A History of the Commonwealth of Kentucky

Citation preview

J J?oclittie

(©lErT.

£>:ED2ii^E

4

Jfunson. Sc

isa])©:Eifi'^

Copyiighl secured

siji^^:s.a

(

A

HISTORY OF THE

COMMONWEALTH OF

KENTUCKY. BY MANN BUTLER,

LOUISVILLE,

A. M.

KY.:

PUBLISHED FOR THE AUTHOR BY WILCOX, DICKERMAN & CO. PRINTED BY

J.

A.

JAMES, CINCINNATI.

18 34.

Entered according to act of Congress, in the year 1834, by

MANN

BUTLER,

in the Clerk's Office of the District

A. M.,

Court of Kentucky.

Stereotyped by J. A. James, Cincinnati.

DEDICATION, TO

GENERAL WILLIAM CLARK, OF THE

STATE OF MISSOURI. Sir:

numerous friends whom the undertaking of Kentucky has procured for me, I know of no one who has conferred such signal obligations upon me, as The papers of your illustrious brother, George Rogers yourself. Clark, so liberally placed by you in my hands, have shed most the

Among

the History of

curious and interesting lights upon the affairs of the western country; and particularly of Kentucky. These could have been

procured from no other source. To whom then, can I so well dedicate self,

who have

memorials of our history, and

this History, as to

your-

some of

the most precious have so kindly contributed them

so faithfully preserved

Were this not the case, who is for the public information! so properly the representative of the pre-eminent founder of Kentucky, and the successful negotiator for its Virginia acknowledgement,

as his only surviving brother]

me to associate your ancient friend in arms, General William H. Harrison, as one to whom the author is next most deeply indebted, for interesting illustrations of the After yourself, allow

early military

Wayne,

movements

of your

common commander.

as well as for the elucidation of

General

some of the obscure

vicissitudes of Indian history.

Be pleased then, to accept this dedication of this work, as a testimonial of my high and unfeigned sense of the obligations conferred upon the great community of the west,

than on

my humble

historical labors.

much more

in your generous co-operation with In the interim I have the honor to remain self,

Your

my'

obliged friend,

MANN

iWticol

BUTLER.

»:

CONTENTS. CHAPTER

I.

Earliest condition of Kentucky— Iroquois, or Jlohawks, known in 1603— Early seatsProgress to the Mississippi and tiie Illinois— Appeal to the Colonial CommissionersGeneral Riaridock's talk— Treaties with the Enslish—Great treaty of 1768—OpmJon of Supreme Court on Indian title—Opinions of General Harrison— Treaties of 1//4— 1775—1785—1795 and 1819. [page 1.

CHAPTER

II.

Government— Prociamation of 17C3—Violations of it—Visit of Dr. Walker in 1747— Xanie the Shawanee river, CumlK.'rland— Visit of John Finley—of Daniel Koone— Long hunters— Visit of Capt. Thomas Bullitt and JIcAfees— Surveys of Louisville—Simon Keulon— Burning of Hendricks— Adventures of the McAfees—

Policv of

tiie

British

JaoiPS Harrod settles Karrodsburg— Battle of Point Pleasant— Treaty of 1774— Treaty Settlement of Booneshorouch and St. Asaphs ^Indian jliethod Of sieie. [page 17.

of 1775

—

—

CHAPTER

III.

—Cliosen a delegate to the VirJohn Jones — Calls on Governor Henry — Receives — Procures the of creation Kentucky county — Brings gun Kentucky gunpowder — on the tanks of Limestone creek — Blackf.sh powder from Fort Pitt Conceals attacks Harrodstown — Singular escape of Kay — Plans approved hy Governor end Council —Spies in Illinois— Arrives at the Falls of Ohio— Eclipse of "the Sun—Passes the Fails— Reaches Kaskaskia— Surprises the 'own — Takes Cahokia. [page

First visit of Clark to [jiiiia

Kentucky— Visits Harrodsiown

Lesislature with Galiriel for

it

35.

CHAPTER —

IV.

—

Plan azainst St. Vincents ^Thanks of ^'irginia St. Vincents revolts from the BritishIllinois county er. Girault Negotiations with Sew Orleans— Indian negotiations.

