205 10 16MB
Portuguese Pages 636 Year 2010
Convite à Filosofia Marilena Chaui
#ONVITEßgß&ILOSOFIA I]nehaj]?d]qe
CanajpaA`epkne]h I]nc]napaCkiao ?kkn`aj]k`]a`ekaa`ek`apatpk O]ienPdki]v Nareok Dhe]`aFaoqoCkjo]c]$can*% Gpe]O_]bbI]nmqao$_kkn`*% Chkne]?qjd] Fkk?]nhkoNe^aenkFn* I]qn_ek>]lpeop]Reaen] L]pn_e]Pn]r]j_] Nkojcah]Iqne_u O]j`n]Nacej]`aOkqv] Laomqeo]e_kjkcnÚ_] OhrekGhecej$oqlanr*% ?]ekI]vvehhe A`ek`a]npa NkoeiaenaP]`]$_kkn`*% =j`nCkiaoRep]ha Lnkcn]i]kreoq]h Dkiai`aIahk"Pnke]@aoecj A`epkn]kahapnje_] Dkiai`aIahk"Pnke]@aoecj ?]l]Dkiai`aIahk"Pnke]@aoecj
-0·a`ek -·eilnaook
EO>J6534)41),4)-/025)0$]hqjk% EO>J6534)41),4)-/03,),$lnkbaookn% ? `*`ak^n]?H3/25// .,-, Pk`koko`enaepkonaoanr]`kolah]A`epkn]ãpe_]O*=* =r*Kp]re]jk=hrao`aHei](00,,Ì1¸]j`]na]j`]nejpania`enek=h]= Bnacqaoe]`kêÌ?AL,.5,5)5,, OkL]qhkÌOL Pah*6,4,,--1-1.ÌB]t6,$TT%--/55,)-2-2 sss*]pe_]*_ki*^n a`epkn]qo_]j`k]o]`]`]_]ranj]kq ]]pepq`abehko be_] =]pepq`a_npe_] L]n]mqabehkokbe]; =pepq`abehko be_]6fka^d^o =nabhatkbehko be_] Behkokbe]6qilajo]iajpkoeopaipe_k Ai^qo_]`aqi]`abejek`]behkokbe] Ejpeh;îpeh;
//. // /1 /1 /2 /3 /6
=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`];
45
Nrbpqbp
/6
Ej]peoikkqaileneoik; Kej]peoik Kaileneoik
56 56 6.
5NIDADEßßßß=behkokbe]
0.
#APqTULOß
#APqTULOß
.. ./ .0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6
=omqaop ao`eo_qpe`]olah] behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja] Pai]o(`eo_elhej]oa_]ilkobehko be_ko
=knecai`]behkokbe]
/.
=l]h]rn]cfilplcf^ Khac]`k`]behkokbe]cnac]l]n] kK_e`ajpaaqnklaq
0/
#APqTULOß
00
Kj]o_eiajpk`]behkokbe]
/4
Kqrej`k]rkv`kolkap]o Kmqalancqjp]r]ikolneiaenkobeh okbko Kj]o_eiajpk`]behkokbe] Jaikneajp]h(jaiieh]cna Iepkabehkokbe] ?kj`e aodeop ne_]ol]n]k oqnceiajpk`]behkokbe]
05 11. 1/ 10
#APqTULOß
13
?]ilko`aejraopec]k`]behkokbe]
04
Kolank`ko`]behkokbe]cnac] Behkokbe]cnac]
15 16
#APqTULOß
Lnej_el]eolank`ko`]deopne]`]behkokbe]
13
=behkokbe]j]deop ne] Kolnej_el]eolank`ko`]behkokbe]
24 25
#APqTULOß
=ola_pko`]behkokbe]_kjpailknja]
2/
#APqTULOß =n]vk
34
Kornekooajpe`ko`]l]h]rn]o^wl Knecai`]l]h]rn]o^wl Kolnej_lekon]_ekj]eo
45 46 5-
#APqTULOß
=]pere`]`an]_ekj]h
4/
=]pere`]`an]_ekj]haoq]oik`]he`]`ao Na]heoikae`a]heoik
50 55
#APqTULOß
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika `kaileneoik6okhqaobehkobe_]o
51
Ej]peoikaaileneoik6mqaop aoanaolkop]o =okhqk`aHae^jevjko_qhkTREE =okhqkg]jpe]j]jko_qhkTREEE =naolkop]`aDacah Aileneop]o(g]jpe]jkoadacahe]jko
#APqTULOß
62 62 63 .-.-/
=n]vkj]behkokbe]_kjpailknja]
-,/
=n]vkj]bajkiajkhkce]`aDqooanh N]vkaok_ea`]`a N]vka`ao_kjpejqe`]`apailkn]h Lknmqa]ej`]b]h]ikoaio^wl; N]vkana]he`]`a
.-0 .-1 .-1 .-3 .-4
Nrbpqbp
.-5
5NIDADEßßßß=ran`]`a
...
#APqTULOßß
Ecjknj_e]aran`]`a
--.
=ran`]`a_kikqir]hkn Ecjkn j_e](ej_anpav]aejoacqn]j] @ebe_qh`]`aol]n]]^qo_]`]ran`]`a
../ ../ ..1
#APqTULOßß
>qo_]j`k]ran`]`a
0
--2
@kci]peoika^qo_]`]ran`]`a =opno_kj_al ao`]ran`]`a
#APqTULOß
..3 ./.
=o_kj_alao`]ran`]`a
-..
Cnack(h]peiada^n]e_k @ebanajpaopakne]ook^na]ran`]`a Ran`]`aab]hoe`]`a Qi]kqpn]pakne]`]ran`]`a =_kj_alk`]ran`]`aj]behkokbe]]j]hpe_] =_kj_alkln]cipe_]`]ran`]`a =o_kj_al ao`]ran`]`aa]deop ne]
.// ./0 ./1 ./4 ./6 ./6 .0-
Nrbpqbp
.0.
5NIDADEßßßß=h ce_]
.00
#APqTULOß
Kj]o_eiajpk`]hce_]
-/0
h ce_k Dan_hepkaL]nije`ao K]l]na_eiajpk`]h ce_]
.01 .02 .03
#APqTULOß
Ahaiajpko`ahce_]
-/4
Lnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o =lnklkoek Koehkceoik Koehkceoik_eajpbe_k
.05 .05 .1. .10
#APqTULOß
=hce_]oei^he_]
-02
=h ce_]i]paipe_] Hejcq]caiaiap]hejcq]cai H ce_]`kolna`e_]`koah ce_]`]onah] ao
.13 .16 .2-
Nrbpqbp
.21
5NIDADEßßßßK_kjda_eiajpk #APqTULOß
.24
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpk
-14
K_kjda_eiajpkakolneiaenkobeh okbko Kobeh okbkoik`anjkoak j]o_eiajpk`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk >]_kja@ao_]npao Hk_ga N]_ekj]heoikaaileneoik =_kjo_ej_e]6koqfaepk(kaq(]laook]ak_e`]`k Oq^fapere`]`aacn]qo`a_kjo_ej_e]
.25
#APqTULOß
.3/ .31 .34 .35 .36 .4.
=lan_alk
-3.
Oajo]kalan_alk Aileneoikaejpaha_pq]heoik Loe_khkce]`]bkni]abajkiajkhkce] Kmqa]lan_alk Lan_alkapakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk
.4/ .40 .40 .42 .44
1
#APqTULOß
=ei]cej]k
-35
?kpe`e]jkaei]cej]k =ei]cej]kj]pn]`ekbehko be_] =bajkiajkhkce]a]ei]cej]k @ao_naraj`k]ei]cai =oik`]he`]`aokqpelko`aei]cej]k Ei]cej]kapakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk
.46 .5.5.5/ .50 .51
#APqTULOß
=hejcq]cai
-41
=eilknp j_e]`]hejcq]cai =bkn]`]hejcq]cai =kqpn]`eiajok`]hejcq]cai =knecai`]hejcq]cai Kmqa]hejcq]cai; Aileneop]oaejpaha_pq]heop]o`e]jpa`]hejcq]cai Lqnebe_]n]hejcq]cai ?npe_]]kaileneoika]kejpaha_pq]heoik =hejcqope_]a]hejcq]cai =atlanej_e]`]hejcq]cai
.52 .53 .54 .55 .56 .6.6. .6/ .6/ .61
#APqTULOß
Klajo]iajpk
-52
Lajo]j`k*** Kmqa`evaiko`e_ekjneko Atlanej_e]o`alajo]iajpk =ejpahecj_e] Ejpahecj_e]ahejcq]cai Ejpahecj_e]alajo]iajpk =ja_aooe`]`a`kipk`k Lajo]iajpkipe_kalajo]iajpkh ce_k ?kikkiepkbqj_ekj] ?kikbqj_ekj]klajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]h
.63 .64 .65 .66 /-/-. /-/ /-1 /-2 /-4
#APqTULOß
=_kjo_e j_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;
.,5
?kjo_ej_e]a_kjda_eiajpk Kej_kjo_eajpa =loe_]jheoa =re`]lomqe_] =]heaj]kok_e]h =opnobkni]o`]]heaj]k =e`akhkce] Ancqaj`kkrq(pen]j`k]io_]n]
/-6 /-6 /./.. /.1 /.3 /.5 //-
Nrbpqbp
//.
5NIDADEßßßß=iap]boe_]ß
//2
)NTRODUljO
=oej`]c]aoiap]boe_]o
..2
=mqaopkiap]boe_]6ÎKmqa;Ï =lancqjp]lahkmqa ?]n]_panope_]o`]iap]boe_]aioaqolank`ko
//3 //3 //4
#APqTULOß
Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]
..4
Kna]heoik`]behkokbe]j]o_ajpa @]_koikhkce]iap]boe_] Iap]boe_]kqkjpkhkce]; Koqnceiajpk`]kjpkhkce]6L]nije`ao`aAhae] Lh]pkakiqj`k`]oaooj_e]o
#APqTULOß
=iap]boe_]`a=neoppahao
//5 //6 //6 /0. /0/
./1
@ebanaj]ajpna=neop pahaoaoaqolna`a_aooknao /02 =iap]boe_]]neopkphe_] /04 Kolnej_el]eo_kj_aepko`]iap]boe_]]neopkphe_] /04
#APqTULOß
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]
.0,
K_neope]jeoika]p]nab]`]ar]jcahev]k =opn]`e aoiap]boe_]oaj_kjpn]`]o lahk_neope]jeoik =iap]boe_]_neop =iap]boe_]_hooe_]kqik`anj] =cn]j`a_neoa`]iap]boe_]6@]re`Dqia G]jpakbei`]iap]boe_]_hooe_]
/1-
#APqTULOß
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailknja]
/1. /10 /12 /14 /15
.1.
=dan]j]g]jpe]j] /2/ =_kjpne^qek`]bajkiajkhkce]`aDqooanh /2/ Kobajiajkokqaooj_e]o /22 ëjpe_kakjpkh ce_k /22 =jkr]kjpkhkce]6jaina]heoik(jaie`a]heoik /24 Kjkook_knlk /26 Kmqakpailk; /3-
#APqTULOß
=behkokbe]lo)iap]boe_]
.2.
=oiknpao`]iap]boe_] =na]he`]`alqn]iajpa`eo_qnoer]`k oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk =na]he`]`alqn]iajpa`eo_qnoer]`ko]^an
/3/ /30 /31
Nrbpqbp
/34
5NIDADEßßßß=_ej_e]
/4.
#APqTULOß
=]pepq`a_eajpbe_]
.3.
Koajok_kiqi ?]n]_panope_]o`koajok_kiqi =]pepq`a_eajpbe_]
/4/ /40 /41
#APqTULOß
=_e j_e]j]deopne]
.33
=opnolnej_el]eo_kj_al ao`a_ej_e] @ebanaj]oajpna]_ej_e]]jpec]a ]_hooe_]kqik`anj] =oiq`]j]o_eajpbe_]o @aoiajpej`k]arkhqkaklnkcnaook_eajpbe_ko Nqlpqn]oaleopaikh ce_]o
/44 /45 /45 /46 /5-
Narkhq ao_eajpbe_]o B]hoebe_]kTnarkhqk ?h]ooebe_]k`]o_ej_e]o
/5. /5/ /50
#APqTULOß
=o_e j_e]odqi]j]o
.40
Oklkooraeo_ej_e]odqi]j]o Kdqi]jk_kikk^fapk`aejraopec]k Bajkiajkhkce](aopnqpqn]heoikai]nteoik Ko_]ilko`aaopq`k`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o
/51 /52 /54 /56
#APqTULOß
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]h
.5-
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_k ?ej_e]`aoejpanaoo]`]aqpehep]neoik =e`akhkce]_eajpebe_eop] =n]vkejopnqiajp]h ?kjbqokajpna_ej_e]ap_je_] Klnk^hai]`kqok`]o_ej_e]o
/6. /60 /61 /63 /65 /66
Nrbpqbp
0--
5NIDADEßßßßKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
0-0
#APqTULOßßß =_qhpqn]
/,0
J]pqnav]dqi]j]; ?qhpk(ej_qhpk6_qhpqn] J]pqnav]a_qhpqn] ?qhpqn]adeop ne] ?qhpqn]a]jpnklkhkce] =_qhpqn]_kikkn`aioei^ he_] =behkokbe]a]oi]jebaop] ao_qhpqn]eo
0-1 0-3 0-4 0-6 0.0 0.0 0.2
#APqTULOß
=atlane j_e]`ko]cn]`ka] ejopepqek`]nahecek
/-1
=nahecekoe`]`a Ko]cn]`k =nahecek =nahecek_kikj]nn]per]`]knecai Nepko Kok^fapkooei^ he_ko I]jebaop]kanarah]k =hae`erej] =re`]]l o]iknpa Iehaj]neoik K^aiaki]h Kla_]`k Ei]jj_e]apn]jo_aj`j_e] Pn]jo_aj`j_e]adean]nmqe] =obej]he`]`ao`]nahecek ?npe_]onahecek Jvqelpaidlp K_kjbhepkajpnaban]vk ?kj_ehe]kajpnabehkokbe]anahecek
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.6 0/0/0// 0/0 0/0 0/1 0/3 0/3 0/5 0/6 0000/ 001
2
#APqTULOßß
Kqjeranok`]o]npao
//1
Klkjpk`areop]`kaola_p]`kn Klkjpk`areop]`k]npeop] =npaanahecek =npaap_je_] Nahecekoe`]`a(]qpkjkie]ap_je_]6 ]^ro^aoq]`ao]l]nek =npaabehkokbe] =]npa_kikpn]^]hdk_ne]`kn =npaaok_ea`]`a
002 004 /1. 010
#APqTULOß
013 016 02/ 025
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej` opne]_qhpqn]h
/15
?qhpqn]lklqh]na_qhpqn]`ai]oo] Ej`opne]_qhpqn]ha_qhpqn]`ai]oo] Koiaeko`a_kiqje_]k =ejbknipe_]
026 03031 042
#APqTULOß
=ateop j_e]pe_]
/35
Oajokikn]ha_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h Fqvk`ab]pkafqvk`ar]hkn pe_]arekhj_e] Ko_kjopepqejpao`k_]ilkpe_k
046 05. 05/ 050
#APqTULOß
=behkokbe]ikn]h
/42
pe_]kqbehkokbe]ikn]h K_neope]jeoik6ejpanekne`]`aa`aran J]pqnav]dqi]j]a`aran ?qhpqn]a`aran Deop ne]arenpq`ao N]vk(`aoafkarkjp]`a pe_]aloe_]jheoa
053 0606/ 062 066 1-3 1-6
#APqTULOßß
=he^an`]`a
0--
=he^an`]`a_kiklnk^hai] 1.. Pnocn]j`ao_kj_al aobehko be_]o`]he^an`]`a 1.2 He^an`]`aalkooe^ehe`]`ak^faper] 1.6 Re`]aiknpa 1/0
#APqTULOßß
pe_]a_e j_e]
0.0
=ilhe]j`kk_]ilk`klkoorah =cajpe_]akolnk^hai]ope_ko Qi]^naranabhatk =hcqjolna_aepko`]Cajpe_]
1/1 1/2 1/5 1/6
#APqTULOßß
=re`]lkhpe_]
0/,
L]n]`ktko`]lkhpe_] Krk_]^qhnek`]lkhpe_] Klk`an`aol pe_k =ejrajk`]lkhpe_] =ok_ea`]`a_kjpn]kAop]`k
10101 102 104 106
3
#APqTULOßß =obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%
00.
=re`]^k] Knecai`]re`]lkhpe_] Bej]he`]`a`]re`]lkhpe_] Konaceiaolkhpe_ko pe_]alkhpe_] Nki]jko6]_kjopnqk`klnj_ela Klk`anpakh ce_k)lkhpe_k6k_neope]jeoik
11/ 110 111 113 115 115 12-
#APqTULOßß =obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%
013
Ke`a]hnalq^he_]jk =jpao`aLmok`fmb J^nrf^sif`l)j^nrf^sbifpjl =narkhqki]mqe]rahe]j] =e`ae]`aok^an]je] Kiqj`k`aokn`aj]`k Aop]`k`aj]pqnav](_kjpn]pkok_e]h(aop]`k_ereh =pakne]he^an]h He^an]heoikabei`k=jpeckNaceia =_e`]`]je]he^an]h =e`ae]`anarkhqk Oecjebe_]`klkhpe_k`]onarkhq ao =onarkhq aook_e]eo
124 125 125 126 02. 13/ 131 133 135 136 1414. 14/
#APqTULOßß =lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjp ne]
03/
=pn]`ekhe^anpne] K`eo_qnok`]oanre`krkhqjpne] =opakne]ook_e]heop]o =lanola_per]i]nteop] =jpa_a`ajpao`]pakne]i]nteop] Cjaoa`]ok_ea`]`aa`kAop]`k E`akhkce] Moufpanarkhqk
140 140 141 142 145 146 15/ 152
#!0É45,/ßß =oatlane j_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTT
045
=Narkhqk`aKqpq^nk =oatlanej_e]opkp]hepne]o6b]o_eoikaj]veoik Kpkp]hep]neoikop]hejeop] =ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e] Kjakhe^an]heoik
156 16/ 161 163 165
#!0É45,/ßß =mqaopk`aik_n pe_]
1,.
=`aik_n]_e]_kike`akhkce] =ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_] @ebe_qh`]`aol]n]]`aik_n]_e]jk>n]oeh
2-/ 2-0 2-4
Nrbpqbp
2-6
Ibfqro^pob`ljbka^a^p
2.6
Fkaf`^ bp_f_ifldocf`^p
2/-
)NTRODUljO
L]n]mqabehkokbe];
Oa]^]j`kj]n]ejcajqe`]`aakolna_kj_aepko`koajok_kiqibknpeh7oajk oa`aet]ncqe]nlah]oq^ieookoe`ae]o`kiej]jpaoa]kolk`anaoaop]^aha_e`ko bknpeh7oa^qo_]n_kilnaaj`an]oecjeÚ_]k`kiqj`k(`]_qhpqn](`]deop) ne]bknpeh7oa_kjda_ankoajpe`k`]o_ne]aodqi]j]oj]o]npao(j]o_e j_e]oa j]lkh pe_] bknpeh7oa`]n]_]`]qi`ajoajkoo]ok_ea`]`akoiaekol]n] oanai_kjo_eajpao`aoea`aoq]o]aojqi]lnpe_]mqa`aoaf]]he^an`]`aa] bahe_e`]`al]n]pk`kobknpeh(ajpklk`aiko`evanmqa]ÚhkokÚ] ki]eopeh`a pk`kokoo]^anao`amqakooanaodqi]jkook_]l]vao*
@] aomqan`] l]n] ] `enaep]( `a _ei] l]n] ^]etk6 ejo_nek ln)deopne_] ateopajpa jk L]nmqa J]_ekj]h `] Oann]`]?]ler]n](jkLe]q7`aoajdk`aFk]mqeiPknnaoC]n_e](`aia]`ko`ko_qhkTT7le_pkcn]i]qo]`k ejpanj]_ekj]hiajpa]l]npen`]`_]`]`a-53,7Úcqn]na`aoajd]`]_ki^]oaail]`nkp tpeh]oe pe_k`a knecailn)deopne_]7`aoajdk`aO]qhOpaej^anc(`aia]`ko`ko_qhkTT7oehdqap]knecej ne]`ko_qhkTET7 le_pkcn]i] lnkfap]`k l]n] qok j] ejpanjap( `] `_]`] `a -55,7 Úcqn] na`aoajd]`] ] l]npen `a ao_qhpqn] ]bne_]j]`aknecailn)deopne_]7`aoajdk`aSehhAeojan(`adeopne]aimq]`nejdko(`]`_]`]`a-54,*
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
).42/$5a«/ L]n]mqabehkokbe];
P
]hao`aIehapk(klneiaenkbeh okbk`amqaoapaijkp_e](]j`]r]lahkof]n`ejo`aoq] _e`]`akhd]j`kl]n]k_ql]n]_kjda_ankikreiajpk`ko]opnkoabkeklneiaenk]o) pnjkik]lnaranqia_heloa*?kjp]]haj`]mqa(jqi]`aoq]o]j`]j]o(P]haopnkla) kqa_]eqjqilkk*=laook]mqakpenkq`]hepane]ne`kiqepk(`evaj`k)hda6ÎAe(P]hao?kik rk_d`ao]^ankmqaoal]oo]jk_qoajk_kjoacqarankmqaoal]oo]j]pann];Ï*Aoo] ]ja`kp]_kjo]cnkq]ei]cai`kbeh okbk_kik]hcqi`eopn]`k(mqaoak_ql]_ki_keo]o `eop]jpaoajkajtanc]kmqaoal]oo]oq]rkhp]* Jkajp]jpk(qi]kqpn]haj`]kbana_aqi]ei]caiklkop]]aoo]*J]nn]]deopkneap]mqa Dan_hepk`abaok(p]i^iqi`kolneiaenkobeh okbko(_kopqi]r]oanreoep]`klknlaook]o mqa`aoaf]r]ikqre)hkaei]cej]r]iaj_kjpn)hkeokh]`kaiancqhd]`kailnkbqj`]oia) `ep] ao*Dan_hepk(lkni(]ooqnlnaaj`e](lkeokaj_kjpn]r]ij]_kvejd](fqjpk]kbkck( k_ql]`k_kiko]b]vanao`kiope_koa(oknnej`k(ahahdao`eve]6Î=mqep]i^ioaaj_kjpn]i ko`aqoaoÏ*Eopk(kmqaDan_hepkaop]r]mqanaj`k`evanmqaaimq]hmqanhqc]nlkoorah k_ql]n)oa_ki]^qo_]`]ran`]`a*Mqajklna_eok]b]op]n)oa`]re`]_kpe`e]j]a`k_kjp]) pk_ki]olaook]ol]n]b]vanbehkokbe]* at]p]iajpa aoo] lkoek mqa ] deop ne] ]pne^qe ]k l]pnkjk `ko beh okbko( O _n]pao* >]etejdk(iqepkbaekap]c]nah](O _n]pao_kopqi]r]_kjrano]n_kiko]pajeajoaoj]ln]] l^he_]`a=paj]o*Ejpanaoo]r])oalah]okleje ao`]olaook]o_kimqai_kjrere]*@ev]deo) p ne]mqa(j]na]he`]`a(O _n]pao]pkniajp]r]ko]pajeajoaolknmqajk_aoo]r]`ab]v)hko _]enai_kjpn]`e aomq]j`kaopaolnapaj`e]iatlhe_]n)hdalknmqafqhc]r]ipankleje ao _knnap]oaran`]`aen]o* ÎRk_`evmqanaolaep]ko_kn]fkokoÏ(`eve]O _n]pao(Îi]o(`ec])ia(kmqa]_kn]cai;Ï* Kqajpk6ÎRk_`evmqaqi]laook]fqop](i]o(`ec])ia(kmqa]fqope];Ï*A]ej`]6ÎRk_ `evmqaoq]klejekran`]`aen](i]o(`ec])ia(kmqa]ran`]`a;Ï*Ikopn]j`kmqa]lneiae) n]naolkop]mqakejpanhk_qpknkbana_e]an]ejoqbe_eajpa(O _n]pao]pn]jobkni]r]jqi]jkr] lancqjp]_qf]naolkop]_kjpn]`eve]]lneiaen]a_khk_]r]kejpanhk_qpknai_kjpn]`ek_kj) oeckiaoik*A]ooei(`alancqjp]ailancqjp](_dac]r]kikiajpkaimqa(ajbqna_e`ka _daek`a`re`]o(kejpanhk_qpknna_kjda_e]jko]^ankmqaoailnafqhc]n]mqao]^e]*Jaooa ikiajpk(`eve]O _n]pao(]laook]aop]r]lnkjp]l]n]_kia]n]behkokb]n* ?kjpailh]nkQjeranok(_kikP]hao(kqren]ran`]`a`erej](_kikDan_hepk(_kjrano]n _ki]olaook]o(_kikO _n]pao(aeorne]oi]jaen]o`ab]vanbehkokbe]* Jkookoatailhko(lkni(l]na_aihar]n)jkol]n]qipailkiqepk`eop]jpa(k`]]j) pec]Cn_e](mqaj]`]$kq(nah]per]iajpa(mq]oaj]`]%paiai_kiqi_kikiqj`k]pq]h* Oane]]behkokbe]qi]]pere`]`a]jpec]_qf]lnpe_]jkpane]oajpe`kjko`e]o]pq]eo;=bej]h( dkfaai`e](qi]opnjkikjko]elah]onq]okhd]j`kl]n]k_q(i]opn]^]hd]aik^oan) r]p neko_kiejopnqiajpkop_je_ko`a]hp]lna_eok*Qi_eajpeop]jkbe_]]kl`kbkck aolan]j`kkqren]rkv`ko`aqoao(i]ona]hev]ejraopec] aoaih]^kn]p neko_kilhatkoa okbeope_]`ko* A mq]j`k mqanaiko ranebe_]n oa jkoo] klejek aop _knnap] kq ej_knnap]( jk o]iko]_kjrano]nj]ln]]l^he_](i]o_kjoqhp]ikokooanrekoa_ajpnko`aejbkni]k _khk_]`kojkoo]`eolkoeklah]ejpanjap(kqaiepeikojkooklajo]iajpk`]o_keo]oa`k iqj`kj]o_d]i]`]oÎna`aook_e]eoÏ*
-,
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
Aioqi](p]hravoaf]lna_eok]_aep]n]`ao_kjbe]j]`aiqepko`amqa(aijkooko`e]o(] behkokbe]jkoanral]n]j]`]*Aoo]b]hp]`aoanrajpe]lk`aoani]eo^ailan_a^e`]oaat]ie) j]nikokmqa]_kjpa_aq_kikoecjebe_]`k`aqi]l]h]rn]cnac](]l]h]rn]plme^)mqaaop j]bkni]k`]l]h]rn]mefilplme^(Îbehkokbe]Ï* =l]h]rn]plme^lkooqe]`keooajpe`komqa(l]n]kocnacko(an]iejoal]nraeo6p^_bo$_k) jda_eiajpk%ap^_balof^$_kj`qp]ikn]h%*Kn](klajo]iajpkik`anjkoal]nkqaooao`keo oajpe`kolknmqa`eopejcqeqajpnaÎ_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]hÏaÎre`]ikn]hÏ(ajpnaÎ_kjda_anÏ aÎ]cenÏ*P^_balof^l]ookq]oecjebe_]nÎ_kjda_eiajpk_eajpbe_kap_je_kÏ*=`eopejkajpna `lkeb`boa^dfoharkqp]i^i]`ebanaj_e]n`keooajpe`komqaaop]r]iqje`kojqi]kqpn] l]h]rn]cnac](]l]h]rn]pmelp(eopk(Îo^ekÏ+Ajmq]jpk(l]n]kocnackoko^ekan](]kiao) ikpailk(]mqahamqalkooq]_kjda_eiajpkoran`]`aenkook^na]na]he`]`aa]mqahamqa ]ce]`a]_kn`k_kikor]hknaoikn]eo(jklajo]iajpkik`anjk(o^ek]mqahamqalkooqe _kjda_eiajpko_eajpbe_ko(p_je_ko(deop ne_ko(]npope_ko6k_eajpeop]* Jkajp]jpk(lkoorahmqa]`eop j_e]ajpnakl]oo]`kaklnaoajpaoaf]iqepkiajkn`k mqal]na_alneiaen]reop]amqa]behkokbe]]ej`]pajd]iqepk]`evanjkiqj`k_kjpailk) n jak*Pkiaikoqiatailhkmqar]e]hi`ajkookpailklnaoajpaaoa`eneca]qibqpqnk hkjcjmqk(jkmq]h]_ej_e]a]op_je_]o]h_]j]ikiteik`aoajrkhreiajpkakiteik lk`anok^nakooanaodqi]jko*Ej`]cqaikooakm^pp^aldobdlakcrqrolqb`klidf`l(eopk( `keopailko`eop]jpao`kjkook(jkoane]i(j]na]he`]`a(bkjpaol]n]_kilnaaj`anikojko) okiqj`kajkooklnaoajpa*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(oajkoane]i_]iejdkol]n]lan_a^aniko ]r]he`]`a`]behkokbe]jko`e]o]pq]eo* K^oanraiko(l]n]p]jpk(klneiaenkbehia`]pnehkce]J^qofu*
?kjda_a)pa]peiaoik
--
M
%VERETTß#OLLECTION+EYSTONE
ORfCULOßAßPALAVRAßORfCULOß POSSUIßDOISßSIGNIFICADOSß PRINCIPAIS ßQUEßAPARECEMß NASßEXPRESSzESß±CONSULTARß UMßORfCULO²ßEß±RECEBERßUMß ORfCULO²ß.OßPRIMEIROßCASO ß SIGNIFICAß±UMAßMENSAGEMß MISTERIOSA²ßENVIADAßPORß UMßDEUSßCOMOßRESPOSTAßAß UMAßINDAGAljOßFEITAßPORß ALGUMßHUMANOßmßUMAßRE VELAljOßDIVINAßQUEßPRECISAß SERßDECIFRADAßEßINTERPRETA DAß.OßSEGUNDO ßSIGNIFICAß ±UMAßPESSOAßESPECIAL² ß QUEßRECEBEßAßMENSAGEMß DIVINAßEßAßTRANSMITEßPARAß QUEMßENVIOUßAßPERGUNTAß gßDIVINDADE ßDEIXANDOß QUEßOßINTERROGANTEßDECIFREß EßINTERPRETEßAßRESPOSTAß RECEBIDAß%NTREßOSßGREGOSß ANTIGOS ßESSAßPESSOAßß ESPECIALßCOSTUMAVAßß SERßUMAßMULHERßEßERAßß CHAMADAßSIBILA
qaireqkbehiaJ^qofuÍ]jpaomqaoapknj]ooaklneiaenk`aqi]oneaÍd`aoa hai^n]n`]_aj]aimqakdan eJakhar]`klahkcqe]Iknbaql]n]kqrenkkn_qhk* Jaop]_aj]]l]na_a]oe^eh](]iqhdanmqana_a^aqkkn_qhk$eopk(]iajo]cai%amqa p]i^ikkn_qhk$kqoaf](]pn]joieookn]`]iajo]cai%*Aoo]iqhdanlancqjp]]Jakoaaha haqkmqaaopao_nepkok^na]lknp]`aajpn]`]`]_]o]aimqa]_]^kq`aajpn]n*Aha`evmqa jk*Ah]ajpkhl]n]aha]ol]h]rn]o(atlhe_]j`k)hdamqaok`aqi]hjcq]diqepk`ao]l]) na_e`](kh]pei*Kmqaaopao_nepk;Klp`bqbfmprj+Kmqaoecjebe_];Î?kjda_a)pa]peiaoik*ÏK kn_qhk`ev]JakmqaahaÍaokiajpaahaÍlk`ano]^anoakqjk]mqahamqar]ehern]nk iqj`k`klk`an`]I]pneta(lknp]jpk(okiajpa_kjda_aj`k]oeiaoikahapan]naolkop]*
Ko]pknaoGa]jq Naarao$Jak%( ?]nnea)=jjaIkoo $Pnejepu%aH]qnaj_a Beod^qnja$Iknbaq%( ai_aj]`kbehia I]pnet(`koeniko S]_dksoge(AQ=( -555*Kbehia atlhkn]]obnkjpaen]o ajpnakna]hakrenpq]h*
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
Lkq_]olaook]omqaren]iaooabehia_kilnaaj`an]iat]p]iajpakoecjebe_]`k`aoo] _aj](lkeoah]]nalnaoajp]k(jkbqpqnk(`aqi]_kjpa_eiajpk`kl]oo]`k(k_knne`kd./ o_qhko(j]Cn_e]* D]re](j]Cn_e]]jpec](j]_e`]`a`a@ahbko(qio]jpqnek`a`e_]`k]k`aqo=lkhk(`aqo `]hqv(`]n]vka`k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk(kl]pnkjk`]o]^a`kne]*Ok^naklknp]h`a ajpn]`]`aooao]jpqnekaop]r]ao_nep]]cn]j`aiajo]cai`k`aqokqklnej_el]hkn_qhk`a =lkhk6Î?kjda_a)pa]peiaoikÏ*Qi]pajeajoa(_d]i]`kO _n]pao(bke]ko]jpqnek_kjoqhp]n kkn_qhk(lkeoai=paj]o(kj`aikn]r](iqepko`eve]imqaahaan]qio^ekaaha`aoaf]r] o]^ankmqaoecjebe_]r]oanqio^ekaoaahalk`ane]oan_d]i]`k`ao^ek*Kkn_qhk(mqaan] qi]iqhdan(lancqjpkq)hda6ÎKmqark_o]^a;Ï*Ahanaolkj`aq6ÎO oaemqaj]`]oaeÏ*=kmqa kkn_qhk`eooa6ÎO _n]paoki]eoo^ek`apk`kokodkiajo(lkeokje_kmqao]^amqajk o]^aÏ*O _n]pao(_kikpk`koo]^ai(kl]pnkjk`]behkokbe]*
Jaka]I]pnet
O
arkhp]niko]kbehiaJ^qofu(lk`aikolancqjp]nlknmqabkebaepkkl]n]hahkajpnaJak aO _n]pao* ?kia_aikolahkjkia`ko`keolanokj]cajoi]o_qhejkolnej_el]eo6JakaIknbaq*Ao) oaojkiaookcnacko* Kbloecjebe_]ÎjkrkÏkqÎnajkr]`kÏa(mq]j`k`epk`a]hcqi(oecjebe_]Îfkraij]bkn] ajk]n`kn`]fqrajpq`aÏ* Jlocbrlanpaj_aiepkhkce]cnac]6an]kjkia`aqiaolnepk(behdk`kOkjka`]Jkepa( mqalkooq]]o]oaan]_]l]v(jqije_kejop]jpa(`ark]nai]^okhqpkoehj_ekl]n]]oatpna) ie`]`ao`kiqj`k*Aork]]j`kok^naqioandqi]jkkqlkqo]j`kharaiajpaok^naoq] _]^a](pk_]j`k)k_kiqi]l]lkqh]raniahd](pejd]klk`anjko `ab]v)hk]`knia_ana okjd]n(i]op]i^i`a]l]na_an)hdajkokjdk(pki]j`kbkni]dqi]j]*`aoo]i]jaen] mqa(jkbehia(Iknbaqoa_kiqje_]lah]lneiaen]rav_kiJak(mqa`aolanp]]ooqop]`k_ki knq`k`aqi]iajo]caij]pah]`aoaq_kilqp]`kn*A(jklneiaenkaj_kjpnk`a]i^ko( Iknbaq oqnlnaaj`a Jak lkn oq] atpnai] rahk_e`]`a( lkn oan _]l]v `a rk]n a lkn l]na_an o]^anpq`k]naolaepk`aooafkraimqajkk_kjda_a* Rne]oravao(Iknbaqlancqjp]]Jakoaahapaioailna]eilnaook`aaop]n`kniej`k aokjd]j`k(_kikoajqj_]peraooa_anpav]`aaop]nna]hiajpa`aolanpk*Aoo]lancqjp]`aet] `aoanbaep]]l]npen`kikiajpkaimqa(ajpnaqi]lhqh]]vqhaqi]raniahd]kbana_e`]o lknIknbaq(Jakao_khdaejcanen]raniahd]$_kik]l]lkqh]`]iepkhkce]%(mqakb]nran] na]he`]`a*Iknbaqmqaihdaikopn]]I]pnet(b]vaj`k)k_kilnaaj`anmqal]ookq]re`] ejpaen]oaio]^anoaaop]r]`aolanpkkqoa`knie]aokjd]r]lknmqa(na]hiajpa(aoparaoai) lna`kniej`kaokjd]j`k* Kmqa]I]pnet;Aoo]l]h]rn]h]pej]*@aner]`aj^qbo(mqamqan`evanÎiaÏ*Aih]pei( j^qofuk nck`]obia]o`koi]ibankokj`akai^nekakbapkoa`aoajrkhrai7k pank*J]hejcq]caip_je_](]i]pnevkikh`al]n]bqj`ek`aqi]la]7k_en_qepk`a _k`ebe_]`knaoa`a_k`ebe_]`knao`]o_knaolneine]o$l]n]lnk`qvenei]cajoj]pahareok%a `kookjo$jko`eo_ko(bep]oabehiao%7a(j]ejbknipe_](]na`a`acqe]o`aajpn]`]oao]`]o `aahaiajpkoh ce_ko`eolkopkoai`apaniej]`]oejpanoa_ ao* Jkbehia(]I]pnetpaipk`koaooaooajpe`ko6ah](]kiaoikpailk(qipankqjerano]h kj`aaopkpk`kokooanaodqi]jko_qf]re`]na]hÎqpanej]Ïa_qf]re`]ei]cejne]bknf]`] lahko_en_qepko`a_k`ebe_]`knaoa`a_k`ebe_]`knao`a_knaoaokjoalah]ona`ao`acqe]o`a ajpn]`]ao]`]`aoej]eoh ce_ko* Mq]hklk`an`]I]pnet;Qo]na_kjpnkh]n]ejpahecj_e]dqi]j]l]n]`kiej]nkiqj) `k(_ne]j`kqi]na]he`]`arenpq]hkqqi]b]ho]na]he`]`aj]mq]hpk`ko]_na`ep]i*=I]pnet kbaepekren]`k_kjpn]kbaepe_aenk6_ne]`]lah]ejpahecj_e]dqi]j](]I]pnetejpahecj_e] ]npebe_e]hmqa`aopn e]ejpahecj_e]mqa]_nekqlknmqao oq^oeopaoqc]j`kkoeopai]janrk) ok_ajpn]h`kodqi]jko*
-.
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
=jpaomqa]l]h]rn]`ljmrq^alobkooaqo]`]_knnajpaiajpa(mq]j`ko d]re]]oajkn) iaoimqej]oiehep]naoa`acn]j`aoailnao]o(b]h]r])oaaiÎ_na^nkahapnje_kÏ*Lknmq; Lknmqaoapn]p]r]`aqik^fapkp_je_kiqepk`ebanajpa`apk`ko]pajpk_kjda_e`kolah] dqi]je`]`a*@ab]pk(kok^fapkop_je_kopn]`e_ekj]eo]ilhe]r]i]bkn]boe_]`kooanaodq) i]jko$kie_nko_ lekakpahao_ lek]qiajp]ikheiepa`kokhdko7kj]rek(k]qpki rahak ]rek]qiajp]ik]h_]j_a`kolodqi]jko7]]h]r]j_](]lkhe](]_d]ra`abaj`](ki]npahk ]qiajp]i]bkn]`]oikodqi]j]o7a]ooeilkn`e]jpa%*Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](kÎ_na^nkaha) pnje_kÏkq_kilqp]`kn]ilhe]aiaoikoq^opepqe]o_]l]_e`]`aoiajp]eokqejpaha_pq]eo `kooanaodqi]jko*=I]pnetk_kilqp]`kncec]jpao_kmqaao_n]rev]kodkiajo(qo]j`k] iajpa`ahaol]n]_kjpnkh]n]oln lne]olan_al ao(oajpeiajpkoalajo]iajpko(b]vaj`k)ko _nanmqak]l]najpana]h* Raj_anklk`an`]I]pnet`aopnqen]]l]nj_e](naop]qn]n]na]he`]`aa]ooacqn]nmqa kooanaodqi]jkolkoo]ilan_a^ana_kilnaaj`ankiqj`kran`]`aenkareranna]hiajpa jaha*Pk`koko_ki^]paona]hev]`kolknJakaoaqo_kil]jdaenkook_ki^]pao_ana^n]eoa `koeopai]janrkok(eopk(ok_ki^]paoiajp]eoajpnako_ajpnko`aoajo]k(lan_alk alajo]iajpkdqi]jkoako_ajpnko]npebe_e]eo`]I]pnet*Kqoaf](]o]ni]oapenkpaekomqa ]l]na_aij]pah]oklqn]ehqok(jkateopai(lkeok_ki^]pajkboe_kaoeiiajp]h*
JakaO_n]pao
L
-/
knmqakolanokj]cajo`kbehia]beni]imqaJakÎkao_khde`kÏ;Lknmqaahaoaopk oacqnko`amqaahaoan_]l]v`ana]hev]nk_ki^]pabej]haraj_an]I]pnet;Lknmqaaha an]qiÎlen]p]ahapnje_kÏ(eopk(]hcqi_]l]v`aejr]`enlnkcn]i]o(`a_ebn]n_ `ecko aiajo]cajo(i]o(ok^napq`k(lknmqaahap]i^ian]qi_ne]`kn`alnkcn]i]o`ana]he`]`a renpq]h(qilanepk_]l]v`aner]hev]n_ki]ln lne]I]pneta_kilapen_kiah]*Lknpanqi lk`anoaiahd]jpa]k`ah](Jakoailna`ao_kjbekq`amqa]na]he`]`ajkan]at]p]iajpa p]h_kikoa]lnaoajp]r]*Oailnapara`re`]omq]jpkna]he`]`alan_a^e`]aoa_nap]iajpa mqaopekj]r]kmqaan]]I]pnet*Aoo]ejpannkc]kkharkq]r]o_qhd]nko_en_qepkoejpanjko `]imqej]$p]jpk]ooeimqa_kiakq]oanlanoacqe`klknah]_kik]hcqilaneckok%a bkn]ioq]oej_qno aooa_nap]omqakbevan]ioan`ao_k^anpklknIknbaq* Lknmqa O _n]pao_kjoe`an]`kkÎl]pnkjk`]behkokbe]Ï;Lknmqaf]i]eooa _kjpajpkq _ki ]o kleje ao aop]^aha_e`]o( _ki ko lna_kj_aepko `a oq] ok_ea`]`a( _ki ]o _naj]o ej) mqaopekj]`]o`aoaqo_kjpann jako*Aha_kopqi]r]`evanmqaan]eilahe`klknqiÎaolnepk ejpaneknÏ$_kikIknbaqejopec]j`kJak%mqakhar]r]]`ao_kjbe]n`]o]l]nj_e]oalnk_qn]n ]na]he`]`aran`]`aen]`apk`]o]o_keo]o* O _n]pao ]j`]r] lah]o nq]o `a =paj]o b]vaj`k ]ko ]pajeajoao ]hcqi]o lancqjp]o6ÎK mqaeookaimqark_]_na`ep];Ï(ÎKmqaeookmqark_aop`evaj`k;Ï(ÎKmqaeookmqa rk_aopb]vaj`k;Ï*Ko]pajeajoao]_d]r]i(lknatailhk(mqao]^e]ikmqaan]]fqope]*O ) _n]paohdaob]ve]lancqjp]o`ap]hi]jaen]ok^na]fqope]mqa(ai^]n]]`koa_kjbqoko(_da) c]r]i_kj_hqok`amqajko]^e]ikmqaah]oecjebe_]r]*Ko]pajeajoao]_na`ep]r]imqa o]^e]ikmqaan]]_kn]cai*?kioq]olancqjp]oej_]joraeo(O _n]paokob]ve]_kj_hqenmqa jko]^e]ikmqaoecjebe_]r]]_kn]cai*Ko]pajeajoao]_na`ep]r]ip]i^imqao]^e]ik mqaan]i]^kj`]`a(]^ahav](]ran`]`a(i]oqilnkhkjc]`k`ehkck_kiO _n]paokob]ve] lan_a^anmqajko]^e]ikmqaan]]mqehkaimqa]_na`ep]r]i* =lancqjp]ÎKmqa;Ïan]kmqaopekj]iajpkok^na]na]he`]`aaooaj_e]halnkbqj`]`a qi] _keo] l]n] ]hi `]o ]l]nj_e]o a _kjpn] ]o ]l]nj_e]o* ?ki aoo] lancqjp]( O _n]pao har]r]ko]pajeajoao]`ao_k^nen]`ebanaj]ajpnam^ob`boapbo(ajpnaian]`obk ^lrlmfkfl asboa^ab* O _n]paoan]behdk`aqi]l]npaen]*Aha`eve]mqaoq]ia]fq`]r]kj]o_eiajpk`ko_kn) lkoamqaahap]i^ian]qil]npaenk(i]ojk`a_knlkoaoei`a]hi]o*=ooei_kikoq] iahe`]r]_ki]i]pnet_knlkn]h(ahahe`]r]_ki]i]pnetiajp]h(]qtehe]j`k]oiajpao] he^anp]n)oa`]o]l]nj_e]oa^qo_]n]ran`]`a*
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
?kikko`aJak(ko_ki^]paook_npe_koan]ip]i^i_ki^]paoiajp]eokq`alaj) o]iajpk*Aajbqna_an]i`ap]hi]jaen]kolk`ankoko`a=paj]omqaO _n]paobke_kj`aj]`k iknpa(]_qo]`k`aaol]hd]n`re`]ook^na]oe`ae]oakor]hknao]pajeajoao(_knnkilaj`k ]fqrajpq`a* Kl]n]hahkajpnaJakaO _n]paojkoaaj_kjpn]]laj]ojkb]pk`amqa]i^kookejo) pec]`kolknÎaolnepkoÏmqakob]vai`ao_kjbe]n`]o]l]nj_e]o(jai]laj]olahkaj_kjpnk _kiqikn_qhkakÎ?kjda_a)pa]peiaoikÏ(ajai]laj]olknmqa]i^kohe`]i_kii]) pnevao*Lk`aikoaj_kjpn)hkp]i^i]k_kil]n]n]pn]fap ne]`aJak]pk_ki^]pabej]hjk ejpanekn`]I]pnetaaiqi]`]oi]eo_ha^naoab]iko]ol]oo]cajo`aqiao_nepk`aqi `eo_lqhk`aO _n]pao(kbeh okbkLh]pk*Aoo]l]oo]caiaj_kjpn])oajqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]> Obm _if`^a_d]i])oaÎKiepk`]_]ranj]Ï*
Kiepk`]_]ranj]
E
i]cejaikoqi]_]ranj]oal]n]`]`kiqj`katpanjklknqi]hpkiqnk*Ajpnakiqnka k_dk`]_]ranj]dqi]bnaop]lknkj`al]oo]qibejkbaeta`ahqvatpanekn(`aet]j`k ] _]ranj] j] k^o_qne`]`a mq]oa _kilhap]* @ao`a k j]o_eiajpk( can]k ]l o can]k( oanaodqi]jkoaj_kjpn]i)oa]he(`a_kop]ol]n]]ajpn]`](]_knnajp]`kooailk`anikran ]_]^a]jaihk_kikran)oa(bkn]`ko]khd]n]laj]o]l]na`a`kbqj`k(reraj`koaijqj_] panreopkkiqj`katpaneknjai]hqv`kOkh(oaif]i]eopanabaper]iajpareopkqjo]kokq) pnkojai]oeiaoiko(i]o]laj]ooki^n]o`kokqpnkoa`aoeiaoiko(lknmqaaopkjkao) _qnkaeik^ehev]`ko*=^]etk`kiqnk(`kh]`k`a`ajpnk`]_]ranj](dqibkckmqaehqiej] r]c]iajpakejpaneknoki^nekab]v_kimqa]o_keo]omqaoal]oo]i`kh]`k`abkn]oaf]i lnkfap]`]o_kikoki^n]oj]ol]na`ao`kbqj`k`]_]ranj]*@kh]`k`abkn](laook]ol]oo]i _kjrano]j`ka_]nnac]j`kjkoki^nkobecqn]okqei]cajo`adkiajo(iqhdanaoa]jei]eo _qf]ooki^n]op]i^ioklnkfap]`]oj]l]na`a`]_]ranj](_kikjqipa]pnk`ab]jpk_dao* Kolneoekjaenkofqhc]imqa]ooki^n]o`a_keo]oalaook]o(kookjo`aoq]ob]h]oa]oei]cajo mqapn]jolknp]ijkoki^nkook]oln lne]o_keo]oatpanj]o(amqako]npab]pkolnkfap]`ko okoanaorerkomqaoaikraiab]h]i* Kolneoekjaenkooa_kiqje_]i(`]j`kjkiao_keo]omqafqhc]iran$oair)h]ona]h) iajpa(lkeoaopkj]k^o_qne`]`a%aei]cej]imqakmqaao_qp]i(amqajko]^aimqa okokjorej`ko`abkn](ok]orkvao`]oln lne]ooki^n]oajk`kodkiajo_qf]oei]cajo aopklnkfap]`]oj]l]na`a7p]i^iei]cej]imqakookjolnk`qve`kolahko]npab]pkomqa aooaodkiajo_]nnac]ijkoki^nkookrkvao`aoanaona]eo* Mq]h ( lkeo( ] oepq]k `aoo]o laook]o ]lneoekj]`]o; Pki]i oki^n]o lkn na]he`]`a( p]jpk]ooki^n]o`]o_keo]oa`kodkiajoatpaneknao_kik]ooki^n]o`ko]npab]pkob]^ne) _]`kolknahao*Aoo]_kjbqok(lkni(jkpai_kik_]qo]]j]pqnav]`kolneoekjaenkoaoei ]o _kj`e ao ]`rano]o ai mqa oa aj_kjpn]i* Mqa ]_kjpa_ane] oa bkooai he^anp]`ko `aoo] _kj`ek`aieone]; Qi`kolneoekjaenko(ej_kjbkni]`k_ki]_kj`ekaimqaoaaj_kjpn](`a_e`a]^]j) `kj)h]*B]^ne_]qiejopnqiajpk_kikmq]hmqa^n]kocnehd ao*@aej_ek(ikra]_]^a]( `alkeok_knlkpk`k7]oacqen(]r]j]j]`enak`kiqnkakao_]h]*Ajbnajp]j`kkok^op_q) hko`aqi_]iejdkjcnaiaa`eb_eh(o]e`]_]ranj]* Jklneiaenkejop]jpa(be_]pkp]hiajpa_acklah]hqiejkoe`]`a`kOkh(_ki]mq]hoaqo khdko jk aopk ]_kopqi]`ko* Aj_da)oa `a `kn lkn _]qo] `ko ikreiajpko mqa oaq _knlk na]hev]lah]lneiaen]ravalahkkbqo_]iajpk`aoaqokhdkook^]hqvatpanj](iqepki]eo bknpa`kmqakbn]_k^nehdk`kbkckmqad]re]jkejpanekn`]_]ranj]*Oajpa)oa`ere`e`kajpna ]ej_na`qhe`]`aak`aohqi^n]iajpk*Ej_na`qhe`]`alknmqaoank^nec]`k]`a_e`enkj`aoa aj_kjpn]]na]he`]`a6jkmqar]ckn]kqj]ooki^n]oaimqaoailnareraq*@aohqi^n]) iajpk$hepan]hiajpa6Îbane`klah]hqvÏ%lknmqaoaqokhdkojk_kjoacqairan_kijepe`av]o _keo]oehqiej]`]o*
MITOßDAßCAVERNAßIMAGINEß QUEßAßCAVERNAßmßUMAßSALAß DEßCINEMAßESCURA ßOßFIOßß DEßLUZ ßAßLUMINOSIDADEß LANlADAßPELOßPROJETOR ßß EßASßIMAGENSßNOßFUNDOßß DAßPAREDEßDAßCAVERNA ßß UMßFILMEßQUEßESTfßSENDOß PROJETADOßNUMAßTELA
-0
4HEß"RIDGEMANß!RTß,IBRARY+EYSTONE
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
=_]ranj]`a Lh]pk(cn]rqn]`] Ao_kh]Bn]j_ao]`k o_qhkTRE*
Oaqlneiaenkeilqhokk`anapknj]n_]ranj]l]n]hern]n)oa`]`kna`kaol]jpk(]pn]) `klah]ao_qne`k(mqahdal]na_ai]eo]_khda`kn]*=hi`eook(lna_eo]]lnaj`an]ranaaooa ]lnaj`ev]`k`khknkok(b]vaj`k)k`aoaf]n]_]ranj]kj`apq`khdab]iehe]na_kjda_e`k* Oajpej`k)oaoai`eolkoekl]n]nacnaoo]n_]ranj]lkn_]qo]`]nq`av]`k_]iejdk( klneoekjaenklani]ja_ajkatpanekn*=kolkq_ko(d]^epq])oahqva_kia]]rankiqj`k* Aj_]jp])oa(pai]bahe_e`]`a`abej]hiajparan]oln lne]o_keo]o(`ao_k^nej`kmqaaoperan] lneoekjaenk]re`]pk`]amqaaioq]lneokren]]laj]ooki^n]o*@kn]r]jpa(`aoaf]nbe_]n hkjca`]_]ranj]l]n]oailnaahqp]n_kipk`]o]ooq]obkn]ol]n]f]i]eonacnaoo]n]ah]* Jkajp]jpk(jklk`aarep]nh]opei]n]oknpa`kokqpnkolneoekjaenkoa(lknbei(pki]]`eb_eh `a_eok`anacnaoo]n]koq^pann jakoki^nekl]n]_kjp]n]ko`ai]eokmqareqa_kjraj_)hko ]oahe^anp]naip]i^i* Mqahda]_kjpa_ajaooanapknjk;Ko`ai]eolneoekjaenkovki^]i`aha(jk]_na`ep]j`k aioq]ol]h]rn]oa(oajk_kjoacqaioehaj_e)hk_kioq]o_]k]`]o(pajp]ib]v)hkaol]j) _]j`k)k* Oa iaoik ]ooei aha paei] ai ]beni]n k mqa req a ko _kjre`] ] o]en `] _]ranj]( _anp]iajpa]_]^]nklkni]p)hk*I]o(mqaio]^a(]hcqjolk`aikqre)hka(_kjpn]]rkjp]`a `ko`ai]eo(p]i^i`a_e`eno]en`]_]ranj]nqikna]he`]`a; Kmqa]_]ranj];Kiqj`k`a]l]nj_e]oaimqareraiko*Mqaok]ooki^n]olnkfa) p]`]ojkbqj`k;=o_keo]omqalan_a^aiko*Mqaokkocnehd aoa]o_knnajpao;Jkookolna) _kj_aepkoakleje ao(jkoo]_naj]`amqakmqaaop]ikolan_a^aj`k]na]he`]`a*Mqaik lneoekjaenkmqaoahe^anp]ao]e`]_]ranj];Kbeh okbk*Kmqa]hqv`kOkh;=hqv`]ran`]`a* Kmqakiqj`kehqiej]`klahkokh`]ran`]`a;=na]he`]`a*Mq]hkejopnqiajpkmqahe^anp] klneoekjaenkna^ah`aa_kikmq]haha`aoaf]he^anp]nkokqpnkolneoekjaenko;=behkokbe]*
Jkoo]o_naj]o_kopqiaen]o
A -1
i jkoo] re`] _kpe`e]j]( ]beni]iko( jac]iko( `aoaf]iko( ]_aep]iko kq na_qo]iko _keo]o( laook]o( oepq] ao* B]vaiko lancqjp]o _kikÎMqa dkn]o ok;Ï kqÎMqa `e] dkfa;Ï*@evaikobn]oao_kikÎAhaaopokjd]j`kÏkqÎAh]be_kqi]hq_]Ï*B]vaiko]ben) i] ao_kikÎKj`adbqi]](dbkckÏkqÎJko]e]j]_dqr]l]n]jkoanaobne]nÏ*=r]he]) iko_keo]oalaook]o(`evaj`k(lknatailhk(ÎAop]_]o]i]eo^kjep]`kmqa]kqpn]ÏaÎI]ne] aopi]eofkrai`kmqaChknejd]Ï* Jqi]`eolqp](mq]j`kko jeikoaopkat]hp]`ko(qi`ko_kjpaj`knaolk`acnep]n]k kqpnk6ÎIajpenkokAqaop]r]hajkbkeeookkmqa]_kjpa_aqÏ(a]hcqi(mqanaj`k]_]hi]n ]^nec](lk`a`evan6ÎR]ikoln]_]^a]jkhqc]n(_]`]qioaf]^aik^faperka`ec]kmqareq( lknmqa]ooeipk`kolk`ankoaajpaj`anÏ*
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
P]i^i_kiqikqrenikokol]eoa]iecko`evanaimqamq]j`kk]ooqjpkkj]) ikn]`kkq]j]ikn]`](jkokiko_]l]vao`aran]o_keo]o_kikah]ook(mqaraikokmqa jejcqirajkraikokmqapk`kiqj`kaopraj`k*@evai(jaooa_]ok(mqaokikoÎiqe) pkoq^faperkoÏ*Kq(_kik`evk`ep]`k(mqaÎmqai]i]kbaek(^kjepkhdal]na_aÏ* Bnamqajpaiajpa(mq]j`k]lnkr]ikoqi]laook](kmqaah]`ev(_kikah]]ca(`evaiko mqaaoo]laook]Îhac]hÏ*Raf]ikoqilkq_ki]eo`alanpkkmqa`evaikoaijkook_kpe`e]jk* Mq]j`klancqjpkÎMqadkn]ook;ÏkqÎMqa`e]dkfa;Ï(iejd]atla_p]per]]`amqa ]hcqi(paj`kqinah cekkqqi_]haj`nek(ia`]naolkop]at]p]*Aimqa]_na`epkmq]j) `kb]k]lancqjp]a]_aepk]naolkop];=_na`epkmqakpailkateopa(mqaahal]oo](lk`aoan ia`e`kaidkn]oa`e]o(mqakmqafl]ookq`ebanajpa`k]ckn]amqakmqarenp]i^id `aoan`ebanajpa`aopaikiajpk(mqakl]oo]`klk`aoanhai^n]`kkqaomqa_e`kakbqpqnk( `aoaf]`kkqpaie`k*=ooei(qi]oeilhaolancqjp]_kjpi(oehaj_eko]iajpa(rne]o_naj]o* LknmqaÎ_naj]oÏ;Lknmqaok_keo]okqe`ae]oaimqa]_na`ep]ikooaimqaopekj]n(mqa ]_aep]ikolknmqaok ^re]o( are`ajpao* =bej]h( mqai jk o]^a mqa kjpai`ebanajpa`a ]i]jd(mqak`e]paidkn]oamqaah]ol]oo]ioai_aoo]n; Mq]j`k`eckÎAhaaopokjd]j`kÏl]n]ianabanen]]hcqimqaaop]_kn`]`ka`evkq lajo]]hcqi]_keo]mqafqhckeilkoorahkqeilnkrrah(pajdkecq]hiajpaiqep]o_naj]o oehaj_eko]o6]_na`epkmqaokjd]n`ebanajpa`aaop]n]_kn`]`k(mqa(jkokjdk(keilkooraha keilnkrrahoa]lnaoajp]i_kiklkoorahalnkrrah(ap]i^imqakokjdkoanah]_ekj] _kikenna]h(ajmq]jpk]reche]oanah]_ekj]_kikmqaateopana]hiajpa*=_na`epk(lknp]jpk( mqa]na]he`]`aateopabkn]`aiei(mqalkooklan_a^)h]a_kjda_)h]p]h_kik(alkneook _naekmqaoae`ebanaj_e]nna]he`]`a`aehqok* =bn]oaÎAh]be_kqi]hq_]Ï_kjpiaoo]oiaoi]o_naj]oai]eoqi]6]`amqao]^aiko `ebanaj_e]najpnao]je`]`aiajp]hahkq_qn](mqa]o]je`]`aiajp]hoa_d]i]n]vkamqa i]hq_]]laook]mqalan`a]n]vkaejrajp]qi]na]he`]`aateopajpao l]n]ah]*=ooei(]k ]_na`ep]nmqaoae`eopejcqenajpnan]vkahkq_qn](]_na`epkp]i^imqa]n]vkoanabana] qi]na]he`]`amqa]iaoi]l]n]pk`ko(]ej`]mqajkckopaiko`]oiaoi]o_keo]o* Mq]j`k]hcqi`evÎKj`adbqi]](dbkckÏkqÎJko]e]j]_dqr]l]n]jkoanao) bne]nÏ( ]beni] oehaj_eko]iajpa iqep]o _naj]o6 ]_na`ep] mqa ateopai nah] ao `a _]qo] a abaepkajpna]o_keo]o(mqakj`adkqranqi]_keo]_anp]iajpadkqraqi]_]qo]l]n]]oq] ateopj_e](kqmqaaoo]_keo]_]qo]`a]hcqi]kqpn]$kbkckqi]_]qo]a]bqi]]oaq abaepk(]_dqr]_]qo]`knaobne]`kkqknaobne]`kabaepk`]_dqr]%*=_na`ep]iko(]ooei( mqa]na]he`]`abaep]`a_]qo]he`]`ao(mqa]o_keo]o(kob]pko(]ooepq] aooaaj_]`ae]iai nah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkmqalk`aioan_kjda_e`]olknj oa(]piaoik(oan_kjpnkh]`]o lknj ol]n]kqok`ajkoo]re`]*
Atan_aj`kjkoo]he^an`]`a
M
q]j`k`evaikomqaqi]_]o]i]eo^kjep]`kmqa]kqpn]kqmqaI]ne]aopi]eo fkrai`kmqaChknejd](]_na`ep]ikomqa]o_keo]o(]olaook]o(]ooepq] ao(kob]pko lk`ai oan _kil]n]`ko a ]r]he]`ko( fqhc]`ko lkn oq] mq]he`]`a $^kjepk( baek( ^ki( nqei(fkrai(rahdk(ajcn]]`k(pneopa(heilk(oqfk%kqlknoq]mq]jpe`]`a$iqepk(lkq_k(i]eo( iajko(i]ekn(iajkn(cn]j`a(lamqajk(h]nck(aopnaepk(_kilne`k(_qnpk%*Fqhc]iko(]ooei(mqa ]omq]he`]`aoa]omq]jpe`]`aoateopai(mqalk`aiko_kjda_)h]oaqo)h]oaijkoo]re`]* Oa`eooaniko(lknatailhk(mqakOkhi]ekn`kmqakraiko(aop]iko]_na`ep]j`kmqa jkoo]lan_alk]h_]j]]o_keo]o`aik`ko`ebanajpao(oravaop]eo_kikokaioeiaoi]o $]bkhd]`aopahernk(^aijkoo]bnajpa(lan_a^e`]_kik^n]j_]a(`ab]pk(ah]k%(kqpn]o ravaop]eo_kikjkol]na_ai$kOkh(`ab]pk(i]ekn`kmqak`eo_k`kqn]`kmqaraiko]khkj) ca%(`alaj`aj`k`]`eop j_e](`ajkoo]o_kj`e ao`areoe^ehe`]`akq`]hk_]hev]ka`kik) reiajpk`kok^fapko*Lkneook]_na`ep]ikomqajkoo]reoklk`aran]o_keo]o`ebanajpaiajpa `kmqaah]ook(i]ojailkneook`enaikomqaaop]ikookjd]j`kkqmqabe_]ikoi]hq_ko*
-2
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
=_na`ep]iko(]ooei(mqaraiko]o_keo]ojkohqc]naoaimqaah]oaopkkq`khqc]nai mqaaop]ikoamqa]lan_alkreoq]hr]ne]_kjbkniaah]oaopaf]iln tei]okq`eop]jpao`a j o*Eookoecjebe_]mqa]_na`ep]ikomqaah]oaj ok_ql]ikohqc]naojkaol]ka(lknp]jpk( _naikomqaaopaateopa(lk`aoan`ebanaj_e]`k$lanpk(hkjca(]hpk(^]etk%aia`e`k$_kilne) iajpk(h]ncqn](]hpqn]%* J]^nec](mq]j`k]hcqi_d]i]kkqpnk`aiajpenkoklknmqajkaop]ne]`evaj`kko b]pkoat]p]iajpa_kik]_kjpa_an]i(aoplnaoajpa]jkoo]_naj]`amqad`ebanaj]ajpna ran`]`aaiajpen]*=lneiaen]`ev]o_keo]op]eo_kikok(ajmq]jpk]oacqj`]b]vat]p]iaj) pak_kjpnnek(`eopkn_aj`k]na]he`]`a* Jkajp]jpk(_kjoe`an]iko]iajpen]`ebanajpa`kokjdk(`]hkq_qn]a`kannk(lknmqak okjd]`kn(khkq_kakmqaann]oaehq`aiejrkhqjp]ne]iajpa(ajmq]jpkkiajpenkok`a_e`a rkhqjp]ne]iajpa`abkni]n]na]he`]`aakob]pko*?kieook(]_na`ep]ikomqakannka]iaj) pen]okb]hoe`]`ao(i]ook`ebanajpaolknmqaokiajpaj]iajpen]d]`a_eok`ab]hoa]n* =k`ebanaj_e]nikoannk`aiajpen](_kjoe`an]j`kklneiaenkqi]ehqokkqqiajc]jk ejrkhqjpneka]oacqj`]qi]`a_eokrkhqjpne](i]jebaop]ikooehaj_eko]iajpa]_naj] `amqaokikooanao`kp]`ko`arkjp]`aamqa`ah]`alaj`a`evan]ran`]`akq]iajpen]* =kiaoikpailk(lkni(jaioailna]r]he]iko]iajpen]_kik]hcqi]_keo]nqei6 jkckop]ikop]jpk`ahannki]j_ao(ranjkrah]o(]ooeopen]behiao;Ajkokiajpen];mqa p]i^i]_na`ep]ikomqa(mq]j`k]hcqijko]reo]mqaaopiajpej`k(]iajpen]]_aep) rah(jkqi]iajpen]Îjk`qnkÏ(Îln]r]hanÏ* Mq]j`k`eopejcqeikoajpnaran`]`aaiajpen]a`ebanaj_e]ikoiajpen]oej]_aepraeo `aiajpen]o]_aepraeo(jkaop]iko]laj]ojkonabanej`k]k_kjda_eiajpkkq`ao_kjda_e) iajpk`]na]he`]`a(i]op]i^i]k_]npan`]laook](oq]ikn]h*=_na`ep]iko(lknp]jpk( mqa]olaook]o(lknmqalkooqairkjp]`a(lk`aioanikn]eokqeikn]eo(lkeo_naikomqa] rkjp]`aklk`anl]n]ao_khdanajpnak>aiakI]h*Aok^napq`k]_na`ep]ikomqaatan_an p]hlk`anatan_an]he^an`]`a(lkeo]_na`ep]ikomqaokikohernaolknmqaao_khdaikork) hqjp]ne]iajpajkoo]o] ao(jkoo]oe`ae]o(jkookooajpeiajpko*
?kjda_aj`k]o_keo]o
J
-3
]^nec](mq]j`kqi]pan_aen]laook]la`aokqpn]o`q]ol]n]mqa`ec]ikmqana]h) iajparen]ikqmqaoaf]iÎk^faper]oÏ(kqmq]j`kb]h]iko`koj]ikn]`ko_kik ej_]l]vao `a ran ]o _keo]o _kik ok kq _kik oaj`kÎiqepk oq^faperkoÏ( p]i^i paikorne]o_naj]ooehaj_eko]o* @ab]pk(]_na`ep]ikomqamq]j`k]hcqimqan`abaj`aniqepkejpajo]iajpaqilkj) pk`areop](qi]lnabanj_e](qi]klejeka]p_]l]v`a^nec]nlkneook(lk`aÎlan`an] k^fapere`]`aÏa`aet]n)oacqe]n]laj]olahkooaqooajpeiajpkoajklah]na]he`]`a*@]iao) i]i]jaen](]_na`ep]ikomqako]l]etkj]`kooapknj]iej_]l]vao`aran]o_keo]o_kik ok(`apanqi]Î]pepq`ak^faper]Ï(amqaoq]l]etkkob]vbe_]nÎiqepkoq^faperkoÏ*Aimqa ]_na`ep]iko(ajpk; =_na`ep]ikomqapank^fapere`]`apanqi]]pepq`aeil]n_e]hmqalan_a^aa_kilnaaj`a ]o_keo]op]eo_kikokran`]`aen]iajpa(ajmq]jpk]oq^fapere`]`aqi]]pepq`al]n_e]h(lao) ok]h(`ep]`]lknoajpeiajpkor]ne]`ko$]ikn( `ek(ia`k(`aoafk%*=ooei(jko ]_na`ep]iko mqa ] k^fapere`]`a a ] oq^fapere`]`a ateopai( _kik ]ej`] ]_na`ep]iko mqa ok `ebanajpao( oaj`kmqa]lneiaen]lan_a^alanbaep]iajpa]na]he`]`aajk]`abkni](ajmq]jpk]oacqj`] jklan_a^a]`amq]`]iajpa]na]he`]`aa(rkhqjpne]kqejrkhqjp]ne]iajpa(]`abkni]* =k `evaniko mqa ]hcqiÎ hac]hÏ lknmqa pai ko iaoiko ckopko( ]o iaoi]o e`ae]o( naolaep]kq`aolnav]]oiaoi]o_keo]omqaj oapai]pepq`ao(d^epkoa_kopqiaoiqepk l]na_e`ko_kikojkooko(aop]iko(oehaj_eko]iajpa(]_na`ep]j`kmqa]re`]_ki]okqpn]o laook]oÍb]ihe](]iecko(ao_kh](pn]^]hdk(ok_ea`]`aÍjkob]voaiahd]jpaokq`ebanajpao ai`a_knnj_e]`ajkni]oar]hknaoikn]eo(lkhpe_ko(nahecekokoa]npope_ko(nacn]o`a_kj) `qp](bej]he`]`ao`are`]*
=_d]iko ^rekmqapk`kokooanaodqi]jkooacqai nacn]oajkni]o`a_kj`qp](lkooqair]hknaoikn]eo(na) hecekoko(lkhpe_ko(]npope_ko(reraij]_kil]jde]`aoaqo oaiahd]jpaoalnk_qn]i`eop]j_e]n)oa`ko`ebanajpao`ko mq]eo`eo_kn`]ia_kikomq]eoajpn]iai_kjbhepk*Eook oecjebe_] mqa ]_na`ep]iko mqa okiko oanao ok_e]eo( ik) n]eoan]_ekj]eo(lkeonacn]o(jkni]o(r]hknao(bej]he`]`ao o lk`aioanaop]^aha_e`kolknoanao_kjo_eajpaoa`kp]) `ko`an]_ek_jek* ?kikoalk`ajkp]n(jkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j]pk`]bae) p] `a `obk ^p pfibk`flp^p( `] ]_aep]k `a _keo]o a e`ae]o mqajqj_]mqaopekj]ikolknmqajkol]na_aij]pqn]eo(
^re]o* ?naiko j] ateopj_e] `k aol]k a `k pailk( j] na]he`]`aatpaneknaj]`ebanaj]ajpnana]he`]`aaokjdk( ]ooei _kik j] `ebanaj] ajpna o]je`]`a iajp]h kq n]) vkahkq_qn]*?naikoj]ateopj_e]`]omq]he`]`aoa`]o mq]jpe`]`ao*?naikomqaokikooanaon]_ekj]eo_]l]vao `a_kjda_an]o_keo]oalkneook]_na`ep]ikoj]ateopj) _e] `] ran`]`a a j] `ebanaj] ajpna ran`]`a a iajpen]7 _naikop]i^ij]k^fapere`]`aaj]`ebanaj]ajpnaah] a]oq^fapere`]`a*?naikoj]ateopj_e]`]rkjp]`aa`] he^an`]`a a lkn eook _naiko j] ateopj_e] `k >ai a `k I]h(_naj]mqajkob]v]_aep]n_kiklanbaep]iajpaj]) pqn]h]ateopj_e]`]ikn]ha`]nahecek*?naikop]i^i mqaokikooanaomqaj]pqn]hiajpalna_eo]i`aoaqooa) iahd]jpaoalkneookpki]iko_kikqib]pk ^rekaej) mqaopekjrah]ateopj_e]`]ok_ea`]`a_kioq]onacn]o( jkni]o(lanieoo aoalnke^e ao*D]ranok_ea`]`a(l]n] j o(pkj]pqn]hmq]jpkd]ranOkh(Hq](`e](jkepa(_dqr]( neko(i]nao(_qabhknaop]o*
%TTMANN#ORBIS
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
=pkej_ek`ko_qhkTRE(]olaook]o ]_na`ep]r]ijkik`ahk`aQjeranok lnklkopklknLpkhkiaq(i]paipe_ka ]opn jkik]hat]j`nejkmqareraqjko_qhk EE*Jaooaik`ahk(]Pann]k_ql]k_ajpnk`k Qjeranok(_kikoarjaop]ehqopn]k`a-05.*
Aoajkbkn^ai]ooei;
M
q]j`k(aiJ^qofu(Jaklancqjp]6ÎKj`aaop]iko;Ï(Iknbaqhda`evmqa]lancqjp] aopamqerk_]`](lkeok_knnapkoane]lancqjp]n6ÎMq]j`kaop]iko;Ï*Kqoaf](Jaklan) cqjp]lahkhqc]nkqlah]na]he`]`aaol]_e]hÍkj`a;Í(i]opane]`alancqjp]nlah] na]he`]`apailkn]hÍmq]j`k;=kikopn]n)hdamqajkaopkreraj`kjk]jk`a-555aoei jko_qhkTTE(Iknbaqlk`aikopn]n]Jakkj`ana]hiajpaaopkreraj`k6jqiiqj`k`ao) pnq`ka]nnqej]`k(r]vek`a_keo]oa`alaook]o(lkeopk`kokooanaodqi]jkoaopk]lneoekj]) `kojkejpanekn`]I]pnet*KmqaJakfqhc]r]oankiqj`kna]hlqn]ehqoka]l]nj_e]* L]n]b]v)hk_kilnaaj`ankmqaoal]oo](Iknbaq$_kikoq]knecaiiepkh ce_]ej`e_]% b]v_kimqaej_aoo]jpaarahkviajpapq`kiq`a`abkni](_kn(p]i]jdk(hqc]napailk(`a i]jaen]mqaJakpajd]`alancqjp]noakaol]kakpailkateopaina]hiajpa* Mq]j`khar]`k]kkn_qhk(Jaklnaoaj_e]b]pkooqnlnaaj`ajpao6r_ne]j]ona]hev]j) `klnk`ceko(_kikajpknp]na`aoajpknp]nqi]_khdanoaipk_]njah](kqi]jpanokhpkojk ]naaiikreiajpk_q^kooaijahaopk_]n*@e]jpa`aoq]oqnlnao](]_ne]j]mqaajpknp]a `aoajpknp]]_khdanhda`evoeilhaoiajpa6Î=_khdanjkateopaÏ*Jakaop`e]jpa`aqi]_kj) pn]`ekajpnareokana]he`]`a6kmqaaharjkateopaakmqaateopajkreopklknaha* At]p]iajpa lkn eook a lkn aop]n lanlhatk( oai _kilnaaj`an k mqa oa l]oo]( mqa k kn_qhkhdaikopn]]ejo_nekok^na]lknp]ÍÎ?kjda_a)pa]peiaoikÏÍ(ej`e_]j`k)hda mqa]jpao`apajp]nnaokhrankoajeci]o`kiqj`katpanjkoani]eolnkraepkokmqa_kia_a _kilnaaj`aj`k)oa]oeiaoik*
-4
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
Mq]jp]oravaojkl]oo]ikolknoepq] ao`aooapelk(mqajkohar]i]`ao_kjbe]nkn] `]o_keo]o(kn]`aj oiaoiko(kn]`kokqpnko; ?naikomqajkoo]rkjp]`ahernal]n]ao_khdanajpnak>aiakI]h*?naikop]i^i j]ja_aooe`]`a`ak^a`a_anojkni]oaonacn]o`ajkoo]ok_ea`]`a*Mqa]_kjpa_a(lkni( mq]j`k(jqi]oepq]k(jkoo]rkjp]`ajkoej`e_]mqa^kib]vankqmqanan]hckmqajkoo] ok_ea`]`alnk^akq_kj`aj];Kq(]k_kjpnnek(mq]j`kjkoo]rkjp]`afqhc]mqaoanqi i]haqi]ejfqope]mqanankqb]van]hckmqajkoo]ok_ea`]`aatecakqk^nec];Kqoaf](d ikiajpkoaijkoo]re`]aimqareraikoqi_kjbhepkajpnakmqajkoo]he^an`]`a`aoaf] $lknmqajkoo]rkjp]`afqhc]oaneookkiahdkn%akmqajkoo]ok_ea`]`a`apaniej]aeil a* ?naikoj]ateopj_e]`kpailk(eopk(jqipn]jo_knnanmqajk`alaj`a`aj o(a_na) ikomqalk`aikoia`e)hk_kiejopnqiajpko_kikknah cekak_nkjiapnk*Jkajp]jpk( mq]j`kaop]ikoaolan]`a]hcqi]_keo]iqepk`aoaf]`]kq`a]hcqiiqepkmqane`k(k pailkl]na_ajkl]oo]n(]`aikn]hkjc](ejpaniejrah7khd]ikol]n]knah cekajahak pailk aop l]oo]j`k( oai _knnaolkj`an jkoo] eilnaook `a mqa aop mq]oa l]n]`k* =k _kjpnnek(oaaop]ikojqi]oepq]k`aiqep]o]peob]k$qi]baop](qiaolap_qhk`ai) oe_]a`]j](qiaj_kjpnk]iknkok(qil]ooaek_ki]ieckomqane`ko%(kpailkrk](l]oo] rahkviajpa(]ej`]mqaknah cekikopnamqaoal]oo]n]irne]odkn]o* RaikomqakOkhj]o_a]haopaaoal a]kaopa(mqaoq]lnaoaj]k`e]aoq]]qoj_e] ]jkepa*Jkookokhdkojkob]vai]_na`ep]nmqakOkhoaikrarkhp]`]Pann]amqaaop] lani]ja_aei rah*Mq]j`k(`qn]jpaiqep]ojkepaooacqe`]o(]_kil]jd]iko]lkoek`]o aopnah]ojk_q(raikomqaah]oiq`]i`ahqc]na]_na`ep]ikomqaoaikraijkoo]rkhp]( ajmq]jpk]Pann]lani]ja_aj]eik^ehe`]`a*Jkajp]jpk(]]opnkjkie]`aikjopn]mqajk eookmqa]_kjpa_a*=Pann]qilh]jap]jqioeopai]_qf]aopnah]_ajpn]hoa_d]i]Okh(kq oaf]( ] Pann] qi lh]jap] `k Oeopai] Okh]n a ah]( fqjp]iajpa _ki kqpnko lh]jap]o( mqa oaikrarkhp]`kOkh(jqiikreiajpk`apn]joh]k*=hi`aooaikreiajpk(ah]]ej`] na]hev]qikqpnk(k`ankp]kaipknjk`aoaqaetkejreorah*Kikreiajpk`apn]joh]k atlhe_]]ateopj_e]`k]jkak`ankp]katlhe_]]ateopj_e]`k`e]a`]jkepa*=ooei(d qi]_kjpn]`ekajpnajkoo]_naj]j]eik^ehe`]`a`]Pann]a]ejbkni]k]opnkjie_] ok^nakoikreiajpkopannaopnao* Aooaoatailhko]ooaiahd]i)oaoatlanej_e]oa`ao_kjbe]j]o`aJak6lknqih]`k( pq`kl]na_a_anpejdka_kikpai`aoana(lknkqpnk(l]na_amqapq`klk`ane]aop]nann]`kkq oanehqok*Paiko]_naj]j]he^an`]`a(i]ookiko`kiej]`kolah]onacn]o`ajkoo]ok_ea) `]`a*Paikoatlanej_e]`kpailkl]n]`kkq`kpailkhecaenk(i]oknah cekjk_kilnkr] aoo]atlanej_e]*Paiko]lan_alk`kOkha`]oaopnah]oaiikreiajpkrkhp]`]Pann] ei rah(i]o]]opnkjkie]jkoajoej]k_kjpnnek*
Ikiajpko`a_neoa
A
-5
ooao_kjbhepkoajpnarne]o`ajkoo]o_naj]okqajpnajkoo]o_naj]oaqio]^anaop]) ^aha_e`kej`e_]i]lnej_el]h_en_qjop j_e]aimqaokikohar]`ko]iq`]n`a]pepq`a* Mq]j`kqi]_naj]_kjpn]`evkqpn]kql]na_aej_kil]prah_kikqpn](kqmq]j`k ]mqehkaimqaoailna]_na`ep]iko_kjpn]ne]`klknqi]kqpn]bkni]`a_kjda_eiajpk( ajpn]ikoai_neoa*=hcqi]olaook]ooaaobkn]il]n]b]van`a_kjp]mqajkdlnk^hai] ]hcqiarkhar]j`k]re`]_kikoapq`kaoperaooaÎiqepk^ai(k^nec]`kÏ*Kqpn]o(lkni( oajpai)oaeilahe`]o]ej`]c]nmq]h]knecai(koajpe`ka]na]he`]`a`ajkoo]o_naj]o* ]ooeimqak_kjbhepkajpnaiejd]rkjp]`aa]onacn]o`aiejd]ok_ea`]`aiahar]i ]_khk_]n]oacqejpamqaopk6okqhernamq]j`kmqankkqb]k]hckmqa_kjpn]ne]iejd]ok) _ea`]`a(kqokqhernamq]j`k`kiejkiejd]rkjp]`aa]k^neck]]_aep]nkmqaiejd]ok) _ea`]`a`apaniej];Kqoaf](okqhernamq]j`koeckiejd]rkjp]`akqmq]j`kokq_]l]v`a _kjpnkh)h]; Kn]( l]n] naolkj`an ] aoo] mqaopk( lna_eo]iko b]van kqpn]o lancqjp]o( i]eo lnkbqj`]o*Paiko`alancqjp]nÎKmqa]he^an`]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]rkjp]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]ok_ea) `]`a;Ï(ÎKmqaokk>aiakI]h(kfqopkakejfqopk;Ï*
]ooeip]i^imqa]oatlanej_e]o `kpailkl]n]`ka`kpailkrahkva]`k pailki]n_]`klahknah cekjkohar]i] ej`]c]n6Î?kiklkoorahmqad]f]`q]o na]he`]`aopailkn]eo`ebanajpao(]i]n_]) `]lahknah ceka]rere`]lknj o;Ï(ÎMq]h kpailkna]haran`]`aenk;Ï*I]o(l]n] naolkj`an]aoo]olancqjp]o(jkr]iajpa lna_eok b]van qi] lancqjp] i]eo lnk) bqj`]aej`]c]n6ÎKmqakpailk;Ï* @]iaoi]i]jaen](]`ebanaj]ajpna jkoo]lan_alk`]eik^ehe`]`a`]Pann] aik^ehe`]`a`kOkhakmqaajoej]]]opnk) jkie]har])jko]lancqjp]n6ÎOajklan) _a^aikokoikreiajpko`]Pann]aoajko) okokhdkooaajc]j]ipklnkbqj`]iajpa( oan mqa lk`anaiko oailna _kjbe]n ai jkoo]lan_alkreoq]hkq`araikooai) lna `ao_kjbe]n `ah];Ï( ÎOan mqa lan_a^a) iko]o_keo]o_kikna]hiajpaok;Ï*L]n] naolkj`an ] aoo]o lancqjp]o( lna_eo]iko b]van`q]okqpn]o(i]eolnkbqj`]o6ÎKmqa lan_a^an;ÏaÎKmqana]he`]`a;Ï* K mqa aop lkn pno `a p]eo lancqjp]o; K b]pk `a mqa aop]iko iq`]j`k `a ]pepq`a* Mq]j`kkmqaan]k^fapk`a_naj]]l]na_a_kik]hck_kjpn]`ep nekkqlnk^haipe_kalkn eookoapn]jobkni]aiej`]c]kkqejpannkc]k(aop]ikol]oo]j`k`]]pepq`a_kopqiaen] ^qfqrabcfilpcf`^* Aoo]iq`]j]`a]pepq`aej`e_]]hck^]op]jpalna_eok6mqaijkoa_kjpajp]_ki]o _naj]okqkleje aolnaaop]^aha_e`]o(mqailan_a^a_kjpn]`e aoaej_kil]pe^ehe`]`aoaj) pnaah]o(mqailnk_qn]_kilnaaj`ankmqaah]ookalknmqaoklnk^haipe_]oaopatlne) iej`kqi`aoafk(kabpbglabp^_bo*Aat]p]iajpaeookkmqa(j]knecai(]l]h]rn]cfilplcf^ oecjebe_](lkeo(aicnack(mefilplme^mqan`evanÎ]ikno]^a`kne]Ï*
#OMPANHIAßDASß,ETRAS ß
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
Mq]`nejdko`] deop ne]ÎKrqÏ( mqa_kil ak hernkLanolkheo(`] _]npqjeop]en]je]j] I]nf]jaO]pn]le* =deop ne]j]nn]`] ailneiaen]laook] a_kjp]]olanel_e]o rere`]olah]ln lne] ]qpkn]jkEn`ko ]e]pkho*
>qo_]j`k]o]`]`]_]ranj]kq]]pepq`abehkobe_]
E
i]cejaiko(lknp]jpk(]hcqimqapki]ooa]`a_eok`ajk]_aep]n]okleje aoaop]) ^aha_e`]oa_kia]ooa]b]vanlancqjp]omqakokqpnkofqhc]iaopn]jd]oaejaolan]`]o* Airav`aÎMqadkn]ook;ÏkqÎMqa`e]dkfa;Ï(lancqjp]ooaÎKmqakpailk;Ï*Ai rav`a`evanÎAopokjd]j`kÏkqÎBe_kqi]hq_]Ï(mqeoaooao]^anÎKmqakokjdk(]hkq_qn]( ]n]vk;Ï* Oqlkjd]ikomqaaoo]laook]bkooaoq^opepqej`koq]o]beni] aolknlancqjp]oaai rav`a`evanÎKj`adbqi]](dbkckÏkqÎJko]e]j]_dqr]l]n]jkbe_]nnaobne]`kÏ(lan) cqjp]ooaÎKmqa_]qo];Ï(ÎKmqaabaepk;Ï7kq(oaaihqc]n`a`evanÎOaf]k^faperkÏkqÎAhao okiqepkoq^faperkoÏ(lancqjp]ooaÎKmqa]k^fapere`]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]oq^fapere`]`a;Ï7a( ]ej`](oaairav`a]beni]nÎAop]_]o]i]eo^kjep]`kmqa]kqpn]Ï(lancqjp]ooaÎKmqa Ði]eoÑ;Ï(ÎKmqaÐiajkoÑ;Ï(ÎKmqak^ahk;Ï* Ai rav `a cnep]nÎIajpenkokÏ( mqaopekj]ooa6ÎK mqa ] ran`]`a;Ï(ÎK mqa k b]hok;Ï( ÎKmqakannk;Ï(ÎKmqa]iajpen];Ï(ÎMq]j`kateoparan`]`aalknmq;Ï(ÎMq]j`kateopa ehqokalknmq;Ï* Oa(airav`ab]h]nj]oq^fapere`]`a`koj]ikn]`ko(ejmqeneooa6ÎKmqak]ikn;Ï(ÎK mqak`aoafk;Ï(ÎKmqaokkooajpeiajpko;Ï*
.,
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
(ULTON $EUTSCHß#OLLECTION#ORBIS
Oanmqalan_a^aiko ]o_keo]o_kik na]hiajpaok;
Oa(aihqc]n`a`eo_knnanpn]jmqeh]iajpaok^naÎi]eknÏaÎiajknÏkqÎ_h]nkÏaÎao_qnkÏ( naokhraooaejraopec]n6ÎKmqa]mq]jpe`]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]mq]he`]`a;Ï* Aoa(airav`a]beni]nmqackop]`a]hcqilknmqalkooqe]oiaoi]oe`ae]o(koiao) ikockopko(]oiaoi]olnabanj_e]oakoiaoikor]hknao(lnabaneooa]j]heo]n6ÎKmqaqi r]hkn;Ï(ÎKmqaqir]hknikn]h;Ï(ÎKmqaqir]hkn]npope_k;Ï(ÎKmqa]ikn]h;Ï(ÎKmqa ]rkjp]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]he^an`]`a;Ï* =hcqimqapki]ooaaoo]`a_eokaop]ne]pki]j`k`eop j_e]`]re`]_kpe`e]j]a`aoe iaoik(pane]l]oo]`k]ej`]c]nkmqaok]o_naj]oakooajpeiajpkomqa]heiajp]i(oe) haj_eko]iajpa(jkoo]ateopj_e]*=kpki]naoo]`eop j_e](aop]ne]ejpannkc]j`k]oeiaoik( `aoaf]j`k_kjda_anlknmqa_naikojkmqa_naiko(lknmqaoajpeikokmqaoajpeikoak mqaokjkoo]o_naj]oajkookooajpeiajpko*Aooa]hcqiaop]ne]_kia]j`k]_qilnenk mqa`eve]kkn_qhk`a@ahbko6Î?kjda_a)pa]peiaoikÏ*Aaop]ne]_kia]j`k]]`kp]nkmqa _d]i]iko`a]pepq`abehkobe_]* =ooei(qi]lneiaen]naolkop]lancqjp]ÎKmqabehkokbe];Ïlk`ane]oan6Î=`a_eok`ajk ]_aep]n_kikj]pqn]eo( ^re]oaare`ajpao]o_keo]o(]oe`ae]o(kob]pko(]ooepq] ao(kor]hknao( ko_kilknp]iajpko`ajkoo]ateopj_e]_kpe`e]j]7f]i]eo]_aep)hkooai]jpaod]r)hkoej) raopec]`ka_kilnaaj`e`kÏ* Lancqjp]n]i(_anp]rav(]qibeh okbk6ÎL]n]mqabehkokbe];Ï*Aahanaolkj`aq6ÎL]n]jk `]nikojkoo]]_aep]keia`e]p]o_keo]o(oaii]eknao_kjoe`an] aoÏ* Lk`aiko`evanmqa]behkokbe]oqncamq]j`kkooanaodqi]jko_kia]i]atecenlnkr]o afqopebe_] aon]_ekj]eomqar]he`aikqejr]he`ai]o_naj]o_kpe`e]j]o* Lknmqan]_ekj]eo;Lknpnoikperkolnej_el]eo6ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqao^`flk^ioec) jebe_]]ncqiajp]`k(`a^]pe`ka_kilnaaj`e`k7aioacqj`k(lknmqao^`flk^ioecjebe_]mqa( ]k]ncqiajp]na`a^]pan(mqanaiko_kjda_an]o_kj`e aoakolnaooqlkopko`ajkookolaj) o]iajpkoako`kokqpnko7aipan_aenk(lknmqao^`flk^ioecjebe_]naolaep]n_anp]onacn]o`a _kanj_e]`klajo]iajpkl]n]mqaqi]ncqiajpkkqqi`a^]papajd]ioajpe`k(_dac]j) `k]_kj_hqo aomqalk`aioan_kilnaaj`e`]o(`eo_qpe`]o(]_aep]oanaolaep]`]olknkqpnko*
=]pepq`a_npe_]
=
lneiaen]_]n]_panope_]`]]pepq`abehko be_]jac]pe) r](eopk(qiÎ`evanjkÏ]koÎln)_kj_aepkoÏ(]koÎln) fqvkoÏ(]kob]pkoaoe`ae]o`]atlanej_e]_kpe`e]j]( ]kmqaÎpk`kiqj`k`evalajo]Ï(]kaop]^aha_e`k*Jqi]l]) h]rn](_khk_]najpnal]njpaoaojkoo]o_naj]ol]n]lk`an ejpannkc]nnr^fpplpr^p`^rp^panr^ipbrpbkqfal* = oacqj`] _]n]_panope_] `] ]pepq`a behko be_] lk) oeper](eopk(qi]ejpannkc]kok^nalnrbpl]o_keo]o( ]o e`ae]o( ko b]pko( ]o oepq] ao( ko _kilknp]iajpko( ko r]hknao(j oiaoiko*p]i^iqi]ejpannkc]kok^na k mlonr a k `ljl `eook pq`k a `a j o ln lneko*ÎK mqa ;Ï(ÎLknmqa;Ï(Î?kik;Ï*Aoo]ook]oej`]c] aobqj`]) iajp]eo`]]pepq`abehko be_]* =b]_ajac]per]a]b]_alkoeper]`]]pepq`abehko be_] _kjopepqaikmqa_d]i]iko`a]pepq`a_npe_]* LknmqaÎ_npe_]Ï; Aican]h(fqhc]ikomqa]l]h]rn]`oqf`^oecjebe_]oan `k _kjpn]( `evan mqa pq`k r]e i]h( mqa pq`k aop ann]`k( mqapq`kbaekkq`ao]cn]`rah*?npe_]i]qdqikn(_ke) o]`acajpa_d]p]kqlnapajoeko]mqa]_d]mqao]^ai]eo mqakokqpnko*I]ojkeookmqaaoo]l]h]rn]mqan`evan*
.-
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
=l]h]rn]`oqf`^rai`kcnackalkooqepnooajpe`kolnej_el]eo6-%Î_]l]_e`]`al]n]fqh) c]n(`eo_anjena`a_e`en_knnap]iajpaÏ7.%Îat]ian]_ekj]h`apk`]o]o_keo]ooailna_kj_aepk aoailn)fqhc]iajpkÏ7/%Î]pere`]`a`aat]iej]na]r]he]n`ap]hd]`]iajpaqi]e`ae](qi r]hkn(qi_kopqia(qi_kilknp]iajpk(qi]k^n]]npope_]kq_eajpbe_]Ï*=]pepq`abehko be) _]qi]]pepq`aÎ_npe_]Ïlknmqalnaaj_daaooaopnooecjebe_]`ko`]jkk`a`oqf`^(]mq]h( _kikoak^oanr](ejoal]nrah`]jkk`ao^`flk^i(mqareiko]jpanekniajpa* =behkokbe]_kia]`evaj`kÎjkÏo_naj]oa]kolna_kj_aepko`k`e]]`e]l]n]mqalko) o]ioan]r]he]`kon]_ekj]ha_nepe_]iajpa(]`iepej`kmqajko]^aikokmqaei]cejr]iko o]^an*Kq(_kik`eve]O _n]pao(_kia]iko]^qo_]nk_kjda_eiajpkmq]j`kokiko_]l]vao `a`evan6ÎO oaemqaj]`]oaeÏ* L]n]Lh]pk(k`eo_lqhk`aO _n]pao(]behkokbe]_kia]_ki]^ajfo^ lkq(_kikao_na) raoaq`eo_lqhk=neop pahao(]behkokbe]_kia]_kikbpm^kql(Î***lkeokodkiajo_kia]i a_kia]n]ioailna]behkokb]nikre`kolahkaol]jpk$***%*=mqahamqaoa_khk_]qi]`ebe) _qh`]`aaoaaol]jp](na_kjda_aoq]ln lne]ecjkn j_e]*$***%@aoknpamqa(oabehkokb]n]i(bke l]n]bqcen`]ecjkn j_e]Ï* >ajfo^ labpm^kqloecjebe_]imqana_kjda_aikojkoo]ecjkn j_e]aat]p]iajpalkn eooklk`aikooqlan)h]*J ojkoaol]jp]ikomq]j`k(lkniaek`ajkooklajo]iajpk(pk) i]iko`eop j_e]`kjkookiqj`k_kopqiaenk(khd]j`k)k_kikoajqj_]kperooaikoreopk ]jpao(_kikoajkperooaikope`kb]ihe](]iecko(lnkbaooknao(hernkoakqpnkoiaeko`a_k) iqje_]kmqajkoperaooai`epkkmqakiqj`k7_kikoaaoperooaiko]_]^]j`k`aj]o) _anl]n]kiqj`kal]n]j oiaoikoalna_eoooaikolancqjp]nkmqa(lknmqaa_kik kiqj`k(alna_eoooaikolancqjp]np]i^ikmqaokiko(lknmqaokikoa_kikokiko* =behkokbe]eje_e]oq]ejraopec]kjqiikiajpkiqepklna_eok6j]mqahaejop]jpaai mqa]^]j`kj]ikojkoo]o_anpav]o_kpe`e]j]oajk`eolkiko`aj]`]l]n]oq^opepq)h]okq l]n] lnaaj_dan ] h]_qj] `aet]`] lkn ah]o* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( ] behkokbe] oa ejpanaoo] lkn ]mqahaejop]jpaaimqa]na]he`]`aj]pqn]h$kiqj`k`]o_keo]o%a]na]he`]`adeop ne_k)ok) _e]h$kiqj`k`kodkiajo%pknj]i)oaaopn]jd]o(aol]jpko]o(ej_kilnaajoraeoaajeci) pe_]o(mq]j`k]okleje aoaop]^aha_e`]o`eolkjraeofjkjkolk`aio]peob]van*Kqoaf](] behkokbe]rkhp])oalnabanaj_e]hiajpal]n]kojljbkqlpab`ofpbjklajo]iajpk(j]hejcq]) caij]]k(lkeojaooaoikiajpko_npe_komqaoai]jebaop]i]eo_h]n]iajpa]atecj_e] `abqj`]iajp]k`]oe`ae]o(`ko`eo_qnokoa`]olnpe_]o* =ooei_kik_]`]qi`aj o(mq]j`klkooqe`aoafk`ao]^an(r]eai`enak]pepq`abehk) o be_]]klan_a^an_kjpn]`e ao(ej_kanj_e]o(]i^ecqe`]`aokqej_kil]pe^ehe`]`aoajpnajko) o]o_naj]o_kpe`e]j]o(]ooeip]i^i]behkokbe]paiaola_e]hejpanaooalahkoikiajpko`a_ne) oakqikiajpko_npe_ko(mq]j`koeopai]onahecekoko(pe_ko(lkhpe_ko(_eajpbe_koa]npope_koao) p]^aha_e`kooaajrkhraiai_kjpn]`e aoejpanj]okq_kjpn]`evai)oaqjo]kokqpnkoa^qo_]i pn]jobkni] aoaiq`]j]o_qfkoajpe`k]ej`]jkaop_h]nkalna_eo]oan_kilnaaj`e`k*
L]n]mqabehkokbe];
K
n](iqepkob]vaiqi]kqpn]lancqjp]6Î=bej]h(l]n]mqabehkokbe];Ï*qi]lancqjp] ejpanaoo]jpa*Jkraikojaikqreikojejcqilancqjp]n(lknatailhk(ÎL]n]mqa i]paipe_]kqboe_];Ï(ÎL]n]mqacakcn]be]kqcakhkce];Ï(ÎL]n]mqadeop ne]kqok) _ekhkce];Ï(ÎL]n]mqa^ekhkce]kqloe_khkce];Ï(ÎL]n]mqa]opnkjkie]kqmqie_];Ï(ÎL]n]mqa lejpqn](hepan]pqn](ioe_]kq`]j];Ï*I]opk`kiqj`k]_d]iqepkj]pqn]hlancqjp]nÎL]n] mqabehkokbe];Ï* Aican]h(aoo]lancqjp]_kopqi]na_a^anqi]naolkop]enje_](_kjda_e`]`koaopq`]j) pao`abehkokbe]6Î=behkokbe]qi]_ej_e]_ki]mq]haoai]mq]hkiqj`klani]ja_ap]h amq]hÏ*Kqoaf](]behkokbe]jkoanral]n]j]`]*Lkneook(_kopqi])oa_d]i]n`aÎbeh okbkÏ ]hcqioailna`eopn]`k(_ki]_]^a]jkiqj`k`]hq](lajo]j`ka`evaj`k_keo]omqa jejcqiajpaj`aamqaok_kilhap]iajpaejpaeo(_kikjkaleo `ek`aP]hao`aIehapk mqa]^naaop]Ejpnk`qk*
..
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
./
Aoo]lancqjp](ÎL]n]mqabehkokbe];Ï(pai]oq]n]vk`aoan*Aijkoo]_qhpqn]aaijko) o]ok_ea`]`a(_kopqi]iko_kjoe`an]nmqa]hcqi]_keo]o paik`enaepk`aateopenoaperan ]hcqi] bej]he`]`a lnpe_] iqepk reorah a `a qpehe`]`a eia`e]p]( `a ik`k mqa( mq]j`k oa lancqjp]ÎL]n]mq;Ï(kmqaoamqano]^an6ÎMq]h]qpehe`]`a;Ï(ÎL]n]mqaoanraeook;Ï(ÎMqa qoklnkraepkokkqr]jp]fkoklkookb]van`eook;Ï* Aeolknmqajejcqilancqjp]ÎL]n]mqa]o_ej_e]o;Ï(lkeopk`kiqj`kei]cej]ran] qpehe`]`a`]o_ej_e]ojkolnk`qpko`]p_je_](eopk(j]]lhe_]k`ko_kjda_eiajpko_eajp) be_kol]n]_ne]nejopnqiajpko`aqok(`ao`ak_nkjiapnk(kpahao_ lekakie_nko_ lek]p] hqvahpne_](]cah]`aen](k]qpki rah(k]rek(]imqej]`ah]r]nnkql]kqhkq](kpahabkja(k n`ek(]pahareok(k_ejai](]imqej]`an]ekoT(k_kilqp]`kn(kok^fapko`alhope_k(ap_* Pk`kiqj`kp]i^iei]cej]ran]qpehe`]`a`]o]npao(p]jpklkn_]qo]`]_kiln]a raj`]`]ok^n]o`a]npa$pe`]o_kiki]eoeilknp]jpaomq]jpki]eo]hpkobknaioaqolnako jkian_]`k%(_kiklknmqajkoo]_qhpqn]rko]npeop]o_kikcjekomqaiana_aioanr]hkne) v]`kol]n]kahkcek`]dqi]je`]`a$]kiaoikpailkmqa(l]n]`kt]hiajpa(jkoo]ok_ea`]) `a_]l]v`anafaep)hkoai]hpn]p)hkooaoq]ok^n]obknairan`]`aen]iajpanarkhq_ekjne]o aejkr]`kn]o(lkeo(jaooao_]oko(jkokÎpaeoÏl]n]kaop]^aha_e`k%*Jejcqi(pk`]re](_kj) oacqaranl]n]mqaoanrene]]behkokbe](`kj`a`evan)oa6ÎJkoanral]n]_keo]]hcqi]Ï* L]na_a(lkni(mqakoajok_kiqijkajtanc]]hckmqako_eajpeop]oo]^aiiqepk^ai* =o_ej_e]olnapaj`aioan_kjda_eiajpkoran`]`aenko(k^pe`kocn]]o]lnk_a`eiajpkoneck) nkoko`alajo]iajpk7lnapaj`ai]cenok^na]na]he`]`a(lkniaek`aejopnqiajpkoak^fapko p_je_ko7lnapaj`aib]vanlnkcnaookojko_kjda_eiajpko(_knnecej`k)koa]qiajp]j`k)ko* Kn](pk`]oaoo]olnapajo ao`]o_ej_e]olnaooql aimqaah]o]`iepai]ateopj_e]`] ran`]`a(]ja_aooe`]`a`alnk_a`eiajpko_knnapkol]n]^aiqo]nklajo]iajpk(kaop]^a) ha_eiajpk`]pa_jkhkce]_kik]lhe_]klnpe_]`apakne]o(a(ok^napq`k(mqaah]o_kjbe]i j]n]_ekj]he`]`a`ko_kjda_eiajpko(eopk(mqaahaookrhe`kojko lknmqaatlhe_]iko b]pko(i]op]i^ilknmqalk`aioan_knnece`koa]lanbaek]`ko* Ran`]`a(lajo]iajpkn]_ekj]h(lnk_a`eiajpkoaola_e]eol]n]_kjda_anb]pko(]lhe_]k lnpe_]`a_kjda_eiajpkopa ne_ko(_knnaka]_iqhk`ao]^anao6bppbpl_gbqfslpbmolmpf* qlpa^p`fk`f^pklpl`fbkqcf`lp)plcfilpcf`lpbabmbkabjabnrbpqbpcfilpcf`^p*K_eaj) peop]l]npa`ah]o_kikmqaop aofnaolkj`e`]o(i]o]behkokbe]mqai]obkniqh]a^qo_] naolkop]ol]n]ah]o* =ooei(kpn]^]hdk`]o_ej_e]olnaooql a(_kik_kj`ek(kpn]^]hdk`]behkokbe](iao) ikmqak_eajpeop]jkoaf]beh okbk*Jkajp]jpk(_kik]laj]oko_eajpeop]oabeh okbkoo]^ai `eook(]i]ekne]`]olaook]o(ajrkhre`]olahkoajok_kiqi(_kjpejq]]beni]j`kmqa]behk) okbe]jkoanral]n]j]`]* L]n]`]n]hcqi]qpehe`]`abehkokbe](iqepko_kjoe`an]imqalna_eok`apaniej]n_h]n]) iajpakqokmqaoalk`ab]van`ah]*@evaiajpkmqa(`ab]pk(]behkokbe]jkoanral]n]j]`]( oaÎoanrenÏbknajpaj`e`k_kik]lkooe^ehe`]`a`ab]vanqokop_je_ko`kolnk`qpkobehko be_ko kq`]n)hdaoqpehe`]`aa_kjie_](k^paj`khq_nko_kiahao7_kjoe`an]ip]i^imqa]l]npa lnej_el]hkqi]eoeilknp]jpa`]behkokbe]j]`]pai]ran_ki]o_ej_e]oa]op_je_]o* L]n]mqailajo]`aoo]bkni](kejpanaooa`]behkokbe]jkaop]ne]jko_kjda_eiajpko $mqabe_]ilkn_kjp]`]_ej_e]%jaij]o]lhe_] aolnpe_]o`apakne]o$mqabe_]ilkn_kjp] `]pa_jkhkce]%(i]ojkoajoej]iajpkoikn]eokqpe_ko*=behkokbe]oane]]]npa`k^ai)reran kq`]re`]_knnap]arenpqko]*Aopq`]j`k]ol]et aoakor_ekodqi]jko(]he^an`]`aa]rkj) p]`a(]j]heo]j`k]_]l]_e`]`a`ajkoo]n]vkl]n]eilknheiepao]kojkooko`aoafkoal]et ao( ajoej]j`k)jko]reran`aik`kdkjaopkafqopkj]_kil]jde]`kokqpnkooanaodqi]jko(] behkokbe]pane]_kikbej]he`]`aajoej]n)jko]renpq`a(mqaklnej_lek`k^ai)reran* Aoo]`abejek`]behkokbe](lkni(jkjko]fq`]iqepk*@ab]pk(iaoikl]n]oanqi]]npa ikn]hkqpe_](kqqi]]npa`k^ai)reran(]behkokbe]_kjpejq]b]vaj`koq]olancqjp]o`ao_kj) _anp]jpaoaai^]n]ko]o6ÎKmqakdkiai;Ï(ÎKmqa]rkjp]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]l]etk;Ï(ÎKmqa ]n]vk;Ï(ÎKmqakr_ek;Ï(ÎKmqa]renpq`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]he^an`]`a;Ï(Î?kikjkopknj]iko hernao(n]_ekj]eoarenpqkoko;Ï(ÎLknmqa]he^an`]`aa]renpq`aokr]hknaol]n]kooanaodqi]) jko;Ï(ÎKmqaqir]hkn;Ï(ÎLknmqa]r]he]ikokooajpeiajpkoa]o] aodqi]j]o;Ï*
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
=ooei(iaoikoa`eooooaikomqakk^fapk`]behkokbe]jkk_kjda_eiajpk`]na]he) `]`a(jaik_kjda_eiajpk`]jkoo]_]l]_e`]`al]n]_kjda_an(iaoikoa`eooooaikomqa kk^fapk`]behkokbe]]laj]o]re`]ikn]hkqpe_](]ej`]]ooeikaopehkbehko be_ka]]pepq`a behko be_]lani]ja_ane]ikoiaoiko(lkeo]olancqjp]obehko be_]oÍlnr(mlonrba`ljl Ílani]ja_ai*
=pepq`abehkobe_]6ej`]c]n
O
a(lknajmq]jpk(`aet]niko`ah]`kkok^fapko_kikomq]eo]behkokbe]oak_ql](rana) ikomqa]]pepq`abehko be_]lkooqe]hcqi]o_]n]_panope_]omqaok]oiaoi]o(ej`a) laj`ajpaiajpa`k_kjpa`kejraopec]`k*Aoo]o_]n]_panope_]ook6
lancqjp]nlnrb$qi]_keo](qir]hkn(qi]e`ae](qi_kilknp]iajpk%*Kqoaf](]behk) okbe]lancqjp]mq]h]na]he`]`aamq]h]oecjebe_]k`a]hck(jkeilknp]kmq7 lancqjp]n`ljl$qi]_keo](qi]e`ae](qir]hkn(qi_kilknp]iajpk%*Kqoaf](]behkok) be]ej`]c]_kik]aopnqpqn]kqkoeopai]`anah] aomqa_kjopepqe]na]he`]`a`a]hck7 lancqjp]nmlonrb$qi]_keo](qi]e`ae](qir]hkn(qi_kilknp]iajpk%*Kqoaf](lkn mqa]hckateopa(mq]h]knecaikq]_]qo]`aqi]_keo](`aqi]e`ae](`aqir]hkn(`a qi_kilknp]iajpk* =]pepq`abehko be_]eje_e])oa`enecej`kaoo]oej`]c] ao]kiqj`kmqajkonk`ae]ao nah] aomqai]jpaiko_kiaha*Lkq_k]lkq_k(`ao_k^namqaaoo]omqaop aolnaooql ai] becqn]`]mqahamqaejpannkc]amqaah]oatecaimqaoaf]atlhe_]`]]paj`j_e]`koandqi]) jk]ejpannkc]nkiqj`ka]oeiaoik_kik`aoafk`a_kjda_)hka_kjda_an)oa*Aikqpn]o l]h]rn]o( ] behkokbe] _kilnaaj`a mqa mob`fp^ `lkeb`bo klpp^ `^m^`fa^ab ab `lkeb`bo( mqa mob`fp^mbkp^opl_obklpp^`^m^`fa^ababmbkp^o* Lkneook(lkq_k]lkq_k(]olancqjp]o`]behkokbe]oa`enecai]kln lneklajo]iajpk6 ÎKmqalajo]n;Ï(Î?kiklajo]n;Ï(ÎLknmqadklajo]n;Ï*=behkokbe]pknj])oa(ajpk(lmbk* p^jbkqlfkqboold^kal*pb^pfjbpjl*Lknoanqi]rkhp]mqaklajo]iajpkna]hev]ok^naoe iaoik(]behkokbe]oana]hev]_kikobcibulkq(oacqej`kkkn_qhk`a@ahbko(^qo_]na]hev]n kÎ?kjda_a)pa]peiaoikÏ*
=nabhatkbehkobe_]
=
l]h]rn]obcibulailnac]`]j]boe_]l]n]`ao_narankikreiajpk`alnkl]c]k`a qi]kj`]hqiejko]kqokjkn]mq]j`k(]kl]oo]n`aqiiaekl]n]kqpnk(aj_kjpn] qik^op_qhkanapknj]]kiaek`akj`al]npeq*aooanapknjk]klkjpk`al]npe`] mqa_kjoanr]`kmq]j`k]l]h]rn]qo]`]j]behkokbe]l]n]oecjebe_]nÎikreiajpk`arkhp] ok^naoeiaoikÏkqÎikreiajpk`anapknjk]oeiaoikÏ*=obcibulcfilpcf`^kikreiaj) pklahkmq]hklajo]iajpk(at]iej]j`kkmqalajo]`klknaha(rkhp])oal]n]oeiaoik _kikbkjpa`aooalajo]`k*klajo]iajpkejpannkc]j`k)oa]oeiaoikkqlajo]j`k)oa]oe iaoik*]_kj_ajpn]kiajp]haimqaklajo]iajpkrkhp])oal]n]oeln lnekl]n]at]ie) j]n(_kilnaaj`ana]r]he]noq]oe`ae]o(oq]orkjp]`ao(oaqo`aoafkoaoajpeiajpko* =nabhatkbehko be_]o^af`^ilknmqar]en]ev`klajo]iajpk(lkeoqiikreiajpk `arkhp]`klajo]iajpkok^naoeiaoikl]n]lajo]n)oa]oeiaoik(l]n]_kjda_an_kik lkoorahkln lneklajo]iajpkkqkln lnek_kjda_eiajpk* Jkokiko(lkni(okiajpaoanaolajo]jpao*Okikop]i^ioanaomqa]caijkiqj) `k(mqaoanah]_ekj]i_kikokqpnkooanaodqi]jko(_kiko]jei]eo(]olh]jp]o(]o_keo]o( kob]pkoa]_kjpa_eiajpko(aatlneieikoaoo]onah] aop]jpklkniaek`]hejcq]caia`ko caopko_kiklkniaek`a] ao(_kilknp]iajpkoa_kj`qp]o*=nabhatkbehko be_]p]i^i oarkhp]l]n]_kilnaaj`ankmqaoal]oo]aij ojaoo]onah] aomqai]jpaiko_ki]na]) he`]`a_en_qj`]jpa(l]n]kmqa`evaikoal]n]]o] aomqana]hev]iko* =nabhatkbehko be_]knc]jev])oaaipknjk`apnocn]j`ao_kjfqjpko`alancqjp]okq mqaop ao6
.0
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
-*
ÎLkn mqa lajo]iko k mqa lajo]iko( `evaiko k mqa `evaiko a b]vaiko k mqa b]va) iko;ÏEopk(mq]eokojlqfslp(]oo^wbpa]o`^rp^pl]n]lajo]nikokmqalajo]iko( `evanikokmqa`evaiko(b]vanikokmqab]vaiko;
.* ÎK mqa mqanaiko lajo]n mq]j`k lajo]iko( k mqa mqanaiko `evan mq]j`k b]h]iko( kmqamqanaikob]vanmq]j`k]ceiko;ÏEopk(mq]hk`lkqb alkqkpbkqfal`kmqa lajo]iko(`evaikokqb]vaiko; /* ÎL]n]mqalajo]ikokmqalajo]iko(`evaikokmqa`evaiko(b]vaikokmqab]vaiko;Ï Eopk(mq]h]fkqbk lkq]cfk^ifa^ab`kmqalajo]iko(`evaikoab]vaiko; (ALES(ULTONß!RCHIVE
Aoo]opnomqaop aopi_kikk^fapko`aej`]c]kklaj) o]iajpk(]hejcq]caia]]kalk`aioannaoqie`]oaikmqa lajo]n(b]h]na]cen;Aah]olnaooql ai]oacqejpalancqjp]6ÎK mqalajo]iko(`evaikoab]vaikoaijkoo]o_naj]o_kpe`e]) j]o_kjopepqekqjkqilajo]iajpkran`]`aenk(qi]hejcq]) cai_kanajpaaqi]]k`kp]`]`aoajpe`k;Ï ?kik reiko( ] ]pepq`a behko be_] eje_e])oa ej`]c]j`k ÎK mqa;Ï(Î?kik;Ï(ÎLknmqa;Ï(`enecej`k)oa]kiqj`kmqajko nk`ae]a]kooanaodqi]jkomqajahareraia_kiahaoanah]) _ekj]i*Oklancqjp]ook^na]bppk`f^$Kmqa;%(]pfdkfcf`^* lkqbpqorqro^$?kik;%(]lofdbj$Lknmqa;%a]cfk^ifa^ab $L]n] mqa ;% `a pk`]o ]o _keo]o* qi o]^an ok^na ] ob^ifa^ab buqboflo]klajo]iajpk* F]nabhatkbehko be_](kqkÎ?kjda_a)pa]peiaoikÏ(ej`]) c]ÎLknmq;Ï(ÎKmq;Ï(ÎL]n]mq;Ïaoa`eneca]klajo]iajpk( hejcq]caia]k(kqoaf](rkhp])oal]n]kooanaodqi]jko*Ok lancqjp]ook^na]`^m^`fa^aba]cfk^ifa^abl]n]`lkeb`bo(c^i^o a^dfo(ln lne]o`kooanaodqi]jko*qio]^anok^nakdkiai _kikoanlajo]jpa(b]h]jpaa]cajpa(kqoaf](ok^na]ob^ifa^ab fkqboflo`kooanaodqi]jko* =]pepq`abehko be_] naoqia)oajk oacqejpamqaopekj]) iajpk6kmqak lajo]n(kb]h]n(k]cen;
.1
Behkokbe]6qilajo]iajpkoeopaipe_k
=
oej`]c] aobqj`]iajp]eo`]]pepq`abehko be_]a`]nabhatkbehko be_]jkoana]) hev]i]k]_]ok(oacqj`klnabanj_e]oakleje ao`a_]`]qi`aj o*=behkokbe]jk qiÎaq]_dkmqaÏkqqiÎaqckopk`aÏ*Jklaomqeo]`aklejeki]jaen]`ko iaeko`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo]*Jklaomqeo]`aian_]`kl]n]_kjda_anlnabanj_e]o`ko _kjoqie`knao_ki]bej]he`]`a`aikjp]nqi]aopn]pce]`alnkl]c]j`]* =oej`]c] aobehko be_]ooana]hev]i`aik`kpfpqbjqf`l*Mqaoecjebe_]eook; = l]h]rn] pfpqbj^ rai `k cnack( oecjebe_]Îqi pk`k _qf]o l]npao aopk hec]`]o lkn na) h] ao`a_kj_kn` j_e]ejpanj]Ï*Jk_]ok`klajo]iajpk(oecjebe_]Îqi_kjfqjpk`ae`ae]o ejpanj]iajpa]npe_qh]`]oanah]_ekj]`]o(cn]]o]lnej_leko_kiqjokq]_anp]onacn]oajkn) i]o`a]ncqiajp]ka`aikjopn]kmqa]okn`aj]ia]onah]_ekj]ijqipk`k_kanajpaÏ* @evanmqa]oej`]c] aobehko be_]ookoeopaipe_]ooecjebe_]`evanmqa]behkokbe]pn]^]hd] _kiajqj_e]`kolna_eokoanecknkoko(^qo_]aj_]`a]iajpkoh ce_koajpnakoajqj_e]`ko(kla) n]_ki_kj_aepkokqe`ae]ok^pe`kolknlnk_a`eiajpko`a`aikjopn]kalnkr](ateca]bqj) `]iajp]kn]_ekj]h`kmqaajqj_e]`kalajo]`k*Okiajpa]ooei]nabhatkbehko be_]lk`a b]van_kimqajkoo]atlanej_e]_kpe`e]j](jkoo]o_naj]oakleje ao]h_]j_aiqi]reok_n) pe_]`aoeiaoi]o*Jkoapn]p]`a`evanÎaq]_dkmqaÏ(i]o`alk`an]beni]nÎaqlajokmqaÏ* K_kjda_eiajpkbehko be_kqipn]^]hdkejpaha_pq]h*oeopaipe_klknmqajkoa_kj) pajp]aik^pannaolkop]ol]n]]omqaop ao_khk_]`]o(i]oatecamqa]oln lne]omqaop ao oaf]irhe`]oa(aioacqj`khqc]n(mqa]onaolkop]ooaf]iran`]`aen]o(aopaf]inah]_ekj]`]o ajpnaoe(ao_h]na]iqi]ookqpn]o(bkniai_kjfqjpko_kanajpao`ae`ae]oaoecjebe_] ao( oaf]ilnkr]`]oa`aikjopn]`]on]_ekj]hiajpa*
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
Mq]j`k]hcqi`evÎAop]iejd]behkokbe]ÏkqÎAop]]behkokbe]`abqh]j]kq`abqh]jkÏ kq]ej`]ÎAop]]behkokbe]`]ailnao]Ï(ajc]j])oaajkoaajc]j]* Ajc]j])oalknmqaei]cej]mqal]n]Îpanqi]behkokbe]Ï^]op]]hcqilkooqenqi_kj) fqjpk`ae`ae]oi]eokqiajko_kanajpaook^napk`]o]o_keo]oalaook]o(^ai_kikpanqi _kjfqjpk`alnej_lekoi]eokqiajko_kanajpaol]n]fqhc]n]o_keo]oa]olaook]o* I]ojkoaajc]j]]kqo]naoo]oatlnaoo aolknmqalan_a^a(]ej`]mqaiqepk_kjbqo]) iajpa(mqadqi]_]n]_panope_]j]oe`ae]oajkolnej_lekomqahar]]`evanmqaokÎqi]be) hkokbe]Ï6]hec]kajpna_anp]oe`ae]oa_anpko_kilknp]iajpko(]onah] aoajpnaaoo]oe`ae]o aaooao_kilknp]iajpko_kikoaperaooai]hcqjolnej_lekomqakoqjeooaikqnah]_ekj]o) oai*Kqoaf](lnaooajpa)oamqa]behkokbe]klan]oeopai]pe_]iajpa(_ki_kanj_e]ah ce_]( mqapaiqi]rk_]kl]n]_kilnaaj`an_kikoanah]_ekj]i(oa_kja_p]iaoaaj_]`ae]i jqipk`kn]_ekj]hiajpa_kilnaajorah]o_keo]oakob]pkomqa]l]na_ai`aik`kbn]c) iajp]`ka`ao_kjatkaijkoo]atlanej_e]_kpe`e]j]*
Ai^qo_]`aqi]`abejek`]behkokbe]
M
q]j`k_kia]iko]aopq`]nbehkokbe](okikohkckhar]`ko]^qo_]nkmqaah]*Jkoo] lneiaen]oqnlnao]oqnca]k`ao_k^nenikomqajkd]laj]oqi]`abejek`]behkok) be](i]orne]o*=oacqj`]oqnlnao]rai]klan_a^anikomqa(]hi`arne]o(]o`abeje) aojkl]na_ailk`anoannaqje`]ojqi]o ai]eo]ilh]*Aeolknmqaiqepko(_daeko`alan) lhate`]`a(ej`]c]i6Î=bej]h(kmqa]behkokbe]mqajaioamqan_kjoacqa`evankmqaah];Ï* Qi] lneiaen] ]lnktei]k jko ikopn] lahk iajko mq]pnk `abeje ao can]eo `k mqa oane]]behkokbe]6 -*
Reok`aiqj`k`aqilkrk(`aqi]_erehev]kkq`aqi]_qhpqn]* Jaoo]`abejek(]behkokbe]_knnaolkj`ane](`aik`kr]ckacan]h(]k_kjfqjpk`a e`ae]o(r]hknaoalnpe_]olahkomq]eoqi]ok_ea`]`a]lnaaj`aa_kilnaaj`akiqj`k a]oeiaoi](`abejej`kl]n]oekpailkakaol]k(ko]cn]`kaklnkb]jk(k^kiak i]q(kfqopkakejfqopk(k^ahkakbaek(kran`]`aenkakb]hok(klkoorahakeilkoorah( k_kjpejcajpaakja_aoonek* Mq]hklnk^hai]`aoo]`abejek;Lknqih]`k(ah]oal]na_a_ki]jkk`aÎiejd] behkokbe]ÏkqÎ]behkokbe]`]ailnao]Ï7lknkqpnk(ah]pkcajne_]apk]ilh]mqajklan) iepa(lknatailhk(`ebanaj_e]najpnabehkokbe]anahecek(behkokbe]a]npa(behkokbe]a_ej_e]* J]ran`]`a(aoo]`abejeke`ajpebe_]behkokbe]a_qhpqn](lkeoaop]qi]reok`aiqj`k _khaper]mqaoaatlneiaaie`ae]o(r]hknaoalnpe_]o`aqi]ok_ea`]`a`apaniej]`]* =`abejek(lknp]jpk(jk_kjoacqa]_an_]n)oa`]aola_ebe_e`]`a`kpn]^]hdkbehko ) be_kalkneookjklk`aiko]_aep)h]_kik`abejek`]behkokbe](i]o]laj]o_kikqi] atlnaookmqa_kjpikqej`e_]]hcqjo]ola_pkomqalk`ankajpn]nj]oq]`abejek*
.* O]^a`kne]`are`]* Jaoo]`abejek(]behkokbe]e`ajpebe_]`]_ki]]pere`]`a`a]hcqi]olaook]omqa lajo]iok^na]re`]ikn]h(`a`e_]j`k)oa_kjpailh]k`kiqj`ka`kokqpnkooanao dqi]jkol]n]]lnaj`anaajoej]n]_kjpnkh]noaqo`aoafko(oajpeiajpkoaeilqhokoa] `enecen]ln lne]re`]`aik`kpe_kao^ek*=behkokbe]oane]qi]ao_kh]`are`]kqqi] ]npa`k^ai)reran7oane]qi]_kjpailh]k`kiqj`ka`kodkiajol]n]jko_kj`qven ]qi]re`]fqop](o^e]abahev(ajoej]j`k)jkok`kijekok^naj oiaoiko(ok^najko) okoeilqhoko(`aoafkoal]et ao*Aoo]`abejek(lkni(jko`ev(`aik`kr]ck(kmqaoa aolan]`]behkokbe]$]o]^a`kne]ejpanekn%(i]ojkkmqaah]akmqab]v]behkokbe]a(lkn eook(p]i^ijklk`aiko]_aep)h](i]o]laj]ona_kjda_anmqajah]aoplnaoajpaqi `ko]ola_pko`kpn]^]hdkbehko be_k* /* Aobknkn]_ekj]hl]n]_kj_a^ankQjeranok_kikqi]pkp]he`]`akn`aj]`]a`kp]`] `aoajpe`k* Jaoo]`abejek(]pne^qe)oabehkokbe]]p]nab]`a_kjda_an]na]he`]`aejpaen](lnkr]j) `kmqakQjeranokqi]pkp]he`]`a(eopk(]hckaopnqpqn]`kkqkn`aj]`klknnah] ao`a
.2
L]n]mqabehkokbe];x).42/$5a«/x
_]qo]aabaepk(amqaaoo]pkp]he`]`an]_ekj]h(kqoaf](lkooqeoajpe`kabej]he`]`a_ki) lnaajoraeolahklajo]iajpkdqi]jk* Komqa]`kp]iaoo]`abejeklna_eo]i_kia]n`eopejcqej`kajpnabehkokbe]ana) heceka]piaoikklkj`kqi]kqpn](lkeo]i^]olkooqaikiaoikk^fapk$_ki) lnaaj`ankQjeranok%(i]o]lneiaen]kb]vlkniaek`kaobknkn]_ekj]h(ajmq]jpk] oacqj`](lkniaek`]_kjbe]j]$b%jqi]narah]k`erej]*Kqoaf](]behkokbe]lnk_qn] `eo_qpen]pkbeikoajpe`kakbqj`]iajpk`]na]he`]`a(ajmq]jpk]_kjo_ej_e]nahe) ceko]oa^]oae]jqi`]`klneiaenkaejmqaopekjrah(mqa]narah]k`erej](k^fapk`a baej`aikjopnrahlah]al]n]]n]vkdqi]j]* Lah] b( ] nahecek ]_aep] lnej_leko ej`aikjopnraeo a ]p iaoik ]mqahao mqa lk) `aioan_kjoe`an]`koenn]_ekj]eolahklajo]iajpk(ajmq]jpk]behkokbe]jk]`iepaej`a) ikjopn]^ehe`]`aaenn]_ekj]he`]`a`a_keo]]hcqi]*Lahk_kjpnnek(klajo]iajpkbehko be) _klnk_qn]atlhe_]na_kilnaaj`aniaoikkmqal]na_aoanenn]_ekj]haejmqaopekjrah* Jkajp]jpk(aoo]`abejekp]i^ilnk^haipe_](lknmqa`behkokbe]]p]nab] `akbana_anqi]atlhe_]kaqi]_kilnaajokpkp]eook^nakQjeranok(ah]^kn]j`k qioeopai]qjerano]hkqqioeopai]`kiqj`k(i]oo]^aiko(dkfa(mqaaoo]p]nab] eilkoorah* ran`]`a mqa( jko oaqo lnei n`eko( ] behkokbe] oa ]lnaoajp]r] _kik qi] atlhe) _]kpkp]hok^na]na]he`]`a(eopk(ok^na]j]pqnav]boe_]aok^nakooanaodqi]jko( lkeojko rean]oq^opepqen]atlhe_]knaheceko]_kikp]i^i_kjopepq]k_kjfqjpk `apk`]o]o_ej_e]opa ne_]oalnpe_]o$kqoaf](jkd]re]`eopejkaoal]n]kajpna behkokbe]a_ej_e]%*Jkajp]jpk(d(jko`e]o`adkfa(lahkiajko`q]oheiep] aolnej_e) l]eo]aoo]lnapajokpkp]hev]`kn]6ailneiaenkhqc]n(]behkokbe]a]o_ej_e]obkn]ioa oal]n]j`kjk_knnan`]deop ne]ako]^an_eajpbe_koa`ere`eqairnekoo]^anaol]npe_q) h]nao(_]`]mq]h_kioaq_]ilkln lnek`aejraopec]ka`aatlhe_]k`aqi]ola_pk `apaniej]`k`]na]he`]`a*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]behkokbe]_kil]npehd]]atlhe_]k`] na]he`]`a_ki]o_ej_e]oa]o]npao(_]`]qi]`]omq]eo`abejej`kqi]ola_pkaqi _]ilk`]na]he`]`al]n]aopq`k$jk_]ok`]o_ej_e]o%al]n]]atlnaook$jk_]ok`]o ]npao%(fjkoaj`k]`ieoorahmqad]f]qi]je_]`eo_elhej]pa ne_]mqalkoo]]^n]j) canokvejd]]pkp]he`]`a`ko_kjda_eiajpkokqk_kjda_eiajpkqjerano]h`kQjeranok* Aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqa]ln lne]behkokbe]fjk]`iepamqaoaf]lkoorahqije_k oeopai] `a lajo]iajpk mqa kbana] qi] je_] atlhe_]k l]n] k pk`k `] na]he`]`a( lkeoaop]lani]ja_a]^anp]a_kjre`]]ihpelh]olanola_per]o`a_kjda_eiajpkoaej) panlnap] ao* Lkn eook( aoo] `abejek p]i^i jk lk`a oan ]_aep]( ai^kn] _kjpajd] ]ola_pkoeilknp]jpao`]]pere`]`abehko be_]*
.3
0* Bqj`]iajp]kpane_]a_npe_]`ko_kjda_eiajpkoa`]olnpe_]o* Crka^jbkqlqi]l]h]rn]mqarai`kh]peiaoecjebe_]Îqi]^]oao he`]ÏkqÎk ]he_an_aok^nakmq]hoalk`a_kjopnqen_kioacqn]j]Ï*@klkjpk`areop]`k_kjda_e) iajpk(oecjebe_]Î]^]oakqklnej_lekn]_ekj]hmqaoqopajp]qi]`aikjopn]kran`]) `aen]Ï*Ok^aop]lanola_per](crka^jbkq^ooecjebe_]Îaj_kjpn]n(`abejenaaop]^aha_ann]) _ekj]hiajpakolnej_leko(]o_]qo]oa_kj`e aomqa`apaniej]i]ateopj_e](]bkni] ako_kilknp]iajpko`a]hcqi]_keo](^ai_kik]ohaeokqnacn]o`aoq]oiq`]j]oÏ* Qblof^rai`kcnack(jkmq]hoecjebe_]r]Î_kjpailh]nqi]ran`]`a_kikokhdko `k aolnepkÏ( eopk ( qi] ]pere`]`a lqn]iajpa ejpaha_pq]h `a _kjda_eiajpk* Ok^ aop] lanola_per]( qi] crka^jbkq^ l qbof`^ oecjebe_]Î`apaniej]n lahk lajo]iajpk( `a i]jaen]h ce_](iap `e_](knc]jev]`]aoeopaipe_]k_kjfqjpk`alnej_leko(_]qo]oa _kj`e ao`a]hcqi]_keo]$`aoq]ateopj_e](`aoaq_kilknp]iajpk(`aoaqoajpe`ka `aoq]oiq`]j]o%Ï* ?kikreikodlkq_k(`oqf`^p]i^iqi]l]h]rn]cnac](mqaoecjebe_]Î]_]l]_e) `]`al]n]fqhc]n(`eo_anjena`a_e`en_knnap]iajpaÏ7Îkat]ian]_ekj]h`apk`]o]o_keo]o oailna_kj_aepkaoailn)fqhc]iajpkÏa]Î]pere`]`a`aat]iej]na]r]he]n`ap]hd]`]) iajpaqi]e`ae](qir]hkn(qi_kopqia(qi_kilknp]iajpk(qi]k^n]]npope_]kq _eajpbe_]Ï* Ok^ aoo] lanola_per]( crka^jbkq^ l `oqf`^ oecjebe_]Îat]iej]n( ]r]he]n a
x).42/$5a«/xL]n]mqabehkokbe];
fqhc]nn]_ekj]hiajpakolnej_leko(]o_]qo]oa_kj`e ao`a]hcqi]_keo]$`aoq]ateo) pj_e](`aoaq_kilknp]iajpk(`aoaqoajpe`ka`aoq]oiq`]j]o%Ï* ?kikcrka^jbkq^ lqbof`^b`oqf`^(]behkokbe]k_ql])oa_kikolnej_leko(]o _]qo]oa_kj`e ao`k_kjda_eiajpkmqalnapaj`]oann]_ekj]haran`]`aenk7_ki]kne) cai(]bkni]ak_kjpa`k`kor]hknaope_ko(lkhpe_ko(nahecekoko(]npope_koa_qhpqn]eo7 _ki]_kilnaajok`]o_]qo]oa`]obkni]o`]ehqoka`klna_kj_aepkjklh]jkej`ere) `q]ha_khaperk7_kikolnej_leko(]o_]qo]oa_kj`e ao`]opn]jobkni] aodeop ne_]o `ko_kj_aepko(`]oe`ae]o(`kor]hknaoa`]olnpe_]odqi]j]o* Lkneook(]behkokbe]rkhp])oal]n]kaopq`k`]orne]obkni]o`a_kjda_eiajpk$lan) _alk( ei]cej]k( iai ne]( hejcq]cai( ejpahecj_e]( atlanej_e]( nabhatk% a `ko rneko pelko `a ]pere`]`aoejpaneknaoa_kilknp]iajpkoatpanjko`kooanaodqi]jko _kikatlnaoo ao`]rkjp]`a(`k`aoafka`]ol]et ao(lnk_qn]j`k`ao_naran]obkni]o ako_kjpa`ko`aoo]obkni]o`a_kjda_eiajpka`aooaopelko`a]pere`]`aa_kilknp]) iajpk_kiknah]k`koandqi]jk_kikiqj`k(_kjoeckiaoika_kikokqpnko* L]n] na]hev]n oaq pn]^]hdk( ] behkokbe] ejraopec] a ejpanlnap] k oecjebe_]`k `a e`ae]o can]eo_kik6na]he`]`a(iqj`k(j]pqnav](_qhpqn](deop ne](ran`]`a(b]hoe`]`a(dqi]je) `]`a(pailkn]he`]`a(aol]_e]he`]`a(mq]he`]`a(mq]jpe`]`a(oq^fapere`]`a(k^fapere`]`a( `ebanaj](nalapek(oaiahd]j](_kjbhepk(_kjpn]`ek(iq`]j](ja_aooe`]`a(lkooe^ehe) `]`a(lnk^]^ehe`]`a(ap_* =]pere`]`abehko be_](lknp]jpk(qi]^kifpb$`]o_kj`e aoalnej_leko`ko]^an a`]]k(eopk(`ko_kjda_eiajpko(`]_ej_e](`]nahecek(`]]npa(`]ikn]h(`]lkhpe_] a `] deop ne]%( qi] obcibul $rkhp] `k lajo]iajpk ok^na oe iaoik l]n] _kjda_an)oa _kik_]l]_e`]`al]n]k_kjda_eiajpk(]hejcq]cai(koajpeiajpka]]k%aqi]`o* qf`^$]r]he]kn]_ekj]hl]n]`eo_anjenajpna]ran`]`aa]ehqok(]he^an`]`aa]oanre`k( ejraopec]j`k]o_]qo]oa_kj`e ao`]oehqo aoa`kolna_kj_aepkoej`ere`q]eoa_khape) rko(`]oehqo aoa`koajc]jko`]opakne]oalnpe_]o_eajpbe_]o(lkhpe_]oa]npope_]o(`ko lna_kj_aepko nahecekoko a ok_e]eo( `] lnaoaj] a `ebqok `a bkni]o `a enn]_ekj]he`]`a _kjpnne]o]katan__ek`klajo]iajpk(`]hejcq]caia`]he^an`]`a%* Aoo]opno]pere`]`ao$^kifpb(obcibula`oqf`^%aopkkneajp]`]olah]ah]^kn]kbe) hko be_]`ae`ae]ocan]eook^na]na]he`]`aakooanaodqi]jko*Lknp]jpk(l]n]mqaaoo]o pno]pere`]`aooana]hevai(lna_eokmqa]behkokbe]oa`abej]_kik^qo_]`kbqj`]iajpk $lnej_leko(_]qo]oa_kj`e ao%a`koajpe`k$oecjebe_]kabej]he`]`a%`]na]he`]`aai oq]oihpelh]obkni]o(ej`]c]j`kkmqaaoo]obkni]o`ana]he`]`aok(_kikokalkn mqaok(alnk_qn]j`k]o_]qo]omqa]ob]vaiateopen(lani]ja_an(iq`]na`ao]l]na_an* =behkokbe]jk_ej_e]6qi]nabhatkok^nakobqj`]iajpko`]_ej_e](eopk( ok^na lnk_a`eiajpko a _kj_aepko _eajpbe_ko* Jk nahecek6 qi] nabhatk ok^na ko bqj`]iajpko`]nahecek(eopk(ok^na]o_]qo]o(knecajoabkni]o`]o_naj]onaheceko]o* Jk]npa6qi]nabhatkok^nakobqj`]iajpko`]]npa(eopk(ok^nako_kjpa`ko(]o bkni]o(]ooecjebe_] ao`]ok^n]o`a]npaa`kpn]^]hdk]npope_k*Jkok_ekhkce]jai loe_khkce](i]o]ejpanlnap]ka]r]he]k_npe_]`ko_kj_aepkoaipk`ko`]ok_ekhk) ce]a`]loe_khkce]*Jklkhpe_](i]oejpanlnap]k(_kilnaajokanabhatkok^na] knecai(]j]pqnav]a]obkni]o`klk`anaoq]oiq`]j]o*Jkdeop ne](i]onabhatk ok^nakoajpe`k`ko]_kjpa_eiajpkoajmq]jpkejoane`kojkpailka_kilnaajok`k mqaoaf]kln lnekpailk* Kbeh okbk]haikEii]jqahG]jp_kjoe`ankqmqa]oej`]c] aobqj`]iajp]eo`]behk) okbe]ok6 Nrbmlabjlpp^_bon]oehnalq^he_]jk* Jkajp]jpk(jko_qhkTT(]iaoi]]beni]k`]deopkne_e`]`a`kooanaodqi]jko(`] n]vka`]ok_ea`]`aharkqe`ae]`amqa]deop ne]`ao_kjpjq]ajklnkcnaooer](_]`] ok_ea`]`apaioq]deop ne]ln lne]airav`aoan]laj]oqi]ap]l]jqi]deop ne]qjerano]h `]o_erehev] ao* =e`ae]`alnkcnaookl]ookq]oan_nepe_]`]lknmqaoanra_kik`ao_qhl]l]n]hacepei]n _khkje]heoiko a eilane]heoiko $ko i]eoÎ]`e]jp]`koÏ pane]i k `enaepk `a `kiej]n ko i]eo Î]pn]o]`koÏ%*L]ookq]oan_nepe_]`]p]i^i]e`ae]`alnkcnaook`]o_ej_e]oa`]op_je_]o( ikopn]j`k)oamqa(ai_]`]lk_]deop ne_]al]n]_]`]ok_ea`]`a(ko_kjda_eiajpkoa]oln) pe_]olkooqaioajpe`kar]hknln lneko(amqap]hoajpe`kap]hr]hkn`ao]l]na_aijqi]lk_] oacqejpakqok`ebanajpaojqi]kqpn]ok_ea`]`a(jkd]raj`k(lknp]jpk(pn]jobkni]k_kj) pjq](]_qiqh]per]alnkcnaooer]`]dqi]je`]`a*
3CIENCEß0HOTOß,IBRARY,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßx=behkokbe]
!UGUSTEß#OMTEßß ¯
Jko_qhkTET(ajpqoe]oi]`]_ki]o_ej_e]oa]op_je_]o(^ai_kik_ki]Oacqj`] NarkhqkEj`qopne]h(]behkokbe]]beni]r]]_kjbe]j]lhaj]apkp]hjko]^an_eajpbe_kaj] pa_jkhkce]l]n]`kiej]na_kjpnkh]n]j]pqnav](]ok_ea`]`aakoej`er`qko* =_na`ep]r])oamqa]ok_ekhkce](lknatailhk(jkokbana_ane]qio]^anoacqnka`abejepe) rkok^nakik`k`abqj_ekj]iajpk`]ook_ea`]`aoamqakooanaodqi]jkolk`ane]iknc]) jev]nn]_ekj]hiajpakok_e]h(arep]j`knarkhq ao(narkhp]oa`aoecq]h`]`ao* =_na`ep]r])oa(p]i^i(mqa]loe_khkce]ajoej]ne]`abejeper]iajpa_kikbqj_ekj]]loemqa dqi]j](mq]eo]o_]qo]o`ko_kilknp]iajpkoakoiaeko`a_kjpnkh)hko(mq]eo]o_]qo]o`]o aik aoakoiaeko`a_kjpnkh)h]o(`ap]hik`kmqaoane]lkoorahhern]n)jko`]o]jcope]o(`k ia`k(`]hkq_qn](]ooei_kikoane]lkoorahqi]la`]ckce]^]oa]`]jko_kjda_eiajpko_eajp) be_koamqalaniepene]jko ]`]lp]nlanbaep]iajpa]o_ne]j]ooatecj_e]o`]ok_ea`]`a(_kik p]i^ia`q_)h]ooacqj`koq]ork_] aoalkpaj_e]he`]`aoloe_kh ce_]o* Jkajp]jpk(jko_qhkTT(]behkokbe]l]ookq]`ao_kjbe]n`kkpeieoik_eajpbe_k)pa_) jkh ce_k`ko_qhk]jpaneknairenpq`a`arneko]_kjpa_eiajpko6]o`q]ocqann]oiqj`e]eo( k^ki^]n`aek`aDenkodei]aJ]c]o]ge(ko_]ilko`a_kj_ajpn]kj]veop]oaaop]hejeop]o( ]ocqann]o`]?knae](`kReapj(`kKneajpaI`ek(`k=bac]jeopk(]oejr]o aonqoo]o`]Dqj) cne]a`]P_da_kohkrmqe](]o`ep]`qn]oo]jcnajp]o`]=ine_]H]pej]a`]ãbne_](]`ar]o) p]k`ai]nao(bhknaop]oapann]o(]lkhqek`k]n(kolanecko_]j_ancajko`a]heiajpkoa nai`eko(k]qiajpk`a`eopn^ekoaokbneiajpkoiajp]eo(kolnk^hai]ope_koalkhpe_ko oqnce`ko_kik`aoajrkhreiajpk`]cajpe_]a`]ajcajd]ne]cajpe_]$]ejoaiej]k]npe) be_e]h(]_hkj]cai(]]hpan]k`]aopnqpqn]`alh]jp]oa]jei]eo%ap_* =hi`eook(]o_ej_e]oa]op_je_]obkn]iej_knlkn]`]o]cn]j`ao_kilhatkoej`qopne]eoa iehep]nao(mqabej]j_e]i]olaomqeo]oa`abejaikmqa`araoanlaomqeo]`ka_kikoankqpehev]) `kokonaoqhp]`ko*K_d]i]`kÎ_kilhatkej`qopne]h)iehep]nÏ`]ocn]j`aolkpj_e]oa_kjie_]o lkooqelk`an`are`]aiknpaok^naklh]jap](jkaopoq^iape`k]ckranjkojai]]ook_e] ao l^he_]o(i]oklan]oa_nap]iajpa(oacqj`koaqoln lnekoejpanaooao(`aoaj_]`a]j`kcqann]o( `ep]`qn]o(rekhj_e]oaipk`]l]npa(mq]j`keook_kjriooq]obej]he`]`ao* Qi]ao_kh]]hai`abehkokbe](]Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnp(ah]^knkqqi]_kj_alk_kjda) _e`]_kikPakne]?npe_](j]mq]h`eopejcqa`q]obkni]o`]n]vk6^o^wlfkpqorjbkq^ia^ o^wl`oqf`^*
(ULTON $EUTSCHß#OLLECTIONß #ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
=o_e j_e]oa]op_je_]o
%SCOLAßDEß&RANKFURTß3EDEß DOß)NSTITUTOßDEß0ESQUISAß 3OCIAL ßQUEßABRIGAVAßUMß GRUPOßDEßPENSADORESßß ALEMjESßMARXISTASß NAßDmCADAßDEß ß RESPONSfVEISßPELAß FORMULAljOßDAß4EORIAß #RqTICA
20
=ola_pko`]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
=n]vkejopnqiajp]h]n]vkp_je_k)_eajpbe_](mqab]v`]o_ej_e]oa`]op_je_]ojk qiiaek`ahe^an]k`kooanaodqi]jko(i]oqiiaek`aejpeie`]k(ia`k(pannkna`aoao) lank*=k_kjpnnek(]n]vk_npe_]]mqah]mqa]j]heo]aejpanlnap]koheiepaoakolanecko`k lajo]iajpkejopnqiajp]ha]beni]mqa]oiq`]j]ook_e]eo(lkhpe_]oa_qhpqn]eoo oana]hev]) nkran`]`aen]iajpaoaperanai_kikbej]he`]`a]ai]j_el]k`kcjankdqi]jkajk]o e`ae]o`a_kjpnkhaa`kijekp_je_k)_eajpbe_kok^na]j]pqnav](]ok_ea`]`aa]_qhpqn]*
Koe`a]eolkhpe_konarkhq_ekjneko
4HEß-UNCHß-USEUM4HEß-UNCH %LLINGSENß'ROUP!RTISTSß2IGHTSßSOCIETYß!23 ß.EWßYORK
Jko_qhkTET(ai`a_knnj_e]`kkpeieoikpn]ve`klah]oe`ae]o`alnkcnaook(`aoajrkh) reiajpkp_je_k)_eajpbe_k(lk`anekdqi]jkl]n]_kjopnqenqi]re`]fqop]abahev(]behkokbe] ]lkopkqjkoe`a]eolkhpe_konarkhq_ekjnekoÍ]j]nmqeoik(ok_e]heoik(_kiqjeoikÍmqa _ne]ne]i(cn]]o]klkhpe_]_kjo_eajpa`koatlhkn]`koaklneie`ko(qi]ok_ea`]`ajkr]( fqop]abahev* Jkajp]jpk(jko_qhkTT(_kikoqnceiajpk`]o_d]i]`]ook_ea`]`aopkp]hepne]okq `konaceiaopkp]hepnekoÍb]o_eoik(j]veoik(op]hejeoik(i]koikÍa_kik]qiajpk`k lk`an`]ook_ea`]`ao]qpknepne]okq`ep]pkne]eo$_kik]o`]=ine_]H]pej](`]oBehelej]oa `]ãbne_]`kOqh%(]behkokbe]p]i^il]ookq]`ao_kjbe]n`kkpeieoiknarkhq_ekjneka`]o qpkle]oa]ej`]c]noakooanaodqi]jko(koatlhkn]`koako`kiej]`ko(oane]i_]l]vao`a _ne]nai]jpanqi]ok_ea`]`ajkr](fqop]abahev* K_nao_eiajpk`]o_d]i]`]o^qnk_n]_e]oÍmqa`kiej]i]oknc]jev] aoaop]p]eo(ai) lnao]ne]eo(lkhpe_k)l]npe`ne]o(ao_kh]nao(dkolep]h]naoÍharkq]behkokbe]]ej`]c]n_kikko oanaodqi]jkolk`ane]i`annq^]naooaeiajoklk`anekmqakockranj]oa_nap]iajpa(mqa ahao`ao_kjda_aiamqa`apaniej]oq]re`]_kpe`e]j](`ao`akj]o_eiajpk]p]iknpa*
21
KCnepk$-45/%( mq]`nk`aA`q]n` Iqj_d$-42/Ì-500%* Jko_qhkTET( ]_na`ep]r])oamqa] loe_khkce]atlhe_]ne] kbqj_ekj]iajpk`] loemqadqi]j](`a ik`k]hern]n)jko`]o ]jcope]o(`kia`ka `]hkq_qn]*
x5.)$!$%ßx=behkokbe]
=_qhpqn] Jko_qhkTET(]behkokbe]`ao_k^na]_qhpqn]_kikkik`kln lnekaaola_be_k`]ateopj) _e]`kooanaodqi]jko*Ko]jei]eookoanaoj]pqn]eo7kodqi]jko(oanao_qhpqn]eo*=j]pqnav] ckranj]`]lknhaeoja_aoone]o`a_]qo]aabaepk7]_qhpqn]katan__ek`]he^an`]`a* =_qhpqn]]_ne]k_khaper]`ae`ae]o(oi^khkoar]hknaolahkomq]eoqi]ok_ea`]`a `abejal]n]oeiaoi]k^kiaki]q(k^ahkakbaek(kfqopkakejfqopk(kran`]`aenkakb]hok( klqnkakeilqnk(klkoorahakeilkoorah(kejareprahak_]oq]h(ko]cn]`kaklnkb]jk( kaol]kakpailk*=_qhpqn]oana]hev]lknmqakodqi]jkook_]l]vao`ahejcq]cai(pn]) ^]hdk a nah]k _ki k pailk* = _qhpqn] oa i]jebaop] _kik re`] ok_e]h( _kik _ne]k `]o k^n]o`alajo]iajpka`a]npa(_kikre`]naheceko]are`]lkhpe_]* L]n] ] behkokbe] `k o_qhk TET( ai _kjokj j_e] _ki oq] e`ae] `a lnkcnaook `] dq) i]je`]`aa`aqi]deop ne]qjerano]h`]o_erehev] ao(d]rane]qi]je_]cn]j`a_qhpqn]ai `aoajrkhreiajpkkqailnkcnaook(`]mq]h]o`ebanajpao_qhpqn]ooane]ib]oaokqap]l]o* L]n]kqpnko(_d]i]`ko`abeh okbkonki jpe_kokq]`alpko`]behkokbe]`knki]jpeoik( ]o_qhpqn]ojkbkni]r]iqi]oamqj_e]qjerano]hlnkcnaooer](i]oan]i_qhpqn]ol]npe) _qh]nao(eopk(j]_ekj]eo*=ooei(_]^e]behkokbe]_kjda_ankÎaolnepk`aqilkrkÏ_kjda) _aj`k]oknecajoa]on]vao`a_]`]_qhpqn](lkeo(l]n]aooaobeh okbko(ki]eoeilknp]jpa`a qi]_qhpqn]jkoaaj_kjpn]ne]aioaqbqpqnk$jkoaqlnkcnaook%(i]ojkoaql]oo]`k(eopk (j]opn]`e ao(jkbkh_hknaj]_ekj]h* Jkajp]jpk(jko_qhkTT(]behkokbe](]beni]j`kmqa]deop ne]`ao_kjpjq](p]i^i ]beni]mqajkd^`riqro^(i]o`riqro^p`ebanajpao(amqa]lhqn]he`]`a`a_qhpqn]oa]o`e) banaj]oajpnaah]ojkoa`araij]k(lkeo]e`ae]`aj]kqi]_ne]k_qhpqn]hajk ]_]qo]`]o`ebanaj]o_qhpqn]eo*Kqoaf](]j]kjk_]qo]`]`ebanaj]_qhpqn]h(lknmqa] ln lne]e`ae]`aj]kqi]ejrajk_qhpqn]h`aqi]_qhpqn]`apaniej]`]$jk_]ok(ejraj) kbaep]lah]o_qhpqn]obn]j_ao]a]hai`ko_qhkTET%* ?]`]_qhpqn]ejrajp]oaqik`k`anah]_ekj]n)oa_kikpailk(`a_ne]noq]hejcq]cai( `aah]^kn]noaqoiepkoaoq]o_naj]o(`aknc]jev]nkpn]^]hdka]onah] aook_e]eo(`a_ne]n ]ok^n]o`alajo]iajpka`a]npa*?]`]qi](ai`a_knnj_e]`]o_kj`e aodeop ne_]o(cak) cnbe_]oalkhpe_]oaimqaoabkni](paioaqik`kln lnek`aknc]jev]nklk`ana]]qpkne) `]`a(`alnk`qvenoaqor]hknao*
!NTONIOß2IBEIRO%DITORAß!BRIL
æj`ekU]jki]ie _kikbehdkjk_khk( `aep]`kjqi]na`a( `ajpnk`]i]hk_](j] nacek`knek@aieje( aiNkn]ei]*
22
=ola_pko`]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
?kjpn]]behkokbe]`]_qhpqn]qjerano]h(]behkokbe]`ko_qhkTTjackqmqadkqraooaqi] je_]_qhpqn]ailnkcnaooka]benikq]ateopj_e]`]lhqn]he`]`a_qhpqn]h*?kjpn]]behkokbe] nki jpe_]`]o_qhpqn]oj]_ekj]eo_kikatlnaook`kÎaolnepk`klkrkÏa`k_kjfqjpk`a pn]`e ao(]behkokbe]`ko_qhkTTjackqmqa]j]_ekj]he`]`abkooa_]qo]`]o_qhpqn]o$]oj]) _ekj]he`]`aookabaepko_qhpqn]eopailknneko%a]benikqmqa_]`]_qhpqn]oanah]_ekj]_ki kqpn]oaaj_kjpn]`ajpnk`aoeoaqoik`ko`apn]jobkni]k*@aoo]i]jaen](klnaoajpaaop rkhp]`kl]n]kbqpqnk(ajkl]n]k_kjoanr]`kneoik`kl]oo]`k*
0HILIPPEß(ALSMAN-AGNUMß0HOTOS,ATINSTOCK
Kbei`]behkokbe]
"ERTRANDß2USSELßß ¯
Jko_qhkTET(kkpeieoik_eajpbe_kap_je_kharkq]behkokbe]]oqlknmqa(jkbqpqnk( o d]rane]_ej_e]o(amqapk`koko_kjda_eiajpkoapk`]o]oatlhe_] aooane]i`]`kolkn ah]o*=ooei(]ln lne]behkokbe]lk`ane]`ao]l]na_an(jkpaj`kikperkl]n]ateopen* Jk ajp]jpk( jk o_qhk TT( ] behkokbe] l]ookq ] ikopn]n mqa ]o _ej_e]o jk lkooqai lnej_leko pkp]hiajpa _anpko( oacqnko a necknkoko l]n] ]o ejraopec] ao( mqa ko naoqhp]`ko lk`aioan`qre`kokoalna_neko(amqa(bnamqajpaiajpa(qi]_ej_e]`ao_kjda_a]pkj`a lk`aenamq]j`kaopajpn]j`kjk_]ilk`aejraopec]k`aqi]kqpn]* Kolnej_leko(koipk`ko(ko_kj_aepkoakonaoqhp]`ko`aqi]_ej_e]lk`aiaop]npk) p]hiajpaamqerk_]`kokq`aolnkre`ko`abqj`]iajpk*?kieook(]behkokbe]rkhpkq]]beni]n oaql]lah`a_kilnaajokaejpanlnap]k_npe_]`]o_ej_e]o(`eo_qpej`k]r]he`]`a`aoaqo lnej_leko(lnk_a`eiajpko`alaomqeo](naoqhp]`ko(`aoq]obkni]o`aatlkoek`ko`]`ko a`]o_kj_hqo aoap_* Bkn]ilnak_ql] ao_ki]b]hp]`aneckn`]o_ej_e]omqahar]n]ikbeh okbk]haik Dqooanh]lnklknmqa]behkokbe]bkooakaopq`kak_kjda_eiajpknecknkok`]lkooe^ehe`]`a `kln lnek_kjda_eiajpk_eajpbe_k(at]iej]j`kkobqj`]iajpko(koipk`koakonaoqh) p]`ko`]o_ej_e]o*Bkn]ip]i^ilnak_ql] ao_kikaoo]omqahar]n]ibeh okbko_kik >anpn]j`NqooahhaMqeja]aopq`]n]hejcq]cai_eajpbe_](]`eo_qpenkolnk^hai]oh ce_ko `]o_ej_e]oa]ikopn]nkol]n]`ktkoakoheiepao`k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpbe_k*
=i]ekne`]`a`]n]vk
23
Jko_qhkTET(kkpeieoikbehko be_khar]r]]behkokbe]]]beni]nmqa(ajbei(kooanaodq) i]jkod]re]ioqlh]jp]`k]oqlanopek(]oatlhe_] aoice_]oab]jpope_]o`]na]he`]`aa ]h_]j]`k]i]ekne`]`an]_ekj]h*=_na`ep]r]p]i^imqa]n]vkoa`aoajrkhre]lhaj]iajpa l]n]mqak_kjda_eiajpk_kilhapk`]na]he`]`aa`]o] aodqi]j]obkooa]pejce`k* Jkajp]jpk(I]nt(jkbej]h`ko_qhkTET(aBnaq`(jkej_ek`ko_qhkTT(lqoan]iai mqaopkaooakpeieoikn]_ekj]heop]*I]ntaBnaq`(_]`]mq]haioaq_]ilk`aejraopec]k a_]`]mq]hrkhp]`kl]n]`ebanajpao]ola_pko`]]kdqi]j]ÍI]nt(rkhp]`kl]n]]a_kjk) ie]a]lkhpe_]7Bnaq`(rkhp]`kl]n]]olanpqn^] aoakookbneiajpkolomqe_koÍ(bevan]i `ao_k^anp]omqa(]pdkfa(_kjpejq]ieilkj`kmqaop aobehko be_]o*Mqa`ao_k^nen]iahao; I]nt`ao_k^neqmqapaiko]ehqok`aaop]nikolajo]j`k_kijkoo]ln lne]_]^a]a ]cej`klknjkoo]ln lne]rkjp]`a`ai]jaen]n]_ekj]haherna(`a]_kn`k_kijkookajpaj) `eiajpkajkoo]he^an`]`a(lknmqa`ao_kjda_aiko]o_kj`e aoa_kjie_]oaok_e]eoj]o mq]eo]_h]ooaok_e]hmqa`kiej]]ok_ea`]`aatan_aoaqlk`anok^na]iajpa`apk`ko(b]) vaj`k_kimqaoq]oe`ae]ol]na]ioanran`]`aoqjerano]eo(rhe`]ol]n]pk`kokoiai^nko `]ok_ea`]`aal]n]pk`]o]o_h]ooaook_e]eo*Aooalk`anok_e]hejreorahmqajkobkn]]lajo]n _kiklajo]ikoa]cen_kik]ceikobke_d]i]`klknaha`ae`akhkce]* Bnaq`(lknoq]rav(ikopnkqmqakooanaodqi]jkopi]ehqok`amqapq`kmq]jpk lajo]i(b]vai(oajpaia`aoaf]i(pq`kmq]jpk`evaikq_]h]iaop]ne]ok^klhajk_kjpnk) ha`ajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]lknmqa`ao_kjda_aiko]ateopj_e]`aqi]bkn]ejreorah(`aqi lk`anÍmqalomqe_kaok_e]hÍmqa]pq]ok^najkoo]_kjo_ej_e]oaimqaah]ko]e^]*= aooalk`anmqa`kiej]a_kjpnkh]ejreorahalnkbqj`]iajpajkoo]re`]_kjo_eajpaaha`aq kjkia`aej_kjo_eajpa*
$AVIDß3EYMOUR-AGNUMß0HOTOS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßx=behkokbe]
@e]jpa `aoo]o `q]o `ao_k^anp]o( ] behkokbe] oa req bkn]`] ] na]^nen ] `eo_qook ok^na k mqa a k mqa lk`a ] n]vk( ok^na k mqa a k mqa lk`a ] _kjo_ej_e]nabhater]kqkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiaj) pk(ok^nakmqaokakmqalk`ai]o]l]nj_e]oa ]oehqo ao* =kiaoikpailk(]behkokbe]para`ana]^nen]o `eo_qoo aope_]oaikn]eo6ÎKdkiaina]hiajpa herna kq ejpaen]iajpa _kj`e_ekj]`k lah] oq] oe) pq]klomqe_]adeop ne_];Ï7ÎOabknejpaen]iajpa _kj`e_ekj]`k(ajpk]deop ne]a]_qhpqn]ok_]q) o]he`]`ao ja_aoone]o _kik ] j]pqnav];Ï* Kq oane] i]eo _knnapk ej`]c]n6 Î?kik ko oanao dqi]jko _kjmqeop]i ] he^an`]`a ai iaek ] pk`ko ko _kj) `e_ekj]iajpko lomqe_ko( deop ne_ko( a_kjie_ko( _qhpqn]eoaimqarerai;Ï*
Ejbejepkabejepk Ko_qhkTETlnkooacqeqqi]pn]`ekbehko be) _]mqaraek`ao`a]=jpecqe`]`aamqabkeiqepk]he) iajp]`]lahklajo]iajpk_neopk*Jaoo]pn]`ek( k i]eo eilknp]jpa oailna bke ] e`ae] `k ejbejepk( eopk(]j]pqnav]apanj]$`kocnacko%(k@aqoapanjk $`ko_neopko%(k`aoajrkhreiajpklhajkapkp]h`] deop ne]kq`kpailk_kikpkp]hev]k`apk`koko oaqoikiajpkokqoq]oap]l]o$_kikj]behkokbe] `aDacah(lknatailhk%*Lnar]ha_e]]e`ae]`apk`k kq`apkp]he`]`a(`]mq]hkodqi]jkob]vail]npa al]npe_el]i* Jk ajp]jpk( ] behkokbe] `k o_qhk TT paj`aq ] `]ni]ekneilknp j_e]]kbejepk(eopk(]kmqaoqnca a `ao]l]na_a( ]k mqa pai bnkjpaen]o a heiepao* Aooa Pn]^]hd]`knaobn]j_aoao_kiaikn]i ejpanaooalahkbejepk]l]na_aq(lknatailhk(jqi] ]lnkr]k`]fknj]`]oai]j]h`a _knnajpabehko be_]$ajpnako]jko-5/,a-51,%_d]) 0,dkn]oabne]onaiqjan]`]o(ai-5/2( j]oeia`e] ao`aL]neo* i]`]ateopaj_e]heoik(mqa`abejeqkdqi]jkkqk dkiai_kikÎqioanl]n]]iknpaÏ(kqoaf](qioan mqao]^amqapailkn]hamqapaniej]amqalna_eo] aj_kjpn]naioeiaoikkoajpe`k`aoq]ateopj_e]* L]n]]i]ekne]`koateopaj_e]heop]o(`keoan]ikoik`kolnerehace]`ko`akdkiai]_ae) p]naajbnajp]noq]bejepq`a6lkniaek`]o]npaoalkniaek`]]klkhpe_k)narkhq_ekjne]* Jaoo]obkni]oat_al_ekj]eo`]]pere`]`a(kodqi]jkooane]i_]l]vao`a`]noajpe`k^na) re`]`aabejepq`a`aoq]re`]* Qikqpnkatailhk`kejpanaooalah]bejepq`a]l]na_aqjkmqaoa_kopqi]_d]i]n`a cfilplcf^a^afcbobk ^(eopk(j]mqah]behkokbe]mqaoaejpanaoo]iajkolah]ooaiahd]j]oa e`ajpe`]`aoaiqepki]eolah]oejcqh]ne`]`aal]npe_qh]ne`]`a* ]ooei(lknatailhk(mqap]hbehkokbe](ejolen]j`k)oajkopn]^]hdko`ko]jpnkl hkcko( ejpanaookq)oalah]`eranoe`]`a(lhqn]he`]`a(oejcqh]ne`]`a`]o`ebanajpao_qhpqn]o(aihqc]n `arkhp]n)oal]n]]e`ae]`aqi]_qhpqn]qjerano]h(mqabke(jko_qhkTET(qi]`]oei]cajo `kejbejepk(eopk(`aqi]pkp]he`]`amqa_kjpane]`ajpnk`aoe(_kikoq]ol]npaokqoaqo ikiajpko(]o`ebanajpao_qhpqn]ooejcqh]nao* Ajbei(qikqpnkatailhk`aejpanaooalah]bejepq`a]l]na_aqmq]j`k]behkokbe](ai rav`a^qo_]nqi]_ej_e]qjerano]hmqa_kjpane]`ajpnk`aoepk`]o]o_ej_e]ol]npe_qh]nao( ejpanaookq)oa lah] iqhpelhe_e`]`a a lah] `ebanaj] ajpna ]o _ej_e]o( lahko heiepao `a _]`] qi]`ah]oaok^napq`klknoaqoeil]ooaoalnk^hai]oejokhraeo*
24
=ola_pko`]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
Jkooko`e]o6]lo)ik`anje`]`a @ao`aia]`ko`ko]jko-52,(oqnca]e`ae]`amqa]ik`anje`]`apaniejkqamqaoa eje_ekq ] l o)ik`anje`]`a* @ev)oa mqa ] ik`anje`]`a _knnaolkj`a lk_] `] ok_ea`]`a ej`qopne]h$]mqah]aimqaklk`ana_kjie_kalkhpe_klanpaj_aocn]j`aoej`opne]oaai mqaoaatlhkn]kpn]^]hdklnk`qperk%(ajmq]jpk]l o)ik`anje`]`a_knnaolkj`aok_ea`]`a l o)ej`qopne]h$]mqah]aimqaklk`ana_kjie_kalkhpe_klanpaj_a]k_]lep]hbej]j_aenka ]koapkn`aoanreko`]ona`aoahapnje_]o`a]qpki]kaejbkni]k%* Kmqaan]]ik`anje`]`a;An]k_kjfqjpk`ae`ae]oa`ar]hknaomqad]re]ijknpa]`k ]behkokbe]a]o_ej_e]o`ao`akbej]h`ko_qhkTREEE]pko]jko-52,amqalk`aiko^nara) iajpanaoqienjkooacqejpao]ola_pko6 -*
Jk_]ilk`k_kjda_eiajpk6
n]_ekj]heoik6_kjbe]j]jklk`an`]n]vk$oaf]_kikn]vkejopnqiajp]h(oaf]_kik n]vk_npe_]%l]n]`eopejcqenajpna]l]nj_e]ana]he`]`aal]n]_kjda_anapn]jobkni]n ] na]he`]`a* K n]_ekj]heoik `abejen] _nepneko mqa laniepe]i `eopejcqen ajpna n]vk a hkq_qn](oanal]na_ankqna]he`]`aa]l]nj_e](_kjda_eiajpkaehqok(ran`]`aae`ak) hkce](a]ooacqn]r]]r]he`]`a`k_kjda_eiajpkbehko be_ka_eajpbe_k7 `eopejk ajpna ejpanekn a atpanekn kq ajpna oqfaepk a k^fapk6 _kjbe]j] ai _nepneko a lnk_a`eiajpkomqalaniepe]i`eopejcqen_h]n]iajpaajpnakoqfaepkkq]_kjo_ej_e] $kejpanekn%akk^fapkkq]o_keo]o$katpanekn%(`ai]jaen]]]ooacqn]n]oq^fapere`]`a $eopk(klajo]iajpk_kioaqolnej_lekoahaeoqjerano]eoa_kioaqolnk_a`eiajpko pa ne_koln lneko%_kikbqj`]iajpkja_aoonek`k_kjda_eiajpkkq_kik_kj`ek ja_aoone]`]k^fapere`]`a_kikbkni]`k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk7 ]beni]k `] _]l]_e`]`a `] n]vk dqi]j] l]n] _kjda_an ] aooj_e] kq ] aopnqpqn] ejpanj]`apk`kokooanao(`abejej`k]o_]qo]oa_kj`e aolah]omq]eo`apaniej]`] ]e`ajpe`]`a`a_]`]_keo]aoq]na]he`]`a(`aikjopn]j`k]onah] aoja_aoone]omqa _]`]qi]`ah]oi]jpi_kikqpn]o`amqa`alaj`aikqmqa`ah]o`alaj`aiakbana) _aj`k]ohaeoja_aoone]o`aiq`]j]kq]hpan]k`apk`]o]o_keo]o*
+EVINß7INTER)MAGE&ORUM'ETTYß)MAGESSTF
Krk_]heop]`]^]j`] Q.(>kjkRkt(ai odksjkaop`ekNkoa >ksh(jkoAop]`ko Qje`ko(pn]joiepe`k ]krerklahkUkqPq^a l]n]-5l]oao* Bkeklneiaenkodks `aoo]i]cjepq`a pn]joiepe`k]krerk l]n]rnekol]oao( ]h_]j]j`kqi] ]q`ej_e]na_kn`a*
25
x5.)$!$%ßx=behkokbe]
.* Jk_]ilk`]lnpe_]6 ]beni]k`]`ebanaj]ajpna]ja_aooe`]`amqanaca]kn`aij]pqn]hkq]ohaeo`]j]) pqnav]a]kn`aidqi]j]`]_qhpqn]$pe_](lkhpe_](]npao%(lkeojaop]]onacn]oajkn) i]o`alaj`ai`]]ka_kjie_](ok_e]halkhpe_]`koln lnekodkiajo*=ej`]mqa] kn`aiok_e]halkhpe_]]pqaok^nakoej`er`qko_kikoaperaooa]iaoi]ja_aooe`]`a mqa]kn`aij]pqn]h(ah]lk`aoaniq`]`]apn]jobkni]`]lahkooanaodqi]jko(kmqa lnkr]mqaah]qi]ejopepqekdqi]j]adeop ne_]7 ]beni]k`amqakooanaodqi]jkookej`er`qkoa]cajpaohernaolknmqaokoanaon]_ek) j]eo`kp]`ko`arkjp]`a(_]l]vao`a_kjpnkh]naik`an]noq]ol]et aoaoaqo`aoafkoamqa ao_khdailknoeiaoiko]o] aomqaln]pe_]i(oaj`klkneooknaolkjoraeolknah]o7 `eopejkajpnakl^he_kaklner]`k6aop]^aha_eiajpk`a_nepnekomqalaniepe]i`eo) pejcqenajpna]aoban]l^he_]kqlkhpe_]$kqk_]ilk`]oejopepqe aook_e]eoa`alk) `an%a]aoban]lner]`]`]ikn]hej`ere`q]h$]pe_]%a`]a_kjkie]`aian_]`k$]lnk) lnea`]`alner]`]`koiaeko`alnk`qk%7 ]beni]k`koe`a]eo`]NarkhqkBn]j_ao]Íecq]h`]`a(he^an`]`aabn]panje`]`aÍ(na) _kjda_eiajpk`aqi]aoban]`a`enaepko_ereoÍk_]ilk`]_e`]`]je]Ía]ilhe]k`ao) oaoe`a]eolah]]beni]k`a`enaepkook_e]eo(mqa`an]iknecai]koikreiajpkook_e]eo`a hqp]_kjpn]kn]_eoik(]kikreiajpkbaiejeop]a]koikreiajpko`ahe^an]koatq]h7 ]beni]k`aqioajpe`klnkcnaooerk`]deop ne]kq`ae`a]eonarkhq_ekjneko`aai]j) _el]k`kcjankdqi]jk(_kihqp]ook_e]eoalkhpe_]o_kjpn]]klnaooka]atlhkn]) ka_kjie_](ok_e]h(lkhpe_]a_qhpqn]h* Klajo]iajpkl o)ik`anjk_nepe_]]oe`ae]oik`anj]oa]ona_qo]* ?kjoe`an]ejbqj`]`]oaehqo ne]o]olnapajo ao`]n]vkjk_kjda_eiajpkaj]lnpe_]( mq]j`kjkqi`eob]n_al]n]katan__ek`]`kiej]kok^nakodkiajo* Fqhc]mqak_kjda_eiajpkjkoa`abejalknlnk_a`eiajpko]npe_qh]`ko`eopejkajpna] ran`]`aa]b]hoe`]`aaoeilahko_nepneko`]qpehe`]`aa`]abe__e]6qi_kjda_eiajpk$behko be_k( _eajpbe_k(]npope_k%rhe`koabknpeh$oaoanrenl]n]]hcqi]_keo]]mqea]ckn]%kqoabknabe_]v l]n]]k^pajk`abejo`aoaf]`kolknmqai_kjda_a(jkeilknp]j`kmqabejooaf]i* ?kjoe`an]ejbqj`]`]]`eopejkajpnaoqfaepkak^fapk(lkeop]jpk]obehkokbe]o_kik]o_ej) _e]ook_kjopnq aooq^faper]o`aoaqok^fapko(komq]eoo ateopai_kiknaoqhp]`k`]oklan] ao pa ne_]oap_je_]o*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(k_kjda_eiajpkjkreo]]qi]na]he`]`aateopajpaaioe iaoi]aoeiejrajkkq_kjopnqk`ak^fapkopa ne_koap_je_ko*Jk_]ok`]behkokbe](aoo] _ne]kbaep]lkniaek`]hejcq]cai(]mq]h(_kikj]hepan]pqn](jk`evkmqa]o_keo]ookaoei _ne]_keo]o]kb]h]n`ah]o*Jk_]ok`]o_ej_e]o(aoo]_ne]kbaep]lkniaek`alnk_a`eiajpko`a h]^kn]p nek(jkmq]hko_eajpeop]ojkk^oanr]ina]he`]`ao(i]o]o_kjopnkai* Jk]`iepa]`eopejkajpnakn`aij]pqn]hja_aoone]akn`aideop ne_]kq_qhpqn]h ejopepq`]lahkodkiajo6]i^]ookejraj aokqejopepqe aodqi]j]o(_kjpejcajpao(ab) ian]o(l]oo]caen]o* Jk]`iepa]`abejek`koandqi]jk_kik]jei]hn]_ekj]h`kp]`k`arkjp]`aherna( i]ok_kj_a^a_kikqioanl]ooekj]h(`aoaf]jpa(mqa]caikre`klkneilqhokoaejopejpko( ai^kn](]kiaoikpailk(ejopepq]qi]kn`aiok_e]hmqanalneiaoaqo`aoafkoal]et ao* =pe_](lknp]jpk(jkoa`abejalah]]kn]_ekj]hrkhqjpne]hernamqa^qo_]]]k^k]kq renpqko](i]ooa`abejalah]^qo_]`]o]peob]k`ko`aoafko(o]peob]kmqa`abeja]bahe_e`]) `aaaop]oana]hev]j]aoban]`]ejpeie`]`aej`ere`q]h* @ao_kjbe]`]lkhpe_]6]`aik_n]_e]can]]]l]pe]_nao_ajpa`ko_e`]`ko7kok_e]heoika k_kiqjeoik`aoai^k_]iainaceiaoaok_ea`]`aopkp]hepne]o*Lkneook`ao_kjbe]`]`eo) pejkajpnakl^he_kaklner]`ka`eilknp j_e]aoban]`]ejpeie`]`aej`ere`q]h* @eilknp j_e]e`ae]`aafcbobk ^(kqoaf](aihqc]n`apki]n]ok_ea`]`a_kikqi] aopnqpqn]mqaklan]lah]`ereokok_e]h`]o_h]ooao$_]`]qi]`]omq]eo_kiqi]na]he`]`a aqi]e`ajpe`]`a`abeje`]olah]a_kjkie]alah]lkhpe_]a_kjpnne]oqi]ookqpn]okqai
3,
=ola_pko`]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
hqp]_kjpjq]%(_kj_a^akok_e]h_kikqi]pae]bn]ciajp]`]`acnqlkomqaoa`ebanaj_e]i lknapje](cjank(nahecek(_kopqiao(_kilknp]iajpko(ckopkoalnabanj_e]o*
Pai]o(`eo_elhej]oa_]ilkobehkobe_ko
= "ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
behkokbe]ateopad.2o_qhko*@qn]jpaqi]deop ne]pkhkjc]a`ap]jpkolank`ko`e) banajpao(oqncen]ipai]o(`eo_elhej]oa_]ilko`aejraopec]kbehko be_koajmq]jpk kqpnko`ao]l]na_an]i*@ao]l]na_aqp]i^i]e`ae]`a=neop pahao`amqa]behkokbe] an]]pkp]he`]`a`ko_kjda_eiajpkopa ne_koalnpe_ko`]dqi]je`]`a* P]i^i`ao]l]na_aqqi]ei]cai(mqa`qnkqiqepkoo_qhko(j]mq]h]behkokbe]an] nalnaoajp]`]_kikqi]cn]j`anrknabnkj`ko](_qf]on]vaoan]i]iap]boe_]a]pakhkce]( _qfkpnkj_kan]]h ce_](_qfkon]ikolnej_el]eoan]i]behkokbe]`]j]pqnav](]pe_]a]lkh) pe_](a_qfkoc]hdkoatpnaikoan]i]op_je_]o(]o]npaoa]oejraj ao*=behkokbe](reop]_kik qi]pkp]he`]`aknc je_]kqrer](an]_d]i]`]`aÎn]ejd]`]o_ej_e]oÏ*Eook`ao]l]na_aq* Lkq_k]lkq_k(]orne]o_ej_e]ol]npe_qh]naobkn]i`abejej`koaqok^faperko(oaqoipk`ko aoaqonaoqhp]`koln lneko(aoa`aohec]n]i`]cn]j`anrkna*?]`]_ej_e](]koa`aohec]n(harkq _kjoeckko_kjda_eiajpkolnpe_kokq]lhe_]`ko`aoaq_]ilk`aejraopec]k(eopk(]o]npao a]op_je_]o]ah]hec]`]o*=ohpei]o_ej_e]o]]l]na_ana]oa`aohec]n`]nrkna`]behkokbe] bkn]i]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o$loe_khkce](ok_ekhkce](]jpnklkhkce](deop ne](hejcqope_](cakcn]be] ap_*%*Kqpnko_]ilko`a_kjda_eiajpka`a]k]^nen]i)oal]n]]behkokbe](i]o]e`ae]`aqi] pkp]he`]`a`ao]^anaomqa_kjpane]aioepk`koko_kjda_eiajpkojqj_]i]eona]l]na_aq* Jko_qhkTT(]behkokbe]bkeoq^iape`]]qi]cn]j`aheiep]kmq]jpkaoban]`aoaqo _kjda_eiajpko*Eooklk`aoan]pne^q`k]`keoikperkolnej_el]eo6
)MMANUELß+ANTßß ¯
ßEPISTEMOLOGIAßEPISTEME ß EMßGREGO ßQUERßDIZERßß ±CIoNCIA²
3-
-*
@ao`akbej]h`ko_qhkTREEE(_kikbeh okbk]haikEii]jqahG]jp(l]ookq)oa]_kj) oe`an]nmqa]behkokbe](`qn]jpapk`kokoo_qhko]jpaneknao(peran]qi]lnapajokenna]) hevrah*Mqalnapajokbkn]aoo];=`amqajkoo]n]vklk`a_kjda_an]o_keo]op]eo_kik okaioeiaoi]o*Aooa_kjda_eiajpk`]na]he`]`aaioe(`kolneiaenkolnej_lekoa`]o lneiaen]o_]qo]o`apk`]o]o_keo]o_d]i])oaiap]boe_]* G]jpjackqmqa]n]vkdqi]j]peraooap]hlk`an`a_kjda_eiajpka]benikqmqa o _kjda_aiko]o_keo]op]eo_kikokknc]jev]`]olah]aopnqpqn]ejpanj]aqjerano]h `ajkoo]n]vk(i]ojqj_]o]^anaikooap]hknc]jev]k_knnaolkj`akqjkknc]je) v]k ai oe `] ln lne] na]he`]`a* @aet]j`k `a oan iap]boe_]( ] behkokbe] oa pknjkq k _kjda_eiajpk`]o_kj`e ao`alkooe^ehe`]`a`k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenkajmq]jpk _kjda_eiajpklkoorahl]n]kooanaodqi]jkon]_ekj]eo* = behkokbe] pknjkq)oa qi] pakne] `k _kjda_eiajpk( kq qi] pakne] ok^na ] _]l]) _e`]`aa]lkooe^ehe`]`adqi]j]o`a_kjda_an(aqi]pe_](kqaopq`k`]o_kj`e ao `alkooe^ehe`]`a`]]kikn]hajmq]jpkna]hev]`]lknhe^an`]`aalkn`aran*?kieo) ok( ] behkokbe] `aet]r] `a oan _kjda_eiajpk `k iqj`k ai oe a pknj]r])oa ]laj]o _k) jda_eiajpk`kdkiai_kikoann]_ekj]haikn]h*
.* @ao`aia]`ko`ko_qhkTET(_kik_kjoamqj_e]`]behkokbe]`a=qcqopk?kipaÍ_d]) i]`]lkoepereoikÍ(bkebaep]qi]oal]n]kajpnabehkokbe]a_ej_e]olkoeper]o$i]pai) pe_](boe_](mqie_](^ekhkce](]opnkjkie](ok_ekhkce]%*=o_ej_e]o(`eve]?kipa(aopq`]i] na]he`]`aj]pqn]h(ok_e]h(loe_kh ce_]aikn]haoklnklne]iajpak_kjda_eiajpk*L]n] aha(]behkokbe]oane]]laj]oqi]nabhatkok^nakoecjebe_]`k`kpn]^]hdk_eajpbe_k(eopk ( qi] ]jheoa a qi] ejpanlnap]k `ko lnk_a`eiajpko kq `]o iapk`khkce]o qo]`]o lah]o_ej_e]oaqi]]r]he]k`konaoqhp]`ko_eajpbe_ko*=behkokbe]pknjkq)oa(]ooei( qi]pakne]`]o_ej_e]okqaleopaikhkce]*=behkokbe]na`qveq)oa(lknp]jpk(pakne]`k _kjda_eiajpk(pe_]aaleopaikhkce]*?kik_kjoamqj_e]`aoo]na`qk(kobeh ok) bkol]oo]n]i]panqiejpanaooalneikn`e]hlahk_kjda_eiajpk`]oaopnqpqn]oabkni]o `ajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]ap]i^ilahkoaqik`k`aatlnaook(eopk(]hejcq]cai*
Mq]eookko_]ilkoln lnekoaimqaoa`aoajrkhra]nabhatkbehko be_]jaopao.2o) _qhko;Okahao6 Kjpkhkce]kqiap]boe_]6_kjda_eiajpk`kolnej_lekoabqj`]iajpkohpeiko`apk`] ]na]he`]`a(`apk`kokooanao* Hce_]6_kjda_eiajpk`]obkni]oanacn]ocan]eo`klajo]iajpk_knnapkaran`]`aenk( ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`ko_kjpa`kolajo]`ko7nacn]oa_nepnekomqa`apaniej]i]bkni] `ko `eo_qnoko kq `ko ]ncqiajpko p]jpk l]n] ] `aikjopn]k _eajpbe_] ran`]`aen] _kik l]n]ko`eo_qnokojk_eajpbe_ko7nacn]ol]n]]ranebe_]k`]ran`]`akqb]hoe`]`a`aqi lajo]iajpkkq`aqi`eo_qnokap_* Aleopaikhkce]6]jheoa_npe_]`]o_ej_e]o(p]jpk]o_ej_e]oat]p]okqi]paipe_]omq]j) pk]oj]pqn]eoa]odqi]j]o7]r]he]k`koipk`koa`konaoqhp]`ko`]o_ej_e]o7_kil]pe^ehe) `]`aoaej_kil]pe^ehe`]`aoajpna]o_ej_e]o(bkni]o`anah] aoajpna]o_ej_e]oap_*
!LBUMßAKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
-ARTINß(EIDEGGERßß ¯
#qRCULOßDEß6IENAßß ASSOCIAljOßFUNDADAßNAß DmCADAßDEßßPORßß FILvSOFOSßQUEßTINHAMßPORß OBJETIVOßAßUNIFICAljOßDOß SABERßCIENTqFICOß.AßFOTO ß -ORITZß3CHLICK ßUMßDOSß FUNDADORESßDOßGRUPO
-ARTINEß&RANCK-AGNUMß0HOTOS,ATINSTOCK
Kejpanaooalah]_kjo_ej_e]nabhater]kqlahkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk`aqoqnceiaj) pk]qi]_knnajpabehko be_]_kjda_e`]_kikcbkljbklildf^(eje_e]`]lahkbeh okbk]haik A`iqj`Dqooanh*Fkejpanaooalah]obkni]oalahkoik`ko`abqj_ekj]iajpk`]hejcq]cai _knnaolkj`a]qi]_knnajpabehko be_]_kjda_e`]_kikcfilplcf^^k^iqf`^(_qfkej_ek]pne) ^q`k]kbeh okbk]qopn]_kHq`secSeppcajopaej* Jkajp]jpk(]]pere`]`abehko be_]jkoanaopnejceqpakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(h ce_]( aleopaikhkce]ape_]*@ao`akej_ek`ko_qhkTT(]deop ne]`]behkokbe]pknjkq)oaqi] `eo_elhej]`acn]j`alnaopceka(_kiah](]deop ne]`]oe`ae]oa]deop ne]`]o_ej_e]o* @ao`a]Oacqj`]Cqann]Iqj`e]h(_kikbajiajk`kpkp]hep]neoikÍb]o_eoik(j]) veoik(op]hejeoikÍ7_ki]ocqann]o`ahe^anp]kj]_ekj]h_kjpn]koeilneko_khkje]eoa]o narkhq aook_e]heop]oairnekol]oao7`ao`ako]jko-52,(_ki]ohqp]o_kjpn]`ep]`qn]oa _kikoikreiajpkolkn`enaepko$`kojacnko(j`eko(iqhdanao(e`koko(dkikooatq]eo(hkq) _ko(_ne]j]oakoat_hq`koa_kjie_]alkhepe_]iajpa%7a`ao`ako]jko-53,(_ki]hqp] lah] `aik_n]_e] ai l]oao oq^iape`ko ] naceiao ]qpknepneko( qi cn]j`a ejpanaooa lah] cfilplcf^mliqf`^naooqnceqa(_kiaha(]o_npe_]o`ae`akhkce]oaqi]jkr]`eo_qookok^na]o nah] aoajpna]pe_]a]lkhpe_](]hi`]o`eo_qoo aoaipknjk`]cfilplcf^a^efpqof^* Bej]hiajpa(`ao`akbej]h`ko_qhkTT(kl o)ik`anjeoikraic]jd]j`knahar j_e]* Oaq]hrklnej_el]h(_kikreikodlkq_k(]_npe_]`apk`koko_kj_aepkoar]hknaomqa(]p dkfa(oqopajp]n]i]behkokbe]aklajo]iajpk`epkk_e`ajp]h6n]vk(o]^an(oqfaepk(k^fapk(deo) p ne](aol]k(pailk(he^an`]`a(ja_aooe`]`a(]_]ok(j]pqnav](dkiaiap_* Reikomqakkpeieoikn]_ekj]heop]`]ik`anje`]`abke_kjop]p]`kjk`a_knnan`ko) _qhkTT6]_npe_]`]oe`akhkce]o(]`ao_k^anp]bnaq`e]j]`kej_kjo_eajpa(]_npe_]`]deop ne]( `]qje`]`a`]_qhpqn]kq`aoq]lhqn]he`]`aj]_ekj]h(`ko^ajab_eko`]o_ej_e]oa`]op_) je_]obkn]i_kjpaop]j`kkor]hknaoae`ae]oik`anjko* Fjkej_ek`ko]jko.,(_ki]ok^n]o`kobeh okbkoSeppcajopaejaDae`accan(]e`ae] `] iap]boe_] _kik _kjda_eiajpk `] na]he`]`a hpei] `ko oanao bke _kjpaop]`] a ]_]^kq _a`aj`khqc]n]kl]lah`]hejcq]caij]ejrajk`koln lnekooanaoa`kok^fapko`a_k) jda_eiajpk* P]i^i(ajpnako]jko-5-1a-52,(_ki]obehkokbe]o`aDqooanha`aIanha]q)Lkjpu( oqnceq]e`ae]`amqa]_kj_alkik`anj]`an]vkan]ejoqbe_eajpal]n]`]n_kjp]`apk`k klajo]iajpkdqi]jk(`]oatlanej_e]oarerj_e]o_knlkn]eo(`]hejcq]caia`]o]npao* @]iaoi]i]jaen](kobeh okbko`k_d]i]`k?n_qhk`aReaj]]beni]n]i(jkej_ek`ko) _qhkTT(koheiepao`]behkokbe]a`]o_ej_e]ol]n]_kjda_an]oln lne]o_keo]oa_kjoe`an]n]i ]_ej_e]]laj]oÎqi]hejcq]cai^aibaep]Ï* Ajpnako]jko-52,a-54,(]k^n]`kbeh okbkbn]j_oIe_dahBkq_]qhpatlnaoo]r]pk`]o ]o_npe_]omqako_qhkTTrejd]b]vaj`k]kn]_ekj]heoikik`anjk(oq]_kj_alk`aia) p]boe_](deop ne](_ej_e]a_qhpqn]* ?kieook(lk`aiko`evanmqakl o)ik`anjeoikraekoaj`kcaop]`kjkejpanekn`]be) hkokbe] ]p k ikiajpk ai mqa( jko ]jko -52,( l`a bej]hiajpa atlnaoo]n)oa _kik qi] lkoekbehko be_]*
!LBUMAKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßx=behkokbe]
-ICHELß&OUCAULTßß ¯
3.
=ola_pko`]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
Pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpkkqaopq`k`]o`ebanajpaoik`]he`]`ao`a_kjda_eiajpkdq) i]jk6k_kjda_eiajpkoajokne]hkqoajo]kalan_alk7]iai ne]a]ei]cej]k7k_k) jda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]h7]e`ae]`aran`]`aab]hoe`]`a7]e`ae]`aehqokana]he`]`a7bkni]o `a _kjda_an k aol]k a k pailk7 bkni]o `a _kjda_an nah] ao7 _kjda_eiajpk ejcjqk a _kjda_eiajpk_eajpbe_k7`ebanaj]ajpna_kjda_eiajpk_eajpbe_kabehko be_kap_* pe_]6aopq`k`kor]hknaoikn]eo$]orenpq`ao%(`]nah]kajpnarkjp]`aal]etk(rkjp]) `aan]vk7bej]he`]`aoar]hknao`]]kikn]h7e`ae]o`ahe^an`]`a(naolkjo]^ehe`]`a(`aran( k^nec]kap_* Behkokbe]lkhpe_]6aopq`kok^na]j]pqnav]`klk`ana`]]qpkne`]`a7e`ae]`a`enaepk( hae(fqope](`kiej]k(rekhj_e]7bkni]o`konaceiaolkhpe_koaoq]obqj`]iajp] ao7j]o) _eiajpkabkni]o`kAop]`k7e`ae]o]qpknepne]o(_kjoanr]`kn]o(narkhq_ekjne]oahe^anpne]o7 pakne]o`]narkhqka`]nabkni]7]jheoaa_npe_]`]oe`akhkce]o* Behkokbe]`]deopne]6aopq`kok^na]`eiajokpailkn]h`]ateopj_e]dqi]j]_kikateo) pj_e]ok_eklkhpe_]a_qhpqn]h7pakne]o`klnkcnaook(`]arkhqkapakne]o`]`ao_kjpejqe`]`a deop ne_]7oecjebe_]`k`]o`ebanaj]o_qhpqn]eoadeop ne_]o(oq]on]v aoa_kjoamqj_e]o* Behkokbe]`]]npakqaop pe_]6aopq`k`]obkni]o`a]npa(`kpn]^]hdk]npope_k7e`ae]`a k^n]`a]npaa`a_ne]k7nah]kajpnai]pne]abkni]j]o]npao7nah]kajpna]npaaok_ea) `]`a(]npaalkhpe_](]npaape_]* Behkokbe]`]hejcq]cai6]hejcq]cai_kiki]jebaop]k`]dqi]je`]`a`kdkiai7 oecjko(oecjebe_] ao7]_kiqje_]k7l]oo]cai`]hejcq]caikn]hao_nep](`]hejcq]cai _kpe`e]j]behko be_](hepanne](_eajpbe_]7`ebanajpaoik`]he`]`ao`ahejcq]cai_kik`e) banajpaobkni]o`aatlnaooka`a_kiqje_]k* Deopne]`]behkokbe]6aopq`k`ko`ebanajpaolank`ko`]behkokbe]7`acnqlko`abeh ok) bkooacqj`kkopai]oalnk^hai]omqa]^kn`]i7`anah] aoajpnaklajo]iajpkbehko be_k a ]o _kj`e ao a_kjie_]o( lkhpe_]o( ok_e]eo a _qhpqn]eo `a qi] ok_ea`]`a7 iq`]j]o kq pn]jobkni] ao`a_kj_aepkobehko be_koai`ebanajpaolk_]o7iq`]j]oj]_kj_alk`k mqaoaf]]behkokbe]a`aoaql]lahkqbej]he`]`a*
3/
x5.)$!$%ßx=behkokbe] GLOSSfRIO
15%34¬%3
#!0É45,/ß =knecai`]ÚhkokÚ] -* Mqamqan`evanldehkokld];=mqaioa]pne^qe]ej) rajk`aoo]l]h]rn]; .* KmqaLepckn]omqane]`evan]koanabanen olaook]o mqa_kil]na_e]i]koFkckoKhile_ko; /* Kmqaikraq]hcqjocnacko ÚhkokÚ]; 0* Ajqianakolnej_el]eopn]ko`]ÚhkokÚ]j]o_ajpa* 1* Mqa]paj`j_e] n]_ekj]he`]`a; 2* Mqaojpaoa;A]jheoa; 3* Mq]h]jkk`a_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenkpn]ve`] lah]ÚhkokÚ]j]o_ajpa; 4* MqaoecjeÚ_]]Úni]nmqa]n]vkaklajo]iajpkkla) n]ik^a`a_aj`k]haeo(lnej_lekoanacn]oqjerano]eo; 5* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnak]_]okj]j]pqnav]aklko) orahj]o] aodqi]j]o; -,* L]n]]]kdqi]j](mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaja_aooe) `]`a(_kjpejcj_e]alkoorah; --* Naoqi]kolnej_el]eohac]`ko`]ÚhkokÚ]cnac]l]n] klajo]iajpkk_e`ajp]h*
#!0É45,/ß Kj]o_eiajpk`]ÚhkokÚ] -* Mqalancqjp]oÚvan]ikolneiaenkoÚh okbkocnacko; .* Kmqa`eve]iko`abajoknao`]Îpaoakneajp]heop]Ïok) ^na]knecai`]ÚhkokÚ]; /* Kmqa`eve]iko`abajoknao`]paoa`kÎieh]cnacna) ckÏok^na]knecai`]ÚhkokÚ]; 0* Kmqad`aran`]`aenkj]opaoaokneajp]heop]a`kie) h]cnacnack; 1* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqakocnackoejrajp]n]i]_ej) _e](]lkhpe_]a]e`ae]`an]vk; 2* Kmqakiepk;Lknmqaiana_e]_kjÚ]j]aan]ej) mqaopekjrah; 3* Mq]eo]oi]jaen]olah]omq]eokiepkj]nn]]knecai `]o_keo]o; 4* Mqa atlhe_] ao bkn]i `]`]o ok^na ] _kjpejq]k kqnqlpqn]`]ÚhkokÚ]_kinah]k _koikckje]a
pakckje];Mq]h]atlhe_]kdkfa]_aep]; 5* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo`ebanaj]oajpnaÚhkokÚ]aiepk; -,* Mq]eo]o_kj`e aodeop ne_]omqalnkle_e]n]ikoqn) ceiajpk`]ÚhkokÚ]j]Cn_e]; --* Lknmqa]ejrajk`]lkhpe_]bke`a_eoer]l]n]kj]o) _eiajpk`]ÚhkokÚ];
#!0É45,/ß ?]ilko`aejraopec]k`]ÚhkokÚ] -* Mq]eokolnej_el]eolank`ko`]ÚhkokÚ]cnac]; .* Mq]eokolnej_el]eopn]ko`]_koikhkce]ln)ok_npe) _];Ao_khd]qi`ahaoakatlhemqa* /* Mqagjaoeokqk`aren;Lknmqaaoo]e`ae]_ajpn]h jklajo]iajpkln)ok_npe_k; 0* Mq]h ] iq`]j] j] a`q_]k `ko fkrajo cnacko j] l]oo]cai`]]neopk_n]_e]l]n]]`aik_n]_e]; 1* Mq]eo]o_kjoamqj_e]ol]n]]ÚhkokÚ]`]iq`]j] j]a`q_]k`kofkrajocnacko; 2* Mqaajoej]r]ikookÚop]o; 3* Mqalnklqjd]O _n]pao_kjpn]kookÚop]o; 4* ?kikLh]pk`ao_naraO _n]pao; 5* K mqa O _n]pao lnapaj`e] ]k ^qo_]n ] aooj_e] a k _kj_aepk; -,* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaklejeka_kj_aepk; --* Lknmqa=paj]o_kj`ajkqO _n]pao iknpa; -.* Lkn mqa ]o lnej_el]eo _]n]_panope_]o `] ÚhkokÚ] jk lank`kok_npe_kej`e_]imqa]lnej_el]hlnak_ql]) kÚhko Ú_]_kikdkiai; -/* Atlhemqa ] `ebanaj] ajpnak oajorah a k ejpahecrah aop]^aha_e`]lknLh]pk* -0* ?ki^]oaj]]Úni]k`a=neop pahao`amqa]Úhk) okÚ]]pkp]he`]`a`apk`]o]o_ej_e]oapki]j`k] `eopejkajpna_kjpailh]ka]k(atlkjd]^nara) iajpa]_h]ooeÚ_]k]neopkphe_]`]o_ej_e]o* -1* Atlkjd]]_h]ooeÚ_]k]neopkphe_]`]o_ej_e]opak) npe_]okq_kjpailh]per]o* -2* Mqamqan`evaniap]boe_]; -3* L]npej`k`a=neop pahao(mq]eookkopnocn]j`ao_]i) lko`]ejraopec]kÚhko Ú_]; -4* Mqamqan`evankjpkhkce];
#!0É45,/ß Lnej_el]eolank`ko`]deopne]`]ÚhkokÚ] -* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]ÚhkokÚ]aopj]deop ne]a paiqi]deop ne]; .* Mqae`ae]ojkr]o]l]pnope_]ejpnk`qveqj]ÚhkokÚ] cnac];Lknmqaok`kci]o; /* Mq]h]`eopejkajpna]oran`]`aoejpnk`qve`]olah] l]pnope_]; 0* Mq]eo]olkoe ao`koÚh okbko_neopkook^na]onah]) aoajpnaban]vk; 1* Mq]eokocn]j`aopai]o`]ÚhkokÚ]ia`ear]h; 2* Kmqaan]klnej_lek`a]qpkne`]`a; ,
30
GLOSSfRIO
3* Naoqi]]opnocn]j`aohejd]o`]ÚhkokÚ]`]Naj]o) _aj] a atlhemqa lkn mqa atlneiai k dqi]jeoik naj]o_ajpeop]* 4* Lknmqa(jkej_ek`]ik`anje`]`a(recknkqk_ape) _eoik; 5* Atlhemqakmqabkekoqnceiajpk`koqfaepk`k_kjda) _eiajpkj]ÚhkokÚ]ik`anj]* -,* ?kikan]_kj_a^e`]]j]pqnav]j]ÚhkokÚ]ik`anj]; Lknmqaaoo]_kj_alkhar] oe`ae]o`aatlaneiaj) p]k_eajpÚ_]a`apa_jkhkce]; --* Lknmqalk`aiko_d]i]n]ÚhkokÚ]ik`anj]`an]) _ekj]heoik; -.* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo]Úni] ao`]ÚhkokÚ]`]oHqvao; -/* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaÚoek_n]p]oaian_]jpeheop]o;
#!0É45,/ß =ola_pko`]ÚhkokÚ]_kjpailkn ja] -* ?kikkoÚh okbko`ko_qhkTET$Dacaha?kipa%aj) paj`e]i]deop ne]; .* ?kikkoÚh okbko`ko_qhkTTl]oo]n]i]lajo]n] deop ne]; /* ?kik an] k kpeieoik `ko Úh okbko `k o_qhk TET _kinah]k o_ej_e]oa op_je_]o; 0* Lknmqajko_qhkTT`ao]l]na_aqkkpeieoik_ki nah]k o_ej_e]oa op_je_]o; 1* Atlhemqa ] `eopejk baep] lah] Ao_kh] `a Bn]jgbqnp ajpnan]vkejopnqiajp]han]vk_npe_]*
31
2* LknmqakoÚh okbko`ko_qhkTTjki]jperan]ik kpeieoik `k o_qhk TET _ki nah]k o narkhq ao ok_e]eoalkhpe_]o; 3* ?kik]ÚhkokÚ]`ko_qhkTET`aÚjeq]_qhpqn]; 4* Mq]h]_kj_alk`kolajo]`knaonkijpe_kook^na ]_qhpqn]; 5* ?kikkoÚh okbko`ko_qhkTT_kj_a^ai]_qhpqn]; -,* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnakoÚh okbko`ko_qhkTETa ko`ko_qhkTTmq]jpk]k`ao]l]na_eiajpk`]Úhk) okÚ]; --* Lknmqa]`ao_k^anp]`]e`akhkce](lknI]nt(a]`k ej_kjo_eajpa( lkn Bnaq`( mqaopekj]n]i k kpeieoik n]_ekj]heop]`ko_qhkTET; -.* =lnaoajpa]hcqjoatailhko`kejpanaooalahkÚjepk kqlah]Újepq`aj]oÚhkokÚ]o`ko_qhkTT* -/* Kmqa`aÚje]]ik`anje`]`ajk_]ilk`k_kjda_e) iajpk; -0* Kmqa`aÚje]]ik`anje`]`ajk_]ilk`]lnpe_]; -1* ?kikraekoaj`kcaop]`kkl o)ik`anjeoikjkej) panekn`]ik`anje`]`a; -2* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_npe_]ol o)ik`anj]o ik`an) je`]`a; -3* Mqaiq`]j]oÚhko Ú_]ok_knnan]i_ki]_npe_]`a G]jp iap]boe_]; -4* Lknmqa(_kiklkoepereoik`a=qcqopk?kipa(]Úhk) okÚ]oana`qve] aleopaikhkce]; -5* Mq]eoko_]ilkoln lneko`]ejraopec]kÚhko Ú_];
5NIDADEß
=n]vk ?]lpqhk-
=n]vk
?]lpqhk.
=]pere`]`an]_ekj]h
?]lpqhk/
=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`];
?]lpqhk0
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoik6okhq aobehko be_]o
?]lpqhk1
=n]vkj]behkokbe]_kjpailknja]
@ao`aoaqolnein`eko(]ÚhkokÚ]_kjoe`ankqmqa]n]vkklan]oacqej`k_anpko lnej_ lekomqaah]lnlne]aop]^aha_aamqaaopkai_kj_kn` j_e]_ki]lnlne] na]he`]`a(iaoikmq]j`kkoailnac]ikooai_kjda_ )hkoatlhe_ep]iajpa*Kq oaf](k_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]hk^a`a_a]_anp]onacn]okqhaeobqj`]iajp]eomqa naolaep]iko]p iaoikmq]j`kjk_kjda_aiko`enap]iajpamq]eookakmqa ok* Jo ]o naolaep]iko lknmqa okiko oanao n]_ekj]eo a lknmqa ok lnej_ leko mqac]n]jpaimqa]na]he`]`a n]_ekj]h*
I]n_]`klneiaenkl]ook`]`kaiokhkhqj]nlknJaeh=niopnkjc(ai.,`afqhdk`a-525(b]pkmqalk`aoan _kjoe`an]`kk le_a`]n]vkajpaj`e`]_kik`kijek`]op_je_]oa`]opa_jkhkce]o*
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
#APqTULOß =n]vk
Kornekooajpe`ko`]l]h]rn]n]vk
$IBNERß,IBRARYßOFßTHEß(ISTORYßOFßß 3CIENCEßANDß4ECHNOLOGYß 3MITHSONIANß)NSTITUTION
J
] l]npa ejpnk`qp ne] `aopa pn]^]hdk( ejoeopeiko j] ]Úni]k `a mqa ] ÚhkokÚ] oa na]hev]_kik_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]h`]na]he`]`aj]pqn]ha_qhpqn]h(`]o_keo]oa`ko oanaodqi]jko*@eooaikomqaah]_kjÚ]j]n]vkamqa(dkfa(ah]p]i^i`ao_kjÚ] `]n]vk*I]o(]p]ckn](jk`eooaikokmqa]n]vk(]lao]n`aoanah]pk]jpec]mq]jpk] ÚhkokÚ]* Ai jkoo] re`] _kpe`e]j] qo]iko ] l]h]rn] o^wl ai iqepko oajpe`ko* @evaiko( lkn atailhk(Îaqaopkq_ki]n]vkÏkqÎahajkpain]vkÏl]n]]Úni]nmqajkooajpeikooacq) nko`a]hcqi]_keo]kqmqao]^aiko_ki_anpav]]hcqi]_keo]*P]i^i`evaikomqa(jqi ikiajpk`abne]kq`a`aoaolank(Î]hcqilan`a]n]vkÏ(_kikoa]n]vkbkooa]hcqi] _keo]mqaoalk`apankqjkpan(lkooqenalan`an(kqna_qlan]n* B]h]ikop]i^ibn]oao_kikÎOark_ia`eooanoq]on]v ao(okq_]l]v`ab]vankmqa rk_iala`aÏ(mqanaj`k`evan_kieookmqamqanaikokqrenkoikperkomqa]hcqipai l]n]mqanankqb]van]hcqi]_keo]*B]vaikolancqjp]o_kikÎMq]h]n]vk`eook;Ï(mqanaj`k o]^anmq]h]_]qo]`a]hcqi]_keo]a(jaooa_]ok(]n]vkl]na_aoan]hcqi]lnklnea`]`amqa ]oln lne]o_keo]opane]i(fmqapane]iqi]_]qo]* =ooei(qo]ikoo^wll]n]jkonabaneniko]kojlqfslp`a]hcqiap]i^il]n]jko nabaneniko o `^rp^p `a ]hcqi] _keo]( `a ik`k mqa p]jpk j o _kik ]o _keo]o l]na_aiko `kp]`ko`an]vk(i]oaioajpe`k`ebanajpa* Aooao lkq_ko atailhko f jko ikopn]i mq]jpko oajpe`ko `ebanajpao ] l]h]rn] o^wl lkooqe6_anpav](hq_e`av(ikperk(_]qo]*Apk`koaooaooajpe`koaj_kjpn]i)oalnaoajpaomq]j) `k]ÚhkokÚ]b]h]j]n]vk* Lkne`ajpeÚ_]nn]vka_anpav](]ÚhkokÚ]]Úni]mqa]ran`]`an]_ekj]h7lkne`ajpeÚ_]n n]vkahq_e`av$jkÚ_]nkqjkaop]nhkq_k%(]ÚhkokÚ]_d]i]jkoo]n]vk`ahqvahqvj]) pqn]h$lkeo]l]h]rn]ir`fabwrai`ahqv%7lkne`ajpeÚ_]nn]vkaikperk(lkn_kjoe`an]nmqa oailna]ceikoab]h]ikoikre`kolknikperko(]ÚhkokÚ]]Úni]mqaokikooanaon]_ekj]eo amqajkoo]rkjp]`an]_ekj]h7lkne`ajpeÚ_]nn]vka_]qo]alknfqhc]nmqa]na]he`]`akla) n]`a]_kn`k_kinah] ao_]qo]eo(]ÚhkokÚ]]Úni]mqa]na]he`]`an]_ekj]h* iqepk_kjda_e`]]_ha^nabn]oa`kÚh okbkL]o_]h6ÎK_kn]kpain]v aomqa]n]vk `ao_kjda_aÏ*Jaoo]bn]oa(]ol]h]rn]oo^wbpao^wljkpikiaoikoecjeÚ_]`k(ej`e_]j`k _keo]o`erano]o*ÎN]v aoÏokkoikperko`k_kn]k(ajmq]jpkÎn]vkÏ]hck`ebanajpa`aÎ_k) n]kÏ7aopakjkiamqa`]ikol]n]]oaik aoal]et ao(ajmq]jpkÎn]vkÏkjkiamqa `]iko_kjo_ej_e]ejpaha_pq]haikn]h* =k `evan mqa k _kn]k pai oq]o ln lne]o n]v ao( L]o_]h aop ]Úni]j`k mqa ]o aik) ao(kooajpeiajpkokq]ol]et aookikperkoa_]qo]o`aiqepk`kmqab]vaiko(`evaiko( mqanaikoalajo]iko*=k`evanmqa]n]vk`ao_kjda_aÎ]on]v ao`k_kn]kÏ(L]o_]haop ]Úni]j`kmqa]_kjo_ej_e]ejpaha_pq]haikn]h`ebanajpa`]ol]et aoa`kooajpeiajpko amqaah]_]l]v`aqi]]pere`]`aln lne]jkikper]`]jai_]qo]`]lah]oaik ao(i]o mqalkooqeoaqoikperkoa_]qo]okqoq]oln lne]on]v ao*
0ASCALßFILvSOFOßFRANCoSßDOß SmCULOß86))
34
=n]vkx#!0É45,/ßx
=ooei(]bn]oa`aL]o_]hlk`aoanpn]`qve`]`]oacqejpai]jaen]6jkoo]re`]aik_ekj]h lkooqe_]qo]oaikperko$]oÎn]v ao`k_kn]kÏ%(mqaok]ol]et aokqkooajpeiajpko(a `ebanajpa`ajkoo]]pere`]`a_kjo_eajpa(`ajkoo]n]vk(oaf]_kik]pere`]`aejpaha_pq]h(oaf] _kik]pere`]`aikn]h* =_kjo_ej_e]]n]vk*?kn]kan]vk(l]etkkqoajpeiajpkoa_kjo_ej_e]ejpaha_) pq]hkqikn]hok`ebanajpao*Oa]hcqiÎlan`a]n]vkÏlknmqaaopoaj`k]nn]op]`klah]o În]v ao`k_kn]kÏ*Oa]hcqiÎna_qlan]]n]vkÏlknmqak_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]ha] _kjo_ej_e] ikn]h oa pknj]n]i i]eo bknpao `k mqa ]o l]et ao* = n]vk( _kik _kjo_ej_e] ikn]h(]rkjp]`an]_ekj]hhernamqajkoa`aet]`kiej]nlahkoeilqhokol]ooekj]eo(i]o na]hev]]o] aoikn]eo_kik]pko_knnapko(`ep]`kolah]ejpahecj_e]kqejpaha_pk* =hi`]bn]oa`aL]o_]h(p]i^ikqreikokqpn]omqaahkce]i]o_ej_e]o(`evaj`kmqa ah]o i]jebaop]i kÎlnkcnaook `] n]vkÏ* =mqe( ] n]vk _khk_]`] _kik _]l]_e`]`a lqn]) iajpaejpaha_pq]hl]n]_kjoacqenk_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk`]j]pqnav](`]ok_ea`]`a(`] deop ne](aeook_kjoe`an]`k]hck^ki(lkoeperk(qiÎlnkcnaookÏ* Lknoan_kjoe`an]`kqiÎlnkcnaookÏ(k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_kreopk_kikoana]he) v]j`kjkpailka_kik`kp]`k`a_kjpejqe`]`a(`ap]hik`kmqa]n]vk_kj_a^e`]_kik pailkn]hp]i^i(eopk(_kik_]l]v`a]qiajp]noaqo_kjpa`koaoq]o_]l]_e`]`ao]pn]) ro`kopailko* =hcqi]oravaokqreikoqilnkbaookn`evan]kqpnk6ÎBqh]jkpnkqtaqipn]^]hdkenn]) _ekj]h7an]qi_]ko(qi]_kjbqok*Ej_kilnaajorah*Fkpn]^]hdk`a^ahpn]jkan]qi]^a) hav]6_h]nk(_kilnaajorah(n]_ekj]hÏ*=mqe(]În]vkÏ(kqÎn]_ekj]hÏ(oecjeÚ_]_h]nav]`ae`ae]o( kn`ai( naoqhp]`k `a aobknk ejpaha_pq]h kq `] ejpahecj_e]( oacqej`k jkni]o a nacn]o `a lajo]iajpka`ahejcq]cai*=k_kjpnnek(Îenn]_ekj]hÏoecjeÚ_]_kjbqok(`aokn`aj]`k(oai oacqen]onacn]oajkni]o`klajo]iajpka`]hejcq]cai_knnapko* Pk`ko aooao oajpe`ko _kjopepqai ] jkoo] e`ae] `a n]vk* J o ] _kjoe`an]iko ] _kjo) _ej_e]ikn]hmqak^oanr]]ol]et ao(kneajp]]rkjp]`aakbana_aÚj]he`]`aope_]ol]n]] ]k*J o]raiko_kik]pere`]`aejpaha_pq]h`a_kjda_eiajpk`]na]he`]`aj]pqn]h(ok_e]h( loe_kh ce_](deop ne_]*J o]_kj_a^aikooacqj`kke`a]h`]_h]nav](`]kn`aj]ka`kneckn alna_eok`kolajo]iajpkoa`]ol]h]rn]o*ÎN]vkÏ`aoecj](lknp]jpk(]ohaeo`klajo]iajpk a]ohaeo`]]knaÛape`]* L]n]iqepkoÚh okbko(lkni(]n]vkjk]laj]o]_]l]_e`]`aikn]haejpaha_pq]h`ko oanaodqi]jko(i]op]i^iqi]lnklnea`]`akqmq]he`]`alneikn`e]h`]oln lne]o_keo]o( ateopej`kj]ln lne]na]he`]`a*L]n]aooaoÚh okbko(jkoo]n]vklk`a_kjda_an]na]he`]`a $j]pqnav](ok_ea`]`a(deop ne]%lknmqaaop]n]_ekj]haioeiaoi]*N]vk`aoecj](]ckn](] kn`aj]kja_aoone]`]oln lne]o_keo]o* B]h])oa(lknp]jpk(aio^wll_gbqfs^$]na]he`]`an]_ekj]haioeiaoi]%aaio^wlpr_* gbqfs^$]n]vkqi]_]l]_e`]`aejpaha_pq]haikn]h`kooanaodqi]jko%*=n]vkk^faper]] ]Úni]k`amqakl_gbqlal`lkeb`fjbkqlkq]na]he`]`an]_ekj]h7]n]vkoq^faper]]]Ún) i]k`amqakprgbfqlal`lkeb`fjbkqlba^^ ln]_ekj]h*L]n]iqepkoÚh okbko(]ÚhkokÚ] kikiajpk`kaj_kjpnk(`k]_kn`ka`]d]nikje]ajpna]o`q]on]v aokqn]_ekj]he`]`ao*
Knecai`]l]h]rn]n]vk
J 35
]_qhpqn]`]_d]i]`]ok_ea`]`ak_e`ajp]h(]l]h]rn]o^wlknecej])oa`a`q]obkjpao6 ]l]h]rn]h]pej]o^qfla]l]h]rn]cnac]idlp*Aoo]o`q]ol]h]rn]ookoq^op]jperko`a) ner]`ko`a`keoran^komqapiqioajpe`kiqepkl]na_e`kaih]peiaaicnack* Idlp rai `k ran^k ibdbfk( mqa mqan `evanÎ_kjp]nÏ(ÎnaqjenÏ(Îqjp]nÏ(Î_]h_qh]nÏ* O^qfl rai`kran^koblo(mqamqan`evanÎ_kjp]nÏ(ÎnaqjenÏ(Îia`enÏ(Îfqjp]nÏ(Îoal]n]nÏ(Î_]h_qh]nÏ* Mqab]vaikomq]j`kia`eiko(fqjp]iko(oal]n]iko(_kjp]ikoa_]h_qh]iko;Lajo]) iko`aik`kkn`aj]`k*Amqaiaekoqo]ikol]n]b]h]nok^naaoo]o] ao;Qo]ikol]h]rn]o $iaoikmq]j`kqo]ikojiankoaop]ikoqo]j`kl]h]rn]o(ok^napq`kkocnackoakonki]) jko(mqaqo]r]ihapn]ol]n]ej`e_]njianko%*
+IRSTYß0ARGETER'LOWß)MAGES)MAGEPLUS
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
Lkneook(idlp(o^qflkqo^wloecjeÚ_]i lajo]nab]h]nkn`aj]`]iajpa(_kiia`e`]a lnklknk(_ki_h]nav]a`aik`k_kilnaaj) orahl]n]kqpnko*=ooei(j]knecai(n]vk] _]l]_e`]`a ejpaha_pq]h l]n] lajo]n a atlne) ien)oa _knnap] a _h]n]iajpa( l]n] lajo]n a `evan]o_keo]op]eo_kikok*=n]vkqi] i]jaen] `a knc]jev]n ] na]he`]`a $ia`en( naqjen(fqjp]n(oal]n]n(_kjp]n(_]h_qh]n%lah] mq]haop]oapknj]_kilnaajorah*(p]i^i( ]_kjÚ]j]`amqalk`aikokn`aj]naknc]) jev]n]o_keo]olknmqaokknc]jevraeo(kn`a) jraeo(_kilnaajoraeojah]oiaoi]oalkn ah]oiaoi]o(eopk(]oln lne]o_keo]ookn]) _ekj]eokqaopkkn`aj]`]oaknc]jev]`]o(ao) pk]npe_qh]`]oa_kja_p]`]o(okoaiahd]j) pao kq `ebanajpao( lkooqai e`ajpe`]`a( ap_*( lk`aj`klkneookoannaqje`]okqoal]n]`]o( ia`e`]oa_]h_qh]`]o* @ao`ak_kiak`]ÚhkokÚ](]knecai`] l]h]rn]o^wlbav_kimqaah]bkooa_kjoe`an]) `]klkop]]mq]pnkkqpn]o]pepq`aoiajp]eo6 -*
]k_kjda_eiajpkehqo nek(eopk(]k_kjda_eiajpk`]ian]]l]nj_e]`]o_keo]omqa jk]h_]j]]na]he`]`akq]ran`]`a`ah]o7l]n]]n]vk(]ehqoklnkri`ajkooko_ko) pqiao(`ajkookolna_kj_aepko(`]]_aep]keia`e]p]`]o_keo]op]eo_kik]l]na_aia p]eo_kikl]na_aioan*=oehqo ao_ne]i]okleje aomqar]ne]i`alaook]l]n]laook]a `aok_ea`]`al]n]ok_ea`]`a*=n]vkoakl aian]klejek7
Ei]caie`a]hev]`] `k@J=dqi]jk*
.* oaik ao(]kooajpeiajpko(ol]et ao(mqaok_ac]o(_] pe_]o(`aokn`aj]`]o(_kjpn) ne]oqi]ookqpn]o(kn]`evaj`kÎoeiÏ]]hcqi]_keo](kn]`evaj`kÎjkÏ]aoo]iaoi] _keo](_kikoajkokq^ooaikokmqamqanaikoakmqa]o_keo]ook*=n]vkreop] _kik]pere`]`akq]k$ejpaha_pq]ha`]rkjp]`a%klkop]l]etk7 /*
_naj]naheceko](lkeo(jaop](]ran`]`ajko`]`]lah]bjqi]narah]k`erej](jk `alaj`aj`k `k pn]^]hdk `a _kjda_eiajpk na]hev]`k lah] jkoo] ejpahecj_e] kq lahk jkookejpaha_pk*=n]vkklkop]narah]kalkneookkoÚh okbko_neopko`eopejcqai ]hqvj]pqn]hÍ]n]vkÍ`]hqvok^naj]pqn]hÍ]narah]k7
0*
]ktp]oaiope_k$`koo]jpko(`kolnkbap]o%(jkmq]hkaolnepk]_na`ep]ajpn]nainah]) k`enap]_kikoan`erejkal]npe_el]n`aha(oaijajdqi]ejpanrajk`kejpaha_pk kq`]ejpahecj_e](jai`]rkjp]`a*Lahk_kjpnnek(ktp]oaiope_katecaqiaop]`k `a]^]j`kjk(`ankileiajpk_ki]]pere`]`aejpaha_pq]ha_ki]rkjp]`a(qinkile) iajpk_kikaop]`k_kjo_eajpa(]lan`]`]_kjo_ej_e]`]ln lne]ej`ere`q]he`]`al]n] ajpnac]n)oa]kckvkkq]kln]van`al]npe_el]n`koanejÚjepk(jqi_kjda_eiajpkmqa o lk`aoanoajpe`kajklk`aoanatlnaookailajo]iajpkoal]h]rn]o*
Kolnej_lekon]_ekj]eo
@
ao`aoaqolnei n`eko(]ÚhkokÚ]_kjoe`ankqmqa]n]vkklan]oacqej`k_anpkolnej) _lekomqaah]ln lne]aop]^aha_aamqaaopkai_kj_kn` j_e]_ki]ln lne]na]he) `]`a(iaoikmq]j`kkoailnac]ikooai_kjda_)hkoatlhe_ep]iajpa*Kqoaf](k _kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]hk^a`a_a]_anp]onacn]okqhaeobqj`]iajp]eomqanaolaep]iko]p
4,
=n]vkx#!0É45,/ßx
iaoikmq]j`kjk_kjda_aiko`enap]iajpamq]eookakmqaok*J o]onaolaep]ikolkn) mqaokikooanaon]_ekj]eoalknmqaoklnej_lekomqac]n]jpaimqa]na]he`]`an]_ekj]h* Mqalnej_lekookaopao;Okahao6 Lnej_lek`]e`ajpe`]`a(_qfkajqj_e]`klk`al]na_anoqnlnaaj`ajpa6Î>>ÏkqÎK mqa ( Ï* K lnej_lek `] e`ajpe`]`a ] _kj`ek `k lajo]iajpk a oai aha jk lk`aiko lajo]n*Aha]Úni]mqaqi]_keo](oaf]ah]mq]hbkn$qioan`]j]pqnav](qi]Úcqn]caki) pne_](qioandqi]jk(qi]k^n]`a]npa(qi]]k%(o lk`aoan_kjda_e`]alajo]`]oabkn lan_a^e`]a_kjoanr]`]_kioq]e`ajpe`]`a* Aooalnej_lek(_qfkajqj_e]`kl]na_a]^oqn`k$lkeo]_d]iko ^rekmqaqi]_keo]oaf] e`jpe_]]oeiaoi]%(qo]`klknjkoo]ok_ea`]`aoaimqalan_a^]iko*Kj`aqo]`k;J] _d]i]`]Î_]npaen]`ae`ajpe`]`aÏ$kjkookNC%_ki]mq]hoa]Úni]aoac]n]jpamqaÎ>>Ï* Klnej_lek`]e`ajpe`]`a]_kj`ekl]n]mqa`aÚj]iko]o_keo]oalkoo]iko_kjda) _)h]o]l]npen`aoq]o`aÚje ao*Lknatailhk(`alkeomqa]i]paipe_]`aÚjeqkpne jcqhk `apaniej]j`koq]e`ajpe`]`a_kikÚcqn]`apnoh]`koa`apno jcqhkoejpanjko_qf]oki] ecq]hoki]`a`keo jcqhkonapko(jajdqi]kqpn]Úcqn]]jkoanaoo]lk`anoan_d]i]) `]`apne jcqhk*Qi]ravaop]^aha_e`]]e`ajpe`]`a`kpne jcqhk(pk`kokopaknai]oalnk^ha) i]omqaki]paipe_k`aikjopn]nok^naaoo]Úcqn]o lk`ankoan`aikjopn]`kooa(]_]`] ravmqaaha`eooanÎpne jcqhkÏ(okq^aniko]mq]hoankq]mq]h_keo]ahaaopoanabanej`k* Lnej_lek`]jk_kjpn]`ek$p]i^i_kjda_e`k_kiklnej_lek`]_kjpn]`ek%( _qfkajqj_e]`kÎ>>aeilkoorahmqa(]kiaoikpailkaj]iaoi]nah]k(oaf]kl >Ï*=ooei(eilkoorahmqa]nrknamqaaop`e]jpa`aieioaf]ajkoaf](]kiaoikpai) lk(qi]i]jcqaen]7mqak_]_dknnejdk`a`kj]Behkiaj]oaf]ajkoaf](]kiaoikpailk( ^n]j_k7mqakpne jcqhkoaf]ajkoaf](]kiaoikpailk(]Úcqn]cakipne_]`apnoh]`koa pno jcqhko7mqakdkiaioaf]ajkoaf](]kiaoikpailk(iknp]h7mqakraniahdkoaf]a jkoaf](]kiaoikpailk(raniahdk(ap_* Oaiklnej_lek`]jk_kjpn]`ek(klnej_lek`]e`ajpe`]`ajklk`ane]bqj_ekj]n* Klnej_lek`]jk_kjpn]`ek]Úni]mqaqi]_keo]kqqi]e`ae]`]mq]h]hck]Úni]`k ajac]`k]kiaoikpailkaj]iaoi]nah]kok_keo]okqe`ae]omqaoajac]i]oeiao) i]oamqalkneookoa]qpk`aopnkai(`ao]l]na_ai(`aet]i`aateopen*Aeolknmqaklnej_lek ajqj_e] mqa eook eilkoorah( kq oaf]( ]Úni] mqa ]o _keo]o a ]o e`ae]o _kjpn]`ep ne]o ok eilajoraeoaeilkooraeo* Jkajqj_e]`k`aooalnej_lek`araikoaop]n]pajpkoo`q]o_kj`e aoj]omq]eod _kjpn]`ek*@ab]pk(klnej_lekajqj_e]mqaeilkoorah]Úni]najac]n]iaoi]_keo] `aqi]kqpn]^ljbpjlqbjmlbk^jbpj^obi^ l*Lknmqaaoo]o`q]o_kj`e ao;Lknmqa d_keo]omqalk`aiiq`]njk_knnan`aoq]oateopj_e]okqjk_knnan`kpailk(`ap]hi]) jaen]mqalk`ankpknj]n)oa`ebanajpao`kmqaan]ia]piaoikklkop]o]kmqaan]i*Lkn atailhk(_kjpn]`ep nekmqa(]mqea]ckn]$jaopapailkajaop]nah]k%(qi]_ne]j]oaf] ajkoaf](]kiaoikpailk(_ne]j]ajk_ne]j]7lkni(jkoan_kjpn]`ep nek`evanmqa aop]_ne]j]qi]_ne]j]aklpboqi]_ne]j](mq]j`k_nao_an*=_kjpn]`ekateopal]n] ] ]Úni]k a jac]k oeiqhp ja]o( i]o jk l]n] qi] ]Úni]k mqa lk`an oan jac]`] jqikqpnkpailk*K_]_dknnejdk`a`kj]Behkiaj](]kajrahda_an(lk`anÚ_]n_ejvajpk6 ahaclf^n]j_kakl^n]j_k* Aoo]o_kj`e aoej`e_]ip]i^imqa]o_keo]omqajkaopkoq^iape`]o]kpailkkq mqajkokpailkn]eo(fqop]iajpalknmqajkiq`]ikqjkoapn]jobkni]i(ok]mqah]o l]n]]omq]eoklnej_lek`ajk_kjpn]`ekklan]oailna`]iaoi]i]jaen]*=ooei(oan oailna_kjpn]`ep nek`evanmqakpne jcqhkpne jcqhkajkpne jcqhk(kqmqakraniahdk raniahdkajkraniahdk(ai^kn]rj^`lfp^pne]jcqh]nlkoo]lan`an]bkni]_kik_knnan `kpailkkq_kiqi]ejpanrajkdqi]j]arj^`lfp^raniahd]lkoo]iq`]n`a_kn_ki kl]oo]n`kpailkkq_kiqi]ejpanrajkdqi]j]* Lnej_lek`kpan_aenkat_hq`k(_qfkajqj_e]`kÎ>kqukqvajkdpan_aen]lkooe) ^ehe`]`aÏ*Lknatailhk6ÎKqaopadkiaiO _n]paokqjkO _n]paoÏ7ÎKqb]naiko]cqann]
4-
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
kqb]naiko]l]vÏ*Aopalnej_lek`aÚja]`a_eok`aqi`ehai]ÍÎkqeopkkq]mqehkÏÍjk mq]h]o`q]o]hpanj]per]ooklkooraeoa_qf]okhqkatecamqa]laj]oqi]`ah]ooaf]ran) `]`aen]*Iaoikmq]j`kpaiko(lknatailhk(qipaopa`aihpelh]ao_khd](ao_khdaikoj] ran`]`a]laj]oajpna`q]okl aoÍÎkqaop_anpkkqaopann]`kÏÍajkdpan_aen]lko) oe^ehe`]`akqpan_aen]]hpanj]per](lkeo(ajpnarne]oao_khd]olkooraeo(o dna]hiajpa`q]o( ]_anp]kq]ann]`]* Lnej_lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpa(mqa]Úni]mqapq`kkmqaateopaapq`kkmqa]_kjpa_a paiqi]n]vk$_]qo]kqikperk%l]n]ateopenkql]n]]_kjpa_an(amqap]hn]vk$_]qo]kq ikperk%lk`aoan_kjda_e`]lah]jkoo]n]vk*Klnej_lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpa_kopqi]oan _d]i]`k`alnej_lek`a_]qo]he`]`al]n]ej`e_]nmqa]n]vk]Úni]mqal]n]pq`kkmqa ateopakq]_kjpa_adqi]_]qo]$j]`]oai_]qo](_kopqi])oa`evanl]n]nabanen)oa]klnej) _lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpa%*Kqoaf](aooalnej_lek]Úni]]ateopj_e]`anah] aokq_kjat ao ejpanj]oajpna]o_keo]o(ajpnab]pko(kqajpna] aoa]_kjpa_eiajpko*Lk`aoanajqj_e]`k`] oacqejpai]jaen]6Î@]`k>(ja_aoo]ne]iajpaoa`]n?Ï*Ap]i^i6Î@]`k?(ja_aoo]ne]iaj) padkqra>Ï* EookjkoecjeÚ_]mqa]n]vkjk]`iep]k]_]okkq] aoab]pko]_e`ajp]eo(i]ooei mqaah]lnk_qn](iaoikl]n]k]_]okal]n]k]_e`ajpa(qi]_]qo]*=`ebanaj]ajpna]_]qo]( kq n]vk oqÚ_eajpa( a ] _]qo] _]oq]h kq ]_e`ajp]h aop ai mqa ] lneiaen] oa na]hev] oai) lna(qjerano]haja_aoone](ajmq]jpk]_]qo]]_e`ajp]hkq_]oq]ho r]hal]n]]mqaha_]ok l]npe_qh]n(l]n]]mqah]oepq]kaola_Ú_](jklk`aj`koancajan]hev]`]aoan_kjoe`an]`] rhe`]l]n]pk`koko_]okokqoepq] aoecq]eokqoaiahd]jpao(lkeo(fqop]iajpa(k_]okkq] oepq]kokje_ko* =iknpa(lknatailhk(qiabaepkja_aoonekaqjerano]h$rhe`kl]n]pk`kokopailko ahqc]nao%`]cqann]a]cqann]]_]qo]ja_aoone]aqjerano]h`]iknpa`alaook]o*I]o eilnareorahkq]_e`ajp]hmqaaop]kq]mqah]cqann]]_kjpa]i*Lk`ai]_kjpa_ankqjk* Jajdqi]_]qo]qjerano]hatecamqa]_kjpa]i*I]o(oaqi]cqann]]_kjpa_an(ah]panja) _aoo]ne]iajpa_]qo]o$iaoik]oi]eo]^oqn`]oaej]_aepraeo%a(oaah]]_kjpa_an(panja) _aoo]ne]iajpa_kikabaepkiknpao*I]o]o_]qo]o`aoo]cqann]okokiajpa]o`aoo]cqann] a`ajajdqi]kqpn]*=ooei(klnej_lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpa]ooacqn]mqa(oadkqrancqann]( dkqra_]qo]l]n]ah]amqa(d]raj`kcqann](]oiknpaorkk_knnan* @ebanajpaiajpa`aooa_]ok(klnej_lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpaaopreckn]j`klhaj]iajpa mq]j`k(lknatailhk(C]hehaq`aikjopnkq]ohaeoqjerano]eo`kikreiajpk`ko_knlkoai mqa`]herna(eopk(jkr_qk*Kqoaf](mq]j`k`ao_k^neqa`aikjopnkq]o_]qo]oj]pqn]eoja) _aoone]oakoabaepkoj]pqn]eoja_aooneko`kikreiajpk`ko_knlkoaimqa`]herna* Lahkmqabkeatlkopk(lk`aikok^oanr]nmqakolnej_leko`]n]vk]lnaoajp]i]hcq) i]o_]n]_panope_]oeilknp]jpao6
CAUSAßVEJAßNAß)NTRODUljO ß NOßTvPICOß±/ßLEGADOßDAß FILOSOFIAßGREGA² ßAßEXPLI CAljOßSOBREßNECESSIDADE ß CONTINGoNCIA ßACASOßEß POSSqVEL
jklkooqaiqi_kjpa`k`apaniej]`k(lkeookcloj^p6ej`e_]i_kik]o_keo]o`a) rai oan lajo]`]o( i]o jk jko `evai mq]eo _keo]o ok jai mq]eo ko _kjpa`ko mqa `araikokqr]ikolajo]n7 lkooqair]he`]`aqjerano]h(eopk(kj`adkqrann]vk$jkooanaodqi]jkoaj]o_keo]o( jkob]pkoajko]_kjpa_eiajpko%(aipk`kpailkaaipk`khqc]n(p]eolnej_lekook ran`]`aenkoaailnac]`kolknpk`ko$kodqi]jko%ak^a`a_e`kolknpk`ko$_keo]o(b]) pko(]_kjpa_eiajpko%7 okja_aooneko(eopk(ej`eolajoraeol]n]klajo]iajpkal]n]]rkjp]`a(ej`eolajo) raeol]n]]o_keo]o(kob]pkoako]_kjpa_eiajpko*Ej`e_]imqa]hck]ooeiajklk`a oan`akqpn]i]jaen]*Kb`bppofloecjeÚ_]mqaeilkoorahmqajkoaf]`aoo]i]jaen] amqalkoo]oan`akqpn]*
4.
