277 99 4MB
German Pages 227 Year 2012
Interview und schriftliche Befragung Grundlagen und Methoden empirischer Sozialforschung von
Horst Otto Mayer
Fachhochschule Vorarlberg 6., überarbeitete Auflage
Oldenbourg Verlag München
Bibliografische Information der Deutschen Nationalbibliothek Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nationalbibliografie; detaillierte bibliografische Daten sind im Internet über http://dnb.d-nb.de abrufbar. © 2013 Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag GmbH Rosenheimer Straße 145, D-81671 München Telefon: (089) 45051-0 www.oldenbourg-verlag.de Das Werk einschließlich aller Abbildungen ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Jede Verwertung außerhalb der Grenzen des Urheberrechtsgesetzes ist ohne Zustimmung des Verlages unzulässig und strafbar. Das gilt insbesondere für Vervielfältigungen, Übersetzungen, Mikroverfilmungen und die Einspeicherung und Bearbeitung in elektronischen Systemen. Lektorat: Christiane Engel-Haas M.A. Herstellung: Constanze Müller Titelbild: thinkstockphotos.de Einbandgestaltung: hauser lacour Gesamtherstellung: freiburger graphische betriebe GmbH & Co. KG, Freiburg Dieses Papier ist alterungsbeständig nach DIN/ISO 9706. ISBN 978-3-486-70691-8 eISBN 978-3-486-71762-4
"?92=EDG6CK6:49?:D
"&$",-&
/+%!,"/"++&+!,1-*/"++&+!,
**2%15'11#,
5'11#,1!&$2*'!&,"#*,'121712#+2'1!&3," ,!&4-**8'#& 0
"#$','2'-,4-, #%0'$$
95*519D9?>
9557B966C5H@
95&?=9>19D9?>
95?@5B1D9?>19D9?> "'#2-0'#
%,!''$' "$++"+.'&%,!'
%03,",,&+#,
"#0)0'2'1!02'-,*'1+31
/3*'22'4#$-01!&3,%
.'&** +,$$-& 1-%%'$$
)-$",,".* -& +$",&"&,*."/
"1*#'2$"#,',2#04'#5*1#6.#02#,',2#04'#5
"'#12'!&.0- #$V0#6.#02#,',2#04'#51
"'##,25'!)*3,%"#1*#'2$"#,1
"30!&$V&03,%"#1',2#04'#51
315#023,%
%V2#)0'2#0'#,
)-&,",,".* -& *+,&*"+"*, * ' &
"'#12'!&.0- #
BE>475C1=D859DE>4+D938@B?25 0E61 95+D938@B?25>7BNP5 "1+#11+-"#**
+#11#,
1D5>E>4+;1 +;1>9F51EC -.#02'-,*'1'#03,%
.1B912 !>49;1D?B5> 1)*'#03,%14#0$&0#,3,"',"#6 '*"3,%
*1D9>7+;145H297 $9;5BD+;1D9C385C9665B5>D91819C
%V2#)0'2#0'#,
"#0$0%# -%#,
95B175> B1=1DEB79545CB1752?75>C "30!&$V&03,%"#0 #$0%3,%
+38B96D7 %O>47 ,59>D5BF95G '>556B17E>7 "2#,#',% #3,""2#,3$ #0#'23,%
9559>J55>+38B9DD5 ?495BE>7E>41D5>=1DB9H -=6?B=E>7E>4&5E297F?>.1B912 #1!&0#' 3,%4-,4#02#'*3,%#,3,"831++#,&T,%#, "#1)0'.2'4#122'12')