—

—

[page 58.

CHAPTER

V.

—

St. Vincents hy tl;e Eriti^^l;— Plans aaainst -Americans— French volunteers J'arch to St. Vinjeuts— -Capture—- Return to Kaskaskia. [page 79.

Recapture of

CHAPTER —

VI.

CHAPTER

VII.

First Colonel—Siege of St. Asapbs, or Loran's First Court of Kentucky—Its ofncers Station— -British Proclamations—Capture of Boone -Siege of Eoonesborough— -Land

Law— Its

Commissioners.

[page S8.

Coloiel David Rogers' Exje'^ition to .New OrieaT^s— Defeat—Captain Eenham -Colonel Bowman's Expedition: -Colonel Pyrd's E.ypialition up Licking— General George Rocers Clark's inarch from Fort JeSersor.-— .^huis up the Land office at Kanodsbura

—

Erpodition against Pickaway.

[pa.?e 1C2.

CHAPTER

VIII.

into Lincoln. Fayeuc and Jtilerson— -Erection cf Fort Jefferson on the Mississinpi— Spanish and Fien-li inlrigue."? at Paris against thewcsteni hoinuia'-v of the United SMtes— -McKpc and Girty— -Vltack on Bryant's Station -Battle of tlie F'lio Licks- -Ex|)C(iition of General Clark to the Cliilicothcs in 17P-2— -Early manners and state of the nrif in Kentucky. [page 116.

Kentucky county divided

CHAPTER

IX.

Land Titiej— Attempts tn sever Kentucky from the United States— -John Jay resists tiieni— Supreme District Court cstaWishcd— -James Wilkinson-—Commerciai Associa lion in Philadelphia--Scttlenieiit of Washiufflon. in Mason county—Indian ricprcrla tlons --Fir.'=t Convciiti.m— Vjr\

-

rcnce, above Quebec, and on both sides of the lakes Ontario. -»

Prfsent state of North America, nolsliy,

17,"(."i,

p. 14, 18,

'20.

Comnmnicatod

!>y

tlii;

politencsfi of Isaac Ncwiiall, Esq. of Salem, .Matsarhuictts, from the Historical Roon,* in that City, derived from Coldcn'i Five Nations, and confinued by thie btter work.

A

nisTOEv OP KEN'xrcEir,

il

Erie and Huron. In this career of conquest, with a magnanimity s^agacious spirit worthy of the ancient Romans, and supe-

and

cotemporary tribes, they successively incorporated the victims of their arms, with their own confederacy. Under this comprehensive policy, some of their greatest

rior to all their

sachems are said

to

have sprung from conquered but concilia-

ted confederates.

In 1672 these tribes are represented as having conquered the Oillinois cr Illinois residing en the Illmois river; and they are likevv'ise at the same time, said to have conquered and incorporated the Satanas, the

Chawanons

they had forinerly driven from the

or Shawanons,

To

la.kes.

they are said by the same high authority,

to

whom

these conquests,

have added

in

iGS5,that; of the Twightwces, as they are called in the Journal

These of Major Washington to Gov. Dinv.iddie, of Virginia. this known as the at more are Miamis, tribes, day, generally and they lived on the river St. Jerome, as the Wabash was first called l)y the French. About the same time, the Mohawks carried their victorious

"arms

to the Illinois

and Mississippi rivers west-

v/ard, Georgia southward." *About 1711, they incorv>iicn driven from Carolina, and they the Tiiscaroras, porated continue at this day, to constitute a part of this once memora-

and

to

and thus changing

ble confederacy; forming the sixth nation,

name of their union, from the Five Nations to that The rifc and progress of these most remarkable Six.

the

of the tribes,

have worthily employed tlic pens of several historians, both French and English; they have even seduced the mind of Dc Witt Clinton, from the cares of the great State of New York, to investiga'.e the history of her most ancient and faithful allies.