=]pere`]`an]_ekj]hx#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =]pere`]`an]_ekj]h =]pere`]`an]_ekj]haoq]oik`]he`]`ao
=
INTUIljOß!ßPALAVRAßß INTUIljOßDERIVAßDEßUMß VERBOßLATINO ßINTUERE ßQUEß SIGNIFICAß±OLHARßATENTA MENTE² ß±CONTEMPLAR² ßß ±VERßCLARAMENTE²
behkokbe]`eopejcqa`q]ocn]j`aoik`]he`]`ao`]]pere`]`an]_ekj]hna]hev]`]olah]n]) vkoq^faper]kqlahkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk6]ejpqek$kqn]vkejpqeper]%ak n]_ek_jek$kqn]vk`eo_qnoer]%* =]pere`]`an]_ekj]h`eo_qnoer](_kik]ln lne]l]h]rn]ej`e_](lan_knnaqi]na]he`]`a kqqik^fapkl]n]_dac]n]_kjda_)hk(eopk(na]hev]rneko]pko`a_kjda_eiajpk]p_kj) oacqen_]lp)hk*=n]vk`eo_qnoer]kqklajo]iajpk`eo_qnoerk_dac]]kk^fapkl]oo]j`k lknap]l]ooq_aooer]o`a_kjda_eiajpk(na]hev]j`kaobknkooq_aooerko`a]lnktei]kl]n] _dac]n]k_kj_aepkkq`abejek`kk^fapk* =n]vkejpqeper]kqejpqek(]k_kjpnnek(_kjoeopajqije_k]pk`kaolnepk(mqa(`a qi]o rav(_]lp]lknejpaenka_kilhap]iajpakk^fapk*=ejpqekqi]reok`enap]aeia) `e]p]`kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk(qi_kjp]pk`enapkaeia`e]pk_kiaha(oaija_aooe`]`a`a lnkr]okq`aikjopn] aol]n]o]^ankmqa_kjda_a*
=ejpqek =ejpqekqi]_kilnaajokchk^]ha_kilhap]`aqi]ran`]`a(`aqik^fapk(`a qib]pk*Jah](`aqi]o rav(]n]vk_]lp]pk`]o]onah] aomqa_kjopepqai]na]he`]`aa ] ran`]`a `] _keo] ejpq`]* qi ]pk ejpaha_pq]h `a `eo_anjeiajpk a _kilnaajok( _kik( lknatailhk(mq]j`kqii`e_k(cn]]o]k_kjfqjpk`a_kjda_eiajpkomqalkooqe(b]vqi `e]cj ope_kaimqa]lnaaj`a`aqi]o rav]`kaj](oq]_]qo]akik`k`apn]p)h]*Ko loe_ hkckooanabanaiejpqekqo]j`kkpanikfkpfdeq(`ao_naraj`k)k_kikkikiajpk aimqapaikoqi]_kilnaajokpkp]h(`enap]aeia`e]p]`a]hcqi]_keo](kqkikiajpk aimqalan_a^aiko(jqio h]j_a(qi_]iejdkl]n]]okhqk`aqilnk^hai]lnpe_k( _eajpbe_k(behko be_k(ikn]hkqrep]h* Qiatailhk`aejpqeklk`aoanaj_kjpn]`kjknki]j_a`aCqei]naoNko](Do^kab pboql7sboba^p*Nek^]h`ka@e]`kneiok`keof]cqjkohec]`kolah]i]eolnkbqj`]]iev]`a aha]h`]`a(_kil]jdaenko`ahqp]oa_qilne`knao`aqi]rejc]j]`ao]jcqa_kjpn]ko]o) o]ooejko`]b]ihe]`a@e]`knei*Nek^]h`k(lkni(oajpa)oa_daek`a]jcope]a]pkniajp]`k( lkeooaqooajpeiajpkolkn@e]`kneiok_kjbqoko(_kikoaajpnaahaodkqraooaiqepki]eo `k mqa ]iev]`a* @e]`knei ]oo]ooej]`k* Mq]j`k k _knlk pn]ve`k l]n] oan lnal]n]`k k bqjan]h(Nek^]h`k`ao_k^namqa@e]`kneian]iqhdan*@aqi]o rav(jqio h]j_a(Nek^]h`k _kilnaaj`apq`kkmqad]re]oajpe`k(pk`kokob]pko]_kjpa_e`koajpnaahaoamqahdal]na) _e]iejatlhe_raeo(pk`]o]o_kjrano]omqad]re]ipe`k(pk`kokocaopkoaopn]jdko`a@e]`k) nei$_kik(lknatailhk(k`af]i]eo^]jd]n)oajkonekoj]_kil]jde]`ko`ai]eof]cqjko% a_kilnaaj`a(ejop]jp]ja]iajpa(]ran`]`a6aoperan]]l]etkj]`klkn@e]`knei* Katailhk`ki`e_kak`aNek^]h`kej`e_]imqa]ejpqeklk`a`alaj`an`a_k) jda_eiajpko]jpaneknaoamqaah]kikiajpkaimqaahaooklan_a^e`ko`aqi]o rav( jqi] ojpaoa ai mqa ]l]na_ai ]npe_qh]`ko a knc]jev]`ko jqi pk`k* Eook oecjebe_] mqa ] ejpqeklk`aoankikiajpkbej]h`aqilnk_aook`a_kjda_eiajpk*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o( kikiajpkaimqak_kjfqjpk`a_kjda_eiajpkomqabkeoaj`k]`mqene`klaniepamqak oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkna]hevaqi]ojpaoa(lan_a^aj`k`aqi]o ravaeia`e]p]iajpa
4/
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
EMPqRICOßDOßGREGOßß EMPEIRqA ß±EXPERIoNCIA²
&RANSß(ALS3TATENSß-USEUMßß FORß+UNST ß#OPENHAGEN
kpk`k`kk^fapk_kjda_e`k$oq]bkni](oaq_kjpa`k(oq]o_]qo]o(oq]olnklnea`]`ao(oaqo abaepko(oq]onah] ao_kikqpnko(oaqoajpe`k%* Fqop]iajpa lkn oan k ikiajpk `a _kj_hqok `a qi lan_qnok( iqepko beh okbko _kj) oe`an]ip]i^imqaqi]ejpqeklk`aoanklkjpkeje_e]h`aqijkrklan_qnok`a_k) jda_eiajpk(eopk(cn]]o]ah](]n]vk`eo_qnoer]lk`an`]nej_ek]qi]jkr]_]`ae]`a _kjda_eiajpkoai_qfklkjpkbej]hd]ranqi]jkr]ejpqek* = ejpqek n]_ekj]h lk`a oan `a `keo pelko6 fkqrf l pbkpsbi lr bjmof`^ a fkqrf l fkqbib`qr^i* =ejpqekoajorahkqailne_]k_kjda_eiajpkmqapaiko]pk`kikiajpk`ajkoo] re`]*=ooei(_kiqio khd]nkqjqio ]pk`areoklan_a^aikoqi]_]o](qidkiai( qi]iqhdan(qi]bhkn(qi]iao]*Jqio ]pk(lknatailhk(_]lpkmqafpqlrj^cilo6rafk oq]_knaoq]olp]h]o(oejpk]i]_eav`aoq]patpqn](]olenkoaqlanbqia(pajdk)]lknejpaenk a`aqi]o rav`e]jpa`aiei* =ejpqekailne_]k_kjda_eiajpk`enapkaeia`e]pk`]omq]he`]`ao`kk^fapkat) panjk_d]i]`]o`anr^ifa^abppbkpsbfp6_kn(o]^kn(k`kn(l]h]`]n(oki(patpqn]*p]i^i] lan_alk`enap]`abkni]o(`eiajo ao(`eop j_e]o`]o_keo]olan_a^e`]o*Ak_kjda_eiajpk `enapkaeia`e]pk`ajkookoaop]`koejpanjkokqiajp]eomqa`alaj`aikq`alaj`an]i`a jkook_kjp]pkoajokne]h_ki]o_keo]o6hai^n]j]o(`aoafko(oajpeiajpko(ei]cajo* =ejpqekoajorahkqailne_]loe_kh ce_](eopk(nabana)oa]koaop]`ko`koqfaepk`k _kjda_eiajpk_kikoan_knlkn]halomqe_kej`ere`q]hÍoajo] ao(hai^n]j]o(ei]cajo( oajpeiajpko( `aoafko a lan_al ao ok at_hqoer]iajpa laook]eo( r]ne]j`k `a laook] l]n] laook]ajqi]iaoi]laook]ai`a_knnj_e]`ar]ne] aoaioaq_knlk(aioq]iajpakq j]o_en_qjop j_e]oaimqak_kjda_eiajpkk_knna* =ooei(]i]n_]`]ejpqekailne_]oq]oejcqh]ne`]`a6lknqih]`k(aophec]`]oej) cqh]ne`]`a`kk^fapkejpq`k$]kÎeopkÏkbana_e`koajo]kalan_alk%a(lknkqpnk(aop hec]`]oejcqh]ne`]`a`koqfaepkmqaejpqe$]kojbrpaop]`kolomqe_ko(ojfke^patlanej) _e]o%*=ejpqekailne_]jk_]lp]kk^fapkaioq]qjerano]he`]`aa]atlanej_e]ejpqeper] jkpn]jobanrahl]n]qikqpnkk^fapk*Nek^]h`kparaqi]ejpqekailne_]* =ejpqekejpaha_pq]h`ebana`]oajorahfqop]iajpalknoq]qjerano]he`]`aaja_aooe`]) `a*Mq]j`klajokÎQi]_keo]jklk`aoanajkoan]kiaoikpailkÏ(oae(oaija_aooe`]) `a`alnkr]oa`aikjopn] ao(mqaeookran`]`aamqaja_aoonekmqaoaf]oailna]ooei( kqmqaeilkoorahmqajkoaf]oailna]ooei*Kqoaf](pajdk_kjda_eiajpkejpqeperk`k lnej_lek`]_kjpn]`ek*Mq]j`k`eckÎK]i]nahk`ebanajpa`k]vqhÏ(oae(oaija_aooe`]`a `alnkr]oa`aikjopn] ao(mqad`ebanaj]oajpna]o_keo]o*Rafk(j]ejpqekoajorah(] _kn]i]nah]a]_kn]vqh(i]orafk(j]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h(]`ebanaj]ajpna]o_knao*Mq]j`k ]benikÎKpk`ki]ekn`kmqa]ol]npaoÏ(oae(oaija_aooe`]`a`alnkr]oa`aikjopn] ao( mqaeookran`]`a(lknmqaejpqkqi]bkni]ja_aoone]`anah]kajpna]o_keo]o* =ejpqekejpaha_pq]hk_kjda_eiajpk`enapkaeia`e]pk`kolnej_leko`]n]vk$e`aj) pe`]`a(_kjpn]`ek(pan_aenkat_hq`k(n]vkoqbe_eajpa%(komq]eo(lknoanailnej_leko(jk lk`ai oan `aikjopn]`ko $lkeo( l]n] `aikjopn)hko( lna_eo]n]iko `a kqpnko lnej_leko( a l]n] `aikjopn]n aopao kqpnko lnej_leko lna_eo]n]iko `a kqpnko( jqi lnk_aook ejpan) iejrahmqajkoeila`ene]`ao]^an_ki_anpav]]ran`]`a`aqilnej_lek%*=hcqjobeh ) okbko]beni]ip]i^imqa_kjda_aikolknejpqek]oe`ae]ooeilhao(eopk(]mqah]omqa jkok_kilkop]o`akqpn]oajklna_eo]i`akqpn]ol]n]oanai_kjda_e`]o*Fqop]iajpa lknmqajk`alaj`ai`akqpnko_kjda_eiajpkokq`akqpn]oe`ae]o(]oe`ae]ooeilhaook ]lnaaj`e`]ojqi]pkejpqeperk*Jkajp]jpk(_kik]ejpqeklk`aoanklkjpkbej]h`aqi lnk_aook`a_kjda_eiajpk(ah]p]i^i]]lnaajokejpaha_pq]h`]onah] aoja_aoone]o ajpna]oe`ae]oaajpnakooanaoaajpna]oe`ae]oa]o_keo]o`amqaoke`ae]o* J]deop ne]`]behkokbe](ko`keoatailhkoi]eo_ha^nao`aejpqekejpaha_pq]haj_kj) pn]i)oaaiLh]pk$o_qhkER]*?*%aai@ao_]npao$o_qhkTREE%* J]j]nn]per]`kIepk`]?]ranj](Lh]pk`ao_narakmqaoal]oo]_kiklneoekjaenkmqa r]hqv`kOkha]o_keo]oak_kil]n]]kbeh okbkmqar]hqv`k^aia]oe`ae]oran`]`aen]o* K lneoekjaenk pai qi] ejpqek ailne_] $pq`k k mqa _kjda_a( _kjda_a lkn oajo]k kq
$ESCARTES߯ -ITOßDAß#AVERNAßVEJAßAß EXPLICAljOßSOBREßOß-ITOß DAß#AVERNAßNAß)NTRODUljO
40
%DUARDOß!LBARELLO%DITORAß!BRIL
=]pere`]`an]_ekj]hx#!0É45,/ßx
COGITOßEMßLATIM ßOßVERBOß COGITAREßSIGNIFICAß±PENSAR²
lknlan_alkoajokne]h%7kbeh okbkpaiqi]ejpqekejpaha_) pq]h$oaqejpaha_pkkqoq]ejpahecj_e]mqa_kjda_a]oe`ae]o ran`]`aen]o%( i]o ]i^ko pi qi _kjda_eiajpk ejpqeperk lknmqa`enapk(eia`e]pk(oaija_aooe`]`a`a`aikjopn] ao( ]ncqiajpkoalnkr]o* Jqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]Jbafq^ bpjbq^cpf`^p(kbeh okbk bn]j_o @ao_]npao $_kjoe`an]`k k eje_e]`kn `k n]_ekj]heoik ik`anjk%`ao_nara]ejpqekejpaha_pq]hmqabe_kq_kjda_e`] _kik`ldfql`^oqbpf^kl(kq(i]eooeilhaoiajpa(`ldfql*@ao) _]npaoao_nara6Î@ldfql)bodlprjÏ(eopk(ÎLajok$`ldfql%(hkck ateopkÏ*Lknmqaaoo]]beni]kqi_kjda_eiajpkejpqeperk; Lknmqamq]j`klajok(oaemqaaopkqlajo]j`kajklna_eok lnkr]nkq`aikjopn]neook(iaoiklknmqalnkr]na`aikjo) pn]nlajo]n(al]n]`aikjopn]nalnkr]nlna_eok(lneiaenk( lajo]n a o]^an mqa oa lajo]* Kn]( l]n] lajo]n lna_eok mqa ]hcqina]hevak]pk`alajo]iajpka(lknp]jpk(]mqahamqa lajo]ateopaja_aoo]ne]iajpa]klajo]nkqajmq]jpklajo]( lkeo(`k_kjpnnek(jkd]rane]k]pk`alajo]n*Aeookp]i^i jk lna_eo] oan lnkr]`k kq `aikjopn]`k( i]o eia`e]p]) iajpaare`ajpa*Lknmqaaoo]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h;Lknmqa na]hev]`]at_hqoer]iajpalahkejpaha_pkkqlah]ejpahecj_e]( oaina_knnan]jajdqi_kjda_eiajpkoajorahkqoajokne]h* Mq]j`k `eckÎLajok( hkck ateopkÏ( aopkq oeilhaoiajpa ]beni]j`k n]_ekj]hiajpa mqa oae mqa okq qi oan lajo]jpa KLajo]`kn(`aNk`ej* kq mqa ateopk lajo]j`k( oai ja_aooe`]`a `a lnkr]o a `a) ikjopn] ao*=ejpqek_]lp](jqije_k]pkejpaha_pq]h(] ran`]`a`klajo]iajpklajo]j`kaioeiaoik* Qikqpnkatailhk`aejpqekejpaha_pq]hkbana_e`klknqi]_knnajpabehko be_]_ne]) `]jko_qhkTTlahkbeh okbk]haikDqooanh(]cbkljbklildf^*Pn]p])oa`]ejpqekejpaha_) pq]h`aaooj_e]okqoecjebe_] ao*Pk`]_kjo_ej_e](`evDqooanh(oailnaÎ_kjo_ej_e]`aÏkq Î_kjo_ej_e]`a]hcqi]_keo]Ï(eopk(pk`]_kjo_ej_e]qi]pklahkmq]hreo]ikoqik^fapk( qib]pk(qi]e`ae]*=_kjo_ej_e]nalnaoajp]kok^fapko(kob]pko(]olaook]o*Aoo]nalnaoaj) p]k lk`a oan `a `keo pelko6 mpf`lidf`^ $eopk ( ailne_]( r]ne]j`k `a laook] l]n] laook] ajqi]iaoi]laook]ai`ebanajpao_en_qjop j_e]o%afkqbib`qr^i$mq]j`kklajo]iajpk( oaina_knnan]ko`]`koloe_kh ce_koej`ere`q]eo(_kjda_a]aooj_e]ja_aoone]`kk^fapk(mqa ]iaoi]l]n]pk`kokooanaon]_ekj]eo7eopk(]lnaaj`a`aqi]o rav]oecjebe_]kkqk oajpe`k`aqi]_keo](ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`]o_kj`e aol]npe_qh]nao`aaol]kapailka `]o_kj`e aoloe_kh ce_]o`a_]`]qi%*Ejpqikoejpaha_pq]hiajpae`ae]okqoecjebe_] ao kq(_kik`ev]bajkiajkhkce](ejpqikoaooj_e]o*B]h])oap]i^i`aqi]fkqrf lbjlqfs^ kqs^ilo^qfs^*Pn]p])oa`]mqah]ejpqekj]mq]h(fqjp]iajpa_kikoajpe`kkqoecjebe_]`k`a ]hcqi]_keo](_]lp]ikop]i^ioaqs^ilo(eopk(]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h_]lp]]aooj_e]`k k^fapk$kmqaahakqkmqaahaoecjebe_]%a]ejpqekaikper]kqr]hkn]per]_]lp]aoo]aooj) _e]]lnaaj`aj`kkmqaah]r]ha$^k](i(^ah](bae](fqop](ejfqop](ap_*%*
=n]vk`eo_qnoer]6`a`qk(ej`qka]^`qk
41
=ejpqeklk`aoanklkjpk`a_dac]`](]_kj_hqok`aqilnk_aook`a_kjda_eiajpk( alk`ap]i^ioanklkjpk`al]npe`]`aqilnk_aook_kcjeperk*Klnk_aook`a_kjda_e) iajpk(oaf]kmqa_dac]]qi]ejpqek(oaf]kmqal]npa`ah](_kjopepqe]n]vk`eo_qnoer]kq kn]_ek_jek* =k_kjpnnek`]ejpqek(kn]_ek_jekk_kjda_eiajpkmqaatecalnkr]oa`aikjo) pn] aoaoana]hev]ecq]hiajpalkniaek`alnkr]oa`aikjopn] ao`]oran`]`aomqaaopk oaj`k_kjda_e`]okqejraopec]`]o*Jko qi]pkejpaha_pq]h(i]ookrneko]pkoejpaha_) pq]eoejpanj]iajpahec]`kokq_kja_p]`ko(bkni]j`kqilnk_aook`a_kjda_eiajpk*
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
Qi_]]`kno]elah]i]jdai^qo_]`]_]]*Ajpn]jki]pkarn]opnko6_dkraqj] rolan] a d lac]`]o jk _dk7 lamqajko c]hdko n]opaenko aopk mqa^n]`ko7 k _]lei aop ]i]oo]`kairnekolkjpko7]_]n_]]`aqi^e_dkaopikopn](ej`e_]j`kmqabke`ark) n]`kb]vlkq_]odkn]o7dqicn]j`aoehj_ekjk]n(jkd_]jpk`aloo]nko(jkdnq`ko `alamqajko]jei]eo* K_]]`knoql amqad]f]qi]kj]lknlanpk*Ahalk`a(ajpk(pki]n`q]o]pepq`ao*Oa( lknpk`]o]ooq]oatlanej_e]o]jpaneknao(peran_anpav]`amqa]kj]aopj]oeia`e] ao( lk`alnal]n]n)oal]n]ajbnajp)h]6o]^amqa_]iejdkoarep]n(oajkaoperanai_kj`e ao`a _])h]7o]^amqa]ni]`ehd]o]ni]n(oaaoperanlnkjpkl]n]_]lpqn)h]7o]^a_kik]pn])h](oa mqeoan_kjoanr)h]rer]alnaoanr]n]aol_ea* K_]]`knlk`a]ej`]aop]noaiiqep]_anpav]oadkqjkqi]kj]jko]nna`knao a(jaooa_]ok(pki]nqi]onea`a]pepq`aol]n]ranebe_]n]lnaoaj]kq]qoj_e]`kbahejk6 lk`alan_knnanpnehd]omqao]^aoanailn lne]o`akj]o7lk`aat]iej]niahdkn]olac]`]o akpelk`a]jei]hmqabke`arkn]`k7lk`a_kil]n]n(aioq]iai ne](kqpn]ooepq] aoj]o mq]eoaoparalnaoajpaqi]kj](ap_* =ooei(l]npej`k`aej`_eko(k_]]`knn]_ek_ej]l]n]_dac]n]qi]_kj_hqokapki]n qi]`a_eok*Paiko]qiatan__ek`an]_ek_jekailne_k$^]oa]`kjko`]`kooajokne]eokq j]atlanej_e]oajorah%alnpe_k$qilajo]iajpkmqareo]]qi]]k%(kqoaf](qiat]ia `arnekooej]eomqalaniepai]]hcqib]vanqi]fkcbok`f^(eopk(pen]nqi]_kj_hqok _ki^]oajko`]`ko_kjda_e`ko*Aooan]_ek_jek(lknoanailne_k(_]n]_panev])oalah]oejcqh]) ne`]`akqej`ere`q]he`]`a`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk$jk_]ok(qi_]]`kn%a`kk^fapk`k _kjda_eiajpk$jk_]ok(qi]oepq]kaimqadoej]eokqej`_eko`aqi]kj]%* Mq]j`k(lkni(qin]_ek_jekoana]hev]ai_kj`e aop]eomqa]ej`ere`q]he`]`aloe) _kh ce_]`koqfaepka]oejcqh]ne`]`a`kk^fapkokoq^opepq`]olkn_nepneko`acajan]he`]`a aqjerano]he`]`a(paiko]abar l(]fkar la]^_ar l* =`a`qk @a`qk a ej`qk ok lnk_a`eiajpko n]_ekj]eo mqa jko har]i `k f _kjda_e`k ]k ]ej`]jk_kjda_e`k(eopk(laniepaimqa]`mqen]iko_kjda_eiajpkojkrkocn]]o]_k) jda_eiajpkof]`mqene`ko*Lkneook(_kopqi])oa`evanmqa(jkn]_ek_jek(kejpaha_pkklan] oacqej`k`^abf^pabo^wbpkqkojatkoa_kjat aoejpanjkoaja_aoonekoajpna]oe`ae]okq ajpnakob]pko* =`a`qk_kjoeopaail]npen`aqi]ran`]`af_kjda_e`]$oaf]lknejpqek(oaf]lkn qi]`aikjopn]k]jpanekn%amqabqj_ekj]_kikqilnej_lekcan]h]kmq]hoaoq^kn`e) j]ipk`koko_]okomqaoank`aikjopn]`ko]l]npen`ah]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(j]`a`qk l]npa)oa`aqi]ran`]`af_kjda_e`]l]n]`aikjopn]nmqaah]oa]lhe_]]pk`koko_]oko l]npe_qh]naoecq]eo*Lkneookp]i^ioa`evmqa]`a`qkr]e`kcan]hl]n]kl]npe_qh]nkq`k qjerano]hl]n]kej`ere`q]h*Klkjpk`al]npe`]`aqi]`a`qkkqqi]e`ae]ran`]`aen] $kq`abejek%kqqi]pakne]ran`]`aen]$eopk(qipk`koeopaipe_k`a`abeje aoa`aikjo) pn] ao^]oa]`]oailnej_lekoran`]`aenkoalnk_a`eiajpko_knnapko%(a]bej]he`]`a`klnk) _aook`a`qperk]ooacqn]n]fkcbok`f^`a_kj_hqo aojkr]oaran`]`aen]o(k^pe`]o_ki^]oa j]`abejek`kk^fapkkqj]pakne]fateopajpa* Lknatailhk(oa`abejenikokpne jcqhk_kikqibecqn]cakipne_]_qfko jcqhkoejpan) jkooki]`kookecq]eooki]`a`keo jcqhkonapko(`ah]`a`qvenaikopk`koko`ebanajpao pelko`apne jcqhkolkooraeo$amqehpankkqeo o_ahao(nap jcqhk(ap_*%(pk`]o]olnklnea`]`ao `apk`kokopne jcqhkolkooraeoapk`]o]olnklnea`]`ao`a_]`]qi`kopelkolkooraeo`a pne jcqhko*Oapki]niko_kiklkjpk`al]npe`]]o`abeje aocakipne_]o`klkjpk(`]hejd]( `]oqlanb_eaa`]becqn](`a`qvenaikopk`]o]obecqn]ocakipne_]olkooraeo* Jk_]ok`aqi]pakne](]`a`qklaniepenmqa_]`]jkrk_]okl]npe_qh]naj_kjpn]`k oaf]_kjda_e`k(`aikjopn]j`kmqa]ahaoa]lhe_]ipk`]o]ohaeo(nacn]oaran`]`ao*Kqoaf]( ]`a`qkqilnk_a`eiajpklahkmq]hqib]pkkqk^fapkl]npe_qh]n_kjda_e`klknfk`ir* pljqi]pakne]can]h*
42
=]pere`]`an]_ekj]hx#!0É45,/ßx
Lknatailhk(aop]^aha_e`]]ran`]`a`]pakne]boe_]`aJaspkj(o]^aikomqa6-%]ohaeo `]boe_]oknah] ao`ej ie_]o`apelkia_ je_k(eopk(oanabanai]nah] ao`abkn]$]k ana]k%ajpna_knlko`kp]`ko`abecqn](i]oo]acn]j`av]7.%kobajiajkoboe_kok_knnai jkaol]kajkpailk7/%_kjda_e`]o]ohaeoeje_e]eo`aqi_kjfqjpkkq`aqioeopai]`a bajiajko(lk`anaikolnaranko]pkomqak_knnankjaooa_kjfqjpkajaooaoeopai]* =ooei(oaaqmqeoan_kjda_anqi_]okboe_kl]npe_qh]nÍlknatailhk(kmqa]_kjpa_an _kiqi_knlkh]j]`kjkaol]klknqi]j]raaol]_e]h(kqmq]h]rahk_e`]`a`aqilnkfpeh h]j]`k`aqioq^i]nejkl]n]]pejcenqi]hrkjqipailk`apaniej]`k(kqmq]hkpailk l]n]qi_anpk]opnkna]hev]nqiikreiajpk`ankp]kaipknjk`aoaqaetkÍ(]lhe_]nae] aooao_]okol]npe_qh]nao]ohaeocan]eo`]boe_]jaspkje]j]ao]^anae_ki_anpav]]naolkop] ran`]`aen]* ?kopqi])oanalnaoajp]n]`a`qklah]oacqejpab niqh]6 Pk`kokouokv$`abejek`kk^fapkkqpakne]can]hok^naqi_kjfqjpk`ak^fapko%7 >v$_]okl]npe_qh]n%7 Lknp]jpk(>u$`a`qk%* Ah]p]i^ilk`aoanatlnaoo]jqi]becqn]6 pk`kokou pk`kokov
= = n]vk kbana_a nacn]o aola_e]eo l]n] na]hev]n qi] `a`qk* Oa p]eo nacn]o jk bknai naolaep]`]o(]`a`qkoan_kjoe`an]`]b]ho]* =ej`qk
43
=ej`qkna]hev]qi_]iejdkejranok]k`]`a`qk*?ki]ej`qk(l]npeiko`a_]) okol]npe_qh]naoecq]eokqoaiahd]jpaoalnk_qn]iko]haecan]h(]`abejekcan]hkq]pakne] can]hmqaatlhe_]aoq^kn`ej]pk`koaooao_]okol]npe_qh]nao*=`abejekkq]pakne]okk^) pe`]ojklkjpkbej]h`klan_qnok*A]n]vkp]i^ikbana_aqi_kjfqjpk`anacn]olna_eo]o l]n]cqe]n]ej`qk*Oap]eonacn]ojkbknainaolaep]`]o(]ej`qkoan_kjoe`an]`]b]ho]* Lknatailhk(_khk_]ikocq]jkbkckak^oanr]ikomqaah]banraaoapn]jobkni]ai r]lkn7_khk_]ikohaepajkbkckaraikop]i^imqaahaoapn]jobkni]air]lkn7_khk_]) ikornekopelko`ahmqe`kojkbkckaraikooailnaoq]pn]jobkni]kair]lkn*Ej`qve) iko`aooao_]okol]npe_qh]naomqakbkcklkooqeqi]lnklnea`]`amqalnk`qv]ar]lkn]k `kohmqe`ko*Aoo]lnklnea`]`ak_]hkn* Ranebe_]iko(lkni(mqako`ebanajpaohmqe`kojkhar]ioailnakiaoikpailkl]n] ar]lkn]n7_]`]qi`ahao(lknp]jpk(`arapanlnklnea`]`aoaola_be_]omqakob]vaiar]lkn]n aipailko`ebanajpao*@ao_k^neiko(lkni(mqakpailkl]n]]_kjpa_an]ar]lkn]kjk kb]pkmqalna_eo]oank^oanr]`kaoeimq]jpk`a_]hkn_]`]hmqe`klna_eo]l]n]_kia]n ]ar]lkn]n(lkeoaoo]]_]qo]`ko`ebanajpaopailkol]n]]ar]lkn]k*Oa_kjoe`an]niko] cq]kjkookl]`nk`aia`e`](`enaikomqaah]banraa_kia]]ar]lkn]n]l]npen`aqi] _anp]mq]jpe`]`a`a_]hknamqaaoo]mq]jpe`]`a`a_]hknmqalna_eo]oan_kjda_e`]* ?kik]cq]bkeao_khde`]l]n]oanren`al]`nk(`enaikomqa]mq]jpe`]`a`a_]hkn `a-,,cn]qo_ajpcn]`ko* Lk`aiko(]oacqen(ranebe_]nqibajiajk`ebanajpa*Raikomqa]cq]akqpnkohmqe) `ko(_khk_]`kojqinabnecan]`kn(aj`qna_aia_kjcah]i(i]omqa(_kikjk_]ok`kr]lkn(
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
./!!ß0HOTOß,IBRARY!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
_]`]hmqe`k_kjcah]kqoaokhe`ebe_]aipailko`ebanajpao*Lnk_qn]iko(jkr]iajpa(]_]q) o]`aoo]`ebanaj]a`ao_k^neikomqa`alaj`ap]jpk`a_anp]olnklnea`]`ao`a_]`]hmqe) `k_kik`]mq]jpe`]`a`abnekmqadjknabnecan]`kn*Lan_a^aiko(bej]hiajpa(mqaaoo] mq]jpe`]`amqa`araikolnk_qn]na(oapki]niko]cq]_kikl]`nk(`enaikomqaah]oa _kjcah]]vankcn]q_ajpcn]`k* ?kiaoo]o`q]ooneao`ab]pko$r]lkna_kjcah]iajpk%(`ao_k^neikomqakoaop]`ko`ko hmqe`kor]ne]i$ar]lkn]kaokhe`ebe_]k%ai`a_knnj_e]`]pailan]pqn]]i^eajpa$_]hkn abnek%amqa_]`]hmqe`k]pejcaklkjpk`aar]lkn]kkq`aokhe`ebe_]kaipailan]pqn]o `ebanajpao*?kiaooao`]`kolk`aikobkniqh]nqi]pakne]`]nah]kajpnakoaop]`ko`] i]pne] Í o he`k( hmqe`k a c]okok Í a ]o r]ne] ao `a pailan]pqn]( aop]^aha_aj`k qi] nah]kja_aoone]ajpnakaop]`k`aqi_knlka]pailan]pqn]]i^eajpa*?dac]iko(lkn ej`qk(]qi]pakne]* =`a`qka]ej`qkok_kjda_e`]o_kikjkia`aejbanj_e](eopk(_kj_hqen]h) cqi]_keo]_ki^]oaaikqpn]f_kjda_e`]*J]`a`qk(`]`kU$`abejekkqpakne]%(ejbenk $_kj_hqk%^(_(`(a$ko_]okol]npe_qh]nao%*J]ej`qk(`]`ko^(_(`(a(ejbenk$_kj_hqk%U* =]^`qk 2ALFß&ROELICH'LOWß)MAGES)MAGEPLUS
Kbeh okbkjknpa)]iane_]jkLaen_a_kj) oe`an]mqa(]hi`]`a`qka`]ej`qk(] n]vk `eo_qnoer] kq n]_ek_jek p]i^i oa na]hev] jqi] pan_aen] ik`]he`]`a `a ejba) nj_e]( ai^kn] aop] jk oaf] lnklne]iajpa `aikjopn]per]* Aoo] pan_aen] ik`]he`]`a _d]i]`]lknaha`a]^`qk* = ]^`qk qi] aol_ea `a ejpqek( i]omqajkoa``aqi]o rav(ej`kl]ook ]l]ookl]n]_dac]n]qi]_kj_hqok*=]^`q) k]^qo_]`aqi]_kj_hqoklah]ejpanlna) p]kn]_ekj]h`aoej]eo(`aej`_eko(`aoecjko* Katailhki]eooeilhaokbana_e`klknLaen_a l]n]atlhe_]nkmqa]]^`qkokko_kj) pko lkhe_e]eo( k ik`k _kik ko `apaperao rk _khap]j`kej`_ekoaoej]eoabkni]j`kqi] atlhe_]kl]n]k_]okmqaejraopec]i* Oacqj`kLaen_a(]]^`qk]bkni]mqa ]n]vklkooqemq]j`keje_e]kaopq`k`aqi jkrk _]ilk _eajpbe_k mqa ]ej`] jk d]re] oe`k ]^kn`]`k* Ah] oa ]lnktei] `] ejpqek `k]npeop]a`]]`erejd]k`k`apapera(mqa( ]jpao`aeje_e]naioaqopn]^]hdko(o _kjp]i _ki]hcqjooej]eomqaej`e_]ileop]o]oacqen* Kodeopkne]`knao_kopqi]iqo]n]]^`qk* @aik`kcan]h(`ev)oamqa]ej`qka]]^`qkoklnk_a`eiajpkon]_ekj]eomqaailna) c]ikol]n]]^nrfpf l`a_kjda_eiajpko(ajmq]jpk]`a`qkklnk_a`eiajpkn]_ekj]h mqaailnac]ikol]n]sbofcf`^okq`ljmols^o]ran`]`a`aqi_kjda_eiajpkf]`mqene`k*
#HARLESß3ANDERSß0EIRCEß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßDAß CIoNCIAßEßDAßLINGUAGEM
Aoppq]`k`apapera Odanhk_gDkhiao( lanokj]cai`]o deop ne]olkhe_e]eo `a?kj]j@kuha*
Na]heoikae`a]heoik
R
eiko]jpanekniajpamqaiqepkobeh okbko`eopejcqain]vkk^faper]an]vkoq^fape) r](_kjoe`an]j`k]behkokbe]kaj_kjpnkak]_kn`kajpna]i^]o*
44
=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`];x#!0É45,/ßx
B]h]n jqi] n]vk k^faper] oecjebe_] ]beni]n mqa ] na]he`]`a atpanj] ]k jkook lajo]) iajpkn]_ekj]haioealknoeiaoi]amqalk`aiko_kjda_)h]fqop]iajpalknoann]_ek) j]h*Oecjebe_]`evan(lknatailhk(mqakaol]kakpailkateopaiaioealknoeiaoiko(mqa ]onah] aoi]paipe_]oa`a_]qo])abaepkateopaij]oln lne]o_keo]o(mqak]_]okateopaj] ln lne]na]he`]`a(ap_* ?d]i])oana]heoik]lkoekbehko be_]mqa]beni]]ateopj_e]k^faper]kqaioe`] na]he`]`aatpanj]_kikqi]na]he`]`an]_ekj]haioealknoeiaoi]a(lknp]jpk(mqa]beni] ]ateopj_e]`]n]vkk^faper]* D beh okbko( lkni( mqa aop]^aha_ai qi] `ebanaj] ajpna ] na]he`]`a a k _kjda_e) iajpkn]_ekj]hmqa`ah]paiko*@evaiahaomqa(ai^kn]]na]he`]`aatpanj]ateop]aioe alknoeiaoi](o lk`aiko_kjda_)h]p]h_kikjkoo]oe`ae]o]bkniqh]ia]knc]jev]i ajk_kikah]oane]aioeiaoi]*Jklk`aikoo]^anjai`evanoa]na]he`]`aatpanekn n]_ekj]hbjpf(lkeoo lk`aikoo]^ana`evanmqaah]n]_ekj]hm^o^kp(eopk(lkniaek `ajkoo]oe`ae]o* Aoo]lkoekbehko be_]_kjda_e`]lahkjkia`ae`a]heoika]beni]]laj]o]ateopj) _e]`]n]vkoq^faper]*=n]vkoq^faper]lkooqelnej_lekoaik`]he`]`ao`a_kjda_eiajpk mqaokqjerano]eoaja_aooneko(eopk(rhe`kol]n]pk`kokooanaodqi]jkoaipk`koko pailkoahqc]nao*Kmqa_d]i]ikona]he`]`a(lknp]jpk(]laj]okmqalk`aiko_kjda_an lkniaek`]oe`ae]o`ajkoo]n]vk*
#APqTULOß =n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`]; Ej]peoikkqaileneoik;
@
akj`arean]ikolnej_lekon]_ekj]eo;@akj`araek]_]l]_e`]`al]n]]ejpqeka l]n]kn]_ek_jek;J]o_aiko_kiahaokqjkooane]i`]`kolah]a`q_]kalahk_ko) pqia;Oane]i]hckln lnek`kooanaodqi]jko(_kjopepqej`k]j]pqnav]`ahao(kqoa) ne]i]`mqene`kolah]atlanej_e];@qn]jpao_qhko(]behkokbe]kbana_aq`q]onaolkop]o]aoo]o lancqjp]o*=lneiaen]be_kq_kjda_e`]_kikej]peoika]oacqj`](_kikaileneoik* Kej]peoik]beni]mqa]kj]o_anikopn]vaikoaijkoo]ejpahecj_e]jko kolnej) _leko n]_ekj]eo i]o p]i^i ]hcqi]o e`ae]o ran`]`aen]o( mqa( lkn eook( ok e`ae]o ej]p]o* Kaileneoik(]k_kjpnnek(]beni]mqa]n]vk(_kioaqolnej_leko(oaqolnk_a`eiajpkoa oq]oe`ae]o(]`mqene`]lknj olah]atlanej_e]*
Kej]peoik
R
]ikob]h]n`kej]peoikpki]j`k`keobeh okbko_kikatailhk6kbeh okbkcnackLh]) pkakbeh okbkbn]j_o@ao_]npao*
45
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
Ej]peoiklh]pje_k Lh]pk`abaj`a]paoa`kej]peoik`]n]vkkq`]oe`ae]oran`]`aen]oairne]o`aoq]o k^n]o(i]o]ol]oo]cajoi]eo_kjda_e`]ooaaj_kjpn]ijko`ehkckoJklkaObm _if`^* JkJklk(O _n]pao`e]hkc]_kiqifkraiao_n]rk]j]hb]^apk*B]vaj`k)hdalancqjp]o _anp]oj]dkn]_anp](kbeh okbk_kjoacqamqakfkraiao_n]rk`aikjopnaokvejdkqi`eb_eh paknai]`acakiapne]*=oran`]`aoi]paipe_]orkoqncej`kjkaolnepk`kao_n]rkia) `e`]mqaO _n]paor]e)hdab]vaj`klancqjp]oar]en]_ek_ej]j`k_kiaha* ?kikeookoane]lkoorah(ej`]c]Lh]pk(oakao_n]rkjkdkqraooaj]o_e`k_ki]n]vk a_kikolnej_leko`]n]_ekj]he`]`a;?kik`evanmqa_kjoacqeq`aikjopn]nkpaknai]lkn qi]lnaj`ev]`krej`k`]atlanej_e](oaahaf]i]eokqren]b]h]n`acakiapne]; J]Obm _if`^(Lh]pk`aoajrkhraqi]pakne]mqafbkn]ao^k]`]jkJklk6]pakne]`] naiejeo_j_e]*J]o_aiko_ki]n]vka]oe`ae]oran`]`aen]o(a]behkokbe]j]`]i]eob]v`k mqajkonahai^n]naoo]oe`ae]o* Lh]pkqicn]j`aao_nepknaqo]aioaqoao_nepkoqilnk_a`eiajpkhepannekmqak ]qtehe]]atlkn]opakne]oiqepk`eb_aeo*Aooalnk_a`eiajpk]^ibdlof^kqkjfql*Freiko qi]`]o]hackne]olh]pje_]oÍkIepk`]?]ranj]Í(p]i^ij]nn]`kj]Obm _if`^*L]n] atlhe_]n]pakne]`]naiejeo_j_e](kbeh okbkj]nn]kIepk`aAn* Kl]opknAn(`]nacek`]L]jbhe](iknnaqabkehar]`kl]n]kNaejk`koIknpko*=he_dac]j) `k(aj_kjpn]]o]hi]o`kodan eocnacko(`ackranj]jpao(`a]npeop]o(`aoaqo]jpal]oo]`koa ]iecko*=he(]o]hi]o_kjpailh]i]ran`]`aalkooqaik_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk* Anbe_]o]^aj`kmqapk`]o]o]hi]onaj]o_aiaikqpn]ore`]ol]n]oalqnebe_]nai`a oaqoannkol]oo]`ko]pmqajklna_eoaii]eorkhp]nPann](lani]ja_aj`kj]apanje`]`a* =jpao`arkhp]n]kjkookiqj`k(]o]hi]olk`aiao_khdan]jkr]re`]mqapank*=hcqi]o ao_khdai]re`]`anae(kqpn]o]`acqannaenk(kqpn]o]`a_kian_e]jpane_k(kqpn]o]`a]npeop]( kqpn]o]`ao^ek* Jk_]iejdk`anapknjkPann](]o]hi]o]pn]raoo]iqi]cn]j`alh]j_ealknkj`a_kn) naqinek(kHapd$mqa(aicnack(mqan`evanÎaomqa_eiajpkÏ%(a^a^ai`aoq]ocq]o*=omqa ^a^aiiqepkaomqa_aipk`]]ran`]`amqa_kjpailh]n]i7]omqa^a^ailkq_kmq]oajk oaaomqa_ai`kmqa_kjda_an]i* =o mqa ao_khdan]i re`] `a nae( `a cqannaenk kq `a _kian_e]jpa ne_k ok ]o mqa i]eo ^a^ai`]ocq]o`kaomqa_eiajpk7]omqaao_khdan]i]o`ao^ekok]omqaiajko^a^ai* =ooei(]olneiaen]o`ebe_ehiajpa$p]hravjqj_]%oahai^n]nk(j]jkr]re`](`]ran`]`amqa _kjda_an]i(ajmq]jpk]okqpn]ooank_]l]vao`ahai^n]napano]^a`kne](qo]j`k]n]vk* ?kjda_an(`evLh]pk(na_kn`]n]ran`]`amqafateopaaij o7`aolanp]n]n]vkl]n] mqaah]oaatan]lknoeiaoi]*LkneookO _n]paob]ve]lancqjp]o(lkeo(]pn]ro`ah]o(]olao) ok]olk`ane]ihai^n]n)oa`]ran`]`aa`kqok`]n]vk*Oajkj]o_ooaiko_ki]n]vka _ki]ran`]`a(ej`]c]Lh]pk(_kiko]^an]ikomqapaikoqi]e`ae]ran`]`aen]]kaj_kj) pn)h];?kiklk`an]iko`eopejcqenkran`]`aenk`kb]hok(oajkj]o_ooaiko_kjda_aj`k aoo]`ebanaj];
Ej]peoik_]npaoe]jk @ao_]npao`eo_qpa]pakne]`]oe`ae]oej]p]oairne]o`aoq]ok^n]o(i]o]oatlkoe ao i]eo_kjda_e`]oaj_kjpn]i)oaai`q]o`ah]o6jkAfp`roplaljqlalaj]oJbafq^ bpjb* q^cpf`^p*Jah]o(@ao_]npaoikopn]mqajkookaolnepklkooqepnopelko`ae`ae]omqaoa`eba) naj_e]ioacqj`koq]knecaiamq]he`]`a6 -*
E`ae]o]`rajp_e]o$eopk(rej`]o`abkn]%6ok]mqah]omqaoaknecej]i`ajkoo]ooajo] ao( lan_al ao(hai^n]j]o7ok]oe`ae]omqajkorilknpanikope`k]atlanej_e]oajokne]h kqoajorah`]o_keo]o]mqaoanabanai*Ok(`aqih]`k(]oe`ae]o`]omq]he`]`aooajokne]eo Í_kn(o]^kn(k`kn(oki(patpqn](p]i]jdk(hqc]n(ap_*Ía(`akqpnk(]oe`ae]o`]o_keo]olan) _a^e`]olkniaek`aoo]omq]he`]`ao*Okp]i^i]okleje aobkniqh]`]o]l]npen`aoo]o e`ae]okqjkoo]oe`ae]o_kpe`e]j]oa_kopqiaen]o(can]hiajpaajc]jko]okqb]ho]o(eopk(ok kleje aona_a^e`]oamqa(aican]h(jk_knnaolkj`aina]he`]`a`]oln lne]o_keo]o*
5,
=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`];x#!0É45,/ßx
Lknatailhk(oajp]`]jqi^]j_k`af]n`ei(rafk]khkjcaqik^fapkao_qnkaei ) rah*Lkni(kk^fapkoa]lnktei]arafkmqaqi]^kh]^n]j_]nkh]j`k*Mq]hlan_alk ran`]`aen];=lneiaen]kq]oacqj`];?kikkiaoikk^fapklk`alnk`qvenj]iaoi] laook]`q]oe`ae]opk`ebanajpao;=j`]j`kjkepalknqi]bhknaop](rafkikreiajpko aao_qpkokjo*Ajoej]n]i)iamqaeookokb]jp]oi]oa]_na`epkmqaaopkqj]lnaoaj] `aqi*I]o(mq]j`kn]e]k`e](`ao_q^nkmqakoikreiajpkoaokjorejd]i`ac]hdko napkn_e`ko`anrknaomqaoaiate]iok^krajpk*Khdkl]n]k_qarafkkOkhikran)oa `ahaopal]n]kaopa*Ajoej]n]i)iamqa]Pann]aopei rahamqakOkhoaikrarkhp] `ah]*I]o(mq]j`kaopq`k]opnkjkie](`ao_q^nkmqap]hklejekb]ho]* .* E`ae]obe_p_e]o6ok]mqah]omqa_ne]ikoaijkoo]b]jp]oe]aei]cej]k(_kilkj`koanao ejateopajpao_kila`]kokql]npao`ae`ae]o]`rajp_e]omqaaopkaijkoo]iai ne]* Lknatailhk(_]r]hk]h]`k(b]`]o(ahbko(`qaj`ao(`n]c ao(oanae](ap_*Ok]ob]^qh] ao `]o]npao(`]hepan]pqn](`ko_kjpkoejb]jpeo(`koiepko(`]ooqlanope ao*Aoo]oe`ae]ojqj_] okran`]`aen]o(lkeojk_knnaolkj`ai]j]`]mqaateop]na]hiajpaao]^aikomqabkn]i ejrajp]`]olknj o(iaoikmq]j`k]ona_a^aikoflnkjp]o`akqpnkomqa]oejrajp]n]i* /* E`ae]oej]p]o6ok]mqah]omqajklk`ane]iren`ajkoo]atlanej_e]oajokne]h(lknmqa jkdk^fapkooajokne]eokqoajoraeol]n]ah]o(jailk`ane]iren`ajkoo]b]jp]oe](lkeo jkperaikoatlanej_e]oajokne]hl]n]_kil)h]o]l]npen`ajkoo]iai ne]*Lknatailhk( ]e`ae]`kejbejepkej]p](lkeojkpaikojajdqi]atlanej_e]oajokne]h`]ejbejepq`a* oe`ae]oej]p]ookejpaen]iajpan]_ekj]eoao lk`aiateopenlknmqafj]o_aiko_ki = ah]o*Kolnej_leko`]n]vk$e`ajpe`]`a(jk_kjpn]`ek(pan_aenkat_hq`k(n]vkoqbe) _eajpa%oke`ae]oej]p]o*P]i^iokej]p]oe`ae]omqa@ao_]npao`ajkiej]`aÎjk ao _kiqjo`]n]vkÏ(_kik(lknatailhk(Îkpk`ki]eknmqa]ol]npaoÏ*Okp]i^iej]) p]o]oe`ae]ooeilhao_kjda_e`]olknejpqekejpaha_pq]h$_kikk_]ok`k`ldfql%*Lkn oanaioeilhao(]oe`ae]oej]p]ook_kjda_e`]olknejpqekaokah]oklkjpk`al]npe`] `]`a`qkn]_ekj]ha`]ej`qk(mqa_kjda_ai]oe`ae]o_kilhat]okq_kilkop]o* =o e`ae]o ej]p]o( `ev @ao_]npao( okÎ] ]ooej]pqn] `k ?ne]`knÏ jk aolnepk `]o _ne]pqn]o n]_ekj]eo(a]n]vk]hqvj]pqn]hej]p]mqajkolaniepa_kjda_an]ran`]`a*Reopkmqa ]oe`ae]oej]p]ook_khk_]`]oaijkookaolnepklkn@aqo(oankoailnaran`]`aen]o( eopk(oailna_knnaolkj`ankejpacn]hiajpao_keo]o]mqaoanabanai(a(cn]]o]ah]o( lk`aikofqhc]nmq]j`kqi]e`ae]]`rajp_e]ran`]`aen]kqb]ho]ao]^anmqa]oe`ae]o be_p_e]ookoailnab]ho]o$jk_knnaolkj`ai]j]`]bkn]`aj o%* =paoa_ajpn]h`koej]peop]o]oacqejpa6oa(`ao`ajkookj]o_eiajpk(jklkooqenikoai jkookaolnepk]n]vk_kioaqolnej_lekoahaeoa]hcqi]oe`ae]oran`]`aen]o`]omq]eo pk`]o]okqpn]o`alaj`ai(jqj_]panaiko_kiko]^anoaqi_kjda_eiajpkran`]`ae) nkkqb]hok(eopk(jqj_]o]^anaikooaqi]e`ae]_knnaolkj`akqjkna]he`]`a]mqa ah]oanabana*Jkpanaikoqi_nepnekoacqnkl]n]]r]he]njkooko_kjda_eiajpko*
Kaileneoik
?
kjpn]ne]iajpa]ko`abajoknao`kej]peoik(ko`abajoknao`kaileneoik]beni]imqa ]n]vk(]ran`]`aa]oe`ae]on]_ekj]eook]`mqene`]olknj olah]atlanej_e]*=jpao `]atlanej_e](`evaiahao(jkoo]n]vk_kikqi]Îbkhd]ai^n]j_kÏ(kj`aj]`] bkeao_nepk7qi]p^qh]n]o]kj`aj]`]bkecn]r]`k*Okiko_kikqi]_an]oaibkni]aoai j]`] eilnaook jah]( ]p mqa ] atlanej_e] rajd] ao_naran j] bkhd]( cn]r]n j] p^qh]( `]n bkni]_an]*=n]vkqi]i]jaen]`a_kjda_ana]]`mqeneiko$lkniaek`]atlanej_e] oajokne]h%jk`a_knnan`ajkoo]re`]*
Koaileneop]oejchaoao
5-
Jk`a_knnan`]deop ne]`]behkokbe](iqepkobeh okbko`abaj`an]i]paoaaileneop](i]o koi]eob]ikokoa_kjda_e`kookkobeh okbkoejchaoao`koo_qhkoTRE]kTREEE(_d]i]`ko(
*OHNß3MIBERT.ATIONALß0ORTRAITß 'ALLERY ß,ONDRES
&RANCISß"ACON߯ ß FILvSOFOßEßESTADISTAßINGLoS
3ANSSOUCI ß0OTSDAM
lkneook(`aaileneop]oejchaoao6Bn]j_eo>]_kj(Pdki]oDk^^ao(FkdjHk_ga(Caknca>angahau a@]re`Dqia* J]ran`]`a(kaileneoikqi]_]n]_panope_]iqepki]n_]jpa`]behkokbe]ejchao]*J] E`]`aI`e](lknatailhk(beh okbkoeilknp]jpao_kikNkcan>]_kjaCqehdania`aK_gd]i an]iaileneop]o7i]eoln teik]j o(>anpn]j`Nqooahhbkeqiaileneop]* Mqa`evaikoaileneop]o; Jkooko_kjda_eiajpko_kia]i_ki]atlanej_e]`kooajpe`ko(eopk(_ki]ooajo]) ao*Kok^fapkoatpaneknaoat_ep]ijkooko ncko`kooajpe`koaraiko_knao(oajpeikoo]^k) naoak`knao(kqreikookjo(oajpeiko]`ebanaj]ajpnakolankakheok(kmqajpaakbnek(ap_* =ooajo] aooanajaiabkni]iqi]lan_alk7kqoaf](lan_a^aikoqi]je_]_ke) o]kqqije_kk^fapkmqajko_dackqlkniaek`arne]oa`ebanajpaooajo] ao*=ooei(rafk qi]_knraniahd]aqi]bkni]]nna`kj`]`](]olenkqilanbqia]`k_e_]`k(oejpk]i]_eav a`eck6ÎLan_a^kqi]nko]Ï*=Înko]Ïknaoqhp]`k`]naqjek`arne]ooajo] ao`ebanajpao jqio k^fapk`alan_alk*
3MITHSONIANß)NSTITUTIONß,IBRARY ß 7ASHINGTON ß$#!RQUIVOßDAß%DITORA
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
'EORGEß"ERKELEYßß ¯
OkPki(]l opkhk `kÎranl]n]_nanÏ( lejp]`klkn ?]n]r]ccekai_*-2,-*
=olan_al ao(lknoq]rav(oa_ki^ej]ikqoa]ook_e]i*=]ook_e]klk`aoa`]nlkn pno ikperko6 lkn oaiahd]j]( lkn lnkteie`]`a kq _kjpecqe`]`a aol]_e]h a lkn oq_aook pailkn]h* = _]qo] `] ]ook_e]k `]o lan_al ao ] nalapek* Kq oaf]( `a p]jpk ]hcqi]o oajo] aooanalapenailknoaiahd]j]kq`ap]jpkoanalapenaijkiaoikaol]kkqln ) tei]oqi]o`]okqpn]o(kq(ajbei(`ap]jpkoanalapenaioq_aooer]iajpajkpailk(_ne]iko kd^epk`a]ook_e)h]o*Aoo]o]ook_e] aook]oe`ae]o* =oe`ae]o(pn]ve`]olah]atlanej_e](eopk(lah]oajo]k(lah]lan_alkalahkd^epk( okhar]`]oiai ne]a(`ah(]n]vk]o]l]jd]l]n]bkni]nkolajo]iajpko* =atlanej_e]ao_naraacn]r]aijkookaolnepk]oe`ae]o(a]n]vkr]e]ook_e)h]o(_ki) ^ej)h]okqoal]n)h]o(bkni]j`kpk`kokojkookolajo]iajpko*Lkneook(@]re`Dqia`en mqa]n]vkkd^epk`a]ook_e]ne`ae]o(oaf]lknoaiahd]j](oaf]lkn`ebanaj]* Katailhki]eoeilknp]jpa$lkn_]qo]`]o_kjoamqj_e]obqpqn]o%kbana_e`klknDqia l]n]ikopn]n_kikbkni]ikod^epkon]_ekj]eok`]knecai`klnej_lek`]_]qo]he`]`a* =atlanej_e]iaikopn](pk`koko`e]o(mqa(oaaqlqoanqihmqe`kjqina_eleajpaa har]n]kbkck(aooahmqe`kbanran(o]ej`k`kna_eleajpaok^]bkni]`ar]lkn*Oakna_eleajpa aoperanpkp]hiajpaba_d]`kaaqk`aop]il]n(na_a^anaeqi^]bk`ar]lkn(_kikoakna_e) leajpaperaooabe_]`klamqajkl]n]_kjpankhmqe`k*
5.
=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`];x#!0É45,/ßx
=atlanej_e]p]i^iiaikopn](pk`kkpailk(mqaoaaqlqoanqik^fapko he`k$qi la`]k`arah](qila`]k`abannk%jk_]hkn`kbkck(jko ahaoa`annapani]op]i^i l]oo]n]k_ql]nqiaol]kiqepki]eknjkejpanekn`kna_eleajpa*=atlanej_e]p]i^i nalapa_kjop]jpaiajpal]n]iei]lkooe^ehe`]`amqapajdk`anapen]nqik^fapklnaok`aj) pnk`aqikqpnk(oaaq]mqa_anaopahpeik(lkeo(]mqa_e`k(ahaokhp]kmqaaop]r]lnaokjkoaq ejpanekn(l]na_aj`k]h]nc]n)oaa]qiajp]n`ap]i]jdk* Atlanej_e]o`aooapelk(ia`e`]mqarkoanalapej`koailna`]iaoi]i]jaen](rk _ne]j`kaiieikd^epk`a]ook_e]nk_]hkn_ki_anpkob]pko*=`mqenkkd^epk`alan_a^an k_]hkna(aioacqe`](qib]pkecq]hkqoaiahd]jpa]kqpnkomqaflan_a^eejian]oravao* Aeookiahar]]`evanmqaÎk_]hkn]`^rp^`aooaob]pkoÏ*?kikkob]pkook`a]qiajpk`k rkhqiakq`]`eiajok`ko_knlkooq^iape`ko]k_]hkn(]_]^k_kj_hqej`kmqaÎk_]hkn] `^rp^`]`eh]p]k`ko_knlkoÏap]i^imqaÎ]`eh]p]k`ko_knlkokbcbfql`k_]hknÏ* ]ooei(`evDqia(mqaj]o_ai]o_ej_e]o*Okah]o(lknp]jpk(kd^epk`a]ook_e]ne`ae]o_kik _kjoamqj_e]`]nalapek`aatlanej_e]o* Kn](]kikopn]n_kikoabkni]klnej_lek`]_]qo]he`]`a(Dqiajkaop`evaj`k]la) j]omqa]oe`ae]o`]n]vkoaknecej]i`]atlanej_e](i]oaop]beni]j`kp]i^imqako ln lnekolnej_leko`]n]_ekj]he`]`aok`aner]`ko`]atlanej_e]* I]eo`kmqaeook*=n]vklnapaj`a(lkniaek`aoaqolnej_leko(oaqolnk_a`eiajpko aoq]oe`ae]o(]h_]j]n]na]he`]`aaioaqo]ola_pkoqjerano]eoaja_aooneko*Aikqpn]ol]) h]rn]o(lnapaj`a_kjda_an]na]he`]`ap]h_kikaioeiaoi](_kjoe`an]j`kmqakmqa_k) jda_ar]ha_kikran`]`al]n]pk`kokopailkoahqc]nao$qjerano]he`]`a%aej`e_]_kik]o _keo]ooka_kikjklk`ane]i(`aik`k]hcqi(oan`aqi]kqpn]i]jaen]$ja_aooe`]`a%* Kn](_kiDqiafjkoalk`a]`iepen]qjerano]he`]`aa]ja_aooe`]`alnapaj`e`]o lah]n]vk*Kqjerano]h]laj]oqijkiakqqi]l]h]rn]can]hmqaqo]ikol]n]jkonabanen nalapek`aoaiahd]j]olan_a^e`]oa]ook_e]`]o*Kja_aoonek]laj]okjkiakqqi] l]h]rn]can]hmqaqo]ikol]n]jkonabanennalapek`]olan_al aooq_aooer]ojkpailk*K qjerano]h(kja_aoonek(]_]qo]he`]`aokiankod^epkolomqe_ko*
Lnk^hai]o`kej]peoik
5/
Oakolnej_lekoa]oe`ae]o`]n]vkokej]pkoalkneookqjerano]eoaja_aooneko(_kik atlhe_]nmqalkoo]iiq`]n;Lknatailhk(Lh]pk]beni]r]mqa]e`ae]`afqope]an]ej]p]( rejd]`]_kjpailh]kejpaha_pq]h`kfqopkaioekq`k_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]h`]o_keo]o fqop]oaioe*Oaj`kej]p](an]qjerano]haja_aoone]* Oai`re`](`eve]kbeh okbkcnack(kooanaodqi]jkor]ne]iiqepkj]ooq]okleje ao ok^nakfqopka]fqope](lkeoaoo]okleje aooabkni]ilknatlanej_e]aaop]r]ne]`alaook] l]n]laook](`alk_]l]n]lk_](`ahqc]nl]n]hqc]n*Lkneookiaoik(okoeilhaolmfkfbp* Qi]fabf^sboa^abfo^(]k_kjpnnek(lknoanran`]`aen](ej]p](qjerano]haja_aoone]( jkokbnaj`k]or]ne] ao`]okleje ao(mqa(]hi`aoanair]neraeo(ok(jki]eo`]oravao( b]ho]o(lkeojkoo]atlanej_e]paj`a]oanajc]jko]kqajc]j]`]* Mq]han]]e`ae]lh]pje_]`]fqope];An]qi]e`ae]ikn]haqi]e`ae]lkhpe_]* Ikn]hiajpa(qi]laook]fqop]$ln]pe_]]e`ae]qjerano]h`]fqope]%mq]j`kb]v_ki mqakejpaha_pkkq]n]vk`kiejaa_kjpnkhaejpaen]a_kilhap]iajpaoaqoeilqhokol]ooek) j]eo(oaqooajpeiajpkoaoq]oaik aoenn]_ekj]eo*Lknmq;Lknmqakejpaha_pkkq]n]vk] l]npaiahdknaoqlanekn`]]hi]kqaolnepka`ara`kiej]n]l]npaejbaneknalekn(hec]`]]ko `aoafkoenn]_ekj]eo`kjkook_knlk* Lkhepe_]iajpa(qi]ok_ea`]`afqop]$eopk(ln]pe_]]e`ae]ej]p]aqjerano]h`afqope]% mq]j`kjah]]o_h]ooaook_e]eooanah]_ekj]i_kikj]ikn]h*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(mq]j`k]o _h]ooaoejbaneknaobknai`kiej]`]oa_kjpnkh]`]olah]o_h]ooaooqlaneknao* =ok_ea`]`afqop]_ne]qi]dean]nmqe]kqqi]ao_]h]`a_h]ooaook_e]eoa`alk`anaoj] mq]h ] _h]ooa a_kjie_] i]eo ejbanekn `ara oan `kiej]`] a _kjpnkh]`] lah] _h]ooa iehep]n l]n]mqa]onemqav]ojklnkrkmqai`aoecq]h`]`ao(ackoiko(cqann]o(rekhj_e]o7]_h]ooa iehep]n(lknoq]rav(`araoan`kiej]`]a_kjpnkh]`]lah]_h]ooalkhpe_]l]n]eila`enmqa koiehep]naomqaen]iqo]n]bkn]a]rekhj_e]_kjpn]]ok_ea`]`aab]vancqann]o]^oqn`]o*
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
Ajbei(]_h]ooalkhpe_]`araoan`kiej]`]a_kjpnkh]`]lahkoo^eko(mqajk`aet]nkmqa kolkhpe_ko]^qoai`klk`analnafq`emqaipk`]]ok_ea`]`a* Fqope](lknp]jpk(k`kijek`]ejpahecj_e]ok^nakoejopejpko(ejpanaooaoal]et ao( p]jpkjkej`er`qkmq]jpkj]ok_ea`]`a* Kn](_kikoqnceiajpk`]loe_]jheoa(kmqa]_kjpa_a_ki]fqope]ikn]hlh]pje_]( eopk(_ki]e`ae]`aqilk`anpkp]h`]n]vkok^na]ol]et aoakooajpeiajpko(ko`aoafko akoeilqhoko;Bnaq`(_ne]`kn`]loe_]jheoa(ikopnkqmqajkpaikoaooalk`an(mqajkoo] _kjo_ej_e](jkoo]rkjp]`aajkoo]n]vklk`aiiajko`kmqakjkookej_kjo_eajpa(eopk( `kmqak`aoafk*Oa]fqope]lh]pje_]an]qi]e`ae]ej]p]`]n]vk(`arane]oanqjerano]hiaj) paran`]`aen]aipk`kokopailko(i]o]loe_]jheoa_kjpaop]]e`ae]lh]pje_]*Klnk^hai]( lknp]jpk(6Î?kikqi]e`ae]ej]p]lk`a`aet]n`aoanran`]`aen];Ï* Kmqa]_kjpa_a_ki]e`ae]`]fqope]lkhpe_]lh]pje_]mq]j`k]hcqjobeh okbkomqa aopq`]n]i]bkni]k`]ook_ea`]`aoa`]lkhpe_]]beni]n]imqa]ecq]h`]`aqi`enaepk `a pk`ko ko _e`]`ko a mqa jajdqi] _h]ooa pai k `enaepk `a `kiej]n a _kjpnkh]n kqpn]o( lkeop]h`kijeka_kjpnkha(at]p]iajpa(]ejfqope];Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(qilajo]iajpk `aik_npe_klk`a]beni]nmqa]fqope]lh]pje_](lknoa^]oa]nj]`aoecq]h`]`a(ejfqop]* Kn](qi]e`ae]ej]p](lknoanlhaj]iajpan]_ekj]h(oailnaran`]`aen]a(lknp]jpk(paiko mqalancqjp]n6Î?kikqi]e`ae]ej]p](]bej]h(lan`aq]ran`]`a;Ï* Pkiaiko( ]ckn]( qi kqpnk atailhk( rej`k `] behkokbe] `a @ao_]npao* @ao_]npao _kj) oe`an]mqa]na]he`]`aj]pqn]hnace`]lknhaeoqjerano]eoaja_aoone]o`kikreiajpkkq lknnah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkaimqa]_]qo]oailnakikreiajpk(eopk(_kjoe`an]mqa ]j]pqnav]qi]na]he`]`aia_ je_]*?kjoe`an]p]i^imqa]ohaeoia_ je_]okqhaeo`k ikreiajpkah]^kn]`]olknoq]behkokbe]kqlknoq]boe_]oke`ae]on]_ekj]eo`a`qve`]o`a e`ae]oej]p]ooeilhaoaran`]`aen]o* Kn](mq]j`k_kil]n]iko]boe_]`a@ao_]npao_ki]`aC]hehaq(ah]^kn]`]j]iaoi] lk_](ranebe_]ikomqa(airneko]ola_pko(]boe_]c]heha]j]klkop]_]npaoe]j]a]mqa oanlnkr]`]a`aikjopn]`]ran`]`aen](a]`a@ao_]npaooan_kjoe`an]`]b]ho]*?kiklk`a) ne]eook]_kjpa_an(oa]oe`ae]o`]boe_]_]npaoe]j]an]ie`ae]oej]p]o`]n]vk; Koatailhkomqalnklqoaikoej`e_]imq]eookko`keocn]j`aolnk^hai]o`kej]peoik6 -*
]ln lne]n]vk$eopk(ko_kjda_eiajpkook^na]na]he`]`aakdkiai%lk`aiq`]nk _kjpa`k `a e`ae]o mqa bkn]i _kjoe`an]`]o qjerano]eo a ran`]`aen]o $ k _]ok`]e`ae] lh]pje_]`afqope]%7
.* ]ln lne]n]vk$eopk(kolnk_a`eiajpko`an]_ek_jek%lk`alnkr]nmqae`ae]o_kjoe`an]`]o n]_ekj]eolk`ai(j]na]he`]`a(oanb]ho]o$k_]ok`arne]oe`ae]o`]boe_]_]npaoe]j]%* Oa]oe`ae]ookn]_ekj]eoaran`]`aen]o(lknmqa_knnaolkj`aina]he`]`a*Kn](oa]na]) he`]`aiq`]n$_kikk_]ok`]na]he`]`aok_e]hkqdeop ne_]%(reopkmqaqi]e`ae]ran`]`aen] `ara_knnaolkj`anna]he`]`a(_kiki]jpane`ae]omqajk]lnaoajp]ip]h_knnaolkj`j_e]; Kq(]k_kjpnnek(oa]na]he`]`alani]ja_an]iaoi]$_kikk_]ok`]na]he`]`aj]pqn]hkq`] j]pqnav]%a(jkajp]jpk(]oe`ae]omqa]oatlhe_]r]ilan`an]i]r]he`]`alknmqakqpn]oi]eo _knnap]oaran`]`aen]o]ooq^opepqn]i(_kik_kjoe`an]n]olneiaen]oe`ae]o_kikran`]`ao ej]p]o;Kqoaf](kej]peoikoa`al]n]_kiklnk^hai]`]iq`]j]`]na]he`]`a$mqaatecaiq) `]j]`]oe`ae]o%(a_ki]iq`]j]`]oln lne]oe`ae]o(baep]lah]ln lne]n]vkjklnk_aook`a _kjda_eiajpk(]hi`klnk^hai]`]b]hoe`]`a`]oe`ae]o(`aikjopn]`]lah]ln lne]n]vk*
Lnk^hai]o`kaileneoik Kaileneoik(lknoq]rav(oa`abnkjp]_kiqilnk^hai]ejokhrah* Oa]o_ej_e]ook]laj]od^epkoloe_kh ce_ko`a]ook_e]nlan_al aoae`ae]olknoaia) hd]j]a`ebanaj](^ai_kiklkn_kjpecqe`]`aaol]_e]hkqoq_aookpailkn]h(ajpk]o _ej_e]ojklkooqairan`]`a]hcqi](jkatlhe_]ina]he`]`a]hcqi](jkjko`k_anpav] ]hcqi]ok^na]na]he`]`a(jk]h_]j]ikok^fapkop]eo_kikokaioeiaoikoap]eo_kik bqj_ekj]ikqklan]ina]hiajpa*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ko_kjda_eiajpkojklkooqaik^fa) pere`]`a(lkeook]laj]od^epkooq^faperko*
50
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoik6okhq aobehko be_]ox#!0É45,/ßx
Kn](ke`a]hn]_ekj]h`]k^fapere`]`a]beni]mqaqi]ran`]`aqi]ran`]`alknmqa _knnaolkj`ana]he`]`a`]o_keo]oa(lknp]jpk(jk`alaj`a`ajkookockopko(jkoo]okle) je ao(jkoo]olnabanj_e]o(jkookolna_kj_aepko(jkoo]ob]jp]oe]o(jkooko_kopqiaoad^epko* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(jkoq^faper](jk`alaj`a`ajkoo]re`]laook]haloe_kh ce_]*Aoo] k^fapere`]`a(lkni(l]n]kaileneop](]_ej_e]jklk`akbana_anjaic]n]jpen* =_ej_e](iankd^epkloe_kh ce_kkqoq^faperk(pknj])oa]bej]hqi]ehqok(a]na]he`]`a p]h_kikaioeiaoi]$]na]he`]`ak^faper]%f]i]eolk`anoan_kjda_e`]lah]jkoo]n]vk* >]op](lknatailhk(mqaaqlkjd]qihmqe`kjkbkcka(aihqc]n`ar)hkbanrana]qiajp]n `arkhqia(aqkraf]cah]na`eiejqen`arkhqia(l]n]mqapk`]]_ej_e]`ao]l]na](fmqa ah]`alaj`a`]nalapek(`]bnamqj_e](`kd^epk`aoailnalan_a^anikoqi]_anp]oq_ao) ok`ab]pkomq]h(p]i^ilknd^epk(`aikokjkia`amofk`mfla^`^rp^ifa^ab* =ooei(`kh]`k`kaileneoik(klnk^hai]_khk_]`kk`]eilkooe^ehe`]`a`k_kjda_e) iajpkk^faperk`]na]he`]`a*
#APqTULOß
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`k aileneoik6okhqaobehkobe_]o Ej]peoikaaileneoik6mqaop aoanaolkop]o
R
,EIBNIZ߯ ß FILvSOFOßEßMATEMfTICOß ALEMjO
eiko(jk_]lpqhk]jpanekn(mqa]n]vkajbnajp]lnk^hai]oonekomq]jpkoq]ej) pajk`aoan_kjda_eiajpkqjerano]haja_aoonek`]na]he`]`a*Reikop]i^imqa( _kik_kjoamqj_e]`a_kjbhepkoaeil]ooaoajpnakej]peoikakaileneoik(oqnceq j]behkokbe]]paj`j_e]]k_ape_eoik(eopk(l]ookq)oa]`qre`]n`amqak_kjda_eiajpkn]) _ekj]h(_kik_kjda_eiajpk_anpk(ran`]`aenkaejmqaopekjrah(oane]lkoorah* Jaopa_]lpqhkr]ikoat]iej]n]hcqi]ookhq aolnklkop]olah]behkokbe]l]n]naokhran aoo]mqaopk*Kolnk^hai]o_ne]`kolah]`erancj_e]ajpnaej]peop]oaaileneop]obkn]ina) okhre`koai`keoikiajpko6klneiaenk]jpaneknbehkokbe]`a@]re`Dqiaaaj_kjpn])oa j]behkokbe]`aHae^jev$beh okbk]haik`ko_qhkTREE%7koacqj`klkopaneknbehkokbe]`a Dqiaaaj_kjpn])oaj]behkokbe]`aG]jp$beh okbk]haik`ko_qhkTREEE%*
=okhqk`aHae^jevjko_qhkTREE
H 51
ae^jevaop]^aha_aqqi]`eopejkajpnasboa^abpabo^wlasboa^abpabc^ql* =oran`]`ao`an]vkajqj_e]imqaqi]_keo]kmqaah](ja_aoone]aqjerano]hiaj) pa(jklk`aj`k`aik`k]hcqioan`ebanajpa`kmqaa`a_kik*Katailhki]eoare`aj) pa`]oran`]`ao`an]vkok]oe`ae]oi]paipe_]o*eilkoorahmqakpne jcqhkjkpajd] pnoh]`koamqa]oki]`aoaqo jcqhkoejpanjkojkoaf]ecq]hoki]`a`keo jcqhkonapko7 eilkoorahmqaqi_n_qhkjkpajd]pk`kokolkjpkoamqe`eop]jpao`k_ajpnkamqajk oaf]]becqn]bkni]`]lahkikreiajpk`aqioaieaetk]kna`kn`aqi_ajpnkbetk7eilko) orahmqa.'.jkoaf]ecq]h]07eilkoorahmqakpk`kjkoaf]i]ekn`kmqa]ol]npao*
=okhqkg]jpe]j]jko_qhkTREEE
=
naolkop]]kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoikkbana_e`]lahkbeh okbk]haik `ko_qhkTREEE(Eii]jqahG]jp(_kjda_e`]_kikjkia`aÎnarkhqk_klanje) _]j]Ïaibehkokbe]*Lknmq;Mq]h]nah]kajpnakmqalnkl aG]jpakmqabevan] ?klnje_k(mq]oa`keoo_qhko]jpao`kg]jpeoik; Raf]iko(iqepk^naraiajpa(kmqabke]narkhqk_klanje_]j]ai]opnkjkie]l]n]( `alkeo(ranikokmqaah]oecjebe_kqaibehkokbe]* =pn]`ek]jpec]aia`ear]h_kjoe`an]r]mqakiqj`klkooq]heiepao$kqoaf](kiqj) `kan]bejepk%(oaj`kbkni]`klknqi_kjfqjpk`aoapaaoban]o_kj_jpne_]o(ai_qfk_ajpnk aop]r]]Pann](ei rah* Çrkhp]`]Pann]cen]r]i]oaoban]oj]omq]eoaop]r]ilnaokokolh]jap]o$kOkha]Hq] an]i_kjoe`an]`kolh]jap]o%(a]hpei]`aoo]oaoban]oan]`ajkiej]`]Îaoban]bet]ÏkqÎaoba) n]`kobetkoÏ(eopk(kj`aaop]r]iaopnah]omqajkiq`]r]i`alkoek*Aicnack(Pann]oa `evD^f^kqDbf^*?kikah]oaaj_kjpn]r]jk_ajpnk(koeopai]]opnkjie_kan]_d]i]`k`a dbl`kqof`lakiqj`kan]atlhe_]`klahkdbl`bkqofpjl*@eve])oamqak?q$]oaoban]o%cen]) r]aipknjk`]Pann]ei rah*=_d]i]`]obslir l`lmbokf`^k^bkena]hev]`]lahk]opnjkik
!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
=oran`]`ao`an]vkokej]p]o*Eookjkoecjebe_]mqaqi] _ne]j](lknatailhk(j]o]_kjda_aj`k]i]paipe_]ao]^aj) `kna]hev]nklan] aoi]paipe_]o(`aikjopn]npaknai]okqna) okhranlnk^hai]ojaoo]na]`k_kjda_eiajpk*Oecjebe_]mqaj]o) _aiko _ki ] _]l]_e`]`a n]_ekj]h( lqn]iajpa ejpaha_pq]h( l]n] _kjda_an e`ae]o mqa jk `alaj`ai `] atlanej_e] l]n] oanai bkniqh]`]oal]n]oanairan`]`aen]o* =o ran`]`ao `a b]pk( ]k _kjpnnek( ok ]o mqa `alaj`ai `] atlanej_e]( lkeo ajqj_e]i e`ae]o mqa ok k^pe`]o lkn iaek `] oajo]k(`]lan_alka`]iai ne]*=oran`]`ao`ab]pkokai) lne_]oaoanabanai]_keo]omqalk`ane]ioan`ebanajpao`kmqa ok(i]omqaok_kikoklknmqadqi]_]qo]l]n]mqaoaf]i ]ooei*Mq]j`k`eckÎAop]nko]raniahd]Ï(j]`]eila`amqaah] lq`aooaoan^n]j_]kq]i]nah](i]ooaah]raniahd]lknmqa ]hcqi]_]qo]]bavoan]ooeiaqi]kqpn]_]qo]lk`ane]p)h]baepk ?n_qhklnapk*Lejpqn]`a-5-/`aG]oeien I]hare_d(]npeop]]^opn]pknqookmqa( ]i]nah]*I]ojk]_e`ajp]hkq_kjpejcajpamqaah]pajd]`lo(a l]n]he^anp]n]]npa`kiqj`kreorah( ]_knmqalkooqeqi]`^rp^kb`bppof^*Kqoaf](qi]nko]lk`apan ^qo_kqnabcekj]obkni]ocakipne_]o* aop]kq]mqah]_kn(i]ojklk`a`aet]n`apan_kn(_]^aj`kn]vk ^qo_]n]_]qo]`]_kn(aopq`]j`k]j]pqnav]`]hqv* =oran`]`ao`ab]pkokran`]`aolknmqal]n]ah]obqj_ekj]klnej_lek`an]vkoqbe) _eajpa(oacqj`kkmq]hpq`kkmqaateopa(pq`kkmqalan_a^aikoapq`k]mqehk`amqapaiko atlanej_e]lkooqeqi]_]qo]`apaniej]`]aaoo]_]qo]lk`aoan_kjda_e`]*Lahklnej_lek `a n]vk oqbe_eajpa Í eopk ( lahk _kjda_eiajpk `]o _]qo]o Í pk`]o ]o ran`]`ao `a b]pk lk`ank(ai_anp]o_kj`e ao(pknj]n)oa(qi`e](ran`]`aoja_aoone]oaoanai_kjoe`an]`]o ran`]`ao`an]vk(eopk(]ej`]mqal]n]_kjda_)h]o`alaj`]iko`]atlanej_e](lk`aiko `aoajrkhranlnk_a`eiajpkolahkomq]eo`ao_k^neikomqa]atlanej_e]aopkbana_aj`kna) h] ao_]qo]eoja_aoone]oajpna]o_keo]o*L]n]Hae^jev(kmqaokran`]`ao`ab]pkl]n]]ejpa) hecj_e]dqi]j]heiep]`]kqbejep]okran`]`ao`an]vkl]n]]ejpahecj_e]`erej]ejbejep]* K^oanr]iko(]ooei(mqa(l]n]Hae^jev(klnej_lek`an]vkoqbe_eajpakq]e`ae]`a_]q) o]he`]`aqjerano]haja_aoone]laniepai]jpan]oe`ae]oej]p]oa]oe`ae]oailne_]o* Kn](fqop]iajpaklnej_lek`]_]qo]he`]`a(_kikreiko(mqaoan]hrk`]o_npe_]o`ko aileneop]o(j]behkokbe]`a@]re`Dqia*L]n]aooabeh okbk(klnej_lek`an]vkoqbe_eajpa ]laj]oqid^epk]`mqene`klknatlanej_e]_kiknaoqhp]`k`]nalapeka`]bnamqj_e] .ICOLAUß#OPmRNICOß `a jkoo]o eilnaoo ao oajokne]eo* = _npe_] `a Dqia _]qo]he`]`a a ]k lnej_lek `a n]vk ¯ oqbe_eajpahar]naolkop]`aG]jp*
-USEUß(ERMITAGE ß3jOß0ETERSBURGO ß2{SSIA
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
3OLßEß,UAßCOMOßPLANETASß PORßISSO ßOSßANTIGOSßEßME DIEVAISßFALAVAMßNOSß3ETEß 0LANETASßOUß3ETEß3fBIOS ß QUEßAPARECEMßNASßCARTASß DEßTARx ßPOISßESSEßBARALHOß mßUMAßINVENljOßMEDIEVALß QUEßCORRESPONDEßgSßIDEIASß EßgßVISjOßDEßUMßMUNDOß DAQUELESßTEMPOS ßQUANDOß Oß3OLßEßAß,UAßERAMßTIDOSß COMOßPLANETAS ßOßMUNDOß TERMINAVAßNAßESFERAßDOß SmTIMOßCmUßEßAß4ERRAßFICAVAß IMvVELßNOßCENTROßDOßMUN DOßbßINTERESSANTEßQUE ß NOßSmCULOß88 ßDEPOISßDASß DESCOBERTASßASTRONxMICASß EßDASßVIAGENSßESPACIAIS ßASß PESSOASßAINDAßACREDITEMß NOßTARx ßCOMOßSEßFOSSEß UMAßESPmCIEßDEßIDEIAßINA TA ßVERDADEIRA ßUNIVERSALßEß NECESSfRIA
52
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoik6okhq aobehko be_]ox#!0É45,/ßx REVOLUljOßAßPALAVRAßß REVOLUljOßQUEßAPARECEß NOßTqTULOßDAßOBRAßDEß #OPmRNICO ßmßUMßTERMOß ASTRONxMICOßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±MOVIMENTOßCOMPLETOßß DEßUMßASTROßOUßDEßUMß SISTEMAßDEßASTROSßQUEß RETORNAßAOßPONTOßß INICIALßEßRECOMElA²
RAZjOß/ßTEXTOßDEß+ANTß ENCONTRA SEßNAß)NTRODUljOß DAßSEGUNDAßEDIljOßDAßß #RqTICAßDAßRAZjOßPURAßEßDIZß OßSEGUINTEß±4ENTEMOS ß POIS ßUMAßVEZ ßEXPERIMEN TARßSEßNjOßSEßRESOLVERjOß MELHORßASßTAREFASßDAß METAFqSICA ßADMITINDOß QUEßOSßOBJETOSßSEßDEVE RIAMßREGULARßPELOßNOSSOß CONHECIMENTO ßOßQUEß ASSIMßJfßCONCORDAßMELHORß COMßOßQUEßDESEJAMOS ß AßSABER ßAßPOSSIBILIDADEß DEßUMßCONHECIMENTOßAß PRIORIßDESSESßOBJETOS ßQUEß ESTABELElAßALGOßSOBREßELESß ANTESßDEßNOSßSEREMßDADOSß 4RATA SEßAQUIßDEßUMAßSE MELHANlAßCOMßAßPRIMEIRAß IDEIAßDEß#OPmRNICOßNjOß PODENDOßPROSSEGUIRßNAß EXPLICAljOßDOSßMOVIMEN TOSßCELESTESßENQUANTOßß ADMITIAßQUEßTODAßAßMULTI DjOßDEßESTRELASßSEßMOVIAß EMßTORNOßDOßOBSERVADOR ß TENTOUßSEßNjOßDARIAßME LHORßRESULTADOßFAZERßANTESß GIRARßOßOBSERVADORßEßß DEIXARßOSßASTROSßIMvVEIS²
53
?klnje_kmq]j`k`]lq^he_]k(ai-10/(`aoq]k^n]A^pobslir bpalplo_bp`bibpqbp(ai mqa`aikjopn]r]mqakoeopai]cak_jpne_kjk`]r]_kjp]`koikreiajpko_ahaopaoa`a iqepkokqpnkobajiajko]opnkjie_ko* Qi] `]o _]n]_panope_]o i]eo i]n_]jpao `k cak_ajpneoik an] k b]pk `a mqa ^]oa]r] oq]oatlhe_] aoaijkoo]atlanej_e]oajokne]h(eopk(jkb]pk`amqalan_a^aikokik) reiajpk`kOkha`ko`ai]eo]opnko(i]ojklan_a^aikokikreiajpk`]Pann]alkneook ] _kjoe`an]iko ei rah* Kn]( ao_nara ?klnje_k(Îpk`] iq`]j] `a lkoek mqa oa r kq `are`]]kikreiajpk`aqi]_keo]k^oanr]`]kq`kk^oanr]`kn(kq]ej`]`aqia`a kqpnkÏ*Eopk(jkdikperkn]_ekj]hl]n]_kjoe`an]nikomqak?qoaikraa]Pann]aop ei rah(lkeolk`ane]oank_kjpnnekkq(]piaoik(lk`ane]`]n)oamqa]i^koaoperaooai aiikreiajpk*=hi`eook(`ev?klnje_k(Îqioeopai]mqa_khkmqakOkhjk_ajpnka]Pan) n]cen]j`koq]rkhp]iqepki]eo]`amq]`kl]n]atlhe_]nkobajiajko]opnkjie_koÏ* $?klnje_kfqhc]r]mqakOkhoai]jpejd]ei rahjk_ajpnk`koeopai](i]o(lkopanekniaj) pa(ko]opnjkiko`aikjopn]n]imqakln lnekOkhna]hev]qiikreiajpk`apn]joh]k( eopk(p]i^ioaikra(i]ojkairkhp]`]Pann]7fqhc]r]p]i^imqakikreiajpk`ko lh]jap]oan]_en_qh]n(i]oGalhan`aikjopn]nmqaahlpe_k*% Aicnack(Okhoa`evEbiflpalkneookkoeopai]`a?klnje_k_d]i]`k`aebifl`kqof`l( aoq]atlhe_]k(`aebifl`bkqofpjl(lkeokOkhaopjk_ajpnk`kjkookoeopai]lh]japneka pq`koaikra]koaqna`kn* Rkhpaiko]ckn]]G]jpak^oanraikokmqaaha`ev* Ej]peop]oaaileneop]o(eopk(pk`kokobeh okbkol]na_aioan_kik]opnjkikocak_jpne) _ko(^qo_]j`kqi_ajpnkmqajkran`]`aenk*L]na_ai(`evG]jp(Î_kik]hcqimqa(mqanaj) `k]oo]nqibn]jck(bevaooakbkckcen]naipknjk`ahaajkkbn]jckaipknjk`kbkckÏ* Mq]hkajc]jk`kobeh okbko;?kjoe`an]nmqak_kjda_eiajpkoaeje_e]paj`k_kiklkjpk `al]npe`]]na]he`]`a6jk_]ok`koej]peop]o(_kik@ao_]npao(]na]he`]`aeje_e]hkejpanekn(k aolnepk(]]hi]dqi]j](mqa@ao_]npao_d]i]`aÎ_keo]lajo]jpaÏkqÎoq^op j_e]lajo]jpaÏ7 jk_]ok`koaileneop]o(]na]he`]`aeje_e]hatpanekn(kiqj`kkq]j]pqnav]*Kn](`evG]jp(Îk lkjpk`al]npe`]`]behkokbe]jklk`aoan]na]he`]`a$oaf]ejpanj](oaf]atpanj]%aoeikaopq`k `]ln lne]b]_qh`]`a`a_kjda_ankqkaopq`k`]n]vkÏ*@ab]pk(kobeh okbko]jpaneknao(ai hqc]n`a(lneiaenka]jpao`apq`k(aopq`]nkmqa]ln lne]n]vkaej`]c]nkmqaah]lk`a akmqajklk`a_kjda_an(kmqa]atlanej_e]akmqaah]lk`aajklk`a_kjda_an7ai rav(ajbei(`alnk_qn]no]^ankmqa_kjda_an(kmqalajo]nakmqa]ran`]`a(lnabanen]i _kia]n`evaj`kkmqa]na]he`]`a$]j]pqnav]akaolnepkdqi]jk%(]beni]j`kmqaah]n]) _ekj]hamqa(lkneook(lk`aoanejpaen]iajpa_kjda_e`]lah]oe`ae]o`]n]vk*?khk_]n]i]na]) he`]`a$p]jpk]`kiqj`katpanekn_kik]`]]hi]dqi]j]%kqkok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpk jk_ajpnkabevan]i]n]vk(kqkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(cen]naipknjk`ah]* B]]iko(lkeo(qi]narkhqk_klanje_]j]aibehkokbe](ao_naraG]jpaioq]k^n]@o* qf`^a^o^wlmro^6]p]ckn](fqhc]r])oaÎmqajkook_kjda_eiajpk`are]oannacqh]`klahko k^fapkoÏ(i]o]ckn]`araikoÎ]`iepenmqakok^fapko`arainacqh]n)oalahkjkook_kjda_e) iajpkÏ*?klnje_k(ao_naraG]jp(Îjk_kilhapkqoq]atlhe_]k(ah]bke_kilhap]`]a_kn) nece`]lknGalhanaJaspkj(mqaikopn]n]imqakmqaahafqhc]r]oanqi]^k]del paoaan]( na]hiajpa(]ran`]`aen]aja_aoone]atlhe_]k]opnkjie_]Ï*Çi]jaen]_klanje_]j]$eopk (`kdahek_ajpneoik_kikpakne]_eajpbe_]`aikjopn]`]%(lnkooacqaG]jp(Î`aikjopnaiko( p]i^i`ai]jaen]qjerano]haja_aoone](mqakok^fapkooa]`]lp]i]k_kjda_eiajpka jkk_kjda_eiajpk]kok^fapkoÏ*Kqoaf](_kia_aiko_khk_]j`kjk_ajpnk]ln lne]n]vk* Jk]n]vk]HqvJ]pqn]h;Jkah]kOkhmqaehqiej]pk`]o]o_keo]oaaipknjk`kmq]h pq`kcen];?kia_aiko(lknp]jpk(lah]HqvJ]pqn]hjk_ajpnk`k_kjda_eiajpkaej`]cqaiko6 ÎKmqaah];Ï(ÎKmqaah]lk`a_kjda_an;Ï(ÎMq]eook]o_kj`e aol]n]mqad]f]_kjda_eiajpk ran`]`aenk;Ï(ÎMq]eookkoheiepaomqak_kjda_eiajpkdqi]jkjklk`apn]jolkn;Ï(Î?kik ]n]vka]atlanej_e]oanah]_ekj]i;Ï* ?kia_aiko( ajpk( lah] n]vk lknmqa( lkn iaek `a oaq aopq`k( _kilnaaj`anaiko k mqaoklprgbfqlal`lkeb`fjbkqlall_gbqlal`lkeb`fjbkql*?kia_aikolah]_npe_]`] n]vklqn]*
-USEUßDOß0RADO ß-ADRI
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
Lknmqa`oqf`^;?kiaoo]l]h]rn](G]jpmqan`evanmqajk oankat]iej]`koko_kjda_eiajpkomqa]n]vk]h_]j]aoei]o `lkaf bpj]omq]eok_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]hlkoorah*Lknmqa mro^;Lknmqaoapn]p]`kat]ia`]n]vk]jpaoaoaiko`]`ko kbana_e`kolah]atlanej_e]*Ao_naraahamqa]_npe_]jk_npe) _]`ahernkoa`aoeopai]obehko be_koaoei`]ln lne]b]_qh`]`a `]n]vkaican]h(_kjoe`an]`]aipk`koko_kjda_eiajpkomqa lk`a]h_]j]noair]han)oa`]atlanej_e]*Kqoaf](ran`]`amqa pk`ko ko jkooko _kjda_eiajpko `ljb ^j _ki ] atlanej_e]( i]ojkran`]`amqapk`koahaomolsbke^j`ah]* ?kik k aopq`k oa nabana o _kj`e ao ja_aoone]o a qjeran) o]eo`apk`k_kjda_eiajpklkoorah]jpao`]atlanej_e]aoaiko `]`ko`]atlanej_e](p]haopq`kjkailne_k*Kqoaf](^moflof $pailnekne`]`a_kinah]katlanej_e](]jpaneknatlanej) _e]ajklnkri`ah]%ajk^mlpqboflof$lkopaneknatlanej_e] a`alaj`ajpa`]atlanej_e]%*G]jp`evmqaahaqo^kp`bkabkq^i( `evaj`kmqa_d]i]`apn]jo_aj`ajp]hÎpk`k_kjda_eiajpkmqa( aican]h(oak_ql]iajko`kok^fapkoai]eo`ajkookik`k`a _kjda_an(j]ia`e`]aimqaaopa`araoan^moflofÏ* Kmqa]n]vk; =n]vkqi]aopnqpqn]r]ve](qi]bkni]lqn]oai_kjpa) `ko*Aoo]aopnqpqn]$ajkko_kjpa`ko%mqaqjerano]h(]iao) i]l]n]pk`kokooanaodqi]jko(aipk`kokopailkoahqc]nao* Kokjdk`]n]vklnk`qv Aoo]aopnqpqn]ej]p](eopk(jk]`mqene`]lah]atlanej_e]*Lkn ikjopnko(cn]rqn]`a oanej]p]ajk`alaj`an`]atlanej_e]l]n]ateopen(]n]vk(`k Bn]j_eo_kCku]`a_*-353)54* lkjpk `a reop] `k _kjda_eiajpk( ^kqboflo bumbofk`f^ a fkab* mbkabkqba^bumbofk`f^(lknp]jpk(]aopnqpqn]`]n]vk^moflof* Lkni(ko_kjpa`komqa]n]vk_kjda_aajkomq]eoah]lajo](aooaooei`alaj`ai`] atlanej_e]*Oaiah](]n]vkoane]oailnar]ve](ejklan]jpa(j]`]_kjda_ane]*=ooei(]atla) nej_e]bknja_a^j^qof^$ko_kjpa`ko%`k_kjda_eiajpkl]n]]n]vkaaop](lknoq]rav( bknja_a^cloj^$qjerano]haja_aoone]%`k_kjda_eiajpk*=i]pne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(lkn oanbknja_e`]lah]atlanej_e](raiabmlfp`aop]alkneook(jk`evan`aG]jp(^mlpqboflof* Mq]hkajc]jk`koej]peop]o;Oqlknmqako_kjpa`kokq]i]pne]`k_kjda_eiajpk okej]pkomq]j`kkmqaej]pk]aopnqpqn]`]n]vk* Mq]hkajc]jk`koaileneop]o;Oqlknmqa]aopnqpqn]`]n]vk]`mqene`]lknatlanej) _e]kq_]qo]`]lah]atlanej_e]*J]ran`]`a(`evG]jp(]atlanej_e]jk_]qo]`]oe`ae]o( i]o]l`^pfll]n]mqa]n]vk(na_a^aj`k]i]pne]kqk_kjpa`k(bkniqha]oe`ae]o* @aoo]i]jaen](]aopnqpqn]`]n]vkej]p]aqjerano]h(ajmq]jpkko_kjpa`kookai) lne_koalk`air]ne]njkpailkajkaol]k(lk`aj`kpn]jobkni]n)oa_kijkr]oatlanej) _e]oaiaoiknarah]nai)oab]hoko(cn]]o]atlanej_e]ojkr]o* Kmqak_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]h(oaikmq]hjkdbehkokbe]jai_ej_e]; ]pkqbpbmqa]n]vkna]hev]ajpnaqi]bkni]qjerano]hej]p]aqi_kjpa`kl]npe_q) h]nkbana_e`klah]atlanej_e]* Mq]h]aopnqpqn]`]n]vk;=n]vk_kjopepq`]lknpnoaopnqpqn]o^moflof6 -*
]aopnqpqn]kqbkni]`]oajoe^ehe`]`a(eopk(]aopnqpqn]kqbkni]`]lan_alkoajorah kqoajokne]h7
.* ]aopnqpqn]kqbkni]`kajpaj`eiajpk(eopk(`kejpaha_pkkq`]ejpahecj_e]7 /* ]aopnqpqn]kqbkni]`]n]vklnklne]iajpa`ep](mq]j`kaop]jkoanah]_ekj]jai_ki ko _kjpa`ko `] oajoe^ehe`]`a jai _ki ko _kjpa`ko `k ajpaj`eiajpk( i]o ]laj]o _kjoeck iaoi]* ?kik( l]n] G]jp( o d _kjda_eiajpk mq]j`k ] atlanej_e] kbana_a _kjpa`ko oajoe^ehe`]`a a ]k ajpaj`eiajpk( ] n]vk( oal]n]`] `] oajoe^ehe`]`a a `k
54
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoik6okhq aobehko be_]ox#!0É45,/ßx
ajpaj`eiajpk(kl`lkeb`b`lfp^^idrj^ajkoq]bqjk_kjda_an*Oq]bqjk]`a obdri^ob`lkqoli^o]oajoe^ehe`]`aakajpaj`eiajpk*@klkjpk`areop]`k_kjda_eiaj) pk(lknp]jpk(]n]vk]bqjknacqh]`kn]`]]pere`]`a`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk* =bkni]`]oajoe^ehe`]`akmqajkolaniepapanlan_al ao(eopk(]bkni]]mqehk oaikmqajklk`ad]ranlan_alk(oaikmqa]lan_alkoane]eilkoorah*Lan_a^aiko pk`]o]o_keo]o_kik`kp]`]o`abecqn](`eiajo ao$]hpqn](h]ncqn](_kilneiajpk%(cn]j`av]7 kqoaf](j o]olan_a^aiko_kikna]he`]`aoaol]_e]eo* Jkejpanaoo]oa_]`]qi`aj or]o_knao`aqi]_anp]i]jaen](ckop]i]eo`aqi] _kn`kmqa`akqpn](kqraokjo`aqi]bkni]la_qhe]n(ckop]i]eo`a_anpkookjo`kmqa`a kqpnko(ap_*Kmqaeilknp]mqaj]`]lk`aoanlan_a^e`klknj ooajklkooqenlnklnea`]`ao aol]_e]eo7lkneook(kbpm^ ljk]hcklan_a^e`k(i]okmqalaniepad]ranlan_alk$lan) _a^aikohqc]nao(lkoe ao(oepq] ao(i]ojklan_a^aikokln lnekaol]k%*=ooei(kaol]k ]bkni]^moflof`]oajoe^ehe`]`aaateopaaijkoo]n]vk]jpaoaoai]atlanej_e]* P]i^io lk`aikolan_a^an]o_keo]o_kikoeiqhp ja]okqoq_aooer]o6lan_a^aiko ]o_keo]o_kikoak_knnaooaijqio ejop]jpakqaiejop]jpaooq_aooerko*Kqoaf](lan_a^a) iko]o_keo]o_kikna]he`]`aopailkn]eo*Jklan_a^aikokpailk$paikoatlanej_e]`k l]oo]`k(`klnaoajpaa`kbqpqnk(lknijkpaikolan_alk`kln lnekpailk%(i]oaha ]_kj`ek`alkooe^ehe`]`a`]lan_alk`]o_keo]oalkneooklqbjml]kqpn]bkni]^ moflof`]oajoe^ehe`]`amqaateopaaijkoo]n]vk]jpao`]atlanej_e]aoai]atlanej_e]* = lan_alk na_a^a _kjpa`ko `] atlanej_e] a ] oajoe^ehe`]`a ko knc]jev] n]_ekj]h) iajpaoacqj`k]bkni]`kaol]ka`kpailk*Aoo]knc]jev]kaol]k)pailkn]h`kok^fa) pko`k_kjda_eiajpkmqaej]p](qjerano]haja_aoone]* =bkni]`kajpaj`eiajpkknc]jev]ko_kjpa`komqahdaokajre]`kolah]oajoe^ehe`]) `a(eopk(knc]jev]]olan_al ao*Jkr]iajpak_kjpa`kkbana_e`klah]atlanej_e]ok^ ]bkni]`kaol]ka`kpailk(a]n]vk(lkniaek`]aopnqpqn]`kajpaj`eiajpk(knc]jev] p]eo_kjpa`koailne_ko* Aoo]knc]jev]kpn]jobkni]]olan_al aoai_kjda_eiajpkoejpaha_pq]eokqai_kj) _aepko*L]n]p]jpk(kajpaj`eiajpklkooqe^moflof$eopk(]jpao`]atlanej_e]aej`alaj`aj) paiajpa`ah]%qi_kjfqjpk`aahaiajpkomqaknc]jev]iko_kjpa`koailne_ko*Aooaoaha) iajpkook_d]i]`ko`a_]packne]oaoaiah]ojklk`ad]ran_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]h( lkeook]o_kj`e aol]n]p]h_kjda_eiajpk*?ki]o_]packne]o^moflof(koqfaepk`k_kjda) _eiajpkbkniqh]ko_kj_aepko* Mq]eook]o_]packne]omqaknc]jev]iko`]`ko`]atlanej_e];=mq]he`]`a(]mq]jpe) `]`a(]_]qo]he`]`a(]bej]he`]`a(]ran`]`a(]b]hoe`]`a(]qjerano]he`]`a(]l]npe_qh]ne`]`a* =ooei(hkjca`a]_]qo]he`]`a(]mq]he`]`aa]mq]jpe`]`aoanainaoqhp]`ko`ad^epkoloe) _kh ce_ko]ook_e]perko(ah]ookkoejopnqiajpkon]_ekj]eo_kikomq]eokoqfaepk`k_kjda_e) iajpkknc]jev]]na]he`]`aa]_kjda_a*=o_]packne]o(aopnqpqn]or]ve]o(ok]oiaoi]oai pk`]lk_]aaipk`khqc]n(l]n]pk`kokooanaon]_ekj]eo* Cn]]oqjerano]he`]`aaja_aooe`]`a`]o_]packne]o(]o_ej_e]ooklkooraeoarhe`]o7 kaileneoik(lknp]jpk(aopamqerk_]`k* Aeo]mqekmq]`nkkq]p^q]`]o_]packne]o6
55
MQ=JPE@=@A
MQ=HE@=@A
NAH=~ÈK
IK@=HE@=@A
Qje`]`a
Na]he`]`a
Oq^oeopj_e] $kqoq^op j_e]%
Lkooe^ehe`]`a+ Eilkooe^ehe`]`a
Lhqn]he`]`a
Jac]k
?]qo]he`]`a $kq`alaj`j_e]%
Ateopj_e]+ Jkateopj_e]
Pkp]he`]`a
Heiep]k
?kiqje`]`a $kqnah]kna_lnk_] ajpnapaniko%
Ja_aooe`]`a+ ?kjpejcj_e]
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
Aiejop]jpa]hcqiG]jp]`iepamqa]na]he`]`a(aioeiaoi](aol]_e]h(pailkn]h(mq]) hep]per](mq]jpep]per](_]qo]h(ap_*Eookoane]nacna`en]kbkckcen]j`kaipknjk`kbn]jck*Kmqa G]jp]beni]mqa]n]vkakoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpklkooqaiaoo]oaopnqpqn]o_kikiaek `a_kjda_eiajpkamqa(lknoanaiah]oqjerano]eoaja_aoone]o(k_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]ha ran`]`aenkl]n]kooanaodqi]jko* eookmqa]n]vklk`a*Kmqaah]jklk`a$ajeookej]peop]oaaileneop]ooaajc]j]n]i% oqlknmqa_kioq]oaopnqpqn]ol]ooa]_kjda_an]na]he`]`ap]h_kikaop]aioeiaoi]* =n]vk_kjda_akok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpk*Kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk]mqaha_kjpa`k ailne_kmqana_a^aq]obkni]oa]o_]packne]o`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk*=n]vkjkaop j]o_keo]o(i]oaij o*=n]vkoailnan]vkoq^faper]ajklk`alnapaj`an_kjda_an] na]he`]`ap]h_kikah]oane]aioeiaoi](jailk`alnapaj`anmqaateop]qi]n]vkk^fape) r]ckranj]j`k]oln lne]o_keo]o* Kannk`koej]peop]oaaileneop]obkek`aoqlknmqajkoo]n]vk]h_]j]]na]he`]`aai oe*L]n]qiej]peop]_kik@ao_]npao(]na]he`]`aaioeaol]_e]h(pailkn]h(mq]hep]per](mq]j) pep]per](_]qo]h*L]n]qiaileneop]_kikDqia(]na]he`]`aaioelk`akqjknalapenb]pko oq_aooerkojkpailk(lk`akqjknalapenb]pko_kjpcqkojkaol]k(lk`akqjknalapen]o iaoi]ooamqj_e]o`a]_kjpa_eiajpko* L]n]G]jp(f]i]eolk`anaikoo]^anoa]na]he`]`aaioeaol]_e]h(pailkn]h(_]qo]h(mq]) hep]per](mq]jpep]per]*=na]he`]`aaioe`ajkiej]`]lknG]jp_kiqi]l]h]rn]cnac](klr* jbklk$krjbkl%7]na]he`]`ap]h_kikknc]jev]`]lah]n]vk(mqaoq^iapako_kjpa`ko `]atlanej_e]oaopnqpqn]o`]oajoe^ehe`]`aa`kajpaj`eiajpk(jkia]`]lknG]jp_ki ]l]h]rn]cnac]me^fkljbklk$cbkjbkl%*Kajc]jk`aej]peop]oaaileneop]oan]oqlknmqa lk`e]i_kjda_ankkrjbkl(mq]j`k(j]ran`]`a(o lk`aiko_kjda_ankbajiajk*Jk ajp]jpk(eookjkjkoeila`a`apan_kjda_eiajpkoran`]`aenkoa`a]h_]j]nko]^an_eajp) be_kqjerano]haja_aoonek*Lknmq;Lknmqao]^aikomqajkoo]n]vklkooqeqi]aopnqpqn] qjerano]h(ja_aoone]a^moflof(mqaknc]jev]ja_aoo]ne]iajpa]na]he`]`aaipaniko`]oclo* j^p`]oajoe^ehe`]`aa`ko`lk`bfqlpa`^qbdlof^p`kajpaj`eiajpk*?kikn]vkoq^faper]( jkoo]n]vklk`ac]n]jpen]ran`]`a`]behkokbe]a`]_ej_e]*
=naolkop]`aDacah
Q
ibeh okbk]haik`ko_qhkTET(Dacah(kbana_aqqi]kqpn]okhqkl]n]klnk^ha) i]`kej]peoika`kaileneoik* Dacah_nepe_kqkej]peoik(kaileneoikakg]jpeoik*=pk`koaj`anakq]iaoi]_n) pe_](mq]hoaf](]`ajkd]ranai_kilnaaj`e`kkmqad`ai]eobqj`]iajp]ha`ai]eo aooaj_e]hn]vk6^o^wlefpqof`^* @ab]pk(]behkokbe](lnak_ql]`]aic]n]jpen]`ebanaj]ajpna]ian]klejek$Îaq]_dk mqaÏ(Îaqckopk`aÏ(Îaqjkckopk`aÏ%a]ran`]`a$ÎaqlajokmqaÏ(ÎaqoaemqaÏ(Îeopk]ooei lknmqaÏ%(_kjoe`ankqmqa]oe`ae]oo oane]in]_ekj]eoaran`]`aen]ooabkooaiejpailkn]eo( lanajao(apanj]o(]oiaoi]oaipk`kpailkaaipk`khqc]n*Qi]ran`]`amqaiq`]ooa _kikpailkkq_kikohqc]naooane]ian]klejek(oane]ajc]jko](jkoane]ran`]`a*=n]) vk(oaj`k]bkjpaa]_kj`ek`]ran`]`a(pane]p]i^i`aoanejpailkn]h* aoo]ejpailkn]he`]`a]pne^q`]n]vkmqaDacah_nepe_kqaipk`]]behkokbe]]jpanekn* =k]beni]nmqa]n]vkdeop ne_](Dacahjkaop(`aik`k]hcqi(`evaj`kmqa]n]vk ]hcknah]perk(mqar]hadkfaajkr]ha]i]jd(mqa_]`]lk_]jk]h_]j]ran`]`aoqjeran) o]eo*KmqaDacahaop`evaj`kmqa]iq`]j](]pn]jobkni]k`]n]vka`aoaqo_kjpa) `kok^n]n]_ekj]h`]ln lne]n]vk*=n]vkjkqi]rpei]`kpailk(mqahdankq^]ne]] ran`]`a(]qjerano]he`]`a(]ja_aooe`]`a*=n]vkjkaopk^deop ne]7ah]]deop ne]*=n]vk jkaopklpailk7ah]kpailk*Ah]`oajpe`k]kpailk* Dacahp]i^ibavqi]_npe_]]koej]peop]oa]koaileneop]oiqepkoaiahd]jpamqa G]jpbevan]*Kqoaf](ej]peop]oaaileneop]o]_na`ep]imqak_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]hrai`]o
-,,
Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoik6okhq aobehko be_]ox#!0É45,/ßx
*OSEPHß(ELMANN ß.EWß9ORK
ß3TAATLICHEß+UNSTSAMMLUNGEN ß+ASSEL
ln lne]o_keo]ol]n]j o(mqak_kjda_eiajpk`alaj`aat_hqoer]iajpa`]]k`]o_keo]o ok^naj o(amqa]ran`]`a]_knnaolkj`j_e]ajpna]_keo]a]e`ae]`]_keo]* L]n]kaileneop](]na]he`]`aÎajpn]Ïaij olah]atlanej_e]*L]n]kej]peop](]ran`]`a Îajpn]Ïaij olahklk`an`ajkoo]bkn]ejpaha_pq]h(_]l]v`apane`ae]omqaokran`]`aen]o lknmqanalnaoajp]ikqnalnk`qvai]oln lne]o_keo]oatpanj]o*Aop]r]_anpkG]jpmq]j`k `eooamqaej]peop]oaaileneop]ooaajc]j]n]ilknat_aook`ak^fapereoik(eopk(lknfqhc]) naimqak_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]h`alaj`ane]ejpaen]iajpa`kok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpk( oaf] lknmqa `alaj`ane] `] atlanej_e]( oaf] lknmqa `alaj`ane] `] _]l]_e`]`a `]o e`ae]o l]n]nalnk`qven]na]he`]`aaioe`]o_keo]o* I]oG]jpp]i^ioaajc]jkqlknmqajkbke_]l]v`a_kilnaaj`anmqa^o^wlprgbfql bl_gbql*Kqoaf](iaoik]beni]j`kmqa]n]vkjk_kjda_a]na]he`]`aaioe(i]o]laj]o ]na]he`]`abajkije_](G]jp]ej`]]`iepe]]ateopj_e]`aqi]na]he`]`aatpaneknn]vka ej]h_]jrahlah]n]vk*@aoo]i]jaen](jk_kilnaaj`aqmqa]n]vk_ne]`kn]`]na]he`]) `a(eopk(mqakna]h]k^n]deop ne_]`]n]vk*
J]pqnav]o)iknp]o atlnaoo]oailk_]o `ebanajpao*Ç`enaep]( lejpqn]`aLeapan ?h]aov(`a-2//7
aomqan`](mq]`nk `aNkuHe_dpajopaej( `a-53.*L]n]Dacah( ]n]vkdeop ne_]( kqoaf](]iq`]j]( ]pn]jobkni]k `]n]vka`a oaqo_kjpa`ko k^n]n]_ekj]h`] ln lne]n]vk*
=n]vk(`evDacah(jkjaiat_hqoer]iajpan]vkk^faper]$]n]vkmqa`evmqa]ran) `]`aaopjkok^fapko%jaiat_hqoer]iajpaoq^faper]$]n]vkmqa`evmqa]ran`]`aaopjk oqfaepk%(i]oah]^rkfa^abkb`bppof^all_gbqfslbalpr_gbqfsl*Ah]k_kjda_eiajpk`] d]nikje]ajpna]o_keo]oa]oe`ae]o(ajpnakiqj`katpanekna]_kjo_ej_e](ajpnakk^fapka koqfaepk(ajpna]ran`]`ak^faper]a]ran`]`aoq^faper]*Kmqa(]bej]h(]n]vkl]n]Dacah; L]n]Dacah(]n]vk6 -*
k_kjfqjpk`]ohaeo`klajo]iajpk(eopk(kolnej_leko(kolnk_a`eiajpko`kn]_ek_jek(]o bkni]oa]oaopnqpqn]oja_aoone]ol]n]lajo]n(]o_]packne]o(]oe`ae]oÍn]vkoq^faper]7
.* ]kn`ai(]knc]jev]k(kaj_]`a]iajpka]onah] ao`]oln lne]o_keo]o(eopk(]na]he`]) `ak^faper]an]_ekj]hÍn]vkk^faper]7 /* ]nah]kejpanj]aja_aoone]ajpna]ohaeo`klajo]iajpka]ohaeo`kna]h*Ah]]qje`]`a`] n]vkoq^faper]a`]n]vkk^faper]*=aoo]qje`]`a(Dacah`kjkia`aaolnepk]^okhqpk*
-,-
Dacah]beni]mqapk`]na]he`]`an]_ekj]hamqapk`]n]_ekj]he`]`ana]h*Kq(aioq]o l]h]rn]o(Îkna]hn]_ekj]hakn]_ekj]hna]hÏ*?kiaoo]]beni]k(lnapaj`aqoecjebe_]n] qje`]`a`]n]vkk^faper]a`]n]vkoq^faper]* Lknmqa]n]vkdeop ne_]; =qje`]`akqd]nikje]ajpnakk^faperkakoq^faperk(ajpna]na]he`]`a`]o_keo]oak oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkjkqi`]`kapanjk(]hckmqaateopeq`ao`apk`kkoailna(i]o
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
qi]`lknrfpq^a^o^wlaaoo]_kjmqeop]]n]vkna]hev]jkpailk*=n]vkjkpai_kik lkjpk`al]npe`]aoo]qje`]`a(i]o]pai_kiklkjpk`a_dac]`](_kikobpriq^al`klan) _qnokdeop ne_kkqpailkn]hmqaah]ln lne]na]hev]* Mq]hkiahdknatailhkl]n]_kilnaaj`ankmqaDacahmqan`evan;Kiahdknatailhk kmqa]_]^]iko`aranjko_]lpqhko.a/`aop]qje`]`a* Reikomqakoej]peop]o_kia]n]i_ki^]paj`k]oqlkoek`amqaklejekaran`]`aok ]iaoi]_keo]*L]n]hern]nai)oa`aoo]oqlkoek(kmqabevan]iahao;@eooan]imqa]klejek lanpaj_a]k_]ilk`]atlanej_e]oajokne]h(laook]h(loe_kh ce_](ejoprahamqa]oe`ae]o`] n]vkokej]p]o(qjerano]eo(ja_aoone]o(eiqpraeo* Koaileneop]o(jkajp]jpk(jac]n]imqakoej]peop]operaooai]_anp]`k(jac]n]imqa ]oe`ae]olq`aooaioanej]p]oabevan]i]n]vk`alaj`an`]atlanej_e]loe_kh ce_]kq`] lan_alk*=kb]v)hk(narah]n]ikolkjpkobn]_ko`koej]peop]o(i]o]^nen]ikbh]j_kl]n] qilnk^hai]mqajklk`e]inaokhran(eopk(]r]he`]`a`]o_ej_e]o* =behkokbe]g]jpe]j]jackq(ajpk(mqaej]peop]oaaileneop]oaoperaooai_anpko*Jackq mqalq`ooaiko_kjda_an]na]he`]`aaioe`]o_keo]o(jackqmqa]n]vklkooqooa_kjpa) `ko ej]pko( ikopn]j`k mqa ko _kjpa`ko `alaj`ai `] atlanej_e]7 i]o jackq p]i^i mqa]atlanej_e]bkooa]_]qo]`]n]vk(kqmqaaop]bkooa]`mqene`](lkeolkooqebkni]oa aopnqpqn]oej]p]o*G]jp`aqlnekne`]`a]koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(ajmq]jpkaileneop]oa ej]peop]o`]r]ilnekne`]`a]kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk* Mqa`evDacah;Mqaaooao_kjbhepkobehko be_kook]deop ne]`]ln lne]n]vk(]mq]h]ben) i]qi]paoa$lknatailhk(]paoaej]peop]%(jac]aoo]paoa$lknatailhk(]paoaaileneop]jac] ]ej]peop]%a_dac]]qi]pan_aen]lkoekmqajac]]o`q]o]jpaneknao$lknatailhk(]lkoek g]jpe]j]%*I]oaoo]pan_aen]paoa(]koan]beni]`](pknj])oaqi]lneiaen]paoamqaoanjac]`] lknqi]kqpn]$lknatailhk(]behkokbe]`k_d]i]`knki]jpeoik]haik(mqajackq]behkok) be]g]jpe]j]%]pmqaqi]pan_aen]paoa$jk_]ok]behkokbe]`aDacah%jacqa]o`q]o]jpaneknao jqi]ran`]`aoqlaneknmqa]oajchk^]a]o_kilnaaj`a*Aooaikreiajpk`]n]vk(atlhe_] Dacah(pai]la_qhe]ne`]`a`ajqj_]`aopnqenejpaen]iajpakmqaah]]benikq]jpao(i]oej) _knlkn]k_]iejdklan_knne`kjqi]ran`]`aoqlanekn*K_]iejdkbaepk`aran`]`aol]n_e]eo mqarkoaj`knaqje`]o]pmqaoa_dacqa]qi]ran`]`apkp]hev]`kn]mqa]oajchk^]*Aeolkn mqaDacah]beni]mqa]deop ne]`]n]vkkq]deop ne]`]behkokbe]]iai ne]`ko_]iejdko lan_knne`ko(mqabkn]i_kjoanr]`koj]mqehkmqapejd]i`aran`]`aenk* Ai_]`]ikiajpk`aoq]deop ne](]n]vklnk`qveqqi]paoa]naolaepk`aoeiaoi] a(hkck]oacqen(qi]paoa_kjpnne]lneiaen](kqqi]]jppaoa*?]`]paoaa_]`]]jppaoa bkn]iikiajpkoja_aoonekol]n]]n]vk_kjda_an)oa_]`]ravi]eo*?]`]paoaa_]`]]jp) paoabkn]iran`]`aen]o(i]ol]n_e]eo*Oaiah]o(]n]vkjqj_]pane]_dac]`k]_kjda_an)oa] oeiaoi]*I]o]n]vkjklk`abe_]naop]_ekj]`]jaoo]o_kjpn]`e aomqaah]ln lne]_nekq lknqi]ja_aooe`]`a`ah]iaoi]6lna_eo]qhpn]l]oo)h]ojqi]ojpaoamqaqj]]opaoao_kj) pnne]o(ikopn]j`kkj`aaop]ran`]`a`a_]`]qi]`ah]oa_kjoanr]j`kaoo]ran`]`a*Aoo] ]n]vkdeop ne_]kq]deop ne]`kAolnepk(mqa^qo_]pknj]n)oaAolnepk=^okhqpk*
Aileneop]o(g]jpe]jkoadacahe]jko
A
i^kn]Dacahpajd]lnklkopkoejpapev]n]deop ne]`]n]vk(_kjoe`an]j`k(lknp]jpk(mqa ej]peop]o( aileneop]o a g]jpe]jko an]i l]npa `k l]oo]`k `aoo] deop ne]( _qfk pniejk kq_qf]_kj_hqokoane]]behkokbe]dacahe]j](eookjkoecjebe_]mqapk`kokobeh okbko pajd]i]_aep]`k]okhqkdacahe]j]_kiknaolkop]bej]h* =ooei(koaileneop]ojk`ao]l]na_an]i*Nabkniqh]n]iiqep]o`aoq]opaoaoalkoe) ao(i]olani]ja_an]iaileneop]o*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(lanoeopa(j]behkokbe](qi]_knnajpa aileneop]*Bkep]i^ikmqa]_kjpa_aq_kikobeh okbkoej]peop]o7akiaoiklk`aoan`epk _kinah]k]komqa]`kp]n]i]behkokbe]g]jpe]j]*Nabkniqh]n]ipaoao(]_nao_ajp]n]ijk) r]oe`ae]oalanola_per]o(i]ooai]jperan]ig]jpe]jko* Dkomqa]_aep]n]i]okhqkdacahe]j](]ooei_kikdkomqa]na_qo]n]ia`komq]eo b]h]naikojkln teik_]lpqhk*
-,.
=n]vkj]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =n]vkj]behkokbe]_kjpailknja]
=n]vkj]bajkiajkhkce]`aDqooanh
APORIAßCONTRADIljOßOUß PARADOXOßNUMßCONTEXTOß ARGUMENTATIVOßOUßNUMß RACIOCqNIO
TRANSCENDoNCIAßCONDIljOß DOßQUEßSEßENCONTRAßNUMß ESTADOßSUPERIORßEßINACES SqVELßAßUMAßDETERMINADAß ORDEMßDEßEXISToNCIAßOUß REALIDADE
-,/
M
q]j`k(jko_qhkTREEE(G]jpao_naraq]@oqf`^a^o^wlmro^(pejd]`e]jpa`aoe`q]o _ej_e]o_kjoe`an]`]olknahaatailh]nao6]i]paipe_]a]_ej_e]`]j]pqnav]*La) n]jpaah]o(`eve]G]jp(]behkokbe]$kq]iap]boe_]%`a_]qo]nlaj](lkeojah]naej]i ]_kjbqok(ko_kjbhepko`a`kqpnej]o(]lkne]o`apk`kpelk*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]behkokbe] ]ej`]jk]h_]jkqkaop]pqpkkq]_kj`ek`a_ej_e]*=p]nab]`]@oqf`^a^o^wlmro^ an]fqop]iajpaat]iej]nmq]eo]o_kj`e aolnaheiej]naomqa`are]ioanlnaaj_de`]okq naolaep]`]ol]n]mqaqi`e]]behkokbe]$]iap]boe_]%lq`aooapknj]n)oaqi]_ej_e](aop]^a) ha_aj`k]o_kj`e ao^moflof`alkooe^ehe`]`aakoheiepao`k_kjda_eiajpkdqi]jk*?kik reiko(aooaat]iaG]jp`ajkiejkq`apn]jo_aj`ajp]h* Jkbej]h`ko_qhkTETaej_ek`ko_qhkTT(]lnak_ql]k_kikpn]jo_aj`ajp]hna]) l]na_aq_ki]behkokbe]`aA`iqj`Dqooanh(]bajkiajkhkce]*=`eo_qook`k`ehai]ajpna kej]peoikakaileneoiknapki]`]lknDqooanh]l]npen`]o`eo_qoo aook^nakobqj`]) iajpko `] h ce_] a `] i]paipe_] a lnkooacqa mq]j`k k beh okbk lnk_qn] `apaniej]n ]o _kj`e ao^moflof`alkooe^ehe`]`a`]behkokbe]_kik_ej_e]necknko]* LknmqaÎbajkiajkhkce]Ï;LknmqaDqooanhnajako`keolnej_el]eooecjebe_]`ko`]l]h]) rn]cbkjbkl(p]eo_kik]l]na_ainaola_per]iajpaaiG]jpaaiDacah*@aG]jp(Dqooanh _kjoanr]]]beni]k`amqajk_kjda_aikoqi]na]he`]`aaioe(i]o]na]he`]`ap]h_kik ]l]na_a]koanaopnqpqn]`]aknc]jev]`]^mofloflah]n]vk7`aDacah(Dqooanh_kjoanr]]]ben) i]k`amqaÎqi]bajkiajkhkce]Ï]`ao_nek`kmqa]l]na_a_kjo_ej_e]a]`ao_nek `k]l]na_an`]_kjo_ej_e]l]n]oeiaoi]*Dacah`eooan]mqa]bajkiajkhkce]]j]nn]per] `]oatlanej_e]o`]_kjo_ej_e]j]deop ne]*Dqooanh`evmqa]bajkiajkhkce]]`ao_nek `]oatlanej_e]o`]_kjo_ej_e]_kik]pere`]`a`a_kjda_eiajpk* =`ao_nekbajkiajkh ce_]atecaqi]]pepq`amqaDqooanh`aoecj]_ki]l]h]rn]cna) c]bml`e(mqaoecjebe_]Îoqolaj`ankfqvkok^na]hcqi]_keo]`amqajkoapai_anpav]Ï*= bml`ebajkiajkh ce_]_kjoeopa(j]ol]h]rn]o`aDqooanh(aiÎÐ_khk_]najpnal]njpaoaoÑjkoo] _naj]j]ateopj_e]`]na]he`]`aatpanekna`ao_naran]o]pere`]`ao`]_kjo_ej_e]kq`]n]vk _kikqilk`an^moflof`a_kjopepqek`]ln lne]na]he`]`aÏ* Kmqaeookmqan`evan; Kmqa_d]i]iko`aÎiqj`kÏkqÎna]he`]`aÏ(`evDqooanh(jkqi_kjfqjpk`a_keo]o alaook]o(]jei]eo(racap]eoaiejan]eoateopajpaoaioeiaoikoamqajkoo]oe`ae]onalna) oajp]i]kpn]jobkni)hkoaik^fapko`a_kjda_eiajpk*Kiqj`kkq]na]he`]`aqi_kj) fqjpk`apfdkfcf`^ bpkq`apbkqfalpmqaoklnk`qve`kolah]_kjo_ej_e]kqlah]n]vk*= n]vkÎ`k]`kn]`aoajpe`kÏaah]`lkpqfqrf^ob^ifa^abjkajmq]jpkateopj_e]`aoanao( i]oajmq]jpkoeopai]`aoecjebe_] aomqa`alaj`ai`]aopnqpqn]`]ln lne]_kjo_ej_e]* Kq(_kikatlhe_]Dqooanh(]na]he`]`a_kjopepq`]lah]_kjo_ej_e]pn]jo_aj`ajp]hkqlah] n]vkpn]jo_aj`ajp]hjkoanabana]ateopj_e]o`aoanaoaoei]bppk`f^p(eopk(]pfdkfcf`^* bp*=oaooj_e]ookran`]`aen]o(qjerano]eoaja_aoone]olknmqaok_kjopepq`]o^moflof lah]ln lne]n]vk*=ooecjebe_] aokqaooj_e]ookk_kjpa`kmqa]ln lne]n]vkkbana_a ]oeiaoi]l]n]`k]noajpe`k(lkeo]n]vkpn]jo_aj`ajp]h`k]`kn]`aoajpe`kakoajpe`k ]je_]na]he`]`aateopajpal]n]]n]vk*
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
N]vkaok_ea`]`a
@
ebanajpaiajpa`]bajkiajkhkce](kqpnkobeh okbko(_kikkomqa_ne]n]i]_d]i]`] Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnp(kj`aoaknecejkq]Pakne]?npe_](]`kp]i]okhqkdacahe]j]( i]o_kiqi]ik`ebe_]kbqj`]iajp]h*Kobeh okbko`aoo]ao_kh](_kikPdak`kn =`knjk(Dan^anpI]n_qoaaI]tDkngdaeian(piqi]bkni]ki]nteop]a(lkneook(na_q) o]i]e`ae]dacahe]j]`amqa]deop ne]k^n]`]n]vk_kikaolnepk(kqmqa]opn]jobkni]) aodeop ne_]o`]n]vkokna]hev]`]olah]ln lne]n]vk(oaimqaaop]oaf]_kj`e_ekj]`]kq `apaniej]`]lah]o_kj`e aook_e]eo(a_kjie_]oalkhpe_]o* L]n]aooaobeh okbko(kajc]jk`aDacahaop(ailneiaenkhqc]n(j]oqlkoek`amqa] n]vkoaf]qi]bkn]deop ne_]]qpjki]$eopk(jk_kj`e_ekj]`]lah]oepq]ki]pane]h kqa_kjie_](ok_e]halkhpe_]`aqi]lk_]%(a(aioacqj`khqc]n(j]oqlkoek`amqa] n]vk]bkn]deop ne_]mqa_ne]]ln lne]ok_ea`]`a(]lkhpe_](]_qhpqn]*Kqoaf](Dacahoa ajc]j]lknmqa_kjoe`an]]n]vk$kqkaolnepk%ej_kj`e_ekj]`]ok_e]h(a_kjie_]alkhepe) _]iajpaalkn_kjoe`an]nmqa]ok_ea`]`a(]a_kjkie]a]lkhpe_]mqaok_kj`e_ekj]`]o lah]n]vk*L]n]ahao(Dacahaop_knnapkmq]j`k]beni]mqa]oiq`]j]odeop ne_]ok_knnai lahko_kjbhepkoa_kjpn]`e ao(i]oaopajc]j]`k]koqlknmqap]eo_kjbhepkooa`kajpna `ebanajpaobkni]o`]n]vk(lkeoahaooa`k_kik_kjbhepkoa_kjpn]`e aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o( ik`ebe_]j`k]ln lne]n]vk* Kobeh okbko`]Pakne]?npe_]_kjoe`an]imqaateopai(j]ran`]`a(`q]oik`]he`]`ao `]n]vk6]o^wlfkpqorjbkq^ikqo^wlq`kf`l*`fbkqcf`^(mqaaop]oanrek`]atlhkn]ka `]`kiej]k(`]klnaooka`]rekhj_e](a]o^wl`oqf`^kqcfilpcf`^(mqanabhapaok^na]o _kjpn]`e aoako_kjbhepkook_e]eoalkhpe_koaoa]lnaoajp]_kikqi]bkn]he^an]`kn]* =Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnpi]jpi]e`ae]dacahe]j]`amqadqi]_kjpejqe`]`apailkn]h kqdeop ne_]ajpna]bkni]]jpanekn`]n]_ekj]he`]`aa]bkni]oacqejpa6]n]vkik`anj]( lknatailhk(jkoqnca`analajpaa`kj]`](i]onaoqhp]`a_kjpn]`e aoa_kjbhepkook_ek) lkhpe_ko`kbej]h`]E`]`aI`e]a`]Naj]o_aj](`aik`kmqa(]koqlan]n]n]_ekj]he`]`a ia`ear]hanaj]o_ajpeop](j]o_a_kikn]_ekj]he`]`aik`anj]* ?]`]jkr]bkni]`]n]_ekj]he`]`a]rep ne]ok^nako_kjbhepko`]obkni]o]jpaneknao( oaimqad]f]nqlpqn]deop ne_]ajpnaah]o*Iq`]j]ook_e]eo(lkhpe_]oa_qhpqn]eo`apanie) j]iiq`]j]ojklajo]iajpk(ap]eoiq`]j]ook]okhqkna]hev]`]lahkpailklnaoaj) pal]n]ko_kjbhepkoa]o_kjpn]`e ao`kl]oo]`k* =n]vkjk`apaniej]jai_kj`e_ekj]]ok_ea`]`a$_kikfqhc]n]Dacah%(i]o`apan) iej]`]a_kj`e_ekj]`]lah]ok_ea`]`aaoq]oiq`]j]o*=ooei(koej]peop]ooaajc]j]i]k oqlkn]eiqp]^ehe`]`a`ko_kjpa`ko`]n]vkakoaileneop]ooaajc]j]i]koqlknmqa]o iq`]j]ook]_]nnap]`]olknjkoo]oatlanej_e]o(mq]j`k(j]ran`]`a(oklnk`qve`]olkn pn]jobkni] aochk^]eo`aqi]ok_ea`]`a*
N]vka`ao_kjpejqe`]`apailkn]h
J
ko]jko-52,(`aoajrkhraq)oa(ok^napq`kj]Bn]j](qi]_knnajpa_eajpbe_]$eje_e]) `]j]hejcqope_]aj]]jpnklkhkce]ok_e]h%_d]i]`]aopnqpqn]heoik*L]n]koaopnq) pqn]heop]o(ki]eoeilknp]jpajk]iq`]j]kq]pn]jobkni]k`aqi]na]he`]) `a$`aqi]hjcq](`aqi]ok_ea`]`aej`caj](`aqi]pakne]_eajpbe_]%(i]o]bpqorqro^kq ]bkni]mqaah]paijklnaoajpa* =aopnqpqn]l]oo]`]a]aopnqpqn]bqpqn]ok_kjoe`an]`]oaopnqpqn]oafcbobkqbpbkqobpfa afcbobkqbpa^bpqorqro^mobpbkqb(oaimqad]f]ejpanaooaai]_kil]jd]npailkn]hiajpa]l]o) o]cai`aqi]aopnqpqn]l]n]kqpn]*=ooei(kaopnqpqn]heoik_eajpbe_k`ao_kjoe`an]]lkoek behko be_]`apelkdacahe]jk(paj`ki]ekn]beje`]`a_ki]g]jpe]j]*Kaopnqpqn]heoikparaqi] cn]j`aejbhqj_e]ok^naklajo]iajpkbehko be_kaeookoanabhapeqj]`eo_qookok^na]n]vk* Oak^oanr]niko^ai(jkp]naikomqa]okhqkdacahe]j]narah]qi]_kj_alk_qiq) h]per]akpeieop]`]n]vk6
-,0
=n]vkj]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
!LBUMAKG IMAGES!NNAß7EISE ,ATINSTOCK
`rjri^qfs^6Dacah_kjoe`an]mqa]n]vk(j]^]p]hd]ejpanj]ajpnapaoaoa]jppaoao(r]e oaj`kajnemqa_e`](r]e]_qiqh]j`k_kjda_eiajpko_]`]ravi]eknaook^naoeiaoi]( p]jpk_kik_kjda_eiajpk`]n]_ekj]he`]`a`kna]h$n]vkk^faper]%mq]jpk_kik_k) jda_eiajpk`]_]l]_e`]`an]_ekj]hl]n]k_kjda_eiajpk$n]vkoq^faper]%* lqfjfpq^6l]n]Dacah(]n]vklkooqebkn]l]n]jkoa`aopnqen]oeiaoi]aioq]o_kj) pn]`e aoejpanj]o7]k_kjpnnek(oqlan]_]`]qi]`ah]oa_dac]]qi]ojpaoad]nik) jeko]`apk`kokoikiajpkomqa_kjopepqn]i]oq]deop ne]* Ejbhqaj_e]`ko lahk aopnqpqn]heoik( rneko beh okbko bn]j_aoao( _kik Ie_dah Bkq_]qhp( F]_mqao@anne`]aCehhao@ahaqva(]kaopq`]nai]deop ne]`]behkokbe](`]o_ej_e]o(`]ok_ea) `]`a(`]o]npaoa`]op_je_]o(`eooan]imqa(oai`re`](]n]vkdeop ne_]Íeopk(iq`] pailkn]hiajpaÍ(i]oaoo]deop ne]jk_qiqh]per](arkhqper](lnkcnaooer]a_kjpjq]* Lahk_kjpnnek(`ao_kjpjq](oana]hev]lkno]hpkoa_]`]aopnqpqn]jkr]`]n]vklkooqeqi oajpe`kln lnek(rhe`k]laj]ol]n]ah]* "ETTMANN#ORBIS
2AYMONDß$EPARDON-AGNUMß 0HOTOS,ATINSTOCK
*ACQUESß$ERRIDAßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOß FRANCoSßDEßORIGEMß ARGELINA
'ILLESß$ELEUZE߯
"ILLß0IERCE4IMEßß,IFEß0ICTURES 'ETTYß)MAGES
=pakne]dahek_jpne_] `a?klnje_klk`a oanqiatailhk `]n]vkdeop ne_] `ao_kjpjq]lnklkop] lknBkq_]qhp(@anne`] a@ahaqva*?kiah](] Pann]`aetkq`aoank _ajpnk`kQjeranok*
4HOMASß+UHNß ßß FILvSOFOßDAßCIoNCIAßQUEß ESTUDAßAßHISTvRIAßDOßß PENSAMENTOßCIENTqFICOß PARAßMOSTRARßQUEßASß CIoNCIASßNjOßSEß DESENVOLVEMßNUMß PROCESSOßCONTqNUOßEß CUMULATIVOßEßSIMßPORßß ±SALTOS²ßOUßREVOLUßlzES
-,1
@evaiahaomqaqi]pakne]$behko be_]kq_eajpbe_]%kqqi]lnpe_]$pe_](lkhpe_](]npo) pe_]%okjkr]ofqop]iajpamq]j`knkilai]o_kj_al ao]jpaneknaoa]ooq^opepqailkn kqpn]o_kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpao(jkoaj`klkoorahb]h]njqi]_kjpejqe`]`alnkcnaooer] ajpnaah]o(lkeookpk`ebanajpaomqajkd_kikjailknmqa_kil]n)h]oafqhc]nqi] `ah]oi]eo]pn]o]`]a]kqpn]i]eo]`e]jp]`]* =ooei(lknatailhk(]pakne]`]nah]pere`]`a(ah]^kn]`]lknAejopaej(jk_kjpejq]) karkhq`]aiahdkn]`]`]boe_]_hooe_](bkniqh]`]lknC]hehaqaJaspkj(i]oqi] lrqo^cpf`^(_ki_kj_aepko(lnej_lekoalnk_a`eiajpko_kilhap]iajpajkrkoa`ebanaj) pao*Paiko`q]oboe_]o`ebanajpao(_]`]mq]h_kioaqoajpe`kar]hknln lneko* Jkoalk`ab]h]njqilnk_aook(jqi]arkhqkkqjqi]r]jk`]n]vk]_]`]jkr] pakne](lkeo]jkre`]`aoecjebe_]fqop]iajpamqaoapn]p]`a]hckpkjkrk(pk`ebanajpaapk kqpnkmqaoan]^oqn`kb]h]nai_kjpejqe`]`aa]r]jk*Jkd_kik`evanmqa]oe`ae]oa]o pakne]ol]oo]`]ookb]ho]o(ann]`]okq]pn]o]`]o6ah]ooeilhaoiajpaok`ebanajpao`]o]pq]eo lknmqaoa^]oae]iailnej_leko(ejpanlnap] aoa_kj_aepkojkrko* Qi] _kj_alk oaiahd]jpa bke `aoajrkhre`] lahk beh okbk jknpa)]iane_]jk Pdki]o Gqdj*Oacqj`kaha(aoo]onarkhq ao]_kjpa_aimq]j`kqi]pakne]_eajpbe_]ajpn]ai_neoa a]_]^]oaj`kaheiej]`]lknkqpn](knc]jev]`]`ai]jaen]`ebanajpa* Aioq]reok(]_]`]lk_]]opakne]o_eajpbe_]oejopepqaiipk`koa`abeje ao`aoaqo k^fapko_kjopepqej`ki]pnevao`aejraopec]ka`alajo]iajpk]omq]eoGqdj`ajkiej]`a
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
!NNAß7EISE!LBUMAKG IMAGES ,ATINSTOCK
PARADIGMAßPALAVRAßDEß ORIGEMßGREGAßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±MODELO²
,YOTARD߯ ß FILvSOFOßPvS MODERNOß FRANCoS 3TEVEß0YKE0REMIUMß!RCHIVE 'ETTYß)MAGES
m^o^afdj^p*Qil]n]`eci]_kilkopk`adel paoao(haeo(lnk_a`eiajpkoiapk`kh ce_koa p_je_]o`alaomqeo]a`a]lhe_]k`ko_kjda_eiajpko(`abejej`k]ojkni]oanacn]o`kmqa `araoanlaomqeo]`ka_kjda_e`k* Kn](]l]npen`a_anpkoikiajpko(_kia]i]oqncen`ebe_qh`]`ao(ennacqh]ne`]`ao(]jk) i]he]o6qi]pakne]_eajpbe_]_kia]]jk`]n_kjp]`aoaqok^fapkokq_anpkok^fapkojkrko ]l]na_ail]n]komq]eokl]n]`eci]ateopajpajkoanra*Jaooaoikiajpkodqi]Î_neoa `kl]n]`eci]Ïkqqi]_neoa`]n]vk_qf]okhqkoa`_kiqi]narkhqk_eajpbe_](eopk( _ki]ejopepqek`aqil]n]`eci]jkrk*Eookjkoecjebe_]mqa]_ej_e]Îlnkcna`eqÏaoei mqaÎiq`kqÏ*Kqoaf](jkd_kjpejqe`]`aajpnaqil]n]`eci]]jpaneknaqijkrk* =ooei(ai_]`]lk_]`aoq]deop ne](]n]vk_ne]ik`ahkokql]n]`eci]oatlhe_]perko l]n]kobajiajkokql]n]kok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpk(jkd]raj`k_kjpejqe`]`ajai lkjpko_kiqjoajpnaahaomqalaniep]i_kil]n)hko*=ckn](aihqc]n`aqilnk_aookheja]n a_kjpjqk`]n]vk(b]h])oaj]ejrajk`abkni]o`ebanajpao`an]_ekj]he`]`a(`a]_kn`k _ki_nepnekomqa]ln lne]n]vk_ne]l]n]oeiaoi]*=n]vkcnac]`ebanajpa`]ia`ear]h mqa(lknoq]rav(`ebanajpa`]naj]o_ajpeop]a`]ik`anj]*=n]vkik`anj]a]ehqiejeop] p]i^iok`ebanajpao(]ooei_kik]n]vkdacahe]j]`ebanajpa`]_kjpailkn ja]* Ajbei(kobeh okbko`epkol o)ik`anjko$_kik(lknatailhk(kbn]j_oHukp]n`akjknpa) )]iane_]jkNknpu%_kjoe`an]i]behkokbe]a]_ej_e]lnpe_]o_qhpqn]eople_]o`kK_e`ajpa _qf]lnapajok`ana]hev]n]n]vkkqk_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]hejbqj`]`]aenna]hevrah*Lkn mq;Lknmqa]n]vkpai]lnapajok`aoank_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk`]na]he`]`a(i]o aop]jkateopa(lkeojkdb]pko(`]`kokq_keo]oaoeii]jaen]o`ab]h]nkqÎfkcko`ahej) cq]caiÏ_kimqaejrajp]ikoiaekol]n]atlneienkmqalajo]ikoaoajpeiko*?d]i]iko p]eofkcko`an]_ekj]eokq`aran`]`aenkooeilhaoiajpaajmq]jpkbqj_ekj]ikqokpaeo l]n]jkookobejoako]^]j`kj]ikolknkqpnkomq]j`k`aet]i`abqj_ekj]nkq`aoanpaeo l]n]jkookobejo*=lnkr]`amqajkd^o^wlaopj]iqhpelhe_e`]`a`abehkokbe]o_kjpn) ne]oqi]ookqpn]oaj]oiq`]j]o`]opakne]o_eajpbe_]o*N]vk(n]_ekj]he`]`a(k^fapere`]) `a(ran`]`aokiepkok_e`ajp]eo(Î_naj]opne^]eoÏ_kik]o`amq]eomqankqpnkolkrko*
2ORTY߯ ßß FILvSOFOßPvS MODERNOß NORTE AMERICANO
Lknmqa]ej`]b]h]ikoain]vk;
@
e]jpa`]o_kj_al ao`ao_kjpejqop]o`]n]vka`kl o)ik`anjeoik(lk`aikob]) van`q]olancqjp]o6
-*
Oa(ai_]`]lk_](lknikperkodeop ne_koapa ne_ko`apaniej]`ko(]n]vkiq`]ejpae) n]iajpa(kmqamqanaiko`evanmq]j`k_kjpejq]ikoailnac]j`k]l]h]rn]o^wl;
.* Oa(ai_]`]_ej_e](behkokbe](pakne]kqatlnaook`klajo]iajpkj]`]dai_kiqi _ki]o]jpaneknaoa]olkopaneknao(lknmqa`evaikomqa]hcqi]ookn]_ekj]eoakqpn]o jkkok;=n]vkjkoane](]bej]h(qiiepkmqajkoo]_qhpqn]ejrajpkql]n]oeiaoi]( _kik`evaikol o)ik`anjko; Lk`aikonaolkj`anlneiaen]lancqjp]`evaj`kmqa_kjpejq]iko]b]h]naio^wl( ]lao]n`ad]raniqep]oa`ebanajpaoÎn]v aoÏ(lknmqai]jpaikoqi]e`ae]mqaaooaj_e]h jkkk_e`ajp]h`an]vk*Mqae`ae]aoo];=`amqa]na]he`]`a(kiqj`kj]pqn]ha_qhpqn]h( kooanaodqi]jko(oq]o] aoak^n]oqjpbkqfalaaooaoajpe`kmlabpbo`lkeb`fal*=]pepq) `an]_ekj]h`a_kjda_an]na]he`]`ajkoajkkpn]^]hdk`klajo]iajpkl]n]]lnaaj`an( _kilnaaj`anaejpanlnap]nkoajpe`k`]o_keo]o(`kob]pko(`]oe`ae]o(] aoar]hknaodqi]) jko*aooae`a]h`k_kjda_eiajpkmqa_kjoanr]`kmq]j`k_kjpejq]iko]b]h]nain]vk* ?kinah]koacqj`]lancqjp](lk`aiko`evanmqa(ai_]`]lk_](koiai^nko`] ok_ea`]`aa`]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]eofqhc]i]r]he`]`a`]ln lne]n]vk_kik_]l]vkqej_]l]v `ana]hev]nke`a]h`k_kjda_eiajpk*Aooafqhc]iajpklk`aoanna]hev]`k`a`q]oi]jaen]o* =lneiaen]i]jaen]kqklneiaenk_nepnek`a]r]he]k`]_]l]_e`]`an]_ekj]hk`]`lb* ok`f^fkqbok^`aqilajo]iajpkkq`aqi]pakne]*Kqoaf](mq]j`kqilajo]iajpkkqqi]
-,2
=n]vkj]behkokbe]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
pakne]oalnkl ai]kbana_anqi_kjda_eiajpk(oeiqhp]ja]iajpap]i^ikbana_aikolnej) _leko(ko_kj_aepkoakolnk_a`eiajpkomqaoqopajp]i]atlhe_]k]lnaoajp]`]*Mq]j`kjk d_kil]pe^ehe`]`aajpna]atlhe_]kakolnej_leko(ko_kj_aepkoakolnk_a`eiajpkokbana_e) `ko(`evaikomqajkd_kanj_e]amqaklajo]iajpkkq]pakne]jkokn]_ekj]eo*=n]vk( ]ooei(k_nepnek`amqa`eolkikol]n]]]r]he]k(kejopnqiajpkl]n]fqhc]n]r]he`]`a`aqi lajo]iajpkkq`aqi]pakne](fqhc]j`k(ah]iaoi](oq]_kanj_e]kqej_kanj_e]* =oacqj`]i]jaen]`ebanajpa`]]jpanekn*=ckn](lancqjp])oaoaqilajo]iajpkkq qi]pakne]_kjpne^qaikqjkl]n]mqakooanaodqi]jko_kjda]ia_kilnaaj`]i]o _en_qjop j_e]oaimqarerai(_kjpne^qaikqjkl]n]]hpan]noepq] aomqakooanaodqi]) jkofqhc]iej]_aepraeokqejpkhanraeo(_kjpne^qaikqjkl]n]iahdkn]n]o_kj`e aoai mqakooanaodqi]jkorerai*=ooei(]n]vk(]hi`aoank_nepnekl]n]]r]he]nko_kjda_e) iajpko(p]i^iqiejopnqiajpk_npe_kl]n]_kilnaaj`aniko]o_en_qjop j_e]oaimqa reraiko(l]n]iq`)h]okqiahdkn)h]o*=n]vkpaiqilkpaj_e]h]perkkqpn]jobkni]`kna lkneook_kjpejq]iko]b]h]njah]a]`aoaf)h]*
N]vkana]he`]`a
K
o`keo_nepnekoreopko]_ei]Í]_kanj_e]ejpanj]`aqilajo]iajpkkq`aqi] pakne]aklkpaj_e]h_npe_k)pn]jobkni]`kn`ko_kjda_eiajpkoÍp]i^ijko]fq) `]i]_kilnaaj`anmqa]n]vkjkqiiepk(lknmqalk`aikolan_a^anmq]j`k ]n]vkren]iepka`aet]`aoann]vk* =j]heoaiko_kikatailhk`aoo]ren]`]]opakne]omqa`abaj`aikn]_eoikamqaok pe`]o_kik_eajpbe_]okqn]_ekj]eo* =o pakne]o n]_eop]o oa ]lnaoajp]i qo]j`k lnej_leko( _kj_aepko a lnk_a`eiajpko $kq ipk`ko%n]_ekj]eo(_eajpbe_ko*B]vailaomqeo]o^ekh ce_]o(cajpe_]o(mqie_]o(ok_ekh ce) _]o7qo]i]ej`qka]`a`qk7`abejai_kj_aepko(ejbanai_kj_hqo ao`ko`]`kok^pe`ko lknatlanej_e]alkn_h_qhkoaop]pope_ko*Qo]j`kp]eolnk_a`eiajpko(b]vai`aikjopn]) aoalkniaek`ah]olnapaj`ailnkr]n6 -*
mqaateopaiÎn]]oÏ7
.* mqa]oÎn]]oÏok^ekh ce_]acajape_]iajpa`ebanajpao7 /* mqadÎn]]oÏ]pn]o]`]oa]`e]jp]`]o(ejbaneknaoaoqlaneknao7 0* mqa]oÎn]]oÏ]pn]o]`]oaejbaneknaojkok_]l]vao(lknatailhk(`a`aoajrkhreiajpk ejpaha_pq]haaopkj]pqn]hiajpa`aopej]`]o]kpn]^]hdki]jq]h(lkeooq]n]vkiqepk lamqaj]ajk_kjoacqai_kilnaaj`an]oe`ae]oi]eo_kilhat]oa]r]j]`]o7 1* mqa]oÎn]]oÏ]`e]jp]`]oaoqlaneknaoaopkj]pqn]hiajpa`aopej]`]o]`kiej]nklh]) jap]amqa(oaeookbknja_aoonekl]n]koaq^ai(pik`enaepk`aatpaniej]n]oÎn]]oÏ ]pn]o]`]oaejbaneknao7 2* mqa( l]n] k ^ai `]oÎn]]oÏ ejbaneknao a `]o oqlaneknao( `ara d]ran oacnac]k n]_e]h $oal]n]k`kohk_]eo`aikn]`e](`apn]^]hdk(`aa`q_]k(`ah]van(ap_*%(lkeo]jkoa) cnac]klk`ab]van]oejbaneknao]nn]op]nai]ooqlaneknaol]n]oaq^]etkjrah(]ooei _kiklk`ab]van]ooqlaneknaopajp]naiejqpehiajpaiahdkn]nkjrah`]oejbaneknao*
-,3
Kn](]n]vklk`a`aikjopn]nmqa]În]_ekj]he`]`aÏn]_eop]enn]_ekj]hamqaaop]oan) rek`]rekhj_e](`]ecjkn j_e]a`]`aopnqek* =ooei( ] ^ekhkce] a ] cajpe_] `aikjopn]i mqa d `ebanaj]o j] bkni]k ]j]pie) _k)beoekh ce_]`kooanaodqi]jkoai`a_knnj_e]`a`ebanaj]oejpanj]o`kknc]jeoika`a `ebanaj]oa_kh ce_]o(eopk(`kiaek]i^eajpa(amqap]eo`ebanaj]ojklnk`qvaiÎn]]oÏ* ÎN]]Ï(lknp]jpk(qi]l]h]rn]ejrajp]`]l]n]]r]he]n(fqhc]nai]jelqh]n]o`ebanaj]o^ek) h ce_]oacajpe_]o*
x5.)$!$%ßx=n]vk
=ok_ekhkce](]]jpnklkhkce]a]deop ne]atlhe_]imqa]o`ebanaj]omqa]^ekhkce]a] cajpe_]]lnaoajp]ijk`a_knnaiokiajpa`]o`ebanaj]oj]o_kj`e ao]i^eajp]eo(i]o p]i^ioklnk`qve`]olah]o`ebanajpaoi]jaen]olah]omq]eokocnqlkook_e]eo`abejai]o nah] ao`apn]^]hdk(`al]najpao_k(]obkni]o`a]r]he]k(`araopqnek(`ad]^ep]k(ap_* Aoo]o`ebanaj]ojkbkni]iÎn]]oÏ* =_ej_e]lkhpe_]a]a_kjie_]atlhe_]imqa(jkejpanekn`aqi]iaoi]ok_ea`]`a( bkni]i)oacnqlkoa_h]ooaook_e]eomqaoa]lnklne]i`]onemqav]oa`klk`an(oq^iapai $lah]bkn](lahkia`k(lah]oqlanopek(lah]iajpen](lah]ehqok%kqpnkocnqlkoa_h]ooao ok_e]eooq]`kiej]kafqopebe_]ip]hb]pk]beni]j`kmqap]eocnqlkokq_h]ooaookejba) neknaoamqalkooqai_]n]_panope_]oboe_]oaiajp]eomqakob]vaioanqi]În]]ejbaneknÏ* ÎN]]Ï(lknp]jpk(jkateopa*qi]l]h]rn]ejrajp]`]l]n]hacepei]n]atlhkn]ka]`kie) j]kmqaqicnqlkok_e]halkhpe_katan_aok^nakokqpnkocnqlko* =loe_khkce]ikopn]mqa]o_]l]_e`]`aoiajp]eo`apk`kokocnqlkoa_h]ooaook_e]eo`a qi]_qhpqn]okecq]eo(i]omqaoai]jebaop]i`aik`ko`ebanaj_e]`ko`alaj`aj`k`ko ik`ko`are`](`apn]^]hdk(`a]_aookao_kh]aa`q_]kbkni]h(`]o_naj]onaheceko]o( `ar]hknaoikn]eoa]npope_ko`ebanaj_e]`koap_*Aoo]o`ebanaj]ojkbkni]iÎn]]oÏa(lkn) p]jpk(În]]Ïqi]l]h]rn]ejrajp]`]l]n]pn]jobkni]n]o`ebanaj]oaifqopebe_]per]ol]n] `eo_neiej] aoaat_hqo ao* =behkokbe](na_khdaj`kb]pko(`]`ko(naoqhp]`ko(atlhe_] aoa`aikjopn] aopn]ve`ko lah]orne]o_ej_e]o(lk`a(ajpk(_kj_hqen`evaj`kmqa6 -*
]pakne]`kn]_eoikb]ho](jkpaibqj`]iajpk_eajpbe_kaenn]_ekj]h7
.* ]pakne]Î_eajpbe_]Ï`kn]_eoik(j]ran`]`a(qi]lnpe_]$ajkqi]pakne]%a_kjie_]( ok_e]h(lkhpe_]a_qhpqn]hl]n]fqopebe_]n]rekhj_e]_kjpn]oanaodqi]jkoa(lknp]jpk( ej]_aeprahl]n]]o_ej_e]o(l]n]]behkokbe]al]n]]n]vk*Qi]În]vkÏn]_eop]jk n]vk(i]oecjkn j_e](lna_kj_aepk(rekhj_e]aenn]_ekj]he`]`a*
15%34¬%3
#!0É45,/ß =n]vk -* AtailheÚmqakornekooajpe`koaimqa]l]h]rn]n]) vkqo]`]_kpe`e]j]iajpa* .*Mqamqan`evanL]o_]h]k]Úni]nmqaÎk_kn]kpai n]v aomqa]n]vk`ao_kjda_aÏ; /*Kmqan]vkk^faper];An]vkoq^faper]; 0*?kjoe`an]j`kmqan]vkrai`kcnackhckoa`kh]pei n]pek(atlhemqakmqaah]oecjeÚ_]`ao`aoq]knecai* 1*Mq]eook]o]pepq`aoiajp]eoklkop]o n]vk; 2*Ajqianakolnej_leko]mqa]n]vkk^a`a_a* 3*Atlhemqaklnej_lek`ae`ajpe`]`a* 4*Atlhemqaklnej_lek`a_kjpn]`ek* 5*Atlhemqaklnej_lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpa* -,*Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`]n]vk;
#!0É45,/ß =]pere`]`an]_ekj]h -* Atlhemqa_kikklan]]n]vk`eo_qnoer]kqkn]_ek_jek* .* Atlhemqa_kikklan]]n]vkejpqeper]*
/* Kmqa]ejpqek;@qiatailhklaook]h`aqi_k) jda_eiajpkejpqeperk* 0* Mq]jpkopelko`aejpqekateopai; 1* Mq]eook]o_]n]_panope_]o`]ejpqekailne_]kq oajorah; 2* Mq]eo]o_]n]_panope_]o`]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h; 3* Atlkjd]]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h`a@ao_]npaokqkÎ_k) cepk_]npaoe]jkÏ* 4* @qiatailhklaook]h`an]_ek_jekailne_kna]he) v]`kaioq]re`]_kpe`e]j]* 5* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]`a`qkna]hev]qi]ejba) nj_e]aqi]ej_hqok;@]b niqh]`]`a`qk* -,* ?kikoana]hev]]ej`qk;@qiatailhk* --* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna]ejbanj_e]`a`qper]a]ej`q) per]; -.* Kmqa]^`qk;AtailheÚmqa_kiqi]deop ne]`a `apaperamqark__kjda_a* -/* KmqakNa]heoik; -0* KmqakE`a]heoik;
-,4
#!0É45,/ß
#!0É45,/ß
=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`]; -*Mqakej]peoik; .*Mqakaileneoik; /*Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`kIepk`aAn(j]nn]`klknLh]pk j]Nal^he_]; 0*?kik@ao_]npaoatlhe_]]oe`ae]oej]p]o(]`rajp_e]o aÚ_p_e]o; 1*?kikkoaileneop]oatlhe_]i]]pere`]`a`k_kjda) _eiajpk; 2*Lknmqa@]re`Dqia]Úni]mqaklnej_lek`a_]q) o]he`]`a(ailnac]`kj]o_ej_e]oaj]ÚhkokÚ](jk ej]pkaoei]`mqene`klknatlanej_e]; 3*Mq]eokolnk^hai]o`kej]peoik; 4*Mq]eokolnk^hai]o`kaileneoik; 5*Lkn mqa ko lnk^hai]o `k ej]peoik a `k aileneoik oqo_ep]ik]l]na_eiajpk`k_ape_eoik;
#!0É45,/ß Kolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`kaileneoik6 okhq aoÚhkoÚ_]o -*Mq]eokopelko`aran`]`ao`eopejcqe`]olknHae^jev; .*?kikHae^jev`aÚjaklnej_lek`an]vkoqÚ_eajpaa atlhe_]mqaahac]n]jpa]ja_aooe`]`aaqjerano]he`]) `a`]oe`ae]o; /*Kmqabke]Înarkhqk_klanje_]j]Ïai]opnkjkie]; 0*Mq]h]_npe_]`aG]jp]koÚh okbkoej]peop]oaaile) neop]o; 1*Kmqabke]Înarkhqk_klanje_]j]ÏaiÚhkokÚ]; 2*KmqaG]jpajpaj`alknpn]jo_aj`ajp]h;Rk_o]^a) ne]`ebanaj_e]npn]jo_aj`ajpaapn]jo_aj`ajp]h; 3*Kmqamqan`evan]lnekne;A]lkopanekne; 4*Mq]h ] nah]k aop]^aha_e`] lkn G]jp ajpna n]vk ] lnekneaatlanej_e]]lkopanekne; 5*G]jpnaokhrakeil]ooaajpnakej]peoikakaileneo) ik; -,*Oacqj`k G]jp( mq]eo ok ]o aopnqpqn]o ] lnekne mqa _kjopepqai]n]vkdqi]j]; --*Mq]eook]obkni]o]lnekne`]oajoe^ehe`]`a; -.*Mq]eook]o_]packne]o]lnekne`kajpaj`eiajpk;K mqaokah]o; -/*Lknmqa]n]vkg]jpe]j]oq^faper]; -0*Atlhemqa]`eopejkg]jpe]j]ajpnajqiajkabaj ) iajk* -1*KmqaDacah_nepe_kqj]oÚhkokÚ]o]jpaneknao oq]; -2*Mqamqan`evan]oajpaj]Î=n]vkdeop ne]apai) lkÏ; -3*Mq]eo]o_npe_]o`aDacah]ej]peop]o(aileneop]oa] G]jp; -4*Kmqaa_kik]n]vkl]n]Dacah; -5* ?kikDacah`ao_narak_]iejdklan_knne`klah]n]) vk;
-,5
=n]vkj]ÚhkokÚ]_kjpailkn ja]
-*Mqamqan`evanbajkiajkhkce]; .*Kmqa]alk_d dqooanhe]j]; /*Mq]eo]o_npe_]o`]Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnp]Dacah; 0*Mq]eook]o`q]oik`]he`]`ao`]n]vk]lnaoajp]`]o lah]Pakne]?npe_]; 1*Mq]h]lkoek`koÚh okbkoaopnqpqn]heop]omq]jpk deopkne_e`]`a`]n]vk; 2*Lknmqakoaopnqpqn]heop]ona_qo]i]e`ae]`alnkcnao) okpa ne_kap_je_k; 3*?kik Pdki]o Gqdj bkniqh] ] deop ne] `] _ej_e] ailnac]j`k]oe`ae]o`al]n]`eci]a_neoa`al]n]) `eci]o; 4*Mqa`evaikoÚh okbkol o)ik`anjkook^na]olnapaj) o ao`]n]vk; 5*Lknmqai]jpaikoke`a]h`]n]_ekj]he`]`a]lao]n`]o iq`]j]odeop ne_]o`]e`ae]`an]vk; -,*Mqa]n]vk_kik_nepnek`a_kanj_e]; --*Mqa oecjeÚ_] _kjoe`an]n ] n]vk qi ejopnqiajpk _npe_kl]n]]r]he]n]o_kj`e ao`are`]`kooanaodq) i]jko; -.*?kjoe`an]j`kklkpaj_e]h_npe_kalkhpe_k`]n]vk( lk`aah]_ki^]panpakne]omqapi]laj]o]]l]nj) _e]`an]_ekj]he`]`a(i]ojkokn]_ekj]eo; -/*Lknmqa]o_neoao`]n]vkokkiahdkn]jp`kpk_kj) pn]k`kci]peoik;Kmqak`kci]peoik;
5NIDADEß
=ran`]`a ?]lpqhk-
Ecjknj_e]aran`]`a
?]lpqhk.
>qo_]j`k]ran`]`a
?]lpqhk/
=o_kj_al ao`]ran`]`a
Aijkoo]ok_ea`]`a iqepk`eb _eh`aolanp]nj]olaook]ok`aoafk`a^qo_]n] ran`]`a*Lk`al]na_anl]n]`kt]hmqa]ooeioaf](lkeol]na_aikoreranjqi]ok) _ea`]`amqa]_na`ep]j]o_e j_e]o(mqahqp]lknao_kh]o(mqana_a^a`e]ne]iajpa ejbkni]aorej`]o`afknj]eo(n`eko(pahareoaoana`aoahapnje_]o(mqalkooqe a`epkn]o(hern]ne]o(^e^hekpa_]o(iqoaqo(o]h]o`a_ejai]a`apa]pnk(r `ako(bkpk) cn]Ú]oa_kilqp]`knao* Kn]( fqop]iajpaaoo]ajkniamq]jpe`]`a`ara _qhkoabkni]o`aejbkni]k mqa ]_]^] pknj]j`k pk `eb _eh ] ^qo_] `] ran`]`a( lkeo pk`k iqj`k ]_na`ep] mqaaopna_a^aj`k(`aik`kor]ne]`koa`ebanajpao(ejbkni]ao_eajp Ú_]o(Úhk) oÚ_]o(lkh pe_]o(]np ope_]oamqaaoo]oejbkni]aookran`]`aen]o(ok^napq`k lknmqap]hmq]jpe`]`a`aejbkni]kqhpn]l]oo]]atlane j_e]rere`]lah]olao) ok]o(mqa(lkneook(jkp iiaekol]n]]r]he]nkmqana_a^ai*
K^n]`]]npeop]iqhpei`e]jknpa)]iane_]j]>]n^]n]Gnqcan(`a-540*=ol]h]rn]oai`aop]mqa(bkni]`]o lah]o hapn]o na_knp]`]o( `evai6ÎRk_ rk_ iaoikÏ* Ai p]i]jdk iajkn( ] l]h]rn] jk can] ] oacqj`] lkooe^ehe`]`a`ahaepqn]6ÎRk_ jkrk_ iaoikÏ*
x5.)$!$%ßx=ran`]`a
#APqTULOß Ecjknj_e]aran`]`a
=ran`]`a_kikqir]hkn
ÎJ
koa]lnaj`abehkokbe](i]o]behkokb]nÏ(f`eooaG]jp*=behkokbe]jkqi_kj) fqjpk `a e`ae]o a `a oeopai]o mqa lkoo]iko ]lnaj`an ]qpki]pe_]iajpa( jk qil]ooaekpqnope_klah]ol]eo]cajoejpaha_pq]eo(i]oqi]`a_eokkq`ahe) ^an]kkneajp]`]lknqir]hkn6]ran`]`a*k`aoafk`kran`]`aenkmqaikra]behkokbe]a oqo_ep]behkokbe]o* =beni]nmqa]ran`]`aqir]hknoecjebe_]mqakran`]`aenk_kjbanao_keo]o(]kooanao dqi]jko(]kiqj`kqioajpe`kmqajkpane]ioabkooai_kjoe`an]`koej`ebanajpaoran) `]`aab]hoe`]`a*
Ecjkn j_e](ej_anpav]aejoacqn]j]
E
cjkn]njko]^an]hcqi]_keo]*=ecjkn j_e]lk`aoanpklnkbqj`]mqajaioamqan ]lan_a^aikokq]oajpeiko(eopk(jko]^aikomqajko]^aiko(jko]^aikomqa ecjkn]iko*Aican]h(kaop]`k`aecjkn j_e]oai]jpiaij oajmq]jpk]o_naj]oa kleje aomqalkooqikol]n]rerana]cenjkiqj`koa_kjoanr]i_kikabe_]vaoapaeo(`a ik`kmqajkpaikojajdqiikperkl]n]`qre`]n`ah]o(jajdqiikperkl]n]`ao_kjbe]n `ah]oa(_kjoamqajpaiajpa(]_d]ikomqao]^aikopq`kkmqadl]n]o]^an* =ej_anpav]`ebanajpa`]ecjkn j_e]lknmqa(j]ej_anpav](`ao_k^neikomqaokikoec) jkn]jpao(mqajkoo]o_naj]oakleje aol]na_aijk`]n_kjp]`]na]he`]`a(mqadb]hd]o j]mqehkaimqa]_na`ep]ikoamqa`qn]jpaiqepkpailkjkooanreq_kiknabanj_e]l]n] lajo]na]cen*J]ej_anpav]jko]^aikokmqalajo]n(kmqa`evankqkmqab]vanai_anp]o oepq] aokq`e]jpa`a_anp]o_keo]o(laook]o(b]pko(ap_*Paiko`re`]o(be_]iko_daeko`a lanlhate`]`aaokikopki]`kolah]ejoacqn]j]* Kqpn]oravao(aop]iko_kjbe]jpaoaoacqnkoa(`analajpa(raikokqkqreiko]hcqi]_ke) o]mqajkoaj_dai`aaol]jpka`a]`ien]k(jko]^aikokmqalajo]nkqkmqab]van_ki ]jkre`]`amqareikokqkqreikolknmqa]o_naj]o(kleje aoae`ae]omqalkooqikojk `k_kjp]`kjkrk*Kaol]jpka]]`ien]k(]ooei_kik]jpao]`re`]a]lanlhate`]`a(jko b]vaimqanano]^ankmqajko]^]iko(jkob]vaimqanano]en`kaop]`k`aejoacqn]j]kq`a aj_]jp]iajpk(jkob]vailan_a^anjkoo]ecjkn j_e]a_ne]ik`aoafk`aoqlan]n]ej_anpav]* Mq]j`keook]_kjpa_a(aop]ikoj]`eolkoek`aaolnepk_d]i]`]_rp`^a^sboa^ab*
@aoafk`]ran`]`a K`aoafk`]ran`]`a]l]na_aiqepk_a`kjkooanaodqi]jkoaoai]jebaop]_kik`aoafk `a_kjbe]nj]o_keo]oaj]olaook]o(eopk(`a]_na`ep]nmqa]o_keo]ookat]p]iajpap]eo_kik ]olan_a^aikoakmqa]olaook]ojko`evai`ecjk`a_kjbe]j]a_n`epk*=kiaoikpailk( jkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j]baep]`alamqaj]oacn]j`ao`a_al aoa(lkneook(`ao`a_a`k(raiko]o _ne]j]olancqjp]nai]ko]`qhpkooap]hkqmq]h_keo]Î`aran`]`akq`aiajpen]Ï* Mq]j`kqi]_ne]j]kqraqi]deop ne](ejrajp]qi]^nej_]`aen]kqqi^nejmqa`k( mq]j`kfkc](rqibehiakqqi]la]pa]pn]h(aopoailna]pajp]l]n]o]^anoaÎ`aran`])
--.
4HEß7ALTß$ISNEYß#OMPANY
Ecjkn j_e]aran`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
--/
`akq`aiajpen]Ï(aopoailna]pajp]l]n]]`ebanaj]ajpnakÎ`aiajpen]Ïa]iajpen]lnk) lne]iajpa`ep](eopk(l]n]]`ebanaj]ajpna^nej_]n(fkc]n(bejcenab]hp]n_kjbe]j]* Mq]j`kqi]_ne]j]^nej_](fkc]abejca(aop_ne]j`kqikqpnkiqj`k(i]eone_kai]eo ^ahk(i]eo_daek`alkooe^ehe`]`aoaejraj ao`kmqakiqj`kkj`a(`ab]pk(rera*I]oo]^a( iaoikmqajkbkniqhaatlhe_ep]iajpap]ho]^an(mqadqi]`ebanaj]ajpnaei]cej]ka lan_alk(]ej`]mqa(jk_]okejb]jpeh(aoo]`ebanaj]oaf]iqepkpjqa(iqepkhara(mq]oaei) lan_alprahÍp]jpk]ooeimqa]_ne]j]]_na`ep]aiiqj`koaoanaoi]n]rehdkoko_kik l]npa`kiqj`kna]h`aoq]re`]* Lkneookiaoik(]_ne]j]iqe) pkoajorahiajpen]`ko]`qhpko(lkeo ]iajpen]`ebanajpa`kÎ`aiajpen]Ï( eopk(]iajpen]`ebanajpa`]ei]ce) j]k(a]_ne]j]oaoajpabane`](i]) ck]`](]jcqope]`]mq]j`kk]`qhpkhda `ev qi] iajpen]( lknmqa( ]k b]v)hk( mqa^n]]nah]k`a_kjbe]j]a]oa) cqn]j]ejb]jpeo* Mq]j`k _ne]j]o( aop]iko oq) faepko ] `q]o `a_al ao6 ] `a mqa ko oanao( ]o _keo]o( ko iqj`ko i]n]re) hdkoko jk ateopaiÎ`a ran`]`aÏ a ] `a mqa ko ]`qhpko lk`ai `evan)jko b]hoe`]`ao a jko ajc]j]n* Aoo] `qlh] `a_alk lk`a ]_]nnap]n `keo naoqh) p]`koklkopko6kq]_ne]j]oana_qo] ] o]en `k iqj`k ei]cejnek a okbna _ki]na]he`]`a_kikoaj`k]hcqi] _keo] nqei a dkopeh ] ah]7 kq( `khknk) o]iajpa(]_aep]]`eopejk(i]op]i) ?aj]`kbehia`a]jei]kLapanL]j( ^ioapknj]iqepk]pajp]a`ao_kj) `a-51/(`]@eojau*?ki]]fq`]`a be]`] `e]jpa `] l]h]rn] `ko ]`qhpko* OejejdkaLapanL]j(Saj`u(Fkdja Jaopa oacqj`k _]ok( ] _ne]j] p]i) Ie_d]ah@]nhejcaopk]_]iejdk`] Pann]`kJqj_]* ^ioa_khk_]`eolkoek`]_rp`^ a^sboa^ab* Jaoo]^qo_](]_ne]j]lk`a`aoaf]nqiiqj`kiahdknai]eo^ahk`kmqa]mqahaai mqareraaaj_kjpn]n]ran`]`aj]ok^n]o`a]npa(`aoaf]j`koan]npeop]p]i^i*Kqlk`a`a) oaf]no]^an_kikalknmqakiqj`kaimqarerap]h_kikaoaahalk`ane]oan`ebanajpa kqiahdkn`kmqa*Jaooa_]ok(`aolanp]`kjah]k`aoafk`a_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]hak `]]kpn]jobkni]`kn]* = _ne]j] jk oa `a_al_ekj] jai oa `aoehq`a _ki kÎb]v `a _kjp]Ï lknmqa o]^a mqa qiÎb]v `a _kjp]Ï* Ah] oa `a_al_ekj] kq oa `aoehq`a mq]j`k `ao_k^na mqa mqanai mqa ]_na`epa_kikoaj`kÎ`aran`]`aÏ]hcqi]_keo]mqaah]o]^akqmqaah]oqlqjd]mqabkooa Î`ab]v`a_kjp]Ï(eopk(`a_al_ekj])oaa`aoehq`a)oamq]j`k`ao_k^na]iajpen]*Kofkrajo oa`a_al_ekj]iaoa`aoehq`aimq]j`k`ao_k^naimqakmqahdaobkeajoej]`kahdaobke atece`kk_qhp]]na]he`]`a(nalneiaoq]he^an`]`a(`eiejqeoq]_]l]_e`]`a`a_kilnaajok a `a ]k* Ko ]`qhpko oa `aoehq`ai kq oa `a_al_ekj]i mq]j`k ajbnajp]i oepq] ao j]o mq]eoko]^an]`mqene`k(]okleje aoaop]^aha_e`]oa]o_naj]oajn]ev]`]oj]_kjo_ej_e] jkokoqbe_eajpaol]n]mqa_kilnaaj`]ikmqaoal]oo]jail]n]mqalkoo]i]cenkq b]van]hcqi]_keo]* =ooei(oaf]j]_ne]j](oaf]jkofkrajokqjko]`qhpko(]^qo_]`]ran`]`aaopoailna hec]`]]qi]`a_alk(]qi]`aoehqok(]qi]`re`](]qi]lanlhate`]`a(]qi]ejoacq) n]j]kq(ajpk(]qiaol]jpkaqi]]`ien]k`e]jpa`a]hckjkrkaejo hepk*
x5.)$!$%ßx=ran`]`a
@ebe_qh`]`aol]n]]^qo_]`]ran`]`a
A
"URKE4RIOLOß0RODUCTIONS'ETTYß)MAGES
ijkoo]ok_ea`]`aiqepk`eb_eh`aolanp]nj]olaook]ok`aoafk`a^qo_]n]ran`]`a* Lk`a l]na_an l]n]`kt]h mqa ]ooei oaf]( lkeo l]na_aiko reran jqi] ok_ea`]`a mqa ]_na`ep]j]o_ej_e]o(mqahqp]lknao_kh]o(mqana_a^a`e]ne]iajpaejbkni] aorej`]o `a fknj]eo( n`eko( pahareo ao a na`ao ahapnje_]o( mqa lkooqe a`epkn]o( hern]ne]o( ^e^hekpa_]o( iqoaqo(o]h]o`a_ejai]a`apa]pnk(r`ako(bkpkcn]be]oa_kilqp]`knao* Kn](fqop]iajpaaoo]ajkniamq]jpe`]`a`ara_qhkoabkni]o`aejbkni]kmqa]_]) ^]pknj]j`kpk`eb_eh]^qo_]`]ran`]`a(lkeopk`kiqj`k]_na`ep]mqaaopna_a^aj`k(`a ik`kor]ne]`koa`ebanajpao(ejbkni] ao_eajpbe_]o(behko be_]o(lkhpe_]o(]npope_]oamqaao) o]oejbkni] aookran`]`aen]o(ok^napq`klknmqap]hmq]jpe`]`a`aejbkni]kqhpn]l]oo] ]atlanej_e]rere`]lah]olaook]o(mqa(lkneook(jkpiiaekol]n]]r]he]nkmqana_a^ai* >]op]ne]( jk ajp]jpk( mqa qi] iaoi] laook]( `qn]jpa qi] oai]j]( haooa `a i]jd mq]pnk fknj]eo `ebanajpao( kqreooa pno jkpe_eneko `a n`ek `ebanajpao a na_a^aooa jkp_e]o bknja_e`]olknpnopfqbp`]Ejpanjap7p]n`a(bnamqajp]ooa`q]oao_kh]o`ebanajpao(kj`ako iaoiko_qnokobkooaiiejeopn]`ko7a(jkepa(reooakojkpe_eneko`amq]pnk_]j]eo`ebanaj) pao`apahareok(l]n]mqa(_kil]n]j`kpk`]o]oejbkni] aona_a^e`]o(`ao_k^neooamqaah]o Îjk^]paiÏqi]o_ki]okqpn]o(mqadrnekoÎiqj`koÏarne]oÎok_ea`]`aoÏ`ebanajpao( `alaj`aj`k`]bkjpa`aejbkni]k* Qi] atlanej_e] _kik aoo] _ne]ne] lanlhate`]`a( `re`] a ej_anpav]* I]o ]o laook]o jkb]vaikqjklk`aib]vanp]hatlanej_e]alkneookjklan_a^aimqa(aihqc]n`a na_a^anejbkni] ao(aopk(j]i]ekne]`]oravao(oa`aoejbkni]j`k*A(ok^napq`k(_kikd kqpn]olaook]o$kfknj]heop](kn]`e]heop](klnkbaookn(klkhe_e]h(knal npan%`evaj`k]ah]ok mqa`araio]^an(kmqalk`aio]^an(kmqalk`aia`araib]vankqoajpen(]k_kjbe]nj] l]h]rn]`aooaoÎaieooknao`aiajo]cajoÏ(]olaook]ooaoajpaioacqn]oa_kjbe]jpao*Kqoaf]( jkdej_anpav]lknmqadecjkn j_e]* Qi]kqpn]`ebe_qh`]`al]n]b]vanoqncenk`aoafk`]^qo_]`]ran`]`a(aijkoo]ok_ea) `]`a(rai`]lnkl]c]j`]* =lnkl]c]j`]pn]p]pk`]o]olaook]oÍ_ne]j]o(fkrajo(]`qhpko(e`kokoÍ_kik_ne]j]o atpnai]iajpaejcjq]oa_n`qh]o*Kiqj`koailnaqiiqj`kÎ`ab]v`a_kjp]Ï6jaha] i]nc]nej]bnao_]b]v]b]ihe]^kjep](]hacna(qje`]abahev7k]qpki rahb]vkdkiai_kjbe]jpa( ejpahecajpa(^ahk(oa`qpkn(^ai)oq_a`e`kjkojac _eko(_daek`aj]ikn]`]ohej`]o7k`aok`k) n]jpab]v]ik]^kjep](]pn]ajpa(^aiailnac]`](^airaope`](_kiqi^ahk]l]np]iajpk ahej`koj]ikn]`ko7k_ec]nnkhar]]olaook]ol]n]^ahooei]ol]eo]cajoat pe_]o(_dae]o`a ]rajpqn]a`ajac _eko_knk]`ko`aoq_aookmqapaniej]i_kihej`kof]jp]naohqv`arah]o*
=lnkl]c]j`]pn]p] pk`]o]olaook]oÍ _ne]j]o(fkrajo(]`qh) pko(e`kokoÍ_kik _ne]j]oatpnai]) iajpaejcjq]oa _n`qh]o*Kiqj`k oailnaqiiqj`k Î`ab]v`a_kjp]Ï*
--0
Ecjkn j_e]aran`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
=lnkl]c]j`]jqj_]raj`aqilnk`qpk`evaj`kkmqaahaal]n]mqaoanra*Ah]raj`a qi]ei]cai$`abahe_e`]`a(`aoq_aook(`afqrajpq`a(`ao]`a(`anemqav](`a^ahav](ap_*% mqapn]joiepe`]lkniaek`klnk`qpk(nk`a]j`k)k`ai]ce]o(^ahav]o(`]j`k)hdamq]he`]) `aomqaok`akqpn]o_keo]o$]_ne]j]o]q`rah(kfkrai^kjepk(k]`qhpkejpahecajpa(ke`kok bahev(]_]o]]cn]`rah(ap_*%(lnk`qvej`kqiapanjkÎb]v`a_kjp]Ï* Qi]kqpn]`ebe_qh`]`al]n]k`aoafk`]^qo_]`]ran`]`arai`]]pepq`a`kolkhpe_ko jkomq]eo]olaook]o_kjbe]i(kqrej`koaqolnkcn]i]o(oq]olnklkop]o(oaqolnkfapko(aj) bei(`]j`k)hdaokrkpkaraj`k)oa(`alkeo(hq`e^ne]`]o(jko lknmqajkok_qilne`]o]o lnkiaoo]o(i]op]i^ilknmqad_knnqlk(i]qqok`k`ejdaenkl^he_k(_nao_eiajpk `]o`aoecq]h`]`aoa`]oejfqope]o(`]ieone]a`]rekhj_e]* Aireop]`eook(]paj`j_e]`]olaook]ofqhc]nmqaeilkoorahd]ranran`]`aj]lkh) pe_]*Iqepkol]oo]i]`ao_kjbe]n`kr]hkna`]ja_aooe`]`a`]`aik_n]_e]a(]k]_aep]nÎraj) `anÏoaqrkpklkn]hcqi]r]jp]caieia`e]p]alaook]h(_]aij]`ao_naj]ajk_ape_eoik* Jk ajp]jpk( aoo]o `ebe_qh`]`ao lk`ai pan k abaepk klkopk( eopk ( oqo_ep]n ai iqep]o laook]o`re`]o(ej_anpav]o(`ao_kjbe]j]oa`aoehqo aomqa]ob]]i`aoaf]n_kjda_an]na]) he`]`a(]ok_ea`]`a(]_ej_e](]o]npao(]lkhpe_]*Iqepko_kia]i]jk]_aep]nkmqahdao `epka]jk]_na`ep]njkmqahdaoikopn]`k*A(_kikO _n]paoai=paj]o(_kia]i]b]van lancqjp]o(]ej`]c]nok^nab]pkoalaook]o(_keo]oaoepq] ao(]atecenatlhe_] ao(]atecen he^an`]`a`alajo]iajpka`a_kjda_eiajpk* L]n]aoo]olaook]ooqncak`aoafka]ja_aooe`]`a`]^qo_]`]ran`]`a*Aoo]^qo_]j]o_a jko `]`re`]a`]ej_anpav](i]op]i^i`]]k`ahe^an]`]_kjpn]kolna_kj_aepko(_kj) pn]]oe`ae]oakleje aoaop]^aha_e`]o(_kjpn]_naj]omqal]n]heo]i]_]l]_e`]`a`alajo]n a`a]cenhernaiajpa* Lk`aiko(`aoo]i]jaen](`eopejcqen`keopelko`a^qo_]`]ran`]`a*Klneiaenkkmqa j]o_a`]ab`bm l(`]fk`boqbw^a`]fkpbdro^k ^a(lknoeiaoik(atecamqao]e]iko`ap]h oepq]kna]`mqenej`k_anpav]o*Koacqj`kkmqaj]o_a`]abif_bo^ lkqab`fpl`ajk ]_aep]n]o_anpav]oa_naj]oaop]^aha_e`]o(`aen]hi`ah]oa`aaj_kjpn]natlhe_] ao(ejpan) lnap] aoaoecjebe_]`kol]n]]na]he`]`amqajko_an_]*Aooaoacqj`kpelk]^qo_]`]ran`]) `aj]]pepq`abehkobe_]*
Atailhko`]^qo_]behkobe_]`]ran`]`a Lk`aikokbana_an`keoatailhko_ha^nao`aoo]^qo_]behko be_]*Fb]h]iko`klneiaenk6 O _n]pao]j`]j`klah]onq]oaln]]o`a=paj]o`e]hkc]j`k_kiko]pajeajoao(ej`]c]j`koao]) ^e]iran`]`aen]iajpakmqaan]i]o_keo]oae`ae]oaimqa]_na`ep]r]i*Koacqj`katailhk k`kbeh okbk@ao_]npao(mqa`e]hkc]_kjoeckiaoik(ej`]c]j`koa_kjda_aran`]`aen]iajpa ]mqehkmqaei]cej]o]^an*Reiko(j]Ejpnk`qk(]oaiahd]j]ajpnaO _n]paoa]lanokj]cai `aJak(jkbehiaJ^qofu*Ranaiko(]ckn](]oaiahd]j]ajpnaJak(Iknbaqa@ao_]npao* @ao_]npao_kia]oq]k^n]behko be_]b]vaj`kqi^]h]jk`apq`kkmqao]^e]6kmqa hdabkn]ajoej]`klahkolna_alpknaoalnkbaooknao(lahkohernko(lah]ore]cajo(lahk_kjrrek _kikqpn]olaook]o*=kbej]h(_kj_hqemqapq`kmq]jpk]lnaj`an](pq`kmq]j`ko]^e]apq`k mq]jpk _kjda_an] lah] atlanej_e] an] `qre`kok a ej_anpk* @a_e`a( ajpk( jk ]_aep]n ja) jdqi`aooao_kjda_eiajpko(]iajkomqalq`aooalnkr]nn]_ekj]hiajpamqaan]i_anpko a`ecjko`a_kjbe]j]*L]n]eook(oq^iapapk`koko_kjda_eiajpkoateopajpaoaioq]lk_] akooaqoln lneko]qiat]ia_npe_k_kjda_e`k_kik`re`]iap`e_](`a_h]n]j`kmqa o ]_aep]ne]qi_kjda_eiajpk(qi]e`ae](qib]pkkqqi]klejekoa(l]oo]`kolahk_nerk `]`re`](narah]nai)oaej`q^epraeol]n]klajo]iajpklqnk*Lknmqa]`re`]_]npaoe]j] iap `e_];Lknmqaah]qiejopnqiajpkejpaha_pq]hailnac]`klahklajo]iajpkl]n]]r]) he]na_kjpnkh]noq]oln lne]oe`ae]o(]_aep]j`k_kikrhe`]okqran`]`aen]ookiajpa]mqah]o mqanaoeopenai]klnk_aook`]`re`]* @ao_]npaooq^iapapk`kokooaqo_kjda_eiajpko]jheoaa]kn]_ek_jek(`aikjopn]j) `kmqalkooqikon]v aobknpaol]n]`qre`]n`]ateopj_e]`ajkook_knlka`kiqj`k*Lkn atailhk(o]^a)oamqa]olaook]omqaokbnan]i]ilqp]k`a]hcqiiai^nk_kjpejq]i
--1
x5.)$!$%ßx=ran`]`a
oajpej`kbnek(_]hkna`knjaooaiai^nkejateopajpa*@ao_]npaolancqjp]6mqaikperkn]_ek) j]hiajparhe`kaqpane]l]n]jkoqlknmqapk`kkiaq_knlk(mqaoejpklanbaep]iajpa(jk qi]ehqok(_kik]`kiai^nk]ilqp]`k$_kjda_e`k_kikÎiai^nkb]jp]oi]Ï%;Qi] e`ae]oaiahd]jpa]l]na_aaiJ^qofu(mq]j`kJakoajpa(]l]rkn]`k(mqaoaq_knlkjkateo) pa(i]oaop_kjranpe`kjqii]pane]h^nehd]jpaareo_kok(kqmq]j`k]lnaj`ahqp]oi]n_e]eo oaioaikran`]_]`aen]kj`aaopoajp]`k(kmqa`aikjopn](lknp]jpk(mqajkna]hiajpa oaq_knlkmqaaopj]hqp]*Oanmqaahalkooqeiaoikqi_knlk; Mq]jpkateopj_e]`kiqj`k(@ao_]npaokbana_aqi]ncqiajpk_kjda_e`k_kikÎ]n) cqiajpk`kokjdkÏ6mq]j`kokjd]iko(aop]iko_kjraj_e`ko`amqa]na]he`]`aokjd]`] ateopaamqa]_kjda_aikop]h_kik(`ai]jaen]mqajkd`ebanaj]ajpna]lan_alk`] na]he`]`alahkokjd]`kna]lan_alk`kiqj`klkn]mqahamqaaop`aolanpk* Kqoaf](jklkooqiko_nepnekol]n]`eopejcqenokjdkareche]a(lknp]jpk(jkpaiko jajdqi_nepnekn]_ekj]hl]n]]beni]nmqakiqj`kateopakqmqaahajkqiokjdk*Aoo] e`ae]]lnaoajp]`]aiJ^qofufqop]iajpalknIknbaq(k`aqo`kokjka`kokjdk(lancqj) p]j`k]Jakoaaopao]^a`eopejcqenajpna]na]he`]`aa]ehqok(lkeol]ookq]re`]jqiiqj) `kmqajkateopana]hiajpa* Jkajp]jpk(ikopn]@ao_]npao(dqiikiajpkaimqa]`re`]oaejpannkilaja_ao) o]ne]iajpalknmqaklajo]iajpkaj_kjpn](ajbei(qi]lneiaen]ran`]`aej`q^eprah6Îaq lajokÏ*Aoo]lneiaen]ran`]`alk`aoanpn]`qve`]lahkoacqejpan]_ek_jek6aqlajok(lkeo(oa aq`qre`]n`amqaaopkqlajo]j`k(]ej`]aopkqlajo]j`k(reopkmqa`qre`]nqi]i]jaen] `alajo]n*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(mq]j`kaopkq`qre`]j`k`apq`k$`]ateopj_e]`aiaq_knlk a`]ateopj_e]`kiqj`k%jklkook`qre`]n`amqaaopkq`qre`]j`k*Kn](`qre`]nqi] i]jaen]`alajo]na(lknp]jpk(mq]j`kaopkq`qre`]j`k(aopkqlajo]j`k6Îaq`qre`kÏoec) jebe_]ÎaqlajokÏ*Ajklkook`qre`]n`amqalajok*=_kjo_ej_e]`klajo]iajpk]l]na_a( ]ooei(_kik]lneiaen]ran`]`aej`q^eprahmqaoank]he_an_al]n]pk`koko_kjda_eiajpko bqpqnko*Kn](oalajok(klajo]nateopaa]mqahamqalajo]ateopa(`kj`a]_ha^na]beni]k `a@ao_]npao6ÎLajok(hkckateopkÏ*=ateopj_e]`klajo]iajpka`koqfaepklajo]jpaoan( ajpk(klkjpk`al]npe`]l]n]]okqpn]oran`]`ao$ateopj_e]`ajkook_knlk(ateopj_e]`k iqj`katpanekn%kqk]he_an_al]n]]na_kjopnqk`ka`eb_ek`ko]^an*
#APqTULOß >qo_]j`k]ran`]`a
@kci]peoika^qo_]`]ran`]`a
M
q]j`klnaop]iko]pajkaiO _n]paokq@ao_]npao(jkp]ikomqa]i^ko(lknikpe) rko`ebanajpaoaqo]j`klnk_a`eiajpko`ebanajpao(b]vaiqi]iaoi]_keo](eopk( `ao_kjbe]i`]okleje aoa_naj]oaop]^aha_e`]oaioq]ook_ea`]`ao(i]op]i^i `ao_kjbe]i`]ooq]oln lne]oe`ae]oakleje ao*@kmqa`ao_kjbe]iahao(]bej]h;@ao_kjbe]i `k`kci]peoik* Kmqa`kci]peoik;
DOGMAßDOGMATISMOß DOGMATISMOßVEMßDAß PALAVRAßGREGAßDOGMA ßQUEß SIGNIFICAß±UMAßOPINIjOß ESTABELECIDAßPORßDECRETOßEß ENSINADAßCOMOßUMAßDOU TRINA ßSEMßCONTESTAljO²
--2
#OLEljOß0ARTICULAR
>qo_]j`k]ran`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
Lh]jkoaioqlanb_ea ik`qh]`]j¸1( `a-513(k^n]`a Huce]?h]ngj] mq]hkolh]jkook lan_a^e`ko(ai^kn] jkateop]ijk aol]k^e`eiajoekj]h `]pah]*
--3
@kci]peoikqi]]pepq`aj]pqn]haaolkjp ja]mqapaiko`ao`aiqepk_ne]j]o*jko) o]_naj]`amqakiqj`kateopaamqaat]p]iajpa`]bkni]_kikklan_a^aiko*Paikoaoo] _naj]lknmqaokikooanaolnpe_ko(eopk(jkonah]_ekj]iko_ki]na]he`]`a_kikoaah]bkooa qi_kjfqjpk`a_keo]o(b]pkoalaook]omqaokpaeokqejpaeol]n]jkoo]ok^narerj_e]* Lknoanqi]klejek`a_nap]`]kqqi]`kqpnej]ejmqaopekj]`](qi`kci]pki]`k _kikqi]ran`]`amqajklk`aoan_kjpaop]`]jai_nepe_]`](_kik]_kjpa_a(lknatai) lhk(j]jkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j](mq]j`k(`e]jpa`aqi]lancqjp]kq`aqi]`re`]mqa]lna) oajp]iko(jkonaolkj`ai6Î]ooeilknmqa]ooeialknmqapai`aoan]ooeiÏ* K`kci]peoikqi]]pepq`a]qpknepne]aoq^ieoo]*=qpknepne]lknmqajk]`iepa `re`](_kjpaop]ka_npe_]*Oq^ieoo]lknmqaoa_qnr]okleje aoaop]^aha_e`]o*=o_neoao( ]o`ebe_qh`]`aoakoeil]ooao`]n]vkikopn]i(]ooei(kklkopk`k`kci]peoik*Ej`e_]i ]pepq`anabhater]a_npe_]ln lne]`]n]_ekj]he`]`a(`aop]_]j`k]eilknp j_e]bqj`]iajp]h `]he^an`]`a`alajo]iajpkl]n]]ln lne]n]vkal]n]]behkokbe]* Kooanaodqi]jkopn]^]hd]i*Kpn]^]hdkqi]]klah]mq]hik`ebe_]iko]o_keo]o a]na]he`]`a`aik`k]_kjoacqenjkoo]lnaoanr]kj]ateopj_e]*Ahao_kjopnkai_]o]o( b]^ne_]iraopqnekaqpajoheko(lnk`qvaik^fapkop_je_ko$koejopnqiajpko%a`a_kjoqik( ejrajp]iiaeko`apn]jolknpa(`a_kiqje_]ka`aejbkni]k*Lkniaek`]lnpe_]kq`k pn]^]hdka`]p_je_](kooanaodqi]jkoknc]jev]i)oaa_kjkie_]iajpa$_khap]`abnqpko( _]]alao_](l]opknaek(]cne_qhpqn](_kin_ek(ej`opne]%(_ne]iejopepqe aook_e]eo$b]ihe]( l]najpao_k(nahecek(_h]ooaoacnqlkook_e]eo(ao_kh](bkni]o`a]ooeopj_e]a`a]il]nk] n) bkoarer]o(dkolep]eo(ap_*%aejopepqe aolkhpe_]o$kAop]`k(klk`anAta_qperk(Haceoh]perk aFq`e_enek(]obkn]oiehep]naolnkbeooekj]eo(kopne^qj]eoa]ohaeo%* Aoo]o lnpe_]o o ok lkooraeo lknmqa ]_na`ep]iko mqa k iqj`k ateopa( mqa p]h _kik k lan_a^aiko a p]h _kik jko ajoej]n]imqaaha*=_na`ep]ikomqalk`aoanik`ebe_]`kkq _kjoanr]`klknj o7mqaatlhe_]`klah]onahece aoalah]o_ej) _e]o(amqanalnaoajp]`klah]o]npao*=_na`ep]ikomqakokqpnko oanaodqi]jkop]i^iokn]_ekj]eo(lkeo(cn]]ohejcq]cai( pnk_]ikoe`ae]oakleje ao(lajo]iko`aik`kiqepkl]na_e`k( a]ao_kh]akoiaeko`a_kiqje_]kc]n]jpai]i]jqpajk `aoo]ooaiahd]j]o* J]]pepq`a`kcipe_](pki]ikokiqj`k_kikf`]`k(fbae) pk(flajo]`k(fpn]jobkni]`k*=na]he`]`aj]pqn]h(ok_e]h(lkhpe_] a_qhpqn]hbkni]qi]aol_ea`aikh`qn]`aqimq]`nkai_qfk ejpaneknjkoejop]h]ikoakj`aateopeiko*Iaoikmq]j`k]_kj) pa_a]hckat_al_ekj]hkqatpn]kn`ejnek$qi]_]popnkba(k]l]na) _eiajpk`aqik^fapkejpaen]iajpajkrka`ao_kjda_e`k%(jkoo] paj`j_e]aolkjp ja]a`kcipe_]]`ana`qvenkat_al_ekj]ha katpn]kn`ejnek]kol]`n ao`kmqaf_kjda_aikoafo]^aiko* Iaoikmq]j`k`ao_k^neikomqa]hcqi]_keo]`ebanajpa`kmqa d]r]ikooqlkopk(aoo]`ao_k^anp]jk]^]h]jkoo]_naj]ajkoo] _kjbe]j]j]na]he`]`a(jaijkoo]b]iehe]ne`]`a_kiah]* Kiqj`k_kik]jkrah]`]pahareok6iqep]_keo]]_kjpa_a(i]o(]bej]h(j]`]]_kjpa_a( lkeomq]j`k]jkrah]paniej](ko^kjobkn]ina_kilajo]`ko(koi]qobkn]ilqje`ko(kolk) ^nao^kjobe_]n]ine_ko(kone_koi]qobe_]n]ilk^nao(]ik_ejd]_]okq_kikik_ejdk_anpk( ]b]ihe]^k]oanabava]b]ihe]ioa`aobav*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ko]_kjpa_eiajpko`]jkrah] oanrai]laj]ol]n]_kjbeni]nanabkn]nkmqafo]^]ikoakmqafaolanr]iko*Pq`koa i]jpijqi]]pikoban]kqjqi_hei]`ab]iehe]ne`]`a(`aoacqn]j]aokooack* J]]pepq`a`kcipe_]kqj]pqn]h(]_aep]ikooaijajdqilnk^hai]mqadqi]na]he) `]`aatpanekn]j oamqa(ai^kn]atpanj]a`ebanajpa`aj o(lk`aoan_kjda_e`]apa_je_]) iajpapn]jobkni]`]lknj o*=_d]ikomqakaol]kateopa(mqajahaaopk]o_keo]o_kik qina_alp_qhk7]_d]ikomqakpailkp]i^iateopaamqajaha]o_keo]oaj oln lneko aop]ikooq^iape`kooq_aook`koejop]jpao*
x5.)$!$%ßx=ran`]`a
@kci]peoikaaopn]jd]iajpk Ao_qpaiko(lkni(lknqiikiajpk(]ej`]c]k`aO]jpk=ckopejdk(aioq]o@lkcfppbp6
D^ol^aljbrPlM^ril) Rjkbdolsbjsfkal)_o^k`l P_bjmboqlcf`^kbdol) M^pp^bqlok^^cf`^o_o^k`l+ JbrPlM^rila^d^ol^) ÎIlkaobpa^pkb_ifk^pcof^pÎ Rjml_obsbjsfkal)of`l P_bjmboqlcf`^ml_ob) M^pp^bqlok^^cf`^oof`l+ Aooaoranoko(jkomq]eo]c]nk]`aOkL]qhkoal]na_a_ki]ja^hej]`aHkj`nao(eopk(_ki qirq`ajok`a]nie`k(`evaimqajk_kjoacqeikoran]na]he`]`a6kjacnk(`ahkjca( ^n]j_k(klk^na(`ahkjca(ne_k7o iqepk`alanpk(oaikrq`]c]nk](kjacnkjacnkaklk) ^nalk^na*I]o(]lao]n`ar)hko`alanpkp]eo_kikok(`ahkjcarkhp]i]oankmqajkok* Klkap]atlneiaqi`kolnk^hai]omqai]eob]o_ej]i]behkokbe]6_kik]ehqoklko) orah;?kiklk`aikorankmqajk;I]o(_kjoamqajpaiajpa(_kik]ran`]`alkoorah; ?kiklk`aikorankmqa(p]h_kik;Mq]h]Îc]nk]Ïmqaoaejpanl aajpnakjkooklajo]) iajpka]na]he`]`a;Mq]h]Îc]nk]Ïmqaoaejpanl aajpnajkookkhd]na]o_keo]o; = ]pepq`a `kcipe_] kq j]pqn]h oa nkila mq]j`k okiko _]l]vao `a qi] ]pepq`a `a aopn]jd]iajpk`e]jpa`]o_keo]omqajkol]na_e]ib]iehe]nao*@keoatailhkolk`aiehqo) pn]naoo]_]l]_e`]`a`aaopn]jd]iajpk(]i^ko`]ao_nepkn]?h]ne_aHeola_pknaioaqhernk> abp`l_boq^aljrkal*Klneiaenkpai_kikppqhkÎI]eo`kmqaqiejoapkÏ* @rpqbfrjmlr`l^`ljmobbkabolnrbbpq^s^sbkal)abqlfkbpmbo^albprqfinrb bo^7bpq^s^sbkalrjfkpbqlmlrp^al)sboab*`i^ol)abmbok^p^iq^p+Bo^rj^Ïbpmbo^k ^Ð) lnrbpbjmobjbafppbo^jnrbab_lj^rd ofl+Abmlfp^bpmbo^k ^`ljb lr^^ka^o _bjabibsbpl_obl`li`el+Bo^sboabqo^kpm^obkqb)`ljmbok^pnrbj^kqfke^jpbr `lomlmi^kl^iqlbmlo^ppfjafwbopliql)rjmi^klqlcodfinr^kql^pmomof^pmbok^p nrbbo^jcbfq^p^mbk^pa^`loa^`^p`^+Abkqolalcf^mla^pmbok^pkle^sf^k^a^abk* qol7li^alababkqolabrj^prmboc`fbqlo^p^g^momof^prmboc`fb+M^ob`f^rjo^pl abpbkelnrbqfsbppbp^alalm^mbi)sboabb^ka^ppb+++B^ka^s^`ljrj^abqbojfk^ l abnrbj`lmf^ppbrjqo^ lnrbbo^fksfpsbim^o^jfj+++J^plkabbpq^of^jkbib^pdi k*
-fRIOßDEß!NDRADEßß ¯ ßESCRITORßß BRASILEIRO
#LAUDIAß!NDUJAR%DITORAß!BRIL
=o_keo]ookiaoikp]eo_kikia]l]na_ai;Aopkklaol]k;I]okmqakaol]k; Oaaq`eooanmqakaol]kbaepk`a_kilneiajpk(]hpqn]ah]ncqn](kj`alk`anae_khk_]n] lnkbqj`e`]`a(oai]mq]hjklk`aikoran(jklk`aikoajtanc]nj]`];I]o]lnkbqj`e) `]`a(mqaialanieparan]o_keo]oaol]_e]eo(fqop]iajpa]mqehkmqajkrafkamqajk lkook ran( oa aq mqeoan khd]n ]o _keo]o* = lnkbqj`e`]`a kq jk aol]_e]h; Oa bkn aol]_e]h( lknmqajk]rafkklaol]k; Oajkbknaol]_e]h(_kiklk`aoan]_kj`ekl]n]mqaaqraf]]o_keo]oklbpm^ l;=_ki) l]jdaiko]ckn]koranoko`klkap]Inek`a=j`n]`a(ao_nepkojklkai]ÎHen]l]qheop]j]Ï6
+EIJUß+OBAYASHI%DITORAß!BRIL
Lnrblqbjmlkifpbj^qbjqf`^a^idf`^(`a>kkha$ai-403%(aIdf`^cloj^i(`aIknc]j$p]i^i ai-403%*?]^ane]i]eop]n`a]kbeh okbk]haikBnacaa]kobeh okbkoejchaoao>anpn]j`Nqooahh a=hbna`Sdepada]`_kilhap]na_kjokhe`]n]cn]j`apn]jobkni]k`]h ce_](]^]j`kj]j`k]o pakne]o]neopkphe_]o`]ejbanj_e]lknqi]jkr]_kj_alk`alnklkoekh ce_]*
!LFREDß7HITEHEADßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEßß MATEMfTICOßBRIThNICO
Hae^jev`aoajrkhraql]n] ]h ce_]qi]hejcq]cai oaiahd]jpa `]i]paipe_]( l]n]mqak_kjpa`k`]o]ben) i] aojk_kilnkiapaooa ]r]he`]`a`kon]_ek_jeko*
=hce_]i]paipe_]
L
]n]ko]jpecko(kolnej_lekoa]ohaeo`]h ce_]_knnaolkj`e]iaopnqpqn]`]ln lne] na]he`]`a(lkeoklajo]iajpkatlneiakna]ha`ahal]npe_el]*=neop pahao`eve]mqa] ran`]`aa]b]hoe`]`aoklnklnea`]`ao`klajo]iajpkajk`]o_keo]o7mqa]na]he) `]`aa]enna]he`]`a$]l]nj_e]ehqo ne]%oklnklnea`]`ao`]o_keo]oajk`klajo]iajpk7 i]o]beni]r]mqaqilajo]iajpkran`]`aenk`araatlneien]na]he`]`a`]_keo]lajo]`]( ajmq]jpkqilajo]iajpkb]hokj]`]lk`aatlneien* L]n]koia`ear]eoal]n]koik`anjkokq_hooe_ko$o_qhkTREE%(]h ce_]an]qi]^oqb abmbkp^ol]n]^ai_kj`qven]n]vkj]o_ej_e]o*?kik]npa`alajo]n(]h ce_]kbana_e]]k _kjda_eiajpk_eajpbe_kabehko be_k]ohaeo`klajo]iajpkran`]`aenkakolnk_a`eiajpko l]n]]]r]he]k`ko_kjda_eiajpko]`mqene`ko*
-02
=h ce_]oei^ he_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Aoo]h ce_]Í]jpec]aik`anj]kq_hooe_]Íjkan]lhaj]iajpabkni]h(lkeojkan] ej`ebanajpa]ko_kjpa`ko`]olnklkoe aojaioklan] aoejpaha_pq]eo`koqfaepk`k_k) jda_eiajpk*=bkni]h ce_]na_a^e]kr]hkn`aran`]`akqb]hoe`]`a_ki^]oaj]ran`]`a kqb]hoe`]`a`ko]pko`a_kjda_eiajpk`koqfaepkaj]na]he`]`akqenna]he`]`a`kok^fapko _kjda_e`ko*=k_kjpnnek(]h ce_]_kjpailkn ja](lnk_qn]j`kpknj]n)oaqilqnkoei^kheo) ik`kpelki]paipe_kaqi_h_qhkoei^ he_k(lnak_ql])oa_]`]raviajko_kik_kjpa) `k i]pane]h `]o lnklkoe ao $] na]he`]`a `ko k^fapko nabane`ko lah] lnklkoek% a _ki ]o klan] aoejpaha_pq]eo`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk$]aopnqpqn]`klajo]iajpk%*Pknjkq)oa lhaj]iajpabkni]h* =ooei_kikki]paipe_khe`]_kik^fapkomqabkn]i_kjopnq`kolah]oln lne]okla) n] aoi]paipe_]o(`a]_kn`k_kilnej_lekoanacn]olnabet]`koa]_aepkolknpk`ko(]ooei p]i^ikh ce_kah]^kn]kooi^khkoa]oklan] aomqa_kjopepqaikk^fapkh ce_klknat_a) hj_e](]lnklkoek*Kh ce_kej`]c]mqacloj^`aralkooqenqi]lnklkoekl]n]mqa6 oaf])hda]pne^q`kkr]hkn`aran`]`akqb]hoe`]`a7 nalnaoajpa]bkni]`klajo]iajpk7a nalnaoajpa]nah]kajpnalajo]iajpk(hejcq]caiana]he`]`a*
5NIVERSITYßOFß3Tß!NDREWS ßß 3COTLAND!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
AXIOMAßFUNDAMENTOßDEß UMAßDEMONSTRAljO ßELAß MESMAßINDEMONSTRfVEL ß ORIGINADAßDEßPRINCqPIOSß INATOSßDAßCONSCIoNCIAß SEGUNDOßOSßRACIONALISTAS ß OUßDEßGENERALIZAlzESßDAß OBSERVAljOßEMPqRICAß SEGUNDOßOSßEMPIRISTAS
'IUSEPPEß0EANOßß ¯
-03
=h ce_]`ao_nara]obkni]o(]olnklnea`]`aoa]onah] ao`]olnklkoe aocn]]o_kjo) pnqk`aqioei^kheoiknacqh]`kakn`aj]`kmqalaniepa`ebanaj_e]nhejcq]cai_kpe`e]) j]ahejcq]caih ce_]bkni]hev]`]* >kkha`abejeq]h ce_]_kikÎkipk`kmqanalkqo]ok^nakailnack`aoi^khko(`ko mq]eooa_kjda_ai]ohaeocan]eo`a_ki^ej]ka_qfkonaoqhp]`ko]`iepaiejpanlnap]k _kanajpaÏ* =h ce_]pknjkq)oa_]`]ravi]eoqi]_ej_e]bkni]h`]hejcq]cai(i]o`aqi]hejcq]) caiiqepkaola_e]h(mqaj]`]pai]ran_ki]hejcq]cai_kpe`e]j](lkeopn]p])oa`aqi]hej) cq]caiejpaen]iajpa_kjopnq`]lknah]iaoi](_ki^]oajkik`ahk`]i]paipe_]* @keo]ola_pko`araioaniaj_ekj]`kol]n]iahdkn_kilnaaj`aniko]nah]kajpna] h ce_]_kjpailkn ja]a]i]paipe_]* -*
=iq`]j]jkik`k`a_kj_a^ankmqaoaf]]i]paipe_]6 @qn]jpao_qhko$j]ran`]`a(`ao`akocnacko%(_kjoe`ankq)oa]i]paipe_]qi] _ej_e]^]oa]`]j]fkqrf lfkqbib`qr^i`aran`]`ao]^okhqp]o(ateopajpaoaioealknoe iaoi]o(oai`alaj`an`ajajdqi]ejpanbanj_e]dqi]j]*Ko]teki]o(]obecqn]ocak) ipne_]o(kojiankoa]oklan] ao]nepipe_]o(kooi^khkoa]oklan] ao]hc^ne_]o an]i_kjoe`an]`koran`]`ao]^okhqp]o(qjerano]eo(ja_aoone]o(mqaateopene]i_kikq oaikodkiajoamqalani]ja_ane]iateopej`kiaoikoakodqi]jko`ao]l]na_ao) oai$l]n]iqepkobeh okbko(]i]paipe_]_dackq]oan_kjoe`an]`]]_ej_e]`erej]lkn at_ahj_e]%* Jkajp]jpk(`ao`ako_qhkTREEl]ookq)oa]_kjoe`an]n]i]paipe_]qi]_ej_e] mqanaoqhp]`aqi]`lkpqor lfkqbib`qr^i(qi]ejrajk`kaolnepkdqi]jk(oaimqa oq]oajpe`]`aooaf]iateopajpaoaioealknoeiaoi]o*Koajpaoi]paipe_kooklqn]o e`a]he`]`ao_kjopnq`]olahkejpaha_pkkqlahklajo]iajpk(mqabkniqh]qi_kjfqjpk necknkok`alnej_leko(nacn]o(jkni]oaklan] aol]n]]_ne]k`abecqn]o(jianko( oi^khko(_h_qhko(ap_* Jkbei`ko_qhkTET(ki]paipe_kep]he]jkCeqoallaLa]jkna]hevkqqiaopq`k ok^na]]nepipe_]`kojianko_]n`ej]eobejepko`aikjopn]j`kmqalk`e]oan`aner]`] `a _ej_k ]teki]o kq lnklkoe ao lneieper]o a `a pno paniko jk `abejraeo Í vank( jiankaoq_aookn`a* @aoo]i]jaen](]i]paipe_]oqnce]_kikqin]ik`]h ce_](_]^aj`k]k]haik Bnacaa]koejchaoao>anpn]j`Nqooahha=hbna`Sdepada]`lnkooacqenkpn]^]hdk`aLa]) jk(kbana_aj`k]o`abeje aoh ce_]o`kopnopanikomqaki]paipe_kep]he]jkfqhc]) n] ej`abejraeo* Bnaca kbana_aq k lneiaenk _kj_aepk `a pfpqbj^ cloj^i a ko lneiaenko atailhko`k`i`rilabmolmlpf bpbabmobaf`^alp*
x5.)$!$%ßx=h ce_]
=i]paipe_]qi]_ej_e]`abkni]oa_h_qhkolqnkoknc]jev]`kojqi]ifkdr^* dbjpfj_if`^lanbaep](j]mq]h_]`]oecjkqi^idlofqjl(eopk(qioi^khk_kiqi je_koajpe`k*ah]^kn]`]lahkaolnepkdqi]jkajklkniaek`aqilajo]iajpk ejpqeperkmqa_kjpailh]ne]ajpe`]`aolanbaep]oaapanj]o(ateopajpaoaioealknoeiao) i]o*
ALGORITMOßPALAVRAßß DERIVADAßDOßNOMEßDOßß MATEMfTICOßISLhMICOßß !L +HOWARIZMIß/ßALGORIT MOßOFERECEßUMßPROCESSOß DEßDECISjOßPARAßRESOLVERß UMßPROBLEMA
.* Iq`]j]jkik`k`a_kj_a^anklajo]iajpk(`eopejcqej`kloe_khkce]apakne]`k_k) jda_eiajpk6 @qn]jpaiqepkoo_qhko(loe_khkce]apakne]`k_kjda_eiajpkaoperan]i_kjbqj`e) `]o(_kjopepqej`kqi]o `eo_elhej]behko be_](aj_]nnac]`]`aaopq`]nkoik`ko_kik _kjda_aiko]o_keo]o(`eopejcqej`kkmqalqn]iajpalaook]haej`ere`q]h$]re`]lo) mqe_]kqiajp]h`a_]`]qi`aj o%`kmqaqjerano]haja_aoonek$rhe`kaipk`koko pailkoahqc]nao(l]n]pk`kokooqfaepko`k_kjda_eiajpk%* Mq]j`k]loe_khkce]oapknjkqqi]_ej_e]$`ao_nek`kob]pkolomqe_koaoq]o haeo%ej`alaj`ajpa`]behkokbe]a]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpklani]ja_aqbehko be_]$lkn jkoan]laj]oqi]`ao_nek`]re`]iajp]h(i]oqiaopq`k`]o`ebanaj]ojk_kj) pa`kaj]bkni]`ko_kjda_eiajpko%(oqnceq]lancqjp]6ÎKj`abe_]]h ce_];Ï*=hcqjo naolkj`an]i6ÎJ]loe_khkce]Ï*=hac]r]imqakolnkcnaooko`]_ej_e]loe_kh ce_]ene]i `abejen]onacn]oqjerano]eo]mqapk`kamq]hmqanlajo]iajpkoaoq^iapa(a]h ce_] oane]]laj]oqin]ik`]loe_khkce](]mqahamqaaopq`]_kikbqj_ekj]klajo]iajpk _eajpbe_k* Aoo]_knnajpah ce_]na_a^aqkjkia`ampf`lildfpjlidf`l(i]obkehkcknabqp]`]lah] i]ekne]`koh ce_koal]npe_qh]niajpalahk]haikA`iqj`Dqooanh(k_ne]`kn`]bajk) iajkhkce]*Çlancqjp]6ÎKj`abe_]]h ce_];Ïkoh ce_konaolkj`an]i6Î?kjoeckiaoi]Ï* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]h ce_]jkl]npa`]loe_khkce]jai`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk( i]oqi]`eo_elhej]behko be_]ej`alaj`ajpa*Aoo]ej`alaj`j_e]`a_knna`]_kilhate`]) `a`klajo]iajpk(lkeo(mq]j`klajo]iko(dmq]pnkb]pknaomqajkolaniepailajo]n6 -%koqfaepkmqalajo]$koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkaopq`]`klah]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk%7 .%k]pk`alajo]n$]oklan] aoiajp]eoaopq`]`]olah]loe_khkce]%7/%kk^fapklajo]`k $aopq`]`klah]o_ej_e]o%7a0%klajo]iajpk`a_knnajpa`k]pk`alajo]n$aooakk^fapk `]h ce_]%* =h ce_]jkoa_kjbqj`a_ki]loe_khkce]jai_ki]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(lknmqaoaq k^fapkklajo]iajpk_kikklan]k`aikjopn]per](mqaoacqanacn]okneajp]`]ol]n] `apaniej]noa]`aikjopn]kran`]`aen]kqb]ho]`klkjpk`areop]`kln lneklajo]) iajpk(eopk(oa]`aikjopn]kk^a`a_aqkqjk]kolnej_lekoh ce_ko* Mq]hkabaepk`aoo]o`q]oiq`]j]ook^na]h ce_]_kjpailkn ja]; Ailneiaenkhqc]n(]ki]jpan ] lnkteie`]`a a ] nah]k _ki ] i]paipe_](] h ce_] l]ookq]oanajpaj`e`]_kik]r]he]`kn]`]ran`]`akqb]hoe`]`a`klajo]iajpk(_kj_a^e`k _kikqi]_kjopnqkejpaha_pq]h*Kn](oaklajo]iajpk_kjopn eoaqoln lnekok^fapko(ai rav`a`ao_k^ne)hkokq_kjpailh)hko(aoo]_kjopnqk(oacqj`kkoln lnekoi]paipe_ko( b]v_kimqa]i]paipe_]`ar]oanajpaj`e`]_kikqiafp`roplkq_kikqi]ifkdr^dbj mqak^a`a_a]_anpko_nepnekoal]`n ao`abqj_ekj]iajpk*=ooeioaj`k(]h ce_]]`kpkq l]n]oekik`ahk`aqi`eo_qnokkq`aqi]hejcq]caimqahe`]_kilqn]obkni]ooai_kj) pa`kap]eobkni]ookoi^khko`apelki]paipe_k$]hcknepiko%* Aioacqj`khqc]n(`eopejcqej`k)oa`]loe_khkce]a`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(]h ce_] l]ookq]`a`e_]n)oaiajko]klajo]iajpkaiqepki]eohejcq]cai(oaf]_kikpn]`qk( nalnaoajp]k kq atlnaook `k lajo]iajpk( oaf] _kik `eo_qnok ej`alaj`ajpa `k lajo]) iajpk*Oaqk^fapkl]ookq]oankaopq`k`aqipelk`apaniej]`k`a`eo_qnok6]lnklkoe) ka]onah] aoajpnalnklkoe ao*Oq]bej]he`]`apknjkq)oaklnkfapk`akbana_anjkni]o a_nepnekol]n]qi]hejcq]cailanbaep](_]l]v`a]r]he]n]o`ai]eohejcq]cajo$_eajpbe_]o( behko be_]o(]npope_]o(_kpe`e]j]o(ap_*%*
-04
=h ce_]oei^ he_]x#!0É45,/ßx &ERNANDOß-ORAES%DITORAß!BRIL
Hejcq]caiaiap]hejcq]cai
L
]n]_kjoacqenoaqlnkl oepk(]h ce_]`eopejcqa `keojraeo`ahejcq]cai6
-*
ifkdr^dbjk^qro^i(eopk(]mqah]mqaqo]ikoaijko) o]re`]_kpe`e]j](j]o]npao(j]lkhpe_](j]behkokbe]7
.* ifkdr^dbj cloj^i( eopk ( ]mqah] mqa _kjopnq`] oa) cqj`klnej_lekoanacn]o`apaniej]`komqa`ao_narai qipelkaola_be_k`ak^fapk(kk^fapk`]o_ej_e]o* Aoo]`eopejkp]i^ilk`aoan]lnaoajp]`]_kik `ebanaj]ajpna`keopelko`ahejcq]cajooei^ he_]o6 -*
Atailhk`aoei^kheoik `ajkp]perk(jk_dk`] Aop]k`]Hqv(jkiapn `aOkL]qhk(_qfkoecjebe_]`k Îlnke^e`kbqi]nÏ*
]ifkdr^dbjpfj_if`^`riqro^i$]hejcq]caiÎj]pq) n]hÏ%(mqaqo]oecjko(iapbkn]o(]j]hkce]o(aomqai]o l]n] atlneien oecjebe_] ao _kpe`e]j]o( naheceko]o( ]npope_]o( lkhpe_]o( behko be_]o* = lnej_el]h _]n]_pa) nope_]`aooaoei^kheoikoan_kjkp]perk(eopk(ko oi^khko _]nnac]i iqepko oajpe`ko a nabanai)oa ] iqep]o oecjebe_] ao* = hejcq]cai _qhpqn]h mlifp* pjf`^( eopk ( jah] ]o l]h]rn]o lkooqai ejianko oecjebe_]`ko7
0HOTOß2ESEARCHERS,ATINSTOCK
.* ] ifkdr^dbj pfj_if`^ idf`l*`fbkqcf`^ $] hejcq]caiÎ_kjopnq`]Ï%( mqa qo] qi oeo) pai]ba_d]`k`aoecjkokqoi^khko$k]hcknepik%(aimqa_]`]oi^khknalnaoajp] qi]je_]_keo]a_knnaolkj`a]qi]je_]oecjebe_]k*Oq]lnej_el]h_]n]_panope_] oanaooaj_e]hiajpaqioei^kheoik`ajkp]perkkqej`e_]perk(arep]j`k]lkheooaie] a]beni]j`k]qjerk_e`]`a`koajpe`koei^khev]`k*Lknatailhk6D.K((((m(( ap_*okoi^khko`ajkp]perkokqej`e_]perko`aqio k^fapkkq`aqio oajpe`k7ok ]hcknepiko*
,UDWIGß7ITTGENSTEINßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßß AUSTRqACO
=h ce_]k_ql])oa_ki]hejcq]caibkni]hkq_ki]hejcq]caioei^ he_k)_eajpbe_]* Lknoanqi`eo_qnokkqqi]hejcq]caimqab]h]`akqpnk`eo_qnokkq`akqpn]hejcq]cai(oa `evmqaah]qi]iap]hejcq]cai* J]re`]_kpe`e]j](lk`aiko`evan(lknatailhk(qi]bn]oa_kik6ÎKOkhqi]aopnah]Ï* =h ce_]_kia]n`evaj`k6Î=bn]oaÐKOkhqi]aopnah]Ñqi]lnklkoek]beni]per]Ï*Lnko) oacqen`evaj`k6Î=lnklkoekÐ=bn]oaLplirj^bpqobi^qi]lnklkoek]beni]per]Ñ qi]lnklkoekran`]`aen]Ï*A]ooeilkn`e]jpa* =e`ae]`]h ce_]_kikiap]hejcq]caipn]jol]na_a_ki_h]nav]mq]j`kat]iej]iko( lknatailhk(]opaoaolnej_el]eo`k]qopn]_kHq`secSeppcajopaej(_qf]ejbhqj_e]oane]oaj) pe`]lknpk`]]h ce_]`ko_qhkTT6 -*
mq]hmqanlnklkoekmqapajd]oecjebe_]`k_kilkop]lknlnklkoe aoahaiajp]nao( j]omq]eooaaj_kjpn]]ran`]`akq]b]hoe`]`a`]lnklkoek_kioecjebe_]`k7
.* ]olnklkoe aoahaiajp]nao]`mqenaioecjebe_]`klknmqa]becqn]i$napn]p]i%kiqj) `kjk_kikb]pkoa_keo]o(i]o_kikÎaop]`ko`a_keo]oÏ7
-05
/* ]olnklkoe ao`]h ce_]okran`]`aen]oej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`]ojk ao`aÎoecjebe_]) `kÏa`aÎaop]`ko`a_keo]oÏ(lknmqa(necknko]iajpa(jkb]h]i`aj]`](lkeonabanai)oa ]mq]hmqanb]pk(oecjebe_]`kkqaop]`k`a_keo]omqalkoo]ik_knnankqjkjkQjeranok* =olnklkoe aoh ce_]ooksboa^abps^wf^p(nabane`]o]laj]o]kln lnekqok`]o_kjraj) aoh ce_]o*
x5.)$!$%ßx=h ce_]
0AULOß-ARGUTTIß0INTO ß FILvSOFOßEßPROFESSORß BRASILEIRO ßESPECIALISTAßEMß LvGICA ßARGUMENTAljOßEß FILOSOFIAßDAßLINGUAGEM
±0ORTRAITß'ALLERY²ßß 4HOEMMESß#ONTINUUM7IKIPmDIA
AioaqhernkFkqolar l idf`^pfj_if`^(kh ce_kL]qhkI]ncqppeLejpkatlhe_]]`eba) naj]ajpnasboa^abas^ifa^abfkcbobk`f^i* ?kikfreiko(qin]_ek_jekna]hev]qi]ejbanj_e](eopk(]k^pajk`aqi]_kj_hq) okkqqi]_kjoamqj_e]_ki^]oaaiqi]jpa_a`ajpa`kmq]hah]atpn]`]*Na]hev]nqi] ejbanj_e]lnk`qvenqi^odrjbkql*Aopalk`aoan`abeje`k_kikqi`eo_qnokjkejpanekn `kmq]hoaatpn]eqi]_kjoamqj_e]*Qi]ncqiajpkbaepk`aoajpaj]oa`anah] aoajpna ]ooajpaj]o(lk`aj`koanmbopr^pfsl$mq]j`k^qo_]]]`aokaik_ekj]h`a]hcqi%kqab* jlkpqo^qfsl$mq]j`k^qo_]]]`aokn]_ekj]h`a]hcqi%*Qi]ncqiajpksifalmq]j`k] ejbanj_e]na]hev]`]aop_knnap]*Eookoecjebe_]mqaÎr]he`]`aejbanaj_e]hÏjkoejjeik`a Îran`]`aÏ(lkeoqi]ncqiajpk_knnapkjkajrkhraja_aoo]ne]iajpaoajpaj]oran`]`aen]o* =ooei(]h ce_]Îkaopq`k`kolnej_lekomqanacai]ejbanj_e]rhe`]Ïaoaq_]ilk Î]mqah]l]npa`]hejcq]caij]mq]haopklnaoajpaoko]ncqiajpko`aikjopn]perkoÏ*Ah]abapq] ]]jheoah ce_]`ko]ncqiajpkol]n]]r]he]noq]_knnakkqej_knnak*L]n]eook(ah]kbana_a qi_kjfqjpk`anacn]omqaaop]^aha_ai_kilna_eok]ol]oo]cajo_knnap]o`ko]jpa_a`ajpao ]ko_kjoamqajpao*Lknp]jpk(ao_naraI]ncqppeLejpk(Îmq]j`katlhe_ep]ikoaop]onacn]o]pn]ro `aoi^khko]`amq]`ko(aj_kjpn]ik)jkojk`kijek`]h ce_]oei^ he_]Ï*
0HOTOß2ESEARCHERS,ATINSTOCK
@abejek`]hce_]oei^he_]
Hce_]`kolna`e_]`koahce_]`]onah] ao
=
neop pahaomq]jpebe_kq]olnklkoe aolah]mq]jpebe_]k`koqfaepk$qlalplpP(kb* kerj P( ^idrkp P%* =hcqjo beh okbko ia`ear]eo a ik`anjko fqhc]n]i ja_aoonek mq]jpebe_]n(]hi`koqfaepk`]lnklkoek(p]i^iklna`e_]`k*Jko_qhkTET(k h ce_kejchoD]iehpkjharkq]r]jpa]mq]jpebe_]k`kolna`e_]`ko(_dac]j`k]kepkpelko `alnklkoe ao6 -*
(AMILTON߯ ßß FILvSOFOßEßLvGICOßESCOCoS
^cfoj^qfs^pqlql*qlq^fp(aimqaoqfaepkalna`e_]`kokpki]`koaipk`]oq]atpajokkq qjerano]hiajpa6ÎPk`kPpk`kMÏ*Lknatailhk6ÎPk`kpne jcqhkpk`kpneh]pan]hÏ7
.* ^cfoj^qfs^pqlql*m^o`f^fp(aimqakoqfaepkpki]`kqjerano]hiajpaaklna`e_]`kl]n) pe_qh]niajpa6ÎPk`kP]hcqiMÏ*Lknatailhk6ÎPk`kpne jcqhk]hcqi]becqn]Ï7 /* ^cfoj^qfs^pm^oqf*qlq^fp(aimqakoqfaepkl]npe_qh]naklna`e_]`kpki]`kqjerano]h) iajpa6Î=hcqjoPokpk`koMÏ*Lknatailhk6Î=hcqjooqh)]iane_]jkookpk`koko^n]oe) haenkoÏ7 0* ^cfoj^qfs^pm^oqf*m^o`f^fp(aimqakoqfaepkaklna`e_]`kokpki]`ko_kikl]npe_qh]nao6 Î=hcqiP]hcqiMÏ*Lknatailhk6Î=hcqi]obecqn]oamqeh]pan]eook]hcqjopne jcqhkoÏ7 1* kbd^qfs^p qlql*qlq^fp( ai mqa k oqfaepk ai pk`] ] oq] atpajok at_hq`k `a pk`] ] atpajok`klna`e_]`k6ÎJajdqiPjajdqiMÏ*Lknatailhk6ÎJajdqipne jcqhk jajdqimq]`n]`kÏ7 2* kbd^qfs^pqlql*m^o`f^fp(aimqapk`koqfaepkat_hq`k`a]laj]oqi]l]npa`klna`e) _]`k6ÎJajdqiP]hcqiMÏ*Lknatailhk6ÎJajdqipne jcqhk]hcqiamqeh]pan]hÏ7 3* kbd^qfs^pm^oqf*qlq^fp(aimqao qi]l]npa`koqfaepkat_hq`]`]atpajok`klna) `e_]`k6Î=hcqiPjkjajdqiMÏ*Lknatailhk6Î=hcqi]becqn]amqeh]pan]hjkja) jdqipne jcqhkÏ7 4* kbd^qfs^pm^oqf*m^o`f^fp(aimqaqi]l]npa`]atpajok`koqfaepkat_hq`]`aqi] l]npa`]atpajok`klna`e_]`k6Î=hcqjoPjkok]hcqjoMÏ*Lknatailhk6Î=hcqipne j) cqhkjk]hcqi]becqn]amqeh]pan]hÏ* =o lnklkoe ao lk`ane]i _kjranpan)oa oeilhaoiajpa qi]o j]o kqpn]o a( bej]hiajpa( qi]lnklkoekoane]]laj]oqi]bnr^ lajpnaqioqfaepkaqilna`e_]`k*?kieook(k
-1,
=h ce_]oei^ he_]x#!0É45,/ßx
n]_ek_jekfjk_kjoeope]aib]vanqi]jkkajpn]naikqpn]$]]jpec]ejanj_e]]neopkp) he_]%(i]oaioan_]l]v`aoq^opepqenkqpn]amqer]hajpa(ailnklkoe ao`]`]o(`aoknpamqa lnklkoe aoqo]j`kl]h]rn]o_kikeljbj(^kfj^i(jloq^i(ap_*lk`ane]ioanpn]p]`]o_kik kon]_ek_jekoi]paipe_komqaqo]ioi^khko_kiku(vaw*Aop]r]]^anp]]lknp]l]n]mqa >kkhalnklqoaooak_h_qhkh ce_k* K_h_qhkh ce_kna]hevkq)oaai`q]oap]l]o`ebanajpao*J]lneiaen](_ki]ejpnk`qk `]ojk ao`a`i^ppbacrk l(i]jpara)oa]e`ae]`amqa]lnklkoek]ej_hqok`aqioq) faepkjqilna`e_]`k(kqiahdkn(]ej_hqok`apk`]kql]npa`]atpajok`koqfaepkaipk`] kql]npa`]atpajok`klna`e_]`k*J]oacqj`]ap]l](_ki]ejpnk`qk`]e`ae]`aobi^ l( l]ookq)oa`]_kj_alkej_hqoer])at_hqoer]`koqfaepka`klna`e_]`k`aamqer]hj_e]kq oq^opepqek`aqilknkqpnk* Çia`e`]mqa]bkni]hev]ka]i]pai]pev]k`]h ce_]oa`aoajrkhran]i(]jkk `alna`e_]`kna_a^aqqijkrkoajpe`kaqijkrkpn]p]iajpk*L]ookq]oanpn]p]`]_kik _h]ooa*Aop]qi_kjfqjpk`ak^fapkomqa(lkooqej`k]hckai_kiqi(Î_]iejd]iai_kj) bknie`]`aÏ*Qilna`e_]`kkmqalaniepanaqjen`apaniej]`kok^fapkoai_h]ooao6]_h]ooa `ko]vqeo(]_h]ooa`koaobne_ko(]_h]ooa`kooqh)]iane_]jko(]_h]ooa`kobahevao(]_h]ooa`ko ieoanraeo(]_h]ooa`koo he`ko(ap_* Qilna`e_]`keokh]`kÍ]vqh(bahev(o he`k(ieoanrah(ap_*Íjkran`]`aenkjaib]hok* Na_a^ap]hr]hkn]laj]o]l]npen`]ej_hqokkqat_hqok`koqfaepkjqi]_h]ooa*?ki]_h]ooa(k lna`e_]`koapknj]qi]nah]kajpna`q]or]neraeo(aaoo]nah]k_d]i])oabqjk* =h ce_]l]oo]]_kjopnqenqioei^kheoikmqalaniepa`abejen]obqj ao`klna`e_]`k( ejpnk`qvej`kjkrkomq]jpebe_]`knao_kikomq]eo]bqjk_]h_qh]`]*Aooa_h_qhk_kjope) pqe]idf`^alpmobaf`^alp* Lknatailhk(]lnklkoekpn]`e_ekj]hÎO _n]paodkiaiÏoanbkni]hev]`]_kikB$]%( kj`a C( ] bqjk( oecjebe_] ]Îmq]he`]`a `a oan dkiaiÏ a ^( ] r]nerah( `aoecj]ÎO _n]paoÏ* Pk`]re](]r]nerahlk`an`aoecj]nqiej`er`qkmq]hmqan(qioqfaepkej`apaniej]`k(a] lnklkoekoanao_nep]_kikB$t%*P]hlnklkoeklk`aoan]ooeimq]jpebe_]`]6 ]qjerano]hoanao_nep]_kik$t%B$t%(`araj`koanhe`]_kikÎl]n]pk`ku(C`auÏ7 ]l]npe_qh]nkqateopaj_e]hoanao_nep]_kik$t%B$t%(`araj`koanhe`]_kikÎateopaqi up]hmqaC`auÏ* Oa(aihqc]n`]ej_hqokpn]`e_ekj]h`klna`e_]`kjkoqfaepk(peraniko_h]ooao(]nah]k oanaop]^aha_e`]ajpnaÎahaiajpkÏaÎ_h]ooaÏ(kqajpna]oln lne]o_h]ooao(pknj]j`k]lnklk) oekiqepki]eo]^n]jcajpaa_kilhat]*Pkiaiko(lknatailhk(]lnklkoekÎKodkiajo okiknp]eoÏa]lnklkoekÎO _n]paoiknp]hÏ*L]n]_]h_qh)h]o(`araiko_kia]nlah]nah]) kajpna]_h]ooa`kodkiajoa]`koiknp]eo6 =$?h]ooa`kodkiajo% >$?h]ooa`koiknp]eo% = >$=_h]ooa`kodkiajoaop_kjpe`]j]_h]ooa`koiknp]eo*% t$O _n]pao% =$?h]ooa`kodkiajo% t;=$O _n]paolanpaj_a_h]ooa`kodkiajo*% @kj`a6 $t%$t;=%m$t;>%(aimqaÎmÏoecjebe_]fjmif`^* Haiko6ÎL]n]pk`ku(ulanpaj_a]>eilhe_]mqaulanpaj_a]?Ï* Lknp]jpk(ÎO _n]paoiknp]hÏ* Okoaeo]oklan] aomqalk`aioanna]hev]`]o_ki]o_h]ooao6
-1-
x5.)$!$%ßx=h ce_]
-*
ej_hqok`aqi]_h]ooaaikqpn]6= >7
.* naqjek`arne]o_h]ooao6@IJ7 /* ejpanoa_k`arne]o_h]ooao_kiahaiajpko_kiqjo6=>?7 0* ]`]_h]ooaqjerano]hmqa]^n]jcapk`kokoahaiajpkoa_qfkoi^khk^7 1* ]`]_h]ooar]ve](eopk(mqajk_kjpiahaiajpk]hcqia_qfkoi^khk@7 2* ]`]_h]ooa_kilhaiajp]n=Ñ`a=(bkni]`]lknpk`kokoahaiajpkomqajklanpaj_ai ]=* Koh ce_komqai]eo`aoajrkhran]i]lkooe^ehe`]`a`aqi]h ce_]`]o_h]ooao(`]obqj) aolnklkoe_ekj]eoa`k_h_qhk`kolna`e_]`kobkn]iBnaca(Sdepada]`(>anpn]j`Nqooahha Seppcajopaej* =h ce_]`kolna`e_]`kobkeajnemqa_e`]aik`ebe_]`]_ki]idf`^a^pobi^ bp(eje_e]`] jko_qhkTETlahkobeh okbkoejchaoaoIknc]j$mqap]i^ian]i]paipe_k%aLaen_a* = h ce_] `]o nah] ao k_ql])oa( _kik k jkia ej`e_]( `]o nah] ao ajpna _kjfqjpko `a k^fapko6i]ekn`kmqa(iajkn`kmqa(lanpk`a(hkjca`a(i]eorahdkmqa(i]eojkrkmqa(l]e `a(ia`a(enik`a(_]qo]`a(bej]he`]`a`a(oaiahd]jpa](`ebanajpa`a(ap_* =onah] aolk`ai]^n]jcan`keokqi]eok^fapko(oaj`k^ejne]o(panjne]o(mq]panj) ne]o(ap_*(`alaj`aj`k`kjiank`ak^fapko]^n]jce`kolknah]*=nah]ki]eo_kjda_e`] ]^ejne](atlnaoo]j]b niqh]tNu(mqaoecjebe_]6dqi]nah]kajpnauav* =onah] aolkooqailnklnea`]`ao_]h_qhraeo*P]eolnklnea`]`aolaniepai`ebanaj_e]n kornekopelko`anah]k(_kiklknatailhk6 nah]kqo^kpfqfs^6`]`kou(vawa`]`]otNuauNv(dqi]nah]ktNv*Lknatailhk6u i]ekn`kmqav(vi]ekn`kmqaw(ui]ekn`kmqaw*Kq6 $tNu%*$uNv%m$tNv% nah]kklqo^kpfqfs^6`]`kou(vawa`]`]otNuauNv(jkoalk`apantNv(ai^kn]d]f] qi]nah]kajpnawau*Lknatailhk6La`nkl]e`aFkk(Fkkl]e`a=jpjek(i]o La`nkjkl]e`a=jpjek(lkeooaq]r7 nah]kfkqo^kpfqfs^6`]`kou(vawa`]`]otNuauNv(jklkoorah`apaniej]nmq]h oane]]nah]kajpnauaw*Lknatailhk6ui]ekn`kmqav(viajkn`kmqaw(i]ojk lk`aikoo]^anoaui]eknkqiajkn`kmqaw7 nah]k`apfjbqof^6tNukiaoikmqauNt*Lknatailhk6^ecq]h]_(_ecq]h]^*Kq6 $t%$u%$tNu%m$uNt% nah]k`a^ppfjbqof^6mq]j`koapaitNu(jkoalk`apanuNt*Lknatailhk6^i]ekn `kmqa_a(lknp]jpk(jkoalk`apan_i]eknmqa^*Kq6 [$t%[$u%$tNu%m$uNt% nah]k obcibufs^6 aop]^aha_a)oa ajpna qi] nah]k pn]joeper] a qi] nah]k oeipne_]* =ooei(lknatailhk(Îulk`aranvÏnabhater]jqiiqj`kkj`ad]f]aolahdko(kj`aÎv lk`aranuÏ* nah]kfoobcibufs^6aop]^aha_a)oaajpnanah] aoejpn]joeper]oa]ooeipne_]o7 nah]kfksbop^6qi]nah]kejrano]$P%]qi]kqpn]nah]k$O%(mq]j`kl]n]pk`koko k^fapkou(vaw(ranebe_])oatNu(oa(aokiajpaoa(dkqranuOt*k_]ok(lknatailhk(`] nah]kÎl]e`aÏaÎbehdk`aÏ* P]jpk]h ce_]`kolna`e_]`ko_kik]h ce_]`]onah] aoaopkoq^iape`]o]qi]h ce_] i]eo]ilh](mqa]`]olnklkoe aokq`k`i`rilmolmlpf`flk^i(lkeo]lnklkoekk_]i) lk`]h ce_]lnklne]iajpa`ep]*K_h_qhk`]olnklkoe ao_kjoeopaaiaop]^aha_ankolnk) _a`eiajpkolahkomq]eolk`aiko`apaniej]n]ran`]`akq]b]hoe`]`a`aqi]lnklkoek(
-1.
