV HLQHUGHUZHQLJHQSRVLWLYEHXUWHLOWZLUG$XFKGHUV\VWHPDWLVFKWKHRORJLVFKH 3DUWVWHLJWPLWGHUDQ.LHUNHJDDUGJHPDKQHQGHQ7KHVHHLQGLHWKHRORJLVFKH $QWKURSRORJLHKDEHQXUÄHLQ7KHPD GDGHU0HQVFKVLFKZDKUKDIWYRUVLFK VHOEVWQLFKWRKQH*RWWYHUVWHKHQNDQQ±XQGGDGHU0HQVFKGDVGHQQRFKVLFK VHOEVWJUQGOLFKPLYHUVWHKHQGWXQNDQQ³'RUWVWHOOWHULQQXFHVHLQHQREHQ GDUJHOHJWHQ%HJULIIGHULQGHU8QEHGLQJWKHLWGHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQVJUQGHQGHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ )UHLKHLW YRU GLH GHQ 0HQVFKHQ HEHQVR DXV]HLFKQHW ZLH VLH LQ LKUHQ 7HQGHQ]HQ ]XU 6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJ SUREOHPDWLVFK LVW 9RU GLHVHP 6HOEVWPLVVYHUVWlQGQLVDEHULVWJHIHLWÄ>Z@HUGLH9HU]ZHLIOXQJGXUFKOLWWHQKDW XQGIROJOLFKNHQQWXQGDOVRQLFKWDQLKU]HUEURFKHQLVW³GHQQHUÄLVWVLFKVHOEVW± VDPWVHLQHUHLJHQHQ3UREOHPDWLN±ÃGXUFKVLFKWLJµLQ*RWW³'DVNRQQWH.RFK YRQ.LHUNHJDDUGXQGDXVHLJHQHU(UIDKUXQJOHUQHQ 'DPLWYHUELQGHWVLFKDEHUGLHDOOJHPHLQH7KHVHGDVVGDVPHQVFKOLFKH6XE MHNWLQVHLQHP6HOEVWVHLQZROOHQXQG1LFKWVHOEVWVHLQN|QQHQLPPHUVFKRQYRP 6HOEVWYHUOXVWYRQGHVWUXNWLYHP=ZHLIHOXQG5HVLJQDWLRQEHGURKWLVW1LFKWHWZD DOOHLQGDQQZHQQHVYRQHLQHUVFKZHUHQ.UDQNKHLWEHWURIIHQZLUGÄ>1@XUZHU GLH,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJVHLQHUVHOEVWDQQLPPW³GLHDXV.RFKV6LFKWLQDOOHQP|JOL FKHQ /HEHQVHUHLJQLVVHQ VWHFNHQ NDQQ ÄJHZLQQW GLH 6WlUNH VHOEVWlQGLJ ]X VHLQ³'LHVH6WlUNH]XUÄ)UHLKHLWLP6HOEVWVHLQ³JHZLQQWGHU0HQVFKDXV*RWW
.2&+ E9JO]XP*ODXEHQVEHJULIILQVJHVDPW '(56 E± $D2± $D2 9JO.2&+ E± $D2 $D2 .2&+ E
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
DOVGHPÄLPPHUQRFKP|JOLFKHQ6LQQ>@GXUFKDOOHV:LGHUVLQQLJHKLQGXUFKXQG GDUEHUKLQDXV³,QVEHVRQGHUHDEHUKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU*RWWHVWKHPDWLNEOHLEW+H JHO±GHUQRFKIHKOHQGH'ULWWHLP%XQGH±IU.RFKDXFKQDFKGHU.UDQNKHLW HLQHZLFKWLJH5HIHUHQ]JU|H*HJHQGHQ,QGLYLGXDOLVPXV.LHUNHJDDUGVEHWRQWHU GLH6R]LDOLWlWJOHLFKVDPDOV9HUPLWWOXQJVVSKlUHGHV*|WWOLFKHQÄ'HU$XIEUXFK DXVGHP/HLGHQKHUDXVJHVFKLHKW³VFKUHLEWHUHWZDÄZHQQGHUHEHQQRFKVLFK YHUORUHQ*HEHQGHEHLVLFKVHOEVWHUIlKUWGDHLQ$QGHUHULKQYHUVWHKWXQGDFKWHW >«@GDGRFK/LHEHLVW±DXFKIULKQ³6ROFKHXQYHUIJEDUHQ(UIDKUXQJHQ HLQHUYHUELQGHQGHQ*HPHLQVDPNHLWVLQGHVLQGHQHQVLFKIU.RFK*RWWDOVGDV $EVROXWHLP =ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ ZLHEHUHLWVHUZlKQWDOVÃ*HLVWGHU*H PHLQVDPNHLWµ EHZDKUKHLWHW6RHUHLJQHWVLFKMHQH9HUV|KQXQJEHUGLHDQJH VLFKWV GHV :LGHUVLQQLJHQ VFKLHU XQEHUZLQGOLFKH 'LIIHUHQ] GHV 1LFKW 9HUVWHKHQVKLQZHJYRQGHU.RFKVFKRQLQVHLQHU'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWVFKUHLEHQ NRQQWH 6LHÄJHZlKUWGLHJHZLVVH(LQVLFKWGDDOOH'LIIHUHQ]XPJULIIHQXQG JHKDOWHQLVWYRQGHUHLQHQLGHQWLVFKHQXQVXQHUUHLFKEDUHQ:DKUKHLW*RWWHV³ $XVJHULFKWHWDXIVLHJHODQJWGHU0HQVFKQDFK.RFKV&UHGR]XUXQEHGLQJWHQ %HMDKXQJVHLQHUVHOEVWXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGLIIHUHQ]EHVWLPPWHU(QGOLFKNHLW 8QWHUGHUHQ%HGLQJXQJHQVWHKHQDXFKGLHVR]LDOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVH LQGHQHQVLFKGHUÄ0HQVFK³LPPHUVFKRQÄDOVHLQEHVWLPPWHU³YRUILQGHWZREHL HUÄQLHPDOV>«@LQVHLQHU%HVWLPPWKHLW>DXIJHKW@>«@VRQGHUQVLFKLPPHUDXFK ]XGLHVHUVHLQHU%HVWLPPWKHLWVHOEVWXQGVR]XVLFKVHOEVW>YHUKlOW@³'DVVXQG ZLHPDQVLFKMHLQGLYLGXHOO]XPHLJHQHQ%HVWLPPWZHUGHQGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJ YHUKlOWLVWGLHIU.RFKDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWHQWVFKHLGHQGHXQGYRQGDKHULP )ROJHQGHQ]XEHGHQNHQGH)UDJH E ,Q HLQHP HUVWHQ 6FKULWW JHKW HV GDEHL XP GDV 9HUKlOWQLV YRQ *RWW XQG 0HQVFKGHVVHQHEHQVRGXUFKXQEHUZLQGOLFKH'LIIHUHQ]HQZLHVLWXDWLYH,GHQWL WlWVPRPHQWHEHVWLPPWHU&KDUDNWHUIU.RFKV%OLFNDXIVR]LDOH $QHUNHQQXQJV %H]LHKXQJHQEHUKDXSWHQWVFKHLGHQGLVW6HLQ5HOLJLRQVEHJULIIZLUGLP=XJH GHVVHQ HEHQVR HQWIDOWHW ZLH GLH EHUHLWV DQJHVSURFKHQH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ *RWWHVYRP*RWWHVEH]XJGHV0HQVFKHQ 'DUDXIKLQZLUG]XP7KHPDZDV VLFKDXVGLHVHUGH]LGLHUWWKHRORJLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHIUGLH]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH 3UD[LVLQYHUVFKLHGHQHQVR]LDOHQ6SKlUHQHUJLEW'HUHQ5HDOLWlWQlPOLFKVLHKW
$D2 $D2 9JOHWZDGLHNULWLVFKHQ:RUWHLQ.2&+J I Ä(U³.LHUNHJDDUGKHLWHVGRUW ÄH[SOL]LHUWQLFKWZLHGHU0HQVFKLQGHU$QJVWXQGDXVGHU$QJVW]XP*ODXEHQNRPPW8QG GDVKlWWHHUGHQNHLFKVFKZHUOLFKRKQH$XVIKUXQJHQEHUGHQ=XVSUXFKDQGHUHU0HQVFKHQ WXQN|QQHQ³ .2&+ E 9JO]XGLHVHU)RUPHOH[HPSODULVFK DD2 II J II .2&+ .2&+D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
.RFKVWHWVGXUFKGLHDQJH]HLJWH6SDQQXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWXQG$QHUNHQQXQJJH SUlJW
*RWWXQG0HQVFK (LQKHLWLQ9HUVFKLHGHQKHLW± 9HUVFKLHGHQKHLWRKQH(LQKHLW Ä>'@DVJDQ]H*HKHLPQLVGHVFKULVWOLFKHQ*ODXEHQVGLH*UXQGLGHHGHUFKULVWOL FKHQ5HOLJLRQ³EHVWHKWQDFK7UDXJRWW.RFKGDULQÄDXVHLQHU:LUNOLFKNHLW>]X OHEHQ@GLHDXHUKDOEPHLQHUJUQGHWXQGGLHGRFK]XWLHIVW]XLQQHUVW]XPLU± ]XPLUVHOEVW±JHK|UW³$XIGLHVH:LUNOLFKNHLW]LHOWVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVGLH5HGH YRQ*RWWGLHGHPQDFKHEHQVRHLQ,PSOLNDWPHQVFKOLFKHU6XEMHNWLYLWlWZLHHWZDV GDYRQ]XJOHLFK]X8QWHUVFKHLGHQGHV]XU6SUDFKHEULQJWÄ>=@ZLVFKHQGHPHLJH QHQ(UIDVVHQGHV$EVROXWHQXQGGHP$EVROXWHQVHOEVW³E]ZÄ]ZLVFKHQPHLQHU IUPLFKXQEHGLQJWJHOWHQGHQ(LQVLFKWYRQ*RWWXQG*RWWVHOEVW³EHVWHKWHLQH 'LIIHUHQ]GLHQXUÄ*RWWGDV$EVROXWHVHOEVW>«@IOOHQNDQQ³,KUDEHUHQW VSULFKWHLQPHQVFKOLFKHU6HOEVWYROO]XJGHUYRP9HUWUDXHQDXIGLHXQDXVVFK|SI EDUH0|JOLFKNHLWÄVROFKH>U@.RQNUHWLRQ*RWWHVXQWHU0HQVFKHQ³EHVWLPPWLVW ZDVIU.RFKHLQH2IIHQKHLWVR]LDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQJHJHQEHUEHGHXWHW+LHU QlPOLFK HQWVFKHLGHW VLFK GLH $OOJHPHLQKHLWVIlKLJNHLW GHU VWHWV LQGLYLGXHOOHQ $EVROXWKHLWVDQVSUFKH ZLH VLH YRU DOOHP LP PHQVFKOLFKHQ $XVVHLQ DXI GLH :DKUKHLWGDV*XWHXQGGLH/LHEHLPSOL]LHUWVLQG6RLVWHWZDÄ:DKUKHLW>«@ LPPHU:DKUKHLWIUDOOHXQGGRFKQXUZDKUIUGHQGHUVLHVHOEVWHLQVLHKW³ ZHVKDOEVLFKMHGHHUQVW]XQHKPHQGH:DKUKHLWVEHU]HXJXQJGHP*HVSUlFKPLW ZLGHUVSUHFKHQGHQ$QVLFKWHQDXVVHW]HQPXVV±YHUWUDXHQGDXIHLQHP|JOLFKHU ZHLVHVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGH*HPHLQVDPNHLW :RHWZDVGHUDUW9HUELQGHQGHV]ZL VFKHQ0HQVFKHQVLFKDXIWXWZLUGDXFKGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ*|WWOLFK$EVROXWHP XQG0HQVFKOLFK5HODWLYHPEHUVFKULWWHQ'LHVDEHUYHUPDJQLHPDQG]XEHZHUN VWHOOLJHQVRQGHUQHVLVW*RWWGHUÄDOVGLHVHU*HLVW>GHU:DKUKHLWXQGGHU/LHEH@ VLFKXQWHUXQVHUHLJQHWXQGVRVLFKVHOEVWHUVFKOLHW³ 8QEHUEUFNEDUH8QWHUVFKLHGHXQG]HLWZHLVH.RLQ]LGHQ]HQSUlJHQGDV*RWW 0HQVFK9HUKlOWQLVLQ.RFKV$XJHQDOVRJOHLFKHUPDHQ*DQ]DQDORJHUVFKHLQW GLH%H]LHKXQJYRQ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWXQG6R]LDOLWlWE]Z$OOJHPHLQKHLW,P+LQWHU JUXQGGLHVHU6LFKWVWHKW.RFKVDQ+HJHODQVFKOLHHQGH7KHRULHGHV$EVROXWHQ ZLHHUVLHLQVHLQHUREHQGDUJHVWHOOWHQ'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIWHQWIDOWHWKDW6HLQ DQWKURSRORJLVFKIXQGLHUWHU5HOLJLRQVEHJULII]HLJWDQZLHGLHVSDQQXQJVYROOH 'LIIHUHQ]YRQ*|WWOLFK$EVROXWHPXQG0HQVFKOLFK5HODWLYHPDXIVHLWHQGHVLQ
.2&+ E $D2 $D2 .2&+MI .2&+ F
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
VR]LDOHQ $QHUNHQQXQJV 9HUKlOWQLVVHQVWHKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQHUIDKUHQXQGYROO ]RJHQZLUG $EHUGLHVHU8QWHUVFKLHGOlVVWVLFKZHQQEHLGH'LPHQVLRQHQ QLHJDQ]GHFNXQJVJOHLFKZHUGHQIU.RFKDXFKYRQÄ*RWWVHOEVW³DXVEHVFKUHL EHQ *RWWHV6HOEVWVHLQLVWMHGRFKVWHWVDXIGLH(UP|JOLFKXQJYRQIUHLJH ZROOWHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWE]ZDXIGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJVHLQHVÄ5HLFKHV³DXVJHULFKWHW 'DEHLZLUGGLH)UDJH]XNOlUHQVHLQREXQGLQZLHIHUQGLHVHVYRPPHQ VFKOLFKHQ*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVXQWHUVFKLHGHQH(LJHQVHLQ*RWWHVLP=XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ.RFKVLP*UXQGHDQWKURSRORJLVFKIXQGLHUWHP$QVDW]EHU]HXJW 5HOLJLRQ 6LFK%HVWLPPHQ/DVVHQ $QHLQHUNULWLVFKDIILUPDWLYHQ/HVDUW+HJHOVKDW.RFKZHLWEHUVHLQH'LVVHUWD WLRQVVFKULIWKLQDXVIHVWJHKDOWHQÄ(VNDQQVLFKXQVHUHQ%HJULIIHQQXUHUHLJQHQ GDVLHHLQVZHUGHQPLWGHU:DKUKHLW³VFKUHLEWHUHWZDLQHLQHU HUVFKLHQHQ +HJHO6WXGLHXQGIJWZLHREHQEHUHLWV]LWLHUWZXUGHKLQ]X Ä'RFKLQLUJHQGHL QHPDXVJHPDFKWHQ6LQQHLVWGDVQLHÃHUUHLFKWµ±'DVLVWGDVÃ.UHX]µGHV'HQ NHQVXQGXQVHUH$XV]HLFKQXQJDOVLQGLYLGXHOOEHVRQGHUH6XEMHNWH]XJOHLFK³ 'HQQQXUDQGHU6WHOOHGHV(LQ]HOQHQXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHU'LIIHUHQ] OlVVWVLFKGDV*|WWOLFK$EVROXWHEHUKDXSWLQWHQGLHUHQ:DVDEHUEHUGHVVHQ MHZHLOVEHVWLPPWH6LFKWKLQDXVJHKWEOHLEWHLQH(LQKHLWVSUlWHQWLRQGLHVLFKDOOHU (UIOOXQJVPRPHQWH]XP7URW]QLHDXI'DXHUVWHOOHQOlVVW9RUGLHVHP+LQWHU JUXQGEHJUHLIW.RFK5HOLJLRQGH]LGLHUWDOVÄ(UZDUWXQJVQLFKW>DOV@(UIOOXQJV JHZLKHLW³=XLKUHP5HFKWNRPPWVLHGHPQDFKQLFKWZRGHU(LQ]HOQHYRU GHQ8QZlJEDUNHLWHQVHLQHV'DVHLQVLQVFKDEORQLVLHUWH9HUDUEHLWXQJVPXVWHUXQG ,PPXQLVLHUXQJVVWUDWHJLHQIOLHKW5HOLJLRQDOV*HZLVVKHLWHLQHVWUDJHQGHQ/H EHQVVLQQVEHZDKUKHLWHWVLFKYLHOPHKULPRIIHQVLYHQ8PJDQJPLW1HJDWLYLWlWVHU IDKUXQJHQXQGGXUFKGLHÄDIILUPDWLYH>@(UQHXHUXQJ³ GHVPLWLKUYHUEXQGHQHQ 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVVHVLQ0RPHQWHQGHV*HOLQJHQV'LHVNL]]LHUWHUHOLJL|VH+DO WXQJZLUGYRQ.RFKDOV*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVXQGGDPLWGXUFKGLHTXD+HJHO/HNWUH KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWH6SDQQXQJYRQ'LIIHUHQ]XQG9HUV|KQXQJJHSUlJWYHUVWDQGHQ Ä>,@QGHU*HJHQZDUW³VRVFKUHLEW.RFKGLH0RGHUQHEHUKDXSWPHLQHQGZLUG ÄÃ5HOLJLRQµDOV9HUELQGXQJPLWHLQHUWUDJHQGHQJHLVWLJHQ*U|HEHUGDVHQGOL FKH6XEMHNWGLH0HQVFKKHLWXQGGLHHQGOLFKH/HEHQVZHOWKLQDXV ZHQQDXFK ]XJOHLFKGDULQ >«@JHOHEW³ZDVDEHUVWHWVDXIGHUÄHUIDKUHQH>Q@(LQVLFKWHLQHV HQGOLFKHQ VLFK WUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHQ 6XEMHNWV³ EHUXKW 'LH )UHLKHLW GHV 0HQ VFKHQVHLQDOOHQ.DXVDOLWlWV]XVDPPHQKlQJHQDEKROGHV9HUP|JHQ]XU6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJNRLQ]LGLHUWDOVRLPUHOLJL|VHQ9HUKlOWQLVPLWHLQHULKQEHUVWHLJHQGHQ :LUNOLFKNHLW)U.RFKOLHJWGDULQGLHEHVRQGHUH(LJHQDUWGHUÄ5HOLJLRQLQGHU 1HX]HLW³GDVVKLHUÄGLH*RWWYHUEXQGHQKHLW]XVDPPHQPLWGHU6HOEVWHUNHQQWQLV
.2&+ G .2&+R (EG .2&+I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHVHQGOLFKHQ6XEMHNWVJHOHEW³ZLUG.HLQHKHWHURQRPH8QWHUZHUIXQJXQWHU GLH+HUUVFKDIWGHV$OOPlFKWLJHQVWHKWLQLKUHP=HQWUXPVRQGHUQHLQ9ROO]XJ YRQ)UHLKHLWGHUVLFKDEHUIUGLHSURGXNWLYH.UDIWXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUHU(UIDK UXQJVNRQVWHOODWLRQHQRIIHQ]HLJWÄ>'@HUUHOLJL|VH$NW³VRODXWHW.RFKV'HILQLWL RQLVWLQhEHUZLQGXQJGHVÄVWDUUHQ6FKHPD>V@YRQ $XWRQRPLHXQGSDVVLYHU +LQQDKPH>«@DOVHLQKHLWOLFKHU9ROO]XJLQGHU'RSSHOKHLWGHV6LFK%HVWLPPHQV XQGGHV%HVWLPPWZHUGHQVDOVRHLQHV6LFKEHVWLPPHQODVVHQV³]XIDVVHQ )UHLKHLWMHQVHLWVYRQWRWDOHP%HVWLPPHQXQGDEVROXWHP %HVWLPPWZHUGHQ 0LWGLHVHP%HJULIIGHVUHOLJL|VHQ9ROO]XJVDOVÃ6LFK%HVWLPPHQ/DVVHQµYHU ELQGHWVLFKEHL.RFKHLQHGRSSHOWH.ULWLNGLH]XUGHXWOLFKHUHQ.RQWXULHUXQJ VHLQHU3RVLWLRQDQJHIKUWVHL(LQHUVHLWVJHKWVLHJHJHQ9HUHLQVHLWLJXQJVWHQGHQ ]HQGHVQHX]HLWOLFKPRGHUQHQ$XWRQRPLHLGHDOVDQ:DVHUKLHUPRQLHUWLVWDXV GUFNOLFKQLFKWGLHÄHPDQ]LSDWRULVFKH>@6WRULFKWXQJ³DOOHV]XNULWLVLHUHQZDV GHP(LQ]HOQHQDOVEORH$XWRULWlWJHJHQEHUWULWWRKQHGDVVHUHVÄVHOEVWHLQ]X VHKHQ³XQGGDULQÄVHLQHHLJHQH9HUZLUNOLFKXQJ]XILQGHQYHUPDJ³'HIL]LWlU DEHUHUVFKHLQWLKPGDVLP$XWRQRPLHJHGDQNHQHEHQIDOOVLPSOL]LHUWH9RUXUWHLO JHJHQEHUMHJOLFKHP1LFKW(LJHQHQHVVHLHLQHSRWHQ]LHOOH4XHOOHPDFKWYROOHU )UHPGEHVWLPPXQJXQG)UHLKHLWVEHUDXEXQJ'DUDXVQlPOLFKUHVXOWLHUWLQOHW]WHU .RQVHTXHQ]HLQ:HOWYHUKlOWQLVGDVVLFKDXV $QJVWGLHHLJHQH8QDEKlQJLJ NHLWVSRVLWLRQYHUORUHQ]XJHEHQDOOHV%HJHJQHQGH]XXQWHUZHUIHQVXFKW'DVV JHUDGHLQVR]LDOHQ(UIDKUXQJHQHLQREMHNWLYHU6LQQJHKDOWOLHJHQN|QQWHGHUGHQ (LQ]HOQHQ PLW XQJHNDQQWHQ QHXHQ 0|JOLFKNHLWHQ VHLQHU VHOEVW NRQIURQWLHUW HUVFKHLQWVRDEHUWHQGHQ]LHOODXVJHVFKORVVHQ8QEHVWLPPWKHLW%HOLHELJNHLWXQG :LOONUVLQGGLH&KDUDNWHULVWLNDGHUGDPLWVFKOLHOLFKHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ)UHLKHLWV SUD[LV6RHQWJHKWGHPXPVHLQH$XWRQRPLHEHVRUJWHQÄ,FK>«@GDLKP>«@ HLQHLQKDOWOLFKH)OOXQJVHLQHV6HOEVW]XNRPPHQN|QQWH³ZHQQHVVLFKDXI$Q GHUHVXQG$QGHUHHLQOLHH'HQQOHLGHULVWLKPÄGLH(LQVLFKW>YHUVSHUUW@GDHV $EKlQJLJNHLW DXIJUXQG YRQ (LQYHUVWlQGQLV JLEW ± $EKlQJLJNHLW RKQH .QHFKWVFKDIW³ 'RFKJLEWHVHEHQ±DQGHUHUVHLWV±DXFKÃ$EKlQJLJNHLWPLW.QHFKWVFKDIWµXQG JHUDGHGLH5HOLJLRQVWHKWDXIGHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHVQHX]HLWOLFKPRGHUQHQ$XWR QRPLHLGHDOVXQWHU9HUGDFKWHLQHGXUFKZHJKHWHURQRPH$QJHOHJHQKHLW]XVHLQ MDGHQ(LQ]HOQHQ]XU8QWHUZHUIXQJXQWHUYRUJHJHEHQH*ODXEHQVZDKUKHLWHQ]X ]ZLQJHQ,P%OLFNDXIGDVWUDGLHUWH&KULVWHQWXPODVVHQVLFKIU.RFKVROFKH Ä$XWRULWlWVIL[LHUWKHLWXQGGDPLWGHUYRUPRGHUQH&KDUDNWHU>«@NDXPEHVWUHL
$D2$QP .2&+R (EG9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2 II .2&+ $D2
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
WHQ³'DEHLKDWHUHLQHUVHLWVHLQHQVFKDEORQLVLHUHQGHQ8PJDQJPLW1HJDWLYL WlWVHUIDKUXQJHQYRU$XJHQGHUQLFKW]XULQGLYLGXHOOHQGDVHLJHQH6HOEVWVHLQ EHUHLFKHUQGHQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ IKUW VRQGHUQ Ä0LOLQJHQ /HLGHQ XQG 7RG³DOVLQ*RWWLPPHUVFKRQEHUZXQGHQEHVFKZ|UW:DVGLHVÄEHLPHLQ]HO QHQKHUYRUUXIWGDVLVWHLQHXQNULWLVFKHQXUYRQDXHQYHUOLHKHQH*HERUJHQKHLW± GHUHQ,QKDOWHLKUHP:HVHQQDFKSDVVLYKLQ]XQHKPHQVLQG³=XPDQGHUHQDEHU ZLUGGHU$XWRQRPLHEHJULIIVFKRQEHL.DQWDXIGHU1HJDWLYIROLHHLQHVDXWRULWlUHQ +HUUVFKHUJRWWHVNRQWXULHUWZDV]XU=HPHQWLHUXQJYRQ9RUXUWHLOHQJHJHQEHU GHU5HOLJLRQHEHQVRYLHOEHLJHWUDJHQKDWZLHGLH7KHRORJLHGDUDXIYLHOIDFKPLW UHDNWLRQlUHU)UHLKHLWVNULWLNDQWZRUWHWH 6REHQXW]WPDQGDQQ GHQ*HGDQNHQGHU$XWRQRPLHDOV6FKODJZRUW>«@XP]XXQWHUVWHOOHQLQDOOHP'HQNHQGDV GLH$EVROXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWV>«@GHQNWWUHLEHQXUGLHDOWH8UVQGHGHV0HQVFKHQGLH+\EULV DOV6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJXQG6HOEVWYHUJ|WWOLFKXQJLKU8QZHVHQ
8QWHUPLQLHUWVLHKW.RFKGXUFKHLQHVROFKH6LFKWDEHUGDVVGLHXQEHGLQJWHÄ)UHL KHLWGHV,FKVHOEVWXQGDOOHLQ>«@HLQXQYHU]LFKWEDUHV0RPHQW>«@LQMHGHP 9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ)UHLKHLWXQG6HOEVWVHLQ³GDUVWHOOWZHLORKQHGDVDQVLHJHNRS SHOWHUHIOH[LYH9HUP|JHQGHVÄ$XFKDQGHUV.|QQHQV³EHUKDXSWNHLQLQGLYL GXHOO]XUHFKQXQJVIlKLJHV$JLHUHQLP*XWHQZLHLP%|VHQGHQNEDUZlUH1D PHQWOLFKNULWLVLHUWHU.DUO%DUWKGDIUÄGLHVHV0RPHQWDEVWUDNWHU)UHLKHLW³DXV ]XVFKOLHHQXQGGDPLWÄGLH)UHLKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ³VHLQHÄLKPVHOEVWHLJHQH
.2&+R 9JOGD]XLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 II $D2 9JOH[HPSODULVFKGLHIROJHQGHQ:RUWH.RFKV Ä(VZLUG>«@YLHO]XYLHO XQGLPPHU]XQXUEHKDXSWHW±RKQHGDDXFKQXUDQGHXWXQJVZHLVHHUNHQQEDUZlUHGDGHU 5HGHQGHVHOEVWPLWVHLQHP/HEHQEHU]HXJWLVWYRQGHPZRYRQHUVSULFKW>«@,Q-UJHQ 0ROWPDQQV%XFKÃ'HUJHNUHX]LJWH*RWWµKHLWHVSURQRQFLHUW Ã'XUFKVHLQHHLJHQH*RWWYHUODV VHQKHLWEULQJWGHU*HNUHX]LJWH*RWW]XGHQ*RWWYHUODVVHQHQµ,FKIUDJH ,VWGDVPHKUDOVHLQ VFK|QHU6DW]":LHGHQQNRPPW*RWWRGHUEULQJWµGHU*HNUHX]LJWH*RWW]XGHQ*RWWYHUODVVH QHQ":HUMHJRWWYHUODVVHQZDUZHLZLHEUHQQHQGRGHUYHUGXUVWHQGJHUQHPDQGDVZLVVHQ P|FKWH'RFKRKQHGDGDVJHVDJWDXVJHIKUWGDUJHOHJWZLUGPXGDQLFKWHLQVROFKHU6DW] ZLHGHU0ROWPDQQVDOVUHLQHU+RKQZLUNHQ"³ '(56 I .2&+R 9JO.2&+ DI:RUDXI.RFKVLFKEH]LHKWLVW]%GLH$XVVDJH.DQWVLQGHU *UXQGOHJXQJ]XU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQZRDOVÄGHUXQVQRFKEULJH%HJULIIVHLQHV>GHVJ|WWOL FKHQ .7@ :LOOHQV³ HLQ ÄDXV GHQ (LJHQVFKDIWHQ GHU (KU XQG +HUUVFKEHJLHUGH PLW GHQ IXUFKWEDUHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQGHU0DFKWXQGGHV5DFKHLIHUVYHUEXQGHQ>HU@³%HJULIIYRUVWHOOLJ JHPDFKWXQGGHVKDOEDOV*UXQGGHVÄPRUDOLVFKH*HIKOV³DXVJHVFKORVVHQZLUG .$17 D >%$ @ .2&+ EI .2&+ D9JODXFK'(56 FI $PÄZLOONUOLFKH>Q@0RPHQWGHV(LQ ]HOVXEMHNWVVHLQ>HP@Ã$XFKDQGHUV.|QQHQ³KlQJWÄGDVVXEMHNWLYH%HZXWVHLQIUHL]XVHLQ³ XQG '(56 G Ä>'@LH )UHLKHLW DOV 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ GLH 6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW XQG GDV 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQKlQJHQGDUDQGDGHUHLQ]HOQHDOV6XEMHNWZHGHUNDXVDOQRFKWHOHRORJLVFK YRP*XWHQGHWHUPLQLHUWLVWGDHUÃDXFKDQGHUVµNDQQGDHULQVHLQHP,FKHLQ=HQWUXPKDW GDVYRQDOOHP%HVWLPPWZHUGHQYHUVFKLHGHQLVW³
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:UGH³VHLQÄLKPDOV0HQVFKHQSULQ]LSLHOO]XVWHKHQGHV0HQVFKHQUHFKW³QLFKW ZLUNOLFK ]X]XODVVHQ 'LH LQ EHLGHQ +LQVLFKWHQ ZDKUQHKPEDUH WKHRORJLVFKH 8QWHUPLQLHUXQJPHQVFKOLFKHU)UHLKHLW]XJXQVWHQJ|WWOLFKHU0DFKWLVWDXV.RFKV 6LFKWPLWKLQ:DVVHUDXIGLH0KOHQGHU5HOLJLRQVNULWLN*HJHQGHUHQ+DXSWHLQ ZDQGGHU0HQVFKZHUGHÄXPVHLQ:HVHQJHEUDFKWVHLQHUK|FKVWHQXQGEHVWHQ 0|JOLFKNHLWHQEHUDXEWXQGIROJOLFKGHSUDYLHUWXQGYHUVWPPHOW>«@ZHQQHUDOV YRQ*RWWEHVWLPPWYHUVWDQGHQZLUG³JLEWHVVRJHVHKHQQlPOLFKNHLQH$UJX PHQWH 'HPJHJHQEHU ZLOO .RFK ÄHLQVLFKWLJ³ PDFKHQ ÄGD *RWW³ DOV ÄGLH :DKUKHLW³YHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQNDQQÄLQGHUGLH)UHLKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ]XVLFK VHOEVWILQGHWXQGGDV6XEMHNWZDKUKDIWDXWRQRPZLUG³'DIUDEHUEHGDUIHV HEHQHLQHVGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHUHQWKHRORJLVFKHQ8PJDQJVPLWGHU)UHLKHLWVWKHPDWLN ZREHLDEHUDQ]XPHUNHQLVWGDVV.RFKVÄ.ULWLNGHUYHUDEVROXWLHUWHQ$XWRQR PLH³DXFKVHOEVWDOO]XSDXVFKDOH=XVFKUHLEXQJHQHWZDJHJHQEHUGHPNDQWL VFKHQ$XWRQRPLHJHGDQNHQYRUQLPPW:RULQLQVHLQHQ$XJHQGHU8QWHUVFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQGHUGHP6XEMHNWXQEHGLQJW]X]XELOOLJHQGHQ$EVROXWKHLWGLHLKPRE VHLQHUÃ)UHLKHLWGHV,FKVHOEVWXQGDOOHLQµHLJQHWXQGVHLQHU6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLH UXQJOLHJWLVWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGQRFKHLQPDOHLJHQV]XHQWIDOWHQ 'DV6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ$EVROXWKHLWXQG6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJ $QVWDWWGLHÃ$EVROXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVµ±VHLQHÄ)lKLJNHLWYRQDOOHPZDVLKP EHZXWZLUGVLFKGLVWDQ]LHUHQ]XN|QQHQ³VHLQHÄ)UHLKHLWQLFKWIHVWJHOHJW]X VHLQ³±YRQYRUQKHUHLQDOVK\EULGHÃ6HOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUXQJµ]XEUDQGPDUNHQ LVWDXV.RFKV6LFKW]ZLVFKHQEHLGHPGHXWOLFK]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ(VWULWWGDPLW DEHU]XJOHLFKHLQH'LIIHUHQ]YRU$XJHQGLHHUDQJHVLFKWVGHUXQHQWULQQEDUHQ 6R]LDOLWlW PHQVFKOLFKHQ /HEHQV IU lXHUVW YLUXOHQW KlOW Ä>.@HLQ HLQ]HOQHU³ QlPOLFKÄLVWMHQXUHUVHOEVWLVROLHUWXQGEH]LHKXQJVORVIUVLFKDOOHLQ(ULVWZDV HULVWLPPHUDXFKPLWGHQDQGHUHQXQGLQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWDQGHUHQRGHU PLWGHPYRQLKQHQhEHUOLHIHUWHQ³:HUGLHLKPHLJQHQGH$EVROXWKHLWVRDXV OHEWGDVVHUVLFKYRQMHGZHGHPVR]LDOHQ%HVWLPPWZHUGHQIUHL]XKDOWHQYHU VXFKW GHP ÄMHGHU (LQ]HOQH³ DOV ÄLQ YLHOIlOWLJHU :HLVH LQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQ GHU
.2&+ D(UIKUWH[HPSODULVFKHLQH6WHOOHDXV%DUWKV7DXIOHKUHDQZRYRQGHU ÄDEVXUGH>Q@>«@LOOXVLRQlUH>Q@ZHLOJHJHQGLHHLQHHLQ]LJH>LKPLP:HUN*RWWHVLQ-HVXV &KULVWXVEHJHJQHQGH@:LUNOLFKNHLWVWUHLWHQGH>Q@,GHHMHQHVKHLGQLVFKHQOLEHUXPDUELWULXP³GLH 5HGHLVWÄNUDIWGHVVHQHVGHP0HQVFKHQ±ZLHEULJHQVVFKRQ*HQYRUJHVHKHQ±]XNl PH*RWWJOHLFKXQGDOVR6FKLHGVULFKWHU]ZLVFKHQ*XWXQG%|VHHEHQ+HUNXOHVDP6FKHLGH ZHJH]XVHLQ³ %$57+ I 'LHVHU)UHLKHLWGHV:lKOHQN|QQHQVÄ]ZLVFKHQ]ZHLVLFK LKP DQELHWHQGHQ 0|JOLFKNHLWHQ³ VR KHLW HV GRUW ÄYHUVDJW³ VLFK GHU &KULVW LQ GHU 7DXIH DD2 :HUYROO]LHKWGLHVHV6LFK9HUVDJHQ" .2&+ D .2&+ D .2&+R II .2&+ D9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2I (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
$QHUNHQQXQJ³HLQJHEXQGHQHV6XEMHNWDXVJHVHW]WLVWPDFKWGLH)UHLKHLWVHLQHU VHOEVWJHUDGHZHJVYRP(UIROJGLHVHV$QVLQQHQVDEKlQJLJ'RFKOLHJWGDULQZLH .RFKHLQVFKlUIWHLQDXVVLFKWVORVHV8QWHUIDQJHQZHLOÄMHGHV/HEHQHLQHV0HQ VFKHQ>«@HLQ/HEHQLQ%HVWLPPWKHLWHQ³ LVW0DQNDQQGLHVH7DWVDFKHLJQRULH UHQXQGVRXQEHZXVVWGXUFKHLQJHVSLHOWH.RQYHQWLRQHQJHOHLWHWZHUGHQRGHUVLH EHZXVVWQHJLHUHQZDVHLQ]ZDQJKDIWHV$QUHQQHQJHJHQDOOHVbXHUOLFK)UHPGH EHGHXWHWH,QMHGHP)DOOVWHOOWVLHLQIUDJHGDVVHLQHUDOOHLQDXVVLFKVHOEVWRKQH GLH$QGHUHQHUVHOEVWVHLQNDQQ±LVWHUHVGRFKLPPHUDXFK PLWLKQHQXQG EHVWLPPWGXUFKGDV9HUKlOWQLV]XLKQHQ :DVGDV6XEMHNWDEHUGDYRQDEKlOWVLFKÄGHP$QGHUHQ>«@DQ]XYHUWUDXHQ³ XQGGDULQOLHJWIULKQGHU8UVSUXQJÄGHVVHQZDVPDQÃ(JRLVPXVµ>VF6HOEVW YHUDEVROXWLHUXQJ .7@QHQQW³NDQQ.RFKZLHIROJWPDUNLHUHQ HVLVWÄGLH8QVL FKHUKHLW>«@GHV$QGHUHQQLFKWVLFKHU]XVHLQ³VHLQHUÄQRFKQLFKWHLQPDOLQGHU /LHEH±MDJHUDGHLQGHU/LHEHQLFKW±VLFKHUVHLQ>]X@N|QQHQ³$OO]XPHQVFK OLFKHUVFKHLQWLKPGHVKDOEGHU9HUVXFKVLFKJHJHQGDVPLWGLHVHU8QVLFKHUKHLW HLQKHUJHKHQGH(QWWlXVFKXQJVULVLNRDE]XVLFKHUQ GXUFKGLH)OXFKWLQGLHWHQGHQ ]LHOO JHZDOWVDPH 'XUFKVHW]XQJ GHV (LJHQHQ RGHU LQ GHVVHQ RSSRUWXQLVWLVFKH $XIJDEHGXUFKGHQ5FN]XJLQDOO]XVWDUUH±]%PRUDOLVWLVFKH±9RUVWHOOXQJHQ YRQVLFKVHOEVWXQGGHU:HOWÄ$QJVWOLHJWGHP]XJUXQGH³QRWLHUW.RFKLP%OLFN DXIGLHEHVDJWHQ$EVLFKHUXQJVVWUDWHJLHQÄ$QJVWYHUORUHQ]XVHLQZHQQPDQ VLFKVHOEVWORVOlWLQVXQDXVJHPDFKW2IIHQHKLQHLQZHQQPDQVLFKDOVRDXVVHW]W GHP$QGHUVVHLQGHV$QGHUHQ³'RFKNDQQÄ*HPHLQVDPNHLW³HWZDLQGHU/LH EHÄQLFKW]XVWDQGHNRPPHQRKQHGDHLQHUGLHV5LVLNRYRQVLFKDXVZLOOHQWOLFK HLQJHKWXQGVLFKKLQDXVZDJWEHUGDV(LJHQH³'D]XEHGDUIHVDOOHUGLQJVHLQHU Ä)UHLKHLWGLHGHQ(LQ]HOQHQQLFKWPLWVLFKVHOEVWDOOHLQOlW³VRQGHUQDXIJUXQG GHUHUHUGLHVK|FKVWULVLNREHKDIWHWHÄJHPHLQVDPH>@/HEHQPLW$QGHUHQVHOEVW DOVRIUHL]XZROOHQ]XOHEHQXQG]XEHMDKHQ³LPVWDQGHLVW (LQHHEHQVROFKH)UHLKHLWKDW.RFKYRU$XJHQZHQQHUGHQÄUHOLJL|VHQ$NW³ DOVHLQÄ6LFKEHVWLPPHQODVVHQ>@³FKDUDNWHULVLHUWÄ,PUHOLJL|VHQ9HUKlOWQLVDOV HLQHPIUHLHQQLFKWDXWRULWlUHQ³VRIDVVWHU]XVDPPHQÄLVWGHU0HQVFKPLWGHP ZDVLKQEHVWLPPW±PLW*RWW±LP(LQYHUVWlQGQLVXQGKDWGDULQVHLQHLQKDOWOLFK TXDOLIL]LHUWH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³LVWVHLQÄ.RQVWLWXLHUWZHUGHQ>«@LGHQWLVFKPLW HLQHP6LFK)LQGHQ6LFK(UNHQQHQLPXQGGXUFKGHQ$QGHUHQ LQ*RWW³:LHHU DQIJWHUZHLVWVLFKGLHVHÃUHOLJL|VH*UXQGHUIDKUXQJµDEHUDOVÄQLFKWJlQ]OLFK DQDORJLHORV³LPVR]LDOHQ/HEHQ Ä:HUHLQHQDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQOLHEWGHUILQGHW
.2&+D .2&+ D .2&+ EI9JO]XGLHVHP3XQNWLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2II $D2 $D2 .2&+ E .2&+R $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VLFKYRQGLHVHPHUZlKOW³:DVKLHUYRUVLFKWLJXQGDP5DQGHDXVJHVSURFKHQ ZLUGNRPPWDQGHUQRUWVGHXWOLFKHUGDKHU Ä1LFKW]XIlOOLJ³KHLWHVLQ0LW*RWW OHEHQ LVWGDV(LQVHKHQ*RWWHVYHUDQODWGXUFKHLQH]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH(UIDKUXQJ'HQQZDVLP *XWHQ]ZLVFKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQJHOLQJWLVWJDUQLFKWDEO|VEDUYRQGHPZDV*RWWLQVLFKVHOEHU LVWXQGEHGHXWHW
*RWW]ZLVFKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQ Ä'HU*HLVWGHUPLFKGHU)UHLKHLW|IIQHW³MHQHUEHVDJWHQ)UHLKHLWLP*RWWHVYHU KlOWQLVGLHVLFKQLFKWDQJVWYROOYRUGHPXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUHQ$QGHUVVHLQ$QGHUHU YHUVFKOLHWVRQGHUQDXIJUXQGGHUHULFKPLFKDXIGLHVHHLQODVVHQPLFKGXUFKVLH EHVWLPPHQ]XODVVHQYHUPDJ±HUÄNDQQPLU³DXV.RFKV6LFKWÄQXUYRQDXHQ YRP$QGHUHQKHU]XNRPPHQ³$OV,QLWLDOZLUNHQKLHU]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH (UIDKUXQJHQGLHGHQ(LQ]HOQHQ]XHLQHPQHXHQHUIOOWHUHQ9HUVWlQGQLVVHLQHU VHOEVWIKUHQXQGGHQHQHUVLFKHEHQGHVKDOERKQH9HUOXVWVHLQHU)UHLKHLWKLQ JLEW (VVLQG(UIDKUXQJHQGHVJHJOFNWHQ=XVDPPHQILQGHQVPLW$QGHUHQDQ GHQHQVLFKLGHDOLWHUHLQ9HUWUDXHQGDUDXIHQW]QGHWGDVVHLQHPHLQHPLQGLYL GXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQ5DXPJHEHQGH]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH*HPHLQVDPNHLWSULQ]L SLHOOJHOLQJHQNDQQ6LHJHOWHQ.RFKDOV(UVFKOLHXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQGHV*ODXEHQV Ä*HOHJHQKHLWHQGD]X³VFKUHLEW.RFKÄVWHOOHQVLFKHLQ³XQG]ZDUJDQ]QHEHQEHL 9LHOOHLFKWWULIIWHVVLFKGDHLQ$QGHUHUPLFKDOVGLHVHQ0HQVFKHQEHPHUNWPLFKDOVRDFKWHW XQGPLUJDQ]DEVLFKWVORVGLH)UHXGHEHUHLWHWHUNDQQWXQGYHUVWDQGHQ]XVHLQ2GHUHV|IIQHW VLFKHLQHUGHP$QGHUHQEULQJWLKPXQEHIDQJHQ9HUWUDXHQHQWJHJHQXQGGHU$QGHUHEHJLQQW WDWVlFKOLFKVLFKIULKQ]XLQWHUHVVLHUHQ>«@$XFKHLQHNOHLQH)UHXQGOLFKNHLWNDQQ*URHVLQ PLUDXVO|VHQZHQQLFKVLHLQPLFKHLQODVVH ZHQQVLHPHLQHQ =LUNHODXIEULFKWLQGHPLFK HUIDVVHGHU/LHEHZUGLJXQGVHOEVW]XP/LHEHQIlKLJ]XVHLQ
'LHYRQ.RFKDQJHIKUWHQ%HLVSLHOHODVVHQVLFKDOV6LWXDWLRQHQJHOLQJHQGHU $QHUNHQQXQJIDVVHQ VLFKDOVXQYHUZHFKVHOEDUHV,QGLYLGXXPJHDFKWHW]XVHKHQ GDVHKUOLFKH,QWHUHVVHGHV$QGHUHQDPHLJHQHQ(UJHKHQ ]XYHUVSUHQGXUFK GHVVHQ=XZHQGXQJGHUHLJHQHQ/LHEHQVZUGLJNHLWXQG/LHEHVIlKLJNHLWLQQH]X ZHUGHQ Ä>'@LH 6WXQGH JHIXQGHQHU $QHUNHQQXQJ³ NDQQ ZLH HU GHPJHPl
$D2 .2&+ E6FKRQLQVHLQHUDOOHUHUVWHQ$XIVDW]YHU|IIHQWOLFKXQJDXVGHP-DKUH NDQQ.RFKGHPJHPlIRUPXOLHUHQ Ä>'@HU0HQVFKKDWLQGHU/LHEHWHLODQGHUYHUV|K QHQGHQ(LQKHLWGLH*RWWLVWDQGHUHLQHQ/LHEH³'RFKHUIJWHLQVFKUlQNHQGKLQ]X Ä/LHEHQ GHKDEHQWHLODQGHUHLQHQ/LHEH±XQGVLHZLVVHQ]XJOHLFKGDLKU/LHEHQYRQGHU/LHEH VHOEVWYHUVFKLHGHQLVW0DQNDQQGLHVUHFKWVFKPHU]KDIWHUIDKUHQ>«@:LU0HQVFKHQKDEHQ QLHGLHVH9ROOHQGXQJ:LUEOHLEHQDEHUDXFKDOOHKLQWHUGHP]XUFNZDVZLULQGHU/LHEHVHLQ N|QQWHQ³ '(56N .2&+ E9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2IIII 9JO.2&+RII .2&+ EI
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
VFKUHLEWGHQÄ(LQ]HOQH>Q@³]XMHQHUÄ(UNHQQWQLVGLHGRFKHLQ*ODXEHLVW³IK UHQGDVVHVÄVHLQ*HLVW³LVWÄZDVLKQ]XGHPPDFKWZDVHUVHOEVWLVW³8QWHU GHPÄVXEMHNWLYHQ*HLVW³YHUVWHKW.RFKGDEHLGDVÄZRUDXI³HLQ0HQVFKÄPLW GHPZDVHULVWWXWXQGVSULFKWDXVJHULFKWHWLVW³ÄGLH*UXQGLGHHVHLQHV/HEHQV³ ÄGDVZDVLKQEHZHJWEHOHEWXQGZRYRQHUOHEW³ 'DVVVLFKPLUHEHQGLHVZDVLFKDOVLFKVHOEVWELQXQGVHLQZLOOGXUFKGDVHU VFKOLHWZDV$QGHUHLQPLUVHKHQLVWMHGRFKDXINHLQHVGHUDP$QHUNHQQXQJV YHUKlOWQLVEHWHLOLJWHQ6XEMHNWH]XUFN]XIKUHQ Ä6ROFKHOHEHQVHQWVFKHLGHQGH (UIDKUXQJZLUGPLUYRQDXHQYRP$QGHUHQKHU]XWHLO³±VLHOLHJWDOVRQLFKW LP9HUIJHQGHV$QHUNDQQWHQ=XJOHLFKDEHUJHKWVLHÄZHLWEHUGDV9HUP|JHQ DXFKGHV$QGHUHQKLQDXV³XQGIROJWQLFKWHLQIDFKGHQ,QWHQWLRQHQVHLQHVDQHU NHQQHQGHQ7XQVÄ8QWHU0HQVFKHQXQGEHLPLUJHKWPLUDXIGDHQWVFKLHGHQ PHKULVWDOVQXU0HQVFKOLFKHVQlPOLFK8QEHGLQJWHV*|WWOLFKHV±ZDVDEHUJH ZLQLFKWDXIKHEWGDHVXQWHU0HQVFKHQLVW³IDVVW.RFKGLHDQVROFKHQ(U IDKUXQJHQVLFK]HLJHQGH'LIIHUHQ]]XVDPPHQ6LHEOHLEHQLP,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ YHURUWHWZHLVHQDEHUEHUVLFKKLQDXVDXIGLH'LPHQVLRQGHV$EVROXWHQ'LHVHV 7UDQV]HQGHQ]PRPHQWHLJQHWLKQHQHEHQGHVKDOEZHLONHLQHGHUEHWHLOLJWHQ3HU VRQHQGDVIUHLH6HOEVWVHLQGHVMHZHLOLJHQ*HJHQEHUVHLQIDFKIUVLFKLQ$Q VSUXFK]XQHKPHQYHUPDJ9LHOPHKUNDQQHLQMHGHUÄLP$QHUNDQQWZHUGHQGXUFK GHQDQGHUHQLQVHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHVDQGHUHQXQGLQGHU*HZLKHLWVHLQHU VHOEVW³DXFKIHKOJHKHQVLFKWlXVFKHQRGHUHQWWlXVFKWZHUGHQÄ>*@HJHQVHLWLJH $QHUNHQQXQJ³ VR VFKUHLEW .RFK GHVKDOE ÄJHOLQJW ZRKO QXU DOV ]XWUDXHQGHV )UHLODVVHQGHVMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ³ZREHLÄMHGHUGHUGDVWXWDXIHLQHKRIIHQWOLFK ZLHGHUVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGH*HPHLQVDPNHLW>VHW]W@GLHGHQ$QGHUHQXQGLKQYHU HLQW³:RDXIHEHQGLHVHV6LFK(LQVWHOOHQYRQ*HPHLQVDPNHLWYHUWUDXWZLUG GDUDXIDOVRGDVVHLQH9HUELQGXQJ]XP*HJHQEHUVLFKHUJHEHQNDQQNRPPWGLH DQJHJOFNWHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWVLFKVWlUNHQGH+DOWXQJGHV*ODXEHQV]XP7UDJHQ 6LFKGXUFKVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]LHKXQJHQEHVWLPPHQ]XODVVHQEHGHXWHW GHPQDFKGHULQLKQHQOLHJHQGHQ&KDQFH]XIROJHQ]XHLQHPLQKDOWOLFKEHVWLPP WHQ6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV]XJHODQJHQ 'DEHLDEHUZLUGYRUDXVJHVHW]WGDVVHV]ZLVFKHQGHQ%HWHLOLJWHQHLQH9HUELQ GXQJJLEWGLHHVLKQHQWURW]LKUHU8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWHUP|JOLFKWVLFK]XVDP PHQ]XILQGHQ+LHU]XEHPHUNW.RFK
$D2I $D2 $D2 $D2 $D2 .2&+ D .2&+D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
*RWWLVWHVGHULP]XIlOOLJHQ QLFKWSODQEDUHQQLFKWNRQVWUXLHUEDUHQ *HOLQJHQYRQ*HPHLQ VDPNHLWHUVFKHLQW*RWWHUVFKHLQW]XIlOOLJGLH*HPHLQVDPNHLWHUJLEWVLFKNRQWLQJHQW±XQG GRFKLVWVLHQRWZHQGLJYRUDXV]XVHW]HQ
,PYHUWUDXHQGHQ6LFK(LQODVVHQDXIGHQ$QGHUHQGDVVPLWGHP:XQVFKYHUEXQ GHQLVWVLFKLQGHU%H]LHKXQJ]XLKPVHOEVWILQGHQ]XN|QQHQZLUGGHPQDFK HLQH'LPHQVLRQGHV0LWHLQDQGHUVLQ$QVSUXFKJHQRPPHQGLHGLH5HGHYRQ *RWWQDKHOHJW6LHDOVRGLHEHVDJWHJ|WWOLFKH'LPHQVLRQXQGHEHQQLFKWGLH%H WHLOLJWHQZLUG]XP%HVWLPPHQGHQZHQQHV]XPHUZDUWHWHQDEHUQLFKWJDUDQ WLHUEDUHQ(UHLJQLVNRPPWGDV6HOEVWXQG$QGHUVVHLQNRLQ]LGLHUHQ6ROFKHLQH (UZDUWXQJKHJWLPPHUVFKRQZHU]%LP*HVSUlFKPLWVHLQHQ:RUWHQYHUVWDQ GHQ]XZHUGHQKRIIWÄ,PPHUXQGQRWZHQGLJXQGPLWMHGHP6DW]GHQZLUDXV VSUHFKHQ³VFKUHLEW.RFKÄVHW]HQZLUGLHV*HPHLQVDPHXQVJHJHQVHLWLJYHUVWH KHQ]XN|QQHQYRUDXVRKQHGDZLUGHVVHQKDEKDIWZlUHQ³ ,P*ODXEHQJH VFKLHKWOHW]WOLFKQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVGDVVGLHVHDOOWlJOLFKEHDQVSUXFKWH'LPHQVLRQ GHV9HUEXQGHQVHLQVLQLKUHPXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUJQDGHQKDIWHQ&KDUDNWHU]X%H ZXVVWVHLQ NRPPW XQG LQ LKU *RWW DOV GDV XQEHGLQJW YHUWUDXHQVZUGLJH *XWH HQWGHFNWZLUG(VZLUGGDQQGDULQVR.RFKHLQÄÃ:HFKVHOµGHVWlWLJHQ6XE MHNWV³ JHZlUWLJW 'DV 2EMHNW GHU (UIDKUXQJ GDV 0LWHLQDQGHU9HUELQGHQGH ZLUGVHOEVW]XPGHQ(UIDKUHQGHQEHVWLPPHQGHQ6XEMHNW:LH.RFKDEHULPPHU ZLHGHUEHWRQWOlVVWVLFKGLHVHU9ROO]XJQLFKWLQ$NWLYLWlWVXQG3DVVLYLWlWVDQWHLOH DXIWHLOHQVRQGHUQÄGHUJDQ]H6LQQKlQJWGDUDQGDQRFKLP6XEMHNWZHFKVHO± DOVRLP:LGHUIDKUQLVFKDUDNWHUGLHVHU(UIDKUXQJ±PHLQHXQG*RWWHV$NWLYLWlW NRLQ]LGLHUHQ³ :HLOGDVEHVDJWH*HPHLQVDPNHLWVPRPHQWLQVHLQHP*HOLQJHQQLFKWDXIGDV +DQGHOQGHU(LQ]HOQHQUHGX]LHUEDULVWNRPPWLKPHLQXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHV(LJHQ VHLQ]X.RFKVSULFKWYRPÄVLHYHUELQGHQGH>Q@Ã'ULWWH>Q@µLKU>HP@JHPHLQVD PH>P@*HLVW³GHUÄGDV*UXQGOHJHQGHDOOHQ9HUVWHKHQV³LVW*RWWVROlVVWVLFK GDV*HVDJWH]XVDPPHQIDVVHQZLUGGHPQDFKLPUHOLJL|VHQ9ROO]XJDOVÄ*HLVW GHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³Ä*HLVWGHVIUHLHQ0LWHLQDQGHUV³RGHU±VR.RFKVKlXILJV WH)RUPXOLHUXQJ±DOVÄ*HLVWGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLW³HUIDKUHQ$OOH$QNOlQJHDQ *HJHQVWlQGOLFKNHLWHWZDLP6LQQHHLQHUYRQGHQLQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ=XVDPPHQ KlQJHQZLHDXFKLPPHUDEJHVRQGHUWHQJ|WWOLFKHQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]ZLOOHUGDEHL DEHU DXVJHVFKORVVHQ ZLVVHQ 'LH JHLVWLJH :LUNOLFKNHLW *RWWHV DOV 0HQVFKHQ YHUELQGHQGHV'ULWWHVLVWYLHOPHKUÄQLFKWVZRUEHUVLFKXQEHWURIIHQÃREMHNWLYµ
.2&+ .2&+ E $D29JODD2 '(56RI Ä8PVFKODJGHU$NWLYLWlW³ .2&+ E $D2 .2&+ D $D2 9JOGD]XXD.2&+ EIIII D J II
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
EHUSUIEDUH$XVVDJHQPDFKHQOLHHQ³QLFKWVDOVRZDVÄGHP9HUVWDQGGHUDXI Ã7DWVDFKHQµDXVLVW³]XJlQJOLFKZlUH 2IIHQ DEHU EOHLEW ]XQlFKVW GLH )UDJH ZLH GLHVH YRP =ZLVFKHQ 0HQVFKOLFKHQXQWHUVFKLHGHQH:LUNOLFKNHLWÃ*RWWHVVHOEVWµJHQDXHUXQGEHU ]HXJHQG]XIDVVHQLVWRKQHVLFKGHPGXUFK.RFKELVZHLOHQHLJHQVDQWL]LSLHUWHQ 9HUGDFKWÄHLQHVYRUNULWLVFKH>Q@Ã7KHLVPXVµRGHUHLQHUÃ6XEVWDQ]RQWRORJLHµ³ DXV]XVHW]HQ %OHLEHQGH'LIIHUHQ]HQ $XFKZHQQGHUJ|WWOLFKHÄ*HLVW>«@NHLQYRQDXHQKLQ]XNRPPHQGHV'ULWWHV QLFKWV$XVPLWWHOEDUHVIUVLFK³VRQGHUQQXULP9ROO]XJZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQÄ9HU VWHKHQ>V@XQG9HUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ>V@ZDKUKDIWDOVGHU(LQHQGHVFKOHFKWKLQ³LVW .RFKVHW]WGLH5HDOLWlW*RWWHV±LP8QWHUVFKLHG]X:DJQHU±QLFKWPLWGHP *HOLQJHQYRQ6R]LDOEH]LHKXQJHQJOHLFKÄ:HLOGLH(UIDKUXQJGHV*ODXEHQVHLQH Ã]ZHLWHµEHUGLHGLUHNWH]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHKLQDXVLVWGHVKDOEEHIlKLJWVLH³ DXVVHLQHU6LFKWÄJHUDGH³GD]XÄGLHPHQVFKOLFKH6FKZlFKHLQDOOHP0HQVFKOL FKHQ>«@HLQ]XJHVWHKHQ³XQGÄDE>]X@ODVVHQYRP3HUIHNWLRQVGUXFN³SHUPDQHQ WHQ*HOLQJHQPVVHQV (QWWlXVFKWHV9HUWUDXHQXQG6FKXOGPLWKLQHLQIDFKGLH8QIlKLJNHLWRGHUGHU 8QZLOOHVLFKDXI$QGHUHHLQ]XODVVHQ±GHUDUWLJH3KlQRPHQHODVVHQLPPHUZLH GHUDQGHU0|JOLFKNHLWVROFKHQ*HOLQJHQV]ZHLIHOQGDVHEHQQLHYROOHQGVLQGHU HLJHQHQ +DQG OLHJW .RFK IKUW GLHV LQVEHVRQGHUH DQKDQG GHU (UIDKUXQJ GHV /HLGHQVYRU$XJHQ6RHUOHLGHWÄMHGHUGHUOHLGHW>«@VHLQHQ6FKPHU]VHLQ 8QKHLOXQGVHLQH1RW XQGGLHHUOHLGHWHULQHLQHPVWUHQJHQ6LQQHDOOHLQHEHQDOV HUVHOEVWXQGNHLQDQGHUHU³ :DVKLHUHUOHEWZLUGLVWQLHÄVXEMHNWORVDOOJH PHLQ³VRQGHUQÄLPVWUHQJHQ6LQQHHLQPDOLJXQGXQYHUJOHLFKEDU>«@'DUXPLVW (LQVDPNHLWXPGDV/HLG³ 0LWLKPJHKWÄ>G@LH*HPHLQVDPNHLWGHV9HUVWHKHQV XQG9HUVWDQGHQZHUGHQV³]X%UXFKMDHVEHGHXWHWHLQHWLHIHÄ(UVFKWWHUXQJ]ZL VFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ>«@9HUWUDXHQV³ 1XQLVWHV]ZDUNHLQHVZHJVDXVJHVFKORV VHQGDVVHLQOHLGHQGHU0HQVFKGXUFKGLH=XZHQGXQJ$QGHUHU7URVWHUIlKUWXQG OHW]WHQ(QGHVZLHGHUEHUVHLQH9HUHLQ]HOXQJKLQDXVNRPPW'RFKLVWGLHVHEHQ GXUFKQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQGHQ]XHU]ZLQJHQHUVWUHFKWQLFKWGXUFKWKHRORJLVFKH 9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJVYHUVXFKHLP6LQQHDEVWUDNWHU7KHRGL]HHPRGHOOHÄ*RWW³VR
.2&+ E 9JO]X.RFKV*HLVWEHJULIILQVJHVDPW DD2 ± '(56 ± .2&+U $QP .2&+ .2&+ E $D2 9JO]X.RFKV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP/HLGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
PDFKW.RFKGHXWOLFKÄLVWNHLQ(UNOlUXQJVJUXQG³IUGDV/HLGHQDXFKDEHUÄLVW >HU@NHLQHUGHUDQGHQ0HQVFKHQYRUEHLEHUQDWUOLFK>«@HLQJULIIH³VRQGHUQ Ä>G@HUIUGDV/HLGHQ]XILQGHQGH6LQQGHUGDV8QKHLOYROOHGDVLQLKPLVWZHQ GHW³ 'LHVHU6LQQDOVHLQH3HUVSHNWLYHGLHEHUGDV:LGHUVLQQLJHGHVHLJHQHQ (UJHKHQVXQGGDULQEHUGLH9HUHLQ]HOXQJKLQDXVIKUWNDQQVLFKQXUMHLQGLYL GXHOO HUVFKOLHHQ XQG QLFKW YRQ DXHQ DQGHPRQVWULHUW ZHUGHQ (U]ZXQJHQHU 7URVWZlUHNHLQHUZHLOHUGLH3HUVSHNWLYHGHV(LQ]HOQHQJDUQLFKWWUHIIHQZUGH .RPPWHVDEHUDXFKGXUFKGHQ=XVSUXFK$QGHUHU]XHLQHP6FKULWWEHUGLH )L[LHUXQJDXIGLHHLJHQH1RWKLQDXVOLHJWGDULQVR.RFKHLQH8PZHQGXQJ± ZHJQXUYRQVLFKVHOEVWKLQDXFK]XP$QGHUHQ 8QGZHQQHU>VFGHU/HLGHQGH@LQGLHVHU8PZHQGXQJLQGLHVHP$XIHUVWHKHQGLH%HMDKXQJ VHLQHUVHOEVWHUIDW±GDHUVHOEVWLPPHUQRFKXQGQXQHUVWUHFKWJHZROOWLVW±GDQQLVWGHU *HLVWGHUXQVYHUELQGHWXQGGHUMHGHPEHLVWHKHQZLOO±GDQQLVWGHU*HLVW*RWWHVEHLLKP DQJHNRPPHQXQG]XVHLQHP7URVW]XVHLQHP7U|VWHUJHZRUGHQ
'LHVH 8PNHKUHUIDKUXQJ DXVJHO|VW GXUFK HLQ NRQWUDIDNWLVFKHV %HMDKW RGHU $QHUNDQQWZHUGHQYRQVHLWHQ$QGHUHUPDFKW.RFKDXFKDP3KlQRPHQHEHQVR ZHQLJHU]ZLQJEDUHU9HUJHEXQJQDPKDIW+LHUZLUGGHP6FKXOGLJHQÄJHJHQGDV 2IIHQNXQGLJHXQGJHJHQGLHHLJHQH6HOEVWHLQVFKlW]XQJ³]XJHWUDXWÄGDHUQRFK DQGHUV±QlPOLFKJXW±VHLQNDQQXQGGDHUGDV9HUNHKUWH6LQQXQG/HEHQV ]HUVW|UHQGHGRFK]XWLHIVWVHOEVWJDUQLFKWZROOHQ³DEHUHEHQÄGDVNDQQGLHVH &KDQFHQHXHQEHMDKEDUHQ/HEHQVHUJUHLIHQ³ :RGLHEHVDJWH&KDQFHGXUFKGDVEHWURIIHQH6XEMHNWHUJULIIHQZLUGLVWGLHV ZLHLPJHIXQGHQHQ7URVWGHV/HLGHQGHQHLQGXUFKNHLQH$QHUNHQQXQJ]XYHUI JHQGHU$NWVLFKEHVWLPPWVHLQODVVHQGHU)UHLKHLW'LHGDULQOLHJHQGH8PNHKU EHZHJXQJKLQ]XHLQHPQLFKWQXUVHOEVWIL[LHUWHQ6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVDEHUPDFKWHV ]XJOHLFKDXIVHLQHYRUKHULJH'LIIHUHQ]GHPJHJHQEHUDXIPHUNVDPZDVHVHL JHQWOLFKVHLQN|QQWHXQGVROOWHDEHULPPHUZLHGHUQLFKWLVWÄ,P$XIJHKHQGHU :DKUKHLW³VR.RFKÄZLUGGLHHLJHQH8QZDKUKHLWEHZXW³XQGÄHUNHQQWHLQHU ZLHXQZUGLJGHU/HHUODXIGHVDOWHQLFKYHUVFKORVVHQHQ/HEHQVLVW³ZDVVLFK LP*HIKOVFKDPKDIWHU5HXHÄEHUGLHV9HUIHKOWH³lXHUW 'LHUHOLJL|VH(UIDK UXQJHUVFKOLHWQLFKWQXUHLQHUIOOWHUHV6HOEVWVHLQVRQGHUQJHUDGHGDULQHLQH GHP0HQVFKHQHLJQHQGH=ZLHVSlOWLJNHLWDQJHVLFKWVGHUHUHUQLHYROOVWlQGLJPLW
$D2I $D2I .2&+ G 9JO]XP3KlQRPHQGHU9HUJHEXQJQHEHQGHP]LWLHUWHQ$XIVDW]LQ VJHVDPWDXFK '(56II$XFKGLHYHU]HLKHQGH3HUVRQHUIlKUWLPXQHU]ZLQJEDUHQ$NW GHU9HU]HLKXQJHLQH$UWYRQ%HMDKXQJZLH.ODXV0LFKDHO.RGDOOHOHKUW Ä(VN|QQWHVHLQ GDVVVLFKPHQVFKOLFKH)UHLKHLW±QLFKWDOV:LOONUIUHLKHLWYHUVWDQGHQVRQGHUQEHJULIIHQDOV :DKUXQJHLJHQHU:UGHLQGHU%LQGXQJDQGLH$FKWXQJGHU:UGHGHUDQGHUHQ±LQNHLQHP DQGHUHQ $NW VR LQWHUHVVHORVODXWHU PDQLIHVWLHUW ZLH LQ GHP LPPHU YRQ 0LYHUVWlQGQLVVHQ XPODXHUWHQ $NW GHU 9HU]HLKXQJ $XFK GHU Ã6FKZlFKVWHµ XQG 8QEHGHXWHQGVWH YHUPDJ GD 6RXYHUlQLWlWXQG*U|HGHV0HQVFKVVHLQV]XP$XVGUXFN]XEULQJHQ³ .2'$//( .2&+ E
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
VLFKLGHQWLVFKVHLQNDQQÄ'HU.HUQGHU5HXHQXQEHVWHKWLQGHU(LQVLFKWVFKXO GLJDP$QGHUHQMDDP*HLVWGHU/LHEHVHOEVW]XVHLQ³ KLQWHUGHVVHQ8QEH GLQJWKHLWHLQMHGHULPPHUZLHGHU]XUFNIlOOW'RFK EHUNlPHHLQHQ0HQVFKHQGLHVH%HVFKlPXQJQLFKWKlWWHHUQLFKWQHXHUIDKUHQGDGLH:DKU KHLWZLHGLH/LHEHLQVLFKXQEHGLQJWXQGVWDUNLVWGHQ9HUVFKXOGHWHQJOHLFKVDPDXI]XIDQJHQ XQGZLHGHULQVLFKDXI]XQHKPHQ
'LH:DKUQHKPXQJGHU'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHPZDVPDQIDNWLVFKLPPHUZLHGHU LVWXQGGHPZDVPDQLP=XVDPPHQVHLQPLW$QGHUHQVHLQN|QQWHYHUGDQNWVLFK DOVR(UIDKUXQJHQSDUWLHOOHU,GHQWLWlW]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ6HLWHQ%OHLEWMHGRFKÄMHGH VROFKH.RQNUHWLRQ*RWWHVXQWHU0HQVFKHQXQGEHLPLUHLQHEHVFKUlQNWHEHGLQJ WH³ ZHLOVLHVWHWVGXUFKGLH5HDOLWlWGHV1LFKWVHLQ6ROOHQGHQGHV1HJDWLYHQ GXUFKEURFKHQ ZLUG NDQQ NHLQH GLHVHU ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ .RQNUHWLRQHQ MHQHV8QEHGLQJWHVHOEVWVHLQDXIGDVVLFKGHU(LQ]HOQHGDULQEH]RJHQHUIlKUW 'DVDQJHVLFKWVGHUZLGHUVSUFKOLFKHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWXQZHLJHUOLFKVLFKHLQVWHOOHQ GHÄ'LIIHUHQ]EHZXWVHLQLP%OLFNDXIGLH:HOWXQGLP%OLFNDXIGDVHLJHQH,FK ÃQ|WLJWµJHUDGH*RWW]XGHQNHQXQG]XJODXEHQ±XQG]ZDU*RWWXQWHUVFKLHGHQ YRQGHU:HOWXQGYRPHLJHQHQ6HOEVW³ 'DVDQ0RPHQWHJHOLQJHQGHU=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKNHLWJHNQSIWH*RWWHVYHU KlOWQLVXQWHUVFKHLGHWVLFKDOVR]XJOHLFKQRFKHLQPDOYRPWHQGHQ]LHOOEUFKLJHQ 9HUKlOWQLV ]X $QGHUHQ XQG OlVVW GHQ 0HQVFKHQ VHLQH 8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLW YRQ *RWWYRP$EVROXWHQEHZXVVWZHUGHQ'DUDXVZlFKVWLKPQDFK.RFKV'DIU KDOWHQGLH)lKLJNHLW]XGHQVHLQH6HOEVWXQG:HOWHUIDKUXQJSUlJHQGHQ=ZLH VSDOW]ZLVFKHQ*XWHPXQG%|VHPHEHQVRDXV]XKDOWHQZLHSDUWLHOO]XEHUZLQ GHQ,P9HUKlOWQLV]XGHPZDVGHP(QGOLFK%HGLQJWHQQLFKWXQWHUZRUIHQLVW NRPPWGHU0HQVFKÄEHUGLH(LQVWHOOXQJGHU=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWKLQDXVZRQDFK LPPHU DOOHV QXU ÃWHLOVWHLOVµ JXW XQG VFKOHFKW YHUPLVFKW XQG GDUXP OHW]WOLFK VLQQORVLVW³ZHLOHULQ*RWWÄHLQHÃ,QVWDQ]µGHU(LQGHXWLJNHLW>NHQQW@GLHLP $PELYDOHQWHQ LP XQDXVJHPDFKW =ZHLGHXWLJHQ GHV 0HQVFKHQOHEHQV RULHQ WLHUW³:DVGLH7KHRORJLHQDFK.RFKEHUGDV6LFKVHOEVW(UNHQQHQGHV0HQ VFKHQDOV]ZHLGHXWLJKLQDXV]XVDJHQKDWLVWGHPQDFKGLHV Ä>-@HQH:DKUKDIWLJ NHLWLP(UVFKUHFNHQEHUVLFKVHOEVW³NDQQRKQH6HOEVWYHUOXVWÄJHOHEWZHUGHQ³ LP*ODXEHQGDUDQ GDZLUDOOHXQGVRMHGHUIUVHLQHLJHQHV/HEHQYRQGHU:DKUKHLWOHEHQGLHJU|HULVWDOVZLU DOOHXQGXQDXVVFK|SIOLFKJHJHQEHUDOOHPZDVZLUYRQLKUUHDOLVLHUWKDEHQ>«@>XQG@GLH
(EG (EG .2&+ E .2&+ E .2&+ E
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GDULQVLFKDOVÃJU|HUµHUZHLVWGDVLHNHLQHQGHUDQVLHJODXEWLQVHLQHP9HUVDJHQXQG 9HUVFKXOGHQXQWHUJHKHQOlW
,Q.RFKV*HGDQNHQGLHÄJ|WWOLFKH>@:DKUKHLW³EHUVWHLJHGLHVLHYHUJHJHQZlU WLJHQGHQÄ>L@QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ%HJHJQXQJHQ³ZHLOVLHDXFKÄQRFKGRUWZLUNVDP³ VHLÄZRGLH(QGOLFKNHLWGHV,QGLYLGXXPV³VROFKH9HUJHJHQZlUWLJXQJHQGXUFK NUHX]HOlVVWVLFKPLW-|UJ'LHUNHQÄHLQH$QHLJQXQJGHV*UXQGPRWLYVGHU5HFKW IHUWLJXQJVOHKUH /XWKHUV³ HQWGHFNHQ 6R KHLW LQ HLQHU $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ .RFKVPLWGHUVHOEHQDXFK ,P*ODXEHQLVWHLQ0HQVFK>«@QLFKWWRWDOLWHUIUVHLQ6HOEVWVHLQDQJHZLHVHQDXIGLH$QHUNHQ QXQJDQGHUHU(UZHLGDGDVQLHLP/HEHQVHLQZLUGGDLKQHLQDQGHUHU>«@0HQVFKJDQ] XQGLQMHGHU+LQVLFKWYHUVWHKW±XQGJHUDGHGDUXPZLUGHUVLFKMHGHV$XJHQEOLFNVIUHXHQLQ GHPHUVLFKYHUVWDQGHQHUIlKUW
'DV:LVVHQXPGLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHUPLFKÃJDQ]XQGLQMHGHU+LQVLFKWµ EHWUHIIHQGHQ'LPHQVLRQGHV$EVROXWHQXQGGHQHQGOLFKUHODWLYHQ%HGLQJXQJHQ XQWHUGHQHQVLHQXUMHXQGMH*HJHQZDUWJHZLQQWUHODWLYLHUWDOVRHLQHUVHLWVGLH PLWXQWHUGUXFNYROOHQ(UZDUWXQJHQDQV$QHUNDQQWZHUGHQGXUFK$QGHUH$QGH UHUVHLWVVHQVLELOLVLHUWHVJHZLVVHUPDHQIUGLHÃNOHLQHQ0RPHQWHGHV*HOLQ JHQVµÄZLVVHQGGDGDV.OHLQVWHGHU$QIDQJGHV*U|WHQVHLQNDQQ³(QW VSULFKWGHUÄ*RWWYHUEXQGHQKHLW³GHV*ODXEHQVDEHUÄGLH*HZLKHLW³XQEHGLQJ WHUZHLVHÄVHOEVWHWZDV³XQGGHVKDOEQLFKWÃWRWDOLWHUDQJHZLHVHQDXIGLH$QHUNHQ QXQJDQGHUHUµ]XVHLQGDQQÄPXVLFKHLQ0HQVFK³ZLHQDFK.RFKÄEHU/X WKHUKLQDXV³IHVW]XKDOWHQLVWDXFKÄQLFKWYRU*RWW³IUÄQLFKWVXQGXQZUGLJ HUDFKWHQ³'DPLWNRPPWGLH6QGHQWKHPDWLNLQGHQ%OLFNGLHHUVLFKLP'LD ORJPLW.LHUNHJDDUGZLHQXQ]X]HLJHQLVWDXINULWLVFKH:HLVHDQHLJQHW 'HU0HQVFK]ZLVFKHQ6QGHXQG*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLW 'HQ$QVDW]LQGHUÄ6HOEVWXQWHUVFKHLGXQJGHV6XEMHNWV]ZLVFKHQVHLQHU)UDJ OLFKNHLWXQGVHLQHU:DKUKHLWGLHGRFK]XJOHLFKEHULKQKLQDXVLVW*RWW]XGHQ NHQ³EHUQLPPW.RFKDXVGUFNOLFKYRQ6¡UHQ.LHUNHJDDUG$PGlQLVFKHQ 'HQNHUUKPWHU]XPHLQHQGLHPHWKRGLVFKH$QZHLVXQJGDV6LFKVHOEVWYHUVWH KHQ GHV (LQ]HOQHQ ]XP :DKUKHLWVNULWHULXP DOOHU WKHRORJLVFKHQ $XVVDJHQ ]X HUKHEHQ=XPDQGHUHQVWUHLFKWHUHEHQGHVVHQ(LQVLFKWLQGLHLPPDQHQWH=ZHL GHXWLJNHLW GHV 6XEMHNWV KHUDXV GDV HQGOLFKEHJUHQ]W XQG XQHQGOLFKIUHL ]X JOHLFKDQVLFKVHOEVWYHU]ZHLIHOWZRULQHVVHLQHVNRQVWLWXWLYHQ*RWWHVEH]XJV
.2&+K ',(5.(1 .2&+E .2&+ E .2&+E 9JOIUGLHIROJHQGHQbXHUXQJHQ]X.LHUNHJDDUG .2&+ E D J II U
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
JHZlUWLJ ZLUG .RFKV YRU GLHVHP +LQWHUJUXQG IRUPXOLHUWH DQWKURSRORJLVFKH 6SLW]HQWKHVHODXWHW GDGHU0HQVFKVLFKZDKUKDIWYRUVLFKVHOEVWQLFKWRKQH*RWWYHUVWHKHQNDQQ±XQGGDGHU 0HQVFKGDVGHQQRFKVLFKVHOEVWJUQGOLFKPLYHUVWHKHQGWXQNDQQ VLFKRKQH*RWWYHUVWHKHQ XQGIROJOLFKVLFKVHOEVWYHUDEVROXWLHUHQ
'LHWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQ*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWXQG6QGHEHJUHLIWHU GDYRQDXVJHKHQGDOVGLHEHLGHQHLQDQGHUHQWJHJHQVHW]WHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQPHQ VFKOLFKHQ6LFKVHOEVWYHUVWHKHQVXQGHQWVSUHFKHQGHU/HEHQVZHLVHQ'DEHLJLOWGHU PHWKRGLVFKH9RUEHKDOWGDVVÄGLH:DKUKHLW>«@GLHDOV*RWWDXVJHVDJWZLUG³ QLFKW ÄRKQH GLH :DKUKDIWLJNHLW GHV (LQ]HOQHQ LP 9HUKlOWQLV ]X VLFK VHOEVW³ GHQNEDULVWDQGHUVLFKIULKQGLH:DKUKHLWHQWVFKHLGHW .RFKVGDPLWDQJH GHXWHWH$XIQDKPHGHUWUDGLWLRQHOOHQWKHRORJLVFKDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ%HVWLPPXQ JHQJHVFKLHKWMHGRFKLQEHZXVVWHU$EZHQGXQJYRP7RWDOLWlWVDQVSUXFKGHUDX JXVWLQLVFKOXWKHULVFKHQ6QGHQOHKUH1LFKWLVWGHU0HQVFKDOVRGXUFKGHQ)DOO $GDPVVHLQHUXUVSUQJOLFKHQhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJPLW*RWWXQGGHP*XWHQJlQ] OLFKYHUOXVWLJJHJDQJHQVRGDVVHUQXQDOVY|OOLJJRWWORVE|VH]XVWHKHQNRPPW 'LH DXINOlUHULVFKH .ULWLN DQ GHQ VXEVWDQ]PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ $QQDKPHQ GLHVHU 6LFKWDXIQHKPHQGPRQLHUW.RFKGDVVGLHEHLGHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQÃ*RWWHEHQELOG OLFKNHLWXQG6QGHµÄDOVNRQWUDGLNWRULVFKHXQGWRWDOHJDUQLFKWYRQHLQHPXQG GHPVHOEHQ6XEMHNW>«@DXVVDJEDUVLQG³6ROOHQVLHLQGDV6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV SRWHQ]LHOOMHGHVHLQ]HOQHQ6XEMHNWVHLQJHKHQN|QQHQPVVHQVLHDXIDOOJHPHLQ PHQVFKOLFKH/HEHQVZHLVHQXQG(UIDKUXQJHQEH]RJHQZHUGHQN|QQHQÄ)UHLQH JHJHQZlUWLJH7KHRORJLHIROJWGDUDXVGDVLHQXUEHLGH%HVWLPPXQJHQ]XVDP PHQ LP %OLFN DXI HLQ 6XEMHNW >«@ GHQNHQ NDQQ³ ZDV ÄLPSOL]LHUW GD NHLQ 0HQVFKMHWRWDO ÃUHVWORVµ QXU6QGHULVW±XQGGLHVGDUXPQLFKWZHLOHUDXFKLQ GHU6QGHQLFKWYRQ*RWWYHUODVVHQLVW³ :DV.RFKMHGRFKDQGHUEHU-DKUKXQGHUWHJHOHKUWHQ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYRQVWD WXVLQWHJULWDWLVXQGVWDWXVFRUUXSWLRQLVEHZDKUHQVZHUWILQGHWLVWGHU*HGDQNH HLQHU3ULRULWlWGHV*XWHQLP0HQVFKHQGHPJHJHQEHUGLH6QGHE]ZGDV%|VH QXUHLQHVHNXQGlUHGHVVHQHLJHQWOLFKJRWWJHPlJXWHV:HVHQSHUYHUWLHUHQGH $QJHOHJHQKHLWGDUVWHOOW(UNDQQHEHQLPPHUÄÃDXFKDQGHUVµ³ZHLOÄHULQVHLQHP ,FKHLQ=HQWUXPKDWGDVYRQDOOHP%HVWLPPWZHUGHQYHUVFKLHGHQLVW³'DULQ LVWHUGXUFKQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQGHQDXFKQLFKWGXUFKHLQHJ|WWOLFKH$OOPDFKW GHWHUPLQLHUW VRQGHUQ ÄVHOEVW HWZDV *|WWOLFKHV 8QEHGLQJWHV³ $EHU GHU 0HQVFKLVW]XJOHLFKDXFKÄGDV:HVHQGDVGDV*|WWOLFKVHLQDOVVHLQ6HLQ.|QQHQ
.2&+ D .2&+K $D2 .2&+ DI .2&+G .2&+P
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
]XPWRWDO:LGHUJ|WWOLFKHQYHUNHKUHQNDQQ³LQGHPHUGDV%|VHZlKOW.XU] JHVDJW (ULVWXUVSUQJOLFKXQGLP*UXQGHJHQRPPHQ(EHQELOG*RWWHVYHUIHKOW VLFKGDULQDEHULPPHUZLHGHUVHOEVWZDVLKQ]XJOHLFKDOV6QGHUFKDUDNWHULVLHUW :DVDEHULVW6QGH".RFKEHVFKUHLEWVLHPLWGHXWOLFKHP%H]XJDXI/HEHQLQ 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQDOVÄGDV6LFKYHUIHVWLJHQLQVLFKDOVRGDV6LFKYHUVFKOLHHQ JHJHQ GHQ *HLVW GHU :DKUKHLW XQG GHU /LHEH YRQ GHP ZLU LPPHU VFKRQ OH EHQ³'DKLQWHUVWHKHQLQVHLQHQ$XJHQJDQ]XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH+DOWXQJHQ %H VLW]ZQVFKH XQG 'XUFKVHW]XQJVLQWHUHVVHQ 6HOEVWVXFKW XQG GHU SHUPDQHQWH 'UDQJHLQ$QGHUHU]XVHLQDEHULQWHUHVVDQWHUZHLVHDXFKGLH6HOEVWDXIJDEH]X JXQVWHQGHVÄ.ROOHNWLYHQXQGhEOLFKHQZHLOPDQGLHHLJHQH3UREOHPDWLNQLFKW GXUFK]XVWHKHQXQGGDV$QGHUVVHLQGHVDQGHUHQQLFKWDXV]XKDOWHQVLFKWUDXW³ :LH .RFK EHWRQW LVW MHGRFK REJOHLFK VLH ÄSHUYHUWLHUWHV LP :LGHUVWUHLW YHU IlOVFKWHV*RWWHVEHZXWVHLQ³LVWÄLQGHU6QGHLPPHUQRFK*RWWHVEHZXWVHLQ³ LQVRIHUQVLHDOV1HJDWLRQGHV*XWHQHWZDV$EJHOHLWHWHVHLQ6HOEVWPLVVYHUVWlQG QLVDEHUGDULQLPPHUQRFKHLQ6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVGDUVWHOOW 'LH0|JOLFKNHLWHLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQ9HUV|KQXQJLQPLWWHQGHUXQYHUPHLGOLFKHQ 'LIIHUHQ]HQHQGOLFKHQ/HEHQVZLHGHVVHQSULQ]LSLHOOH8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWYRQ *RWWGLHJHUDGHLQ(UIDKUXQJHQGHU9HUHLQ]HOXQJ]XP7UDJHQNRPPWZHUGHQ DOVRGXUFK.RFKJOHLFKHUPDHQDXVJHVDJW'HQ5HVXOWDWHQVHLQHU'RNWRUDUEHLW GHQ*RWWHVEHJULIIEHWUHIIHQGLVWHUGDPLWLP*UXQGHWUHXJHEOLHEHQ1XUNRPPW KLHUGDVXQYHUUHFKHQEDUH(LJHQVHLQ*RWWHV]XVWlUNHUHU.RQWXUZLHLP)ROJHQ GHQDXFKGHQEHUHLWVPDUNLHUWHQ6SDQQXQJHQQDFKJHKHQGQlKHUKLQ]X]HLJHQ LVW *RWW )UVLFKXQGXQWHUXQV Ä:LHGXYRQ*RWWJODXEVWVRKDVWGXLKQ³±PLW0DUWLQ/XWKHUV:RUWHQEHWRQW .RFKGDVVDOOH5HGHYRQ*RWWLPUHOLJL|VHQ*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVLKUHQ$XVJDQJ QHKPHQPXVV $OVGDYRQDEVWUDKLHUWHV(WZDVQlPOLFKZUGH*RWWYHUJHJHQ VWlQGOLFKWXQGVRGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHV(QGOLFKHQXQWHUZRUIHQ$EHUGDPLWZLOO .RFKDXFKQLFKWGDIUSOlGLHUHQGDVVYRQ*RWWQXUJHVDJWZHUGHQNDQQZDVHU MHÃIUPLFKµLVW9LHOPHKUPXVVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQ]XJOHLFKGHXWOLFKZHUGHQZDV *RWWDOVHUVHOEVWLQGHU%H]LHKXQJYRQ*RWWXQG0HQVFKLVW=ZDULVWHUQXU LQQHUKDOEGLHVHV9HUKlOWQLVVHVHUVHOEVWDEHUHULVWGDULQHEHQDXFKHUVHOEVW'LH (LJHQVWlQGLJNHLW*RWWHVLQGHU*RWWHVEH]LHKXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ]XP7KHPD]X PDFKHQ±PLWGLHVHP$QOLHJHQULFKWHWVLFK.RFKXDJHJHQWKHRORJLVFKH7RWDOL
(EG .2&+ D (EG $D2 %HOHJVWHOOHQ]XGLHVHUEHL/XWKHUKlXILJXQGYDULDQWHQUHLFKEHJHJQHQGHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJ ILQGHQVLFKLQ (%(/,1* 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ .2&+ D±D
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
WlWVNRQ]HSWHGLH*RWWDOVÄDOOHVLQDOOHP³DOV,QEHJULIIGHU:LUNOLFKNHLW]XU 6SUDFKHEULQJHQ6RQlPOLFKYHUOLHUHQ0HQVFKXQG:HOWLKUH(LJHQUHFKWXQG EWLQVEHVRQGHUHGHU0HQVFKVHLQH)UHLKHLWHLQ'HPJHJHQEHUVWHOOW.RFK NODU Ä*RWW LVW QLFKW DOOHV VRQGHUQ GHU 0HQVFK LVW JHUDGH YRU *RWW DXFK HW ZDV³8PGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ)UHLKHLWZLOOHQVLQGDOVR*RWWXQG0HQVFKYRQ HLQDQGHU]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ :LFKWLJLVW.RFKDEHU]XEHWRQHQGDVVGHUHQ9HUKlOWQLVDOV,GHQWLWlWEHL]X JOHLFK EHVWHKHQGHU 'LIIHUHQ] ]X VWHKHQ NRPPW DOVR NHLQ NRQWUDGLNWRULVFKHU *HJHQVDW]]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ6HLWHQDXVJHVDJWZLUG'DPLWVROO9HUVFKLHGHQHV DXVJHVFKORVVHQVHLQ(UVWHQVNULWLVLHUWHUGLH$QVLFKWMHGH'LIIHUHQ]GHV0HQ VFKHQ]X*RWWVHLHLQ$XVGUXFNGHU6QGHXQGVROOWHIROJOLFKQLFKWVHLQ9LHO PHKULVWGHU*ODXEHQGHLQGHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWLQGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWPLW*RWWDOV *ODXEHQGHULQVHLQHU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWJHJHQEHU*RWWDQHUNDQQW'LH$XWRQRPLH LQGHU*RWWHVEH]LHKXQJLVWNHLQVW|UHQGHVhEHOVRQGHUQK|FKVWOHJLWLPZHLO EHLGHVVLFKQLFKWNDWHJRULVFKDXVVFKOLHW=ZHLWHQVULFKWHWHUVLFKJHJHQGLH0HL QXQJGLH'LIIHUHQ]GHV0HQVFKHQ]X*RWWPVVHOHW]WHQ(QGHVYROOVWlQGLJDE JHVFKDIIWZHUGHQVRGDVVDOVRHLQHVFKDWRORJLVFKHV=XVDPPHQIDOOHQ*RWWHVXQG GHV0HQVFKHQHLQ9HUVFKPHO]HQEHLGHUHLQ$XIJHKHQGHV0HQVFKHQLQ*RWW DQ]XYLVLHUHQVHL'ULWWHQVOHKQWHUGLH9RUVWHOOXQJDEGLH'LIIHUHQ]GHV0HQ VFKHQ]X*RWWVHLGDGXUFKDXI]XKHEHQGDVVLP*ODXEHQGDV,FKDOV$JHQWGHU 6QGHGXUFK&KULVWXVHUVHW]WZLUG9LHOPHKUNRUUHVSRQGLHUWGHU$QQDKPHGXUFK *RWWGLH6HOEVWDQQDKPHGHV0HQVFKHQLQNOXVLYHGHUGDULQEHZXVVWZHUGHQGHQ OHW]WHQ1LFKWEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ'HQQRFKLVWÄ>G@DV9HUHLQWVHLQGHV*ODXEHQGHQ PLW*RWW>«@HLQH9HUEXQGHQKHLWJDQ]HLJHQHU$UW³XQGQLFKW]XYHUZHFKVHOQ PLW]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQZHLOHVÄTXDOLIL]LHUW>LVW@GXUFK GLHhEHUOHJHQKHLW*RWWHV³:LHDEHULVWGLHVHhEHUOHJHQKHLW]XYHUVWHKHQ" *RWWVHOEVW 'LH$OOPDFKWGHV*XWHQGHU/LHEHXQGGHU:DKUKHLW Ä=XP*RWWVHLQ*RWWHV³VRVWHOOW.RFKLQHLQHU$XVOHJXQJGHVHUVWHQ*ODXEHQVDU WLNHOVNODUÄJHK|UW>«@0DFKWXQGGDPLWhEHUOHJHQKHLW³DOOHP$QGHUHQVHLQHU VHOEVW JHJHQEHU :lUHGHP QLFKW VR GDQQ N|QQWH *RWW QLFKW DEVROXW XQG XQEHGLQJWVHLQZHLO$QGHUHVLKQLQ$EKlQJLJNHLWHQ]ZlQJH'DVORJLVFKH$U
*HPHLQWVLQGLQVEHVRQGHUHGLH$QVlW]H.DUO%DUWKV3DXO7LOOLFKVXQG:ROIKDUW3DQQHQ EHUJV .2&+ D 9JOIUGLHJHGDQNOLFKHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQ .2&+ I'RUWPDFKW.RFKLP$Q VFKOXVVDQGHQ+HJHOLDQHU-XOLXV6FKDOOHUGHXWOLFKGDVV*RWWGHVKDOEDOVSHUVRQDOHV6XEMHNW XQGQLFKWDOVZLOOHQORVH6XEVWDQ]JHGDFKWZHUGHQPXVVZHLOVRQVWGHU0HQVFKLKPJHJHQEHU QLFKWIUHLMDQXUHLQ7HLOFKHQLQQHUKDOEGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$OOKHLWZlUH .2&+ .2&+$OOHQLFKWZHLWHUQDFKJHZLHVHQHQ$XVIKUXQJHQLPIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWW UHNXUULHUHQDXIGLHVHQ7H[W
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JXPHQWYHUELQGHWVLFKEHL.RFKPLWHLQHPOHEHQVSUDNWLVFKHQ3UREOHP Ä(LQQXU RKQPlFKWLJHU*RWWZlUHNHLQHU>«@DQGHQPDQJODXEHQRGHUDXIGHQPDQVLFK YHUODVVHQN|QQWH³$XVGHU)RUPXOLHUXQJÄQXURKQPlFKWLJ³DEHUOlVVWVLFK KHUDXVOHVHQGDVVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQDXFKGLH9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHVÄQXUPlFKWLJHQ³ *RWWHVPLVVYHUVWlQGOLFKLVW6RIUDJW.RFKLQUKHWRULVFKHU:HLVHÄZLHGLHVH 8QEHGLQJWKHLWXQG$EVROXWKHLWGHVHLQHQ*RWWHV±ZLHPLWKLQVHLQH0DFKW± UHFKWZDKUKHLWVJHPlEHJULIIHQLVW HWZDQXUH[NOXVLYDOOHV$QGHUHDXVVFKOLH HQGQXUVHSDUDWIUVLFK"³'LH$QWZRUWHUIROJWPLWWHOVHLQHU5HLKHYRQ5LFK WLJVWHOOXQJHQZRGXUFKGDVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQUHFKWHZDKUKHLWVJHPlH9HUVWlQG QLVJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWHU0DFKWLPPHUPHKU.RQWXUEHNRPPW $QHUVWHU6WHOOHVWHKWGHUEHUHLWVGXUFK*RWWIULHG:LOKHOP/HLEQL]YROO]RJHQH $EZHLVHLQHVYROXQWDULVWLVFKHQ%HJULIIV*RWWHVGHVVHQ*WHDXVIUHLHU6RXYHUl QLWlWHUZlFKVWXQGGHUVRJHVHKHQLPPHUDXFKDQGHUVKDQGHOQN|QQWHÄ6HLQ HLJHQHV7XQLVW>«@IULKQVHOEVWEHOLHELJ8QGDOOHVZDVHUWXWXQGDXVIKUWLVW EOR]XIlOOLJ NDQQVHLQRGHUDXFKQLFKWVHLQ³FKDUDNWHULVLHUW.RFKGLH0DFKW DXVEXQJGLHVHVJ|WWOLFKHQ:LOONUKHUUVFKHUVGHQHUXDQRFKLQPDQFKHQ*H GDQNHQJlQJHQEDUWKVFKHU7KHRORJLHDXFK-QJHOZlUHKLHU]XQHQQHQDXIWUHWHQ VLHKW6ROFKH%HOLHELJNHLWDEHULVWQLFKWQXUYHUKHHUHQGLP%OLFNDXIGDV9HU OlVVOLFKNHLWVEHGUIQLVGHU*OlXELJHQ6LHLVWZLH.RFKHLQVFKlUIWLPFKULVWOL FKHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQHLJHQWOLFKEHUZXQGHQDXFKZHQQVLHVFKRQHLQLJH-DKU KXQGHUWHEHUGDXHUWKDWÄ'LHVHU6FKULWWGHU*RWWHVHUNHQQWQLVEHUGLHEODQNH ZLOONUOLFKH$OOPDFKW*RWWHVKLQDXVZLUG>«@LP&KULVWHQWXPYROO]RJHQPLWGHU
(EG (EG 9JOGD]X/HLEQL]µ:RUWHDXVGHP'LVFRXUVGHPpWDSK\VLTXH Ä:HQQPDQVDJW GDGLH'LQJHQLFKWGXUFKHLQH5HJHOGHU*WHVRQGHUQDOOHLQGXUFKGHQ:LOOHQ*RWWHVJXW VHLHQ]HUVW|UWPDQDXFK ZLHPLUVFKHLQW RKQHGDUDQ]XGHQNHQDOOH/LHEH]X*RWWXQGDOOHQ VHLQHQ5XKP'HQQZDUXPVROOWHPDQLKQIUGDVOREHQZDVHUJHWDQKDWZHQQHUJOHLFKHU ZHLVHOREHQVZHUWZlUHVRIHUQHUJHQDXGDV*HJHQWHLOWXW"³ /(,%1,= 9JO]XPGLHVEH]JOLFKHQ5HNXUVDXI/HLEQL]XQG%DUWK .2&+ ± .RFKEH]LHKWVLFKKLHULQVEHVRQGHUHDXI%DUWKVLQ.',,HQWIDOWHWH3UlGHVWLQDWLRQVOHKUH Ä'LH /HKUHYRQ*RWWHV*QDGHQZDKO³KHLWHVGRUWÄLVWGLH6XPPHGHV(YDQJHOLXPV6LHLVW,QEH JULIIGHUIURKHQ%RWVFKDIWGLH-HVXV&KULVWXVKHLW>«@:DKO±GDVVROO]XQlFKVWQXUXQWHU VWUHLFKHQXQGHUNOlUHQZDVVFKRQPLW*QDGHJHVDJWLVW *RWWZlKOWLQVHLQHU/LHEHHLQ$QGHUHV ]XU*HPHLQVFKDIWPLWVLFKVHOEVW'DVEHGHXWHW]XHUVWXQGYRUDOOHP *RWWZlKOWVLFKVHOEVW ]XJXQVWHQGLHVHV$QGHUHQ*RWWJLEWVLFKVHOEVWGLH%HVWLPPXQJVLFKQLFKWJHQJHQ]XODVVHQ DQVLFKVHOEVWREZRKOHUVLFKVHOEVWJHQJHQN|QQWH>«@'D*QDGH*QDGHGD*RWWVLH QLHPDQGHPVFKXOGLJLVWXQGGDQLHPDQGVLHYHUGLHQHQNDQQGD*QDGHQLFKW*HJHQVWDQG HLQHV$QVSUXFKHVXQG5HFKWVVHLQNDQQDXIVHLWHQGHVVHQGHPVLHZLGHUIlKUWGDVLHGHU %HVFKOXXQG(QWVFKOXVHLQHV:LOOHQVLVWGDVVDJWGHU%HJULIIGHU:DKO³ %$57+ I Ä*RWWKHLWHVQRFKEHL.DUO%DUWK³NRPPHQWLHUW.RFKÄKDWVLFKLQIUHLHU/LHEHHQWVFKORVVHQ VLFKLQ-HVXV&KULVWXV]XRIIHQEDUHQDEHUHUNDQQLQVHLQHUIUHLHQ6RXYHUlQLWlWDXFKDQGHUV REVFKRQZLUQLFKWZLVVHQZLHDQGHUV³ .2&+ ±HUN|QQWHVLFKDEHUHEHQDXFK ÃVHOEVWJHQJHQµ9RQVROFKHU6HOEVWJHQJVDPNHLW*RWWHV]HXJWDXFK-QJHOV7ULQLWlWVWKHROR JLH YJOREHQ$D
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
(UNHQQWQLVGD*RWWGLH/LHEHVHOEVWLVW³ ZRYRQHUQXULP±IULKQMHGRFK DXVJHVFKORVVHQHQ±:LGHUVSUXFKJHJHQVLFKVHOEVWDEZHLFKHQN|QQWH 0LWGLHVHPDOVZHVHQWOLFKFKULVWOLFKDXVJHZLHVHQHQ*RWWHVYHUVWlQGQLVYHUELQ GHWVLFK]ZHLWHQVHLQHYRQ.RFKLP$QVFKOXVVDQ*HGDQNHQ+HJHOVDXVJHIKUWH ±XQGLKPPLW:DJQHUJHPHLQVDPH±(LQVLFKWLQGLHEUFKLJH/RJLNH[NOXVLY VRXYHUlQHU 0DFKWDXVEXQJ 0DFKW NDQQ VLFK GHPQDFK QLFKW HUZHLVHQ ± QXU GXUFKGHQ(UZHLVLKUHUVHOEVWDEHULVWVLH±RKQHVLFKGDIUHLQHV$QGHUHQ]X EHGLHQHQ'DYRQGDVVGLHV$QGHUHYRQLKUDEKlQJLJLVWDEHULVWVLHXPLKUHU 6HOEVWGDUVWHOOXQJ ZLOOHQ VR VHOEVW DEKlQJLJ Ä,KUH 8QHLQJHVFKUlQNWKHLW LKUH VRXYHUlQH8QDEKlQJLJNHLWN|QQWH>«@GLHVRYRUJHVWHOOWH0DFKW*RWWHV>«@QXU GXUFKVHW]HQZHQQVLHGDV$QGHUHYHUQLFKWHWH³ZRPLWVLHDEHU]XJOHLFKDXFK VLFKGHQ$EVFKLHGJHEHQZUGH=XU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQDOVVHOEVWlQGLJ DEHULVWVLHDXIJUXQGLKUHU(LJHQORJLNQLFKWLQGHU/DJH$XVGLHVHU6LFKWPVVWH *RWWGHP]ZDQJKDIWHQ%HJHKUHQIROJHQGLHLKPDOVEHGURKOLFKHUVFKHLQHQGH IUHLH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQJHZDOWVDPNOHLQ]XKDOWHQRKQHGDEHLDEHU GLHDQYLVLHUWH7RWDOKHUUVFKDIWMHPDOVHUUHLFKHQ]XN|QQHQ2GHUZLH.RFKHV DXVGUFNW Ä>(@LQHVROFKH0DFKWLVWLQVLFKXQZDKU6LHNDQQGHVZDKUHQ*RWWHV 0DFKW QLFKW VHLQ³ $Q LKUH 6WHOOH UFNW HEHQGHVKDOE LP &KULVWHQWXP ÄGLH 0DFKWIUHLODVVHQGHU/LHEH³GLHHV*RWWHUODXEWGHV0HQVFKHQÄHQGOLFKH)UHLKHLW QHEHQVLFKDQ]XHUNHQQHQ³XQGJHOWHQ]XODVVHQÄVHOEVW]XP:LGHUVSUXFK³ JHJHQVLFK 6FK|SIXQJVWKHRORJLVFKJHZHQGHWEHGHXWHWGLHV]XGHPGDVV*RWWQLFKWRKQH GLH:HOWE]ZGHQ0HQVFKHQ]XGHQNHQLVW:LUGGHUHQ(UVFKDIIXQJQlPOLFKDOV 7lWLJNHLWHLQHV6XEMHNWVYRUJHVWHOOWJLOWGDIUZDVIUMHGHVVXEMHNWLYH+DQGHOQ JLOW (VLVWEHUKDXSWQXULP7XQYRQHWZDVDOVRLQGHPHVÄHLQ5HVXOWDWYRQVLFK XQWHUVFKHLGHW³6RLVWDOVR*RWWQXUÄPLWGHPYRQLKP8QWHUVFKLHGHQHQ³± 0HQVFKXQG:HOW±QLFKWDEHURKQHRGHUJHJHQHVDOVDXVVLFKKHUDXVKDQGHOQ GHV6FK|SIHUVXEMHNWDQ]XVHKHQ%HLGHVLQGHEHQVRZHQLJLQHLQV]XVHW]HQZLH LQH[WUHPHU:HLVH]XGLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ'LH:HOWLVWDXV*RWWXQGLVW]XJOHLFKVHLQ $QGHUHVGHPZLH*RWWHLQXQWLOJEDUHV6HOEVWVHLQHLJQHW -HQHVDQHUNHQQHQGH)UHLODVVHQGHV$QGHUHQGDV3ULQ]LSJ|WWOLFKHU/LHEHLVW QXQZLH.RFKLQHLQHPGULWWHQ3XQNWDXVIKUWGDVY|OOLJH*HJHQWHLOMHJOLFKHU )RUPYRQ%HIHKOVJHZDOWXQG*HKRUVDPVIRUGHUXQJ1LFKWPXVVGHU0HQVFK*RWW JHJHQEHUVHLQHQHLJHQHQ:LOOHQDXIJHEHQXQGVLFKEHGLQJXQJVORVXQWHUZHUIHQ VRQGHUQHUZLUGDOVJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQVSDUWQHUDN]HSWLHUW'LHV JLOWLQ.RFKV$XJHQIUGLHÄ6FK|SIXQJ³LP*DQ]HQGLHÄNHLQH0DVFKLQHNHLQ
.2&+ (EG (EG (EG .2&+ 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]X.RFKV6FK|SIXQJVEHJULII DD2± $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
EORHVIHUWLJHV3URGXNWVHLQ³NDQQ ZHQQLKUGHQQQDFK GHUJHVFKLOGHUWHQ /RJLNGHV+DQGHOQVHLQH(LJHQVWlQGLJNHLW]XNRPPHQVROO'DUEHUKLQDXVDEHU KDWVLHDOVVLFKYRUDXVJHVHW]WHV$QGHUHVJ|WWOLFKHU/LHEHGDV3RWHQ]LDOGD]XGHP :HVHQLKUHV6FK|SIHUVXQGGDPLWGHP9HUKlOWQLV]XLKPDXVVLFKVHOEVW]XHQW VSUHFKHQ 'DPLWZLUGIU.RFKYLHUWHQVGLH±GXUFK5XGROI%XOWPDQQXQG:ROIKDUW 3DQQHQEHUJNXOWLYLHUWH±5HGHYRQ*RWWDOVGHUÄDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGH>Q@:LUNOLFK NHLW³XQSODXVLEHOXQG]ZDUEHUHLWVDXVJDQ]SURIDQHQ*UQGHQ Ä1XUDOOHVµVD JHQLVWVFKRQUHLQORJLVFKQLFKWPHKUDOVÃQLFKWVµJHVDJW³,P%HVRQGHUHQDEHU SUDOOWGLHVHV*RWWHVYHUVWlQGQLVDQGHUPLWGHU)UHLKHLWYHUNRSSHOWHQ5HDOLWlWGHV %|VHQDE$XIJUXQGVHLQHV$QHUNDQQWVHLQVDOVIUHLNDQQGHU0HQVFKÄ*RWWQLFKW QXUIXUFKWEDUHUZHLVHEHOHLGLJHQVFKlGLJHQHQWVWHOOHQVRQGHUQLKPVRJDUVHLQ *RWWVHLQVWUHLWLJPDFKHQXQGLKPGHQ7RGDQWXQ XQGGLH1DWXUNDQQGDVLQLKUHU :HLVHDXFK³'DV%HVWLPPWZHUGHQGXUFK*RWWEHGHXWHWHEHQNHLQH9HUSIOLFK WXQJ]XDEVROXWHP*HKRUVDPVRQGHUQGLH*HZlKUHLQHV'DVHLQVLQXQDEKlQJL JHU)UHLKHLWPLWDOOLKUHQ$PELYDOHQ]HQÄ'HUZDKUH*RWWLVWGHUGHUPLFKGHQ (LQ]HOQHQ DOV GLHV ,FK DOV 6XEMHNW >«@ YRQ VLFK VF YRQ *RWW IUHL OHEHQ OlW³'HU0HQVFKDEHULVWQXUVHOEVWHWZDVZHLOHUGLH0|JOLFKNHLWKDWE|VH ]XVHLQDOVRQLFKW]XP7XQGHV*XWHQGHWHUPLQLHUWLVW $QGHU:LOOHQVIUHLKHLW±JHQDXHUDP6HOEVWVHLQ±GHV0HQVFKHQKDWGLHWKHRORJLVFKH7KHVH GD*RWWDOOHVLQDOOHPLVWRGHUVHLQZLUGGDHUGLHÃDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGH:LUNOLFKNHLWµLVWLKUH *UHQ]H HLQH*UHQ]HIUHLOLFKGLH*RWWXPVHLQHU*RWWKHLWZLOOHQVHOEVWZLOOLQVRIHUQHUGHQ 0HQVFKHQDOVVHLQHQIUHLHQ%QGQLVSDUWQHUZLOO>«@
'DPLWDEHUHQWVWHKW*RWWÄDXFKHLQSRWHQWLHOOHU.RQWUDKHQWXQG$QWDJRQLVW³ 'RFKZLOO.RFKNHLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQ2KQPDFKWJHJHQEHUGHP1HJDWLYHQGDV :RUWUHGHQGHQQ Ä>6@HOEVW>«@QRFKLP7RG>«@EOHLEW*RWWZDVHULVW GLH DOOHVXFKHQGHQLHPDQGHQDXIJHEHQGH/LHEH³6HLQ:LOOHVWHKWHLQGHXWLJJH JHQDOOHVZDVGLHVHPVHLQHP:HVHQZLGHUVSULFKWDEHUÄ>H@UZLOOZDVHUZLOO QLFKWRKQHXQV³QLFKWDP:LOOHQGHV0HQVFKHQYRUEHL6RLVWHUQLFKWGLH 8UVDFKHGHV%|VHQDEHUDOVGDVLQMHGHU/DJHLPPHUQRFKP|JOLFKHÄXQDXV VFK|SIEDU>H@*XWH³VHKUZRKOGHU*UXQGVHLQHUhEHUZLQGXQJ'LH7KHVHKLQ JHJHQGDVVÄIU*RWW>«@DXFKGDV%|VH]XHWZDVJXW³LVWYHUJHKWVLFKLQ
$D2 .2&+ .2&+ .2&+J .2&+G (EG .2&+ (EG (EG (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
LKUHU3DXVFKDOLWlWHEHQVRDQGHU6HOEVWVLFKWGHVDP%|VHQ/HLGHQGHQ ZLHHV DOOJHPHLQGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQJXWXQGE|VHQLYHOOLHUW,VWEHL*RWWGDVXQWHU0HQ VFKHQ%|VHJXWGDQQ±VR.RFKLP5HNXUVDXI.DQW±HUVFKHLQW*RWWGHP (LQ]HOQHQQLFKWQXUDOVUDFKVFKWLJHUXQG]RUQLJHU9ROOVWUHFNHUGHV%|VHQVRQ GHUQHVYHUOLHUWDXFKGDV*XWHXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQVHLQHXQEHGLQJWH*HOWXQJ 9LHOPHKUZHUGHQÄ>G@DVJDQ]H(OHQGGLHVHU:HOWGDVEHU0HQVFKHQKHUHLQEUH FKHQGH8QKHLOGLHJDQ]HQ9HUEUHFKHQ>«@HLQJHUDGHYRQ*RWWDOVGHPDEVROXW *XWHQDXIJHGHFNWHU6NDQGDO³*RWWHV:LOOH]HLJWVLFKLQLKQHQQXUDOV*HJHQ WHLO -DHVJHVFKLHKWQLFKWVRKQH*RWWHV:LOOHQDEHUYLHOYLHO]XYLHOJHJHQVHLQHQ:LOOHQ GDQQ ZHQQGHU:LOOH*RWWHVYHUNHKUWYHUVWHOOWXQGYHUGHFNWZLUGZHLO0HQVFKHQLKQQLFKWLQLKU HLJHQHV:ROOHQDXIJHQRPPHQKDEHQXQGHEHQQLFKWWXQ
(VLVWDEHUÄGLHEHVWLPPHQGH.UDIWGHV*RWWHVJHGDQNHQV³GDVVHUÄGDV%|VHDOV %|VHVGKDOVGDV:LGHUJ|WWOLFKHXQGGDV:LGHUVLQQLJHTXDOLIL]LHUW³XQGGDPLW GHP6XEMHNWHUP|JOLFKWLP(UNHQQHQXQG*ODXEHQGHVSUDHYDOHQW*XWHQVLFKGHP%|VHQ]X VWHOOHQXPHV]XEHUZLQGHQGKXPGXUFK]XVHW]HQZDVGDV%|VHQDFKVHLQHP%HJULIIVHLQ VROO HEHQGDV1LFKWVHLQ6ROOHQGH
6LFKGXUFK*RWWEHVWLPPWVHLQ]XODVVHQLQGHPDXIGLH9RUPDFKWGHV*XWHQ YHUWUDXWZLUGEHGHXWHWVRQDFKPHQVFKOLFKHUVHLWVDXFKHLQHQ=XJHZLQQDQ'LIIH UHQ]LHUXQJVNUDIWKLQVLFKWOLFKGHVMHXQGMHPRUDOLVFK*HVROOWHQ:RGDVDOOJH PHLQH*XWHGXUFKGHQ0HQVFKHQDOV%HVWLPPHQGHVHUJULIIHQXQG]XP+DQG OXQJV]LHOHUKREHQ ZLUGNDQQ.RFK]XIROJH YRQHLQHU.RRSHUDWLRQ]ZLVFKHQ *RWWXQG0HQVFKJHVSURFKHQZHUGHQ *RWWXQG0HQVFK .RRSHUDWLRQPLWGHP$EVROXWHQLP(QGOLFKHQ Ä'LHDEVROXWH0DFKWGLHDOOHPEHUOHJHQHXQGGDUXPYRUQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQ GHPZHLFKHQGH0DFKW±GLH$OOPDFKW±GHVZDKUHQ*RWWHV³VRIDVVW.RFK]X VDPPHQÄNDQQQXUGLHGHU:DKUKHLWXQGGHU/LHEHVHLQ³'HUHQ%HVRQGHUKHLW LVWGDVVVLHQLFKWSHU=ZDQJYHUIJWVRQGHUQXPGDVIUHLH(LQYHUQHKPHQXQG GDV=XVDPPHQVHLQPLWGHP$QGHUHQZLUEW6LHOlVVWGHQ0HQVFKHQIUHLYRQ DOOHP9HUIJHQXQG%HKHUUVFKHQZROOHQLQVHLQHPIUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQJHOWHQ±VLH HUNHQQWLKQDOVRLP%OLFNDXIVLFKVHOEVWDQ.RFKPDFKW]XGHPDXIGLH'LIIH
9JO.$17 DI>%$ I@ .2&+ (EG .2&+G 9JO]XGLHVHPLP)ROJHQGHQHQWIDOWHWHQ*HGDQNHQ .2&+ E±E.RFK JUHLIWGDPLWGHXWOLFKHLQHQ*HGDQNHQ/XWKHUVDXIGHQGLHVHULQVHLQHU6FKULIW'HVHUYRDUEL WULRHQWIDOWHWKDW YJOGD]X +(506 (LQPDOPHKUEOHLEWGLHJ|WWOLFKH$OOPDFKWEHL .RFKDEHUDXIGLH(U|IIQXQJYRQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJEHVFKUlQNW .2&+
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
UHQ]J|WWOLFKHU/LHEH]XPPHQVFKOLFKHQ/LHEHQN|QQHQDXIPHUNVDP'HUHQ$E VROXWKHLW]HLJWVLFKGDULQGDVVVLHVLFKQLFKWDEKlQJLJYRQGHU=XVWLPPXQJGHV 0HQVFKHQPDFKWXQGQLFKWDQGHVVHQ$EOHKQXQJ]HUJHKW6LHLVWÄVRLP$XVKDO WHQEHUOHJHQ³'DULQ]HLJWVLHVLFK]XJOHLFKDOVÄGLH0DFKWGHU:DKUKHLW³ LQGHPÄ>V@LH>IUHL@EHU]HXJWZHQVLHEHU]HXJW³VLFKDOVRÄGHP(LQVSUXFKXQG GHU$EZHLVXQJGHV$QGHUHQ³ZLHVHLQHUÄIUHLH>Q@(LQVLFKW³DXVVHW]W :R *RWWHV0DFKWGHU/LHEHGHU:DKUKHLWXQGGHV*XWHQ]XP=LHONRPPWLQGHP GLH0HQVFKHQLQVLHÄHLQZLOOLJHQNRPPWVHLQH/LHEH]XU9ROOHQGXQJLVWVLHLQ )UHLKHLWDEVROXW³,QVROFKHUIUHLHQ(LQZLOOLJXQJZLUGGHU(LQ]HOQHZLHDQJH GHXWHW]XP.RRSHUDWLRQVSDUWQHU*RWWHVLQGHPHUVLFKDXIGLHLKPGDPLW]XHU NDQQWH0|JOLFKNHLWGHV6HOEVWVHLQVHLQOlVVW (LQ.RRSHUDWLRQVYHUKlOWQLVOLHJWIU.RFKGDQQYRUZHQQGLHGDUDQ%HWHLOLJ WHQVLFKDOVMH6HOEVWlQGLJHDXIHWZDVJHPHLQVDP*HZROOWHVEH]LHKHQDXIHLQ =LHOLQGHVVHQ(UVWUHEHQVLHVLFKVHOEVWEHUVFKUHLWHQGPLWHLQDQGHUYHUEXQGHQ VLQG ,P )DOOH GHU *RWW0HQVFK%H]LHKXQJ VLHKW HU GLHV 9HUELQGHQGH LQ GHU WUDGLWLRQHOOHQ5HGHYRP5HLFK*RWWHVDXIGHQ%HJULIIJHEUDFKW'LHEHVDJWH DOOPlFKWLJHhEHUOHJHQKHLW*RWWHVDEHUPDFKW.RFKKLHUHLQPDOPHKUQDPKDIW ,P*HJHQVDW]]XP0HQVFKHQLVW*RWWLGHQWLVFKPLWGHPZDVHUZLOODOVRPLW GHPJHPHLQVDPHQ*XWHQLP%OLFNDXIGDVEHLGHYHUEXQGHQVLQG(UEUDXFKW QLFKWHUVWVHLQSDUWLNXODUHV6HOEVWVHLQ]XWUDQV]HQGLHUHQXP]XP$OOJHPHLQHQ]X JHODQJHQÄ*RWW³VRGHILQLHUWHV.RFKÄLVWLQ(LQKHLWGDV'RSSHOWH (ULVWHU VHOEVWXQGGLH*HPHLQVDPNHLWGHU0HQVFKHQXQWHUHLQDQGHUXQGPLWLKP(ULVWHU VHOEVWXQGGHU*RWWXQGGHQ0HQVFKHQ(LQHQGH9HUV|KQHQGH³2GHUZLHHUHV Ä>L@Q+HJHOVFKHU%HJULIIVVSUDFKHIRUPXOLHUW *RWWLVWGLH,GHQWLWlWGHU,GHQWLWlW XQGGHU1LFKWLGHQWLWlW³'LHVHJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWH(LQKHLWGHV]XQlFKVWXQG]X PHLVW'LIIHUHQWHQ±HWZDGHVJHZROOWHQXQGYROOEUDFKWHQ*XWHQRGHUGHULQGLYL GXHOOHUNDQQWXQGDOOJHPHLQJOWLJHQ:DKUKHLW±DEHUUHDOLVLHUWVLFKZLHGHUXPQXU XQWHUPHQVFKOLFKHU%HWHLOLJXQJZRGXUFKVLH]XJOHLFKIUDJPHQWDULVLHUWZLUG 'DVZDKUKDIW$OOJHPHLQHNDQQXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHV3DUWLNXODUHQQLFKW DOVVROFKHVHUVFKHLQHQVRQGHUQQXULQJHEURFKHQHU:HLVHLQGHPHVVLFKJOHLFK VDPLP0HQVFKHQLQNDUQLHUW,P5HDOLVLHUHQGHV*XWHQ*RWWHV E]ZGHV5HLFKHV *RWWHV LVWGLHVHUVRJHUDGHPLWGHPHLQEH]RJHQZDVHUDOOHLQWXQNDQQ (VLQ GHUNRQNUHWHQ$XIJDEHUHDOLVLHUHQXQGQLFKWZRJHJHQ.RFKVLFKGHXWOLFKDXV VSULFKWLQOHW]WOLFK]ZDQJKDIWHQ$EVROXWLVPHQ'LH5HDOLVLHUXQJLPHLQPDOLJHQ 'HWDLO QlPOLFK LVW HEHQVR VHOEVWlQGLJ ]X ILQGHQ ZLH ]X YROO]LHKHQ XQG QLFKW VFKRQYRUJHJHEHQRGHUDXVGHPDOOJHPHLQHQ*XWHQDE]XOHLWHQ'HU0HQVFK±
(EG (EG (EG 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ .2&+ E±E .2&+J9JO'(56 I $D2$QP
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
XQGPLWLKPDOOHV3DUWLNXODUH±LVWJHUDGHLQVHLQHPHQGOLFKHQ5HDOLVDWLRQVYHU P|JHQDQHUNDQQWXQGJHZROOW(ULVW]XU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWIUHLJHODVVHQZDVDXV GHU%HVWLPPWKHLW*RWWHVDOVGHU:DKUKHLWGHU/LHEHXQGGHV*XWHQVHOEVWIROJW 'LHVH%HJULIIHQlPOLFKEHVFKUHLEHQNHLQH.DXVDOLWlWVYHUKlOWQLVVHVRQGHUQVRO FKHGHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ(U|IIQXQJYRQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVP|JOLFKNHLWHQ 'HQQRFKXQWHUVWUHLFKW.RFKGLHhEHUOHJHQKHLW*RWWHVGHUQLFKWHUVWDXIHLQH LKPHLQJHUlXPWH&KDQFHRGHUDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJYRQVHLWHQGHV0HQVFKHQ DQJHZLHVHQLVWXPGLHVHP)UHLKHLW]XJHZlKUHQVRQGHUQVROFKHVLPPHUVFKRQ WXW=XJOHLFKDEHUPDFKWHUNODU :RVHLQPHQVFKOLFKHV*HJHQEHUHQWVSUHFKHQG UHDJLHUWJHZLQQW*RWWLQVHLQHP6HOEVWVHLQJHZLQQHQGDV*XWHGLH:DKUKHLW XQGGLH/LHEHDQ3UlJQDQ]XQGYHUOLHUHQJHZLVVHUPDHQDQ$EVWUDNWKHLW'D]X EUDXFKWHVXQDEGLQJEDUGHQ0HQVFKHQGHULP(QGOLFK5HODWLYHQGDV$EVROXWH LQWHQGLHUWXQGDXIIUDJPHQWDULVFKH:HLVHUHDOLVLHUWÄ1LFKWQXUNRPPWHVGDUDXI DQGDGDV*XWHXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQLQGLHVHU:HOW>«@SUDNWL]LHUWZLUG±VRQ GHUQGD,FKHVWXHGDHVGHUMH(LQ]HOQHWXW³VFKlUIW.RFKDEHUHLQ'LHVH .ODUVWHOOXQJVROOHLQHUVHLWVKHUYRUKHEHQGDVVÄLFKVHOEVW³DOVSRWHQ]LHOOHU7lWHU GHV *XWHQ ÄLQ PHLQHU XQYHUWUHWEDU HLQPDOLJHQ ,QGLYLGXDOLWlW >«@ YRQ *RWW JHZROOWXQGDQHUNDQQWELQ³$QGHUHUVHLWVYHUELQGHWVLFKPLWGLHVHU%HWRQXQJ HLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQÄ:UGHGHVHLQ]HOQHQ³ HLQH$EVDJHDQMHJOLFKH)RUPHLQHU .ROOHNWLYPRUDOGLHVLFKQLFKW±ZLH*RWWVHOEVW±GHUXQKLQWHUJHKEDUHQ)UHLKHLW GHV,QGLYLGXXPVDXVVHW]W*HQDXGLHVHU3XQNWVWHKWDXFKLP=HQWUXPYRQ.RFKV $QHLJQXQJGHV5HLFK*RWWHV*HGDQNHQVLQGHUGLH$XVVDJHQEHUÃ*RWWVHOEVWµ JOHLFKVDPZLHGHULQGLH%H]JHGHV6R]LDOHQUFNEHUVHW]WZHUGHQ%HYRUGHU 5HLFK*RWWHV*HGDQNHMHGRFKLP)ROJHQGHQHQWIDOWHWZLUGLVWQXQGHUZLHHU ZlKQWYRQ.RFKVHOEVWDQWL]LSLHUWH(LQZDQG]XEHGHQNHQHUZUGHÄ5HPLQLV ]HQ]HQHLQHVYRUNULWLVFKH>Q@Ã7KHLVPXVµRGHUHLQHUÃ6XEVWDQ]RQWRORJLHµ³EH GLHQHQ *RWWDOV6XEMHNW 5HPLQLV]HQ]HQHLQHVYRUNULWLVFKHQ7KHLVPXV" 0LWVHLQHULQGHQ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ3DVVDJHQXQNRPPHQWLHUWHQWIDOWHWHQhEHU ]HXJXQJGDVV*RWWÄÃGDV$EVROXWHµDOV6XEMHNW³]XGHQNHQVHLJHKW.RFKQDFK HLJHQHP$QVSUXFKYRQHLQHUÄhEHUOHJXQJDXVGLHMHGHU0HQVFKYRUQHKPHQ NDQQ³ZHQQHUVLFKPLWGHU)UDJHNRQIURQWLHUWÄZLHHUVLFK]XGHQ5HDOLWlWHQ VHLQHV/HEHQVVHOEVWYHUKlOWXQGZLHHUVLFKLQGLHVHQVHLQHQ/HEHQVEH]JHQ VHOEVWYHUVWHKW³'HUOHEHQVSUDNWLVFKH$XVJDQJVSXQNWGHXWHWHVLFKEHUHLWVLQ VHLQHP+LQZHLVDQQLHPDQGN|QQHVLFKDXIHLQHQ*RWWYHUODVVHQGHUÃQXURKQ PlFKWLJµLVWDOVRVHOEVWQLFKWVYHUPDJZHLOHUVHOEVWQLFKWVLVW*RWWVRKLHHV
.2&+ E (EG (EG .2&+U $QP $D2 I
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DXVGUFNOLFKPXVVXPGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVZLOOHQVHOEVWHWZDVVHLQ 'LH,GHQWLILNDWLRQ*RWWHVDOVÃ$OOPDFKWGHU/LHEHGHU:DKUKHLWXQGGHV*XWHQµ OlVVWVLFKYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQG]XQlFKVWHLQPDODOV5HIOH[DXIGLHDPELYDOHQ WH(UIDKUXQJQDFKYROO]LHKHQGDVV/LHEHXQWHU0HQVFKHQHQGHQ:DKUKHLWUHODWL YLHUWXQG*XWHVYRQ%|VHPGXUFKNUHX]WZHUGHQNDQQ±XQGGDVVPDQGHQQRFK QLFKWGDYRQDE]XODVVHQYHUPDJDOOGLHVIUVLFKRGHUDQGHUH]XHUZDUWHQÄ/lW HLQHU GLHVHQ =ZLHVSDOW³ ]ZLVFKHQ HUZDUWHWHU XQG UHDOHU /HEHQVZLUNOLFKNHLW ÄZLUNOLFKEHLVLFK]XVRLVWHU³ZLH.RFKVFKUHLEWÄEHUHLWVLQGHU%HZHJXQJ GLHEHUGLHVH>Q@KLQDXVIKUW(UILQGHWLP*HLVW±LQ*RWW±HLQHQ$QKDOW]XP %HVWHKHQGHU1RW³ hEHUGHQSURMHNWLYHQ&KDUDNWHUGLHVHVDXVGHU1RWJHERUHQHQNRQWUDIDNWL VFKHQ6HW]HQVDXI*RWWDOVGHUJOHLFKVDPXQYHUVLHJEDUHQ4XHOOHGHVLPPHUQRFK P|JOLFKHQ*XWHQGDVPLFKGD]XEHIlKLJWÄGHQQRFKLFKVHOEVWVHLQ³]XN|Q QHQZLOO.RFKDEHUKLQDXVJHKHQ1LFKWLVWÄGDV8QEHGLQJWH±XQGPLWKLQ*RWW± >«@YRQGHUWUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWEHGLQJW³VRQGHUQVRZXUGHGHXW OLFKÄDXVVLFKVHOEVWÃHWZDVµ³VRQVWÄZlUHHVQLFKWXQEHGLQJW³'DV$XVVLFK VHOEVW6HLQ*RWWHVOlVVWVLFKDPQLFKWLQNDXVDOHQ+DQGOXQJVVLQQEHUIKUEDUHQ &KDUDNWHUHEHQMHQHUYRQ.RFKDOVJ|WWOLFKLGHQWLIL]LHUWHQ3KlQRPHQHGHU/LHEH GHU:DKUKHLWXQGGHV*XWHQYHUVWlQGOLFKPDFKHQ6RZRKQWGLHVHQGUHLHQXQ ZHLJHUOLFKHLQGDVVLHLQWHQGLHUHQGH6XEMHNWEHUVWHLJHQGHU$QVSUXFKLQQHGHU HVYRQGHUXQYHUIJEDUHQ)UHLKHLW$QGHUHUDEKlQJLJVHLQOlVVWXQGXPJHNHKUW,Q LKUHP]ZDULQWHQGLHUEDUHQDEHUQLFKWPDFKEDUHQ$XINRPPHQPHOGHWVLFKHLQ GDV0HQVFKHQP|JOLFKHEHUVWHLJHQGHV$QGHUHVGDVLQDFWXDOVUHDOP|JOLFK YRUDXVJHVHW]WZLUG$OV$XVGHXWXQJGLHVHU(UIDKUXQJVNRQVWHOODWLRQODVVHQVLFK .RFKVLQV6SHNXODWLYHEHUJOHLWHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQGLHÃEHUOHJHQHhEHUPDFKW *RWWHVµ EHWUHIIHQG GXUFKDXV QDFKYROO]LHKEDU PDFKHQ 'LH GDEHL DXVJHVDJWH $V\PPHWULHLP*RWW0HQVFK9HUKlOWQLVZLUGPLWKLQGDGXUFKUHODWLYLHUWGDVV GLH)UHLKHLWVLFKGXUFK:DKUKHLWV]XPXWXQJHQ /LHEHVEHNXQGXQJHQRGHUGDV $QGHUHQI|UGHUOLFKH*XWHEHVWLPPHQ]XODVVHQGDEHLVWHWVYRUDXVJHVHW]WLVWXQG LQGLHVHP6LQQHDOVGHP0HQVFKHQGXUFK*RWWVHOEVWHLQJHUlXPWJHGHXWHWZHU GHQ NDQQ $OOHUGLQJV VLQG .RFKV UHDOLVWLVFK DQPXWHQGH %HVFKUHLEXQJHQ GHV J|WWOLFKHQ$JLHUHQVQLFKWGDYRUJHIHLWGLHYRPLKPDQJHVWUHEWH%RGHQKDIWXQJ ]X YHUOLHUHQ XQG ]XPLQGHVW DXI VSUDFKOLFKHU (EHQH LQ HLQHQ ÃYRUNULWLVFKHQ 7KHLVPXVµDE]XJOHLWHQ'DVPDJDXFKPLWVHLQHUQDFKGHUHLJHQHQ.UDQNKHLWVHU IDKUXQJLPPHUVWlUNHUGXUFKVFKHLQHQGHQSHUV|QOLFKHQ)U|PPLJNHLW]XVDPPHQ KlQJHQ
.2&+ D .2&+ E .2&+U $QP (LQ$XVGUXFNGDYRQLVWDXFKGLHPLWGHP5XKHVWDQGYHUVWlUNWHLQVHW]HQGHLQWHQVLYH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ.RFKVPLWHLQ]HOQHQ:HUNHQDOWSURWHVWDQWLVFKHU)U|PPLJNHLW]%DXV GHU)HGHUYRQ-RKDQQ+DEHUPDQQ3KLOLSS1LFRODL3DXO*HUKDUGWXQG&DWKDULQD5HJLQDYRQ
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