To

this

summary, other

authorities

may

well be added,

on a point, so vital to tlie early, history of Kentucky, and of Western America. This becomes more necessary, since the connection of these tribes with the history of Kentucky, has escaped the notice of all our recent writers. Even the emi-

nent biographer of our

illustrious

Washington, .=ccms

neglected these annals, in their relations

to

TLUcI.cr's Lives of Ihe Indians,

to

havt

our colonial history.

p. 39.

3

HISTORY OP KEXTrCKY. Yet-, it

could not be from

which attaches

to

any dubious

them,

since

or unimportant charactei-, they are derived from the

highest colonial authorities and embrace the treaty history oi' The tribes in question, says Governor Western America. in his "Administration of the British Colonies," about 1664, carried their arms, as far south as Carolina, and as far west as the Mississippi, over a vast country, which extended twelve hundred miles in length, and about six hundred in

Pownal

breadth; where they destroyed whole nations, of whom there are no accounts remaining among the English. "The rights of these tribes," says the same respectable authority, "to the

hunting lands of Ohio, (meaning the river of that name) may be fairly proved by the conquest they made in subduing the

Shavanocs, Delawares, Twictwees, and

Oillinois, as

they stood

possessed thereof, at the peace of Ryswick in IGQiy In further confirmation of this Indian title, it must be mentioned, that Lewis Evans, a gentleman whom Dr. Franklin compli-

ments, as possessed "of great American knowledge," represents in his m^p of the middle colonies of Great Britain on this

Ohio

continent, the country

on the south-easterly

side of the

hunting lands of the Six Nations. In his his map, he expressly says, * "that the Shawanese

river, as the

analysis to

who were formerly one of

the most considerable nations of

these parts of America, whose seat extended from Kentucke, soutb-westward to the Mississippi, have been subdued by the confederates, (or Six Nations) and the country since their property,"

This chain of testimony

is

become

corroborated by the statements of

the Six Nations to the commissioners of the provinces of

Penn-

sylvania, Virginia, and Maryland, at an Indian council held v/ith them in 1744. When at this meeting, the Indian Chiefs were called upon by the colonial commissioners "to tell what nations of Indians they had conquered lands from in Virginia,

and

to receive satisfaction for

to;" they are said

such lands, as thev had a ri^ht

by Dr. Franklint

to

have made

this reply:

* Franklin's Works, vol. 4. f Franklin's Works, vol. 4, 271. Oliscrvations on the conlucl of the French, dedicated to Win. Shirley, Gov. Boston, 1753; p. 4.

HISTOKY aV KENTUCKY.

4

W6 conquered

"All the world knows-, that

the several nationis

Jiving on the

Susquehannah, Cohongoranto (now Potomack) and back of the Great Mountains in Virginia j" "we conquered the nations residing there, and that land, if the Virginians ever get a good right to

These

it

it,

had

tribes

themselves under the

must be by us." as early as

previously,

1701,

placed

protection and government of Great

In their deed, or treaty of the 4th of September, 1726^ this disposition of their country. confirmed Calculating they Britain.

implicitly in

on

this

acknowledgment, General Braddock, when^ to command one of the military expe-

1755, he came over

ditions, directed against the

Such a treaty appears at this day, to be utterly beyond tions," the advantages which could have been claimed from Dunmore's The principal blow had been struck by the left expedition. his army apart from him, at the bloody battle of Point Pleasant, in which, under Gen. Andrew Lewis, with the choicest of the western backwoodsmen, the Indians fought v/ith an

wing of spirits

open resolution worthy of their highest military fame, although they retreated. Gov. Dunmorc crossed the Ohio seventy-five miles above the mouth of

him, little

Kenhawa, and ordered Lewis

to join

towns eighty miles from the river. Hero but said to have taken place, when the Governor

at the Indian

fighting

is

have little deserved the suhpatched up a peace, which would the evinced by legislature of Virginia,t gequent suspicions *3vn, which after having been abandoned by Colonel Harrod, on the late rupture, with the Indians, had been re-possessed by him. In this visit, he either had a commission of major, or

was from

Dunmore's war and prominent talents, head of the irregular troops, then in

his service in

voluntarily placed at the

Kentucky.