=h ce_]oei^ he_]x#!0É45,/ßx
`a]_kn`k_kioq]hec]k_kikqpn]kq_kikqpn]o(ajpaj`aj`klknran`]`a]r]he`]`a`] hec]kalknb]hoe`]`a]ejr]he`]`a`]hec]k*Kqoaf](_kikreiko]_ei](]h ce_]oak_ql] _ki]r]he`]`akq]ejr]he`]`a`]oejbanj_e]oa(lknp]jpk(ran`]`aab]hoe`]`aokl]n]ah] kos^ilobpa^pmolmlpf bpakos^ilobpa^pfkcbok`f^p* Ko_]okoi]eooeilhao`a_h_qhko`alnklkoe aonabanai)oa_kjfqjk$ÎLa`nk_]jp] bLa`nk`]j]Ï%(jac]k$ÎLa`nk_]jp]*La`nkkl_]jp]Ï%(`eofqjk$ÎLa`nk_]jp]lrLa`nk `]j]Ï%aeilhe_]k$ÎPbLa`nk_]jp](bkqlLa`nk`]j]Ï%* K_h_qhk_kjoeopaai]pne^qenks^iloÎran`]`aÏ]qi]`]olnklkoe ao(kr]hknÎb]hoe) `]`aÏkqpn]aejbanenks^iloa^ifd^ lajpnaah]o*L]n]mqaoalan_a^]mqak_kjpa`k`]o lnklkoe ao ennahar]jpa( o ejpanaoo]j`k oq] bkni]( raf]iko _kik ok oei^khev]`ko ko rneko_h_qhko`]ohec] aolnklkoe_ekj]eo6 _h_qhk`]_kjfqjkb$oi^khk`]_kjfqjk*% l m l*m r r r r b b b r b b b b _h_qhk`]jac]kkl$oi^khk`]jac]k[% l [l r b b r _h_qhk`]`eofqjklr$oi^khk`]`eofqjk^% l m l^m r r r r b r b r r b b b _h_qhk`]eilhe_]kfjmif`^nrb$oi^khk`]eilhe_]k% l m lm r r r r b b b r r b b r Qiatailhklk`an]fq`]n)jko]_kilnaaj`an_kikbqj_ekj]k_h_qhk*Oa`eooaniko6 OaLa`nk_a]najoa$m%kq_]p]nejajoa$n%(ajpk^n]oehaenk$o%*Kn](La`nkjk^n]oehaenk* Lknp]jpk(jk_a]najoajai_]p]nejajoa(panaiko6 $l^mn%*n[l^[m ?h_qhk`]^e)eilhe_]kkqamqer]hj_e]$oi^khk`]amqer]hj_e]j%6 l r r b b
m r b r b
ljm r b b r
Aooao_h_qhko_kjopepqai]oi]pnevao(mqaok_kikp]^ah]omqa]lnaoajp]ipk`]o]o oepq] aolkooraeomqa_]`]hek]ook_e]]qil]n`alnklkoe aoahaiajp]naoman*
-1/
x5.)$!$%ßx=h ce_] GLOSSfRIO
15%34¬%3
#!0É45,/ß Kj]o_eiajpk`]hce_] -*K mqa oecjeÚ_]`k jk qok _kpe`e]jk mqa b]vaiko `]ol]h]rn]ohce_]ahce_k;Mqajk aoaopklnao) oqlkop]ojaooaqok; .*Mq]hbkek_kjÛepkajpna]ÚhkokÚ]`aDan_hepka]`a L]nije`ao; /*Lknmqako_kjÛepkoajpna]oÚhkokÚ]o`aDan_hepka `aL]nije`aooqo_ep]n]ik]l]na_eiajpk`]h ce_]; 0*Kmqa]`e]hpe_]lh]p je_]; 1*Kmqa]]j]hpe_]kqh ce_]]neopkphe_]; 2*Mq]eo]o`ebanaj]oajpna]`e]hpe_]lh]p je_]a]j]) hpe_]kqh ce_]]neopkphe_];
-/* ?kik]olnklkoe aooa_h]ooeÚ_]i`klkjpk`areop] `]nah]k; -0* Atlhemqakmqaokfqvk]lk`pe_k(delkppe_ka`eo) fqjperk* -1* Lknmqakn]_ek_jekqi]ejbanj_e]ia`e]p]; -2* Mqaqioehkceoik; -3* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`koehkceoik; -4*?kik_kjopepq`kqioehkceoik; -5*Mqaokpaniki]ekn(iajknai`ek;Mq]h]bqj) k`kpaniki`ek; .,* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eonacn]o`koehkceoikran`]`aenk; .-*Lknmqakoehkceoik`a_h]n]qi]ejanj_e]; ..*=mqanacn]o`aejbanj_e]koehkceoik`arak^a`a_an; ./*MqaokÚcqn]oaik`ko`koehkceoik;
#!0É45,/ß Ahaiajpko`ahce_] -*Lknmqa]h ce_]jkajpn]j]_h]ooeÚ_]k]neopkphe) _]`]o_ej_e]o; .*Jk lajo]iajpk ]neopkphe_k( mq]eo ]o lnej_el]eo _]) n]_panope_]o`]h ce_];
.0*Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaoehkceoik`e]hpe_ka_eajpÚ_k; Lknmqakoehkceoik`e]hpe_kln lnek`]nap ne_]; .1* Mq]eo]onacn]o`koehkceoik_eajpÚ_k; .2* Atlhemqakmqaokkopnopelko`alnaieoo]o`koehk) ceoik_eajpÚ_k* .3* @a]_kn`k_ki=neop pahao(_kikqi]_ej_e]r]e`k cjank oaol_eaoa`aop]o]koej`er`qko;
/*Mq]hkk^fapk`]h ce_];
.4* Mq]eo]oatecj_e]obaep]ol]n]mqaqioehkceoik_eaj) pÚ_k_dacqa]k_kj_aepkran`]`aenk`aqi]_keo];
0*Mqaokamq]eook]o_]packne]o;
.5*=lnklkoekoacqejparan`]`aen]kqb]ho];
1*Mq]eook]o`q]olnklnea`]`ao`]o_]packne]oh ce) _]o;Atlhemqa)]o*
atpajok`kpanikÎ]opnkÏi]ekn`kmqa]`kpan) = ikÎlh]jap]Pann]Ï*
2*Mq]h]_h]ooeÚ_]k`]o_]packne]ooacqj`k]atpaj) oka]_kilnaajok;
Atlhemqalknmq*
3*Kmqaqi]lnklkoek;Mq]eookoaqoahaiajpko;
4*Kmqaok]ran`]`aa]b]hoe`]`ah ce_]o`aqi]lnk) lkoek;
_kilnaajok`kpanikÎ^keÏiajkn`kmqa]`k = panikÎ]jei]hÏ*
Atlhemqalknmq*
5*Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnalnklkoekateopaj_e]halnk) lkoeklna`e_]per]; -,*?kik]olnklkoe aooa_h]ooeÚ_]i`klkjpk`areop] `]mq]he`]`a; --*?kik]olnklkoe aooa_h]ooeÚ_]i`klkjpk`areop] `]mq]jpe`]`a; -.*?kik]olnklkoe aooa_h]ooeÚ_]i`klkjpk`areop] `]ik`]he`]`a;
/,*=lnklkoekoacqejparan`]`aen]kqb]ho];
/-*@ec]oadkqjk_kjpn]`ekajpna]ooacqejpaolnk) lkoe aoaatlhemqalknmq* ]%Pk`kokooanaodqi]jkookn]_ekj]eo* La`nkenn]_ekj]h* ^%Jajdqilh]jap]paihqvln lne]* Rjqoehqiej])oa]oeiaoik* _%Pk`]o]o_ej_e]o`aoaf]i_kjda_an]ran`]`a* =^ekhkce]k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk`kobaj ) iajkonah]_ekj]`ko re`]*
-10
GLOSSfRIO
#!0É45,/ß =hce_]oei^he_] -* Mq]hkk^faperk`]h ce_]oei^ he_]; .* Lknmqa]h ce_]]neopkphe_]jkan]lhaj]iajpabkn) i]h;
5* Mq]eo ko `keo pelko `a hejcq]cai oei^ he_]; Mq]eo okoq]o`ebanaj]o; -,* Lknmqa]h ce_]qi]iap]hejcq]cai; --*Mq]eo]olnej_el]eopaoao`aSeppcajopaej; -.*?kikoa`eopejcqairan`]`aar]he`]`aejbanaj_e]h;
/* Lknmqa]h ce_]_kjpailknja]pknjkq)oalhaj]iaj) pabkni]h;
-/*@]hcqjopelko`alnklkoe aoaimqakoqfaepkak
0* Kmqa]h ce_]bkni]h`ao_nara;
-0*Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna]ejanj_e]]neopkphe_]ak_h)
1* Lknmqa(]kl]oo]n`]_kj_alkejpqeper] _kjopnqpe) r](]i]paipe_]oa]lnkteikq`]h ce_];Mqaoecje) Ú_]`evanmqa]i]paipe_]qi]hejcq]caioei^ ) he_]lanbaep];
-1*Har]j`kai_kjoe`an]kklna`e_]`k_kik_h]ooaa
2* Mqabkekloe_khkceoikh ce_k; 3* Lkn mqa ] h ce_] jk oa _kjbqj`a _ki ] loe_khkce] jai_ki]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk; 4* Mqajraeo`ahejcq]cai]h ce_]`eopejcqa;
-11
lna`e_]`kaopkmq]jpeÚ_]`ko* _qhkh ce_k`alnklkoe ao; _kikbqjk(kmqa]h ce_]`kolna`e_]`ko; -2*Mqaklan] aolk`aioanna]hev]`]o_ki]o_h]ooao; -3*Kmqa]h ce_]`]onah] ao; -4*Mq]eo]olnklnea`]`ao_]h_qhraeo`]onah] ao; -5*Kmqa_h_qhklnklkoe_ekj]h;
5NIDADEß
K_kjda_eiajpk ?]lpqhk-
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpk
?]lpqhk.
=lan_alk
?]lpqhk/
=ei]cej]k
?]lpqhk0
=hejcq]cai
?]lpqhk1
Klajo]iajpk
?]lpqhk2
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;
?anp]ravqicnack`eooa6ÎKlajo]iajpk kl]ooaek`]]hi]Ï*?kieookmqeo `evanmqaklajo]iajpk ]i]jaen]_kikjkookaol nepkl]na_ao]en`a`ajpnk `aoeiaoikalan_knnankiqj`kl]n]_kjda_ )hk*=ooei_kikjkl]ooaekhar]) ikojkook_knlk]pk`]l]npa(jklajo]iajpkhar]ikojkoo]]hi]]pk`]l]npa ai]eohkjca`kmqak_knlk(lkeo]]hi]jkaj_kjpn]k^op_qhkob oe_kol]n] oaq_]iejd]n* Klajo]iajpk aoo]_qneko]]pere`]`alkniaek`]mq]ho] iko`ajoiaoiko oai o]eniko `a jkook ejpanekn* Lkn eook( kqpnk Úhokbk ao_naraq mqa lajo]n ] i]jaen]lah]mq]ho]en`aoeaajpn]naioeokqi]oaiaoi]_keo]*?kikqi rkkoaio]en`khqc]n*
Atlane j_e]ona]hev]`]oj]o`q]o hpei]o`_]`]o`ko_qhkTETlknApeajja)FqhaoI]nau(qpehev]j`k]bkpk) cn]Ú]_kikejopnqiajpk`aejraopec]k`kikreiajpk`ko_knlko*
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
#APqTULOß =lnak_ql]k_kik _kjda_eiajpk K_kjda_eiajpkakolneiaenkobehokbko
M
3ERßAßPALAVRAßSER ßEMßPOR TUGUoS ßTRADUZßAßPALAVRAßß LATINAßESSEßEßAßEXPRESSjOßß GREGAßTgßvNTAß!ßPALAVRAßß LATINAßESSEßmßOßINFINITIVOßß DEßUMßVERBO ßOßVERBOßSERßß !ßEXPRESSjOßGREGAßTgßß vNTAßQUERßDIZERß±ASßCOISASßß EXISTENTES ßOSßENTES ßOSßß SERES²ß.OßSINGULAR ßß TgßvNTAßSEßDIZßTwßvN ßß CUJAßTRADUljOßmß±Oß3ER²
-ICHAELß.ICHOLSON#ORBISß ,ATINSTOCK
q]j`kaopq`]ikokj]o_eiajpk`]behkokbe]j]Cn_e](reikomqakolneiaenkobeh ) okbkoÍkoln)ok_npe_koÍ`a`e_]r]i)oa]qi_kjfqjpk`aej`]c] aolnej_el]eo6 ÎLknmqaa_kik]o_keo]oateopai;Ï(ÎKmqakiqj`k;Ï(ÎMq]h]knecai`]j]pqnav] amq]eo]o_]qo]o`aoq]pn]jobkni]k;Ï*Aoo]oej`]c] ao_khk_]r]ijk_ajpnk]lancqjp]6 ÎKmqapl]o_keo]o;Ï*Lkq_k]lkq_kaoo]lancqjp]l]ookq]oan]ooeibkniqh]`]6ÎKmqa kPbo;Ï* Kolneiaenkobeh okbkok_ql]r]i)oa_ki]knecaia]kn`ai`kiqj`k(khpjlp(a ] behkokbe] j]o_ajpa an] qi] `lpjlildf^* Lkq_k ] lkq_k( l]ookq)oa ] ej`]c]n k mqa an] k ln lnekhpjlp(mq]han]klnej_lekapanjkmqakn`aj]r]pk`]o]o_keo]oamqalani]ja_e] eiqprahok^]iqhpelhe_e`]`aapn]jobkni]k`ah]o*Aooalnej_lekan]_kj_a^e`k_kikk bqj`keilana_rahlnaoajpaaipk`]o]o_keo]o(b]vaj`k)]oateopenp]eo_kikok*Aooabqj`k lnaoajpaaipk`]o]o_keo]okOan*=ooei(l]ookq)oa]lancqjp]nmq]han]akmqaan]lPbo( qk(oq^f]_ajpa]pk`kokooanao*?kieook(]behkokbe]j]o_ajpapknjkq)oakjpkhkce](eopk( _kjda_eiajpkkqo]^anok^nalPbo* Lknaooaiaoikikperk(]hcqjoaopq`ekoko_kjoe`an]imqakolneiaenkobeh okbkojk pejd]iqi]lnak_ql]klnej_el]h_kik_kjda_eiajpk_kik_kjda_eiajpk(eopk(jk ej`]c]r]ioalk`aikokqjk_kjda_ankOan(i]ol]npe]i`]lnaooqlkoek`amqaklk) `aiko_kjda_an(lkeo]ran`]`a(oaj`k^iqebf^(eopk(lnaoaj]ai]jebaop]k`]o_keo]o l]n] ko jkooko oajpe`ko a l]n] k jkook lajo]iajpk( oecjebe_] mqa k Oan aop i]jebaopk a lnaoajpal]n]j oa(lknp]jpk(j oklk`aiko_kjda_an* Pk`]re](]klejek`amqakolneiaenkobeh okbkojkoalnak_ql]r]i_kijkoo]_]l]_e) `]`aalkooe^ehe`]`a`a_kjda_eiajpkjkat]p]*L]n]p]jpk(^]op]har]nikoai_kjp]kb]pk `a]beni]naimqa]na]he`]`a$kOan(]j]pqnav]%n]_ekj]hamqa]lk`aiko_kjda_anlknmqa p]i^iokikon]_ekj]eo7jkoo]n]vkl]npa`]n]_ekj]he`]`a`kiqj`k(`ah]l]npe_el]j`k*
Dan_hepk(L]ni je`aoa@ai_nepk =hcqjoatailhkoej`e_]i]ateopj_e]`]lnak_ql]k`kolneiaenkobeh okbko_kik _kjda_eiajpka(]mqe(pki]naikopno6Dan_hepk`abaok(L]nije`ao`aAhae]a@ai _nepk `a=^`an]* Dan_hepk`abaok_kjoe`an]r]]j]pqnav]$kiqj`k(]na]he`]`a%qiÎbhqtklanlpqkÏ( kao_k]iajpk_kjpejqk`kooanaoaiiq`]j]lanlpq]*@eve]6ÎJklk`aiko^]jd]n)jko `q]oravaojkiaoiknek(lknmqa]ocq]ojqj_]ok]oiaoi]oaj ojqj_]okikokoiao) ikoÏ*?kil]n]r]kiqj`k_d]i]`aqi]rah]mqamqaei]oai_aoo]n(pn]jobkni]j`k ]_an]aibkck(kbkckaibqi]]a]bqi]]ai]n*K`e]oapknj]jkepa(krankoapknj] kqpkjk(kjkrkbe_]rahdk(kmqajpaaobne](kie`koa_](pq`koapn]jobkni]jkoaq_kjpnnek* Kiqj`kqilnk_aookej_aoo]jpa`apn]jobkni]kaimqa_]`]oanqiikreiajpkai `enak]koaq_kjpnnek* =na]he`]`a(l]n]Dan_hepk(]d]nikje]`ko_kjpnneko(mqajk_aoo]i`aoapn]jobkn) i]nqjojkokqpnko*Oapq`kjk_aoo]`aoapn]jobkni]nlanajaiajpa(_kikatlhe_]nmqa
$EMvCRITOßDEß!BDERAßß Cß߯ßCßßA#
-14
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
3TEFANß+RIEGEL'LOWß)MAGES)MAGEPLUS
fTOMOßAßPALAVRAßfTOMOß TEMßORIGEMßGREGAßEßSIG NIFICAß±OßQUEßNjOßPODEßSERß CORTADOßOUßDIVIDIDO² ßISTOß m ßAßMENORßPARTqCULAßINDI VISqVELßDEßTODASßASßCOISAS
Haepqn]`a hejcq]cai^n]eha l]n]`abe_eajpao reoq]eo*
-15
jkoo]lan_alkjkokbana]]o_keo]o_kikoabkooaiaopraeo(`qn]`kqn]oalani]jajpao; ?kiaoo]lancqjp]kbeh okbkej`e_]r]]`ebanaj]ajpnak_kjda_eiajpkmqajkookooajpe) `kojkokbana_aiak_kjda_eiajpkmqajkooklajo]iajpk]h_]j](lkeojkookooajpe`ko jkokbana_ai]ei]cai`]aop]^ehe`]`aajkooklajo]iajpk]h_]j]]ran`]`a_kikiq) `]j]_kjpjq]* L]nije`ao`aAhae]_khk_]r])oaj]lkoekklkop]`aDan_hepk*@eve]mqao lk`aiko lajo]nok^na]mqehkmqalani]ja_aoailnae`jpe_k]oeiaoik(eopk(mqaklajo]iajpk jklk`alajo]nok^na_keo]omqaokajkok(mqakn]ok`aqiik`kakn]ok`akqpnk( mqaok_kjpnne]o]oeiaoi]oa_kjpn]`ep ne]o* ?kjda_an]h_]j]nke`jpe_k(eiqprah*Jkookooajpe`kojkokbana_ai]ei]cai`a qiiqj`kaiej_aoo]jpaiq`]j](jqibhqtklanlpqk(kj`aj]`]lani]ja_ae`jpe_k ]oeiaoik(kj`apq`koapknj]k_kjpnnek`aoeiaoik6k`e]ren]jkepa(kejranjkren]lne) i]ran](k`k_aoapknj]]i]nck(klamqajkren]cn]j`a(kcn]j`a`eiejqe(k`k_a]i]nc](k mqajpaaobne](kbnekoa]mqa_a(khmqe`kren]r]lknkqren]o he`k* ?kiklajo]nkmqaajk]kiaoikpailk;?kiklajo]nkejoprah;?kiklajo]n kmqaoapknj]klkopka_kjpnnek]oeiaoik;Jklkoorah(`eve]L]nije`ao*Lajo]n ]lnaaj`anqioanaioq]e`ajpe`]`alnkbqj`]alani]jajpa*?kieook(]beni]r]kiaoikmqa Dan_hepkÍlan_a^analajo]nok`ebanajpaoÍ(i]ok`eve]jkoajpe`kklkopk]k`aDan_he) pk(eopk(lan_a^aikoiq`]j]oeilajoraeoa`araikolajo]ne`ajpe`]`aoeiqpraeo* @ai _nepk`a=^`an]`aoajrkhraqqi]pakne]ok^nakOankqok^na]j]pqnav]_kjda) _e`]_kikjkia`a]pkieoik6]na]he`]`a_kjopepq`]lknpkiko*Kooanaooqncailkn _kilkoek`kopkiko(pn]jobkni]i)oalknjkrko]nn]jfko`kopkikoaiknnailknoa) l]n]k`kopkiko* Ko pkiko( l]n] @ai _nepk( lkooqai bkni]o a _kjoeopj_e]o `ebanajpao $na`kj) `ko( pne]jcqh]nao( heoko( `qnko( ikhao( nqck) oko(lkjpe]cq`ko(ap_*%aaoo]o`ebanaj]oako `ebanajpaoik`ko`a_ki^ej]kajpnaahao lnk`qvai ] r]nea`]`a `a oanao( oq]o iq) `]j]o a `ao]l]ne ao* Lkn iaek `a jkooko
ncko`kooajpe`ko(lan_a^aikokmqajpaa kbnek(k`k_aak]i]nck(koa_kakie`k( kcn]j`aaklamqajk(k`qnkakikha(o]) ^knao( k`knao( patpqn]o( k ]cn]`rah a k `a) o]cn]`rah( oajpeiko ln]van a `kn( lknmqa lan_a^aikokoabaepko`]o_ki^ej] ao`ko pkiko mqa( ai oe iaoiko( jk lkooqai p]eo mq]he`]`ao $eopk ( jk ok `k_ao jai ]i]ncko(jai]vqeojairan`ao(jaicn]j) `aojailamqajko(lkeook]oiajknaol]n) p_qh]oi]pane]eoateopajpao%* Okiajpaklajo]iajpklk`a_kjda_ankopkiko(mqaokejreoraeol]n]jkoo]lan_al) koajokne]h*@aoo]i]jaen](@ai _nepk_kj_kn`]r]_kiDan_hepkaL]nije`aoaimqad qi]`ebanaj]ajpnakmqa_kjda_aikolkniaek`ajkoo]lan_alkakmqa_kjda_aiko ]laj]olahklajo]iajpk7lkni(`erano]iajpa`kokqpnko`keobeh okbko(jk_kjoe`an]r]] lan_alkehqo ne](i]o]laj]oqiabaepk`]na]he`]`aok^naj o*K_kjda_eiajpkoajokne]h kqoajorahpkran`]`aenkmq]jpk]mqehkmqaklajo]iajpklqnk]h_]j](ai^kn]`aqi] ran`]`a`ebanajpaaiajkolnkbqj`]kqiajkonahar]jpa`kmqa]mqah]]h_]j]`]lahklqnk lajo]iajpk* Aooaopnoatailhkojkoikopn]imqa(`ao`akooaqo_kiako(]behkokbe]lnak_qlkq)oa _kiklnk^hai]`k_kjda_eiajpk(lkeooailnaaopararkhp]`]l]n]]mqaopk`kran`]`aenk* @ao`akej_ek(kobeh okbkooa`an]i_kjp]`amqajkooklajo]iajpkl]na_aoacqen_anp]o
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
haeokqnacn]ol]n]_kjda_an]o_keo]oamqadqi]`ebanaj]ajpnalan_a^analajo]n*Lajo]) iko_ki^]oajkmqalan_a^aikokqlajo]ikojac]j`kkmqalan_a^aiko;Klajo]iaj) pk_kjpejq](jac]kq_knneca]lan_alk;Kik`k_kikkooanaojko]l]na_aikik`k _kikkooanaona]hiajpaok;
O_n]paoakookbeop]o Lnak_ql] ao_kikaoo]ohar]n]i(j]Cn_e]_hooe_](]`q]o]pepq`aobehko be_]o6]`ko okbeop]oa]`aO _n]paoÍ_kiahao(kolnk^hai]o`k_kjda_eiajpkpknj]n]i)oa_ajpn]eo* @e]jpa`]lhqn]he`]`aa`ko]jp]ckjeoiko`]obehkokbe]o]jpaneknao(kq`ko_kjbhepkoajpna ]orne]okjpkhkce]o(kookbeop]o_kj_hqn]imqajklk`aiko`lkeb`bokOan(lkeo(oalq`o) oaiko(lajo]n]ikopk`ko`]iaoi]i]jaen]ad]rane]qi]je_]behkokbe](qi]ravmqa] ran`]`aqjerano]ha]iaoi]l]n]pk`kokodqi]jko*?kjoamqajpaiajpa(o lk`aikopan lmfkfbppr_gbqfs^pok^na]na]he`]`a* Lkn eook( l]n] oa nah]_ekj]nai _ki k iqj`k a _ki ko kqpnko dqi]jko( ko dkiajo `arair]han)oa`aqiejopnqiajpkÍ]hejcq]caiÍl]n]lanoq]`enkokqpnko`aoq]oln ) lne]oe`ae]oakleje ao*=ran`]`aqi]mqaopk`aklejeka`alanoq]ok(a]hejcq]cai i]eoeilknp]jpa`kmqa]lan_alkaklajo]iajpk* Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](O _n]pao(`eop]j_e]j`k)oa`kolneiaenkobeh okbkoÍmqaoak_ql]r]i ai_kjda_an]j]pqnav]Í(lnklqjd]_kia]nlahkkn_qhk`a@ahbko(eopk(lahkÎ_kjda_a)pa ]peiaoikÏ(a(klkj`k)oa]kookbeop]o(]beni]r]mqa]ran`]`alk`aoan_kjda_e`]`ao`amqa _kilnaaj`]ikomqalna_eo]iko_kia]n]b]op]j`k]oehqo ao`kooajpe`ko(]oeilkoe ao `]ol]h]rn]oa]iqhpelhe_e`]`a`]okleje ao*Lkooqikoqi]]hi]n]_ekj]hamqajko]ooacq) n]mqalk`aiko]h_]j]n]ran`]`aamqa]]h_]j]iko]laj]olahklajo]iajpk(eopk(lah] ]pere`]`a`ajkoo]n]vk*?kik]oe`ae]ookej]p]oaijkoo]]hi]n]_ekj]h(_kjda_an)oa]oe iaoikb]vankpn]^]hdkl]n]kl]npkkqj]o_eiajpk`]oe`ae]oa]qtehe]nko`ai]eo]na]hev]n aooal]npk* Ko ncko`kooajpe`ko(`evO _n]pao(jko`kokiajpa]o]l]nj_e]o`]o_keo]oa]ol]h]) rn]o(ian]okleje aook^naah]o*=i]n_]`]]l]nj_e]a`]klejekoq]r]ne]^ehe`]`a6r]ne] `alaook]l]n]laook]ar]ne]jqiiaoikej`er`qk*I]ojko r]ne]6p]i^ioa_kjpn]) `ev*?kjda_an_kia]n]at]iej]n]o_kjpn]`e ao`]o]l]nj_e]oa`]okleje aol]n]lk`an ]^]j`kj)h]oal]oo]n`]]l]nj_e]aooj_e](`]klejek]k_kj_aepk*Kat]ia`]okleje ao ]mqahalnk_a`eiajpkmqaO _n]pao_d]i]r]`afolkf^(_kikmq]hkbeh okbk_kjoacqe]mqa oaqoejpanhk_qpknaona_kjda_aooaimqajko]^e]ikmqaei]cej]r]io]^an7kl]npk`]oe`ae]o an]]j^frqf`^(_ki]mq]h(cn]]o]lancqjp]o]`amq]`]obaep]olahkbeh okbk(kejpanhk_qpkn aj_kjpn]r]aioq]]hi]n]_ekj]h]e`ae]ran`]`aen]kq]aooj_e]`]_keo]lnk_qn]`]*
PARTOßEMßGREGO ßPARTOßSEß DIZßMAIoUTICA
Lh]pka=neoppahao O _n]paobav]behkokbe]rkhp]n)oal]n]jkoo]_]l]_e`]`a`a_kjda_anaej`]c]nmq]eo]o _]qo]o`]oehqo ao(`koannko(`kb]hoka`]iajpen]*Lh]pka=neop pahaodan`]n]i`aO _n]pao klnk_a`eiajpkbehko be_k`a]^kn`]nqi]mqaopk_kia]j`klah]`eo_qookalahk`a^]pa `]okleje ao_kjpnne]ook^naah]*=hi`eook(l]oo]n]i]`abejen]obkni]o`a_kjda_ana]o `ebanaj]oajpnak_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenka]ehqok(ejpnk`qvej`kj]behkokbe]]e`ae]`a mqaateopai`ebanajpaoi]jaen]o`a_kjda_ankqcn]qo`a_kjda_eiajpk* Lh]pk`eopejcqamq]pnkbkni]okqcn]qo`a_kjda_eiajpk(mqark`kcn]qejbanekn]k oqlanekn6`obk ^(lmfkfl(o^`fl`kflafkqrf lfkqbib`qr^i*Ko`keolneiaenkocn]qobkni]ik mqaaha_d]i]`a`lkeb`fjbkqlpbkpsbi(ajmq]jpkko`keohpeikobkni]ik`lkeb`fjbkql fkqbifdsbi* =_naj]jkoo]_kjbe]j]jk_kjda_eiajpkoajokne]h6_naikomqa]o_keo]ookp]eo _kik]olan_a^aikoaijkoo]ooajo] ao*=klejekjkoo]]_aep]k`kmqajkoajoej]) n]iok^na]o_keo]okqkmqa`ah]olajo]iko_kjbkniajkoo]ooajo] aoahai^n]j]o*Aooao `keolneiaenkocn]qo`a_kjda_eiajpkjkokbana_ai]laj]o]]l]nj_e]`]o_keo]okqoq]o
-2,
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
IDEIAßPARAß0LATjO ßASß IDEIASßSjOßAßREALIDADEß VERDADEIRAßEßCONHECo LASß mßTERßCONHECIMENTOßVER DADEIRO
ei]cajo$ok]ooki^n]o`]o_keo]oran`]`aen]o%a_knnaolkj`aioepq]k`kolneoekjae) nko`]_]ranj]*Lknoanaiehqo neko(aooao`keocn]qo`araioan]b]op]`kolah]olaook]omqa ^qo_]ik_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk(lkeoaopa`evnaolaepkobppk`f^p`]o_keo]o7lknp]jpk( okiajpa ko `keo hpeiko cn]qo `arai oan _kjoe`an]`ko rhe`ko* K n]_ek_jek Í mqa( l]n] Lh]pk(oana]hev]`ai]jaen]lanbaep]j]i]paipe_]Ípnaej]aatan_ep]jkooklajo]iajpk( lqnebe_])k`]ooajo] aoakleje aoaklnal]n]l]n]]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h(mqa_kjda_a]o aooj_e]o`]o_keo]okqkmqaLh]pk`ajkiej]_ki]l]h]rn]fabf^* =folkf^a]j^frqf`^ok_npe_]ookpn]jobkni]`]olknLh]pkjqilnk_a`eiajpk`a) jkiej]`klknaha`a`e]h pe_](mqa_kjoeopaaipn]^]hd]natlkj`kaat]iej]j`kpaoao_kj) pnne]ook^naqiiaoik]ooqjpkkqok^naqi]iaoi]_keo](`ai]jaen]]`ao_k^nenmq]h `]opaoaob]ho]a`araoan]^]j`kj]`]amq]hran`]`aen]a`araoan_kjoanr]`]*=bej]he`]) `a`klan_qnok`e]hpe_kkq`katan__ek`e]hpe_klnklkn_ekj]n(]koaqpniejk(]ejpqek ejpaha_pq]h`aqi]aooj_e]kqe`ae]* =neop pahao`eopejcqaoapabkni]okqcn]qo`a_kjda_eiajpk6pbkp^ l(mbo`bm l(fj^* dfk^ l(jbjof^(ifkdr^dbj(o^`fl`kflafkqrf l*Ajmq]jpkLh]pk_kj_a^e]k_kjda_e) iajpk_kik]^]j`kjk`aqicn]qejbaneknlknqioqlanekn(l]n]=neop pahao(jkook_kjda) _eiajpk r]e oaj`k bkni]`k a ajnemqa_e`k lkn ]_qiqh]k `]o ejbkni] ao pn]ve`]o lkn pk`kokocn]qo(`aik`kmqa(aihqc]n`aqi]nqlpqn]ajpnak_kjda_eiajpkoajorahak ejpaha_pq]h( d _kjpejqe`]`a ajpna ahao* =ooei( ]o ejbkni] ao pn]ve`]o lah]o oajo] ao oa knc]jev]ialaniepai]lan_alk*=olan_al aooaknc]jev]ialaniepai]ei]cej]k* Fqjp]o(lan_alkaei]cej]k_kj`qvaiiai ne](hejcq]caia]kn]_ek_jek* =neop pahao_kj_a^a(lkni(qi]oal]n]kajpnakooaeolneiaenkocn]qoakhpeik(] ejpqekejpaha_pq]h(mqaqi]pk`klajo]iajpklqnkajk`alaj`a`kocn]qo]jpaneknao* Aoo]oal]n]k(lkni(jkoecjebe_]mqakokqpnkocn]qokbana]i_kjda_eiajpkoehqo neko kqb]hokoaoeimqakbana_aipelko`a_kjda_eiajpko`ebanajpao(mqark`aqicn]qiajkn ]qicn]qi]ekn`aran`]`a* Ai _]`] qi `ahao paiko ]_aook ] qi ]ola_pk `k Oan kq `] na]he`]`a a( j] ejpqek ejpaha_pq]h(paikok_kjda_eiajpk`kolnej_lekoqjerano]eoaja_aooneko`klajo]iajpk $e`ajpe`]`a(jk_kjpn]`ek(pan_aenkat_hq`k%a`kolneiaenkolnej_lekoa`]olneiaen]o _]qo]o`]na]he`]`akq`kOan*=`ebanaj]ajpnakooaeolneiaenkocn]qoakhpeik`a_knna `]`ebanaj]`kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk(eopk(kooaeolneiaenkocn]qo_kjda_aik^fapko mqaoakbana_ai]j oj]oajo]k(j]ei]cej]k(jkn]_ek_jek(ajmq]jpkkopeikhe`] _kilnej_lekoa_]qo]olneiaen]o(eopk(_kikmqao lk`aoan]h_]j]`klahklajo]iajpk lqnk*Kqoaf](jkokqpnkocn]qo(k_kjda_eiajpkk^pe`klknej`qkkqlkn`a`qk(lkn `aikjopn] aoalnkr]o(i]ojkhpeikcn]q_kjda_aikokmqaej`aikjopnrah$lnej_) leko%lknmqa_kj`ek`apk`]o]o`aikjopn] aoan]_ek_jeko*
Lnej_lekocan]eo ?ki ko beh okbko cnacko( aop]^aha_an]i)oa ]hcqjo lnej_leko can]eo `k _kjda_eiajpk ran`]`aenk6 ]`apaniej]k`]obkjpaoabkni]o`k_kjda_eiajpk6oajo]k(lan_alk(ei]cej]) k(iai ne](hejcq]cai(n]_ek_jekaejpqekejpaha_pq]h7 ]`eopejkajpnak_kjda_eiajpkoajorahak_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]h7 kl]lah`]hejcq]caijk_kjda_eiajpk7 ]`ebanaj]ajpnaklejekao]^ankq_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk7 ]`ebanaj]ajpna]l]nj_e]aaooj_e]7 ]`abejek`kolnej_leko`klajo]iajpkran`]`aenk$e`ajpe`]`a(jk_kjpn]`ek(pan) _aenkat_hq`k%(`]bkni]`k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk$e`ae]o(_kj_aepkoafqvko%a`ko lnk_a`eiajpkol]n]]h_]j]nk_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk$ej`qk(`a`qk(ejpqek%7
-2-
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
k aop]^aha_eiajpk `a lnk_a`eiajpko _knnapko mqa kneajp]i ] n]vk j] ^qo_] `k _k) jda_eiajpk a ]ooacqn]i oq] _dac]`] ] _kjda_eiajpko ran`]`aenko $ai Lh]pk( aooa lnk_a`eiajpk]`e]hpe_](ai=neop pahao(]h ce_]kqkmqaaha_d]i]`a]j]hpe_]%7 ]`eopejk`ko_]ilko`k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenkoacqj`kkok^fapko_kjda_e`ko ai_]`]qi`ahao(`eopejkmqabkeoeopai]pev]`]lkn=neop pahaoaipnon]iko6qblo* qf`l$nabanajpa]kooanaomqa]laj]olk`aiko_kjpailh]nkqk^oanr]n(oai]cenok^na ahao kq jahao ejpanbanen%7 moqf`l $nabanajpa o ] ao dqi]j]o6 pe_]( lkhpe_] a a_kjk) ie]%7aq`kf`l$nabanajpab]^ne_]k`aejopnqiajpkoa`ak^fapkoa]kpn]^]hdkdqi]) jk(kmq]hlk`aejpanbanenjk_qnok`]j]pqnav]Í_kik]]cne_qhpqn]a]ia`e_ej]Í(a b]^ne_]nejopnqiajpkokq]npab]pkoÍ_kikko]npao]j]pko(]]nmqepapqn](]ao_qhpqn](] lkaoe](]nap ne_](ap_*%*
Kobehokbkoik`anjkoak j]o_eiajpk`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk
M
q]j`koa`evmqa]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpkpknjkq)oaqi]`eo_elhej]aola_be_]`] behkokbe]okiajpa_kikobeh okbkoik`anjko$]l]npen`ko_qhkTREE%(jkoalna) paj`a`evanmqa]jpao`ahaoklnk^hai]`k_kjda_eiajpkjkd]re]k_ql]`kkqpnko beh okbko(aoeimqa(l]n]koik`anjko(]mqaopk`k_kjda_eiajpkbke_kjoe`an]`]]jpanekn `]kjpkhkce]alna_kj`ekkqln)namqeoepkl]n]]behkokbe]a]o_ej_e]o* Lknmqaaoo]iq`]j]`alanola_per]`kocnackol]n]koik`anjko;Lknmqa]behkokbe] ik`anj] lnaooql a ] lnaoaj] `k _neope]jeoik( k mq]h pnkqta mqaop ao a lnk^hai]o mqa ko]jpeckobeh okbko`ao_kjda_e]i*=lanola_per]_neopejpnk`qveq]hcqi]o`eopej aomqa nkilan]i_ki]e`ae]cnac]`aqi]l]npe_el]k`enap]ad]nikjeko]ajpnakjkookejpa) ha_pka]ran`]`a(jkookoanakiqj`k(lkeokobeh okbko]jpecko_kjoe`an]r]imqan]iko ajpaol]npe_el]jpao`apk`]o]obkni]o`ana]he`]`a6lknjkook_knlk(l]npe_el]iko`]j]pq) nav]7lknjkoo]]hi](l]npe_el]iko`]ejpahecj_e]`erej]* K_neope]jeoik(lkni(l]npa`]_kj_alkfq`]e_]`aqi]oal]n]kajpnakdkiai a@aqo(_]qo]`]lahkla_]`kknecej]hkqlah]mqa`]`klneiaenkdkiaia`]lneiaen]iq) hdan7lahkla_]`k(kodqi]jkobe_]n]ioal]n]`ko`]ejpahecj_e]`erej]alan`an]ikoh]ko d]nikjekoko_ki]j]pqnav]*@aoo]i]jaen]k_neope]jeoik]benikqmqakannka]ehqokok l]npa`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]ai`a_knnj_e]`k_]npanlanranpe`k`ajkoo]rkjp]`a(]l okla) _]`kknecej]h*?ne]`ko_kiqi]ejpahecj_e]lanbaep]aqi]rkjp]`aherna(klneiaenkdkiai a]lneiaen]iqhdanqo]n]i]he^an`]`al]n]pn]jocna`en]kn`ai`a@aqo(mqahdaolnke^e]k _kjda_eiajpk`k^aia`ki]h*Lknkncqhdk(=`kaAr]ejbnejcen]i]hae`erej]a(]kb]v)hk( bkn]ilqje`ko(lan`aj`kk_kjp]pk`enapk_ki@aqoa]ran`]`a(]eiknp]he`]`a`aoaqo_kn) lko(]lanbaek`]ejpahecj_e]a`]rkjp]`a(_]ej`kl]n]oailnajkannkaj]ehqok* Ai _kjoamqj_e] `] _kj_alk _neop `k oan dqi]jk( ] behkokbe] lna_eokq ajbnajp]n lnk^hai]ojkrko6 -*
?kik(oaj`koanao`a_]`koalanranpe`ko(lk`aiko_kjda_an]ran`]`a;
.* =kejpnk`qven]jkk`ala_]`kknecej]h(k_neope]jeoikejpnk`qveq]oal]n]kn]`e_]h ajpnakodqi]jko$lanranpe`koabejepko%a]`erej`]`a$lanbaep]aejbejep]%*?kieook(bav oqncen]lancqjp]6_kikkbejepk$dqi]jk%lk`a_kjda_an]ran`]`a$ejbejep]a`erej]%; Aeolknmqa(`qn]jpapk`]]E`]`aI`e](]bpknjkq)oa_ajpn]hl]n]]behkokbe](lkeoan] lkniaek`ah]mqaaoo]olancqjp]oan]inaolkj`e`]o*Ieoane_kn`ekok(@aqolnkiapaq]ko dkiajo]na`ajkal]n]eookajrekqoaqBehdkl]n]o]hr)hko*?nanjkBehdkpan]oqlnai] renpq`a(]b(mqaehqiej]jkookejpaha_pkacqe]jkoo]rkjp]`a(laniepej`kjkoo]n]vkk _kjda_eiajpk`kmqaaop]koaq]h_]j_a(]kiaoikpailkmqajkoo]]hi]]_aep]]oran) `]`aooqlaneknao(narah]`]olkn@aqoa_kjpe`]oj]oAo_nepqn]oO]cn]`]o*?kieook(k_neope])
-2.
4HEß'ENERALß,IBRARIES4HEß5NIVERSITYßOFß ß4EXASßATß!USTIN7IKIPmDIA
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
3ANTOß!GOSTINHOßß ¯
-2/
jeoikejpnk`qveqqi]`eopejkeilajorahl]n]kobeh okbko]jpecko(mq]hoaf](]`eopejk ajpnaran`]`ao`an]vkaran`]`ao`ab(kqajpnak_kjda_eiajpkmqajkoo]n]vklk`a ]h_]j]n lkn oe iaoi] a k _kjda_eiajpk mqa o ]h_]j]iko lkn iaek `a qi] narah]k `erej]*=oran`]`aomqa`alaj`ai`anarah]k`erej]ok]mqah]omqajkoo]n]vkbejep]a eilanbaep]jko jklk`a]h_]j]nokvejd]_kikok(ok^napq`k(]mqah]omqao lk`aiko ]_aep]noai_kilnaaj`an$_kikk_]ok(lknatailhk(`]Aj_]nj]k`kBehdk`a@aqo(kq] O]jpooei]Pnej`]`a(kq]Aq_]neope]%*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]oran`]`ao`]bokjfpqoflp+D( lknp]jpk(`q]oi]jaen]o`a_kjda_an6lah]]pere`]`a`]n]vkkqhqvj]pqn]halah]]_aep]k `]narah]kkqhqvok^naj]pqn]h* Reopkmqa]ran`]`a(p]jpk`an]vk_kik`ab(paioq]knecaij]o]^a`kne]aejpahecj) _e]`a@aqo$lkeoaopak_ne]`kn`apk`]o]o_keo]o%(]ran`]`a(`ere`e`]l]n]j o(ej`ereo] aqi]aioeiaoi]*Eookoecjebe_](ailneiaenkhqc]n(mqajklk`ad]ran_kjpn]`ekajpna ran`]`ao`]ba`]n]vk(lkeo]ran`]`ajklk`a_kjpn]`evan]ran`]`a(a(aioacqj`k(oa dkqran]hcqi]_kjpn]`ek(]oran`]`ao`an]vk`araioan]^]j`kj]`]oailnkraepk`]o ran`]`ao`]b(qi]ravmqa]n]vkdqi]j]aopoqfaep]]kannka]kb]hok*K_kjda_eiajpk n]_ekj]h(iaoikmqajk`alaj`]`]b(oq^kn`ej])oa]ah]* =hi`]`eopejk`]oran`]`ao(k_neope]jeoikpnkqta]e`ae]`amqa^`^rp^a^sbo* a^ab]ejpahecj_e]`erej]ajmq]jpk^`^rp^alboolbalc^ipl]rkjp]`adqi]j](_qf] he^an`]`alanrano]lkhqejkoo]ejpahecj_e]kqn]vk*Aoo]e`ae]_neopbkebqj`]iajp]`]l]n) pe_qh]niajpa_kiO]jpk=ckopejdkj]e`ae]`ambppl^(rej`]`k@enaepkNki]jk(mqa`abeja ]laook]_kikqioqfaepk`a`enaepkoa`aranao*Oaokikolaook]o(`evaiko_neopko(okiko naolkjoraeolknjkooko]pkoalajo]iajpko*Jkoo]laook]jkoo]`lkp`fk`f^(mqajkoo] ]hi]`kp]`]`arkjp]`a(ei]cej]k(iai ne]aejpahecj_e]*=ran`]`aoapknj](lknp]jpk( qi]mqaopk`a_kjo_ej_e]* = rkjp]`a herna a( ]lneoekj]`] jqi _knlk l]ooekj]h a bn]_k( lk`a iancqhd]n jkoo] ]hi]j]ehqokajkannk*Aop]njkannkkqj]ran`]`a`alaj`an(lknp]jpk(`aj oiaoiko( `ajkoo]_kjo_ej_e](alkneooklna_eo]ikoo]^anoalk`aikokqjk_kjda_an]ran`]`aa aimqa_kj`e aop]h_kjda_eiajpklkoorah*Kolneiaenkobeh okbko_neopkoakoia`ea) r]eo]beni]n]imqalk`aiko_kjda_an]ran`]`a(`ao`amqa]n]vkjk_kjpn]`ec]]baoa oq^iap]]ah]jkpk_]jpaoran`]`aohpei]oalnej_el]eo* Kobeh okbkoik`anjko(lkni(jk]_aep]n]iaoo]onaolkop]oalknaooaikperk]mqao) pk`k_kjda_eiajpkpknjkq)oa_ajpn]hl]n]ahao* Kobeh okbkocnackooaoqnlnaaj`e]imqalq`aooad]ranannk(ehqokaiajpen]*?kik] ran`]`aÍ^iqebf^Ían]_kj_a^e`]_kiklnaoaj]ai]jebaop]k`kran`]`aenk]kojko) okooajpe`kokq]kjkookejpaha_pk(eopk(_kiklnaoaj]`kOanjkoo]atlanej_e]oajorah a+kq]klqnklajo]iajpk(]lancqjp]behko be_]o lk`e]oan6Î?kiklkoorahkannkkq] ehqok;Ï*Kqoaf](oakran`]`aenkkln lnekOanb]vaj`k)oaranaipk`]o]o_keo]o(lnaoajpa aijkoo]olan_al ao(aijkoo]ol]h]rn]o(aijkookolajo]iajpko(_kikkb]hoklkoorah oakb]hok`evanalajo]nmqaateopakmqajkateopa;?kiklkoorahrankmqajk(`evan kmqajk(lajo]nkmqajk; L]n] ko ik`anjko( ] oepq]k at]p]iajpa _kjpnne]* Lancqjp]i6Î?kik k _kjda_e) iajpk `] ran`]`a lkoorah;Ï* @a b]pk( oa ] ran`]`a k mqa aop jk ejpaha_pk ejbejepk `a @aqo(ajpkaopao_kj`e`]`ajkoo]n]vkbejep]ajkpaiko]_aook]ah]*=ran`]`a(lknp]j) pk(jkkmqaaopi]jebaopkj]na]he`]`a(i]o`alaj`a`]narah]k`erej]*Kn](]narah]) ko _kjda_e`]lah]bal]n]aop]]ran`]`abjrk^e(]_kjbe]j]mqajkohar]]`evan Î]ooeioaf]Ïamqajkoo]n]vkjklk`aajpaj`an*Lknkqpnkh]`k(reopkmqajkookejpaha_pk heiep]`kbkelanranpe`klah]jkoo]rkjp]`ala_]`kn](_kiklk`aiko_kjda_an]piaoik ]oran`]`ao`an]vk(eopk(]omqaaop]ne]i]kjkook]h_]j_aoaik]qthek`]narah]ka`] b;Kqoaf](]pmqalkjpklk`aiko]`iepenmqajkoo]n]vkkqhqvj]pqn]h_]l]v`aqi o]^anran`]`aenk; Lkneookiaoik(kobeh okbkoik`anjkok^oanr]n]imqa]oran`]`ao`abd]re]iej) bhqaj_e]`k]ln lne]i]jaen]`a_kj_a^an]oran`]`ao`an]vk*@ab]pk(qi]ran`]`a`ab
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
]hcklnkbane`kalnk_h]i]`klknqi]]qpkne`]`aejmqaopekjrah$@aqo(]jfko(o]jpko%aaooa ]ola_pk_kikmqaÎ_kjp]iejkqÏ]oran`]`ao`an]vk(b]vaj`k_kimqakobeh okbkoo ]_ae) p]ooaiqi]e`ae]oaaop]reaooa_kikoahk`a]hcqi]]qpkne`]`ana_kjda_e`]lah]Ecnaf]* =ooei(iaoikqi]ran`]`amqalk`e]oan]h_]j]`]lknjkoo]n]vko an]]_aep]oabkooa ]qpknev]`]lkn]hcqi_kjoe`an]`koqlanekn$qibeh okbk]jpeck(qio]jpk(qil]l](qi _kj_heka_haoeope_k(ap_*%*Aaoo]]qpkne`]`aan]]ej`]i]eknoaaoperaooaoepq]`]jkl]oo]`k `eop]jpaaoq]oe`ae]o_kjda_e`]olah]haepqn]`ahernkokqlknhe ao`aao_kh]* =lneiaen]p]nab]mqakoik`anjkooa`an]ibke]`ana_qo]nklk`an`a]qpkne`]`ao ok^na]n]vk(oaf]]]qpkne`]`a`]oEcnaf]o(oaf]]`]oao_kh]oa`kohernko*?kia]i(lkneook( oal]n]j`kb`an]vk(_kjoe`an]j`k_]`]qi]`ah]orkhp]`]l]n]_kjda_eiajpko`ebanaj) paoaoaimqaqi]`ar]oq^kn`ej]n)oakqpn]*Lnkooacqaib]vaj`k]_npe_]`]]qpkne`]`a ]pne^q`]pn]`ek(]kohernko`ko]jpeckoa]kajoej]iajpk`]oao_kh]o*Al]oo]i]atlhe_]n _kik]n]vkaklajo]iajpklk`aipknj]n)oai]eobknpao`kmqa]rkjp]`aa_kjpnkh)h] l]n]mqaoaarepakannk* Klnk^hai]`k_kjda_eiajpkpknj])oa(lknp]jpk(_nq_e]ha]behkokbe]lna_eo]_kia]n lahkat]ia`]_]l]_e`]`adqi]j]`a_kjda_an(lahkajpaj`eiajpk(kaopq`k`]ln lne] n]vk dqi]j] kq `a jkook ejpaha_pk kq ajpaj`eiajpk* ?ki eook( k lkjpk `a l]npe`] `ko ik`anjkokprgbfqlal`lkeb`fjbkql*Ko`keobeh okbkomqa(jko_qhkTREE(eje_e]iaooa pn]^]hdkokkejchoBn]j_eo>]_kjakbn]j_oNaj@ao_]npao*Kbeh okbkmqalnkl a(lah] lneiaen]rav(qi]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpklnklne]iajpa`ep]kejchoFkdjHk_ga*Lk`a) iko `evan mqa ] l]npen `k o_qhk TREE( lknp]jpk( ] pakne] `k _kjda_eiajpk pknj])oa qi] `eo_elhej]_nq_e]h`]behkokbe]*
>]_kja@ao_]npao
?
kik `eooaiko( ko cnacko ej`]c]r]i6Î?kik k annk lkoorah;Ï* Ko ik`anjko lan) cqjp]n]i6Î?kik]ran`]`alkoorah;Ï*L]n]kocnacko(]ran`]`aan]^iqebf^(l]n] koik`anjko(sbofq^p*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(l]n]koik`anjkopn]p])oa`a_kilnaaj`an aatlhe_]n_kikkonah]pkoiajp]eoÍjkoo]oe`ae]oÍ_knnaolkj`ai]kmqaoal]oo]ran) `]`aen]iajpaj]na]he`]`a*=lao]n`aoo]o`ebanaj]o(koik`anjkonapki]n]ikik`k`a pn]^]hd]nbehkokbe_]iajpalnklkopklknO _n]pao(Lh]pka=neop pahao(mq]hoaf](_kia]nlahk at]ia`]okleje ao_kjpnne]oaehqo ne]ol]n]qhpn]l]oo)h]oai`enakran`]`a* =jpao`a]^kn`]nk_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk(>]_kja@ao_]npaoat]iej]n]iat]qope) r]iajpa]o_]qo]oa]obkni]o`kannk(ej]qcqn]j`kqiaopehkbehko be_kmqalani]ja_an j]behkokbe](eopk(]]jheoa`]o_]qo]oabkni]o`kojkookolna_kj_aepko*
>]_kj >]_kjah]^knkqqi]pakne]_kjda_e`]_kik^`oqf`^alpalilp*@a]_kn`k_ki>]_kj( ateopaimq]pnkpelko`a`khkokq`aei]cajomqabkni]ikleje ao_neop]hev]`]oalna_kj) _aepko(mqaeila`aik_kjda_eiajpk`]ran`]`a6 -*
qDOLOßAßPALAVRAßqDOLOßVEMß DOßGREGOßEIDOLONßEßSIGNIFI CAß±IMAGEM²
alilpa^`^sbok^$]_]ranj]`amqab]h]>]_kj]`kIepk`]?]ranj](`aLh]pk%6]o kleje aomqaoabkni]iaij olknannkoa`abaepko`ajkooko ncko`kooajpe`ko*Ok koi]eob_aeo`aoanai_knnece`kolknjkookejpaha_pk7
.* alilpalcorj$kb nqian]khqc]n`]o`eo_qoo aoa`ko`a^]paol^he_koj]Nki] ]jpec]%6 ok ]o kleje ao mqa oa bkni]i ai j o _kik _kjoamqj_e] `] hejcq]cai a `ajkoo]onah] ao_kikokqpnko*Ok`eb_aeo`aoanairaj_e`ko(i]okejpaha_pkpai lk`anok^naahao7 /* alilpalqb^qol$kpa]pnkkhqc]naimqabe_]ikol]ooerko(kj`aokiko]laj]oaola_) p]`knaoana_alpknao`aiajo]cajo%6ok]okleje aobkni]`]oaij oai`a_knnj_e]
-20
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
`kolk`anao`]o]qpkne`]`aomqajkoeil aioaqolkjpko`areop]akopn]jobkni]i ai `a_napko a haeo ejmqaopekjraeo* O lk`ai oan `aobaepko oa dkqran qi] iq`]j] ok_e]halkhpe_]7
,ARRYß7ß3MITH%PA,ATINSTOCK
0* alilpa^qof_l$]pne^kqi]cnql]iajpkdqi]jkaimqapk`kolkooqai]iaoi] knecai(kiaoik`aopejk(]oiaoi]o_]n]_panope_]oakoiaoiko_kilknp]iajpko%6 ok]okleje aomqaoabkni]iaij oai`a_knnj_e]`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]*Okln ) lneko`]aol_eadqi]j]ao lk`aioanraj_e`kooadkqranqi]nabkni]`]ln lne] j]pqnav]dqi]j]*
Kajpklnaoe`ajpa `koAop]`koQje`ko( CakncaS*>qod(_ki oq]ia>]n^]n] >qodaoaql]e(k at)lnaoe`ajpaCaknca >qod(`qn]jpaqi `eo_qnokjqi] qjeranoe`]`a`k Pat]o(ai`avai^nk `a.,,4*?aj] atailh]n`kmqa >]_kj_d]i]`a Î`khk`apa]pnkÏ*
= `aikhek `ko `khko ( lknp]jpk( qi] nabkni] `k ejpaha_pk( `ko _kjda_eiajpko a `]ok_ea`]`a*L]n]ko`keolneiaenko(>]_kjlnkl a]ejop]qn]k`aqijqlal(`abeje`k _kikkik`koacqnk`aÎ]lhe_]n]n]vkatlanej_e]Ï(eopk(`a]lhe_]nklajo]iajpkh ce_k ]ko`]`kokbana_e`kolahk_kjda_eiajpkoajorah*Kipk`k`arapknj]nlkoorah6 -*
knc]jev]na_kjpnkh]nko`]`kona_a^e`ko`]atlanej_e]oajorah(cn]]o]lnk_a`eiaj) pko]`amq]`ko`ak^oanr]ka`aatlaneiajp]k7
.* knc]jev]na_kjpnkh]nkonaoqhp]`kok^oanr]_ekj]eoaatlaneiajp]eol]n]_dac]n]_k) jda_eiajpkojkrkokqbkniqh]k`apakne]oran`]`aen]o7 /* `aoajrkhranlnk_a`eiajpko]`amq]`kol]n]]]lhe_]klnpe_]`konaoqhp]`kopa ne_ko( lkeol]n]ahakdkiaiÎiejeopnk`]j]pqnav]Ïa(oaokq^an_kjda_)h]$k^a`a_an)hda( `ev>]_kj%(lk`an_ki]j`)h]*Kipk`k(`ev>]_kj(kik`koacqnka_anpk`aÎ]lhe) _]n]n]vkatlanej_e]Ï(eopk(`a]lhe_]nklajo]iajpkran`]`aenk]ko`]`kokbana_e) `kolahk_kjda_eiajpkoajorah* >]_kj]_na`ep]r]mqak]r]jk`ko_kjda_eiajpkoa`]op_je_]o(]oiq`]j]ook_e]eo alkhpe_]oak`aoajrkhreiajpk`]o_ej_e]oa`]behkokbe]lnkle_e]ne]iqi]cn]j`anabkni] `k_kjda_eiajpkdqi]jk(mqaoane]p]i^iqi]cn]j`anabkni]`]re`]dqi]j]*P]jpk ]ooeimqa(]kh]`k`aoq]ok^n]obehko be_]o(ao_naraqqi]k^n]behko be_k)lkhpe_](]Kls^ >qi kqfa^(j]mq]h`ao_naraaj]nn]qi]ok_ea`]`ae`a]halanbaep](j]o_e`]`k_kjda_eiajpk ran`]`aenka`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]op_je_]o*
-21
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
@ao_]npao @ao_]npaohk_]hev]r]]knecai`kannkai`q]o]pepq`aomqa_d]ikq`a^qfqrabpfkc^kqfp kqmob`lk`bfqlpa^fkc k`f^6 -*
]mobsbk l(mqa]b]_ehe`]`a_kimqajkookaolnepkoa`aet]har]nlah]okleje aoa e`ae]o]hdae]o(oaioalnak_ql]nairanebe_]noaokkqjkran`]`aen]o*Ok]okleje ao mqaoa_neop]hev]iaij oj]bkni]`alna_kj_aepko$_khk_]`koaij olknl]eo(lnk) baooknao(hernko(]qpkne`]`ao%amqaao_n]rev]ijkooklajo]iajpk(eila`ej`k)jko`a lajo]na`aejraopec]n7
.* ]mob`fmfq^ l(mqa]b]_ehe`]`aa]rahk_e`]`a_kimqajkoo]rkjp]`ajkob]vaiepen fqvkook^na]o_keo]o]jpao`aranebe_]nikooajkoo]oe`ae]ookkqjkokran`]`ae) n]o* Ok kleje ao mqa aiepeiko ai _kjoamqj_e] `a jkoo] rkjp]`a oan i]eo bknpa a lk`anko]mqajkookejpaha_pk*Knecej]i)oajk_kjda_eiajpkoajorah(j]ei]cej]k( j]hejcq]caiaj]iai ne]* Aoo]o`q]o]pepq`aoej`e_]imqa(l]n]@ao_]npao(kannkoepq])oajk_kjda_eiajpkoaj) orah$kqoaf](oajo]k(lan_alk(ei]cej]k(iai ne]ahejcq]cai%(`ai]jaen]mqak_k) jda_eiajpkran`]`aenklqn]iajpaejpaha_pq]h(kqoaf](bqj`]`k]laj]oj]oklan] ao`a jkookejpaha_pkkqajpaj`eiajpkapai_kiklkjpk`al]npe`]kqe`ae]oej]p]o$ateopajpao aijkoo]n]vk%kqk^oanr] aomqabkn]iejpaen]iajpa_kjpnkh]`]olahklajo]iajpk* ?kik>]_kj(@ao_]npaop]i^iaop_kjraj_e`k`amqalkoorahraj_anko`abaepko jk _kjda_eiajpk( lkn iaek `a qi] nabkni] `k ajpaj`eiajpk a `]o _ej_e]o* $@ebanajpa) iajpa`a>]_kj(@ao_]npaojkr]ja_aooe`]`a`aaoo]nabkni]p]i^iateceniq`]j]o ok_e]eoalkhpe_]o*% Aoo]nabkni]`araoanbaep]lahkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkmq]j`kaopa_kilnaaj`a] ja_aooe`]`a`aaj_kjpn]nbqj`]iajpkooacqnkol]n]ko]^anaoa(l]n]p]jpk(ejopepqenqi jqlal* Kok^faperkolnej_el]eo`kipk`kok6 -*
]ooacqn]n]nabkni]`kejpaha_pkl]n]mqaaopaoec]k_]iejdkoacqnk`]ran`]`a$lkn) p]jpk(]b]op]n]lnarajka]lna_elep]k%7
.* kbana_anlnk_a`eiajpkolahkomq]eo]n]vklkoo]_kjpnkh]n)oa]oeiaoi]`qn]jpak lnk_aook`a_kjda_eiajpk o]^aj`k mqa _]iejdk lan_knnan a o]^aj`kna_kjda_anoa qinaoqhp]`kk^pe`kran`]`aenkkqjk7
$ISCOURSEß ONß -ETHODß 0UBLISHEDß BYß LANß -AIRE ß!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
/* laniepen]]ilhe]kkqk]qiajpk`ko_kjda_eiajpkocn]]o]lnk_a`eiajpkooacq) nkomqalaniep]il]oo]n`kf_kjda_e`k]k`ao_kjda_e`k7 0* kbana_ankoiaekol]n]mqakojkrko_kjda_eiajpkolkoo]ioan]lhe_]`ko(lkeoko]^an `ara(jk`evan`a@ao_]npao(pknj]nkdkiaiÎoajdkn`]j]pqnav]Ï* Lknmqakipk`koapknj]ja_aoonek; Baep]o]o_npe_]o]qpkne`]`a`]oao_kh]oa`kohernko(`]pn]`eka`kolna_kj_aepko(k oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk`ao_k^na)oa_kikqi]_kjo_ej_e]mqal]na_ajklk`an_kjp]n _kik]qthek`kiqj`kl]n]cqe)hk(`ao_kjbe]`ko_kjda_eiajpkooajoraeoa`ko_kjda) _eiajpkodan`]`ko*Aopo *?kjp]]laj]o_kioaqln lneklajo]iajpk*Oq]okhe`kpknj] ej`eolajorahqiipk`kmqa lkoo] cqe]n k lajo]iajpk ai `enak ]ko _kjda_eiajpko ran`]`aenkoa`eopejcqe)hko`kob]hoko*Aeolknmqa@ao_]npaoao_naraAfp`roplaljqlala Obdo^pm^o^^afob lalbpmofql*Ok^nakipk`k(`evaha(j]nacn]ER`]oObdo^p6 Mlojqlal)bkqbkalobdo^p`boq^pbc`bfp)do^ ^p pnr^fpqlalplpnrb^pl_pbosbj bu^q^jbkqbg^j^fpqlj^ol`ljlsboa^abfol^nrfilnrbc^iplb`ebd^ol)pbjpb`^k* p^o`ljbpclo lpfk qbfpb^rjbkq^kalmoldobppfs^jbkqbpr^@fk`f^)^l`lkeb`fjbkql sboa^abfolabqrallnrbiebpmlppsbibpmbo^o+
$ISCURSOßDOßMmTODOßß FAC SqMILEßDAßCAPAßDAßOBRAß $ISCURSOßDOßMmTODO ßDEß $ESCARTES ßPUBLICADAßEMß
-22
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
@ao_]npao(lknp]jpk(`abejakipk`k_kikqi_kjfqjpk`anacn]o_qf]o_]n]_panope_]o lnej_el]eookpno6 -*
_anp]o$kipk`k`oacqn]j]]klajo]iajpk%7
.* b_aeo$kipk`karep]_kilhe_] aoaaobknkoejpaeo%7 /* ]ilh]o$kipk`k`aralaniepenmqaoa]h_]j_apk`koko_kjda_eiajpkolkooraeol]n] kajpaj`eiajpkdqi]jk%* @ao_]npaoah]^kn]mq]pnkcn]j`aonacn]o`kipk`k6 -* D{VIDAßMETvDICAßCOMOßJfß VIMOS ßmßAßDECISjOßDEßNjOß ACEITARßNENHUMßPENSA MENTOßOUßNENHUMAßIDEIAß EMßQUEßPOSSAßHAVERßAß MENORßD{VIDA
obdo^a^bsfak`f^6o ]`iepen_kikran`]`aenkqi_kjda_eiajpkare`ajpa(eopk(jk mq]haok^nakmq]hjk_]e^]]iajkn`re`]*L]n]eook@ao_]npao_nekqqilnk_a`e) iajpk(]a sfa^jbqaf`^(lahkmq]hkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(]j]heo]j`k_]`]qi `aoaqo_kjda_eiajpko(_kjda_aa]r]he]]obkjpaoa]o_]qo]o`a_]`]qi(]bkni]ak _kjpa`k`a_]`]qi(]b]hoe`]`aa]ran`]`a`a_]`]qiaaj_kjpn]iaekol]n]hern]n)oa `apq`kmq]jpkoaf]`qre`koklan]jpaklajo]iajpk7
.* obdo^a^afsfpl6l]n]_kjda_anikona]he`]`ao_kilhat]olna_eo]iko`ere`en]o`ebe_qh) `]`aoakolnk^hai]oaioq]ol]n_ah]oi]eooeilhao(at]iej]j`k_]`]qi]`ah]oai _kjbknie`]`a_ki]nacn]`]are`j_e]7
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
/* obdo^a^loabj6kolajo]iajpko`araioankn`aj]`koaioneaomqark`koi]eooei) lhao]koi]eo_kilhatko(`koi]eob_aeo]koi]eo`eb_aeo(lkeo]kn`ai_kjoeopaai `eopne^qenko_kjda_eiajpko`ap]hi]jaen]mqalkoo]ikol]oo]n`k_kjda_e`k]k`ao) _kjda_e`k7 0* obdo^a^bkrjbo^ l6]_]`]_kjda_eiajpkjkrkk^pe`k(b]van]nareok_kilhap]`ko l]ooko`]`ko(`konaoqhp]`kol]n_e]eoa`koaj_]`a]iajpkomqalaniepen]i_dac]n]k jkrk_kjda_eiajpk*
Hk_ga
!Nß%SSAYßCONCERNINGß(UMANEß5NDERSTANDINGßINßFOURß BOOKS!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
*OHNß,OCKE߯
F
kdjHk_gakeje_e]`kn`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpklnklne]iajpa`ep]lknmqaoalnkl a ] ]j]heo]n _]`] qi] `]o bkni]o `a _kjda_eiajpk mqa lkooqiko( ] knecai `a jkoo]o e`ae]oajkooko`eo_qnoko(]bej]he`]`a`]opakne]oa]o_]l]_e`]`ao`koqfaepk_kcjko_ajpa nah]_ekj]`]o_kikok^fapkomqaahalk`a_kjda_an* Hkckj]]^anpqn]`aoq]k^n]Bkp^flpl_oblbkqbkafjbkqlerj^kl(Hk_gaao_nara6 Sfpqlnrblbkqbkafjbkqlpfqr^leljbj^`fj^alplrqolppbobppbkpsbfpba*ieb qla^s^kq^dbjbqlalaljkflnrbqbjpl_obbibp)pbrbpqral`lkpfpqb`boq^jbkqbkrj qmf`lnrb)mlopr^kl_obw^)jbob`baloabklpplqo^_^ielabfksbpqfd*il+Lbkqbkaf* jbkql)`ljllliel)nrbklpc^wsbobmbo`b_boqla^p^plrqo^p`lfp^p)klpbl_pbos^^pf jbpjl8obnrbo^oqbbbpclo lpfqr*il^afpq k`f^bc^w*ilpbrmomofll_gbql+
%NSAIOßSOBREßOßENTENDI MENTOßHUMANOßFAC SqMILEß DAßCAPAßDEß%NSAIOßSOBREß OßENTENDIMENTOßHUMANO ß DEß*OHNß,OCKE ßEMßEDIljOß DEß
-23
=ooei_kikkkhdk(mqab]vranajkoar]oeiaoik(kajpaj`eiajpkdqi]jkb]v _kjda_an(i]ojkoa_kjda_a]oeiaoik*L]n]_kjda_an)oa(eopk(l]n]mqakajpaj`eiajpk pknja)oaqik^fapk`a_kjda_eiajpkl]n]oeiaoik(Înamqan]npaaaobknkÏ*?kik@ao_]npao a>]_kj(Hk_ga]beni]]ja_aooe`]`a`kajpaj`eiajpkat]iej]n]oeiaoik*?kik>]_kja @ao_]npao(Hk_gap]i^i_kjoe`an]mqaja_aoonekaobknk(pn]^]hdk(`a_eokl]n]b]vank ajpaj`eiajpkpki]n)oa]oeiaoik_kikk^fapk`aejraopec]k*Lkni(]ooei_kik=neo) p pahao`ebane]`aLh]pk(Hk_ga`ebana`a@ao_]npao* Lh]pka@ao_]npaooal]n]i(`aqih]`k(]atlanej_e]oajorah(mqalk`aaop]noqfaep]]k annk(a(`akqpnk(k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk(mqalqn]iajpaejpaha_pq]h*@ao_]npao(lkni( `ebana`aLh]pk(lknmqa_kjoe`an]mqak_kjda_eiajpkoajorahlk`aa`araoanailnac]) `klknj o(`ao`amqaoq^iape`k]kipk`ka_kjpnkh]`klahkajpaj`eiajpk*=neop pahaoa
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
Hk_ga_kjoe`an]imqak_kjda_eiajpkoana]hev]lkncn]qo_kjpjqko(l]npej`k`]oajo]k ]p_dac]noe`ae]o*Jkajp]jpk(Hk_ga`ebana`a=neop pahaolknmqa(l]n]aopa(kolnej_leko `klajo]iajpka`]na]he`]`ajkok_kjda_e`kolknatlanej_e]oajorahjailnk_a`ai `]atlanej_e]oajorah(i]ook_kjda_e`ko]laj]olahklqnklajo]iajpkkqlah]ejpqek ejpaha_pq]h*L]n]Hk_ga(lkni(pk`]o]oe`ae]oapk`kokolnej_leko`k_kjda_eiajpk`ane) r]i`]atlanej_e]oajorah*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(kejpaha_pkna_a^a`]atlanej_e]oajorah pk`kki]pane]h`k_kjda_eiajpkalknaooaikperklk`a)oa`evanmqajkdj]`]aijkook ajpaj`eiajpkmqajkpajd]rej`k`]ooajo] ao* Prmlke^jlp nrb l bpmofql pbg^) mlo ^ppfj afwbo) rj^ clie^ bj _o^k`l) pbj kb* kerj^ibqo^)pbjkbkerj^fabf^+@ljlbpq^p`ebd^o^j^ifm^i^so^)ilkdbabpborjpfjmibppfdklalpl_gbqlpba^ppfdkfcf`^ bp)e^_fq^^p `lfp^pbsbf`ri^pfdkfcf`^ bp+K^nrbibnrbc^i^)^m^i^so^klqo^arwrjmbkp^jbkqlg cbfql)j^plob^ifw^+B^nrbibnrbbp`rq^ob`b_b)mbi^m^i^so^)lmomoflmbkp^jbkql+ =hejcq]caiklqo^arwei]cajoran^]eo`aknecaiikpkn]aoajokne]hkbjobmobpbkq^ e`ae]obaep]olknqilajo]iajpkoehaj_ekok(i]oaj_]nj]]ooecjebe_] ao*=ol]h]rn]oqj oajpe`ka`of^joajpe`k*
#APqTULOß Klajo]iajpk
Lajo]j`k***
?
anp]ravqicnack`eooa6ÎKlajo]iajpkkl]ooaek`]]hi]Ï*?kieookmqeo`evanmqa klajo]iajpk]i]jaen]_kikjkookaolnepkl]na_ao]en`a`ajpnk`aoeiaoika lan_knnankiqj`kl]n]_kjda_)hk*=ooei_kikjkl]ooaekhar]ikojkook_knlk] pk`]l]npa(jklajo]iajpkhar]ikojkoo]]hi]]pk`]l]npaai]eohkjca`kmqak_knlk( lkeo]]hi]jkaj_kjpn]k^op_qhkoboe_kol]n]oaq_]iejd]n* Klajo]iajpkaoo]_qneko]]pere`]`alkniaek`]mq]ho]iko`aj oiaoikooai o]eniko`ajkookejpanekn*Lkneook(kqpnkbeh okbkao_naraqmqalajo]n]i]jaen]lah]mq]h o]en`aoeaajpn]naioeokqi]o aiaoi]_keo]*?kikqirkkoaio]en`khqc]n* Aijkook_kpe`e]jkqo]iko]ol]h]rn]ombkp^oambkp^jbkqlaioajpe`kor]ne]`koaih) pelhko*Lk`aiko_dac]n]qi]laook]]iec](r)h]oehaj_eko]a`evan)hda6ÎLknb]rkn(`ec])ia aimqark_aoplajo]j`k;Ï*?kieookna_kjda_aikoqi]]pere`]`aokhepne](ejreorahl]n] j oamqalna_eo]oanlnkbane`]l]n]oan_kil]npehd]`]* Kqpn]oravao(lkni(lk`aiko`evan]aoo]iaoi]laook]6ÎRk_lajo]mqajkoaek mqark_aoplajo]j`k;Ï*Jaooa_]ok(`]iko]ajpaj`anmqa`eolkiko`aoej]eoÍ]hcqi] _keo] mqa bke `ep]( qi caopk( qi khd]n( qi] atlnaook beoekjie_] Í mqa jko laniepai ÎranÏklajo]iajpk`a]hcqia(lknp]jpk(]_na`ep]ikomqalajo]np]i^ioapn]`qvai oej]eo_knlkn]eoareoraeo*Klajo]iajpkiajkookhepnekaiajkooa_napk`kmqaoalk`a) ne]oqlkn* =hcqi]oravao(_dac]ikol]n]]hcqiaej`]c]iko6Î?kik(lajokq;Ï(akqreiko] naolkop]6ÎOei*R]ikob]vankpn]^]hdkÏ*Kqajpk6Î=ej`]aopkqlajo]j`kjk]ooqjpk*R]iko ran`alkeoÏ*Jaooao_]oko(lajo]npki]`klknj o_kikoejjeik`a`ahe^an]ka`a`a_e) ok(_kik]hckmqanaoqhp]jqi]]k* Iqep]oravao(lk`ai`evan)jko6ÎRk_lajo]`ai]eo(jkb]v^aio]`aÏ*Kqkqreiko ] bn]oa6ÎAh] be_kq l]n]`] h j] aomqej]( mqeap]( lajo]j`k( lajo]j`kÏ* Lk`aiko b]h]n6ÎLkn i]eomqalajoajeookjk_kjoeck]_na`ep]na(mq]jpki]eolajok(iajko]_na`epkÏ*=ckn]( lajo]nreopk_kiklnak_ql]k$b]vaj`ki]ho]`a%(_eoi]$be_]nl]n]`](mqeap](_eoi]j) `k%(`re`]$mq]jpki]eolajok(iajko]_na`epk%*
-52
Klajo]iajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
=hcqjofknj]eo_kopqi]ilq^he_]n]hckmqa]hcqi`eooa_kikppqhk6ÎKlajo]iajpk `k`e]***Ï(mqanaj`k`evan_kieookmqaqi]`apaniej]`]e`ae](`abejej`k]hcqi]ooqjpk( bkelq^he_]iajpa]jqj_e]`]*Aoo]iaoi]e`ajpebe_]kajpnalajo]iajpkae`ae]lk`a]l]) na_anmq]j`k(lknatailhk(qi_npe_khepannekao_nara6ÎKhernk`aBqh]jkpai]hcqjo^kjo lajo]iajpko(i]opaikqpnko^]j]eoÏ(_h]ooebe_]j`ke`ae]oaiÎ^k]oÏaÎ^]j]eoÏ(eopk(qi]o mqa`evai]hckjkrkkqejpanaoo]jpaakqpn]omqanalapaihqc]nao)_kiqjokqbnerkhe`]`ao* Oqlkiko(`aoo]i]jaen](mqad^kjoai]qolajo]iajpko(p]jpk]ooeimqab]h]ikoai Îlajo]iajpklkoeperkÏaaiÎ]b]op]nkoi]qolajo]iajpkoÏ* Qilnkbaooknlk`a_nepe_]nkpn]^]hdk`aqi]hqjk`evaj`k]aha6ÎAooapn]^]hdkikopn] mqark_jkmqeolajo]nÏ*=mqe(lajo]njko pane`ae]oi]op]i^i]hckmqaoalk`a mqanankqjkmqanan(]hckrkhqjpneka`ahe^an]`k(qi]bkni]`a]pajka_kj_ajpn]k* Aoo]ei]cai`a_kj_ajpn]k]l]na_a(lknatailhk(mq]j`k]hcqioav]jc]a`ev6ÎMqa) nai(lknb]rkn(b]vanoehj_ek;Jkaopkraj`kmqaaopkqlajo]j`k;Ï* Afiaj_ekj]ikok_ha^naÎLajok(hkckateopkÏ$@ldfql)bodlprj%(`a@ao_]npao(a] `abejek`kdkiai_kikÎ_]jeklajo]jpaÏ(baep]lknL]o_]h*=mqe(lajo]nalajo]iajpk ej`e_]i]ln lne]aooj_e]`kooanaodqi]jko*
Kmqa`evaiko`e_ekjneko
O
-53
alnk_qn]nikombkp^oambkp^jbkqljko`e_ekjneko(jkp]naikomqakornekooajpe) `ko`]`ko]aooaopaniko]^n]jcaikoatailhkomqa`aiko`kqok`aoo]ol]h]rn]o aijkook_kpe`e]jka]ej`]]_nao_ajp]i]hcqjokqpnkooajpe`ko* Mbkp^o(`evaiko`e_ekjneko(oecjebe_]6-*Î]lhe_]n]]pere`]`a`kaolnepk]koahaiajpko bknja_e`kolahk_kjda_eiajpkÏ7Îbkni]na_ki^ej]ne`ae]oÏ7Îfqhc]nÏ(ÎnabhapenÏ(În]_ek_ej]nÏ( Îaola_qh]nÑ7.*Îatan_an]ejpahecj_e]Ï7Îia`ep]nÏ(ÎranÏ7/*Îatan_ankaolnepkkq]]pere`]`a _kjo_eajpa`aqi]i]jaen]chk^]h6oajpen(mqanan(nabhapenÏ70*Îpanqi]klejek(qi]_kjre_) kÏ71*ÎoqlknÏ(ÎlnaoqienÏ(Î_nanÏ(Î]`iepenÏ(Îoqolaep]nÏ(Î]_d]nÏ72*Îaolan]nÏ(Îpaj_ekj]nÏ73* Îlnak_ql]n)oaÏ74*Î]r]he]nÏ75*Î_eoi]nÏ* Mbkp^jbkql( `a ]_kn`k _ki ko `e_ekjneko( oecjebe_]6 -*Îk ]pk `a nabhapen( ia`ep]n kq lajo]n(kqklnk_aookiajp]hmqaoa_kj_ajpn]aie`ae]oÏ7.*Î]pere`]`a`a_kjda_eiajpkkq mqapajd]lknk^fapkk_kjda_eiajpkÏ7/*Î_kjo_ej_e]Ï(ÎiajpaÏ(ÎaolnepkÏ(Îajpaj`eiajpkÏ( Îejpaha_pkÏ(În]vkÏ70*Îlk`an`abkniqh]ne`ae]oa_kj_aepkoÏ71*Îb]_qh`]`a`alajo]nhkce_]) iajpaÏ(În]_ek_jekÏ(Îlkjpk`areop]Ï(Îbkniqh]k`aqifqvkÏ72*Î]mqehkmqalajo]`kkq knaoqhp]`k`k]pk`alajo]n6e`ae](lkjpk`areop](klejek(fqvkÏ73*Îb]jp]oe]Ï(ÎokjdkÏ(Î`a) r]jaekÏ(Îhai^n]j]Ï(Îna_kn`]kÏ(Î_qe`]`kÏ(Îlnak_ql]kÏ(Îatla_p]per]Ï74*Î_kjfqjpk`]o e`ae]okq`kqpnej]`aqilajo]`kn(`aqi]ok_ea`]`a(`aqicnqlk(`aqi]_khapere`]`aÏ* =ooei(jkatailhkÎRk_lajo]`ai]eo(jk^kil]n]]o]`aÏ(mbkp^oambkp^jbkql oecjebe_]iÎlnak_ql]kÏ7jkatailhkÎLkni]eomqalajoajeook(jk]_na`epkmqaoaf]]o) oeiÏ(mbkp^oambkp^jbkqloecjebe_]iÎ_eoi]ÏaÎ`re`]Ï7jkatailhkÎ=ej`]aopkqlajo]j`k jk]ooqjpkÏ(mbkp^oambkp^jbkqloecjebe_]iÎbkni]nqi]klejekkqqilkjpk`areop]Ï7jk atailhkÎ=_]^ai_kiaooa^]nqhdk(jkaopkraj`kmqaaopkqlajo]j`k;Ï(mbkp^oambkp^* jbkqloecjebe_]iÎ]pere`]`aiajp]hkqejpaha_pq]hl]n]bkniqh]nqi]e`ae]kqqi_kj_aepkÏ* Oaaq`eooan6ÎLajokmqaah]renÏ(aopkqatlneiej`kqi]Îatla_p]per]Ï7oa`eooan6ÎLajok mqark_o]^a`eookÏ(aopkqatlneiej`kqi]ÎoqlkoekÏ7oa`eooan6ÎLajoaejaha]jkepaejpae) n](jailq`a`knienÏ(aopkqatlneiej`kÎlnak_ql]kÏ7oa`eooan6ÎAq]relan`e`]ailaj) o]iajpkoÏ(mqank`evanmqare]hcqi_eoi]j`k(b]jp]oe]j`k(ei]cej]j`k*I]ooaaq`eooan6 Î=pakne]`]nah]pere`]`anaoqhp]`kpn]^]hdk`klajo]iajpk`aAejopaejÏ(aopkq`evaj`kmqa klajo]iajpkqi]]pere`]`aejpaha_pq]h`alnk`qk`a_kjda_eiajpko* Mq]j`k lnk_qn]iko ] knecai `]o l]h]rn]o mbkp^jbkql a mbkp^o( `ao_k^neiko mqa lnk_a`ai`aqiran^kh]pejk(kran^kmbkabob(mqaoecjebe_]6Îbe_]naioqolajokÏ(Îaop]nkq be_]nlaj`ajpakqlaj`qn]`kÏ(Îoqolaj`anÏ(Îlao]nÏ(Îl]c]nÏ(Îat]iej]nÏ(Î]r]he]nÏ(Îlkj`an]nÑ( Î_kilajo]nÏ(Îna_kilajo]nÏaÎamqehe^n]nÏ*
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
Mbkp^o(lknp]jpk(oqolaj`ankfqhc]iajpk$]pbkni]nqi]e`ae]kqklejek%(lao]n $_kil]n]n e`ae]o( kleje ao( lkjpko `a reop]%( ]r]he]n $fqhc]n k r]hkn `a qi] e`ae] kq kle) jek(kqoaf](oaran`]`aen]kqb]ho](fqop]kqejfqop](]`amq]`]kqej]`amq]`]%(at]iej]n $e`ae]o(kleje ao(fqvko(lkjpko`areop]%(lkj`an]n$eopk(lao]ne`ae]oalkjpko`areop]l]n] ao_khdanqi`ahao%(amqehe^n]n$aj_kjpn]nkiaek)panikajpnaatpnaikokqajpnaklkopko%* Mbkp^ob(mqa`aner]`ambkabob(_]n]_panev])oai]eo_kikqi]]pere`]`aok^nae`ae]o(kle) je ao(fqvkoalkjpko`areop]fateopajpao`kmqa_kik_ne]kkqlnk`qk`aqi]e`ae] kqlkjpk`areop]* Lknaooaikperk(mq]j`khaikokopatpkobehko be_ko]jpeckoaik`anjko(ao_nepkoai h]pei( jkp]iko mqa jk qo]i mbkabob a mbkp^ob l]n] `evan mbkp^o( i]o ailnac]i `keo kqpnkoran^ko6`ldfq^obafkqbiifdbob* @ldfq^oboecjebe_]Î_kjoe`an]n]pajp]iajpaÏaÎia`ep]nÏ*Aooaran^krai`akqpnk(^dbob( mqaoecjebe_]Îailqnn]nl]n]`e]jpa`aoeÏ(ap]i^i`kran^k^dfq^ob(mqaoecjebe_]Îai) lqnn]nl]n]]bnajpa_kibkn]Ï(Î]cep]nÏ*Mbkp^o(ajmq]jpk`ldfq^ob(Î_khk_]n`e]jpa`aoe ]hcqi]_keo]l]n]_kjoe`an)h]_ki]pajkÏkqÎbkn]n]hcqi]_keo]]be_]n`e]jpa`aj o l]n]oanat]iej]`]Ï* Kran^kfkqbiifdbobrai`]_kilkoek`a`q]okqpn]ol]h]rn]o6fkqbo(eopk(ÎajpnaÏ(a ibdbob(mqaoecjebe_]Î_khdan(naqjen(na_khdan(ao_khdanahanÏ$eopk(naqjen]ohapn]o_kiko khdko%*Lkneook(fkqbiifdboboecjebe_]Îao_khdanajpnaÏ(ÎnaqjenajpnarnekoÏ(Î]l]jd]nÏ(Î]lnaj) `anÏ(Î_kilnaaj`anÏ(ÎhanajpnaÏ(Îhan`ajpnk`aÏ*@kj`a6_kjda_anaajpaj`an* Oanaqjenikokornekooajpe`ko`kopnoran^koÍmbkp^ob(`ldfq^* obafkqbiifdbobÍ(ranaikomqambkp^oambkp^jbkqloailnaoecjebe_]i ]pere`]`aomqaatecai]pajk6lao]n(]r]he]n(amqehe^n]n(_khk_]n`e]jpa `aoel]n]_kjoe`an]n(naqjenaao_khdan(_khdanana_khdan*Klajo]iajpk (]ooei(qi]]pere`]`alah]mq]h]_kjo_ej_e]kq]ejpahecj_e]_khk_] ]hck`e]jpa`aoel]n]]pajp]iajpa_kjoe`an]n(]r]he]n(lao]n(amqehe^n]n( naqjen(_kilnaaj`an(ao_khdan(ajpaj`anahanlkn`ajpnk* Eookatlhe_]pk`kokooajpe`komqareikooqncenjko`e_ekjneko`] hjcq]lknpqcqao]ajkoatailhkomqa`aiko6ia`ep]n(_kj_ajpn]n)oa( _eoi]n( klej]n( pan e`ae]o( _kilnaaj`an ]o _keo]o( n]_ek_ej]n( bkniqh]n _kj_aepko(panqilkjpk`areop](nabhapen(]r]he]n(lnak_ql]n)oa* Klajo]iajpk]_kjo_ej_e]kq]ejpahecj_e]o]ej`k`aoe$Îl]o) oa]j`kÏ%l]n]en_khdaj`k(naqjej`k(na_khdaj`kko`]`kokbana_e`kolah] atlanej_e](lah]lan_alk(lah]ei]cej]k(lah]iai ne](lah]hejcq]) cai(arkhp]j`k]oe(l]n]_kjoe`an)hko]pajp]iajpa(_khk_)hko`e]jpa`a oe(k^oanr)hkoejpaha_pq]hiajpa(lao)hko(]r]he)hko(napen]j`k`ahao_kj) _hqo ao(bkniqh]j`ke`ae]o(_kj_aepko(fqvko(n]_ek_jeko(r]hknao* K lajo]iajpk atlneia jkoo] ateopj_e] _kik oanao n]_ekj]eo a _]l]vao`a_kjda_eiajpk]^opn]pkaejpaha_pq]h(aok^napq`ki]jebaop] oq]ln lne]_]l]_e`]`al]n]`]n]oeiaoikhaeo(jkni]o(nacn]oalnej) _lekol]n]]h_]j]n]ran`]`a`a]hcqi]_keo]*
KlejpknI]n_ah @q_d]ilaopq`] kp]^qhaenk`a t]`nav]jpao`k ln teikh]j_a*
%LIOTß%LISOFON4IMEßß,IFEß0ICTURES'ETTYß)MAGES
Atlane j_e]o`alajo]iajpk
I
qep]o ravao jko ]_kjpa_a `a l]oo]niko dkn]o i]pqp]j`k( _eoi]j`k( mqanaj`k _kilnaaj`an]hcqi]_keo]mqajkoao_]l]*B]vaikojkoo]o]pere`]`ao`apk`k`e]( i]o l]na_aiko `eopn]`ko lknmqa jkoo] ]pajk aop _kj_ajpn]`] jkqpn] l]npa( j]mqehkmqaaop]ikomqanaj`k_kilnaaj`anajk_kjoacqeiko*?]jo]`ko(l]n]iko`a_eo) i]na`a`]n]pajk]k]ooqjpk*@analajpa(_kioqopka]hacne](mq]oacnep]iko6ÎAjpaj`eÏ* Oajpeikokiaoikmqamq]j`k_kilhap]ikoqimqa^n])_]^a](pk`]o]ola]oaioaqo`a) re`kohqc]nao(]becqn]^aireorah`e]jpa`aj o*Peraikoqi]atlanej_e]`alajo]iajpk*
-54
Klajo]iajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
Kqpn]oravao(]ooeopej`k]qi]]qh](haj`kqihernk_eajpbe_k(b]vaj`kqipn]^]hdkjk h]^kn]p nek(naokhraj`kqilnk^hai]jk_kilqp]`kn(r]iko]_kil]jd]j`kl]ook]l]ook ]oe`ae]o(koaj_]`a]iajpko`kon]_ek_jeko(]onah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkajpna_anp]o_keo]o(]o _kjoamqj_e]o`aqi]]beni]ka`aqi]jac]ka(bej]hiajpa(]_kj_hqok]mqa_dac]i] ]qh](khernk(kpn]^]hdkjkh]^kn]p nekkqjk_kilqp]`kn*=kpniejk`a_]`]qi]`aoo]o]pe) re`]`aopaiko_kjo_ej_e]`amqa]lnaj`aiko]hcqi]_keo]mqajko]^]ikoamqabevaiko qilan_qnokl]n]_kjda_)h]a_kilnaaj`)h]*Peraikoqi]atlanej_e]`alajo]iajpk* Ai_anp]ok_]oe ao(`e]hkc]j`k_kiqi]kqpn]laook](]_kjrano]r]eb]vaj`koqncen e`ae]oj]omq]eojqj_]oad]re]lajo]`k(kqr]eb]vaj`k_kimqaoalan_a^]mqa]hcqi]o e`ae]o(mqaoafqhc]r]i_h]n]oa_knnap]o(j]ran`]`aok_kjbqo]oaej_knnap]o*B]h]j`k_ki ]kqpn]laook](rkq`aoajrkhraj`ke`ae]omqaaqjaio]^e]mqapejd]amqabkn]i`aolanp]) `]oaiieilkn]hcqi]_keo]mqakkqpnkia`eooa*?h]nebe_k]hcqi]o(_knnefkkqpn]o(]^]j) `kjkkqpn]op]jp]o(`ao_q^nkjkr]o(penk_kj_hqo aokqiaaj_dk`alanlhate`]`a*Peraqi] atlanej_e]`alajo]iajpk* Mq]j`klajo]iko(lkikoaiikreiajpkkmqajkorai`]lan_alk(`]ei]cej]k( `]iai ne]7]lnaaj`aikokoajpe`k`]ol]h]rn]o7aj_]`a]ikoa]npe_qh]ikooecjebe_] ao( ]hcqi]orej`]o`ajkoo]atlanej_e]oajorah(kqpn]o`ajkookn]_ek_jek(kqpn]obkni]`]ola) h]onah] aoajpnaei]cajo(l]h]rn]o(hai^n]j]oae`ae]o]jpaneknao*Klajo]iajpk]lnaaj`a( _kil]n](oal]n](]j]heo](naja(kn`aj](oejpapev](_kj_hqe(nabhapa(`a_ebn](ejpanlnap](ejpannkc]*
=ejpahec j_e]
=
-55
loe_khkce]_kopqi]`abejen]ejpahecj_e]lknoq]bqjk(_kjoe`an]j`k)]qi]]pe) re`]`a mqa pai lkn k^faperk na]hev]n jkoo] ]`]lp]k ]k ]i^eajpa lahk aop]^aha) _eiajpk`anah] aoajpnaiaekoabejol]n]]okhqk`aqilnk^hai]kq`aqi] `ebe_qh`]`a*Aoo]`abejek_kj_a^a(lknp]jpk(]ejpahecj_e]_kikqi]]pere`]`aaiejaj) paiajpalnpe_]a]`eopejcqa`a`q]okqpn]omqap]i^ilkooqaibej]he`]`a]`]lp]per]a nah]_ekj]iiaekoabejo6kfkpqfkqlake_fql* ?kil]npehd]iko k ejopejpk a k d^epk _ki ko ]jei]eo* K ejopejpk( lkn atailhk( jko har]]qpki]pe_]iajpa]_kjpn]en]lqleh]mq]j`kjkookokhdkoaopkiqepkatlkopkohqv a]`eh]p)h]mq]j`kaop]ikoj]ao_qne`k7har])jko]]b]op]nn]le`]iajpa]ik`aqi] oqlanb_eaiqepkmqajpamqalkoo]mqaei]n)jko*Kejopejpkej]pk*=k_kjpnnek(kd^epk ]`mqene`k(i]o(_kikkejopejpk(paj`a]na]hev]n)oa]qpki]pe_]iajpa*Lknatailhk(mqai ]`mqenakd^epk`a`enecenqira_qhk(iq`]]oi]n_d]o(leo]j]ai^na]cai(jk]_ahan]`kn kqjkbnaekoailna_eo]nlajo]njaoo]oklan] ao7mqai]lnaj`a]l]pej]nkq]j]`]n(na]he) v]i]mqej]hiajpakocaopkoja_aooneko(`alkeo`a]`mqene)hko* Ejopejpkad^epkokbkni]o`a_kilknp]iajpk_qf]lnej_el]h_]n]_panope_]oanai aola_e]hev]`kokqaola_be_ko6]]^ahd]o]^ab]van]_khiae](i]oej_]l]v`ab]vankjejdk7 kfkk)`a)^]nnk_kjopn eqi]Î_]o]Ï(i]oej_]l]v`ab]vanqi]_khiae]7lkook]lnaj`an] j]`]n(i]oaooad^epkjkiab]vo]^an]j`]n`a^e_e_hap]* Kejopejpkakd^epkaola_e]hev]i]obqj ao(koiaekoakobejoajklkooqaibhate^e) he`]`al]n]iq`)hkokql]n]]`]lp]nqiiaek]qijkrkbei(jail]n]qo]niaekojkrko l]n]qibeifateopajpa*=paj`j_e]`kejopejpka`kd^epk]nalapekak]qpki]peoik `]onaolkop]o]kolnk^hai]o* =ejpahecj_e]`ebana`kejopejpka`kd^epklknoq]bhate^ehe`]`a(lah]_]l]_e`]`a`a aj_kjpn]njkrkoiaekol]n]qijkrkbei(kq`a]`]lp]niaekoateopajpaol]n]qi]bej]he) `]`ajkr](lah]lkooe^ehe`]`a`aajbnajp]n`ai]jaen]`ebanajpaoepq] aojkr]oaejrajp]n jkr]ookhq aol]n]ah]o(lah]_]l]_e`]`a`aao_khdanajpnarnekoiaekolkooraeoaajpna rnekobejolkooraeo*Jaooajrahlnpe_k(]ejpahecj_e]_]l]v`a_ne]nfkpqorjbkqlp(eopk( `a`]nqi]bqjkjkr]aqioajpe`kjkrk]_keo]ofateopajpao(l]n]mqaoenr]i`aiaeko ]jkrkobejo*
$OKUMENTACIJAß$ELAß !RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
?kil]npehd]iko ] ejpahecj_e] lnpe_] _ki ]hcqjo ]jei]eo( aola_e]hiajpa _ki ko _deil]jvo*Kloe_ hkckGdhanbavatlanej_e]o_ki]hcqjo`aooao]jei]eoa`aikjopnkq mqaan]i_]l]vao`a_kilknp]iajpkoejpahecajpao6 _khk_]`kqi_deil]jvjqi]lamqaj]o]h](l a)oa]oaqh]`kqi_anpkjiank`a _]etkpao a lnaj`a)oa qi] ^]j]j] jk papk* =l o o]hpko ejopejperko $ejbnqpbanko% l]n] ]c]nn]n]^]j]j](k_deil]jv_kjoacqaailehd]nko_]etkpao(oq^enjahaoa]c]nn]nk ]heiajpk7
+yHLER߯ ßUMß DOSßPRINCIPAISßTEvRICOSßDAß PSICOLOGIAßDAß'ESTALT
_khk_]`k qi _deil]jv jqi] lamqaj] o]h]( j]o iaoi]o _en_qjop j_e]o ]jpaneknao( i]o kbana_aj`k ^]i^qo ai rav `a _]etkpao( k _deil]jv paniej] lkn aj_]et]n ko ^]i^qoqjojkokqpnko(bkni]j`kqiejopnqiajpkl]n]]l]jd]n]^]j]j]* Gdhanatlhe_]k_kilknp]iajpk`k_deil]jvikopn]j`kmqaahaoa_kilknp]lan_a) ^aj`kqi_]ilklan_alperkjkmq]h]^]j]j](ko_]etkpaoako^]i^qobkni]iqi]pkp]) he`]`aaoanah]_ekj]i_kikl]npao`aqipk`k(`aik`kmqako_]etkpaokqko^]i^qook lan_a^e`ko_kikl]npao`]l]eo]caia_kikiaekol]n]qibei$]c]nn]n]^]j]j]%* Kb]pk`amqak_deil]jvlan_a^aqi_]ilklan_alperk(ajkk^fapkoeokh]`ko(`a) ikjopn]`kmq]j`k(jkhqc]n`ko^]i^qo(ok_khk_]`ko]n]iao(mqak]jei]hajc]j_d]n qjojkokqpnkol]n]_khdan]bnqp]7kqmq]j`k(jkhqc]n`ko_]etkpao(ok_khk_]`]oiaoejd]o `ap]i]jdko`ebanajpao(mqalk`aioanailehd]`]olahk]jei]hl]n]]c]nn]n]^]j]j]* Jkajp]jpk(k^oanr])oa]hckejpanaoo]jpa*@alkeo`a_kian]^]j]j](k_deil]jvj]`] b]v_kiko_]etkpao(ko^]i^qo(ko]n]iaokq]oiao]o*Be_]ioq]rkhp]_kikk^fapkooai oajpe`k*=k_kjpnnek(qi]_ne]j]j]oiaoi]o_en_qjop j_e]o(`alkeo`a_kjoacqen]l]jd]n qi`k_a(lknatailhk(at]iej]nkok^fapko*Oa`ao_k^nenmqaok`aoikjpraeo(ah]pajp]n b]van(_kiko_]etkpaoa]oiao]o(qi]ao_]`](a_kiko^]i^qoako]n]iao(qi]na`a* Aoo]`ebanaj]jko_kilknp]iajpko`k_deil]jva`]_ne]j]narah]mqaaop]hpei] qhpn]l]oo] ] oepq]k eia`e]p] `a bkia a `a qok `enapk `ko k^fapko a lnar qi] oepq]k bqpqn]l]n]]mq]haj_kjpn]qi]okhqk(pn]jobkni]j`kkok^fapkoaiejopnqiajpkolnk) lne]iajpa`epko* =_ne]j]^kqb`fm^qi]oepq]kaqo^kpcloj^ko`]`ko`aqi]oepq]klnaoajpa(b]^ne) _]j`kiaekol]n]_anpkobejomqa]ej`]aopk]qoajpao*Ah]pbibj_o^`]oepq]kl]oo]`](bpmb* o^]oepq]kbqpqn](lod^kfw^]oepq]klnaoajpa_ki^]oajko`]`kohai^n]`ko(aolan]`koa lan_a^e`ko(fj^dfk^qi]oepq]kjkr]anaolkj`a]ah](iaoikmqa]ej`]aopaf]]qoajpa* =_ne]j]oanah]_ekj]_kikpailkapn]jobkni]oaqaol]klknaoo]nah]kpailkn]h* =_ne]j]obmobpbkq^oaqiqj`ka^qr^ln]pe_]iajpaok^naaha*Oq]ejpahecj_e]`ebana(lkn) p]jpk(`]`k]jei]h*
(ULTONß!RCHIVE+EYSTONE'ETTYß)MAGES
Ejpahec j_e]ahejcq]cai
J
kokiko`kp]`ko]laj]o`aejpahecj_e]lnpe_]kqejopnqiajp]h(i]op]i^i`a ejpahecj_e]pa ne_]a]^opn]p]*Lajo]iko* Katan__ek`]ejpahecj_e]_kiklajo]iajpkejoal]nrah`]hejcq]cai(_kikfreiko( lkeo]hejcq]caikmqajkolaniepaaop]^aha_annah] ao(_kj_a^)h]oa_kilnaaj`)h]o* Cn]]oooecjebe_] aobp`^a^aobab(]_ne]j]lk`alajo]njaooaok^fapkoab]^ne_)hko* =hejcq]cai]npe_qh]lan_al aoaiai ne]o(lan_al aoaei]cej] ao(kbana_aj`k]k lajo]iajpkqibhqtkpailkn]hmqa_kjoanr]aejpanhec]]oe`ae]o* Kloe_ hkckLe]cap(]kaopq`]n]cjaoa`]ejpahecj_e]j]o_ne]j]o(ikopnkq_kik] ]mqeoek `] hejcq]cai a ] `k lajo]iajpk _]iejd]i fqjp]o* =ooei( lkn atailhk( qi] iajej]`a0]jko]ej`]jk_]l]v`alajo]nnah] aonaranoraeokqna_lnk_]olknmqajk `kiej]]hejcq]cai`aooapelk`anah]k*Oaoalancqjp]n]ah]6ÎRk_paiqienik;Ï(ah] naolkj`an6ÎOeiÏ* Oa _kjpejq]niko ] lancqjp]n6ÎMqai k oaq enik;Ï( ah] naolkj`an6
0IAGET߯ ß CRIADORßDAßEPISTEMOLOGIAß GENmTICA ßDEDICOU SEßß gßLOGICA ßgßBIOLOGIA ßß gßPSICOLOGIAßEßgßFILOSOFIA
.,,
Klajo]iajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
ÎLa`nejdkÏ*Jkajp]jpk(oahdalancqjp]niko6ÎLa`nejdkpaiqi]eni;Ï(ah]`en6ÎJkÏ(lkeo ]hejcq]caimqaah]lkooqelaniepa)hdaaop]^aha_annah] aoajpnaah]akiqj`k(i]ojk ajpnakiqj`kaah]* =ejpahecj_e]dqi]j](_kik]pere`]`aiajp]ha`ahejcq]cai(lk`aoan`abeje`]_kik ]_]l]_e`]`al]n]ajbnajp]nkq_khk_]n`e]jpa`aoelnk^hai]olnpe_koapa ne_ko(l]n]ko mq]eoaj_kjpn](ah]^kn]kq_kj_a^aokhq ao(oaf]lah]_ne]k`aejopnqiajpkolnpe_ko$]o p_je_]o%(oaf]lah]_ne]k`aoecjebe_] ao$e`ae]oa_kj_aepko%*?]n]_panev])oalah]bhate^ehe) `]`a(lh]ope_e`]`aaejkr]k(^ai_kiklah]lkooe^ehe`]`a`apn]jobkni]n]ln lne]na]he) `]`a$pn]^]hdk(]npao(p_je_]o(] aolkhpe_]o(ap_*%*=ejpahecj_e]oana]hev](lknp]jpk(_kik _kjda_eiajpka]k* K_kjda_eiajpkejpahecajpa]lnaaj`akoajpe`k`]ol]h]rn]o(ejpanlnap])k(ejrajp]jk) rkooajpe`kol]n]l]h]rn]o]jpec]okq_ne]jkr]ol]h]rn]ol]n]jkrkooajpe`ko*Kikreiajpk `k_kjda_an(lkeo(qiikreiajpk_qfk_knlk]hejcq]cai*Cn]]o]ah](_kil]npehd]iko _kikqpnkokojkooko_kjda_eiajpkoana_a^aiko`akqpnkoko_kjda_eiajpko* ?kiqje_]k( ejbkni]k( iai ne] _qhpqn]h( pn]joieook( ejkr]k a nqlpqn]6 aeo k mqa]hejcq]cailaniepaejpahecj_e]*?h]nebe_]k(knc]jev]k(kn`aj]iajpk(]jheoa(ej) panlnap]k(_kilnaajok(ojpaoa(]npe_qh]k6aeokmqa]ejpahecj_e]kbana_ahejcq]cai*
Ejpahec j_e]alajo]iajpk
=
JUqZOßCOMOßJfßVIMOS ßOß JUqZOßRELACIONAßPOSITIVAßOUß NEGATIVAMENTEßUMßSUJEI TOß3ßEßUMßPREDICADOßOUß CONJUNTOßDEßPREDICADOSß0ß 3ßmß0ß3ßNjOßmß0ß4AMBmMß RELACIONAß3ßEß0ßNECESSA RIAMENTEß±3vCRATESßmß MORTAL²ßACIDENTALMENTEß ±3vCRATESßmßPEQUENO²ß POSSIVELMENTEß±3vCRATESß PODERfßVIRßgßPRAlA² ß±3Eß NjOßCHOVER ß3vCRATESßVIRfßgß PRAlA² ßETC
.,-
ejpahecj_e]_khda(na_khdaanajako`]`kokbana_e`kolah]lan_alk(lah]ei]cej]) k(lah]iai ne]alah]hejcq]cai(bkni]j`kna`ao`aoecjebe_] ao_ki]omq]eo knc]jev]ikoakn`aj]ikojkookiqj`kajkoo]re`](na_a^aj`ka`]j`koajpe`k] ahao*Klajo]iajpk(lkni(r]e]hi`kpn]^]hdk`]ejpahecj_e]6]^opn]e$kqoaf](oal]n]%ko `]`ko`]o_kj`e aoeia`e]p]o`ajkoo]atlanej_e]akoah]^kn]ok^]bkni]`a_kj_aepko( e`ae]oafqvko(aop]^aha_aj`k]npe_qh] aoejpanj]oaja_aoone]oajpnaahaolahkn]_ek_jek $ej`qka`a`qk%(lah]]jheoaalah]ojpaoa*Bkniqh]pakne]o(lnk_qn]lnkr)h]oaranebe) _)h]o(lkeoaoprkhp]`kl]n]]ran`]`a`k_kjda_eiajpk* Qi_kj_aepkkqqi]e`ae]qi]na`a`aoecjebe_] aomqajkokbana_a6koajpe`kej) panjkaaooaj_e]h`]mqehk]mqaoanabana7kojatko_]qo]eokq]onah] aoja_aoone]oajpna oaqoahaiajpko(`aoknpamqalknahao_kjda_aiko]knecai(kolnej_leko(]o_kjoamqj_e]o( ]o_]qo]oakoabaepko`]mqehk]mqaoanabana*K_kj_aepkkqe`ae]jkokbana_a]aooj_e])oec) jebe_]kja_aoone]`a]hcqi]_keo](oq]knecaikq_]qo](oq]o_kjoamqj_e]okqoaqoabaepko( oaqik`k`aoana`a]cen* =ooei(lknatailhk(rafknko]o(i]nc]ne`]o(cen]oo eo*I]o_kj_a^klahklajo]iajpk k_kj_aepkkq]e`ae]qjerano]h`abhkn*Oejpk_knlkomqajpao(iknjko(bneko(cah]`ko(oejpkk bnek`]jara(k_]hkn`kOkh(]pale`av]cn]`rah`]cq]`ki]nkq`]leo_ej]*I]o_kj_a^k lahklajo]iajpkk_kj_aepkkq]e`ae]`apailan]pqn]*Rafkqi]^kh](jk_kjfqjpkiqoe_]h pk_kqipne jcqhk(ao_narkok^naqi]iao]_qfkp]ilkpaimq]pnkh]`koecq]eo*I]olahk lajo]iajpk_kj_a^kk_kj_aepkkq]e`ae]`aaoban]kq_n_qhk(`apne jcqhk(`amq]`n]`k* Rkq]hi6lahklqnklajo]iajpk(bkniqhkk_kj_aepk`abecqn]cakipne_]a`]ohaeomqa] nacai(ah]^kn]j`k]teki]o(lkopqh]`koapaknai]o* Ko_kj_aepkokqe`ae]ookna`ao`aoecjebe_] ao_qfkojatkokqhec] aookatlnaooko lahklajo]iajpklkniaek`kofqvko(lahkomq]eoaop]^aha_aikokoahkoejpanjkoaja_ao) onekoajpnaqioana]omq]he`]`ao(]olnklnea`]`ao(ko]pne^qpkomqahdalanpaj_ai(]ooei _kik ]mqahao lna`e_]`ko mqa hda ok ]_e`ajp]eo a mqa lk`ai oan napen]`ko oai mqa eook ]bapakoajpe`ka]na]he`]`a`aqioan* Qi_kjfqjpk`afqvko_kjopepqeqi]pakne](mq]j`k6 aop]^aha_a)oa_ki_h]nav]qi_]ilk`ak^fapkoakolnk_a`eiajpkol]n]_kjda_)hkoa ajqj_e)hko7 knc]jev]i)oaakn`aj]i)oako_kj_aepko7
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
]npe_qh]i)oaa`aikjopn]i)oakofqvko(ranebe_]j`koaq]_kn`k_kinacn]oalnej_leko `an]_ekj]he`]`aa`aikjopn]k* Pakne]atlhe_]k(`ao_nekaejpanlnap]kcan]h`]o_]qo]o(bkni]o(ik`]he`]`aoa nah] ao`aqi_]ilk`ak^fapko(_kjda_e`kocn]]o]lnk_a`eiajpkoaola_be_ko(ln lneko `]j]pqnav]`kok^fapkoejraopec]`ko* Klajo]iajpkah]^kn]pakne]o(kqoaf](qi]atlhe_]kkqejpanlnap]kejpaha_pq]h`a qi_kjfqjpk`abajiajkoaoecjebe_] ao$k^fapko(b]pko(oepq] ao(]_kjpa_eiajpko%(mqa aop]^aha_a]j]pqnav](kr]hkna]ran`]`a`ap]eobajiajko*Lkneookb]h]ikoaipakne]`] nah]pere`]`a(pakne]cajpe_](pakne]]neopkphe_](pakne]loe_]j]hpe_](ap_*Qi]pakne]lk`akq jkj]o_an`enap]iajpa`aqi]lnpe_]apankqjkqi]]lhe_]klnpe_]`enap](i]ojk ]lnpe_]mqalaniepa`apaniej]n]ran`]`akqb]hoe`]`apa ne_]aoei_nepnekoejpanjko ln lne]pakne]$oaf]oq]_knnaolkj`j_e]_ki]o_keo]opaknev]`]o(oaf]]_kanj_e]ejpan) j]`aoaqo]ncqiajpko(oaqon]_ek_jeko(oq]o`aikjopn] aoaoq]olnkr]o(oaf](ajbei(] _kjoeopj_e]h ce_]`aoq]ooecjebe_] ao%*=lnpe_]kneajp]kpn]^]hdkpa ne_k(ranebe_]oq]o _kj_hqo ao(i]ojk`apaniej]oq]ran`]`akqb]hoe`]`a* Klajo]iajpklnkl aaah]^kn]pakne]oa_ne]i pk`ko*
=ja_aooe`]`a`kipk`k
Q
o]nqiipk`koacqennacqh]nakn`aj]`]iajpaqi_]iejdk]pn]ro`kmq]h qi_anpkk^faperk]h_]j]`k*Jk_]ok`k_kjda_eiajpk(k_]iejdkkn`aj]) `kmqaklajo]iajpkoacqalkniaek`aqi_kjfqjpk`anacn]oalnk_a`eiaj) pkon]_ekj]eo(_kipnobej]he`]`ao6 -*
MmTODOßAßPALAVRAßß MmTODOßVEMßDOßGREGOßß METHODOS ßFORMADAßPORß METAß±ATRAVmSßDE² ß±PORß MEIOßDE² ßEßPORßHODOSß ±VIA² ß±CAMINHO²
_kj`qven`ao_k^anp]`aqi]ran`]`a]pajpk`ao_kjda_e`]7
.* laniepen]`aikjopn]ka]lnkr]`aqi]ran`]`af_kjda_e`]7 /* laniepen]ranebe_]k`a_kjda_eiajpkol]n]]ranecq]noaokkqjkran`]`aenko* Kipk`k(lknp]jpk(qiejopnqiajpkn]_ekj]hl]n]]`mqenen(`aikjopn]nkqranebe_]n _kjda_eiajpko* Lknmqaoaoajpa]ja_aooe`]`a`aqiipk`k;Lknmqa(_kikreiko(kannk(]ehqok(k b]hok(]iajpen]nkj`]ik_kjda_eiajpk(ejpanbanaij]atlanej_e]ajklajo]iajpk*L]n] `]noacqn]j]]k_kjda_eiajpk(klajo]iajpk_ne]nacn]oalnk_a`eiajpkomqalaniepai ]koqfaepk_kcjko_ajpa]banena_kjpnkh]npk`kokol]ookomqana]hev]jk_kjda_eiajpk`a ]hcqik^fapkkq_kjfqjpk`ak^fapko* =behkokbe]_kjda_aq`ebanajpao_kj_al ao`aipk`k* Lh]pk(lknatailhk(_kjoe`an]r]mqakiahdkn_]iejdkl]n]k_kjda_eiajpkran`]) `aenkan]kmqalaniepe]]klajo]iajpkhe^anp]n)oa`k_kjda_eiajpkoajorah$_naj]o(kle) je ao%(eopk(`]oei]cajoa]l]nj_e]o`]o_keo]o*=pne^q]aooal]lahhe^an]`kn`eo_qook n]_ekj]h(j]bkni]`k`ehkck* Jk`ehkck(koejpanhk_qpknao(cqe]`kolah]olancqjp]o`kbeh okbk$jk_]ok(O _n]pao%( at]iej]ia`eo_qpaikleje aomqa_]`]qi`ahaolkooqeok^na]hcqi]ooqjpk7`ao_k^nai mqaoq]okleje aook_kjpn]`ep ne]oajkhar]i]_kjda_eiajpk]hcqi*=_aep]i]^]j`k) j)h]oa_kjoacqai(lkq_k]lkq_k(_dac]ne`ae]qjerano]hkqaooj_e]`]_keo]lnk_qn]) `]*Lknoapn]p]n`aqi_kjbnkjpkajpnaei]cajoakleje ao_kjpnne]okq_kjpn]`ep ne]o(aooa ipk`kkq_]iejdkan]_d]i]`klknLh]pk`a`e]h pe_]$`eo_qook`apaoao_kjpnne]oaai _kjbhepkkqklkoek%* =neop pahao(jkajp]jpk(_kjoe`ankq]`e]hpe_]ej]`amq]`]]klajo]iajpk(lkeo(`eve] aha(p]hlnk_a`eiajpkhe`]_kiian]okleje aolnkrraeo(jkkbana_aj`kjajdqi]c]n]jpe] `amqapajd]ikooqlan]`kk_kjbhepk`akleje aoa]h_]j]`k]aooj_e]ran`]`aen]`]_keo] ejraopec]`]*Lknaooaikperk(`abejeqklnk_a`eiajpkbehko be_k)_eajpbe_k_kikqiipk`k
6ERß5NIDADEß ßCAPqTULOß
.,.
Klajo]iajpkx#!0É45,/ßx 6ERß5NIDADEß ßCAPqTULOß
`aikjopn]perkmqaoana]hev]lkniaek`aoehkceoiko*Koehkceoikqi_kjfqjpk`apno fqvkokqlnklkoe aomqalaniepak^panqi]_kj_hqokran`]`aen]*Pn]p])oa`aqiipk`k `a`qperkjkmq]h(`a`q]olnaieoo]o(`a`qv)oaqi]_kj_hqok*Lknatailhk6 Pk`kokodkiajookiknp]eo* O _n]paodkiai* Hkck(O _n]paoiknp]h*
ESTRUTURALISMOßMmTODOß DEßANfLISEßNAßETNOLOGIA ß ANTROPOLOGIA ßFILOSOFIA ß SOCIOLOGIA ßECONOMIAß EßTEORIAßLITERfRIA ßQUEß INVESTIGAßUMßFENxMENOß BUSCANDOßSUASßESTRUTURASß PROFUNDASß%STUDOßDEßß UMAßCATEGORIAßDEßFATOSß QUEßENFOCAßESPECIALMENTEß ASßESTRUTURAS
.,/
=neop pahao_kjoe`an]r](lkni(mqakok^fapkomqaok_kjda_e`kolknatlanej_e](a jko lahklqnklajo]iajpk(`arane]ioacqenqiipk`kej`qperk(jkmq]hkoehkceoik oane]knaoqhp]`k]h_]j]`klahk_kjda_eiajpk* ?kikreikojklneiaenk_]lpqhk`aop]Qje`]`a(`qn]jpa]ik`anje`]`a$eopk(]l]n) pen `k o_qhk TREE%( ] ja_aooe`]`a `a qi ipk`k pknjkq)oa ]ej`] i]eo eilaneko] `k mqa ]jpao(lkeo(_kikreiko(koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkjko]^aoalk`a]h_]j]n]ran`]`a* Reikop]i^imqal]n]koik`anjko(kipk`klaniepaqi]nabkni]`]ejpahecj_e](kba) na_anacn]ol]n]kpn]^]hdk`klajo]iajpka]ooacqn]]]ilhe]k`ko_kjda_eiajpko* Kipk`k(j]orne]obkniqh] aomqana_a^aqjk_knnan`]deop ne]`]behkokbe]a`]o _ej_e]o(oailnaparakl]lah`aqiobdri^alo`klajo]iajpk(eopk(`aranebe_]`kna]r]he]) `kn`]oe`ae]oapakne]o6cqe]kpn]^]hdkejpaha_pq]h$lnk`qk`]oe`ae]o(`koatlaneiajpko( `]opakne]o%a]r]he]konaoqhp]`kok^pe`ko* @ao`a =neop pahao( ] behkokbe] _kjoe`an] mqa( ]k h]`k `a qi ipk`k can]h mqa pk`k a mq]hmqan _kjda_eiajpk `ara oacqen( p]jpk l]n] ] ]mqeoek _kik l]n] ] `aikjopn]k a ranebe_]k`aran`]`ao(kqpnkoipk`kol]npe_qh]naookja_aooneko(lkeokok^fapko]oa) nai_kjda_e`kop]i^iatecaiipk`komqaaopaf]iai_kjbknie`]`a_kiahaoa(]ooei( d]ran`ebanajpaoipk`ko_kjbknia]aola_ebe_e`]`a`kk^fapk]oan_kjda_e`k*@aoo]i]) jaen](ok`ebanajpaoajpnaoekoipk`ko`]cakiapne]a`]boe_](`]^ekhkce]a`]ok_ekhkce]( `]deop ne]a`]mqie_](a]ooeilkn`e]jpa* ejpanaoo]jpajkp]n(pk`]re](mqa(ai_anpkolank`ko`]deop ne]`]behkokbe]a`]o_ej) _e]o(_dackq)oa]lajo]njqiipk`kje_kmqakbana_ane]koiaoikolnej_lekoa]oiao) i]onacn]ol]n]pk`koko_]ilko`k_kjda_eiajpk*=ooei(lknatailhk(C]hehaqfqhckqmqa kipk`ki]paipe_k`arane]oanqo]`kaipk`koko_kjda_eiajpko`]j]pqnav](lkeo(`eve] aha(Î]j]pqnav]qihernkao_nepkai_]n]_panaoi]paipe_koÏ* @ao_]npao( ej`k i]eo hkjca mqa C]hehaq( fqhckq mqa qi o a iaoik ipk`k `arane] oanailnac]`klah]behkokbe]alknpk`]o]o_ej_e]o(qi]j^qebpfprkfsbop^ifp(kqk_kjda) _eiajpk`]loabjja_aoone]`]oe`ae]o(rhe`]l]n]pk`kokok^fapko`a_kjda_eiajpk*?k) jda_anoane]kn`aj]naaj_]`a]naijatko_kjpjqko]oe`ae]onabanajpao]qik^fapkap]h lnk_a`eiajpk`arane]oankiaoikaipk`koko_kjda_eiajpkolknmqaaooakik`kln ) lnek`klajo]iajpk(oaf]mq]hbknkk^fapk]oan_kjda_e`k* Kobeh okbkoa_eajpeop]o`kbej]h`ko_qhkTETp]i^i]beni]r]imqaqije_kipk) `k`arane]oanoacqe`k*Ajpqoe]oi]`ko_kik`aoajrkhreiajpk`]boe_](fqhc]n]imqapk`ko ko_]ilko`ko]^an`arane]iailnac]nkipk`kqo]`klah]Î_ej_e]`]j]pqnav]Ï(iaoik mq]j`kkk^fapkbkooakdkiai*=ckn](jkan]p]jpk]e`ae]`akn`aj]iajpkejpanjk`]o e`ae]omqahar]r]`abao]`aqije_kipk`k`a_kjda_eiajpk(i]o]e`ae]`]_]qo]he`]`a kq`aatlhe_]k_]qo]h`apk`kokob]pko(bkooaiahaoj]pqn]eokqdqi]jko* Jko_qhkTT(lkni(ok^napq`k_ki]bajkiajkhkce]`aDqooanha_ki]_knnajpa`k lajo]iajpk_kjda_e`]_kikaopnqpqn]heoik(l]ookq)oa]_kjoe`an]nmqa_]`]_]ilk`k_k) jda_eiajpk`ar]panoaqipk`kln lnek(`apaniej]`klah]j]pqnav]`kk^fapk(lah]bkni] _kikkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpklk`a]lnktei]n)oa`aooak^fapkalahk_kj_aepk`aran`]`a mqa_]`]aoban]`k_kjda_eiajpk`abejal]n]oeln lne]* =ooei(lknatailhk(_kjoe`an])oakipk`ki]paipe_k(eopk(`a`qperk(ln lnekl]n] k^fapkomqaateopai]laj]oe`a]hiajpaamqaok_kjopnq`koejpaen]iajpalahkjkooklaj) o]iajpk7]k_kjpnnek(kipk`katlaneiajp]h(eopk(ej`qperk(ln lnek`]o_ej_e]oj]pq) n]eo(mqak^oanr]ioaqok^fapkoana]hev]iatlaneiajpko*
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
F]o_ej_e]odqi]j]opiipk`ko`a_kilnaajoka`aejpanlnap]k`koajpe`k `]o] ao(`]olnpe_]o(`ko_kilknp]iajpko(`]oejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o(`kooajpe) iajpko(`ko`aoafko(`]opn]jobkni] aodeop ne_]o(lkeokdkiai(k^fapk`aoo]o_ej_e]o( qioandeop ne_k)_qhpqn]hmqalnk`qv]oejopepqe aoakoajpe`k`ah]o*P]hoajpe`kkmqa lna_eo]oan_kjda_e`k* Jk_]ok`]o_ej_e]oat]p]o$]oi]paipe_]o%(kipk`k`a`qperkp]i^i_d]i]`k ]tekipe_k(eopk(^]oae]k_kjda_eiajpkjqi_kjfqjpk`apanikolneieperkoa`a]teki]o ej`aikjopnraeo(mqaokklkjpk`al]npe`]`]_kjopnqka`aikjopn]k`kok^fapko* Jk_]ok`]o_ej_e]oj]pqn]eo$boe_](mqie_](^ekhkce](ap_*%(kipk`kej`qperkp]i^i _d]i]`katlaneiajp]hadelkp pe_k*Atlaneiajp]hlknmqaoa^]oae]aik^oanr] aoa aiatlaneiajpko(p]jpkl]n]bkniqh]nmq]jpkl]n]ranebe_]n]opakne]o*Delkppe_klknmqa ko_eajpeop]ol]npai`adel paoaook^nakok^fapkomqacqe]ikoatlaneiajpkoa]]r]he]k `konaoqhp]`ko* Jk_]ok`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o$loe_khkce](ok_ekhkce](]jpnklkhkce](deop ne](ap_*%(ki) pk`k_d]i]`k_kilnaajoerk)ejpanlnap]perklknmqaoaqk^fapkok]ooecjebe_] aokqko oajpe`ko`ko_kilknp]iajpko(`]olnpe_]oa`]oejopepqe aona]hev]`]okqlnk`qve`]olahko oanaodqi]jko* Mq]jpkbehkokbe](ai^kn]kobeh okbkopajd]iko_eh]`kajpnarnekoipk`kolkooraeo( ]pq]hiajpamq]pnkpn]kook_kiqjo]ko`ebanajpaoipk`kobehko be_ko6 -*
kipk`kobcibufslÍl]npa`]]qpk]jheoakq`k]qpk_kjda_eiajpk`klajo]iajpk7
.* `oqf`l Í ejraopec] ko bqj`]iajpko a ]o _kj`e ao ja_aoone]o `] lkooe^ehe`]`a `k _kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk(`]]kpe_](`]_ne]k]npope_]a`]]pere`]`alkhpe_]7 /* abp`ofqfslÍ`ao_nara]oaopnqpqn]oejpanj]okqaooj_e]o`a_]`]_]ilk`ak^fapko`k _kjda_eiajpka`]obkni]o`a]kdqi]j]7 0* fkqbomobq^qfslÍ^qo_]]obkni]o`]hejcq]caia]ooecjebe_] aokqkooajpe`ko`ko k^fapko(`kob]pko(`]olnpe_]oa`]oejopepqe ao(oq]oknecajoapn]jobkni] ao*
Lajo]iajpkipe_kalajo]iajpkhce_k
J
k_]lpqhk]jpanekn(reikomqa]hjcq]cnac]lkooq]`q]ol]h]rn]ol]n]nabanen)oa hejcq]cai6jvqelpaidlp*Reikop]i^i(p]jpkjkaopq`k`]hejcq]cai_kikjk `]ejpahecj_e](mqak]pk`ab]h]nak]pk`alajo]nokejoal]nraeo*Lkneookiaoik( lk`aikonabanen)jko]`q]oik`]he`]`ao`klajo]iajpk(_kjbknialna`kiejakjvqelp kqkidlp* =pn]`ekbehko be_](ok^napq`k]l]npen`ko_qhkTREEE$_ki]behkokbe]`]Ehqopn]k%a `ko_qhkTET$_ki]behkokbe]`]deop ne]`aDacahaklkoepereoik`a=qcqopk?kipa%(]ben) i]r]mqa`kiepkh ce_]d]re]qi]arkhqk`kaolnepkdqi]jk(eopk(kiepkan]qi] b]oakqap]l]`kaolnepkdqi]jka`]_erehev]kmqa]jpa_a`e]k]`rajpk`]h ce_]kq`k lajo]iajpkh ce_k(_kjoe`an]`k]ap]l]lkopaneknaarkhq`]`klajo]iajpka`]_erehev]k* Aoo]pn]`ekbehko be_]bav_nanmqakiepklanpaj_ane]]_qhpqn]oÎejbaneknaoÏ(Îlneieper]oÏkq Î]pn]o]`]oÏ(ajmq]jpkklajo]iajpkh ce_kkqn]_ekj]hlanpaj_ane]]_qhpqn]oÎoqlaneknaoÏ( Î_erehev]`]oÏaÎ]`e]jp]`]oÏ* Aoo]oal]n]kpailkn]haarkhqper]`a`q]oik`]he`]`ao`alajo]iajpkb]ve]_kimqa oafqhc]ooa]lnaoaj](aijkoo]ook_ea`]`ao(`aatlhe_] aoipe_]o$eopk(]onahece ao(]hepa) n]pqn](]o]npao%_kikqi]aol_ea`aÎnao`qkÏkqÎnaopkÏ`aqi]b]oal]oo]`]`]arkhqk `]dqi]je`]`a(`aopej]`]]`ao]l]na_an_ki]lhaj]arkhqk`]n]_ekj]he`]`a_eajpbe_] abehko be_]* Dkfa(lkni(o]^a)oamqa]_kj_alkarkhqper]aopamqerk_]`]amqaklajo]iajpk _kj_aepq]haklajo]iajpkipe_klk`ai_kateopenjqi]iaoi]ok_ea`]`a*Aopq`ko`a]j)
.,0
Klajo]iajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
!NNEMIEKß6ELDMAN+IPAß #ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
pnklkhkce]ok_e]h(mqaaopq`]koiepko`]ook_ea`]`ao`ep]ooahr]cajoap]i^i]oiepkhk) ce]o`ajkoo]ook_ea`]`ao(`ep]o_erehev]`]o(ikopn]n]imqa(jk_]ok`ajkoo]ook_ea`]`ao(] lnaoaj]oeiqhp ja]`klajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]ha`klajo]iajpkipe_k`a_knna`kik`k _kik]ei]cej]kok_e]hpn]jobkni]aiiepk]mqehkmqaklajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]hah]^kn] j]o _ej_e]o a j] behkokbe]* >]op] ran k _]npan ice_k)i]n]rehdkok `]`k ]ko o]phepao( ]ko ]qpi]pko(]ko_kilqp]`knaol]n]_kjop]p]niko]l]oo]cai`]_ej_e]]kiepk* Jkajp]jpk(aopq`ko`ajaqnkhkce]a`]]jheoa`]]j]pkie]a`]beoekhkce]`k_na^nk dqi]jk ikopn]i mqa aooa nck lkooqe `q]o l]npao( kq `keo daieobneko7 ai qi `ahao hk_]hev])oa]hejcq]caiaklajo]iajpkoei^ he_koa]baperko$lnklajoko]ki]n]rehdkok aei]cej]k_ne]`kn]%a(jkkqpnk(]hejcq]caiaklajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]eo*?anp]olao) ok]o(_kikko]npeop]o(`aoajrkhraii]eokdaieobnekoei^ he_ka]baperk(ajmq]jpkkqpn]o( _kikko_eajpeop]o(`aoajrkhraii]eokdaieobnek_kj_aepq]hah ce_k* =ooei(]lna`kiej j_e]`aqi]kqkqpn]bkni]`klajo]iajpk`alaj`a(`aqih]`k( `]opaj`j_e]olaook]eoa`]deop ne]`are`]`koej`er`qkoa(`akqpnk(`kik`k_kikqi] ok_ea`]`a kq qi] _qhpqn] na_knnai i]eo ] qi] `k mqa kqpn] bkni] l]n] ejpanlnap]n ] na]he`]`a(ejpanrenjkiqj`kaatlhe_]n)oa]oeiaoi]*
,mVI 3TRAUSS߯ ß ANTROPvLOGOßEßFILvSOFOß BELGA ßUMßDOSßPRINCIPAISß EXPOENTESßDOßESTRUTURALIS MOßFRANCoSß&OIßPROFESSORß NAß5NIVERSIDADEßDEß3jOß 0AULOß530 ßDEßßAß ßEßREALIZOUßPESQUISASß ANTROPOLvGICASßCOMßqNDIOSß BOROROSßEßNHAMBIQUARASß ENTREßßEß
K
]jpnkl hkck?h]q`aHre)Opn]qoo aopq`kq k Îlajo]iajpk oahr]) caiÏ l]n] ikopn]n mqa ko _d]) i]`kooahr]cajojkok]pn]o]`kojai lneieperko(]laj]oklan]i_kiklajo]) iajpkipe_k* ÎK iepk a k nepkÏ( ao_nara Hre) )Opn]qoo(Îjkokoeilhaohaj`]ob]^qhk) o]o(i]oqi]knc]jev]k`]na]he`]`a] l]npen`]atlanej_e]oajorahajmq]jpk p]hÏ* L]n] atlhe_]n ] _kilkoek `a qi iepk(Hre)Opn]qoooanabana]qi]]pere) `]`a mqa ateopa ai jkoo] ok_ea`]`a a mqa(aibn]j_o(oa_d]i]_of`li^db*
,EBRECHTß-USICßß!RTS#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
?kikkiepkbqj_ekj]
Ehqopn]k`]deop ne] `kNae=npqn(becqn] haj`ne]^nepje_]*
.,1
Mqailn]pe_]_of`li^dblnk`qvqik^fapkjkrk]l]npen`ala`]koabn]ciajpko`a kqpnkok^fapko*R]enaqjej`k(oaiqilh]jkiqepknce`k(pq`kkmqaaj_kjpn]amqaoanra l]n]kk^fapkmqaaop_kilkj`k*Klajo]iajpkipe_kb]vat]p]iajpa]iaoi]_keo](eopk ( r]e naqjej`k ]o atlanej_e]o( ]o j]nn]per]o( ko nah]pko( ]p _kilkn qi iepk can]h* ?ki aooaoi]pane]eodapankcjakolnk`qv]atlhe_]kok^na]knecaia]bkni]`]o_keo]o(oq]o bqj aoaoq]obej]he`]`ao(kolk`anao`erejkook^na]j]pqnav]aok^nakodqi]jko*Kiepk lkooqe(]ooei(pno_]n]_panope_]olnej_el]eo6
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
-*
crk lbumif`^qfs^6klnaoajpaatlhe_]`klkn]hcqi]]kl]oo]`]_qfkoabaepkolan) i]ja_an]ijkpailk*Lknatailhk(qi]_kjopah]kateopalknmqa(jkl]oo]`k(_ne]j) ]obqceper]oab]iejp]oiknnan]ij]bhknaop]abkn]ihar]`]o]k_qlknqi]`aqo] mqa]opn]jobknikqaiaopnah]o7]o_dqr]oateopailknmqa(jkopailkol]oo]`ko(qi] `aqo]]l]etkjkq)oalknqidqi]jka(jklk`aj`kqjen)oa]aha`enap]iajpa(qjeq)oa lah]pneopav](b]vaj`koq]ohcnei]o_]naiok^nakiqj`k(ap_*7
.* crk llod^kfw^qfs^6kiepkknc]jev]]onah] aook_e]eo$`al]najpao_k(`a]he]j]o(`a pnk_]o(`aoatk(`ae`]`a(`alk`an(ap_*%`aik`k]hacepei]nac]n]jpen]lani]jj_e] `aqioeopai]_kilhatk`alnke^e aoalanieoo ao*Lknatailhk(qiiepk_kikk`a `elkateopa$_kij]nn]per]o`ebanajpao%aimq]oapk`]o]ook_ea`]`aooahr]cajoapai ]bqjk`ac]n]jpen]lnke^ek`kej_aopk(oai]mq]hkoeopai]ok_eklkhpe_k(^]oa]`k j]ohaeo`al]najpao_ka`a]he]j]o(jklk`aoani]jpe`k7 /* crk l`ljmbkp^qof^6kiepkj]nn]qi]oepq]kl]oo]`](mqa]jac]k`klnaoajpa amqaoanrap]jpkl]n]_kilajo]nkodqi]jko`a]hcqi]lan`]_kikl]n]c]n]jpen) )hdao mqa qi annk l]oo]`k bke _knnece`k jk lnaoajpa( `a ik`k ] kbana_an qi] reok aop]^ehev]`]anacqh]nev]`]`]j]pqnav]a`]re`]_kiqjepne]* Lknatailhk(ajpnakoiepkocnacko(aj_kjpn])oak`]knecai`kbkck(mqaLnkia) paq nkq^kq `k Kheilk l]n] ajpnac]n ]ko iknp]eo a laniepen)hdao k `aoajrkhreiajpk `]op_je_]o*Jqi]`]orano ao`aooaiepk(j]nn])oamqaLnkiapaq`eooa]kodkiajo mqa oa lnkpacaooai `] _ han] `a Vaqo na]hev]j`k k o]_neb_ek `a qi ^ke( i]o mqa oa ikopn]ooaii]eo]opqpko`kmqaaooa`aqo(_kiaj`k]o_]njaoaajre]j`k)hda]opnel]o ackn`qn]o*Vaqo`ao_k^neq]]npei]jd]akodkiajooane]ilqje`ko_ki]lan`]`k bkckoaLnkiapaqjkhdaoajoej]ooaqi]jkr]]npei]jd]6_khk_]nlanbqiaoaej_ajok j]ol]npao`a`e_]`]o]k`aqo* ?kiaooaiepk(j]nn])oakik`k_kikkodqi]jkooa]lnklne]n]i`a]hck`erejk $kbkck%a_ne]n]iqinepq]h$ko]_neb_ek`aqi]jei]h_kilanbqiaoaej_ajok%l]n] _kjoanr]nkmqad]re]inkq^]`k`ko`aqoao* ?kikklan]klajo]iajpkipe_k; =jpao`ai]eoj]`](lah]naqjek`adapankcjako*Kiepknaja(fqjp](nah]_ekj]ab]v ahaiajpko`ebanajpaoadapankcjako]cenaiqjook^nakokqpnko*Lknatailhk(_knlko`a _ne]j]ookaopnah]o(hcnei]o`aqi]`aqo]ok_dqr](k`e]k_]nnk`k`aqo=lkhk(]jkepa ki]jpk`aqi]`aqo](kpailkqi`aqo$j]iepkhkce]cnac](?nkjko%(ap_* Aioacqj`khqc]n(kiepkknc]jev]]na]he`]`a(`]j`ko_keo]o(]kob]pko(oejopepqe ao qioajpe`k]j]h ce_kaiap]b ne_k(eopk(qi]_keo]r]halknkqpn](oq^opepqekqpn](nalna) oajp]kqpn]*Jkiepk`a`elk(lknatailhk(koloakik`k`a]j`]npiqioecjebe_]`k ]j]h ce_k(iap]b ne_kaoei^ he_kiqepklna_eok*H]^`_k(]r`a`elk(mqan`evanÎ_ktkÏ7 H]ek(l]e`a`elk(mqan`evanÎlpknpkÏ7`elkmqan`evanÎlej_d]`kÏ* Aoo]nabanj_e]]koloa]kik`k`a]j`]nqi]nabanj_e]nah]k`kodqi]jko _kikokhka(lknp]jpk(_ki]pann](aoei^khev]kqiap]bknev]qi]mqaopkiqepkcn]ra6ko dqi]jkoj]o_an]i`]pann]kq`]qjek`aqidkiaia`aqi]iqhdan;Oa`]pann](`ara) ne]ioaneiknp]eo*Jkajp]jpk(iknnai*L]n]atlneien]]jcope]`aoanaiiknp]eoakb]pk `akodqi]jko(lknp]jpk(j]o_anai`aqidkiaiaqi]iqhdanajk`]pann](kiepkoei) ^khev]]iknp]he`]`a]pn]ro`]`ebe_qh`]`al]n]oanah]_ekj]n_ki]pann](eopk(l]n]]j`]n $_ktk(pknpk(ej_d]`k%*L]n]atlneien]`ebe_qh`]`a`a]_aep]nqi]knecaidqi]j]iknp]h(k iepkoei^khev]]bn]cehe`]`a`]ohaeodqi]j]ob]vaj`kH]eki]j`]ni]p]noaqbehdk`elk( `elk]oo]ooej]noaql]e(H]ek(a_]o]n)oa_kioq]ia(Fk_]op]* Aipan_aenkhqc]n(kiepkaop]^aha_anah] aoajpnakooanaoj]pqn]eoadqi]jko(oaf] b]vaj`kdqi]jkoj]o_anai(lknatailhk(`a]jei]eo(oaf]b]vaj`kko]opnko`a_e`enai] oknpaak`aopejk`kodqi]jko$_kikj]]opnkhkce]%(oaf]b]vaj`k_knao(iap]eoala`n]o`a) bejenai]j]pqnav]`aqidqi]jk$_kik]i]ce](lknatailhk%* ?keo]oadqi]jkooanah]_ekj]ilknl]npe_el]k(oeil]pe](]jpel]pe](lknbkni]ooa_na) p]o`a]k]`eop j_e]*Kiqj`kqipa_e`k`ah]koarj_qhkooa_napkomqalna_eo]ioan
bDIPOß2EIßQUANDOßbDIPOß NASCE ßUMAßVIDENTE ß4IRm SIAS ßPREVoßQUEßOßMENINOß MATARfßOßPAIßEßSEßCASARfß COMßAßMjEß!PAVORADO ßOß REIß,AIO߯ßOßPAI߯ßMANDAß MATARßbDIPOß/ßESCRAVOß QUEßDEVERIAßMATARßOß MENINOßSENTEßPIEDADEßEß OßLANlAßNUMßPRECIPqCIOß SEMßVERIFICARßSEßELEßESTfß OUßNjOßMORTOßEßENTREGAß AOßREIßOßCORAljOßDEßUMAß CORlA ßCOMOßSEßFOSSEßOß DEßbDIPOß!ßCRIANlAßNjOß MORREßEßmßRECOLHIDAßPORß UMßPASTORß%STE ßPORßSUAß VEZ ßAßENTREGAßAßUMßOUTROß REI ßQUE ßIDOSO ßLAMENTAVAß NjOßTERßFILHOSß!OßCRESCER ß bDIPOßSUSPEITAßQUEßNjOßmß FILHOßDEßSEUSßPAISßADOTIVOSß EßSAIßgßPROCURAßDOSßPAISß VERDADEIROSß.OßCAMINHO ß VoßUMAßBATALHAßENTREßUMß GRUPOßNUMEROSOßEßUMß PEQUENOßCOLOCA SEßAOß LADOßDESTEß{LTIMOßEßMATAß OßCHEFEßDOßOUTROßGRUPOß¯ß SEUßPAI ß,AIOß#HEGANDOß gßSUAßCIDADEßNATAL ßFICAß SABENDOßQUEßUMßMONS TROßESTAVAßDEVORANDOßASß VIRGENSßEßSvßINTERROMPERfß AßMATANlAßSEßALGUmMß DECIFRARßUMßENIGMAßQUEß PROPzEßbDIPOßDECIFRAßOß ENIGMAß#OMOßRECOMPEN SA ßRECEBEßAßRAINHAßEMß CASAMENTOß#ASA SEßCOMß *OCASTA ßSEMßSABERßQUEßSEß TRATAVAßDEßSUAßVERDADEIRAß MjE ßEßCOMßELAßTEMßFILHOSß !ßPROFECIAßSEßCUMPREß!ß CIDADEßSERfßCASTIGADAß COMßAßPESTEßE ßAOßTENTARß COMBATo LA ßPEDINDOßAOSß DEUSESßQUEßLHEßDIGAMßOß QUEßAßCAUSOU ßbDIPOßFICAß SABENDO ßPORß4IRmSIAS ßQUEß MATOUßOßPAIßEßCASOU SEß COMßAßMjEßbDIPOßFURAßOSß OLHOSßEßEXILA SE ßENQUANTOß *OCASTAßSEßSUICIDA
.,2
Klajo]iajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
`a_ebn]`koaok^nakomq]eokodkiajolk`ai]`mqenen]hcqilk`anlkniaek`]eiep]k $raopenlahao`a]jei]eo(b]^ne_]np]heoio(be_]nai_anp]olkoe ao(lh]jp]nb]vaj`k_anpko caopko(lnkjqj_e]n`apaniej]`]ol]h]rn]o%*Kiepk`a_ebn]koa_napk*Knepkeiep]klk`an* =j]hkce]oaiapbkn]obkni]ioi^khko(eopk(ei]cajo_]nnac]`]oao]pqn]`]o`aoaj) pe`ko ihpelhko a oeiqhp jako( oanrej`k l]n] atlhe_]n _keo]o `ebanajpao kq l]n] oq^opepqen qi]_keo]lknkqpn]*=ooei(lknatailhk(qi]iaoi]aje_]_keo]_kikkbkcklk`aoei) ^khev]nqi`aqo(qi]l]etk(_kikk]ikna]_ han]$lknmqaok]n`ajpao%(k_kjda_eiajpk $lknmqaaopaqi]ehqiej]k%(]lqnebe_]k`a]hcqi]_keo]$_kikj]]hmqeie]%(klk`an ok^na]j]pqnav]$lknmqalaniepak`aoajrkhreiajpk`]op_je_]o%(]`ebanaj]ajpnako]je) i]eoakodkiajo$lknmqaaopao_kvaiko]heiajpkoajmq]jpk]mqahaoko_kiai_nqo%(ap_*
?kikbqj_ekj]klajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]h
K
lajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]hkqh ce_kklan]`ai]jaen]`ebanajpaaiaoikklkop]`k lajo]iajpk ipe_k* = lneiaen] a bqj`]iajp]h `ebanaj] aop jk b]pk `a mqa aj) mq]jpkklajo]iajpkipe_kklan]lkn_of`li^db$]ook_e]kanaqjek`abn]ciaj) pkodapankcjako%(klajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]hklan]lknipk`k$lnk_a`eiajpkh ce_kl]n]] ]npe_qh]kn]_ekj]hajpnaahaiajpkodkikcjako%*@aoo]`ebanaj]naoqhp]ikqpn]o6 qi_kj_aepkkqqi]e`ae]jkqi]ei]caijaiqioi^khk(i]oqi]`ao_nek aqi]atlhe_]k`]aooj_e]kqj]pqnav]ln lne]`aqioan(nabanej`k)oa]aooaoana okiajpa]aha7 qi_kj_aepkkqqi]e`ae]jkokoq^opepqpkol]n]]o_keo]o(i]o]_kilnaajokejpa) ha_pq]h`ah]o7 qi_kj_aepkkqqi]e`ae]jkokbkni]o`al]npe_el]kkq`anah]k`ajkookaolne) pkaikqpn]na]he`]`a(i]ookknaoqhp]`k`aqi]]jheoakq`aqi]ojpaoa`ko`]`ko `]na]he`]`akq`kln lneklajo]iajpk7 qifqvkaqin]_ek_jekjklani]ja_aijkjrah`]atlanej_e](jaiknc]jev]i] atlanej_e]jah]iaoi](i]o(l]npej`k`ah](]oeopai]pev]iainah] aon]_ekj]eomqa ]pknj]i_kilnaajorah`klkjpk`areop]h ce_k7 qifqvkaqin]_ek_jek^qo_]i]o_]qo]oqjerano]eoaja_aoone]olah]omq]eoqi] na]he`]`ap]h_kik(`eopejcqej`kkik`k_kikah]jko]l]na_a`kik`k_kikai oeiaoi]7]o_]qo]oakoabaepkookdkikcjako(mqan`evan(ok`aiaoi]j]pqnav]7 qifqvkaqin]_ek_jekaopq`]iaejraopec]i]`ebanaj]ajpnajkoo]orerj_e]ooq^) faper]o(laook]eoa_khaper]o(ako_kjda_eiajpkocan]eoak^faperko(mqaok`apk`koa`a jejcqiail]npe_qh]n*Aop]^aha_ai]`ebanaj]ajpnarerj_e]ooq^faper]oa]aopnqpq) n]k^faper]`klajo]iajpkaican]h7 klajo]iajpkh ce_koq^iapaoaqolnk_a`eiajpko]ipk`ko(eopk(]nacn]o`arane) be_]ka`acajan]hev]k`ko_kjda_eiajpko]`mqene`ko7]nacn]o`akn`aj]iajpka oeopai]pev]k`kolnk_a`eiajpkoa`konaoqhp]`ko(`aik`kmqaqi_kjda_eiajpk jkrkjklk`aoeilhaoiajpaoan]_nao_ajp]`k]ko]jpaneknao$_kikj]_of`li^db%(i]o o oafqjp]]ahaooak^a`a_an]_anp]onacn]oalnej_lekoejpaha_pq]eo*
.,3
Klajo]iajpkh ce_kkqn]_ekj]h$kqklajo]iajpkk^faperk%klan]`a]_kn`k_kiko lnej_leko `a e`ajpe`]`a( _kjpn]`ek( pan_aenk at_hq`k( n]vk oqbe_eajpa a _]qo]he`]`a7 `eo) pejcqaran`]`ao`ab]pkaran`]`ao`an]vk7`ebanaj_e]ejpqek(`a`qk(ej`qka]^`qk7 `eopejcqa]jheoaaojpaoa7`ebanaj_e]nabhatkaranebe_]k(pakne]alnpe_](_ej_e]ap_je_]* Oanahanikok_]lpqhk.`]Qje`]`a-(lan_a^anaikoiahdkn]`ebanaj]ajpna]o`q]o ik`]he`]`ao`alajo]iajpkraj`k]`ebanaj]ajpna]atlhe_]k`lpjldkf`^$ipe_]%a] `lpjlidf`^$_kj_aepq]h%`]na]he`]`a(p]eo_kikbkn]iah]^kn]`]oj]Cn_e]*
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
K lajo]iajpk _koikcje_k j]nn]r] ] knecai `] j]pqnav] lkn iaek `a caja]hkce]o `erej]o6]obkn]oakooanaoj]pqn]eoaop]r]ilanokj]hev]`koaoei^khev]`kolahko`aqoao( pepoadan eo(_qf]onah] aooatq]eo`]r]iknecaio_keo]o(]kodkiajo(oaop] ao`k]jk( ]k`e]ajkepa(o_khdaep]o(ok_ea`]`a*Oq]ol]et aojk_knnaolkj`e`]ooaatlneie]i lknn]eko(pnkr ao(pailaop]`ao(pqb ao(`aoanpko*Oaqo]iknaoa`aoafkona]hev]`koi]jebao) p]r]i)oaj]]^qj` j_e]`]lnei]ran](`]o_khdaep]o(`]lnk_ne]k`ko]jei]eo* Klajo]iajpk_koikh ce_katlhe_]r]]knecai`]j]pqnav]lah]ateopj_e]`aqikq ]hcqjoahaiajpkoj]pqn]eo$pann])oa_k(cq])ie`k(]n)bnek(bkck)mqajpa%(]mevpfp(mqa(lkn oq]bkn]ejpanj]j]pqn]h(oapn]jobkni]r](`]j`kknecai]pk`]o]o_keo]oa]kodkiajo*Ko lneiaenkobeh okbko_kjoe`an]r]ikoahaiajpkoknecejneko_kikbkn]o`erej]o(i]ofjk an]ilanokj]hev]`]ojaioq]]katlhe_]`]lkn`aoafko(l]et aoabqnknao* =neop pahaooeopai]pevkqh ce_]an]_ekj]hiajpa]o_koikhkce]okqpakne]ook^na]j]pq) nav]jqi]cpf`^(eopk(jqi]pakne]kq_ej_e]ok^na]i]pne]a]bkni]`kooanaoj]pqn]eo aok^na]o_]qo]o`aoaqoikreiajpko* L]n]kocnacko(_kikreiko(ikreiajpk$hkbpfp%oecjebe_]6 pk`]iq`]j]mq]hep]per]`aqioanmq]hmqan$lknatailhk(qi]oaiajpamqaoapknj] nrkna(qik^fapk^n]j_kmqa]i]naha_a(qi]jei]hmqa]`ka_a(]hckmqajpamqaaobne]( ]hckbnekmqaaomqajp](k`qnkmqa]ikha_a(kikhamqaaj`qna_a(ap_*%7 pk`]iq`]j]kq]hpan]kmq]jpep]per]$lknatailhk(qi_knlkmqa]qiajpaa`eie) jq](mqaoa`ere`]aikqpnkoiajknao(mqaaj_kilne`akqaj_qnpa(]h]ncqakqaopnae) pa(ap_*%7 pk`]iq`]j]`ahqc]nkqhk_kikk$oq^en(`ao_an(_]en(]pn]fap ne]`aqi]bha_d](k `aohk_]iajpk`aqi^]n_k(]mqa`]`aqi]la`n](kharep]n`aqi]lhqi](ap_*%7 pk`]can]kkqj]o_eiajpkapk`]_knnqlkkqiknpa`kooanao* Aooaoikreiajpko(`ev=neop pahao(lkooqai_]qo]o(lkeopq`kkmqaateopalkooqe_]qo] ak_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenkk_kjda_eiajpk`]o_]qo]o*Okmq]pnk]o_]qo]o`koikre) iajpko6 -* `^rp^j^qbof^iÍ]i]pne]`amqa]hcqi]_keo]baep]$i]`aen](la`n](iap]h(h) mqe`k%7 .* `^rp^cloj^iÍ]bkni]mqa]hcqi]_keo]lkooqeamqa]ej`ere`q]hev]a]`ebanaj) _e]`]okqpn]o$]iao]_]qo]bkni]h`]i]`aen](]aoppq]_]qo]bkni]h`]la`n](]p]] _]qo]bkni]h`kiap]h(krejdk_]qo]bkni]h`khmqe`k%7 /* `^rp^jlqofwlrbcf`fbkqbÍ]mqehkmqab]vqi]i]pne]na_a^anqi]bkni]`apan) iej]`]$jk_]ok`kok^fapko]npebe_e]eokq]npab]pko(]_]qo]abe_eajpak]npaokÍk_]nlej) paenkmqab]v]iao](kao_qhpknmqab]v]aoppq](kbannaenkmqab]v]p]](kreje_qhpknmqa b]vkrejdk7jk_]ok`kooanaoj]pqn]eo(]_]qo]abe_eajpap]i^iqi]_keo]j]pqn]hÍlkn atailhk(k_]hkn`annapakiap]h(kokhaomqajp]qi_knlkahda`kqpn]_kjoeopj_e]kq bkni](ap_*%7 0* `^rp^cfk^iÍkikperkkqbej]he`]`al]n]]mq]h]_keo]ateopa(oapn]jobkni]aoana]) hev]$]iao]ateopal]n]mqalkoo]ikoqo)h]l]n]nabae ao(ao_naran(`alkoep]nk^fapko(ap_*7] aoppq](l]n]k_qhpk`aqi`aqo7]p]](l]n]_khk_]niko^a^e`]o7krejdk(l]n]^a^aniko* ?ki ] boe_] ]neopkphe_] raiko ] j]pqnav] pknj]n)oa ejpahecrah ]k lajo]iajpk( mqa lk`aatlhe_)h](`ao_nar)h](_kilnaaj`)h]aejpanlnap)h]_kj_aepq]hiajpa*
.,4
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;x#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =_kjo_e j_e]lk`a _kjda_anpq`k; ?kjo_e j_e]a_kjda_eiajpk
!LBUMAKG.ORTHß7INDßß 0ICTUREß!RCHIVES,ATINSTOCK
-ITOßDEß.ARCISOßCONTAßOß MITOßQUEßOßJOVEMß.ARCISO ß BELqSSIMO ßNUNCAßTINHAß VISTOßSUAßPRvPRIAßIMAGEMß 5MßDIA ßPASSEANDOßPORßUMß BOSQUE ßVIUßUMßLAGOß!PRO XIMOU SEßEßVIUßNASßfGUASß UMßJOVEMßDEßEXTRAORDI NfRIAßBELEZAßPELOßQUALßSEß APAIXONOUßPERDIDAMENTEß $ESEJAVAßQUEßOßOUTROßSAqS SEßDASßfGUASßEßVIESSEßAOß SEUßENCONTRO ßMASßCOMOßOß OUTROßPARECIAßRECUSAR SEßAß SAIRßDOßLAGO ß.ARCISOßMER GULHOUßNASßfGUAS ßFOIßgSß PROFUNDEZASßgßPROCURAßDOß OUTROßQUEßFUGIAßEßMORREUß AFOGADOß.ARCISOßMORREUß DEßAMORßPORßSIßMESMO ßOUß MELHOR ßDEßAMORßPORßSUAß PRvPRIAßIMAGEMßOUßPELAß AUTOIMAGEMß/ßNARCISIS MOßmßOßENCANTAMENTOßEßAß PAIXjOßQUEßSENTIMOSßPORß NOSSAßPRvPRIAßIMAGEMßOUß PORßNvSßMESMOSßPORQUEß NjOßCONSEGUIMOSßDIFEREN CIARßOßEUßDOßOUTRO
#HARLESß$ARWINßß ¯ ßNATURALISTAß INGLoS
.,5
?
kikreiko(]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk`eopejcqakaq(]laook](k_e`]`kakoqfaepk7 `eopejcqap]i^icn]qo`a_kjo_ej_e]$l]ooer](rere`](nabhater]%apai_kik_ajpnk ]becqn]`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(ajpaj`e`k_kik_kjo_ej_e]`aoenabhater]kq ]pere`]`an]_ekj]hmqa_kjda_a]oeiaoi]* Mqa]_kjpa_an(lkni(oakoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk`ao_k^nenmqa]_kjo_ej_e]lko) oqei]eoqicn]q(]hi`kopnomqaiaj_ekj]iko(a(ok^napq`k(oa`ao_k^nenmqajkoa pn]p] at]p]iajpa `a i]eo qi cn]q a^ _kjo_ej_e]( i]o `a ]hck mqa ] _kjo_ej_e] `ao_k) jda_aaok^nakmq]hjqj_]lk`annabhapen`enap]iajpa;Mqaaooa]hck(`ao_kjda_e`kkqo ej`enap]iajpa_kjda_e`k(`apaniej]pq`kmq]jpk]_kjo_ej_e]akoqfaepkoajpai(mqanai( b]vai(`evaialajo]i;Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(mqaoq_a`anmq]j`kkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiaj) pk`ao_k^nenqiheiepaejpn]jolkjrah_d]i]`kkej_kjo_eajpa;
Kej_kjo_eajpa
K
_ne]`kn`]loe_]jheoa(Oeciqj`Bnaq`(ao_naraqmqa(jkpn]jo_knnan`]ik`anje`]) `a(kodqi]jkobkn]ibane`kopnoravaoamqa]obane`]o]pejcen]ikjkookj]n_eoeo) ik(eopk(]^ah]ei]caimqalkooq]iko`aj oiaoiko_kikoanao_kjo_eajpao+ n]_ekj]eoa_ki]mq]h(`qn]jpao_qhko(aoperaikoaj_]jp]`ko*Mqabane`]obkn]iaoo]o; =lneiaen]bke]mqajkoejbheceq?klnje_k(]klnkr]nmqa]Pann]jkaop]r]jk_ajpnk `k Qjeranok a mqa ko dkiajo jk an]i k _ajpnk `k iqj`k* = oacqj`] bke _]qo]`] lkn @]nsej(]klnkr]nmqakodkiajo`ao_aj`ai`aqilnei]p](mqaok]laj]oqiahkj] arkhqk`]oaol_eaoajkoanaoaola_e]eo(_ne]`kolkn@aqol]n]`kiej]n]j]pqnav]*= pan_aen]bke_]qo]`]lahkln lnekBnaq`_ki]loe_]jheoa(]kikopn]nmqa]_kjo_ej_e]] iajknl]npaa]i]eobn]_]`ajkoo]re`]lomqe_]* J]k^n]@fk`lbkp^flppl_ob^mpf`^kifpb(Bnaq`ao_nara6 >mpf`^kifpbmolmbjlpqo^onrblBrklpljbkqbklpbkelok^pr^momof^ `^p^ j^p q^j_j bpq obarwfal ^ `lkqbkq^o*pb `lj fkcloj^ bp o^o^p b co^djbkq^* a^pa^nrfilnrbpbm^pp^clo^a^`lkp`fk`f^)klobpq^kqba^sfa^mpnrf`^%+++&+>afsfpl almpnrf`lkrjmpnrf`l`lkp`fbkqbbkrjmpnrf`lfk`lkp`fbkqb`lkpqfqrf^mobjfpp^ crka^jbkq^ia^mpf`^kifpb)pbj^nr^ibi^pbof^fk`^m^wab`ljmobbkabolpmol`bpplp m^qlidf`lp)qlcobnrbkqbpnr^kqldo^sbp)a^sfa^mpnrf`^bc^w*ilpbkqo^oklnr^aol a^`fk`f^%+++&+>mpf`^kifpbpbob`rp^^`lkpfabo^o^`lkp`fk`f^`ljl`lkpqfqrfkal^ bppk`f^a^sfa^mpnrf`^)j^pkbi^s^mbk^prj^nr^ifa^ababpq^)mlabkal`lbufpqfo `ljlrqo^pnr^ifa^abpb^qjbpjlc^iq^o+
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
=loe_]jheoa
-*
)"! !RCHIV3TR+EYSTONE
B
naq`an]i`e_kjaqnkhkceop]aaopq`]r]ko`eopn^eko`koeopai]janrkok*Oacqej`k ko i`e_ko `a oq] lk_]( qo]r] ] deljkoa a ] oqcaopk jk pn]p]iajpk `ko `kajpao iajp]eo(i]ooajpe])oaejo]peobaepk_kikonaoqhp]`kok^pe`ko*@qn]jpa]hcqipailk( aiReaj](pn]^]hdkq_kiki`e_k>naqan(mqahdanah]pkqk_]ok`aqi]l]_eajpa(=jj]K*( mqa]lnaoajp]r]oejpki]o`adeopane]$`eopn^ekoboe_kooai_]qo]oboe_]o(lkeoan]ii]je) baop] ao`alnk^hai]olomqe_ko%* Aioaqnah]pk(>naqan_kjpkq]Bnaq`mqa]l]_eajpaoqcanen]qiipk`k`apn]p]iaj) pkjkmq]hoalnklqjd]]b]h]nok^naoaqolnk^hai]o`eneko(lknmqaeookpn]ve]]hrek]ko oaqooejpki]o$aooalnk_a`eiajpkrene]]oan_d]i]`k`ajqlal`^qoqf`l(eopk(`alqne) be_]kkqheilav]`]]hi]%*Bnaq`l]ookq(ajpk(]ailnac]naooalnk_a`eiajpk_kioaqo l]_eajpao6aihqc]n`aqo]n]deljkoaa]oqcaopk(b]ve]_kimqakl]_eajpanah]t]ooajqi `erab]h]ooa(naolkj`aj`k]oq]olancqjp]o* Qi] l]_eajpa la`eq)hda mqa jk ] ejpannkilaooa _ki ]o lancqjp]o( i]o ] `aet]ooa b]h]naolkjp]ja]iajpa*=l]npen`aajpk(Bnaq`bke]^]j`kj]j`k]olancqjp]o(i]o(`arav ai mq]j`k( ejpannkile] ] l]_eajpa( `evaj`k)hda l]h]rn]o okhp]o a la`e])hda mqa b]h]ooa ] lneiaen]l]h]rn]mqahdareaooa_]^a]]kkqrenkmqaaha`eooan]ÍlkopanekniajpaBnaq` `ajkiej]ne]aooalnk_a`eiajpk`aq`kf`^ab^ppl`f^ lifsob* Bnaq` lan_a^aq mqa( ai _anpko ikiajpko( ] l]_eajpa na]ce] ] _anp]o l]h]rn]o a jk lnkjqj_e]r]]mqah]mqahdarean]_]^a](_ajoqn]j`k)]lkn]hcqiikperkecjkn]`klkn ah]alknaha*Jkpkqp]i^imqa(aikqpn]ok_]oe ao(`alkeo`ab]van]]ook_e]kherna`a l]h]rn]o(]l]_eajpabe_]r]iqepk]cep]`]ab]h]r]iqepk* K^oanrkqmqa(_anp]oravao(]hcqi]ol]h]rn]o]b]ve]i_dkn]noaiikperk]l]najpaa( kqpn]oravao(]b]ve]ihai^n]n)oa`ab]pko`]ejb j_e](kq]har]r]i]j]nn]nqiokjdkmqa peran]j]jkepa]jpanekn* Lah]_kjrano](lah]ona] ao`]l]_eajpa(lahkookjdkoj]nn]`koalah]ohai^n]j]oej) b]jpeo(Bnaq``ao_k^neqmqa]re`]_kjo_eajpa`aoq]l]_eajpaan]`apaniej]`]lknqi]re`] ej_kjo_eajpa(mqap]jpkah]_kikaha`ao_kjda_e]i*?kilnaaj`aqp]i^imqa(okiajpa ejpanlnap]j`k]ol]h]rn]o(kookjdko(]ohai^n]j]oakocaopko`]l]_eajpa(_dac]ne]]aoo] re`]ej_kjo_eajpa* Bnaq``ao_k^neq(bej]hiajpa(mqakooejpki]odeopne_ko`aoq]l]_eajpapejd]ipno bej]he`]`ao6
3IGMUNDß&REUDßß ¯ ßFUNDADORßß DAßPSICANfLISEß3UASßß TEORIASßTIVERAMßGRANDEß IMPACTOßNAßPSICOLOGIA ßß NAßPSIQUIATRIA ßNAßß FILOSOFIAßEßNASßCIoNCIASß HUMANASßEßSOCIAIS
_kjp]nej`enap]iajpa]kokqpnkoa]oeiaoi]kooajpeiajpkoej_kjo_eajpao7
.* lqjen)oalknpanp]eooajpeiajpko7 /* na]hev]n( lah] `kaj] a lahk okbneiajpk( qi `aoafk ej_kjo_eajpa mqa oq] _kjo_ej_e] fqhc]n]ejpkhanrah* Pn]p]j`k`akqpnkol]_eajpao(Bnaq``ao_k^neqmqa(ai^kn]ahao(_kjo_eajpaiajpa(mqe) oaooai]_qn](]hckjahao_ne]r]qi]^]nnaen](qi]naoeopj_e]ej_kjo_eajpa_qn]*Lknmq; Lknmqakol]_eajpaooajpe]i)oaejpanekniajpa]ia]]`kolkn]hcqi]_keo]`khknko]apaie) `](]hckmqad]re]ilajko]iajpaaomqa_e`kamqajkoqlknp]r]ihai^n]n*Bnaq``ao_k) ^neq(]ooei(mqakaomqa_eiajpk_kjo_eajpaklan]r]oeiqhp]ja]iajpa`a`q]oi]jaen]o6 -*
_kiknaoeopj_e]pan]le]7
.* ok^]bkni]`]`kaj]lomqe_](lkeokej_kjo_eajpajkaomqa_aak^nec]kaomqa_e`k ]na]l]na_anok^]bkni]`aoejpki]omqaoai]jebaop]i_kii]eknejpajoe`]`aj]o `kaj]olomqe_]o* @aoajrkhraj`kaikqpnkol]_eajpaoaaioeiaoikkoaopq`ko`kooejpki]o(`koao) mqa_eiajpko(`kookjdko(`]ohai^n]j]o(]lhe_]j`kjaooaoaopq`ko]p_je_]`]]ook_e]k hernaalnk_a`eiajpkol]n]ejpanlnap]k`aooao]_kjpa_eiajpkolomqe_ko(Bnaq`bke_ne]j) `k k mqa _d]ikq `a ^kifpb a^ sfa^ mpnrf`^( kq loe_]jheoa( _qfk k^fapk _ajpn]h an] k
.-,
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;x#!0É45,/ßx
aopq`k`kej_kjo_eajpaa_qf]bej]he`]`aan]]_qn]`]olanpqn^] aoa`kaj]oiajp]eo$`]o jaqnkoao%(paj`k_kikipk`k]fkqbomobq^ la_kikejopnqiajpk]ifkdr^dbj$p]jpk] hejcq]cairan^]h_kik]hejcq]cai_knlkn]h(b]h]`]lahkooejpki]oalahkocaopko%*
=re`]lomqe_]
@
#OMPLEXOßDEßbDIPOßß NOßCAPqTULOßANTERIOR ßNOß TvPICOßSOBREßOßPENSAMEN TOßMqTICO ßHfßUMAßNOTAß SOBREßOßMITOßDEßbDIPOßß %SSEßMITOßFOIßTRANSFORMA DOßPELOßPOETAßGREGOßß 3vFOCLESßNUMAßDASßTRAGm DIASßMAISßIMPORTANTESßEß IMPRESSIONANTESßDAßCULTU RAßOCIDENTAL ßbDIPOß2EI
.--
qn]jpapk`]]oq]re`](Bnaq`jk_aookq`anabkniqh]n]pakne]loe_]j]hpe_](]^]j) `kj]j`k]hcqjo_kj_aepko(_ne]j`kkqpnko(]^]j`kj]j`k]hcqi]op_je_]opan]lq) pe_]oa_ne]j`kkqpn]o*Jkr]iko(]mqe(]_kil]jd]n]deop ne]`]bkni]k`]loe) _]jheoa(i]o]lnaoajp]n]hcqi]o`aoq]olnej_el]eoe`ae]oaejkr] ao* =re`]lomqe_]_kjopepq`]lknpnoejop j_e]o(`q]o`ah]oej_kjo_eajpaoa]laj]oqi] _kjo_eajpa*L]n]ej`e_)h]o(Bnaq`qokqkopanikofppl(braprmbo*br(mqa_kopqi]i]l]na_an aipanikorej`ko`kh]peiÍkfa(kbdlakprmbobdl*Ke`]ejop j_e]ejpaen]iajpaej_kjo) _eajpa7kack(]ejop j_e]_kjo_eajpa7koqlanacklkooqe]ola_pkoej_kjo_eajpaoa]ola_pko _kjo_eajpao* Ke`bkni]`klknejopejpko(eilqhokoknc je_koa`aoafkoej_kjo_eajpao(kqoaf](lahk mqaBnaq``aoecj]_kikmripbp*Aop]ooknace`]olahkmofk`mflalmo^wbo(mqaatecao]) peob]keia`e]p]*Ke`]ajance]`koejopejpkoa`ko`aoafkoai^qo_]`]na]hev]k`aooa lnej_lek `k ln]van* Bnaq` `ao_k^neq mqa ejopejpko( eilqhoko a `aoafko ej_kjo_eajpao( ai oqi](]olqho ao(ok`aj]pqnav]oatq]halkneookailnackqqipanikp]i^irej`k`k h]peil]n]nabanen)oa]ah]o6if_fal$mqa(aih]pei(oecjebe_]Îh]o_re]Ï(Îhqtne]Ï(Î`aoafkoatq]h rekhajpkÏ%*Ke`knaoanr]p neklneieperk`]ajance]lomqe_]kqknaoanr]p nek`]he^e`k* Bnaq``ao_k^neqp]i^imqa]oatq]he`]`ajkoana`qv]k]pkoatq]hcajep]h(i]oajrkhra pk`koko`aoafkomqala`aio]peob]kamqalk`aioano]peobaepkoaimq]hmqanl]npa`a jkook_knlkkqj]pkp]he`]`a`aha* L]n]ao_ j`]hk`]ok_ea`]`aaqnklae]`kbej]h`ko_qhkTETaej_ek`kTT(Bnaq`ej) pnk`qveq]e`ae]`apbur^ifa^abfkc^kqfia]ooej]hkqpnob]oao`aoo]oatq]he`]`a(mqaoa`eba) naj_e]ilahko nckomqaoajpailn]vanalahkok^fapkokqoanaomqa`kln]van*Aoo]ob]oao oa`kajpnakolneiaenkoiaoao`are`]ako1kq2]jko(hec]`]o]k`aoajrkhreiajpk`ke`6 ]c^pblo^i(mq]j`kk`aoafkakln]vanhk_]hev]i)oalneikn`e]hiajpaj]^k_]aj]ejcaopk `a]heiajpko(akoaeki]panjkkk^fapk`aln]van$kqoaqooq^opepqpko(_kik]i]i]`aen]( ]_dqlap](ko`a`ko%7]c^pb^k^i(mq]j`kk`aoafkakln]vanhk_]hev]i)oalneikn`e]hiajpa j]oat_na ao(akok^fapko`aln]vanok^nej_]n_kii]oo]oa_kipejp]o(]i]oo]n^]nnkkq ]nceh](_kian_keo]o_naiko]o(oqf]n)oa7a]c^pbcif`^(mq]j`kk`aoafkakln]vanhk_]hev]i) )oalneikn`e]hiajpajk nckcajep]hi]o_qhejk(kb]hkkqljeo(lkeo]_ne]j](iajejkkq iajej](o na_kjda_aaooa nckoatq]h*Jaoo]b]oa(l]n]koiajejko(]iakk^fapk`k `aoafka`kln]van7l]n]]oiajej]o(kl]e* jaoo]pan_aen]b]oamqaoqnca(jk_ajpnk`ke`(`apaniej]j`kpk`]]re`]lomqe_](k mqaBnaq``ajkiejkq`a`ljmibulkr`ib^oa^pkbrolpbpkq_kilhatk`a`elk* KpanikÎ_kilhatkÏailnac]`klknBnaq`l]n]ej`e_]nmqaoapn]p]`aqi_kjfqjpk `arne]olqho aoj]omq]eooaatlneiakiaoik`aoafk(eopk(k`aoafkej_aopqkoklah]ia kqlahkl]e*aooak`aoafkbqj`]iajp]hmqaknc]jev]]pkp]he`]`a`]re`]lomqe_]a`apan) iej]koajpe`k`ajkoo]re`](lkeopq`k`alaj`an`a_kik]_ne]j]_kjoacqenkqjkoq) lan]naooa_kilhatk*aooa_kilhatkmqa`apaniej]p]i^ikoajpeiajpk`]^jb^ ^a^ `^pqo^ lkqkoqnceiajpk`aqikqpnk_kilhatk(_kjda_e`k_kik`ljmibulab`^pqo^ l( jkmq]h]_ne]j]paialan`ankb]hk$lkeo]oiajej]op]i^iei]cej]imqaklkooqai% _kiklqjek`aoaq`aoafkej_aopqkok* Koqlanack]_ajoqn]`]olqho ao(mqa]ok_ea`]`aa]_qhpqn]eil ai]ke`(eila) `ej`k)k`ao]peob]vanlhaj]iajpaoaqoejopejpkoa`aoafko*]nalnaook(l]npe_qh]niajpa] nalnaookoatq]h*I]jebaop])oa_kjo_ej_e]ej`enap]iajpa(ok^]bkni]`]ikn]h(_kikqi _kjfqjpk`aejpan`e aoa`a`aranao(alkniaek`]a`q_]k(lah]lnk`qk`]ei]cai`k
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
Îaqe`a]hÏ(eopk(`]laook]ikn]h(^k]arenpqko]*?kik_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h(koqlanack]lna) oajp]]ola_pko_kjo_eajpao7_kik]pere`]`a`analnaook(oq]oklan] aookej_kjo_eajpao* Ahaoa`aoajrkhrajqilank`kmqaBnaq``aoecj]_kikmbolalabi^qk`f^(oepq]`kajpna ko2kq3]jkoakej_ek`]lq^an`]`akq]`khao_j_e]*Jaooalank`k(bkni])oajkoo]lan) okj]he`]`aikn]haok_e]h(`ai]jaen]mqa(mq]j`k]oatq]he`]`acajep]hlnklne]iajpa`ep] oqnca(k^nec]`]]oacqenk_]iejdkpn]]`klahkoqlanack* Kackkqkaq]_kjo_ej_e](lamqaj]l]npa`]re`]lomqe_](oq^iape`]]ko`aoafko `ke`ak^oanr]k(_ajoqn]analnaook`koqlanack*K^a`a_a]kmofk`mfla^ob^ifa^ab( kqoaf](ja_aooe`]`a`aaj_kjpn]nk^fapkomqalkoo]io]peob]van]ke`oaipn]jocna`en]o atecj_e]o`koqlanack* Jqiajo]ekejpepqh]`kÎKackake`Ï(Bnaq`ao_naramqakackÎqilk^na_kep]`kÏ(ao) lnaie`kajpnapnoao_n]re` aokqlknpnooajdknao6ko`aoafkoejo]_eraeo`ke`(]oarane`]`a nalnaooer]`koqlanackakolanecko`kiqj`katpanekn*Lknaooaikperk(]bkni]bqj`]iajp]h `]ateopj_e]l]n]kack]^kd pqf^*Oaoaoq^iapan]ke`(pknj])oaeikn]ha`aopnqperk7oaoa oq^iapan]koqlanack(ajhkqmqa_a`a`aoaolank(lkeoreranjqi]ejo]peob]kejoqlknprah7 oajkoaoq^iapanna]he`]`a`kiqj`k(oan`aopnq`klknaha*?]^a]kackaj_kjpn]n_]) iejdkol]n]]]jcope]ateopaj_e]h*Aop]iko`ere`e`koajpnaklnej_lek`kln]van$mqajk _kjda_aheiepao%aklnej_lek`]na]he`]`a$mqajkoeil aheiepaoatpanjkoaejpanjko%* =kack)aq(kqoaf](_kjo_ej_e](`]`]qi]bqjk`qlh]6]kiaoikpailkob`^i`^o ke`(o]peob]vaj`kkoqlanack(ap^qfpc^wboke`(heiep]j`kklk`anek`koqlanack*=re`]_kjo) _eajpajkni]hkamqeh^nekaj_kjpn]`klah]_kjo_ej_e]l]n]na]hev]noq]`qlh]bqjk*=o jaqnkoaoej`e_]i]o`ebe_qh`]`ao`]na]hev]k`aooaamqeh^neka]oloe_koao$kq]hkq_qn]% atlneiai]ej_]l]_e`]`a`kackl]n]na]hev]noq]`qlh]bqjk(oaf]lknmqake`kqkoqla) nackokat_aooer]iajpabknpao(oaf]lknmqakackat_aooer]iajpabn]_k* Kej_kjo_eajpaaopeila`e`k`ai]jebaop]n)oa`enap]iajpa_kjo_ej_e](i]o_kjoa) cqab]v)hkej`enap]iajpa*=i]jaen]i]eoabe_]vl]n]]i]jebaop]k]oq^opepqek(eopk (kej_kjo_eajpakbana_a_kjo_ej_e]qioq^opepqpk]_aeprahlknah]alkniaek`kmq]hah] lk`ao]peob]vanke`kqkoqlanack*Kooq^opepqpkookei]cajo$eopk(nalnaoajp] ao]j]) h ce_]o`kok^fapko`k`aoafk%abkni]ikfj^dfkoflmpnrf`l(mqa(]kk_qhp]na`eooeiqh]n kran`]`aenk`aoafk(ko]peob]vej`enap]iajpalkniaek`ak^fapkooq^opepqpko$]_dqlap]a k`a`k(l]n]koaeki]panjk7]opejp]oa]lejpqn]kq]nceh]a]ao_qhpqn]l]n]]obavao7qi] laook]]i]`]jkhqc]n`kl]ekq`]ia%*=hi`kooq^opepqpkona]eo$_dqlap](]nceh](laook] ]i]`]%(kei]cejnekej_kjo_eajpap]i^ikbana_akqpnkooq^opepqpkoÍkoi]eobnamqaj) paookkookjdko(koh]lokoako]pkob]hdko*Jahao(na]hev]iko`aoafkoej_kjo_eajpao(`aj]) pqnav]oatq]h*Ok]o]peob]kei]cejne]`k`aoafk* =hcqiokjd](lknatailhk(mqaok^aqi]ao_]`](kqmqaaopiancqhd]`kj]cq] jqij]qbncek(kqmqaaopjkiaek`kbkckjqiej_j`ek*J]na]he`]`a(okjdkq_kiqi] nah]k oatq]h lnke^e`]( atlnaoo] lkn iaek `a ei]cajo oq^opepqper]o( jk _]ok( ] ao_]`] $] anak`kljeokq`k_hep neo%(]cq]$kaolani]kqkohmqe`kor]cej]eo%kqkbkck$]]n`j) _e]`kknc]oik%*=hcqimqan`evanqi]l]h]rn](aomqa_a)]kqoaajc]j](_kiapaqih]lok a`evqi]kqpn]mqajkooqnlnaaj`a(lkeoj]`]pai]ran_ki]mqah]mqaoamqane]`evan* Na]hevkqqi`aoafklnke^e`k*=hcqir]e]j`]j`klknqi]nq]a(oaimqanan(pkn_akla mqa^n]kk^fapkmqaaop]r]_]nnac]j`k*?kiaooa]pkb]hdkna]hevkqqi`aoafklnke^e`k*Kq oaf](p]jpkkokjdk_kikkh]lok`ahejcq]caikq`aiai ne]ak]pkb]hdkej`e_]imqa jkoo]ateopj_e]jkpn]jo_knna]k]_]ok(jai`aoaf]iko(lajo]iko(oajpeikokqb]vaiko _keo]o]k]_]ok(i]oaop]iko`apaniej]`kolah]oklan] aoja_aoone]o`]he^e`k* = re`] lomqe_] ` oajpe`k a _khkn]k ]baperk)oatq]h ] pk`ko ko k^fapko a ] pk`]o ]o laook]omqajkonk`ae]iaajpnakomq]eoreraiko*Lkneook(oaimqao]e^]ikolknmqa(`a) oaf]ikoa]i]iko_anp]o_keo]oalaook]o(k`e]ikoapaiaikokqpn]o*=o_keo]oakokqpnko okejraope`kolknjkoo]he^e`k_ki_]nc]o]baper]oej_kjo_eajpao* lknaooaikperkmqa_anp]o_keo]o(_anpkookjo(_anp]o_knao(_anpko]jei]eo(_anp]o oepq] ao jko aj_dai `a l]rkn( ajmq]jpk kqpnko jko aj_dai `a ^ai)aop]n( oai mqa k
.-.
0RIVATEßCOLLECTION ß0ARIS!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;x#!0É45,/ßx
Ka`elqoNat(-5..( k^n]oqnna]heop]( hakok^napah]`a I]tAnjop*
.-/
lkoo]ikoatlhe_]n*=knecai`]ooeil]pe]oa]jpel]pe]o(]iknaoa `eko(ia`koaln]vanao aopaijkoo]i]eopajn]ejb j_e](aican]hjkolneiaenkoiaoaoa]jko`ajkoo]re`](mq]j) `koabkni]i]onah] ao]baper]obqj`]iajp]eoak_kilhatk`a`elk* Aoo] `eiajok ei]cejne] `a jkoo] re`] lomqe_] Í oq^opepqe ao( okjdko( h]loko `a hejcq]caia`aiai ne](]pkob]hdko(ln]vana`aoln]van_kik^fapkokqlaook]o(ia`kkq ^ai)aop]n_kik^fapkokqlaook]oÍej`e_]mqakona_qnokoej_kjo_eajpaol]n]oqncenej`e) nap]iajpa_kjo_ej_e]lkooqai`keojraeo6kjrah`k`lkqb alj^kfcbpql$ao_]`](i]na ej_j`ek(jkokjdk7]l]h]rn]aomqa_e`]a]lnkjqj_e]`](jkh]lok7klpkn_e`kkqkk^fapk l]npe`k(jk]pkb]hdk7ko]bapko_kjpnnekolkn_keo]oalaook]o%akjrah`k`lkqb ali^qbkqb( mqak_kjpa`kej_kjo_eajpana]hak_qhpk$ko`aoafkooatq]eo%* Jkoo]re`]jkni]hoal]oo]jklh]jk`ko_kjpa`koi]jebaopkoa(lknp]jpk(jkei]ce) jnek*Okiajpaqi]]jheoalomqe_]aloe_kh ce_]`aooao_kjpa`ko(lkniaek`ap_je_]o aola_e]eo$pn]ve`]olah]loe_]jheoa%(jkolaniepa`a_ebn]nk_kjpa`kh]pajpamqaoa`eooeiq) h]ok^k_kjpa`ki]jebaopk* =hi`kona_qnokoej`ere`q]eo_kpe`e]jkomqajkookej_kjo_eajpaqo]l]n]i]jebaop]n)oa( a]hi`kona_qnokoqo]`koj]ojaqnkoaoaloe_koao$aooaona_qnokookkopfkqlj^p%(ateopa qikqpnkna_qnok(`aajkniaeilknp j_e]l]n]]re`]_qhpqn]haok_e]h(eopk(l]n]]ateopj) _e]_khaper]*Pn]p])oa`kmqaBnaq``aoecjkq_kikjkia`apr_ifj^ l* J] oq^hei]k( ko `aoafko ej_kjo_eajpao ok o]peobaepko ej`enap]iajpa lknmqa ok pn]jobkni]`koaiqi]kqpn]_keo](atlneiai)oalah]_ne]k`a]hcqi]_keo]aopei]`]( r]hknev]`]lkoeper]iajpa6]ok^n]o`a]npa(]o_ej_e]o(]nahecek(]behkokbe](]op_je_]o(]o ] aope_]oalkhpe_]o*=npeop]o(iope_ko(lajo]`knao(ao_nepknao(_eajpeop]o(h`anaolkhpe_ko o]peob]vaioaqo`aoafkolah]oq^hei]ka(lknp]jpk(lah]na]hev]k`ak^n]oalah]_ne]k `aejopepqe aonaheceko]o(ok_e]eo(lkhpe_]o(ap_* Jk`araiko_kjbqj`enkej_kjo_eajpa`ao_k^anpklah]loe_]jheoa_ki]jkk(ateo) pajpaj]loe_khkce](`apr_`lkp`fbkqb*Koq^_kjo_eajpa]mqahacn]q`]_kjo_ej_e]mqaklan] _kik_kjo_ej_e]l]ooer]a_kjo_ej_e]rere`]jknabhater](lk`aj`kpknj]n)oalhaj]iajpa _kjo_eajpa*Kej_kjo_eajpa`amqab]h]]loe_]jheoa(]k_kjpnnek(f]i]eooan_kjo_eajpa`e) nap]iajpa(lk`aj`koan_]lp]`k]laj]oej`enap]iajpaalkniaek`ap_je_]oaola_e]eo`a ejpanlnap]k(`aoajrkhre`]olah]loe_]jheoa*
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
=]heaj]kok_e]h
Ç
opnobane`]oj]n_oe_]oiaj_ekj]`]olknBnaq`lna_eo]iko]_nao_ajp]ni]eoqi]6] mqajkobkeejbhece`]lknI]nt_ki]jkk`ae`akhkce]*L]n]_kilnaaj`)h](lna_e) o]ikolneiaenk_kilnaaj`ankbajiajk`]]heaj]kok_e]h* I]ntan]beh okbk(]`rkc]`kadeopkne]`knaejpanaookq)oalknqiaopq`kbaepklknqi kqpnk beh okbk( Baqan^]_d* Aopa ejraopec]n] k ik`k _kik oa bkni]i ]o nahece ao( eopk ( k ik`k_kikkooanaodqi]jkooajpaija_aooe`]`a`akbana_anqi]atlhe_]kl]n]]kne) caia]bej]he`]`a`kiqj`k* =k^qo_]naoo]atlhe_]k(atlhe_]Baqan^]_d(kodqi]jkolnkfap]il]n]bkn]`aoeqi oanoqlanekn`kp]`k`]omq]he`]`aomqafqhc]i]oiahdknao6ejpahecj_e](rkjp]`aherna(^kj) `]`a(fqope](^ahav](i]o]ob]vaiateopenjaooaoanoqlnaik_kikoqlanh]per]o(eopk(aha kjeo_eajpa a kjelkpajpa( o]^a pq`k( b]v pq`k( lk`a pq`k* Lkq_k ] lkq_k( ko dqi]jko oa aomqa_ai`amqabkn]iko_ne]`knao`aooaoanal]oo]i]]_na`ep]njkejranok(kqoaf](mqa aooaoanbkemqaiko_nekqakockranj]*L]oo]i]]`kn)hk(lnaop]n)hda_qhpk(pai)hk*Jkoa na_kjda_aijaooalrqolmqa_ne]n]i*Aih]pei(ÎkqpnkÏoa`ev^ifbkrp*Mq]j`kkodkiajo jkoana_kjda_aijqikqpnkmqaahaoiaoiko_ne]n]i(ahaooa]heaj]i*Baqan^]_d`aoec) jkqaooab]pk_kikjkia`a]heaj]k* =]heaj]kkbajiajklahkmq]hkodkiajo_ne]ikqlnk`qvai]hcqi]_keo](`k ej`alaj`j_e]]aoo]_ne]pqn]_kikoaah]ateopeooalknoeiaoi]aaioeiaoi](`aet]i)oa ckranj]nlknah]_kikoaah]peraooalk`anaioealknoeiaoi](jkoana_kjda_aij]k^n] mqa _ne]n]i( b]vaj`k)] qi pbo*lrqol( oal]n]`k `ko dkiajo( oqlanekn ] ahao a _ki lk`an ok^naahao* I]nt jk oa ejpanaookq ]laj]o lah] ]heaj]k naheceko]( i]o ejraopeckq ok^napq`k ] ]heaj]kok_e]h*Ejpanaookq)oaai_kilnaaj`an]o_]qo]olah]omq]eokodkiajoecjkn]i mqaokko_ne]`knao`]ok_ea`]`a(`]lkhpe_](`]_qhpqn]a]cajpao`]deop ne]*Ejpanaookq)oa ai_kilnaaj`anlknmqakodqi]jko]_na`ep]imqa]ok_ea`]`ajkbkeejopepq`]lknahao( i]olknrkjp]`aak^n]`ko`aqoaokqlah]bkn]_ac]`]ohaeo`]j]pqnav](airav`alan_a) ^anaimqaokahaoln lnekomqa(ai_kj`e aodeop ne_]o`apaniej]`]o(_ne]i]oejopepqe) aook_e]eoÍb]ihe](nah] ao`alnk`qka`apn]^]hdk(nah] ao`apnk_](hejcq]caikn]h( hejcq]caiao_nep](ao_kh](nahecek(]npao(_ej_e]o(behkokbe]Ía]oejopepqe aolkhpe_]oÍhaeo( `enaepko(`aranao(pne^qj]eo(Aop]`k(atn_epk(eilkopko(lneo ao*=]kok_eklkhpe_]adeop ne) _]_d]i])oalnteo*K`ao_kjda_eiajpk`]knecaia`]o_]qo]o`]lnteohar]kodkiajo] ]pne^qen]qikqpnkkq]kqpnko$`erej`]`ao(bkn]o`]j]pqnav]%]mqehkmqa(j]na]he`]`a(bke lnk`qve`klknoq]ln lne]]k*I]nt`ajkiejkqaooa`ao_kjda_eiajpk`]ln lne]lnteo _ki]atlnaook]heaj]kok_e]h* Lknmqad]heaj]kok_e]h;Lknmqakooanaodqi]jkojkoana_kjda_ai_kikoqfae) pkook_e]eo(lkhpe_ko(deop ne_ko(_kik]cajpaoa_ne]`knao`]na]he`]`aj]mq]hrerai;Lkn mqa(]hi`ajkoalan_a^anai_kikoqfaepkoa]cajpao(kodqi]jkooaoq^iapaio_kj)
CANIlOßPENSANTEßß AßEXPRESSjOßPROVmMßDAß FRASEßDOßFILvSOFOß0ASCALßß ±/ßHOMEMßNjOßPASSAßß DEßUMßCANIlOß;CANAßß DELGADAßEßFRfGIL= ßOßMAISßß FRACOßDAßNATUREZA ßMASßß mßUMßCANIlOßPENSANTE²ßß /ßFILvSOFOßQUISßREALlARßß AßPOTENCIALIDADEßDOßß HOMEMßPORßTRfSßDEßSUAß APARENTEßFRAGILIDADE
!LBUMAKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
=loe_]jheoa`ao_k^neq(]ooei(qi]lk`anko]heiep]kolnapajo ao`]_kjo_ej_e] l]n] `kiej]n a _kjpnkh]n ] na]he`]`a a k _kjda_eiajpk* L]n]`kt]hiajpa( lkni( jko na) rahkq]_]l]_e`]`ab]jpope_]`]n]vka`klajo]iajpkl]n]kqo]n]pn]raoo]nlnke^e aoa nalnaoo aoa^qo_]n]ran`]`a(iaoikmqal]n]eookoaf]lna_eok`aoikjp]n]^ah]ei]cai mqakooanaodqi]jkopi`aoeiaoiko* Hkjca `a `aor]hknev]n ] pakne] `k _kjda_eiajpk( ] loe_]jheoa ateca `k lajo]iajpk mqajkb]]_kj_aoo aooe`ae]oaop]^aha_e`]o(ikn]hrecajpa(]kolna_kj_aepkoaokle) je ao`ajkoo]ok_ea`]`a(i]omqakoajbnajpaaijkia`]ln lne]n]vka`klajo]iajpk* =_kjo_ej_e]bnceh(i]oah]mqa`a_e`aa]_aep]_knnankneo_k`]]jcope]akneo_k`a `aoraj`]na`a_ebn]nkej_kjo_eajpa*=_aep]a`a_e`aajbnajp]n]]jcope]l]n]_dac]n]k_k) jda_eiajpk`amqaokikoqi_]jeklajo]jpa*
&EUERBACH߯ ß FILvSOFOßALEMjO
.-0
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;x#!0É45,/ßx
.-1
`e aook_e]eo(lkhpe_]o(_qhpqn]eo_kikoaah]operaooaire`]ln lne](lk`anln lnek(rkjp]`a ln lne]akockranj]ooai(aihqc]n`aoanai_kjpnkh]`]oackranj]`]olknahao;L]n]_ki) lnaaj`an k bajiajk `] ]heaj]k ok_e]h( I]nt aopq`kq k ik`k _kik ]o ok_ea`]`ao ok lnk`qve`]odeopkne_]iajpalah]lnteo`kooanaodqi]jko* Ranebe_kq mqa( deopkne_]iajpa( qi] ok_ea`]`a $lamqaj]( cn]j`a( pne^]h( eilane]h( jk eilknp]% oailna _kia] lkn qi] `ereok a mqa aoo] `ereok knc]jev] pk`]o ]o nah] ao ok_e]eomqaoankejopepq`]o]oacqen*Pn]p])oa`]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk*J]hqp]lah] ok^narerj_e](kooanaodqi]jkooa]cnql]il]n]atlhkn]nkona_qnoko`]j]pqnav]a`ere) `ai]op]nab]o6p]nab]o`kodkiajo]`qhpko(p]nab]o`]oiqhdanao]`qhp]o(p]nab]`kodkiajo fkrajo(p]nab]`]oiqhdanaofkrajo(p]nab]`]o_ne]j]oa`koe`koko*=l]npen`aoo]`ereok( knc]jev]i]lneiaen]ejopepqekok_e]h6]c^jif^(j]mq]hkdkiai]`qhpk(j]mq]he`]`a `al]e(pknj])oa_dabaa`kiej]]iqhdan]`qhp](oq]aolko]aia`aoaqobehdko(komq]eo p]i^iok`kiej]`kolahkl]e* =ob]ihe]opn]^]hd]iapnk_]iajpnaoekolnk`qpko`kpn]^]hdk*Oqncaqi]oacqj`] ejopepqekok_e]h6]pnk_](eopk(k`ljo`fl*=hcqi]ob]ihe]o(qo]j`k]bkn]kq]]op_e]( _kjmqeop]ipann]oiahdknao`kmqakqpn]oa_kjoacqai_khdaep]okqc]`kaii]eknmq]jpe) `]`amqakqpn]o(pnk_]j`koaqolnk`qpkolknqi]mq]jpe`]`ai]eknmqa]`akqpn]o*Be_]i i]eone_]o*=oiqepklk^nao(jkpaj`k_kjoacqe`klnk`qvenj]`]kqiqepklkq_k(raai)oa k^nec]`]o]pn]^]hd]nl]n]]oi]eone_]oaipnk_]`alnk`qpkol]n]]ok^narerj_e]*?kia] ]oqncenqi]pan_aen]ejopepqekok_e]h6kqo^_^ielpbosfi(mqa`aoai^k_]nj]ao_n]re`k* Koi]eone_koalk`ankokonajai)oaa`a_e`ai_kjpnkh]nk_kjfqjpk`ab]ihe]o(`eo) pne^qej`kajpnaoekolk`anaoaat_hqej`k]hcqi]ob]ihe]o`apk`klk`an*?kia]]oqncen qi]mq]np]ejopepqekok_e]h6klk`anlkhpe_k(`akj`arenkBpq^al* = aoo] ]hpqn]( ko oanao dqi]jko f _kia]n]i ] atlhe_]n ] knecai a ] bej]he`]`a `k iqj`k(fah]^kn]n]iiepkoanepko*=ob]ihe]one_]oalk`anko]o`k]]hcqjo`aoaqoiai) ^nko]qpkne`]`aat_hqoer]l]n]j]nn]niepkoa_aha^n]nnepko*?ne]iqi]kqpn]ejopepqek ok_e]h6]obifdfl(`kiej]`]lkno]_an`kpaoo]`ko`]ob]ihe]olk`anko]oamqa(lknpanai] ]qpkne`]`al]n]oanah]_ekj]n_kiko]cn]`k(pknj]i)oapaie`koarajan]`kolahknaop]jpa `]ok_ea`]`a*Okqijkrklk`anok_e]h* Kornekocnqlko`ab]ihe]o`enecajpao`eolqp]iajpnaoepann]o(]jei]eoaoanrkoa`k ej_ek]qi]jkr]ejopepqekok_e]h6]drboo^(_ki]mq]hkoraj_e`kooapknj]iao_n]rko`ko raj_a`knao(aklk`ana_kjie_k(ok_e]h(iehep]n(nahecekokalkhpe_koa_kj_ajpn]]ej`]i]eo ailkq_]oiko* ?kiaoo]`ao_nek(I]ntk^oanrkqmqa]ok_ea`]`aj]o_alah]aopnqpqn]k`aqi_kj) fqjpk`a`ereo ao6`ereokoatq]h`kpn]^]hdk(`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk(`ereokok_e]h`]o pnk_]o(`ereokok_e]h`]onemqav]o(`ereokok_e]h`klk`ana_kjie_k(`ereokok_e]h`klk`an iehep]n(`ereokok_e]h`klk`annahecekoka`ereokok_e]h`klk`anlkhpe_k*Lknmqaafsfpl; Lknmqaaipk`]o]oejopepqe aook_e]eo$b]ihe](pn]^]hdk(_kin_ek(cqann](nahecek(lkhpe_]% qi]l]npa`apilk`an(nemqav](^ajo(]ni]o(e`ae]oao]^anao(pann]o(pn]^]hd]`knao(lk`an lkhpe_k(ajmq]jpkkqpn]l]npajklkooqej]`]`eook(aop]j`koq^fqc]`]kqpn](ne_](lk`a) nko]aejopnq`]*Aooa_kjfqjpkaopnqpqn]`k`a`ereo aopknj])oa_]`]ravi]eo_kilhatk(ej) pne_]`k(jqiankok(iqhpelhe_]j`k)oaaiiqep]okqpn]o`ereo ao(ok^]bkni]`ajqianko]o ejopepqe aook_e]eoamqa]_]^]ilknnarah]n]aopnqpqn]bqj`]iajp]h`]ook_ea`]`ao_kik `ereokok_e]h`]o_h]ooaook_e]eo* =aooa_kjfqjpk$p]jpkoeilhaomq]jpk_kilhatk%`aejopepqe aoj]o_e`]o`]`ereok ok_e]hI]nt`aqkjkia`a_kj`e aoi]pane]eo`]re`]ok_e]halkhpe_]*Lknmqaj^qb* of^fp;Lknmqaoanabanai]k_kjfqjpk`alnpe_]ook_e]eolah]omq]eokodkiajoc]n]jpaioq] ok^narerj_e]lkniaek`kpn]^]hdka`]pnk_]`kolnk`qpko`kpn]^]hdk(amqa_kjopepqai ]a_kjkie]* =r]ne]k`]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo`aqi]ok_ea`]`a_kjopepqe]deop ne]`aoo]ok_ea) `]`a(aI]nt]o`aoecjkq_kikik`ko`alnk`qk(`abeje`kolknaha_ki^]oaaipno b]pknao lnej_el]eo6 ] cloj^ a^ molmofba^ab kq ko iaeko `a lnk`qk( ] afsfpl pl`f^i a^p
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
`i^ppbpa]oobi^ bppl`f^fpabmolar l$kq]na]hev]kok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk%*=deop ne]]iq) `]j](l]oo]caikqpn]jobkni]k`aqiik`k`alnk`qkl]n]kqpnk*P]hiq`]j]jk oana]hev]lkn]_]okjailknrkjp]`aherna`kooanaodqi]jko(i]o]_kjpa_a`a]_kn`k_ki _kj`e aoa_kjie_]o(ok_e]eoa_qhpqn]eofaop]^aha_e`]o(mqalk`aioan]hpan]`]o`aqi] i]jaen]p]i^i`apaniej]`](cn]]olnteodqi]j]`e]jpa`ap]eo_kj`e ao`]`]o* Kb]pk`amqa]iq`]j]`aqi]ok_ea`]`akq]iq`]j]deop ne_]oab]]ai_kj`e) ao`apaniej]`]oharkqI]nt]]beni]nmqaÎkodkiajob]vai]deop ne](i]okb]vaiai _kj`e ao `apaniej]`]oÏ( eopk ( mqa jk bkn]i ao_khde`]o lkn ahao* Lkn eook p]i^i( aha `eooa6Îkodkiajob]vai]deop ne](i]ojko]^aimqa]b]vaiÏ* Aop]iko(]mqe(`e]jpa`aqi]oepq]k_khaper]iqepkl]na_e`]_ki]mqaaj_kjpn]iko jk_]ok`ajkoo]re`]lomqe_]ej`ere`q]h*=ooei_kikfqhc]ikomqajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]o]^a pq`k(lk`apq`k(b]vkmqalajo]amqan(i]o(j]na]he`]`a(aop`apaniej]`]lahkej_kjo) _eajpaaecjkn]p]h`apaniej]k(]ooeip]i^i(j]ateopj_e]ok_e]h(kooanaodqi]jkofqh) c]imqao]^aikmqa]ok_ea`]`a(`evaj`kmqa@aqokq]j]pqnav]]_ne]n]i(ejopepqn]i] lkhpe_]a]deop ne](amqakodkiajookoaqoejopnqiajpko7kq(ajpk(]_na`ep]imqab]vai kmqab]vaialajo]ikmqalajo]ilknmqaokej`er`qkohernao(]qpjkikoa_kilk`an l]n]iq`]nk_qnok`]o_keo]o_kikamq]j`kmqeoanai* Lknatailhk(mq]j`k]hcqi`evmqaqi]laook]lk^nalknmqamqan(lknmqalnacqe) ko](kqlan`qhne](kqecjkn]jpa(aopei]cej]j`kmqaokikokmqaokikookiajpalknjkoo] rkjp]`a(_kikoa]knc]jev]ka]aopnqpqn]`]ok_ea`]`a(`]a_kjkie](`]lkhpe_]jkperao) oaijajdqilaokok^najkoo]re`]*=iaoi]_keo]]_kjpa_amq]j`k]hcqi`evoanlk^na Îlah]rkjp]`a`a@aqoÏajklkn_]qo]`]o_kj`e ao_kj_nap]oaimqarera*Kqmq]j`kb]v qi]]beni]kn]_eop](oacqj`k]mq]hÎ]j]pqnav]bav]hcqjooqlaneknaoakqpnkoejbaneknaoÏ* =]heaj]kok_e]hk`ao_kjda_eiajpk`]o_kj`e aodeop ne_k)ok_e]eo_kj_nap]oai mqareraikoamqaoklnk`qve`]olah]]kdqi]j]p]i^iok^klaok`akqpn]o_kj`e) aodeop ne_]o]jpaneknaoa`apaniej]`]o*Dqi]`qlh]]heaj]k6lknqih]`k(kodkiajo jkoana_kjda_ai_kik]cajpaoa]qpknao`]re`]ok_e]h_kioq]oejopepqe ao(i]o(lkn kqpnkh]`ka]kiaoikpailk(fqhc]i)oaej`er`qkolhaj]iajpahernao(_]l]vao`aiq`]n] ln lne]re`]_kikamq]j`kmqeoanai(]lao]n`]oejopepqe aook_e]eoa`]o_kj`e aodeop ) ne_]o*Jklneiaenk_]ok(jklan_a^aimqafkpqfqrbj]ok_ea`]`a7jkoacqj`k_]ok(ecjkn]i mqa]ok_ea`]`afkpqfqra^`apaniej]oaqolajo]iajpkoa] ao*
=opn obkni]o`]]heaj]k
L
k`aikob]h]naipnocn]j`aobkni]o`a]heaj]kateopajpaoj]ook_ea`]`aoik`an) j]okq_]lep]heop]o6
-*
=^ifbk^ lpl`f^i(j]mq]hkodqi]jkojkoana_kjda_ai_kiklnk`qpknao`]oejope) pqe aook_eklkhpe_]oako_eh]iajpna`q]o]pepq`ao*Jqi]`ah]o(]_aep]il]ooer]iajpa pq`kkmqaateopa(lknoanpe`k_kikj]pqn]hkq`aknecai`erej]7]ok_ea`]`akkqpnk $^ifbkrp%(]hckatpanjk]j o(oal]n]`k`aj o(`ebanajpa`aj oa_kilk`anpkp]hkqja) jdqilk`anok^naj o*J]kqpn](kodqi]jkooana^ah]iej`ere`q]hiajpa_kjpn]aooa kqpnkok_e]h(fqhc]j`kmqa(lknoq]ln lne]rkjp]`aaejpahecj_e](lk`aii]eo`kmqa] na]he`]`amqako_kj`e_ekj]amqaah]jkpailk`anjajdqiok^naj o*
.* = ^ifbk^ l b`lkjf`^( j] mq]h ko lnk`qpknao jk oa na_kjda_ai _kik lnk`qpknao jai oa na_kjda_ai jko k^fapko lnk`qve`ko lkn oaq pn]^]hdk* Ai jkoo]o ok_ea`]`ao ik`anj]o kq _]lep]heop]o( ] ]heaj]k a_kjie_] `a_knna `] pn]jobkni]k `a oanao dqi]jkoai_keo]o(eopk(`]pn]jobkni]k`aqi]_h]ooaok_e]hÍkopn]^]hd]`knao lnk`qperkoÍaiian_]`kne]* @ab]pk(kopn]^]hd]`knao(_kik_h]ooaok_e]h(aopk`aolkf]`ko`koiaeko`alnk) `qk(kqoaf](]lnklnea`]`a`koiaeko`alnk`qklanpaj_a(`abkni]l]npe_qh]n(]
.-2
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;x#!0É45,/ßx
qi]_h]ooaok_e]hmqa]lnklneapne]`k_]lep]h$`kjko`]opann]o(`]oej`opne]o(`k _kin_ek(`ko^]j_ko(`]oao_kh]o(`kodkolep]eo(`]obnkp]o`a]qpki raeo(`aje^qo kq`a]re ao(ap_*%(mq]hkopn]^]hd]`knaoraj`aioq]bkn]`apn]^]hdk*Raj`aj`k oq]bkn]`apn]^]hdkjkian_]`k`]_kiln]araj`]`apn]^]hdk(kopn]^]hd]`knaook ian_]`kne]oa(_kikpk`]ian_]`kne](na_a^aiqilnak(eopk(ko]hnek*Ajpnap]jpk( ko pn]^]hd]`knao jk lan_a^ai mqa bkn]i na`qve`ko _kj`ek `a _keo]o mqa lnk) `qvai _keo]o7 jk lan_a^ai mqa bkn]i abprj^kfw^alp a `lfpfcf`^alp* Ko pn]^]hdko lnk`qvai]heiajpko$lahk_qhperk`]pann]a`ko]jei]eo%(k^fapko`a_kjoqik$lah] ej`opne]%(ejopnqiajpkol]n]]lnk`qk`akqpnkopn]^]hdko$imqej]o%(_kj`e ao l]n] ] na]hev]k `a kqpnko pn]^]hdko $pn]jolknpa `a i]pne]o)lnei]o( `a lnk`qpko a `apn]^]hd]`knao%*=ian_]`kne])pn]^]hd]`knlnk`qvian_]`kne]o*Aop]o(]k`aet]nai ]ob]vaj`]o(]oqoej]o(]ob^ne_]o(koao_nep nekoaajpn]naij]ohkf]o(j]obaen]o(jko oqlanian_]`ko( jko pelmmfkd `bkqbop( l]na_ai ]he aop]n lknmqa h bkn]i _khk_]`]o $jk lajo]iko jk pn]^]hdk dqi]jk mqa jah]o aop _neop]hev]`k a jk lajo]iko jk pn]^]hdkdqi]jkna]hev]`kl]n]mqa_dac]ooai]pj o%a(_kikkpn]^]hd]`kn(ah]o p]i^ina_a^aiqilnak* Kpn]^]hd]`knr]eo_kiln]o*Khd]kolnakoao]^amqajklk`an]`mqenenmq]oa j]`]`kmqaaopatlkopkjk_kin_ek(i]ojkhdal]oo]lah]_]^a]mqabkeaha(jk ajmq]jpkej`er`qk(aoei_kik_h]ooaok_e]h(mqailnk`qveqpq`k]mqehk_kioaqpn]) ^]hdkamqajklk`apankolnk`qpkolknmqaklnak`ahaoiqepki]eo]hpk`kmqak lnak`aha(eopk(mqakoaqo]hnek* =lao]n`eook(kpn]^]hd]`knlk`a(_daek`akncqhdk(ikopn]n]kokqpnko]o_keo]o mqaahab]^ne_](kq(oa_kian_enek(mqaaharaj`a(]_aep]j`kjklkooq)h]o(_kikoaeook bkooaiqepkfqopkaj]pqn]h*=oian_]`kne]o`aet]i`aoanlan_a^e`]o_kiklnk`qpko `kpn]^]hdkal]oo]i]oanreop]o_kik^ajoaioealknoeiaoi]o$_kik]lnkl]c]j`] ]oikopn]akbana_a%* Kpn]^]hd]`knjkoana_kjda_a_kiklnk`qpkn`]oian_]`kne]o(jklk`ar)h]o _kik_neop]hev]k`aoaqpn]^]hdk(`aoq]]k*Ah]ohda]l]na_aioal]n]`]o`aha(at) paneknao]ahaalk`aii]eo`kmqaaha6okqilrqol$^ifbkrp%ajkqi]atlnaook`] ]pere`]`a`kpn]^]hd]`kn* /* = ^ifbk^ l fkqbib`qr^i( naoqhp]jpa `] oal]n]k ok_e]h ajpna qo^_^iel j^qbof^i $mqa lnk`qvian_]`kne]o%aqo^_^ielfkqbib`qr^i$mqalnk`qve`ae]o%*=`ereokok_e]hajpna ]o`q]oik`]he`]`ao`apn]^]hdkhar]]_nanmqakpn]^]hdki]pane]hqi]p]nab]mqa jkateca_kjda_eiajpko(i]o]laj]od]^ehe`]`aoi]jq]eo(ajmq]jpkkpn]^]hdkejpa) ha_pq]hnaolkjorahat_hqoer]iajpalahko_kjda_eiajpko*Reraj`kjqi]ok_ea`]`a ]heaj]`](koejpaha_pq]eop]i^ioa]heaj]i* Lknqih]`k(aomqa_aikqecjkn]imqaoq]oe`ae]oaopkhec]`]o]kleje aoalkj) pko`areop]`]_h]ooa]mqalanpaj_ai(eopk(]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa(aei]cej]i(]k_kj) pnnek(mqaoke`ae]oqjerano]eo(rhe`]ol]n]pk`ko(aipk`kokopailkoahqc]nao*Lkn kqpnk(aomqa_aj`kkqecjkn]j`k]knecaiok_e]h`]oe`ae]oaoaqln lnekpn]^]hdkl]n] _ne)h]o(]_na`ep]imqa]oe`ae]oateopaiaioealknoeiaoi]o(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`k oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk7]_na`ep]imqa_ne]i]na]he`]`aa]_kjpnkh]i(`enecaia`k) iej]i*Lkq_k]lkq_k(l]oo]i]]_na`ep]nmqa]oe`ae]ooalnk`qvaiqi]ookqpn]o( ok_]qo]oaabaepkoqi]o`]okqpn]oamqaokiko]laj]ona_alp_qhkokqejopnqiajpko `ah]o*=oe`ae]ooapknj]ioal]n]`]o`aoaqo]qpknao(atpanj]o]ahao(pn]jo_aj`ajpao] ahao6pknj]i)oarjlrqol* =opnocn]j`aobkni]o`]]heaj]k$ok_e]h(a_kjie_]aejpaha_pq]h%pi_kik_]qo]o ] lnklnea`]`a lner]`] `ko iaeko `a lnk`qk( ] `ereok ok_e]h `]o _h]ooao( ] atlhkn]k a_kjie_]a]`kiej]klkhpe_]`aqi]_h]ooaok_e]hlknkqpn]$mqa]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa `]ok_ea`]`a%*?ki^]oajkbajiajk`]]heaj]k(lk`aiko_kilnaaj`ankbajiajk `]e`akhkce]*
.-3
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
=e`akhkce]
,EOß&ELTRAN%DITORAß!BRIL
=
]heaj]kok_e]hoaatlneiajqi]Îpakne]Ï`k_kjda_eiajpkaolkjp ja](bkni]j`k kpbkpl`ljrj`]ok_ea`]`a*Lknoaqejpani`ek(okei]cej]`]oatlhe_] aoafqo) pebe_]per]ol]n]]na]he`]`ap]h_kik`enap]iajpalan_a^e`]arere`]* Qiatailhk`aooaoajok_kiqi]l]na_ajk_]ok`]Îatlhe_]kÏ`]lk^nav](oacqj`k ]mq]hklk^nalk^nalknoq]ln lne]_qhl]$lnacqe](ecjkn j_e]%kqlknrkjp]`a`erej]kq lknejbanekne`]`aj]pqn]h*Aooaoajok_kiqiok_e]h(j]ran`]`a(knaoqhp]`k`aqi]ah]^k) n]kejpaha_pq]hok^na]na]he`]`a(baep]lahkolajo]`knaokqejpaha_pq]eo`]ok_ea`]`aÍo]) _an`kpao(beh okbko(_eajpeop]o(lnkbaooknao(ao_nepknao(fknj]heop]o(]npeop]oÍ(mqa`ao_naraia atlhe_]ikiqj`k`klkjpk`areop]`]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa`aoq]ok_ea`]`a* =bqjklnej_el]h`]e`akhkce]k_qh) p]n a `eooeiqh]n ]o `ereo ao ok_e]eo a lkh) pe_]o( `]j`k)hdao ] ]l]nj_e] `a ej`ereok ok_e]ha`a`ebanaj]oj]pqn]eoajpnakooa) nao dqi]jko* Fkafsfpl6 ]lao]n `] `ereok ok_e]h`]o_h]ooao(okikohar]`ko]_nanmqa okiko pk`ko ecq]eo lknmqa l]npe_el]iko `] e`ae] `a Îdqi]je`]`aÏ( kq `] e`ae] `a Îj]kÏaÎlpne]Ï(kq`]e`ae]`aÎn]]Ï(ap_* Afcbobk ^p k^qro^fp6 okiko har]`ko ] _nan mqa ]o `aoecq]h`]`ao ok_e]eo( a_kjie_]o alkhpe_]ojkoklnk`qve`]olah]`ereok ok_e]h`]o_h]ooao(i]olkn`ebanaj]oej`e) re`q]eo `ko p]hajpko a `]o _]l]_e`]`ao( `] ejpahecj_e](`]bkn]`arkjp]`ai]eknkq iajkn(ap_* =lnk`qke`akh ce_]`]ehqokok_e]h pai_kikbej]he`]`ab]van_kimqapk`]o ]o_h]ooaook_e]eo]_aepai]o_kj`e aoai mqarerai(fqhc]j`k)]oj]pqn]eo(jkni]eo( _knnap]o( fqop]o( oai lnapaj`an pn]jobkn) i)h]okq_kjda_)h]ona]hiajpa(oaihar]n ai_kjp]mqadqi]_kjpn]`eklnkbqj) `]ajpna]o_kj`e aona]eoaimqareraiko a]oe`a]eo* Lkn atailhk( ] e`akhkce] ]beni] mqa okikopk`ko_e`]`koa(lknp]jpk(paikopk) `kokoiaoiko`enaepkook_e]eo(a_kjie_ko( lkhpe_ko a _qhpqn]eo* Jk ajp]jpk( o]^aiko mqa eook jk ]_kjpa_a `a b]pk6 ]o _ne]j]o `anq]jkpi`enaepko7koe`kokojkpi `enaepko7 ko `enaepko _qhpqn]eo `]o _ne]j]o j]o ao_kh]o l^he_]o ok ejbaneknao ]ko `]o _ne]j]omqaaopkaiao_kh]ol]npe_qh]nao( Ejpanekn`]hkf]Rehh]@]ohq(aiOkL]qhk*J]hkf]( ]oian_]`kne]o`acneba`aopej]i)oa]ko_kjoqie`knao lkeokajoejkjk`aiaoi]mq]he`]`aai mqapilk`an]mqeoeperkl]n]_kiln)h]o* ]i^]o7kojacnkoaj`ekook`eo_neiej]`ko Kpn]^]hd]`knmqa]olnk`qvjklk`a]`mqene)h]o* _kikejbaneknao7kodkikooatq]eooklan) oacqe`ko_kiklanranpe`ko(ap_* =i]ekne](lkni(]_na`ep]mqakb]pk`aoanahaepkn(l]c]n]o`re`]oa_kjpne^qen_kiko eilkopkofjkob]v_e`]`ko(oai_kjoe`an]n]o_kj`e ao_kj_nap]omqab]vai]hcqjooanai i]eo_e`]`ko`kmqakqpnko*=bqjk`]e`akhkce]eila`en)jko`alajo]njaoo]o_keo]o*
.-4
=_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k;x#!0É45,/ßx
Kolnk_a`eiajpko`]e`akhkce]
.-5
?kik lnk_a`a ] e`akhkce] l]n] k^pan aooa b]jpope_k naoqhp]`k; Ai lneiaenk hqc]n( klan]lknfksbopl(eopk(_khk_]koabaepkojkhqc]n`]o_]qo]oapn]jobkni]aop]ohpei]o aiabaepko*Ah]klan]_kikkej_kjo_eajpa6aopab]^ne_]ei]cajoaoejpki]o7]mqah]b]^ne_] e`ae]oab]ho]o_]qo]he`]`ao* Lknatailhk(koajok_kiqiok_e]h]beni]mqa]iqhdanqioanbnceh(oajoeperk(ej) pqeperk(baepkl]n]]o`kqn]o`kh]na`]i]panje`]`aamqa(lkneook(bke`aopej]`](lknj]) pqnav](l]n]]re`]`kiope_](k_qe`]`k`ki]ne`ka`]b]ihe]*=ooei(kÎoanbaiejejkÏ _khk_]`k_kik_]qo]`]Îbqjkok_e]hbaiejej]Ï* Kn](deopkne_]iajpa(kmqak_knnaqbkeat]p]iajpak_kjpnnek6j]`ereokoatq]h)ok_e]h `kpn]^]hdkaj]`ereok`kolk`anaojkejpanekn`]b]ihe](]pne^qeq)oaiqhdanqihqc]n har]j`k)oaai_kjp]khqc]ni]o_qhejk7_kikaopaan]khqc]n`k`kijek(`]]qpkne`]`aa `klk`an(`aq)oaiqhdankhqc]noq^kn`ej]`ka]qtehe]n(]bqjk_kilhaiajp]na(reopk mqakjiank`a^n]kol]n]kpn]^]hdkal]n]]cqann]]qiajp]r]klk`anek`k_daba`] b]ihe]a_dabaiehep]n(]bqjknalnk`qpkn]`]iqhdanpknjkq)oaeilnao_ej`rah(pn]vaj`k _kik_kjoamqj_e]oq]`aoecj]klneknepne]l]n]]i]panje`]`a* Aop]^aha_e`]oaoo]o_kj`e aook_e]eo(an]lna_eoklanoq]`en]oiqhdanao`amqaoaqhq) c]naoq]bqjkjklnkrejd]i`kik`k`aknc]jev]kok_e]h(i]o`]j]pqnav](aan]i at_ahajpaoa`aoafraeo*L]n]eook(ikjpkq)oa]e`akhkce]`kÎoanbaiejejkÏa`]Îbqjkbaie) jej]Ï_kikj]pqn]eoajk_kikdeop ne_]oaok_e]eo*?kikoak^oanr](qi]raveilh]jp]`] qi]e`akhkce](l]oo]iko]pki]nkoabaepkolah]o_]qo]o* =oacqj`]i]jaen]`aklan]n`]e`akhkce]]lnk`qk`kfj^dfkoflpl`f^i(lkniaek `]ei]cej]knalnk`qpkn]*Na_khdaj`k]oei]cajo`enap]oaeia`e]p]o`]atlanej_e]ok) _e]h$eopk(`kik`k_kikreraiko]onah] aook_e]eo%(]e`akhkce]]onalnk`qv(i]opn]jo) bkni]j`k)]ojqi_kjfqjpk_kanajpa(h ce_kaoeopaipe_k`ae`ae]omqabqj_ekj]iai`keo naceopnko6_kiknalnaoajp] ao`]na]he`]`a$oeopai]atlhe_]perkkqpa ne_k%a_kikjkni]o anacn]o`a_kj`qp]a_kilknp]iajpk$oeopai]lnao_neperk`ajkni]oar]hknao%*Nalnaoaj) p] ao( jkni]o a r]hknao bkni]i qi pa_e`k `a ei]cajo mqa atlhe_]i pk`] ] na]he`]`a a lnao_narail]n]pk`]]ok_ea`]`akmqaah]`araa_kik`aralajo]n(b]h]n(oajpena]cen*= e`akhkce]]ooacqn](]pk`ko(ik`ko`aajpaj`an]na]he`]`aa`aoa_kilknp]njah]kq`e]jpa `ah](aheiej]j`k`re`]o(]joea`]`ao(]jcope]o(]`ien] ao(k_qhp]j`k]o_kjpn]`e ao`] re`]ok_e]h(^ai_kik]o_kjpn]`e aoajpnaaop]a]oe`ae]omqaoqlkop]iajpa]atlhe_]i a_kjpnkh]i* Ajbei(qi]pan_aen]i]jaen]`aklan]k`]e`akhkce]krplalpfik`fl*Qiei]cejnek ok_e]hoal]na_a_kiqi]bn]oaj]mq]hjaipq`k`epk(jailk`aoan`epk(lknmqa(oapq`k bkooa `epk( ] bn]oa lan`ane] ] _kanj_e]( pknj]n)oa)e] ej_kanajpa a _kjpn]`ep ne]( a jejcqi ]_na`ep]ne]jah]*=_kanj_e]a]qje`]`a`kei]cejnekok_e]hkqe`akhkce]ri(lknp]jpk(`k mqaoehaj_e]`k* Lknatailhk(]e`akhkce]]beni]mqak]`qhpnekbaiejejk_neia$p]jpk]ooeimqadk) iajomqai]p]i]aolko]ak]i]jpa`ah]ok_kjoe`an]`koejk_ajpaolknmqaln]pe_]n]i qi]pkÎaijkia`]dkjn]Ï%(mqa]rencej`]`abaiejej]lna_eko]amqakdkikooatq]heo) ikqi]lanranokaqi]`kaj]cn]ra$pkcn]ramqa(l]n]]hcqjo(@aqonaokhraqlqjenko dkikooatq]eoajre]j`k]laopa(eopk(]=e`o%* K mqa aop oaj`k oehaj_e]`k lah] e`akhkce]; Ko ikperko lahko mq]eo( ai jkoo] ok_ea) `]`a(krj_qhkajpnaoatkalnk_ne]kpkeilknp]jpa$_keo]mqajk]_kjpa_aaipk`]o ]ook_ea`]`ao(i]o]laj]oai]hcqi]o(_kik]jkoo]%*Jkoo]ok_ea`]`aateca]lnk_ne]k hacpei]ahac]hÍ]mqaoana]hev]lahkoh]ko`k_]o]iajpkÍ(lknmqaah]c]n]jpa(l]n]] _h]ooa`kiej]jpa(]pn]joieook`k_]lep]h]kodan`aenko*=ooeioaj`k(k]`qhpnekbaiejejk a]lan`]`]rencej`]`aoklaneckokol]n]k_]lep]hal]n]]pn]joieookhac]h`]nemqav]7 lkneook(klneiaenkoapknj]_neiaa]oacqj`]r]hknev]`]_kikrenpq`aoqlnai]`]oiq) hdanaofkrajo*
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
Aijkoo]ok_ea`]`a(]nalnk`qk`]bkn]`apn]^]hdkoab]vlahk]qiajpk`kjiank `apn]^]hd]`knaoa(lknp]jpk(]lnk_ne]k_kjoe`an]`]bqj`]iajp]hl]n]k]qiajpk`k_]) lep]h(mqalna_eo]`]ik`ak^n]*Lknaooaikperk(pk`]oatq]he`]`amqajkoana]hev]n_ki bej]he`]`analnk`qper]oan_kjoe`an]`]]jkni]h(lanrano]a`kajpe](`kj`a]_kj`aj]k `kdkikooatq]heoik* =e`akhkce]lan`ane]oq] bkn] a _kanj_e] oa are`aj_e]ooa aoo]o _keo]o a lkn eook ]o oehaj_e]*
E`akhkce]aej_kjo_eajpa =e`akhkce]oa]ooaiahd]]]hcqjo]ola_pko`kej_kjo_eajpaloe_]j]hpe_k*D(lahkia) jko(pnooaiahd]j]olnej_el]eoajpnaahao6 -*
kb]pk`amqa]`kp]iko_naj]o(kleje ao(e`ae]ooaio]^an`akj`arean]i(oailajo]n aioq]o_]qo]oaikperko(oai]r]he]noaokkqjk_kanajpaoaran`]`aen]o7
.* e`akhkce] a ej_kjo_eajpa klan]i ]pn]ro `k ei]cejnek $]o nalnaoajp] ao a nacn]o o]`]o `] atlanej_e] eia`e]p]% a `k oehj_ek( na]hev]j`k)oa ej`enap]iajpa lan]jpa ] _kjo_ej_e]* B]h]iko( ]ceiko( lajo]iko( paiko _kilknp]iajpko a lnpe_]o mqa jko l]na_ailanbaep]iajpaj]pqn]eoan]_ekj]eolknmqa]ok_ea`]`akonalapa(ko]_aep](ko ej_qpaaij olah]b]ihe](lah]ao_kh](lahkohernko(lahkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k(lah]o nah] ao`apn]^]hdk(lah]olnpe_]olkhpe_]o*Qirq`aei]cajoaop]^aha_e`]oejpan) l a)oaajpnajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]a]na]he`]`a7 /* ej_kjo_eajpa a e`akhkce] jk ok `ahe^an] ao rkhqjpne]o* K ej_kjo_eajpa mob`fp^ `a ei]cajo(oq^opepqpko(okjdko(h]loko(]pkob]hdko(oejpki]o(oq^hei] aol]n]i]jebao) p]n)oaa(]kiaoikpailk(ao_kj`an)oa`]_kjo_ej_e]*=e`akhkce]mob`fp^`]oe`ae]o)ei]) cajo(`]ejranok`a_]qo]oaabaepko(`koehj_ekl]n]i]jebaop]nkoejpanaooao`]_h]ooa `kiej]jpaaao_kj`)hko_kikejpanaooao`aqi]je_]_h]ooaok_e]h*
Ancqaj`kkrq(pen]j`k]io_]n]
@
e]jpa`klk`an`kej_kjo_eajpaa`]e`akhkce](lk`an]ikooanhar]`ko]Îajpnac]n kolkjpkoÏ(`evaj`k6ÎL]n]mqap]jpkaobknkj]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(oa(]bej]h( pq`kehqok(rqaio_]n];Ï(ÎL]n]mqa_kilnaaj`an]]pere`]`a`]_kjo_ej_e](oa ah]]Ðlk^na_kep]`]Ñ(aolnaie`]ajpnake`akoqlanack(aoi]c]`]ajpna]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa akoe`a hkcko;Ï* Pk`]re](qi]lancqjp]p]i^ilkoorah6Î?kik(oaj`k]_kjo_ej_e]pkbnceh(kej) _kjo_eajpaa]e`akhkce]pklk`ankoko(Bnaq`aI]nt_dac]n]i]_kjda_)hko(atlhe_]noaqo ik`ko`abqj_ekj]iajpkaoq]obej]he`]`ao;Ï* Jk_]ok`aBnaq`(bkn]i]lnpe_]i`e_]a]^qo_]`aqi]p_je_]pan]lqpe_]l]n]ej) `er`qkomqalaniepen]i]`ao_k^anp]`kej_kjo_eajpaakpn]^]hdkpa ne_kmqa`aqknecai loe_]jheoa*Jk_]ok`aI]nt(bke]`a_eok`a_kilnaaj`an]na]he`]`a]l]npen`]lnpe_] lkhpe_]`aqi]_h]ooaok_e]h$kopn]^]hd]`knao%mqalaniepeq]lan_alk`koia_]jeoiko `a`kiej]kaatlhkn]kok_e]eo(`akj`aoqnceq]bkniqh]kpa ne_]`]e`akhkce]* =^qo_]`]_qn]`kookbneiajpkolomqe_ko(aiBnaq`(a]hqp]lah]ai]j_el]k`koat) lhkn]`ko(aiI]nt(_ne]n]i_kj`e aol]n]qi]pki]`]`a_kjo_ej_e]lah]mq]hkoqfaepk `k_kjda_eiajpkl`ana_kia]n]_npe_]`]oehqo aoa`kolna_kj_aepkomqaeje_e]n]`ao`a ]Cn_e](i]o(]ckn](_kik_npe_]`aoq]oln lne]oehqo aoalna_kj_aepko* Aihqc]n`aejr]he`]n]n]vk(]nabhatk(klajo]iajpka]^qo_]`]ran`]`a(]o`ao_k) ^anp]o`kej_kjo_eajpaa`]e`akhkce]bevan]ikoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpklan_a^an]o_kj`e) aoÍlomqe_]o(ok_e]eo(deop ne_]oÍj]omq]eok_kjda_eiajpkaklajo]iajpkoana]hev]i*
..,
=lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpkx#!0É45,/ßx
15%34¬%3
#!0É45,/ß =lnak_ql]k_kik_kjda_eiajpk -* Mqamqan`evan_koikhkce];Akjpkhkce]; .* AimqaDan_hepkaL]nije`ao`eo_kn`]i;Aimqa _kj_kn`]i; /* ?kik@ai _nepkatlhe_]]`ebanaj]ajpnalan_alk alajo]iajpk; 0* Mq]h ] lkoek `ko okÚop]o ] naolaepk `k _kjda_e) iajpk; 1* LknmqaO _n]paooakl a]kookÚop]o; 2* Kmqaok]enkje]a]i]eqpe_]ok_npe_]o; 3* Mq]eokocn]qo`a_kjda_eiajpkl]n]Lh]pk; 4* Oacqj`kLh]pk(kmqa_kjda_aikoai_]`]cn]q`k _kjda_eiajpk; 5* Atlhemqa ] `eopejk lh]p je_] ajpna _kjda_eiajpk oajoraha_kjda_eiajpkejpahecrah* -,* Mq]eokocn]qo`k_kjda_eiajpkl]n]=neop pahao; --* Oacqj`k=neop pahao(kmqa_kjda_aikoai_]`]cn]q `k_kjda_eiajpk;?kikoa`eopejcqaiaoanah]_ek) j]ikocn]qo`k_kjda_eiajpk; -.* Oacqj`k=neop pahao(kmqa_kjda_aikolknejpqek ejpaha_pq]h; -/* =lnaoajpa]hcqjo`kolnej_lekocan]eook^nak_kjda) _eiajpkbkniqh]`kolahklajo]iajpkcnack* -0* Mq]eokopnolnej_el]eo_]ilko`ko]^anbkniqh]`ko lkn=neop pahao; -1* ?kikk_neope]jeoik_kj_a^akooanaodqi]jko; -2* Mqa lnk^hai]o jkrko l]n] k _kjda_eiajpk bkn]i pn]ve`kolahk_neope]jeoik; -3* Lknmqa]b]ooqieqqihqc]npkeilknp]jpal]n]k _kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk; -4* Atlhemqa]`ebanaj]ajpnaran`]`ao`abaran`]`ao `an]vk* -5* Atlhemqakmqak_neope]jeoikajpaj`alknlaook]a ]o_kjoamqj_e]o`aoo]e`ae]l]n]k_kjda_eiajpk* .,* Lknmqa]lancqjp]cnac]ok^nak_kjda_eiajpkan] Î_kikoklkooraeokannka]ehqokÏ; .-* Lknmqa]lancqjp]ik`anj]ok^nak_kjda_eiajpk Î_kikk_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenklkoorahÏ; ..* Lkn mqa ] ]qpkne`]`a pejd] l]lah lnalkj`an]jpa j] _kj_alkia`ear]h`]ran`]`a; ./* MqaÚvan]ikoÚh okbkoik`anjko`e]jpa`kl]lah`] ]qpkne`]`ajk_kjda_eiajpk; .0* LknmqakoÚh okbkoik`anjko_kia]ilah]pakne] `k_kjda_eiajpk; .1* Oacqj`kBn]j_eo>]_kj(mq]eookakmqaokko`khko; .2* L]n]>]_kj(mq]eo]olnej_el]eoÚj]he`]`ao`kipk`k; .3* Oacqj`k@ao_]npao(mq]eoko`keolnej_el]eolna_kj) _aepkomqaeila`aik_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk;
..-
.4* Lknmqa@ao_]npaofqhc]kipk`kja_aoonek; .5* K mqa @ao_]npao ajpaj`a lkn ipk`k; Mq]eo ]o pno _]n]_panope_]olnej_el]eo`]onacn]o`kipk`k; /,* Mq]eokok^faperko`kipk`k_]npaoe]jk; /-* Mq]eook]onacn]o`kipk`k_]npaoe]jk; /.* Mqa]`re`]iap `e_]; //* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaklajo]iajpk`a@ao_]npaoak lajo]iajpk`aHk_ga; /0* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaklajo]iajpk`aHk_gaaklaj) o]iajpk`a=neop pahao; /1* ?kikHk_gaatlhe_]]bkni]k`]oe`ae]o; /2* LknmqaHk_gaqiaileneop]; /3* LknmqaHk_gaqijkiej]heop]; /4* Mq]h ] `ebanaj] lnej_el]h ajpna aileneoik a n]_ek) j]heoik; /5* Kmqa]_kjo_ej_e]`aoenaÛater]kqkoqfaepk`k _kjda_eiajpk; 0,* Kmqa]_kjo_ej_e]`aoe_kik_kjo_ej_e]loe_kh ) ce_]; 0-* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnakoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkak aqloe_kh ce_k; 0.* Kmqa]_kjo_ej_e]`aoeikn]hkqpe_]; 0/* Kmqa]_kjo_ej_e]`aoelkhpe_]; 00* Mq]eookkocn]qo`]_kjo_ej_e]; 01* @atailhko`ko`ebanajpaocn]qo`a_kjo_ej_e]* 02* @a]_kn`k_ki]bajkiajkhkce](kmqa]ejpaj_ek) j]he`]`a`]_kjo_ej_e];
#!0É45,/ß =lan_alk -* Mqa]oajo]k; .* Lknmqa]oajo]k]i^cq]; /* Lknmqaoa`evmqa]lan_alk]ojpaoa`aiqep]o oajo] aooeiqhpja]o; 0* ?kikkoaileneop]oatlhe_]i]oajo]k; 1* ?kikkoejpaha_pq]heop]oatlhe_]i]oajo]k; 2* Mq]eo]o_npe_]omqa]loe_khkce]`]bkni]a]bajk) iajkhkce]Úvan]i]aileneop]oaejpaha_pq]heop]ojk pk_]jpa oajo]ka lan_alk; 3* ?kik]caop]hpa]bajkiajkhkce]atlhe_]i]oajo]) ka]lan_alk; 4* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`]lan_alk; 5* Ao_khd] ]hcqi]o `]o _]n]_panope_]o `] lan_alk a atlhemqa)]o* -,* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqaÎdqiÐiqj`klan_a^e`kÑ(mqa paikoe`ae]ooajoraeokqoecjeÚ_] aolan_alper]oÏ; --* @klkjpk`areop]`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(mq]eo ok]olnej_el]eopakne]ook^na]lan_alk; -.* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnalan_alkalajo]iajpk;
x5.)$!$%ßxK_kjda_eiajpk
#!0É45,/ß =ei]cej]k -* ?kikkoaileneop]o_kj_a^ai]ei]cej]k; .* ?kikkoejpaha_pq]heop]o_kj_a^ai]ei]cej]k; /* Lknmqa(j]pn]`ekÚhko Ú_](]ei]cej]kan]_kjoe) `an]`]qi]lan_alkajbn]mqa_e`];Iaj_ekja]hcqjo lnk^hai]omqaaoo]_kj_alkjklk`e]naokhran* 0* ?kik]bajkiajkhkce]_kj_a^a]ei]cej]k; 1* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]ei]cej]k`ebana`]lan_al) klknmqa]ei]cej]kjkk^oanr]akei]cej]`k jkk^oanrrah; 2* Mqa oecjeÚ_] `evan mqa ] ei]cej]k `ebana `] lan) _alklknmqa]ei]caiqi]jhkck`k]qoajpa; 3* Atlhemqa a atailheÚmqa ] _]l]_e`]`a enna]hev]`kn] `]ei]cej]k* 4* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaokjdk(]npaahkq_qn]; 5* Mq]eookkopelkokqik`]he`]`ao`aei]cej]k; -,* Ao_khd]pnoik`]he`]`ao`aei]cej]kaatlhemqa)]o* --* Mq]hkl]lah`]ei]cej]kl]n]k_kjda_eiajpk;
#!0É45,/ß =hejcq]cai -* Atlkjd]]oe`ae]o`a]hcqjoÚh okbkook^na]eilkn) pj_e]`]hejcq]cai* .* LknmqaLh]pkoanabana hejcq]cai_kikld ni]gkj; /* Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`kiepk^^he_k`]Pknna`a>]^ah; 0* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqakiepki]jebaop]]bkn]na]he) v]`kn]`]hejcq]cai; 1* Mqa oecjeÚ_] `evan mqa ] hejcq]cai pai qi lk`an aj_]jp]p nek;?kikaooalk`anoai]jebaop]; 2* Mqaokl]h]rn]op]^qo;@]hcqjoatailhko* 3* Lknmqajk`enaepk]jpeck]l]na_e]klk`anice_k)nahe) cekok`]hejcq]cai; 4* Mqamqan`evanhcko; 5* Atlhemqa]`eopejkajpnahejcq]caiahjcq]o* -,* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eonaolkop]ol]n]]lancqjp]ok^na] knecai`]hejcq]cai; --* Kmqa]hejcq]cai; -.* Atlhemqalknmqa]hejcq]caiqioeopai]* -/* Atlhemqakmqaokkooecjko* -0* Atlhemqa]obqj ao`ajkp]per](_kjkp]per]a_kiqje) _]per]`]hejcq]cai* -1* ?kikkaileneop]atlhe_]]hejcq]cai; -2* Lknmqako`eopn^eko`ahejcq]caibkn]ieilknp]j) paol]n]koaileneop]o; -3* ?kikkoejpaha_pq]heop]oatlhe_]i]hejcq]cai; -4* Lknmqak_]ok`aDahajGahhanbkeeilknp]jpal]n]ko ejpaha_pq]heop]o; -5* Mq]eokolkjpko_kiqjoj]o_kj_al ao`ahejcq]cai `aaileneop]oaejpaha_pq]heop]o;?kikaoo]o_kj_al) ao_kjoe`an]ik]ola_pk_kjkp]perk`]hejcq]cai;
.,* Aimqaoa^]oa]r]klkoepereoikh ce_kl]n]lnklkn qi]lqneÚ_]k`]hejcq]cai; .-* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqaklkoepereoikh ce_k`]r]j) b]oa oejp]tah ce_]; ..* Mq]eo]oheiep] aoakoamqrk_ko`klkoepereoikh ) ce_k; ./* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eoe`ae]o`]hejcqope_]; .0* Ao_khd]pnoe`ae]o`]hejcqope_]aatlhemqa)]o* .1* Atlhemqakmqaqioecjkhejcqope_kkqran^]h* .2* Kmqaan]]_kj_alk^ejne]`koecjkkq`]hejcq]) cai; .3* Mq]hkl]lah`koajpe`ka`]ooecjeÚ_] aol]n]oal]oo]n `aqi]_kj_alk^ejne]`]hejcq]cai _kj_alk panjne](j]mq]hoa_kilnaaj`amqadqi]ejpan)nah]) k_kjpjq]ajpnal]h]rn]o(na]he`]`aalajo]iajpko; .4* ?kjoe`an]j`k ] bkni] panjne] `] hejcq]cai( _kik lk`aiko_kj_a^)h]; .5* Mq]eokomq]pnkb]pknaomqa_kjopepqai]hejcq]cai; /,* Ao_khd]`keo`aooaob]pknaoaatlhemqa)ko*
#!0É45,/ßß Klajo]iajpk -* ?epa]hcqjoatailhko`kornekooajpe`komqa`]iko
ol]h]rn]olajo]iajpkalajo]naijkoo]re`]_kpe) `e]j]* .* Mq]eo ko lnej_el]eo oajpe`ko mqa ko `e_ekjneko `k l]n]]ol]h]rn]olajo]nalajo]iajpk; /* MqaoecjeÚ_]ikoran^kolajo]na(_kcep]naaejpahhe) cana; Mq]j`k naqjeiko oaqooajpe`ko( mqa oecjeÚ_] Îlajo]iajpkÏ; 0* ?kik]loe_khkce]_kj_a^a]ejpahecj_e]; 1* Mq]eo]o`ebanaj]oajpnaejopejpkad^epk; 2* Mq]eo]ooaiahd]j]oajpnaejopejpkad^epk; 3* ?kikalknmqa]ejpahecj_e]`ebana`kejopejpka`k d^epk; 4* Mqa]ejpahecj_e]lnpe_]kqejopnqiajp]h; 5* ?kiklk`aiko`aÚjen]ejpahecj_e]ajmq]jpk]pere) `]`aiajp]ha`ahejcq]cai;Mqamqanaiko`evan]k b]h]nikoaiÎ_kjda_eiajpkejpahecajpaÏ; -,* Atlhemqalknmqaklajo]iajpkr]ei]eohkjca`kmqa ]ejpahecj_e]* --* Mqaqi_kj_aepkkqe`ae]; -.* Mqaokkofqvko; -/* Mq]j`kkofqvko_kjopepqaiqi]pakne]; -0* Mqaqi]pakne];@akj`aah]j]o_a; -1* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eoÚj]he`]`ao`kipk`kl]n]k_k) jda_eiajpk;Lknmqaoa`evmqaahapaiqil]lahna) cqh]`kn; -2* Atlhemqakmqaokipk`k`a`qperk(ipk`kej`qpe) rkaipk`k`a_kilnaajokaejpanlnap]k* -3* Lknmqakipk`kj]o_ej_e]oat]p]op]i^i_d]) i]`k`a]tekipe_k;
...