*HUDGHDP%HLVSLHOYRQ.RFKV$QHLJQXQJGHV5HLFK*RWWHV*HGDQNHQVZLUG MHGRFKHLQPDOPHKUGHULPPHUDXFKWUDGLWLRQVNULWLVFKH&KDUDNWHUVHLQHV'HQ NHQVGHXWOLFK *RWWHV5HLFK 'DV8QEHGLQJWHLP%HGLQJWHQ 'DVVÄGDV8QEHGLQJWHLQGLH%HGLQJWKHLWHQXQG=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWHQGHUJHJHEHQHQ /HEHQVXPVWlQGH KLQHLQ]XGHQNHQ ZHLO GDULQ ]X UHDOLVLHUHQ LVW³ PDFKW .RFK QlPOLFKNULWLVFKJHJHQEHUGHU5DGLNDOLWlWGHU5HLFK*RWWHV3UHGLJW-HVXJHO WHQG'HUHQ3RLQWHHQWGHFNWHULQGHUÄDQMHGHQ(LQ]HOQHQ³JHULFKWHWHQ)RUGH UXQJ XQEHGLQJW>«@GHPYHUSIOLFKWHW]XVHLQZDVLQVLFKXQEHGLQJWHLQGHXWLJXQGLPPHUJHOWHQG LVW GHP*HLVWGHU9HUV|KQXQJGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWDOOHU0HQVFKHQGHU:DKUKHLWXQGGHU QLFKWQDFKODVVHQGHQ/LHEH±XQGDOVRGHP5HLFK*RWWHV
1LFKW]XOHW]WJHK|UWLQGLHVHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJDXFKGDV*HERWGHU)HLQGHVOLHEH GLHÄLQGHPVLHQLFKW*OHLFKHVPLW*OHLFKHPYHUJLOW>«@GHP$QGHUHQVHOEVW DOV)HLQGGLH&KDQFHGHU(LQVLFKWXQGDOVRGHV$EODVVHQVYRQVHLQHU)HLQG VFKDIW³RIIHQOlVVW.RFKVLHKWGDULQEHUHLWVDQJHOHJW ZDVGLH1HX]HLW>«@DOVZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJJHJHQGLH)HLQGVFKDIWDXIELHWHW HLQ *HOWHQXQG/HEHQODVVHQGHV$QGHUHQGDVVHOEVWLQGHQ)lOOHQQRFKVWDWWKDWLQGHQHQGHU $QGHUHPLUJOHLFKJOWLJZLUGXQGPDQVLFKDXVGHP:HJHJHKW
'RFKPLWGHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWHLQDQGHU*OHLFKJOWLJHULVWHVQLFKWZHLWKHUZHLO VLH.RFKVSULFKWDXFKYRQGHUÄ*OHLFKJOWLJNHLWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³VRGXUFK LKU 9HUKlOWQLV QLFKW LQ LKUHP MH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6HOEVWVHLQ EHWURIIHQ VLQG 'DV 5HLFK*RWWHVRGHUZDV*RWWXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQLVWNRPPWGHPKLQJHJHQJH UDGHLQ(UIDKUXQJHQLQWHQVLYHQ6LFK=XVDPPHQILQGHQV]XU:LUNOLFKNHLW'DU EHUKLQDXVJHODQJWPDQDQJHVLFKWVGHUYRQ*HZDOWXQG)HLQGVHOLJNHLW]HXJHQGHQ Ä*HVFKLFKWHXQG>«@SROLWLVFKVR]LDOHQ*HJHQZDUW³RKQHKLQVFKQHOO]XGHP (UJHEQLV ÄDQJHVLFKWVGLHVHU*HVHOOVFKDIW±NHLQ5HLFK*RWWHV³'LHVH.RQVH TXHQ]MHGRFKPXVVQXU]LHKHQZHUGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ5HODWLYHPXQG$EVROXWHP YRQ%HGLQJWHPXQG8QEHGLQJWHQQLFKWYROO]LHKWVRQGHUQEHLGHVLGHQWLIL]LHUW :LUGGLHEHVDJWH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJVHLWHQVGHU7KHRORJLHQLFKWYROO]RJHQVRQGHUQ GHU5DGLNDOLWlW-HVXZRUWZ|UWOLFKQDFKJHIROJWJHUlWGLHVHLQ.RFKV$XJHQ]XU ,GHRORJLHÄ'HQQ>«@XQNULWLVFK5HODWLYHV]XP$EVROXWHQ³]XHUKHEHQNHQQ *UHLIIHQEHUJ,QGLHVHQ:HUNHQZROOWHHULP*UXQGHKHUDXVILQGHQDXIZHOFKH:HLVHJOHLFK VDPREMHNWLYHWKHRORJLVFKGRJPDWLVFKH$XVVDJHQLQGHU)U|PPLJNHLWGHV6XEMHNWVUHVRQLHUHQ .2&+ 9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 $D29JOGD]XLQVJHVDPW DD2 ± $D2 .2&+D .2&+ E
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
]HLFKQHWLGHRORJLVFKHV'HQNHQGDVVWHWVÄ$XVGUXFNHLQHVQLFKWGXUFKVFKDXWHQ 6WUHEHQVQDFK6LFKHUKHLW³LVWPLWGHP=LHOÄGDV1LFKW(LJHQHGDV$QGHUHVLFK YHUIJEDU]XPDFKHQ³ 1XQ EOHLEW DEHU KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU )UDJH ZLH DQJHVLFKWV GHV LPPHU ZLHGHU GXUFKVFKODJHQGHQ%|VHQGLHLGHDOH6R]LDOLWlWGHV5HLFKHV*RWWHVEHUKDXSW]XP ZHOWJHVWDOWHQGHQ3ULQ]LSVROOZHUGHQN|QQHQLQ-HVX%RWVFKDIWÄHLQQLFKWJHO|V WHU5HVW³.RFKVLHKWGLHVHV3UREOHPEHUVSUXQJHQMDGLHQLFKWLQGLH/RJLN GHU HLJHQHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH SDVVHQGHQ 1HJDWLYLWlWVHUIDKUXQJHQ ± ]% /HLGHQ 6FKXOG7RG±VFKOLFKWDEJHEOHQGHWZHQQGDV5HLFK*RWWHVYHUEXQGHQPLWHQW VSUHFKHQGHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ $SSHOOHQ ]XP LQQHUZHOWOLFK ]X HUVWUHEHQGHQ ,GHDO HUNOlUWZLUG(EHQVRDEHUNULWLVLHUWHUGHVVHQ(VFKDWRORJLVLHUXQJHWZDLQ*HVWDOW GHU3RVLWLRQVHLQHV/HKUHUV3DQQHQEHUJ+LHUQlPOLFKZLUGHQWZHGHUEDUDOOHU 9HUQXQIWHLQ:LVVHQEHU=XNQIWLJHVEHDQVSUXFKW*RWWDOVJHJHQZlUWLJQRFK GHIL]LWlUKLQJHVWHOOWRGHUÄVHLQÃ5HLFKµPLWGHQ0HQVFKHQ>«@IU*RWWVHOEVWDOV QHEHQVlFKOLFK³DXVJHJHEHQ:DVDEHUVWHOOW.RFKGHPHQWJHJHQ" (LQHUVHLWVLVW*RWWÄQLFKWRKQHVHLQÃ5HLFKµPLWGHQ0HQVFKHQ]XGHQNHQ³ JHK|UW HV DOVR ]X LKP LQ (UIDKUXQJHQ JHOLQJHQGHU =ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKNHLW JHJHQZlUWLJ]XZHUGHQ6ROFKH0RPHQWHHQWKDOWHQÄLQVLFKHLQHQhEHUVFKX XQGGDPLWGDV9HUVSUHFKHQLQGLH=HLWKLQHLQZHLWHU]XZLUNHQXQGDOVRLQGLH QRFKDXVVWHKHQGH9ROOHQGXQJ]XWUHLEHQ³±HLQ9HUVSUHFKHQGDVGLH1HJDWLYL WlWVXQG'LIIHUHQ]EHVWLPPWKHLWHQGOLFKHQ'DVHLQVEHUGHQ0RPHQWKLQDXV DXFKLP+DQGHOQ]XWUDQV]HQGLHUHQHUODXEWÄ:HLODOVRGDV8QEHGLQJWHLPEH GLQJWHQ /HEHQLVW³EULQJW.RFKGLHVDXIGHQ3XQNW ÄLVW GDVHQGOLFKH/HEHQ HLQHV 0HQVFKHQ QLFKW QXU YRUOlXILJ XQG YHUJlQJOLFK XQG LVW QLFKW QXU DOOHV EUXFKVWFNKDIWZDVZLUWXQHUIDKUHQXQGJHVWDOWHQ³9LHOPHKUJLOW Ä0DQFKHV JHOLQJWXQVDXFKIUDJORV³HWZDÄLQHLQHP*HVSUlFKHLQ(LQYHUVWlQGQLV]XHUIDK UHQGDVMHGHVZHLWHUH:RUWHUEULJW³'RFKJLEWHVDXFKGHQÄ6FKPHU]GHV 1LFKWJHOLQJHQVXQG]XZHLOHQGHV9HUVFKXOGHQV³GHUÄ>H@LQH(LQGHXWLJNHLWGHV /HEHQV³ XQHUVFKZLQJOLFK HUVFKHLQHQ OlVVW $XV GHU (UIDKUXQJ ÄGHU 8QEH
.2&+ E .2&+ E I9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2±.RFKHQWGHFNWLQ-HVX5HLFK *RWWHV3UHGLJWIROJHQGHQ:LGHUVSUXFK (LQHUVHLWVSUHGLJWXQGSUDNWL]LHUW-HVXVGDV$XVKDOWHQ GHV%|VHQZHLOHVVLFKJHJHQEHUGHUhEHUPDFKWGHV5HLFKHV*RWWHVRKQHKLQHUVFK|SIHQ ZLUG$QGHUHUVHLWVDEHULVWHUQLFKWIUHLYRQ=RUQXQG6WUDIJHGDQNHQJHJHQEHUGHQHQGLHLKP QLFKWIROJHQZRPLWHUVHLQHHLJHQH%RWVFKDIWZHQLJVWHQVSXQNWXHOOKLQWHUJHKW(VEOHLEWDOVR ÄGLHZHOWKDIWH'XUFKVHW]XQJGHV5HLFKHV*RWWHVEHLPLUGLVFKZLUNHQGHQ-HVXVLQGHU6FKZH EH³ZHQQHVXPGLH)UDJHÄGHUhEHUZLQGXQJGHV%|VHQ³JHKW DD2 I .2&+ E9JOIUGLHNULWLVFKH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW3DQQHQEHUJLQGLHVHU )UDJH '(56GII .2&+ E (EG .2&+ (EG (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
GLQJWKHLW *RWWHV³ DEHU VROO GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW HUZDFKVHQ ÄXQV DXFK DXIULFKWLJ XQVHUHU=ZHLGHXWLJNHLWXQG8Q]XOlQJOLFKNHLW]XVWHOOHQ³GKVLHQLFKWUHVLJ QLHUHQGVRQGHUQIUZHLWHUH0RPHQWHGHV*HOLQJHQVRIIHQDQ]XQHKPHQ 9RQGLHVHPGXUFKGDV8QEHGLQJWHVLFKEHVWLPPWVHLQODVVHQGHQ/HEHQVYROO ]XJLVW*RWWDOVGDV8QEHGLQJWH±DQGHUHUVHLWV±DOVRQRFKHLQPDO]XXQWHUVFKLH GHQ'HPNRUUHVSRQGLHUWGLHJHJHQHLQH0RUDOLVLHUXQJGHV5HLFKHV*RWWHVDXV JHVSURFKHQH$XVNXQIW.RFKVGDV&KULVWHQWXPVHLNHLQHSROLWLVFKH5HOLJLRQGLH VLFK DQ LKUHQ SROLWLVFKVR]LDOHQ PLWKLQ |IIHQWOLFKHQ )ROJHQ ]X EHZDKUKHLWHQ KlWWH9LHOPHKUJHKWHVEHLP5HLFK*RWWHV*HGDQNHQYRQMHKHULPPHUDXFK GDUXPGDVVGHUÄHLQ]HOQH>@GDVÃ+HLOµZHUGHQVHLQHUVHOEVWLQGHUhEHUHLQVWLP PXQJPLW*RWWHV)ULHGHQXQG*HUHFKWLJNHLW YJO5|P ±XQGVRLP(LQLJ ZHUGHQ PLW VLFK VHOEVW ILQGH>W@³ 'LHVHV LQGLYLGXHOOH 6LFKVHOEVWILQGHQ GHV 6XEMHNWVLQGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWPLW$QGHUHQLVWLQ.RFKV$XJHQDOVLQQHUOLFKHV *HVFKHKHQQLFKWLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUEDU(V]XJXQVWHQHLQHUYRQ0HQVFKHQGHNUH WLHUWHQ6R]LDOXWRSLHGHV5HLFKHV*RWWHVGLHGDV$EVROXWHYROOVWlQGLJLQV(QG OLFK5HODWLYHKLQHLQ]LHKWDXV]XEOHQGHQKLHH)UHLKHLWGXUFK=ZDQJ]XHUVHW]HQ ,QGHU,JQRUDQ]JHJHQEHUGLHVHPQXUVXEMHNWLYVLFKYROO]LHKHQGHQ6LQQHVZDQ GHOVLHKW.RFKHWZDGDVIXQGDPHQWDOH'HIL]LWÄGHV0DU[LVPXVLQDOOHQ)RUPHQ VHLQHUELVKHULJHQ9HUZLUNOLFKXQJ³EHJUQGHWGHUÄGLHVHDXVVFKODJJHEHQGH,P SOLNDWLRQPLWGHU%HUXIXQJDXIGLH0DVVHGHV9RONHVRGHUGHUHQ8QWHUGUFNWVHLQ VLFK VFKHQNHQ ]X N|QQHQ PHLQW³ :HU ZLH .RFK HV 0DU[ ]XVFKUHLEW GDV Ä$OOJHPHLQH>@ DOV QXU PHQVFKOLFKHV ,GHDO³ GHNODULHUW ÄUHNODPLHUW HV IU GHQ %HVLW]GHV0HQVFKHQXQGSHUYHUWLHUWHVVR³'LH5HGHYRQ*RWWYHUZHLVWGHP KLQJHJHQDXIGDVÄZDKUKDIWHLQH>@$OOJHPHLQH>@³GDVÄGHU0HQVFK>«@DXHU VLFK³KDWXQGGDVHVLKPHUP|JOLFKWVLFKDXV)UHLKHLWLQGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWPLW $QGHUHQ]XILQGHQ'LHVDEHUEOHLEWDOVIUHLKHLWOLFKHHLQHYRQ$QGHUHQQLFKW YHUIJEDUH$QJHOHJHQKHLW .RFKV ]ZLHVSlOWLJHU %HJULII YRQ *RWW DOV LQ GLH *HVWDOWXQJ GHU HQGOLFK UHODWLYHQ/HEHQVYHUKlOWQLVVHHLQJHKHQGHVXQGGDYRQGHQQRFKLPPHUZLHGHU]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQGHV $EVROXWHV OHLWHW ZLH JHVHKHQ DXFK VHLQH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GHV 5HLFK*RWWHV*HGDQNHQV$OVDXVVFKODJJHEHQGIUGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]LVWGDEHLGDV 3KlQRPHQGHUVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLKHLWYRU$XJHQJHWUH WHQ ,P 6LQQH GHV 5HLFK*RWWHV*HGDQNHQV LVW VLH QRWZHQGLJ DQ]XHUNHQQHQ RKQHGDPLWEHUGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJJHOLQJHQGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWDP2UWHGHV(LQ ]HOQHQYHUIJHQ]XN|QQHQ'DV5HLFK*RWWHV±HVLVWHEHQ]XJOHLFKÄPLWWHQ
(EG 9JO]XGLHVHP3XQNW .2&+ EI $D2 .2&+O .2&+S (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
XQWHUHXFK³XQGÄLQZHQGLJLQHXFK³6HLQH9HUZLUNOLFKXQJKlQJWGDUDQGDVV EHLGH 'LPHQVLRQHQ ± GLH VR]LDOH XQG GLH LQGLYLGXHOOH ± ]XVDPPHQNRPPHQ 'HUHQLPPHUZLHGHUKHUYRUWUHWHQGH3DVVXQJHQDXLJNHLWE]Z8QYHUV|KQOLFKNHLW GHXWHW.RFKJHZLVVHUPDHQYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQGVHLQHV%HJULIIGHVVLFKOHW]WHQ (QGHVDOOHP=XJULIIHQW]LHKHQGHQ$EVROXWHQ0RPHQWHGHV*HOLQJHQVYRQ*H PHLQVDPNHLWWUHWHQDOVGHVVHQVLWXDWLYH9HUJHJHQZlUWLJXQJYRU$XJHQGLHDEHU VWHWVZLHGHUQHX]XUFNLQGLHGLIIHUHQ]EHVWLPPWH(QGOLFKNHLWIKUW6LQGVROFKH 9HUV|KQXQJVHUIDKUXQJHQDXFKLQ.RFKV$XJHQGXUFKQLFKWV]XEHZHUNVWHOOLJHQ VR OlVVW VLFK LKQHQ GRFK JHZLVVHUPDHQ GHU %RGHQ EHUHLWHQ ± RGHU HEHQ GLH 0|JOLFKNHLWGDVVVLHVLFKHLQVWHOOHQYRQYRUQKHUHLQPLQLPLHUHQ6RLVWIULKQ ÄGDV5HFKWGLHlXHUH(UP|JOLFKXQJVROFKHU)UHLKHLWLPYHUV|KQHQGHQ*HLVW³ ZHLOHV]XPLQGHVWJDUDQWLHUWGDVVGHU(LQ]HOQHVLFKLQQHUKDOEGHUYHUVFKLHGHQHQ VR]LDOHQ6SKlUHQDOVIUHLDQHUNDQQWZLVVHQGDUI:LHPLWGLHVHU$QHUNHQQXQJ VHLQHUVHOEVWYHUIlKUWGDVDEHULVWZLHGHUXP6DFKHVHLQHU)UHLKHLW'LHVLFKGDU DXVIUGLH,QVWLWXWLRQHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQVHUJHEHQGHQ6SDQQXQJHQZHU GHQLPIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWW]XP7KHPD
0HQVFKXQG0HQVFK )UHLKHLWGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJ± $QHUNHQQXQJDXV)UHLKHLW =ZLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG)UHLKHLW :LHVFKRQEHLP%HJULIIGHV*|WWOLFK$EVROXWHQHQWIDOWHW.RFKDXFKVHLQH6R]L DOWKHRULHLQNULWLVFKDIILUPDWLYHP$QVFKOXVVDQ0RWLYH+HJHOV(UJHKWGDEHL YRQGHVVHQ5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLHDXVGLHHUÄDOVHLQH3KLORVRSKLHGHU/HEHQVZHOW³ OLHVWDOVHLQHSKLORVRSKLVFKH5HIOH[LRQMHQHUVR]LDOHQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHDOVRLQ GHQHQÄMHGHU(LQ]HOQHDOV6XEMHNWZLUNOLFKXQGIROJOLFKEHVWLPPWLVWXQGVLFKDOV VROFKHUYRUILQGHW³0HQVFKOLFKHV6HOEVWVHLQELOGHWVLFKGHP]XIROJHDXIXQHQW ULQQEDUH:HLVHLQ.RQWH[WHQGHV6R]LDOHQRGHUZLH.RFKDXFKVFKUHLEWÄLQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³ GHQHQ]X]XJHK|UHQNHLQH$QJHOHJHQKHLW IUHLHU:DKOGDUVWHOOW9LHOPHKUZHUGHQGHP(LQ]HOQHQGXUFKGDV$QHUNDQQWXQG VRPLW%HVWLPPWVHLQDOV)DPLOLHQPLWJOLHG7HLOQHKPHUDP0DUNW6WDDWVEUJHU HWFEHUKDXSWHUVWÄ&KDQFHQGHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ³RGHUÄ&KDQFHQGHV6LFK ILQGHQVDOV6XEMHNW³ HU|IIQHW,QVRIHUQHLQMHGHUGLHVHLKPUHFKWOLFKHLQJH UlXPWHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHV6HOEVWVHLQVVWHWVLPPHUVFKRQLUJHQGZLHHUJULIIHQ KDWVLQGDOOHLP$OOJHPHLQHQGHUVR]LDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQLQGLHVLHKLQHLQJHVWHOOW
6RODXWHQYHUVFKLHGHQHhEHUVHW]XQJVYDULDQWHQYRQ/NGHUHQOHW]WHUHELVKLQ]XU 5HYLVLRQGHU/XWKHUELEHO 9HUZHQGXQJIDQGXQGGDQDFKGXUFKGLHHUVWHUHHUVHW]WZXUGH .2&+D $D2 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 II (EG $D2
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
VLQGLQGLYLGXHOODXFKÃJXWDXIJHKREHQµ0LWHLQHP6HLWHQKLHEJHJHQ.DQWJLEW .RFKGHPHQWVSUHFKHQG]XYHUVWHKHQGDVVÄ>Y@RQGLHVHUUHDOHQ%HVWLPPWKHLW >«@QLFKWLPPHU]XÃWUDQV]HQGHQWDOµ]XDEVWUDKLHUHQVRQGHUQGLHVH>«@DOVJH OHEWHSUDNWL]LHUWH:LUNOLFKNHLW]XEHJUHLIHQ³LVW $EHUHUVHOEVWVFKWWHWDXFK:DVVHULQGHQ:HLQGHUHUGLHHLQHUÄÃVR]LDOH>Q@ .RQVWLWXWLRQGHV6XEMHNWVµ³ GDV:RUWUHGHQHVDOVRJHZLVVHUPDHQLQGHQ EHVDJWHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ DXIJHKHQ ODVVHQ Ä+HJHO³ VR PRQLHUW .RFKÄOHKUWGDV$XIJHKREHQVHLQGHV6XEMHNWV>«@LP$OOJHPHLQHQYRQ5HFKW XQG6LWWOLFKNHLW³REZRKOHVÄGDULQQLFKWDOVHVVHOEVWVRDXIJHKREHQ>LVW@GDVVHV ZDKUKDIWLGHQWLVFKPLWVLFKXQGVHLQHU:LUNOLFKNHLWVHLQN|QQWH³ 9LHOPHKU XQWHUVFKHLGHWVLFKGDV6XEMHNWÄLP/HEHQLQGLHVHU6SKlUHJOHLFKVDPÃQRFKHLQ PDOµYRQLKU XQGHVWXWGDVLQVHLQHP*HZLVVHQ³ :RGLHVHVVLFKPHOGHW NRPPW]XJOHLFKGLHJUXQGVlW]OLFKH8QEHGLQJWKHLWXQG)UHLKHLWPHQVFKOLFKHQ 6HOEVWVHLQV JHJHQEHU DOOHQ lXHUHQ ,QVWDQ]HQ ]X %HZXVVWVHLQ $XV GHP LP *HZLVVHQ YHUDQNHUWHQ 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVYHUP|JHQ GHV 0HQVFKHQ UHVXOWLHUW ÄHLQHQLFKWDXVWLOJEDUHLPPHUQXUDXIKHEEDUHXQG]XJOHLFKDOVQHXHLQJHVHW]W]X EHJUHLIHQGH'XDOLWlWYRQ6XEMHNWXQGVR]LDOHUOHEHQVZHOWOLFKHU%HVWLPPWKHLW³ E]ZYRQ6XEMHNWXQGLKP]XWHLOZHUGHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ $XIJUXQGGLHVHU XQEHUZLQGOLFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]YHUPDJGHU(LQ]HOQHQLHPDOVJDQ]XQGJDUPLWGHQ LKQEHVWLPPHQGHQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQYHUV|KQW]XVHLQGLHLKPVRPLWQLHPDOV ]XP$EVROXWHQZHUGHQN|QQHQVRQGHUQYLHOPHKUGXUFKHLQHLPPDQHQWH.ULVHQ DQIlOOLJNHLWJHNHQQ]HLFKQHWVLQG6LHVLQGQlPOLFKLQLKUHP%HVWDQGXQGLKUHU 4XDOLWlWDEKlQJLJYRPGXUFKNHLQHUOHLlXHUOLFKH0DQDKPHQHU]ZLQJEDUHQ XQGLQGLHVHP6LQQHIUHLHQ:LOOHQGHUDQLKQHQEHWHLOLJWHQ6XEMHNWH'DVVHLQHU GXUFKVHLQHQVR]LDOHQ.RQWH[WLP%OLFNDXIHWZDV%HVWLPPWHVEHVWlWLJWXQGVR ]XHLQHPHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ7XQLQ6WDQGJHVHW]WZLUGVDJWQRFKODQJHQLFKWVGDU EHUDXVREXQGZLHHUGLHVHLKPHLQJHUlXPWH&KDQFHQXW]WMDLQZLHIHUQLKP GLHVEHUKDXSWHQWVSULFKW(VLVWGLHVHVXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUH0RPHQWGDV.RFKYRQ HLQHUÄ8QYHUIJEDUNHLWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³VSUHFKHQOlVVW :HLOGHU 3UR]HJHJHQVHLWLJHU$N]HSWDWLRQXQG6HOEVWILQGXQJHLQ9HUKlOWQLVYRQ)UHLHQLVWLVWHUZHGHU LQVHLQHP(LQWUHWHQQRFKLQVHLQHP*HOLQJHQGXUFKLUJHQGHWZDVJDUDQWLHUWDXFKQLFKWHWZD GXUFKHLQ9HUWUDXHQDXI*RWW
*RWWLVWIU.RFKNHLQ*DUDQWIXQNWLRQLHUHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]LHKXQJHQVRQ GHUQGHU(UP|JOLFKXQJVJUXQGHLQHVQLFKWUHVLJQDWLYHQ8PJDQJVPLWGHUHQXQ EHUZLQGOLFKHU6FKHLWHUQVDQIlOOLJNHLW'LH5HGHYRQ*RWWEHDQWZRUWHWJHZLV VHUPDHQGLH)UDJHZLHGLHDXVGHUÄ(QGOLFKNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQ³UHVXOWLHUHQGH
$D2 $D2 $D2 (EG $D2 .2&+ D
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
8QVLFKHUKHLWVR]LDOHU9HUKlOWQLVVHÄGLHQXULQJHOXQJHQHQ$XJHQEOLFNHQYHU VFKZLQGHWXQGGHP(LQGUXFNGHV8QEHGLQJWHQZHLFKW³ VR]XHUWUDJHQLVW GDVVVLHQLFKW]XPDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGHQ)DNWRUJHUlW+LHUNRPPW*RWWHEHQDOV Ä*HLVWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³ Ä*HLVWGHVIUHLHQ0LWHLQDQGHUV³ RGHUÄ*HLVWGHU *HPHLQVDPNHLW³]XU*HOWXQJYRQGHPYHUWUDXHQGVLFKEHVWLPPHQ]XODVVHQ IU.RFKGDV:HVHQGHU FKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQLVW(LQPDOPHKUDEHU]HLJWVLFK KLHUGLHOHW]WH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ*|WWOLFKHPXQG0HQVFKOLFKHPGHU0RPHQWHSDU WLHOOHU,GHQWLWlWJHJHQEHUVWHKHQ :LH.RFKGLHVH6SDQQXQJYRQLQGLYLGXHOOHU)UHLKHLWXQGVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQ QXQJLQQHUKDOEYHUVFKLHGHQHU6R]LDOEHUHLFKHQDPKDIWPDFKWXQGZHOFKH3RWHQ ]LDOHHUDXIVHLWHQGHV&KULVWHQWXPVIULKUH/|VXQJHQWGHFNWZLUGLQIROJHQGHQ 8QWHUDEVFKQLWWHQ]XP7KHPD'HP5HFKW NRPPWGDEHLHLQHJUXQGOHJHQGH %HGHXWXQJ]XLQVRIHUQHVDOVÄGLHXQVDOOHQJHPHLQVDPH6SKlUHIUHLJHODVVHQHU )UHLKHLWVlXHUXQJ³IUHLQVHOEVWEHVWLPPWHV+DQGHOQLQVlPWOLFKHQVR]LDOHQ *HVWDOWXQJHQXQHQWEHKUOLFKLVW'DVVLQ(KHXQG)DPLOLH :LUWVFKDIW 6WDDWXQG3ROLWLN XQG.LUFKH &KDQFHQGHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJDQHU NDQQWHUPDHQIUHLHUJULIIHQZHUGHQN|QQHQGDULQPDQLIHVWLHUWVLFKIU.RFKGLH :LUNOLFKNHLWGHV5HFKWV±PLWLKULVWGHVKDOEQXQGHU$QIDQJ]XPDFKHQ 5HFKW =ZLVFKHQ)RUPDOLWlWXQG,QKDOWOLFKNHLW 0HQVFKHQZUGH )UHLKHLWXPLKUHUVHOEVWZLOOHQ 'LH0HQVFKHQZUGHLVWIU.RFKÄGDV3ULQ]LSGDV)XQGDPHQWDOHDOOHQ5HFKWV³ VLHLVWÄGDV0HQVFKHQUHFKW³DQGHPVLFKGHU5HFKWVRGHU8QUHFKWVFKDUDNWHU VR]LDOHU9HUKlOWQLVVHEHUKDXSWHQWVFKHLGHW:DVDEHULVWPLWGLHVHP%HJULII LQVHLQHQ$XJHQJHVDJW"Ä>'@LH:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQ³VRGHILQLHUWHV.RFKLQ DOOHU.U]HÄLVWVHLQH)UHLKHLW³$XVGUFNOLFKVFKOLHWHUVLFKGDPLW,PPDQXHO .DQWV%HJULIIVEHVWLPPXQJDQ]XGHUHUSRLQWLHUWEHPHUNWLKUVHLÄGHU6DFKH QDFKLQGHU*HVFKLFKWHELVKHXWHQLFKWVKLQ]XJHIJW>ZRUGHQ@±XQG>«@DXFK QLFKWVKLQ]X]XIJHQ³ 8QEHGLQJWH:UGHHLJQHWGHP0HQVFKHQDXV.DQWV6LFKWDXIJUXQGVHLQHU)l KLJNHLW]XVLWWOLFKHU$XWRQRPLHGLHLKQÄEHUDOOHQ3UHLV³GKEHUDOOHVR]LD OHQ %HZHUWXQJVPDVWlEH SULQ]LSLHOO ÄHUKDEHQ³ VHLQ OlVVW $OV PLW PRUDOL
(EG .2&+ D $D2 .2&+D .2&+T .2&+P (EG .2&+ D .$17 D>%$@9JOJUXQGOHJHQG]X.DQWV0HQVFKHQZUGHEHJULII 7,('( 0$11±
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
VFKHP (QWVFKHLGXQJVYHUP|JHQ EHJDEWHV 9HUQXQIWZHVHQ LVW HU QLH LQ *lQ]H DQGHUZHLWLJ]XYHU]ZHFNHQGHUÄ=ZHFNDQVLFKVHOEVW³ZHLOQXUZLUNOLFK]XLKP JHK|UWZRULQHUDXVHLJHQHQ*UQGHQ±GXUFKHLQHQ$NWGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ± ÄHLQVWLPPHQ³NDQQ'DVVGHU0HQVFKGDEHLQLFKWZLOONUOLFKDJLHUWGDIU VRUJW GLH LKP LQQHZRKQHQGH 3UILQVWDQ] GHV *HZLVVHQV YRUGHP HU VLFK LP %OLFNDXIGLHVLWWOLFKDOOJHPHLQH=XVWLPPXQJVIlKLJNHLWVHLQHV+DQGHOQVXQZHL JHUOLFK]XYHUDQWZRUWHQKDWÄ)U.DQW³VRQRWLHUW.RFKÄNRQ]HQWULHUWVLFKLQ JHZLVVHU:HLVHLPDXWRQRPHQIUHLHQXQGVHOEVWEHZXWHQ*HZLVVHQGLHÃ:UGHµ GHV0HQVFKHQ³ $XFKHUVHOEVWVFKUHLEWGHPIRUXPLQWHUQXPZLHVFKRQDQJH GHXWHWGLHVEH]JOLFKHLQH]HQWUDOH5ROOH]X'DVIUGLHEHVRQGHUH'LJQLWlWGHV 0HQVFKHQDXVVFKODJJHEHQGH)UHLKHLWVYHUP|JHQHUVFKOLHWVLFKGHPQDFKDOOHU HUVWLQGHU(UIDKUXQJGHV*HZLVVHQVGDVGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWGHVHLJHQHQ6HOEVW VHLQVJHJHQEHUDOOHQlXHUHQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHQ]X%HZXVVWVHLQEULQJW .RFKNQSIWGLH*HZLVVHQVHUIDKUXQJHWZDDQ6LWXDWLRQHQLQGHQHQHV]XP .RQIOLNW]ZLVFKHQGHQhEHU]HXJXQJHQGHV(LQ]HOQHQXQGGHQDQLKQKHUDQJH WUDJHQHQ9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQNRPPW'LHLP*HZLVVHQHLQVHW]HQGH5HIOH[L RQEHUGDVZDVMHW]WÄJXWXQGULFKWLJ³ZlUHÄEULQJWHLQHQ0HQVFKHQLQ'LVWDQ] ]XGHQVLFKDXIGUlQJHQGHQ$QIRUGHUXQJHQVRGDHULKQHQQLFKWDXVJHOLHIHUW LVW³ (U NDQQ $EVWDQG QHKPHQ YRP LKQ EHVWLPPHQGHQ +DQGOXQJVNRQWH[W LQGHPHUVLFK]XVLFKVHOEVWYHUKlOWXQGYROO]LHKWGDULQMHQHXQEHGLQJWH)UHLKHLW DXIGLHGHU:UGHEHJULIIUHNXUULHUW0LW.RFKV:RUWHQJHVDJW Ä,QGLHVHP6LQQH HLQÃ*HZLVVHQ]XKDEHQµHLQ6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVLQ8QEHGLQJWKHLW]XVHLQGDULQ JHUDGHKDWGHU(LQ]HOQHVHLQH:UGH³$XFKQRFKZRHUJHJHQEHU$QGHUHQ VFKXOGLJZLUGXQGGHQNEDUVWDUNGXUFKVHLQHQVR]LDOHQ+DQGOXQJVNRQWH[WEH VWLPPWLVWEOHLEWLKPVRHLQ0RPHQWYRQ)UHLKHLWHUKDOWHQ1LHPDQGQlPOLFK NDQQGXUFK6FKXOGXUWHLOHXQGHQWVSUHFKHQGH6WUDIPDQDKPHQGLH(LQVLFKWHLQHV 7lWHUVLQGLH9HUZHUIOLFKNHLWVHLQHU7DWHQHU]ZLQJHQ6LHEOHLEWÄHLQ$NWVHLQHU )UHLKHLW GHQQGLHVH(LQVLFKWLVWQXUDOVIUHLHU9ROO]XJ³DOVÄ6HOEVW]XUHFKQXQJ GHV7lWHUV³GHUVHLQ9HUJHKHQLP*HZLVVHQDOVÄ:LGHUVSUXFK>«@]XGHP ZRYRQ>«@>HU@VHOEVWDOVGDV5HFKWHXQG5LFKWLJHEHU]HXJWLVW³DQVHKHQN|Q QHQPXVV(UVWZHQQHUVLFKVHLQH6FKXOGVHOEVWDQ]XHLJQHQYHUPDJKDWHUVLH
.$17 D>%$@ 9JODD2 ±>%$±@9JO]XP%HJULIIGHV6HOEVW]ZHFNVEHL.DQW *(5 +$5'7 ± 9JO]X.DQWVLQVEHVRQGHUHLQGHU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQHQWIDOWHWHP*HZLVVHQVEHJULII %$57+E± .2&+F 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XP*HZLVVHQVEHJULIIEHL.RFKLQVJHVDPW .2&+ FII9JO]XU9HUNQSIXQJYRQ*HZLVVHQVXQG$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLN '(56D II .2&+F .2&+D .2&+I YJO.2&+T II
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DOVRDXFKHLQJHVHKHQ'DULQPHOGHWVLFKGLHYRQ.DQWQDPKDIWJHPDFKWH6HOEVW ]ZHFNKDIWLJNHLWGHV6XEMHNWVÄGDVQXULVWLQGHPHVVLFKVHOEVWYROO]LHKWRGHU YROO]LHKHQNDQQ³±HLQH$NWLYLWlWGHUVLFKDOOHV]XXQWHUZHUIHQKDWGDV]XU %HVWLPPWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWHVZHUGHQZLOO:RGHU6FKXOGLJJHZRUGHQHVHLQ9HU JHKHQDOVVROFKHVDQ]XHLJQHQLQGHU/DJHLVWZLUGLKP]XJOHLFKGHXWOLFKGDVV ÄVHLQH )UHLKHLW QLFKW LQ VHLQHQ 7DWHQ DXFK QLFKW LQ VHLQHU 8QUHFKWVWDW DXI JHKW³ $QNOlQJHDQGLHUHIRUPDWRULVFKH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYRQ3HUVRQXQG:HUNVLQG KLHUNDXP]XEHUK|UHQ6RZLUGGXUFKGDV7KHPDGHV*HZLVVHQVHLQHGHXWOLFKH 7UDGLWLRQVOLQLHPDUNLHUWGLHVLFKYRQGHU7KHRORJLH/XWKHUVEHU.DQWV(WKLNELV KLQHLQLQ'HEDWWHQGHV-DKUKXQGHUWV]LHKHQOlVVW)U.RFKOLHJWGHP HQWVSUHFKHQGHLQHUGHUJU|WHQXQGZLUNXQJVYROOVWHQ9HUGLHQVWHGHV:LWWHQEHU JHU5HIRUPDWRUVGDULQÄGLH'LPHQVLRQZHOWXQDEKlQJLJHU*HZLVVHQKDIWLJNHLW HUVFKORVVHQ³]XKDEHQ:HLOGHU0HQVFKLQVHLQHP,QQHUHQXQPLWWHOEDU]X *RWWLVWNDQQLKQVRQDFKÄ>N@HLQH+DQGOXQJ NHLQÃ:HUNµ XQGNHLQH*HJHEHQ KHLW±QLFKWVHQGOLFK%HVWLPPWHV±>«@LQVHLQHU6HOEVWHLQVFKlW]XQJXQGLQGHU Ã5HFKWIHUWLJXQJµVHLQHV/HEHQVOHW]WOLFKGHILQLHUHQ³'LHGHUDUWDN]HQWXLHUWH FKULVWOLFKH)UHLKHLWNRPPWEHL/XWKHUDEHUQLFKWDOVHLQJOHLFKVDPQDWUOLFKHV 9HUP|JHQGHV0HQVFKHQ]XVWHKHQVRQGHUQVLHZLUGDXIGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ$NWGHU XQYHUGLHQWHQ*HUHFKWVSUHFKXQJGHV6QGHUV]XUFNJHIKUW%LVKHXWHZLUGGLH VHU*HGDQNHJHUQPLWHLQHPEHUGLH%H]JHGHV*ODXEHQVZHLWKLQDXVJHKHQGHQ %HJUQGXQJVDQVSUXFKYHUNQSIWZLHIROJHQGH:RUWHDXVGHU)HGHU:ROIJDQJ +XEHUVH[HPSODULVFK]HLJHQ Ä'LH)UHLKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQLVWHLQHLKPYRQ*RWW JHJHEHQHXQGJHVFKHQNWH)UHLKHLW³XQGHEHQGLHVHÄJHVFKHQNWH)UHLKHLW³QLFKW DEHU ÄGLH )UHLKHLW GLH PDQ GXUFK HLJHQH /HLVWXQJ HUULQJW³ VHL HV ÄGLH DOOHU 0HQVFKHQZUGH ]XJUXQGH OLHJW³ :UGH XQG )UHLKHLW GHV 0HQVFKHQ VLQG GHPQDFKUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFK]XEHJUQGHQ.RFKVWLPPW+XEHUVLQGHQ VHOEHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJJHK|UHQGHU)RUPXOLHUXQJ]XÄGLH$XVVDJHYRQGHUXQDQ WDVWEDUHQ:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQ³KHEHGDUDXIDEÄGDGHP0HQVFKHQDOV3HUVRQ HLQH(LJHQVWlQGLJNHLWJHJHQEHUDOOHQ:HOWEH]JHQLQGLHHUYHUIORFKWHQLVW ]XNRPPW³-HGRFKWULIIWGHUIXQGLHUHQGHUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKH%HJUQ GXQJVJDQJDXIVHLQHQHUNOlUWHQ:LGHUVSUXFK±HLQ:LGHUVSUXFKGHUVLFKDXFK JXWDXI(EHUKDUG-QJHOVUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKH(LQJHPHLQGXQJGHV0HQ VFKHQZUGHJHGDQNHQVEH]LHKHQOLHH
.2&+ .2&+T 9JOLQVJHVDPW %$57+E .2&+ E9JO'(56 FI F OII .2&+ E +8%(5 +8%(57g'7 9JOREHQ$
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
'LHLP*HZLVVHQVLFKYROO]LHKHQGH)UHLKHLWXQEHGLQJWHQ 6HOEVWVHLQV ZLUG .RFK]XIROJHLQLKUHUXQEHGLQJWHQ(LJHQDUWXQWHUODXIHQZHQQVLHYRQZHOFKHU *U|HDXFKLPPHUDEKlQJLJDQJHVHKHQZLUG6LHXQGGLHDQVLHJHNQSIWH:U GHEHVWHKWZLOOPDQNHLQHUFRQWUDGLFWLRLQDGLHFWRDXIVLW]HQDOVRXQDEKlQJLJ ÄYRQLUJHQGHLQHU,QVWDQ]³QLFKWQXU±ZLHDXFKGLHEHQDQQWHQ*HJHQSRVLWLRQHQ VDJHQZUGHQ±ÄYRQGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWRGHUYRQHLQHP6WDDW³VRQGHUQDXFKÄYRQ HLQHPDOV,QVWDQ]YRUJHVWHOOWHQÃ*RWWµ³'DVVGHU0HQVFKÄLQNHLQHQlXHUHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQXQG7DWHQDXIJHKW³ZHLOHUVLFKLP9HUKlOWQLV]XVLFKVHOEVWYRQ DOOHQ LKQ IHVWOHJHQGHQ %HVWLPPWKHLWHQ GLVWDQ]LHUHQ XQG PLW LKQHQ XPJHKHQ NDQQILQGHWGHPQDFKLP0RWLYHLQHULKUHQ*HJHQVWDQGDOOHUHUVWKHUYRUEULQ JHQGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJNHLQHDQJHPHVVHQHWKHRORJLVFKH'HXWXQJ6HLQH LQGLHVHP9ROO]XJ]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPHQGHXQYHUOLHUEDUH:UGHGHU]XIROJH HUÄVHOEVWHWZDV(LJHQHVLVW HLQÃ,FKµHLQHLQPDOLJEHVRQGHUHVXQGDOVRLQGLYL GXHOOHV6XEMHNW³ZLUGNRQWHUNDULHUWZRVLHQXUDOVHWZDVYRQDXHQ9HUOLHKH QHVHUVFKHLQW'LHVH*HJHQOlXILJNHLW]HLJWVLFKIU.RFKGDULQGDVVGHPJ|WWOL FKHQ=XVSUXFKYRQ)UHLKHLW±JHPlGHVGLDOHNWLVFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHVYRQ*HVHW] XQG(YDQJHOLXP±]XJOHLFKHLQJHERWVPlLJHU$QVSUXFKLQQHZRKQW 'HUYRU *RWW*HUHFKWHZLUG]XHLQHPDQGHU/LHEH]XP1lFKVWHQRULHQWLHUWHQ/HEHQV ZDQGHOEHIUHLWZDVVHLQHUJHVFK|SIOLFKHQDEHUGXUFKVQGLJH6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLW DXFK ZHLWHUKLQ GXUFKEURFKHQHQ %HVWLPPXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQ VROO ,QVJHVDPW VFKHLQWGDPLWGLH:UGHHWZDVGHP0HQVFKHQOHW]WOLFK)UHPGHV]XVHLQZHLOVLH ÄLKPYRQ*RWWQXU]XJHVSURFKHQ]XHUNDQQWXQGYHUKHLHQLVW>«@DOV=XVSUXFK XQG $QVSUXFK EHU LKP VWHKW LKP DEHU VLFK HQW]LHKW XQG VR ÃXQYHUIJEDUµ EOHLEW³.RFKZLGHUVSULFKWGLHVHU6LFKWZHLVHLQGHUHUHLQHQ7UHQGGHUSURWHV WDQWLVFKHQ 7KHRORJLH GHV -DKUKXQGHUWV HQWGHFNW GXUFK HLQH .ULWLN LKUHU DQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ *UXQGODJH GHU DXJXVWLQLVFKOXWKHULVFKHQ (UEVQGHQOHKUH GHU]XIROJHVLFKGLHXUVSUQJOLFKHhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJYRQ*RWWXQG0HQVFKGXUFK GHQ)DOO$GDPVLQVWRWDOH*HJHQWHLOYHUNHKUWKDW6RJHVHKHQYHUELHWHWHVVLFK QlPOLFKJHUDGH]XGHP(LQ]HOQHQHLQH:UGH]X]XHUNHQQHQGLHLKPÄDQVLFK MHQVHLWVYRQJXW XQGE|VH³]XNRPPW:LHREHQGDUJHOHJWHUVFKHLQW.RFK MHGRFKGLHGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH/HKUHYRPJRWWJHPlHQ8UVWDQGGHV0HQVFKHQLQ LKUHU$N]HQWVHW]XQJEHZDKUHQVZHUW GLHSULPlUHhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ GHVJRWW HEHQELOGOLFKHQ0HQVFKHQPLW*RWWE]ZGHUSULRULWlUH&KDUDNWHUGHV*XWHQLP 0HQVFKHQGHPJHJHQEHUGLH6QGHE]ZGDV%|VHQXUHWZDV=ZHLWUDQJLJHV GDUVWHOOW:HLOVLFKGHU(LQ]HOQHGLHVHUVHLQHUJUXQGVlW]OLFKHQ$PELYDOHQ]DOV JHZLVVHQKDIWHVVLFK]XVLFKVHOEVWYHUKDOWHQGHV:HVHQEHZXVVWVHLQNDQQLVWHU
.2&+P (EG .2&+ E .2&+ E YJO'(56 D 9JO.2&+P9JOREHQ$ 9JO.2&+ E±± DI KII
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DXIVLHQLFKWVFKOHFKWKLQIHVWJHOHJW,QVHLQHPÄ6LFK'LVWDQ]LHUHQ.|QQHQLVWHU KLQDXVEHUGDV(QGOLFKH LVWHUDOVHQGOLFKHV:HVHQXQHQGOLFKXQGEHVLW]WGDULQ HLQHHLJHQH:UGHLVWHU*RWWJOHLFK³0LWGLHVHP)UHLKHLWVYHUP|JHQYHUELQ GHWVLFKGLH)lKLJNHLW]XUVLWWOLFKHQ$XWRQRPLH]XU:DKOYRQJXWRGHUE|VHRGHU WKHRORJLVFKJHVSURFKHQ GHU0HQVFKLVW ÄGDV:HVHQGDV>«@IlKLJLVW*RWW JOHLFKRGHU*RWWZLGULJXQGJRWWORV]XVHLQ³ (UPXVVGHVKDOE±.RFKV)RU PHOZXUGHEHUHLWV]LWLHUW±ÄDOVVHOEVWHWZDV*|WWOLFKHV8QEHGLQJWHV³EHJULIIHQ ZHUGHQZHQQJOHLFKHUÄGDV*|WWOLFKVHLQDOVVHLQ6HLQ.|QQHQ]XPWRWDO:LGHU J|WWOLFKHQYHUNHKUHQNDQQ³1XUGDQQZLUGLKPDXFKÄXQEHGLQJWHXQGXQDQ WDVWEDUH:UGH]XHUNDQQW³ 'LH8QDEGLQJEDUNHLWUHFKWOLFKJHVLFKHUWHU$QHUNHQQXQJ *HQDXLQGLHVHPKXPDQHQ3RWHQ]LDO]XVLWWOLFKHU$XWRQRPLHGDVHULP6\PERO GHU*RWWHEHQELOGOLFKNHLWSDVVHQG]XP$XVGUXFNJHEUDFKWILQGHWVLHKW.RFK DOVRGLH:UGHGHV0HQVFKHQEHJUQGHW-HGRFKVFKlUIWHUHLQGDVVGDPLWÄVHLQH SULQ]LSLHOOH)UHLKHLWVHLQLP%OLFNDXIMHGHJHVFKLFKWOLFKH5HDOLWlWXQEHGLQJWHV )UHLVHLQN|QQHQ³DQJHVSURFKHQLVW±HLQH'LPHQVLRQVHLQHV6HOEVWVHLQVDOVR GLHQLFKWLQHPSLULVFKZDKUQHKPEDUHU3UD[LVDXIJHKW6LHNRPPWDOOHQ6XEMHN WHQXQDEKlQJLJGDYRQ]XZLHH[SOL]LWVLHYROO]RJHQZLUGREJOHLFKIU.RFK JLOW Ä:HUVHLQHUEHZXWLVWXQGGDVLVWLQLUJHQGHLQHU:HLVHMHGHU0HQVFKGHU LVWÃHWZDVµHLQ:HVHQIUVLFK GHULVWHLQXQYHUZHFKVHOEDUHUÃ'LHVHUµ³$XI XQYHUWUHWEDUH:HLVHQlPOLFKEH]LHKWVLFKGHU(LQ]HOQHGDEHLDXIVLFKVHOEVWXQG VHW]WVLFKGDPLWVHOEVWDOV,QGLYLGXXP(UQLPPWVLFKJHZLVVHUPDHQVHOEVW GDV5HFKWGD]XVHLQXQGVRHUVFKHLQWHUIU$QGHUH ÄHULVW>«@HLQIDFKGD³XQG LVWGLHVGRFKÄUHDOLWHUQXUZHQQGLH$QGHUHQLKQLQVHLQHP6HOEVWVHLQLQVHLQHP 'DVHLQOHEHQODVVHQ³'DPLWNRPPWGLHHLQJDQJVDQJHGHXWHWH6SDQQXQJ]ZL VFKHQ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWXQG6R]LDOLWlWLQV6SLHO1LHPDQGJHKWGHPQDFKLQGHQJH VHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHQDXILQGHQHQHUVLFKYRUILQGHWZHLOHLQMHGHU IlKLJLVWVLFKDXIXQEHGLQJWHIUHLH:HLVH]XVLFKVHOEVWXQGGDPLWDXFK]XGHQ LKQEHVWLPPHQGHQ.RQWH[WHQ]XYHUKDOWHQ'RFKLVWGLHSUDNWLVFKH5HDOLVLHUXQJ GLHVHV9HUP|JHQVGDYRQDEKlQJLJGDVVGLHGHQ(LQ]HOQHQEHVWLPPHQGHQ6R]L DOYHUKlOWQLVVHGHPJHJHQEHURIIHQVLQG'DIUPVVHQVLHVR.RFKGLHÄ)RUP GHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³JHQDXHU ÄGHUDQHUNHQQHQGHQ(LQUlXPXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWRGHU
.2&+P $D2 (EG (EG .2&+ DI .2&+ E .2&+ E .2&+ (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
ZDVGDVJOHLFKHVDJWYRQ0HQVFKHQZUGH³KDEHQ=ZDUEHUXKWZLHHUPLW 1DFKGUXFNHLQVFKlUIWÄ)UHLKHLW>«@QLFKWDXI$QHUNHQQXQJ³GLHLPPHUQXU HLQH Ä%HVWlWLJXQJ XQG (LQVHW]XQJ GHVVHQ >LVW@ ZDV VLH DQHUNHQQW³ -HGHU VHOEVWEHVWLPPWHQbXHUXQJDEHUÄOLHJW>«@HLQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV>«@ ]XJUXQGH³ZHLOVLHRKQHIUHPGH=XJHVWlQGQLVVHQLFKWJHWlWLJWZHUGHQN|QQWH 6LHPVVWHVLFKVRQVWJHZDOWVDPJHJHQGLHDOV+LQGHUQLVHUVFKHLQHQGHQ$QVSU FKHGHV$QGHUHQGXUFKVHW]HQZDVHQWZHGHULQHLQHQ]ZDQJKDIWHQ'DXHUNRQIOLNW EHUJHKHQRGHUOHW]WHQ(QGHV]XHLQHPHLQVHLWLJHQ)UHLKHLWVYHU]LFKWIKUHQZU GH+HJHOV*HGDQNHQHLQHVÄ.DPSI>V@XP$QHUNHQQXQJ³GHXWHW.RFKLQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ VR GDVV GLHVHU GHQ =XVWDQG GHU 5HFKWORVLJNHLW EH VFKUHLEW ZlKUHQG DOOHUHUVW GLH :LUNOLFKNHLW GHV 5HFKWV VR]LDOH 9HUKlOWQLVVH VWLIWHWLQGHQHQ)UHLKHLWJHOHEWZHUGHQNDQQÄ1XUZHQQGLH$QHUNHQQXQJDOV 5HFKW JDUDQWLHUW LVW³ YHUPDJ GHPQDFK GHU (LQH ÄVHLQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQ VR ZDKU>]X@QHKPHQGDVVHUGHQ$QGHUHQDOVHLQHQLKQ$QHUNHQQHQGHQDQHUNHQQW NDQQGLH$QHUNHQQXQJSUDNWL]LHUWH:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLW RGHUUH]LSURNH,QWHUVXE MHNWLYLWlW VHLQ³ 'LHVHV9HUKlOWQLVLVWIU.RFKNHLQHVIDOOVGHUDUWXP]XNHKUHQGDVVGDV5HFKW ]XP3URGXNWVR]LDOHU+DQGOXQJVYROO]JHHUNOlUWZLUG (VEHUXKWQLFKWÄDXIGHU $QHUNHQQXQJMHGHVGXUFKGHQ$QGHUHQDOVRDXIHLQ>HP@$QHUNHQQHQDOV$QHU NDQQWVHLQ±RGHUVFKOLFKWDXI5H]LSUR]LWlW³(VKDWYLHOPHKUÄVHLQHQHLJHQHQ LKPLPPDQHQWHQ*UXQGLQGHUQLFKWKLQWHUJHKEDUHQ)UHLKHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQ³ VRGDVVGLH)UDJH]XEHDQWZRUWHQLVWÄZLH>«@GLH)UHLKHLWGHVHLQ]HOQHQ]X GHQNHQ>LVW@VRGDYRQLKUKHUGLH6R]LDOLWlWXQGGLH6SKlUH|IIHQWOLFKHU$OO JHPHLQKHLWEHJUHLIOLFKZLUG³.RFKEHGLHQWVLFKGDIUHLQHVKHJHOVFKHQ*H GDQNHQV Ä>'@DV5HFKW³VRVFKUHLEW.RFKÄJUQGHWLPDOOJHPHLQHQ:LOOHQGHV(LQ]HO QHQ³ ± HLQH )RUPXOLHUXQJ GLH DXVGUFNOLFK DXI +HJHOV 5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLH UHNXUULHUW'RUWQlPOLFKZLUGÄGLH5HFKWVIlKLJNHLW>EHUKDXSW@³LQGHUÄ3HUV|Q OLFKNHLW³GHV6XEMHNWVYHUDQNHUW'HU]XIROJHELQÄLFKDOV'LHVHUYROONRPPHQ QDFKDOOHQ6HLWHQ>«@EHVWLPPWHXQGHQGOLFKHGRFKVFKOHFKWKLQUHLQH%H]LH KXQJDXIPLFK³XQGZHLPLFKVRÄLQGHU(QGOLFKNHLW>«@DOVGDV8QHQG OLFKH
.2&+P .2&+D (EG 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ .2&+ .2&+DI .2&+D9JO]XGLHVHP0RWLYEHL+HJHOGLH$XVIKUXQJHQXQWHQ% $D2 .2&+ (EG .2&+ F+HUYRUKG9HUI .2&+D 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ %$5786&+$7 ± +(*(/>@
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$OO J H PH L QH XQG)U HLH ³3HUVRQ]XVHLQDEHUEHGHXWHWIU+HJHOVLFKLP %OLFNDXIGHQXQHQGOLFKDOOJHPHLQHQ&KDUDNWHUGHVXQPLWWHOEDUHQ6HOEVWYHUKlOW QLVVHVDXFKH[SOL]LWÄ]XP*HJHQVWDQGHXQG=ZHFNH³ ]XKDEHQ'DUDXI]LHOW GDVYRQLKPIRUPXOLHUWHÄ5HFKWVJHERW> «@ VH LHL QH3 HU VR QX QG UH VS H N WLHU H G L H D QG HU H Q DO V 3 H U VR QH Q³:HUVLFKQXQVHOEVWDOV3HUVRQZLOO QHJLHUWÄDOOHNRQNUHWH%HVFKUlQNWKHLWXQG*OWLJNHLW³]XJXQVWHQVHLQHUHEHQ GLHVHWUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHQDOOJHPHLQHQ)UHLKHLWGLHHUDQGHUHQQXUYRUHQWKDOWHQ NDQQZHQQHUSDUWLNXODUH%HVWLPPXQJHQDQLKUH6WHOOHVHW]WÄ>1@XULP:ROOHQ VROFKHU$OOJHPHLQKHLW³LQGHUGHU(LQ]HOQHÄPLWVLFKXQGGHQDQGHUHQLGHQWLVFK LVW³NDQQHUÄVHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOVIUHLHV:HVHQJHZLVHLQXQGNDQQLKP HEHQGLHVH$QHUNHQQXQJUHDOLWHUGXUFKGHQ:LOOHQGHVDQGHUHQ]XWHLOZHUGHQ³ 'DPLWDEHUÄEHJUQGHWGLHVHV$OOJHPHLQHGLH.RPPXQLNDWLRQXQWHUGHQ0HQ VFKHQXQGGLHJHJHQVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ³±QLFKWDEHUEHJUQGHQ/HW]WHUHGDV $OOJHPHLQH'LHVHVLVWYLHOPHKUYRUDXV]XVHW]HQDOVHLQHWUDQVVXEMHNWLYH*U| HLQ%H]XJDXIGLHDOOHZHQQVLHVLFKUHFKWYHUVWHKHQLPPHUVFKRQPLWHLQDQ GHUYHUEXQGHQVLQGZDVDEHUHUVW]XP=LHONRPPWZHQQVLHÄGDVSDUWLNXODU (LJHQHGDUHLQ]XYHUZDQGHOQ³YHUP|JHQHVDOVRVHOEVWZROOHQ 'HUULFKWLJH8PJDQJPLWGHP5HFKW 'DV5HFKWVRKlOW.RFKIHVWÄLVWGLHUHDOH(UP|JOLFKXQJYRQ)UHLKHLW³LQGHP HVDOVÄVWDDWOLFKHJHVHW]WHVÃSRVLWLYHVµ5HFKWµYHUELQGOLFKPDFKWGDVVDOOHLQ LKUHU%HVWLPPWKHLWDOVDOOJHPHLQDQJHVHKHQZHUGHQ³:RHVNHLQHQ%HVWDQG KDWÄKHUUVFKWGHU>«@.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJGKGHU.DPSIXP+HUUVFKDIW DXI/HEHQXQG7RG³ZHLONHLQHUVLFKGHV:RKOZROOHQVGHU$QGHUHQJHZLVVVHLQ NDQQ:HLOGDV5HFKWGHPJHJHQEHUHLQHJHPHLQVFKDIWVNRPSDWLEOH)UHLKHLWV SUD[LVHUP|JOLFKWVWLPPW.RFKGHP'LNWXP.DQWV]XZRQDFKHVDOVÄGDV+HL OLJVWH³DQJHVHKHQZHUGHQNDQQÄZDV*RWWDXI(UGHQKDW³$XFKYHUPDJHULP ÄPRGHUQHQDXI5HFKWXQG*HVHW]EHUXKHQGHQ6WDDW5HDOLVDWLRQHQGHVÃ5HLFKHV *RWWHVµ³DOVRÄ5HDOLVDWLRQHQGHVVHQZDV*RWWLQVHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWPLWGHQ 0HQVFKHQZLOO³ ]XHQWGHFNHQ0LWGLHVHP+RKHOLHGDXIGDV5HFKWXQGVHLQH KLVWRULVFKJHZDFKVHQHQLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ$XVJHVWDOWXQJHQYHUELQGHWVLFKGHUNULWL
+(*(/>@ $D2>@ $D2>@ $D2>@ .2&+ F (EG (EG .2&+ .2&+D .$17 .2&+ E $D2
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
VFKH$EZHLVDQGHUHUWKHRORJLVFKHU=XJULIIVZHLVHQ6RPRQLHUW.RFKHLQHYRU DOOHPLPOXWKHULVFKJHSUlJWHQ3URWHVWDQWLVPXVJUDVVLHUHQGHÄ5HFKWVEOLQGKHLW³ 6LHVFKOlJWVLFKGDULQQLHGHUGDVVGLHUHFKWOLFKH2UGQXQJGHV=XVDPPHQOHEHQV DXIHLQHREULJNHLWOLFKYHUDQWZRUWHWHÄÃ1RWVWDQGVPDQDKPHµDQJHVLFKWVGHV8Q KHLOVLQGHU:HOW³UHGX]LHUWXQGHLQVHLWLJHU:HLVHPLWGHP&KDUDNWHUDXWRULWlUHU =ZDQJVJHZDOWDVVR]LLHUWZLUG*HJHQEHUGLHVHP$N]HQWDXIQHJDWLYH)XQN WLRQHQZLH'URKXQJXQG6WUDIHEHWRQW.RFKHLQHQIUHLKHLWVHUP|JOLFKHQGHQ6LQQ GHV5HFKWVIUGHQHULQGHUEHVDJWHQ7UDGLWLRQVOLQLHDEHUHUVWH$QVlW]HILQGHW 'DVV/XWKHUGLH'LPHQVLRQGHVZHOWXQDEKlQJLJHQ*HZLVVHQVHUVFKORVVHQXQG GHU (PDQ]LSDWLRQ SROLWLVFKHU 0DFKW YRQ NOHULNDOHU %HYRUPXQGXQJ GHQ :HJ EHUHLWHWKDWZHL.RFKDOV]XNXQIWVWUlFKWLJH1HXHUXQJHQDXIGHP:HJ]XP PRGHUQHQ5HFKWVVWDDW]XZUGLJHQ'RFKEOHLEWEHLGHVLQ+DOEKHLWEHJULIIHQ LQVRIHUQ]XJOHLFKGLH2EULJNHLW]XU6DFKZDOWHULQGHUYHUDUHOLJLRHUKREHQZLUG XQGVRPLW=XJULIIDXIHLQH$QJHOHJHQKHLWLQQHUVWHUhEHU]HXJXQJHUKlOW(UVWGHU UHOLJL|VZHOWDQVFKDXOLFKQHXWUDOH5HFKWVVWDDWOlVVWGLH*HZLVVHQVXQG*ODX EHQVIUHLKHLWLP*UXQGUHFKWGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJZLUNOLFK]X|IIHQWOLFKHU*HO WXQJJHODQJHQ.RFKIRUGHUWGHVKDOEXQHUPGOLFKÄGDVSURWHVWDQWLVFKH&KULVWHQ WXP GLH HYDQJHOLVFKH .LUFKH XQG 7KHRORJLH³ VROOWHQ GLHVHQ ÄQLFKW HWZD QXU KLQQHKPHQ VRQGHUQ VHOEVW ZROOHQ³ 'DEHL OLHJW VHLQ $XJHQPHUN ZHQLJHU GDUDXIGDVVFKULVWOLFKHV*HGDQNHQJXW(LQJDQJLQGLH)RUPXOLHUXQJHQGHV5HFKWV JHIXQGHQKDWDOVYLHOPHKUDXIIROJHQGHU(LQVLFKW Ä'HU*ODXEHLVWQXUZHQQHU IUHL XQG QLFKW HU]ZXQJHQ LVW³ 'XUFK GDV GH]LGLHUW IRUPDOH 6HOEVWEHVWLP PXQJVUHFKWGHU3HUVRQXQGGHQGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQGHQVWDDWOLFKHQ9HU]LFKWGDU DXIGHQ*HEUDXFKGLHVHV5HFKWVLQKDOWOLFK]XQRUPLHUHQZLUGVRQDFKDXFKGLH +HUDXVELOGXQJHLQHUVHOEVWYHUDQWZRUWHWHQFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VHQ/HEHQVKDOWXQJ HUP|JOLFKW$QGHUVJHVDJW 'HU*ODXEHOHEWYRQVR]LDOHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQGLH HUQLFKWJDUDQWLHUHQNDQQZHLOVLHVRQVWVHLQHPIUHLHQ6LFK(LQVWHOOHQ]XZLGHU ODXIHQZUGHQ.ULWLVFKJUHQ]WVLFK.RFKGHPJHPlYRQ3RVLWLRQHQDEGLHVLFK GDVEHUKPWH%|FNHQI|UGH'LNWXP]X(LJHQPDFKHQXPGLH5HOLJLRQDOV%H VFKDIIHULQHLQHVIUGHQ5HFKWVVWDDWNRQVWLWXWLYHQ:HUWHJHUVWHV]XU*HOWXQJ]X EULQJHQ'HUHQ+DXSWIHKOHUHQWGHFNWHULP)HVWKDOWHQDQGHUÄ$QVLFKWGDV
.2&+P (EG .2&+Q .2&+ 9JOGD]X .2&+±.RFKEH]LHKWVLFKKLHUNRQNUHWDXIGLHLQGHU+DELOLWD WLRQVVFKULIW:ROIJDQJ9|JHOHVDXIJHIKUWHQ3RVLWLRQHQ'LHVHXQWHUQLPPWLP$QVFKOXVVDQ GDVYRQVHLQHP'RNWRUYDWHU:ROIJDQJ+XEHULQLWLLHUWH3URJUDPPHLQHUgIIHQWOLFKHQ7KHROR JLHGHQÄ9HUVXFK>«@%|FNHQI|UGHV6DW]YRQGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQGHV6WDDWHVGLHGLHVHU VHOEVW QLFKW JDUDQWLHUHQ NDQQ DP %HLVSLHO GHV %HJULIIV 0HQVFKHQZUGH GXUFK]XIKUHQ³ ZRGXUFKÄGLH$EKlQJLJNHLWGHV5HFKWVYRQNXOWXUHOOHQDXFKUHOLJL|VHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQGLH VLFKNXOWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKXQGWKHRORJLVFKDQDO\VLHUHQODVVHQ³DXIJHGHFNWZHUGH'DPLWDEHU ZUGHQNHLQHFKULVWOLFKHQ([NOXVLYLWlWVDQVSUFKHJHVWHOOWVRQGHUQÄ>G@LH7KHRORJLH>«@UHLKW
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
5HFKWVHLLQVLFKVHOEVWEHJUQGXQJVGHIL]LWlUXQGEHGUIHGDUXPHLQHULKPlXH UHQ%HJUQGXQJ³ :LHDEHUVROOWHHLQDQJHPHVVHQHUNLUFKOLFKWKHRORJLVFKHU8PJDQJPLWGHP PRGHUQHQ5HFKWVVWDDWDXVVHKHQ".RFKV$QWZRUWQLPPW$XVJDQJEHLP|IIHQW OLFKDQHUNDQQWHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVUHFKWGHU3HUVRQGDVGHP*ODXEHQGHQLKP ]XNRPPHQGHQ)UHLUDXPOlVVW=ZLVFKHQGLHVHUDQHUNHQQHQGHLQJHUlXPWHQ &KDQFHXQGGHUHQ:DKUQHKPXQJDEHUEHVWHKWHEHQHLQH'LIIHUHQ]GLHDEVLFKWOL FKHUZHLVHVHLWHQVGHV5HFKWVQLFKWDXIJHKREHQZLUGZHLOHVVRQVWVHLQH)RUPDOL WlW YHUO|UH XQG LQKDOWOLFK EHVWLPPWH /HEHQVZHLVHQ YRUVFKUHLEHQ ZUGH ÄÃ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJµ³VREULQJW.RFKGLH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJDXIGHQ3XQNWÄLVW >«@]XQlFKVW>«@HLQIRUPDOHV5HFKW³]XJOHLFKDEHULVWHVÄDOVVROFKHV>«@IU GHQ(LQ]HOQHQVRJDUSULPlURGHUYRUUDQJLJHLQHOHEHQVODQJH$XIJDEH>«@ GLH $XIJDEHQlPOLFKVLFKLQVHLQHP/HEHQVHOEVW]XYHUVWHKHQXQGVHOEVW]XEH VWLPPHQ³:RUDQDQZHOFKHQ,QKDOWHQVLFKGLHVHUGDEHLRULHQWLHUWEOHLEWHLQH DXVUHFKWOLFKHU6LFKWRIIHQH)UDJH2EGHU(LQ]HOQH]XUÄ(LQVLFKWLQGLHNRPPX QLNDWLYH,PSOLNDWLRQGHV5HFKWV³NRPPWDOVRGHVVHQ$QVSUXFKDXIGLHZHFK VHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWIROJWLVW6DFKHVHLQHVDXWRQRPHQ*HZLV VHQV'DVVMHPDQGGDUDXVJDUGLH)ROJHUXQJ]LHKWLQÄVHOEVWJHZROOWH>U@9HUDQW ZRUWXQJ(LJHQLQLWLDWLYHLQGHUPHQVFKHQZUGLJHQ=XZHQGXQJ³ ]X]HLJHQ NDQQQLFKWYHUIJWZHUGHQÄ7KHRORJLHXQG.LUFKHDEHUN|QQWHQ>«@]XEHGHQ NHQJHEHQZDVGDV.HQQZRUWÃPHQVFKHQZUGLJµEHVDJWXQGHQWKlOW³ZRPLW VLHMHGRFKGHP(LQ]HOQHQDXFKQXUHLQH QLFKWGHNUHWLHUEDUH0|JOLFKNHLWGHV 6LFKVHOEVWYHUVWHKHQVHU|IIQHWHQ*HQDXGDUDXIDEHUVROOWHLQ.RFKV$XJHQNLUFK OLFKWKHRORJLVFKDEJH]LHOWZHUGHQ $OVRVDJHPDQDOV9HUWUHWHUDOV=HXJHµGHV&KULVWOLFKHQZDVQDFKHLJHQHUhEHU]HXJXQJJXW XQGUHFKWXQGZDVVFKOHFKWXQG]HUVW|UHULVFKXQGPHQVFKHQYHUDFKWHQGLVW>«@ZDVGLH9RU ]JHXQGGLH3UREOHPHHLQHUGDXHUKDIWHQ*HPHLQVDPNHLWLQGHU/LHEHZDVGLH9RU]JHXQG 3UREOHPHHLQHU(KHXQGZDVGLHHLQHUDQGHUHQ/HEHQVIRUPVLQG>«@8QGPDQVDJHHVYRU DOOHPLQ5HVSHNWYRUGHUIUHLHQ(LQVLFKWVIlKLJNHLWGHVGHU$QGHUHQ ZRKOZLVVHQGGDPDQGD
VLFKHLQLQGHQSOXUDOLVWLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVGLVNXUVLQGHQ'LDORJGHU5HOLJLRQHQXQG:HOWDQ VFKDXXQJHQ³ 9g*(/( ,P'XUFKJDQJGXUFKXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKVWH3RVLWLRQHQNRPPW 9|JHOHDXFKDXI7UDXJRWW.RFK]XVSUHFKHQGHPHUYRUZLUIWÄGDV5HFKWLQVJHVDPWDXIIRUPD OH$VSHNWH]XUHGX]LHUHQ³REJOHLFKHVÄQLFKWQXUGHU9HUZLUNOLFKXQJGHUJU|WP|JOLFKHQ )UHLKHLWGHVHLQ]HOQHQ³GLHQHVRQGHUQÄDXFKEHVWLPPWH.RQVHQVHGHU*HVHOOVFKDIW³UHSUlVHQ WLHUH DD2I .2&+ 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ .2&+QII $D2 $D2$QP (EG (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
QLFKWVYRU]XVFKUHLEHQKDWGDMDHLQHhEHUOHJXQJHLQ5DWVFKODJQXUHLQJHKWLQGLH6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJGHVGHU$QGHUHQZHQQHUXQGVLHGDVVHOEVWHLQVLHKW
:DVDXV.RFKV6LFKWÃGLH9RU]JHXQGGLH3UREOHPHHLQHUGDXHUKDIWHQ*HPHLQ VDPNHLWµLQGHQ/HEHQVIRUPHQYRQ)DPLOLHXQG(KHJHUDGHYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQG GHV6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVYRUEHKDOWVVLQGZLUGQXQ]XP7KHPDZHUGHQ )DPLOLHXQG(KH )DPLOLH =ZLVFKHQ(OWHUQXQG.LQGHUQ Ä(OWHUQXQG.LQGHU³VRVFKUHLEW(PDQXHO+LUVFKÄVLQGVLFKXQHQWULQQOLFKDOV GLH0HQVFKHQGDZHOFKHHLQDQGHU]XP6HJHQRGHU8QVHJHQZHUGHQPVVHQ³ .RFKJUHLIW+LUVFKV)RUPXOLHUXQJDXIXQGIJWLKUKLQ]XGDVVÄGDEHL>«@ZHGHU GDVHLQHQRFKGDVDQGHUHJDUDQWLHUW³LVW:DVKLQJHJHQIUDJORVIHVWVWHKW (OWHUQ JLEWHVQLFKWRKQH.LQGHUXQGDOOH.LQGHUKDEHQ(OWHUQ%HLGHU,GHQWLWlWKlQJWLQ GLHVHU+LQVLFKWDQGHU([LVWHQ]GHUMHZHLOVDQGHUHQ6HLWHXQGLVWVRYRQYRUQKH UHLQEHVWLPPWGXUFKGLH9HUEXQGHQKHLWLQHLQHPVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVÄ:HQQ (OWHUQVFKDIW>«@LKUHUVHLWVQXULVWGXUFKGHQ%H]XJ]XHLQHP.LQGRGHU]X.LQ GHUQ>«@GDQQLVWPLWGHU(OWHUQVFKDIWLPPHUDXFKGLHÃ)DPLOLHµJHJHEHQ³ 6LHILJXULHUWDOVGDV*HPHLQVDPHLQGHPDOOH%HWHLOLJWHQXQZHLJHUOLFKYHUEXQ GHQVLQGVHLHVGXUFKOHLEOLFKH$EVWDPPXQJRGHU6WLHIE]Z$GRSWLRQVYHUKlOW QLVVH0LWGHUIDPLOLlUHQ=XVDPPHQJHK|ULJNHLWVLHKW.RFKHLQHÄ9HUSIOLFKWXQJ ]XHLQHP9HUKDOWHQ³HLQKHUJHKHQ±Ä]XU(U]LHKXQJDOV(OWHUQSIOLFKW³DXIGHU HLQHQXQG]XULPPHUVHOEVWEHZXVVWHUHQ$QHLJQXQJGHUHOWHUOLFKHLQJHUlXPWHQ /HEHQVP|JOLFKNHLWHQDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWH'DVVÄDXVGHU7DWVDFKHGHV=XVDP PHQOHEHQVDXVGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLW>«@DXVGHP)DPLOLH6HLQ³VROFKH9HUELQG OLFKNHLWHUZlFKVWLVWÄXQZHLJHUOLFKXQGXQYHUPHLGEDUVRREHLQ%HWHLOLJWHURGHU %HWURIIHQHUGDVZLOORGHUQLFKW³'LHEHUHLWVLQ+LUVFKV:RUWHQDQNOLQJHQGH 6FKLFNVDOVKDIWLJNHLWGHV(OWHUQ.LQG9HUKlOWQLVVHVIKUWDEHUEHNDQQWOLFKQLFKW ]XHLQHP$XWRPDWLVPXVLP+DQGHOQ9LHOPHKUNDQQVLFKGHU(LQ]HOQHGHUVLFK LKPXQHQWULQQEDUVWHOOHQGHQ9HUKDOWHQVDQIRUGHUXQJHEHQVRHQW]LHKHQZLHHUVLFK LKUZLGPHQNDQQ,QEHLGHQ)lOOHQKDQGHOWHUDXV)UHLKHLWGLHDOV9HUP|JHQ VLFK]XDOOHQ*HJHEHQKHLWHQYHUKDOWHQ]XN|QQHQLPPHUGLH0|JOLFKNHLW]XP *XWHQ XQG ]XP %|VHQ LPSOL]LHUW :DV DEHU LVW LQ .RFKV $XJHQ GDV KLHU ]X 7XHQGHZHLOVLFKDXVGHP)DNWXPGHV)DPLOLH6HLQVVHOEVWHUJHEHQGH*XWH"
.2&+ I +,56&+ .2&+ EI .2&+ $D2 (EG 9JO.2&+
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$XIVHLWHQGHU(OWHUQNRPPWHVGDULQ]XP$XVGUXFNÄGDVLHLQVRIHUQZLUN OLFK(OWHUQVLQGDOV]XLKUHP/HEHQHLQEHVWlQGLJHV,QWHUHVVHDQGHQ.LQGHUQ XQGGHUHQ+HUDQZDFKVHQ]XU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWJHK|UW³.RFKEHVFKUHLEWGDPLW HLQH9HUSIOLFKWXQJGLHVLFKGHP.LQGJHJHQEHUYRQ%HJLQQDQVWHOOWXQGGHUHQ 0LVVDFKWXQJZHLWUHLFKHQGH)ROJHQKDW6RKlQJWÄ>G@LH)UHLKHLWYRQ0HQVFKHQ >«@]HLWOHEHQVGDUDQGDMHGHU0HQVFKDOVHLQDQGHUHV6XEMHNWJHERUHQXQG DOVVROFKHVDQHUNDQQWZLUG³ (LQH%HGLQJXQJPHQVFKOLFKHU)UHLKHLWLVWGHP QDFKGLH*HEXUWZRPLW.RFKDXVGUFNOLFKNHLQHQEORHQELRORJLVFKHQ9RUJDQJ PHLQWÄ>1@LFKWDOVÃ5HSURGX]LHUWHµNRPPHQ0HQVFKHQDXIGLH:HOW³GKQLFKW DOV 3URGXNW LKUHU (OWHUQ RGHU (UJHEQLV QDWUOLFKHU /HEHQVSUR]HVVH VRQGHUQ Ä>D@OV*HERUHQH³$XVGHU$EJUHQ]XQJZLUGGHXWOLFKZRUDXI.RFKKLQDXV ZLOO 'DV(UHLJQLVHLQHU*HEXUWOlVVWVLFKQLFKWDOOHLQDXIEHUJHRUGQHWH.DXVDOL WlWHQ]XUFNIKUHQVRQGHUQLVWLPPHUDXFKGHU$QIDQJHLQHVQHXHQGLHJHJHEH QHQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHGXUFKEUHFKHQGHQ'DVHLQV(VZLUGGDULQZLHHUPLW+DQ QDK$UHQGWKHUDXVVWHOOWGHUNDQWLVFKH)UHLKHLWVEHJULIIUHJHOUHFKWVLQQHQIlOOLJ LQVRIHUQGDV=XU:HOW.RPPHQGHV(LQ]HOQHQÄHLQH5HLKHYRQ)ROJHQ³GHUDUW LQLWLLHUWÄGDQLFKWVYRUKHUJHKW³'DEHLOLHJWGHU$N]HQWDXIGHP0RPHQWGHV 1HXHQELVODQJQLH'DJHZHVHQHQHLQHVMHGHQ0HQVFKHQOHEHQV'HVVHQ%HJLQQ LVWGLHÄ*HEXUWVVWXQGH³MHHLJHQHU)UHLKHLWZHLOGHU(LQ]HOQHGDULQDOVGDV XQYHUZHFKVHOEDUH6XEMHNWHUVFKHLQW]XGHPHU=HLWVHLQHV/HEHQVZLUG'LH *HEXUWVWHKWGHPQDFKIUGDVSULQ]LSLHOOXQDXVJHVFK|SIWH3RWHQ]LDOHLQHVQXU LQGLYLGXHOO]XYROO]LHKHQGHQXQGGXUFKQLFKWVDEVROXW]XGHWHUPLQLHUHQGHQ:HU GHQV]XVLFKVHOEVW,QGLHVHP3RWHQ]LDOVLHKW.RFKGLHÄ*HLVWLJNHLW³RGHUÄ3HU VRQDOLWlW³GHV0HQVFKHQYHUDQNHUWÄGLHNHLQ7HLOYRQLKPLVWXQGNHLQYRUKDQ GHQHV(WZDVGDVLKPYRQ1DWXUYRQHLQHUQLFKWPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXUYRUJHJH EHQJOHLFKVDPÃHLQJHSIODQ]WµZlUH³6LHLVWQXUDOVDOOHHQGOLFKH%HVWLPPWKHLW WUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHU6HOEVWYROO]XJGHUGLHÄXUHLJHQH6DFKHXQVUHU)UHLKHLW>«@DOV OHLEKDIWLJHU*HLVWZHVHQ³DXVPDFKW'LHV9HUP|JHQDEHUNDQQGHU0HQVFK SUDNWLVFKQXUUHDOLVLHUHQZHQQHULQVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVVHKLQHLQJHERUHQZLUGGLH LKPGDIU5DXPJHEHQ $OV]ZHLWH%HGLQJXQJGHU)UHLKHLWIRUPXOLHUW.RFKGHVKDOEGDVVPDQÄGDV QHXJHERUHQH.LQGEHUHLWVHLQHHLJHQH3HUVRQVHLQOlW³HVDOVRÄDOVHLQHHLJHQH XQYHUWDXVFKEDUH3HUVRQDOVHLQHLJHQHV6XEMHNWGDVDXVVLFKKHUDXVVLFK]X lXHUQIlKLJLVWDQHUNHQQ>W@³'LHPLWGHP*HERUHQVHLQYHUNQSIWHQ3RWHQ
$D2 .2&+ E $D2 9JO.2&+ I EI .$17 F>$@,P2ULJLQDOWHLOVJHVSHUUW9JOHWZD.2&+ EI .2&+ E $D2 I 9JO]X.RFKV%HJULIIGHVVXEMHNWLYHQ*HLVWHV .2&+ E± I .2&+ I
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
]LDOHEHGUIHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJXPVLFKHQWIDOWHQ]XN|QQHQLQVEHVRQGHUHDP $QIDQJHLQHV/HEHQVÄ0HQVFKHQNRPPHQQLFKWIHUWLJ]XU:HOW³VRQGHUQVLH ÄEUDXFKHQ>«@HLQHQ5DXPHLQ8PIHOGLQGHPVLH]XQHKPHQGDOVIUHLH>«@ KHUDQZDFKVHQ>«@N|QQHQ³VROOHQVLHÄVHOEVWHUVWZHUGHQZDVVLHVLQG 6XEMHN WH³'LH(OWHUQ±ZLHDQDORJGD]XGLHDQGHUHQ%H]XJVSHUVRQHQ±ZHUGHQVR QDFK LKUHU DXV GHP IDPLOLlUHQ 9HUKlOWQLV ]X GHQ .LQGHUQ HUZDFKVHQHQ 9HU SIOLFKWXQJGDGXUFKJHUHFKWGDVVVLHGHUHQ6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWDQHUNHQQHQXQGVR ]XU5HDOLVLHUXQJYHUKHOIHQ 'DEHLDEHUJLEW.RFK]XEHGHQNHQGDVVÄNHLQHUVHLQÃ,FKµVHLQ6HOEVWVHLQ YRP$QGHUHQYRQGHQ(OWHUQYRQGHUGDV.LQGDQVSUHFKHQGHQ0XWWHU>KDW@±VR DOVVHLGDVYRP$QGHUHQHU]HXJWSURGX]LHUW³'LHVHHLQHUVR]LDOHQ.RQVWLWXWL RQGHV6XEMHNWVZLGHUVSUHFKHQGH6LFKWVXFKWHUDXFKHQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFK ]XYHULIL]LHUHQ'HPQDFKHQWKlOWEHUHLWVGLHTXD*HEXUWYROO]RJHQH7UHQQXQJ YRQGHU0XWWHUGHQÄ.HLPGHV6HOEVWEHZXWZHUGHQV³GHUVSlWHULP,FK6DJHQ HUVWH%OWHQWUHLEW 'LHPLWGHP$XIGLH:HOW.RPPHQHLQVHW]HQGH:DKU QHKPXQJGHU'LIIHUHQ]]XQlFKVW]XUPWWHUOLFKHQ$QGHUHQKDWLKUH.HKUVHLWHLQ HLQHPEDVDOHQ:LVVHQXPVLFKVRZLHXPHLQHJUXQGOHJHQGH(LQKHLWYRQ6HOEVW XQG :HOW (V NRPPW ]XP $XVGUXFN LP %HJHKUHQ GDQDFK GHQ JHEXUWOLFKHQ %UXFK]XEHUZLQGHQGHVVHQ(UIOOXQJRGHU9HUVDJXQJYRQVHOEVWUHIHUHQWLHOOHQ /XVWE]Z8QOXVWHPSILQGXQJHQEHJOHLWHWZLUG'DVDXI(LQKHLWDE]LHOHQGH9HU ODQJHQFKDQJLHUWYRQ$QIDQJDQ]ZLVFKHQGHPVR]LDOHQ%HGUIQLVQDFK=XZHQ GXQJXQGGHPDVR]LDOHQ'UDQJVLFKGHU$QGHUHQ]XEHPlFKWLJHQ$XVGLHVHQ (UNHQQWQLVVHQIROJHUW.RFKGDVVGHU3UR]HVVGHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWZHUGHQVRGHUGHU ,FK%LOGXQJLQVWHWHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHQVR]LDOHQ%H]JHQYHUOlXIW RKQHDEHUDXIVLHUHGX]LHUEDU]XVHLQ=ZDUZLUGGDV,FK6DJHQYHUPLWWHOVGHU $QUHGHGXUFKGLH(OWHUQHUOHUQWGRFKÄQXUZHLOGDV.LQGLP%HJULIIHZDUVHLQHU VHOEVWDOVHLQÃ,FKµEHZXW]XZHUGHQNRQQWHQ$QGHUHHVDOV'XDQVSUHFKHQXQG KDWHVGDV,FK6DJHQJHOHUQW³ (VZDUEHUHLWVÄHLQÃ,FKµ>«@DOVHVGDVQRFK QLFKWVDJHQNRQQWH³ LQVRIHUQHVVLFKVHLQHU'LIIHUHQ]]XUXQG(LQKHLWPLWGHU :HOWDXIGLHJHVFKLOGHUWH:HLVHEHZXVVWZDU5REHUW6SDHPDQQGHQ.RFKLQ GLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJDQIKUWEULQJWGHQEHVDJWHQ6DFKYHUKDOWIROJHQGHUPD HQDXIGHQ%HJULII Ä'LH=XZHQGXQJ]XP.LQGKDWYRQ$QIDQJDQGHQ&KDUDN WHUGHU$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHVÃ6XEMHNWHVµXQGQXUVRXQGQLFKWDOVÃ.UHDWXUµVHLQHU (OWHUQNDQQHVÃIUVLFKµZHUGHQZDVHVÃDQVLFKµLVW 6XEMHNW³ (LQ]LJDOVR ZHQQGLHHOWHUOLFKH)UVRUJHDQHUNHQQWHVEHUHLWVEHLP1HXJHERUHQHQPLWHLQHU
.2&+ E .2&+ E .2&+ D9JOGLHVH7H[WVWHOOHDXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH (EG YJO'(56 E± $D2 63$(0$11 .RFK]LWLHUW6SDHPDQQVbXHUXQJLQ .2&+ D E I9JODXFKIUGLHIROJHQGHQ6lW]H6SDHPDQQV$UJXPHQWDWLRQGLHVLFK.RFK]XHLJHQ PDFKW
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VHOEVWlQGLJHQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLW]XWXQ]XKDEHQYHUPDJGLHVHVLFKDXFK]XHQWIDO WHQÄ.HLQ.LQG³VR6SDHPDQQÄZUGH]XHLQHPJHVXQGHQ0HQVFKHQKHUDQ ZDFKVHQZHQQVHLQH(OWHUQLKPLQGHU+DOWXQJGHVVHQHQWJHJHQWUlWHQGHUÃDXV LKPHWZDVPDFKHQµZLOO³ 9LHOPHKULVWHVDOVHWZDV(LJHQHVDQ]XVHKHQGDV DXV VLFK KHUDXV DJLHUHQ NDQQ ± HLQH 8QWHUVWHOOXQJ GLH DOOH HUQVW JHPHLQWHQ .RPPXQLNDWLRQVYHUVXFKHVHLHVPLW:RUWHQ/DXWHQRGHUHLQHP/lFKHOQRKQH KLQYRUQHKPHQ.RPPXQLNDWLYZLUGÄGDV,FKGHV.LQGHV³LPPHUVFKRQYRUDXV JHVHW]WXQGÄVRGHVVHQHLJHQVWlQGLJHVÃ,FKµVDJHQ³JHZHFNW )LQGHWGLHEDVDOH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWGHV.LQGHVNHLQHDXVGUFNOLFKH$QHUNHQ QXQJLVWGLHVQLFKWQXU]XP1DFKWHLOYRQGHVVHQIUHLKHLWOLFKHU,FK(QWZLFNOXQJ ZLH.RFK]XVDJHQZHL Ä,PPHUZHQQGLH(OWHUQLKU.LQGJHOWHQODVVHQLKP VHLQH:UGH]XJHVWHKHQHVDOVRDQQHKPHQHPSIDQJHQVLH>«@LQVROFKHU$QHU NHQQXQJVHOEVWHWZDVIUVLFK]XUFN³VLQGVLHGDULQÄVHOEVWQHXJHZUGLJW³ 'LH $N]HSWDQ] GHV QDFK DXHQ GHQNEDU XQHLJHQVWlQGLJHQ 1HXJHERUHQHQ DOV HLJHQVWlQGLJHV:HVHQLVWYRP%HZXVVWVHLQJHWUDJHQGDVVGHVVHQ:HUGHQ]X HLQHPDXWRQRPHQ6HOEVWDXFKYRPHLJHQHQ7XQDEKlQJW0LWGHU+HUDXVIRUGH UXQJGHU(OWHUQVFKDIWHUVFKOLHWVLFKVRJHVHKHQHLQQHXHU6LQQIUGLH%HVWLP PXQJGHVHLJHQHQ'DVHLQVMHGRFKQXUZHQQGLHVHULQGLHMHZHLOLJH6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJDXIJHQRPPHQZLUG(EHQVRYHUKlOWHVVLFKPLWGHUHOWHUOLFKHQ$QHU NHQQXQJGHV.LQGHV'HVVHQ/HEHQLVWLKQHQÄLQGHQ6FKRLQGLH+lQGHJHOHJW ±XQGGHQQRFKRGHUJHUDGHVREHVLW]HQVLHHVQLFKW³GHQQÄLPPHUIKUWGDV .LQGDXFKHLQHLJHQHV/HEHQ XQGMHHUZDFKVHQHUHVZLUGGHVWREHZXWHUZLUG XQGPXVVHVGDVWXQ³ =XU(UIDKUXQJ]XEULQJHQGDVVJHQDXGLHVHV(LJHQHLQ GHP]XILQGHQLVWZDVPLW$QGHUHQYHUELQGHWLP*HPHLQVDPHQGDULQEHVWHKW IU.RFKGHUWLHIHUHEHUGLHEORH6XEVLVWHQ]KLQDXVJHKHQGH±XQGGDULQUHOL JL|VH±6LQQGHVIDPLOLlUHQ=XVDPPHQVHLQVÄ:DVLQGHU)DPLOLHJHOHEWXQG MHGHPIUVHLQHLJHQHV/HEHQEHZXWZHUGHQVROOLVWGLHHLQIDFKH:DKUKHLWGD NHLQHUDOV6HOEVWlQGLJHUQXUDXVVLFKDOOHLQOHEW³ 9HUWUDXHQXQG9HUOlVVOLFK NHLW9HUVWlQGQLV5FNVLFKWQDKPHXQG1DFKVLFKW±DOOGLHVZLUGLGHDOHUZHLVH YRQDOOHQ)DPLOLHQDQJHK|ULJHQHUOHEWXQGDXVIUHLHU6HOEVWYHUSIOLFKWXQJSUDNWL ]LHUW 'LH8QHU]ZLQJEDUNHLWVROFKHQ6R]LDOYHUKDOWHQVHQWKlOWMHGRFK.RQIOLNW SRWHQ]LDOH6ROlXIWGLHVHLWHQVGHU(OWHUQQRFKVRJXWJHPHLQWH(U]LHKXQJVWHWV *HIDKUDOVlXHUOLFKH9HUSIOLFKWXQJHPSIXQGHQ]XZHUGHQZlKUHQGLKUHLP ,GHDOIDOOÄORVODVVHQGH/LHEH³LPPHUPHKUDXVGHU+DQGJLEWÄZDVGLH+HUDQ ZDFKVHQGHQ DQ 6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW HUUHLFKHQ³ %HLGH '\QDPLNHQ N|QQHQ GLH )DPLOLH]XHLQHUIUGLH%HWHLOLJWHQQDFKKDOWLJEHGUFNHQGHQ/DVWZHUGHQODVVHQ
63$(0$11 .2&+ E $D2 $D2 .2&+ E 9JO$D2± $D2I
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
GLHOHEHQVODQJH9HUOHW]XQJHQXQGHLQHLKU6HOEVWVHLQEHVWLPPWH8QYHUV|KQOLFK NHLWPLWVLFKEULQJW%HVWHQIDOOVDEHULVWHVGHQ(OWHUQJHJHEHQLKUHÄ.LQGHU ORV>]X@ODVVHQ>«@LP9HUWUDXHQGDUDXIGDGLHVH ZLVVHQ ZDVHLQ /HEHQOH EHQVZHUWPDFKWXQGGDUXPVHOEVWlQGLJLKUHQ:HJVFKRQILQGHQZHUGHQ³'LH .LQGHUKLQJHJHQN|QQHQZHQQGLH)DPLOLHLKUHQ6LQQHUIOOWKDW.UDIWDXVGHU (ULQQHUXQJDQLKUH(OWHUQVFK|SIHQ ZHLOVLHVLFKDOVÄEHGLQJXQJVORVDQJHQRP PHQ³XQGLPÄHLJHQ/LHEHQZLHGHUXPEHMDKW³HUIDKUHQKDEHQZDUHQVRZLHDXI HLQJHJHQVHLWLJHV9HUVWlQGQLVJHWURIIHQVLQGGDV.RQIOLNWHRIIHQDXV]XWUDJHQ HUODXEWH6RZLFKWLJGLH7UHQQXQJYRQGHQ(OWHUQIUGLH(QWZLFNOXQJHLQHV 0HQVFKHQKLQ]XU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWLVWVRZHQLJNDQQHLQHUVLFKYRQGHUÄQDWUOL FKH>Q@ %DVLV >V@HLQHU ,GHQWLWlW GLHVH RGHU MHQH (OWHUQ ]X KDEHQ >«@ Y|OOLJ HPDQ]LSLHUHQ³'LHYRQ.RFKKHUDXVJHVWHOOWH8QHQWULQQEDUNHLWGHV(OWHUQ .LQG9HUKlOWQLVVHVUHLFKWZHLWEHUGLH3KDVHGHVIDPLOLlUHQ=XVDPPHQOHEHQV KLQDXV1LHPDQGNRPPWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQXPKLQVLFKGD]XLQV9HUKlOWQLV]X VHW]HQVHLHVXPHUIDKUHQH9HUOHW]XQJHQ]XYHUDUEHLWHQRGHUVLFKGDVDOVSRVLWLY (UIDKUHQHDQ]XHLJQHQ*HQDXGDULQDEHUOLHJWGLH]XY|UGHUVWGHQ.LQGHUQDXVGHU )DPLOLHHUZDFKVHQH9HUSIOLFKWXQJ6LH]LHOWDXIGDVÄVHOEVWJHZROOWH$QQHKPHQ GHV HLJHQHQ /HEHQV³ LQ VHLQHU *HJHEHQKHLW ZDV ODXW .RFK JOHLFKEHGHXWHQG GDPLWLVWGDVVGHU(LQ]HOQHÄ]XHLQHU%HMDKXQJGHU=XIlOOLJNHLWVHLQHU+HUNXQIW³ ILQGHW 2EGLH)DPLOLHGHQLKULQQHZRKQHQGHQ1RUPHQJHUHFKWZLUGVWHKWXQGIlOOW ZLHJHVHKHQPLWGHU6HOEVWYHUSIOLFKWXQJLKUHU0LWJOLHGHU'DUEHUYHUPDJQLH PDQGYRQDXHQ]XYHUIJHQVROOGLH)DPLOLHQLFKW]XHLQHU=ZDQJVDQVWDOWYHU NRPPHQÄ6DFKHGHV5HFKWV³NDQQIU.RFKVRHLQ]LJÄGLHlXHUH)RUP>«@GHU )DPLOLH³VHLQZlKUHQGVLHÄDOV5DXPGHV9HUWUDXHQVGHV9HUVWHKHQVGHU9HU OlOLFKNHLW EHUUHFKWOLFK³ LVW (V PXVV LQ VHLQHQ $XJHQ LP ,QWHUHVVH GHV 6WDDWHVVHLQÄVROFKHYHUOlOLFKHQ%H]LHKXQJHQlXHUOLFKSULYLOHJLHUHQ³ZHLOLQ LKQHQGDXHUKDIWHLQHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH9HUDQWZRUWXQJEHUQRPPHQZLUGGLHÄVHL QHU3IOLFKWGLH6FKZDFKHQ]XVFKW]HQ³HQWVSULFKW'RFKOlVVWVLFKGLH.RQ WLQXLWlWIDPLOLlUHU9HUKlOWQLVVHHEHQQLFKWSROLWLVFKUHFKWOLFKRUJDQLVLHUHQXQG HLQMHGHU9HUVXFKLQGLHVH5LFKWXQJZlUH]XP6FKDGHQGHUXQDEGLQJEDUDXWR QRPHQ6HOEVWYHUSIOLFKWXQJGHV(LQ]HOQHQ6RLVWÄ>J@HJHQEHUGHPZDVLQHLQHU ULFKWLJHQ)DPLOLHJHVFKLHKWXQGGHP.LQGPLWJHJHEHQZLUG>«@GLH5HFKWVIRUP ]ZHLWUDQJLJ³ZHLOHVDXIJUXQGGHULQGHQWUDJHQGHQ%H]LHKXQJHQVHOEVWOLH JHQGHQ9HUELQGOLFKNHLWJHVFKLHKW0LWGLHVHU6LFKWEULQJW.RFKGLH'LIIHUHQ]
$D2 $D2 I $D2 9JODXFKIUGHQIROJHQGHQ6DW] $D2 ± 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH .2&+ E± ± .2&+ E $D2 $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
YRQ5HFKWXQG0RUDO]XU*HOWXQJGLHHUDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWDOVÄHLQH1HX DXIODJHGHUOXWKHULVFKHQ=ZHL5HLFKH/HKUH³]XLQWHUSUHWLHUHQYHUPDJ'LH EHVDJWH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJLVWLPPHUGRUWHWKLVFKUHOHYDQWZR6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVH EHGDFKWZHUGHQLQVRIHUQGLHVHVWHWVHLQH,QQHQXQGHLQH$XHQVHLWHKDEHQ 1DFKDXHQVLQGVLHUHFKWOLFKHU5HJXOLHUXQJXQWHUZRUIHQGLHRKQH5FNVLFKW DXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJGHUMHZHLOV%HWHLOLJWHQQRWIDOOVDXFK]ZDQJVZHLVHGXUFK JHVHW]WZLUG=XJOHLFKDEHUKDEHQVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVVHLPPHUDXFKHLQHÄ%LQ QHQPRUDO³VLHHQWKDOWHQQXUYRP(LQ]HOQHQÄLP*HZLVVHQZDKU]XQHKPHQGH>@ $QIRUGHUXQJHQ³GHUHQSUDNWLVFKH(LQKROXQJDOOHLQDXWRQRPHUIROJW6RUHJHOW EHLVSLHOVZHLVHGDV6RUJHUHFKWDXVZHOFKHQ*UQGHQDXFKLPPHUDXIEUHFKHQGH .RQIOLNWHXPGLHHU]LHKHULVFKH=XVWlQGLJNHLWIUGDV.LQGRKQHMHGRFKGHUHQ *HVWDOWXQJLP(LQ]HOQHQQRUPLHUHQ]XN|QQHQXQG]XZROOHQ(VVWHOOWVLFKHU GDVVGLH(OWHUQDXFKQDFKHLQHU7UHQQXQJLKUHQHU]ZLQJEDUHQ3IOLFKWHQHWZDGHU 8QWHUKDOWVSIOLFKWQDFKNRPPHQÄ5HFKWVFKDIIW.ODUKHLWXQGLQVRIHUQ6WDELOLWlWÃ IUHLOLFKQLHJHJHQGHQ:LOOHQGHU%HWHLOLJWHQ³GLHHVVRJDUÄDOV:DIIHJHJHQGHQ $QGHUHQDOV0LWWHOGHU6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJ³PLVVEUDXFKHQN|QQHQZLH.RFK LP %OLFN DXI ELVZHLOHQ ]XP .OHLQNULHJ DXVXIHUQGH 6RUJHUHFKWVVWUHLWLJNHLWHQ KHUYRUKHEW+LQVLFKWOLFKLKUHVÄJXWHQOHEHQVI|UGHUOLFKHQ6LQQ>V@³DEHULVWGLH UHFKWOLFKH5HJXOLHUXQJGHU)DPLOLHÄYRQGHQ%HWHLOLJWHQYRQGHQMHZHLOLJHQ 5HFKWVLQKDEHUQVHOEVWPLWKLQHLJHQV]XZROOHQ³=ZDUVFKDIIWVLHQLFKWGLH LQQHUH *HPHLQVDPNHLW GHV =XVDPPHQOHEHQV DEHU VLH VWlUNW VLH XQG JLEW LKU ]XVlW]OLFKH6LFKHUKHLW)U.RFKEHGHXWHWGDVLQVEHVRQGHUHDXFKGDVVGLH(OWHUQ HLQHUHFKWOLFKYHUELQGOLFKH(KHHLQJHKHQE]ZGDVVHVÄLP)DOOHGHU$GRSWLRQ RGHU ZHLWHUHU $XVQDKPHIlOOH >«@ HLQH HLJHQH JHJHEHQHQIDOOV JHULFKWOLFKH 5HFKWVIHVWVWHOOXQJ³JLEW'DEHLVWHOOWHUGLH6LFKHUKHLWIUGDV.LQGLQGHQ 9RUGHUJUXQGEHUGHVVHQIDPLOLlUH=XJHK|ULJNHLWVR.ODUKHLWKHUUVFKWZlKUHQG VHLQH(OWHUQLKUHP:LOOHQ|IIHQWOLFK$XVGUXFNYHUOLHKHQKDEHQGDXHUKDIW]X VDPPHQ]XEOHLEHQ'LH.RQWLQXLWlWGHUHOWHUOLFKHQ%H]LHKXQJGRNXPHQWLHUW LP|IIHQWOLFKHQ(KHVFKOXVVLVWZLHGHUXPGLHÄLQQHUH9RUDXVVHW]XQJ³XQGGDV Ä]XVDPPHQKDOWHQGH>@%DQG³GHU)DPLOLH6LFKRIIL]LHOOHKHOLFK]XYHUELQGHQ LVWIU.RFKHLQHEHZXVVWH :DKUQHKPXQJGHU9HUDQWZRUWXQJGLH(OWHUQDOV (OWHUQIULKU.LQGKDEHQXQGDOVÄSRWHQWLHOOHHLQVLFKWVIlKLJH0HQVFKHQ³DXFK ZDKU]XQHKPHQ±DEHUHEHQDXFK]XLJQRULHUHQ±LQGHU/DJHVLQG:LHGDPLW DQJHGHXWHWVLQG(KHXQG)DPLOLHYRQlKQOLFKHQ.RQIOLNWG\QDPLNHQJHSUlJW
.2&+ I 9JODXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2I I .2&+ $D2 $D2 .2&+ E 9JODD2 ± $D2 $D2
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
(KH )UDJLOH*HPHLQVDPNHLW .RFKVLHKWGLH(KHGXUFKÄHLQHLQQHUH6SDQQXQJ³EHVWLPPWÄLQGHULKUH/HEHQ GLJNHLWDEHUDXFKLKUH)UDJLOLWlWXQG.ULVHQDQIlOOLJNHLWZXU]HOW³6LHLVWHL QHUVHLWVHLQH6DFKHGHVVXEMHNWLYHQ(PSILQGHQVXQG:ROOHQV]ZHLHU0HQVFKHQ KDWDQGHUHUVHLWVDEHUDOVGLH%HWHLOLJWHQPLWHLQDQGHUYHUELQGHQGH*U|HREMHNWL YHQ&KDUDNWHU6SDQQXQJVYROOQLPPWVLFKGDV9HUKlOWQLVGLHVHUEHLGHQ0RPHQWH LQVEHVRQGHUHGHVKDOEDXVZHLOGLHUHFKWOLFKH,QVWLWXWLRQGHU(KHLKUHQ6WDWXV ÄDOVYHUSIOLFKWHQGYRUJHJHEHQHUYRQ*RWWPLWGHUQDWUOLFKHQ/HLEOLFKNHLWHLQ JHULFKWHWHUXQGDQJHRUGQHWHU6WDQG³LP*HIROJHGHU0RGHUQHZHLWKLQYHUORUHQ KDW:DVIU/XWKHUXQGGLHOXWKHULVFKH2UWKRGR[LHQRFKVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKZDU GHQ (KHVFKOXVV DXI J|WWOLFKHU 6FK|SIXQJVRUGQXQJ ]X JUQGHQ ZXUGH GXUFK URPDQWLVFKHZLHOLEHUDOLVWLVFKH6LFKWZHLVHQLQ)UDJHJHVWHOOW (LQ]LJGDVOLH EHYROOH(QWIODPPHQGHU3DUWQHUIUHLQDQGHUGLHVLFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJDOV(UIOOXQJ LKUHUVHOEVWHPSILQGHQRGHULKUHDXWRQRPH(QWVFKHLGXQJ ]XPJHPHLQVDPHQ /HEHQ NDQQ GHPQDFK GLH (KH EHJUQGHQ 'HUHQ 5HFKWVIRUP ZLUG LQ GLHVHP =XJH]XHWZDVUHLQbXHUOLFKHP6HNXQGlUHPKHUDEJHVWXIWXQGELVZHLOHQJDUDOV IUHLKHLWVEHGURKHQGH=ZDQJVPDQDKPHDQJHVHKHQ'DVVGLH(KHLQIROJHGHVVHQ LKUHQJ|WWOLFKEHJUQGHWHQ9RUJHJHEHQKHLWVFKDUDNWHUHLQJHEWKDWXQGJHJHQ ZlUWLJDXILQGLYLGXHOOHQ,QWHUHVVHQIXWLVWLQ.RFKV$XJHQWKHRORJLVFKNHLQHV ZHJV]XEHNODJHQ9LHOPHKUJHK|UWHVHEHQ]XUQHX]HLWOLFKHQWGHFNWHQÄ:UGH GHV0HQVFKHQ>«@QLFKWVPLW:DKUKHLWVDQVSUXFKIUVLFKJHOWHQ]XODVVHQZR UDQHUQLFKWPLWVHLQHU(LQVLFKWEHWHLOLJWVHLQNDQQ³=ZDUIKUWGLHV]XHLQHP *HOWXQJVYHUOXVWEHUNRPPHQHU6LWWOLFKNHLWDEHUHVVWHLJHUWDXFKÄGLH&KDQFH >«@YRQJHZLVVHQKDIWHU/HEHQVIKUXQJ³XQGÄ6HOEVWYHUDQWZRUWOLFKNHLW³ZHLO LGHDOHUZHLVHQLHPDQGPHKUÄÃXQQ|WLJµDOVRRKQHSRWHQWLHOOHLQVLFKWLJH1RWZHQ GLJNHLWHLQH9HUSIOLFKWXQJHLQJHKW³$QJHVLFKWVGHUYHUlQGHUWHQ/DJHN|QQHQ WKHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQ]XU(KHQDFK.RFKV8UWHLOQXUQRFKGDUDXI]LHOHQ
.2&+L9JOIUGLHIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]X(KHJUXQGOHJHQG DD2 ± .2&+ E 'LHVHUÄJUXQGOHJHQGH$VSHNWGHVHYDQJHOLVFKHQ(KHYHUVWlQGQLVVHV³ LVW.RFK]XIROJHELVLQGLHMQJVWH=HLWLQGHU(WKLNJHWHLOWH$QVLFKW'DIUYHUZHLVWHUDXI .DUO%DUWK(UQVW%UXQQHU'LHWULFK%RQKRHIIHUXQG7UXW]5HQGWRUII YJO'(56 EI 9JO]XU(QWZLFNOXQJGHV(KHYHUVWlQGQLVVHV .2&+LIIII.RFKUHNXUULHUW DXI6FKOHJHOXQGGHQIUKHQ6FKOHLHUPDFKHUIUGLHURPDQWLVFKHDXI+HUGHUIUGLHOLEHUDOLVWL VFKH6LFKWGHU(KH/XWKHUV3RVLWLRQUHNRQVWUXLHUWHULQ GHUV E± .XU]XQGNQDSS IDVVWHUGLHVHGRUWZLHIROJW]XVDPPHQ Ä:LUGQDFKGHU%HGLQJXQJGHV*HJHEHQVHLQVGHU(KH JHIUDJW>«@GDQQLVWVLHDOV*RWWHV2UGQXQJ*DEHXQG$XIWUDJ]XHUNHQQHQ,KUHPlXHUHQ 5DKPHQQDFKLVWVLH*HJHQVWDQGGHVZHOWOLFKHQ5HFKWV8QGLKUHULQQHUHQ$XVJHVWDOWXQJXQG (UIOOXQJQDFKLVWVLHGHUFKULVWOLFKH6WDQGGHUDEHUYRQGHQ(KHOHXWHQVHOEVWFKULVWOLFK]X JHVWDOWHQXQGDOOWlJOLFKFKULVWOLFK]XOHEHQLVW³ DD2 .2&+ E .2&+
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHUHQ/HEHQVGLHQOLFKNHLWIUGHQ(LQ]HOQHQQDFKYROO]LHKEDU]XPDFKHQ=X GHP PVVHQ VLH GDV WUDGLWLRQHOO PLW GHU (KH YHUEXQGHQH 8QYHUEUFK OLFKNHLWVSDWKRVEHUZLQGHQZHLOGLHVHXQWHUPRGHUQHQ%HGLQJXQJHQDOVÄHLQH SUHNlUHIUDJLOH*HPHLQVDPNHLWLQ*HJHQVHLWLJNHLW³YRU$XJHQWULWWGLHÄVLFK QLFKWYRQVHOEVW³HUKlOWXQGGHUHQ%HVWDQGGXUFKQLHPDQGHQ]XJDUDQWLHUHQLVW 'DVV.RFK6HQVLELOLWlWIUGLH.ULVHQDQIlOOLJNHLWGHU(KHHLQIRUGHUWEHGHXWHW DEHU NHLQH $EVDJH DQ GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHV YRQ 'DXHU JHSUlJWHQ HKHOLFKHQ =XVDPPHQOHEHQV8QWHUHUQHXWHP5FNJULIIDXI+HJHOV5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLHVXFKW HUKLQJHJHQGHXWOLFK]XPDFKHQZDUXP/HW]WHUHVVLWWOLFKDQ]XVWUHEHQLVW ZHLO GLH(LQ]HOQHQVRÄGLH$XIKHEXQJLKUHU,VRODWLRQLQHLQHU*HPHLQVDPNHLW³HUODQ JHQLQGHUVLHYRUEHKDOWORVÄHLQDQGHUDQJHK|UHQ³'HU(KHVFKOXVVDOV$XIJH KHQÄLQMHQHU(LQKHLW³LVWZLH+HJHOVFKUHLEWIUGLH%HWHLOLJWHQÄHLQH6HOEVWEH VFKUlQNXQJDEHUHEHQLQGHPVLHLQLKULKUVXEVWDQWLHOOHV6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQJH ZLQQHQLKUH%HIUHLXQJ³6RVHKUHVGDEHLDXILKUIUHLHV:ROOHQXQG(PSILQ GHQDQNRPPWVRZHQLJJHKWGDVVLH9HUELQGHQGHDOOHLQGDUDXI]XUFN(LQ9HU VWlQGQLVGHU(KHDOV9HUWUDJ]ZLVFKHQ]ZHL6XEMHNWHQGLHVLFKLP%OLFNDXI HWZDV%HVWLPPWHVLKQHQlXHUOLFK%OHLEHQGHVDQHUNHQQHQRGHUHLQLJHQDQVRQV WHQDEHUYRQHLQDQGHUXQEHWURIIHQVLQGVFKOLHW.RFKPLW+HJHODXV(EHQVR YHUZLUIWHUGDVURPDQWLVFKH,GHDOHLQHUDOOHLQDXIJHJHQVHLWLJHQ/LHEHVHPSILQ GXQJHQJUQGHQGHQHKHOLFKHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWGHUHQ]XIlOOLJHUXQGVXEMHNWLYHU &KDUDNWHUNHLQH'DXHUKDIWLJNHLWYHUVSULFKW.RFKEULQJWGLHDYLVLHUWH9HUEXQ GHQKHLW YLHOPHKU DOV 9HUHLQWVHLQ ]ZHLHU 0HQVFKHQ ÄLQ HLQHP JHPHLQVDPHQ Ã'ULWWHQµ,GHQWLVFKHQ³DXIGHQ%HJULIIÄHEHQLQGHP*HKDOWGHUVLHYHUELQ GHW³,QGLHVHVYRQEHLGHQXQWHUVFKLHGHQH*HPHLQVDPHGLHÄ*RWWVHOEVWGHU HLQH*HLVWGHUDOOHU:DKUKHLWXQGDOOHU/LHEH³ LVWOHJWHLQMHGHUDXVVLFKKH UDXVJHKHQGXQGGLHHLJHQH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWDXIJHEHQGVHLQH,QGLYLGXDOLWlWKL QHLQ6RZHLHUQXUQRFKXPVLFKLQGHPÄHU]XJOHLFKXPGHQ$QGHUHQZHL³ XQGLVWHUQXUQRFKLGHQWLVFKPLWVLFKÄLQGHU,GHQWLWlWPLWGHP$QGHUHQ³ 'LHVHYHUELQGHQGH,GHQWLWlWDEHULVWQLFKWHLQHLQPDOHUUXQJHQHU6WDWXVVRQGHUQ LVWZLUNOLFKQXUDOVHLQVWHWLJHU3UR]HVVGHU]XJOHLFKGDV=LHOGHU(KHGDUVWHOOW 6LHHUIOOWVLFKLQLPPHUUHLFKHUZHUGHQGHUÄ*HPHLQVDPNHLWXQG=XVDPPHQJH K|ULJNHLW³
9JOGD]XQXUGLH+LQZHLVHLQGHU(LQOHLWXQJ .2&+LI .2&+ E .2&+ E YJO IU GLH IROJHQGHQ 'DUOHJXQJHQ ]X .RFKV +HJHO5H]HSWLRQ '(56LI II +(*(/>@ 9JOGD]X DD2 >@>@ 9JOGD]X DD2±>@ .2&+L .2&+ E .2&+L 9JOHEG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
,P8QWHUVFKLHG]X+HJHOVLHKW.RFKGDV$XVVHLQDXIHLQ/HEHQLQVROFKHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ9HUEXQGHQKHLWEHUHLWVLPHURWLVFKHQ%HJHKUHQDQJHOHJWGDV QLFKW QRWZHQGLJ ]XU HJR]HQWULVFKHQ 9HUHLQQDKPXQJ GHV *HJHQEHUV IKUHQ PXVV*UXQGVlW]OLFKLPSOL]LHUWHVHLQ8QJHQJHQDQVLFKVHOEVWXQGGDPLW YHUEXQGHQGHQ:XQVFKPLWHLQHP$QGHUHQ]XVHLQÄIUGHQPDQXQDXVWDXVFK EDUHLQ]LJDUWLJLVW±EHLGHPPDQYHUVWDQGHQXQGDQJHQRPPHQLVW³$XVGHP HURWLVFKHQ%HJHKUHQNDQQVRJHVHKHQZLHYRQVHOEVWHLQHEHVWlQGLJHUH)RUPGHV =XVDPPHQVHLQVHQWVWHKHQLQGHUVLFKGLH%HWURIIHQHQDOVVLHVHOEVWZLHGHU]XILQ GHQ YHUP|JHQ .RFK UHIOHNWLHUW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ GLH PLW GHP *H OWXQJVYHUOXVWGHU(KHYHUEXQGHQHQ9HUlQGHUXQJHQLQGHU$QEDKQXQJYRQ/LH EHVEH]LHKXQJHQ6LHHQWVWHKHQXQPHUNOLFKHURKQHGDVVHVGD]XÄHLQHUEHZXWHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJ³DUWLNXOLHUW]%LQGHU9HUOREXQJEHGDUI Ä0LWGHU=HLWJHZ|KQW PDQVLFKDQHLQDQGHUXQGLVWPHKURGHUZHQLJHUÃIHVWOLLHUWµDOVREHVWlQGLJ]X VDPPHQ³XQGZLUGÄ]XQHKPHQGHLQDQGHUXQHQWEHKUOLFK³'HUZDFKVHQGHQ *HPHLQVDPNHLWZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU/LHEHZRKQWREGLHVHU([NOXVLYLWlWHLQH9HU ELQGOLFKNHLWLQQHGLHGDUDXI]LHOWVLFKGHPMHZHLOV$QGHUHQJHJHQEHUYHUOlVV OLFK ]X ]HLJHQ /HW]WHUHV UHVXOWLHUW ]ZDU DXV GHU /LHEH ]XU JHOLHEWHQ 3HUVRQ VHOEVWJHZLQQWDEHUYHUWUDXHQVVWLIWHQGH3UlJQDQ]QXUZHQQGLHVHEHZXVVWJH ZROOWZLUGXQGVLFKHQWVSUHFKHQGlXHUW:RGLHVJHVFKLHKWVSULFKW.RFKZHJHQ GHUGDPLWDQJH]LHOWHQ'DXHUKDIWLJNHLWEHUHLWVYRQHLQHU(KH:LUGGLH/LHEH ]XHLQDQGHUQLFKWQXUHPSIXQGHQVRQGHUQGHUDUWEHZXVVWYROO]RJHQHQWKlOWVLH QlPOLFKHLQ0RPHQWYRQVLWWOLFKHU6HOEVWYHUSIOLFKWXQJ]XLKUHULPPHUQHXHQ 5HYLWDOLVLHUXQJ'DULQNRPPWDEHUHEHQÄHLQH9HUELQGOLFKNHLW³]XP7UDJHQ ÄGLHLQGHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWGHU3HUVRQHQOLHJW³XQGQLFKWHWZDYRQDXHQDQJH VRQQHQZLUG6LHlXHUWVLFKÄLQGHUIUHLHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHVHLQHQGXUFKGHQ DQGHUHQ³DOVXQYHUZHFKVHOEDUHVXQGHLJHQVWlQGLJHV6XEMHNWZRULQ.RFKHLQGHU /LHEHVEH]LHKXQJLPPDQHQWHVÄ5HFKWV0RPHQW³HUEOLFNW6RVHKUQlPOLFKGLH *HJHQOLHEHGHVJHOLHEWHQ0HQVFKHQHUVHKQWZLUGVRZHQLJOlVVWVLHVLFKHU]ZLQ 9JODXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH .2&+ E±.RFKNULWLVLHUW+HJHOVJHJHQOlXILJH 3RVLWLRQLQ GHUVL II,QVJHVDPWPRQLHUWHUGDVV+HJHOGLH/LHEHLQGHQ%HUHLFKGHV 6LQQOLFKHQ1DWUOLFKHQ%HOLHELJHQDEVFKLHEWXPGLH(KHOHW]WOLFKGRFKDOVGHP:LOOHQGHU (LQ]HOQHQYRUDXVOLHJHQGHVLWWOLFKH2UGQXQJ]XUHSULVWLQLHUHQVRGDVVHWZDDXFKGHU|IIHQWOLFKH (KHVFKOXVVDOVLKU$QIDQJHUVFKHLQW 9JO]XUEHLDOOHU$PELYDOHQ]JUXQGVlW]OLFKHQ6R]LDOLWlWGHV%HJHKUHQV .2&+ E ± I .2&+ E9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2± .2&+ .2&+N9JO'(56 'DVVGLHLQGHU(KH]XUGDXHUKDIWHQ(LQVWHOOXQJ ZHUGHQGH/LHEHVLFKDOVÄDQKDOWHQGH>V@,QWHUHVVHDP$QGHUHQ³lXHUWGDVÄRKQHYLHOH:RUWH >«@JHWUDJHQ>LVW@YRQHLQHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³9JO'(56 'DVVEHLGH YRPÄ:LOOHQ]XPJHPHLQVDPHQ/HEHQ³EHVWLPPWVLQGÄlXHUWVLFKYRUDOOHPLQGHUJHJHQVHL WLJHQ$FKWXQJGLHHLQHUIUGHQDQGHUHQVHLQHQDQGHUHQKHJW³XQGGLHVLFKDXILKQÄDOVGLH VHQXQYHUJOHLFKOLFKHQ0HQVFKHQ³VHOEVWXQGQLFKWDXIEHVWLPPWHOLHEHQVZHUWH(LJHQVFKDIWHQ EH]LHKW9JO]XPÃ5HFKWV0RPHQWµGHU/LHEHLP)ROJHQGHQ '(56NII
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JHQ9LHOPHKUÄZLOOGHU/LHEHQGHJHUDGHGDGHUDQGHUHIUHLDXIVHLQ6XFKHQ DQWZRUWHWXQGLQVHLQ/LHEHQHLQZLOOLJW³ZDVGLHVHPVRQDFKDOVÄVHLQ5HFKW³ ]XHUNDQQWZHUGHQPXVV5lXPHQVLFKEHLGHLP9HUKlOWQLV]XHLQDQGHUVROFKH (LJHQVWlQGLJNHLWHLQVLQGVLHDOOHUHUVWLQGHU/DJHGDUDXVHLQHEHULKUMHZHLOL JHV6RVHLQKLQDXVJHKHQGH%HUHLFKHUXQJLKUHUVHOEVW]XJHZLQQHQ'DEHLJLOW Ä>,@QGHPZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ%HLWUDJGHQMHGHU]XLKU³GHUJHPHLQVDPJHOHEWHQ /LHEHÄOHLVWHWIXQJLHUWMHGHUDOV7lWHUXQG(PSIlQJHU]XJOHLFK³LVWDOVRQLH PDQGGHUDOOHV%HVWLPPHQGH'DVGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQGH8QYHUIJEDUNHLWVPR PHQW JLEW GHU EHLGH 3DUWQHU YHUELQGHQGHQ HLQHQGHQ %H]LHKXQJ YRQ GHU VLH HEHQVREHVWLPPWVLQGZLHVLHVLFK]XLKUYHUKDOWHQHLQXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHVXQG GDULQJ|WWOLFKHV(LJHQVHLQ(VZLUGGLHÄ/LHEHQLFKW>«@ZLHHLQ'LQJ³ KHU JHVWHOOW,KUH:LUNOLFKNHLWOlVVWVLFKDXINHLQHQYRQEHLGHQXQGDXFKQLFKWDXI HLQH$UW.ROOHNWLYKDQGHOQ]XUFNIKUHQZHLOGLH%HWHLOLJWHQLPPHUDXFK6HOE VWlQGLJHEOHLEHQ'LH/LHEHQGHQVRIROJHUW.RFKZLVVHQGDUXPÄGDLKU/LHEHQ YRQGHU/LHEHVHOEVWYHUVFKLHGHQLVW³GHUHQ5HDOVHLQVLHYRUDXVVHW]HQZHQQ VLHVLFKGHPMHZHLOVDOVIUHLDQHUNDQQWHQ$QGHUHQYHUWUDXHQVYROOKLQJHEHQ6LH LVWGDVEHUHLWVEHQDQQWHJHPHLQVDPHÄÃ'ULWWH>@µ³GHU(KHLKUHÄWUDQVVXEMHNWLYH $OOJHPHLQKHLW³Ã*RWWXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQµLQGHPEHLGHDOV8QWHUVFKLHGHQH YHUHLQWVLQG±HLQHVSDQQXQJVYROOH(LQKHLWDXVGHUZLHHLQJDQJVEHWRQWGLH YLWDOH(QWZLFNOXQJVIlKLJNHLWGHV=XVDPPHQVHLQVUHVXOWLHUW,QGHPGLH(KHSDUW QHUGHVVHQ3IOHJHZLOOHQWOLFKLQLKUH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJDXIQHKPHQVXFKHQVLH JHUDGHLKUHEOHLEHQGH8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWYRQHLQDQGHUHWZDDXFKLKU(LQJHEXQ GHQVHLQLQDQGHUH%H]LHKXQJHQÄPLWLQKDOWOLFKHP=XJHZLQQLQGLH*HPHLQVDP NHLW]XUHLQWHJULHUHQ³ 'RFKJUQGHWLQGHU6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQYHUELQGOLFKHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWXQG GHVVHQ9HUDQNHUXQJLPVXEMHNWLYHQ:ROOHQXQG(PSILQGHQDXFKGLHÄ$QIlOOLJ NHLWMHGHU(KHIUGLH.ULVH³6RNDQQGHQ(LQHQGDV%HZXVVWVHLQIUGDVLKQ PLWGHP$QGHUHQ9HUELQGHQGHDEHEEHQRGHUJlQ]OLFKYHUVFKZLQGHQZDVGLH $OOJHPHLQKHLWVGLPHQVLRQ GHU (KH IU LKQ XQZLUNOLFK ZHUGHQ OlVVW .RFK VFKUlQNWGLHVDEHUHLQ Ä1LFKWKDWMHQH$OOJHPHLQKHLWVLFKDXIJHO|VW DEHUHUGHU HLQ]HOQHKDWYHUOHUQWVLHEHLVLFKVHOEVW]XYROO]LHKHQ³YHUPDJVLFKQLFKWPHKU ÄLQVHLQHP,QQHUQIUGHQ$QGHUHQIUVHLQHQEHVWLPPWHQ$QGHUHQ³DXI]X EULQJHQ(UYHUVWHKWGLHVHV Ä6FKHLWHUQHLQHU(KH³GH]LGLHUWDOV6FKHLWHUQGHV HLQ]HOQHQÄDQGHU)RUGHUXQJ]XOLHEHQ³DQGHUhEHUZLQGXQJVHLQHU%HVFKUlQ NXQJDXIVHLJHQH,FKGXUFKGHVVHQ$XIKHEXQJLP$OOJHPHLQHQGKLQGHU,GHQ
.2&+N (EG (EG $D2 .2&+L (EG $D2 9JO]XU.ULVHQDQIlOOLJNHLWGHU(KHLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 I (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
WLWlWPLWGHP$QGHUHQÄDQGHU/LHEHVHOEVW³XQGGDPLWÄDQGHU6LWWOLFKNHLW³ GLHDOV$XIJDEHXQG%HVWLPPXQJLQVHLQHP0HQVFKVHLQVHOEVWOLHJW)U.RFK LVW6FKHLWHUQVFKXOGKDIWXQGWUDJLVFKYHUKlQJQLVYROO]XJOHLFKZHLOLPPHUDXFK GHU$QGHUHVHLQH5ROOHLP=HUEUHFKHQGHU(KHVSLHOW VHLHVZHLOHUGLH/LHEHV EHPKXQJHQGHV(LQHQQLFKWHUZLGHUWRGHULQVHLQHUEHVRQGHUHQ(LJHQDUWIU GLHVHQDOVQLFKWOLHEEDUHUVFKHLQW-HGH(KHNULVHLVWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQHLQH9HU WUDXHQVNULVH:HPGDVLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQPLWJHVHW]WH9HUWUDXHQ GDVVGLHVHUHVJUXQGVlW]OLFKÄJXWPHLQWXQGLKPGDV%|VHGLH.UlQNXQJRGHUGLH %HPlFKWLJXQJQXUXQWHUOlXIW³]XVFKDQGHQZLUGÄGHPLVWGLH*HPHLQVDPNHLW PLWVHLQHPDQGHUHQ]HUEURFKHQ³5HFKWOLFKH%HVWLPPXQJHQN|QQHQQLFKWV GD]XEHLWUDJHQGLHVHÄ%HGURKWKHLWGHU(KHGLHLKUGRFKVHOEVWHLQZRKQWDE]X ZHQGHQ³ZHLOVLFKGDVYRP6XEMHNWDXVJHKHQGH:ROOHQXQG(PSILQGHQGHU /LHEHQLFKWHLQNODJEDUXQGHU]ZLQJEDULVW:RULQOLHJWGDQQDEHUGLH%HGHXWXQJ GHV5HFKWVIUGLH(KH" )U.RFKVWHKWIHVWGDVVÄ>G@HU6LQQGHU(KH>«@QLFKWYRQGHU5HFKWVIRUP GHU(KHDEKlQJLJ³LVW'DVRIIL]LHOOH-D:RUWEHGHXWHWÄQLFKWPHKUDEHUDXFK QLFKWZHQLJHUDOVGDV|IIHQWOLFKH$XVVSUHFKHQGHUEHLGHQ(KHSDUWQHUGDVLH ]XVDPPHQJHK|UHQXQGVLFKVHOEVWGLH(KHYHUVSURFKHQKDEHQ³ 'DUDQELQGHW VLHDOOHLQLKUDXIGLHJHPHLQVDPH=XNXQIWJHULFKWHWHU:LOOHGHUÄVWDDWOLFKHUVHLWV QXUDQHUNDQQW³ZLUGXQGÄVR>«@UHFKWVYHUELQGOLFK³LVW'LHVH|IIHQWOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJÄIJWGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWGLHLPJHJHQVHLWLJHQ6LFKOLHEHQVHOEVW OLHJWQXUHLQHJHZLVVH6WUHQJHKLQ]X³$OOHUGLQJVZHUGHQVLHQXQ|IIHQWOLFK DOV9HUKHLUDWHWHLGHQWLIL]LHUWZDVPLW]XVlW]OLFKHQ5HFKWHQXQG3IOLFKWHQHLQKHU JHKW'D]XJHK|UWLP)DOOHGHV=HUEUHFKHQVGHU(KHGLH5HJHOXQJGHU6FKHL GXQJLQGHUHQ9ROO]XJ9HUP|JHQVIUDJHQHEHQVR]XP7KHPDZHUGHQZLHVROFKH GHV6RUJHUHFKWV$XFK]LHOW GDV5HFKWGDUDXIGLH)UHLKHLWEHLGHU%HWHLOLJWHQ JHJHQEHUHLQDQGHU]XVLFKHUQDOVRLKUHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ $QHUNHQQXQJHLQH lXHUH)RUP]XJHEHQ1LFKWPHKUDEHUNDQQGLHVLQ.RFKV$XJHQJHZlKUOHLVWHQ DOVGLH(VNDODWLRQYRQ.RQIOLNWHQ]XYHUKLQGHUQZlKUHQGGDUEHUKLQDXVJHKHQ GH9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQHEHQ6DFKHGHV(LQ]HOQHQVLQG'LHVHU0|JOLFKNHLWHQDEHU EHJLEWVLFKYROOVWlQGLJZHUDXIGLH|IIHQWOLFKH(KHVFKOLHXQJYHU]LFKWHWZDV DEHUVWDDWOLFKHUVHLWV]XDN]HSWLHUHQLVW'RFKZLUGVLFKGDVIUGLH(KHJUXQGOH JHQGHÄJHJHQVHLWLJH9HUWUDXWVHLQ>«@LQGHU*HJHQZDUWQLFKW]XIlOOLJXQGYLHO OHLFKWVRJDU]XHUVWGDULQEHNXQGHQGDGLHEHLGHQGLHJlQJLJJHZRUGHQH6FKHX YRUGHU5HFKWVJHVWDOWGHU(KHEHUZLQGHQ³'DVVGLH(KHOHXWHLKUHYHUELQGOLFK