,125 (1B1=5D5BF?> ME697;59DCF5BD5975> 0EC1==5>8M>75JG9C385>JG59.1B912
.0V$3,%4-,&7.-2#,',"3)2'4#122'12')
!BBDE=CG18BC3859>4+97>969;1>J ->9F1B91D5E>429F1B91D5>1 >@1CCE>7CD5CD259>?=9>1.1B912 45B >@1CCE>7CD5CD >@1CCE>7CD5CD259AE1>D9D1D9F5>.1B912 59>61385BD,5CD6OB45>%9DD57CD5CD259AE1>D9D1D9F5>.1B912 45B#??F>@1CCE>7CD5CD ->D5BC38954CD5CD259>?=9>1.1B912 45B ->D5BC38954CD5CD ->D5BC38954CD5CD259?B49>11D5>E>4JG59E>12 8M>7975>+D938@B?25>45B%1>>/89D>5I-,5CD ->D5BC38954CD5CD259AE1>D9D1D9F5>1D5>E>4JG59E>128M>7975> +D938@B?25>45BD,5CD ->D5BC38954CD5CD259?B49>11D5>E>4=58B112 8M>7975>+D938@B?25>45B ,5CDF?>#BEC;11D5>E>4=58B1128M>7975>+D938@B?25>495.1B91>J1>181>7CD5CDC259>?=9>11D5>45B (89#?5669J95>DC?G9545B#?>D9>75>J;?5669J95>D 0EC1==5>81>7CD5CDC259?B49>11D5>495 #?BB5C1>1C*E>4#5>417CD5CD259AE1>D9D1D9F5>1D5>495 #?BB5C1>1CB L25BC938D45B2581>45>1
%-$,".*",-+/*,-& +.*!*&
"'#$)2-0#,,*71#
"'#!*312#0,*71#
"'#+3*2'.*#0#%0#11'-,1,*71#
"'#)-40',8,*71#
!>819C
**"!,
',&*2#"#1 #0'!&21
"012#**3,%"#0#0%# ,'11#',2 #**#,3,"%0$')#,
$'++*
$",*,-*.*1"!&"+
+!* "+,*
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
&:G=>EGG:LMBFFM>G0>@>EG
*>BM?:=>GBGM>KOB>P LM:G=:K=BLB>KM>L 'GM>KOB>PNG= L?K:@NG@
8B>E
1.11.15
9>7
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
/2D>249E5:6/:DD6?D4927EKFC/:DD6? D4927E
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
1N;C>DMBO> 'GM>KIK>M:MBHG
>@KB??>NG= 5BKDEBBM
%>F>BGL:FD>BM>G
/1C=138D495/9CC5>C3816DJEB/9CC5>C3816D
GB@MNGM>K:G=>K>F:GBGM>KG:EBLB>KM>G@>L>EELGMBHG>G H=>K Y;>KEB>?>KM>G 1F:M: PB> KMRI>G ;SP BLMBGO>KL=>G>GILRDM>G;>@KYG=>M=B>NG L>K>'GM>KIK>M:MBHGLOB>E?:EM>BGLG 1HE#??>DM>LBG=SNF >BLIB>E=B>%>LM:EM@>L>MS>+>G=>K3KL:GSNLB ;NG@ MMKB;NB>KNG@ &:EH #??>DM >M< O@E +:R>K "B>L> #BG?EYLL>LBG=SN;>KY5BKDEBBMFX@ EBG:N= A G:GLKB>G;>H;:G "B>+>GLG>GMPBEGV;>KS>N@NG@>G#BGLM>EENG@>GY;>K=B> 5>EM;SP Y;>K=:L4>KA:EM>G:G=>K>KNFLBKL=>G>G 1BMN:MBHG>GSNK>G=B>L>SNDHGMKHEEB>K>GH=>K@>SB>EMSN O>KWG=>KG #L LBG= =B>L 4HKLM>EENG@>G ;SP +H=>EE> OHG NGM>K L=EBG 1BMN:MBHG>G LHPB> 8NL:FF>GAWG@>G BG =>K 5BKD EBBM 1HE 4HKLM>EENG@>G NG= +H=>EE> >QBLMB>K>G G>;>G>B G:G=>K NG= DXGG>G LBG "B>L S>B@>G S 4HEDLP>BLA>BM>GPB>
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
/1C=138D495/9CC5>C3816DJEB/9CC5>C3816D
=>KAHE;:KD>BM%>G:NB@D>BM>M< LHLBG=LN;C>DMBO> #BG?EYLL> ABG =>KEB&+(