-4* Lkn mqa k ipk`k j]o _ej_e]o j]pqn]eo p]i^i _d]i]`k`aatlaneiajp]hadelkppe_k; -5* Lkn mqa k ipk`k j]o _ej_e]o dqi]j]o p]i^i _d]i]`k`a_kilnaajoerk)ejpanlnap]perk; .,* Mq]eokopn]ko_kiqjo]ko`ebanajpaoipk`koÚhk) o Ú_ko; .-* ?kik ] jaqnkhkce]( ] ]j]pkie] a ] Úoekhkce] `k _) na^nkdqi]jkk`ao_narai;Mq]eo]o_kjoamqj_e]o `aoo]`ao_nekl]n]`eopejcqenikoej`er`qkoa_qh) pqn]olahkpelk`alajo]iajpkmqa`aoajrkhrai; ..* Oacqj`kHre)Opn]qoo(mq]eook]opnolnej_el]eo_]) n]_panope_]okqbqj ao`kiepk; ./* Ao_khd]qiiepkaikopna_kikahaatlhe_]qi]na]) he`]`a* .0* Atlhemqalknmqakiepkqi]na`a`aiapbkn]oa `aoi^khkomqalna_eo]ioan`a_ebn]`kokqejpanlna) p]`ko*
#!0É45,/ß =_kjo_ej_e]lk`a_kjda_anpq`k; -* Oacqj`kBnaq`(mq]eook]opnobane`]oj]n_oe_]omqa klajo]iajpkk_e`ajp]heil o]kooanaodqi]jko; .* KmqaeookmqaBnaq`_d]ikq`aloe_]jheoa; /* ?kikBnaq`_dackq]k_kj_aepk`aej_kjo_eajpa; 0* ?kikBnaq``ao_nara]aopnqpqn]akbqj_ekj]iajpk `]re`]lomqe_]; 1* Mq]eo]ob]oao`]oatq]he`]`aejb]jpeh(oacqj`kBnaq`; 2* Lkn mqa k _kilhatk `a `elk k _kilhatk jq_ha]n `]ojaqnkoao;Mq]j`kaooa_kilhatkoa`aoajrkhra;
../
3* Lknmqa(oacqj`kBnaq`(kackkq]_kjo_ej_e]qi Îlk^na_kep]`kÏ; 4* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna_kjpa`ki]jebaopka_kjpa) `kh]pajpa`ajkooko]pko(caopko(l]h]rn]o(okjdko; 5* ?kik klan] k ej_kjo_eajpa $e` a oqlanack%; Mq]h ] bqjk`kookjdko(`kooejpki]oa`]oq^hei]k; -,* @e]jpa `k lk`an `k ej_kjo_eajpa( Bnaq` `abaj`aq ] bkn]`klajo]iajpk*Lknmq; --* Kmqa]heaj]knaheceko];A]heaj]kaican]h; -.* Mq]hkejpanaooa`aI]ntlah]]heaj]kok_e]h; -/* ?kik I]nt atlhe_] ] knecai `] ]heaj]k ok_e]h _ki ^]oa j] `ao_nek `k oqnceiajpk `]o ejopepqe) aook_e]eoalkhpe_]obqj`]`]oj]`ereok`]o_h]o) oaook_e]eo; -0* Lknmqa]]Úni]kÎkodkiajob]vai]deop ne](i]o jko]^aimqa]b]vaiÏ]ooej]h]]ateopj_e]`aqi] `qlh]]heaj]kok_e]h; -1* Mq]eo ok ]o pno bkni]o `] ]heaj]k jk ik`k `a lnk`qk_]lep]heop]; -2* Kmqae`akhkce];?kikah]oqnca; -3* Mq]h]lnej_el]hbqjk`]e`akhkce];Mq]hoq]lnej_e) l]hÚj]he`]`a; -4* Atlhemqa_kikejranok(ei]cejnekok_e]haoehj_ek okkolnej_el]eolnk_a`eiajpkol]n]]klan]k`] e`akhkce]* -5* Mq]eo ]o oaiahd]j]o ajpna ] e`akhkce] a k ej_kjo) _eajpa`ao_k^anpklah]loe_]jheoa; .,* =o`ao_k^anp]o`aI]ntaBnaq`ejr]he`]ikpn]^]hdk _kjo_eajpa`klajo]iajpk;
5NIDADEß
=iap]boe_] Ejpnk`qk
=oej`]c] aoiap]boe_]o
?]lpqhk-
Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]
?]lpqhk.
=iap]boe_]`a=neop pahao
?]lpqhk/
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]
?]lpqhk0
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailknja]
?]lpqhk1
=behkokbe]l o)iap]boe_]
Jk okiko qi] _kjo_e j_e] naÛater] lqn]( i]o qi] _kjo_e j_e] aj_]nj]`] jqi _knlk* Jkook _knlk jk ]laj]o qi] _keo] j]pqn]h( p]h _kik ] b oe_]( ] ^ekhkce] a ] loe_khkce] k aopq`]i( i]o qi _knlk dqi]jk( eopk ( d]^ep]`k a]jei]`klknqi]_kjo_e j_e]*Jkokikolajo]iajpklqnk(lkeookikoqi _knlk* Jk okiko qi] _keo] j]pqn]h( lkeo okiko qi] _kjo_e j_e]* K iqj`k jk qi_kjfqjpk`a_keo]oab]pkoaopq`]`kolah]o_e j_e]ooacqj`knah]ao `a_]qo]aabaepkahaeoj]pqn]eo*=h i`kiqj`k_kik_kjfqjpkn]_ekj]h`ab]) pko_eajp Ú_ko(dkiqj`k_kikhqc]nkj`areraiko_kikokqpnkoank`a]`ko lah]o_keo]o(qiiqj`kmq]hep]perk`a_knao(okjo(k`knao(Úcqn]o(Úoekjkie]o( k^op_qhko(qiiqj`k]baperk`alaook]o(hqc]nao(hai^n]j]o(lnkiaoo]o(aola) n]j]o(_kjÛepko(hqp]o*Okikooanaopailkn]eoÍj]o_aikoapaiko_kjo_e j_e] `]iknpa*Okikooanaoejpanoq^faperkoÍreraikoj]_kil]jde]`kokqpnko*Ok) ikooanao_qhpqn]eoÍ_ne]iko]hejcq]cai(kpn]^]hdk(]ok_ea`]`a(]nahecek(] lkh pe_](] pe_](]o]npaoa]op _je_]o(]ÚhkokÚ]a]o_e j_e]o*
Ai-53,(kbkpcn]bkf]lkj oGajKd]n](n]`e_]`kjkoAop]`koQje`ko(lq^he_kqkhernkKja$Qi%*=hi`k ppqhk(jkd jajdqikqpnkpatpk]khkjck`aoq]o1,,l cej]o(]laj]obkpkoai^n]j_kalnapk`ankopko ajmq]`n]`kooailna`]iaoi]i]jaen](`aet]j`kreoraeoat_hqoer]iajpakokhdko(kj]neva]^k_]*=mqe aopknalnk`qve`]o]o`kvalneiaen]ol cej]o`khernk* Jaoo]lk_](kiqj`k]pn]raoo]r]qiikiajpk`aa^qhek_qhpqn]h(aimqa]_kj`ekateopaj_e]h`]o laook]oaop]r]aitamqa*Khernk`aKd]n]pn]`qvaoo]_kjo_e j_e]`aqi`qlhkrapkn`]ateop j_e]6ÎqiÏ oecjeÚ_] p]jpk mqa _]`] laook] je_] ai oq]o oejcqh]ne`]`ao _kik p]i^i mqa okiko pk`ko ecq]eo( l]npehd]j`kqi]e`ajpe`]`adqi]j]_kiqi*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
)NTRODUljO =oej`]c]aoiap]boe_]o =mqaopkiap]boe_]6ÎKmqa;Ï
L
knmqaqi]_keo]lk`aiq`]na(jkajp]jpk(_kjoanr]noq]e`ajpe`]`aej`ere`q]h(`a p]hi]jaen]mqalk`aiko`evanmqa]jbpj^_keo](]ej`]mqa]raf]iko`ebanajpa`k mqabkn]]jpao;?kiko]^aikomqaqi]`apaniej]`]nkoaen]]iaoi]mqa(jk]jk l]oo]`k(jkl]oo]r]`aqin]ik_kilkq_]obkhd]oaoaibhkn;?kiko]^aikomqaL]qhk( dkfa]`qhpk(kiaoikL]qhkmqa_kjda_aiko_ne]j]; Lknmqaoejpkmqaoaemqaokq`ebanajpa`]o_keo]o;Lkni(lknmqap]i^ioejpkmqa oaemqaqikqpnk_knlk(`ebanajpaaoaiahd]jpa]kiaq(jkqi]_keo](i]oqi]hcqi; Lknmqaaqakkqpnklk`aikoran`aik`k`ebanajpa(oajpenackop]n`aik`k`ebanajpa( `eo_kn`]nok^nap]jp]o_keo]o(b]van_keo]o`ebanajpaoa(jkajp]jpk(]i^ko]`iepeiko(oai oki^n]`a`re`](mqaqipne jcqhk(kjiank1(k_n_qhk(ko]n_ko`kL]h_ek`]=hrkn]`] kq]olen ie`ao`kAcepkokat]p]iajpa]oiaoi]o_keo]ol]n]ahaal]n]iei; Kmqaqi]_keo];Aqik^fapk;Kmqa]oq^fapere`]`a;Kmqak_knlkdqi]jk;A qi]_kjo_ej_e]; Lancqjp]o _kik aoo]o _kjopepqai k _]ilk `] iap]boe_]( ]ej`] mqa jai oailna ]o iaoi]ol]h]rn]opajd]ioe`kqo]`]ol]n]bkniqh)h]o* Lknatailhk(qibeh okbkcnackjkb]h]ne]aiÎj]`]Ï(i]oaiÎJkOanÏ*Jkb]h]ne] aiÎk^fapkÏ(i]oaiÎajpaÏ(lkeo]l]h]rn]l_gbqlo bkeqo]`]]l]npen`]E`]`aI`e]a(jk oajpe`kaimqa]ailnac]ikodkfa(o bkeqo]`]`alkeo`ko_qhkTREE* P]i^ijkb]h]ne]aiÎ_kjo_ej_e]Ï(i]oaimpv`e(eopk(aiÎ]hi]Ï*F]i]eob]h]ne] aiÎoq^fapere`]`aÏ(lkeoaoo]l]h]rn](_kikoajpe`kmqahda`]ikodkfa(o bkeqo]`]]l]n) pen`ko_qhkTREEE*=iq`]j]`krk_]^qhnek`]behkokbe]jk_qnok`koo_qhkoej`e_]mqa iq`]n]ikoik`ko`abkniqh]n]omqaop aoanaolkj`)h]o(lkeo]behkokbe]aopj]deop ne] alkooqeqi]deop ne]*Jkajp]jpk(ok^aoo]oiq`]j]olnkbqj`]o(lani]ja_aq]mqaopk iap]boe_]bqj`]iajp]h6Lnrbqo_]]aooj_e]`aqiajpa kq`aqi]_keo]*Lkneook(lknoankaopq`k`]lrp^alknmqa]lrp^kbana_akOanna]haran) `]`aenk`aqiajpa(kbana_aklkjpeikalanaja(]Behkokbe]Lneiaen]`arane]oan`aoecj]`] _ki]l]h]rn]lkqlildf^*Jaooa_]ok(]l]h]rn]jbq^cpf`^oane]]laj]o]ej`e_]k`khqc]n k_ql]`kj]oaop]jpaolahkohernko]neopkphe_ko`aBehkokbe]Lneiaen](hk_]hev]`ko`alkeo`ko pn]p]`kook^na]boe_]kq]j]pqnav]* = l]h]rn] lkqlildf^ `ene] mq]h k ]ooqjpk `] Behkokbe] Lneiaen]( ajmq]jpk ] l]h]rn] jbq^cpf`^`ene]]laj]omq]hkhqc]n`kohernko`]Behkokbe]Lneiaen]jk_]phkck`]ok^n]o `a=neop pahao* Lknmqa(ajpk(]pn]`ekbehko be_]_kjo]cnkq]l]h]rn]jbq^cpf`^airav`alkqlil* df^;Lknmqa=neop pahao(]k`abejen]Behkokbe]Lneiaen](p]i^i]benikqmqaah]aopq`]ko lneiaenkolnej_lekoa]o_]qo]olneiaen]o`apk`kokooanaokq`apk`]o]oaooj_e]o(aopq`k mqa`arasfo^kqbp`apk`kokokqpnko(lknmqa]_kj`ek`apk`koahao* Mqamqan`evanÎren]jpaoÐ;L]n]=neop pahao(oecjebe_]Îaop]n]_ei]`ko`ai]eo(aop]n ]hi`kmqarai`alkeo(oanoqlanekn]kmqarai`alkeo(oan]_kj`ek`]ateopj_e]a`k _kjda_eiajpk`kmqarai`alkeoÏ*Kn](]l]h]rn]jbq^mqan`evanat]p]iajpaeook6Îkmqa aop]hi`aÏ(Îkmqaaop]_ei]`aÏ(Îkmqarai`alkeoÏ(i]ojkoajpe`k`aoanoqlaneknkq `aoan]_kj`ek`a]hcqi]_keo]*Oa]ooei(ajpk]l]h]rn]jbq^cpf`^jkmqan`evan ]laj]okhqc]nkj`aoaaj_kjpn]ikoao_nepkolkopaneknao]kopn]p]`ko`aboe_](jkej`e_] qiiankhqc]njqi_]phkck`ak^n]o(i]ooecjebe_]Îkaopq`k`a]hcqi]_keo]mqaaop ]_ei]a]hi`]o_keo]oboe_]okqj]pqn]eoamqa]_kj`ek`]ateopj_e]a`k_kjda_e) iajpk`ah]oÏ* Lkneook(]pn]`ek_kjo]cnkq]l]h]rn]jbq^cpf`^i]eo`kmqa]l]h]rn]lkqlildf^*Jb* q^cpf`^(jaooa_]ok(mqan`evan6Î]mqehkmqa_kj`ekabqj`]iajpk`apq`kkmqaateopaa `apq`kkmqalq`anoan_kjda_e`kÏ* =p ]mqe naolkj`aiko lancqjp]6ÎLkn mqa iap]boe_] ai hqc]n `a kjpkhkce];Ï* I]o ]ej`]jknaolkj`aikolancqjp]lnej_el]h6ÎLknmqa]iap]boe_]kqkjpkhkce]k_qlkq khqc]nmqa(jkej_ek`]behkokbe](an]k_ql]`klah]_koikhkce]kqboe_];Ï*L]n]eook(lna_e) o]iko]_kil]jd]nkoikperkomqahar]n]i]qi]_neoa`]_koikhkce]a]koqnceiajpk`] kjpkhkce](mqa]_]^]ne]na_a^aj`kkjkia`aiap]boe_]*
./,
Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Koqnceiajpk`]kjpkhkce]6L]ni je`ao`aAhae]
M
q]j`kaopq`]ikokoqnceiajpk`]h ce_](reiko]eilknp j_e]`klajo]iajpk`a L]nije`ao*Bkeahaklneiaenkbeh okbk]]beni]nmqakiqj`klan_a^e`klknjkooko oajpe`ko Í k _koik aopq`]`k lah] _koikhkce] Í qi iqj`k ehqo nek( baepk `a ]l]nj_e]o(ok^na]omq]eobkniqh]ikojkoo]okleje ao*Bkeahap]i^iklneiaenk]_kjpn]) lkn]aooaiqj`kiqprah$baepk`aiq`]j]lanaja`ko_kjpnnekomqaoapn]jobkni]iqjo jkokqpnko%]e`ae]`aqilajo]iajpka`aqi`eo_qnokran`]`aenkonabane`komqehkmqa na]hiajpa(]kOanÍqlk)lk* KOan(`evL]nije`ao*?kieook(lnapaj`aq`evanmqakOanoailnae`jpe_k]oeiao) ik(eiqprah(apanjk(eilana_rah(ejreorah]kojkookooajpe`koareorah]laj]ol]n]klaj) o]iajpk*BkeL]nije`aoklneiaenk]`evanmqa]]l]nj_e]oajorah`]o_keo]o`]j]pqnav] jklkooqena]he`]`a(jkateopana]haran`]`aen]iajpa(kl*?kjpn]lo(]ooei(kOan$lk% ]kJkOan$jblk%(`a_h]n]j`k6ÎkJkOanjkÏ*=behkokbe]_d]i]`]lknL]nije`ao`a Î]Re]`]Ran`]`aÏ$^iqebf^%(mqajac]na]he`]`aa_kjda_eiajpkÎRe]`aKlejekÏ$au^%( lkeoaop]oak_ql]_ki]o]l]nj_e]o(_kikJkOan* Kn](]_koikhkce]kqboe_]k_ql]r])oafqop]iajpa_kikiqj`kmqalan_a^aikoajk mq]hreraiko_ki]o`ai]eo_keo]oj]pqn]eo*K_ql]r])oa_ki]j]pqnav]_kikqi_koik kqkn`ainacqh]na_kjop]jpa`aoqnceiajpk(pn]jobkni]ka`ao]l]na_eiajpk`]o_keo]o* =_koikhkce]^qo_]r]]atlhe_]kl]n]kabsfo(eopk(l]n]]iq`]j]`]o_keo]o(l]n]] l]oo]cai`aqi]_keo]]qikqpnkik`k`aateopen(_kjpnnek]kmqalkooq]*=_koikhkce] `a`e_]r])oaiqhpelhe_e`]`a`kooanao(iqp]^ehe`]`a`ahaoaoklkoe aoajpnaahao* L]nije`aopknjkq]_koikhkce]eilkoorah]k]beni]nmqaklajo]iajpkran`]`aenk ateca]e`ajpe`]`a(]jkpn]jobkni]ka]jk_kjpn]`ek`kOan*?kjoe`an]j`k]iq`]j] `aqi]_keo]aikqpn]_kjpnne]_kikkJkOan(L]nije`aop]i^i]beni]r]mqakOan jkiq`]lknmqajkpai_kikjailknmqaiq`]najkpaijkmqaiq`]n(lkeo(oaiq) `]ooa(`aet]ne]`aoankOan(pknj]j`k)oa_kjpnnek]oeiaoik(kJkOan*?kik_kjoamqj_e]( ikopnkqmqaklajo]iajpkran`]`aenkjk]`iepa]iqhpelhe_e`]`akqlhqn]he`]`a`aoanao amqakOanqjkaje_k* Ko]ncqiajpko`]Ao_kh]Aha]p]an]inecknkoko*@eve]i6 ]`iep]ikomqakOanjkoaf]qjk(i]oihpelhk*Jaooa_]ok(_]`]oanahaiaoika klkokqpnkooanao7lknp]jpk(_]`]oanakl]kiaoikpailk(kmqaeilajorah kq]^oqn`k*KOanqjkajklk`aoanihpelhk7 ]`iep]ikomqakOanjkoaf]apanjk(i]oparaqi_kiakapanqibei*=jpao`aha( kmqad]re];KqpnkOan;Jk(lkeokOanqjk*KJkOan;Jk(lkeokJkOankj]`]* Lknp]jpk(kOanjklk`apanpe`kqi_kiak*Panqibei;Oaperan(mqaren`alkeo `aha;KqpnkOan;Jk(lkeokOanqjk*KJkOan;Jk(lkeokJkOankj]`]*Lknp]jpk( kOanjklk`a]_]^]n*Oai_kiakaoaibei(kOanapanjk7 ]`iep]ikomqakOanjkoaf]eiqprah(i]oiqprah*JkmqakOaniq`]ne];Jkqpnk Oan;Jk(lkeokOanqjk*JkJkOan;Jk(lkeokJkOankj]`]*Lknp]jpk(oakOan iq`]ooa(pknj]n)oa)e]JkOana`ao]l]na_ane]*KOaneiqprahak`arenqi]ehqok `ajkookooajpe`ko* KmqaL]nije`ao]beni]r]an]]`ebanaj]ajpnambkp^oambo`b_bo*Lan_a^aiko]j]) pqnav]j]iqhpelhe_e`]`aaj]iqp]^ehe`]`a`]o_keo]omqaoapn]jobkni]iqi]oj]okqpn]o aoapknj]i_kjpnne]o]oeiaoi]o*I]olajo]ikokOan(eopk(]e`ajpe`]`a(]qje`]`a(] eiqp]^ehe`]`aa]apanje`]`a`]mqehkmqaaioeiaoik*Lan_a^anran]l]nj_e]o*Lajo]n _kjpailh]n]na]he`]`a_kike`jpe_]]oeiaoi]*Lajo]n_kjpailh]nkqlk(kOan* Iqhpelhe_e`]`a(iq`]j](j]o_eiajpkalana_eiajpkok]l]nj_e]o(ehqo ao`kooajpe) `ko*=k]^]j`kj)h]o(]behkokbe]l]ookq`]_koikhkce]kjpkhkce]*
./-
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
Lh]pkakiqj`k`]oaoo j_e]o
P
]i^i]kaopq`]niko]h ce_](reikomqaLh]pk`a`e_kq]oq]k^n]naokhqk`k eil]ooabehko be_k_ne]`klahk]jp]ckjeoikajpnaklajo]iajpk`aDan_hepk`abaok ak`aL]nije`ao`aAhae]* Lh]pk_kjoe`ankqmqaDan_hepkpejd]n]vkjkmqaoanabana]kiqj`ki]pane]haoaj) orah(iqj`k`]oei]cajoa`]okleje ao*=i]pne](`evLh]pk((lknaooj_e]alknj]pqnav]( ]hck eilanbaepk( mqa jk _kjoacqa i]jpan ] e`ajpe`]`a `]o _keo]o( iq`]j`k oai _aoo]n( l]oo]j`k`aqiaop]`k]kqpnk(_kjpnnekkqklkopk*Kiqj`ki]pane]hkq`ajkoo]atla) nej_e]oajorahiqpraha_kjpn]`ep neka(lkneook(`ahao jko_dac]i]o]l]nj_e]o`]o _keo]oaok^naahao lk`aikopankleje ao_kjpnne]oa_kjpn]`ep ne]o* Lknaooaikperk(`evLh]pk(L]nije`aoaop_anpk]katecenmqa]behkokbe]`ar]]^]j) `kj]naooaiqj`koajorahak_ql]n)oa_kikiqj`kran`]`aenk(ejreorah]kooajpe`koa reorah]laj]o]klqnklajo]iajpk*Kran`]`aenkkOan(qjk(eiqprah(e`jpe_k]oeiaoik( apanjk(eilana_rah(lqn]iajpaejpahecrah* Aeolknmqa]kjpkhkce]lh]pje_]ejpnk`qvqi]`ereokjkiqj`k(]beni]j`k]ateo) pj_e]`a`keoiqj`koejpaen]iajpa`ebanajpaoaoal]n]`ko6kjrkalpbkpsbi`]iq`]j]( `]]l]nj_e](`k`aren`ko_kjpnneko(akjrkalfkqbifdsbi`]e`ajpe`]`a(`]lani]jj_e]( `]ran`]`a(_kjda_e`klahkejpaha_pklqnk(oaijajdqi]ejpanbanj_e]`kooajpe`koa`]o kleje ao*Klneiaenkkjrkala^p`lfp^p*Koacqj`k(kjrkala^pfabf^pkqa^pbppk`f^p sboa^abfo^p*Kiqj`k`]oe`ae]okq`]oaooj_e]okiqj`k`kOan7kiqj`koajorah`]o _keo]okq]l]nj_e]okiqj`k`kJkOan*Kiqj`koajorahqi]oki^n](qi]_ le] `abkni]`]kqeilanbaep]`kiqj`kejpahecrah`]oe`ae]okqaooj_e]o* Jkp]iko(]mqe(qi]`ebanaj]ajpna]kjpkhkce]`aL]nije`aoa]`aLh]pk*L]n]klne) iaenk(kiqj`koajorah`]o]l]nj_e]okJkOanaioajpe`kbknpa(eopk(jkateopa(jkpai na]he`]`ajajdqi](kj]`]*L]n]Lh]pk(lkni(kJkOanjkklqnkj]`]*Aha]hcqi] _keo]*Kmqaaha;Ahallrqol`kOan(kmqa`ebanajpa`kOan(kmqaejbanekn]kOan(kmqajko ajc]j]ajkoehq`a(]_]qo]`koannko*Aihqc]n`aoanqilqnkj]`](kJkOanqic^iplpbo( qi]oki^n]`kOanran`]`aenk(]mqehkmqaLh]pk_d]i]`ampbral*Pbo*KJkOankoajorah* D]ej`]qi]kqpn]`ebanaj]eilknp]jpaajpna]kjpkhkce]`aL]nije`aoa]`aLh]) pk*Klneiaenk]beni]r]mqakOan(]hi`aeiqprah(apanjkae`jpe_k]oeiaoik(an]je_k kqqjk*D]re]lOan*Mq]hklnk^hai]`aoo]]beni]kl]niaje`a]j]; Oa(`kh]`k`k`arendan]_hepe]jk(d]re]qi]iqhpelhe_e`]`aejbejep]`aoanao_kjpnneko qjo]kokqpnkoa_kjpnneko]oeiaoiko(iqhpelhe_e`]`a_kjpn]`ep ne]mqajklk`ane]oan lajo]`]jai`ep](reopkmqaklajo]iajpkateca]e`ajpe`]`a`klajo]`k(jkajp]jpk(`k h]`k`]e`ajpe`]`aqj])je_]`aL]nije`ao(mqanaop]r]l]n]]behkokbe];O hdanaop]r]laj) o]na`evanpnobn]oao6ÎkOanÏ(ÎkJkOanjkÏaÎkOanqjk(e`jpe_k(apanjkaeiqprahÏ* Aioqi](]behkokbe]_kia]r]apaniej]r]jaoo]opnobn]oao(j]`]i]eolk`aj`klaj) o]nkq`evan*L]nije`aol]n]heo]r]]behkokbe]*Oaaop]mqeoaooalnkooacqen_kikejraopec]k `]ran`]`aaoaperaooai]eok^fapko]_kjda_an(an]lna_eokmqa^n]n]qje`]`a)qje_e`]`a`k Oan`aL]nije`ao*BkekmqabavLh]pk*Mqa`eooaaha; Ailneiaenkhqc]n(oacqej`kO _n]paoakookbeop]o(Lh]pk`eopejcqeqpnooajpe`kol]n] ]l]h]rn]pbo6koajpe`k`aoq^op]jperk(eopk(`ana]he`]`aateopajpa7koajpe`kran^]hbknpa( aimqaoecjebe_]ÎateopaÏapbomqan`evanÎateopj_e]Ï7akoajpe`kran^]hi]eobn]_k(aimqa kran^kpbokran^k`ahec]k(eopk(kran^kmqalaniepahec]nqioqfaepkaoaqlna`e_]`k* @eopejcqeq( ]ooei( ]hi `k oajpe`k oq^op]jper]`k $Îk oanÏ(Îqi oanÏ%( `keo oajpe`ko l]n] k ran^k6koajpe`kateopaj_e]hakoajpe`klna`e_]perk*Lknatailhk6ÎKdkiaiÏ$ateopa%aÎK dkiaijloq^iÏ$lkooqeqilna`e_]`k_kikl]npa`aoq]aooj_e]%* Aioacqj`khqc]n(]benikqmqa(jkoajpe`kbknpa`apbo$eopk(_kikoq^op]jperka_kik ran^kateopaj_e]h%(ateopaiihpelhkooanaoajkqio (i]o_]`]qi`ahaolkooqeko]pne^q) pko`kOan`aL]nije`ao$e`ajpe`]`a(qje`]`a(apanje`]`a(eiqp]^ehe`]`a%*Aooaooanaook ]ofabf^pkqcloj^pfkqbifdsbfp(pkp]hiajpaei]pane]eo(mqa_kjopepqaikiqj`kran`]`aenk( kiqj`kejpahecrah*
./.
Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Aipan_aenkhqc]n(]benikqmqa(jkoajpe`ki]eobn]_k`kran^kpbo(eopk(_kikran^k`a hec]kkq`]lna`e_]k(_]`]e`ae]qioqfaepkna]h(mqalkooqeqi_kjfqjpk`alna`e_]`ko na]eokq`alnklnea`]`aoaooaj_e]eoamqa]b]vaioankmqaah]aioeiaoi]*Qi]e`ae] $ateopa%aqi]e`ae]rj^bppk`f^kq_kjfqjpk`amq]he`]`aoaooaj_e]eomqa]b]vaioank mqaah]ja_aoo]ne]iajpa*Lknatailhk(]fqope]$d]e`ae]`afqope]%adoanaodqi]jko mqaplgrpqlp$lkooqaiklna`e_]`k`]fqope]_kikl]npa`aoq]aooj_e]%* @aoo]i]jaen](_]`]e`ae](aioeiaoi](_kikkOan`aL]nije`ao6qj](e`jpe_]] oeiaoi](apanj]aeiqprahÍqi]e`ae]*=kiaoikpailk(_]`]e`ae]`ebana`apk`]o]o kqpn]olahk_kjfqjpk`amq]he`]`aokqlnklnea`]`aoejpanj]oaja_aoone]olah]omq]eoah] qi]aooj_e]`apaniej]`](`ebanajpa`]o`ai]eo$]e`ae]`adkiai`ebanajpa`]e`ae]`a lh]jap](mqa`ebanajpa`]e`ae]`a^ahav](mqa`ebanajpa`]e`ae]`a_kn]cai(ap_*%* =p]nab]`]behkokbe]`qlh]6 -*
`ara_kjda_anmqae`ae]oateopai(eopk(mqae`ae]opl7
.* `ara_kjda_anmq]eook]omq]he`]`aokqlnklnea`]`aoaooaj_e]eo`aqi]e`ae](eopk( lnrbqi]e`ae](oq]aooj_e]*
Jk_ajpnk`aHkj`nao( aiLe_]`ehhu?en_qo( bkeanece`]qi] ao_qhpqn]`aAnko aidkiaj]cai]k _kj`a`aOd]bpao^qnu $-23-)-3-/%(beh okbk ejchomqaoqopajpkq klajo]iajpk _kjda_e`k_kik ikn]h`k oajpeiajpk*
.//
=oe`ae]okqbkni]oejpahecraeo$kqaooj_e]oejpahecraeo%(`evLh]pk(okoanaolanbae) pkoa(lknoq]lanbaek(pknj]i)oajlabilpfkqbifdsbfpkqm^o^afdj^pfkqbifdsbfplanbaepko mqa ]o _keo]o oajoraeo i]pane]eo pajp]i eiep]n eilanbaep]iajpa* K oajorah ( lkeo( qi] eiep]keilanbaep]`kejpahecrah6]o_keo]ooajoraeookei]cajo`]oe`ae]o(okJkOanao pajp]j`kejqpehiajpaeiep]n]lanbaek`kooanaoejpahecraeo* ?]^a behkokbe] l]oo]n `]o _ le]o eilanbaep]o ]ko ik`ahko lanbaepko( ]^]j`kj]j`k ]o fj^dbkplah]obppk`f^p(]olmfkfbplah]ofabf^p(]o^m^ok`f^plah]obppk`f^p*Klajo]iajpk( ailnac]j`k]`e]hpe_](`aral]oo]n`]fkpq^_fifa^ab`lkqo^afqof^a^p`lfp^ppbkpsbfpfabkqf* a^abo^`flk^ia^p`lfp^pfkqbifdsbfp(e`ajpe`]`a`]oe`ae]omqaok]na]he`]`a(koan(kqlk* Ko`ehkcko`aLh]pkl aiaii]n_d]]`e]hpe_](eopk(k_]iejdkoacqnk$jqelalp% mqajko_kj`qv`]ooajo] ao(`]olan_al ao(`]oei]cajoa`]okleje ao_kjpailh]k ejpaha_pq]h`koanna]h`]o_keo]o(e`ae]ran`]`aen](mqaateopaaioeiaoi]jkiqj`k`]o lqn]oe`ae]okqjkiqj`kejpahecrah* Pkiaiko qi `ehkck l]n] ]_kil]jd]niko k lnk_a`eiajpk lh]pje_k* L ?^knrbqb ^qo_]]e`ae]kq]aooj_e]`k]ikn* Jqi]baop](kbana_e`]lknqilkap]mqac]) jdkqqilnieklknoq]lkaoe](_kjrano]i_ej) _k]ieckoaO _n]pao*Qi`ahao]beni]mqapk`ko ko `aqoao na_a^ai dejko a lkai]o `a hkqrkn( i]ojajdqibkebaepk]kiahdkn`ko`aqoao(Anko( k]ikn*Lnkl a(ajpk(mqa_]`]qib]]qi]dk) iaj]cai]Anko`evaj`kkmqak]ikn* L]n] qi `ahao( k ]ikn k i]eo ^kj`kok `ko `aqoao( lknmqa jko har] ]k o]_neb_ek lahk oan ]i]`k( ejolen])jko k `arkp]iajpk a k `a) oafk `a b]van k ^ai* L]n] k oacqejpa( lna_eok `eopejcqen `keo pelko `a ]ikn6 k ]ikn oatq]h a cnkooaenka k]ikn aolenepq]hajpna ]o]hi]o( lkeoklneiaenk^naraahkck]_]^](ajmq]jpk koacqj`kapanjk*Fkpan_aenk]beni]mqako mqa k ]jpa_a`an]i pejd]i heiep]`k iqepk k ]ikn(pki]j`k)k]laj]o_kikqi]nah]kaj) pna`q]olaook]o*K]ikn(`evaha(kmqakn`aj]( knc]jev]akneajp]kiqj`k(lkeoahamqab]v kooaiahd]jpaooa]lnktei]naiako`ebanajpao oa ]b]op]nai* K ]ikn qi] bkn] _ oie_] `a kn`aiad]nikje]`kQjeranok* !DAMß7OOLFITT#ORBIS
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
Kmq]npklnabananapknj]n]k]iknajpna]olaook]oaj]nn]qiiepk*Jklnej_lek(ko dqi]jkoan]i`apnopelko6d]re]kdkiai`qlhk(]iqhdan`qlh]akdkiai)iqhdan(eopk (k]j`n cejk*Pejd]iqio _knlk(_ki`q]o_]^a]o(mq]pnk^n]koamq]pnklanj]o*?kik oafqhc]r]ioanao_kilhapko(`a_e`en]id]^ep]njk_q*Vaqo(nae`ko`aqoao(ajbqna_aq)oa( pkikq`aqi]aol]`]ako_knpkqlah]iap]`a* @a_]`ko(oal]n]`koa`aoaolan]`ko(kodqi]jkopane]i`ao]l]na_e`koaAnkojkhdao peraooa`]`k nckooatq]eoako]fq`]ooa]lnk_qn]n]iap]`alan`e`]*Komqaan]idkiajo `qlhko a iqhdanao `qlh]o ]i]i ko `a iaoik oatk( ajmq]jpk ko mqa an]i ]j`n cejko ]i]i]laook]`koatkklkopk*=i]naj_kjpn]n]jkoo]iap]`aak]iknaooaaj_kjpnk* Bej]hiajpa(klkap](]jbepnek`]baop](pki]]l]h]rn]`evaj`k6ÎPk`kokomqaialna_a) `an]ihkqr]n]ik]iknlahk^aimqab]v]kodqi]jko(i]ojajdqihkqrkqk]iknlknaha iaoik*kmqab]nae*K]ikn(Anko(ki]eo^ahk(kiahdkn`ko`aqoao*Ki]eo^ahk(lknmqa oailnafkraiaoqpeh(lknmqalajapn]eilan_alperahiajpaj]o]hi]o7kiahdkn(lknmqak`ae] ]rekhj_e]a]`aob]vkj`aateopen7ejolen]ko]npeop]oalkap]o(pn]vaj`k]^ahav]]kiqj`kÏ* Naop]O _n]pao* ÎJklk`anaeb]h]nÏ(`evaha*ÎJkpajdkp]hajpkl]n]b]van`eo_qnokopk^ahkoÏ* Kokqpnko(lkni(jkoa_kjbkni]iakk^nec]i]b]h]n* ÎAop^aiÏ(napnq_]aha*ÎJ^pc^i^obfaljbrgbfql+Ï ?kiaoo]lamqaj]bn]oa(Lh]pkiq`]npk`kkpki`k`ehkck(lkeoÎb]h]n`kiaqfaepkÏ oecjebe_]mqaÎjkrkqb]vanahkcekoahkqrknaooei]cajoa]l]nj_e]o`k]ikn(mqajk rkqaiepeni]eoqi]klejekok^nak]ikn(i]omqarkq^qo_]n]bppk`f^`k]ikn(kpbo`k ]ikn(rkqejraopec]n]fabf^`k]iknÏ* O _n]paop]i^i_kia]_kiqiiepk*Mq]j`k]`aqo]=bnk`epaj]o_aq(dkqraqi] cn]j`abaop]l]n]ko`aqoao(i]oaomqa_an]i)oa`a_kjre`]n]`aqo]Lajne]$Mkf^%*Ieoa) nrahab]iejp](Lajne]aolankqkbei`]baop](aocqaenkq)oalahkof]n`ejoa_kiaqkonaopko( ajmq]jpk ko `ai]eo `aqoao `knie]i* Jqi _]jpk `k f]n`ei( req Ajcajdk =opqpk $Mlolp% a`aoafkq_kj_a^anqibehdk`aha(`aep]j`k)oa]koaqh]`k*@aooa]pkoatq]hj]o_aqAnko(k ]ikn* ?kik oq] ia( Anko aop oailna _]najpa( b]iejpk( ieoanrah7 _kik oaq l]e( Anko ]opqpk(o]^a_ne]natla`eajpaoajcajdkokol]n]_kjoacqenkmqamqan* Mq]hkoajpe`k`kiepk;Jaha`ao_k^neikomqak]ikn_]nj_e]a]op_e](`aoafk`a o]_e]n]bkiaa]oa`a(`aoafk`alnaaj_deiajpk(`aoafk`a_kilhap]n)oaa`aaj_kjpn]n] lhajepq`a*=i]n`aoaf]nk]i]`k_kikkmqajko_kilhap](jkoo]_e]ao]peob]v(jko` lhajepq`a*=i]n`aoaf]nbqj`en)oaj]lhajepq`a`k]i]`kaoanqio _kiaha* Kmqalk`a_kilhap]na`]nlhajepq`a]qioan_]najpa;Kmqaaioeiaoik_kilhapk alhajk(eopk(kmqalanbaepk*K]ikn`aoafk`alanbaek*Kmqa]lanbaek; = d]nikje]( ] lnklknk( ] ejpacne`]`a kq ejpaenav] `] bkni]* @aoaf]iko ]o bkni]o lanbaep]o*Kmqaqi]bkni]lanbaep];=bkni]lanbaep](]_]^]`](lhaj](ejpaen]iajpana]) hev]`](oaib]hd]o(oaib]hp]o(oai`abaepko(oaija_aooe`]`a`apn]jobkni]n)oa(eopk(oai ja_aooe`]`a`aiq`]n`abkni]*=bkni]lanbaep]kmqa_d]i]iko`a^ahav]*K]ikn `aoafk`a^ahav]* Kj`aaop]^ahav]j]o_keo]o_knlkn]eo;Jko_knlko^ahko(_qf]qjekajcaj`n]qi]^a) hav]6]eiknp]he`]`a`kol]eo]pn]ro`kobehdko*Kj`aaop]^ahav]j]o_keo]oej_knlkn]eo;J]o ]hi]o^ah]o(_qf]^ahav]aopj]lanbaek`aoaqolajo]iajpkoa] ao(eopk(j]ejpahecj_e]* Mqa]i]ikomq]j`k]i]iko_knlko^ahko;Kmqad`aeilana_rahj]mqehkmqa(lkn j]pqnav](lana_rah(eopk(]i]iko]lkopane`]`akq]`ao_aj`j_e]*Mqa]i]ikomq]j`k ]i]iko]hi]o^ah]o;Kmqad`aeilana_rahj]ejpahecj_e](eopk(]oe`ae]o*K]iknlahko _knlko^ahkoqi]ei]caikqqi]oki^n]`k]iknlahkeilana_rah(i]ok]iknlah]o ]hi]o^ah]ok]iknlkn]hckmqaaioeiaoikalknoeiaoikeilana_raha]^okhqp]) iajpalanbaepk* Oak]ikn`aoafk`ae`ajpebe_]n)oa_kik]i]`k(`abqj`en)oajahapknj]j`k)oa_kik aha(ajpk]mq]he`]`akq]j]pqnav]`koan]i]`k`apaniej]oaqi]iknlhaj]iajparan) `]`aenkkqqi]]l]nj_e]`a]ikn*=i]nklana_rahpknj]n)oalana_rahp]i^i*=i]nk
./0
=iap]boe_]`a=neop pahaox#!0É45,/ßx
iqprahpknj]n)oaiqprahp]i^i*Klana_rahakiqprahokoki^n]o(_ le]oeilanbaep]o `koanran`]`aenk(eilana_rahaeiqprah*=obkni]o_knlkn]eo^ah]ookoki^n]okqei]cajo `]ran`]`aen]^ahav]eilana_rah*=^]j`kj]j`k)]olah]ran`]`aen]^ahav](]i]ikojkaop] kq]mqah]_keo]^ah](i]o]e`ae]kq]aooj_e]`]^ahav](k^ahkaioeiaoik(je_k(na]h* =o]hi]o^ah]ook^ah]olknmqajah]od]lnaoaj](]ej`]mqaejreorahlneiaen]reop]( `a]hckeilana_rah6kejpaha_pk(l]npaeiknp]h`ajkoo]]hi]*Mqa]i]kejpaha_pk;Qikqpnk ejpaha_pkmqaoaf]i]eo^ahkai]eolanbaepk`kmqaahaamqa(]koan]i]`k(pknj]lanbaepka ^ahkmqaik]i]*Kmqaqiejpaha_pkran`]`aen]iajpa^ahkalanbaepk;Kmqa]i]]^ahav] lanbaep]*Kj`aoaaj_kjpn]]p]h^ahav];J]oe`ae]o* Kmqa]bppk`f^kq]fabf^`k]ikn;K]iknk`aoafk`]lanbaekeilana_rah`]o bkni]o ^ah]o( `]mqehk mqa lani]ja_a oailna e`jpe_k ] oe iaoik( `]mqehk mqa lk`a oan _kjpailh]`klhaj]iajpalahkejpaha_pka_kjda_e`klhaj]iajpalah]ejpahecj_e]*Oaj`k ]iknejpaha_pq]hlahkejpahecrahkqlah]oe`ae]o(k]iknk`aoafk`ao]^an6mefilplmef^( Î]ikn`]o]^a`kne]Ï*Lahk]ikn(kejpaha_pkdqi]jkl]npe_el]`kejpahecrah(pki]l]npajk iqj`k`]oe`ae]okq`]oaooj_e]o(_kjda_aj`kkpbosboa^abfol* =kjpkhkce](]ooei(]ln lne]behkokbe]ak_kjda_eiajpk`kOan(eopk(`]oe`ae]o7] l]oo]cai `]o kleje ao ok^na ]o _keo]o oajoraeo iqpraeo nqik ]k lajo]iajpk ok^na ]o aooj_e]oeiqpraeo*L]oo]n`koajorah]kejpahecrahÍp]nab]`]behkokbe]Íl]oo]n`]]l]) nj_e]]kna]h(`kJkOan]kOan*
#APqTULOß =iap]boe_]`a=neoppahao
@ebanaj]ajpna=neoppahaoaoaqolna`a_aooknao
A
i^kn]]kjpkhkce]pajd]_kia]`k_kiL]nije`aoaLh]pk(_kopqi])oa]pne^qenoaq j]o_eiajpk]=neop pahaomq]j`kaopaatlhe_ep]iajpabkniqh]]e`ae]`aqi]_ej_e]kq `eo_elhej]mqapai_kikbej]he`]`aln lne]kaopq`k`kOan(`ajkiej]j`k)]Behkokbe] Lneiaen]*=hi`eook(pnokqpnkoikperkohar]i]]pne^qen]=neop pahaokej_ek`]iap]boe_]6 -*
./1
`ebanajpaiajpa`aoaqo`keolna`a_aooknao(=neop pahaojkfqhc]kiqj`k`]o_keo]o oajoraeo(kq]j]pqnav](qiiqj`k]l]najpaaehqo nek*Lahk_kjpnnek(qiiqj`k na]h a ran`]`aenk _qf] bppk`f^ ( fqop]iajpa( ] iqhpelhe_e`]`a `a oanao a ] iq`]j] ej_aoo]jpa* Aihqc]n`a]b]op]n]iqhpelhe_e`]`aak`aren_kikehqo aokqoki^n]o`kran`]) `aenkOan(=neop pahao]beni]mqakoan`]j]pqnav]ateopa(na]h(mqaoaqik`kln lnek `aateopen]iq`]j]amqaaop]jkqi]_kjpn]`ekeilajorah*lkoorahqi] _ej_e]paknpe_]ran`]`aen]ok^na]j]pqnav]a]iq`]j]6]boe_]*I]olna_eok(lne) iaenk(`aikjopn]nmqakk^fapk`]boe_]qioanna]haran`]`aenkaeookp]nab]`] Behkokbe]Lneiaen]kq`]Îiap])boe_]Ï*
.* `ebanajpaiajpa`aoaqo`keolna`a_aooknao(=neop pahao_kjoe`an]mqa]aooj_e]ran) `]`aen]`]o_keo]oj]pqn]eoa`kooanaodqi]jkoa`aoq]o] aojkaopjkiqj`k
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
ejpahecrah(oal]n]`k`kiqj`koajorah(jkmq]h]o_keo]oboe_]okqj]pqn]eoateopai akj`areraiko*=oaooj_e]o(`ev=neop pahao(aopkj]oln lne]o_keo]o(jkoln lneko dkiajo(j]oln lne]o] aoap]nab]`]behkokbe]_kjda_)h]o]heiaoikkj`aateo) paia]_kjpa_ai* ?kik_kjda_)h]o;L]npej`k`]oajo]k]p]h_]j]n]ejpaha_k*=aooj_e]`a qioankq`aqi]]k_kjda_e`]lahklajo]iajpk(mqa_]lp]]olnklnea`]`aoejpan) j]oaja_aoone]o`aooaoankq`aoo]]k(oai]omq]eoahakqah]jkoane]ikmqaok*= iap]boe_]jklna_eo]]^]j`kj]naopaiqj`k(i]o(]k_kjpnnek(k_kjda_eiajpk`] aooj_e]`kmqaateopaaijkookiqj`k* /* ]koa`a`e_]nBehkokbe]Lneiaen]kqiap]boe_](]behkokbe]`ao_k^namqad`ebanajpao pelko`aoanaokqajpaomqaoa`ebanaj_e]ifqop]iajpalknoq]oaooj_e]o*Aikqpn]o l]h]rn]o(l]n]L]nije`aod]re]]laj]okOanje_k(qjkaeiqprah7l]n]Lh]pk(d]re] ]o_keo]oi]pane]eokqoajoraeo(oqfaep]oiq`]j](amqaan]i_ le]oeilanbaep]okq oki^n]o`koanran`]`aenkkq`]na]he`]`a(]oE`ae]o*Lk`aikolan_a^anmqak_nepnek `aL]nije`aoa`aLh]pkl]n]`eopejcqenna]he`]`aran`]`aen]a]l]nj_e]]]qoj_e] kq]lnaoaj]`aiq`]j]*=neop pahaop]i^iqo]n]iq`]j]_kik_nepnek`a`eba) naj_e]k`kooanao(lknikb]n`ai]jaen]_kilhap]iajpajkr]* ÎIq`]j]Ï(aicnack(oa`evÎikreiajpkÏ*=l]h]rn]cnac]l]n]ÎikreiajpkÏhkbpfp $`a kj`a rai ]o l]h]rn]o `fkqf`l( `fkbj^( `fkbjqf`^( ai lknpqcqo%*ÎIkreiajpkÏ jk oecjebe_](lkni(oeilhaoiajpaiq`]j]`ahqc]nkqhk_kikk*Oecjebe_]pk`]amq]hmqan iq`]j]mqaqioanokbn]kqna]heva*ÎikreiajpkÏ6 pk`]iq`]j]mq]hep]per]`aqioanmq]hmqan$lknatailhk(qi]oaiajpamqaoapknj] nrkna(qik^fapk^n]j_kmqa]i]naha_a(qi]jei]hmqa]`ka_a(]hckmqajpamqaaobne]( ]hckbnekmqaaomqajp](k`qnkmqa]ikha_a(kikhamqaaj`qna_a(ap_*%7 pk`]iq`]j]kq]hpan]kmq]jpep]per]$lknatailhk(qi_knlkmqa]qiajpaa`eie) jq](mqaoa`ere`]aikqpnkoiajknao(mqaaj_kilne`akqaj_qnpa(]h]ncqakqaopnaepa( ap_*%7 pk`]iq`]j]`ahqc]nkqhk_kikk$oq^en(`ao_an(_]en(]pn]fap ne]`aqi]bha_d](k `aohk_]iajpk`aqi^]n_k(]mqa`]`aqi]la`n](kharep]n`aqi]lhqi](ap_*%7 pk`]]hpan]kaimqaqioanl]ooa`]]kl]etkkql]ooere`]`a(kql]ooa`]l]o) oere`]`a]pere`]`a$lknatailhk(`a_knp]n]oan_knp]`k(`a]i]n]oan]i]`k(kq`a oan`aoaf]`k]`aoaf]n(`aoanpk_]`k]pk_]n(ap_*%7 pk`]can]kkqj]o_eiajpkapk`]_knnqlkkqiknpa`kooanao7j]o_an(reranaiknnan okikreiajpko* Jqi]l]h]rn]6kabsfo(aipk`kokooaqo]ola_pko(kjlsfjbkql*L]nije`aoaLh]pk at_hqn]ikikreiajpk`]aooj_e]`kOan* Mqab]v=neop pahao;Jac]mqaikreiajpkaJkOankqenna]he`]`aoaf]ikiaoik*A `ebanaj_e]nkooanao_kjbkniaaopaf]ikqjkaiikreiajpk* Ateopa ] aooj_e] `ko oanao mqa ok a aopk ai ikreiajpk( eopk ( ko oanao boe_ko kq j]pqn]eo$iejan]eo(racap]eo(]jei]eo(dqi]jko%(_qfkik`k`aoanoa_]n]_panev]lknj]o_an( reran(iq`]n(nalnk`qven)oaa`ao]l]na_an*Okoanaoai`arenamqaateopaijk`aren* Ateopa]aooj_e]`kooanaoi]paipe_ko(mqajkateopaiaioeiaoiko(i]oateopai _kikbkni]o`]o_keo]oj]pqn]eo(lk`aj`k(lkni(oanoal]n]`ko`ah]olahklajo]iajpka panoq]oaooj_e]o_kjda_e`]o7okoanaomqa(lknaooj_e](okei raeo(eopk(jkj]o_ai( jkiq`]i(jkoapn]jobkni]ijailana_ai(jkaop]j`kai`arenjaijk`aren* Ateopa ] aooj_e] `a oanao _qf] aooj_e] eiqprah kq ei rah Í jk j]o_ai( jk oa pn]jobkni]i a jk lana_ai Í( i]o mqa na]hev]i qi ikreiajpk hk_]h lanbaepk( apanjk( oai_kiakaoaibei6ko]opnko(mqana]hev]ikikreiajpk_en_qh]n*
./2
=iap]boe_]`a=neop pahaox#!0É45,/ßx
A(bej]hiajpa(ateopa]aooj_e]`aqioanapanjk(eiqprah(eilana_rah(oailnae`jpe) _k]oeiaoik(lanbaepk(ei]pane]h(`kmq]hkikreiajpkaopejpaen]iajpaat_hq`k(_kjda) _e`k]laj]olahkejpaha_pk(mqak_kjda_a_kikoal]n]`k`ajkookiqj`k(oqlanekn]pq`k mqaateopa(amqakoanlknat_ahj_e]6koan`erejk* L]n]_]`]qi`aooaopelko`aoanaoq]oaooj_e]oateopaqi]_ej_e]paknpe_]ln lne] $boe_](^ekhkce](loe_khkce](i]paipe_](]opnkjkie]%*I]op]i^i`arad]ranqi]_ej_e] can]h(i]eo]ilh](i]eoqjerano]h(]jpanekn]pk`]oaoo]o(_qfkk^fapkjkoaf]aooakq]mqaha pelk`aOan(aoo]kq]mqah]ik`]he`]`a`aaooj_e](i]okOanaican]h(]aooj_e]aican]h* Pn]p])oa`aqi]_ej_e]paknpe_]mqaejraopec]kmqa]aooj_e]a]mqehkmqab]v_kimqa d]f]aooj_e]ol]npe_qh]naoa`ebanaj_e]`]o*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(`arad]ranqi]_ej_e]mqa aopq`akOanajmq]jpkOan(oai_kjoe`an]n]o`ebanaj_e] ao`kooanao* Aoo]_ej_e]i]eo]hp](i]eo]ilh](i]eoqjerano]h]Behkokbe]Lneiaen](ao_nara=neop ) pahaojklneiaenkhernk`]k^n]_kjda_e`]_kikJbq^cpf`^*
=iap]boe_]]neopkphe_]
J
]Jbq^cpf`^(=neop pahao]beni]mqa]Behkokbe]Lneiaen]aopq`]kolneiaenkolnej_) lekoa]o_]qo]olneiaen]o`apk`]o]o_keo]oaejraopec]ÎkOanajmq]jpkOanÏ* =k`abejen]kjpkhkce]kqiap]boe_]_kikaopq`k`kÎOanajmq]jpkOanÏ(=neop pahaoaop `evaj`kmqa]Behkokbe]Lneiaen]aopq`]]oaooj_e]ooai`ebanaj_e)h]oaiaooj_e]oboe_]o( i]paipe_]o(]opnkjie_]o(dqi]j]o(ap_*(lkeo_]^ao`ebanajpao_ej_e]oaopq`)h]o_kik `ebanajpaoajpnaoe*Çiap]boe_]_]^aipnoaopq`ko6 -*
MOVER ßMOVIMENTOßß LEMBREMOSßQUEßOßMO VIMENTO ßKqNESIS ßmßTODAß EßQUALQUERßALTERAljOßOUß MUDANlAßEXPERIMENTADAß PORßUMßSERßMUDANlAßDEß QUALIDADEßEßQUANTIDADE ß MUDANlAßDEßLUGARßNAS CERßEßMORRERß/ß0RIMEIROß -OTORßOßDIVINO ßmß)MvVELß PORQUEßPERFEITO ßJAMAISß SUBMETIDOßAßQUALQUERß TIPOßDEßMOVIMENTO ßß SEMPREßIDoNTICOßAßSIß MESMOß/SßSERESßMUDAMß MOVEM SE ßPARAßREALIZARß TODASßASßALTERAlzESßE ßß UMßDIA ßDEIXAREMßDEß MOVER SE
./3
k`koan`erejk(]na]he`]`alneiaen]aoqlnai]`]mq]hpk`kknaop]jpalnk_qn]]lnk) tei]n)oa(eiep]j`koq]lanbaekeiqprah*=o_keo]ooapn]jobkni]i(`ev=neop pahao( lknmqa`aoaf]iaj_kjpn]noq]aooj_e]pkp]halanbaep](eiqprah_kik]aooj_e]`ere) j]*lah]iq`]j]ej_aoo]jpamqa^qo_]ieiep]nkmqajkiq`]jqj_]*Lkneook(koan `erejkkLneiaenkIkpknEi rah`kiqj`k(eopk(]mqehkmqa(oai]cen`enap]iajpa ok^na]o_keo]o(be_]j`k]`eop j_e]`ah]o(]o]pn]e(`aoaf]`klknah]o*P]h`aoafk]ob]v iq`]nl]n](qi`e](jki]eoiq`]n$aooa`aoafk(`ev=neop pahao(atlhe_]lknmqadk `arenalknmqak`arenapanjk(lkeo]o_keo]oj]pqn]eojqj_]lk`ank]h_]j]nkmqa `aoaf]i(eopk(]lanbaekeiqprah%* =iq`]j]kqk`arenok]i]jaen]lah]mq]h]j]pqnav](]koaqik`k(oa]lanbae) k]a^qo_]eiep]n]lanbaek`keiqprah`erejk*Koan`erejk_d]i])oaLneiaenkIkpkn lknmqaklnej_lekmqaikrapk`]]na]he`]`a(a_d]i])oaLneiaenkIkpknEi rahlkn) mqajkoaikraajkikre`klknjajdqikqpnkajpa(lkeo(_kikfreiko(jlsbo oecjebe_]Îiq`]nÏ(Îokbnan]hpan] aomq]hep]per]oamq]jpep]per]oÏ(j]o_anlana_an(akoan `erejk(lanbaepk(jkiq`]jqj_]7
.* k`kolneiaenkolnej_lekoa_]qo]olneiaen]o`apk`kokooanaokqaooj_e]oateopajpao7 /* k`]olnklnea`]`aokq]pne^qpkocan]eo`apk`kokooanao(oaf]iahaomq]eobknai(cn]]o ]ko mq]eo lk`aiko `apaniej]n ] aooj_e] l]npe_qh]n `a qi oan l]npe_qh]n ateopajpa* = aooj_e]kqlrp^]na]he`]`alneiaen]ahpei]`aqioan(]mqehkoaikmq]hqioanjk lk`anateopenkq`aet]n`aoankmqa*Çaooj_e](ajpaj`e`]`aoo]lanola_per]qjeran) o]h(=neop pahao`kjkia`aoq^op j_e](a]iap]boe_]aopq`]]oq^op j_e]aican]h*
Kolnej_el]eo_kj_aepko`]iap]boe_]]neopkphe_]
@
ai]jaen]iqepk^naraaoeilhebe_]`](kolnej_el]eo_kj_aepko`]iap]boe_]]neopk) phe_]$amqaoapknj]nk]o^]oao`apk`]]iap]boe_]k_e`ajp]h%lk`aioan]ooei naoqie`ko6
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
mofjbfolpmofk`mflp6okkopnolnej_lekomqaaopq`]ikoj]h ce_](eopk(fabkqfa^ab( kl`lkqo^af laqbo`bfolbu`iral*Kolnej_lekoh ce_kookkjpkh ce_kolknmqa`abe) jai]o_kj`e aooai]omq]eoqioanjklk`aateopenjaioanlajo]`k7kolneiaenko lnej_lekoc]n]jpai(oeiqhp]ja]iajpa(]na]he`]`aa]n]_ekj]he`]`a`]o_keo]o7 `^rp^pmofjbfo^p6ok]mqah]omqaatlhe_]ikmqa]aooj_e]ap]i^i]knecaiak ikperk`]ateopj_e]`aqi]aooj_e]*?]qo]$l]n]kocnacko%oecjebe_]jko lmlonr `a]hcqi]_keo]i]op]i^iklnral`ljlqi]_keo]kmqaah]*=o_]qo]olne) iaen]ojko`evaikmqa(_kik(lknmqaal]n]mqaqi]_keo]* Okmq]pnk]o_]qo]olneiaen]o6 -*
_]qo]i]pane]h(eopk(]mqehk`amqaqioanbaepk(oq]i]pne]$lknatailhk(cq](bkck( ]n(pann]%7
.* _]qo]bkni]h(eopk(]mqehkmqaatlhe_]]bkni]mqaqioanlkooqe$lknatailhk(knekkq ki]nokbkni]o`]cq]7iao]]bkni]]ooqie`]lah]i]pne]i]`aen]_ki]]k`k _]nlejpaenk%*=bkni]lnklne]iajpa]aooj_e]`aqioan(]mqehkmqaahaaioeiaoik kq]mqehkmqak`abejaaioq]e`ajpe`]`aa`ebanaj]_kinah]k]pk`kokokqpnko7 /* _]qo]abe_eajpakqikpnev(eopk(]mqehkmqaatlhe_]_kikqi]i]pne]na_a^aqqi] bkni]l]n]_kjopepqenqi]aooj_e]$lknatailhk(k]pkoatq]h]_]qo]abe_eajpamqa b]v]i]pne]`k rqhk]kna_a^ankaolani]na_a^an]bkni]`aqijkrk]jei]hkq `aqi]_ne]j]7k_]nlejpaenk]_]qo]abe_eajpamqab]v]i]`aen]na_a^an]bkni]`] iao]7kbkck]_]qo]abe_eajpamqab]vko_knlkobnekopknj]nai)oamqajpao(ap_*%7 0* ]_]qo]bej]h(eopk(]_]qo]mqa`kikperk(]n]vkkqbej]he`]`al]n]]hcqi]_keo]ateo) penaoanp]h_kikah]$lknatailhk(k^ai_kiqi]_]qo]bej]h`]lkhpe_](]bahe_e`]`a ]_]qo]bej]h`]]kpe_]7]bhkn]_]qo]bej]h`]oaiajpapn]jobkni]n)oaainrkna7k LneiaenkIkpknEi rah]_]qo]bej]h`kikreiajpk`kooanaoj]pqn]eo(ap_*%7 j^qof^6kahaiajpk`amqa]o_keo]o`]j]pqnav](ko]jei]eo(kodkiajo(ko]npab]pko okbaepko7oq]lnej_el]h_]n]_panope_]lkooqenrenpq]he`]`aokq_kjpanaioeiaoi] lkooe^ehe`]`ao`apn]jobkni]k(eopk(`aiq`]j]7 cloj^6kmqaej`ere`q]hev]a`apaniej]qi]i]pne](b]vaj`kateopen]o_keo]okqko oanaol]npe_qh]nao7oq]lnej_el]h_]n]_panope_]oan]mqehkmqaqi]aooj_e]7 mlqk`f^6 ] renpq]he`]`a mqa aop _kjpe`] jqi] i]pne] a lk`a ren ] ateopen( oa bkn ]pq]hev]`]lkn]hcqi]_]qo]7lknatailhk(]_ne]j]qi]`qhpkailkpj_e]kqqi ]`qhpkailkpaj_e]h7]oaiajpa]nrknaailkpj_e]kqailkpaj_e]h7 ^ql6]]pq]hev]k`aqi]i]pne]lknqi]bkni]ajqi]bkni]7k]pk]bkni]mqa ]pq]hevkqqi]lkpj_e]_kjpe`]j]i]pne]*Lknatailhk(]nrknak]pk`]oaiajpa(k ]`qhpkk]pk`]_ne]j](]iao]k]pk`]i]`aen](ap_* Lkpj_e]ai]pne]oke`jpe_ko(]ooei_kikbkni]a]pkoke`jpe_ko*=i]pne]kq lkpj_e]qi]na]he`]`al]ooer]mqalna_eo]`k]pka`]bkni](eopk(`]]pere`]`amqa_ne] kooanao`apaniej]`ko*Cn]]o]ko_kj_aepko`alkpj_e]a]pk(]iap]boe_]]neopkphe_]lk`a atlhe_]n]_]qo]a]n]_ekj]he`]`a`apk`kokoikreiajpkoj]pqn]eokq`kooanaoboe_ko(eopk (`apk`kokooanao`kp]`ko`ai]pne]abkni]*K`arenjk]l]nj_e]jaiehqok(ahak ikreiajpklahkmq]h]lkpj_e]oa]pq]hev](]i]pne]na_a^a]bkni]aiq`]`abkni]* bppk`f^6]qje`]`aejpanj]aej`eookhrahajpnaqi]i]pne]aqi]bkni](qje`]`a mqahda`qi_kjfqjpk`alnklnea`]`aokq]pne^qpkomqa]b]vaioanja_aoo]ne]iajpa ]mqehkmqaah]*=ooei(lknatailhk(qioandqi]jklknaooj_e]kqaooaj_e]hiajpa qi]jei]hiknp]hn]_ekj]h`kp]`k`arkjp]`a(can]`klknkqpnkooaiahd]jpao]ahaa _]l]v`acan]nkqpnkooaiahd]jpao]aha(ap_*7
./4
=iap]boe_]`a=neop pahaox#!0É45,/ßx
^`fabkqb6qi]lnklnea`]`akq]pne^qpkmqaqi]aooj_e]lk`apankq`aet]n`apan oai lan`an oaq oan ln lnek* Lkn atailhk( qi oan dqi]jk n]_ekj]h kq iknp]h lkn aooj_e](i]o^]etkkq]hpk(ckn`kkqi]cnk(jacnkkq^n]j_k(lkn]_e`ajpa*=dqi]) je`]`a]aooj_e]aooaj_e]h$]jei]h(iknp]h(n]_ekj]h(rkhqjpnek%(ajmq]jpkk]_e`ajpa kmqa(ateopej`kkqjkateopej`k(jqj_]]bap]koan`]aooj_e]$i]cnk(ckn`k(]hpk( ^]etk(jacnk(^n]j_k%*=aooj_e]kqjerano]h7k]_e`ajpakl]npe_qh]n7 pr_pq k`f^6]mqehkaimqaoaaj_kjpn]i]i]pne])lkpj_e](]bkni])]pk(kj`aaopk ko]pne^qpkoaooaj_e]eoa]_e`ajp]eo(ok^nakmq]h]cai]omq]pnk_]qo]o7aioqi](k Oanlnklne]iajpa`epk* =neop pahaoqo]k_kj_aepk`aoq^op j_e]ai`keooajpe`ko6jqilneiaenkoajpe`k(oq^o) p j_e]koanej`ere`q]h7jqioacqj`koajpe`k(oq^op j_e]kcjankkq]aol_ea]mqaqi oanej`ere`q]hlanpaj_a*Jklneiaenkoajpe`k(]oq^op j_e]qioanej`ere`q]hateopajpa7jk oacqj`k(k_kjfqjpk`]o_]n]_panope_]ocan]eomqakoej`er`qko`aqicjanka`aqi] aol_ea lkooqai* =neop pahao b]h] ai pr_pq k`f^ mofjbfo^ l]n] nabanen)oa ]ko oanao ej`ere) `q]eona]hiajpaateopajpao(_kioq]aooj_e]aoaqo]_e`ajpao7lknatailhk(O _n]pao7aai pr_pq k`f^pbdrka^l]n]nabanen)oa]kooqfaepkoqjerano]eo(eopk(cjankoaaol_eaomqajk ateopaiaioealknoeiaoiko(i]oo ateopaiaj_]nj]`kojkoej`er`qko(lk`aj`k(lk) ni(oan_kjda_e`kolahklajo]iajpk*=ooei(lknatailhk(kcjankÎ]jei]hÏa]oaol_eao Îranpa^n]`kÏ(Îi]ibankÏaÎdqi]jkÏjkateopaiaioeiaoiko(i]oateopaiaiO _n]pao kq]pn]ro`aO _n]pao* Kcjankqiqjerano]hbkni]`klknqi_kjfqjpk`alnklnea`]`ao`]i]pne]a`] bkni]mqa_]n]_panev]ikmqad`a_kiqijkooanao`aqi]iaoi]aol_ea*=aol_ea p]i^iqiqjerano]hbkni]`klknqi_kjfqjpk`alnklnea`]`ao`]i]pne]a`]bkni] mqa_]n]_panev]ikmqad`a_kiqijkoej`er`qkooaiahd]jpao*=ooei(kcjankbkni]) `klknqi_kjfqjpk`aaol_eaooaiahd]jpaoa]oaol_eao(lknqi_kjfqjpk`aej`er`qko oaiahd]jpao*Koej`er`qkokqoq^op j_e]olneiaen]ookoanaona]hiajpaateopajpao7koc) jankoa]oaol_eaokqoq^op j_e]ooacqj`]ookqjerano]he`]`aomqaklajo]iajpk_kjda_a ]pn]ro`koej`er`qko7 mobaf`^alp6ok]o_]packne]omqareikojkaopq`k`]h ce_]amqap]i^iokkjpkh ce) _]o(lknmqaoanabanaiaopnqpqn]a]kik`k`aoan`]oq^op j_e]kq`]aooj_e]$mq]j) pe`]`a(mq]he`]`a(nah]k(hqc]n(pailk(lkooa(]k(l]etk%*Reiko(]kaopq`]n]h ce_]( mqa]oq^op j_e]]lneiaen]_]packne]*=neop pahaoatlhe_]mqa]oq^op j_e]`ebana`]o `ai]eo_]packne]olknmqa(ajmq]jpkpk`]ooklna`e_]`ko]pne^q`ko]qioqfaepk(ah] jk]pne^q`]]jejcqilknmqaah](fqop]iajpa(koqfaepkmqana_a^akolna`e_]`ko kq]o`ai]eo_]packne]o*Kolna`e_]`ko]pne^q`ko]qi]oq^op j_e]ok_kjopepqperko `aoaqoana`aoaqik`k`aoan(`aoq]aooj_e](lkeopk`]na]he`]`alk`aoan_kjda_e`] lknmqalkooqemq]he`]`ao$iknp]h(eiknp]h(bejepk(ejbejepk(^ki(i]q(ap_*%(mq]jpe`]`ao $qi(iqepko(]hcqjo(lkq_k(iqepk(cn]j`a(lamqajk%(nah]_ekj])oa_kikqpnko$ecq]h( `ebanajpa(oaiahd]jpa(i]ekn(iajkn(oqlanekn(ejbanekn%(aopai]hcqihqc]n$]mqe(]he( lanpk(hkjca(jk]hpk(ai^]etk(aibnajpa(]pno(ap_*%(aopjkpailk$]jpao(`alkeo(]ckn]( kjpai(dkfa(]i]jd(`a`e](`ajkepa(oailna(jqj_]%(na]hev]] aokqb]v]hcqi]_keo] $]j`](lajo](`knia(_knp](_]e(lnaj`a(_nao_a(j]o_a(iknna(caniej](bnqpebe_](bhknao_a( ap_*%aokbna] ao`akqpnkooanao$_knp]`k(lnaok(iknpk(mqa^n]`k(]nn]j_]`k( lqt]`k(]pn]`k(har]`k(_qn]`k(ajrajaj]`k(ap_*%*
./5
=o_]packne]okqlna`e_]`kolk`aioanaooaj_e]eokq]_e`ajp]eo(eopk(lk`aioanja) _aoonekoaej`eolajoraeoj]pqnav]ln lne]`aqioankqlk`aioan]hckmqaqioanlko) oqelkn]_]okkqmqahda]_kjpa_alkn]_]ok(oai]bap]noq]j]pqnav]* Pkiaikoqiatailhk*Oaaq`eooanÎO _n]paodkiaiÏ(ja_aoo]ne]iajpapanae`ahda `]nkooacqejpaolna`e_]`ko6iknp]h(n]_ekj]h(bejepk(]jei]h(lajo](oajpa(]j`](nalnk`qv( b]h](]`ka_a(oaiahd]jpa]kqpnko]pajeajoao(iajkn`kmqaqi]ikjp]jd]ai]ekn`k mqaqic]pk(]i](k`ae]*=_e`ajp]hiajpa(ahalk`anpankqpnkolna`e_]`ko6baek(^]etk(
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
`ebanajpa`]i]ekne]`ko]pajeajoao(_]o]`k(_kjranokq_kiH]mqao(aoparajk^]jmqapa`a =cpkj(ao_qhleqpnoaoppq]o(bkebkn]`k]ajrajaj]n)oalahkpne^qj]h`a=paj]o* Oajkookatailhk(lkni(bkooaqi]oq^op j_e]cajne_]kqaola_be_](pk`kokolna`e) _]`kopane]i`aoanaooaj_e]eo(lkeok]_e`ajpakmqa]_kjpa_aokiajpal]n]kej`er`qk ateopajpa(akcjanka]aol_eaokqjerano]eomqao ateopaijklajo]iajpkaaj_]nj]`ko j]oaooj_e]oej`ere`q]eo* ?kiaooa_kjfqjpk`a_kj_aepkobkni])oakmq]`nk`]kjpkhkce]kqiap]boe_]]neopk) phe_]_kikatlhe_]kcan]h(qjerano]haja_aoone]`kOan(eopk(`]na]he`]`a*Aooamq]`nk _kj_aepq]hoandan`]`klahkobeh okbkolkopaneknao(mqalnk^hai]pev]nk]hcqjo`aoaqo]o) la_pko(aop]^aha_ankjkrko_kj_aepko(oqlneienk]hcqjokqpnko(`aoajrkhraj`kkmqa_k) jda_aiko_kikjbq^cpf`^l`fabkq^i* = iap]boe_] ]neopkphe_] ej]qcqn]( lknp]jpk( k aopq`k `] aopnqpqn] can]h `a pk`ko ko Oanaokq]o_kj`e aoqjerano]eoaja_aoone]omqab]vai_kimqaateop]qiOanamqalkoo] oan_kjda_e`klahklajo]iajpk*=beni]mqa]na]he`]`ajkoaqpk`kejpahecrahkq_kjda) _raha]lnaoajp])oa_kik_kjda_eiajpkpaknpe_k`]na]he`]`aaipk`kokooaqo]ola_pko can]eokqqjerano]eo(`araj`klna_a`an]oejraopec] aomqa_]`]_ej_e]na]hev]ok^naqi pelk`apaniej]`k`aOan* =iap]boe_]ejraopec]6 ]mqehkoaikmqajkdOanaojai_kjda_eiajpk`koOanao6kopnolnej_lekoh ce_k)kj) pkh ce_koa]omq]pnk_]qo]o7 ]mqehkmqab]vqiOanoanja_aoo]ne]iajpakmqaaha6i]pne](lkpj_e](bkni]a]pk7 ]mqehkmqab]vqiOanoanja_aoo]ne]iajpa_kikaha6aooj_e]alna`e_]`kokq_]pa) ckne]o7 ]mqehkmqab]vqiOanateopen_kik]hck`apaniej]`k6]oq^op j_e]ej`ere`q]h$oq^op j) _e]lneiaen]%a]oq^op j_e]_kikcjankkqaol_ea$oq^op j_e]oacqj`]%* eopkaopq`]nÎkOanajmq]jpkOanÏ*
#APqTULOß =o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]
K_neope]jeoika]p]nab]`]ar]jcahev]k
=
koqncen(k_neope]jeoikan]i]eoqi]ajpna]orne]onahece aokneajp]eo7oq]on]vao aj_kjpn]r]i)oaj]nahecekfq`]e_](eopk(jqi]nahecekmqa(_kikpk`]o]onahece ao ]jpec]o(an]j]_ekj]hkq`aqilkrkl]npe_qh]n*Jkajp]jpk(d]re]jaha]hckejateo) pajpajkfq`]oikaj]okqpn]onahece ao]jpec]o6]e`ae]`aar]jcahev]k(eopk(`aaol]hd]n] Î^k])jkr]Ïl]n]kiqj`kejpaenk(]bei`a_kjranpankojk_neopkoapknj]n)oaqi]nahecek qjerano]h* Kn](_kik_kjranpan]aoo]naheceklaook]o`akqpn]onahece ao(mqalkooq]iqil]o) o]`kaqioajpe`kln lnekol]n]ah]o;Koar]jcahev]`knaoqo]n]iiqepkoatla`eajpaol]n]
.0,
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
eook(har]j`kai_kjp]]o_kj`e aoa]iajp]he`]`a`komqa`arane]ioan_kjranpe`ko*L]n] kjkook]ooqjpk(ejpanaoo]]laj]oqipelk`aar]jcahev]ka_kjranok6k`koejpaha_pq]eo cnackoanki]jko(eopk(`]mqahaomqad]re]ioe`kbkni]`kojko ainahece ao`ebanajpao `]fq`]e_](_kikp]i^id]re]ioe`ka`q_]`koj]pn]`ekn]_ekj]heop]`]behkokbe]*L]n] _kjranp)hkoaikopn]n]oqlanekne`]`a`]ran`]`a_neopok^na]pn]`ekbehko be_](kolne) iaenkoL]`nao`]Ecnaf]kqejpaha_pq]eo_neopko$OkL]qhk(OkFkk(O]jpk=i^n oek(O]jpk Aqo^ek( O]jpk =ckopejdk( ajpna kqpnko% ]`]lp]n]i ]o e`ae]o behko be_]o nahecek _neop a bevan]ioqncenqi]behkokbe]_neop* Airneko]ola_pko(lk`aiko`evanmqak_neope]jeoik(ajmq]jpkp]h(jklna_eo]r]`a qi]behkokbe]6 oaj`k qi] nahecek `] o]hr]k( oaq ejpanaooa i]ekn aop]r] j] ikn]h( j] moqf`^ `ko lna_aepkorenpqkoko`aet]`kolknFaoqo(ajkaiqi]qblof^ok^na]na]he`]`a7 oaj`kqi]nahecekrej`]`kfq`]oik(flkooq]qi]e`ae]iqepk_h]n]`kmqaan]k Oan(lkeo@aqo`eooa]Ikeoo6ÎAqokq]mqahamqa(bkeaoan*Aqokq]mqahamqaokqÏ7 oaj`kqi]nahecek(oaqejpanaooai]eknaop]r]j]bajkj]n]vkpa ne_](j]_naj]a jkjk_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]h(j]narah]kajkj]nabhatk* Bke( lknp]jpk( k `aoafk `a _kjranpan ko ejpaha_pq]eo cnacko a ko _dabao a eilan]`knao nki]jko$eopk(]mqahaomqaaop]r]i]_kopqi]`kobehkokbe]%mqaÎailqnnkqÏko_neopko l]n]]iap]boe_]*
=opn]`e aoiap]boe_]oaj_kjpn]`]olahk_neope]jeoik 'EOFFREYß#LEMENTS#ORBIS
A
OkL]qhk(qi `kolajo]`knao`] =jpecqe`]`a_neop(ai lejpqn]naj]o_ajpeop]*
.0-
re`ajpaiajpa( ]o `q]o cn]j`ao pn]`e ao iap]boe_]o ej_knlkn]`]olahk_neope]jeoikbkn]iklh]pkjeoika k]neopkpaheoik*Jkajp]jpk(_kik]ok^n]o`aLh]pk a=neop pahaod]re]ibe_]`klan`e`]o`qn]jparnekoo_qhko( ]jpao`aej_knlkn)h]ok_neope]jeoikpkikq_kjp]pk_kipno kqpn]opn]`e aoiap]boe_]o(mqabkni]n]i(]ooei(k_kjpa) `k`]olneiaen]oah]^kn] aoiap]boe_]o_neopo6kjaklh]pk) jeoik(kaopke_eoikakcjkope_eoik* Kjaklh]pkjeoik(_kikkjkiaej`e_](bkeqi]napki]) `]`]behkokbe]`aLh]pk(i]o_kiqi_kjpa`kaolenepq]heop] a iope_k* Ko jaklh]pje_ko ]beni]r]i ] ateopj_e] `a pno na]he`]`ao`eopejp]olknaooj_e]6kiqj`koajorah`]i]p) ne]kq`ko_knlko(kiqj`kejpahecrah`]olqn]obkni]oei]) pane]eo(a(]_ei]`aooao`keoiqj`ko(qi]na]he`]`aoqlnai]( oal]n]`]`apk`kknaopk(ej]h_]jrahlahkejpaha_pkdqi]jk( hqvlqn]aaolhaj`knei]pane]h(kQjkkqk>ai*Lknoanqi] hqv(kQjkoaenn]`e]7oq]oenn]`e] ao$mqakojaklh]pje_ko _d]i]r]i `a bj^k^ bp% bkni]n]i k iqj`k ejpahecrah( kj`aaopkkOan(]Ejpahecj_e]a]=hi]`kIqj`k* @aoo]o lneiaen]o ai]j] ao lanbaep]o oacqen]i kqpn]o( i]eo]b]op]`]o`kQjka(lkneook(eilanbaep]o6kiqj`koajo) rah`]i]pne](ei]cai`a_]`]kq_ le]eilanbaep]`kiqj) `kejpahecrah*Lknoaqejpaha_pk(kdkiail]npe_el]`kiqj`k ejpahecrah*Lqnebe_]j`k)oa`]i]pne]`aoaq_knlk(`aoajrkh) raj`koaqejpaha_pk(kdkiailk`aoq^en]hi`klajo]iaj) pkapanktp]oaiope_k(lahkmq]hoabqj`a_ki]hqv`kQjk anapknj]]koaek`]na]he`]`aoqlnai]kq`k>ai*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
Kaopke_eoik(ai^kn]iqepk`ebanajpa`kjaklh]pkjeoikÍlkeojac]r]]ateopj_e]`a na]he`]`aooal]n]`]oaoqlaneknao]kiqj`koajorahÍ(p]i^iejbhqaj_ekqklajo]iajpk _neopk*Koaopke_ko]beni]r]i]ateopj_e]`aqi]N]vkQjerano]hkqEjpahecj_e]Qjeran) o]h(mqalnk`qvackranj]pk`]]na]he`]`a(`a]_kn`k_kiqilh]jkn]_ekj]hja_aoonek(] mqa`]r]ikjkia`aLnkre`j_e]*Kdkiai(ai^kn]eilqhoekj]`klknejopejpko(_kikko ]jei]eo(l]npe_el]`]N]vkQjerano]hlknmqalkooqen]vkarkjp]`a* =l]npe_el]kj]n]_ekj]he`]`aqjerano]hjkoa`lahkoeilhao_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_) pq]h(i]olah]]kikn]h(eopk(lah]najj_e]]pk`kokoejopejpko(lahk`kijekrkhqjpnek n]_ekj]h`apk`koko`aoafkoalah]]_aep]k`]Lnkre`j_e]*=N]vkQjerano]h]j]pqnav]7 ]Lnkre`j_e]k_kjfqjpk`]ohaeoja_aoone]omqanacai]j]pqnav]7]]kn]_ekj]hdqi]) j]$ln lne]`ko^ek%]re`]ai_kjbknie`]`a_ki]j]pqnav]a_ki]Lnkre`j_e]* Kcjkope_eoikan]qi`q]heoikiap]boe_k(eopk(]beni]r]]ateopj_e]`a`keolnej_) lekooqlnaiko`akj`alnkrejd]pk`]]na]he`]`a6k>ai(kq]hqvei]pane]h(akI]h(kq]pnar] i]pane]h*L]n]kocj ope_ko(kiqj`kj]pqn]hkqkiqj`koajorahnaoqhp]`k`]rep ne]`k I]hok^nak>aialkneook]beni]r]imqa]o]hr]kaop]r]aihe^anp]n)oa`]i]pne]$`k_kn) lk%]pn]ro`k_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]ha`ktp]oaiope_k*Cjkope_eoikrai`]l]h]rn]cna) c]dklpfp(mqaoecjebe_]Î_kjda_eiajpkÏ*L]n]kocj ope_ko(k_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]hlk`a( lknoeiaoik(]h_]j]n]ran`]`alhaj]apkp]h`k>aia]b]op]nkolk`anaoi]pane]eo`kI]h* Mqabavk_neope]jeoikj]o_ajpa; =`]lpkqjkr]brne]o_kj_al ao`]iap]boe_]jaklh]pje_](`eooknaoqhp]j`kko oacqejpaolkjpko`kqpnejneko6 oal]n]kajpnai]pane]h)_knlkn]haaolenepq]h)ej_knlkn]h7 oal]n]kajpna@aqo)Qjkakiqj`ki]pane]h7 pn]jobkni]k`]lneiaen]ai]j]kjaklh]pje_]$Oan(Ejpahecj_e](=hi]`kIqj`k% j]e`ae]`]Pnej`]`a`erej](lah]]beni]k`amqak@aqo)Qjkoai]jebaop]aipno ai]j] ao e`jpe_]o ] aha ln lnek6 k Oan( mqa k L]e7 ] Ejpahecj_e]( mqa k Aolnepk O]jpk7]=hi]`kIqj`k(mqakBehdk7 ]beni]k`amqadqi]oacqj`]ai]j]k(eopk(]mqah]mqarai`]hqv`]Pnej`]`a amqabkni]kiqj`kejpahecrah`]olqn]obkni]okqejpahecj_e]oei]pane]eolanbaep]o( mqaokko]jfko$]n_]jfko(mqanq^ejo(oan]bejo(ap_*%7 ik`ebe_]k`]e`ae]jaklh]pje_]mq]jpk]kiqj`koajorahlah]]beni]k`amqak iqj`koajorahkqi]pane]hjkqi]ai]j]k`a@aqo(i]oqi]`of^ l6@aqobav kiqj`k`kj]`](_kik`ev]>^he](jkhernk`]Cjaoa7 ]`ieook`amqa]]hi]dqi]j]l]npe_el]`]`erej`]`aÍjk`enap]iajpa(aoeilah] ia`e]k`kBehdka`kAolnepkO]jpkÍ(amqak_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]hjkoq) be_eajpal]n]har]n]ktp]oaiope_ka]k_kjp]pk_ki@aqo(oaj`kja_aoone]]do^ ^ p^kqfcf`^kqb(mqak_najpana_a^alknqiieopnek`erejk* @kaopke_eoik(k_neope]jeoiki]jpara`q]oe`ae]o6 ]`amqaateopaqi]Lnkre`j_e]`erej]n]_ekj]h(mqackranj]pk`]o]o_keo]oakdkiai7 ]`amqa]lanbaekdqi]j]`alaj`a`a]^]j`kj]npk`koko]lapepao(eilqhokoa`aoa) fko_knlkn]eokq_]nj]eo(ajpnac]j`k)oaLnkre`j_e]*Aoo]ajpnac](lkni(jk(_kik lajo]r]ikoaopke_ko(qi]]k`ahe^an]`]`ajkoo]rkjp]`acqe]`]lah]n]vk(i]o ateca_kik_kj`ek]bai?neopka]cn]]o]jpebe_]jpa* Kcjkope_eoikoan_kjoe`an]`kqi]danaoe]a(lkneook(nafaep]`k*Jkajp]jpk(k_neope]) jeoik_kjoanr]n`kcjkope_eoik`q]oe`ae]o6 ]`amqakI]hateopana]hiajpa6k`aijek7 ]`amqa]i]pne]kq]_]njak_ajpnkkj`ak`aijek(eopk(kI]h(]caok^nakiqj) `kaok^nakdkiai*
.0.
WWWPERSONALUMICHEDUß !RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
=hcqjoo_qhkoi]eop]n`a(k_neope]jeoikpkikq_kjda_eiajpk`a]hcqi]o`]ok^n]o `aLh]pka`a]hcqi]o`]ok^n]o`a=neop pahaomqad]re]ioe`k_kjoanr]`]oapn]`qve`]o lknbeh okbkon]^ao(_kik=rann eo(=re_aj]a=h)B]n]^e(a_kiajp]`]olknbeh okbkofq`aqo _kikBehkj`a=hat]j`ne]aI]eije`ao*Naqjej`kaoo]ok^n]oa]oah]^kn] aolna_a`aj) pao(^]oa]`]oj]opnopn]`e aoiaj_ekj]`]o(k_neope]jeoiknaknc]jevkq]iap]boe_]cnac]( ]`]lp]j`k)]oja_aooe`]`ao`]nahecek_neop*
AUSß+ß4HIEMEß0HILOSOPHENBILDER ßß "ASELßß°ß3TICHßVERMUTLICHßiLTERßß ALSßß*AHREßß!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
!L &ARABIßC߯
=iap]boe_]_neop
A
i^kn]]iap]boe_]_neopoaf]qi]naah]^kn]k`]iap]boe_]cnac](iqep]o`]oe`ae]o cnac]ojklk`ane]ioan]_aep]olahk_neope]jeoik*Raf]iko]hcqjoatailhko6
l]n]kocnacko(kiqj`k$oajorahaejpahecrah%apanjk7l]n]ko_neopko(kiqj`kbke _ne]`klkn@aqo]l]npen`kj]`]apaniej]njk`e]`kFqvkBej]h7
&ILONßDEß!LEXANDRIAßß ßA#߯ßCß
l]n]kocnacko(]`erej`]`aqi]bkn]_ oie_]n]_ekj]heilaook]h7l]n]ko_neopko(@aqo laook]h(]qje`]`a`apnolaook]oalkneook`kp]`k`aejpaha_pka`arkjp]`a(_kikk dkiai(ai^kn]oqlanekn]aopa(lknmqakejpaha_pk`erejkkjeo_eajpa$o]^apq`k`ao`a pk`]]apanje`]`a%a]rkjp]`a`erej]kjelkpajpa$lk`apq`k`ao`apk`]]apanje`]`a%7 l]n]kocnacko(kdkiaiqioanj]pqn]h(`kp]`k`a_knlka]hi](aop]lkooqej`kqi] l]npaoqlaneknaeiknp]hmqakejpaha_pkkqn]vk7l]n]ko_neopko(kdkiaiqioan ieopk(j]pqn]hlknoaq_knlk(i]ook^naj]pqn]hlknoq]]hi]eiknp]h7 l]n]kocnacko(]he^an`]`adqi]j]qi]bkni]`a]k(eopk(]_]l]_e`]`a`]n]vk l]n]kneajp]nackranj]n]rkjp]`a(]bei`amqaaop]ao_khd]kmqa^ki(fqopkaren) pqkok7l]n]ko_neopko(kdkiaihernalknmqaoq]rkjp]`aqi]_]l]_e`]`al]n] ao_khdanp]jpkk^aimq]jpkki]h(oaj`ki]eolk`anko]`kmqa]n]vka(lahkla_]`k( `aopej]`]lanranoe`]`aa]kr_ek(`aik`kmqa]]kikn]ho oan^k](fqop]aren) pqko]oabkncqe]`]lah]balah]narah]k7 l]n]kocnacko(k_kjda_eiajpkqi]]pere`]`a`kejpaha_pk$ktp]oaiope_k`amqa b]h]r]ikojaklh]pje_kojkan]]hckieopanekokkqenn]_ekj]h(i]o]bkni]i]eo]hp] `]ejpqekejpaha_pq]h%7l]n]ko_neopko(]n]vkdqi]j]heiep]`]aeilanbaep](ej_]) l]v`a(lknoeiaoi]aokvejd](]h_]j]n]ran`]`a(lna_eo]j`koanok_knne`]a_knnece`] lah]balah]narah]k* Aoo]o`ebanaj]oÍaiqep]okqpn]omqajkbkn]iiaj_ekj]`]o]mqeÍ]_]nnap]n]i cn]j`aoiq`]j]oj]iap]boe_]dan`]`]`kocnacko*Klnk^hai]lnej_el]hl]n]ko_neopko bkek`aaj_kjpn]nqiiaekl]n]naqjen]oran`]`ao`]n]vk$behkokbe]%a]oran`]`ao`]b $nahecek%(eopk(l]n]naqjenjkr]iajpa]mqehkmqa(]kj]o_an(]behkokbe]d]re]oal]n]`k(lkeo oal]n]n]n]vkaiepk* @aik`k^]op]jpanaoqie`k(lk`aiko`evanmqako]ola_pkomqal]oo]n]i]_kjopepqen k_ajpnk`]jkr]iap]boe_]bkn]ikooacqejpao6
.0/
lnkr]n]ateopj_e]`a@aqoako]pne^qpkokqlna`e_]`ko`aoq]aooj_e]*L]n]]iap]boe) _]cnac](]`erej`]`aan]qi]bkn]ei]pane]h(n]_ekj]haeilaook]h_kjda_e`]lknjkoo] n]vk*L]n]]iap]boe_]_neop(@aqoqi]laook]pnej]kqqi]laook]ieopaneko](mqa oanarah]]kaolnepk`komqalkooqaib*?kik_kj_ehe]n]_kj_alkn]_ekj]heop]`ko cnackoa]_kj_alknaheceko]`ko_neopko;Lnkr]j`kn]_ekj]hiajpamqa@aqoateopa( iaoikmqa]_]qo]`aoq]ateopj_e]oaf]qiieopnek`]b*Alnkr]j`kn]_ekj]hiajpa mqaahalkooqe(lknaooj_e](kooacqejpaolna`e_]`ko6apanje`]`a(ejbejepq`a(kjeo_ej) _e](kjelkpj_e](^kj`]`a(fqope]aieoane_ n`e](iaoikmqap]eo]pne^qpkooaf]iqi ieopnek`]b7
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
lnkr]nmqakiqj`kateopaajkapanjk(i]obke_ne]`k`kj]`]lkn@aqoanapknj]n]k j]`](jk`e]`kFqvkBej]h7lnkr]nmqakiqj`knaoqhp]`]rkjp]`a`erej]ackranj]`k lah]Lnkre`j_e]`erej](]mq]h]cap]jpklkniaekoj]pqn]eo$]ohaeo`]j]pqnav]%mq]jpk lkniaekook^naj]pqn]eo$koieh]cnao%*Lknmqaan]ja_aoone]aoo]lnkr];Lknmqa(`klkj) pk`areop]`]n]vk(@aqo(oaj`klanbaepk(_kilhapk(lhajkaapanjk(jk_]na_e]`aj]`]( jklna_eo]r]`aj]`]a(lknp]jpk(jkpejd]lknmqajail]n]mqa_ne]nkiqj`k7 lnkr]nmqa(ai^kn]@aqooaf]ei]pane]haejbejepk(oq]]klk`apanabaepkoi]pane]eo abejepko(_kikkiqj`kakdkiai7lknp]jpk(lnkr]nmqa@aqo_]qo]abe_eajpa`a pk`]o]o_keo]oamqaqi]_]qo]ei]pane]haejbejep]lk`alnk`qvenqiabaepki]pane]ha bejepk(iaoikmqaeookoaf]qiieopnek`]bmqa]n]vkk^nec]`]]]_aep]n* @ab]pk(]behkokbe]cnac](aijkia`kolnej_leko`]e`ajpe`]`aa`]jk_kjpn]`ek( oailna `aikjopnkq mqa qi] _]qo] lna_eo] oan `a iaoi] j]pqnav] mqa oaq abaepk a( lkn aooaikperk(]oE`ae]o$aiLh]pk%akLneiaenkIkpknEi rah$ai=neop pahao%an]i_]qo]o bej]eoaf]i]eo_]qo]oi]pane]eo(bkni]eokqabe_eajpao*Lknmq;Lknmqaqi]_]qo]bej]h]ca ]`eop j_e](oaioae`ajpebe_]n_ki]mqehkmqa]`aoaf](]lnk_qn]*=k_kjpnnek(]okqpn]opno _]qo]o]cai`enap]iajpaok^na]o_keo]ooaiahd]jpao]ah]o(`aiaoi]j]pqnav]mqaah]o* Qi] lh]jp] _]qo] kqpn] lh]jp]( qi ]jei]h _]qo] kqpnk ]jei]h oaiahd]jpa( qi dqi]jk _]qo]kj]o_eiajpk`akqpnkoandqi]jk(a]ooeilkn`e]jpa* Kn](]_ne]k`kiqj`klkn@aqooane](l]n]]iap]boe_]cnac](qi]enn]_ekj]he`]`a aqi]_kjpn]`ek(lkeooapn]p]`aqioanejbejepkaei]pane]h(_qf]]klnk`qvqiabaepk klkopkj]pqnav]`]_]qo](eopk(bejepkai]pane]h*Qiieopnek`]b(`enkkoiap]boe_ko _neopko* lnkr]nmqa]]hi]dqi]j]ateopaamqaeiknp]h(aop]j`k`aopej]`]o]hr]kkq _kj`aj]kapanj]o(oacqj`k]rkjp]`a`]Lnkre`j_e]`erej]7 lnkr]nmqajkd_kjpn]`ekajpna]he^an`]`adqi]j]a]kjeo_ej_e])kjelkpj_e]`a @aqo*=_kjpn]`ekateopal]n]]n]vk(i]ojkateopal]n]]b* Mq]hoane]]_kjpn]`ekn]_ekj]hajpna]he^an`]`adqi]j]l]n]b]vank^aikqki]h(a ]kjeo_ej_e])kjelkpj_e]`erej];=_kjpn]`ekaop]ne]jkb]pk`amqa(oa@aqobav_]`]qi `kodkiajoa(`ao`a]apanje`]`a(o]^akmqa_]`]qi`ahaoao_khdan(ajpkkdkiaijk herna(i]ofbkelna`apaniej]`klah]rkjp]`a`a@aqo*L]n]]bjkd_kjpn]`ek]hcqi] jeook(ai^kn]d]f]ieopnek* lnkr]n mqa ]o e`ae]o $lh]pje_]o%( kq ]o ai]j] ao $jaklh]pje_]o%( kq ko cjanko a ]oaol_eao$]neopkphe_ko% ateopai( ok oq^op j_e]o na]eo( _ne]`]o lahk ejpaha_pk a lah] rkjp]`a `a @aqo a ateopai j] iajpa `erej]* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( e`ae]o( ai]j] ao( cjankoaaol_eaookoq^op j_e]oqjerano]eoakoqjerano]eoateopaip]jpkmq]jpkko ej`er`qko7 lnkr]nmqakOanoa`evkq`araoanajpaj`e`k`aik`k`ebanajpa_kjbkniaoanaben]] @aqokqo_ne]pqn]o*L]n]kocnacko(jkajp]jpk(kOanateope]`a`ebanajpaoi]jaen]o( i]olkooq]qije_koajpe`kjkmqaoanabanana]he`]`aaaooj_e]`apk`kokoaj) pao*Aoo]e`ae](l]n]ko_neopko(jklk`anoani]jpe`]* Lh]pk(lknatailhk(]benikqmqakOano lk`e]aop]nnabane`koe`ae]o`kiqj`kejpa) hecrah(lkeo]o_keo]ooajoraeoan]ikJkOan(_ le](ei]cai(oki^n]`kran`]`aenkOan*F =neop pahao_kjoe`ankqkOan_kikna]hl]n]]o_keo]oj]pqn]eokqoajoraeo(l]n]kLneiaenk Ikpkn Ei rah( l]n] ko oanao i]paipe_ko( lkeo ] `ebanaj] ajpna ahao nabane])oa ]laj]o ]k b]pk`alk`anaiaop]nkqjkoq^iape`koiq`]j]kq]k`aren* Jk_]ok`k_neope]jeoik(lkni(jkan]lkoorahi]jpan]`ebanaj]lh]pje_]ajpnak OanakJkOan(lkeoaopaiqj`kapq`kkmqajahaateopak^n]`a@aqo(_ne]pqn]`a@aqo ajkian]]l]nj_e]*I]op]i^ijkan]lkoorahi]jpan]e`ae]]neopkphe_]`amqa]`e) banaj]ajpnakooanaoaop]ne]]laj]oj]lnaoaj]kq]qoj_e]`k`arenkq`]iq`]j](lkeo
.00
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
l]n]ko_neopkokoan`a@aqo`aj]pqnav]`ebanajpa`koan`]o_keo]o(qi]ravmqaaha _ne]`knaah]ook_ne]pqn]o(ajkdj]`]ai_kiqiajpnaahao*Knaoqhp]`k`]ja_aooe`]`a `a]beni]nmqakOanjklkooqekiaoikoajpe`k(mq]j`k]lhe_]`k]@aqoao_ne]pqn]o(bke ]`ereok`]iap]boe_]aipnopelko`a_kjda_eiajpk6 -*
]pakhkce](mqaoanabana]kOan_kikoan`erejkkq@aqo7
.* ]loe_khkce]n]_ekj]h(mqaoanabana]kOan_kikaooj_e]`]]hi]dqi]j]7 /* ] _koikhkce] n]_ekj]h( mqa oa nabana ]k Oan _kik aooj_e] `]o _keo]o j]pqn]eo kq `k iqj`k* bej]hiajpa(a_kik_kjoamqj_e]`apk`]oaoo]o_kj_al ao(lnkr]nmqaban]vk(na) rah]ka_kjda_eiajpkejpaha_pq]hjkokej_kil]praeojai_kjpn]`ep nekoa(mq]j) `kkbknai(]bkqnarah]k`araoan_kjoe`an]`]oqlaneknn]vka]kejpaha_pk(mqa `araioq^iapan)oa]ah]* Are`ajpaiajpa(kolajo]`knao_neopkojqj_]oalqoan]i`a]_kn`kok^napk`koaooao ]ola_pko(aqi]`]oi]n_]o_]n]_panope_]o`]iap]boe_]_neopbke]`lkqolsopf^* L]n]]hcqjo(lknatailhk(ko_d]i]`koÎqjerano]eoÏ$e`ae]o(ai]j] ao(cjanko(aol) _eao%an]ijkiaocan]eo_ne]`kolknjkoo]n]vkajkoanao(oq^op j_e]okqaooj_e]ona]eo* L]n]kqpnko(kOan`arane]oan]beni]`k_kikiaoikoajpe`kl]n]@aqoal]n]]o_ne]pqn]o(] `ebanaj]ajpnaahaooaj`k`acn]qajk`aj]pqnav]*L]n]iqepko(ban]vkan]iej_kil]) praeoa`arane]ioanejpaen]iajpaoal]n]`]o(_]`]mq]h_kioaq_]ilkln lnek`a_kjda_e) iajpk(oaimqaqi]`araooaoq^iapan)oakqpn]*A]ooeilkn`e]jpa* Ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`]o_kjpnkrnoe]o(`erancj_e]oa`ebanaj]oajpnakolajo]`knao( k_neope]jeoikhackql]n]]iap]boe_]]oal]n]kajpnapakhkce]$@aqo%(loe_khkce]n]_ekj]h $]hi]%a_koikhkce]n]_ekj]h$iqj`k%(^ai_kik]e`ajpebe_]k`apno_kj_aepko6pbo(bp* pk`f^apr_pq k`f^(mqaoapknj]n]ioejjeiko* ?kik_kjoamqj_e]`]e`ajpebe_]kajpnaoan(aooj_e]aoq^op j_e](`aqih]`k(a(`a kqpnk]]beni]k`amqaateopaiaooj_e]okqoq^op j_e]oqjerano]eop]jpkmq]jpkej`ere) `q]eo(]iap]boe_]l]ookq]panqijiankeheiep]`k`aoanaol]n]ejraopec]n6]ooq^op j_e]o qjerano]eo_kikcq](]n(pann](bkck(dkiai(]jfk(]jei]h(racap]h(k^ai(kran`]`aenk(k fqopk(k^ahk(klao]`k(khara7]ooq^op j_e]oej`ere`q]eokqkooanaol]npe_qh]nao7]ooq^o) p j_e]o_ahaopao(]opannaopnao(]o]mqpe_]o(]oi]paipe_]o(]oknc je_]o(]oejknc je_]o(ap_* ?]`]qi]`ah]oan]ejraopec]`]oacqj`kkopnolnej_leko$e`ajpe`]`a(_kjpn]`ek(pan_aenk at_hq`k%(]omq]pnk_]qo]o$i]pane]h(bkni]h(abe_eajpa(bej]h%(k]pka]lkpj_e](]i]pne] a]bkni](]o_]packne]o$mq]he`]`a(mq]jpe`]`a(]k(l]etk(nah]k(pailk(hqc]n(ap_*%(k oeilhaoak_kilkopk(ap_*
=iap]boe_]_hooe_]kqik`anj]
=
.01
l]npen`kbej]h`ko_qhkTREa(_kii]eknejpajoe`]`a(jkej_ek`ko_qhkTREE(k lajo]iajpkk_e`ajp]h_kia]]okbnanqi]iq`]j]_kjoe`anrah(mqaeni]jebao) p]n)oaj]iap]boe_]* Ko beh okbko _hooe_ko $o_qhk TREE% fqhc]r]i)oa ik`anjko lkn panai nkile`k _ki ] pn]`ek`klajo]iajpklh]pje_k(]neopkphe_kajaklh]pje_ka(lkn_kjoacqejpa(lknjk i]eo ]_aep]nai ] pn]`ek mqa d]re] oe`k ah]^kn]`] lahko ia`ear]eo* Lkn nafaep]nai ] ]q) pkne`]`anaheceko]a]]qpkne`]`a`ko]jpeckoai]ooqjpkbehko be_k(reikomqaklkjpk`a l]npe`] `] behkokbe] ] pakne] `k _kjda_eiajpk( eopk ( ] ejraopec]k ok^na ] _]l]_e`]`a dqi]j]l]n]_kjda_an]ran`]`a(`aik`kmqaqi]_keo]kqqiajpao _kjoe`an]`kna]h oa]n]vkdqi]j]lq`an_kjda_)hk(eopk(oalq`anoank^fapk`aqi]e`ae]ran`]`aen]ao) p]^aha_e`]necknko]aiapk`e_]iajpalahkejpaha_pkdqi]jk*Aoo]atecj_e]_kj`qv]qi] naah]^kn]k _kilhap] `] iap]boe_]* Lk`aiko( `a ik`k naoqie`k( ]lkjp]n ko oacqejpao pn]ko_]n]_panope_ko`]jkr]iap]boe_]6
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
]beni]k`]ej_kil]pe^ehe`]`aajpnaban]vk(]_]nnap]j`k]oal]n]k`a]i^]o(`a oknpamqa]naheceka]behkokbe]lkoo]ioacqen_]iejdkoln lneko(iaoikmqa]oacqj) `]jkaopaf]lq^he_]iajpa]qpknev]`]]atlkne`ae]omqa_kjpn]`ec]i]oran`]`aokq `kci]o`]b$]EjmqeoekakO]jpkKb_ek(_ne]`kolah]Ecnaf]?]p he_]l]n]_kjpnkh]n kolajo]iajpko`ko_neopko(an]i]pq]jpaoajkbkn]ilkq_kokolajo]`knaooq^ia) pe`ko]p]eopne^qj]eo(_kikbkek_]ok`aC]hehaq%7
Lknaooa_nepnek(@ao_]npaoako_]npaoe]jko`enkmqadokiajpapnooq^op j_e]o6] oq^op j_e]lajo]jpa$]]hi]%(`abeje`]lahk]pne^qpk`klajo]iajpk7]oq^op j_e]atpajo] $] i]pne] `ko _knlko%( `abeje`] lahk ]pne^qpk `] atpajok7 a ] oq^op j_e] ejbejep] $@aqo%( `abeje`]lahk]pne^qpk`]ejbejepq`a* Beh okbkoaileneop]o(_kikkejchoPdki]oDk^^ao(_kjoe`an]imqajkpaiko_kik _kjda_an]oq^op j_e]`erej]jai]oq^op j_e]]jie_]lknmqajkok`]`]oatlanej_e] oajokne]halkneooki]eo]`amq]`kb]h]n]laj]oaioq^op j_e]_knl na]*?kik_kjoamqj) _e](o _kjda_aiko_knlkalkneookDk^^aojac]mqalkoo]ikoah]^kn]nqi]iap]boe_]6 lk`aikoah]^kn]nqi]cakiapne]aqi]boe_](mqaok_kjda_eiajpko`a_keo]o_knlkn]eo* Lknoq]rav(kbeh okbkfq`aq)dkh]j`o>]nq_dAolejko]_kjoe`an]mqalna_eokhar]n ai_kjp]]`abejekcan]h`aoq^op j_e](]_aep]lknpk`kokobeh okbko`ao`akopailko`a =neop pahao*Aoo]`abejek6Îoq^op j_e]]mqehkmqaateopaaioealknoeajk`alaj`a`a kqpnkol]n]ateopenÏ* Oaaoo]]`abejek`aoq^op j_e](ajpkpk`]o]o_keo]omqabkn]i_ne]`]okqlnk`qve) `]olkn@aqojklk`aioan_d]i]`]o`aoq^op j_e](lkeojkateopailknoeiaoi]oa`a) laj`ai`]]k`erej]l]n]ateopen*?kjoamqajpaiajpa(`evAolejko](jkQjeranokdqi] je_]oq^op j_e](@aqokq]j]pqnav]*=`abejekcan]h`aoq^op j_e]6]mqehkmqaateopaai oealknoeamqajk`alaj`a`akqpnkooanaol]n]ateopen*
%RICHß,ESSING!LBUM,ATINSTOCK
na`abejek`k_kj_aepk`aOankqoq^op j_e]*Koik`anjko_kjoanr]i]`abejekpn]) `e_ekj]h`]oq^op j_e]_kikkOanmqaateopaaioealknoeiaoik(mqaoq^oeopaai oealknoeiaoik*Lkni(aihqc]n`a_kjoe`an]nmqa]oq^op j_e]oa`abejalkncja) nkaaol_ea(d]raj`kp]jpkopelko`aoq^op j_e]omq]jpkocjankoaaol_eaodkqran( l]oo])oa]`abejen]oq^op j_e]har]j`kai_kjoe`an]koaqolna`e_]`koaooaj_e]eokq oaqo]pne^qpkoaooaj_e]eo(eopk(]mqah]olnklnea`]`aokq]pne^qpkooaikomq]eoqi] oq^op j_e]jkkmqaah]*
%SPINOSA߯
na`abejek `k _kj_aepk `a _]qo] kq _]qo]he`]`a* Reiko mqa ] iap]boe_] ]neopkphe_] lnklqjd]mq]pnkpelko`a_]qo]o(lkeo]_]qo]an]ajpaj`e`]_kik]mqehkmqanaolkj) orahlah]i]pne](lah]bkni](lah]]kalah]bej]he`]`a`a]hcqi]_keo]* Koik`anjko_kjoe`an]imqa_]qo]]mqehkmqalnk`qvqiabaepk`apaniej]`ka ]`iepai]laj]o`keopelko`a_]qo]o6]bcf`fbkqba]cfk^i*Kabaepklk`aoanlnk`qve`k lknqi]jpa_a`ajpa$kbkck]_]qo]kqk]jpa_a`ajpa`k]mqa_eiajpka`]`eh]p]k `aqi_knlk%kqaireop]`aqibei$jkoo]o] aoj]o_ai`aao_khd]omqab]vaiko `koiaekol]n]]h_]j]nqi`apaniej]`kbei%*@^rp^bcf`fbkqb]mqah]j]mq]hqi] ]k]jpanekn`apaniej]_kik_kjoamqj_e]ja_aoone]]lnk`qk`aqiabaepk*@^rp^ cfk^i]mqah]mqa`apaniej](l]n]kooanaolajo]jpao(]ao_khd]`]na]hev]kkqjk na]hev]k`aqi]]k*=_]qo]abe_eajpapai]h_]j_aqjerano]hj]j]pqnav](eopk(] pkp]he`]`a`]j]pqnav]klan]lknnah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkkqlkn_]qo]he`]`aabe_eajpa ja_aoone]*=_]qo]bej]ho pair]he`]`al]n]]]k`aoanao`kp]`ko`an]vkarkjp]) `a(lknp]jpk(o klan]j]]k`a@aqoaj]o] ao`kodkiajo*Jkd_]qo]bej]hj]o klan] ao`]j]pqnav]* ]iap]boe_]jkoa`ere`aaipakhkce](loe_khkce]n]_ekj]ha_koikhkce]n]_ekj]h*=pak) hkce]qi_kjda_eiajpk`ebanajpa`]iap]boe_](ai^kn](_kikaop](aopq`a]oq^op j) _e]ejbejep]7]loe_khkce]n]_ekj]hqi_kjda_eiajpk`ebanajpa`]iap]boe_](ai^kn]( _kikaop](aopq`a]oq^op j_e]lajo]jpa7]_koikhkce]`ebanajpa`]iap]boe_](ai^k) n](_kikaop](aopq`a]oq^op j_e]atpajo]*
.02
2ICHARDß#UMMINS#ORBIS
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Krajpk]_]qo] abe_eajpa`kikre) iajpk`]odhe_ao`ko can]`knao`aajance]( aib]vaj`]`a rajpkj]?]heb nje]( Aop]`koQje`ko*
Mqaaopq`]]iap]boe_];=aooj_e]`koanejbejepk(]aooj_e]`koanlajo]jpakq`k lajo]iajpk(]aooj_e]`koanatpajokkq`]atpajoka]aooj_e]`aqioan_kilkopk`a lajo]iajpkaatpajok(eopk(kdkiai*?kikokaopq`]`ko;?kik_kj_aepkokqe`ae]o necknko]iajpan]_ekj]eo* =oq^op j_e]ejbejep]_kjda_e`]lah]e`ae]n]_ekj]h`aqibqj`]iajpkkqlnej_lek ]^okhqpkmqalnk`qv]aooj_e]a]ateopj_e]`apq`kkmqaateopaÍ@aqo*=oq^op j_e] lajo]jpa_kjda_e`]lah]e`ae]n]_ekj]h`aqi]b]_qh`]`aejpaha_pq]harkheper]mqalnk`qv lajo]iajpkoa] aooacqj`kjkni]o(nacn]oaipk`koaop]^aha_e`kolknah]iaoi]aj) mq]jpklk`an`a_kjda_eiajpkÍ]_kjo_ej_e]_kikb]_qh`]`a`anabhatka`analna) oajp]k`]na]he`]`alkniaek`ae`ae]oran`]`aen]oa_kikrkjp]`amqaao_khda]o] ao*= oq^op j_e]atpajo]_kjda_e`]lah]e`ae]n]_ekj]h`aqi]na]he`]`aboe_k)cakipne_]mqa lnk`qvko_knlko_kikbecqn]oabkni]o`kp]`]o`a_kilneiajpk(h]ncqn](lnkbqj`e`]`a( rkhqiaaikreiajpkÍ]j]pqnav]_kikoeopai]`ahaeoja_aoonek`abeje`klah]ia_ je) _]alah]i]paipe_]* Pnoe`ae]oa]laj]opnoklan]ij]iap]boe_]6]e`ae]`koanejbejepk_kik_]qo]abe) _eajpa `] j]pqnav] a `k dkiai7 ] e`ae] `k oan lajo]jpa bejepk _kik _]qo] abe_eajpa `ko lajo]iajpko(`ko_kj_aepkoa`]o] aodqi]j]o7]e`ae]`koanatpajokkqj]pqnav]_kik _]qo]abe_eajpamqa(lah]onah] ao`aikreiajpkanalkqok(lnk`qvpk`koko_knlko*@aqo( dkiaiaj]pqnav]okkok^fapko`]iap]boe_]*Ejbejepk(bejepk(_]qo]abe_eajpaa_]qo]bej]h okkolneiaenkolnej_leko`amqaoak_ql]]iap]boe_]*E`ae]oran`]`aen]olnk`qve`]olahk ejpaha_pkdqi]jk(_ki]omq]eokoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpknalnaoajp]a_kjda_a]na]he`]) `a(okkobqj`]iajpko`]iap]boe_]_kik_ej_e]ran`]`aen]kq_kikBehkokbe]Lneiaen]*
=cn]j`a_neoa`]iap]boe_]6@]re`Dqia
O
.03
a]na]he`]`aejraopec]`]lah]iap]boe_]]mqah]mqalk`aa`araoann]_ekj]hiajpa aop]^aha_e`]lah]oe`ae]oran`]`aen]olnk`qve`]olahklajo]iajpkkqlah]n]vkdq) i]j](mqa]_kjpa_anoaoalnkr]nmqap]eoe`ae]ookd^epkoiajp]eo`koqfaepk`k _kjda_eiajpkajk_knnaolkj`ai]na]he`]`a]hcqi]; =iap]boe_]]jpec]aia`ear]h^]oa]r])oaj]]beni]k`amqa]na]he`]`akqkOanateo) paaioeiaoikamqaahaoakbana_ap]h_kik]klajo]iajpk* =iap]boe_]_hooe_]kqik`anj]^]oa]r])oaj]]beni]k`amqakejpaha_pkdqi]jk kqklajo]iajpklkooqeklk`anl]n]_kjda_an]na]he`]`ap]h_kikaioeiaoi]amqa( cn]]ooklan] aoejpaha_pq]eokq]ko_kj_aepkomqanalnaoajp]i]o_keo]oa]opn]jobkn) i]iaik^fapko`a_kjda_eiajpk(koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkpai]_aook]kOan*
#HRISTIE´Sß)MAGES#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
P]jpkjqi_]ok_kikjkqpnk(]iap]boe_]^]oa]r])oaai`keolnaooqlkopko6 -*
]na]he`]`aaioeateopaalk`aoan_kjda_e`]7
.* e`ae]okq_kj_aepkookqi_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk`]na]he`]`a(lknmqa]ran`]`a ]_knnaolkj`j_e]ajpna]o_keo]oakolajo]iajpko(kqajpnakejpaha_pka]na]he`]`a* Aooao`keolnaooqlkopko]ooajp]r]i)oajqije_kbqj`]iajpk6]ateopj_e]`aqiOan Ejbejepk$@aqo%mqac]n]jpe]]na]he`]`aa]ejpahece^ehe`]`a`apk`]o]o_keo]o(`kp]j`kko dqi]jko`aqiejpaha_pk_]l]v`a_kjda_)hkop]eo_kikokaioeiaoiko* @]re` Dqia `en mqa ko `keo lnaooqlkopko `] iap]boe_] jk pi bqj`]iajpk( jk lkooqair]he`]`a]hcqi]* =iap]boe_]Í]jpec](ia`ear]ha_hooe_]kqik`anj]Ían]oqopajp]`]lknpnolnej) _lekomqafaopq`]ikomq]j`kpn]p]iko`]e`ae]k_e`ajp]h`]n]vk6klnej_lek`]e`aj) pe`]`a(k`]jk_kjpn]`ekak`]n]vkoqbe_eajpakq`]_]qo]he`]`a*Ko`keolneiaenko oanre]i`ac]n]jpe]l]n]]e`ae]`aoq^op j_e]kqaooj_e]7kpan_aenkoanre]`ac]n]jpe]l]n] atlhe_]n]knecaia]bej]he`]`a`]o_keo]o(^ai_kik]onah] aoajpnakooanao* Dqia(l]npej`k`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(ikopnkqmqakoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk klan]]ook_e]j`koajo] ao(lan_al aoaeilnaoo aona_a^e`]olahko ncko`kooajpe`koa nape`]oj]iai ne]*=oe`ae]oj]`]i]eook`kmqad^epkoiajp]eo`a]ook_e]k`aei) lnaoo aooaiahd]jpaokq`aeilnaoo aooq_aooer]o* Mqa]e`ae]`aoq^op j_e]kq`aaooj_e];J]`]i]eo`kmqaqijkiacan]h`]`kl]n] ej`e_]nqi_kjfqjpk`aei]cajoa`ae`ae]omqajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]paikd^epk`a]ook_e]nlkn _]qo]`]ooaiahd]j]oajpnaah]o*Klnej_lek`]e`ajpe`]`aak`]jk_kjpn]`ekokoeilhao) iajpaknaoqhp]`k`alan_a^anikonalape`]anacqh]niajpa_anp]o_keo]ooaiahd]jpaoaoai) lna`]iaoi]i]jaen](har]j`k)jko]oqlknmqa(lknmqa]olan_a^aiko_kikoaiahd]jpaoa oailna`]iaoi]i]jaen](eookhdao`]ne]qi]e`ajpe`]`aln lne](ej`alaj`ajpa`aj o* Mqa]e`ae]`]_]qo]he`]`a;Kiankd^epkmqajkoo]iajpa]`mqena`aaop]^aha_an nah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkajpnalan_al aoaeilnaoo aooq_aooer]o(_d]i]j`k]o]jpaneknao `a_]qo]oa]olkopaneknao`aabaepko*=nalapek_kjop]jpaanacqh]n`aei]cajokqeilnao) o aooq_aooer]ojkohar]_naj]`amqadqi]_]qo]he`]`ana]h(atpanj](ln lne]`]o_keo]o aej`alaj`ajpa`aj o* Oq^op j_e](aooj_e](_]qo](abaepk(i]pne](bkni]apk`kokokqpnko_kj_aepko`]iap]) boe_]$@aqo(iqj`k(]hi](ejbejepk(bejepk(ap_*%jk_knnaolkj`ai]oanao(]ajpe`]`aona]eoa atpanj]o(ej`alaj`ajpao`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(i]ookjkiaocan]eo_kimqakoq) faepkjkiae]aej`e_]oaqoln lnekod^epko]ook_e]perko*Aeolknmqa]iap]boe_]bkeoailna ]heiajp]`]lkn_kjpnkrnoe]oejbej`raeo(lkeojkoanabane]]jajdqi]na]he`]`aatpanj] ateopajpaaioealknoe(i]o]d^epkoiajp]eo`kooqfaepko(d^epkomqaokiqepkr]neraeo a`kknecai]ejian]o`kqpnej]obehko be_]ooaijajdqibqj`]iajpkna]h* =l]npen`aDqia(]iap]boe_](p]h_kikateopen]`ao`akocnacko(pknj]r])oaeilkoorah*
$AVIDß(UME߯ ß FILvSOFOßBRIThNICO
G]jpakbei`]iap]boe_]_hooe_]
K
lneiaenk]na]cen]kolnk^hai]olkopkolknDqiabkeG]jp(]k`a_h]n]nmqa(cn]]o ]kbeh okbkejcho(l`aÎ`aolanp]n`kokjk`kcipe_kÏ*Kmqakokjk`kcipe_k; pki]n_kiklkjpk`al]npe`]`]iap]boe_]]e`ae]`amqaateopaqi]na]he`]`aai oe$@aqo(]hi](iqj`k(ejbejepk(bejepk(i]pne](bkni](oq^op j_e](_]qo]he`]`a%(mqalk`aoan _kjda_e`]lknjkoo]n]vkkq(kmqa`jkiaoik(pki]n_kiklkjpk`al]npe`]`]iap]) boe_]]]beni]k`amqa]oe`ae]olnk`qve`]olknjkoo]n]vk_knnaolkj`aiat]p]iajpa] qi]na]he`]`aatpanj](mqaateopaaioealknoeiaoi]* Aldjqf`l]mqahamqa]_aep](oaiat]iaaoai_npe_](]beni] aook^na]o_keo]oa ok^na]oe`ae]o*Dqia`aolanpkq]iap]boe_]`kokjk`kcipe_klknmqa]bknkq]ej`]c]n ok^naoq]ln lne]r]he`]`aaoq]lnapajok]k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk*
.04
'ASGLOWß-USEUMß°ß'ASGLOW
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
=hackne]`ko_ej_k oajpe`ko(lejpqn]`a Cn]n``aH]enaooa( `a-2246]]q`ek nalnaoajp]`]lah] _ne]j]mqapk_]k pnejcqhk7]reok( lah]_ne]j]_kikao) lahdk7kl]h]`]n(lah] iqhdan_ki]bnqp]7 kkhb]pk(lah]_ne]j] oacqn]j`kbhknao7 kp]pk(lahk_kjp]pk `ko_knlkoÍ]ooaj) o] ao(lan_al ao aeilnaoo ao`amqa b]h]Dqia*
6ERß5NIDADEß ßESPE CIALMENTEßOßCAPqTULOß ßEß TAMBmMßAß5NIDADEß ßES PECIALMENTEßOßCAPqTULOßßß
Kmqaabpmboq^oalplklaldjqf`l;ej`]c]n(]jpao`apq`k(oa]iap]boe_]lkoo) raha(oabkn(aimqa_kj`e aolkoorah*@aolanp]n`k`kci]peoikah]^kn]nqi]`oqf`^a^ o^wlqbof`^(eopk(qiaopq`kok^na]aopnqpqn]aklk`an`]n]vkl]n]`apaniej]nkmqa ah]lk`aakmqaah]jklk`a_kjda_anran`]`aen]iajpa* Mq]j`kat]iej]ikoko_kj_aepko`an]vkaran`]`a(reikomqaG]jpna]hevkqqi] Înarkhqk_klanje_]j]Ïaibehkokbe](eopk(ateceqmqa(]jpao`amq]hmqan]beni]kok^na ]oe`ae]o(dkqraooakaopq`k`]ln lne]_]l]_e`]`a`a_kjda_an(eopk(`]n]vk(amqaan] lna_eokikopn]nmqa]n]vkjk`alaj`a`]o_keo]ojainacqh]`]lknah]oaoei]o_keo]o `alaj`ai`]n]vkaoknacqh]`]olknah]*Reikop]i^imqaaha`eopejcqen]`q]ocn]j`ao ik`]he`]`ao`a_kjda_eiajpk6ko_kjda_eiajpkoailne_ko(eopk(^]oa]`kojko`]`ko`] atlanej_e] loe_kh ce_] `a _]`] qi `a j o( a ko _kjda_eiajpko ^ moflof( eopk ( ^]oa]`ko at_hqoer]iajpaj]aopnqpqn]ejpanj]`]ln lne]n]vk(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`]atlanej_e] ej`ere`q]h`a_]`]qi*Reiko(]hi`eook(mqaaha`eopejcqen]]o`q]oi]jaen]olah]omq]eo aooao`keopelko`a_kjda_eiajpkooaatlneiai6kofqvko]j]hpe_kokqatlhe_]perko$aimqa klna`e_]`k]laj]oatlhe_ep]k_kjpa`klajo]`kjk_kj_aepk`koqfaepk%akofqvkooejppe) _kokq]ilhe]perko$aimqaklna`e_]`k]_nao_ajp]jkrko`]`komqajkaop]r]ilajo]`ko jk_kj_aepk`koqfaepk%*Bej]hiajpa(reikomqa]mqaopk`k_kjda_eiajpkaop]r]naoqie`] jqi]lancqjp]bqj`]iajp]h6oklkooraeofqvkooejppe_ko^moflof; @ab]pk(`evG]jp(qifqvk(l]n]panr]hkn_eajpbe_kabehko be_kkqr]hknpa ne_k(`ara lnaaj_dan`q]o_kj`e ao6 -*
oanqjerano]haja_aoonek7
.* oanran`]`aenk(eopk(_knnaolkj`anna]he`]`amqaajqj_e]*
.05
Ko fqvko ]j]hpe_ko lnaaj_dai ]o `q]o _kj`e ao( i]o jk ko fqvko oejppe_ko* Lkn mq;Lknmqaqifqvkoejppe_koa^]oae]jko`]`ko`]atlanej_e]ej`ere`q]ha(_kik^ai ikopnkqDqia(p]hatlanej_e]jko`oajo] aoaeilnaoo aomqa]ook_e]ikoaie`ae]o( i]oaop]ojkokqjerano]eoaja_aoone]ojai_knnaolkj`aina]he`]`a* Kn](_kikfreiko(okiajpafqvkooejppe_kookbkjpa`k_kjda_eiajpk*Lknp]jpk(oa mqeoanikona]hev]niap]boe_]a_ej_e](paiko(lneiaenk(`alnkr]nmqaoklkooraeofqvko oejppe_koqjerano]eo(ja_aoonekoaran`]`aenkoa(lknp]jpk(`aikjopn]nmqap]eofqvkojk lk`aioanailne_koaoei`araioanfqvkooejppe_ko^moflof(kqoaf](mqajk`alaj`ai `]atlanej_e]ej`ere`q]h*=lancqjp]6Îlkoorah]iap]boe_]_kik_ej_e];Ï$eopk(_kik
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
_kjda_eiajpkqjerano]h(ja_aoonekaran`]`aenk%o lk`anoannaolkj`e`]oa(lneiaenk(bkn lnkr]`kmqadkqmqalk`ad]ranfqvkooejppe_ko^moflofok^na]ona]he`]`aoiap]boe_]o( eopk(@aqo(]hi](iqj`k(oq^op j_e](i]pne](bkni](ejbejepk(bejepk(_]qo]he`]`a(ap_*Oap]eo fqvkojkbknailkooraeo(]iap]boe_]_kik_ej_e]jkoanlkoorah* ReikomqaG]jp`aikjopnkq]ateopj_e]a]r]he`]`a`kofqvkooejppe_ko^moflofj]o _ej_e]o(]lnaoajp]j`k(`aqih]`k(]`ebanaj]ajpnacbkjbkl$]na]he`]`al]n]jkookaj) paj`eiajpk%akrjbkl$]na]he`]`aaioe%(a(`akqpnk(mqak_kjda_eiajpk`]na]he`]`a bajkije_k(kqoaf](]i]jaen]_kikkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkknc]jev]`aik`kqjeran) o]haja_aoonekko`]`ko`]atlanej_e](cn]]oobkni]o^moflof`]oajoe^ehe`]`a$aol]ka pailk%a`ko_kj_aepko^moflof`kajpaj`eiajpk$]o_]packne]o%*Kmqa_kjda_an; ?kjda_anbkniqh]nfqvkomqajko]lnaoajpaipk`]o]olnklnea`]`ao`aqik^fapk $]o oq]o lnklnea`]`ao lkoeper]o% a at_hq]i pk`]o ]o lnklnea`]`ao mqa k k^fapk jk lk`a lkooqen$]olnklnea`]`aojac]per]o%*Lknatailhk(mq]j`k`eck6ÎKjiank0qiejpaenk l]nÏ(aooafqvk]beni]mqaqi_anpkk^fapk$0%]hcqi]_keo]$qijiank%mqalkooqe `apaniej]`]olnklnea`]`aolkoeper]o$ejpaenk(l]n%a(lkn_kjoacqejpa(`ahaaopkat_hq`]o lnklnea`]`aojac]per]o(`ebanajpao`]omqalkooqe$bn]_ekjnekail]n%* Mq]j`k`eck6ÎEopkqi]iao](`ai]`aen](lkooqemq]pnklo(aopfqjpkf]jah](qo]) `]l]n]ao_naranÏ(aopafqvk]beni]mqa_anpkk^fapk$eopk%]hcqi]_keo]$iao]%mqalkooqe_an) p]omq]he`]`ao$i]`aen](mq]pnklo(oanral]n]ao_naran(aopfqjpkf]jah]%a(lkn_kjoacqejpa( `ahaaopkat_hq`]okqpn]o_keo]o$jkqi]_]`aen](jkqihernk%a]ahaokjac]`]o_anp]o lnklnea`]`ao$jk`are`nk(jkaopfqjpklknp](jkoanral]n]`aep]n(ap_*%* Qifqvk(lknp]jpk(jko`]_kjda_an]hcqi]_keo](`ao`amqaaop]lkoo]oan]lnaaj) `e`]j]obkni]o`kaol]ka`kpailkajko_kj_aepko`kajpaj`eiajpk*Qi]_keo]l]oo]] ateopenmq]j`koapknj]k^fapk`aqifqvk*Eookjkoecjebe_]mqakfqvk`of^]ln lne]_keo]( i]ooeimqa^c^wbufpqfom^o^kp*Kfqvkmb]na]he`]`a`a]hcqi]_keo]]k_khk_)h]_kik oqfaepk`aqi]lnklkoek(eopk(]k_khk_)h]_kikk^fapk`aqi_kjda_eiajpk*(lknp]j) pk(kfqvkmqal a]mq]he`]`a(]mq]jpe`]`a(]_]qo]he`]`a(]oq^op j_e](]i]pne](]bkni]( ]aooj_e]`]o_keo]o(j]ia`e`]aimqaaop]oateopai]laj]oajmq]jpkokk^fapko`a_k) jda_eiajpklkopkolah]obkni]o`kaol]k(`kpailkalahko_kj_aepko`kajpaj`eiajpk* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(qi]_keo]ateopamq]j`klk`aoanlkop]lahkoqfaepk`k_kjda_e) iajpk(ajpaj`e`kjk_kikqioqfaepkej`ere`q]haloe_kh ce_k$Fkk(La`nk(I]ne](=j]%( i]o_kikkoqfaepkqjerano]hkqaopnqpqn]^moflofqjerano]h`]n]vkdqi]j](]mqehkmqa G]jp`ajkiej]`aOqfaepkPn]jo_aj`ajp]h*Mq]j`kkfqvkbknoejppe_ka^moflof(k_kjda) _eiajpkk^pe`kqjerano]h(ja_aoonekaran`]`aenk*Lk`aikoo]^ankmqaoka_kikok aooaofqvkooejppe_ko^moflofat]iej]j`k]i]paipe_]a]boe_]* Jkajp]jpk(]`aikjopn]k`amqa(cn]]oobkni]o^moflof`]oajoe^ehe`]`aacn]]o ]ko_kj_aepko^moflof`kajpaj`eiajpk(kofqvkooejppe_ko^moflofoklkooraeo(qi]`a) ikjopn]kmqajk]fq`]aij]`]]lancqjp]ok^na]lkooe^ehe`]`a`]iap]boe_]*Lknmq; ?kikreiko(G]jp`eopejcqeq`q]oik`]he`]`ao`ana]he`]`a6]mqaoakbana_a]j oj] atlanej_e]ana_a^a]obkni]o`]oajoe^ehe`]`aa]o_]packne]o`kajpaj`eiajpk$kbaj) iajk%a]mqajkoakbana_aatlanej_e]jaina_a^abkni]oa_]packne]o$kkrjbkl%* Kn](]iap]boe_]lnapaj`aoan]_ej_e]mqa_kjda_a]o_keo]oaioe(kkrjbkl(]mqehkmqa oane]`]`k]klajo]iajpklqnkoaijajdqi]nah]k_ki]atlanej_e]*Jkajp]jpk(o d _kjda_eiajpkqjerano]haja_aoonekÍ_ej_e]ran`]`aen]Í`]mqehkmqaknc]jev]`klahk oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk$koqfaepkpn]jo_aj`ajp]h%j]obkni]o`kaol]ka`kpailka`a ]_kn`k_kiko_kj_aepko`kajpaj`eiajpk*Oakkrjbkl]mqehkmqajqj_]oa]lnaoajp] oajoe^ehe`]`ajai]kajpaj`eiajpk(i]o]beni]`klahklajo]iajpklqnk(jklk`aoan _kjda_e`k*Aoakkrjbklkk^fapk`]iap]boe_](aop]jkqi_kjda_eiajpklkoorah* Pkiaikoqiatailhkmqar]ejko]fq`]nj]_kilnaajok`]]ncqiajp]kg]jpe]j]* Mq]j`k]iap]boe_]oanabana]@aqo(ah]k`abeja_kikei]pane]h(ejbejepk(apanjk(ej) _]qo]`k(lnej_lekabqj`]iajpk`]oaooj_e]oaateopj_e]o`apk`kokooanao* Raf]iko _]`] qi] `]o mq]he`]`ao ]pne^q`]o ]k oqfaepkÎ@aqoÏ kq e`ae] `a @aqo*
3UJEITOß4RANSCENDENTALßß AßPALAVRAßTRANSCENDENTALßß VEMßDOßVOCABULfRIOß MEDIEVALßEßSIGNIFICAß ±AQUILOßQUEßTORNAßPOSSqVELß ALGUMAßCOISA ßAßCONDIljOß NECESSfRIAßDEßPOSSIBI LIDADEßDAßEXISToNCIAßEß DOßSENTIDOßDEßALGUMAß COISAß!OßFALARßEMß3UJEITOß 4RANSCENDENTAL ß+ANTßESTfß AFIRMANDOßQUEßOßSUJEITOß DOßCONHECIMENTOßOUßAß RAZjOßPURAßUNIVERSALßmßAß CONDIljOßNECESSfRIAßDEß POSSIBILIDADEßDOSßOBJETOSß DOßCONHECIMENTOßQUE ßPORß ISSO ßSjOßPOSTOSßPORßELE
.1,
=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
.1-
Ei]pane]h6lknp]jpk(jkaol]_e]h7ejbejepk6lknp]jpk(jkaol]_e]h7apanjk6lknp]jpk(jkpai) lkn]h7ej_]qo]`k6lknp]jpk(oai_]qo]7lnej_lekabqj`]iajpk`apq`k6lknp]jpk(]_ei]a bkn]`apk`]]na]he`]`a_kjda_e`](jkoq^iape`k]jajdqi]_kj`ekkqej_kj`e_ekj]`k* =e`ae]iap]boe_]`a@aqo]e`ae]`aqioanmqajklk`ajko]l]na_anok^]bkni] `kaol]kapailk7`aqioan]kmq]h]_]packne]`]_]qo]he`]`ajkoa]lhe_]7`aqioan mqa( jqj_] paj`k oe`k `]`k ] j o( lkopk( ajpnap]jpk( _kik bqj`]iajpk a lnej_lek `a pk`]]na]he`]`aa`apk`]]ran`]`a*=ooei(]e`ae]iap]boe_]`a@aqoao_]l]`apk`]o]o _kj`e ao`alkooe^ehe`]`a`k_kjda_eiajpkdqi]jka(lknp]jpk(]iap]boe_]qo]ehacepe) i]iajpaaoo]e`ae]l]n]]beni]nmqa@aqoateopaal]n]`evankmqaaha*G]jpailnac]qi] ]ncqiajp]koaiahd]jpal]n]`keokqpnkok^fapko`]iap]boe_]6]ateopj_e]`]]hi]kq oq^op j_e]lajo]jpaa]`eo_qook`]bejepq`akqejbejepq`a`kiqj`k* =p]ckn](`evG]jp(]iap]boe_]paioe`kqi]ejoajo]pav`kcipe_]*Paioe`k]lnapaj) ok`a_kjda_an]mqahaooanaomqa(fqop]iajpa(ao_]l]i`apk`]lkooe^ehe`]`adqi]j]`a _kjda_eiajpk(lkeookoanao]komq]eojkoa]lhe_]i]o_kj`e aoqjerano]eoaja_aoone]o `kofqvko(eopk(aol]k(pailk(_]qo]he`]`a(mq]he`]`a(mq]jpe`]`a(oq^op]j_e]he`]`a(ap_* Aoo]iap]boe_]jklkoorah* I]oeookjkoecjebe_]mqapk`]iap]boe_]oaf]eilkoorah* Mq]h ] iap]boe_] lkoorah; ]mqah] mqa pai _kik k^fapk ] ejraopec]k `ko _kj) _aepko qo]`ko lah]o _ej_e]o Í aol]k( pailk( mq]jpe`]`a( mq]he`]`a( _]qo]he`]`a( oq^o) p]j_e]he`]`a(qjerano]he`]`a(ja_aooe`]`a(ap_*Í(eopk(mqapai_kikk^fapkkaopq`k`]o _kj`e ao`alkooe^ehe`]`a`apk`k_kjda_eiajpkdqi]jka`apk`]atlanej_e]dqi]j] lkoorah(kqoaf](kaopq`k`]o_kj`e ao^moflof`]ateopj_e]`kok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpk* =iap]boe_]aopq`](lknp]jpk(^p`lkaf bprkfsbop^fpbkb`bppof^pa^l_gbqfsfa^abbjdbo^i ajkkÎOanajmq]jpkOanÏ(jai@aqo(]hi]aiqj`k(jaioq^op j_e]ejbejep](lajo]jpaa atpajo]*Aopq`]]oi]jaen]olah]omq]eokoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkl a]na]he`]`a(eopk( aop]^aha_akok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpka`]atlanej_e]*=iap]boe_]k_kjda_eiajpk`k _kjda_eiajpkdqi]jka`]atlanej_e]dqi]j](kq(aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(`kik`k_kik kooanaodqi]jko(ajmq]jpki]jebaop] ao`kOqfaepkPn]jo_aj`ajp]h(`abejaiaaop]^aha) _aina]he`]`ao* D(]hi`aooa(qikqpnkk^fapkl]n]]iap]boe_]*Jkoapn]p](lkni(`aqik^fapk pa ne_kaoei`aqik^fapklnpe_k(mq]hoaf](]]kdqi]j]_kik]kikn]h(kqkmqaG]jp _d]i]`a^ lifsobmloabsbo*Lknmqa]ikn]h(kq]pe_](oapknj]k^fapk`]iap]boe_];Lkn _]qo]`]he^an`]`a* Oa]n]vkpa ne_]`aranaolkj`anlancqjp]ok^na]lkooe^ehe`]`a`k_kjda_eiajpk ran`]`aenk(]n]vklnpe_]`aranaolkj`anoacqejpalancqjp]6lkoorah]]kherna; =n]vkpa ne_]ikopn]mqapk`kokooanao(ej_hqej`kkodkiajo(okoanaoj]pqn]eo*Eook oecjebe_]mqaokoanaooq^iape`ko]nah] aoja_aoone]o`a_]qo]aabaepk(p]eo_kikaop]) ^aha_e`]olah]_ej_e]`]j]pqnav]kqboe_]*=j]pqnav]knaejk`]ohaeoj]pqn]eo`a_]qo]) he`]`aa(_kikjah](pq`k]_kjpa_a`aik`kja_aoonek(ah]knaejk`]ja_aooe`]`a(jk d]raj`k]hqc]nl]n]ao_khd]ohernao*Jkajp]jpk(kooanaodqi]jkook_]l]vao`a]cenlkn ao_khd]herna(lkn`apaniej]kn]_ekj]h`aoq]rkjp]`aaok_]l]vao`a]cenaijkia`a bejokqbej]he`]`aodqi]j]o(ajk]laj]o_kj`e_ekj]`kolkn_]qo]oj]pqn]eoja_aoone]o* ?kikeooklkoorah; = ]k herna kq lkn ao_khd] rkhqjpne] n]_ekj]h qi] ]k lkn bej]he`]`a a jk lkn _]qo]he`]`aja_aoone]kqlknja_aooe`]`a*Jaooaoajpe`k(]]kikn]hikopn]mqa(]hi`k naejk_]qo]h`]j]pqnav](ateopaknaejkpe_k`]he^an`]`aa`]bej]he`]`a*?]^aiap]boe_] kaopq`k`aoo]kqpn]ik`]he`]`a`ana]he`]`a(mqajkj]pqn]hjaipa ne_](i]olnpe_]* =ooei(]kh]`k`k_kjda_eiajpk`]n]vkpa ne_](]iap]boe_]pai_kikk^fapkkaopq`k`] n]vklnpe_]kq`]pe_]* ?kiklkoorah]he^an`]`a;?kiklkoorah]]khernalknbej]he`]`a;Mq]eook]o bej]he`]`ao`]re`]pe_];Kmqak`aran;Kmqaa_kiklkoorah]cenlkn`aran;Kmqa ]renpq`a;Aeo]hcqjo`kopai]o`]iap]boe_]_kikaopq`k`]n]vklnpe_]*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
#APqTULOß =kjpkhkce]_kjpailknja]
=dan]j]g]jpe]j]
=
l o]okhqkg]jpe]j]l]n]klnk^hai]`]iap]boe_](aop]jki]eonapknjkq]jpe) c]_kj_alk`a_kjda_eiajpk`]na]he`]`aaioe(i]o_]iejdkqjkoajpe`kej]q) cqn]`klknG]jp(_kjda_e`k_kike`a]heoik* Lknmqafab^ifpjl; Reikomqa]behkokbe]$j]=jpecqe`]`a(j]E`]`aI`e]aj]Ik`anje`]`a%an]na]heop]( eopk ( kq l]npe] `] ]beni]k `a mqa ] na]he`]`a kq k Oan ateopai ai oe iaoiko a mqa( _kikp]eo(lk`aioan_kjda_e`kolah]n]vkdqi]j](kql]npe]`]]beni]k`amqa]n]vk dqi]j] an] k lk`an l]n] _kjda_an ]o _keo]o ai oe iaoi]o kq ] na]he`]`a ai oe* Reiko p]i^imqakna]heoik_hooe_kkqik`anjkejpnk`qven]qi]iq`]j]jkna]heoik]jpeck aia`ear]h(lkeoatecen]mqa(]jpao`aeje_e]nqi]ejraopec]kiap]boe_]`]na]he`]`a(bkooa naolkj`e`]]mqaopk6ÎLk`aiko_kjda_an]na]he`]`a;Ï* Reiko(]oacqen(knaoqhp]`k`aoo]atecj_e]6@]re`Dqiaikopn]j`kmqak_kjpa`k `]iap]boe_]ok]laj]ojkoo]oe`ae]oamqaaop]ookjkiaocan]eo]pne^q`ko]kod^epko loe_kh ce_ko`a]ook_e]nko`]`ko`]oajo]ka`]lan_alk*Koajpeiajpkoq^faperkkqloe) _kh ce_k`anacqh]ne`]`a(_kjop j_e]abnamqj_e]`ajkoo]oeilnaoo aookpn]jobkni]`ko aiajpe`]`aoiap]boe_]omqa(j]ran`]`a(jkateopai* G]jp_kilhapkq]pn]fap ne]ik`anj](i]o_ki`q]oejkr] aobqj`]iajp]eo6ailne) iaenkhqc]n(pn]jobknikq]ln lne]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpkaiiap]boe_](]k]beni]nmqa aop]ejraopec]]o_kj`e aocan]eo`]k^fapere`]`a(eopk(`k_kjda_eiajpkqjerano]haja_ao) onek`kobajiajko(a(aioacqj`k(ikopnkqmqakoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkjk(_kik lajo]n]Dqia(koqfaepkloe_kh ce_kej`ere`q]h(i]oqi]aopnqpqn]qjerano]h(e`jpe_]l]n] pk`kokooanaodqi]jkoaipk`kokopailkoahqc]nao(amqa]n]vk(_kikb]_qh`]`a^ moflof`a_kjda_ankqkOqfaepkPn]jo_aj`ajp]h*Amqana]he`]`a_kjda_raha_kjda_e`]] bajkije_](eopk(]mqah]lkop]lah]k^fapere`]`aaop]^aha_e`]lah]oklan] ao`kOqfaepk Pn]jo_aj`ajp]hok^nako`]`ko`]atlanej_e]* Kmqa]k^fapere`]`a;Kmqabajiajk;Kmqa]na]he`]`aajmq]jpkk^fapkkqba) jiajk;]na]he`]`aaopnqpqn]`]lah]ofabf^plnk`qve`]olahkoqfaepk*Lkneook]iap]boe_] oapknj]fab^ifpq^kqrjfab^ifpjl*K_kjda_eiajpkjkrai`]o_keo]ol]n]koqfaepk`k _kjda_eiajpk(i]or]e`]oe`ae]olnk`qve`]olahkoqfaepkl]n]]o_keo]o*
=_kjpne^qek`]bajkiajkhkce]`aDqooanh
M
q]j`kaopq`]iko]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(reikomqakbeh okbk]haikDqooanh pnkqta(jkej_ek`ko_qhkTT(qi]jkr]]^kn`]cai`k_kjda_eiajpk]mqa`aqk jkia`acbkljbklildf^*Aoo]]^kn`]cai(_kikranaiko]ckn](para_kjoamqj_e]o l]n]]iap]boe_]* Oacqj`kDqooanh(]bajkiajkhkce]aopaj_]nnac]`](ajpnakqpn]o(`apnop]nab]olnej_e) l]eo6`eopejcqenaoal]n]nloe_khkce]abehkokbe](]beni]n]lnekne`]`a`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiaj) pkkq_kjo_ej_e]nabhater]`e]jpa`kok^fapkoa]ilhe]n+najkr]nk_kj_aepk`abajiajk*
.1.
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
@eopejkaoal]n]kajpnaloe_khkce]abehkokbe] Jkbej]h`ko_qhkTETajkej_ek`ko_qhkTT(iqepkolajo]`knaofqhc]n]imqa]loe) _khkce]pki]ne]khqc]n`]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpka`]h ce_]a(lknp]jpk(`]behkokbe]*J] klejek`ahao(]_ej_e]lkoeper]`kloemqeoikoane]oqbe_eajpal]n]atlhe_]n]o_]qo]oa]o bkni]o`a_kjda_eiajpk(oaija_aooe`]`a`aejraopec] aobehko be_]o* Dqooanh(lkni(ikopnkqkamqrk_k`ap]hklejek*=loe_khkce](`evaha(_kikpk`]a mq]hmqan_ej_e](aopq`]aatlhe_]c^qlpl_pbossbfp(i]ojklk`akbana_ankobqj`]iajpko `ap]eoaopq`koaatlhe_] ao(lkeokobqj`]iajpko(_kikkjkiaej`e_](jkokb]pkok^) oanrraeo*Kaopq`k`kobqj`]iajpko_]^abehkokbe]* = loe_khkce] atlhe_]( lkn iaek `a k^oanr] ao a `a nah] ao _]qo]eo( b]pko iajp]eo a _kilknp]iajp]eo(eopk(koia_]jeoikoboe_ko(beoekh ce_koalomqe_komqajkob]vaipan oajo] ao(lan_al ao(hai^n]j]o(lajo]iajpkokqmqajkolaniepaina]hev]n] aolah]o mq]eojko]`]lp]iko]kiaek]i^eajpa*=behkokbe](lkni(`ebana`]loe_khkce](lknmqaej) raopec]kmqa]lan_alk(kmqa]iai ne](kmqak_kilknp]iajpk(kmqamqan`evan Îlomqe_kÏ(kmqamqan`evanÎboe_kÏ(ap_*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(jkatlhe_]b]pkoiajp]eoa`a _kilknp]iajpklkniaek`aatlhe_] ao_]qo]eo$kq`anah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepk%(i]o`ao) _nara]ooecjebe_] aomqa_kjopepqai]re`]lomqe_](koajpe`k`]o]pere`]`aoaklan] ao lomqe_]o*?kik(l]n]]bajkiajkhkce](]ooecjebe_] aook]oaooj_e]o(]behkokbe]`ebana`] loe_khkce]lknmqaaop]bumif`^c^qlpa]mqah]abp`obsbbppk`f^p`]re`]lomqe_]* Pkiaikoqiatailhk* Mq]j`k qi loe_ hkck aopq`] ] lan_alk( lnk_qn] `eopejcqen `keo pelko `a b]pko6 ko b]pkoatpanjkok^oanrraeo(]mqa`kjkia`aaopiqhko$hqv(_]hkn(_kn(bkni]`kok^fapko( `eop j_e](ap_*%(akob]pkoejpanjkoej`enap]iajpak^oanrraeo(]mqa`kjkia`anaolkop]o* @ere`akb]pklan_alperkaiaopiqhkoatpanjkoaejpanjko$kmqa]_kjpa_ajkoeopai]jan) rkokajk_na^nk%aainaolkop]oejpanj]oaatpanj]o$]oklan] ao`koeopai]janrkokak ]pkoajokne]h`aoajpenkqlan_a^an]hcqi]_keo]%* Mq]j`k qi beh okbk aopq`] ] lan_alk( lnk_a`a `a ik`k iqepk `ebanajpa* ?kia] lancqjp]j`k6ÎKmqa]lan_alk;Ï(`ebanajpaiajpa`kloe_ hkck(mqal]npa`]lancqjp]6 Î?kik]_kjpa_aqi]lan_alk;Ï* Kmqa]lan_alk;=jpao`ai]eoj]`](qiik`k`a]jkoo]_kjo_ej_e]nah]_ekj]n)oa _kikiqj`katpaneknlknejpani`ek`ajkook_knlk*Aioacqj`khqc]n(qi_anpkik`k `a]_kjo_ej_e]nah]_ekj]n)oa_ki]o_keo]omq]j`k]opki]_kikna]he`]`aomq]hep]per]o$_kn( o]^kn(k`kn(p]i]jdk(bkni](`eop j_e]o(]cn]`raeo(`ao]cn]`raeo(`kp]`]o`abeoekjkie]a`a oajpe`k(^ah]o(bae]o(`ebanajpaoqi]o`]okqpn]o(l]npao`aqi]l]eo]cai(ap_*%*=lan_alk qi]sfsk`f^*Aipan_aenk(aoo]rerj_e]qi]bkni]`a_kjda_eiajpk`kp]`]`aaopnqpqn]6 dk^ql`alan_a^an$lah]_kjo_ej_e]%adk`loobi^qllan_a^e`k$]_keo]atpanj]%7]_]n]_pa) nope_]lnej_el]h`klan_a^e`k]`akbana_an)oalknb]_ao(lknlanbeokqlanola_per]o(_kik]hck ejpaniejrah(mqajkookooajpe`kojqj_]lk`ai]l]jd]n`aqi]o rava`aik`kpkp]h* Kmqa]lan_alk;Kq(aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(mq]h]bppk`f^`]lan_alk;qi] rerj_e]`]_kjo_ej_e](qi]pk(_qfk_knnah]pkokmq]he`]`aolan_a^e`]olah]ia`e]k`a jkook_knlk7qiik`k`aaop]nikojkiqj`ka`ajkonah]_ekj]niko_ki]lnaoaj] `]o_keo]o`e]jpa`aj o7qiik`k`ebanajpa(lknatailhk(`]rerj_e]ei]cej]per](`] rerj_e]nabhater](ap_* = loe_khkce] jko `ev mqa e lan_alk a jko kbana_a qi] atlhe_]k _]qo]h l]n] ah]( i]ojklk`ajko`evankmqa]lan_alk(lkeol]n]eooklna_eo]ne]_kjda_an]aooj_e]`] ln lne]_kjo_ej_e]*
I]jqpajk`]lnekne`]`a`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk
.1/
?kjoanr]j`k)oabeahpn]`ekik`anj]ag]jpe]j](Dqooanhlnerehace]kq`lnekne`]`a _kjo_ej_e]nabhater]kq]koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(eopk(]beni]mqa]oaooj_e]o`ao_ne) p]olah]behkokbe]oklnk`qve`]okq_kjopepq`]olah]_kjo_ej_e]ajmq]jpkqilk`anl]n] `]noecjebe_]kna]he`]`a*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
=_kjo_ej_e]`amqab]h]kbeh okbkjk(are`ajpaiajpa(]mqah]`amqab]h]kloe_ ) hkck* L]n] aopa( ] _kjo_ej_e] k jkia `]`k ] qi _kjfqjpk `a b]pko atpanjko a ejpanjko k^oanrraeoaatlhe_]`ko_]qo]hiajpa*=_kjo_ej_e]]mqaoanabanakbeh okbkkoqfaepk`k _kjda_eiajpk(_kikaopnqpqn]a]pere`]`aqjerano]haja_aoone]`ko]^an*]?kjo_ej_e] Pn]jo_aj`ajp]hkqkOqfaepkPn]jo_aj`ajp]h* Mq]hklk`an`]_kjo_ej_e]nabhater];K`a_kjopepqenkq_ne]n]oaooj_e]o(lkeoaop]o j]`]i]eook`kmqa]opfdkfcf`^ bplnk`qve`]olah]_kjo_ej_e](j]mq]he`]`a`aqilk) `anqjerano]h`aal^ labpbkqfal]kiqj`k* =_kjo_ej_e]jkqi]_keo]ajpna]o_keo]o(jkqib]pkk^oanrrah(jai(_kik ei]cej]r]]iap]boe_](qi]oq^op j_e]lajo]jpakqqi]]hi](ajpe`]`aaolenepq]h*=_kjo) _ej_e]qi]lqn]]pere`]`a(k]pk`a_kjopepqenaooj_e]okqoecjebe_] ao(`]j`koajpe`k ]kiqj`k`]o_keo]o*Aop]oÍkqkiqj`k_kikoecjebe_]kÍokk_knnah]pk`]_kjo_ej) _e]( ]mqehk mqa reo]`k lkn ah] a `ah] na_a^a oajpe`k* Jk qi] oq^op j_e] $qi] _keo]%( i]o qi] ]pere`]`a $qi] ]k%* Lkn oan qi] ]k mqa reo] ko k^fapko _kik oecjebe_] ao( pk`]_kjo_ej_e]oailna`lkp`fk`f^ab*=eook$oan_kjo_ej_e]`a%(Dqooanh`kjkia`a fkqbk`flk^ifa^ab* =_kjo_ej_e]qi]pkejpaj_ekj]haoq]aooj_e]]ejpaj_ekj]he`]`a(kqk]pk`are) o]n ]o _keo]o_kikoecjebe_] ao* K iqj`k kq ] na]he`]`a _kik oecjebe_]k k_knnah]pk ejpaj_ekj]h`]_kjo_ej_e](eopk(kmqareo]`klknah]*=ooei(lknatailhk(lan_a^ank ]pkejpaj_ekj]h`]_kjo_ej_e](klan_a^e`kkoaq_knnah]pkejpaj_ekj]ha]lan_alk] qje`]`aejpanj]aja_aoone]ajpnak]pkak_knnah]pk(ajpnaklan_a^anaklan_a^e`k*lkn aooaikperkmqa(_kjda_aj`k]aopnqpqn]ejpaj_ekj]hkq]aooj_e]`]_kjo_ej_e](oalk`a _kjda_an]aooj_e]`]lan_alk$a(`]iaoi]i]jaen](]aooj_e]`]ei]cej]k(`]ia) i ne](`]nabhatk(ap_*%*
=ilhe]k+najkr]k`k_kj_aepk`abajiajk @ao`aG]jp(cbkjbklej`e_]r]]mqehkmqa(`kiqj`katpanjk(oakbana_a]koqfaepk`k _kjda_eiajpkok^]oaopnqpqn]o_kcjeper]o^moflof`]_kjo_ej_e]$eopk(ok^]obkni]o^ moflof`kaol]ka`kpailkaok^ko_kj_aepko^moflof`kajpaj`eiajpk%*Jkajp]jpk(Dacah ]ilhekqk_kj_aepk`abajiajk(]beni]j`kmqapq`kkmqa]l]na_ao lk`a]l]na_anl]n] qi]_kjo_ej_e]amqa]ln lne]_kjo_ej_e]ikopn])oa]oeiaoi]jk_kjda_eiajpk`aoe( oaj`kah]ln lne]qibajiajk*Lkneook(bkeDacahklneiaenk]qo]n]l]h]rn]cbkljbklil* df^l]n]_kiah]ej`e_]nk_kjda_eiajpkmqa]_kjo_ej_e]pai`aoeiaoi]lkniaek`ko `ai]eobajiajkomqahda]l]na_ai* Dqooanhi]jpik_kj_aepkg]jpe]jkadacahe]jk(i]o]ilhe]]ej`]i]eo]jkk`a bajiajk*L]n]_kilnaaj`anikoaoo]]ilhe]klna_eo]iko_kjoe`an]n]_npe_]mqaaj`a) na]]G]jpa]Dacah* G]jpamqerk_kq)oa]k`eopejcqenbajiajkakrjbkl(lkeo(_kiaoo]`eopejk(i]jpara ]rahd]e`ae]iap]boe_]`]na]he`]`aaioekq`kÎOanajmq]jpkOanÏ(iaoikmqa`eooaooamqa jk]lk`]iko_kjda_an*Dacah(lknoq]rav(]^kheq]`ebanaj]ajpna]_kjo_ej_e]akiqj`k( lknmqa`eooan]mqaaopaj]`]i]eo`kmqakik`k_kik]_kjo_ej_e]oapknj]]oln lne]o _keo]o(pknj])oaiqj`kah]iaoi](pq`koaj`kbajiajk6bajiajkejpaneknÍ]_kjo_ej_e] ÍabajiajkatpaneknÍkiqj`k_kiki]jebaop]k`]_kjo_ej_e]j]o_keo]o* ?kjpn]G]jp(Dqooanh]beni]mqajkdkrjbkl(jkd]Î_keo]aioeÏej_kcjko_) rah*Pq`kkmqaateopabajiajkao ateopaibajiajko*Bajiajk]lnaoaj]na]h`a _keo]ona]eo`e]jpa`]_kjo_ej_e]7]mqehkmqaoa]lnaoajp]`enap]iajpa(Îailaook]Ï(Îai _]njaakookÏ(_kjo_ej_e]* ?kjpn]Dacah(Dqooanh]beni]mqa]_kjo_ej_e]lkooqeqi]aooj_e]`ebanajpa`]oao) oj_e]o `ko bajiajko( lkeo ah] `k]`kn] `a oajpe`k o _keo]o a aop]o ok na_alpkn]o `a oajpe`k* = _kjo_ej_e] jk oa aj_]nj] j]o _keo]o( jk oa pknj] ]o ln lne]o _keo]o( i]o ` oecjebe_]k]ah]o(lani]ja_aj`k`ebanajpa`ah]o* Kmqakbajiajk;]bppk`f^*
.10
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
Kmqa]aooj_e];]pfdkfcf`^ lkqkpbkqfal`aqioan(oq]e`ae](oaqbfalp*=behk) okbe]]`ao_nek`]aooj_e]`]_kjo_ej_e]$`aoaqo]pkoa_knnah]pko%a`]oaooj_e]o`]o _keo]o* Lkn eook( ] behkokbe] qi] bfaqf`^ Í `ao_nek `k bfalp kq `]o aooj_e]o* ?kik k bfalpkq]aooj_e]kbajiajk(]behkokbe]qi]bajkiajkhkce]*
Kobajiajkokqaoo j_e]o
B
'ERTß3CH~TZ!LBUMß AKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
ajiajkjkok]laj]o]o_keo]oi]pane]eomqalan_a^aiko(ei]cej]ikokqhai^n]) iko_kpe`e]j]iajpalknmqaokl]npa`ajkoo]re`]*P]i^ijkok(_kikoqlqjd] G]jp(]laj]o]o_keo]oj]pqn]eo(aopq`]`]olah]o_ej_e]o`]j]pqnav]$boe_](mqie_]( ^ekhkce]( ]opnkjkie]( cakhkce]( ap_*%* Bajiajk ok p]i^i _keo]o lqn]iajpa e`a]eo kq e`a]he`]`ao(eopk(_keo]omqaateopai]laj]ojklajo]iajpk(_kikkoajpaoaopq`]`kolah] i]paipe_]$becqn]ocakipne_]o(jianko(klan] ao]hc^ne_]o(_kj_aepko_kikecq]h`]`a( `ebanaj](e`ajpe`]`a(ap_*%alah]h ce_]$_kikko_kj_aepko`aqjerano]he`]`a(l]npe_qh]ne`]) `a(ej`ere`q]he`]`a(ja_aooe`]`a(_kjpn]`ek(ap_*%* =hi`]o_keo]oi]pane]eo(j]pqn]eoae`a]eo(p]i^iokbajiajko]o_keo]o_ne]`]o lah]]kalah]lnpe_]dqi]j]o$p_je_]o(]npao(ejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o(_naj]ona) heceko]o(r]hknaoikn]eo(ap_*%*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(konaoqhp]`ko`]re`]a`]]kdqi]j]o Í]mqehkmqa_d]i]iko`a_qhpqn]Íokbajiajko(eopk(oecjebe_] aokqaooj_e]omqa ]l]na_ai_kjo_ej_e]amqaok_kjopepq`]olah]ln lne]_kjo_ej_e]* =bajkiajkhkce]]`ao_nek`apk`kokobajiajko(kqbfalpkqaooj_e]o(kqoecje) be_]k`apk`]oaop]ona]he`]`ao6i]pane]eo(j]pqn]eo(e`a]eo(_qhpqn]eo* =k]ilhe]nk_kj_aepk`abajiajk(Dqooanhlnklomqa]behkokbe]`eopejcqeooa`ebanaj) paopelko`aaooj_e]okqbajiajkoamqa_kjoe`an]ooa_]`]qi`ahao_kiki]jebaop]j`k qipelk`ana]he`]`a`ebanajpa(qipelk`aoan`ebanajpa*B]hkq(]ooei(aiobdfbpalpbo6] nacek_kjo_ej_e](]nacekj]pqnav](]naceki]paipe_](]nacek]npa(]nacekdeop ne]( ]naceknahecek(]naceklkhpe_](]nacekpe_](ap_*Lnklomqa]behkokbe]ejraopec]ooa]o aooj_e]oln lne]o`aooaooanaokq`aooaoajpao(_ne]j`klkqlildf^pobdflk^fp* ?kiaoo]lnklkop](Dqooanhb]ve]_kimqa]iap]boe_]`kÎOanajmq]jpkOanÏa]ia) p]boe_]`]ooq^op j_e]o$@aqo(]hi](iqj`k7ejbejepk(lajo]jpa(atpajo]%_a`aooaihqc]n]k aopq`k `k oan `ebanaj_e]`k ai ajpao `kp]`ko `a aooj_e]o ln lne]o a enna`qpraeo qjo ]ko kqpnko*Aooaaopq`koane]]kjpkhkce]ok^]bkni]`akjpkhkce]onacekj]eo*
ëjpe_kakjpkhce_k
-ARTINß(EIDEGGERßß ¯
.11
R
eikomqa]l]h]rn]lkqlildf^`aner]`kl]npe_leklnaoajpa`kran^kbfk^f$oan%(eopk (`alk$ÎajpaÏ%aq lkq^$Î]o_keo]oÏ(ÎkoajpaoÏ%(`komq]eoraikoq^op]jperkqlk6 ÎkOanÏ* Kbeh okbk]haikI]npejDae`accanlnkl a`eopejcqen`q]ol]h]rn]o6kqf`lalkqli* df`l* ìkqf`l oa nabana aopnqpqn] a aooj_e] ln lne] `a qi ajpa( ]mqehk mqa aha ai oe iaoik( oq] e`ajpe`]`a( oq] `ebanaj] ai b]_a `a kqpnko ajpao( oq]o nah] ao _ki kqpnko ajpao*Lkqlidf`loanabana]kaopq`kbehko be_k`koajpao(ejraopec]k`ko_kj_aepkomqa jkolaniep]i_kjda_ana`apaniej]nlahklajo]iajpkaimqa_kjoeopai]oik`]he`]`ao jpe_]o(mq]eokoipk`ko]`amq]`kol]n]kaopq`k`a_]`]qi]`ah]o(mq]eo]o_]packne]o mqaoa]lhe_]i]_]`]qi]`ah]o* Ai naoqik6 kqf`l `ev naolaepk ]ko ajpao ai oq] ateopj_e] ln lne]7 lkqlidf`l `ev naolaepk]koajpaopki]`ko_kikk^fapko`a_kjda_eiajpk*?kikateopai`ebanajpaoaoba) n]okqnace aojpe_]o(ateopenkkjpkhkce]onacekj]eomqaoak_ql]i_ki_]`]qi]`ah]o* Aijkoo]atlanej_e]_kpe`e]j](`eopejcqeikoaolkjp]ja]iajpa_ej_kcn]j`aoaopnqpqn]o jpe_]o6
-*
"AUHAUSß!RCHIV!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
koajpaoi]pane]eokqj]pqn]eomqa_d]i]iko`a `lfp^pob^fp$bnqp]o(nrknao(la`n]o(neko(aopnah]o( ]nae](kOkh(]Hq](iap]eo(ap_*%7
.* koajpaoi]pane]eo]npebe_e]eomqap]i^i_d]i]) iko`a`lfp^pob^fp$jkoo]_]o](iao]o(_]`aen]o( ]qpki raeo(pahabkja(_kilqp]`kn(h il]`]o(_dq) raenk(nkql]o(_]h]`ko(ln]pko(p]hdanao(ap_*%7 /* koajpaoe`a]eo(eopk(]mqahaomqajkok_keo]o i]pane]eo(i]oe`ae]ocan]eo(_kj_a^e`]olahklaj) o]iajpkh ce_k(i]paipe_k(_eajpbe_k(behko be_k a]komq]eo`]ikokjkia`afab^ifa^abp$ecq]h) `]`a( `ebanaj]( jiank( n]ev mq]`n]`]( _n_qhk( _kjfqjpk( _h]ooa( bqjk( r]nerah( bnamqj_e]( ]jei]h(racap]h(iejan]h(boe_k(lomqe_k(i]pne]( ajance](ap_*%7 0* ko ajpao mqa lk`ai oan r]hknev]`ko lkoeper] kq jac]per]iajpaa]komq]eo`]ikokjkia`as^* ilobp $^ahav]( baeqn]( r_ek( renpq`a( n]nk( _kiqi( ^ki(i]h(fqopk(ejfqopk(`eb_eh(b_eh(lkoorah(ei) lkoorah( ran`]`aenk( b]hok( `aoafrah( ej`aoafrah( ap_*%7 1* koajpaomqalanpaj_ai]qi]na]he`]`a`ebanaj) pa `]mqah] ] mqa lanpaj_ai ]o _keo]o( ]o e`a]he) `]`aoakor]hknaoa]komq]eo`]ikokjkia`a jbq^cpf`lp$]`erej`]`akqk]^okhqpk7kejbejepk akj]`]7]iknpaa]eiknp]he`]`a7]e`ajpe`]`a a]]hpane`]`a7kiqj`k_kikqje`]`a(]nah]k a`ebanaj_e]k`apk`kokoajpaokq`apk`]o]o aopnqpqn]ojpe_]o(ap_*%*
Ik^ehenekl]n]mq]npk`araopen`a oajdkn](`a-5./(l]npa`]?]o]Î=i DknjÏ(atlaneiajp]h(_ne]k`k`aoecjan I]n_ah>naqan(mqaqokq_kj_aepko _kjopnqpereop]oaioaqpn]^]hdk*
?kikl]oo]iko`]atlanej_e]jpe_]ejraopec]kkjpkh ce_]; Mq]j`k]mqehkmqab]vl]npa`ajkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j]oapknj]lnk^haipe_k(aopn]jdk( _kjbqok7mq]j`kokikooqnlnaaj`e`kolah]o_keo]oalah]olaook]o(lknmqa]_kjpa_a]hck ejaolan]`kkqeilnareorah7mq]j`k`aoaf]ikoqo]n_anp]o_keo]oajko]^aiko_kikhe`]n _kiah]o7ajbei(mq]j`kkoecjebe_]`k_kopqiaenk`]o_keo]o(`]o] ao(`kor]hknaokq`]o laook]olan`aoajpe`kkqoaikopn]k^o_qnka_kjbqok(kqmq]j`kkmqajkobke`epk(ajoej]) `kapn]joiepe`kok^naahaofjkjkoo]peob]vamqanaikoo]^ani]eoaiahdkn* Lk`aiko(ajpk(lancqjp]n6ÎKmqaeookmqa_d]i]iko`a_keo]na]h$_keo]oj]pqn]eoa _keo]o]npebe_e]eokq_qhpqn]eo%;Ï*@enaikomqaqi]_keo]_d]i]`]`ana]hlknmqalanpaj_a] qi_kjfqjpk`aajpaomqalkooqaiai_kiqi]iaoi]aopnqpqn]kjpkh ce_]6okajpaomqa ateopaibkn]`aj o(aopkjkiqj`k`e]jpa`aj o(eopk(okqipbo7okajpaomqaateopai mqanj okolan_a^]ikomqanjk(mqanj okoqoaikomqanjk7aopklnaoajpaojkiqj`k( iaoikmqajkaopaf]ilnaoajpaol]n]j o(lkeolk`aiaop]nlnaoajpaol]n]pk`kokqbe_]n lnaoajpaol]n]j oai]hcqiikiajpk(eopk(okqi]ob^ifa^ab7okajpaomqa_kia]i ] ateopen a lk`ai `ao]l]na_an( iaoik mqa oaq `ao]l]na_eiajpk oaf] iqepk i]eo hajpk `k mqakjkook(okajpaomqa`qn]ialkooqai`qn]k(eopk(okqbjmlo^fp7okajpaomqaoa pn]jobkni]ijkpailk(oklnk`qve`kolah]]k`akqpnkoalnk`qvaikqpnko(k^a`a_aj`k ]_anpkolnej_leko(eopk(ok_]qo]oaabaepko(ok`^rp^ifa^abp*Pbo(ob^ifa^ab(qbjmlo^ifa^aba `^rp^ifa^abok_kj_aepkokjpkh ce_komqa`ao_narai]aooj_e]`koajpao_d]i]`koÎ_keo]oÏ* Jk_]ok`koajpaoe`a]eo(ko_kj_aepkokjpkh ce_kook^]op]jpa`ebanajpao*Ailneiaenk hqc]n(p]eoajpaojkok_keo]ona]eoÍbpqb_]r]hkqi]_keo]na]h(i]o^fabf^`k_]r]hkjk
.12
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
)MAGE&ORUM!GENCEß&RANCEß0RESSE
qi]_keo](qi_kj_aepkaateopa]laj]o_kik_kj_aepk*Aioacqj`khqc]n(jk_]qo]iqjo ]kokqpnko(i]ookajpaomqalkooqaiqi]`abejekln lne](lk`aj`knah]_ekj]n)oa_ki kqpnkoÍ]e`ae]`adkiaijk_]qo]]e`ae]`a_]r]hk(i]oah]olk`ainah]_ekj]n)oamq]j) `kkdeopkne]`kn(lknatailhk(ikopn]]`ebanaj]ajpnaok_ea`]`ao_qfkatn_epko lkooqe ]ejb]jp]ne]a]mqah]omqaejrajp]n]i]_]r]h]ne]7qi_n_qhkjk_]qo]qipne jcqhk(i]o lk`aiko ejo_naran pne jcqhko jqi _n_qhk l]n] `aikjopn]n qi paknai] kq naokhran qi lnk^hai]*Ok(lknp]jpk(bkqbpobi^`flk^fp(i]ojkoknace`kolahk_kj_aepk`a_]qo]he`]`a* Aipan_aenkhqc]n(jkateopai`kiaoikik`kmqa]o_keo]o(eopk(jk_kia]i]ateopen( pn]jobkni]i)oaa`ao]l]na_aiÍqipne jcqhk(qi]ejbanj_e](]e`ae]`aracap]hjkj]o) _aijaiiknnai(ok^qbjmlo^fp*Fab^ifa^ab(obi^ la^qbjmlo^ifa^abokko_kj_aepko kjpkh ce_kol]n]koajpaoe`a]eo* Jk_]ok`koajpaomqaokr]hknao(ko_kj_aepkokjpkh ce_kolnej_el]eomqako`ao_narai aooaj_e]hiajpaok]nr^ifa^ab$qir]hknlk`aoanjac]perkkq]beni]perk%a]mli^ofa^ab kqlmlpf l$kor]hknaooailnaoa]lnaoajp]i_kikl]nao`aklkopko6^ki)i]q(^ahk)baek( fqopk)ejfqopk(ran`]`aenk)b]hok(ap_*%* K^oanraikomqakoajpe`k`]o_keo]oj]pqn]eooa]hpan]_ki]iq`]j]`ko_kjda_e) iajpko_eajpbe_ko(]ooei_kikoa]hpan]koajpe`k`koajpaoe`a]eo$kmqakocnackoajpaj) `e]ilknjiankjkkmqa]i]paipe_]ik`anj]ajpaj`alknjiank(lknatailhk%* Jk_]ok`koajpaona]eo]npebe_e]eo(eopk(`]o_keo]olnk`qve`]olahkdkiai_ki]op_je_]oa ]o]npao(]iq`]j]jk]laj]o`aoajpe`k(i]o`]oln lne]o_keo]oÍajpaop_je_kobe_]i k^okhapkoa_]aiai`aoqokmq]j`kkqpnko(i]eookbeope_]`ko(oklnk`qve`ko*Koajpe`k `kor]hknaop]i^iiq`]j]o`ebanajpaook_ea`]`aoalk_]o6kmqaan]ej]_aeprahjqi] ok_ea`]`akqjqi]lk_]lk`apknj]n)oa]_aepraha`aoafrahjkqpn]kqre_a)rano]* Oa_kjoe`an]nikokoajpaoj]lanola_per]`kooanaodqi]jko(`enaikomqapk`kokoajpao Íj]pqn]eo(]npebe_e]eo(e`a]eo(r]hknao(iap]boe_koÍokajpao_qhpqn]eoadeop ne_ko(oq^iape) `ko]kpailk(iq`]j](lkeooaqoajpe`kÍoq]aooj_e]Íiq`]_ki]_qhpqn]*Jkajp]jpk( lk`aikok^oanr]np]i^imqa]o_]packne]okjpkh ce_]o$oan(na]he`]`a(_]qo]he`]`a(pailk) n]he`]`a( e`a]he`]`a( ]pailkn]he`]`a( nah]k( `ebanaj]( mq]he`]`a( mq]jpe`]`a( lkh]ne`]`a( klkoek(ap_*%lani]ja_ai(]ej`]mqaiq`aioaqok^fapko*=ooei(lknatailhk(]_ej_e] boe_]lk`akbana_anqi]atlhe_]kejpaen]iajpajkr]l]n]kbajiajk`]lan_alk`]o_k) nao*?kjpq`k(]ateopj_e]`]hqv(`]_kn(`]lan_alk`]o_keo]o_khkne`]olani]ja_aa]aoo] lani]jj_e]mqaoanabana]kjpkhkce]*Qi]ok_ea`]`alk`a_kjoe`an]nkdkikooatq]heoik i]o_qhejkqir]hknlkoeperk$_kikbkek_]okj]ok_ea`]`acnac]]jpec]%kqqir]hknjac]perk $_kikj]ok_ea`]`aejchao]repkne]j](`ko_qhkTET%(i]ok]pk`ar]hkn]nlkoeper]kqjac]pe) r]iajpa]hcqi]]klani]ja_aaaoo]lani]jj_e]mqaejpanaoo]kjpkhkce]*
=jkr]kjpkhkce]6jaina]heoik(jaie`a]heoik
-ERLEAU 0ONTYßß ¯
.13
B
eh okbkomqarean]i]l oDqooanha]`kp]n]ioq]oe`ae]o`aoajrkhran]i]jkr]kjpkhk) ce]*Ajpnaaooaobeh okbko(`keoiana_aiaola_e]h`aop]mqa6k]haikI]npejDae`accan $`amqaib]h]iko]jpanekniajpa%akbn]j_oI]qne_aIanha]q)Lkjpu*=i^koik`ebe) _]n]irne]o`]oe`ae]o`aDqooanhaaobkn]n]i)oal]n]he^an]n]kjpkhkce]`krahdklnk^hai] `aet]`klah]iap]boe_](mq]hoaf](k`ehai]`kna]heoika`ke`a]heoik(`ehai]mqaDqooanh naokhran]aib]rkn`ke`a]heoiklahkl]lahlnalkj`an]jpamqa`an]_kjo_ej_e]pn]jo_aj) `ajp]hkq]koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk* Mq]hk`ehai]lkopklahkna]heoikalahke`a]heoik;Kna]heoik]beni]mqa(oaaheie) j]nikokoqfaepkkq]_kjo_ej_e](naop]i]o_keo]oaioeiaoi]o(]na]he`]`aran`]`aen](k oanaioe* Ke`a]heoik(]k_kjpnnek(]beni]mqa(oaaheiej]niko]o_keo]okqkkrjbkl(naop]] _kjo_ej_e]kqkoqfaepkmqa(lkniaek`]oklan] ao`k_kjda_eiajpk(narah]]na]he`]`a( kk^fapk*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
Dae`accanaIanha]q)Lkjpu]beni]imqa]o`q]olkoe aoaopkamqerk_]`]oamqaok ÎannkociakoÏ(_]^aj`kjkr]kjpkhkce]oqlan)hko*?kiknaokhranqilnk^hai]iehaj]n _kikaooaamqa(]bej]h(]ln lne]deop ne]`]iap]boe_]a`]kjpkhkce]; @evaiko`keobeh okbko6oaaheiej]niko]_kjo_ej_e](jkok^n]j]`](lkeo]o_keo]o ateopail]n]j o(eopk(l]n]qi]_kjo_ej_e]mqa]olan_a^a(ei]cej](mqa`ah]ooahai^n]( jah]o lajo]( mqa ]o pn]jobkni] lahk pn]^]hdk( ap_* Oa aheiej]niko ]o _keo]o( p]i^i jk naop]j]`](lkeojklk`aikoreranoaikiqj`kjaibkn]`aha7jkokikoko_ne]`knao`k iqj`kaoeioaqod]^ep]jpao* @]ikooajpe`k]kiqj`k(pn]jobkni]iko]o_keo]o(_ne]ikoqpajoheko(k^n]o`a]npa( ejopepqe aook_e]eo(i]ojk_ne]ikokln lnekiqj`k*Oai]_kjo_ej_e](jkdiqj`k l]n]j o*Oaikiqj`k(jkpaiko_kik_kjda_anjai]cen*Qiiqj`koaij ooanpq`k mq]jpkoamqaen](iajkokmqaajpaj`aikolknna]he`]`a*Qi]_kjo_ej_e]oaikiqj`k oanpq`kmq]jpkoamqaen](iajko_kjo_ej_e]dqi]j]* =jkr]kjpkhkce]l]npa`]]beni]k`amqabpq^jlpkljrkala`amqaljrkalj^fp sbielalnrbkp$eopk(jkaolankqkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkl]n]ateopen%(i]o(oeiqhp]) ja]iajpa(`amqaokiko_]l]vao`a`]noajpe`k]kiqj`k(_kjda_)hkapn]jobkni)hk* Jkokikoqi]_kjo_ej_e]nabhater]lqn](i]oqi]_kjo_ej_e]aj_]nj]`]jqi_kn) lk*Jkook_knlkjk]laj]oqi]_keo]j]pqn]h(p]h_kik]boe_](]^ekhkce]a]loe_khkce] kaopq`]i(i]oqi_knlkdqi]jk(eopk(d]^ep]`ka]jei]`klknqi]_kjo_ej_e]*Jk okikolajo]iajpklqnk(lkeookikoqi_knlk*Jkokikoqi]_keo]j]pqn]h(lkeookiko qi]_kjo_ej_e]* K iqj`k jk qi _kjfqjpk `a _keo]o a b]pko aopq`]`ko lah]o _ej_e]o oacqj`k na) h] ao `a _]qo] a abaepk a haeo j]pqn]eo* =hi `k iqj`k _kik _kjfqjpk n]_ekj]h `a b]pko _eajpbe_ko(dkiqj`k_kikhqc]nkj`areraiko_kikokqpnkoank`a]`kolah]o_keo]o( qiiqj`kmq]hep]perk`a_knao(okjo(k`knao(becqn]o(beoekjkie]o(k^op_qhko(qiiqj`k ]baperk`alaook]o(hqc]nao(hai^n]j]o(lnkiaoo]o(aolan]j]o(_kjbhepko(hqp]o* Okikooanaoqbjmlo^fpÍj]o_aikoapaiko_kjo_ej_e]`]iknpa*Okikooanaofkqbo* pr_gbqfslpÍreraikoj]_kil]jde]`kokqpnko*Okikooanao`riqro^fpÍ_ne]iko]hejcq]) cai(kpn]^]hdk(]ok_ea`]`a(]nahecek(]lkhpe_](]pe_](]o]npaoa]op_je_]o(]behkokbe]a ]o_ej_e]o* Kmqa(lkeo(]na]he`]`a;fqop]iajpa]ateopj_e]`kiqj`ki]pane]h(j]pqn]h(e`a]h( _qhpqn]ha]jkoo]ateopj_e]jaha*=na]he`]`ak_]ilkbkni]`klknoanaokqajpao`ebanaj) _e]`koanah]_ekj]`koajpnaoemqalkooqaioajpe`kaioeiaoikoamqap]i^ina_a^ai `aj okqpnkoajkrkooajpe`ko*=na]he`]`akqkOanjkkK^fapk)?keo](oai]_kjo_ej_e]* I]o(p]i^i(jkkOqfaepk)?kjo_ej_e](oai]o_keo]oakokqpnko*=na]he`]`akqkOan k_nqv]iajpka]`ebanaj_e]kajpnakoajorahakejpahecrah(ajpnaki]pane]h)j]pqn]hak e`a]h)_qhpqn]h(ajpnakmq]hep]perkakmq]jpep]perk(ajpnakb]pkakoajpe`k(ajpnaklomqe_ka k_knlkn]h(ap_*Kmqaaopq`]]kjpkhkce];Koajpaokqoanao^kqbpmqaoaf]iejraopec]`kola) h]o_ej_e]oaabmlfpmqaoapknj]n]iajecipe_kol]n]jkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j]*Aikqpn]ol]) h]rn]o6koajpaokqkooanao^kqbp`aoanaipn]jobkni]`koai_kj_aepko`]o_ej_e]oa(_kik reikoj]Ejpnk`qk`aopahernk(abmlfpmqajkoo]atlanej_e]_kpe`e]j]okbnaqkaol]jpk(] ]`ien]kakaopn]jd]iajpk`amqaahaooaf]i_kikjkol]na_aioan(kqjkoaf]ikmqa jkol]na_aioan* =kjpkhkce]aopq`]]oaooj_e]o]jpaomqaoaf]ib]pko`]_ej_e]atlhe_]per]a`alkeo mqaoapknj]n]iaopn]jd]ol]n]j o*@eck(lknatailhk6ÎRafkaop]_]o]raniahd](ln tei] `]]vqhÏ*=kjpkhkce]ej`]c]6ÎKmqaran(mq]h]aooj_e]`]reok;Ï(ÎKmqaqi]_]o]kq mq]h]aooj_e]`]d]^ep]k;Ï(ÎMqaraniahdkkq]vqhkqmq]h]aooj_e]`]_knkqkmqa _kn;Ï(ÎMqaran_knao;Ï* Lancqjpk(lknatailhk6ÎMqadkn]ook;Ï*=kjpkhkce]ej`]c]6ÎKmqakpailk;Ï(ÎMq]h ]aooj_e]`]pailkn]he`]`a;Ï* La`nkb]h]6Î=_e`]`afaoplanpkÏ*=kjpkhkce]ej`]c]6ÎKmqakaol]k;Ï(ÎMq]h] aooj_e]`]aol]_e]he`]`a;Ï(ÎMqalanpkahkjca;Ï(ÎMqa]`eop j_e];Ï*
.14
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
=jpjek`ev]L]qhk6Î=mqah]o`q]onrknaooke`jpe_]o(i]o]pan_aen]`ebanajpaÏ*= kjpkhkce]ej`]c]6ÎKmqae`ajpe`]`a;Ï(ÎA]`ebanaj];Ï(ÎKmqaÐ`q]oÑaÐpan_aen]Ñ(kqoaf](k mqakjiank;Ï* =j]ia`ev6ÎKqreqi]ioe_]^ahooei](jkaoo]_keo]bae]mqark_aopao_qp]j`kÏ*= kjpkhkce]ej`]c]6ÎKmqa]^ahav]a]baeqn];Ï(ÎAteopaik^ahkaioeakbaekaioe(kq^ahav] kqbaeqn]ok]r]he] aoar]hknaomqa]pne^qikoo_keo]o;Ï(ÎKmqaqir]hkn;Ï* ?a_he]_kjp]]Fk]j]6ÎLa`nkna]hevkqqi]pkcajankoklnkpacaj`k]_ne]j](i]oAqc) je]bkeackop]]kjk]fq`)hkÏ*=kjpkhkce]ej`]c]6ÎKmqa]cajankoe`]`akqkackoik;Ï( ÎAteopaiaioealknoeiaoikokqok]r]he] aomqab]vaiko`]o] aodqi]j]o;Ï(ÎKmqa qir]hkn;Ï* ?kikoak^oanr](]kjpkhkce]ejraopec]]aooj_e]kqkoajpe`k`kajpaboe_kkqj]pq) n]h(`kajpalomqe_k(h ce_k(i]paipe_k(aoppe_k(pe_k(pailkn]h(aol]_e]h(ap_*Ejraopec]]o `ebanaj]oa]onah] aoajpnaahao(oaqik`kln lnek`aateopen(oq]knecai(oq]bej]he`]`a* Kmqakiqj`k;Kmqakaqkq]_kjo_ej_e];Kmqak_knlk;Kmqakkqpnk;Kmqa kaol]k)pailk;Kmqa]hejcq]cai;Kmqakpn]^]hdk(]nahecek(]]npa(]ok_ea`]`a(] deop ne](]iknpa(kejbejepk;Aeo]omqaop ao`]kjpkhkce]* Na_qlan])oa(]ooei(]rahd]mqaopkbehko be_]6ÎKmqaeopkmqa;Ï(i]o]_nao_e`]`a jkr]mqaopk6ÎL]n]mqaieopkmqa;Ï*Rkhp])oa(lkeo(]^qo_]nkOankq]aooj_e]`]o_keo]o( `ko]pko(`kor]hknaodqi]jko(`]re`]a`]iknpa(`kejbejepka`kbejepk*=lancqjp]ÎKmqa eopkmqa;Ïnabana)oa]kik`k`aoan`koajpaoj]pqn]eo(]npebe_e]eo(e`a]eoadqi]jko7]lan) cqjp]ÎL]n]mqaieopkmqa;Ïnabana)oa]koajpe`kkqoecjebe_]k`aooaoajpao* Pkiaikoqiatailhkl]n]jko]fq`]n]_kilnaaj`ankik`k`alajo]n`]kjpkhkce]* =_kil]jdaiko(^naraiajpa(kaopq`k`aIanha]q)Lkjpuok^na]aooj_e]kqkoan`kjkook _knlka(]oacqen(koana]aooj_e]`kpailk*
Kjkook_knlk
K
mqakjkook_knlk;Mq]h]oq]aooj_e]; =boe_]`enmqaqi]cnac]`k`apkiko(qi]_anp]i]oo]aajance]mqabqj_ekj]`a ]_kn`k_ki]ohaeocan]eo`]j]pqnav]*=mqie_]`enmqabaepk`aikh_qh]o`acq](kte) cjek(_]n^kjk(`aajvei]oalnkpaj]o(bqj_ekj]j`k_kikmq]hmqankqpnk_knlkmqie_k* =^ekhkce]`enmqaqiknc]jeoikrerk(qiej`er`qkiai^nk`aqi]aol_ea$]jei]h( i]ibank(ranpa^n]`k(^la`a%(_]l]v`a]`]lp]n)oa]kiaek]i^eajpalknklan] aoabqj) aoejpanj]o(`kp]`k`aqi_ `eckcajpe_kdana`epnek(mqaoanalnk`qvoatq]hiajpa*= loe_khkce]`enmqaqibaeta`a_]nja(io_qhko(kooko(mqabkni]i]l]nahdkona_alpknao `aaopiqhkoatpanjkoaejpanjkoa]l]nahdkoaieooknao`anaolkop]oejpanj]oaatpanj]o] p]eoaopiqhko(_]l]v`apan_kilknp]iajpkok^oanrraeo* Pk`]oaoo]onaolkop]o`evaimqajkook_knlkqi]_keo]ajpna]o_keo]o(qi]imqej] na_alper]a]per]mqalk`aoanatlhe_]`]lknnah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepk(oq]oklan] aook k^oanrraeo`enap]kqej`enap]iajpaÍlk`aj`koanat]iej]`kaioaqoijeiko`ap]hdao jkoh]^kn]p neko(_h]ooebe_]`ka_kjda_e`k*Jkook_knlk(_kikmq]hmqan_keo](qik^fapk `a_kjda_eiajpk* Lkni(oaneookk_knlkmqaklppl; Iaq_knlkqioanreorahjkiaek`kokqpnkooanaoreoraeo(i]omqapai]la_qhe]ne) `]`a`aoanqireorahre`ajpa6rafk(]hi`aoanreop]*Jko eook*Lkookiaran(okqreorah l]n]ieiiaoi]*Alkookiaranraj`k* Iaq_knlkqioanp_peh_kikkokqpnko_knlko(lk`aj`koanpk_]`k*I]op]i^i paiklk`an`apk_]n(pk_]jpa7a_]l]v`apk_]n)oa(_kikmq]j`kiejd]ik`enaep]pk_] ]aomqan`]afjko]^aikomqaipk_]amqaipk_]`k*
.15
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
Iaq_knlkokjknk_kikkqpnko_knlko(_kikko_neop]eoakoiap]eo7lk`aoankqre`k* I]o pai k lk`an `a kqren* I]eo `k mqa eook( lk`a b]van)oa kqren a lk`a kqren)oa mq]j`k aiepaokjo*@kbqj`k`]c]nc]jp](l]oo]j`klah]hjcq]alahko`ajpao(_kikoikreiajpko `aiaqoh^ekopn]jobknik]okjkne`]`aaioajpe`k(`evaj`kl]h]rn]o*Kqk)iab]h]j`ka kqkmqaiiab]h]*Okqokjkn]l]n]ieiiaoi]* Iaq_knlkaopaj`a]ikapk_]kqpn]ikaikqpnk_knlk(rqikhd]n(lan_a^aqi] beoekjkie](ao_qp]qi]kqpn]rkv6oaemqa`e]jpa`aieiaopqi_knlkmqaiaqkqpnk( qikqpnkdqi]jkd]^ep]`klkn_kjo_ej_e]aaqkoaelknmqaiab]h]a(_kikaq(oaq_knlk lnk`qvl]h]rn]o(oajpe`ko* Reorah)re`ajpa(p_peh)pk_]jpa(okjknk)kqrejpa+b]h]jpa(iaq_knlkoarraj`k(oapk_] pk_]j`k(oaao_qp]ao_qp]j`kab]h]j`k*Iaq_knlkjk_keo](jkimqej](jkbaeta `akooko(io_qhkoao]jcqa(jkqi]na`a`a_]qo]oaabaepko(jkqina_alp_qhkl]n] qi]]hi]kql]n]qi]_kjo_ej_e]6iaqik`kbqj`]iajp]h`aoana`aaop]njkiqj`k( `aianah]_ekj]n_kiahaa`aahaoanah]_ekj]n_kieck*Iaq_knlkqioajorahmqaoajpaa oaoajpa(mqaoao]^aoajpenaoaoajpej`k*qi]ejpanekne`]`aatpaneknev]`]aqi]atpanekne) `]`aejpaneknev]`]*aooakoankq]aooj_e]`kiaq_knlk*Iaq_knlkpai(_kikpk`koko ajpao(qi]`eiajokiap]boe_]kqkjpkh ce_]*
Kmqakpailk;
A
op]iko]_kopqi]`ko]_kjoe`an]nkpailk_kikqi]hejd]nap](baep]`]oq_aook`a ejop]jpao(kq_kikqi]oq_aook`aÎ]ckn]oÏÍqiÎ]ckn]Ïmqafbkekl]oo]`k(k Î]ckn]Ïmqaaopoaj`kklnaoajpa(qiÎ]ckn]Ïmqarenkbqpqnk* =iap]boe_]na]heop]qo](bnamqajpaiajpa(]ei]cai`knekl]n]nalnaoajp]nkpailk _kik]hckmqal]oo]oai_aoo]n6]j]o_ajpakl]oo]`k(khqc]nkj`aiaaj_kjpnkklna) oajpa(]bkvkbqpqnk*D`keoajc]jkojaoo]ei]cai*Ailneiaenkhqc]n(pn]p])oa`aqi] ei]caibpm^`f^il]n]nabanen)oa]kmqaqbjmlo^i(eopk(lnapaj`aatlhe_]n]aooj_e]`k pailk $k ao_k]iajpk% qo]j`k ] aooj_e] `k aol]k $] oq_aook `a lkjpko%* Ai oacqj`k hqc]n(]ei]cai`knekjk_knnaolkj`a]kao_k]iajpk`kpailk*L]n]mqa_knnaolkj`aooa( lna_eo]ne]aop]nejranpe`](lkeo]cq]mqaaopj]j]o_ajpa]mqah]mqa]ej`]jkl]ookq lahkhqc]nkj`aaopkqa(lknp]jpk(ah](l]n]iei(kbqpqnkajkkl]oo]`k7]cq]mqaaop j]bkv]mqah]mqafl]ookqlahkhqc]nkj`aaopkqa(lknp]jpk(l]n]iei(kl]oo]`kajk kbqpqnk* Pajp]j`k arep]n ko ajc]jko `k na]heoik( ] iap]boe_] e`a]heop] `en mqa k pailk ] bkni]`koajpe`kejpanjk(eopk(qi]bkni]_ne]`]lahkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkkqlah] _kjo_ej_e]nabhater]l]n]knc]jev]n]atlanej_e]oq^faper]`]oq_aook*Kpailkjkateo) pa(i]oqi]e`a]he`]`alnk`qve`]lah]n]vk(qi_kj_aepkoq^faperkl]n]aopnqpqn]nkmqa atlaneiajp]`k_kikoq_aooerk* Qijkrkajc]jk]_]^]`aoan_kiape`k*Oakpailkbknqi]bkni]kqqi_kj_aepk lnk`qve`klah]_kjo_ej_e]nabhater]kqlahkoqfaepkl]n]knc]jev]n]oq_aook(jkd]ran oq_aook]knc]jev]n(lkeo]_kjo_ej_e]nabhater]kqkoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkklan]oailna aat_hqoer]iajpa_kikmqa]pq]h(_kikmqaaop`]`klnaoajpaiajpa]klajo]iajpk* L]n]]nabhatko ateopa]oeiqhp]jae`]`a(a]oq_aookoana`qv]qi]atlanej_e]loe_k) h ce_]kqailne_](]koajpeiajpk`amqadqiÎ]jpaoÏaqiÎ`alkeoÏamqap]eol]h]rn]o ej`e_]ikik`k_kikjkonabaneiko]hai^n]j]oaatla_p]per]olaook]eo* Ej`]cqaiko(lkni(kmqareraj_e]nkln lnekpailk*Mq]j`kreraj_ekkiaqlna) oajpa(ahaoa]lnaoajp]_kikqi]oepq]kj]mq]hoejpk(b]k(`eck(lajok_keo]o(]pqk`a rne]oi]jaen]oapajdkatlanej_e]`aqi]oepq]k]^anp](eopk(j]mq]hiqep]o_keo]o oklkooraeol]n]ieiaaimqaiqep]o_keo]olk`ai]_kjpa_an*Mq]j`knaiaiknkiaq l]oo]`k(lan_a^kmqaajpnaahaakiaqlnaoajpadqi]`ebanaj]6mq]j`kahaan]kiaq
.2,
!LFREDß%ISENSTAEDT4IMEß,IFEß0ICTURES'ETTYß)MAGES
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailkn ja]x#!0É45,/ßx
.2-
lnaoajpa(p]i^iaop]r]]^anpk]iqep]olkooe^ehe`]`ao(i]ookiajpa]hcqi]ooana]hev]) n]i*Lkneook(kl]oo]`khai^n]`kjkqi]oepq]k]^anp]_kikklnaoajpa(i]oba_d]`]( paniej]`]*=ooei(iaql]oo]`kjkoeilhaoiajpakmqaraek]jpao`kiaqlnaoajpa(i]o ]hckmq]hep]per]iajpa`ebanajpa`klnaoajpa6aopa]^anpk7]mqaha(ba_d]`k* Mq]j`kei]cejkiaqbqpqnk(]jparafk(^]oa]`]j]olkooe^ehe`]`ao]^anp]oaiiaqlna) oajpa(_kikoane]oa_anp]olkooe^ehe`]`aooa_kj_napev]ooaiaoakqpn]ojkoana]hev]ooai* Iaqbqpqnkjkoeilhaoiajpakmqarai`alkeo`kiaqlnaoajpa(i]o]hckmq]hep]per]iaj) pa`ebanajpa`klnaoajpa6kmqalk`anoanoa]o]^anpqn]o`kiaqlnaoajpaoa_kj_napev]nai a(lknp]jpk(oakmqa(dkfa(aop]^anpkkqaioqolajok(aoperan(]i]jd(ba_d]`kana]hev]`k* Iaql]oo]`kaiaqbqpqnkjqj_]okkoiaoiko*?]`]ravmqaiahai^nk`kiaql]o) o]`k(aqkb]k_ki^]oajkiaqlnaoajpaa(]_]`]rav(aopa`ebanajpa(b]vaj`k)iana_kn`]n `ai]jaen]o`erano]okmqal]ookq*?]`]ravmqaei]cejkiaqbqpqnk(aqkb]k_ki^]oajk iaqlnaoajpa(mqa(oaj`koailna`ebanajpa(ei]cej]`ebanajpaiajpakbqpqnk*Jknarerkk l]oo]`k(i]oknaiaiknkp]h_kikokqdkfaaiiaqlnaoajpa*Jkrerkiaqbqpqnk(i]o kei]cejkp]h_kikokqdkfaaiiaqlnaoajpa*Klnaoajpaqi]_kjpn]kpailkn]hmqa ]nn]j_]kl]oo]`k`kaomqa_eiajpka]^nakbqpqnkl]n]klkoorah*Kl]oo]`kakbqpqnkok `eh]p] aopailkn]eo(`eopajo ao`klnaoajpa* Mqahai^n]n;_]lp]njk_kjpjqkpailkn]hqi]`ebanaj]ob^iajpnakmqaaopkqre) raj`kjklnaoajpaakmqaaopkqreraj_e]j`k`kl]oo]`k*Mqaaomqa_an;lan`an]beoekjk) ie]kqknahark`aqiikiajpk`kl]oo]`k*Mqaaolan]n;^qo_]njk_kjpjqkpailkn]h qi]`ebanaj]mlppsbiajpnakmqaaopkqreraj`kakmqaaopkqreraj_e]j`k`kbqpqnk* Kmqakpailk; Ailneiaenkhqc]n(qiao) _k]iajpkejpanjkaatpanjk(qi bhqen_kjpjqk(mqar]elnk`qvej) `k`ebanaj]o`ajpnk`aoeiaoik* Aioacqj`k(qi]_kjpn]ka qi]`eh]p]k`aoeiaoik(qi fqjp]n)oa ] oe iaoik a _kjoeck iaoik$j]hai^n]j]%aqiat) l]j`en)oa ] oe iaoik a _kjoeck iaoik$j]aolan]j]%*Kpailk ]lnk`qk`]e`ajpe`]`aa`] `ebanaj]_kjoeckiaoika(jao) oa oajpe`k( qi] `eiajok `k iaq oan $jk aopkq kl pailk( i]oplrpailkn]h%aqi]`eiaj) ok`apk`kokoajpao$jkaopk klpailk(i]oplpailkn]eo%* Kpailkjkqina_alp) _qhk `a ejop]jpao( jk qi] he) jd]`aikiajpkooq_aooerko(jk ] `eop j_e] ajpna qi Î]ckn]Ï( qiÎ]jpaoÏaqiÎ`alkeoÏ(i]o kikreiajpkejpanjk`koajpao l]n] naqjenai)oa _kjoeck iao) iko $k lnaoajpa _kik _ajpnk mqa^qo_]kl]oo]`kakbqpqnk%a J]Lajjouhr]je]Op]pekj(aiJkr]Ukng( l]n]oa`ebanaj_e]nai`aoeiao) kcn]j`anah cek`]aop]koa`aop]_] iko$klnaoajpa_kik`ebanaj] ok^na]iqhpe`k(aibkpk`a=hbna` mq]hep]per]aib]_a`kl]oo]`ka Aeoajop]a`p(`a-50/* `kbqpqnk%*KOanpailk*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
#APqTULOß =behkokbe]lo)iap]boe_]
=oiknpao`]iap]boe_]
!NNAß7EISE!LBUMß AKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
J
*~RGENß(ABERMASß ß FILvSOFOßEßSOCIvLOGOßß ALEMjO
-ARTINEß&RANCK-AGNUMß0HOTOS,ATINSTOCK
]deop ne]`]behkokbe](lanek`e_]iajpa`a_h]n]`]]iknpa`]iap]boe_]* Bke]ooei(jko_qhkTREEE(_ki]ok^n]o`aDqiaaG]jp$]ej`]mqaaopapajd]_kjoe`a) n]`kmqa]iap]boe_](`aolkf]`]`aoq]lnapajok`a_ej_e](lk`ane]ok^nareran_kikoeopa) i]`kolnej_lekomqa]n]vkailnac]j]_kjopepqek`]o_ej_e]oajkiqj`kikn]h%* Bke]ooeip]i^ijkbej]h`ko_qhkTETaej_ek`ko_qhkTT(mq]j`koa_kjopepqn]i aoa_kjokhe`]n]i]o_ej_e]ol]npe_qh]naoÍat]p]o(j]pqn]eoadqi]j]oÍ(_]`]mq]h_ki oaqok^fapkoaipk`koln lneko(`abejeper]iajpaoal]n]`]o`]behkokbe]*=_kjbe]j]j]_]) l]_e`]`a`]o_ej_e]ol]n]_kjda_an_kilhap]iajpa]na]he`]`apk`]akpk`k`]na]he`]`a harkq]qi]]pepq`a`ajkiej]`]_eajpebe_eoik(l]n]]mq]h]_ej_e]rejd]oq^opepqenejpae) n]iajpa]behkokbe]j]p]nab]`k_kjda_eiajpk(hemqe`]j`k`aqi]ravlknpk`]o]oehqo ao behko be_]o_kjpe`]oj]iap]boe_]* Oa(j]lanola_per]`aDqiaaG]jp(]iap]boe_]_kik_ej_e]an]eilkoorahlknmqa] n]vkdqi]j]jkpai_kik]h_]j]nk_kjda_eiajpk`]na]he`]`aaioe(j]lanola_per]`k _eajpebe_eoik]iap]boe_]`ao]l]na_aoeilhaoiajpalknmqajkpaik^fapk(jkpaikmqa _kjda_an*Jklneiaenk_]ok(d]re]qiheieparej`k`]ln lne]n]vk7jkoacqj`k(dkqra] oq^opepqek`]behkokbe]lah]o_ej_e]o* =pq]hiajpa(lnk_h]i])oa(]ej`]qi]rav(]iknpa`]iap]boe_]* Jqi hernk lq^he_]`k ai -54-( _ki k ppqhk `a Mbkp^jbkql mp*jbq^cpf`l( k beh okbk ]haikFncajD]^ani]oat]iej]kmqa]mqeaop]iko_d]i]j`k`aiknpa`]iap]boe_]( b]h]j`kail]oo]cai`kl]n]`eci]`]kjpkhkce]l]n]k`]cfilplcf^a^`lkp`fk`f^a`aopa l]n]kl]n]`eci]`]cfilplcf^a^ifkdr^dbj*Aoo]o`q]ol]oo]cajojko_kj`qvai]klajo]) iajpkl o)iap]boe_k* Lknm^o^afdj^a^lkqlildf^(D]^ani]oajpaj`a]iap]boe_]cnac]a]_hooe_](eopk( ]oiap]boe_]ona]heop]o*Lknm^o^afdj^a^cfilplcf^a^`lkp`fk`f^(D]^ani]oajpaj`ap]jpk ]_npe_]g]jpe]j]_kik]bajkiajkhkce]dqooanhe]j](eopk(]obehkokbe]omqa`an]ilnek) ne`]`a]koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkkq_kjo_ej_e]`aoenabhater]a`]omq]eolnkrean]i iap]boe_]oe`a]heop]o*Lknm^o^afdj^a^cfilplcf^a^ifkdr^dbjD]^ani]oajpaj`a]lnek) ne`]`a_kjbane`]oaopnqpqn]ocn]i]pe_]eoah ce_]o`]hejcq]caikq`]ohejcq]cajo_kik i]jaen]o`aknc]jev]n]na]he`]`aa`]n)hdaoajpe`k(`alaniepen]]r]he]k`ko_kjda_eiaj) pko_eajpbe_koa`a]ooacqn]n]lnpe_]_kiqje_]per]ajpnakooanaodqi]jko*Aopahpeik l]n]`eci]_knnaolkj`alk_]`]mp*jbq^cpf`^* Lk`aikojko]_an_]n`kÎl]n]`eci]`]hejcq]caiÏkq`]Îlk_]l o)iap]boe_]Ïlkn rneko_]iejdkokqat]iej]j`k]olkoe ao`a`ebanajpaobeh okbko_kjpailkn jako*Ao_k) hdaiko]laj]o`keoatailhko(qi`ahaorej`k`]hejcqope_]akkqpnk(`]k^n]`kbeh okbk bn]j_oIe_dahBkq_]qhp*Aooaoatailhkojkaockp]ik]ooqjpk(i]okbana_aikolnej_el]eo pn]ko`klajo]iajpk_kjpailkn jakjkmqanaolaep]iap]boe_]*
-ICHELß&OUCAULTßß ¯
.2.
=behkokbe]l o)iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
=na]he`]`alqn]iajpa`eo_qnoer]`k oqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk
K
.2/
mqa ] behkokbe] `] _kjo_ej_e]; = behkokbe] mqa _kjbana lnekne`]`a ]k oqfaepk `k _kjda_eiajpkkq_kjo_ej_e]`aoenabhater]* Reikomqakoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkb]voq]lneiaen]]l]nekj]iap]boe_]_hooe_] _ki@ao_]npao(qi]ravmqa]_kjo_ej_e]`aoenabhater](lkjpk`al]npe`]`k_kjda_eiaj) pk(_kj_a^e`]_kikpr_pq k`f^mbkp^kqba(j]_kj`ek`aoq^op j_e](oq]na]he`]`aia) p]boe_]*]]hi]* Reikop]i^imqa]_npe_]g]jpe]j]jko `a_h]n]]eilkooe^ehe`]`a`ajkoo]n]vk _kjda_anoq^op j_e]oaioe(_kikp]i^i_kj_a^akoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkjk_kik oq^op j_e]lajo]jpakq]hi]aoei_kik^qfsfa^ababobmobpbkq^ l(eopk(_kikoqfaepk pn]jo_aj`ajp]ha_kikoqfaepkikn]h*Koqfaepkklk`anl]n]naqjenjqi]ojpaoa^moflof ko`]`ko`]atlanej_e]knc]jev]`kolah]obkni]o^moflof`]oajoe^ehe`]`aalahko_kj_aepko ^moflof`kajpaj`eiajpk(lnk`qvej`knalnaoajp] aook^nakobajiajko* Reikop]i^imqa]`aooq^op]j_e]hev]k`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpklnkooacqaj] bajkiajkhkce] `a Dqooanh( l]n] mqai ] _kjo_ej_e] jk qi] oq^op j_e] lajo]jpa kq ]hi]aoeiqi^qlfkqbk`flk^ikqÎ_kjo_ej_e]`aÏ(qi]lqn]]pere`]`a`areo]n]o_keo]o _kikoecjebe_] ao_kjopepq`]olknah]iaoi]ajmq]jpk_kjo_ej_e]pn]jo_aj`ajp]h* Ai^kn]jaooalan_qnokdeop ne_k)behko be_k]_kjo_ej_e]`aoenabhater]pajd]`aet]`k `aoanqi]oq^op j_e]l]n]oan_kjoe`an]`]qi]]pere`]`akq]pk(qi]ola_pkbke_kjoanr]) `k`ao`a@ao_]npao]pDqooanh(mq]hoaf](koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpkqi]na]he`]`aoal]) n]`]a`eopejp]`]na]he`]`a`kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]_kjo_ej_e] qiik`k`aateopenkqqiik`k`aoankjpkhkce_]iajpa`ebanajpa`]o_keo]oa(`klkjpk`a reop]`ko]^an(ah]]jpanekno_keo]o(lkeoah]mqa_kj_a^a]oe`ae]o`]o_keo]o$@ao_]npao%( mqanalnaoajp]]o_keo]o$G]jp%(mqa_kjopepqe]o_keo]o_kikoecjebe_] ao$Dqooanh%* =ooei(]obehkokbe]o`]_kjo_ej_e]_kjoanr]iqilnaooqlkopkmqa(jkbej]h`]o_kj) p]o(iap]boe_k(qi]ravmqa]lnekne`]`akqklnerehcek`koqfaepkjk`]`klahkob]pko`] atlanej_e]$jaop](]o_keo]ook]jpaneknao]j oajko]bap]ij]oajo]kaj]lan_alk%a oeilahk_kjda_eiajpklqn]iajpaejpahecrah`amqa(l]n]d]ran_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenk( ja_aoonekmqa]mqahamqa_kjda_aoaf]]_kj`ek`]mqehkmqa_kjda_e`k*Mqan_kik oq^op j_e](mqan_kik]pere`]`a^moflofkq]pere`]`alqn](lprgbfqlbufpqbbbufpqb`ljrj jlalabpboafpqfkqla^pabj^fp`lfp^p* Hejcqeope_]iajpa(koqfaepk]lneiaen]laook]`kran^k(]mqah]mqa`ev6brlajok* Kn](koaopq`ko`kolnkjkiaolaook]eolah]hejcqope_]aopnqpqn]h_dac]n]i]_kj_hq) o aoiknp]eol]n]]e`ae](khqc]na]bqjk`koqfaepkajpaj`e`k_kikqi]ateopj_e]`a) paniej]`]kqqiik`k`aoan`apaniej]`k* Mq]j`kb]h]iko(ailnac]ikokolnkjkiao_d]i]`kolaook]eo(ÎaqÏaÎpqÏ*Aooaai) lnack(ikopn]]hejcqope_](jkoanabana]oq^op j_e]o(aooj_e]okqajpe`]`aoateopajpao*= mqana]he`]`aÎaqÏaÎpqÏoanalknp]i;=qi]na]he`]`alqn]iajpahejcqope_](lqn]iajpa `eo_qnoer](lkeoaooaolnkjkiaookil`r bpajkpbobp* KmqaamqaikÎaqÏ;(oeiqhp]ja]iajpa(kmqalnkbanak`eo_qnoka]mqehk]mqai k`eo_qnokoanabanaÍÎaq]j`kÏ(Îaqia_knpaeÏ(Îaq]_dkmqaÏ(ÎaqlajokÏ(ÎaqmqankÏjko ejbkni]i`amqadqi]qpkn`]b]h]amqaaooa]qpknb]h]`aoeiaoik*Kqoaf](kÎaqÏk nabanajpaaknabane`k`k`eo_qnok*khk_qpkn* Lkneookiaoik(kÎpqÏ]hk_qp nek(kqoaf](]mqaha]mqaikÎaqÏb]h]amqajkb]h]( lkeo(oab]h]n(pknj])oaqiÎaqÏ*KÎpqÏkejpanhk_qpkn*Kn](oakÎaqÏlk`apknj]n)oaÎpqÏmq]j) `k]hcqihdab]h]aoakÎpqÏlk`apknj]n)oaÎaqÏmq]j`kb]h](eookoecjebe_]mqa]Îlneiaen] laook]Ïa]Îoacqj`]laook]Ï`koran^kojkoklaook]ojkoajpe`kboe_kaiap]boe_k(eopk (oanao(aoeiird^obpkqmlpf bpjqi`eo_qnok*ÎAqÏaÎpqÏokoecjkor]veko(`eolkjraeoa i raeomqaoalnaaj_daiaoaikreiajp]imq]j`kdqihk_qpknmqaoal a_kikÎaqÏa
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
!NGELI!CERVOßDOßARTISTA
qiejpanhk_qpknlkopk_kikÎpqÏ*=iahdknlnkr]`amqajkoklaook]oaioajpe`kboe_k aiap]boe_kaopjkmqa_d]i]iko`aÎpan_aen]laook]Ï*@ab]pk(aoo]pan_aen]laook]lk`a oanqidqi]jk(qi]jei]h(qi`aqokqqi]_keo](lknp]jpk(jkÎlaook]Ï7]hi`eook(] cn]ipe_]]`abeja_kik^nrfil`amqaoab]h]ajk_kik^nrbi^$laook]%`amqaioab]h]*A j]pan_aen]Îlaook]Ïmqa_kjfqc]ikokoran^ko`ajkiej]`koeilaook]eo*
Pen]`k_]npqjeop]=jcahel]n]]Bkhd]`aO*L]qhk*
J]odeop ne]oai mq]`nejdko(ko^]h ao `ab]h]ej`e_]i mqaikhk_qpkn*
KlnkjkiaÎaqÏknc]jev]pk`]]hejcq]caiapk`kokooecjkohejcqope_ko*lkn_]qo] `ahamqakpailkran^]hbqj`]iajp]hklnaoajpa$]_kej_e`j_e]ajpnakajqj_e]jpa`k`eo) _qnok(kajqj_e]`k`k`eo_qnokakmqaajqj_e]`klahk`eo_qnok%(`ai]jaen]mqal]oo]`ka bqpqnkoa`abejai_kikpailkojklnaoajpao*lknnabanj_e]]ahamqaoa`eopejcqaiaoa knc]jev]i(lknatailhk(ko`aikjopn]perko6aopa+aooa+]mqaha$_kjbknia]lnkteie`]`akq ]`eop j_e]`khk_qpkn%(]mqe+]he$p]i^i_kjbknia]lnkteie`]`akq`eop j_e]`khk_qpkn%( ap_*oq]lnaoaj]kq]qoj_e]mqa`apaniej]koajpe`k`koran^komqaej`e_]iklan] ao iajp]eo6ÎaqlajokÏ`ebanajpa`aÎaqoqlkjdkÏ(lkeoklneiaenkqi]klan]k`kÎaqÏ ajmq]jpkkoacqj`kqi]]pepq`a`kÎaqÏaib]_a`a]hck`ebanajpa`aha7ÎaqlajokÏ`eba) najpa`aÎpqlajo]oÏ(lkeoo lkook`evanÎpqlajo]oÏoaiaperanao`epkÎaqlajokÏ(ap_* Aooaoaopq`ko_dac]i_kj_hqok`amqakoqfaepkkq]oq^fapere`]`apaiqibqj`]) iajpklqn]iajpahejcqope_kajkboe_kjaiiap]boe_k*Mq]eoko_nepnekol]n]_kj_a^)hk _kikqi]ateopj_e]lqn]iajpahejcqope_]; aijajdqi]hjcq](`amq]hmqanlk_]anacek(`aet]`ad]ranlnkjkiaolaook]eo7 ]k_kjpnnek`ko`ai]eooecjko`]hejcq]cai(kolnkjkiaolaook]eojkoanabanai] qi]aooj_e]ej`ere`q]h(]qiajpaej`ere`q]h(]qi]_keo]oajorahkq]qi]_keo]ejpa) hecrah(i]onabanai)oa]qi]na]he`]`alqn]iajpa`eo_qnoer](]lnkr]`eookaop]j`kj] pn]jobkni]k`kÎaqÏaiÎpqÏa`kÎpqÏaiÎaqÏoeilhaoiajpalknk_ql]naikn]]lkoe) k`ahk_qpkn(kn]]`aejpanhk_qpkn(pn]jobkni]kmqaoane]]^okhqp]iajpaeilkoorah oakÎaqÏbkooaqi]oq^op j_e]$lkeooapknj]ne]kqpn]oq^op j_e]]koanÎpqÏ%kqoabkooa qi]]pere`]`aateopajpaaioeiaoi]$lkeooapknj]ne]l]ooere`]`a]koankÎpqÏ%7 klnkjkialaook]hÎaqÏknc]jev]pk`kokokqpnkolnkjkiao(^ai_kikko]`faperko(ko ]`rn^ekoako`aikjopn]perko(knc]jev]j`k)korkhp]`khk_qpkn7 klnkjkialaook]hÎaqÏknc]jev]]pailkn]he`]`alknnabanj_e]]klnaoajpa(mqak pailkaimqakÎaqÏb]h]7 klnkjkialaook]hÎaqÏik`ebe_]koajpe`k`koran^ko_ki^]oajkoran^komqaej`e) _]i`eolkoe aoaklan] aoiajp]eo`khk_qpkn*Lknatailhk(Îaq_naekmqar]e_dkranÏ _kjranpa jqi] ajqj_e]k oq^faper] ]hck mqa ai oe iaoik k^faperk a atpanekn ]k oqfaepkÎr]e_dkranÏ* Aooao]ola_pkoatlhe_]ilknmq(]bej]h(]behkokbe]]_]^kq]_na`ep]j`kmqakoqfaepkan] qi]na]he`]`a`apaniej]`]$oaf]_kikoq^op j_e]lajo]jpa(oaf]_kik]pere`]`alajo]jpa%
.20
=behkokbe]l o)iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
amqapejd]lnekne`]`aalnerehcekok^na]o_keo]o(`aha`alaj`aj`k]ateopj_e]`kaol]k( `kpailk(`]o_]packne]o(`]ooecjebe_] ao*=iap]boe_]oeilhaoiajpapn]jobknikqjqi oankqjqiik`k`aoan]mqehkmqajkoajkqiik`k`ab]h]n*
=na]he`]`alqn]iajpa`eo_qnoer]`ko]^an
O
6EJAM SEßASßIDEIASßDEßß ORDEMßEßMmTODOßNAßß 5NIDADEß ßNOßESTUDOßß SOBREß$ESCARTES
.21
akoqfaepkqihqc]naqi]lkoekr]ve](`eolkjrahai rahjqi`eo_qnok(kiaoik lk`anoan`epk`kk^fapk`k`eo_qnokkq`]mqehkmqa]pn]`ekiap]boe_]akjpkh ce_] _d]i]r]`ana]he`]`aatpanj](j]pqnav](iqj`k(ok_ea`]`a* @q]ok^n]o`kbeh okbkbn]j_oIe_dahBkq_]qhpjko]fq`]i]_kilnaaj`anaoo]]beni]k* Jqi]k^n]oecjebe_]per]iajpaejpepqh]`]>pm^i^so^pb^p`lfp^p(Bkq_]qhpatlhe_]_kik alknmqa]behkokbe]a]o_ej_e]o(ajpnakoo_qhkoTRaTET(_kj_a^an]i]na]he`]`a`ai]) jaen]oiqepk`ebanajpao*L]n]aoo]atlhe_]k(ejpnk`qvk_kj_aepk`abmfpqbjb$l]h]rn]cnac] mqaoecjebe_]r]Î_ej_e]Ï%(ajpaj`e`]_kikqi]aopnqpqn]`a_kjda_eiajpko`apaniej]`] lknqi]na`a`a_kj_aepkomqaokkoejopnqiajpko_kikomq]eo(jqi]`]`]lk_](kolaj) o]`knaoejraopec]iaejpanlnap]i]na]he`]`a*Qi]bmfpqbjbqi_kjfqjpk`aajqj_e]`ko kq`a`eo_qnoko^]oa]`kojqi_anpkejopnqiajpk_kj_aepq]hmqaknc]jev]]hejcq]caiak lajo]iajpkahdao`koajpeiajpk`amqa]ol]h]rn]o_knnaolkj`aio_keo]o* J]bmfpqbjb`]Naj]o_aj](`evBkq_]qhp(k_kj_aepkmqaknc]jev]ko`eo_qnokok`apb* jbie^k ^*Kqoaf](konaj]o_ajpeop]o_kj_a^ai]na]he`]`a_kikqipa_e`kaqi]pn]i]ai mqa]o_keo]ooa]npe_qh]ilknlkooqnai]ola_pkooa_napkoaejreoraeomqa]o]lnktei]i lknmqa ok oaiahd]jpao kq ]o `eop]j_e]i lknmqa ok `ebanajpao* = oaiahd]j] knc]jev] ]na]he`]`alknnah] ao`aoeil]pe]a]jpel]pe]ajpna]o_keo]oa(lkneook(j]Naj]o_aj]( `aoajrkhrai)oa_kiejpajoe`]`a]]hmqeie]$]oeil]pe]a]jpel]pe]ajpna_anp]o_keo]omqa lk`aioanpn]jobkni]`]oaikqpn]o%(]]opnkhkce]$]oeil]pe]a]jpel]pe]j]nah]k`ko]o) pnko_kikooanaodqi]jko%a]i]ce]j]pqn]h$kq_ej_e]`koh]kooa_napkoajpnakooanao( laniepej`k]cenok^naahaolahk_kjda_eiajpk`aooaoh]ko%* Mq]j`koal]oo]l]n]kaopq`k`kn]_ekj]heoikik`anjk`ko_qhkTREE(jkoaranebe_] qi]_kjpejq]kiahdkn]`]`aoo]bmfpqbjbaoeikoqnceiajpk`aqi]kqpn]_kilhap]) iajpa`ebanajpa*Lknmq;Lknmqak_kj_aepkknc]jev]`kn`]hejcq]caia`klajo]iajpk `aet]`aoan]oaiahd]j]aoapknj]]obmobpbkq^ l*Nalnaoajp]n]]pere`]`a`koqfaepk `k_kjda_eiajpkmqaoana_kjda_a_kikqi]na]he`]`a`eopejp]`]o_keo]o]oanai_kjda) _e`]o*Nalnaoajp]njk^qo_]nkoh]kooa_napko`aoeil]pe]a]jpel]pe]ajpna]o_keo]oa oei]oe`ajpe`]`aoa`ebanaj]ona]eoajpnaah]oa]onah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkajpna_keo]o `aiaoi]j]pqnav](`eolkop]ojqi]kn`aiejopepq`]lahklajo]iajpk(ai_kjbknie`]`a _kiqiipk`k*?kjda_anlnaikn`aioneao_]qo]eo`a_keo]o`aiaoi]j]pqnav]a `eopejcqe)h]oejpnejoa_]iajpa`]omqaok`aj]pqnav]`ebanajpa*Kn`aj]n(e`ajpebe_]na`eba) naj_e]nok]oklan] ao`]nalnaoajp]ka`abejai]bmfpqbjbik`anj]* Mq]j`k oa l]oo] ]k aopq`k `] behkokbe] a `]o _ej_e]o ] l]npen `k o_qhk TET( ao_nara Bkq_]qhp(jkp])oamqa(jkr]iajpa(ah]ojkok]na]hev]ki]eo]r]j]`]aiahdkn]`]`k mqad]re]oe`klajo]`klahklajo]iajpk_hooe_kkqik`anjkaoeimqaaopkknc]jev]`]o lknkqpn]bmfpqbjb(lknp]jpk(lknqi]jkr]na`a`eo_qnoer]*Mq]hk_kj_aepkmqaoanra`a ejopnqiajpk l]n] ] hejcq]cai a l]n] k lajo]iajpk knc]jev]nai k `eo_qnok `k _kjda_e) iajpk;=efpqof^kq]efpqlof`fa^ab(ajpaj`e`]_kikkik`k`aoan`]o_keo]oa`]ol]h]) rn]o*?kjda_anaop]^aha_an]j]hkce]`abqj aoajpna_keo]oaajpnal]h]rn]oa_keo]o(^ai _kikaop]^aha_an]oq_aookkq]kn`ai`aoqnceiajpk(`aoajrkhreiajpka`ao]l]nek`]o _keo]oa`]ol]h]rn]ojkpailk* Qi]bmfpqbjb(`evBkq_]qhp(atlneiako]^an`aqi]lk_]*I]okmqako]^an; Jkhernk>^onrblildf^alp^_bo(Bkq_]qhp_kia]atlhe_]j`kkmqako]^ankl* Ahajk]_qhpqn]`aqi]lk_](lkeojkqi]pkp]he`]`a`ae`ae]o(r]hknaoalnpe_]o mqalkooqaikiaoikoajpe`kaatlneiaikiaoikpk`k*=hi`eook(ahajklnaooql a] ateopj_e]`aqioqfaepkalkneookahajk6
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
]_ej_e](lkeojkqi_kjda_eiajpk`aqik^fapk`apaniej]`klknqioqfaepk`a) paniej]`k7 ]atlanej_e](lkeojkqi]rerj_e]oq^faper]7 aolnepk`aqilkrk(lkeojkqi]_kjo_ej_e]_khaper]kqqioqfaepk_khaperk7 e`akhkce](lkeojklnaooql aqi]_kjo_ej_e]kqej_kjo_ej_e]_khaper]mqafqopebemqa oq]bkni]aoq]ejop]h]kjkiqj`k* Ko]^anp]i^ijklnaooql aqi]_kjpejqe`]`aajpnaqiaop]`kh]pajpakqrenpq]h `a_kjda_eiajpkoaqiaop]`k`a_kjda_eiajpko]pq]hev]`ko(jailnaooql a]_kjpejqe) `]`aajpna]`ao]l]nek`aqi]_ej_e]a]lani]jj_e]`anao`qkoaraopceko`ah]jqi] _ej_e]jkr]*Ko]^anaopoailnanabane`k]klnaoajpaa(_kikp]h(jklkooqeqil]oo]`k jaiqibqpqnk*Eookoecjebe_]mqaajpna`q]obkni]o`ao]^anjkd_kjpejqe`]`aaoei `ao_kjpejqe`]`a(_kikoar]kaopq`]n]obmfpqbjbp* Kmqa(lkeo(ko]^an; Aha ( ai lneiaenk hqc]n( k `kijek `a k^fapko `a qi] lnpe_] `eo_qnoer]* Kq oaf]( k _]ilk`a_keo]olkop]o_kikk^fapkolah]]pere`]`a`k`eo_qnok*=kjkia)h]o(`abeje)h]o( naqje)h]o(kn`aj)h]oaknc]jev)h]ok`eo_qnokqi]lnpe_]mqaejopepqekoln lnekok^fapko aaoo]lnpe_]ko]^an* Aioacqj`k(ahakaol]kjkmq]hqioqfaepkln]pe_]qi`eo_qnokaoa]lnaoajp]_kik oqfaepkat]p]iajpalknmqana]hev]aoo]lnpe_]`eo_qnoer]*Kqoaf](]ooei_kik]lnpe_]`eo) _qnoer]ejopepqekk^fapk(`]iaoi]i]jaen]ejopepqekoqfaepk* Aipan_aenk(ko]^ank_]ilkjkmq]hkoajqj_e]`kooa_kkn`aj]iaoaoq^kn`ej]i oacqj`k nacn]o a _nepneko `abeje`ko lah] ln lne] lnpe_] `eo_qnoer]* Ai kqpnko paniko( k o]^anqi`eo_qnokmqalnk`qvl]n]oeiaoik]onacn]o`aoq]ajqj_e]kakik`k`a knc]jev]k`aoaqoajqj_e]`ko* Aimq]npk(ko]^an]lkooe^ehe`]`a`aqoka`a]lnklne]k`aqi`eo_qnoklknmqai lkooqekq]`mqena]_kilapj_e]l]n]lnk`qvenajqj_e]`ko_kjbkniaoonacn]o`]lnpe_] `eo_qnoer]aireckn* Oako]^anqi]lnpe_]`eo_qnoer](kmqak`eo_qnok; Jkr]iajpa(Bkq_]qhp_kia]atlhe_]j`kkmqak`eo_qnokkl*Ahajk6 ]l]h]rn]kq]b]h](lkeojk]]k`aqioqfaepkb]h]jpa7 k mqa oa nabana ] k^fapko $lkeo k `eo_qnok jk qi] bn]oa ej`e_]per]%( ] oecjebe_] ao $lkeojkqi_kjfqjpk`aoecjebe_]jpaokq`aoecjkoknc]jev]`kolknqi]_kjo_ej_e] lnk`qpkn]`aoecjebe_] ao%kq]r]hknao`aran`]`akq`ab]hoe`]`a$lkeok`eo_qnokjk ]lnklkoekh ce_]jaikfqvkh ce_k%* K`eo_qnokqi]na`a`aajqj_e]`kokq`anah] aomqapknj]ilkoorahd]ranoecjebe) _]jpao(jkiao(bn]oao(oecjebe_] ao(lnklkoe ao(fqvko(l]h]rn]kqb]h]ak^fapko*Kajqj_e]) `k]bqjk`k`eo_qnokaaopaajcaj`n]koajqj_e]`ko`ai]jaen]or]ne]`]o(oacqj`k]o nacn]omqa_kjopepqai(ai_]`]lk_](qi] cloj^ lafp`ropfs^* Oanaqjeniko]oe`ae]o`aBkq_]qhpok^nako]^an_kiklnpe_]`eo_qnoer]akaopq`k`ko lnkjkiaolaook]eo_kikhqc]naoalkoe ao`eo_qnoer]o(kmqalk`aiko_kj_hqen; Kaopq`k`kolnkjkiaojkoajoej]mqakoqfaepkqiabaepklnk`qve`klah]hejcq]) cai*=Î]nmqakhkce]`ko]^anÏjkoajoej]mqaoqfaepkak^fapkokabaepkolnk`qve`kolahk `eo_qnok*Klnej_lek`]iap]boe_]na]heop]Íkk^fapkkqkOanÍaklnej_lek`]iap]boe_] e`a]heop] Í k oqfaepk kq ] _kjo_ej_e] `a oe Í jk ok lnej_leko( i]o oeilhao abaepko `] hejcq]caia`k`eo_qnok* Jkd]raj`kl]n]]iap]boe_]qilnej_lekkqqibqj`]iajpkjaina]he`]`aokq oanao(`ara)oa_kj_hqen(lknqih]`k(mqaah]lanpaj_a]qi]bkni]k`eo_qnoer]kq]qi] hejcq]cai`ao]l]na_e`]a(lknkqpnk(mqa(jklnaoajpa(ah]aopiknp]*
.22
Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
15%34¬%3
).42/$5a«/ =oej`]c] aoiap]boe_]o -* Mq]h_kjoe`an]`]]mqaopkiap]boe_]bqj`]iaj) p]h;Lknmqaokikohar]`ko]bkniqh)h]; .* Mq]eokooajpe`ko`kran^kj]lancqjp]Îkmqa;Ï* Alknmqaaooaooajpe`ko`aÚjaiko`keopai]olnej) _el]eo`]iap]boe_]; /* Kmqa]iap]boe_]ejraopec]; 0* Mq]eokolnej_el]eolank`ko`]deop ne]`]iap]boe_]; 1* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`klneiaenklank) `k`]iap]boe_]; 2* Mqa`evDqia]aooanaolaepk;Lknmqa_kiahapan) iej]klneiaenklank`k`]iap]boe_]; 3* Mqa oecjeÚ_] `evan mqa( _ki G]jp( ] iap]boe_] oq^opepq`]lah]_npe_]`]n]vklqn]pa ne_]; 4* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`]iap]boe_]_kj) pailknja];
#!0É45,/ß Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_] -* Mq]han]]lancqjp]Úhko Ú_]baep]]pko_qhkTREE; Mq]han]koecjeÚ_]`k`aoo]lancqjp]; .* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]ÚhkokÚ]j]o_a_kik_koik) hkce];Kmqaan]]_koikhkce]; /* Mq]h ] knecai `k ailnack `] l]h]rn] iap]boe_]; ?kimqaoajpe`kbkeailnac]`]; 0* MqaoecjeÚ_]]l]h]rn]kjpkhkce]; 1* Nah]_ekja]`aÚjek`a=neop pahaook^na]BehkokÚ] Lneiaen]_kikqokmqalkopanekniajpabkebaepk`] l]h]rn]kjpkhkce]* 2* AtlhemqakmqaoecjeÚ_]]Úni]nmqa]iap]boe_]kq kjpkhkce]aopq`]ÎkOanajmq]jpkOanÏ* 3* Lkn mqa ] l]h]rn] iap]boe_] Ú_kq _kjo]cn]`] l]n] `aoecj]n]BehkokÚ]Lneiaen]kqkjpkhkce]; 4* Naoqi]kolnej_el]eopn]ko`klajo]iajpk`aL]n) ije`aopki]j`k_kiknabanj_e]]klkoekajpna na]he`]`aa]l]nj_e]* 5* LknmqaL]nije`ao_nepe_kq]_koikhkce]ak`arena _kiaoo]_npe_]`aqknecai]kmqarene]]oan]kjpk) hkce]kqiap]boe_]; -,* =lnaoajpakolnej_el]eo]ncqiajpko`]Ao_kh]Aha]p]* --* Atlhemqa_kikalknmqaL]nije`ao`ebanaj_e]aj) pnalan_a^analajo]n* -.* Atlhemqa]`ereoklh]p je_]ajpnaiqj`koajoraha iqj`kejpahecrah* -/* Mq]h ] lnej_el]h `ebanaj] ajpna k lajo]iajpk `a Lh]pkak`aL]nije`ao;
.23
-0* Mq]eo]opno]pepq`ao_ki]omq]eoLh]pknaokhraqk eil]ooa Úhko Ú_k `aet]`k lkn L]nije`ao( mqa na) `qven]]ÚhkokÚ] ]Úni]kÎkOanÏa jac]kÎk JkOanjkÏ; -1* Mqa ok ]o e`ae]o kq bkni]o ejpahecraeo; Mq]eo ]o oq]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]okqmq]he`]`ao; -2* Atlhemqa_kikalknmqa(l]n]Lh]pk(]ÚhkokÚ]_kj) oeopaail]oo]n`]]l]nj_e]oajorah aooj_e]ejpa) hecrah`]o_keo]o(`]klejek e`ae]* -3* Atlkjd]_kioq]ol]h]rn]okmqa`evO _n]paojk`e) hkckK^]jmqapaa_kik(lkniaek`aha(atlhe_]mq]h ]aooj_e]`k]iknkq]e`ae]ran`]`aen]`k]ikn*
#!0É45,/ß =iap]boe_]`a=neoppahao -* Mq]eokoikperkolahkomq]eo]pne^qai]=neop pahao kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]; .* Mq]eokolnej_el]eooajpe`ko`]l]h]rn]cnac]gjaoeo; /* Mq]h]lkoek`a=neop pahao]naolaepk`]iq`]j] kqikreiajpk;Atlhemqa_kikahaailnac]]e`ae] `aikreiajpkl]n]`eopejcqenko`ebanajpaopelko`a oanao* 0* Atlhemqakmqa=neop pahaoajpaj`alknBehkokÚ]Lne) iaen]kqiap]boe_]* 1* Mq]eookkopnoaopq`komqa_]^ai iap]boe_]; 2* Kmqaokamq]eookkolneiaenkolnej_leko(oacqj) `k=neop pahao; 3* Kmqaokamq]eook]o_]qo]olneiaen]o(oacqj`k =neop pahao; 4* Kmqaoki]pne]abkni](oacqj`k=neop pahao; 5* Kmqaoklkpj_e]a]pk(oacqj`k=neop pahao; -,* Kmqaokaooj_e]a]_e`ajpa(oacqj`k=neop pahao; --* Kmqa]oq^opj_e](oacqj`k=neop pahao;Mq]eoko `keooajpe`koaimqa]ailnac]; -.* Kmqaoklna`e_]`kokq_]packne]o(oacqj`k=neop ) pahao;@]hcqjoatailhko* -/* Pki]j`k=neop pahao_kiknabanj_e](kmqa]iap]) boe_]ejraopec];
#!0É45,/ß =o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_] -* Lknmqalk`aiko`evanmqak_neope]jeoik(_kikna) hecek(jklna_eo]r]`]ÚhkokÚ]; .* Lknmqa(ajpnap]jpk(k_neope]jeoikbkehar]`k]bkn) iqh]nqi]iap]boe_]; /* Atlhemqa^naraiajpakmqakjaklh]pkjeoik* 0* Atlhemqa^naraiajpakmqakaopke_eoik*
x5.)$!$%ßx=iap]boe_]
1* Atlhemqa^naraiajpakmqakcjkope_eoik* 2* Kmqak_neope]jeoikpkikq`kjaklh]pkjeoik; 3* Kmqak_neope]jeoikpkikq`kaopke_eoik; 4* Kmqak_neope]jeoikpkikq`kcjkope_eoik; 5* =lnaoajpa ]hcqi]o `ebanaj]o ajpna k lajo]iajpk cnackak_neopk* -,* Atlhemqalknmqa]`ebanaj]ajpnaran`]`ao`an]vk aran`]`ao`abklnej_el]hlnk^hai]l]n]]ah]^k) n]k`aqi]ÚhkokÚ]_neop* --* Mq]eokopno]ola_pko_kj_anjajpao]@aqomqa_kjo) pepqaik_ajpnk`]iap]boe_]_neop;Atlhemqa)ko^na) raiajpa* -.* =hi`]olnkr]onabanajpao]@aqoa _ne]k`kiqj) `k(mqakqpn]olnkr]obkn]ieilknp]jpaol]n]]Úhk) okÚ]_neop; -/* Lkn mqa ko _neopko jk lk`e]i i]jpan ] `eopejk lh]p je_]ajpnakoajorahakejpahecrah; -0* Mq]eoko_]ilkoÚhko Ú_kooqnce`ko_ki]]Úni]) k_neop`amqakOanjklkooqekiaoikoajpe`k mq]j`knabane`k]@aqoa o_ne]pqn]o; -1* AtlhemqalknmqakoÚh okbkoik`anjkob]h]ij]ej) _kil]pe^ehe`]`aajpnaban]vk* -2* Atlhemqa ] na`aÚjek ik`anj] `k _kj_aepk `a Oan kqoq^opj_e]* -3* Mq]eo ok ]o oq^opj_e]o l]n] @ao_]npao; A l]n] Dk^^ao; -4* Mqa`evAolejko]ok^na]oq^opj_e]; -5* Atlhemqa]na`aÚjekik`anj]`k_kj_aepk`a_]q) o]he`]`a* .,* L]n]koik`anjko(kmqa]iap]boe_]aopq`]; .-* Mq]eo ]o pno e`ae]o mqa klan]i j] iap]boe_] ik) `anj]; ..* Mq]eo an]i ko `keo cn]j`ao lnaooqlkopko `] iap]) boe_]; Atlhemqa _ki oq]o l]h]rn]o _kik a lkn mqa @]re`Dqiako_nepe_]* ./* L]n]Dqia(mqaok]oe`ae]o; .0* L]n]Dqia(mqa]oq^opj_e]kq]aooj_e]; .1* L]n]Dqia(mqa]_]qo]he`]`a; .2* KmqakÎokjk`kcipe_kÏ(oacqj`kG]jp;Akmqa oecjeÚ_]`aolanp]n`aooaokjk; .3* Mq]h]`eopejkg]jpe]j]ajpnafqvko]j]hpe_koa fqvkooejppe_ko; .4* LknmqaG]jp]Úni]mqao d_ej_e]kqo]^anran) `]`aenkoabknailkooraeofqvkooejppe_ko]lnekne; Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( atlhemqa _kik G]jp e`ajpeÚ_] _kjda_anabkniqh]nfqvkooejppe_ko]lnekne* .5* ?kikG]jplnkr]mqajkoklkooraeofqvkooejppe) _ko]lneknej]iap]boe_];Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(_kik G]jpatlhe_]lknmqajklk`aiko_kjda_ankjqia) jkkq]_keo]aioe(mqaan]kk^fapk`]iap]boe_]; /,* Mq]h]iap]boe_]mqalkoorahl]n]jkookajpaj`e) iajpk;Mq]eookkok^fapko`aejraopec]kiap]b) oe_]mqaaopk]k]h_]j_a`ajkookajpaj`eiajpk;
#!0É45,/ß
GLOSSfRIO
=kjpkhkce]_kjpailkn ja] -* Atlhemqakmqake`a]heoikej]qcqn]`klknG]jpa _kikoa`ebanaj_e]`kna]heoik* .* Mq]eook]opnop]nab]omqaDqooanh]pne^qe bajk) iajkhkce]; /* LknmqaDqooanhikopnkqmqa]loe_khkce]jklk`a) ne]oq^opepqen]h ce_]a]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk; Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna]ÚhkokÚ]a]loe_khkce]; 0* Kmqa]_kjo_ej_e]naÛater];Lknmqa_kjo_ej) _e]pn]jo_aj`ajp]h; 1* Kmqa]bajkiajkhkce]ajpaj`alknejpaj_ekj]he`]) `a`]_kjo_ej_e]; 2* LknmqaDacahbkeklneiaenk]ailnac]n]l]h]rn] bajkiajkhkce]; K mqa lnapaj`aq oecjeÚ_]n _ki ah]; 3* Mq]h ] _npe_] `a Dqooanh _kj_alk g]jpe]j] `a baj iajk; 4* Mq]h]_npe_]`aDqooanh _kj_alkdacahe]j]`a baj iajk; 5* KmqaDqooanhajpaj`alknbaj iajk; -,* Mq]hk_]ilk`kobaj iajko;Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o( mq]hk]h]nc]iajpk`k_kj_aepk`abaj iajkpn]ve) `klknDqooanh; --* KmqaDqooanhajpaj`alknÎnace ao`koanÏ;Lknmqa `aoo]e`ae]oqnca]`aÎkjpkhkce]onacekj]eoÏ; -.* K mqa ] `eopejk ajpna jpe_k a kjpkh ce_k lnk) lkop]lknDae`accan; -/* Oacqj`k Dae`accan( mq]eo ok ]o _ej_k aopnqpqn]o
jpe_]o`ajkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j]; -0* Oacqj`kDae`accan(mq]j`kl]oo]iko`]atlanej) _e] jpe_]]k_kjda_eiajpkkjpkh ce_k; -1* Kjpkhkce_]iajpa(kmqaqioanna]hkq]na]he`]) `a; -2* Kjpkhkce_]iajpa(kmqaqioane`a]hkqqi]e`a]) he`]`a; -3* Mq]eoko_kj_aepkokjpkh ce_kol]n]`ao_narankoan `kor]hknaokqkoajpaomqaokr]hknao; -4* Mq]hk`ehai]ajpnae`a]heoikana]heoik; -5* Kmqanaop]oanapen]niko]_kjo_ej_e];Kmqanaop] oaaheiej]niko]o_keo]o;Kmqa`evqi]jkr]kjpk) hkce]mqaoa]b]op]p]jpk`ke`a]heoik`]_kjo_ej) _e]_kik`kna]heoik`]o_keo]o; .,* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqaokikoqi]_kjo_ej_e]aj) _]nj]`] a pailkn]h; K mqa k iqj`k l]n] oanao aj_]nj]`koapailkn]eo; .-* Kmqa]jkr]kjpkhkce]ajpaj`alknna]he`]`a; ..* K mqa ] kjpkhkce] ejraopec]; Mq]eo ]o oq]o lnej_e) l]eomqaop ao; ./* Atlhemqalknmqa]ejraopec]kkjpkh ce_]`]oao) oj_e]oqi]ejraopec]kok^na]ooecjeÚ_] ao* .0* =lnaoajpa_kioq]ol]h]rn]o]i]jaen]_kikIan) ha]q)Lkjpuejraopec]]aooj_e]`ajkook_knlk*
.24
Kj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_]x#!0É45,/ßx GLOSSfRIO .1* Atlkjd]_kioq]ol]h]rn]o]i]jaen]_kikIanha]q)
)Lkjpu_nepe_]]o_kj_al aopn]`e_ekj]eo`kpailk* .2* =lnaoajpa_kioq]ol]h]rn]o]`ao_nekmqaIanha]q) )Lkjpukbana_a`]aooj_e]`kpailk*
#!0É45,/ß =ÚhkokÚ]lo)iap]boe_] -* Kmqak_eajpeÚ_eoik;Lknmq(l]n]aha(]iap]boe) _]eilkoorah; .* KmqaD]^ani]oajpaj`alknÎl]n]`eci]`]kjpkhk) ce]Ï;AlknÎl]n]`eci]`]ÚhkokÚ]`]_kjo_ej_e]Ï;A lknÎl]n]`eci]`]ÚhkokÚ]`]hejcq]caiÏ; /* =lao]n`]o`ebanaj]o(mq]hk]ola_pk_kiqi ÚhkokÚ] `a@ao_]npaoa bajkiajkhkce]`aDqooanh;Paj`kai reop]aooa]ola_pk_kiqi(mq]hklnaooqlkopkiap]) boe_k_kiqi]pk`]o]oÚhkokÚ]o`]_kjo_ej_e]; 0* ?kik]hejcqope_]]j]heo]kolnkjkiaolaook]eoÎaqÏ aÎpqÏ; 1* Mq]eokolkjpko`]]jheoahejcqope_]`kolnkjkiao laook]eomqahar]i]`evanmqakoqfaepkkq]oq^fape) re`]`apai]laj]oateopj_e]j]hejcq]caikqqi] ateopj_e]lqn]iajpahejcqope_];
.25
2* Mq]h]_kj_hqokÚhko Ú_]`]]jheoahejcqope_]mqa ]b]op]]iap]boe_]rej`]`]oÚhkokÚ]o`]_kjo_ej_e]; 3* KmqaIe_dahBkq_]qhpajpaj`alknaleopaia; 4* ?kikBkq_]qhp`eopejcqa]aleopaia`]Naj]o_aj]a ]aleopaia_hooe_]kq`kn]_ekj]heoikik`anjk; 5* ?kikBkq_]qhp`ao_nara]aleopaia]l]npen`ko_qhk TET; -,* K mqa Bkq_]qhp ajpaj`a lkn o]^an; Atlkjd] k mqa aha`evmqako]^anjk* --* K mqa Bkq_]qhp ajpaj`a lkn o]^an; Atlkjd] k mqa aha`evmqako]^an* -.* KmqaBkq_]qhpajpaj`alkn`eo_qnok;Atlkjd]kmqa aha`evmqak`eo_qnokjk* -/* KmqaBkq_]qhpajpaj`alkn`eo_qnok;Atlkjd]kmqa aha`evmqak`eo_qnok* -0* Lknmqalk`aikob]h]nailajo]iajpkl o)iap]b) oe_kmq]j`knaqjeiko]]jheoahejcqope_]`kolnk) jkiao laook]eo a ] ]jheoa bkq_]qhpe]j] `k o]^an a `k`eo_qnok;
5NIDADEß
=_ej_e] ?]lpqhk-
=]pepq`a_eajpbe_]
?]lpqhk.