(EG .2&+ E .2&+L .2&+ 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ '(56 EI LII .2&+L .2&+ E .2&+ .2&+ E
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JHZROOWHQ9HUEXQGHQKHLW|IIHQWOLFK$XVGUXFNYHUOHLKHQXQGGDPLWÄGLH5HFKWV IRUPGHU(KHIULKUH(KHDN]HSWLHUHQXQGEHZXW>«@HLQJHKHQ³OHJWVLFK IU .RFK DXV FKULVWOLFKHU 6LFKW QDKH ZHLO GDPLW GLH 9RUEHKDOWVORVLJNHLW GHV JHPHLQVDPHQ/HEHQVREMHNWLY]XP$XVGUXFNJHEUDFKWZLUG'DVVGLHVJHOLQJW DEHUEOHLEWZLHGHUXPHLQ6DFKHGHV9HUWUDXHQVGDVVLFKDEHUÄDXI*RWWXQG GDPLWDXIGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWJHPHLQVDPHU/LHEH³]XJUQGHQYHUPDJ :LUWVFKDIW =ZLVFKHQ(LJHQQXW]XQG*HPHLQVLQQ ,QVHLQHUÄNOHLQH>Q@(WKLN³GLHDQKDQGGHU=HKQ*HERWHYHUVFKLHGHQH/HEHQVEH UHLFKHDXIGDVÄZDVVHLQXQGJHWDQZHUGHQVROOXQGZDVQLFKW³KLQGXUFK OHXFKWHWQLPPW.RFKDXFKGLH|NRQRPLVFKH6SKlUHLQV9LVLHUÄ'XVROOVWQLFKW VWHKOHQ³GDVVLHEWH*HERWELOGHWGRUWGHQELEOLVFKHQ$XVJDQJVSXQNWHLQHUZLUW VFKDIWVHWKLVFKHQ%HWUDFKWXQJGLHVLFKXPGDV7KHPDGHV(LJHQWXPVJUXSSLHUW 6HLQHQ5HIOH[LRQHQVWHOOW.RFKHLQHDOOJHPHLQH$QPHUNXQJYRUDQGLHHQWJHJHQ SHUVH|NRQRPLHNULWLVFKHU0RUDOLVPHQHLQVFKlUIWÄGDGDVÃ0DFKHQµXQGÃ9HU IJHQµQLFKWLQMHGHP=XVDPPHQKDQJYHUZHUIOLFKVLQG³9LHOPHKUIROJWGLH /HJLWLPLWlWVROFKLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU+DQGOXQJVYROO]JHLQ%H]XJDXI'LQJHXQG 6DFKHQDXVGHPPRGHUQHQ*UXQGUHFKWDXI(LJHQWXPZLHHVHWZDGXUFK$UW **YHUIDVVXQJVPlLJJDUDQWLHUWLVW'LHVVWHKWLQHQJVWHP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLW GHQJUXQGOHJHQGHQ)UHLKHLWVUHFKWHQGLHXQJH]ZXQJHQH6HOEVWHQWIDOWXQJXQG N|USHUOLFKH8QYHUVHKUWKHLWJHZlKUOHLVWHQ $UW** 'DGXUFKDEHUZLUGIU .RFKQXU]XP*HVHW]HUKREHQZDVSULQ]LSLHOOJLOW GDVV)UHLKHLWVLFK]XP$XV GUXFNEULQJHQPXVVZHQQVLHQLFKWEORDEVWUDNWH0|JOLFKNHLWVHLQVROO0LW +HJHOYHUVWHKWHUÄ(LJHQWXPDOVHOHPHQWDUHbXHUXQJGHU)UHLKHLW³GLHHLQHQ 0HQVFKHQDOOHUHUVW]XUÄVHOEVWlQGLJHQ3HUVRQ³PDFKW,QGHPGLHVHUVLFKHLQHU 6DFKHEHPlFKWLJWXQGEHUVLHYHUIJWEHUVFKUHLWHWHUQLFKWDOOHLQGLH$XHQ JUHQ]HQVHLQHVQXUIROJHZLGULJDXIV,QQHUOLFKH]XEHVFKUlQNHQGHQXQHQGOLFKHQ 6HOEVWVHLQV=XJOHLFKHUKHEWHUVRIU$QGHUHHUNHQQEDUGHQ$QVSUXFKDXVVLFK KHUDXVGD]XVHLQÄ)UHLKHLWGLHLP(LJHQWXPVLFKGDUVWHOOW>«@LVWGLH:LOONU IUHLKHLWEHOLHELJHQ9HUIJHQVLVW+HUUVFKDIWEHU'LQJH³DXIGLHLGHDOLWHUVRQVW QLHPDQG=XJULIIKDWXQGGXUFKGHUHQH[NOXVLYHQ*HEUDXFKGLH$XWRQRPLHGHV (LQ]HOQHQJOHLFKVDPPDQLIHVWZLUG 'DVVGLH*UHQ]H]ZLVFKHQÄ0HLQXQG
.2&+ I .2&+ E .2&+ E $D2I 9JODXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH $D2I $D2(VIHKOWHLQH[SOL]LWHU9HUZHLVDXI+HJHOGHVVHQ9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJYRQ )UHLKHLWXQG(LJHQWXPKLHUDEHUGHXWOLFKLP+LQWHUJUXQGVWHKW9JODXFKIUGLHIROJHQGHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ]XP(LJHQWXPVEHJULII %$5786&+$7 ± 5,77(5 +(*(/ > @±>±@ .2&+ EI
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
'HLQ³QLFKWYHUOHW]WZLUGYHUVWHKWVLFKNHLQHVZHJVYRQVHOEVW Ä1XUNUDIWGHU $QHUNHQQXQJDOV*OLHGHLQHU5HFKWVJHPHLQVFKDIWKDWHLQ0HQVFK(LJHQWXPXQG LVWHUGDGXUFKLQGHUgIIHQWOLFKNHLWHLQHVHOEVWlQGLJH3HUVRQ³'HUDOOJHPHLQHQ *HZlKUOHLVWXQJIUHLHQ+DEHQVXQG9HUIJHQVHLJQHWLQ.RFKV$XJHQDEHUHLQ HNODWDQWHU:LGHUVSUXFKGHUIUGHQZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ%HUHLFKLQVJHVDPWFKDUDN WHULVWLVFKLVW Ä(LJHQWXPZlUHQLFKWRKQHGDV5HFKWGHU5HFKWVJHPHLQVFKDIWHV EHUXKWVRJDUGDUDXI±XQGHVVFKOLHWGRFKGLH$QGHUHQDXV³'DULQGDVVGHU (LQ]HOQHSHUVR]LDOHU=XJHK|ULJNHLWDOVVHOEVWlQGLJH3HUVRQDQHUNDQQWLVWVWHFNW DOVRGLH.RQ]HVVLRQVLFKZHQLJVWHQVLQ%H]XJDXIGDVZDVLKPJHK|UWZLOONU OLFKVHOEVWEH]RJHQXQGUFNVLFKWVORV]XYHUKDOWHQ'LHVH(LQVFKUlQNXQJLQGLYL GXHOOHU9HUIJXQJVJHZDOWDXIGDV(LJHQHZLUGGXUFKGLHUHFKWOLFKH=XVLFKHUXQJ MHGRFKQLFKWJHZlKUOHLVWHW:LH.RFKHLQVFKlUIWNHQQWÄGLH:LOONUIUHLKHLW>«@ DQVLFKNHLQH*UHQ]H³XQGOlXIWWHQGHQ]LHOO*HIDKUVLFK]XPHJRLVWLVFKHQÄ9HU IJHQEHUGLHDQGHUH3HUVRQ³DXI]XVSUHL]HQÄGDVGLHVHXPLKU(LJHQHVEULQJW GLHVHVLFKDQ]XSDVVHQVXFKW³ $XIGDV|NRQRPLVFKH0DUNWJHVFKHKHQEHUWUDJHQVWHOOWVLFKGLHDP(LJHQ WXPVEHJULIIQDPKDIWJHPDFKWH:LGHUVSUFKOLFKNHLWZLHIROJWGDU 7HLOQHKPHQ NDQQQXUZHUEHU(LJHQWXPYHUIJWXQGZLOONUOLFKPLWLKPXPJHKHQHVÄWDX VFKHQXQGYHUNDXIHQXQGGDIUDQGHUHVNDXIHQNDQQ³'LHVJHVFKLHKWYHUPLW WHOVGHV*HOGHVGDVGDV(LJHQWXPEHZHJOLFKZHUGHQOlVVW'DVVHVEHLPZLUW VFKDIWOLFKHQ8PJDQJPLWGHP(LJHQWXPVWHWVXP*HZLQQPD[LPLHUXQJJHKWZDV ]XHLQHUÄVWUXNWXUHOOH>Q@5FNVLFKWVORVLJNHLW³JHJHQEHUGHQ$QGHUHQIKUWGLH DOV*HJQHULP.RQNXUUHQ]JHVFKHKHQGHV0DUNWHVHUVFKHLQHQLVW.RFK]XIROJH ÄQLFKWVRJOHLFK]XWDGHOQ³:UGHGHU(LQ]HOQHGHQ9HUOXVWVHLQHV(LJHQWXPV LQWHQGLHUHQEUlFKWHHUVLFKOHW]WHQ(QGHVXPVHLQH)UHLKHLWXPGLH0|JOLFKNHLW EHUKDXSWXQDEKlQJLJYRQ$QGHUHQ]XDJLHUHQ=XJOHLFKJHIlKUGHWHHLQ9HU]LFKW DXIÄ(LJHQLQLWLDWLYHXQG/HLVWXQJ>«@GLH%DVLVGHVlXHUHQ/HEHQV³DOOHUGHV VHQ6LFKHUVWHOOXQJGXUFKGLHJHVDPWJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH)XQNWLRQGHUÄ:LUWVFKDIW PLW LKUHU 3URGXNWLRQ YRQ *WHUQ³ LVW 'DV 0DUNWJHVFKHKHQ FKDUDNWHULVLHUW .RFKDOVHLQÄIUHLHV6SLHOGHU.UlIWH³GHVVHQ:LOONUOLFKNHLWQXUGXUFKGLH0H FKDQLVPHQGHV0DUNWHV$QJHERWXQG1DFKIUDJH*HZLQQXQG9HUOXVWEHJUHQ]W ZLUG$QVRQVWHQKHUUVFKWGRUWÄZDVDQVLFKVHOEVWGDV5HFKWJDUQLFKWNHQQW ZDVVRJDUGLHUHFKWOLFKH*UHQ]HDP5HFKWGHV$QGHUHQVWlQGLJ]XEHUUHQQHQ VXFKW³-HGRFKKlQJWVHLQ)XQNWLRQLHUHQYRQUHFKWOLFKHQ5HJHOXQJHQDEGLH
$D2 (EG $D2 $D2 $D2 (EG (EG (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
HWZDGDV6FKOLHHQYRQIUDOOHJHOWHQGHQ9HUWUlJHQHUP|JOLFKHQ(VJLEWDOVR DXIGHP0DUNWNHLQHXQEHJUHQ]WHIUHLH:LOONUVRQGHUQDXFKKLHUGLH*UHQ]HQ GHV5HFKWVGLHEHUKDXSWHLQH(UZDUWXQJVVLFKHUKHLWJDUDQWLHUHQ=XJOHLFKDEHU VFKLHWGHUQRWZHQGLJH(JRLVPXVGHV*HZLQQHU]LHOXQJVLQWHUHVVHVWHQGHQ]LHOO EHUGDV5HFKWGHV$QGHUHQKLQDXVGHPQLFKWVJHJ|QQWZLUGZDV]XPHLJHQHQ 1DFKWHLOJHUHLFKWHÄ'DV0LWHLQDQGHUGHV0DUNWHVLVWHLQ*HJHQHLQDQGHU³ LQ GHPMHGHURKQH5FNVLFKW]XQHKPHQGDV6HLQHVXFKW(UÄNHQQWVHOEVWNHLQH VR]LDOH*HUHFKWLJNHLW³DXIGHUVHLQ)XQNWLRQLHUHQDEHUDXIEDXW 'LHLP5HFKWDXI(LJHQWXPDXVJHVSURFKHQH$QHUNHQQXQJDOVVHOEVWlQGLJH 3HUVRQHQWKlOWDOVRGDV3RWHQ]LDOHLQHPVR]LDOIHLQGOLFKHQ(JRLVPXVGHQ%RGHQ ]X EHUHLWHQ GHU VLFK JHJHQ VHLQH HLJHQHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ ULFKWHW 'DUDXV ]LHKW .RFKDEHUHEHQQLFKWGLH.RQVHTXHQ]HLQH$EVFKDIIXQJGHV(LJHQWXPV]XHPS IHKOHQ 'DVÄÃ+DEHQµXQGÃ+DEHQ:ROOHQµ>«@YRQ6DFKHQXQG'LQJHQ>«@ PXQLFKWHJRLVWLVFK $QGHUHVFKlGLJHQGVHLQ³ ZHQQHVLP]XJHVSURFKHQHQ 5DKPHQ EOHLEW (LQ VWDDWOLFKNRQWUROOLHUWHU .ROOHNWLYLVPXV LQGHV NlPH QXU HLQHU3UREOHPYHUODJHUXQJJOHLFKZUGHGRFKGDQQGLH6WDDWVPDFKWEHUGDV (LJHQHXQGGDPLWGLH)UHLKHLWGHU%UJHU]XYHUIJHQYHUVXFKHQ'DVVGHU (LQ]HOQHZLHHUDOV(LJHQWPHUDQHUNDQQWLVWDXFKGHQ$QGHUHQHWZDV(LJHQHV ]XJHVWHKWXQGVLHGDPLWDOVVHOEVWlQGLJHYRQLKPXQWHUVFKLHGHQH3HUVRQHQUHV SHNWLHUWIROJWQLFKWYRQVHOEVWDOVÄHWKLVFKH)RUGHUXQJ>«@DXVGHU5HFKWVRUG QXQJ³,Q.RFKV$XJHQ IROJWGHU$SHOO]XUH]LSURNHP9HUKDOWHQÄDXVGHU NULWLVFKHQ(LQVLFKWGDGDVUHFKWVVWDDWOLFKHJHVHW]WH5HFKWDXI(LJHQWXPZLUN OLFK5HFKWDOVRULFKWLJXQGJXWIUGDV=XVDPPHQOHEHQGHU0HQVFKHQ±ZDKUHV 5HFKW±LVW³:HUGLHVLQGLYLGXHOOHLQVLHKWZHLVLFKDXFKYHUSIOLFKWHWGDV Ä5HFKWGHV=XVDPPHQOHEHQV>«@VHOEVW]XZROOHQ³XQGLQVHLQHU/HEHQVSUD[LV ]XYHUDQWZRUWHQ-HGRFKLVWGLHVH(LQVLFKWHEHQNHLQHGLUHNWH)ROJHGHU$QHU NHQQXQJDOV3HUVRQVRQGHUQYRQGLHVHUIUHL]XYROO]LHKHQZRUDXVGLHEHVDJWH 6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHUVR]LDOHQ=XVLFKHUXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWVUlXPHQXQGLKUHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ1XW]XQJUHVXOWLHUW 'DVVQDFKGHP*HVHW]GHV0DUNWHV]ZLVFKHQ=DKOXQJVIlKLJHQXQGXQIlKLJHQ XQWHUVFKLHGHQZLUGQDFKGHP0RWWRÄZHUQLFKWVKDWJHKWOHHUDXV³LVWIU .RFK DXIJUXQG GHV HQJHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHV YRQ )UHLKHLW XQG (LJHQWXP QLFKW ]X DN]HSWLHUHQÄ'LHVHU:LGHUVSUXFK>«@>ZUGH@VLFKVHOEVWEHUODVVHQ>«@GDV
9JODD2 (EG (EG $D2 9JODD2 $D2 $D2I $D2 $D2
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
5HFKWXQGGDPLWDXFKGLH:LUWVFKDIWXQGGLH*HVHOOVFKDIW]XJUXQGHULFKWHQ³ 'HVKDOESOlGLHUWHUIUHLQHVR]LDOH0DUNWZLUWVFKDIWXQGHLQHQVR]LDOHQ5HFKWV VWDDWZHLOQXUGXUFKHLQHJHUHJHOWH8PYHUWHLOXQJGDIUJHVRUJWZHUGHQNDQQ GDVVMHGHUHWZDV(LJHQHVKDWZRUEHUHUYHUIJHQNDQQ $QGHUVDEHUN|QQWH DXFKQLHPDQGDQGHU0DUNWZLUWVFKDIWWHLOKDEHQGLHJHQDXGDUDXIDXIEDXWXQG VRQVWNHLQHIUHLHZlUHZHQQGHU=XJDQJ]XLKUQLFKWDOOHQJOHLFKHUPDHQJH|II QHWZlUH'LHVDEHUOlXIWGHUUHFKWOLFKHLQJHUlXPWHQ:LOONUIUHLKHLWGHV0DUNWHV ]XZLGHUXQGPDFKWVLH]XJOHLFKP|JOLFKZREHLDXFKQXUYHUWHLOWZHUGHQNDQQ ÄZDV]XYRUDP0DUNWHUZLUWVFKDIWHW³ ZXUGHÄ'DV)UHLKHLWVUHFKWDXI(LJHQWXP LVWDOVRHLQ5HFKWLQQHUKDOEGHVVR]LDOHQ5HFKWVVWDDWHV³XQGRKQHLKQQLFKWUHDOL VLHUEDUZRUDXV.RFKÄGDVUHFKWVVWDDWOLFKH(UIRUGHUQLVVR]LDOVWDDWOLFKHU/HLVWXQ JHQ³OHJLWLPLHUWVLHKW6RVHKUHVDEHUXPGHU)UHLKHLWZLOOHQ$XIJDEHGHV 6WDDWHVLVWÄGLHÃ8QJHUHFKWLJNHLWHQµDXIJUXQGGHV(LJHQWXPVUHFKWVXQGVHLQHU :LOONUOLFKNHLWDE]XVFKZlFKHQ³VRZHQLJNDQQHUÄGLH8UVDFKHGLHVHU8QJH UHFKWLJNHLWGHQ:LGHUVSUXFKLP(LJHQWXPVUHFKWDOV5HFKWDOOHUXQGGLHDXVGHU $XVEXQJGHV(LJHQWXPVUHFKWVIROJHQGHQ0DUNWJHVHW]OLFKNHLWHQHWZDGLHGHQ .RQNXUUHQWHQYHUGUlQJHQGH0DUNWPDFKW³]XP9HUVFKZLQGHQEULQJHQ'LH 8QDXIO|VOLFKNHLWGLHVHV:LGHUVSUXFKVLVWLQ.RFKV$XJHQQXU]XP6FKDGHQGHV 5HFKWVDXI(LJHQWXPXQGVRGHU)UHLKHLWDXIGHUHLQHQXQGGHU6XEVLVWHQ]GHV 6WDDWHVDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHDXV]XEOHQGHQ6RZLHHUDXFKÄQLFKWYHUKLQGHUQ >NDQQ@GDHV0HQVFKHQJLEWGLHDXI.RVWHQ$QGHUHUJDUQLFKWDUEHLWHQZRO OHQ³*OHLFKKHLWVLGHDOHVLQGQXUGXUFKVHW]EDUXQWHU,QNDXIQDKPHYRQ8QIUHL KHLW:HUGLH)UHLKHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQDQHUNHQQWPXVVKLQJHJHQGLHGDUDXVVLFK HUJHEHQGHQ$V\PPHWULHQLPVR]LDOHQ/HEHQDN]HSWLHUHQGLHLPPHUQXUDQQlKH UXQJVZHLVHDXVJOHLFKEDUVLQG .RFKPDFKWDEHUGHXWOLFKGDVVDXVGHUUHFKWOLFKHQ*DUDQWLHIUHLEHUGDV(L JHQWXP]XYHUIJHQDXFKGLH0|JOLFKNHLWIROJWDXIHV]XYHU]LFKWHQÄ:DVPDQ KDWGDVPXPDQQLFKWEHVLW]HQ³ZHQQGHQQGDV9HUKlOWQLVGD]XHLQHVGHU)UHL KHLWVHLQVROO)UHLKHLW]HLJWVLFKDOVRQLFKWQXULQGHU9HUIJXQJEHUGDV(L JHQWXPVRQGHUQDXFKLP1LFKW)HVWJHOHJWVHLQDXIGDVZDVPDQKDW:HUQLFKWV KDWOHEWWURW]GHPRIIHQVLFKWOLFKYRQDQGHUHQÄ6HOEVWJHZlKOWH$UPXW>«@LVW RKQHLQQHUHQ:LGHUVSUXFKQLFKW]XUHDOLVLHUHQ³ZHLOPDQLQLKUÄSDUDVLWlUYRP %HVLW]$QGHUHU³OHEW-HVXVHOEVWJHZlKOWH%HVLW]ORVLJNHLW9RUELOGIUYHU VFKLHGHQH/HEHQVIRUPHQLP/DXIHGHU.LUFKHQJHVFKLFKWHLVWODXW.RFKNHLQH QRUPDWLYH$QZHLVXQJVRQGHUQÄGHU%HZHLVGDPDQDOV(LQ]HOQHUYRP%HVLW
(EG 9JODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ $D2± $D2 $D2I $D2 (EG $D2 (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
]HQIUHLVHLQGDPDQOHEHQNDQQRKQHVLFKDQGDV9HUJlQJOLFKH]XYHUOLH UHQ³'DYRQOlVVWVLFKGHUMHQLJHEHZHJHQGHUÄLQHLQHPJHLVWLJLQQHUOLFKHQ 6LQQHVHOEVWÃEHZHJOLFKµLP%OLFNDXIVHLQ(LJHQWXPZLUG >«@VLFKLQVHLQHP +DEHQ:ROOHQVHOEVWHLQVFKUlQNW³.RFKVLHKWGRUWÄGLH'LPHQVLRQGHV*HLV WHV³GK*RWWHVVLFKDXIWXQZR0HQVFKHQVLFKGHUDUWYRP(LJHQWXPYRP +DEHQXQG9HUIJHQHPDQ]LSLHUHQ'DVVMHPDQGDOOH1W]OLFKNHLWVHUZlJXQJHQ XQG.DONXODWLRQHQVHLQOlVVWNDQQDEHUDXIGHP+LQWHUJUXQGYRQGHUHQ]XYRU JHVFKLOGHUWHU:LFKWLJNHLWQLHHLQGDXHUKDIWHU=XVWDQGVHLQ9LHOPHKUVLQGGDPLW (UIDKUXQJHQJHPHLQWLQGHQHQVLFK]ZDQJORVH*HPHLQVDPNHLWHLQVWHOOWGLHGHQ (LQ]HOQHQEHUVHLQ(LJHQHVKLQDXVJHKHQOlVVW GDV%HZXVVWZHUGHQYRQ:DKU KHLWGLHUHFKWYHUVWDQGHQNHLQHP0HQVFKHQ]XJHK|UWZHLOQLHPDQGGDV9HUVWH KHQGHV$QGHUHQVWHXHUQNDQQRGHUGLH(UIDKUXQJYRQ/LHEHLQGHUÄHVNHLQ 0HLQXQG'HLQVRQGHUQQXUHLQHQG*HPHLQVDPHV³JLEWXQGGLHVLFKLP]ZHFN IUHLHQ*HEHQXQG1HKPHQHUQHXHUW 6WDDWXQG3ROLWLN =ZLVFKHQ(UP|JOLFKXQJXQG=ZDQJ ,QGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XP5HFKWXQG]XU:LUWVFKDIWLVWGLH(EHQHGHV6WDDWHV EHUHLWVPHKUIDFKDQJHVSURFKHQZRUGHQ'LHVHQVLHKW.RFKXQWHUPRGHUQHQ%H GLQJXQJHQGXUFKHLQHÄLPPDQHQWH$QWLWKHWLN³ JHSUlJW (LQHUVHLWVLVWHVVHLQ ]HQWUDOHV=LHODOOHQ%UJHUQJOHLFKHUPDHQHLQVHOEVWEHVWLPPWHV/HEHQ]XHU P|JOLFKHQDQGHUHUVHLWVVHW]WHUGDIULPPHUDXFK=ZDQJVPLWWHOHLQ Ä>1@LFKW QXUGXUFKGLH5HFKWVRUGQXQJ³GHUHQQRUPDWLYHU*UXQGLQGHUXQEHGLQJWHQ)UHL KHLWGHV,QGLYLGXXPVGKLQGHU0HQVFKHQZUGHOLHJWÄVRQGHUQHEHQ>«@ ]XJOHLFKGXUFK+HUUVFKDIWXQG0DFKW³]HLJWVLFKVWDDWOLFKHV+DQGHOQGHPQDFK GHILQLHUW :HOFKH.RQIOLNWHDXVGLHVHP:LGHUVSUXFKXQXPJlQJOLFKHUZDFK VHQ]HLJW.RFKDQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ.RQVWHOODWLRQHQDXI 'HUIUGHQPRGHUQHQ5HFKWVVWDDWFKDUDNWHULVWLVFKH.RQIOLNWPDQLIHVWLHUWVLFK HUVWHQVDOV6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ)UHLKHLWXQG6LFKHUKHLW:LH.RFKHLQVFKlUIW EHGHXWHWGLHYHUIDVVXQJVPlLJH$QHUNHQQXQJLQGLYLGXHOOHU$XWRQRPLHQLFKW GHUHQ+HUYRUEULQJXQJ 9LHOPHKUZLUGGLHVHGDGXUFKQXUÄLQLKUHHLJHQHYRU XQGEHUVWDDWOLFKH*OWLJNHLWHLQXQGIUHLJHVHW]W³ VRGDVVVLHGLH*UHQ]HDOOHU SROLWLVFKUHFKWOLFKHQ$NWLYLWlWHQELOGHW'LHÄ*HZLVVHQVXQG*HVLQQXQJVIUHL KHLW³ DXI GLH GLH Ä5HVSHNWLHUXQJ GHU 0HQVFKHQZUGH³ ]LHOW LVW DOVR HLQH
$D2I 9JO]XGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQGDUEHU $D2± $D2 (EG .2&+ E 9JOGD]X DD2± F± .2&+ E 9JODXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2I $D2
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
ÄUHFKWVVWDDWOLFKHLQJHUlXPWH>@XQG]XJOHLFKGLHVHP6WDDWJHERWHQH>@³ $QJHOH JHQKHLW*HQDXDXVGLHVHP=XJOHLFKDEHUUHVXOWLHUWGLHEHVDJWH6SDQQXQJ6R ZlUHRKQHGDVVHVIUDOOHJHOWHQGHV5HFKWLVWDOVVHOEVWEHVWLPPWH,QGLYLGXHQ DQHUNDQQW]XVHLQHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH/HEHQVSUD[LVXQP|JOLFK-HGHUPVVWH IUFKWHQGXUFKGLH$QGHUHQEHUYRUWHLOW]XZHUGHQXQGQLHPDQGN|QQWHVLFK VLFKHU VHLQ GDVV LKP GDV 6HLQH ]XJHVWDQGHQ ZLUG 1XU ZR 5HFKWVVLFKHUKHLW KHUUVFKWNDQQLQ.RFKV$XJHQYRQGHQVR]LDOHQ$NWHXUHQ ZHFKVHOVHLWLJGLH $QHUNHQQXQJLKUHVIUHLHQ3HUVRQVHLQVHUZDUWHWZHUGHQ'DQQQlPOLFKJLEWHV HLQHÄ0DFKWGLH>«@QRWIDOOV]XHU]ZLQJHQYHUPDJ³ ZDVVHLWHQVGHU(LQ]HO QHQ]XWXQYHUZHLJHUWZLUG'HVVHQ)UHLKHLWVDXVEXQJVW|WLP)DOOHGHV.RQ IOLNWVPLWGHU)UHLKHLWVDXVEXQJ$QGHUHUVHOEVWDQHLQH*UHQ]HGLHGXUFKGDV VWDDWOLFKJHVHW]WH5HFKWPDUNLHUWZLUG2EJOHLFKGHU(LQVDW]YRQ*HZDOWÄJUXQG VlW]OLFKLPPHUUHFKWVYHUQHLQHQG³LVWPXVVDQGLHVHU6WHOOHÄGDVDQVLFKUHFKWV ZLGULJH0LWWHOÃ*HZDOWµGHP=ZHFNGHV5HFKWVGLHQVWEDUJHPDFKW³ZHUGHQ 8P)UHLKHLW]XVLFKHUQNRPPHQ6DQNWLRQVPDQDKPHQ]XP=XJHGLH]XJOHLFK YRQIUHLKHLWVEHUDXEHQGHU$UWVLQG)U.RFKLVWGLHVHU:LGHUVSUXFKXQXPJlQJ OLFKZHLODQWKURSRORJLVFKEHJUQGHW Ä(UGHU0HQVFKLVWGDV6XEMHNWGHVVHQ )UHLKHLWMHGHU]HLWLQGDV%|VHGDV/HEHQV]HUVW|UHULVFKHXPVFKODJHQNDQQ³ 'HU:LOONU&KDUDNWHUGHU)UHLKHLWOlVVWMHGHQ9HUVXFKVLHUHFKWVVWDDWOLFKYROO NRPPHQDE]XVLFKHUQLOOXVRULVFKHUVFKHLQHQMDSURGX]LHUWQXUQHXH8QIUHLKHLW $OOHGLHVHP=LHOYHUSIOLFKWHWHQ*HVHW]HVLQGGHVKDOEVWHWVQXUUHODWLYH$QQlKH UXQJHQXQGIXQJLHUHQDOVÄ:LOONU5HJHOXQJVUHFKWRGHU6FKOLFKWXQJVUHFKWDQJH VLFKWVLPPHUQHXDXIEUHFKHQGHU'LVVHQVHXQG,QNRPSDWLELOLWlWHQ³ 'DVGDEHL YHUIROJWH$QOLHJHQÄGLHIUHLH9HUZLUNOLFKXQJGHU)UHLKHLWGHUHLQ]HOQHQLQGHU *HPHLQVFKDIW]XHUP|JOLFKHQ³ OlVVWVLFKSROLWLVFKHEHQDXVVFKOLHOLFKLP 0RGXVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJUHDOLVLHUHQ9RQVHLWHQGHV6WDDWHVN|QQHQGHPQDFK ]ZDUGXUFKlXHUHV5DKPHQVHW]HQ&KDQFHQDXWRQRPHU/HEHQVJHVWDOWXQJHLQJH UlXPWZHUGHQ'RFKLVWGHUHQMHLQGLYLGXHOOH:DKUQHKPXQJQLFKWYHUIJEDU VRQGHUQ 6DFKH GHU )UHLKHLWÄ:DV GLH 0LWJOLHGHU HLQHV 6WDDWHV YRP 6WDDW ]X 5HFKWHUZDUWHQN|QQHQQlPOLFK6FKXW]JHJHQ*HZDOWGDVN|QQHQVLHYRQLKP QXUHUZDUWHQZHQQVLHVHOEVWDXIMHGH6HOEVWGXUFKVHW]XQJPLWWHOV*HZDOWYHU ]LFKWHQ³'LHVDEHU]HLJWLQ.RFKV$XJHQQXUÄZLHHOHPHQWDUGHU5HFKWVVWDDW VHLQHUVHLWVDQJHZLHVHQLVWDXIGLHUHFKWOLFKH*HVLQQXQJVHLQHU%UJHULQQHQXQG %UJHUVHOEVWGDV5HFKW]XZROOHQXQGGDV8QUHFKW]XPHLGHQ³'DULQOLHJW
(EG $D2 $D2I $D2 9JO.2&+P (EG 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH .2&+QII .2&+ EI $D2
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
HLQH$PELYDOHQ]ZHLOGHP6WDDWGLH'LPHQVLRQGHV*HZLVVHQVYHUVFKORVVHQLVW NDQQHUÄGLHVHJHQHUHOOH=XVWLPPXQJGXUFKQLFKWVHU]ZLQJHQ(UPXVLFKDXI VLHYHUODVVHQ³6LHOlVVWVLFKQLFKWEHIHKOHQREJOHLFKGDVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH =XVDPPHQOHEHQDXIGLH3UD[LVVROFKHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJIXQGDPHQ WDODQJHZLHVHQLVW:RUHFKWOLFKH6DQNWLRQVJHZDOWLQV6SLHONRPPHQPXVVWULWW JHUDGH GLH GLHVEH]JOLFKH 8QHLQVLFKWLJNHLW GHV (LQ]HOQHQ YRU $XJHQ 'DVV 6WUDIPDQDKPHQ]XHLQHP8PGHQNHQGHV7lWHUV]XU(LQVLFKWLQGLH9HUZHUI OLFKNHLWVHLQHV9HUJHKHQVIKUHQOlVVWVLFKZLHGHUXPQLFKWJDUDQWLHUHQZHLOHU GLHVÄQXULQIUHLHU(LQVLFKWVHOEVWWXQ³NDQQ.RFKIDVVW]XVDPPHQ Ä(WZDV bXHUHVOlWVLFKHU]ZLQJHQHWZDV,QQHUOLFKHVQLH³'LH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ GHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOOHU%UJHUDOVVHOEVWEHVWLPPWH,QGLYLGXHQXQGGHUHQ:DKU QHKPXQJGLHVHV6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVUHFKWVGKÄZLHVLHHVPLW,QKDOWHQIOOHQ XQG VR SUDNWL]LHUHQ³ OlVVW VLFK LQ .RFKV $XJHQ YRQVHLWHQ GHV 6WDDWHV QLFKW EHUZLQGHQ(UNDQQHLQ(KHUHFKWVFKDIIHQDEHUQLFKWEHVWLPPHQZLHGLH (KHQJHIKUWZHUGHQ 'HUIUGHQPRGHUQHQ5HFKWVVWDDWFKDUDNWHULVWLVFKH.RQIOLNW]ZLVFKHQ)UHL KHLWXQG0DFKWOlVVWVLFK]ZHLWHQVDQKDQGGHV3UREOHPVGHU*OHLFKKHLWYRU$X JHQIKUHQ'LHVHVUFNWHDOVSROLWLVFKUHFKWOLFKHV7KHPDDOOHUHUVWPLWGHU)UDQ ]|VLVFKHQ5HYROXWLRQLQV=HQWUXPGLHHLQHQÄ.DPSIXPGLH*OHLFKKHLWL6 HLQHU*OHLFKVWHOOXQJXQGJHJHQMHGHÃGLVNULPLQLHUHQGHµ5DQJ8QJOHLFKKHLW³LQ *DQJJHVHW]WKDW)U.RFKLVWHVDEHUHLQHELV]XPKHXWLJHQ7DJHRIIHQH )UDJHZLHGLHGDPLWDYLVLHUWH(JDOLWlW]XYHUVWHKHQLVW'LHEHLGHQSROLWLVFKHQ ([WUHPSRVLWLRQHQMHGHQIDOOVZHLVHQDXIHLQHLKULQQHZRKQHQGH6SDQQXQJKLQ $XIGHUHLQHQ6HLWHVWHKWGDVOLEHUDOLVWLVFKH.RQ]HSWHLQHUÄ*OHLFKKHLW>«@YRU GHP*HVHW]³GHU]XIROJHGHU6WDDWGDVDOOHQ0HQVFKHQYRQ+DXVHDXVHLJQHQ GH)UHLKHLWVYHUP|JHQXQGGDPLWLKUH(LJHQLQLWLDWLYH]XI|UGHUQKDEH'HPJH JHQEHU YHUVXFKW PDQ DXI GHU DQGHUHQ 6HLWH Ä*OHLFKKHLW >«@ GXUFK GDV *H VHW]³ GKSHUVR]LDOVWDDWOLFKHU,QLWLDWLYH]XHWDEOLHUHQ:lKUHQGOHW]WHUH6LFKW JHJHQGHQ/LEHUDOLVPXVYRUEULQJWHUUHGHHLQHUDQJHVLFKWVGHU|NRQRPLVFKHQ :LUNOLFKNHLWEORILNWLYHQ)UHLKHLWGDV:RUWJLEWGLHVHUGHQ6R]LDOVWDDWVEHIU ZRUWHUQ]XYHUVWHKHQGDVVMHGHLKUHU0DQDKPHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJHLQVFKUlQ NHXQGZLHGHUXP8QJOHLFKKHLWSURGX]LHUH.RFKVFKOlJWVLFKDXINHLQHGHUEHL GHQ6HLWHQVRQGHUQYHUZHLVWGDUDXIGDVVÄGLH.RPSDWLELOLWlWYRQGHPRNUDWL VFKHU3DUWL]LSDWLRQXQG5HFKWVVWDDWOLFKNHLWHLQHUVHLWVVR]LDOVWDDWOLFKHU3ODQXQJ
.2&+ .2&+T $D2 .2&+P .2&+ D9JOGLHVH7H[WVWHOOHDXFKIUGDV)ROJHQGH .2&+ F 9JOIUGLHVH(QWJHJHQVHW]XQJDXFK .2&+ ± F
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
DQGHUHUVHLWV>«@ELVKHXWHQLFKWHUZLHVHQ³LVW9LHOPHKUVLHKWHUKLHUHLQH XQDXIO|VOLFKH6SDQQXQJREZDOWHQ 6RUHVXOWLHUWGLHPDWHULHOOH8QJOHLFKKHLWGHUHQWZHJHQGHU6R]LDOVWDDWHQWVWDQ GHQLVWDXVGHUUHFKWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWVUHFKWHQE]ZGHUHQ:DKU QHKPXQJ LP |NRQRPLVFKHQ %HUHLFK 0LW GHU 0|JOLFKNHLW GLH HLJHQHQ ZLUW VFKDIWOLFKHQ,QWHUHVVHQEHOLHELJ]XYHUIROJHQVRODQJHGLH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJGHU $QGHUHQJHZDKUWEOHLEWHQWVWHKHQZHQLJVWHQVIUHLQHQ7HLOGHU%HY|ONHUXQJ 9HUKlOWQLVVH GLH LKQHQ NDXP 9HUZLUNOLFKXQJVFKDQFHQ HU|IIQHQ 'LHVH 8Q JOHLFKKHLWKHUYRUEULQJHQGHVR]LDOH'\QDPLNELOGHWGHQ(QWGHFNXQJV]XVDPPHQ KDQJIUHLQHZHLWHUH,PSOLNDWLRQGHV5HFKWV 'DPLWÄMHGH3HUVRQ>«@]XHLQHU HLJHQHQ:DKUQHKPXQJLKUHU)UHLKHLWDOV6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJ³LQGHU/DJHLVW PXVVÄDXFKIUMHGHQGLHUHDOH0|JOLFKNHLW]XU$XVEXQJVHLQHV6HOEVWVWDQGHV VHLQHU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWJHJHEHQVHLQ³(VEUDXFKWDOVRÄHLQÃ7HLOKDEHUHFKWµ >«@GDVGLHUHDOHDXFKPDWHULHOOH%DVLVIUHLQPHQVFKHQZUGLJHV/HEHQHLQHV MHGHQJDUDQWLHUW³ (QWVSUHFKHQGH6R]LDOVWDDWVLQLWLDWLYHQVLQGQXQZLH.RFKIHVWKlOWNHLQH0LW OHLGVEHNXQGXQJHQVRQGHUQEULQJHQQXUGLH$OOJHPHLQJHOWXQJGHVIUDOOHJOHLFK JOWLJHQ5HFKWV]XP7UDJHQ,KUH/HJLWLPLWlWKlQJWGLHVHULKUHU*UXQGODJHIRO JHQGVRDEHU]XJOHLFKGDUDQGDVVVLHGLHIUHLH7lWLJNHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQVLFKHUQ XQGHUP|JOLFKHQQLFKWDEHUSHU$OLPHQWDWLRQVWLOOVWHOOHQ'HQGDPLWEHVFKULHEH QHQ%DODQFHDNWEHLMHGHUSROLWLVFKHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJ QHX]XYROO]LHKHQLVW IU .RFKGLH]HQWUDOH$XIJDEHGHVGHPRNUDWLVFKHQ5HFKWVVWDDWV Ä>(@ULVWGLH,QVWL WXWLRQ]XP$XVWUDJGHV6WUHLWHV]ZLVFKHQMHQHQEHLGHQÃ(FNZHUWHQµ)UHLKHLWXQG VR]LDOHU*OHLFKKHLW³'LHVHXQDXIK|UOLFK]XOHLVWHQGH$XVJOHLFKVDUEHLWNDQQ QXU]XXQJXQVWHQGHV6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVUHFKWVEHHQGHWZHUGHQ6RULFKWHWVLFK .RFKDXVGUFNOLFKJHJHQHLQHLQVHLQHQ$XJHQPDU[LVWLVFKDQPXWHQGH$XVUX IXQJ VR]LDOHU *OHLFKKHLW ]XP 6WDDWV]LHO :R )UHLKHLW |IIHQWOLFK ]XJHVWDQGHQ ZLUGNRPPWHVYLHOPHKUVFKRQGHVKDOE]X8QJOHLFKKHLWZHLOGLH:DKUQHKPXQJ HLQJHUlXPWHU&KDQFHQLQGLYLGXHOOVHKUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKDXVIDOOHQNDQQXQGVWDDW OLFKQLHGLUHNW]XLQLWLLHUHQLVW0LWMHGHUVR]LDOSROLWLVFKHQ,QQRYDWLRQDEHUZDFK VHQGLH0DFKWEHIXJQLVVHGHV6WDDWHVDQÄREZRKOPDQGRFKJHUDGHGLHÃ$EVFKDI IXQJµYRQ+HUUVFKDIWGXUFK*OHLFKKHLWLQWHQGLHUWH³=XJOHLFKODVVHQVLFKGDEHL QLHPDOVDOOH,QWHUHVVHQEHUFNVLFKWLJHQZDV]XLPPHUQHXHQ5HJHOXQJVEHGDUIHQ IKUWXQGEHGLQJWGDVVVLFKÄGDV%HZXWVHLQVWDDWOLFKHQ8QUHFKWVIDVWJlQ]OLFK DQVHLQHP6R]LDOUHFKW³IHVWPDFKW(LQPDOPHKUDOVRVW|WVWDDWOLFKH0DFKW DQJHVLFKWVGHU|IIHQWOLFKDQHUNDQQWHQ)UHLKHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQDQLKUH*UHQ]HQ
.2&+ F .2&+ 9JOQHEHQGLHVHU6HLWHIUGDV)ROJHQGHDXFK .2&+ D .2&+ 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2± 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH .2&+ I E F EI .2&+P
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
XQGLVWEHLPXQXPJlQJOLFKHQ9HUVXFKGLHVHDXI6R]LDOYHUWUlJOLFKNHLW]XVWLP PHQYRU*UHQ]EHUVFKUHLWXQJHQQLFKWJHIHLW 'DYRQ]HXJWGULWWHQVQLFKW]XOHW]WDXFKGLH6SKlUHGHV3ROLWLVFKHQVHOEVWGLH ÄGXUFK]RJHQLVWYRQ.RQNXUUHQ]XQG.DPSI>«@XPGLH0DFKW5HFKW]XVHW ]HQ³'LHVHUDQWDJRQLVWLVFKH&KDUDNWHUGHUVLFKLP*HJHQHLQDQGHUYRQ3DU WHLHQ9HUElQGHQXQG,QWHUHVVHQJUXSSHQVSLHJHOWLVWLQ.RFKV$XJHQQLFKWSHU VHDEVFKOlJLJ]XEHXUWHLOHQ(VEUDXFKWGLHSROLWLVFKH.RQIURQWDWLRQZHLOQLH YRQYRUQKHUHLQIHVWOLHJWZDVDQJHVLFKWVNRQNUHWHU3UREOHPODJHQGDVIUDOOH 5HFKWHGDUVWHOOWXQGZLHHV]XHUUHLFKHQLVW-HGRFKHQWKlOWVLHGLH*HIDKUGDVV VLFKOHW]WHQ(QGHV3DUWLNXODULQWHUHVVHQGLUHNWLQGHU*HVHW]JHEXQJGXUFKVHW]HQ 6RJHUlWGXUFKGDVSRODULVLHUWHDXI$XVVFKDOWXQJGHV2SSRQHQWHQ]LHOHQGH*H JHQHLQDQGHUSROLWLVFKHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJHQWHQGHQ]LHOOGLH2ULHQWLHUXQJDP *HPHLQZRKODXVGHP%OLFN6HW]WVLFKHLQH6HLWHGHV0HLQXQJVVSHNWUXPVEHL GHQ:DKOHQGXUFKNDQQHV]XGHPÄGDKLQNRPPHQGD5HJLHUXQJVHQWVFKHLGXQ JHQDEJHVWW]WGXUFKGLHKHUUVFKHQGH3DUWHLRGHU3DUWHLHQNRDOLWLRQDQGLH6WHOOH SDUODPHQWDULVFKHUVWULWWHQHU*HVHW]HWUHWHQ³3ROLWLVFKH0DFKWYHUPDJGDQQ UHODWLYXQJHKLQGHUWHLQJHVHW]W]XZHUGHQXPGLHMHHLJHQH.OLHQWHO]XEHI|UGHUQ ZRJHJHQGLH2SSRVLWLRQQXUUKHWRULVFKDQNlPSIHQNDQQ%HVWDQGVJHIlKUGHQGIU GHQ5HFKWVVWDDWZLUNWVLFKGLHVZLH.RFKHLQVFKUlQNHQGGHXWOLFKPDFKWMHGRFK QXUDXVÄZHQQGHU:LOOHDOOHU]XPHQVFKHQZUGLJHQHUWUlJOLFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ IUDOOH±GHU:LOOHGHUEHUGLHEORHLJHQHQ,QWHUHVVHQKLQDXVJHKW±QDFKOlW RGHUJDUYHUVFKZLQGHW³ =XPLQGHVWDQJHOHJWLVWGLHVHVGHVWUXNWLYH3RWHQ]LDODEHULPDQWDJRQLVWLVFKHQ &KDUDNWHUGHVSROLWLVFKHQ0HLQXQJVNDPSIHVGHU]XHLQHUWHLOZHLVHQ.RUUXPSLH UXQJGHV5HFKWVIKUHQNDQQ$XVHWKLVFKHU6LFKWLVWODXW.RFKDEHUGHU:LGHU VSUXFKHLQHV+DQGHOQVKHUDXV]XVWHOOHQGDVZDVIUDOOHVROOJHOWHQN|QQHQGHU 8PVHW]XQJSDUWLNXODUHU9RUOLHEHQGLHQOLFKPDFKW6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKYHUVXFKW MHGHUSROLWLVFK7lWLJHÄHLQHQEHVWLPPWHQIULKQQRWZHQGLJHQ,QKDOW>«@DOV VHLQÃ,QWHUHVVHµGXUFK]XVHW]HQ³ 8PGLHVHV,QWHUHVVHDEHU|IIHQWOLFKJHOWHQG PDFKHQ]XN|QQHQPXVVHUVROOGLHVJHZDOWIUHLJHVFKHKHQGHVVHQ$OOJHPHLQ KHLWVIlKLJNHLWXQWHU%HZHLV]XVWHOOHQZLVVHQ:RUDQVLFKGLHVHMHNRQNUHWEH PLVVWLVWQLHYRQYRUQKHUHLQDXVJHPDFKW'LHVHLPSOL]LWH1RUPGHV3ROLWLVFKHQ LVWVWDUN]XPDFKHQXPHLQHQHXH)RUPSROLWLVFKHU3UD[LVDQ]XVWUHEHQ$OVGH UHQ&KDUDNWHULVWLNDEHQHQQW.RFKGDVVVLHÄ]XLKUHP,QKDOWGLHJHPHLQVDPHQ =ZHFNHDOOHUKDWGLHVHDOVGDV3ROLWLVFKHEHJUHLIWXQGVRGLH3ROLWLNDXVGHU$E KlQJLJNHLWYRP|NRQRPLVFKVR]LDOHQ,QWHUHVVHQNDPSIO|VW³(VZlUHGLHVHLQH 3ROLWLNIUGLHÄGHU)ULHGH>«@DOVHLQ=LHOJHKDOWEHVWLPPHQG³LVWLQGHPHQWJH
.2&+ E .2&+ E $D2 .2&+O9JOGLHVH6WHOOHDXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ .2&+
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
JHQ DQWDJRQLVWLVFKHU /DJHUELOGXQJ ÄK|KHUH )RUPHQ GHU *HPHLQVDPNHLW >«@ EHUGHQJHJHQ=XVWDQGGHU.RQIURQWDWLRQ³KLQDXVLQWHQGLHUWZHUGHQ7HLOZHL VH VLHKW .RFK GLHV LQ GHU UHFKWVVWDDWOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GHV (LQ]HOQHQ DOV JOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWHU7HLOQHKPHUDP|IIHQWOLFKHQ/HEHQEHUHLWVUHDOLVLHUWZREHL GHUHQIRUPDOHU&KDUDNWHUGLHLQKDOWOLFKH*HVWDOWXQJGHV0LWHLQDQGHUVZHLWKLQ RIIHQOlVVW'HUSURVSHNWLHUWH)ULHGHKLQJHJHQHUIOOWÄVLFKHUVWLQHLQHUQLFKWUHJ OHPHQWLHUWHQ.RPPXQLNDWLRQEHU,QKDOWHP|JOLFKHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWGLHLKUHP :HVHQQDFKNHLQHUUHFKWOLFKHQ1RUPLHUXQJ]XJlQJOLFKVLQG³ 5HOLJLRQVJHPHLQVFKDIWHQXQG.LUFKHQVLQGQHEHQDQGHUHQ]LYLOJHVHOOVFKDIWOL FKHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQLQVHLQHQ$XJHQSUlGHVWLQLHUWGDIUHLQHQVROFKHQ2UWDXI]X ELHWHQ'RUWVROOGDQQÄGLHNRPPXQLNDWLYH3UD[LV³EHKHLPDWHWVHLQÄLQGHUGLH 0HQVFKHQ >«@ LKUH (UIDKUXQJHQ DXVWDXVFKHQ JHPHLQVDPH +DQGOXQJV]LHOH HQWZLFNHOQXQGVLFKLQGHUJHJHQVHLWLJHQ9HUVWlQGLJXQJXQG$QHUNHQQXQJVHOEVW GHILQLHUHQ³'HU6WDDWDEHUVROOWHLQ.RFKV$XJHQGLH$XVELOGXQJHLQHUVRO FKHQ6SKlUHI|UGHUQXQGLKUHQ%HVWDQGVFKW]HQVHLQH(LQJULIIHDEHUDQVRQVWHQ DXIGLH(LQKHJXQJYRQGHU$OOJHPHLQKHLWVLFKYHUVFKOLHHQGHQ3DUWLNXODULQWHUHV VHQEHVFKUlQNHQ'DULQOLHJWDXFKHLQHQRWZHQGLJH6HOEVWUHODWLYLHUXQJ6WDDWHV GHVVHQXQHQWULQQEDU]ZLVFKHQ=ZDQJVJHZDOWXQG)UHLKHLWVHLQUlXPXQJFKDQJLH UHQGHU&KDUDNWHUVRDOOHUHUVWDQV/LFKWUFNWDEHU]XJOHLFKSDUWLHOO]XP*XWHQ KLQEHUVFKULWWHQZHUGHQNDQQ-HGRFKLVWZLH.RFKYHUGHXWOLFKWDXFKÄGLHGHP 6WDDW YRUDXVOLHJHQGH 6SKlUH GHV *HPHLQZHVHQV >«@ VHOEVW ZLHGHUXP GXUFK :LOONUJHIlKUGHW³6LHLVWDXFKGHU6SDQQXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ DXVJHVHW]WZLHGHUIROJHQGH$EVFKQLWW]XU.LUFKH]HLJW .LUFKH =ZLVFKHQ,QVWLWXWLRQXQG*HZLVVHQ 'DVVHUGHQ%HUHLFKGHU.LUFKHHEHQIDOOVGXUFKGDVVSDQQXQJVYROOH9HUKlOWQLV YRQLQGLYLGXHOOHU)UHLKHLWXQGVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJJHSUlJWVLHKWPDFKW.RFK DP%HLVSLHOGHU7DXIHGHXWOLFK'HUHQ|IIHQWOLFKHU9ROO]XJLPSOL]LHUWQlPOLFK LPPHUDXFKÄGLH(UNOlUXQJGHU*HPHLQGHYRQLKUHU6HLWHDXVXQYHUEUFKOLFK GLHV.LQGGLHVHQ0HQVFKHQDOVLKU]XJHK|ULJDQ]XHUNHQQHQ³'LH]HLFKHQKDIW GRNXPHQWLHUWH.LUFKHQ]XJHK|ULJNHLWGHV7lXIOLQJVKDWDEHU]XQlFKVWQXUGHQ &KDUDNWHUÄHLQH>U@YRQGLHVHU*HPHLQGHIUGHQ%HWUHIIHQGHQHLQJHUlXPWH>Q@ &KDQFH]XGLHVHU*HPHLQVFKDIW³ÄHLQH>U@]XHUNDQQWH>Q@:UGH³GLHVLFKHUVW ÄLQLKUHP6LQQHUIOOWZHQQGHU%HWUHIIHQGHVHOEVWGDVZLOO³$QGHUVJHVDJW Ä1XUZHUYRQVLFKDXVEHMDKWGDHULQGHU.LUFKHLVWGHULVWZLUNOLFKLQGHU
(EG $D2 .2&+ F YJOQHEHQGLHVHU6WHOOH]XP)ROJHQGHQDXFK '(56 D .2&+ F .2&+I (EG
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
.LUFKH 8QG GDV OHEHQVODQJ³ ,Q VROFKHP ,QVLVWLHUHQ DXI GLH XQYHUWUHWEDUH 6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQLQ*ODXEHQVIUDJHQGDVVLFKKLHUJHJHQHLQREMHN WLYLVWLVFKHV9HUVWlQGQLVGHU7DXIHDOV(LQJOLHGHUXQJLQGLH*HPHLQGH-HVX&KULV WLZHQGHWHQWGHFNW.RFKHLQSURWHVWDQWLVFKHV.HUQDQOLHJHQ'HPLVWDXFKVHLQ (LQWUHWHQIUGLH.LQGHUWDXIHYHUSIOLFKWHWPLWGHUGLH(OWHUQJHUDGH]XP$XV GUXFNEULQJHQEHUGHQ/HEHQVJDQJLKUHV1DFKZXFKVHVQLFKWOHW]WJOWLJYHUI JHQ]XN|QQHQ 6LHEHNXQGHQZLHVLHLKU.LQGVHKHQZROOHQ QlPOLFKDOVHLQHQYRQ*RWWJHZROOWHQXQGYRQ LKPKHUNRPPHQGHQXQGGDUXPXQHQGOLFKOLHEHQVZHUWHQ0HQVFKHQ>«@ZRKOZLVVHQGGD QLFKWYRUKHUVHKEDULVWZDVDXVGLHVHP.LQGHHLQPDOZHUGHQZLUG
'HQQRFKEULQJHQVLHLQGHU7DXIHLKUH+RIIQXQJDXIGDVJ|WWOLFKEHJUQGHWH *XWVHLQGLHVHVHLJHQVWlQGLJ]XIKUHQGHQ/HEHQV]XU6SUDFKHXQGJHEHQLKP GDPLWHLQHEHVWLPPWHDXFKHU]LHKHULVFKEHGHXWVDPH3HUVSHNWLYHYRU.RFKVHW]W GLHVLQ$QDORJLH]XDQGHUHQ$NWHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJHWZDDOVPQGLJH5HFKWV SHUVRQRGHUKLQVLFKWOLFKHLQHUEHUXIOLFKHQ=XVWlQGLJNHLWZHLOGRUWLPPHUJLOW Ä(UVWZLUGHLQHPJHVDJWZDVPDQVHL>«@GDPLWPDQGDV=XJHVSURFKHQHVLFK VHOEVW]XHLJHQPDFKHXQGDOVRVHOEVWZHUGH³6RZHQLJHLQ0HQVFKDXHUKDOE VROFKHULKQEHVWLPPHQGHQVR]LDOHQ%H]JH]XVLFKNRPPWVRVHKUKlQJWGHUHQ %HGHXWVDPNHLWDEHUGDYRQDEREXQGZLHHUVLFKGDVMHZHLOV =XHUNDQQWH]X (LJHQPDFKW%H]JOLFKGHU7DXIHVWHOOW.RFKGHVKDOEIHVW Ä'LHK|FKVWH:UGL JXQJ GLH HLQ 0HQVFK HUKDOWHQ NDQQ ± HLQ 9HUVSUHFKHQ IUV JDQ]H /HEHQ ± ÃQW]WµLKPQLFKWV>«@ZHQQHUGLHV9HUVSUHFKHQQLFKWIUVHLQ/HEHQVHOEVW JHOWHQOlW³ 'DVVHVDXIGLHVHXQYHUWUHWEDULQGLYLGXHOOH$QHLJQXQJLQVEHVRQGHUHDXVSUR WHVWDQWLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHDQNRPPWUHODWLYLHUWDEHUGHQYHUELQGOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHU DOOHUFKULVWOLFKHQ7UDGLWLRQVJHKDOWHXQGNLUFKOLFKHQ9ROO]JH6RQRWLHUW.RFK
$D2 9JODD2II.RFKEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLDXI/XWKHUV.QSIXQJGHUVDNUDPHQWDOHQ *QDGHDQGHQ*ODXEHQLPDOOJHPHLQHQXQGGDV9HUVWlQGQLVGHU7DXIHDOVHLQHQOHEHQVODQJHQ 9ROO]XJLPEHVRQGHUHQ YJODD2II .DUO%DUWKV.ULWLNGHU.LQGHUWDXIHXQWHU]LHKWHU YRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGVHOEVWHLQHU.ULWLNZHLOGLHVHUQLFKW]XEHJUQGHQYHUPDJZDUXPHV HLQHVlXHUHQREMHNWLYHQ=HLFKHQVEHGDUIZHQQGLH7DXIHQXUDOVEHZXVVWHV%HNHQQWQLVXQG 6HOEVWIHVWOHJXQJHLQHV0HQVFKHQYHUVWDQGHQZLUG YJODD2II 'DVV%DUWKKLHUQXQ SO|W]OLFKVRVWDUNDXIGLHHUZDFKVHQH:LOOHQVHQWVFKHLGXQJVHW]WVFKHLQW]XGHPDXVVHLQHQ ÄHLJHQHQ3UlPLVVHQ QLFKWEHJUQGHW³ ZHLO HVÄQLFKWFKULVWRORJLVFK>«@ GDUJHOHJW>ZLUG@³ DD2 .2&+I $D29JO'(56 E .2&+I
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
'DULQLP:DKUKHLWVYHUKlOWQLVLP*HZLVVHQLP*ODXEHQDQ*RWWGDULQVHOEVWELQLFKIUHL QLFKWDEKlQJLJYRQGHU.LUFKHRGHUVRQVWHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWELQLFKZLHPDQJHVDJWKDW XQPLWWHOEDU]X*RWW'DVLVWGRFKGLHJURH(QWGHFNXQJGHU5HIRUPDWLRQ
0LW GLHVHU %LQGXQJ GHV &KULVWVHLQV DQ ÄHLQ QLFKWLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHV HLQ QLFKW REMHNWLYLHUEDUHV QLFKW GXUFK %HREDFKWXQJ NRQVWDWLHUEDUHV .ULWHULXP³ ± GHQ *ODXEHQGDV*HZLVVHQGLH*HVLQQXQJ±JHKWMHGRFKHLQHSULQ]LSLHOOHÄ.ULVHGHU ,QVWLWXWLRQDOLWlWGHU.LUFKH>«@LPUHIRUPDWRULVFKHQ&KULVWHQWXP³HLQKHU6LH ILQGHW$XVGUXFNLQ/XWKHUV8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHUVLFKWEDUHQLQVWLWXWLR QDOLVLHUWHQ.LUFKHPLWLKUHQ*HPHLQGHQ$PWVWUlJHUQXQG9HUZDOWXQJVVWUXNWX UHQXQGGHUXQVLFKWEDUHQ.LUFKHLQGHUDOOHZDKUKDIW*ODXEHQGHQPLWHLQDQGHU YHUEXQGHQVLQG.RFKYHUVWHKWGLHVHHNNOHVLRORJLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJVRGDVV DXVLKUHLQHÄSULPlUH1LFKW,QVWLWXWLRQDOLWlW³GHU.LUFKHIROJW2IIHQOlVVWVLH LQVHLQHQ$XJHQDEHUGLH)UDJHZHOFKHQ6LQQHLQHLQVWLWXWLRQHOOH*HVWDOWEHU KDXSWQRFKKDEHQNDQQZHQQGHP*ODXEHQGHUMHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ*RWWHVEH]LH KXQJDOOHLQLJH3ULRULWlW]XNRPPW 'LHVH6FKZLHULJNHLWZLUGYHUVWlUNWGXUFK$XIO|VXQJVHUVFKHLQXQJHQGLHVLFK PLWGHUPRGHUQHQÄ.ULVHGHV6FKULIWSULQ]LSV³YHUELQGHQ6RKDWGLH]X/XWKHUV =HLWHQQRFKEHU]HXJHQGH%HJUQGXQJGHUNLUFKOLFKHQ(LQKHLWDXVGHPELEOLVFK EH]HXJWHQXQGLQ/HKUHZLH%HNHQQWQLVYHUELQGOLFKDXVJHGUFNWHQHLQHQ:RUW *RWWHVGXUFKGHQ6LHJHV]XJKLVWRULVFKHU%LEHONULWLNVHLWGHU$XINOlUXQJ]XQHK PHQGDQ3ODXVLELOLWlWYHUORUHQÄ(VJLEW³ZLH.RFKVNQDSSHV)D]LWDXVGLHVHU (QWZLFNOXQJODXWHWÄNHLQHQ:HJ]XUFN]XU(LQLJNHLWGHUHLQHQIHVWVWHKHQGHQ UHLQHQ/HKUH³1XUVROFKH,QKDOWHGLHVLFKNUDIWLQGLYLGXHOOHU(LQVLFKWDOV ZDKUHUVFKORVVHQKDEHQYHUP|JHQQDFKGHU'HNODVVLHUXQJYRQ%LEHOXQG'RJ PD]XP0HQVFKHQZRUWQRFKQRUPDWLYH*HOWXQJ]XHUODQJHQ'DPLWDEHU]HU EULFKW DXFK GHU HLQVWPDOV VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKH =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU NLUFKOLFKLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHQ:RUWYHUNQGLJXQJXQGGHPGXUFKVLH±]XPLQGHVW SRWHQ]LHOO±HUZHFNWHQ*ODXEHQ 6HLQ3OlGR\HUIUHLQHQDQJHPHVVHQHQ8PJDQJPLWGHP%HGHXWXQJVXQG $XWRULWlWVYHUOXVWNLUFKOLFKHU,QVWLWXWLRQHQJHKWDXIWKHRUHWLVFKHU(EHQHGDKLQ
.2&+M .2&+ YJO]XP)ROJHQGHQ '(56H II 9JO]XU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJYRQVLFKWEDUHUXQGXQVLFKWEDUHU.LUFKH %$57+D .2&+ H8OULFK%DUWKVSULFKWDQDORJ]X.RFKDEHURKQHDXILKQ]XUHNXUULHUHQGDYRQGDVV Ä.LUFKH>«@DXVUHIRUPDWRULVFKHU6LFKWHLQ9HUVXFKGHU,QVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUXQJGHV1LFKWLQVWLWX WLRQDOLVLHUEDUHQ³VHL DD2 9JO GD]X XQG ]XP )ROJHQGHQ .2&+ ± H ±± M II'HU7HUPLQXVÄ.ULVHGHV6FKULIWSULQ]LSV³JHKWDXIGHQ HUVFKLHQHQHQJOHLFKQDPL JHQ$XIVDW]YRQ.RFKV'RNWRUYDWHU:ROIKDUW3DQQHQEHUJ]XUFN YJO3$11(1%(5* GHUGDUDXVGLHWKHRORJLVFKH$XIJDEHHUKHEWÄ>G@LHKHUPHQHXWLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHQ EHUOLHIHUWHQ7H[WHQXQGXQVHUHU*HJHQZDUW>«@GXUFKHLQHQ(QWZXUIGHUEHLGHYHUELQGHQGHQ *HVFKLFKWH³VRZRKO]XEHZDKUHQDOVDXFKDXI]XKHEHQ DD2 .2&+M
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DXVGHUHQÄ QDFKHYDQJ9HUVWlQGQLV QRWZHQGLJ³NULVHQKDIWHU9HUIDVVWKHLW.RQ VHTXHQ]HQ ]X ]LHKHQ XQG VLFK NODU ]X PDFKHQ ÄÃ*HLVWµ Ã*ODXEHµ XQG ÃIUHLH .RPPXQLNDWLRQµ ODVVHQ VLFK QLFKW LQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUHQ ± QXU 5lXPH GDIU 'LHVH%HJUHQ]WKHLWJLOWDXFKIUÄ>D@OOHLQKDOWOLFKHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJHQGHUFKULVWOL FKHQ:DKUKHLWVEHU]HXJXQJ>«@±HLQVFKOLHOLFKGHU$XVVDJHQGHU6FKULIWGHV 'RJPDVXQGGHU%HNHQQWQLVVH±³GLHDOOHUHUVWZDKUÄZHUGHQZRVLFKHLQ(LQ ]HOQHUGDQNLKUHULQ:DKUKHLW>«@VHOEVWYHUVWHKW³.LUFKOLFKLQVWLWXWLRQHOO NDQQ HV VR JHVHKHQ QXU GDUXP JHKHQ GLHVHV IUHLH 6LFKVHOEVW9HUVWHKHQ LP FKULVWOLFKHQ*RWWHVJODXEHQP|JOLFK]XPDFKHQXQGHEHQGDUDXIVlPWOLFKH9ROO ]JHDXV]XULFKWHQ Ä'LH.LUFKH³VR.RFK ÄLVWDOOHLQDXI GLH*ODXEHQV XQG *HZLVVHQVELOGXQJEH]RJHQ³ ZDVGHQ9HU]LFKWDXIQRUPDWLYH9RUJDEHQDOOHU $UWEHGHXWHW'RFKUHGHWGLHVH=LHODQJDEHDXFKNHLQHU%HOLHELJNHLWGDV:RUW 9LHOPHKUNRPPHQKLHUGLHELEOLVFKHQZLHGRJPDWLVFKHQ7UDGLWLRQVJHKDOWHGHV &KULVWHQWXPV]XLKUHP5HFKWGLHXQEHVFKDGHWLKUHVKLVWRULVFKUHODWLYHQ&KDUDN WHUV XQHQWEHKUOLFK IU GLH +HUDXVELOGXQJ HLQHU HLJHQVWlQGLJHQ hEHU]HXJXQJ VLQG :LUZWHQQLFKWZDV*ODXEHQ*ODXEHDQ*RWWLVWZlUHXQVGDVQLFKWYRUJHVDJW>«@GDPLW ZLUIUHLGDV:DKUHGDUDQHLQVHKHQXQGGDVVRJXWZLUQXUN|QQHQVHOEVWPLWHLJHQHQ:RUWHQ VDJHQ
'DVVHVIUHPGH:DKUKHLWV]XPXWXQJHQEUDXFKWXP]XHLQHUVHOEVWYHUDQWZRUWH WHQJHZLVVHQKDIWHQ:DKUKHLWVEHU]HXJXQJ]XJHODQJHQGDUDXVUHVXOWLHUWIU .RFKHEHQVRGLHKHUYRUJHKREHQH5HOHYDQ]GHVTXDEHUNRPPHQHU7UDGLWLRQ Ã9RU*HVDJWHQµZLHHVGLH(LQELQGXQJLQGHP&KULVWOLFKHQYHUSIOLFKWHWH.RP PXQLNDWLRQVYHUKlOWQLVVHQDKHOHJW6RNDQQHUGLH.LUFKHLGHDOW\SLVFKDOVÄJHLVWL JH*HPHLQVFKDIWYRQDQ:DKUKHLWLQWHUHVVLHUWHQ0HQVFKHQ³EHVFKUHLEHQLQGHU VLFKÄHLQH$QUHJXQJMDHLQH$QOHLWXQJLQPHLQHP:DKUKHLWVYHUKlOWQLVLQPHL QHP*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVXQGHLQH)|UGHUXQJGHVVHQLPJHJHQVHLWLJHQ$XVWDXVFK³ YROO]LHKW'LH8QDEGLQJEDUNHLWGLHVHVJHJHQVHLWLJHQ$XVWDXVFKVUKUWDXFK GDKHUGDVVMHGH:DKUKHLWVHUNHQQWQLVSHUVSHNWLYLVFKJHEURFKHQLVWDEHU]XJOHLFK GHQ$QVSUXFKHQWKlOWIUDOOHHLQVHKEDUDOOJHPHLQJOWLJXQGDEVROXW]XVHLQ /HW]WHUHVDEHUNDQQQXUGXUFKGHQIUHLHQ$XVWDXVFKYRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQYHULIL ]LHUWRGHUHEHQZLGHUOHJWZHUGHQ 'HU,QVWLWXWLRQGHVNLUFKHQOHLWHQGHQ$PWHVVFKUHLEW.RFKKLHUHLQHPRGHULH UHQGH)XQNWLRQ]X(VKDWGLH$XIJDEHHLQHXQJH]ZXQJHQH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ EHUGDVYHUELQGOLFK&KULVWOLFKH]XHUP|JOLFKHQ =XPHLQHQGXUFKLQKDOWOLFKH WKHRORJLVFKH%HLWUlJHGLHJHVSUlFKVDQUHJHQGVLQGRGHUDXVXIHUQGH'LVNXVVLRQHQ
.2&+ $QP .2&+ I .2&+M $D2 $D2 I9JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 II '(56 ± ±
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
ZLHGHU]XP.HUQGHV3UREOHPV]XU:DKUKHLWVIUDJH]XUFNIKUHQ'DEHLJHKW HV GDUXP ÄEHLGHV GLH )UHLKHLW GHV 1DFKGHQNHQV XQG GDV =XVDPPHQILQGHQ LPPHUQHX³DQ]XUHJHQ'LHVHU$XVJOHLFKDEHUJHOLQJWQXUZHQQ]XPDQGHUQ DXFKGHUÄ9HUDEVROXWLHUXQJMHZHLOVEHVWLPPWHU XQGVRLQ:DKUKHLWUHODWLYHU NLUFKOLFKHUXQGWKHRORJLVFKHU3RVLWLRQHQ³JHZHKUWZLUGZHVKDOEGDVNLUFKHQOHL WHQGH$PWDXIÄGLHJHJHQVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ³GHU(LQ]HOQHQWURW]GLYHUJLHUHQ GHUhEHU]HXJXQJHQ]XGULQJHQKDW1LFKW.RQVHQVELOGXQJLVWGDVXQEHGLQJWH =LHOGHVLQQHUNLUFKOLFKHQ*HVSUlFKVVRQGHUQGLH6FKlUIXQJGHUMHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ *ODXEHQVXQG*HZLVVHQVEHU]HXJXQJ±DEHUHEHQVRGDVVGLHVHGLHÄ$QHUNHQ QXQJVHOEVWGHVYRQPLUYHUVFKLHGHQHQ$QGHUHQ³DOVDXFKDXIGLH:DKUKHLW DXI*RWWEH]RJHQEHLQKDOWHW'HUJHPHLQVDPH%H]XJVSXQNW*RWWRGHUGLHDEVR OXWH:DKUKHLWGHQHLQMHGHUQXULQSHUVSHNWLYLVFKHU*HEURFKHQKHLWEHLVLFK]X YHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQYHUPDJVWLIWHWHLQHEOHLEHQGH'LIIHUHQ]HQEHUJUHLIHQGH9HU EXQGHQKHLWÄ'LHFKULVWOLFKH(LQKHLWGLHMDYRQNHLQHPREMHNWLYHQLQKDOWOLFK DXVIRUPXOLHUWHQ.DQRQRGHU0DVWDEPHKUJDUDQWLHUWZLUGLVWGDQQGLHVHOEVW JHZROOWH(LQLJNHLWDOV9HUV|KQOLFKNHLW³:RVLHVLFKHLQVWHOOWGDLVW*RWWSUl VHQWDOVGHUMHQLJHÄ*HLVWGHU0HQVFKHQ]XXQEHGLQJWHUXQGEHGLQJXQJVORVHU $N]HSWDWLRQXQWHUHLQDQGHUEHIlKLJW³GHUHVP|JOLFKPDFKWGDVVHLQHUÄGHQ $QGHUHQUHVSHNWLHUWDOVHLQHQGHUZLHHUXPGLH:DKUKHLWVHLQHUhEHU]HXJXQJ ULQJW³$OVÄHQGOLFKH>«@*HVWDOWGHUÃ*HPHLQVFKDIWDOOHU*ODXEHQGHQµ³ZLUG GLH.LUFKHÄ]XVDPPHQJHKDOWHQGXUFKGHQHLQHQ*HLVWGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWDOOHU 0HQVFKHQXQGGHUHQIUHLHUJHJHQVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJLQ*RWW³ :HQQVLFKÄGLH.LUFKH±XQGGDVKHLWQDFKHYDQJHOLVFKHP9HUVWlQGQLV DOOH $PWVWUlJHULQGHU.LUFKHXQGDOOH&KULVWHQJHJHQVHLWLJ±>DOV@IUGLHVH*HZLV VHQVELOGXQJGHVHLQ]HOQHQ³]XVWlQGLJEHJUHLIWNDQQVLHLQ.RFKV$XJHQDXFK HLQHSROLWLVFKH5HOHYDQ]HQWIDOWHQ 6LHEULQJWVLFKGDQQÄDOV,QVWDQ]GHU*H ZLVVHQKDIWLJNHLW³|IIHQWOLFK]XU*HOWXQJDEHUQLFKWLQGHP6LQQHGDVVVLHVLFK VHOEVWJOHLFKVDPDOV*HZLVVHQIU$QGHUHDXIVSLHOWH1XUDQGLHVHU6WHOOHOlVVW VLFKIU.RFKEHUKDXSWYRPÄVRJHQDQQWH>Q@SROLWLVFKH>Q@0DQGDWGHU.LUFKH³ UHGHQZRHVXPGDVLQGLYLGXHOOH*HZLVVHQJHKWÄEH]RJHQDXIGLHSROLWLVFKHQ *UXQGVlW]H EH]RJHQ DXI VHLQH SROLWLVFKHQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ³ :HLO VHLQH 0DFKWVWUXNWXUHQQLFKWGDYRUJHIHLWVLQGLQEORHQ=ZDQJXQGUHLQH:LOONU XP]XVFKODJHQRGHU]XP6SLHOEDOOSDUWLNXODUHU,QWHUHVVHQVGXUFKVHW]XQJ]XZHU
.2&+M .2&+ I .2&+M (EG .2&+ .2&+ .2&+ .2&+ F .2&+ E .2&+ F
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHQÄEHGDUIGHU6WDDWGHUNULWLVFKHQXQGHLJHQVWlQGLJHQ,QVWDQ]GHV*HZLVVHQV XQGGHU]ZDQJIUHLHQSHUVRQDOHQ.RPPXQLNDWLRQ HUEHGDUILQGLHVHP6LQQHGHU .LUFKH³ ZHQQ VLH GHQQ VROFKHU .RPPXQLNDWLRQ 5DXP ]X JHEHQ YHUPDJ 0HKUDOVGDVDEHUYHUPDJDXV.RFKV6LFKWDXFKGLH,QVWLWXWLRQ.LUFKHQLFKWXQG PHKUGDUIVLHDXFKQLFKWN|QQHQZROOHQZHQQVLHVLFKNODUPDFKWGDVVÄ>Z@DKU LVWIUGHQ(LQ]HOQHQQXUGDV>LVW@ZDVLKPHLQOHXFKWHWZDVLKQDOV:DKUKHLW HUJUHLIWXQGZRUDXIHUVLFKHLQOlW³:LHÄULVNDQW³HVVLFKLQVWLWXWLRQHOODXFK DXVQLPPWGLHÄ%HGHXWXQJGHUHLJHQHQ(LQVLFKW³GHUDUWJUR]XVFKUHLEHQXQGLKU IUHLHV6LFK%LOGHQDOOHQ(LQ]HOQHQDQHUNHQQHQGHLQ]XUlXPHQ QXUVRNDQQHV EHUKDXSWLPPHUZLHGHU]XMHQHUÄVHOEVWJHZROOWH>Q@(LQLJNHLWDOV9HUV|KQOLFK NHLW³NRPPHQLQGHUHQXQJH]ZXQJHQHP*HOLQJHQ*RWWXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQ JHJHQZlUWLJZLUG
)D]LW -HQHÃVHOEVWJHZROOWH(LQLJNHLWDOV9HUV|KQOLFKNHLWµYRQGHUDP(QGHGHVOHW]WHQ $EVFKQLWWVQRFKHLQPDOGLH5HGHZDUKDWVLFKLP/DXIHGHV.DSLWHOVDOV.RFKV WKHRORJLVFKHU=HQWUDOJHGDQNHHUZLHVHQ'DVVLKU$XINRPPHQLQGHPVLFK*RWW DOVGDV8QHQGOLFKHLP(QGOLFKHQDOVGDV$EVROXWHLP5HODWLYHQ]HLJWGDPLW VWHKWXQGIlOOWREVLHÃVHOEVWJHZROOWµLVWZLUGGXUFKGLH)RUPXOLHUXQJQRFKHLQ PDOXQWHUVWULFKHQ'DPLWWUlJW.RFKGHUYRQLKPQDPKDIWJHPDFKWHQJ|WWOLFK DEVROXWHQ(LJHQDUWGHV6XEMHNWV5HFKQXQJGDVLQVHLQHUXQEHGLQJWHQ)UHLKHLW GXUFKQLFKWV]XZDVHVVLFKQLFKW]XJOHLFKVHOEVWEHVWLPPWEHDQVSUXFKW]XZHU GHQYHUPDJ,P*HZLVVHQGDVZXUGHLP%OLFNDXIYHUVFKLHGHQH*HVHOOVFKDIWV VSKlUHQGXUFKJHVSLHOWXQWHUVFKHLGHWHVVLFKYLHOPHKULPPHUQRFKHLQPDOYRQ DOOHPZDVHVLQ%H]XJDXI$QGHUHXQG$QGHUHVLVWXQGZDVLKPDXIJUXQGVHLQHU MHVSH]LILVFKHQVR]LDOHQ%HVWLPPWKHLWDQ(UZDUWXQJHQHQWJHJHQJHEUDFKWZLUG 'DULQOLHJWVHLQHXQEHGLQJWH:UGHEHJUQGHWGHUHQHWZDDXFKGXUFK-QJHO EHPKWH5FNIKUXQJDXIHLQHGLHVHQLKUHQ*HJHQVWDQGDOOHUHUVWNRQVWLWXLHUHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK *RWW .RFK GHXWOLFK ZLGHUVSULFKW 'LHV EHWULIIW DXFK GLH UHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLVFKEHVFKZRUHQHWRWDOH6QGKDIWLJNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQGHU LP$NWGHUDXVGHP1LFKWVVFK|SIHQGHQJ|WWOLFKHQ*HUHFKWVSUHFKXQJJDQ]QHX XQGDQGHUVZHUGH$QDORJ]X:DJQHUV,QVLVWLHUHQDXIGHPEHLP0HQVFKHQYRU DXV]XVHW]HQGHQ)UHLKHLWVYHUP|JHQDN]HQWXLHUW.RFKGHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVDQ WHLOLPUHOLJL|VHQ6LFK%HVWLPPHQ/DVVHQGXUFK*RWW:HLOIULKQQLFKWVZDKU VHLQNDQQZDVHUQLFKW]XJOHLFKIUVLFKZDKUVHLQOlVVWLVWHLQMHGHU0HQVFK LPPHUVFKRQDXIÃK|FKVWLQGLYLGXHOOHµ:HLVHVHOEVWHWZDVXQGHEHQGDUDQNQSIW DXVVHLQHU6LFKWGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWDQ*HUDGHGHVKDOENDQQ.RFK]XIROJHDEHU
.2&+ E .2&+M (EG
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
$QHUNHQQXQJQLFKWDOOHVJHVFKZHLJHGHQQGDV$EVROXWHVHLQZHLOQLHDXVJH PDFKWLVWZLHGDV6XEMHNWVLFKVHOEVW]XGHPYHUKlOWZDVHVLP.RQWH[WYRQ $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQIU$QGHUHLVW,QGHU%HWRQXQJGHUGDUDXVUHVXOWLH UHQGHQ6SDQQXQJVKDIWLJNHLWXQG'LIIHUHQ]EHVWLPPWKHLWJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/H EHQVOlVVWVLFKGDV:DJQHUV$QVDW]JHJHQEHUKHUYRU]XKHEHQGH3OXVYRQ.RFKV 3RVLWLRQHQWGHFNHQ(UWKHPDWLVLHUWGDEHLDOOHUGLQJVQLFKWQXUGDVLQGLYLGXHOOH 9HUP|JHQVLFK]XVR]LDOHQ 5ROOHQ (UZDUWXQJHQDXIJHZLVVHQKDIWH'LVWDQ]]X EHJHEHQXPVLHNULWLVFKNRQVWUXNWLY]XSUIHQRGHUJDU]XUFN]XZHLVHQ=X JOHLFK ZHL HU MHQH QHJDWLYHQ 6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJHQ ]X EHGHQNHQ GLH HLQHUVHLWV GXUFK GLH JHQHUHOOH 8QVLFKHUKHLW EHU GDV QLFKWDQWL]LSLHUEDUH 9HUKDOWHQ GHU MHZHLOV$QGHUHQDXVJHO|VWZHUGHQ N|QQHQ DQGHUHUVHLWVPLWUHDOHQ(UIDKUXQJHQ GHVOHLGYROOHQ$EEUXFKV]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWHLQKHUJHKHQ 9RU GLHVHP +LQWHUJUXQG PLVFKW VLFK LQ DOOHV ZDV PDQ LP VR]LDOHQ .RQWH[W VHOEVWLVWXQGVHLQZLOOHLQ%HZXVVWVHLQMHHLJHQHU(QGOLFKNHLWXQG)HKOVDPNHLW HLQ'LHGHPQDFK]XJHZlUWLJHQGH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHU$EVROXWKHLWGHV6XE MHNWVXQGGHVVHQXQHQWULQQEDUHUHQGOLFKUHODWLYHU3RVLWLRQDOLWlWZLUGQDFK.RFK DOVHLQH6SDQQXQJHUOHEWLP%OLFNDXIGLH*RWW]XU6SUDFKH]XEULQJHQLVW *RWW DOVÃ*HLVWGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWµDXIGHQLPPHUVFKRQVHW]WZHUGDV=XVDPPHQ ILQGHQPLW$QGHUHQLQGHU:DKUKHLWLQGHU/LHEHXQGLP*XWHQDOVUHDOP|JOLFK YRUDXVVHW]W XQGDXIGHQLPPHUQRFKNRQWUDIDNWLVFK]XYHUWUDXHQYHUPDJZHP GLH(UIDKUXQJJHOLQJHQGHQ9HUEXQGHQVHLQVYHUZHKUWEOHLEW,QOHW]WHUHP$VSHNW OLHHQVLFK0RPHQWHGHV/XWKHUVFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVPRWLYVHQWGHFNHQZREHL GLHGDPLWPDUNLHUWH+DOWXQJXQYHUEUFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWXQG*RWWYHUWUDXHQVZLH HLQPDOPHKUJHJHQEHU-QJHOIHVW]XKDOWHQLVWGHQXQYHUWUHWEDULQGLYLGXHOOHQ *ODXEHQVYROO]XJGHV6LFK%HVWLPPHQ/DVVHQVYRUDXVVHW]W'LHVHPHQWVSULFKW QDFK.RFKHLQH2IIHQKHLWIUGLHÃNOHLQHQ0RPHQWHµJOFNHQGHQ*HOLQJHQVXQG HLQH%HIUHLXQJGDYRQDOOHVYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK$QGHUH]XHUZDUWHQGLH HEHQQLFKWDOOHVLVW2KQHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJRKQHGDVVDOVRGLH6XE MHNWHVLFKZLHHVLP)UHLKHLWVUHFKW]XDOOJHPHLQHU*HOWXQJHUKREHQZXUGHJH JHQVHLWLJGLHLKQHQMHZHLOVHLJQHQGH)UHLKHLWDIILUPDWLYHLQUlXPHQGDVZXUGH HWZD DQKDQG GHV (OWHUQ.LQG9HUKlOWQLVVHV GHXWOLFK DEHU PDQJHOW HV LKUHP IUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQDQGHQQ|WLJHQlXHUHQ5HDOLVDWLRQVEHGLQJXQJHQ'DVVGLHVH HLJHQVJHZROOWXQGDN]HSWLHUWZHUGHQLVWZLHGHUXPHLQH$QJHOHJHQKHLWXQHU ]ZLQJEDUHU*HZLVVHQVHLQVLFKW6REOHLEWHLQHSULQ]LSLHOOH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ VR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJXQGLQGLYLGXHOOHP6HOEVWVHLQDXIGHUHQSURGXNWLYH%HDU EHLWXQJPDQVLFK.RFK]XIROJHNLUFKOLFKWKHRORJLVFKIRNXVVLHUHQVROOWH 6SDQQXQJHQLQ.RFKV3RVLWLRQZXUGHQGRUWPDUNLHUWZR*RWWPLWWKHLVWLVFKHQ $QNOlQJHQDOVDOOPlFKWLJHV+DQGOXQJVVXEMHNWEHJHJQHWGDVDOVGLH/LHEHGLH :DKUKHLWXQGGDV*XWHLQQHUZHOWOLFKE]ZDP0HQVFKHQWlWLJZLUG6LHODVVHQ VLFKGDQQHUPlLJHQZHQQGDVYRPPHQVFKOLFKHQ*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLV]XXQWHU VFKHLGHQGH6HOEVWVHLQ*RWWHVLQVHLQHUXQIDVVOLFKHQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]DQGLHDPEL YDOHQWH6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJGHVVHQUFNJHEXQGHQZLUGGHUXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQ HQGOLFKHQ/HEHQVDQGHU8QHQGOLFKNHLWYRQ/LHEHXQG:DKUKHLWIHVWKlOW±ZRKO
$7KHRORJLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
ZLVVHQGGHUHQ$XINRPPHQQLHDOOHLQDXVVLFKVHOEVWKHUDXVJDUDQWLHUHQ]XN|Q QHQ'HPEHL:DJQHUJlQ]OLFKLQGLH,PPDQHQ]VR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOW QLVVHKHUDEJHKROWHQXQG]XGHUHQLPPDQHQWHP6ROOHQVSULQ]LSHUNOlUWHQ*RWWLVW LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH PLW .RFK HLQ EOHLEHQGHV 0RPHQW YRQ 7UDQV]HQGHQ] ]X]X VFKUHLEHQ 8PVLFKDXFKQRFKLPÄ1LFKWJHOLQJHQ>@³GHVLQGLYLGXHOO*HZROOWHQ RGHU*HVROOWHQÄXPJULIIHQXQGJHKDOWHQ³ZLVVHQ]XN|QQHQÄYRQGHU>«@:DKU KHLW*RWWHVGLHQLFKWZLUVHOEVW>«@VLQG³DEHUGLHQXUIUGHQÃHWZDVµLVWGHU VLFKLP*ODXEHQYRQLKUVREHVWLPPWVHLQOlVVWGDVVHUGDULQVHOEVWHWZDVLVW *RWW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LUGLHEHUGLHVHPHUVWHQ.DSLWHOVWHKHQGHhEHUVFKULIW PDFKWYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQGGHVVRHEHQJH]RJHQHQ)D]LWVHLQHWKHRORJLVFK]X WKHPDWLVLHUHQGH6SDQQXQJQDPKDIW6LHVROOQXQQRFKHLQPDOPLW%H]XJDXIGLH KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWHQ3RWHQ]LDOHGHU3RVLWLRQHQ-QJHOV:DJQHUVXQG.RFKV]XP $XVGUXFNNRPPHQ (LQHUVHLWVVRLQVLQXLHUWHVGLHhEHUVFKULIW]LHOWGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWDXIHLQH 'LPHQVLRQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGLHHVXQDEKlQJLJVHLQOlVVWYRQGHQLKP NUDIW VR]LDOHU $QHUNHQQXQJ ]XNRPPHQGHQ %HVWLPPWKHLWHQ %HL -QJHO VWHKW KLHUIUGDVPLWGHU*HZLVVKHLWJ|WWOLFKHU$QHUNDQQWVHLQVYHUEXQGHQH%HZXVVW VHLQÃVFKRQHWZDVµ]XVHLQXQGGHVKDOEQLFKWGDVDXVVLFKPDFKHQ]XPVVHQ ZDVPDQDXV6LFKWGHU$QGHUHQVHLQVROOWH:DJQHUKLQJHJHQGHXWHWGLHGHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQVWDWXVTXRWUDQV]HQGLHUHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQGHV VLFKLQVHLQHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHQPLVVDFKWHWILQGHQGHQ6XEMHNWV DOV$QWL]LSDWLRQHQJ|WWOLFKYHUV|KQHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ.RFKVFKOLHOLFKYHU VWHKW GLH 8QEHGLQJWKHLW LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6HOEVW XQG )UHLVHLQV DOV .HQQ]HLFKHQ GDIUGDVVGDV6XEMHNWDQVLFKVHOEVWHWZDV*|WWOLFKHVLVWZHLOHVYRQGDKHU QLFKWLQGHPDXIJHKWZDV$QGHUHLQLKPVHKHQVRQGHUQVLFK]XDOOHPZDVYRQ LKPHUZDUWHWZLUGQRFKHLQPDOLQV9HUKlOWQLVVHW]HQNDQQ $QGHUVHLWVLPSOL]LHUWGLHhEHUVFKULIW]XJOHLFKDXFKGDVV*RWWPLWGHQVR]LD OHQ:LU%H]JHQLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJ]XEULQJHQLVW%HLDOOHQGUHL$XWRUHQYHU ELQGHWVLFKGLHVPLWGHU)UDJHQDFKHLQHU)RUPGHV6R]LDOHQGLHGHUYRQ*RWW KHUDXVJHVDJWHQ8QDEKlQJLJNHLWPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVYRQGHQIDNWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQHQWVSUlFKH%HL-QJHOOlVVWVLFKKLHUGHU9HUZHLV DXI9HUKlOWQLVVHDXVPDFKHQLQGHQHQGHU0HQVFKHQVLFKYRQGHPZDVHULQIRO JHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU(UZDUWXQJHQDXVVLFKPDFKHQPXVVLPPHUDXFKXQWHU VFKLHGHQZLVVHQN|QQWH:DJQHU]LHOW±OHW]WOLFK±DXIGLH9ROOHQGXQJGHULQGHU 0RGHUQHEHJRQQHQHQ5HDOLVDWLRQV\PPHWULVFKHJDOLWlUHU$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOW QLVVHLQGHQHQDOOHVLFKLQLKUHU)UHLKHLWEHMDKWZLVVHQ.RFKJHKWHVXPHLQH $QHUNHQQXQJVSUD[LVLQGHUGLH6XEMHNWHHLQDQGHUIUHL]XODVVHQYHUP|JHQZHLO VLHDOOHU'LIIHUHQ]HQXQG8QVWLPPLJNHLWHQ]XP7URW]DXIHLQHVLFK]ZLVFKHQ LKQHQHLQVWHOOHQGHXQGVLHHUIOOHQGH9HUEXQGHQKHLWYHUWUDXHQN|QQHQ
.2&+
$7UDXJRWW.RFK 8QEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWVHLQXQGXQYHUIJEDUH$QHUNHQQXQJ
*RWWOlVVWVLFKGHPQDFKHEHQVRLP=XVDPPHQKDQJVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJV YHUKlOWQLVVHDOV,QEHJULIIYRQGHUHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUH[SOL]LWHU,GHDOJHVWDOW]XU 6SUDFKHEULQJHQZLHHUGDYRQXPGHVLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGHU6XEMHNWH ZLOOHQGDVHVYRQ*RWWKHUXQEHGLQJW]XDFKWHQXQG]XVFKW]HQJLOW]XJOHLFK XQWHUVFKHLGHQZHUGHQPXVV (VLVWGLHVHWKHRORJLVFKH'RSSHOSHUVSHNWLYHGLHLPIROJHQGHQ.DSLWHODXVJH KHQGYRQGHQGUHL$XWRUHQPLWJHQXLQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ3RVLWLRQHQLQV*HVSUlFK JHEUDFKWXQGVRLP%OLFNDXILKUH5HLFKZHLWHJHSUIWZLUG
7HLO%
,FKRGHU:LU"3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQDXIGDV 9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ WKHRORJLVFKUHIOHNWLHUW %3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
(LQOHLWXQJ ,FKRGHU:LU" ,FKRGHU:LU"±PLWGHU)UDJHGLHEHUGHQIROJHQGHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ3HUVSHN WLYHQDXIGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJVWHKWVFKHLQWHLQDE VWUDNWHU*HJHQVDW]NRQVWUXLHUW]XZHUGHQ'HQQZHUZUGHEHVWUHLWHQZROOHQ GDVV MHGHV Ã:LUµ MHGH VR]LDOH 9HUJHPHLQVFKDIWXQJVIRUP DXV YHUVFKLHGHQHQ Ã,FKVµEHVWHKW":HUZUGHXPJHNHKUWEHWUDFKWHWDOOHQ(UQVWHVGDYRQDXVJHKHQ GDVVGLHVHÃ,FKVµ]XQlFKVWHLQPDOHLQVDPXQGDOOHLQIUVLFKVHOEVWH[LVWLHUHQXP VFKOLHOLFK YLHOOHLFKW LQ GLH *HPHLQVFKDIW HLQHV Ã:LUµ HLQ]XWUHWHQ RGHU HEHQ QLFKW" 'HU/LEHUDOHVDJWHHUVHLGDYRQEHU]HXJWGDGDV,QGLYLGXXPVHLQHQVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ YRUDXVJHKH>«@'HU.RPPXQLWDULVWZHQGHWHGDJHJHQHLQGDGDV,QGLYLGXXPNHLQHVZHJV VHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWYRUDXVJHKHVRQGHUQLP*HJHQWHLOYRQLKUDEKlQJH
0LWGLHVHUGHURELJHQ7LWHOIUDJHVWDUNYHUZDQGWHQ*HJHQEHUVWHOOXQJYHUVXFKW +LQULFK)LQN(LWHOGLH)URQWHQGHULQGHQ HU-DKUHQHLQVHW]HQGHQSROLWLVFK SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'HEDWWH]ZLVFKHQ/LEHUDOLVPXVXQG.RPPXQLWDULVPXV]XNOl UHQÄ7DWVlFKOLFK³VRIJWHUDOOHUGLQJVPLW9HUZHLVDXIGDUDQ]HQWUDOEHWHLOLJWH 'HQNHUXQGGHUHQJHLVWHVJHVFKLFKWOLFKH9RUOlXIHUKLQ]XÄLVW ZHGHUGHUHLQH PDQGHQNHDQ+REEHV.DQW5DZOVRGHU'ZRUNLQ QRFKGHUDQGHUH PDQGHQNH DQ$ULVWRWHOHV+HJHO0DF,QW\UHRGHU:DO]HU HLQHLQKHLWOLFKHV3KlQRPHQ³ (EHQVRXQVFKDUIZLUGGHUJHUDGHVFKDUIJHVWHOOWH.RQWUDVW]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU PDFKWPDQVLFKNODUZDVVR)LQN(LWHOZHLWHUGHP.RPPXQLWDULVWHQGXUFKDXV
),1.(,7(/ D $D29JO]XU.RPPXQLWDULVPXV/LEHUDOLVPXV'HEDWWHDQGHUQHEHQGHQJHQDQQ WHQXDQRFK&KDUOHV7D\ORUXQG5REHUW1%HOODKVRZLH-UJHQ+DEHUPDV]HQWUDOEHWHLOLJW ZDUHQ GLH LQVWUXNWLYHQ %HLWUlJH LP+DQGEXFK .RPPXQLWDULVPXV YRQ .DUO+HLQ] 1XVVHU +DUDOG6WHO]HUXQG-DQ3KLOLSS6FKDHIHU 5((6(6&+b)(5±'LH'HEDWWHQDKP LKUHQ$QIDQJPLW0LFKDHO6DQGHOV YHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ:HUN/LEHUDOLVPDQGWKH/LPLWVRI -XVWLFHLQGHPHUVLFKNULWLVFKPLW-RKQ5DZOV HUVFKLHQHQHU7KHRU\RI-XVWLFHDXVHLQDQ GHUVHW]WH'LHYRQ5DZOVLQVHLQHQ HUVFKLHQHQ9RUOHVXQJHQEHUGHQ%HJULIIGHV3ROLWL VFKHQ/LEHUDOLVPXVDXIJHZRUIHQH)UDJHPDUNLHUWGHQDOOHQ.RQWUDKHQWHQLP*UXQGHJHPHLQ VDPHQ3UREOHPKRUL]RQW Ä:LHNDQQHLQH JHUHFKWHXQGVWDELOH*HVHOOVFKDIWYRQIUHLHQXQG JOHLFKHQ%UJHUQGDXHUKDIWEHVWHKHQZHQQGLHVHGXUFKLKUHYHUQQIWLJHQUHOLJL|VHQSKLORVR SKLVFKHQXQGPRUDOLVFKHQ/HKUHQYRQHLQDQGHUJHWUHQQWVLQG"³ 5$:/6 $QGHU %HDQWZRUWXQJGLHVHU)UDJHXQGLQVEHVRQGHUHDQGHU%HXUWHLOXQJGHVVHQZLHVLFKGLHÃUHOLJL| VHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQXQGPRUDOLVFKHQ/HKUHQµ]XPIUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQGHV(LQ]HOQHQYHUKDOWHQ VFKHLGHQVLFKMHGRFKGLH*HLVWHU
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
ÄYRQOLEHUDOHU6HLWH]XJHVWDQGHQZLUG³ GDVVHUÄLP5HFKW>LVW@ZHQQHUDXIGHU KLVWRULVFKHQXQGVR]LDOHQ6LWXLHUWKHLWGHV,QGLYLGXXPVEHKDUUW³$OOHUGLQJVVHL GXUFKGLHVHV=XJHVWlQGQLVGLHHQWVFKHLGHQGH)UDJHQRFKOlQJVWQLFKWEHDQWZRU WHW ÄZLHKlQJWGDV,QGLYLGXXPGHVJHQDXHUHQYRQLKU³GHUKLVWRULVFKVR]LDOHQ /DJHLQGHUHVVLFKMHVFKRQYRUILQGHWÄDE"³)LQN(LWHOYHUZHLVWLP/DXIHGHV 7H[WHVVFKOLHOLFKDXIHLQHÄIXQGDPHQWDOH'LIIHUHQ]>«@GLHGDV,QGLYLGXXP± EHLDOOHU*HPHLQVDPNHLW±DXFKYRQVHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWXQGLKUHU6SUDFKH *HVFKLFKWHXQG.XOWXUWUHQQW³ZHLOLKPLQVHLQHUÄ(LQ]LJDUWLJNHLWLPPHUDXFK HLQ0RPHQWXQDXIO|VOLFKHU)UHPGKHLW³HLJQHW*HVHOOVFKDIWOLFKJHVHKHQPVVH VLFKGLHVLQGHUÄLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH>Q@$QHUNHQQXQJGHV$QGHUHQDOV$QGHUHQ³XQG ÄQLFKWQXU>«@DOV7UlJHUDOOJHPHLQHUJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKHU5ROOHQXQG)XQNWLR QHQ³QLHGHUVFKODJHQ 1XQJHKWHVLP)ROJHQGHQQLFKW±RGHUQXUDP5DQGH±XPGLH'HEDWWH]ZL VFKHQ.RPPXQLWDULVPXVXQG/LEHUDOLVPXVZHQQJOHLFKGLHJHQDQQWHQJHLVWHVJH VFKLFKWOLFKHQ9RUOlXIHUEHLGHU6HLWHQ]X:RUWNRPPHQZHUGHQ$XVGHPHLQOHL WHQGHQ5HNXUVDXI)LQN(LWHOVGLHVEH]JOLFKHQ'LVNXVVLRQVEHLWUDJOlVVWVLFKDEHU OHUQHQGDVVGLH)UDJH,FKRGHU:LU"QLFKWQRWZHQGLJHLQHQVWDUUHQXQGDEVWUDN WHQ*HJHQVDW]LPSOL]LHUW6LHYHUPDJDXFKXQWHUGHUIUDJORVHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJ JHVWHOOW]XZHUGHQGDVVGHU(LQ]HOQHYRQMHKHULQVR]LDOH9HUKl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Ã:LUµLP9HUIJHQEHUGDV
),1.(,7(/ D $D2 $D2 $D2 9JO ]X +RQQHWKV %OLFN DXI GLH /LEHUDOLVPXV.RPPXQLWDULVPXV'HEDWWH +211(7+ F2KQH.RPPXQLWDULVWLPHLJHQWOLFKHQ6LQQH]XHLQVWHKW+RQQHWKGRFKGHP.RPPXQL WDULVPXVRIIHQVLFKWOLFKQlKHUDOVGHP/LEHUDOLVPXVZRUDXIHWZDDXFK%HDWH5|VVOHUKLQZHLVW ZHQQVLHLP%OLFNDXI+RQQHWKV]ZHLWHV+DXSWZHUN'DV5HFKWGHU)UHLKHLWVFKUHLEW Ä>,@QD QXPEHURI>«@SDVVDJHV+RQQHWKVHHPVWRDUJXHWKDWVRFLDOIUHHGRPDQGWKHVRFLDOOLIHH[ SUHVVHGLQH[LVWLQJVRFLDOLQVWLWXWLRQVKDVSULRULW\RYHUWKHFODLPVRIPRUDODQGOHJDOIUHHGRP >«@:LWKRXWEHLQJDEOHWRJRLQWRGHWDLOVKHUHLWLVHYLGHQWWKDWWKLVFRPHVYHU\FORVHWRD FRPPXQLWDULDQSRVLWLRQ ZLWKUHVSHFWWRLQGLYLGXDOVLWPHDQVWKDWVRFLDOUROHVDUHJXLGLQJRXU OLYHVLQSURYLGLQJXVZLWKPHDQLQJIXOHQGV VRFLDOO\DQGSROLWLFDOO\LWPHDQVWKDWWKHÃLQVWLWX WLRQDOVWUXFWXUHRIUHDOVRFLDOIUHHGRPFDQQRWEHSXWLQGDQJHUµE\LQGLYLGXDOPRUDODQGOHJDO IUHHGRP³ 5g66/(5 +HUYRUKG9HUI
(LQOHLWXQJ
Ã,FKµ'LH]XQlFKVWEDQDOZLUNHQGH$XVVDJHÄGD$OOHMHZHLOVDXFK(LQHRGHU (LQHUVLQG³YHUZHLVWVRJHVHKHQDXIHLQHK|FKVWVSDQQXQJVYROOHWHQGHQ]LHOO NRQIOLNWWUlFKWLJH.RQVWHOODWLRQ'RFKJLEWHVDXFKQRFKGLH]ZHLWHYRPÃ:LUµ DXVJHKHQGH$QWZRUWP|JOLFKNHLWGHU]XIROJHÄGHU0HQVFKDOVHLQ:HVHQJH GDFKW³ZHUGHQPXVVÄGDVVHLQH6XEMHNWLYLWlWJDQ]XQGJDUGHPVR]LDOHQ3UR]H VR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJYHUGDQNW³ /HW]WHUH)RUPXOLHUXQJHQWVWDPPWHLQHUYRQ$[HO+RQQHWKV6WXGLHQ]XU$QHU NHQQXQJVWKHRULHGLHXQWHUGHPDXIVFKOXVVUHLFKHQ7LWHO'DV,FKLP:LU HUVFKLHQHQVLQG+RQQHWKÄPLWGHVVHQ1DPHQVLFKGHU%HJULIIGHU$QHUNHQ QXQJLQGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'LVNXVVLRQXQWUHQQEDUYHUELQGHW³ LVWHLQHUGHUEHLGHQ'HQNHUGLHLP=HQWUXPGHUIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQVWHKHQ (UYHUN|USHUWGDEHLZLHZLUVHKHQZHUGHQDXFKZRUWZ|UWOLFKHLQHIUGHQ3UL PDWGHVÃ:LUµJHJHQEHUGHPÃ,FKµHLQWUHWHQGH3RVLWLRQ6HLQHJHUDGHDQJHIKU WH 7KHVH GDVV VLFK GDV 6XEMHNW ÃJDQ] XQG JDU GHP VR]LDOHQ 3UR]H VR]LDOHU $QHUNHQQXQJYHUGDQNWµHQWVWDPPWHLQHP7H[WGHUDXVGUFNOLFKDXIGLHNULWL VFKH*HJHQSRVLWLRQGHV86DPHULNDQLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQXQG3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHUV -RHO:KLWHERRNUHDJLHUW :KLWHERRNGHUDQGHUHLP)ROJHQGHQ]HQWUDOH'HQNHUPDFKWVLFKJOHLFKVDP IUHLQHSULQ]LSLHOOH8QDQJHSDVVWKHLWGHV,FKJHJHQEHUGHP:LUVWDUNXQGZL GHUVSULFKWLP=XJHGHVVHQ+RQQHWKVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHU$OWHUQDWLYVLFKWHQHU JLVFK6HLQHNULWLVFKHQ:RUWPHOGXQJHQKDEHQHLQHELVLQGLHMQJVWH=HLWKL QHLQIRUWGDXHUQGH'HEDWWHDXVJHO|VWGLHGLHVHP.DSLWHODOV*UXQGODJHGLHQW
),1.(,7(/ DI +211(7+I+HUYRUKG9HUI +211(7+F +2567(5 9JO:+,7(%22. (LQHDQDORJH.ULWLNDQ+RQQHWKV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVGLHVLFK DOOHUGLQJVLQGHQ'HWDLOVXQWHUVFKHLGHWILQGHWVLFKHWZDEHL'HWOHI+RUVWHUGHUJHJHQEHU +RQQHWKGLH)UDJHDXIZLUIW Ä:DVDEHULVWPLWGHUDXWRQRPHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJGHU,QGLYLGXHQEHL :HUWNRQIOLNWHQ".|QQHQGLHHLQ]HOQHQ0HQVFKHQWURW]GHUDOOJHPHLQHQ0RUDOGHUZHFKVHOVHL WLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHQQRFKLKUHPRUDOLVFKHQ3ULRULWlWHQVHW]HQ"³ +2567(5 %HL 0DJQXV6FKOHWWHKHLWHVJDQ]lKQOLFK Ä/lVVWVLFKLQGLYLGXHOOH)UHLKHLW>«@LQGHPYRQ+RQ QHWKEHWRQWHQ6LQQHÃLQGHPVLFKPLWJXWHQ*UQGHQVDJHQOlVVWGDVVMHGHU0HQVFKHLQWLHI VLW]HQGHV,QWHUHVVHDQGHUXQJHVW|UWHQ(QWIDOWXQJRGHU9HUZLUNOLFKXQJVHLQHUYRQLKPVHOEVW DOVNRQVWLWXWLYHUOHEWHQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLWEHVLW]WµVR]LDOElQGLJHQ"³ 6&+/(77(I YJO DXFK '(56II 'LH'HEDWWHQDKPLKUHQSXEOL]LVWLVFKHQ$XVJDQJPLWHLQHPLQGHU=HLWVFKULIW3V\ FKHYHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ7H[W:KLWHERRNVDXIGHQ+RQQHWKQRFKLPVHOEHQ-DKUPLWVHLQHUHEHQ GRUWDEJHGUXFNWHQ5HSOLNUHDJLHUWH YJO+211(7+I 'DULQYHUZHLVW+RQQHWKDXFKDXI GLH:KLWHERRNXQGLKQYHUELQGHQGH)UHXQGVFKDIWVRZLHGHUEHLGHQJHPHLQVDPH2ULHQWLHUXQJ DQ GHU )UDQNIXUWHU NULWLVFKWKHRUHWLVFKHQ 7UDGLWLRQ DD2 :KLWHERRNV NULWLVFK DIILUPDWLYHV9HUKlOWQLV]XUOHW]WHUHQGLHHULQVEHVRQGHUHLQ*HVWDOW$OEUHFKW:HOOPHUVNHQ QHQJHOHUQWKDWVFKOlJWVLFKLQVHLQHP:HUN3HUYHUVLRQDQG8WRSLD :+,7(%22. QLH GHU=ZHL-DKUHVSlWHU±±HUVFKLHQHLQHDXI+RQQHWKV5HSOLNEH]RJHQH(UZLGHUXQJ :KLWHERRNVGLHQRFKHLQPDOLQHLQHUVWlUNHUSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKRULHQWLHUWHQ6LFKWZHLVHGLH
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
6RODVVHQVLFKQlPOLFKQLFKWQXUGLHEHLGHQ6HLWHQGHU7LWHOIUDJH,FKRGHU:LU" PLWNRQNUHWHQ3RVLWLRQHQYHUNQSIHQ:KLWHERRNVNULWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHYHUPDJ PLWKLQLP6LQQHHLQHV KHXULVWLVFKHQ 5DKPHQV]XIXQJLHUHQXP+RQQHWKVLQ HLQHU9LHO]DKOYRQ3XEOLNDWLRQHQXQGLQKDOWOLFKHQ%H]JHQHQWIDOWHWHPDQHUNHQ QXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ$QVDW]EHUKDXSWXQGWKHPDWLVFKIRNXVVLHUWLQGHQ%OLFN QHKPHQ]XN|QQHQ'LHVEHGHXWHW]XJOHLFKGDVV:KLWHERRNVGDUEHUKLQDXVJH KHQGHQ3RVLWLRQHQLP)ROJHQGHQQXUHLQH1HEHQUROOHVSLHOHQ9LHOPHKUGLHQW VHLQHNULWLVFKH6LFKWHEHQYRUDOOHPGD]XEHVWLPPWH)DFHWWHQGHVKRQQHWKVFKHQ :HUNVVFKDUI]XVWHOOHQ=XGHPEH]LHKWHUHLQH9LHO]DKOZHLWHUHU3RVLWLRQHQLQ VHLQH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW +RQQHWK HLQ ZDV LKUH 'HEDWWH ]X HLQHP YLHO VWLPPLJHQ*HVSUlFKPDFKW'LHVHU9LHOVWLPPLJNHLWZLUGLP)ROJHQGHQ5HFK QXQJJHWUDJHQDXFKGDGXUFKGDVVELVZHLOHQQRFKZHLWHUH3RVLWLRQHQ(LQJDQJ LQV*HVSUlFKILQGHQ 'D]XJHK|UHQQLFKW]XOHW]WDXFKGLHLQGHQ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ.DSLWHOQHUDUEHL WHWHQWKHRORJLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHPDWLNGLHLQGLHSKL ORVRSKLVFKH'HEDWWHJXWHLQJHEUDFKWZHUGHQN|QQHQ'HQQGLH5HGHYRQ*RWW ]LHOWGHPQDFKHLQHUVHLWVDXIHLQH'LPHQVLRQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVGLHHV XQDEKlQJLJVHLQOlVVWYRQGHQLKPNUDIWVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XNRPPHQGHQ %HVWLPPWKHLWHQ$QGHUVHLWV±XQGGDPLWHUJLEWVLFKZLHZLUVHKHQZHUGHQHLQH EHU:KLWHERRNKLQDXVJHKHQGH6LFKW±LPSOL]LHUWVLH]XJOHLFKDXFKHLQHGLHVHU 8QEHGLQJWKHLWGHV6HOEVWJHOLQJHQGHQIDOOVHQWVSUHFKHQGH)RUPGHV6R]LDOHQ %HYRUHVDEHUQXQLQGLH'HEDWWH]ZLVFKHQ+RQQHWKXQG:KLWHERRNKLQHLQ JHKWVLQG]XQlFKVWGLHEHLGHQ.RQWUDKHQWHQQRFKHLQPDOHLQOHLWHQGLQGHQ%OLFN ]XQHKPHQ1DFKHLQHUHUVWHQ,QVLFKWQDKPHYRQ+RQQHWKV$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULH ZHUGHQGLH6FKZHUSXQNWHYRQ:KLWHERRNV.ULWLNDQGLHVHUYRUJHVWHOOW
HLJHQHQ$UJXPHQWHZLHGHUKROWH '(56 ,P5DKPHQHLQHV(QGHDQGHU1HZM@HGH6R]LDOSKLORVRSKLH³ZLH +LQULFK)LQN(LWHOVFKUHLEWÄYRUDOOHPDQGHUHQQDFKGHPZDVGLH*HVHOOVFKDIW LP,QQHUVWHQ]XVDPPHQKlOW³VRODXWHW+RQQHWKV]XY|UGHUVWGXUFKGLH/HNWUH +HJHOVJHVFKXOWH$QWZRUWNXU]JHVDJW $QHUNHQQXQJ'DVVZLUDQGHUVDOVGHULQ VHLQHQ$XJHQJHJHQZlUWLJÃJUDVVLHUHQGH6XEMHNWLYLVPXVµHVZDKUKDEHQZLOO VFKOHFKWKLQÃVR]LDOH:HVHQVLQGGLHLKUH)UHLKHLWLKUHPRUDOLVFKHQ)lKLJNHLWHQ LKU(UNHQQWQLVYHUP|JHQXQGLKUJDQ]HV'DVHLQGHUYRUJlQJLJHQ,QWHUDNWLRQPLW LKUHVJOHLFKHQ YHUGDQNHQµ VXFKW HU YHUPLWWHOV GLHVHU .DWHJRULH DXV]XZHLVHQ 1LFKWZHQLJHUDOVÄGLHPHQVFKOLFKH/HEHQVIRUPLPJDQ]HQ³LVWVHLQHV(UDFKWHQV ÄGXUFK GLH 7DWVDFKH JHSUlJW >«@ GD ,QGLYLGXHQ QXU GXUFK ZHFKVHOVHLWLJH $QHUNHQQXQJ]XVR]LDOHU0LWJOLHGVFKDIWXQGGDPLW]XHLQHUSRVLWLYHQ6HOEVWEH ]LHKXQJJHODQJHQ³,QGLYLGXHQVLQGGHPQDFKNHLQHYRQEORHQ(LJHQLQWHUHVVHQ JHOHLWHWHQ(LQ]HONlPSIHU9LHOPHKUVLQGVLHLPPHUVFKRQGXUFKGDVHLQJDQJV DQJHIKUWHÃ3ULPDWGHU,FK'XE]Z:LU3HUVSHNWLYHµYRUGHU,FK3HUVSHNWLYH VR]LDOYRUKHUEHVWLPPW :DVHLQMHGHULQGHQHLJHQHQ$XJHQLVWVHLQNDQQXQG ZLOOKlQJWJlQ]OLFKGDYRQDEZDVDQGHUHLQLKPVHKHQ±XQGGDVZLHGHUXPLVW JHOHLWHWGXUFKDOOHQ%HWHLOLJWHQJHPHLQVDPHÄQRUPDWLYJHUHJHOWH>@)RUPHQGHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³ +RQQHWKV3OlGR\HUJHJHQHLQVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKXQGYHUHLQ]HOW PLVV YHUVWDQ GHQHVÃ,FKµXQGIUGDVÃ:LUµUH]LSURNHU9HUEXQGHQKHLW]LHOWDEHUJHUDGHGDUDXI GHPÄLQGLYLGXHOOHQ)UHLVHLQN|QQHQ³GLHQOLFK]XVHLQ'LHVHVQlPOLFKNDQQZLH HUNODUVWHOOWÄQXULQJHJOFNWHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWJHJHEHQVHLQ³YHUPDJHVGRFK
%(51(5=803) ),1.(,7(/ E +211(7+F (EG +211(7+F
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
ÄGHP(LQ]HOQHQRKQHGLHDQHUNHQQHQGH%HVWlWLJXQJGXUFKGHQ$QGHUHQQLFKW]X JHOLQJHQ>«@VHLQH$EVLFKWHQXQG,PSXOVH]ZDQJORV]XUHDOLVLHUHQ³ %OHLEW VROFKH%HVWlWLJXQJV\VWHPDWLVFKDXVXQGJOFNWGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGGLH,QWHUVXE MHNWLYLWlW QLFKW NRPPW HV QDFK +RQQHWK ]XP .DPSI YRQ 6XEMHNWHQ XP GLH $QHUNHQQXQJLKUHUVHOEVW$QGLHVHQIULKQ]HQWUDOHQ*HGDQNHQNQSIWHUHLQ GH]LGLHUWVR]LDONULWLVFKHV$QOLHJHQ .DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJ±$[HO+RQQHWKV=HQWUDOEHJULIIPLWGHPHUVHLWGHP (UVFKHLQHQVHLQHUJOHLFKQDPLJHQ+DELOLWDWLRQVVFKULIWLP-DKUH JHUDGH]X LGHQWLIL]LHUWZLUGEULQJWHEHQVRHLQHQGHVNULSWLYHQ%HIXQGKLQVLFKWOLFKGHULQQH UHQ '\QDPLN YRQ 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQ ZLH HLQ QRUPDWLYHV ,QWHUHVVH DQ GHUHQ JHJHQZDUWVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU*HVWDOWXQJ]XP$XVGUXFN$XIKHJHOVFKH0RWLYH ]XUFNJUHLIHQGVFKUHLEW+RQQHWKLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ%H]LHKXQJHQHLQLPSOL]LWHV .RQIOLNWSRWHQ]LDO]XGDVVLFKH[SOL]LWHQWIDOWHWZHQQVLHGHQMHZHLOVEHWHLOLJWHQ 6XEMHNWHQGLH%HVWlWLJXQJLKUHUVHOEVWYHUZHKUHQ$XVVR]LDOHQ0LVVDFKWXQJVHU IDKUXQJHQUHVXOWLHUHQ(UZDUWXQJVEHUVFKVVHGLHVLFKLQHLQHPNRQWH[WWUDQV ]HQGLHUHQGHQNlPSIHULVFKHQ6WUHEHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJHQWODGHQ %HVWHQIDOOVNRPPWHVGDQQ]XHLQHUGLHVHP9HUODQJHQJHUHFKWZHUGHQGHQ 0RGLILNDWLRQGHU%H]LHKXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWOLFKDXV]XPDFKHQGHQ%H GUIQLVVHQQDFKHLQHU)RUWHQWZLFNOXQJGHUEHUHLWVHWDEOLHUWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHU KlOWQLVVHWKHRUHWLVFKH8QWHUVWW]XQJ]XWHLOZHUGHQ]XODVVHQ±GDUDXIULFKWHWVLFK +RQQHWKVJHJHQZDUWVEH]RJHQHV,QWHUHVVH'HUODQJMlKULJH)UDQNIXUWHU3URIHVVRU IU6R]LDOSKLORVRSKLHXQG'LUHNWRUGHVHEHQGRUWDQVlVVLJHQ,QVWLWXWVIU6R]LDO IRUVFKXQJVWHOOWVLFKGDPLWDXVGUFNOLFKLQGLH7UDGLWLRQVOLQLHGHUGXUFK0D[ +RUNKHLPHU EHJUQGHWHQ ,GHH HLQHU .ULWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH ,P 8QWHUVFKLHG ]X +RUNKHLPHUXQG7KHRGRU:$GRUQRGHUHQ'LDOHNWLNGHU$XINOlUXQJIULKQGDV 'RNXPHQW HLQHV XOWLPDWLYHQ 9HUWUDXHQVYHUOXVWHV LQ GLH 9HUlQGHUEDUNHLW GHU PRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWGDUVWHOOWLVW+RQQHWKVVR]LDONULWLVFKHV$QOLHJHQMHGRFK YRQEHJUQGHWHQ)RUWVFKULWWVKRIIQXQJHQJHWUDJHQ'HUHQIHVWHQ*UXQGELOGHWGHU ÄQRUPDWLYH>@%RGHQGHU0RGHUQH³GLHLQLKUHPÄQRUPDWLYH>Q@*HKDOW³DXFK VHLQ/HKUHU-UJHQ+DEHUPDVLQNULWLVFKHU$EVHW]XQJYRQ+RUNKHLPHU$GRUQR ]XZUGLJHQZHL+RQQHWKQLPPWGHQYRQ+DEHUPDVJHZLHVHQHQÄ$XVZHJDXV GHU 6DFNJDVVH GHV >«@ 1HJDWLYLVPXV³ LQ GHQ GLH *UQGHUJHQHUDWLRQ GHU )UDQNIXUWHU6FKXOHDQJHVLFKWVGHU7RWDOLWDULVPHQGHV-DKUKXQGHUWVVXN]HVVL
(EG 9JOGD]XYRUDOOHP +211(7+F G *UXQGOHJHQGIUGLHVH6HOEVWYHURUWXQJGLHPLWGHULP)ROJHQGHQQXUVNL]]LHUWHQ.ULWLN GHU YRUKHUJHKHQGHQ *HQHUDWLRQHQ .ULWLVFKHU 7KHRULHELV KLQ]X +DEHUPDV HLQKHUJHKW LVW IROJHQGHU$XIVDW] +211(7+E'DULQZHUGHQ.ULWLNSXQNWHDXIJHQRPPHQGLH+RQQHWK VFKRQLQVHLQHU'RNWRUDUEHLWGDUJHOHJWKDW '(56 9JODXFKVHLQH$XVVDJHQLQ %2/ 7$16.,+211(7+± +211(7+ +$%(50$6 D ± :(//0(5
(LQOHLWXQJ
YHYHUIDOOHQLVW1LFKWGLHHPDQ]LSDWRULVFKHQ3RWHQ]LDOHVSUDFKOLFKHU9HUVWlQGL JXQJELOGHQDEHUGHQ$QVDW]SXQNWVHLQHUNULWLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWVWKHRULHVRQ GHUQMHQHEHUVFKLHHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQYRQGHQHQEHUHLWVGLH 5HGHZDU 'DV5HFKWGHU)UHLKHLW±PLWGHP7LWHOGHQ+RQQHWKVHLQHP]ZHLWHQ SXEOL]LHUWHQ+DXSWZHUNJHJHEHQKDWWULWWJHZLVVHUPDHQGHUDOOHQJHVHOOVFKDIW OLFKXPODXIHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQJHPHLQVDPH=LHOSXQNWYRU$XJHQ (V JHKW GHQ GLH $IILUPDWLRQ LKUHU VHOEVW HUKHLVFKHQGHQ 6XEMHNWHQ XP QLFKWV DQGHUHVDOVLKU)UHLVHLQN|QQHQGDVVR]LDOHQ%HGLQJXQJHQXQWHUOLHJW'LHVHDEHU VLQGLQPRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWHQYRQGHU,GHHLQGLYLGXHOOHU)UHLKHLWVUHFKWHJH SUlJWÄ)UGLHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJVV\VWHPHGLHVHV7\SVYRQ*HVHOO VFKDIW³VRVFKUHLEW+RQQHWKÄNDQQJHOWHQGDLQLKQHQDXIIXQNWLRQVVSH]LILVFKH :HLVH$VSHNWHGHUHWKLVFKHQ9RUVWHOOXQJYHUN|USHUWVLQGDOOHQ6XEMHNWHQJOHL FKHUPDHQ]XLQGLYLGXHOOHU)UHLKHLW]XYHUKHOIHQ³$QGHUHUIDKUEDUHQ(LQO| VXQJGLHVHVMHEHUHLFKVW\SLVFKLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHQÄ)UHLKHLWVYHUVSUHFKHQV³± IU+RQQHWKHLQH)UDJHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ±EHPLVVWVLFKPLWKLQGLH*HUHFKWLJNHLW VR]LDOHU9HUKlOWQLVVH'DVV+RQQHWKVEHVDJWH6WXGLHGDUDXIDE]LHOWÄGLH]XNQI WLJHQ(UIRUGHUQLVVHVR]LDOHU*HUHFKWLJNHLW³EHZXVVW]XPDFKHQIKUWGLHNULWL VFKHXQGYHUlQGHUXQJVZLOOLJH6FKODJVHLWHVHLQHV'HQNHQVYRU$XJHQ6RVHKUHV QlPOLFKDXFKJHJHQZlUWLJOHJLWLPHUZHLVHHUZDUWHWZHUGHQNDQQDOVIUHLHV,QGL YLGXXPLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH%HMDKXQJ]XILQGHQ±GLHGLHVEH]JOLFKHQVR]LDOHQ(UIO OXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQHUVFKHLQHQLKPLPPHUQRFKDXVEDXIlKLJ'HPJHPlJHKWHV +RQQHWKGDUXPVLFKÄLQHLQHUJHPHLQVDPHQ5FNHULQQHUXQJDQGLHDXIGHP QRUPDWLYHQ%RGHQGHU0RGHUQHDXVJHWUDJHQHQ.lPSIHGHU$QVSUFKH>]X@YHU VLFKHUQGLHLPKLVWRULVFKHQ3UR]HGHVVR]LDOHQ(LQNODJHQVLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHU )UHLKHLWVYHUVSUHFKHQQRFKQLFKWDEJHJROWHQVLQG³7UHWHQGLHXQDEJHJROWHQHQ DEHUJOHLFKZRKOLQGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVRUGQXQJEHUHLWVYHUDQNHUWHQ )UHLKHLWVDQVSUFKHYRU$XJHQJHKWGLH*HVFKLFKWHLKUHUJHUHFKWLJNHLWVVFKDIIHQ GHQ(UIOOXQJGDUDXIZLOOHUOHW]WOLFKKLQDXVJHOLQJHQGHQIDOOVZHLWHU6ROFKHV )RUWVFKUHLWHQJHVFKLHKWQDFK+RQQHWKLPPHUVFKRQXQGLPPHUQRFKLP0RGXV GHVÄ.DPSI>V@XP$QHUNHQQXQJ>«@GHUDOVPRUDOLVFKH.UDIWLQQHUKDOEGHU VR]LDOHQ/HEHQVZLUNOLFKNHLWGHV0HQVFKHQIU(QWZLFNOXQJHQXQG)RUWVFKULWWH VRUJW³ *HJHQ+RQQHWKVLP(LQJDQJV]LWDWDXVJHSURFKHQH*UXQGWKHVHGHVÄ3ULPDWV GHU,FK'X%H]LHKXQJRGHUGHU:LUµ3HUVSHNWLYHYRUGHP6WDQGSXQNWGHVYHU HLQ]HOWHQVHLQHHLJHQHQ,QWHUHVVHQNDONXOLHUHQGHQ,QGLYLGXXPV³KDWQXQZLH
+211(7+ $D2 $D2 (EG +211(7+G %(51(5=803)
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JHVDJW PLW EHVRQGHUHU 9HUYH -RHO :KLWHERRN (LQZDQG HUKREHQ :KLWHERRN YHUWHLGLJWGDEHLGHQÃ6WDQGSXQNWGHVYHUHLQ]HOWHQVHLQHHLJHQHQ,QWHUHVVHQNDO NXOLHUHQGHQ,QGLYLGXXPVµXQGZLGHUVSULFKWGHVVHQ QLFKWQXU GXUFK+RQQHWK EHWULHEHQHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHU(LQKHJXQJ
'LH8QDQJHSDVVWKHLWGHV,FK -RHO:KLWHERRNV.ULWLNGHV ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV Ä'HU+REEHVLDQLVPXVKDWWHQLFKWY|OOLJXQUHFKW³0LWHLQHUSURYRNDQWHQ7KHVH OlVVWGHU1HZ«@JHZDOW ORV³DXFKVHLQÄVR]LDOHV*HJHQEHU>«@DQ]XHUNHQQHQ³JHQ|WLJWZHUGH%HL LKP ILQGHQ ]XGHP ]ZHL YRQ :KLWHERRN DOV lXHUVW ZLUNPlFKWLJ EHIXQGHQH 6SLHODUWHQGHVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ3DUDGLJPDV]XVDPPHQ HLQHSKLORVRSKL VFKHGLHGXUFK-UJHQ+DEHUPDVµÄNRPPXQLNDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKH:HQGH³LQL WLLHUWZXUGHXQGHLQHSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKHGLHGHUEHWRQWSRVWIUHXGLDQLVFKHÄUHOD WLRQDOWXUQ³DQJHVWRHQKDW'XUFKEHLGHVLHKW:KLWHERRNÄZLFKWLJH(LQVLFKWHQ DXV GHU 6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH XQG 7ULHEWKHRULH YHUORUHQ JHKHQ³ LQ GHQHQ GHU XQEHGLQJW]XUHWWHQGHÄ:DKUKHLWVJHKDOWGHV+REEHVLDQLVPXV³ EHZDKUWOLHJW (LQVLFKWHQVLQGJHPHLQWPLWGHQHQVRXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH'HQNHUZLH*HRUJ:LO KHOP)ULHGULFK+HJHO6LJPXQG)UHXG'RQDOG::LQQLFRWW'LHWHU+HQULFK
:+,7(%22. (EG (EG +211(7+I +211(7+G +$%(50$6 D *5((1%(5*0,7&+(// 0,7&+(// :+,7(%22. :+,7(%22.