/:DD6?D4927E=:496D!2?56=?:DEDJDE6>2E:D49 F?5?249G@==K:6932C
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
5BLL>GLGLGDHGLMKNB>KM
5:AKA>BMNG= -;C>DMBOBMWM
4HF5BLL>GLKP>K=>GNGM>K:G=>K>FG>NMK:E>"BLM:GSNG= 'GM>KLN;C>DMBO> 5>KM?K>BA>BM @>?HK=>KM ">GGHA>G P>K=>G %YEMB@D>BM=>K =:LL ;>K>BML =B> #GMLB=NG@ P>KM?K>B OHKSN@>A>G >BG> 5>KMNG@ NLL:@>G
/1C=138D495/9CC5>C3816DJEB/9CC5>C3816D
=:KLM>EEM "B>4HK@>A>GLP>BL>FNLLC>=HG?YK)KBMBDL>BG ">GGBGM>KLN;C>DMBOY;>KIKY?;:K>NLL:@>G LBG==B> :LBLPBLL>GLGGMGBL "B>'2:5;D9F9DMD=>KPBLL>GLEB>@M=:KBG=:LL LB> 9>D5BCE2:5;D9F >138@BO621B L>BG FYLL>G .HII>K 1
"B> 1KNG@>G =YK?>G GB> =H@F:MBL?:LLM L>BG LHG=>KGFYLL>GBFF>K>BG>K5B=>KE>@NG@=NKN>$:DM>GH? ?>GLM>A>G
":FBMNLL:@>GBGM>KLN;C>DMBOG:G=B>O>K >@KB??>NG= P>G=>M>G >@KB??>@>G:N;>LMBFFM;SP =>?BGB>KMP>K=>G ,>;>G 5BKDEBBM =>K )E:KLM>EENG@ P:L FBM >BG>F >@KB?? BG >BG>K PBLL>GLBM @>G:N @>F>BGM BLM LBG= :NAK=>NMB@D>BM>G OHG >@KB??>GSNO>KF>B=>G
67:?:E:@?G@?68C:77
N?@:;> >BG>K PBLL>GL@KB??L;BE=NG@ BLM >L =>G 'G A:EM>BG>L >@KB??>LLH@>G:NNG=LH>BG=>NMB@PB>FX@EB LMBFF>G >B =>K >@KB??L;>LMBFFNG@ DXGG>G OB>K KM>G NGM>K L=>GP>K=>GO@E )HG>@>GNG=1HG=>K@>E=
495*519D9?> 49557B966C5H@ 495&?=9>19D9?>C?G95 495?@5B1D9?>19D9?>
KM>G=>K >@KB??L;>LMBFFNG@
95*519D9?> &B>K@>AM>L=:KNF=:L5>L>G>BG>K1:SN>K?:LL>G=:KSNE> +:MA>F:MBDNG= @>GP:L>BG"BG@BLM 5WAK>G=?YK=B>+:MA>F:MBD>KNG=*H@BD>K *H@BD 5>KM?K>BA>BMPBK=C>=HGL?HK=>KM $YK=B>
4>KMK>M>K=>K$K:GD?NKM>K1S BLM5>KM?K>BA>BM>BG>1>E;LMMWNLBG> %>L>EELA>G=> ,:MNK LHG=>KG BFF>K IKH=NSB>KM> %>LEEMPHK:NLLBKM>GMLB=NG@>GNG=IHEBMBLNLPBKDNG@>G>BG>LGHNMK:E` @>F>BGM>G &:G=>EGL SPBG@>G= >K@>;>G 5>BM>KL ?YAKM =:L .HLMNE:M =>K 5>KM?K>BA>BM =:SN =:LL GHKF:MBO> 4HK@:;>G =>F GBGLK>BKE:LL>GNG=LHFBM>BG>KPBLL>GLKIKY?NG@>GMSH@>GP>K=>G O@E =:SN =HKGH : &HKDA>BF>K LHPB> &:;>KF:L :;>K :NK
/1C=138D495/9CC5>C3816DJEB/9CC5>C3816D
=B>0>:E=>?BGBMBHG>BG>@KHZ> >=>NMNG@A:M?BG=>M=B>L>;>BLH SB:E PBKMLBLM>LPBLL>GL@KB??>G BG =>K 0>@>ED>BG>4>KP>G=NG@ #BGF:ELBG==B> >=>NMNG@>G=>KAB>K O>KP>G=>M>G >@KB??> L>AK DHFIE>Q NG= SNF :G=>K>G TG=>KNG @>G NGM>KPHK?>G 1H BLM >L H?M SP>L>EE LK PBKMLEL =B> ">?BGBMBHG OHG >@KB??>GSNWG=>KGS $:FBEB>K;>BMLEHL>GK:M>"KH@>G>M< ">G 4>KLNL 0>BKBL BF ">NMLG ):BL>KK>BL>G` =>L >@KB??L d#BL>G;:AG` SN >K?:LL>G ?YAKM 1>B??>KM 1 :G d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`