=_ej_e]j]deop ne]
?]lpqhk/
=o_ej_e]odqi]j]o
?]lpqhk0
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]h
Qi]`]o_]n]_pan ope_]oi]eojkr]o`]_e j_e]aopaimqa]olaomqeo]o_eajp Ú_]o l]oo]n]i]b]vanl]npa`]obkn]olnk`qper]o`]ok_ea`]`a(eopk (`]a_kjkie]*= ]qpki]k(]ejbkni]pev]k(]paha_kiqje_]k`apaniej]ibkni]o`alk`an a_kjie_k(ik`ko`aknc]jev]nkpn]^]hdkej`qopne]hakooanreko(_ne]ilnkÚo) oaoak_ql]aojkr]o(`aopnkailnkÚooaoak_ql]ao]jpec]o(ejpnk`qvai] rahk_e`]`aj]lnk`qk`aian_]`kne]oaaioq]`eopne^qeka_kjoqik(ik`e) Ú_]j`kl]`naoej`qopne]eo(_kian_e]eoaaopehko`are`]*=_e j_e]pknjkq)oal]npa ejpacn]jpaaej`eolajorah`]]pere`]`aa_kjie_]*Pknjkq)oa]cajpaa_kjie_k alkh pe_k*
Aopnqpqn]`k@J=ai/@*
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
#APqTULOß =]pepq`a_eajpbe_] Koajok_kiqi KOkhiajkn`kmqa]Pann]*Mqai`qre`]n`eookoa(`e]ne]iajpa(raikoqilamqajk _n_qhk]raniahd]`klan_knnank_q(ej`k`ahaopa]kaopa; KOkhoaikraaipknjk`]Pann](mqalani]ja_aei rah*Mqai`qre`]n`eookoa(`e]) ne]iajpa( raiko k Okh j]o_an( lan_knnan k _q a oa ln; = ]qnkn] jk k oaq _kiak a k _nalo_qhkoaqÚi; =o_knaoateopaiaioeiaoi]o*Mqai`qre`]n`eookoal]oo]iko]re`]raj`knko]o raniahd]o(]i]nah]oa^n]j_]o(k]vqh`k_q(kran`a`]onrknao(k]h]n]jf]`k`]h]n]jf]a `]p]jcanej]; ?]`]cjankkqaol_ea`a]jei]eofoqnceqp]h_kikko_kjda_aiko*=hcqilk`ane] ei]cej]nqilaetapknj]n)oaqinlpehkqloo]nk;Ainahecek(_kik]fq`]e_](]_neopa] eoh ie_](kohernkoo]cn]`kojkajoej]imqa]`erej`]`a_nekq`aqi]o ravpk`koko]je) i]eo(jqio `e]; = b]ihe] qi] na]he`]`a j]pqn]h _ne]`] lah] j]pqnav] l]n] c]n]jpen ] ok^narerj_e] dqi]j]al]n]]paj`an]bapere`]`aj]pqn]h`kodqi]jko(mqaoajpai]ja_aooe`]`a`a reranfqjpko*Mqai`qre`]n`eook(oaraiko(jkiqj`kejpaenk(jkl]oo]`kajklnaoajpa(] b]ihe]ateopej`kj]pqn]hiajpaaoaj`k]_hqh]lneiaen]`]ok_ea`]`a; =În]]Ïqi]na]he`]`aj]pqn]hkq^ekh ce_]lnk`qve`]lah]`ebanaj]`ko_hei]o(`] ]heiajp]k(`]cakcn]Ú]a`]nalnk`qkoatq]h*Mqai`qre`]n`eook(oaraikomqako ]bne_]jkookjacnko(ko]oepe_kook]i]nahko`akhdkolqt]`ko(koj`ekookraniahdkoa koaqnklaqo(^n]j_ko; ?anpav]o_kikaoo]obkni]ijkoo]re`]akoajok_kiqi`ajkoo]ok_ea`]`a(pn]joie) pe`k`acan]kl]n]can]k(a(iqep]oravao(]koapn]jobkni]nai_naj]naheceko](pknj])oa qi]`kqpnej]ejmqaopekjrah* Napkiaikojkookoatailhko* =]opnkjkie]`aikjopn]mqakOkhiqep]oravaoi]ekn`kmqa]Pann]a(`ao`a?kln) je_k(mqa]Pann]mqaoaikraaipknjk`kOkh*= lpe_]`aikjopn]mqa]o_knaookkj`]o hqiejko]o(k^pe`]olah]nabn]kanaÛatkkq`a_kilkoek`]hqv^n]j_]* =^ekhkce]`aikjopn]mqakocjankoa]oaol_eao`a]jei]eooabkni]n]ihajp]iajpa( jk_qnok`aiehd ao`a]jko(]l]npen`aik`eÚ_] ao`aie_nknc]jeoikoatpnai]iajpa oeilhao* Deopkne]`knaoa]jpnkl hkckoikopn]imqakmqaajpaj`aikolknb]ihe]$l]e(ia( Úhdko7aolko](i]ne`k(eniko%qi]ejopepqekok_e]hna_ajpooei]Í`]p]`ko_qhkTRÍ aln lne]`]Aqnkl]k_e`ajp]h(jkateopej`kj]=jpecqe`]`ajaij]ook_ea`]`ao]bne_]j]o( ]oepe_]oa]iane_]j]oln)_khki^e]j]o*Ikopn]ip]i^imqajkqib]pkj]pqn]h(i]o qi]_ne]kdqi]j](atece`]lkn_kj`e aodeop ne_]o`apaniej]`]o* Ok_e hkckoa]jpnkl hkckoikopn]imqa]e`ae]`aÎn]]Ïp]i^ina_ajpaÍ`]p]`k o_qhkTREEEÍ(oaj`kqo]`]lknlajo]`knaomqalnk_qn]r]iqi]atlhe_]kl]n]]o`eba) naj]oboe_]oa_qhpqn]eoajpnakoaqnklaqoakolkrkomqaoapknj]n]i_kjda_e`ko`koaq) nklaqo]l]npen`ko_qhkTER(_ki]ore]cajo`aI]n_kLkhk(a`ko_qhkTR(_ki]oCn]j`ao J]rac] aoa]o`ao_k^anp]o`a_kjpejajpaoqhpn]i]nejko*
3CIENCEß0HOTOß,IBRARY,ATINSTOCK
Jkoo]okleje ao_kpe`e]j]o
-ARCOß0OLO߯ ß MERCADORßEßEXPLORADORßVE NEZIANOß/ßRELATOßDEßSUASß EXPEDIlzESßPELOß/RIENTEß FOIßPORßMUITOßTEMPOßUMAß DASßPOUCASßINFORMAlzESß SOBREßAßÆSIAßNOß/CIDENTE
.3.
=]pepq`a_eajpbe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
=kmqal]na_a(dqi]cn]j`a`ebanaj]ajpnajkoo]o_anpav]o_kpe`e]j]oak_kjda_e) iajpk_eajpÚ_k*?kikalknmqaaoo]`ebanaj]ateopa;
?]n]_panope_]o`koajok_kiqi
Q
i^naraat]ia`ajkookoo]^anao_kpe`e]jkoa`koajok_kiqi`ajkoo]ok_ea`]`a narah]mqaahaolkooqai]hcqi]o_]n]_panope_]omqahdaookln lne]o6
ok oq^faperko( eopk ( atlneiai oajpeiajpko a kleje ao ej`ere`q]eo a `a cnqlko( r]) ne]j`k`aqi]laook]l]n]kqpn](kq`aqicnqlkl]n]kqpnk(`alaj`aj`k`]o_kj`e) aoaimqareraiko*=ooei(lknatailhk(oaaqbkn]npeop](ranae]^ahav]`]nrkna7oa aqbkni]n_ajaen](]mq]he`]`a`]i]`aen]7oaaoperanl]ooa]j`kok^kokh(]oki^n]l]n] `ao_]jo]n7oabkn^ke])bne](kobnqpkomqa`ark_khdanl]n]c]jd]nkiaq`e]*Oaaqbkn dej`q(qi]r]_]oano]cn]`]l]n]iei7oabkn`kj]`aqibnecknÚ_k(aop]naeejpanaoo]) `]j]mq]he`]`aaj]mq]jpe`]`a`a_]njamqalk`anaeraj`an7 lknoanaioq^faperko(har]i]qi]]r]he]kmq]hep]per]`]o_keo]o_kjbkniakoabaepko mqalnk`qvaiaijkooko ncko`kooajpe`kokq_kjbkniako`aoafkomqa`aolanp]i aij oakpelk`aÚj]he`]`akq`aqokmqahdao]pne^qiko(kqoaf](]o_keo]ookfqh) c]`]o lkn j o _kik cn]j`ao kq lamqaj]o( `k_ao kq ]va`]o( lao]`]o kq harao( jkr]o kqrahd]o(^ah]okqbae]o(mqajpaokqbne]o(paeokqejpaeo(`aoafraeokqej`aoafraeo( _khkne`]okqoai_kn(_kio]^kn(k`kn(ln tei]okq`eop]jpao(ap_*7 ]cnql]i)oakq`eopejcqai)oa_kjbknia]o_keo]oakob]pkojkol]na]ioaiahd]jpao kq`ebanajpao*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqafqhc]ikooanaib]pko`ebanajpaoqi_knlkmqa _]eaqi]laj]mqaÛqpq]jk]n7 okej`ere`q]hev]`knao(eopk(_]`]_keo]kq_]`]b]pkjko]l]na_a_kikqiej`er`qk `eopejpk`akqpnkolknlkooqenmq]he`]`aomqajko]bap]i`ai]jaen]`ebanajpa6]oa`] i]_e](]la`n]nqcko](k]hck`koq]ra(kiah`k_a(kbkckmqajpa(kinikna bnek(]i]`aen]`qn](ap_*7 i]op]i^iokcajan]hev]`knao(lkeopaj`ai]naqjenjqi]o klejekkqjqi]o e`ae]_keo]oab]pkofqhc]`kooaiahd]jpao6b]h]iko`ko]jei]eo(`]olh]jp]o(`kooanao dqi]jko(`ko]opnko(`koc]pko(`]oiqhdanao(`]o_ne]j]o(`]oao_qhpqn]o(`]olejpqn]o( `]o^a^e`]o(`konai`eko(ap_*7 ai`a_knnj_e]`]ocajan]hev] ao(paj`ai]aop]^aha_annah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepkaj) pna]o_keo]okqajpnakob]pko6Îkj`adbqi]](dbkckÏ7Îmqaipq`kmqan(pq`klan`aÏ7 Î`eva)ia_kimqai]j`]oapa`enaemqaioÏ7]lkoek`ko]opnko`apaniej]k`aopejk `]olaook]o7iqhdaniajopnq]`]jk`arapki]n^]jdkbnek7ejcaneno]hmq]j`koapai pkjpqn]^kil]n]]lnaook7iqhdan]oo]jd]`]mqanoanaopqln]`]7iajejk`anq] `ahejmqajpa(ap_*7 jkoaoqnlnaaj`aijaioa]`ien]i_ki]nacqh]ne`]`a(_kjop j_e](nalapeka`e) banaj]`]o_keo]o(i]o(]k_kjpnnek(]]`ien]kakaol]jpkoa`enecail]n]kmqa ei]cej]`k_kikje_k(atpn]kn`ejnek(i]n]rehdkokkqien]_qhkok*Fqop]iajpalkn eook(aijkoo]ok_ea`]`a(]lnkl]c]j`]a]ik`]aopkoailnaejrajp]j`kkÎatpn]kn) `ejnekÏ(kÎjqj_]reopkÏ7
.3/
lahkiaoikikperkajklkn_kilnaaj`anaikmqaoaf]ejraopec]k_eajpÚ_](paj) `ai]r)h]mq]oa_kiki]ce](_kjoe`an]j`kmqa]i^]oÍi]ce]aejraopec]k_eaj) pÚ_]Íhe`]i_kikieopanekok(kk_qhpk(kej_kilnaajorah*Aoo]ei]cai`]_ej_e] _kiki]ce]]l]na_a(lknatailhk(jk_ejai](mq]j`kkoÚhiaoikopn]ikoh]^kn]) p neko_eajpÚ_konalhapko`ak^fapkoej_kilnaajoraeo(_kihqvaomqa]_aj`aia]l])
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
c]i(pq^ko`akj`ao]aibqi]]o_khkne`]o(at]p]iajpa_kikokikopn]`]o]o_]ran) j]ok_qhp]o`koi]cko*Aoo]iaoi]e`ajpeÚ_]kajpna_ej_e]ai]ce]]l]na_ajqi lnkcn]i] `] pahareok ^n]oehaen]( k C^kqpqf`l( mqa( _kik k jkia ej`e_]( ikopn] ]ko pahaola_p]`knaonaoqhp]`ko_eajpÚ_ko_kikoabkooaiaol]jpko]k^n]`ai]ce](]ooei _kikate^ai]ckok_qhpeop]o_kikoabkooai_eajpeop]o7 _kopqi]ilnkfap]nj]o_keo]okqjkiqj`koajpeiajpko`a]jcope]a`aia`k`e]jpa `k`ao_kjda_e`k*=ooei(lknatailhk(`qn]jpa]E`]`aI`e](]olaook]ore]ik`ai) jekaipk`]l]npaa(dkfa(ajtanc]i`eo_kork]`knaojkaol]k7 lknoanaioq^faperko(cajan]hev]`knao(atlnaoo ao`aoajpeiajpko`aia`ka]jcope]a `aej_kilnaajokmq]jpk]kpn]^]hdk_eajpÚ_k(jkoo]o_anpav]o_kpe`e]j]oakoajok_k) iqi`ajkoo]ok_ea`]`akq`ajkookcnqlkok_e]h_neop]hev]i)oaailna_kj_aepko_kiko mq]eol]oo]iko]ejpanlnap]npk`]]na]he`]`amqajko_an_]apk`koko]_kjpa_eiajpko*
=]pepq`a_eajpbe_] ?]n]_panope_]ocan]eo`]]pepq`a_eajpbe_] Kmqa`eopejcqa]]pepq`a_eajpÚ_]`]]pepq`a_kopqiaen]kq`koajok_kiqi;=jpao `ai]eoj]`](]_ej_e]abp`lkÛ^`]ran]_e`]`a`ajkoo]o_anpav]o(`ajkoo]]`aokeia`e]p] o_keo]o(`]]qoj_e]`a_npe_]a`]b]hp]`a_qnekoe`]`a*Lkneook(kj`araiko_keo]o(b]pkoa ]_kjpa_eiajpko(]]pepq`a_eajpÚ_]rmol_ibj^pal_pq`rilp(]l]nj_e]omqalna_eo]ioan atlhe_]`]oa(ai_anpko_]oko(]b]op]`]o* Aimq]oapk`koko]ola_pkolk`aiko`evanmqak_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_kkl a)oalkj) pklknlkjpko_]n]_panope_]o`koajok_kiqi6
A`s]n`D*Sdepa( ]opnkj]qp]jknpa) )]iane_]jk(bhqpq]j`k j]cn]re`]`avank `kaol]k(ai/`a fqjdk`a-521* .!3!
k^faperk(lkeolnk_qn]]oaopnqpqn]oqjeran) o]eoaja_aoone]o`]o_keo]oejraopec]`]o7 mq]jpep]perk( kq oaf]( ^qo_] ia`e`]o( l]`n ao(_nepneko`a_kil]n]ka`a]r]) he]kl]n]_keo]omqal]na_ai`ebanajpao* =ooei( lkn atailhk( ]o `ebanaj]o `a _kn okatlhe_]`]olkn`ebanaj]o`aqiiao) ikl]`nkkq_nepnek`aia`e`](k_ki) lneiajpk`akj`]hqiejko]7]o`ebanaj]o `aejpajoe`]`a`kookjo(lahk_kilneiaj) pk`akj`]okjkn]7 dkikcjak(eopk(^qo_]]ohaeocan]eo`a bqj_ekj]iajpk `ko bajiajko( mqa ok ]o iaoi]o l]n] b]pko mqa jko l]na_ai `ebanajpao*Lknatailhk(]haeqjerano]h`] cn]rep]k`aikjopn]mqa]mqa`]`aqi] la`n]a]Ûqpq]k`aqi]lhqi]okik) reiajpko mqa k^a`a_ai iaoi] hae jk ejpanekn`k_]ilkcn]rep]_ekj]h7 cajan]hev]`kn(lkeonajaej`ere`q]he`]`aook^]oiaoi]ohaeo(koiaoikol]`n aokq _nepneko`aia`e`](ikopn]j`kmqalkooqai]iaoi]aopnqpqn](ai^kn]oaf]ioaj) okne]hiajpalan_a^e`]o_kik`ebanajpao*=ooei(lknatailhk(]mqie_]ikopn]mqa] ajkniar]nea`]`a`a_knlko`a_knna`]oejian]o_ki^ej] ao`aqilamqajkj) iankheiep]`k`aahaiajpkomqa_kil aiko_knlko_kilhatko7
.30
=]pepq`a_eajpbe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
`ebanaj_e]`kn( lkeo jk naja jai cajan]hev] lkn oaiahd]j]o ]l]najpao( i]o `eo) pejcqaajpnakomqal]na_aiecq]eo(`ao`amqak^a`a]i]aopnqpqn]o`ebanajpao*=l]) h]rn]nrbfgll]na_aoan]iaoi]_keo]mqa]l]h]rn]ejchao]`ebbpba]l]h]rn]bn]j_ao] colj^db( mq]j`k( j] na]he`]`a( ok iqepk `ebanajpao( lknmqa oa nabanai ] aopnqpqn]o ]heiajp]nao`ebanajpao7 o aop]^aha_anah] ao_]qo]eo`alkeo`aejraopec]n]j]pqnav]kqaopnqpqn]`kb]pkao) pq`]`kaoq]onah] ao_kikqpnkooaiahd]jpaokq`ebanajpao*=ooei(lknatailhk(qi _knlkjk_]elknmqalao]`k(i]oklaok`aqi_knlk`alaj`a`k_]ilkcn]rep]_ek) j]hkj`aoaaj_kjpn]Ílkneookmqa(j]oj]raoaol]_e]eo(kj`a]cn]re`]`aecq]h] vank(pk`koko_knlkoÛqpq]i(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`klaokkq`kp]i]jdk7qi_knlk paiqi]_anp]_knjklknmqa_khkne`k(i]olknmqa(`alaj`aj`k`aoq]_kilkoek mqie_]aboe_](naÛapa]hqv`aqi]`apaniej]`]i]jaen](ap_*7 oqnlnaaj`a)oa_ki]nacqh]ne`]`a(]_kjop j_e](]bnamqj_e](]nalapeka]`ebanaj] `]o_keo]oalnk_qn]ikopn]nmqaki]n]rehdkok(katpn]kn`ejnekkqkÎieh]cnkokÏok qi_]okl]npe_qh]n`kmqanacqh]n(jkni]h(bnamqajpa*Qia_heloa(qipannaikpk(qi bqn]_k(]anqlk`aqirqh_k(ai^kn]at_al_ekj]eo(k^a`a_aiohaeo`]boe_]*Lnk) _qn](]ooei(]lnaoajp]natlhe_] aon]_ekj]eo(_h]n]o(oeilhaoaran`]`aen]ol]n]kob]pko( klkj`k)oa]kaolap]_qh]n(]kice_ka]kb]jpope_k7
#ERIMES!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
`eopejcqa)oa`]i]ce]*=i]ce]]`iepaqi]l]npe_el]kkqoeil]pe]oa_nap]ajpna_ke) o]o`ebanajpao(mqa]caiqi]ook^nakqpn]olkniaek`amq]he`]`aok_qhp]oa_kjoe`an]k loemqeoikdqi]jkqi]bkn]_]l]v`ahec]n)oa]loemqeoikooqlaneknao$lh]japneko(]o) pn]eo(]jche_ko(`aikj]_ko%l]n]lnkrk_]nabaepkoejaolan]`koj]o_keo]oaj]olaook]o* =]pepq`a_eajpÚ_](]k_kjpnnek(klan]qi`aoaj_]jp]iajpkkq`aoajbaepe]iajpk`k iqj`k(ikopn]j`kmqajahajk]caibkn]ooa_nap]o(i]o_]qo]oanah] aon]_ekj]eo mqalk`aioan_kjda_e`]oamqap]eo_kjda_eiajpkolk`aioanpn]joiepe`ko]pk`ko7 ]Úni]mqa(lahk_kjda_eiajpk(kdkiailk`ahe^anp]n)oa`kia`ka`]ooqlanope ao( `aet]j`k`alnkfap)hkojkiqj`kajkokqpnko7 lnk_qn]najkr]n)oaaik`eÚ_]n)oa_kjpejq]iajpa(arep]j`k]pn]jobkni]k`]opak) ne]oai`kqpnej]oa`aop]oailna_kj_aepkook_e]eo*Kb]pk_eajpÚ_knaoqhp]`aqiqo^* _^iell]_eajpaahajpk`aejraopec]ka`alaomqeo]n]_ekj]h(]^anpk]iq`]j]o(jk oaj`kjaiqiieopnekej_kilnaajorahjaiqi]`kqpnej]can]hok^nakiqj`k* 'ILESß'ASTONß'RANGERß ßEPISTEMvLOGOß FRANCoS
AioaqhernkIdf`^bÛilplÛ^a^p`fk`f^p(kÚh okbk`]o_ej_e]o(CehaoC]opkjCn]jcan( ao_nara6 >`fk`f^rj^cloj^pfpqbj^qf`^jbkqblod^kfw^a^almbkp^jbkqll_gbqfsl+%+++& A^j^df^Î`lkpfabo^a^rj`lkgrkqlabmoqf`^pabpqfk^al^^molsbfq^olpmlabobp pl_obk^qro^fpÎ)^`fk`f^qbof^`lkpbos^alrj^^m^ok`f^abjfpqoflbdo^sfa^abof* qr^i)qo^ lnrb^fka^elgbpromobbkab^j^flof^alpbpmofqlp+Alcbfqf`bfol^l`fbkqfpq^ e^mbk^prjmbnrbklm^ppl)c`fiabqo^kpmlo)nr^kal`lkpfabo^alplpÏjfi^dobpÐa^ `fk`f^jlabok^+Nr^kqlj^fpbp`^m^j^lpklpplppbkqfalp^pclo ^pk^qro^fpa^pnr^fp bi^ pb ^molsbfq^ %lka^p eboqwf^k^p) bibqof`fa^ab) bjfppbp bibqokf`^p&) j^fp m^ob`b bi^ ob^ifw^olpplkelpalpjdf`lp+%+++&>`fk`f^)bkqobq^kql)^mbk^pmlabopboj^df^^lp lielpabbpmb`q^alobp)mlfp^mbk^ppbif_boq^kala^j^df^nrb^`fk`f^molmof^jbkqb afq^mlababpbkslisbo*pb+
Kpn]^]hdk_eajpbe_kiap`e_kaoeopaipe_k Kob]pkokqk^fapko_eajpÚ_kojkok`]`koailne_koaolkjp jako`ajkoo]atlanej) _e]_kpe`e]j](i]ook`lkpqoralplahkpn]^]hdk`]ejraopec]k_eajpÚ_]*Aop]qi_kjfqj) pk`a]pere`]`aoejpaha_pq]eo(atlaneiajp]eoap_je_]o(na]hev]`]o_ki^]oaaijqlalpmqa laniepaiac]n]jpaimqa]lnej_el]hi]n_]`]_ej_e]oaf]kofdlo6
.31
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
oal]n]nkoahaiajpkooq^faperkoak^faperko`aqibajiajk7 _kjopnqenkbajiajk_kikqik^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk(_kjpnkhrah(raneÚ_rah(ejpan) lnapraha_]l]v`aoannapeÚ_]`kkq_knnece`klknjkr]oah]^kn] ao7 `aikjopn]nalnkr]nkonaoqhp]`kok^pe`ko`qn]jpa]ejraopec]k(cn]]o]kneckn`]o nah] ao`aÚje`]oajpnakob]pkoaopq`]`ko7]`aikjopn]k`araoanbaep]jko l]n] raneÚ_]n]r]he`]`a`konaoqhp]`kok^pe`ko(i]op]i^il]n]lnarann]_ekj]hiajpajk) rkob]pko_kikabaepko`kofaopq`]`ko7 nah]_ekj]n _ki kqpnko b]pko qi b]pk eokh]`k( ejpacn]j`k)k jqi] atlhe_]k n]_ekj]h qjeÚ_]`](lkeookiajpaaoo]ejpacn]kpn]jobkni]kbajiajkaik^fapk_eajpÚ_k( eopk(aib]pkatlhe_]`klknqi]pakne]7 bkniqh]n qi] pakne] can]h ok^na k _kjfqjpk `ko bajiajko k^oanr]`ko a `ko b]pko ejraopec]`ko(eopk(bkniqh]nqi_kjfqjpkoeopaipe_k`a_kj_aepkomqaatlhemqaia ejpanlnapai]o_]qo]oakoabaepko(]onah] ao`a`alaj`j_e](e`ajpe`]`aa`ebanaj] ajpnapk`kokok^fapkomqa_kjopepqaik_]ilkejraopec]`k* Lkneook(jkhernk]_ei]_ep]`k(Cn]jcanjko`evmqaÎkran`]`aenkoecjeÚ_]`k`]_ej_e]( mqa]`eopejcqa`apk`]kqpn]bkni]`ajkoo]]pere`]`a_erehev]`](k`aoanqijqlalab mbkp^jbkqlbab^ lÏ* @aheiep]nkq`aÚjenkob]pko]ejraopec]n(oal]n]j`k)ko`akqpnkooaiahd]jpaokq`e) banajpao7aop]^aha_ankolnk_a`eiajpkoiapk`kh ce_kol]n]k^oanr]k(atlaneiajp]ka raneÚ_]k`kob]pko7_kjopnqenejopnqiajpkop_je_koa_kj`e ao`ah]^kn]p nekaola_Ú_]o l]n] ] laomqeo]7 ah]^kn]n qi _kjfqjpk oeopaipe_k `a _kj_aepko mqa bkniai ] pakne] ca) n]h`kobajiajkoaopq`]`ko(mqa_kjpnkhaiacqeaik]j`]iajpk`]laomqeo](]hi`a ]ilhe)h]_kijkr]oejraopec] ao(alaniep]i]lnareok`ab]pkojkrko_ki^]oajkof _kjda_e`ko6aooaookkoln)namqeoepkol]n]]_kjopepqek`aqi]_ej_e]a]oatecj_e]o `]ln lne]_ej_e]* =_ej_e]`eopejcqa)oa`koajok_kiqilknmqaaopaqi]klejek^]oa]`]aid^e) pko( lna_kj_aepko( pn]`e ao _neop]hev]`]o( ajmq]jpk ] lneiaen] ^]oae])oa ai laomqeo]o( ej) raopec] aoiap `e_]oaoeopaipe_]oaj]atecj_e]`amqa]opakne]ooaf]iejpanj]iajpa _kanajpaoa`ec]i]ran`]`aok^na]na]he`]`a*=_ej_e]`lkeb`fjbkqlmqanaoqhp]`aqi pn]^]hdkn]_ekj]h* Mqapelk`a_kjda_eiajpkaooa; Rai`a=neop pahao]lneiaen]cn]j`a`aÚjek`k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k6]_ej_e] qi_kjda_eiajpk`]o_]qo]oalah]o_]qo]o(eopk(qi_kjda_eiajpk`aikjopn]perk* Arai`kÚj]h`kNaj]o_eiajpka`kej_ek`]ÚhkokÚ]ik`anj](_kiBn]j_eo>]_kj( C]hehaqa@ao_]npao(]e`ae]`amqa(]hi`a_kjda_eiajpk`aikjopn]perk(]_ej_e]qi _kjda_eiajpkaÚ_]v(eopk(_]l]v`alaniepen]kdkiaijko _kjda_ankiqj`k(i]o p]i^i`kiej)hkapn]jobkni)hk* Kpn]^]hdk_eajpÚ_koeopaipe_kalkneookqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]qioeopai]kn`a) j]`ka_kanajpa`alnklkoe aokqajqj_e]`ko^]oa]`koaiqilamqajkjiank`alnej) _leko(_qf]Új]he`]`a`ao_naran(atlhe_]nalnaran`kik`ki]eo_kilhapklkoorahqi _kjfqjpk `a bajiajko( kbana_aj`k oq]o haeo ja_aoone]o* = pakne] _eajpÚ_] laniepa mqa qi]iqhpelhe_e`]`aailne_]`ab]pko]l]najpaiajpaiqepk`ebanajpaooaf]i_kilnaaj`e) `ko_kikoaiahd]jpaoaoq^iape`kooiaoi]ohaeo7are_a)rano](laniepa_kilnaaj`anlkn mqab]pko]l]najpaiajpaoaiahd]jpaook`ebanajpaoaoq^iape`ko]haeo`ebanajpao*
.32
=_ej_e]j]deop ne]x#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =_e j_e]j]deopne]
=opn olnej_el]eo_kj_al ao`a_e j_e]
D
eopkne_]iajpa( pno pi oe`k ]o lnej_el]eo _kj_al ao `a _ej_e] kq `a e`a]eo `a _eajpeÚ_e`]`a6]o^`flk^ifpq^(_qfkik`ahk`ak^fapere`]`a]i]paipe_]7]bjmf* ofpq^(mqapki]kik`ahk`ak^fapere`]`a`]ia`e_ej]cnac]a`]deop ne]j]pqn]h`k o_qhkTREE7a]`lkpqorqfsfpq^(_qfkik`ahk`ak^fapere`]`a]`ri`]e`ae]`an]vk_kik _kjda_eiajpk]lnktei]perk* = _kj_alk n]_ekj]heop] Í mqa oa aopaj`a `ko cnacko ]p k Új]h `k o_qhk TREE Í ]Úni] mqa ] _ej_e] qi _kjda_eiajpk n]_ekj]h `a`qperk a `aikjopn]perk _kik ] i]) paipe_](lknp]jpk(_]l]v`alnkr]n]ran`]`aja_aoone]aqjerano]h`aoaqoajqj_e]`koa naoqhp]`ko(oai`aet]njajdqi]`re`]*Qi]_ej_e]]qje`]`aoeopaipe_]`a]teki]o( lkopqh]`koa`aÚje ao(mqa`apaniej]i]j]pqnav]a]olnklnea`]`ao`aoaqk^fapk(a`a `aikjopn] ao(mqalnkr]i]onah] ao`a_]qo]he`]`amqanacaikk^fapkejraopec]`k* Kk^fapk_eajpÚ_kqi]nalnaoajp]kejpaha_pq]hqjerano]h(ja_aoone]aran`]`aen] `]o_keo]onalnaoajp]`]o(a_knnaolkj`aln lne]na]he`]`a(lknmqaaop]n]_ekj]haejpahec) rahaioeiaoi]*=oatlanej_e]o_eajpÚ_]ookna]hev]`]o]laj]ol]n]raneÚ_]na_kjÚni]n ]o`aikjopn] aopa ne_]o(ajkl]n]lnk`qvenk_kjda_eiajpk`kk^fapk(lkeoaopa_kjda) _e`kat_hqoer]iajpalahklajo]iajpk*Kk^fapk_eajpÚ_ki]paipe_k(lknmqa]na]he`]`a lkooqeqi]aopnqpqn]i]paipe_](kq(_kik`eooaC]hehaq(Îkcn]j`ahernk`]j]pqnav]aop ao_nepkai_]n]_panaoi]paipe_koÏ* =_kj_alkaileneop]Ímqar]e`]ia`e_ej]cnac]a=neop pahao]pkÚj]h`ko_qhk TETÍ]Úni]mqa]_ej_e]qi]ejpanlnap]k`kob]pko^]oa]`]aik^oanr] aoaatla) neiajpkomqalaniepaiaop]^aha_anej`q aoamqa(]koanai_kilhap]`]o(kbana_ai]`a) Újek`kk^fapk(oq]olnklnea`]`aoaoq]ohaeo`abqj_ekj]iajpk*=pakne]_eajpÚ_]naoqhp] `]ok^oanr] aoa`koatlaneiajpko(`aik`kmqa]atlanej_e]jkpaioeilhaoiajpa] bqjk`araneÚ_]na_kjÚni]n_kj_aepko(i]o]`alnk`qve)hko*Aeolknmqa(jaop]_kj_alk( oailnadkqracn]j`a_qe`]`kl]n]aop]^aha_anipk`koatlaneiajp]eonecknkoko(lkeo`a) hao`alaj`e]]bkniqh]k`]pakne]a]`aÚjek`]k^fapere`]`aejraopec]`]* Aoo]o`q]o_kj_al ao`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`alkooq]ikiaoiklnaooqlkopk(ai^kn]kna]) hev]ooai`ai]jaen]o`ebanajpao*=i^]o_kjoe`an]r]imqa]pakne]_eajpÚ_]an]qi]atlhe) _]kaqi]nalnaoajp]kran`]`aen]`]ln lne]na]he`]`a(p]h_kikaop]aioeiaoi]*= _ej_e]an]qi]aol_ea`an]ekT`]na]he`]`a* = _kj_alk n]_ekj]heop] an] efmlqqf`l*abarqfs^( eopk ( `aÚje] k k^fapk a oq]o haeo a `eook`a`qve]lnklnea`]`ao(abaepkolkopaneknao(lnareo ao*=_kj_alkaileneop]an]efml* qqf`l*fkarqfs^(eopk(]lnaoajp]r]oqlkoe aook^nakk^fapk(na]hev]r]k^oanr] aoaatla) neiajpkoa_dac]r]`aÚjek`kob]pko(ooq]ohaeo(oq]olnklnea`]`ao(oaqoabaepkolkopa) neknaoa]lnareo ao* =_kj_alk_kjopnqpereop]Íeje_e]`]aijkooko_qhkÍ_kjoe`an]]_ej_e]qi] _kjopnqk`aik`ahkoatlhe_]perkol]n]]na]he`]`aajkqi]nalnaoajp]k`]ln lne]na]) he`]`a*K_eajpeop]_ki^ej]`keolnk_a`eiajpkoÍqirej`k`kn]_ekj]heoik(kqpnkrej`k `kaileneoikÍa]ahao]_nao_ajp]qipan_aenk(rej`k`]e`ae]`a_kjda_eiajpk]lnktei]) perka_knnecrah*
.33
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
?kikkn]_ekj]heop](k_eajpeop]_kjopnqpereop]atecamqakipk`khdalaniep]ahdac]) n]jp]aop]^aha_an]teki]o(lkopqh]`ko(`aÚje aoa`a`q aook^nakk^fapk_eajpÚ_k*?kik kaileneop](k_kjopnqpereop]atecamqa]atlaneiajp]kcqeaaik`eÚmqa]teki]o(lkopq) h]`ko(`aÚje aoa`aikjopn] ao*Jkajp]jpk(lknmqa_kjoe`an]kk^fapkqi]_kjopnqk h ce_k)ejpaha_pq]haqi]_kjopnqkatlaneiajp]hbaep]aih]^kn]p nek(k_eajpeop]jkaola) n]mqaoaqpn]^]hdk]lnaoajpa]na]he`]`aaioeiaoi](i]okbana]aopnqpqn]oaik`ahko`a bqj_ekj]iajpk`]na]he`]`a(atlhe_]j`kkobajiajkok^oanr]`ko*Jkaolan](lknp]jpk( ]lnaoajp]nqi]ran`]`a]^okhqp](aoeiqi]ran`]`a]lnktei]`]mqalk`aoan_knnece`]( ik`eÚ_]`](]^]j`kj]`]lknkqpn]i]eo]`amq]`]]kobajiajko*Okpno]oatecj_e]o`a oaqe`a]h`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`a6 -*
mqad]f]_kanj_e]$eopk(mqajkd]f]_kjpn]`e ao%ajpnakolnej_lekomqakneajp]i ]pakne]7
.* mqakoik`ahko`kok^fapko$kqaopnqpqn]o`kobajiajko%oaf]i_kjopnq`ko_ki^]oa j]k^oanr]kaj]atlaneiajp]k7 /* mqakonaoqhp]`kok^pe`kolkoo]ijko ]hpan]nkoik`ahko_kjopnq`ko(i]op]i^i ]hpan]nkoln lnekolnej_leko`]pakne](_knnecej`k)]*
@ebanaj]oajpna]_e j_e]]jpec]a]_hooe_]kqik`anj]
M
q]j`k]lnaoajp]ikokoe`a]eo`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`a(`eooaikomqap]jpkke`a]hn]_ekj]) heop]_kikkaileneop]oaeje_e]n]i_kikocnacko*Eook(lkni(jkoecjeÚ_]mqa] _kj_alk]jpec]a]_hooe_]kqik`anj]$o_qhkTREE%`a_ej_e]oaf]ie`jpe_]o* Ajpna]orne]o`ebanaj]o(`araikoiaj_ekj]nqi](p]hrav]i]eolnkbqj`]6]_ej_e]]j) pec]an]qi]_ej_e]qbloqf`^(kqoaf](]laj]o_kjpailh]r]kooanaoj]pqn]eo(oaif]i]eoei]ce) j]nejpanrenjahaokqok^naahaolkniaekop_je_ko7]_ej_e]_hooe_]qi]_ej_e]mqareo]jk o ]k_kjda_eiajpkpa ne_k(i]ook^napq`k]lhe_]klnpe_]kqp_je_]*Bn]j_eo>]_kj`eve] mqaÎo]^anlk`anÏ(a@ao_]npaoao_naraqmqaÎ]_ej_e]`arapknj]n)jkooajdknao`]j]pqnav]Ï*= _ej_e]_hooe_]kqik`anj]j]o_arej_qh]`]e`ae]`afkqbosfok^k^qrobw^(`a_kjda_)h]l]n] ]lnklne]n)oa`ah](l]n]_kjpnkh)h]a`kiej)h]*=_ej_e]jk]laj]o_kjpailh]k`]ran`]) `a(i]ook^napq`kkatan__ek`klk`anekdqi]jkok^na]j]pqnav]*Jqi]ok_ea`]`aaimqa k_]lep]heoikaopoqncej`ka(l]n]]_qiqh]nk_]lep]h(`ara]ilhe]n]_]l]_e`]`a`kpn]^]hdk dqi]jkl]n]ik`eÚ_]naatlhkn]n]j]pqnav](]jkr]_ej_e]oanejoal]nrah`]p_je_]* J]ran`]`a(i]eo_knnapkb]h]naiÎpa_jkhkce]Ï`kmqaaiÎp_je_]Ï*@ab]pk(]p_je_]qi _kjda_eiajpkailne_k(mqa(cn]]ok^oanr]k(ah]^kn]qi_kjfqjpk`ana_aep]oalnpe_]o l]n]]cenok^na]o_keo]o*=pa_jkhkce](lkni(qio]^anpa ne_kmqaoa]lhe_]ln]pe_]iajpa* Lknatailhk(qinah cek`aokhqik^fapkp_je_kmqaoanral]n]i]n_]ndkn]ooacqej`k kikreiajpkokh]njk_q*Qi_nkjiapnk(lkni(qik^fapkpa_jkh ce_k6lknqih]`k(oq] _kjopnqklnaooql a_kjda_eiajpkopa ne_kook^na]ohaeo`kikreiajpk$]ohaeo`klj`qhk% a(lknkqpnk(oaqqok]hpan]]lan_alkailne_]a_kiqi`kok^fapko(lkeooanral]n]ia`en ]mqehkmqajkoo]lan_alkjk_kjoacqalan_a^an*Qi]hajpa`a]qiajpkqik^fapkp_je) _k(i]okpahao_ lekakie_nko_ lekokk^fapkopa_jkh ce_ko(lkeooq]_kjopnqklnaooql a k_kjda_eiajpk`]ohaeo_eajpÚ_]o`aÚje`]olah] lpe_]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(qik^fapkpa_) jkh ce_kmq]j`koq]_kjopnqklnaooql aqio]^an_eajpÚ_kamq]j`koaqqokejpanbanajko naoqhp]`ko`]olaomqeo]o_eajpÚ_]o*=_ej_e]ik`anj]pknjkq)oaejoal]nrah`]pa_jkhkce]*
=oiq`]j]o_eajpbe_]o
R
eiko]p]mqe`q]ocn]j`aoiq`]j]oj]_ej_e]*=lneiaen]`ah]ooanabanal]oo]) cai`kn]_ekj]heoika`kaileneoik]k_kjopnqpereoik(eopk(`aqie`a]h`a_eajpe) Ú_e`]`a^]oa]`kj]e`ae]`amqa]_ej_e]qi]obmobpbkq^ l`]na]he`]`ap]h_kik
.34
=_ej_e]j]deop ne]x#!0É45,/ßx
ah]aioeiaoi](]qie`a]h`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`a^]oa]`kj]e`ae]`amqakk^fapk_eajpÚ_k qijlabil_kjopnq`kajkqi]nalnaoajp]k`kna]h(qi]]lnktei]kok^nakik`k`a bqj_ekj]iajpk`]na]he`]`a(i]ojkk_kjda_eiajpk]^okhqpk`ah]*=oacqj`]iq`]j] nabana)oal]oo]cai`]_ej_e]]jpec]Ípaknpe_](mq]hep]per]Í_ej_e]_hooe_]kqik`an) j]Ípa_jkh ce_](mq]jpep]per]*Lknmqadkqrap]eoiq`]j]ojklajo]iajpk_eajpÚ_k; @qn]jpa_anpkpailk(fqhckq)oamqa]_ej_e]$_kik]ok_ea`]`a%arkhqealnkcne`a*Ark) hqkalnkcnaookok`q]oe`ae]oiqepkna_ajpaoÍ`]p]i`koo_qhkoTREEEaTETÍ(i]o iqepk]_aep]olah]olaook]o*>]op]rankhai]`]^]j`aen]^n]oehaen]l]n]lan_a^an_kik]o laook]o]_d]ij]pqn]hb]h]naiÎKn`aiaLnkcnaookÏ* =ojk ao`aarkhqka`alnkcnaookl]npai`]oqlkoek`amqakpailkqi]he) jd]_kjpjq]adkikcja]$_kik]ei]cai`knek(mqareiko]kaopq`]n]iap]boe_]%*K pailkoane]qi]oq_aook_kjpjq]`aejop]jpao(ikiajpko(b]oao(lank`ko(lk_]o(mqa ene]ioaoki]j`kqjo]kokqpnko(]_qiqh]j`k)oa`ap]hik`kmqakmqa]_kjpa_a`alkeo knaoqhp]`kiahdkn]`k`kmqa]_kjpa_aq]jpao*?kjpjqka_qiqh]perk(kpailkoane]qi ]lanbaek]iajpk`apk`kokooanao$j]pqn]eoadqi]jko%* Arkhqkalnkcnaookok]_naj]j]oqlanekne`]`a`klnaoajpaainah]k]kl]oo]`ka `kbqpqnkainah]k]klnaoajpa*=ooei(koaqnklaqo_erehev]`kooane]ioqlaneknao]ko]bne) _]jkoa]koj`eko(]boe_]c]heh]e_k)jaspkje]j]oane]oqlanekn]neopkphe_](]boe_]mq jpe_] oane]oqlanekn`aC]hehaqa`aJaspkj* ArkhqenoecjeÚ_]pknj]n)oaoqlaneknaiahdkn`kmqaoaan]]jpao*Lnkcna`enoecjeÚ_]en jqinqik_]`]raviahdknj]`enak`aqi]Új]he`]`aoqlanekn* Arkhqkalnkcnaookp]i^ioql aikpailk_kikqi]oneaheja]n`aikiajpko hec]`kolknnah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepk(aimqakl]oo]`k_]qo]aklnaoajpa(abaepk(rej`k] pknj]n)oa_]qo]`kbqpqnk*Raikoaoo]e`ae]]l]na_anmq]j`k(lknatailhk(koi]jq]eo`a deop ne] ]lnaoajp]i ]oÎejÛqj_e]oÏ mqa qi ]_kjpa_eiajpk ]jpanekn pane] pe`k ok^na qi kqpnk(lkopanekn* Arkhqenalnkcna`enlnaooql aiqi]_kj_alk`]deop ne]oaiahd]jpamqa]^ekhkce] ]lnaoajp]mq]j`kb]h]aicania(oaiajpakqh]nr]*Kcania(]oaiajpakq]h]nr]okajpao mqa_kjpiaioeiaoikopq`kkmqahdao]_kjpa_an(kqoaf](kbqpqnkfaop_kjpe`kjk lkjpkeje_e]h`aqioan_qf]deop ne]kq_qfkpailkj]`]i]eo`kmqak`ao`k^n]nkqk `aoajrkhranlhajk`]mqehkmqaahafan]lkpaj_e]hiajpa* Aoo]e`ae]aj_kjpn])oalnaoajpa(lknatailhk(j]`eopejkajpnal]oao`aoajrkhre`ko aoq^`aoajrkhre`ko*Mq]j`k`eckmqaqil]okqaop`aoajrkhre`k(`eckmqaoaemqa]h) _]jkq]Új]he`]`amq]haop]r]`aopej]`k`ao`amqaoqnceq*Mq]j`k`eckmqaqil]o kqaopoq^`aoajrkhre`k(aopkq`evaj`kmqa]Új]he`]`aÍmqa]iaoi]l]n]ahaal]n]k `aoajrkhre`kÍ]ej`]jkbke(i]o`aranoan]h_]j]`]ai]hcqiikiajpk`kpailk*Jk lkn]_]ok(]oatlnaoo aoÎ`aoajrkhre`kÏaÎoq^`aoajrkhre`kÏbkn]iqo]`]ol]n]oq^opepqen `q]okqpn]o(pe`]o_kikkbajoer]oa]cnaooer]o6l]oaoÎ]`e]jp]`koÏal]oaoÎ]pn]o]`koÏ(eopk (l]oaoÎarkhq`koÏaÎjkarkhq`koÏ(l]oaoÎ_kilnkcnaookÏaÎoailnkcnaookÏ* Ai naoqik( arkhqk a lnkcnaook lnaooql ai _kjpejqe`]`a pailkn]h( ]_qiqh]k _]qo]h`ko]_kjpa_eiajpko(oqlanekne`]`a`kbqpqnka`klnaoajpa_kinah]k]kl]oo]`k( ateopj_e]`aqi]Új]he`]`a]oan]h_]j]`]*Oqlqjd])oamqa]oiq`]j]o_eajpÚ_]oej`e) _]r]iarkhqkkqlnkcnaook`ko_kjda_eiajpkodqi]jko*
@aoiajpej`k]arkhqkaklnkcnaook_eajpbe_ko
= .35
ÚhkokÚ]`]o_ej_e]o(aopq`]j`k]oiq`]j]o_eajpÚ_]o(eiloqi`aoiajpe`ko e`ae]o`aarkhqkalnkcnaook*Eookjkmqan`evanmqa]ÚhkokÚ]`]o_ej_e]oreaooa]b]) h]nai]pn]okanacnaook_eajpÚ_](lkeoaoo]o`q]ojk aooke`jpe_]oo`aarkhqka lnkcnaook(]laj]o_kikoej]hpnk_]`k$airav`a_]iejd]n_]qo]ha_kjpejq]iajpal]n]]bnaj) pa(_]iejd]n)oa)e]_]qo]ha_kjpejq]iajpal]n]pno%*Kmqa]ÚhkokÚ]`]o_ej_e]o_kilnaaj) `aqbkemqa]oah]^kn] ao_eajpÚ_]oakoe`a]eo`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`aokafcbobkqbpaabp`lkqkrlp*
Mq]j`k(lknatailhk(_kil]n]iko]cakiapne]_hooe_]kqcakiapne]aq_he`e]j]$mqa klan]_kikaol]klh]jk%a]cakiapne]_kjpailkn ja]kqpklkh ce_]$mqaklan]_kik aol]kpne`eiajoekj]h%(raikomqajkoapn]p]`a`q]oap]l]okq`a`q]ob]oaooq_aooer]o`] iaoi]_ej_e]cakipne_](aoei`a`q]ocakiapne]o`ebanajpao(_kilnej_leko(_kj_aepko( k^fapko(`aikjopn] ao_kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpao*Jkdkqraarkhqkalnkcnaook`aqi] l]n]kqpn](lkeook`q]ocakiapne]o`erano]oajkcakiapne]ooq_aooer]o* Mq]j`k_kil]n]iko]oboe_]o`a=neop pahao(C]hehaq)JaspkjaAejopaej(jkaop]iko `e]jpa`aqi]iaoi]boe_](mqapane]arkhq`kkqlnkcna`e`k(i]o`e]jpa`apnoboe_]o`e) banajpao(^]oa]`]oailnej_leko(_kj_aepko(`aikjopn] ao(atlaneiajp] aoapa_jkhkce]o _kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpao*Ai_]`]qi]`ah]o(]e`ae]`aj]pqnav]`ebanajpa7ai_]`]qi] `ah]okoipk`koailnac]`kook`ebanajpao7ai_]`]qi]`ah]okmqaoa`aoaf]_kjda_an `ebanajpa* Mq]j`k_kil]n]iko]_ej_e]`]hejcq]cai`ko_qhkTET$mqaan]^]oa]`]jkoaopq) `ko`aÚhkhkce](eopk(jkoaopq`ko`]knecaia`]deop ne]`]ol]h]rn]o%_ki]hejcqope_] _kjpailkn ja] $mqa( _kik reiko jk _]lpqhk `a`e_]`k hejcq]cai( aopq`] aopnqpqn]o%( raiko`q]o_ej_e]o`ebanajpao*Akiaoiklk`aoan`epk`apk`]o]o_ej_e]o* RaneÚ_kq)oa( lknp]jpk( qi] `ao_kjpejqe`]`a a qi] `ebanaj] pailkn]h ajpna ]o pak) ne]o_eajpÚ_]o_kik_kjoamqj_e]jk`aqi]bkni]i]eoarkhq`](i]eolnkcnaooer]kq iahdkn `a b]van _ej_e]( i]o _kik naoqhp]`k `a `ebanajpao i]jaen]o `a _kjda_an a _kjo) pnqenkok^fapko_eajpÚ_ko(`aah]^kn]nkoipk`koaejrajp]npa_jkhkce]o*KÚh okbkC]opkj >]_dah]n`_nekq]atlnaookormqro^bmfpqbjlidf`^l]n]atlhe_]naoo]`ao_kjpejqe`]`ajk _kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k*
Nqlpqn]oaleopaikhce_]o
Q
i_eajpeop]kqqicnqlk`a_eajpeop]o_kia]i]aopq`]nqibajiajkailna) c]j`kpakne]o(ipk`koapa_jkhkce]o`eolkjraeoaioaq_]ilk`apn]^]hdk*Lkq_k ]lkq_k(`ao_k^naimqako_kj_aepko(kolnk_a`eiajpko(koejopnqiajpkoateopaj) paojkatlhe_]ikmqaaopkk^oanr]j`kjaihar]i]konaoqhp]`komqaaopk^qo_]j`k* Aj_kjpn]i(`ev>]_dah]n`(qiÎk^op_qhkaleopaikh ce_kÏ* L]n]oqlan]nkk^op_qhkaleopaikh ce_k(k_eajpeop]kqkcnqlk`a_eajpeop]olna_eo]ipan ]_kn]cai`a`evanÎjkÏ*Lna_eo]i`evanÎjkÏpakne]ateopajpaa]koipk`koapa_jkhkce]o ateopajpao(na]hev]j`k]nqlpqn]aleopaikhce_]*Aop]_kj`qvah]^kn]k`ajkr]opakne]o( jkrkoipk`koapa_jkhkce]o(mqa]bap]ipk`kk_]ilk`a_kjda_eiajpkoateopajpao*=ooei( qi]jkr]_kj_alk_eajpÚ_]aianca(har]j`kp]jpk]ej_knlkn]njah]ko_kjda_eiajpko ]jpaneknaomq]jpk]]b]op)hkoejpaen]iajpa*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa(l]n]>]_dah]n`(]deop ne]`]o iq`]j]o_eajpÚ_]obaep]`aabp`lkqfkrfa^abp$jkr]opakne]o(jkrkoik`ahko(jkr]opa_jk) hkce]omqankilai_kiko]jpecko%i]op]i^i_kilknp]`lkqfkrfa^abp(mq]j`koa_kjoe) `an]mqakjkrkbkeoqo_ep]`klahk]jpeckamqal]npa`aopaej_knlkn]`]lkn]mqaha* @]iaoi]i]jaen](Cn]jcanlnkl amqa`eopejc]ikoajpna`keopelko`a`ao_kjpejqe) `]`ao_eajpÚ_]o6qi]buqbok^akqpn]fkqbok^* = `ao_kjpejqe`]`a atpanj] mq]j`k d qi de]pk n]`e_]h ajpna qi] oepq]k _eajp) Ú_]_] pe_](aimqako_kjda_eiajpkoaopk`eolanokoaokejraneÚ_raeo(akoqnceiajpk `aqi]`eo_elhej]_eajpÚ_]_qfko_kj_aepko(ipk`koap_je_]o_kjoacqaiÎlnkn`aijk _]koÏ*Aoo]`eo_elhej]kn`aj]`kn](necknko]aoeopaipe_]jkiq`]]_ej_e]]jpanekn(]laj]o ]naknc]jev]* =`ao_kjpejqe`]`aejpanj]mq]j`k(i]jpe`]qi]iaoi]reokk^faper]`aqi_]ilk `ab]pko(pakne]o`ebanajpaooaoq_a`aijkejpanekn`aooa_]ilk*Jkhernk>`fk`f^b^p`fk* `f^p(ao_naraCn]jcan6 Qlj^kallbubjmila^jb` kf`^)sbjlpnrb^jb` kf`^a^obi^qfsfa^abobpqofq^bpq bjormqro^`lj^jb` kf`^kbtqlkf^k^`ippf`^)bfpplkl^mbk^pbjmlkqlpfpli^alp+ Lobcbobk`f^ialbpm^ lbalqbjml)nrbpbosb)afd^jlp)abab`lo^ labcrkalm^o^rj^
,AUREß!LBIN 'UILLOT!LBUMß AKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
'ASTONß"ACHELARDßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEß ENSAqSTAßFRANCoS ßCONSI DERADOßOßPAIßDAßEPISTEMO LOGIAßCONTEMPORhNEA
EPISTEMOLOGIAßAßPALAVRAß EPISTEMOLOGIAßmßCOMPOSTAß DEßDOISßTERMOSßGREGOSß EPISTEME ßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±CIoNCIA² ßEßLOGIA ßVINDAßß DEßLOGOS ßQUEßSIGNIFICAßß ±CONHECIMENTO²ßß %PISTEMOLOGIAßmßOßß CONHECIMENTOßFILOSvFICOß SOBREßASßCIoNCIAS
.4,
=_ej_e]j]deop ne]x#!0É45,/ßx
"ILLß0IERCE4IMEßß,IFEß0ICTURESß 'ETTYß)MAGES
jb` kf`^)crka^jbkq^ijbkqbjlafÛ`^al)`ljlpmol`bafjbkqlpabjbafa^alpbpm^* lpbalpqbjmlpm^pp^kal^abmbkabo)bkql)aljlsfjbkqlobi^qfslall_pbos^alobal l_pbos^al+>sbil`fa^aba^molm^d^ lalcbkjbklirjfklplqlok^*pb)bj`ljmbkp^* l)rj^`lkpq^kqbrkfsbop^i^_plirq^+Qla^p^pabj^fpjlafÛ`^ bpalpbkqfallmbo^q* oflalp`lk`bfqlpcpf`lpab`loobjabpp^jra^k ^alnr^aola^abp`of lalpcbkjbklp+ Mq]j`k d `ao_kjpejqe`]`a ejpanj]( jk d( lkni( nqlpqn] pkp]h( lkeo( `ev Cn]jcan( _kiki]jpe`]]iaoi]reokk^faper]`aqi_]ilk`ab]pko(]pakne]]jpaneknej_kn) lkn]`]_kikqi_]okl]npe_qh]n$oravao]p`eiejqpk%`]jkr]pakne](i]oqjerano]h*D `ao_kjpejqe`]`a(i]ojkd`aopnqek`]pakne]]jpanekn*
Narkhq ao_eajpbe_]o
WWWSOSANTIKVARIUMHUß !RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
4HOMASß+UHNßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOß NORTE AMERICANO
0TOLOMEU߯ ßß CIENTISTAßGREGOßQUEßVIVEUß EMß!LEXANDRIA ßRECONHECI DOßPORßSEUSßTRABALHOSßCOMß MATEMfTICA ßASTRONOMIA ß GEOGRAFIAßEßCARTOGRAFIA
@
erano]iajpa`a>]_dah]n`(kÚh okbk`]_ej_e]Pdki]oGqdj_kjoe`an]mqa]deo) p ne]`]_ej_e]baep]`a`ao_kjpejqe`]`aoa`anqlpqn]on]`e_]eo*Gqdj`aoecj]ko ikiajpko`anqlpqn]a`a_ne]k`ajkr]opakne]o_ki]atlnaookobslir l`fbk* qÛ`^(_kik(lknatailhk(]narkhqk_klanje_]j](mqaoq^opepqeq]atlhe_]kcak_jpne_] `aLpkhkiaqlah]dahek_jpne_]`a?klnje_k* Oacqj`kGqdj(qi_]ilk_eajpÚ_k_ne]`kmq]j`kipk`ko(pa_jkhkce]o(bkni]o`a k^oanr]k a atlaneiajp]k( _kj_aepko a `aikjopn] ao bkni]i qi pk`k oeopaipe_k( qi]pakne]mqalaniepak_kjda_eiajpk`aejiankobajiajko*=pakne]oapknj]qiik) `ahk`a_kjda_eiajpkkqqil]n]`eci]_eajpÚ_k*Kl]n]`eci]oapknj]k_]ilkjkmq]h qi]_ej_e]pn]^]hd]jkni]hiajpa(oai_neoao* Gqdjqo]]atlnaook`fk`f^kloj^il]n]nabanen)oa]kpn]^]hdk_eajpÚ_kjkejpanekn `aqil]n]`eci]aop]^aha_e`k*Aipailkojkni]eo(qi_eajpeop](`e]jpa`aqib]pkkq`a qibajiajk]ej`]jkaopq`]`k(katlhe_]qo]j`kkik`ahkkqkl]n]`eci]_eajpÚ_k ateopajpa*Ai_kjpn]lkoek`fk`f^kloj^i(k_knna]obslir l`fbkqÛ`^*Qi]narkhqk _eajpÚ_]]_kjpa_amq]j`kk_eajpeop]`ao_k^namqakl]n]`eci]`eolkjrahjk_kjoacqa atlhe_]nqibajiajkkqqib]pkjkrk(oaj`kja_aooneklnk`qvenqikqpnkl]n]`eci]( ]pajpkejateopajpaa_qf]ja_aooe`]`ajkan]oajpe`]lahkoejraopec]`knao*Jqi]narkhq) k_eajpÚ_](jko jkrkobajiajkook`ao_k^anpkoa_kjda_eiajpko]jpeckook]^]j) `kj]`ko(i]odqi]iq`]j]lnkbqj`]j]i]jaen]`ak_eajpeop]rankiqj`k(_kikoa l]oo]ooa]pn]^]hd]njqiiqj`k_kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpa* =_ej_e](lknp]jpk(jk_]iejd]jqi]re]heja]n_kjpjq]alnkcnaooer](i]olkno]h) pkokqnarkhq ao*=ooei(mq]j`k]e`ae]`aln pkj)ahpnkj)jqpnkjajpn]j]boe_](]`ar) nqoajpn]j]^ekhkce](]`aajvei]ajpn]j]mqie_]kq]`abkjai]ajpn]j]hejcqope_](ko l]n]`eci]oateopajpaookej_]l]vao`a]h_]j]n(_kilnaaj`anaatlhe_]naooaok^fapkokq bajiajko(atecej`k]_ne]k`ajkrkoik`ahko_eajpÚ_ko* Lknmqa(ajpk(paiko]ehqok`alnkcnaooka`aarkhqk;Lkn`keoikperkolnej_el]eo6 -*
.4-
`k h]`k `k _eajpeop]( lknmqa aopa oajpa mqa o]^a i]eo a iahdkn `k mqa ]jpao( f mqa kl]n]`eci]]jpaneknjkhdalaniepe]_kjda_an_anpkok^fapkokqbajiajko*?kik pn]^]hd]r]_kiqi]pn]`ek_eajpÚ_]a]]^]j`kjkq(paikoajpeiajpk`amqakl]o) o]`kaop]r]ann]`k(an]ejbanekn]klnaoajpa]^anpklknoaqjkrkpn]^]hdk*Jkaha(i]o kÚh okbk`]_ej_e]mqalan_a^a]nqlpqn]a]`ao_kjpejqe`]`aa(lknp]jpk(]`ebanaj] pailkn]h*@kh]`k`k_eajpeop](klnkcnaookqi]sfsk`f^pr_gbqfs^7
.* `kh]`k`kojk_eajpeop]o(lknmqareraikook^]e`akhkce]`klnkcnaooka`]arkhqk( `kÎjkrkÏa`kÎb]jpope_kÏ*=hi`eook(raikokonaoqhp]`kopa_jkh ce_ko`]o_ej_e]o6 j]rao aol]_e]eo( _kilqp]`knao( o]phepao( bknjko `a ie_nk)kj`]o( pahabkjao _ahqh]nao( _qn]`a`kaj]ofqhc]`]oej_qnraeo(k^fapkolhope_ko`ao_]npraeo(aaooaonaoqhp]`ko pa_jkh ce_kook]lnaoajp]`kolahkockranjko(lah]oailnao]oalah]lnkl]c]j`]_kik Îoecjko`klnkcnaookÏajk`]`ebanaj]pailkn]h*@kh]`k`kojk_eajpeop]o(klnk) cnaookqi]`obk ^fablidf`^*
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
!NNAß7EISE!LBUMß AKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
D(lkni(qi]n]vki]eolnkbqj`]l]n]jkoo]_naj]jklnkcnaook*@ao`a]=jpecqe) `]`a(_kjda_anoailnabke_kjoe`an]`kkiaeki]eolna_ekokaaÚ_]vl]n]_ki^]pankia`k( ]oqlanopeka]o_naj`e_ao*Kn](jk_]ok`]ik`anje`]`a(krj_qhkajpna_ej_e]a]lhe_]k lnpe_]`ko_kjda_eiajpko$pa_jkhkce]o%bavoqncenaik^fapkomqajko b]_ehep]n]i]re`] dqi]j]$iaeko`apn]jolknpa(`aehqiej]k(`a_kiqje_]k(`a_qhperk`kokhk(ap_*%(i]o ]qiajp]n]i]aolan]j]`are`]$nai`eko(_enqnce]o(ap_*%*@klkjpk`areop]`konaoqhp]`ko lnpe_ko(oajpeikomqaaop]ikoaiiahdknao_kj`e aomqako]jpeckoalkneookb]h]iko aiarkhqkalnkcnaook* Ajpnap]jpk(Gqdjjkna_qo]pkp]hiajpa]e`ae]`aqilnkcnaook_eajpÚ_k*Fqhc]mqa( are`ajpaiajpa(jkoalk`a]_aep]n]rahd]e`ae]`klnkcnaookaimqaoaoqlqjd]mqa(_ki kl]oo]n`kpailkak]_iqhk`a_kjda_eiajpko(]_ej_e]oa]lnktei]r]_]`]ravi]eo `]ran`]`a7i]olk`a)oab]h]nailnkcnaookpk`]ravmqaqijkrkl]n]`eci]kqqi]jkr] pakne]oaikopn]i_]l]vao`anaokhranqii]eknjiank`alnk^hai]o`kmqako]jpaneknao a`ab]vani]eoaiahdknaolnareo ao`kmqaahao*
B]hoebe_]k narkhqk
R
eikomqa]_ej_e]_kjpailkn ja]_kjopnqpereop](fqhc]j`kmqab]pkoabajia) jkojkrkolk`aiatecen]ah]^kn]k`ajkrkoipk`ko(jkr]opa_jkhkce]oajkr]o pakne]o* =hcqjoÚh okbko`]_ej_e](ajpnakomq]eoG]nhLkllan(]Úni]n]imqa]naah]^kn]k _eajpÚ_] `a_knna `k b]pk `a pan d]re`k qi] iq`]j] jk _kj_aepk Úhko Ú_k)_eajpÚ_k `] ran`]`a* Aop]( _kik f reiko( bke _kjoe`an]`] `qn]jpa iqepko o_qhko ] _knnaolkj`j_e] at]p]ajpnaqi]e`ae]kqqi_kj_aepka]na]he`]`a*Reikop]i^imqa(jko_qhkTT(bke lnklkop]qi]pakne]`]ran`]`a_kik_kanj_e]ejpanj]ajpna_kj_aepko*J]_kj_alk]j) panekn(kb]hok]_kjpa_e]mq]j`kqi]e`ae]jk_knnaolkj`e]_keo]mqa`arane]nalnaoajp]n* J]jkr]_kj_alk(kb]hok]lan`]`]_kanj_e]`aqi]pakne](]ateopj_e]`a_kjpn]`e ao ajpnaoaqolnej_lekokqajpnaaopaoa]hcqjo`aoaqo_kj_aepko* Lkllan]Úni]mqa]oiq`]j]o_eajpÚ_]ookqi]_kjoamqj_e]`]_kj_alk`]ran) `]`a_kik_kanj_e]pa ne_]*Alnkl amqaqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]oaf]]r]he]`]lah]lkooe^e) he`]`a`aoanb]ho]kqb]hoeÚ_]`]*=b]hoeÚ_]koa]lke]j]e`ae]]jpanekn`]ran`]`a_kik _knnaolkj`j_e]ajpna]oe`ae]oa]o_keo]o*Kqoaf](Lkllan_kjoe`an]mqa]]jpec]jkk`a ran`]`ajkoanral]n]`lkÛoj^oqi]pakne]Íqi]pakne]oai]jpi_kjÚni]`]cn]]o oq]_kanj_e]ejpanj]Í(i]ooanral]n]obcrq^oqi]pakne]*
+ARLß0OPPER߯
.!3!
Bkpkcn]be]`ap]hd]`] `]ejbj_e]`ajkook Qjeranok(mq]j`k aopapejd]]laj]o /4,,,,]jko`a e`]`a(k^pe`]lkn k^oanr]p nek`] J]o]*Aop]ei]cai( `erqhc]`]ai baranaenk`a.,,/( qi]ranok`ap]hd]`] `]lnk`qve`]lahk pahao_ lek?K>A(ai -55.(_kjbeni]j`k] pakne]`k^ec^]jc*
.4.
=_ej_e]j]deop ne]x#!0É45,/ßx
L]n]atlhe_]naoo]`ebanaj]ajpna_kjÚni]k$kqraneÚ_]k%anabqp]k$kqb]hoeÚ_]) k%(Lkllanqo]koacqejpaatailhk6qi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]mqa`eooanmqaÎpk`koko_eojao ok^n]j_koÏjklk`aoanraneÚ_]`]kq_kjÚni]`]lknmqajajdqioandqi]jkf]i]eoreq kqranpk`koko_eojao7pk`]re](^]op]mqa]hcqiraf]qije_k_eojajacnkl]n]nabqp]n $kqb]hoeÚ_]n%aoo]pakne]* Qi]_ej_e]bkniqh]del paoaol]n]naokhranlnk^hai]oa]o_kjoanr]]pmqaoaf]i nabqp]`]okqb]hoeÚ_]`]olkn]hcqib]pk*Aoo]odel paoaookran`]`aolnkreo ne]oi]jpe`]o ]pmqaoaf]i_kjpaop]`]okqjk_kjoec]iatlhe_]njkrkolnk^hai]o* Qi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]^k](`evLkllan(mq]jpki]eo]^anp]aoperan]b]pkojkrkomqa lkoo]ipknj]nb]hokokolnej_lekoako_kj_aepkoaimqaoa^]oa]r]*=ooei(kr]hkn`aqi] pakne]jkoaia`alknoq]ran`]`a(i]olah]lkooe^ehe`]`a`aoanb]ho]*=c^ipb^_fifa^aboane] k_nepnek`a]r]he]k`]opakne]o_eajpÚ_]oac]n]jpene]]e`ae]`alnkcnaook_eajpÚ_k(lkeo ^jbpj^qblof^mqar]eoaj`k_knnece`]lknb]pkojkrkomqa]b]hoeÚ_]i* =i]ekne]`koÚh okbko`]_ej_e](ajpnakomq]eoGqdj(`aikjopnkqk]^oqn`k`]lkoek `aLkllan*@ab]pk(`evaiahao(f]i]eodkqraqije_k_]okaimqaqi]pakne]lq`aooaoan b]hoeÚ_]`]lknb]pko_eajpÚ_kokqf]i]eodkqraqije_k_]okaimqaqib]pkjkrkc]n]j) peooa]_kanj_e]`aqi]pakne](^]op]j`keilkn]ah]iq`]j]opkp]eo* ?]`]ravmqajkrkob]pkolnkrk_]n]iran`]`aen]oacn]j`aoiq`]j]opa ne_]o(aoo]o iq`]j]ojkbkn]ibaep]o_kikk^faperk`aÎiahdkn]nÏkqÎ]lneikn]nÏqi]pakne]ateo) pajpa(i]o_kikk^faperk`a]^]j`kj)h]lknqi]kqpn]*Kl]lah`kb]pk_eajpÚ_kjk k`ab]hoa]nkqb]hoeÚ_]nqi]pakne](i]ok`alnkrk_]nkoqnceiajpk`aqi]jkr]pakne] ran`]`aen]*kran`]`aenkajkkb]hokmqacqe]k_eajpeop](oaf]]ran`]`aajpaj`e`]_kik _knnaolkj`j_e]ajpnae`ae]a_keo](oaf]ajpaj`e`]_kik_kanj_e]ejpanj]`]oe`ae]o*
?h]ooebe_]k`]o_e j_e]o fk`f^(jkoejcqh]n(nabana)oa]qiik`ka]qie`a]h`a_kjda_eiajpkmqaat]iej]) iko]p]mqe*@fk`f^p(jklhqn]h(nabana)oao`ebanajpaoi]jaen]o`ana]hev]k`ke`a]h `a_eajpeÚ_e`]`aoacqj`kko`ebanajpaob]pkoejraopec]`koako`ebanajpaoipk`koa pa_jkhkce]oailnac]`ko* =lneiaen]_h]ooeÚ_]koeopaipe_]`]o_ej_e]o`amqapaikojkp_e]bke]`a=neop pa) hao(mq]hfjkonabaneikojkej_ek`aopahernk*KÚh okbkcnackailnackqpno_nepnekol]n] _h]ooeÚ_]nkoo]^anao6
@
_nepnek`]^rpk`f^lrmobpbk ^a^^ lerj^k^klppbobpfksbpqfd^alp(har]j`k`eo) pejkajpna]o`fk`f^pqbloqf`^p$_kjda_eiajpk`kooanaomqaateopaia]caiej`a) laj`ajpaiajpa`]]kdqi]j]%a]o`fk`f^pmoqf`^p$_kjda_eiajpk`apq`kmq]jpk ateopa_kikabaepk`]o] aodqi]j]o%7 _nepnek`]fjrq^_fifa^ablrmboj^kk`f^ba^jrq^_fifa^ablrjlsfjbkqlalppbobp fksbpqfd^alp(har]j`k`eopejkajpnajbq^cpf`^$aopq`k`kOanajmq]jpkOan(bkn]`a mq]hmqaniq`]j]%(cpf`^lr`fk`f^pa^k^qrobw^$aopq`k`kooanao_kjopepq`kolkn i]pne] a bkni] a oq^iape`ko iq`]j] kq ]k ikreiajpk% a j^qbjqf`^ $aopq`k `kooanao`kp]`ko]laj]o`abkni](oaii]pne](eiqpraeo(i]oateopej`kjkooanao j]pqn]eoa_kjda_e`kolkn]^opn]k%7 _nepnek`]jla^ifa^abmoqf`^(har]j`k`eopejkajpna`fk`f^pnrbbpqra^j^moufp $]]kpe_](lkhpe_]aa_kjie_](mqapaikln lnek]cajpa_kikÚi%a]oq`kf`^p$] b]^ne_]k`ak^fapko]npeÚ_e]eokq]]kmqapai_kikÚi]lnk`qk`aqik^fapk `ebanajpa`k]cajpa%*
.4/
?kilamqaj]or]ne] ao(aoo]_h]ooeÚ_]kbkei]jpe`]]pko_qhkTREE(mq]j`kajpk ko _kjda_eiajpko oa oal]n]n]i ai ÛilpÛ`lp( `fbkqÛ`lp a q`kf`lp* =l o aooa lank`k( ] ÚhkokÚ]paj`a]`ao]l]na_anj]o_h]ooeÚ_] ao_eajpÚ_]o$qio]^an`ebanajpa`k_eajp)
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
Ú_k%(]ooei_kik`ah]o`ao]l]na_ai]op_je_]o*@]oejian]o_h]ooeÚ_] aolnklkop]o(]o i]eo_kjda_e`]oaqpehev]`]obkn]ibaep]olknÚh okbkobn]j_aoaoa]haiao`ko_qhkTET( ^]oa]j`k)oaaipno_nepneko6qfmlabl_gbqlbpqra^al(qfmlabjqlalbjmobd^al(qfmlab obpriq^all_qfal*@aooao_nepnekoa`]oeilheÚ_]kbaep]ok^na]orne]o_h]ooeÚ_] ao]jpa) neknaonaoqhpkq]mqah]mqaoa_kopqi]qo]n]pdkfa6 _ej_e]o i]paipe_]o kq hce_k)i]paipe_]o $]nepipe_]( cakiapne]( hca^n]( pneck) jkiapne](h ce_](boe_]lqn](]opnkjkie]lqn](ap_*%7 _ej_e]oj]pqn]eo$boe_](mqie_](^ekhkce](cakhkce](]opnkjkie](cakcn]Ú]boe_](l]hakj) pkhkce](ap_*%7 _ej_e]odqi]j]okqok_e]eo$loe_khkce](ok_ekhkce](]jpnklkhkce](cakcn]Ú]dqi]j]( a_kjkie](hejcqope_](loe_]jheoa(]nmqakhkce](deop ne](ap_*%7 _ej_e]o]lhe_]`]o$pk`]o]o_ej_e]omqa_kj`qvaiejrajk`apa_jkhkce]ol]n]ej) panrenj]j]pqnav](j]re`]dqi]j]aj]ook_ea`]`ao(_kik(lknatailhk(`enaepk(ajca) jd]ne](ia`e_ej](]nmqepapqn](ejbknipe_](ap_*%* ?]`] qi] `]o _ej_e]o oq^`ere`a)oa ai n]iko aola_Ú_ko( _ki jkr] `aheiep]k `k k^fapka`kipk`k`aejraopec]k*=ooei(lknatailhk(]boe_]oq^`ere`a)oaaiia_ je_]( ]_ope_]( lpe_]( ap_*7 ] ^ekhkce]( ai ^kp je_]( vkkhkce]( Úoekhkce]( cajpe_]( ap_*7 ] loe_khk) ce]oq^`ere`a)oaailoe_khkce]`k_kilknp]iajpk(`k`aoajrkhreiajpk(loe_khkce]_hje_]( loe_khkce]ok_e]h(ap_*(a]ooeioq_aooer]iajpa(l]n]_]`]qi]`]o_ej_e]o*Lknoq]rav(ko ln lnekon]iko`a_]`]_ej_e]oq^`ere`ai)oaai`eo_elhej]o_]`]ravi]eoaola_Ú_]o( ia`e`]mqaoaqok^fapko_kj`qvai]laomqeo]o_]`]ravi]eo`ap]hd]`]oaaola_e]hev]`]o*
#APqTULOß =o_e j_e]odqi]j]o Oklkooraeo_e j_e]odqi]j]o
A
i^kn]oaf]are`ajpamqapk`]amq]hmqan_ej_e]dqi]j](lknmqanaoqhp]`]]pere`]) `adqi]j]`a_kjda_eiajpk(]atlnaookÎ_ej_e]odqi]j]oÏnabana)oamqah]o_ej) _e]omqapikln lnekoandqi]jk_kikk^fapk*=oepq]k`ap]eo_ej_e]oiqepk aola_e]h*Ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqaoaqk^fapk^]op]jpana_ajpa6kdkiai_kikk^fapk _eajpÚ_k qi] e`ae] oqnce`] ]laj]o jk o_qhk TET* =p ajpk( pq`k mq]jpk oa nabane] ]k dqi]jkan]aopq`]`klah]ÚhkokÚ]* Aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqaoqncen]i`alkeomqa]o_ej_e]oi]paipe_]oaj]pqn]eoaop]) r]i_kjopepq`]oafd]re]i`aÚje`k]e`ae]`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`a(`aipk`koa_kjda_eiajpko _eajpÚ_ko(`aik`kmqa]o_ej_e]odqi]j]obkn]ihar]`]o]eiep]na_kle]nkmqa]mqah]o _ej_e]od]re]iaop]^aha_e`k(pn]p]j`kkdkiai_kikqi]_keo]j]pqn]hi]pai]pevraha atlaneiajprah*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(l]n]c]jd]nnaolaep]^ehe`]`a_eajpÚ_](]o`eo_elhej]o _kjda_e`]o_kik_ej_e]odqi]j]olnk_qn]n]iaopq`]noaqk^fapkailnac]j`k_kj_aepko( ipk`koap_je_]olnklkopkolah]o_ej_e]o`]j]pqnav]*
.40
=o_ej_e]odqi]j]ox#!0É45,/ßx
Aipan_aenkhqc]n(lknpanaioqnce`kjklank`kaimqalnar]ha_e]]_kj_alkaileneo) p]a`apaniejeop]`]_ej_e](p]i^ilnk_qn]n]ipn]p]nkk^fapkdqi]jkqo]j`kkoik`ahko delkppe_k)ej`qperkoaatlaneiajp]eo`aaopehkaileneop](a^qo_]r]ihaeo_]qo]eoja_aoone]o aqjerano]eol]n]kobajiajkodqi]jko*?kik(ajpnap]jpk(jkan]lkoorahna]hev]nqi] pn]jolkoekejpacn]halanbaep]`koipk`ko(`]op_je_]oa`]opakne]oj]pqn]eol]n]koao) pq`ko`kob]pkodqi]jko(]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o]_]^]n]ipn]^]hd]j`klkn^k^ildf^_ki]o _ej_e]oj]pqn]eoaoaqonaoqhp]`kopknj]n]i)oaiqepk_kjpaopraeoalkq_k_eajpÚ_ko* Aoo]oepq]kharkqiqepko_eajpeop]oaÚh okbko]`qre`]n`]lkooe^ehe`]`a`a_ej_e]o mqaperaooaikdkiai_kikk^fapk*Mq]eo]olnej_el]eok^fa aobaep]olkooe^ehe`]`a`]o _ej_e]odqi]j]o; =_ej_e]he`]_kib]pkok^oanrraeo(eopk(_kioanaoa]_kjpa_eiajpkomqa(j]o_kj) `e aoaola_e]eo`ah]^kn]p nek(okk^fapko`aatlaneiajp]k*?kikk^oanr]n)atlane) iajp]n(lknatailhk(]_kjo_ej_e]dqi]j]ej`ere`q]h(mqaoane]kk^fapk`]loe_khkce]; Kqqi]ok_ea`]`a(k^fapk`]ok_ekhkce];Kqqi]lk_]l]oo]`](k^fapk`]deop ne]; =_ej_e]^qo_]]ohaeok^faper]ocan]eo(qjerano]eoaja_aoone]o`kob]pko*?kikaop]^a) ha_anhaeok^faper]ol]n]kmqaaooaj_e]hiajpaoq^faperk(_kikkloemqeoikdqi]jk; ?kikaop]^aha_anhaeoqjerano]eol]n]]hckmqal]npe_qh]n(_kikk_]ok`aqi]ok) _ea`]`adqi]j];?kikaop]^aha_anhaeoja_aoone]ol]n]kmqa]_kjpa_aqi]je_]rav( _kikk_]ok`kb]pkdeop ne_k; =_ej_e]klan]lkn]jheoa$`a_kilkoek`aqib]pk_kilhatkaiahaiajpkooei) lhao%aojpaoa$na_kilkoek`kb]pk_kilhatklknoahak`koahaiajpkooeilhao(`eo) pejcqej`kkoaooaj_e]eo`ko]_e`ajp]eo%*?kik]j]heo]naoejpapev]nkloemqeoikdqi]) jk(qi]ok_ea`]`a(qi]_kjpa_eiajpkdeop ne_k; =_ej_e]he`]_kib]pkonace`kolah]ja_aooe`]`a_]qo]hkqlahklnej_lek`k`apanie) jeoikqjerano]h*Kdkiai`kp]`k`an]vk(rkjp]`aahe^an`]`a(_]l]v`a_ne]nÚjo ar]hknao(`aao_khdanajpnarne]okl aolkooraeo*?kik`]nqi]atlhe_]k_eajpÚ_] ja_aoone]mqehkmqa(lknaooj_e](_kjpejcajpa(lkeohernaa]calknhe^an`]`a; =_ej_e]he`]_kib]pkok^faperko(eopk(_kikobajiajko`alkeomqabkn]ilqneÚ_]) `ko`apk`kokoahaiajpkooq^faperko(`apk`]o]omq]he`]`aooajoraeo(`apk`]o]okle) je aoapk`kokooajpeiajpko(`apk`koko`]`ko]baperkoar]hkn]perko*Kn](kdqi]jk fqop]iajpakoq^faperk(koajorah(k]baperk(kr]hkn]perk(kklej]perk*?kikpn]jobkn) i)hkaik^fapere`]`aoai`aopnqenoq]lnej_el]h_]n]_panope_](]oq^fapere`]`a;
Kdqi]jk_kikk^fapk`aejraopec]k
A
i^kn]]o_ej_e]odqi]j]ooaf]ina_ajpao(]lan_alk`amqakooanaodqi]jkook `ebanajpao`]o_keo]oj]pqn]eo]jpec]*@aooalkjpk`areop]lk`aiko`evanmqa(`ko) _qhkTR]kej_ek`ko_qhkTT(]ejraopec]k`kdqi]jkna]hevkq)oa`apnoi]jaen]o `ebanajpao6 -*
.41
Lank`k`kdqi]jeoik6eje_e])oajko_qhkTR_ki]e`ae]naj]o_ajpeop]`]afdkfa^ab aleljbj_kik_ajpnk`kQjeranok(lnkooacqajkoo_qhkoTREaTREE_kikaopq`k `kdkiai_kik^dbkqbjlo^i(lkhpe_kap_je_k)]npope_k(`aopej]`k]`kiej]na_kj) pnkh]n]j]pqnav]a]ok_ea`]`a(_dac]j`k]ko_qhkTREEEmq]j`koqnca]e`ae]`a`fsfif* w^ l(eopk(`kdkiai_kikn]vkmqaoa]lanbaek]alnkcne`apailkn]hiajpalkn iaek`]oejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]oa`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]o]npao(`]op_je_]oa `kokb_eko*Kdqi]jeoikjkoal]n]dkiaiaj]pqnav](i]o_kjoe`an]kdkiaiqi oanj]pqn]h`ebanajpa`ko`ai]eo(i]jebaop]j`kaoo]`ebanaj]_kikoann]_ekj]haherna( ]cajpape_k(lkhpe_k(p_je_ka]npope_k*
Kb]pkdqi]jkdeop ne_kkqpailkn]h6oqncajkpailkaoapn]jobkni]jkpailk*Ai _]`]lk_]deop ne_](kob]pkolomqe_ko(ok_e]eo(lkhpe_ko(nahecekoko(a_kjie_ko(p_je_koa ]npope_kolkooqai]oiaoi]o_]qo]ocan]eo(kiaoikoajpe`kaoacqaikoiaoikor]hknao( `araj`koan_kilnaaj`e`ko(oeiqhp]ja]iajpa(_kikl]npe_qh]ne`]`aodeop ne_]okqÎreo ao `aiqj`kÏaola_Ú_]okq]qpjki]oa_kikap]l]okqb]oao`k`aoajrkhreiajpkcan]h`] dqi]je`]`a(eopk(`aqilnk_aook_]qo]hqjerano]h(mqaklnkcnaook* Kdeopkne_eoiknaoqhpkqai`keolnk^hai]omqajklq`an]ioannaokhre`kolknoaqo ]`alpko6kobi^qfsfpjl$jqi]lk_]aimqa]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o^qo_]r]i]qjerano]he`]`a `aoaqo_kj_aepkoaipk`ko%a]pr_loafk^ l^rj^ÛilplÛ^a^efpqof^$jqi]lk_]ai mqa]o_ej_e]odqi]j]olnapaj`e]ioal]n]n)oa`]ÚhkokÚ]%* Obi^qfsfpjl7]ohaeo_eajpÚ_]ookrhe`]o]laj]ol]n]qi]`apaniej]`]lk_]a_qhpq) n](jklk`aj`koanqjerano]hev]`]o*CfilplÛ^a^efpqof^6koej`er`qkodqi]jkoa]oejope) pqe aook_ek_qhpqn]eoo ok_kilnaajoraeooaoaqaopq`k_eajpÚ_koq^kn`ej]n)oa]qi] pakne]can]h`]deop ne]mqa_kjoe`ana_]`]bkni]kok_ek_qhpqn]h(oaf]_kikÎreok`aiqj) `kÏl]npe_qh]n(oaf]_kikap]l]`aqilnk_aookdeop ne_kqjerano]h* L]n]ao_]l]n`aoo]o_kjoamqj_e]o(kok_e hkck]haikI]tSa^anlnklomqa]o_ej) _e]odqi]j]oÍjk_]ok(]ok_ekhkce]a]a_kjkie]Ípn]^]hd]ooaioaqok^fapko_kikqfmlp fab^fpajk_kikb]pkoailne_ko*Kpelke`a]h(_kikkjkiaej`e_](kbana_a_kjopnq ao _kj_aepq]eolqn]o(mqalaniepai_kilnaaj`anaejpanlnap]nb]pkol]npe_qh]naok^oanrraeo* =ooei(lknatailhk(kAop]`koa]lnaoajp]_kikqi]bkni]`a`kiej]kok_e]halkhpe_] ok^rnekopelkoe`a]eo$`kiej]k_]neoipe_](`kiej]klaook]h^qnk_npe_](ap_*%(_]^aj) `k]k_eajpeop]raneÚ_]nok^mq]hpelkaj_kjpn])oak_]okl]npe_qh]nejraopec]`k*
!LBUMAKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
&ICHTE߯ ßFILvSOFOß IDEALISTAßALEMjO
!LBUMAKG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
/* Lank`k`kdeopkne_eoik6`aoajrkhre`kjkÚj]h`ko_qhkTETaej_ek`ko_qhkTTlkn @ehpdau( Úh okbk a deopkne]`kn ]haik* Aoo] _kj_alk( dan`aen] `k e`a]heoik ]haik $G]jp(Be_dpa(O_dahhejc(Dacah%(ejoeopaj]`ebanaj]lnkbqj`]ajpnadkiaiaj]pqnav] aajpna_ej_e]oj]pqn]eoadqi]j]o(_d]i]`]olkn@ehpdau`aÎ_ej_e]o`kaolnepkkq `]_qhpqn]Ï*Kob]pkodqi]jkookdeop ne_ko(`kp]`ko`ar]hkna`aoajpe`k(`aoecjeÚ) _]kaÚj]he`]`aa`araioanaopq`]`ko_kiaoo]o_]n]_panope_]omqako`eopejcqai `kob]pkoj]pqn]eo*=o_ej_e]o`kaolnepkkq`]_qhpqn]jklk`aiajk`araiqo]n kipk`k`]k^oanr]k)atlaneiajp]k(i]o`arai_ne]nkipk`k`]atlhe_]ka _kilnaajok`kpbkqfal`kob]pkodqi]jko(aj_kjpn]j`k]_]qo]he`]`adeop ne_]mqa kockranj]*
%MILEß$URKHEIMßß ¯ ßSOCIvLOGOß FRANCoS
3CHELLING߯ ßß FILvSOFOßALEMjO
#OURTESYß%VERETTß#OLLECTIONß ,ATINSTOCK
.* Lank`k`klkoepereoik6eje_e])oajko_qhkTET_ki=qcqopk?kipa(l]n]mqai]dq) i]je`]`a]pn]raoo]pnoap]l]olnkcnaooer]o(ej`k`]oqlanopeknaheceko]iap]boe_] apakhkce]l]n]_dac]nÚj]hiajpa_ej_e]lkoeper](lkjpkÚj]h`klnkcnaookdqi]jk* ?kipaajb]pev]]e`ae]`kdkiai_kikqioanok_e]halnkl akaopq`k_eajpÚ_k`] ok_ea`]`a6 ]ooei _kik d qi] boe_] `] j]pqnav]( `ara d]ran qi] boe_] `k ok_e]h( ] pl`flildf^(mqa`araaopq`]nkob]pkodqi]jkoqo]j`klnk_a`eiajpko(ipk`koap_) je_]oailnac]`kolah]o_ej_e]o`]j]pqnav]* = _kj_alk lkoepereop] jk paniej] jk o_qhk TET _ki ?kipa( i]o oan qi] `]o_knnajpaoi]eolk`anko]oaejÛqajpaoj]o_ej_e]odqi]j]oaipk`kko_qhkTT* =ooei(lknatailhk(]loe_khkce]lkoepereop]]Úni]mqaoaqk^fapkjkkloemqeoik _kik_kjo_ej_e](i]o_kik`ljmloq^jbkqll_pbossbimqalk`aoanpn]p]`k_kik ipk`katlaneiajp]h`]o_ej_e]oj]pqn]eo*=ok_ekhkce]lkoepereop]$eje_e]`]lkn?kipa a`aoajrkhre`]_kik_ej_e]lahkbn]j_oAieha@qngdaei%aopq`]]ok_ea`]`a_kik b]pk]Úni]j`kmqakb]pkok_e]h`araoanpn]p]`k_kikqi]`lfp^mq]hok]lhe_]`ko kolnk_a`eiajpko`a]jheoaaojpaoa_ne]`kolah]o_ej_e]oj]pqn]eo*Koahaiajpkokq pkikook_e]eookkoej`er`qko(k^pe`kolknre]`]]jheoa7]onah] ao_]qo]eoajpnako ej`er`qko(na_kilkop]olknre]`]ojpaoa(_kjopepqai]oejopepqe aook_e]eo$b]ihe]( pn]^]hdk(nahecek(Aop]`k(ap_*%*
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
-AXß7EBER߯ ß SOCIvLOGOßEßFILvSOFOßß ALEMjO
.42
2OBERTß#APA#ORNELLß#APA-AGNUM,ATINSTOCK
=o_ej_e]odqi]j]ox#!0É45,/ßx
C]nkp]bkpkcn]b]`]lknNk^anp ?]l]ai>]n_ahkj](`qn]jpa] Cqann]?erehAol]jdkh](ai-5/5* Kob]pkodqi]jkookdeop ne_ko( `kp]`ko`ar]hkna`aoajpe`k( `aoecjebe_]kabej]he`]`aa `araioanaopq`]`ko_kiaoo]o _]n]_panope_]omqako`eopejcqai `kob]pkoj]pqn]eo*
Bajkiajkhkce](aopnqpqn]heoikai]nteoik
=
_kjopepqek`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o_kik_ej_e]oaola_Ú_]o_kjokhe`kq)oa]l]npen `]o_kjpne^qe ao`apno_knnajpao`alajo]iajpk(mqa(ajpnako]jko.,a1,`k o_qhkTT(lnkrk_]n]iqi]nqlpqn]aleopaikh ce_]aqi]narkhqk_eajpÚ_]jk _]ilk`]odqi]je`]`ao*
=_kjpne^qek`]bajkiajkhkce]
.43
?kikreikoairnekoikiajpko`aopahernk(]bajkiajkhkce]ejpnk`qveq]jkk`a aooj_e]kqoecjeÚ_]k_kikqi_kj_aepkmqalaniepa`ebanaj_e]nejpanj]iajpaqi]na]) he`]`a`akqpn]o(aj_kjpn]j`koaqoajpe`k(oq]bkni](oq]olnklnea`]`aoaoq]knecai* @aoo]i]jaen](]bajkiajkhkce]_kiakqlknlaniepenmqabkooabaep]]`ebanaj]neck) nko]ajpna]aoban]kqnacek`]aooj_e]Îj]pqnav]Ïa]aoban]kqnacek`]aooj_e]ÎdkiaiÏ* =oacqen(laniepeqmqa]aoban]kqnacekÎdkiaiÏbkooaejpanj]iajpa`ebanaj_e]`]aiao) oj_e]o`erano]o6klomqe_k(kok_e]h(kdeop ne_k(k_qhpqn]h*?kiaoo]`ebanaj_e]k(c]n]jpe] o_ej_e]odqi]j]o]r]he`]`a`aoaqolnkfapkoa_]ilko_eajpÚ_ko`aejraopec]k6loe_k) hkce](ok_ekhkce](deop ne](]jpnklkhkce](hejcqope_](a_kjkie]* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna]lanola_per]lkoepereop]a]bajkiajkh ce_];@keoatailhkolk) `ai]fq`]n)jko]_kilnaaj`)h]* Na_qo]j`k]lanola_per]iap]boe_](mqaoanabane]]klomqe_kaipaniko`a]hi]a`a ejpanekne`]`a(]loe_khkce]rkhp])oal]n]kaopq`k`kob]pkolomqe_ko`enap]iajpak^oanr) raeo*=kn]`e_]hev]naoo]_kj_alk(]loe_khkce]lkoepereop]b]ve]`kloemqeoikqi]oki]`a ahaiajpkoboe_k)mqie_ko(]j]pie_koaÚoekh ce_ko(`aoknpamqajkd]re](lnklne]iajpa b]h]j`k(qik^fapk_eajpÚ_k`ajkiej]`kÎklomqe_kÏ(i]oabaepkolomqe_ko`a_]qo]ojk lomqe_]o $boe_]o( mqie_]o( Úoekh ce_]o( ]j]pie_]o%* Lkn eook( ] loe_khkce] _kjoe`an]r])oa qi]_ej_e]j]pqn]hln tei]`]^ekhkce](paj`k_kikk^fapkk_kilknp]iajpk_kikqi b]pkatpanjk(k^oanrrahaatlaneiajp]h* =k_kjpnnek(]loe_khkce]_kik_ej_e]dqi]j]`kloemqeoikpknjkq)oalkoorah]l]n) pen `k ikiajpk ai mqa qi _kjfqjpk `a b]pko ejpanjko a atpanjko hec]`ko _kjo_ej_e] $oajo]k(lan_alk(ikpne_e`]`a(hejcq]cai(ap_*%lq`an]ioan`aÚje`ko_kik`kp]`ko`a oecjeÚ_]kk^faper]ln lne]* Na_qo]j`k]lanola_per]`]ÚhkokÚ]`]deop ne](mqa_kjoe`an]r]]ook_ea`]`ao_kik ap]l]o _qhpqn]eo a _erehev]p ne]o `a qi lnk_aook deop ne_k qjerano]h( ] ok_ekhkce] rkhp])oa
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
l]n]kaopq`k`kob]pkook_e]eok^oanrraeo*Ejolen]j`k)oaj]o_ej_e]oj]pqn]eo(]ok_ekhkce] lkoepereop]b]ve]`]ok_ea`]`aqi]oki]`a] aoej`ere`q]eoapki]r]kej`er`qk_kik ahaiajpkk^oanrraha_]qo]`kok_e]h(`aoknpamqajkd]re]]ok_ea`]`a_kikqik^fapk kqqi]na]he`]`alnklne]iajpa`ep](i]oqiabaepk`a] aoloe_kh ce_]o`koej`er`qko* Okiajpa]`aÚjek`kok_e]h_kik]hckaooaj_e]hiajpa`ebanajpa`klomqe_kÍa_kik jkoaj`k]ian]oki]`a] aoej`ere`q]eoÍlaniepeqkoqnceiajpk`]ok_ekhkce]_kik _ej_e]lnklne]iajpa`ep]* Ainaoqik(]jpao`]bajkiajkhkce](_]`]qi]`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o`aob]ve]oaqk^) fapkjqi]cnac]`k`aahaiajpko`aj]pqnav]`erano]`kpk`k(aopq`]r]]onah] ao_]qo]eo atpanj]oajpnaaooaoahaiajpkoa]o]lnaoajp]r]_kikatlhe_]kahae`aoaqk^fapk`aej) raopec]k*=bajkiajkhkce]c]n]jpeqo_ej_e]odqi]j]o]ateopj_e]a]aola_eÚ_e`]`a`a oaqok^fapko*
=_kjpne^qek`kaopnqpqn]heoik Kaopnqpqn]heoiklaniepeqmqa]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o_ne]ooaiipk`koaola_Ú_kol]n] kaopq`k`aoaqok^fapko(hern]j`k)]o`]oatlhe_] aoia_ je_]o`a_]qo]aabaepkoaimqa lkneookperaooai`a]^]j`kj]n]e`ae]`ahae_eajpÚ_]* =_kj_alkaopnqpqn]heop]raekikopn]nmqakob]pkodqi]jko]ooqiai]bkni]`a aopnqpqn]o(eopk(`aoeopai]omqa_ne]ioaqoln lnekoahaiajpko`]j`k]ahaooajpe`klah] lkoekalah]bqjkmqak_ql]ijkpk`k*=oaopnqpqn]ookpkp]he`]`aoknc]jev]`]ooa) cqj`klnej_lekoejpanjkomqahdaookln lnekoamqa_ki]j`]ioaqoahaiajpkokql]npao( oaqik`k`abqj_ekj]iajpkaoq]olkooe^ehe`]`ao`apn]jobkni]kpailkn]hkqdeop ne_]* Jah]o(kpk`kjk]oki]`]ol]npaojaiqi_kjfqjpk`anah] ao_]qo]eoajpnaahaiajpko eokhraeo(i]oqilnej_lekkn`aj]`kn(`ebanaj_e]`knapn]jobkni]`kn*Qi]aopnqpqn]qi] pkp]he`]`a`kp]`]`aoajpe`k* Freiko]jkk`aaopnqpqn]mq]j`k(jko_]lpqhko`a`e_]`kopakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk( jkonabaneikopakne]`]lan_alk(bkniqh]`]lah]loe_khkce]`]dbpq^iqkq`]bkni](^ai _kikmq]j`kjkonabaneikopakne]`]hejcq]cai(ah]^kn]`]lah]hejcqope_]_kjpailkn ja]* =l o]loe_khkce]a]hejcqope_](]lneiaen]`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o]oapn]jobkni]nlnk) bqj`]iajpa(cn]]oe`ae]`aaopnqpqn]a]kipk`kaopnqpqn]h(bke]]jpnklkhkce]ok_e]h* Aop]l`aikopn]nmqa(]k_kjpnnek`kmqalajo]r]]]jpnklkhkce]lkoepereop](]o_d]i]`]o Îok_ea`]`aolneieper]oÏjkan]iqi]ap]l]]pn]o]`]`]arkhqk`]deop ne]ok_e]h`]dq) i]je`]`a(i]oqi]bkni]k^faper]`aknc]jev]n]onah] aook_e]eo`aik`k`ebanajpa`k jkook(_kjopepqej`kaopnqpqn]o_qhpqn]eo* K ]jpnkl hkck ?h]q`a Hre)Opn]qoo( lkn atailhk( ikopnkq mqa ]o aopnqpqn]o `aoo]o ok_ea`]`aook^]oa]`]ojklnej_lek`kr]hknkq`]amqer]hj_e](mqalaniepa]pnk_]a] _en_qh]k`a_anpkooanao`ai]jaen]]_kjopepqenkpk`k`]ok_ea`]`a(knc]jev]j`kpk`]o]o nah] aook_e]eo6]pnk_]kq_en_qh]k`]oiqhdanao$aopnqpqn]`kl]najpao_k_kikoeopai] ok_e]h`a]he]j]o%(]pnk_]kq_en_qh]k`ak^fapkoaola_e]eo$aopnqpqn]`k`ki_kikoeopa) i]ok_e]h`]cqann]a`]l]v%a]pnk_]a_en_qh]k`]l]h]rn]$aopnqpqn]`]hejcq]cai_kik oeopai]`klk`annahecekokalkhpe_k%*Kik`k_kik_]`]qi`aooaooeopai]okqaopnqpqn]o l]n_e]eooaknc]jev]aoanah]_ekj]_kikokqpnko`aÚja]aopnqpqn]can]haaola_Ú_]`aqi] ok_ea`]`aÎlneieper]Ï(mqalk`a(]ooei(oan_kilnaaj`e`]aatlhe_]`]_eajpeÚ_]iajpa*
=_kjpne^qek`ki]nteoik Ki]nteoiklaniepeq_kilnaaj`anmqakob]pkodqi]jkookejopepqe aook_e]eoadeo) p ne_]olnk`qve`]ojklahkaolnepkalah]rkjp]`aherna`koej`er`qko(i]olah]o_kj`e ao k^faper]oj]omq]eo]]kaklajo]iajpkdqi]jko`araina]hev]n)oa*Harkq]_kilnaaj) `anmqakob]pkodqi]jkoi]eoknecejnekokqlneinekook]onah] ao`kodkiajo_ki] j]pqnav]j]hqp]lah]ok^narerj_e]amqap]eonah] aook]o`apn]^]hdk(`]j`kknecaio lneiaen]oejopepqe aook_e]eo6b]ihe]$`ereokoatq]h`kpn]^]hdk%(l]opknaeka]cne_qhpqn] $`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk%(pnk_]a_kin_ek$`eopne^qekok_e]h`kolnk`qpko`kpn]^]hdk%*
.44
=o_ej_e]odqi]j]ox#!0É45,/ßx
=ooei(]olneiaen]oejopepqe aook_e]eookb`lkjf`^p*L]n]i]jp)h]o(kcnqlkok_e]h _ne]e`ae]oaoajpeiajpko(r]hknaoaoi^khko]_aepkolknpk`koamqafqopeÚ_]ikqhacepei]i ]oejopepqe ao]ooei_ne]`]o*P]i^il]n]_kjoanr)h]o(kcnqlkok_e]h_ne]ejopepqe ao`a lk`anmqaoqopajpai$lah]bkn](lah]o]ni]okqlah]ohaeo%]onah] aook_e]eoa]oe`ae]o)r]) hknao)oi^khkolnk`qve`ko* @aoo] i]jaen]( k i]nteoik laniepeq o _ej_e]o dqi]j]o _kilnaaj`an ]o ]npe_qh]) aoja_aoone]oajpnaklh]jkloe_kh ce_kakok_e]h`]ateopj_e]dqi]j]7ajpnaklh]jk a_kjie_kak`]oejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o7ajpnapk`]oah]oak_kjfqjpk`ae`ae]oa`a lnpe_]omqaqi]ok_ea`]`alnk`qv* Cn]]o ]k i]nteoik ]o _ej_e]o dqi]j]o lq`an]i _kilnaaj`an mqa ]o iq`]j]o deop ne_]ojknaoqhp]i`a] aoo^ep]oaaolap]_qh]nao`a]hcqjoej`er`qkokqcnqlko`a ej`er`qko(i]o`ahajpkolnk_aookook_e]eo(a_kjie_koalkhpe_ko^]oa]`koj]bkni]]ooq) ie`]lah]lnklnea`]`a`koiaeko`alnk`qkalah]onah] ao`apn]^]hdk*=i]pane]he`]`a `]ateopj_e]a_kjie_]_ki]j`]]okqpn]oaoban]o`]re`]ok_e]ha`]aolenepq]he`]`aako lnk_aookodeop ne_ko]^n]jcaipk`]oah]o* AjÚi(ki]nteoikpnkqta_kikcn]j`a_kjpne^qekok_ekhkce](_ej_e]lkhpe_]a deop ne]]ejpanlnap]k`kobajiajkodqi]jko_kikatlnaookanaoqhp]`k`a_kjpn]) `e ao ok_e]eo( `a hqp]o a _kjÛepko ok_eklkhpe_ko `apaniej]`ko lah]o nah] ao a_kjie_]o ^]oa]`]oj]atlhkn]k`kpn]^]hdk`]i]ekne]lah]iejkne]`aqi]ok_ea`]`a* Ainaoqik(]bajkiajkhkce]laniepeq]`aÚjeka]`aheiep]k`kok^fapko`]o_ej) _e]odqi]j]o7kaopnqpqn]heoiklaniepeqqi]iapk`khkce]mqa_dac]ohaeo`kob]pkodq) i]jkooaimqaoaf]ja_aoonekeiep]nkq_kle]nkolnk_a`eiajpko`]o_ej_e]oj]pqn]eo7k i]nteoiklaniepeq_kilnaaj`anmqakob]pkodqi]jkookdeopkne_]iajpa`apaniej]`ko amqa]deopkne_e`]`a(hkjca`aeila`enmqaoaf]i_kjda_e`ko(c]n]jpa]ejpanlnap]kn]_ek) j]h`ahaoak_kjda_eiajpk`aoq]ohaeo* ?kiaoo]o_kjpne^qe ao(mqabkn]iej_knlkn]`]o`ai]jaen]oiqepk`ebanaj_e]`]ola) h]orne]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o(kok^op_qhkoaleopaikh ce_kobkn]iqhpn]l]oo]`koabkelkoo) rah`aikjopn]nmqakobajiajkodqi]jkook`kp]`ko`aoajpe`kaoecjeÚ_]k(okdeo) p ne_ko(lkooqaihaeoln lne]o(ok`ebanajpao`kobajiajkoj]pqn]eoalk`aioanpn]p]`ko _eajpeÚ_]iajpa*
Ko_]ilko`aaopq`k`]o_e j_e]odqi]j]o
O
apki]niko]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o`a]_kn`k_kioaqo_]ilko`aejraopec]k(lk`a) iko`eopne^q)h]o`]oacqejpai]jaen]6
Loe_khkce] aopq`k`]oaopnqpqn]o(`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]oklan] ao`]iajpadqi]j]$_kjo_ej) _e](rkjp]`a(lan_alk(hejcq]cai(iai ne](ei]cej]k(aik ao%7 aopq`k`]oaopnqpqn]oa`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`ko_kilknp]iajpkodqi]jkoa]jei]eo7 aopq`k`]onah] aoejpanoq^faper]o`koej`er`qkoaicnqlkaaiok_ea`]`a7 aopq`k`]olanpqn^] ao$l]pkhkce]o%`]iajpadqi]j]a`ko_kilknp]iajpkodqi]) jkoa]jei]eo*
Ok_ekhkce] aopq`k`]oaopnqpqn]ook_e]eo6knecaiabkni]`]ook_ea`]`ao(pelko`aknc]jev] aook) _e]eo(a_kjie_]oalkhpe_]o7 aopq`k`]onah] aook_e]eoa`aoq]opn]jobkni] ao7
.45
aopq`k`]oejopepqe aook_e]eo$knecai(bkni](oajpe`k%*
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
A_kjkie] aopq`k`]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo$j]pqn]eoaok_e]eo%`alnk`qkanalnk`qk`]nemqa) v](`aoq]obkni]o`a`eopne^qek(_en_qh]ka_kjoqik7 aopq`k`]oaopnqpqn]olnk`qper]oÍnah] ao`alnk`qkabkn]olnk`qper]oÍoacqj) `kk_nepnek`]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk(`]bkni]`]lnklnea`]`a(`]onacn]o`kian) _]`ka`ko_e_hkoa_kjie_ko7 aopq`k`]knecai(`k`aoajrkhreiajpk(`]o_neoao(`]opn]jobkni] aoa`]nalnk`qk `]obkni]oa_kjie_]okqik`ko`alnk`qk*
=jpnklkhkce] aopq`k`]oaopnqpqn]okqbkni]o_qhpqn]eoaioq]oejcqh]ne`]`akql]npe_qh]ne`]`a(eopk (_kik`ebanajpaoajpnaoelknoaqolnej_lekoejpanjko`abqj_ekj]iajpkapn]jobkn) i]k*=_qhpqn]ajpaj`e`]_kikik`k`are`]chk^]h`aqi]ok_ea`]`a(ej_hqej`k nahecek(bkni]o`alk`an(bkni]o`al]najpao_k(bkni]o`a_kiqje_]k(knc]jev]k `]re`]a_kjie_](]npao(p_je_]o(_kopqiao(_naj]o(bkni]o`alajo]iajpka`a_ki) lknp]iajpk(ap_*7 aopq`k`]o_kiqje`]`ao`ep]oÎlneieper]oÏ(eopk(p]jpk`]omqa`ao_kjda_ai]`ereok ok_e]h ai _h]ooao a na_qo]i knc]jev]n)oa ok^ ] bkni] `k ian_]`k a `k lk`an aop]p]h mq]jpk`]mqah]omqafeje_e]n]iklnk_aook`a`ereokok_e]halkhpe_]*
Deopne] aopq`k`]cjaoaa`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]obkni] aook_e]eoaioaqo]ola_pkoa_kj) ie_ko(ok_e]eo(lkhpe_koa_qhpqn]eo7 aopq`k`]opn]jobkni] ao`]ook_ea`]`aoa_kiqje`]`ao_kiknaoqhp]`kaatlnaook `a_kjÛepko(hqp]oa_kjpn]`e aoejpanj]oobkni] aook_e]eo7 aopq`k`]opn]jobkni] ao`]ook_ea`]`aoa_kiqje`]`aook^keil]_pk`a]_kjpa_e) iajpkolkhpe_ko$narkhq ao(cqann]o_ereo(_kjmqeop]opannepkne]eo%(a_kjie_ko$_neoao( ejkr] ao p_je_]o( `ao_k^anp]o `a jkr]o bkni]o `a atlhkn]k `] nemqav] kq lnk_a) `eiajpko`alnk`qk(iq`]j]oj]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk%(ok_e]eo$ikreiajpko ok_e]eo( ikreiajpko lklqh]nao( iq`]j]o j] aopnqpqn] a knc]jev]k `] b]ihe]( `] a`q_]k(`]ikn]he`]`aok_e]h(ap_*%a_qhpqn]eo$iq`]j]o_eajpÚ_]o(pa_jkh ce_]o(]n) pope_]o(Úhko Ú_]o(pe_]o(naheceko]o(ap_*%7 aopq`k`ko]_kjpa_eiajpkomqa(ai_]`]_]ok(`apaniej]n]ikq`apaniej]i]lnaoan) r]kkq]iq`]j]`aqi]bkni]kok_e]haioaqo]ola_pkoa_kjie_ko(lkhpe_ko( ok_e]eoa_qhpqn]eo7 aopq`k`ko`ebanajpaooqlknpao`]iai ne]_khaper]$`k_qiajpko(ikjqiajpko(lej) pqn]o(bkpkcn]Ú]o(Úhiao(ika`]o(hle`aobqjanne]o(paopaiqjdkoanah]pkokn]eoaao) _nepko(ap_*%*
Hejcqope_] aopq`k `]o aopnqpqn]o `] hejcq]cai _kik oeopai] `kp]`k `a lnej_leko ejpanjko `a bqj_ekj]iajpkapn]jobkni]k7 aopq`k`]onah] aoajpnahjcq]$]aopnqpqn]%ab]h]kql]h]rn]$kqok`]hjcq]lahko b]h]jpao%7 aopq`k `]o nah] ao ajpna ] hejcq]cai a ko kqpnko oeopai]o `a oecjko a oi^khko kq kqpnkooeopai]o`a_kiqje_]k*
.5,
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]hx#!0É45,/ßx
Loe_]jheoa aopq`k`]aopnqpqn]a`kbqj_ekj]iajpk`kej_kjo_eajpaa`aoq]onah] ao_kik_kjo) _eajpa7 aopq`k `]o l]pkhkce]o kq lanpqn^] ao ej_kjo_eajpao a oq]o atlnaoo ao _kjo_eajpao $jaqnkoaoaloe_koao%* @araikok^oanr]nmqa6
ETNOGRAFIAßMmTODOßUTI LIZADOßPELAßANTROPOLOGIAß NOßESTUDOßDESCRITIVOßDASß DIVERSASßETNIAS ßDEßSUASß CARACTERqSTICASßANTROPOLv GICAS ßSOCIAIS ßETCß0ODE SEß DIZERßQUEßASßANOTAlzESß DETALHADASßDAßOBSERVAljOß DOßPESQUISADORßCONSTI TUEMßAßETNOGRAFIA ETNOLOGIAßNAßANTROPOLO GIA ßCIoNCIAßQUEßESTUDAßß OSßFATOSßEßDOCUMENTOSßß LEVANTADOSßPELAßETNOGRAFIA
_]`]qi]`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]ooq^`ere`a)oaairnekon]iko(`aÚje`kolah]aola_e) Ú_e`]`a_nao_ajpa`aoaqok^fapkoaipk`ko*=ooei(lk`aikob]h]nailoe_khkce]ok) _e]h(_hje_](`k`aoajrkhreiajpk(`]]lnaj`ev]cai(`]_ne]j](`k]`khao_ajpa(ap_*Kq ai ok_ekhkce] lkhpe_]( `k pn]^]hdk( nqn]h( qn^]j]( a_kjie_]( ap_* P]i^i lk`aiko b]h]naideop ne]a_kjie_](lkhpe_](kn]h(ok_e]h(ap_*Kqhar]nai_kjoe`an]kmqa] ]jpnklkhkce]`alaj`a`aejraopec] aobaep]olah]apjkcn]Ú]alah]apjkhkce]kqlah] ]nmqakhkce](]ooei_kik]hejcqope_]pn]^]hd]_ki]bkjkhkce](]bkjpe_](]cn]ipe_]( ]oai jpe_](]oejp]ta(ap_*7 ai^kn]_ki_]ilkoaipk`koaola_Ú_ko(]o_ej_e]odqi]j]opaj`ai]]lnaoajp]n naoqhp]`koi]eo_kilhapkoao]peob]p nekomq]j`kpn]^]hd]iejpan`eo_elhej]niajpa( `aik`k]]^n]jcankoihpelhko]ola_pkooeiqhp jakoaoq_aooerko`kobajiajko aopq`]`ko7 ko`aoajrkhreiajpko`]hejcqope_](`]]jpnklkhkce]a`]loe_]jheoaoqo_ep]n]ik]l]) na_eiajpk`aqi]jkr]`eo_elhej]kqejpan`eo_elhej]_eajpÚ_]6]oaiekhkce](mqaaopq) `]ko`ebanajpaooeopai]o`aoecjkoaoi^khkomqa_kjopepqai]oihpelh]oa`ebanajpao bkni]o`a_kiqje_]k*K`aoajrkhreiajpk`]oaiekhkce]_kj`qveqe`ae]`amqaoec) jkoaoi^khkook] aoalnpe_]oo _ek)deop ne_]o(eopk(aopknabane`koonah] aook) _e]eoaooq]o_kj`e aodeop ne_]o(_]`]ok_ea`]`aa_]`]_qhpqn]_kjopepqej`k)oa_kik qioeopai]mqaejpacn]apkp]hev]rnekooq^oeopai]o`aoecjkoaoi^khko$hejcq]cai( ]npa(nahecek(ejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o(_kopqiao(ap_*%*Rnekoaopq`ekokolnklqoa) n]imqakipk`k`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]obkooa_]l]v`a`ao_naranaejpanlnap]naooao oq^oeopai]oakoeopai]can]hmqakoqjeÚ_]*Aooaipk`k]oaiepe_](pki]`]_kik iapk`khkce]ln lne]o_ej_e]odqi]j]oa_]l]v`aqjeÚ_)h]o*
#APqTULOß Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vk ejopnqiajp]h Ke`a]h_eajpbe_k
K
.5-
lan_qnok mqa Úvaiko jk aopq`k `]o _ej_e]o are`aj_e] ] ateopj_e] `a qi e`a]h _eajpÚ_k6ai^kn]_kjpejqe`]`aoanqlpqn]oi]nmqaiko_kjda_eiajpko_eajpÚ) _ko(]_ej_e]]_kjÚ]j]mqa]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]h`alkoep]j]n]vk_kik_]l]_e`]) `al]n]_kjda_an]na]he`]`a(iaoikmqaaop](]Új]h(pajd]`aoanejpaen]iajpa_kjopnq`] lah]ln lne]]pere`]`an]_ekj]h*
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
= h ce_] mqa naca k lajo]iajpk _eajpÚ_k _kjpailkn jak aop _ajpn]`] j] e`ae] `a `aikjopn]kalnkr](^]oa]`]j]`aÚjekkq_kjopnqk`kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpklkn oq]olnklnea`]`aoabqj aoa`]lkoek`koqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(lkniaek`]oklan]) ao`a]jheoa(ojpaoaaejpanlnap]k*=_ej_e]_kjpailkn ja]bqj`])oa6 j]`eopejkajpnaoqfaepkak^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk(mqalaniepaaop]^aha_an]e`ae]`a k^fapere`]`a(eopk(`aej`alaj`j_e]`kobajiajkoainah]k]koqfaepkmqa_kjda) _aa]ca7 j]e`ae]`aipk`k_kikqi_kjfqjpk`anacn]o(jkni]oalnk_a`eiajpkocan]eo(mqa oanrail]n]`aÚjenkq_kjopnqenkk^fapkal]n]k]qpk_kjpnkha`klajo]iajpk`qn]jpa ]ejraopec]ka(]l oaop](l]n]]_kjÚni]kkqb]hoeÚ_]k`konaoqhp]`kok^pe`ko*= e`ae]`aipk`kpai_kiklnaooqlkopkmqaklajo]iajpkk^a`a_aqjerano]hiajpa] _anpkolnej_lekoejpanjkoÍe`ajpe`]`a(jk_kjpn]`ek(pan_aenkat_hq`k(n]vkoqÚ) _eajpaÍ`komq]eo`alaj`aik_kjda_eiajpk`]ran`]`aa]at_hqok`kb]hok*=ran) `]`alk`aoan_kilnaaj`e`]oaf]_kik_knnaolkj`j_e]ja_aoone]ajpnako_kj_aepko a]na]he`]`a(oaf]_kik_kanj_e]ejpanj]`koln lneko_kj_aepko7 j]oklan] ao`a]jheoaaojpaoa(eopk(`al]oo]cai`kpk`k_kilhatkooq]ol]npao _kjopepqejpaokq`al]oo]cai`]ol]npao]kpk`kmqa]oatlhe_]a`apaniej]*Kk^fa) pk_eajpÚ_kqibajiajkoq^iape`k]jheoaaojpaoa(mqa`ao_naraikob]pko k^oanr]`kokq_kjopnkai]ln lne]ajpe`]`ak^faper]_kikqi_]ilk`anah] aoej) panj]oja_aoone]o(kqoaf](qi]aopnqpqn]mqalk`aoan_kjda_e`]aioaqoahaiajpko( oq]olnklnea`]`ao(oq]obqj aoaoaqoik`ko`alani]jj_e]kq`apn]jobkni]k7 j]e`ae]`ahae`kbajiajk(eopk(`anacqh]ne`]`aoa_kjop j_e]oqjerano]eoaja_ao) one]o(mqa`aÚjaikik`k`aoana`a_kilknp]n)oa`kk^fapk(oaf]aopapki]`k_kik qi_]ilkoal]n]`k`ko`ai]eo(oaf]aioq]onah] ao_kikqpnkok^fapkokq_]ilko `ana]he`]`a*=hae_eajpÚ_]`aÚjakmqakb]pk)bajiajkkqkk^fapk_kjopnq`kla) h]oklan] ao_eajpÚ_]o*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]hae_eajpÚ_]`ev_kikkk^fapkoa_kjo) pepqe(_kikoa_kilknp](lknmqaa_kiklani]ja_a(lknmqaa_kikoapn]jobkni]( ok^namq]eobajiajko]pq]a`amq]eookbna]k*=hae`aÚjakk^fapkoacqj`kqioeo) pai]_kilhatk`anah] aoja_aoone]o`a_]qo]he`]`a(_kilhaiajp]ne`]`a(ej_hqoka at_hqok*=e`ae]`ahaereo]i]n_]nk_]npanja_aoonek`kk^fapka]b]op]n]oe`ae]o`a ]_]ok(_kjpejcj_e](ej`apaniej]k(kbana_aj`kkk^fapk_kik_kilhap]iajpa`apan) iej]`klahklajo]iajpkkq_kilhap]iajpa_kjda_e`kkq_kcjko_rah7
P_je_]`a_hkj]) cai`acajaoai h]^kn]p nek`]Qjaol `aF]^kpe_]^]h$OL%( kj`aoaaj_kjpn]k ^]j_k`acajao`k LnkfapkCajki]*=o ]ikopn]o`a_hkjao okejk_qh]`]oai lh]_]o`a_nao_eiajpk _ki]bej]he`]`a`a atpn]k`a@J=* =laomqeo]lnk_qn] _ki^]pan]`kaj]`k ]i]nahejdkmqa]p]_] ]h]rkqn]`]h]n]jf]* 'USTAVOß2OTH&OLHAß)MAGEM
jk qok `a ejopnqiajpko pa_jkh ce_ko a jk oeilhaoiajpa p_je_ko*Koejopnqiajpkop_je_kooklnkhkjc]iajpko`a _]l]_e`]`ao`k_knlkdqi]jka`aopej]i)oa]]qiajp)h]o j]nah]k`kjkook_knlk_kikiqj`k*Koejopnqiajpko pa_jkh ce_ko ok _ej_e] _neop]hev]`] ai k^fapko i]pane]eo( j]`] lkooqai ai _kiqi _ki ]o _]l]_e`]`ao a ]lpe` ao `k_knlkdqi]jk7reo]iejpanrenjkobajiajkoaopq`]`ko aiaoik_kjopnqenkln lnekk^fapk_eajpÚ_k7`aopej]i)oa ]`kiej]napn]jobkni]nkiqj`kajkoeilhaoiajpa]b]) _ehep]n]nah]k`kdkiai_kikiqj`k*=pa_jkhkce]_kj) bana_ej_e]lna_eoka_kjpnkha`konaoqhp]`ko(]lhe_]k lnpe_]aejpan`eo_elhej]ne`]`a* j]_ne]k`aqi]hejcq]caiaola_Ú_]aln lne](`eop]jpa `]hejcq]cai_kpe`e]j]a`]hejcq]caihepanne]*=_ej_e] lnk_qn]]b]op]nko`]`komq]hep]perkoalan_alperk)aikperko `ko k^fapko kq `ko bajiajko l]n] cq]n`]n kq _kjopnqen ]laj]ooaqo]ola_pkomq]jpep]perkoanah]_ekj]eo*
.5.
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]hx#!0É45,/ßx
=hejcq]cai_kpe`e]j]a]hepanne]ok_kjkp]per]oalkheooie_]o(kmqaoecjeÚ_]mqa jah]o]ol]h]rn]olkooqaiihpelhkooecjeÚ_]`kooeiqhp jako(oq^ajpaj`e`ko(]i^ecqe`]) `aoaatlneiaip]jpkkoqfaepkmq]jpk]o_keo]o(kqoaf](atlneiai]onah] aorere`]oajpna koqfaepkakiqj`kmq]hep]perk`aokjo(_knao(bkni]o(k`knao(r]hknao(oajpeiajpko(ap_* J]o_ej_e]o(lkni(okjoa_knaookatlhe_]`ko_kikr]ne]kjk_kilneiajpk`]o kj`]ookjkn]oahqiejko]o(k^oanr]`]oaia`e`]ojkh]^kn]p nek*R]hknaoaoajpeiajpkook atlhe_]`kolah]o]jheoao`k_knlkrere`ka`]_kjo_ej_e](baep]olah]loe_khkce](lah]o]jhe) oao`]aopnqpqn]aknc]jev]k`]ok_ea`]`a(baep]olah]ok_ekhkce]alah]]jpnklkhkce]* =hejcq]cai_eajpÚ_]`aop]_]kk^fapk`]onah] ao_kikoqfaepk(oal]n])k`]atlanej) _e]rere`]_kpe`e]j]iajpaa_kjopn eqi]hejcq]cailqn]iajpa`ajkp]per]l]n]atlneien oai]i^ecqe`]`ao]ohaeo`kk^fapk*Koei^kheoik_eajpÚ_knkila_kikoei^kheoik`] hejcq]cai_kpe`e]j]_kjopnqej`kqi]hejcq]cailn lne](_kioi^khkoqjrk_koa`ajk) p]perko(`aoecjeÚ_]`kje_kaqjerano]h*=_ej_e]_kjopn ek]hcknepikab]h]lkniaek`ahao kq`aqi]_ki^ej]p ne]`aaopehki]paipe_k* Fqop]iajpalknoanaiaopaokolnej_el]eopn]ko`ke`a]h_eajpÚ_k(lk`aiko_kilnaaj) `anlknmqaateopaikolnk^hai]oaleopaikh ce_koat]iej]`kojko_]lpqhkolna_a`ajpao* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ke`a]h`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`aeil ao_ej_e]o_nepnekoaÚj]he`]`aomqa( mq]j`keila`e`ko`aoa_kj_napev]nai(bkn]inqlpqn]oaiq`]j]opa ne_]olnkbqj`]o( b]vaj`k`ao]l]na_an_]ilkoa`eo_elhej]o_eajpÚ_kokqhar]j`k]koqnceiajpk`ak^fapko( ipk`ko(`eo_elhej]oa_]ilko`aejraopec]kjkrko*
?e j_e]`aoejpanaoo]`]aqpehep]neoik
@
ao`a]Naj]o_aj]Íeopk(`ao`akDqi]jeoik(mqa_khk_]r]kdkiaijk_ajpnk `kQjeranoka]Úni]r]oaqlk`anl]n]_kjda_ana`kiej]n]na]he`]`aÍ(`q]o_kj) _al aook^nakr]hkn`]_ej_e]aoperan]ioailnaai_kjbnkjpk* =lneiaen]`ah]o(mqa_d]i]naiko`afab^ial`lkeb`fjbkqlabpfkqbobpp^al(]Úni]mqa kr]hkn`aqi]_ej_e]aj_kjpn])oaj]mq]he`]`a(jknecknaj]at]pe`k(j]_kanj_e]aj] ran`]`a`aqi]pakne](ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`aoq]]lhe_]klnpe_]*=pakne]_eajpÚ_]r]ha lknpn]van_kjda_eiajpkojkrkook^nab]pko`ao_kjda_e`ko(lkn]ilhe]nko]^andqi]jk ok^na]na]he`]`aajklknoan]lhe_rahj]lnpe_]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(lknoanran`]`aen] mqa]_ej_e]lk`aoan]lhe_]`]j]lnpe_](i]okqok`]_ej_e]_kjoamqj_e]ajk_]qo] `k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k* =oacqj`]_kj_alk(_kjda_e`]_kikrqfifq^ofpjl(]Úni](]k_kjpnnek(mqakr]hkn`a qi]_ej_e]aj_kjpn])oaj]mq]jpe`]`a`a]lhe_] aolnpe_]omqalkoo]laniepen*kqokkq ]qpehe`]`aeia`e]p]`ko_kjda_eiajpkomqalnkr]]ran`]`a`aqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]ahda _kjbanar]hkn*Ko_kjda_eiajpkooklnk_qn]`kol]n]naokhranlnk^hai]olnpe_koaaopao `apaniej]ijko k]l]na_eiajpk`aqi]_ej_e](i]op]i^ioq]opn]jobkni] aojk `a_knnan`kpailk* =o`q]o_kj_al aookran`]`aen]o(i]ol]n_e]eo*Oaqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]bkooaah]^kn]`] ]laj]olknoq]oÚj]he`]`aolnpe_]oeia`e]p]o(ejian]olaomqeo]of]i]eopane]ioe`kbaep]oa ejiankobajiajkof]i]eopane]ioe`k_kjda_e`ko(lkeo(_kibnamqj_e](ko_kjda_eiajpko pa ne_koaopki]eo]r]j]`ko`kmqa]o_]l]_e`]`aop_je_]o`aqi]lk_]a(aican]h(oq] ]lhe_]ko lan_a^e`]ao lkoorahiqepkpailk`alkeo`ad]ranoe`kah]^kn]`]* Jkajp]jpk(oaqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]jkbkn_]l]v`aoqo_ep]n]lhe_] ao(oajkbkn_]) l]v`alaniepenkoqnceiajpk`ak^fapkop_je_koapa_jkh ce_ko(ejopnqiajpko(qpajoheko( imqej]o(ia`e_]iajpko(`anaokhranlnk^hai]oeilknp]jpaol]n]kooanaodqi]jko(ajpk oanaikok^nec]`ko]`evanmqa]p_je_]a]pa_jkhkce]ok_ac]o(ej_anp]o(]nneo_]`]oalane) cko]o(lknmqaoklnpe_]ooai^]oaopa ne_]ooacqn]o*J]na]he`]`a(pakne]alnpe_]_eajpÚ) _]oaopknah]_ekj]`]oj]_kj_alkik`anj]a_kjpailkn ja]`a_ej_e](iaoikmqaqi] lkoo]aop]ni]eo]r]j]`]`kmqa]kqpn]*
.5/
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
=`eopejka]nah]kajpna`fk`f^mro^a`fk`f^^mif`^a^lk`aokhq_ekj]nkeil]ooa kqk_kjbnkjpkajpna]o`q]o_kj_al aook^nakr]hkn`]opakne]o_eajpÚ_]o(c]n]jpej`k(lkn qih]`k(mqaqi]pakne]lkoo]a`ar]oanah]^kn]`]oai]lnak_ql]k_kiÚjolnpe_ko eia`e]pko(ai^kn]lkoo](i]eop]n`a(_kjpne^qenl]n]ahao7a(lknkqpnk(c]n]jpej`kk_]npan _eajpÚ_k`apakne]o_kjopnq`]o`enap]iajpa_kiÚj]he`]`aolnpe_]o(]omq]eolk`ai(lkn oq]rav(oqo_ep]nejraopec] aolqn]iajpapa ne_]o* Lk`a)oa`evanmqaoklnk^hai]oa`eÚ_qh`]`aop_je_]oalnpe_]omqaoqo_ep]ik`a) oajrkhreiajpk`a_kjda_eiajpkopa ne_ko*O]^aiko(lknatailhk(mqakmqie_kH]rkeoean `a_e`eqaopq`]nkbajiajk`]_ki^qopkl]n]naokhranlnk^hai]oa_kjie_ko`aehqie) j]k`]_e`]`a`aL]neo(amqaC]hehaqaPknne_ahheejraopec]n]ikikreiajpk`ko_knlkojk r_qkl]n]naokhranlnk^hai]o`a_]nnac]iajpk`acn]j`aolaokojkolknpkoal]n]naolkj) `an]qi]lancqjp]`ko_kjopnqpknao`abkjpao`kof]n`ejo`]_e`]`a`aBhknaj]* Jk ajp]jpk( k mqa oailna oa raneÚ_] mqa ] atlhe_]k _eajpÚ_] a ] pakne] ]_]^]i _kjda_aj`kiqepki]eob]pkoanah] ao`kmqakmqaan]ja_aoonekl]n]okhq_ekj]nklnk) ^hai]lnpe_k(`ap]hik`kmqa]olaomqeo]opa ne_]ork]r]j]j`kfoai]lnak_ql]k lnpe_](ai^kn]_kia_ai]oqncena]oqo_ep]n(pailko`alkeo(okhq aolnpe_]ol]n]lnk^ha) i]ojkrko*=ooei(lknatailhk(l]ookq)oaiqepkpailk]pmqa]pakne]ahapnki]cjpe_]`a Danpvhar]ooaop_je_]o`an]`ek`ebqok*
=e`akhkce]_eajpebe_eop]
K
oajok_kiqi(ecjkn]j`k]o_kilhat]onah] aoajpna]opakne]o_eajpÚ_]oa]op_) je_]o(ajpna_ej_e]lqn]a_ej_e]]lhe_]`](ajpnapakne]alnpe_]aajpnaran`]`aa qpehe`]`a(paj`a]e`ajpeÚ_]n]o_ej_e]o_kikonaoqhp]`ko`aoq]o]lhe_] ao*Aoo] e`ajpeÚ_]k`aoai^k_]jqi]]pepq`a_kjda_e`]_kik_eajpeÚ_eoik(eopk(]crplbkqob `fk`f^bq`kf`^a]firpla^kbrqo^ifa^ab`fbkqÛ`^* At]iejaiko^naraiajpa_]`]qi`aooao]ola_pkomqa_kjopepqai]e`akhkce]`]_ej) _e]j]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja]*
K_eajpebe_eoik K_eajpeÚ_eoik]_naj]ejbqj`]`]`amqa]_ej_e]lk`aa`ara_kjda_anpq`k7mqa( `ab]pk(_kjda_apq`ka]atlhe_]k_]qo]h`]ohaeo`]na]he`]`ap]h_kikaop]aioeiao) i]*=k_kjpnnek`ko_eajpeop]o(mqajk_aoo]i`aajbnajp]nk^op_qhkoaleopaikh ce_ko( lnk^hai]oaajeci]o(koajok_kiqi_eajpeÚ_eop]na`qj`]jqi]e`akhkce]ajqi]iepk) hkce]`]_ej_e]* Fablildf^a^`fk`f^6_naj]jklnkcnaookaj]arkhqk`ko_kjda_eiajpko_eajpÚ_ko mqa(qi`e](atlhe_]nkpkp]hiajpa]na]he`]`aalaniepenki]jelqh)h]pa_je_]iajpa(oai heiepaol]n]]]kdqi]j]* Jfqlildf^a^`fk`f^6_naj]j]_ej_e]_kikoabkooai]ce]alk`anekeheiep]`kok^na ]o_keo]oakodkiajo(`]j`k)hdakhqc]nmqaiqepko_kopqi]i`]nonahece ao(eopk(qi _kjfqjpk`kqpnejnek`aran`]`aoejpailkn]eo(]^okhqp]oaejmqaopekjraeo* =e`akhkce]a]iepkhkce]_eajpeÚ_eop]oaj_]n]i]_ej_e]jklahklneoi]`kpn]^]hdk `k_kjda_eiajpk(i]olahklneoi]`konaoqhp]`ko$]lnaoajp]`ko_kikaolap]_qh]naoaie) n]_qhkoko%aok^napq`k_kikqi]bkni]`alk`anok_e]ha`a_kjpnkha`klajo]iajpkdq) i]jk*Lknaooaikperk(]_aep]i]fablildf^a^`ljmbqk`f^(eopk(]e`ae]`amqad(j]ok) _ea`]`a(komqao]^aiakomqajko]^ai(mqakolneiaenkook_kilapajpaoapik`enaepk `ai]j`]na`aatan_anlk`anao(ajmq]jpkko`ai]eookej_kilapajpao(`araj`kk^a`a_an aoani]j`]`ko*Ainaoqik(]ok_ea`]`a`araoan`enece`]a_ki]j`]`]lahkomqaÎo]^aiÏa ko`ai]eo`araiata_qp]n]op]nab]omqahdaookkn`aj]`]o*
.50
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]hx#!0É45,/ßx
=ehqok`]jaqpn]he`]`a`]_e j_e] ?kik]_ej_e]oa_]n]_panev]lah]oal]n]kalah]`eopejkajpnakoqfaepk`k_kjda_e) iajpkakk^fapkalknnapen]n`kok^fapko`k_kjda_eiajpkkoahaiajpkooq^faperko7_kik ko lnk_a`eiajpko _eajpÚ_ko `a k^oanr]k( atlaneiajp]k a ejpanlnap]k lnk_qn]i ]h_]j]nkk^fapkna]hkqkk^fapk_kjopnq`k_kikik`ahk]lnktei]`k`kna]h7a(ajÚi( _kikkonaoqhp]`kok^pe`kolknqi]_ej_e]jk`alaj`ai`]^k]kqirkjp]`a`k_eaj) peop]jai`aoq]ol]et ao(aop]iko_kjraj_e`ko`amqa]_ej_e]jaqpn]kqeil]n_e]h*@ev n]vkkmqa]o_keo]ookaioeiaoi]o*@aoejpanaoo]`]iajpa* Jkajp]jpk(aoo]ei]cai`]jaqpn]he`]`a_eajpÚ_]ehqo ne]*Mq]j`kk_eajpeop]ao_k) hdaqi]_anp]`aÚjek`aoaqk^fapk(`a_e`aqo]nqi`apaniej]`kipk`kaaolan]k^pan _anpkonaoqhp]`ko(oq]]pere`]`ajkjaqpn]jaieil]n_e]h(i]obaep]lknao_khd]olna_eo]o* R]ikopki]npnoatailhkomqajko]fq`]nk]ao_h]na_anaopalkjpk* -*
-USEUß$Oß(OMEM ß0ARIS
=bkpkcn]be]( ejrajp]`]ai-4/5( bkeiqepkqo]`] _kikbkni]`a naceopnk`kolkrko ajpk_d]i]`ko`a lneieperko(_kik jaopa`]cqanna pelk `aqij`ek ^kpk_q`k(`]p]`k `a-400*
.51
Kn]_eoikjk]laj]oqi]e`akhkce]ok_e]halkhpe_]7p]i^iqi]pakne]mqaoa lnapaj`a_eajpÚ_](]lke]`]aik^oanr] ao(`]`koahaeo_kjoacqe`ko_ki]^ekhkce](] loe_khkce](]ok_ekhkce]*qi]_anp]i]jaen]`a]lnaoajp]np]eo`]`ko`aik`k]pn]jo) bkni]n`ebanaj]opje_]oa_qhpqn]eoai`ebanaj]o^ekh ce_]oj]pqn]eoeiqpraeoaoa) l]n]nkooanaodqi]jkoaioqlaneknaoaejbaneknao(`]j`k]kolneiaenkofqopeÚ_]per]o l]n]atlhkn]n(`kiej]naiaoikatpaniej]nkooacqj`ko*
.* Lkn mqa ?klnje_k para `a ao_kj`an ko naoqhp]`ko `a oq]o laomqeo]o a C]hehaq bke bkn) ]`k]_kil]na_anlan]jpa]Ejmqeoekajac]nmqa]Pann]oaikre]aina`kn`kOkh; Lknmqa]_kj_alk]opnkjie_]cak_jpne_]$ah]^kn]`]j]=jpecqe`]`a%laniepe]mqa ]Ecnaf]Nki]j]i]jperaooa]e`ae]`amqa]na]he`]`a_kjopepq`]lknqi]dean]nmqe] `aoanao(mqark`koi]eolanbaepkoÍko_ahaopaoÍ]koi]eoeilanbaepkoÍkoejbanj]eo Í(paj`k]Pann]_kiklkjpkejpania`enekajpnak_ahaopaakejbanj]h*Aoo]lkoek`] Pann]_kiklkjpkejpania`enekoanre]`a^]oal]n]]]Úni]k`amqa]iaoi]bqjk lanpaj_e]Ecnaf]amqaaop](lknp]jpk(aop]r]i]eoln tei]`a@aqo`kmqa]okqpn]o nahece aoamqa(jkiqj`k_neopk(ah]k_ql]r]qihqc]ni]eo]hpk`kmqakonaeoako eilan]`knao*Aopao(lknoq]rav(j]dean]nmqe]`alanbaek`kooanao(aop]r]i]_ei]`ko ^]n aoaaopao]_ei]`ko_]ilkjaoaoaoanrko*Oa]]opnkjk) ie] `aikjopn]ooa mqa ] Pann] jk k _ajpnk `k Qjeranok a oa]ia_ je_]c]heh]e_]`aikjopn]ooamqapk`kokooanaoaopk oq^iape`ko o iaoi]o haeo `k ikreiajpk( ajpk ]o dean]n) mqe]o_ahaopao(j]pqn]eoadqi]j]olan`ane]ihacepeie`]`aa bqj`]iajpk(jklna_eo]j`koannaolaep]`]o*Qi]ok_ea`]`a aqi]_kj_alk`klk`anren]i)oa]ia]]`]olknqi]jkr] _kj_alk_eajpÚ_]* /* Jkook pan_aenk atailhk lk`a oan `]`k _ki ] ]jpnklk) hkce]*@qn]jpaiqepkpailkko]jpnkl hkcko]Úni]n]i mqa d]re] `q]o bkni]o `a lajo]iajpk _eajpeÚ_]iajpa k^oanrraeoa_kihaeo`ebanajpao6klajo]iajpkh ce_k) )n]_ekj]h`ko_erehev]`ko$dkiajoaqnklaqo^n]j_ko]`qh) pko%aklajo]iajpkln)h ce_kaln)n]_ekj]h`kooahr]) cajokqlneieperko$]bne_]jko(j`eko(pne^ko]qopn]he]j]o%* K lneiaenk an] _kjoe`an]`k oqlanekn( ran`]`aenk a ark) hq`k7koacqj`k(ejbanekn(b]hok(oqlanope_ekoka]pn]o]`k( _]^aj`k ]ko ^n]j_ko aqnklaqo Î]qtehe]nÏ ko oahr]cajo ÎlneieperkoÏ]]^]j`kj]noq]_qhpqn]a]`mqenen]_qhpqn] Îarkhq`]Ï `ko _khkjev]`knao* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( qi] _ej_e] _kik ] ]jpnklkhkce] oeilhaoiajpa atlneie] _ki_kj_aepkoapakne]oklk`an`ko`kiej]jpaoahacepe) i]r]]`kiej]k_khkje]h*
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
=o_kj`e ao]pq]eo`]laomqeo]akocn]j`aoejpanaooaoaifkck Kiahdkn_]iejdkl]n]lan_a^an]eilkooe^ehe`]`a`aqi]_ej_e]jaqpn]har]nai _kjoe`an]kkik`k_kik]laomqeo]_eajpÚ_]oana]hev]aijkookpailk* @qn]jpa o_qhko ko _eajpeop]o pn]^]hd]n]i ej`ere`q]hiajpa $iaoik mqa lkooqooai ]qtehe]naoa`eo_lqhko%aioaqolamqajkoh]^kn]p neko*Oq]olaomqeo]oan]i_qopa]`]okq lknahaoiaoikokqlknnaeo(jk^naoa^qncqaoaone_ko(mqa`aoaf]r]i]ch ne]`al]pnk_ej]n `ao_k^anp]oa]or]jp]cajolnpe_]omqa`ah]olk`ane]i]`ren*Lknoq]rav(koajok_kiqi ok_e]hkhd]r]k_eajpeop]_kikfksbkqlobdkfl* Dkfako_eajpeop]opn]^]hd]i_khaper]iajpa(aiamqelao(jkocn]j`aoh]^kn]p nekoqje) ranoepneko(jko`koejopepqpko`alaomqeo]ajko`]ocn]j`aoailnao]opn]joj]_ekj]eomqa l]npe_el]i `aqioeopai] _kjda_e`k _kik`ljmibul fkarpqof^i*jfifq^o*=olaomqeo]ook Új]j_e]`]olahkAop]`k$j]oqjeranoe`]`aoaejopepqpko%(lah]oailnao]olner]`]o$aioaqo h]^kn]p neko%alkn]i^ko$jko_ajpnko`aejraopec]k`k_kilhatkej`qopne]h)iehep]n%*Ok laomqeo]omqaatecai]hpkoejraopeiajpkoa_kjie_koa`]omq]eooaaolan]inaoqhp]`ko mqa]klejekl^he_]jaioailna_kjda_a*=hi`eook(ko_eajpeop]o`aqi]iaoi]na] `aejraopec]khqp]iajpnaoelknmqa_kilapailknna_qnokoaÚj]j_e]iajpko(apaj`ai ]b]vanoacna`k`aoq]o`ao_k^anp]o(lkeo`alaj`ai`ah]ol]n]_kjoacqenbqj`koaraj_an] _kilapek_kikqpnko* O]^aiko(dkfa(mqa]i]ekne]`konaoqhp]`ko_eajpÚ_komqaqo]ikoaijkoo]re`]_kpe) `e]j]Íimqej]o(nai`eko(banpehev]jpao(lnk`qpko`aheilav]a`adeceaja(i]pane]eooej) ppe_ko(_kilqp]`knaoÍperan]i_kikknecaiejraopec] aoiehep]naoaaopn]pce_]o(_ki) lape aoa_kjie_]oajpnacn]j`aoailnao]opn]joj]_ekj]eoa_kilape aolkhpe_]oajpna cn]j`aoAop]`ko*Iqepk`kmqaqo]ikoaijkook_kpe`e]jklnkri`alaomqeo]ojq_ha]nao( ^]_panekh ce_]oaaol]_e]eo* Koajok_kiqiok_e]h(]ckn](rk_eajpeop]_kikbkdbkebfolbj^dl(ainkql]o^n]j) _]o jk ejpanekn `a cn]j`ao h]^kn]p neko nalhapko `a k^fapko ej_kilnaajoraeo( nk`a]`k `a kqpnko_eajpeop]o(b]vaj`k_h_qhkoieopanekoko`e]jpa`a`avaj]o`a_kilqp]`knao* P]jpkj]reok]jpaneknÍk_eajpeop]_kikejrajpknacjekokhepnekÍmq]jpkj]]pq]h Ík_eajpeop]_kikiai^nk`aqi]amqela`aajcajdaenkoai]ckoÍ(koajok_kiqir] _ej_e]`aohec]`]`k_kjpatpk`]o_kj`e ao`aoq]na]hev]ka`aoq]oÚj]he`]`ao*Aeolknmqa paj`a]]_na`ep]nj]jaqpn]he`]`a_eajpÚ_](j]e`ae]`amqakje_k_kilnkieook`]_ej_e] k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenka`aoejpanaoo]`ka]okhqk_knnap]`ajkookolnk^hai]o* =e`akhkce]_eajpeÚ_eop]qo]aoo]ei]caie`a]hev]`]l]n]_kjokhe`]n]`]jaqpn]he`]`a _eajpÚ_](`eooeiqh]j`k(_kieook(]knecaia]Új]he`]`a`]i]ekne]`]olaomqeo]o(`aopej]) `]o]_kjpnkh]n]j]pqnav]a]ok_ea`]`aoacqj`kkoejpanaooao`kocnqlkomqa`kiej]iko Új]j_e]iajpko`koh]^kn]p neko*
=n]vkejopnqiajp]h
L
knmqadqi]e`akhkce]aqi]iepkhkce]`]_ej_e];
=Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnpa]n]vkejopnqiajp]h Mq]j`kaopq`]iko]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk(at]iej]iko]jkk`ae`akhkce]_kik h ce_]ok_e]hei]cejne]`ak_qhp]iajpk`]na]he`]`adeop ne_]*=kaopq`]nikokj]o_eiajpk `]ÚhkokÚ](at]iej]iko]`ebanaj]ajpnajvqelpaidlp(eopk(ajpna]atlhe_]k]jpnklk) i nÚ_]aice_]`kiqj`ka]atlhe_]kn]_ekj]h*Mq]j`kaopq`]iko]n]vk(reikomqa ]hcqjoÚh okbko]haiao(naqje`koj]Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnp(`ao_naran]i]n]_ekj]he`]`ak_e) `ajp]h_kikejopnqiajp]hev]k`]n]vk*Oanaqjenikoaooaornekoaopq`komqaÚvaiko]p ]mqe(lk`anaikonaolkj`anlancqjp]ok^na]e`akhkcev]ka]iepkhkcev]k`]_ej_e]*
.52
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]hx#!0É45,/ßx
=o^wlfkpqorjbkq^iÍmqakobn]jgbqnpe]jko(_kik=`knjk(I]n_qoaaDkngdaeian( p]i^i `aoecj]n]i _ki ] atlnaook o^wl firjfkfpq^ Í j]o_a mq]j`k k oqfaepk `k _k) jda_eiajpk pki] ] `a_eok `a mqa _kjda_an aljfk^o a `lkqoli^o ] j]pqnav] a ko oanao dqi]jko*=ooei(lknatailhk(kÚh okbkBn]j_eo>]_kj(jkej_ek`ko_qhkTREE(_nekqqi] atlnaookl]n]nabanen)oa]kk^fapk`k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k6Î]j]pqnav]]pkniajp]`]Ï* =pkniajp]n]j]pqnav]b]v)h]na]cen]_kj`e ao]npeÚ_e]eo(_ne]`]olahkdkiai*Kh]) ^kn]p nek_eajpÚ_k]i]jaen]l]n]`ecipe_]`aabapq]naooapkniajpk(lkeo(jaha(lh]jp]o( ]jei]eo(iap]eo(hmqe`ko(c]oao(ap_*okoq^iape`ko]_kj`e ao`aejraopec]kpkp]hiajpa `erano]o`]oj]pqn]eo(`ai]jaen]]b]van_kimqa]atlaneiajp]koqlana]atlanej_e]( `ao_k^nej`kbkni]o(_]qo]o(abaepkomqajklk`ane]ioan_kjda_e`kooa_kjpooaiko]la) j]o_ki]]pere`]`aaolkjp ja]`]j]pqnav]*=pkniajp]n]j]pqnav]_kjda_anoaqooacna) `kol]n]`kiej)h]apn]jobkni)h]* Kpkniajpk`]na]he`]`a]qiajp]_ki]_ej_e]_kjpailkn ja](qi]ravmqaaop]jk oa_kjpajp]ai_kjda_an]o_keo]oakooanaodqi]jko(i]oko_kjopn e]npeÚ_e]hiajpaa]lhe) _]konaoqhp]`ko`aoo]_kjopnqk]kiqj`kboe_k(^ekh ce_kadqi]jk$lomqe_k(ok_e]h(lk) hpe_k(deop ne_k%*=ooei(lknatailhk(]knc]jev]k`klnk_aook`apn]^]hdkj]oej`opne]o ]lnaoajp])oa _kik _eajpÚ_] lknmqa ^]oa]`] ai _kj_aepko `] loe_khkce]( `] ok_ekhkce]( `]a_kjkie](mqalaniepai`kiej]na_kjpnkh]nkpn]^]hdkdqi]jkaipk`koko]ola_pko $_kjpnkhaok^nak_knlkakaolnepk`kopn]^]hd]`knao%(]Úi`amqa]lnk`qpere`]`aoaf]] i]eknlkoorahl]n]naj`anhq_nko]k_]lep]h* J]ia`e`]aimqa]n]vkoapknj]ejopnqiajp]h(]_ej_e]r]e`aet]j`k`aoanqi]bkn) i]`a]_aook]ko_kjda_eiajpkoran`]`aenkol]n]pknj]n)oaqiejopnqiajpk`a`kiej]k( lk`anaatlhkn]k*L]n]mqajkoaf]lan_a^e`]_kikp]h(l]oo]]oanoqopajp]`]lah]e`ak) hkce]_eajpeÚ_eop](mqa(]pn]ro`]ao_kh]a`koiaeko`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo](`aoai^k_] j]iepkhkce]_eajpeÚ_eop]*
3CIENCEß0HOTOß,IBRARY,ATINSTOCK
Ah]^kn]k_eajpbe_]Tiepkhkce]_eajpbe_]
3PENCER߯ ßß FILvSOFOßINGLoSß-UITOßß INFLUENCIADOßPELASßß CIoNCIASßNATURAIS ß3PENCERß VIAßAßSOCIEDADEßCOMOßß UMßORGANISMOßVIVOßß 3UASßTESESßFORAMßMUITOß CRITICADASßAPvSßAßCON SOLIDAljOßEßOßDESENVOL VIMENTOßDAßSOCIOLOGIAßß EßDAßANTROPOLOGIA
Pk`]re](`araiko`eopejcqenajpnakikiajpk`]ejraopec]k_eajpÚ_]lnklne]iajpa `ep]ak`]e`akhkcev]k)iepkhkcev]k`aqi]_ej_e]*Qiatailhklk`an]qtehe]n)jko] lan_a^anaoo]`ebanaj]* Mq]j`k@]nsejah]^kn]]pakne]^ekh ce_]`]arkhqk`]oaol_eao(kik`ahk`aatlhe) _]kqo]`klknahalaniepe])hdaoqlknmqaklnk_aookarkhqperkk_knne]lknoahakj]pqn]h `koi]eo]lpkook^narerj_e]* Kn]( j] iaoi] lk_]( ] ok_ea`]`a _]lep]heop] aop]r] _kjraj_e`] `a mqa k lnkcnaook ok_e]hadeop ne_klnkrejd]`]_kilapeka`]_kj_knnj_e]`koej`er`qko(oacqj`k]hae a_kjie_]`]kbanp]a`]lnk_qn]*QiÚh okbk(Olaj_an(]lhe_kq(ajpk(]pakne]`]nseje]j] ok_ea`]`a6jaop](koi]eoÎ]lpkoÏ$eopk(koi]eo_]l]vao`a_kilapena_kj_knnan%pknj]i)oa k^qro^ijbkqboqlaneknao]kokqpnko(raj_aj`k)koainemqav](lnerehcekoalk`an* =kpn]jolknqi]pakne]^ekh ce_]l]n]qi]atlhe_]kÚhko Ú_]ok^na]aooj_e]`]ok) _ea`]`a(Olaj_anpn]jobknikq]qblof^`fbkqÛ`^a^bslir laifablildf^bslir`flkfpq^*Lkn mq;Ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqacajan]hevkql]n]pk`]]na]he`]`anaoqhp]`kok^pe`kojqi _]ilkl]npe_qh]n`a_kjda_eiajpkoaola_Ú_ko*Aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqapkikq_kj_ae) pkonabanajpao]b]pkoj]pqn]eoako_kjranpaqaib]pkook_e]eo(_kikoajkdkqraooa`eba) naj]ajpnaj]pqnav]aok_ea`]`a*Qi]rav_ne]`]]e`akhkce]arkhq_ekjeop](karkhq_ekjeoik pknjkq)oapakne]`]deop ne]a(]oacqen(iepkhkce]_eajpÚ_]`klnkcnaookdqi]jk*
Koabaepko`]n]vkejopnqiajp]h Kailnack`]jkk`an]vkejopnqiajp]hjkolaniepa_kilnaaj`an6 ]pn]jobkni]k`aqi]_ej_e]aie`akhkce]aiepkok_e]h(eopk(aioajok_kiqi _eajpeÚ_eop]7
.53
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
mqa]e`akhkce]`]_ej_e]jkoana`qvpn]jobkni]k`aqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]ai e`akhkce](i]oaj_kjpn])oaj]ln lne]_ej_e]mq]j`kaop]_kj_a^e`]_kikejopnq) iajpk`a`kiej]k(_kjpnkhaalk`anok^na]j]pqnav]a]ok_ea`]`a7 mqa ]o e`ae]o `a lnkcnaook p_je_k a jaqpn]he`]`a _eajpÚ_] lanpaj_ai ]k _]ilk `] e`akhkce]_eajpeÚ_eop]*
?kjbqokajpna_e j_e]ap_je_]
R
eikomqa]_ej_e]ik`anj]a_kjpailkn ja]pn]jobkni]]p_je_]aipa_jkhkce]( eopk ( l]oo] `] imqej])qpajohek imqej] _kik ejopnqiajpk `a lna_eok( mqa laniepa_kjda_eiajpkoi]eoat]pkoajkrko* Aoo]pn]jobkni]kpn]v`q]o_kjoamqj_e]olnej_el]eo6]lneiaen]oanabana]k_kjda) _eiajpk_eajpÚ_ka]oacqj`](]kaop]pqpk`kok^fapkop_je_ko6 k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k_kj_a^e`k_kikidf`^a^fksbk l$l]n]okhqk`alnk^ha) i]opa ne_koalnpe_ko%a_kikidf`^a^`lkpqor l$`ak^fapkopa ne_ko%(cn]]olkooe) ^ehe`]`a`aaopq`]nkobajiajkooai`alaj`an]laj]o`kona_qnoko`ajkoo]lan_alk a`ajkoo]ejpahecj_e]*]ooeimqa(lknatailhk(C]hehaqoanabana]kpahao_ lek_kik qiejopnqiajpk_qf]bqjkjk]`aoeilhaoiajpa]lnktei]nk^fapko`eop]jpao(i]o `a_knnecen]o`eopkn ao`ajkookokhdkoac]n]jpen)jko]ei]cai_knnap]`]o_keo]o*K iaoikbke`epkok^nakie_nko_ lek(ok^na]^]h]j]`alna_eok(ok^nak_nkjiapnk* Aijkookpailk(koejopnqiajpkop_je_k)pa_jkh ce_kork]hi`]_knnak`a jkoo]lan_alk(lkeo_knnecaib]hd]o`ajkooklajo]iajpk(qi]ravmqaokejpahe) cj_e]o]npeÚ_e]eo$k_kilqp]`knbke_d]i]`k`aÎ_na^nkahapnje_kÏ%i]eo]_qn]`]o `k mqa jkoo] ejpahecj_e] ej`ere`q]h* Are`ajpaiajpa( ok _kjda_eiajpko _eajpÚ_ko mqa laniepai ] _kjopnqk `aooao ejopnqiajpko( i]o `]j`k)hdao _]l]_e`]`ao mqa _]`]qi`aj o(_kikej`er`qk(jklkooqe*Kn](kok^fapkop_je_k)pa_jkh ce_ko]i) lhe]i]e`ae]`]_ej_e]_kikejrajka_kjopnqk`koln lnekobajiajko7
-*
.* kok^fapkop_je_kook_ne]`kolah]_ej_e]_kikejopnqiajpko`a]qthek]kpn]^]hdk dqi]jk(imqej]ol]n]`kiej]n]j]pqnav]a]ok_ea`]`a(ejopnqiajpko`alna_eok l]n]k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_ka(ok^napq`k(aioq]bkni]_kjpailkn ja](_kik]q) pi]pko*Aopaookkk^fapkp_je_k)pa_jkh ce_klknat_ahj_e](lknmqalkooqai]ooa) cqejpao_]n]_panope_]o(i]n_]o`kjkrkaop]pqpk`aooak^fapk6
*OAQUqNß3ALVADORß,LAVADOß1UINO
ok_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_kk^faper]`k(eopk(`alkoep]`ka_kj_napev]`kjqik^fapk* Oknaoqhp]`ka_knlkneÚ_]k`a_kjda_eiajpko_eajpÚ_ko7 ?d]nca`k_]npqjeop] ]ncajpejkMqejk ok^na]lnpe_] _eajpbe_]*
.54
Ke`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]hx#!0É45,/ßx
okk^fapkomqalkooqaiaioeiaoikoklnej_lek`aoq]nacqh]k(i]jqpajka pn]jobkni]k*=oimqej]o]jpec]o`alaj`e]i`abkn]oatpanj]ol]n]na]hev]noq]o bqj ao$]h]r]j_]o(lkhe]o(i]jerah]o(bkn]iqo_qh]n`aoanaodqi]jkokq`a]jei]eo( bkn]de`nqhe_](ap_*%*=oimqej]oik`anj]ook]qpi]pkolknmqa(`]`kkeilqhok ahpne_k)ahapnje_keje_e]h(na]hev]ilknoeiaoi]opk`]o]oklan] aol]n]]omq]eobk) n]ilnkcn]i]`]o(ej_hqej`k]_knnak`aoq]ln lne]]k(]na]heiajp]k`aajance]( ]pn]jobkni]k*Ok]qpknnacqh]`]oa]qpk_kjoanr]`]o(lknmqalkooqaiaioeiao) i]o]oejbkni] aoja_aoone]o]koaqbqj_ekj]iajpk7 _kik_kjoamqj_e](jkoklnklne]iajpaqik^fapkoejcqh]nkqej`ere`q]h(i]oqi pfpqbj^abl_gbqlpejpanhec]`kolkn_ki]j`kona_lnk_ko7 okoeopai]omqa(qi]ravlnkcn]i]`ko(na]hev]iklan] aopa ne_]o_kilhat]o(mqa ik`eÚ_]ik_kjpa`k`koln lneko_kjda_eiajpko_eajpÚ_ko(eopk(kok^fapkop_je) _k)pa_jkh ce_kob]vail]npa`kpn]^]hdkpa ne_k* Kn](koajok_kiqiok_e]hecjkn]aoo]opn]jobkni] ao`]_ej_e]a`]p_je_]a_kjda) _a]laj]ooaqonaoqhp]`koi]eoeia`e]pko6kok^fapkomqalk`aioanqo]`kolknj o$imqe) j]`ah]r]n(sfabld^jb(pahareok]_]^k(imqej]`a_]h_qh]n(_kilqp]`kn(nk^ej`qopne]h( pahabkja_ahqh]n(b*_llh(]l]nahdk`ail/(ap_*%* ?kik(l]n]qo)hko(lna_eo]ikona_a^anqi_kjfqjpk`aejbkni] ao`ap]hd]`]oaok) Úope_]`]o(paj`aiko]e`ajpeÚ_]nk_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k_kioaqoabaepkopa_jkh ce_ko* ?kieook(`aet]iko`alan_a^ankaooaj_e]h(eopk(mqa]o_ej_e]ol]oo]n]i]b]vanl]npa `]o bkn]o a_kjie_]o lnk`qper]o `] ok_ea`]`a a pnkqtan]i iq`]j]o ok_e]eo `a cn]j`a lknpaj]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk(j]lnk`qkaj]`eopne^qek`kok^fapko(j]bkni]`a _kjoqie)hko*Jklan_a^aikomqa]olaomqeo]o_eajpÚ_]ookÚj]j_e]`]olknailnao]oa ckranjko(`ai]j`]j`kcn]j`aooki]o`ana_qnokomqanapknj]i(cn]]o]konaoqhp]`kok^) pe`ko(j]bkni]`ahq_nkalk`anl]n]ko]cajpaoÚj]j_e]`knao* Lknjklan_a^anikoklk`aneka_kjie_k`]o_ej_e]o(hqp]ikol]n]pan]_aook(l]n] lkooqena_kjoqienkok^fapkopa_jkh ce_ko(i]ojkhqp]ikolahk`enaepk`a]_aookp]jpk ]ko_kjda_eiajpko_kikolaomqeo]o_eajpÚ_]o(jaihqp]ikolahk`enaepk`a`a_e`enoaq ik`k`aejoankj]re`]a_kjie_]alkhpe_]`aqi]ok_ea`]`a* Aeolknmqa(ajpnakqpnkoabaepko`ajkoo]_kjbqokajpna_ej_e]apa_jkhkce](]_aep]iko( jk>n]oeh(lkhpe_]oa`q_]_ekj]eomqalnkÚooekj]hev]ikofkrajojkajoejki`ekÍlknp]jpk( ]jpaomqapajd]ipe`k]_aooko_ej_e]olnklne]iajpa`ep]oÍamqa`aopej]ilkq_kona) _qnokol^he_koona]o`alaomqeo]j]oqjeranoe`]`aoÍlknp]jpk(i]jpaj`kko_eajpeop]o j]ian]_kj`ek`analnk`qpknao`a_ej_e]olnk`qve`]oaikqpnkol]oaoaok_ea`]`ao*
Klnk^hai]`kqok`]o_e j_e]o
=
.55
hi`klnk^hai]]jpanekn(eopk(`apakne]o_eajpÚ_]ooanaibkniqh]`]o_ki^]oa ai_anp]o`a_eo aoaao_khd]o`k_eajpeop]kq`kh]^kn]p nekkj`apn]^]hd]iko_eaj) peop]o(_ki_kjoamqj_e]oone]ol]n]kooanaodqi]jko(qikqpnklnk^hai]p]i) ^ipn]ve`klah]o_ej_e]o6koaqqok* Reikomqaqi]pakne]_eajpÚ_]lk`aj]o_anl]n]`]nnaolkop]]qilnk^hai]lnpe_k kqp_je_k*Reikop]i^imqa]ejraopec]k_eajpÚ_]lk`aen]r]j]j`kl]n]`ao_k^an) p]o`abajiajkoanah] aomqafjklkooqainah]k`enap]_kikolnk^hai]olnpe_ko eje_e]eoa(_kik_kjoamqj_e](bnamqajpaqi]pakne]aop]niqepki]eo]r]j]`]`kmqa ]op_je_]oapa_jkhkce]omqalk`ank]lhe_)h]*Iqep]oravao(]heo(k_eajpeop]jaioamqan ei]cej]mqa]pakne]pan]lhe_]klnpe_]* at]p]iajpaeookmqapknj]kqok`]_ej_e]]hck`ahe_]`k(mqa(aican]h(ao_]l]`]o iko`koln lnekolaomqeo]`knao*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqa]ie_nkboe_]kqboe_]mq jpe_] `aoai^k_]j]b]^ne_]k`]o]ni]ojq_ha]nao7]^ekmqie_]a]cajpe_](j]`a]ni]o^]_pa) nekh ce_]o*Pakne]ook^na]hqvakokilaniepai]_kjopnqk`ao]phepao]npeÚ_e]eo(mqa(oa
x5.)$!$%ßx=_ej_e]
ok_kja_praeoejop]jp]ja]iajpaaipk`kkchk^kpannaopnal]n]]_kiqje_]kaejbkni]) k(p]i^ioknaolkjoraeolknaolekj]caiiehep]nalkncqann]o_ki]ni]opahacqe]`]o* Mq]j`kaopq`]niko]pe_](ranaikokocn]raolnk^hai]oikn]eopn]ve`kolah]op_je) _]o`aoajrkhre`]olah]cajpe_]_kjpailkn ja]* Qi]`]o_]n]_panope_]oi]eojkr]o`]_ej_e]aopaimqa]olaomqeo]o_eajpÚ_]ol]o) o]n]i]b]vanl]npa`]obkn]olnk`qper]o`]ok_ea`]`a(eopk(`]a_kjkie]*=]qpki]k( ]ejbkni]pev]k(]paha_kiqje_]k`apaniej]ibkni]o`alk`ana_kjie_k(ik`ko`a knc]jev]nkpn]^]hdkej`qopne]hakooanreko(_ne]ilnkÚoo aoak_ql] aojkr]o(`aopnkai lnkÚoo aoak_ql] ao]jpec]o(ejpnk`qvai]rahk_e`]`aj]lnk`qk`aian_]`kne]oaai oq]`eopne^qeka_kjoqik(ik`eÚ_]j`kl]`n aoej`qopne]eo(_kian_e]eoaaopehko`are`]*= _ej_e]pknjkq)oal]npaejpacn]jpaaej`eolajorah`]]pere`]`aa_kjie_]*Pknjkq)oa]caj) paa_kjie_kalkhpe_k* =hi`ab]vanl]npaaooaj_e]h`]]pere`]`aa_kjie_](]_ej_e]p]i^il]ookq]b]van l]npa`klk`anlkhpe_k*Jklkn]_]ok(lknatailhk(mqackranjko_neaiiejeopnekoaoa) _nap]ne]o`a?ej_e]aPa_jkhkce]amqa`aopejairan^]ol]n]Új]j_e]nlaomqeo]o_ereoaie) hep]nao*@kiaoikik`kmqa]ocn]j`aoailnao]oÚj]j_e]ilaomqeo]oa]p_ne]i_ajpnko a h]^kn]p neko`a ejraopec]k _eajpÚ_]( p]i^i ko ckranjko `apaniej]i mq]eo _ej_e]o oank`aoajrkhre`]oa(jaop]o(mqalaomqeo]ooankÚj]j_e]`]o* Aoo]jkr]lkoek`]o_ej_e]oj]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja](]hi`aej`e_]nmqai) jeikkqmq]oaejateopajpakcn]q`ajaqpn]he`]`aa`ahe^an`]`a`ko_eajpeop]o(ej`e_]p]i) ^imqakrpl`]o_ej_e]o`aÚjakona_qnokoÚj]j_aenkomqajah]ooankejraope`ko* =ok_ea`]`a(lkni(jkhqp]lahk`enaepk`aejpanbanenj]o`a_eo ao`aailnao]oackran) jkomq]j`kaopao`a_e`aiÚj]j_e]nqipelk`alaomqeo]airav`akqpnk*@aoo]i]jaen](k _]ilk_eajpÚ_kpknj])oa_]`]ravi]eo`eop]jpa`]ok_ea`]`aoaimqaaop]aj_kjpnaiaeko l]n]kneajp]nkqok`]o_ej_e]o(lkeoaopa`aÚje`k^kqbp`kej_ek`]oln lne]olaomqeo]oa clo^`k_kjpnkhamqa]ok_ea`]`alk`ane]atan_anok^naaha* Qiatailhk`ahqp]ok_e]hl]n]ejpanbanenj]o`a_eo aook^na]olaomqeo]oaoaqoqoko aj_kjpn])oajkoikreiajpkoa_kh ce_ko(jkjkrkikreiajpk`]cajpe_]aaiiqepkoik) reiajpkook_e]eohec]`ko]naerej`e_] ao`a`enaepko*@aik`kcan]h(lkni(]e`akhkce]_eaj) peÚ_eop]paj`a]oaniqepki]eobknpa`kmqaaooaoikreiajpkoa(ai`a_knnj_e]`kolk`anao a_kjie_ko(lkhpe_koaiehep]naoajrkhre`ko(]heiep]nkoaqlk`an`a]k*
NOVOßMOVIMENTOßDAßß GENmTICAßTERMOßINVEN TADOßPORßCIENTISTASßPARAß INDICARßUMßCONJUNTOßDEß PRINCqPIOSßEßVALORESßAß SEREMßDEFENDIDOSßDIANTEß DOSßPROBLEMASßmTICOSß TRAZIDOSßPELAßGENmTICAß CONTEMPORhNEA
15%34¬%3
#!0É45,/ß =]pepq`a_eajpÚ_] -* @]hcqjoatailhko`a_anpav]o`koajok_kiqia oq]nabqp]klah]o_ej_e]o* .* Mq]eo ]o lnej_el]eo _]n]_panope_]o `ko o]^anao `k oajok_kiqi;@aoo]o_]n]_panope_]o(ao_khd]pnoa atlhemqa)]o* /* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`k_kjda_eiajpk _eajpÚ_kaiklkoek]koajok_kiqi;@aoo]o_]) n]_panope_]o(ao_khd]pnoaatlhemqa)]o*
0* Lknmqaaijkoo]ok_ea`]`a]_ej_e]paj`a]oanpk) i]`]_kikoabkooai]ce];Mq]hkamqrk_k`aoo] reok; 1* Mqa]pere`]`aoejpaha_pq]eoc]n]jpaineckn]kpn]^]) hdk_eajpÚ_k; 2* ?kik=neop pahao`aÚja]_ej_e];?kikCn]jcan`a) Úja]_ej_e]; 3* Mq]eo ko ln)namqeoepko l]n] ] _kjopepqek `a qi] _ej_e]; 4* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]_ej_e]qilajo]iajpk oeopaipe_k;
/,,
=]pepq`a_eajpbe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
#!0É45,/ßß =_ej_e]j]deopne] -* Mq]eo]opnolnej_el]eo_kj_al ao`a_ej_e]; .* Atlhemqa ^naraiajpa ] _kj_alk n]_ekj]heop] `a _ej_e]* /* Atlhemqa ^naraiajpa ] _kj_alk aileneop] `a _ej_e]* 0* Atlhemqa^naraiajpa]_kj_alk_kjopnqpereop]`a _ej_e]* 1* AtlhemqakmqaoecjeÚ_]i]oatlnaoo aoÎdelkppe) _k)`a`qperkÏaÎdelkppe_k)ej`qperkÏ* 2* Mq]eokolnej_leko`ke`a]h`a_eajpeÚ_e`]`aj]_kj) _alk_kjopnqpereop]`a_ej_e]; 3* Mq]h]lnej_el]h`ebanaj]ajpna]_ej_e]]jpec]a] _ej_e]_hooe_]kqik`anj]; 4* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnap_je_]apa_jkhkce]; 5* Atlhemqa]oe`ae]o`alnkcnaookaarkhqk_eajpÚ_ko a]_kj_alk`adeop ne]lnaooqlkop]lknah]o* -,* @]hcqjoatailhkomqaej`emqai]`ao_kjpejqe`]) `a`ko_kjda_eiajpko_eajpÚ_ko* --* MqaoecjeÚ_]i]oatlnaoo aoÎnqlpqn]aleopaikh ce) _]ÏaÎk^op_qhkaleopaikh ce_kÏ(_ne]`]olknC]opkj >]_dah]n`l]n]oanabanen oiq`]j]o_eajpÚ_]o; -.* Mq]eo ko pelko `a `ao_kjpejqe`]`a _eajpÚ_] ]lna) oajp]`kolknCn]jcan; -/* KmqaPdki]oGqdjajpaj`alknnarkhqk_eajpÚ) _];Mq]j`kah]]_kjpa_a;Lknmqaah]qi]nqlpqn] n]`e_]h_kinah]k _ej_e]]jpanekn; -0* Kmqaqil]n]`eci]_eajpÚ_kaqi]_ej_e]jkn) i]h; -1* Kmqaqi]_neoa`al]n]`eci]_eajpÚ_k; -2* Lknmqa(]lao]n`]onqlpqn]oa`ao_kjpejqe`]`ao(_kj) pejq]iko]_na`ep]j`kjklnkcnaook`]o_ej_e]o; -3* MqafqopeÚ_]per]kbana_aGqdjl]n]]`iepeniko(_ki ]hcqi]onaopne ao(]e`ae]`alnkcnaook_eajpÚ_k; -4* ?kikG]nhLkllanatlhe_]]iq`]j]`aqi]pakne] _eajpÚ_]; -5* Mq]eo]o_npe_]obaep]o]LkllanlknkqpnkoÚh okbko `]_ej_e]; .,* Mq]eoko_nepnekoqo]`kolkn=neop pahaol]n]_h]ooe) Ú_]n]o_ej_e]o; .-* Mq]eoko_nepnekoqo]`ko]l]npen`ko_qhkTREEl]n] _h]ooeÚ_]n]o_ej_e]o;
#!0É45,/ß =o_ej_e]odqi]j]o -* Lknmqa]oepq]k`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]oiqepkao) la_e]hjk_kjfqjpk`]o_ej_e]o; .* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eok^fa aomqabkn]ibaep]o o_ej) _e]odqi]j]o; /* =jpao `] _kjopepqek `]o _ej_e]o dqi]j]o( mq]eo bkn]i ko pno lnej_el]eo lank`ko `a aopq`k `k dq) i]jk;Naoqi]^naraiajpa_]`]qi`ahao*
/,-
0* ?kik k deopkne_eoik lajo]r] ko b]pko dqi]jko; Mq]eokolnk^hai]o`kdeopkne_eoikmqajklq`a) n]ioannaokhre`kolknoaqooacqe`knao; 1* Mq]h]lnklkop]`aI]tSa^anl]n]oqlan]nkolnk) ^hai]o`kdeopkne_eoik; 2* Mq]h]lnej_el]h_kjpne^qek`]bajkiajkhkce]l]n] ]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o; 3* Mq]h]lnej_el]h_kjpne^qek`ki]nteoikl]n]]o _ej_e]odqi]j]o; 4* Mq]h]lnej_el]h_kjpne^qek`kaopnqpqn]heoikl]n] ]o_ej_e]odqi]j]o;
#!0É45,/ß Ke`a]h_eajpÚ_ka]n]vkejopnqiajp]h -* Mq]eo ko bqj`]iajpko `] _ej_e] _kjpailknja]; @aooao(ao_khd]pnoaatlhemqa)ko* .* Kmqake`a]h`]_ej_e]_kik_kjda_eiajpk`aoej) panaoo]`k; /* Kmqa]_kj_alkqpehep]neop]`]_ej_e]; 0* Lknmqalk`aiko`evanmqa]_kj_alk`k_kjda_e) iajpk`aoejpanaoo]`ka]`kqpehep]neoikokran`]) `aen]o(i]ol]n_e]eo; 1* Kmqak_eajpeÚ_eoik;Atlhemqakmqaok]e`akhk) ce]`]_ej_e]a]iepkhkce]`]_ej_e]* 2* Kmqa]e`ae]`ajaqpn]he`]`a_eajpÚ_]; 3* Lknmqa]ei]cai`]jaqpn]he`]`a_eajpÚ_]ehqo ) ne]; 4* ?kikoana]hev]]laomqeo]_eajpÚ_]_kjpailknja]; 5* Kmqa]n]vkejopnqiajp]hkq]n]vkehqiejeop] ]lnaoajp]`]lah]Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnp;Mq]h]nah]k ajpnaaoo]n]vka]e`ae]`k_kjda_eiajpk_eajpÚ_k _kiklk`anl]n]]pkniajp]n]j]pqnav]; -,* Mqab]pkoaoepq] aonah]perko o_ej_e]ooapknj]i _kilnaajoraeocn]]o e`ae]`an]vkejopnqiajp]h; --* Mq]eo]o_kjoamqj_e]o`]pa_jkhkce]l]n]k_kjda) _eiajpk_eajpÚ_k; -.* Kmqaqik^fapkpa_jkh ce_k; -/* Lknmqahqp]ikol]n]lkooqenk^fapkopa_jkh ce_koa jkl]n]pank_kjpnkha`]oejraopec] ao_eajpÚ_]o; -0* Mq]eo ko lnk^hai]o pe_ko( a_kj ie_ko a lkhpe_ko mqaoqncen]i_kikqok`]o_ej_e]o;
5NIDADEß
Kiqj`k`]lnpe_] ?]lpqhk-- =_qhpqn] ?]lpqhk-. =atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecek ?]lpqhk-/ Kqjeranok`]o]npao ?]lpqhk-0 =_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h ?]lpqhk-1 =ateopj_e]pe_] ?]lpqhk-2 =behkokbe]ikn]h ?]lpqhk-3 =he^an`]`a ?]lpqhk-4 pe_]a_ej_e] ?]lpqhk-5 =re`]lkhpe_] ?]lpqhk-, =obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-% ?]lpqhk-- =obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.% ?]lpqhk-. =lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne] ?]lpqhk-/ =oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTT ?]lpqhk-0 =mqaopk`aik_npe_]
L]n]rnekoÚhokbkoadeopkne]`knao(]_qhpqn]oqncamq]j`kkodkiajolnk`q) vai ]o lneiaen]o pn]jobkni]ao j] j]pqnav] lah] ]k `k pn]^]hdk* ?ki k pn]^]hdk( ko oanao dqi]jko lnk`qvai k^fapko ejateopajpao j] j]pqnav] $_]o]( qpajo heko( ejopnqiajpko%( knc]jev]i)oa ok_e]hiajpa l]n] na]hev)hk( `ere`ej`k ]op]nab]oajpnadkiajoaiqhdanao(]`qhpkoa_ne]j]o*L]n]]qiajp]nkona_qn) okolnk`qve`ko(ejopepqai]b]i he]a]onah]ao`al]najpao_k(]o]h`ae]oareh]o* L]n]lnkpac )h]o(ejrajp]i]o]ni]oa]cqann]*L]n]_kjoacqenoailna_kj`e) aob]rknraeol]n]kpn]^]hdkal]n]]iahdkne]`kmqalnk`qvai(ejrk_]ia ]`kn]ibkn]o`erej]o(ejopepqej`k]nahecek*Korneko]cnql]iajpkodqi]jko( j]o_e`ko`kpn]^]hdka`kooeopai]o`al]najpao_k(pnk_]iajpnaoelnk`qpko`a oaqopn]^]hdko(ejrajp]j`kk_ki n_ek*=o`aoecq]h`]`aooqncaimq]j`kqi] l]npa`]_kiqje`]`apki]l]n]oe(_kiklnklnea`]`alner]`](pann]o(]jei]eo( cq]o6_kia]]`ereokok_e]h`akj`aoqncenk]o_h]ooaook_e]eoako_kjÛepkoa( `aopao(]ejopepqek`klk`an*
Jqi]`]o bkpkoi]eo_kjda_e`]o `k bkpcn]bk bn]j_ o?]npean)>naookj(qidkiaiaqic]pk_kil]npe) hd]ioq]okhe`kajpnakoa`eb_eko`k_ajpnk`aJkr]Ukng(j]`_]`]`a-50,*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
#APqTULOß =_qhpqn]
J]pqnav]dqi]j];
iqepk_kiqikqrenikoa`evanikobn]oao`kpelkÎ?dkn]nln lnek`]j]pqnav]dq) i]j]ÏaÎDkiaijk_dkn]Ï*KqajpkÎ`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]pania`k`k`ao_kjda) _e`kÏaÎAh]_kn]fko](jkpaiia`k`aj]`]Ï*P]i^i_kiqi]bn]oaÎ=oiqhdanao okj]pqn]hiajpabncaeoaoajoraeo(lknmqaj]o_an]il]n]]i]panje`]`aÏ(^ai_kikaop] kqpn](ÎBqh]j]qi]`aoj]pqn]`](lkeojkpaikiajkn]ikn]koÚhdkoÏ* ?kibnamqj_e]kqreiko`evan6ÎKodkiajookbknpaoan]_ekj]eo(baepkol]n]k_ki]j) `kal]n]]re`]l^he_]Ï(`kj`a(_kik_kjoamqj_e](aop]kqpn]bn]oa6ÎBqh]j]jail]na_a iqhdan*Raf]_kikoaraopaRaf]kailnackmqa]nn]jfkqÏ*Jkn]nkao_qp]nikomqako jacnkookej`khajpaolknj]pqnav](kolk^naookj]pqn]hiajparekhajpko(kofq`aqookj]) pqn]hiajpa]r]najpko(kon]^aookj]pqn]hiajpa_kian_e]jpaoaolanpko(kobn]j_aoaook j]pqn]hiajpaejpanaoo]`koaioatkakoejchaoaook(lknj]pqnav](Ûaqipe_ko* Bn]oao_kikaoo]oaiqep]okqpn]olnaooql ai(lknqih]`k(mqaateopaqi]j]pqnav] dqi]j](]iaoi]aipk`kokopailkoahqc]nao(a(lknkqpnk(mqaateopaqi]`ebanaj]`a j]pqnav]ajpnadkiajoaiqhdanao(lk^naoane_ko(jacnko(j`eko(fq`aqo(n]^ao(bn]j_aoao kqejchaoao*D]rane](]ooei(qi]j]pqnav]dqi]j]qjerano]h(]iaoi]l]n]pk`ko(aqi] j]pqnav]dqi]j]`ebanaj_e]`]lknaol_eao(i]jaen]`]`ebanaj]ajpnarne]oaol_eao`a lh]jp]okq`a]jei]eo6qi]j]pqnav]baiejej](qi]i]o_qhej](qi]^n]oehaen](qi]bn]j_a) o](qi]f]lkjao](qi]jacn](qi]^n]j_](qi]fq`]e_](qi]]ne]j](ap_* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]j]pqnav]pane]baepkkdkbolerj^klqjerano]ha]obpm`fbper* j^k^p l]npe_qh]nao( `a ik`k mqa _anpko oajpeiajpko( _kilknp]iajpko( e`ae]o a r]hknao oane]ikoiaoikol]n]pk`kkcjankdqi]jk$oane]ij]pqn]eol]n]pk`kokodqi]jko% ajmq]jpkkqpnkor]ne]ne]il]n]_]`]aol_ea$kqoatk(kqapje](kqpelk(kqcnqlk(kq_h]ooa ok_e]h%*@evanmqa]hcqi]_keo]k^qro^ikqmlok^qrobw^oecjeÚ_]`evanmqaaoo]_keo]ateo) paja_aoo]ne]iajpa$kqoaf](jklk`a`aet]n`aateopenjailk`aoan`ebanajpa`kmqa%a qjerano]hiajpa$aipk`kokopailkoahqc]nao%lknmqaah]abaepk`aqi]_]qo]ja_aoone] aqjerano]h*Aoo]_]qo]]j]pqnav](mqaoailna]iaoi]aipk`]l]npa*OecjeÚ_]`evan( lknp]jpk(mqap]h_keo](lknoanj]pqn]h(jk`alaj`a`]]kaejpajk`kooanaodqi]jko aoei`]oklan] aoja_aoone]oaqjerano]eona]hev]`]olah]j]pqnav]*=ooei_kik`]j]) pqnav]`ko_knlkooanaickranj]`kolknqi]haej]pqn]h(]hae`]cn]rep]kqjerano]h(_kik `]j]pqnav]`]cq]oan_kilkop]lkn`keopkiko`ade`nkcjekaqi`aktecjek(kq _kik`]j]pqnav]`]]^ahd]lnk`qveniaha`]nkoaen]lnk`qvennko]o(p]i^ioane]mlo k^qrobw^mqakodkiajooajpai(lajo]ia]cai7alkneookd]rane]qi]k^qrobw^erj^* k^*Mqa]_kjpa_ane]_ki]obn]oaomqaiaj_ekj]iko]_ei]oaikopnooaikomqa(d]raj`k qi] j]pqnav] dqi]j]( ]hcqi]o `ah]o ok _kjpn]`ep ne]o a kqpn]o jk _knnaolkj`ai ]ko b]pko`]na]he`]`a; =ooei(lknatailhk(`evanmqaÎj]pqn]h_dkn]nj]pneopav]Ïajpn]ai_kjpn]`ek_ki] e`ae]`amqaÎdkiaijk_dkn]Ï(lkeo(oaeookbkooaran`]`a(kdkiaipane]`aoan_kjoe`an]) `kqioanmqajklkooqej]pqnav]dqi]j]amqaao_]l]`]ohaeo`]j]pqnav](fmqa_dkn]n _kjoe`an]`kj]pqn]h*Kiaoikoal]oo]_ki]obn]oaook^nakia`ka]_kn]cai6jah]o`epk mqakia`kj]pqn]h(i]omqaqi]_anp]laook]]`ienrahlknmqajkpaiia`k*Jaopa
/,0
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
_]ok(aop]iko`e]jpa`aqi]_kjpn]`ek*@ab]pk(b]h])oa`aqi]_keo]j]pqn]h$kia`k%aoa `evmqaahalk`a`aet]n`aateopenkq`a]_kjpa_an$qi]laook]]`ienrahjkpaiia`k%( i]oeookeilkoorah(lkeopq`kkmqaj]pqn]hja_aoonek(kqoaf](]_kjpa_aoailnaja) _aoo]ne]iajpa(qi]ravmqakj]pqn]hkmqajk`alaj`a`aqi]ejpanrajkkq`aqi] `a_eok`kooanaodqi]jko*=hi`aoan_kjpn]`ep nek`evanmqakia`kj]pqn]hamqad laook]o mqa jk pi ia`k( ]ej`] l]na_aiko pan ]`ien]k lkn mqai( ieopaneko]iajpa( ao_]l]`]hae`]j]pqnav](mqa_kjoacqajkpankqjkoajpen]hckj]pqn]h(eopk(ia`k* Ai _anp]o ok_ea`]`ao pne^]eo( k oeopai] `a ]he]j]o ajpna ]o pne^ko( mqa `apaniej] ]o nah] ao`al]najpao_kmqaknc]jev]ia_kjoanr]i]_kiqje`]`a(atecamqa(]kj]o_an(] _ne]j]oaf]har]`]eni`kl]e(mqa`arannaolkjo]^ehev]n)oalah]re`]alah]a`q_]k `]_ne]j]*Aikqpn]o(koeopai]`al]najpao_katecamqa]_ne]j]oaf]ajpnacqaeni`] ia*Jko`keo_]oko(]nah]klnej_el]h`]_ne]j]aop]^aha_e`]_ki]pe]ajk_ki]ia ^ekh ce_]*Oa]ooei(_kikÚ_]]]Úni]k`amqa]oiqhdanao]i]ik^qro^ijbkqbkopbrp Úhdkoamqaabpk^qro^a^]iqhdanmqajk`aikjopn]aooa]iknÚ_]j`k_kikoÚhdkoa _qe`]j`k`ahao; Ai_anp]ook_ea`]`ao(_kjoe`an])oamqa]iqhdaneilqn]l]n]he`]n_ki]pann]a_ki ko]heiajpko*Lknaooaikperk(k_qhperk`]pann](klnal]nk`ko]heiajpkoako_qe`]`ko_ki ] _]o] ok `a naolkjo]^ehe`]`a `ko dkiajo( _]^aj`k o iqhdanao ] cqann] a k _ki]j`k `]_kiqje`]`a*Oa]ooei(_kikÚ_]]bn]oamqa]Úni]mqakdkiaibknpa(baepkl]n] kmqaatecabkn]a_kn]cai(l]n]k_ki]j`ka]cqann](ajmq]jpk]iqhdanbkebaep]l]n] ]i]panje`]`a(]_]o](kpn]^]hdk`kiope_k(]o]pere`]`ao`aqioanbncehaoajorah;Kq oaf](oakodkiajoa]oiqhdanaolkooqai_anp]o_]n]_panope_]oj]pqn]eo(aop]o`araioan k^nec]pkne]iajpaja_aoone]oaqjerano]eo(a]oiaoi]oaipk`kokopailkoahqc]nao$lkeo ]j]pqnav]klan]aipk`]l]npaaaipk`kpailkoailna`]iaoi]i]jaen]%(`aoknpamqa oaneilkoorahmqaqi]ok_ea`]`a]pne^q]]kodkiajop]nab]omqaqi]kqpn]ok_ea`]`a _kjoe`anak^qro^ijbkqbbaiejej]o(are_a)rano](mqa]pne^q]oiqhdanaop]nab]omqaqi] kqpn]ok_ea`]`a_kjoe`anak^qro^ijbkqbi]o_qhej]o* O]^a)oamqako_khkjev]`knaoaqnklaqo^n]j_ko(]kejopepqnai]ao_n]re`kj]=i) ne_](ao_khdan]iko]bne_]jko_kikao_n]rkolnabanaj_e]eolkn_kjoe`an]naimqakojacnko lkooq]i atpn]kn`ejne] bkn] boe_]( cn]j`a _]l]_e`]`a `a pn]^]hdk a iqep] ejpahecj_e] l]n]na]hev]np]nab]o_kik^fapkop_je_ko(_kikkajcajdk`a]_]n* Oa]ooei(oa]ao_n]re`k`ko]bne_]jkobkeejopepq`]lkn_]qo]`aoq]cn]j`a_]l]_e`]) `aaejpahecj_e]l]n]kpn]^]hdk`]]cne_qhpqn]a`kajcajdk`a]_]n(_kikÚ_]]]Úni]) k`amqa]j]pqnav]bavkojacnkoej`khajpao(lnacqekokoai]h]j`nko; Kn](kodeopkne]`knao^n]oehaenkoikopn]imqa]]^khek`]ao_n]r]pqn]$lah]mq]hiqe) pkojacnkohqp]n]iaiknnan]i%o bkena]hev]`]lahkAop]`k^n]oehaenkmq]j`k]ahepaa_k) jie_]_kjoe`ankqi]eohq_n]perkkqok`]ik`ak^n]eiecn]jpal]n]qi_anpkpelk`a ]cne_qhpqn] $k _]b% a l]n] ] ej`opne] j]o_ajpa* Bke( lknp]jpk( lkn n]v ao a_kjie_]o mqa ]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa^n]oehaen]`ko_qhkTET]`iepeq]]^khek`]ao_n]r]pqn](kmqa]_]n) napkq]oq^opepqek`koao_n]rko]bne_]jkolahkoeiecn]jpaoaqnklaqo*=]^khekbav_ki mqakian_]`k`apn]^]hdkbkooak_ql]`klahkopn]^]hd]`knao^n]j_koeiecn]jpaoamqa] i]ekne] `ko ao_n]rko he^anp]`ko Ú_]ooa oai ailnack( oai d]^ep]k( oai ]heiajp]k a oaijajdqi`enaepkok_e]h(a_kjie_kalkhpe_k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(koat)ao_n]rkoclo^j fjmbafalpabqo^_^ie^o_kikpn]^]hd]`knaohernaoabkn]ii]jpe`ko_kikan]iaiaop]`k `a_]peraenk(eopk(oai`enaepko*Jkdkqramobdrf ^k^qro^ijaifkalik`f^k^qro^iaoei `lkaf bp pl`f^fp b b`lkjf`^p mqa _]qo]n]i `aoailnack( a b]hp] `a c]n]jpe]o l]n] ] ok) ^narerj_e]aeila`eiajpk`a_kj`e ao`are`]`ecj]o$ikn]`e](raopqnek(]heiajp]k( ejopnqkao_kh]n(ap_*%* Lk`an]ikoat]iej]niqepk`kmqa`evaikokqkqreikoaijkook_kpe`e]jkk^oanr]j) `kkmq]jpkk^qro^ifw^jlpkooanaodqi]jko(j]pqn]hev]j`koaqo_kilknp]iajpko(e`ae]o( r]hknao(bkni]o`arerana`a]cen*Ran]ikoajpk_kik(ai_]`]_]ok(kob]pko`aoiajpai p]hj]pqn]hev]k*Ran]iko_kikkooanaodqi]jkor]ne]iai_kjoamqj_e]`]o_kj`e ao
/,1
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
ok_e]eo(a_kjie_]o(lkhpe_]o(deop ne_]oaimqarerai*Ran]ikomqaokikooanao_qf]]k `apaniej]jkookik`k`aoan(]cenalajo]namqa]e`ae]`aqicjankdqi]jkj]pqn]ha `aaol_eaodqi]j]oj]pqn]eojklkooqebqj`]iajpkj]na]he`]`a*Ran]ikomqa]e`ae]`a j]pqnav]dqi]j]_kik]hckqjerano]h(ejpailkn]haateopajpaaioealknoeiaoi]jkoa oqopajp]*Lknmq;Lknmqakooanaodqi]jkook_qhpqn]eokqdeopne_ko*
?qhpk(ej_qhpk6_qhpqn]
ÎL
a`nkiqepk_qhpk(_kjda_arne]ohjcq]o(ajpaj`a`a]npaa`ahepan]pqn]*Ï ÎEi]ceja_h]nkmqak=jpjekjklk`ak_ql]nk_]nckmqalhaepae]*Jkpai_qhpqn] jajdqi]*oaie]j]hb]^apkÏ ÎJk_naekmqa]o_qhpqn]obn]j_ao]kq]haioaf]ioqlaneknao^n]oehaen]*Rk_]_d] mqad]hcqi]_keo]oqlaneknjkoo]ioe_]lklqh]n;Ï ÎKqreqi]_kjbanj_e]mqa_nepe_]r]]_qhpqn]`ai]oo](i]oial]na_aqmqa]_kjba) naj_eop]`abaj`e]]_qhpqn]`aahepa*Lkneook(jk_kj_kn`aeejpaen]iajpa_kiah]*Ï ÎKhernk`aOehr]ok^na]_qhpqn]`kocq]n]jeo^aiejpanaoo]jpa*=lnaj`emqakik`k _kikajpaj`ai]naheceka]cqann]iqepk`ebanajpa`kjkook*Ï Aoo]obn]oaoaiqep]okqpn]omqab]vail]npa`kjkook`e]]`e]ej`e_]imqaailnac]) iko]l]h]rn]`riqro^$kqoaqo`aner]`ko(_kik`riql(fk`riql%aioajpe`koiqepk`ebanajpao a(lknravao(_kjpn]`ep neko* J]lneiaen]aj]oacqj`]bn]oamqaiaj_ekj]iko]_ei](_qhpqn]e`ajpeÚ_]`]_ki] lkooa`a_anpko_kjda_eiajpko$hjcq]o(]npa(hepan]pqn](oan]hb]^apev]`k%*Jah]o(b]h])oaai qboaklqbo_qhpqn](pbokqklpbo_qhpk*=lkooa`a_qhpqn]reop]_kik]hcklkoeperk(aj) mq]jpkÎoan ej_qhpkÏ _kjoe`an]`k ]hck jac]perk* = oacqj`] bn]oa `aet] ajpnaran mqaÎpan _qhpqn]Ïd]^ehep]]hcqi]k_ql]n]hcqilkopkkq_]nck(lkeoÎjkpan_qhpqn]ÏoecjeÚ_]jk aop]nlnal]n]`kl]n]qi]_anp]lkoekkqbqjk*Jaoo]o`q]olneiaen]obn]oao(]l]h]rn] `riqro^oqcanap]i^ilnaopcekanaolaepk(_kikoaÎpan_qhpqn]ÏkqÎoan_qhpkÏbkooakiao) ikmqaÎoaneilknp]jpaÏ(ÎoanoqlaneknÏ* Kn](mq]j`kl]oo]ikopan_aen]bn]oa(]_qhpqn]fjkl]na_aoanqi]lnklnea`]`amqa kej`er`qklkoo]pan(i]o]nr^ifa^ab`aqi]_khapere`]`aÍbn]j_aoao(]haiao(^n]oehaenko* P]i^iejpanaoo]jpak^oanr]nmqa]_khapere`]`a]l]na_a_kikqi]`faperkmq]heÚ_]perk l]n]`eopejcqenpelko`a_qhpqn]6]bn]j_ao](]]hai(]^n]oehaen]*Jaoo]bn]oa(]_qhpqn]oqnca _kik ]hck mqa ateopa ai oe a lkn oe iaoi] a mqa lk`a oan _kil]n]`] $_qhpqn] oqlanekn( _qhpqn]ejbanekn%* =hi`eook(j]bn]oa(_qhpqn]]l]na_analnaoajp]`]lknqi]]pere`]`a]npope_](]ioe) _]lklqh]n*Eooklaniepaaop]^aha_an`q]onah] ao`ebanajpao`]pan_aen]bn]oa_ki]o`q]o lneiaen]obn]oao6 -*
`ab]pk(]pan_aen]bn]oa(_kik]lneiaen](e`ajpeÚ_]_qhpqn]a]npao$ajpaj`an`a]npaa hepan]pqn](j]lneiaen]bn]oa7]ioe_]lklqh]n^n]oehaen](j]pan_aen]%7
.* jk ajp]jpk( ]hck _qnekok ]_kjpa_a mq]j`k l]oo]iko `]o `q]o lneiaen]o bn]oao pan) _aen](lkeoj]o`q]olneiaen]oÎ_qhpkÏaÎej_qhpkÏoqnce]i_kikafcbobk ^ppl`f^fp*Jqi l]o_kikkjkook(`evanmqa]hcqiej_qhpklknmqaoaie]j]hb]^apk`aet]pn]jo) l]na_anmqa_qhpqn]]hckmqamboqbk`b]_anp]o_]i]`]okq_h]ooaook_e]eook_e]hiaj) palnerehace]`]o(ajmq]jpk]ej_qhpqn]aop`kh]`k`kojklnerehace]`kook_e]hiajpa( lknp]jpk(`kh]`k`klkrka`klklqh]n*Ajpnap]jpk(]pan_aen]bn]oa]Úni]mqa]_qhpqn] ^n]oehaen]jkejbaneknbn]j_ao]kq]hailkn_]qo]`ajkoo]ioe_]mlmri^o+Jk aop]n]iko`e]jpa`aqi]_kjpn]`ek;?kiklk`ane]d]ran_qhpqn]lklqh]n$]ioe_]%( oaklklqh]nej_qhpk;
/,2
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
F ] mq]np] bn]oa $] mqa oa nabana _kjbanj_e] ok^na _qhpqn] `a i]oo]% ejpnk`qv qi jkrkoecjeÚ_]`kl]n]]l]h]rn]`riqro^*Jah]jkoapn]p]i]eo`alaook]o_qhp]okqej_qhp]o jai`aqi]_khapere`]`amqalkooqeqi]]pere`]`a_qhpqn]hmqalkoo]oan_kil]n]`]`a kqpn]o*=ckn](aop]iko`e]jpa`]e`ae]`amqakrj^jbpj^`libqfsfa^abkqkrj^jbpj^ pl`fba^ablk`ad]ran`keopelko`a_qhpqn]6]`ai]oo]a]`aahepa*=bn]oajkjko`evkmqa ]_qhpqn]$oane]lkooa`a_kjda_eiajpkokqoane]]pere`]`a]npope_];%*Ajpnap]jpk(]bn]oajko ejbkni]ok^naqi]klkoekajpnabkni]o`a_qhpqn](`alaj`aj`k`aoq]knecaia`aoq] `aopej]k(lkeo`riqro^abj^pp^p]jpklk`aoecjeÚ_]nÎknecej]`]j]i]oo]Ï_kikÎ`aopej]) `]i]oo]Ï(akiaoiklk`aoan`epk`]`riqro^abbifqb(kqoaf](lk`aoecjeÚ_]nÎknecej]`] j]ahepaÏkqÎ`aopej]`]ahepaÏ* Bej]hiajpa(]hpei]bn]oamqaiaj_ekj]iko_kikatailhk]lnaoajp]qioajpe`kpk) p]hiajpa `eranok `ko ]jpaneknao jk mqa pk_] l]h]rn] `riqro^* B]h])oa ]ckn] j] `riqro^ alp dr^o^kfpaaop]]l]na_aai`q]oi]jebaop] ao6]cqann]a]nahecek$mqa(lknp]jpk(j]`]pi] ran_ki]lkooa`a_kjda_eiajpko(_ki]pere`]`a]npope_]kq_ki]`ereokok_e]hajpnai]oo] aahepa%*Jaoo]hpei]bn]oa(]_qhpqn]]l]na_ajko _kik]hckln lnekalpcq]n]jeo(i]op]i) ^i_kik]hcqi]_keo]mqajkoaheiep]]k_]ilk`ko_kjda_eiajpkoa`]o]npao(lkeooa nabananah]k`kocq]n]jeo_kikp^do^al$]nahecek%a_kik`lkÜfqlb^jloqb$]cqann]%* Raiko(]ooei(mqal]oo]n`]j]pqnav]_qhpqn]mq]j`kb]h]iko`kooanaodqi]jkojk naokhra jkoo]o `eÚ_qh`]`ao `a _kilnaajok `aooao oanao( qi] rav mqa( ]ckn]( lna_eo]iko lancqjp]nkmqamqanaiko`evanmq]j`k]Úni]ikomqakooanaodqi]jkookoanao_qhpq) n]eo(reopkmqa]l]h]rn]`riqro^lkooqeiqepkooajpe`ko(]hcqjo`ahao_kjpn]`ep nekoajpnaoe*
J]pqnav]a_qhpqn]
J
klajo]iajpkk_e`ajp]h(k^qrobw^lkooqernekooajpe`ko6
lnej_lek`are`]kqlnej_lek]perkmqa]jei]aikreiajp]kooanao*Jaooaoajpe`k( b]h])oaaiÎ`aet]n]cen]j]pqnav]ÏkqÎoacqen]j]pqnav]Ïl]n]oecjeÚ_]nmqaoapn]p]`a qi]bkn]aolkjp ja](_]l]v`acan]na`a_qe`]n`apk`kokooanaolknah]can]`ko* aopakoajpe`k`]l]h]rn]cnac]mevpfp_ki]mq]h(_kikreiko(oaeje_e]]ejraopec]k Úhko Ú_]7 aooj_e]ln lne]`aqioankq]mqehkmqaqioanja_aoo]ne]iajpaaioeiaoik*Jao) oa]ola_pk(]j]pqnav]`a]hcqi]_keo]k_kjfqjpk`amq]he`]`ao(lnklnea`]`aoa]pne) ^qpkomqa]`aÚjailnklne]iajpa*Jk_]ok`kooanaorerko(oq]j`khakq`eolkoek ej]p](aolkjp ja]7a(jk_]ok`kooanaodqi]jko(aoo]`eolkoekej]p]oaqpailan]) iajpkkqoaq_]npan*=mqe(k^qro^ikqfk^qlkl ai)oa]kmqa^`fabkq^i$kmqalk`a oankq`aet]n`aoan%a]kmqa^anrfofallkn_kopqiakqlah]nah]k_kik]i^eajpa a_ki]o_en_qjop j_e]o`are`]7 knc]jev]kqjerano]haja_aoone]`kooanaooacqj`kqi]kn`ainace`]lknhaeoqjeran) o]eoaja_aoone]o*Jaooaoajpe`k(]j]pqnav]oa_]n]_panev]lahkkn`aj]iajpk`kooanao( lah]nacqh]ne`]`a`kobajiajkokq`kob]pko(lah]bnamqj_e](_kjop j_e]analapek `aaj_]`a]iajpkoÚtkoajpna]o_keo]o(eopk(`anah] ao`a_]qo]he`]`aajpnaah]o*Ai kqpnkopaniko(]j]pqnav]]kn`aia]_kjatkqjerano]haja_aoone]ajpna]o_keo]o( atlnaoo]oaihaeoj]pqn]eo*Pn]p])oa`]j]pqnav]p]h_kikaopq`]`]lah]o_ej_e]o`ep]o j]pqn]eo$boe_](mqie_](^ekhkce](]opnkjkie](ap_*%7 pq`kkmqaateopajkQjeranokoai]ejpanrajk`]rkjp]`aa`]]kdqi]j]o*Jaooa oajpe`k(k^qrobw^kqk^qro^ikl a)oa]^oqfÛ`f^i(^oqbc^ql(^oqfc`fl(q`kf`laqb`klidf`l* K^qro^ipq`kmq]jpkoalnk`qvaoa`aoajrkhraoaijajdqi]ejpanbanj_e]dqi]j]7
/,3
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
_kjfqjpk`apq`kmq]jpkateopaalan_a^e`klahkodqi]jko_kikkiaek]i^eajpa jkmq]hrerai*=j]pqnav](]mqe(p]jpkoecjeÚ_]k_kjfqjpk`]o_kj`e aoboe_]oaimqa reraiko_kik]o_keo]omqa_kjpailh]iko_kiaikk$]l]eo]cai(ki]n(k_q(]o aopnah]o(pannaikpko(a_heloao(pqb ao(anql aorqh_ je_]o(ap_*%*=j]pqnav]kiqj`k reorah_kikiaek]i^eajpaa_kik]mqehkmqaateopabkn]`aj oamqalnkrk_]e`ae]o aoajpeiajpkoaij o7 l]n]]o_ej_e]o_kjpailkn ja]o(]j]pqnav]jk]laj]o]na]he`]`aatpanj](`]`]a k^oanr]`](lan_a^e`]`enap]iajpalknj o(i]oqik^fapk`a_kjda_eiajpkah]^kn]) `klah]oklan] ao_eajpÚ_]ol]n]atlhe_]n]na]he`]`aatpanj]* Mq]jpk`riqro^(`keookoaqooecjeÚ_]`koeje_e]eo6 -*
.*
Rej`] `k ran^k h]pejk `libob( mqa pai k oajpe`k `aÎ_qhper]nÏ(Î_ne]nÏ(Îpki]n _kjp]Ï a Î_qe`]nÏ(`riqro^oecjeÚ_]r](j]=jpecqe`]`anki]j](k_qe`]`k`kdkiai_ki]j]) pqnav] Í `kj`a ^dof`riqro^* Pejd] k oajpe`k p]i^i `aÎ_qe`]`k `ko dkiajo _ki ko `aqoaoÏ $`kj`a ] l]h]rn] `riql l]n] oa nabanen ]ko nepko nahecekoko% a k `aÎ_qe`]`k _ki ] ]hi] a k _knlk `]o _ne]j]oÏ( _ki oq] a`q_]k a bkni]k $`kj`a ] l]h]rn] mrbof`riqro^%*Jaoo]hpei]]_alk(`riqro^an]k_qhperkkq]a`q_]k`kaolnepk`]o _ne]j]ol]n]pknj]nai)oaiai^nkoat_ahajpaokqrenpqkoko`]ok_ea`]`alahk]lanbae) k]iajpkanaÚj]iajpk`]omq]he`]`aoj]pqn]eo$_]npan(j`kha(pailan]iajpk%*?ki aooaoajpe`k(`riqro^_knnaolkj`e]]kmqakocnacko_d]i]r]i`am^fabf^(]bkni]k kqa`q_]k`k_knlka`kaolnepk`koiai^nko`]ok_ea`]`a$`am^fabf^rai]jkoo] l]h]rn]mba^dldf^%* Jaoo]lneiaen]]_alk(]_qhpqn]an]k]lneikn]iajpk`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]lah] a`q_]kaioajpe`k]ilhk(eopk(_kikbkni]k`]o_ne]j]ojko lah]]hb]^ape) v]k(i]op]i^ilah]eje_e]kre`]`]_khapere`]`alkniaek`k]lnaj`ev]`k`] `]j]a`]cejope_]$l]n]]a`q_]kkqbkni]k`k_knlk(lnal]n]j`k)kl]n]]o]pe) re`]`ao`]cqann]%a`a atan__eko iajp]eo( _ki k ]lnaj`ev]`k `acn]ipe_]( lkaoe]( kn]p ne]kqahkmqj_e](deop ne](_ej_e]oaÚhkokÚ]$l]n]]a`q_]kkqbkni]k`k aolnepk(lnal]n]j`k)kl]n]]o]pere`]`ao`]lkhpe_]%*=laook]_qhp]an]]laook]Úoe_]) iajpa^ailnal]n]`](ikn]hiajparenpqko](lkhepe_]iajpa_kjo_eajpaal]npe_el]jpa( ejpaha_pq]hiajpa`aoajrkhre`]lahk_kjda_eiajpk`]o_ej_e]o(`]o]npaoa`]ÚhkokÚ]* Lk`aiko k^oanr]n mqa( jaooa lneiaenk oajpe`k( `riqro^ a k^qrobw^ jk oa klq) jd]i*Kodqi]jkook_kjoe`an]`kooanaoj]pqn]eo(ai^kn]`ebanajpao`ko]jei]eoa `]olh]jp]olknmqaok`kp]`ko`ahejcq]caia`alajo]iajpk(eopk(lknmqalkooqai aolnepk*Oq]j]pqnav](lkni(jklk`aoan`aet]`]lkn_kjp]ln lne](lknmqapaj`an] oan]cnaooer](`aopnqper](ecjkn]jpa(lna_eo]j`klkneookoana`q_]`](bkni]`](_qhper]`] `a]_kn`k_kikoe`a]eo`aoq]ok_ea`]`a*=_qhpqn]qi]pbdrka^k^qrobw^mqa]a`q) _]kako_kopqiao]_nao_ajp]ij]pqnav]`a_]`]qi(eopk(qi]k^qrobw^^anrfof* a^(mqaiahdkn](]lanbaek]a`aoajrkhra]k^qrobw^fk^q^`a_]`]qi* =l]npen`ko_qhkTREEE(`riqro^l]oo]]oecjeÚ_]nlpobpriq^alpb^p`lkpbnrk`f^p`]) mqah]bkni]kkqa`q_]k`kooanaodqi]jko(naoqhp]`koatlnaookoaik^n]o(baepko( ] aoaejopepqe ao6]op_je_]oakokb_eko(]o]npao(]nahecek(]o_ej_e]o(]ÚhkokÚ](] re`]ikn]ha]re`]lkhpe_]kqkAop]`k*Pknj])oaoejjeik`a_erehev]klknmqakolaj) o]`knaofqhc]r]imqakonaoqhp]`ko`]bkni]k)a`q_]koai]jebaop]i_kii]ekn _h]nav]ajepe`avj]obkni]o`aknc]jev]k`]re`]ok_e]halkhpe_]kqj]re`]_ereh* Jaoo]oacqj`]]_alkpaiej_ek]oal]n]ka(lkopanekniajpa(]klkoekajpna k^qrobw^a`riqro^*Kolajo]`knao_kjoe`an]imqadajpnakdkiaia]j]pqnav]qi] `ebanaj]aooaj_e]h6aop]klan]lkn_]qo]he`]`aja_aoone]kq`a]_kn`k_kihaeoja_ao) one]o`a_]qo]aabaepk(i]okdkiai`kp]`k`ahe^an`]`aan]vk(]cej`klknao_khd]( `a]_kn`k_kir]hknaoaÚjoaop]^aha_e`kolknahaln lnek*Lkn_kjoacqejpa(]k^qrobw^ k_]ilk`]ja_aooe`]`a_]qo]hkq`aoneaokn`aj]`]o`a_]qo]oaabaepkomqaklan]i lknoeiaoiko(oai`alaj`an`]rkjp]`a`a]hcqi]cajpa7ai_kjpn]l]npe`](]`riqro^
PUERICULTURAßEMßLATIM ß PUERßSIGNIFICAß±MENINO²ßEß PUERA ß±MENINA²
CIVILßAßPALAVRAßCIVILßVEMßDOß LATIMßCIVES ßQUEßQUERßDIZERß ±CIDADjO² ßDEßONDEßVEMß CIVITAS ßAßCIDADE %STADO ß DONDEßCIVILIZAljOß
/,4
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
'UTOß,ACAZ!CERVOßDOßARTISTA
k_]ilkejopepq`klah]]k`kodkiajo(mqa]caiao_khdaj`khernaiajpaoaqo]pko( `]j`k]ahaooajpe`k(Új]he`]`aar]hknlknmqaejopepqai]o`eopej ao$ejateopajpaoj] j]pqnav]%ajpna^kiai]q(ran`]`aenkab]hok(pehajk_erk(fqopkaejfqopk(^ahkabaek( hacpeikaehacpeik(lkoorahaeilkoorah(o]cn]`kalnkb]jk* Çia`e`]mqaaopaoacqj`koajpe`kbkelnar]ha_aj`k(]hi`aÎ_erehev]kÏ(`riqro^ l]ookqp]i^i]oecjeÚ_]n]nah]kmqakooanaodqi]jkook_e]hiajpaknc]jev]`ko $eopk(_erehev]`ko%aop]^aha_ai_kikpailka_kikaol]k(_kikokqpnkooanaodq) i]jkoa_ki]j]pqnav](nah] aomqaoapn]jobkni]ijkpailkar]ne]i_kjbknia]o _kj`e ao`kiaek]i^eajpa*=ckn](_qhpqn]pknj])oaoejjeik`adeopne]* =`eopejkajpnak^qrobw^a`riqro^l]oo](ajpk(]ha) r]nai_kjp]]i]jaen]_kikkpailkoana]hev]6j]j]pq) nav](kpailkobmbqf l$k`e]oailnaoq_a`a]jkepa(]o aop] ao`k]jkoaoq_a`aioailna`]iaoi]i]jaen](]o aol_eaoracap]eoa]jei]eooanalnk`qvaioailna`]iao) i]i]jaen](ko]opnkona]hev]ioailnakoiaoikoikre) iajpko(ap_*%7kpailk`]_qhpqn]k`]qo^kpcloj^ l$eopk (`]oiq`]j]ojko_kopqiao(j]ohaeo(j]oaik ao(jko lajo]iajpko( j]o p_je_]o( jk raopqnek( j] ]heiajp]k( j]hejcq]cai(j]oejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o(ap_*%*L]n] rnekoÚh okbkoadeopkne]`knao(]_qhpqn]oqncamq]j`kko dkiajolnk`qvai]olneiaen]opn]jobkni] aoj]j]pqna) v]lah]]k`kqo^_^iel*?kikpn]^]hdk(kooanaodqi]jko lnk`qvaik^fapkoejateopajpaoj]j]pqnav]$_]o](qpajoheko( ejopnqiajpko%(knc]jev]i)oaok_e]hiajpal]n]na]hev)hk( `ere`ej`k ]o p]nab]o ajpna dkiajo a iqhdanao( ]`qhpko a _ne]j]o*L]n]]qiajp]nkona_qnokolnk`qve`ko(ejopepqai ]b]ihe]a]onah] ao`al]najpao_k(]o]h`ae]oareh]o*L]n] lnkpac)h]o(ejrajp]i]o]ni]oa]cqann]*L]n]_kjoacqen oailna_kj`e aob]rknraeol]n]kpn]^]hdkal]n]]ia) hdkne]`kmqalnk`qvai(ejrk_]ia]`kn]ibkn]o`erej]o( ejopepqej`k ] nahecek* Ko rneko ]cnql]iajpko dqi]jko( j]o_e`ko`kpn]^]hdka`kooeopai]o`al]najpao_k(pnk_]i ajpnaoelnk`qpko`aoaqopn]^]hdko(ejrajp]j`kk_kin_ek* =o`aoecq]h`]`aooqncaimq]j`kqi]l]npa`]_kiqje`]) Oej]eo`kopailko( `apki]l]n]oe(_kiklnklnea`]`alner]`](pann]o(]jei]eo( k^n]`aCqpkH]_]v* cq]o6_kia]]`ereokok_e]h`akj`aoqncenk]o_h]ooao ok_e]eoako_kjÛepkoa(`aopao(]ejopepqek`klk`an*
?qhpqn]adeopne]
?