(LQOHLWXQJ
XQG0DUN6DFNVHLQHGHPPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWHLJQHQGHÄYRURGHUDXHUVR]LDOH 'LPHQVLRQ³]XU*HOWXQJJHEUDFKWKDEHQLQGHUHLQVLFKVR]LDODXVZLUNHQGHV 1HJDWLYLWlWVSRWHQ]LDOYHUDQNHUWLVW:HUGHQGLHVH'LPHQVLRQXQGGDVLQLKUYHU DQNHUWH3RWHQ]LDOLQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHU0DQLHUXQWHUEHVWLPPWRGHUJOHLFK JDQ]NDVVLHUWIKUWGDVQDFK:KLWHERRNHLQHUVHLWV]XP9HUOXVWHLQHUSKlQRPHQ JHUHFKWHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJGHUFRQGLWLRKXPDQD$QGHUHUVHLWVOlXIWPDQVR*HIDKU HLQHPVR]LDONRQIRUPLVWLVFKHQXQGJHVHOOVFKDIWVXQNULWLVFKHQ6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV DXIWKHRUHWLVFKHU(EHQHGHQ%RGHQ]XEHUHLWHQÄ*HQDXGDVSDVVLHUWLQ+RQQHWKV 7KHRULHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³XUWHLOW:KLWHERRNPLWGHXWOLFKHQ:RUWHQ (LQ+REEHVLDQLVPXVLQ5HLQIRUPGHUGDV6XEMHNWLQVWDUUHU2SSRVLWLRQ]XDO OHP,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQVWHKHQVlKHYHUILHOHDOOHUGLQJVDXFKDXV:KLWHERRNV6LFKW HLQHUHEHQVRJURHQ(LQVHLWLJNHLW ZLHVHLQ*HJHQWHLOÄ%RWKSRVLWLRQVIDLOWR FRUUHFWO\HOXFLGDWHWKHUHODWLRQRIVRFLDELOLW\DQGDQWLVRFLDELOLW\³VFKUHLEWHU XQGPDFKWLQHLQHUWUHIIHQGHQ9HUKlOWQLVEHVWLPPXQJ]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQ3ROHQGDV ÄSURSHUGHVLGHUDWXP³DXV3DVVHQGGD]XELOOLJW:KLWHERRNGHUKREEHVLDQLVWL VFKHQ6LFKWGHV6XEMHNWVLP(LQJDQJV]LWDW]XÃQLFKWY|OOLJµXQULFKWLJ]XVHLQ ZDVXPJHNHKUWEHGHXWHWGDVVVLHDXVVHLQHU6LFKWNHLQHVZHJVJlQ]OLFKLP5HFKW LVW 'LHDXFKLQWKHRORJLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYH]XVWHOOHQGH)UDJHLVWYRUGLHVHP+LQ WHUJUXQGZLHEHLGHVSRVLWLY]XU*HOWXQJJHEUDFKWZHUGHQNDQQ GLHJ|WWOLFK DEVROXWH'LPHQVLRQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQVXQGGHVVHQXQZHLJHUOLFKH(LQELQ GXQJLQVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVH :HFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJXQGGLH$UEHLWGHV1HJDWLYHQ±VRODXWHWGHU7L WHOYRQ:KLWHERRNVDQWLLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHU6WUHLWVFKULIW,KU1DPHLVW3UR JUDPP0LWGHU+HJHOHQWOHKQWHQ5HGHYRQGHUÄ$UEHLWGHV1HJDWLYHQ³]LHOW :KLWHERRNQlPOLFKDXIHLQHÄ1HLJXQJ³GHV0HQVFKHQÄGLHJHJHEHQHQ9HUKlOW QLVVH]XUFN]XZHLVHQ³XQGQDFKHLJHQHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQ]XDJLHUHQ'LHVHDXV GHUDXHUVR]LDOHQ'LPHQVLRQGHV6HOEVWHQWVSULQJHQGH1HLJXQJVROOMHQHQ5H ]LSUR]LWlWVYHUSIOLFKWXQJHQJHUDGH]XZLGHUODXIHQGLH+RQQHWKLQVR]LDOH%H]LH KXQJHQYRQMHKHUÄHLQJHEDXW³VLHKW'DVNDQQHEHQVRGHVWUXNWLYHZLHNRQVWUXN WLYH)ROJHQDXVVLFKKHUDXVVHW]HQ6RKDEHQVFKUHLEW:KLWHERRNÄGDVÃ1LHG ULJVWHµXQGGDVÃ+|FKVWHµLPPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQLPVHOEHQ0XWWHUERGHQLKUH :XU]HOQ³%HLVHLQHP9HUVXFKGLHVH:XU]HOQIUHL]XOHJHQXP+RQQHWKV$Q VDW]HLQHUUDGLNDOHQ.ULWLN]XXQWHU]LHKHQUHNXUULHUWHUZLHREHQVFKRQDQJHGHX
$D2 :+,7(%22. :+,7(%22. :+,7(%22. 9JO+(*(/ Ä'DV/HEHQ*RWWHVXQGGDVJ|WWOLFKH(U NHQQHQPDJDOVRZRKODOVHLQ6SLHOHQGHU/LHEHPLWVLFKVHOEVWDXVJHVSURFKHQZHUGHQ GLHVH ,GHHVLQNW]XU(UEDXOLFKNHLWXQGVHOEVW]XU)DGKHLWKHUDEZHQQGHU(UQVWGHU6FKPHU]GLH *HGXOGXQG$UEHLWGHV1HJDWLYHQGDULQIHKOW³ +211(7+G :+,7(%22.
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
WHWDXIYHUVFKLHGHQHVXEMHNWSKLORVRSKLVFKHXQGWULHEWKHRUHWLVFKH(LQVLFKWHQ 'UHL3RVLWLRQHQODVVHQVLFKXQWHUVFKHLGHQGHUHQKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKHQ:DKUKHLWV JHKDOWHUJHJHQ+RQQHWKXQGGHQGXUFKLKQYHUWUHWHQHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVVWDUN PDFKW'DUDQLVWGLH*OLHGHUXQJGHV.DSLWHOVRULHQWLHUWZREHLPLWXQWHUQRFK ZHLWHUH$QVlW]HKLQ]XJH]RJHQZHUGHQXQGMHGHU$EVFKQLWWPLWWKHRORJLVFKHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQMHZHLOVLP$QVFKOXVVDQHLQHQGHUGUHL$XWRUHQGHVHUVWHQ+DXSW WHLOVDEVFKOLHW
=XU*OLHGHUXQJGHV.DSLWHOV ,P=HQWUXPGHVHUVWHQ$EVFKQLWWVVWHKHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJHQPLWGHP'HQNHQ +HJHOVGHVVHQEHZXVVWVHLQVSKLORVRSKLVFKH(LQVLFKWHQDXVGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLH GHV*HLVWHV:KLWHERRNJHJHQ+RQQHWKVYRUDOOHPDQKDQGGHU-HQDHU6FKULIWHQ HQWZLFNHOWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHJHOWHQGPDFKW6LFKLQZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHU NHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHHLQ]XIJHQVRVFKlUIW:KLWHERRNLP=XJHGHVVHQHLQ EHGHXWHWIUGDVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQSULPlUVHOEVWEH]RJHQHXQGVR]LDOXQYHUEXQGH QH6XEMHNW]XQlFKVWHLQPDOHLQHQ6HOEVWYHUOXVWXQGNHLQHQ6HOEVWJHZLQQZLH +RQQHWKEHKDXSWHW+RQQHWKV*HJHQWKHVHLVWGXUFKGLH$QQDKPHHLQHUÃYRUJlQ JLJHQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµ JHOHLWHW GLH GLH 6XEMHNWH YRQ MHKHU YHUELQGHW XP VFKOLHOLFKLQ)RUPYRQHPDQ]LSDWRULVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVNlPSIHQVWXIHQZHLVH DQV/LFKWJHEUDFKW]XZHUGHQ'DVVGLHVHUVR]LDOYHUPLWWHOWH:HJ]XVLFKVHOEVW DEHUHLJHQWOLFKLQGLH8QWHUZHUIXQJXQWHUYRUKHUUVFKHQGH1RUPHQXQG.RQYHQ WLRQHQIKUWZLUGYRQ-XGLWK%XWOHUJHZLVVHUPDHQ:KLWHERRNV1HJDWLYVLFKW PRGLIL]LHUHQG XQG YHUVFKlUIHQG KHUDXVJHVWHOOW ,Q HLQHP NXU]HQ 6HLWHQEOLFN ZLUGLKUHEHQIDOOVDQ+HJHORULHQWLHUWHUDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHU$QVDW]VNL] ]LHUWGHUDXFK$XVVLFKWHQDXIHLQHQLFKWXQWHUZHUIHQGH)RUPYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJ HQWKlOW(VVFKOLHHQVLFKWKHRORJLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQXQWHU5HNXUVDXI(EHUKDUG -QJHODQGLHHUNXQGHQZDVYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGGLH5HGHYRQHLQHUÃJ|WWOL FKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJµGHV0HQVFKHQEHGHXWHQNDQQ % 'HU]ZHLWH$EVFKQLWWPDFKW:LQQLFRWWV6LFKWGHUIUKNLQGOLFKHQ(QWZLFNOXQJ ]XP7KHPDGLH+RQQHWKLP6LQQHGHUUHODWLRQDOHQ3V\FKRDQDO\VHLQWHUSUHWLHUW ZlKUHQG:KLWHERRNLKUHLQHYLHOVWlUNHUH1lKH]XP1HJDWLYLVPXV)UHXGV]X VFKUHLEW$XVGHQJHJHQVlW]OLFKHQ6LFKWZHLVHQHUJHEHQVLFKMHZHLOVDQGHUH.RQ
,FK RULHQWLHUH PLFK GDEHL ORVH DQ +RQQHWKV GLUHNWHU (UZLGHUXQJ DXI :KLWHERRN GLH HEHQIDOOVGLHYRQGLHVHP]XU8QWHUPDXHUXQJGHVHLJHQHQNULWLVFKHQ$QOLHJHQVLQV)HOGJHIKU WHQ'HQNHUDOV/HLWIDGHQYHUZHQGHW YJOLQVEHVRQGHUH+211(7+I± $OOHUGLQJV JHKW+RQQHWKHLJHQWPOLFKHU:HLVHDXI:KLWHERRNV+HJHO,QWHUSUHWDWLRQQXULQHLQHUNXU]HQ )XQRWHHLQGLHGHQ+LQZHLVHQWKlOWÄGDGLH(LQIKUXQJGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIILQGHU 3KlQRPHQRORJLHQLFKWVHKUNODUXQGZHQLJKLOIUHLFKLVW³ DD2 $QP :LHLFKLP )ROJHQGHQGDUOHJHKDWHUGLHVH$QVLFKWVSlWHUDXIJHJHEHQ YJO'(56K J XQG DXFKGDV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQV.DSLWHOGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLHHLQHUDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQLQVHLQHP6LQQHXQWHU]RJHQ
(LQOHLWXQJ
VHTXHQ]HQIUGDVPHQVFKOLFKH6R]LDOYHUKDOWHQ%HL+RQQHWKIROJWDXVGHULGHD OHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWIUKNLQGOLFKHU*HERUJHQKHLWVHUIDKUXQJHQGDVOHEHQVODQJH 6WUHEHQQDFK9HUVFKPHO]XQJPLWGHP$QGHUHQEHL:KLWHERRNVFKOlJWVLFKHLQ LQIDQWLOHV$OOPDFKWVHUOHEHQOHW]WOLFKLQHLQHUSULQ]LSLHOODQWLVR]LDOHQ1HLJXQJGHV 6XEMHNWVQLHGHU'DPLWJHKWMHZHLOVHLQHVSDQQXQJVYROOH%H]LHKXQJ]XGHQJH JHEHQHQ6R]LDOE]Z$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQHLQKHUZRULQEHLGHHLQJHVHOO VFKDIWVNULWLVFKHV3RWHQ]LDOYHUDQNHUWVHKHQGDVVLHWKHRUHWLVFKIUXFKWEDU]XPD FKHQ YHUVXFKHQ 'DVV GHU LQWHUVXEMHNWLY DXVJHULFKWHWH 9HUVFKPHO]XQJVGUDQJ E]ZGDVVHOEVWEH]RJHQH2PQLSRWHQ]VWUHEHQWHQGHQ]LHOOEHUGHQVWDWXVTXR KLQDXVVFKLHHQVROOGLHYRQ+RQQHWKYHUZHQGHWH.DWHJRULHGHULQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ E]ZLPPDQHQWHQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]DXVGUFNOLFKPDFKHQ'DUDXVHUJLEWVLFKHLQH 9HUELQGXQJ]X)DON:DJQHUVÃ7KHRORJLHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJµGHULQDEVFKOLHHQ GHQWKHRORJLVFKHQhEHUOHJXQJHQQDFKJHJDQJHQZLUG % ,PGULWWHQ$EVFKQLWWJHKWHVVFKOLHOLFKXPGHQGXUFK+DEHUPDVDXVJHUXIHQHQ 3DUDGLJPHQZHFKVHOYRQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRULH GHP+RQQHWKVLFKDQVFKOLHWXQGJHJHQGHQ:KLWHERRNGLHNULWLVFKHQ(LQVLFKWHQ YRQ+HQULFKXQG6DFNVVWDUNPDFKW(QWJHJHQGHUDQHUNHQQXQJVE]ZNRPPX QLNDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ5HGXNWLRQGHV6XEMHNWVDXIHLQEORHV,QWHUDNWLRQVSUR GXNW ZLUG GDEHL GLH 8QKLQWHUJHKEDUNHLW GHV LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6HOEVWEH]XJV YRU DOOHPDXFKDOVHLQHV$QNHUSXQNWVIU.ULWLNXQG.RUUHNWXUVWDUNJHPDFKW'DIU VWHKWGHU%HJULIIGHU*HZLVVHQVDXWRQRPLHGHUQDFKHLQHP6HLWHQEOLFNDXI%HDWH 5|VVOHUVLQHLQHlKQOLFKH5LFKWXQJZHLVHQGH3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJGHVKRQQHWK VFKHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVLP$QVFKOXVVDQ7UDXJRWW.RFKWKHRORJLVFKJHZHQ GHWZLUG %
%+RQQHWKYV:KLWHERRN, 9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHO XQG]XUFN (LQOHLWXQJ +REEHVXQG+HJHO Ä'HU+REEHVLDQLVPXVKDWWHQLFKWY|OOLJXQUHFKW³'DVVVHLQH(U|IIQXQJVWKHVH EHL+RQQHWKNHLQHVZHJVDXISXUH$EOHKQXQJVW|WKDW:KLWHERRNNODUYRU$X JHQ(LQ$QOLHJHQGHPGHVVHQIUKHV+DXSWZHUN.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJJH ZLGPHWLVWHQWGHFNWHUQlPOLFKGDULQÄGHQ:DKUKHLWVJHKDOWGHV+REEHVLDQLV PXVVRZLHHUVLFKIU+HJHOGDUVWHOOWH]XEHZDKUHQ³*HQDXHUJHVDJWVLQGHV +HJHOV6FKULIWHQGHU-HQDHU-DKUH ± GHQHQ+RQQHWKGRUWGLHDXFK GXUFKGHQ$XWRUGHV/HYLDWKDQLQVSLULHUWHÄhEHU]HXJXQJ³HQWQLPPWÄGDVLFK DXVHLQHP.DPSIGHU6XEMHNWHXPGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJLKUHU,GHQWL WlWHLQLQQHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU=ZDQJ]XUSUDNWLVFKSROLWLVFKHQ'XUFKVHW]XQJ YRQIUHLKHLWVYHUEUJHQGHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQHUJLEW³:DVDQGLHVHU,GHHDXI$QUH JXQJHQ7KRPDV+REEHVµ]XUFNJHKWLVW+RQQHWKV5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ]XIROJHGDV Ä'HQNPRGHOO HLQHV VR]LDOHQ .DPSIHV XQWHU GHQ 0HQVFKHQ³ $OOHUGLQJV JH VFKLHKWGHUYRQLKPEHVFKULHEHQH*HGDQNHQWUDQVIHUQLFKWRKQH0RGLILNDWLRQHQ GLHGHP8UVSUXQJVPRWLYELV]XHLQHPJHZLVVHQ*UDGGHQÃQHJDWLYHQ6WDFKHOµ ]LHKHQ *HQDX DXI GLHVHQ 3XQNW ]LHOW :KLWHERRN ZHQQ HU NULWLVFK DQPHUNW Ä+RQQHWKV*HEUDXFKGHVIUKHQ+HJHOLQ2SSRVLWLRQ]XP+HJHOGHU3KlQRPH QRORJLH³GLHQHÄGD]XGLH.RQIOLNWQDWXUXQGGDPLWGLH,QWHQVLWlWGHV.DPSIHV EHLGHU6XFKHQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJLQUDGLNDOHU:HLVH]XUHGX]LHUHQ³'LHEHVDJWH 2SSRVLWLRQVELOGXQJYRQGHU+RQQHWKZLHZLUVHKHQZHUGHQVSlWHUDEJHUFNW LVWEHWUHLEWHULQ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJPLW(QWVFKLHGHQKHLW6REH]LFKWLJWHU +HJHOVHKUGHXWOLFKJHSUlJWGXUFK-UJHQ+DEHUPDVµHLQVFKOlJLJH,QWHUSUHWDWL RQHLQHVDOOPlKOLFKHQ$EUFNHQVYRQDXVVHLQHU6LFKWEHVRQGHUVSURGXNWLYHQ
:+,7(%22. 9JO]XGHQIROJHQGHQHLQOHLWHQGHQ%HPHUNXQJHQLQVJHVDPW DD2± :+,7(%22. +211(7+G9JO]XU5HNRQVWUXNWLRQYRQ+RQQHWKV+REEHVXQG+HJHOGDUVWHO OXQJ DD2± ± $D2 :+,7(%22. Ä>'@D+HJHOLQGHQEHLGHQ-HQHQVHU9RUOHVXQJHQ³±JHPHLQWVLQG GDV6\VWHPGHU6LWW OLFKNHLW XQG GLH 5HDOSKLORVRSKLH ± ÄHLQH HLJHQWPOLFKH VSlWHU SUHLVJHJHEHQH 6\VWHPDWLN
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
8UVSUXQJVHLQVLFKWHQ,P/DXIHGHU-HQDHU=HLWXQGNXOPLQLHUHQGLQGHU3KlQR PHQRORJLH GHV *HLVWHV YROO]LHKW VLFK LP KHJHOVFKHQ 'HQNHQ GHPQDFK HLQH Ä+LQZHQGXQJ]XU%HZXWVHLQVSKLORVRSKLH³GLHHVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQÄPLWGHP 3UHLVGHV9HU]LFKWVDXIHLQHQVWDUNHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVEH]DKOW³ 'DJHJHQELHWHW:KLWHERRNHLQH$XVOHJXQJGHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQV.DSLWHOV GHU3KlQRPHQRORJLHGHV*HLVWHVDXIGLHJHUDGHGLHVHQ9HU]LFKWEHJUW6R LQWHUSUHWLHUWHU+HJHOVVLFKGRUWQLHGHUVFKODJHQGH+LQZHQGXQJ]XU%HZXVVW VHLQVSKLORVRSKLH EHWRQW SRVLWLY ÄDOV 9HUVXFK >«@ GHQ PDWHULDOLVWLVFKHQ XQG SV\FKRORJLVFKHQ:DKUKHLWVJHKDOWGHV+REEHVLDQLVPXV]XEHZDKUHQ³1LFKWDXI ÃGLH ZHFKVHOVHLWLJH $QHUNHQQXQJ LKUHU ,GHQWLWlWµ VLQG GLH 6XEMHNWH GHPQDFK SULPlUDXVVRQGHUQGDUDXIGHQ$QGHUHQ]XJXQVWHQGHUHLJHQHQHJR]HQWULVFKHQ %HJLHUGHLQGHVVHQ6HOEVWVHLQHLQ]XVFKUlQNHQ'DUEHU]XHLQHPVR]LDONRQIRU PHQ9HUKDOWHQKLQDXV]XJHKHQZDVQLHPDOVJlQ]OLFKJHOLQJWÄHUIRUGHUWHLQHQ .DPSI³ ±LP6LQQHHLQHVNRQIOLNWUHLFKHQ(QWZLFNOXQJVSUR]HVVHV±GHUHUVW HLQPDO]XIKUHQLVW 'HP0RWLYGHV.DPSIHVDEHUNRPPWDXFKLQ+RQQHWKV+HJHOGHXWXQJHLQH ]HQWUDOH5ROOH]X]XPDOZLHJHVHKHQQLFKWRKQHGHQ+LQZHLVGDVVGDPLWLQ PRGLIL]LHUWHU )RUP HLQ KREEHVLDQLVWLVFKHV (UEVWFN DQJHHLJQHW ZLUG 'XUFK ZHOFKH9HUlQGHUXQJHQGLHVHLQGHQ-HQDHU6FKULIWHQVLFKYROO]LHKHQGH$QHLJ QXQJDXVVHLQHU6LFKWJHSUlJWLVWLVWQXQ]X]HLJHQ 'DUDXIKLQNRPPW:KLWH ERRNVGLHVEH]JOLFKHDQKDQGGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLHGHV*HLVWHVYRUJHWUDJHQH .ULWLNLQGHQ%OLFN XPQDFKHLQHPNXU]HQ6HLWHQEOLFNDXI-XGLWK%XWOHU VFKOLHOLFKWKHRORJLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQXQWHU%H]XJQDKPHDXI(EHUKDUG-QJHO DQ]XVWUHQJHQ
9RUJlQJLJH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW +RQQHWKV DQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH+HJHOGHXWXQJ %HL +REEHV EHUXKW GHU NRPSHWLWLYH &KDUDNWHU GHU VR]LDOHQ 6SKlUH GLH RKQH VWDDWOLFKH*HJHQPDQDKPHQ]XP6FKODFKWIHOGGHVQDWXUZFKVLJHQÄ.ULHJ>V@ ]XJUXQGHJHOHJWKDW³LVWHLQH7KHVHGLH+DEHUPDVLQVHLQHP SXEOL]LHUWHQ$XIVDW]$UEHLW XQG,QWHUDNWLRQIRUPXOLHUW YJO+$%(50$6 :DV+HJHOGHPQDFKÃVSlWHUSUHLVJHJH EHQµKDWLVWHLQ9HUVWlQGQLVGHV*HLVWHVÄQDFKGHP0XVWHUGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWKDQGHOQGHU XQGVSUHFKHQGHU6XEMHNWH³DQGHVVHQ6WHOOHGDVÄ0XVWHUGHU6HOEVWUHIOH[LRQ³WULWW DD2 0LWKLQNRPPWHUDXFKGDUDXI]XVSUHFKHQGDVVGHU-HQDHUÄ+HJHO6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQDXVGHP ,QWHUDNWLRQV]XVDPPHQKDQJNRPSOHPHQWlUHQ+DQGHOQVQlPOLFKDOV5HVXOWDWHLQHV.DPSIHV XP$QHUNHQQXQJEHJUHLIW³ DD2 ZRUDXV+RQQHWKQDFKHLJHQHP%HNXQGHQGHQHQW VFKHLGHQGHQ,PSXOVIUVHLQHQHLJHQHQ$QVDW]EH]RJHQKDW YJOVHLQHZRKODXIGLHVHQ+D EHUPDV$XIVDW]EH]RJHQHQ$XVVDJHQLQ %2/7$16.,+211(7+ +211(7+GI :+,7(%22. $D2
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
HLQHV MHGHQ JHJHQ MHGHQ³ ZHUGHQ ZUGH DXI GHQ SULQ]LSLHOO HJRLVWLVFKHQ 6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJVLQWHUHVVHQGHU(LQ]HOQHQÄ(UVWHQV.RQNXUUHQ]]ZHLWHQV0L WUDXHQGULWWHQV5XKPVXFKW³VLQGGLHLQGHUÄPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXU³GHUHVDOOHLQ XPGHQ)RUWEHVWDQGGHVMHHLJHQHQ:RKOHUJHKHQVJHKWDQJHOHJWHQÄGUHLKDXSW VlFKOLFKH>Q@.RQIOLNWXUVDFKHQ³:HLOGHUHQVR]LDOGHVWUXNWLYH)ROJHQDXFKDXI GLHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJVP|JOLFKNHLWHQGXUFKVFKODJHQNDQQGLH([LV WHQ]HLQHVKLHU(LQKDOWJHELHWHQGHQ6WDDWHVQXULQ$OOHU,QWHUHVVHOLHJHQ'LHVHP JHJHQEHUYHUSIOLFKWHWPDQVLFKGHVKDOE±XQG]ZDUDXVHLQHPIXQGDPHQWDOHQ 6HOEVWLQWHUHVVHKHUDXV±]XU6HOEVWEHVFKUlQNXQJ +HJHOVÄ8PGHXWXQJGHV+REEHVVFKHQ0RGHOOV³IKUWDXV+RQQHWKV6LFKWGD ]XGDVVÄGHUSUDNWLVFKH.RQIOLNW>«@]ZLVFKHQGHQ6XEMHNWHQ³DOVHLQYRQMHKHU ÄVLWWOLFKHV*HVFKHKHQ³HUVFKORVVHQZLUG $QVWHOOHGHV6WUHEHQVQDFKÄSXUH>U@ 6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJ³WUHLEWMHW]WGHU$QVSUXFKÄDXIGLHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJ YRQ'LPHQVLRQHQGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ,QGLYLGXDOLWlW³GDV.DPSIHVJHVFKHKHQDQ 1LFKWGLHDXVGHUGHVWUXNWLYHQ'\QDPLNGHVÃ-HGHUJHJHQ-HGHQµUHVXOWLHUHQGH (LQVLFKW VLFK XP GHV HLJHQHQ :RKOHUJHKHQV ZLOOHQ ]XJXQVWHQ HLQHU IU DOOH YHUELQGOLFKHQ5HJXOLHUXQJVLQVWDQ]HLQVFKUlQNHQ]XPVVHQYHUJHVHOOVFKDIWHW PLWKLQDOOHUHUVWGDV6XEMHNW,Q+HJHOV6\VWHPGHU6LWWOLFKNHLW VLHKW +RQQHWK YLHOPHKU ÄGLH ,GHH HLQHU YRUJlQJLJHQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW GHV 0HQ VFKHQ³ODXWZHUGHQ$XVGHU-HQDHU5HDOSKLORVRSKLH JHZLQQWHUGHQ ]LHPOLFKlKQOLFKHQ*HGDQNHQÄGDMHGHVPHQVFKOLFKH=XVDPPHQOHEHQHLQH$UW YRQ HOHPHQWDUHU JHJHQVHLWLJHU %HMDKXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ 6XEMHNWHQ YRUDXVVHW]W³ 'HUHQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHÄ%H]LHKXQJRGHU%HVFKUlQNXQJ³VRVFKUHLEW+HJHOGRUW LVW NHLQHVZHJV DOOHUHUVW ÄDXV]XKHFNHQ RGHU KHUHLQ]XEULQJHQ³ YLHOPHKU ZLUG Ä>G@HU 0HQVFK >«@ QRWZHQGLJ DQHUNDQQW XQG LVW QRWZHQGLJ DQHUNHQQHQG³ $OOHVZHLWHUHGDUDXIZLOO+RQQHWKYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGKLQDXVVWHOOWHLQHQ ZLHDXFKLPPHUJHDUWHWHU8PJDQJPLWGLHVHUSULPlUHQ6R]LDOLVLHUWKHLWGDU Ä'DZLUXQVJHOHJHQWOLFKDOVIUHLHUIDKUHQZHQQZLUXQVVW|UULVFKJHJHQEHU =XPXWXQJHQYRQ1RUPDOLWlWYHUKDOWHQ>«@RGHUHQWVFKLHGHQDXIXQVHUHHLJHQHQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQEHKDUUHQ³EHVLW]WÄJHZLVVHUPDHQHLQHQVHNXQGlUHQ&KDUDN
9JO]XGLHVHP0RWLYGHVVHQDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQXQGSROLWLVFKHQ)ROJH UXQJHQLQVEHVRQGHUHGDVXQG.DSLWHOGHV/HYLDWKDQ +2%%(6 ± ± ± ± 'LH]LWLHUWH)RUPHOILQGHWVLFKHWZDLQ DD2 +2%%(6 +211(7+G+HUYRUKG9HUI'DJHJHQNDQQDOOHUGLQJVGDUDXIYHUZLHVHQZHU GHQGDVVLP*UXQGHDXFK+REEHVHLQH'LPHQVLRQÄVLWWOLFKHU³$OOJHPHLQKHLWNHQQW GDVVDOOH 6XEMHNWHDQLKUHU6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJLQWHUHVVLHUWXQGVRDXIQHJDWLYH:HLVH±LP.ULHJ±PLWHL QDQGHUYHUEXQGHQVLQG +211(7+G+HUYRUKG9HUI9JO]XU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ+RQQHWKVPLW+H JHOV6\VWHPGHU6LWWOLFKNHLW DD2± $D2 +(*(/
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
WHU³(VJHKWQlPOLFKÄ>G@HU8PJDQJPLWGHQDQGHUHQGLHVR]LDOH,QWHUDNWLRQ³ VROFKHQÄ'LVWDQ]LHUXQJHQ]ZDQJVOlXILJYRUDXV³6RIRUPXOLHUW+RQQHWKGLHVHQ *HGDQNHQLQVHLQHPSXEOL]LHUWHQ]ZHLWHQ+DXSWZHUN'DV5HFKWGHU)UHL KHLWGDV HU DP /HLWIDGHQ YRQ +HJHOV 5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLH HQWIDOWHW $XFK KLHU GLHQW +REEHVµ 3RVLWLRQ DOV .RQWUDVWIROLH 'HU HQJOLVFKH 3KLORVRSK ZLUG ]XP 9DWHUHLQHVQHJDWLYHQ)UHLKHLWVYHUVWlQGQLVVHVHUNOlUWGDVGLH$EZHVHQKHLWlXH UHU:LGHUVWlQGHXQGHLQHUHLQLQGLYLGXHOOH3UlIHUHQ]RULHQWLHUXQJDN]HQWXLHUW 6WDWWGHVVHQVLHKW+RQQHWKGHQÄ9ROO]XJYRQ)UHLKHLWDQGLH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHLQHV HQWJHJHQNRPPHQGHQGDVHLJHQH=LHOEHVWlWLJHQGHQ6XEMHNWV³JHNRSSHOWZR]X HVÄ,QVWLWXWLRQHQGHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ>«@EHGDUI³ 'DVVVROFKH ,QVWLWXWLRQHQQLFKWGDV3URGXNWHLQHUDXVGHU1RWJHERUHQHQhEHUHLQNXQIW]ZL VFKHQHLJHQWOLFKYRQHLQDQGHULVROLHUWHQ,QGLYLGXHQGDUVWHOOHQVRQGHUQJHURQQHQH )RUPHQ VLHLPPHUVFKRQ YHUELQGHQGHU9HUKlOWQLVVHLVWGLH+HJHOLP8QWHU VFKLHG]X+REEHV]XJHVFKULHEHQH$QVLFKW'HUSURGXNWLYH&KDUDNWHUGHV.DPS IHVXP$QHUNHQQXQJEHVWHKWGDQQGDULQHEHQGLHVHYRUJlQJLJH9HUEXQGHQKHLW DQV/LFKW]XEULQJHQXPVLHVFKOLHOLFKLQVWLWXWLRQHOO]XYHUREMHNWLYLHUHQ1HJD WLYSKlQRPHQHZLH9HUEUHFKHQ5DXEXQG*HZDOWIKUHQ]XGHQSDUDGLJPDWL VFKHQ.RQIOLNWVLWXDWLRQHQGLH+RQQHWKLQ+HJHOV-HQDHU6FKULIWHQGDUDXIKLQ DQDO\VLHUWILQGHW'LHGDEHLMHZHLOVDXIEUHFKHQGHQ7lWHU2SIHU.RQIURQWDWLRQHQ ZHUGHQVRJHGHXWHWGDVVHVLQLKQHQHLJHQWOLFKXPGLHhEHUZLQGXQJHLQHVPDQ JHOKDIWHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQVJHKWPLWGHPVWHWVGLHHLQ]HOQHÄ3HUVRQ³LPÄ*DQ ]H>Q@DXIGHP6SLHOVWHKW³LP%OLFNDXILKUÄ*DQ]HV]XHLQHPDQVLFKQLFKWL JHQ³]XZHUGHQGURKW 6R]HLJWVLFK]%MHQHULQGHU-HQDHU5HDOSKLORVRSKLHEHJHJQHQGH%HVLW]OR VHZHQQHUHLQHQ$QGHUHQGHUYLHOEHVLW]WDQJUHLIWEHL/LFKWHEHVHKHQNHLQHV ZHJVLQKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKHU0DQLHUYRQ1HLGXQG0LVVJXQVWJHWULHEHQ6HLQH Ä7lWLJNHLWJHKWQLFKWDXIGDV1HJDWLYHGDV'LQJVRQGHUQGDVVLFK:LVVHQGHV $QGHUHQ³GHULKQLQVHLQHPUHLQEHVLW]RULHQWLHUWHQ6WUHEHQDXVJHVFKORVVHQXQG VRKHUDEJHZUGLJWKDW'LHVDEHUZDUQLFKWGLHEHZXVVWH,QWHQWLRQGHV$QGHUHQ± GLHREHUIOlFKOLFKEHWUDFKWHWYRPEORHQ%HVLW]HQZROOHQEHVWLPPWZDU±ZHV KDOELKPGXUFKGHQIUHPGHQhEHUJULIIÄ]XP%HZXWVHLQ>NRPPW@GDHUJDQ] HWZDVDQGHUHVWDWDOVHUPHLQWH³'HU$QVSUXFKGHVHLQHQLQGHQ$XJHQGHV DQGHUHQ%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJILQGHQ]XPVVHQZLUGYRPDQGHUHQGDPLW]XPLQGHVW
+211(7+ (EG 9JODD2± $D2 +(*(/ +(*(/ 9JOLQVJHVDPW]X+RQQHWKV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHU-HQDHU5HDOSKLORVRSKLH +21 1(7+G±LQVEHVRQGHUHDEHUIIIUGLHIROJHQGH'DUVWHOOXQJ +(*(/ 9JOIUGDV)ROJHQGH DD2II $D2
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
HLQ6WFNZHLWDN]HSWLHUW6HLQEHVLW]HUJUHLIHQGHV7XQZDUGHPQDFKYRQMHKHU DXFKGXUFKGLH9HUZHLJHUXQJGLHVHVVWLOOVFKZHLJHQGHQ$QVSUXFKVXQGVRGXUFK HLQHXQXPJlQJOLFKH%H]XJQDKPHDXIGHVVHQ8UKHEHUEHVWLPPWÄ%HLGH3DUWHL HQ³IROJHUW+RQQHWKÄKDEHQVLFKDOVRDOOHLQDXIJUXQGGHVSURSRVLWLRQDOHQ*H KDOWHVLKUHUMHZHLOLJHQ+DQGOXQJVRULHQWLHUXQJHQVFKRQZHFKVHOVHLWLJDQHUNDQQW DXFKZHQQGLHVHVR]LDOHhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJLKQHQWKHPDWLVFKQLFKWSUlVHQWVHLQ PDJ³,KU.RQIOLNWLVWGDPLWQRFKQLFKWHQGJOWLJDXVJHIRFKWHQVRQGHUQJHKW ÄDXI/HEHQXQG7RG³ZHLWHUELVHLQMHGHUVLFKHUJHKHQNDQQÄYRQGHP$QGH UHQDQHUNDQQW]XVHLQLKPDOVDEVROXW]XJHOWHQ³0LWGLHVHPILQDOHQ(UJHEQLV ZLUGDEHUQXUGLHJUXQGVlW]OLFKHVR]LDOH%HGLQJWKHLWLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQV DXIVHLWHQGHV6XEMHNWVHLQJHKROWZRULQGLHSRVLWLYH3URGXNWLYNUDIWGHV1HJDWL YHQGHV.DPSIHVYROOHQGV]XP=XJHNRPPW 'DVVZLH+HJHODQVROFKHQVWLOLVLHUWHQ.RQIOLNWV]HQHQDXI]HLJWÄGLH%LOGXQJ GHV SUDNWLVFKHQ ,FK DQ GLH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ GHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ6XEMHNWHQJHEXQGHQLVW³VWHOOWGHQHUVWHQYRQGUHLVHLQHU*HGDQNHQ GDUGLH+RQQHWKLQVHLJHQH'HQNHQEHUQLPPW=ZHLWHQVLVWGLHVHLQHLP-HQDHU 6FKULIWZHUN]XPLQGHVWLQ$QVlW]HQDQJHOHJWHÄ6WXIHQWKHRULHVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQ QXQJ³ 'HPQDFKODVVHQVLFKGUHL$QHUNHQQXQJVVSKlUHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQLQGH QHQGLHEHVDJWHÃ%LOGXQJGHV,FKµDXIMHVSH]LILVFKH:HLVHYRQVWDWWHQJHKW$QJH IDQJHQEHLGHQIDPLOLlUHQ/LHEHVEDQGHQEHUGLHEUJHUOLFKHQ5HFKWVYHUKlOWQLV VHELVKLQ]XGHQVWDDWOLFKVLWWOLFKHQ6ROLGDULWlWVEH]LHKXQJHQGXUFKOlXIWGDV6XE MHNWGDEHLHLQHQ(QWZLFNOXQJVZHJGHUHVLPPHU PHKUVHLQHUVHOEVWEHZXVVW ZHUGHQOlVVWXQG]XHLQHUVXN]HVVLYHVLFKVWHLJHUQGHQ$XWRQRPLHIlKLJNHLWIKUW 8PJHNHKUW EHWUDFKWHW ZlFKVW LP =XJH GHVVHQ EHL LKP GLH (LQVLFKW DXI GLH $QHUNHQQXQJ$QGHUHUXPVHLQHVIUHLHQ6HOEVWVHLQVZLOOHQNRQVWLWXWLYDQJHZLH VHQ]XVHLQ'DVVGDPLWDEHUNHLQYRQYRUQKHUHLQKDUPRQLVFKHU3UR]HVVDXVJH PDOWZHUGHQVROOVRQGHUQHLQNRQIOLNWUHLFKHV*HVFKHKHQPDFKWGULWWHQVGHU *HGDQNHGHV.DPSIVXP$QHUNHQQXQJNODU 'DV9RUDQVFKUHLWHQGHUÃ%LOGXQJGHV,FKµLP6LQQHGHVGUHLVWXILJHQ0RGHOOV EH]LHKWGHP]XIROJHGLHQ|WLJH$QWULHEVNUDIWDXVEHUVFKVVLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJV HUZDUWXQJHQZLHVLHVLFKHWZDLQGHUDXIGHU6WXIHGHV5HFKWVYHUKlOWQLVVHVDQ JHVLHGHOWHQ.RQIURQWDWLRQYRQ7lWHUXQG2SIHU]HLJHQ'LHVH(UZDUWXQJHQVSHL VHQVLFKDEHUHEHQDXVHLQHUYRUJlQJLJHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWYRQGHUKHUXQGDXI GLHKLQPDQVLFKGDQQUH]LSURNLQGLH3IOLFKWQLPPW+RQQHWKGDYRQZLUGLP QlFKVWHQ$EVFKQLWW]XKDQGHOQVHLQVLHKWGHQGDEHLEHDQVSUXFKWHQQRUPDWLYHQ +RUL]RQWLQGHQIUKNLQGOLFKHQ(UIDKUXQJHQHLQHULQWHQVLYHQ9HUEXQGHQKHLWPLW GHQSULPlUHQ%H]XJVSHUVRQHQYHUDQNHUW)UGHUHQXUVSUQJOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHU
+211(7+G +(*(/ $D2 +211(7+G $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
DXVGHPGDV$QVSUFKHVWHOOHQGH6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQDOOHUHUVWKHUYRUJHKWYHUPDJ HUDXFKLQ+HJHOV6\VWHPGHU6LWWOLFKNHLW%HOHJH]XILQGHQ'RUWNDQQPDQÄGDV 9HUKlOWQLVYRQ(OWHUQXQG.LQGHUQ³DOVHLQHOLHEHYROOH9HUELQGXQJÄDEVROXWH>Q@ (LQVVHLQ>V@³EHVFKULHEHQILQGHQGLHVLFK]XJOHLFKGHU$XVELOGXQJHLQHULPPHU ÄJU|HUH>Q@LQQHUH>Q@1HJDWLYLWlWXQGGDPLWK|KHUH>Q@,QGLYLGXDOLWlW³DXIVHLWHQ GHV.LQGHVI|UGHUOLFK]HLJHQVROO,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWXQG6XEMHNWLYLWlWE]ZVR]LD OH$QHUNHQQXQJXQGLQGLYLGXHOOHV6HOEVWVHLQYHUVHW]W+RQQHWKDXIGLHVHU*UXQG ODJHLQHLQH5DQJRUGQXQJGLHYRQ:KLWHERRNZLHQXQ]X]HLJHQLVWJHUDGH ZHJV XPJHNHKUW ZLUG RKQH GLH HLQH JHJHQ GLH DQGHUH 6HLWH DXI VFKOLFKW DEVWUDNWH:HLVHDXV]XVSLHOHQ
8UVSUQJOLFKH8QYHUEXQGHQKHLW :KLWHERRNV KREEHVLDQLVWLVFKH+HJHOGHXWXQJ :lKUHQG+RQQHWKVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHV3URJUDPPLQ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJ DQ+HJHOV-HQDHU6FKULIWHQDQNQSIWQLPPW:KLWHERRNVGDUDXIEH]RJHQH*H JHQUHGH$QOHLKHQEHLGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLHGHV*HLVWHV'LHYHU|IIHQWOLFKWH 6FKULIWZLGPHWVLFKDXVVHLQHU6LFKWGHPÄ9HUVXFK>«@GHQPDWHULDOLVWLVFKHQ XQG SV\FKRORJLVFKHQ :DKUKHLWVJHKDOW GHV +REEHVLDQLVPXV ]X EHZDKUHQ³ 'DEHLKDWHUYRUDOOHP]HQWUDOH$EVFKQLWWHGHV]ZHLWHQ.DSLWHOVLP%OLFNGDV GHQ7LWHOÄ6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ³WUlJWÄ:LHEHL+REEHVµ*HVHOOVFKDIWVYHUWUDJ³VR EULQJWHUGLHGRUWEHJHJQHQGH$QVLFKWDXIGHQ3XQNWÄ]ZLQJWHLQHVWUXNWXUHOOH 6DFNJDVVH>«@GLH6XEMHNWHLQ:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLWLKUH$OOPDFKWDXI]XJHEHQXQG HLQH%H]LHKXQJPLWHLQDQGHUHLQ]XJHKHQ³'DVVVLHVLFKZLH+HJHOVFKUHLEW ÄDQHUNHQQHQ >«@ DOV JHJHQVHLWLJ VLFK DQHUNHQQHQG³ LVW GHPQDFK HUVW GHU Ä*LSIHOSXQNW HLQHV /HUQSUR]HVVHV³ LP =XJH GHVVHQ VLFK HEHQ NHLQH LKQHQ ÄDQJHERUHQH>@,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWRGHU*HVHOOLJNHLW³VWXIHQZHLVHHQWIDOWHW$P $QIDQJVWHKWYLHOPHKUHLQ6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQGDVQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVVLFKVHOEVW EHJHKUWXQG]XU(UIOOXQJGLHVHUVHLQHU%HJLHUGHGDVLKPEHJHJQHQGH2EMHNW DXVQXW]W(VÄYHUQLFKWHW³ZLH+HJHOVFKUHLEWÄGHQVHOEVWlQGLJHQ*HJHQVWDQG XQGJLEWVLFKGDGXUFKGLH*HZLKHLWVHLQHUVHOEVW³±HLQHYROOHQGVHJR]HQWULVFKH $NWLRQVZHLVH GLH GDV 6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQ DEHU VFKOLHOLFK ]XU JHJHQOlXILJHQ
+(*(/ :+,7(%22. 9JO ]X :KLWHERRNV LP IROJHQGHQ UHNRQVWUXLHUWHU +HJHO $XVOHJXQJLQVJHVDPW DD2± 9JO+(*(/ ±'DEHLKDW:KLWHERRNLQVEHVRQGHUHGHQ$EVFKQLWWDD2 ±YRU$XJHQ :+,7(%22. I +(*(/ :+,7(%22. $D2
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
Ä(UIDKUXQJYRQGHU6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWVHLQHV*HJHQVWDQGHV³IKUW%OHLEWRKQH GDV2EMHNWGLH%HJLHUGHXQJHVWLOOWJHKWGHUHQ%HIULHGLJXQJMHGRFKVWHWV PLW GHVVHQ1HJDWLRQHLQKHUVRGDVVHVLPPHUZLHGHUUHVWLWXLHUW XQGQHJLHUW ZHUGHQ PXVV 8P GHQ GDUDXV HUZDFKVHQGHQ :LHGHUKROXQJV]ZDQJ DG LQILQLWXP ]X GXUFKEUHFKHQEHQ|WLJWGDV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQVDJWLKPQDFK+HJHOGLH(UIDK UXQJHLQHVDQGHUVJHDUWHWHQ*HJHQVWDQGHV0LW+DQV*HRUJ*DGDPHUV,QWHU SUHWDWLRQGHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQV.DSLWHOVDXIGLH:KLWHERRNDQGLHVHU6WHOOH UHNXUULHUWJHVSURFKHQ 1XUHWZDVZDVWURW]VHLQHP1HJLHUWVHLQGDLVWDOVRQXUZDVVLFKVHOEVWQHJLHUWNDQQGXUFK VHLQH([LVWHQ]GHP,FKEHVWlWLJHQZDVHVEHJLHULJDQVWUHEW GDHVQLFKWV]XNHQQHQEUDXFKW DOVVLFKVHOEVW
hEHUGDV9HUP|JHQVLFKVHOEVW]XYHUQHLQHQRKQHGDPLWJOHLFKDP(QGH]X VHLQDEHUYHUIJWHLQ]LJHLQDQGHUHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQ(LQHVVROFKHQEHGDUIGDV Ã,FKµ DOVR XP ]X HLQHU WUDJIlKLJHQ *HZLVVKHLW VHLQHU VHOEVW ]X JHODQJHQ (V ÄHUUHLFKW³ ZLH +HJHO UHVPLHUW ÄVHLQH %HIULHGLJXQJ QXU LQ HLQHP DQGHUHQ 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ³LVWDOVRQXUÄDQXQGIUVLFKLQGHPXQGGDGXUFKGDHVIU HLQDQGHUHVDQXQGIUVLFKLVWGDVKHLW>«@DOVHLQ$QHUNDQQWHV³ :KLWHERRNEH]LHKWDXVGLHVHP*HGDQNHQJDQJNULWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQLP%OLFN DXI+RQQHWKV$QHUNHQQXQJVOHKUH'LHGHUHLJHQHQ6HOEVWEHVWlWLJXQJGLHQHQGH +LQZHQGXQJ]XP$QGHUHQVLHKWHUHUVWHQVSULPlUGXUFKGLHHJR]HQWULVFKH%H JLHUGHGHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQVDQJHWULHEHQQLFKWDEHUYRQVR]LDOHQE]ZVLWWOL FKHQ*HVLFKWVSXQNWHQJHOHLWHW'DIUVSULFKWDXFKHLQ+LQZHLV*DGDPHUVGHQ )RUWJDQJGHV.DSLWHOVEHWUHIIHQG +HJHOV(QWVFKHLGXQJ]XQlFKVWGDVÄ6HOEVW EHZXWVHLQGHV+HUUQ³GHUVLFKVHLQHV.QHFKWHVEHPlFKWLJW]XWKHPDWLVLHUHQ PDFKHGHXWOLFKGDVVVLFKGDV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQÄXPGHU9HUJHZLVVHUXQJGHU $QHUNHQQXQJ ZLOOHQ³ HUVW HLQPDO ÄEHJLHULJ DXI GDV DQGHUH 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ
+(*(/ 9RU]JOLFKJHUDGHLP%OLFNDXIHLQHHUIDKUXQJVQDKH(UVFKOLHXQJGHV6HOEVWEHZXVV WVHLQV.DSLWHOVLVWGLH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ+DQV*HRUJ*DGDPHUV *$'$0(5 ZRHVKHLW Ä1DWUOLFKKDWQLFKWGHUEHVWLPPWH*HJHQVWDQGGHU%HJLHUGHGHUYHUQLFKWHWZLUG6HOEVWlQGLJ NHLW±HUYHUOLHUWVLHMD:DVXQVHUHQ+XQJHUXQG'XUVWVWLOOWLVWHLQEORHV$QGHUHVGHVVHQ 1HJDWLRQ ZLUVLQG $EHU HEHQ GHVKDOE EHGHXWHW GLHVHV VLQQOLFKH 6HOEVWJHIKO NHLQ ZDKUHV 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ'HU=XVWDQGZLOGHU%HJLHUGHHWZDJURHU+XQJHURGHUJURHU'XUVWEH VWHKW]ZDUGDULQQLFKWV]XNHQQHQDOVVLFKVHOEVW1LFKW]XIlOOLJUHGHQZLUYRQ:ROIVKXQJHU RGHU%lUHQKXQJHU GHU+XQJHULVWVRDOOEHKHUUVFKHQGJHZRUGHQGDXQVQLFKWVDQGHUHVHUIOOW DOVZDVGDV7LHUHUIOOWGDVLQGLH(LQGHXWLJNHLWVHLQHU,QVWLQNW]JHHLQJHODVVHQLVWXQGHEHQ GHVKDOEQLFKWHLJHQWOLFKHLQÃ%HZXWVHLQµVHLQHUVHOEVWEHVLW]W'DVGUFNWVLFKGDULQDXVGD GLH%HIULHGLJXQJGHU%HJLHUGHVLFKVHOEHUDOV6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQDXIKHEW'DPLWGLH%HJLHUGH]X ZLUNOLFKHP6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQJHODQJWGDUIGHU*HJHQVWDQGGHU%HJLHUGHLQDOOVHLQHUÃ1LFKWLJ NHLWGHV$QGHUQµQLFKWDXIK|UHQ]XVHLQ³ DD2 $D2 +(*(/ $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
ULFKWHWXQGHVXPVHLQH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW]XEULQJHQVXFKW³(EHQGLHVHUOHLGHW ZLH:KLWHERRN]ZHLWHQVIHVWKlOWGDVIUGLH6HOEVWEHVWlWLJXQJGHVHLQHQJH EUDXFKWHDQGHUH6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQWHLOZHLVHVFKRQGXUFKGLHLKPHLQVHLWLJDEJH Q|WLJWH6HOEVWQHJDWLRQÄ-HPDQGDQGHUHQDQ]XHUNHQQHQKHLW³VRJHVHKHQÄDQ VLFKVHOEVW5DXEEDX]XWUHLEHQ³XQGQLFKW]XVLFKVHOEVW]XJHODQJHQ/HW]WHUHV EOHLEW]XQlFKVWGHPYRUEHKDOWHQGHUVLFKGLHJHZROOWH%HVWlWLJXQJHUVWULWWHQKDW 'HU YRQ +HJHO LP )RUWJDQJ GHV .DSLWHOV PLW GHU HUZlKQWHQ +HUU.QHFKW 7KHPDWLNEHVFKULWWHQH:HJIKUWZLH:KLWHERRNGULWWHQVEHPHUNWOHW]WOLFK]XU Ä(EHQHGHV*HLVWHV>«@RGHUG>HU@,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW³KLQDXIÄ:DVIUGDV %HZXWVHLQZHLWHUZLUG³VFKUHLEW+HJHOLQ9RUDQNQGLJXQJGHVVHQ LVWGLH(UIDKUXQJZDVGHU*HLVWLVWGLHVHDEVROXWH6XEVWDQ]ZHOFKHLQGHUYROONRPPHQHQ )UHLKHLW XQG 6HOEVWlQGLJNHLW LKUHV *HJHQVDW]HV QlPOLFK YHUVFKLHGHQHU IU VLFK VHLHQGHU 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ>H@GLH(LQKHLWGHUVHOEHQLVW ,FKGDV:LUXQG:LUGDV,FKLVW
9RPHLQ]HOQHQ,FK]XU(LQKHLWGHV:LURGHUYRQGHU6XEMHNWLYLWlW]XU,QWHUVXE MHNWLYLWlWIKUWDOOHUGLQJVDXV:KLWHERRNV6LFKWNHLQJHUDGOLQLJHU:HJVRQGHUQ HLQ GDPLW QXU YRUJH]HLFKQHWHU K|FKVW NRQIOLNWUHLFKHU (QWZLFNOXQJVSUR]HVV Ä>'@DV 6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQ >PXVV@ GXUFK HLQH 2G\VVHH OHUQHQ GDV HV VHLQH *UXQGYRUDXVVHW]XQJHQLP*HLVWKDWXQGQXUGXUFKLKQ%HIULHGLJXQJHUODQJHQ NDQQ³'DEHLLVWHVHEHQVRGDYRQDQJHWULHEHQ$QGHUH]X2EMHNWHQVHLQHUHJR ]HQWULVFKHQ%HJLHUGH]XPDFKHQ ZLHJHIlKUGHWYRQ$QGHUHQHEHQGD]XJH PDFKW]XZHUGHQZDVWHQGHQ]LHOO]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHU*HJHQZHKUIKUW,QGLHVHP ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ.RQIOLNWNRPPWGLH1HJDWLYLWlWGHVKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKHQ(UEHV GHXWOLFK]XP7UDJHQ:HLOGLHGDUDQ%HWHLOLJWHQLKUH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWXQGLKU %HJHKUHQGLHVHH[SDQVLY]XU'DUVWHOOXQJ]XEULQJHQQLFKWDXIJHEHQZROOHQ PDQ|YULHUHQVLHVLFKLQHLQHÄVWUXNWXUHOOH6DFNJDVVH³KLQHLQDXVGHUVLHQXU EHLGVHLWLJH 6HOEVWEHVFKUlQNXQJ LQ ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU $QHUNHQQXQJ KLQDXVIKUW 'LHVDEHULVWGDVYRUOlXILJH(UJHEQLVÄHLQHV/HUQSUR]HVVHV>«@GHULQHLQHU DIIHNWLYK|FKVWDXIJHODGHQHQ:HLVHEHJLQQWQlPOLFKPLWGHP.DPSIDXI/HEHQ XQG7RG³'LHGDEHL]XP=XJHNRPPHQGH1HJDWLYLWlW±:KLWHERRNVSULFKW GLHVEH]JOLFKYRQGHUÄ$UEHLWGHV1HJDWLYHQ³ ±GHUHQ*UXQGLQGHUSULPlUHQ 6HOEVWEH]JOLFKNHLWGHV6XEMHNWVOLHJWLVWDEHUQLHPDOVJDQ]HLQ]XKHJHQ9LHO PHKU
*$'$0(5 :+,7(%22. $D2I +(*(/ :+,7(%22. $D2 (EG (EG'LHZLHREHQYHUGHXWOLFKWDXI+HJHO]XUFNJHKHQGH)RUPXOLHUXQJYHUZHQGHWHU LP$QVFKOXVVDQGDVJOHLFKQDPLJH:HUNGHV3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHUV$QGUp*UHHQ '(56
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
PDQLIHVWLHUWVLFK6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQDOVHLQDQGLH2EHUIOlFKHGUlQJHQGHV3KlQRPHQGHV/H EHQVKDUWQlFNLJDOVÃ)UVLFKVHLQµ±$EVFKOLHXQJ±LQ%H]XJDXIVHLQH8PJHEXQJXQGHLQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHV(OHPHQWGLHVHV)UVLFKVHLQVEOHLEWDQLKPDXFKLQGHQVSlWHUHQ>«@LQK|KH UHP0DHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ$XIKHEXQJHQKDIWHQGLHHVGXUFKOlXIW
'DVVVLHGLHVHÄVLJQLILNDQWH'LPHQVLRQYRQ$EVFKOLHXQJXQG)UVLFKVHLQQLFKW EHDFKWHW³VRQGHUQDXVGHUVR]LDOHQ.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV6XEMHNWVXQZHLJHUOLFKGHV VHQ 6R]LDELOLWlW IROJHQ OlVVW ± GDULQ OLHJW IU :KLWHERRN ÄGHU ]HQWUDOH 7UXJ VFKOXVVGHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ3RVLWLRQ³E]ZGHU3RVLWLRQ+RQQHWKV $XFKZHQQVHLQH)RUPXOLHUXQJHQGLHVHQ(LQGUXFNELVZHLOHQQDKHOHJHQJHKW HV:KLWHERRNDEHUOHW]WHQ(QGHVQLFKWXPHLQEORHV$XVVSLHOHQYRQ6XEMHNWLYL WlWJHJHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWÄ'HU$XIEDXGHV%XFKHV³VRVFKUHLEWHUQlPOLFK +HJHOV3KlQRPHQRORJLHEHWUHIIHQGÄPDFKWGHXWOLFKGDVVLQGHUÃ2UGQXQJGHV 6HLQVµ>«@GLH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW>«@LQGHUÃ2UGQXQJGHV:LVVHQVµKLQJHJHQ 6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQXQG6XEMHNWLYLWlW³SULRULWlUVLQG$QGHUVJHVDJW 2KQH)UDJH ILQGHWGHU0HQVFKVLFKLPPHUVFKRQLQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQYRU'RFK VDJWGLHVH7DWVDFKHQRFKQLFKWVGDUEHUDXVZLHHUVLFKVHOEVW]XGLHVHUVHLQHU VR]LDOHQ 9RUILQGOLFKNHLW YHUKlOW =XU DP (QGH GHV YRQ +HJHO EHVFKULHEHQHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVSUR]HVVHVVWHKHQGHQÄ(LQVLFKWGDVVZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ Q|WLJLVW³XPGHVHLJHQHQ6HOEVWVHLQVZLOOHQNDQQHEHQNHLQHUVWHOOYHUWUHWHQG IUGHQ$QGHUHQVRQGHUQQXUMHGHUIUVLFKNRPPHQ'LHVH(LQVLFKWIROJW]XGHP ÄQLFKWDXVHLQHUIUKHUHQ(UIDKUXQJGHU:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLW³RGHUPLW+RQQHWK JHVSURFKHQDXVGHP*HQ|WLJWZHUGHQGXUFKGLH5H]LSUR]LWlWV]ZlQJHMHQHUYRU JlQJLJHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWGHUHQQRUPDWLYHU*HKDOWLQ$QHUNHQQXQJVNlPSIHQ ]XP9RUVFKHLQJHEUDFKWZLUG :KLWHERRNEHVFKUHLEWVLHVWDWWGHVVHQDOV5HVXOWDWHLQHU(UIDKUXQJGHV6FKHL WHUQV:DVVFKHLWHUWLVWGHU9HUVXFKGDVMHHLJHQH6HOEVWVHLQJHJHQGDVGHV $QGHUHQGXUFK]XVHW]HQGHUHEHQVRZLHLFKDXIPLUXQYHUIJEDUH:HLVHÃIU VLFKµLVW'HU]ZLVFKHQGHQ6XEMHNWHQDXVJHWUDJHQHÃ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJµ EULQJWVREHWUDFKWHWNHLQHLKPYRUDXVOLHJHQGH9HUEXQGHQKHLWDQV/LFKWVRQGHUQ IKUWJDQ]LP*HJHQWHLOGLH±JHPlGHUÃ2UGQXQJGHV:LVVHQVµ±XUVSUQJOLFKH 8QYHUEXQGHQKHLWGHU%HWHLOLJWHQYRU$XJHQ'LHVHHUZHLVWVLFKDEHUDOVSUHNlU ZHLOVLHGHQDOOVHLWVHUKREHQHQ$EVROXWKHLWVE]Z$OOPDFKWVDQVSUFKHQ*UHQ ]HQVHW]WZDVLQ)RUPHLQHU6HOEVWEHVFKUlQNXQJ]XJXQVWHQGHV$QGHUHQLQGLYL GXHOOÃJHZXVVWµZLUGÄ,QGHU7DW³VFKUHLEW:KLWHERRNÄEHVWHKWGLHWUDQV]HQ GHQWH)UHLKHLWGHV6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQVGDULQGDVVHVYRQVLFKDEVWUDKLHUHQRGHU DQVHLQHPÃ$QVLFKVHLQµGLH1HJDWLRQYROO]LHKHQNDQQ³$EHUHVNDQQGLHVH
:+,7(%22. (EG $D2 $D2 $D2 $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
1HJDWLRQHEHQIRUWZlKUHQGDXFKDP$QGHUHQVHLQHUVHOEVWYROO]LHKHQGHQQHV EOHLEWZHVHQWOLFKVHOEVWEH]RJHQÃIUVLFKµ9RQGDKHUWHQGLHUWGDV6XEMHNWGD]X LPPHUZLHGHUDXI]XEHJHKUHQJHJHQGLHQ|WLJJHZRUGHQH%HVFKUlQNXQJVHLQHV $EVROXWKHLWVDQVSUXFKV'LHVHV%HJHKUHQGDV:KLWHERRNLQDXVGUFNOLFKHU$Q OHKQXQJDQ)UHXGDXFKDOVÄ$OOPDFKWVVWUHEHQGHU3V\FKH³EH]HLFKQHQNDQQ IKUWDEHUVHLQHUQHJDWLYHQ(LJHQDUW]XP7URW]NHLQHVZHJV]XEORÃQHJDWLYHQµ .RQVHTXHQ]HQ(VLVWVRVFKlUIWHUHLQÄQLFKWQXUHLQHGHUZLFKWLJVWHQ4XHOOHQ GHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ'HVWUXNWLYLWlWVRQGHUQLQVHLQHU1HLJXQJGLHJHJHEHQHQ9HU KlOWQLVVH]XUFN]XZHLVHQ>«@DXFKHLQH4XHOOHGHU.UHDWLYLWlW³'LHVH4XHOOH EULQJW+RQQHWKDXVVHLQHU6LFKW]XP9HUVLHJHQLQGHPHUÄGDV6XEMHNWYRQ$Q IDQJDQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYNRQVWLWXLHUW³VHLQOlVVW 6RZHQLJHV:KLWHERRNDEHUXPHLQEORHV$XVVSLHOHQYRQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWJH JHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWJHKWVRRIIHQEOHLEWHLQHYRQLKPQXUJHVWUHLIWH)UDJHGLH 7KRPDV%HGRUIDXIJHZRUIHQKDW ,VWHVP|JOLFKÄDXI,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW>]X@UH NXUULHU>HQ@³RKQHÄLQHLQHUSUlVWDELOLHUWHQ+DUPRQLHGHU=ZHLVDPNHLW>]X@HQ GH>Q@³QlPOLFKVRGDVVPDQÄGHU.RQIOLNWKDIWLJNHLWGHV6XEMHNWVXQGGHV0LW HLQDQGHUV]ZLVFKHQ6XEMHNWHQHLQHQ3ODW]YHUVFKDIIW"³ %HL-XGLWK%XWOHUGLH ]ZDULQ+RQQHWKVÄUH]LSURNH>U@$QHUNHQQXQJVNRQ]HSWLRQ³HEHQIDOOV3KlQRPHQH ZLHÄ8QWHUZHUIXQJ³Ä.RQIOLNWXQG+HUUVFKDIW³±LP8QWHUVFKLHG]X+HJHO± XQWHUEHOLFKWHWILQGHWNRPPWHLQHVROFKH)RUPYRQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWLQGHQ %OLFN
(EG (EG $D2 %('25) %HGRUIlXHUW HEG$QP GLH9HUPXWXQJGDVVÄ:KLWHERRNGLH )UDJHGDKLQJHKHQGEHDQWZRUWHQ>ZUGH@GDGDV3DUDGLJPDGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW±]XPLQGHVW DOVIXQGDPHQWDOH.DWHJRULH±DXI]XJHEHQVHL$EHUREGLHVGHUJHHLJQHWH:HJLVW³VRIJWHU KLQ]XÄNDQQIUGHQ0RPHQWRIIHQEOHLEHQ³:KLWHERRNDEHUEHUKUWGLHDXIJHZRUIHQH)UDJH ]XPLQGHVWZHQQHUPLW-RQDWKDQ/HDUGDQDFKIUDJWZLHPDQÄÃGLHPHQVFKOLFKH,UUDWLRQDOLWlW HUQVWQHKPHQXQG]XJOHLFKDQHLQGHPRNUDWLVFKHV,GHDOJODXEHQµ³NDQQ :+,7(%22. 'LHVH)UDJHLVWEHL:KLWHERRNYRQGHU8QWHUVWHOOXQJJHWUDJHQGDVVGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWL YLVPXVHLQSROLWLVFKHV,GHDOYHUWHLGLJHQZLOOLP%OLFNDXIGDVGLHQHJDWLYHQ.UlIWHLP6XEMHNW VW|UHQGHUVFKHLQHQZHVKDOEPDQVLHWKHRUHWLVFKZHJ]XHUNOlUHQYHUVXFKW %87/(5'LHHUVWMQJVWLQ,.b+(,02XDIISXEOL]LHUWH'HEDWWH]ZL VFKHQ%XWOHUXQG+RQQHWKKDWIUGDV)ROJHQGHOHLGHUQLFKWPHKUEHUFNVLFKWLJWZHUGHQN|Q QHQ'DVV%XWOHUGRUWDEHUYRQLKUHUVRHEHQ]LWLHUWHQ XQGPLW:KLWHERRNV6LFKWYHUZDQGWHQ +RQQHWK.ULWLNQLFKWDEZHLFKW]HLJHQGLHVHGLUHNWDQ+RQQHWKJHULFKWHWHQ:RUWH Ä6RIRUPH RQHRIWKHVDOLHQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ\RXUSRVLWLRQDQGPLQHKDVWRGRZLWKWKHGLIIHUHQWZD\V WKDWZHWKLQNDERXWQHJDWLYLW\,QP\ YLHZWKHHWKLFDOUHODWLRQDPRQJSHRSOHGHSHQGVRQ DFNQRZOHGJLQJDQGVWUXJJOLQJDJDLQVWWKHWKUHDWRIGHVWUXFWLRQDQGWKDWDJUHVVLRQLVSDUWRI SV\FKLFDQGVRFLDOOLIH%XWIRU\RXQHJDWLYLW\LVFRQFHSWXDOO\VHSHUDWHGIURPUHFRJQLWLRQDQG \RXKROGWKDWQHJDWLYLW\GRHVQRWSURSHUO\EHORQJWRWKH+HJHOLDQHODERUDWLRQRIVRFLDOUHOD WLRQV³ %87/(5
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
-HQVHLWVYRQ6HOEVWJHZLQQXQG6HOEVWYHUOXVW HLQ6HLWHQEOLFN DXI-XGLWK%XWOHU 0HKUDOVGHQNQDSSHQ+LQZHLVÄGDGLH(LQIKUXQJGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJULIIH LQGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLH³QDFKVHLQHP'DIUKDOWHQÄQLFKWVHKUNODUXQGZHQLJ KLOIUHLFKLVW³KDW+RQQHWKLQ%H]XJDXI:KLWHERRNV+HJHO$XVOHJXQJQLFKW]X 3DSLHUJHEUDFKW$OOHUGLQJVKDWHUGLHGXUFK-UJHQ+DEHUPDVYRUJHSUlJWH,QWHU SUHWDWLRQVWKHVHVSlWHUIDOOHQJHODVVHQ+HJHOVÄDQIlQJOLFKH>U@,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLV PXV³VHLVFKOLHOLFKÄHLQHPPRQRORJLVFKHQ.RQ]HSWGHV*HLVWHV³]XP2SIHU JHIDOOHQ6RUFNWEHLLKPDXFKQRFKGDVSRVW-HQHQVHU:HUNLQGHQDOVXU VSUQJOLFKDQJHVHKHQHQÄLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ5DKPHQ>@³HLQ$XV GHP 6HOEVWEHZXVVWVHLQV.DSLWHO GHU 3KlQRPHQRORJLH GHV *HLVWHV YHUPDJ HU GDQQLQHLQHUHUVFKLHQHQHQ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHQ*HGDQNHQKHUDXV]XOHVHQ GDVVÄGLH0|JOLFKNHLWYRQ6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ>«@DQGLH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHLQHU$UW YRQ3URWRPRUDOJHEXQGHQ³VHLGHUHQ3ULQ]LSDXIGHQ1DPHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ ODXWH ÄÃ$QHUNHQQXQJµ³ RGHU ÄGLH ZHFKVHOVHLWLJH %HVFKUlQNXQJ GHU HLJHQHQ HJR]HQWULVFKHQ %HJLHUGH ]XJXQVWHQ GHV MHZHLOV $QGHUHQ³ ZLUG GDPLW ]XP IXQGDPHQWDOHQ 0HFKDQLVPXV HLQHU VR]LDOHQ /HEHQVUHDOLWlW HUNOlUW DXIJUXQG GHUHU GDV 6XEMHNW DOOHUHUVW VHLQHU VHOEVW EHZXVVW ZLUG 'HPJHJHQEHU VHW]W :KLWHERRNZLHJHVHKHQDXIGLH9RUJlQJLJNHLWGHV)UVLFKVHLQV'LHVEHLQKDOWHW GLH7KHVHGDVVMHQHÃZHFKVHOVHLWLJH%HVFKUlQNXQJGHUHLJHQHQHJR]HQWULVFKHQ %HJLHUGH]XJXQVWHQGHVMHZHLOV$QGHUHQµGLH+RQQHWKGHP6XEMHNWDOVSURWR PRUDOLVFKHV $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKDOWHQ XQWHUVWHOOW NHLQHVZHJV GDV *UXQGJHVHW] ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ$JLHUHQVGDUVWHOOW:DVGDVSULPlUVHOEVWEH]RJHQH6XE MHNWDQWUHLEWLVWYLHOPHKU]XQlFKVWXQG]XPHLVWGHU9HUVXFKGHQ$QGHUHQ]X JXQVWHQGHUHLJHQHQHJR]HQWULVFKHQ%HJLHUGHLQGHVVHQ6HOEVWVHLQHLQ]XVFKUlQ NHQ:DVEHL+RQQHWKPRUDOLVFKH6HOEVWEHVFKUlQNXQJKHLWNRPPWVRHUVWHLQ PDODOVHLQYRQDXHQDXIJHQ|WLJWHUXQGHLQVHLWLJHUÃ5DXEEDXDQVLFKVHOEVWµ]X VWHKHQGHUQXUGHUXQHLQJHVFKUlQNWHQ6HOEVWHQWIDOWXQJGHVVLFKJHUDGHDOVVWlU NHUHUZHLVHQGHQ$QGHUHQGLHQW'DVV$QHUNHQQXQJZLHGLHVHQHJDWLYH=XVSLW ]XQJHVQDKHOHJWPLW8QWHUZHUIXQJYHUVFKZLVWHUWLVWELOGHWHLQHVR]LDOSKLORVR SKLVFKH*UXQGDQQDKPHGHUYRUDOOHPDOV*HQGHUWKHRUHWLNHULQEHNDQQWJHZRUGH QHQ-XGLWK%XWOHU$XFKVLHEH]LHKWVLFKIULKUH1HJDWLYVLFKWDXI+HJHOV3Kl QRPHQRORJLHGHV*HLVWHVZHLDEHUVFKOLHOLFKDXFKHLQSRVLWLYHV*HJHQELOG]X HQWZHUIHQ
+211(7+I $QP +211(7+K +211(7+G +211(7+J (EG
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
%XWOHUGLHEHUVLFKVHOEVWVDJWÄDOORIP\ZRUNUHPDLQVZLWKLQWKHRUELWRID FHUWDLQVHWRI+HJHOLDQTXHVWLRQV³JHZLQQWDOOHUGLQJVDXVLKUHU/HNWUHGHU 3KlQRPHQRORJLHGLHIROJHQUHLFKH(LQVLFKWGDVVGLHÄ'\DGH³DOV$XVJDQJVSXQNW ÄHLQHU$QDO\VHGHVVR]LDOHQ/HEHQV³XQDQJHPHVVHQLVW6RVFKUHLEWVLH Ä:HQQZLUGDQDFKIUDJHQZRGXUFK$QHUNHQQXQJHUP|JOLFKWZLUGVWHOOHQZLUIHVWGDVVGDIU QLFKWDOOHLQGHU$QGHUH>«@YHUDQWZRUWOLFKVHLQNDQQGHQQGLHVHU$QGHUH>«@EUDXFKWHLQHQ 5DKPHQXP]XVHKHQXQG]XEHXUWHLOHQZHULFKELQ
'LHVHU%HXUWHLOXQJVUDKPHQLVW%XWOHU]XIROJHÄGXUFKGLH6SUDFKHEHGLQJWXQG YHUPLWWHOW>«@GXUFK.RQYHQWLRQHQGXUFK$EODJHUXQJHQYRQ1RUPHQGLHLK UHP:HVHQQDFKJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU$UWVLQGXQGGLH3HUVSHNWLYHGHUDP$XV WDXVFK%HWHLOLJWHQEHUVWHLJHQ³ 1LFKWGLHDP$XVWDXVFK%HWHLOLJWHQHQWVFKHL GHQGDUEHUZLHVLHGHQMHZHLOV$QGHUHQZDKUQHKPHQ9LHOPHKUUHSURGX]LHUHQ VLHQXUZDVODXWKHUUVFKHQGHU1RUPÄDP6HOEVWIUMHGHUPDQQDQHUNDQQWZHUGHQ NDQQXQGZDVQLFKW³:LH+RQQHWKJHKW%XWOHUGDEHLYRQGHU$QQDKPHHLQHU VFKOHFKWKLQVR]LDOHQ.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV6XEMHNWVDXV'RFKEHLQKDOWHWGHUÄ3UR]H GHU6XEMHNWZHUGXQJ³DXVLKUHU6LFKWHEHQZHLOHUVWHWVLP5DKPHQYRQQRUPDWLY JHSUlJWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQVWDWWILQGHW]XJOHLFKHLQHQÄ3UR]HGHV 8QWHUZRUIHQZHUGHQVGXUFK0DFKW³2GHUDQGHUVJHVDJW Ä'DV6XEMHNWLVWJH Q|WLJWQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJVHLQHUHLJHQHQ([LVWHQ]LQ.DWHJRULHQ%HJULIIHQXQG 1DPHQ]XWUDFKWHQGLHHVQLFKWVHOEVWKHUYRUJHEUDFKWKDW³ZREHLGLHÄ8QWHU RUGQXQJ³XQWHUGHUHQ+HUUVFKDIWÄGHU3UHLV>«@>VHLQHU@([LVWHQ]³LVW'HUYRQ :KLWHERRNDN]HQWXLHUWHÃ5DXEEDXDQVLFKVHOEVWµ%XWOHUVSULFKWDQDORJGD]XYRQ HLQHPVR]LDOLQGX]LHUWHQÃ6HOEVWYHUOXVWµLVWKLHUQLFKWZHLWVWHOOWDEHUIUVLHQXU %87/(5 ;99JOIUGLHIROJHQGH'DUVWHOOXQJLQVJHVDPWGLHNQDSSHXQGSRLQWLHU WH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQYRQ%XWOHUV+HJHO5H]HSWLRQEHL6WHIIL+REX ',(6II %87/(59JO]XGLHVHPLP)ROJHQGHQHQWIDOWHWHQ*HGDQNHQLQWHUVXEMHNWLY VWlQGLJUHSURGX]LHUWHU1RUPHQLQVJHVDPW DD2II $D2 (EG (EG %87/(5 %XWOHUHQWZLFNHOWGLHVHQ*HGDQNHQLP$QVFKOXVVYRUDOOHPDQ0LFKHO )RFDXOWXQG/RXLV$OWKXVVHU 9JODD2±±'LH'RSSHOKHLWYRQ6XEMHNWZHUGXQJ XQG 8QWHUZHUIXQJ YHUVXFKW VLH GXUFK GHQ $XVGUXFN ÃVXEMHFWLRQµ GW Ã6XEMHNWLYDWLRQµ ]X IDVVHQPLWGHPVLHGHQYRQ)RFDXOWYHUZHQGHWHQIUDQ]|VLVFKHQ$XVGUXFNÄDVVXMHWWLVVHPHQW³ ZLHGHU]XJHEHQVXFKW ÄDVVXMHWWLVVHPHQWEH]HLFKQHWVRZRKOGDV:HUGHQGHV6XEMHNWVZLHGHQ 3UR]HGHU8QWHUZHUIXQJ³ DD2 YJODXFKGLH$QJDEHQGHVhEHUVHW]HUV5DLQHU$QVpQ DD2 1DFK 0DJQXV 6WULHWV SODXVLEOHU ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ DEHULVW%XWOHUNHLQHVZHJV DOV 9HUWUHWHULQ GHU SRVWVWUXNWXUDOLVWLVFKHQ 9HUDEVFKLHGXQJ GHV 6XEMHNWV DQ]XVHKHQ ,Q VHLQHQ $XJHQWULWWVLHÄGDV.DQWLVFKH9HUPlFKWQLVGHV$XINOlUXQJVSURMHNWV³EHZDKUHQGGHXWOLFKIU ÄGDV,QWHUHVVHHLQHVÃ,FKµ³HLQÄGDVQLFKWQXUEHVWLPPWVHLQZLOOGXUFKGLHHVYHUPDFKWHQGHQ XQG]XJOHLFKHUP|JOLFKHQGHQ2UGQXQJHQVRQGHUQGDVVLFKLQHLQ9HUKlOWQLV]XGLHVHQEULQJHQ ZLOOGDV±IUHLVHLQZLOOXQG IUGDV6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJVUHFKWDQGHUHUGHUhEHUVHKHQHQXQG GHUXQWHUGHQKHUUVFKHQGHQ2UGQXQJHQ/HLGHQGHQHLQWUHWHQZLOO³ 675,(7 %87/(5
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
HLQH6HLWHGHU0HGDLOOHGDUÄ7KHSULFHRIVHOINQRZOHGJH³VFKUHLEWVLHÄZLOOEH VHOIORVV³'LHVHU3UHLVLVWXQXPJlQJOLFKHU:HLVH]XHQWULFKWHQGHQQVRKHLW HVEHLLKULQDXVGUFNOLFKHP$XVJDQJYRQ+HJHO ÄZKDWHYHUWKHVHOILVZLOOILQG LWVHOIRQO\WKURXJKDUHIOHFWLRQRILWVHOILQDQRWKHU³:HLOHVVLFKEHUKDXSWQXU LP$QGHUHQVHLQHUVHOEVW]XILQGHQYHUPDJZHJHQVHLQHVVR%XWOHUV$XVGUXFN ÄHNVWDWLFFKDUDFWHU³HLJQHWGHP6XEMHNWHLQWLHIVLW]HQGHVÄGHVLUHIRUUHFRJQLWL RQ³GHVVHQ(UIOOXQJVWHWVYHUOXVWEHKDIWHWLVW'XUFKGLHVHV$QHUNHQQXQJVEH JHKUHQQlPOLFKZLUGPDQUHJHOUHFKWÄDXVVLFKKLQDXVJHQ|WLJW³XPVFKOLHOLFK IHVW]XVWHOOHQ GDVVGHUHLQ]LJH:HJ]XU6HOEVWHUNHQQWQLVEHUHLQH9HUPLWWOXQJIKUWGLHVLFKDXHUKDOEGHV HLJHQHQ6HOEVWNUDIWHLQHU.RQYHQWLRQRGHU1RUPYROO]LHKWGLHPDQQLFKWJHPDFKWKDWXQGLQ GHUHQ/LFKWPDQVLFKQLFKWDOV$XWRULQRGHU+DQGHOQGHHLJHQHQ5HFKWVYHUVWHKHQNDQQ,Q GLHVHP6LQQHLVWGDV+HJHO¶VFKH6XEMHNWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHVGDVGHP6FKZDQNHQ]ZL VFKHQ9HUOXVWXQG(NVWDVHQLFKWHQWJHKHQNDQQ
'DVVGDVÃ6XEMHNWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJµGLHVHPÃ6FKZDQNHQ]ZLVFKHQ9HUOXVWXQG (NVWDVHQLFKWHQWJHKHQNDQQµKDWHLQHUVHLWVGHQ&KDUDNWHUHLQHVXQXPJlQJOL FKHQ9HUKlQJQLVVHV$QGHUHUVHLWVDEHULVWGDPLWDXFKJHVDJW :HQQGDV6XEMHNW VLFK PLWMHGHP*HZLQQDQ%HVWLPPWKHLWLPPHUDXFK VHOEVWYHUOLHUWNDQQHV HLJHQWOLFKQLHYROOHQGVEHLVLFKDQJHODQJHQ*HQDXGDUDXVHQWZLFNHOW%XWOHUQXQ GRFKHLQ3RWHQ]LDOVLFKGHP7RWDOLWlWVDQVSUXFKGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ8QWHUZHU IXQJVPHFKDQLVPHQ]XHQW]LHKHQ 'LHVR]LDOHQÄ)XQNWLRQVEHGLQJXQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³]LHOHQDXVLKUHU6LFKW QlPOLFK JHUDGHGDUDXIÄXQVHUH(UIDVVXQJ XQG)L[LHUXQJ³ ]XEHZLUNHQ ÄGDV %HJHKUHQ>QDFK$QHUNHQQXQJ .7@VWLOO]XVWHOOHQXQGGHP/HEHQLQHLQHPEH VWLPPWHQ6LQQHLQ(QGH]XPDFKHQ³3DUDGLJPDWLVFKGDIULVWGDV6FKLFNVDO GHV.QHFKWVLQ+HJHOV3KlQRPHQRORJLHGHUQDFK%XWOHUV/HVDUWÄGXUFK(U NHQQWQLVVHLQHUHLJHQHQ)lKLJNHLW]XU)RUPJHEXQJGLH6WHOOXQJGHV+HUUQ³HLQ
%87/(5EI9JOGD]X DD2II $D2%XWOHUEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLDXIIROJHQGH3DVVDJHDXVGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLH Ä(V LVWIUGDV6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQHLQDQGHUHV6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ HVLVWDXHUVLFKJHNRPPHQ'LHV KDWGLHJHGRSSHOWH%HGHXWXQJ HUVWOLFKHVKDWVLFKVHOEVWYHUORUHQGHQQHVILQGHWVLFKDOVHLQ DQGHUHV:HVHQ ]ZHLWHQVHVKDWGDPLWGDV$QGHUHDXIJHKREHQGHQQHVVLHKWDXFKQLFKWGDV DQGHUHDOV:HVHQVRQGHUQVLFKVHOEVWLPDQGHUQ³ +(*(/ 'DEHLDN]HQWXLHUWVLH QXQGHQ]HLWOLFKSULPlUHQ&KDUDNWHUGHV6HOEVWYHUOXVWVVRGDVVGDV6XEMHNWZHQQHVZDVXP VHLQHUVHOEVWZLOOHQQ|WLJLVWEHUVLFKKLQDXV]X$QGHUHQJHKWQLFKWPHKUDOVHVVHOEVW]XVLFK ]XUFNNHKUHQNDQQ9JO]XGLHVHP0RWLYLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2I %87/(5 II %87/(5E %87/(5D9JO]XLKUHP%HJULIIGHV$QHUNHQQXQJVEHJHKUHQVLQGHPVLH*H GDQNHQ6SLQR]DVXQG+HJHOV]XYHUELQGHQVXFKW DD2II %87/(5 $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
QLPPWQXUXPVFKOLHOLFKÄ+HUUEHUVLFKVHOEVW]XZHUGHQ³ :DVLKP]XYRU DQ5HSUHVVLRQXQG8QWHUZHUIXQJYRQDXHQKHU]XWHLOZXUGHKDWHUJHZLVVHU PDHQGXUFKVHLQH$QHUNHQQXQJDOVVHOEVWlQGLJHV6XEMHNWYHULQQHUOLFKWVRGDVV HUVLFKQXQPHKUEHUHLWZLOOLJVHOEVWYHUVNODYW)U%XWOHUVFKOlJWVLFKGDULQHLQH K|FKVWVXEWLOZLUNHQGH)RUPVR]LDOHUÄ*HZDOW³QLHGHUGLHGDVÄ6XEMHNW>«@VLFK VHOEVWDQWXWXPVHLQHQ6XEMHNWVWDWXV]XVWDELOLVLHUHQ³XQGGHULKPYHURUGQHWHQ Ä3IOLFKW]XU+HUVWHOOXQJGHU,GHQWLWlW³QDFK]XNRPPHQ(V]HLJWVLFKKLHUJH QDXHUJHVDJWÄ>G@LH*HZDOWGHU6SUDFKH³YHUPLWWHOVHLQGHXWLJHU%HQHQQXQJHQ ÄGDV 8QVDJEDUH HLQ]XIDQJHQ XQG GDPLW ]X ]HUVW|UHQ³ 'HPQDFK ÄUXIW³ GLH DQHUNHQQHQGHÄ$QUHGH³DOVMHPDQG%HVWLPPWHVÄGDV6XEMHNWLQV/HEHQ³XQG XQWHUZLUIWHV]XJOHLFKHLQHUIL[LHUWHQ,GHQWLWlWZRGXUFKZLHVFKRQJHVDJWVHL QHPÄ/HEHQLQHLQHPEHVWLPPWHQ6LQQHLQ(QGH³JHPDFKWZLUG,QZHOFKHP 6LQQHDEHUZLUGGHP/HEHQGHV6XEMHNWVVRHLQ(QGHJHPDFKW" 'D]XYHUPHUNW%XWOHU Ä>'@DV/HEHQOLHHVLFKDOVHEHQGDVYHUVWHKHQZDV EHU MHGHQ XQVHUHU (UNOlUXQJVYHUVXFKH KLQDXVJHKW³ XQG YHUZHLVW LP VHOEHQ $WHP]XJDXIHLQÄ%HJHKUHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJ³GDVÄVLFKDOV%HJHKUHQDP /HEHQ³KlOWDQVWDWWÄVLFK>«@LQGHU%HIULHGLJXQJ³HQGJOWLJHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQV ÄDXI]XO|VHQ³:HLOGDVLQLKUHQ$XJHQHNVWDWLVFKVWUXNWXULHUWH6HOEVWQLHPDOV YROOHQGV EHU VLFK YHUIJHQ NDQQ VRQGHUQ VWHWV GHQ GXUFK JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH 1RUPHQ EHVWLPPWHQ 3HUVSHNWLYHQ $QGHUHU DXVJHVHW]W LVW YHUPDJ HV VLFK LP *UXQGH DXFK QLH PLW VLFK LGHQWLVFK ]X ZLVVHQ $XV GLHVHU 1RW PDFKW %XWOHU JOHLFKVDPHLQH7XJHQG -HQHVXQHQWULQQEDUHhEHUVLFKKLQDXVJHKHQ0VVHQ GHV6XEMHNWVZLGHUVHW]WVLFKGHP,GHQWLWlWV]ZDQJ]XUHQGJOWLJHQ5FNNHKULQ VLFKVHOEVW'HPJHPlKHLWHVEHLLKUGDVVGDVÄ%HJHKUHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJ >«@GLH$QHUNHQQXQJ³ ZLH VLHDXIJUXQGVR]LDOHU.RQYHQWLRQHQ]XWHLO ZLUG ÄEHJUHQ]W³ ZlKUHQG GHP EHJHKUHQGHQ 6XEMHNW ÄHLQ>@ hEHUVFKXVV XQG HLQH 8QGXUFKVLFKWLJNHLW³HLJQHW$QGLHVHU6WHOOHLVWDXFKGDVGXUFKGLHÃ*HZDOWGHU 6SUDFKHµ]HUVW|UWHÃ8QVDJEDUHµYRQGHPREHQGLH5HGHZDUQRFKHLQPDOLQV %87/(5 9JO]XLKUHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHU+HUU.QHFKW7KHPDWLNDXIGLHKLHU QXUNXU]HLQJHJDQJHQZLUG DD2±(LQHDXVIKUOLFKH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQILQGHWVLFKEHL .8&+ II $XVGUFNOLFKÄKlOW³%XWOHUPLWGLHVHU/HVDUW+HJHOVÄ7H[WYRUGHU$XIO|VXQJLQGHQ*HLVW DQ³ ',(6 ZDV6WHIIL+REXIROJHQGHUPDHQEHJUQGHW Ä:lKUHQG>«@LQGHU 3KlQRPHQRORJLHGHU.DPSIXPGLH$QHUNHQQXQJOHW]WOLFKLQGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ PQGHWZHLVW%XWOHUGLHVHQOHW]WHQ6FKULWW]XUFNZHLOHVLKU]XIROJHNHLQHIUHLH:HLVHJHEHQ NDQQLQGHUGDVGHQNHQGH6HOEVWVLFKZLGHUVSUHFKHQGH:HOWYHUVLRQHQDQHUNHQQHQN|QQH³ ',(6 %('25) %87/(59JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 II $D29JOKLHU]XDXFKLKUHQ%H]XJDXI$OWKXVVHULQ GLHV II %87/(5 $D29JO]XP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2II $D2 $D2
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
6SLHO]XEULQJHQ HVVWHKWGDQQIUGLHÄDXHUKDOEGHU.DWHJRULHQGHU,GHQWLWlW³ OLHJHQGH'LPHQVLRQGHVHNVWDWLVFKHQ6HOEVW2GHUDQGHUVJHVDJW (VVWHKWIUGDV VLFKGHP6XEVXPPLHUWZHUGHQXQWHUDOOJHPHLQH1RUPHQHQW]LHKHQGH,QGLYLGXHO OH %HL%XWOHU]HLFKQHVLFKVFKUHLEW5DKHO-DHJJLREZRKOVLHÄGLHJUXQGOHJHQG VR]LDOH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV6XEMHNWVEHKDXSWHW³ÄGRFKVRHWZDVDEZLHHLQH5HVW 5RPDQWLNDXWKHQWLVFKHU6XEMHNWLYLWlW³LKUH'DUOHJXQJHQHYR]LHUWHQÄGDV*H JHQELOG HLQHV YRP 6R]LDOHQ XQEHVFKDGHWHQ 6HOEVW³ $QJHVLFKWV GHV JHUDGH 'DUJHOHJWHQLVWGLHVHU(LQVFKlW]XQJ]X]XVWLPPHQ$OOHUGLQJVGHXWHWVLFKEHL %XWOHUGDUEHUKLQDXVDXFKHLQHDOWHUQDWLYHÄ.RQ]HSWLRQYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³DQ GLHQLFKWLQ8QWHUZHUIXQJDXVPQGHQPXVV Ä'LHVHQDFKKHJHOLDQLVFKH$XVOH JXQJ³VR%XWOHU]|JHDXV ÄXQVHUHUJHPHLQVDPHQXQGXQDElQGHUOLFKHQ7HLO EOLQGKHLWLQ%H]XJDXIXQVVHOEVW³GLH.RQVHTXHQ] GDVVZLU]XQlFKVWHLQPDOYRQGHU)RUGHUXQJDEODVVHQGDVVGHU$QGHUHMHGHU]HLWPLWVLFKVHOEVW LGHQWLVFK]XVHLQKDW'LH$XVVHW]XQJGHU)RUGHUXQJQDFK6HOEVWLGHQWLWlWXQGLQVEHVRQGHUH QDFKYROOVWlQGLJHU.RKlUHQ]VWHOOWVLFKVRVFKHLQWPLUHLQHUJHZLVVHQHWKLVFKHQ*HZDOWHQW JHJHQGLHYHUODQJWGDVVZLUMHGHU]HLWXQVHUH6HOEVWLGHQWLWlWYRUIKUHQXQGDXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQ XQGYRQDQGHUHQGDVVHOEHYHUODQJHQ
2IIHQEOHLEWIUHLOLFKLQZLHZHLWHLQVROFKHV$QHUNHQQXQJVLGHDOLQGHVVHQ5DK PHQ ÄGDV6R]LDOH³ ZLHGHUÄLQGHUG\DGLVFKHQ%HJHJQXQJ>«@YHUDQNHU>W@³ ZLUGDQJHVLFKWVGHUZLHYRQ%XWOHUEHVFKULHEHQMHGH]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH %HJHJQXQJLPPHUVFKRQUHJXOLHUHQGHQ1RUPHQXQG.RQYHQWLRQHQEHUKDXSW UHDOLVLHUEDULVW$OVÄQXUVFKZHU]XHUIOOHQ³ FKDUDNWHULVLHUWVLHHVGHQQDXFK (LQKLHUZHLWHUIKUHQGHU'HXWXQJVYRUVFKODJILQGHWVLFKEHL1RWJHU6OHQF]ND 'LHYRQ%XWOHUIDYRULVLHUWH)RUPYRQÄ$QHUNHQQXQJ³VRVFKUHLEWHUÄYROO]LHKW VLFK>«@LQHLQHP$NWGHU=XZHQGXQJ]XP$QGHUHQGHUGLH6XEVXPWLRQXQWHU QRUPDWLYH$OOJHPHLQKHLWQLFKWPHKUP|JOLFKPDFKW³MD]XJOHLFKÄGLH*UHQ]H GLHVHU6XEVXPWLRQ³DQHUNHQQW *HQDXDXIHLQHGHUDUWÄEHGLQJXQJVORVH$QHU NHQQXQJGHV,QGLYLGXXPV³ GXUFKGLHÄKLHUDUFKLVFKH5ROOHQ]XRUGQXQJHQ>«@ DXIJHEURFKHQZHUGHQ³ODXIHLP*UXQGHGDVFKULVWOLFKHÄ/LHEHVJHERW³PLWVHLQHU Ä7HQGHQ]]XUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³KLQDXV 'LH/LHEHHUVFKHLQWVR JHVHKHQDOVHLQHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH9HUKlOWQLVZHLVHLQGHUGHP$QGHUHQMHQVHLWV GHU6RUJHXP6HOEVWJHZLQQRGHU6HOEVWYHUOXVWEHJHJQHWZHUGHQNDQQ6OHQF]ND
(EG 9JOGD]X 6/(1&=.$II -$(**, %87/(5I $D2 $D2 6/(1&=.$ (EG $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
EHWRQWPLWKLQGDVVVLFKGLHVHEHL%XWOHUDQYLVLHUWHÄ'XUFKEUHFKXQJ³GHV]X QlFKVW XQG ]XPHLVW YRUKHUUVFKHQGHQ 8PJDQJV PLWHLQDQGHU GHU HEHQ GXUFK 1RUPHQXQG.RQYHQWLRQHQUHJXOLHUWLVWLP6LQQHHLQHUÄ5HYROXWLRQGHU'HQ NXQJVDUW³MHXQGMHÄHLQVWHOOW³ VROOKHLHQ QLFKWHLQIDFKKHUYRU]XUXIHQRGHU DQ]XHPSIHKOHQLVW $QGLHVHU6WHOOHOlVVWVLFKQXQDXIPRGLIL]LHUWH:HLVH(EHUKDUG-QJHOV5HGH YRQHLQHUJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJLQV6SLHOEULQJHQZREHLDEHUQRFKHLQPDOGHU JHVDPWH$EVFKQLWW]XUHNDSLWXOLHUHQLVW
*RWWDOV*HKHLPQLVGHV6HOEVW WKHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQHQLP *HVSUlFKPLW(EHUKDUG-QJHO Ä'DVVGHU0HQVFKVLFKLQGHQ$XJHQ*RWWHV>«@HUKHEOLFKDQGHUVDXVQLPPWDOV LQXQVHUHQHLJHQHQ$XJHQGDVLVW³DXV(EHUKDUG-QJHOV6LFKWÄGHU*UXQGGDIU GDVVGHUÃ'LDORJµGHU7KHRORJLHPLWGHU3KLORVRSKLH>«@LPPHUZLHGHUGLH)RUP HLQHV6WUHLWJHVSUlFKVDQQHKPHQZLUGXQGDQQHKPHQPXVV³ )UGDVIROJHQGH 9RUKDEHQHLQHUWKHRORJLVFKHQ,QWHUYHQWLRQLQ+RQQHWKV:KLWHERRNVXQG%XWOHUV VR]LDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'LVNXUVEHU$QHUNHQQXQJHUZHLVWVLFK-QJHOV7KHVHDOV K|FKVWDXIVFKOXVVUHLFK$QHUNDQQW]XVHLQEHGHXWHWLP*UXQGHJHQDXGLHV LQ GHQ$XJHQ$QGHUHUHWZDV]XVHLQ:HOFKHQWLHIJUHLIHQGHQ8QWHUVFKLHGHV-QJHO ]XIROJHPDFKWREPDQLPJ|WWOLFKHQRGHULPPHQVFKOLFKHQ%OLFNIHOGHUVFKHLQW VFKlUIWVHLQH5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHGDQNHQVHLQ'HPQDFKVR KDEHQZLUJHVHKHQÄZLUGGHU0HQVFKDOOHUHUVWGDGXUFKHLQ0HQVFK>«@GDHU VLFKYRQ*RWW>«@XQZLGHUUXIOLFKDQHUNDQQWZHL³QLFKWDEHULQGHPHUYHU VXFKWÄVLFKVHOEHUGHILQLWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJ]XYHUVFKDIIHQ³ 'DEHLLVW]XEH GHQNHQGDVVGHU'UDQJ]XP/HW]WHUHQQDFK-QJHODXV/HLVWXQJV]ZlQJHQXQG 6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVLPSHUDWLYHQIROJWGLHIUGDV/HEHQGHU(LQ]HOQHQLQQHU KDOE GHU PRGHUQHQ 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVH QRUPDWLY SUlJHQG VLQG :lKUHQG GHU 0HQVFKLQGHQ$XJHQGHV0HQVFKHQDOVRDOVMHPDQGHUVFKHLQWGHUHWZDV%H VWLPPWHVDXVVLFK]XPDFKHQKDWLVWHUDXV*RWWHV6LFKWYRUXQGXQDEKlQJLJYRQ DOOHPHLJHQHQ7XQOlQJVWVFKRQHWZDV=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHE]ZVR]LDOH$QHU NHQQXQJVRNDQQPDQGLHVDXFKIRUPXOLHUHQLVWDQGLH(UIOOXQJQRUPDWLYHU 9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQXQG6HOEVW%LOGHUJHNQSIW'LHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJ ZLUG KLQJHJHQ RKQH MHGZHGHQ 9RUEHKDOW XQZLGHUUXIOLFK XQG EHGLQJXQJVORV ]XWHLO'HPQDFKKlWWHGLH7KHRORJLH]XP]XUFNOLHJHQGHQDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUH WLVFKHQ'LVNXUV)ROJHQGHVEHL]XWUDJHQ 6LHKlWWHLPEHVDJWHQ6LQQH]XWKHPDWL VLHUHQÄZDVGHU0HQVFKLQGHQ$XJHQ*RWWHVLVW³XPGLH QLFKWQXU VR]LDOSKL
$D2 -h1*(/MI -h1*(/F
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
ORVRSKLVFKH%HVFKUlQNXQJGDUDXIÄZDVGHU0HQVFKLQGHQ$XJHQGHV0HQVFKHQ LVW³ NULWLVFK]XKLQWHUIUDJHQXQG]XNRUULJLHUHQ 9RQGLHVHUNULWLVFKNRUULJLHUHQGHQ6WRULFKWXQJJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQHQVLVW ]XQlFKVWHLQPDO+RQQHWKV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVEHWURIIHQ'HQ0HQVFKHQE]Z VLFKVHOEVWDOVGXUFK*RWWDQHUNDQQW]XYHUVWHKHQKHLWPLW-QJHOJHVDJWHLQHV XQEHGLQJWHQ6HOEVWZHUWHVLQQH]XZHUGHQGHUNHLQ5HVXOWDWHLQHV%HVWLPPWZHU GHQVGXUFKVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJGDUVWHOOW9RUJlQJLJHUQRFKDOVGLH,QWHUVXEMHN WLYLWlWVROlVVWVLFK+RQQHWKJHJHQEHUIHVWKDOWHQLVWDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU3HUVSHN WLYH *RWW DXI GHQ VLFK GDV 6XEMHNW LP *ODXEHQ DOV :RKHU HLQHV GHILQLWLYHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQVEH]LHKWÄ0DQPXGDQQDXVVLFKVHOEHUQLFKWVPHKUPDFKHQ 0DQLVWMDVFKRQHWZDV³EULQJW-QJHOGDVGDPLWHLQKHUJHKHQGH6HOEVWYHU VWlQGQLVDXIGHQ3XQNW'LH)UDJHLVWQXUZDVJHQDXÃPDQµGHP]XIROJHÃVFKRQ LVWµ$XIHLQHSULPlUH6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVLP6LQQH:KLWHERRNVZLOO -QJHOMHGHQIDOOVQLFKWKLQDXV VLHJLOWLKPDXVGUFNOLFKDOV,QEHJULIIGHV6QG KDIWHQ1lKHUVWHKWLKP%XWOHUV*HGDQNHGDVVGDVHNVWDWLVFKVWUXNWXULHUWH6XE MHNWVLFKJUXQGVlW]OLFKVHOEVWHQW]RJHQLVWXQGGHVKDOELQGHQVR]LDOYRUKHUEH VWLPPWHQ,GHQWLWlWHQQLHPDOVDXIJHKW'RFKZLUGGLHVHVIUGHQ0HQVFKHQGHP QDFK ZHVHQWOLFKH 9RQDQGHUZlUWVKHU6HLQ EHL -QJHO QLFKW LQ GHU 6FKZHEH HLQHV]LHOORVHQ%HJHKUHQVJHODVVHQVRQGHUQYHUHLQGHXWLJW8UVSUQJOLFKHUDOV GLH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWLVWDXVVHLQHU3HUVSHNWLYH*RWW 0LWGLHVHUhEHUELHWXQJVWKHVHDEHUJHKWDXFKHLQKHUGDVVGLH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV 6XEMHNWVXPDOOHVR]LDOHQ7RWDOLWlWVDQVSUFKH]XUHODWLYLHUHQHEHQYROOVWlQGLJ DXIHLQHJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJ]XUFNJHIKUWZLUG'DVNRPPWDOOHUGLQJVHLQHU EORHQ3UREOHPYHUODJHUXQJJOHLFK(VLVWGDQQPLW%XWOHUJHVDJWQXQPHKUÄGLH J|WWOLFKH0DFKWGHU%HQHQQXQJ³DXVGHUÄGLHLGHRORJLVFKH.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV 6XEMHNWV³ IROJW GXUFK GLH HV ÄLQV VR]LDOH 'DVHLQ KLQHLQJH]ZXQJHQ ZLUG³ $XFK:KLWHERRNVEHU]HXJHQGHV$UJXPHQWGDIUGDVV]ZLVFKHQGHQ6XEMHNWHQ HLQHÃXUVSUQJOLFKH8QYHUEXQGHQKHLWµYRUKHUUVFKWHQWIDOWHWDXIGLHVHU(EHQH VHLQH:LUNXQJ GDVVHVHLQH6DFKHLVWVLFKYRQMHKHULQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVYHU KlOWQLVVHQYRU]XILQGHQHLQHDQGHUHDEHUZLHPDQVLFKMHLQGLYLGXHOOGD]XYHU KlOW'HQQGHUGDPLWDOVXQKLQWHUJHKEDUDN]HQWXLHUWH6HOEVWEH]XJGHV6XEMHNWV HQWKlOWHLQ1HJDWLRQVSRWHQ]LDOLP%OLFNDXI5H]LSUR]LWlWVHUZDUWXQJHQMHGZHGHU $UWVHLHQHVVR]LDOHRGHUJ|WWOLFKH-QJHOVJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJDEHUNRQIURQ WLHUWLKUH$GUHVVDWHQ]XJHVSLW]WJHVDJWPLWGHUDV\PPHWULVFKHQ9HUKDOWHQVHU ZDUWXQJ]X(KUHQ*RWWHVÃ5DXEEDXDQVLFKVHOEVW]XWUHLEHQµ'DVVÃPDQVFKRQ HWZDVLVWµEHGHXWHWHEHQQLFKWQXUGDVVÃPDQDXVVLFKVHOEHUQLFKWVPHKUPDFKHQ PXVVµ0DQVROOHVDXFKQLFKW*HQDXGRUWPDQLIHVWLHUWVLFKIU-QJHOGLHVQG KDIWH6HOEVWYHUIHKOXQJGHV0HQVFKHQZRHLQHUGHP,UUJODXEHQYHUIlOOWHWZDV DXVVLFKPDFKHQVLFKVHOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKHQ]XN|QQHQE]ZVRJDU]XPVVHQZLH
-h1*(/M )$&,867(6.( %87/(5 %XWOHUUHIHULHUWKLHUHLQHQ*HGDQNHQ/RXLV$OWKXVVHUV
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
HV LKP JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH /HLVWXQJVLPSHUDWLYH VXJJHULHUHQ -QJHOV J|WWOLFKHU $QHUNHQQXQJZRKQWGHPQDFKHLQQRUPDWLYHU$QVSUXFKLQQHGHUGDV6XEMHNW HEHQVR]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHP9HUKDOWHQQ|WLJWZLHGLHVR]LDOHQ9HUKDOWHQVHUZDU WXQJHQGHQHQHVVLFKNUDIWGHV*ODXEHQVVROOHQW]LHKHQN|QQHQ/HW]WHQV(QGHV KDWPDQHVGDQQDEHUDXIGHU(EHQHGHV*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVVHVPLWHLQHUEORHQ 5HSURGXNWLRQGHV=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ]XWXQZRGXUFKKLQWHUUFNVXQWHUPL QLHUWZLUGGDVVPDQYRUDOOHP%HVWLPPWZHUGHQXQG6LFK%HVWLPPHQÃVFKRQ HWZDVLVWµ'HQQGDVLVWPDQVFKOLHOLFKDXFKQXUDXIJUXQGYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJ ZDVZLHGHUXP]XHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQQlPOLFKQLFKWVHOEVWEH]RJHQHQ$XVULFKWXQJ GHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQVYROO]XJVIKUHQVROO $XVGLHVHPYLWL|VHQ=LUNHOEHIUHLWZRKOQXUHLQDOWHUQDWLYHV9HUVWlQGQLVGHV VHQ ZDV ÃPDQµ DXIJUXQG J|WWOLFKHU $QHUNHQQXQJ ÃVFKRQ LVWµ +LHU NDQQ PLW :KLWHERRNDXIGLHSULPlUH6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVYHUZLHVHQZHUGHQ GLHDXVVHLQHU6LFKWMHGZHGHU%H]RJHQKHLWDXI$QGHUHYRUDXVJHKWMDHLQH1HL JXQJ]XU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQE]Z]XU*HJHQZHKUJHJHQMHGZHGHVR]LDOH9HU KDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJEHLQKDOWHW$XFKGLHVEH]JOLFKDEHUJLOW XUVSUQJOLFKHUQRFK DOVMHGHU$NWPLWGHPVLFKGDV6XEMHNWYRU$QGHUHQMHNRQNUHWLGHQWLIL]LHUWLVW LKPDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYH*RWW.HLQ6XEMHNWLVWYRQGDKHUJOHLFK]XVHW ]HQPLWVHLQHQ7DWHQLQGHQHQHVVLFKYRU$QGHUHQDOV%HVWLPPWHV]XP$XV GUXFNEULQJWVRQGHUQXQDEKlQJLJGDYRQLVWHVOlQJVWÃVFKRQHWZDVµ:KLWHERRNV +LQZHLVGDUDXIGDVVGLH7HQGHQ]GHVSULPlUHLJHQVLQQLJHQ6XEMHNWV]XU1HJDWL RQDOOHV1LFKW(LJHQHQVRZRKO'HVWUXNWLRQXQG*HZDOWDOVDXFK,QQRYDWLRQXQG .UHDWLYLWlWPLWVLFKEULQJHQNDQQLVWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGVR]XGHXWHQGDVV HVDXINHLQHVYRQEHLGHQIHVWJHOHJWLVW(VNDQQVRXQGVRXQGLPPHUQRFKDQ GHUVDJLHUHQ.|QQHQKHLWPLWKLQQLFKW0VVHQRGHUJDU6ROOHQ±HLQ8QWHU VFKLHGDXIGHQHVKLHUVWDUNDQNRPPW'HQQZlKUHQG+RQQHWKYRQÄMHQH>P@LP VR]LDOHQ/HEHQVSUR]HYHUDQNHUWH>Q@,PSHUDWLY³VSULFKWGHUÄDOVHLQQRUPDWLYHU =ZDQJ>«@GLH,QGLYLGXHQ]XUVFKULWWZHLVHQ(QWVFKUlQNXQJGHV*HKDOWHVGHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJQ|WLJW³LVWVRJHVHKHQDOOHPZDVGDVLQGLYL GXHOOH6HLQ.|QQHQYRQYRUQKHUHLQQRUPDWLY]XELQGHQEHDQVSUXFKWHLQH$EVD JH]XHUWHLOHQ'LHVVWHOOWDXFK:KLWHERRNDXIVHLQH:HLVHKHUDXVLQGHPHUGLH (LQVLFKWLQGLH1RWZHQGLJNHLWVLFKUH]LSURNDQ]XHUNHQQHQXQGLPMHHLJHQHQ 6HOEVWVHLQHLQ]XVFKUlQNHQDQHLQHXQYHUWUHWEDUVHOEVW]XPDFKHQGH(UIDKUXQJ NQSIW6LHVWHOOWVLFKPLW6OHQF]NDJHVDJWMHXQGMHHLQ$XFKQDFKGLHVHU(LQ VLFKWNDQQGDV6XEMHNWPLWKLQLPPHUQRFKDQGHUVDOVHVVR]LDOYRQLKPHUZDUWHW ZLUGXQGDXFKGDVÃPXVVµQLFKW]ZLQJHQGVFKOHFKWVHLQVRQGHUQGDVÃNDQQµVLFK JHQDXVRJXWDOVSRVLWLYHUZHLVHQ'HPMHGHPEHVWLPPWHQ6RVHLQYRUDXVOLHJHQ GHQJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQNRUUHVSRQGLHUWGLHGDPLWDXVJHVDJ WH)UHLKHLW GLH)UHLKHLWGXUFKQLFKWVXQGQLHPDQGHQIHVWJHOHJW]XVHLQVLFKYRQ DOOHPXQGMHGHPGLVWDQ]LHUHQXQGVWHWVDXFKDQGHUV]XN|QQHQ,KUÃJ|WWOLFKHUµ &KDUDNWHUNRPPWLQLKUHU8UVSUXQJVXQG9RUDXVVHW]XQJVORVLJNHLW]XP7UDJHQ
+211(7+GI
%9RQ+REEHV]X+HJHOXQG]XUFN
VRZLHGDULQGDVVVLHQLFKWDXIHPSLULVFKH3KlQRPHQHUHGX]LHUEDULVW,QLKUHU XQHLQVFKlW]EDUHQ6SRQWDQHLWlWPDFKWVLHSRWHQ]LHOOLPPHUZLHGHUHLQHQÄ$Q IDQJ³ *HQ-RK XQGKDWVLHÄQLHPDQG>«@MHJHVHKHQ³ -RK -RK 0LWHLQHUWUHIIHQGHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJ0D[)ULVFKVJHVDJW ,QGLHVHUGHP J|WWOLFKHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQ GHV 0HQVFKHQ NRUUHVSRQGLHUHQGHQ )UHLKHLW NRPPW Ä*RWWDOVGDV/HEHQGLJHLQMHGHP0HQVFKHQ³]XP7UDJHQDOVÄGDVZDVQLFKW HUIDEDULVW³XQGGDVMHGHP9HUVXFKGHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ(LQ]HOQHQDQHUNHQQHQG ]XHUIDVVHQ*UHQ]HQVHW]W +LHUNRPPW-XGLWK%XWOHUPLWLKUHU.ULWLNDQDOOHQ9HUVXFKHQ]XHLQHUDE VFKOLHHQGHQ6HOEVWLGHQWLWlW]XJHODQJHQXQGGHQGDIUJUXQGOHJHQGHQJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKHQ1RUPHQXQG.RQYHQWLRQHQLQV6SLHO6LHVWLPPWJUXQGVlW]OLFKPLW -QJHOV'LDJQRVHEHUHLQGDVVVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJDQGLH(UIOOXQJQRUPDWL YHU9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQXQG6HOEVW%LOGHUJHNQSIWLVWGHQHQ]XIROJHÃPDQ HWZDVDXVVLFKPDFKHQPXVVµ%XWOHUVRKDEHQZLUJHVHKHQVXFKWQDFKHLQHP *HJHQELOG HLQH]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJGLHYRQGHU%HJUHQ]WKHLW DOOHU6HOEVWELOGHUXQG,GHQWLWlWVNRQVWUXNWLRQHQDXVJHKWXQGVRN|QQWHPDQVD JHQGHP$QGHUHQVHLQ*HKHLPQLVOlVVW*RWWDOV*HKHLPQLVGHV6HOEVW±VROlVVW VLFKGDUDQGHQ7LWHOYRQ-QJHOV+DXSWZHUNPRGLIL]LHUHQGDQNQSIHQ,QGLH VHP6LQQHZUGHGLHVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVHOEVWÃJ|WWOLFKµZHQQHVLQLKUJH OlQJH GDV $QGHUVN|QQHQ GHV $QGHUHQ DQ]XHUNHQQHQ VHLQH )UHLKHLW DOVR LQ NHLQHQVHOEVWJHZlKOWHQRGHU DXFKYRQ*RWW IUHPGEHVWLPPWHQ%LOGHUQVHLQHU VHOEVW DXI]XJHKHQ Ä'X VROOVW GLU NHLQ %LOGQLV PDFKHQ KHLW HV YRQ *RWW³ VFKUHLEWGHUEHUHLWV]LWLHUWH0D[)ULVFKZREHLHUÄ*RWW³ZLHJHVDJWÄDOVGDV /HEHQGLJHLQMHGHP0HQVFKHQGDVZDVQLFKWHUIDEDULVW³YHUVWHKW(UIJW KLQ]X Ä(VLVWHLQH9HUVQGLJXQJGLHZLUVRZLHVLHDQXQVEHJDQJHQZLUGIDVW RKQH8QWHUODZLHGHUEHJHKHQ±$XVJHQRPPHQZHQQZLUOLHEHQ³0LWOLHEHQ GHP%OLFNEHWUDFKWHWHUVFKHLQHGHUDQGHUH0HQVFKÄZLHGDV$OOZLH*RWWHV XQHUVFK|SIOLFKH *HUlXPLJNHLW VFKUDQNHQORV DOOHV 0|JOLFKHQ YROO DOOHU *H KHLPQLVVH YROO XQIDEDU³ 'HPHQWJHJHQ ]HLJH VLFK ÄGDV (QGH GHU /LHEH³ GDULQGDVVGHUJHOLHEWHÄ0HQVFKIHUWLJIUXQV³VHLÄHLQHUUHJHQGHV5lWVHOGDV DXV]XKDOWHQZLUPGHJHZRUGHQVLQG0DQPDFKWVLFKHLQ%LOGQLV'DVLVWGDV /LHEORVHGHU9HUUDW³ 'LH.RLQ]LGHQ]GHV6R]LDOHQXQGGHV*|WWOLFKHQVROlVVWVLFKGDUDXVVFKOLH HQKDWLKUHIUHLVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGHQ0RPHQWHXQG6LWXDWLRQHQDEHUVLHOlVVWVLFK QLFKW DXI 'DXHU VWHOOHQ 6LH EOHLEW ]XGHP DXI GHQ VR]LDOHQ 1DKEHUHLFK EH VFKUlQNWZDVDXFKNDXPDQGHUVZQVFKHQVZHUWZlUH9LHOPHKULVWHVDXVJXWHQ *UQGHQ]XQlFKVWXQG]XPHLVWVRZLH$UPLQ1DVVHKLWUHIIHQGIRUPXOLHUW Ä$P
)5,6&+ (EG (EG (EG $D2I
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
HKHVWHQN|QQHZLUGLH:HOWNDONXOLHUHQ±LPZDKUVWHQ6LQQHDOVREHUHFKQHQ± ZHQQVLFKGLH$QGHUHQlKQOLFKYHUKDOWHQZLHZLUVHOEVW³ZHVKDOEÄZLUXQVGHU >«@+HUVWHOOXQJYRQ9HUWUDXWKHLW>EHKHOIHQ@GXUFK>«@GLHhEHUZLQGXQJYRQ )UHPGKHLWGXUFK*HZRKQKHLWHQ(UZDUWXQJHQXQG5RXWLQHQ³$OOHVDQGHUH ZlUHHLQSHUPDQHQWHU$XVQDKPH]XVWDQG'HQQRFKKDWGLHLQVROFKHQÃ*HZRKQ KHLWHQ(UZDUWXQJHQXQG5RXWLQHQµVLFKQLHGHUVFKODJHQGHÄVR]LDOH2UGQXQJ³ HLQHQ:LHGHUKDNHQLQGHU)UHLKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVDXIGLHGLH5HGHYRQGHVVHQ J|WWOLFKHP$QHUNDQQWVHLQ]LHOW.UDIWLKUHUNDQQHVLPPHUDXFKDQGHUVDOVYRQ LKPHUZDUWHWZLUG 0LW:KLWHERRNJHVSURFKHQ 'DV6XEMHNWLVWEHIlKLJWÄGLHJHJHEHQHQ9HU KlOWQLVVH ]XUFN]XZHLVHQ³ XQG QDFK HLJHQHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ ]X DJLHUHQ ± HLQ 9HUP|JHQGDVHUZLHREHQJHVDJWDXFKDXIGDVÄ$OOPDFKWVVWUHEHQGHU3V\ FKH³]XUFNIKUHQNDQQ'LHVH)RUPXOLHUXQJVROODXVGUFNOLFKDQ0RWLYHDXV GHU7ULHEWKHRULH6LJPXQG)UHXGVHULQQHUQGHP:KLWHERRNHEHQIDOOVKREEHVLD QLVWLVFKH=JH]XVFKUHLEW,P=XJHGHVVHQZHQGHWHUVLFKJHJHQ+RQQHWKVÄ9HU VXFKGLH3V\FKRDQDO\VHPLWHLQHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ3RVLWLRQ]XYHUELQ GHQ³'DEHLZUGHQQlPOLFKGLHYRQ)UHXGDXIJHGHFNWHQÄDQWLVRFLDOIRUFHV >«@LQWKHKXPDQSV\FKH³]XJXQVWHQGHUÄSURVRFLDODVSHFWVRIRXUSV\FKRORJL FDOLQKHULWDQFH³GHXWOLFKXQWHUEHVWLPPW'DYRQLVWQXQ]XKDQGHOQ
1$66(+, (EG :+,7(%22. $D2 :+,7(%22.