He

himself only speaks of settling in the fall of Kentucky militia which would confirm

'77, the accounts of the

the idea of his previous

command, besides being known

at that

In the ensuing autumn Clark returned to back to Kentucky in the spring of '76.* came and again Virginia, its value to Virginia ?.sa frontier, as well on reflected He deeply

time as Major Clark.

as to the rest of the confederacy.

The

result of these meditations

suo-uested to him, the importance of assembling the people of

the country at Harrod's

Town, as

vise a plan for the public defence.

it

was then called, to deAt this time the claim of

Henderson and Company, acquired under the treaty of WataTrcKV. officers

59

on the opposite side of the Mississippi as every influto counteract the extended agency and con;

ence was required trol

of the British;

hatchet from

who had

Lake Superior

distributed the

to Detroit,

bloody belt and and the Mississippi. In

tliis long chain of intrigue with the Indians, post St. Vincents formed an important link; not only from the warlike character of the adjacent tribes, but from their contiguity to Kaskaskia, it was utterly beyond the " of force at the command Clark, joined by every man in Kentucky ;" he, therefore, resorted to other means. The American soldiers were instructed to speak of the Falls of Ohio, as the

and the settlements of Kentucky. Yet

head quarters of the army, from which the present troops were only a detachment; that reinforcements were daily expected from that point, which was fortifying, and that when they arrived,

more extensive military movements would take place. Some such artifice was necessary to excuse the apparent rashness of invading the

Illinois,

with so small a force.

Courts of civil ju.

were likewise established by Clark, which were held by French judges, freely chosen by the people, leaving an apAbout this time, M. Cere, who was mentioned peal to Clark. that his family at Kaskaskia should be the only before, uneasy

risdiction

one placed under a guard, and fearful of venturing into the power of the American officer without a safe conduct; procured the reconunendation of the Spanish Governor at St. Louis, as

well as the

commandant

at St.

Genevieve, supported by the

in-

fluence of the greater part of the citizens, for the purpose of obIt was all in vain; Colonel Clark perempand intimated, that he wished to hear no more such applications; that he understood M. Cere was " a sensible

taining this security. torily refused it;

man,'' and if he was innocent of the charge of inciting the Indians against the Americans, he need not be afraid of delivering himself up. This backwardness would only increase tlie Shortly after this expression of Clark's suspicion against him.

M. Cere to whom they were no doubt communicated, repaired to Kaskaskia, and without visiting his family, immediately waited on Colonel Clark; who informed him that the sentiments,

crime with which he stood charged was, encouraging the In-

HISTORY OF KE^'TTCKV.

60

dians in their murders and devastations on our

An

enormity, whose perpetrators,

own

frontiers-

continued the American

commander, it behooved every civilized people to punish, whenever they got such violators of the laws of honorable war-

To this accusation, M. Cere frankly was a mere merchant, and had never been conaffairs of state beyond what the interests of his busi-

fare within their power. replied; that he

cerned

in

ness required; moreover, his remote position had prevented him from understanding the merits of the war, now raging between the United States and Great Britain. He defied, he said,

any man

to prove, that

he had encouraged the Indian barbari-

many could be produced, who had heard him express his disapprobation of all such cruelties; though, at the same ties; while

time,

it

was necessary

numbers indebted

to

to

inform Colonel Clark, that there were who might, by his ruin, seek to dis-

him,

In charge their pecuniary obligations to him. nent French merchant declared his willingness strictest inquiry

into the

fine, this

emi-

to support the

only heinous charge against him.

This was every thing the American officer required; he desired M. Cere to retire into another room, while he sent for his accuby the greater part

sers; they immediately attended, followed

M. Cere was summoned

confront them, the former immediately shewed their confusion at his appearance; the parties were told by Colonel Clark, that he had no disposition

of the inhabitants.

to

condemn any man unheard; that M. Cere was now present, and he (Clark) was ready to do justice to the civilized world by punishing him if guilty of inciting the Indians to commit their

to

enormities on helpless

gan left

women and

children.