/,5
kiG]jp(_kjokhe`])oa]e`ae]`amqa]j]pqnav]knaejk`]_]qo]he`]`akq`]ja_ao) oe`]`aajmq]jpk]_qhpqn]knaejk`]rkjp]`adqi]j](`]]k`kp]`]`aÚj]he`]`a a`]he^an`]`a(p]eo_kikoaatlneiaij]pe_](j]lkhpe_](j]o]npao(j]o_ej_e]oa j]ÚhkokÚ]* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(G]jp`eopejcqeqajpnakobfkla^k^qrobw^Íeopk(`]o_keo]ooq^) iape`]oohaeoj]pqn]eo`a_]qo]he`]`a(mqaokqjerano]eoaja_aoone]oÍakobfkla^jlo^i Íkqoaf](`]o] aodqi]j]ona]hev]`]olknqi]ao_khd]rkhqjpne]kqlknhe^an`]`aaoa) cqj`kÚj]he`]`aon]_ekj]eo*=l]npen`aajpk(]oal]n]kajpnaobfkla^kb`bppfa^abaobfkl a^if_boa^abbkeejpanlnap]`]_kikoal]n]kajpnak^qrobw^a`riqro^* Dacah( jk ajp]jpk( _kilnaaj`aq aoo] oal]n]k `a i]jaen] ^]op]jpa `erano]* L]n] ]_kil]jd]nikooaqlajo]iajpklna_eo]iko(lknqiikiajpk(napki]n]jkk`aaf^i* qf`^(mqareikoaikqpn]oQje`]`ao`aopahernk*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=deopne]dacahe]j] Lh]pka=neop pahao(`erancej`kmq]jpk]kl]lah`]`e]hpe_]jk_kjda_eiajpk(_kj_kn) `]r]ilknijqilkjpk6]`e]hpe_]kidlp$eopk(klajo]iajpkak`eo_qnokatlnaooko jqi]lnklkoekkqjqifqvk%`ere`e`kailna`e_]`koklkopkokq_kjpnneko(_kik(lkn atailhk6Î]_kn]caiqi]renpq`aÏaÎ]_kn]caijkqi]renpq`aÏ7Îkdkiaiqi]je) i]hn]_ekj]hÏaÎkdkiaijkqi]jei]hn]_ekj]hÏ*Kqoaf](j]`e]hpe_](koqfaepk`aqi] lnklkoekkq`aqifqvk]l]na_a`ere`e`kejpanj]iajpalknlna`e_]`ko_kjpn]`ep nekoÍ Î]_kn]caiajkqi]renpq`aÏ7Îkdkiaiajkn]_ekj]hÏ* Kn](`evaiko`keoÚh okbko(]na]he`]`aa]ran`]`ak^a`a_ai]klnej_lek`ae`ajpe) `]`aaat_hqai]_kjpn]`ek*Aop]_kjoe`an]`]foob^i$`klkjpk`areop]`]na]he`]`a%a fjmlppsbi$`klkjpk`areop]`]ran`]`a%(lkeoenna]haeilkoorahmqaqi]_keo]oaf]a jkoaf]ah]iaoi]]kiaoikpailkaj]iaoi]nah]k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]hckna]ha ran`]`aenkmq]j`k6 -*
lk`aiko_kjda_ank_kjfqjpk`aoaqolna`e_]`kolkoeperko(eopk(]omq]he`]`aoalnk) lnea`]`aomqa_kjopepqaioq]aooj_e]7
.*
lk`aiko]b]op]nkolna`e_]`kojac]perko(mqaok_kjpnneko]kolkoeperkoamqa(oaaope) ranailnaoajpao(`aopnkai]e`ajpe`]`akq]aooj_e]`]_keo]*Ainaoqik(lna`e_]`ko lkoeperkoajac]perkojklk`aiaop]nfqjpkojqiiaoikoqfaepkkqjqi]iaoi]_ke) o](lkeoaoo]qjek`ko_kjpnnekoqi]_kjpn]`eka]_kjpn]`ek`aopn e]na]he`]`a `aqi]_keo]kq`aqi]aooj_e]*
POSITIVOßEMßGERAL ß ATRIBUI SEßOßCARfTERßDEß POSITIVOßgQUILOßQUEßmßREAL ß CONCRETOßEßEXISTENTE ßß OUßQUEßmßDADOßNAßß EXPERIoNCIA
Lh]pka=neop pahaooaajc]j]n]i(fqhc]Dacah*L]n]aha(Î]`e]hpe_]]je_]i]jaen] lah]mq]hlk`aiko]h_]j]n]na]he`]`aa]ran`]`ajklah]aheiej]k`ko_kjpn]`ep neko( i]o_kilnaaj`aj`kmqakna]hakran`]`aenkj]`]i]eook`kmqakikreiajpkejpan) jk `] _kjpn]`ekÏ( lkeo( _kik f `eooan] o]^e]iajpa Dan_hepk(Î] na]he`]`a k Ûqtk `ko _kjpn]`ep nekoÏ* Jk ajp]jpk( `ev Dacah( Dan_hepk p]i^i oa ajc]jkq lknmqa fqhc]n] mqa kopaniko_kjpn]`ep nekoan]il]nao`apanikolkoeperkoklkopko$mqajpa)bnek(oa_k)ie`k( _h]nk)ao_qnk(`k_a)]i]nck(o]`ek)`kajpa(rerk)iknpk(ap_*%*=ran`]`aen]_kjpn]`ek`e]hpe) _]lkooqe`q]o_]n]_panope_]olnej_el]eo6 -*
Kopaniko_kjpn]`ep nekojkok`keopanikolkoeperko`lkqooflpkqlmlpqlp(i]o`keo lna`e_]`ko_kjpn]`ep neko`kiaoikoqfaepkamqao ateopaijac]j`kqi]kkqpnk* Aihqc]n`a`evanmqajpa)bnek(oa_k)ie`k(`k_a)]i]nck(i]pane]h)aolenepq]h(j]pqn]h)_qh) pqn]h(`araiko_kilnaaj`anmqa(af^ibqf`^jbkqb(lna_eok`evan6mqajpa)jkmqajpa( bnek)jkbnek(`k_a)jk`k_a(]i]nck)jk]i]nck(i]pane]h)jki]pane]h(aolenepq]h)jk aolenepq]h(j]pqn]h)jkj]pqn]h(_qhpqn]h)jk_qhpqn]h7
.*
Kjac]perk$kkl`ajk`k_a(jkbnek(jki]pane]h(jk_qhpqn]h(ap_*%(lknp]jpk(jk qipaniklkoeperk`lkqoofl]kqpnklkoeperk(i]oran`]`aen]iajpalkbd^qfsl`a qilkoeperk*Oaaq`eooan(lknatailhk(Îk_]`anjkjk]nrknaÏ(aooakljkqi ran`]`aenkjac]perk(lkeok_]`anjka]nrkna_kjpejq]i_kik`keopanikolkoeperko* Aooakl(oeilhaoiajpa(oecjeÚ_]mqak_]`anjka]nrknaok`q]o_keo]o`ebanajpao( _]`]mq]h_kioq]olnklnea`]`aoamq]he`]`aoln lne]o(_]`]mq]hateopej`klanbaep]) iajpaqioaikkqpnk*Aooakl(`evDacah(ian]kbd^ lbuqbok^(j]mq]hmq]hmqan _keo]lk`aoan]jac]k`amq]hmqankqpn]$k_]`anjkjk6]nrkna(]iao](]^kh](k iajejk(Fkk(]lknp](ap_*%(lkeo_]`]_keo]lk`aoanlan_a^e`]alajo]`]lkoeper]iajpa oai]okqpn]o*J]jac]katpanj](`evaikomqaÎ=ÏjkÎ>Ï(Î?ÏkqÎ@Ï(a_]`]qi`ao) oaopanikorjlrqol_kinah]k]ko`ai]eo*Kran`]`aenkjac]perkqi]kbd^ l fkqbok^(j]mq]hkpanikjac]`kjkrjlrqolmq]hmqan(i]ollrqolalprgbfqlkql pbrlrqol*J]jac]kejpanj](`evaikomqaÎ=Ï]kiaoikpailkaj]iaoi]nah]k Î=ajk=Ï*Lknatailhk(o]^aikomqaqi_]`anjkbaepk`al]lahamqakl]lahrai `]onrknao7`e]hape_]iajpa(jk`enaikoÎk_]`anjkjk]nrknaÏaoeimqaÎk_]`an) jkqi]jknrknaÏ*
/-,
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
/--
J]jac]kejpanj]d_kjpn]`eklnklne]iajpa`ep]a]`e]hpe_](mqa_kjopepqekpai) lka]deop ne](kikreiajpklahkmq]hdlkoek(oqlnaookaoqlan]k`]o_kjpn]`e ao* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(aihqc]n`a]_kjpn]`ekoan]`aopnqeklqn]aoeilhao`aqioqfaepk( ah]kikreiajpk`aoq]na]hev]kran`]`aen]* =_kjpn]`ek`e]hpe_]jkonarah]mqa(aihqc]n`apki]niko`keooqfaepko_kjpnneko( _]`] mq]h _ki oaqo lna`e_]`ko lkoeperko ln lneko( a at]iej]niko ] klkoek ajpna ahao( `araiko_kilnaaj`anmqaqio aiaoikoqfaepk_kjopepq`klknlna`e_]`ko_kjpn]`ep ) neko(lknqi]]Úni]kaqi]jac]kejpanj]o(amqakpn]^]hdkmqakoqfaepkna]hev]l]n] oqlan]naoo]_kjpn]`ekkikreiajpk`kln lnekpailk(]ln lne]deop ne]* Mqaiaooaoqfaepkmqana]hev]kikreiajpk`]lkoekaoqlan]k`alna`e_]`ko_kj) pn]`ep nekokq`]o_kjpn]`e ao;Dacahk_d]i]`aÎkAolnepkÏ*Lknmqakoqfaepk`kolna`e_]) `ko_kjpn]`ep nekokAolnepk;Lknmqakikreiajpk`]deop ne]naÛaterkaokiajpaqi aolnepk_]l]v`anaÛatk(eopk(`arkhp]n)oaok^naoeiaoika`a_kjda_an)oa]oeiaoik* Kmqaaoo]naÛatk;Kikreiajpkjkmq]hkAolnepkoa_khk_]]oeiaoik_kikbpm* ofql(lnk`qvej`kkpailka]deop ne]* KAolnepk_kia]oaqlan_qnokpailkn]h_kikqioqfaepk`kmq]h]k^qrobw^qi lna`e_]`k_kjpn]`ep nek*Kqoaf](kAolnepkejpanekne`]`aajkejpanekne`]`a*?kikjk ejpanekne`]`aahaj]pqnav](kjkAolnepk*Jkej_ek`klan_qnokdeop ne_k)pailkn]h(lkn) p]jpk(kAolnepkjkAolnepk(lkeoj]pqnav]kqlqn]atpanekne`]`a*=atpaneknev]k`k Aolnepk_kikj]pqnav]k^n]oq](i]oaoo]k^n]oq]jac]k_kikAolnepklknmqaaha( mqaei]pane]h(oa]lnaoajp]j]lqn]i]pane]he`]`a`]j]pqnav]kq_kikk_kjfqjpk`]o_ke) o]oj]pqn]eo*KAolnepkeje_e]oq]i]n_d]pailkn]hlkj`k)oa]oeiaoik_kik`lfp^$oq^o) p j_e](mq]he`]`a(mq]jpe`]`a(nah] ao`a_]qo]aabaepk(ap_*%*Ahapann](cq](]n(bkck(_q( ]opnko(i]nao(iejan]eo(racap]eo(]jei]eo* L]n]_kjoanr]n)oarerk(_]`]oanj]pqn]h$kq_]`]_keo]%lna_eo]_kjoqienkooanaomqak nk`ae]i6ko]jei]eo_kjokiaicq](lh]jp]o(kqpnko]jei]eo(]n(_]hkn(hqv7]olh]jp]o_kj) okiai_]hkn(cq](hqv7ko]opnko_kjokiaiajance]ai]pne](ap_*Kn](eookoecjeÚ_]mqak Aolnepkajmq]jpkj]pqnav]jac])oa]oeiaoik_kjoqiej`k)oa]oeiaoik* Aoo] jac]k `a oe `] j]pqnav] lahk _kjoqik jk pn]jobkni]`kn]( lkeo ah] oa na]) hev]]laj]ol]n]_kjoanr]n]o_keo]oj]pqn]eo*Ajpnap]jpk(kAolnepkjki]jebaop]]laj]o oaqlna`e_]`kjac]perk(]jkejpanekne`]`akqj]pqnav](i]op]i^ii]jebaop]qikqpnk lna`e_]`k(klna`e_]`k`]jkatpanekne`]`a(mqajac]]atpanekne`]`a`]j]pqnav]*Aooalna) `e_]`k`]jkatpanekne`]`a]`lkp`fk`f^_kimqakAolnepkl a)oa]oeiaoik_kikej) panekne`]`akqjkatpanekne`]`a*?kikj]pqnav](kAolnepk]ejpanekne`]`amqaoa]Úni] _kikjkejpanekne`]`akqlqn]atpanekne`]`a7_kik_kjo_ej_e](kAolnepk]jkatpanek) ne`]`akqjac]k`]atpanekne`]`aj]pqn]h*?kikj]pqnav](kAolnepkjac]oq]ejpanekne) `]`a(ateopej`kok^]bkni]`ko_knlkoj]pqn]eo7_kik_kjo_ej_e](]Úni])oa`ebanajpa`] j]pqnav]ajac]]atpanekne`]`aj]pqn]h*KAolnepklnk`qv]ooei]_kjpn]`ekajpna]oq] ateopj_e]_kik_keo]aoq]ateopj_e]_kik_kjo_ej_e]* ?kikkooanaoj]pqn]eo(]_kjo_ej_e]p]i^i^qo_]_kjoanr]n)oa(i]okb]vjklahk oeilhao_kjoqik`]o_keo]oj]pqn]eo(i]olah]jac]k`]ian]j]pqn]he`]`a`ah]o*Kmqa aoo]jac]k; Mq]j`k`eckÎEopkqi]ikjp]jd]Ï(pajdk]eilnaook`amqaianaÚnk]qi]_keo] j]pqn]h(`ebanajpa`aiei(ateopajpaaioeiaoi]a_ki_]n]_panope_]olkoeper]oln lne]o* Ajpnap]jpk(koeilhaob]pk`amqaaq_d]iaqi]_keo]`aÎikjp]jd]Ïej`e_]mqaah](aj) mq]jpkikjp]jd]kq_kikikjp]jd](jkateopabjpf(i]oateopam^o^jfj(eopk(lkooqe qioajpe`kaiiejd]atlanej_e]*Kqoaf](jkraiko]j]pqnav]`]njkiao]oeiaoi]a o_keo]oj]pqn]eo*Okikoj omqa]ojkia]iko(`evaj`k_kikateopail]n]j o* Oqlkjd]iko]ckn]mqaaqlanpaj]]qi]_kiqje`]`a_qf]nahecekoaf]lkhepaop](mqa ]_na`epamqako`aqoao(oqlaneknao]kodkiajo(i]o`kp]`ko`abkni]dqi]j](d]^ep]iko hqc]nao]hpko*L]n]iei(]ckn](qi]ikjp]jd]jki]eoqi]oeilhao_keo](i]o]ikn]`] o]cn]`]`ko`aqoao*Kq(ajpk(ei]cejaikomqaokikoqi]ailnao]_]lep]heop]atlhkn]`k) n]`aiejnekoamqad]f]qi]f]ve`]`abannkj]ikjp]jd]*?kikailnaoneko(_kiln]iko
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
]ikjp]jd]l]n]atlhkn)h]*Jkr]iajpa(ah]`aetkq`aoanqi]oeilhao_keo]j]pqn]hl]n] pknj]n)oalnklnea`]`alner]`](hk_]h`apn]^]hdka_]lep]h*Ei]cejaiko(lknÚi(mqaokiko lejpknao a mqa r]iko lejp]n ] ikjp]jd]* Jaooa _]ok( ah] jk jai ikn]`] `ko `aqoao( jailnklnea`]`alner]`]_]lep]heop](jaihk_]h`apn]^]hdk(i]obkni](_kn(rkhqia(hejd]o( lnkbqj`e`]`aÍqi_]ilk`areoe^ehe`]`a* Ok^ aoo]o mq]pnk bkni]o ÍÎeopk qi] ikjp]jd]Ï(Îikn]`] `ko `aqoaoÏ(Îf]ve`] `a iejnek`abannk+lnklnea`]`alner]`]+_]lep]hÏaÎ_]ilk`areoe^ehe`]`a]oanlejp]`kÏÍ(] ikjp]jd]_kik`lfp^j]pqn]h`ao]l]na_aq(bkejac]`]_kikian]_keo]lah]_kjo_ej_e]* Pknjkq)oakl`lfp^lknmqaoapknjkqikjp]jd]l]n]j o(oecjeÚ_]k(qiajpa_qhpqn]h* Aipanikodacahe]jko(kAolnepkjackq)oa_kikj]pqnav]pn]jobkni]j`k)oaj]jkj]pq) nav](eopk(j]_qhpqn]* = j]pqnav] k oan ai oe( ] jac]k abapq]`] lah] _kjo_ej_e] ] pn]jobknikq ai oan l]n]j okqoanl]n]]_kjo_ej_e]*Reopkmqa]_kjo_ej_e]naÛater](eopk(_kjo_ej_e]`a oekqqio]^anok^naoe(ah]l]n]oe*Lk`aiko`evanmqakikreiajpkpailkn]h`ajac]k na]hev]`klahkAolnepk]l]oo]cai`kbjpf]km^o^pfamqaaoo]l]oo]caikikreiajpk mqahar]kAolnepk`]j]pqnav]_qhpqn]*@araiko_kilnaaj`anmqa]jac]k`e]hpe_]jk oecjeÚ_]]`aopnqekailne_]kqi]pane]h`a_keo]o$]cq](k]n(]pann](kbkck(]i]pne](] ajance](ko_knlkoj]pqn]eo_kjpejq]iateopej`k%(aoei]`aopnqek`aoaqpbkqfaleia`e]pk mqaprmbo^allknqioajpe`kjkrk(lknqioecjeÚ_]`kjkrkmqaah]ol]oo]i]panl]n] j o(oecjeÚ_]`kmqalkopklahkln lnekAolnepk_kik_kjo_ej_e]* =k na_kjda_an)oa _kik ikreiajpk ejpanjk `a lkoek( jac]k a oqlnaook `a oaqo lna`e_]`ko_kjpn]`ep neko$j]pqnav]ajkj]pqnav]kq_kjo_ej_e]7_kjo_ej_e]ajk_kjo) _ej_e]kqj]pqnav]%(kAolnepkoana_kjda_a_kikoqfaepkmqaoalnk`qv]oeiaoikamqa ahajkoajkkikreiajpk`alnk`qk`aoeiaoik*AooaikreiajpkaimqakAolnepk oaatpaneknev]j]j]pqnav]aoaejpaneknev]j]_qhpqn]]efpqof^jk_kikoamqj_e]pailk) n]h`a]_kjpa_eiajpkoa`a_]qo]oaabaepko(i]o_kikre`]`kAolnepk* Kpailk(lknp]jpk(]re`]`kAolnepk(kik`k_kikkAolnepkoal a]oeiaoikaoa `aoajrkhra*Kpailk_qhpqn]hkpailk`]ok^n]oaejopepqe aodqi]j]oÍnahecek(]npao( _ej_e]o(ÚhkokÚ](ejopepqe aook_e]eo(ejopepqe aolkhpe_]o*=_]`]lank`k`aoq]pailkn]) he`]`akAolnepkoa]lnaoajp]j]bkni]`aqi]_qhpqn]`apaniej]`](mqaatlneiakaopcek `a`aoajrkhreiajpkaolenepq]hkqn]_ekj]h`]dqi]je`]`aaj]mq]h_]`]_qhpqn]l]npe_qh]n oaatlneia_kiqi_]npanln lnekmqajac]`kaqhpn]l]oo]`klahkoaopcekooacqejpao( jqilnkcnaook_kjpjqk*
=deopne]aiI]nt I]nt(mqap]i^i_kj_a^a]_qhpqn]_kikdeop ne](_nepe_]]_kj_alkdacahe]j](kq kfab^ifpjlbpmfofqr^ifpq^`aDacah*L]n]aha(]_qhpqn]jki]jebaop]k`kAolnepkaoei kik`k_kik(ai_kj`e ao`apaniej]`]oajkao_khde`]olknahao(kodkiajolnk`qvai i]pane]hiajpa$lahkpn]^]hdk(lah]knc]jev]ka_kjie_]%oq]ateopj_e]a`koajpe`k] aoo]lnk`qki]pane]h*=deop ne]jkj]nn]kikreiajpkpailkn]h`kAolnepk(i]o]ohq) p]ona]eo`kooanaodqi]jkona]eomqalnk`qvaianalnk`qvaioq]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo`a ateopj_e](eopk(lnk`qvaianalnk`qvai]oobi^ bppl`f^fp(lah]omq]eooa`eopejcqai`] j]pqnav]aj]omq]eookejopepq`]o]o`ereo aook_e]eo(kqoaf](]o_h]ooaook_e]eo_kjpn]`ep ) ne]o*?]`]_qhpqn]atlneia]i]jaen]_kikjah]oa`aÚjai]lnklnea`]`aa]`ereokok_e]h `kpn]^]hdk(oaknc]jev]i]oejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]omqareo]i_kjoanr]k`]bkn) i]ateopajpa`]lnklnea`]`aaoklnk`qve`]o]oe`ae]o_kimqa]o_h]ooaook_e]eoatlhe_]i l]n]oeiaoi]okoajpe`k`]bkni]kok_e]haimqarerai* =o`ebanajpaobkni] aook_e]eook`apaniej]`]olahkik`k`alnk`qka`analnk`q) k`]re`]i]pane]h`kodkiajo7aoo]obkni] aook_e]eook_kjopepq`]olkn_kjpn]`e ao ejpanj]oajpnakodkiajo`ere`e`koai_h]ooaook_e]eo_kjpnne]oaaihqp]*Kikreiajpk`] deop ne])_qhpqn](lknp]jpk(na]hev]`klah]hqp]`]o_h]ooaook_e]eol]n]i]jpankql]n]raj) _anbkni]o`aatlhkn]ka_kjie_](klnaookok_e]h(`kiej]klkhpe_]*KÚi`aoo]ohq)
/-.
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
p]oa`]o_kjpn]`e ao`alaj`an`]_]l]_e`]`a`aknc]jev]klkhpe_]a`a_kjo_ej_e]`] hpei]_h]ooaok_e]hatlhkn]`]$klnkhap]ne]`k(lnk`qve`klahk_]lep]heoikej`qopne]h%l]n] aheiej]n]`aoecq]h`]`aa]ejfqope]deop ne_]o*
?qhpqn]a]jpnklkhkce] ANTROPOLOGIAßAßPALAVRAß ANTROPOLOGIAßmßCOMPOSTAß DEßDUASßPALAVRASßGREGASß ANTROPOS ßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±HOMEM² ßEßLOGqA ß±ESTU ß DO²ßPALAVRAßDERIVADAßß DEßLvGOS ßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±PENSAMENTOßOUßRAZjO² ß ±LINGUAGEMßOUßDISCURSO²
=
]jpnklkhkce] aopq`] ko oanao dqi]jko j] _kj`ek `a oanao _qhpqn]eo* K ]jpnkl ) hkcklnk_qn](]jpao`ai]eoj]`](`apaniej]naimqaikiajpka`amqai]jaen] kodqi]jkoejopepqaioq]`ebanaj]ainah]kj]pqnav](b]vaj`k]ooeioqncenk iqj`k_qhpqn]h* KoÚh okbko(]l]npen`ko_qhkTREEE(_kjoe`an]n]imqakodqi]jko`ebanai`]j]pqna) v]cn]]o]klajo]iajpk(hejcq]cai(]kpn]^]hdka]krkhqjpne]herna* Ko]jpnkl hkcko(]l]npen`ko_qhkTT(oaijac]n]]Úni]k`koÚh okbko(lnk_qn]i ]mqah]]k_ki]mq]hkooanaodqi]jkoejopepqai]_qhpqn]lnklne]iajpa`ep]*Kqoaf]( _kikkoÚh okbko(ko]jpnkl hkckop]i^i_kjoe`an]imqa]o_kj`e aol]n]mqad]f]_qh) pqn]okklajo]iajpk(]hejcq]cai(kpn]^]hdka]]krkhqjpne](lknifqhc]imqajk ^]op]]lkjp]naoo]o_kj`e aoamqalna_eok`evanmqa]kkodkiajoln]pe_]n]ikqmqa `a_eokpki]n]imqakoÚvan]il]oo]n`]lkooe^ehe`]`a`]_qhpqn]na]he`]`aabaper]`ah]* Oa(l]n]iqepkodeopkne]`knao(aoo]]kbkekpn]^]hdk(l]n]iqepko]jpnkl hkcko]_qh) pqn]bkeejopepq`]mq]j`kkodqi]jkoi]n_]n]ioei^khe_]iajpaoq]`ebanaj]_kinah]) kj]pqnav](`a_nap]j`kqi]haemqajklk`ane]oanpn]jocna`e`]a(oakbkooa(]_kiqje) `]`aatecene]nal]n]k_ki]iknpa`kpn]jocnaookn*=`ebanaj]ajpnadkiaiaj]pqnav]( mqa`knecai_qhpqn](oqnca_ki]hae`]lnke^ek`kej_aopk(haeejateopajpaajpnako]je) i]eo*Aoo]hae`ej_ekoatq]he`]`alnklne]iajpadqi]j](mqajk]laj]o]o]peob]k eia`e]p]`aqi]ja_aooe`]`a^ekh ce_](i]o`aÚje`]lknnacn]omqaejopepqaiklnke^e`k aklaniepe`kj]atlnaook`k`aoafk*Kooanaodqi]jko`koajpe`koatq]he`]`a* L]n]]hcqjo]jpnkl hkcko(]hi`aoo]hae(]`ebanaj]ajpnadkiaiaj]pqnav]p]i^i aop]^aha_e`]mq]j`kkodqi]jko`aÚjaiqi]kqpn]haemqa(oapn]jocna`e`](_]qo]]nq) j]`]_kiqje`]`aa`kej`er`qk6]haemqaoal]n]k_nqak_kve`k(haep]i^iejateopajpa ajpnako]jei]eo*=oal]n]kajpnak_nqak_kve`ka]atecj_e]`amqakodqi]jko_ki]i ]heiajpkomqal]oo]n]ilahkbkck_khk_]i]_qhejne]jklkjpkeje_e]h`]_qhpqn]*=ooei _kik]oatq]he`]`adqi]j](p]i^i]]heiajp]kdqi]j]jk]laj]o]o]peob]k`a qi]ja_aooe`]`a^ekh ce_]`aok^narerj_e](i]oaophec]`]]nacn]omqahda`kqioajpe) `klnklne]iajpadqi]jk* Aoo]o`q]olneiaen]ohaeoaopnqpqn]ikiqj`kdqi]jk]l]npen`]klkoekajpnamrol $laniepe`k%afjmrol$lnke^e`k%(klkoekejateopajpal]n]pk`kknaop]jpa`]j]pqnav]*Oa) tq]he`]`aa_qhejne]ejpnk`qvai]`eiajokoei^ he_]`]re`]dqi]j]*
=_qhpqn]_kikkn`aioei^he_]
= /-/
_qhpqn]ejopepq`]jkikiajpkaimqakodqi]jko`apaniej]il]n]oeiaoiko nacn]oajkni]o`a_kj`qp]mqa]ooacqn]i]ateopj_e]a_kjoanr]k`]_kiqje) `]`aalkneook`araioank^a`a_e`]ook^laj]`alqjek$mqalk`aen`ao`aqi _]opeckkq]atlqhokl]n]hkjca`kcnqlk`aknecai]p]iknpa%* Kmqa]haedqi]j];=haedqi]j]qii]j`]iajpkok_e]hmqaknc]jev]pk`]]re`] `koej`er`qkoa`]_kiqje`]`a(p]jpklknmqa`apaniej]kik`k`aaop]^aha_eiajpk`ko _kopqiaoa`aoq]pn]joieook`acan]k]can]k_kiklknmqalnaoe`a]o] aomqa_ne]i ]oejopepqe aook_e]eo$nahecek(b]ihe](bkni]o`apn]^]hdk(cqann]al]v(`eopne^qek`]op]) nab]o(bkni]o`alk`an(ap_*%*=haejkqi]oeilhaolnke^ekl]n]_anp]o_keo]oak^nec]k l]n]kqpn]o(i]o]]Úni]k`amqakodqi]jkook_]l]vao`a_ne]nqi]kn`ai`aateo) pj_e]mqajkoeilhaoiajpaj]pqn]h$boe_](^ekh ce_]%*Aoo]kn`ai]kn`aioei^he_]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=kn`aioei^ he_]_kjoeopaj]_]l]_e`]`adqi]j]l]n]`]no_keo]oqioajpe`kmqa aop]hi`aoq]lnaoaj]i]pane]h(eopk(j]_]l]_e`]`a`a]pne^qenoecjeÚ_] aoar]hknao o_keo]oa]kodkiajo(`eopejcqej`kajpna^aiai]h(ran`]`aab]hoe`]`a(^ahav]abaeqn]7 `apaniej]j`koaqi]_keo]kqqi]]kfqop]kqejfqop](hacpei]kqehacpei](lkoorah kqeilkoorah*aoo]`eiajokoei^ he_]mqaejopepq`]_ki]hae`]lnke^ek`kej_aopk a]hae`]lnke^ek`k_nq* Cn]]ohejcq]caia]kpn]^]hdk(kooanaodqi]jkopki]i_kjo_ej_e]`kpailka `]o`ebanaj]opailkn]eo$l]oo]`k(lnaoajpa(bqpqnk%(pki]i_kjo_ej_e]`]iknpaahda`k qi oajpe`k7 knc]jev]i k aol]k( dqi]jev]j`k)k $eopk ( `]j`k oajpe`k ]k ln teik a ]k `eop]jpa(]k]hpka]k^]etk(]kcn]j`aa]klamqajk(]kreoraha]kejreorah%*=`ebanaj_e]k pailkn]haaol]_e]hlaniepamqakooanaodqi]jkooanah]_ekjai_kik]qoajpa`ebanaj) _e]j`k jk o k lnaoajpa `k l]oo]`k a `k bqpqnk a k ln teik `k `eop]jpa( i]o p]i^i `eopejcqej`kko]cn]`k`klnkb]jkako`aqoao`kodkiajo* Lk`aiko(ajpk(`aÚjen]_qhpqn]_kikpaj`kpnooajpe`kolnej_el]eo6 -*
_ne]k`]kn`aioei^ he_]`]ibf(eopk(`aoeopai]o`aejpan`e aoak^nec] aoaop]) ^aha_e`ko]l]npen`]]pne^qek`ar]hknaoo_keo]o$^k]o(io(lanecko]o(o]cn]`]o(`e]) ^ he_]o%(]kodqi]jkoaoq]onah] ao$`ebanaj]oatq]h(oecjeÚ_]`k`]rencej`]`a(banpe) he`]`a(renehe`]`a7`ebanaj]apne]abkni]`apn]p]iajpk`]o_ne]j]o(`koi]eorahdko ai]eofkrajo7bkni]o`apn]p]iajpk`ko]ieckoa`koejeiecko7bkni]o`a]qpkne`]`a abkni]o`anah]k_kiklk`an(ap_*%(]ko]_kjpa_eiajpko$oecjeÚ_]`k`]cqann](`] laopa(`]bkia(`kj]o_eiajpka`]iknpa(k^nec]k`aajpann]nkoiknpko(ap_*%7
.*
_ne]k`aqi]kn`aioei^ he_]`]oatq]he`]`a(`]hejcq]cai(`kpn]^]hdk(`kaol]k( `kpailk(`ko]cn]`ka`klnkb]jk(`kreoraha`kejreorah*Kooi^khkooqncaip]jpk l]n]obmobpbkq^o_kikl]n]fkqbomobq^o]na]he`]`a(`]j`k)hdaoajpe`klah]lnaoaj]`k dqi]jkjkiqj`k7
/*
_kjfqjpk`amoqf`^p(`ljmloq^jbkqlp(^ bpafkpqfqrf bplahkomq]eokodqi]jkooa nah]_ekj]iajpnaoea_ki]j]pqnav]a`ah]oa`eopejcqai(]cej`kok^naah]kq]pn]ro `ah](ik`eÚ_]j`k)]$nepq]eo`kpn]^]hdk(nepq]eonahecekoko(_kjopnqk`ad]^ep] ao(b]) ^ne_]k`aqpajohekoaejopnqiajpko(_qhejne](pa_ah]cai(raopqnek(bkni]o`acqann] a`al]v(`]j](ioe_](lejpqn](ao_qhpqn](bkni]o`a]qpkne`]`a(ap_*%*
.ATHANß"ENN#ORBIS
J]na]he`]`a(jkateopa^`riqro^(jkoejcqh]n(i]o`riqro^p(jklhqn]h(lkeokooeopai]o `alnke^ekalanieook(]oejopepqe aook_e]eo(naheceko]o(lkhpe_]o(kor]hknao(]o_naj]o( ko_kilknp]iajpkor]ne]i`abkni]kok_e]hl]n]bkni]kok_e]halk`air]ne]njqi] iaoi] ok_ea`]`a jk `a_knnan `k pailk* = aooa oajpe`k ]ilhk lk`aiko ]_nao_ajp]n qi kqpnk(naopnepk(lnkrajeajpa`k]jpeckoajpe`k`a_qhperk`kaolnepk6]_qhpqn]_kik_ne]k `ak^n]o`]oajoe^ehe`]`aa`]ei]cej]kÍ]ok^n]o`a]npaÍa_kik_ne]k`ak^n]o`] ejpahecj_e]a`]naÛatkÍ]ok^n]o`alajo]iajpk(eopk(]_ej_e]a]ÚhkokÚ]*
Aopnah]`a`]re( oi^khkfq`]e_k( aioej]ckc]`a >q`]laopa(Dqjcne]( ai-535*
/-0
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
aooa oacqj`k oajpe`k mqa har] k oajok _kiqi ] e`ajpeÚ_]n _qhpqn] a ao_kh] $a`q) _]kbkni]h%(`aqih]`k(a(`akqpnk(]e`ajpeÚ_]n_qhpqn]a^ah]o)]npao$ioe_](lejpqn]( ao_qhpqn](`]j](hepan]pqn](pa]pnk(_ejai](ap_*%*p]i^iaooaoajpe`kmqahar]`eopejk ajpna_qhpkoaej_qhpko(ajpaj`e`]naola_per]iajpa_kikÎao_kh]niajpaejopnq`koÏaÎoai ejopnqkao_kh]nÏ*
=behkokbe]a]oi]jebaop] ao_qhpqn]eo
=
ÚhkokÚ]oaejpanaoo]lknpk`]o]oi]jebaop] ao_qhpqn]eo(lkeo(_kikao_naraqkÚh ) okbkIkjp]ecja(Îj]`]`kmqadqi]jkiaaopn]jdkÏ* Kolnej_el]eo_]ilkoÚhko Ú_konah]perkooi]jebaop] ao_qhpqn]eook6]ÚhkokÚ]`]o _ej_e]o$mqareikoj]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk%(`]nahecek(`]o]npao(`]ateopj_e]pe_]a `]re`]lkhpe_]*=hi`eook(]ÚhkokÚ]k_ql])oap]i^i_ki]_npe_]`]oe`akhkce]omqaoa knecej]ij]re`]lkhpe_]i]omqaoaaopaj`ail]n]pk`]o]oi]jebaop] ao`]_qhpqn]*
#APqTULOß =atlane j_e]`ko]cn]`ka] ejopepqek`]nahecek =nahecekoe`]`a
O
/-1
aat_apq]niko]o]pere`]`ao_qhpqn]eohec]`]o`enap]iajpaok^narerj_e]`kej`er) `qka`]aol_ea$_khap]alnal]nk`a]heiajpko(lnkpak_kjpn]]oejpailneao(_qe`]) `k_kikona_i)j]o_e`ko(ejopnqiajpkooeilhaol]n]]hqp]_kjpn]ejeiecko%(lk`a) iko`evanmqa]nahecek]]pere`]`a_qhpqn]hi]eo]jpec]amqaateopaaipk`]o]o_qhpqn]o* Lknmq; Lknmqa`ao_k^neikomqaokikodqi]jkomq]j`kpaiko]atlanej_e]`amqaokiko _kjo_eajpao`]o_keo]o(`kokqpnkoa`aj oiaoiko*Oa]_kjo_ej_e]]`ao_k^anp]`ajkoo] dqi]je`]`a(oa]`ao_k^neikolknmqajko`ebanaj_e]iko`kokqpnkooanao`]j]pqnav](cn]) ]ohejcq]caia]kpn]^]hdk(lk`aiko]pne^qen]kb]pk`aoaniko`kp]`ko`a_kjo_ej_e]] _kj`eka]_]qo]lneikn`e]h`koqnceiajpk`]nahecekoe`]`a* @ab]pk(`ao`aiqepk_a`kkooanaodqi]jkolan_a^ainacqh]ne`]`aoj]j]pqnav]ao]) ^aimqajkok]_]qo]`ah]o7lan_a^aip]i^imqadj]j]pqnav]_keo]opaeoajk_er]o( ^k]oa]ia]]`kn]oana_kjda_aimqap]i^ijkokko_ne]`knao`ah]o*=lan_alk`] na]he`]`aatpanekn_kik]hckej`alaj`ajpa`]]kdqi]j](`aqi]kn`aiatpanj]a`a _keo]o`amqalk`aikojko]lkoo]nl]n]kqokkq`amqa`araikobqcenlknmqaok`aopnq) per]ojko_kj`qv_naj]ailk`anaooqlaneknao]kdqi]jka^qo_]`aiaekol]n]_kiq) je_]n)jko_kiahaol]n]mqaoaf]ilnkl_ekojkoo]re`]dqi]j]*J]o_a(]ooei(]_naj] j]$o%afsfka^ab%p&*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=_kjo_ej_e]p]i^inaolkjorahlah]`ao_k^anp]`]iknpa*QiÚh okbk`eooamqa okiajpakooanaodqi]jkoo]^aimqaokiknp]eoaqikqpnkao_naraq6ÎK]jei]h]_]^]( i]okdkiaiiknnaÏ*Kmqaeookmqan`evan; Mq]j`k ej`e_]iko ko lnej_el]eopn]ko`]_qhpqn](k^oanr]ikomqa jah]a lkn ah] ko dkiajob]vai]`ao_k^anp]`kpailk(kqpi]atlanej_e]`kpailk(eopk(`aqi]`e) banaj_e]kjkejpanekn`aoq]re`]_kinaolaepk]kmqaf]_kjpa_aqa]kmqaaop]_kjpa) _aj`k*=ooeimqaah]oanah]_ekj]_ki]iai ne](mqanaolkjorahlahkoajpeiajpk`] e`ajpe`]`alaook]ha`]_kjpejqe`]`a`aqi]re`]mqapn]jo_knnajkpailk* Reikop]i^imqaqikqpnk]ola_pkbqj`]iajp]h`]_qhpqn]]]pere`]`a`kpn]^]) hdk*Kn](]kpn]^]hd]n(kodkiajooanah]_ekj]i_kiqipailkmqajkklnaoajpaaoei kbqpqnk(lkeokpn]^]hdkbaepkaireop]`a]hckmqa]ej`]jkateopajklnaoajpaamqaren ]ateopenjkbqpqnk* =lan_alk`kpailk(kpn]^]hdka]iai ne]b]vai_kimqakodkiajooaf]i_]l]) vao`aaop]^aha_annah] ao_kik]qoajpa6kl]oo]`khai^n]`k(kbqpqnkaolan]`k* Oanaqjenikojqi]je_]atlanej_e]koajpeiajpk`kpailkak`]e`ajpe`]`alao) ok]hjkp]naikomqakodqi]jkook_kjo_eajpao`amqadoanaoa_keo]omqa`ao]l]na_ai jkpailkakqpn]omqaoqncaijkpailk(amqaahaolani]ja_ai`qn]jpaqi_anpkpailk lknmqaok_]l]vao`ahec]nl]oo]`k(lnaoajpaabqpqnk(eopk(ok_]l]vao`alan_a^anmqa bufpqbjamqamlpprbjfabkqfa^ab*I]op]i^iok_kjo_eajpao`amqalk`ai`ao]l]na_an qi`e]*Kqoaf](o]^aimqaiknnai* Kn](kb]pk`amqaokiko_kjo_eajpao`kpailk_kikqi]lnaoaj]$klnaoajpa%oepq]) `]ajpna`q]o]qoj_e]o$kl]oo]`kakbqpqnk%a`amqaokiko_kjo_eajpao`ajkoo]e`ajpe) `]`aa`]e`ajpe`]`a`ajkookooaiahd]jpaojkohar]]_kj_a^an]lani]jj_e]`aoo]e`aj) pe`]`ajqipailkbqpqnk(eopk(]_kj_a^anqi]ateopj_e]bqpqn](jqikqpnkhqc]nkqjqi kqpnkiqj`k(l]n]kj`ar]iko]l o]iknpa*Aooakqpnkiqj`kp]jpklk`aoanqihqc]n oal]n]`k( ateopajpa jkqpnk aol]k a jkqpnk pailk( _kik lk`a oan ] l]npa ejreorah `aopa jkookiqj`k*=_naj]jqi]re`]bqpqn]atlhe_]lknmqaqi]`]olneiaen]oi]jebaop] ao naheceko]oaipk`]o]o_qhpqn]ookkonepq]eobja^nao(k_qe`]`k_kikoiknpko$mqajk `araioan`aet]`kooaioalqhpqn]%(mqa]ooacqn]ioq]ajpn]`]j]re`]bqpqn](a]^qo_]`a iaekol]n]_kiqje_]n)oa_kiahao* =_naj]ai`erej`]`aoajqi]kqpn]re`]]l o]iknpa`aÚjakj_hak`]nahecekoe`]) `aaoaatlneiaj]atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`k*
Ko]cn]`k
K
o]cn]`k]atlanej_e]`]lnaoaj]`aqi]lkpj_e]kq`aqi]bkn]ok^naj]pqn]h mqad]^ep]]hcqioanÍlh]jp](]jei]h(dqi]jk(_keo]o(rajpko(cq]o(bkck*Aoo]lk) pj_e]p]jpkqilk`anmqalanpaj_aln lne]a`aÚjeper]iajpa]qi`apaniej]`k oanmq]jpk]hckmqaahalk`alkooqenalan`an(jkpana]`mqenen*Ko]cn]`k]atlanej_e] oei^ he_]`]`ebanaj]ajpnakooanao(`]oqlanekne`]`a`a]hcqjook^nakqpnko(`klk`anek `a]hcqjook^nakqpnkoÍoqlanekne`]`aalk`anoajpe`ko_kikaol]jpkoko(ieopanekoko(`a) oaf]`koapaie`ko* =p^`o^ifa^abejpnk`qvqi]nqlpqn]ajpnaj]pqn]haok^naj]pqn]h(iaoikmqakooa) naoo]cn]`kooaf]ij]pqn]eo$_kik]cq](kbkck(krqh_k%6ok^naj]pqn]h]bkn]kqlk) pj_e]l]n]na]hev]n]mqehkmqakodqi]jkofqhc]ieilkoorahabapq]n_kjp]j`k]laj]o _ki]obkn]oa_]l]_e`]`aodqi]j]o*=ooei(lknatailhk(aimq]oapk`]o]o_qhpqn]o( qicqannaenk_qf]bkn](`aopnav]aejraj_e^ehe`]`aokaol]jpko]o_kjoe`an]`kd]^ep]`k lknqi]lkpj_e]o]cn]`]*Qi]jei]hbankv(]opqpk(rahkvaejraj_rahp]i^i]ooei _kjoe`an]`k* Lkn oq] bkni] a ]k ieopaneko]o( ^ajrkh]o a i]hrkh]o( k bkck qi `ko lnej_el]eo ajpao o]cn]`ko* Ai nace ao `aonpe_]o( ] o]_n]hev]k _kj_ajpn])oa j]o cq]o( n]n]oaja_aoone]o*
/-2
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
Ko]cn]`kklan]kaj_]jp]iajpk`kiqj`k(d]^ep]`klknbkn]oi]n]rehdko]oalk`anao ]`ienraeomqa]caii]ce_]iajpa*?ne]irj_qhko`aoeil]pe])]pn]ka`a]jpel]pe])nalqhok ajpnapk`kokooanao(]cai]`eop j_e](ajh]]iajpao`ebanajpao_kih]kooa_napkoaaÚ_]vao* Pk`]o]o_qhpqn]olkooqairk_^qhkol]n]atlneienko]cn]`k_kikbkn]ok^naj]pqn]h mqad]^ep]kiqj`k*=ooei(j]o_qhpqn]o`]Lkhejoe]a`]Iah]joe](]l]h]rn]mqa`aoecj]k o]cn]`kj^k^$aoq]or]ne]jpao%*J]o_qhpqn]o`]opne^kojknpa)]iane_]j]o(b]h])oaailobk* a^$aoq]or]ne]jpao%(nabanej`k)oa]klk`anice_klkooq`klknpk`]o]o_keo]o(mqahdao` re`](rkjp]`aa]k(bkn]mqaoalk`ankq^]n`akqpn]o_keo]ol]n]oe(mqaoalk`alan`an mq]j`knkq^]`]lknkqpnkooanao(mqaoalk`aeilkn]kqpnkoi]eobn]_ko* Ajpna]o_qhpqn]o`koj`ekooqh)]iane_]jko(ko]cn]`k`aoecj]`klknl]h]rn]o_kik qrkm^ a ^fdobp* J]o ]bne_]j]o( d _ajpaj]o `a paniko( `alaj`aj`k `] hjcq] a `] nah]k i]jpe`]_kikok^naj]pqn]h(i]okpanikbqj`]iajp]h(ai^kn]_kir]ne]jpao`alnkjj) _e](kqr(Îbkn]qjerano]haimqa_kej_e`ai]mqehkmqaa]mqehkmqaateopaÏ* J] _qhpqn] da^n]e_]( `keo paniko `aoecj]r]i k o]cn]`k6 n^alp a ebobj( oecjeÚ_]j`k ]mqahaooanaokq_keo]omqaokoal]n]`kolkn@aqol]n]oaq_qhpk(oanrek(o]_neb_ek(ap]i) ^i]omqaokoal]n]`]o`apk`]o]okqpn]ol]n]na_a^anqi]lqjek*Lknoanai_keo]o oal]n]`]olkn@aqo(jklk`aioanpk_]`]olahkdkiail]n]oaqqokao lk`aioanpk) _]`]o nepq]hiajpa lkn ]mqahao mqa @aqo ]qpknev] kq ]qpknevkq* =ooei( ] =n_] `] =he]j]( kj`a aop]r]i cq]n`]`ko ko patpko o]cn]`ko( an] n^alp a( lknp]jpk( ejpk_rah* P]i^i ko lneoekjaenko`aqi]cqann]o]jp]lanpaj_e]i]@aqo(oaj`k`a_h]n]`koebobj*J]_qhpqn] cnac](^dklp$lqnk%a^dflp$ejpk_rah%(a(j]nki]j](p^`bo$`a`e_]`k`erej`]`a%ap^k`qrp $ejrekhrah%_kjopepqai]aoban]`ko]cn]`k* O]cn]`k(lkeo(]mq]he`]`aat_al_ekj]hÍ^k]kqi(^ajÚ_]kqi]hÚ_](lnkpapkn]kq ]ia]]`kn]Ímqaqioanlkooqeamqakoal]n]a`eopejcqa`apk`kokokqpnko(ai^kn](ai iqep]o_qhpqn]o(pk`kokooanaolkooq]i]hcko]cn]`k(lahkmqaoa`ebanaj_e]iqjo`kokqpnko* Ko]cn]`klk`aoqo_ep]n`arkka]ikn(nalqho]a `ek*Aooaooajpeiajpkooqo_ep]i qikqpnk6knaolaepkbaepk`apaikn*J]o_ai(]mqe(koajpeiajpknahecekoka]atlanej_e] `]nahecek* =naheceklnaooql amqa(]hi`koajpeiajpk`]`ebanaj]ajpnaj]pqn]haok^naj]pq) n]h(d]f]koajpeiajpk`]oal]n]kajpnakodqi]jkoako]cn]`k(iaoikmqaaopad]^epa jkodqi]jkoaj]j]pqnav]*
=nahecek RELIGIjOßAßPALAVRAßß RELIGIjOßVEMßDOßLATIMßß RELIGIO ßFORMADAßPELOßß PREFIXOßREß±OUTRAßVEZ² ßß ±DEßNOVO² ßEßOßVERBOßß LIGAREß±LIGAR² ß±UNIR² ßß ±VINCULAR²
/-3
=
nahecekqisk`ril*Mq]eo]ol]npaorej_qh]`]o;Kiqj`klnkb]jkakiqj`ko]cn]) `k(eopk(]j]pqnav]$cq](bkck(]n(]jei]eo(lh]jp]o(]opnko(la`n]o(iap]eo(pann](dq) i]jko%a]o`erej`]`aomqad]^ep]i]j]pqnav]kqqihqc]noal]n]`k`]j]pqnav]* J]orne]o_qhpqn]o(aoo]hec]koei^khev]`]jkikiajpk`abqj`]k`aqi]]h`ae]( reh]kq_e`]`a6kcqe]nahecekokpn]]Úcqn]ojk_dk$_n_qhk(mq]`n]`k(pne jcqhk%analapak iaoikcaopkjk]n$j]`enak`k_q(kq`ki]n(kq`]Ûknaop](kq`k`aoanpk%*Aooao`keo caopko`aheiep]iqiaol]kjkrk(o]cn]`k$jk]n%a_kjo]cn]`k$jkokhk%*Jaooajkrkaol]) kancqai)oakp^kqrofl$aih]pei(qbjmirj(ÎpailhkÏ%aoq]rkhp]koa`eb_eko`]jkr] _kiqje`]`a* ?kikoa]_na`ep]mqa]bqj`]k`kaol]k_khaperkbkebaep]lahko]j_aopn]eocqe]`kolkn `aqoaolnkpapknao(krj_qhkoaaop]^aha_ajko ajpnakodkiajoako`aqoaoi]op]i^i ajpnako`ao_aj`ajpaoako]jpal]oo]`ko(kocrka^alobp*Lknaooaikperk(aiejian]onahe) ce aod_qhpkojko l]n]]o`erej`]`ao(i]op]i^il]n]ko]j_aopn]eo(mqareraiqi]re`] jqikqpnkiqj`kalk`aiejpan_a`anfqjpk]ko`aqoaoaijkia`aoaqo`ao_aj`ajpao* = _aneije] `] hec]k bqj`]`kn] ]l]na_a( lkn atailhk( j] nahecek fq`]e_]( mq]j`k Fakr`k]]klkrkkhqc]nkj`a`arad]^ep]nÍ]Pann]Lnkiape`]Í(ej`e_]kaol]kkj`ak pailhk`aranoana`eÚ_]`k(kneajp]]i]jaen]_kik`araoana`eÚ_]`ka`apaniej]oq]Ú) j]he`]`a(eopk(jahaoankbaepkokoo]_neb_ekoajahaoan_khk_]`]]=n_]`]=he]j](oi^khk
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
`krj_qhkmqaqjaklkrkaoaq@aqo*=bqj`]k`kaol]k_khaperk_en_qjo_naraqihqc]n `apaniej]`k(a]=n_](mqa_kjpi]hae`erej]ao_nep](qioi^khk`ahec]kmqana_kn`] ]lneiaen]hec]k6koej]hj]pqn]hkbana_e`klkn@aqo]Jk_kiklnkr]`aoaqh]k_kiaha aoq]`ao_aj`j_e](eopk(k]n_k)neo* P]i^ijk_neope]jeoik]obifdflatlhe_ep]`]lknqicaopk`aqjekajpnak_qa] pann]*J]ranokh]pej]`kJkrkPaop]iajpk(klneiaenk]l opkhk(_qfkjkiada^n]e_kan] Oeik(l]oo]]oan_d]i]`k`aLa`nk$aih]pei(Mbqorp%l]n]oei^khev]n]la`n]$aih]pei( mbqo^%ok^na]mq]hbqj`]`]]_e`]`a_neop(eopk(]Ecnaf]*Faoqo`eooa]La`nk6ÎPqoLa`nk $Mbqorp%aok^naaop]la`n]$mbqo^%a`eÚ_]nae]iejd]ecnaf](a]olknp]o`kejbanjkjklnar]) ha_ank_kjpn]ah]*Aqpa`]nae]o?d]rao`kNaejk6kmqaifd^obpj]Pann]oanifd^aljk?q7k mqaabpifd^obpj]Pann]oanabpifd^aljk?qÏ* Lkniaek`]p^`o^ifw^ la`]`lkp^do^ l(]nahecek_ne]]e`ae]`aaol]ko]cn]`k* Ko_qo(kikjpaKheilk$j]Cn_e]%(]oikjp]jd]o`k`aoanpk$aiEon]ah%(pailhkoaecnaf]o $j]ojkoo]ook_ea`]`ao%oko]jpqneko*Ai_anp]onahece ao(aooaohqc]naook]ikn]`]`ko `aqoao(aikqpn]o(khqc]nkj`ak`aqooai]jebaop]*Kaol]k`]re`]_kiqioal]n])oa`k aol]ko]cn]`k6jaopareraiko`aqoao(okbaep]o]o_aneije]o`a_qhpk(okpn]ve`]okbanaj) `]oabaep]olna_ao_kila`e`koo`erej`]`ao$_khdaep](l]v(rep ne]j]cqann](^kil]npk( Úi`aqi]laopa(_qn]`aqi]`kaj](ap_*%7jklneiaenk(pn]jo_knna]re`]lnkb]j]`kodq) i]jko*=nahecekknc]jev]kaol]k`]j`k)hdamq]he`]`aodqi]j]okqmq]he`]`ao_qhpqn]eo( `erano]o`]ooeilhao_]n]_panope_]oj]pqn]eo*
=nahecek_kikj]nn]per]`]knecai
=
nahecek jk pn]joiqp] ]laj]o k aol]k* P]i^i mq]heÚ_] k pailk( `]j`k)hda ] i]n_]`ko]cn]`k* Kqbjmlp^do^alqi]k^oo^qfs^*J]nn]]knecai`ko`aqoaoa(lah]]k`]o`erej`]) `ao(]knecai`]o_keo]o(`]olh]jp]o(`ko]jei]eoa`kooanaodqi]jko*Lkneook(]j]nn]per] naheceko]oailna_kia]_ki]hcqi]atlnaook`kpelk6Îjklnej_lekÏ(Îjk_kiakÏ(Îmq]j) `kk`aqouaop]r]j]Pann]Ï(Îmq]j`k]`aqo]vreqlah]lneiaen]ravÏ(ap_* = j]nn]per] o]cn]`] ] efpqof^ p^do^a^( mqa ko cnacko _d]i]r]i `a jfql* Aopa jk qi]b]^qh]kehqo ne](qi]b]jp]oe]oai_kjo_ej_e](i]o]i]jaen]lah]mq]hqi]ok_ea`]) `aj]nn]l]n]oeiaoi]oaq_kiakak`apk`]]na]he`]`a(ej_hqoerak_kiakkqj]o_eiajpk `koln lneko`aqoao*O p]n`e]iajpa(mq]j`koqnceq]ÚhkokÚ]a(`alkeo`ah](]pakhkce](]n]) vkatecene]mqako`aqoaojkbkooai]laj]oeiknp]eo(i]op]i^iapanjko(oai_kiaka oaiÚi*=jpao(lkni(`]ÚhkokÚ]a`]pakhkce](]nahecekj]nn]r]pakckje]o$`kcnackqeblp( Î`aqoÏ7dlkf^(Îcan]kÏ%(eopk(]can]kkqkj]o_eiajpk`ko`aqoao(oaie`aqoaoadan eo* K_kjpn]opaajpna`e]ajkepa$hqvapnar]%(ajpna]oaop] ao`k]jk$bnek(mqajpa(]iajk( _kiÛknao(_kibnqpko(_ki_dqr]o(_kioa_]o%(ajpnakj]o_eiajpka]`ao]l]nek$re`]a iknpa%(ajpnapelko`a]jei]eo$pannaopnao(]mqpe_ko(rk]`knao(bankvao(` _aeo%(ajpnapelko `adqi]jko$^n]j_ko(jacnko(]i]nahko(raniahdko(]hpko(^]etko(lahq`ko(ch]^nko%(]op_je) _]ok^pe`]olahk_kjpnkhaok^na]hcqi]bkn]j]pqn]h$bkck(cq](rajpko(la`n]o(]nae](anr]o% are`aj_e]iqiiqj`kkn`aj]`kanacqh]n(jkmq]hkodqi]jkoj]o_ai(reraiaiknnai* =deop ne]o]cn]`]kqiepkj]nn]_kikalknmqa]kn`ai`kiqj`kateopaa_kikalknmqa bke`k]`]]kodqi]jkolahko`aqoao*=ooei(]hi`aoanqi]qbldlkf^(]deop ne]o]cn]`] qi]_koikckje]$`kcnackhpjlp(Îiqj`kÏ(adlkf^(Îcan]kÏ%6j]nn]kj]o_eiajpk(] Új]he`]`aaklana_eiajpk`apk`kokooanaook^]]k`ko`aqoao* =ooei_kikd`keoaol]ko(d`keopailko6k]jpanekn_ne]kkqdkbpb`ko`aqoao a`]o_keo]o$pailk`kr]veka`k_]ko%akpailkknecejnek`]cjaoa`apq`kmq]jpkateopa $pailk`klhajka`]kn`ai%*Jaooapailko]cn]`k`]kn`ai(jkr]iajpaqi]`ereok6k qbjmlmofjfqfsl(ejpaen]iajpa`erejk(mq]j`kpq`kbke_ne]`k(akqbjmlal^dlo^(lnkb]jk( aimqareraikooanaoj]pqn]eo(ej_hqej`kkodkiajo*
/-4
!BBAS-AGNUM,ATINSTOCK
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
Ai^kn]]j]nn]per]o]cn]`]oaf]qi]atlhe_]kl]n]] kn`ai j]pqn]h a dqi]j]( ah] jk oa `eneca ]k ejpaha_pk `ko _najpao$jkÚhkokÚ]jai_ej_e]%(i]ooaaj`ana]]k_k) n]k`ahao*@aolanp]aik aoaoajpeiajpkoÍ]`ien]k( aol]jpk(ia`k(aolan]j](]ikn( `ek*Lknmqaoa`enecaol]e) t ao`k_najpa(]nahecekhdala`aqi]o _keo]6c(kqoaf](] _kjÚ]j](]`aoklhaj]]kmqahdai]jebaop]`k_kik]k `]`erej`]`a*=]pepq`abqj`]iajp]h`]b]mfba^ab6nao) laepklahko`aqoaoalahko]jpal]oo]`ko*=nahecek_naj]( jko]^an*=pajp]per]l]n]pn]jobkni]n]nahecekaio]^an n]_ekj]h_d]i])oapakhkce]*
Nepko
L
Beah]jeieop]`]apje] `kckj(lkrk`aIhe( j]ãbne_]k_e`ajp]h(jk naceopnk`kbkp cn]bk bn]j_o=^^]o( `a-552*
knmqa]nahecekhec]dqi]jkoa`erej`]`a(lknmqakn) c]jev]kaol]kakpailk(kooanaodqi]jkolna_eo]i c]n]jpenmqa]hec]ka]knc]jev]koai]jpajd]ia oaf]ioailnalnkl_e]o*L]n]eookok_ne]`kokonepko* Knepkqi]_aneije]aimqacaopko`apaniej]`ko(l]) h]rn]o`apaniej]`]o(k^fapko`apaniej]`ko(laook]o`apanie) j]`]oaaik ao`apaniej]`]o]`mqenaiklk`anieopanekok `alnaoajpeÚ_]nkh]kajpnakodqi]jkoa]`erej`]`a*L]n] ]cn]`a_an`kjoa^ajab_eko(l]n]oqlhe_]njkrko`kjoa^aja) b_eko(l]n]hai^n]n]^kj`]`a`ko`aqoaokql]n]atkn_ev]n oq]_ han](_]okkodqi]jkopajd]ipn]jocna`e`k]ohaeoo]) cn]`]o(]o_aneije]onepq]hope_]ook`acn]j`ar]nea`]`a* Jk ajp]jpk( qi] rav Út]`] ] oei^khkce] `a qi nepq]h( oq] aÚ__e] `alaj`an `]ob* mbqf ljfkr`flp^bmbocbfq^`knepk(p]h_kikbkeln]pe_]`kj]lneiaen]rav(lknmqajah]ko ln lneko`aqoaokneajp]n]icaopkoal]h]rn]o`kodqi]jko*Qinepknahecekoknalapeperk ai`keooajpe`kolnej_el]eo6]_aneije]`aranalapenqi]_kjpa_eiajpkaooaj_e]h`]deop ) ne]o]cn]`]$lknatailhk(jk_neope]jeoik(]aq_]neope]a]_kiqjdk(mqanalapai]O]jp] ?ae]%7a(aioacqj`khqc]n(]pko(caopko(l]h]rn]o(k^fapko`araioanoailnakoiaoiko(lkn) mqabkn]i(j]lneiaen]rav(_kjo]cn]`kolahkln lnek`aqo*Knepk]naiaikn]klanaja `kmqa]_kjpa_aqjqi]lneiaen]ravamqarkhp]]]_kjpa_an(cn]]o]knepq]hmqa]^kha] `eop j_e]ajpnakl]oo]`kaklnaoajpa*
Kok^fapkooei^he_ko
=
/-5
nahecek jk o]_n]hev] ]laj]o k aol]k a k pailk( i]o p]i^i oanao a k^fapko `k iqj`k(mqaoapknj]ioi^khko`a]hcqib]pknahecekok* Ko oanao a k^fapko oei^ he_ko ok napen]`ko `a oaq hqc]n _kopqiaenk( ]ooqiej`k qi oajpe`kjkrkl]n]pk`]]_kiqje`]`aÍlnkpapkn(lanoacqe`kn(^ajbaepkn(]ia]]`kn*Ok^na aooaoankqk^fapkna_]e]jkk`ap]^q$l]h]rn]lkhejoe]mqaoecjeÚ_]Îejpk_rahÏ%6qi ejpan`epk(kqoaf](jklk`aoanpk_]`kjaii]jelqh]`klknjejcqimqajkaopaf]nahecek) o]iajpa]qpknev]`kl]n]eook* ]ooei(lknatailhk(mqa_anpko]jei]eooapknj]io]cn]`kokqp]^qo(_kik]r]_]j] æj`e](k_kn`aenklanbaepk_kjo]cn]`kl]n]ko]_neb_ek`]Lo_k]fq`]e_](kpq_]jkl]n]]j]k ej`caj]Pq_]j](`k>n]oeh*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqa_anpkok^fapkooapknj]io]cn]`kokq p]^qo(_kikklkakrejdk_kjo]cn]`kolahkl]`na_neopk`qn]jpaknepq]h`]ieoo]amqa o lk`aioan_kjoqie`konepq]heope_]iajpaaok^_kj`e aoiqepk`apaniej]`]o*@kiaoik
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
ik`k(aiejian]onahece ao(]orencajolneikcjep]o`]olnej_el]eob]ihe]ooapknj]ip]^qo( _kik]oraop]eo(j]Nki]]jpec]*P]i^ik^fapkooapknj]ioi^khkoo]cn]`koejpk_raeo( _kikkolanc]iejdkofq`]e_komqa_kjpikopatpkoo]cn]`ko]jpecko(_anp]ola`n]oqo]`]o lahko_dabaonahecekoko]bne_]jko(ap_* Kop]^qooanabanaikq]k^fapkoaoanaolqnkokqlqneÚ_]`kol]n]ko`aqoao(kq]k^fa) pkoaoanaoeilqnko(mqa`arailani]ja_an]b]op]`ko`ko`aqoaoa`kodqi]jko*]ooei( mqa(aiejian]o_qhpqn]o(]iqhdaniajopnq]`]p]^q$aopeilqn]%a(jkfq`]oikajk eoh]ieoik(]_]nja`alkn_kp]^q$eilqn]%* =nahecekpaj`a]]ilhe]nk_]ilkoei^ he_k(iaoikmqajkpn]jobkniapk`kokooanao ak^fapkoaip]^qokqejpk_raeo*Ah]kb]vrej_qh]j`koanaoamq]he`]`aolanokj]he`]`a`a qi`aqo*=ooei(lknatailhk(aiiqep]onahece ao(_kik]o]bne_]j]o(_]`]`erej`]`alnkpa) pkn]`aqi]opnk(qi]_kn(qi]jei]h(qi]la`n]aqiiap]hlna_ekoko(qik^fapko]jpk* =Úcqn]k`ko]cn]`koab]vlknbj_ibj^p6]ooei(lknatailhk(kai^hai]`]`aqo] Bknpqj]an]qi]nk`](]rah]ajbqj]`]`aqij]rekaqi]_knjq_ le]7k`]`aqo]=paj](k _]l]_apaa]aol]`]7k`aDaniao(]oanlajpaa]o^kp]o]h]`]o7k`aKt ooe(]ooapaÛa_d]o aol]hd]`]olahk_knlk7k`aEai]jf(kraope`k^n]j_k(]ocq]o`ki]nako_]^ahko]krajpk7 k`aFaoqo(]_nqv(]_knk]`aaolejdko(k_knlkchknekokai]o_ajok*
I]jebaop]kanarah]k
D
nahece aoaimqako`aqoaooai]jebaop]i6oqncai`e]jpa`kodqi]jkoai^a) hav](aolhaj`kn(lanbaekalk`anakohar]i]ranqi]kqpn]na]he`]`a(ao_kj`e`] ok^]na]he`]`a_kpe`e]j](j]mq]hkaol]k(kpailk(]obkni]o`kooanao(kookjoa ]o_knao(koahaiajpkoaj_kjpn]i)oaknc]jev]`koa`eolkopko`aqi]kqpn]i]jaen](oa_nap] aran`]`aen]*=`erej`]`a(har]j`kqidqi]jk]koaqiqj`k(`aoraj`])hda]ran`]`aak ehqiej]_kioq]hqv* An]eook(_kikreiko(kmqaoecjeÚ_]r]]l]h]rn]cnac]^iqebf^(]ran`]`a_kiki]) jebaop]kkqehqiej]k*=ehqiej]klk`aoanpannrah(lknmqa`]`k]qidqi]jkran kmqakokhdkodqi]jkojk_kjoacqairan(kqrenkmqakokqre`kodqi]jkojklk`ai kqren(_kjda_ankmqa]ejpahecj_e]dqi]j]jkpaibkn]ol]n]_kjda_an*=onahece aoej) `caj]o`]o=ine_]oa]cnac]okobifdfbpa^j^kfcbpq^ l*firjfk^ lkq`]re]cai]k iqj`k`erejk* Dnahece aoaimqak`aqonarah]ran`]`ao]kodqi]jkooaib]v)hkoo]en`aoaqiqj) `k*Lk`aipanokjdkoareo ao(i]okbqj`]iajp]hkqrenkmqa]`erej`]`ahdao`ev(lknmqa `ah] lnkri k oajpe`k lneiaenk a hpeik `a pk`]o _keo]o a `k `aopejk dqi]jk* K mqa oa narah]jk]ran`]`a`kiqj`k]pn]ro`]re]caireoekjne]]qikqpnkiqj`k6kmqaoa narah]]rkjp]`a`k`aqo(j]mq]hk_najpa_kjÚ]a_qfko`aocjekoaha_qilna*An]eookk mqaoecjeÚ_]r](_kikreiko(]l]h]rn]da^n]e_]bjrk^e(Î]ooeioaf]Ï*Fq`]oik(_neope]jeo) ikaeoh]ieoikokobifdfbpa^obsbi^ l* J]o`q]oik`]he`]`ao`anahecek(lkni(]i]jebaop]k`]ran`]`aa]narah]k`] rkjp]`aatlneiaikiaoik]_kjpa_eiajpk6]kodqi]jko`]`k_kjda_anoaq`aopejkak `apk`]o]o_keo]o(eopk(]ohaeo`erej]o*
=hae`erej]
K
o`aqoaookmlabobpjfpqboflplp*Okbkn]olanokjeÚ_]`]oalkneookokslkq^abp* Ieopanekoko(lknmqaoq]o`a_eo aookeilnareoraeoa(iqep]oravao(ej_kilnaaj) oraeol]n]ko_nepnekodqi]jko`a]r]he]k*Rkjp]`ao(lknmqakmqa]_kjpa_ajk iqj`ki]jebaop]qimqananlaook]h(oqlnaikaejmqaopekjrah*=nahecek(]kaop]^aha_an
/.,
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
BqBLIA ßALCORjOßAßPALAVRAß BqBLIAßmßGREGAßEßQUERßDIZERß ±LIVRO²ßAßPALAVRAßfRABEß ALCORjOßSIGNIFICA ßSEGUNDOß ALGUNSßESTUDIOSOS ß±LERßß EMßVOZßALTA²ßE ßSEGUNDOß OUTROS ß±COLEljOßDASßß PALAVRASßREVELADAS²
/.-
kh]kajpnakdqi]jkak`erejk(lnk_qn]qi_]iejdklahkmq]h]rkjp]`a`ko`aqoaooaf] ^ajÚ_]alnkl_e]]kooaqo]`kn]`knao* =rkjp]`a`erej]lk`apknj]n)oal]n_e]hiajpa_kjda_e`]`kodqi]jkoj]bkni]`aibfp( eopk ( `a_napko( i]j`]iajpko( kn`aj]iajpko( _ki]j`ko ai]j]`ko `] `erej`]`a* =ooei _kik]kn`ai`kiqj`k`a_knna`ko`a_napko`erejko(eopk(`]haekn`aj]`kn]mq]hja) jdqioanao_]l](p]i^ikiqj`kdqi]jkaopoq^iape`k]i]j`]iajpko`erejko(`ko mq]eokoi]eo_kjda_e`ko(j]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]h(okko@avI]j`]iajpko(`]`kolknFakr] Ikeoo*P]i^iok`aknecai`erej]]o@kvaP^q]o`]Haemqabqj`]n]i]nal^he_]nk) i]j](_kikan]i`aknecai`erej]]ohaeocnac]oatlhe_ep]`]oj]Fi^a^aj]Lafppbf^(k^n]o ]pne^q`]o]Dkiank(^ai_kikj]opn]c`e]o* Kik`k_kik]rkjp]`a`erej]oai]jebaop]aihaeolaniepa`eopejcqen`keocn]j`ao pelko`anahecek*Dnahece aoaimqa]`erej`]`aqo]ejpania`enekol]n]narah]n]hae*k _]ok`]nahecekfq`]e_](aimqaFakroar]ha(lknatailhk(`aJk(Ikeoo(O]iqah(l]n]`]n ]_kjda_an]hae*P]i^ijaoo]nahecek]`erej`]`ajk_aoo]`ahai^n]n]klkrk]ohaeo( ok^napq`kmq]j`kaopkoaj`kpn]jocna`e`]o*Aoo]naiaikn]k`]haea`]olnkiaoo]o`a _]opeckana`ajkjah]o_kjpe`]o]p]nab]`kmolcbq^(]n]qpk`a@aqo*P]i^ij]nahecek cnac]ko`aqoaooar]hai`aejpania`enekol]n]i]jebaop]noq]rkjp]`a*Aop](lknoanieopa) neko]aej_kilnaajorah(atecaqipelkaola_e]h`aejpania`enek(ksfabkqb(mqaejpanlnap] koajeci]o`erejko(rkl]oo]`kakbqpqnkakoatl a]kodkiajo* Dnahece ao(lkni(aimqako`aqoaoi]jebaop]ioq]hae`enap]iajpa(oaina_knnan] ejpania`eneko(eopk(oailna_eo]n`aejpnlnapao*Oknahece ao`]firjfk^ lfkafsfar^ia `kuq^pbjpqf`l(_kikk_]ok`]i]ekne]`]onahece aokneajp]eo(mqaatecai(l]n]]ehqie) j]kaktp]oa(qi]a`q_]kaola_e]h`kejpaha_pka`]rkjp]`a`ko]`alpko* Bnamqajpaiajpa(lnkbap]oare`ajpaoajpn]iaipn]joal]n]na_a^an]narah]k(i]o] na_a^aijklknmqapajd]ioe`ka`q_]`kol]n]eookaoeilknmqa]`erej`]`akoao_khdaq l]n]i]jebaop]n)oa*Kpn]joa`kolnkbap]oa`ko]`erejdko`ebana`ktp]oaiope_k`koehqie) j]`kolknmqa(jklneiaenk(kej`er`qkpai]_aook]qi_kjda_eiajpkmqalk`a_kilnaaj) `an$iaoik_kicn]j`a`eÚ_qh`]`a%alkneooklk`apn]joiepe)hk]kokqpnko(ajmq]jpkjk oacqj`kjkd_kjda_eiajpk(jkd]pere`]`aejpaha_pq]hmqa`alkeooaf]pn]joieoorah] kqpnko(i]odiancqhdkabqok`kej`er`qkj]`erej`]`a(jqi]atlanej_e]ejpn]`qvrah aejpn]joieoorah* =oobifdfbpobsbi^a^p$`ebanajpao(lknp]jpk(`]onahece aoatppe_]o%na]hev]i(_kjoanr]i apn]joiepai]narah]kna_a^e`]aireo aoaokjdkolknlnkbap]oare`ajpao*Lk`aib]) v)hk`a`q]oi]jaen]o`ebanajpao(lknao_nepkkqkn]hiajpa* Jk_]ok`]onahece aofq`]e_](_neopaeoh ie_](]onarah] aook_kjoecj]`]olknao) _nepkkq]l o]iknpa`]mqahamqa]ona_a^aq$]Pkn]dao_nep]]l o]iknpa`aIkeoo(ko Ar]jcahdkookao_nepko]l o]iknpa`aFaoqo(k=h_knkao_nepk]l o]iknpa`aI]ki% kqmq]j`k]mqahamqa]ona_a^aqna_a^a`a@aqo]kn`ai`aao_nar)h]o(l]n]mqaejpacnai kopatpko`]deop ne]o]cn]`]aoaf]ipn]joieooraeo$k_]ok`kolnkbap]o`k=jpeckPao) p]iajpka`aFkk`aL]piko(]qpkn`k=lk_]heloa(jkJkrkPaop]iajpk%*Lknaooaikperk( fq`aqo(_neopkoaiqqhi]jkook_d]i]`ko`aMlslpalIfsolaoq]onahece ao(Obifdfbp alIfsol* Jk_]ok(lknatailhk(`]onahece aocnac]anki]j]]jpec]o(`]o]bne_]j]o(`]oej`ca) j]o`]opno=ine_]o(kre`ajpahar]`klan]jpako`aqoaokqqi`aqol]n]ran]rkjp]`a `erej]mqa`a_e`aok^na]re`]a]iknpa`aqiej`er`qkkq`aqicnqlk(ok^na]_kjpa_e) iajpkoj]pqn]eoa+kqdqi]jko(ok^nakopailkol]oo]`koabqpqnko(`araj`k(]l o]reok( `ev)h]]kokqpnko(lnkbane)h]l]n]ejpacn)h]iai ne]naheceko]kn]h* Jko`keo_]oko(lkni(l]n]mqaÚmqaej`eo_qprah]knecai`erej]`]narah]k(]at) lkoekao_nep]kqkn]ho lk`aoanbaep]lknl]n^kh]o(iapbkn]o(ei]cajoadeop ne]o_qfk oajpe`klna_eo]noan`a_ebn]`klahkohaepknaokqkqrejpao*@aqoao(lnkbap]oare`ajpaob]h]i lkniaek`abkfdj^pkqlo`rilp*@aoo]i]jaen](k_]npanpn]jo_aj`ajpaaieopanekok`] rkjp]`a`erej]lnaoanr]`k*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=re`]]lo]iknpa
R
eikomqakoajpeiajpknahecekoka]atlanej_e]`]nahecekokejoal]nraeo`]lan) _alk`ajkoo]iknp]he`]`aa`]_naj]aijkoo]eiknp]he`]`a*Pk`]nahecek(lkn) p]jpk(atlhe_]jko ]knecai`]kn`ai`kiqj`kj]pqn]hi]op]i^i]`kooanao dqi]jkoahdaoajoej]lknmqaokiknp]eoakmqalk`aikq`araiaolan]n]l o]iknpa* J]mq]oapkp]he`]`a`]onahece ao(kieopnek`]iknpaoailnaatlhe_]`k_kik_kjoa) mqj_e]`a]hcqi]b]hp]_kiape`]_kjpn]]hcqi`aqokq`a]hcqi]kbajo]mqakodkiajo Úvan]i]ko`aqoao*Jklnej_lekkodkiajoan]ieiknp]eoarere]ij]_kil]jde]`ko`aq) oaokq`a@aqo7]oacqen(]hcqikq]hcqjo_kiapaiqi]pn]jocnaookeilan`kraha_ki ah]rai]cn]j`alqjek6]iknp]he`]`al]n]pk`ko* Jkajp]jpk(]eiknp]he`]`ajkaoppkp]hiajpalan`e`](lkeoko`aqoao$kq@aqo%_kj) _a`ai]koiknp]eoqi]re`]]l o]iknpa(`ao`amqa(j]re`]lnaoajpa(naolaepai]rkjp]`a a]hae`erej]o* ?kik]eiknp]he`]`a;=hcqi]onahece ao]Úni]i]eiknp]he`]`a`k_knlkdqi]jk ]ooacqn]j`kmqaaopalkooqeqiarmil(baepk`akqpn]i]pne](mqalani]ja_a]l o]iknpa( amqa(lknoanbaepk`ai]pne]oqpeh(lk`alajapn]njk_knlk`akqpnkooanaol]n]nah]_ekj]n)oa _kikorerko*Kqpn]onahece ao]_na`ep]imqak_knlkiknp]h(i]od]^ep]`klknqi]ajpe) `]`aÍaolnepk(]hi](oki^n]ei]pane]h(oklnkÍ(mqaoaneiknp]hoako`a_napko`erejko akonepq]eoperanaioe`knaolaep]`kolahkÚahkq(jk_]ok`kfq`]oika`k_neope]jeoik(oa ]hi`eookkcjankdqi]jkperanna_a^e`kklan`k`erejklahkla_]`k`ko]j_aopn]eo* Lkn]_na`ep]naiÚniaiajpajqi]kqpn]re`]Ímqalk`aoaneia`e]p](]l o]ikn) pa`k_knlk(kqlk`aatecennaaj_]nj] aolqneÚ_]`kn]o]pkaolnepkkq]]hi]]h]n)oa eiknp]he`]`aÍ(]onahece aolkooqainepkobqjanneko(aj_]nnac]`ko`alnal]n]nac]n]jpen ]ajpn]`]`kiknpkj]kqpn]re`]*Knepq]hbja^naheil](lqneÚ_](]`knj]alanbqi]k_kn) lkiknpkaklnkpaca_ki]oalqhpqn]*Lahkiaoikikperk(]hi`konepkobqjanneko(ko _aiepneko(j]i]ekne]`]onahece aoal]npe_qh]niajpaj]o]bne_]j]o(ej`caj]oak_e`ajp]eo ]jpec]o(an]ihqc]nao_kjo]cn]`ko(_]ilkoo]jpko(jkomq]eookiajpa]hcqjo(aai_anp]o _kj`e ao(lk`e]ilajapn]n* Ai]hcqi]onahece ao(_kikj]]jpec]acl_e]aj]cnac](]lanbaep]lnaoanr]k`k_knlk iknpk(eopk(`aoq]fj^dbj(an]aooaj_e]hl]n]mqabkooana_kjda_e`klahko`aqoaojknaejk `koiknpkoana_a^aooa]eiknp]he`]`a*Jk_]ok`koacl_ekod]re]qi]ejopepqekok_e]h(] ?]o]`koIknpko(aj_]nnac]`]`aai^]ho]i]nko_]`ranao(lnal]n]j`k)kol]n]]lnaoanr]k j] re`]bqpqn]*Jk_]ok`kocnacko( an] lna_eok mqa k _knlk iknpk lani]ja_aooa ejrekh]`k $oaiokbnan`acn]`]klkn]jei]eoaejpailneao%(]Úi`amqa`ahaj]o_aooaoq]ei]cai rer]aejpaen](oq]oki^n](lkeoan]aop]mqal]npe]l]n]kkqpnkiqj`kl]n]pknj]n)oaeiknp]h* J]o nahece ao `k aj_]jp]iajpk( _kik ] ]jpec] cnac]( ]o ]bne_]j]o a ]o ej`caj]o `]o =ine_]o(]iknpa_kj_a^e`]`a`erano]oi]jaen]o(i]oaipk`]oah]okiknpkÚ_]aj_]jp]) `k(eopk(pknj])oa]hckice_k*Ai]hcqi]o(kiknpk`aet]oaq_knlkl]n]ajpn]njqikqpnk alani]ja_anjkiqj`k(ok^bkni]or]ne]`]o7kq`aet]oaq_knlkaoaqaolnepklani]ja_a jkiqj`k(]cep]j`kkorajpko(]ocq]o(kbkck(ajoej]j`k_]jpk]koloo]nko(lnkpacaj`k]o _ne]j]o( ajoej]j`k ko i]eo rahdko( ao_kj`aj`k a ]_d]j`k _keo]o* Ai kqpn]o(kiknpk pai oq]ei]caikqoaqaolnepkhar]`k]kiqj`k`erejk(]he`aobnqp]j`k`]o`ah_e]o`aqi]re`] lanajaiajpalanbaep]a^ah]7oa(lkni(oq]ob]hp]opannaj]obkn]ip]jp]oap]eomqajkl`a oanlan`k]`k(oq]ei]caikqaolnepkr]c]napanj]iajpalah]opnar]o(oainalkqokaoai `ao_]jok*Kiaoikhda]_kjpa_anoakonepq]eobja^naojklq`anaioanna]hev]`kokqoajk peranaioe`kna]hev]`ko]`amq]`]iajpa*Aooalan]i^qh]nlah]opnar]ojkateopaj]onahece ao `anaaj_]nj]k(lknmqa(aihqc]n`aoo]lqjek(kaolnepk`aranpanp]jp]ore`]oaok^p]jp]o bkni]omq]jp]oja_aoone]ooq]lqneÚ_]k(]pmqalkoo]l]npe_el]n`]bahe_e`]`alanaja* J]onahece ao`]o]hr]k(_kikk_]ok`kfq`]oik(`k_neope]jeoika`keoh]ieoik( ]bahe_e`]`alanajajk]laj]oej`ere`q]h(i]op]i^i_khaper]*Oknahece aoaimqa] `erej`]`a lnkiapa lan`k]n ] b]hp] knecejne]( ajre]j`k qi o]hr]`kn( mqa( o]_neÚ_]j`k)oa lahkodqi]jko(c]n]jpa)hdao]eiknp]he`]`aa]na_kj_ehe]k_ki@aqo*
IMORTALIDADEßDUASßHIS TvRIASßNOSßMOSTRAMßAßIM PORThNCIAßDAßCONSERVAljOß DAßIMAGEMßPERFEITAßDOß CORPOßMORTOßCOMOßCONDI ljOßDEßSUAßIMORTALIDADE 5MAßDASßHISTvRIASßmß NARRADAßPORß(OMEROßNOß POEMAß)LqADA ßQUEßRELATAß AßGUERRAßDEß4ROIAßTOMADOß DEßCvLERAßEßF{RIA ß!QUILES ß DEPOISßDEßVENCERß(EITORß NOßCOMBATE ßDESFIGURAßEß DESTROlAßSEUßCORPO ßPARAß DESESPEROßDEßSEUSßAMIGOSß EßFAMILIARES ßPOISßDESSAß MANEIRAß!QUILESßTIROUßDEß (EITORßOßDIREITOßgßIMORTA LIDADEß!PIEDADAßCOMßOß DESESPEROßDAßFAMqLIAßEßDOSß AMIGOSßDOßMORTO ßAßDEUSAß !TENAßFAZßUMAßINTERVEN ljOßMIRACULOSAßEßOßCORPOß mßRECOMPOSTOßPARAßPASSARß PELOßRITOßF{NEBREßQUEßLHEß ASSEGURARfßVIDAßFUTURAß !ßOUTRAßENCONTRA SEßNUMAß TRAGmDIAßDEß3vFLOCLES ß!N TqGONAßOSßIRMjOSßDEß!N TqGONA ß%TmOCLESßEß0OLINICE ß LUTAMßEMßPARTIDOSßCON TRfRIOSß0OLINICE ßACUSADOß PELOßREIß#REONTEßDEßTRAIljOß POLqTICA ßmßVENCIDOßEßMORTOß EMßCOMBATEßPORß%TmOCLESß #OMOßTRAIDORßPOLqTICO ßAß LEIßDAßCIDADE %STADOßNjOß LHEßDfßOßDIREITOßAßFUNERALßEß SEPULTURAß)SSOßATORMENTAß !NTqGONA ßENCHENDO AßDEß DORß/ßAMORßFRATERNOßLEVA Rfß!NTqGONAßAßENFRENTARßOß REIßEßAßLEIßDAßCIDADE ßREALI ZANDOßOSßRITOSßF{NEBRESßEß ENTERRANDOßOßIRMjOß
/..
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
-USEUß(ISTvRICOß.ACIONAL ßß 2IOßDEß*ANEIRO!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
?kik]b]hp]kqmqa`]knecejne]]pejceq]pk`kokodqi]jko(klan`k`erejka]na`aj) k`a_knnai`aqi]`a_eok`erej](mqa`aran]pejcen]pk`kokodqi]jko(oa]_na`ep]nai anaolaep]nai]hae`erej]ao_nep]jkopatpkoo]cn]`koaoacq]n`]nai]aolan]j]j]lnkiao) o]`ao]hr]kmqahdaobkebaep]lkn@aqo*Jaooapelk`anahecek(]k^n]`ao]hr]kna]hev]`] lknqiajre]`k`a@aqo$jbppf^p(aida^n]e_k7`ofpql(aicnack%*=onahece ao`]o]hr]kok jbppf kf`^pa`libqfs^p*Qilkrk$lkrk`a@aqo%oano]hrklah]haealahkajre]`k`erejk*
Iehaj]neoik #ANUDOSßNOß"RASIL ßAß ESPERANlAßMILENARISTAß MANIFESTOU SEßEMßß VfRIOSßMOVIMENTOSßPOLq TICO RELIGIOSOSßPOPULARES ßß COMOßFOIßOßCASOßDEßß #ANUDOSß0ARAßSIGNIFICARß OßREINOßDEßFELICIDADEßEß ABUNDhNCIAßQUEßMUDA RIAßPARAßSEMPREßAßFACEß DESmRTICAßEßMISERfVELßDOß SERTjOßNORDESTINO ßOßCHEFEß RELIGIOSOßDEß#ANUDOS ßß !NTxNIOß#ONSELHEIRO ßDIZIAß ±/ßSERTjOßVAIßVIRARßMARßEßß OßMARßVAIßVIRARßSERTjO²
4ELOLOGIAßDAß,IBERTAljOß OßMILENARISMO ßEMßOUTRAß FORMA ßESTfßPRESENTEßß NUMAßCONCEPljOßRELIGIOSAß CATvLICAßDOßSmCULOß88 ßAß 4EOLOGIAßDAß,IBERTAljO ß DESENVOLVIDAßNAß!MmRICAß ,ATINAßNOSßANOSßßEß QUEßPROPUNHAßOßRETORNOß DAß)GREJAßgßPUREZAßIGUA LITfRIA ßLIVREßEßJUSTAßDOSß PRIMEIROSßCRISTjOS ßß CRIANDOßOßREINOßDEß$EUSß NAß4ERRA ßCONFORMEßß PROMETIDOßPORß*ESUS
K
iehaj]neoikln lnek`]onahece ao`]o]hr]k*]aolan]j]`]bahe_e`]`alanaja jkiqj`kmq]j`k(]l ookbneiajpkolnkbqj`ko(kooanaodqi]jkobknainacaja) n]`ko(lqneÚ_]`koahe^anp]`kolah]`erej`]`a* KpanikÎiehaj]neoikÏlnkri`aqi]_naj]lklqh]n_neop(ai^kn]jkoaf]at_hqoe) rk`]nahecek_neop*>]oa]`koailnkba_e]o`kolnkbap]o@]jeahaEo]]o(jk=lk_]heloa`aOk Fkk(aj]olna`e ao`ai]ckoaoe^eh]o(cnqlkolklqh]nao_neopko(`qn]jpa]E`]`aI`e]( aolan]r]i mqa ?neopk rkhp]ooa lah] oacqj`] rav( _ki^]paooa ko i]hao $] laopa( ] bkia( ] cqann]a]iknpa%(raj_aooak`aijek(aj_]nj]`kjqickranj]jpalanranok(k]jpe_neopk(a ejopepqooaknaejk`a@aqoj]Pann](_ki]`qn]k`aieh]jko`a]^qj` j_e](fqope]abahe) _e`]`a*=kÚi`aieh]jko(d]rane]]naooqnnaek`koiknpko(kFqvkBej]hakÚi`kiqj`k pannajk*Kiehaj]neoik(lknp]jpk(]_naj]jqiNaejk`aIeh=jkomqa]jpa_a`aalnal]n] kÚi`kiqj`k(]k_]^k`kmq]hoaeje_e]]re`]apanj]`koahaepkolkn@aqo* Jkajp]jpk(kpanikÎiehaj]neoikÏ_kopqi]oanqo]`kjkoajpe`ki]eo]ilhkai]eo can]h`aaolan]j]jqipailkbqpqnk`abahe_e`]`a(fqope](d]nikje](l]va]^qj` j_e]*Aooa pailkoankhpeikpailkkqkÚi`kopailko*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(kodkiajooankbahevao l]n]oailnaaj]`]i]eod]ranl]n]j]nn]nok^naahaolknmqaj]`]i]eo]_kjpa_an* Jaooaoajpe`k]ilhk`aaolan]j]`abahe_e`]`aa]^qj` j_e]jkÚi`kopailko(mq]j) `k ] `kn( ] ieone]( ] ejfqope] a ] i]h`]`a paniej]nk( kqpn]o nahece ao( mqa jk ] _neop( lk`ankoan_d]i]`]o`aiehaj]neop]oakqpnkocnqlko_qhpqn]eodqi]jkojk_neopkop]i) ^ioapknj]nk]`alpko`anahece aoiehaj]neop]o*=ooei(lknatailhk(koj`ekocq]n]jeo( `kL]n]cq]ea`k>n]oeh(]_na`ep]ij]Pann]oaiI]hao(mqaoqncen]hi`koi]nao(`alkeo mqa]pann](_]jo]`]aejbahev(bkn]pn]raoo]`]lknahao(ak`aqo(^ajrkhka_haiajpa(hdao`an ]pann]jkr](kj`a]oÛa_d]ork]nkokvejd]ol]n]pn]van]_]]a]lao_](akj`aokvejdkoko bnqpkoaj_dank]o_aop]o(jkd]ranbnekjai_dqr](jaicqann]jaiiknpa* Pk`]o]onahece aookatlanej_e]o`ab(i]o]onahece ao`]o]hr]k$iaooe je_]o%ok nahece ao`]ba`]aolan]j]*Kiehaj]neoikatlneia(jkcn]qi]eo]hpk(]aolan]j]nahe) ceko]`]onahece ao`]o]hr]k*Jk_]ok`kiehaj]neoik_neopk(]aolan]j]rkhp])oal]n]] ateopj_e]bqpqn]`aqi]ok_ea`]`ajkdean]nmqev]`](ecq]hepne]afqop]7lknaooaikperk( bke_kjoe`an]`k(lah]knpk`kte]_neop(qi]ebobpf^(eopk(qila_]`k_kjpn]]baop]^aha_e`] lah]`kqpnej]_neop(oacqj`k]mq]hknaejk`a@aqofateopaj]Pann]`ao`a]naooqnnaek `a?neopk6]Ecnaf]* =aolan]j]iehaj]neop]ln lne]`]o_h]ooaolklqh]nao(aiok_ea`]`aoaimqalnar]) ha_ai]`aoecq]h`]`a(]ejfqope](]at_hqoka]ieone]*
K^aiaki]h
=
/./
o nahece ao kn`aj]i ] na]he`]`a oacqj`k `keo lnej_leko bqj`]iajp]eo6 k _bj a k j^i$kq]hqva]pnar](klqnkakeilqnk%* Jaooa]ola_pk(dpnopelko`anahece ao6]omlifqbpq^p(aimqadejianko`aqoao(]hcqjo ^kjo(kqpnkoi]qo(kq]piaoik_]`]`aqolk`aj`koankn]^ki(kn]i]q7]oar^ifpq^p(j]o mq]eo]`q]he`]`a`k^aia`ki]haopaj_]nj]`]aÚcqn]`]ai`q]o`erej`]`ao]jp]cje_]o
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
mqajk_aoo]i`a_ki^]pan)oa7a]ojlklqbpq^p(aimqakiaoik`aqop]jpk^kimq]jpk i]q(kq(_kikjk_]ok`kfq`]oik(`k_neope]jeoika`keoh]ieoik(]`erej`]`ak^aiak i]hlnkri`aajpe`]`ao`aikj]_]o(ejbaneknao`erej`]`aaaihqp]_kjpn]ah]* Jk _]ok `k lkhepaoik a `k `q]heoik( ] `ereok ^ai)i]h jk lnk^haipe_]( ]ooei _kik jk k j]o nahece ao ikjkpaop]o mqa jk atecai `] `erej`]`a _kilknp]iajpko oailna^kjo(qjebkniaoadkikcjako(lkeo]]k`k`aqoejokj`rahaej_kilnaajorah* Klnk^hai](lkni(ateopajkikjkpaoikfq`]e_k)_neopkaeoh ie_k* ?kiabaepk(]`erej`]`afq`]e_k)_neopaeoh ie_]`aÚje`]pakhkce_]iajpa_kikrj pbo mlpfqfsl kq ^Ûoj^qfsl6 @aqo ^ki( fqopk( ieoane_kn`ekok( _haiajpa( _ne]`kn je_k `a pk`]o]o_keo]o(kjelkpajpaakjeo_eajpa(i]o(ok^napq`k(apanjkaejÚjepk*@aqokoanlan) baepklknat_ahj_e](kln lnek^aiaaopaapanjk_kikAha*Oak^aiapanjkaejÚjepk( _kikoqnceqoq]jac]k(ki]h;Mqalkoepere`]`alk`ane]panki]hoa(jklnej_lek(d]re] okiajpa@aqo(apanj]aejÚjep]iajpa^ki;=`iepenqilnej_lekapanjkaejÚjepkl]n]k i]hoane]]`iepen`keo`aqoao(ej_knnaj`kjklneiaenkai]eocn]ra`kola_]`ko(lkeop]jpk ko@avI]j`]iajpkomq]jpkk?na`k_neopk]Úni]id]ranqio aje_k@aqo* =hi`eook(@aqo_nekqpk`]o]o_keo]o`kj]`]7pq`kkmqaateopa(lknp]jpk(k^n]`a @aqo*Oaki]hateopa(oane]k^n]`a@aqo;Lkni(@aqo(oaj`kkln lnek^ai(lk`ane]_ne]nk i]h;?kikklanbaepk_ne]ne]keilanbaepk;Mq]h(lkeo(]knecai`ki]h;=_ne]pqn]* @aqo_nekqejpahecj_e]oei]pane]eolanbaep]o(ko]jfko*@ajpnaahao(oqncai]hcqjomqa ]olen]i]pankiaoiklk`anakiaoiko]^anmqa]`erej`]`a(hqp]j`k_kjpn]ah]*Iajko lk`ankoko a iajko o^eko( ok raj_e`ko a atlqhoko `] lnaoaj] `erej]* Jk na_kjda_ai( lkni(]`annkp]*Bkni]iqinaejkoal]n]`k(`a_]koapnar]o(lnkooacqaij]hqp]_kjpn]k ?ne]`kn*Mqarep ne]i]eknpane]ioajk_knnkilan]i]eo]hp]`]o_ne]pqn]o]l oko]jfko( eopk(kdkiai;R]haj`k)oa`]he^an`]`a`]`]]kdkiai(ko]jfko`ki]h_knnkilai] _ne]pqn]dqi]j]a(_kiaop](ki]hajpn]jkiqj`k* Ki]hkla_]`k(eopk(]pn]jocnaook`]hae`erej]mqaklneiaenkdkiaia]lneiae) n]iqhdanln]pe_]n]i*Oq]lqjekbkekoqnceiajpk`kokqpnkoi]hao6iknpa(`kaj](`kn( bkia(oa`a(bnek(pneopav]( `ek(]i^ek(hqtne](cqh](lnacqe](]r]nav]*Lahki]h(]_ne]pqn] ]b]op])oa`a@aqo(lan`a]lnaoaj]`erej]a]^kj`]`aknecej]hmqalkooq]* Ki]h(lknp]jpk(jkqi]bkn]lkoeper]`aiaoi]na]he`]`amqak^ai(i]olqn] ]qoj_e]`k^ai(lqn]lner]k`k^ai(jac]pere`]`a(bn]mqav]*=ooei_kik]pnar]jk ]hcklkoeperk(i]ooeilhao]qoj_e]`]hqv(]ooeip]i^iki]hlqn]]qoj_e]`k^ai*D qio @aqoaki]haop]nhkjcaalner]`k`aha(lkeoAhak^aiakje_k^ai*
Kla_]`k
D
nahece ao`]atpanekne`]`aanahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`a*=onahece ao`]atpanek) ne`]`aok]mqah]oaimqako`aqoaolkooqaibkni]reorah$dqi]j](]jei]h(ra) cap]hkqiejan]h%aoa`enecaio] aoatpanj]oareoraeo`kooanaodqi]jko7jah]( ]okn`ajoakoi]j`]iajpkooanabanai]_kilknp]iajpko`erejkoadqi]jkoatpanjkoa reoraeoa]nah]k`kodkiajo_kiko`aqoaooaatlneiajkonepkoaj]o_aneije]o* =onahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`aok]mqah]oaimqa]`erej`]`a_kj_a^e`]_kiklqnk aolnepk(ejreorahl]n]kokhdko`ajkook_knlk(aoa`eneca]k_kn]k(]kaolnepk(]hi]`k _najpa(b]h]j`koq]_kjo_ej_e]afqhc]j`kko]pkodqi]jko]l]npen`]oejpaj aoejpanek) nao`k]cajpa*=hi`a_qhpq]n]`erej`]`a_kinepkoa_aneije]o(j]nahecek`]ejpanekne`]) `a]nah]kbqj`]iajp]h`kdkiai_kik$o%`aqo$ao%`aaolnepkl]n]aolnepk* Ai]hcqi]onahece ao`]atpanekne`]`a(kla_]`kqi]]katpanj]reorah(_kiape`] rkhqjpne]kqejrkhqjp]ne]iajpa_kjpn]]`erej`]`alah]rekh]k`aqip]^qkqlah]i na]hev]k`aqinepk*=b]hp]foobsbok`f^(oajpe`]j]bkni]`]sbodlke^(pn]vaj`k_kik _kjoamqj_e]qi]fjmrobw^mqa_kjp]iej]kb]hpkokakcnqlk(atecej`knepq]eo`alqneÚ) _]kkqo]_neb_ekoatle]p neko*
PECADOßPALAVRAßQUEßß VEMßDOßLATIMßEßSIGNIFICAß ±CULPA ßFALTA ßCRIME ßß AljOßMf ßERRO²
/.0
2EPRODUljO
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
Aikqpn]onahece ao`]atpanekne`]`a$_kik]o`ko^]^ehjeko(_ahp]o( ^q`eop]o(_dejaoao(cnacko(dej`qo%(kla_]`kjk]laj]oqi]ennaranj_e] ranckjdko](i]op]i^iqi]`rim^_]qo]`]oaf]lknmqakla_]`knaop lkooq`klkn`aijeko(ajbaepe]`klkni]qoaolnepko(oaf]lknmqakla) _]`knoapknj]`aoia`e`k(`evkmqajk`ara(b]vkmqajk`ara(`aoaf]k mqajklk`a`aoaf]njaipan*Jaooao_]oko(]hi`konepq]eo`alqneÚ_]k a`ao]_neb_ekoatle]p neko(pknj]i)oaja_aoonekokobulo`fpjlp$mqakoo]) _an`kpaoln]pe_]iok^nakoaj`aikje]`koakoajbaepe]`ko%alqneÚ_] ao ej`ere`q]eo$]qpkÛ]cah]k(fafqi(]^opejj_e]oatq]h%* J]onahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`a(_kiklknatailhkkfq`]oikak_neo) pe]jeoik(]b]hp]kqla_]`kqi]kbajo]_kiape`]_kjpn]@aqolkniaek `aqi]]kejpanj]ejreorahÍ]fkqbk lÍ(mqaoai]jebaop]jqi]pk atpanjkreorah(paj`k_kik_]qo]kqqi]rkjp]`aikqqiajpaj`eiajpk amqerk_]`k*Mq]j`k_]qo]`klknqi]rkjp]`ai(kla_]`kqi`ofjb7 mq]j`k_]qo]`klknqiajpaj`eiajpkamqerk_]`k(qibool*qi]qo^kp* dobpplatlaneiajp]`]j]bkni]`a`rim^(atecej`katle]kej`ere`q]h*J]o nahece ao`]atpanekne`]`a(klan`k`alaj`aat_hqoer]iajpa`aqi]cn]] `erej](eopk(]`erej`]`alk`akqjklan`k]n(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`kone) pq]eo`alqneÚ_]kna]hev]`kolahkej`er`qkkqlahkcnqlk*J]onahece ao `]ejpanekne`]`a(klan`kÍmqap]i^irenj]bkni]`aqi]cn]]`e) rej]Íatecaqi]atlanej_e]ejpaneknlna_eo](k^oobmbkafjbkql(eopk(k na_kjda_eiajpk`]b]hp]$]_kjÚookj]bkni]`aÎaqlamqaeÏ%a]lnpe_]`a ] aomqai]jebaopaiatpanj]iajpa]`eolkoekejpanekn`k]nnalaj`e`k( oaf]lkniaek`alna_aoakn] ao(oaf]lkniaek`ao]_neb_ekoejÛece`ko]oe iaoik$]qpkÛ]cah]k(fafqi(]^opejj_e]oatq]h(ajpnac]`a^ajoj]bkni] `aaoikh]o(ap_*%* J]i]ekne]`]onahece ao`]atpanekne`]`a(]b]hp]kqla_]`kqi]b]p]) he`]`a*Kc^qrj$Î`aopejkÏ(aih]pei7Îb]`kÏ(ailknpqcqo%kq]jlfo^$Î`ao) pejkb]p]hÏ(aicnack%`apaniejkq`ao`aoailnamqaahaoane]_kiape`klkn ]hcqi(l]n]`aocn]]oq]a`aoaqcnqlk*=b]hp]jk`alaj`a`]rkjp]`a`k =`kaAr]_kjopanj]`kolah]_qhl]`k ]cajpa(i]o`aqi]`a_eok`erej](kq`]lkooaookaajbaepe]iajpk`kla_]) la_]`kknecej]hj]Atlqhok`k`aj( `kn(kq`kb]pk`amqaahalan`aq]ia`e`]`kmqalaniepe`k]kodqi]jko* qi`ko]bnao_kolejp]`kolknI]o]__ek J]onahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`aÍ_kikk_]ok`kfq`]oika`k_neope]jeoik j]_]lah]>n]j_]__e`]ecnaf]`aO]jp] I]ne]`ah?]nieja(aiBhknaj]* Í(]b]hp]j]o_a`]he^an`]`a`k]cajpa(mqa(_kjda_aj`kk^aiaki]h$]hae `erej]%(pn]jocne`a_kjo_eajpaarkhqjp]ne]iajpak`a_napk`a@aqo* PECADOßORIGINALßOßPECADOß Jkfq`]oik(kla_]`k]ejbn]kPkn]d(eopk(hae`erej]narah]`]*?kikkla_]`k ORIGINALßDIFEREßDEßTODOSßOSß NOSSOSßPECADOSßPORQUEß _kjp]iej]kcnqlk(kla_]`kn`arajko ]_aep]n(i]ola`en]@aqolqjekaokbneiajpko NELEßOßHOMEMßEßAßMULHERß lahkomq]eoatlea]_qhl](lqneÚmqa]oeiaoika]kcnqlk*@aoo]i]jaen](kfq`]oikajb]) DESEJARAMßPOSSUIRßOßMES MOßSABERßEßOßMESMOßPODERß pev]]oe`ae]o`a_kjÚook(]nnalaj`eiajpkalajepj_e]* DEß$EUSß2IVALIZARAMßCOMß Jkeoh]ieoik(kCn]j`aLa_]`k]e`kh]pne]$b]vanei]cajo`a=h%aklkhepaoik*Ko SEUßCRIADORßEßDESEJARAMß SEUßLUGARß%SSAßFALTAßNjOß `ai]eola_]`kookkoiaoiko`kfq`]oik(qi]ravmqakEohna_kjda_a]hae`erej]nara) PODEßSERßCORRIGIDAßPORßNE h]`]]Ikeoo*K_najpao]hrk(]lao]n`aoaqola_]`ko(lah]_kjop j_e](lah]b(lah]ok^n]oa NHUMAßAljOßHUMANAßPOR QUEßNENHUMßSERßHUMANOß ]_ei]`apq`klknoaq]nnalaj`eiajpkalajepj_e]* POSSUIßAßMESMAßDIGNIDADEß K_neope]jeoik(_kiOkL]qhkaO]jpk=ckopejdk(ejpnk`qv]e`ae]`amb`^allofdfk^i* QUEß$EUSß!ßINFERIORIDADEß HUMANAßTORNAßIMPOSSqVELß Aooala_]`kjk]laj]oklneiaenkla_]`kjai]laj]okla_]`k_kiape`kj]oknecajo( AOSßHOMENSßEXPIARßAßCULPAß mq]j`k=`kaAr]rere]ijkL]n]ok*Ahalofdfk^ijkoajpe`k`amqa`aoecj]kbpq^alab EßREDIMIR SEß3OMENTEßOß mb`^almqai]n_]]j]pqnav]dqi]j]ai_kjoamqj_e]`aoq]knecai(kqoaf](`aiai^nk PRvPRIOß$EUSßPODEßEXPIARß OßPECADOßORIGINALßESSAß `aqicjank`aoanao$kcjankdqi]jk%_qf]knecaiaj_kjpn])oajkla_]`k_kiape`klahk EXPIAljOßmßREALIZADAßPELOß ]j_aopn]h(lkeokla_]`k`klneiaenkdkiaia`]lneiaen]iqhdanbkekla_]`k`kol]eoa SACRIFqCIOßDOßMESSIAS ßDOß CRISTO ßISTOßm ßDOßENVIADOß lkhqeql]n]oailnapk`]]`ao_aj`j_e]dqi]j]* QUEßmßOßDEUSßENCARNADOßß Oai`re`](l]n]k_neope]jeoik(kla_]`kqilnk^hai]pakh ce_kejokhrah(lkeok@aqo OUßOß&ILHOßDEß$EUS ß*ESUS _neopkkjelkpajpaakjeo_eajpa(o]^aj`kpq`k`ao`a]apanje`]`aa(lknp]jpk(_kjda_aj`k
/.1
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
lnare]iajpakla_]`kn*Oalqjakla_]`k(i]oo]^e]mqaoane]_kiape`k(jkoane]ejfqopk( lknjkeila`enmqaoaf]_kiape`k;Oa_kjda_aapanj]iajpamqaila_]namqaijkla) _]n(jkoan@aqo_kikkc^qrja]jlfo^;A_kikb]h]nj]he^an`]`aajkherna)]n^pnek`k la_]`kn(oa`ao`a]apanje`]`a@aqoo]^e]mqaaha_kiapane]kla_]`k;
Ei]j j_e]apn]jo_aj` j_e]
M
q]j`kaopq`]ikoko]cn]`k(reikomqa(aiejian]o_qhpqn]o(kooanaoak^fapko o]_nkod]^ep]ikjkookiqj`k(okei]jajpao]aha*=olneiaen]oatlanej_e]ona) heceko]ooklkneookm^kqbpq^p(kqoaf](jah]opq`kok`aqoaoaaopaoaopkaipk`] l]npa(aol]hd]`kolah]j]pqnav]*Kooanaopki]il]npaj]`erej`]`a(ikperklahkmq]hlko) oqaij^k^(lobka^aqrkm^*Kkqr]bne_]jkatlneia]_kj_alk`]ei]jj_e]l]jpaop]* =k_kjpnnek`]onahece aol]jpaop]okq`]ei]jj_e]`ko`aqoaojkiqj`k(]onahece ao qbpq^pokpn]jo_aj`ajpao(eopk(ko`aqoaoaopkoal]n]`ko`kiqj`kj]pqn]hadqi]jk( reraijkqpnkiqj`ka]caiok^nakjkook*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqako`aqoaocnacko( ai^kn]pajd]ibkni]dqi]j](reraijkikjpaKheilk(aFakr(mqalkooqe]pne^qpkodq) i]jko$_kik]rkv%(i]jebaop])oa(lknatailhk(jkikjpaOej]e*Aeolknmqa(j]onahece ao `]pn]jo_aj`j_e](b]h])oaj]sfpfq^ l`ko`aqoaol]n]nabanen)oa]koikiajpkoaimqaoa _kiqje_]i_kikooanaodqi]jko* J]orne]onahece ao`]pn]jo_aj`j_e](]reoep]k`erej]jklnk^haipe_](lknmqako `aqoaolkooqaibkni]oi]pane]eoÍ]jei]eo(_kikj]nahecekacl_e](dqi]j]o(_kikj]o nahece aocnac]anki]j]*=reoep]kqilnk^hai]j]nahecek_neop(lknmqak@aqo_neopk ar^psbwbpjfpqboflplapkp]hiajpa`ebanajpa`]obkni]oateopajpaojkiqj`k*Ailneiaenk hqc]n(apanjk(ej_knl nak(ejÚjepk(lhajkalanbaepk(ajklkoorahmqa]l]na]]kodkiajo ahdaob]ha`enap]iajpa(lkeol]n]eookpane]`alkooqen_knlkarkv*Lknaooalneiaenkikperk( k_neope]jeoikb]h]j]reoep]k`a@aqolkniaek`ko]jfkoao]jpko(aj]ejolen]k`ajkook aolnepklahkAolnepkO]jpk(ajre]`klahkL]e*Aioacqj`khqc]n(_kjopepq`klknpnolao) ok]omqaokqi]o $L]e(BehdkaAolnepkO]jpk%(`kj`ak_]npanpkp]hiajpaej_kilnaajorah aieopanekok`]aj_]nj]k`kBehdkaiFaoqo?neopk(lkeo_kikatlhe_]nmqaqi]`]olaook]o `]Pnej`]`aoaoal]na`]okqpn]ol]n]rend]^ep]najpnakodkiajoamqaqioanapanjk(ei]) pane]haejÚjepkpkia]bkni]i]pane]h(iknp]h(Újep](_]najpaaeilanbaep]`kdqi]jk; L]n]oqlan]n]o`eÚ_qh`]`ao(k_neope]jeoikb]h]j]reoep]k`a@aqolkniaek`ko]jfko ao]jpko(aj]ejolen]k`kAolnepkO]jpk(ajre]`klahkL]e*
PANTEqSTAßTHEOS ßEMß GREGO ßSIGNIFICAß±DEUS²ß PAN ßEMßGREGO ßSIGNIFICA ß ±TODOS ßTUDO²
Pn]jo_aj` j_e]adean]nmqe]
R
eikomqa(lah]hae`erej](ejopepq`]]kn`ai`kiqj`kj]pqn]hadqi]jk*Reiko p]i^imqak_kjda_eiajpk`aoo]haepaj`a]pknj]n)oaqi_kjda_eiajpkaola_e]h( oaf]lknmqaokiajpa]hcqjookao_khde`kol]n]_kjda_)h](oaf]lknmqakpatpk`] haeej_kilnaajorahaatecalaook]o_]l]vao`ab]van]ejpanlnap]k$lnkbap]oare`ajpao%( oaf]]ej`]lknmqa]ln lne]ejpanlnap]kk^o_qn]aatecajkrkoejpnlnapao* ?kjop]p]ikomqak_kjda_eiajpk`]haea`]rkjp]`a`erej]ookaooaj_e]eol]n]]j]n) n]per]`]deop ne]o]cn]`]al]n]]na]hev]k_knnap]aaÚ_]v`konepko*?kik_kjoamqj_e](]o nahece aopaj`ai]ejopepqenqicnqlk`aej`er`qko(oal]n]`ko`knaop]jpa`]_kiqje`]`a( aj_]nnac]`ko`apn]joiepen]deop ne]o]cn]`](ejpanlnap]n]haeakooej]eo`erejko(na]hev]nko nepkoai]n_]nkaol]k)pailko]cn]`ko* I]cko(]opn hkcko(re`ajpao(lnkbap]o(t]io(o]_an`kpaoal]folkooqaio]^anaoalk) `anaoaola_e]eo*Ok_]l]vao`a_qn]n(`alnarankbqpqnk(`a]lh]_]n]_ han]`ko`aqoao(`a ]jqj_e]n]rkjp]`a`erej](`a`aopnqen]`eop j_e]$lkniaek`al]h]rn]oacaopko%*Eje_e]h) iajpa(oq]bqjkpn]vanko]cn]`kl]n]kcnqlka]_kjoanr)hk*Lkq_k]lkq_k(lkni( bkni]iqicnqlkoal]n]`k(qi]_h]ooaok_e]h(_kiatecj_e]oalk`anaoln lneko(lner]i
/.2
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
]_kiqje`]`a`]lnaoaj]`enap]`ko]cn]`ka`eopkn_ai]bqjkknecejne]mqalkooq]i( pn]jobkni]j`k)]ai`kijekalk`anok^na]_kiqje`]`a*Pknj]i)oakolknp]`knaooei^ ) he_ko`ko]cn]`kaia`e]`knaoej`eolajoraeo* =nahecek(_kikfk^oanr]iko(na]hev]kaj_]jp]iajpk`kiqj`k(atlhe_]j`k)klahk i]n]rehdkok a ieopanekok* K cnqlk mqa `api k o]^an nahecekok( ]k pknj]n)oa `apajpkn `k lk`an(lkooqeklk`ani]eo]hpk6k`aaj_]jp]n(`aoaj_]jp]nanaaj_]jp]nkiqj`k*Lkneook( jqilneiaenkikiajpk(klk`annahecekok_kj_ajpn])oaj]oiko`aqio (mqalkooqep]i) ^i]]qpkne`]`aiehep]nak`kijeka_kjie_kok^napk`]]_kiqje`]`a* Çia`e`]mqa]onah] aook_e]eooapknj]ii]eo_kilhat]o(_ki`ereo aook_e]eo`k pn]^]hdka`]lnklnea`]`a(klk`anl]oo]lknqi]`ereok6qicnqlk`api]]qpkne`]`a naheceko]akqpnk(]iehep]naa_kjie_]*Lkni(pk`kko]^an`]_kiqje`]`aÍdeop ne]o]) cn]`](ejpanlnap]k`]hae`erej](nepq]eoÍaj_kjpn])oaj]oiko`]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]( mqal]oo](`aoo]i]jaen](]oank^n]kejpaha_pq]hafqn`e_kej`eolajorah`]]qpkne`]`a a_kjie_]aiehep]n* J]onahece ao`]pn]jo_aj`j_e](pnook]o_kjoamqj_e]olnej_el]eo`aooa`aoajrkh) reiajpkdeop ne_k6 -*
]bkni]k`aqi]]qpkne`]`amqa`apiklnerehcek`ko]^an(lknmqa_kjda_a]rkj) p]`a `erej] a oq]o haeo* ?ki ah]( oqnca ] fkpqfqrf l p^`boalq^i b b`ibpfpqf`^* Jk lkn ]_]ok(?_ank`enmqa]l]h]rn]obifdflrai`kran^kibdbob(ÎhanÏ*Koo]_an`kpaookej) paha_pq]eo*Kcnqlko]_an`kp]h`apirnekoo]^anao6k`]deop ne]o]cn]`](k`konepq]eo( k`]ohaeo`erej]o(lah]omq]eoeilkop]]ikn]he`]`a]kcnqlk*?kikaooaoo]^anaooa nabanai]k`erejk(_kjopepqai]pakhkce]*Koo]_an`kpao(kqqi]l]npa`ahao(okpa hk) cko*P]eoo]^anaohdao`kkooacqejpaolk`anao6
jdf`l6okkoje_komqa_kjda_aiao]^aii]jelqh]nkorj_qhkooa_napkoajpna]o _keo]o7 afsfk^qofllr^afsfke^qofl6okkoje_ko_]l]vao`alnaranko]_kjpa_eiajpkolah] ejpanlnap]k`ko]opnko(`aoej]eoa`]oajpn]jd]o`ko]jei]eo7 molmf`f^qofl6okkoje_ko_]l]vao`ana]hev]nkonepko`ai]jaen]_knnap]a]`amq]`] l]n]k^pajk`kob]rknao`erejko7 mrkfqfsl6okkoje_komqa_kjda_ai]ohaeo`erej]oalk`ailqjenkopn]jocnaooknao kqejÚeo* .*
/.3
]bkniqh]k`aqi]`kqpnej]naheceko]^]oa]`]j]e`ae]`aefbo^onrf^(eopk(`aqi] na]he`]`aknc]jev]`]j]bkni]`acn]qooqlaneknaoaejbaneknaokj`aoaoepq]ipk`koko oanao(lknrkjp]`a`erej]*Koajpaooa`eopejcqailknoq]lnkteie`]`akq`eop j_e]`ko `aqoao(oacqj`kkhqc]ndeannmqe_k(Útkaeiqprah(mqahdaobke`aopej]`k* =ooei(lknatailhk(]hcqi]onahece aolk`ai_kjoe`an]n_anpko]jei]eoi]eoln ) teiko`ko`aqoao(oaj`klkneooki]eolk`ankoko(i]eoo^ekoaiahdknao`kmqapk`koko kqpnkoajpao*Kqpn]olk`ai_kjoe`an]n]oajpe`]`aoei]pane]eooqlaneknaoa]oi]pane]eo kq_knlkn]eoejbaneknao*Kqpn]olk`ai_kjoe`an]nkodqi]jkokcn]qi]eo]hpk`]dean]n) mqe](pk`kokokqpnkooanaoaop]j`koq^kn`ej]`ko]ahaoa`araj`k)hdaok^a`ej_e]* J]onahece aolkhepaop]o(]dean]nmqe]_kia]lahkoln lneko`aqoao(d]raj`k`aq) oaooqlaneknaoaejbaneknao*J]onahece aoikjkpaop]o(]dean]nmqe]l a]`erej`]`ajk pklk`aqi]ao_]h]ako`ai]eooanaookkn`aj]`kooacqj`koq]i]eknkqiajknoa) iahd]j]_kiah]*=ooei(lknatailhk(jk_neope]jeoik(dqi]dean]nmqe]_ahaopa$]j) fko(]n_]jfko(mqanq^ejo(oan]Újo(pnkjko(lkpaop]`aoao]jpko%aqi]dean]nmqe]pannao) pna$dkiajo(]jei]eo(lh]jp]o(iejan]eo%(aop]j`k]^]etk`ah]ko`aijekoa]opnar]o*= jkk`adean]nmqe]ejpnk`qv]ojk ao`aprmbofloafkcboflo(`aÚjej`k]nah]kajpna ]i^kolahki]j`kalah]k^a`ej_e]*@aoo]i]jaen](]nahecekknc]jev]kiqj`ka( _kieook(]ok_ea`]`a*Are`ajpaiajpa(komqaoak_ql]i_ki]o_keo]oo]cn]`]oaopk jkpklk`]dean]nmqe]dqi]j]apk`kokokqpnkohdao`araik^a`ej_e]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
/*
klnerehcek`kqok`]rekhj_e]o]cn]`]l]n]lqjenkob]hpkokokqla_]`knao*Eje_e]hiaj) pa(atece])oamqapk`kokoiai^nko`]_kiqje`]`abkooailea`koko(kqoaf](naolaep]o) oai`aqoao(p]^qo(nepq]eoa]iai ne]`ko]jpal]oo]`ko*?kikoqnceiajpk`]_h]ooa o]_an`kp]h(l]ookq)oa]atecenmqaaooaoiai^nko`]_kiqje`]`aÍkoo]_an`kpaoÍ bkooai_]opko(eopk(lkooqooaiejpacne`]`a_knlkn]haaolenepq]hl]n]kÚ_e]nkonepkoa ejpanlnap]n]ohaeo*J]mq]he`]`a`a_]opko(okkoi]eolqnkoalkneookejraope`ko(]l o a`q_]kaeje_e]k(`klk`an`alqneÚ_]k*@apiklk`anfq`e_enek*
J]onahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`a(_kikk_]ok`k_neope]jeoika`kfq`]oik(klnereh) cekfq`e_eneka`]rekhj_e]o]cn]`]atan_e`kjko ok^nak_knlkak_kilknp]iajpk`ko Úeo(i]ook^napq`kok^na]o]hi]o*?kikeooklkoorah; Jk_]ok`k_]pkhe_eoikkq`k_neope]jeoik`]Ecnaf]`aNki](lknatailhk(eookbae) pk lkn iaek `a `keo lnk_a`eiajpko lnej_el]eo* K lneiaenk ] `lkÛppl a^p c^iq^p lr alp mb`^alp(baep]lan]jpako]_an`kpa(mqapaiklk`anl]n]lan`k]nkq]^okhrania`e]jpak ]nnalaj`eiajpk`kla_]`kna`]olajepj_e]omqahdaokeilkop]o* Dqi_ `eckpe_k)nahecekokmqa`apaniej]mq]eookkola_]`ko$mb`^alpjloq^fp(mb* `^alpsbkf^fp(mb`^alp`^mfq^fp%(mq]eokoik`ko`ala_]n$mlo^ql(m^i^so^pafkqbk bp%(mq]h k`]jk_]qo]`k]kla_]`knamq]eo]olajepj_e]omqa`ara_qilnen*Kla_]`knb]vqiat]) ia`a_kjo_ej_e](_kjbaoo]]ko]_an`kpa(pknj]j`kreorah$lknl]h]rn]o%kooacna`ko`aoq] ]hi]aajpnac])oaieoane_ n`e]`a@aqo(nalnaoajp]`klahko]_an`kpamqalqjaalan`k]* Koacqj`klnk_a`eiajpkkbu^jbp^`boalq^ia^pfabf^pba^plmfkfbpalpÛfp*@ab]pk( ko]^annahecekok_neopkaop_kjoecj]`kjqipatpkÍ]Ao_nepqn]O]cn]`]Íajqi_kjfqjpk `apatpkoejpanlnap]perko`klneiaenkÍ]pakhkce]n]_ekj]hÍ(bkni]j`k]`kqpnej]_neop* L]npa`aoo]`kqpnej]_kjopepq`]lknran`]`aonarah]`]o_kilnaajoraeol]n]]n]vkdqi]) j](l]npa_kjopepq`]lknran`]`aonarah]`]oej_kilnaajoraeol]n]]ejpahecj_e]dqi]j]* Aoo]ohpei]oran`]`ao_kjopepqaiko`kci]o`]b ajklk`aioanmqaopekj]`]o*Mqaopek) j)h]okqlnklkn)hdaoqi_kjpa`kkqoecjeÚ_]`k`ebanajpao`kaop]^aha_e`klah]`kqpnej] _kjoe`an]`kla_]`kiknp]h*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa]pn]jocnaooknaheceko]lk`ak_knnanlkniaek `klajo]iajpkkq`]oe`ae]o*]ebobpf^$l]h]rn]cnac]mqaoecjeÚ_]Îklejek`eo_kn`]jpaÏ%* =ejopepqeko]_an`kp]hpaiklk`anl]n]lqjendanaoe]oakb]vlknpno_]iejdko6] bu`ljrkel$kÚah^]je`k`]_kiqje`]`a`ko_najpaoalnkiape`klqjekapanj]%(] l_qbk la^`lkÛpplab^oobmbkafjbkql`kdanaca$aican]h(k^pe`]lkniaek`apknpqn]% kq]`lkabk^ l jloqb*=ooei(ko]cn]`k`knecainahecek(ajmq]jpk]ok_ea`]`ab]v ]l]na_anklk`anpakh ce_k`]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]*
=obej]he`]`ao`]nahecek
=
ejrajk_qhpqn]h`ko]cn]`koana]hev]_kiklnk_aook`aoei^khev]kaaj_]jp]) iajpk`kiqj`k(oaf]j]bkni]`]fj^kk`f^`kok^naj]pqn]hjkj]pqn]h(oaf]j]`] qo^kp`bkak`f^`kok^naj]pqn]h*Ko]cn]`k`oecjeÚ_]k]kaol]k(]kpailka]ko oanaomqajahaoj]o_ai(reraiaiknnai* = l]oo]cai `k o]cn]`k nahecek `apaniej] ]o Új]he`]`ao lnej_el]eo `] atlanej_e] naheceko]a`]ejopepqekok_e]hnaheceko]*Ajpnaaoo]oÚj]he`]`ao`aop]_]iko6 lnkpacankooanaodqi]jko_kjpn]kia`k`]j]pqnav](jah]aj_kjpn]j`kbkn]o^ajÚ) _]o(_kjpn]lkop]ooi]hÚ_]oa`aopnqe`kn]o7 `]n]kodqi]jkoqi]_aookran`]`a`kiqj`k(aj_kjpn]j`katlhe_] aol]n]]kne) cai(]bkni](]re`]a]iknpa`apk`kokooanaoa`koln lnekodqi]jko7 kbana_an]kodqi]jko]aolan]j]`are`]]l o]iknpa(oaf]j]bkni]`anaaj_]nj]k lanaja(oaf]j]bkni]`anaaj_]nj]klqneÚ_]`kn](oaf]j]bkni]`]eiknp]he`]`aej) `ere`q]h(mqalaniepaknapknjk`kdkiai]k_kjrrek`enapk_ki]`erej`]`a(oaf]j] bkni]`abqok`kaolnepk`kiknpkjkoaek`]`erej`]`a*=onahece ao`]o]hr]k(p]j)
/.4
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
pk]o`apelkfq`]e_k)_neopkmq]jpk]o`apelkkneajp]h(lnkiapai]kooanaodqi]jko he^anp)hko`]laj]a`]`kn`]ateopj_e]pannaj]7 kbana_an_kjokhk]ko]Ûepko(`]j`k)hdaoqi]atlhe_]kl]n]]`kn(oaf]ah]boe_](oaf] lomqe_]7 c]n]jpenknaolaepkojkni]o(onacn]oa]kor]hknao`]ikn]he`]`aaop]^aha_e`]lah] ok_ea`]`a*Aican]h(kor]hknaoikn]eookaop]^aha_e`kolah]ln lne]nahecekj]bkni] `ai]j`]iajpko`erejko(eopk(]naheceknaah]^kn]]onah] aook_e]eoateopajpao_kik nacn]oajkni]o(atlnaoo ao`]rkjp]`a`ko`aqoaokq`a@aqo(c]n]jpej`k]k^nec]pk) nea`]`a`]k^a`ej_e]]ah]ook^laj]`ao]j aook^naj]pqn]eo*
?npe_]onahecek !RALDOß$Eß,UCß#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
= %PICURO߯ßA# ß FILvSOFOßGREGOßATOMISTA ß FUNDADORßDOßEPICURISMO
/.5
olneiaen]o_npe_]onahecekbaep]ojklajo]iajpkk_e`ajp]hrean]i`koÚh okbko ln)ok_npe_ko(mqa_nepe_]n]iklkhepaoikak]jpnklkiknÚoik`ko`aqoao*=Ún) i]n]iahaomqa(`klkjpk`areop]`]n]vk(]lhqn]he`]`a`ko`aqoao]^oqn`](lkeo ]aooj_e]`]`erej`]`a]lhajepq`aejÚjep](jklk`aj`kd]ranoajkqi]lkpj_e]`ere) j]*@a_h]n]n]ip]i^i]^oqn`kk]jpnklkiknÚoik(mqa]pne^qe]ko`aqoaomq]he`]`aoa lnklnea`]`aodqi]j]ojqicn]qoqlanh]perk(eopk(_kikoako`aqoaojkbkooaioajk oqlan)dkiajo*=n]vk(lkni(o]^amqaahao`araioanprmo^)dqi]jko(kqoaf](]omq]he) `]`ao`kooanao`erejkojklk`ai_kjbqj`en)oa_ki]o`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]*Aoo]o_npe_]o bkn]inapki]`]oaoeopai]pev]`]olknLh]pk(=neop pahaoalahkoaopke_ko* Qi]kqpn]_npe_]nahecekbkebaep]lahkcnackAle_qnkanapki]`]lahkh]pejkHq_n_ek* =nahecek(`evaiahao(b]^qh]kehqo ne](j]o_e`]`kia`k`]iknpaa`]j]pqnav]*oq) lanopek*Jko_qhkTRE(kolajo]`knao_d]i]`kohe^anpejkonapki]iaoo]iaoi]_npe_]* Jko_qhkTREE(kÚh okbkAolejko]p]i^i]na_khk_](i]o(airav`a_kia]nlah]na) hecek(_kia]lah]prmbopqf l*Kodkiajo(`evaha(piia`k`amqai]haohdao]_kjpa]i ajqpnaiaolan]j]`amqa^ajohdao]`rajd]i*Ikre`kolknaoo]o`q]ol]et ao$ia`ka aolan]j]%(jk_kjÚ]iaioeiaoikojaijko_kjda_eiajpkon]_ekj]eol]n]arep]ni]haoa ]pn]en^ajo*L]ooekj]hkqenn]_ekj]hiajpa(fqhc]imqa]knecai`koi]haoa^ajoaj_kjpn])oa aibkn]o_]lne_dko]o(_kik]oknpaa]bknpqj](al]oo]i]]_na`ep]njah]o_kiklk`anao mqakockranj]i]n^epn]ne]iajpa*Aoo]_naj]]oqlanopek* L]n]]heiajp)h](_ne]i]nahecekaaop](l]n]_kjoanr]noaq`kijekok^nakodkiajo( ejopepqeklk`anpakh ce_k)lkhpe_k(eopk(qi]lkhpe_]`enece`]a_ki]j`]`]lah]nahecek(kq iahdkn(lahko`apajpknao`klk`aneknahecekok*@aoo]i]jaen](o]_an`kpaoapa hkckob]vai _nan mqa ]o haeo lkhpe_]o jk bkn]i ejopepq`]o lahko ln lneko dkiajo( i]o lah] rkjp]`a `a@aqokq`ko`aqoaoamqaaop]bkenarah]`]]]hcqjomqa(lkneook(pik`enaepk`erejk`a `kiej]na_ki]j`]nko`ai]eo*J]o_e`]`kia`koqlanope_ekok(]nahecekaop(lknp]jpk(] oanrek`]pen]je](aaop]p]jpki]eobknpamq]jpki]eokodkiajobknai`aet]`koj]ecjk) n j_e]`]ran`]`aen]j]pqnav]`a@aqo(`]oran`]`aen]o_]qo]o`apk`]o]o_keo]oa`]knecai dqi]j]`klk`anlkhpe_ka`]ohaeo* =_npe_]Úhko Ú_]nahecek_kj_ajpnkq)oa(lkq_k]lkq_k(j]]Úni]k`]`ebanaj] ajpna nahecek narah]`] a ran`]`aenk _kjda_eiajpk `a @aqo( kq oaf]( j] `ebanaj] ajpna ] _naj]jqi]`erej`]`aok^naj]pqn]hmqaeil ahaeo]kodkiajoak_kjda_eiajpkn]_ekj]h `]aooj_e]`a@aqo*Aoo]`ebanaj]harkq(jkoo_qhkoTREEaTREEE(e`ae]`aqi]nahecek jknarah]`](jkok^naj]pqn]h(_d]i]`]`aobifdflk^qro^ikqabpjl*Rkhp]j`k)oa_kjpn]] naheceknarah]`]aejopepq_ekj]hev]`]_kiklk`ana_haoeope_kalk`anpakh ce_k)lkhpe_k(ko Úh okbko]Úni]n]i]ateopj_e]`aqi@aqomqaqi]bkn]kqqi]ajance]ejpahecajpa( ei]jajpaj]pqnav](_kjda_e`klah]n]vka_kjpnnekoqlanopek* K^oanr]iko(lknp]jpk(mqa]o_npe_]onahecekrkhp]i)oa_kjpn]`keo`aoaqo]ola_pko6 kaj_]jp]iajpk`kiqj`k(_kjoe`an]`koqlanopek(aklk`anpakh ce_k)lkhpe_kejopepq_ek) j]h(_kjoe`an]`kpen je_k*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Jko_qhkTET(kÚh okbkBaqan^]_d_nepe_kq]nahecek_kik^ifbk^ l*Kooanaodqi]) jkorerai(`ao`aoailna(jqi]nah]k_ki]j]pqnav]a(`ao`aiqepk_a`k(oajpaija) _aooe`]`a`aatlhe_)h]akb]vai]j]heo]j`k]knecai`]o_keo]o(]nacqh]ne`]`a`ko]_kj) pa_eiajpkoj]pqn]eo(]knecai`]re`](]_]qo]`]`kna`]iknpa(]_kjoanr]k`kpailk l]oo]`kj]iai ne]a]aolan]j]`aqipailkbqpqnk*L]n]eook(_ne]iko`aqoao*@k)hdao bkn]oalk`anaomqaatlneiai`aoafkodqi]jko*B]vai)jko_ne]`knao`]na]he`]`a*Lkq_k ]lkq_k(l]oo]i]_kj_a^)hko_kikckranj]jpao`]na]he`]`a(`kp]`ko`abkn]oalk`anao i]eknao`komqakodqi]jko* Jaooaikreiajpk(cn]`q]hiajpa(`acan]k]can]k(kooanaodqi]jkooaaomqa_ai `amqabkn]iko_ne]`knao`]`erej`]`a(ejranpai]olkoe aoafqhc]i)oa_ne]`kolahko`aq) oao*Aopao(_]`]ravi]eo(pknj]i)oaoanaokjelkpajpao(kjeo_eajpaoa`eop]jpao`kodqi]jko( atecej`k`aopao_qhpk(nepkak^a`ej_e]*Pknj]i)oapn]jo_aj`ajpaoal]oo]i]`kiej]n] ei]cej]ka]re`]`kooanaodqi]jko*=]heaj]knaheceko]aooahkjcklnk_aooklahkmq]h kodkiajojkoana_kjda_aijklnk`qpk`aoq]ln lne]_ne]k(pn]jobkni]j`k)kjqi kqpnk$^ifbkrp%(aopn]jdk(`eop]jpa(lk`ankoka`kiej]`kn*K`kijek`]_ne]pqn]$`aqoao% ok^naoaqo_ne]`knao$dkiajo%]]heaj]k* =]jheoa`aBaqan^]_dbkenapki]`]lknI]nt(`amqai_kjda_aiko]_ha^naatlnaook6 Î=nahecekk lek`klkrkÏ*?kiaoo]]Úni]k(I]ntlnapaj`aikopn]nmqa]nahecekÍnaba) nej`k)oa]kfq`]oik(]k_neope]jeoika]keoh]ieoik(eopk(onahece ao`]o]hr]kÍ]iknpa) _a]_ki^]pere`]`a`koklneie`koaatlhkn]`ko(lknmqahdaolnkiapaqi]re`]bahevjkbqpqnk ajqikqpnkiqj`k*J]aolan]j]`abahe_e`]`aafqope]kllrqoljrkal(ko`aolkooq`ko( atlhkn]`koadqiehd]`ko`aet]i`a_ki^]pan]o_]qo]o`aoq]oieone]okbpqbjrkal* Pk`]re](I]ntbavqi]kqpn]]Úni]kmqa(aican]h(jkhai^n]`]*@eooaahamqaÎ] nahecekh ce_]aaj_e_hkl`e]lklqh]n(aolnepk`aqiiqj`koaiaolnepkÏ*MqaoecjeÚ_]i aoo]ol]h]rn]o; ?kiah]o(I]ntlnk_qnkqikopn]nmqa]nahecekqi]bkni]`a_kjda_eiajpka`a atlhe_]k`]na]he`]`a(qo]`]lah]o_h]ooaolklqh]naoÍh ce_]aaj_e_hkl`e]Íl]n]`]n oajpe`ko_keo]o(onah] aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o(aj_kjpn]j`koecjeÚ_] aoÍkaolnepkjk iqj`k oai aolnepk Í mqa hdao laniep]i( lanek`e_]iajpa( hqp]n _kjpn] ko lk`anao pen ) je_ko* I]nt pejd] j] hai^n]j] ]o narkhp]o _]ilkjao]o a lklqh]nao `qn]jpa ] Nabkni] Lnkpaop]jpa(^ai_kikj]NarkhqkEjchao]`a-200(j]NarkhqkBn]j_ao]`a-345ajko ikreiajpkoiehaj]neop]omqaatlneien]i(j]E`]`aI`e]ajkej_ek`koikreiajpkook) _e]heop]o(]hqp]lklqh]n_kjpn]]ejfqope]ok_e]halkhpe_]* Oa lkn qi h]`k( j] nahecek( d ] c^`b lmf`f^ `k _kjbknieoik( d( lkn kqpnk h]`k( ] c^`b`lj_^qfs^`komqaqo]iko]^annahecekok_kjpn]]oejopepqe aohacepei]`]olahklk`an pakh ce_k)lkhpe_k*
Iupdkoahcko
J
]i]ekne]`]o_qhpqn]o(]nahecekoa]lnaoajp]_kikoeopai]atlhe_]perkcan]h(kba) na_aj`k_]qo]oaabaepko(nah] aoajpnaoanao(r]hknaoikn]eoap]i^ioqopajp]k ]klk`anlkhpe_k*Jah]oaabaper]qi]sfplabjrkalje_](rhe`]l]n]pk`]]ok) _ea`]`a(abknja_a]oaqoiai^nkoqi]_kiqje`]`a`a]ka`a`aopejk* Jk_]ok`]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]h(lkni(]nahecekpknjkq)oa]laj]oi]eoqioeopai]at) lhe_]perk`]na]he`]`a(ajpnakqpnko*=nqlpqn]_kikjvqelp(abapq]`]lahkoqnceiajpka `aoajrkhreiajpk `k idlp( eopk ( `k lajo]iajpk n]_ekj]h( `aobav k lnerehcek `] nahecek _kiksfplabjrkal kf`^*BehkokÚ]a_ej_e]ah]^kn]n]iatlhe_] ao_qfkolnej_lekook _kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpao`ko`]nahecek* Reiko]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`klajo]iajpkÚhko Ú_kmq]j`k]ÚhkokÚ]j]o_a j]Cn_e]*Reikop]i^ikopn]komqa_kjopepqaike`a]h_eajpÚ_k*@e]jpa`aoo]o`q]o bkni]o`a_kjda_eiajpk(kiepkoa]lnaoajp]_kikn]`e_]hiajpa`eopejpk*Ai^kn]eookf pajd]oe`k]j]heo]`k]jpanekniajpa(r]ikona_]lepqh]n]`eopejkajpnajvqelpaidlp6
6EJA SEßSOBRETUDOßAßß 5NIDADEß ßCAPqTULOSßßEß
//,
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
ANTINOMIAßCONTRADIljOß ENTREßDOISßARGUMENTOSßVf LIDOS ßLvGICOSßOUßCOERENTES ß MASßQUEßCHEGAMßAßCON CLUSzESßDIAMETRALMENTEß OPOSTAS ßDEMONSTRANDOßß ASßCONTRADIlzESßINERENTESß AOßINTELECTOßHUMANO
//-
Kjvqelpqi]b]h](qinah]pkkqqi]j]nn]per]_qfkpai]lnej_el]h]lofdbj$kne) cai`kiqj`k(`kodkiajo(`]op_je_]o(`ko`aqoao(`]onah] aoajpnadkiajoa`aqoao( ap_*%7jkoa`aÚjalahkk^fapk`]j]nn]per]kq`knah]pk(i]ombiljlal`ljlk^oo^kqmbil jlal`ljlmolcbob^jbkp^dbj(`aoknpamqamq]hmqanpai]amq]hmqanoanlk`aioank^) fapk`aiepk6pknj]i)oaipe_ko]koapn]jobkni]naiair]hknaoaoi^khkoo]cn]`ko* Kjvqelppai_kikbqjknaokhran(jqilh]jkoei^ he_kaei]cejnek(]o]jpejkie]o( ]opajo ao(ko_kjÛepkoa]o_kjpn]`e ao`]na]he`]`aok_e]hmqajklk`aioannaokhre`]o kqokhq_ekj]`]olah]ln lne]ok_ea`]`a(_ne]j`k(]ooei(qi]oacqj`]na]he`]`a(mqaatlhe_] ]knecai`klnk^hai]aknaokhra`aik`kmqa]na]he`]`alkoo]_kjpejq]n_kiklnk^hai] oaioan`aopnq`]lknaha*Kiepk_ne]qi]_kilajo]koei^ he_]aei]cejne]l]n]`eÚ) _qh`]`ao(pajo aoahqp]ona]eope`]o_kikejokhraeo7aoo]okhqkei]cejne]lknmqaklan] _ki]h ce_]ejreorahaoq^f]_ajpaknc]jev]kok_e]h*Kqoaf](_kjÛepko(pajo ao(hqp]oa ]jpejkie]ojkokreoraeoalan_alpraeo(i]oejreoraeoaeilan_alpraeo(_ki]j`]j`kk bqj_ekj]iajpkreorah`]knc]jev]kok_e]h*Kiepkoanabana]aooabqj`kejreorahapajok aknaokhraei]cej]ne]iajpal]n]c]n]jpen]lani]jj_e]`]knc]jev]k*=hi`aoanqi] h ce_]`]_kilajo]k(qi]h ce_]`]_kjoanr]k`]ok_ea`]`a(ejopnqiajpkl]n]arep]n ]iq`]j]a]`ao]cnac]k`kcnqlk*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ah]^kn]`kl]n]k_qhp]n]atla) nej_e]`]deop ne]kq`kpailk* Kjvqelpjk]laj]oabaepk`]o_]qo]ook_e]eo(i]opknj])oa_]qo]p]i^i(eopk(qi] ravah]^kn]`k(l]oo]]lnk`qvenabaepkook_e]eo6ejopepqe ao(_kilknp]iajpko(oajpeiajpko( ap_* qi] ]k ok_e]h _ki abaepko ok_e]eo* Qhpn]l]oo] ]o bnkjpaen]o `] ok_ea`]`a kj`a bke oqo_ep]`k(lkeooq]atlhe_]kreo]atlneienaopnqpqn]oqjerano]eo`kaolnepkdqi]jka`k iqj`k*=ooei(lknatailhk(koiepkopakcje_koa_koikcje_ko_kj_anjajpaolnke^ek `kej_aopk(ai^kn]nabanajpaooja_aooe`]`aoejpanj]o`aqi]ok_ea`]`al]n]]ah]^kn]k `]ohaeo`al]najpao_ka`koeopai]`a]he]j]o(naooqncaaipk`]o]ook_ea`]`ao(atlneiej`k qi]aopnqpqn]qjerano]h`]_qhpqn]* Kjvqelpnarah]qi]aopnqpqn]ej_kjo_eajpa`]ok_ea`]`a(`ap]hik`kmqalkoorah`eo) pejcqen]aopnqpqn]ej_kjo_eajpaqjerano]ha]oiajo]cajol]npe_qh]naomqa_]`]ok_ea`]`aej) rajp]l]n]naokhran]opajo aoako_kjÛepkokq_kjpn]`e aoej_kjo_eajpao*Kiepk_kjp]qi] deop ne]`n]ipe_]j]mq]h]kn`ai`kiqj`k$knaejkracap]h(iejan]h(]jei]hadqi]jk%bke _ne]`]a_kjopepq`]*Ko]_kjpa_eiajpkoj]nn]`koatlneiai(oeiqhp]ja]iajpa(qi]aopnq) pqn]can]h`klajo]iajpkdqi]jkaqi]okhqkl]n_e]hmqaqi]ok_ea`]`a`apaniej]`] aj_kjpnkql]n]klnk^hai]*=ooei(]`ebanaj]dkiai)racap]h(dkiai)]jei]h(dkiai)iq) hdan(re`])iknpa(pnar])hqvqi]`ebanaj]mqa]pkniajp]qjerano]hiajpapk`]o]o_qhpqn]o( i]o_]`]qi]`ah]olkooqeqi]j]nn]per]ipe_]aola_Ú_]l]n]naolkj`an]aooapkniajpk* ?kil]n]`k]k`eo_qnokÚhko Ú_ka_eajpÚ_k(k`eo_qnokipe_kklan](oacqj`kHre)Opn]qoo( lahkia_]jeoik`k_of`li^db(eopk(]ooei_kik]hcqifqjp]la`]koal]npao`ak^fapko]j) peckol]n]b]vanqik^fapkjkrk(jkmq]hoalk`ailan_a^an]ol]npaokqla`]ko`kok^fapko ]jpaneknao(]ooeip]i^ikjvqelp_kjopn eoq]j]nn]per](jk_kikkidlp(ah]^kn]j`k`a lkjp]]lkjp]oaqk^fapk_kik]hckaola_Ú_k(i]o_kikqi]nn]jfkaqi]_kjopnqk_ki la`]ko`aj]nn]per]ofateopajpao* Kidlp^qo_]]_kanj_e](_kjopnqej`k_kj_aepq]hiajpaoaqk^fapk(ajmq]jpkkjvqelp b]^ne_] oaq k^fapk lah] naqjek a _kilkoek `a bn]ciajpko `ol]nao a `eol]n]p]`ko `k iqj`kateopajpa(`]j`k)hdaoqje`]`ajqijkrkoeopai]atlhe_]perkjkmq]h]`mqenaioec) jeÚ_]`koei^ he_k*Kidlplnk_qn]]qje`]`aok^]`eranoe`]`aa]iqhpelhe_e`]`a7kjvqelp b]vat]p]iajpakklkopk(lnk_qn]]iqhpelhe_e`]`aa]`eranoe`]`aok^]qje`]`a*qilaj) o]iajpkailne_ka_kj_napk(ajkqilajo]iajpk_kj_aepq]ha]^opn]pk* ?kil]n]`k]k`eo_qnokÚhko Ú_ka_eajpÚ_k(kiepkoaikopn]qi]klan]khejcqo) pe_]klkop]]kidlp*AopalqneÚ_]]hejcq]cai`koahaiajpkomq]hep]perkoaaikperko(^qo_] napen]n p]jpk mq]jpk lkoorah ] ]i^ecqe`]`a `ko paniko mqa ailnac]( qpehev]j`k lnkr]o( `aikjopn] aoa]ncqiajpkon]_ekj]eo*Kiepk(]k_kjpnnek(klan]lkniap]bknev]k_kj) pjq](kqoaf](qiiaoikoecjeÚ_]jpa$l]h]rn]kq_kjfqjpk`al]h]rn]o%paj`an]lkooqen qijiankeiajok`aoecjeÚ_] aokq`aoajpe`ko*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Kiepkklan]_ki]o]pqn]k`koajpe`k(aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(qiiaoikb]pklk`aoan j]nn]`k`aejian]oi]jaen]o`ebanajpao(`alaj`aj`k`kmqaoamqaen]ajb]pev]n(a]o_ke) o]o`kiqj`k$]jei]eo(racap]eo(iejan]eo(dqi]jko%lk`aina_a^anejiankooajpe`ko( _kjbkniakhqc]nmqak_qlaij]j]nn]per]*=ooei(]klkoekre`])iknpa(dkiai)iqhdan( dqi]jk)]jei]h(hqv)pnar](mqajpa)bnek(oa_k)ie`k(^ki)i]q(fqopk)ejfqopk(_anpk)ann]`k( cn]j`a)lamqajk(_nq)_kve`k(l]e)ia(eni)enik(l]e)Úhdk(l]e)Úhd](ia)Úhdk(ia)Úhd]( ap_* oank klkoe ao _kjop]jpao a nacqh]nao ai pk`ko ko iepko( i]o ko _kjpa`ko mqa ]o atlneiaiokejqianraeo*
3CIENCEß0HOTOß,IBRARY,ATINSTOCK
K_kjbhepkajpnaban]vk
=
'IORDANOß"RUNOßß ¯
@ap]hda`kO]jpk Oq`nek(iknp]hd] aimqapane]oe`k ajrkhre`kk_knlk`a Faoqomq]j`kpen]`k `]_nqv(amqaoa aj_kjpn]aiPqnei* 3ECONDOß0IA-USEOß$ELß3INDONE
kejop]qn]n]nqlpqn]ajpnajvqelpaidlp(]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]hlnkrk_kqqi]_kj) pa_eiajpk`ao_kjda_e`kaikqpn]o_qhpqn]o6k_kjÛepkajpna]ba]n]vk(mqaoa i]jebaopkq`ao`aiqepk_a`k*Fj]Cn_e]]jpec](]o_npe_]o`aDan_hepk(Lepckn]o aTaj b]jaonahecek]ooej]h]r]i]nqlpqn]_kiah]*I]eop]n`a(=paj]obknkqkÚh okbk =j]tckn]o]bqcenl]n]arep]n]_kj`aj]kl^he_](]_qo]`klahkpne^qj]h]pajeajoa`aÎej) rajp]nqijkrk`aqoÏ7O _n]pao(fqhc]`k_qhl]`k`aeilea`]`aa`a_knnqlk`]fqrajpq`a( bke_kj`aj]`kiknpa* J]Naj]o_aj](Cekn`]jk>nqjk(mqa]Úni]n]]ei]jj_e]`]Ejpahecj_e]ejÚjep]]k iqj`k$ÎkQjkbkni]ai]pne](Úcqn]`]j]pqnav]ejpaen](klan]j`k`aoaqejpaneknÏ(`eve] aha%(bke_kj`aj]`kbkcqaen]*C]hehaq(j]lk_]ik`anj](bkebkn]`k]]^fqn]noq]opaoao ok^nakikreiajpkokh]n(]oi]j_d]ohqj]naoaokh]naoaklnej_lek`]ejn_e](bqj`]iajpk `]ia_ je_]_hooe_]* Jaioailna]ÚhkokÚ]]^]j`kjkqkopai]o`]nahecek*Pk`]re](k_qlkq)oa`ahao`k lkjpk`areop]`kidlpajk`kjvqelp*=ooeilnk_a`aj`k(`aolkfkq)ko`aoq]_kj`ek `ajfpqoflpl]n]pn]jobkni)hkoai_kj_aepkoapakne]o*Raf]iko]hcqi]o`ebanaj]oajpna] i]jaen]_kikk_najpanahecekokakÚh okbk_kj_a^aikopai]onahecekoko* L]n]]]hi]naheceko](eqi@aqo7l]n]]ÚhkokÚ]( mob`fplmols^o^bufpqk`f^a^afsfka^ab*L]n]]]hi] lea`ko](@aqoqiajpalanbaepk(^kiaieoane_kn`ek) ok(i]ofqopk(lqjej`kkoi]qoana_kilajo]j`kko ^kjo*L]n]]ÚhkokÚ](@aqoqi]oq^op j_e]ejÚjep]( i]omob`fplmols^omqaoq]aooj_e]_kjopepq`]lkn qiejpaha_pkkjeo_eajpaaqi]rkjp]`akjelkpajpa* L]n]k_najpa(]aolenepq]he`]`a`erej]jkej_ki) l]prah_ki]aolan]j]`alk`anran@aqo]pq]ni]pa) ne]hiajpa ok^na k iqj`k( na]hev]j`k ieh]cnao7 l]n] ] ÚhkokÚ](mob`fplmols^oo^`flk^ijbkqbmqalkoorah qi]]k`kaolnepkok^na]i]pne]alknmqa(oaj`k @aqokjeo_eajpa(b]vaj`kieh]cnaooqolaj`ane]]kn`aj]) kja_aoone]`kiqj`kmqaAhaln lnekaop]^aha_aq* I]eo`kmqaeook*Oaj`k@aqoqiaolnepklanbae) pkaejÚjepk(mqaja_aooe`]`apane]`a_ne]nqiiqj`k i]pane]h(Újepkaeilanbaepk;=hi`eook(lna_eokat) lhe_]n_kikqi]_]qo]aolenepq]hejÚjep]lnk`qvqi abaepki]pane]hÚjepk*I]eo]ej`]*@aqoapanjk(lkn) p]jpk]hdaek]kpailk7i]okiqj`kjkapanjk(lkeo bke_ne]`klkn@aqoa(jaooa_]ok(_kikqioanapanjk na]hev]qi]]kpailkn]h;?kikb]h]nai@aqo^kqbp `kiqj`kaabmlfp`kiqj`k(oaÎ]jpaoÏaÎ`alkeoÏok mq]he`]`ao`kpailkajk`]apanje`]`a;
//.
=atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka]ejopepqek`]nahecekx#!0É45,/ßx
L]n]kÚah(]]hi]eiknp]ha`aopej]`]]qi]re`]bqpqn]7l]n]]ÚhkokÚ](_]^alcbob`bo mols^pmqa`aikjopnai]eiknp]he`]`a* Koiope_koatlaneiajp]i]bqoklhaj]jkoaek`a@aqo(oajpaiaop]njahaajahare) ran*L]n]]ÚhkokÚ](jkoajpeiko@aqo(i]ok_kjda_aikolah]n]vk* Aoo]la_qhe]ne`]`an]_ekj]heop]`]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]h]bapkq]ln lne]nahecek*@ab]pk( l]n]_kilapen_ki]ÚhkokÚ]aoqlh]jp)h](]naheceklna_eokqkbana_an)oaj]bkni]`alnk) r]on]_ekj]eo(_kj_aepko(paoao(pakne]o*Pknjkq)oapakhkce](_ej_e]ok^na@aqo*Pn]jobknikq kopatpko`]deop ne]o]cn]`]ai`kqpnej](_keo]mqajajdqi]kqpn]nahecekbav* Jkajp]jpk(]lao]n`]pakhkce]a`]o`kqpnej]o(_anp]o_naj]onaheceko]of]i]eolk`ank oanpn]jobkni]`]oaipaoaoa`aikjopn] aon]_ekj]eooaioanai`aopnq`]o*Jkd_kik lnkr]nn]_ekj]hiajpamqaFakrb]hkq]Ikeoo(jkikjpaOej]e*Jkd_kiklnkr]nn]_ek) j]hiajpa]rencej`]`a`aI]ne](]aj_]nj]k`kBehdk`a@aqo(]O]jpooei]Pnej`]`a(] Aq_]neope]*Oksboa^abpa^ca(_kikp]eo(jfpqoflp*Aopaookran`]`aoejmqaopekjraeo(eopk (`kci]o*Aeolknmqak]l opkhkL]qhk`a_h]nkqmqaÎ]bqiao_ j`]hkl]n]]n]vkÏ$ ieopaneko]aej_kilnaajorah%amqaÎ]n]vkqiao_ j`]hkl]n]]bÏ$ok^an^]akncqhdko]( mqanaj`kajpaj`ankej_kilnaajorah%* Pkiaikoqiatailhk`k=jpeckPaop]iajpk*=hej]nn]`kmqa(`qn]jpaqi]^]p]hd]( FkoqbavkOkhl]n]n(]Úi`amqa(_kiklnkhkjc]iajpk`k`e](lq`aooaraj_an]cqann]* Aoo]deop ne]o]cn]`]lnaooql amqakOkhoaikreiajp]aipknjk`]Pann]amqaaop]lani]) ja_aei rah*Aop]j`kj]nn]`]jkpatpknarah]`klahkln lnek@aqo(]deop ne]`aFkoqjk lk`aoan_kjpaop]`]* =iaoi]pakne]`]ik^ehe`]`a`kOkhaeik^ehe`]`a`]Pann]ateope]_kikpaoaÚhko Ú) _k)_eajpÚ_]jklajo]iajpk`a=neop pahaoa(_kikp]h(bkenabqp]`]lah]_ej_e]`a?klnje) _k(C]hehaqaGalhan*Lkni(oa]aopaoan]laniepe`knabqp]nqi]pakne]Úhko Ú_k)_eajpÚ_] lkn iaek `a kqpn]( jk hdao an] laniepe`k jac]n ] deop ne] `a Fkoq* Aeo lkn mqa( `qn]jpa o_qhko(]Ecnaf]_kjoe`ankqkdahek_ajpneoikqi]danaoe](_kj`ajkq)]aoq^iapaqo^eko( _kikC]hehaq(]kopne^qj]eo`]Ejmqeoek* Qikqpnkatailhk(]ckn]rej`k`]^ekhkce](r]ej]iaoi]`enak6]pakne]`]arkhq) k(`a@]nsej(mqa`aikjopn]]knecai`kdkiai]l]npen`alnei]p]o*=>^he]]Úni] mqakdkiaibke_ne]`k`enap]iajpalkn@aqo(oq]ei]caiaoaiahd]j](jkoatpk`e] `] _ne]k* @aoo] lanola_per]( ] pakne] `]nseje]j] bke _kjoe`an]`] danaoe]( _kj`aj]`] a( `qn]jpa ]jko( jk l`a oan ajoej]`] j]o ao_kh]o _neopo( paj`k iaoik d]re`k qi _]ok( jkoAop]`koQje`ko(`aqilnkbaookn`alneiaenkcn]qlnk_aoo]`klknqipne^qj]hlkn ajoej)h]* Qiatailhk(]ckn]rej`k`kJkrkPaop]iajpk(]lnaoajp]kiaoiklnk^hai]*Deopk) ne]`knao( hejcqeop]o a ]jpnkl hkcko Úvan]i aopq`ko ok^na ]o _qhpqn]o `a pk`] ] nacek `k KneajpaI`eka`kjknpa`]ãbne_](jah]oaj_kjpn]j`kqi]nabanj_e]_kjop]jpa]klk(]k rejdk(]k_kn`aenkeikh]`ka]k`aqoiknpkanaooqo_ep]`k*An]i_qhpqn]o`aqi]ok_ea`]`a ]cnne](_kinepko`abanpehe`]`a`]Pann]a`ko]jei]eo(na]hev]j`k_aneije]oiqepkoaia) hd]jpaoomqaoane]ina]hev]`]o(`alkeo(lah]ieoo]_neop*@aooalkjpk`areop](knepq]h`] ieoo]lanpaj_a]qi]pn]`eknaheceko]]cnne](kneajp]ha]bne_]j](iqepk]jpanekn]k_neo) pe]jeoik*Aoo]`ao_k^anp]_eajpÚ_](lkni(_kjpn]ne]]oran`]`ao_neopo(j]ia`e`]aimqa ]ieoo]_kjoe`an]`]hepqnce]mqanalapaanaiaikn]qi_kjfqjpkje_kajkrk`aarajpko nah]perkore`](l]etkaiknpa`aFaoqo* Lk`an]ikolnkooacqen_kikoatailhko(i]ojkja_aoonek*Kmqamqanaiko`aop]) _]n]mqe]la_qhe]ne`]`a`]nah]kmqa(j]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]h(_ne]`kn]`]ÚhkokÚ]a`]_ej) _e](oaaop]^aha_aqajpna]n]vka]b*=o`eÚ_qh`]`ao`aoo]nah]kk_ql]n]ikoia`ear]eo( koik`anjkoajkooko_kjpailkn jako(l]na_aj`kejokhraeo* =nahecek]_qo]]ÚhkokÚ]a]_ej_e]`adanaoe]a]paoik(ajmq]jpk]i^]o]_qo]i] nahecek`a`kci]peoik(oqlanopek(]pn]okaejpkhan j_e]*
///
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
?kj_ehe]kajpnabehkokbe]anahecek
R
nekoÚh okbkolnk_qn]n]i_kj_ehe]nÚhkokÚ]anahecek*@]opajp]per]obaep]o(iaj_ek) j]naikopno(_nkjkhkce_]iajpai]eoln tei]o`aj o6]`aG]jp(]`aDacaha]`] bajkiajkhkce]* =_npe_]g]jpe]j]lnapajok`]iap]boe_]`aoan_ej_e]`eneca)oaÚhkokÚ]mq]j`k aop]lnapaj`aatlhe_]n]na]he`]`aaioe`a]hcqjooanao(pki]j`k]bkni]`aqi]pakhkce] n]_ekj]h$`aikjopn]kn]_ekj]h`]aooj_e]aateopj_e]`a@aqo%(qi]loe_khkce]n]_ekj]h $`aikjopn]k `] ateopj_e] a `] eiknp]he`]`a `] ]hi]% a qi] _koikhkce] n]_ekj]h $`a) ikjopn]k`]knecai(aooj_e]aÚj]he`]`a`kiqj`kkq`]j]pqnav]%*Reiko(]kaopq`]n ]n]vka]ran`]`a(mqa]`eopejkajpnabajiajkakrjbkllaniepa]G]jpheiep]nk_k) jda_eiajpkpa ne_k]k_]ilkbajkije_kaeila`en]lnapajok`]n]vk`apaknev]nok^na k_]ilk`]o_keo]oaioe* =iap]boe_]jk_kjda_eiajpk`]aooj_e]aioe`a@aqo(`]]hi]a`kiqj`k7aopao okkrjbklp$na]he`]`aaioe%ej]_aooraeo]kjkookajpaj`eiajpk*=nahecek(lknoq]rav( jkpakhkce](jkpakne]ok^na@aqo(]hi]aiqj`k(i]onaolkop]]qi]lancqjp]mqa] n]vkjklk`anaolkj`anpakne_]iajpa6ÎKmqalk`aikoaolan]n;Ï* Mq]hkl]lah`]nahecek;Kbana_anlnej_lekol]n]]]kikn]habknp]ha_an]aolan]j] jqi`aopejkoqlanekn`]]hi]dqi]j]*Oai]_naj]ai@aqoajqi]]hi]hernajkd]ra) ne]dqi]je`]`a(i]o]laj]o]jei]he`]`aj]pqn]h7oai]_naj]j]eiknp]he`]`a`]]hi](k _qilneiajpk`k`aranjkoane]koej]h`ajkoo]`aopej]kbqpqn]jqi]re`]oqlanekn* Dacahoacqajqi]`enak`erano]`]`aG]jp*L]n]aha(]na]he`]`ajkoajk]deo) p ne]`kAolnepkai^qo_]`]e`ajpe`]`a_kjoeckiaoik*@aqojkqi]oq^op j_e]_qf] aooj_e] pane] oe`k Út]`] ]jpao a bkn] `k pailk( i]o k oqfaepk aolenepq]h mqa oa abapq] _kikoqfaepkpailkn]h(_qf]]kahaiaoikoai]jebaop]j`kl]n]oeiaoik*=i]eo^]et] i]jebaop]k`kaolnepk]j]pqnav]7]i]eo]hp](]_qhpqn]* J]_qhpqn](kaolnepkna]hev])oalneiaenk_kik]npa(]oacqen_kiknahecek(`alkeo_kik Aop]`ka(Új]hiajpa(_kikÚhkokÚ](jqi]oamqj_e]mqaabapq]k]lanbaek]iajpk`kao) lnepkmqar]enqik]kpniejk`kpailk*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa@aqooai]jebaop](lneiaenk( _kik]npaj]o]npao(`alkeo_kiknahecekj]onahece ao(_kikAop]`kjkoAop]`koaÚj]hiaj) pa_kikÚhkokÚ]j]oÚhkokÚ]o*Aihqc]n`aklknnahecekaÚhkokÚ](Dacahb]v`]nahecekqi ikiajpk`]deop ne]`kAolnepkkq`a@aqoaqi]ap]l]lnal]n]p ne]`]ÚhkokÚ](j]mq]h @aqooana_kjda_a]oeiaoik_kik@aqo* =bajkiajkhkce](_kikreiko(`ao_naraaooj_e]o_kjopepq`]olah]ejpaj_ekj]he`]`a `]_kjo_ej_e](mqa`k]`kn]`aoajpe`kna]he`]`a*=_kjo_ej_e]_kjopepqe]ooecjeÚ_] ao( ]ooqiej`k^qfqrabp`ebanajpao(_]`]mq]h_kioaq_]ilkaola_Ú_k(oq]aopnqpqn]aÚj]he) `]`ao ln lne]o* =ooei _kik d ] ]pepq`a j]pqn]h $] _naj] na]heop] ejcjq] j] ateopj_e] `]o_keo]o%a]]pepq`aÚhko Ú_]$]naÛatk%(dp]i^i]]pepq`anaheceko](_kikqi]`]o lkooe^ehe`]`ao`]re`]`]_kjo_ej_e]*Mq]j`kaop]oanah]_ekj]_kikiqj`klkniaek`]o jk aoa`]olnpe_]ohec]`]o]ko]cn]`k(_kjopepqe]]pepq`anaheceko]* =ooei(]_kjo_ej_e]lk`anah]_ekj]n)oa_kikiqj`k`ai]jaen]or]ne]`]oÍoajok _kiqi(_ej_e](ÚhkokÚ](]npao(nahecekÍ(`aoknpamqajkdklkoekjaiat_hqokajpna ah]o(i]o`ebanaj]*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa]klkoeko oqncenmq]j`k]_kjo_ej_e](aop]j`k jqi]]pepq`a(lnapaj`annah]_ekj]n)oa_kikiqj`kqpehev]j`koecjeÚ_] aoalnpe_]o`a qi]kqpn]]pepq`a*Bkeeookmqaajcaj`nkq]klkoekak_kjÛepkajpnaÚhkokÚ]anahecek( lkeo(oaj`k]pepq`ao`ebanajpao`]_kjo_ej_e](_]`]qi]`ah]ojkl`aqoqnl]nkoik`ko `a_kjda_ana]cenjai]ooecjeÚ_] ao`]kqpn]*
//0
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß Kqjeranok`]o]npao
Klkjpk`areop]`kaola_p]`kn =npeop]ak^n]`a]npa
O
alancqjp]niko]]hcqikmqaqi^oqfpq^(mq]oa_anpkmqa]laook]naolkj`an mqak]pkn$`apa]pnk(_ejai](pahareok%(k_kilkoepkniqoe_]hak_]jpkna(ai]hcqjo _]oko(ej_hqenko^]eh]nejko*Aoo]naolkop]ejpanaoo]jpap]jpklahkmqa]Úni]_kik lahkmqaoehaj_e]* @ab]pk(koehj_ek_kjoeopaaijkej_hqenj]_]packne]Î]npeop]Ï(lknatailhk(kolkap]oa nki]j_eop]o(eopk(]hepan]pqn]ÍÎokao_nepknaoajk]npeop]oÏ(`ene]]laook]*P]i^iaopk at_hq`koko`enapknao`ala]opa]pn]eo(Úhiaoajkrah]o`apahareokÍÎ`enecaiko]npeop]o( i]ojkok]npeop]oÏ(`ene]aoo]iaoi]laook]*=koehaj_e]nok^nakoao_nepknaoa`enapknaoa]k ao_khdan]hcqjo]npeop]o_kik`aÚje`knao`k]npeop](aoo]laook]aop]Úni]j`k(iaoikmqa jkko]e^](mqaqi]npeop]]mqahamqana]hev]qi]lanbkni]j_ajqiaolap_qhk* =npeop]oane](lknp]jpk(]mqahamqa`aoailajd]qil]lahjqiaolap_qhk$k]pknak ^]eh]nejk%a]mqahamqa]lnaoajp]]kl^he_kqi]_kilkoekaoq]ejpanlnap]k$k_kilk) oepkniqoe_]hak_]jpkn%* ?qneko]iajpa(lkni(oala`eniko]aoo]iaoi]laook]mqajko`atailhko`al_o^p ab^oqb(ln]pe_]iajpa_anpkmqajkob]h]n`komq]`nko`aHakj]n`k`]Rej_e(`]oao_qhpqn]o `aIe_dah]jcahk(`aNk`ejkq`k=haef]`ejdk(`]ookj]p]o`a>aapdkrajkq`kolnah`eko `a?dklej(`]o lan]o`aRan`eaLq__eje(`koIrp^a^p(`a?]i ao(`a]hcqi^]h(_kikk Nrb_o^*Klwbp* @a ik`k can]h( aoo] laook] e`ajpeÚ_] k^n] `a ]npa _ki k^fapko _ne]`ko jk l]oo]`k( _kjoanr]`ko naolaepko]iajpa ai iqoaqo kq ]lnaoajp]`ko ai eilknp]jpao pa]) pnkol]n]qil^he_knaopnepk* =naolkop]ejpanaoo]jpalkn`keoikperko6ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqa]ajqian]k `]ok^n]o`a]npajk_kej_e`aat]p]iajpa_kikmqa]laook]ajpaj`alkn]npeop](lkeo]ck) n]p]i^i]l]na_ailejpknao(ao_qhpknao(lkap]o7aioacqj`k(lknmqaaoo]laook]paj`a] _kjoe`an]n]k^n]`a]npa_kik]hck]mqalkq_kopi]_aook(oaf]lknmqaoklkq_kokomqa ]_kilnaaj`ai(oaf]lknmqaoklkq_kokomqa`eol ai`ana_qnokoÚj]j_aenkol]n]bnq)h] a(jaopa_]ok(]k^n]`a]npa`ebanajpa`kmqaoaoql aoank]npeop](qi]ravmqaaopalan) baep]iajpa]_aoorahl]n]mqai]ooeopa]qiÚhia(qi]jkrah]kqqiodks* J]ran`]`a(aoo]_qneko]`eo_nal j_e]ajpnakmqaoaajpaj`alkn]npeop]alknk^n]`a ]npaej`e_]mqa(]k`evanmqaiqi]npeop](]laook]aopatlneiej`kklkjpk`areop]`] _d]i]`]_qhpqn]`ai]oo]kq_qhpqn]`kaolap_qhk7amqa(]katlhe_]nkmqaajpaj`alkn k^n]`a]npa(aoo]laook]aopatlneiej`kklkjpk`areop]`]_d]i]`]_qhpqn]anq`ep]kq _qhpqn]`aahepa(lknp]jpk(`aqiaola_p]`knmqarerajqi]ok_ea`]`a`ere`e`]ai_h]ooao ok_e]eo(j]mq]hokiajpa]hcqjolk`aiajpaj`anabnqen]]npa* Jaopa_]lpqhkpn]p]naiko]laj]o`]k^n]`a]npaaioaqoajpe`ki]eo]ilhk*Jkln te) ik_]lpqhk(aopq`]naiko]_qhpqn]`ai]oo]kq]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h(`ai]jaen]]_kilnaaj) `aniko_kikalknmqa(aijkoo]ok_ea`]`a(]olaook]opaj`ai]oal]n]n]npeop]ak^n]`a ]npa(]e`ajpeÚ_]nklneiaenk_kik`aoailajdkjqiaolap_qhka]oacqj`]_kik^fapko `eop]jpaoaieopanekokomqaokiajpa]hcqjolk`aibnqena_kilnaaj`an*
//1
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Nah]k_ki]k^n]`a]npa
-*
]]lnktei]ka]`eopejkajpna]npaa]npao]j]pk7
.*
]lnkteie`]`aajpna]npaa]jpecqe`]`a7
/*
]ateopj_e]`aoqlknpaoboe_ko$hernk(?@%l]n]k^n]o`a]npa mqa( ai oe iaoi]o( ok _kjoe`an]`]o ej]_aooraeo( i]o o mq]eooalk`apan]hcqi]_aookcn]]o]qik^fapkej`qopne]h mqa]onalnk`qv*
Panjk`abahpnk(`k ]haikFkoab>aquo( -542(l]n]mqaik ]npeop]qi]aol_ea `at]i_]l]v`a ]ooeieh]n]ajance]`a qik^fapk_kiqi( _kjbanej`k)hdajkrk oecjebe_]`k*
#OLEljOßPARTICULAR
Oalancqjp]niko]aoo]iaoi]laook]kmqaah]atlaneiajp]`e]jpa`aqi]k^n]`a ]npa(mq]oa_anpkmqajko`enmqaoajpanaolaepk(mqaoaoajpaaik_ekj]`]_ki]^ahav] `]k^n]amqapai]`ien]klahk]npeop]mqa]_nekq*Aoo]laook](]ckn](aopatlneiej`k klkjpk`areop]`aqiaola_p]`knmqarerajqi]ok_ea`]`aej`qopne]hkql o)ej`qopne]h( eopk(jqi]ok_ea`]`aaimqakok^fapko`aqoka`a_kjoqikoklnk`qve`koaionea(ok ]jjeiko$lkeo]i]n_]naceopn]`]`kb]^ne_]jpajkej`e_]qi]laook]na]hkq_kj_nap]mqa pajd]baepkklnk`qpk%(`ao_]npraeo(abianko*Kqoaf](kok^fapko`aqoka_kjoqik`eneko jklnkrk_]inaolaepk(jk_]qo]iaik aolknoq]^ahav]jailnkrk_]i]`ien]klkn oaqolnk`qpknao* Oa(lknÚi(lancqjp]niko]aoo]laook]oaah]lkooqek^n]o`a ]npa(ah]lk`anjko`evanmqaoei$oq]b]ihe]ne_]alk`a_ki) ln]nk^fapko`a]npa%kqjko`enmqajk(i]olk`an_kilhap]n] naolkop]`evaj`kmqalkooqek^fapko`a]npao]j]pk(]hcqi]o]jpe) cqe`]`ao(]hcqihernk`a]npaa]hcqi?@`aqi_kilkoepkn_ha) ^na*Aoo]naolkop]iqepkejpanaoo]jpalknmqajah]lan_a^aiko6
At]iejaikoaooaopno]ola_pkolnaoajpaojklkjpk`areop] `kaola_p]`kn* -*
=k]lnktei]n]npaa]npao]j]pk(kaola_p]`knpaiaiiajpa kb]pk`amqap]jpk]k^n]`a]npa_kikkk^fapk]npao]j]hok pn]^]hdkobaepkolknqi]je_]laook]Í`ebanajpaiajpa`a qiklannek(mqapn]^]hd]_ki_ajpaj]o`akqpnkojqi]he) jd]`aikjp]cai(k]npeop]ak]npaokna]hev]iokvejdkoqi pn]^]hdk_kilhapk(ok]qpknao`aoq]olnk`q ao*=hi`eo) ok(ajmq]jpkklnk`qpkej`qopne]h(baepkaionea(eilaook]h( ]k^n]`a]npaa]`a]npao]j]pkokej`ere`q]hev]`]okqlao) ok]eo(atlneiej`k]ejpajk(]d]^ehe`]`aakp]hajpk`amqai ]ona]hev]*Jkajp]jpk(]k`eopejcqenajpna]npaa]npao]j]pk(k aola_p]`knpaiaiiajpa]i]ekn_kilhate`]`aar]nea`]`a `alnk_a`eiajpkoai]pane]eoailnac]`kolahk]npeop]mq]j) `k_kil]n]`k_kik]npaok*=hi`eook(]`eopejkp]i^i har]ai_kjp]kb]pk`amqak]npaok_kopqi]b]^ne_]nrneko atailh]nao`kiaoikk^fapkajmq]jpkk]npeop]paj`a]lnk) `qven]laj]oqi(kqoaf](]k^n]`a]npapaj`a]oanlan_a^e`] _kikje_]a_kikn]ne`]`aajmq]jpkkk^fapk]npao]j]hjk lkooqeaoo]_]n]_panope_]*
.*
=k]lnktei]nk^n]`a]npaa]jpecqe`]`a(kaola_p]`knoeilhaoiajpaaopi]jpaj`k] e`ae]`amqa]ocn]j`aok^n]o`a]npabkn]ina]hev]`]ojkl]oo]`ka_kjoanr]`]olah] dqi]je`]`a_kikqi^ai_khaperk$iaoikmqalkq_kopajd]i]_aook`enapk]ah]o%* I]ojko eook*Kian_]`k`a]jpecqe`]`ao_kjoeopaai]l]jd]nqik^fapk`aqoka `a_kjoqikl]n]napen)hk`k_en_qepk`kqoka`k_kjoqik(b]vaj`k)kr]han_kikqi] la]`a_kn]per]kqqiajbaepa(kq_kikqi]la]`aaopei]k$Îaopdiqepko]jko j]b]ihe]Ï7Îbke`aiaq^eo]rÏ7Îiejd]]r qokqjk`e]`aoaq_]o]iajpkÏ%*Kn](at]) p]iajpakiaoikmqa]_kjpa_a_ki]k^n]`a]npamq]j`k_kjoanr]`]jkiqoaqkq
//2
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
j]^e^hekpa_](kqoaf](ah]p]i^inapen]`]`k_en_qepk`kqoka`k_kjoqik(l]oo]j`k ]r]hanaioealknoeiaoi]_kikqi]la]je_]*Aeolknmqa(aolkjp]ja]iajpa(k aola_p]`kn]lnktei]k^n]`a]npaa]jpecqe`]`a*
#OSTAß0INHEIROß )NSTITUTOß0ORTUGUoSßß DOß,IVRO
/*
=laook]_kimqaiaop]iko_kjrano]j`kp]hravjqj_]lkoo]en]=paj]orankL]npa) jkj(kq]Nki]ran]?]lah]Oeopej]lejp]`]lknIe_dah]jcahk`qn]jpa]Naj]o_aj]( kq =hai]jd] l]n] k baoper]h `a >]unaqpd( mq]j`k ]o k^n]o `a Ne_d]n` S]cjan ok ata_qp]`]o(kq]L]neol]n]ran(jkIqoaq`kHkqrna(]Jlk^Ifp^lejp]`]lknHakj]n`k `]Rej_e(kq]Cn]i]`kl]n]]ooeopen]kBaoper]hJ]_ekj]h`a?ejai](kq]?]ilko`k Fkn`kl]n]kBaoper]hJ]_ekj]h`aIoe_]Anq`ep]*I]oaoo]laook]o]^amqa]eilnaj) o](kn`ek(k_ejai](k`eo_k(]pahareok(kr`aklk`ainalnk`qvenkqpn]joiepenaoo]o k^n]o(h]j]j`k)]ojkian_]`k`a_kjoqikalaniepej`kqi]_aookej`enapk]ah]o*Ai kqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]ok_ea`]`aej`qopne]h`aoajrkhraqna_qnokop_je_kol]n]iqhpelhe_]n ]mqehkmqa_kjoe`an]`kkpn]ki]eoi]n_]jpa`]k^n]`a]npa6pbo kf`^*Kmqap]hrav kaola_p]`knjko]e^]mqa]pn]joieooka]nalnk`qk`]ok^n]o`a]npalkooqe`q]o _]n]o6jqi]`ah]o(`aik_n]pev]k]_aook]npa7j]kqpn](oq^iapa]o]npao]qiian_]) `kjkrk(_ne]`klah]_d]i]`]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h*
Klkjpk`areop]`k]npeop] &ERNANDOß0ESSOAßEßSEUSß HETERxNIMOSßALmMßDEß !LBERTOß#AEIRO ßOßPOETAß PORTUGUoSß&ERNANDOß 0ESSOA߯ ßTINHAß DOISßOUTROSßHETERxNIMOSß PRINCIPAISß2ICARDOß2EISßEß ÆLVAROßDEß#AMPOS
=
h^anpk?]aenk(qi`kodapanjeiko`klkap]Banj]j`kLaook](har])jko]k i]ck`] ]npamq]j`kao_nara6
Ljbrlie^okqfal`ljlrjdfo^ppli+ Qbkell`lpqrjbab^ka^ombi^pbpqo^a^p Lie^kalm^o^^afobfq^bm^o^^bpnrboa^) Babsbwbjnr^kallie^kalm^o^qop+++ Blnrbsbgl^`^a^jljbkql ^nrfilnrbkrk`^^kqbpbrqfke^sfpql) Bbrpbfa^omlofppljrfql_bj+++ Pbfqbolm^pjlbppbk`f^i Nrbqbjrj^`of^k ^pb)^lk^p`bo) Obm^o^ppbnrbk^p`bo^absbo^p+++ Pfkql*jbk^p`fal^`^a^jljbkql M^o^^bqbok^klsfa^abalJrkal+ =bqbok^klsfa^ab`kiqj`k*Klkap]qja`q]ol]h]rn]omqa(jkni]hiajpa(aopkoal]) n]`]oaiaoikaiklkoek$bqbok^aklsfa^ab%(lkeokapanjk]qoj_e]`apailk(]mqehk mqa(bkn]`kpailk(lani]ja_aoailnae`jpe_k]oeiaoik(ajmq]jpkkjkrklqn]pai) lkn]he`]`a(lqnkikreiajpkpailkn]haimqaoqncakmqajkd]re]]jpao*?kikoana]hev] aoo]qje`]`a`kapanjka`kjkrk(]l]najpaiajpaeilkoorah;Ah]oana]hev]lahkoal]n]ko dqi]jko6ah]oana]hev]lkniaek`]]npa* Ianha]q)Lkjpu `eve] mqa ] ]npa ^asbkql $qi ren ] oan `k mqa jqj_] ]jpao ateopeq%( _kiklnkiaoo]ejÚjep]`a^`lkqb`fjbkqlp$]ok^n]o`ko]npeop]o%*Jkajo]ek>ifkdr^dbj fkafobq^b^pslwbpalpfik`fl(ahaao_nara6
//3
L mofjbfol abpbkel k^p m^obabp a^p `^sbok^p crka^s^ rj^ qo^af l mlonrb ob* `lief^rj^lrqo^7^a^mbo`bm l+>nr^pbbqbokfa^aba^^oqb`lkcrkab*pb`lj^nr^* pbbqbokfa^aba^bufpqk`f^erj^k^bk`^ok^a^bmlofpplqbjlp)klbubo``flabklppl `lomlbabklpplppbkqfalp)`ljnrb`ljmobbkaboklpp^dbpqf`ri^ l`riqro^i)nrbklp fkpbobklqbjml+
Mqa`evaiko`aoajdkoj]ol]na`ao`]_]ranj];Mqakooanaodqi]jkook`kp]`ko`a khdkoaiko(mqalkneookl]n]kodqi]jkokiqj`kreorahal]n]oanreopk(amqakokhdko a]oiko`k]npeop]`k]rankiqj`k*K]npeop]]mqahamqana_khda`ai]jaen]jkr]aejq) oep]`]]mqehkmqaaopj]lan_alk`apk`koamqa(jkajp]jpk(jejcqil]na_alan_a^an* =kb]v)hk(jko`koajpeiajpk`]mq]oaapanje`]`a`]k^n]`a]npa(lkeoah]]atlnaook lanaja`]_]l]_e`]`alan_alper]`ajkook_knlk* Mqaiqj`kpn]ve`klahk]npeop];=mqahaapanj]iajpajkrk*Apanj]iajpa(lknmqapk ]jpeckalanajamq]jpk]lan_alkdqi]j]*Jkrk(lknmqak]npeop]klan_a^a_kikjqj_] bkn]lan_a^e`k]jpaolahko`ai]eodkiajo*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqaklejpknIkjaplej) pkqrne]oravao]iaoi]_]pa`n]hia`ear]hmqaateope]alan`qn]diqepkoo_qhko(i]o( ai_]`]pah](j]o_aqqi]jkr]_]pa`n]h*Nabanej`k)oa]aoo]opah]o`aIkjap(kÚh okbkC]o) pkj>]_dah]n`ao_nara(jqiajo]ek`ajkiej]`kLmfkqloplif`fq^almbilpbibjbkqlp6
"ARONß$Eß-EYER#ONDmß.ASTßß !RCHIVE#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
-ONET߯ ßPINTORß IMPRESSIONISTAßFRANCoS
Koahaiajpko(_kikreiko]kaopq`]n]_koikhkce]cnac](okk]n(kbkck(]pann]a] cq]*>]_dah]n`jko`evmqaIkjaplejpkq]ola`n]o`]_]pa`n]h_kikoabkooai`a]n$Î^nq) i]]vqh]`]_kikk_qÏ%a`alkeo]olejpkq_kikoabkooai`abkck$Îkk_na`kokhlkajpaÏ( Îqi ]opnk nqerkÏ%* = oacqen( aha lejpkq qi] _]pa`n]h ]mqpe_]( aoran`a]`] a oq^i]nej]7 a( Új]hiajpa(]lejpkqpannaopna(i]nnkia_ejv](Új_]`]lk`anko]iajpajk_dk*Pki]j`k] apanje`]`a`koahaiajpkoa]lanaje`]`a`]_]pa`n]hia`ear]h(Ikjap_nekq]_]pa`n]h_kik k^n]`a]npa(_kikoa]_]`]ravah]aoperaooaoaj`kreop]lah]lneiaen]rav(_]`]pah]b]vaj) `k)]ejpaen]iajpajkr]* Mqalnk_qn]k]npeop];Naolkj`aklkap]?]aenk+Laook]6Îkl]oikaooaj_e]h+mqapai qi] _ne]j] oa( ]k j]o_an(+nal]n]ooa mqa j]o_an] `aran]oÏ* K ]npeop] ^qo_] k aol]jpk lnk) bqj`k`amqaiokq^aooamqaaopraj`kkiqj`klah]lneiaen]rav(`aqi]_ne]j]mqa okq^aooa`aran`]`a$Î`aran]oÏ%mqaj]o_aql]n]kiqj`kamqaahaj]o_aql]n]ah]*K]npeop] ^qo_]kiqj`kaiaop]`kj]o_ajpa(ei]cej]j`k)kjko p]h_kikoane]]koanreopklknj o lah]lneiaen]rav(i]op]i^ip]h_kikpane]oe`kaioeiaoikjkikiajpkknecejnek`a oaqoqnceiajpk(]jpaomqaj oateopooaikol]n]lan_a^)hk*aooaiqj`kknecejnek(]jpa) neknjkoo]lnaoaj]jaha(kmqalnk_qn]klejpkn?v]jja(_qfkpn]^]hdk]ooei_kiajp]`k lknIanha]q)Lkjpujkajo]ek>a sfa^ab@w^kkb6
!LBUM!KG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
Rjaf^)@i^rabJlkbqnrfpnrb^`^qbao^iclppbsboa^abfo^jbkqb^ob^Î^ob^bj pr^pr_pq k`f^)^ob^klmomofl`lo^ la^pmbao^p+B^`^qbao^iqljlra^_orj^^wr* i^a^qla^^j^qof^^wrinrb^momof^_orj^qlj^o^al`r^wri+++Krjlrqolaf^)lr* qolplkelbibjbkq^opb^mlabo^a^slkq^ababmfkq^o+@i^rabJlkbqnrbonrb^`^qbao^i pbqlokbrj^bpmlkg^abirw)nrb^_plos^bjqla^p^ppr^pÛibfo^pabmbao^pbbjqlalp lppbrplok^jbkqlpll`obabrjplimlbkqb+Bkql)kbpp^kls^qbi^)^`^qbao^irj^pqol al`b)rj^pqolorfsl)rjpbo^alojb`falkl`^iloalaf^+>pqloobp_ofk`^s^jj^fp^iql kl`r)nr^kalob`b_f^jlbibjbkql^obl+Bf*i^p^dlo^j^fpmboqla^Qboo^)j^fpqboobp* qob)^oabkal^mbk^prjmlr`l)`ljlcldldr^oa^alk^pmbao^pabrj^i^obfo^+
#mZANNE߯ ß PINTORßFRANCoSßPvS IM PRESSIONISTA
Sfsbjlp bj jbfl ^lp l_gbqlp `lkpqoralp mbilp eljbkp) bkqob rqbkpiflp) `^p^p) or^p) `fa^abp b k^ j^flo m^oqb al qbjml p lp sbjlp ^qo^sp a^p ^ bp erj^k^p ab nrbmlabjpbolpmlkqlpab^mif`^ l%+++&+>mfkqro^ab@w^kkbprpmbkabbpqbpe_fqlp bobsbi^lcrkalabK^qrobw^fkrj^k^pl_oblnr^ipbfkpq^i^leljbj%+++&^m^fp^dbj ^m^ob`bpbjsbkql)^dr^ali^dlpbjjlsfjbkql)lpl_gbqlpqo^kpfalpebpfq^kal`ljl k^lofdbja^Qboo^+Rjjrkalpbjc^jfif^ofa^ab%+++&+Prjerj^kl)`lkqral)grp* q^jbkqb`^m^wabpp^sfplnrbs^f^q^po^wbp)^nrja^erj^kfa^ab`lkpqfqra^%+++&+ L^oqfpq^^nrbibnrbÛu^bqlok^^`bppsbi^lpabj^fperj^klplbpmbq`rilabnrb m^oqf`fm^jpbjmbo`b_bo+ =k^n]`a]npaÎÚt]apknj]]_aoorahÏkiqj`kaimqareraikoamqalan_a^aikooai jko`]niko_kjp]`ahaa`aj oiaoikojaha*=k^n]`a]npajko`]rankmqaoailnareiko oairan(]kqrenkmqaoailnakqreikooaikqren(]oajpenkmqaoailnaoajpeikooaioajpen(
//4
%DUARDOß3IMzES&OLHAß)MAGEM
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
]lajo]nkmqaoailnalajo]ikooailajo]n(]`evankmqaoailna`eooaikooai`evan*Lkn eook(jah]alknah](]na]he`]`aoanarah]_kikoaf]i]eo]perooaikoreopk(kqre`k(`epk(oaj) pe`kkqlajo]`k*Aeolknmqak]npeop]kmqal]oo]lah]atlanej_e]`aj]o_anpk`k`e]l]n] ]Îapanj]jkre`]`a`kiqj`kÏ* Kmqaaoo]atlanej_e];=ejrajk`aiqj`kokq]na_ne]k`kiqj`k*?kikao_na) raklkap]Bannaen]Cqhh]njqihernkejpepqh]`kPl_ob^^oqb6
!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
&ERREIRAß'ULLARß ßß POETA ßCRONISTAßEßCRqTICOßß DEßARTEßMARANHENSE ß CRIADORßDOßMOVIMENTOß NEOCONCRETOßQUEßROMPEUß COMßAßPOESIAßCONCRETAßEß APROXIMOUßOßPOETAßDOSß ARTISTASßPLfSTICOS
*ORGEßDEß,IMA߯ ß POETAßALAGOANO
//5
>^oqbjrfq^p`lfp^p+Rj^a^p`lfp^pnrb^^oqb)m^ob`b)rj^qo^kpcloj^ l pfj_if`^aljrkal+Nrboafwbo7l^oqfpq^`of^rjjrkallrqolÎj^fp_lkfqllrj^fp fkqbkpllrj^fppfdkfÛ`^qfsl)lrj^fploabk^alÎmlo`fj^a^ob^ifa^abfjbaf^q^%+++&+ K^qro^ijbkqb)bppbjrkallrqolnrbl^oqfpq^`of^lrfksbkq^k^p`babpr^`riqro^)abpr^ bumbofk`f^absfa^)a^pfabf^pnrbbibqbjk^`^_b ^)bkÛj)abpr^sfplabjrkal%+++&+ Lk`aikoranaoo]na_ne]k`kiqj`kkqoq]pn]jobkni]koei^ he_]oa]_kil]jd]n) ikoklkai]`aFknca`aHei](ÎLkai]`kj]`]`knÏ6 >dr^c^ip^)^dr^_l^+ K^a^)k^a^alo >dr^j^kp^)^dr^alfa^) ^nrfcof^)^ifjlok^) ^dr^cjb^+ K^a^)k^a^alo >dr^pl_b)^dr^abp`b) ^dr^j^kp^)^dr^alfa^+ K^a^)k^a^alo >dr^qbi^j_b)^dr^qb^_o^ ^) ^dr^qbibs^)^dr^qbj^q^+ K^a^)k^a^alo Pbkl)nrbobpq^oabqf)k^a^alo< K^a^)k^a^alo+ Necknko]iajpa(jkdj]`]jaooalkai]mqa`ao_kjda]iko*Jajdqi]`]ol]h]rn]o ailnac]`]olahklkap]jko`ao_kjda_e`]*A(jkajp]jpk(pq`k]ejpaen]iajpajkrk*K lkai]`evkmqa(]jpao`aha(f]i]eod]re]oe`k`epkamqa(oaiaha(jqj_]oane]`epk* Klkai]oa_kjopn elahkfkck`aoajpe`ko`]l]h]rn]k^a^*Kk^a^keilan]perk`k ran^kk^a^o$klkap]kn`aj]]kj]`]`knmqaj]`a6ÎJ]`](j]`]`knÏ%(i]op]i^iklnk) jkiaej`aÚje`kjac]perk$oajkj]`]n(`evklkap](j]`]naop]n]kj]`]`kn6ÎJ]`](j]`]) `knÏ%*Klkjpk`aat_h]i]kÎÏaiÎJ]`](j]`]`knÏej`e_]kqokran^]h`ak^a^7]]qoj_e] `klkjpk`aat_h]i]kaiÎJ]`](j]`]`kn*Ïej`e_]kqoklnkjkiej]h`ak^a^*Kiaoik fkckbaepk_ki]l]h]rn]k^a^alo6ah]oanabanamqahamqana]hev]]]k`aj]`]n(i]op]i) ^iej`e_]kj`akqjkmqaaoo]]koana]hev]ÍÎj]`knÏ* =cq]`ao_nep]lkniaek`aklkoe ao6ah]Î^k]ÏaÎb]ho]Ï(Îi]jo]ÏaÎ`ke`]Ï(Îbne]Ïa Îiknj]Ï(Îok^aÏaÎ`ao_aÏ(Î]^n]]ÏaÎi]p]Ï*Kmqaah];ejoprah(iq`]j`koai_aoo]n(klkj) `k)oa]oeiaoi](_kjpn]`ep ne]*Lkneookqi]bkn]mqa]nn]op]pq`kl]n]kr]vek*=cq] oei^khev]]bqc]_e`]`aa]ejop]^ehe`]`a`kiqj`k(oq]]_khde`]$Îpah]i^a(pa]^n]]Ï%aoq] rekhj_e]$Îpahar](pai]p]Ï%*Kmqaoajpa]mqahamqaj]`];@kn*I]olknmqaahalna_eo]j]`]n a_kjpejq]nj]`]j`k;Lknmqaokiajpa]ooeiajbnajp]n]bkn]akr]vek`]o_keo]o(jkoa `aet]noa`qvenlah]]_khde`]`ah]ojaioa`aet]n`aopnqenlah]rekhj_e]`ah]o*=`kn`amqai j]`]kmqanaop]]kÎj]`])`knÏ(eila`ej`k)k`apn]jobkni]n)oa(ahap]i^i(ailqnkj]`]* Klkap]jkob]vran(ok^]]l]nj_e]_]hi]a_kopqiaen]`]o_keo]o`apk`k`e](]ran`]`a lnkbqj`]`aqiiqj`k_kjpn]`ep nekmqaoanpq`k(oalq`anna`qvenkdkiai]j]`](i]o mqaoanqij]`]`e]jpa`]mqahamqalkooqe]bkn]l]n]oqlknp]naajbnajp]n]`kn`aaop]n jkiqj`k*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Ei]cai`a=jj] @qj_]j(`]j]nej] `kcnqlk`aoq] ia(Eo]`kn]@qj_]j( aibkpk`a-5.2* !RNOLDß'ENTHE)MAGNO(ULTON'ETTYß)MAGESß#ONTRIBUTOR
=kfkc]n_ki]`qlhe_e`]`a`aoajpe`k`aÎj]`]Ïa_ki]_kilkoek`]l]h]rn]k^a^* alo(klkap]pn]joÚcqn]]hejcq]cai_kpe`e]j]l]n]b]v)h]`evan]hckjkrk*Aooa]hck(eopk( koajpe`kjkrk(jkateopa]jpaojai`alkeo(jkateopa]mqijai]hi`klkai](i]o kln lneklkai]_kiknaejrajkkqna_ne]k`]hejcq]cai* =hejcq]caimqab]h]iko_kpe`e]j]iajpa]hejcq]caiejopepq`](qi]Îb]h]b]h]`]Ï( aimqanalnk`qveiko]ooecjeÚ_] ao`]ol]h]rn]ooailajo]njah]o*=hejcq]cai`klkap]( `knki]j_eop](`k_kjpeop]qi]hejcq]caiejopepqejpa(_ne]`kn](ejrajpkn]`aoecjeÚ_] ao jkr]o(qi]Îb]h]b]h]jpaÏ* Mqaao_naran;L]n]klkap]aknki]j_eop](`evkÚh okbkaao_nepknbn]j_oFa]j)L]qh O]npna( `eop]j_e]n)oa `] hejcq]cai)ejopnqiajpk a ajpn]n j] ^qfqrab mlqf`^( pn]p]j`k ]o l]h]rn]o_kikajpaona]eoajk_kikiankooecjkokqoej]eoaop]^aha_e`ko*]l]jd]n]hej) cq]caiaiaop]`koahr]cai$_kikFknca`aHei]b]v_ki]l]h]rn]k^a^%(_kikoa]ol]h]) rn]obkooaioanao_kik]pann](]nahr](]ikjp]jd]kq]cq]$at]p]iajpa_kikjklkai] `aFknca`aHei]]l]h]rn]k^a^a]l]h]rn]dr^okkiqj`ka]]k`kdkiai%*Klkap] mqanmqa]ol]h]rn]ooecjeÚmqai(aioealknoe(]hcqi]_keo]mqaokah]oln lne]ook^] bkni]`alkai]*Klnko]`kn`aoaf](]hi`eook(mqaah]o`aoecjaikiqj`k(]ej`]mqal]n] p]jpkahapajd]`aejrajp]njkr]iajpakiqj`klkniaek`]ol]h]rn]o*Kmqa]hepan]pqn]; ]_ne]k`aqiiqj`kmqaateopa_kikl]h]rn]aokiajpalah]aj]l]h]rn]* K mqa d `a aol]jpkok j]o ]npao mqa ah]o `aoraj`]i kq `ao_k^nai k iqj`k na) _ne]j`k)k `a kqpn] i]jaen] a ai kqpn] `eiajok* Fqop]iajpa lknmqa na_ne]i k iqj`k _kil]h]rn]o(okjo(pn]ko(_knao(caopko(ikreiajpko(bkni]o(i]oo]o(rkhqiao]na]he`]`a _ne]`]jkaop]mqijai]hi`]k^n](]ooei_kikjkaopj]k^n](i]o]ln lne] k^n]`a]npa* P]hrav]iahdkn_kilnkr]k`eookaopaf] j]ioe_]aj]`]j]* Baep] `a okjo( ] ioe_] oan `aopnq`] oa pajp]niko kqren _]`] oki oal]n]`]iajpa kq nalnk`qve)hko _kik jk pkmqa `a qi _knlk `a _neop]hkq`aiap]h*Lah]d]nikje](lah]lnklkn) k(lah]_ki^ej]k`aokjo(lahknepikalah] lan_qook(]ioe_]_ne]qiiqj`kokjknkmqa o ateopalknah](jah]amqaah]ln lne]*Ah]na) _khda ] okjkne`]`a `k iqj`k a `a jkoo] lan) _alk]q`eper](i]onaejrajp]kokia]]q`e) k_kikoaaopaof]i]eodkqraooaiateope`k* Baep]`aikreiajpko(caopkoanepiko(]`]j) ]oan`aopnq`]oapajp]nikoeokh)hkokqnaq) je)hkoia_]je_]iajpa(_kikai^kja_ko*Ah]o ateopaj]ikreiajp]kacaope_qh]knepi]`]o `k`]j]nejka`]`]j]nej](mqana_ne]ik_kn) lkdqi]jk]ooei_kikna_ne]ikikreiajpk aknepik`kln lnekiqj`k_qfkoajpe`ka_qf] na]he`]`ajkokoajkk]pk`a`]j]n* =hepan]pqn](_kik]lejpqn](]ioe_](]ao) _qhpqn] a mq]hmqan `]o ]npao( ] l]oo]cai `k fkpqfqral]kfkpqfqrfkqb(kqoaf](qi]pn]joÚcq) n]k`kateopajpajqi]kqpn]na]he`]`amqak b]vnaj]o_anaoan`ai]jaen]ejpaen]iajpajkr]* =pn]jobkni]kkqpn]joÚcqn]k`]na]he`]`a jqi]kqpn](jkr]aateopajpa]laj]ojkpn]^]) hdkna]hev]`klahk]npeop](_d]i])oak^n]*
/0,
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
=npaanahecek
R
eikomqa(]l]npen`]_]l]_e`]`al]n]nah]_ekj]n)oa_kik]qoajpa(kodkiajo_ne]) n]i]hejcq]cai(ejopepqn]ikpn]^]hdka]nahecek*Aoo]olneiaen]oi]jebaop] ao _qhpqn]eo`an]iknecaiolneiaen]obkni]o`]ok_e]^ehe`]`aÍ]re`]_kiqjepne] Ía`]]qpkne`]`aÍklk`annahecekok*Hejcq]cai(pn]^]hdkanahecekejopepqn]ikooi^k) hko`]knc]jev]kdqi]j]`kaol]ka`kpailk(`k_knlka`kaolnepk*=o]npao(eopk(]o p_je_]okq]npaoia_ je_]o(j]o_an]iejoal]nraeo`aoo]dqi]jev]k`kiqj`kj]pqn]h* Aaoo]dqi]jev]k(_kikreiko(_kj`qveqo]_n]hev]k`kiqj`kj]pqn]h*@ab]pk( ]kaopq`]niko]nahecek(reikomqa]nah]k_kiko]cn]`k(]kknc]jev]nkaol]kakpai) lkakoajpeiajpk`]_kiqjdkkqoal]n]kajpnakodqi]jkoa]j]pqnav]a`ahao_ki k`erejk(o]_n]hevkqkpk`k`]na]he`]`a*=o]_n]hev]keilhe_kqmqapk`]o]o]pere`]`aodq) i]j]o]ooqieooai]bkni]`anepq]eo6]cqann](]oaia]`qn]a]_khdaep](]_qhejne](]opnk) _]o(kj]o_eiajpka]iknpa(]`kaj]a]_qn]an]ina]hev]`]onepq]heope_]iajpa7]iq`]j] `]oaop] ao(]l]oo]cai`k`e]jkepaa`]jkepa]k`e](]lnaoaj]kq]qoj_e]`arajpkoa _dqr]o(kikreiajpk`ko]opnko(aioqi](pk`koko]_kjpa_eiajpkoj]pqn]eoan]i_an_]`ko dqi]j]iajpalkn_qhpkonahecekoko(`a`e_]`koobkn]o`erej]omqako_]qo]r]i* =o]_n]hev]ka]nepq]hev]k`]re`]Úvan]i_kimqaia`e_ej](]cne_qhpqn](_qhejne]( a`eÚ_] ao(lnk`qk`aqpajoheko(ioe_](`]j]oana]hev]ooai_kiknepkokqoacqej`kne) pq]eo(amqa_anpkoqpajoheko$b]_]o(lqjd]eo(]`]c]o(_he_ao(p]]o(len]o(ap_*%aejopnqiajpko $ok^napq`kkoiqoe_]eo%(]ooei_kik_anpkoraopqneko$i]jpko(pje_]o(_keb]o(ap_*%a]`kn) jko $pe]n]o( _knk]o( _kh]nao( lqhoaen]o( ]jeo( lejpqn]o b]_e]eo a _knlkn]eo% oa pknj]ooai aha) iajpko`ko_qhpko*Oaia]na_khdan(_]]nalao_]n(_kvan]heiajpko(Ú]napa_an(]ooei_kik lejp]n(ao_qhlen(`]j]n(_]jp]napk_]nejopnqiajpkookjknkooqncen]i(lknp]jpk(_kik]pe) re`]`aop_je_k)naheceko]o* Kmqadkfa_d]i]iko`a^ah]o)]npao$lejpqn](ao_qhpqn](`]j](ioe_]%j]o_aqdie) hjekojkejpanekn`ko_qhpkonahecekokoal]n]oanre)hko*@ab]pk(kolneiaenkok^fapko]npope) _ko$aop]pqap]o(lejpqn]oj]ol]na`ao`a_]ranj]o(okjok^pe`kolknlan_qook%an]ik^fapko jdf`lp(kqoaf](jkan]iqi]nalnaoajp]kjaiqi]ejrk_]k]ko`aqoao(i]o]aj_]n) j]k`ahao(lkeo]_na`ep]r])oamqa]obkn]o`erej]oaop]r]ijahao*Aooaolneiaenkok^fapko an]ikocbqf`ebpako]npeop]okq]npaokoan]ikocbfqf`bfolp* Lkq_k]lkq_k(ia`e`]mqa]onahece aobkn]ioaknc]jev]j`kjkejpanekn`]ook_ea) `]`ao(ai^kn]rnekobape_daobkooai_kjoanr]`ko(l]ookq)oae`ae]`amqahqc]naoa_keo]o `aopej]`koo]_n]he`]`akqre`]naheceko]d]re]ioe`kao_khde`kolahkoln lneko`aqoaoa mqahk_]eoak^fapko]ooeiao_khde`ko`arane]iÚ_]noal]n]`ko`apk`kknaopk(naoanr]`ko at_hqoer]iajpal]n]dkjn]na]`kn]nko`aqoao`ai]jaen]o`apaniej]`]olahkoln lneko `aqoao(eopk(ai_qhpko*Kok^fapkob]^ne_]`ko_kiaoo]Új]he`]`alahko]npeop]o)]npaoko l]oo]n]i]pans^iloab`riql* =koqncen(j]olneiaen]ook_ea`]`aoa_qhpqn]o(k]npeop]an]qii]ckÍ_kikki`e_k ak]opn hkckÍ(qi]npaokÍ_kikkkhaenk(ki]n_ajaenk(k]nmqepapk(klejpknakao_qhpkn Íaqieje_e]`kjqikb_eko]cn]`kÍ_kikkioe_kak`]j]nejk*An]qii]cklkn) mqa_kjda_e]koieopnekoo]cn]`ko7an]qi]npaokkq]npÚ_alknmqab]^ne_]r]kok^fapko aejopnqiajpko`ko_qhpko7an]qikÚ_e]jpalknmqana]hev]r]knepq]hlkniaek`al]h]rn]o( caopko(okjoa`]j]oÚt]`kolah]pn]`ekalah]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]*An](j]mq]he`]`a`a i]ck(]npÚ_aa`apajpkn`aqikb_ekmqana]hev]r]oq]]npaÍkqoaf](jkan]kmqadkfa _d]i]iko `aÎ]npeop]Ï a oei qi oanre`kn nahecekok* Oq] ]npa( lkn oan l]npa ejoal]nrah `k _qhpka`knepq]h(jkoaabapq]r]oacqj`k]rkjp]`aej`ere`q]h`k]npeop](eopk(jklnkre) jd]`]he^an`]`a_ne]`kn]`kp_je_k)]npaok(i]oatece]mqaahanaolaep]ooaa_kjoanr]ooa ]oiaoi]onacn]oajkni]oakoiaoikolnk_a`eiajpkol]n]]b]^ne_]k`kok^fapko`ko _qhpkoal]n]]na]hev]k`kocaopkoahejcq]cajojkonepq]eo(lkeop]jpkkok^fapko_kikko caopkoa]ol]h]rn]od]re]ioe`kajoej]`kokqej`e_]`kolahko`aqoao*
/0-
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
K]npÚ_aeje_e]r])oajkooacna`ko`]o]npaokqp_je_]ona_a^aj`kqi]a`q_]kaola) _e]h(pknj]j`k)oaqifkf`f^albjjfpqoflp*=lnaj`e]]_kjda_an]i]pne])lnei]lnaaop]^a) ha_e`]l]n]katan__ek`aoq]]npa(]qo]nqpajohekoaejopnqiajpkolnaaop]^aha_e`kol]n]] oq]]k(]na]hev]ncaopko(lnkjqj_e]nl]h]rn]o(qpehev]n_knao(i]jelqh]nanr]ooacqj`kqi na_aepqnekÚtkaoa_napk(_kjda_e`k]laj]olahkoeje_e]`ko*K]npeop]an](lknp]jpk(kÚ_e]jpa `a_qhpkoab]^ne_]`kn`kok^fapkoacaopko`ko_qhpko*Oaqpn]^]hdkj]o_e]`aqi`kialp `aqoao$mqa`an]i]kodqi]jkok_kjda_eiajpk`kbkck(`koiap]eo(`]ooaiajpao(`ko ]jei]eo(`]ocq]oa`korajpko(ap_*%aan]qi`kidqi]jkm^o^ko`aqoao* Iaoik mq]j`k( deopkne_]iajpa( rne]o ok_ea`]`ao $_kik ] cnac]( ] nki]j]( ] _neop% klan]iqi]`ereokok_e]haimqako`apajpknao`]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]na]hev]iko_qhpko( i]ofjkb]^ne_]ikoejopnqiajpko(kok^fapkoakohk_]eo`ko_qhpko(i]jpe`]]nah]k ajpna]]pere`]`a`ko]npeop]okq]npaokoa]nahecek*j]mq]he`]`a`aoanre`knao`]]qpk) ne`]`a naheceko] mqa ok aj_]nnac]`ko`apa_ankoraopqneko(b]^ne_]n]ofke]o( lnk`qven ko k^fapkoakoejopnqiajpko(_kjopnqenkohqc]nao`ko_qhpko(ancqan]hp]nao(ao_qhlenkqlejp]n ]oÚcqn]o`ko`aqoaoa`aoaqonalnaoajp]jpao(lnk`qven]oioe_]o(ko_]jpkoakoejopnq) iajpkoiqoe_]eo(na]hev]n]o`]j]o*=ocn]j`aok^n]o`a]npa`]ook_ea`]`ao]jpec]oa`] ok_ea`]`a_neopia`ear]h(]ooei_kik`]_qhpqn]fq`]e_]a`]_qhpqn]eoh ie_](oknahecek) o]oÍpailhko(_]pa`n]eo(l]h_eko(_he_ao(p]]o(i]jpko(pje_]o(_d]lqo(_kh]nao(lqhoaen]o( ]jeo( aoppq]o( mq]`nko( ioe_]o a ejopnqiajpko iqoe_]eo( cn]rqn]o a ehqopn] ao `a i]) jqo_nepko(ap_*(pq`keookan]aj_kiaj`]`klah]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]alahkokÚ_e]jpao`ko _qhpko(mqaaop]^aha_e]i]onacn]o`ab]^ne_]k(`apaniej]r]ikoi]pane]eoa]obkni]o(]o _knao(konepiko(koikreiajpko(kookjo(ap_* Aoo]nah]klnkbqj`]_ki]nahecek(mqa`apaniej]r]pk`]]]pere`]`a]npope_k)]npao]j]h( ej`e_]]]qoj_e]`a]hckmqaoapknj]n`a_eoerko_qhkoi]eop]n`a6]^rqlkljf^a^p^oqbp* Oai`re`](j]ok_ea`]`acnac]aj]nki]j]]jpec]o(qi]l]npa`]lnk`qk]npope) _k)]npao]j]hao_]l]r]`klk`an`]]qpkne`]`anaheceko](i]ol]n]Ú_]nok^klk`an`]]qpkne) `]`alkhpe_](mqaaj_kiaj`]r]`ko]npÚ_aoa`eb_eko(k^fapko(raopqneko(ik^eheneko(fke]o( ]`knjko(aoppq]oalejpqn]o(eilkj`k]ko]npeop]o]ao_khd]mqaÚvan]`koi]pane]eo(`]o bkni]o(`]o`eiajo ao(ap_* L]n]mqa]]qpkjkie]`]o]npaoreaooa]]_kjpa_anbkelna_eokmqakik`k`alnk`qk _]lep]heop]abpp^`o^ifw^ppbkiqj`kai^f`fw^ppbpk`]]_qhpqn](h]j]j`kpk`]o]o]pere`]`ao dqi]j]ojkian_]`k*EookoecjeÚ_kq(lkni(mqa(hernao`klk`annahecekoka`klk`anlkh) pe_k(ko]npeop]ooaren]i]^n]ko_kiklk`ana_kjie_k*=koahern]nai`kr]hkn`a_qhpk( ]ok^n]o`a]npabkn]i]lneoekj]`]olahkr]hkn`aian_]`k*
LAICOßPALAVRAßDEßORIGEMß LATINAßLAICUS ßQUEßEQUI VALEßgßEXPRESSjOß±SECULAR² ß OUßSEJA ßQUEßSEßREFEREßß AßTUDOßQUEßSEßOPzEßgß RELIGIjOßOUßSEßMANTmMß NEUTROßgßIDmIAßDEßß RELIGIOSIDADE
6ALDEMIRß#UNHA!BRILß)MAGENS
?lqh]`k@kik `]Nk_d](ai Fanqo]hi(Eon]ah*
/0.