%+RQQHWKYV:KLWHERRN,, 9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWW XQG]XUFN (LQOHLWXQJ 2PQLSRWHQFHRUIXVLRQ" Ä+RPRKRPLQLOXSXV ZHUKDWQDFKDOOHQ(UIDKUXQJHQGHV/HEHQVXQGGHU*H VFKLFKWHGHQ0XWGLHVHQ6DW]]XEHVWUHLWHQ"³IUDJW6LJPXQG)UHXGLQVHLQHU HUVFKLHQHQ6FKULIW'DV8QEHKDJHQLQGHU.XOWXU'DVVGHU0HQVFKGHP 0HQVFKHQ ]XP :ROIH ZUGH JlEH HV NHLQH VHLQ *HZDOWSRWHQ]LDO ]lKPHQGH VWDDWOLFKH2UGQXQJZDU7KRPDV+REEHVµHUNOlUWHhEHU]HXJXQJ$XFK)UHXG ZHLXPÄ>G@LH([LVWHQ]GLHVHU$JJUHVVLRQVQHLJXQJGLH>«@XQVHU9HUKlOWQLV ]XP1lFKVWHQVW|UWXQGGLH.XOWXU]XLKUHP$XIZDQGQ|WLJW³VR]LDEOH6XEMHNWH KHUDQ]XELOGHQÄ,QIROJHGLHVHUSULPlUHQ)HLQGVHOLJNHLWGHU0HQVFKHQJHJHQHL QDQGHU³VRIlKUWHUIRUWÄLVWGLH.XOWXUJHVHOOVFKDIWEHVWlQGLJYRP=HUIDOOEH GURKW³ZHVKDOEVLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHHU]LHKHULVFKH*HJHQPDQDKPHQHUJUHLIW (VVLQG$XVVDJHQZLHGLHVHGLHHVlXHUVWQDKHOHJHQ)UHXGLQHLQHKREEH VLDQLVWLVFKH 7UDGLWLRQVOLQLH ]X VWHOOHQ )U :KLWHERRN GHU VLFK VHOEVW DOV ÄFORVH>@WRD)UHXGLDQSHVVLPLVW³EH]HLFKQHWYHUELQGHWVLFKGDPLWHLQHHUQHXWH *HJHQZHKUJHJHQGHQ'HXWXQJVDQVSUXFKGHVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ3DUDGLJPDV ±GLHVPDODOOHUGLQJVLQ%H]XJDXIGHVVHQSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKH6SLHODUW'DVVVHLQ :LGHUSDUWDXFKKLHU$[HO+RQQHWKKHLWKlQJWPLWGHU5H]HSWLRQHLQHUGH]LGLHUW SRVWIUHXGLDQLVFKHQ ZHLO EH]LHKXQJVRULHQWLHUWHQ 7KHRULHELOGXQJ LQ GHU 3V\ FKRDQDO\VH ]XVDPPHQ GLH EHL GLHVHP VHLW .DPSI XP $QHUNHQQXQJ KlXILJHU
)5(8' D'DVVÄGHU0HQVFK>«@HLQ:ROIIUGHQ0HQVFKHQ³LVWVWHOOW+REEHV LP:LGPXQJVVFKUHLEHQVHLQHU6FKULIW'H&LYHKHUDXV +2%%(6 (VKHLWDEHUGRUW GDVVÄVLFKHUEHLGH6lW]HZDKU³VLQG 'HU0HQVFKLVWHLQ*RWWIUGHQ0HQVFKHQXQG 'HU 0HQVFKLVWHLQ:ROIIUGHQ0HQVFKHQ³ HEG ±ZREHLHVZLH+HUIULHG0QNOHUVFKUHLEWÄYRQ GHUSROLWLVFKHQ2UJDQLVDWLRQGHU9HUKlOWQLVVHXQWHUGHQHQGLH0HQVFKHQMHZHLOV]XHLQDQGHULQ %H]LHKXQJWUDWHQ³DEKLQJÄZHOFKH(LJHQVFKDIWMH]HQWUDOZDUGDV:|OILVFKHRGHUGDV*|WWOL FKH³ 0h1./(5 )5(8' D (EG 9JOHWZD:KLWHERRNV$XVVDJHQLQ :+,7(%22. +211(7+:+,7(%22. +211(7+:+,7(%22.
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
EHJHJQHW,QVEHVRQGHUH+RQQHWKV%H]XJQDKPHDXIGDV:HUN'RQDOG::LQ QLFRWWVLVW:KLWHERRNGDEHLHLQ'RUQLP$XJHÄ>/@LNHWKHUHODWLRQDODQDO\VWV³ VRKHEWHUNULWLVFKKHUYRUÄKHWHQGVWRPDNHVHOHFWLYHXVHRI:LQQLFRWW³'HQ HQJOLVFKHQ.LQGHUDU]WXQG3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHUOLHVW:KLWHERRNQLFKWQXUDOVHLQHQ 7KHRUHWLNHULQGHVVHQ:HUNDQGHUVDOVEHL)UHXGGLH%HGHXWXQJGHULQWHUDNWLYHQ 0XWWHU.LQG%H]LHKXQJ IU GHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVSUR]HVV GHV 6XEMHNWV JURJH VFKULHEHQZLUG'DUEHUKLQDXVVWHOOWHUIHVW Ä:LQQLFRWWZDVDWKHRULVWRIRPQL SRWHQFHHYHU\ELWDVPXFKDV)UHXG³(VLVWDXVVHLQHU6LFKWGLH$QQDKPHHLQHV LQGHU3V\FKHVHLWIUKNLQGOLFKHU=HLWWLHIYHUDQNHUWHQ$OOPDFKWVEHJHKUHQVZDV EHLGHQ'HQNHUQDOVKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKDQWLVR]LDOHV0RWLYWURW]DOOHU8QWHUVFKLHGH JHPHLQVDPLVW+RQQHWKVRVHLQ9RUZXUIHQW]LHKWVLFKGLHVHU$QVLFKWHLQPDO PHKU]XJXQVWHQVHLQHVÄPXFK>«@PRUHVRFLDEOHYLHZ³
(LQVFKOlJLJDQGLHVHU6WHOOHVLQGDXHU.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJYDGLHIROJHQGHQ6WX GLHQ +211(7+D E E G I D E$OOHUGLQJVKDWVLFK+RQ QHWKYRQHLQHUVHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHHLJQHQGHQÄ7HQGHQ]]XUhEHUSV\FKRORJLVLHUXQJ³ %2/7$16., +211(7+ VFKOLHOLFK ]XJXQVWHQ HLQHV VWlUNHU KLVWRULVFK VR]LRORJLVFKHQ$QVDW]HVGLVWDQ]LHUW YJODD2 I 'LHVH(QWZLFNOXQJVFKOlJWVLFKZLHHU HEGVHOEVWVFKUHLEW]XHUVWLQVHLQHU'HEDWWHPLW1DQF\)UDVHUEHU8PYHUWHLOXQJRGHU$QHU NHQQXQJ"QLHGHU YJO)5$6(5+211(7+ XQGNXOPLQLHUWLQ'DV5HFKWGHU)UHLKHLW YJO+211(7+ GDVNHLQHUOHLGLUHNWH%H]XJQDKPHQDXIGLHSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKH7KHRULH ELOGXQJPHKUHQWKlOW(EHQVRYHUKlOWHVVLFKDXFKPLWVHLQHPMQJVWHUVFKLHQHQ$XIVDW]EDQG 'LH$UPXWXQVHUHU)UHLKHLWZRHU]ZDULQHLQHU6WXGLHDXI)UHXGXQG0LWVFKHUOLFK]XVSUH FKHQNRPPWGHUHQJHVHOOVFKDIWVWKHRUHWLVFKH$QQDKPHQMHGRFKDEVFKOlJLJEHXUWHLOW '(56 D ,P5DKPHQHLQHVSXEOL]LHUWHQ*HVSUlFKHVPDFKW+RQQHWKLQ%H]XJDXI3DVVDJHQ LQVHLQHU+DELOLWDWLRQVVFKULIWGHXWOLFKLQGHQHQHUPLWKLOIHYRQ(UNHQQWQLVVHQGHU6lXJOLQJV IRUVFKXQJDUJXPHQWLHUW Ä,FKELQPLUQLFKWPHKUJDQ]VLFKHUREPHLQHGDPDOLJHQ$XVVDJHQ WDWVlFKOLFKULFKWLJVLQG*HZLVVMHGHV.LQGLVWDXIGLH]XZHQGXQJVYROOH/LHEH6RUJHXQG 3IOHJHVHLQHUSULPlUHQ%H]XJVSHUVRQHQDQJHZLHVHQXPEHUKDXSWHLQHQWZLFNOXQJVIlKLJHU 0HQVFKZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQ±GDUDQGUIWHVLFKEHUGLH-DKUWDXVHQGHKLQZHJQLFKWVJHlQGHUW KDEHQZLHMDGLH8QWHUVXFKXQJHQYRQ-RKQ%RZOE\XQGYLHOHQDQGHUHQEHU]HXJHQGJH]HLJW KDEHQ,Q]ZLVFKHQDEHUELQLFKGDYRQEHU]HXJWGDVVGLHVHOLHEHYROOH=XZHQGXQJMHQVHLWV LKUHVDQWKURSRORJLVFKHUIRUGHUOLFKHQ0LQLPXPVMHQDFKKLVWRULVFKHQ8PVWlQGHQVHKUYHU VFKLHGHQH)RUPHQDQQHKPHQNDQQ LQ$EKlQJLJNHLWGDYRQZLHGDVNOHLQH.LQGLQHLQHU.XO WXUZDKUJHQRPPHQXQGDGUHVVLHUWZLUG>«@XQGNHLQH)UDJHLVWHVGDQQGDVVVLFKDXFKGLH HQWVWHKHQGHQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQXQG&KDUDNWHUIRUPDWLRQHQLQ$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQGLHVHQ8QWHU VFKLHGHQLQGHUVR]LDOHQ0LNURSK\VLNOLHEHYROOHU=XZHQGXQJHUKHEOLFKYRQHLQDQGHUXQWHU VFKHLGHQ GUIWHQ³ %(51(5=803) 'LHV EHGHXWHW MHGRFK NHLQH JUXQGVlW]OLFKH $EVDJHDQVHLQHQLP)ROJHQGHQQDFKJH]HLFKQHWHQ5HNXUVDXI6lXJOLQJVIRUVFKXQJXQG3V\ FKRDQDO\VH±YJOHWZDDXFKVHLQH$XVVDJHQLP6WUHLWJHVSUlFKPLW:KLWHERRN +211(7+ :+,7(%22.±VRQGHUQQXUHLQH5HODWLYLHUXQJE]Z.RQWH[WXDOLVLHUXQJGHVGDPLWHUKR EHQHQ *HOWXQJVDQVSUXFKV XQEHVFKDGHW IUHLOLFK GHV ÃDQWKURSRORJLVFK HUIRUGHUOLFKHQ 0LQL PXPVµDQOLHEHYROOHU=XZHQGXQJGHVVHQHLQMHGHU0HQVFKEHGDUIXQGGDVVHLQH3HUV|QOLFK NHLW]XWLHIVWSUlJW:LHZLUQRFKVHKHQZHUGHQLVWVFKRQGLHVDEHUHLQHJHKDOWYROOH7KHVH :+,7(%22. +211(7+:+,7(%22.,P2ULJLQDONXUVLY $D2
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
1LFKW GLH )HLQGVHOLJNHLW YRQHLQDQGHU XQWHUVFKLHGHQHU XQG GXUFK 2PQLSR WHQ]ZQVFKHDQJHWULHEHQHU6XEMHNWHELOGHWIU+RQQHWKQlPOLFKGHQ$XVJDQJV SXQNW,P$QVFKOXVVDQ:LQQLFRWWVWHOOWHUHLQ6WUHEHQQDFKGHU:LHGHUKROXQJ LQWHQVLYHUIUKNLQGOLFKHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWVHUIDKUXQJHQDOVSULPlUKLQ2PQLSR WHQFHRUIXVLRQ"±VRZHUGHQGLHGLIIHULHUHQGHQ3RVLWLRQHQ+RQQHWKVXQG:KLWH ERRNVLP7LWHOHLQHVSXEOL]LHUWHQ6WUHLWJHVSUlFKV]ZLVFKHQEHLGHQDXIGHQ 3XQNWJHEUDFKW:LH+RQQHWKVHLQH6LFKWLP5HNXUVDXI3V\FKRDQDO\VHXQG 6lXJOLQJVIRUVFKXQJLQVEHVRQGHUHDEHUDXI(LQVLFKWHQ:LQQLFRWWVLP(LQ]HOQHQ EHJUQGHWVROOQXQ]XU'DUVWHOOXQJNRPPHQ XPGDQDFK:KLWHERRNVZLGHU VSUHFKHQGH3HUVSHNWLYHYRU$XJHQ]XIKUHQ %HLGHYHUELQGHQPLWLKUHP MHZHLOLJHQ=XJULIIDXIGLHIUKNLQGOLFKH(QWZLFNOXQJVSKDVHHLQJHVHOOVFKDIWVNUL WLVFKHV $QOLHJHQ GDV PLW GHU 6XFKH QDFK HLQHU LQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ ,QVWDQ] GHU 7UDQV]HQGHQ]HLQKHUJHKW 'LHVZLUGVFKOLHOLFKPLW)DON:DJQHUVUHOLJLRQV WKHRUHWLVFKHP0RWLYGHULPPDQHQWHQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]LQV*HVSUlFKJHEUDFKW
9HUVFKPHO]XQJVVHKQVFKWH +RQQHWKVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKH :LQQLFRWWGHXWXQJ Ä>:@HKDYHEHHQOLYLQJLQDQHVVHQWLDOO\SRVW)UHXGLDQHUD³VFKUHLEW6WHSKHQ $0LWFKHOO LP5FNEOLFNDXIGLHYRUDQJHJDQJHQHQ-DKU]HKQWHSV\FKRDQD O\WLVFKHU7KHRULHELOGXQJ1LFKWYRQGHUIUHXGVFKHQ7ULHEOHKUHVHLHQ]XOHW]WGLH ÄELJLGHDV³DXVJHJDQJHQVRQGHUQYRQHLQHP$QVDW]GHQHU JHPHLQVDP PLWVHLQHP.ROOHJHQ-D\5*UHHQEHUJDXIGHQ1DPHQÄWKHUHODWLRQDOPRGHO³ JHWDXIW KDWÄ,QWKLVYLVLRQ³ VRFKDUDNWHULVLHUW0LWFKHOOGLH%HVRQGHUKHLWGHU UHODWLRQVRULHQWLHUWHQ6LFKWLP*HJHQVDW]]XUYRUKHUGRPLQLHUHQGHQÄRQHSHUVRQ >«@SV\FKRORJ\³ WKHEDVLFXQLWRIVWXG\LVQRWWKHLQGLYLGXDODVDVHSHUDWHHQWLW\ZKRVHGHVLUHVFODVKZLWKDQ H[WHUQDOUHDOLW\EXWDQLQWHUDFWLRQDOILHOGZLWKLQZKLFKWKHLQGLYLGXDODULVHVDQGVWUXJJOHVWR PDNHFRQWDFWDQGWRDUWLFXODWHKLPVHOI>«@7KHSHUVRQLVFRPSUHKHQVLEOHRQO\ZLWKLQWKLV WDSHVWU\RIUHODWLRQVKLSV>«@
=XGHQ:HJEHUHLWHUQGLHVHVEHWRQWSRVWIUHXGLDQLVFKHQÃUHODWLRQDOPRGHOVµ]lKOW 0LWFKHOOXD'RQDOG::LQQLFRWW'DVLVWHLQH=XRUGQXQJGLHDXFKIU+RQ QHWKDXHU)UDJHVWHKW6RXQWHUVWUHLFKWHULQ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJGDVV:LQ QLFRWWHLQHÄLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRUHWLVFKH(UZHLWHUXQJGHVSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKHQ
9JO DD2 9JO ]XP (QWVWHKXQJVNRQWH[W GHV *HVSUlFKV GLH $QJDEHQ LQ $//(1 2µ&21125 DI 0,7&+(// ,P2ULJLQDONXUVLY (EG9JOGD]X *5((1%(5*0,7&+(// 0,7&+(// $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
(UNOlUXQJVUDKPHQV³HQWVFKHLGHQGYRUDQJHWULHEHQKDWZHLOLQVHLQHQ6FKULIWHQ GHU KRKH Ä6WHOOHQZHUW IUKNLQGOLFKHU ,QWHUDNWLRQVHUIDKUXQJHQ³ DN]HQWXLHUW ZLUG'HPJHKWHLQIRUVFKXQJVJHVFKLFKWOLFKHU$EULVVYRUDXVGHUXQWHU9HUZHLV DXI0LWFKHOOVXQG*UHHQEHUJV8QWHUVXFKXQJHQGLH+LQZHQGXQJ]XHLQHUVWlUNHU UHODWLRQVRULHQWLHUWHQ6LFKWGHV0HQVFKHQLQGHU3V\FKRDQDO\VHQDFK]HLFKQHW +RQQHWKIKUWGDIU6WXGLHQDXVGHP%HUHLFKGHU6lXJOLQJVE]Z.OHLQNLQGIRU VFKXQJ GHU HU-DKUHDQ ]% 'DQLHO 6WHUQV :HUN 7KH ILUVW UHODWLRQVKLS ,QIDQWDQG0RWKHUGDVVFKRQLP7LWHOGHQXUDQIlQJOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHUGHV,QWHU VXEMHNWLYHQ EHWRQW ,P VFKDUIHQ .RQWUDVW GD]X VWHKW )UHXGV DOV ÄÃPRQROR JLVFK>@µ³EH]HLFKQHWHVÄ%LOGYRQGHUSV\FKLVFKHQ(QWZLFNOXQJGHV.LQGHV³ GDVZHLWHQWHLOVGLHÄ%H]LHKXQJHQ]XDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQQXUDOVHLQHEORH)XQN WLRQLQGHU(QWIDOWXQJGHUOLELGLQ|VHQ7ULHEH³DQVLFKWLJPDFKW'HVVHQ'HX WXQJVDQVSUXFKVR+RQQHWKYHUPDJQLFKWOlQJHU]XIROJHQZHUVLFKGXUFKGHQ UHODWLRQDOHQ$QVDW]EHOHKUHQOlVVW'HPQDFKLVWHVQlPOLFKHLQ]LJXQGDOOHLQ ÄMHQH>@XQDEKlQJLJH'LPHQVLRQVR]LDOHU,QWHUDNWLRQHQLQQHUKDOEGHUHUGDV.LQG VLFK³YHUPLWWHOWÄGXUFKGLHHPRWLRQDOH%LQGXQJ]XDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQ³ÄDOVHLQ HLJHQVWlQGLJHV6XEMHNW]XEHJUHLIHQOHUQW³ 1XULQPLWWHQGHVVLHXPJHEHQGHQ Ã*HZHEHVYRQ%H]LHKXQJHQµLQQHUKDOEGHVVHQVLHDOOHUHUVWHQWVWHKWVHLGLHLQGL YLGXHOOH3HUVRQZDKUQHKPEDUZDUEHUHLWVEHL0LWFKHOO]XOHVHQ0LWGHP=LHO GHUHQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYEHGLQJWHQ.RQVWLWXWLRQVSUR]HVVYRQGHQIUKHVWHQ$QIlQJHQ KHU]XUHNRQVWUXLHUHQEHGLHQWVLFK+RQQHWKGHUUHODWLRQDOHQ3V\FKRDQDO\VHGLH HU±ZLHQRFK]X]HLJHQVHLQZLUG LP8QWHUVFKLHG]X:KLWHERRN±EHUHLWVEHL :LQQLFRWWVWDUNDXVJHSUlJWILQGHW 7UHQQXQJVVFKPHU]HQ±YRQGHU$EKlQJLJNHLW]XU8QDEKlQJLJNHLW $Q:LQQLFRWWV:HUNLQWHUHVVLHUW+RQQHWKYRUDOOHPZLHGDULQGHUÄVSH]LILVFK SV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKH>@%HLWUDJ]XPPRGHUQHQ6XEMHNWYHUVWlQGQLV³]XU*HOWXQJ JHEUDFKWZLUG'LHVHP%HLWUDJHLJQHWVRVWHOOWHULQHLQHU YHU|IIHQWOLFKHQ 6WXGLH]XGHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQGHUPRGHUQHQ6XEMHNWNULWLNKHUDXVWUDGLWLRQHOOHU ZHLVHHLQHSULPlUQHJDWLYH6WRULFKWXQJ6RKHLWHVLQ)UHXGVVWLOLVLHUWHU$Q VSUDFKHDQGDVVLFKIUHLXQGVHOEVWEHVWLPPWZlKQHQGH6XEMHNW
+211(7+G 9JO67(51 +211(7+G $D2 $D2 +211(7+E 9JO]X+RQQHWKV:LQQLFRWW5H]HSWLRQLQVJHVDPWYD '(56 D II E II E II G II F ± +211(7+ :+,7(%22.II 9JOGD]X+211(7+D±1HEHQGHUSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKHQIKUW+RQQHWKKLHU DXFKHLQHVSUDFKSKLORVRSKLVFKH9DULDQWHGHU6XEMHNWNULWLNDQGLHLP)ROJHQGHQDXVJHEOHQGHW ZLUG
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
'XYHUWUDXVWGDUDXIGDGXDOOHVHUIlKUVWZDVLQGHLQHU6HHOHYRUJHKW>«@WURW]GHUDXJHQ VFKHLQOLFKVWHQ%HZHLVHGDLQGHLQHP6HHOHQOHEHQEHVWlQGLJYLHOPHKUYRUVLFKJHKHQPX DOVGHLQHP%HZXWVHLQEHNDQQWZHUGHQNDQQ
:HUGXUFKXQEHZXVVWH7ULHENUlIWHEHKHUUVFKWZLUGVROlVVWVLFKGDUDXVVFKOLH HQYHUPDJQLFKW]XJOHLFKDXWRQRP]XVHLQLPSOL]LHUWGLHVGRFKJHUDGHVLFK VHOEVW EHKHUUVFKHQ ]X N|QQHQ )U +RQQHWK MHGHQIDOOV VHW]W GLH ÄSV\FKRORJL VFKH>@.ULWLNGHV6XEMHNWV³LP6LQQH)UHXGVGHP%HJULIIHLQHVÄVLFKYROONRP PHQWUDQVSDUHQWH>Q@³ÄVHLQHUVHOEVWPlFKWLJH>Q@:HVHQ>V@³HLQ(QGH$QVWDWW GDUXPDEHUHLQHUY|OOLJHQ'HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHVDXWRQRPLHIlKLJHQ6XEMHNWVGDV :RUW]XUHGHQYHUVXFKW+RQQHWKVLFKDQGHVVHQ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQXQWHUYHUlQGHU WHQ9RU]HLFKHQ'DEHLNRPPHQÄMHQHVXEMHNWEHUJUHLIHQGHQ0lFKWH³GHV8Q EHZXVVWHQHEHQQLFKWDOV+LQGHUXQJVJUQGHVRQGHUQÄDOV.RQVWLWXWLRQVEHGLQ JXQJHQGHU,QGLYLGXDOLVLHUXQJYRQ6XEMHNWHQ³XQGLKUHUÄ)UHLKHLWRGHU6HOEVWEH VWLPPXQJ³]XP7UDJHQ:DVHUVROHW]WHQ(QGHVDQYLVLHUWLVWHLQÄLQWHUVXEMHN WLYLWlWVWKHRUHWLVFKH>U@%HJULII>@GHV6XEMHNWV³GHUVLFKHLQHPYRUDOOHPPLW :LQQLFRWWV+LOIHÄSV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKHUZHLWHUWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV³YHUGDQNW 'DEHLZHUGHQGLHGHQ0HQVFKHQEHVWLPPHQGHQ.UlIWHGHV8QEHZXVVWHQQLFKW DOV$XVGUXFNHLQHUÄYRUVR]LDOHQ7ULHEQDWXU³VRQGHUQDOV1LHGHUVFKODJLP=XJH GHV6R]LDOLVDWLRQVSUR]HVVHVHUZRUEHQHU5HDNWLRQVPXVWHUYHUVWDQGHQ 'LHV LVW HLQH 6LFKWZHLVH GLH +RQQHWK ZLH HU LQ HLQHU HUVFKLHQHQHQ )UHXG6WXGLHKHUDXVDUEHLWHWVFKOLHOLFKGRFKDXFKEHLP9DWHUGHU3V\FKRDQDO\ VH]XPLQGHVWLQ$QVlW]HQDQJHOHJWILQGHW/HW]WHUHUEDKQWVLFKGHP]XIROJHLP 5DKPHQGHU6FKULIW+HPPXQJ6\PSWRPXQG$QJVWYRQ ÄGHQ:HJ]XVHL QHUHLJHQHQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ $XIIDVVXQJ³LQGHPHUGDVIUKNLQGOLFKH Ä9HUODVVHQZHUGHQGXUFKGLH>«@0XWWHU³DOV8UVLWXDWLRQHLQHUOHEHQVODQJIRUW ZLUNHQGHQLPPHUZLHGHUUHDNWLYLHUEDUHQÄ7UHQQXQJVDQJVW³GHXWHW:LH)UHXG DXFKIRUPXOLHUHQNDQQJHKWDXVGHUEHVDJWHQÄ*HIDKUHQVLWXDWLRQ>@³HLQÄ%H GUIQLVJHOLHEW]XZHUGHQ³KHUYRUÄGDVGHQ0HQVFKHQQLFKWPHKUYHUODVVHQ ZLUG³ +RQQHWKVLHKWLQGLHVHQIUHXGXQW\SLVFKHQ:RUWHQÄEHLQDKZ|UWOLFKHLQH ]HQWUDOH,GHH:LQQLFRWWV³YRUZHJJHQRPPHQGHUHQ$XVIKUXQJVHLQYRUUDQJL JHV,QWHUHVVHJLOW
)5(8' +211(7+DI $D2 (EG $D2 $D2 'LHV KDW +RQQHWK LQ .DPSIXP $QHUNHQQXQJ QRFK RIIHQJHODVVHQ 9JO '(56G 9JO]XGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJLQVJHVDPW +211(7+D± )UGLH=LWDWH )5(8' E +211(7+D
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
'HUIUKNLQGOLFKHQ(UIDKUXQJGXUFKGLH0XWWHUYHUODVVHQ]XZHUGHQNRPPW QlPOLFKDXFKEHL:LQQLFRWWHLQHSDUDGLJPDWLVFKH%HGHXWXQJ]X$P$QIDQJGHV ÄIURP GHSHQGHQFH WRZDUGV LQGHSHQGHQFH³ IKUHQGHQ :HUGHJDQJV GHQ DXV VHLQHU6LFKWMHGHV,QGLYLGXXPPHKURGHUZHQLJHUHUIROJUHLFKGXUFKOlXIWVWHKW DEHU]XQlFKVWHLQH0XWWHUXQG.LQGV\PELRWLVFKYHUELQGHQGHÄDEVROXWHGHSHQ GHQFH³1LFKWQXULVWGDV.LQGKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU(UIOOXQJVHLQHU%HGUIQLVVHDXI GDV9HUVWlQGQLVXQGGLH8QWHUVWW]XQJGHU0XWWHU]XWLHIVWDQJHZLHVHQÄ>7@KH PRWKHUKHUVHOI³VFKUHLEW:LQQLFRWWÄLVLQDGHSHQGHQWVWDWH³6LHEHILQGHWVLFK QlPOLFKLQHLQHP=XVWDQGY|OOLJHU+LQJDEHJHJHQEHULKUHPÄEDE\ZKLFKDW ILUVWVHHPVOLNHDSDUWRIKHUVHOI³1HEHQGHP6WLOOHQXQG*HVWLOOWZHUGHQZLUG GLHVH(LQKHLWLQVEHVRQGHUHLQ3KDVHQGHV+DOWHQVXQG*HKDOWHQZHUGHQVHUOHEW Ä1RRQHFDQKROGDEDE\XQOHVVLGHQWLI\ZLWKDEDE\³PDFKW:LQQLFRWWKLHU JHOWHQG+RQQHWKEH]HLFKQHWGHQIUGLHVH(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHFKDUDNWHULVWLVFKHQ Ä=XVWDQGGHV9HUVFKPRO]HQVHLQV³DOVHLQHÄSULPlUH³QRFKÄXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWH ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW³GLHVRPLWGHQÄ$QIDQJMHGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQV³DXV PDFKW$XIVLHIROJWHLQH3KDVH]XQHKPHQGHU'LIIHUHQ]LHUWKHLWGLHEHL:LQQL FRWW XQWHU GHU hEHUVFKULIW ÄUHODWLYH GHSHQGHQFH³ VWHKW ÄGHSHQGHQFH WKDW WKH LQIDQWFDQNQRZDERXW³ =XPEHVDJWHQ%HZXVVWVHLQVHLQHU$QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXIGLH0XWWHUJHODQJWGDV .LQGZHQQGLHVHVLFKPHKUXQGPHKUYRQGHUVWDUNHQ$GDSWLRQDQVHLQH%H GUIQLVVH]XJXQVWHQDQGHUHU$QOLHJHQ]XUFN]LHKW'HPNRUUHVSRQGLHUWHLQ]X QHKPHQGHV*HZDKUZHUGHQVHLQHUVHOEVWLQ8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWYRQGHUXPJHEHQ GHQ:HOW+RQQHWKVSULFKWKLHUYRQHLQHUDOVÄVFKPHU]KDIWHUOHEWH>Q@.OXIW³GLH Ä]ZLVFKHQLQQHUHUXQGlXHUHU5HDOLWlW³GDGXUFKDXI]XEUHFKHQEHJLQQWGDVV GLH0XWWHUDXI'LVWDQ]JHUlW'LHKHUDXVIRUGHUQGH(UIDKUXQJHLQHUXQNRQWURO OLHUEDUHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWJHJHQEHU]XVWHKHQGLHNHLQHVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKH(UIO OXQJGHUHLJHQHQ%HGUIQLVVH PHKU JHZlKUWEHJOHLWHWGHQ0HQVFKHQYRQQXQ DQ DXI VHLQHP OHEHQVODQJHQ :HJ ÄWRZDUGV LQGHSHQGHQFH³ 6R KHLW HV EHL
:,11,&277 E 9JOGD]X $D2± $D2 (EG $D2 +211(7+G $D2 $D2 :,11,&277 E9JO]XGLHVHU(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHLQVJHVDPW DD2± +211(7+G 9JO]XGLHVHU(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHLQVJHVDPW :,11,&277 E I'DVVVLHZHQLJHU HLQHQ HUUHLFKEDUHQ 6WDWXV DOV YLHOPHKU HLQ LPPHU QHX DXV]XWDULHUHQGHV 6SDQQXQJVJHIJH ]ZLVFKHQ$EKlQJLJNHLWXQG8QDEKlQJLJNHLWEHVFKUHLEWPDFKWIROJHQGHV=LWDWGHXWOLFK Ä,Q GHSHQGHQFHLVQHYHUDEVROXWH7KHKHDOWK\LQGLYLGXDOGRHVQRWEHFRPHLVRODWHGEXWEHFRPHV UHODWHGWRWKHHQYLURQPHQWLQVXFKDZD\WKDWWKHLQGLYLGXDODQGWKHHQYLURQPHQWFDQEHVDLGWR EHLQWHUGHSHQGHQW³ DD2
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
:LQQLFRWW ÄWKHWDVNRIUHDOLW\DFFHSWDQFHLVQHYHUFRPSOHWHG>«@QRKXPDQ EHLQJLVIUHHIURPWKHVWUDLQRIUHODWLQJLQQHUDQGRXWHUUHDOLW\³'HU*UXQG GDIUGDVVGLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQLQQHUHUXQGlXHUHU5HDOLWlWRGHU]ZLVFKHQ 6HOEVWXQG:HOWEHUKDXSWDOVQHJDWLYEHODVWHQGHUIDKUHQZLUGOLHJWDEHULQGHU 3KDVHMHQHUÃDEVROXWHGHSHQGHQFHµ]ZLVFKHQ0XWWHUXQG.LQGEHJUQGHW,P XUDQIlQJOLFKHQÄ=XVWDQGV\PELRWLVFKHQ(LQVVHLQV³SUlJWVLFKVRIROJHUW+RQ QHWKDXVVHLQHU:LQQLFRWW/HNWUHHLQÄ(UIDKUXQJVVFKHPDYROOVWlQGLJHQ=XIULH GHQVHLQV³ HLQ GDV Ä]HLWOHEHQV KLQWHU GHP 5FNHQ GHU 6XEMHNWH GHQ :XQVFK ZDFKKlOWPLWHLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQYHUVFKPRO]HQ]XVHLQ³ )XVLRQVEHGUIQLVVH±GLHEOHLEHQGH$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQGHUSULPlUHQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW 'DVVPHQVFKOLFKH6XEMHNWHLQLKUHP9HUKDOWHQXQEHZXVVWGXUFKHLQHGHUDUWLJH 9HUVFKPHO]XQJVVHKQVXFKWJHOHLWHWZHUGHQLVWHLQIU+RQQHWK]HQWUDOHU*HGDQ NH$QLKPKlOWHUZHLWHUIHVWZHQQHUGLHGXUFK'DQLHO6WHUQLQZLUNPlFKWLJHU :HLVHEHVWULWWHQH7KHVHHLQHU6WXIHXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHQ(LQVVHLQVDP/HEHQVEH JLQQGHUHULQ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJQRFKIROJWVFKOLHOLFKYHUZLUIW8QWHU VWW]XQJILQGHWHUGDIUEHL)UHG3LQH'LHVHUEHVWlWLJW6WHUQV6LFKWGDVVPDQ VFKRQLPIUKHQ6lXJOLQJVDOWHUGHU8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWGHVHLJHQHQ6HOEVWYRQGHU :HOWJHZDKULVW]ZDUJUXQGVlW]OLFK'RFKVWHOOWHULKUGLH$QQDKPH]XPLQGHVW SKDVHQZHLVHU9HUVFKPHO]XQJV]XVWlQGHDQGLH6HLWHÄ,ZRXOGSURSRVH³VFKUHLEW 3LQH ÄWKDW WKH LQIDQW KDV PRPHQWV RI WKH H[SHULHQFH RI ERXQGDU\OHVVQHVV RU PHUJHU±QRWDQRQJRLQJVWDWHRIZHHNV¶RUPRQWKV¶GXUDWLRQ³6ROFKH0R PHQWHKHLWHVZHLWHUNlPHQLQVEHVRQGHUHDXI ZKHQWKHLQIDQWLQWKHPRWKHU¶VDUPVKDYLQJVXFNHGYLJRURXVO\DWEUHDVWRUERWWOHSURJUHV VLYHO\FDOPVDQGIDOOVLQWRVOHHSDVERG\WRQXVUHOD[HVDQGKHRUVKHPHOWVLQWRWKHPRWKHU¶V ERG\
0LWGHUHSLVRGLVFKHQ:LHGHUNHKUVROFKHU9HUVFKPHO]XQJVRGHU)XVLRQVPRPHQ WHGHUHQ(LQWUHWHQGHQDQVRQVWHQYRQ$QIDQJDQJHJHEHQHQ=XVWDQGGHU'LIIH UHQ]LHUWKHLW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWXQG:HOWDEO|VWJHKWIU+RQQHWKZHLWHUKLQGLH
:,11,&277E +211(7+G 9JOGD]XXQG]XPIROJHQGHQGLH$XVIKUXQJHQLQ +211(7+I II6WHUQVVFKX OHPDFKHQGH.ULWLNDP.RQ]HSWGHU6\PELRVHNRPPWHWZD]XP$XVGUXFNLQ67(51 Ä,QIDQWVEHJLQWRH[SHULHQFHDVHQVHRIDQHPHUJHQWVHOIIURPELUWK7KH\DUHSUHGHVLJQHGWREH DZDUHRIVHOIRUJDQL]LQJSURFHVVHV7KH\QHYHUH[SHULHQFHDSHULRGRIWRWDOVHOIORWKHUXQGLIIH UHQWLDWLRQ7KHUHLVQRFRQIXVLRQEHWZHHQVHOIDQGRWKHULQWKHEHJLQQLQJRUDWDQ\SRLQWGXULQJ LQIDQF\7KH\DUHDOVRSUHGHVLJQHGWREHVHOHFWLYHO\UHVSRQVLYHWRH[WHUQDOVRFLDOHYHQWVDQG QHYHUH[SHULHQFHDQDXWLVWLFOLNHSKDVH³ 3,1( 9JO]X3LQHV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW6WHUQV$EZHLVGHV6\PSLRVH .RQ]HSWV DD2± $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$XVELOGXQJGHVEHVDJWHQ(UIDKUXQJVVFKHPDVYROOVWlQGLJHQ=XIULHGHQVHLQVHLQ KHU,QOHLFKWYHUlQGHUWHU'LNWLRQNDQQHUDXFKYRQHLQHPÄ(UZDUWXQJVVFKHPD>@ GHU*HERUJHQKHLW³UHGHQGDVZLHHUNRQNUHWLVLHUWÄHLQHQLHYHUVLHJHQGH4XHOOH GHU $QWLVR]LDOLWlW³ GDUVWHOOW ZHLO HV ÄHLQ VWHWV QHXHV $XIEHJHKUHQ JHJHQ GLH 8QDEKlQJLJNHLWXQG8QYHUIJEDUNHLWGHVGLH6R]LDOLWlWYHUN|USHUQGHQ$QGH UHQ³DOV7HQGHQ]HQWKlOW$QWLVR]LDOLVWGLHVHVLP%HUHLFKGHV8QEHZXVVWHQ YHUDQNHUWH*HERUJHQKHLWVVWUHEHQDOVRQLFKWLQGHP6LQQHGDVVHVYRQHJR]HQWUL VFKHU$UWZlUHRGHUGDV6XEMHNWLQGLH,VRODWLRQWULHEH(VULFKWHWVLFKYLHOPHKU JHJHQ GHQ 'LIIHUHQ]FKDUDNWHU VR]LDOHU 9HUKlOWQLVVH GLH VWHWV ]ZLVFKHQ DXFK 8QWHUVFKLHGHQHQDXIJHVSDQQWVLQG 'DVLQ6R]LDOEH]LHKXQJHQYHUELQGXQJVVWLIWHQGH(OHPHQWVWHOOWIU+RQQHWKGLH MHZHLOV GHP LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6HOEVWVHLQ GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ JHOWHQGH ZHFKVHOVHLWLJH $QHUNHQQXQJGDU*HJHQEHUGLHVHPDOOJHJHQZlUWLJHQ9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJVPR GXV ZHFNW GDV IUKNLQGOLFK HUZRUEHQH (UZDUWXQJVVFKHPD GHU *HERUJHQKHLW HLQHUVHLWV HLQ 8QEHKDJHQ ZHLO HV GDULQ NHLQH YROOVWlQGLJH (UIOOXQJ ILQGHW Ä7KHUHLVDQXQHDVLQHVVZLWKUHFRJQLWLRQEHFDXVHLWLVDUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ LQGHSHQGHQWVXEMHFWV³PDFKW+RQQHWKGHXWOLFKXQGOR]LHUWLQGLHVHP0DQJHO HPSILQGHQHLQHQÄGULYHIRUUHEHOOLRQDJDLQVWWKHH[LVWLQJIRUPVRIUHFRJQLWLRQ³ $QGHUHUVHLWVZHL+RQQHWKÄGLHXQUHJHOPlLJZLHGHUNHKUHQGHQ)XVLRQVHUOHE QLVVHGHV6lXJOLQJV³DXFKÄDOVÃ1XOOSXQNWµDOOHU(UIDKUXQJHQYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³ ]XGHXWHQ $OVWLHIVLW]HQGH&KLIIUHQHLQHU*HERUJHQKHLWGLHIULPPHUKLQWHUXQVOLHJWWUHLEHQVLHQRFK DOOHV6WUHEHQQDFKMHQHQJHEURFKHQHQ)RUPHQYRQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWDQGLHGLH*HVWDOWGHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQHUZDFKVHQHQ6XEMHNWHQEHVLW]W
'DVIUKNLQGOLFKH*HERUJHQKHLWVHUOHEHQVRODVVHQVLFKEHLGH$XVVDJHQLP=X VDPPHQKDQJOHVHQLPSOL]LHUWHLQLGHDOHVZHLOGDVHLJHQH6HOEVWVHLQ]XYROOHU (UIOOXQJEULQJHQGHV$QHUNDQQWVHLQDQGHPLQIROJHGHVVHQDOOH$QHUNHQQXQJV HUIDKUXQJHQGLHPDQXPGHUÄRULJLQDOH[SHULHQFH³ZLOOHQHUVWUHEWJHPHVVHQ ZHUGHQ'LHQRUPDOHUZHLVHÃJHEURFKHQHQ)RUPHQYRQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµP|JHQ GHP,GHDOMHQHUXUVSUQJOLFKHQ8QYHUVHKUWKHLWJOHLFKZHUGHQ±VROlVVWVLFKGHU :XQVFKDXIGHQ3XQNWEULQJHQGHUQDFK+RQQHWKGDV6XEMHNWLQVHLQHPWLHIVWHQ ,QQHUQEHZHJW'HVVHQDOVDQWLVR]LDOWLWXOLHUWHV6WUHEHQLVWDOVRHLJHQWOLFKQXUDXI HLQHGLIIHUHQ]ORVH)RUPYRQ6R]LDOLWlWDXV'DVVÄVHOEVW3HUVRQHQLQUHLIHP$OWHU DXI7UHQQXQJHQPLWVFKZHUGXUFKVFKDXEDUHU3DQLNUHDJLHUHQ³]HLJWIU+RQQHWK H[HPSODULVFKZHOFKHÄ0KH³HVLKQHQPDFKWÄGLH8QDEKlQJLJNHLWYRQJHOLHE WHQRGHUEHJHKUWHQ6XEMHNWHQDQ]XHUNHQQHQXQGGLHGDGXUFKEHGLQJWH*HEUR
+211(7+I 9JODXFKDD2 ZRYRQHLQHPÄSV\FKLVFKH>Q@(UZDUWXQJV VFKHPDGHUOHLEOLFKVHHOLVFKHQ*HERUJHQKHLW³GLH5HGHLVW +211(7+:+,7(%22. (EG +211(7+I +211(7+:+,7(%22.
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
FKHQKHLWGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW]XDN]HSWLHUHQ³'DVJHZlKOWH%HLVSLHOYHUGHXW OLFKW]XJOHLFKZLHQDKVLFKGHU9HUVFKPHO]XQJVXQG*HERUJHQKHLWVWULHEDQGHU *UHQ]H]XP3DWKRORJLVFKHQEHZHJW'DYRUDEHUEHZDKUHQGHQ0HQVFKHQEHV WHQIDOOV]ZHLDXVJOHLFKHQGH)lKLJNHLWHQ]XGHQHQHUZLH+RQQHWKHLQPDOPHKU LP5HNXUVDXI:LQQLFRWWKHUDXVDUEHLWHWHEHQIDOOVDXVIUKNLQGOLFKHU=HLWKHU GLVSRQLHUWLVW 'D]XGHQ9HUOXVWGHUSULPlUHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWEHZlOWLJHQ]XN|QQHQYHU KHOIHQGHP6XEMHNWVR+RQQHWKPLW:LQQLFRWW]ZHLEHUHLWVLQIUKNLQGOLFKHU =HLWHUZRUEHQH.RPSHWHQ]HQ GDVLVW]XPHLQHQÄGLH)lKLJNHLW>«@ÃPLWVLFKµ DOOHLQ]XVHLQ³ XQG]XPDQGHUHQÄGLH)lKLJNHLW³VLFKÄSHULRGLVFKKLQWHU GLHMHZHLOVHUULFKWHWHQ,FK*UHQ]HQ]XUFNIDOOHQ]XODVVHQ³ $OOHLQVHLQN|QQHQ LP6FKXW]HHLQHUJHIKOWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW 7KH &DSDFLW\ WR EH $ORQH ODXWHW GHU7LWHOHLQHU YHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ6WXGLH :LQQLFRWWVDXIGLH+RQQHWKLPHUVWHQ)DOOYRUDOOHPUHNXUULHUW'RUWLVW]XOH VHQ Ä0DWXULW\DQGWKHFDSDFLW\WREHDORQH³±EHLGH$XVGUFNHVLQGDXV6LFKW GHV3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHUVÄQHDUO\V\QRQ\PRXV³]XYHUZHQGHQ±ÄLPSOLHVWKDWWKH LQGLYLGXDOKDVKDGWKHFKDQFHWKURXJKJRRGHQRXJK PRWKHULQJWREXLOGXSD EHOLHILQDEHQLJQHQYLURQPHQW³=XP*ODXEHQDQRGHUZLH+RQQHWKIRUPX OLHUW]XP9HUWUDXHQDXIGHQJXWDUWLJHQEHJQVWLJHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUGHUHVXPJH EHQGHQ:HOWJHODQJWGDV.LQGGDGXUFKGDVVGLH0XWWHUE]ZGLHSULPlUHQ%H ]XJVSHUVRQHQIUHLQHYHUOlVVOLFKHHPRWLRQDOH=XZHQGXQJHLQVWHKHQ,P:HFK VHO]ZLVFKHQ(SLVRGHQLQWHQVLYHU1lKHXQG3KDVHQJHO|VWHU'LVWDQ]ELOGHWVLFK LQLKPGDQQGLHÄ=XYHUVLFKW³KHUDXVÄGDGLHHLJHQHQ%HGUIQLVVHGXUFKGHQ DQGHUHQGDXHUKDIW(UIOOXQJILQGHQ³VRGDVVHVÄLP6FKXW]H³GLHVHUÄJHIKOWHQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW³]XQHKPHQGÄVRUJORVPLWVLFKDOOHLQ]XVHLQ³YHUPDJ $QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFK JHZHQGHW HUIlKUW GDV .LQG VR IROJHUW +RQQHWK YHUPLWWHOVGHUPWWHUOLFKHQE]ZHOWHUOLFKHQ/LHEHVLFKVHOEVWKLQVLFKWOLFKVHLQHU :QVFKH XQG%HGUIQLVVHDOVJUXQGVlW]OLFKEHMDKW 6LHEHGHXWHQIU $QGHUH HWZDV XQG GLHVHV :HUWJHVFKlW]ZHUGHQ EHWULIIW ± DOO]XPDO DXV IUKNLQGOLFKHU 6LFKW±GLHJDQ]H3HUVRQ'DGXUFKGDVVGLHLPOLHEHYROOHQ8PVRUJWVHLQLPSOL ]LHUWH6HOEVWEHVWlWLJXQJLQWHUQDOLVLHUWZLUGJHODQJWÄGDV.OHLQNLQG>«@]XHLQHP 9HUWUDXHQLQVLFKVHOEHU³ DXVGHPHVVHLQHOHEHQVODQJK|FKVWZLFKWLJH)lKLJ
+211(7+I +211(7+E $D2 :,11,&277 F $D29JO]XPÄ$OOHLQVHLQN|QQHQ³LQVJHVDPW +211(7+EI G II +211(7+G $D2 $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
NHLW ]XP $OOHLQVHLQ VFK|SIW 'DV GDPLW JHZRQQHQH 0D DQ 8QDEKlQJLJNHLW JHJHQEHU$QGHUHQYHUPDJGDQQQlPOLFKDXFKGLHVHQ]XJHVWDQGHQ]XZHUGHQ LQVRIHUQPDQVLFKMHGHQIDOOVGDUDXIYHUODVVHQNDQQGDVVVLHGLH%H]LHKXQJYRQ VLFKDXVEHZDKUHQÄ>2@KQHGLHJHIKOVPlLJH6LFKHUKHLWGDGLHJHOLHEWH3HU VRQ>«@LKUH=XQHLJXQJDXIUHFKWHUKlOW³VFKUHLEW+RQQHWKPLW%OLFNDXFKDXIV (UZDFKVHQHQDOWHUÄZlUHGHPOLHEHQGHQ6XEMHNWGLH$QHUNHQQXQJLKUHU8QDE KlQJLJNHLWJDUQLFKWP|JOLFK³6LHLVWLKPDEHUP|JOLFKZHQQHVGHU=XQHL JXQJGHUJHOLHEWHQ3HUVRQJHIKOVPlLJVLFKHUVHLQNDQQ.UDIWHLQHUIUKNLQG OLFKHUZRUEHQHQHPRWLRQDOHQ(UZDUWXQJVKDOWXQJJHJHQEHU$QGHUHQLQGHULFK PLFKDXIGHUHQSULQ]LSLHOOH9HUELQGOLFKNHLWPLUJHJHQEHU]XYHUODVVHQIlKLJ ELQYHUPDJLFKDOVRQDFK+RQQHWKGHQ'LIIHUHQ]FKDUDNWHUVR]LDOHU9HUKlOWQLVVH ]XDN]HSWLHUHQ$XFKGLHVH(LQVWHOOXQJKDWEHUHLWV$QHUNHQQXQJVFKDUDNWHUZLH +RQQHWKLQVHLQHUHUVFKLHQHQ6WXGLH9HUGLQJOLFKXQJKHUDXVDUEHLWHW 6LH HQWKlOWÄGHQ9RUVFKXHLQHU)RUPYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³GLHVFKRQLQÄGHUXQZLOO NUOLFKHQgIIQXQJ³IUGLH3HUVSHNWLYHQ$QGHUHUDOVEHUKDXSWIUPLFKEHGHXW VDP]XP7UDJHQNRPPW $XFKGLH)lKLJNHLW]XP$OOHLQVHLQDEHUEHLQKDOWHWHLQÃDQWLVR]LDOHVµ0RPHQW LPKRQQHWKVFKHQ6LQQH9HUVLFKHUWGDVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYNRQVWLWXLHUWH6HOEVWYHU WUDXHQGDV6XEMHNWGHUJUXQGVlW]OLFKHQ/HJLWLPLWlWVHLQHU%HGUIQLVVHOHUQWHV GDPLWQlPOLFK]XJOHLFKDXIHEHQGLHVHQ]XLQVLVWLHUHQ1DFK+RQQHWKV/HNWUH NRUUHVSRQGLHUWGHU%HIlKLJXQJ]XP$OOHLQVHLQN|QQHQEHL:LQQLFRWWGHPJHPl GDV6LFK(LQVWHOOHQHLQHVÄLQWUDSV\FKLVFKH>Q@'UXFN>V@>«@GHUGDVKHUDQZDFK VHQGH6XEMHNWLQ5LFKWXQJGHU,QGLYLGXLHUXQJGUlQJW³2EVHLQHV9HUWUDXHQVLQ GLH SULQ]LSLHOOH VR]LDOH (UIOOEDUNHLW GHU HLJHQHQ %HGUIQLVVH YHUPDJ HV VLH DQJVWIUHL]XDUWLNXOLHUHQXQGLQ2SSRVLWLRQJHJHQGLHIDNWLVFKHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJV EHGLQJXQJHQQDPKDIW]XPDFKHQ$XFKGLHVDEHUJHVFKLHKWÃLP6FKXW]HHLQHU JHIKOWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµYRQGHUKHUXQGDXIGLHKLQGLHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ$Q VSUFKHLQVHOEVWVLFKHUHU:HLVHIRUPXOLHUWZHUGHQ'DVVGHUHQ6FKXW]VLFKXQWHU GHQ%HGLQJXQJHQHLQHUÃJHEURFKHQHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµVFKOLHOLFKDOV,OOXVLRQ HQWSXSSHQNDQQLVWHLQH6FKZLHULJNHLWGLHYHUPLWWHOVMHQHU]ZHLWHQIUKNLQGOLFK HUZRUEHQHQ.RPSHWHQ]NRPSHQVLHUEDULVW
$D2 +211(7+9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPWGDV,,,.DSLWHOPLWGHUVSUHFKHQGHQhEHU VFKULIWÄ'HU9RUUDQJGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³ DD2II +211(7+E
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
'LH,FK*UHQ]HQDXIKHEHQ GXUFK9HUJHJHQZlUWLJXQJHUOHEWHU ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW 'LH7KHVHHLQHUGHP0HQVFKHQHLJQHQGHQÄ)lKLJNHLW³VLFKÄSHULRGLVFKKLQWHU GLHMHZHLOVHUULFKWHWHQ,FK*UHQ]HQ]XUFNIDOOHQ]XODVVHQ³VLHKW+RQQHWKLQ :LQQLFRWWV7KHRULHGHUVRJhEHUJDQJVREMHNWHXQGSKlQRPHQHJUXQGJHOHJW :LQQLFRWWV$XVJDQJVSXQNLQGHUKLHUHLQVFKOlJLJHQ6WXGLH7UDQVLWLRQDO2EMHFWV DQG7UDQVLWLRQDO3KHQRPHQDGLHDXIHLQHQ SXEOL]LHUWHQ$UWLNHO]XUFN JHKWLVWHLQHUHFKWXQVSHNWDNXOlUH%HREDFKWXQJ ÄWKHVPDOOFKLOGZKRLVÃORVWµLQ SOD\³=XQlFKVWLVWHVGHUHLJHQH'DXPHQRGHUGHU.LVVHQ]LSIHOVSlWHUGDV .XVFKHOWLHUGLH3XSSHRGHUHLQH0HORGLHZRPLW]XEHVFKlIWLJHQGDV.LQGLQ HLQHQJHUDGH]XVHOEVWXQGZHOWYHUJHVVHQHQ=XVWDQG]XYHUVHW]HQVFKHLQW1DFK :LQQLFRWWV'DIUKDOWHQHUIOOHQGLHVHSUDNWLVFKHQ9ROO]JHHLQHGRSSHOWH)XQN WLRQ VLHJHEHQHLQHUVHLWV]HLWZHLVH(QWODVWXQJGDYRQGLHPLWGHU'LVWDQ]]XU 0XWWHUDXIJHNRPPHQH6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQLQQHUHUXQGlXHUHU5HDOLWlWVWlQGLJ DXVWDULHUHQ]XPVVHQ$QGHUHUVHLWVYHUKHOIHQVLHHLQHU]XQHKPHQGGHVLOOXVLR QLHUWHQ5HDOLWlWVDN]HSWDQ]]XPDOOPlKOLFKHQ'XUFKEUXFKGHUHEHQQLFKWUXFNDU WLJHUIROJHQNDQQ:DVLQMHQHPVHOEVWXQGZHOWYHUJHVVHQHQ6SLHO]XP$XV GUXFNNRPPWLVWPLW:LQQLFRWWJHVDJW ÄDQLQWHUPHGLDWHVWDWHEHWZHHQDEDE\¶V LQDELOLW\DQGKLVJURZLQJDELOLW\WRUHFRJQL]HDQGDFFHSWUHDOLW\³'LH*HJHQ VWlQGHVHLQHV6SLHOV±LQVRIHUQKDQGHOWHVVLFKGDEHLXPÄWUDQVLWLRQDOREMHFWV³± GLHQHQLKP]XPhEHUJDQJLQHLQHÄLQWHUPHGLDWHDUHDRIH[SHULHQFH³GHUHLQH ZHGHUQXUVXEMHNWLYIDQWDVWLVFKHQRFKVFKRQREMHNWLYUHDOLVWLVFKH(LJHQDUW]X NRPPW'DGXUFKNDQQGDV.LQGGLHLKP]XQHKPHQGEHZXVVWZHUGHQGH8QWHU VFKLHGHQKHLWYRQGHQSULPlUHQ%H]XJVSHUVRQHQHEHQVRHUVDW]ZHLVHEHUEUFNHQ ZLHHVVLFKVXN]HVVLYHLQVLHHLQ]XEHQYHUPDJ +RQQHWKDN]HQWXLHUWDQGLHVHU6WHOOHGDV3KlQRPHQGHVÄUHDOLW\WHVWLQJ³ ZRPLWGHUELVZHLOHQDJJUHVVLY]HUVW|UHULVFKH8PJDQJPLWGHQ%H]XJVREMHNWHQ XQGSHUVRQHQJHPHLQWLVW'HVVHQ=LHOEHVWHKWGHPQDFKGDULQGLHXQDEKlQJLJH XQGXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUH(LJHQDUWGHUlXHUHQ5HDOLWlW]XHUSUREHQ(UZHLVWVLFK GDV2EMHNWGHU*HZDOW±]%GLH0XWWHU±DOVEHKDUUOLFKLVWGLHVHLQZLFKWLJHU /HUQVFKULWWDXIGHP:HJGDKLQHVDOVÄHQWLW\LQLWVRZQULJKW³DQHUNHQQHQ]X N|QQHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJIUDOOGLHVDEHULVWGDVVPDQGDVLQIDQWLOH6SLHODXI HOWHUOLFKHU6HLWH±LPZDKUVWHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHV±PLWVSLHOWXQGHUVWQDFKXQG QDFK'HVLOOXVLRQLHUXQJVYHUVXFKHDQEDKQW
$D29JO]XUIROJHQGHQ'DUVWHOOXQJYRQ+RQQHWKV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHU 7KHRULHGHUhEHUJDQJVREMHNWHLQVJHVDPW '(56E± E± G II :,11,&277E9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2II $D2 $D2 :,11,&2779JOGD]X +211(7+G±I :,11,&277D
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:DV+RQQHWKV,QWHUHVVHZHFNWLVWDEHUYRUDOOHP:LQQLFRWWVZHLWHUJHKHQGH 7KHVHHVKLHUQXUPLWGHPÄ%HJLQQHLQHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYDN]HSWLHUWHQ,OOXVLRQV ELOGXQJ³ ]XWXQ]XKDEHQ6RVHKUQlPOLFKZLHREHQGDUJHOHJWÄGLH$XIJDEH ]ZLVFKHQ9HUVFKPHO]XQJVZXQVFKXQG,FK$EJUHQ]XQJHLQH%DODQFH]XZDKUHQ HLQHSV\FKLVFKH+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ>GDUVWHOOW@GLHQLFKWQXUGDV.OHLQNLQGVRQ GHUQDXFKMHGHU(UZDFKVHQHHUQHXW]XEHVWHKHQKDW³VRVHKUEHGDUIHVLPPHU ZLHGHUGHUÄVSLHOHULVFKHQ([NXUVLRQLQGLH=ZLVFKHQZHOWGHUhEHUJDQJVREMHN WH³:LH2GR0DTXDUGSRLQWLHUWEHPHUNWÄEUDXFKHQXQGKDEHQDXFKGLH(U ZDFKVHQHQ>«@LKUH7HGG\ElUHQ³%HL:LQLFRWWEHJHJQHQ.XQVWXQG5HOLJLRQ DOVH[HPSODULVFKH2UWHHLQHUVROFKHQVR]LDODN]HSWLHUWHQ5HDOLWlWVYHUOHXJQXQJ PLW NRPSHQVDWRULVFKHU XQG VWDELOLVDWRULVFKHU )XQNWLRQ +RQQHWK NRPPW KLHU HLQHUVHLWVDXIGDV3KlQRPHQGHV$XIJHKHQVLQGHU*UXSSH]XVSUHFKHQ D XQG YHUVXFKWVLFKDQGHUHUVHLWVDQHLQHUVlNXODUHQ'HXWXQJUHOLJL|VHU7URVWYHUVSUH FKHQ E D 'DV,FKLP:LU )XVLRQVHUOHEQLVVHLQGHU*UXSSH 8QWHUGHPVSUHFKHQGHQ7LWHO'DV,FKLP:LUIKUW+RQQHWKÄGDV)XVLRQVHUOHEQLV LQGHU*UXSSH³DOVHLQ%HLVSLHOIUHLQHDXFKLP(UZDFKVHQDOWHUQRFKYRUJH QRPPHQHÃ([NXUVLRQLQGLH=ZLVFKHQZHOWGHUhEHUJDQJVREMHNWHµYRU$XJHQ(V ZLUG JHVXFKW XP VLFK ÄHQWODVWHQG KLQWHU GLH HLQPDO HUULFKWHWHQ ,FK*UHQ]HQ ]XUFNIDOOHQ]XODVVHQ³ 2ELQGHUVXEOLPLHUWHQ)RUPGHUYROONRPPHQJHGDQNHQYHUORUHQHQHNVWDWLVFKHUOHEWHQ.RRSH UDWLRQRELQGHUXQJOHLFKUDXVFKKDIWHUHQ)RUPGHVOHLEOLFKHQ0LWVFKZLQJHQVLQGHUMXEHOQGHQ 0DVVHRELP)XEDOOVWDGLRQEHLP5RFNNRQ]HUWRGHULQGHU$EJHVFKLHGHQKHLWGHU]HLWYHUJHV VHQHQZLHLP6SLHOYHUVXQNHQHQ$UEHLWVJUXSSH
±VWHWVYROO]LHKWVLFKGDEHLMHQHhEHUVFKUHLWXQJGHU6HOEVW:HOW'LIIHUHQ]GHU VFKRQGDVLP6SLHOYHUVXQNHQH.LQGLPPHUZLHGHUWHLOKDIWLJ]XZHUGHQEHGXUIWH 'LHVHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ XQWHUVWUHLFKW +RQQHWK LQ DOOHU 'HXWOLFKNHLW ZHQQ HU VFKUHLEWÄGDGDV)XVLRQVHUOHEQLVLQGHU*UXSSHIUGHQ(UZDFKVHQHQGLHGLUHN
+211(7+G+HUYRUKG9HUI +211(7+E 0$548$5' E2GR0DUTXDUGZHLLQGHULKPHLJHQHQ0LVFKXQJDXV,URQLHXQG (UQVWKDIWLJNHLWSDVVHQGH%HLVSLHOHGDIU]XQHQQHQZLHDXFKGLH(UZDFKVHQHQÄLKU9HUWUDX WKHLWVGHIL]LWGXUFK'DXHUSUlVHQ]GHV9HUWUDXWHQ³ DD2 NRPSHQVLHUHQ Ä]%LQGHPVLH .ODVVLNHUPLWVLFKIKUHQ GLHEHLGHQHQPDQLPPHUVFKRQ]XZLVVHQJODXEWZRUDQPDQPLW LKQHQLVW XQGVRNRPPWPDQGDQQHWZD PLW*RHWKHGXUFKV-DKU PLW%HHWKRYHQGXUFK%RQQ PLW+DEHUPDVGXUFKV6WXGLXP PLW5HLFK5DQLFNLGXUFKGLH*HJHQZDUWVOLWHUDWXU XQGVRIRUW³ +211(7+EI (EG $D2
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
WHVWH :LGHUVSLHJHOXQJ VHLQHU IUKNLQGOLFKHQ (UIDKUXQJHQ GDUVWHOOW³ 1HEHQ LKUHU NRPSHQVDWRULVFKHQ )XQNWLRQ VROOHQ VROFKH ÄÃJHVXQGHQµ 5HJUHVVLRQVHU VFKHLQXQJHQ³DXFKGHUÄ:LHGHUJHZLQQXQJSV\FKLVFKHU9LWDOLWlW³GLHQHQXQG ]ZDUZHLOVLHÄHLQH5HNRQNUHWLVLHUXQJLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³EHLQKDO WHQ'LHEHVDJWHQNROOHNWLYHQ9HUVFKPHO]XQJVHUIDKUXQJHQEULQJHQVROlVVWVLFK GHU.UHLVVFKOLHHQGDVHLQVWNUDIWGHUHOWHUOLFKHQ)UVRUJHJHZDFKVHQH6HOEVW XQG :HOWYHUWUDXHQ QHX ]XP 7UDJHQ GDV 9HUWUDXHQ GDUDXI DOVR ÃLP 6FKXW]H HLQHUJHIKOWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµ]XZDQGHOQGLHGHPHLJHQHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQ HLQJHVFKUlQNW%HMDKXQJ]XWHLOZHUGHQOlVVW'DUDXVHUZDFKVHQHQHLQPDOPHKU %HGUIQLVDQVSUFKHGLHEHUGLH]XQlFKVWXQG]XPHLVWÃJHEURFKHQHQ)RUPHQµ GHV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQKLQDXVZHLVHQ'DVVHUGDEHLDXFKGHQ7RGDOVHQGJOWLJHP $EEUXFKVR]LDOHU%H]LHKXQJHQLP%OLFNKDW]HLJWHLQHVHOWHQH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW ]XQJ+RQQHWKVPLWHLQHUH[SOL]LWWKHRORJLVFKHQ7KHPHQVWHOOXQJGLHGHU5HOLJL RQDOVHLQHPÃhEHUJDQJVSKlQRPHQµQDFKJHKW E 'DV:LUGDVVWlUNHULVWDOVGHU7RG 6lNXODUH)RUPHQGHV7URVWHV ,QVHLQHP%HLWUDJ]XUHUVFKLHQHQ)HVWVFKULIWIUGHQNDWKROLVFKHQ7KHROR JHQ-RKDQQ%DSWLVW0HW]EHPKW+RQQHWKVLFKDXVGUFNOLFKXPGLHSRVLWLYH $QHLJQXQJHLQHVFKULVWOLFKHQ7UDGLWLRQVJHKDOWHVQlPOLFKGHU8QVWHUEOLFKNHLWV YRUVWHOOXQJ(QWPlFKWLJXQJHQGHU5HDOLWlWODXWHWGHUYLHOVDJHQGH7LWHOGHVHU ZlKQWHQ7H[WHVGHUZHQQJOHLFKNHLQHUHOLJL|VHQVRGRFK]XPLQGHVW6lNXODUH )RUPHQGHV7URVWHVLQ$XVVLFKWVWHOOW9LHOVDJHQGLVWGHUYRQ+RQQHWKJHZlKOWH 7LWHO(QWPlFKWLJXQJHQGHU5HDOLWlWZHLOGDULQEHUHLWVDQNOLQJWZDVIULKQGHQ EHVRQGHUHQ*HKDOWVlNXODUHU7URVWHUIDKUXQJHQDXVPDFKW6LHVWHOOHQGHQ+HUU VFKDIWVDQVSUXFK HLQHU DOV EHGUFNHQG HPSIXQGHQHQ :LUNOLFKNHLW LQIUDJH ,Q GLHVHU:LUNOLFKNHLWVSLHJHOWVLFKQlKHUEHWUDFKWHWGDV:HOWELOGGHVGXUFKIRUW VFKUHLWHQGHÄZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH$XINOlUXQJ³ZLH+RQQHWKVFKUHLEWKHXW]XWDJH ÄEHLQDKHVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKJHZRUGHQHQ1DWXUDOLVPXV³ZLGHU6FKLHUDOWHUQD WLYORVHUVFKHLQWYRQGDKHUGLH(LQVLFKWGDVVDXFKGDVHLJHQH'DVHLQGHQNDXVD OHQ*HVHW]PlLJNHLWHQGHV:HUGHQVXQG9HUJHKHQVXQWHUOLHJW 2EZLUHVZROOHQRGHUQLFKWREZLUJOlXELJVLQGRGHUEHU]HXJWH$WKHLVWHQ>«@ 8QVGURKW GDVVHOEH6FKLFNVDOGDVDOOHQQDWUOLFKHQ:HVHQEHVFKLHGHQLVWZLUZHUGHQPLWGHU*HEXUW HLQHPULVNDQWHQ/HEHQDXVJHVHW]WVLQGVWlQGLJYRQRUJDQLVFKHQ.UDQNKHLWHQEHGURKWXQG VHKHQLP7RGGHP8QWHUJDQJDOOHV/HEHQGLJHQHQWJHJHQ
(EG $D2 'HU7H[WOLHJWDOV:LHGHUDEGUXFNLPYHU|IIHQWOLFKHQ$XIVDW]EDQG'DV,FKLP:LU YRU YJO+211(7+H 'HU2ULJLQDOWH[WZXUGHDEJHGUXFNWLQ 3(7(5685%$1± +211(7+H I9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 ± $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
4XHU]XGLHVHUDOVDOWHUQDWLYORVWLWXOLHUWHQ3HUVSHNWLYHOLHJHQDEHUQDFK+RQQHWKV 'LDJQRVHGHQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ8PJDQJPLWGHP7RGSUlJHQGH+DQGOXQJVZHLVHQ XQG+DOWXQJHQÄ.HLQHUYRQXQVLVWLUULWLHUW³VRVWHOOWHUHWZDIHVWÄZHQQVLFK HLQH3HUVRQDP*UDEPDOPLWGHPMQJVW9HUVWRUEHQHQ]XXQWHUKDOWHQEHJLQQW³ REZRKO GLHV LQ GLH GRPLQDQWH QDWXUDOLVWLVFKH /HEHQVVLFKW RIIHQVLFKWOLFK QXU VFKZHULQWHJULHUW]XZHUGHQYHUPDJ$XFKGDULQÄPLW(UJULIIHQKHLWDQ%HJUlE QLVVHQWHLO>]X@QHKPHQ>«@GHUHQULWXHOOHU$EODXIYRQGHUPHKURGHUZHQLJHU VWLOOVFKZHLJHQGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHLQHUXQVWHUEOLFKHQ6HHOHOHEW³HQWGHFNWHU HLQHGXUFKDXVJlQJLJH3UD[LVGLHNDXPHLQHP%HWHLOLJWHQZLGHUVSUFKOLFKHU VFKHLQW3KlQRPHQHGLHVHU$UWLQGHQHQVLFKGLHDQDFKURQLVWLVFKH9RUVWHOOXQJ HLQHV)RUWOHEHQVEHUGHQ7RGKLQDXVZHLWHU%DKQEULFKWVWHOOHQIU+RQQHWKLQ )UDJHGDVVGLHQDWXUDOLVWLVFKH'DVHLQVVLFKWDEVROXW]XVHW]HQLVW9LHOPHKUZLUG OHW]WHUHLPPHUZLHGHUUHODWLYLHUWZHQQÄZLUXQVPHQWDOH=XVWlQGHHUODXEHQLQ GHQHQGLHYHUOlOLFKHQ8QWHUWHLOXQJHQXQVHUHU:HOWVLFKWPLWHLQHP0DOHLQJHN ODPPHUWRGHUDXIJHKREHQVLQG³6ROFKH0RPHQWHHLQHUÄNRJQLWLYH>Q@5HJUHV VLRQ>@³IKUHQ]ZDUZLH+RQQHWKEHWRQWQLFKW]XUÄVFKODJDUWLJHQ:LHGHUNHKU HLQHVUHOLJL|VHQ*UXQGYHUWUDXHQV³GHP]XIROJHZLUÄXQVRGHUDQGHUH>«@PLW HLQHP0DOGHUVFKW]HQGHQ+DQG*RWWHVDQYHUWUDXW³ZLVVHQ'RFKZLOOHUVLH DXFKQLFKWPLW)UHXGDOV$XVGUXFNWULHEJHVWHXHUWHU,OOXVLRQHQEUDQGPDUNHQGLH ]XJXQVWHQ HLQHU DXIJHNOlUWUDWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQ :HOWDQVFKDXXQJ ]X EHUZLQGHQ ZlUHQ+RQQHWKKlOWVWDWWGHVVHQHLQHSV\FKRORJLVFKH/HVDUWIUSKlQRPHQJH UHFKWGLHHUHEHQXQWHU5HNXUVDXI'RQDOG:LQQLFRWWV7KHRULHGHUhEHUJDQJVRE MHNWHIRUPXOLHUW 0DFKWGLH9HUOXVWHUIDKUXQJGLHGHU7RGHLQHVQDKHVWHKHQGHQ0HQVFKHQEH GHXWHW GHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG YRQ LQQHUHU XQG lXHUHU 5HDOLWlW YRQ :XQVFK XQG :LUNOLFKNHLW QlPOLFK PLW EHVRQGHUHU 6FKlUIH EHZXVVW YHUPDJ +RQQHWK GDV )HVWKDOWHQ DP )RUWOHEHQ GHV 9HUVWRUEHQHQ DOV ÃWUDQVLWLRQDO SKHQRPHQRQµ ]X GHXWHQ:HUVROFKHVWXWEHWULWWDOVRHLQHQLQWHUPHGLlUHQ(UIDKUXQJVEHUHLFKLQ GHPWURVWVWLIWHQGGLHYHUORUHQH%H]LHKXQJDXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQZHUGHQNDQQÄ'LH NRJQLWLYH5HJUHVVLRQ³VRVFKlUIW+RQQHWKDEHUHQWJHJHQYRUVFKQHOOHU3DWKRORJL VLHUXQJHQHLQÄHUIROJWLP'LHQVWHLQHUDXIJHNOlUWHQ%HZlOWLJXQJGHV/HEHQV³ GHQQ ÄZLUDOOHEHGUIHQJHOHJHQWOLFKVROFKHU(QWODVWXQJHQVHLHVXPXQVNRQW UDIDNWLVFKGHU1lKHJHOLHEWHU3HUVRQHQ]XYHUVLFKHUQVHLHVXPXQVHUHUbQJVWH DQJHVLFKWVHLQHUXQYHUIJEDUHQ:HOW+HUU]XZHUGHQ³'DVVHVVLFKEHLVROFKHQ
$D2 (EG $D2 $D2 $D2 9JO]XU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW)UHXG +211(7+H± 9JO]XU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW:LQQLFRWWXQG]XPIROJHQGHQ +211(7+H± :LQQLFRWWHQWIDOWHWVHLQH7KHRULHGHVhEHUJDQJVREMHNWVLQ :,11,&277 +211(7+H
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
NRPSHQVDWRULVFK]XQHQQHQGHQ9ROO]JHQXPGH]LGLHUWVlNXODUH)RUPHQGHV 7URVWHVKDQGHOWKlQJWIU+RQQHWKRIIHQVLFKWOLFKGDUDQGDVVVLHHEHQIDOOVNDX VDOGHWHUPLQLVWLVFKUHGX]LHUEDUE]ZQDWXUDOLVLHUEDUVLQG6LHPDUNLHUHQGHQÄ%H UHLFKHLQHUUDWLRQDOJHGXOGHWHQ0HWDSK\VLN³GHUDOV3URGXNWIUKNLQGOLFKHU ZRUEHQHU%HGUIQLVVHQDFKHLQHU(QWODVWXQJYRQGHU6HOEVW:HOW6SDOWXQJ]X GHFKLIIULHUHQLVW$OOHQWKHRUHWLVFKHQ(QW]DXEHUQV]XP7URW]EOHLEWKLHUDEHUHLQ 0RPHQWGHV=DXEHUVHUKDOWHQGHQ+RQQHWKGHQMHZHLOV%HWURIIHQHQQLFKWQHK PHQP|FKWHMDGHULKPJHUDGH]XUÄ6WHLJHUXQJXQVHUHUUDWLRQDOHQ)lKLJNHLWHQ³ Q|WLJHUVFKHLQW*HPHLQWLVWGLHDXFKLQLQWHQVLYHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWVHUIDKUXQJHQ UHNDSLWXOLHUWH$QHUNHQQXQJVJHZLVVKHLWDXVIUKNLQGOLFKHQ7DJHQGLHJHZLVVHU PDHQÃVWlUNHULVWDOVHU7RGµ +RQQHWKJUHLIWGLHVHQ)DGHQZLHGHUDXIZHQQHULQVHLQHPHUVFKLHQHQHQ :HUN'DV5HFKWGHU)UHLKHLWGLH)DPLOLHDOVÄHLQH>@GHUJDQ]ZHQLJHQ6WlWWHQLQ XQVHUHQ *HVHOOVFKDIWHQ³ EH]HLFKQHW ÄDQ GHQHQ GLH 6XEMHNWH QRFK VlNXODUHQ 7URVW]XHPSIDQJHQYHUP|JHQZHLOVLHVLFK]XPLQGHVWILNWLYLQHLQHPVLHEHU GDXHUQGHQ *DQ]HQ DXIJHKREHQ ZLVVHQ N|QQHQ³ 'HP LQWHUJHQHUDWLRQHOOHQ &KDUDNWHUIDPLOLlUHU6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHVROHJWHUGRUWGDUZRKQWGDV3RWHQ]LDO LQQHGLH*UHQ]HQHQGOLFKHQ/HEHQVHLQ6WFNZHLWEHUVFKUHLWEDUZHUGHQ]X ODVVHQÄ'DV.LQGNDQQVLFKSUREHZHLVH]XP,QWHUDNWLRQVSDUWQHUVHLQHV9DWHUV RGHUVHLQHU0XWWHUPDFKHQGLH(OWHUQN|QQHQVLFKYRQGHQELRORJLVFKHQ*HJH EHQKHLWHQLKUHV$OWHUVHQWODVWHQLQGHPVLH]XP6SLHONDPHUDGHQLKUHU7RFKWHU RGHULKUHV6RKQHVZHUGHQ³ VFKUHLEW+RQQHWK'XUFKGLHYHUPLWWHOVZHFKVHOVHL WLJHU5ROOHQEHUQDKPHVSLHOHULVFKVLFKYROO]LHKHQGH3URJUHVVLRQE]Z5HJUHVVL RQZLUGLQVHLQHQ$XJHQÄGDV8QYHUIJEDUHDQXQVHUHU1DWXUIUNXU]H$XJHQ EOLFNHHQWPlFKWLJW³ -HQHPXQYHUPHLGOLFKHQ6FKLFNVDOGHU9HUJlQJOLFKNHLWXQG GHV6WHUEHQPVVHQVYHUPDJPDQVRGHPQDFKPRPHQWKDIW]XHQWIOLHKHQ(LQH GDXHUKDIWH)RUPHUKlOWGLHVHULQWHUJHQHUDWLRQHOOH5ROOHQWDXVFKZHQQGLH.LQGHU VFKOLHOLFK)UVRUJHSIOLFKWHQIULKUH(OWHUQEHUQHKPHQ$XFKGDULQVLHKW+RQ QHWKGDV3RWHQ]LDOHLQHUIUHLKHLWVVWLIWHQGHQÄ(QWODVWXQJYRQEHGUFNHQGHU(LQ VDPNHLWXQG7RGHVIXUFKW³DQJHOHJW 'LHÄIUVRUJOLFKH+HLPKROXQJLQGHQ/H EHQVDQIDQJ³±.LQGGHUHLJHQHQ.LQGHU]XZHUGHQ±ÄYHUPDJ>«@PLWGHUHLJHQ WPOLFKHQ.UDIWGHU'HUHDOLVLHUXQJGLHKHLOVDPHWU|VWHQGH)LNWLRQ]XHU]HXJHQ GDXQVHU/HEHQLP.UHLVGHU)DPLOLHDQVHLQHQ$QIDQJVSXQNW]XUFNNHKUWXQG GDKHUHLQHQVWLPPLJHQ$EVFKOXVVILQGHQNDQQ³ :DVLP%OLFNDXIV/HEHQVHQGHUHNDSLWXOLHUWZLUGLVWZLHGHUXPMHQHQDFK +RQQHWKDP$QIDQJGHV/HEHQVVWHKHQGHÄRULJLQDOH[SHULHQFH³HLQHUXQJHEUR
(EG (EG +211(7+9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 (EG $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
FKHQHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWYRQGHUHUVFKUHLEWPDQHUOHEHVLFKGDULQÄVRIXOO\ ORYHG>«@WKDWDOO\RXUZLVKHVDPELWLRQVLQWHQWLRQVDUHH[SHULHQFHGVRPHZKDW DXWRPDWLFDOO\>«@IXOILOOHG³ 'DVVGHUHQ:LHGHUEHOHEXQJGLHXQEHZXVVWH$Q WULHEVNUDIWKLQWHUDOOHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWHQWIDOWXQJVEHVWUHEXQJHQGDUVWHOOW ZLUGYRQ:KLWHERRNDXVGUFNOLFKEHVWULWWHQZHQQHUHWZDYRQHLQHUÄSUHVXSSR VLWLRQ RI RPQLSRWHQFH³ VSULFKW *HJHQ +RQQHWKV 5H]HSWLRQ YRQ )UHXG XQG :LQQLFRWWEULQJWHUZLHQXQ]X]HLJHQLVWHLQHDOWHUQDWLYH'HXWXQJGHVIUK NLQGOLFKHQ2EMHNWEH]LHKXQJVYHUKDOWHQVXQGGHUGDULQ]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPHQ GHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ7ULHEQDWXU]XU*HOWXQJ'HPQDFKLVWHVHLQH(UIDKUXQJYRQ $OOPDFKWGLHGLHDXFKYRQDN]HQWXLHUWHQ9HUVFKPHO]XQJV]XVWlQGHGHP6lXJ OLQJYHUVFKDIIHQ
$OOPDFKWVIDQWDVLHQ :KLWHERRNVKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKH :LQQLFRWW'HXWXQJ Ä>:@KRVLQFH:LQQLFRWW¶VIDPRXVDSHUFXWKDWWKHUHFDQEHQREDE\ZLWKRXWD PRWKHUFDQGLVDJUHHZLWKWKHFHQWUDOLW\RILQWHUDFWLRQDQGLWVUDPLILFDWLRQVIRU FODVVLFDOWKHRU\"³ :LH:KLWHERRNVUKHWRULVFKJHPHLQWH)UDJHDQNOLQJHQOlVVW LVWHUHLQHP9HUVWlQGQLVGHUIUKNLQGOLFKHQ(QWZLFNOXQJJHJHQEHUQLFKWJUXQG VlW]OLFK DEJHQHLJW GDV VLFK EH]LHKXQJVRULHQWLHUWHU DOV GHU NODVVLVFK IUHXGLDQLVFKH$QVDW]DXVQLPPWÄ)UHXG¶VWKHRU\RISULPDU\QDUFLVVLVPPXVWEH FULWLFL]HG³ JLEW HU LP 6WUHLWJHVSUlFK PLW +RQQHWK GHPJHPl ]X 3URWRNROO *HPHLQWLVWGLHLQGHU SXEOL]LHUWHQ6FKULIW=XU(LQIKUXQJGHV1DU]LPXV HQWZLFNHOWHÄ9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHUXUVSUQJOLFKHQ/LELGREHVHW]XQJGHV,FKV³GLH GRUW DOV IU GDV 6lXJOLQJVDOWHU FKDUDNWHULVWLVFK HUNOlUW ZLUG 'LHV JHKW ODXW )UHXG PLW HLQHU DXVJHSUlJWHQ Ä6HOEVWJHQJVDPNHLW XQG 8Q]XJlQJOLFKNHLW³ DXIVHLWHQ GHV .LQGHV HLQKHU =XGHP LVW HV GXUFK ÄHLQH hEHUVFKlW]XQJ GHU 0DFKW³VHLQHUÄ:QVFKHXQGSV\FKLVFKHQ$NWH³JHSUlJWGLHVLFKQDFKDXHQ KLQDXFKDJJUHVVLY$XVGUXFNYHUVFKDIIW.ULWLNZUGLJHUVFKHLQW:KLWHERRNDQ GHU$QQDKPHGHVSULPlUHQ1DU]LVVPXVQXQGDVVVLHGHP6lXJOLQJHLQHJlQ]OLFK DQWLVR]LDOHXQGUHDOLWlWVYHUOHXJQHQGH+DOWXQJ]XVFKUHLEW'HVVHQ2IIHQZHUGHQ
+211(7+:+,7(%22. $D2 :+,7(%22.9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQLQVEHVRQGHUH '(16II III II +211(7+:+,7(%22.±I :+,7(%22. II II:KLWHERRNKDWLQHLQHPXQWHUGHP(LQGUXFNGHUSROLWLVFKHQ'LVNXVVLRQHQ ZlKUHQGGHU&RURQD3DQGHPLHYHUIDVVWHQ7H[WVHLQH.ULWLNDQ+RQQHWKNU]OLFKQRFKHLQPDO EHNUlIWLJW 'HVVHQ7LWHOÄ0LVXVHRI:LQQLFRWW³]HLJWGLH6WRULFKWXQJDQ YJO'(16 +211(7+:+,7(%22. 9JOGD]X)5(8' )UGDV=LWDW DD2 $D2 $D2
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
IUGLH:LUNOLFKNHLWDXFKGHV6R]LDOHQNDQQQlPOLFKVRQXUY|OOLJXQYHUPLWWHOW XQGKDQGVWUHLFKDUWLJHUIROJHQ(VLVWVWHOOWHUXQWHU9HUZHLVDXI-HDQ/DSODQFKH KHUDXVZLHEHLPÃFDUWHVLDQLVFKHQFRJLWRµ ÄWKHUH¶VQRHVFDSHQRZD\RXWXQOHVV \RXEULQJLQ*RGDVDGHXVH[PDFKLQD³=XGLHVHP0LWWHOP|FKWH:KLWHERRN DOOHUGLQJVQLFKWJUHLIHQ6WDWWGHVVHQVFKOLHWHUVLFKKLHUGHU(JR3V\FKRORJLH +HLQ]+DUWPDQQVDQEHLGHPHVKHLW Ä'LH$XIJDEHGHU$QSDVVXQJGHV0HQ VFKHQ DQ GHQ 0HQVFKHQ LVW >«@ YRQ $QEHJLQQ JHJHEHQ³ 1HEHQ GHQ YRQ )UHXGEHVFKULHEHQHQQDU]LVVWLVFKHQ1HLJXQJHQVRJUHLIWHU+DUWPDQQV%HLWUDJ DXINRPPHQGHP1HXJHERUHQHQDGDSWLYH.RPSHWHQ]HQ]XGLHHVEHUHLWVLP JHZLVVHQ0DHIUVHLQHVR]LDOH8PZHOWDXIJHVFKORVVHQVHLQODVVHQ 'LHVHV0DEHU]LHKHQGLHLP%DQQGHVREHQVNL]]LHUWHQÃUHODWLRQDOPRGHOµ VWHKHQGHQ3RVLWLRQHQDXV:KLWHERRNV6LFKWMHGRFKJHZDOWLJ0LWGHVVHQ'RPL QDQ]GURKHQQlPOLFKMHQHDQWLVR]LDOHQ$VSHNWHGHUFRQGLWLRKXPDQDGLHLKPLQ )UHXGV%LOGGHUIUKNLQGOLFKHQ/HEHQVSKDVH]XVWDUNKHUYRUJHKREHQVLQGYROO HQGVDXVUDGLHUW]XZHUGHQÄ,QWKHLUDWWHPSWWRFRXQWHUDFWWKHRQHVLGHGQHVVRI WKHRUWKRGR[)UHXGLDQVWKHPHPEHUVRIWKH5HODWLRQDO/HIW³ZLH:KLWHERRNVLH ELVZHLOHQQHQQWÄDUHRIWHQJXLOW\RIRQHVLGHGQHVVLQWKHRSSRVLWHGLUHFWLRQ 7KDWLVWRVD\WKH\RIWHQWHQGWRK\SRVWDWL]HWKHSURVRFLDOTXDOLWLHVRIWKHKXPDQ DQLPDO³'LHVH9HUHLQVHLWLJXQJDEHUEHJLEWVLFKLQVHLQHQ$XJHQGHVXQDE ZHLVOLFKHQDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ:DKUKHLWVJHKDOWVIUHXGVFKHU(LQVLFKWHQLQVEH VRQGHUHGDV3KlQRPHQGHV1DU]LVVPXVEHWUHIIHQG6WDWWGLHGDPLWJHVWHOOWH+H UDXVIRUGHUXQJDQ]XQHKPHQÄWKDWWKHHVVHQWLDOVRFLDELOLW\RIWKHKXPDQDQLPDO PXVWEHFDOOHGLQWRTXHVWLRQ³ZLUGGDV)UDJZUGLJHOLHEHUIUDJORVYRUDXVJH VHW]W6RJHVWHKWPDQGHPZLHHVDXVGUFNOLFKKHLWÄNRPSHWHQWH>Q@6lXJOLQJ³ TXD*HEXUWHLQHÄZHLWDXVJU|HUH$XVVWDWWXQJ]XU$QSDVVXQJ³DQGLH6R]LDOYHU KlOWQLVVH]XXQGOlVVWLKQÄVWlUNHUDXIGLH5HDOLWlWHLQJHVWLPPW³VHLQÄDOVPDQMH ]X JODXEHQ YHUPRFKWH³ $XFK YHUNHKUW VLFK GLH GXUFK )UHXGV 1DU]LVVPXV 7KHVHDN]HQWXLHUWH6HOEVWJHQJVDPNHLWXQG8Q]XJlQJOLFKNHLWKLHUGHUDUWLQLKU *HJHQWHLOGDVVGDV.LQGDOVHLQÄYRQ$QIDQJDQKRFKLQWHUDNWLYPLWGHU0XW WHU³LQUH]LSURNHP$XVWDXVFKVWHKHQGHV:HVHQHUVFKHLQW8QWHUGHPQDKHOLH JHQGHQ7LWHO9RQ)UHXG]X6WHUQEULQJW0DUWLQ'RUQHV$XWRUGHV%XFKHV'HU NRPSHWHQWH6lXJOLQJGLHVH7KHRULHHQWZLFNOXQJVRDXIGHQ3XQNW 1LFKWPHKUGDV%LOGGHVVDWWHQVHOLJDQGHU%UXVWLQGHQ6FKODIVLQNHQGHQ6lXJOLQJVVRQGHUQ GDVGHVUH]LSURNHQ/lFKHOVSLHOV]ZLVFKHQ0XWWHUXQG.LQGGDVPLWGUHLELVYLHU0RQDWHQ VHLQHQ+|KHSXQNWHUUHLFKWV\PEROLVLHUWQXQGHQDNWLYHQ8UVSUXQJGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ([LVWHQ]
+211(7+:+,7(%22. +$570$11 9JO]X+DUWPDQQV$QVDW] +$57.$03I :+,7(%22. $D2 :+,7(%22.+HUYRUKG9HUI'LH5HGHYRPÄNRPSHWHQWHQ6lXJOLQJ³JHKW DXIGHQJOHLFKQDPLJHQYRQ/-RVHSK6WRQHKHUDXVJHJHEHQHQ6DPPHOEDQG 6721( ]XUFNXQGZXUGHLPGHXWVFKVSUDFKLJHQ5DXPGXUFK0DUWLQ'RUQHVJHSUlJW '251(6 :+,7(%22.
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
'LHVHV3DUDGLHVLVWNHLQ2UWPHKUDQGHP0LOFKXQG+RQLJLQGHQ6lXJOLQJIOLHHQGHUQXU QRFKGHQ0XQG]X|IIQHQEUDXFKWVRQGHUQHLQHUDQGHP]ZHL6XEMHNWH0LOFKXQG+RQLJ DXVWDXVFKHQXQGVLFKEHUGLH$UWGHV$XVWDXVFKVNRQWLQXLHUOLFKPLWHLQDQGHUYHUVWlQGLJHQ
$XFK+RQQHWKV$QVDW]KDW:KLWHERRNPLWVHLQHU.ULWLNDQGLHVHU7KHRULHSHUV SHNWLYHLP9LVLHU6RXQWHUVWHOOWHULKPDOOHLQGHVKDOEÄYRQGHQ.OHLQNLQGIRU VFKHUQ>«@DQJH]RJHQ³]XVHLQZHLOÄLKUH(UJHEQLVVH>]HLJHQ@GDGDV0HQ VFKHQNLQG>«@DELQLWLRVR]LDOLVW³'RFKOlVVWVLFK+RQQHWKV3RVLWLRQDXIGHQ HUVWHQ%OLFNGHUGDUJHVWHOOWHQ6LFKWZHLVHNDXPJlQ]OLFK]XRUGQHQ'LHYRQ'RU QHV EHPKWH ,G\OOH GHV VDWWHQ 6lXJOLQJV GHU VLFK DQ GLH PWWHUOLFKH %UXVW VFKPLHJWOHJWHUHUJHUDGHQLFKW]XJXQVWHQGHVQHXHQ,GHDOELOGVGHUDXI$XJHQ K|KHÃ0LOFKXQG+RQLJµDXVWDXVFKHQGHQ%H]LHKXQJVSDUWQHU]XGHQ$NWHQ'D QLHO6WHUQV9HUDEVFKLHGXQJGHUV\PELRWLVFKHQ)XVLRQVHUOHEQLVVHGLHLQVEHVRQ GHUHDQGHUEHVDJWHQ6]HQHKDIWHQZHLVWHUZLHJHVHKHQPLW)UHG3LQH]XUFN 'HVVHQÄ7KHRULHGHU0RPHQWH³QDFKGHUHVZHGHUEHUHFKWLJWLVWÄGHQ6lXJOLQJ >«@DOVJlQ]OLFKLQVLFKYHUVHQNWXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUW³QRFKLKQDOVÄY|OOLJNRPSH WHQW³ XQGVR]LDOLQWHUDNWLYDQ]XVHKHQJUHLIWDXFK:KLWHERRNDIILUPDWLYDXI $Q GHU SKlQRPHQJHUHFKWHQ 'HXWXQJ GHU HSLVRGLVFK ZLHGHUNHKUHQGHQ 9HU VFKPHO]XQJV]XVWlQGH]ZLVFKHQ0XWWHUXQG.LQGVFKHLGHQVLFKDOOHUGLQJVGLH *HLVWHUGHUEHLGHQ.RQWUDKHQWHQ 7KHGDUNVLGHRI:LQQLFRWW±GLHDQWLVR]LDOH7HQGHQ]GHV6XEMHNWV 2PQLSRWHQFHRUIXVLRQ"±GLHEHUGHPSXEOL]LHUWHQ6WUHLWJHVSUlFK]ZL VFKHQ +RQQHWK XQG :KLWHERRN SUDQJHQGH )UDJH VWHOOW GLH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 'HXWXQJVRSWLRQHQQHEHQHLQDQGHU+RQQHWKDN]HQWXLHUWGHQ$VSHNWGHU)XVLRQDQ GHQIUKNLQGOLFKHQ9HUVFKPHO]XQJVHUIDKUXQJHQ(UEHWRQWZLHJHVHKHQGDVV VLHYRUDOOHPDOV0RPHQWHHLQHVK|FKVWLQWHQVLYHQ9HUEXQGHQVHLQVPLWHLQHP DQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQHUOHEWZHUGHQZDVHUGXUFKGHQ%HJULIIHLQHUÃXQJHEURFKH QHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµHLQ]XIDQJHQVXFKW:KLWHERRNKLQJHJHQOHJWVHLQ$X JHQPHUNGDUDXIGDVVGLH9HUVFKPHO]XQJV]XVWlQGHGHP6lXJOLQJHLQH(UIDKUXQJ YRQ$OOPDFKWYHUVFKDIIHQQDFKGHUHQ5HVWLWXWLRQGLHVHUGHPQDFKLQ3KDVHQGHU 7UHQQXQJEHJHKUW:LHEHL+RQQHWKNRPPWGLHVHPIUKNLQGOLFKHLQVHW]HQGHQ 6WUHEHQHLQHOHEHQVODQJH%HGHXWXQJ]XLVWHVGHU*UXQGYRQGHP0HQVFKHQ LQQHZRKQHQGHQÄDQWLVRFLDOWHQGHQFLHV³DQGHQHQVLFK]HLJW ÄWKDWWKURXJKRXW OLIHWKHDFFHSWDQFHRIWKHLQGHSHQGHQWREMHFWLVDSUREOHP³ 'DVLPPHUZLHGHUDXIEUHFKHQGH8QYHUP|JHQ$QGHUHLQLKUHPVHOEVWlQGLJHQ $QGHUVVHLQDQHUNHQQHQ]XN|QQHQIROJWDEHUHEHQQLFKWDXVGHP:XQVFKQDFK 5FNNHKULQGLHLGHDOLVLHUWH*HERUJHQKHLWHLQHUXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWL YLWlW9LHOPHKUVROOVLFKGDULQGDV)RUWZLUNHQMHQHVIUKNLQGOLFKHQ2PQLSR
'251(6 :+,7(%22. $D2± +211(7+:+,7(%22.
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
WHQ]HUOHEHQVQLHGHUVFKODJHQGHP)UHXGLQVHLQHU$QQDKPHHLQHVSULPlUHQ1DU ]LVVPXVHWZDVEHU]RJHQHQ7ULEXWJH]ROOWKDWÄ%\PLQLPL]LQJRUGHQ\LQJWKH UROHRIRPQLSRWHQFHLQSV\FKLFOLIH³VFKlUIW:KLWHERRNNULWLVFKHLQÄ+RQQHWK SURYLGHVXVZLWKDQRYHUO\VRFLDOL]HGDFFRXQWRIWKHKXPDQDQLPDODQG>«@ GRPHVWLFDWHVSV\FKRDQDO\WLFWKHRU\³'DULQXQGYRUDOOHPDEHULQVHLQHUGHP EHVDJWHQÃRYHUVRFLDOL]LQJµYHUSIOLFKWHWHQ:LQQLFRWW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHUZHLVWVLFK +RQQHWKDXVVHLQHU6LFKWDOVOHJLWLPHU(UEHGHUEH]LHKXQJVRULHQWLHUWHQ3V\FKR ORJLHE]Z6lXJOLQJVIRUVFKXQJÄ>/@LNHWKHUHODWLRQDODQDO\VWVKHWHQGVWRPDNH VHOHFWLYHXVHRI:LQQLFRWW³ODXWHW:KLWHERRNV'LDJQRVHGLHVLFKVHLQHUDOWHU QDWLYHQ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVWKHVHYHUGDQNW Ä:LQQLFRWWZDVDWKHRULVWRIRPQLSRWHQFH HYHU\ELWDVPXFKDV)UHXG³ 'DVV:LQQLFRWWEHUGDVYRQ)UHXGLQVROLSVLVWLVFKHQ=JHQJH]HLFKQHWH%LOG GHUIUKHQ.LQGKHLWKLQDXVJHKWLQGHPHUGLH0XWWHU.LQG5HODWLRQLQV=HQWUXP VHLQHUDOVREMHNWEH]LHKXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKILUPLHUHQGHQ5HIOH[LRQHQVWHOOWEHGHXWHW ZLHJHVDJWDXFKIU:KLWHERRNHLQHQ)RUWVFKULWWÄ>7@KDWWKHUH¶VQREDE\ZL WKRXWDPRWKHUZKLFKPHDQV\RXFDQQRWWDONDERXWDPRQDGLFVHOIHQFORVHG LQIDQWZLWKRXWDPRWKHU³LVWHLQH7KHVHGHVEULWLVFKHQ3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHUVGLH HUDXFKIUVHLQHHLJHQH3RVLWLRQLQ$QVSUXFKQLPPW6LHPDFKWHEHQNODUÄGDVV )UHXGV0RGHOOGHVDXWDUNHQ,FK]XU(UKHOOXQJGHUIUKHVWHQ(QWZLFNOXQJVSKDVH QXUK|FKVWXQ]XOlQJOLFKWDXJOLFKLVW³'RFKVREHUHFKWLJWHVDXFKVHLQPDJ :LQQLFRWWDOVHLQHQÄWZRSHUVRQSV\FKRORJLVW³]XOHVHQVRLOOHJLWLPHUVFKHLQW HV:KLWHERRNGLHVHQIUHLQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHV3URJUDPPLQ%HVFKODJ]X QHKPHQ8QWHUVFKODJHQZLUGQlPOLFKVRZDVHUÄWKHGDUNVLGHRI:LQQLFRWW³ QHQQW GLHDQWLVR]LDOHKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKH'LPHQVLRQYRQGHVVHQ7KHRULHDQJH VLFKWVGHUHUHULQJU|HUH1lKH]X)UHXGUFNWDOVHV+RQQHWKOLHEVHLQNDQQ %HFDXVHKHZDVDSHGLDWULFLDQDVZHOODVDQDQDO\VWZKRWHQGVWREHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWHGG\ EHDUVELWVRIVWULQJDQGVHFXULW\EODQNHWV:LQQLFRWWLVUHJXODUO\YLHZHGDVEHQHYROHQWMRYLDO DQGUHDVVXULQJ±DVDQDYXQFXODUDQGKHOSIXOILJXUHVWDQGLQJLQVWDUNFRQWUDVWWRWKHGDUN GHPDQGLQJDQGVHYHUH'U)UHXG>«@%XWWKLVLVRQO\SDUWRIWKHVWRU\
,QVHLQHP%HLWUDJ]XHLQHUSXEOL]LHUWHQ+RQQHWK)HVWVFKULIWEULQJW:KLWH ERRNHLQPDOPHKUGHQDQGHUHQ7HLOGHU*HVFKLFKWHLQNULWLVFKHU$EJUHQ]XQJ
:+,7(%22. $D2 +211(7+:+,7(%22.,P2ULJLQDONXUVLY $D2:RUDXIHUDQVSLHOWLVW:LQQLFRWWV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW)UHXGLQ:,1 1,&277 G'RUWVDJWHUPLWHLQHPEHUKPWJHZRUGHQHQ'LNWXP Ä,RQFHVDLG Ã7KHUHLVQR VXFKWKLQJDVDQLQIDQWµPHDQLQJRIFRXUVHWKDWZKHQHYHURQHILQGVDQLQIDQWRQHILQGVPD WHUQDOFDUHDQGZLWKRXWPDWHUQDOFDUHWKHUHZRXOGEHQRLQIDQW³ DD2 $QP :+,7(%22. :+,7(%22. +211(7+:+,7(%22. :+,7(%22.