The

accusers be-

whisper to one another and retire: until but one was of six or seven at first; this person was asked for his proof, to

but he had none to produce, and M. Cere was honorably acquitted, not more to his own satisfaction, than to that of his

neighbors and friends. He was then congratulated by Colonel Clark upon his acquittal, and informed, that although his be-

coming an American

citizen, would be highly acceptable, yet he did not sincerely wish to do so, he was perfectly at liberty to dispose of his property, and to remove elsewhere. Cere deif

HISTORY OF KENTUCKY. liorhted

at the

fair

61

and generous treatment he had met with, became a " most

immediately took the oath of allegiance, and valuable" friend to the American cause.

So successful was

the

management of

Clark, that whether he

bribed, or whether he punished, both methods

ducive to the public interest.

were made con-

In this case, he seems to have

kept up an appearance of rigor for the very opportunity of enhancing the indulgence, he wished and determined to exercise :

As an reserve in favors, was a common feature of his policy. exhibition of Colonel Clark's tact in governing under the critical circumstances in

which he was placed,

The

narration has

this detail

has been

now

arrived at the comthought necessary. the French in of the present State reduction settlements, plete of Illinois; not more by the force of arms than by the adroit policy of the

American commander, and the good disposition of The American government, too, was then in

the inhabitants.

alliance with their ancient countrymen, Avhose dominion, no still clung affectionately round their hearts. In this wav

doubt,

the ancient town of Kaskaskias, which had been two years before the city of Philadelphia, now flourishing so nobly under the auspices of American liberty; as disand in the arts, as she is retinguished for her fame in learning

was reduced settled

nowned

for her virtues

and opulence.

While

to

exhibit the

fluctuating condition of things, Kaskaskia, her predecessor planted under the protection of a powerful monarchy, numbers

but ninety-six persons,* and is almost a deserted village, filled with ruins of the nicest masonry. Colonel Clark, with his brave

and men, on the 23d of November, 1778, was voted the thanks of the House of Delegates, " for their extraordinary reso-

officers

and perseverance in so hazardous an enterprise, and for the important services thereby rendered their country."

lution

Post St. Vincents still continued to occupy the thoughts of Clark as a point of great importance to the safety of his present " It was position, and to the extension of the Virginia dominion.

never" he says, "out of my mind;" it had indeed occupied his it has been seen in his first descent down the Ohio,

thoughts

;

* Censua of 1830.

F

HISTORY OF KE>TrcKY.

62

and was only relinquished at that time from his weaknessHis early inclinations were revived by his success at Kaskasfor M. Gibault, the Roman Catholic kia, and he sent priest of This gentleman, received the thanks of who subsequently public Virginia for his had been attached to the Ameristeadily distinguished services, his village, as well as that of St. Vincents.

can cause

;

he readily gave Colonel Clark every information he him that Governor Abbot had lately gone on busi-

desired; told

ness

to

Detroit, and that a military expedition from the Falls

ao-ainst St. Vincents,

which Clark pretended

to raeditatey

waa

He indeed offered, if it met the approbascarcely necessary. " take the business on tion of Colonel Clark, to himself, and he had no doubt of

American

his

being able to bring that place over to the he said, " my being at the trouble

interest without"

of marching against patriotic priest

it."

Nor

is

must have taken

it

unfair to believe, that this

into consideration the interests

of his parishioners, by endeavoring to save them, if possible, from the chances of military spoil and violence. The generous and equal spirit which, the ancient church of

Rome had so rightfully, yet so rarely has met, at the hands c^ Protestant conquerors, and the beneficent administration of Clark, all united, no doubt, to propagate the American influence, and extend

its

To

arms.

readily acceded; for

these offers of

M.

Gibault, Clark most

was the fondest wish of his

heart, yet he scarcely ventured to believe he should realize it; and, moreover, at the desire of the clergyman, a Dr. Lafont was associated it

member

of the embassy. The principal charge hands M. Gibault. of On the 14th of July, was, however, the French gentlemen accompanied by a spy of Clark's, an as a temporal

in the

additional security

which he seems, scarcely ever

to

lected in his enterprises, set off for St. Vincent's, or

have neg*0. Post,

After full explanations of the state as it was very often called. of affairs between the priest and his flock, in two or three days, the inhabitants threw off the British government, and assembling in a body at the church, they, in the most solemn took the oath of allegiance to the commonwealth of »

A

corruption of

Au

Poste.

manner, Virginia.