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
=npaap_je_] ARTEßAßPALAVRAßARTEßVEMß DOßLATIMßARSßEßCORRESPONDEß AOßTERMOßGREGOßTmKHNE ß ±TmCNICA² ßSIGNIFICANDOß ±TODAßATIVIDADEßHUMANAß SUBMETIDAßAßREGRASßEMß VISTAßDAßFABRICAljOßDEßß ALGUMAßCOISA²ßEMßLATIM ß ARTESjO ßARTqFICEßOUßARTISTAß SEßDIZßARTIFEX ß±OßQUEßFAZß COMßARTE² ßEßTAMBmMß OPFICIS ß±OßQUEßEXERCEßUMß OFqCIO²ßEßOßRESULTADOßDEß SUAßAljOßSEßDIZßOPUSßß NOßSINGULAR ßEßOPERAßß NOßPLURAL ßISTOßm ßEMßß PORTUGUoS ß±OBRA²
/0/
R
eiko(jkej_ek`aopa_]lpqhk(mqa]i]ekne]`]olaook]o]lnktei]aolkjp]ja]iajpa ^oqba^oqbp^k^ql*Aoo]]lnktei]k(_kik`eooaiko(`a_knna`kb]pk`amqak]npeop]a k]npaoklnk`qvaiokvejdkoalknejpaenkqi]k^n]amqaaop]atlneiaoaqop]hajpko ad]^ehe`]`ao*I]od]ej`]kqpnkikperkl]n]aoo]]lnktei]k6kb]pk`amqa(deopkne_]iaj) pa(]npaa]npao]j]pkan]i]iaoi]_keo](a(lknp]jpk(k]npaokak]npeop]an]ikiaoik* =]npakqp_je_]an](lknp]jpk(qi]]pere`]`anacn]`]aireop]`]lnk`qk`aqi] k^n]* Ai oajpe`k ]ilhk( ^op kq qhekb oecjeÚ_]r] Îd]^ehe`]`a a ]cehe`]`a l]n] ejrajp]n iaekol]n]raj_anqi]`eÚ_qh`]`akqqik^op_qhklkopkolah]j]pqnav]Ï*Aioajpe`kao) pnepk(oecjeÚ_]r]Îk]lnaj`ev]`ka]lnpe_]`aqikb_ekmqalkooqenacn]o(lnk_a`eiajpkoa ejopnqiajpkoln lnekoÏ*>opkqqhekban]qio]^anlnpe_k* Lknoanqi]d]^ehe`]`a`enece`]lknnacn]oalnk_a`eiajpko_kireop]lnk`qk`a qi]npab]pkkq_ki]Új]he`]`a`araj_anqi]`eÚ_qh`]`aeilkop]lah]j]pqnav](]]npa kqp_je_]oa`aÚje]lknklkoek]kmqa]_kjpa_amlo^`^pl(^ai_kik]kmqaoeilhao) iajpabpmlkq kblkqjk`ahe^an]`k(a]kmqak^qro^i(eopk(mqaateopakq]_kjpa_aoai ]ejpanrajkdqi]j]*Lkneook(aioaqoajpe`ki]eocan]h(]npaan]Îqi_kjfqjpk`anacn]oa lnk_a`eiajpko_ki]bqjk`a^ai`enecenqi]]pere`]`adqi]j]mq]hmqanl]n]mqaaop] na]hev]ooakÚi]mqaoalnkloÏ* Jaoo]lanola_per](b]h]r])oaai]npai`e_](]npalkhpe_](]npaiehep]n(]npanap ne_](]npa lkpe_](]npa`eappe_](]npa`]j]rac]k(]npa`]_]](]npa`alejp]n(ao_qhlen(`]j]n(ap_* Lh]pkjk`eopejcqe]]]npa`]o_ej_e]ojai]`eopejcqe]`]ÚhkokÚ](qi]ravmqapk`]oah]o ok]pere`]`aodqi]j]okn`aj]`]oanacn]`]o*=`eopejklh]pje_]an]baep]ajpna`keopelko `a]npaokqp_je_]o6]ograf`^qfs^p(eopk(`a`e_]`]o]laj]o]k_kjda_eiajpk(a]oafpmlpfqf* s^pkqfjmbo^qfs^p(rkhp]`]ol]n]qi]]klnpe_]* =neop pahao(lkni(aop]^aha_aq`q]o`eopej aomqalan`qn]n]ilkno_qhkoj]_qhpqn] k_e`ajp]h*=lneiaen]`eopejcqa_ej_e]`a]npakqp_je_]6]_ej_e]qio]^anpa ne_kmqaoa nabana]kkb`bppofl$]kmqajklk`aoan`ebanajpa`kmqalknoanabaepk`a_]qo]oj]pqn]eo ja_aoone]o%(ajmq]jpk]]npakqp_je_]qio]^anlnpe_kmqaklan]jk_]ilk`k`lkqfk* dbkqbkq`kmlppsbi$`kmqalk`aoan`ebanajpa`kmqalknoanabaepk`aqi]`ahe^an]k kq`a_eokdqi]j]%* =oacqj`]`eopejkaop]^aha_e`]jk_]ilk`]ln lne]lnpe_]_ki]`ebanaj]ajpna ^ lac^_of`^ l*=]k(aicnackmoufp(]mqah]]pere`]`adqi]j]aimqak]cajpa(k]pk mqaahana]hev]a]Új]he`]`a^qo_]`]lknahaoke`jpe_koÍ]moufp`aÚja]]kpe_]a] ]klkhpe_]$]ooei(lknatailhk(kdkiaimqa]carenpqko]iajparenpqkoka]renpq`a ]]kmqaahana]hev](`ai]jaen]mqajkoalk`aoal]n]nk]cajparenpqkok(k]pkrenpqkok a]renpq`akqÚj]he`]`a`]]k%*=b]^ne_]k(aicnackmlfbpfp(]mqah]]pere`]`adqi]j] j]mq]hk]cajpa$k]npaokkq]npeop]%(]]kmqaahana]hev]$]onacn]oakolnk_a`eiajpko oacqe`kolknaha%a]Új]he`]`a^qo_]`]$]k^n]%ok`ebanajpaoa`eopejpkoÍ]mlfbpfp`aÚja ]o]npaokqp_je_]o_kik]pere`]`ao`ab]^ne_]k$]ooei(lknatailhk(ki`e_k(]]k`a _qn]na]o]`ana_kjmqeop]`]jkoke`jpe_ko7`]iaoi]i]jaen](kao_qhpkn(k_ejvahak inikna(]onacn]o`]ao_qhpqn]a]aoppq]jkoke`jpe_ko%* Lkopanekniajpa(koÚh okbkojaklh]pje_ko_kilhap]n]i]o`eopej ao]neopkphe_]o`eo) pejcqej`k]op_je_]okq]npao_qf]Új]he`]`a]qtehe]n]j]pqnav]Í_kik]ia`e_ej](] ]cne_qhpqn] Í `]mqah]o _qf] Új]he`]`a b]^ne_]n qi k^fapk _ki ko i]pane]eo kbana_e`ko lah]j]pqnav]Ík]npao]j]pklnklne]iajpa`epk*@eopejcqen]ip]i^iqikqpnk_kjfqjpk `a]npaoap_je_]omqajkoanah]_ekj]i_ki]j]pqnav](i]o]laj]o_kikln lnekdk) iai(l]n]pknj)hkiahdknkqlekn6ioe_](`]j](lkaoe]anap ne_]* = _h]ooeÚ_]k `]o ]npao kq p_je_]o oacqeq qi l]`nk mqa bke `apaniej]`k lah] ao) pnqpqn] `] ok_ea`]`a ]jpec] a( lknp]jpk( lah] knc]jev]k ok_e]h bqj`]`] j] ao_n]re`k* = `ereokok_e]hajpnadkiajohernaoaao_n]rko(eilkj`k]aopaopk`]o]ok_ql] aoapk`ko kopn]^]hdkoi]jq]eoanaoanr]j`kmqahao]o]pere`]`aojki]jq]eo(har]r]]qi]_qhpqn]
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
mqa`aolnav]r]kpn]^]hdki]jq]h*Qi]k^n](>pk m`f^pabJbo` oflbÛilildf^(ao_nep]lahk deopkne]`knnki]jkR]nnk(kbana_a]_h]ooeÚ_]kmqalan`qn]n`ko_qhkEE`*?*]ko_qhk TR(`ere`ej`k]o]npaoai^oqbpif_bo^fp$kq`ecj]o`kdkiaiherna%a^oqbppbosfplrjb` kf* `^p$ln lne]o`kpn]^]hd]`kni]jq]h%* An]i]npaohe^an]eo6cn]ipe_](nap ne_](h ce_](]nepipe_](cakiapne](]opnkjkie]ai) oe_](_kilkj`kk_qnn_qhkao_kh]n`kodkiajohernao*An]i]npaoia_ je_]opk`]o]okqpn]o ]pere`]`aop_je_]o6]cne_qhpqn](_]](lao_](ia`e_ej](ajcajd]ne](]nmqepapqn](j]rac]k( lejpqn](ao_qhpqn](kh]ne](_]nlejp]ne](i]n_aj]ne](Ú]kapa_ah]cai(ap_* Aoo] _h]ooeÚ_]k oan fqopeÚ_]`] lkn O]jpk Pkio `a =mqejk `qn]jpa ] E`]`a I`e] _kik`ebanaj]ajpna]o^oqbpnrbafofdbjlqo^_^iela^o^wl$kq]o]npaohe^an]eo%a^pnrb afofdbjlqo^_^iela^pjlp$kq]o]npaoia_ je_]o%*Reopkmqa(jqi]lanola_per]naheceko] _neop(okiajpa]]hi]hernaak_knlkl]n]ah]qi]lneok(_kj_hqe)oamqa]o]npaohe^an]eo okoqlaneknaoo]npaoia_ je_]o* Lknmqa]o]npaoi]jq]eook_d]i]`]o`a]npaoÎia_ je_]oÏ;=ol]h]rn]ocnac]ojb* `e^kfh $ia_ je_]% a jb`e^k $imqej]% oecjeÚ_]iÎejrajk ajcajdko]Ï(Îaopn]p]cai] ]opq_ekokÏ* Eje_e]hiajpa( an]i ailnac]`]o l]n] oa nabanen ] aopn]p]cai]o `a cqann] a j] ikjp]cai`a_ajneko`apa]pnk*Lkq_k]lkq_kl]oo]n]i]oecjeÚ_]np]i^ipk`katla) `eajpad]^ehe`kokl]n]naokhranqi]`eÚ_qh`]`a_knlkn]hkql]n]oqlan]nqik^op_qhk ]k`k_knlkdqi]jk*Mq]hkaopn]p]cai]]opq_ekokkq]ejrajkd]^ehe`ko];B]van_ki mqa ]hcqi bn]_k na]heva qi] p]nab] ]_ei] `a oq]o bkn]o( cn]]o ] qi ejopnqiajpk mqa ]ilhe]oq]obkn]o*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqaqi]]h]r]j_]aqii]npahkokimqej]o kqk^fapkoia_ je_ko(lkeo]]h]r]j_]laniepa`aohk_]nqilaokmqaqi]laook](okvejd]( f]i]eo`aohk_]ne](aki]npahklaniepamqa^n]nkqqjenk^fapkomqa]oikookvejd]ojk _kjoacqene]imqa^n]nkqqjen*=p_je_]kq]npaejrajp]ejopnqiajpkoajcajdkokoa]opqpko l]n]]qtehe]nk_knlk]na]hev]nqi]]pere`]`alajko](`qn](`eb_ehmqa(j]ook_ea`]`ao]jpe) c]o(an]na]hev]`]lknao_n]rkokqoanrkoalkndkiajohernaolk^nao* =l]npen`]Naj]o_aj](lkni(pn]r])oaqi]hqp]lah]r]hknev]k`]o]npaoia_ je_]o lkn`q]on]v aolnej_el]eo6ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqa_kia]]oqncenke`a]h`]sfa^^qf* s^(mqar]hknev]]]lhe_]klnpe_]kqp_je_]`ko_kjda_eiajpkopa ne_ko$_kikoarai Hakj]n`k`]Rej_e_kioq]oejraj ao`aimqej]o`apk`kpelka_kikoarp]i^ij] eilknp j_e] `ko k^fapko p_je_ko mqa laniepen]i ] na]hev]k `]o Cn]j`ao J]rac] ao a ko`ao_k^neiajpkoi]npeiko%7aioacqj`k(lknmqakDqi]jeoiknaj]o_ajpeop]`ecjeÚ_] k_knlkdqi]jkaaoo]`ecje`]`aoapn]`qvj]_d]i]`]Î^]p]hd]lah]`ecje`]`a`]o]npao ia_ je_]oÏl]n]hdao`]n]iaoi]_kj`ek`]o]npaohe^an]eo*=hi`eook(aop]iko]ckn]jk ej_ek`k_]lep]heoikaia`e`]mqaaopaoa`aoajrkhra(kpn]^]hdkl]oo]]oan_kjoe`an]`k bkjpaa_]qo]`]onemqav]o(oaj`klkneookr]hknev]`k*=r]hknev]k`kpn]^]hdk]_]nnap]] r]hknev]k`]o]npaoia_ je_]o* =lneiaen]`ecje`]`ak^pe`]lah]o]npaoia_ je_]obkeoq]ahar]k_kj`ek`a`l* keb`fjbkql(_kik]o]npaohe^an]eo*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(jah]ojkd]re]]laj]o]]lhe_]k nkpejaen]`anacn]o`ab]^ne_]ki]jq]h`ak^fapko(i]o_kjda_eiajpkopa ne_kol]n]]ej) rajka_kjopnqk`aejopnqiajpkoal]n]]na]hev]k`a]pere`]`ao_kik]ia`e_ej](] ajcajd]ne](]]nmqepapqn](]^]hope_](]lejpqn]a]ao_qhpqn]* = oacqj`] `ecje`]`a bke ]h_]j]`] jk Új]h `k o_qhk TREE a ] l]npen `k o_qhk TREEE( mq]j`koa`eopejcqen]i]oÛk^ifa^abp`]orne]o]npaoia_ je_]o(eopk(]omqapi_kik Úikmqa qfi]kodkiajo$]ia`e_ej](]cne_qhpqn](ajcajd]ne](]nmqepapqn](_qhejne](ko ]npao]j]pko(_kikp]i^i]kh]ne](i]n_aj]ne](Ú]k(pa_ah]cai(p]la]ne](fk]hdane](re) `n]ne]( f]n`ej]cai( ap_*% a ]mqah]o _qfk Úi lnk`qven k _bil a lnkrk_]n k oajpeiajpk `] ^ahav]$]lejpqn](ao_qhpqn](lkaoe]kqhepan]pqn](]ioe_](kpa]pnka]`]j]%* ?ki]e`ae]`arqfifa^ab(qi]l]npa`]o]npaoia_ je_]opknjkq)oaabaper]iajpahe^an]h a_kieookoqncen]i]o_d]i]`]omolÛppbpif_bo^fp$_kikki`e_k(kajcajdaenk(k]`rk) c]`k(k]nmqepapk(klnkbaookn(ap_*%* ?ki]e`ae]`a_bibw^(qi]l]npa`]o]npaoia_ je_]opn]jobknikq)oaj]o_d]i]`]o ^ah]o)]npao(ik`klahkmq]hj obkiko]_kopqi]`ko]ajpaj`an]]npa*
/00
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
/01
= `eopejk ajpna ]npao `] qpehe`]`a a ]npao `] ^ahav] ]_]nnapkq qi] oal]n]k ajpna q`kf`^$kpeh%a^oqb$k^ahk%(har]j`kei]cai`]]npa_kik]kej`ere`q]haolkjp ja]( rej`]`]oajoe^ehe`]`aa`]b]jp]oe]`k]npeop]_kikdkfl`of^alo*Ajmq]jpkkp_je_kreopk _kik]lhe_]`kn`anacn]oalnk_a`eiajpkorej`ko`]pn]`ekkq`]_ej_e](k]npeop]reopk _kik`kp]`k`afkpmfo^ l(ajpaj`e`]_kikqi]aol_ea`aehqiej]kejpaneknaaolenepq]h ieopaneko]mqahar]kcjek]_ne]n]k^n]* =hi`eook(_kik]k^n]`a]npalajo]`]]l]npen`aoq]Új]he`]`aÍ]_ne]k`k^ahk Í(pknj])oaejoal]nrah`]Úcqn]`kl^he_k$aola_p]`kn(kqrejpa(haepkn%(mqafqhc]a]r]he] kk^fapk]npope_k_kjbkniapajd]kqjkna]hev]`k]^ahav]*=^ahav]rai]npe_qh]`]jkk `a^kickopkakfqhc]iajpk`]k^n]`a]npalahk_nepnek`k^kickopk`knecai]k_kj) _aepk`agrwlabdlpql(mqaoan]ilh]iajpaaopq`]`klknG]jp* Cjek_ne]`knaejolen]k(`kh]`k`k]npeop]$b]h])oajaha_kikÎ]jei]hej_kil]nrahÏ%( ^ahav](`kh]`k`]k^n](afqvk`ackopk(`kh]`k`kl^he_k(_kjopepqaikoleh]naook^nako mq]eooaancqan(_kikranaiko]`e]jpa(qi]`eo_elhej]Úhko Ú_]6]aop pe_]* Pk`]re](`ao`akÚj]h`ko_qhkTETa`qn]jpako_qhkTT(ik`eÚ_kq)oa]nah]kajpna ]npaap_je_](eopk(]`eopejka]oal]n]kajpnak^ahkakpeh* Lkn qi h]`k( _kik reiko ]k aopq`]n ]o _ej_e]o( k aop]pqpk `] p_je_] ik`eÚ_kq)oa mq]j`k aop] oa pknjkq pa_jkhkce]( lknp]jpk( qi] bkni] `a _kjda_eiajpk a jk oeilhao ]kb]^ne_]`kn]`a]_kn`k_kinacn]oana_aep]o*Lknkqpnk(]o]npaol]oo]n]i]oan_kj_a) ^e`]oiajko_kik_ne]kcaje]hieopaneko]ai]eo_kikbumobppl`of^alo^(eopk(_kik pn]joÚcqn]k`kiqj`kaik^n]]npope_]* =o ]npao ok reop]o _kik qo^_^iel a^ bumobppl a ikopn]i mqa( `ao`a mqa oqncen]i lah]lneiaen]rav(bkn]iejoal]nraeo`]_ej_e]a`]p_je_]*=ooei(lknatailhk(]ao_qh) pqn]cnac]pane]oe`keilkoorahoai]cakiapne]7]lejpqn]a]]nmqepapqn]`]Naj]o_aj] okej_kilnaajoraeooai]i]paipe_]a]pakne]`]d]nikje]a`]olnklkn ao7]lejpqn] eilnaooekjeop](ej_kilnaajorahoai]boe_]a] lpe_](eopk(oai]pakne]`]o_knao(ap_*= jkre`]`a`kÚj]h`ko_qhkTETa`apk`kko_qhkTTaopjkb]pk`amqa(]ckn](]o]npaojk k_qhp]iaoo]onah] ao(ko]npeop]ooanabanaiatlhe_ep]iajpa]ah]oa^qo_]ij]o_ej_e]oa j]op_je_]onaolkop]oaokhq aol]n]lnk^hai]o]npope_ko* =koapki]n]o]npao_kikatlnaook_ne]`kn]a_kikpn]^]hdkatlnaooerk(jkoamqan `evanmqaah]olan`an]ikrj_qhk_ki]e`ae]`a^ahav]aoeimqa]oq^kn`ej]n]i]qi kqpnkr]hkn(]ran`]`a*=k^n]`a]npa^qo_]_]iejdko`a]_aook]kna]ha`aatlnaook`] ran`]`a*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]o]npaolnapaj`aiatlneienlkniaeko]npope_ko]ln lne]na]) he`]`a*BumofjfooecjeÚ_]Îejpanlnap]nÏ(kqoaf](aj_kjpn]nkqnarah]nlpbkqfal`]o_keo]oa`k iqj`k*Klejpkn`aoaf]narah]nkmqa]reoe^ehe`]`aejpanlnap]j`kkiqj`kreorah7ki) oe_k(kmqa]okjkne`]`aejpanlnap]j`kkiqj`kokjknk7k`]j]nejk(kmqa]ik^ehe`]`a _knlkn]hejpanlnap]j`kkiqj`k`kikreiajpk7kao_nepkn(kmqa]l]h]rn]ejpanlnap]j`k kiqj`k`]hejcq]cai7kao_qhpkn(kmqai]pane]he`]`a`kp]`]`abkni]ejpanlnap]j`kk iqj`k`]i]pne]a`]bkni]*L]n]b]v)hk(na_knnaiop_je_]oa]koejopnqiajpkop_je) _ko$_kik(]heo(oailnaÚvan]i(]lao]n`]ei]cai`kcjek_ne]`knejolen]`k(mqapen]`a `ajpnk`aoe]k^n]%* Pnoi]jebaop] ao]npope_]o_kjpailkn ja]olk`aiehqopn]nkik`k_kik]npaap_) je_]oaaj_kjpn]iaoa_kiqje_]i6]bkpkcn]Ú](k_ejai]akabpfdk* Bkpkcn]Ú]a_ejai]oqncai(eje_e]hiajpa(_kikp_je_]o`analnk`qk`]na]he`]`a* Lkq_k]lkq_k(lkni(pknj]i)oaejpanlnap] ao`]na]he`]`aa_kieookoqncai_kik]npao `]atlnaook*Kabpfdk(lknoq]rav(ejpnk`qv]o]npaolhope_]o$lejpqn](ao_qhpqn](]nmqepa) pqn]%jk`aoajdkaj]lnk`qk`aejopnqiajpkop_je_ko$qo]`koj]ej`opne](jkoh]^kn]) p neko_eajpÚ_ko(jkodkolep]eo(ai_kjoqhp nekoi`e_koa`ajpneko(ap_*%a`aqpajoheko _kpe`e]jko$ej`k`ao`a]qpki raeoa]re ao]pimqej]o`kiope_]okqahapnk`kiope_ko( ik^ehenek(hqiejne]o(p]hdanao(_klko(ln]pko(t_]n]o(hleo(_]jap]o(pa_e`kol]n]i raeoa _knpej]o(fke]oa^efqpane]o(_]h]`ko(ap_*%* @ao`a ko ]jko -5.,)-5/,( ]o bnkjpaen]o ajpna ]npa a p_je_] pknj]i)oa _]`] rav i]eo pjqao6lna_eokqi]lah_qh]pa_je_]iajpalanbaep]l]n]]bkpk]npope_]al]n]k_ejai]
`a]npa7lna_eokqii]pane]hpa_je_]iajpalanbaepkl]n]mqaqi`eo_klkoo]nalnk`qven qi_kj_anpk7lna_eokamqel]iajpkop_je_ko`a]hp]mq]he`]`aalna_eokl]n]]lnk`qk `abkpko(Úhiao(`eo_ko(r`ako(_ajnekoaehqiej]kpa]pn]eo*=p_je_]`ab]^ne_]k`ko ejopnqiajpko iqoe_]eo a ] ejrajk `a ]l]nahdko ahapnje_ko l]n] ioe_]( ]o lkooe^ehe`]) `aop_je_]o`ajkr]opejp]oa_knao(cn]]o]koi]pane]eooejppe_ko(ik`eÚ_]j`k]lejpqn]( ]olkooe^ehe`]`aop_je_]o`ajkrkoi]pane]eo`a_kjopnqk(ik`eÚ_]j`k]]nmqepapqn](k oqnceiajpk`ajkrkoi]pane]eooejppe_ko(ik`eÚ_]j`k]ao_qhpqn](ok]hcqjoatailhko`] nah]kejpanj]ajpna]pere`]`a]npope_]aejrajkp_je_k)pa_jkh ce_]* Aoo]nah]kpknjkq)oapkaopnaep]mqa]`eopejkajpna]npaanq`ep]a]npalklqh]noa ^]oae]j]lnaoaj]`]pa_jkhkce]`alkjp]j]lneiaen]aj]]qoj_e]`aoo]pa_jkhkce](j] oacqj`]7kqoaf](]]npalklqh]n]npao]j]h7]anq`ep](pa_jkh ce_]*P]i^i_kjÚni]]cn]j) `alnkteie`]`aajpna]npaoapa_jkhkce]kb]pk`amqaiqepko]npeop]o_dac]i]]lnaoajp]n _kikk^n]`a]npaqi]ejpanlnap]k`koln lnekok^fapkoaejopnqiajpkop_je_ko*Ajk iajkooecjeÚ_]perkkb]pk`a]hcqi]op_je_]o(mqaoanre]i`aejopnqiajpkol]n]]o]npao( panaioapknj]`k(ah]oln lne]o(bkni]o`a]npa(_kikbkek_]ok`]o_d]i]`]o]npaocnÚ_]o( j]o_e`]o`]op_je_]o`aeilnajo]l]n]]nalnk`qk`ak^n]o`a]npa* Kok^fapkolnk`qve`ko_ki^]oa jkabpfdkej`e_]imqabkn]i_kj_a^e) `ko_ki]lnak_ql]k`amqa(]hi `apaeo(p]i^ioaf]i^ahko*Jkaj) p]jpk(lkoorah`eopejcqenajpnaaooao k^fapkop_je_koa]ok^n]o`a]npa* =`ebanaj]ajpna]k^n]`a]npaa kok^fapkop_je_koaopaioq]oÚj]) he`]`ao6]k^n]`a]npabumobppfs^(k k^fapk p_je_k( ]ej`] mqa ^ahk(crk* `flk^i*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(jkok^fapko p_je_ko j]o_e`ko `k abpfdk ko i]pa) ne]eoa]obkni]oaopkoq^kn`ej]`ko crk lmqa`arailnaaj_dan$qi]_]) `aen]`araoan_kjbknprahl]n]oajp]n7 qi] _]jap]( ]`amq]`] l]n] ao_naran7 qi]qpki rah(]`amq]`kl]n]]hk_k) ikk7qi]cah]`aen](]`amq]`]l]n] ]_kjoanr]k`ko]heiajpko7qi]hq) iejne](]`amq]`]l]n]]`eopne^qek kq_kj_ajpn]k`ahqv(ap_*%*@]k^n] `a]npa(lkni(jkoaaolan]jaioa ateca bqj_ekj]he`]`a( d]raj`k jah] lhaj]he^an`]`al]n]he`]n_kibkni]o ai]pane]eo(_knaoaikreiajpko(okjo acaopko(oehj_ekoal]h]rn]o`komq]eo Reop]]na]`kAilenaOp]pa>qeh`ejc(aiJkr]Ukng* oaaolan]mqaatlnei]ioecjeÚ_] ao Jkrkoi]pane]eo`a_kjopnqk(_kikk_eiajpk( aran`]`ao(a_qf]^ahav]`a_knnafqop]) k]kakre`nk(bkn]iqo]`kolah]]nmqepapqn]jk o_qhkTT(]hpan]j`kk_ajnek`]oiapn lkhao* iajpa`aoaqlk`anatlnaooerk*
7ASSILYß+ANDINSKY!LBUMß !KG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
$AVIDß2ß&RAZIERß0HOTOLIBRARY0HOTOß2ESEARCHERS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
"AUHAUSßAßESCOLAßDEßß DESIGNßEßARQUITETURAßDEß VANGUARDAß"AUHAUSß±CASAßß DEßCONSTRUljO² ßSURGIDAß ENTREßASßDUASßGUERRASß MUNDIAIS ßNOßSmCULOß88 ß ALTEROUßAßRELAljOßENTREßOSß CONCEITOSßDEß{TILßEßDEßBELO
Nahecekoe`]`a(]qpkjkie]ap_je_]6]]qn]aoq]`ao]l]nek
J
]`]iahdknl]n]oejpapev]nklan_qnokmqaÚvaiko]p]mqe`kmqaqiajo]ek(dkfa _hooe_k(ao_nepklknS]hpan>ajf]iejai-5/1(ejpepqh]`k>l_o^ab^oqbk^bo^abpr^ obmolarqf_fifa^abq`kf`^*
/02
"ENß6AUTIER&LUXUS!RQUIVOßDAß%DITORA
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
Iuopanu^kt(k^n] `k]npeop]>aj R]qpean(hec]`k]k ikreiajpkBhqtqo* Jkn pqhk(lk`a)oa han]ejo_nek6ÎJk ]^n]*Aop]_]et]lan`a pk`koaqr]hkna oecjebe_]kaoppe_] _kikk^n]`a]npa $ieopnek%jkejop]jpa aimqa]^anp]Ï*Kq oaf](k]npeop]har]]k l]nkteoikk_kj_aepk `a]qn]*
Jaooaajo]ek(>ajf]iej]_kil]jd]kikreiajpkdeop ) ne_kaok_e]hjkmq]h]o]npaol]oo]i`k_]ilknahecekok]k `aoq]]qpkjkie](kq]k_]ilk]npope_klnklne]iajpa`epk( a `eopejcqa k ikiajpk nahecekok( mq]j`k ]o ]npao lkooqai Îr]hkn`a_qhpkÏ(akikiajpk]qpjkik(mq]j`kl]oo]i] panÎr]hkn `a atlkoekÏ* L]n] na]hev]n oq] ]jheoa( >ajf]iej ejpnk`qvk_kj_aepk`a^ro^* Mqa]]qn]; =]qn](atlhe_]>ajf]iej(]]^okhqp]oejcqh]ne`]`a`a qioanÍj]pqn]hkq]npope_kÍ(oq]_kj`ek`aatailh]n je_kmqaoakbana_ajqi]mqea]ckn]ÎennalaprahÏ(oq]mq]) he`]`a`aapanje`]`aabqc]_e`]`aoeiqhp ja]o(oaqlanpaj_e) iajpkja_aoonek]k_kjpatpkaimqaoaaj_kjpn]aoq]l]n) pe_el]kjqi]pn]`ekmqahda`oajpe`k*(jk_]ok`]k^n] `a]npa(oq]^rqbkqf`fa^ab(eopk(krj_qhkejpanjkajpnaoq] qje`]`aaoq]`qn]^ehe`]`a*=k^n]`a]npalkooqe]qn]kq ]qnpe_] mq]j`k pai ]o oacqejpao mq]he`]`ao6 je_]( qj]( ennalaprah(`qn]`kqn]babian](jkr]bl]npe_el]jpa`aqi] pn]`ek(_]l]v`apknj]n`eop]jpakmqaaoplanpkaaopn]jdk kmqal]na_e]b]iehe]nlknmqapn]joÚcqn]]na]he`]`a* >ajf]iejao_nara6 Bjprj^)lnrb^^ro^ajf]iej6 >rkf`fa^aba^l_o^ab^oqbfakqf`^ pr^fkpbo lkl`lkqbuqla^qo^af l+Pbj a sfa^)bpp^qo^af l^idljrfqlsfsl)buqo^loafk^of^jbkqbs^ofsbi+Rj^^kqfd^bp* qqr^abSkrp)mlobubjmil)bpq^s^fkp`ofq^krj^`boq^qo^af lbkqoblpdobdlp)nrb c^wf^jabi^rjl_gbqlab`riql)bbjlrqo^qo^af lk^Fa^abJaf^)nr^kallpalrqlobp a^Fdobg^sf^jkbi^rjalilj^ic^wbgl+Lnrbbo^`ljrj par^pqo^af bp)`lkqral) bo^^rkf`fa^aba^l_o^lr)bjlrqo^pm^i^so^p)pr^^ro^+
/03
=bkni]i]eolneieper]`aejoank`]k^n]`a]npajk_kjpatpk`]pn]`ekoaatlneie] jk_qhpk*=oi]eo]jpec]ok^n]o`a]npa(_kiko]^aiko(oqncen]i]oanrek`aqinepq]heje) _e]hiajpaice_ka`alkeonahecekok*Kmqa`aeilknp j_e]`a_eoer]mqaaooaik`k`aoan ]qnpe_k`]k^n]`a]npajqj_]oa`aop]_]_kilhap]iajpa`aoq]bqjknepq]h* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o6kr]hknje_k`]k^n]`a]npaÎ]qpjpe_]Ïpaioailnaqibqj`]iaj) pkpakh ce_k(lkni]eonaikpkmqaoaf]6ahalk`aoanna_kjda_e`k(_kiknepq]hoa_qh]nev]`k( iaoikj]obkni]oi]eolnkb]j]o`k_qhpk`k^ahk*Aoo]obkni]olnkb]j]o`k_qhpk`k^ahk(oqn) ce`]oj]Naj]o_aj]arecajpao`qn]jpapnoo_qhko(`aet]n]ii]jebaopkaooabqj`]iajpk* K_qhpk`k^ahk(]koq^opepqenk_qhpk`ko`aqoao(_kjoanrkqk_]npan]qnpe_k`]k^n]`a ]npa*Kqoaf](]kl]oo]n`k_]ilknahecekok]kaoppe_k(]k^n]`a]npa_kjoanrkq]]qn]*lna_eok( ajpk(atlhe_]n_kikalknmqa(j]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja](]]qn]bkelan`e`]kq`aopnq`]* >ajf]iejlnkooacqa6
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
%+++&c`fifabkqfÛ`^olpc^qlobppl`f^fpbpmb`Û`lpnrb`lkaf`flk^jlab`ikfl^qr^ia^ ^ro^+Bibabofs^abar^p`fo`rkpq k`f^p)bpqobfq^jbkqbifd^a^p `obp`bkqbafcrplbfkqbkpf* a^abalpjlsfjbkqlpabj^pp^p+C^wbo^p`lfp^pÏÛ`^objj^fpmoufj^pÐrj^mobl`rm^* lql^m^fulk^a^a^pj^pp^pjlabok^p`ljlpr^qbkak`f^^prmbo^ol`^oqbo kf`lab qlalplpc^qlp^qo^spa^pr^obmolarqf_fifa^ab+@^a^af^Û`^j^fpfoobpfpqsbi^kb`bppfa^ab abmlpprfoll_gbql)qlmboqlnr^kqlmlppsbi)bjfj^dbj)lr^kqbp)k^pr^`mf^)k^pr^ obmolar l+@^a^af^Û`^j^fpkqfa^^afcbobk ^bkqob^obmolar l)`ljlbi^klplcbob* `fa^mbi^pobsfpq^pfirpqo^a^pbmbilpal`rjbkqoflp`fkbj^qldoÛ`lp)b^fj^dbj+Kbpq^) ^rkfa^abb^aro^_fifa^abpb^ppl`f^jqlfkqfj^jbkqb`ljl)k^obmolar l)^qo^kpfql* ofba^abb^obmbqf_fifa^ab+Obqfo^oll_gbqlalpbrfksir`ol)abpqorfopr^^ro^)^`^o^`qbop* qf`^abrj^cloj^abmbo`bm l`rg^`^m^`fa^abab`^mq^oÏlpbjbie^kqbkljrkalÐql ^dra^nrb)do^ ^p obmolar l)bi^`lkpbdrb`^mq*il^qklcbkjbkl kf`l+ =lan`]`]]qn]`a_knna(]jpao`ai]eoj]`](`k`aoafk`amqa^n]n]`eop j_e]a]pn]jo) _aj`j_e]`kok^fapko]npope_ko(_qf]`eop j_e]apn]jo_aj`j_e]lnkrejd]`aoanaije_ko a`aoaaj_kjpn]naiaihk_]eokj`a]laj]o]hcqjolk`e]i_kjpailh)hko*Aoo]mqa^n]pkn) jkq)oalkoorahcn]]onalnk`qkp_je_]`]ok^n]o`a]npa*Are`ajpaiajpa(`ev>ajf]iej( ]]npaoailnabkenalnk`qprah(^]op]j`kran`eo_lqhkoeiep]j`kkoiaopnao*=mqaopk(lkn) p]jpk(jkaopjkb]pk`]nalnk`qk(aoeij]jkr]ik`]he`]`a`analnk`qven6]nalnk`q) kp _je_](mqalaniepa]ateopj_e]`kk^fapk]npope_kaioneaamqa(ai_anpko_]oko( _kikj]bkpkcn]Ú](jk`eo_kajk_ejai](pknj]eilkoorah`eopejcqenajpnakknecej]ha] _ le](eopk(`aob]v]oln lne]oe`ae]o`aknecej]ha_ le]* ?kjpejq]kÚh okbk6 %+++&^obmolar lq`kf`^a^l_o^ab^oqbobmobpbkq^rjmol`bpplklsl)nrbpbsbj abpbkslisbkalk^efpqof^fkqbojfqbkqbjbkqb^qo^spabp^iqlppbm^o^alpmloilkdlpfk* qbos^ilp)j^p`ljfkqbkpfa^ab`obp`bkqb+@lj^ufildo^sro^)labpbkelqloklr*pbmbi^ mofjbfo^sbwqb`kf`^jbkqbobmolarqsbi)jrfql^kqbpnrb^fjmobkp^mobpq^ppbljbpjl pbosf lm^o^^m^i^so^bp`ofq^+ @lkeb`bjlp^pdfd^kqbp`^pqo^kpcloj^ bpmolsl`^a^pmbi^fjmobkp^Î^obmol* ar lq`kf`^a^bp`ofq^+J^p^fjmobkp^obmobpbkq^^mbk^prj`^plbpmb`f^i)bj_lo^ abfjmloq k`f^ab`fpfs^)abrjmol`bpplefpqof`lj^fp^jmil+Èufildo^sro^)k^Fa^ab Jaf^)pbdrbj*pb^bpq^jm^bj`e^m^ab`l_obb^dr^*cloqb)^ppfj`ljl^ifqldo^Û^) klfk`flalp`rilUFU+ @lj^ifqldo^Û^)^q`kf`^abobmolar l^qfkdbrj^bq^m^bppbk`f^ijbkqbkls^+ Bppbmol`bafjbkqljrfqlj^fpmob`fpl)nrbafpqfkdrb^qo^kp`of lalabpbkelkrj^ mbao^abpr^fk`fplpl_obrj_il`labj^abfo^lrrj^mo^k`e^ab`l_ob)mbojfqfr p ^oqbp doÛ`^p mbi^ mofjbfo^ sbw `lil`^o kl jbo`^al pr^p molar bp kl pljbkqb bj j^pp^)`ljlg^`lkqb`f^^kqbp)j^pq^j_jk^cloj^ab`of^ bppbjmobkls^p+ Abpp^cloj^)^p^oqbpdoÛ`^p^anrfofo^jlpjbflpabfirpqo^o^sfa^`lqfaf^k^+Do^* ^p ifqldo^Û^bi^p`ljb ^o^j^pfqr^o*pbkljbpjlksbinrb^fjmobkp^+J^p^ifql* do^Û^^fka^bpq^s^bjpbrpmofjoaflpnr^kalclfriqo^m^pp^a^mbi^clqldo^Û^+ Mbi^mofjbfo^sbwklmol`bpplabobmolar la^fj^dbj)^jlclfif_bo^a^a^p obpmlkp^_fifa^abp^oqpqf`^pj^fpfjmloq^kqbp)nrb^dlo^`^_f^jrkf`^jbkqb^lliel+ @ljllliel^mobbkabj^fpabmobpp^alnrb^jlabpbke^)lmol`bpplabobmolar l a^pfj^dbkpbumbofjbkqlrq^i^`bibo^ lnrb`ljb lr^pfqr^o*pbkljbpjlksbinrb ^m^i^so^lo^i+ Pblglok^ifirpqo^albpq^s^`lkqfalsfoqr^ijbkqbk^ifqldo^Û^)l`fkbj^c^i^albp* q^s^sfoqr^ijbkqb`lkqfalk^clqldo^Û^+>obmolar lq`kf`^alpljfkf`flr*pbklÛj alp`rilm^pp^alXp`rilUFUZ+@ljbi^)^qfkdfr*pbq^im^aolabnr^ifa^abnrbbi^kl pljbkqbmlaf^qo^kpcloj^objpbrpl_gbqlp^qlq^ifa^aba^pl_o^pab^oqbqo^af`flk^fp) pr_jbqbkal*^p^qo^kpcloj^ bpmolcrka^p)`ljl`lknrfpq^om^o^pfrjird^omomofl bkqoblpmol`bafjbkqlp^oqpqf`lp+
/04
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
@aoo]i]jaen](lknp]jpk(]`aopnqek`]]qn]aoplnaÚcqn]`]j]ln lne]aooj_e]`] k^n]`a]npa_kik]hcklkoorahlknmqapk`]k^n]`a]npalkooqe`keor]hknao6kab`riqlakab bumlpf l(aaopahpeikoqo_ep]]nalnk`qpe^ehe`]`a(_qf]atpajok(mq]jpe`]`aamq]he`]`a `alaj`ai`]o_kj`e aoo _ek)deop ne_]omqa]atecenaia]lkooe^ehep]nai* >ajf]iej`ev]ej`]6 Pbof^mlppsbiob`lkpqfqrfo^efpqof^a^^oqb^m^oqfoal`lkcolkqlabalfpmlilp)kl fkqboflo a^ momof^ l_o^ ab ^oqb) b sbo l `lkqb al abpp^ efpqof^ k^ s^of^ l al mbpl `lkcbofalpbg^^rjmlil)pbg^^lrqol+Lpalfpmlilpplls^iloab`riqla^l_o^bpbr s^iloabbumlpf l+>obmolar l^oqpqf`^`ljb ^`ljfj^dbkp^pbosf la^j^df^+L nrbfjmloq^)kbpp^pfj^dbkp)nrbbufpq^j)bklnrbpbg^jsfpq^p+L^i`b)`lmf^almbil eljbj m^ibliqf`l k^p m^obabp ab pr^ `^sbok^) rj fkpqorjbkql ab j^df^) p l`^* pflk^ijbkqbbumlpql^lplielpalplrqolpeljbkp7kljufjl)bibabsbpbosfpqlmbilp bpmofqlp+ L s^ilo ab `riql) `ljl q^i) nr^pb l_ofd^ ^ j^kqbo pb`obq^p ^p l_o^p ab ^oqb7 `boq^pbpqqr^pafsfk^ppljbkqbpl^`bppsbfp^lprjlp^`boalqb)k^_ahh])`boq^pj^al* k^pmboj^kb`bj`l_boq^pnr^pbl^klfkqbfol)`boq^pbp`riqro^pbj`^qbao^fpa^Fa^ab Jaf^plfksfpsbfp)alplil)m^o^ll_pbos^alo+ Èjbafa^nrb^pl_o^pab^oqbpbbj^k`fm^jalpbrrplofqr^i)^rjbkq^j^pl`^* pfbpm^o^nrbpbg^jbumlpq^p+>sfpf_fifa^ababrj_rpql)nrbmlabpboabpil`^alabrj ird^om^o^lrqol)j^flonrb^abrj^bpqqr^afsfk^)nrbqbjpr^pbabÛu^klfkqboflo ab rj qbjmil+ > sfpf_fifa^ab ab rj nr^aol j^flo nrb ^ ab rj jlp^f`l lr ab rj ^cobp`l)nrblmob`babo^j+Bpb^sfpf_fifa^ababrj^jfpp^)mlopr^momof^k^qrobw^) klbo^q^isbwjbklonrb^abrj^pfkclkf^)bpq^prodfrkrjjljbkqlbjnrbpr^sf* pf_fifa^abmoljbqf^pboj^flonrb^a^jfpp^+>sfpf_fifa^ababrj^l_o^ab^oqb`obp`br bjq^ibp`^i^)`ljlpsoflpjqlalpabpr^obmolarqf_fifa^abq`kf`^)nrb^jra^k ^ abkc^pbabrjmlilm^o^lrqol`loobpmlkab^rj^jra^k ^nr^ifq^qfs^`ljm^osbi nrbl`loobrk^Mo*Efpqof^+@ljbcbfql)^ppfj`ljlk^Mo*Efpqof^^mobmlkabo k`f^ ^_plirq^als^iloab`riql`lkcbofal l_o^ibslr*^^pbo`lk`b_fa^bjmofjbfolird^o `ljlfkpqorjbkqljdf`l)bpj^fpq^oab`ljll_o^ab^oqb)aljbpjljlal^mob* mlkabo k`f^^_plirq^`lkcbofa^elgb^pbrs^iloabbumlpf l^qof_rf*iebcrk bpfkqbf* o^jbkqbkls^p)bkqob^pnr^fp^Ï^oqpqf`^Ð)^ kf`^abnrbqbjlp`lkp`fk`f^)bnrbq^isbw pbobsbibcrqro^jbkqb`ljlpb`rkaof^+
=npaabehkokbe]
@
POmTICAßOßVOCfBULOßß POmTICAßmßAßTRADUljOßß PARAßPOIESIS ßPORTANTO ßß PARAß±FABRICAljO²
/05
klkjpk`areop]Úhko Ú_k(lk`aikob]h]nai`keocn]j`aoikiajpko`apaknev]k`] ]npa*Jklneiaenk(ej]qcqn]`klknLh]pka=neop pahao(]ÚhkokÚ]pn]p]]o]npao`klkjpk `areop]`]lk pe_]7jkoacqj`k(]l]npen`ko_qhkTREEE(`klkjpk`areop]`]aop pe_]* >oqbmlqf`^kjkia`aqi]k^n]]neopkphe_]ok^na]o]npao`]l]h]rn]b]h]`]aao_ne) p](`k_]jpka`]`]j](eopk(ok^na]lkaoe]akpa]pnk$pn]c`e]a_ki`e]%*=]npalkpe_] aopq`]]ok^n]o`a]npa_kikb]^ne_]k`aoanao(] aoacaopko^oqfÛ`f^fp(eopk(lnk`qve`ko lahko]npÚ_aokq]npeop]o*Kqoaf](]boe_]aopq`]kooanaoa]o] aolnk`qve`kolah]j]pqna) v]7]lkpe_](kob]^ne_]`kolahkooanaodqi]jko* =k^n]`a]npalajo]`]`klkjpk`areop]`aoq]_kjbknie`]`a]jkni]o(nacn]oalnk) _a`eiajpko`a_kjopnqk_kikqib]vannacn]`kakn`aj]`k7lkneookkopn]p]`kook^na]o ]npaolkpe_]o(ao_nepko`ao`a]]jpecqe`]`a]p]ik`anje`]`a(lkooqaiqi_]npanmobp`of* qfslkqkloj^qfsl(eopk(kbana_ai]ojkni]o_knnap]oa]`amq]`]omqa_]`]qi]`]o]npao `araoacqenl]n]^aina]hev]noaqÚi(^ai_kik]ojkni]okqnacn]omqakaola_p]`kn`ara oacqenl]n]]r]he]n]mq]he`]`a`]ok^n]o*Ok^aooa]ola_pk(]]npalkpe_]qi]mob`bmqfs^( eopk(]]lnaoajp]k`alna_aepkol]n]kb]vanakfqhc]n]ok^n]o* =hi`eook(_kik]k^n]`a]npalajo]`]aioq]`alaj`j_e]_ki]pe_](]lkhpe_] a]iap]boe_](eopk(_ki]oe`ae]o`a^ai$ej`ere`q]ha_khaperk%a`aran`]`a(oaqr]hkn p]i^i`apaniej]`klah]mq]he`]`akq`ecje`]`a`kk^fapkkq`kpai]]^kn`]`klkn ah]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(kopn]p]`ko`a]npalkpe_]`eopejcqaik^fapkoa]ooqjpkojk^nao
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
$rkhp]`kol]n]k`erejk(l]n]k^aial]n]kran`]`aenk%ak^fapkokq]ooqjpkoreo(^]etkoa iaomqejdko$rkhp]`kol]n]]olamqajav]oaiaomqejd]ne]o`ajkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j]%afqhc] ]ok^n]o`a]npa_kiaooao_nepneko* Aioaqqokeje_e]h(]aoppe_]oanabane]]kaopq`k`]ok^n]o`a]npaajmq]jpk_ne] ao `]oajoe^ehe`]`a$eopk(`]oatlanej_e]o`ko_ej_koajpe`koa`kooajpeiajpko_]qo]`kolkn ah]o%(paj`k_kikÚj]he`]`ak^ahk*Lkq_k]lkq_k(oq^opepqeq]jkk`a]npalkpe_]al]o) okq]`aoecj]npk`]ejraopec]kÚhko Ú_]mqapejd]lknk^fapk]o]npaokqqi]]npa*@kh]`k `k]npeop]a`]k^n](]aoppe_]^qo_]_kilnaaj`an_kikoa`]na]hev]k`]^ahav]7`kh]`k `kaola_p]`knana_alpkn(^qo_]ejpanlnap]n]na]kk^n]`a]npaok^]bkni]`kfqvk`a ckopkkq`k^kickopk* ?kikoaqjkiaej`e_](]aoppe_]oak_ql]lnabanaj_e]hiajpa_ki]atlnaook`]oaj) oe^ehe`]`aa`]b]jp]oe]`k]npeop]a_kikoajpeiajpklnk`qve`klah]k^n]ok^nakaola_p]) `knkqna_alpkn* ?kiajp]j`kkoqnceiajpk`]aoppe_]j]ik`anje`]`a(kÚh okbkbn]j_oHq_Bannu(jk hernkEljl^bpqebqf`rpÎ>fksbk laldlpqlk^bo^abjl`oqf`^(ao_nara6
ESTmTICAßESTmTICAßmßAßTRA DUljOßDAßPALAVRAßGREGAß AISTHETIKm ßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±CONHECIMENTOßSENSORIAL² ß ±EXPERIoNCIAßSENSqVEL² ß ±SENSIBILIDADE²ß&OIßEM PREGADAßPELAßPRIMEIRAßVEZß PARAßREFERIR SEßgSßARTESß PELOßALEMjOß"AUMGARTEN ß PORßVOLTAßDEß ßPORTANTOß EMßPLENAßMODERNIDADEß OU ßCOMOßVIMOSßNOSßCAPq TULOSßSOBREßOSßPERqODOSßDAß FILOSOFIAßEßSOBREßAßRAZjO ß NAßmPOCAßDOßRACIONALIS MOßEßDAßAFIRMAljOßDAß AUTONOMIAßDOßSUJEITOßDOß CONHECIMENTO
&RANCOISß$URAND3TRINGER'ETTYß)MAGES
Lk^p`fjbkqla^bpqqf`^`ljlafp`fmifk^ÛilpÛ`^bpqfkafpplirsbijbkqbifd^al jrq^ lo^af`^inrbfkqbosjk^obmobpbkq^ lal_bilnr^kalbpqbmbkp^albj qbojlpabdlpql)mloq^kql)^m^oqfoalnrbkleljbjfoildl^m^ob`bo`ljl^bppk`f^ jbpj^ a^ pr_gbqfsfa^ab) `ljl l j^fp pr_gbqfsl al prgbfql+ @lj l `lk`bfql ab dlpql) bcbqfs^jbkqb)l_bilifd^alqlfkqfj^jbkqb pr_gbqfsfa^aberj^k^nrbpbabÛkb)kl ifjfqb)mbilmo^wbonrbmolmlo`flk^)mbi^ppbkp^ bplrmbilppbkqfjbkqlpnrbprp`fq^bj kp%+++&+@ljlk^p`fjbkqlaldlpql)^^kqfd^ÛilplÛ^a^^oqbabsb)mloq^kql)`baboird^o ^rj^qblof^a^pbkpf_fifa^ab+ =jkk`aaoppe_](mq]j`kbkniqh]`]a`aoajrkhre`]jkoo_qhkoTREEEaTET(_kj_a^e] ]o]npao_kik^ah]o)]npaoalnaooqlqjd]mqa6 -*
]]npaqi]]pere`]`adqi]j]^rqklj^(eopk(jkaop]oanrek`]nahecekjai`] lkhpe_](i]olkooqeÚj]he`]`aln lne]7
.*
]]npalnk`qpk`]atlanej_e]oajokne]hkqlan_alper]$oajoe^ehe`]`a%(`]ei]cej]k a`]ejolen]k`k]npeop]_kik_ne]`kn]qpjkikkqherna*Kqoaf](]oq^fapere`]`a`k ]npeop]kqoq]ejolen]kj^fpfjmloq^kqb`kmqalna_aepko(jkni]oanacn]o`a_kjo) pnqk`aqi]k^n]7
/*
]Új]he`]`a`]]npaabpfkqbobpp^a^$jkqpehepne]%kq`lkqbjmi^qfs^*Aikqpn]ol]h]) rn]o(]k^n]`a]npajkaop]oanrek`k_qhpk(jai`]lkhpe_](jai`]lnpe_]ikn]h `]orenpq`ao(]ooei_kikjkaop`aopej]`]]lnk`qvenk^fapko`aqoka`a_kjoqik(a oei]lnkle_e]n]`lkqbjmi^ la^_bibw^7
0*
]_kjpailh]k(`kh]`k`k]npeop](]^qo_]`k^ahk$ajk`kpehjai`k]cn]`rah%a( `kh]`k`kl^he_k(]]r]he]kkqkfqhc]iajpk`kr]hkn`a^ahav]]pejce`klah]k^n] lkniaek`kgrwlabdlpql7
1*
k^ahkafcbobkqb`k^kia`kran`]`aenk*K^aik^fapk`]pe_]7]ran`]`a(k^fapk`] _ej_e]a`]iap]boe_]7a]^ahav](kk^fapkln lnek`]aoppe_]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(_kj) pn]]pn]`ek]neopkphe_]$mqa`]r]qi]Új]he`]`aikn]hok^n]o`a]npa(]npe_qh]j) `k)]oe`ae]`k^aia`]renpq`a%a_kjpn]]pn]`eklh]pje_]$mqa`]r]qi]Új]he`]`a _kcjeper]o]npao(]npe_qh]j`k)]oe`ae]`]ran`]`a%(]aoppe_]]Úni]]^rqlkljf^a^p ^oqbplah]`eopejkajpna^ahav](^kj`]`aaran`]`a7
2*
_kik]k^n]`a]npaj]o_a`]oajoe^ehe`]`aejolen]`]`k]npeop]j]_kj`ek`aoq^fapere) `]`a_ne]`kn]aherna(oaqr]hknaj_kjpn])oajko j]bkn]`aoq]^ahav](i]op]i^i aioq]lofdfk^ifa^ab*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(k]npeop]ran`]`aenkjk]mqahamqaoacqana) cn]okqlna_aepkoÚt]`kolah]pn]`ek`aoaqkb_ek(jai]mqahamqapn]`qvail]h]rn]o( _knao(bkni]o(caopko(ikreiajpko(rkhqiao(i]oo]o(pn]ko]hckfateopajpaj]j]pqnav] kqaioq]ok_ea`]`a(i]o]mqahamqa_]l]v`aqi]`of^ lej`ep]kqknecej]h*
,UCß&ERRYß ßFILvSOFOß FRANCoSßEßEX MINISTROßDAß %DUCAljOßDAß&RANlAßENTREß ßEß ßFICOUßBASTAN TEßCONHECIDOßEMßßPORß TERßBANIDOßOßVmUßISLhMICOß DASßESCOLASßFRANCESAS
/1,
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
Kfqvkaoppe_kkqfqvk`ackopk
0ABLOß0ICASSO'ALERIAß&UJI ß 4vQUIO ß*APjO
=qpknnapn]pk`abnajpa l]n]]iknpa$-53.%( k^n]`aL]^hkLe_]ook*
/1-
=koqncen(reikomqa]aoppe_]]Únikq]`ebanaj]ajpnak^ahkakran`]`aenk*Eookoec) jeÚ_]mqakfqvkaoppe_kakfqvk_eajpÚ_kaiap]boe_kok`ebanajpao*@ab]pk(kran`]`aenk kmqa_kjda_e`klahkejpaha_pklkniaek`a`aikjopn] aoalnkr]o(]omq]eolaniepai( ]pn]ro`a_kj_aepko`kajpaj`eiajpkahaeoh ce_]o(ejbanenqil]npe_qh]n`aqiqjerano]h $`a`qk%kqejbanenqiqjerano]h`arnekol]npe_qh]nao$ej`qk%*K^ahk(]k_kjpnnek(pai ]la_qhe]ne`]`a`alkooqeneia`e]p]iajpa$oai`a`qkaoaiej`qk%qir]hknqjerano]h( ai^kn]]k^n]`a]npaoaf]aooaj_e]hiajpal]npe_qh]n* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]k^n]`a]npa(aioq]l]npe_qh]ne) `]`aaoejcqh]ne`]`aje_](kbana_a]hckqjerano]h$]^ahav]% oai ja_aooe`]`a `a `aikjopn] ao( lnkr]o( ejbanj_e]o a _kj_aepko*Mq]j`khaekqilkai](ao_qpkqi]okj]p]kq k^oanrkqimq]`nk(lkook`evan(oailna_eo]n`a_kj_aepko jai`alnkr]oh ce_]o(mqaok^ahkokqmqa]heaop^^aha) v](ajkoeilhaoiajpa_keo]o^ah]o*=^ahav](aioaqoaj) pe`kqjerano]haapanjk(aj_kjpn])oalknejpaenkjqi]k^n] oejcqh]nmqa(aioeiaoi](]hckje_kaej_kil]nrah* = la_qhe]ne`]`a `k fqvk `a ckopk aop ai lnkbanen qifqhc]iajpk`ar]hknqjerano]hpaj`k_kikk^fapk]hck oejcqh]nal]npe_qh]n* K pn]p]iajpk i]eo eilknp]jpa `k fqvk `a ckopk bke baepklknG]jpjqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]@oqf`^a^c^`ria^abab grid^o*Jaooaaopq`k(kÚh okbk_kia]`eo_qpej`kklnk^ha) i]lkopklahkckopk(eopk(_kikÎ_]`]qipaioaqckopkÏ aÎckopkjkoa`eo_qpaÏ(]pkp]hoq^fapere`]`a`kckopkjk lk`ane]oanren`a_nepnekl]n]kfqhc]iajpk`]ok^n]o`a ]npa(lkeop]jpkkckopk`k]npeop]ej`ere`q]haej_kil]) nrah_kikkockopko`kl^he_kokej`ere`q]eoaej_ki) l]nraeo* ?kik( lknp]jpk( b]h]n jk fqvk `a ckopk _kik ]r]he]`kn`]ok^n]o`a]npa;Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(_kik`]n qjerano]he`]`a]aooafqvk;Ai]eo6_kik`]n)hdaqjerano]) he`]`aoaina_knnan]kolnk_a`eiajpkoh ce_koa_eajpÚ_ko `a`aikjopn] aoalnkr]o; G]jpejpnk`qvqi]itei]6Îlkoorah`eo_qpenkckopkÏ*Qi]`eo_qook`ebanajpa`a qi]`eolqp]*BehkokÚ_]iajpa(qi]`eolqp]qi]^]p]hd]`a]ncqiajpkomqaatecailnk) r]o(`aikjopn] aoaare`j_e]o(]Úi`amqaqi]klejekkqqi]e`ae]lnar]ha]ok^na]o mqahdaok_kjpnne]o*Qi]`eo_qookqilnk_aook`a]Új]iajpk`]okleje ao_qf]Új]) he`]`a_dac]n]qi]_kn`kajpna]ol]npao*=ooei(jkoa`eolqp]ok^nak^ahk(i]olk`a)oa `eo_qpe)hk*Aoo]`eo_qookqi]naÛatk_ki]Új]he`]`a`aoa_dac]n]qifqvkaoppe_k `ljm^oqfie^almloqlalp* Lknmqa]naÛatklkoorah;Lknmqa]k^n]`a]npa]hck_kiqje_rahÍ]heo(o ateopa l]n]_kiqje_]n)oa(kbana_aj`k)oaoajoe^ehe`]`a`kona_alpknao*Oak]npeop]l]npa(aolkjp]) ja]iajpa(`]_kiqje_]^ehe`]`a`]k^n](lknmqa(aioaqjpeik(na_kjda_amqaoajpeiaj) pko(e`ae]oakleje aook_kil]npehdraeo*=atlanej_e]aoppe_]Íp]jpk`kh]`k`k]npeop] _kik`kh]`k`kl^he_kÍ_kiqje_rahal]npehdrah* G]jplk`an(ajpk(ikopn]nmqa]atlanej_e]aoppe_](]kiaoikpailk(qi]atla) nej_e]ej`ere`q]hkql]npe_qh]n(i]omqa(lknoan`aolanp]`]ai_]`]qi`aj olah]^ahav]( p]i^iaopnah]_ekj]`]]e`ae]oqjerano]eo`]n]vk$mqa]iaoi]aipk`koj o%*=ooei _kikaol]kapailkok]obkni]oqjerano]eo`]oajoe^ehe`]`aa]o_]packne]oako_kj_aepko okkoqjerano]eo`kajpaj`eiajpk(]^ahav]qi]e`ae]qjerano]h`]n]vk*Oaq_kjpa`ka oq]bkni]lk`air]ne]noacqj`k]o_en_qjop j_e]odeop ne_]oaoacqj`k]ejolen]kaoaj) oe^ehe`]`aoq^faper]o`k]npeop](i]okpbkqfjbkqlal_bil(bqj`]iajpk`kfqvk`ackopk( qjerano]hlknmqa]^ahav]qi]e`ae]`]n]vk*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=]npa_kikpn]^]hdk_ne]`kn
Ç
,OTHARß7OLLEH!RQUIVOßDAß%DITORA
ia`e`]mqaoa`aoajrkhra]ok_ea`]`aej`qopne]h$kq]ok_ea`]`a`kpn]^]hdk%aok) ^napq`kia`e`]mqaklajo]iajpk`aaomqan`]oq^hejd]]`apaniej]kdeop ne_] $a_kjie_](ok_e]halkhpe_]%`apk`]o]o]pere`]`aodqi]j]o(`ao`akpn]^]hdk]p ]o]npao(]ÚhkokÚ]r]e`aet]j`k`ah]`k]ei]cai`k]npeop]_kikcjek_ne]`knejolen]`k aknecej]ha]`]k^n]`a]npa_kikna]hev]k`koajpeiajpk`k^ahk_qf]]r]he]kbaep] lahkfqvk`ackopk$]ej`]mqaaoo]o`q]oei]cajopajd]ilani]ja_e`kj]ok_ea`]`a_kik ]i]jaen]lah]mq]h(_kiqiajpa(]olaook]o_kj_a^ai]]npa%* @ab]pk(]o]npao`aet]n]i`aoanlajo]`]olah]ÚhkokÚ]alah]_npe_]`a]npaat_hqoer]) iajpa`klkjpk`areop]`]lnk`qka_kjpailh]k`aoejpanaoo]`]o`]^ahav]l]n]oanai reop]o`akqpn]olanola_per]o(p]eo_kikbumobpplabbjl bpbabpbglp(fkqbomobq^ lb`oqf`^ a^ob^ifa^abpl`f^i(^qfsfa^abfksbkqlo^abmol`bafjbkqlpfkafqlpm^o^^`lkpqor labl_gb* qlp^oqpqf`lp(ap_*Aoo]iq`]j]bav_kimqa]oe`ae]o`a^kickopka`a^ahav]lan`aooaik mofsfidflbpqqf`lamqa]aoppe_]oa]lnktei]ooa_]`]ravi]eo`]e`ae]`alkpe_](lknp]jpk( `]]npa_kikqo^_^ielajk_kik_kjpailh]kaoajoe^ehe`]`a(b]jp]oe]aehqok*Are`aj) paiajpa(]jkr]aoppe_]jknapki]]lkpe_]_kiklna_alper]kq_kik]lnaoajp]k`a lna_aepko(nacn]oajkni]o`kb]van]npope_k(aoei]e`ae]`]k^n]`a]npa_kikqib]van* Pnookkopai]olnej_el]eoejraopec]`kolah]ÚhkokÚ]`]]npa6]nah]kajpna^oqbb k^qrobw^(ajpna^oqbbp^_bo(a^pÛk^ifa^abpa^^oqb*
Nah]kajpna]npaaj]pqnav] -AGRITTE߯ ßß PINTORßSURREALISTAßBELGA
Pn]e k`]oei]cajo( k^n]`a-5.5`aNaj I]cneppaj]mq]hoa raaik_]_dei^ka] ejo_nekÎEopkjk qi_]_dei^kÏ* -AGRITTEß&OUNDATION
Qi]k^n]`a]npaqi^oqbc^qlaqi^oqfc`fl*=npab]pk(lknmqajkbaep]lah]]k`] j]pqnav]aoeilah]]k`ahe^an]`]`aqioandqi]jk7]npeb_ek(oaf]lknmqa]k^n]ailnac] na_qnoko_kikomq]eojko`]eilnaook`aoan]hckj]pqn]hai^kn]pajd]oe`kb]^ne_]`]( oaf] lknmqa( ]k _kjpnnek( jko har] l]n] hkjca `] j]pqnav]( l]n] qi iqj`k ejpaen]iajpa lnk`qve`klahkodqi]jko* P]hravqi`koiahdknaoatailhkol]n]_kilnaaj`anikomqa]k^n]`a]npaqi]n) pab]pkaqi]npeb_ekaj_kjpna)oajqimq]`nk`klejpknI]cneppa_kjda_e`k_kikFpqlkl rj`^`efj_l+Kmq]`nkkbana_aqikqpnkmq]`nk`ajpnk`aha(eopk(qi]pah]lejp]`]jk ejpanekn`]pah]i]pane]hiajpa`]`]*D(]ooei(qi]pah]i]pane]h(mqakoqlknpa`aqi] kqpn]pah](]lejp]`]*Jaoo]oacqj`]pah](d]nalnaoajp]kiejq_eko](at]p]a`ap]hd]`]`a qi_]_dei^k(ok^kmq]haopao_nepkÎEopkjkqi_]_dei^kÏ* K mqa k lejpkn lnapaj`a ]k jac]n mqa k _]_dei^k oaf] qi _]_dei^k; Lnapaj`a ]Úni]n mqa ÎeopkÏ( kq oaf]( ] lejpqn]( jk ] Î_keo]Ïateopajpajkiqj`k*ÎEopkÏ jk qi _]_dei^k lknmqa ] mfkqro^ ab rj `^`efj_l* Ai kq) pn]ol]h]rn]o(qi_]_dei^klejp]) `k kq qi _]_dei^k)ai)lejpqn] jk]_keo]i]pane]h_d]i]`]`^* `efj_laoei(fqop]iajpa(]lejpq) n]`aqi_]_dei^k*Lkni]eomqa k_]_dei^klejp]`koal]na]_ki qi_]_dei^ki]pane]h(]i^ko`e) banailknmqaklneiaenko ateopa ai lejpqn] kq lejp]`k* ÎEopk jk qi _]_dei^kÏ oecjeÚ_] Îkhda ] lejpqn]Ï(Îkhda k pn]^]hdk `k lej) pknÏ(Îraf]qiiqj`klejp]`kÏ*
/1.
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
=iiaoeocnac] =lneiaen]ai]eo]jpec]nah]kajpna]npaaj]pqnav]lnklkop]lah]ÚhkokÚ]bke]`] jjbpfp(l]h]rn]cnac]pn]`qve`]l]n]klknpqcqo_kikfjfq^ l6Î]]npaeiep]]j]pqnav]Ï( ao_nara=neop pahao*=k^n]`a]npanaoqhp]`]]pere`]`a`k]npeop]l]n]eiep]noanaona]eo$j]pq) n]eokqok^naj]pqn]eo%aoq]o] aolkniaek`al]h]rn]o(ikreiajpko(caopko(oajpeiajpko( okjo( _knao( bkni]o( rkhqiao( ap_*( a k r]hkn `] k^n] `a_knna `] d]^ehe`]`a `k ]npeop] l]n] aj_kjpn]ni]pane]eoabkni]o]`amq]`kol]n]k^pankabaepkeiep]perk* Mqa]jjbpfp; L]n]=neop pahao(fjfq^ojkoecjeÚ_]$_kikoecjeÚ_]r]l]n]Lh]pk%Î_kle]nÏ(i]oÎnalna) oajp]nÏ]na]he`]`alkniaek`]b]jp]oe]a`]k^a`ej_e]]nacn]oalna_aepkol]n]mqa]k^n] Ûdrob]hcqioan$j]pqn]hkqok^naj]pqn]h%(]hcqioajpeiajpkkqaikk(]hcqib]pk$]_kj) pa_e`kkqejrajp]`k%*D]nikje]alnklknk`]obkni]o(`konepiko(`]o_knao(`]ol]h]rn]o kq`kookjokbana_aikoiaekoja_aoonekol]n]mqa]Új]he`]`aoaf]]h_]j]`](abpabnrbk ]npeop]oec]]ojkni]o(]onacn]o(kolnk_a`eiajpkoalna_aepko`aoaqkb_ek* J]o]npao(eiep]n(atlhe_]=neop pahao(pfjri^o*=ooei_kikk_]]`knoeiqh]oanqi ]n^qopkkqqi]nk_d]l]n]]l]jd]n]lnao](]ooeip]i^ik]pknoeiqh]caopkoa] ao`] lanokj]cail]n]j]nn]nb]pko(atlknoajpeiajpkomqalk`aioan_kilnaaj`e`koaatlane) iajp]`kolahkl^he_k(aklejpknoeiqh]qi]_aj]kqqik^fapklkniaek`apn]koa_knao* I]o]oeiqh]ko ]npope_]oabknoajpe`]alan_a^e`]_kiknalnaoajp]j`k]hckna]h* Kiahdknatailhkl]n]_kilnaaj`anikokmqaan]]jjbpfpaj_kjpn])oaj]deop ne] `k_kj_qnokmqa]_e`]`a`a=paj]olnkikraql]n]]ao_khd]`]aoppq]`]`aqo]=paj](] oanejop]h]`]jkL]npajkj*@keoao_qhpknao]lnaoajp]n]ioq]ok^n]o*Qi]`ah]oan]qi]iq) hdanlanbaep]abke]`ien]`]lknpk`ko*=kqpn]an]qi]Úcqn]cnkpao_]6]_]^a]an]ajknia( ko^n]ko(iqepkhkjckoa]oiko(i]eknao`kmqakolo*Bkene`e_qh]nev]`]lknpk`ko*Jk ajp]jpk( mq]j`k ]o `q]o aoppq]o bkn]i _khk_]`]o jko ]hpko la`aop]eo `k L]npajkj( kj`a an]ireop]o`a^]etkl]n]_ei](raneÚ_kq)oa]hckaol]jpkok6]koanreop]`a^]etkl]n]_ei] ]aoppq]lanbaep]pknj]n])oane`_qh](]_]^a]a]oiko`a=paj]l]na_an]iiejo_qh]oa `aolnklkn_ekj]eol]n]oaq_knlk7ai_kjpn]l]npe`](]aoppq]cnkpao_]kq`abkni]`]pkn) j]n])oalanbaep](lkeo]_]^a](ko^n]koa]oikooapknj]n]ilnklkn_ekj]eo]k_knlk*= aoppq]cnkpao_]bke_kjoe`an]`]]jjbpfplanbaep](]^k]eiep]k(araj_aqk_kj_qnok*K ]npeop]jk_klekqjainalnk`qveqqi]iqhdanaoei]pfjrilr(_]h_qh]j`ki]pai]pe_]) iajpa]olnklkn aoajpna]ol]npao`aoaq_knlk(ajpnaaop]oakhk_]haimqaoane]ejop]h]`] a]i]jaen]_kikoane]reop]*
Ejolen]k_ne]`kn]
/1/
=`aÚjek]neopkphe_]`]]npa_kik]k`aeiep]n]j]pqnav]bke_kjoanr]`]`qn]jpa rejpa a pno o_qhko( kq oaf]( ]p k oqnceiajpk `k Nki]jpeoik( jk Új]h `k o_qhk TREEE a ej_ek`ko_qhkTET* =l]npen`kNki]jpeoik(]ÚhkokÚ]l]oo]]`aÚjen]k^n]`a]npa_kik_ne]koq^faper]* Ajmq]jpkj]_kj_alk]jpanekn(kq_kj_alklkpe_]$jkoajpe`k`amlfbpfp(eopk(`kb]van kq`kb]^ne_]n%(kr]hkn`]k^n]aj_kjpn]r])oaj]_knnak`k]npeop]aioacqenkolna_aepkoa j]mq]he`]`akq`ecje`]`a`kk^fapklnk`qve`k(j]_kj_alkaoppe_]kr]hkn_khk_]`kj] Úcqn]`k]npeop]_kikcjekaei]cej]k_ne]`kn]*Aihqc]n`aeiep]k(l]oo])oa]b]h]nai fkpmfo^ l* K]npeop]reopk_kikqiÎaqÏ(eopk(_kikejpanekne`]`aaoq^fapere`]`aaola_e]eomqa j]o_ai_ki]`eolkoekatpn]kn`ejne]l]n]na_a^anqi]aol_ea`aoklnkok^naj]pqn]h mqakeilaha]_ne]n]k^n]*Fkpmfo^ lejolen]nk]nkqkoklnkok^naj]pqn]hmqaeilnacj]k aolnepk`k]npeop](kneajp]oq]b]jp]oe]aoq]lan_alk$kqoajoe^ehe`]`a%akb]vatlen]naooa oklnkj]bkni]`aqi]k^n]`a]npa*Aop](lknp]jpk(`araatlneienoajpeiajpkoaaik ao iqepki]eo`kmqaÚcqn]nkqnalnaoajp]n]na]he`]`a*=k^n]`a]npa]atpaneknev]k`ko oajpeiajpkoejpaneknao`kcjekat_al_ekj]h*
=ckn]]]npajkeiep]jainalnk`qv]j]pqnav](i]oif_boq^*pbabi^(_ne]j`kqi]na]) he`]`a lqn]iajpa dqi]j] a aolenepq]h6 lah] ]pere`]`a herna `k ]npeop]( eopk ( oq] b]jp]oe] _ne]`kn](kodkiajooaecq]h]i]k_ne]`kn]`a@aqo* Aoo]_kj_alk`]]npa_kikejolen]ka_kik_ne]kaolenepq]hmqahe^an]kdkiai `klaok`]j]pqnav]_kjpailkn ja](j]ÚhkokÚ](]kikiajpkaimqaoa`]oal]n]k ajpnadkiaiaj]pqnav]_kikj]o_eiajpk`]e`ae]`a_qhpqn]*(lknp]jpk(_kjpailkn ja] e`ae]g]jpe]j]`a`ebanaj]ajpnaknaejkj]pqn]h`]_]qo]he`]`aja_aoone]aknaejkdq) i]jk`]he^an`]`aa`koÚjoae`ae]dacahe]j]`kAolnepk_kik_qhpqn]adeop ne](_kik ejpanekne`]`aaiklkoekatpanekne`]`aa_]qo]he`]`aja_aoone]`]j]pqnav]* P]i^i Jeapvo_da oq^hejd] k _]npan oq^faperk( at_al_ekj]h( `k ]npeop] _kik cjek _ne]`kna]Úni]k_]npanh`e_k`]o]npao*L]n]aooaÚh okbk(]]npafkck(he^an`]`a_ne]`kn]( ai^ne]cqava`ahnek(bkn]]Úni]per]`]re`]6Îqiaop]`k`areckn]jei]hÏ(Îqi]at]hp]k `koajpeiajpk`]re`]aqiaopeiqh]jpa`]re`]Ï*
/MIKRON0HOTORESEARCHERS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
.IETZSCHE߯ ß FILvSOFOßALEMjOßCUJAßOBRA ß DEßCARfTERßASSISTEMfTICOßEß FRAGMENTfRIO ßmßCONSIDERA DAßUMAßDASßMAISßORIGINAISß DAßHISTvRIAßDOßPENSAMEN TOßCONTEMPORhNEO
Kpn]^]hdkatlnaooerk = pan_aen] i]jaen] `a _kj_a^an ] nah]k ajpna ]npa a j]pqnav] jkoo] _kjpailkn ) ja]6_kj_a^a]]npa_kikpn]^]hdk`]atlnaooka_kjopnqk*=k^n]`a]npajklqn] _ne]pere`]`aaolenepq]haolkjp ja]aherna(i]oqiqo^_^iell]n]]atlnaook`aqioajpe`k jkrk(ao_kj`e`kjkiqj`k(aqimol`bpplab`lkpqor l`kk^fapk]npope_k(aimqak]npeop] _kh]^kn]_ki]j]pqnav]kqhqp]_kiah]a_kjpn]ah](oal]n])oa`ah]kqrkhp]]ah](raj_a] naoeopj_e]`ah]kq`k^n])oaoatecj_e]o`ah]*=]npapn]^]hdk`]atlnaookmqa_kjopn e qioajpe`kjkrk$]k^n]%akejopepqe_kikl]npa`]_qhpqn]* K]npeop]jkqicjekokhepnekaat_al_ekj]h(i]oqioanok_e]hmqa^qo_]atlneien oaqik`k`aaop]njkiqj`kj]_kil]jde]`kokqpnkooanaodqi]jko(jqiai^]pa_kj) pjqk_ki]j]pqnav](_ki]ok_ea`]`aa_kjoeckiaoik*]hcqimqa(]hi`arkhp]n)oa l]n]oeiaoikl]n]_kilnaaj`an)oalkniaek`]k^n]mqaatlneiaoaqpn]^]hdk`a_ki) lnaajok(p]i^inaÛapaok^na]ok_ea`]`a(alkniaek`]k^n]rkhp])oal]n]kok_e]h(oaf] l]n]_nepe_)hk(oaf]l]n]]Úni)hk(oaf]l]n]oqlan)hk*Iaoikmq]j`kkln lnek]npeop]oa r_kikqioanokhepnekaeokh]`k(mqa(jk`evan`klejpknG]j`eojgu(lna_eo]Îeokh]n)oaai oeiaoikÏ(oq]k^n]jkatlneiakeokh]iajpkaoei]i]jaen]_kik(rkhp]j`k)oal]n]oe iaoik(aj_kjpn]ko_]iejdkol]n]atlneien]na]he`]`a* Jaoo]_kj_alk(oq^hejd])oak_]npan`]k^n]`a]npa_kikÛ` l*Aop]l]h]rn]rai`a qiran^kh]pejk(Ûkdbob(mqaoecjeÚ_]Îao_qhlenÏ(Îlejp]nÏ(Î_kilknqi]k^n]Ï(Înalnaoajp]nÏ( Î]nnqi]nkq]nn]jf]n]o_keo]oÏ(Îei]cej]nÏ(Îi]mqej]nÏ(Îbknf]nÏ7a(lknatpajok(Î`eob]n]nÏ( Î`eooeiqh]nÏ(Îaj_k^nenÏaÎÚjcenÏ*?kikoak^oanr](koajpe`klneiaenk`aoo]l]h]rn]aop`e) nap]iajpanabane`ko]npao6aop]ookqiÛkdfjbkql(jkjkoajpe`k`aqi]iajpen]kq`a qi]ehqok(aoeijkoajpe`k`akbana_anqi]kqpn]na]he`]`a(ejateopajpajkiqj`k`]`k( _kikqi]aoppq](qimq]`nkkqqilkai]*_kiaooaoajpe`k`]Ú_kmqaklkap]Ban) j]j`kLaook]ao_narakob]ikokoranokoaimqa`aÚjakmqaqilkap]6 Lmlbq^rjÛkdfalo Cfkdbql`ljmibq^jbkqb Nrb`ebd^^Ûkdfonrbalo >alonrbabsbo^ppbkqb+ Mqajko`evaiaooaoranoko;Ailneiaenkhqc]n(_kikjklkai]`aFknca`aHei]ok^na kj]`]`kn(Banj]j`kLaook]fkc]_ki]l]h]rn]ÎÚjce`knÏ6klkap]qiÚjce`knlknmqaÎÚj) ca`knÏ*Lkni(lnkooacqaklkai](kmqaklkap]Újca;ÎBejcamqa`knÏ(eopk(jkoajpe`k `aÛkdbob(_kil aqilkai](_kjopn eqi]k^n](]nn]jf]]ol]h]rn]ol]n]`evan]`kn*AÎÚj) ca_kilhap]iajpaÏ(eopk(pn]joÚcqn]]`knailkai]*I]okmqaaoo]`knmqaaha_kjopn e ail]h]rn]oj]bkni]`alkai];Jkqi]iajpen](lkeo]`knÚjce`]$kqoaf](_kjopnq`] _kikk^n]%]`knmqaÎ`aran]ooajpaÏ(eopk(mqaoajpa`aran`]`a(na]hiajpa*
/10
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
Nah]kajpna]npaao]^an @q]ocn]j`ao_kj_al aolan_knnai]deop ne]`]onah] aoajpna]]npaako]^an(]i^]o eje_e]`]oj]Cn_e]_kiLh]pka=neop pahao* = _kj_alk lh]pje_]( mqa okbnan ]hpan] ao jk _qnok `] deop ne] ok_ek_qhpqn]h `k k_e`ajpaaqnklaq(_kjoe`an]]]nparj^cloj^al`lkeb`fjbkqlerj^kla(lknp]jpk(nah]) _ekj]`]_ki]ran`]`a*=]neopkphe_](mqap]i^iokbnaniq`]j]ojk_knnan`]deop ne] k_e`ajp]h(pki]]]npa_kik^qfsfa^abmoqf`^erj^k^* Hai^naikomqaLh]pkjk`eopejcqen]ajpna_ej_e]+ÚhkokÚ]a]npaoamqa`ebanaj_e]n] ]o]npaokqp_je_]oaigraf`^qfs^paafpmlpfqfs^p(eopk(]mqah]o_qf]p]nab]paniej]jk_k) jda_eiajpka]mqah]omqa(ai^kn]oaf]i_kjda_eiajpko(p]i^ikneajp]i]na]hev]k `aqi]]k$_kikk_]ok`]ia`e_ej](`]lkhpe_](`]pe_](ap_*%*=aoo]o`q]obkni]o`a ]npa k Úh okbk _kjpn]l a ]mqah]o ]npao mqa _d]i] `a fjfq^qfs^p6 lkaoe]( pa]pnk( lejpqn]( ao_qhpqn](_qhejne](nap ne_]*Aoo]o]npao$mqa(_kiat_ak`]_qhejne](enkoapn]jobkni]n j]o^ah]o)]npao%oepq]i)oajklh]jki]eo^]etk`k_kjda_eiajpk* @ab]pk(l]n]Lh]pk(]o]npaoeiep]per]ojkok]mqah]omqa(_kikl]n]=neop pahao(oe) iqh]ianalnaoajp]i]na]he`]`a(lkeo(lh]pkje_]iajpa(eiep]noecjeÚ_]_kle]na`abkni]n* Hai^naikomqaLh]pk`eopejcqa]na]he`]`aai`keolh]jkokqÎiqj`koÏ6k j^qbof^ikq pbkpsbiakbpmfofqr^ikqfkqbifdsbi*=ran`]`akqkooanaoran`]`aenkook]oaooj_e]oej_kn) l na]oapanj]oaeiqpraeo(]oe`ae]o(ateopajpao]laj]ojklh]jkejpahecraha_kjda_e`]oat) _hqoer]iajpalah]n]vk*Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](]o_keo]o_knlkn]eo(_kjda_e`]olknejpani`ek `]oajoe^ehe`]`akq`ko ncko`kooajpe`ko(ok]laj]oeiep] aokq_ le]oeilanbaep]o`]o aooj_e]oejpahecraeo*=ok^n]o`]o]npaoeiep]per]o(lknoq]rav(eiep]i]o_keo]ooajoraeo* Ok(lknp]jpk(_ le]oeilanbaep]o`a_ le]oeilanbaep]oalkneookoklqn]ehqokab]hoe`]`a( kq]bkni]i]eo^]et]aeilanbaep]`k_kjda_eiajpk* J]Naj]o_aj](]_kj_alklh]pje_]$eopk(`amqa]]npaqi]bkni]`a_kjda_e) iajpk%napki]`](i]o_kijkrkoajpe`k6]Úni])oa(]ckn](mqaiaoik]o]npaoeiep]per]o $l]npe_qh]niajpa]lejpqn](]ao_qhpqn]a]lkaoe]%ok(fqjp]iajpa_ki]o]npaofq`e_]per]oa `eolkoeper]o(qi]`]obkni]o]hp]o`a]_aook]k_kjda_eiajpkran`]`aenkao_keo]o`erej]o( Ú_]j`k]^]etk]laj]o`]ÚhkokÚ]a`ktp]oaiope_k* Aoo] iq`]j] oa `ara ]k b]pk `a mqa( `qn]jpa ko o_qhko TR a TRE( ko lh]pje_ko `] Naj]o_aj]na`ao_k^nen]ikoao_nepkodanipe_koa`ai]ce]j]pqn]h(]pne^q`ko$amqerk_]) `]iajpa%]ko]jpeckoacl_eko(_qf]o]^a`kne]bkeahkce]`]lknLh]pkairneko`aoaqo`e) hkcko*Kn](jaooaoao_nepko]Úni]`kmqa@aqo_nekqkdkiai`]j`k)hda]_]l]_e`]`a`a _ne]njkrkoiqj`ko(lknmqahda`aq]_]l]_e`]`a`a_kjda_an]obkni]ooa_nap]oaejreoraeo `]o_keo]o(eopk(oq]oaooj_e]okqe`ae]olqn]o*K]_aook]aoo]obkni]o_kjoacqe`klkn iaek`]o]npaoaaop]ook(lknp]jpk(kejopnqiajpklnerehace]`kl]n]l]oo]n`k_kjda_eiaj) pkoajorah]k_kjda_eiajpkejpahecrah(_dac]j`kÚhkokÚ]* =r]hknev]k`]o]npao_kik_kjda_eiajpkaj_kjpn]oaq]lkcaqajpnakÚj]h`ko_qhk TREEE]pia]`ko`ko_qhkTET(`qn]jpakNki]jpeoik(mq]j`k]]npa_kj_a^e`]_kikÎk
nck$kqejopnqiajpk%can]h`]ÚhkokÚ]Ï(aipno]ola_pko`ebanajpao6l]n]]hcqjo(]o]npao ok]je_]re]`a]_aook]kqjerano]ha]k]^okhqpk7l]n]kqpnko(_kikDacah(]o]npaook] lneiaen]ap]l]`]re`]_kjo_eajpa`kaolnepk(lnal]n]j`kk]`rajpk`]naheceka`]Úhkok) Ú]7akqpnko(ajÚi(]o_kj_a^ai_kikkje_k_]iejdkl]n]naqjenkoejcqh]nakqjerano]h( kl]npe_qh]nakcan]h(lkeo(lkniaek`]oejcqh]ne`]`a`aqi]k^n]]npope_](paiko]_aook ]koecjeÚ_]`kqjerano]h`a]hcqi]na]he`]`a*Aoo]hpei]lanola_per]]mqaaj_kjpn]iko( lknatailhk(jko_qhkTT(jkÚh okbkI]npejDae`accan(l]n]mqai]k^n]`a]npa`aora) h]iajpka`aoraj`]iajpk`]ran`]`a* Oa(j]_kj_alklh]pje_](]]npaqip^_bo(j]]neopkphe_]ah]qic^wbokqqip^_bo moqf`l*=_kj_alk]neopkphe_]l]npa`]`ebanaj]ajpnakpa ne_kaklnpe_k(mqa(_kik reiko(`a_knna`]`ebanaj]ajpnakja_aoonek$k^fapk`]pakne]%aklkoorah$k^fapk`]ln) pe_]%*=]npa`aÚje`](ajpk(_kik]pere`]`alnpe_]b]^ne_]`kn]kqmlfbpfp*
/11
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Aoo] _kj_alk bke i]jpe`] `qn]jpa o_qhko a( bnamqajpaiajpa( ner]hevkq _ki ]o r]) ne]jpao`]_kj_alklh]pje_](ai^kn](kqpn]oravao(_kateopeooal]_eÚ_]iajpa_kiah]o* Jko_qhkTET(]_kj_alk]neopkphe_]na_a^aqinabknklknl]npa`]mqahaomqa]Úni]i] qpehe`]`aok_e]h`]o]npao$l]npe_qh]niajpa]hepan]pqn]%*A(jko_qhkTT(`]mqahaomqa_kj_a) ^ai]]npa_kik_kjopnqk(lnk_aookapn]^]hdk`]atlnaook_ne]`kn]*
Bej]he`]`ao`]]npa @q]o_kj_al aolna`kiej]ijk_knnan`]deop ne]`]o]npao(_kj_anjajpaooÚj]he`]) `ao`]]pere`]`a]npope_]6]mba^ddf`^a]bumobppfs^* =_kj_alkla`]cce_]aj_kjpn]oq]lneiaen]bkniqh]kaiLh]pka=neop pahao*Ai >Obm _if`^(atlkj`k]la`]ckce]l]n]]_ne]k`]_e`]`alanbaep](Lh]pkat_hqe`]mifplan) baep]koln]pe_]jpao`]o]npaoeiep]per]o(lkap]o(lejpknaoaao_qhpknao(lknmqa(_kikreiko( Î_kle]i_ le]oÏ(eopk(eiep]i]o_keo]ooajoraeoakbana_aiqi]ei]cai`aonaolaepko]`k `erejka`]o_keo]o`erej]o(lkeo]lnaoajp]iko`aqoao_kikdqi]jkoa]nna^]p]`kolknl]e) t aodqi]j]o*Pk`]re](kÚh okbknaoo]hp]pno]npao`eolkoeper]o$]`]j](]ioe_]a]aopn]) pce]%apno]npaofq`e_]per]o$]cn]ipe_](]i]paipe_]a]`e]hpe_]%_kik`eo_elhej]obqj`]) iajp]eoj]bkni]k`k_knlka`]]hi](kqoaf](`k_]npan`]o_ne]j]oa`ko]`khao_ajpao* =ooei(k_nepnek`k_kjda_eiajpkak`]la`]ckce]$kqbkni]k`k_]npan%at_hqai `]_e`]`alanbaep]pno`]obqpqn]o^ah]o)]npao$lkaoe](lejpqn]aao_qhpqn]%a_kjoanr]i]la) j]o`q]o`ah]o$ioe_]a`]j]%*Lknoq]rav(=neop pahao(j]>oqbmlqf`^(`aoajrkhrahkjc]) iajpakl]lahla`]c ce_k`]o]npao(l]npe_qh]niajpa]pn]c`e](mqa(oacqj`kkÚh okbk(pai ]bqjk`alnk`qven]_]p]noa(eopk(]lqneÚ_]kaolenepq]h`koaola_p]`knao(_kikre`ko a]l]rkn]`ko_ki]bne](kdknnkna]o_kjoamqj_e]o`]ol]et aomqaikrai]olanokj]) cajopnce_]o*Aoo]bqjk_]pnpe_]kqlqneÚ_]`kn]]pne^q`]ok^napq`kioe_]* J]>oqbmlqf`^(=neop pahaoao_nara6 >j pf`^klabsbpbomo^qf`^a^mlorjpqfmlab_bkbc`flnrbabi^mlababofs^o) j^pmlorplpj iqfmilp)gnrbmlabpbosfom^o^^bar`^ l)m^o^molmlo`flk^o^`^q^opb b)bjqbo`bfolird^o)m^o^lobmlrpla^^ij^b^prpmbkplabpr^pc^afd^p+ A_k]j`k]ol]h]rn]o`a=neop pahao(haikoaiLjbo`^aloabSbkbw^(`aOd]gaola]na6 Qlaleljbjnrbbjpfklqo^d^j pf`^B^nrbjklqlnrbjal`bpplkp`lk`lo* abp)abqo^f bp)mfie^dbkp)^oj^afie^p+Pbrbpmofqlsfsbbjklfqbl_p`ro^)Pbrp^cbqlp plkbdolp`ljllob_l7Klpb`lkÛbbjeljbjq^i+++ =_kj_alkla`]c ce_]`]]npana]l]na_aaiG]jpmq]j`k]Úni]mqa]bqjki]eo ]hp]`]]npalnk`qvenkpbkqfjbkqlalpr_ifjb(eopk(]ahar]kak]nna^]p]iajpk`ajkook aolnepk`e]jpa`]^ahav]*=mqaha_qfkaolnepka`q_]`ka_qhper]`klah]o]npao_]l]vjk o `abkniqh]nkfqvk`ackopk]`amq]`k(eopk(`a_kilnaaj`anmqa]]npajkaoplnao]]k pehjai]kln]vanaoei]k^ahk(_kik]ej`]_]l]v`aoa`aet]n]nna^]p]nlahk^ahk_kik ]hckpannrahaaol]jpkok(_kik]lnktei]kdqi]j]`kejÚjepk* P]i^iDacahejoeopajkl]laha`q_]perk`]]npa*=la`]ckce]]npope_]oaabapq]ai `q]oik`]he`]`aooq_aooer]o6j]lneiaen](]]npakiaekl]n]]a`q_]kikn]h`]ok_ea`]) `a$_kik=neop pahaod]re]ikopn]`k]naolaepk`]pn]c`e]%7j]oacqj`](cn]]oi]jaen] _kik`aopn e]^nqp]he`]`a`]i]pne](eilkj`k)hda]lqnav]`]bkni](a`q_]]ok_ea`]`a l]n]l]oo]n`kj]pqn]ha`ki]pane]h]k]npope_ka(`aopa(bkni]i]eo]hp]`]nahecek(]nahe) cekaolenepq]hkq`]ejpanekne`]`a* L]n]Dacah(]aolenepq]hev]klnkcnaooer]`]o]npao$kq]l]oo]cai`]lnalkj`an j_e] `]`]j](`]lejpqn]a`]ao_qhpqn]l]n]klna`kijek`]ioe_]a`]hepan]pqn]%atlneiak ikreiajpkla`]c ce_k`al]oo]cai`]nahecek`]atpanekne`]`a$ko`aqoaoaaolnepkoaopk reoraeoj]j]pqnav]aoab]vaireoraeolknoq]onalnaoajp] aoj]o]npaolhope_]o(eopk(j] lejpqn]aj]ao_qhpqn]%nahecek`]ejpanekne`]`a$koan`erejkkAolnepk=^okhqpk(kqoaf](] n]vka]ran`]`a(_qf]ei]pane]he`]`aoaatlneia]`amq]`]iajpaj]ioe_]aj]hepan]pqn]%*
/12
Kqjeranok`]o]npaox#!0É45,/ßx
/13
Lknaop]^aha_anqi]nah]kejpnjoa_]ajpna]npaaok_ea`]`a(klajo]iajpkaoppe_k `a aomqan`] p]i^i ]pne^qe Új]he`]`a la`]c ce_] o ]npao( `]j`k)hda ] p]nab] `a _npe_] ok_e]h a lkhpe_]( ejpanlnap]k `k lnaoajpa a ei]cej]k `] ok_ea`]`a bqpqn]* = ]npa `ara oanbkd^g^a^kq`ljmoljbqfa^(eopk(aop]n]oanrek`]ai]j_el]k`kcjankdqi]jk( kbana_aj`k)oa_kikejopnqiajpk`kaobknk`ahe^anp]k* Jqi]kqpn]lanola_per](]]npa_kj_a^e`]_kikatlnaook(mqapn]jobkni]jqiÚi ]mqehkmqal]n]]okqpn]o]pere`]`aodqi]j]oqiiaek*]ooeimqaoa`evmqa]lejpqn]a] ao_qhpqn]b]vairan]reok(]hepan]pqn]b]vb]h]n]hejcq]cai(]ioe_]b]vkqren]]q`ek(]`]j) ]b]voajpenk_knlk*Kqoaf](lejpqn]aao_qhpqn]jkoajoej]ikmqaran7]ioe_]jkoajoej] kmqakqren7]`]j]jkoajoej]kmqaikran)oaalkooqenqi_knlk7]hepan]pqn]jkoajoej]k mqa]hejcq]cai7a]ooeilkn`e]jpa*=]npanarah]kai]jebaop]k`]aooj_e]`]na]he`]) `a(mqaaop]iknpa_e`]aaomqa_e`]aijkoo]ateopj_e]_kpe`e]j](]ooei_kikaopna`qve`]] _kj_aepkoj]o_ej_e]oaj]ÚhkokÚ](apn]jobkni]`]aiejopnqiajpkj]p_je_]aj]a_kjkie]* ?kikatlnaook(]o]npaopn]joÚcqn]i]na]he`]`al]n]mqapajd]iko]_aookran`]`ae) nk]ah]*@aoamqehe^n]kaop]^aha_e`kkqkejopepq`k(`ao_ajpn]ikreiajpko(okjo(bkni]o( _knaoal]h]rn]o(napen]j`k)ko`k_kjpatpk_kopqiaenkl]n]b]van)jko_kjda_)hkojqi]kq) pn]`eiajok(]`eiajok_ne]`kn]kqejopepqejpa`kjkrk*=]npaejrajp]qiiqj`k`a_k) nao(bkni]o(rkhqiao(i]oo]o(okjo(caopko(patpqn]o(nepiko(ikreiajpko(l]h]rn]o(l]n]jko `]n]_kjda_anjkookln lnekiqj`k*Lknoanatlnaooer](pfj_if`^a^ibdof`^* =l]h]rn]pj_lilrai`kcnackaoecjeÚ_]Îkmqaqja(fqjp](oejpapev]jqi]qje`]`ako `ebanajpao(`]j`k)hdaoqioajpe`kje_kajkrkmqajklkooq]imq]j`koal]n]`koÏ*Qi oi^khkqioecjkkqqioej]hmqalkooqeqi]b]_ai]pane]h$qioki(qipn]k(qi]_kn% aqi]b]_aei]pane]hkqiajp]h(koajpe`k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(_kikpk`koecjk(koi^khk qioecjeÚ_]jpa$oaq]ola_pki]pane]h%aqioecjeÚ_]`k$oaq]ola_pkiajp]h%*=la_qhe]ne`]) `a`koi^khkaopjkb]pk`amqaahaqioecjk`ebanajpa`akqpnkolknmqaqioecjkqi oej]ha(lknp]jpk(qi]ej`e_]kkqqiej`e_]perk$`ajkp]perk%(]lkjp]j`k`enap]iajpa l]n]]_keo]oej]hev]`]kqej`e_]`](i]ojkoi^khkjklna`kiej]k]ola_pkej`e_]perka oei]]Úni]k`aqioecjeÚ_]`kmqaqo]koej]hl]n]oecjeÚ_]nqi]_keo]`ebanajpa`]mqa) h]mqaoane]oeilhaoiajpaej`e_]`]* Lknatailhk(_kikoecjkkqoej]h(]l]h]rn]mlj_^ej`e_]qi]`apaniej]`]]ra*Jk ajp]jpk(l]n]ko_neopko(]lki^]oei^khev]kAolnepkO]jpka(l]n]]olaook]oaican]h(] l]v*=ooei(mq]j`kjqi]_]pa`n]hraiko]lejpqn]`aqi]lki^]kqmq]j`kjqi]l]o) oa]p]raikoqi]^]j`aen]aimqad]Úcqn]`aqi]lki^](jkaop]iko`e]jpa`aqi oecjkej`e_]perk`aqi]]raaoei`e]jpa`aqipj_lil*@]iaoi]i]jaen](]aoppq]`a khdko raj`]`ko _ki qi] ^]h]j] j]o iko oei^khev] ] fqope] a ] ^]j`aen] raniahd]( ] narkhqk*=o]npaopn]^]hd]i_kioi^khkoa_ne]ioi^khko* =l]h]rn]^ibdlof^p]i^irai`kcnackaoecjeÚ_]Îkmqaaopjkhqc]n`aqi]kqpn] _keo]ÏkqÎkmqa]lnaoajp]ej`enap]iajpaqi]_keo]lkniaek`aqi]kqpn]ÏkqÎkb]h]n`a qi]_keo]lkniaek`akqpn]Ï*Jaooa]ola_pk(pk`]]hackne]oei^ he_](qi]ravmqakoi) ^khkoanabanao_keo]olkniaek`akqpn]omqa(aioeiaoi]o(jkej`e_]i]_keo](i]o] oecjeÚ_]ikq]atlneiai*=`ebanaj]ajpna]]hackne]akoi^khk]laj]o`acn]q(eopk( ]]hackne]klan]_kirnekooi^khkooeiqhp jakoajk_kiqi]laj]o* Qi atailhk _hooe_k `a ]hackne] ] la] hepanne] _kjpe`] j] Obm _if`^ `a Lh]pk6 k Iepkkq=hackne]`]?]ranj]$mqareiko]keje_e]naopahernk%*Jah]kÚh okbkjkj]nn]qi ]_kjpa_eiajpkna]haoei]hacknev]aoei^khev]kikreiajpk`]]hi]dqi]j]l]oo]j`k`]o pnar]o`]ecjkn j_e]$]_]ranj]%hqv`k_kjda_eiajpk$]hqv`kOkh%*Qikqpnkatailhk`a ]hackne](p]i^ib]ikok(]_aj]`kÚhia`a?d]nhao?d]lhej(Qbjmlpjlaboklp(j]mq]h kklannekpaioaq_knlkaoaqoikreiajpkoejpaen]iajpa_kjpnkh]`kolah]oimqej]oa `arkn]`klknqi]`ah]o*=mqe(p]i^i(?d]lhejjkaopj]nn]j`kqib]pkkqqi]_kjpa) _eiajpkaoei]hacknev]j`kkqoei^khev]j`k]rekhj_e]`kpn]^]hdkej`qopne]h*@]iaoi] i]jaen]( k Úhia J^qofu( mqa ]j]heo]iko j] Ejpnk`qk( ]hacknev] ko neo_ko a lanecko mqa ]ia]]i]dqi]je`]`a_kiklk`anek`ko_kilqp]`knao(imqej]o`alnk`qvenehqo ao kqna]he`]`aoenna]eo(eopk(renpq]eo*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=npaaok_ea`]`a
O
a]_kil]jd]niko]opn]jobkni] aookbne`]olah]o]npao(m^pp^kala^crk lobifdfl* p^ ^rqlkljf^a^l_o^ab^oqb`ljl`of^ lbbumobppl(jkp]naikomqa]oiq`]j]o bkn]i`a`keopelko* @aqih]`k(dkqraiq`]j]omq]jpk]kc^wbo^oqpqf`l(`ebanaj_e]j`k)oaaibp`li^pab ^oqbkqbpqfilp^oqpqf`lpÍ_hooe_k(c pe_k(naj]o_ajpeop](^]nnk_k(nk_k_ (nki jpe_k(eilnao) oekjeop](na]heop](atlnaooekjeop](]^opn]pk(_kjopnqpereop](oqnna]heop](ap_* Aoo]oiq`]j]o_kj_anjai_kj_alk`kk^fapk]npope_k(onah] aoajpnai]pne] abkni](op_je_]o`aah]^kn]k`koi]pane]eo(nah]k_kikl^he_k(]khqc]nk_ql]`k lknqi]]npajkejpanekn`]o`ai]eoaoanrej`k`al]`nk]ah]o(o`ao_k^anp]o`alnk_a`e) iajpkoai]pane]eojkrko(ap_*@akqpnkh]`k(lkni(]oiq`]j]o_kj_anjai`apaniej]) kok_e]h`]]pere`]`a]npope_](eopk(]kb]pk`amqaoq]oiq`]j]ojk`alaj`ai]laj]o `a qi] deop ne] ejpanj] `ko lnk_a`eiajpko ]npope_ko a oei `] ejoank `]o ]npao j] re`] ok_e]h*=o]npaoatlneiai]obkni] aook_e]eoaimqaj]o_aiaj]omq]eorerai(lkeo]]npa pl`f^ijbkqbabqbojfk^a^6 -*
lah]Új]he`]`aok_e]h`]ok^n]o6aop]r]i`aopej]`]o]k_qhpknahecekok(j]=jpecqe`]`a7 an]ibaep]ol]n]`]nlnaopcek]oaqol]pnk_ej]`knao(j]Naj]o_aj]7adkfaaopk`aope) j]`]o]lan_knnank_en_qepk`kian_]`k`a]npa7
.*
lahkhqc]nok_e]hk_ql]`klahk]npeop]6i]ck)]npaok)kÚ_e]jpa`anepko(j]=jpecqe`]`a7 Új]j_e]`kalnkpace`klknqiia_aj]o(j]Naj]o_aj]7lnkÚooekj]hhe^an]h`alaj`aj) pa`kian_]`k`a]npa(jko`e]o`adkfa7
/*
lah]o _kj`e ao `a na_alk `] k^n] `a ]npa6 ] _kiqje`]`a `a Úeo( j] =jpecqe`]`a7 qi]ahepane_](_qhper]`]a_kilk`anlkhpe_k(j]Naj]o_aj]7]_h]ooaa_kjkie_]iajpa `kiej]jpaalkhepe_]iajpa`enecajpa(`aqih]`k(a]o_h]ooaolklqh]naokq]i]oo](`a kqpnk(aijkooko`e]o*
=`eo_qookok^na]nah]k]npa)ok_ea`]`aharkq]`q]o]pepq`aoÚhko Ú_]oklkop]o6] mqa ]Úni] mqa ] ]npa o ]npa oa bkn mro^( eopk ( oa jk aoperan lnak_ql]`] _ki ]o _en) _qjop j_e]odeop ne_]o(ok_e]eo(a_kjie_]oalkhpe_]o*Pn]p])oa`]`abao]`]Î]npalah]]npaÏ* =kqpn]]Úni]mqakr]hkn`]k^n]`a]npa`a_knna`aoaq`ljmoljfppl`oqf`l`e]jpa`]o _en_qjop j_e]olnaoajpao*Pn]p])oa`]Î]npaajc]f]`]Ï(j]mq]hk]npeop]pki]lkoek`e]jpa `aoq]ok_ea`]`a(hqp]j`kl]n]pn]jobkni)h]aiahdkn)h](al]n]_kjo_eajpev]n]olaook]o ok^na]oejfqope]oa]oklnaoo ao`klnaoajpa* =o`q]o_kj_al aooklnk^haipe_]o*=lneiaen]lknmqaei]cej]k]npeop]a]k^n]`a ]npa_kikabpmolsfalpabo^wbpkljrkalbifsobpa^pfkÜrk`f^pa^pl`fba^abok^naahaoÍ kmqaeilkoorah*=oacqj`]lknmqa_knnakneo_k`ao]_neÚ_]nkpn]^]hdk]npope_kaijkia `]oÎiajo]cajoÏmqa]k^n]`araajre]nok_ea`]`al]n]iq`)h](`]j`k]k]npeop]kl]lah `a`lkp`fk`f^`oqf`^`klkrkklneie`k* =lneiaen]_kj_alk`aoai^k_]jk_d]i]`kbkni]heoik$]lanbaek`]bkni]mqa _kjp]ajkk_kjpa`k`]k^n]%*=oacqj`](jk_kjpaq`eoik$]Îiajo]caiÏmqa_kjp]( iaoikmqa]bkni]`]k^n]oaf]lna_ne](`ao_qe`]`](nalapeper]aoaibkn]ejkr]`kn]%* Jkajp]jpk(lk`aiko`evanmqaqi]k^n]`a]npacn]j`aa`qn]`kqn]mq]j`kjah]] lanbaek`]bkni]a]nemqav]`]ooecjeÚ_] ao`aoaq_kjpa`kokejoal]nraeo(aopk]npe) _qh]`]ojqi]qje`]`ad]nikjeko]mqa]_kjopepqe_kikje_]*Jah](apanje`]`aabqc]_e`]) `aokoeiqhp ja]o*@e]hkc]_kikiqj`klnaoajpalknmqajkao_kj`aoaqlanpaj_eiajpk ja_aoonek]k_kjpatpkdeop ne_kaok_e]haimqaoaaj_kjpn]ajkmq]hj]o_aq7`e]hkc]_ki kl]oo]`klknmqap]i^ijkao_kj`aoq]l]npe_el]kjqi]pn]`ekmqahda`oajpe`k7 a`e]hkc]_kikbqpqnklknmqaoannapki]`](pn]jobkni]`]aoqlan]`]lknkqpn]ok^n]omqa jah]aj_kjpn]nkqijkrklkjpk`al]npe`]*
/14
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a] ej` opne]_qhpqn]h ?qhpqn]lklqh]na_qhpqn]`ai]oo]
J
ko_qhkTET(]_knnajpa]npope_]`ajkiej]`]Nki]jpeoik_nekq]e`ae]`apn]`ek lklqh]n(kqkmqako]npeop]onki jpe_ko`ajkiej]r]ibpmofqlabrjmlsl(_qf] i]jebaop]k_kjopepq]kbkh_hkna*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(_kikNki]jpeoikoqnce) n]i]oe`ae]o`a^oqbmlmri^oa`riqro^mlmri^o_kiki]jebaop] ao`]pn]`ekkqaolnepk `aqilkrk(eopk(_kikcli`ilob* LknmqakNki]jpeoikpnkqtap]eoe`ae]o;Lknmqaaoo]_knnajpa]npope_]_kej_e`a_ki qi]oepq]kdeop ne_]`apaniej]`](mq]hoaf](]_kjokhe`]kakbknp]ha_eiajpk`koAop]) `koj]_ekj]eo(mqal]oo]n]i]oan`aÚje`kolah]qje`]`a`ahjcq]anahecekalah]qje`]`a pannepkne]h kq lkhpe_]* Oqnca ] e`ae] lkhpe_] `a j]k a( _ki ah]( k bajiajk `k j]_ek) j]heoik*Ejpaha_pq]eoa]npeop]oaqnklaqo_kjoe`an]r]imqa]j]_ekj]he`]`a_kjopepq]k bpmofqlabrjmlsl(kmq]hoaatlneie]j]hjcq](jko_kopqiao(j]nahecek(j]o]npaoaj]o pn]`e aoj]_ekj]eo* Pk`]re](jklk`aikoaomqa_anmqakoAop]`koj]_ekj]eokqj] aoan]iok_ea`]`ao_]) lep]heop]oa(_kikp]eo(`ere`e`]oai_h]ooaook_e]eo6]^qncqaoe]_]lep]heop](]lamqaj]^qncqa) oe]bkni]`]lknlamqajkolnklneapneko(bqj_ekjnekol^he_koaejpaha_pq]eo(aklnkhap]ne]`k kq ko pn]^]hd]`knao ej`qopne]eo a nqn]eo* Jk lh]jk _qhpqn]h( aoo] `ereok a_kjie_k)ok_e]h pnkqtapno_kjoamqj_e]o(mqalani]ja_ai]pko`e]o`adkfa6 -*
]_qhpqn]a]o]npaobkn]i`eopejcqe`]oai`keopelkolnej_el]eo6]anq`ep]$kq`aahepa%( ln lne]`koejpaha_pq]eoa]npeop]o`]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa`]ok_ea`]`a(a]lklqh]n$kq ejcjq]%(ln lne]`kopn]^]hd]`knaoqn^]jkoanqn]eo7
.*
mq]j`k lajo]`]o _kik lnk`q ao kq _ne] ao _khaper]o rej`]o `k l]oo]`k j]_ekj]h( bkni]j`k]pn]`ekj]_ekj]h(]_qhpqn]a]npalklqh]naona_a^an]ikjkia`abkh_hkna( _kjopepq`k lkn iepko( haj`]o a nepko lklqh]nao( `]j]o nacekj]eo lklqh]nao( ioe_]o nacekj]eolklqh]nao(]npao]j]pko(ap_*7
/*
]]npaanq`ep]kq`aahepal]ookq]oank_kjfqjpk`]o^ah]o)]npao_ki]ok^n]olnk`qve`]o kq_ne]`]ojklnaoajpalkn]npeop]oej`ere`q]eo(mqaoa`enece]i]qil^he_ki]fknep]) ne]iajpa^qncqo(eopk(ao_kh]nev]`k(ejopnq`kaaj`ejdaen]`k(_kjoqie`kn`]ok^n]o `a]npa*
=`eopejkajpna]npalklqh]naanq`ep](ai^kn]pajd]oe`kna]hiajpaqi]_kjoamqj) _e]`]`ereoka_kjie_k)ok_e]h`]o_h]ooao(jkbkereop]`aoo]i]jaen](aoei_kik_]qo]`] lkn `ebanaj]o j] i]jaen] `a na]hev)h]o* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( ] `eopejk bke _kj_a^e`] $a _kjpejq]]o)hk(]pdkfa%_kik`ebanaj]k^cloj^ak^nr^ifa^ab`]oln lne]o]npao*=o lnej_el]eo`ebanaj]oan]i]lkjp]`]o6
/15
-*
k^`ljmibufa^aba^bi^_lo^ l6]]npalklqh]ni]eooeilhaoaiajko_kilhat]`k mqa]anq`ep](mqai]eookÚope_]`](i]eoatecajpaai]eoah]^kn]`]mq]jpkbkni]a ]k_kjpa`k7
.*
k^obi^ l`ljlklslb`ljlqbjml6]lklqh]npaj`a]oanpn]`e_ekj]heop]analapeper]( ajmq]jpk]anq`ep]paj`a]oan`ar]jcq]n`]arkhp]`]l]n]kbqpqnk7
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
/*
k^obi^ l`ljlm _if`l6j]lklqh]n(_kik]o_ne] ao_kopqi]ioan_khaper]o(]npeop]o al^he_kpaj`ai]jkoa`eopejcqen7j]anq`ep](_h]n]]`eopejkajpnak]npeop]$mqa oailnaqiej`er`qk_ne]`kn%akl^he_k$mqaqi_khaperk`a_kjoqie`knao%7
0*
kljlalab`ljmobbkpla^ob^ifa^ab6j]]npalklqh]n(]k^n]ei]jajpa]koaqiqj) `kkq]kiqj`k`]`k(atlneiej`k)k`enap]iajpap]h_kikaha7j]]npaanq`ep](]k^n] ^qo_]pn]jo_aj`ankiqj`k(`eop]j_e]n)oa`ahal]n]iahdkn_kilnaaj`)hk(na_ne)hk( `]n)hdajkrkooajpe`ko*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(j]]npalklqh]nk]npeop]atlneia`enap]) iajpakmqaoal]oo]aioaq]i^eajpa(kmq]hkiaoikl]n]oaql^he_kalkneook eia`e]p]iajpa_kilnaaj`e`klknpk`ko*J]anq`ep](k]npeop]^qo_]jkrkoiaeko`a atlnaookl]n]_ne]njkr]ooecjeÚ_] ao(oei^khev]nlaook]o(]_kjpa_eiajpko(aik ao( hqc]nao(ap_*(`ai]jaen]mqaoq]k^n]jkeia`e]p]iajpa_kilnaajorahl]n]pk`ko aoeil]n]kobkqbkafalpkl^pprkql(mqa(lkneook(]ejpanlnap]il]n]knaop]jpa`kl) ^he_k$kqoaf](]]npaanq`ep]`knecaiÚcqn]`k`oqf`lab^oqb(mqaatlhe_](ejpanlnap] a]r]he]]ok^n]ol]n]kl^he_k%*
?ki k `aoajrkhreiajpk `] ok_ea`]`a ej`qopne]h a `]o cn]j`ao iapn lkhao( ko pn]^]) hd]`knao`aohk_]n]i)oa_]`]ravi]eo`]ovkj]onqn]eokq`k_]ilk(l]oo]j`k]naoe`enj]o lanebane]o`]ocn]j`ao_e`]`ao(]pn]raoo]j`k)]opk`]o]oi]jdo]koa`enecenai]kpn]^]hdk j]ob^ne_]oapk`]o]op]n`ao]knacnaoo]naiooq]o_]o]o*Paj`koe`kbkn]`ko]`aet]nk _]ilk(]i]ekne]`aooaopn]^]hd]`knaop]i^i`aet]r]l]n]pnooq]_qhpqn]aoq]]npa$mqa koejpaha_pq]eod]re]i`ajkiej]`kbkh_hkna%* J]o _e`]`ao( `keo bajiajko ]_kjpa_an]i6 lkn qi h]`k( ai oaqo ^]ennko a hk_]eo `a pn]^]hdk(koklannekoaoq]ob]ihe]obkn]i_ne]j`kqi]_qhpqn]aqi]]npaln lne]o(_d]) i]`]o`amlmri^obp7lknkqpnk(l]oo]n]i]b]vanl]npa`]cn]j`ai]oo]`a_kjoqie`knao `kolnk`qpkoej`qopne]eol]n]komq]eo_kia]n]i]oannalnk`qve`]o(aih]nc]ao_]h](ran) o aooeilheÚ_]`]oaejbaneknao`kolnk`qpkoa`]o_ne] ao`]_qhpqn]a`]]npa`aahepa*Aoo] nalnk`qkoeilheÚ_]`]`]ok^n]oanq`ep]o`aqknecai]kmqarene]]oan_kjda_e`k_kik jkia`a_qhpqn]a]npa`ai]oo]* @aoo] i]jaen]( ai jkooko `e]o( ]o ]npao _kopqi]i oan `eopejcqe`]o ai6 bkh_hkna $]o pn]`e ao_khaper]oj]_ekj]eolklqh]nao%(lklqh]n$]o_ne] ao`ko]npeop]omqalanpaj_ai _h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]%(anq`ep]kq`aahepa$]o_ne] ao_kilhat]oa`ar]jcq]n`]`a]npeop]o ej`ere`q]eomqaoa`enecai]qil^he_knaopnepk%a`ai]oo]$Új]j_e]`]lknailnao]omqa b]vaip]jpk]onalnk`q aooeilheÚ_]`]o`]ok^n]o`]]npaanq`ep]_kikp]i^i_kiln]i l]n]lnk`qkaiao_]h]ej`qopne]h]ok^n]o`a]npeop]oej`ere`q]eoa]o`aopej]i]kian_]`k `a_kjoqikaih]nc]ao_]h]%* =ooei(lknatailhk(k^qi^]iaq^kekq]_kjc]`]okbkh_hkna7ko]i^]`aiknnka ko^m$mq]j`kjkok]lnklne]`kolah]oailnao]o`a_qhpqn]`ai]oo]%oklklqh]nao7qi mq]`nk`aP]noeh]`k=i]n]hkqqi]ao_qhpqn]`aHuce]?h]ngokanq`ep]o7]ioe_]oanp]ja) f]$mqaeiep]]ioe_]`lrkqovjknpa)]iane_]j]%(]ioe_]`ko@Fo(]i]ekne]`koÚhiao(]o jkrah]o`apahareok(ap_*ok`ai]oo]*
Ej`opne]_qhpqn]ha_qhpqn]`ai]oo]
M
q]j`kaopq`]iko]nahecekoe`]`a(reikomqa]onahece aolnk`qvaikbk`^kq^jbkql aljrkal(eopk(koajpeiajpk`amqakiqj`kj]pqn]hadqi]jkaopainah]k _kiqiiqj`kok^naj]pqn]h`abkn]o`erej]omqaoai]jebaop]i`ai]jaen]or]) ne]`]o(ejatlhe_raeoaieopaneko]o*Mq]j`kaopq`]ikokoqnceiajpk`]ÚhkokÚ]a(`alkeo( k `]o _ej_e]oap_je_]o( reiko mqa ] ik`anje`]`a _kj_hqeq qi lnk_aook mqa ]ÚhkokÚ] _kia]n]`ao`a]Cn_e]6kabpbk`^kq^jbkqlaljrkal(eopk(]l]oo]cai`kiepkn]vk( `]i]ce]_ej_e]ah ce_]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(l]ookq)oa`]_naj]ai_]qo]ook^naj]pq) n]eol]n]ko]_kjpa_eiajpkooq]atlhe_]kn]_ekj]hkqoq]j]pqn]hev]kadqi]jev]k* Aooalnk_aook(_kikreikojk_]lpqhk]jpanekn(he^ankq]o]npao`]bqjkaÚj]he`]`anahe) ceko]o(`]j`k)hdao]qpkjkie]*
/2,
!LBUM!KG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
!LBUM!KG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
4HEODORß!DORNOßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEßß SOCIvLOGOßALEMjO ßß FUNDADOR ßJUNTOßCOMß (ORKHEIMER ßDAß%SCOLAßß DEß&RANKFURT ßEMß
-AXß(ORKHEIMERßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEßß SOCIvLOGOßALEMjO ßUMßß DOSßFUNDADORESßDAßß %SCOLAßDEß&RANKFURT
/2-
P]i^ireikojk_]lpqhk]jpaneknmqa(jkajo]ekok^na]`aopnqek`]]qn](`alkeo `aatlhe_]n]eilknp j_e]`]]qpkjkie]`]o]npao(S]hpan>ajf]iej]ooqie]qi]lkoek kpeieop](lkeo_kjoe`an]r]mqa]ok_ea`]`aej`qopne]hhar]n]nalnk`qk`]ok^n]o`a]npa $lahkhernk(lah]o]npaocnÚ_]o(lah]bkpkcn]Ú](lahkn`ekalahk_ejai]%amqaeooklaniepene] i]ekne]`]olaook]ok]_aook]_ne] aomqa(]pajpk(]laj]oqjolkq_kolk`e]i_kjda) _anabnqen*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(>ajf]iejaolan]r]mqa]nalnk`qkp_je_]`]ok^n]o`a ]npalnkikraooa]`aik_n]pev]k`]_qhpqn]a`]o]npao* Kkpeieoik`a>ajf]iejjkan]ejbqj`]`k*>]op]l]n]eookhar]nikoai_kjoe`an]k koabaepkook_e]eoalkhpe_ko`klneiaenkcn]j`aiaek`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo](eopk(] ejrajk`]eilnajo]lknCqpaj^anc(jko_qhkTR(l]n]raneÚ_]noq]eilknp j_e]l]n]] `aik_n]pev]k`]_qhpqn]* ?kikoao]^a(]_qhpqn]aqnklae]$ajpnakoo_qhkoEaTREE%an]aiejajpaiajpa_neop( eopk(e`ae]o(r]hknao(_kopqiao(haeo(ejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]o(ejopnqka_kjda_eiajpko an]i]mqahaoejopepq`kolahkajoej]iajpk_neopklkniaek`]Ecnaf]*Aoo]_qhpqn]bqj`]r])oa ejpaen]iajpaj]ejpanlnap]ka_haoeope_]`]>^he]*Kn](klneiaenkhernkeilnaookbke]>^he]( mqa]pajpkateope]aibkni]`ai]jqo_nepko]laj]oaiecnaf]oaoej]ckc]o$=jpeckPaop]) iajpkkq]Pkn]d(aida^n]e_ka]n]i]e_k7=jpeckaJkrkPaop]iajpk(aicnackaaih]pei%a o an]he`]lknaola_e]heop]o$n]^ejko(o]_an`kpao(pa hkcko%(ajmq]jpkknaop]jpa`]ok_ea`]`a] na_a^e]kn]hiajpa(he`]airkv]hp]lahkohapn]`ko`qn]jpa]ohepqnce]onaheceko]oa(_kikl]oo]n `kpailk(aihjcq]oejateopajpao(mqaokiajpaqjolkq_ko_kilnaaj`e]i* =keje_e]nkikreiajpknahecekok_kjda_e`k_kikNabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa(jkÚj]h`ko) _qhkTR(I]npejHqpankpn]`qveq]>^he]l]n]k]haik(abkeaoo]pn]`qkmqaCqpaj^anc eilneieq*Lah]lneiaen]ravkpatpko]cn]`k`ko_neopkolk`e]oan]`mqene`kahe`klknpk`ko komqa_kjda_e]ik]haik*@]iaoi]i]jaen](]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpaejchao](bn]j_ao]a dkh]j`ao]na]hevkq]opn]`q ao`]>^he]l]n]kejcho(kbn]j_oakdkh]j`oa]oeilneieq jaoo]ohjcq]o* L]n]`ebqj`en]naheceknabkni]`]a_ki^]pan]Ecnaf]?]p he_]Nki]j]$_d]i]`]`a Îl]leop]Ï%(kolnkpaop]jpao]Úni]n]imqapk`koko_neopkoan]i_]l]vao`a_kilnaaj`an koajoej]iajpko^^he_kooailna_eo]nmqal]`naoapa hkckokoatlhe_]ooai*L]n]eook(eje) _e]n]iqilnk_aook`a]hb]^apev]kjkol]oaonabkni]`ko]Úi`amqapk`kokoÚeolq) `aooaihan]oO]cn]`]oAo_nepqn]o*?kikao_naraqqideopkne]`knejcho(_ki]eilnajo]a] Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa(]>^he]bke`aik_n]pev]`]* Aoo]haepqn]`]>^he]bav_kimqa_]ilkjaoao(j]=hai]jd]aj]Dkh]j`](]ooei_kik pn]^]hd]`knao`k_]ilka`]o_e`]`ao(j]Ejch]pann](lan_a^aooaimqaoq]ook_ea`]`aoaoaqo ckranj]jpaojkoacqe]ikoajoej]iajpko^^he_ko(an]iejfqopko(_nqeo(pen je_ko(]jpe_neo) pko*A]oi]oo]olklqh]naooana^ah]n]iaipk`]l]npa(atecej`kfqope](ecq]h`]`aahe^an`]) `a*=haepqn]`]oO]cn]`]oAo_nepqn]opara(]ooei(qiabaepk`a_kjo_eajpev]klklqh]n* Jkajp]jpk(kkpeieoik`aS]hpan>ajf]iej`aetkq`ah]`kqikqpnk]ola_pk`klnk) _aookmqaoaqo_khac]o`]Ao_kh]`aBn]jgbqnpat]iej]n]i_ki`ap]hda*@ab]pk(]l]npen`] Oacqj`]NarkhqkEj`qopne]hjko_qhkTETalnkooacqej`kjkmqadkfaai`e]oa`ajkie) j]ok_ea`]`al o)ej`qopne]hkql o)ik`anj](]o]npao(mqad]re]ioapknj]`k]qpjki]o kqoahe^an]`k`]oq^ieooknahecek(bkn]ioq^iape`]o]qi]jkr]oanre`k6]onacn]o `kian_]`k_]lep]heop]a]e`akhkce]`]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h$atlnaook_qjd]`]lknPdak`kn =`knjkaI]tDkngdaeianjqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]Af^iqf`^albp`i^ob`fjbkql(l]n]ej`e_]n qi]_qhpqn]^]oa]`]j]e`ae]aj]lnpe_]`k_kjoqik`aÎlnk`qpko_qhpqn]eoÏb]^ne_]`koai onea*=atlnaookÎej`opne]_qhpqn]hÏoecjeÚ_]mqa]ok^n]o`a]npaokian_]`kne]o(_kik pq`kkmqaateopajk_]lep]heoik*% >ajf]iej jk harkq ai _kjp] k b]pk `a mqa ] nalnk`qk a ] `eopne^qek `]o k^n]o oane]ibaep]olknailnao]o_]lep]heop]o(reo]j`k]khq_nkbkl`aik_n]pev]k`]o]npao* =ooei(lan`e`]]]qn](]]npajkoa`aik_n]pevkq(i]ooeÚ_kq)oal]n]_kjoqiknle`kjk ian_]`k`]ik`]ajkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo](pn]jobkni]j`k)oaai`lfp^ibsb( bkqobqbkfjbkql a afsbopl l]n] ]o dkn]o `a h]van* ?kik ao_narai =`knjk a Dkngdaeian( dkfa(]k^n]`a]npajkpn]jo_aj`akiqj`k`]`k(Î]npaoaiokjdkÏalkneookiaoik
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
ÎokjkÏ(kqoaf](]`knia_a]_ne]pere`]`a(]_kjo_ej_e](]oajoe^ehe`]`a(]ei]cej]k(klaj) o]iajpka]_npe_]p]jpk`k]npeop]_kik`kl^he_k* Ok^klk`anek`aailnao]o_]lep]heop]o(]ok^n]o`a]nparan`]`aen]iajpa_ne]`kn]o(_n) pe_]oan]`e_]eobkn]iaor]ve]`]ol]n]oapknj]naiajpnapajeiajpk7akqpn]ok^n]ol]oo]n]i ]oanlnk`qve`]ol]n]_aha^n]nkateopajpa(aihqc]n`a_kilnaaj`)hk(_nepe_)hkalnklkn qikqpnkbqpqnkl]n]]dqi]je`]`a*=bkn]`a_kjda_eiajpk(_npe_]aejrajk`]o]n) paoÚ_kqna`qve`]]]hcqi]olnk`q ao`]]npaanq`ep](ajmq]jpkknaop]jpa`]lnk`qk ]npope_]bke`aopej]`k]qi_kjoqiknle`k(pn]jobkni]j`k)oaaioej]h`apq^qrpok_e]ha lnaopceklkhpe_kl]n]]npeop]oaoaqo_kjoqie`knaoaaiiaek`a`lkqolib`riqro^ilknl]npa `koailnaonekoalnklneapneko`koiaeko`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo]*
=i]ooebe_]k_qhpqn]h Ok^koabaepko`]i]ooeÚ_]klah]ej`opne]alahk_kjoqik_qhpqn]eo(]o]npao_knnai kneo_k`alan`anoq]bkn]oei^ he_]a(_kiah](k`alan`an]hcqi]o`aoq]olnej_el]eo_]) n]_panope_]o6 -*
`aatlnaooer]o(paj`ai]pknj]n)oanalnk`qper]oanalapeper]o7
.*
`apn]^]hdk`]_ne]k(paj`ai]pknj]n)oaarajpkol]n]_kjoqik7
/*
`aatlaneiajp]kaejrajk`kjkrk(paj`ai]pknj]n)oaÎ_kjo]cn]k`k_kjo]cn]) `kÏlah]ik`]alahk_kjoqik7
0*
`a `qn]`kqn]o( paj`ai ] pknj]n)oa l]npa `k ian_]`k `] ik`]( l]oo]caenk( abiank( oail]oo]`kaoaibqpqnk7
1*
`abkni]o`a_kjda_eiajpkmqa`aoraj`]i]na]he`]`aa]h_]j]i]ran`]`a(paj`ai ]pknj]n)oa`eooeiqh]k`]na]he`]`a(ehqokb]hoeÚ_]`kn](lq^he_e`]`aalnkl]c]j`]*
= ]npa lkooqe ejpnejoa_]iajpa r]hkn `a atlkoek kq sfpf_fifa^ab( eopk ( bufpqb m^o^ pbo`lkqbjmi^a^bcora^*aooaj_e]hiajpabpmbq`ril(l]h]rn]mqarai`kh]peiaoecjeÚ_] Î`]`kreoe^ehe`]`aÏ*Jkajp]jpk(ok^k_kjpnkhaa_kjie_kae`akh ce_k`]oailnao]o`a lnk`qk]npope_](]]npaoapn]jobknikqaioaqklkopk6qiarajpkl]n]pknj]nejreorah p]jpk k ln lnek pn]^]hdk _ne]`kn `ko ]npeop]o a `]o k^n]o _kik ] na]he`]`a( i]o_]n]j`k)] a`eooeiqh]j`k)]*=hi`eook(]oailnao]o`alnk`qk_qhpqn]hpb^molmof^j`a_ne] ao lklqh]naoaanq`ep]ooailnamqaaop]o_kia]i]ejpanaoo]n]qil^he_k(lkeoaopareopk _kikqicn]j`a_kjoqie`knailkpaj_e]h*=kb]vanaoo]]lnklne]k(]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h jko r]eaheiej]j`kko]ola_pko_npe_ko(ejkr]`knaoalkhie_ko`]ok^n]o(i]or]ep]i) ^ipn]jobkni]j`k)]oaijla^(eopk(ai]hckm^pp^dbfolmqa`araraj`aniqepkajmq]j) pkjkrka(]oacqen(`ao]l]na_anoai`aet]nn]opnk* =ej`opne]_qhpqn]hjk]pejcaiknp]hiajpa]laj]o]ok^n]o`a]npa(i]o]ok^n]o`a lajo]iajpk( b]vaj`k)]o lan`an ] bkn] _npe_]( ejkr]`kn] a _ne]`kn]* k mqa raiko( lkn atailhk(_ki]lnkheban]k`kohernko`a]qpk]fq`](_ki]orano aonaoqie`]oaoeilheÚ) _]`]o`ak^n]o_eajpÚ_]o$p]jpk`]o_ej_e]oat]p]oaj]pqn]eo_kik`]o_ej_e]odqi]j]oa `]ÚhkokÚ]%(_ki]i]jaen]`abkni]`]_kimqaÚhiaoajkrah]opn]p]iko]_kjpa_eiajpko deop ne_ko(ap_*Aihqc]n`aafcrpl`riqro^i(l]oo]]d]ranian]srid^ofw^ labfkcloj^ bp* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]ok^n]o`alajo]iajpk`aet]i`aoanejopec]`kn]o`a_kjda_eiajpk l]n] oa na`qven `erqhc]k nle`] a oeilhao `a e`ae]o _qf] _kilhate`]`a a eilknp j_e] Ú_]ilan`e`]o*
I]ooebe_]kranoqo`aik_n]pev]k_qhpqn]h Bkooai kqpn]o ]o _en_qjop j_e]o( ]o k^n]o `a ]npa a `a lajo]iajpk lk`ane]i( _kik `aoaf]r]>ajf]iej(`aik_n]pev]n)oa_kikojkrkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k(lkeopk`kolk`a) ne]i(ailnej_lek(pan]_aook]ah]o(_kjda_)h]o(ej_knlkn)h]oaioq]re`](_nepe_)h]o(ako ]npeop]oalajo]`knaolk`ane]ioqlan)h]oaikqpn]ok^n]o(jkr]o*
/2.
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
Oapki]niko]`riqro^jkoajpe`knaopnepk`ak^n]o`a]npaa`alajo]iajpkajkjk oajpe`k]jpnklkh ce_k]ilhk(mqa]lnaoajp]ikojkaopq`kok^na]e`ae]`a_qhpqn](lk`a) iko`evanmqa]`aik_n]pev]k`]_qhpqn]a`]]npapai_kiklna_kj`ek]e`ae]`amqako ^ajo_qhpqn]eookafobfqlabqlalpajklnerehcek`a]hcqjo*@aik_n]_e]_qhpqn]hoecjeÚ_] `enaepk`a]_aooka`abnqek`]ok^n]o_qhpqn]eo(`enaepkejbkni]kabkni]k_qhpqn]eo( `enaepklnk`qk_qhpqn]h* Kn](]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h]_]nnap]knaoqhp]`kklkopk]ki]ooeÚ_]nkmqa]mqeaop]iko _d]i]j`k`a`riqro^aioajpe`knaopnepk$eopk(k^n]o`a]npaa`alajo]iajpk%*Lknmq; Ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqaoal]n]ko^ajo_qhpqn]eolahkoaqoqlkopkr]hkn`aian_]`k6 dk^n]oÎ_]n]oÏaÎn]n]oÏ(`aopej]`]o]kolnerehace]`komqalk`ail]c]nlknah]o(bkni]j`k qi]ahepa_qhpqn]h7adk^n]oÎ^]n]p]oÏaÎ_kiqjoÏ(`aopej]`]oi]oo]*=ooei(airav`a c]n]jpen k iaoik `enaepk `a pk`ko pkp]he`]`a `] lnk`qk _qhpqn]h( ] ej`opne] _qhpqn]h ejpnk`qv]afsfplpl`f^iajpnaahepaÎ_qhp]Ïai]oo]Îej_qhp]Ï*Kmqa]i]oo];qi]cnac]`k oaibkni](oainkopk(oaie`ajpe`]`aaoailhajk`enaepk_qhpqn]* Aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqa`of^^firpl`amqapk`kopi]_aook]koiaoiko^ajo_qhpq) n]eo(_]`]qiao_khdaj`khernaiajpakmqa`aoaf](_kikk_kjoqie`knjqioqlanian_]`k* Jkajp]jpk(^]op]lnaop]niko]pajk]kodknneko`kolnkcn]i]o`an`ekapahareokkq]k mqaraj`e`kj]o^]j_]o`afknj]eol]n]ranikomqa(lahkolnako(]oailnao]o`a`erqhc]k _qhpqn]hfoaha_ekj]n]i`a]jpaikkmqa_]`]cnqlkok_e]hlk`aa`arakqren(rankqhan* Jk_]ok`kofknj]eoanareop]o(lknatailhk(]mq]he`]`a`kl]lah(kaopehk`]ohapn]oa ei]cajo(kpelk`ai]j_dapaa`ai]pne]lq^he_]`]`aÚjaik_kjoqie`kna`apaniej]i k_kjpa`k`]mqehk]mqapan]_aookakpelk`aejbkni]kmqalk`anna_a^an*Oa_kil]) n]niko(jqi]i]jd(_ej_kkqoaeofknj]eo(lan_a^anaikomqakiaoikiqj`kÍaopajk mq]hpk`koreraikoÍpn]jobkni])oaai_ej_kkqoaeoiqj`ko`ebanajpaokqiaoikklko) pko(lkeoqiiaoik]_kjpa_eiajpkna_a^a_ej_kkqoaeopn]p]iajpko`eranokoaibqjk`k haepknmqa]ailnao]fknj]hope_]lnapaj`a]pejcen* Aipan_aenkhqc]n(lknmqaejrajp]qi]Úcqn]_d]i]`]Îaola_p]`kni`ekÏ(Îkqrejpa i`ekÏaÎhaepkni`ekÏ(]komq]eook]pne^q`]o_anp]o_]l]_e`]`aoiajp]eoÎi`e]oÏ(_anpko _kjda_eiajpkoÎi`ekoÏa_anpkockopkoÎi`ekoÏ(kbana_aj`k)hdaolnk`qpko_qhpqn]eoÎi) `ekoÏ*MqaoecjeÚ_]eook; =ej`opne]_qhpqn]hsbkab_qhpqn]*L]n]raj`)h](`araoa`qvena]cn]`]nk_kjoqie`kn* L]n]oa`qve)hka]cn]`)hk(jklk`a_dk_)hk(lnkrk_)hk(b]v)hklajo]n(b]v)hkpanejbkni]) aojkr]omqaklanpqn^ai(i]o`ara`arkhran)hda(_kijkr]]l]nj_e](kmqaahafo]^a( freq(fbav*=Îi`e]Ïkoajok_kiqi`ofpq^ifw^almqa]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h`arkhra_ki _]n]`a_keo]jkr]*
(/2EUTERS,ATINSTOCK
Ko]pknaoO]i SknpdejcpkjaVka O]h`]j]$aioq] _]n]_panev]k`ecep]h% ai_aj]`kbehia =r]p]n(`a.,,5(`k `enapkn_]j]`ajoa F]iao?]iankj*
/2/
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Aimq]npkhqc]n(lknmqa`aÚja]_qhpqn]_kiki^wbobbkqobqbkfjbkql(afsboplbafp* qo^ l(`aik`kmqapq`kkmqaj]ok^n]o`a]npaa`alajo]iajpkoecjeÚ_]pn]^]hdk`] oajoe^ehe`]`a(`]ei]cej]k(`]ejpahecj_e](`]naÛatka`]_npe_]jkpaiejpanaooa(jk Îraj`aÏ*I]ooeÚ_]n(]ooei(_^k^ifw^o]atlnaook]npope_]aejpaha_pq]h*Aihqc]n`a`ebqj) `ena`erqhc]n]_qhpqn](`aolanp]j`kejpanaooalknah](]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hna]hev]]srid^of* w^ l`]o]npaoa`ko_kjda_eiajpko* Ao_narai=`knjkaDkngdaeian6 >^qolÛ^a^fj^dfk^ lba^bpmlkq^kbfa^abal`lkprjfalo`riqro^iabelgbkl qbjkb`bppfa^ababpbobumif`^a^bjqbojlpmpf`lidf`lp+Lpmomoflpmolarqlp%+++&m^o^* ifp^j^nrbi^pc^`ria^abpmbi^pr^momof^`lkpqfqrf ll_gbqfs^+Bibpplcbfqlpabjlal nrb^pr^^mobbkpl^abnr^a^bufdb)mlorji^al)o^mfabwabmbo`bm l)`^m^`fa^abab l_pbos^ lb`ljmbqk`f^bpmb`Û`^8mlolrqoli^al)cbfq^abjlal^sbq^o)abc^ql)^ ^qfsfa^abjbkq^ialbpmb`q^alo)pbbibklnrfpbomboabolpc^qlpnrbpbabpbkoli^jo^mf* a^jbkqb pr^cobkqb%+++&+>sflik`f^a^pl`fba^abfkarpqof^ilmbo^klpeljbkpabrj^ sbwmloqla^p+Lpmolarqlpa^fka pqof^`riqro^imlabjbpq^o`boqlpabpbobj^ibdobjbk* qb`lkprjfalpbjbpq^alabafpqo^ l+J^p`^a^rjabpqbprjjlabilaldfd^kqbp`l jb`^kfpjlb`lkjf`lnrbabpablfk`flj^kqjqralpl_mobpplq^kqlklqo^_^iel nr^kqlkli^wbonrbiebpbjbie^kqb+
Koiaeko`a_kiqje_]k MEIOSßEMßLATIM ßMEIOßSEß DIZßMmDIUMßE ßNOßPLURAL ß MEIOSßSEßDIZßMEDIAß/Sß PRIMEIROSßTEvRICOSßDOSß MEIOSßDEßCOMUNICAljOß EMPREGARAMßAßPALAVRAß LATINAßMEDIAß#OMOßERAMß TEvRICOSßDEßLqNGUAßINGLESA ß DIZIAMßMASSßMEDIA ßISTOß m ß±OSßMEIOSßDEßMASSA²ß !ßPRON{NCIA ßEMßINGLoS ß DOßLATIMßMEDIAßmß±MqDIA²ß 1UANDOßOSßTEvRICOSßDEß LqNGUAßINGLESAßDIZEMß±THEß MEDIA² ßESTjOßDIZENDOß±OSß MEIOS²ß0ORßAPROPRIAljOß DAßTERMINOLOGIAßDESSESß TEvRICOSßNOß"RASIL ßAßPA LAVRAßMqDIAßPASSOUßAßSERß EMPREGADAßCOMOßSEßFOSSEß UMAßPALAVRAßFEMININAßNOß SINGULARß°ß±AßMqDIA²
7AYNEß-ILLER-AGNUM,ATINSTOCK
=
atlnaookÎ_kiqje_]k`ai]oo]Ïbke_ne]`]l]n]nabanen)oa]kok^fapkopa_jkh ce_ko _]l]vao `a pn]joiepen ] iaoi] ejbkni]k l]n] qi l^he_k iqepk ]ilhk( eopk ( l]n]]i]oo]*Eje_e]hiajpa(nabane])oa]kn`eka]k_ejai](lkeo]eilnajo]lnaooq) lqjd]laook]o]hb]^apev]`]o(kmqajkan]namqane`klahkn`ekjailahk_ejai]aioaqo _kiako*Lkq_k]lkq_kaopaj`aq)oal]n]]eilnajo](]lq^he_e`]`akqlnkl]c]j`](]bkpk) cn]Ú](kpahabkja(kpahcn]bk(kbkj cn]bk_kiko`eo_koa]pahareok*Aooaok^fapkopa_jkh ce) _kookkojbflplknejpani`ek`komq]eo]ejbkni]kpn]joiepe`]kq_kiqje_]`]* K aopq`ekok `ko iaeko `a _kiqje_]k I]nod]hh I_Hqd]j _kil]nkq ]o `ebanaj]o la`]c ce_]oajpnakajoejk^]oa]`kjkhernkeilnaookakajoejk_kjpailkn jakmqaai) lnac]na_qnoko]q`ekreoq]eo*@evI_Hqd]jmqa(j]=jpecqe`]`aaj]E`]`aI`e](ko]hqjko ]lnaj`e]ikqrej`kklnkbaooknanalapej`kkmqaaha`eve](eopk(kajoejkan]bqj`]iaj) p]hiajpakn]haatece]cn]j`apn]^]hdk`]iai ne](d]raj`kiaoikp_je_]oaola_e]eol]n] ]lnaj`an]iaiknev]n*=hi`eook(jko_qnokoi]eo]r]j]`ko(]hi`]o]qh]o(koaopq`]jpao _kle]r]i kq lnk`qve]i l]n] oaq qok laook]h i]jqo_nepko `a cn]ipe_]( `e_ekjneko( aj) oej]iajpko^oe_ko`a]nepipe_]acakiapne]*Kajoejkak]lnaj`ev]`k(lknoanaikn]eo( an]i _khaperko( lkeo pk`ko ko aopq`]jpao `alaj`e]i `] ]qh] iejeopn]`] lahk lnkbaookn a iaiknev]r]ikajoej]iajpklkniaek`a`eo_qoo aoa`eolqp]o_kiko_khac]o* Aoo]oepq]k(`evI_Hqd]j(iq`kq_ki]_dac]`]`khernkeilnaook(lkeojko ko aopq`]jpaol]oo]n]i]pan]_aook]koiaoikoi]pane]eomqakolnkbaooknao(i]op]i^i ]o ]qh]o l]oo]n]i ] ]lke]n)oa jko ao_nepko( atecej`k iajko `] iai ne] `a lnkbaooknao a ]hqjko*=hi`eook(oqnceqkaopq`kokhepnekaej`ere`q]h_kik]hcki]eoeilknp]jpa`kmqa ]`eo_qooka]`eolqp]_khaper]o* Kn](lnkooacqaI_Hqd]j(aop]ikoraj`kkÚj]h`]Îc]hte]`aCqpaj^ancÏ$kqoaf](`k hernkeilnaook%(_ki]_dac]`]`kn`ek(`k`eo_k(`]pahareoka`k_kilqp]`knoao_kh]o* @ab]pk(kojkrkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]kokreoq]eoaokjknko(qo]iiqepklkq_k]ao_nep] $_kiat_ak`kfknj]heoikeilnaook%aaopeiqh]i]kn]he`]`a*=oao_kh]o(_kik]o`]=jpe) cqe`]`aa`]E`]`aI`e](]`kp]i_]`]ravi]eokona_qnoko]q`ekreoq]eol]n]kajoejkak ]lnaj`ev]`kanaejpnk`qvaikopn]^]hdko`acnqlka]o`eo_qoo ao_khaper]o* >ajf]iejb]h]r]aiÎnalnk`qpe^ehe`]`aÏ`]k^n]`a]npa7I_Hdq]jb]h]aiÎia_]jev]) kÏ`]atlnaookdqi]j]*Ao_naraaha(jqiajo]ekejpepqh]`kÎReok(okiabne]Ï6
-ARSHALLß-C,UHANßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEß EDUCADORßCANADENSE
/20
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
>kqbpa^fjmobkp^)rjibfqlobo^^idrjnrbafp`bokf^bplka^s^bkfdj^p+>mp ^fjmobkp^)m^pplr^pfdkfÛ`^o^idrjnrb`loof^lplielp)nrbbp`^mrif^^lilkdla^p prmboc`fbpalqbuqlfjmobppl+Elgbbjaf^)klÛk^iabq^imol`bppl)`ebd^jlp^^if^o^ e^_fifa^ababibosbilwjbkqb`lj^afpqo^ l)bjsbwab`lj^p^_balof^+J^p fjmobk* p^) jb`^kfw^ la^bp`ofq^)pr`babrklp`rilabwbklsb^clqldo^Û^bbjpbdrfa^^ jb`^kfw^ lalpdbpqlperj^klpklÛijb+>fpplpbdrfr*pb^jb`^kfw^ la^c^i^kl qbibclkb)klclkdo^clbkloafl+@ljl`fkbj^c^i^alb)Ûk^ijbkqb)`lj^qbibsfpl)pl* _obsbfl^jb`^kfw^ la^qlq^ifa^aba^bumobpplerj^k^)a^slw)aldbpqlba^Ûdro^ erj^k^bj^ l+@^a^rjabppbpbpqdflpa^jb`^kfw^ la^bumobpplerj^k^`lj* m^olr*pb)bjpbr j_fql) obslir labÜ^do^a^mbi^momof^jb`^kfw^ la^bp`ofq^+ Kmqakoiaeko$kqÎ]i`e]Ï%rae_qh]i;Kmqapn]joiepai;Ok^]bkni]`anki]j_ao( jkrah]o(_kjpko(jkp_e]o(ioe_]o(`a^]pao(`]j]o(fkcko(ahaopn]joiepaifkcloj^ bp*Aj) pqoe]oi]`k_kikoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k_kikra_qhko`aejbkni]k(I_Hqd]jao_nara jkiaoikajo]ek6 Bpq^^ml`^abqo^kpf la^bo^`ljbo`f^i)nr^kal^molar lbafpqof_rf lab rqfifa^abp^_plosf^lbkdbkelalpeljbkp+M^pp^jlpelgba^molar labjbo`^alof^p bjm^`lq^a^pm^o^lbjm^`lq^jbkqla^fkcloj^ l+>kqboflojbkqb)kpfks^a^jlp XÏkpÐ)^nrf)pllpBpq^alpRkfalp)bsfabkqbjbkqbZlpjbo`^alpbpqo^kdbfolp`ljrqfif* a^abp+Elgb)fks^afjlp`riqro^pfkqbfo^p`ljfkcloj^ lbki^q^a^)afsboplbfabf^p+ Kn](at]p]iajpaaoo]fks^pl`riqro^i(_kil]_kpao`aejbkni] ao(e`ae]oa`erano ao mqajk`ara_]qo]najpqoe]oikaoeinaÛatk(lkj`an]ka_npe_](lkeolna_eoklancqj) p]n6mqai]olnk`qv;(mqai]oail]_kp];(mqai]o`eopne^qe;(l]n]mqaiok`eopne^q`]o;( _kimqaÚj]he`]`a;
=lnkl]c]j`]
PROPAGANDAßAßPALAVRAß PROPAGANDAßDERIVAßDOßVER BOßPROPAGAR ßQUEßSIGNIFICAß ±MULTIPLICARßUMAßESPmCIEß PORßMEIOßDAßREPRODUljO² ß ±ESPALHAR SEßPORßUMßTERRI TvRIO² ß±AUMENTARßNUME RICAMENTEßPORßCONTfGIO² ß ±IRRADIAR SE² ß±DIFUNDIR SE²ß E ßPORßEXTENSjO ß±DIVULGAR²ß !ßPROPAGANDAßmßUMAß DIFUSjOßEßUMAßDIVULGA ljOßDEßIDEIAS ßVALORES ß OPINIzES ßINFORMAlzESß PARAßOßMAIORßN{MEROßDEß PESSOASßNOßMAISßAMPLOß TERRITvRIOßPOSSqVELßbßCOMß ESSEßSENTIDOßQUEßFALAMOSß EMßPROPAGANDAßRELIGIOSAß EßEMßPROPAGANDAßPOLqTICAß !MBAS ßPORQUEßSEßDIRIGEMß PUBLICAMENTEßAOßMAIORß N{MEROßPOSSqVELßDEßß PESSOAS ßSjOßFORMASßß DEßPUBLICIDADE
/21
Ailnac]j`k]o]npaocnÚ_]o(]bkpkcn]Ú](]ioe_](]`]j]a]lkaoe]a`ebqj`ej`k)oa lkniaek`afknj]eo(nareop]o(_]np]vao(n`ekapahareok$kqoaf](lah]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h%(] lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]h]`ebqoka`erqhc]k`alnk`qpko`aopej]`koraj`]a`enece`ko ]_kjoqie`knao*Ah]p]i^ina_a^akjkia`amr_if`fa^ab`ljbo`f^i(lknmqabaep]lq^he) _]iajpakqoa`eneca]kl^he_kajpaj`e`k_kik_kjoqie`kn*Aoo]lnkl]c]j`]klan]lkn iaek`a6 -*
atlhe_] aooeilheÚ_]`]oaahkcekoat]can]`kook^nakolnk`qpko7
.*
pild^kp_qnpkomqalkoo]ioanb]_ehiajpacn]r]`ko7
/*
]l]najpaejbkni]kalnaop]k`aoanrek]k_kjoqie`kn7
0*
c]n]jpe]`amqak_kjoqie`knoanecq]h]pk`kiqj`kajkqi`aohk_]`k$lkeo_kj) oqienkmqakqpnko_kjokiai%(i]o(]kiaoikpailk(oan`ebanajpa`apk`kiqj`k $lkeoklnk`qpkhda`]nqi]ej`ere`q]he`]`aaola_e]h%*
L]n]oanaÚ_]v(]lnkl]c]j`]`arana]hev]n`q]oklan] aooeiqhp ja]o6lknqih]`k( `ara]Úni]nmqaklnk`qpklkooqekor]hknaoaop]^aha_e`kolah]ok_ea`]`aaimqaoaaj_kj) pn]k_kjoqie`kn$lknatailhk(oa]re`]aib]ihe]iqepkr]hknev]`](kolnk`qpko`arai ]l]na_an]oanrek`]ia(`kl]e(`koÚhdko(`]deceajaa^ahav]`kh]n(`]o]`a`]o_ne]j]o( `]bahe_e`]`a_kjfqc]h(ap_*%a(lknkqpnk(]hi`a`aolanp]n`aoafkomqak_kjoqie`knjk lkooq](lna_eo](ok^napq`k(]ooacqn]n]o]peob]k`aooao`aoafko$`kj`akpild^kÎoq]o]peo) b]kc]n]jpe`]kqoaq`ejdaenk`arkhp]Ï%* Aioaqo_kiako(`ao`aÚjo`ko_qhkTET]pkoia]`ko`ko_qhkTT(]lnkl]c]j) `] _kian_e]h oq^hejd]r] a ahkce]r] ]o mq]he`]`ao `k lnk`qpk6 ]lnaoajp]r]( lkn atailhk( koabaepko_qn]perko`konai`eko(koabaepkodeceje_ko`ko]^k(`ko]^kjapaa`]l]op]`a `ajpao(k_kjbknpk`aqi]ik^he](k^kickopk`aqi]la]`ankql]`]ik`]*Lk`e]p]i) ^i]lnaoajp]naoo]omq]he`]`aokbana_aj`k]l]h]rn]`a]hcqiaola_e]heop]mqal]npe_el]n]
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
`]b]^ne_]k`klnk`qpkkqmqakqo]n]akna_kiaj`]r]$b]h]r]ii`e_ko(`ajpeop]o(b]n) i]_qpe_ko(`kj]o`a_]o](ik`eop]o(ap_*%*?kikj]an]`]ok_ea`]`aej`qopne]hkolnk`qpko an]ir]hknev]`kolknoq]`qn]^ehe`]`a(]lnkl]c]j`]paj`e]]ejrajp]nqi]ei]cai`qn]) `kqn]mqaoapknj]r]qi]aol_ea`aj^o`^l]n]kna_kjda_eiajpkeia`e]pk`klnk`qpk ab]_ehiajpanalape`]lknpk`ko*Aoo]Îi]n_]Ïlk`e]oan]ai^]h]cai$aih]p]o`aiap]hkq aire`nko_kibkni]_]n]_panope_]%(qi`aoajdk(qipild^k(qi]lamqaj]iahk`e](qi] nei](mqalaniepe]knle`kna_kjda_eiajpk`klnk`qpklkniqepkoaiqepko]jko*Qi] `]olnkl]c]j`]oi]eo_kjda_e`]oa`ahkjc]`qn]kbkeqo]`](`ao`ako]jko-5/,(lknqi] ej`opne]`a]l]nahdko`an`ekabkj cn]bko(]N?=Re_pkn(_qf]Îi]n_]Ïan]qi_k_kik kqre`kln teik`aqicn]ikbkjaaok^kmq]hd]re]ko`evanaoÎ=rkv`k`kjkÏ(l]n]oqcanen Ú`ahe`]`a`kokiaÚ`ahe`]`a`k_kjoqie`kn*Jko]jko-50,(lknatailhk(d]re]iahk`e]o apild^kpl]n]qi]j]hcoe_k$ÎIahdkn]hiahdknajkb]vi]hÏ%(l]n]qilanbqialklq) h]n$Î?]odiana>kqmqap(]bn]cn j_e]`anko]ol]n]rk_Ï%(l]n]qiÚt]`kn`a_]^ahko$ÎHat `qn]hat(jk_]^ahko CqiatÏ%(l]n]qi]^nehd]jpej]$ÎChkopkn](]^nehd]jpej]mqakdkiai ]`kn]Ï%*Jko]jko-51,(d]re]qi`aoajdk_]n]_panope_k$]nko]`korajpko%]_kil]jd]`k`a qi]bn]oaiah `e_]ln lne]_kimqak_kjoqie`kneia`e]p]iajpae`ajpeÚ_]r]qi]_ki) l]jde]]na](]R]nec*=lnkl]c]j`]p]i^i^qo_]r]]Úni]nac]n]jpenklnk`qpkpn]vaj`k kjkia`kb]^ne_]jpa_kiklnkr]`]mq]he`]`a$cq]n]j`]=jp]n_pe_](_anraf]`]>n]di]( pa_e`k`a]hck`k`]=ine_]B]^nehkq`]>]jcq(k>ekpje_k`kH]^kn]p nekBkjpkqn]%kq _kikc]n]jpe]`]at_hqoere`]`a$Î?de_hapao(]`ah_e]mqao =`]iob]^ne_]Ï%* ?kik]qiajpk`]_kilapekajpnalnk`qpknaoa`eopne^qe`knao(_kik_nao_eiajpk `kian_]`k`]ik`](_kik]`rajpk`]ok_ea`]`al o)ej`qopne]h_qfkolnk`qpkook`ao_]n) praeo(oai`qn]^ehe`]`a$]ok_ea`]`al o)ej`qopne]h]Îok_ea`]`a`k`ao_]npaÏ%a`a_kjoq) ikeia`e]pk$]heiajpkoanabae aoejop]jp jako%(aok^napq`kia`e`]mqalaomqeo]o`a ian_]`kej`e_]imqa]oraj`]o`alaj`ai`]_]l]_e`]`a`ai]jelqh]n`aoafko`k_kjoq) ie`kna]piaoik`a_ne]n`aoafkojaha(]lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]hbke`aet]j`k`a]lnaoajp]n klnk`qpklnklne]iajpa`epk$_kioq]olnklnea`]`ao(mq]he`]`ao(`qn]^ehe`]`a%l]n]]Ún) i]nko`aoafkomqaahana]hev]ne]6oq_aook(lnkolane`]`a(oacqn]j](fqrajpq`aapanj](^ahav]( ]pn]koatq]h(bahe_e`]`a* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]lnkl]c]j`]kqlq^he_e`]`a_kian_e]hl]ookq]sbkabofj^dbkpb pfdklpajk]oln lne]oian_]`kne]o* =ooei(lknatailhk(]p^ailkq_kpailk(l]n]raj`anqi_anpk_ec]nnk(airav`a ]lnaoajp)hk`enap]iajpa(aioaqhqc]n]l]na_e]iikpk_e_hap]o(rahaenko(_knne`]o`a]qpk) i raeoakpild^kÎkoq_aookÏ*Kqoaf](raj`e])oa]ei]cai`koq_aookl]n]]mq]hk_ec]nnk oapknj]n]ejopnqiajpkej`eolajorah*Qi]kqpn]i]n_]`a_ec]nnkl]oo]r]]_kilapen_ki ]]jpanekna(aihqc]n`kln lnek_ec]nnk(]lnaoajp]r]qiln`ekai_kjopnqk_kiajca) jdaenkoa]nmqepapko^ai)oq_a`e`kobqi]j`k(akpild^k(Î]i]n_]ejpahecajpaÏ*Kqoaf](raj) `e])oak_ec]nnk]lah]j`k)oal]n]]ei]cai`komqaan]iejpahecajpaoalkneookkao_khde]i* =ooei(p]i^i(aihqc]n`]i]jpaec]a`]i]nc]nej]_kioq]olnklnea`]`aoamq]he`]`ao( ]l]na_a]b]ihe]bahevpki]j`kk_]b`]i]jda_kjoqiej`kklnk`qpk(eopk(raj`a)oa] ei]cai`]bahe_e`]`aa`]d]nikje]`kiope_]ol]n]]omq]eo]i]nc]nej]kqi]jpaec]] _kj`ekej`eolajorah*=ooeip]i^i(aihqc]n`ko]^kjapaa`k`aok`kn]jpa(_kioq]o lnklnea`]`aoamq]he`]`ao(oqnca]ei]cai`]oajoq]he`]`a`]iqhdankq`kdkiaimqako qo]i*K]qpki rah]lnaoajp]`k_kiklnkr]`aoq_aook(_d]niaoatq]haejpahecj_e]`k _kjoqie`kn(ok^napq`kmq]j`kokajb]pev]`]o]oejkr] aopa_jkh ce_]o`kra_qhk(_qfk _kjoqiklnaooql a]ei]cai`aqi]laook]ik`anj]a]pq]hev]`]*A]ooeilkn`e]jpa* =lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]hp]i^ipb^molmof^`a]pepq`ao(kleje aoalkoe ao_npe_]o kqn]`e_]eoateopajpaoj]ok_ea`]`a(bps^wf^oaq_kjpa`kok_e]hkqlkhpe_ka]oejraopajqi lnk`qpk(pn]jobkni]j`k)]oaiik`]_kjoqirahal]oo]caen]*Baiejeoik(cqannehd]nark) hq_ekjne](ikreiajpko_qhpqn]eo`alanebane](he^an]koatq]h(`enaepkodqi]jko(ap_*ok pn]jobkni]`koaimq]he`]`aomqaraj`aiqilnk`qpk* I]ojko eook*=lq^he_e`]`ajkoa_kjpajp]ai_kjopnqenei]cajo_ki]omq]eok _kjoqie`knoae`ajpeÚ_]alkneook_kjokiakolnk`qpko*Ah]ko]lnaoajp]_kikob^ifw^ l
/22
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
$ANIELß,OBO7IKIPmDIA
FUGACIDADEßEßEFEMERIDA DEßREFERoNCIA ßEMßLINHASß GERAIS ßgßDROMOLOGIA ßTEO RIAßDOßURBANISTAßEßFILvSOFOß FRANCoSß0AULß6IRILIO ßgßMO DERNIDADEßLqQUIDA ßTEORIAß DOßSOCIvLOGOßPOLONoSß:YG MUNTß"AUMAN ßEßgßTEORIAß DOßEFoMERO ßDOßFILvSOFOß FRANCoSß'ILLESß,EPVOTSKY
$AVIDß(ARVEYß ßß GEvGRAFOßMARXISTAßß BRIThNICO
ababpbglpmqak_kjoqie`knjaio]^e]mqapejd]al]oo]]panÍqi]nkql]kqqilanbq) iaok]ook_e]`ko]re]cajo]l]oao`eop]jpaoaat pe_kokq]qi]nah]koatq]hb]jpope_]7 qiqpajohek`kiope_kkqqio]^kail ok]lnaoajp]`ko_kik]oqlnai]`abao]`k baiejeoik(he^an]j`k]iqhdan`]ohe`ao_]oaen]o7qi]heiajpkl]n]_ne]j]o]lnaoajp]`k _kikc]n]jpe]`ao]`aa]hacne]ejb]jpeo(`aolanp]j`kj]_ne]j]k`aoafk`a_kjoqie)hka har]j`k]iakqkl]e]]`mqene)hklknmqaaolan]ic]jd]npn]jmqehe`]`aa_anpav]`a^ai ]heiajp]nkoÚhdko* Reopk(lkni(mqa]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja]kql o)ik`anj]]mqah]aimqapq`k rahkv(bqc]vaabiank(`ao]l]na_aj`k`]jkepal]n]k`e](]lnkl]c]j`]lna_eo]]_kil]) jd]naooanepik*?kieook(ah]`aoajrkhra]e`ae]`amqaoq]aÚ__e]a_kilapepere`]`aoank i]eknaojkoeilhaoiajpalkn]cenok^nako`aoafkofateopajpaoaoeilknoq]_]l]_e`]`a l]n]ejrajp]n`aoafkojkrkoai]jelqh)hko`a]_kn`k_kik_kjoqik`alnk`qpkooailna jkrkoabqc]vao* I]o]lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]hr]e]ej`]i]eohkjca*@ab]pk(_kikqlalplpfkafsarlppl jbo`^alof^pnrb`lkpljbjjbo`^alof^p(]lnkl]c]j`]l]oo]]aopeiqh]nei]cajo`aej`er) `qkoraj_a`knaoj]_kilapekejopepq`]lahkian_]`k`apn]^]hdk6nkql]o(_]h]`ko(^kho]o al]op]o`acneba(o]^kjapao(lanbqiaoa`aok`kn]jpaomqaoqcanainamqejpaadi^jlro(_ko) ipe_ko`ai]n_]ob]iko]o(ap_*(l]oo]i]_kjopepqenkln lnek_knlk`kej`er`qk(bkni]i oq]ei]cai_kikqi]aol_ea`apbdrka^k^qrobw^kq`ajp`^o^_kh]`]aioq]laha* =aooanaolaepk(ao_nara@]re`D]nraujkhernk>`lkaf lmp*jlabok^6 >`ljmbqf lkljbo`^alab`lkpqor labfj^dbkpm^pp^^pborj^pmb`qlsfq^i a^`lk`look`f^bkqob^pbjmobp^p+Lpr`bpplql`i^o^jbkqbir`o^qfslnrblfksbpqf* jbkqlk^`lkpqor la^fj^dbj%m^qol`kfla^p^oqbp)bumlpf bpab^oqbp)molar bp qbibsfpfs^p)bq`+&pbqlok^qlfjmloq^kqbnr^kqllfksbpqfjbkqlbjkls^pc_of`^pbj^* nrfkofl+>fj^dbjpbosbm^o^bpq^_bib`borj^fabkqfa^abkljbo`^al)lnrbpb^mif`^ q^j_j^ljbo`^alabqo^_^iel+>^nrfpf labrj^fj^dbj%mlojbfla^`ljmo^ab rjpfpqbj^abpfdklp`ljlolrm^pabdofcbbl`^oola^jla^&pbqlok^rjbibjbkql pfkdri^ojbkqbfjmloq^kqbk^^rql^mobpbkq^ lklpjbo`^alpabqo^_^ielb)mlobuqbk* pl)m^pp^^pbom^oqbfkqbdo^kqba^_rp`^abfabkqfa^abfkafsfar^i)^rqloob^ifw^ lb pfdkfÛ`^ala^sfa^+
N`ekapahareok
/23
Kolneiaenkoaopq`kook_ekh ce_ko(loe_kh ce_koaÚhko Ú_kook^nakoiaeko`a_kiq) je_]k`ai]oo]bkn]ibaepkomq]j`koa`aq]atl]jok`]okj`]o`an`ek*I]eo`kmqa k pahabkja( k pahcn]bk oai Úk a k bkj cn]bk( k n`ek `aolanpkq ejpanaooa lknmqa _ki aha eje_ekq)oaabaper]iajpa]ejbkni]ka]_kiqje_]k`ai]oo]]`eop j_e]* @keob]pko(k_]ok`]pn]joieookn]`ekbje_]`a>drboo^alpjrkalpakqok`aiajo]) cajon]`ekbje_]olahkj]veoik(jko]fq`]i]lan_a^ankeil]_pka]eilknp j_e]`kn`ek* Jkoia]`ko`ko]jko-5/,(kfkraiKnokjSahhao(]pkna`enapkn`a_ejai](enn]`ekq lknqi]n`ek`aJkr]Ukngknki]j_a`aD*C*Sahho(>drboo^alpjrkalp(mqaj]nn]r]] ejr]ok`]Pann]lkni]n_e]jko*KnokjSahhaoaoq]pqni]jk]reo]n]ikl^he_k`amqa oapn]p]r]`aqi]k^n]`aÚ_k_eajpÚ_](i]o]]lnaoajp]n]i_kikoa`ab]pkJkr]Ukng aoperaooaoaj`kejr]`e`]lkn]heajcaj]o*Kl je_kpkikq]_e`]`a(laook]obqcen]i`aoq]o _]o]o(lnk_qn]j`kpnajo(je^qo(iapnoa]qpki raeol]n]ao_]l]n`]]ia]]*A`alkeok l je_kpkikqkl]o(oaj`kja_aoonekmqakckranjkakatn_epkjknpa)]iane_]jkoejpan) reaooail]n]]_]hi]n]lklqh]k* =pn]joieook`a>drboo^alpjrkalpikopnkqklk`an`alanoq]oka`a_kjraj_e) iajpk`kn`ekajkoatlhe_]koacqj`kb]pk(eopk(oaqqok_kpe`e]jkaejpajokbaepklahk lk`anj]veop]]haik_kiÚj]he`]`a`alnkl]c]j`]lkhpe_]*?kjbanj_e]o`aejpaha_pq]eo j]veop]o(`eo_qnoko`aDephan(ajpnareop]o_kiiehep]jpao`kl]npe`kj]veop]apn]joieook`a jkp_e]o`enap]iajpa`]obnajpao`acqann]bkn]iailnac]`kol]n]_kjraj_an]ok_ea`]`a
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
]haiok^na]cn]j`av](fqopav]alk`anek`kj]veoik*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(kj]veoik`ao_k) ^neqaatlhknkq]`^m^`fa^abjl_fifw^alo^`kn`ek* Jk>n]oeh(jko]jko-50,(`qn]jpa]`ep]`qn]`aCaphekR]nc]o(bke_ne]`klahkckranjk qilnkcn]i]`enekl]n]pn]joiepen]ojkp_e]okÚ_e]eoa]oe`ae]o`k`ep]`kn6]Slwal?o^pfi( ateopajpa]pdkfa* @aecq]heil]_pkalk`an`a_kjraj_eiajpk]pahareok*L]n]_kiajp]na_nepe_]naooa lk`anek( k _ejai] lnk`qveq ]hcqjo Úhiao* Ko i]eo ejpanaoo]jpao bkn]i Obab ab fkqofd^p( Jbo^`lfk`fak`f^aLpeltabQorj^k* Obababfkqofd^p$ppqhkaimqa]l]h]rn]obabpai`qlhkoajpe`k(oecjeÚ_]j`kÎna`a`a pahareokÏaÎpn]i]`aejpnec]oÏ%j]nn]]i]jaen]_kikqifknj]heop]`ajkpe_eneko`apahare) ok(mqad]re]]_]^]`k`aoan`aiepe`k(jkhpeiklnkcn]i]naokhra`evanpk`]o]oran`]`ao mqaoailnabkn]eila`e`k`a`evan*Koq_aook`aooahpeiklnkcn]i]bkepkcn]j`amqa ]na`a`apahareok(aihqc]n`a`aiepe)hk(]qiajpkq)hdako]hneka`aq)hdaqilnkcn]i] at_hqoerk(aina`aj]_ekj]h(jkmq]haha_kjrk_]r]]lklqh]k]cnep]n_kjpn]koeopai]*Kq oaf](koeopai]hdal]c]r]l]n]cnep]n_kjpn]ahalknmqaklnkcn]i]pejd]]hpooei]]q`ej_e] ad]re]ailnao]ol]c]j`kna`aiehd ao`a` h]naol]n]l]pnk_ej)hk*KÚhiapaniej]_ki k]pkn_kiapaj`koqe_`ekaibnajpao_ ian]o(]krerkaai_knao(a_ki]na`analapej`k ]_aj]lknmqa]]q`ej_e]an]ajkniaakhq_nkÚj]j_aenkeiajok*Kqoaf](koeopai]a]na`a `apahareokraj_an]i* AiJbo^`lfk`fak`f^(k]ooaookn`klnaoe`ajpa`koAop]`koQje`ko(`qn]jpa]_]il]) jd]lah]naahaek(pai`aeila`en]mqa`]`]lklqh]ne`]`a`klnaoe`ajpa_]qo]`]lknqi ao_ j`]hkoatq]h*?kjpn]p]qib]ikoklnk`qpkn`a_ejai]`aDkhhuskk`l]n]okhq_ekj]nk lnk^hai]*=okhqk_kjoeopaaiejrajp]nqilnk^hai]i]eonqiknkok`kmqakao_ j`]hk oatq]h(mqal]ooa]k_ql]n]klejekl^he_]*Mqalnk^hai]ejrajp]n;Qi]cqann]aiqil]o `]Aqnkl]_ajpn]ha]ejpanrajk`klnaoe`ajpajknpa)]iane_]jka`katn_epk`koAop]`ko Qje`kol]n]o]hr]nkoejk_ajpao(rpei]o`apannkneop]oacqannehdaenko* Qo]j`kna_qnokopa_jkh ce_koiqepk]r]j]`koaokÚope_]`ko(klnk`qpkn_ejai]pkcn) Ú_kjko ejrajp]qi]cqann]_kilhap](_kijkpe_enekoÎ]krerkÏ`]Îbnajpa`a^]p]hd]Ïa nalknp]cajo_ki]oÎrpei]oÏ(_kik]ej`]ikopn]]rep ne]jknpa)]iane_]j]a_ne]qiokh`]) `kdan e(mqaoane`kh]pn]`klah]klejekl^he_]*Are`ajpaiajpa(klnaoe`ajpabkenaahaepk* K_eja]op](_kjpq`k(Ú_]ajpqoe]oi]`k_kikoq_aook`aoq]ejrajk(l]oo]]]_na`ep]njah] amqanmqa]Îcqann]Ï_kjpejqa*K]ooaooknlnaoe`aj_e]hajpkhda`ev6Î=cqann]]_]^kq*@aq j]pahareokÏ*Aoo]bn]oalanbaep](lkeo_kiah]k]ooaooknlnaoe`aj_e]h`ev]k_eja]op]mqa pk`]amq]hmqanejrajkoapknj]na]he`]`a`ao`amqa]lnaoajp]`]lah]pahareokamqa(lkn) p]jpk(]ooei_kik]pahareokbavateopenqi]cqann](]ooeip]i^ibav_kimqak_kjÛepk paniej]ooa*K_eja]op](lkni(]_na`ep]mqac]jd]nqiKo_]noa_kjp]nmqabkek]qpkn`] cqann]*L]n]arep]naooalaneck(k]ooaooknlnaoe`aj_e]h_d]i]kOanrekOa_napk(mqai]p]k _eja]op]*Jkr]iajpa(raj_akoeopai](cn]]opahareok* LpeltabQorj^kb]vqifkck`al]h]rn]oaiejcho_kikork_^qhkoqorb(j^ka pelt*Qorj^kqijkialn lnek(qiok^najkia7qorbmqan`evanÎran`]`aenkÏ7j^kmqan `evanÎdkiaiÏ7peltoecjeÚ_]Îaolap_qhkÏakran^kqlpeltmqan`evanÎikopn]nÏ*Kppqhk `ev(lknp]jpk6ÎAolap_qhk`aPnqi]jÏkqÎAolap_qhk`kdkiairan`]`aenkÏ* @amqapn]p]kÚhia;@aqifkrai(Pnqi]j(_qf]b]ihe]kraj`aq(]kj]o_an(l]n]qi lnkcn]i]`apahareok(kQorj^kPelt(pn]joiepe`k]krerk`qn]jparejpaamq]pnkdkn]o l]n] pk`kkl]o*Pnqi]jjk o]^a mqa qi] lanokj]cai `a pahareok ajko]^a mqa ] _e`]`avejd]kj`aj]o_aq(_nao_aqarera(]ao_kh]mqabnamqajpkq(kailnackmqalkooqe( ]olaook]omqa_kjda_aa_kimqai_kjrerajkateopaina]hiajpa*Jko]^amqa(`ao`ak j]o_eiajpk(rerajqi_ajnekamqareopklknpk`kkl]opk`]o]odkn]o`k`e]*Lkn]_]ok( qi `e] `ao_k^na ] ran`]`a a pai `a pki]n qi] `a_eok aooaj_e]h6 lani]ja_an j] Ú_k _kikaolap_qhk$pelt%kqpknj]n)oaqidkiairan`]`aenk$aiejcho(qorbj^k%aikopn]n $aiejcho(qlpelt%]ran`]`a(ajbnajp]j`k)]*Ahaklp]nlah]oacqj`]]hpanj]per](i]okmqa eilnaooekj]jparankl^he_k]_kil]jd]n]pki]`]`a`a_eokran`]`aen]_kikoabkooa
/24
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
qiaolap_qhk`aÚ_k*Pnqi]j`eopejcqaajpnana]he`]`aaÚ_k(i]okl^he_kfjk `eopejcqaajpnaran`]`aaiajpen](bkqlomb`fallah]pahareok* AooaÚhiaejolenkqqilnkcn]i]`apahareokdkh]j`o(_kle]`kai`q]orano aolah] pahareok ^n]oehaen]6 @^p^ alp ^oqfpq^p a ?fd _olqebo* = i]ekne] `k l^he_k ^n]oehaenk p]hrav jko]e^]kmqaoaf]amqaioaf]k>ec>nkpdan(kqkCn]j`aEnik*qi]lanokj]cai`k nki]j_a`aCakncaKnsahh(.651* KCn]j`aEnik
/25
Knki]j_a$ao_nepkai-504(`]p]ejranpe`]l]n]-540%`ao_naraqi]ok_ea`]`apkp]hep) ne]j]mq]hpk`kooklani]jajpaiajparece]`kolkn_ ian]o`apahareok*=kejbnejcenai ]hcqi]nacn]kqhae(oklnaokoapknpqn]`ko(_kj`e_ekj]`kol]n]jkrkhp]n]ann]n*=olaook]o jk_kjreraiqi]o_ki]okqpn]o(oajpaiokhe`kaja_aooe`]`a`aoa_kiqje_]n*L]n]eook( pk`koko`e]oarne]oravaolkn`e]Î_kjrano]iÏ_kiqi]pah]`apahareokj]mq]hdqinko) pk^kj`kok(k>ec>nkpdan(kCn]j`aEnik(mqakorece]ahdaob]h](oaij]ran`]`a`evan)hdao j]`](]jkoan`]n)hdaokn`ajo*Jaoo]ok_ea`]`aateopakÎIejeopnek`]Ran`]`aÏ(_qf]bqjk lnk`qven]iajpen](aheiej]j`ka`abkni]j`kb]pko(laook]oa]_kjpa_eiajpkolkniaek`a j]nn]per]ob]ho]o(]oanrek`klk`an`k>ec>nkpdan*Jah]p]i^ibke_ne]`]]ÎJkrehjcq]Ï( qi`al]np]iajpkaj_]nnac]`k`aiq`]nkoajpe`k`]ol]h]rn]o_kjbkniako`aoafko`k>ec >nkpdan(eila`ej`kmqa]olaook]o_kilnaaj`]ikran`]`aenkoajpe`k`ah]o* Aoo]deop ne]pannrahok^nak_kjpnkha`a_knlko(_kn] aoaiajpao`]olaook]olknoeo) pai]o_nqeo`areceh j_e]aiok_ea`]`aopkp]hepne]oparaoaq_kjpa`k_npe_kejpaen]iajpa aor]ve]`k]koanren`aik`ahkl]n]qilnkcn]i]`apahareokÎajcn]]`ka`eranpe`kÏ(qi bkqobqbkfjbkql(_kik]_kjpa_a_kipq`kj]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h* @koiaeko`a_kiqje_]k(oai`re`](kn`eka]pahareoki]jebaop]ii]eo`kmqa pk`kokokqpnko]mqahaopn]ko`]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hmqa]lkjp]ikojkej_ek`aopa_]lpqhk( lkeo]i^kookjbo`^alof^pnrbsbkabjjbo`^alof^pj]bkni]`aejbkni]k(ajpnapaje) iajpkah]van* ?kia]iejpnk`qvej`k`q]o`ereo ao6]`kl^he_k$]o_d]i]`]oÎ_h]ooaoÏ=(>(?a@%a ]`kodknneko$]lnkcn]i]koaknc]jev]aidknnekoaola_Ú_komqa_ki^ej]i]Î_h]ooaÏ( ]k_ql]kÍ`kj]o`a_]o](pn]^]hd]`knao^n]]eo(lnkÚooekj]eohe^an]eo(ata_qperkoÍ(] e`]`aÍ_ne]j]o(]`khao_ajpao(]`qhpkoÍakoatk%* Aoo] `ereok baep] l]n] ]paj`an o atecj_e]o `ko l]pnk_ej]`knao( mqa Új]j_e]i ko lnkcn]i]opaj`kaireop]ko_kjoqie`knaolkpaj_e]eo`aoaqolnk`qpkoa(lknp]jpk(_ne]i] aola_eÚ_]k`k_kjpa`ka`kdknnek`a_]`]lnkcn]i]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(k_kjpa`k(] bkni]akdknnek`klnkcn]i]fpn]vaiaioaqln lnekejpanekn]i]n_]`kl]pnk_ej]`kn* Iqep]oravao(kl]pnk_ej]`knÚj]j_e]qilnkcn]i]mqaj]`]pai]ran(`enap]iajpa( _kik_kjpa`ka]bkni]rae_qh]`ko*Ahakb]vlknmqa(jaooa_]ok(jkaopraj`aj`kqi lnk`qpk(i]o]fj^dbj`aoq]ailnao]*]ooei(lknatailhk(mqaqi]ailnao]`a_koi) pe_kolk`a(aihqc]n`al]pnk_ej]nqilnkcn]i]baiejejk(l]pnk_ej]n_kj_anpko`aioe_] _hooe_]7qi]naraj`a`kn]`aikpk_e_hap]o(aihqc]n`al]pnk_ej]nqilnkcn]i]l]n]]`k) hao_ajpao(lk`al]pnk_ej]nqilnkcn]i]ok^naa_khkce]* =Úcqn]`kl]pnk_ej]`kn`apaniej]k_kjpa`ka]bkni]`akqpnkolnkcn]i]o(]ej`] mqa jk l]pnk_ej]`ko lkn aha* Lkn atailhk( qi ^]j_k `a qi ckranjk aop]`q]h lk`a l]) pnk_ej]nqilnkcn]i]`a]q`ep nek(lkeoeook_kjrajeajpal]n]]pn]en_heajpao(i]olk`a( ej`enap]iajpa(ejÛqaj_e]nk_kjpa`krae_qh]`klahkojkpe_eneko*Lknmq; Lknmqa]mq]jpe`]`a`a`ejdaenkl]c]lahk^]j_kn`ekkqpahareokl]n]klnkcn]) i]`a]q`ep nekiqepkahar]`]aejpanaoo]]kolnklneapneko`]mqah]n`ekkqpahareok*Oa kjkpe_enek]lnaoajp]njkp_e]o`aob]rknraeo]kckranjk`kAop]`k]kmq]hlanpaj_ak^]j) _k(aopalk`aoqolaj`ankl]pnk_jek`klnkcn]i]`a]q`ep nek*L]n]jklan`ank_heajpa(] aieookn]`an`ekkq`apahareokjkrae_qh]jkp_e]o`aob]rknraeomqahackranjka(lekn( rae_qh]]laj]o]omqahdaokb]rknraeo*@aoo]i]jaen](k`enaepkejbkni]k`ao]l]na_a(a kokqrejpaokqpahaola_p]`knaook`aoejbkni]`kokqÚ_]ii]hejbkni]`ko*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
'ILLESß0ERESS-AGNUM,ATINSTOCK
=`aoejbkni]k(]heo(klnej_el]hnaoqhp]`k`]i]ekne]`kojkpe_eneko`an`ekapa) hareok*?kiabaepk(_kikok]lnaoajp]`]o]ojkp_e]o;@aik`kcan]h(ok]lnaoajp]`]o`a i]jaen]]eila`enmqakkqrejpaakaola_p]`knlkoo]ihk_]hev)h]ojkaol]kajkpailk* C^iq^abil`^ifw^ lbpm^`f^i6kaol]kna]hk]l]nahdk`an`eka]pah]`]pahareok(mqa pi]la_qhe]ne`]`a`anapen]n]o`ebanaj]oa`eop j_e]ocakcnÚ_]o(`ap]hik`kmqa]hck ]_kjpa_e`kj]?dej](j]æj`e](jkEn]mqa(jkoAop]`koQje`kokqai?]ilej]Cn]j`al]na] ecq]hiajpaln teikaecq]hiajpa`eop]jpa*@klkjpk`areop]`]pah](aj_dajpaojqireh]na) fkajqi]_e`]`a`aIej]oCan]eookecq]hiajpaln tei]oaecq]hiajpa`eop]jpao*]ooei( lknatailhk(mqako]_kjpa_eiajpkojk`e]--`aoapai^nk`a.,,-j]_e`]`a`aJkr]Ukng $]`aopnqek`]o`q]opknnao`kSknh`Pn]`a?ajpan%bkn]ioajpe`ko_kicn]j`aaikkjk >n]oeh(_kiiqep]olaook]onabanej`k)oa]ahao_kikoabkooai]hckiqepkln teikamqa]o ]pejce](ai^kn]_kjpejq]ooaik^oanr]j`k_]hi]iajpaaoaijajdqi]aikk]o_ne]j]o aob]nn]l]`]oab]iejp]ola`ej`kaoikh]oj]oaomqej]o`]onq]o`]o_e`]`ao^n]oehaen]okj`a reraikopahaola_p]`knao* C^iq^abil`^ifw^ lqbjmlo^i6ko]_kjpa_eiajpkooknah]p]`ko_kikoajkperaooai _]qo]ol]oo]`]ojaiabaepkobqpqnko7oqncai_kikmlkqlplqn]iajpa]pq]eokqlnaoajpao( oai _kjpejqe`]`a jk pailk( oai knecai a oai _kjoamqj_e]o7 bufpqbj ajmq]jpk bknai k^fapko`apn]joieookaabfu^jabbufpqfooajkbknaipn]joiepe`ko*Lknmq;Lknmqapi ]bufpqk`f^abrjbpmbq`rilao lani]ja_aij]_kjo_ej_e]`]olaook]oajmq]jpklan) i]ja_ankaolap_qhk`aoq]pn]joieook*
Nabqce]`ko nq]j`ajoaoj]nacek `aJc]n](ln teik bnkjpaen]_ki Nq]j`](`qn]jpa ki]oo]_napje_k k_knne`kjaooal]o ai-550*
=ooei(lknatailhk(`ao`akoamqaopnk`]Úhd]`aqi]lnaoajp]`kn`apahareoka(`a) lkeo(`aooaiaoik]lnaoajp]`kn(^ai_kik`aqilq^he_epnekiqepk_kjda_e`kjk>n]oeh( ko jkpe_eneko `a n`ek a pahareok l]oo]n]i ] `a`e_]n ] i]ekn l]npa `k pailk ] jkp_e]o ok^na _neiao $nkq^ko( bqnpko( dkie_`eko( oamqaopnko( aopqlnko( rekhj_e] _kjpn] _ne]j]o( ap_*% _kik oa peraooai oqnce`k `k j]`]( nalajpej]iajpa* = lklqh]k l]ookq ] oajpen)oa ]ia]]`]a]ia`nkjp]`]lknmqal]ookq]na_a^anqi]ran`]`aen]ajtqnn]`]`ajkp_e]o ok^na p]eo ]ooqjpko( ai^kn] ko _neiao f peraooai ateopj_e] a f dkqraooai ]qiajp]`k diqepkpailk*Ajajdqijkpe_enekaop]^aha_aqnah]kajpnakolnk^hai]olkopkolah] a_kjkie]$`aoailnack(at_hqokok_e]h(`ao]^neck(bkia(ieone](ap_*%(oq]o_kjoamqj_e]o ok_e]eo$`aoecq]h`]`aok_e]h(ejfqope](_knnqlk`ko]l]nahdkolkhe_e]eoafq`e_eneko(ap_*%a ]_neiej]he`]`a*Jajdqi]ejbkni]kna]hbkepn]joiepe`]ok_ea`]`a* =ooeip]i^iko]_kjpa_eiajpko`]_e`]`a`aJkr]Ukng(]mqajkonabaneiko]jpa) nekniajpa( har]n]i k ckranjk `ko Aop]`ko Qje`ko ] ejr]`en a ^ki^]n`a]n k =bac]jeopk* Aopal]om^pplr^bufpqfolknmqal]ookq]oanqiaolap_qhk`an`ekapahareok*@a_knne`ko ]hcqjoiaoaoapaniej]`]]ejr]okjknpa)]iane_]j](k=bac]jeopk`ao]l]na_aq`koiaeko `a_kiqje_]kaiqep]cajpafjkoahai^n]`amqaaooal]oateopa*
/3,
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
I]ojko eook*N]`ekqrejpaoapahaola_p]`knaoperan]ikoajpeiajpk`amqak]p]mqa opknnao`aJkr]Ukngd]re]oe`kqi]pknalajpejk`ahkq_qn](]hckejo]jk(o^epkaejat) lhe_rah(lkeojkpejd]ijajdqi]ejbkni]kok^nakmqaharkq]p]h]_kjpa_eiajpk$lkn atailhk(mqai]nikq(pnaejkqalnal]nkqkocqannehdaenkon]^ao;(lknmqaao_khdan]iko ]hrkomqaao_khdan]i;%*@]iaoi]i]jaen](]pk`kojk>n]oehl]na_e]ej_kilnaajorahkmqa oal]oo]r]jkln lnek=bac]jeopk(ejr]`e`klahkatn_epkjknpa)]iane_]jk(lkeomq]j`kpan) iko_kikÎ=he]j]`kJknpaÏaÎP]ha^]jÏl]oo]n]i]oanqo]`kolahkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]) k(jejcqio]^e]kmqamqane]i`evan*Aan]iqo]`ko_kikoaperaooai`ljb ^al^bufpqfo j]mqahaikiajpkajkÚvaooail]npa`aqi]deop ne]mqakopahaola_p]`knaoakon]`ekq) rejpao`ao_kjda_e]i*Ajejcqibkeejbkni]`klahkojkpe_eneko(lkeoaopaooa_kjpajp]r]i ai qo]n ]mqah]o atlnaoo ao oai i]eknao atlhe_] ao* Lani]ja_aiko pk abpfkcloj^alp mq]jpk]jpao`]oÎejbkni] aoÏ* Na]he`]`abn]ciajp]`] L]n]`kt]hiajpa(n`ekapahareoklk`aijkokbana_ankiqj`kejpaenkjqiejop]jpa(i]o kb]vai`ap]hi]jaen]mqakiqj`kna]h`ao]l]na_a(naop]j`k]laj]onap]hdkobn]ciajp]`ko `aqi]na]he`]`a`aolnkre`]`an]evjkaol]kajkpailk*Eia`e]p]iajpa`alkeo`aatlane) iajp]niko]ehqok`amqabkikoejbkni]`kook^napq`k(lan_a^aikomqaj]`]o]^aiko* P]i^iejpanaoo]jpa]fksboplajpnana]he`]`aaÚ_klnk`qve`]lahkoiaeko*=_]^]) iko`aiaj_ekj]nkik`k_kikkjkpe_enekjko]lnaoajp]qiiqj`kenna]h(oaideop ne]( oai_]qo]ojai_kjoamqj_e]o(`ao_kjpjqkabn]ciajp]`k*Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](]opahajkra) h]o_ne]ikpbkqfjbkqlabob^ifa^ab*Ah]okb]vaiqo]j`kpnolnk_a`eiajpkolnej_el]eo6
/3-
-*
kpailk`ko]_kjpa_eiajpkopahajkrahope_kohajpkl]n]`]n]ehqok`amqa(]_]`] _]lpqhk(l]ookq)oa]laj]oqi`e]`ajkoo]re`](kql]oo]n]i)oa]hcqi]odkn]o(p]eo _kikna]hiajpal]oo]ne]ioabooaikoj o]reranko]_kjpa_eiajpkoj]nn]`ko7
.*
]olanokj]cajo(oaqod^epko(oq]hejcq]cai(oq]o_]o]o(oq]onkql]o(oaqok^fapkook ]lnaoajp]`ko_kikiteik`aob^ifpjllkoorah(`aik`k]eila`enmqajkooejp]) iko`eop]jpao`ahao$_kikjkooajpeikojk_ejai]ajkpa]pnk%7
/*
_kik_kjoamqj_e](]pahajkrah]jko]l]na_a_kikobi^qlalob^i(ajmq]jpkkjkpe_e) nekjko]l]na_a_kikenna]h*>]op]ran(lknatailhk(]na]k`a_e`]`aoejpaen]omq]j) `kqi]lanokj]cai`]jkrah]iknna$]olaook]o_dkn]i(mqanaien]kajpannk(Ú_]i `ahqpk%kqmq]j`kqi]_kjpa_eiajpkaol]jpkokk_knne`kaikqpn]l]npa`kiqj`k ]lnaoajp]`k_kikoabkooaqi_]lpqhk`apahajkrah]*K^oanr])oa(ai_kjpn]lkjpk( qi]b]hp]`ana]k`]olaook]o`e]jpa`a_d]_ej]ona]eo(k_knne`]oaijkoo]olnkteie) `]`aoa]lnaoajp]`]ojkojkpe_eneko*
R]ha]laj](p]i^i(iaj_ekj]n`keokqpnkoabaepkomqakoiaeko`ai]oo]lnk`qvai aijkoo]iajpa6]afpmbopla^^qbk la]fkc^kqfifw^ l* L]n]]paj`an]koejpanaooaoa_kjie_ko`kol]pnk_ej]`knao(n`ekapahareok`ere`ai ]lnkcn]i]kai^hk_komqa`qn]i`aoapa]`aviejqpko(oaj`k_]`]^hk_kejpannkile`k lahko_kian_e]eo*Aoo]`ereok`kpailkjkohar]]_kj_ajpn]n]]pajk`qn]jpakooapakq `aviejqpko`alnkcn]i]a]`ao_kj_ajpn)h]`qn]jpa]ol]qo]ol]n]]lq^he_e`]`a* Lkq_k]lkq_k(eookoapknj]qid^epk*=npeop]o`apa]pnk]Úni]imqa(`qn]jpaqi aolap_qhk(oajpaikl^he_kÚ_]n`ao]pajpk]_]`]oapaiejqpko*Lnkbaooknaok^oanr]imqa oaqo]hqjkolan`ai]]pajk]_]`]`aviejqpkoao rkhp]i]oa_kj_ajpn]n]l oqi]l]q) o]mqa`k]oeiaoiko(_kikoa`ere`eooai]]qh]aiÎlnkcn]i]ÏaÎ_kian_e]hÏ* Kn]( qi `ko naoqhp]`ko `aoo] iq`]j] iajp]h pn]jol]na_a mq]j`k _ne]j] a fkrai pajp]ihanqihernk6jk_kjoacqaihani]eo`kmqaoapa]`aviejqpko`a_]`]rav(jk _kjoacqaioqlknp]n]]qoj_e]`aei]cajoaehqopn] aojkpatpk(jkoqlknp]i]e`ae]`a lna_eo]nhanÎqihernkejpaenkÏ*Jaooa]ola_pk(]]pajka]_kj_ajpn]k(]_]l]_e`]`a`a ]^opn]k ejpaha_pq]h a `a atan__ek `k lajo]iajpk bkn]i `aopnq`]o* ?kik aolan]n mqa lkoo]i`aoaf]naejpanaoo]n)oalah]ok^n]o`a]npaa`alajo]iajpk;
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Lknoanqin]ik`]ej`opne]_qhpqn]ha(lknp]jpk(lknoanbqj`]iajp]hiajparaj`a`knao `a_qhpqn]mqalna_eo]i]cn]`]n]k_kjoqie`kn(koiaeko`a_kiqje_]kkejb]jpehev]i* ?kikeook]_kjpa_a; Qi]laook]$_ne]j]kqjk%ejb]jpehmq]j`kjk_kjoacqaoqlknp]n]`eop j_e]pai) lkn]hajpnaoaq`aoafka]o]peob]k`aha*=_ne]j]ejb]jpehfqop]iajpalknmqal]n]ah]kej) panr]hkajpnak`aoafka]o]peob]kejpkhanrah$lkneook]_ne]j]lamqajej]_dkn]p]jpk%* Kn](kmqab]vaikoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k;Lnkiapaiakbana_aido^qfÛ`^ lfkpq^k* q kb^*?kikk_kjoacqai;?ne]j`kaij oko`aoafkoakbana_aj`klnk`qpko$lq^he_e`]`a alnkcn]i]k%l]n]o]peob]v)hko*Kkqrejpamqacen]kaf^i`k]l]nahdk`an`ek_kjpejq]) iajpaakpahaola_p]`knmqaiq`]_kjpejq]iajpa`a_]j]hkb]vailknmqao]^aimqa(ai ]hcqihqc]n(oaq`aoafkoaneia`e]p]iajpao]peobaepk* =hi `eook( _kik ] lnkcn]i]k oa `eneca ]k mqa f o]^aiko a f ckop]iko( a _kik pki]]_qhpqn]ok^]bkni]`ah]vanaajpnapajeiajpk(koiaekoo]peob]vaieia`e]p]iajpa jkooko`aoafkolknmqajkatecai`aj o]pajk(lajo]iajpk(naÛatk(_npe_](lanpqn^]) k`ajkoo]oajoe^ehe`]`aa`ajkoo]b]jp]oe]*Aioqi](jkjkola`aikmqa]ok^n]o`a ]npaa`alajo]iajpkjkola`ai6pn]^]hdkoajokne]haiajp]hl]n]_kilnaaj`)h]o(]i)h]o( _nepe_)h]o(oqlan)h]o*=_qhpqn]jkoo]peob]v(oaperanikol]_ej_e]l]n]_kilnaaj`)h]a`a_e) bn)h]*Atecai]pqne`]`a*Koiaeko`a_kiqje_]kjkoo]peob]vailknmqaj]`]jkola`ai( oajkmqalani]ja]ikol]n]oailnaejb]jpeo* Klnaook`eooeiqh]`] Qi kqpnk pn]k `] ej`opne] _qhpqn]h mqa iana_a jkoo] ]pajk oaq ^rqlofq^ofpjl( ok^]]l]nj_e]`aabjl`o^`f^*Qi`koiahdknaoatailhkoaj_kjpn])oajkolnkcn]i]o`a ]_kjoahd]iajpk* Qi aola_e]heop] Í oailna qi aola_e]heop] Í jko ajoej] ] reran( qi kqpnkjkoajoej]]_ne]nkoÚhdko(kqpnkjkoajoej]]b]vanoatk(a]ooeirkoaoq_a`aj`k aola_e]heop]omqajkoajoej]i]panqi_knlkfqrajehao]q`rah(^k]oi]jaen]o(f]n`ej]cai( ia`ep]kaolenepq]h(ajÚi(jkdqije_k]ola_pk`ajkoo]ateopj_e]mqa`aeta`aoan ajoej]`klknqiaola_e]heop]_kilapajpa* Ailnej_lek(oane]]^oqn`kaejfqopk_kjoe`an]np]eoajoej]iajpko_kikÎ]qpknepnekoÏ* Lahk_kjpnnek(`aran]iko_kjoe`an)hkoqi]bkni]`a`aik_n]pev]naok_e]hev]n_kjda_e) iajpko*Kj`aoaaj_kjpn]kh]`kÎ]qpknepnekÏ`aooapelk`alnkcn]i]k$jkn`ekaj]paha) reok%a`alq^he_]k$jk_]ok`anareop]o(fknj]eoahernko%;Jkb]pk`amqabqj_ekj]i_kik fkqfjfa^ lpl`f^i* @a b]pk( _kik ko iaeko `a _kiqje_]k jko ejb]jpehev]i( `eiejqai jkoo] ]pajk a_]l]_e`]`a`alajo]iajpk(ejranpaina]he`]`aaÚ_kalnkiapai(lknejpani`ek`] lq^he_e`]`a( _khk_]n ] bahe_e`]`a eia`e]p]iajpa ]k ]h_]j_a `a jkoo]o iko( ]_]^]i jko pn]jobkni]j`kjqim _if`la`fibm^ppfsl*Qi]ravmqajkopknj]iko` _aeoal]ooerko( kolnkcn]i]o`a]_kjoahd]iajpk(hkjca`a`erqhc]nejbkni] ao$_kikl]na_aoan]ejpaj) kcajanko]`koaola_e]heop]o%(pknj]i)oaqilnk_aook`afk`ri`^ l`ar]hknao(d^epko( _kilknp]iajpkoae`ae]o(lkeojkaop]ikolnal]n]`kol]n]lajo]n(]r]he]nafqhc]nkmqa raiko(kqreikoahaiko*Lkneook(Ú_]ikoejpeie`]`ko(eopk(l]oo]iko]_kjoe`an]nmqa j]`]o]^aiko(mqaokikoejalpkol]n]rerana]cenoajkoacqeniko]]qpkne`]`a_kila) pajpa`kaola_e]heop]* @aoo]i]jaen](qi_kjfqjpk`alnkcn]i]oalq^he_] aomqalk`ane]ipanran`]`aenk oecjeÚ_]`k_qhpqn]hpknj]i)oal`lkqoofl`]_qhpqn]a`aoq]`aik_n]pev]k(lkeooa`ene) cai]qil^he_kpn]jobkni]`kaii]oo]ej_qhp](ejb]jpeh(`aoejbkni]`]al]ooer]* Jqihernkejpepqh]`kNr^qol^odrjbkqlpm^o^bifjfk^o^qbibsfpl(FannuI]j`an$mqa bke(`qn]jpamqejva]jko(ata_qperkanah] ao)l^he_]oaina`ao`apahareokjknpa)]iane_]) j]o%atlhe_]lknmqa]pahareokjklk`aoan_kjoe`an]`]qiiaek`a_kiqje_]k`aik) _npe_k*Oaqo`keolnej_el]eo]ncqiajpkook`a_]npana_kjie_kapa_jkh ce_k* @klkjpk`areop]b`lkjf`l(]ona`ao`apahareokokkqlnklnea`]`aolner]`]okq_kj) _aoo aoaop]p]eol]n]ailnao]olner]`]omqa(_kikp]eo(klan]i_ki]oe`ae]o`ahq_nka`a
/3.
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
_kjoanr]k`aoaqln lneklk`an*?kik_kjoamqj_e](]ao_khd]`k_kjpa`k`kolnkcn]i]o $`kjkpe_enekpahajkrah](`k`a^]pa]klnkcn]i]`a]q`ep nek(`koaolknpao]ko_kj_anpko`a ioe_]a`]j]%`apaniej]`]lahk_nepnek`kir`ol$ajk`]mq]he`]`a%a`]`lkpbos^ l almlabo`kolnklneapneko$at_hqej`k(lknp]jpk(pq`kmq]jpklkoo]lnailaneckaooalk) `anap]i^iklk`an`kockranjkoateopajpao(`komq]eo`alaj`ai]o_kj_aoo ao%*Kqpnko( lknp]jpk( `a_e`ai k mqa lk`aiko a `araiko ran* Okiko na_alpknao a jk lnk`qpknao `] ejbkni]ka`]_kiqje_]k(_kikoane]k_]ok(oa]pahareokbkooa`aik_npe_]* @klkjpk`areop]qb`klidf`l(db]pknaomqaheiep]ikln lnekiaeka`apaniej]ik mqaahalk`apn]joiepen*Raf]iko]hcqjoajpnakorneko]lkjp]`kolknI]j`an6 >rpk`f^abprqfibw^+=pah]`aqipahareoknlnk`qv]ei]cailkniaek`aqi]cn]`a `alkjpkohk_]hev]`koaimqejdajp]ohejd]o$]ei]caimqaraikoreop]_kikoaao) peraooalknpno`]Új]na`a`aqi_k]`kn`a_d%*EookoecjeÚ_]mqajaipk`]ei]cai oanjpe`]kqÎheil]Ï(eopk(mqajaipk`kokolkjpkokqÎoej]eoÏmqa]bkni]iok jpe`ko*Lkneook(]pahareokpailnabanj_e]lknei]cajo_qfkoÎoej]eoÏkqlkjpkooaf]i jpe`ko(ap]eoei]cajookkonkopkoai`ilpb*rm(kqoaf](reopko`aiqepklanpk*=hi `eook(kmqaaop]pnoaairkhp]`]ei]caijklk`aoan_kilhatk$iqepkok^fapko( iqep]o_knao%(i]olna_eo]oanki]eooeilhaolkoorah*Lknaooaikperk(l]n]Îheil]nÏ] ei]cai(d]paj`j_e]`aoal]n)h]`k_kjpatpkaimqaah]oaaj_kjpn](l]n]mqaah] lkoo]oanjpe`]j]pn]joieook* =ooei(jkolnkcn]i]ocakcnÚ_kokqpqnope_ko(]_ ian]jk_kjoacqaikopn]n qi]Ûknaop]$ikopn]qi]i]j_d]ran`akqikopn]]hcqi]onrknao%kqqi]_e`]`a $ikopn]qi]i]j_d]_ejv]kqikopn]]hcqi]nq]_ki]hcqi]o_]o]o%7jkojkpe_eneko alnkcn]i]o`a`a^]pao(lknatailhk(jqj_]raikokpk`k`]_aj](jqj_]raikopq`k kmqaaopna]hiajpa]_kjpa_aj`k(i]o]laj]oqi_knpa(ao_khde`klah]_ ian]* Aoo] atecj_e] pa_jkh ce_] `a Ú_]n _ki ei]cajo cn]j`ao a oeilhao p]i^i `a) paniej]]oatlnaoo ao`a]npeop]o(fknj]heop]o(`a^]pa`knao(ap_*(lkeopk`koajpeiajpk kqlajo]iajpkoqpeoÚ_]iejreoraeoao okpn]joieooraeo]oaik aoi]eo_kiqjo ai]eooeilhao*lkneookmqa]pahareokpailnabanj_e]lknlnkcn]i]o`a]q`ep nek( lnkcn]i]ook^narekhj_e](ko_d]i]`koÚhiao`a]kaaolknpao(eopk(pk`]o]ooe) pq] aoaimqakooajpeiajpko(]hi`aoanailkq_ko(oklnareoraeo*P]i^ilkn eook(j]opahajkrah]o(]c]i]`aoajpeiajpko]lnaoajp]`kooailnaijei]a]iaoi] $]ikn( `ek(n]er](ia`k(i]h`]`a(^kj`]`a(]hacne]at]can]`]%(`ao]l]na_aj`kpk`]] oqpehav]`]re`]ejpaneknaaik_ekj]h* Obar la^mbo`bm l*=pahareoko lk`apn]joiepenoej]eoreoq]eoaokjknko*=hi`a lk`ankbana_an]laj]oei]cajol]n]]reop]a]]q`ek(]oei]cajoreoq]eoaokjkn]o jkaopk_kja_p]`]o6raikoei]cajo`eop]jpao_kiokiln teik$lknatailhk(ikj) p]jd]o]khkjca_kijpe`koki`aloo]nkoa`a_]_dkaen]o(mqajklk`an]ikoaop]n ao_qp]j`k`aran`]`a7`q]olaook]o_]iejd]j`k]khkjcajqi]nq]akokijpe`k`a oq]_kjrano](mqajklk`an]ikoaop]nkqrej`k]aoo]`eop j_e](ap_*%*=_ ian]jk _kjoacqa]lnaoajp]nqi]_aj]_kilhap]`aqi^]hjai]pkp]he`]`a`aqi]knmqao) pn]oejbje_]*=hi`eook(j]pahareok]ei]caijklk`apanlnkbqj`e`]`a(lknmqa oailna]_d]p]`]7kikreiajpkjqj_]lk`aoanreopkjkoaqnepikln lnek(lknmqa oailna`eopkn_e`ka`abkni]`k* Obdo^pabqo^kpjfppl*Ai`a_knnj_e]`]oheiep] aopa_jkh ce_]o`kiaek(]pahareok k^a`a_a]qi_kjfqjpk`anacn]omqa`apaniej]ikmqaiahdknl]n]]pn]joieooka kmqa`araoanarep]`k*@]o/1nacn]oiaj_ekj]`]olknI]j`an(oaha_ekj]iko]hcqi]o6 -*
/3/
]cqann]pahareoekj]iahdkn`kmqa]l]vlknmqa_kjpiiqep]]kaqioajpeiajpk lk`ankok6kia`k$]l]v]iknb]aoaicn]]7jah]]oaik aookejpaneknaoaoqpeoa jkd_kikpahareoekj)h]o%*Lahkiaoikikperk(rekhj_e]pahareoekj]iahdkn`kmqa jkrekhj_e]7
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
b]pko atpanjko $k_knnj_e]o a ]_kjpa_eiajpko% pahareoekj]i iahdkn `k mqa ejbkni]) ao $e`ae]o( kleje ao( lanola_per]o%( lkeo i]eo bknpa ikopn]n _keo]o a b]pko `k mqa ]_kil]jd]nn]_ek_jekoalajo]iajpko7
/*
]bkn]nkopkodqi]jko(_keo]opahareoekj]iiahdkn`kmqaoanaorerko$laook]o(]jei]eo alh]jp]o%(lknmqa]o_keo]ookoeilhao(_kiqje_]i`enap]iajpaoq]oei]cajojqi] iajo]caioai_kilhe_]k(ajmq]jpk]olaook]ook_kilhat]o(n]_ek_ej]i(oaaik) _ekj]i(`evai_keo]ooqpeo7
0*
h`anaonahecekokoalkhpe_ko_]neoipe_kopahareoekj]iiahdkn`kmqakojk_]neoipe) _ko(lkeoaopaooa`enecai]klajo]iajpka]koajpeiajpk`]olaook]o(ajmq]jpk]mqa) haooa`enecai]aik aoi]eooeilhaoareoraeo(mqaok^aipn]joiepe`]o7
1*
i]eob_ehpn]joiepenqio `kmqaiqepko7lkneook(jko]_kjpa_eiajpko`ai]oo] kq`aiqhpe`k(ao_khda)oaqi]je_]laook]l]n]klej]nab]h]nkqqi]oamqj_e]`a laook]oajpnareop]`]oqi]]qi]7
2*
iahdknpn]joiepenknc]jev] aodeannmqe_]o`kmqa`aik_npe_]o(lkeo]olneiaen]opi qi]bkni]iqepkoeilhao(mq]hoaf](]]qpkne`]`aakooq^kn`ej]`kokqkooacqe`knao7
3*
]ooqjpko_qnpko_ki_kiak(iaekaÚiokiahdknao`kmqa]ooqjpkohkjckomqaate) cailhqn]he`]`a`aejbkni] aoa]lnkbqj`]iajpk`alkjpko`areop]7
4*
oajpeiajpko `a _kjÛepk pahareoekj]i iahdkn `k mqa oajpeiajpko `a _kj_ n`e]7 lkn eook(_kilapekpahareokj]iahdkn`kmqa_kklan]k7
5*
]i^ek a _kjoqik pahareoekj]i iahdkn `k mqa aolenepq]he`]`a( lkeo ] _ ian] jk pai_kikhe`]n_kioqpehav](`eranoe`]`aa]i^ecqe`]`a7
-,* mq]j`kpahareoekj]nÎlkrkolneieperkoÏ(]lnaoajpaioe_](`]j](_]jpk(_]](lao_](hq) p]oaarepaajpnareop]ooq^faper]oj]omq]eooaatlneiaie`ae]o(kleje ao(oajpeiajpko _kilhatko7 --* k^ev]nnkakaopn]jdkpahareoekj]iiqepk^ai7 -.* ]atlnaookb]_e]hiahdkn`kmqakoajpeiajpk6k_dknkpahareoekj]iahdkn`kmqa] pneopav](kneokpahareoekj]iahdkn`kmqa]]hacne]7 -/* ]iknpapahareoekj]iahdkn`kmqa]re`]6j]iknpapq`kaop_h]nka`a_e`e`k7j]re`]( pq`k]i^cqk(Ûqe`k(jk_kilhap]iajpa`a_e`e`k(]^anpk]iqep]olkooe^ehe`]`ao* Jqi]ok_ea`]`a_kik]jko) o](kmqa(]Új]h(]pahareok; Aijkoo]ok_ea`]`a(]pahare) okqiiaekp_je_k`a_kiqje) _]k]`eop j_e]mqaailnaop]`k fknj]heoik]e`ae]`analknp]caia jkp_e](`]hepan]pqn]]e`ae]`kbk) hdapeijkrahao_k(`kpa]pnk]e`ae] `anah]k_kiqil^he_klnaoaj) pa a `k _ejai] ko lnk_a`eiajpko _ki ei]cajo* @k lkjpk `a reop] `kna_alpkn(k]l]nahdkpahareokn qiahapnk`kiope_k(_kikkhemqe) `eÚ_]`knkq]cah]`aen]*@klkjpk `areop]`klnk`qpkn(ahaqi_aj) pnk`alk`ana_kjie_kalkhpe_k a `a _kjpnkha ok_e]h a _qhpqn]h* qi] ian_]`kne] mqa pn]joiepa a raj`akqpn]oian_]`kne]o*
Banj]j`k?khhkn( ajpk_]j`e`]pk
Lnaoe`j_e]`] Nal^he_](jk hpeik`a^]pa na]hev]`klah]PR Chk^kai-1`a `avai^nk`a-545* =PRbkenaolkjorah lah]lnkfak`a ?khhkn(mqaj]`]an] oajkei]cai* !NTONIOß-ILENA%DITORAß!BRIL
.*
/30
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
?ejai]
WWWCZYTANKIHOXPLß !RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
?kik]pahareok(k_ejai]qi]ej`opne]*?kikah](`alaj`a`aejraopeiajpko(ian) _]`ko(lnkl]c]j`]*?kikah](lnak_ql])oa_kikhq_nk(]ik`](k_kjoqik* Jkajp]jpk(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`]^k]kqimq]he`]`a`koÚhiao(k_ejai]`ebana`] pahareokai`keo]ola_pkobqj`]iajp]eo*Ailneiaenkhqc]n(jkaopoq^iape`koheiep]) aopa_jkh ce_]omqa`kiej]i]pahareok7aioacqj`k(jahaoklkooraeo]olnk`q aoej) `alaj`ajpao(]ok^n]o]npope_]oa]onaÛat ao_npe_]o(]qoajpao`]pahareok*Jklkn]_]ok( eje_e]ikoaopahernk_kiajp]j`kqiÚhia$J^qofu%a(jk`a_knnan`aopa_]lpqhk(iaj_ekj]) ikornekoÚhiaojkomq]eok_ejai]_]l]v`ab]van_npe_]o_kjpqj`ajpaopahareok* K_ejai]]ejrajk`aqi]bkni]_kjpailkn ja]`a]npa6]`]ei]caiokjkn]ai ikreiajpk*Jaha(]_ ian]_]lp]qi]ok_ea`]`a_kilhat](ihpelh]a`ebanaj_e]`](_ki) ^ej]j`k`ai]jaen]pkp]hiajpajkr]ioe_](`]j](hepan]pqn](ao_qhpqn](lejpqn](]nmqepa) pqn](deop ne]a(cn]]o]kona_qnokopa_jkh ce_ko`koabaepkoaola_e]eo(_ne]na]he`]`aojkr]o( ejo hep]o(jqi]ei]cej]klhope_]ejÚjep]mqao pai_knnaolkj`ajpajkookjdko* ?kikkhernk(k_ejai]paiklk`anatpn]kn`ejnek(ln lnek`]k^n]`a]npa(`apknj]n lnaoajpak]qoajpa(ln teikk`eop]jpa(`eop]jpakln teik(ajpna_nqv]j`kna]he`]`aaenna]) he`]`a(ran`]`aab]jp]oe](naÛatka`ar]jaek* Mq]j`kran`]`aen]iajpacn]j`aa]npope_k(jaha]_ne]pere`]`a`k`enapkna`aoq]amqe) la p_je_] a ] atlnaooere`]`a `n]ipe_] kq _ie_] `ko ejpnlnapao lk`ai i]jebaop]n)oa _kioqpehav]a`eranoe`]`a(e`ae]oakleje aolk`aioanpn]^]hd]`]o(ejpanlnap]`]oapn]jo) iepe`]o(kbana_aj`k)oalhaj]iajpa]kl^he_k(oai`eopejkpje_](oatq]h(naheceko]kqok) _e]h*Ok^aooa]ola_pk(S]hpan>ajf]iejpejd]n]vk]k_kjoe`an]nk_ejai]]]npa`aik_n) pe_]`kjkookpailk*
=ejbknipe_] !DAMß3CHAFF߯ ß FILvSOFOßMARXISTAßPOLONoS
J
qi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]>pl`fba^abfkclojqf`^(klajo]`kn=`]iO_d]bboanabanaÎnark) hqk`]ie_nkahapnje_]Ïajkp]mqa(iaoikoaijko`]niko_kjp](aop]ikonk`a]) `kolknah](`ao`akolamqajkok^fapko`aqok_kpe`e]jk(_kikknah cek`amq]npvk( ]_]h_qh]`kn]`a^khokakpahabkja_ahqh]n(]pko_kilqp]`knaoakorkkoaol]_e]eo*Iaj_ekj] p]i^i]Înarkhqkj]ie_nk^ekhkce]Ï(_ki]`ao_k^anp]`k_ `eckcajpe_k`kooanaorerko( `]mq]hoqnceq]ajcajd]ne]cajpe_](mqalk`a]hpan]nk_ `eckcajpe_k`alh]jp]o(]jei]eo aoanaodqi]jko*Iaj_ekj]]ej`]]Înarkhqk`]ajance]jq_ha]nÏ(k^pe`]ia`e]jpa]Úook a bqok _kjpnkh]`]o `a pkiko( lk`aj`k lnkle_e]n ]ko dqi]jko na_qnoko ajancpe_ko ln]) pe_]iajpaeheiep]`ko(ai^kn]pajd]oe`klneknep]ne]iajpaqo]`]l]n]Újoiehep]nao*O_d]bb `ajkiej]aoo]ocn]j`aoiq`]j]o`aÎoacqj`]narkhqkp_je_k)ej`qopne]hÏ(ao_naraj`k6 Qo^q^*pba^pbdrka^obslir lq`kf`l*fkarpqof^i+>mofjbfo^)nrbmlabpbopfqr^a^ bkqob l Ûk^i al p`ril USFFF b l fk`fl al p`ril UFU b `rg^p qo^kpcloj^ bp kfkdrj ebpfq^bj`e^j^oabobslir l)qbsbldo^kabjofqlabpr_pqfqrfok^molar l^clo ^ cpf`^alpeljbkpmbi^bkbodf^a^pjnrfk^p%mofjbfolmbi^rqfifw^ lals^mlobj^fp ^af^kqbpl_obqralmbi^rqfifw^ la^bibqof`fa^ab&+>pbdrka^obslir l)^nrbbpq^jlp ^ppfpqfkal^dlo^)`lkpfpqbbjnrb^p`^m^`fa^abpfkqbib`qr^fpaleljbjpl^jmif^a^p bpr_pqfqra^pmlo^rqj^qlpnrbbifjfk^j`ljufql`obp`bkqblqo^_^ielerj^klk^ molar lbklppbosf lp+
/31
Klkjpkeilknp]jpa]ooej]h]`klknO_d]bb]`ebanaj]ajpnako]jpeckok^fapkop_je) _koÍmqa]ilhe]r]i]bkn]boe_]dqi]j]Íakojkrkok^fapkopa_jkh ce_koÍmqa]i) lhe]i]obkn]oejpaha_pq]eodqi]j]o(eopk(]o_]l]_e`]`ao`klajo]iajpk(lkeookk^fapko mqa `alaj`ai `a ejbkni] ao a mqa klan]i ejbkni] ao kq bknja_ai ejbkni] ao* @a b]pk(ko_kilqp]`knaona]hev]i`aik`katpnai]iajpanle`kklan] aoh ce_]omqaqi oandqi]jkhar]ne]iqepki]eopailkl]n]na]hev]n7lkooqep]i^iqi]iai ne]iqepk
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
oqlanekniahdkniai ne]dqi]j]7aaopknc]jev]`k`ai]jaen]]]qpk_knnecen]i]ekn l]npa`]ob]hd]oa`koajc]jkomqa_kiapanjqi]klan]kkqjqilnk_aook*Okkool_p kqko^rqj^qlplnklne]iajpa`epko* ?kik]l]h]rn]fkclojqf`^ej`e_](kojkrkok^fapkopa_jkh ce_kolnk`qvaiapn]jo) iepaifkcloj^ bp*jaooaoajpe`kmqa`evaikomqaoaqik`ahkjk]bkn]boe_]jai ia_ je_]aoeiiajp]hkq_ana^n]h* ?kilqp]`knao _kjpnkh]i ]o ]ni]o a klan] ao iehep]nao( ko rkko aol]_e]eo( ]o kla) n] ao `a ]anklknpko( `a ^]j_ko a ^kho]o `a r]hknao( `a oeopai]o qn^]jko `a pnback a `a oacqn]j]( `a a`eb_eko `ajkiej]`ko ÎejpahecajpaoÏ( ]hi `a oapknao ejpaenko `k pn]^]hdk ej`qopne]h a `] lnk`qk a_kjie_]* Aopk lnaoajpao jko _]nnko `a hpeik pelk( jko aop]) ^aha_eiajpko_kian_e]eomqaraj`aijk]p]_]`kajkr]nafk(jkooapknao]`iejeopn]perko `]oejopepqe aol^he_]oalner]`]o*Aj_kjpn]i)oaj]oao_kh]oab]vail]npa`koeopai]`a ajoejka]lnaj`ev]`k`kol]oaoa_kjkie_]iajpalk`ankoko*Aopklnaoajpaoj]oa`epkn]oa lnk`qpkn]ocnÚ_]o(jkoao_nep neko`aajcajd]ne](]nmqepapqn]a]`rk_]_e]7jko_kjoqhp neko i`e_koadkolep]eo7j]olnk`qpkn]o_ejai]pkcnÚ_]o(bkjkcnÚ_]o(pahareoer]oan]`ekbje) _]o*Pknj]n]i)oaejopnqiajpko`apn]^]hdk`aao_nepknao(]npeop]o(lnkbaooknaoaaopq`]jpao( ]hi`aklan]n_kik_knnaeka_kikh]vanaajpnapajeiajpk* >ajf]iejb]h]n]jkoabaepko`]nalnk`qk`]ok^n]o`a]npa$lahkohernko(lahkn`eka lahk_ejai]%*I_Hqd]jlnaren]kpniejk`]Îc]hte]`aCqpaj^ancÏ$eopk(kiqj`k`khernk eilnaook%_kik]`rajpk`]pahareok*=i^kooq^hejd]n]i]olkpaj_e]he`]`ao`aqi]`ebq) ok_qhpqn]hoailna_a`ajpao(j]ia`e`]aimqakojkrkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]kpknj]n]i ]_aooraeo]olnk`q ao_qhpqn]eo`kiqj`kpk`k*Aooaiaoikabaepklk`aoanreopk_ki] ejbknipe_]6paiko(dkfa(]_aookeia`e]pk]iqoaqoejpaenko(^e^hekpa_]oejpaen]o(fknj]eo_ki) lhapkoailn]pe_]iajpapk`]o]ohjcq]o(`eolkjraeojko^]j_ko`a`]`koejbkni]pev]`ko* =ejbknipe_]klan]_kikmqa@]re`D]nrau_d]ikq`aÎ_kilnaookaol]k)pailk) n]hÏ*@ab]pk(kik`k`alnk`qk_]lep]heop]oailnaoa^]oakqjklk`ana_kjie_kok^nak aol]k$]lnklnea`]`a`kpannep neklah]oailnao]olner]`]oalahkoAop]`ko%aok^nakpailk $k_kjpnkha`kpailkok_e]hiajpaja_aoonekl]n]]lnk`qk(`eopne^qeka_en_qh]k`]o ian_]`kne]oa`anapknjk(ok^]bkni]`ahq_nk(`k_]lep]hejraope`k%(i]o(]pq]hiajpa(aooa lk`an]cec]jpkq)oalknmqa]pa_jkhkce]ahapnje_]na`qv`eop j_e]o$_kilneiakaol]k%a lknmqaknapknjk`khq_nk]k_]lep]hejraope`kn]le`ooeik$_kilneiakpailk%*=aooa naolaepk(ao_naraI_Hqd]j6
&ALAREMOSßDASßCONSE QUoNCIASßECONxMICASßEß SOCIAISßDAßINFORMfTICAß NOSßCAPqTULOSßDEDICADOSß gßPOLqTICAßEßSUASßCONSE QUoNCIASßMORAISßEßNOSß CAPqTULOSßDEDICADOSßgß mTICAß!QUIßEXAMINAREMOSß APENASßALGUNSßASPECTOSß CULTURAISßDESSEßNOVOßMEIOß DEßCOMUNICAljO
Klab`looboa^pbo^pjb` kf`^p)bpqbkabjlpklppl`lomlklbpm^ l+Elgb)mloj) m^pp^alj^fpabrjp`rilabqb`klildf^bibqokf`^)bpqbkabjlplklpplmomoflpfpqb* j^kboslpl`bkqo^ikrj^_o^ ldil_^i)^_lifkal)klql`^kqb^lklpplmi^kbq^)q^kqll bpm^ l`ljllqbjml+ Kq oaf]( `qn]jpa ] lneiaen] a ] oacqj`] narkhq ao ej`qopne]eo( k _knlk dqi]jk ao) paj`aq)oajkaol]k(lneiaenk_kikpahao_ lek(kie_nko_ leka]oimqej]o]r]lkn$jko pn]jolknpaoaj]ob^ne_]o%(`alkeo_ki]oimqej]oahpne_]o$jkopn]jolknpaoaj]ob^ne) _]o%( k pahcn]bk( k pahabkja( k n`ek( k _ejai] a ] pahareok* I]o ]ckn]( _ki ko o]phepao a ]ejbknipe_](jkook_na^nkkqjkookoeopai]janrkok_ajpn]hmqa(lkniaek`]ojkr]o imqej]o(oaatl]j`aoaiheiepao(`eiejqej`k`eop j_e]oaol]_e]eoaejpanr]hkopailkn]eo ]p]^khenkaol]kakpailk* = ejbknipe_] a ko o]phepao _khk_]i k qjeranoklk*ifkb `qn]jpa .0 dkn]o( oai oanai eila`e`kolkn`eop j_e]oa`ebanaj]ocakcnÚ_]o(ok_e]eoalkhpe_]ojailkn`eopejkajpna k`e]a]jkepa(kjpai(dkfaa]i]jd*Pq`koal]oo]^nrf(_kikoarj]o_d]i]`]oÎo]h]o`a ^]pa)l]lkÏ(jkolnkcn]i]o`a_kiqje_]klk*ifkb(_kikkIOJ(kqj]oÎna`aook_e]eoÏ(ai mqalkoorah_kjrano]n_kilaook]o`akqpnkatpnaik`kiqj`k_qf]lnaoaj]ejop]jp ) ja]7apq`koal]oo]^dlo^(_kikoarj]ocn]j`aoklan] aoÚj]j_aen]obaep]ojqileo_]n `akhdkoajpnaailnao]okqajpna^]j_kooepq]`kojko_kjÚjo`]Pann](ai^kn]oaqobqoko dknnekooaf]i_kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpao* At]iejaiko]hcqjo]ola_pko_qhpqn]eo`]ejbknipe_]*
/32
=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
K_kilqp]`knjqj_]ann] Jqihernkejpepqh]`kLnrbfkclojqf`^(ájcahkOk]naoat]iej]kÎiepk`k_kilqp]) `kn^kiÏ6]e`ae]ice_]`aqi]imqej]mqanaokhrapq`koeilhaoiajpa_kik]lanp]n`a qi^kpk(oaijqj_]ann]n6 Bpp^sfpljdf`^al`ljmrq^alo`of^a^k^pmbppl^pb`lkqof_rfm^o^^`lkpqor* labrjjfql7ljfqlal`ljmrq^alo_lj+L`ljmrq^alorjÑpbolkfmlqbkqbÒ)_lj) o^`flk^i)bÛ`fbkqb)nrbmbkp^bobplisbqlalplpmol_ibj^p^mobpbkq^alp^bib)abcloj^ fjm^o`f^i)fksbpqfalabrj^iqldo^rabgrpqf ^)pbjkrk`^boo^o+%+++&>fkclojqf`^^m^* ob`b)bkql)`ljl^`e^sbabrjjrkalbÛ`fbkqb)fkc^isbi)cbifw)lkablqo^_^ielpbo obarwfalbli^wbo^rjbkq^al+ =hi`eook(]lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]h(^ai_kik]hepan]pqn](k_ejai]a]pahareok(]he) iajp]iaooaiepk]k]lnaoajp]n_kilqp]`knaomqab]h]i(kqrai(oajpai(pirkjp]`a( okikre`kolknoajpeiajpkoaaik ao(oki]eolkj`an]`komqakooanaodqi]jko$p]jpk ]ooeimqa_kopqi]ieila`enaarep]ncqann]o%a(oaann]ikqb]hd]i(lkn]hcqi]ejpanba) nj_e]ej`are`]`a]hcqioandqi]jki]h)ejpaj_ekj]`k*=dqi]jev]k`k_kilqp]`kn qi`kopai]o`kÚhia/--.ÎRj^lafppbf^klbpm^ l(jkmq]hk_kilqp]`knD=H5,,, okbnaqi]Î_neoajanrko]Ïlknmqajklk`aiajpen7kq`kÚhiaLeljbj_f`bkqbkofl(ai mqak_kilqp]`kn`kp]`k`aoajpeiajpko(l]oo]]]i]na`aoaf]oandqi]jk(eopk(ajra) hda_anaiknnan7kq(ajÚi(]deop ne]`aLejk__dekjk]jk.,,-(eopk(k_kilqp]`kn)_ne]j] ai`eolqp]_ki]_ne]j]dqi]j]lahk]ikn`]ia(jkÚhiaFkqbifdk`f^^oqfÛ`f^i* ?kikk^oanr]Ok]nao(]reokice_]k_qhp]kb]pk`amqak_kilqp]`knqi]imqe) j]a(_kikp]h(lnk`qve`](lnkcn]i]`](_kjoanr]`]aklan]`]lknoanaodqi]jko*D(lkn) p]jpk(pn]^]hdkdqi]jkl]n]b]v)hkateopenabqj_ekj]nÍpn]^]hdkej`qopne]hl]n]lnk`qven ]imqej]apn]^]hdkejpaha_pq]hai]jq]h`a]j]heop]o`aoeopai]o$mqahar]jp]i]oja_ao) oe`]`ao`koqoqneko%(lnkcn]i]`knao$mqaah]^kn]ik_kjfqjpk`aejopnq aomqa`aÚjai kmqaa_kik]imqej]r]ena]hev]n]oklan] ao`aoaf]`]olahkqoqnek%(klan]`knao$mqa hec]ia`aohec]i]oimqej]o(nal]n]ioaqo`abaepko(ap_*%(lnal]n]`knao`a`]`ko$naolkj) oraeolah]ah]^kn]kkqna_alkaaieook`a`]`ko%a`ecep]`knao$naolkjoraeolah]aj) pn]`]`a`]`kojk_kilqp]`kn%*Dlahkiajko/1pelko`apn]^]hdkodqi]jkoja_aooneko l]n]mqaqi_kilqp]`knklana*
=hejcq]caiejbknipe_]
/33
Ai^kn] d]f] ej`opne]o lnk`qpkn]o `a _kilqp]`knao j] Aqnkl] a j] ãoe]( lna`kie) j]ijk>n]oeh]oimqej]o`alnk_a`j_e]jknpa)]iane_]j]*Kqoka]lkooa`k_kilqp]`kn ]l]na_ail]n]]olaook]o_kikoej]h`apq^qrpok_e]h(lk`analnaopcek*Lkneook(ailnac]n ]hejcq]caip_je_]aihjcq]ejchao]p]i^i]l]na_a_kiklnkr]`al]npe_el]kjqi iqj`kp_je_k]r]j]`ka_kjda_e`klknlkq_ko* @eooknaoqhp]i`q]o_kjoamqj_e]olnej_el]eo6kqkomqaecjkn]i]hjcq]ejchao]Ú) _]iat_hq`ko`kqok`k_kilqp]`kn(mqabqj_ekj](lknp]jpk(_kikqilk`an`aat_hqok _qhpqn]h$kqat_hqok`ecep]h%(kqkoqoqnekooad]^epq]i]ailnac]nl]h]rn]o_kiktloa( fkmrq(pfqb(altkil^a(rmil^a(b*j^fi(abibqb(rmdo^ab(eljbm^db(ap_*oaipan]iajkne`ae] `kmqaoecjeÚ_]i*Kqoaf](]kailnac]n_kij]pqn]he`]`aqirk_]^qhnek_qfkoajpe`khdao ao_]l]a]knapanl]h]rn]o_kikoabkooaiian]oklan] ao`aqik^fapkp_je_k(kqoqnek paj`a]jklan_a^ank_kilqp]`kn_kikqi]ian_]`kne]lnk`qve`]a_kian_e]hev]`]lkn cn]j`aoikjkl hekoa_kjie_koejpanj]_ekj]eomqa`kiej]i]_kilapekjkian_]`ka eil aioq]hejcq]caiaoq]ohaeo* Oaf]]koajpen)oaat_hq`k(oaf]]kailnac]nqi]hejcq]cai_qfkoecjeÚ_]`k`ao_k) jda_e`ka`]mq]h]laj]o]hcqjork_^qhkook]_aooraeoaiaiknev]`kol]n]Újoklan]_ek) j]eo(kqoqnek`k_kilqp]`knpaj`ajko ]]Úni]neilhe_ep]iajpak_]npanieopanekok `kk^fapkailnac]`k(i]op]i^i]ecjkn]n(`aqih]`k(mqa]at_hqok`aiqepkojk ejpaha_pq]h$kqian]iajpa`ecep]h%(aoeiok_e]h$jkaopkat_hq`kolknoanaiej_]l]vao`a
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
klan]np]hk^fapk(aoeilknmqa`ao_kjda_ai]hjcq]aimqa]oklan] aobkn]iÚt]`]o%(a( `akqpnk(mqakqok]`amq]`k]_]nnap]`alaj`j_e]a_kjie_]a_qhpqn]h*
Klk`anejbknipe_k J]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja](]mlppbabfkcloj^ bp$_eajpÚ_]o(p_je_]o(a_kjie_]o( lkhpe_]o(iehep]nao%mlppbabmlabo* Ko_kilqp]`knaook_ajpnko`a]_qiqh]k`aejbkni] aoalkneookok_ajpnko`a lk`an* =`]i O_d]bb atlhe_] mqa ] atlnaookÎok_ea`]`a ejbknipe_]Ï( ailnac]`] lkn aha l]n]`aoecj]n]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja](oecjeÚ_]qi]ok_ea`]`aj]mq]hpk`]o]oaoban]o `]re`]l^he_]a`]re`]lner]`]aopk_k^anp]olknlnk_aookoejbkni]pev]`koalknejpahe) cj_e]o]npeÚ_e]eomqa`kknecai]jkr]ocan] ao`a_kilqp]`knao*Klnk^hai](`evaha( o]^anmqaipai]caopk`apk`]]i]oo]`aejbkni] aomqa_kjpnkh]]ok_ea`]`a(mqai qpehev]aoo]oejbkni] ao(_kikal]n]mqa]oqpehev]*Klnk^hai]jkaopaimqaio]^aa mqaijko]^aklan]nqi_kilqp]`kn$eookoanaokhrab]_ehiajpa_kipnaej]iajpkapk`]o ]olaook]olk`aiklan)hk%(aoeiainrbjqbjbnrbjklqbjlmlabom^o^^oj^wbk^ob rqfifw^ofkcloj^ bp^abnr^a^p*Klnk^hai](lknp]jpk(oaj`k`alk`an(mliqf`l* =aooanaolaepk(ao_naraájcahkOk]nao6 Lmlabokl kf`lb`lk`bkqo^albjrj kf`lmlkql)j^pafpqof_ral`ljl rj^qbf^Xfpqlnrbnrboafwbo^m^i^so^fkdibp^sa^Z)rj^obabmloqla^^pl`fba^ab+ >nrf)^m^ob`bj^pobabpab`ljmrq^alobp%soflp`ljmrq^alobpfkqboifd^alp)k^j^fl* of^a^psbwbp)^qo^spabifke^pqbibckf`^p&+@^a^`ljmrq^alo)abpp^cloj^)obmobpbkq^ rj mlkql ab `lk`bkqo^ l ab mlabo b) mlo jbfl abpp^ fkqboifd^ l) bibp ^`^_^j clo* j^kalrj^Ïqbf^Ðabmlabo)mbojb^kalqla^^pl`fba^ab+Abpp^j^kbfo^)^fkclojqf`^ mlabpbosfpq^`ljlrjfkpqorjbkqlnrbmolmf`f^l`lkqoliba^sfa^a^pmbppl^pabsfal ^lpbr^iqldo^rab`lk`bkqo^ la^pfkcloj^ bpb ^iq^sbil`fa^ab`ljnrbbi^ppl molm^d^a^p+Bjmlr`lppbdrkalpmlab*pbqbo^`bppl^_^k`lpaba^alplkabpb`lk`bk* qo^rjk jboljrfqldo^kababfkcloj^ bpbl_qbo)abnr^inrbom^oqbalm^plral jrkal)sof^pfkcloj^ bppl_obrjabqbojfk^al^pprkqllrmbppl^+ Eookhar]aooa]qpkn]]lkjp]nkopnoi]eknaolanecko`]]_qiqh]ka`eopne^qek`a ejbkni] ao* Klneiaenklaneckklk`an`a_kjpnkhaok^na]olaook]olknmqa(_ki^]oaaiejbkni]) aol]n_e]eoa`eolano]ona_khde`]oairneko]nmqerko(lkoorahcan]njkr]oejbkni] ao mqaoeopai]pev]i]olneiaen]oalaniepaina_kjopepqend^epko(ejpanaooaoaikreiajpko `]olaook]o(_kikk_]ok^]op]jpaoeilhao`]na_kjopepqek`]o] ao`a]hcqilkniaek `]o_ajpn]eopahabje_]o(mqalk`ai`evanl]n]mqai]hcqipahabkjkq(mq]jp]oravao(lkn mq]jpkpailk(ap_*@aoo]i]jaen](]olaook]olk`aioan_kjpnkh]`]olahkolk`anaol^he_ko $_kikklk`anlkhe_e]hakiehep]n%* Koacqj`klaneck(`a_knnajpa`]_ajpn]hev]k`]ejbkni]k(]lkooa`aejbkni] ao lknlaook]ojk]qpknev]`]omqaajpn]iai_kjp]pk_kiejbkni] aooecehko]op]jpk`koa) pknl^he_k$ejbkni] aoiehep]nao(a_kjie_]o(lkhpe_]o%_kik`]re`]lner]`]`]olaook]o $_kik(lknatailhk(]o_kjp]o^]j_ne]o%* Kpan_aenklaneckaopj]lkooe^ehe`]`a`aqok`aejbkni] aolknlk`anaolner]`kol]n] _kjpnkh]nlaook]oaejopepqe ao(]ooei_kikl]n]_]qo]n)hdao`]jk*k_]ok`]aolekj]cai ej`qopne]halkhpe_]a`]]k`kooajdknao`k_neiaknc]jev]`k(mqaqo]i]oejbkni] ao l]n]ln]pe_]noamqaopnko(_d]jp]cajo(]oo]ooej]pko* `aooaeiajoklk`anmqa(_kikreiko(pn]p]kÚhiaJ^qofu* = ]Úni]k `a mqa ko _kilqp]`knao `aik_n]pev]i ]o ejbkni] ao jk qi] paoa ran`]`aen]6]ejbknipe_](p]h_kikraioaj`kln]pe_]`](aoprkhp]`]l]n]]_kj_ajpn]ka _ajpn]hev]k`]oejbkni] aoal]n]k_kjpnkha`]re`]a`]o] ao`koej`er`qko(ajkl]n] ]`ebqok`aik_npe_]`]ejbkni]k*L]n]k_kilqp]`knklan]n(ahalna_eo]`a`]`koa`] _ajpn]hev]k`ko`]`koÍaopaqib]pkp_je_k*=`aik_n]pev]k`]ejbkni]k(lknp]jpk(
/34
=ateopj_e]pe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
jklk`alnkren`]ln lne]p_je_]ejbknipe_](lkeoaop]_ajpn]hev]`kn]*=`aik_n]pev]k `]ejbkni]k`alaj`a`a] aolkhpe_]o`]ok_ea`]`aa`kockranjko*kmqaoarj]ohqp]o ok_e]eolknhaceoh] aomqaeila]i]ejr]ok`]re`]lner]`](]aolekj]cailkhpe_]aie) hep]n(ap_*p]i^ikmqaehqopn]`klahkikreiajpkok_eklkhpe_k`anaoeopj_e]ahqp]`]o lanokj]cajo`aJ^qofu*
#APqTULOß =ateop j_e]pe_]
Oajokikn]ha_kjo_e j_e]ikn]h
I
/35
qep]o ravao( pki]iko _kjda_eiajpk `a ikreiajpko j]_ekj]eo a ejpanj]_ekj]eo `ahqp]_kjpn]]bkia*Be_]ikoo]^aj`kmqa(aikqpnkol]oaoajk>n]oeh(iehd]nao `alaook]o(ok^napq`k_ne]j]oae`koko(iknnai`alajne]aej]jek*Oajpeiko lea`]`a*Oajpeikoej`ecj]k`e]jpa`ap]i]jd]ejfqope]$aola_e]hiajpamq]j`kraikok `aolan`_ek`komqajkpibkiaareraij]]^qj` j_e]%*Oajpeikonaolkjo]^ehe`]`a*Ik) re`kolah]okhe`]nea`]`a(l]npe_el]iko`a_]il]jd]o_kjpn]]bkia*Aooaooajpeiajpkoa]o ] ao`aoaj_]`a]`]olknahaoatlneiaijkookpbkpljlo^i(eopk(]i]jaen]_kik]r]he]iko jkoo]oepq]ka]`ajkookooaiahd]jpaooacqj`ke`ae]o_kik]o`agrpqf ^afkgrpqf ^* Mq]jp]oravao(har]`kolkn]hcqieilqhokej_kjpnkhrahkqlkn]hcqi]aikkbknpa $ia`k(kncqhdk(]i^ek(r]e`]`a(_kr]n`e]%(b]vaiko]hcqi]_keo]`amqa(`alkeo(oajpeiko ranckjd](naiknok(_qhl]*Ckop]n]iko`arkhp]njkpailka]cen`aik`k`ebanajpa*Aooao oajpeiajpkop]i^iatlneiaijkookpbkpljlo^i(eopk(]]r]he]k`ajkook_kilknp]) iajpkoacqj`ke`ae]o_kik]o`a`boqlaboo^al* Aiiqep]ok_]oe ao(Ú_]iko_kjpajpaoaaik_ekj]`ko`e]jpa`aqi]laook]_qf]ol]) h]rn]oa] aoi]jebaop]idkjaope`]`a(dkjn]`av(aolnepk`afqope](]hpnqoikÍiaoik mq]j`kpq`keookhda_qop]o]_neb_eko*Oajpeikomqadcn]j`av]a`ecje`]`ajaoo]laook]* Oajpeiko]`ien]klknah]a`aoaf]ikoeiep)h]*P]eoaik aoaoajpeiajpkop]i^iat) lneiaijkookpbkpljlo^i(eopk(]i]jaen]_kik]r]he]iko]_kj`qp]a]]k`akqpn]o laook]ooacqj`ke`ae]o_kik]o`ajofqlado^kabw^ab^ij^* Jkn]n]oravaookikopki]`kolahkdknnkn`e]jpa`]rekhj_e]6_d]_ej]`aoanaodqi]) jkoa]jei]eo(hej_d]iajpko(]oo]ooej]pko^nqp]eo(aopqlnko(cajk_`ek(pknpqn]oaoqlh_eko* ?kibnamqj_e](Ú_]ikoej`ecj]`ko]ko]^anmqaqiejk_ajpabkeejfqop]iajpa]_qo]`ka _kj`aj]`k(ajmq]jpkkran`]`aenk_qhl]`klani]ja_aeilqja*Oajpeiko_ han]`e]jpa`k _ejeoik`koiajpenkoko(`komqaqo]ikqpn]olaook]o_kikejopnqiajpkl]n]oaqoejpanao) oaoal]n]_kjoacqenr]jp]cajo_qop]`]^k])b`akqpnko*Pk`koaooaooajpeiajpkop]i^i i]jebaop]ijkookpbkpljlo^ikq]i]jaen]_kik]r]he]iko]o_kj`qp]o]hdae]ooacqj`k e`ae]o_kik]o`agrpqlafkgrpql(`boqlaboo^al* Reraiko_anp]ooepq] ao(kqo]^aikomqabkn]irere`]olknkqpnko(_kikoepq] ao`a atpnai]]Ûeka]jcope]*=ooei(lknatailhk(qi]laook]mqane`](_kiqi]`kaj]pan) iej]h(aoprer]]laj]olknmqaoaq_knlkaophec]`k]imqej]o*Oq]o`knaookejpkhanraeo*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Ej_kjo_eajpa(caiajkokbneiajpk*Jkoane]iahdknmqa`ao_]jo]ooaail]v;Jkoane]lna) banrah`aet)h]iknnan;Lk`aiko`aohec]nko]l]nahdko;Kqjkpaikok`enaepk`ab]v)hk; Mqab]van;Mq]h]]k_knnap]; Qi] fkrai `ao_k^na mqa aop cnre`]* Oajpa mqa oaq _knlk a oaq aolnepk ]ej`] jk aopklnal]n]`kol]n]]cn]re`av*O]^amqaoaql]n_aenk(iaoikmqa`aoafa]lke)h](pkfk) raia`aolnal]n]`kmq]jpkah]amqa]i^kojkpank_kiknaolkjo]^ehev]n)oalhaj]iajpa lah]caop]k(lahkl]npkalah]_ne]k`aqiÚhdk*=i^koaopk`aokneajp]`ko*Jko]^ai oalk`ank_kjp]n_kik]qthek`aoq]ob]ihe]o$oa]operanai%* Oaah]bkn]laj]oaopq`]jpa(pan`a`aet]n]ao_kh]l]n]pn]^]hd]n(]Úi`al]c]nkl]npk a]n_]n_ki]o`aolao]o`]_ne]j]*Oq]re`]aoaqbqpqnkiq`]nkl]n]oailna*Oapn]^]hd]( o]^amqalan`ankailnack(lknmqarerajqi]ok_ea`]`aj]mq]hkol]pn ao`eo_neiej]i]o iqhdanaocnre`]o(ok^napq`k]ookhpaen]o*Na_ae]jk_kjp]n_ki]]fq`]ak]lkek`ko]ie) cko*=kiaoikpailk(lkni(`aoaf]]_ne]j](okjd]_kiah](i]opaia`]n)hdaqi]re`]`a ieone]aoanejfqop]_kimqaijkla`eql]n]j]o_an*Lk`ab]vanqi]^knpk;@arab]v)hk; Qil]e`ab]ihe]`aoailnac]`k(_kirnekoÚhdkolamqajkoa]aolko]`kajpa(na_a^a qi]kbanp]`aailnackmqaatecamqaoaf]`aokjaopka_kiap]ennacqh]ne`]`aomqa^ajaÚ) _eaioaql]pnk*O]^amqakpn]^]hdkhdalaniepenoqopajp]nkoÚhdkoal]c]nkpn]p]iajpk `]aolko]*@ara]_aep]nkailnack(iaoiko]^aj`kkmqaoanatece`k`aha;Kq`arana_q) o)hkarankoÚhdko_kibkiaa]iqhdaniknnaj`k; Qin]l]vj]ikn](dpailko(qi]ik]`amqaickop]iqepkalknah]_knnaolkj`e`k* ?kjda_aqi]kqpn]*=l]etkj])oalan`e`]iajpaa_knnaolkj`e`k*=i]`q]oiqhdanaoa]i) ^]ok]i]i*Lk`apan`keo]iknaooeiqhp jako(kqaop]npn]ej`k]]i^koa]oeiaoik;@ara i]ck]nqi]`ah]oa]oeiaoik(nkilaj`k_kiqi]l]n]Ú_]n_ki]kqpn];K]iknateca qi]je_]laook]]i]`]kqlk`aoanihpelhk;Mqaoajpenk]o`q]oiqhdanaooaahahdao_kj) p]nkmqaoal]oo];Kq`araniajpenl]n]]i^]o;Mqab]van;Oa(ajmq]jpkaop]pkniajp]`k lah]ej`a_eok(qi_kjda_e`kkrkn]_kiqi]`]oiqhdanao(kn]_ki]kqpn]a(_kjda_aj`k qi]`ah]o(`aran_kjp]n]ah]kmqareq;Aijkia`]]iev]`a(`arab]h]nkq_]h]n; Qi]iqhdanrqibqnpk*Rqi]_ne]j]i]hpn]lehd]aaobkia]`]lac]nbnqp]oalao jqi]ian_a]ne]*O]^amqak`kjk`]ian_a]ne]aopl]oo]j`klkniqep]o`eÚ_qh`]`aoamqa kbqnpkb]n`ebanaj]l]n]aha*I]op]i^ir]ieone]a]bkia`]_ne]j]*@ara`ajqj) _e)h]( fqhc]j`k mqa _ki eook ] _ne]j] jk oa pknj]n qi ]`qhpk h]`nk a k lnklneapnek `]ian_a]ne]jkpanlnafqvk`ab]pk;Kq`aranoehaj_e]n(lkeo]_ne]j]_knnakneo_k`a na_a^an lqjek at_aooer]( oan har]`] lah] lkh_e]( oan fkc]`] jkr]iajpa o nq]o a( ]ckn]( narkhp]`](l]oo]n`kbqnpk]kdkie_`ek;Mqab]van; Qi]laook]r(j]olknp]o`aqi]ao_kh](qifkrairaj`aj`k`nkc]]qikqpnk*Aoo] laook]o]^amqap]jpkkfkraipn]Ú_]jpa_kikkfkrai_kjoqie`knaopkna]hev]j`k] ao] mqabkn]ihar]`kolah]]pere`]`a`k_neiaknc]jev]`k(_kjpn]kmq]h]obkn]olkhe_e]eol]na) _aieilkpajpao*@ara`ajqj_e]nkfkraipn]Ú_]jpa(iaoiko]^aj`kmqa_kieookjk]pej) cen]olk`anko]obkn]omqaoqopajp]ikpnÚ_k(i]o]laj]oqibn]_k]jah`aqi]_knnajpa _neiejko]mqalani]ja_aneilqjaamqalk`anrkhp]n)oa_kjpn]mqaibav]`ajj_e];Kq `arab]h]n_ki]o]qpkne`]`aoao_kh]naol]n]mqapkiai]hcqi]lnkre`j_e]_kinah]k ]kfkrai_kjoqie`kn;I]o`amqa]`e]jp]nrkhp]n)oa_kjpn]k_kjoqik(oaj]`]lk`ab]van _kjpn]]raj`]lnklne]iajpa`ep];Jkajp]jpk(_kiklk`anoajpen)oaail]vo]^aj`kmqa dqifkraimqap]hravlkoo]oano]hrk`aqir_ekmqaen`aopnq)hk;Mqab]van; Oepq] ao_kikaoo]oÍi]eo`n]ipe_]okqiajko`n]ipe_]oÍoqncaioailnaai jkoo] re`]* Jkoo]o `re`]o mq]jpk `a_eok ] pki]n jk i]jebaop]i jkook pbkpl jlo^i $eopk(jkookooajpeiajpkomq]jpk]k`boqlakboo^al(]kgrpqlakfkgrpql%(i]ol ailnk) r]jkoo]`lkp`fk`f^jlo^i(lkeoatecaimqa(oaioanikok^nec]`kolknkqpnko(`a_e`]iko kmqab]van(mqafqopeÚmqaikol]n]j oiaoikoal]n]kokqpnko]on]v ao`ajkoo]o`a_e) o aoamqa]ooqi]ikopk`]o]o_kjoamqj_e]o`ah]o(lknmqaokikonaolkjoraeolknjkoo]o kl ao*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hjkoaheiep]]kojkookooajpeiajpkoik) n]eo(i]ooanabanap]i^i]]r]he] ao`a_kj`qp]mqajkohar]i]pki]n`a_eo aolknj o iaoiko(]]cenai_kjbknie`]`a_kiah]oa]naolkj`anlknah]olan]jpakokqpnko*
/4,
=ateopj_e]pe_]x#!0É45,/ßx MORALßAßPALAVRAßMORALß VEMßDAßPALAVRAßLATINAßMOS ß MORIS ßQUEßQUERßß DIZERß±OßCOSTUME²ßNOß PLURALßMORESßSIGNIFICAßß OSßHfBITOSßDEßCONDUTAßß OUßDEßCOMPORTAMENTOßß INSTITUqDOSßPORßUMAßß SOCIEDADEßEMßCONDIlzESß HISTvRICASßDETERMINADAS
Pk`ko ko atailhko iaj_ekj]`ko ej`e_]i mqa koajok ikn]h a ] _kjo_ej_e]ikn]h nabanai)oa ] r]hknao $fqope]( dkjn]`av( aolnepk `a o]_neb_ek( ejpacne`]`a( cajankoe`]`a%( ] oajpeiajpkolnkrk_]`kolahkor]hknao$]`ien]k(ranckjd](_qhl](naiknok(_kjpajp]iaj) pk(_ han](]ikn(`re`](ia`k%a]`a_eo aomqa_kj`qvai]] ao_ki_kjoamqj_e]ol]n] j o a l]n] ko kqpnko* Ai^kn] ko _kjpa`ko `ko r]hknao r]neai( lk`aiko jkp]n mqa aopk nabane`ko]qir]hkni]eolnkbqj`k(iaoikmqa]laj]ooq^ajpaj`e`k6k_ljkqk_bj*Ko oajpeiajpkoa]o] ao(j]o_e`ko`aqi]klkajpnak_ljakj^rkqajpnak_bjakj^i( p]i^iaopknabane`ko]]hcki]eolnkbqj`kaoq^ajpaj`e`k6jkook`aoafk`a]b]op]n]`kna kokbneiajpka`a]h_]j]n]bahe_e`]`a(oaf]lknÚ_]niko_kjpajpao_kjko_kiaoiko(oaf]lkn na_a^aniko]]lnkr]k`kokqpnko*=hi`eook(kooajpeiajpkoa]o] aoikn]eook]mqahao mqa`alaj`ai]laj]o`aj oiaoiko(mqaj]o_ai`ajkoo]_]l]_e`]`a`a]r]he]na`a_e`en lknj oiaoikoajkhar]`kolknkqpnkokqk^nec]`kolknahao7aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(koajok a]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]eopi_kiklnaooqlkopkbqj`]iajp]h]e`ae]`aif_boa^ab`k]cajpa* Koajokikn]ha]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h`evainaolaepk]r]hknao(oajpeiajpko(ejpaj ao( `a_eo aoa] aonabane`ko]k^aia]ki]h(]k`aoafk`abahe_e`]`aa]katan__ek`]he^an`]) `a*@evainaolaepkonah] aomqai]jpaiko_kikokqpnkoa(lknp]jpk(j]o_aiaateopai _kikl]npa`ajkoo]re`]_kikqpnko]cajpaoikn]eo*Koajoka]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]eooklkn eook_kjopepqperko`ajkoo]bufpqk`f^fkqbopr_gbqfs^(eopk(`ajkoo]onah] ao_kikqpnko oqfaepkoikn]eo*
Fqvk`ab]pkafqvk`ar]hkn
O
/4-
a `eooanikoÎAop _dkraj`kÏ( aop]naiko ajqj_e]j`k qi ]_kjpa_eiajpk _kjop]p]`k lknj o(akfqvklnkbane`kqifqvk`ab]pk*Oa(lkni(b]h]niko6Î=_dqr]^k]l]n] ]olh]jp]oÏkqÎ=_dqr]^ah]Ï(aop]naikoejpanlnap]j`ka]r]he]j`kk]_kjpa_eiajpk* Jaooa_]ok(lnkbaneikoqifqvk`ar]hkn* Fqvko`ab]pkok]mqahaomqa`evaimqa]hckkqateopaamqa`evailnrb^p`lfp^p pl(`ljlplamlonrbpl*Aijkoo]re`]_kpe`e]j](i]op]i^ij]iap]boe_]aj]o_ej) _e]o(kofqvko`ab]pkaopklnaoajpao*@ebanajpaiajpa`ahao(kofqvko`ar]hknok^s^if^ bp lnkbane`]oj]ikn]h(j]o]npao(j]lkhpe_](j]nahecek*=r]he]i_keo]o(laook]o(] ao(atla) nej_e]o(]_kjpa_eiajpko(oajpeiajpko(aop]`ko`aaolnepk(ejpaj aoa`a_eo ao_kik^kjo kqi]qo(`aoafraeokqej`aoafraeo* Fqvko`ar]hknjkoaheiep]i]`evannrb^idlkq`ljl^idl(i]ooanabanai]kmqa ]hckabsbpbo*@aoo]lanola_per](kofqvkoikn]eo`ar]hknokjkni]perko(eopk(ajqj_e]i jkni]omqa`evai_kik`araioanko^kjooajpeiajpko(]o^k]oejpaj aoa]o^k]o] aoa _kik`araioan]o`a_eo aoa] aohernao*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(okjkni]omqa`apaniej]i kabsbopbo`ajkookooajpeiajpko(jkooko]pko(jkooko_kilknp]iajpko*Oklkneookfqvko mqa ajqj_e]i k^nec] ao a ]r]he]i ejpaj ao a ] ao oacqj`k k _nepnek `k _knnapk a `k ej_knnapk* Kofqvkoikn]eo`ar]hknjko`evailnrbplk^ai(ki]h(]he^an`]`a(]bahe_e`]`a* Kofqvkoikn]eojkni]perkojko`evaimqaoajpeiajpko(ejpaj ao(]pkoa_kilknp]iaj) pkoabsbjlpqbolrc^wbol]n]]cenikohernaiajpaal]n]]h_]j]nikok^aia]bahe_e`]`a* Ajqj_e]ip]i^imqa]pko(oajpeiajpko(ejpaj aoa_kilknp]iajpkook_kj`ajraeokq ej_knnapko`klkjpk`areop]ikn]h* ?kikoalk`ak^oanr]n(oajokikn]ha_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hokejoal]nraeo`]re`]_qh) pqn]h(qi]ravmqaaop]`aÚjal]n]koiai^nko`aqi]_qhpqn]kor]hknaolkoeperkoajac]) perkomqa`arainaolaep]na`aoaf]nkq`apaop]na`aolnav]n* Mq]h]knecai`]`ebanaj]ajpnafqvko`ab]pka`ar]hkn;=`ebanaj]ajpna]j]pqnav] a]_qhpqn]*=lneiaen](_kikreiko(_kjopepq`]lknaopnqpqn]oalnk_aookoja_aooneko( mqaateopaiaioealknoeiaoiko(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`aj o6]_dqr](lknatailhk(qi bajiajkiapaknkh ce_k_qf]o_]qo]oa_qfkoabaepkoja_aoonekojk`alaj`ai`aj oa mqa]laj]olk`aiko_kjop]p]naatlhe_]n*
/SWALDOß'OELDI#OLEljOßPARTICULAR ß2*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=_dqr](k^n]`k ]npeop]lhope_k Kos]h`kCkah`e( atlkop]jkIqoaq `a=npaIk`anj] =hkoekI]c]hdao $I=I=I%(aiNa_eba*
Lknoq]rav(]_qhpqn]j]o_a`]i]jaen]_kikkooanaodqi]jkoejpanlnap]i]oeiao) ikoa]ooq]onah] ao_ki]j]pqnav](]_nao_ajp]j`k)hdaoajpe`kojkrko(ejpanrej`kjah]( ]hpan]j`k)]lkniaek`kpn]^]hdka`]p_je_](`]j`k)hdaoecjeÚ_]`kooei^ he_koar]hknao* @evanmqa]_dqr]_l^l]n]]olh]jp]olnaooql a]nah]k_qhpqn]h`kodqi]jko_ki] j]pqnav]lknejpani`ek`]]cne_qhpqn]*?kjoe`an]n]_dqr]_bi^lnaooql aqi]nah]kr]) hkn]per]`kodqi]jko_ki]j]pqnav](lan_a^e`]_kikk^fapk`a_kjpailh]k(aj_]jpka `ahaepa*=_dqr]j]pqn]h7mqaoaf]^k]kq^ah](qi]]r]he]kkqejpanlnap]k_qhpqn]h* Bnamqajpaiajpajkjkp]iko]knecai_qhpqn]h`kor]hknaoikn]eo(`koajokikn]ha `]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hlknmqaokikoa`q_]`ko$_qhper]`ko%l]n]ahaoajahao(_kikoabkooai j]pqn]eokqbpe_ko(ateopajpaoaioealknoeiaoiko*Lknmqaeook]_kjpa_a;Lknmqa(l]n] c]n]jpen]i]jqpajk`kol]`n aoikn]eo]pn]ro`kpailkaoq]_kjpejqe`]`a`acan]k ]can]k(]ook_ea`]`aopaj`ai]k^qro^ifw*ilp(eopk(]b]van_kimqaoaf]ioacqe`koa naolaep]`ko _kik oa bkooai qi] oacqj`] j]pqnav]* = k^qro^ifw^ l `] ateopj_e] ikn]h ao_kj`a(lknp]jpk(]aooj_e]`]ikn]h(kqoaf](mqaah]aooaj_e]hiajpaqi]_ne]kdeop ) ne_k)_qhpqn]h(]hckmqa`alaj`a`a`a_eo aoa] aodqi]j]o*
pe_]arekh j_e]
M
q]j`k]_kil]jd]iko]deop ne]`]oe`ae]ope_]o(`ao`a]=jpecqe`]`a_hooe_]$cna) _k)nki]j]%]pjkooko`e]o(lk`aikolan_a^anmqa(aioaq_ajpnk(aj_kjpn])oak lnk^hai]`]rekhj_e]a`koiaekol]n]arep)h](`eiejq)h](_kjpnkh)h]*@ebanajpao bkni] aook_e]eoa_qhpqn]eoejopepqn]i_kjfqjpko`ar]hknaope_ko_kikl]`n ao`a_kj) `qp](`anah] aoejpanoq^faper]oaejpanlaook]eo(`a_kilknp]iajpkook_e]eomqalq`aooai c]n]jpen]oacqn]j]boe_]alomqe_]`aoaqoiai^nkoa]_kjoanr]k`kcnqlkok_e]h* Are`ajpaiajpa]orne]o_qhpqn]oaok_ea`]`aojk`aÚjen]ijai`aÚjai]rekhj_e] `]iaoi]i]jaen](]k_kjpnnek(`k)hda_kjpa`ko`ebanajpao(oacqj`kkopailkoakohq) c]nao(`ap]hi]jaen]mqakmqaqi]_qhpqn]kqqi]ok_ea`]`afqhc]irekhajpklk`ajk oan]r]he]`k]ooeilknqi]kqpn]*Jkajp]jpk(i]hcn]`k]o`ebanaj]o(_anpko]ola_pko`] rekhj_e]oklan_a^e`ko`]iaoi]i]jaen]j]orne]o_qhpqn]oaok_ea`]`ao(bkni]j`kk
mTICAßAßPALAVRAßmTICAßVEMß DEßDUASßPALAVRASßGREGASß mTHOS ßQUEßSIGNIFICAß±OßCA RfTERßDEßALGUmM² ßEßoTHOS ß QUEßSIGNIFICAß±OßCONJUNTOß DEßCOSTUMESßINSTITUqDOSß PORßUMAßSOCIEDADEßß PARAßFORMAR ßREGULARßEßß CONTROLARßAßCONDUTAßDEß SEUSßMEMBROS²
/4.