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
YRQGHUHLQVHLWLJHQ/HVDUWGHV-XELODUV]XP7UDJHQ :LHVFKRQLQVHLQHU YHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ*HQHUDODEUHFKQXQJPLWGHPLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ3DUDGLJPD ZHLVWHULQVEHVRQGHUHGDUDXIKLQGDVVODXW:LQQLFRWWMHQHUXUDQIlQJOLFKH=XVWDQG HLQHUÃDEVROXWHGHSHQGHQFHµDXV6LFKWGHV.LQGHVJHUDGHQLFKWDOVHLQH6LWXDWLRQ GHU $EKlQJLJNHLW VRQGHUQ GHU $OOPDFKW HUOHEW ZLUG 'LH 0XWWHU EHUQLPPW GDEHLHLQHÄDX[LOLDU\HJRIXQFWLRQ³GKVLHIXQJLHUWDOVHLQH(UZHLWHUXQJGHV IUKNLQGOLFKHQ6HOEVWGDVQRFKYRQXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHU$UWLVWÄ$WWKHWLPHRI DEVROXWHGHSHQGHQFH³VFKUHLEW:LQQLFRWWÄWKHLQIDQWKDVQRW\HWVHSDUDWHGRXW WKHÃQRWPHµIURPWKHÃPHµ³9LHOPHKUJLEWHVIUGHQ6lXJOLQJLQGLHVHU3KDVH JHZLVVHUPDHQQXUVLFKVHOEVWXQGGLHHLJHQHQ%HGUIQLVVHZRPLWHLQ]HQWUDOHV (OHPHQWYRQ)UHXGV1DU]LVVPXV7KHRULHEHVWlWLJWZLUGZLH:KLWHERRNEHWRQW =ZDUJHKWHUZLHJHVDJWDXFKPLW3LQHGDYRQDXVGDVVHVYRQ$QIDQJDQ]XP :HFKVHO]ZLVFKHQNXU]HQ0RPHQWHQGHU9HUVFKPHO]XQJXQGOlQJHUHQ3KDVHQ GHU'LIIHUHQ]LHUWKHLWLP0XWWHU.LQG9HUKlOWQLVNRPPW'RFKVLHKWHUÄGLH%H GHXWXQJ³ GHU EHLGHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ Ä0RPHQWH QLFKW YRQ LKUHU =HLWGDXHU VRQGHUQYRQLKUHUDIIHNWLYHQ,QWHQVLWlW³DEKlQJHQGLHLP=XVWDQGGHU9HU VFKPHO]XQJHEHQVWDUNDXVJHSUlJWLVW 6RN|QQHQGLH$XVVDJHQ:LQQLFRWWVLPPHUQRFK:DKUKHLWEHDQVSUXFKHQGH QHQ]XIROJHGHUSULPlUH1DU]LVVPXVDXVIUKNLQGOLFKHU6LFKWHLQHÄOLYLQJUHDOL WL>\@³XQGÄRPQLSRWHQFH>«@QHDUO\DIDFWRIH[SHULHQFH³GDUVWHOOHQ:lK UHQGGLH0XWWHULQLKUHU]XQlFKVWEHGLQJXQJVORVHQ$GDSWLRQDQGLH%HGUIQLVVH GHV.LQGHV]%EHUHLWZLOOLJDN]HSWLHUWÄWKDWKHUEUHDVWLVSDUWRIWKHLQIDQW³ LVWVLHDXFKLP=XJHGHU]XQHKPHQGHQ'LVWDQ]QDKPHJHIRUGHUWGHVVHQLOOXVLRQl UH6HOEVWEHUVFKlW]XQJELV]XHLQHPJHZLVVHQ*UDG]XEHVWlWLJHQÄ7KHJRRG HQRXJKPRWKHUPHHWVWKHRPQLSRWHQFHRIWKHLQIDQWDQGWRVRPHH[WHQWPDNHV VHQVH RI LW³ KHLW HVEHL:LQQLFRWW 'DPLW HV VFKOLHOLFK GDV XQDEKlQJLJH (LJHQVHLQGHU5HDOLWlWE]ZGHVÃQRWPHµDQ]XHUNHQQHQYHUPDJLVWHV]ZDUDOO PlKOLFK]XGHVLOOXVLRQLHUHQDEHUDXFKZHLWHUKLQLQVHLQHUDOOPDFKWVWUXQNHQHQ :HOWXQG6HOEVWZDKUQHKPXQJ]XXQWHUVWW]HQ+LHUNRPPHQGLH3KlQRPHQH
:KLWHERRNEH]LHKWVLFKLQGHUPLWÄ7KHPLVXVHRI:LQQLFRWW³EHUVFKULHEHQHQ3DVVDJH GLHVHV7H[WHV YJODXFK]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2II QLFKWQDPHQWOLFKDXI+RQQHWKVRQGHUQ QXULQVJHVDPWDXIGLHDOVÄ5HODWLRQDOOHIW³WLWXOLHUWHEH]LHKXQJVRULHQWLHUWH5LFKWXQJLQQHUKDOE GHU3V\FKRDQDO\VH'RFKYHUZHLVWHUZLHGHUKROWDXI1RsOOH0F$IHHV6WXGLH]XP9HUKlOWQLV YRQ3ROLWLNXQG3V\FKRDQDO\VHGLHLQVEHVRQGHUH+RQQHWKV:LQQLFRWW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ/HVDUW HLQHUlXHUVWNULWLVFKHQ/HNWUHXQWHU]LHKW YJO0&$)(( II 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DXHUGHP :+,7(%22.± ± +211(7+:+,7(%22.± I :+,7(%22. :,11,&277 (EG :+,7(%22. :,11,&277 G :,11,&277E (EG :,11,&277 D
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
GHVhEHUJDQJVREMHNWVXQGGHU=HUVW|UXQJLQV6SLHOGLH:KLWHERRNlKQOLFKZLH +RQQHWKDOVKLOIUHLFKH0HWKRGHQDXIGHP:HJKLQ]XHLQHULPPHUVWlUNHUVLFK DXVSUlJHQGHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWVDN]HSWDQ]XQG6R]LDELOLWlWYHUVWHKW-HGRFKVRKlOW HUJHJHQEHU+RQQHWKV/HVDUWIHVWÄZUGHGLHJDQ]H9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHVhEHU JDQJVREMHNWVRKQHGLH$QQDKPHHLQHV8U]XVWDQGVGHU$OOPDFKWNHLQHQ6LQQ HUJHEHQ ZHLO $OOPDFKW JHQDX GDV 3UREOHP LVW GDV GXUFK VLH DQJHVSURFKHQ ZLUG³:DVVLFKGXUFKGHQVSLHOHULVFKHQ:HFKVHOLQHLQHLQWHUPHGLlUH6SKlUH ]ZLVFKHQ5HDOLWlWXQG)LNWLRQ$XVGUXFNYHUVFKDIIWLVWGHPQDFKNHLQH*HERU JHQKHLWVVHKQVXFKWVRQGHUQGHU:XQVFKGLH.RQWUROOH]XUFN]XHUODQJHQ,P $QVFKOXVVDQ0HODQLH.OHLQVSULFKW:KLWHERRNGLHVEH]JOLFKYRQÄRPQLSRWHQW GHIHQVHPHFKDQLVPV³GLHGDV%DE\PRELOLVLHUWZHQQHVPLWGHU8QDEKlQJLJNHLW GHVÃQRWPHµNRQIURQWLHUWZLUG'HPHQWVSUHFKHQGVLHKWHUDXFKGDVYRQ:LQ QLFRWWDQDO\VLHUWH3KlQRPHQIUKNLQGOLFKHU$JJUHVVLRQXQG=HUVW|UXQJVZXW± Ä>WKDW@WKHLQIDQWEHJLQVWRJHWDNLFNRXWRINLFNLQJ³ ±]XQlFKVWHLQPDOYRP %HJHKUHQJHOHLWHWGLH,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJGHUHLJHQHQ$OOPDFKWDE]XZHKUHQ(UVW QDFKXQGQDFKHQWIDOWHQGLHVHGHVWUXNWLYHQ$NWLRQHQHLQHQODXW+RQQHWKGDULQ YRQMHKHULPSOL]LHUWHQSURGXNWLYHQ&KDUDNWHU 6LHIKUHQGHP.LQGZHQQHWZD GLHHVJHZlKUHQODVVHQGH0XWWHUVLFKJHJHQEHUVHLQHQ$QJULIIHQDOVEHKDUUOLFK HUZHLVW YRU $XJHQ GDVV PDQ JHJHQEHU GHU XPJHEHQGHQ :HOW LPPHU DXFK PDFKWORVLVW =ZLVFKHQ'HVWUXNWLRQXQG,QQRYDWLRQ GLH$PELYDOHQ]GHU$OOPDFKW 'LHÃGXQNOH6HLWHµ:LQQLFRWWVGKVHLQHIUHXGLDQLVFKJHSUlJWH6HQVLELOLWlWIU GLHLP0HQVFKHQYRQ$QIDQJDQEHKHLPDWHWHQDQWLVR]LDOHQ%HVWUHEXQJHQNHKUW :KLWHERRNRIIHQVLFKWOLFKQLFKWKHUYRUXPGLHGHPJHJHQEHUÃKHOOHQµ$VSHNWH GHUFRQGLWLRKXPDQD]XYHUGHFNHQÄ>)@XQFWLRQLQJPHPEHUVRIFRQYHQWLRQDO VRFLHW\³KHUDQ]XELOGHQGLH]XUVLFKVHOEVWEHVFKUlQNHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV $QGHUHQGHVÃQRWPHµIlKLJVLQGEOHLEWDXFKKLHUGDVHUNOlUWH=LHOGHUGXUFK GLH (OWHUQ PDJHEOLFK EHHLQIOXVVWHQ (QWZLFNOXQJ 'RFK ZLH :KLWHERRN PLW 1RsOOH0F$IHHKHUDXVVWHOOW Ä(QYLURQPHQWVFDQIDLO³3DWKRORJLVFKH)ROJHQ NDQQHVGHPQDFKKDEHQZHQQGLH'HVLOOXVLRQLHUXQJGHULQIDQWLOHQ2PQLSRWHQ] IDQWDVLHQGHUDUWYRQVWDWWHQJHKWGLH.LQGHUQDXIZHOFKH:HLVHDXFKLPPHUNHL
:+,7(%22. 9JOHWZDVHLQH$XVVDJHQGD]XLQ +211(7+:+,7(%22.± *UXQGOH JHQGIU0HODQLH.OHLQV7KHRULHGHUÄGHIHQVHPHFKDQLVPV³LVWLKU$XIVDW]Ä$&RQWULEXWLRQWR WKH3V\FKRJHQHVLVRI0DQLF'HSUHVVLYH6WDWHV³ ZRHVKHLW Ä>4@XLWHOLWWOHFKLOGUHQ SDVVWKURXJKDQ[LHW\VLWXDWLRQV DQGUHDFWWRWKHPZLWKGHIHQFHPHFKDQLVPV WKHFRQWHQWRI ZKLFKLVFRPSDUDEOHWRWKDWRIWKHSV\FKRVHVRIDGXOWV³ ./(,1 'DVV:LQQLFRWW VLFKLKUH*HGDQNHQLQPRGLIL]LHUWHU)RUPDQJHHLJQHWKDW]HLJWVHLQLPVHOEHQ-DKUYHU|IIHQW OLFKWHU$XIVDW]Ä7KH0DQLF'HIHQFH³ YJO:,11,&277 :,11,&277 E :+,7(%22. 0&$)((
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
QHQ5DXP]XPGDUJHOHJWHQ8PJDQJPLW7UHQQXQJXQG9HUOXVWOlVVW,P$Q VFKOXVVDQGHQDXFKNOLQLVFKHUIDKUHQHQ:LQQLFRWWEHQHQQWHUP|JOLFKH.RQVH TXHQ]HQGLHVROFKHVR]LDOLQGX]LHUWHQ)HKOHQWZLFNOXQJHQIUGLH%HWURIIHQHQ]X KDEHQYHUP|JHQ Ä>7@KHLURPQLSRWHQFHZRQ¶WEHPROOLILHG³ÄWKH\PD\DWWHPSW WRPDLQWDLQWKHLUSRVLWLRQRIÃWRWDOLWDULDQH[FOXVLRQµDQGRPQLSRWHQWO\GHQ\WKH H[LVWHQFHRIWKHÃQRWPHµ³ÄFKLOGUHQFDQEHFRPHFRQVXPHGE\GHVWUXFWLYHUDJH DQGKDWUHGRIWKHPRWKHUDQGWKHUHE\RIWKHÃQRWPHµLQJHQHUDO³9HUVFKLHGH QH3V\FKRVHQKDEHQKLHUZLHGHUSUDNWL]LHUHQGH3V\FKRDQDO\WLNHU:KLWHERRN]X VDJHQZHLLKUHQ8UVSUXQJ :R]XGLHPDQJHOQGH$EPLOGHUXQJGHUIUKNLQGOLFKHQ2PQLSRWHQ]XQGLKUHV $QNlPSIHQVJHJHQGDVXQDEKlQJLJH6HOEVWVHLQGHV$QGHUHQIKUHQNDQQVSLH JHOWVLFKLQVHLQHQ$XJHQDXFKLQGHUSROLWLVFKHQ:HOWODJHGHV-DKUHVZL GHUÄ*LYHQWKLVVWDWHRIDIIDLUV³VRVFKUHLEWHU ,ZRXOGVXJJHVWWKDW:LQQLFRWW¶VFOLQLFDOGRFWULQHV±VSHFLILFDOO\WKHÃKDWUHGRIWKHQRWPHµ± DUHSDUWLFXODUO\ZHOOVXLWHGIRUDGGUHVVLQJDZRUOGWKDWLVDZDVKLQUDFLVPWULEDOLVPUHOLJLRXV KDWUHGQDWLRQDOLVPPLVRJ\Q\DQG[HQRSKRELD>«@:LWKHWKQLFFOHDQVLQJJHQRFLGHPDVV EHKHDGLQJVUDSHDVDZHDSRQRIZDULQWHQWLRQDOVWDUYDWLRQDQGLQGLVFULPLQDWHDHULDOERP ELQJZHDUHZLWQHVVLQJWKHDWWHPSWWRGHVWUR\WKHÃQRWPHµ
1HJDWLYH3KlQRPHQHZLHGLHVHPVVHQDXV:KLWHERRNV6LFKWDEHULPLQWHUVXE MHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ5DKPHQXQHUNOlUWEOHLEHQZHLOKLHUGLH6R]LDELOLWlWGHV0HQ VFKHQVHLQH1HLJXQJVLFKDXIGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH6WUXNWXUVR]LDOHU9HUKlOWQLVVH HLQ]XODVVHQ HLQVHLWLJ DN]HQWXLHUW ZLUG ÄÃ0LVUHFRJQLWLRQ RI WKH RWKHUµ³ VR VFKUHLEWHUPLWGHXWOLFKHU6WRULFKWXQJJHJHQ+RQQHWKÄLVWRRZHHNDFRQFHSWWR GHVFULEHWKHVHSKHQRPHQD³'DV6WUHEHQGHQ$QGHUHQDOVGDVÃQRWPHµ]X ]HUVW|UHQZLUGGHPQDFKLQVHLQHUQHJDWLYHQ.UDIWDEJHPLOGHUWZHQQPDQHVQXU DOV$XVGUXFNYHUZHLJHUWHU$QHUNHQQXQJYHUVWHKW'DULQQlPOLFKLVWGLH8QWHU VWHOOXQJHQWKDOWHQGDVVGLHPRUDOLVFKH)RUGHUXQJVLFK]XJXQVWHQGHV$QGHUHQ VHOEVW]XEHVFKUlQNHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUEHZXVVW]XUFNJHZLHVHQZLUG'LHV DEHUJHVFKLHKWKLHUQDFK:KLWHERRNV'DIUKDOWHQQLFKW*DQ]XQJHILOWHUWVFKOlJW LQGHQYRQLKPDXVIJHIKUWHQ3KlQRPHQHQZLH5DVVLVPXVUHOLJL|VEHJUQGHWHP +DVVRGHU1DWLRQDOLVPXVYLHOPHKUMHQHV2PQLSRWHQ]VWUHEHQGXUFKGDVHEHQ QLFKWVR]LDOHQ8UVSUXQJVLVW-HGHQIDOOVLVWHVGDVQLFKWLQGHP6LQQHGDVVHV DOOHUHUVWLQ5HDNWLRQDXIGLH8QDEKlQJLJNHLWGHV$QGHUHQHQWVWQGH6RQGHUQHV JUQGHWLP$OOPDFKWVHUOHEHQGDVLQGHQ3KDVHQHLQHUXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHQ(LQKHLW PLWGHUDOV,FK(UZHLWHUXQJIXQJLHUHQGHQ0XWWHUDXINRPPW =ZDUNDQQGDVVR]LDOH8PIHOGZLHJHVHKHQI|UGHUOLFKRGHUKLQGHUOLFKLP %OLFNDXIGLH6XEOLPLHUXQJGHV2PQLSRWHQ]VWUHEHQGHVVHLQDEHUHVNDQQHEHQ VHLQ(QWVWHKHQQLFKWYHUKLQGHUQ)DOVFKZlUHHVGHVKDOEDXFKLQLKPHLQUHLQ
:+,7(%22. $D2 (EG
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
UHDNWLYHV3KlQRPHQ]XVHKHQZLH:KLWHERRNHVLQ+RQQHWKV3RVLWLRQLPSOL]LHUW VLHKW +RQQHWK>«@WHQGVWRDVVXPHWKDWDQWLVRFLDOSKHQRPHQDOLNHGHVWUXFWLYHQHVVDQGRPQLSRWHQFH DUHQRWLQWULQVLFIHDWXUHVRISV\FKLFOLIHEXWDUHUHDFWLYHWKDWLVWKHUHVXOWRIHQYLURQPHQWDO IDLOXUH7KHLPSOLFDWLRQLVWKDWWKH\FRXOGEHDYRLGHGWKURXJKEHWWHUIDPLOLDODUUDQJHPHQWVDQG FKLOGUHDULQJSUDFWLFHV
%HL+RQQHWKVRKDWWHQZLUJHVHKHQZLUGGLHDQWLVR]LDOH7HQGHQ]GHP$QGHUHQ GLH$QHUNHQQXQJVHLQHVXQDEKlQJLJHQ6HOEVWVHLQVLPPHUZLHGHU]XYHUZHKUHQ DOVHLQH5HDNWLRQDXIGHQ'LIIHUHQ]FKDUDNWHUGHV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQYHUVWDQGHQ 'DKLQWHUVWHKWGHU:XQVFKLQMHQHXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW]XUFN]X NHKUHQGLHLQIUKNLQGOLFKHU=HLWHUOHEWZXUGH$XV:KLWHERRNV6LFKWHQWVWDP PHQGLHDQWLVR]LDOHQ$QWHLOHLP0HQVFKHQGLHVHUXQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHQ$XVJDQJVOD JHVHOEVWLQGLHZLHHUPRQLHUWÄ+RQQHWKV*HEUDXFKGHV%HJULIIVÃ,QWHUVXEMHN WLYLWlWµ]XYLHO%HGHXWXQJ³KHUHLQVFKPXJJHOW'XUFKGDVXUVSUQJOLFKH2PQL SRWHQ]HUOHEHQDQWLVR]LDOJHSUlJWWULIIWGHU0HQVFKQlPOLFKHUVWDXIGLHIU6R]L DOYHUKlOWQLVVHVSH]LILVFKH8QDEKlQJLJNHLWGHV$QGHUHQPLWGHU HUVLFKGDQQ PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU HUIROJUHLFK ]X DUUDQJLHUHQ OHUQW 'LHVHV VFKRQ LQ )UHXGV 7KHRULHGHVSULPlUHQ1DU]LVVPXVKHUDXVJHDUEHLWHWHÄ3KlQRPHQGHV1HJDWLYHQ³ NDQQHUGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGLQVHLQHUYRUVR]LDOHQ(LJHQDUWVREHVFKUHLEHQGDVVHV HLQHQ ÄUHLQHQ hEHUVFKX GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 3V\FKH³ RGHU HLQH ÄSULQ]LSLHOOH 1LFKW.RQJUXHQ]³PLWGHPRGHUHLQHQÄ$QWDJRQLVPXV]XP*HVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ³ LPSOL]LHUW'DULQOLHJWQRFKHLQDQGHUH3RLQWHLP%OLFNDXIGLH.RQVHTXHQ]HQ GHVIUKNLQGOLFKHLQVHW]HQGHQ$OOPDFKWVVWUHEHQV 1LFKWQXUGHVWUXNWLYZLUNWHVVLFKDXVZLHHWZDLP)DOOHGHV5DVVLVPXVRGHU GHU 0\VRJ\QLH 'XUFK VHLQHQ hEHUVFKXVVFKDUDNWHU XQG GLH VR]LDOH 1LFKW .RQJUXHQ]GLHPLWLKPHLQKHUJHKWZLUGHVIU:KLWHERRNYLHOPHKUDXFK]XP LQGLYLGXHOOHQ$XVJDQJVSXQNWYRQ.UHDWLYLWlW,QQRYDWLRQXQG:LGHUVWDQG,Q
:+,7(%22.9JOKLHU]XDXFK:KLWHERRNVLP6FKDWWHQGHU&RURQD3DQGHPLH XQGLKUHU/HXJQXQJE]Z5HODWLYLHUXQJGXUFK863UlVLGHQW7UXPSIRUPXOLHUWHQ:RUWH Ä,IWKH HYHQWVRIDQQXVKRUULELOOLVRIKDYHQ¶WSURYLGHGGHFLVLYHHYLGHQFHFRQILUPLQJRXUVSHFLHV¶ SRZHUIXOSURSHQVLW\WRRPQLSRWHQWO\GHQ\UHDOLW\,GRQ¶WNQRZZKDWZRXOV,WVHHPVWRPH WKDWWKHIDLOXUHWRDFNQRZOHGJHWKHH[LVWHQFHRIWKDWSURSHQVLW\FDQLWVHOIRQO\EHXQGHUVWRRGDV DQDFWRIGHQ\LQJUHDOLW\KXPDQUHDOLW\³ '(56 :+,7(%22. :+,7(%22. 9JOHWZDGLH$XVIKUXQJHQLQ :+,7(%22. I I'DVVSDQQXQJVYRO OHXQGLPEHVWHQ)DOOHSURGXNWLYH9HUKlOWQLVYRQSV\FKLVFKHU,OOXVLRQVELOGXQJXQGGHUVR]LD OHQ5HDOLWlWLVW7KHPDYRQ:KLWHERRNV0RQRJUDILH3HUYHUVLRQDQG8WRSLD '(56 ,Q '(56ZLUGGDVÄGHVLUHWRUHVWRUHWKHRULJLQDORQHQHVV³DOVÄWKRURXJKO\-DQXVIDFH SKHQRPHQRQ³EH]HLFKQHW Ä,QLWVVXEOLPDWHGDQGGLIIHUHQWLDWHGIRUP>«@LWEHFRPHVWKHGULYH WRFUHDWHJUHDWHUDQGPRUHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGXQLWLHV$VVXFKLWFDQEHFRPHWKHVRXUFHRIVRPHRI KXPDQLW\¶VPRVWVXEOLPHDFFRPSOLVKPHQWV±WKHSURIRXQGORYHIRUDQRWKHUSHUVRQ%DFK¶V 6W0DWWKHZ3DVVLRQDQGDFWVRISROLWLFDOVROLGDULW\2QWKHRWKHUKDQGZKHQWKDWGHVLUHUH
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJNDQQGHUEHU]HXJWH$GHSWIUHXGVFKHU5HOLJLRQVNULWLN JDU]XU6XFKHÄQDFKHLQHPÃIXQNWLRQDOHQbTXLYDOHQWµGHU5HOLJLRQ³DXIUXIHQ QDFK ÄHLQH>U@ 6SKlUH³ LQ GHU ZLU ÄXQVHUH $OOPDFKWVZQVFKH XQG ,OOXVLRQHQ XQWHU]XEULQJHQ³ YHUP|JHQ XP LKUHQ ÄXWRSLVFKHQ *HKDOW³ DXV]XVFK|SIHQ +RQQHWKV9HUVXFKHLQHUVR]LDOHQ(LQKHJXQJGHV$QWLVR]LDOHQZLUGGDEHLKLQJH JHQHLQPDOPHKU]XP*HJHQVWDQGGHU.ULWLN:KLWHERRNXQWHUVWHOOWÄ+RQQHWKV 7KHRULHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³VFKOLHOLFKHLQHQÄ,GHDOLVPXV³GXUFKGHQÄGHU.RQ IOLNW]ZLVFKHQ,QGLYLGXXPXQG*HVHOOVFKDIW³]XJXQVWHQGHXWOLFKÄNRQIRUPLVWL VFKH>U@ ,PSOLNDWLRQHQ³ KHUXQWHUJHVSLHOW ZLUG 'LH $QQDKPH HLQHV VROFKHQ Ä.RQIOLNW>V@³VLHKWHUDOOHUGLQJVÄIUHLQHNULWLVFKH7KHRULHGHU*HVHOOVFKDIW>DOV@ JUXQGOHJHQG³DQ±HLQH$XVVDJHGLHEHLDOOHU.ULWLNDXIHLQ+RQQHWKXQGLKP JHPHLQVDPHV$QOLHJHQYHUZHLVWZLHGHUIROJHQGH$EVFKQLWW]HLJHQZLUG
,QQHUZHOWOLFKH7UDQV]HQGHQ] GDVVWULWWLJH.ULWHULXPNULWLVFKHU *HVHOOVFKDIWVWKHRULH *HJHQEHU:KLWHERRNV$QVLFKWGDVVGLHÄ9HUDEVFKLHGXQJGHV*HGDQNHQVHLQHU $VR]LDOLWlWLP6XEMHNW>«@DOV,QGLNDWRUHLQHU>«@NRQIRUPLVWLVFKHQ7HQGHQ] JHOWHQVROO³HUKHEW+RQQHWKGHXWOLFKHQ:LGHUVSUXFK:DUXPVRIUDJWHUPLW %H]XJDXIVHLQHQ.RQWUDKHQWHQÄHLQH*HVHOOVFKDIWVWKHRULHQXUGDQQÃNULWLVFKµ VHLQ>NDQQ@ZHQQVLH>«@YRQGHU$QQDKPHDXVJHKWGD]ZLVFKHQLQGLYLGXHO OHP6HOEVWXQGJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU2UGQXQJHLQVWUXNWXUHOOHU.RQIOLNWEHVWHKW³ EOHLEWIULKQXQNODU$XFKHUYHUIROJWVFKOLHOLFKHLQGH]LGLHUWJHVHOOVFKDIWVNULWL VFKHV$QOLHJHQZRULQHUVLFKLPhEULJHQGXUFKDXVPLW:KLWHERRNYHUEXQGHQ ZHL%HLGHQVRPHUNW+RQQHWKDQLVWÄGLH2ULHQWLHUXQJDQGHU7UDGLWLRQGHU .ULWLVFKHQ7KHRULH³JHPHLQVDPZlKUHQGVLHVLFKLP%OLFNDXIGHUHQÄ]HLWJHPl H>@ $NWXDOLVLHUXQJ³ XQHLQV VLQG :DV KHLW GDV YRU GHP +LQWHUJUXQG GHV JHUDGH$XVJHIKUWHQJHQDX" )UGDVÄXUVSUQJOLFKH3URJUDPPGHU)UDQNIXUWHU6FKXOH³LVWDXV+RQQHWKV 6LFKWLQVEHVRQGHUHÄ>G@LH,GHH³EH]HLFKQHQGÄGDHLQHNULWLVFKH*HVHOOVFKDIWV PDLQVXQGLIIHUHQWLDWHGDQGXQVXEOLPDWHG>«@LWFDQOHDGQRWRQO\WRPDQLFSV\FKRVLVDQG DGGLFWLRQEXWDOVRWRVRPHRIWKHKXPDQDQLPDO¶VPRVWDEKRUUHQWFUHDWLRQVZKLFKZHPLJKW DGGFDQEHYLHZHGDVH[SUHVVLRQVRIWKHGHDWKLQVWLQFW¶VDWWDFNVRQFRPSOH[LW\³ :+,7(%22. :+,7(%22. (EG +211(7+I (EG $D2 +211(7+E9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPW DD2IIXQG'(56 ±+RQ QHWKEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLYRUDOOHPDXI+RUNKHLPHUVSURJUDPPDWLVFKHQ$XIVDW]7UDGLWLRQHOOH
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
DQDO\VHGHU5FNELQGXQJDQHLQHLQQHUZHOWOLFKH,QVWDQ]GHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]EH GDUI³:DVDXIWKHRUHWLVFKHU(EHQHDOVVR]LDOHVhEHOLGHQWLIL]LHUWZLUGPXVV GHPQDFK LQ GLHVHU 1HJDWLYLWlW XQG 9HUlQGHUXQJVZUGLJNHLW DXFK GXUFK GLH NRQNUHW%HWURIIHQHQHUIDKUHQZHUGHQE]ZHUIDKUEDUVHLQ'HUHQPHKURGHUZH QLJHUH[SOL]LWHV0DQJHOHPSILQGHQZHLVWGDQQEHUHLWVEHUGLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH *HJHQZDUWVODJHKLQDXVZHVKDOE+RQQHWKGLHVEH]JOLFKYRQHLQHPÄ0RPHQW GHU LQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ 7UDQV]HQGHQ]³ VSULFKW 1XU GXUFK GHQ 1DFKZHLV HLQHU VROFKHQ HPSLULVFKHQ 9HUDQNHUXQJ OlVVW VLFK HLQH VR]LDONULWLVFK DXVJHULFKWHWH 7KHRULHLQVHLQHQ$XJHQEHUKDXSWQRUPDWLYUHFKWIHUWLJHQXQGDQGHUVYHUPDJ VLHDXFKQLFKWLQHLQHWUDQVIRUPDWLYH3UD[LVEHU]XJHKHQ 0LW:KLWHERRNVLHKWHUVLFKLPJHPHLQVDPHQ$QOLHJHQYHUEXQGHQHUQHXW ÄHLQHVROFKH,QVWDQ]GHULQQHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ7UDQV]HQGLHUXQJ>«@]XORNDOL VLHUHQ³:lKUHQGGLHVHUDEHULQGHQZLHJHVHKHQDXVIUKNLQGOLFKHU=HLWKHU IRUWZLUNHQGHQÄ$OOPDFKWVSKDQWDVLHQHLQHQVR]LDOHQ*DUDQWHQGHUhEHUVFKUHL WXQJJHJHEHQHU6R]LDORUGQXQJHQDXVILQGLJ³ PDFKWIOOW+RQQHWKÄGLHVHQ3ODW] GXUFK*HIKOHGHU'HPWLJXQJXQG0LVVDFKWXQJ³DXV$QGHUVJHVDJW ,QGHU (UIDKUXQJGDVVÄHQWJHJHQLKUHU(UZDUWXQJHLQHDOVYHUGLHQWDQJHVHKHQH$QHU NHQQXQJ DXVEOHLEW³ VLHKW HU GDV JHVXFKWH Ã0RPHQW HLQHU LQQHUZHOWOLFKHQ 7UDQV]HQGHQ]µ]XWDJHWUHWHQDQGDVNULWLVFKWKHRUHWLVFKDQJHNQSIW]XZHUGHQ YHUPDJ 'DEHL VWHOOW +RQQHWK PLWKLQ VHOEVW HLQHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]X VHLQHQ HQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ (UNXQGXQJHQ LP $QVFKOXVV DQ :LQQLFRWW KHU 'HPQDFKLVWHVHEHQMHQHVDXVGHUHOWHUOLFKHQ)UVRUJHHUZDFKVHQH(UZDUWXQJV VFKHPD GHU *HERUJHQKHLW GDV DOOHQ VSH]LILVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQ ]XJUXQGHOLHJW'DVÄ%HGUIQLV>«@HLQHQXUVSUQJOLFKHQ=XVWDQGJHVLFKHUWHU JHIDKUORVHU6\PELRVHZLHGHUKHU]XVWHOOHQ³LVWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQÄQXUGLHSULPLWL YH .HKUVHLWH GHV PHQVFKOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHV LQ ZHVHQWOLFKHQ %HVWDQGWHLOHQ GHU HLJHQHQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVR]LDODQHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQ³'HULP)DOOHGHU9HUOHW ]XQJGLHVHV,QWHUHVVHDXINRPPHQGH.RQIOLNW]ZLVFKHQLQGLYLGXHOOHP$QVSUXFK XQGVR]LDOHU5HDOLWlWYHUGDQNWVLFKDOVRMHQHUÃRULJLQDOH[SHULHQFHµHLQHUHLQVW PDOVYHUV|KQWHQ6HOEVW:HOW%H]LHKXQJ$OVGDV ZLHGHU ]XYHUZLUNOLFKHQGH ,GHDOHLQHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWÄLQGHUGLHDNWXHOOQRFKQLFKWDQHUNDQQWHQ$QVSU XQG.ULWLVFKH7KHRULHYRQ GHVVHQSURJUHVVLYH3RWHQ]LDOHDXIGHP:HJ]XU'LDOHNWLNGHU $XINOlUXQJDXIJUXQGGHUKLVWRULVFKHQ1HJDWLYVLWXDWLRQYHUVFKWWJHJDQJHQVLHKW +211(7+D9JO]XGLHVHP*HGDQNHQXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2 IIXQG'(56E$XFKLQMQJHUHQ9HU|IIHQWOLFKXQJHQKDW+RQQHWKGLH±DQ+DEHUPDV NULWLVFKHDQVFKOLHHQGH±)UDJHQDFKHLQHPÃHPDQ]LSDWRULVFKHQ,QWHUHVVHµDQGLH.ULWLVFKH 7KHRULHDQ]XNQSIHQYHUPDJZLHGHUDXIJHJULIIHQ YJO'(56E +211(7+E I +211(7+D $D2 $D2 +211(7+E +211(7+F
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
FKHDQHUNDQQWZlUHQ³WUHLEWVLHGDV6XEMHNWLQGHQÃ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJµ KLQHLQÄ'LHVLVW+RQQHWKV9HUVLRQLQQHUZHOWOLFKHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]³YRQGHU VLFK:KLWHERRNV$OWHUQDWLYSRVLWRQLQVRIHUQVFKDUIXQWHUVFKHLGHWDOVHUGDVJH VHOOVFKDIWVEHUVFKUHLWHQGH3RWHQ]LDOJHUDGHLQQLFKWVR]LDOLVLHUEDUHQ$QWHLOHQ GHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ3V\FKHYHURUWHW'LHVHHQW]LHKHQVLFKGHUKRQQHWKVFKHQ7HOHR ORJLHJUXQGVlW]OLFKZHLOVLHVLFKHEHQVRGHVWUXNWLYZLHSURGXNWLYDXVZLUNHQ N|QQHQZDV]XHLQHP.RQIOLNWPLWRIIHQHP$XVJDQJIKUW :HQLJVWHQV]XHUZlKQHQDEHULVWDQGLHVHU6WHOOH+RQQHWKVSDUWLHOOH6HOEVW NRUUHNWXUGLHHUQDFKHLJHQHP%HNXQGHQLP5DKPHQVHLQHUXQWHUGHP 7LWHO8PYHUWHLOXQJRGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ"YHU|IIHQWOLFKHQ'HEDWWHPLW1DQF\)UD VHUYROO]RJHQKDWÄ>=@XSV\FKRORJLVFKXQG]XZHQLJVR]LRORJLVFK³VRZLHPLW HLQHPÄQRUPDWLYH>Q@'HIL]LW³EHKDIWHWHUVFKHLQWHVLKPGHPQDFKGDVEORH (PSILQGHQPDQJHOQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ]XU*UXQGODJHGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWVNULWLN]X PDFKHQ'HQQVRVWHOOWHUIHVWHVJLEWGLHVEH]JOLFKÄJHQJHQGVHOWVDPHYHU UFNWHXQGLGLRV\QNUDWLVFKH(UZDUWXQJHQGLHQLFKWJHUHFKWIHUWLJWVLQG³ZDV HLQ]XVlW]OLFKHV/HJLWLPDWLRQVNULWHULXPHUIRUGHUOLFKPDFKWÄ$QHUNHQQXQJVHU ZDUWXQJHQ³VROOHQLQIROJHGHVVHQQXUQRFKÄGDQQJHUHFKWIHUWLJW>VHLQ@ZHQQHV VLFKXP$UWLNXODWLRQHQGHU2UGQXQJHQKDQGHOWLQGLHVLHHLQJHODVVHQVLQG³ ,P.RQWH[WGHUPRGHUQHQÄEUJHUOLFKNDSLWDOLVWLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWVIRUP³GLH HUÄDOVGDV5HVXOWDWHLQHU$XVGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJYRQGUHL$QHUNHQQXQJVVSKlUHQ³ EHJUHLIWVLQGGDVGLH2UGQXQJHQYRQ/LHEH5HFKWXQG/HLVWXQJÄ>8@PYRQ LKUHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ$XWRQRPLH³GLHGDEHLVWHWVYRQJUXQGOHJHQGHU%HGHXWXQJ LVWÄWDWVlFKOLFK*HEUDXFKPDFKHQ]XN|QQHQVWHKWHVGHQHLQ]HOQHQ6XEMHNWHQ JOHLFKHUPDHQ]XMHQDFK$UWGHU6R]LDOEH]LHKXQJHQWZHGHULQLKUHU%HGUIWLJ NHLWLQLKUHU5HFKWVJOHLFKKHLWRGHUVFKOLHOLFKLQLKUHQVR]LDOHQ%HLWUlJHQDQHU NDQQW]XZHUGHQ³1HJDWLYIRUPXOLHUWJLEWHVDOVRIU+RQQHWKMHQVHLWVGHU EHVDJWHQÄGUHL3ULQ]LSLHQ³NHLQHUOHLÄPRUDOLVFKH>@)RUGHUXQJHQ³GLHÄDOVJH UHFKWIHUWLJWJHOWHQN|QQHQ³1DQF\)UDVHUVWHOOWDQJHVLFKWVGLHVHU5HVWULNWLR QHQNULWLVFKIHVW Ä+RQQHWKJHOLQJWHVQLFKWLQGHUJHJHEHQHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ :HOW)X]XIDVVHQXQG]XJOHLFKEHUVLHKLQDXV]XZHLVHQ³GKJOHLFKHUPD HQÄ,PPDQHQ]XQG7UDQV]HQGHQ]JHUHFKW]XZHUGHQ³'HUGXUFK:KLWHERRN
),1.(,7(/ E (EG +211(7+F ± D± 9JOGD]XLP)ROJHQGHQLQJHVDPW %2/ 7$16.,+211(7+ I %2/7$16.,+211(7+ $D2 I (EG +211(7+F $D2 +211(7+D )5$6(5 $D2
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
HUKREHQH.RQIRUPLVPXVYRUZXUIJHZLQQWGXUFKGLHQRUPDWLYH(LQKHJXQJGHU $QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQDOVRQRFKHLQPDODQ%HUHFKWLJXQJZHLOGLHVHVLFK DPJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFK(LQJHVSLHOWHQXQG*HOWHQGHQ]XRULHQWLHUHQKDEHQ ,VWDEHU+RQQHWKXQG:KLWHERRNZHQLJVWHQVGDVDQGLHÄ5HGHYRQGHUÃ7UDQV ]HQGHQ]LQGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ,PPDQHQ]µ³JHNQSIWHVR]LDONULWLVFKH$QOLH JHQJHPHLQVDPGDQQWHLOHQVLHHLQ0RWLYGDV+RQQHWK]XIROJHÄUHOLJL|VHQ8U VSUXQJVLVW³3DVVHQGGD]XZXUGHREJOHLFKZHGHU:KLWHERRNQRFKHU±ZDV QLFKWIUDOOH3URWDJRQLVWHQLP8PIHOGGHU.ULWLVFKHQ7KHRULHJLOW±YHUGlFKWLJW ZHUGHQN|QQHQÃYHUNDSSWHµ7KHRORJHQ]XVHLQGHU%HUHLFKGHV5HOLJL|VHQLP ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWPHKUIDFKJHVWUHLIW'DEHLZDUHQDXFKGLHMHZHLOLJHQ SV\FKRORJLVFKHQ*UXQGPRWLYHLP6SLHO%HL+RQQHWKEUDFKWHVLFKGDVIUKNLQG OLFKH*HERUJHQKHLWVVWUHEHQLQÃVlNXODUHQ)RUPHQ7URVWHVµ]XP$XVGUXFNGLHHV EUDXFKWXPGHUHQGOLFKNHLWVXQGGLIIHUHQ]EHVWLPPWHQ5HDOLWlWGHV/HEHQVZH QLJVWHQVYRUEHUJHKHQG]XWURW]HQ:KLWHERRNYHUZLHVDXIGDV'HVLGHUDWHLQHV IXQNWLRQDOHQbTXLYDOHQWHV]XU5HOLJLRQZREHLLKPHLQVR]LDOHU2UWYRU$XJHQ VWHKWDQGHPGDVXWRSLVFKHJHVHOOVFKDIWVYHUlQGHUQGH3RWHQ]LDOGHVVXEMHNWLYHQ $OOPDFKWVVWUHEHQV]XP7KHPDZHUGHQNDQQ1LPPWPDQKLQ]XGDVVEHL)DON :DJQHU GDV 0RWLY HLQHU LPPDQHQWHQ 7UDQV]HQGHQ] E]Z HLQHV LPPDQHQWHQ 7UDQV]HQGLHUHQVHEHQIDOOVDEHUHEHQGH]LGLHUWUHOLJLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKYRQ]HQWUDOHU %HGHXWXQJLVWHUJLEWVLFKHLQHLQWHUHVVDQWH$XVJDQJVVLWXDWLRQIUGLHIROJHQGH =ZLVFKHQEHWUDFKWXQJ
*RWW]ZLVFKHQ,PPDQHQ]XQG7UDQV]HQGHQ] WKHRORJLVFKH 5HIOH[LRQHQLP$QVFKOXVVDQ)DON:DJQHU (VLVWZLHJHVDJW$[HO+RQQHWKVHOEVWGHUGDUDXIKLQZHLVWGDVVÄGLH5HGHYRQ GHU Ã7UDQV]HQGHQ] LQ GHU JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ ,PPDQHQ]µ >«@ UHOLJL|VHQ 8U VSUXQJV³LVW%HL+LQULFK)LQN(LWHOILQGHWVLFKQRFKHLQPDOSRLQWLHUW]XVDP PHQJHIDVVW ZDVGLHVH5HGHLQ+RQQHWKV)DOOEHGHXWHW :RMHPDQGYRQGHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ9HUKDOWHQVE]Z5ROOHQHUZDUWXQJHQÄDEZHLFKHQGH$QSUFKH ]XVWHOOHQQLFKWXPKLQNDQQ³EHUVFKUHLWHWHUGLHJHJHQZlUWLJHQ9HUKlOWQLVVH DXIÄHLQHLGHDOH]XNQIWLJH*HPHLQVFKDIW³KLQÄLQGHUGLHDNWXHOOQRFKQLFKW DQHUNDQQWHQ$QVSUFKHDQHUNDQQWZlUHQ>«@'LHVLVW+RQQHWKV9HUVLRQLQQHU ZHOWOLFKHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]³GLHGHXWOLFKH*HPHLQVDPNHLWHQPLW)DON:DJQHUV Ã9HUVLRQµDXIZHLVW %HL:DJQHUVRKDEHQZLUJHVHKHQZLUGGDPLWHEHQIDOOVGLHEHUVFKLHHQGH (LJHQDUWNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHU$QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQEHJULIIOLFKJHIDVVW(VVLQG JHQDXHUJHVDJWDQGHQVR]LDOHQ6\VWHPPHFKDQLVPHQDESUDOOHQGH$QVSUFKHDXI
+211(7+D (EG ),1.(,7(/ E
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
LQGLYLGXHOOH6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJGLHZHLOVLHVLFKIUHLKHLWVUHFKWOLFKOHJLWLPLHUW ZLVVHQ IHVWJHKDOWHQ ZHUGHQ ZDV VLH ]X $QNHUSXQNWHQ HLQHU ÄLPPDQHQWH>Q@ 7UDQV]HQGHQ]³ZHUGHQOlVVW'DULQVROFKHQNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJV HUZDUWXQJHQ$XVGUXFNVP|JOLFKNHLWHQ]XYHUVFKDIIHQHQWGHFNW:DJQHUPLWKLQ HLQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHV 5HOHYDQ]SRWHQ]LDO GHU FKULVWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQ ZHQQ VLH GHQQ VR YHUVWDQGHQ ZLUG ZLH HV GHP IU VLH ]HQWUDOHQ *RWWHVJHGDQNHQ HQW VSULFKW'LHVHUIXQJLHUWEHL:DJQHUZHLOLQLKP±GDVLVWGHULGHHOOH*HKDOWGHU *RWWHVWRG9RUVWHOOXQJ±GDVSULQ]LSLHOOH6FKHLWHUQYRQ$EVROXWLQVWDQ]HQMHGZH GHU$UWHLQIUDOOHPDOIHVWJHKDOWHQLVWJOHLFKVDPDOV%ODXSDXVHIUHLQHDXVXQG GXUFKVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJSUDNWL]LHUWH)UHLKHLW ,PPDQHQWH7UDQV]HQGHQ]E]ZLPPDQHQWHV7UDQV]HQGLHUHQEH]HLFKQHWEHL :DJQHU ]XQlFKVW HLQPDO GHQ GHP J|WWOLFKHQ $QQHUNHQQXQJVLGHDO JHPlHQ )UHLKHLWVYROO]XJLQQHUKDOEGHUVR]LDOHQ/HEHQVYHUKlOWQLVVH GLHMHHLJHQH6HOE VWlQGLJNHLWQLFKWDXI.RVWHQGHU$QGHUHQDXV]XOHEHQVRQGHUQLP%H]XJDXI GLHVHXQGXQWHU%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJYRQGHUHQIUHLHP6HOEVWVHLQ'LHVHU9ROO]XJ GHUJHZLVVHUPDHQGLH5HDOLWlWGHV*|WWOLFKHQLP6R]LDOHQGDUVWHOOWLVWHVQXQ GHU LP )DOOH JHJHQOlXILJHU JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU %HGLQJXQJHQ ]X GHQ EHVDJWHQ (UZDUWXQJVEHUVFKVVHQIKUWGLHLQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HGHYRQ*RWWSDVVIlKLJHQ $XVGUXFN ILQGHQ N|QQHQ 5HOLJLRQ LVW GDQQ ZLH :DJQHU PLW 0DU[ VFKUHLEW VRZRKO(OHQGVDXVGUXFNLP%OLFNDXIXQHUIOOWJHEOLHEHQH)UHLKHLWVZQVFKHDOV DXFK3URWHVWJHJHQGLHGDIUYHUDQWZRUWOLFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVVH*RWWDEHUVWHKWLP *UXQGHIUMHQHÄLGHDOH]XNQIWLJH*HPHLQVFKDIWLQGHUGLHDNWXHOOQRFKQLFKW DQHUNDQQWHQ$QVSUFKHDQHUNDQQWZlUHQ³DXIGLHLQÄ+RQQHWKV9HUVLRQLQQHU ZHOWOLFKHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]³GLHEHUVFKVVLJHQ(UZDUWXQJHQGHU6XEMHNWH]LHOHQ ,QGHU5HGHYRQ*RWWYHUPRFKWHVLFKPLWKLQGDVÃVlNXODUHµ7URVWEHGUIQLVUHOLJL |V]XDUWLNXOLHUHQGDVVLFKQDFKHLQHUhEHUZLQGXQJGHU=HUULVVHQKHLWHQXQG 'LIIHUHQ]HQLP6HOEVW:HOW9HUKlOWQLVQDFKGHP9RUELOGGHVIUKNLQGOLFKHUOHE WHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVLGHDOVVHKQW'HQQGDVÃ*|WWOLFKHµJHUlWEHL:DJQHU]XP 3UlGLNDWJHOLQJHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVH :lKUHQG]ZLVFKHQ:DJQHUXQG+RQQHWKDXIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNVWDUNH*HPHLQ VDPNHLWHQ]XKHUUVFKHQVFKHLQHQN|QQWHQGLH8QWHUVFKLHGH]ZLVFKHQ:DJQHU XQG:KLWHERRNQLFKWJU|HUVHLQ'DV*RWWHVSUlGLNDWGHU$OOPDFKW:KLWHERRNV HQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHU*UXQGEHJULIIJHK|UWEHL:DJQHU]XUFKULVWOLFKHU VHLWVHLJHQWOLFKEHUZXQGHQHQ9RUVWHOOXQJVZHOWGHVVHOEVWlQGLJVHOEVWPlFKWLJHQ :HOWHQKHUUVFKHUVGHUYRP0HQVFKHQJHZDOWVDPXQG]RUQLJY|OOLJH8QWHURUG QXQJIRUGHUW$QGHVVHQ6WHOOHWULWWGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJV\PPHWULVFKH$QHUNHQ QXQJJOHLFKJOWLJ6HOEVWlQGLJHUXQGGLHVHUhEHUVFKULWWVROOVLFK±LPZDKUVWHQ 6LQQHGHV:RUWHV±LGHDOHUZHLVHDXFKLP%HUHLFKGHV]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ E]ZJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQVYROO]LHKHQ:KLWHERRNVYRQ$OOPDFKWVIDQWDVLHQ
9JO]XP0RWLYGHULPPDQHQWHQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]XQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ :$*1(5 P± ),1.(,7(/ E
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
GLHDXVIUKNLQGOLFKHU=HLWIRUWZLUNHQEHVHW]WHV6XEMHNWHQWVSULFKWLQVHLQHP XQEHGLQJWHQ 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJVGUDQJ DXI GLHVHP +LQWHUJUXQG QLFKW QXU GHP DOWHQFKULVWOLFKHUVHLWVEHUZXQGHQHQ*RWWVRQGHUQDQDORJGD]XGHPDOWHQVQ GLJHQ$GDP.ULHJ7HUURU)DQDWLVPXVHWFZDUHQSDVVHQGHUZHLVHDXFK:KLWH ERRNV%HLVSLHOHIUGHQÃKDWUHGRIWKHQRWPHµGHUPLWGHP2PQLSRWHQ]VWUHEHQ HLQKHUJHKW'DVVLQGDEHUIU:KLWHERRNQLFKWGHVVHQHLQ]LJP|JOLFKH$XVZLU NXQJHQ GHUPHQVFKOLFKH$OOPDFKWVWULHELVWLQVHLQHPHLJHQVLQQLJHQVLFKGHU VR]LDOHQ5H]LSUR]LWlWVORJLNQHJDWLYLVWLVFKHQW]LHKHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUDXFK$QNHU SXQNWIUHLQHQ1RQNRQIRUPLVPXVGHUSURGXNWLYH9HUlQGHUXQJHQIUHLVHW]HQ NDQQ 'LHV PDFKW ]XJXQVWHQ NRQIRUPLVWLVFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQVFKlGOLFK VR :KLWHERRNV9RUZXUIJHJHQ+RQQHWKZHUGDV6XEMHNWLQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHU 0DQLHULPPHUVFKRQDXI$QHUNHQQXQJDXVVHLQOlVVW(VLVWHLQ9RUZXUIGHQ PDQ JXW XQG JHUQH DXFK JHJHQEHU :DJQHU HUKHEHQ NDQQ GHVVHQ ÃJ|WWOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJµGHQ(LQ]HOQHQPLWHLQHPQRUPDWLYHQ6ROOHQNRQIURQWLHUWGHPJH JHQEHUHV]XPLQGHVWNHLQHJXW]XKHLHQGH$OWHUQDWLYHJLEW %H]LHKWPDQDOOHUGLQJV+RQQHWKVVR]LDOWKHRUHWLVFKH6HOEVWNRUUHNWXUPLWHLQ GHP]XIROJH$QHUNHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQQXUGDQQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWVLQGZHQQVLHDQ GLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHLQJHVSLHOWH±LPPDQHQWH±$QHUNHQQXQJVRUGQXQJDSSHOOLH UHQN|QQHQYHUPDJGDV%LOGPRGLIL]LHUW]XZHUGHQ=ZDUZHL:DJQHUVHLQH DXIGDVÃJ|WWOLFKHµ$QHUNHQQXQJVLGHDONRQ]HQWULHUWH5HOLJLRQLQGHQPRGHUQHQ 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQLQVRIHUQEHUHLWVYHUZLUNOLFKWDOVGDULQGLH*HOWXQJYRQ)UHL KHLWVXQG0HQVFKHQUHFKWHQJDUDQWLHUWLVWGHUHQQRUPDWLYHV=HQWUXPHULQGHU SUDNWLVFKHQ,GHHVR]LDOYHUPLWWHOWHU)UHLKHLWHQWGHFNW1XUZHLOVLFKGLH(LQ]HO QHQPLWKLQUHFKWOLFKSROLWLVFKÄDOVIUHLHXQGDXWRQRPHVHOEVWEHVWLPPHQGHXQG VHOEVW]ZHFNOLFKH3HUVRQHQDQHUNDQQW³ ZLVVHQN|QQHQKDOWHQVLHDQLKUHQGD GXUFKOHJLWLPLHUWHQ6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVDQVSUFKHQDXFKHQWJHJHQV\VWHPL VFKHU *HJHQOlXILJNHLWHQ IHVW $EHU VROFKH *HJHQOlXILJNHLWHQ JHKHQ ZRUDQ :DJQHUKLHULQVEHVRQGHUHGHQNWQLFKWQXUYRQGHU9HUZHUWXQJVORJLNGHUNDSLWD OLVWLVFKHQgNRQRPLHDXV6LH]HLJHQVLFKHWZDDXFKLQGHU6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ 5HFKWVYHUOHW]XQJXQG5HFKWV]ZDQJ6RZHQLJEHL:DJQHUHQGJOWLJNODUZLUG REHUDQHLQHYROOVWlQGLJHVR]LDOH5HDOLVDWLRQGHVJ|WWOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVLGHDOV XQGGDPLWDQHLQ8QQ|WLJZHUGHQGHU5HOLJLRQDOVHLJHQVWlQGLJHU6SKlUHJODXEW (VVSULFKWYLHOGDIUGLHRIIHQVLFKWOLFKHQ6SDQQXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJV LGHDOXQGVR]LDOHU5HDOLWlWDXFKDOV$XVGUXFNGHU%HJUHQ]WKHLWXQG(QGOLFKNHLW GHV0HQVFKHQP|JOLFKHQXQGGDPLWDOVÃDXI(UGHQµSULQ]LSLHOOXQEHUZLQGOLFK]X YHUVWHKHQ 'DUDXVHUJHEHQVLFK]ZHL3HUVSHNWLYHQ(LQHUVHLWVLVWGHPQDFKGLHSULQ]LSLHO OH%HJUHQ]WKHLWLQQHUZHOWOLFKHU9HUlQGHUXQJVSRWHQ]LDOHWKHRORJLVFK]XWKHPDWL VLHUHQ*RWWGHU,QEHJULIIHLQHUGLH)UHLKHLWDOOHUHUP|JOLFKHQGHQ6R]LDOLWlWJHKW QLFKWLQGHU,PPDQHQ]GHUIDNWLVFKHQ6R]LDORUGQXQJDXI'DVLVWJHUDGHDXFKGHU
:$*1(5 9JO ]XP )ROJHQGHQ DD2 ± XQG '(56 ± ±
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VR]LDOHQ1LFKW,QWHJULHUEDUNHLWLQGLYLGXHOOHU)UHLKHLWZHJHQVRGLHHEHQVWHWVGLH 0|JOLFKNHLW]XU1RUPDEZHLFKXQJELVKLQ]XGHQ:KLWHERRNDXIJHIKUWHQ*H ZDOWSKlQRPHQHQHQWKlOW'LHEOHLEHQGH7UDQV]HQGHQ]*RWWHVDEHULPSOL]LHUW DQGHUHUVHLWVPLW-|UJ'LHUNHQJHVSURFKHQGLH:DKUQHKPXQJGHV)DNWLVFKHQ ÄLP=HLFKHQHLQHUNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ1RUPDWLYLWlW³GLHDOOHLQQHUZHOWOLFKHWDE OLHUWHQ2UGQXQJHQRELKUHUEHJUHQ]WHQ9HUEHVVHUXQJVIlKLJNHLWEHUVWHLJW'HU 1HJDWLYFKDUDNWHUGHV.RQWUDIDNWLVFKHQLVWGDQQJHZLVVHUPDHQQLFKWGDGXUFK KHUDEJHGLPPWGDVVGDVZDVGDEHLEHDQVSUXFKWZLUGHLJHQWOLFKEHUHLWVJHVHOO VFKDIWOLFKUHDOLVLHUWVHLQPXVV(VLVWQLFKWZLHEHL+RQQHWKGHUGLHVR]LDOHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVRUGQXQJ]XP0DVWDEGHVOHJLWLPHUZHLVH(UZDUWEDUHQHUNOlUW YRQYRUQKHUHLQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHLQJHKHJW(LQVWDUNHU1RQNRQIRUPLVPXV GK HLQH DEVROXWH =XUFNZHLVXQJ VR]LDOHU 9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQ LP 6LQQH :KLWHERRNVGHULQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJYRQXWRSLVFKHQ3RWHQ]LDOHQVSULFKW KlWWHGDULQVHLQHQ3ODW](UNDQQVLFKDXI*RWWDOVGHQMHQLJHQEH]LHKHQGHULP PHUDXFKQLFKWYRQGLHVHU:HOWLVWVRZLHGLHVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVRUGQXQJ LPPHUQRFKRIIHQIUNUHDWLYH1HXVFK|SIXQJHQEOHLEHQPXVVÄ$QGHUHQIDOOV³ VRHLQPDOPHKU'LHUNHQ ZUGHGDVSROLWLVFKH/HEHQQXUQRFKGHU$EDUEHLWXQJYRQ9ROO]XJVGHIL]LWHQJOHLFKHU)UHLKHLW JHOWHQXQGNHLQHJHVFKLFKWOLFKHQ(QWZLFNOXQJHQYRQ1HXHPHUNHQQHQODVVHQ8QGGDVUHOLJL| VH/HEHQZUGHJHUDGHGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ$OWHPXQG1HXHP0HQVFKHQ6QGHXQG*QDGH HLQ]LHKHQ
'DVVGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ,GHDOXQG:LUNOLFKNHLWYRQ1HXXQG$OWQLFKWHLQ]X]LH KHQ LVW EHGHXWHW DEHU ]XJOHLFK LKUHU DOV JOHLFKVDP HQGORV ]X EHDUEHLWHQGHU 6SDQQXQJJHZDKU]XZHUGHQ'LHJ|WWOLFKHÄ7UDQV]HQGHQ]³LP6LQQHGHVLPPHU QRFKXQHUUHLFKWHQXQGDXIJUXQGGHUXQEHUZLQGOLFKHQ3DVVXQIlKLJNHLWGHV6XE MHNWVOHW]WOLFKXQHUUHLFKEDUHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVLGHDOVYHUPDJVLFKZRPDQVLFKDXI VLHEH]LHKWÄDOVNUHDWLYH8QUXKHLP,PPDQHQWHQ³DXV]XZLUNHQhEHU:DJQHU KLQDXVPVVWHGDQQDEHUQRFKGHXWOLFKHUHLQJHVFKlUIWZHUGHQGDVVGHULQWHUVXE MHNWLYH*HKDOWGHV*RWWHVJODXEHQVQXULP0RGXVGHVXQYHUWUHWEDULQGLYLGXHOOHQ *ODXEHQVYROO]XJV]XP7UDJHQNRPPWXQGDOOHLQGHVKDOEVFKRQQLFKWYROOHQGVLQ GLHEHVWHKHQGHQ6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVH]XEHUIKUHQLVW9LHOPHKUVWHFNWLQLKP VHOEVW GDV QHJDWLYH 3RWHQ]LDO HLQHV 6LFKGLVWDQ]LHUHQV YRQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ =XVWlQGHQGLHGHP=XVLFKILQGHQGHV6XEMHNWVKLQGHUOLFKVLQGZDVHEHQVRGHVW UXNWLYHZLHSURGXNWLYH)ROJHQKDEHQ 'DPLWVLQGZLUZLHGHUEHL:KLWHERRNGHVVHQ.ULWLNDQ+RQQHWKV,QWHUVXEMHN WLYLVPXVQXQLQHLQHGULWWH5XQGHJHKW1LFKWDOV$GHSWHQGHVÃUHODWLRQDOWXUQµ QLPPWHULKQGDEHLDXIV.RUQVRQGHUQDOV6FKOHUYRQ-UJHQ+DEHUPDVXQG $QKlQJHUGHUGXUFKLKQDXVJHUXIHQHQÃNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ:HQGHµ'XUFKGLHVH
',(5.(1D (EG ',(5.(1G'LHUNHQEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLDXIHLQHQ*HGDQNHQ)ULHGULFK:LOKHOP *UDIV
%9RQ)UHXG]X:LQQLFRWWXQG]XUFN
JHKHQQDFK:KLWHERRNÄ(LQVLFKWHQDXVGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH³YHUORUHQGLH HUDOVHLQHZHLWHUH)UVSUHFKHULQLP%OLFNDXIGHQ:DKUKHLWVJHKDOWGHV+REEH VLDQLVPXVEHDQVSUXFKW
:+,7(%22.
%+RQQHWKYV:KLWHERRN,,, 9RQGHU 6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRULHXQG ]XUFN (LQOHLWXQJ +REEHVXQG+DEHUPDV 7KRPDV+REEHVVHLGDUDQJHVFKHLWHUWGHQÄhEHUJDQJYRP1DWXUIDNWXPGHV .ULHJHVDOOHUJHJHQDOOH]XU1DWXUUHFKWVQRUPGHVEUJHUOLFKHQ=XVWDQGHV³DOV ]ZLQJHQG]XHUZHLVHQVFKUHLEW-UJHQ+DEHUPDV'HUÄ%HJUQGHUGHU6R]LDO SKLORVRSKLH³KDEHQlPOLFKQLFKWHUNOlUHQN|QQHQZDVÄGLH3DUWHLHQLP1DWXU ]XVWDQG³HLJHQWOLFKGD]XYHUDQODVVHQVROOÄLKUHQDWUOLFKHQ>«@XQEHJUHQ]WHQ +DQGOXQJVIUHLKHLWHQJHJHQGLHQDFKDOOJHPHLQHQ*HVHW]HQNRPSDWLEHOJHPDFK WHQ XQG EHJUHQ]WHQ >«@ )UHLKHLWHQ HLQ]XWDXVFKHQ³ +DEHUPDV IKUW GLHVHV 6FKHLWHUQDXIIHKOHUKDIWH$XVJDQJVEHGLQJXQJHQ]XUFN*HQDXHUJHVDJWKlWWH +REEHVGDV6XEMHNWQLFKWDOVSULPlUVHOEVWEH]RJHQXQGHJRLVWLVFKEHVFKUHLEHQ GUIHQVRQGHUQYRQYRUQKHUHLQPLWVR]LDOHQ.RPSHWHQ]HQDXVVWDWWHQPVVHQ 'LHÄHLJHQH)UHLKHLW>«@DOVHLQHGXUFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJNRQVWLWXLHU WH )UHLKHLW³ ]X YHUVWHKHQ GDV YHUPDJ QlPOLFK VR +DEHUPDV QXU ZHU ÄVLFK VHOEVWDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHVDQGHUHQ]XEHWUDFKWHQ³LPVWDQGHLVW'DVVHV GHPDOOJHPHLQHP:RKOGLHQWGHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ9HUIJXQJVEHUHLFK]XEHJUHQ ]HQLVWPLWKLQHLQH(LQVLFKWIUGLHPDQÄMHQHVR]LDOH3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHUHUVWHQ 3HUVRQ3OXUDOHLQQHKPHQ³N|QQHQPXVV =XP3HUVSHNWLYZHFKVHOZHJYRPÃ,FKµXQGKLQ]XPÃ'XµE]ZÃ:LUµVFKHL QHQGLHDOOHLQDQVLFKVHOEVWLQWHUHVVLHUWHQKREEHVVFKHQ6XEMHNWHMHGRFKVFKOHFKW KLQXQIlKLJ]XVHLQ±HLQ0LVVVWDQGYRQGHPQDFK+DEHUPDVOHW]WOLFKQXUHLQH JUXQGVlW]OLFKH8PZHQGXQJGHVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ%OLFNVEHIUHLW6HLQ3OlGR\HUJHKW
+$%(50$6 $D2 +$%(50$6 9JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2±'DVVEHL+REEHV GDV3UREOHPGHVhEHUJDQJVYRP1DWXU]XP5HFKWV]XVWDQGXQJHO|VWEOHLEWKDW+DEHUPDV VFKRQLQVHLQHU JHKDOWHQHQXQG ]XHUVWSXEOL]LHUWHQ0DUEXUJHU$QWULWWVYRUOHVXQJ KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHW 9JO '(56 II$XIOHW]WHUHQ7H[WEH]LHKWVLFKDXFK+RQQHWKLP 5DKPHQVHLQHU$XVIKUXQJHQ]X+REEHVLQ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJ 9JO+211(7+G $QP $QP $QP +$%(50$6 (EG
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GDKLQGHQXDGXUFK+REEHVYRUDQJHWULHEHQHQÄ3DUDGLJPHQZHFKVHO]XU6XE MHNWSKLORVRSKLH³PLWLKUHUSULQ]LSLHOOHQÄ5HIHUHQ]DXIGDVHUOHEHQGHHUNHQQHQGH XQGKDQGHOQGH6XEMHNW³KLQWHUVLFK]XODVVHQ6WDWWGHVVHQLVWDXIGDV+DEHUPDV ]XIROJH RKQHKLQ VSlWHVWHQV VHLW QDFKKHJHOVFKHU =HLW DQJHVDJWH Ä3DUDGLJPD>@ VSUDFKOLFKHU9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJ³XP]XVWHOOHQ 'HPQDFKÄILQGHWVLFK³GDV6XE MHNWÄPLWVHLQHQ$QVSUFKHQLPHLQJHOHEWHQ+RUL]RQWHLQHU/HEHQVZHOWYRUGLH HVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYPLWDQGHUHQNRPPXQLNDWLYYHUJHVHOOVFKDIWHQ6XEMHNWHQWHLOW³ 'DV3UREOHPGHVhEHUJDQJV YRP1DWXU]XP5HFKWV]XVWDQG ZLUGLQGLHVHP 5DKPHQVRJHO|VWGDVVHVVFKOLFKWZHJJDUQLFKWDXINRPPHQNDQQ'HQQÄGLH 6XEMHNWH³VLQGKLHULPPHUVFKRQÄ]X7HLOQHKPHUQDQ.RPPXQLNDWLRQVXQG]X 0LWJOLHGHUQYRQ.RRSHUDWLRQVJHPHLQVFKDIWHQVR]LDOLVLHUWZRUGHQ³ $OVVROFKH N|QQHQVLHDEHUJDUQLFKWXPKLQUHGHQGZLHKDQGHOQGGLH3HUVSHNWLYHQGHUPLW LKQHQLQUH]LSURNHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQYHUEXQGHQHQ$QGHUHQHLQ]X QHKPHQ'DEHLXQWHUVWHOOHQVLHHLQDQGHU]XGHP]XHLQHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQhEHU HLQNXQIWILQGHQ]X N|QQHQ ZDV VLHOHW]WHQ(QGHVJDUDXI ÄHLQHDOOHVR]LDOHQ *UHQ]HQXQGORNDOHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHQWUDQV]HQGLHUHQGH:LU3HUVSHNWLYH³DXV JHULFKWHWVHLQOlVVW +DEHUPDVNDQQGLHVEH]JOLFKDXFKYRQGHULQGHQOHEHQVZHOWOLFKHQ6R]LDO YHUKlOWQLVVHQLPSOL]LHUWHQÄ,GHHHLQHUXQYHUVHKUWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW³VSUHFKHQ GLHMHGHV0LWHLQDQGHUXPJHKHQ]XPÄ9RUVFKHLQYRQV\PPHWULVFKHQ9HUKlOWQLV VHQIUHLHUUH]LSURNHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³PDFKW$XVLKUYHUPDJLQVHLQHQ$XJHQGLH *UXQGODJHIUHLQHQÄ+XPDQLVPXV³JHZRQQHQ]XZHUGHQÄGHUVLFKQLFKWDXI 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJYHUVWHLIW³6LFKDOOHQlXHUHQ:LGHUVWlQGHQHQWJHJHQDOVPDQ VHOEVW]XEHKDXSWHQ±JHQDXGDVWUHLEWGHQ0HQVFKHQQDFKKREEHVVFKHU$QWKUR SRORJLH SULPlU DQ %HL +DEHUPDV EHJHJQHW HLQH VROFKH 9HUKDOWHQVZHLVH QXU QRFKÄ>X@QWHU%HGLQJXQJHQVWUDWHJLVFKHQ+DQGHOQV³ZLHVLHLQQHUKDOEGHVNDSL WDOLVWLVFKHQ0DUNWHVXQGGHVSROLWLVFKEURNUDWLVFKHQ$SSDUDWHVKHUUVFKHQ 'RUW IlOOWGHU(LQ]HOQHÄDXVGHQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ%H]JHQKHUDXV³GHQHQHUVHLQLQGL YLGXHOOHV6HOEVWVHLQYHUGDQNWXQGHQWVFKHLGHW±]XPLQGHVWDXIGHP3DSLHU± ÄDOOHLQQDFK0DJDEHVXEMHNWLYHU3UlIHUHQ]HQ³8UVSUQJOLFKHUDEHULVWLKP
+$%(50$6I 9JOGD]XLQVJHVDPWGDVPLWHLQHU+REEHV'DUVWHOOXQJDQKHEHQGH.DSLWHOÄ'HU3DUDGLJ PHQZHFKVHO]XU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLHXQGGDV)ROJHSUREOHPGHU%HJUQGXQJELQGHQGHU1RU PHQ³LQ +$%(50$6±'HQDOOPlKOLFKHQ:HFKVHOKLQ]XPÃ3DUDGLJPDVSUDFK OLFKHU9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJµYROO]LHKW+DEHUPDVDD2± QDFK9JO]XGHQGLHVEH]JOL FKHQ$XVIKUXQJHQLP)ROJHQGHQDXHUGHP '(56 D ± E±9JO JUXQGOHJHQG]X+DEHUPDVµHLJHQHP$QVDW] '(56 H +$%(50$6 (EG $D2 +$%(50$6 D $D2 +$%(50$6 E
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
GDV(LQJHEXQGHQVHLQLQGLHNRPPXQLNDWLYVWUXNWXULHUWHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHGHU/H EHQVZHOWZRJHJHQHUVLFKQXU]XPHLJHQHQ6FKDGHQZHQGHQNDQQ'DJHJHQOHJW -RHO:KLWHERRNVHLQKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKHV9HWRHLQ :KLWHERRNVWHOOWGHQ3DUDGLJPHQZHFKVHODXVGUFNOLFKLQIUDJHPLWGHVVHQ $XVUXIXQJ+DEHUPDVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQGLH7KHVHHLQHUÄVRFLDELOLW\RIWKHKXPDQ VXEMHFWDOOWKHZD\GRZQ³YRUDOOHPJHJHQ.ULWLNDEVFKLUPHQP|FKWH'LHIU EHUZXQGHQHUNOlUWH6XEMHNWE]Z%HZXVVWVHLQVSKLORVRSKLHKlOWQlPOLFK(LQ VLFKWHQEHUHLWYRQGHQHQDXFKQDFKGHUÄNRPPXQLNDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKH>Q@:HQ GH³HLQEOHLEHQGHU3UREOHPGUXFNDXVJHKW*HJHQ+DEHUPDVXQG+RQQHWKGHQ HULQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJDOVÄ+DEHUPDVLDQHU³DQVSULFKWIKUWHUKLHUGLH GXUFK'LHWHU+HQULFKXQG0DUN6DFNVDXIXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH:HLVHDN]HQWXLHUWH $QQDKPHHLQHUÄDQIlQJOLFKH>Q@$QVFKDXXQJGHV6HOEVW³LQV)HOG0LWLKUYHU ELQGHWVLFKIU:KLWHERRNHLQHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQLFKW]XYHUHLQQDKPHQGHJOHLFK VDPXUZFKVLJH'LPHQVLRQYRQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWGLHNHLQHVZHJVQXUHLQGHVWUXNWL YHV3RWHQ]LDOLQVLFKWUlJWVRQGHUQ]%DXFK$XVJDQJVSXQNWLQQRYDWLYHU.ULWLN VHLQNDQQ:HUVLHDXHQYRUOlVVWXPLKUHQVW|UHQGHQ&KDUDNWHU]XGRPHVWL]LH UHQVRVHLQ9RUZXUIUHGHWHLQHP6R]LDONRQIRUPLVPXVGDV:RUW %HYRULP)ROJHQGHQ:KLWHERRNVXQWHU5HNXUVYRUDOOHPDXI+HQULFKXQG 6DFNVYRUJHWUDJHQH+DEHUPDVXQG+RQQHWKNULWLNWKHPDWLVLHUWZLUG JHKWHV ]XQlFKVW XP GLH %H]LHKXQJ GHU EHLGHQ .ULWLVLHUWHQ 7UHIIHQ :KLWHERRNV (LQZlQGHJHJHQ+DEHUPDVDXFKDXI+RQQHWK]X"±VRN|QQWHGLHGDEHLOHLWHQGH )UDJHLQ$QOHKQXQJDQGHQ7LWHOHLQHV+DEHUPDV7H[WHVODXWHQ'DEHLZLUGGDV +DXSWDXJHQPHUNDXIGDVLQXQVHUHP=XVDPPHQKDQJHQWVFKHLGHQGH7KHPDGHV 9HUKlOWQLVVHVYRQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWXQG,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWJHOHJW'LHGLHVEH]JOL FKHQ *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ XQG 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQ +DEHUPDV XQG +RQQHWK ODVVHQVLFKJXWDQKDQGLKUHU5H]HSWLRQGHU6R]LDOLVDWLRQVWKHRULH*HRUJH+HUEHUW 0HDGVKHUDXVDUEHLWHQ1LFKW]XOHW]WULFKWHWDXFK:KLWHERRNJHQDXGDUDXIVHLQ NULWLVFKHV+DXSWDXJHQPHUN$OVHLQH]XVlW]OLFKH.ULWLNSHUVSHNWLYHGLH+RQ QHWKV]ZHLWHV+DXSWZHUNQRFKLQGLH'LVNXVVLRQPLWHLQEH]LHKWZLUGGDUEHU KLQDXVJHKHQGQRFK%HDWH5|VVOHUV9HUWHLGLJXQJLQGLYLGXHOOHU$XWRQRPLHHLQEH ]RJHQ EHYRUGDQQLP$QVFKOXVVDQ7UDXJRWW.RFK]XUWKHRORJLVFKHQ5HIOH [LRQGHV*HVDJWHQEHUJHJDQJHQZLUG
+211(7+:+,7(%22. +$%(50$6 D :+,7(%22. $D2 ±
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
$EVFKLHGYRP6XEMHNW +DEHUPDV+RQQHWKXQGGLH NRPPXQLNDWLYH:HQGH Ä+LQWHUGLHNRPPXQLNDWLYH:HQGH³KDEHHVVHLWVHLQHU6WXGLHQ]HLWÄNHLQ=X UFN³PHKUJHJHEHQDQWZRUWHW+RQQHWKDXIGLH)UDJHLQZLHIHUQHUGXUFKGLH $UEHLWHQVHLQHV/HKUHUV+DEHUPDVJHSUlJWZRUGHQVHL*HPHLQWLVWMHQHUEH UHLWVHUZlKQWH3DUDGLJPHQZHFKVHOGHQ+DEHUPDVµÄNRPPXQLNDWLRQVWKHRUHWL VFKH>U@$QVDW]³HLQIUDOOHPDO]XYROO]LHKHQEHDQVSUXFKW 2ULHQWLHUWDPÄ0R GHOOGHUVSUDFKOLFKHQ9HUVWlQGLJXQJ>«@EHUZLQGHW³GLHVHUGHPQDFK GLH6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLHLQGHPHULP6HOEVWGHV6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQVGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJXQG GHU6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJGLHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH6WUXNWXULQHLQDQGHUYHUVFKUlQNWHU3HUVSHNWLYHQ XQGJHJHQVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJIUHLOHJW
(VVLQG:RUWHGLHDXFKDXV+RQQHWKV)HGHUVWDPPHQN|QQWHQ'HPHQWVSUH FKHQGYHUPDJHUVHLQHHLJHQH3RVLWLRQXQEHVFKDGHWDOOHU'LIIHUHQ]HQÄDOV,Q WHQVLYLHUXQJ GHV KDEHUPDVLDQLVFKHQ $QVDW]HV QLFKW DOV %UXFK PLW LKP³ ]X FKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ:RULQHUGLHVHPMHGHQIDOOVJUXQGVlW]OLFKIROJWLVWGHU$EVFKLHG YRQHLQHUÄ%HZXVVWVHLQVSKLORVRSKLHGLHEHLGHUDEVWUDNWHQ6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJGHV HUNHQQHQGHQ6XEMHNWVHLQVHW]WVWDWWGLHVHVDOV5HVXOWDW]XEHJUHLIHQ³±DOV5H VXOWDWYRQÄ9HUKlOWQLVVHQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³1XUYHUPLWWHOVGHV $QJHVSURFKHQZHUGHQVGXUFK$QGHUHGLHPLFKDOVHLJHQVWlQGLJHQ,QWHUDNWLRQV SDUWQHUDGUHVVLHUHQJHODQJHLFKQDFK+DEHUPDV]XHLQHPLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVW YHUKlOWQLV'LHVHPÄGXUFKGLH6WUXNWXUVSUDFKOLFKHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWJHVHW]WHQ >«@6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLV>@³JHKWZLHHU]XGHPDQPHUNWNHLQÄQRFKVRYRUJlQJLJHV 0LWVLFK9HUWUDXWVHLQ³YRUDXV:lKUHQG+DEHUPDVµOHW]WHUHU+LQZHLVNULWLVFK DXIHLQ*UXQGPRWLY'LHWHU+HQULFKVDQVSLHOW±XPGDVHVQRFKJHKHQZLUG± HQWZLFNHOWHUVHLQDOWHUQDWLYHVÄ0RGHOOGHVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKSURGX]LHUWHQ,FK³ DP /HLWIDGHQ GHU 6R]LDOWKHRULH *HRUJH +HUEHUW 0HDGV 'HU SUDJPDWLVWLVFKH 3KLORVRSK XQG 3V\FKRORJH LVW DXFK IU +RQQHWK HLQH ZLFKWLJH %H]XJVJU|H ZHVKDOEHULP)ROJHQGHQLP=HQWUXPVWHKHQZLUG:LH+DEHUPDVVFKOLHWVLFK +RQQHWKGHPÄ0HDGLDQGLFWXPWKDWWKHVHOILVDSURGXFWRILQWHUDFWLRQ³HQW
%2/7$16.,+211(7+ +$%(50$6 E %2/7$16.,+211(7+ +$%(50$6 E9JO]X+DEHUPDVµ7KHRULHGHU6XEMHNWNRQVWLWXWLRQGHQIUGDV )ROJHQGH JUXQGOHJHQGHQ 0HDG$XIVDW] ,QGLYLGXLHUXQJ GXUFK 9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJ '(56 EEHV± 9JODXIGLH0HDG,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHQLQGHU7KHRULHGHVNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ +DQGHOQV '(56 E± +$%(50$6 F +$%(50$6 E +211(7+:+,7(%22.6R:KLWHERRNV)RUPHO]XGHUHUDQPHUNW Ä$WWKDW OHYHORIJHQHUDOL]DWLRQQRRQHLVJRLQJWRGLVDJUHH7KHTXHVWLRQLVKRZVKRXOGLWEHLQWHU SUHWHGFRQFUHWHO\":KDWDUHLWVGHWDLOV"$QGZKDWDUHLWVLPSOLFDWLRQV"³
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
VFKLHGHQDQ %HLGHWHLOHQPLWKLQJUXQGVlW]OLFKGLH$QVLFKWGDVVVLFKGDV 6XEMHNWVHLQHVVR]LDOHQ.RQVWLWXLHUWVHLQVZHJHQLP.RQIOLNWIDOOQXUGXUFKGLH NRQWUDIDNWLVFKH8QWHUVWHOOXQJHLQHULGHDOHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWDELOLVLHUHQNDQQ 0HDG5H]HSWLRQ, 'DV6HOEVWDOV3URGXNWVR]LDOHU,QWHUDNWLRQ Ä,QNHLQHUDQGHUHQ7KHRULH³VRVFKUHLEW+RQQHWKEHU0HDGÄLVWGHU*HGDQNH GDGLHPHQVFKOLFKHQ6XEMHNWHLKUH,GHQWLWlWGHU(UIDKUXQJHLQHULQWHUVXEMHNWL YHQ$QHUNHQQXQJYHUGDQNHQVRNRQVHTXHQWXQWHUQDWXUDOLVWLVFKHQ'HQNYRUDXV VHW]XQJHQHQWZLFNHOWZRUGHQ³2EGLHVHU(LJHQDUWYHUKLOIWVLH+RQQHWKLQVHL QHU+DELOLWDWLRQVVFKULIWGD]XGDVEHL+HJHOHQWGHFNWH$QHUNHQQXQJVPRGHOO]X QDWXUDOLVLHUHQRGHUZDVGDV*OHLFKHEHVDJHQVROOÄLQHLQHQDFKPHWDSK\VLVFKH 7KHRULHVSUDFKH]XEHUVHW]HQ³0LWGHP3UlGLNDWÃQDFKPHWDSK\VLVFKµEHGLHQW HUVLFKGHXWOLFKKDEHUPDVLDQLVFKHP9RNDEXODU(VYHUZHLVWDXIGLHSURJUDPPD WLVFKH)RUGHUXQJVHLQHV/HKUHUVGDVVÄZLU]XPQDFKPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ'HQNHQ NHLQH$OWHUQDWLYH³KDEHQVRQGHUQDXFKQRFKGLHÄEHZXWVHLQVSKLORVRSKLVFKH
+211(7+G9JO]XU0HDG5H]HSWLRQ+RQQHWKVLQVJHVDPW DD2±
'(56D± E±'LHVH=XVWLPPXQJZLUGGXUFK+RQQHWKVVFKOLHOLFKH Ä$ENHKUYRQ0HDG³ '(56F YJOLQVJHVDPWII QLFKWJUXQGVlW]OLFKLQIUDJH
JHVWHOOWGLHVLFKDQGHVVHQQXQDOVÄ]XVWDUN³HPSIXQGHQHPÄ1DWXUDOLVPXV³IHVWPDFKW :HLO GHU ÄZHFKVHOVHLWLJH>@ $NW GHU 3HUVSHNWLYEHUQDKPH³ ]X PHFKDQLVWLVFK DEODXIH VHL HV QXU VFKZHUP|JOLFKGDUDQDQNQSIHQGÄ$QHUNHQQXQJDOVHLQKDELWXDOLVLHUWHV9HUKDOWHQ]XEHJUHL IHQGDVVLFKLQHLQHPKLVWRULVFKHQ5DXPPRUDOLVFKHU*UQGHYROO]LHKW³ DD2I 'LHV KLQGHUWLKQDEHUQLFKWGDUDQDXFKLQVSlWHUHQ9HU|IIHQWOLFKXQJHQDQ]HQWUDOHQ0RWLYHQ0HDGV IHVW]XKDOWHQRKQHLKQ]XQHQQHQ YJOHWZDGLH$XVIKUXQJHQ]XUÄ9HUZDQGOXQJGHUNRRSHUD WLYHU]HXJWHQ1RUPHQLQGHQ*OHLFKNODQJVR]LDOHU*HZRKQKHLWHQ³LQ GHUVII$XFK GLH(UVHW]XQJGHVÄ0HDGVFKH>Q@Ã,µGXUFKHLQHDQGHUHDQWKURSRORJLVFKH9HUPXWXQJ³ '(56 F YJOII QlPOLFKGXUFKGDVLP]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ.DSLWHOHUZlKQWHÃ(UZDU WXQJVVFKHPDLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ*HERUJHQVHLQVµLQGHPHUPLW:LQQLFRWWDQWLVR]LDOH1HLJXQJHQ GHV6XEMHNWVYHUDQNHUWEHGHXWHWNHLQHY|OOLJH$EZHQGXQJYRQGHU]XYRUYHUWUHWHQHQ3RVLWLRQ 'LHZLHLP)ROJHQGHQXQWHUGDUJHOHJWPLW0HDGYHUWUHWHQH1RWZHQGLJNHLWHLQHVNRQWUD IDNWLVFKHQ$XVJULIIVDXIHLQHLGHDOH,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWLQ6LWXDWLRQHQGHV.RQIOLNWV]ZLVFKHQ ,QGLYLGXXP XQG *HVHOOVFKDIW KDWLKU 3HQGDQW LQ GHU IUKNLQGOLFK HQWZLFNHOWHQ (UZDUWXQJ YROOVWlQGLJHQ$QHUNDQQWVHLQVGLHGHQ0HQVFKHQJHJHQGHQPDQJHOKDIWHQ&KDUDNWHUGHUIDNWL VFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQLPPHUZLHGHUUHEHOOLHUHQOlVVW +211(7+G +$%(50$6 G9JOGLHVHQ$XIVDW]LQVJHVDPW]X+DEHUPDVµ%HJULIIGHVQDFK PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ'HQNHQV'DVV+RQQHWKVLFKKLHUDQ+DEHUPDVDQVFKOLHW]HLJWDXFKVHLQ 9HUZHLV DXI GDV GHU QDFKKHJHOVFKHQ =HLW JHZLGPHWH .DSLWHO DXV GHVVHQ 0RQRJUDILH 'HU SKLORVRSKLVFKH'LVNXUVGHU0RGHUQH YJO+211(7+G$QP :KLWHERRN :+, 7(%22. $QP ZHLVW]XGHPDXIHLQHQlKQOLFKHQ5HNXUV+DEHUPDVµDXI0HDGLQ GHP SXEOL]LHUWHQ$XIVDW]Ä$UEHLWXQG,QWHUDNWLRQ³KLQYRQGHPZLFKWLJH,PSXOVHIU +RQQHWKV$QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHDXVJHJDQJHQVLQG Ä8QWHUQDWXUDOLVWLVFKHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQ GHV3UDJPDWLVPXV³VFKUHLEW+DEHUPDVGRUWÄZLHGHUKROW*+0HDG>«@GLH(LQVLFKW+HJHOV GDVLFKGLH,GHQWLWlWGHV,FKHUVWGXUFK(LQEXQJLQVR]LDOH5ROOHQQlPOLFKLQGLH.RPSOH
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
8PIRUPXQJ³GHU0HWDSK\VLNYHUDEVFKLHGHQPVVHQ8QKDOWEDUJHZRUGHQVR +DEHUPDVLVWGHU$XVJDQJYRQÄHLQH>U@YRUJlQJLJH>Q@(LQKHLWLQGHU0DQQLJIDO WLJNHLWGHU(UVFKHLQXQJHQ³ GLHPDQSHU5HNXUVDXIGHQXQEHGLQJWHQ6HOEVWEH ]XJGHV6XEMHNWVDOVPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ5HVWEHVWDQGUHWWHQ]XN|QQHQPHLQWH+DOW EDUVLQGKLQJHJHQQXUQRFK7KHRULHQGLHVLFKGHUEHWRQWSUR]HGXUDOLVWLVFKHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlWHLQHUQDWXUE]ZHUIDKUXQJVZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKGRPLQLHUWHQ0RGHUQH YHUSIOLFKWHQ(QWVFKHLGHQGHPQDFKDOOHLQPHWKRGLVFKNRQWUROOLHUEDUH9HUIDKUHQ GDUEHUZDVYHUQQIWLJZDVZDKUJXWXQGVFK|QLVWNDQQGLHVQLFKWLQHLQHU MHQHQ3UR]HVVHQYRUDXVOLHJHQGHQVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRUHWLVFKJHIDVVWHQ9HUQXQIWLQ VWDQ]EHUHLWVIXQGLHUWVHLQ(EHQ/HW]WHUHVYHUWUHWHQ]XKDEHQDEHULVWGLHVFKZH UH+\SRWKHNGLH+RQQHWKPLW+DEHUPDVDXIGHPKHJHOVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVPR GHOOODVWHQVLHKW +HJHOVÄJHUDGH]XPDWHULDOLVWLVFKDQPXWHQGHV3URJUDPP³VR VFKUHLEWHUIDVWHQWWlXVFKW VWHKWQRFKZLHVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKXQWHUGHULGHDOLVWLVFKHQ3UlVXSSRVLWLRQGDGDV]XXQWHUVX FKHQGH.RQIOLNWJHVFKHKHQ>VFGHU.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJ .7@YRQHLQHPREMHNWLYHQ*DQJ GHU9HUQXQIWEHVWLPPWLVWGHUHQWZHGHUDULVWRWHOLVFKGLH*HPHLQVFKDIWVQDWXUGHV0HQVFKHQ RGHUEHZXWVHLQVSKLORVRSKLVFKGLH6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJGHV*HLVWHV]XU(QWIDOWXQJEULQJW
6RZLUGGDQQHWZDKlOW+RQQHWKIHVWGLHYHUPLWWHOVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHU$QHUNHQ QXQJVLFKYROO]LHKHQGH6HOEVWZHUGXQJGHV0HQVFKHQEHL+HJHOÄQLFKWDOVHLQ HPSLULVFKHV*HVFKHKHQLQQHUKDOEGHUVR]LDOHQ:HOWEHWUDFKWHWVRQGHUQ]XHLQHP %LOGXQJVYRUJDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ VLQJXOlUHQ ,QWHOOLJHQ]HQ VWLOLVLHUW³ (LQH XQWHU SRVWPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQHLQ]XQHKPHQGH6LFKWGHV6XEMHNWVNDQQGHP ÃHPSLULVFKHQ*HVFKHKHQLQQHUKDOEGHUVR]LDOHQ:HOWµMHGRFKQLFKWVPHKUYRU DXVJHKHQODVVHQVRQGHUQPXVVZDVVLHPLWQRUPDWLYHP$QVSUXFK]XHUNOlUHQ EHVWUHEWLVWDOV5HVXOWDWHEHQGLHVHV3UR]HVVJHVFKHKHQVDXV]XZHLVHQLPVWDQGH VHLQ*HQDXGDULQHQWGHFNW+RQQHWKGLH6WlUNHYRQ0HDGVÄ7KHRULHGHU,QWHUVXE MHNWLYLWlW³GDVVVLHHLQHÄGLH(LQVLFKWHQGHVGHXWVFKHQ,GHDOLVPXVZLVVHQVFKDIW OLFKHLQKROHQGH>@(UNOlUXQJPHQVFKOLFKHU6XEMHNWLYLWlW³DQ]XELHWHQYHUPDJ :RUDXIGLHVHU(UNOlUXQJVDQVDW]DXFKDXVVHLQHU6LFKWKLQDXVOlXIWEULQJWGHU 7LWHOGHU HUVFKLHQHQHQ0HDG6WXGLHVHLQHV/HKUHUV+DEHUPDV]XP$XV GUXFNGLHHULP=XJHGHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQPHKUIDFK]LWLHUW ,QGLYLGXLHUXQJGXUFK 9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJ PHQWDULWlWYRQ9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQDXIGHU%DVLVJHJHQVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJNRQVWLWXLHUHQ NDQQ³ +$%(50$6 $QP +$%(50$6 G± $D2 +211(7+G $D2 $D2I+HUYRUKG9HUI'DV3UlGLNDWÃZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKµLVWZRKOKLHUV\QRQ\P]X ÃQDWXUDOLVWLVFKµXQGÃHPSLULVFKµ]XYHUVWHKHQ 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQGLH0HDG,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHQLQ +$%(50$6 E± +21 1(7+G ±+RQQHWK]LWLHUW+DEHUPDVµ6WXGLHDQIROJHQGHQ6WHOOHQ '(56G $QP $QP
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
,QGLYLGXLHUXQJGXUFK9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJ±GDVKHLW]XJOHLFK GDLVWQLFKWV DP LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6HOEVW GDV QLFKW GDV (UJHEQLV YRQ 6R]LDOLVDWLRQVSUR]HVVHQ ZlUHVRQGHUQGLHVHQLUJHQGZLHYRUDXVJLQJHÄ0HDG³VFKUHLEW+RQQHWKHQWVSUH FKHQGÄNHKUW>«@GDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ,FKXQGVR]LDOHU:HOWXPXQGEHKDXSWHW HLQH9RUUDQJLJNHLWGHU:DKUQHKPXQJGHV$QGHUHQYRUGHU(QWZLFNOXQJGHV 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQV³ (EHQGLHVH 8PNHKUXQJ LVW HV GLH GHQ DPHULNDQLVFKHQ 'HQNHUODXW+DEHUPDV]XHLQHPUHJHOUHFKWHQ3LRQLHUGHUNRPPXQLNDWLRQVWKHR UHWLVFKHQ$EZHQGXQJYRQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLHZHUGHQOlVVW1LHPDQGDQGH UHPDOV0HDGQlPOLFKLVWHV]X]XVFKUHLEHQÄGLH,FK,QVWDQ]GHU%HZXWVHLQV SKLORVRSKLH]XHLQHPÃ0LFKµ]XHLQHPLQ,QWHUDNWLRQV]XVDPPHQKlQJHQXQWHU GHQ$XJHQHLQHV$OWHUHJRHUVWHQWVWHKHQGHQ6HOEVWKHUDE>JH@VHW]W³]XKDEHQ 'LH5HGHYRQGHU+HUDEVHW]XQJGHV6HOEVW]XJXQVWHQHLQHU9RUUDQJLJNHLWGHV $QGHUHQE]ZGHUVR]LDOHQ:HOWZHLVWGHXWOLFKDXIHLQDV\PPHWULVFKHV*HIlOOH KLQ'HPJHPlYHUOlXIWGLHSUDNWLVFKH,GHQWLWlWVELOGXQJGHV6XEMHNWVEHL0HDG VRGDVVGLHYRQGHQLQHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWXPODXIHQGHQ:HUWHQXQG1RUPHQ GXUFKVHW]WHQ9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQGHU$QGHUHQLQWHUQDOLVLHUWZHUGHQ,P=XJH GHVVHQHQWZLFNHOWVLFKGDVÃ0HµKHUDXV ÄWKDWVHOIZKLFKLVDEOHWRPDLQWDLQLWVHOI LQWKHFRPPXQLW\WKDWLVUHFRJQL]HGLQWKHFRPPXQLW\LQVRIDUDVLWUHFRJQL]HV WKHRWKHUV³+RQQHWKHQWGHFNWLQGLHVHU)RUPXOLHUXQJHLQHQZLFKWLJHQ%HOHJ IU0HDGVJURH1lKH]X+HJHOZHLOVLHGLH:HFKVHOVHLWLJNHLWGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ EHVFKZ|UW ,QGHP LFK LKUH 9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQ HUIOOH DIILUPLHUH LFK GLH $QGHUHQDOV]XGLHVHQ(UZDUWXQJHQEHUHFKWLJWH3HUVRQHQXQGNDQQLFK PLFK GXUFKVLHHEHQVREHVWlWLJWZLVVHQÄ>,@WLVKLVWDNLQJRIWKHDWWLWXGHRIWKHRWKHUV WKDWJXDUDQWHHVWRKLPWKHUHFRJQLWLRQRIKLVRZQULJKWV³EULQJW0HDGGLHVH 5H]LSUR]LWlWVORJLNQRFKHLQPDODXIGHQ3XQNW9RPÃ0HµGDV+DEHUPDVDOVHLQH VLFKLP,QQHUHQGHV0HQVFKHQHLQKDXVHQGHÄNRQVHUYDWLYH0DFKW³EHVFKUHLEWGLH ÄPLWGHP%HVWHKHQGHQYHUVFKZLVWHUW³LVWOlVVWVLFKDEHUGLH,QVWDQ]GHVÃ,µXQ WHUVFKHLGHQ (V YHUN|USHUW VR 0HDG ÄWKH UHVSRQVHRI WKH LQGLYLGXDO WR WKH DWWLWXGHRIWKHFRPPXQLW\DVWKLVDSSHDUVLQKLVRZQH[SHULHQFH³ 'LHVHQVWHWV QDFKWUlJOLFKHQ 5HDNWLRQHQ LQ GHQHQ VLFK GDV Ã,µ PDQLIHVWLHUW KDIWHW LQ LKUHU XQJUHLIEDUHQ6SRQWDQHLWlWHLQHSRWHQ]LHOOZLGHUVWlQGLJNUHDWLYH(LJHQDUWDEHU HEHQVRHWZDV1HEXO|VHVDQ:KLWHERRNV%HPHUNXQJGDVVGLHÄXQEHVWLPPWH 1DWXUGHVÃ,FKµ>«@YHUVFKLHGHQHQ,QWHUSUHWHQ0HDGVEUHLWHQ5DXP>ELHWHW@HV
+211(7+G +$%(50$6 E 0($' 9JO]XGHQ%HJULIIHQGHVÃ0HµXQGÃ,µLQVJHVDPW DD2± ± 9JO]X+RQQHWKV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGLHVHV=LWDWV +211(7+GI 0($' +$%(50$6 E 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ+DEHUPDVµXQG+RQQHWKV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHQ GHV9HUKlOWQLVVHVYRQÃ,µXQGÃ0Hµ '(56 E± +211(7+G ± 0($'
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
JHPlLKUHQHLJHQHQWKHRUHWLVFKHQXQGSROLWLVFKHQ$EVLFKWHQDXV]XJHVWDOWHQ³ ZLUGLQVEHVRQGHUHDQGHQGLHVEH]JOLFKHQbXHUXQJHQYRQ+RQQHWKXQG+D EHUPDVGHXWOLFK 0HDG5H]HSWLRQ,, 'DVZLGHUVWlQGLJH,FKXQGGLHNRQWUDIDNWLVFKH ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW 'DVÄ,³VRZDUEHUHLWV]XOHVHQÄLVWKHUHVSRQVHRIWKHLQGLYLGXDOWRWKHDWWLWXGH RIWKHFRPPXQLW\³GLHHVLQ)RUPGHVÃ0HµLQWHUQDOLVLHUWKDW'DVVGLHVH5HDN WLRQYRQQHJDWLYHU$UWVHLQNDQQZDV]XP.RQIOLNW]ZLVFKHQ]ZLVFKHQÃ,µXQG Ã0HµE]Z]ZLVFKHQ,QGLYLGXXPXQG*HPHLQVFKDIWIKUWVSLHOWEHL0HDGGXUFK DXVHLQH5ROOH$OOHUGLQJVVSUHQJWGHU)DOOGHVZLGHUVWlQGLJHQ(LQ]HOQHQGHU VLFK]XGHQVR]LDOQRUPLHUWHQ9HUKDOWHQVDQIRUGHUXQJHQDXINULWLVFKH'LVWDQ] EHJLEWNHLQHVZHJVGHQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ5DKPHQVHLQHV'HQNHQV 'DVMHGHQIDOOVPDFKHQ+DEHUPDVXQG+RQQHWKLQLKUHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVWDUN (QWVSUHFKHQGEHPHUNW0HDGHLQVFKUlQNHQGLP%OLFNDXIGLHEHVDJWH.RQIOLNWVL WXDWLRQ 2IFRXUVHVXFKDVLWXDWLRQLVRQO\SRVVLEOHZKHUHWKHLQGLYLGXDODSSHDOVVRWRVSHDNIURPD QDUURZDQGUHVWULFWHGFRPPXQLW\WRDODUJHURQHWKDWLVODUJHULQWKHORJLFDOVHQVHRIKDYLQJ ULJKWVZKLFKDUHQRWVRUHVWULFWHG2QHDSSHDOVIURPIL[HGFRQYHQWLRQVZKLFKQRORQJHUKDYH DQ\PHDQLQJWRDFRPPXQLW\LQZKLFKWKHULJKWVVKDOOEHSXEOLFO\UHFRJQL]HGDQGRQHDSSHDOV WRRWKHUVRQWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDWWKHUHLVDJURXSRIRUJDQL]HGRWKHUVWKDWDQVZHUWRRQH¶VRZQ DSSHDO±HYHQLIWKHDSSHDOEHPDGHWRSRVWHULW\
'XUFKKDOWHQOlVVWVLFKHLQHLQGLYLGXHOOH2SSRVLWLRQVKDOWXQJGHQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQJHJHQEHUGHPQDFKDOOHLQGDQQZHQQGHU(LQ]HOQHGDEHLDQ HLQHVHLQHPZLGHUVWlQGLJHQ9HUODQJHQOHW]WOLFKGRFK5DXPJHEHQGH*HPHLQ VFKDIW]XDSSHOOLHUHQYHUPDJ.HLQHVZHJV]ZLQJHQGDEHUPXVVGLHVHLQHVFKRQ UHDOH[LVWLHUHQGHÃFRPPXQLW\µVHLQZLH0HDGV9HUZHLVDXIGHQHEHQVRGHQNED UHQ$SSHOODQGLH1DFKZHOW]HLJW :DV+RQQHWKXQG+DEHUPDVDQGLHVHP*HGDQNHQLQWHUHVVLHUWLVWZHQLJHUGLH %HDQWZRUWXQJGHU)UDJHGDQDFKZRUDXV0HQVFKHQELVZHLOHQLQ]LHPOLFKDXV ZHJORVHQ KLVWRULVFKHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ LKUH VFKLHU XQElQGLJH :LGHUVWDQGVNUDIW VFK|SIHQ9LHOPHKU]LHKHQVLHGDUDXVGHQ*HZLQQHLQHVZHLWHUHQ$UJXPHQWVIU
:+,7(%22. 9JO]XGHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ%HGHXWXQJVGLPHQVLRQHQGHVÃ,µ HEG$QP 0($' 9JO :+,7(%22. II :KLWHERRN IRUPXOLHUW IROJHQGH $OWHUQDWLYGHXWXQJ Ä0HDGV%HREDFKWXQJGDVVHVQRWZHQGLJLVWHLQHLGHDOH*HPHLQVFKDIWDQ]XVSUHFKHQEHWULIIW QXUGLH$XIUHFKWHUKDOWXQJGHU2SSRVLWLRQJHJHQGLHJHJHEHQHVR]LDOH2UGQXQJ6LHEHWULIIW QLFKWGLH4XHOOH>«@DXVGHUGLHVHLQGLYLGXHOOH2SSRVLWLRQHQWVSULQJW8QGGLHVHV$UJXPHQW VFKOLHWNHLQHVIDOOVGLH([LVWHQ]YRQYRUVR]LDOHQ4XHOOHQGHV6HOEVWDXV³ DD2 $QP 0($'
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
LKUHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKH6LFKWGHV0HQVFKHQ6LFKÄLQGLH3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHU HUZHLWHUWHQ5HFKWVJHPHLQVFKDIW³KLQHLQ]XYHUVHW]HQVFKUHLEW+RQQHWKJHZlKUW GHPÄ6XEMHNW>«@EHUGHQPRUDOLVFKHQ%UXFKPLWGHP*HPHLQZHVHQKLQZHJ GLHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJRKQHGLHHVHLQHSHUV|QOLFKH,GHQWLWlWQLFKW DXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQNDQQ³+DEHUPDVHQWGHFNWLQGHU8QDEGLQJEDUNHLWVHLQHV$XV JULIIVÄDXIHLQHÃXPIDVVHQGHUH*HPHLQVFKDIWµ³HLQHQ%HOHJGDIUGDVVHVÄGXUFK XQGGXUFKJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKNRQVWLWXLHUWLVW³6HOEVWZRHVVLFKUDGLNDOYRQGHQ 6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQDEKHEWLQGLHHVHLQJHEXQGHQLVWEOHLEWGDV6XEMHNWDOVR IXQGDPHQWDODEKlQJLJGDYRQGXUFK$QGHUHDQHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQ1DFK+RQQHWK HQWVSULQJWGDUDXVGLHÄ1|WLJXQJVLFKIUHLQH(UZHLWHUXQJ³GHUJHJHQZlUWLJDOV PDQJHOKDIW HUIDKUHQHQ Ä$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVH>@ HLQ]XVHW]HQ³ XP VLFK ZLHGHULQGLHVHLQWHJULHUHQ]XN|QQHQ,QVHLQHQ$XJHQÄLVWHV>GDV@ZDVLQGHU 6R]LDOSV\FKRORJLH0HDGVÃ.DPSIXP$QHUNHQQXQJµKHLHQNDQQ³ 'DVVGDV 6XEMHNW]XUÄNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ8QWHUVWHOOXQJHLQHUHUZHLWHUWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ 5HFKWHQ³XQG]XP(LQVDW]IUGHUHQ:LUNOLFKZHUGHQ]ZLQJWZHQQHVPLWGHQ Ä1RUPHQVHLQHUVR]LDOHQ8PZHOW³LQ.RQIOLNWJHUlW +DEHUPDVVSULFKWKLHUYRP ÄNRQWUDIDNWLVFK XQWHUVWHOOWHQXQLYHUVHOOHQ'LV NXUV³ LP Ä8PZHJ >«@ EHU GHQ³ VLFK GHU (LQ]HOQH VHLQHV LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQVÄDOV IUHLHU:LOOH>«@XQGVFKOHFKWKLQLQGLYLGXLHUWHV:HVHQ³ GHQQRFK]XYHUJHZLVVHUQYHUPDJ 'LHVHU8PZHJZLUGGXUFK]ZLVFKHQPHQVFK OLFKH.RPPXQLNDWLRQLPPHUVFKRQEHVFKULWWHQZHLOVLHDOOHQDQLKU%HWHLOLJWHQ GLHÄXQYHUPHLGOLFKH>@,GHDOLVLHUXQJGHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJLPSXWLHUWHQ=XUHFKHQEDU NHLW³DEYHUODQJW8PEHUKDXSWPLWHLQDQGHUEHUHWZDVVSUHFKHQ]XN|QQHQ PXVV PDQGHPQDFKYRQHLQDQGHUHUZDUWHQE]ZVLFKUH]LSURN]XJHVWHKHQ]X VHOEVWJHWURIIHQHQXQGJXWEHJUQGHWHQ8UWHLOHQLQGHU/DJH]XVHLQ,QGLHVHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJ ]X YROO]LHKHQGHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ DOV ]XUHFKQXQJVIlKLJ OLHJW IU +DEHUPDVGDVQRUPDWLYH3RWHQ]LDOMHQHUEHUHLWVHUZlKQWHQÃ,GHHHLQHUXQYHU VHKUWHQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWµEHJUQGHWGLHLPNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ8PJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ 0HQVFKHQZLUNVDPZLUG'DJHJHQZHQGHW+RQQHWKNULWLVFKHLQGDVVVLFKGLHVH GHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQGHV0LWHLQDQGHUUHGHQV]XHQWQHKPHQGHQRUPDWLYH,GHHÄLQ
+211(7+G +$%(50$6 E9JOGD]X :+,7(%22. $QP +211(7+G (EG $D2 +$%(50$6 E 9JO ]X +DEHUPDVµ NRPPXQLNDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHU 'HXWXQJ 0HDGVLQVJHVDPW DD2± +$%(50$6 H9JO]XGHQLPIROJHQGHQQXUNXU]VNL]]LHUWHQÃXQYHUPHLGOLFKHQµ 9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ+DQGHOQV DD2±(LQHDQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH 3RLQWLHUXQJGHUÃZHFKVHOVHLWLJLPSXWLHUWHQ=XUHFKHQEDUNHLWµILQGHWVLFKLQ'(56 E Ä(LQHUPXGHQDQGHUHQDOV]XUHFKQXQJVIlKLJHQ$NWRUDQHUNDQQWKDEHQVREDOGHULKP]XPX WHW]XVHLQHP6SUHFKDNWDQJHERWPLWÃ-DµRGHUÃ1HLQµ6WHOOXQJ]XQHKPHQ³
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHQPRUDOLVFKHQ(UIDKUXQJHQGHUEHWHLOLJWHQ6XEMHNWHDOVVROFKH>V@JDUQLFKW³ QLHGHUVFKODJH GHQQGLHVHHUIDKUHQHLQH%HHLQWUlFKWLJXQJGHVVHQZDVZLUDOVLKUHPRUDOLVFKHQ(UZDUWXQJHQ >«@ EHWUDFKWHQ N|QQHQ QLFKW DOV (LQVFKUlQNXQJ YRQ LQWXLWLY EHKHUUVFKWHQ 6SUDFKUHJHOQ VRQGHUQDOV9HUOHW]XQJYRQVR]LDOLVDWRULVFKHUZRUEHQHQ,GHQWLWlWVDQVSUFKHQ
+RQQHWKVNULWLVFKH:RUWHGUlQJHQOHW]WHQ(QGHVGDUDXIGLHVSUDFKWKHRUHWLVFKH $EVWUDNWLRQVHEHQH]XYHUODVVHQXPGDVQRUPDWLYH3RWHQ]LDOXQHUIOOWHU$QHU NHQQXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQDQKDQGNRQNUHWHU$OOWDJVHUIDKUXQJHQKHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQ 'DVVEHL+DEHUPDVLQGLHVHP6LQQHHLQÄVR]LRORJLVFKHV'HIL]LW³YRUKHUUVFKW PDFKW+RQQHWKEHUHLWVLQVHLQHU SXEOL]LHUWHQ'LVVHUWDWLRQVVFKULIW.ULWLNGHU 0DFKW ]XP 7KHPD ,P VSlWHU KLQ]XJHIJWHQ 1DFKZRUW VFKOLHW HU VLFK GHU ÄJUXQGVlW]OLFKH>Q@,GHHGLHYRQ+DEHUPDV>«@HLQJHEUDFKWZRUGHQLVW³DEHU QRFKHLQPDODXVGUFNOLFKDQ ÄGLHNRPPXQLNDWLYH$OOWDJVSUD[LVDOVHLQLQWHUVXE MHNWLYHV*HVFKHKHQ³]XEHJUHLIHQÄGHVVHQLGHDOLVLHUHQGH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQYRQ VLFKDXVJHZLVVHUPDHQHLQHPRUDOLVFKH(QWZLFNOXQJHU]ZLQJHQ³0LWVHLQHP %HVWUHEHQGLHVHPRUDOLVFKH(QWZLFNOXQJEHU+DEHUPDVKLQDXVJHKHQGLQGHQ NRQNUHWHQ8QUHFKWVHPSILQGXQJHQVR]LDOHU$NWHXUH]XYHUDQNHUQZLOOHUPLWKLQ ÄGLH OLQJXLVWLVFKH :HQGH QDWUOLFK QLFKW UFNJlQJLJ³ PDFKHQ 6LH VROO QXU ÄDQGHUVDXVEXFKVWDELHUWZHUGHQ³(VEOHLEWDOVREHLPGXUFKGLHVH:HQGHEH VLHJHOWHQ $EVFKLHG YRQ GHU 3KLORVRSKLH GHV 6XEMHNWV $Q GLHVHU 6WHOOH VHW]W :KLWHERRNV*HJHQUHGHDQ
$XVJDQJEHLP6XEMHNW :KLWHERRNV:LGHUUXIGHU NRPPXQLNDWLYHQ:HQGH Ä'LHUHLHULVFKH5KHWRULNGH>V@3DUDGLJPHQZHFKVHO>V@³VRPDFKW:KLWHERRN LP%OLFNDXIGLHGXUFK+DEHUPDVXQG+RQQHWKDXVJHUXIHQHÄLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWL VFKH>@:HQGH³GHXWOLFKHUVFKHLQWLKPEHLQlKHUHP+LQVHKHQDOVHLQHEORH ,PPXQLVLHUXQJVVWUDWHJLH6LHGLHQWLKUHQ3URWDJRQLVWHQGD]XGDVHLJHQH'HQNHQ
+211(7+E I %2/7$16.,+211(7+ 9JOYDGLH$XVIKUXQJHQ]X+DEHUPDVLQ +211(7+ ± +211(7+ %2/7$16.,+211(7+ $D2 :+,7(%22. 9JO ]XP )ROJHQGHQ YD GLH $XVIKUXQJHQ :KLWHERRNV LQ DD2 ±± ± '(56I I +211(7+:+,7(%22. ±6HLQHNULWLVFKH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW+DEHUPDVGLHVLFKLQYLHOHQ9HU|I IHQWOLFKXQJHQQLHGHUVFKOlJWXQGHWZDDXFK+DEHUPDVµ5H]HSWLRQGHU3V\FKRDQDO\VHEHWULIIW KDWHU]XVDPPHQJHIDVVWLQ :+,7(%22.± +211(7+I
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
YRUGHP3UREOHPGUXFN]XVFKW]HQGHUZHLWHUKLQYRQGHUIUJlQ]OLFKEHU ZXQGHQHUNOlUWHQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHPDWLNDXVJHKWÄ$XIJUXQGGLHVHUQXUVFKHLQ EDUHQhEHUZLQGXQJ³GURKWMHGRFKZLH:KLWHERRNHLQPDOPHKUEHWRQWÄGHU :DKUKHLWVJHKDOWGHVVHQYHUORUHQ>]XJHKHQ@ZDVLFK+REEHVLDQLVPXVQHQQH³ ,QVEHVRQGHUH]ZHL'HQNHUIKUWHULQV)HOGEHLHUGLHVHQ:DKUKHLWVJHKDOWLQ VXEMHNWSKLORVRSKLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHEHZDKUWVLHKW 'LHWHU+HQULFKPLWVHLQHP *HGDQNHQHLQHUXUVSUQJOLFKHQ6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWV XQG0DUN 6DFNVPLWVHLQHP3OlGR\HUIUGDV6XEMHNWDOVHLQHUDXHUVR]LDOHQ.ULWLNLQVWDQ] 9RUJlQJLJH6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLW PLW'LHWHU+HQULFKJHJHQGHQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV .HLQÄQRFKVRYRUJlQJLJHV0LWVLFK9HUWUDXWVHLQ³VFKUHLEW+DEHUPDVPXVV GHP YROOVWlQGLJ DXV VR]LDOHQ ,QWHUDNWLRQVSUR]HVVHQ HUNOlUEDUHQ 6HOEVW PHKU XQWHUVWHOOWZHUGHQMDÄGDV)LFKWHVFKH$XVJDQJVSUREOHP³NDQQDXVVHLQHU6LFKW PLWGHP:HFKVHO]XPNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ3DUDGLJPDDOVÄJHJHQVWDQGORV³JHOWHQ %HLGH$XVVDJHQVWHOOHQ*UXQGDQQDKPHQ'LHWHU+HQULFKVLQ)UDJHDXIGHVVHQ 0LWWHGHU HU-DKUHSXEOL]LHUWH=Z|OI7KHVHQJHJHQ-UJHQ+DEHUPDVVLH UHDJLHUHQ'DVYRQ+DEHUPDVÃJHJHQVWDQGVORVµJHQDQQWHÃILFKWHVFKH$XVJDQJV SUREOHPµNXU]JHVDJW GLH)UDJHQDFKGHP*UXQGGHVVLFKXUVSUQJOLFKDXIVLFK VHOEVWEH]LHKHQGHQXQGVLFKGDULQJOHLFKZRKOEHUHLWVYRUDXVVHW]HQGHQ6XEMHNWV VWHOOWIU+HQULFKHLQ]HQWUDOHVSKLORVRSKLVFKHV7KHPDGDU(UEHJHJQHWGHU GDPLWDXIJH]HLJWHQ$SRULHGXUFKGLH$QQDKPHMHQHUHUZlKQWHQYRUJlQJLJHQ 9HUWUDXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVPLWVLFKVHOEVWYRQGHUHVQLFKWQXUEHLMHGHPUHIOH[L YHQ6HOEVWEH]XJLPPHUVFKRQ*HEUDXFKPDFKW$XFKDOOHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ%H ]XJQDKPHQDXIHVPVVHQGLHVHSUlUHIOH[LYH'LPHQVLRQGHV6HOEVWVHLQVOlQJVW YRUDXVVHW]HQZDV:KLWHERRNVEHVRQGHUHV,QWHUHVVHILQGHW6RKHLWHVEHL+HQ ULFK (VLVW]ZDUP|JOLFKXQGZLH]X]HLJHQLVWVRJDUQRWZHQGLJGDGLH(QWZLFNOXQJLQGHUGLH ZLVVHQGH6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJDXINRPPWYRQDXHQDQJHUHJWZLUG'DUDXILVWGDQQDEHUDXFKGLH VR]LDOH*HQHVHGHV6HOEVWZLVVHQVEHVFKUlQNW,KUHLJHQWOLFKHU*UXQGLVWJDQ]XQGJDUHQGR JHQ
:+,7(%22. +$%(50$6 FI9JO]X+DEHUPDV$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW+HQULFKDXFKGLH IROJHQGHQ3DVVDJHQDXVGHU7KHRULHGHVNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ+DQGHOQV '(56 DII 9JO+(15,&+ 9JO+(15,&+ 9JO]XU(QWZLFNOXQJYRQ+HQULFKVLP)ROJHQGHQDQJHVSURFKHQHP =HQWUDOJHGDQNHQHLQHUXUVSUQJOLFKHQ6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWV '5,/23DUVSUR WRWRNDQQGLHVH)RUPXOLHUXQJ+HQULFKVVWHKHQ Ä'LH9HUWUDXWKHLWPLW%HZXWVHLQNDQQEHU KDXSWQLFKWDOV5HVXOWDWHLQHV8QWHUQHKPHQVYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ6LHOLHJWMHVFKRQYRUZHQQ %HZXWVHLQHLQWULWW³ +(15,&+ +(15,&+
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
:DUXPGDV+LQHLQUHJLHUHQGHV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQLQV6XEMHNWDXIJUXQGYRQGHVVHQ YRUJlQJLJHU6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLWGHUDUWLJHQ%HVFKUlQNXQJHQXQWHUOLHJWVFKlUIHQ +HQULFKV7KHVHQJHJHQ+DEHUPDVHLQÄ.RPPXQLNDWLRQVWDWW6XEMHNWLYLWlW"³ ODXWHWGLHKLHUHLQVFKOlJLJH)UDJHGLHHULQGHU]HKQWHQVHLQHU7KHVHQEHDQWZRU WHW+DEHUPDVµÄ7KHVHYRP9RUUDQJGHU>VSUDFKOLFKJHVWHXHUWHQ .7@,QWHUDN WLRQ³VRVWUHLFKWHUKHUDXVKlWWHGDQQÄOHLFKWHV6SLHO³ZHQQYRPÄ(UZHUEGHU )lKLJNHLWGLHJUDPPDWLVFKHHUVWH3HUVRQVLQJXODULV GDV3URQRPHQÃLFKµ ]X JHEUDXFKHQ>«@GHU%HVWDQGYRQ6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVDEKlQJLJ³ZlUH'DJHJHQ DEHUVSULFKWDXVVHLQHU6LFKWVFKRQGLHVFKOLFKWH7DWVDFKHGDVVGDV,FKVDJHQ .|QQHQVLFKVSlWHUHQWZLFNHOWDOVHWZDGDV9HUP|JHQXQWHU(LQVDW]YRQ'H PRQVWUDWLYSURQRPLQDDXI$QGHUHV]XYHUZHLVHQ$XFK/HW]WHUHVLVWPLWKLQVFKRQ GXUFKHLQHQGDVMHZHLOV$QYLVLHUWHYRQVLFKXQWHUVFKHLGHQGHQXQGDXIVLFKEH ]LHKHQGHQ6HOEVWEH]XJEHVWLPPWGHUDOVVROFKHUHLQHYRUJlQJLJH6HOEVWYHUWUDXW KHLWYRUDXVVHW]W(EHQVR]HLJWZLH+HQULFKIHVWKlOWÄGLHVHPDQWLVFKH8QWHUVX FKXQJ GHV LFKµ*HEUDXFKV >«@ GD HU QXU DXIJUXQG HLQHV YRUDXVJHKHQGHQ 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQVDXI6HLWHQGHV6SUHFKHUVYHUVWlQGOLFK]XPDFKHQLVW³:R KHUQlPOLFKVROOWHHUVRQVWZLVVHQN|QQHQGDVVHUVHOEVWHVLVWDXIGHQHUGDPLW YRU$QGHUHQUHNXUULHUW":HUGLHVH)UDJHQLFKWDOO]XUDVFKIUÃJHJHQVWDQGVORVµ HUNOlUWNRPPWODXW+HQULFKXPGLHVSDQQXQJVYROOH(LQVLFKWQLFKWKHUXP GDZLU]ZDUHLQHUVHLWVJDUQLFKWXPKLQN|QQHQXQVLQ8QWHUVXFKXQJHQEHUGLHZLVVHQGH 6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJPLW+LOIHYRQ3URQRPLQDZLHLFKµXQGPLFKµ]XDUWLNXOLHUHQGDZLUXQV DQGHUHUVHLWVDEHUDXFKMHGHU]HLWGDUEHULPNODUHQ]XVHLQKDEHQGDGLH%H]LHKXQJVHOEVW QLFKWLPZLUNOLFKHQ*HEUDXFKGHU3URQRPLQDDXIJHKW
'LHVHVYRQ+HQULFKDN]HQWXLHUWH1LFKW$XIJHKHQGHU6HOEVWEH]LHKXQJLPVR]LD OLVDWRULVFKHUZRUEHQHQ6SUDFKJHEUDXFKPDFKW:KLWHERRNJHJHQ+DEHUPDVµXQG +RQQHWKV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVJHOWHQG'HUHQGXUFK0HDGJHSUlJWH6LFKWGHU
9JO]XPIROJHQGHQGLHPLWGLHVHUhEHUVFKULIWYHUVHKHQHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XU]HKQWHQ 7KHVHLQ +(15,&+ ±9JODXFKGLHWHLOVJOHLFKODXWHQGHQWHLOVSUl]LVLHUWHQ)RUPX OLHUXQJHQLQ GHUV I $D2 +(15,&+ $D2 (VPDJYHUZXQGHUQGDVV+HQULFKYRQ:KLWHERRNLQHLQHKREEHVLDQLVWLVFKH/LQLHJHVWHOOW ZLUG'RFKLVWGDUDQ]XHULQQHUQGDVV+HQULFK+REEHVDOVÄHUVWHQ7KHRUHWLNHUGHUPRGHUQHQ *HVHOOVFKDIW³ +(15,&+ EH]HLFKQHQXQGGHVVHQDQWKURSRORJLVFKHQ=HQWUDOEHJULII GHU6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJDOV,QLWLDOPRGHUQHQ6XEMHNWGHQNHQVZUGLJHQNDQQÄ,P%HJULIIGLHVHU 6HOEVWHUKDOWXQJ³VFKUHLEW+HQULFKEHU+REEHVÄLVWGLHSROHPLVFKH1RWHQLFKW]XEHUVHKHQ (URSSRQLHUWGHUWHOHRORJLVFKHQ'HXWXQJGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXULQHLQHP8QLYHUVXPGDVDOV =ZHFNV\VWHP DXIJHIDVVW LVW 'LH .ULWHULHQ IU GLH 5LFKWLJNHLW VHLQHV +DQGHOQV NDQQ GHU 0HQVFKQXULQVLFKVHOEVWILQGHQ ±HUVHOEVWGDVLVWGLH6WUXNWXUHLQHU$NWLYLWlWQLFKWHLQ HUVWHV=LHODOOHVVHLQHV6WUHEHQVGDVHUVHLQHP7XQYRUJHRUGQHWILQGHWXQGLQ%H]LHKXQJDXI GDVVHLQHYRQ5XKHXQWHUVFKHLGEDUH$NWLYLWlWDOOHLQYHUVWlQGOLFKLVW±DOVHLQH%HGLQJXQJ QlPOLFKXQWHUGHU=LHOHYHUZLUNOLFKWZHUGHQN|QQHQ³ DD2 'DULQNQGLJWVLFKIU
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
]XIROJHGLH*HQHVHGHV6HOEVWDXIGLHhEHUQDKPHYRQNRPPXQLNDWLYYHUPLWWHO WHQ)UHPGSHUVSHNWLYHQ]XUFNJHKWNRQWHUWHUPLWGHP+LQZHLV 6LFK]XHLJHQ PDFKHQ]XN|QQHQZDVDQGHUHDQHLQHPDQHUNHQQHQVHW]WHEHQVRHLQH)lKLJ NHLW]XU6HOEVWUHIHUHQ]YRUDXVZLHHLQHOHPHQWDUHV:LVVHQXPVLFKVHOEVW2KQH GLHVHV:LVVHQGDV:KLWHERRNLQ+HQULFKVYRUJlQJLJHU6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLWEH ZDKUWVLHKWZUGHLFKPLFKGXUFKGLH)UHPGSHUVSHNWLYHQJDUQLFKWDQJHVSUR FKHQIKOHQN|QQHQXQGYHUPRFKWHLFKPLFKDXFKQLFKWSRVLWLYRGHUQHJDWLY]X LKQHQ]XYHUKDOWHQ'HU9HU]LFKWDXIGLH$QQDKPHHLQHVZLHHUHVQHQQWÄ3UR WRRGHU3Ul6HOEVW³GDVIUHLQHYRUVSUDFKOLFKHXQGÄYRUUHIOH[LYH>@)RUPGHU 6HOEVW.HQQWQLV³VWHKWOLHHOHW]WOLFKGDV6HOEVWDOVÄ5HVXOWDWGHU3UlJXQJHLQHU WDEXODUDVDGXUFKGLHVR]LDOH)RUP³HUVFKHLQHQ 6ROFKHLQHU([WUHPSRVLWLRQDEHUKDEHQ+DEHUPDVXQG+RQQHWKPHKURGHU ZHQLJHUGHXWOLFKZLGHUVSURFKHQ)UHLPWLJUlXPW+DEHUPDVLQHLQHU$QPHUNXQJ HLQ GDVV VHLQH 5HGH YRQ HLQHP GXUFK NRPPXQLNDWLYH 3HUVSHNWLYEHUQDKPH ÄKHUJHVWHOOWHQ6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLV>@³NHLQHVZHJVGHQRQWRJHQHWLVFKHQ$QQDKPHQ ÄYRUVSUDFKOLFKH>U@:XU]HOQGHUNRJQLWLYHQ(QWZLFNOXQJ³XQGHLQHVÄUXGLPHQWl UHQ6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLV>VHV@³ZLGHUVSUHFKH $XFK+RQQHWKKDWNHLQ3UREOHPGD PLWLQ5HDNWLRQDXI:KLWHERRNGHU$QQDKPHHLQHVÄSUHOLQJXLVWLFVHOI³]X]XV WLPPHQ=XGHPVWLPPWHUGHUDXV+HQULFKVVXEMHNWSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ$QQDKPHQ ]XJHZLQQHQGHQ7KHVH]XÄGDGHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ%HJHJQXQJ>«@LPPHUHLQH $UWYRQHOHPHQWDUHU6HOEVWHPSILQGXQJYRUDXVJHKHQPXXPGLH7DWVDFKH]X HUNOlUHQGDGDV,QGLYLGXXPVLFKDOV$GUHVVDWYRQ=XZHQGXQJRGHU$QHUNHQ QXQJ]XEHJUHLIHQYHUPDJ³ 0HKUDOVGDVVGLHVH7DWVDFKHHLQHORJLVFKH(UNOlUXQJILQGHWIROJWDXVGHP 9RUDXVVHW]HQPVVHQMHQHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWHPSILQGXQJIU+RQQHWKDOOHU GLQJVQLFKW'LHDOOHVÄEHUUDJHQGH%HGHXWXQJYRQ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW³EOHLEW GDGXUFKHEHQVRXQDQJHWDVWHWZLHLP)DOOHYRQ+DEHUPDVGHUGLHVRHEHQ]LWLHU WHQ:RUWHVRJOHLFKZLHGHUHQWNUlIWHW'HU*HKDOWÄVROFKH>U@RQWRJHQHWLVFKH>U@ $XVVDJHQ³VRVFKUHLEWHUÄSUlMXGL]LHUH>@³NHLQHVZHJVZDVÄDXIGHU(QWZLFN OXQJVVWXIHGHUEHKHUUVFKWHQ0XWWHUVSUDFKH³YRQVWDWWHQJHKHÄ(UVFKHLQW]X EHKDXSWHQ³ODXWHW:KLWHERRNVGLHVEH]JOLFKHU.RPPHQWDU +HQULFKGDVÄIUHLJHVHW]WH>@PLWVLFKVHOEHUYHUWUDXWH>@³VSH]LILVFKÄPRGHUQH%HZXWVHLQ³ DD2 DQ :+,7(%22. +$%(50$6 FLQNO$QP 9JO +211(7+ :+,7(%22. I +RQQHWK OlVVW GRUW KHUDXJHIRUGHUW GXUFK :KLWHERRNXQWHUDQGHUHPYHUODXWHQ Ä6RWKHUHLVDSUHOLQJXLVWLFVHOIZKLFKLVSUREDEO\DO UHDG\IURPTXLWHHDUO\RQDVRFLDOVHOIEHFDXVHLWSODFHVLWVHOIZLWKLQWKHVRFLDOZRUOG³ ± HLQH$XVVDJHGLHIUHLOLFKVRJOHLFKDXIGLHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ%DKQHQ]XUFNJOHLWHW +211(7+I $D2 +$%(50$6 F$QP
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GDVV6SUDFKHHLQHQDXWDUNHQ.RVPRVELOGHWVRGDVVZLUZHQQZLUHLQPDOLQGHVVHQ8P]lX QXQJVLQGNHLQHQ=XJDQJPHKU]XGHQYRUXQGDXHUVSUDFKOLFKHQ.UlIWHQKDEHQGLHDXILKQ HLQZLUNHQXQGLKQYHU]HUUHQ
'LHYRUXQGDXHUVSUDFKOLFKHE]ZVR]LDOH'LPHQVLRQGHV6HOEVWVRPDFKW :KLWHERRNGDPLWNODUZLUGEHL+DEHUPDVHEHQVRZLHEHL+RQQHWKVRZHLWVLH EHUKDXSWLQGHQ%OLFNNRPPWLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHLQJHKHJW'DVVGDULQXQ NRQWUROOLHUEDUH 3RWHQ]LDOH VWHFNHQ GLH DXI GLH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVH HLQZLUNHQVLHSURGXNWLYYHUlQGHUQDEHUDXFKYHU]HUUHQN|QQHQDEHUZLUGGD GXUFKYRQYRUQKHUHLQDXVJHVFKORVVHQ+RQQHWKEHJHJQHWGLHVHP9RUZXUIPLW GHP+LQZHLV+HQULFKV*HGDQNHGHUYRUJlQJLJHQ6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLWKDEHHLQH UHLQÄEHJULIIOLFK>H@³3RLQWHXQGVROOHNHLQHÄVWUXNWXUHOOH>@,QVWDQ]GHU6R]LDO IHLQGOLFKNHLWLP0HQVFKHQ³DXV]HLFKQHQ$XIMHGHQ)DOOVROOGLHVHU*HGDQNH DEHUQDFK+HQULFKV$XVNXQIW]%GDV)ROJHQGHEHLQKDOWHQ ÄGDQXUGRUWHLQ *HVSUlFKDXINRPPWGDVGLHVHQ1DPHQYHUGLHQWZRGLH,QWHU$NWHXUHDQGHUHV VLQGDOVGLH>«@Ã6SUHFKHUµGHU>«@7KHRULHGHVNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ+DQGHOQV³ 6LHPVVHQDQGHUHVXQG PHKUQRFKVHLQN|QQHQKHLWGDVDOVQXU3URGXNWH MHQHVVSUDFKOLFKHQ,QWHUDNWLRQVSUR]HVVHVLQGHQVLHHLQJHEXQGHQVLQGZHQQVLH GHQQGDUDQLP:RUWVLQQHVHOEVWEHWHLOLJWVHLQVROOHQ 'LHVHVVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUH$QGHUVXQG0HKU6HLQGHVXUVSUQJOLFKPLW VLFKVHOEVWYHUWUDXWHQ6XEMHNWVLPSOL]LHUWQLFKWDXV]XUHFKQHQGH3RWHQ]LDOHÄGHU ,QGLYLGXDWLRQ GHU .UHDWLYLWlW XQG GHU 6SRQWDQHLWlW³ :HJHQ LKUHU ]XQlFKVW HLQPDOMHQVHLWVYRQ*XWXQG%|VHDQJHVLHGHOWHQ(LJHQDUWVWHOOHQVLHDOOHUGLQJV VR:KLWHERRNÄIUGLH3KLORVRSKLHGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWHLQJHZDOWLJHV3UREOHP GDU³ZDVLKUHLQHQWHQGHQ]LHOONRQIRUPLVWLVFKHQXQGNRQYHQWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQ$Q VWULFKJLEW'LHVH7HQGHQ]ILQGHWHUXQWHU5HNXUVDXI(UQVW7XJHQGKDWV,QWHU SUHWDWLRQVFKRQEHL0HDGDQJHOHJW6RHLJQHWGHPPHDGVFKHQ6HOEVWQHEHQGHP GLHVR]LDOHQ(UZDUWXQJHQLQWHUQDOLVLHUHQGHQÃ0HµZLHJHVHKHQ]ZDUDXFKGLH± DOOHUGLQJV DENQIWLJH ± 'LPHQVLRQ GHV GDUDXI ]XVWLPPHQG RGHU DEZHLFKHQG
:+,7(%22. 9JO GD]X GLH +DEHUPDV.ULWLN .ODXV0LFKDHO .RGDOOHV LQ
'(56 ± ±+DEHUPDVYHUZHUIHÄSHUVH>«@GLH,QDQVSUXFKQDKPH
HLQHUXQEHVWLPPWHQ)UHLKHLW³ÄGLHVLFKGHPJHUHJHOWHQÃRUGHQWOLFKHQ'LVNXUVHQW]LHKW³XQG VHLQHÄ3KLORVRSKLH³KDEHYRQGDKHUÄHWZDV=ZDQJKDIWHVDQVLFK³ '(56 I +211(7+I +(15,&+ ,P$XVJDQJYRQ+HQULFKNRPPWDXFK-|UJ'LHUNHQ]X)RUPXOLHUXQ JHQGLH+RQQHWKV7KHVHHQWJHJHQVWHKHQ Ä:LH+HQULFKEHWRQWNDQQGDV6HOEVWREVHLQHU 6LQJXODULWlWDOOHVR]LDOHQ2UGQXQJHQLPPHUDXFKEHUVWHLJHQ>«@,QGLYLGXHOOH)UHLKHLWGLH IUVLFKVLQJXOlULVWYHUPDJDOV1HJDWLRQVSRWHQ]YRQ6LWWOLFKNHLWVRUGQXQJHQ]XIXQJLHUHQ>«@ 6LHNDQQVLFKDEHUDXFKDOVGHUHQSHUPDQHQWH.ULWLNXQG.RUUHNWXUEHWlWLJHQXPGLHVHLQGHU '\QDPLNVWlQGLJHQ7UDQV]HQGLHUHQV]XRSWLPLHUHQ$XFKLQGLHVHP)DOOEOHLEWHLQ7UDQV]HQ GHQ]YRUEHKDOW GHV VLQJXOlUHQ 6HOEVW XQG VHLQHU )UHLKHLWVG\QDPLN JHJHQEHU GHU VR]LDOHQ 2UGQXQJEHVWHKHQ ',(5.(1F :+,7(%22. (EG
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
UHDJLHUHQGHQÃ,µÄ$EHU0HDGVSULFKWQLFKWYRQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³ZLH7X JHQGKDWVFKUHLEWXQGGDVKDWVHLQH*UQGHZHLOEHLLKP DXFKIUHLQHLJHQVWlQGLJHV6LFKYHUKDOWHQ>«@GDVNRQYHQWLRQHOO9RUJHJHEHQHGDVHLQ]LJH 0DWHULDO>EOHLEW@DQGHPHVVLFKDEDUEHLWHQNDQQXQGGDV(UJHEQLVGLHVHU$UEHLWN|QQHQQXU YHUEHVVHUWHNRQYHQWLRQHOOH9RUVWHOOXQJHQVHLQ
9RQGLHVHP.RQYHQWLRQDOLVPXVGHU0HDGVYRQGHU'LPHQVLRQGHVÃ0HµGRPL QLHUWHQ6HOEVWEHJULIISUlJWXQGÄ+HLGHJJHUV>«@Ã0DQµ>«@VHKUQDKH³EULQJW VLHKW:KLWHERRNDXFK+RQQHWKVXQG+DEHUPDVµ3RVLWLRQHQJHSUlJW'HQQDXFK VLHN|QQHQGDV6XEMHNWQXUYRP,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQKHUXQGDXIV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYH KLQGHQNHQZDVHLQQLFKWYRQMHKHUVR]LDOUHVWULQJLHUWHV9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ3Kl QRPHQHQ ZLH ,QGLYLGXDWLRQ .UHDWLYLWlW XQG 6SRQWDQHLWlW HUVFKZHUW ,P $Q VFKOXVVDQGHQEULWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQ0DUN6DFNVIKUW:KLWHERRNYRU$XJHQ ZHOFKHUÄ3RWHQ]LDOH]XU.ULWLN³PDQVLFKGDPLWEHJLEW $XHUVR]LDOH.ULWLNLQVWDQ] PLW0DUN6DFNVJHJHQGHQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXV Ä+RZFDQLQWHUVXEMHFWLYHUHFRJQLWLRQJURXQGWKHLGHQWLW\DQGVHOIFRQVFLRXVQHVV RIWKHVXEMHFW"³IUDJW6DFNVLQGHU6WXGLHDXIGLH:KLWHERRNKLHUUHNXUULHUW $QDORJ]X+HQULFKPDFKWHUNODUGDVVGLHVH)UDJHQLFKWEHDQWZRUWHWZHUGHQ NDQQRKQHVLFKNODU]XPDFKHQÄWKDWLQRUGHUWRKDYHVXFKLQWHUVXEMHFWLYHUHFRJ QLWLRQWKHUHPXVWDOUHDG\EHDQDFWLYHVXEMHFWPLQLPDOO\DZDUHRILWVHOI³0LW GHU$QQDKPHHLQHVVROFKHQÄUXGLPHQWDU\VXEMHFW³YRQGHPHUHLQGXUFKVR]LDOH $QHUNHQQXQJVSUR]HVVHJHIRUPWHVXQGVWUXNWXULHUWHVÄVXEVWDQWLDOVXEMHFW³XQWHU VFKHLGHWZLOOHUZLH:KLWHERRNHV]XVDPPHQIDVVWDPDXINOlUHULVFKHQÄ%LOG HLQHV6HOEVW³IHVWKDOWHQÄGDVDXHUKDOEGHU:HOW±DXHUKDOEMHGHUWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ :HOW±VWHKHQXQGGLHVHEHXUWHLOHQNDQQ³(VLVWHLQ6HOEVW%LOGGHVVHQ*UXQG ODJH6DFNV]XIROJHHLQHGXUFK.DQWV%HJULIIGHVDXWRQRPHQ6XEMHNWVEHJUQGHWH ÄHJRORJLFDOFRQFHSWLRQRIWKH>«@VHOI³ELOGHW 'DVVGHU0HQVFKTXD9HUQXQIWDXVVLFKVHOEVWKHUDXVZLVVHQNDQQZDVJXW XQGULFKWLJLVWYHUSIOLFKWHWLKQ]ZDU]XP$OOJHPHLQHQIUDOOH=XWUlJOLFKHQHV PDFKWLKQDEHUDXFKSDUWLHOOXQDEKlQJLJYRP(UZDUWXQJVGUXFNXQKLQWHUIUDJWHU +DQGOXQJVNRQYHQWLRQHQ/HW]WHUHVEULQJWGHQHUZlKQWHQ$EVWDQG]XU:HOWPLW VLFK ZRULQ:KLWHERRNLP 5HNXUVDXI6DFNV]ZHL $VSHNWHHLQHUVXEMHNWLYHQ .ULWLNIlKLJNHLWYHUDQNHUWILQGHWGLHGXUFKGDVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKH*HJHQPR
78*(1'+$7 I $D2 :+,7(%22. 'LH$XVIKUXQJHQ]X6DFNVILQGHQVLFK DD2I 6$&.6I9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2± $D2 (EG :+,7(%22. 6$&.6
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GHOOYHUORUHQ]XJHKHQGURKHQ:HQQJOHLFKHVXQ]XWUHIIHQGZlUH]XEHKDXSWHQ Ä>WKDW@WKHLQGLYLGXDOLVIXOO\HPSRZHUHGWRVWUXFWXUHVRFLHW\³±GLHJHJHQWHLOLJH QDFK6DFNVGHPÄ+HJHOLDQPRGHO³]%+RQQHWKV]X]XVFKUHLEHQGH7KHVHLVW ]XPLQGHVWGHXWOLFK]XUHODWLYLHUHQ ÄVRFLHW\ LQVRPHIRUP LVIXOO\HPSRZHUHG WRVWUXFWXUHWKHLQGLYLGXDO³'HQ$QSDVVXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU 6WUXNWXULHUXQJVSUR]HVVH VWHKW QlPOLFK VR HLQH VLFK QLFKW IUDJORV HLQIJHQGH VRQGHUQJUXQGVlW]OLFKZLGHUVSUHFKHQGH'LPHQVLRQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQV HQWJHJHQ,QGLHVHULVWVR:KLWHERRNDOVGDVHLQH.ULWLNSRWHQ]LDOHLQHÄ4XHOOH GHU'\QDPLN,QQRYDWLRQXQG.UHDWLYLWlW³DQJHOHJWÄRKQHGLH*HVHOOVFKDIWHQ]XU 6WDJQDWLRQYHUXUWHLOWZlUHQ³ 1XQUHGHQZHGHU+RQQHWKQRFK+DEHUPDVHLQHUEORHQ.RQVHUYLHUXQJGHV VWDWXVTXRGDV:RUW'RFKYHUPDJLKUGXUFK0HDGEHVWLPPWHU%OLFNDXFKQRFK GLHLQGLYLGXHOOH$EZHLFKXQJYRPVR]LDO(LQJHVSLHOWHQQLFKWDQGHUVGHQQDOV 6R]LDOLVDWLRQVSURGXNWDQ]XVHKHQ :HUVLFKGHQYRUJHJHEHQHQ9HUKDOWHQVHUZDU WXQJHQHQW]LHKWWXWGLHVVWHWVLP$XVJULIIDXIHLQHLGHDOLVLHUWH)RUPYRQ6R]LDOL WlWZHLOHUVLFKVHLQHUVHOEVWYRQMHKHUQXULP$QHUNDQQWZHUGHQGXUFK$QGHUH YHUJHZLVVHUQNDQQÄ'LH([LVWHQ]GHVÃ0LFKµLVWHV³VR+RQQHWKÄGLHGDV6XE MHNW]ZLQJWVLFKLP,QWHUHVVHVHLQHVÃ,FKµIUQHXH)RUPHQGHUVR]LDOHQ$QHU NHQQXQJHLQ]XVHW]HQ³ 'DUDXIDEHU]LHOWGHPQDFKMHGHULQGLYLGXHOOH:LGHU VSUXFK JHJHQ GLH HWDEOLHUWHQ 9HUKDOWHQVHUZDUWXQJHQ LPPHU VFKRQ :HLO HV ÄGXUFKXQGGXUFKJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKNRQVWLWXLHUWLVW³VFKUHLEWDQDORJGD]X+DEHU PDVLVWÄGDV6HOEVWGHPGLHVH(LJHQOHLVWXQJHQ]XJHPXWHWZHUGHQ³JDUQLFKW LPVWDQGHÄDXV*HVHOOVFKDIWEHUKDXSWKHUDXV>]X@WUHWHQXQGVLFKLQHLQHP5DXP DEVWUDNWHU(LQVDPNHLWXQG)UHLKHLWDQ>]X@VLHGHOQ³ 9LHOPHKUPXVVHVVLFKHEHQ VWHWVÄLQ5LFKWXQJDXIHLQHÃXPIDVVHQGHUH*HVHOOVFKDIWµ³ KLQHQWZHUIHQÄLQGHU MHGHUGLH3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHVMHGHQDQGHUHQHLQQHKPHQXQGMHGHUDXIUH]LSURNH $QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKDOOHUHFKQHQNDQQ³ Ä,QGLYLGXDOLVPXVDOV.HKUVHLWHGHV8QL YHUVDOLVPXV³ 'LHVHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH(LQJHPHLQGXQJDOOHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ(LJHQVLQQVVROO ]ZDULQLKUHUXQLYHUVDOLVWLVFKHQ$E]ZHFNXQJMHGHQSDUWLNXODUHQ7UDGLWLRQV]X VDPPHQKDQJWUDQV]HQGLHUHQ1DFK:KLWHERRNV'DIUKDOWHQDEHUIKUWVLHJHQDX ]XP*HJHQWHLOLQVRIHUQVRHLQ]ZHLWHVLP6LFK'LVWDQ]LHUHQ.|QQHQGHV6XE MHNWVYHUDQNHUWHV.ULWLNSRWHQ]LDOXQWHUPLQLHUWZLUG GLH)lKLJNHLWÄVLFKVHOEVW DOOHU]XIlOOLJHQHPSLULVFKHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQ]XHQWOHGLJHQ³ XPHLQHLJHQVWlQ GLJHV8UWHLO]XIlOOHQ±HLQ8UWHLOGDUEHUÄZKDWFRXQWVDVUDWLRQDOWKRXJKWZKDW
$D2 :+,7(%22. +211(7+G +$%(50$6 E (EG +$%(50$6 EI :+,7(%22.