63

HISTORr OF KENTUCKY.

A

commandant was

elected,

and the American

flag

immediately

astonishment of the Indians. displayed over the fort, to the Thus again fell another of the French villages established about 1745, owing to the pure good will of the inhabitants towards the American government; and another barrier of counteract-

was ing influence over the barbarous hostilities of the Indians,

The savages were told by their French " that their old Father, the King of France, was come to friends, life again, and was mad with them for fighting for the English

gained for Kentucky.

;

that if they did not wish the land to be bloody with war, they must make peace with the Americans."

About

the 1st of August,

M. Gibault and

party, returned with

the joyful intelligence, of having peaceably adjusted every American interest; no less thing at St. Vincents in favor of the

astonishment of Clark, than of the inhabitants of Kaskaskia.

to his gratification,

to the

jiow opened itself on Clark

months

for

which

his troops

;

it

and that

A new

source of perplexity was the expiration of the three

had been

enlisted.

But the discre-

tionary powers so wisely lodged with an officer acting on so remote a stage, and under such embarrassing difficulties, de-

termined him not to divest himself of the only American {>ower, on which he could rely upon any emergency; and to strain his authority, for the preservation of that interest, for

which

was conferred upon him.

it

men upon a new

He, therefore, re-enlisted

footing, raised a

company among the naown officers, established a garrison at Kaskaskia under the command of Captain Williams, and another at Cahokia, under that of Captain Bowman. Colonel William Linn, who had accompanied the expedition as a volunteer, now took charge of the troops, who wished to rehis

tive inhabitants

commanded by

their

turn and was the bearer of orders from Colonel Clark,

by building a stockade Twelfth opens

street,

to

the

fort at the

to es-

This order was executed

tablish a fort at the Falls of Ohio.

termination of the present

on the easterly side of the large ravine, that river

at

that

point.*

Here was planted

the

* The fort here mentioned, was in 1782, succeeded by a larger one, built by the rejular troops assisted by the militia from all the settled parts of the district. It was situated be-

64

HISTORY OP KENTUCKY.

thrifty

germ of Louisville, now

which seems

emporium of Kentucky, and grow with the countless proswith whose remotest commerce the

fairly destined to

perity of this great republic,

and continued union, she

is

vitally connected.

Captain John

Montgomery was despatched to Richmond, in charge of M. Rocheblave, the British commandant of Kaskaskia. In regard to this officer, who expressed himself with great bitterness of the Americans,

and the natives who had sided

with them. Colonel Clark exerted himself very much, to pi'ocure a restoration to Mrs. Rocheblave, of his slaves, that had

been seized as public plunder. This was attempted by inviting to a dinner with some of the officers, as well as with his

him

acquaintance, where this restitution was, it seems, to have offered; but it Avas entirely frustrated by the violent and insulting language of the former commandant; he called them

been

a parcel of rebels, and provoked such indignation that he was immediately sent to the guard house all further thoughts of sav;

ing his slaves were now abandoned. They were subsequently sold for the amount of five hundred pounds, and the proceeds divided among the troops as prize money. The Governor of Virginia

was informed of the whole of Clark's proceedings, and the civil commandant was desired by him, who

appointment of a

should take charge of the political afl'airs of this secluded portion In consequence of this recommendation, of the commonwealth.

was passed in October, 1778, establishing the county of Illinois, and embracing within its boundary all the chartered an

act

limits of Virginia,

west of the Ohio river.

There was

thorized the raising of a regiment of five hundred

opening communications with

New

also au-

men, and the

Orleans for their support.

twccn llio prrscnl Sixth niid KigliUi strpcts, on tlir iiortlicrn sido of Main street, immediately on the I'link ofthe river. In honor of tlie third repnhliraii (5ovcrnor of Virginia, the fort vvasrallcd Fort Nelson. Hcventh street passed tlnonch tlie lirst gate opposite to the head quarters of General Clarli Tlie principal military defence in this part of the country deserves n few more partiiularp. It contained aliont an acre of ground, and was snrroun