>BLIB>E
":L 0>BKBGLB N?LNF FB>KNG@ :EE>K #B@>GLG =:L 5>L>G =>K #BL>G;:AG SN ;> LMBFF>G
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
>BLIB>E
95&?=9>19D9?> 'G=>G1HSB:E 5BKMLBLM>LPBLL>GLGA:;>G"> 1HSB:E 5BKMLGD>BG>G:EE@>F>BG@YEMB@>GNG=S>BMEHL@>EM>G=>G5:AK NG=%>BLM>L A>BML:GLIKNLA:G=>EMLBBE>=B@EBK>BG;:KNG@>G PBLL>GLG 'AK> N?@:;> BLM >L GBL>G OHG -;C>DM>G SN ;>LMBF F>GLHG=>KG=>GPBLL>GL@>G O@E E;>KM1 (,20,1$/'(),1,6,21(1+$1'(/6(55,&+70K 0>@>E BLM AB>K >BG> -KB>GMB>KNG@ :G ;BLA>KB@>G ">?BGBMBHG>G =>L ;>A:G=>EM>G >@KB??>L SP> .LRA:M>LFBM %>@>GLMWG=>G =>K 'GG>GP>EM SN MNG &>KF:GG #;;BG@A:NL
>BLIB>E
.LR
BLM >BG OHEEDHFF>G H;C>DMBO>K >QI>KBF>G M>EE>K 8P>B@ =>K ,:MNKPBLL>GLK 3GM>K EM>K PBK= =B> 8>BM SPBLG %>;NKM NG= #K A>;NG@O>KLM:G=>G $K:@>G:F%>;NKML=:MNF
>BLIB>E
"B> HI>K:MBHG:E> ">?BGBMBHG PBK= C>=HKA>;EBK P>GG>LLB@KB??>FBMBG=BK>DM>F>FIBKBLG >SN@A:G =>EM $YKLHEMA>HK>MBLG >@KB??> :NMBL)HG LMKNDM> H=>K E:M>GM> 4:KB:;E>G @>G:GGM PB> LHSB:E> 1G >M< FYLL>G 'G=BD:MHK>G @>?NG=>G P>K =>G =B> ;>H;: 2:M;>LMWG=> 4>KA:EM>GLP>BL>G H=>K 8N LMWG=>;>G>GG>GO@E )HG>@>GNG=1HG=>K@>E=1 ?? 1',.$624(1)>452G BE=NG@L:;LKN?
>BLIB>E
:6,96@C:6 #BG >@KB?? BLM ?YK =:L >@K>B?>G =>K 5BKDEBBM GBB 5BLL>GL >@KB??> DXGG>G LBG O>KL=>G>G 2A>HKB>G NGM>KLB=>G LB> FYLL>G C>=HKA:E;>BG>K2A>HKB>DE:K;>LMBFFMNG=>BGA>BMEBK P>G=>MP>K=>G *6=6G2?E6 ,96@C:6? 68C:776 *$",L, .!'*!+%-+ *>KG>GNGM>K0>BS $*&& 0>:DMBHGL LI>DM -++!&",, )HG=BMBHGB>K>G #'&!,!.!+%-+ 'G?HKF:MBHGL #KP>K;4>KWG=> +>GLK:K;>BMNG@ KNG@OHG$WAB@ O>K:K;>BM>G=>L5>L>G BG=BOB=N>EE> D>BM>G#BGLM>E )HGLMKNDMBHG #'&+,*-#,!.!+%-+ ENG@>G=NKG>GMLM>AM=NKDMBO>'GM>KIK>M:MBHG NG=)HGLMKNDMBHG
33 *62=:ENE68C:776F?5,96@C:6?
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
/1C=138D495/9CC5>C3816DJEB/9CC5>C3816D
LIKNB LBG= 'G =>G 0>:EPBLL>GLG FNLL C>=HV;>K>BGLMBFFNG@SPBLG=>GNLL:@>GNG==>K0>: EBMWMOHKA:G=>GL>BG >B=>K>FIBKBLGV;>KIKY?NG@=>L5:AKA>BML@>A:EM>LMA>HK>MB /N:GMBM:MBO>NG= LK NLL:@>G PBK= SPBLG JN:GMBM:MBO>G NG= JN:EBM:MBO>G JN:EBM:MBO>4>K?:AK>G 4>K?:AK>G NGM>KL=>G >B=>G 4>K?:AK>G EB>@>G NGM>KL=EB MA>HK>MBL )HGS>IM> NG= =:FBM NGM>KL=EB F>MAH=H EH@BL4HKLM>EENG@>GSN%KNG=>
%6E9@5@=@8:62=D2D:DG@?%6E9@56
CF?52??29>6?
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
"B>.HLBMBHG=>L)KBMBLG0:MBHG:EBLFNLSWAEMSNK1>1?=?