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
FRXQWV DV D JRRG UHDVRQRUDV DQ HQG ZRUWK SXUVXLQJ³ :LH 6DFNV KHUDXV VWUHLFKWYHUIlOOW+DEHUPDVQlPOLFKDOOHUXQLYHUVDOLVWLVFKHQ=LHOYRUJDEHQ]XP 7URW]HLQHPÄFRPPXQLWDULDQSDURFKLDOLVP³ XQG]ZDUDXV]ZHL*UQGHQ(LQHU VHLWVILQGHQGLHYRQLKPQXUK|FKVWIRUPDOEHVFKULHEHQHQ3UR]HVVHLQWHUVXEMHNWL YHU9HUVWlQGLJXQJGHUHQ]ZDQJORVHU=ZDQJGLH6XEMHNWH]XUUH]LSURNHQ$QHU NHQQXQJ Q|WLJWQLFKWLPOXIWOHHUHQVRQGHUQLPPHUDXFK WUDGLWLRQVJHSUlJWHQ 5DXPVWDWW:HQQGDV6HOEVWYROOHQGVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKNRQVWLWXLHUWLVWXQGKLQWHU VHLQH±EHL/LFKWHEHWUDFKWHWVWHWVGXUFKEHUNRPPHQH:HUWYRUVWHOOXQJHQJH SUlJWHQ±.RQVWLWXWLRQVEHGLQJXQJHQQLFKW]XUFNJHKHQYHUPDJEOHLEWIUDJOLFK ZLHHVGDQQYRQLKQHQDEVHKHQN|QQHQVROOÄ2WKHUORFLRWKHUXQLYHUVDOL]DWL RQV³ ZlUH GLH UHODWLYLVWLVFKH )ROJHUXQJ GLH PDQ PLW 6DFNV GDUDXV ]LHKHQ PVVWH $QGHUHUVHLWVXQGGLHVLVWDQGLHVHU6WHOOHEHVRQGHUVYLUXOHQWJHKW+DEHUPDV± XQGPLWLKP+RQQHWK±GDYRQDXVGDVVYHUJHVHOOVFKDIWHWH6XEMHNWHQXUÄFHUWDLQ SDWWHUQ>V@RIUHDFWLRQ³ DQGHQ7DJOHJHQYRUDOOHP JDUQLFKWXPKLQN|QQHQ GLH$QHUNHQQXQJLKUHUVHOEVW]XHUZDUWHQÄ%XWWKRVHSDWWHUQVRIUHDFWLRQDUH >«@FRQWLQJHQWRQWKHLQGLYLGXDO>«@PDNHXS³ VWHOOW6DFNVKHUDXVLQ%H]XJ ZRUDXIPDQJHUDGHLQSOXUDOLVWLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWHQPLWHLQHUJURHQ9DULDQ] UHFKQHQPXVV:LUGGLHVDXVJHEOHQGHWJHODQJHQHLJHQWOLFKQXUÄORFDOO\YDOLG XQLYHUVDOL]DWLRQV³ LQGHQ6WDWXVGHV8QLYHUVHOOHQXQGLQWHUVXEMHNWLY9HUELQGOL FKHQ$OVOHW]WH%DVWLRQJHJHQVROFKHXQJHSUIWHQ9HUDEVROXWLHUXQJVYHUVXFKH HUVFKHLQW6DFNVXQG:KLWHERRNGDV]XDXWRQRPHQ(LQVLFKWHQIlKLJHXQGGDULQ ZLGHUVWlQGLJH6XEMHNW±RGHUZLHPDQDXFKVDJHQN|QQWH GDV*HZLVVHQÄ,IWKH VHOI>«@LVDQLQWHUVXEMHFWLYHFRQVWUXFWDOOWKHZD\GRZQ³ODXWHWKLQJHJHQGHU 8PNHKUVFKOXVVÄWKHLQGLYLGXDOFDQQRWWUDQVFHQGKLVRUKHUVRFLRKLVWRULFDOVHW WLQJ³(VZlUHGDQQGHQ$QVSUFKHQVHLQHVVR]LRKLVWRULVFKHQ.RQWH[WHVHEHQ VRDXVJHOLHIHUWZLHGLHVHUDEVROXWJHVHW]WZUGHhEULJEOLHEHZLH:KLWHERRN HLQVFKlUIWÄOHGLJOLFKHLQJODWWODXIHQGHU)XQNWLRQDOLVPXVPLWVHLQHQNRQIRUPLV WLVFKHQ,PSOLNDWLRQHQ³ ,QVHLQHU(UZLGHUXQJDXI:KLWHERRNYHUZHKUWVLFK+RQQHWKJHJHQGHVVHQ 9RUZUIHXQGVWHOOWKHUDXV 'LHÄVHLW'HZH\XQG0HDGVHLW:LWWJHQVWHLQXQG +DEHUPDV³XQEH]ZHLIHOEDUH7KHVHGDVVGDVÄLQGLYLGXHOOH6XEMHNW³HLQ,QWHUDN WLRQVSURGXNWVHLEHVDJHQLFKWGDVVHVÄQXUDXVGHPEHVWHKWZDVHVDQhEHU]HX JXQJHQ:QVFKHQXQG$EVLFKWHQGXUFKGLHhEHUQDKPHGHU3HUVSHNWLYHGHV
6$&.6 $D2 (EG (EG (EG (EG $D2 :+,7(%22.
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
,QWHUDNWLRQVSDUWQHUVJHOHUQWKDW³:DVVLHDOOHUGLQJVEHVDJWVRIKUW+RQQHWK ZHLWHUDXVLVWGLH$EKlQJLJNHLWMHGZHGHQDXVGUFNOLFKHQ%H]XJVDXIVLFKVHOEVW YRQGHUVSUDFKOLFKYHUPLWWHOWHQVR]LDOHQ)UHPGSHUVSHNWLYHÄ>1@XUDOV+LQZHLV DXI HLQHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHQ 6DFKYHUKDOW³ ZLOO HU JHOWHQ ODVVHQ ZDV :KLWHERRN XQWHU9HUZHLVDXI+HQULFKXQG6DFNVGHP6XEMHNWDQQLFKWVR]LDOLVLHUEDUHP (LJHQVHLQ]XHUNHQQW DOV+LQZHLVDXIGLHVR]LDOLVDWRULVFKHUZRUEHQH)lKLJNHLW ]XUVHOEVWEHZXVVWHQ$UWLNXODWLRQLQGLYLGXHOOHLJHQHUhEHU]HXJXQJHQ:QVFKHQ XQG$EVLFKWHQ'LHVDEHULVWVR+RQQHWKEHUKDXSWQXUP|JOLFKÄLP0HGLXP HLQHVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYJHWHLOWHQDOOJHPHLQHQ9RNDEXODUV³GHVVHQPDQVLFK]X EHGLHQHQOHUQWXPDOOHUHUVWLQGLYLGXHOOHV6XEMHNW]XZHUGHQ$OVHLQHSRWHQ]LHOO NULWLVFKH,QVWDQ]GLHVLFKYRQGHPZDVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYJHWHLOWZLUGXQGDOOJH PHLQJLOWLPPHUDXFKQRFKHLQPDOXQWHUVFKHLGHQNDQQZHLOVLHGDYRQJUXQG VlW]OLFKXQWHUVFKLHGHQLVWZLUGHVDEHUVROHW]WHQ(QGHVQHJLHUW %HVWlWLJXQJILQGHWGLHVH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQLQGHU$UWXQG:HLVHZLH+RQQHWKLQ VHLQHUSXEOL]LHUWHQ,GHHQJHVFKLFKWHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGDV3KlQRPHQGHV *HZLVVHQVGDVWUDGLWLRQHOOIUGLHYRQ6DFNVWDUNJHPDFKWHLQGLYLGXHOOH.ULWLN LQVWDQ]VWHKWLQGHQ%OLFNQLPPW$QGHUEHWUHIIHQGHQ6WHOOHJHKWHVXPGLHLQ VHLQHQ$XJHQVWDUNHÄ'HXWXQJVNUDIW³GHUÄ7KHRULH>$GDP@6PLWKµIUGLH(UNOl UXQJGHU%LOGXQJPRUDOLVFKHU*HZRKQKHLWHQ³'LHVHPDFKWHUGDUDQIHVWGDVV VLH PLW GHU 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHUVXN]HVVLYHQ 9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJ GHU LQQHUHQ .RQWUROOLQVWDQ] UHFKQHW GLH ELV ]XU QDKH]X YROOVWlQGLJHQ $XVO|VFKXQJ DOOHU SHUV|QOLFKHQ %HYRU]XJXQJHQ UHLFKHQN|QQHQVROO>«@>'@HU:HJDXIGHPGDV6PLWK]XIROJHP|JOLFKVHLQVROOLVWGHU HLQHUDOOPlKOLFKHQ9HUODJHUXQJGHU3HUVSHNWLYHGHU=ZHLWHQ3HUVRQLQGDVHLJHQH6HOEVWZR GLHVHGDQQDOV*HZLVVHQPHLQ9HUKDOWHQGDUDXIKLQNRQWUROOLHUWREHVPLWGHQVR]LDOHQ(UZDU WXQJHQHLQHULPPHUXPIDQJUHLFKHUZHUGHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWYHUHLQEDULVW
'DPLWVLHKW+RQQHWKGLH)UDJHJHO|VWZLHVLFKGLHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKÄHWDEOLHUWHQ 1RUPHQLQDOOWlJOLFKH+DQGOXQJVJHZRKQKHLWHQ>«@YHUZDQGHOQ³ 6RQlPOLFK GDVV±0HDGVÃ0HµLVWKLHUQLFKWZHLW±GDVÄLQGLYLGXHOOH*HZLVVHQ³DOVLQQHU SV\FKLVFKH5HSUlVHQWDQ]GHUÄPRUDOLVFKHQ5HDNWLRQVKDOWXQJHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU *UXSSHQXQGLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHU.UHLVH³IXQJLHUW$XIGLHVHNRQIRUPLWlWVVWLIWHQGH )XQNWLRQDEHUEOHLEWHVGDPLWVFKOLHOLFKDXFKUHGX]LHUWZDVVLFKDXFKGHXWOLFK LQ+RQQHWKV]ZHLWHP+DXSWZHUN'DV5HFKWGHU)UHLKHLWQLHGHUVFKOlJW'DUDXI LVWQXQQRFKHLQ]XJHKHQZREHLGLH3KLORVRSKLQ%HDWH5|VVOHUKLQ]XJHKROWZLUG
+211(7+I 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2 I $D2 $D2 'HQ+LQZHLVGDUDXIYHUGDQNHLFKGHU5H]HQVLRQ&KULVWRSK7U|ELQJHUV9JO]XP)RO JHQGHQ75g%,1*(5 IXQG+211(7+II +211(7+ (EG $D2I
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
GLH+RQQHWKVGRUWLJHbXHUXQJHQ]XHQWVFKLHGHQHP:LGHUVSUXFKKHUDXVJHIRU GHUWKDEHQ
6R]LDOH%HGLQJXQJHQGHU$XWRQRPLH"±%HDWH5|VVOHUV.ULWLN DQ+RQQHWK Ä,I\RXZDQWWRKDYHWKHFDNHRI>«@LQGLYLGXDODXWRQRP\>«@WKHQ\RXFDQQRW DOVRHDWLWE\JUDQWLQJWKHVRFLDOLQVWLWXWLRQVRIDJLYHQSHULRGQRUPDWLYHSULRULW\ RYHUPRUDOIUHHGRP³ 0LWGLHVHQ:RUWHQZHLVW%HDWH5|VVOHUDXIHLQHQHNOD WDQWHQ:LGHUVSUXFKKLQGHQVLHLQ+RQQHWKV6WXGLH'DV5HFKWGHU)UHLKHLWDXV ILQGLJPDFKW'RUWZLUGGHPQDFKHLQHUVHLWV]XJXQVWHQGHU$XWRQRPLHE]ZPR UDOLVFKHQ)UHLKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVDUJXPHQWLHUWDQGHUHUVHLWVDEHUGHQVR]LDOHQ,QVWL WXWLRQHQHLQQRUPDWLYHU9RUUDQJJHJHQEHUMHGZHGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ(LJHQDNWLYL WlW ]XJHZLHVHQ 'DV DEHU LVW LQ LKUHQ $XJHQ HLQH VFKOHFKWKLQ XQYHUGDXOLFKH .RPELQDWLRQGHQQ Ä>0@RUDOIUHHGRPKDVWRNHHSLWVSULRULW\RYHUH[LVWLQJVR FLDOFRQWH[WVDQGLQVWLWXWLRQVVLQFHRWKHUZLVHLWZRXOGQRWEHZKDWLWLVVXSSRVHG WREH LQGLYLGXDOIUHHGRP³5|VVOHUV*HZlKUVPDQQIUGLHVHV%HKDUUHQDXI GHPSULRULWlUHQ&KDUDNWHULQGLYLGXHOOHU)UHLKHLWJHJHQEHUGHQVR]LDOHQ.RQWH[ WHQXQG,QVWLWXWLRQHQLQQHUKDOEGHUHUVLHSUDNWL]LHUWZLUGLVW,PPDQXHO.DQW 6HLQ$XWRQRPLHEHJULIIGHQ+RQQHWKLP$XVJDQJYRQ+HJHODOVÄYROONRPPHQ PRQRORJLVFK³XQGÄELQGXQJVORV³EUDQGPDUNWHUVFKHLQWLKUXQYHU]LFKWEDU± MHGHQIDOOV ZHQQGDV6XEMHNWGD]XIlKLJVHLQVROO ÄWRSXWVRFLDODQGSROLWLFDO FRQGLWLRQVLQWRTXHVWLRQ³ 'HP(LQ]HOQHQHLQVROFKHV9HUP|JHQ]XUNULWLVFKHQ'LVWDQ]QDKPHHLQ]X UlXPHQLVWRIIHQVLFKWOLFKDXFK+RQQHWKV%HVWUHEHQ6RVSULFKWHULQ'DV5HFKW GHU)UHLKHLWHWZDYRQGHUVSH]LILVFKPRGHUQHQÄ,QVWLWXWLRQGHUÃ*HZLVVHQVSU IXQJµ³GLHÄGHQ6XEMHNWHQGLHVWDDWOLFKYHUEUJWH&KDQFH³HU|IIQHÄJHJHEHQHQ IDOOVDXI'LVWDQ]]XDOOGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ]XJHKHQGHQHQVLHLKUH VR]LDOH)UHLKHLWYHUGDQNHQ³6LHVROOHQGXUFKGLHGDULQVLFKQLHGHUVFKODJHQGH Ä$QHUNHQQXQJ LKUHU Ã0RUDOLWlWµ >«@ LQ GLH /DJH YHUVHW]W ZHUGHQ JHJHQ GLH KHUUVFKHQGH2UGQXQJLKUHUHIOH[LYJHZRQQHQHQhEHU]HXJXQJHQJHOWHQG]XPD
5g66/(59JOQHEHQGLHVHP7H[WLP)ROJHQGHQDXFKLKUH$XVIKUXQJHQ]X +RQQHWKLQ GLHV II$OOHUGLQJVLVWGLHNULWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHGHVSXEOL]LHUWHQ 7H[WHVLQGHUOHW]WJHQDQQWHQ0RQRJUDSKLHRIIHQVLFKWOLFKHWZDVDEJHVFKZlFKWZRUGHQZHVKDOE LFK5|VVOHUV$UJXPHQWDWLRQLP)ROJHQGHQYRQGHUIUKHUHQ9HUVLRQDXVHQWIDOWH 5g66/(5 +211(7+ $D2 5g66/(5 +211(7+ I9JO]XPDXI.DQWJHPQ]WHQ%HJULIIGHUUHIOH[LYHQE]ZPRUD OLVFKHQ)UHLKHLWLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2±±
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
FKHQ³'RFKGDV*HOWHQGPDFKHQLQGLYLGXHOOHU*HZLVVHQVEHU]HXJXQJHQVR +RQQHWKZHLWHUNDQQÄQXUVRZHLW]XJHODVVHQ³VHLQZLHLP=XJHGHVVHQÄGDV LQVWLWXWLRQHOOH*HIJHGHUHLJHQWOLFKHQGHUVR]LDOHQ)UHLKHLWQLFKWJHIlKUGH>W@³ ZLUG'HQ*HGDQNHQGLHVHUÃHLJHQWOLFKHQµÃVR]LDOHQ)UHLKHLWµGXUFKGHUHQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQJHIJHGHPQDFKGLHEORVHNXQGlUHPRUDOLVFKH$XWRQRPLHEHGLQJW XQGEHJUHQ]WZLUGIKUWHUDXI+HJHO]XUFN'DEHLXQWHUVWUHLFKWHULQVEHVRQGH UHGDVVGDVKHJHOVFKH)UHLKHLWVNRQ]HSWDXVGUFNOLFKHLQHQWLHIJUHLIHQGHQ0DQ JHOLQQHUKDOEGHUNDQWLVFKHQ)UHLKHLWVNRQ]HSWLRQ]XEHUZLQGHQWUDFKWH 1LFKW QXU GLH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ $EVLFKWHQ VROOHQ GHP 0DVWDE JHQJHQ LKUHUVHLWV RKQH MHGH )UHPGHLQZLUNXQJ]XVWDQGHJHNRPPHQ]XVHLQVRQGHUQDXFKGLHlXHUHVR]LDOH5HDOLWlWVROO VRYRUJHVWHOOWZHUGHQN|QQHGDVLHIUHLYRQDOOHU+HWHURQRPLHXQGMHGHP=ZDQJLVW
'LHVDEHUVROLHVWHV+RQQHWKEHL+HJHOLVWHEHQGDQQGHU)DOOZHQQGLHVR]LDOH 5HDOLWlWDOVHLQ%QGHOYRQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQEHJULIIHQZLUGLQGHQHQGLH6XEMHNWH GXUFKZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHVRPLWHLQDQGHUYHUEXQGHQVLQG GDVVVLHVLFKGXFKGHQMHZHLOV$QGHUHQKLQVLFKWOLFKLKUHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ$EVLFK WHQEHVWlWLJWZLVVHQN|QQHQ:lKUHQG$XWRQRPLHEHL.DQWDOVÄ/HLVWXQJHLQHV HLQVDPHQDXIVLFKVHOEVWEH]RJHQHQ6XEMHNWV³HUVFKHLQHGHFNH+HJHOLKUH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQE]ZJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ(UP|JOLFKXQJVXQG5HDOLVLHUXQJVEH GLQJXQJHQDXI3HU*HZLVVHQVSUIXQJÄEHVWLPPWH+DQGOXQJV]XPXWXQJHQXQWHU 9HUZHLVDXIUHFKWIHUWLJHQGH*UQGHDE]XOHKQHQ³±GDVYHUKlOWVLFKZLH+RQ QHWKNODUVWHOOWGHPQDFKVWHWVÄSDUDVLWlUJHJHQEHUHLQHUVR]LDOHQ/HEHQVSUD[LV³ GLHVROFKHQ6HOEVWYROO]JHQÄQLFKWQXULPPHUVFKRQYRUDXVJHKWVRQGHUQGHUVLH EHUKDXSWHUVWLKUHLJHQWOLFKHV([LVWHQ]UHFKW³YHUGDQNHQ 0LWGLHVHU7KHVH ZLOOHU]XQlFKVWHLQPDOKHUDXVVWHOOHQGDVVGLHEORH0|JOLFKNHLWLQVÄUHIOH[L YH>@0RUDWRULXPGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ6HOEVWJHVHW]JHEXQJ³HLQ]XWUHWHQLQGHPWZD ]XEHVWLPPWHQ5ROOHQHUZDUWXQJHQDXINULWLVFKH'LVWDQ]JHJDQJHQZLUGKLVWR ULVFKEHWUDFKWHWGDV5HVXOWDWHLQHU(PDQ]LSDWLRQGHU6XEMHNWHGXUFKLKUH$QHU NHQQXQJDOVVHOEVWEHVWLPPWH$NWHXUHGDUVWHOOW'DULQOLHJWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQHLQH GLUHNWH)ROJHZLUNXQJGHUNDQWLVFKHQ.RQ]HSWLRQ 'HU(LQ]HOQH]XYRUQRFKDXIJUXQGGHUKHUUVFKHQGHQ0RUDODXIIDVVXQJDQGLHNRQNUHWH6LWW OLFKNHLWVHLQHU/HEHQVZHOWJHEXQGHQZLUGPLWGHU*HGDQNHQILJXUGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ6HOEVWJH VHW]JHEXQJLP1DPHQGHU)UHLKHLWGD]XHUPlFKWLJWVLFKLQHLQH3HUVSHNWLYH]XYHUVHW]HQDXV
$D2 $D2 9JO]XP %HJULII GHU VR]LDOHQ )UHLKHLW LQVJHVDPW XQG]XP )ROJHQGHQ DD2± ±(UEH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLLQVEHVRQGHUHDXIGLH(LQOHLWXQJVSDUDJUDIHQGHU 5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLH $D2 $D2 $D2 $D2
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
GHUKHUDXVHUVRZRKONULWLVFKJHJHQEHVWHKHQGH1RUPHQRSSRQLHUHQDOVDXFKNRQVWUXNWLYIU QHXH1RUPV\VWHPHHLQWUHWHQNDQQ
0LWKLQZLUGHEHQGLHVHU(LQ]HOQH]XU(LQQDKPHHLQHUVROFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHDEHUMH NRQNUHWEHUKDXSWQXUHUPlFKWLJWLQGHPHUSHU6R]LDOLVDWLRQLQGDVGDIUDXV VFKODJJHEHQGH6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVHLQHVPRUDOLVFKHQ6XEMHNWVYHUVHW]WZLUGZDV IU+RQQHWKGDV5HVXOWDWDQHUNHQQHQGHU=XUHFKQXQJLVW$XIJUXQGGHVVHQZHL HLQ0HQVFKGDVVHUÄ>G@DV5HFKW³KDWÄVLFKLQPRUDOLVFKUHOHYDQWHQ.RQIOLNWHQ DXI VHLQ Ã*HZLVVHQµ ]X EHUXIHQ³ 3DUDVLWlU LVW HLQ VROFKHV 6LFKEHUXIHQ DXI HLJHQH*HZLVVHQVHLQVLFKWHQGLHQDFKNDQWLVFKHUhEHU]HXJXQJLP1DPHQGHV $OOJHPHLQHQHUIROJWIU+RQQHWKGHVKDOEZHLOGDULQVRJHWDQZLUGDOVN|QQH PDQÄGXUFKUHIOH[LYH'LVWDQ]LHUXQJYRQDOOHQJHJHEHQHQ1RUPHQHLQH3HUVSHN WLYHHUUHLFKHQXQWHUGHUYROONRPPHQELQGXQJVORVXQGLQGHP6LQQXQSDUWHLOLFK EHUGLH9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJVIlKLJNHLWYRQPRUDOLVFKHQ*UXQGVlW]HQ³]XEH ILQGHQ ZlUH 'DVV GLHVHU QHXWUDOH XQG XQYRUHLQJHQRPPHQH 6WDQGSXQNW HLQH Ä)LNWLRQ³GDUVWHOOWÄXQYHUPHLGOLFKDEHUJOHLFKZRKO6FKHLQ³LVW]HLJWVLFKIU +RQQHWKGDUDQGDVVVLFKGLH$NWHXUHÄQLFKW>«@YRQGHQLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ$UUDQ JHPHQWV³ O|VHQ N|QQHQ ÄLQ GLH VLH MHZHLOV HLQJHODVVHQ VLQG³ 6LH ZUGHQ XQZHLJHUOLFK ÄDXI QRUPDWLYH 5HJHOQ VWRHQ YRQ GHQHQ VLH VLFK QLFKW ZHLWHU ORVO|VHQN|QQHQZHLOVLHVLHIUGHQ,QEHJULIILKUHUVR]LDOHQ/HEHQVZHOWKDOWHQ PVVHQ³ *HJHQGHQ+RQQHWKV$XVIKUXQJHQ]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGHQ9RUZXUIGLHÄNDQWL VFKH PRUDOLVFKH )UHLKHLW³ N|QQH ÄVFKRQ EHJULIIOLFK QLFKW EHU LKUH VR]LDOHQ *UXQGODJHQXQG(UP|JOLFKXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQLKUH9HUZXU]HOXQJLQGHU6LWWOLFK NHLWUHIOHNWLHUHQ³EH]LHKW5|VVOHUDXVGUFNOLFK6WHOOXQJ6LHPDFKWGHXWOLFK GDVVJHQDXGDV*HJHQWHLOGHU)DOOLVW'HQQGHUDXIGLH9HUDOOJHPHLQHUEDUNHLW KDQGOXQJVOHLWHQGHU0D[LPHQGUlQJHQGH.DWHJRULVFKH,PSHUDWLYLPSOL]LHUWJHUD GHQLFKWGDV=HUUELOGHLQHVLQHLQVDPHU6HOEVWSUIXQJHLQJHVFKORVVHQHQ(LQ]HO QHQ'HVVHQ]ZHLWHU)RUPXOLHUXQJLQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJ]XU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LW WHQ GLH GLH XQEHGLQJWH $FKWXQJVZUGLJNHLW GHV VHOEVW]ZHFNKDIWHQ 6XEMHNWV EHVFKZ|UW IJW .DQW QlPOLFK HUOlXWHUQG KLQ]X Ä'HQQ GDV 6XEMHNW ZHOFKHV =ZHFNDQVLFKVHOEVWLVWGHVVHQ=ZHFNHPVVHQZHQQMHQH9RUVWHOOXQJEHLPLU DOOH:LUNXQJWXQVROODXFKVRYLHOP|JOLFKPHLQH=ZHFNHVHLQ³ 'LHVVHW]WHUVWHQVYRUDXVZLH5|VVOHUGDUOHJWGDVVGHU(LQ]HOQH7HLOHLQHUVR ]LDOHQ:HOWLVWLQGHULKPHLQH9LHO]DKOVXEMHNWLYHU=ZHFNVHW]XQJHQEHJHJQHQ
$D2 $D2 $D2 $D2 (EG (EG 5g66/(5 9JO]XPIROJHQGHQ HEGXQG',(6 .$17 D>%$ @
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GLHHUEHLGHU0D[LPHQZDKOHUQVW]XQHKPHQXQG]XEHUFNVLFKWLJHQKDW=ZHL WHQVZLUGZHQQGHQQGLH=ZHFNHGHV$QGHUHQEHUKDXSWPHLQHVROOHQVHLQN|Q QHQDXFKEHL.DQWYRQHLQHUOHEHQVZHOWOLFKMHGHQIDOOVQLFKWIHUQOLHJHQGHQhEHU HLQVWLPPXQJ LQ PRUDOLVFKHU +LQVLFKW DXVJHJDQJHQ Ä0RUDOLWlW³ VR VFKUHLEW 5|VVOHU+RQQHWKV)RUPXOLHUXQJGHXWOLFKZLGHUVSUHFKHQGÄLVWEHL.DQWGHVKDOE QLFKWSDUDVLWlUJHJHQEHUGHUVR]LDOHQ:HOWVRQGHUQLVWYLHOPHKULKURUJDQLVLH UHQGHV3ULQ]LS³ ZHLOVLHGLH3IOLFKWHQWKlOWGDVJHPHLQVDP*HWHLOWH±RGHUZLH HVEHL.DQWKHLW ÄHLQH>«@SRVLWLYHhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ]XU0HQVFKKHLW³±]X VXFKHQ'RFKZHLOVLHDXIGDVPRUDOLVFK$OOJHPHLQH]LHOWPXVVÄ$XWRQRPLH >«@ VLFK DXV >GHQ@ EHVWLPPWHQ VR]LDOHQ .RQWH[WHQ EHIUHLHQ VLFK YRQ LKQHQ HPDQ]LSLHUHQ>«@N|QQHQ³XQGGDUIÄLQGLYLGXHOOH)UHLKHLW>«@QLFKWDXILKUH VR]LDOHQ%HGLQJXQJHQUHGX]LHUWZHUGHQ³ *HQDXGDVDEHUJHVFKLHKWLP)DOOHYRQ+RQQHWKVDQ+HJHODQVFKOLHHQGHU GH]LGLHUWVR]LDOHU)UHLKHLWNRQ]HSWLRQDQKDQGGHUHUHUQLFKW]XOHW]WDXFKÄGLH *UHQ]HQGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ)UHLKHLW³LP6LQQH.DQWVYRU$XJHQIKUHQP|FKWH 0LWKLQJHKWHVLKPGDUXPGLHPLWGHP(LQUHLHQGLHVHU*UHQ]HQYHUEXQGHQHQ *HIDKUHQ]XYHUGHXWOLFKHQ1RFKHLQPDOVHLEHWRQWGDVV+RQQHWK]XIROJHÄGLH NXOWXUHOOYHUDQNHUWH9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ)UHLKHLW>«@HLQHQOHJLWLPHQ 3ODW]LPLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ1HW]ZHUNKRFKHQWZLFNHOWHU*HVHOOVFKDIWHQ³HLQQLPPW JHUDGHÄZHLOVLH³ZLHHUEHJUQGHQGKLQ]XIJWÄHLQHVXEMHNWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJ DQHUNHQQWDXIGLHVLFKMHGHV,QGLYLGXXPEHLGHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQVR]LDOHQ 5ROOHQ]XPXWXQJHQ XQG +DQGOXQJVYHUSIOLFKWXQJHQ EHJUQGHW ]XUFN]LHKHQ GDUI³3UREOHPDWLVFKZLUGHVDXVVHLQHU6LFKWDEHUGDQQZHQQGLHVH'LVWDQ] QDKPHDXIHLQHVRUDGLNDOH:HLVHHUIROJWZLHHUVLHLQÄ.DQWV.RQVWUXNWLRQGHV PRUDOLVFKHQ6WDQGSXQNWV³YHUODQJWILQGHW 1LFKWQXULVWPDQGHPQDFKQlPOLFK EHLGHU6XFKHQDFKGHUUHFKWHQ+DQGOXQJVPD[LPHYHUSIOLFKWHWÄVLFKLQGLH3HUV SHNWLYHQDOOHUSRWHQWLHOO%HWURIIHQHQ]XYHUVHW]HQ³LQGHPPDQYRQGHUÄXUV SUQJOLFKHQ3DUWHLQDKPHIUHLQ]HOQHYRQLKQHQDEVLHKW³0HKUQRFKVROOHQ ZLUQDFK.DQWÄDXFKYRPVR]LDOHQ%HGHXWXQJVJHKDOWGHU%H]LHKXQJHQ³DEVHKHQ ÄLQGHQHQZLUXQVLPPHUVFKRQEHILQGHQ³MDÄLJQRULHUHQ>«@ZDVHVEHUKDXSW KHLWHLQHGHUDUWLJH%LQGXQJ]XSIOHJHQXQG]XXQWHUKDOWHQ³ =XU,OOXVWUDWLRQIKUW+RQQHWKHLQ%HLVSLHODXVGHUDNDGHPLVFKHQ/HEHQVZHOW DQ (LQ+RFKVFKXOOHKUHUHQWGHFNWHLQ3ODJLDWLP7H[WHLQHVEHIUHXQGHWHQ.ROOH JHQXQGULQJWPLWVLFKVHOEVWXPGLHULFKWLJH5HDNWLRQ1DFK.DQWVR+RQQHWK PVVWHHUQLFKWQXUGDUEHUQDFKVLQQHQZLHVLFKGHU)DOODXV6LFKWDOOHU%HWURI
5g66/(5 +HUYRUKG9HUI .$17 D>%$ @ 5g66/(5 +211(7+ $D2 $D2 $D2 $D2I9JOIUGDVIROJHQGH%HLVSLHO DD2II
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
IHQHQGDUVWHOOWVRQGHUQÄDXFKYRQGHQEHUHLWVH[LVWLHUHQGHQ1RUPHQGHU)UHXQG VFKDIWRGHUGHU.ROOHJLDOLWlW³DEVHKHQ'RFKNDQQGHUÄ+RFKVFKXOOHKUHU>«@ LQVHLQHQhEHUOHJXQJHQ³EHKDXSWHW+RQQHWKÄQLFKWHLQIDFKYRQGHQLPSOL]LWHQ 1RUPHQVROFKHU%H]LHKXQJVPXVWHUDEVWUDKLHUHQ³GHQHQHUÄLQGHU5ROOHGHV )UHXQGHVRGHUGHV.ROOHJHQ³OlQJVWYHUSIOLFKWHWLVWhEHUKDXSWIUDJWPDQQDFK GHPLQ+DQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQPRUDOLVFK*HERWHQHQÄQLFKWDOVEH]LHKXQJVORVHV XQVLWXLHUWHV :HVHQ VRQGHUQDOV 0XWWHU .ROOHJH RGHU )UHXQG³ ZDV GLH (QW VFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJÄYRUJlQJLJ>@³ELQGH (EHQVRJLOWIUGHQÄ)DOOGHUPRUDOL VFKHQ,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJYRQ=XPXWXQJHQGLHXQVXQEHJUQGHWHUVFKHLQHQ³GDVV GDEHLÄGLHVHVR]LDOH[LVWLHUHQGHQ+DQGOXQJVYHUSIOLFKWXQJHQ>«@GHQQRUPDWLYHQ .RQWH[W³ELOGHQ :LUGGLHYRUJlQJLJHQRUPDWLYH*HEXQGHQKHLWHLQJHNODPPHUWÄHQWVWHKWGLH )LNWLRQHLQHV XQYHUEXQGHQHQ6XEMHNWV ZHOFKHVDOOVHLQH *UXQGVlW]HDXVGHU DEVWUDNWHQ3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHUDOOJHPHLQHQ0HQVFKKHLWJHZLQQHQPX³)U +RQQHWKVWHOOWGLHVHLQHSDWKRORJLVFK]XQHQQHQGH*UHQ]EHUVFKUHLWXQJPRUDOL VFKHU)UHLKHLWGDUSDWKRORJLVFKZHLOGDV6XEMHNWVRHLQHU)HKOGHXWXQJYHUIlOOW GLHHVYRQVHLQHUIXQGDPHQWDOHQ(LQJHEXQGHQKHLWLQVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVYHU KlOWQLVVHJlQ]OLFKGLVWDQ]LHUW'LHVIKUWZLHHUPLWGUDVWLVFKHQ:RUWHQIRUPX OLHUW]XUÄ$EVWUHLIXQJDOOHUSHUV|QOLFKHQ,GHQWLWlW³]XJXQVWHQHLQHUDQGHUHQXQG VLFKVHOEVWJHJHQEHUHUEDUPXQJVORVHQÄPRUDOLVFKHQ8QEHGLQJWKHLW³2GHUHV HQGHW LQ GHU *HZDOWHVNDODWLRQ HLQHV ÄPRUDOLVFK PRWLYLHUWH>Q@ 7HUURULVPXV³ KLQWHUGHVVHQYHUPHLQWOLFKGHP*XWHQGLHQHQGHQ=LHOHQÄDOOH>@H[LVWLHUHQGHQ +DQGOXQJVUHJHOQ³YHUVFKZLQGHQ'HU*UXQGIHKOHUPRUDOLVFKHU)UHLKHLWDEHU EHVWHKWIU+RQQHWKLQGHU$XVEOHQGXQJGHU7DWVDFKHGDVVHLQMHGHUÄYRUJlQJLJ EHL GHU %HVWLPPXQJ VHLQHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQGVlW]H DQ GLH EHUHLWV H[LVWLHUHQGH 0RUDOLWlWVHLQHU*HVHOOVFKDIWJHEXQGHQLVW³GLHÄIUGHQHLQ]HOQHQXQYHUIJ EDUH*HOWXQJVNUDIWEHVLW]>W@³ 9RUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGVWHOOHQ9ROO]JHPRUDOLVFKHU)UHLKHLWÄLKUHUPRGDOHQ 9HUIDWKHLWQDFKQXUÃ0|JOLFKNHLWHQµGHU)UHLKHLWGDU VLHGLHQHQGHU'LVWDQ]LH UXQJhEHUSUIXQJRGHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQJHJHEHQHQ,QWHUDNWLRQVYHUKlOWQLV VHQELOGHQDEHUVHOEVWQLFKWHLQHVROFKHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYJHWHLOWH:LUNOLFKNHLWLQ
$D2 $D2 $D2 $D2 (EG $D29JOLQVJHVDPW]XUGDPLWDQJHVSURFKHQHQSDWKRORJLVFKHQ(UVFKHLQXQJGHV ÄXQYHUEXQGHQHQ0RUDOLVWHQ³ DD2± $D29JOLQVJHVDPW]XUGDPLWDQJHVSURFKHQHQSDWKRORJLVFKHQ(UVFKHLQXQJGHV ÄPRUDOLVFKHQ7HUURULVPXV³ DD2± $D2 $D2
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
QHUKDOEGHUVR]LDOHQ:HOWDXV³Ä(LQVROFKH:LUNOLFKNHLWGHU)UHLKHLW³VLHKW +RQQHWKYLHOPHKUÄHUVWGRUWJHJHEHQZR6XEMHNWHVLFKLQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHU NHQQXQJ GHUDUW EHJHJQHQ GD VLH LKUH +DQGOXQJVYROO]JH MHZHLOV DOV (UIO OXQJVEHGLQJXQJGHU+DQGOXQJV]LHOHGHV*HJHQEHUVEHJUHLIHQN|QQHQ³+lOW PDQ KLQJHJHQ ÄGLH EORH Ã0|JOLFKNHLWµ GHU )UHLKHLW VFKRQ IU GHUHQ JDQ]H Ã:LUNOLFKNHLWµ³ZLUGHVHEHQSDWKRORJLVFK 5|VVOHUZHLVW+RQQHWKV9RUZXUIÄ.DQWLVFKH)UHLKHLWEHGHXWH>«@GDVVZLU XQVLPPHUXQGMHGHU]HLWIUHLPDFKHQN|QQHQXQGDXFKIUHLPDFKHQPVVHQYRQ >«@VR]LDOHQ%LQGXQJHQ ZLH)UHXQGVFKDIW ZHQQZLUDOVPRUDOLVFKH$NWHXUH KDQGHOQ³ ]XQlFKVWVR]XUFNGDVVVLHHLQHSDVVHQGH3DVVDJHDXVGHU0HWD SK\VLNGHU6LWWHQDQIKUWÄ0RUDOLVFKHUZRJHQ³VFKUHLEW.DQWGRUWÄLVWHVIUHL OLFK3IOLFKWGDHLQ)UHXQGGHPDQGHUHQVHLQH)HKOHUEHPHUNOLFKPDFKH GHQQ GDVJHVFKLHKWMD]XVHLQHP%HVWHQXQGHVLVWDOVR/LHEHVSIOLFKW³.HLQHVZHJV IROJHUW5|VVOHUYHUODQJWGLH2ULHQWLHUXQJDP.DWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYDOVRHLQH /RVO|VXQJYRQVR]LDOHQ%LQGXQJHQ9LHOPHKUVROOHQÄZLUXQVDXFKLQ)UHXQG VFKDIWHQ P|JOLFKVW DQPRUDOLVFKH5HJHOQKDOWHQXQGLP.RQIOLNWIDOO]XPLQGHVW GHQ.RQIOLNWDOVVROFKHQHUNHQQHQXQGEHQHQQHQ³'HPJHJHQEHUVFKHLQW +RQQHWKV$OWHUQDWLYSRVLWLRQDEHUGDUDXIKLQDXV]XODXIHQGHQ.RQIOLNW]ZLVFKHQ PRUDOLVFKHUXQGEH]LHKXQJVE]ZUROOHQVSH]LILVFKHU9HUSIOLFKWXQJ]XJXQVWHQ GHU /HW]WHUHQ DXI]XO|VHQ Ä+RQQHWK VHHPV WR DUJXH³ VFKUHLEW 5|VVOHU ÄWKDW VRFLDOIUHHGRPDQGWKHVRFLDOOLIHH[SUHVVHGLQH[LVWLQJVRFLDOLQVWLWXWLRQVKDV SULRULW\RYHUWKHFODLPVRIPRUDODQGOHJDOIUHHGRP³ZlKUHQGMHGZHGHU$Q VSUXFKDXIPRUDOLVFKH)UHLKHLWXQWHU9HUGDFKWVWHKWLQV3DWKRORJLVFKHDE]XUXW VFKHQ >:@LWKUHVSHFWWRLQGLYLGXDOVLWPHDQVWKDWVRFLDOUROHVDUHJXLGLQJRXUOLYHVLQSURYLGLQJXV ZLWKPHDQLQJIXOHQGV>«@VLQFHWKHQRUPVRIVRFLDOLQVWLWXWLRQVLQWKHJXLVHRIDOUHDG\PRUH RUOHVVDFFHSWHGLGHDVDOZD\VGHOLPLWWKHSRVVLELOLWLHV±WKHHQGV±RIPRUDOIUHHGRP
'LHVH5HVWULNWLRQXQG/LPLWLHUXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWVP|JOLFKNHLWHQLP1DPHQGHU VR]LDOHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWGHUHQZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHPLWLKUHQ 5ROOHQHUZDUWXQJHQNODUEHJUHQ]HQZDVVLFKQRFKLP5DKPHQGHV*HERWHQHQ EHZHJWVWHOOWDXV5|VVOHUV6LFKWHLQH8QWHUPLQLHUXQJPRUDOLVFKHU$XWRQRPLH GDU 9LHODXVJHJOLFKHQHUDEHUWURW]GHPHQWVFKLHGHQLVWKLQJHJHQ.DQWV3HUVSHNWL YH
$D2 (EG $D2 5g66/(5 .$17 9JOGD]X 5g66/(5I 5g66/(5 5g66/(5 (EG
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
KHLQVLVWVRQWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQVRFLDOHQDEOLQJFRQGLWLRQVIRULQGLYLGXDODXWRQRP\DQG WKHQHFHVVLW\RIEHLQJDEOHWRSXWVRFLDODQGSROLWLFDOFRQGLWLRQVLQWRTXHVWLRQ>«@,WLVWKH DXWRQRPRXVDJHQWVWKHPVHOYHVZKRKDYHWRVROYHPRUDOHWKLFDOVRFLDODQGUROHUHODWHGSURE OHPV
(QWJHJHQGHU$QQDKPHHLQHUYROOVWlQGLJHQÄÃVR]LDOH>Q@.RQVWLWXWLRQGHV6XE MHNWVµ³YHUZHLVWDXFK7UDXJRWW.RFKDXIÄHLQHQLFKWDXVWLOJEDUHLPPHUQXUDXI KHEEDUHXQG]XJOHLFKDOVQHXHLQJHVHW]W]XEHJUHLIHQGH'XDOLWlWYRQ6XEMHNWXQG VR]LDOHUOHEHQVZHOWOLFKHU%HVWLPPWKHLW³'DEHLVWHKWGDVVFKRQKlXILJHUDQ JHVSURFKHQH*HZLVVHQGDIUGDVVÄGDV6XEMHNW>«@QLHPDOVDXI>JHKW@LQVHLQHU %HVWLPPWKHLW³GXUFKVR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHVRQGHUQÄVLFKLPPHU DXFK]XGLHVHUVHLQHU%HVWLPPWKHLWVHOEVWXQGVR]XVLFKVHOEVW³YHUKlOWE]Z YHUKDOWHQNDQQ'LHVJHVFKLHKWÄLQVHLQHP*HZLVVHQGHU,QVWDQ]GHU6HOEVW UHIOH[LRQVHLQHU%HVWLPPWKHLW³ZRHVVLFKÄLQ8QEHGLQJWKHLWDOVRDEVROXW]X VLFKVHOEVW³YHUKlOW'RUWJHKWHVDXINULWLVFKH'LVWDQ]QLFKWQXU]XPHLJHQHQ 7XQVRQGHUQDXFK]XGHQÃVR]LDOHQ(UZDUWXQJHQGHU*HPHLQVFKDIWµ9RUGLHVHP +LQWHUJUXQGLVWQXQDXFKDXIGLHVHQGULWWHQ'HEDWWHQJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ+RQQHWKXQG :KLWHERRN XQGGHQDQGHUHQ HLQWKHRORJLVFKHU%OLFN]XZHUIHQ
*RWWLQ*HZLVVHQXQG*HPHLQVDPNHLW WKHRORJLVFKH 5HIOH[LRQHQLP$QVFKOXVVDQ7UDXJRWW.RFK ,P5DKPHQHLQHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW+DEHUPDVµSROLWLVFKHU(WKLNZHLVW .RFKDXIHLQH)UDJHKLQGLHEHLGLHVHPXQEHDQWZRUWHWEOHLEW ÄZDVGHQ(LQ]HO QHQ EHUKDXSW NRQVHQVEHUHLW XQG ]XP .RQVHQV IlKLJ VHLQ OlW³ 'DVV GHU 0HQVFKDXILQWHUVXEMHNWLYH9HUVWlQGLJXQJDXVLVWIROJWIU+DEHUPDVVRKDEHQ ZLU JHVHKHQ DXV VHLQHU JDQ] XQG JDU LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ .RQVWLWXWLRQ $XFK LQ +RQQHWKV7KHRULHLVWHVGLHWRWDOHVR]LDOH$ENQIWLJNHLWGHV(LQ]HOQHQGLHLKQ YRQMHKHUQDFK9HUKlOWQLVVHQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$QHUNHQQXQJVWUHEHQOlVVWÄ(U VFKHLQWGDV6XEMHNW]XQlFKVWGXUFKSDUWLNXODULVWLVFKHHLJHQVLQQLJH,QWHUHVVHQ EHVWLPPW³VRPDFKW.RFKGHPHQWJHJHQNODUGDQQEHGHXWHWHLQVROFKHU6FKULWW EHUVLFKKLQDXVÄQLFKWZHQLJHUDOVHLQHQJlQ]OLFKHQ6LQQHVZDQGHO³ $QGHUV DEHU NRPPW HV LQ VHLQHQ $XJHQ EHUKDXSW QLFKW ]XU Ä9HUELQGOLFKNHLW HLQHU 1RUP³DOVGDGXUFKGDVVÄGLH(LQ]HOQHQYRQVLFKDXVGLHVH1RUPLQLKU%HZXW VHLQDXIQHKPHQ³XQGVLFKGXUFKVLHEHVWLPPHQODVVHQÄ'LHVH9HUDQWZRUWXQJ
$D2 .2&+D (EG (EG .2&+O $D2 $D2I
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
NDQQLK>QHQ@NHLQ'LVNXUVXQGNHLQ.RQVHQVDEQHKPHQ³±HEHQVRZHQLJDEHU HLQHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHWDEOLHUWH$QHUNHQQXQJVRUGQXQJLQGLHPDQÄKLQHLQVR]LDOL VLHUW³ZRUGHQLVW0LW.RFKLVWDQGLHVHU6WHOOHYLHOPHKUDXIGHQ9RUUDQJGHV *HZLVVHQV]XLQVLVWLHUHQMHQHULQQHUHQ,QVWDQ]DOVRLQGHUGDV6XEMHNWVHLQHUDXI XQEHGLQJWH:HLVHVHOEVWJHZlUWLJLVWXQGVLFKLQ'LIIHUHQ]]XP$QGHUHQVHW]W,Q QLFKWV DQGHUHP ÄNRQ]HQWULHUW³ VLFK IU GHQ YRQ 5|VVOHU LQV )HOG JHIKUWHQ Ä.DQW³VRQRWLHUW.RFKÄGLHÃ:UGHµGHV0HQVFKHQ³ (LQHUÄQDKH]XYROOVWlQGLJH>Q@$XVO|VFKXQJDOOHUSHUV|QOLFKHQ%HYRU]XJXQ JHQ³ZLH+RQQHWKVLHDOV=LHOIRUPXOLHUWLVWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGDE]XVD JHQ'HQQLP*HZLVVHQLVWHVLGHDOLWHUJHUDGHGDUXP]XWXQGDVSHUV|QOLFK%H YRU]XJWHXQGGDVDOOJHPHLQ*HERWHQHLQ'HFNXQJ]XEULQJHQ'DVDOOJHPHLQ *HERWHQHLVWDEHUQLFKWYRUVFKQHOOPLWGHQVR]LDOHQ(UZDUWXQJHQHLQHUNRQNUHWHQ *HPHLQVFKDIWE]ZGHULPSOL]LWHQ1RUPDWLYLWlWSHUV|QOLFKHU%LQGXQJHQ]XLGHQ WLIL]LHUHQVRQGHUQNDQQJHUDGHDXFKGXUFKGHUHQ=XUFNZHLVXQJJHOWHQGJH PDFKWZHUGHQ'DVKDW5|VVOHUVNDQWLVFKLQVSLULHUWH.ULWLNDQ+RQQHWKGHXWOLFK DXIJH]HLJW'LH9RUDXVVHW]XQJGDIULVWGDVZDV:KLWHERRNLP$QVFKOXVVDQ +HQULFKXQG6DFNVXQWHUVWULFKHQKDW 'DVVGDV6XEMHNWQLFKWGDVUHLQH3URGXNW VR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHVRQGHUQHWZDVXQDXVWDXVFKEDU(LJHQHVGDU VWHOOW0LW.RFKWKHRORJLVFKJHVSURFKHQ 'HU0HQVFKPXVVÄDOVVHOEVWHWZDV *|WWOLFKHV8QEHGLQJWHV³DQJHVHKHQZHUGHQ±HLQ:UGHWLWHOGHUJXWPLW+HQ ULFKV9HUZHLVDXIGLHXUVSUQJOLFKH6HOEVWYHUWUDXWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWV]XVDPPHQ JHEUDFKWZHUGHQNDQQ'LHVHUDN]HQWXLHUWJHUDGHGLHDOOHQEHVWLPPWHQ%H]XJ QDKPHQJHJHQEHUXQEHGLQJWH(LJHQDUWPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQV0LW6DFNV PDFKW:KLWHERRNPLWKLQGDV6XEMHNWDOVHLQHDXHUVR]LDOH.ULWLNLQVWDQ]VWDUN GLHVLFKGHUXQJHSUIWHQ$EVROXWVHW]XQJGHUHVHLQVFKOLHHQGHQ7UDGLWLRQVJH PHLQVFKDIWJHZLVVHQKDIWZLGHUVHW]WÄ'LHVXEMHNWLYH9HUDQNHUXQJ³VRVFKUHLEW DXFK.RFKLP5DKPHQGHUEHUHLWV]LWLHUWHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW+DEHUPDV LVWGHUHLQ]LJH:HJDXIGHPHLQH 1RUP>«@UHDOYHUELQGOLFKZLUG'DPLWLVW>«@DXVJHVFKORVVHQGDHLQHlXHUOLFKEOHLEHQGH GXUFKVXEMHNWLYH(LQVLFKWQLFKWHLQ]XKROHQGH$XWRULWlWQRUPDWLYH,QKDOWHVHW]W>«@.HLQZLH LPPHUYRU]XVWHOOHQGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU.RQVHQVYHUPDJDXVVLFKVHOEVWYHUELQGOLFKH1RUPHQ KHUYRU]XEULQJHQ
6ROFKHP,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLVPXVVWHKWGLHJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWH(LJHQDUWGHV6XEMHNWV HQWJHJHQGDVVLFKLP*HZLVVHQDXIXQEHGLQJWH:HLVH]XVLFKVHOEVWYHUKlOW'DV LQGLHVHU8QEHGLQJWKHLWVGLPHQVLRQGHV6HOEVWJUQGHQGH$XWRQRPLHYHUP|JHQ
$D2 %2/7$16.,+211(7+ .2&+F +211(7+ .2&+P 9JO]XUWKHRORJLVFKHQ'LPHQVLRQYRQ+HQULFKV6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH ',(5.(1F .2&+OI
%9RQGHU6XEMHNWSKLORVRSKLH]XU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVSKLORVRSKLHXQG]XUFN
LVWZLH5|VVOHUV$UJXPHQWDWLRQHLQJHVFKlUIWKDWNHLQHQYRUDXVOLHJHQGHQOH EHQVZHOWOLFKHQ %LQGXQJHQ E]Z 5ROOHQHUZDUWXQJHQ XQWHU]XRUGQHQ VRQGHUQ JHUDGHGHUHQ(UP|JOLFKXQJVEHGLQJXQJXQG.RUUHNWLYÄ7KLVSXWVDORWRIZHLJKW RQDXWRQRPRXVDJHQWV³UlXPWDOOHUGLQJVVFKRQ5|VVOHUHLQ 'LHGLHVHVXEMHNWLYH9HUDQNHUXQJGHV1RUPDWLYHQYROO]LHKHQGH,QVWDQ]GHV *HZLVVHQVVRKHLWHVGHPJHPlEHL.RFKLVWÄHLQHXQJHPHLQ]ZHLGHXWLJH 6DFKH³ (VLVWPLW+HJHOJHVSURFKHQVWHWVÄDXIGHP6SUXQJH>«@LQV%|VH XP]XVFKODJHQ³XQGGDVÃSHUV|QOLFK%HYRU]XJWHµGLUHNW]XYHUDEVROXWLHUHQ 'LHVH$PELYDOHQ]LVWSULQ]LSLHOO]XDN]HSWLHUHQLQVRIHUQGHP6XEMHNW)UHLKHLW ]XHUNDQQWZHUGHQVROO.RFKV7KHVHGDVVÄPLWGHU:DKOIUHLKHLW³DQGHUGLH Ä6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJGLH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWXQGGDV6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQ³HLQHVMHGHQ 6XEMHNWVÄKlQJHQ³ÄGDV%|VHJHJHEHQ³LVWOlVVWVLFKKLHUVWDUNPDFKHQ'HQQ HLJQHWGHP6XEMHNWGLHIUHLKHLWOLFKH)lKLJNHLW]XU'LVWDQ]QDKPHYRQDOOHPXQG MHGHPKDWHVDQGHUVJHVDJWÄLQVHLQHP,FKHLQ=HQWUXP>«@GDVYRQDOOHP %HVWLPPWZHUGHQYHUVFKLHGHQLVW³NDQQHVÄZHGHUNDXVDOQRFKWHOHRORJLVFKYRP *XWHQGHWHUPLQLHUW³VHLQ$XIWKHRORJLVFKHU(EHQHOlVVWVLFKGHPKLQ]XIJHQ Ä>$@P6HOEVWVHLQ>«@GHV0HQVFKHQKDWGLHWKHRORJLVFKH7KHVHGD*RWWDOOHV LQDOOHPLVWRGHUVHLQZLUGGDHUGLHÃDOOHVEHVWLPPHQGH:LUNOLFKNHLWµLVWLKUH *UHQ]H³0LWGHUEHVDJWHQ7KHVHYHUELQGHWVLFKQlPOLFKGLH9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHU ILQDOHQ'XUFKVHW]XQJGHVDOOHQJHPHLQVDPHQ*XWHQZLHVLHGDV5HLFK*RWWHV 6\PEROJHUDGHDXFKLP6LQQHHLQHV6R]LDOLGHDOVDXVGUFNW*HVWHKWPDQGHP 0HQVFKHQDQGLHVHU6WHOOHNHLQÄ:lKOHQ.|QQHQ³]XÄGHJUDGLHUW³PDQLKQÄ]X HLQHULFKXQGZLOOHQORVHQ0DULRQHWWH*RWWHV³RGHUDQGHUHU0lFKWHGLHVHLQ 7XQLQHLQHYRUKHUEHVWLPPWH5LFKWXQJGUlQJHQ:HUKLQJHJHQ)UHLKHLW]XODVVHQ ZLOOPXVVDXFKHLQUlXPHQGDVVGLH(QWVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ*XWXQG%|VHQLFKW SURJUDPPLHUEDULVW±GHUPXVVPLWGHP6FKOLPPVWHQDEHUDXFKPLWGHP%HVWHQ UHFKQHQ 'LHVHPLWGHPXQNRQWUROOLHUEDUHQ&KDUDNWHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQVHLQ KHUJHKHQGH$PELYDOHQ]PDFKW:KLWHERRNVRKDEHQZLULQGHQ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ $EVFKQLWWHQJHVHKHQLPPHUZLHGHUJHJHQ+RQQHWKVWDUNGHUVLHOHW]WOLFK]X JXQVWHQGHV,QWHUVXEMHNWLYHQDXIKHEW'RFKGLHVHV=XJHVWlQGQLVGDUIQLFKWGDV OHW]WHWKHRORJLVFKH:RUW]XU6DFKHVHLQ'HQQHVNDQQDXFK]XMHQHUÄ,GHQWLWlW GHVVXEMHNWLYHQ:LVVHQVXQG:ROOHQVXQGGHVZDKUKDIWLJHQ*XWHQ³NRPPHQ GLHGDVLQGLYLGXHOOH*HZLVVHQVXUWHLOIUVLFKEHDQVSUXFKW'DPLWLVWZLH.RFK EHWRQWHLQH$OOJHPHLQKHLWLP6SLHOGLHGLHIUHLH(LQVLFKWDXFKGHV$QGHUHQPLW
5g66/(5 .2&+F +(*(/> @ .2&+G (EG $D2 (EG +(*(/> @
%3KLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
HLQVFKOLHHQN|QQHQPXVVXQGVRQXULP8PZHJEHUGHVVHQ$QHUNHQQXQJDOV DXWRQRPHV6XEMHNWUHDOZLUG$QGLHVHU6WHOOHLVWGHU*HGDQNHHLQHUXQYHUPHLG OLFKHQ NRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ ,GHDOLVLHUXQJ GHU EHL +DEHUPDV XQG +RQQHWK DXI MH HLJHQH :HLVH EHJHJQHWH WKHRORJLVFK DXI]XJUHLIHQ 'HQQ GLH DQJHVLFKWV GHU =ZHLGHXWLJNHLWGHV*HZLVVHQVDXIEUHFKHQGH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHPHLJHQHQ $EVROXWKHLWVDQVSUXFK XQG GHP GLH $QGHUHQ PLW HLQVFKOLHHQGHQ $EVROXWHQ VHOEVW PDFKW HV ZR VLH EHZXVVW ZLUG XQXPJlQJOLFK DXI HLQH P|JOLFKH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYH9HUEXQGHQKHLWLP$EVROXWHQ]XYHUWUDXHQ$XIGLHVHVHW]WLQ NRQWUDIDNWLVFKHU(UZDUWXQJGHU*ODXEHLQGHPHUVLFKDXI*RWWGDV$EVROXWH EH]LHKWXQGGDULQRIIHQZLUGIUGLH$QHUNHQQXQJVRZLHGLH%HODQJHGHV$QGH UHQ'DVLVWXQGEOHLEWHLQVXEMHNWLYHU9ROO]XJGHUYRU9HULUUXQJHQQLFKWJHIHLW LVWDEHUDXFK]XP=LHONRPPHQNDQQÄ>*@HJHQVHLWLJH$QHUNHQQXQJ³VRKHLW HVEHL.RFKÄJHOLQJWZRKOQXUDOV]XWUDXHQGHV)UHLODVVHQGHVMHZHLOV$QGHUHQ³ ZREHLÄMHGHUGHUGDVWXWDXIHLQHKRIIHQWOLFKZLHGHUVLFKHLQVWHOOHQGH*HPHLQ VDPNHLW>VHW]W@GLHGHQ$QGHUHQXQGLKQYHUHLQW³ $XIHLQHVROFKH*HPHLQVDPNHLWLQGHUVLFKGDV6XEMHNWLQVHLQHUXQEHGLQJWHQ )UHLKHLWDXIJHKREHQXQGHUIOOWHUIDKUHQNDQQRKQHGDEHLÃDQVLFKVHOEVW5DXE EDX]XWUHLEHQµOlVVWVLFKPLW.RFKGLH5HGHYRQ*RWWDXVULFKWHQ'DGXUFKZLUG HLQHUVHLWVGHUNRQWLQJHQWH&KDUDNWHULKUHV$XINRPPHQVKHUDXVJHVWHOOWGDV±LP 8QWHUVFKLHG]X+RQQHWK±NHLQHU/RJLNGHV=ZDQJVIROJWVRQGHUQVHOEVWQXUDOV HLQIUHLHV*HVFKHKHQGHQNEDULVW'DVVVLFK]ZLVFKHQXQWHUVFKLHGHQHQ6XEMHNWHQ EHUKDXSWHLQH%H]LHKXQJDXIEDXWGHUVLHVLFK]XLQQHUVWYHUSIOLFKWHWZLVVHQ ZLUGVRPLWKLQDOVHLQHXQVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKH$QJHOHJHQKHLWHQWGHFNWGLHQLH ]XPVLFKHUHQ%HVLW]ZLUG,KUHUQHXWHU=XVDPPHQEUXFKLVWNHLQHVZHJVDXV]X VFKOLHHQLKU*HOLQJHQQLFKWYRUSURJUDPPLHUW'LH5HGHYRQ*RWWDEHUVWHOOW DQGHUHUVHLWVGHQYHUKHLXQJVYROOHQ&KDUDNWHUVROFKHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWVHUIDKUXQ JHQKHUDXV ZLUGGDULQZHQLJVWHQVVLWXDWLYLP=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQGLH(UIO OXQJGHUHLJHQHQ$EVROXWKHLWHUIDKUHQYHUPDJGDVHLQHGDUEHUKLQDXVJHKHQGH (UZDUWXQJVJHZLVVKHLW±*ODXEHQ±LP0HQVFKHQ]XZHFNHQGLHVLFKLQHLQHU YHUWUDXHQVYROOHQ2IIHQKHLWVR]LDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQJHJHQEHUDXVZLUNHQNDQQ 6ROFKH9HUEXQGHQKHLWZHQQVLHGHQQIUHLXQGXQJH]ZXQJHQ]XVWDQGHNRP PHQVROONDQQQLFKWJHPDFKWXQGEHZHUNVWHOOLJWZHUGHQ$XILKUXQYHUIJEDUHV $XINRPPHQLVWQXU]XYHUWUDXHQ±XQGZRGLHVHV9HUWUDXHQLQGLH0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHUXQEHGLQJWHQGLHMHHLJHQH$EVROXWKHLWLQVLFKEHJUHLIHQGHQ*HPHLQVDP NHLWEHZXVVWYROO]RJHQZLUGOlVVWVLFKPLW.RFKYRP*ODXEHQVSUHFKHQ'HVVHQ PDFKWORVH0DFKW]HLJWVLFKLQGHUJHZLVVHQ(UZDUWXQJGDVVGLH'LIIHUHQ]HQGHV VR]LDOHQ/HEHQVQLFKWGDVOHW]WH:RUWEHKDOWHQPVVHQVRQGHUQJUXQGVlW]OLFK DXIKHEEDUVLQG'DVDEHUEOHLEWDXV6LFKWGHV*ODXEHQV*RWWDOVGHPLQJHOLQ JHQGHU*HPHLQVDPNHLWVLFKPDQLIHVWLHUHQGHQ*HLVWEHUODVVHQ
.2&+D
7HLO&
6XEMHNWHYRQKHXWH]ZLVFKHQ,FK:LUXQG*RWW± JHJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQDXIGDV 9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJ &*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
(LQOHLWXQJ 6XEMHNWHYRQKHXWH]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG $QHUNHQQXQJ *HJHQZDUWGLDJQRVWLVFKH*UXQGWKHVH GDV $QHUNHQQXQJVYDNXXP ,Q$[HO+RQQHWKV SXEOL]LHUWHU(VVD\VDPPOXQJ'HVLQWHJUDWLRQGLHODXW 8QWHUWLWHO%UXFKVWFNHHLQHUVR]LRORJLVFKHQ=HLWGLDJQRVH]XVDPPHQIKUWZLUG GHU*HJHQZDUWVJHVHOOVFKDIWHLQÄ$QHUNHQQXQJVYDNXXP³DWWHVWLHUWÄ'LHNXOWX UHOOH$OOWDJVSUD[LV³VHLLQGHQ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ-DKU]HKQWHQÄ6FKULWWIU6FKULWW YRQLKUHQWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ:HUWELQGXQJHQEHIUHLW³ZRUGHQÄRKQHGDDQGHUHQ 6WHOOHEHUHLWVVROFKHEHUJUHLIHQGHQ2ULHQWLHUXQJVPXVWHUZLHGHUKlWWHQWUHWHQ N|QQHQLQGHQHQGLH6HOEVWYHUZLUNOLFKXQJVYHUVXFKHGHUYHUHLQ]HOWHQ6XEMHNWH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJILQGHQN|QQWHQ³,P*HJHQVDW]]XGHQLQGLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJWUDNWLHUWHQÄ7KHRUHWLNHU>Q@GHUÃ3RVWPRGHUQHµ³GXUFKGLHGHU GLDJQRVWL]LHUWH:DQGHOYRUEHKDOWORVDOVÄ&KDQFHHLQHU3OXUDOLVLHUXQJYRQLQGLYL GXHOOHQ)RUPHQGHU/HEHQVJHVWDOWXQJ³JHIHLHUWZHUGHZDUQW+RQQHWKYRUGHV VHQ SUREOHPDWLVFKHU 6HLWH 0LW GHU 2ULHQWLHUXQJVNUDIW ÄOHEHQVZHOWOLFK HLQJH VSLHOWH>U@$QHUNHQQXQJVIRUPHQ³JHKWGHQ6XEMHNWHQDXVVHLQHU6LFKWMHQHV0D DQÄVR]LDOH>P@5FNKDOW³YHUORUHQGDVLKQHQGLHQ|WLJH6HOEVWVLFKHUKHLWXQG Ä(UPXWLJXQJ³IUGLH9HUIROJXQJHLJHQHU/HEHQV]LHOHYHUVFKDIIWH'HU)UHL KHLWVJHZLQQGHQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWVYHUOXVWWUDGLWLRQHOOHU:HUWPXVWHUHLQEULQJW
+211(7+ 9JO]XPIROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2II'LHPLWGLHVHP6WLFK ZRUWPDUNLHUWH*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVHZLUGDNWXDOLVLHUHQGZHLWHUYHUIROJWLP6DPPHOEDQG6WUXN WXUZDQGHOGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ 9JO+211(7+XD7KRPDV:HOVNRSSHWZDVSULFKWGRUW YRQHLQHUÄ.ULVHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³GLHÄLQGHU0RGHUQHVHOEVWDQJHOHJW³VHLXQGDOVGHUHQ Ä.HQQ]HLFKHQ³HUHLQHÄGLH,QGLYLGXDOLVLHUXQJGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]JH³EHJOHLWHQGHÄ'HVLQ WHJUDWLRQXQG,QVWDELOLWlW³DQJLEW :(/6.233 9RQKLHUDXVOlVVWVLFKHLQH/LQLH]X $QGUHDV5HFNZLW]µ]HLWGLDJQRVWLVFKHP:HUN*HVHOOVFKDIWGHU6LQJXODULWlWHQ YJO5(&.:,7= II ]LHKHQZRHEHQIDOOVYRQHLQHUÄ.ULVHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ³GLH5HGHLVWLQGHUVLFK HLQHWLHIHUOLHJHQGHÄ.ULVHGHV$OOJHPHLQHQ³PDQLIHVWLHUH 'HPQDFKZLUGHWZDGLHHLQVWIU DOOH QDFKYROO]LHKEDUHÄ%HUHFKHQEDUNHLW GHU /HLVWXQJV XQG 4XDOLILNDWLRQVNULWHULHQ DXI GLH 8QEHUHFKHQEDUNHLWYRQ0DUNWHUIROJXQGÃJHOXQJHQHU3HUIRUPDQ]µ³XPJHVWHOOW DD2 $D2 (EG9JOGD]X DD2II(UYHUZHLVWDXI-HDQ)UDQoRLV/\RWDUG-HDQ%DXGULOODUGXQG 5LFKDUG5RUW\ $D2I
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
KDWDOVR9HUXQVLFKHUXQJ,QVWDELOLWlWXQG2ULHQWLHUXQJVORVLJNHLW]XU.HKUVHLWH 0LWKLQZlFKVWZLH+RQQHWKDQIJWGXUFKGDVVRHQWVWDQGHQHÄ$QHUNHQQXQJV YDNXXP³GLH*HIDKUGDVVLQÄYRUIDEUL]LHUWH>Q@/HEHQVVWLOH>Q@³KLOIUHLFKHÄ(U VDW]DQJHERWHIUGLHVR]LDOOHHUODXIHQGHQ%LRJUDSKLHQ³JHIXQGHQZHUGHQXQG PDQVLFKXQEHGDFKWLQQHXH$EKlQJLJNHLWHQIOFKWHW +RQQHWKV Ä=HLWGLDJQRVH>@³GDVUlXPWHUVHOEVWHLQLVWÄHQWVFKHLGHQGYRQ :HLFKHQVWHOOXQJHQDXIGHU(EHQHSKLORVRSKLVFKHU*UXQGPRWLYHPLWEHVWLPPW³ 6LHVHW]WGLH$QQDKPHYRUDXVGDVVÄGLH9HUZLUNOLFKXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWDXIHQW VSUHFKHQGH)RUPHQVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJDQJHZLHVHQLVW³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Ã$QHUNHQQXQJVYDNXXPµYHUZHLVW VSLHOWDOOHUGLQJVLQDOOHQGUHLLP)ROJHQGHQXQWHUQRPPHQHQ]HLWGLDJQRVWLVFKHQ (UNXQGXQJVJlQJHQ ZHLWHU HLQH 5ROOH 'DVV QlPOLFK GDV VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKH 2ULHQWLHUWVHLQGHVLQGLYLGXHOOHQ/HEHQVYROO]XJVGXUFKVR]LRNXOWXUHOOYHUPLWWHOWH :HUWPXVWHUXQWHUPRGHUQHQ%HGLQJXQJHQ]XQHKPHQGVFKZLQGHW±ZDVDXIVHLWHQ GHU6XEMHNWH]X(UIDKUXQJHQYRQ9HUXQVLFKHUXQJXQG,QVWDELOLWlWIKUW'DUDXV HUJLEWVLFKHLQHUVHLWVGLHGXUFK+RQQHWKDXVJHPDFKWH6XFKHQDFKQHXHQJOHLFK VDPÃDOWHµ9HUWUDXWKHLWVWLIWHQGHQ$EKlQJLJNHLWHQ$QGHUHUVHLWVVWHOOWVLFKGLH YRQLKPDXIJHZRUIHQH)UDJHREGHU)UHLKHLWVJHZLQQGHQGHU$XVJDQJDXVDOO]X IHVWJHIJWHQ/HEHQVPRGHOOHQYHUVSULFKWGHQJOHLFK]HLWLJHQ6LFKHUKHLWVYHUOXVW DXI]XZLHJHQYHUPDJXQGZHOFKH7KHUDSLHGHU'LDJQRVH]XIROJHQKDW 'DVLQGLHVHU$UEHLWIRNXVVLHUWH6SDQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQ,FKXQG:LU LQGLYLGXHOOHP6HOEVWVHLQXQGVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJZLUGVR]HLJWHVGLHVNL] ]LHUWHJHJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH*UXQGWKHVHQRFKHLQPDODXIQHXH:HLVH]XP 7KHPD*OHLFKHVVROOIUGHVVHQWKHRORJLVFKH,QVLFKWQDKPHJHOWHQGLHEHUHLWVLP )DOOGHULQ7HLO$EHKDQGHOWHQ$XWRUHQMHZHLOVDXIDNWXHOOH3UREOHPNRQVWHOODWLR QHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQVKLQHUZHLWHUWZXUGH'DVIROJHQGH.DSLWHOOlVVW VSLHJHOELOGOLFKGD]XGLHHKHUJUXQGOHJHQGHQVR]LDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ7KHPHQVWHO OXQJHQGHV]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ7HLOVLQJHJHQZDUWVEH]RJHQH3KlQRPHQDQDO\VHQ EHUJHKHQ'DVVGDPLWQRFKPDOV]HQWUDOH(LQVLFKWHQDXVGHQYRUDQJHKHQGHQ *HGDQNHQJlQJHQLQHLQHPDEVFKOLHHQGHQ6LQQHJHEQGHOWZHUGHQ]HLJWVLFK DXFKGDUDQGDVVHLQPDOPHKU(EHUKDUG-QJHO)DON:DJQHUXQG7UDXJRWW.RFK MHZHLOVDOVWKHRORJLVFKH*HVSUlFKVSDUWQHULQGLHQXQVR]LRORJLVFKHQE]ZJH JHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKHQ'HEDWWHQHLQEH]RJHQZHUGHQ
$D2 $D2
(LQOHLWXQJ
=XP$XIEDXGHV.DSLWHOV ,QGHQNRPPHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWHQXQWHUQLPPWGLHYRUOLHJHQGH$UEHLWGUHLJHJHQ ZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH(UNXQGXQJVJlQJH'DEHLJHKWHVZLHGLH.DSLWHOEHUVFKULIW DQNOLQJHQOlVVWMHZHLOVGDUXPSDUDGLJPDWLVFKH(UIDKUXQJVNRQVWHOODWLRQHQ]X DQDO\VLHUHQDQKDQGGHUHUVLFK6XEMHNWHYRQKHXWHLP6SDQQXQJVIHOG]ZLVFKHQ ,FK:LUXQG*RWWYHURUWHQODVVHQ$OV=XJDQJVPLWWHOGLHQHQGDEHLMHZHLOV]HLW JHQ|VVLVFKH5RPDQHLQGHQHQDNWXHOOH6HOEVWXQG:HOWHUIDKUXQJHQOLWHUDULVFK YHUGLFKWHW]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPHQ ,PHUVWHQ)DOOVLQGHV7H[WHGHV6FKULIWVWHOOHUV:LOKHOP*HQD]LQRYHUPLWWHOV GHUHUVLFKGHP OlQJVWQLFKWPHKUQXU LQGHU%HUXIVVSKlUHEHKHLPDWHWHQ3Kl QRPHQGHUÃ(UVFK|SIXQJµXQGGHVÃHUVFK|SIWHQ6XEMHNWVµVRZLHGHUGDUDXIEH ]RJHQHQ5HGHYRPÃ%XUQRXWµDQJHQlKHUWZLUG,P$QVFKOXVVDQ+DUWPXW5RVD OlVVW VLFK GLHVH SDWKRORJLVFK ]X QHQQHQGH *HJHQZDUWVHUIDKUXQJ DOV 5HVXOWDW HLQHVWLHIJUHLIHQGHQ:DQGHOVVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJVEH]LHKXQJHQYHUVWHKHQGLH ±ZLHHUPLWVWDUNHQ1lKHQ]X+RQQHWKVRELJHU'LDJQRVHIRUPXOLHUW±GHQ(LQ ]HOQHQ NHLQ VWDELOHV 6HOEVWVHLQ PHKU YHUVFKDIIHQ VRQGHUQ ]X DQGDXHUQGHQ 6HOEVWVWHLJHUXQJVEHPKXQJHQDQWUHLEHQ'DV8QZRKOHPSILQGHQHLQHP]LHOOR VHQ:HWWEHZHUEXP$QHUNHQQXQJDXVJHVHW]W]XVHLQNRPPWVRGLHLQGLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJHQWIDOWHWH7KHVHLQGHULQIODWLRQlUHQ5HGHYRQÃ%XUQRXWµXQG Ã(UVFK|SIXQJµ]XP$XVGUXFN=XJOHLFKDEHUGLHQWGLH6HOEVWEH]HLFKQXQJDOV %XUQRXW2SIHUDPELYDOHQWHUZHLVHZLHXQWHU5HNXUVXDDXIGHQ3V\FKRWKHUD SHXWHQ5DLQHU*URVVJH]HLJWZLUGELVZHLOHQGHP9HUVXFKHLQH$UW(UVDW]DQHU NHQQXQJIUGHQQRFKJHOHLVWHWH$UEHLW]XJHQHULHUHQ$XFKGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 9RUVRUJHSURJUDPPHVLQGQLFKWIUHLGDYRQGHQSUREOHPDWLVFKHQ6WHLJHUXQJV GUXFN]XSHUSHWXLHUHQ,QGHUDEVFKOLHHQGHQWKHRORJLVFKHQ5HIOH[LRQZLUGMHQHV %HIUHLWZHUGHQYRQ EHUXIOLFKHQ /HLVWXQJV]ZlQJHQGDV(EHUKDUG-QJHOPLWGHU Ã$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFK*RWWµYHUEXQGHQVLHKWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJJHOWHQG JHPDFKW & =ZHLWHQVZLUGDXVJHKHQGYRQ0LWKX6DQ\DOV5RPDQ,GHQWLWWLGLHDPELYDOHQWH 6LWXDWLRQGHVLQGLHDNWXHOOHQ.lPSIHXP,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNYHUZLFNHOWHQ6XEMHNWV DQDO\VLHUW$PELYDOHQWLVWGDUDQGDVVÃOLQNH,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNµHLQHUVHLWVYRP $XVVHLQDXIGLHJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWH$QHUNHQQXQJGLVNULPLQLHUWHU*UXSSHQXQG GDPLWGXUFKHLQHQSULQ]LSLHOOHQ$OOJHPHLQKHLWVEH]XJJHOHLWHWLVW$QGHUHUVHLWVLVW VLHDEHUJHQHLJWGLHMHHLJHQHGXUFKNROOHNWLYH=XJHK|ULJNHLWEHGLQJWH%HVRQ GHUKHLWVWDUN]XU*HOWXQJEULQJHQ]XZROOHQ'DVVVLFKOHW]WHUHU'UDQJELVZHLOHQ ±XQGLQUHOLJL|VIXQGDPHQWDOLVWLVFKHQE]ZUHFKWHQ)RUPHQYRQ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN XQJOHLFKVFKlUIHU±YHUVHOEVWlQGLJWZLUGPLW7KRPDV0H\HUDOV5HDNWLRQDXIGLH HLJHQH,GHQWLWlWYHUXQVLFKHUQGHVR]LDOH'LIIHUHQ]HUIDKUXQJHQJHGHXWHW0LWKLQ PDFKWVLFKGDUDQGHU3DUWLNXODULVPXVYRUZXUIYRQVHLWHQGHULGHQWLWlWVSROLWLNNULWL VFKHQ)URQWIHVWGHVVHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH9DULDQWHQLP$QVFKOXVVDQ6LONHYDQ '\N DXFKNULWLVFK LQV9LVLHUJHQRPPHQZHUGHQ(VIROJWHLQ%OLFNDXI.ZDPH $QWKRQ\$SSLDKV3OlGR\HUIUHLQHhEHUZLQGXQJGHVLGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKHQ.RO
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
OHNWLYLVPXV]XJXQVWHQÃLQGLYLGXHOOHUHUµ,GHQWLWlWVNRQ]HSWLRQHQGLHHLQHPIUHLH UHQ8PJDQJPLWGHPXQHQWULQQEDUHQ*HSUlJWZHUGHQGXUFKVR]LDOH%HVWLPPWKHL WHQHQWVSULQJHQ'LHVHV(LJHQUHFKWGHV,QGLYLGXHOOHQZLUGVFKOLHOLFKPLW)DON :DJQHUDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHVRDN]HQWXLHUWGDVVDXIGHU)ROLHVHLQHV DQHUNHQQXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKJHIDVVWHQ*RWWHVJHGDQNHQVJHJHQMHGZHGH9HUEHVRQ GHUXQJGHV$OOJHPHLQHQ]XYRWLHUHQLVW & ,PGULWWHQXQGOHW]WHQ$EVFKQLWWNRPPWVFKOLHOLFKDQKDQGYRQ6DOO\5RRQH\V 5RPDQ1RUPDO3HRSOHGDVDPRXU|VHLQURPDQWLVFKH/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHQYHUZL FNHOWHÃ6XEMHNWYRQKHXWHµLQGHQ%OLFN0LW(YD,OORX]ZLUGGLHURPDQWLVFKH /LHEHDOVHLQHJHJHQZlUWLJ]HQWUDOHXQGJOHLFKZRKOGXUFK$PELYDOHQ]HQJH NHQQ]HLFKQHWH$QHUNHQQXQJVVSKlUHYHUVWDQGHQ$QVLHNQSIWVLFKHLQHUVHLWVGLH (UZDUWXQJ IU GLH (LQ]HOQHQ ]XU VLFKHUHQ 4XHOOH HLQHV DQJHVLFKWV VR]LDOHU :DQGOXQJVSUR]HVVHYHUXQVLFKHUWHQ6HOEVWZHUWJHIKOV]XZHUGHQ$QGHUHUVHLWV IKUWGLH/LHEHVVXFKHHEHQIDOOVDXIXQVLFKHUHV7HUUDLQZHLOGDEHLNDXPPHKU IHVWH 1RUPHQ XQG .RQYHQWLRQHQ NODUH 2ULHQWLHUXQJ ELHWHQ =XGHP VWHKW GDV PRGHUQH$XWRQRPLHLGHDOWHQGHQ]LHOOLP:LGHUVSUXFK]XGHUVLFKHLQHUDQGHUHQ 3HUVRQXQGGHUHQ$QHUNHQQXQJDXVVHW]HQGHQ+DOWXQJGLHIU/LHEHVEH]LHKXQ JHQ JHUDGH]X JUXQGOHJHQG LVW 'DVV GLHVHU *HJHQVDW] ]ZLVFKHQ )UHLKHLW XQG /LHEHE]Z$QHUNHQQXQJXQEHUZLQGOLFKLVWZLUGDEVFKOLHHQGPLW7UDXJRWW .RFKWKHRORJLVFKKLQWHUIUDJW'DEHLZLUGGDVUHOLJL|VH*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVDOV4XHO OHHLQHVVHOEVWVLFKHUHQYHUWUDXHQVYROOHQ8PJDQJVPLWXQZHLJHUOLFKGXUFK6SDQ QXQJHQ8QVLFKHUKHLWHQXQG.ULVHQJHSUlJWHQ/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHQWKHPDWLVFK &
&$XVJHEUDQQWXQGIHUWLJPLWVLFKVHOEVW"'DV HUVFK|SIWH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJ XQG*RWW (UVFK|SIXQJVJHIKOH ]ZLVFKHQ(PSLULHXQG(PSILQGHQ Ä$OVLFKMQJHUZDUKDWWHLFKPLUHLQH:HLOHHLQJHUHGHWLFKVHLPHODQFKROLVFK EH]LHKXQJVZHLVHGHSUHVVLYEH]LHKXQJVZHLVHHLQEXUQRXW)DOO³UHVPLHUWGHU 3URWDJRQLVWLQ:LOKHOP*HQD]LQRVHUVFKLHQHQHP5RPDQ$XHUXQVVSULFKW QLHPDQGEHUXQVÄ'DPDOV³VRIlKUWHUIRUWÄZDUMHGHUKDOEZHJVHLQVLFKWLJH 0HQVFKHLQHVYRQGLHVHQGUHLHQZHLOGLH:HOW XQGPDQVHOEVWLQLKU DXIDQGHUH :HLVHQLFKWPHKU]XHUWUDJHQZDU³6LFKVHOEVW]XSDWKRORJLVLHUHQGLHQWH*HQD ]LQRV)LJXUGHPQDFKGD]XGLH:HOWE]ZGDVHLJHQH,QGHU:HOW6HLQHUWUlJOL FKHUZHUGHQ]XODVVHQ'DVVDP(QGHGHUHLQLJHUPDHQXQEHVWLPPWEOHLEHQGHQ 6HOEVWGLDJQRVHGLH(LQVLFKWVWHKWÃHLQEXUQRXW)DOOµ]XVHLQOlVVWVLFKGXUFKDXV DOV LURQLVFKHU .RPPHQWDU GHV VR]LRORJLVFK XQG SV\FKRORJLVFK EHZDQGHUWHQ $XWRUV]XU.RQWURYHUVHXPGDVGDPLWDXIJHUXIHQH/HLGHQOHVHQÄ:RKONHLQH Ã/DLHQ'LDJQRVHµE]Z6HOEVW(WLNHWWLHUXQJ³VFKUHLEWGHU3V\FKRWKHUDSHXW5DL QHU*URVVKDWQlPOLFKÄMHPDOVVRYLHO PHGLDOH $XIPHUNVDPNHLWHUUHLFKWZLH GLHÃ1LFKW'LDJQRVHµ%XUQRXW³ *URVVµ:RUWHXQWHUVWUHLFKHQZLHXPVWULWWHQHV±JHOLQGHJHVDJW±DXVPHGL]L QLVFKHU6LFKWQDFKZLHYRULVWGLHVEH]JOLFKEHUKDXSWYRQHLQHPHLJHQVWlQGL JHQ.UDQNKHLWVELOG]XVSUHFKHQGDVVLFKQRFKGD]XLQGHQOHW]WHQ-DKU]HKQWHQ EHLQDKHHSLGHPLVFKYHUEUHLWHWKDEHQVROOÄ,QGHU,QWHUQDWLRQDO&ODVVLILFDWLRQRI 'LVHDVHV ,&' DOVZHOWZHLWJOWLJHP'LDJQRVH6\VWHPGHU:HOWJHVXQGKHLWVRU JDQLVDWLRQ:+2H[LVWLHUW%XUQRXW³ZLH*URVVKHUDXVVWHOOWÄDXFKZHLWHUKLQQXU DOV³HLQHVYRQYLHOHQÄÃ3UREOHPH>Q@PLW%H]XJDXI6FKZLHULJNHLWHQEHLGHU/H EHQVEHZlOWLJXQJµ³'HUGDPLWODQGOlXILJEH]HLFKQHWH=XVWDQGFKURQLVFKHU(U
*(1$=,12 'DVV*HQD]LQRV:HUNLQVJHVDPWHLQHZDKUH)XQGJUXEHGDUVWHOOW ZHQQHVXPGLH+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJHQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ$UEHLWVOHEHQVJHKW]HLJW1HUHD9|LQJLQ LKUHUOHVHQVZHUWHQOLWHUDWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ6WXGLH$UEHLWXQG0HODQFKROLHGLHQHEHQ*HQD ]LQRDXFKQRFKDQGHUH$XWRULQQHQXQG$XWRUHQEHKDQGHOW 9JO9g,1* ± $D2 *5266 (EG9JOGD]XXQG]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2IIXQGGLHLQHLQHlKQOLFKH5LFKWXQJ]LH OHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQEHL'251(6II9JO]XP7KHPD%XUQRXWLQVJHVDPWGLH%HLWUl
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
VFK|SIXQJ GXUFK $UEHLW NDQQ KHLW HV LP HLQVFKOlJLJHQ 3RVLWLRQVSDSLHU GHU 'HXWVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWIU3V\FKLDWULH3V\FKRWKHUDSLHXQG1HUYHQKHLONXQGH '*331 ÄHLQHQ5LVLNR]XVWDQGIUHLQHVSlWHUHSV\FKLVFKHRGHUN|USHUOLFKH (UNUDQNXQJGDUVWHOOHQ³RGHUDOV1HEHQHIIHNWDNXWHU(UNUDQNXQJHQDXIWUHWHQ6R XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKVLFKGHU%HIXQGLP(LQ]HOQHQGDUVWHOOHQNDQQVRÄXQNODU³LVWHV GHPSXEOL]LHUWHQ'*3313DSLHU]XIROJHDXFKÄRE>«@WDWVlFKOLFKHLQH UHOHYDQWH=XQDKPHYRQ%XUQRXW%HVFKZHUGHQHUIROJWLVW³ZDVGXUFKGLHDN WXHOOH(UKHEXQJYRQVHLWHQGHV'DFKYHUEDQGVGHU%HWULHEVNUDQNHQNDVVHQVRJDU H[SOL]LWYHUQHLQWZLUG'HPJHJHQEHUKDWVLFKGLHELV]XPKHXWLJHQ7DJHDQ GDXHUQGH|IIHQWOLFKPHGLDOH'DXHUEHVFKlIWLJXQJPLWGHP7KHPD%XUQRXWMH GRFKOlQJVWYHUVHOEVWlQGLJW GDVLQGGLH%HULFKWHÄEHUHUVFK|SIWH/HLVWXQJV VSRUWOHULQQHQDXVJHEUDQQWH6WDUVGLHGHV(UIROJVEHUGUVVLJVHLHQJHVWUHVVWH XQGHQWNUlIWHWH0DQDJHULQQHQXQG$QJHVWHOOWHXQGQHXHUGLQJVDXFKEHU6WXGLH UHQGHGLHXQWHUJHVWLHJHQHP:HWWEHZHUEVGUXFN>«@OHLGHQZUGHQ³ GDLVWGLH 5HGHYRPGXUFKIDPLOLlUHhEHUEHDQVSUXFKXQJEHGLQJWHQÄ(OWHUQ%XUQRXW³RGHU YRQGHQGXUFKKRKH/HLVWXQJVDQIRUGHUXQJHQJHTXlOWHQÄ%XUQRXW.LGV³ XQGGD VLQGKLVWRULVFKHE]ZVR]LRORJLVFKH6WXGLHQGLHGLH0RGHUQHDOVÄ=HLWDOWHUGHU (UVFK|SIXQJ³WLWXOLHUHQGLHÄHUVFK|SIWH*HVHOOVFKDIW³RGHUGLHÄ0GLJNHLWVJH VHOOVFKDIW³DXVUXIHQYRPÄHUVFK|SIWHQ6HOEVW³RGHUYRPÄEHUIRUGHUWHQ6XE MHNW³KDQGHOQ 2PQLSUlVHQWVFKHLQWMHGHQIDOOVGHU(LQGUXFN]XVHLQGDVVPDQRELQGLYLGXHOO RGHU NROOHNWLY PLW GHQ YHUIJEDUHQ .UlIWHQ WHQGHQ]LHOO DP (QGH LUJHQGZLH DXVJHEUDQQWXQGIHUWLJLVWÄ%XUQRXW³VROlVVWVLFKGLHVHU%HIXQGPLW/LQGDXQG 7RUVWHQ +HLQHPDQQ GHXWHQ ÄLVW LQ GHU *HJHQZDUWVJHVHOOVFKDIW ]X HLQHP GHU PHLVWJHQDQQWHQ XQG YLHOGLVNXWLHUWHQ 8QZRKOJHIKOH JHZRUGHQ³ ZHLO HV GLH YLHOIDFKÄZDKUJHQRPPHQHQ)ROJHQGHUZDFKVHQGHQ/HLVWXQJVDQIRUGHUXQJHQLQ %HUXIVXQG3ULYDWOHEHQDXIGHQ3XQNW>]X@EULQJHQ³HUODXEW'DEHLJLOWZDV 8OULFK%U|FNOLQJSRLQWLHUWKHUDXVVWHOOW Ä:HU%XUQRXWVDJWVSULFKWLP0RGXVGHU .XOWXUNULWLN³GHUPHLQWDOVRÄQLHPDOVEORLQGLYLGXHOOHV/HLGHQVRQGHUQVWHWV JHLQGHQIROJHQGHQ6DPPHOElQGHQ 1(&.(/:$*1(5 0,;$XD II )8&+6 XD '(876&+(*(6(//6&+$)7)h536«@LFKELQHLQHJXWH.UDIWJHZRU GHQ0HLQ$XVZHJLVWGDV6WLOOZHUGHQ2IWKDEHLFKLQGLHVHU6WLOOHSO|W]OLFKHLQHLUUVLQQLJH +RIIQXQJ,FKN|QQWHDP6FKUHLEWLVFKDQIDQJHQ]XKHXOHQZHLOLFKEHU]HXJWELQHVJLEWHLQH (UO|VXQJ
(LQHFKURQLVFKH1HJDWLYHLQVWHOOXQJ]XPHLJHQHQ-REVRZXUGHREHQJHVDJW JHK|UW]XGHQ6\PSWRPHQGLHQDFKRIIL]LHOOHU/HVDUWGLH'LDJQRVHÃ%XUQRXWµ QDKHOHJHQ$EVFKDIIHODEHUPDFKWWURW]GHPZHLWHU(UZlKOWJHZLVVHUPDHQGHQ :HJGHULQQHUHQ(PLJUDWLRQ6HLQVXEYHUVLYHV6FKZHLJHQMHGRFKGXUFKGDVHU VLFKHLQHUOHW]WJOWLJHQ$IILUPDWLRQGHUVFKLFNVDOKDIWHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHHQW]LHKW± GHUHUVWH6DW]GHV5RPDQVODXWHW Ä:HLOVHLQH/DJHXQDElQGHUOLFKZDUPXVVWH $EVFKDIIHODUEHLWHQ³±GLHVHUOHW]WHÃ$XVZHJGHV6WLOOZHUGHQVµDOVRKlOWLP PHUQRFKHLQHÃLUUVLQQLJH+RIIQXQJµDXIÃ(UO|VXQJµDXIUHFKW 3DVVHQGGD]XYHUZHLVW+DUWPXW5RVDGDUDXIGDVVEHL6¡UHQ.LHUNHJDDUGYRP ÄEHUHGWH>Q@6FKZHLJHQHLQHVHVVHQWLHOOHQ±UHVRQDQWHQ±%H]RJHQVHLQV³GLH5HGH LVWÄGDVVGHU0HQVFKYRQ9RJHOXQG/LOLHDOVÃ/HKUPHLVWHUQGHV6WLOOVHLQVµOHU QHQN|QQH³'DEHLJHKWHVXPGDV%H]RJHQVHLQDXI*RWWGDV.LHUNHJDDUGLQ VHLQHQ'UHL)URPPHQ5HGHQLP$XVJDQJYRP*OHLFKQLVGHUVRUJORVHQ/LOLHQ JHWUDJHQLVWGLHLKUHQ*UXQGLQSRVLWLYHQ*UXQGWHQGHQ]HQGHU0RGHUQHKDEHQ]HLJWVLFKDP GHXWOLFKVWHQLQIROJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWHQVHLQHV:HUNV '(56±± 526$ 9JODD2± *(1$=,12I (EG *(1$=,12 526$$QP
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
XQG9|JHO 0WII HQWIDOWHWÄ>:@RGXDEHUVFKZHLJHQN|QQWHVW³KHLWHV GRUW ZUGHGDV/HLGHQZRKOQLFKWPHKUVRJURVHLQ>«@ XQGGLHVHV6WLOOHVHLQNDQQVW'XOHUQHQ YRQGHP9RJHOXQGGHU/LOLH>«@:DVDEHUGUFNWGLHVH6WLOOHDXV"6LHGUFNWDXV(KUIXUFKW YRU *RWW GD HU HV LVW GHU GD ZDOWHW XQG DOOHLQ HU HV LVW GHP :HLVKHLW XQG 9HUVWDQG ]X NRPPW
$EVFKDIIHOVVFKZHLJHQGH+LQQDKPHGHVGXUFKGLHHLJHQH$UEHLWVVLWXDWLRQEH GLQJWHQ/HLGHQVDOVXQDElQGHUOLFKHV(UJHKHQEULQJWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGGLH (LQVLFKW]XP$XVGUXFNVLFKQLFKWVHOEVWGDUDXVHUO|VHQ]XN|QQHQ)U.LHUNH JDDUGLVWGLHVGHU3XQNWDQGHPGHXWOLFKZLUGGDVV*RWWDOOHLQHVLVWYRQGHP (UO|VXQJHUKRIIWZHUGHQNDQQ'DYRQDXVJHKHQGZREHLGLHVH]XJHJHEHQHUPD HQ]LHPOLFKVFKURIIH(QWJHJHQVHW]XQJYRQ*RWWXQG0HQVFKQRFKQLFKWGHU WKHRORJLVFKHQ:HLVKHLWOHW]WHU6FKOXVVGDUVWHOOWOlVVWVLFKMHW]WHLQHWKHRORJLVFKH 3HUVSHNWLYHDXIGDVVRHEHQ*HVDJWHZHUIHQ =XQlFKVWLVWIHVW]XKDOWHQ .HLQQRFKVRDFKWVDPHU6HOEVW(LQVDW]LQGHQDXI 'DXHU JHVWHOOWHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVNlPSIHQ GLH QDFK 5RVD KHXWH YRUKHUUVFKHQ YHUPDJGLHGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH,QVWDELOLWlW$QHUNHQQXQJVXQVLFKHUKHLWXQG(U VFK|SIXQJVJHIDKUYROOHQGV]XEDQQHQ'HQQVRHLQPDOPHKU5RVDÄHLQHEHU VR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJYHUPLWWHOWH³6HOEVWXQGÄ:HOWEH]LHKXQJ³LVWQLHPDOVHLQH ÄÃWUDJHQGHµ³ZHLOÄVLHVWHWV*HIDKUOlXIW]XVDPPHQ]XEUHFKHQ 6R]LDOH$QHU NHQQXQJNDQQLPPHUXQGEHUDOODXFKYHUVDJWZHUGHQXQGLQ0LVVDFKWXQJXP VFKODJHQ VLH LVW ]XPLQGHVW XQG JHUDGH XQWHU PRGHUQHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ LPPHU EHGURKW³:HUVLFKGLHVHOHW]WH%HGURKWKHLWLQLKUHPXQEHUZLQGOLFKHQXQG XQNDONXOLHUEDUHQ&KDUDNWHUDEHUHLJHQVEHZXVVWPDFKWGHVVHQ(UZDUWXQJHQDQ GLHHWZDGXUFK%HUXIVDUEHLW]XJHQHULHUHQGH6HOEVWZHUWVFK|SIXQJUHODWLYLHUHQ VLFKDXFK3RWHQ]LHOOLVWGDULQGLH(LQVLFKWHQWKDOWHQGDVVGDV(UKRIIWHQlPOLFK ]XHLQHPVWDELOHQ6HOEVWVHLQ]XJHODQJHQVRQLHPDOVLQ(UIOOXQJJHKHQNDQQ (QWJHJHQ5RVDVVWDUNQHJDWLYJHIlUEWHU6LFKWGHUVSlWPRGHUQHQ0RGHUQHGLH PLW0DUWLQ'RUQHVJHVDJWELVZHLOHQGHQ(LQGUXFNÄHLQHU3URMHNWLRQYRQ*H JHQZDUWVXQEHKDJHQ LQ HLQH YHUPHLQWOLFKEHVVHUH 9HUJDQJHQKHLW³ PDFKW LVW GLHVH'HVLOOXVLRQLHUXQJDEHUDXFKSRVLWLY]XEHXUWHLOHQ(VVWHOOWHLQHQWKHROR JLVFK]XDN]HQWXLHUHQGHQ)RUWVFKULWWLP%HZXVVWVHLQGHU)UHLKHLWGDUGDVVGLH ,GHQWLWlWGHU6XEMHNWHQLFKWPHKUGHFNXQJVJOHLFKPLWYRQYRUQKHUHLQIHVWJHOHJ WHQ RGHU HLQPDO HUUHLFKWHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ LVW 1LFKWV DQGHUHV VSULFKWVLFKMDLQGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ%H]XJQDKPHDXI*RWWXQGJ|WWOLFKH$QHUNHQ QXQJDXVDOVGDV%HZXVVWVHLQMHHLJHQHU8QEHGLQJWKHLWDOOHQVR]LDOHQ%HVWLPPW KHLWHQJHJHQEHU'HUJUDVVLHUHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVXQVLFKHUKHLWGLHVLFKLQGHQ 'LVNXVVLRQHQXP%XUQRXWXQG(UVFK|SIXQJDXVVSULFKWNRPPWLQVRIHUQDXFKHLQ
.,(5.(*$$5' I 526$ I '251(6 'RUQHVNULWLVFKH(LQVFKlW]XQJEH]LHKWVLFKDXIHLQH9LHO]DKOYRQND SLWDOLVPXVNULWLVFKHQ*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVHQ
&'DVHUVFK|SIWH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW
SURGXNWLYHU&KDUDNWHU]XZHLOVLHHLQWHQGHQ]LHOOIUHLKHLWVJHIlKUGHQGHV6LFKHU KHLWVEHGUIQLVLQ)UDJHVWHOOW%HGHQNWPDQPLWKLQGLHGDUJHOHJWH$PELYDOHQ] GHU%XUQRXW0HWDSKHUXQGGHUSURSK\ODNWLVFKHQ$QWL(UVFK|SIXQJVVWUDWHJLHQLQ GHQHQVLFKGHU:XQVFKE]ZGHU,PSHUDWLYDXVGUFNWZHLWHUKLQDOVOHLVWXQJVIl KLJHV6XEMHNWJHOWHQ]XN|QQHQZLUGGLHVH,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJXPVRGULQJOLFKHU 'DVLVWLQ]ZHL+LQVLFKWHQQRFKZHLWHUDXV]XIKUHQ 7KHRORJLVFK]XEHVWUHLWHQLVWHUVWHQVGLH)RUGHUXQJDQÄGDVPHQVFKOLFKH,FK VLFKGXUFK$UEHLWGLHMHQLJH$QHUNHQQXQJYHUVFKDIIHQ]XVROOHQGLH>«@GDV 3HUVRQVHLQGHV0HQVFKHQNRQVWLWXLHUW³6RIRUPXOLHUWHV(EHUKDUG-QJHOLP =XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHVVHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVWKHRORJLHEHUHLWVGDV7KHPDÃ$UEHLWµ JHVWUHLIWZXUGH$QJHVLFKWVGHUDPELYDOHQWHQ.RQVHTXHQ]GLHVHV6ROOHQVQlP OLFK VWlQGLJ GDYRQ EHGURKW ]X VHLQ VLFK HQWZHGHU DOV OHLVWXQJVIlKLJ RGHU XQIlKLJHUZHLVHQ]XN|QQHQEULQJW-QJHOÄ>G@DVGHQ0HQVFKHQYRU*RWWGHIL QLWLYDQHUNHQQHQGH(YDQJHOLXPYRQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ³LQV6SLHO (VVWHOOWÄGLH SHUVRQNRQVWLXLHUHQGH)XQNWLRQYRQ$UEHLW³JUXQGVlW]OLFKLQ)UDJH'LHVH,Q IUDJHVWHOOXQJDEHUHUIlKUWEHU-QJHOKLQDXVJHVDJWVFKRQDQVLFKVHOEVWZHU GHVHLJHQHQ8QJHQJHQVJHJHQEHUGHQXPODXIHQGHQ/HLVWXQJVDQVSUFKHQLQ QHZLUG VHLHVGXUFKhEHUIRUGHUXQJXQG(UVFK|SIXQJVHLHVGXUFKPDQJHOQGH ,GHQWLILNDWLRQPLWGHPHLJHQHQ-RE6ROFKH(UIDKUXQJHQPVVHQNHLQHVZHJVQXU GDVHLJHQH6FKHLWHUQPDQLIHVWLHUHQ6LHHQWKDOWHQDXFKGLHSRWHQ]LHOOZHLWHUIK UHQGH(LQVLFKWPLWGHPEHUXIOLFKHQ6RVHLQQLFKWYROONRPPHQEHUHLQ]XVWLP PHQGDULQLQGLYLGXHOOQLFKWDXI]XJHKHQ'LHVHVSRVLWLYH)UHLKHLWVPRPHQWGDV GHPQHJDWLYHQ(UJHKHQGHU1LFKW(QWVSUHFKXQJJHJHQEHUGHQ$QIRUGHUXQJHQ GHUZHWWEHZHUEVPlLJJHSUlJWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJVRUGQXQJLQQHZRKQWLVWWKHROR JLVFKVWDUN]XPDFKHQ (VZLUGUHOLJL|VDUWLNXOLHUEDULQGHUGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWPHQVFKOLFKHQ6HOEVW VHLQV WKHPDWLVLHUHQGH 5HGH YRQ *RWW XQG YRP HLJHQHQ $QHUNDQQWVHLQ GXUFK *RWW(LQP|JOLFKHU2UWVROFKHU6HOEVWWKHPDWLVLHUXQJOlVVWVLFKPLW-QJHOHWZD Ä>L@P*RWWHVGLHQVW³DXVPDFKHQZRÄZLUDXIXQVVHOEVWDOV3HUVRQHQDQJHVSUR FKHQ³ZHUGHQÄGLHPHKUVLQGDOVGLH6XPPHLKUHU7DWHQ³6FKRQGLHEORH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJGHVLQXQVHUHQ%UHLWHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUIUDOOHDUEHLWVIUHLHQ 6RQQWDJVYRPDUEHLWVDPHQ:HUNWDJDEHUYHUPDJGHP0HQVFKHQLQGLHVHP6LQ QHHWZDVEHUVLFKVHOEVW]XVDJHQZLH1RWJHU6OHQF]NDDQVFKDXOLFKIHVWKlOW Ä'XELVWQLFKWQXU0LWWHO]XP=ZHFN³NDQQPDQVLFKGXUFKGLHVRQQWlJOLFKH Ä)UHLVWHOOXQJ YRQ GHU (UZHUEVWlWLJNHLW³ JHVDJW VHLQ ODVVHQ Ä>G@X JHKVW QLFKW GDULQDXI>«@7UlJHUHLQHU)XQNWLRQLP'LHQVWHLQHV*DQ]HQ>]X@VHLQ³VRQGHUQ Ä>G@XELVW³VHOEVWÄHLQLQVLFKZHUWYROOHV*DQ]HVHLQ,QGLYLGXXP³'HUÄDU EHLWVIUHLH>@6RQQWDJ>@³KHEW6OHQF]NDKHUYRULVWHLQÄV\PEROLVFKHU2UWLQGLYL
-h1*(/ (EG -h1*(/ D 6/(1&=.$
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
GXHOOHU)UHLKHLW³ZHLOHUGLHÄNROOHNWLYH(ULQQHUXQJ³GDUDQZDFKKlOWÄGDVVGHU 0HQVFKPHKULVWDOVGLH%HUXIV]ZHFNHXQG$UEHLWV]XVDPPHQKlQJHLQGHQHQHU VWHKW³)UGLH.XOWLYLHUXQJGLHVHVÃV\PEROLVFKHQ2UWVµYHUPDJGHUVRQQWlJOL FKH*RWWHVGLHQVWVHLQHQHLJHQHQ%HLWUDJ]XOHLVWHQ'HUSUDNWLVFKH8PJDQJPLW GHQÄV\PEROLVFKHQ)RUPHQGHUFKULVWOLFKHQhEHUOLHIHUXQJHQG>HQ@%LOGHU>Q@ XQG *HVFKLFKWHQ GLH VLH LQ VLFK EHUJHQ G>HQ@ /LWXUJLHQ GLH GLH FKULVWOLFKH +HLOVJHVFKLFKWH]XU$XIIKUXQJEULQJHQ³PXVVGDQQGDYRQJHOHLWHWVHLQVLHGHQ 6XEMHNWHQ]XP0HGLXPZHUGHQ]XODVVHQXPVLFKPLW:LOKHOP*UlEJHVDJW ÄVHOEVWLQFKULVWOLFKHU)UHLKHLW]XDOOHQ'LQJHQGHV/HEHQVGHQ(UIDKUXQJHQGHV *OFNVXQGGHU1RWLQ'HXWXQJHQYHUKDOWHQ]XN|QQHQ³,QVROFKHPGXUFK FKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VH.RPPXQLNDWLRQDQJHVWRHQHP6LFKYHUKDOWHQN|QQHQVWHFNW GDQQDXFKHLQ3RWHQ]LDO]XU'LVWDQ]QDKPHJHJHQEHUGHUIUGDVDNXWOHLGHQGH 6XEMHNWDOV,OOXVLRQRIIHQVLFKWOLFKJHZRUGHQHQ9RUVWHOOXQJGXUFKGLH%HIROJXQJ YRQEHUXIOLFKHQ/HLVWXQJVDQIRUGHUXQJHQMHPDOVHQGJOWLJH6HOEVWXQG$QHU NHQQXQJVVLFKHUKHLWHUUHLFKHQ]XN|QQHQRGHUPHKUQRFK ]XPVVHQ =ZHLWHQVLVWKLHUMHGRFKNHLQVWDUUHV*HJHQVDW]YHUKlOWQLV]XEHVFKZ|UHQZLH HVVLFKLPRELJHQ.LHUNHJDDUG=LWDW]ZLVFKHQGHPYHUVWXPPHQGHQ6XEMHNWXQG GHPDOOHLQUHGHQGHQ*RWWDQGHXWHWXQGEHL-QJHODXVGUFNOLFK ZLUG-QJHO QlPOLFK HUKHEW GHQ Ä]XU /HLVWXQJ QRFK QLFKW RGHU QLFKW PHKU IlKLJH>Q@ 0HQVFK>HQ@³JHZLVVHUPDHQ]XP,GHDOW\SXVGHVJRWWJHIlOOLJHQ0HQVFKHQLQ VFKDUIHU$EJUHQ]XQJ]XGHPMHQLJHQGHUÄGXUFK>«@HLJHQHV7XQ]XVLFKVHOEVW >]X@NRPPHQ³ YHUVXFKW/HW]WHQ(QGHVHUJLEWVLFKGDUDXVHLQXQGLDOHNWLVFKHV 9HUKlOWQLVYRQSDVVLYHP(UJHKHQXQGDNWLYHP+DQGHOQGDVGHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ YRQÃJHUHFKWµXQGÃVQGLJµJOHLFKNRPPHQVROO'RFKLVWGLHYRP/HLVWXQJVJH GDQNHQEHKHUUVFKWH%HUXIVVSKlUHQLFKWSHUVH]XYHUWHXIHOQXPLKUHLQHKLQWHU GHQ.LUFKHQPDXHUQYHUERUJHQHJXWHVFKOHFKWKLQDXHUDOOWlJOLFKH*HJHQZHOW JHJHQEHU]XVWHOOHQ1XULQPLWWHQGHV$UEHLWVDOOWDJVHQWIDOWHWHGLH)UHLKHLWJ|WW OLFKXQEHGLQJWHQ6HOEVWVHLQVLKUGDUJHOHJWHVNULWLVFKEHJUHQ]HQGHV3RWHQ]LDOGDV PLWKLQDXFKHLQHNRQVWUXNWLYH6HLWHKDW 'LH,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJGHVSHUVRQNRQVWLWXWLYHQ&KDUDNWHUVMHQHU$QHUNHQQXQJ GLHGXUFKEHUXIOLFKH/HLVWXQJVQDFKZHLVHQLHHQGJOWLJ]XHUULQJHQLVWLPSOL]LHUW GLH)UDJHQDFKVR]LDOHQ3UD[LV]XVDPPHQKlQJHQLQQHUKDOEGHUHUGLH6XEMHNWH QLFKWQDFKHLQHU±LPZDKUVWHQ6LQQHGHV:RUWHV±ÃHUVFK|SIHQGHQµ6WDELOLVLH UXQJLKUHUVHOEVWJLHUHQ PVVHQ )RUPHQGHV0LWHLQDQGHUVZlUHQGDVLQGHQHQ GDVMHHLJHQH6FKHLWHUQN|QQHQRGHUPLW5DLQHU*URVVJHVDJWGLHÄHKHUVFKZD FKHQRKQPlFKWLJHQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVDQWHLOHLP%HZXVVWVHLQ³JHKDOWHQZHUGHQ N|QQHQXQGÄQLFKW ZHJHQEHUJURHU6FKDP VRIRUWZLHGHU>]X@YHUGUlQJHQ³
$D2I *5b%I -h1*(/ -h1*(/D *5266
&'DVHUVFK|SIWH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW
VLQGÄ,QHLQHP]ZHLWHQ6FKULWW³ODXW*URVVµ+RIIQXQJÄHUP|JOLFKWGLHVHLQWUD SV\FKLVFKH$QHUNHQQXQJGHUDEJHOHKQWHQ6HOEVWDQWHLOH>«@EHLYLHOHQ0HQVFKHQ DXFKHLQHLQWHUSHUVRQDOH7ROHUDQ]JHJHQEHUDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQ0LWJHIKODXFK IUGHUHQ6FKZlFKH³(LQHVROFKHPSDWKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHGLHHLQHSDUWLHOOH %HJUHQ]XQJGHUUHLQHQ.RQNXUUHQ]ORJLNEHGHXWHWHLP%OLFNDXIDQGHUHHLQ]X QHKPHQOlVVWVLFKQLFKWHU]ZLQJHQ6LHVHW]WZLH*URVVHLQUlXPWYRUDXVGDVV GDVÄ,QGLYLGXXPVLFK>«@DOV>«@ÃXQKHLOEDUµNRQIOLNWKDIWHV6XEMHNW>]X@EH JUHLIHQ³XQGYRQGDKHUÄ8QVLFKHUKHLWXQG$PELYDOHQ]>«@>]X@WROHULHU>HQ@³ YHUPDJ'DVVLFKLPUHOLJL|VHQ*RWWHVEH]XJDXVVSUHFKHQGH9HUWUDXHQMHQVHLWV GHVVFKZDQNHQGHQ%RGHQVVR]LDOHU$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHVHOEVWVFKRQHW ZDVXQGYRQGDKHUQLFKWQXUÃLQGLH:HOWJHZRUIHQµVRQGHUQDXFKÃLQGHU:HOW JHWUDJHQµ]XVHLQN|QQWHVLFKKLHUXQEHVFKDGHWDOOHUEOHLEHQGHQ6SDQQXQJHQ DOVOHEHQVGLHQOLFKHUZHLVHQ(VHQWKlOWGLHGHQVFKHLWHUQGHQ$QGHUHQHLQEH]LH KHQGH+RIIQXQJGDVVQRFKODQJHQLFKWÃIHUWLJPLWVLFKVHOEVWµVHLQPXVVZHUPLW GHUHLJHQHQ/HLVWXQJVNUDIWDP(QGHLVW
(EG (EG
&%LQLFKZDVZLUVLQG"'DVLGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKH 6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW $OOJHPHLQKHLWVEH]XJXQG%HVRQGHUXQJVZLOOH GLH&UX[PLW GHU,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN Ä>'@DVLVWGLH&UX[PLWGHU,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNGDVVVLHXQVGD]XEULQJWLQ0XVWHUQ ]X VSUHFKHQ GLH ZLU MD HLJHQWOLFK VSUHQJHQ ZROOHQ³ JLEW GLH .XOWXUZLVVHQ VFKDIWOHULQXQG5RPDQDXWRULQ0LWKX6DQ\DOLP/DXIHHLQHVXQOlQJVWSXEOL]LHUWHQ ,QWHUYLHZV ]X 3URWRNROO Ä)UDXHQ PXVVWHQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH ÃJHQXLQ ZHLEOLFKHµ (UIDKUXQJHQYRUEULQJHQ>«@XPLKUH5HFKWHHLQIRUGHUQ]XN|QQHQ³IJWVLH H[HPSODULVFKDQ'DGXUFKDEHUZXUGHHLQÃ0XVWHUµGDVPDQÃHLJHQWOLFKVSUHQ JHQZROOWHµZHLOHVGHPEHNlPSIWHQ8QUHFKW]XJUXQGHODJXQWHUJUQGLJZHLWHU WUDGLHUW GDVV)UDXHQZHVHQWOLFKDQGHUVVLQGDOV0lQQHULQVRIHUQVLHÃJHQXLQ ZHLEOLFKH(UIDKUXQJHQµPDFKHQ'HULGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKH)DFKMDUJRQVSULFKWKLHU YRQÄVWUDWHJLVFKHP(VVHQ]LDOLVPXV³(UXQWHUVWUHLFKWGDPLWGDVVGLHGLIIHUHQWH %HVRQGHUKHLWGHUMHHLJHQHQ±NROOHNWLYHQ±,GHQWLWlWJDQ]EHZXVVWEHUEHWRQW ZHUGHQ PXVV XP GDV DQYLVLHUWH =LHO ]X HUUHLFKHQ GLH ÄJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWH>@ $QHUNHQQXQJ>«@DXVJHJUHQ]WHU>«@0LQGHUKHLWHQ³'DVVLQGÄXQWHUDQGHUHP HWKQLVFKH0LQGHUKHLWHQZLHGLH,QGLDQHUGLH$IURDPHULNDQHUXQGGLH+LVSDQLFV LQGHQ86$)UDXHQ6FKZXOHXQG/HVEHQ7UDQVXQG,QWHUVH[XHOOH$OWH2E GDFKORVH([3V\FKLDWULHSDWLHQWHQXQG%HKLQGHUWH³=XGLHVHPHJDOLWDULVWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVVWUHEHQVWHKWGLH]XJOHLFKVWUDWHJLVFKIRUFLHUWH8QJOHLFKKHLWGLH GHUMHZHLOVEHWURIIHQHQVR]LDOHQ*UXSSHDOOHQ$QGHUHQJHJHQEHU]XNRPPHQ VROODOOHUGLQJVLQQLFKWXQHUKHEOLFKHU6SDQQXQJ(EHQGDULQVFKOlJWVLFKGLHYRQ 6DQ\DODQJHVSURFKHQHÃ&UX[GHU,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNµQLHGHU
6&+(//(59JO]XP7KHPD,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNEHUEOLFNVPlLJ 0(«@)RURQFHVXFKDVWURQJPDQWDNHVRIILFHQRERG\FDQSUHGLFWZKDW ZLOOKDSSHQ>«@2QHWKLQJWKDWLVYHU\OLNHO\WRKDSSHQLVWKDWWKHJDLQVPDGHLQWKHSDVWIRUW\ \HDUVE\EODFNDQGEURZQ$PHULFDQVDQGE\KRPRVH[XDOVZLOOEHZLSHGRXW>«@$OOWKH UHVHQWPHQWZKLFKEDGO\HGXFDWHG$PHULFDQVIHHODERXWKDYLQJWKHLUPDQQHUVGLFWDWHGWRWKHP E\FROOHJHJUDGXDWHVZLOOILQGDQRXWOHW
0LWGHU:DKO'RQDOG7UXPSV]XP863UlVLGHQWHQLP1RYHPEHUVDKHQ QLFKW ZHQLJH 5RUW\V =XNXQIWVSURJQRVH ]XU JHJHQZlUWLJHQ :LUNOLFKNHLW ZHU GHQ 'DUEHU KLQDXV HQWZLFNHOWH VLFK GHU $XVGUXFN Ä,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN³ LP 1DFKJDQJGLHVHUDOV)DQDOZDKUJHQRPPHQHQ$EVWLPPXQJÄ]XHLQHUXELTXLWlUHQ &KLIIUHIUGLH3UREOHPHGHU/LQNHQXQGLKUHU9HUDQWZRUWXQJIUGHQ(UIROJGHU 1HXHQ5HFKWHQ³±XQG]ZDUQLFKWQXULQQHUKDOEGHU86$$XFKÄGDV%UH[LW 9RWXPGHU$XIVWLHJGHU $I'XQGGLH6WlUNHUHFKWHU3DUWHLHQLQ]DKOUHLFKHQ /lQGHUQ(XURSDV³VWLHHQ.RQWURYHUVHQGDUEHUDQZDVVLFKGLHGDULQQLHGHU VFKODJHQGHÄ5HFKWVZHQGH³DXVJHO|VWKDEHQN|QQWH4XHUGXUFKGLHSROLWLVFKHQ /DJHUZLUGHVLQQHUKDOEGHUVLFKELV]XPKHXWLJHQ7DJHXPGLHVHQ$XVGUXFN UDQNHQGHQ|IIHQWOLFKPHGLDOHQ'DXHUGHEDWWHQIUSODXVLEHOJHKDOWHQGHU,GHQWL WlWVSROLWLNGLH6FKXOGDQGHURIIHQVLFKWOLFKJHZRUGHQHQ'HPRNUDWLHNULVHGHU *HJHQZDUW]XJHEHQÄ6LHVHLSDUWLNXODUXQGYHUVWHOOHGHQ%OLFNDXIGLHJURHQ
9$1',@QGHPHUHLQHGHU$OWHUQDWLYHQNXOWXUHOOHU,GHQWLWlWVELO GXQJLP5FNJULIIDXIJHKHLOLJWH7UDGLWLRQHQRGHUNQVWOLFKLPPXQLVLHUWH*H ZLVVKHLWHQ DEVROXW VHW]W³ XQG ÄDQ GLH 6WHOOH GHU PRGHUQHQ 2IIHQKHLW WUHWHQ >OlVVW@³VFKDIIWGHU)XQGDPHQWDOLVPXVHLQDWWUDNWLYHV Ä$QJHERWIUNXOWXUHOO YHUXQVLFKHUWHLQLKUHUDQJHVWDPPWHQ,GHQWLWlWJHNUlQNWHRGHUVR]LDO|NRQRPLVFK HQWZXU]HOWH,QGLYLGXHQXQG.ROOHNWLYH³0LWGHQUHOLJL|VHQ$EVROXWKHLWVDQ VSUFKHQVLQGPLWKLQSROLWLVFKH+HUUVFKDIWVDPELWLRQHQYHUEXQGHQGLHDXIGHQ $XVVFKOXVVZHQQQLFKWGLH9HUQLFKWXQJDOOHU$QGHUVJODXEHQGHQKLQDXVODXIHQ :lKUHQGKLHUGLHUHOLJL|VH=XJHK|ULJNHLWEHU,QRGHU([NOXVLRQ±E]Z/HEHQ
$D2 $D2 $D2I $D2 $D2 0(«@HLQVHW]W³GDPLWLKQHQDQJHVLFKWVPDQQLJ IDFKHU'LVNULPLQLHUXQJVHUIDKUXQJHQLPMHZHLOLJHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ.RQWH[W Ä*OHLFKVWHOOXQJXQG(PDQ]LSDWLRQ³]XWHLOZHUGH6LHHQWVSULFKWLP*HJHQVDW] ]XGHQEHLGHQSHUVHÃ,GHQWLWlWVZDKQµI|UGHUQGHQ$OWHUQDWLYYDULDQWHQJUXQGVlW] OLFKGHPZDV0H\HUHLQHÄNRQVWUXNWLYH,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN³QHQQW(VJHKWLKU GHPQDFK]XQlFKVWHLQPDOGDUXPGHQÄIDLUHQ8PJDQJXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHUNXOWX UHOOHU,GHQWLWlWHQPLWHLQDQGHU³LQQHUKDOEHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW]XEH I|UGHUQLQGHPDQÄNXOWXUHOOH=XJHK|ULJNHLWRGHU=XUHFKQXQJ³JHNRSSHOWHÄ%H QDFKWHLOLJXQJHQ³EHUZXQGHQZHUGHQ$XINRQVWUXNWLYHP3IDGEOHLEWGLHVHU 7\SXVYRQ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNDOOHUGLQJVQXUVRODQJHIRUPXOLHUW0H\HUHLQVFKUlQ NHQGZLHHUVLFKRIIHQIUÄGLH9HUVWlQGLJXQJEHUJHPHLQVDPH+DQGOXQJV
0(«@8Q WHUVFKLHGHQ³]HLJW-HQVHLWVGLHVHU$OOJHPHLQKHLWVRULHQWLHUXQJGURKWSURJUHVVLYH Ä$QWLGLVNULPLQLHUXQJVSROLWLN³LQHLQHUHJUHVVLYHÄ'LVNULPLQLHUXQJVSROLWLN³XP ]XVFKODJHQGLHOHW]WHQ(QGHVÄ'RPLQDQ]8QJOHLFKKHLW1LFKWDQHUNHQQXQJXQG $XVVFKOXVV³EHI|UGHUW 'DVVHLQVROFKHU:HJYRQVHLWHQÃOLQNHU,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNµEHVFKULWWHQZLUGLVW GHU7HQRUGHULKUJHJHQZlUWLJHQWJHJHQVFKODJHQGHQ.ULWLNGHUHQ*UXQGYRUZXUI REHQEHUHLWV]LWLHUWZXUGH 6LHYHUWUHWHÄ3DUWLNXODULQWHUHVVHQYRQ0LQGHUKHLWHQ ]XODVWHQHLQHV³±DXIJHJQHULVFKHU6HLWHÄXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKJHIDVVWHQ³±Ä$OOJH PHLQHQ³1DFKHLQHPZHLWHUHQ$XV]XJDXV6DQ\DOV5RPDQZLUGLP)ROJHQGHQ HLQDQGLH6R]LRORJLQ6LONHYDQ'\NDQVFKOLHHQGHU%OLFNDXIGLHXQWHUVFKLHGOL FKHQ$XVIRUPXQJHQGLHVHU7KHVHJHZRUIHQ
'DV3DUWLNXODUHDXI.RVWHQGHV$OOJHPHLQHQ ]XU.ULWLNOLQNHU ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN Ä:DV]XU=HLWDQGHQ8QLYHUVLWlWHQSDVVLHUWXQGVLFKYRQGRUWDXVDXIGLHJHVDP WH*HVHOOVFKDIWDXVEUHLWHWLVWHLQNROOHNWLYLVWLVFKHV1DUUDWLYGDVLFKIU]XWLHIVW JHIlKUOLFKKDOWH³SURNODPLHUWGHUNDQDGLVFKH3V\FKRORJH-RUGDQ3HWHUVRQDQ OlVVOLFKHLQHU'HEDWWHPLW6DQ\DOV5RPDQILJXU6DUDVZDWL3HWHUVRQGHULQ,GHQ WLWWLDOVOLWHUDULVFKH*HVWDOWDXIWULWWLVWDXFKLPZLUNOLFKHQ/HEHQHLQVFKDUIHU .ULWLNHUÃOLQNHU,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNµ Ä'LH+DXSWDXVVDJHGLHVHU,GHRORJLH³IJWHU DQVHLHVGDVVÄGLH:HOW>«@DOVHLQ.DPSIIHOG>«@XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH>U@*UXS SHQ³ YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ PVVH ZDV SUREOHPDWLVFKH )ROJHQ KDEH Ä'DGXUFK VFKDIIHQZLUMHGH,GHHYRQVHOEVWlQGLJHQ,QGLYLGXHQDEMHGH9RUVWHOOXQJYRQ LQGLYLGXHOOHU 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ³ $XI VHLQ %HNHQQWQLV KLQ HU ZUGH IU ÄGLH *OHLFKEHUHFKWLJXQJYRQ0HQVFKHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU+HUNXQIW³HLQWUHWHQÄVR ODQJH GDPLW &KDQFHQJOHLFKKHLW JHPHLQW LVW³ XQG NHLQH NQVWOLFK KHUJHVWHOOWH Ä(UJHEQLVJOHLFKKHLW³HUZLGHUW6DUDVZDWLHU]UQW &KDQFHQJOHLFKKHLWLVWHLQHIDWDOH/JH>«@:LUVXJJHULHUHQGHQ6FKZlFKHUHQ (VZDUGRFK DOOHVJOHLFKDOVRPXVVHVDQHXFKOLHJHQZHQQLKU]XUFNEOHLEW:RPLWZLUOHXJQHQGDVVHV XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQJLEW
,QGHUILQJLHUWHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ]ZLVFKHQ6DUDVZDWLXQG3HWHUVRQGLHEUL JHQVUHDOH$XVVDJHQGHVOHW]WHUHQKHUEHL]LWLHUWNRPPWPDQFKHV]XU6SUDFKH
$D2+HUYRUKG9HUI $D2 9$1'7@KH\WKUHZWKHPVHOYHVLQWRWKHPRYHPHQW SROLWLFVRILGHQWLW\ORVLQJDVHQVHRIZKDWZHVKDUHDVFLWL]HQVDQGZKDWELQGVXV DVDQDWLRQ³XUWHLOW/LOODLQVHLQHU6WUHLWVFKULIW7KHRQFHDQGIXWXUH/LEHUDOEHU GLHÄ$PHULFDQ/LEHUDOV³DXVGHU'HPRNUDWLVFKHQ3DUWHL'HQ:DKOVLHJGHV UHSXEOLNDQLVFKHQ.DQGLGDWHQ7UXPSVLHKWHUDOV.RQVHTXHQ]GHUYRQGHPRNUDWL VFKHU6HLWHVHLWGHQ HU-DKUHQ]XQHKPHQGEHI|UGHUWHQÄSVHXGRSROLWLFVRI VHOIUHJDUGDQGLQFUHDVLQJO\QDUURZDQGH[FOXVLRQDU\VHOIGHILQLWLRQ³DQGLHLQ DNDGHPLVFKHQ.RQWH[WHQNXOWLYLHUWZRUGHQVHLÄ7KH\DUHORVLQJ³IDVVW/LOODGLH LP )DQDO YRQ NXOPLQLHUHQGH (QWZLFNOXQJ PLW PHWDSKRULVFKHQ 0LWWHOQ ]XVDPPHQÄEHFDXVHWKH\KDYHUHWUHDWHGLQWRFDYHVWKH\KDYHFDUYHGIRUWKHP VHOYHVLQWKHVLGHRIZKDWRQFHZDVDJUHDWPRXQWDLQ³$OVHLQ]HQWUDOHV*UQ GXQJVGRNXPHQWGLHVHVSURJUDPPDWLVFKHQ5FN]XJVLQGLHHQJH%HKDXVXQJGHU TXD*UXSSHQ]XJHK|ULJNHLWJHVWLIWHWHQMHHLJHQHQ,GHQWLWlWDXVGHUNHLQ:HJDXI GHQÃJUHDWPRXQWDLQµHLQHVDOOHÃFLWL]HQVµEHWUHIIHQGHQXQGYHUELQGHQGHQÄFRP PRQJRRG³IKUWZHLVW/LOODGDVÄ&RPEDKHH5LYHU&ROOHFWLYH6WDWHPHQW³DXV ,QGHP GXUFKHLQH*UXSSHYRQÄ%ODFNIHPLQLVWVDQG/HVELDQV³YHUIDVVWHQ
9$1'Q@,UUZHJ>«@ GHULQGHQYHUJDQJHQHQ-DKUHQYRQ7UXPSEHU%ROVRQDURELV]XU$I'ZLHGHUHUVFKUHFNHQG RIWEHVFKULWWHQZRUGHQLVWXQGNODUPDFKWGDVVGDV3RVWXODWHLQHUZLHDXFKLPPHULPDJLQLHUWHQ 1RUPDOLWlWQXUEHU$EZHUWXQJGHV$QGHUVDUWLJHQIXQNWLRQLHUW© *(11,(6 :HQQJOHLFK GLHVHU9RUZXUIGHQXQEHVFKROWHQHQ7KLHUVHXQEHUHFKWLJWHU:HLVHWULIIWGHUVLFKLP(LQVDW] JHJHQ 5DVVLVPXV HLQHQ 1DPHQ JHPDFKW KDW ZHLVW *HQQLHV GRFK DXI HLQ 3UREOHP GHU ,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLN.ULWLNKLQDXIGDVLFKXQWHQQRFKHLQJHKHQZHUGH 9$1'«@'DPLWVLHLKUH9HUXQVLFKHUXQJQLFKWEHPHUNWHVDJWH 1LYHGLWDVFKQHOO Ã,QGHULQYLHOOHLFKWQLFKWDEHU&RORXULVWHLQH.DWHJRULH1lPOLFKHLQH8Q WHUGUFNXQJVNDWHJRULH'DVNDQQPDQVLFKQLFKWHLQIDFKVRDXVVXFKHQµ6DUDVZDWLOLHLKUHQ /DSWRS]XVFKQDSSHQXQGHQWJHJQHWH Ã$QVFKHLQHQGGRFKµ
Ä,GHQWLWlWLVWHLQHQRWZHQGLJH/JH³IDVVWVLHGLHVH+DOWXQJLP/DXIHGHV*H VSUlFKVQRFKHLQPDO]XVDPPHQ$OV6DUDVZDWLGDQQDP(QGHGHV5RPDQVPLW GHP3KLORVRSKHQ.ZDPH$QWKRQ\$SSLDKHLQ3RGLXPVJHVSUlFK]XLKUHP)DOO IKUWNRPPWGLH)UDJHDXIRENROOHNWLYH,GHQWLWlWHQZLH]%UDFHVR]LDONRQV WUXLHUWVHLHQ$SSLDKEHMDKWPHUNWDEHUDQHUZROOHGDPLWDXVGUFNOLFKÄQLFKW³ JHVDJWKDEHQÄGDVVVLHEHOLHELJVLQG³ 'LHLURQLVFKH:HQGXQJGLH6DQ\DOLKUHU*HVFKLFKWHJLEWIKUWGHQ=ZLH VSDOWGHUGHPLGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKHQ.DPSIXPJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWH$QHUNHQQXQJ LQQHZRKQWQRFKHLQPDOQHXYRU$XJHQ 'HUGHP$OOJHPHLQKHLWVEH]XJWHQGHQ ]LHOOZLGHUVWUHLWHQGH%HVRQGHUXQJVZLOOHJUQGHWGHPQDFKDXIHLQHUÃQRWZHQGL JHQ/JHµDXINROOHNWLYHQ,GHQWLWlWHQGLHHEHQVRÃNRQVWUXLHUWµVLQGZLHLKQHQ HLQÃXQEHOLHELJHUµ&KDUDNWHUHLJQHW0DQNDQQVLHVLFKÃHLQIDFKVRDXVVXFKHQµ DEHU±VRNDQQPDQ6DQ\DOV5RPDQYHUVWHKHQ±PDQPXVVHVLUJHQGZLHDXFK 1LFKWRKQH*UXQGOlVVWVLH.ZDPH$QWKRQ\$SSLDKEULJHQVZLHGHUXPPLWUHDO JHWlWLJWHQ$XVVDJHQLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJDXIWUHWHQ'HQQGHUEULWLVFK JKDQDLVFKH3KLORVRSKDXIGHPLP)ROJHQGHQUHNXUULHUWZLUGKDWVLFKPLWGHP DPELYDOHQWHQ&KDUDNWHUNROOHNWLYHU,GHQWLWlWHQXPGHUHQ$QHUNHQQXQJLGHQWL WlWVSROLWLVFKVWHWVJHNlPSIWZLUGLQWHQVLYEHVFKlIWLJW Ä,IZKDWPDWWHUVDERXWPHLVP\LQGLYLGXDODQGDXWKHQWLFVHOIZK\LVVRPXFK FRQWHPSRUDU\WDONRILGHQWLW\DERXWODUJHFDWHJRULHV±JHQGHUHWKQLFLW\QDWLR QDOLW\ÃUDFHµVH[XDOLW\±WKDWVHHPVRIDUIURPLQGLYLGXDO"³IUDJW$SSLDK]X
6$1«@FDQEHKDSS\ZLWKLQWKH ORQJHUUXQ³ $SSLDKYHUQHLQWGLHVH)UDJHGHQQHUVLHKWLQGHUSROLWLVFKHQ)RU GHUXQJDOVÃVFKZDU]µRGHUÃKRPRVH[XHOOµDQHUNDQQW]XZHUGHQGHQWHQGHQ]LHO OHQ=ZDQJLPSOL]LHUWGDVVVLFKGLHPLWGHQEHVDJWHQ,GHQWLWlWVPHUNPDOHQDXV JHVWDWWHWHQ3HUVRQHQZLHGHUXPDOO]XHLQGHXWLJHQÄVFULSWVWKDWJRZLWKEHLQJDQ $IULFDQ$PHULFDQRUKDYLQJVDPHVH[GHVLUHV³]XXQWHUZHUIHQKDEHQ$QVWDWW DEHUVRVHLQH)RUPXOLHUXQJHLQH7\UDQQHLGXUFKHLQHDQGHUH]XHUVHW]HQZLOOHU GDVMHLQGLYLGXHOOH3RWHQ]LDOGHV:lKOHQN|QQHQVVWDUNPDFKHQ$XVGUFNOLFK IRUGHUW$SSLDKKLHUGHQÄUHVSHFWIRUDXWRQRP\³HLQ-HGHP0HQVFKHQLVWGHP QDFKGLH0|JOLFKNHLWHLQ]XUlXPHQVLFK]XGHQNROOHNWLYHQ,GHQWLWlWVPHUNPDOHQ GLHLKQYRQ*HEXUWDQXQHQWULQQEDUEHVWLPPHQDXIGLH:HLVHVHOEVW]XYHUKDO WHQGDVVHVLKPREOLHJWZDVJHQDXVLHIULKQSHUV|QOLFKEHGHXWHQ6RN|QQWHQ VLHHQWJHJHQLKUHUSROLWLVFKHQhEHUK|KXQJDXIGHQ5DQJYRQÄSHUVRQDOGLPHQVL RQVRIWKHVHOI³KHUDEJHVWXIWXQG(LJHQVFKDIWHQZLHÄLQWHOOLJHQFHFKDUPZLW FXSLGLW\³JOHLFKZHUGHQLQGHUHQMHEHVRQGHUHPXQGXQHLQGHXWLJEOHLEHQGHQ 0LVFKYHUKlOWQLVVLFKGLHXQYHUJOHLFKOLFKH(LJHQDUWHLQHVMHGHQ0HQVFKHQPDQL
$D29JOGD]XDXFKGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ3DVVDJHQLQ GHUVIIII $33,$+ $D2I (EG $D2 (EG $D2 $D2
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
IHVWLHUW'DPLWLVWHLQH'LPHQVLRQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQVHUUHLFKWGLHEHUHLWV ]XUDEVFKOLHHQGHQWKHRORJLVFKHQ5HIOH[LRQKLQEHUZHLVW
-HQVHLWVGHV DQWL LGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKHQ:LU WKHRORJLVFKH 5HIOH[LRQHQLP$QVFKOXVVDQ)DON:DJQHU .ZDPH$QWKRQ\$SSLDKVMQJVWHV%XFK7KHOLHVWKDWELQGLQGHPHUGHQILQ JLHUWHQ&KDUDNWHUYHUVFKLHGHQHUNROOHNWLYHU,GHQWLWlWVNDWHJRULHQ±&UHHG&RXQW U\&RORXU&ODVV&XOWXUH±KHUDXVDUEHLWHWHQGHWPLWHLQHP'LNWXPGHVDQWLNHQ 'LFKWHUV3XEOLXV7HUHQWLXV$IHUÄ,FKELQHLQ0HQVFKQLFKWV0HQVFKOLFKHVLVW PLUIUHPG³KHLWHVEHL7HUHQWLXVGHUHLQVWDOVDIULNDQLVFKHU6NODYHQDFK5RP JHODQJWLVW)U$SSLDKNRPPWGDULQZLHHUDEVFKOLHHQGQRFKDQIJWHWZDV (QWVFKHLGHQGHV]XP$XVGUXFN ÄWKHUH¶VDQLGHQWLW\WKDWVKRXOGELQGXVDOO³± ÄRXUFRPPRQKXPDQLW\³3DVVHQGGD]XVWHKHQDP(QGHYRQ0LWKX6DQ\DOV ,GHQWLWWL*HGDQNHQGHU3URWDJRQLVWLQ1LYHGLWDEHUÄGDVZDVXQVDOOHYHUELQGHW³ $OVR-XGLWK%XWOHUVDJW>«@0HQVFKVHLQKHLW9HUOHW]OLFKVHLQ$EHUZLUVLQGHEHQQLFKWQXU LP6FKPHU]YHUHLQWZLUVLQGDXFKLQGHU/LHEHYHUHLQW,P,QWHUHVVHDQHLQDQGHULQ(PSDWKLH XQG$QWHLOQDKPH:LUVLQGDOOHGDGXUFKDOOH:LUDOOHVLQGYLHOH:LUDOOHVLQGDOOH*HVFKOHFK WHUDOOHUDFHVDOOH.ODVVHQDOOH.DVWHQZLUDOOHVLQGJDQ]XQUHOLJL|VGDV:XQGHUGHU6FK|S IXQJXQGDOVVROFKHVVROOWHQZLU]ZLVFKHQGXUFKDEXQG]XLQQHKDOWHQXQGGHQ6FKDXHUGHU (KUIXUFKWYRUXQVHUHUNRPSOH[HQ([LVWHQ]YHUVSUHQ
:DVKLHUÃJDQ]XQUHOLJL|VµGDVÃ(KUIXUFKWµKHLVFKHQGHÃ:XQGHUGHU6FK|SIXQJµ JHQDQQWZLUGLVWÃXQVHUHNRPSOH[H([LVWHQ]µDOV0HQVFKHQ GDVVÃZLUDOOHYLHOH VLQGµXQGQLHQXUHLQGHXWLJGLHHLQHQ=XU:LU,GHQWLWlWGLHVHVEHUJUHLIHQGHQ +XPDQLWlWVEHZXVVWVHLQVDEHUIKUWKHLWHVLP5RPDQZHLWHUDOOHLQGLHÃ/LHEHµ GKZDKUKDIWHVÃ,QWHUHVVHDQHLQDQGHUµZHFKVHOVHLWLJHÃ(PSDWKLHXQG$QWHLO QDKPHµ'HQDQVROFKGLIIHUHQ]EHUVWHLJHQGHP$XVWDXVFK%HWHLOLJWHQYHUPDJ GHPQDFK±LP%H]XJDXIVLFKXQG$QGHUH±GHXWOLFK]XZHUGHQGDVVGDVZDV VLHTXDVR]LRNXOWXUHOOHU3UlJXQJVLQGQLFKWDOOHVLVWZDVVLHLQGLYLGXHOODXV PDFKWXQGZDVVLHVHOEVWVHLQN|QQWHQ 'LHVHVÃ:XQGHUGHU6FK|SIXQJµGDVÃZLUDOOHVLQGµQlPOLFKQLFKWYROOHQGV XQWHU JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFK YRUJHSUlJWH ,GHQWLWlWVNDWHJRULHQ VXEVXPLHUEDUH,QGLYL GXHQOlVVWVLFKJOHLFKVDPDXFKÃJDQ]UHOLJL|VµDXVOHJHQ 0LW)DON:DJQHU JHVDJW (VJHK|UW]XUÄJHLVWOLFKVDFKOLFKHQ(LJHQDUWGHUFKULVWOLFKHQ5HOLJLRQ³ GHQ0HQVFKHQÄXQDEKlQJLJYRQELRORJLVFKJHVFKOHFKWOLFKHQUDVVLVFKHQQDWLR QDOHQXQGVR]LDOHQ=XUHFKQXQJHQ³DQHUNDQQWVHLQ]XODVVHQ±GHQQÄYRU*RWW
$D2 (EG 6$1VLQG@DOOH0HQVFKHQJOHLFK³%HL:DJQHUYHUELQGHWVLFKPLWGLHVHP*UXQGPR WLYHLQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHU5HOHYDQ]DQVSUXFKLQVRIHUQHVGDV$QJHERWHQWKlOW VLFKGHUMHHLJHQHQ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWDQJHVLFKWVLKUHU%HGURKWKHLWGXUFKGHQYRQ VR]LDOHU6HLWHDXVJHKHQGHQ$QSDVVXQJVXQG(UZDUWXQJVGUXFNLPPHUZLHGHU]X YHUJHZLVVHUQ$SSLDKVLPOHW]WHQ$EVFKQLWWGDUJHOHJWHV3OlGR\HUIUGLH$XWR QRPLHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ:lKOHQN|QQHQVGDVHUJHJHQEHUGHPLGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFK EHWULHEHQHQ,GHQWLIL]LHUWZHUGHQPLWJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKJHWHLOWHQ(LJHQVFKDIWHQ± UDFHJHQGHUHWF±HUKHEWOlVVWVLFKGDUDQJXWDQNQSIHQ&KULVWOLFKHUVHLWVYRQ HLQHUJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ$OOHUGXUFK*RWW]XUHGHQZLH:DJQHUHV QDKHOHJWKDWVRJHVHKHQ]XP=LHOGLHVHV0RPHQWIUHLHQ6LFKYHUKDOWHQVLQ%H ]XJDXIGLHVFKLHUXQDElQGHUOLFKH%HVWLPPWKHLWGXUFKVR]LDOH*UXSSHQ]XJHK| ULJNHLWHQEHZXVVW]XPDFKHQXPGDV6XEMHNW]XHLQHPVHOEVWEHVWLPPWHQ8P JDQJGDPLW]XHUPXWLJHQ9RQKLHUDXVODVVHQVLFKDXFKGLH$XVIKUXQJHQGHU ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ $EVFKQLWWH DXV WKHRORJLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH LP $QVFKOXVV DQ :DJQHUUHNDSLWXOLHUHQ $P$QIDQJGHV.DSLWHOVZXUGHHLQIUÃOLQNH,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNµFKDUDNWHULVWL VFKHU 6SDQQXQJVFKDUDNWHU KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHW GHU GDULQ EHJUQGHW LVW GDVV VLH JOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWH$QHUNHQQXQJIUGLVNULPLQLHUWH*UXSSHQHUVWUHLWHQZLOOXQG JOHLFK]HLWLJGHUHQXQYHUJOHLFKOLFKH%HVRQGHUKHLWEHU*HEKUJHOWHQGPDFKW /HW]WHUHVKDWVLFKLQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW7KRPDV0H\HUDOV*UXQGHLQHV SRWHQ]LHOOHQ8PVFKODJVLKUHVHLJHQWOLFKNRQVWUXNWLYHQ8PJDQJVPLWGHUVSH]L ILVFKPRGHUQHQ$QZHVHQKHLWYRQ'LIIHUHQ]LQGHVWUXNWLYHQ,GHQWLWlWVZDKQHU ZLHVHQ bKQOLFKHVEHNODJHQGLHNULWLVFKJHJHQVLHDXIJHEUDFKWHQ6SDOWXQJV $EOHQNXQJVXQG1HROLEHUDOLVPXVYRUZUIHLQVRIHUQVLHÃOLQNH,GHQWLWlWVSROLWLNµ EH]LFKWLJHQRKQH5FNVLFKWDXI9HUOXVWHGLHGLIIHUHQWHQ$QOLHJHQ$QGHUHURGHU GDV*HPHLQZRKOXPGLH'XUFKVHW]XQJLKUHUSDUWLNXODUHQ,QWHUHVVHQ3RVLWLRQHQ XQG *HOWXQJVEHGUIQLVVH ]X NlPSIHQ ,P $QVFKOXVV DQ 0H\HU OlVVW VLFK GLH H[NOXVLYLVWLVFKH7HQGHQ]GLHVHVHLJHQWOLFKDXI,QNOXVLRQ]LHOHQGHQ(QJDJHPHQWV DOV$XVGUXFNHLQHVGXUFKJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH'LIIHUHQ]HUIDKUXQJHQ]XWLHIVWLUULWLHU WHQ,GHQWLWlWVEHZXVVWVHLQVEHJUHLIHQ'DV6LFK$EVFKOLHHQJHJHQ$QGHUHHU ZlFKVWGHPQDFKGDUDXVGDVVPDQÄ9HUVFKLHGHQDUWLJNHLW,QIUDJHVWHOOXQJ:L GHUVSUXFKLQGHUVR]LDOHQ8PZHOW>«@DOV%HGURKXQJXQG4XHOOHOlKPHQGHU $QJVWDOV9HUZHLJHUXQJVHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJHPSILQGHQPXVV³ (LQH9RUDXVVHW]XQJXPVROFKHP(PSILQGXQJV]ZDQJHQWIOLHKHQ]XN|QQHQ LVWQDFK0H\HUÄGLH)lKLJNHLW>«@'LVWDQ]]XGHQMHZHLOVEHUQRPPHQHQHLJH QHQ5ROOHQ³XQGÄVR]LDOHQ=XJHK|ULJNHLW>HQ@³HLQ]XQHKPHQ $XIQLFKWVDQGH UHV DOV GDUDXI HLQ VROFKHV 'LVWDQ]LHUXQJVYHUP|JHQ ]X EHVWlUNHQ ]LHOW HLQH FKULVWOLFKH5HOLJLRQLQGHUHVLPVRHEHQHQWIDOWHWHQ6LQQHXPGLH9HUJHZLVVH
:$*1(5S 0(ZHUWHW@³'RFKJHKRUFKWGHU%OLFNGHVDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQQLFKWSHU VHGHP:XQVFKGDQDFKJHOLHEW]XZHUGHQXQGVLFKVRLPHLJHQHQ6HOEVWVHLQ DXIJHZHUWHWRGHUDQHUNDQQW]XHUIDKUHQ:HUGDVZLOOPDFKWVLFKYLHOPHKULP PHUDXFKDEKlQJLJXQGVHW]WVLFKGHPXQHU]ZLQJEDUHQÃ-DµGHV*HJHQEHUVDXV (EHQGDUXPDEHUKlOWGLH/LHEHQLFKWXQEHGLQJWZDVPDQVLFKYRQLKUYHUVSULFKW ,QVEHVRQGHUHÄLQGHU0RGHUQH³ZRVLHDXV,OORX]µVR]LRORJLVFKHU6LFKWÄGDV SULPlUHXQGZLFKWLJVWH7HUUDLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJELOGHW³LVWVLHGHVKDOEQLFKW QXUHLQHÄHUVHKQWH³VRQGHUQÄDXFKHLQHVFKZLHULJH(UIDKUXQJ³ /LHEHVWHOOW HEHQVRHLQHÄ4XHOOHYRQ:HUW³ZLHZHLOPDQVLFKKLHUGHPÃ%OLFNHLQHVDQGH UHQµXQZHLJHUOLFKDXVVHW]HQPXVVHLQHÄ4XHOOHGHU8QVLFKHUKHLW³XQGGHUÄ%H GURKXQJGHU$XWRQRPLH³GDU 'LHVHU$PELYDOHQ]VROOQXQLP$QVFKOXVVDQ(YD,OORX]XQGPLWH[HPSODUL VFKHQ9HUZHLVHQDXI6DOO\5RRQH\VHLQJDQJV]LWLHUWHQ5RPDQZHLWHUQDFKJH JDQJHQZHUGHQ'DEHLULFKWHWVLFKGHU)RNXV]XQlFKVWDXIGLHVSH]LILVFKH8QVL FKHUKHLWVHUIDKUXQJGLHGDPLWYHUEXQGHQLVWGDVV/LHEHVYHUKlOWQLVVH]XPÃZLFK WLJVWHQ7HUUDLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJµJHZRUGHQVLQG 'DQQZLUGGLHIUURPDQWL VFKH%H]LHKXQJHQHEHQIDOOVFKDUDNWHULVWLVFKHÄ6SDQQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ SDVVLHUWVFKUHLEW+DUULVVLQG0LOOHQQLDOV GLHTXDOLIL]LHUWHVWH*HQHUDWLRQLQGHU*HVFKLFKWH GLHGHQ:RKOVWDQGLKUHU(OWHUQWURW]GHPQLHHUUHLFKHQZLUG³ ,//28=9JO]XGLHVHP7KHPDLP)ROJHQGHQ DD2II ',(6 II ,//28=I,OORX]EH]LHKWVLFKLP/DXIHLKUHU8QWHUVXFKXQJHQLPPHUZLHGHUDXI $[HO+RQQHWK ,//28= $D2 ,//28= ,//28= $D2 ,//28= $D2
&'DVDPRXU|VH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW
XQG$XWRQRPLH³LQV$XJHJHIDVVW (VIROJHQVFKOLHOLFKWKHRORJLVFKHhEHU OHJXQJHQ GLH DQ ,OORX]µ HLJHQH $XVIKUXQJHQ ]XU UHOLJL|VHQ 'LPHQVLRQ GHU /LHEHDQNQSIHQ
'DVYHUXQVLFKHUWH%HJHKUHQ Ä,FKZHWWHGXZUGHVWVRWXQDOVREZLUXQVQLFKWNHQQHQZHQQZLUXQV]XIlOOLJ EHJHJQHQ³VDJW&RQQHOO]X0DULDQQH5RRQH\V+DXSWILJXUHQVWHKHQDQGLHVHU 6WHOOHGHV5RPDQVNXU]YRUGHP6FKXODEVFKOXVVXQGGHQNHQGDUEHUQDFKVLFK IUGLHVHOEH8QLYHUVLWlW]XEHZHUEHQ6LHKDEHQLKU9HUKlOWQLVELVODQJJHKHLP JHKDOWHQXQGQRFKQLFKWWKHPDWLVLHUWREVLHHVEHUKDXSWIRUWIKUHQZROOHQ$XI &RQQHOOVÃ:HWWHµMHGHQIDOOVHUZLGHUW 0DULDQQH>«@HUVWHLQPDOQLFKWV-HOlQJHUVLHVWLOOLVWGHVWRQHUY|VHUZLUGHUYLHOOHLFKWZUGH VLHZLUNOLFKVRWXQDOVREVLHLKQQLFKWNHQQWXQGGLH9RUVWHOOXQJLKUH$XIPHUNVDPNHLWQLFKW ZHUW]XVHLQO|VW3DQLNLQLKPDXVQLFKWQXUZDV0DULDQQHVHOEVWDQJHKWVRQGHUQDXFKZDV VHLQH=XNXQIWEHWULIIWZHOFKH0|JOLFKNHLWHQHUKDW
:DVDQGLHVHP5RPDQDXV]XJKHUYRUVWLFKW GDVVVFKRQGLHEORHÃ9RUVWHOOXQJµ 0DULDQQHV,QWHUHVVHÃQLFKWZHUWVHLQµ]XN|QQHQ&RQQHOOGDV)UFKWHQOHKUW =XJOHLFKHUVFKHLQHQLKPGDGXUFKVHLQH=XNXQIWVP|JOLFKNHLWHQLQ*lQ]HJHIlKU GHWÄ'LHÃ$QJVWYRU=XUFNZHLVXQJµ³VFKUHLEWGHPJHPl(YD,OORX]ÄLVWHLQH %HGURKXQJGLHVWlQGLJEHU%H]LHKXQJHQVFKZHEWZHLOVLHGDVJDQ]H*HElXGH GHV6HOEVWZHUWVEHGURKW³'HU]HLWZHLVH(QW]XJYRQ$XIPHUNVDPNHLWYRQVHLWHQ GHUJHOLHEWHQ3HUVRQGDV]HLJWVLHDQKDQGYLHOHUVHOEVWJHIKUWHU,QWHUYLHZVXQG HPSLULVFKHU6WXGLHQDXIYHUPDJ]XHLQHUlXHUVWWLHIJHKHQGHQ9HUXQVLFKHUXQJ ]XIKUHQ$XV6LFKWGHU6R]LRORJLQÄGUFNWVLFK³GDULQÄHWZDVDXVGDVZLUDOV ÃNRQ]HSWXHOOH 6HOEVWXQVLFKHUKHLWµ EH]HLFKQHQ N|QQHQ DOVR HLQH8QVLFKHUKHLW EH]JOLFKGHVHLJHQHQ6HOEVWELOGVXQGGHU.ULWHULHQ]XP$XIEDXHLQHVVROFKHQ 6HOEVWELOGV³'LHVH8QVLFKHUKHLWKDWÄPLWGHQYHUlQGHUWHQ%HZHUWXQJVLQVWUX PHQWHQ]XWXQYRQGHQHQGLH$QHUNHQQXQJ³KHXWHDEKlQJWXQGGLHÄ>L@QGHU YRUPRGHUQHQ:HOW>«@VR]XVDJHQREMHNWLY³ZDUHQ Ä*HVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH.ODVVH XQGVRJDUÃ&KDUDNWHUµJHK|UHQ]XHLQHU:HOWLQGHUGHU:HUWHLQHV0HQVFKHQ YRQYRUQKHUHLQEHNDQQWLVW|IIHQWOLFKGHPRQVWULHUWZLUGXQGYRQMHGHP]XEHXU WHLOHQLVW³ 8QWHUPRGHUQHQ%HGLQJXQJHQZLUGÃGHU:HUWHLQHV0HQVFKHQµKLQJHJHQLP ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ$XVWDXVFKSHUIRUPDWLYKHUYRUJHEUDFKWXQG]ZDUDQKDQG
$D2 5221(U@$QHUNHQQXQJ³GDVJOHLFKEHGHXWHQGGDPLWLVWHLQHÄGDXHUKDIWH>@%LQ GXQJ³H[SOL]LWDQ]XVWUHEHQ:lKUHQGLP -DKUKXQGHUWGDVEHLLKUKlXILJDOV 9HUJOHLFKVJU|H IXQJLHUW GHU %LQGXQJVZLOOH GXUFKVFKQLWWOLFKHUZHLVH IU GLH 3DUWQHUZDKOYRQYRUQKHUHLQEHVWLPPHQGZDUZLUGHUQXQWHQGHQ]LHOOWDEXLVLHUW =ZDULVWÄGXUFKGLHLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHXQGQDUUDWLYH9HUVFKUlQNXQJYRQ/LHEHXQG (KH>«@GDVQDUUDWLYH7HORVGHV$QHUNHQQXQJVSUR]HVVHV³QDFKZLHYRUÄHLQH %LQGXQJ³VRGDVVÄGLHPHLVWHQURPDQWLVFKHQ%H]LHKXQJHQ³LUJHQGZDQQÄHQWZH
5221(@$XIIDVVXQJGHV6HOEVW³GLHXQWHUPRGHUQHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGRPLQLHUHQGH 'HP]XIROJH PXVV ÄGDV 6HOEVW³ ]ZLQJHQG ÄDOV VWUDWHJLVFKHU 6LHJHU DXV HLQHU ,QWHUDNWLRQKHUYRUJHKHQ³DQVWDWWÄVLFKVHOEVWLQ)RUPGHU/LHEHDOV$JDSHKLQ ]XJHEHQRKQHGDHLQ|NRQRPLVFKHV.DONOGHQ$XVWDXVFKUHJXOLHUWH³ Ã/LHEHDOV$JDSHµ±GDPLWLVWVRVFKHLQWHV,OORX]µ,GHDOEHQDQQWGDVVWLOO VFKZHLJHQGLP+LQWHUJUXQGLKUHUNULWLVFKHQ'LDJQRVHGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ/LH EHVSUD[LVVWHKW6RILQGHWVLFKEHLLKUDXFKÄGLHOHLVH+RIIQXQJ³IRUPXOLHUWÄGD ZLU>«@YLHOOHLFKWVRJDUQHXH)RUPHQOHLGHQVFKDIWOLFKHU/LHEHZLHGHUHUILQGHQ N|QQHQ³ZDVDXVLKUHU6LFKWYHUXQP|JOLFKWZLUGZHQQHVGHQ6XEMHNWHQYRU UDQJLJ XP VLFK VHOEVW JHKW 'DV 'RPLQDQWZHUGHQ GLHVHV |NRQRPLVFK VWUDWHJLVFKH 2ULHQWLHUXQJVPXVWHUV KDW ZLH VLH LP $QVFKOXVV DQ 0D[ :HEHU IRUPXOLHUWHLQHÄ(QW]DXEHUXQJ³GHU/LHEHEHZLUNWGHUHQXUVSUQJOLFKÄYHU]DX EHUWH³E]ZUHOLJL|VH)RUPQRFKGLHÄY|OOLJH6HOEVWDXIRSIHUXQJXQG3UHLVJDEH GHV6HOEVW³IRUGHUWH 'DPLWVLQGZLUEHLP7KHPDGHU5HOLJLRQDQJHODQJWZDV QDFKHLQHPOHW]WHQ$XV]XJDXV1RUPDO3HRSOHHLQHWKHRORJLVFKH5HIOH[LRQGHV 'DUJHOHJWHQJHUDGH]XSURYR]LHUW
0LW*RWWOLHEHQ ]ZLVFKHQ$OOHLQVHLQXQG=XVDPPHQVHLQ Ä,FKOLHEHGLFK,FKVDJGDVQLFKWHLQIDFKQXULFKWXHVZLUNOLFK³$XI&RQQHOOV GHXWOLFKHQ*HIKOVDXVGUXFNGHULKPZLHZLUEHUHLWVJHK|UWKDEHQDOOHUGLQJV
$D2 (EG (EG $D2 (EG $D2 $D2 I 5221(«@HLQ>HV@3DDU>V@GDVNHLQHVVHLQZLOO³LPPHUZLHGHUHQWWlXVFKWZLUG 6LH XQWHUVWUHLFKWHLQPDOPHKUPLWZHOFKHUÄ0DFKW>«@>G@LHURPDQWLVFKH/LHEH>«@ GDV6HOEVWELOGHLQHU3HUVRQYHUPLWWHOWEHUGHQ%OLFNHLQHVRGHUHLQHUDQGHUHQ³ SRVLWLY]XEHVWLPPHQYHUPDJ,OORX]VSULFKWGLHVEH]JOLFKDXFKYRQÄGHU/LHEH DOVHLQHU0DFKWGLHGDVDOOWlJOLFKH/HEHQ>«@WUDQV]HQGLHUHQ³XQGGHP6XEMHNW ]XUÄ4XHOOHH[LVWHQWLHOOHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]³ZHUGHQNDQQÃ(LQQHXHV/HEHQµEH GHXWHWGLH(UIDKUXQJGHV*HOLHEWZHUGHQVGHPJHPlIU5RRQH\V3URWDJRQLVWLQ 6LHZLUGDXVLKUHQÃDOWHQµ/HEHQVEH]JHQJOHLFKVDPKHUDXVJHKREHQGLHVLHQLH ÃJODXEHQµOLHHQGDVVVLHLQGHQ$XJHQ$QGHUHUOLHEHQVZHUWVHLQN|QQWH 'DVVLFKGDULQZLGHUVSLHJHOQGHÄ%LOGGHU/LHEHDOVHLQHUWRWDOHQ(UIDKUXQJ³ GLHXQEHGLQJWH+LQJDEHHLQIRUGHUWZHLOVLFKGXUFKVLHGDVHLJHQH6HOEVWVHLQDXI QHXH:HLVHHUVFKOLHWVWHOOWDXV,OORX]µ6LFKWHLQHELVLQGLH*HJHQZDUWKLQHLQ ZLUNHQGHNXOWXUHOOH)ROJHGHV&KULVWHQWXPVGDU,Q6SDQQXQJ]XGLHVHUÄTXDVLUH OLJL|VH>Q@/LHEHVDXIIDVVXQJ³VWHKWGDVVGLH(LQ]HOQHQ]XJOHLFKGXUFKGLHWKH PDWLVLHUWHQ 6HOEVWXQVLFKHUKHLWHQ XQG $XWRQRPLHDQVSUFKH JHSUlJW VLQG 6LH VFKZlFKHQÄGLH)lKLJNHLWGHV6HOEVW³VRKlOW,OORX]IHVWÄ6HOEVWDXIJDEHXQG (NVWDVH]XHUIDKUHQ³XQGLPOLHEHYROOHQ6LFKKLQJHEHQDQ$QGHUHÄHQGJOWLJH $QHUNHQQXQJ³]XILQGHQ,VWDEHUGHVKDOEQXQZLHLKUHVFKDUIH'LDJQRVHODX WHWÄ>D@OOHVZDVKHLOLJDQGHU/LHEHZDU³ DOVRGHUHQUHOLJL|VWUDQV]HQGHQWDOH 'LPHQVLRQLP9HUVFKZLQGHQEHJULIIHQ" (LQHWKHRORJLVFKH$QWZRUWDXIGLHVH)UDJHNDQQEHLGHPDQVHW]HQZDVLQGHQ ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ.DSLWHOQEHUHLWVEHUGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6HOEVWVHLQXQG$QHU NHQQXQJJHVDJWZXUGH'HP]XIROJHLVWGLHVSDQQXQJVYROOH%H]LHKXQJ]ZLVFKHQ OLHEHYROOHU +LQJDEH DQ $QGHUH XQG $XIUHFKWHUKDOWXQJ MH HLJHQHU $XWRQRPLH
$D2I 6RKHLWHVLP8PVFKODJVWH[WGHV%XFKHV ,//28= ,//28=9JOGD]XLP)ROJHQGHQLQVJHVDPW DD2IIII $D2 $QP $D2 $D2 ,//28= ,//28=
&'DVDPRXU|VH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW
QLFKWSHUVHGHUDUWQHJDWLY]XEHXUWHLOHQZLHHV,OORX]µ$XVIKUXQJHQ]XPLQGHVW LQVLQXLHUHQ'DVVVLFKGDV6XEMHNW]XDOOHQVR]LDOHQ%LQGXQJHQXQG9HUELQG OLFKNHLWHQ GHQHQ HV VLFK DXVJHVHW]W VLHKW QRFK HLQPDO LQV 9HUKlOWQLV VHW]HQ NDQQYHUZHLVWDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWYLHOPHKUDXIGHVVHQJ|WWOLFKXQEHGLQJWHQ &KDUDNWHU'HPHQWVSULFKWGLH5HGHYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGXUFK *RWWDOV*UHQ]HMHGZHGHQ%HVWLPPWZHUGHQVGXUFK$QGHUHXQG$QGHUHV'DVVHV LP=XJHGHU0RGHUQH]XGHPYRQ,OORX]GLDJQRVWL]LHUWHQ9HUELQGOLFKNHLWVYHU OXVWLQ/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHQJHNRPPHQLVWZHLOHVGHQ6XEMHNWHQLPPHUDXFKXP GLH:DKUXQJLKUHU)UHLKHLWJHKWWULWWYRUGLHVHP+LQWHUJUXQGJUXQGVlW]OLFKDOV HLQ)RUWVFKULWWYRU$XJHQ0LWKLQLVWGLH/LHEHLP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHURELJHQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJHQ XP $[HO +RQQHWK -RHO :KLWHERRN XQG -XGLWK %XWOHU EHUHLWVDOVHLQHVROFKHVR]LDOH9HUKlOWQLVZHLVHVWDUNJHPDFKWJHZRUGHQLQGHU GLH)UHLKHLWGHV,QGLYLGXXPVLP6LQQHVHLQHU1LFKW)HVWOHJEDUNHLWHLJHQV%HVWl WLJXQJILQGHWÃ'DV*|WWOLFKHLQMHGHP0HQVFKHQµZLHPLW0D[)ULVFKJHVDJW ZXUGHZLOODQHUNDQQWVHLQ*HQDXGDUXPNRPPWLQVEHVRQGHUHLP)DOOHGHU/LH EHQLHPDQGKHUXPZHLOVLHQDFKJHUDGHGDV*HJHQWHLOYRQ=ZDQJXQG9HUSIOLFK WXQJGDUVWHOOW :DV,OORX]DOVÃNRQ]HSWXHOOH6HOEVWXQVLFKHUKHLWµEHVFKUHLEWKlQJWPLWGLHVHU XQXPJlQJOLFKHQ(LQUlXPXQJYRQ)UHLKHLWLP/LHEHVYHUKlOWQLVHQJ]XVDPPHQ Ä'LH&KDQFH]XU*HPHLQVDPNHLW³OLHJWPLW7UDXJRWW.RFKJHVDJWDOOHLQLQGHU Ä:UGH G>HU@ )UHLKHLWGHV $QGHUHQ $EHUGLHVH LVW LPPHU DXFK PHLQH 2KQ PDFKW³ZHLOVLHQLFKWQRWZHQGLJPHLQHQ$QVSUFKHQIROJW*HJHQGDV5LVLNR ]XVFKHLWHUQXQGHQWWlXVFKW]XZHUGHQNDQQVLFKGDEHLQLHPDQGJlQ]OLFKDEVL FKHUQ=XJOHLFKDEHUJLOWGDVVÄ*HPHLQVDPNHLW³DXFKLP)DOOHGHU/LHEHHLQPDO PHKU PLW.RFKJHVDJWÄQLFKW]XVWDQGHNRPPHQ>NDQQ@RKQHGDHLQHUGLHV 5LVLNRYRQVLFKDXVZLOOHQWOLFKHLQJHKWXQGVLFKKLQDXVZDJWEHUGDV(LJHQH³ *HQDXHLQVROFKHU6FKULWWEHUV(LJHQHKLQDXVVWHOOWDEHUDXV,OORX]µVR]LRORJL VFKHU6LFKWIUGDV]ZLVFKHQ$XWRQRPLHEHGUIQLVXQG/LHEHVE]Z$QHUNHQ QXQJVYHUODQJHQKLQXQGKHUJHULVVHQH6XEMHNWHLQVFKZLHULJHV8QWHUIDQJHQGDU
9JO]X,OORX]JUXQGVlW]OLFKNULWLVFKHU6LFKWDXIGLHPRGHUQH$N]HQWXLHUXQJYRQ)UHLKHLW XQG,QGLYLGXDOLWlW DD2'RUWVFKUHLEWVLH Ä0HLQH$QDO\VHGHU/LHEHXQWHUGHQ%HGLQ JXQJHQGHU0RGHUQHLVWNULWLVFKDEHUVLHLVWNULWLVFKDXVHLQHUHUQFKWHUWPRGHUQHQ3HUVSHNWL YHGDVKHLWDXVHLQHU3HUVSHNWLYHIUGLHDXVJHPDFKWLVWGDGLH0RGHUQH]ZDU=HUVW|UXQJ XQG(OHQGLQJURHP6WLOYHUXUVDFKWKDWIULKUH]HQWUDOHQ:HUWH SROLWLVFKH(PDQ]LSDWLRQ 6lNXODULVPXV5DWLRQDOLWlW,QGLYLGXDOLVPXVPRUDOLVFKHU3OXUDOLVPXV*OHLFKKHLW DEHUJHJHQ ZlUWLJNHLQHEHUOHJHQH$OWHUQDWLYHLQ6LFKWLVW'HQQRFKPXHVHLQHUQFKWHUWHV8QWHUIDQJHQ EOHLEHQIUGLH0RGHUQHHLQ]XWUHWHQZHLOGLHVHLQLKUHUZHVWOLFKHQNXOWXUHOOHQ$XVSUlJXQJ QRFKQLHGDJHZHVHQH)RUPHQHPRWLRQDOHQ(OHQGVXQGGHU=HUVW|UXQJWUDGLWLRQHOOHU/HEHQV ZHOWHQKHUEHLJHIKUWRQWRORJLVFKH9HUXQVLFKHUXQJ]XHLQHPGDXHUKDIWHQ0HUNPDOGHVPR GHUQHQ /HEHQV JHPDFKW XQG ]XQHKPHQG DXI GLH 2UJDQLVDWLRQ YRQ ,GHQWLWlW XQG %HJHKUHQ EHUJHJULIIHQKDW³ HEG .2&+ E (EG
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
7KHRORJLVFKPXVVHVGHVKDOEGDUXPJHKHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHV6LFKVHOEVWYHUVWH KHQVDXI]X]HLJHQGLHHLQHQ8PJDQJPLWGLHVHUDPELYDOHQWHQ/DJHHU|IIQHQ 'DEHLNDQQDXI.RFKUHNXUULHUWZHUGHQLP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHPGDV7KHPD YRQ/LHEHVXQG3DDUEH]LHKXQJHQEHUHLWVJHVWUHLIWZXUGH 5HNDSLWXOLHUWPDQGDVJHUDGH*HVDJWHLVWHUVWHQVGDV6WUHEHQQDFKÃHQGJOWL JHU $QHUNHQQXQJµ GDV GHP /LHEHVZXQVFK KHXWLJHU 6XEMHNWH LQQHZRKQW ]X UHODWLYLHUHQ:HQQGHPUHOLJL|VHQ*RWWHVEH]XJGDV%HZXVVWVHLQHLJHQHU8QEH GLQJWKHLWDOOHPVR]LDOHQ%HVWLPPWZHUGHQJHJHQEHUHQWVSULFKWPDFKWHUSRWHQ ]LHOODXFKIUHLGDYRQXPMHGHQ3UHLVJHOLHEWZHUGHQ]XPVVHQ0LW2GR0DU TXDUGN|QQWHPDQGDULQGHQ%HLWUDJGHU5HOLJLRQ]XHLQHUÄ.XOWXUGHU(LQVDP NHLWVIlKLJNHLW³HQWGHFNHQ Ä*RWW³VFKUHLEW0DUTXDUGÄLVWGHUGHUQRFKGDLVW ZHQQQLHPDQGPHKUGDLVW³'LHVUHOLJL|V]XNRPPXQL]LHUHQ]LHOWGDUDXIGDV LQGLYLGXHOOH)UHLKHLWVEHZXVVWVHLQ]XVWlUNHQXQGHLQVLFKGHPVR]LDOHQ'UXFN XQEHGLQJWGLHJURH/LHEHILQGHQ]XPVVHQZLGHUVHW]HQGHV$OOHLQVHLQN|QQHQ ]XI|UGHUQ'DEHLLVWDXFK]XEHGHQNHQGDVVVLFKQLFKWQXUGDV6XFKHQXQG)LQ GHQGHU/LHEHKHUDXVIRUGHUQGDXVQLPPW(VLVWDXFKÄVFKZHU³ZLHGLH.QVWOH ULQXQG-RXUQDOLVWLQ&KULVWLDQH5|VLQJHUVDJWÄVLFK]XHLQHPVLQJXOlUHQ/HEHQ ]XEHNHQQHQ0DQZLUGGLHJDQ]H=HLWEHGDXHUW>«@ Ã6RHLQHWROOH)UDXZLHGX HLQHV7DJHVZLUVWGXVFKRQMHPDQGHQILQGHQµ³.XU]XP 'DV6XEMHNWVlKHVLFK ÄKHXWHHLQH>P@UHJHOUHFKWHQ=ZDQJ]XU/LHEH³DXVJHVHW]W±HLQHDPELYDOHQWH (UIDKUXQJGLHWKHRORJLVFKHUQVW]XQHKPHQLVW'HQQHEHQVRZHQLJZLHGLHIUHLH *HJHQOLHEHHLQHVDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQLVWGDV/LHEHVYHUODQJHQEHUKDXSW]XHU ]ZLQJHQ+LHUYHUPDJ,VROGH.DUOHV.RQ]HSWHLQHUÄVR]LRORJLVFKDXIJHNOlUWH>Q@ 6HHOVRUJH³5HOHYDQ]]XHQWIDOWHQ,KU$QOLHJHQLVWHVÄLQGLYLGXHOOH6HOEVWGHX WXQJVPXVWHU³ GXUFK GLH PDQ HWZD LQ /LHEHVGLQJHQ JHOHLWHW ZLUG ÄDOV VR]LDO KHUYRUJHEUDFKWH>]X@LGHQWLIL]LHU>HQ@³XPÄVLFKYRQLKQHQ>«@GLVWDQ]LHUHQ³]X N|QQHQ0DQKDEHHVKHXWHÄLQGHU6HHOVRUJH³KlXILJ
9JOREHQ $ 0$548$5' DI 7+2//%$5)866 (EG5|VLQJHUKDWLKUH(UIDKUXQJHQXQG%HREDFKWXQJHQLQHLQHP%XFKPLW7LWHO/LHEH ZLUGEHUZHUWHWDXVIKUOLFKGDUJHOHJW 9JO5g6,1*(5 .$5/( .$5/( I$OOHUGLQJVVLHKW.DUOHVLFKEHPLJWYRUHLQHUÄHLQVHLWLJH>Q@XQGXQ UHDOLVWLVFKH>Q@%HWRQXQJGHU>«@(LQPDOLJNHLWGHV,QGLYLGXXPV³]XZDUQHQZHLOGDGXUFKÄGLH JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ3UR]HVVHGHU9HUHLQVDPXQJXQG$XIO|VXQJJHPHLQVDPHU)RUPHQEHJQVWLJW XQGYRUDQJHWULHEHQ³ZUGHQÄVWDWWGDLKQHQHQWJHJHQJHZLUNW³ZHUGH DD2 0LWKLQ VHLÄ>G@HU0HQVFK>«@QDFKFKULVWOLFKHU$XIIDVVXQJQLFKWLQVLFKVHOEVWEHJUQGHWVRQGHUQ YRQMHQVHLWVVHLQHUVHOEVWKHUEHMDKWXQGJHZROOW³DOVRGXUFK*RWWNRQVWLWXLHUW DD2 'LHVHVH[WHUQH.RQVWLWXLHUWZHUGHQNRPPWGDQQGDULQ]XP$XVGUXFNGDVVÄGLH.LUFKHDOV *HPHLQVFKDIW-HVX&KULVWL>«@GDV,QGLYLGXXPLQGHU7DXIH>DFKWHW@EHYRUHVDOVVHOEVWlQGLJH ,QVWDQ]DXIWUHWHQNDQQXQGLQGHU%HHUGLJXQJQDFKGHPHVDOVVHOEVWlQGLJHV:HVHQ]XH[LVWLH UHQDXIJHK|UWKDW³ HEG .DUOHVGXUFK/XKPDQQLQVSLULHUWH7KHVHÄGDGLH9RUVWHOOXQJYRP VHOEVWEHVWLPPWHQ,QGLYLGXXPHLQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHUXQGNXOWXUHOOHU0\WKRVLVW³ DD2
&'DVDPRXU|VH6XEMHNW]ZLVFKHQ6HOEVWVHLQ$QHUNHQQXQJXQG*RWW
PLW0HQVFKHQ]XWXQGLHVLFKDQJHVLFKWVGHUJURHQ9LHOIDOWGHU0|JOLFKNHLWHQ/LHEHXQG 6H[XDOLWlWLQXQVHUHU*HVHOOVFKDIW]XOHEHQPKVDP]XRULHQWLHUHQYHUVXFKHQGLHHQWWlXVFKW XQGYHUXQVLFKHUWQLFKWPHKUZHLWHUZLVVHQXQGVLFKVHOEVWZRP|JOLFKIUHLQ%H]LHKXQJVYHU VDJHQDQNODJHQGDVVHLQH8UVDFKHQQLFKWLQ'HIL]LWHQGHUHLJHQHQ3V\FKHVRQGHUQLQEHULQ GLYLGXHOOHQ'\QDPLNHQKDW+LHUNDQQGLH$QDO\VHYRQ(YD,OORX]KLOIUHLFKVHLQ6LHGLHQWGHU ÃVR]LRORJLVFKHQ$XINOlUXQJµXQGHUP|JOLFKW'LVWDQ]]X(UIDKUXQJHQXQG*HIKOHQGLHZLULQ GHU5HJHODOVXQVHU8UHLJHQVWHVEHWUDFKWHQXQGGDPLWXQVVHOEVW]XUHFKQHQ
(LQGXUFK,OORX]µ*HVHOOVFKDIWVGLDJQRVHJHOHLWHWHVVHHOVRUJHUOLFKHV+DQGHOQ]LHOW GHPQDFKEHU.DUOHKLQDXVJHVDJWGDUDXIGLHJ|WWOLFKXQEHGLQJWH)UHLKHLWGHV 6XEMHNWV]XPRELOLVLHUHQ±XPLKP]XHQWODVWHQGHP'LVWDQ]JHZLQQJHJHQEHU GHQ VR]LDO YHUPLWWHOWHQ ,GHDOYRUVWHOOXQJHQ URPDQWLVFKHU /LHEH ]X YHUKHOIHQ 6ROFKHQ$EVWDQGVDJW.DUOHYHUPDJJHUDGHÄGLHIUHPGHFKULVWOLFKH6\PERO VSUDFKH³]XYHUPLWWHOQLQGHPVLHPLUHWZDLQ*HVWDOWYRQLQV6HHOVRUJHJHVSUlFK HLQJHEUDFKWHUÄ*HEHWH3VDOPHQ/LHGHU>«@XQJHZRKQWH3HUVSHNWLYHQGHUHLJH QHQ:HOWXQG3HUVRQ³HUVFKOLHWXQGGDULQÄQHXH'LPHQVLRQHQGHU6HOEVWXQG )UHPGZDKUQHKPXQJHU|IIQHW³ =ZHLWHQV LVW GDV $QHUNHQQXQJVVWUHEHQ GDVGHP /LHEHVZXQVFK LQQHZRKQW ZHQQHVVLFKGHQQHLQVWHOOW DXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWDEHUDXFK]XDIILUPLHUHQ :HQQQLFKWÃ$OOHVµE]ZÃ(QGJOWLJHVµYRP6XFKHQXQG)LQGHQGHU/LHEHHUZDU WHWZHUGHQ PXVV ZHLO PDQLP9HUKlOWQLV]X*RWWE]Z]XVLFKVHOEVWVFKRQ HWZDV LVW GDQQ NDQQ GLH DXV GHU 8QYHUIJEDUNHLW GHV $QGHUHQ UHVXOWLHUHQGH 8QVLFKHUKHLWNHLQHVFKOHFKWKLQQLJHVHLQÄ$Q*RWWJODXEHQKHLWGDUDXIYHUWUDX HQZDVLP0LWHLQDQGHUYRQ0HQVFKHQP|JOLFKZHUGHQNDQQ³VFKUHLEW.RFK *HPHLQWLVWHLQ9HUWUDXHQGDVDXVGHU*HZLVVKHLWVHOEVWVFKRQHWZDV]XVHLQ JHVFK|SIWZLUGXQGDXIJUXQGGHVVHQGLHVHÄ$QJVW³YHUJHKW ÄYHUORUHQ]XVHLQ ZHQQPDQVLFKVHOEVWORVOlWLQVXQDXVJHPDFKW2IIHQHKLQHLQZHQQPDQVLFK DOVRDXVVHW]WGHP$QGHUVVHLQGHV$QGHUHQ³(VVHW]WGDUDXIGDVVHLQH9HUEXQ GHQKHLWJHJHQVHLWLJHU/LHEHQLFKWXQP|JOLFKLVWLQGHUVLFKGLH%HWHLOLJWHQVHOEVW ]XWLHIVWDXIJHZHUWHWXQGDQHUNDQQWILQGHQ'DEHLZLUGPLW.RFKJHVDJWÄDXI *RWWXQGGDPLWDXIGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWJHPHLQVDPHU/LHEH³JHEDXW'LH5HGH YRQ*RWWEULQJWDOVRHLQGHU/LHEHVEH]LHKXQJHLJQHQGHV8QEHGLQJWKHLWVPRPHQW ]XU6SUDFKHGLHVLFKHEHQQLFKWÄZLHHLQ'LQJ³KHUVWHOOHQOlVVW9LHOPHKUEOHL ZLUGVRWKHRORJLVFKXQWHUPDXHUW2IIHQEOHLEWVRDEHUGLH)UDJHZLHGDV6XEMHNWGHQQEHU KDXSWGD]XEHIlKLJWVHLQVROOÄVLFKNULWLVFKXQGGDPLWUHIOHNWLHUWDXIJHJHQZlUWLJH0RUDOHQ XQG7UHQGV]XEH]LHKHQXQGVLFKGHP'UXFN]XP.RSLHUHQ]XHQW]LHKHQ³ I ZHQQLKP GDVNULWLVFKH'LVWDQ]LHUXQJVYHUP|JHQGHV6LFK%HVWLPPHQ.|QQHQVDEJHVSURFKHQZLUGXQG ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWDOVHWZDVDXFKQRFKGXUFKGLH.LUFKHQJHPHLQVFKDIW9HUOLHKHQHVHUVFKHLQW .$5/( .$5/( .2&+ E $D2 .2&+ E .2&+N
&*HJHQZDUWVGLDJQRVWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQ
EHQGLHDQLKUEHWHLOLJWHQ6XEMHNWHLPPHUDXFKÃMHIUVLFKµXQGGDVVVLHGDUEHU KLQDXVJHKHQGÃ]XVDPPHQNRPPHQµNDQQNHLQHVGHUEHLGHQVFKOLFKWZHJEHLP MHZHLOVDQGHUHQKHUYRUUXIHQÄ/LHEHUHDOLVLHUWVLFK>«@DOVZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$QHU NHQQXQJGHUHLQ]HOQHQ³ZHLOVLHQLFKWHU]ZXQJHQZHUGHQNDQQVRQGHUQLQ )UHLKHLWJHVFKLHKW=LHOHQEHLGHWDWVlFKOLFKGDUDXIDEGDVVLKU=XVDPPHQILQGHQ JHOLQJHQNDQQGDQQ VHW]HQVLHYRUDXVÄGDLKU/LHEHQYRQGHU/LHEHVHOEVW YHUVFKLHGHQLVW³'LH/LHEHVWHOOWJOHLFKVDPQRFKHWZDVDQGHUHVGDUDOVLKUHMH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ%HILQGOLFKNHLWHQXQG:LOOHQVEHVWUHEXQJHQÃ*RWWµGDVOlVVWVLFK YRQ.RFKOHUQHQLVWHLQ:RUWIUHEHQGLHVHLP/LHEHVZXQVFKDOVP|JOLFKDQYL VLHUWH'LPHQVLRQJHPHLQVDPHU/LHEHGLHVLFKLQGHU5HGHYRQLKPDXVGUFNOLFK PDFKHQXQGVR]XP*HJHQVWDQGH[SOL]LWHQ9HUWUDXHQVHUKHEHQOlVVW 'DGXUFKLVWNHLQ*HOLQJHQGHV%H]LHKXQJVJHVFKHKHQVYRUSURJUDPPLHUWGDV YLHOPHKULPPHUDXFKDQGHUVSDQQXQJVYROOHQ8QWHUVFKLHGHQKHLWGHUEHWHLOLJWHQ 6XEMHNWHVFKHLWHUQNDQQ$XVGHU(LQVLFKWGDVVHLQJOFNHQGHV=XVDPPHQNRP PHQLQGHU/LHEHQLFKWJlQ]OLFKDPMHHLJHQHQ7XQKlQJWVRQGHUQVLFK±ZLH MHGHV*OFN±NRQWLQJHQWHUZHLVHHLQVWHOOWN|QQWHXPJHNHKUWDXFKHLQH+DOWXQJ HUZDFKVHQIUGLHGDVDNWXHOOH6FKHLWHUQGHU/LHEHQLFKWGHUHQJHQHUHOOHV6FKHL WHUQEHGHXWHWPXVVÄ*ODXEHQG³VR.RFKÄVHW]HLFKGDUDXIGDGLH/LHEHVHOEVW LQPHLQHQ%UFKHQLQPHLQHP=HUEUHFKHQYRQ/LHEHQLFKW]X%UXFKJHKW³XQG IUGDV6XEMHNWGLHVHU9HUWUDXHQVKDOWXQJÄLVW>«@*RWWGLH/LHEH³$OOHUGLQJV LVWHLQHVROFKH(LQVWHOOXQJGLHVLFKDQNRQNUHWHQ(UIDKUXQJHQGHV*HOLQJHQV NDQQXQGDXVGHU'DQNEDUNHLWIUGLHVHOHEWHEHQVRZHQLJHU]ZLQJEDUZLHGLH /LHEHVHOEVW%HLGHVVHW]WIUHLH6XEMHNWHYRUDXVGLHVLFKZLOOHQWOLFKDXIGDVHLQ ODVVHQ N|QQHQ ZDVLKQHQDQ*XWHPZLGHUIlKUW'HUHQXQKLQWHUJHKEDUHUXQG QXUDQ]XHUNHQQHQGHU6HOEVWEH]XJLVWGLHÃ&KDQFH]XU*HPHLQVDPNHLWµXQG]X JOHLFKGHU*UXQGIUGLHEOHLEHQGHQ6SDQQXQJHQLP=ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ 'DVV OHW]WHUH QLHPDOV ]XJXQVWHQ HLQHU ÃHQGJOWLJHQ $QHUNHQQXQJµ YROOHQGV EHUZLQGEDUVLQGPDFKWQLFKWQXUGLH/LHEH]XHLQHULPPHUZLHGHUVSDQQHQGHQ $QJHOHJHQKHLW(VHQWKlOWDXFKGLHWKHRORJLVFK]XXQWHUVWUHLFKHQGH(LQVLFKW GDVVLFKQLFKWHUVWGDQQÃHWZDVELQµZHQQLFKYRQ$QGHUHQÃJHOLHEWZHUGHµ
$D2 $D2 .2&+ E I
(SLORJ (SLORJ :LUVLQGGDV9RON ,FKELQ9RONHU
Ä(LQ*HIKOGHU,QWHUQLHUXQJJUXQGLHUWGLH(ULQQHUXQJ³GHV6FKULIWVWHOOHUV/XW] 6HLOHUDQGLHHLJHQVHUOHEWH''5=HLWÄGD]XGLH9LHO]DKOGHU*HVFKLFKWHQYRQ GHU$EZHUWXQJGHVHLQ]HOQHQVHLQHU,QGLYLGXDOLWlWDOVGDV0LQGHUHQ|WLJHQIDOOV 9HU]LFKWEDUH³ 0DQ ZDU DQJHVLFKWV GHV Ä:DKUKHLWVPRQRSROV GHU 'LNWDWXU³ JHIRUGHUWÄHLQHJUXQGVlW]OLFKDQGHUVJHDUWHWH:HOWGHV,FKV>«@DXV]XSUlJHQ >«@DOVXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQHLQHUSOXUDOLVWLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW³6RPXVVWH ÄGDV(LJHQH'LIIHUHQWHÃLQVLFKµJHKDOWHQZHUGHQ³XPHVGHUJlQ]OLFKHQÄ$XI KHEXQJLQHLQHPHU]ZXQJHQHQNROOHNWLYHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJ³MDGHUJHZQVFKWHQ Ä*OHLFKVFKDOWXQJ³]XHQW]LHKHQ$OVGDQQVFKOLHOLFKÄDXIGHQ6WUDHQJHUXIHQ ZXUGHÃ:LUVLQGGDV9RONµVWDQGMHPDQGQHEHQPLU³HULQQHUWVLFK6HLOHU GHUVDJWH Ã8QGLFKELQ9RONHUµ:LHDXFKLPPHU±DOVVLFKÃGDV9RONµHPDQ]LSLHUHQZROOWH ZDUÃ9RONHUµVFKRQGD8QGPLWLKPZHQQHU*OFNKDWWHVHLQDXIEHVRQGHUH:HLVHUHVLVWHQ WHVXQGELVGDKLQYRQ0RGHQ0RGHUQHXQG/LIHVW\OHZHLWJHKHQGXQEHGURKWHVDUFKDLVFKHV ,FK
6HLOHUV OLWHUDULVFK YHUGLFKWHWH 5HPLQLV]HQ]HQ DQ GLH -DKUH YRQ 0DXHU XQG 0DXHUIDOO]HLJHQHLQ,FKGDVLQNHLQHP:LUJDQ]DXIJHKREHQVHLQZLOO(VZL GHUVWUHEW GHU YROOVWlQGLJHQ (LQJHPHLQGXQJ LQV .ROOHNWLYH SULQ]LSLHOO JDQ] JOHLFKREHVVLFKGDPLWGLNWDWRULVFKHP=ZDQJUHYROXWLRQlUHU%HZHJWKHLWRGHU ]HLWJHLVWNRQIRUPHP.RQVXPYHUKDOWHQKLQJlEH*HJHQGLHÃ$EZHUWXQJVHLQHU ,QGLYLGXDOLWlWµ]XJXQVWHQGHVVHQZDVDOOHZROOHQRGHUZROOHQVROOHQ]XJXQVWHQ YRQÃ9RONHV:LUµHUZHLVWVLFKÃ9RONHUV,FKµJHOLQJHQGHQIDOOVDOVÃDXIEHVRQGHUH :HLVHUHVLVWHQWµ 'RFKVROFKH5HVLVWHQ]LQGLYLGXHOOHQ6HOEVWVHLQVÃLQVLFKµDXIUHFKW]XHUKDOWHQ LVWNHLQHHLQIDFKH$QJHOHJHQKHLW±]XPDOQLFKWXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQHLQHV
'HUYLHOIDFK]LWLHUWH6ORJDQVWDPPWZRKODXVGHP.RQWH[WGHU/HLS]LJHU0RQWDJVGH PRQVWUDWLRQHQ 6(,/(5 (EG (EG (EG
(SLORJ
8QUHFKWVUHJLPHVGDVVLFKGLH)RUPHOÄ9RP,FK]XP:LU³EHWRQWHUPDHQDXI GLH )DKQHQ JHVFKULHEHQ KDWWH $EHU DXFK LQQHUKDOE HLQHU SOXUDOLVWLVFKHQ XQG IUHLKHLWOLFKGHPRNUDWLVFKYHUIDVVWHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWKHUUVFKHQNROOHNWLYH=ZlQJH YRU±EHL6HLOHUZDUYRQÃ0RGHQ0RGHUQHXQG/LIHVW\OHµGLH5HGH±JHJHQ GHUHQ$XHQGUXFNVLFKGLHMHHLJHQHLQGLYLGXHOOH3HUVSHNWLYHQLFKWOHLFKWDOVHLQ LQQHUHUNULWLVFKHU*HJHQKDOWEHZDKUHQOlVVW0LWKLQLVWÄNHLQHLQ]HOQHU>«@MH QXU HU VHOEVW LVROLHUW XQG EH]LHKXQJVORV IU VLFK DOOHLQ³ VRQGHUQ HLQ MHGHU 0HQVFKÄLVWZDVHULVWLPPHUDXFKPLWGHQDQGHUHQ³LQ%H]LHKXQJ]XGHQHQHU XQWHU EHVWLPPWHQ VR]LRNXOWXUHOOHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ DXIZlFKVW XQG OHEW Ã,PPHU DXFKµKHLWDEHUXPJHNHKUWEHWUDFKWHWÃQLFKWQXUµ6RZHQLJYRQGHUVR]LDOHQ 6LWXLHUWKHLWGHV6XEMHNWVGLHHVLQVHLQHU6HOEVWZHUGXQJIUDJORVVWDUNDXI$QGHUH DQJHZLHVHQVHLQOlVVWDEVWUDKLHUW]XZHUGHQYHUPDJVRZHQLJLVWGDPLWDXFK VFKRQDOOHVGDUEHUJHVDJWZDVHVLVWXQGVHLQNDQQ'HU3KLORVRSK+LQULFK )LQN(LWHOZXUGHLP/DXIHGHU$UEHLWEHUHLWVPLWVHLQHP+LQZHLVDXIMHQHÄIXQ GDPHQWDOH'LIIHUHQ]³]LWLHUWÄGLHGDV,QGLYLGXXP±EHLDOOHU*HPHLQVDPNHLW± DXFKYRQVHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWXQGLKUHU6SUDFKH*HVFKLFKWHXQG.XOWXUWUHQQW³ ZHLO LKP LQ VHLQHU Ä(LQ]LJDUWLJNHLW LPPHU DXFK HLQ 0RPHQW XQDXIO|VOLFKHU )UHPGKHLW³HLJQHW=ZLVFKHQGLHVHUÃXQDXIO|VOLFKHQ)UHPGKHLWµGLH]%GDQQ *HVWDOWJHZLQQWZHQQÃ9RONHUµLQPLWWHQYRQÃ9RONHV:LUµDXIGHPXQYHUUH FKHQEDUHQ(LJHQVHLQVHLQHVÃ,FKVµEHKDUUWXQGGHUXQHQWULQQEDUHQ=XJHK|ULJNHLW ]X6R]LDOYHUKlOWQLVVHQEHVWHKHQYLHOIlOWLJH6SDQQXQJHQ'LHJHJHQZDUWVGLDJQRV WLVFKHQ6FKODJOLFKWHUGHV]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ$EVFKQLWWVKDEHQGDVLP%OLFNDXIGLH XQPLWWHOEDUH*HJHQZDUWH[HPSODULVFKYRU$XJHQJHIKUW'LHVVROOQXQXQWHU 5HNXUVDXFKDXIGLHDQGHUHQ7HLOHGLHVHU$UEHLWQRFKHLQPDODEVFKOLHHQGUHND SLWXOLHUWZHUGHQ
ÄÃ9RP,FK]XP:LUµ³VRLQIRUPLHUWGHU+LVWRULNHU-HQV6FK|QHÄZDUMHQH3DUROHPLWGHU GLH.ROOHNWLYLHUXQJGHU/DQGZLUWVFKDIWLQGHU''5GXUFKJHVHW]WZXUGH'DVKHLWGDVVDOOH VHOEVWVWlQGLJZLUWVFKDIWHQGHQ%lXHULQQHQXQG%DXHUQGLH.RQWUROOHEHULKUH%HWULHEHDEJH EHQXQGGLHVHLQ/DQGZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH3URGXNWLRQVJHQRVVHQVFKDIWHQNXU]/3*EHUIKUHQ VROOWHQ)RUPDOZXUGHQVLH]ZDUQLFKWHQWHLJQHWYHUORUHQDEHUYROOVWlQGLJGLH.RQWUROOHEHU LKU(LJHQWXP'DPLWZROOWHQVLFK3DUWHLXQG6WDDWGHQGLUHNWHQ=XJULIIDXIGHQOlQGOLFKHQ 5DXPVLFKHUQ>«@=XQlFKVWZDUGLH6('EHPKWGLH%HWURIIHQHQIUHLZLOOLJIUGLH.ROOHNWL YLHUXQJ]XJHZLQQHQ'RFKHVZXUGHVFKQHOONODUGDVVGDVQLFKWIXQNWLRQLHUWH'LHPHLVWHQ /DQGZLUWHZROOWHQXQDEKlQJLJH%DXHUQEOHLEHQXQGQLFKWDEKlQJLJ$UEHLWHQGH%HLP9RONV DXIVWDQGYRP-XQL ]HLJWHVLFKGDQQDXFKLQGHQ'|UIHUQZLHJURGHU:LGHUVWDQG JHJHQGLHVH3ROLWLNZDU'DQDFKZDUHUVWHLQPDO5XKHGRFK HU]ZDQJGLH6('GDQQGHQ %HLWULWWIDVWDOOHU%HWULHEVLQKDEHULQGLH/3*±PLWDOOHQ0LWWHOQ³ .(//(5+2)) 'LH :RUWHGHV+LVWRULNHUVXQGVWHOOYHUWUHWHQGHQ%HDXIWUDJWHQ]XU$XIDUEHLWXQJGHU6(''LNWDWXU LP/DQG%HUOLQVWDPPHQDXVHLQHP,QWHUYLHZLQGHPHU.ULWLNDQHLQHUYRQVHLWHQGHV %HUOLQHU6HQDWVJHVWDUWHWHQ:HUEHNDPSDJQHEWGLHHEHQGLHVHQ6ORJDQÄ9RP,FK]XP:LU³ XQUHIOHNWLHUWLQV=HQWUXPVWHOOWH .2&+ D ),1.(,7(/ D
(SLORJ
:DVHVEHGHXWHWÄLQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQ>]X@OHEHQLQGHQHQ³PLW&KDUOHV7D\ORU JHVDJWÄGDV6WUHEHQQDFK$QHUNHQQXQJVFKHLWHUQNDQQ³ ZXUGHLP]XUFNOLH JHQGHQ.DSLWHODQKDQGGHUDPELYDOHQWHQ6HOEVWHUIDKUXQJHQGHUHULOOXVWULHUWGLH VLFKGXUFK6WHLJHUXQJGHUEHUXIOLFKHQ/HLVWXQJVELODQ]SHULGHQWLWlWVSROLWLVFKHP .DPSIHLQVDW]RGHULQGHPVLHVLFKIU$QGHUHOLHEHQVE]ZEHJHKUHQVZHUWPD FKHQLQYHUXQVLFKHUQGHXQGWHQGHQ]LHOOGHVWUXNWLYH$EKlQJLJNHLWHQYHUVWULFNHQ 'DVVGDVMHHLJHQH6HOEVWVHLQGDEHLDOVYROOHQGVGDYRQDEKlQJLJDQJHVHKHQZLUG VR]LDOH$QHUNHQQXQJ]XILQGHQVHLHVLP%OLFNDXIGLH3HUIRUPDQ]DP$UEHLWV SODW]KLQVLFKWOLFKEHVWLPPWHUNROOHNWLYHU,GHQWLWlWVPHUNPDOHRGHUGXUFKV*H OLHEWZHUGHQLVWHLQH9RUVWHOOXQJGLHHV]XKLQWHUIUDJHQJLOW'HQQGLHLP=XJH GHVVHQHUKHLVFKWH6HOEVW%HVWlWLJXQJNDQQHEHQLPPHUDXFKDXVEOHLEHQ0DJ GHUHQ RKQH )UDJH DOV EHVWlUNHQG HUOHEWH(UIOOXQJ DXV 6LFKW GHV EHWURIIHQHQ 6XEMHNWVDXFK$OOHVEHGHXWHQPXVVLKUH9HUVDJXQJQLFKWXQEHGLQJWKHLHQGDVV $OOHV1LFKWVLVWXQGHVVHOEVWDXIJDQ]HU/LQLHYHUVDJWKDW 'DVMHGHQIDOOVLVWHLQJHZLFKWLJHU3XQNWGHUDXVWKHRORJLVFKHU6LFKWEHJUQ GHWHU:HLVHVWDUN]XPDFKHQLVWXQG]ZDULQGHPGLHVR]LDOH8QYHUUHFKHQEDUNHLW GHV6XEMHNWVDOV6LJQXPGHULKPNUDIWVHLQHV*RWWHVYHUKlOWQLVVHV]XWHLOZHUGHQ GHQ*|WWOLFKNHLW]XU6SUDFKHJHEUDFKWZLUG6LFKYHUPLWWHOVGHUV\PEROLVFKHQ $XVGUXFNVIRUPHQGLHFKULVWOLFKHUVHLWVDXI]XELHWHQVLQGVHOEVWDXI*RWW]XEH ]LHKHQEHGHXWHWVHLQHUVHOEVWDOVJ|WWOLFKDEVROXWLQQH]XZHUGHQ LP6LQQHGHV HLJHQHQ1LFKW$XIJHKHQVLQDOOHQZHOWOLFKHQE]ZVR]LDOHQ%HGLQJXQJHQXQG %HVWLPPWKHLWHQ0|JOLFKH0HGLHQVROFKHU6HOEVWYHUJHZLVVHUXQJVRZXUGHLP ]XUFNOLHJHQGHQ.DSLWHOEHLVSLHOKDIW]HLJWVLQGHWZD GLHIHLHUOLFKH%HJHKXQJ GHV6RQQWDJVEHUKDXSWGHULQ'LIIHUHQ]]XPDUEHLWVDPHQ:HUNWDJDOVÄV\PER OLVFKHU 2UW LQGLYLGXHOOHU )UHLKHLW³ YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ GLH 7DXIH DOV Ä6\PEROGHU0HQVFKHQZUGH³LQGHUGLH1LFKW)HVWOHJEDUNHLWGHV6XEMHNWVDXI GDVZDVHVVR]LDOLVWXQGVHLQVROO]XP $XVGUXFNNRPPW GDV6HHOVRUJHJH VSUlFKDOV2UWHLQHVDXFKGXUFKVHQVLEHOHLQJHEUDFKWHÄFKULVWOLFKH>@6LQQIRUPHQ ZLH *HEHWH 3VDOPHQ /LHGHU³ HUP|JOLFKWHQ 'LVWDQ] XQG )UHLKHLWVJHZLQQV JHJHQEHU GHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFK XPODXIHQGHQ ,GHDOYRUVWHOOXQJHQ VRZLH GHP HLJHQHQ6FKHLWHUQDQGHUHQ(UIOOXQJÄ-HGRFK³VRLVWPLW7UDXJRWW.RFKHLQ VFKUlQNHQG]XIRUPXOLHUHQ Ä)UGDV,QQHUVWHIUGHQ*ODXEHQNDQQHLQHlXHUH +DQGOXQJXQG=XVDJH³QXUGDQQÄEHGHXWVDPVHLQZHQQVLHHUJULIIHQXQGYHU VWDQGHQ³ZLUG'DQQDEHULVWVLHHVDXFK .RFKVHLQVFKUlQNHQGH)RUPXOLHUXQJXQWHUVWUHLFKWHLQPDOPHKUGDVVDOOHLQLQ GHUÄLPPHUDXFKPHLQH2KQPDFKW³EHGHXWHQGHQÄ)UHLKHLWGHV$QGHUHQ³GHP GLHÃlXHUH+DQGOXQJXQG=XVDJHµHWZDLP6HHOVRUJHJHVSUlFKHLQVLFKWLJZHUGHQ
7$HQ@RGHUJDUZHJHUNOlU>HQ@³ZLOOZLHHV QLFKWQXU -QJHO DQ]XVWUHEHQVFKHLQW6HLQKLHU]XHULQQHUQGHU+LQZHLVÄVRHWZDVZLH6ROLSVLV PXV³VHLÄHLQHJRWWHVOlVWHUOLFKH7KHRULH³EHWULIIWGDV*HVDJWHPLWKLQQLFKW:R QlPOLFKGHP6XEMHNWHLQHYRQDXHQDQHVJHULFKWHWHÃ=XVDJHEHGHXWVDPZLUGµ ZHLOHVVLHÃHUJULIIHQµXQGLQ%H]XJDXIVLFKVHOEVWÃYHUVWDQGHQµKDWLVWHVGDULQ DXFK]ZDQJORVPLW$QGHUHQYHUEXQGHQ±XQG]ZDUQLFKWQXUPLWGHQHQGLHHV NRQNUHWPLWGHUÃ=XVDJHµNRQIURQWLHUWHQ(EHQVRZLHÄGHU*ODXEH>«@GHQHLQ ]HOQHQ]XK|FKVWYHUHLQ]HOW³ÄLKQXQYHUWUHWEDULKQVHOEVWPHLQW³LVWHUGRFK QLHQXUPHLQ*ODXEHVRQGHUQGLH:DKUKHLWIUDOOH>«@ GDVDOVRZDVLFK>«@IUDOOHDOVLKUH :DKUKHLWEHJUHLIHIROJOLFKDOOHQZQVFKH6RDXIGLHDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQ]XJHKHQLQGHUhEHU ]HXJXQJGDGLH:DKUKHLWGHV*ODXEHQVDXFKIUVLHJLOW GDVYHUELQGHW0HQVFKHQ
'LH*HOWXQJ QLFKWQXU GHUÃ:DKUKHLWGHV*ODXEHQVµYRQGHULFKIUPLFKEHU ]HXJWELQLVWMHGRFKQLFKWVZDV]XHU]ZLQJHQXQGGXUFK]XVHW]HQZlUHVRQGHUQ ZLHGHUXPQXUHWZDVGHUXQYHUIJEDUHQ)UHLKHLWGHV$QGHUHQDXV]XVHW]HQGHV $QGLHVHU6WHOOHOHJWVLFKQXQQRFKGLH)UDJHQDKHZDUXPHVZHQQGRFKGLH WKHRORJLVFK]XDN]HQWXLHUHQGH'LPHQVLRQVR]LDOXQYHUUHFKHQEDUHQ6HOEVWVHLQV DXISKLORVRSKLVFKHU6HLWHOlQJVWKHUYRUJHKREHQZLUGEHUKDXSWGHUWKHRORJL VFKHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH EHGDUI 6LH OlVVW VLFK LP $QVFKOXVV DQ GHQ 3ROLWLNZLVVHQ VFKDIWOHUXQG6R]LDOSKLORVRSKHQ,ULQJ)HWVFKHUEHDQWZRUWHQ Ä(LQH9RUDXVVHW]XQJGHU0|JOLFKNHLWGHV7RWDOLWDULVPXV³VRVFKUHLEWHULQ HLQHP$XIVDW]GHUVLFKGHP9HUKlOWQLVYRQ,QGLYLGXXPXQG*HPHLQVFKDIWLP
-h1*(/H -h1*(/ .2&+I :$*1(5N :$*1(5 E -h1*(/H .2&+H
(SLORJ
/LFKWHGHU+HJHOVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHGHV*HLVWHVZLGPHWOLHJHÄLQGHU$XVVFKDO WXQJMHGHU$UWYRQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]³*HQDXGLHVLVWDXVVHLQHU6LFKWGLH)ROJH ÄGHUÃ9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJµXQGÃ9HUJHVFKLFKWOLFKXQJµGHV*|WWOLFKHQGLH+HJHO XQWHUQRPPHQ³KDEHXPÄ,QGLYLGXXPXQG*HPHLQVFKDIWHQGJOWLJ]XYHUV|K QHQ³:RDEHUÃMHGH$UWYRQ7UDQV]HQGHQ]µDXVJHVFKDOWHWZHUGHN|QQHÄYRQ ÃDXHQµKHUNHLQHUOHL6LQQIRUGHUXQJNHLQH1RUPNHLQH.ULWLNDQGLH:LUNOLFK NHLWKHUDQJHWUDJHQZHUGHQ³VRGDVVGDVÄ,QGLYLGXXP³EDUVHLQHVÄXQPLWWHOED UH>Q@ 9HUKlOWQLV>VVHV@ >«@ ]X *RWW >«@ VFKXW]ORV GHQ 0lFKWHQ GHV 'DVHLQV SUHLVJHJHEHQ³VHLÄ'HUXQHQGOLFKH:HUWGHV,QGLYLGXXPVµYRQGHPDXFK +HJHO VSULFKW³ VR ODXWHW )HWVFKHUV DEVFKOLHHQGH 7KHVH VHL ÄQXU JDUDQWLHUW ZHQQHVXQPLWWHOEDU]X*RWWµLVW³±HLQHP*RWWYHUVWHKWVLFKGHUQLFKWLQGHU ,PPDQHQ]VR]LRKLVWRULVFKHU.RQWH[WHDXIJHKW 8QDEKlQJLJYRQGHUK|FKVWVWULWWLJHQ)UDJHREÄLP+HJHOVFKHQ'HQNHQGDV ,QGLYLGXXPYHUORUHQJHKW³GLHLP5DKPHQGHUYRUOLHJHQGHQ$UEHLWVFKRQLP =XVDPPHQKDQJPLW7UDXJRWW.RFKEHJHJQHWLVWLQWHUHVVLHUWDQ)HWVFKHUV6LFKW KLHU YRU DOOHP GLH HQJH 9HUNRSSOXQJ YRQ J|WWOLFKHU 7UDQV]HQGHQ] XQG XQHQGOLFKHP:HUWGHV,QGLYLGXXPVµ'LHQLFKWKRFKJHQXJ]XVFKlW]HQGH%H GHXWXQJGHV7UDQV]HQGHQ]JHGDQNHQVOLHJWGHPQDFKGDULQGDVVHUGHP,QGLYL GXXPHLQHQXQEHGLQJWHQ+DOWLP-HQVHLWVLPPDQHQWHU6R]LDOEH]JHHU|IIQHW DXIJUXQGGHVVHQHVQLFKWÃVFKXW]ORVGHQ0lFKWHQGHV'DVHLQVSUHLVJHJHEHQµLVW (VZLUGZHQQHVVLFKDXVGHU*RWWXQPLWWHOEDUNHLWVHLQHV*ODXEHQVKHUDXVYHU VWHKWHEHQVRGHVÃXQHQGOLFKHQ:HUWVµVHLQHUVHOEVWLQQHZLH]XUSRWHQ]LHOOHQ 4XHOOHNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHUÃ6LQQIRUGHUXQJHQµÃ1RUPHQµXQGÃ.ULWLNµ'DULQNDQQ GLHEHVRQGHUH(UVFKOLHXQJVNUDIWHLQHUFKULVWOLFKUHOLJL|VHQ6HOEVWWKHPDWLVLHUXQJ LP+RUL]RQWJ|WWOLFKHU7UDQV]HQGHQ]HQWGHFNWZHUGHQ$XILKUHP+LQWHUJUXQG EOHLEWMHGHV:LU]XJXQVWHQGHV,FKVEHUVFKUHLWEDUGDVVLFKVRGHVVHQYHUJHZLV VHUQNDQQGDVVHVLQVHLQHQVR]LDOHQ%H]JHQQLFKWDXIJHKW
)(76&+(5 9JO]XP)ROJHQGHQ DD2I $D2 (EG (EG (EGÄ)DVWDOOH2SSRVLWLRQJHJHQ+HJHOJLQJYRQGHP9RUZXUIDXVGDLQVHLQHU3KLOR VRSKLHGDV,QGLYLGXXPXQWHUGUFNWZHUGH³VFKUHLEW+HQQLQJ2WWPDQQGHUGLHVHP9RUZXUILQ HLQHUDXVIKUOLFKHQ'DUVWHOOXQJGHU+HJHO5H]HSWLRQQDFKJHJDQJHQLVW 2770$11 $QGUHDV$UQGWEHPHUNWGD]X Ä6RHLQVHLWLJXQGLP (LQ]HOQHQ YLHOIDFKVFKOLFKWLUULJGLHVH $XIIDVVXQJDXFKLVWVRNDQQVLHDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHDEHUDXFKQLFKWGDGXUFKHQWNUlIWHW ZHUGHQGDVV+HJHO]XP'HQNHUGHU,QGLYLGXDOLWlWLQHLQHPVWDUNHQ6LQQHVWLOLVLHUWZLUGGHP VWHKWVFKRQGHU$ULVWRWHOLVPXV+HJHOVHQWJHJHQGHU,QGLYLGXHQLPPHUVFKRQDOVYHUJHVHOO VFKDIWHWH,QGLYLGXHQYHUVWHKW³ $51'7 9JOGD]XGLHWUHIIHQGHQ:RUWH.ODXV0LFKDHO.RGDOOHV Ä*HZLVVLVWGLH9HUVWlQGLJXQJ EHU:DKUKHLWLPPHUHLQNRPPXQLNDWLYHU3UR]HVV'DUDXVOHLWHWVLFKGLH9HUZLHVHQKHLWDXI *HPHLQVFKDIWDXI.LUFKHDXI6WDDWDE'RFKGHU3HUVRQNHUQJHKWLQGLHVHQ9HUPLWWOXQJVSUR ]HVVHQQLFKWDXIZLUGQLFKWVXEVWDQ]LHOOÃDXIJHKREHQµ'HU6WDFKHOGHU1RQNRQIRUPLWlWKDW VLFKLQMHGHPNLUFKOLFKRGHUSROLWLVFKDQJHVDJWHQ9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJVSUR]HVV]XU*HOWXQJ]X
(SLORJ
*OHLFKZRKOLVW*RWWDXFKDOVÃLP:LUµEHJHJQHQG]XU6SUDFKH]XEULQJHQ DOV MHQHU Ä>L@Q GHU VR]LDOHQ 3UD[LV³ JHOLQJHQGHU ÄZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU $QHUNHQQXQJ³ PDQLIHVWHÄ*HLVWGHUYHUV|KQHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ³ZLH)DON:DJQHULP$Q VFKOXVVDQ+HJHOVFKUHLEW6RZHQLJHVGXUFKGDV=XWHLOZHUGHQYRQ$QHUNHQ QXQJDXFK]ZLQJHQG GD]XNRPPWGDVVGLHDQHUNDQQWH3HUVRQZLOOZDVGLH DQHUNHQQHQGHZLOOVRVHKULVWGDV)UHLKHLWV]XJHVWlQGQLVDOVPDQVHOEVWHWZDV %HVWLPPWHVVHLQ]XGUIHQGRFKGLH0|JOLFKNHLWVEHGLQJXQJHLQHUXQJH]ZXQ JHQRIIHQHQXQGQLFKWLQVLFKYHUVFKORVVHQHQ/HEHQVZHLVHÄ>'@DV(LJHQH'LI IHUHQWH³ PXVV GDQQ QLFKW ÄÃLQ VLFKµ JHKDOWHQ ZHUGHQ³ XP HV GHU JlQ]OLFKHQ Ä$XIKHEXQJ LQ HLQHP HU]ZXQJHQHQ NROOHNWLYHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ³ MD GHU JH ZQVFKWHQÄ*OHLFKVFKDOWXQJ³PLWDOOHU.UDIW]XHQW]LHKHQZLHHVGHPHLQJDQJV ]LWLHUWHQ /XW] 6HLOHU QDFK HLJHQHP %HNXQGHQ MHQVHLWV HLQHU IUHLKHLWOLFK GHPRNUDWLVFKHQ*UXQGRUGQXQJHUJLQJ=ZDULVWDXFKGLHOHW]WHUHQLFKWGDYRU JHIHLW±]XPDOLQ SDQGHPLVFKHQ 1RWVWDQGV]HLWHQ±GHQ)UHLUDXPGHV6XEMHNWV EHU*HEKUHLQ]XVFKUlQNHQ'RFKLVWVLHSULQ]LSLHOORIIHQIU.ULWLNXQG.RU UHNWXUXQGGDPLWDXFKIUGDVSRWHQ]LHOOH$XINRPPHQHLQHVQXULQIUHLHU$XVHL QDQGHUVHW]XQJ VLFK LPPHU QHX NRQVWLWXLHUHQGHQ XQG ZHLWHUKLQ KLQWHUIUDJEDU EOHLEHQGHQJHPHLQVDPHQ:LU%HZXVVWVHLQV :RGDV6XEMHNWLQVHLQHPIUHLHQ6LFK9HUKDOWHQJHJHQEHUGHQHVEHVWLP PHQGHQVR]LDOHQ%H]JHQDEHUEHUKDXSWHWZDVZLOOVHW]WHVXQZHLJHUOLFKYRU DXVGDPLWDXIGLH=XVWLPPXQJ$QGHUHUVWRHQ]XN|QQHQ(VEDXWGDUDXIGDVV VLFKMHQH*HPHLQVDPNHLWMHQHV:LUHUJHEHQNDQQGDVPLW7UDXJRWW.RFKDOV EULQJHQ*HZLVVGLHQRQNRQIRUPH([LVWHQ]NDQQVLFKDXIVSUHL]HQNDQQVLFKDXISOXVWHUQ]XU QHJDWLYLVWLVFKHQ.ULWLNLQVWDQ]GHUMHGHUDIILUPDWLYH6FKULWWLQ9HUJHPHLQVFKDIWXQJVIRUPHQLP K\SHUNULWLVFKHQ8UWHLO]HUEU|VHOW$EHUGLHVH*HIDKUIUDXWKHQWLVFKH/HEHQVIKUXQJZLUGKLHU IUZHQLJHUUHOHYDQWHUDFKWHWDOVGLH$XIO|VXQJGHVQRQNRQIRUPHQ6HOEVWLQ3UR]HVVHQHLQHU QLFKWVHOWHQPLW%HJHLVWHUXQJHLQKHUJHKHQGHQ)RUPLHUXQJYRQ*HPHLQVFKDIWE]Z*HPHLQ VFKDIWHQGHUHQ$EVRUSWLRQVNUDIWGXUFKVXJJHVWLYHZLHPDFKWYROOHSROLWLVFKUHOLJL|VH'HX WXQJVVWUDWHJLHQYHUVWlUNWZLUG³ .RGDOOH .RGDOOHVSULFKWLP$QVFKOXVVDQ.LHUNH JDDUGYRQHLQHUÄIUHLKHLWOLFKHQ6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJLQGHU*HJHQZDUWGHV$EVROXWHQ³DXVGHU KHUDXVVLFKÄGDV6HOEVWLQDEVROXWJHUHFKWIHUWLJWHU1LFKWLGHQWLWlW>«@JHJHQMHJOLFKH*HVWDOW HLQHVYHUIKUHULVFKHQ.ROOHNWLYZDKQV]XLPPXQLVLHUHQYHUPDJ³ DD2 :$*1(5 9JOKLHU]XQRFKHLQPDO+RQQHWKGHUYRQHLQHPÄLPVR]LDOHQ/HEHQVSUR]HYHUDQNHU WH>Q@,PSHUDWLY³VFKUHLEWGHUÄDOVHLQQRUPDWLYHU=ZDQJ>«@GLH,QGLYLGXHQ]XUVFKULWWZHLVHQ (QWVFKUlQNXQJ GHV *HKDOWHV GHU ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ Q|WLJW³ +211(7+ G I RGHUYRQHLQHPÄ=ZDQJ]XU5H]LSUR]LWlW>«@GHUGLHHLQDQGHUEHJHJQHQGHQ6XEMHNW JHZDOWORVGD]XQ|WLJWDXFKLKUVR]LDOHV*HJHQEHU>«@DQ]XHUNHQQHQ³ DD2 $QDORJ GD]XKHLWHVEHL:DJQHU Ä'LH5HDOLVLHUXQJYRQ$QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQOlWVLFKQLFKW HU]ZLQJHQ$EHUGHU=ZDQJGHUGDQQQ|WLJZLUGZHQQ)UHLKHLWQLFKWLQGHU)RUPYRQ$QHU NHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQUHDOLVLHUWZLUGYHUGHXWOLFKWQXUQRFKHLQPDOGDGXUFKLKQGLH(LQVLFKW HU]ZXQJHQ ZLUG GHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ DXIJUXQG YRQ IUHLHU 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ QDFK]XNRPPHQ³ :$*1(5 6(,/(5
(SLORJ
Ä*RWWXQWHUGHQ0HQVFKHQ³V\PEROLVLHUW]XZHUGHQYHUPDJÃ*RWWLP:LUµ]X VXFKHQEHGHXWHWGLH8QHU]ZLQJEDUNHLWMHGHV:LU]XDN]HSWLHUHQGDVLQVHLQHP NRQWLQJHQWHQ$XINRPPHQQXULQWHQGLHUEDUDEHUQLFKW]XEHZHUNVWHOOLJHQLVW ZHQQPDQGHQQGHQMHZHLOV$QGHUHQZLUNOLFKLQVHLQHPIUHLHQ$QGHUVVHLQGDEHL KDEHQZLOO0DQNDQQLKQQXUDOVVROFKHQDQHUNHQQHQXQGDXIVHLQ'DEHLVHLQ KRIIHQ )UDJWPDQQDFKHLQHU)RUPGHV6R]LDOHQGLHIUGDVIUHLH6LFK(LQVWHOOHQVRO FKHUVHOEVWJHZROOWHU9HUEXQGHQKHLWLP,FKEHUJUHLIHQGHQ:LUGLHEHVWHQ$XV VLFKWHQE|WHZlUHGDVPLW+LQULFK)LQN(LWHOJHVDJWZRKOZHQLJHUGLHÄH[NOX VLYH>@*HIKOVLQQLJNHLWYRQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHQ³DOVYLHOPHKUÄMHQHVZHLWJHKHQG IRUPDOLVLHUWHXQGGLVWDQ]LHUWH*HVHOOVFKDIWVVSLHOGDVZLUDOOHDOV5HLFKIUHXQGOL FKHUWDNWYROOHU$OOWlJOLFKNHLWNHQQHQ³ 0DQHQWIHUQWVLFKYRQHLQDQGHURKQHVLFKGXUFK*OHLFKJOWLJNHLW]XYHUOHW]HQ0DQZHWWHLIHUW PLWHLQDQGHURKQHVLFK]XEHUYRUWHLOHQ0DQEHVFKHQNWHLQDQGHURKQH]XEHVFKlPHQXQG PDQHQW]LHKWVLFKJHJHEHQHQIDOOVGLH=XVWLPPXQJRKQH]XEHOHLGLJHQ
.2&+J ),1.(,7(/ D
/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV /LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV $//(1$0