=ateopj_e]pe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
bqj`k_kiqi_kjpn]kmq]hkor]hknaope_kookancqe`ko*Bqj`]iajp]hiajpa(]rekhj_e] lan_a^e`]_kikÎatan__ek`]bkn]boe_]a`k_kjopn]jceiajpklomqe_kl]n]k^nec]n]h) cqi]]cen`aik`k_kjpnnekoq]j]pqnav]a]koaqoankq_kjpn]oq]ln lne]rkjp]`aÏ* Lkniaek`]bkn]a`]_k]klomqe_](k^nec])oa]hcqi]b]van]hck_kjpnnek]oe(]kooaqo ejpanaooaoa`aoafko(]koaq_knlkaoq]_kjo_ej_e](_]qo]j`k)hda`]jkolnkbqj`koaenna) l]nraeo(_kik]iknpa(]hkq_qn](]]qpk]cnaookkq]]cnaook]kokqpnko* Mq]j`kqi]_qhpqn]aqi]ok_ea`]`a`aÚjaikmqaajpaj`ailknj^i(`ofjbas`fl( `aÚjai]mqehkmqafqhc]ioanqi]rekhj_e]_kjpn]qiej`er`qkkq_kjpn]kcnqlk*Oeiqh) p]ja]iajpa(ancqaikor]hknaolkoeperkoÍk_bj(kjofqla]sfoqrabÍ_kik^]nnaen]o pe_]o_kjpn]]rekhj_e]* Aijkoo]_qhpqn](]rekhj_e]ajpaj`e`]_kiksfli^ l`]ejpacne`]`aboe_]alomqe_] `a]hcqi(`]oq]`ecje`]`adqi]j]*Aeolknmqak]oo]ooej]pk(]pknpqn](]ejfqope](]iaj) pen](kaopqlnk(]_]hje](]i)b(knkq^kok_kjoe`an]`korekhj_e](eikn]he`]`aa_neia* P]i^i_kjoe`an]ikorekhj_e]]molc^k^ l`]o_keo]oo]cn]`]o(_kik]ejr]okankq^k `aecnaf]o(pailhko(oej]ckc]o7`aopnqek`apatpko(ei]cajoaoi^khkonahecekoko7ejr]ok a`aopnqek`apiqhko*@]iaoi]i]jaen](rekhj_e]]afp`ofjfk^ lpl`f^ibmliqf`^`a laook]o lkn oq]o _kj`e ao pje_]o( _naj]o naheceko]o( _kjre_ ao lkhpe_]o a lnabanj_e]o oatq]eo(oaf]lkniaek`alneok(pknpqn]aiknpa* ?kjoe`an]j`kmqa]dqi]je`]`a`kodqi]jkonaoe`ajkb]pk`aoanain]_ekj]eo(`k) p]`ko`arkjp]`aherna(`a_]l]_e`]`al]n]]_kiqje_]kal]n]]re`]aiok_ea`]`a(`a _]l]_e`]`a l]n] ejpan]cen _ki ] j]pqnav] a _ki k pailk( jkoo] _qhpqn] a ok_ea`]`a jko `aÚjai_kikprgbfqlpal`lkeb`fjbkqlba^^ l)alkneookhk_]hev]]rekhj_e]aipq`k mq]jpkna`qv]qioqfaepk_kj`ek`ak^fapk*@klkjpk`areop]pe_k(okikolaook]oa jklk`aikooanpn]p]`ko_kik_keo]o(eopk(_kikoanaoejanpao(enn]_ekj]eo(`aopepq`ko`a hejcq]caia`ahe^an`]`a*Kor]hknaope_kooakbana_ai(lknp]jpk(_kikatlnaookac]n]j) pe]`ajkoo]_kj`ek`aoanaodqi]jkokq`aoqfaepkon]_ekj]eoa]cajpaohernao(lnke^ej) `kikn]hiajpa]rekhj_e](eopk(pq`kkmqajkopn]jobkniaai_keo]qo]`]ai]jelqh]`] lknkqpnko* =k`aÚjena]b]op]nbkni]o`arekhj_e](qi]_qhpqn]aqi]ok_ea`]`a`aÚjaiqi_kj) fqjpk `a ejpan`e ao mqa `arai oan naolaep]`]o lkn oaqo iai^nko* ?ki eook( jko b]vai lan_a^anmqa]ikn]hlnaooql aqi]`eopejkbqj`]iajp]h6]mqah]ajpnakmbojfqfalak molf_fal*=pe_]jkni]per]at]p]iajpalknmqaoq]ojkni]o`apaniej]ilanieoo aoa lnke^e aoareo]ieilknheiepaoa_kjpnkhao]kneo_klani]jajpa`]rekhj_e]*
Ko_kjopepqejpao`k_]ilkpe_k
L
/4/
]n]mqad]f]_kj`qp]pe_]lna_eokmqaateop]k^dbkqb`lkp`fbkqb(eopk(]mqahamqa _kjda_a]`ebanaj]ajpna^aiai]h(_anpkaann]`k(laniepe`kalnke^e`k(renpq`aa r_ek*=_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hjko _kjda_ap]eo`ebanaj]o(i]op]i^ioana_kjda_a _kik_]l]v`afqhc]nkr]hkn`ko]pkoa`]o_kj`qp]oa`a]cenai_kjbknie`]`a_kiko r]hknaoikn]eo(oaj`klkneooknaolkjorahlknoq]o] aoaoaqooajpeiajpkoalah]o_kj) oamqj_e]o`kmqab]vaoajpa*@lkp`fk`f^aobpmlkp^_fifa^abok_kj`e aoej`eolajoraeo `]re`]pe_]* =_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hi]jebaop])oa(]jpao`apq`k(j]_]l]_e`]`al]n]`ahe^an]n`e]jpa `a]hpanj]per]olkooraeo(]r]he]j`k_]`]qi]`ah]ooacqj`kkor]hknaope_ko(al]n]`a_e`en aao_khdanqi]`ah]o]jpao`ah]j]n)oaj]]k*]_]l]_e`]`al]n]]r]he]nalao]n]oikpe) r] aolaook]eo(]oatecj_e]obaep]olah]oepq]k(]o_kjoamqj_e]ol]n]oeal]n]kokqpnko( ]_kjbknie`]`aajpnaiaekoaÚjo$ailnac]niaekoeikn]eol]n]]h_]j]nÚjoikn]eoei) lkoorah%(]k^nec]k`anaolaep]nkaop]^aha_e`kkq`apn]jocna`e)hk$oakaop]^aha_e`kbkn eikn]hkqejfqopk%* =rkjp]`aaooalk`an`ahe^an]perka`a_eo nek`k]cajpaikn]h*L]n]mqaatan]aooa lk`an(]rkjp]`a`araoanifsob(eopk(jklk`aaop]noq^iape`]rkjp]`a`aqikqpnkjai
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
lk`aaop]noq^iape`]]koejopejpko$kqeilqhokoj]pqn]eo_acko%aol]et ao$oajpeiajpkoa aik aoej_kjpnkhraeomqa`kiej]ik]cajpa%(i]o(]k_kjpnnek(`arapanlk`anok^naahao aah]o(`kiej]j`k)koa_kjpnkh]j`k)ko* K_]ilkpe_k(]ooei(_kjopepq`klahk]cajpaherna(mqakoqfaepkikn]hkq]laook] ikn]h(alahkor]hknaoak^nec] aomqabkni]ik_kjpa`k`]o_kj`qp]oikn]eo(kqoaf](]o renpq`aokq]o_kj`qp]oa] ao_kjbkniao]k^ai*
K]cajpaikn]h K]cajpaikn]h(eopk(koqfaepkikn]hkq]laook]ikn]h(o lk`aateopenoalnaaj_dan ]ooacqejpao_kj`e ao6 oan_kjo_eajpa`aoea`kokqpnko(eopk(oan_]l]v`anaÛatka`ana_kjda_an]ateopj) _e]`kokqpnko_kikoqfaepkope_koecq]eo]oe7 oan`kp]`k`arkjp]`a(eopk6-%`a_]l]_e`]`al]n]_kjpnkh]nakneajp]n`aoafko(eilqh) oko(paj`j_e]o(l]et ao(oajpeiajpkol]n]mqaaopaf]iai_kjbknie`]`a_ki]ojkn) i]oakor]hknaokq]orenpq`aona_kjda_e`]olah]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h7a.%`a_]l]_e`]`a l]n]`ahe^an]na`a_e`enajpnarne]o]hpanj]per]olkooraeo7 oannaolkjorah(eopk(na_kjda_an)oa_kik]qpkn`]]k(]r]he]nkoabaepkoa]o_kjoa) mqj_e]o`ah]ok^naoeaok^nakokqpnko(]ooqie)h](^ai_kikooq]o_kjoamqj_e]o( naolkj`aj`klknah]o7 oanherna(eopk(oan_]l]v`akbana_an)oa_kik_]qo]ejpanj]`aoaqooajpeiajpko(]pepq) `aoa] ao(lknjkaop]noq^iape`k]lk`anaoatpanjkomqakbkn_aiak_kjopn]jf]i ]oajpen(]mqanana]b]van]hcqi]_keo]*=he^an`]`ajkp]jpkklk`anl]n]ao_khdan ajpnarnekolkooraeo(i]oklk`anl]n]]qpk`ajkiej]n)oa(`]j`k]oeiaoik]onacn]o `a_kj`qp]* =he^an`]`aajpaj`e`]_kik_]l]_e`]`al]n]oa]qpk`apaniej]nb]v_kimqa(`klkjpk `areop]`k]cajpakqoqfaepk+laook]ikn]h(]pe_]l]np]`aqi]`eopejkaooaj_e]h(mq]h oaf](]`ebanaj]ajpnam^ppfsfa^aba^qfsfa^ab* L]ooerk]mqahamqaoa`aet]ckranj]na]nn]op]nlknoaqoeilqhoko(ej_hej] aoal]e) t ao(lah]o_en_qjop j_e]o(lah]^k]kqioknpa(lah]klejek]hdae](lahkia`k`kokqpnko( lah]rkjp]`a`aqikqpnk(jkatan_aj`koq]ln lne]_kjo_ej_e](rkjp]`a(he^an`]`aanao) lkjo]^ehe`]`a* =k_kjpnnek(]perkkqrenpqkok]mqahamqa_kjpnkh]ejpanekniajpaoaqoeilqhoko(oq]o ej_hej] aoaoq]ol]et ao(`eo_qpa_kjoeckiaoika_kikokqpnkokoajpe`k`kor]hknaoa `koÚjoaop]^aha_e`ko(ej`]c]oa`araia_kik`araioannaolaep]`kokqpn]jocna`e`kolkn kqpnkor]hknaoaÚjooqlaneknao]koateopajpao(]r]he]oq]_]l]_e`]`al]n]`]n]oeiaoik]o nacn]o`a_kj`qp](_kjoqhp]oq]n]vkaoq]rkjp]`a]jpao`a]cen(pai_kjoe`an]klahko kqpnkooaioq^kn`ej]n)oajaioq^iapan)oa_ac]iajpa]ahao(naolkj`alahkmqab]v(fqhc] oq]oln lne]oejpaj aoana_qo]]rekhj_e]_kjpn]oea_kjpn]kokqpnko*Jqi]l]h]rn]( ^rqkljla(_kikp]h(ran`]`aen]iajpaherna*
Kor]hknaokqbejope_ko ?kikf`eooaiko(k_]ilkpe_k_kjopepq`klkn`keolkhkoejpanj]iajpanah]_ek) j]`ko6k]cajpakqoqfaepk+laook]ikn]hakor]hknaoikn]eokq]orenpq`aope_]o(mqaok _kjoe`an]`kokoÚjo`]]kpe_]kq]Új]he`]`a`]re`]ikn]h* @k lkjpk `a reop] `ko r]hknao( ] pe_] atlneia ] i]jaen] _kik qi] _qhpqn] a qi] ok_ea`]`a`aÚjail]n]oeiaoi]okmqafqhc]ioanki]hakr_ek(]rekhj_e]ak_neiaa( _kik_kjpn]l]npe`](kmqa_kjoe`an]ioank^aia]renpq`a(]^n]j`qn]akinepk*Ej`a) laj`ajpaiajpa`k_kjpa`ka`]bkni]mqa_]`]_qhpqn]hda`(pk`]o]o_qhpqn]o_kjoe`a) n]irenpq`a]hckmqakiahdkn_kikoajpeiajpk(_kik_kj`qp]a_kik]k7]renpq`a
PAIXjOßEMßNOSSAßLINGUA GEMßCOTIDIANAßATUAL ßUSA MOSßAßPALAVRAßPAIXjOßPARAß NOSßREFERIRMOSßAOßAMORß &ILOSvFICAßEßETICAMENTE ß PORmM ßOßAMORßmßUMAßß ENTREßMUITASßPAIXzES ßß POISßPAIXjOßSIGNIFICAßTODOß DESEJO ßTODAßEMOljOßEßTO DOßSENTIMENTOßCAUSADOSß EMßNvSßOUßPORßUMAßFORlAß IRRACIONALßINTERNAßOUßß PELAßFORlAßINCONTROLfVELßß DEßALGUMAßCOISAßEXTREMAß QUEßNOSßDOMINAß.Aßß PAIXjOßNjOßSOMOSßß SENHORESßDEßNvSßMESMOS ß MASßARRASTADOSßPORßß IMPULSOSßINTERNOSßOUß FORlASßINTERNASßQUEßNOSß DIRIGEMßEßCONTROLAMßß !LEGRIA ßTRISTEZA ßAMOR ß vDIO ßMEDO ßESPERANlA ß CvLERA ßINVEJA ßAVAREZA ßß ORGULHOßSjOßPAIXzES
AUTxNOMOßAßPALAVRAß AUTxNOMOßVEMßDOßGREGOß AUTOSß±EUßMESMO² ß±SIß MESMO² ßEßNOMOSß±LEI² ß ±NORMA² ß±REGRA² ß!QUELEß QUEßTEMßOßPODERßPARAß DARßAßSIßMESMOßAßREGRA ßAß NORMA ßAßLEIßmßAUTxNOMOß EßGOZAßDEßAUTONOMIAßOUß LIBERDADEß!UTONOMIAß SIGNIFICAß±AUTODETERMI NAljO²ß1UEMßNjOßTEMßAß CAPACIDADEßRACIONALßPARAßAß AUTONOMIAßmßHETERxNOMO ß PALAVRAßQUEßVEMßDOßGREGOß HETEROß±OUTRO² ßEßNOMOSß ±RECEBERßDEßUMßOUTROßAß NORMA ßAßREGRAßOUßAßLEI²
/40
=ateopj_e]pe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
]bu`bik`f^(]na]hev]klanbaep]`aqiik`k`aoan(oajpena]cen*Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](kr_ek kmqaklekn_kikoajpeiajpk(_kik_kj`qp]a_kik]k7kr_ek]_^fubw^`kooajpe) iajpkoa`]o] ao* Lknna]hev]n)oa_kiknah]kejpanoq^faper]aok_e]h(]pe_]jk]hdae]kqej`ebanajpao _kj`e aodeop ne_]oalkhpe_]o(a_kjie_]oa_qhpqn]eo`]]kikn]h*?kjoamqajpaiajpa( ai^kn]`klkjpk`areop]`]ok_ea`]`amqa]ejopepqeqi]pe_]oaf]oailna_kjoe`an]`] qjerano]h$rkfsbop^ilknmqaoaqor]hknaookk^nec]p nekol]n]pk`kokooaqoiai^nko%(`a b]pk(pk`]pe_]aopainah]k_kikpailka]deop ne](pn]jobkni]j`k)oal]n]naolkj`an ]atecj_e]ojkr]o`]ok_ea`]`aa`]_qhpqn](lkeookikooanaodeop ne_koa_qhpqn]eoajkoo] ]koa`aoajnkh]jkpailk*
Koiaekoikn]eo =hi`koqfaepkkqlaook]ikn]ha`kor]hknaokqÚjoikn]eo(k_]ilkpe_k]ej`] _kjopepq`klknqikqpnkahaiajpk6kojbflpl]n]mqakoqfaepkna]hevakoÛkp* ?kopqi])oa`evanmqakoÚjofqopeÚ_]ikoiaeko(`aik`kmqa(l]n]]h_]j]nqiÚi hacpeik(pk`kokoiaeko`eolkjraeookrhe`ko*Jk_]ok`]pe_](lkni(aoo]]Úni]kjk ]_aeprah* Oqlkjd]ikoqi]ok_ea`]`amqa_kjoe`anaqir]hknaqiÚiikn]h]ha]h`]`aajpna oaqoiai^nko(^]oa]`]j]_kjÚ]j]na_lnk_]*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa]iajpen](]ejraf](]]`qh]) k(]i)b(]_nqah`]`aakia`k`arankaop]nat_hq`ko`]re`]ikn]ha(lkn_kjoacqejpa( ] aomqaailnacqaiaoo]o]pepq`aoaaooaooajpeiajpko_kikiaekol]n]]h_]j]nkÚi $jk_]ok(]ha]h`]`a%oankeikn]eo* Jkajp]jpk(lk`ane]]_kjpa_anmqa(l]n]bkn]n]hcqiha]h`]`a(oane]lna_eokb]v)hk oajpenia`k`]lqjeklah]`aoha]h`]`a(kqoane]lna_eokiajpen)hdal]n]mqajklan`ao) oa]_kjÚ]j]ai_anp]olaook]oa_kjpejq]ooaha]h]ah]o*Jaooao_]oko(kÚiÍ]ha]h`]`a ÍjkfqopeÚ_]ne]koiaekoÍqok`kia`ka`]iajpen];=naolkop]pe_]kl*Lknmq; Lknmqaaooaoiaeko`aonaolaep]i]_kjo_ej_e]a]he^an`]`a`]laook]ikn]h(mqa]cene]lkn _k]katpanj]ajklknna_kjda_eiajpkejpaneknaran`]`aenk`kÚipe_k* Jk_]ok`]pe_](lknp]jpk(jaipk`kokoiaekookfqopeÚ_raeo(i]o]laj]o]mqahao mqaaopk`a]_kn`k_kikoÚjo`]ln lne]]k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(Ûkpqf`lpbufdbjjbflp qf`lp* =nah]kajpnaiaekoaÚjolnaooql a]e`ae]`aafp`bokfjbkql(eopk(mqao]e^]iko `eopejcqenajpnaiaekoikn]eoaeikn]eo(p]eo_kikjkoo]_qhpqn]kqjkoo]ok_ea`]`ako`a) Újai* Eook oecjeÚ_] p]i^i mqa aooa `eo_anjeiajpk jk j]o_a _kjko_k( i]o lna_eo] oan ]`mqene`ka(lknp]jpk(]laook]ikn]hjkateopa_kikqib]pk`]`k(i]o_ne]`]lah]re`] ejpanoq^faper]aok_e]h(lna_eo]j`koana`q_]`]l]n]kor]hknaoikn]eoal]n]]orenpq`ao`a oq]ok_ea`]`a* Lk`an]iko(ajpnap]jpk(ej`]c]noa]a`q_]kpe_]jkoane]qi]rekhj_e]*Ailne) iaenkhqc]n(lknmqa(oap]ha`q_]kreo]pn]jobkni]n)jko`al]ooerko$kqoq^iape`kobkn] `]ol]et ao%ai]perko$kqoajdknao`ajkoo]n]vkahe^an`]`a%(lk`an]ikolancqjp]noa jkoo]j]pqnav]jkoane]aooaj_e]hiajpal]ooekj]ha(lknp]jpk(oabkn]n)jkon]_ekj]he`]`a ]per]jkoane]qi]pk`arekhj_e]_kjpn]]jkoo]j]pqnav]aolkjp ja](fmqarekhj_e] bkn]n]hcqi]oajpena]cen`ai]jaen]_kjpnne]oq]j]pqnav]*Aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqa( oaaoo]a`q_]kreo]_khk_]n)jkoaid]nikje]aai]_kn`k_kikor]hknao`ajkoo]ok_ea) `]`a(lk`an]ikoej`]c]noaeookjkjkooq^iapane]]qilk`anatpanjkjkoo]_kjo_ej) _e](klk`an`]ikn]hok_e]ha(jaooa_]ok(airav`aoqfaepko]qpjkikokqhernao(oan]iko ao_n]rko`]ojkni]o(nacn]oar]hknaoeilkopkolknjkoo]ok_ea`]`a*L]n]naolkj`an]aoo]o mqaop aolna_eo]ikoat]iej]nk`aoajrkhreiajpk`]oe`ae]ope_]oj]ÚhkokÚ]*
/41
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
#APqTULOß =behkokbe]ikn]h pe_]kqbehkokbe]ikn]h
P
k`]_qhpqn]a_]`]ok_ea`]`aejopepqeqi]ikn]h(eopk(r]hknao_kj_anjajpao]k^aia ]ki]h(]klaniepe`ka]klnke^e`ka_kj`qp]_knnap]aej_knnap](rhe`kol]n]pk`ko kooaqoiai^nko*?qhpqn]oaok_ea`]`aobknpaiajpadean]nmqev]`]oa_ki`ebanaj]o `a_]op]okq`a_h]ooaoiqepklnkbqj`]olk`ai]piaoiklkooqenrne]oikn]eo(_]`]qi] `ah]onabane`]]kor]hknao`aqi]_]op]kq`aqi]_h]ooaok_e]h* Jk ajp]jpk( ] oeilhao ateopj_e] `] ikn]h jk oecjeÚ_] ] lnaoaj] atlh_ep] `a qi] qf`^(ajpaj`e`]_kikÛilplÛ^jlo^i(eopk(qi]naÛatkmqa`eo_qp](lnk^hai]pevaaej) panlnapakoecjeÚ_]`k`kor]hknaoikn]eo*=k_kjpnnek(_kik`eooaikojk_]lpqhk]jpanekn( pk`]ok_ea`]`apaj`a]k^qro^ifw^o]ikn]h(`ai]jaen]]]ooacqn]noq]lanlapq]k]pn]ro `kopailko*@ab]pk(ko_kopqiaook]jpaneknao]kjkookj]o_eiajpkabkni]ikpa_e`k`] ok_ea`]`aaimqareraiko(`aik`kmqa]_]^]ioaj`k_kjoe`an]`koejmqaopekjraeoa]o ok_ea`]`aopaj`ai]j]pqn]hev)hko$eopk(]pki)hko_kikb]pkoj]pqn]eoateopajpaolknoe iaoiko%*Jko eook*L]n]]ooacqn]noaq]ola_pkk^nec]p nekmqajklk`aoanpn]jocna`e`k( iqep]ook_ea`]`aopaj`ai]p^`o^ifw*ilp(kqoaf](]onahece aoko_kj_a^aikn`aj]`kolahko `aqoao(j]knecai`kopailko*?kik]oln lne]ol]h]rn]oej`e_]i(qf`^ajlo^inabanai)oa ]k_kjfqjpk`a_kopqiaopn]`e_ekj]eo`aqi]ok_ea`]`aamqa(_kikp]eo(ok_kjoe`an]`ko r]hknaoak^nec] aol]n]]_kj`qp]`aoaqoiai^nko* =ÚhkokÚ]ikn]hkq]`eo_elhej]`ajkiej]`]^qf`^j]o_amq]j`koal]oo]]ej`]c]nl nrbpl(ablkabsjalnrbs^ibjko_kopqiao* =ÚhkokÚ]ikn]hkq]pe_]j]o_amq]j`k(]hi`]omqaop aook^nako_kopqiao(p]i) ^ioa^qo_]_kilnaaj`ank_]npan`a_]`]laook](eopk(kpbkpljlo^ia]`lkp`fk`f^ jlo^iej`ere`q]eo* Lk`aiko`evan(_ki^]oajkopatpko`aLh]pka`a=neop pahao(mqa(jkK_e`ajpa(]pe_] kqÚhkokÚ]ikn]heje_e])oa_kiO _n]pao*
O_n]pao(kej_]jorahlancqjp]`kn Lan_knnaj`kln]]oanq]o`a=paj]oÍ_kjp]iLh]pka=neop pahaoÍ(O _n]paolancqj) p]r]]ko]pajeajoao(bkooaifkrajokqrahdko(kmqaan]ikor]hknaojkomq]eo]_na`ep]r]i amqanaolaep]r]i]k]cen* Mqalancqjp]ohdaob]ve]aha;Ej`]c]r]6ÎKmqa]_kn]cai;Ï(ÎKmqa]fqope];Ï(ÎKmqa ]lea`]`a;Ï(ÎKmqa]]iev]`a;Ï*=ah]oko]pajeajoaonaolkj`e]i`evaj`koanairenpq`ao* O _n]paorkhp]r]]ej`]c]n6ÎKmqa]renpq`a;Ï*Napnq_]r]iko]pajeajoao6Î]cenai_kjbkn) ie`]`a_kik^aiÏ*AO _n]paomqaopekj]r]6ÎMqak^ai;Ï* =olancqjp]ook_npe_]opaniej]r]ioailnalknnarah]nmqako]pajeajoaonaolkj`e]i oailajo]njkmqa`eve]i*Nalape]ikmqahdaobkn]ajoej]`k`ao`a]ejb j_e]*?kik_]`] qid]re]ejpanlnap]`koq]i]jaen]kmqa]lnaj`an](an]_kiqi(mq]j`kqicnqlk_kj) rano]r]_kikÚh okbk(qi]lancqjp]na_a^annaolkop]o`ebanajpaoa_kjpn]`ep ne]o*=l oqi _anpkpailk`a_kjrano]_kiO _n]pao(qi]pajeajoare])oa`e]jpa`a`q]o]hpanj]per]o6kq v]jc]n)oa_ki]eilanpejj_e]`kÚh okbklancqjp]`knaenai^kn]ennep]`k(kqna_kjda_an mqajko]^e]kmqaei]cej]r]o]^an(`eolkj`k)oa]_kia]n(j]_kil]jde]`aO _n]pao(] ^qo_]Úhko Ú_]`]renpq`aa`k^ai*
mTHOSßNAßLqNGUAßGREGAß EXISTEMßDUASßVOGAISßPARAß PRONUNCIARßEßGRAFARßNOSSAß VOGALßEßUMAßVOGALßBREVE ß CHAMADAßEPSqLON ßEßUMAß VOGALßLONGA ßCHAMADAß ETAßbTHOS ßESCRITAßCOMßAß VOGALßLONGA ßSIGNIFICAß±COS TUME²ßPORmM ßSEßESCRITAß COMßAßVOGALßBREVE ßmTHOS ß SIGNIFICAß±CARfTER² ß±qNDOLEß NATURAL² ß±TEMPERAMENTO² ß ±CONJUNTOßDASßDISPOSIlzESß FqSICASßEßPSqQUICASßDEßUMAß PESSOA²ß.ESSEßSEGUNDOß SENTIDO ßmTHOSßSEßREFEREß gSßCARACTERqSTICASßDEßCADAß UM ßASßQUAISßDETERMINAMß QUEßVIRTUDESßEßQUEßVqCIOSß CADAßINDIVqDUOßmßCAPAZßß DEßPRATICAR
/42
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
(ENRIß#ARTIER "RESSON -AGNUM,ATINSTOCK
Lkq_k`alkeo`kI]ek `a-524(aiL]neo(k _hemqa`kbkp cn]bk bn]j_o?]npean)>naookj _]lp]kat]pkejop]jpa aimqakkhd]n`] oajdkn]nalkqo]ok^na ]iejeoo]e]`]ik]( oqcanej`kqi] oqlkop]_ajoqn]*
/43
Lknmqako]pajeajoaooajpe]i)oaai^]n]]`ko$aiaoikennep]`ko%_ki]olancqjp]o ok_npe_]o;Lkn`keoikperkolnej_el]eo6ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknlan_a^anaimqa_kjbqj`e]i r]hknaoikn]eo_kikob]pko_kjop]praeoaioq]re`]_kpe`e]j]$`eve]i(lknatailhk(Î?kn]) caikmqabavbqh]jkj]cqann]_kjpn]kolano]oÏ%7aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqa(ejrano]iaj) pa(pki]r]ikob]pko`]re`]_kpe`e]j]_kikoabkooair]hknaoikn]eoare`ajpao$`eve]i( lknatailhk(Î_anpkb]vanp]h]k(lknmqaiaqo]jpal]oo]`ko]Úvan]iaiaqol]najpao ]b]vaiÏ%*Ainaoqik(_kjbqj`e]ib]pkoar]hknao(lkeoecjkn]r]i]o_]qo]okqn]v aolkn mqar]hknev]r]i_anp]o_keo]o(_anp]olaook]okq_anp]o] aoa`aolnav]r]ikqpn]o*Lkneook iaoikoaai^]n]]r]ikqoaennep]r]imq]j`kO _n]paohdaoikopn]r]mqaaop]r]i_kj) bqoko(`evaj`k)hdaomqad]re]i`epkmqa]_kj`qp]`abqh]jkan]_kn]fko](i]ojkd]re]i atlhe_]`kkmqa]_kn]cai(kqmqa]_kj`qp]`a^ahpn]jkan]fqop](i]ojkd]re]iatlhe) _]`kkmqa]fqope]*P]eo_kjbqo ao(lkni(jkan]i$ajkok%ejatlhe_raeo* Jkooko oajpeiajpko( jkoo]o _kj`qp]o( jkoo]o ] ao a jko) oko_kilknp]iajpkookik`ah]`kolah]o_kj`e aoaimqare) raiko$b]ihe](_h]ooaacnqlkok_e]eo(ao_kh](nahecek(pn]^]hdk( _en_qjop j_e]o lkhpe_]o( ap_*%* Okiko bkni]`ko lahko _kopqiao `ajkoo]ok_ea`]`a(mqajkoa`q_]l]n]naolaep]nikoanalnk`q) venikokor]hknaolnklkopkolknah]_kik^kjoa(lknp]jpk(_kik k^nec] aoa`aranao*@aoo]i]jaen](r]hknaoa`aranaol]na_ai ateopenlknoeaaioeiaoiko(l]na_aioanj]pqn]eoaejpailk) n]eo(b]pkokq`]`ko_kikomq]eojkonah]_ekj]iko`ao`ajkook j]o_eiajpk6okikona_kilajo]`komq]j`kkooacqeiko(lqje) `komq]j`kkopn]jocna`eiko* O _n]pao ai^]n]]r] ko ]pajeajoao lknmqa ko bkn]r] ] ej) `]c]nmq]h]knecaia]aooj_e]$kq]oecjeÚ_]kran`]`aen]a ja_aoone]%`]orenpq`ao$r]hknaoak^nec] ao%mqafqhc]r]iln]) pe_]n ]k oacqen ko _kopqiao `a =paj]o* ?kik a lkn mqa o]^e]i mqaqi]_kj`qp]an]^k]kqi(renpqko]kqre_eko];Lknmqa(lkn atailhk(]_kn]caian]_kjoe`an]`]renpq`aa]_kr]n`e](r_ek; Lknmqar]hknev]r]ilkoeper]iajpa]fqope]a`aor]hknev]r]i] ejfqope](_ki^]paj`k)];Jqi]l]h]rn]6kmqaan]iakmqar]) he]ina]hiajpako_kopqiaomqahdaod]re]ioe`kajoej]`ko; @enecej`k)oa ]ko ]pajeajoao( O _n]pao jk o hdao lancqjp]) r]mq]hkoajpe`k`ko`lpqrjbpaop]^aha_e`ko$kor]hknaope_kokq ikn]eo `] _khapere`]`a( pn]joiepe`ko `a can]k ] can]k%( i]o p]i^i ej`]c]r] mq]eo ]o `eolkoe ao `a `^oqbo $_]n]_panope_]o laook]eo(oajpeiajpko(]pepq`ao(_kj`qp]oej`ere`q]eo%mqahar]r]i ]hcqi]naolaep]nkq]pn]jocna`enkor]hknao`]_e`]`aalknmq* =kej`]c]nlnrbpl]renpq`aak^ai(O _n]paona]hev](j] ran`]`a(`q]oejpannkc] ao*Lknqih]`k(ejpannkc]]ok_ea`]`a l]n]o]^anoakmqaah]aopd]^epq]`]]_kjoe`an]nrenpqkoka^ki _knnaolkj`aabaper]iajparenpq`aa]k^ai7a(lknkqpnk(ejpan) nkc]koej`er`qkol]n]o]^anoa(]k]cen(lkooqaiabaper]iajpa _kjo_ej_e] `k oecjeÚ_]`k a `] Új]he`]`a `a oq]o ] ao( oa oaq _]npankqoq]j`khaokrenpqkokoa^kjona]hiajpa*=ej`]c]k pe_]ok_npe_]`eneca)oa(lknp]jpk(ok_ea`]`aa]kej`er`qk* =omqaop aook_npe_]oej]qcqn]i]pe_]kqÚhkokÚ]ikn]hlknmqa`aÚjaik_]ilkjk mq]hr]hknaoak^nec] aoikn]eolk`aioanaop]^aha_e`kolah]`apaniej]k`aoaqlkjpk `al]npe`]6]`lkp`fk`f^al^dbkqbjlo^i*prgbfqlqf`llrjlo^iokiajpa]mqahamqao]^a kmqab]v(_kjda_a]o_]qo]oakoÚjo`aoq]]k(koecjeÚ_]`k`aoq]oejpaj aoa`aoq]o ]pepq`aoa]aooj_e]`kor]hknaoikn]eo*O _n]pao]Úni]mqa]laj]okecjkn]jpare_ekokkq ej_]l]v`arenpq`a(lkeomqaio]^akmqa^aijklk`an`aet]n`a]cenrenpqko]iajpa*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=neoppahaoa]lnteo Oa`araiko]O _n]paokej_ek`]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]h(`araiko]=neop pahao]`eopejkaj) pnao]^anpakn pe_kkq_kjpailh]perkao]^anlnpe_k*Ko]^anpaknpe_kkq_kjpailh]perk k_kjda_eiajpk`aoanaoab]pkomqaateopaia]caiej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`aj oaoai jkoo]ejpanrajkkqejpanbanj_e](eopk(`aoanaoab]pkoj]pqn]eoa`erejko*Ko]^anlnpe_k k_kjda_eiajpk`]mqehkmqao ateopa_kik_kjoamqj_e]`ajkoo]]ka(lknp]jpk(`a) laj`a`aj o*=pe_]a]lkhpe_]okqio]^anlnpe_k*Ko]^anlnpe_klk`aoan`a`keopelko6 lnteokqp_je_]* J]moufp(k]cajpa(]]ka]Új]he`]`a`k]cenokejoal]nraeokqe`jpe_ko(lkeok ]cajpa(kmqaahab]va]Új]he`]`a`aoq]]kokkiaoik*=ooei(lknatailhk(`evan] ran`]`aqi]renpq`a`k]cajpa(ejoal]nrah`aoq]b]h]ran`]`aen]a`aoq]Új]he`]`a(mqa lnkbanen qi] ran`]`a7 jk lk`aiko `eopejcqen k b]h]jpa( ] b]h] a k _kjpa`k b]h]`k* J] moufppe_](okiko]mqehkmqab]vaikoakmqab]vaiko]Új]he`]`a^k]kqrenpqko]*=k _kjpnnek(j]p_je_](`ev=neop pahao(k]cajpa(]]ka]Új]he`]`a`]]kok`ebanajpaoa aopkoal]n]`ko(oaj`kej`alaj`ajpaoqjo`kokqpnko* Qi _]nlejpaenk( lkn atailhk( ]k b]van qi] iao]( na]hev] qi] ]k p_je_]( i]o aha ln lnekjkaoo]]kjai]iao]lnk`qve`]lknah]*=p_je_]pai_kikÚj]he`]`a] b]^ne_]k`a]hcqi]_keo]mqa`ebanajpa`k]cajpa$]iao]jkk_]nlejpaenk(`erano]) iajpa(lknatailhk(`aqi]]krenpqko](lkeoaop]koan`kln lnek]cajpamqa]na]hev]%* =hi`eook(ajmq]jpkj]moufp]]kaoq]Új]he`]`aoke`jpe_]o$]renpq`a]Új]he`]`a `]]krenpqko]%(j]p_je_]]Új]he`]`a`kk^fapkb]^ne_]`k`ebanajpa`]]kb]^ne_]`kn] $]]kp_je_]`ab]^ne_]nqi]iao](lknatailhk(eilhe_]kpn]^]hdkok^na]i]`aen]_ki ejopnqiajpko]lnklne]`ko(i]oeookj]`]pai]ran_ki]Új]he`]`a`]iao](qi]ravmqa kÚimqaah]pn]n`apaniej]`klahkqokalahkqoqnek%*@aoo]i]jaen](=neop pahao`eo) pejcqa]qf`^a]q`kf`^_kiklnpe_]omqa`ebanailahkik`k`anah]k`k]cajpa_ki] ]ka_ki]Új]he`]`a`]]k* P]i^i`araiko]=neop pahao]`aÚjek`k_]ilk`]o] aope_]o*Aop]ojko ok `aÚje`]olah]renpq`a(lahk^aialah]k^nec]k(i]op]i^ilanpaj_aimqah]aoban]`] na]he`]`aj]mq]h_]^ai]abif_bo^ la]ab`fplkqbp`lie^* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(mq]j`kk_qnok`aqi]na]he`]`aoacqahaeoja_aoone]oaqjerano]eo( jkd_kikjailknmqa`ahe^an]naao_khdan(lkeo]o_keo]o]_kjpa_ankja_aoo]ne]iajpa p]eo_kik]ohaeomqa]onacai`apaniej]imqa`ar]i]_kjpa_an*Jk`ahe^an]ikook^na]o aop] ao`k]jk(kikreiajpk`ko]opnko(]bkni]`koiejan]eokq`koracap]eo*Jk`ahe^a) n]ikojai`a_e`eikook^na]mqehkmqanace`klah]j]pqnav](eopk(lah]ja_aooe`]`a* I]o`ahe^an]ikoa`a_e`eikook^napq`k]mqehkmqa(l]n]oana]_kjpa_an(`alaj`a`a jkoo]rkjp]`aa`ajkoo]]k*Jk`ahe^an]ikoajk`a_e`eikook^nakkb`bppofl(lkeok ja_aoonekkmqaaoanoailnap]h_kik(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`aj o*@ahe^an]ikoa `a_e`eikook^nakmlppsbi(eopk(ok^na]mqehkmqalk`aoankq`aet]n`aoan(lknmqal]n]oan a]_kjpa_an`alaj`a`aj o(`ajkoo]rkjp]`aa`ajkoo]]k*?kieook(=neop pahao]_nao) _ajp]e`ae]`a_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h(pn]ve`]lknO _n]pao(]e`ae]`aslkq^abdrf^a^mbi^o^wl _kikkkqpnkahaiajpkbqj`]iajp]h`]re`]pe_]* Lkneookiaoik(`araiko]=neop pahaoqi]`eopejkmqaoan_ajpn]haipk`]o]obkn) iqh] aok_e`ajp]eo`]pe_](mq]hoaf](]`ebanaj]ajpnakmqamlok^qrobw^$kq_kjbknia mevpfp%akmqamloslkq^ab$kq_kjbkniahe^an`]`a%*Kja_aooneklknj]pqnav]7k lkoorah(lknrkjp]`a*Aeolknmqa(`ao`a=neop pahao(]Úni])oamqa]pe_]$a]lkhpe_]%oa nabanao_keo]oao] aomqaaopkaijkooklk`an* =eilknp j_e]`]`]lkn=neop pahaorkjp]`an]_ekj]h(`ahe^an]kaao_khd]kharkq ]_kjoe`an]n(ajpnapk`]o]orenpq`ao(qi]`ah]o_kik_kj`ek`apk`]o]okqpn]oalnaoajpa ai pk`]o ah]o6 ] lnq`j_e] kq o]^a`kne] lnpe_]* K lnq`ajpa ]mqaha mqa( ai pk`]o ]o oepq] ao( _]l]v `a fqhc]n a ]r]he]n mq]h ] ]pepq`a a mq]h ] ]k mqa iahdkn na]hev]nk ] Új]he`]`ape_](kqoaf](ajpna]orne]oao_khd]olkooraeo(mq]h]i]eo]`amq]`]l]n]mqak ]cajpaoaf]renpqkokana]hevakmqa^kil]n]oeal]n]kokqpnko*
/44
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
Oapki]niko]qf`^^Kf`j^`l(`a=neop pahao(jah]aj_kjpn]naiko]ojpaoa`]orenpq) `aomqa_kjopepq]i]at_ahj_e]a]ikn]he`]`acnac]o`qn]jpakpailk`]Cn_e]_hooe_]* Jaoo]k^n](=neop pahao`eopejcqar_ekoarenpq`aolahk_nepnek`kat_aook(`]b]hp]a`]ik) `an]k6qir_ekqioajpeiajpkkqqi]_kj`qp]at_aooerkokq(]k_kjpnnek(`aÚ_eajpao7 qi]renpq`a(qioajpeiajpkkqqi]_kj`qp]ik`an]`ko* Naoqie`]iajpa(aeokmq]`nk]neopkphe_k6 Renpq`a
R_eklknat_aook
R_eklknb]hp]
_kn]cai
paiane`]`a
_kr]n`e]
pailan]j]
he^anpej]cai
ejoajoe^ehe`]`a
he^an]he`]`a
lnk`ec]he`]`a
]r]nav]
naolaepkln lnek
rqhc]ne`]`a
rehav]
i]cjeÚ_j_e]
r]e`]`a
ik`ope]
cajpehav]
en]o_e^ehe`]`a
ej`ebanaj]
ran]_e`]`a
kncqhdk
`ao_n`epkln lnek
]cq`av]`aaolnepk
vki^]ne]
cnkooane]
]iev]`a
_kj`ao_aj`j_e]
p`ek
fqop]ej`ecj]k
ejraf]
i]harkhj_e]
Khac]`k`kobehokbkocnacko Oaat]iej]nikoklajo]iajpkÚhko Ú_k`ko]jpecko(ranaikomqajaha]pe_]]Úni] pnocn]j`aolnej_leko`]re`]ikn]h6
/45
-*
lknj]pqnav](kooanaodqi]jko]olen]i]k^aiabahe_e`]`a(mqao lk`aioan]h_]j) ]`kolah]_kj`qp]renpqko]7
.*
]renpq`aqi]at_ahj_e]]h_]j]`]lahk_]npan(p]jpk]ooeimqa]l]h]rn]cnac]mqa ]`aoecj]^obq(mqamqan`evanÎat_ahj_e]Ï*]bkn]ejpanekn`k_]npanmqa_kjoeopa j]_kjo_ej_e]`k^aiaj]_kj`qp]`aÚje`]lah]rkjp]`acqe]`]lah]n]vk(lkeo_]^a ]aop]hpei]k_kjpnkhaok^naejopejpkoaeilqhokoenn]_ekj]eo`ao_kjpnkh]`ko(mqaateo) paij]j]pqnav]`apk`koandqi]jk7
/*
]_kj`qp]pe_]]mqah]j]mq]hk]cajpao]^akmqaaopakmqajkaopaioaqlk) `anna]hev]n(nabanej`k)oa(lknp]jpk(]kmqalkooraha`aoafrahl]n]qioandqi]jk* O]^ankmqaaopaijkooklk`anoecjeÚ_](lnej_el]hiajpa(jkoa`aet]n]nn]op]nlah]o _en_qjop j_e]ojailahkoejopejpko(jailknqi]rkjp]`a]hdae](i]o]Úni]njkoo] ej`alaj`j_e]ajkoo]_]l]_e`]`a`a]qpk`apaniej]k*
Koqfaepkpe_kkqikn]hjkoaoq^iapa]ko]_]oko`]oknpa$kqkmqako]jpecko_d]) i]r]i`acloqrk^%(jairkjp]`aa]ko`aoafko`aqikqpnk(jaipen]je]`]ol]et ao$kq oajpeiajpkoa`aoafkoej_kjpnkhraeo%(i]ok^a`a_a]laj]ooq]_kjo_ej_e]Ímqa_kjda) _ak^aia]orenpq`aoÍaoq]rkjp]`an]_ekj]hÍmqa_kjda_akoiaeko]`amq]`kol]n] _dac]n]koÚjoikn]eo*=^qo_]`k^aia`]bahe_e`]`aok]aooj_e]`]re`]pe_]* KoÚh okbko]jpecko$cnackoanki]jko%_kjoe`an]r]imqa]re`]pe_]pn]jo_knne]_kik qiai^]pa_kjpjqkajpnajkooko]lapepaoa`aoafkoÍ]ol]et aoÍajkoo]n]vk*Lknj]pq) nav](okikol]ooekj]eoa]p]nab]lneiaen]`]pe_]]a`q_]k`ajkook_]npankq`ajkoo] j]pqnav]l]n]oacqeniko]kneajp]k`]n]vk*=rkjp]`alkooq]qihqc]nbqj`]iajp]h jaoo]a`q_]k(lkeoan]ah]mqa`arane]oanbknp]ha_e`]l]n]laniepenmqa]n]vk_kjpnkh]ooa a`kiej]ooa]ol]et ao* K l]ooekj]h ]mqaha mqa oa `aet] ]nn]op]n lkn pq`k mq]jpk o]peob]] eia`e]p]iajpa oaqo ]lapepao a `aoafko( pknj]j`k)oa ao_n]rk `ahao* @ao_kjda_a ] ik`an]k( ^qo_] pq`k eik`an]`]iajpa(]_]^]j`krpei]`aoeiaoik*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Lk`aikonaoqien]pe_]`ko]jpeckoaipno]ola_pkolnej_el]eo6 -*
k o^`flk^ifpjl6 ] re`] renpqko] ]cen ai _kjbknie`]`a _ki ] n]vk( mqa _kjda_a k ^ai(k`aoaf]acqe]jkoo]rkjp]`a]paha*=re`]renpqko]]mqah]aimqa]rkjp]`aoa `aet]cqe]nlah]n]vk7
.*
kk^qro^ifpjl6]re`]renpqko]]cenai_kjbknie`]`a_ki]j]pqnav]$k_koik%a_ki jkoo]j]pqnav]$jkookqelp%(mqa]l]npa`kpk`kj]pqn]h*=cenrkhqjp]ne]iajpajk (lknp]jpk(]cen_kjpn]]ja_aooe`]`aj]pqn]h$ok^naaop]jkpaikolk`anjajdqi%a oei]cenaid]nikje]_kiah](`ap]hi]jaen]mqaklkoorah(`aoaf]`kana]hev]`klkn jkoo]rkjp]`ana]hevajkoo]j]pqnav]ej`ere`q]ha]_khkmqaaid]nikje]_kikpk`k `]j]pqnav]7
/*
]fkpbm^o^_fifa^abbkqobqf`^bmliqf`^6eopk(]ejoal]n]^ehe`]`aajpna]_kj`qp]`k ej`er`qk a ko r]hknao `] ok_ea`]`a( lkeo okiajpa j] ateopj_e] _kil]npehd]`] _ki kqpnkoaj_kjpn]ikohe^an`]`a(fqope]abahe_e`]`a*
=pe_](lknp]jpk(an]_kj_a^e`]_kikbar`^ lal`^oqboalprgbfqljlo^il]n]`k) iej]nn]_ekj]hiajpaeilqhoko(]lapepaoa`aoafko(l]n]kneajp]n]rkjp]`anqik]k^aia bahe_e`]`a(al]n]bkni)hk_kikiai^nk`]_khapere`]`aok_eklkhpe_]*Oq]Új]he`]`aan] ]e^ojlkf^bkqobl`^oqboalprgbfqlsfoqrlplblps^ilobp`libqfslp(mqap]i^i`arane]i oanrenpqkoko*
K_neope]jeoik6ejpanekne`]`aa`aran
@
ebanajpaiajpa `a kqpn]o nahece ao `] =jpecqe`]`a( mqa an]i j]_ekj]eo a lkhpe_]o( k _neope]jeoikj]o_a_kiknahecek`aej`er`qkomqajkoa`aÚjailknoaqlanpaj) _eiajpk]qi]j]kkq]qiaop]`k(i]olknoq]bjqiiaoikaje_k@aqo*Ai kqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ajmq]jpkj]o`ai]eonahece ao]jpec]o]`erej`]`aoanah]_ekj]r]_ki]_kiq) je`]`aok_e]halkhepe_]iajpaknc]jev]`](k@aqo_neopknah]_ekj])oa`enap]iajpa_kikoej`e) r`qkomqajaha_naai*EookoecjeÚ_](]jpao`ai]eoj]`](mqa]re`]pe_]`k_neopkjk`aÚ) je`]lknoq]nah]k_ki]ok_ea`]`a(i]olknoq]nah]kaolenepq]haejpanekn_ki@aqo*@aoo] i]jaen](k_neope]jeoikejpnk`qv`q]o`ebanaj]olneikn`e]eoj]]jpec]_kj_alkpe_]6 ailneiaenkhqc]n(]e`ae]`amqa]renpq`aoa`aÚjalknjkoo]nah]k_ki@aqoajk _ki]_e`]`a$]mifp%jai_kikokqpnko*Jkoo]nah]k_kikokqpnko`alaj`a`]mq]) he`]`a`ajkoo]nah]k_ki@aqo(je_kia`e]`knajpna_]`]ej`er`qkako`ai]eo* Lknaooaikperk(]o`q]orenpq`ao_neopolneiaen]oa_kj`e ao`apk`]o]okqpn]ook ]c$mq]he`]`a`]nah]k`ajkoo]]hi]_ki@aqo%a]`^ofa^ab$k]ikn]kokqpnkoa] naolkjo]^ehe`]`alah]o]hr]k`kokqpnko(_kjbkniaateca]b%*=o`q]orenpq`aook lner]`]o(eopk(oknah] ao`kej`er`qk_ki@aqoa_kikokqpnko]l]npen`]ejpeie) `]`aa`]ejpanekne`]`a`a_]`]qi7 aioacqj`khqc]n(]]Úni]k`amqaokiko`kp]`ko`arkjp]`aherna$kqifsob*^o_qofl% amqa(ai`a_knnj_e]`]`aok^a`ej_e]`klneiaenkdkiai]koi]j`]iajpko`ere) jko$kqkla_]`kknecej]h`a=`kaAr]%(jkoo]rkjp]`aoalanranpaqajkoo]he^an`]`a `eneca)oaaolkjp]ja]iajpal]n]ki]hal]n]kla_]`k(eopk(l]n]]pn]jocnaook`]o haeo`erej]o*Okikooanaobn]_ko(la_]`knao(`ere`e`koajpnak^ai$k^a`ej_e]]@aqo% aki]h$`aok^a`ej_e]]@aqoaoq^ieook`kherna)]n^pnekpajp]k`aikj]_]%*K _neope]jeoik_kjoe`an](lknp]jpk(mqa(ai`a_knnj_e]`kla_]`kknecej]h(koandqi]) jkpknjkq)oaqi]j]pqnav]bn]_](ej_]l]v`ana]hev]nk^aia]orenpq`ao]laj]olah] bkn]`aoq]ln lne]rkjp]`a* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o( ajmq]jpk l]n] ko Úh okbko ]jpecko ] rkjp]`a an]qi]b]_qh`]`a n]_ekj]h_]l]v`a`kiej]na_kjpnkh]n]`aoia`e`]l]ooekj]h`ajkooko]lapepaoa`aoafko(
/5,
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
d]raj`k(lknp]jpk(qi]bkn]ejpanekn$]rkjp]`a_kjo_eajpa%mqajkopknj]r]ikn]eo(l]n]k _neope]jeoik(]ln lne]rkjp]`aaoplanranpe`]lahkla_]`kalna_eo]iko`k]qthek`erejk l]n]jkopknj]nikoikn]eo*Aooa]qthekpn]ve`klah]ibfafsfk^obsbi^a^kqlahkoj^ka^* jbkqlp`enap]iajpakn`aj]`kolkn@aqo]kodkiajoamqa`araioank^a`a_e`kok^nec]pk) ne]iajpa(oaijajdqi]at_ak*
=e`ae]`a`aran =_kj_alk_neopejpnk`qvqi]jkr]e`ae]j]ikn]h6]e`ae]`k`aran(eopk(]e`ae]`a mqa]renpq`a]k^nec]k`a_qilnenkmqakn`aj]`klah]hae`erej]* Lkniaek`]narah]k]kolnkbap]o$=jpeckPaop]iajpk%a`aFaoqo?neopk$JkrkPaop]) iajpk%(@aqopknjkqoq]rkjp]`aaoq]haei]jebaop]o]kooanaodqi]jko(`aÚjej`kapanj]) iajpak^aiaki]h(]renpq`aakr_ek(]bahe_e`]`aa]ejbahe_e`]`a(]o]hr]kak_]opeck* L]n]k^a`a_anhae`erej](pnorenpq`aookja_aoone]o6c(bpmbo^k ^a`^ofa^ab*Ok]oren) pq`aopakhkc]eo(eopk(nabane`]ojkoo]nah]k_ki@aqoÍoanrenpqkok^qo_]n]@aqoa _qilnen]rkjp]`a`a@aqo(kq(_kikoahj]>^he](kdkiairenpqkok]mqaha_qfk_kn]k aop_daek_ki]Hae`a@aqo* D( lkni( renpq`ao mqa oa nabanai ] mq]he`]`ao mqa jkoo] ]hi] kq jkook aolnepk `arai]`mqenenl]n]oa]lanbaek]naiana_an]o]hr]klnkiape`]lkn@aqo*=hae`erej] `aÚjamq]pnkrenpq`aolnej_el]eokqlneiaen]oÍ]orenpq`ao_]n`a]eoÍ`]omq]eopk`]o ]okqpn]o`alaj`ai6cloq^ibw^(grpqf ^(qbjmbo^k ^amorak`f^*=hi`ah]o(k_neope]jeoik `aÚjarenpq`aomqa_kj_anjai]kjkook_kilknp]iajpkatpaneknkqjkoo]_kj`qp](eopk (]orenpq`aoikn]eo6pl_ofba^ab(molafd^ifa^ab(qo^_^iel(`^pqfa^ab(j^kpfal(jlapqf^a dbkbolpfa^ab*Aiklkoek]ah]o(`aÚjakolnej_el]eor_eko(_kjda_e`ko_kikkooapala_]) `ko_]lep]eo6dri^(^s^obw^(mobdrf ^(iru of^(fo^$kq`ibo^%(pl_bo_^$kqlodriel%(fksbg^* Aeonaoqie`]iajpakmq]`nk_neopk6 Renpq`aopakhkc]eo
Renpq`ao_]n`a]eo
Renpq`aoikn]eo
Oapala_]`ko_]lep]eo cqh]
b
_kn]cai
ok^nea`]`a
aolan]j]
fqope]
lnk`ec]he`]`a
]r]nav]
_]ne`]`a
pailan]j]
pn]^]hdk
lnacqe]
lnq`j_e]
_]ope`]`a
hqtne]
i]joe`k
en]$kq_ han]%
cajankoe`]`a
ejraf]
ik`ope]
ok^an^]$kqkncqhdk%
=kodqi]jko_]^ana_kjda_an]rkjp]`aa]hae`a@aqo(_qilnej`k)]ok^nec]pkne]iaj) pa(eopk(lkn^qlpababsbo*Aopakje_kmqapknj]ikn]eoqioajpeiajpk(qi]ejpajk( qi]_kj`qp]kqqi]]k* ?ki]_kj_alk`k]pkikn]h_kik_qilneiajpkrkhqjpnek`k`aran(eopk(_kik k^nec]k`ak^a`ej_e]rkhqjpne]ohaeo`erej]okq]koi]j`]iajpko`erejko(k_neope]jeo) ikhackqÚhkokÚ]ikn]h]`eopejkajpnapnopelkobqj`]iajp]eo`a_kj`qp]6
/5-
-*
]`lkarq^jlo^ilrqf`^(mqaoana]hev]`a]_kn`k_ki]ojkni]oa]onacn]oeilkop]o lahk`aran7
.*
]`lkarq^fjlo^ilr^kqfqf`^(mqaoana]hev]_kjpn]ne]j`k]ojkni]oa]onacn]oÚt]`]o lahk`aran7
/*
]`lkarq^fkafcbobkqb jlo^i(mq]j`k]ceikoaioepq] aomqajkok`aÚje`]olahk ^aialahki]h(aj]omq]eojkoaeil ai]ojkni]oa]onacn]o`k`aran*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=e`ae]`aejpajk Fqjp]iajpa_ki]e`ae]`k`aran(]ikn]h_neopejpnk`qveqqi]kqpn](p]i^i`a_eoe) r]j]_kjopepqek`]ikn]he`]`ak_e`ajp]h6]e`ae]`aejpajk* =p k _neope]jeoik( ] ÚhkokÚ] ikn]h hk_]hev]r] ] _kj`qp] pe_] j]o ^ bp b k^p ^qfqr* abpsfpsbfp`k]cajpaikn]h(]ej`]mqaperaooai_kiklnaooqlkopk]hckmqaoana]hev]r]jk ejpanekn`k]cajpa(aioq]rkjp]`an]_ekj]hkq_kjo_eajpa*An]i]o_kj`qp]oreoraeomqa an]ifqhc]`]orenpqko]okqre_eko]o*K_neope]jeoik(lkni(qi]nahecek`]ejpanekne`]`a( ]Úni]j`kmqa]rkjp]`aa]hae`erej]ojkaopkao_nep]oj]ola`n]ojaijkolanc]iejdko( i]oejo_nep]ojk_kn]k`kooanaodqi]jko*=lneiaen]nah]kpe_](lknp]jpk(oaaop]^aha) _aajpnak_kn]k`kej`er`qka@aqo(ajpna]]hi]ejreoraha]`erej`]`aejreorah* ?kik_kjoamqj_e](l]ookq)oa]_kjoe`an]n_kikoq^iape`k]kfqhc]iajpkpe_kpq`k mq]jpk(ejreorah]kokhdkodqi]jko(reorah]kaolnepk`a@aqo(lknp]jpk(pq`kmq]jpk]_kj) pa_aaijkookejpanekn(aijkook_kn]k*K`aranjkoanabana]laj]oo] aoreoraeo(i]o p]i^i]ko`aoafko`k_kn]k(eopk(ofkqbk bpfksfpsbfp(mqal]oo]i]oanfqhc]`]oape_]) iajpa*Aeolknmqaqi_neopk(mq]j`koa_kjbaoo](k^nec])oa]_kjbaoo]nla_]`ko_kiape`kolkn ]pko(l]h]rn]oaejpaj ao*Oq]]hi](ejreorah(paikpaopaiqjdk`kkhd]n`a@aqo(mqa]fqhc]*
J]pqnav]dqi]j]a`aran
K
_neope]jeoikejpnk`qv]e`ae]`kabsbol]n]naokhranqilnk^hai]pe_k(mq]hoaf](kba) na_anqi_]iejdkoacqnkl]n]jkoo]rkjp]`a(mqa(oaj`khernai]obn]_](oajpa)oa `ere`e`]ajpnak^aiaki]h*Jkajp]jpk(aoo]e`ae]_ne]qilnk^hai]jkrk*Oak oqfaepkikn]h]mqahamqaaj_kjpn]aioq]_kjo_ej_e]$rkjp]`a(n]vk(_kn]k%]ojkni]o `]_kj`qp]renpqko](oq^iapaj`k)oa]laj]o]k^aiaf]i]eo]lk`anaoatpanjko_kjo_ej) _e](_kikb]h]nai_kilknp]iajpkpe_kmloabsbo;Aopajkoane]klk`anatpanjk`aqi] rkjp]`aatpanj]$@aqo%(mqajko`kiej]ajkoeil aoq]ohaeo(bkn]j`k)jko]]cenai_kj) bknie`]`a_kinacn]orej`]o`abkn]`ajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]; Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(oa]pe_]atecaqioqfaepk]qpjkik(]e`ae]`aabsbojkejpnk`q) vene]]ebqbolkljf^(eopk(k`kijek`ajkoo]rkjp]`aa`ajkoo]_kjo_ej_e]lknqilk`an aopn]jdk]j o;
Nkqooa]qa]ikn]h`k_kn]k Qi`koÚh okbkomqalnk_qn]n]inaokhranaoo]`eÚ_qh`]`abkeNkqooa]q(jko_qhkTREEE* L]n]aha(]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hakoajpeiajpk`k`aranokej]pko(okÎ]rkv`]j]pqnav]Ïak Î`a`k`a@aqoÏaijkook_kn]k*=lao]n`kla_]`k`klneiaenkdkiai(_kjoanr]ikoai jkook_kn]kraopceko`]^kj`]`aknecej]halkneookj]o_aikolqnkoa^kjo(`kp]`ko`acaja) nkoe`]`aa`a^ajarkhj_e]l]n]_kikokqpnko*Oak`aranl]na_aoanqi]eilkoekaqi] k^nec]katpanj](eilkop]lkn@aqo]kodqi]jko(lknmqajkoo]^kj`]`aj]pqn]hbkelanran) pe`]lah]ok_ea`]`a(mq]j`kaop]_nekq]lnklnea`]`alner]`]akoejpanaooaolner]`ko(pknj]j) `k)jkoackop]o(iajpenkokoa`aopnqperko*L]n]Nkqooa]q(bke]k`]nj]o_eiajpko^wlrqfifq* of^kqo^wlalpfkqbobppbpmqa]ok_ea`]`aoehaj_ekq]^kj`]`aj]pqn]h`k_kn]kdqi]jk* =ooei(hkjca`aoanqi]eilkoekatpanj](k`aranoeilhaoiajpakmqajkobkn]] na_kn`]njkoo]^k]j]pqnav]knecejne](mqaÚ_]ne]l]n]oailnaao_kj`e`]ok^koejpanaooao `]n]vkoak`aranjkjkoÚvaooana_qlan)h]*K^a`a_aj`k]k`aran$hae`erej]ejo_nep]j] j]pqnav]aaijkook_kn]k%(aop]ikok^a`a_aj`k]j oiaoiko(]kojkookooajpeiajpko ajkoo]oaik ao(ajkn]vk(lkeoaop](lnerehace]j`k]qpehe`]`aakejpanaooaej`ere`q]eo( naolkjorahlah]ok_ea`]`aackop]alanrano]*
G]jpa]ikn]h`]n]vklnpe_] Qi]kqpn]naolkop]]kiaoiklnk^hai](p]i^ijkÚj]h`ko_qhkTREEE(bkepn]ve`] lkn G]jp* Klkj`k)oa Îikn]h `k _kn]kÏ `a Nkqooa]q( G]jp rkhp] ] ]Úni]n k l]lah `]
/5.
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
n]vkj]pe_]*Jkateopa^kj`]`aj]pqn]h*Lknj]pqnav](`evG]jp(okikoackop]o(]i^e_ek) oko(`aopnqperko(]cnaooerko(_nqeo(re`ko`aln]vanaomqajqj_]jkoo]_e]ialahkomq]eo i]p]iko(iajpeiko(nkq^]iko*fqop]iajpalkneookmqalna_eo]iko`k`aranl]n]jko pknj]nikooanaoikn]eo* N]vklqn]pane_]an]vklqn]lnpe_] =atlkoekg]jpe]j]l]npa`a`q]o`eopej ao6 -*
]`eopejkajpnao^wlmro^qbof`^lrbpmb`ri^qfs^ao^wlmro^moqf`^7
.*
]`eopejkajpna^ lmlo`^rp^ifa^ablrkb`bppfa^aba^ lmloÛk^ifa^ablrif_boa^ab*
=n]vklqn]pane_]a]n]vklqn]lnpe_]okqjerano]eo(eopk(]oiaoi]ol]n]pk`ko kodkiajoaipk`kokopailkoahqc]naoÍko`lkqb alp`ko_kjda_eiajpkoa`]o] ao lk`air]ne]njkpailkajkaol]k(i]o]ocloj^p`]]pere`]`an]_ekj]h`a_kjda_eiajpka `]]pere`]`an]_ekj]hlnpe_]kq]kikn]hokqjerano]eo*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ko_kjpa`ko `k _kjda_eiajpk a `] ]k `alaj`ai `] r]ne]k deop ne_] kq `] atlanej_e]( i]o oq]o bkni]oej`alaj`ai`]atlanej_e]a`]deop ne](lkeo`alaj`ai`kprgbfqlqo^kp`bkabkq^i( _kikreikoj]pakne]`k_kjda_eiajpk* =`ebanaj]ajpnan]vkpa ne_]an]vklnpe_]aj_kjpn])oaaioaqok^fapko*?kjoanr]j) `k]`eopejkmqa=neop pahaoaop]^aha_an]ajpnaqblof^amoufp(G]jp_kjoe`an]mqa]n]vk pa ne_]kqaola_qh]per]pai_kiki]pne]kq_kjpa`k]na]he`]`aatpanekn]j o(qioeopa) i]`ak^fapkomqaklan]ioacqj`khaeoja_aoone]o`a_]qo]aabaepk(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa `ajkoo]ejpanrajk7ai_kjoamqj_e](]n]vklnpe_]jk_kjpailh]qi]_]qo]he`]`aat) panj]ja_aoone](i]oejopepqeoq]ln lne]na]he`]`a(j]mq]hoaatan_a*Aoo]na]he`]`alnpe_] fqop]iajpa]re`]ikn]hkq]ateopj_e]dqi]j]aiok_ea`]`a(ateopj_e]mqa`alaj`a`] ]k`]rkjp]`adqi]j](lkeo]ok_ea`]`aqi]ejopepqek_ne]`]lahkoln lnekodkiajo* =`ebanaj]ajpnan]vklqn]pa ne_]an]vklqn]lnpe_]`a_knna`]`eopejkajpnakb* `bppfa^abaÛk^ifa^ab,if_boa^ab* Ja_aooe`]`aahe^an`]`a
/5/
=j]pqnav]knaejk`]kb`bppfa^ab(eopk(`a]_kjpa_eiajpkonace`kolknoamqj_e]o ja_aoone]o`a_]qo]aabaepkÍknaejk_kjda_e`klah]o_ej_e]oat]p]oaj]pqn]eo$boe_]( ]opnkjkie](mqie_](^ekhkce]%*@ebanajpaiajpa`knaejk`]j]pqnav](dknaejkdqi]jk`] moufp(jkmq]h]o] aookna]hev]`]on]_ekj]hiajpajklknja_aooe`]`a_]qo]h(i]opaj`k aireop]ÚjokqlknÚj]he`]`a*J]ia`e`]aimqakoÚjookaop]^aha_e`kolahkoln lneko oanaodqi]jko(okbnqpk`abp`lie^pslirkqof^pa(lknp]jpk(]]kmloÛk^ifa^abqi] ^ lslirkqof^ifsobkqmloif_boa^ab* =n]vklnpe_]katan__ek`]he^an`]`a_kiklk`ann]_ekj]hl]n]ejopepqenÚjope_ko $kor]hknaoikn]eo%(kq]haeikn]h(mqa]iaoi]l]n]pk`kokoej`er`qko(qi]ravmqa] n]vklnpe_]qjerano]haaj_kjpn])oaaipk`kokooanaodqi]jko*L]n]]h_]j]naooaoÚjo kqr]hknao(koiaeko`araioanpe_kop]i^ialkneook]n]vklnpe_]ejopepqejkni]ol]n] ]]kpe_]*Kn](l]n]mqai]n]vklnpe_]ejopepqeÚjoajkni]o;L]n]oeiaoi]*L]n]mq; L]n]]kneajp]k`aoq]_kj`qp]_kjbknia]k^ai*J]ia`e`]aimqa]n]vklnpe_]pai klk`anl]n]_ne]njkni]oaÚjoikn]eol]n]oeiaoi](ah]p]i^iklk`anl]n]eil)hko ]oeiaoi]*Aoo]eilkoek`aÚjoajkni]omqa]n]vklnpe_]b]v]oeiaoi]`]mqehkmqa ah]ln lne]_nekqkabsbo* K`aran(lknp]jpk(hkjca`aoanqi]eilkoekatpanj]baep]jkoo]rkjp]`aajkoo] _kjo_ej_e](]atlnaook`ajkoo]he^an`]`a(eopk(`]lnaoaj]`]haeikn]hbjkp(i]je) baop]ki]eo]hp]`]dqi]je`]`abjkp*K^a`a_an]k`arank^a`a_an]oeln lnek_kik oann]_ekj]hmqa`]oeiaoik]haeikn]h*Lknhe^an`]`a`]rkjp]`a(koqfaepkikn]h(eopk( ]n]vklnpe_]qjerano]h(`]oeiaoikkor]hknao(koÚjoa]ojkni]o`ajkoo]]kikn]h* Lkneookokiko^rqkljlp*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
@aranaejpanaooa Naop](lkni(qi]mqaopk6oaokikon]_ekj]eoahernao(lknmqar]hknao(Újoajkni]oik) n]eojkokaolkjp jakoaij o(i]olna_eo]i]ooqien]bkni]`k`arana`aqi]haeikn]h; Naolkj`aG]jp6lknmqajkokikooanaoikn]eo]laj]o*P]i^iokikooanaoj]pqn]eo( oq^iape`ko_]qo]he`]`aja_aoone]`]j]pqnav]*Jkook_knlkajkoo]loemqaokbaepko`a ]lapepao(eilqhoko(`aoafkoal]et ao*Jkookooajpeiajpko(jkoo]oaik aoajkooko_ki) lknp]iajpkook^m^oqba^k^qrobw^bjkp(atan_aj`k`kijekok^naj o(oq^iapaj`k) )jko_]qo]he`]`aj]pqn]hejatknrah*Mqaioaoq^iapa]ahaojklk`alkooqen]]qpkjk) ie] pe_]* Lkn mq; Lknmqa eilqhoko( ]lapepao( l]et ao ok _]qo]`ko ai j o lkn _keo]o a bkn]oatpanj]o]j ook^na]omq]eojkpaiko`kijekaomq]eojkooq^iapaiko*=mqe( jkoo]rkjp]`ajkherna(i]o_kjopn]jce`]lknbkn]oatpaneknao]ah]* = j]pqnav] jko eilaha ] ]cen mlo fkqbobppb* ?kik l]n] Nkqooa]q( p]i^i l]n] G]jp kejpanaooa]bkni]j]pqn]h`kackoik(mqajkohar]]qo]n_keo]oalaook]o_kikiaeko a ejopnqiajpko l]n] k mqa `aoaf]iko* =hi `eook( atlhe_] G]jp( k ejpanaooa jko b]v reran j]ehqok`amqaokikohernaoan]_ekj]eolknna]hev]niko] aomqafqhc]ikopanaioe`k `a_e`e`]ohernaiajpalknj o(mq]j`k(j]ran`]`a(okqieilqhok_ack`apaniej]`klah] _]qo]he`]`aj]pqn]h*=cenmlofkqbobppb]cen`apaniej]`klknikper] aoboe_]o(lomqe_]o( rep]eo(i]jaen]`ko]jei]eo* Reopkmqa]lapepao(eilqhoko(`aoafko(paj`j_e]o(_kilknp]iajpkoj]pqn]eo_kopqi]i oaniqepki]eobknpao`kmqa]n]vk(]n]vklnpe_]a]ran`]`aen]he^an`]`alna_eo]iÎ`k) ^n]nÏjkoo]l]npaj]pqn]haklpfjmlojkookoanikn]h*Ah]okb]vaik^nec]j`k)jko]l]oo]n `]oikper] ao`kejpanaooal]n]k`aran*L]n]oanikohernao(lna_eo]ikooank^nec]`kolahk absboabpbojlpifsobp* =ooei(lancqjp]mqaÚvaikojk_]lpqhk]jpanekn$ok^naklaneck`a]a`q_]kpe_] oanqi]rekhj_e]_kjpn]jkoo]j]pqnav]aolkjp]ja]iajpal]ooekj]h%(G]jpnaolkj`anmqa ] rekhj_e] aop ai jk _kilnaaj`aniko jkoo] `aopej]k n]_ekj]h a ai _kjbqj`eniko jkoo]he^an`]`a_ki]o]peob]kenn]_ekj]h`apk`kokojkooko]lapepaoaeilqhoko*J]ia) `e`]aimqa]rkjp]`a`aÚjajkoo]j]pqnav]n]_ekj]h(j]ia`e`]aimqaah]oa`eopejcqa `kiankeilqhokj]pqn]h(lkeopai_kjo_ej_e]`koÚjoa`koiaekoa_]l]v`afqopeÚ_]n qi]]k(aj]ia`e`]aimqak`aranqi]_ne]krkhqjpne](lk`aiko_kj_hqenmqak `arannarah]jkoo]ran`]`aen]j]pqnav]`aoanaon]_ekj]eo*K`aranjkjkoeilkopkaoei lnklkopklah]n]vkjkoo]rkjp]`aherna*Mq]j`kkmqananak`aran_kej_e`ai(okikopbobp jlo^fp(lkeo]renpq`a]bkn]`]rkjp]`al]n]_qilnenk`aran*
K`aran(]Úni]G]jp(jkoa]lnaoajp]]pn]ro`aqi_kjfqjpk`a_kjpa`koÚtko(mqa `aÚjene]i]aooj_e]`a_]`]renpq`aa`ene]imqa]pko`arane]ioanln]pe_]`koaarep]`koai _]`]_en_qjop j_e]`ajkoo]re`]*K`aranjkqi_]phkck`arenpq`aojaiqi]heop]`aÎb]] eopkÏaÎjkb]]]mqehkÏ*K`aranqi]cloj^mqa`arar]hanl]n]pk`]amq]hmqan]kikn]h* Aoo] bkni] jk ej`e_]per]( i]o fjmbo^qfs^* Qi eilan]perk k mqa jk ]`iepa de) l paoao$Îoa***ajpkÏ%jai_kj`e aomqakb]ne]ir]hanai_anp]ooepq] aoajkr]hanai kqpn]o(i]or]hafk`lkaf`flk^ijbkqbbpbjbu`b bpl]n]pk`]o]o_en_qjop j_e]o`apk`]o ]o] aoikn]eo*Lkneook(k`aranqieilan]perk_]pacne_k*Kn`aj]ej_kj`e_ekj]hiajpa* Jkqi]ikper]kloe_kh ce_](i]o]haeikn]hejpanekn* Keilan]perk_]pac ne_katlneia)oajqi]b niqh]can]h6>dbbj`lkclojfa^ab^mb* k^p`lj^nrbi^jufj^mbi^nr^imlpp^pnrbobo^ljbpjlqbjmlnrbbi^pbqlokbrj^ibf rkfsbop^i+ Aoo]b niqh]laniepa]G]jp`a`qven]opnojufj^pjlo^fpmqaatlneiai]ej_kj`e) _ekj]he`]`a`ko]pkona]hev]`kolkn`aran*Okah]o6 -*
=ca_kikoa]itei]`apq]]k`araooaoananece`]lknpq]rkjp]`aaihaeqjerano]h `]j]pqnav]*
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
Keilan]perk_]pacne_ka]oitei]oikn]eo
)MMANUELß+ANTßß ¯
/50
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
.*
=ca`ap]hi]jaen]mqapn]pao]dqi]je`]`a(p]jpkj]pq]laook]_kikj]laook]`a kqpnai(oailna_kikqiÚiajqj_]_kikqiiaek*
/*
=ca_kikoa]itei]`apq]]k`araooaoanren`ahaeqjerano]hl]n]pk`kokooanao n]_ekj]eo*
=lneiaen]itei]]Úni]]rkfsbop^ifa^ab`]_kj`qp]pe_](]mqehkmqapk`kamq]h) mqanoandqi]jkn]_ekj]h`arab]van_kikoabkooaqi]haej]pqn]h(eopk(ejmqaopekjrah( rhe`]l]n]pk`koaipk`kpailkahqc]n*=]klkn`aranqi]ibfjlo^il]n]k]cajpa* =oacqj`]itei]]Úni]]afdkfa^abalppbobperj^klp`ljlmbppl^pa(lknp]jpk(] atecj_e]`amqaoaf]ipn]p]`ko_kikÚi`]]kaf]i]eo_kikiaekkq_kikejopnqiaj) pkl]n]jkookoejpanaooao* =pan_aen]itei]]Úni]mqa]rkjp]`amqa]calkn`aranejopepqeqinaejkdqi]jk `aoanaoikn]eolknmqan]_ekj]eoa(lknp]jpk(`kp]`ko`aqi]rkjp]`ahaceoh]`kn]hernakq ]qpjki]*=pan_aen]itei]atlneia]afcbobk ^lrpbm^o^ lbkqoblobfklk^qro^ia^p `^rp^pblobfklerj^klalpÛkp* Keilan]perk_]pac ne_kjkajqj_e]k_kjpa`kl]npe_qh]n`aqi]]k(i]o]bkni] can]h`]o] aoikn]eo*=oitei]o`aet]i_h]n]]ejpaneknev]k`k`aran(lkeoaopaj]o_a `]n]vka`]rkjp]`ahaceoh]`kn]qjerano]h`k]cajpaikn]h*K]_kn`kajpnarkjp]`aa`aran kmqaG]jp`aoecj]_kikslkq^ab_l^nrbnrbol_bj* Kjlqfsljlo^i`]rkjp]`a^k]]cenmloabsbo*Kjsbijlo^i`]rkjp]`a^k]kobp* mbfqlmbilabsbo(lnk`qve`kaij olah]n]vk*K^a`ej_e]haeikn]h(naolaepklahk`arana lahkokqpnko_kjopepqai]^kj`]`a`]rkjp]`ape_]* Keilan]perk_]pac ne_kjkjko`evl]n]oanikodkjaopko(kbana_aj`k)jko]aooj_e] `]dkjaope`]`a7jail]n]oanikofqopko(ran]vao(cajankokokq_kn]fkoko_ki^]oaj]`a) Újek`]aooj_e]`]fqope](`]ran`]`a(`]cajankoe`]`akq`]_kn]cai*Jkjko`evl]n] ln]pe_]nikoaop]kq]mqah]]k`apaniej]`](i]ojko`evl]n]pbojlpqf`lp`rjmofkall absbo$]opnoitei]oikn]eo%*aopamqa`apaniej]lknmqaqi]]kikn]h`aranoan oailnadkjaop](fqop](ran]v(cajanko]kq_kn]fko]*=k]cen(`araikoej`]c]noajkoo]]k aopai_kjbknie`]`a_kikoÚjoikn]eo(eopk(_ki]oitei]o`k`aran* Lknmqa(lknatailhk(iajpeneikn]h;Lknmqakiajpenkokpn]jocne`a]opnoitei]o ikn]eo*=kiajpen(jknaolaep]aioq]laook]aj]`kkqpnk]dqi]je`]`a$_kjo_ej_e]( n]_ekj]he`]`aahe^an`]`a%(ln]pe_]qi]rekhj_e]ao_kj`aj`k`aqikqpnkoandqi]jkqi] ejbkni]kran`]`aen]a(lkniaek`kajc]jk(qo]]^k])b`kkqpnk*P]i^ijknaolaep] ]oacqj`]itei](lkeooa]iajpen]lq`aooaqjerano]hev]n)oa(kcjankdqi]jk`arane] ]^`e_]n`]n]vka`k_kjda_eiajpk(`]naÛatka`]_npe_](`]_]l]_e`]`al]n]`ahe^an]na ao_khdan(reraj`kj]i]eo_kilhap]ecjkn j_e](jkannkaj]ehqok* Lknmqaqilkhpe_k_knnqlpkeikn]h;Lknmqapn]jocne`a]opnoitei]o*Lknmqak dkie_`ekeikn]h;Lknmqapn]jocne`a]opnoitei]o*=onaolkop]o`aNkqooa]qa`aG]jp( ai^kn] `ebanajpao( lnk_qn]i naokhran ] iaoi] `eÚ_qh`]`a( mq]h oaf]( atlhe_]n lkn mqa k `arana]he^an`]`a`]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]hokejoal]nraeoa_kil]praeo*=okhqk`a]i^ko _kjoeopaai_kjoe`an]nk`aran_kik]hckmqaj]o_aaijkookejpanekn(lnklkopklahk_kn]) k$Nkqooa]q%kqlnklkopklah]n]vk$G]jp%(`aob]vaj`k(]ooei(]eilnaook`amqaahajko oane]eilkopk`abkn](lknqi]rkjp]`aaopn]jd]jkoo]*
?qhpqn]a`aran
N /51
kqooa]qaG]jplnk_qn]n]i_kj_ehe]nk`arana]e`ae]`aqi]j]pqnav]dqi]j]mqa lna_eo] oan k^nec]`] ikn]h* Jk ajp]jpk( lk`an]iko nalapen ] lancqjp] mqa Úva) iko]jpao(i]oej`]c]j`k]ckn]6oa]pe_]atecaqioqfaepk_kjo_eajpaa]qpjkik( _kikatlhe_]nmqa]ikn]hatef]k_qilneiajpk`k`aran(`aÚje`k_kikqi_kjfqjpk`a r]hknao(jkni]o(Újoahaeoaop]^aha_e`kolah]_qhpqn];Jkreiko(lknatailhk(]`ebanaj] ajpna]orenpq`ao]lkjp]`]olkn=neop pahaoa]mqah]o`aÚje`]olahk_neope]jeoik;I]ojk
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
o eook*Jklk`aikolan`an`areop]kb]pk`amqaokiajpaai]hcqi]o_qhpqn]omqa] n]vk(]rkjp]`aa]he^an`]`aok_kjoe`an]`]o]^]oa`]ikn]h7amqap]i^iokiajpa ai]hcqi]o_qhpqn]omqa]l]na_a]`eopejkajpnaja_aooe`]`aj]pqn]hahe^an`]`aikn]h* Iaoikmqaoa`ec](_kiG]jp(mqak_kjpa`k`ko]pkoikn]eo$eopk(]orenpq`ao%`alaj`a `a_kj`e aodeop ne_]o(i]omqa]bkni]qjerano]h`k`aran$kqkeilan]perk_]pac ne_k% qjerano]haej`alaj`ajpa`]or]ne] ao_qhpqn]eo(jklk`aikoaomqa_an`amqaokiajpa jqi]_qhpqn]deopkne_]iajpa`apaniej]`](eopk(j]_qhpqn]_neop(mqaoqnca]e`ae]`amqa ]ikn]haophec]`]jkk`a`aran* Aioqi](]mqehkmqafqhc]ikooan]bkni]qjerano]hak_kjpa`kqjerano]h`]ikn]h aop_qhpqn]hiajpa`apaniej]`k*Jaooa_]ok(jkaop]n]iko`arkhp]]klnk^hai]`]atpa) nekne`]`aajpnakoqfaepka]bkni]ak_kjpa`k`k]pkikn]h(qi]ravmqaaopaook`aÚje) `kolah]_qhpqn](eilkj`k)oa`abkn]]koiai^nko`aqi]_qhpqn]`apaniej]`];=naolkop] ]aoo]mqaopkbkepn]ve`](jko_qhkTET(lknDacah*
=lanola_per]dacahe]j] Ikn]haok_ea`]`a Dacah_nepe_]Nkqooa]qaG]jplkn`keoikperko*Ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknpanai`]`ki]eo ]pajknah]kajpnaoqfaepkdqi]jkaj]pqnav]$eopk(nah]kajpnan]vkal]et ao%`k mqanah]kajpnaoqfaepkdqi]jka_qhpqn]kqdeop ne]*Kqoaf](Nkqooa]qlnapaj`e]mqak dkiai(nacnaoo]j`k]qi]nah]k`ad]nikje]_ki]j]pqnav](na_qlan]ooaoq]j]pqnav] knecej]h(^k]a^ajarkhajpa(lan`e`]ok^koabaepko`]re`]ok_e]h^]oa]`]j]n]vkqpehepne]a `koejpanaooao*G]jp(lknoq]rav(lnklo]`eopejkbqj`]iajp]hajpnaknaejkja_aoonek`] j]pqnav]aknaejkdqi]jk`]he^an`]`a(`eopejcqej`kajpnakmqaaij orai`]j]pqnav] $eilqhoko(]lapepao(l]et ao%akmqaaij o`araren`]n]vklnpe_]kq`]he^an`]`a$]ik) n]h_kik_kjbknie`]`aajpnakmqananak`arankqajpna]rkjp]`aa]haeikn]h%* Aioacqj`khqc]n(Dacahko_nepe_]lknpanai]`iepe`k]nah]kajpna]pe_]a]ok_e]^e) he`]`a`kooanaodqi]jko_ki^]oaaih]koiqepkbncaeo(eopk(lknpanai_kj_a^e`k]ok) _e]^ehe`]`a_kiknah] aolaook]eo`enap]oajpnaej`er`qko(mq]j`k`arane]ip)h]pki]`k _ki^]oajkoh]kobknpao`]onah] aook_e]eo(Út]`]olah]oejopepqe aook_e]eo$b]ihe](ok) _ea`]`a_ereh(Aop]`k%*Nkqooa]qaG]jp`aet]n]i`a_kjoe`an]nki]eoeilknp]jpa(eopk(mqa ]onah] aolaook]eoajpnaej`er`qkook`apaniej]`]oaia`e]`]olknoq]onah] aook_e]eo* Okaop]ohpei]o(atlhe_]Dacah(mqa`apaniej]i]re`]pe_]kqikn]h`koej`er`qko* Okiko(`evDacah(oanaodeop ne_koa_qhpqn]eo*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa(]hi`ajkoo]rkjp]`a ej`ere`q]hoq^faper]$mqaNkqooa]q_d]ikq`a`lo^ l(aG]jp`ao^wlmoqf`^%(ateopaqi] kqpn]rkjp]`a(iqepki]eolk`anko](mqa`apaniej]]jkoo]6]slkq^abl_gbqfs^(ejo_nep]j]o ejopepqe aokqj]_qhpqn]*Aoo]rkjp]`ajk]laj]oqi]bkni]`kmqanan(_kikaiG]jp( aoeiqi_kjfqjpk`a_kjpa`ko`apaniej]`ko$Újo(r]hknao(jkni]o`kp]`ko`a_kjpa`ko `apaniej]`ko%* =slkq^abl_gbqfs^qi]rkjp]`aeilaook]h(_khaper](ok_e]h(l^he_]adeopkne_]iajpa `apaniej]`]*Aooamqananeilaook]h(ok_e]hadeop ne_k_ne]]oejopepqe aook_e]eo(lkhpe_]o( naheceko]o(]npope_]oa(_kiah]o(]ikn]he`]`a_kikoeopai]nacqh]`kn`]re`]_khaper]lkn iaek `a jlobp( eopk ( `ko _kopqiao a `ko r]hknao `a qi] ok_ea`]`a( jqi] lk_] `apan) iej]`]*=ikn]he`]`aqi]pkp]he`]`abkni]`]lah]oejopepqe ao$b]ihe](nahecek(]npao( p_je_]o(_ej_e]o(nah] ao`apn]^]hdk(knc]jev]klkhpe_](ap_*%(mqak^a`a_ai(pk`]o(]ko iaoikor]hknaoa]koiaoiko_kopqiao(a`q_]j`kkoej`er`qkol]n]ejpaneknev]nai]rkj) p]`ak^faper]`aoq]ok_ea`]`aa`aoq]_qhpqn]* =re`]pe_]k]_kn`ka]d]nikje]ajpna]rkjp]`aoq^faper]ej`ere`q]ha]rkjp]`a k^faper]_qhpqn]h*Na]hev])oalhaj]iajpamq]j`kejpaneknev]ikojkoo]_qhpqn](`ap]hi]jae) n]mqaln]pe_]ikoaolkjp ja]ahernaiajpaoaqo_kopqiaoar]hknao(oaijahaolajo]niko( oaiko`eo_qpeniko(oai`ahao`qre`]niko(lknmqaok_kikjkoo]ln lne]rkjp]`ako`a) oaf]*Kmqa(ajpk(k`aran;K]_kn`klhajkajpnajkoo]rkjp]`aoq^faper]ej`ere`q]ha] pkp]he`]`ape_]kqikn]he`]`a*
/52
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
?kik_kjoamqj_e](keilan]perk_]pac ne_kjklk`anoanqi]bkni]qjerano]h`ao) lnkre`]`a_kjpa`k`apaniej]`k(_kik]Úni]n]G]jp(i]opan(ai_]`]lk_](ai_]`] ok_ea`]`aal]n]_]`]_qhpqn](_kjpa`ko`apaniej]`ko(rhe`ko]laj]ol]n]]mqah]bkni]) kdeop ne_]a_qhpqn]h*=ooei(_]`]ok_ea`]`a(ai_]`]lk_]`aoq]deop ne](`aÚjakor]hk) naolkoeperkoajac]perko(ko]pkolaniepe`koakolnke^e`kol]n]oaqoiai^nko(k_kjpa`k `ko`aranaoa`keilan]perkikn]h*L]n]qioqfaepk(pboqf`lbifsoboan(lknp]jpk(ln)oa`a ]_kn`k_ki]onacn]oikn]eo`aoq]ok_ea`]`a(ejpaneknev]j`k)]o* Ikn]hadeopne]
*ß&ERREIRAßDAß3ILVA%DITORAß!BRIL
Dacah]Úni]mqalk`aikolan_a^ankqna_kjda_ankikiajpkaimqaqi]ok_ea`]`aa qi]_qhpqn]ajpn]iai`a_hjek(lan`aibkn]l]n]oa_kjoanr]na]^nai)oao_neoaoejpanj]o mqa]jqj_e]ioaqpniejkaoq]l]oo]cai]qi]kqpn]bkni]kok_ek_qhpqn]h*Aooaikiaj) pk]mqahajkmq]hkoiai^nko`]mqah]ok_ea`]`aa`]mqah]_qhpqn]_kjpaop]i]ikn]he`]`a recajpa(_kjpaop]ikor]hknaoa]ojkni]oejopepq`ko(oajpai)oaklneie`koaaoi]c]`kolkn ahaoa]cai`aik`k]pn]jocna`e)hko*K`a_hjek`aqi]ok_ea`]`akq`aqi]_qhpqn]kik) iajpkjkmq]hk]jpeck]_kn`kajpna]orkjp]`aooq^faper]oej`ere`q]eoa]rkjp]`ak^faper] ejopepq_ekj]hnkila)oaejatkn]rahiajpa(]jqj_e]j`kqijkrklank`kdeop ne_k* Ajpnakornekoatailhkokbana_e`kolknDacahl]n]atlhe_ep]n]nqlpqn]ajpna]rkjp]`a pe_]ej`ere`q]ha]rkjp]`aikn]h_khaper]lk`aiko`aop]_]n`keo6]l]oo]cai`]]neopk_n]) _e]`aik_n]_e](j]Cn_e](a]l]oo]cai`]_kiqje`]`aia`ear]hok_ea`]`aik`anj]*
Ar]Sehi]a ?]nhkoV]n](ai_aj] `]la]=jpckj](`a O bk_hao(ai-532*
/53
Dacah]lnaoajp]]_neoape_]cnac]at]iej]j`kqi]pn]c`e](]>kqdlk^(`aO bk_hao* K_kjÛepkoaaop]^aha_aajpna=jpckj](mqanalnaoajp]]]jpec]b]ihe]]neopk_npe_](bqj) `]`]aih]ko`ao]jcqa(ak`enecajpalkhpe_k?nakjpa(mqanalnaoajp]]jkr]mifp`aik) _npe_]*Koeniko`a=jpckj](Apk_haoaLkheje_a(hqp]n]iail]npe`ko_kjpnneko7Lkheje_a( ]_qo]`klkn?nakjpa`apn]eklkhpe_](raj_e`kaiknpkai_ki^]palknApk_hao*?kik pn]e`knlkhpe_k(]hae`]_e`]`ajkhda`k`enaepk]bqjan]haoalqhpqn]*Aeookmqa]pkn) iajp]=jpckj](aj_daj`k)]`a`kn*Lknmq; J]nahecekoe`]`a`]mifp]neopk_npe_](qicqannaenkr]hknkokmqaiknnaai_ki^]paj] Ûkn`]fqrajpq`aaoplnkiape`keiknp]he`]`a*L]n]p)h](lna_eokmqaoaq_knlkiknpk lani]ja]ejrekh]`k$oaiokbnan`acn]`]klkn]jei]eoaejpailneao%(]Úi`amqa`aha j]o]oq]ei]cairer]aejpaen](oq]oki^n](lkeoaop]mqal]oo]nl]n]kkqpnkiqj`ka oaneiknp]h*Knepq]hbja^naheil](lqneÚ_](]`knj]alanbqi]k_knlkiknpkaklnkpaca
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
_ki]oalqhpqn]*Jqi]mifp]neopk_npe_](f]i]eooa_kjpaop]ne]k`enaepk`aLkheje_a]kone) pkobja^naoaoalqhpqn]*I]oat]p]iajpaeookmqa]hae`]jkr]mifpkq`]_e`]`a`aik) _npe_]jklk`a_kj_a`an]Lkheje_a*K]iknbn]panjkhar]n=jpckj]]ajbnajp]n?nakjpa( na]hev]j`kkonepkobja^naoaajpann]j`kkenik*=kb]v)hk(_kj`aj])oap]i^iiknpa* Aoo]pn]c`e]j]nn]ko_kjÛepkoajpna^pibfpklbp`ofq^pal`lpqrjb$kl]oo]`k]neopk) _npe_k(haceoh]`klahko`aqoao_kiklnkpapknao`]ohejd]cajo`ao]jcqakq`]ob]ihe]oa oaqocqannaenko%a^pibfpbp`ofq^pa^`fa^ab$klnaoajpa`aik_npe_k(haceoh]`klahkodkiajo( `aÚje`ko_kik_e`]`ko(ajklahkoh]ko`ao]jcqakqlah]ohejd]cajob]iehe]nao%*Kb]pk `a mqa =jpckj]( l]n] `abaj`an ] b]ihe]( ]o _naj]o naheceko]o a ko r]hknao ]neopk_npe_ko( pajd]`a_kjbnkjp]n)oa_ki?nakjpa(mqanalnaoajp]]mifp`aik_npe_]akor]hknao`aik) _npe_ko(ej`e_]]_neoape_](kqoaf](mqa`ao]l]na_aq]]jpec]ikn]he`]`a]neopk_npe_]kq] d]nikje]]neopk_npe_]ajpna]rkjp]`aej`ere`q]hoq^faper]a]rkjp]`ak^faper]ejopepq_ek) j]h(amqaoqnceqqi]jkr]ikn]he`]`a(]d]nikje]`aik_npe_]ajpna]rkjp]`aej`ere`q]h oq^faper]a]rkjp]`ak^faper]ejopepq_ekj]h* = _neoa pe_] mqa ]_kil]jd] ] l]oo]cai `] ikn]he`]`a _kiqjepne] ia`ear]h l]n] ]`]ok_ea`]`aik`anj]k_knnaai`keoikiajpkooq_aooerko*Klneiaenknalnaoajp]`k lah]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa7koacqj`k(lahkoqnceiajpk`]e`ae]`a_kjpn]pkok_e]h* =_kiqje`]`aia`ear]han]_kj_a^e`]_kik]bkni]j]pqn]h`anah]kajpnakodqi]) jko(ejopepq`]lkn@aqoa_kjbkniadean]nmqe]`aoanaomqaknc]jev]r]kpk`k`]j]pqnav]* Jah](_]`]ej`er`qkan]`aÚje`kjklknoq]omq]he`]`aoln lne]okqlaook]eo(i]ooacqj) `kkhqc]na]bqjkmqak_ql]r]jqi]dean]nmqe]`alkopko(_]nckoakb_eko(mqae]i`ko i]eoahar]`ko$l]l]aeilan]`kn%]pkoi]eodqieh`ao$kooanrko`]cha^]akoao_n]rko%*K hqc]na]bqjkan]idana`epneko(eopk(`apaniej]r]i]lkoeka]k_ql]k`]ob]ihe]o( l]oo]j`k`al]eol]n]Úhdko(`ap]hi]jaen]mqa_]`]qi(]kj]o_an(fpejd]lna`apaniej]`] oq]re`]aoaqbqpqnk* =hi`]dean]nmqe]a`k_]npandana`epnek`]ok_ql] ao(aop]oaop]r]iknc]jev]`]o _kiqjep]ne]iajpaai`q]obkni]olnej_el]eo6]_]r]h]ne](l]n]kojk^nao(a]o_knlkn] ao `a kb_eko( l]n] ko dkiajo hernao jk jk^nao* = _]r]h]ne] lkooq] r]hknao pe_ko ln lneko $_kikoar(lknatailhk(j]odeop ne]o`kNae=npqn%(`aop]_]j`k)oa]^n]rqn]j]cqann]a] `abao]`k_neope]jeoik_kjpn]koejÚeo$_kikoarj]o?nqv]`]o%*=o_knlkn] ao`akb_eko p]i^ilkooq]ioaqor]hknaoln lneko(mqa`ebane]i`a_knlkn]kl]n]_knlkn]k*P]j) pk]_]r]h]ne]_kik]o_knlkn] aooacqe]r]ilah]orenpq`ao_neopoa_kj`aj]r]ikooapa la_]`ko_]lep]eo* Jk pklk `] dean]nmqe] aj_kjpn]r])oa ] Ecnaf] ?]p he_] Nki]j]( `alkoepne] a cq]n`e `]oran`]`ao`erej]o*Lkneook(k_kjpnkhalkhpe_k(aolenepq]haikn]h`]o_kiqje`]`aoa`ko naejko an] baepk lah] ]qpkne`]`a `ko a_haoeope_ko( `a i]jaen] mqa k ]ola_pk ejpanekn a ao) lenepq]hev]`k`]re`]pe_](mqa_]n]_panev]n]k_neope]jeoikaioaqo_kiako(bke(lkq_k] lkq_k(_a`aj`khqc]n]qi]ikn]h`]atpanekne`]`a(lkniaek`]mq]hkoiai^nko`]Ecnaf] lk`e]i_kjpnkh]n]re`]`koÚeo*Aoo]ikn]han]_d]i]`]lahko_neopko`ajlo^ia^pl_o^p* =oÎk^n]oÏan]i]o] aoatpanj]olah]omq]eo]hcqi`aikjopn]r]oanqi_neopk_kik(lkn atailhk(]k^nec]pknea`]`a`koo]_n]iajpko$_kikk^]peoikak_]o]iajpk%(]_kiqjdk jk`kiejck`aLo_k](]olanacnej] ao]hqc]naoo]jpko(]atpnai])qjkj]dkn]`]ikn) pa(]oaoikh]ol]n]ko nbkoalk^nao(kl]c]iajpk`a`veikol]n]]Ecnaf](]_aha^n]k `koo]jpkoai`e]oaola_e]eo(ap_*Aioqi](oanqi^ki_neopkkqqi_neopkrenpqkokan] _qilnenrnekonepq]eoatpanjko* =Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa]^na]_neoa`aoo]ikn]he`]`alknmqalnkl anaop]qn]n]ikn]h _neop`]ejpanekne`]`aa`]aolenepq]he`]`aa_ki^]pan]]qpkne`]`aa_haoeope_]`kl]l]`k aoaqonalnaoajp]jpao*?ki^]paj`k]Îikn]h`]ok^n]oÏ(]Nabkni]l]oo]]s^ilofw^o^`lkp* `fk`f^ fkafsfar^i( iqepk i]eo `k mqa ko nepq]eo a_haoeope_ko* L]oo] ] r]hknev]n ] lea`]`a( ]^kj`]`aejpanekn(]b(]_]ne`]`a(kq]ikn]h`k_kn]k*?ki]`aor]hknev]k`]ikn]h nepq]hev]`]kqatpanj]a]r]hknev]k`]_kjo_ej_e]ej`ere`q]ha]ejpanekne`]`a`]oejpaj) ao(]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa`annq^]kleh]na_haoeope_k`]ikn]he`]`aia`ear]h*
/54
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
"ETTMANN#ORBIS
Koacqj`kleh]n`aoo]ikn]he`]`aÍk_]npan`erejkaj]pqn]h`]_kiqje`]`a_kik dean]nmqe]dana`epne]`alkopko(_]nckoabqj aoÍajpn]ai_neoa_kikoqnceiajpk`] ok_ea`]`aik`anj](eopk(_ki]e`ae]`amqa]knecai`]ok_ea`]`aoaaj_kjpn]klpfkaf* sarlp( _kj_a^e`ko _kik ej`alaj`ajpao( eokh]`ko( _qfk r]hkn jk `a_knna `a oaq hqc]n j] dean]nmqe]`a_]nckoabqj aoaoei`alaj`a`aoq]omq]he`]`aoa_]n]_panope_]olaook]eoa ok^napq`k`aoanai`kp]`ko`an]vka`arkjp]`ahernal]n]fqhc]na]cen*K_kjpn]lkjpkaj) pna]]jpec]e`ae]`a_kiqje`]`aa]jkr]e`ae]`aej`er`qkn]_ekj]hhernahar]e`ae]`amqa ]ok_ea`]`aejopepq`]lknqi`lkqo^ql$k_kjpn]pkok_e]h%lahkmq]hkoej`er`qko`a_e`ai reranai_kjfqjpkaok^]oiaoi]ohaeo*Lknmqakoej`er`qko_kjpn]p]iajpnaoe;Lknmqa ]n]vkhdaoikopn]mqai]eopeha`aoaqejpanaooaqjenbkn]oana_qnoko(airav`areran jkeokh]iajpk*Alk`ai_kjpn]p]nlknmqaok`kp]`ko`arkjp]`aherna(jkaop]j`koq^ia) pe`ko]kolk`anao`]j]pqnav](`]_kiqje`]`aa`]Ecnaf]*=ooei(_ki]oe`ae]o`afkafsarl o^`flk^iifsoba`a`lkqo^qlpl`f^ioqncaqi]jkr]ikn]he`]`a_qfkbqj`]iajpkaj_kjpn])oa at]p]iajpajaoo]Úcqn]`kej`er`qk_kikn]vkarkjp]`a* `aoo]Úcqn]`kej`er`qkik`anjk(`evDacah(mqal]npaiNkqooa]qaG]jp*Eookoec) jeÚ_](aipanikodacahe]jko(mqa]i^koei]cej]iaop]n_kj_a^aj`kqi]pe_]qjerano]h aejpailkn]hlknmqajklan_a^aimqakoqfaepkikn]h`amqab]h]ijkkdkiai_kik qioanqjerano]haejpailkn]h(aoeikej`er`qkp]h_kik]_]^]`aoanlnk`qve`klah]_qh) pqn]alah]deop ne]aqnklae]oik`anj]o*
=lanola_per]`a>ancokj
(ENRIß"ERGSONßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEßß DIPLOMATAßFRANCoS
Jqi]lanola_per]mqap]i^ilnk_qn]_kilnaaj`an]nah]kajpnaabsboa`riqro^kq ajpnaabsboaefpqof^a(lknp]jpk(]oiq`]j]oj]obkni]oajko_kjpa`ko`]ikn]he`]`a( oqnca(jkej_ek`ko_qhkTT(]k^n]`kÚh okbkbn]j_oDajne>ancokj*L]n]p]jpk(>ancokj `eopejcqa`q]oikn]eo6]jlo^icb`e^a^a]jlo^i^_boq^* =ikn]hba_d]`]k]_kn`kajpnakor]hknaoako_kopqiao`aqi]ok_ea`]`aakooajpe) iajpkoa]o] ao`koej`er`qkomqajah]rerai*]ikn]hnalapeper](d]^epq]h(naolaep]`] mq]oa]qpki]pe_]iajpalknj o* Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](]ikn]h]^anp]qi]`of^ l`ajkrkor]hknaoajkr]o_kj`qp]o(mqa nkilai]ikn]hba_d]`](ejop]qn]j`kqi]pe_]jkr]*Ko_ne]`knaope_kook(l]n]>ancokj( ej`er`qkoat_al_ekj]eoÍdan eo(o]jpko(lnkbap]o(]npeop]oÍ(mqa_khk_]ioq]ore`]o]oan) rek`aqipailkjkrk(ej]qcqn]`klknahao(cn]]o]] aoatailh]nao(mqa_kjpn]ne]i] ikn]hba_d]`]recajpa* Dacah`ene]mqa]ikn]h]^anp]^ancokje]j]o lk`a]_kjpa_anmq]j`k]ikn]he`]`are) cajpaaopai_neoa(lnaopao]paniej]n(lknmqaqijkrklank`kdeop ne_k)_qhpqn]haopl]n] _kia]n*=ikn]hba_d]`](mq]j`koajpe`]_kiknalnaookn]aklnaookn](a]pkp]he`]`ape_]( mq]j`klan_a^e`]_kik_kjpnne]oq^fapere`]`aej`ere`q]h(ej`e_]i]mqahaikiajpkai mqa]ojkni]oakor]hknaoikn]eookatlaneiajp]`ko_kikrekhj_e]$eopk(_kikeilkoek atpanj]a]qpknepne]%ajki]eo_kikna]hev]kpe_](eopk(_kikatlnaoo ao`]he^an`]`a*
Deopne]arenpq`ao
R
eaikok^oanr]j`kmqakor]hknaoikn]eoik`eÚ_]i)oaj]deop ne]lknmqaoaq_kj) pa`kabqbojfk^allkn_kj`e aodeop ne_]o*Lq`aiko_kilnkr]n]`apaniej]k deop ne_]`k_kjpa`k`kor]hknao(at]iej]j`k]orenpq`ao`aÚje`]oai`ebanajpao lk_]o( _kik oa r( lkn atailhk( j] `ebanaj] ajpna k mq]`nk ]neopkphe_k a k _neopk `]o renpq`aokqj]o_neoaope_]o]ooej]h]`]olknDacah*
?kil]n]j`k=neoppahaoa_neope]jeoik
/55
Mq]j`kat]iej]iko]orenpq`ao`aÚje`]olahk_neope]jeoik(`ao_k^neikomqa(ai^kn] ]orenpq`ao]neopkphe_]ojkoaf]i]b]op]`]o(`aet]i`aoan]oi]eonahar]jpao*K^oanr]iko(
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
]ooei(k]l]na_eiajpk`arenpq`aojkr]o(_kj_anjajpaonah]k`k_najpa_ki@aqo$renpq) `aopakhkc]eo%(lkoek`]fqope]a`]lnq`j_e]_kikrenpq`aol]npe_qh]nao$renpq`aomqa( l]n]=neop pahao(jkan]il]npe_qh]nao(lkeo]fqope]knaoqhp]`k`]renpq`aajkqi]`]o renpq`ao(a]lnq`j_e]]_kj`ek`apk`]o]orenpq`ao%(oq^opepqek`]]iev]`alah]_]) ne`]`a$ajpaj`e`]_kik]ikn]kln teikaaooa]ikn_kiknaolkjo]^ehe`]`alah]o]hr]k `kkqpnk%*Lk`aikop]i^ik^oanr]nmqakmqa=neop pahao_d]i]r]`as`flpn]jobkni]`k aimb`^al(lknp]jpk(ai]hckrkhp]`kl]n]]nah]k`k_najpa_ki]hae`erej]*Mq]jpkoren) pq`aoikn]eo(aj_kjpn]ikoajpnaah]oqi]mqa(l]n]=neop pahao(an]qir_ekÍ]ik`ope] Í(]hi`araneÚ_]nikok]l]na_eiajpk`arenpq`aoecjkn]`]okq`ao_kjda_e`]olkn=neop ) pahao(_kik]dqieh`]`aa]_]ope`]`a* ?kik_neope]jeoik(oqncap]i^i_kikrenpq`a]hckmqa(l]n]qicnackkqqinki]) jk(f]i]eolk`ane]b]vanl]npa`kor]hknao`kdkiaiherna6kpn]^]hdk*Ai_kjpn]l]npe`]a _kik_kjoamqj_e](k _ek(r]hknev]`klahko]jpeckoa_kjoe`an]`klah]ok_ea`]`aao_n]reop] cna_k)nki]j]_kik_kj`ekl]n]katan__ek`]ÚhkokÚ]a`]lkhpe_](pknj])oa(]l]npen`a ajpk(kr_ek`]lnacqe]*
=ilhe]j`k]_kil]n]k6]pe_]`aAolejko] Oa(]ckn](pki]niko_kiknabanj_e]qiÚh okbk`ko_qhkTREE(Aolejko](_qf]k^n]lnej) _el]hejpepqh])oaqf`^(ranaikokmq]`nk`]orenpq`aoa`kor_eko]hpan]n)oalnkbqj`]iajpa* =j]pqn]he`]`a`]ol]et ao L]n]Aolejko](okikooanaoj]pqn]hiajpa]baperko(eopk(jkook_knlkejejpannqlp]) iajpa]bap]`klknkqpnko_knlko$mqalk`ai_kjoanr)hkanacajan)hkkqajbn]mqa_)hka `aopnq)hk%a]bap]kqpnko_knlko$p]i^ilk`aj`k_kjoanr)hko(nacajan)hko(ajbn]mqa_) )hkokq`aopnq)hko%aaoo]o]ba_ ao_knlkn]eooaatlneiaiaijkoo]]hi]j]bkni]`a]ba) pko kq oajpeiajpko* Kq oaf]( k mqa oa l]oo] ai jkook _knlk loemqe_]iajpa rere`k lkn j ook^]bkni]]baper]*=ooei(lknatailhk(mq]j`k]hcqi]_keo]]qiajp]]_]l]_e`]`a rep]h`ajkook_knlk(atlaneiajp]iko]iknlknah]7a(]k_kjpnnek(mq]j`k]hcqi]_keo] ajbn]mqa_ap]h_]l]_e`]`a(atlaneiajp]iko `eklknah]*K]bapkkqoajpeiajpk(lknp]jpk( _kjopepqperk`]nah]k`ajkoo]]hi]_kijkook_knlk* Jkooko]bapko(atlhe_]Aolejko](lk`aioanm^fubpkq^ bp*Okl]et aomq]j`k_]q) o]`kolknbkn]okq_keo]oatpanj]o7ok] aomq]j`k_]qo]`kolknjkoo]bkn]ejpanj]* =ol]et aookj]pqn]eo*Lknmq;Lknmqaokiko_ne]pqn]omqareraink`a]`]olknej) ian]okqpn]oaokiko]bap]`kolknah]o`aejian]oi]jaen]o(kqoaf](okikoj]pqn]hiajpa l]ooekj]eolknmqaokikoj]pqn]hiajpal]ooerko(eopk(ej_aoo]jpaiajpaokbnaiko]]k `a _]qo]o atpaneknao ] j o* =ooei( lkn j]pqnav]( reraiko _an_]`ko lkn kqpnko oanao( i]eo bknpao`kmqaj o(mqa]caiok^naj oalkneook(`evAolejko](]l]ooere`]`akq]ol]et ao jkok^k]ojaiio(oeilhaoiajpaokj]pqn]eo*Jkokr_eko`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]jai oej]eo`aqi]rkjp]`abn]_]kqlanranpe`]aoei]i]jaen]_kikj]pqn]hiajpaateopeiko na_a^aj`kaokbnaj`k]]k`a_]qo]oatpanj]o*Qi]l]etkej`e_]]bkn]kq]bn]mqav]`a jkookoan$jkook_knlkajkoo]]hi]%l]n]ateopena]cen* Pnook]ol]et aoknecej]eokqlneieper]o6^ibdof^(qofpqbw^aabpbgl*=o`ai]eo`ane) r]i)oa`aop]o*=ooei(`]l]etk`a]hacne]j]o_ai]o`a^jlo(absl l(bpmbo^k ^(pbdro^k ^( `lkqbkq^jbkql(jfpbof`oaf^(diof^7`]l]etk`apneopav]oqncai]o`aafl(fksbg^(lodriel( ^oobmbkafjbkql(jlapqf^(erjfia^ab(jbal(abpbpmbol7`]l]etk`k`aoafk(_kjbkniaaopa oa_ki^eja_ki]]hacne]kq_ki]pneopav](lnkri]do^qfal(]diof^(]_bkbslik`f^(] `ibo^(]`orbia^ab(]sfkd^k ^(]^j_f l(kqbjlo(]lrp^af^(]iru of^(]^s^obw^* Qi] l]etk pneopa ]mqah] mqa atlaneiajp]iko mq]j`k oajpeiko ] `eiejqek `] _]l]_e`]`a `a oan a ]cen `a jkook _knlk a `a jkoo] ]hi] Í lkn pneopav] mqa k`e]iko k mqafqhc]ikomqajkoajbn]mqa_a(]ooei_kiklknpneopav]mqaoajpeikol]et ao_kikk ia`kak`aoaolank(mqajkohar]i]bqcen`]o_keo]oa`kokqpnkokq]mqanan`aopnq)hko*=k
0,,
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
_kjpnnek(qi]l]etk]hacnaatlaneiajp]`]mq]j`koajpeikok]qiajpk`]_]l]_e`]`a `aateopena]cen`ajkook_knlka`ajkoo]]hi]Ílkn]hacne]mqa]i]ikokmqafqhc]iko mqajkobknp]ha_a(]ooei_kiklkn]hacne]mqaoajpeiko]iev]`aacajankoe`]`alkn]mqa) haomqa]qiajp]ijkoo]bkn]rep]h*Jk_]ok`k`aoafk(lk`aikopanl]et aopneopao$_kik] _nqah`]`a(]]i^ek(]]r]nav]%kq]hacnao$_kik]cn]pe`ka]^ajarkhj_e]%a(lknp]jpk(k `aoafklk`aatlneien]`eiejqekkqk]qiajpk`ajkoo]bkn]l]n]ateopen* =oanre`kl]ooekj]ha]he^an`]`a]baper] Mqakr_ek;Jkpanl]et ao*]bn]mqav]l]n]ateopen(]cenalajo]n*`aet]n)oahar]n ]laj]olkn]bapkol]ooerkokql]et ao(oq^iapaj`k)oa]ahao(lkeo_kieookjko`aet]iko ckranj]nlah]o_]qo]oatpanj]o$_keo]oakqpnkodqi]jko%(mqal]oo]i]panlk`anok^naj o* ?kik oq_qi^eiko ]k lk`anek `a bkn]o atpanj]o; @aet]j`k)jko `kiej]n lah]o l]et ao pneopao a lah]o `aoaf]jpao j]o_e`]o `] pneopav]* Lkn eook( ai rav `a r_ek( Aolejko] b]h] ai Îoanre`kdqi]j]Ï*@ab]pk(okikooanrkomq]j`kjkoo]ol]et ao`apaniej]ijkoo]re`]a( lknp]jpk(mq]j`kjkokikohernao(i]oreraikook^klk`anatpanjk`]o_keo]oa`akqpnko( mqajko]nn]op]il]n]kj`amqanai*Kn](mq]jpki]eobn]_kookiko(i]eol]ooerkookikoa p]jpki]eobn]_komq]jpki]eol]et aopneopaoa`aoafkopneopaojko`kiejai* Mqa]renpq`a;Jk_qilnen`aranaoak^nec] ao(i]ooan]_]qo]ejpanj]`ajkooko oajpeiajpko(]pkoalajo]iajpko*Kqoaf](oanhernapanbkn]ejpaneknl]n]l]oo]n`]l]ooere) `]`a]baper]$oq^ieook]_]qo]oatpanj]o%]pere`]`a]baper]$oan_]qo]ejpanj]`ko]bapko(`ko lajo]iajpkoa`]o_kj`qp]o%*Pb^pbosfalm^ful)^sfoqrab^ l+Oanrenpqkokkqoanherna (lkeo(l]oo]n`]l]etk]k(pknj]n)oa_]qo]]per]ejpanj]`ajkooko]bapkoalajo]iajpko* L]oo]n`]oanre`khe^an`]`a ?kikl]oo]n`]l]etk]k;=^]j`kj]j`kkooajpeiajpko(ko]bapko(]oaik ao;@a i]jaen]jajdqi]*Okikooanaoj]pqn]hiajpa]baperkoa`aet]n`aatlaneiajp]n]bapkokq oajpeiajpkooeilhaoiajpa`aet]n`aoandqi]jk* =l]oo]caioa`jkejpanekn`]ol]et aoacn]]o]ah]o*@ab]pk(]ol]et aoako`aoafko pneopaojkoajbn]mqa_aiajkopknj]i_]`]ravi]eol]ooerkoajmq]jpk]ol]et aoako`a) oafko]hacnaojkobknp]ha_ai*=re`]pe_]oaeje_e]mq]j`klnk_qn]iko]qiajp]nl]et aoa `aoafko]hacnaoa]b]op]nl]et aoa`aoafkopneopao(lkeo(ia`e`]mqa]ol]et ao`a]hacne]a `a`aoafk]hacnajkobknp]ha_ai(r]iko]`mqenej`klk`anok^naj oiaoikoa`eiejqej`k klk`anek`]obkn]oatpanj]o*Mq]j`kjkoo]n]vkoapknj]_]l]v`aoanrere`]lknj o]bape) r]iajpa(eopk(mq]j`katlaneiajp]ikomqa`lkeb`boi]eobknpa`kmqafdklo^oamqak _kjda_eiajpk]bkn]ln lne]`ajkoo]]hi](jkoo]]pere`]`an]_ekj]hoapknj]]hacne]*Kn]( ]]pere`]`an]_ekj]hjk`alaj`a`a_]qo]oatpanj]o(i]oat_hqoer]iajpa`]bkn]ejpanj] `ajkoo]n]vk*=ooeioaj`k(qi]n]vkbknpa]hacnaaqi]n]vk]hacnabknpa6_kiah]oa eje_e]]l]oo]cai]baper]a_kcjeper]mqajkohar]`]l]etk]k(`]oanre`krenpq`a* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(l]oo]iko`]l]etk]k(`]oanre`khe^an`]`apn]jobkni]j`k]o l]et ao]hacnaoa]o`aoaf]jpaoj]o_e`]o`]]hacne]ai]pere`]`ao`amqaokiko]_]qo]*= renpq`a]bkn]l]n]oana]cen]qpkjki]iajpa(eopk(_kihe^an`]`a* >kiai]q
0,-
K_lj(atlhe_]Aolejko](]mqehkmqapehl]n]k_nao_eiajpk`ajkookoan7kj^r(k mqajkoeila`a`a]h_]j]n]hck^kil]n]jkoo]ateopj_e]*Oaf]j]ol]et ao(oaf]j]o] ao( pk`koj ooailna^qo_]ikok_lj* qfi$iaoikmqajkoajc]jaiko]oaqnaolaepk%ajko aobkn]ikol]n]]b]op]nkmqafqhc]ikoj^r*kl`fsll]n]jkoo]ateopj_e]* Kn](atlhe_]Aolejko](reraikoj]_kil]jde]`kokqpnkooanaodqi]jkoaokikopk`ko ikre`kolknl]et ao*Aop]olk`aipknj]n)jko_kjpnnekoqjo]kokqpnkoaejeieckoqjo`ko kqpnko(`ap]hi]jaen]mqa_]`]qilk`apknj]n)oaqik^op_qhkl]n]mqakokqpnko_kjoe) c]ik^ki)pehmqa`aoaf]i*Lknaooaikperk(]ol]et aoako`aoafko]hacnao$_kikk]ikn(
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
] ^ajarkhj_e]( k _kjpajp]iajpk( ] cn]pe`k( ] aolan]j]( ] oacqn]j]% lk`ai _ne]n h]ko `a_kj_kn` j_e]ajpnakodkiajo(ajmq]jpk]ol]et aoako`aoafkopneopao$_kikk `ek(k ia`k(]ejraf](kkncqhdk(k`aoaolank(]rejc]j]%oailnakopknj]iejeiecko* Pk`]re](qi]l]etkoailnaejoprah(lkeojah]jkookoajpeiajpk`alaj`a`a_]q) o]oatpanj]oa`a_en_qjop j_e]omqajk`alaj`ai`aj o*Lknaooaikperk(l]et aoa`a) oafko]hacnaolk`aiiq`]napknj]nai)oapneopao(ajbn]mqa_an)jkoajkopknj]nejeiecko qjo`kokqpnko* L]n]naokhranaoo]`eÚ_qh`]`a(Aolejko]lnkl a`q]ookhq ao6`aqih]`k(qi]ok_ea`]) `alkhpe_]_qf]oejopepqe aob]rkna]i]`eiejqek`]obkni]o`arekhj_e]abknp]ha]i koh]ko`a]iev]`a(cn]pe`ka^ajarkhj_e]ajpnakodkiajo(aop]^ehev]j`koq]ol]et aoa oaqo`aoafko]hacnao7aoo]ok_ea`]`a(l]n]Aolejko](]ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]*@akqpnk(] re`]pe_]_kik]krenpqko]*MqaoecjeÚ_]eook; =renpq`a(`evAolejko](jkoajk]na]hev]k`ajkoo]_]l]_e`]`a_kcjeper]kqn]) _ekj]h$kq(_kikatlhe_]aha(]renpq`a`]]hi]`lkeb`bo%(a(lkneook(jah]jqj_]jkoajc]) j]ikomq]jpk]kmqa^ki)pehl]n]jkookoan(jah]qi]bapk`a]hacne]aqi`aoafk]hacna jqj_]oapn]jobkni]iai]bapkoa`aoafkopneopao*=ooeioaj`k(komqa]cailknrenpq`ajk okikre`kolahk `ek(lahkia`k(lah]ejraf](lahkkncqhdkakqpn]ol]et ao_ne]`kn]o`a ejeiev]`aa`eo_ n`e]*?kjoamqajpaiajpa(]renpq`ab]rkna_aa_kjoanr]]_kj_ n`e]]baper] a_kcjeper]ajpnakodkiajo* =ooei_kik]lkhpe_]`aik_npe_]aop]^ehev]l]et aoa`aoafko]hacnao(lnkikraj`k] _kj_ n`e]ok_e]h(]ooeip]i^i]re`]pe_]lnkikra]_kj_ n`e]a]iev]`aajpnakoej`e) r`qko*J]lkhpe_]`aik_npe_](]^]oa`]_kj_kn` j_e]aj_kjpn])oajkb]pk`amqakmqa ^ki)pehl]n]]ok_ea`]`ap]i^ikl]n]oaqoiai^nko7j]pe_](aoo]^]oa`]`]lahk b]pk`amqakmqa^ki)pehl]n]qiej`er`qkjkk^op_qhkl]n]k^aia]qpehe`]`a`ko kqpnko(i]ob]rkna_a]renpq`a`ko`ai]eo*
K^oanr]ikomqa]pe_]aolejko]j]arep]kbana_anqimq]`nk`arenpq`aoar_eko(`eo) p]j_e]j`k)oa `a =neop pahao a `] ikn]h _neop( l]n] ^qo_]n j] e`ae] ik`anj] `a ej`er`qk hernakj_hak`]]kikn]h*J]qf`^(Aolejko]f]i]eob]h]aimb`^alaaiabsbo7b]h]ai co^nrbw^aaiclo ^l]n]oan(lajo]na]cen* =orenpq`ao]neopkphe_]oejoanai)oajqi]ok_ea`]`amqar]hknev]r]]onah] aook_ek) lkhpe_]oajpnakooanaodqi]jko(`kj`a]lnaaiejj_e]`]lnq`j_e](`]]iev]`aa`]fqo) pe]*=orenpq`ao_neopo(lknoq]rav(atlneiaie`ae]o(_kopqiaoar]hknao`aqi]ok_ea`]`a rkhp]`]l]n]]nah]k`kodqi]jko_ki@aqoa]hae`erej]*=renpq`aaolejko]j]pki]] nah]k`kej`er`qk_ki]j]pqnav]a]ok_ea`]`a_ajpn]j`k)oaj]oe`ae]o`aejpacne`]`a ej`ere`q]ha`abkn]ejpanj]l]n]nah]_ekj]n)oahernaiajpa_ki]i^]o* Qilajo]`kn_kjpailkn jak(=h]o`]enI]_Ejpuna(jqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]Abmlfpa^sfo* qrab(lnk_qn]na`aÚjen]e`ae]`asfoqrabj]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja](j]mq]h]lhqn]he`]) `aa`eranoeÚ_]k`aejopepqe aook_e]eoeil ail]n]qiiaoikej`er`qkqi]cn]j`a r]nea`]`a`a_kj`qp]oa_kilknp]iajpko`ebanajpaoÍdjkni]oar]hknaoj]b]ihe](j] ao_kh](jko`ebanajpaopelko`alnkÚoo aoa`apn]^]hdko(j]o`ebanajpaobkni]olkhpe_]o(ap_* Ej`]c]I]_Ejpuna6lkoorahb]h]nairenpq`ajkoejcqh]nÍ^sfoqrabÍkqoanlna_eok_kj) oe`an]nmqaai_]`]aoban]`]ateopj_e]dqipelk`apaniej]`k`arenpq`aaailnac]nk lhqn]hÍ^psfoqrabp;I]o(oaf]jkoejcqh]n(oaf]jklhqn]h(b]h]nairenpq`aeilhe_]qi]e`ae] can]h`arenpq`aa_]^aej`]c]n6_kikaj_kjpn]nqi]e`ae]`arenpq`amqalkoo]`]n_kjp]`] iqhpelhe_e`]`a`a_kj`qp]oa`aik`ko`are`]; I]_ Ejpuna( ejolen]j`k)oa ai =neop pahao( _kj_a^a ] renpq`a _kik moufp( lknp]jpk( _kik]mqah]]kkq_kj`qp]j]mq]hk]cajpa(k]pka]Új]he`]`aokejoal]nraeoaiao) ike`jpe_ko*Lkneook(]_kj_a^a_kikqi]mq]he`]`adqi]j]]`mqene`]mqa(aimq]hmqan aoban]`are`]a]pere`]`a(jkopknj]_]l]vao`a]h_]j]nqi^aiejpanjkln lne]lnpe_] kqln lne]_kj`qp](eopk(ejoal]nrah`]]kmqak^qo_]akna]hev]*
3TEVEß0YKE#ONTRIBUTORß 'ETTYß)MAGES
Qi]_kj_alk_kjpailkn ja]`]renpq`a
!LASDAIRß-ACß)NTYREß ß FILvSOFOßBRIThNICO
0,.
-ICHAELß!PPLETON4HEß.EWß9ORKß4IMES,ATINSTOCK
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
O]_]o`a]nnkvok `ao_]nnac]`]oai LknpkLnj_ela(jk D]epe(ai]k`] ]fq`]dqi]jepne]( ]hcqjo`e]o`alkeo `kpannaikpkmqa `aopnqeqkl]oai f]jaenk`a.,-,*
0,/
I]_Ejpunaoalnak_ql]_kikb]pk`amqaok_ea`]`ao_kik]jkoo]okejpanj]iajpa iqepk`ebanaj_e]`]oaioq]oejopepqe aook_e]eo(_]`]qi]`ah]o_kijkni]oanacn]o`a _kj`qp]ln lne]o(`ai]jaen]mqakmqalk`aoanpe_kj]b]ihe]jkkoanj]lnkÚookak mqape_kai]i^]olk`anjko)hkj]lkhpe_](ap_*Lan]jpa]iqhpelhe_e`]`a`a_kj`qp]o a_kilknp]iajpkoatece`kolknjkoo]ook_ea`]`ao(]qje`]`ape_]]h_]j]`]mq]j`kok) iko_]l]vao`a]r]he]nkoihpelhko^ajokqr]hknao`a_]`]aoban]`ajkoo]ateopj_e]hqv `]qje`]`a`ajkoo]re`](eopk(`ajkook`aoafk`aqi]re`]_kanajpa(ejpaen]kqjpacn](`a p]hi]jaen]mqaaooa`aoafk`a_kanj_e]`are`]a`aejpaenav]`a_]npankneajp]_]`]qi] `ajkoo]o_kj`qp]oa_]`]qi`ajkooko_kilknp]iajpko* ?kikatlhe_]I]_Ejpuna(]qje`]`ape_]`ajkoo]re`]_kik]qje`]`a`aqi]j]n) n]per](_ki_kiak(iaekaÚi(j]mq]hlk`aikoe`ajpeÚ_]nqi]o aiaoi]re`]rere`]kq j]nn]`](qio aiaoikaqkqqio aiaoikoqfaepkjk`a_knnan`kpailkaj]o`ebanaj) pao] ao(_kj`qp]oa_kilknp]iajpko*Lknaooaikperk(]sfoqrab$jkoejcqh]najklhqn]h% ]mqehkmqalnkle_e]]qje`]`a`]j]nn]per]`ajkoo]re`](eopk(kmqa`oajpe`kojkoo]o ^qo_]o(]kojkookoaj_kjpnko(ojkoo]olan`]oabnqopn] ao(laniepej`kk]qiajpk`ajko) ok]qpk_kjda_eiajpka`ajkoo]]qpkjkie]* Kn](]qje`]`a`aqi]re`]kq]j]nn]per]_kjpjq]`aqi]re`]oql amqarer]ikoj] _kil]jde]`kokqpnko(eopk(`ao`akj]o_eiajpk(aop]ikoejoane`kojqi]b]ihe](jqi] _e`]`a(jqil]o(jqi]_h]ooaok_e]h(jqicnqlk(jqi]hjcq](jqi]nahecek(ap_*Aikqpn]o l]h]rn]o(j]o_aiko_kikiai^nko`aqi]pn]`ekmqalkooqejkni]oar]hknao*Aoo]pn]`e) kkpannajkok^nakmq]hoaancqajkoo]re`]pe_]a(lknp]jpk(aop]p]jpklk`ana]hev]n)oa ailhaj]_kjbknie`]`a_kikmqana_a^e`k`aoo]pn]`ek_kik(]k_kjpnnek(lk`ana]he) v]n)oa_kik_npe_]`aoo]iaoi]pn]`ek$_kikikopn]iDacaha>ancokj(lknatailhk%* Mq]j`k]pn]`ek`aÚjarenpq`aomqaeila`ai]koej`er`qko]na]hev]k`]sfoqrab _kik_kanj_e]aqje`]`a`are`]a`a_kj`qp]okqmqaeila`ai]^qo_]`aqibqpqnk jkrk(eopk(`ajkr]olkooe^ehe`]`ao`aateopj_e]ej`ere`q]ha_khaper](aoo]pn]`ekaop iknp]a]re`]pe_]o lk`anna]hev]n)oa_kjpn]ah](ejopepqej`kjkni]o(r]hknao(_kj`qp]oa _kilknp]iajpko_]l]vao`aejopepqenqi]pn]`ekjkr]arer]* Mq]hk_nepnek`]iq`]j]pe_];Naolkj`aI]_Ejpuna6]o^`flk^ifa^ab*Kqoaf](qi] pn]`ek iknna a _ki^]pe`] ape_]iajpa mq]j`k oaqo r]hknao a oq]o jkni]o oa pknj]i enn]_ekj]eol]n]naolkj`an]ko]joaekope_ko`koej`er`qkoa`]_khapere`]`a*Lkneook(ao) _naraI]_Ejpuna(]deop ne]`]ikn]ha`]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]h]deop ne]`aoq_aooerko`ao]Úko
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
]]hcqi]kn`aiikn]hlnaateopajpaalknnabanj_e]]aoo]deop ne]mqa]oqlanekne`]`a n]_ekj]h `a qi] pe_] lk`a oan aop]^aha_e`]* =ooei( ] l]oo]cai `a qi] pn]`ek ikn]h ] qi]pe_]jkr]`a_knna`]enn]_ekj]he`]`a`]lneiaen]lan]jpa]oiq`]j]odeop ne_]oa`] n]_ekj]he`]`a`]oacqj`]l]n]_knnaolkj`an]klnaoajpaa(lknp]jpk(`aoq]_]l]_e`]`al]n] laniepen]_]`]qi]_kanj_e]`are`]a]ejpaenav]`a_]npan*
=hcqjo_kiajpneko =ok^oanr] ao`aI]_Ejpunalk`aioqo_ep]n]hcqi]onaÛat aoejpanaoo]jpaomqajko laniepainapki]nrneko]ola_pko`]pe_]mqareaiko]^kn`]j`k]p]mqe(l]npe_qh]niaj) pa`keo(]o]^an(]e`ae]`amqa`arad]ranlnklknkajpnaiaekoaÚjoikn]eo$eopk(Újo ikn]eoatecaiiaekoikn]eo%a]mqaopk`]lhqn]he`]`a`a_kj`qp]omqajkoo]ok_ea`]`a jkoeil a* -*
O^`flk^ibfoo^`flk^iÍDrne]oi]jaen]o`aajpaj`anaoo]`eopejk*=mqe(oqcaneiko lajo)h]pki]j`k_kiknabanj_e]]e`ae]`ao^qfl(ajpaj`e`]_kiklnklknkajpna `keokqi]eopaniko$_kikreiko]kaopq`]n]n]vk%*ÎLnklknkÏoecjeÚ_]mqadqi] ia`e`]_kiqi]kopanikoamqa(cn]]o]ah](ahaooapknj]idkikcjakokq`aiao) i]j]pqnav](lk`aj`klkneookoannah]_ekj]`ko*
Jaoo]lanola_per](`enaikomqaqi]pe_]n]_ekj]h$kq`kp]`]`ao^qfl%mq]j`kjah] dlnklknkkqdkikcajae`]`aajpnakoiaekoakoÚjo`]]k(aenn]_ekj]hmq]j`kjk ateopaaoo]lnklknk(eopk(iaekoaÚjookdapankcjakokq`aj]pqnav]`ebanajpa*Reopk mqa(`ao`a=neop pahao(]moufplnaooql aaateca]lnklkn_ekj]he`]`a$qi]]kpe_]o ]h_]j]Újope_kooakoiaeko`]]kbknaipe_kop]i^i%(`enaikomqa]enn]_ekj]he`]`a $]qoj_e]`alnklknkkq`adkikcajae`]`aajpnaiaekoaÚjo%eilkooe^ehep]]moufpa] renpq`a(eopk(iaekoeikn]eookdapankcjako]Újoikn]eoaej_]l]vao`ana]hev)hko* @keoatailhkolk`ai]qtehe]n)jkomq]jpk]aoo]mqaopk* Klneiaenk`ahaojko`]`klah]]pepq`a`aiqepkoÚh okbkoai`abao]`]pkhan j_e] naheceko]alkhpe_]ajk_ki^]pa]kooqlh_ekoapknpqn]o`alneoekjaenkonahecekokoalkhpe) _ko*Ej`]c]iko`abajoknao`]pkhan j_e]6kmqaoalnapaj`amq]j`koa]lneoekj]]hcqi lknoq]o_naj]onaheceko]okqlknoq]oe`ae]olkhpe_]o;Anaolkj`ai6lnapaj`a)oak^nec]nk lneoekjaenk]najqj_e]nooq]o_naj]okqooq]oe`ae]o*Ej`]c]ijkr]iajpa6kj`aaopk ]o_naj]oa]oe`ae]o`klneoekjaenk;Naolkj`ai6j]]hi]`k_najpaaj]n]vk`kiehep]jpa lkhpe_k*Jaooa_]ok(enn]_ekj]hkq`aolnklkn_ekj]hoqlhe_e]napknpqn]noaq_knlk(qi]rav mqakmqaoamqan]pejcenoaqaolnepk*Aoo]enn]_ekj]he`]`akq`aolnklknkajpnakoiaeko akoÚjopai`q]o_kjoamqj_e]olkooraeo6kqklneoekjaenk_kjoanr]ejp]_pkoaqaolnepka `aet]oaq_knlklana_anok^]pknpqn](]mq]h(lknp]jpk(jk]h_]j]kÚiaolan]`k(mq]hoaf]( k^pan]najj_e]o_naj]onaheceko]okqoe`ae]olkhpe_]o7kqklneoekjaenkÚjca_kjbaoo]n anajqj_e]nooq]o_naj]oae`ae]o(iajpej`kl]n]ejpannkilan]pknpqn]a(jkr]iajpa(k Úijk]h_]j]`klahkopknpqn]`knaolknmqa(aioaqaolnepk(klneoekjaenkjkoa`k^nkq ]kpknpqn]`kn* Lk`an)oa)e](ajpk(oqlknmqaoane]n]_ekj]hpknpqn]n`enap]iajpakaolnepk`klneoek) jaenk$_kikjkoikopn](lknatailhk(kao_nepknCakncaKnsahh(jknki]j_a.651(mqaiaj) _ekj]ikojk_]lpqhkok^naej`opne]_qhpqn]h%*Kn](naolkj`aiko`abajoknao`]pkhan j_e]( ]mqe]enn]_ekj]he`]`aoane]]ej`]i]ekn*Lknmq;Lknmqakopknpqn]`knao`kaolnepkmqa) naik^pan]]`aokaolenepq]h`klneoekjaenk(eopk(mqanaimqaoq]rkjp]`aaoq]n]vkoa `k^nai(i]o]mqaha_qf]rkjp]`aa_qf]n]vkbkn]i`k^n]`]olah]pknpqn]jk`]`aok slirkqof^ao^`flk^i]kpknpqn]`kn(lkeolan`aqkaolnepk$]rkjp]`aa]n]vk%mq]j`kaopa bkepknpqn]`k* Lkn_kjoacqejpa(pk`]amq]hmqanbkni]`apknpqn]ailnac]`]lknqi]ok_ea`]`a eikn]h lknmqa enn]_ekj]h( lkeo jk _kjoacqa aop]^aha_an qi] nah]k lnklkn_ekj]h kq qi] o^qfl ajpna iaeko $] pknpqn]% a Újo $] ]`aok rkhqjpne] `k pknpqn]`k rkjp]`a `k pknpqn]`kn%*
0,0
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
Koacqj`katailhklk`aren`aqi]oqlkoek*Oqlkjd]ikoqi]ok_ea`]`aaimqa oa]_na`epamqa]_]qo]`]re`]dqi]j]oaf]ko]jcqaamqa]o`ebanaj]oajpnaej`er`qkoa cnqlko`aej`er`qkooaf]i`apaniej]`]olahkoaqpelk`ao]jcqa*Jqi]ok_ea`]`a_kik aoo](lk`aoqncenqicnqlknahecekokmqa_kjoe`anakoaqo]jcqao]cn]`ka]^ajk]`klkn @aqoaaop]^aha]_kikjkni]ikn]h]lnke^ek`]ieopqn]`ko]jcqa`aqi_najpa_kik o]jcqa`kojk_najpao(oal]n]j`kÚeoaejÚeolahko]jcqa*@aoo]lnke^eklk`ai`a_kn) nankqpn]o(_kik(lknatailhk(]`a_]o]iajpko_kijk_najpaokq]pn]jobqok`ao]jcqa l]n]`kajpao* Kn]( ] cajpe_] _kjpailkn ja] `aikjopn] mqa ] _]qo] `] re`] jk k o]jcqa( eopk ( mqa k oqnceiajpk `] re`] `alaj`a `k _kilknp]iajpk `a _anpko _e`ko $_kik k @J= aNJ=%(mqaj]`]pi]ran_kiko]jcqa(`aoknpamqa]olaook]oreraiaoa`ebanaj_e]i qi]o`]okqpn]olkn_kj`e ao^ekh ce_]omqajk`alaj`ai`ko]jcqa*Jaooa_]ok(lnke^en ikn]hiajpaqi]pn]jobqok`ao]jcqa(mqalk`ane]o]hr]nqi]re`](eikn]hlknmqaen) n]_ekj]h(lkeojkdnah]kajpna]mq]he`]`aikn]h`aqi]re`]$oanqi_najpabanrknkok% a]mq]he`]`aboe_k)mqie_]`ko]jcqa7]lnke^ekjkpe_]lknmqaoa^]oae]jqi]`ao) lnklknk(qi]ravmqajkddkikcajae`]`aajpnaoanqi_najpaapanqi`apaniej]`k pelk`ao]jcqa* .*
0,1
Rkfa^ab b `lbok`f^ ab sfa^ b miro^ifa^ab ab `ljmloq^jbkqlp pl`f^fp Î Ok_ea`]`ao ejpanj]iajpaiqepk`ebanaj_e]`]oaioq]oejopepqe ao(_]`]qi]`ah]o_kijkni]o a nacn]o `a _kj`qp] ln lne]o( lk`ai can]n _kjÛepko `a _kj`qp]o `a p]h i]jaen] mqa qi_kilknp]iajpk_kjoe`an]`kpe_kjqi]ejopepqeklk`ane]jkkoanjqi]kqpn]* Aoo]oepq]kjkohar]]ej`]c]nmq]hkoajpe`k`k]l]na_eiajpk(jkohpeikopailko(`a atlnaoo ao_kikÎpe_]`]ailnao]Ï(Îpe_]`]lnkÚookÏ(Îpe_]i`e_]Ï$a`k`ajpeop]( `klnkbaookn(`k]hqjk(`koikpkneop]o(`]o`kj]o`a_]o](ap_*%*=kmqapq`kej`e_](pa) n]iko`a_kjoe`an]njko mqadrne]oaihpelh]oejopepqe aook_e]eoi]op]i^i ihpelh]ope_]oamqaaop]olk`aiaop]nai_kjÛepkkqoan_kjpnne]oqi]ookqpn]o* ?kikoanpe_kÍeopk(panqje`]`aa_kanj_e]`are`]Íaip]eo_en_qjop j_e]o;
Lknatailhk(lk`an]ikooqlknmqa]Îpe_]b]iehe]nÏpane]_kikr]hknk]iknna_lnk) _k(]k^a`ej_e]a]_kjÚ]j](i]omqa]Îpe_]`]ailnao]Ïlk`ane]r]hknev]n]_kilapek( koacna`ka]`ao_kjÚ]j]*@aoo]i]jaen](]re`]renpqko]]lnaj`e`]ai_]o]jkjkolna) l]n]ne]l]n]oanikope_kojqi]ailnao]*Are_a)rano](eopk(qifkraiaqi]fkraimqa pn]^]hd]ooaijqi]ailnao](]koa_]o]naiapanaiÚhdko(jkaop]ne]ilnal]n]`kol]n] ln]pe_]n]pe_]b]iehe]n*=oqlkoek`amqadrne]ope_]omqalk`aioan_kjÛep]jpaoao mq]eo`araiko]`]lp]n)jkohar]]ei]cej]nmqa]pe_]oane]_kikqi_]o]_kmqark_pen]a l a_kjbknia]dkn](khqc]na]pailan]pqn]* Kn](dqiamqrk_k`a^]oajaoo]oqlkoek`aqi]lhqn]he`]`a`ape_]o*@ab]pk(_]`] ejopepqekok_e]ha_]`]lnkÚookaop]^aha_aiqi_kjfqjpk`ajkni]omqaoanabanaijk mq]he`]`aikn]h`ko_kilknp]iajpkoa`]o_kj`qp]o`aoaqoiai^nkoaoeicrk`fl* k^ifa^ababÛ``f^l]n]k`aoailajdk]`amq]`kkqaolan]`k`aqi]]k$ailnao]ne]h( lnkÚooekj]h%*Aoo]ojkni]ojkokpe_]okqikn]eo(i]olod^kfw^`flk^fpa^ajfkfpqo^qfs^p* Lkn_kjoacqejpa(jkdrne]ope_]o* Pk`]re](ai^kn]aioeiaoi]ojkoaf]ipe_]ojaibkniaipe_]ol]npe_qh]nao(lk) `aikoa`araikolancqjp]noaaoo]ojkni]o`abqj_ekj]he`]`aaaÚ__e]`k`aoailajdk aopkkqjk`a]_kn`k_kikor]hknaope_ko`]ok_ea`]`aj]mq]hateopai*@aoo]i]jaen]( lk`aiko_kjoanr]n]e`ae]`amqaqi]pe_](at]p]iajpa(rj^$`aÚje`]a`apaniej]`] lknqi]_qhpqn]aqi]ok_ea`]`aai_kj`e aodeop ne_]o`]`]o%amqalknah]mqa]r]he]) iko]mq]he`]`aikn]h`]o] aona]hev]`]oj]o`ebanajpaoejopepqe aook_e]eoalkhpe_]oa j]olnkÚoo ao* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(lk`aikoape_]iajpaej`]c]noa(aioq]ojkni]o`abqj_ekj]he`]`a aaÚ__e](]oejopepqe aoa]olnkÚoo aonaolaep]ikqjkkolnej_lekoikn]eo6oanaolaep]i kqjk]atecj_e]ikn]h`]jkrekhj_e](oab]rkna_aikqjkkatan__ek`]]qpknnaÛatk( `]naolkjo]^ehe`]`aa`]he^an`]`a`kooaqoiai^nko*A]ooeilkn`e]jpa*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
N]vk(`aoafkarkjp]`a N]_ekj]heoikpe_k =pn]`ekÚhko Ú_]mqaat]iej]iko]p]mqe_kjopepqekn]_ekj]heoik pe_k(lkeo]pne) ^qen]vkdqi]j]khqc]n_ajpn]hj]re`]pe_]*@q]o_knnajpaolnej_el]eobkni]i]pn]`e) kn]_ekj]heop]6]mqah]mqae`ajpeÚ_]n]vk_kiejpahecj_e]kqejpaha_pk$`loobkqbfkqbib`* qr^ifpq^%a]mqah]mqa_kjoe`an]mqa(j]ikn]h(]n]vke`ajpeÚ_])oa_ki]rkjp]`a$`loobkqb slirkq^ofpq^%* J]o`q]o_knnajpao(lkni(d_kj_kn` j_e]mq]jpke`ae]`amqa(lknj]pqnav](okiko oanaol]ooekj]eo(_daeko`a]lapepao(eilqhokoa`aoafko_acko(`aoajbna]`koa`aoia`e`ko( _]^aj`kn]vk$oaf]_kikejpahecj_e](jkejpaha_pq]heoik(oaf]_kikrkjp]`a(jkrkhqjp]) neoik%aop]^aha_anheiepaoa_kjpnkhaol]n]l]et aoa`aoafko* Ackoik( ]cnaooere`]`a( ]r]nav]( ^qo_] eheiep]`] `a ln]vanao _knlkn]eo( oatq]he`]`a oai bnaeko( iajpen]( delk_neoe]( i)b( `aoafk `a lkooa $p]jpk `a _keo]o _kik `a laook]o%( ]i^ek`aoia`e`](_nqah`]`a(ia`k(_kr]n`e](lnacqe]( `ek(eilqhoko]oo]ooejko(`aolna) vklah]re`]alahkooajpeiajpko]hdaekook]hcqi]o`]oiqep]ol]et aomqajkopknj]i eikn]eoaej_]l]vao`anah] ao`a_ajpaoa`ecj]o_kikokqpnkoa_kjko_kiaoiko*Mq]j`k _a`aiko]ah]o(okikore_ekoko a _qhl]`ko* = pe_] ]lnaoajp])oa( ]ooei( _kik pn]^]hdk`] fkqbifdk`f^a+kq`]slkq^abl]n]`kiej]na_kjpnkh]naoo]ol]et ao* =_kj_alkejpaha_pq]heop] L]n]]_kj_alkejpaha_pq]heop](]re`]pe_]kqre`]renpqko]`alaj`a`k_kjda_eiaj) pk(lkeookiajpalknecjkn j_e]mqab]vaikoki]hajko`aet]iko]nn]op]nlkneilqhoko al]et ao_kjpnnekorenpq`aa]k^ai*Koandqi]jk(oaj`kaooaj_e]hiajpan]_ekj]h(`ara b]van_kimqaoq]n]vkkqejpahecj_e]$kejpaha_pk%_kjda]koÚjoikn]eo(koiaekoikn]eo a]`ebanaj]ajpna^aiai]h(`aik`k]_kj`qven]rkjp]`ajkikiajpk`]`ahe^an]ka `]`a_eok*=re`]pe_]`alaj`a`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]ejpahecj_e]kqn]vk(oai]mq]h] rkjp]`ajklk`an]pq]n* =_kj_alkrkhqjp]neop] L]n]]_kj_alkrkhqjp]neop](]re`]pe_]kqikn]h`alaj`aaooaj_e]hiajpa`]jkoo] rkjp]`a(lknmqa`ah]`alaj`ajkook]cenalknmqaah]lk`amqanankqjkmqanankmqa] ejpahecj_e]hdakn`aj]*Oa]rkjp]`abkn^k](oanaikorenpqkoko(oabkni(oanaikore_ekoko* =rkjp]`a^k]kneajp]jkoo]ejpahecj_e]jkikiajpk`]ao_khd]`aqi]]k(ajmq]jpk] rkjp]`ai`aore]jkoo]n]vk`]^k]ao_khd](jkikiajpk`a`ahe^an]na`a]cen*=re`] pe_]`alaj`a`]mq]he`]`a`ajkoo]rkjp]`aa`]`eo_elhej]l]n]bkn)h]nqik]k^ai*K `arana`q_]]rkjp]`al]n]mqaoapknjanap]a^k]* ?kjrancj_e]oajpna]o`q]o_kj_al ao Qi]l]etk$]ikn( `ek(ejraf](]i^ek(kncqhdk(ia`k%_khk_])jkoian_`a_keo]oa laook]omqa`aoaf]ikolkooqenkq`aopnqen*Kn]_ekj]heoikpe_k$oaf]j]_kj_alkejpaha_) pq]heop](oaf]j]rkhqjp]neop]%`aÚja]p]nab]`]a`q_]kikn]ha`]_kj`qp]pe_]_kiklk) `anek`]n]vkl]n]eila`en)jko`alan`an]he^an`]`aok^koabaepko`al]et ao`aoia`e`]o aej_kjpnkhraeo*L]n]p]jpk(]pe_]n]_ekj]heop]`eopejcqakb`bppfa^ab(abpbglaslkq^ab* =ja_aooe`]`a`evnaolaepk]pq`kmq]jpkja_aooep]ikol]n]_kjoanr]njkoo]ateopj) _e]6]heiajp]k(^a^e`](d]^ep]k(]c]o]hdkjkbnek(lnkpak_kjpn]]oejpailneao(nah]) aooatq]eol]n]]lnk_ne]k(`ao_]jokl]n]oana_qlan]n`k_]jo]k(ap_* L]n]kooanaodqi]jko(o]peob]van]oja_aooe`]`aobkjpa`ao]peob]k*K`aoafkl]npa `]o]peob]k`aja_aooe`]`ao(i]o]_nao_ajp]]ah]okoajpeiajpk`kln]van(`]j`ko_keo]o( olaook]oaooepq] aojkr]omq]he`]`aoaoajpe`ko*Jk`aoafk(jkoo]ei]cej]k^qo_]k ln]vanabkca`]`knlahkoecjeÚ_]`k]pne^q`k]kmqa`aoaf]`kkqej`aoaf]`k*
0,2
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
=i]jaen]_kikei]cej]iko]o]peob]k(kln]van(k_kjpajp]iajpkmqa]hcqi]_keo] kq]hcqijko`kpn]jobkni]aoo]_keo]kqaooa]hcqiaik^fapk`a`aoafk(kmqajkohar] ]lnk_qn)hkoailna(iaoikmq]j`kjk_kjoacqeikolkooq)hkkq]h_]j)hk*K`aoafk( lkeo(]^qo_]`]bnqek`]mqehkmqa`aoaf]`k(lknmqakk^fapk`k`aoafk`oajpe`kjkoo] re`](`apaniej]jkookooajpeiajpkoajkoo]o] ao*Oa(_kikko]jei]eo(paikoja_aooe`]) `ao(okiajpa_kikdqi]jkopaiko`aoafk*Lkneook(iqepkoÚh okbko]Úni]imqa]aooj) _e]`kooanaodqi]jko`aoaf]namqaokikooanaoÎ`aoaf]jpaoÏ6jk]laj]o`aoaf]iko(i]o ok^napq`k`aoaf]ikooan`aoaf]`kolknkqpnko* =rkjp]`a`ebana`k`aoafklknlkooqenpno_]n]_panope_]omqaaopajklkooqe6 -*
k]pkrkhqjpnekeilhe_]qiaobknkl]n]raj_ank^op_qhko*Aopaolk`aioani]pane]eo $qi]ikjp]jd]oqncajkiaek`k_]iejdk%(boe_ko$b]`ec](`kn%kqlomqe_ko$`aocko) pk(bn]_]ook(bnqopn]k%*=paj]_e`]`aa]lanoaran]j](]naoeopj_e]a]_kjpejq]k`k aobknkoki]n_]o`]rkjp]`aalkneookb]h]ikoaiclo ^abslkq^ab7
.*
k]pkrkhqjpnekateca`eo_anjeiajpkanaÛatk]jpao`a]cen(eopk(ateca`ahe^an]k(]r]) he]kapki]`]`a`a_eok*=rkjp]`alao](_kil]n](]r]he](`eo_qpa(fqhc]]jpao`]]k7
/*
]rkjp]`anabana)oa]klkoorah(eopk(]kmqalk`aoankq`aet]n`aoanamqaoapknj] na]hkq]_kjpa_acn]]o]k]pkrkhqjpnek(mqa]pq]paj`kaireop]koÚjoa]lnareok `]o_kjoamqj_e]o*Lkneook(]rkjp]`aejoal]nrah`]naolkjo]^ehe`]`a*
K`aoafkl]etk*=rkjp]`a(`a_eok*K`aoafkj]o_a`]ei]cej]k*=rkjp]`aoa]npe) _qh]naÛatk*K`aoafkjkoqlknp]kpailk(kqoaf](`aoaf]nmqanan]o]peob]keia`e]p] akln]vaneia`e]pk*=rkjp]`a(]k_kjpnnek(na]hev])oajkpailk7kaobknka]lkj`an]k pn]^]hd]i_ki]nah]kajpnaiaekoaÚjoa]_aep]i]`aikn]`]o]peob]k*J^plabpbgl nrblcbob`b slkq^ablpjlqfslpfkqboflobpblpÛkpbuqboflobpa^^ l+ Çrkjp]`a_]^a]a`q_]kikn]h`k`aoafk*J]_kj_alkejpaha_pq]heop](]ejpahecj_e] kneajp]]rkjp]`al]n]mqaaop]a`qmqak`aoafk*J]_kj_alkrkhqjp]neop](]rkjp]`a^k] paiklk`an`aa`q_]nk`aoafk(ajmq]jpk]rkjp]`aioq^iapa)oa]ahaalk`a(aiiqepko _]oko(lanranp)hk* ?kjo_ej_e](`aoafkarkjp]`abkni]ik_]ilk`]re`]pe_]6_kjo_ej_e]a`aoafknaba) nai)oaojkoo]ofkqbk bpajlqfs^ bp7]rkjp]`a(ojkoo]o^ bpaÛk^ifa^abp*=olneiaen]o `evainaolaepkmq]he`]`a`]]pepq`aejpaneknkq`kooajpeiajpkoejpanjko]koqfaepkikn]h7]o hpei]o(mq]he`]`a`]]pepq`aatpanj](`]o_kj`qp]oa`ko_kilknp]iajpko`koqfaepkikn]h* L]n]]_kj_alkn]_ekj]heop](]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]hk_kjda_eiajpk`]oikper] aoaej) paj ao$mqaikraiejpanekniajpakoqfaepkikn]h%a`koiaekoaÚjo`]]kikn]h_]l]) vao`a_kj_napev]n]mqah]oikper] aoaejpaj ao*?kjrik^oanr]nmqa]lkoek`aG]jp( ai^kn]n]_ekj]heop](`ebana`]o`ai]eolknmqa_kjoe`an]ennahar]jpao]oikper] aoaejpaj) ao`koqfaepk(qi]ravmqa]pe_]`evnaolaepkbkni]qjerano]h`k]pkikn]h(_kik]pk herna`aqi]rkjp]`an]_ekj]h^k](mqa]calkn`aranoacqj`k]ohaeoqjerano]eomqa`aq]oe iaoi]*Keilan]perk_]pac ne_kat_hqeikperkoaejpaj ao$mqaokoailnal]npe_qh]nao% lknmqaaopaokpn]jobkni]ne]iai]hck_kj`e_ekj]`klknahaoa(lknp]jpk(kpknj]ne]iqi eilan]perkdelkppe_k(`aopnqej`k)k_kikbqj`]iajpkqjerano]h`]]kpe_]lkn`aran*
pe_]`]oaik aoa`k`aoafk
0,3
Kn]_ekj]heoikpe_kjk]je_]_kj_alkÚhko Ú_]`]ikn]h*Qi]kqpn]_kj_alk Úhko Ú_]_kjda_e`]_kikbjlqfsfpjlqf`l* L]n]kaikpereoikpe_k(kbqj`]iajpk`]re`]ikn]hjk]n]vk(i]o]bjl l*Jkooko oajpeiajpkook_]qo]o`]ojkni]oa`kor]hknaope_ko*Ejolen]j`k)oaaiNkqooa]q(]hcqjo aikpereop]o]Úni]i]^kj`]`aj]pqn]h`ajkookooajpeiajpkoajkoo]ol]et ao(mqaok( lkneook(]bkni]ak_kjpa`k`]ateopj_e]ikn]h_kiknah]kejpanoq^faper]aejpanlao) ok]h*Kqpnkoaikpereop]oo]heajp]i]qpehe`]`a`kooajpeiajpkokq`]oaik aol]n]jkoo] ok^narerj_e]al]n]jkoo]onah] ao_kikokqpnko(_]^aj`kpe_]kneajp]naoo]qpehe`]`a `aik`k]eila`en]rekhj_e]ac]n]jpennah] aofqop]oajpnakooanaodqi]jko*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
D ]ej`] qi] kqpn] _kj_alk pe_]( bn]j_]iajpa _kjpnne] n]_ekj]heop] $a( lkn eook( iqep]oravao_d]i]`]`afoo^`flk^ifpq^%(mqa_kjpaop]n]vkklk`anak`enaepk`aejpanrenok) ^nak`aoafka]ol]et ao(e`ajpeÚ_]j`k]he^an`]`a_ki]lhaj]i]jebaop]k`k`aoaf]jpaa`k l]ooekj]h*Aoo]_kj_alkaj_kjpn])oaaiJeapvo_daaairnekoÚh okbko_kjpailkn jako* Ai^kn]_kir]ne]jpao(aoo]_kj_alkÚhko Ú_]lk`aoannaoqie`]jkooacqejpaolkj) pkolnej_el]eo(paj`k_kiknabanj_e]]k^n]jeapvo_de]j]>dbkb^ildf^a^jlo^i6 ]ikn]hn]_ekj]heop]bkeancqe`]_kiÚj]he`]`analnaookn]ajkl]n]c]n]jpenkatan_) _ek`]he^an`]`a7 ]ikn]hn]_ekj]heop]pn]jobknikqpq`kkmqaj]pqn]haaolkjp jakjkooanaodqi]jko air_ek(b]hp](_qhl](aeilo]ahao(_kikojkiao`arenpq`aa`aran(pq`kkmqaklne) ia]j]pqnav]dqi]j]7 l]et ao(`aoafkoarkjp]`anabanai)oare`]aatl]jok`ajkoo]bkn]rep]h(lknp]jpk( jkoanabanai(aolkjp]ja]iajpa(]k^aia]ki]h( lkeoaopaookqi] ejrajk`] ikn]hn]_ekj]heop]7 ]ikn]hn]_ekj]heop]bkeejrajp]`]lahkobn]_kol]n]_kjpnkh]na`kiej]nkobknpao(_qfko `aoafko(l]et aoarkjp]`a]Úni]i]re`](iaoikj]_nqah`]`aaj]]cnaooere`]`a*Lkn ia`k`]bkn]rep]h`kobknpao(kobn]_ko_kj`aj]n]il]et aoa`aoafko(oq^iapan]i] rkjp]`an]vk(ejrajp]n]ik`aranaeilqoan]i_]opecko]kopn]jocnaooknao7 pn]jocna`enjkni]oanacn]oaop]^aha_e`]o]ran`]`aen]atlnaook`]he^an`]`aaok) iajpakobknpaook_]l]vao`aoo]kqo]`e]*L]n]`eo_elhej]na`k^n]n]rkjp]`a`kobkn) pao(]ikn]hn]_ekj]heop](ejrajp]`]lahkobn]_ko(pn]jobknikq]pn]jocnaookaib]hp]( _qhl]a_]opeck7 ]bkn]rep]hoai]jebaop]_kiko]`a`k_knlka`]]hi](_kikbkn]`]ei]cej]k _ne]`kn]*Lkneook(kobknpao`ao_kjda_ai]jcope](ia`k(naiknok(dqieh`]`a(ejraf]* =ikn]h`kobn]_ko(lkni(]pepq`alna_kj_aepqko]a_kr]n`a`komqapaiai]o]`a a]re`](ejraf]ikobknpaoalnk_qn]i(lah]iknpeÚ_]k`k_knlkalahko]_neb_ek`k aolnepk(rejc]n)oa`]bkn]rep]h7 ]ikn]h`kobn]_kolnk`qpk`knaooajpeiajpk(mqak`ae]apaia]re`](ajrajaj]j`k)] _ki]_qhl]akla_]`k(rkhp]j`k_kjpn]oeiaoi]k `ekre`]7 ] ikn]h `ko naooajpe`ko( ^]oa]`] jk ia`k a jk `ek re`] $o l]et ao( ]ko `aoafko( rkjp]`abknpa%(ejrajp]qi]kqpn]re`](bqpqn](apanj](ej_knl na](mqaoan`]`]_kik na_kilajo]]komqao]_neÚ_]naioaqoeilqhokorep]eoa]_aep]naikor]hknao`kobn]_ko7 ]ok_ea`]`a(ckranj]`]lknbn]_kodel _nep]o(eil a]kobknpaoik`ahkope_komqako ajbn]mqa]iakopknjailneoekjaenko` _aeo`]delk_neoe]`]ikn]hrecajpa7 lna_eoki]jpankobknpao(`evaj`k)hdaomqak^aipq`kkmqabknp]ha_ak`aoafk`] re`]ai]hpq`kkmqa_kjpnnek]aooa`aoafk* L]n]aooaoÚh okbko(mqalk`aiko_d]i]n`a]jpenn]_ekj]heop]o(]ikn]hn]_ekj]heop]kq `kobn]_koanaooajpe`komqapaiai]re`](k_knlk(k`aoafka]ol]et ao]jlo^ialpbp`o^* slp(`komqanajqj_e]iran`]`aen]he^an`]`ape_]*Okatailhk`aoo]ikn]h`aao_n]rko6 ]pe_]ok_npe_](]ikn]hg]jpe]j](]ikn]hfq`]e_k)_neop(]pe_]`]qpkle]ok_e]heop](]pe_] `aik_npe_](aioqi](pk`]ikn]hmqa]Úniamqakodqi]jkookecq]eo(oaf]lknoanai n]_ekj]eo$O _n]pao(G]jp%(oaf]lknoanaieniko$nahecekfq`]e_k)_neop%(oaf]lknlkooqnai koiaoiko`enaepko$pe_]ok_e]heop]a`aik_npe_]%* ?kjpn]]_kj_alk`koao_n]rko(]Úni])oa]jlo^ialppbkelobpkq]qf`^alpjbiel* obp(`ko^ofpqlf(]jlo^i^ofpql`oqf`^(bqj`]`]jkoejopejpkorep]eo(jko`aoafkoaj]mqehkmqa Jeapvo_da_d]i]`aslkq^ababmlqk`f^(_qfkik`ahkoaaj_kjpn]jkocqannaenko^ahkoa ^kjo`]ook_ea`]`ao]jpec]o(^]oa]`]oj]cqann](jko_ki^]paoajkofkcko(j]o`eolqp]olah] ch ne]alah]b]i](j]^qo_]`]dkjn]a`]_kn]cai*
ARISTOIßDOßGREGOß±OSß MELHORES²ß%SSAßPALAVRAß REFERIA SEßgQUELESßQUEß REALIZAVAMßDEßUMßMODOß EXCELENTEßOSßVALORESßß GREGOSßDEßCORAGEMßNAß GUERRA ßDAßBELEZAßFqSICAßEß DOßRESPEITOßAOSßDEUSESß 3jOßAßELITEßOUßAßCLASSEßß DOMINANTE
0,4
=behkokbe]ikn]hx#!0É45,/ßx
Aoo]_kj_alk`]pe_]oqo_ep]`q]ok^oanr] ao*Ailneiaenkhqc]n(hai^naikomqa] pe_]j]o_a_kikpn]^]hdk`aqi]ok_ea`]`al]n]`aheiep]na_kjpnkh]n]rekhj_e](eopk(kqok `]bkn]_kjpn]kqpnai*Reikomqa]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]hoaancqa_kiknaÛatk_kjpn]]rekhj_e]( aijkia`aqioandqi]jk_kj_a^e`k_kikn]_ekj]h(`aoaf]jpa(rkhqjpnekaherna(mqa(oaj) `koqfaepk(jklk`aoanpn]p]`k_kik_keo]*=rekhj_e]an]hk_]hev]`]p]jpkj]o] ao_kjpn] kqpnaiÍ]oo]ooej]pk(pknpqn](oqlh_ek(ao_n]re`k(_nqah`]`a(iajpen](ap_*Í_kikj]o] ao _kjpn]j oiaoikoÍl]ooere`]`a(_kr]n`e]( `ek(ia`k(]`qh]k(ejraf](naiknok(ap_*=pe_] oalnklqjd](]ooei(]ejopepqenr]hknao(iaekoaÚjomqajkohe^an]ooai`aoo]`qlh]rekhj_e]* Ko_npe_ko`]ikn]hn]_ekj]heop](lkni(]Úni]imqa]ln lne]pe_](pn]jobkni]`]ai _kopqiao(lna_kj_aepko_neop]hev]`koaok^napq`kai_kjÚ]j]j]_]l]_e`]`a]l]vecq]`kn] `]n]vk(pknjkq)oa]bkni]lanbaep]`]rekhj_e]*?kjpn]]pe_](ko]jpenn]_ekj]heop]o`abaj) `aikr]hkn`aqi]rekhj_e]jkr]alqneÚ_]`kn]Í]lkpj_e]kq]bkn]`koejopejpkoÍ( _kjoe`an]`]he^anp]`kn]*Klnk^hai]_kjoeopaaio]^anoap]hrekhj_e]lk`apanqil]lah* Ai oacqj`k hqc]n( _qnekok k^oanr]n mqa iqepko `ko _d]i]`ko enn]_ekj]heop]o _kj) pailkn jako^]oae]i)oaj]loe_]jheoaaj]pakne]bnaq`e]j]`]nalnaook`k`aoafk$bqj`]) iajp]hiajpa(`k`aoafkoatq]h%*Lnkl aiqi]pe_]mqahe^anak`aoafk`]nalnaook]mqa] ok_ea`]`akoq^iapaq(nalnaook_]qo]`kn]`aloe_koao(jaqnkoao(]jcope]oa`aoaolanko*K ]ola_pk_qnekokaopjkb]pk`amqaBnaq`_kjoe`an]r]atpnai]iajpalaneckokhe^an]nkfa( ]olqho aoak`aoafk(lknmqa]loe_]jheoad]re]`ao_k^anpkqi]hec]klnkbqj`]ajpnak `aoafk`aln]vanak`aoafk`aiknpa(]rekhj_e]ej_kjpnkhrah`k`aoafkoajkbknkneajp]`k a_kjpnkh]`klahkor]hknaope_kolnklkopkolah]n]vkalknqi]ok_ea`]`an]_ekj]h* Aoo]o `q]o k^oanr] ao jk `arai( lkni( ao_kj`an ko inepko a ]o `eÚ_qh`]`ao `] lnklkop]ikn]h]jpenn]_ekj]heop]*koaqcn]j`ainepk`aojq`]n]delk_neoe]a]rekhj_e] `]ikn]hrecajpa(pn]van`arkhp]k]jpecke`a]h`abahe_e`]`amqajkoo]ok_ea`]`a`aopnqeq lkniaek`]nalnaooka`kolna_kj_aepko*Lkni(]`eÚ_qh`]`a(_kik]_]^]iko`a]ooej]h]n( aopaio]^anoakmqa`araiko_nepe_]na]^]j`kj]n]n]vkkq]n]_ekj]he`]`analnaookn] arekhajp](ejrajp]`]lknjkoo]ok_ea`]`a(mqalna_eo]oan`aopnq`]lknqi]jkr]ok_ea`]`a aqi]jkr]n]_ekj]he`]`a* Jaooa]ola_pk(ejpanaoo]jpak^oanr]nmqajko Bnaq`aJeapvo_da_nepe_]n]i]rekhj) _e]ao_kj`e`]ok^]ikn]hrecajpaaijkoo]_qhpqn](i]o]iaoi]_npe_]bkebaep]lkn>anc) okj$mq]j`k`ao_naraq]ikn]hba_d]`]%alknI]nt$mq]j`k_nepe_kq]e`akhkce]^qncqao]%* I]nt]Úni]r]mqakor]hknao`]ikn]hrecajpaÍhe^an`]`a(bahe_e`]`a(n]_ekj]he`]`a( naolaepkoq^fapere`]`aadqi]je`]`a`a_]`]qi(ap_*Ían]idel _nep]ojkaioeiao) iko$_kikfqhc]r]Jeapvo_da%(i]olknmqaan]ienna]hevraeoaeilkooraeojqi]ok_ea`]`a rekhajp] _kik ] jkoo]( ^]oa]`] j] atlhkn]k `k pn]^]hdk( j] `aoecq]h`]`a ok_e]h a a_k) jie_](j]at_hqok`aqi]l]npa`]ok_ea`]`a`ko`enaepkolkhpe_koa_qhpqn]eo*=ikn]h ^qncqao](`eve]I]nt(lnapaj`aoanqin]_ekj]heoikdqi]jeop](i]o]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo _kj_nap]oaimqarera]i]ekne]`]ok_ea`]`aeila`ai]ateopj_e]lhaj]`aqioandqi]) jkmqana]hevakor]hknaope_ko*L]n]I]nt(lknp]jpk(pn]p]r])oa`aiq`]n]ok_ea`]`al]n] mqa]pe_]lq`aooa_kj_napev]n)oa* ?npe_]o oaiahd]jpao bkn]i baep]o lkn lajo]`knao ok_e]heop]o( ]j]nmqeop]o( qp le_ko( l]n]komq]eoklnk^hai]jkoaaj_kjpn]r]j]n]vk_kiklk`anek`kobn]_konaooajpe`ko _kjpn]kobknpao(i]ojkik`k_kik]ok_ea`]`aaopknc]jev]`](lkeojah]keilan]perk_]) pac ne_kg]jpe]jk(lknatailhk(jklk`aoannaolaep]`k(qi]ravmqa]knc]jev]kok_e]h l aqi]l]npa`]ok_ea`]`a_kik_keo](ejopnqiajpkkqiaekl]n]]kqpn]l]npa*
pe_]aloe_]jheoa 6ERß5NIDADEß ßCAPqTULOß
0,5
M
q]j`kaopq`]ikokoqfaepk`k_kjda_eiajpk(reikomqa]loe_]jheoaejpnk`qve] qi _kj_aepk jkrk( k ej_kjo_eajpa( mqa heiep]r] k lk`an ok^an]jk `] n]vk a `] _kjo_ej_e](]hi`a`ao_knpej]n]oatq]he`]`a_kikbkn]`apaniej]jpa`ajkoo] ateopj_e](jkooklajo]iajpkajkoo]_kj`qp]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Jk_]ok`]pe_](]`ao_k^anp]`kej_kjo_eajpapn]v_kjoamqj_e]ocn]raop]jpkl]n]]o e`ae]o`a_kjo_ej_e]naolkjoraharkjp]`aherna_kikl]n]kor]hknaoikn]eo* @ab]pk(oa(_kiknarah]]loe_]jheoa(pljlpjkookoeilqhokoa`aoafkoej_kjo_eajpaoa oaaopao`ao_kjda_ai^]nnaen]oaheiepaol]n]]^qo_]`]o]peob]ka(ok^napq`k(oa_kjoa) cqai]o]peob]k^qnh]j`kaajc]j]j`k]_kjo_ej_e](_kik(ajpk(i]jpan(lknatailhk( ]e`ae]`arkjp]`ahernamqa]calkn`aran; Lknkqpnkh]`k(oakmqaoal]oo]aijkoo]_kjo_ej_e]oeilhaoabaepk`eob]n]`k_qf]o _]qo]ona]eookej_kjo_eajpaoaao_kj`e`]o(_kikb]h]nai_kjo_ej_e]naolkjorah;?kik] _kjo_ej_e]lk`ane]naolkjo]^ehev]n)oalahkmqa`ao_kjda_aamqaf]i]eooapknj]_kjo_eajpa; I]eocn]ra(lkni(]_kjoamqj_e]l]n]kor]hknaoikn]eo*Aihqc]n`aoqncenai_kik atlnaook`aÚj]he`]`aolnklkop]olknqi]rkjp]`a^k]arenpqko]mqa`aoaf]k^ai(ko r]hknaoaÚjope_kooqncai_kiknacn]oajkni]onalnaooer]omqa`arai_kjpnkh]njkooko `aoafkoaeilqhokoej_kjo_eajpao*Eook]_]nnap]`keolnk^hai]ope_kojkrko* Ailneiaenkhqc]n(_kikb]h]nai]qpkjkie]ikn]h(oak`aran(kor]hknaoakoÚjook eilkopko]koqfaepklknqi]n]vkklkop]]kej_kjo_eajpaa(lknp]jpk(klkop]]kjkookoan na]h;=n]vkjkoane]qi]Ú_kaqilk`annalnaooerkatpanjk(ej_kil]prah_ki]`aÚ) jek`]]qpkjkie];Aioacqj`khqc]n(reopkmqako`aoafkoej_kjo_eajpaooai]jebaop]i lkn`eob]n_ao(_kik]n]vklk`ane]lnapaj`an_kjpnkh)hkook^k`arana]orenpq`aooajk pai]_aook]ahao; =loe_]jheoaikopn]mqaokikonaoqhp]`kaatlnaook`ajkoo]deop ne]`are`](i]n) _]`]lah]oatq]he`]`aejo]peobaep](mqa^qo_]o]peob] aoei]cejne]ooaif]i]eolk`ano]) peob]van)oalhaj]iajpa*Jkokiko]qpknaojaioajdknao`ajkoo]deop ne](i]oabaepk`ah]* Ikopn])jkop]i^imqajkooko]pkookna]hev] aoej_kjo_eajpao`aikper] aooatq]eo mqa`ao_kjda_aikoamqanalapeikore`]]bkn]* @klkjpk`areop]`kej_kjo_eajpa(iajpen(i]p]n(nkq^]n(oa`qven(`aopnqen(paian(]i^e) _ekj]nokoeilhaoiajpa^jlo^fp(lkeolfk`lkp`fbkqbabp`lkeb`bs^ilobpjlo^fp*Ejian]o ravao(_kilknp]iajpkomqa]ikn]he`]`afqhc]eikn]eookna]hev]`ko_kik]qpk`abao]`k oqfaepk(mqakoailnac]l]n]`abaj`anoq]ejpacne`]`alomqe_]]ia]]`]$na]hkqb]jp]oek) o]%*Oaok]pkoikn]hiajpa_kj`ajraeo(lk`ai(lkni(oanloe_khkce_]iajpaja_aooneko* Jaooa_]ok(_kikfqhc)hkoa_kj`aj)hkoikn]hiajpa; B]n]iko(lkni(qi]ejpanlnap]kl]n_e]h`]loe_]jheoaoa_kjoe`anooaiko]laj]o aooa]ola_pk`aoq]cn]j`a`ao_k^anp](ecjkn]j`kqikqpnkmqap]i^ihdaaooaj_e]h*@a b]pk(]loe_]jheoaaj_kjpn]`q]oejop j_e]okq`q]ob]_ao]jp]cje_]ojkej_kjo_eajpa6kfa kqif_falpbur^i(ai^qo_]`]o]peob]k(akprmbobdlkq`bkpro^jlo^i(ejpaneknev]`]lahk oqfaepk(mqa]^oknrakor]hknao`aoq]ok_ea`]`a* Jkoo]loemqaqi_]ilk`a^]p]hd]ej_kjo_eajpaajpna`aoafkoa_ajoqn]o*Ke`]i] klnke^e`k7koqlanackmqanoan]i]`klknnalneienke`(ei]cej]j`k)oap]jpki]eo]i]`k mq]jpki]eonalnaookn*Ke``ao_kjda_abnkjpaen]o7koqlanacko _kjda_a^]nnaen]o*Raj_a) `kn(ke`rekhj_e]mqa`aopn ekokqpnko*Raj_a`kn(koqlanackrekhj_e]mqa`aopn ekoq) faepk*Jaqnkoaoaloe_koaook_]qo]`]op]jpklknqie`atpnai]iajpabknpaaqioqlanack bn]_k(mq]jpklknqioqlanackatpnai]iajpabknpaaqie`bn]_k*=^]p]hd]ejpanekno lk`a oan`a_e`e`]aijkooklnkraepklknqi]pan_aen]ejop j_e]6]`lkp`fk`f^* @ao_k^nen]ateopj_e]`kej_kjo_eajpajkoecjeÚ_](lknp]jpk(aomqa_an]_kjo_ej_e] a]^]j`kj)h]_kik]hckehqo nekkqejpeh*Lahk_kjpnnek(]loe_]jheoajkokiajpaqi] pakne]ok^nakoandqi]jk(i]o]jpao`apq`kqi]pan]le]l]n]]qtehe]nkoqfaepkjk]qpk) _kjda_eiajpkaqiik`k`aarep]nmqaahaoapknjaqifkcqapa`]obkn]oej_kjo_eajpao`k e`a`koqlanack* Jk_]okaola_Ú_k`]pe_](]loe_]jheoaikopnkqmqaqi]`]obkjpao`kookbneiajpko lomqe_ko(_]qo]`a`kaj]oa`alanpqn^] aoiajp]eoaboe_]o(knecknat_aooerk`koqla) nack(kqoaf](`aqi]ikn]he`]`ance`](mqalnk`qvqifab^ialbdl$r]hknaoaÚjope_ko%en) na]hevrah(pknpqn]j`kloemqe_]iajpa]mqahaomqajk_kjoacqai]h_]j)hklknpanaioe`k a`q_]`koj]_naj]`amqaaooae`a]hoane]na]hevrah*
0-,
=he^an`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
$IVULGAljO
Eo]^ahhaDqllanp ai_aj]`kbehia I]`]ia>kr]nu( `a-55-(]`]lp]k _ejai]pkcnbe_]`k nki]j_aao_nepklkn Bh]q^anpai-413* Aii]>kr]nu qi]lanokj]cai ajna`]`]lah]joe] `aqi]re`]]iknko] i]eoejpajo]*
Mq]j`kqi]ok_ea`]`analneiako`aoafkoej_kjo_eajpao`ap]hik`kmqajklkoo]i aj_kjpn]niaekoei]cejnekoaoei^ he_ko`aatlnaook(mq]j`kko_ajoqn]a_kj`aj]`ap]h bkni]mqajqj_]lkoo]ii]jebaop]n)oa(lnal]n]k_]iejdkl]n]`q]o]hpanj]per]oecq]hiaj) pa`eop]jpao`]pe_]6kq]pn]jocnaookrekhajp]`aoaqor]hknaolahkooqfaepkonalneie`kokq] naoecj]kl]ooer]`aqi]_khapere`]`ajaqn pe_](mqa_kjbqj`ajaqnkoaaikn]he`]`a* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(aihqc]n`ape_](drekhj_e]7lknqih]`k(rekhj_e]`]ok_ea`]`a( mqaateca`kooqfaepkol]`n ao`a_kj`qp]eilkooraeo`aoanaina]hev]`koa(lknkqpnk(rek) hj_e]`kooqfaepko_kjpn]]ok_ea`]`a(lkeookiajpapn]jocna`ej`ka`aolnav]j`kkor]hknao aop]^aha_e`kolk`ankok^nareran* Aioqi](oai]nalnaook`]oatq]he`]`a(jkdok_ea`]`ajaipe_](i]o]at_aooer] nalnaook`]oatq]he`]`a`aopn e(lneiaenk(]pe_]a(`alkeo(]ok_ea`]`a* Kmqa]loe_]jheoalnkl aqi]jkr] ikn]h oatq]h mqa d]nikjeva( p]jpk mq]j) pk bkn lkoorah( ko `aoafko ej_kjo_eajpao( ]o bkni]o `a o]peob]v)hko a ] re`] ok_e]h* Aoo] ikn]h(are`ajpaiajpa(o lk`aoanna]hev]`] lah]_kjo_ej_e]alah]rkjp]`aherna(`aoknpa mqa]loe_]jheoalnk_qn]bknp]ha_)h]o_kik ejop j_e]oik`an]`kn]o`ke`a`koqlanack* Okikoape_]iajpahernaoanaolkjoraeojk lknmqalkoo]ikob]vanpq`kmq]jpkmqaen]) iko( jai lknmqa mqaen]iko pq`k mq]jpk lkoo]ikob]van(i]olknmqa]lnaj`aiko] `eo_neiej]n]obnkjpaen]oajpnaklaniepe`k aklnke^e`k(paj`k_kik_nepneke`a]h]]q) oj_e]`]rekhj_e]ejpanj]aatpanj]*
#APqTULOß =he^an`]`a =he^an`]`a_kiklnk^hai] B]h]ikolkap]o6 ^qlokbfo^pb`^ %j^pmflo7^c^iq^ abpbab& ^irw^m^d^a^ %j^pmflo7ldlpql albp`rol&
0--
^mloq^cb`e^a^ %j^pmflo7^`e^sb mloabkqol&
Aooalkai]`aFkoL]qhkL]aojkob]h](`abkni]atpnai]iajpa_kj_ajpn]`]alna_eo]( `kj_hak`]he^an`]`aa`a_kiklk`aikolan_a^anoq]]qoj_e]*Klkap]h]j]qi_kjpn]) lkjpkajpnaqi]oepq]katpanj]atlaneiajp]`]_kikqi`]`kkq_kikqib]pk$]pknjae) n]oa_](]hqv]l]c]`](]lknp]ba_d]`]%a]ejn_e]naoecj]`]jkejpanekn`koqfaepk$]b]hp]`a oa`a(kckopk`kao_qnk(]_d]ralkn`ajpnk%*K_kjpn]lkjpkbaepklah]atlnaookÎi]oleknÏ* MqaoecjeÚ_]ah];Mqa`e]jpa`]]`ranoe`]`a$]b]hp]`acq](]b]hp]`ahqv(]b]hp]`a]^anpqn]%( najqj_e]iko]ajbnajp)h]$fjaimqanaiko^a^ancq](]ooei_kikfjaimqanaikohqv kqlknp]o]^anp]o%(b]vaik)jko_ilhe_ao`ah]*Lkni(jkeookklekn*Lekn]najj_e] he^an`]`a*Najqj_e]ikooa`a(mqajkob]ne]]^nen]pknjaen]7najqj_e]iko]k`aoafk`ahqv( mqajkob]ne]]_aj`an]hqv7najqj_e]iko]k]^anpk(mqajkob]ne]cen]n]_d]ra*@aoo]i]jae) n](oa_qn](ao_qne`kalneok`aet]i`aaop]nbkn]`aj ol]n]oapknj]naij oiaoiko(_ki jkoo]b]hp]`aoa`a(jkookckopk`kao_qnkajkoo]b]hp]`arkjp]`a`acen]n]_d]ra* Qikqpnklkai]p]i^ikbana_ak_kjpn]lkjpkajpnaj oakiqj`k6
2ENATOßDOSß!NJOS%DITORAß!BRIL
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
*OSmß0AULOß0AESßß ¯ ßPOETAßß BRASILEIRO
Jaooalkai](?]nhko@nqiikj``a=j`n]`a(_kikFkoL]qhkL]ao(_kjbnkjp])jko_ki ]na]he`]`aatpanekn6kÎr]opkiqj`kÏ`kmq]hokikoqi]lamqaj]l]n_ah]ajkmq]haop]) ikoiancqhd]`ko*Pk`]re](ko`keolkai]o`ebanai(lkeoairav`]ejn_e]naoecj]`](_kik jk lkai] `a L]ao( aop]iko ]ckn] `e]jpa `] ]Úni]k `a mqa jkook oan i]eo r]opk `k mqakiqj`k6lahkjkook_kn]kÍoajpeiajpkoaei]cej]kÍokikoi]eknao`kmqak iqj`k(_ne]ikokqpnkoiqj`kolkooraeo(ejrajp]ikokqpn]na]he`]`a*=^neiko]pknjaen]( ]_aj`aiko]hqvacen]iko]_d]ra* Ai^kn]`ebanajpao(ko`keolkai]o]lkjp]il]n]kcn]j`apai]`]pe_](`ao`amqa aop]oapknjkqmqaopkÚhko Ú_]6lnrbbpqblnrbklbpqbjklpplmlaboq]nmqa6ÎAeomqa_dac]]nk`]rer](har]j`k]o]q`]`aln]hÏ* =opakne]ope_]olnk_qn]n]ioailnaajbnajp]nkarmilmol_ibj^`]ja_aooe`]`aa`] _kjpejcj_e](`aÚjej`kk_]ilk`]he^an`]`alkoorah*
=o_kj_al ao`a=neoppahaoa`aO]npna
0-1
=lneiaen]cn]j`apakne]Úhko Ú_]`]he^an`]`aatlkop]lkn=neop pahaoaioq]k^n] qf`^^Kf`j^`la(_kir]ne]jpao(lani]ja_a]pn]ro`koo_qhko_dac]j`k]pko_qhkTT( mq]j`kbkenapki]`]lknO]npna*Jaoo]_kj_alk(]he^an`]`apblmb]kmqa_kj`e_ekj]`k atpanj]iajpa$ja_aooe`]`a%a]kmqa]_kjpa_aoaiao_khd]`ahe^an]`]$_kjpejcj_e]%* @ev=neop pahaomqaherna]mqahamqapaiaioeiaoikklnej_lekl]n]]cenkqjk ]cen(eopk(]mqahamqa_]qo]ejpanj]`aoq]]kkq`]`a_eok`ajk]cen*=he^an`]`a _kj_a^e`]_kiklmlabomibklbfk`lkaf`flk^ia^slkq^abm^o^abqbojfk^o^pfjbpj^(kq oaf](l]n]]qpk`apaniej]n)oa*lajo]`](p]i^i(_kik]qoj_e]`a_kjopn]jceiajpkoat) panjkoaejpanjko(eopk(_kikrj^`^m^`fa^abnrbklbk`lkqo^l_pq`rilpm^o^pbob^ifw^o kbjclo ^a^mlo`lfp^^idrj^m^o^^dfo*Pn]p])oa`]aolkjp]jae`]`alhaj]`k]cajpa(mqa `]oeiaoikkoikperkoakoÚjo`aoq]]koaioan_kjopn]jce`kkqbkn]`klknj]`]a lknjejcqi* =hi `a `eopejcqen ajpna k kb`bppofl a k `lkqfkdbkqb( =neop pahao p]i^i `eopejcqa ajpnak`lkqfkdbkqbakmlppsbi6klneiaenkklqnk]_]ok(i]okoacqj`kkmqalk`a]_kj) pa_an`ao`amqaqioandqi]jk`ahe^anaa`a_e`]na]hev]nqi]]k*=ooei(j]_kj_alk
0ARAMOUNTß0ICTURES!LBUM,ATINSTOCK
]neopkphe_](]he^an`]`aklnej_lekl]n]ao_khdanajpna^iqbok^qfs^pmlppsbfp(na]hev]j`k)oa _kik`a_eoka]pkrkhqjpnek*?kjpn]ne]iajpa]kja_aoonekkqja_aooe`]`aa_kjpej) cj_e](ok^]omq]eok]cajpaokbna]]k`aqi]_]qo]atpanj]mqakk^nec]]]cen`aqi] `apaniej]`]i]jaen](jk^qlslirkqoflifsobl^dbkqb`^rp^abpf(eopk(`^rp^fkqbdo^iab pr^^ l*Oai`re`](lk`an)oa)e]`evanmqa]rkjp]`aherna`apaniej]`]lah]n]vkkqlah] ejpahecj_e]a(jaooa_]ok(oane]lna_eok]`iepenmqajk_]qo]`aoekqej_kj`e_ekj]`](i]o mqa_]qo]`]lahkn]_ek_jekkqlahklajo]iajpk* Jkajp]jpk(_kik`eooan]ikoÚh okbkolkopaneknao]=neop pahao(]ejpahecj_e]fk`ifk^] rkjp]`al]n]qi]_anp]`enak(i]ojk]k^nec]jai]_kjopn]jca(p]jpk]ooeimqalk`a) iko]cenj]`enak_kjpnne]ej`e_]`]lah]ejpahecj_e]kqn]vk*lknoanhernaaej_kj`e) _ekj]`]mqa]rkjp]`alk`aoacqenkqjkko_kjoahdko`]_kjo_ej_e]*=he^an`]`aoanpe_] mq]j`kkatan__ek`]rkjp]`aaoperanaid]nikje]_ki]`enak]lkjp]`]lah]n]vk* Aioq]k^n]Lpboblk^a^(kÚh okbkbn]j_oFa]j)L]qhO]npnaharkqaoo]_kj_alk]k lkjpkheiepa*L]n]aha(^if_boa^ab^bp`lie^fk`lkaf`flk^inrblmomofleljbjc^wabpbr pbobabpbrjrkal*Mq]j`kfqhc]ikoaop]nok^klk`an`abkn]oatpanj]oi]eolk`anko]o `kmqajkoo]rkjp]`a(aooafqhc]iajpkqi]`a_eokherna(lkeokqpnkodkiajo(j]oiao) i]o_en_qjop j_e]o(jkoa_qnr]n]ijaioanaoecj]n]i* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(l]n]O]npna(_kjbkni]n)oakqnaoecj]n)oaqi]`a_eokherna(p]jpk mq]jpkjkoanaoecj]njaioa_kjbkni]n(hqp]j`k_kjpn]]o_en_qjop j_e]o*Mq]j`k`evaiko mqajklk`aikob]van]hcqi]_keo]lknmqaaop]ikob]pec]`ko(]b]`ec]qi]`a_eokjkoo]( p]jpk]ooeimqaqi]kqpn]laook](j]oiaoi]o_en_qjop j_e]o(lk`ane]`a_e`enjkoaoajpen _]jo]`]a]cen*@]iaoi]i]jaen](mq]j`k`evaikoaop]najbn]mqa_e`koalkneookjkpaiko bkn]l]n]b]van]hcqi]_keo](]bn]mqav]qi]`a_eokjkoo](lkeoqikqpnklk`ane](j]o iaoi]o_en_qjop j_e]o(jkoa_kjoe`an]nbn]_ka]cen*=ooeip]i^imq]j`k`evaikomqa jqi]`]`]oepq]kjkdkmqab]van(aooa]^]j`kjk`]]kqi]`a_eokjkoo]*
)MAGE&ORUM!GENCEß&RANCEß0RESSE
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
*EAN 0AULß3ARTREßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßEßß ROMANCISTAßFRANCoS ßß PRINCIPALßPENSADORßDAßß ESCOLAßEXISTENCIALISTA
K]pknI]n_ahhk I]opnke]jeai_aj] `kbehiaKaopn]jcaenk( `a-523(`k`enapkn ep]he]jkHq_dejk Reo_kjpe*Kbehia ^]oa]`kjkhernk dki jeik`kao_ne) pknbn]j_o=h^anp ?]iqoapn]p]`] mqaopk`k]^oqn`k `]ateopj_e]*
?a`anp]jpkmq]jpkjk_a`anqi]`a_eokjkoo]*Lkneook(O]npnab]vqi]]Úni]k ]l]najpaiajpal]n]`kt]h(`evaj`kmqaÎaop]iko_kj`aj]`kohe^an`]`aÏ*Mq]hkl]n]`k) tk;E`ajpeÚ_]nif_boa^aba`lkabk^ l(eopk(`keopanikoej_kil]praeo(lkeohernamqai jkaop_kj`aj]`k* KmqaO]npnalnapaj`a`evan; Mqa( l]n] ko dqi]jko( ] he^an`]`a _kik ] ja_aooe`]`a a ] b]p]he`]`a( kq oaf]( jk lk`aikoao_]l]n`ah]*ah]mqa`aÚja]dqi]je`]`a`kodqi]jko(oaiao_]l]p ne]*aoo] e`ae]mqaaj_kjpn]ikojklkai]`a?]nhko@nqiikj`(mq]j`k]Úni]mqaokikoi]eknao `kmqakÎr]opkiqj`kÏ*ah]p]i^imqaoaaj_kjpn]jklkai]`aRe_ajpa`a?]nr]hdk( mq]j`kjko`evmqa]bahe_e`]`aÎaopoailna]laj]okj`a]lkikoÏaÎjqj_]]lkikokj`a j oaop]ikoÏ*Okiko]cajpaohernaop]jpkl]n]pan_kikl]n]lan`an]bahe_e`]`a*
0-2
=he^an`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
=_kj_alkpe_]mqaqjaja_aooe`]`aahe^an`]`a =oacqj`]_kj_alk`]he^an`]`abke(eje_e]hiajpa(`aoajrkhre`]lknqi]ao_kh]`a ÚhkokÚ]`klank`kdahajope_k(kaopke_eoik*Aoo]_kj_alk(ik`eÚ_]`]airneko]ola_) pko(naooqncajko_qhkTREE_kiAolejko]a(jko_qhkTET(_kiDacah*Jah]_kjoanr]`]] e`ae]]neopkphe_]`amqa]he^an`]`a]]qpk`apaniej]k(]ooei_kik_kjoanr]`]]e`ae] `amqaherna]mqahamqa]caoaioanbkn]`kjai_kjopn]jce`klknj]`]jailknjejcqi a(lknp]jpk(]caeilqhoekj]`kaolkjp]ja]iajpalknqi]bkn]ejpanj]ln lne]*Jkajp]jpk( `ebanajpaiajpa`a=neop pahaoa`aO]npna(aooaoÚh okbkojkoepq]i]he^an`]`ajk]pk`a ao_khd]na]hev]`klah]rkjp]`aej`ere`q]hoal]n]`]`]ja_aooe`]`aaklkop]]ah](i]o]_k) hk_]ik^^qfsfa^abab`^a^rjbknr^kqlm^oqbabrjqlalkb`bppofl(kmq]h]cahernaiajpa mlonrb]caja_aoo]ne]iajpa* KÎpk`kÏlk`aoan^k^qrobw^$jk_]ok`koaopke_ko%(]pr_pq k`f^$jk_]ok`aAolejko]% kqlBpmofql_kikdeop ne]$jk_]ok`aDacah%*Aimq]hmqan`ko_]oko(j]pqnav](oq^op j_e]a Aolnepkok^qlq^ifa^ab`ljlmlabo^_plirqlab^ l(]cej`koacqj`koaqoln lnekolnej_) leko(`]j`k]oeiaoi]oq]ohaeo(oq]onacn]o(oq]ojkni]o*?kikj]`]atpaneknk^nec]]j]pq) nav](]oq^op j_e]kqkAolnepk]]cen(i]o]cai]laj]olknoaqlk`anejpanjk(aopaookhernao* Jkajp]jpk(reopkmqaaoo]]klnkri`]aooj_e]kq`kln lnekoan`kpk`k(oq]]kjk _kjpejcajpajaiian]iajpalkoorah(i]oja_aoone](eopk(`a_knnaja_aoo]ne]iajpa`] oeilhaoateopj_e]aaooj_e]`]j]pqnav](`]oq^op j_e]kq`kAolnepk*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o( mlonrblqlallnrblrmlpprflpbonrbmlpprfnrbbib^dba^j^kbfo^`ljl^db* Kq(_kikatlhe_]Aolejko](mbi^kb`bppfa^aba^bppk`f^lralpboa^pr_pq k`f^nrb bpq^^dbbmlofpplpr^^ lÜrfbpmlkq kb^bkb`bpp^of^jbkqbabi^jbpj^*Oaq]cenqi] ja_aooe`]`ahernakqqi]he^an`]`aja_aoone]lknmqa]ja_aooe`]`ajkqilk`anatpanjk mqa]bkn]]]cen(i]o]laj]o]haeejpanj]`aoq]ln lne]]k(haemqaah]`]oeiaoi]* Aoo]pkp]he`]`a(ja_aoone]ahernaaioeiaoi]lknmqaj]`]]bkn]kq]k^nec]`katpa) nekn(ejop]qn](lah]]k`aoq]he^an`]`a(haeoajkni]oja_aoone]ol]n]pk`]]na]he`]`akq l]n]pk`]o]ooq]ol]npao$koej`er`qko_kjopepq`kolknah]%*Aikqpnkopaniko(]he^an`]) `ajkqilk`anej_kj`e_ekj]`kl]n]ao_khdan$]j]pqnav]jkao_khda(]oq^op j_e]jk ao_khda(kAolnepkjkao_khda%(i]olmlaboalqlalm^o^^dfobj`lkclojfa^ab`lkpfdl jbpjl(oaj`kja_aoo]ne]iajpakmqaab]vaj`kja_aoo]ne]iajpakmqab]v* ?kiklk`aikok^oanr]n(aoo]_kj_alkjki]jpi]klkoekajpnahe^an`]`aaja) _aooe`]`a(i]o]Úni]mqa]kb`bppfa^ab$]ohaeo`]j]pqnav](]ojkni]oanacn]o`]_qhpqn](]o haeo`]deop ne]%^j^kbfo^mbi^nr^i^if_boa^abalqlalpbj^kfcbpq^*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o( ]pkp]he`]`ahernalknmqaoal a]oeiaoi]j]ateopj_e]a`aÚjalknoeiaoi]]ohaeoa]o nacn]o`aoq]]pere`]`a7aja_aoone]lknmqap]eohaeoanacn]oatlneiaija_aoo]ne]iajpak mqaah]ab]v*If_boa^abklbp`liebobabif_bo^o)j^p^dfolrc^wbo^idrj^`lfp^bj`lk* clojfa^ab`lj^k^qrobw^al^dbkqbnrb)kl`^pl)lqlal* Kmqa(ajpk(]he^an`]`adqi]j]ajmq]jpkkdkiaiqi]l]npa_kjopepq`]lahk pk`kamqa]cajkejpanekn`kpk`k; Ok`q]o]onaolkop]o]aoo]mqaopk6
0-3
-*
] lneiaen]$`]`] lahko aopke_ko alkn Dacah%]Úni] mqak pk`k n]_ekj]h amqa oq]o l]npaop]i^ikok(oaj`khernaomq]j`k^dfobjbj`lkclojfa^ab`lj^pibfpalqlal( l]n]k^ai`]pkp]he`]`a7
.*
]oacqj`]$`]`]lknAolejko]%]Úni]mqa]ol]npaook`aiaoi]aooj_e]mqakpk`k a( lknp]jpk( ok n]_ekj]eo a hernao _kik aha( `kp]`]o `a bkn] ejpanekn l]n] ]cen lkn oe iaoi]o(`aoknpamqa]he^an`]`aqlj^om^oqb^qfs^k^^qfsfa^abalqlal*Pki]nl]npa ]per]oecjeÚ_](lknqih]`k(_kjda_an]o_kj`e aoaop]^aha_e`]olahkpk`k(_kjda_an oq]o_]qo]oakik`k_kik`apaniej]ijkoo]o] ao(a(lknkqpnk(cn]]o]p]h_kjda_e) iajpk(jkoanqifkcqapa`]o_kj`e aoa_]qo]omqa]pq]iok^naj o(i]o]cenok^na ah]op]i^i*Jkokikohernaol]n]bp`liebopq`k(i]okokikol]n]c^wbopq`kmq]jpk aopaf]`a]_kn`k_kijkookoana_kijkoo]_]l]_e`]`a`a]cen(cn]]o]k_kjda_eiajpk mqalkooqiko`aj oiaoikoa`]o_en_qjop j_e]oaimqar]iko]cen*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
(ULTON $EUTSCHß#OLLECTIONß #ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
L]n]koaopke_ko(kdkiaiherna]mqaha_qf]n]vk_kjda_a]ja_aooe`]`aj]pqn]ha] ja_aooe`]`a`aoq]ln lne]j]pqnav]apaibkn]l]n]cqe]na`enecen]rkjp]`al]n]mqaaop] atan]qilk`an]^okhqpkok^na]enn]_ekj]he`]`a`koejopejpkoaeilqhoko(eopk(ok^na]o l]et ao*Oanherna]cen_kjbknia]j]pqnav]$oacqej`koq]ohaeoja_aoone]o%a_kjbknia] j]pqnav]`k]cajpa$oacqej`kqi]rkjp]`alaook]hlk`anko]`enece`]lah]n]vk%* L]n]Aolejko](kdkiaiherna]mqahamqa]ca_kik_]qo]ejpanj](_kilhap]apkp]h`a oq]]k*Aop]jklnkri`aqi]ao_khd]rkhqjpne]aoei`k`aoajrkhreiajpkaolkjp jak `]aooj_e]kqj]pqnav]n]_ekj]h`k]cajpa*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]ooei_kikkpk`k]caherna) iajpalah]ja_aooe`]`a`aoq]aooj_e](]ooeip]i^ikej`er`qkherna]calknja_aooe`]) `a`aoq]ln lne]aooj_e]*Okikohernao(`evAolejko](mq]j`kokikoqi]lkpj_e]ejpanj] l]n]]lhqn]he`]`aoeiqhp ja]`a]bapko(e`ae]oa] aomqa`a_knnai`ajkookln lnekoana `komq]eookiko]je_]_]qo]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(okikohernaomq]j`kkmqaokiko(kmqa oajpeiko(kmqab]vaikoakmqalajo]ikoatlneiaijkoo]bkn]ejpanj]l]n]ateopena]cen* @aoo]i]jaen](Aolejko]jk]_aep]]e`ae]aopke_]`]he^an`]`a_kiklk`anekkqeilnek`] rkjp]`aok^na]ol]et ao*@evahamqajkokikohernaolknmqajkoo]rkjp]`a`kiej]jkoo]o l]et ao(i]olknmqaokikohernaomqajkoo]n]vkqi]bapk]hacnai]eobknpa`kmqako ]bapkoj]o_e`ko`]ol]et ao* L]n]Dacah(kdkiaihernaqi]Úcqn]mqa]l]na_aj]deop ne]aj]_qhpqn]ok^`q]o bkni]olnej_el]eo*J]lneiaen](]he^an`]`adqi]j]_kej_e`a_kikoqnceiajpk`]_qhpqn]( kqoaf](hernakdkiaimqajkoa`aet]`kiej]nlah]bkn]`]j]pqnav]amqa]raj_a( `k^n]j`k)]oq]rkjp]`alkniaek`kpn]^]hdk(`]hejcq]caia`]o]npao*Ok^aoo]lneiaen] bkni](lk`aikojkp]nmqa]he^an`]`a(ai^kn]lkoo]atlneien)oajkoej`er`qko(nabana)oa iqepk i]eo ] qi] ]pepq`a `k dkiai qjerano]hiajpa _kjoe`an]`k( kq( oa oa mqeoan( jk _kikej`er`qk(i]o_kikrep ne]`]_qhpqn]ok^na]j]pqnav]* Aioq]kqpn]bkni](kdkiaiherna_kikej`er`qkhernab]voq]]l]nekj]deop ne] ai`keoikiajpkooq_aooerkojkomq]eokoacqj`kikiajpk`alaj`a`klneiaenk*Klne) iaenk ikiajpk k `k oqnceiajpk `k dkiai _neopk kq k oqnceiajpk `] ejpanekne`]`a _neop(mqa`ao_k^na]_kjo_ej_e]_kik_kjo_ej_e]`aoe7koacqj`kikiajpk(`a_knnajpa `k`aoajrkhreiajpkejpanjk`k_neope]jeoik(k`koqnceiajpk`]ej`ere`q]he`]`an]_ekj]h ik`anj] kq `k ej`er`qk _kik _kjo_ej_e] `a oe naÛater]( eopk ( _kik n]vk a rkjp]`a ej`alaj`ajpao`]j]pqnav]kq`]ja_aooe`]`aj]pqn]haej`alaj`ajpa`]_k]k`a]qpkne) `]`aoatpanj]oj]`aÚjek`aoaqlajo]iajpka`aoq]rkjp]`a*
=he^an`]`a_kiklkooe^ehe`]`ak^faper]
'EORGEß,UKACSßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßß MARXISTAßH{NGARO
FACULTY STAFFOUEDUß !RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
=hi`]o_kj_al ao]jpaneknao(ateopa]ej`]qi]pan_aen]_kj_alk(mqalnk_qn]qjen ahaiajpko`]o`q]okqpn]o*=Úni](_kik]oacqj`](mqajkokikoqilk`anej_kj`e_ekj]h `aao_khd]ajpnamq]eomqanlkooraeo(i]omqajkoo]oao_khd]ook_kj`e_ekj]`]olah]o_en) _qjop j_e]oj]pqn]eo(lomqe_]o(_qhpqn]eoadeop ne_]oaimqareraiko(eopk(lah]pkp]he`]`a j]pqn]ha_qhpqn]haimqaaop]ikooepq]`ko*=Úni](_kik]lneiaen](mqa]he^an`]`aqi ]pk`a`a_eokaao_khd]ajpnarnekolkooraeo*Pk`]re](jkoapn]p]`]he^an`]`a`anrbobo ]hcqi]_keo]aoei$_kikf`eve]Aolejko]%`ac^wbo]hcqi]_keo]*Okikohernaol]n]b]van ]hcqi]_keo]mq]j`kpaikoklk`anl]n]b]v)h]* Aoo]pan_aen]_kj_alk`]he^an`]`a(mqaaj_kjpn]ikoailajo]`knaoi]nteop]o$_kik CakncaHqg]_oaHq_eajCkh`i]j%aailajo]`knaorej`ko`]bajkiajkhkce]a`kateopaj) _e]heoik$_kikIanha]q)Lkjpu%ejpnk`qv]jkk`amlppf_fifa^abl_gbqfs^*Klkoorahjk ]laj]o]hcqi]_keo]oajpe`]kqlan_a^e`]oq^faper]iajpalknj o(i]op]i^iaok^na) pq`k]hcqi]_keo]ejo_nep]k^faper]iajpajkoaek`]ln lne]ja_aooe`]`a(ej`e_]j`kmqak _qnok`aqi]oepq]klk`aoaniq`]`klknj o(ai_anp]o`ena aoaok^_anp]o_kj`e ao* =he^an`]`a]_]l]_e`]`al]n]lan_a^anp]eolkooe^ehe`]`aoaklk`anl]n]na]hev]n]mqah]o ] aomqaiq`]ik_qnok`]o_keo]o(`]j`k)hdakqpn]`enakkqkqpnkoajpe`k* J]ran`]`a(]jkoan]mqahaoÚh okbkomqa]Úni]n]i]he^an`]`a_kikqilk`an]^) okhqp]iajpaej_kj`e_ekj]h`]rkjp]`a(aimq]eomqan_en_qjop j_e]o$_kikkÚvan]i(lkn
,UCIENß'OLDMANßß ¯ ßFILvSOFOßß MARXISTAßROMENO
0-4
=he^an`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
n]v ao`ebanajpao(G]jpaO]npna%(ko`ai]eo(j]opno_kj_al ao]lnaoajp]`]o(oailnahar]) n]iai_kjp]]qbkplajpnajkoo]he^an`]`aa]o_kj`e aoÍj]pqn]eo(_qhpqn]eo(lomqe) _]oÍmqajko`apaniej]i*=o`eo_qoo aook^na]ol]et ao(koejpanaooao(]o_en_qjop j_e]o deop ne_k)ok_e]eo(]o_kj`e aoj]pqn]eooailnaaoperan]ilnaoajpaoj]pe_]alkneookqi] e`ae]_kik]`amlppf_fifa^abl_gbqfs^oailnaaoparalnaooqlkop]kqeilh_ep]j]opakne]o ok^na]he^an`]`a*
He^an`]`aalkooe^ehe`]`ak^faper] ?kjpn]kpq`kkqkj]`]
&ERNANDOß3EIXAS%DITORAß!BRIL
Klkoorahjkklnkrrah*Aopaklnareorah(eopk(]hckmqalk`aiko_]h_qh]na]jpa) ran(lknmqaqi]lnk^]^ehe`]`a_kjpe`]jkob]pkoajko`]`komqa]j]heo]iko*Klkoorah( lkni(]mqehk`of^allah]jkoo]ln lne]]k*kmqaraiateopj_e]cn]]o]kjkook]cen* Jk ajp]jpk( jk oqnca _kikÎnrkna ieh]cnko]Ï a oei _kik ]mqehk mqa ]o _en_qjop j_e]o ]^nen]il]n]jkoo]]k* =he^an`]`a]_kjo_ej_e]oeiqhp ja]`]o_en_qjop j_e]oateopajpaoa`]o] aomqa( oqo_ep]`]olknp]eo_en_qjop j_e]o(jkolaniepaiqhpn]l]oo)h]o(`]j`k)hdaokqpnknqika qijkrkoajpe`k(mqajkpane]ioai]jkoo]]k*Ai^kn]mq]hmqanqi`aj o(aijkoo] re`]_kpe`e]j](oaf]_]l]v`aooao]pko`ahe^an`]`a(jkd`re`]`amqadikiajpko(j] deop ne](aimqaaooao]pko]l]na_ai`abkni]cn]j`eko]aatailh]n(_kjopepqej`k]mqehk mqa_d]i]iko`aÎ] ao`kodan eoÏ*Lknmqako_d]i]iko`adan eo;Jklknmqa_kn]) fko]iajpaajbnajp]n]ioepq] aoaimqakqpnkopane]ina_q]`kaoeilknmqa(]kna]hev]n qi]]k(]^nen]iqibqpqnkl]n]iqepkokqpnko(iq`]j`kk_qnok`klnaoajpa(mqal]) na_e]ejareprah*Aoo]]kjkbkeeikper]`]jaibkeqiieh]cna*Kqoaf](jkbkeqi]]k ejatlhe_rah* Oaqo ikperko( oq]o _]qo]o a oq] atlhe_]k aj_kjpn]i)oa j] i]jaen] _kik k]cajpa(ailneiaenkhqc]n(bke_]l]v`aejpanlnap]n]o_kj`e aoa_en_qjop j_e]o`]`]o( lan_a^aj`kmqa(oaiqi]ejpanrajk(ah]ooacqene]iqi_qnokmqa(`alkeo(`en]ikopan oe`kejareprah7a(aioacqj`khqc]n(bke_]l]v`alan_a^an]hpanj]per]omqa(lkq_kreoraeo( p]i^iaop]r]ilnaoajpaoalk`ane]ioanna]hev]`]o* Jkookiqj`k(jkoo]re`]ajkooklnaoajpabkni]iqi_]ilk`a_kj`e aoa_en_qjo) p j_e]o mqa jk bkn]i ao_khde`]o jai `apaniej]`]o lkn j o a ai _qfk ejpanekn jko ik) raiko*Jkajp]jpk(aooa_]ilkpailkn]h6paraqil]oo]`k(paiqilnaoajpaapanqi bqpqnk_qfkorapknaokq`ena aoflk`aioanlan_a^e`kokqiaoik]`erejd]`ko_kiklko) oe^ehe`]`aok^faper]o*@e]jpa`aooa_]ilk(lk`an]iko]ooqien`q]o]pepq`ao6kq]ehqok`a mqapaikolk`anl]n]iq`)hkaimq]hmqan`enakmqa`aoaf]niko(kq]naoecj]k(mqa jkohar]]`evanmqaj]`]lk`aikob]van* @aet]`k]oeiaoik(k_]ilk`klnaoajpaoacqenqi_qnokmqajk`alaj`a`aj o aoanaikooq^iape`kol]ooer]iajpa]ahaÍ]pknjaen]lani]ja_anoa_]kqr]v]n(ejqj) `]j`k]_]o](]hqvlani]ja_an]l]c]`]kqd]ranqi_qnpk)_en_qepk(ej_aj`e]j`k]_]o]( ]lknp]lani]ja_anba_d]`]kqoan]nnki^]`](`aet]j`k]_]o]oanejr]`e`]*=he^an`]`a( lkni(jkoaaj_kjpn]j]ehqok`kÎlkookpq`kÏjaijk_kjbknieoik`kÎj]`]lkookÏ* Aj_kjpn])oaj]`eolkoekl]n]ejpanlnap]na`a_ebn]n]ohejd]o`abkn]a`ena ao`k_]ilk lnaoajpa_kiklkooe^ehe`]`aok^faper]o(eopk(_kik]^anpqn]`ajkr]o`ena aoa`ajkrko oajpe`ko]l]npen`kmqaaop`]`k*
=ej`]qi]rav(]lkaoe] #ARLOSß$RUMMONDßDEßß !NDRADE߯
0-5
J]`]iahdkn`kmqaqikqpnklkai]`a?]nhko@nqiikj`l]n]atlnaoo]naoo]e`ae]* Pn]p])oa`aqilkai]jkmq]hklkap]na_kjda_amqaoaq_kn]kjki]eor]opk`kmqak iqj`k(_kikahaei]cej]n]6
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Iqj`kcn]j`a Kl)jbr`lo^ lklj^flonrbljrkal+ jrfqljbklo+ Kbibkl`^_bjkbj^pjfke^palobp+ Mlofppldlpqlq^kqlabjb`lkq^o+ Mlofppljbafpml) mlofppljbdofql) mlofpplcobnrbkqllpglok^fp)jbbumlkel`or^jbkqbk^pifso^of^p7 mob`fplabqlalp+ Pfj)jbr`lo^ ljrfqlmbnrbkl+ P^dlo^sbglnrbkbibkl`^_bjlpeljbkp+ Lpeljbkpbpql`clo^)bpqlk^or^+ >or^bklojb+J^flo)jrfqlj^floalnrbbrbpmbo^s^+ J^pq^j_j^or^kl`^_bqlalplpeljbkp+ >or^jbklonrbljrkal+ Ljrkaldo^kab+ Qrp^_bp`ljldo^kabljrkal+ @lkeb`bplpk^sflpnrbibs^jmbqoiblbifsolp)`^okbb^idlal+ Sfpqb^pafcbobkqbp`lobpalpeljbkp) ^pafcbobkqbpalobpalpeljbkp) p^_bp`ljlafc`fiplcoboqralfppl)^jlkql^oqralfppl krjpmbfqlabeljbj+++pbjnrbbibbpq^ib+ Cb`e^lplielpbbpnrb`b+ Bp`rq^^dr^klpsfaolp) ql`^ij^+Kl^krk`f^k^a^+ Bkqobq^kqlbp`loobk^pjlp) ql`^ij^s^ffkrka^kalqral+++ Obk^p`bol^p`fa^abppr_jbop^p< Lpeljbkppr_jboplpÍsliq^ol< Jbr`lo^ lklp^_b+ Bpq mfal)ofa`rilbcodfijbr`lo^ l+ P^dlo^abp`r_ol `ljlqofpqbfdklo^o`boq^p`lfp^p+ %K^plifalabfkafsarl abp^mobkaf^ifkdr^dbj `ljnrblpeljbkppb`ljrkf`^j+& Lrqolo^bp`rqbflp^kglp) ^pplk^q^p)lpmlbj^p)^p`lkÛppbpm^qqf`^p+ Krk`^bp`rqbfslwabdbkqb+ Bjsboa^abplrjrfqlml_ob+ Lrqolo^sf^gbf m^pbpfj^dfkoflp)c`bfpabe^_fq^o) fie^ppbjmol_ibj^p)kll_pq^kqbbu^rpqfs^pb`lksl`^kal^lprf`afl+ Jbrp^jfdlpclo^j pfie^p+ Fie^pmboabjleljbj+ Bkqobq^kql^idrkppbp^is^o^jb qolrubo^j^klq`f^ abnrbljrkal)ldo^kabjrkalbpq`obp`bkalqlalplpaf^p) bkqoblcldlbl^jlo+ Bkql)jbr`lo^ lq^j_jmlab`obp`bo+ Bkqobl^jloblcldl)
0.,
=he^an`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
bkqob^sfa^blcldl) jbr`lo^ l`obp`babwjbqolpbbumilab+ Îësfa^crqro^kpqb`of^objlp+ Mqajko`evklkap]; Mqajkj]okhe`k`aqi]rkjp]`aej`ere`q]h$kÎi]eor]opkiaq_kn]kÏ(_kikk lkap]ei]cej]n]]jpao%mqalk`aikoajbnajp]nhernaiajpakÎiqj`kcn]j`aÏ(lkeoÎj]okhe) `k`aej`er`qk`ao]lnaj`eÏ]hejcq]cai`kodkiajoaÎre]fael]oaoei]cejnekoÏ(ehd]o`a qpkle](j]omq]eojkdlnk^hai]o*=k_kjpnnek(j]_kil]jde]`kokqpnkomqalk`aiko ajbnajp]nkiqj`k(ao_qp]j`kÎrkv`acajpaÏmqajkopn]v]jkp_e]`amqakiqj`k_nao_a pk`k`e](eopk(pn]jobkni])oaej_aoo]jpaiajpaÎajpnakbkckak]iknÏ(ajpnahqp]o(cqann]o( _kjÛepkoa^qo_]`al]v(ajpaj`eiajpkafqope]*Okikohernaojk_kjpn]kiqj`k(i]ojk iqj`k(lkeookiajpajahaÎiaq_kn]kp]i^ilk`a_nao_anÏ* @evklkap]jkranokÚj]h6Îiaq_kn]k_nao_aÏ$]qiajp]iaqlk`an`amqanana`a b]van%j]_kil]jde]`kokqpnko(kqoaf](iq`](oapn]jobkni](]lnaj`aj`k(Î]hejcq]cai _kimqakodkiajooa_kiqje_]iÏ(eopk(oq]o`knao(oaqookbneiajpko(oq]o^]p]hd]oaoq]o aolan]j]o*Okiajpapaj`k_kjp]pk_kikiqj`k(_kjda_aj`koaqoheiepaoaoq]o]^anpqn]o l]n]kolkooraeomqajkoo]he^an`]`alk`anat_h]i]n6Îêre`]bqpqn]j opa_ne]naikoÏ*
Jkokikohernao]lao]n`kiqj`k(i]ocn]]o]aha Aoo] iaoi] _kj_alk `] he^an`]`a _kik lkooe^ehe`]`a k^faper] ejo_nep] jk iqj`k aj_kjpn]ikojkÚh okbkIanha]q)Lkjpu(mq]j`kao_nara6
0.-
K^p`bo ) pfjriq^kb^jbkqb) k^p`bo al jrkal b k^p`bo m^o^ l jrkal+ Pl_ l mof* jbfol^pmb`ql)ljrkalgbpq`lkpqfqralbpljlpplif`fq^alpmlobib+Pl_lpbdrkal ^pmb`ql)ljrkalklbpqfkqbfo^jbkqb`lkpqfqralbbpq^jlp^_boqlp^rj^fkÛkfa^* ababmlppsbfp+Bufpqfjlp)mloj)pl_lpalfp^pmb`qlp^ljbpjlqbjml+Kle)mlfp) kb`bppfa^ab^_plirq^kbjbp`lie^^_plirq^)g^j^fpplr`ljlrj^`lfp^bg^j^fpplr rj^mro^`lkp`fk`f^%+++&+>pfqr^ lsbjbjpl`loola^ab`fplb)klfkqbo` j_flbkqob ^pfqr^ lb^nrbibnrb^^pprjb)fjmlppsbiabifjfq^o^Ïm^oqbnrb`^_b pfqr^ lÐb ^Ïm^oqbnrb`^_b if_boa^abÐ+ Qloqro^*pbrjeljbjm^o^c^w*ilc^i^o+Pbbibob`rp^a^okljbpbbkabob lpnrb iebnrbobj^oo^k`^o)klmlopr^ab`fplplifqof^bpbj^mlflpkljrkal+nrbbibpb pbkqb^fka^`ljpbrp`ljm^kebfolpb^fka^bkd^g^alkrj^irq^`ljrj8lrmlonrb) abpabejbpbplr^klp)qbjbkcobkq^albpq^molsl`^ lbjmbkp^jbkqlbkbi^^mlpq^* o^qla^pr^sfa^8lr)bkÛj)mlonrbbibnrbomols^o)riqo^m^pp^kal*^)lnrbbibpbjmob mbkplrbafppbpl_ob^if_boa^ab+ Q^fpjlqfs^ bpkl^kri^j^if_boa^ab)j^piebal^k`lo^alrolklpbo+Bibkl rj^`lkp`fk`f^kr^nrbobpfpqb alo)j^plmofpflkbfol`ljpbrp`ljm^kebfolp)lr `lj^nrbibpnrb^j^bpl_`rgllie^obibsfsb)lr)bkÛj)^`lkp`fk`f^lodrielp^jbkqb plifqof^nrb)^fka^)rjjlalabbpq^o`ljlplrqolp%+++&+Bp`liebjlpklppljrkalb klppljrkalklpbp`lieb%+++&+ @lk`obq^jbkqbqlj^a^)^if_boa^abpbjmoblbk`lkqolabklpplfkqboflo`ljl buqboflo)abdo^a^kal*pb)pbjkrk`^qlok^o*pbkri^) jbafa^nrbafjfkrf^qlibo k`f^ alpa^alp`lomlo^fpbfkpqfqr`flk^fpabklpp^sfa^+Erj`^jmlabif_boa^abbrj^ Ïif_boa^ab`lkaf`flk^a^Ð)mlonrbqbkelmlppf_fifa^abpmoufj^pbafpq^kqbp+++ >bp`lie^absfa^nrbc^wbjlpqbjpbjmobird^opl_ob^_^pbabpfqr^ bpa^a^pb mlppf_fifa^abp^_boq^p+Jfke^if_boa^abmlababpsf^ojfke^sfa^alpbkqfalbpmlkq kbl nrbqbof^)j^plc^wabpifw^kalpl_obbpqbpbkqfal)bpmlp^kal*lfkf`f^ijbkqbm^o^abmlfp ^c^pq^o*pbabib)bklmlorj^`of^ l^_plirq^%+++&+ Plrrj^bpqorqro^mpf`lidf`^befpqof`^+Ob`b_frj^j^kbfo^abbufpqfo)rjbpqfilab bufpqk`f^+Qla^p^pjfke^p^ bpbjbrpmbkp^jbkqlpbpqlbjobi^ l`ljbpp^bpqorqr* o^+Klbkq^kql)plrifsob)kl^mbp^oafpqllr^nrjabpp^pjlqfs^ bp)j^pmlojbflabi^p) plbi^pnrbjbc^wbj`ljrkf`^o`ljjfke^sfa^)`ljljrkalb`ljjfke^if_boa^ab+
%RICß4RAVERS0ASCALß,Eß&LOCHEPA#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
I]jebaop]jpao`a _kiqje`]`ao`a eiecn]jpao`aL]neo ]pae]ibkckai _]nnkoaijkrai) ^nk`a.,,1(ai]pk _kjpn]]lkhpe_]`k ckranjkbn]j_o*
= he^an`]`a ] _]l]_e`]`a l]n] `]niko qi oajpe`k jkrk ]k mqa l]na_e] b]p]he`]`a( pn]jobkni]j`k ] oepq]k `a b]pk jqi] na]he`]`a jkr]( _ne]`] lkn jkoo] ]k* Aoo] bkn] pn]jobkni]`kn](mqapknj]na]hkmqaan]okiajpalkoorahamqaoa]_d]r]]laj]oh]pajpa _kiklkooe^ehe`]`a(kmqab]voqncenqi]k^n]`a]npa(qi]k^n]`alajo]iajpk(qi]]k danke_](qiikreiajpk]jpenn]_eop](qi]hqp]_kjpn]]`eo_neiej]koatq]hkq`a_h]ooa ok_e]h(qi]naoeopj_e]pen]je]a]rep ne]_kjpn]ah]* Klkoorahjklqn]_kjpejcj_e]kq]_]ok*Kja_aoonekjkb]p]he`]`a^nqp]*Klko) orahkmqaoaaj_kjpn]]^anpkjk_kn]k`kja_aoonekamqajkoo]he^an`]`a]c]nn]l]n] b]van)oahe^an`]`a*Jkook`aoafkajkoo]rkjp]`ajkokej_kj`e_ekj]`ko(i]oko_kj`e_ek) j]iajpkojkokk^op_qhkohe^an`]`aaoeikiaeklahkmq]hah]lk`aatan_an)oa* Oaj]o_aikojqi]ok_ea`]`amqajkoajoej]_anpkor]hknaoikn]eoÍfqope](ecq]h`]) `a(ran]_e`]`a(cajankoe`]`a(_kn]cai(]iev]`a(`enaepkbahe_e`]`aÍa(jkajp]jpk(eila`a ]_kj_napev]k`ahaolknmqaaopknc]jev]`]aaopnqpqn]`]`aik`k]eila`e)hko(kna_k) jda_eiajpk`]_kjpn]`ekajpnake`a]ha]na]he`]`aklneiaenkikiajpk`]he^an`]`a a`]re`]pe_]_kikna_qo]`]rekhj_e]*Koacqj`kikiajpk]^qo_]`]o^na_d]olah]o mq]eolkoo]l]oo]nklkoorah(eopk(qi]kqpn]ok_ea`]`amqa_kj_napevajkna]h]mqehkmqa ]jkoo]lnkl ajke`a]h* Aooaoacqj`kikiajpkej`]c]oaqilkoorahateopaaoapaikoklk`anl]n]pknj)hk na]h(eopk(oapaiko_kikl]oo]n`]Îlaj]`areranÏa`]Înrknaieh]cnko]Ï]qi]bahe_e`]`a mqa(ajÚi(aopaf]kj`aj oaop]iko* Kpan_aenkikiajpkk`]jkoo]`a_eok`a]cena`]ao_khd]`koiaekol]n]]]k* Khpeikikiajpk`]he^an`]`a]na]hev]k`]]kl]n]pn]jobkni]nqilkoorah jqina]h(qi]lkooe^ehe`]`ajqi]na]he`]`a* Aeolknmqaklkap]FkoL]qhkL]aoejpnk`qvkÎi]okleknÏaioaqlkai]*@ab]pk(] pknjaen]aopoa_](i]okleknjkpanoa`a(eopk(jk]cenl]n]mqa]cq]lkoo]_knnanlah] pknjaen]*@ab]pk(]hqvaop]l]c]`](i]okleknckop]n`kao_qnk(eopk(jk]cenl]n]mqa ]hqvlkoo]]_aj`an)oa*@ab]pk(]lknp]aoppn]j_]`](i]oklekno]^anmqa]_d]raaop`k h]`k`a`ajpnkaj]`]b]vanl]n]cen)h]*Kiqj`kfaop_kjopepq`k(ao_naraIanha]q)Lkjpu Í]pknjaen]aopoa_](]hqv]l]c]`]a]lknp]ba_d]`]*Lkni(kiqj`k(lnkooacqakÚh okbk( jkaop_kilhap]iajpa_kjopepq`k(jkaoplnkjpka]_]^]`k(i]o(_kikao_nara?]nhko @nqiikj`(Îkcn]j`aiqj`kaop_nao_aj`kpk`koko`e]oÏlahkbkcka]ikn`kooanaodq) i]jko(akleknoane]najqj_e]n]ahalknaop]nikojaha*
0..
=he^an`]`ax#!0É45,/ßx
!LBUM!KG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
Re`]aiknpa
R
3oNECAßßA#¯ßD# ß FILvSOFOßROMANO
e`]aiknpajkok(l]n]j odqi]jko(oeilhao]_kjpa_eiajpko^ekh ce_ko*?kik `eooaqiÚh okbk(]o_keo]o]l]na_aia`ao]l]na_ai(ko]jei]eo_kia]ia]_]^]i( okiajpakoandqi]jkreraaiknna(eopk(bufpqb*Re`]aiknpaok^`lkqb`fjbkqlp pfj_if`lp(okoecjeÚ_] ao(lkooqaioajpe`kab]vaioajpe`k* Reranaiknnanok]`ao_k^anp]`]Újepq`adqi]j](`ajkoo]pailkn]he`]`aa`ajkoo] e`ajpe`]`a6qi]re`]jfke^ajfke^(]iknpa*Aop](aokiajpaah](_kilhap]kmqaokiko( `evaj`kkmqabkiko*Lkneook(koÚh okbkoaopke_kolnklqjd]imqaokiajpa]l o]iknpa( mq]j`kpaniej]i]ore_eooepq`ao`]re`](lk`aiko]Úni]nmqa]hcqibkebahevkqejbahev* ÎMqaijkokq^aniknnan^aipanrere`ki]hÏ(]Únikqkaopke_kOja_]*Ajmq]jpkrerko( okikopailkaiq`]j](bpq^jlppbkal*KoÚh okbkoateopaj_e]heop]o`eooan]i6Î]ateopj) _e]lna_a`a]aooj_e]Ï(oecjeÚ_]j`k_kieookmqajkoo]aooj_e]]ojpaoaÚj]h`kpk`k`a jkoo]ateopj_e]* Jqi`aoaqoajo]eko(Cfilplc^o^mobkabo^jloobo(Ikjp]ecjaao_nara6 Nr^inrbonrbpbg^^aro^ labklpp^sfa^)bi^`ljmibq^+Pr^rqfifa^abklobpfabk^ nr^kqfa^ababaro^ lbpfjklbjmobdlnrbieba^fp+Enrbjsfsbrjrfqlbklsfsbr+ Jbafq^fpl_obfpplbknr^kqllmlabfpc^wbo)mlfpabmbkababsp)bklalk jbol ab^klp)qboabpsfsfal_^pq^kqb+ A_kj_hqe6 Jbafq^opl_ob^jloqbjbafq^opl_ob^if_boa^ab8nrbj^mobkabr^jloobo)abp^* mobkabrabpbosfo8kbkerjj^i^qfkdfonrbjk^bufpqk`f^`ljmobbkabrnrb^mofs^* la^sfa^klrjj^i8p^_bojlooboklpbufjbabqla^prgbf lb`l^ l+ Iknnanqi]pkokhepnek*Iknna)oao 6]aooj_e]`]iknpa]okhe`k*Kiknpkl]npa okvejdk7korerkoÚ_]iokvejdko]klan`)hk*Naop]o]q`]`aana_kn`]k* Reranaop]n_kikokqpnko*Rera)oa_kikqpnai6]aooj_e]`]re`]]ejpan_knlknae`]) `aa]ejpanoq^fapere`]`a* Korerkoaopkajpnah]]`ko6aop]iko_kikokqpnkoaahaoaopk_kjko_k(okikol]n]ko kqpnkoaahaookl]n]j o*Jkajo]ekLÛiplclbpr^plj_o^(Ianha]q)Lkjpujko`ev6 AbÏjloob*pbpÐm^o^Ïsfsb*pbpÐ^`lkpbnrk`f^klbu^q^)mlfppb^mbk^p^alo b^jloqbclobjfksl`^a^pm^o^abÛkfo^pr_gbqfsfa^ab)bkql)m^o^bi^)^sfa^`ljlr* qolpbkljrkalpbolfjmlppsbfp+++Bpq^jlpsboa^abfo^jbkqbpp^mbk^pnr^kalkl l p^_bjlp+ Bpp^ fdklo k`f^ ^ plifal %+++&+ > plifal ab lkab bjbodfjlp m^o^ ^ sfa^ fkqbopr_gbqfs^^mbk^p^ksl^abrj^sfa^^kkfj^b^_^oobfo^nrbklppbm^o^alp lrqolpfjm^imsbi+ =pe_]kiqj`k`]onah] aoejpanoq^faper]o(eopk(ajpnakaqakkqpnk_kikoqfaepko a laook]o( lknp]jpk( _kik oanao _kjo_eajpao( hernao a naolkjoraeo* Jajdqi] atlanej_e] are`aj_e]p]jpk]`eiajokaooaj_e]hiajpaejpanoq^faper]`]re`]a`]re`]pe_]mq]jpk] `k`ehkck*Kq]iko]ej`]qi]ravIanha]q)Lkjpu6
0./
K^ bumbofk`f^ al afildl) `lkpqfqrf*pb bkqob jfj b l lrqol rj qboobkl `ljrj) jbrmbkp^jbkqlblabibcloj^jrjpqb`fal)jfke^pc^i^pb^pabibplfksl`^a^p mbi^fkqboil`r l)fkpbobj*pbkrj^lmbo^ l`ljrja^nr^ikbkerjabkpl`of^* alo+Erjbkqob*alfp)brbllrqolpljlp`li^_lo^alobp)krj^ob`fmol`fa^abmbocbfq^) `lbufpqfjlpkljbpjljrkal+Klafildl)Û`lif_bo^alabjfjjbpjl)lpmbkp^jbk* qlpablrqobjplabibjbpjl)klplrbrnrbjlpclojl)bj_lo^brlp^mobka^ql ildlk^p ^jbjbpjljb^kqb`fmb^bibp)^ppfj`ljl^pl_gb bpablrqobj^oo^k`^j abjfjmbkp^jbkqlpnrbbrklp^_f^mlpprfo)abq^ijlalnrb)pbiebbjmobpqlmbkp^* jbkqlp)bjqol`^bibjbc^wmbkp^o+Pljbkqbabmlfp)nr^kalÛ`lplwfkelbjbob`loal
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
alafildl)c^wbkalabpqbrjbmfpaflabjfke^sfa^mofs^a^plifqof^)nr^kallrqobj qloklr*pb ^mbk^p rj^ ^rpk`f^) nrb mlppl) q^isbw) pbkqf*il `ljl rj^ ^jb^ ^) mlfp abp^m^ob`br^ob`fmol`fa^abnrbklpobi^`flk^s^k^`lk`loa k`f^bk^afp`loa k`f^+ Lknmqa]re`]ejpanoq^fapere`]`a_knlkn]halomqe_](alknmqa]re`]pe_]na_elnk) _e`]`aajpnaoqfaepko(p]jpkoÚh okbko`an]i]iev]`akhqc]n`arenpq`alnkaiejajpa(at) lnaook`ki]eo]hpke`a]h`afqope]*Jqiajo]ek(Afp`ropla^pbosfalslirkqof^(lnk_qn]j) `k_kilnaaj`anlknmqakodkiajonajqj_e]ihe^an`]`aarkhqjp]ne]iajpaoanrai]ko pen]jko(kÚh okbkH]>kpea_kjpn]lo]]iev]`aoanre`krkhqjpne](ao_naraj`k6 @boq^jbkqb)lqfo^klkrk`^^j^kbj^j^al+>^jfw^abkljbp^do^al)`lfp^ p^kq^7 p mlab bufpqfo bkqob dbkqb ab _bj) k^p`b a^ j qr^ bpqfj^ b pb `lkpbos^ kl q^kqlmlojbflab_bkbc`flp)j^pmbi^sfa^_l^bmbilp`lpqrjbp_lkp+Lnrbqlok^rj ^jfdlpbdrolablrqol^pr^fkqbdofa^ab+@ljld^o^kqf^p)qbjpbr_ljk^qro^i)pr^ Ûabifa^ab)pr^`lkpq k`f^+Klmlabe^sbo^jfw^ablkabe`orbia^abbfkgrpqf ^+Bkqob lpj^rp)nr^kalpbgrkq^j)erj^`lkpmfo^ l)klpl`fba^ab+Klpb^mlf^jjrqr^* jbkqb)j^pqbjbj*pbjrqr^jbkqb+Klpl^jfdlp)pl` jmif`bp+ =ooeip]i^iAolejko]]Úni]mqakoandqi]jki]eohernaj]_kil]jde]`kokq) pnko`kmqaj]okhe`kamqaÎokiajpakooanaodqi]jkohernaookcn]pkoana_kjda_e`koqjo ]kokqpnkoÏ(lknmqakooqfaepkohernaook]mqahaomqaÎjqj_]]cai_kibn]q`a(i]ooailna `a^k])bÏ*
#APqTULOß pe_]a_e j_e]
=ilhe]j`kk_]ilk`klkoorah
=
_]^]iko`aran]nah]kajpnahe^an`]`aalkooe^ehe`]`a*Reikop]i^imqa(`ao`a =neop pahao(]pe_]`aheiepkqk_]ilk`]]kdqi]j]o_keo]oa]ko]_kjpa_eiaj) pkomqaaopkaijkooklk`an(`eopejcqej`k(`aqih]`k(kkb`bppoflak`lkqfkdbkqb $mqajkaopkaijkooklk`an%a(`akqpnk(kmlppsbi$mqaaopaijkooklk`anna]hev]n%* Reiko(ajÚi(mqakja_aoonekpaj`aq]e`ajpeÚ_]n)oa_kikmqa]_kjpa_alknj]pqnav]kq oacqj`k]ohaeoj]pqn]eo(ok^na]omq]eoj]`]lk`aiko(amqaklkoorahbkee`ajpeÚ_]`k]k mqa]_kjpa_alknhe^an`]`a* Jk ajp]jpk( mq]j`k aopq`]iko ] _ej_e] a ] pa_jkhkce] _kjpailkn ja]o( reiko mqa `aetkq`aoanare`ajpa]e`ae]`amqa]j]pqnav]qi]bkn]mqa(k^a`a_aj`kooq]oln ) lne]ohaeoja_aoone]o(naoeopa]kjkooklk`an*Lahk_kjpnnek(ko]^an_eajpÚ_k)pa_jkh ce_k l]na_a`kiej]n]obkn]oj]pqn]eo`aik`k_]`]ravi]eo]ilhka_nao_ajpa(oaf]lah]_]) l]_e`]`a`alnaranko]_kjpa_eiajpkoj]pqn]eo(oaf]lkniaek`aejpanraj aomqaiq`]i k ln lnek _qnok `] j]pqnav]* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( k _]ilk `k ja_aoonek l]na_a _]`] rav iajknak_]ilk`klkoorah(_]`]ravi]ekn*
0.0
pe_]a_ej_e]x#!0É45,/ßx
Reiko p]i^i mqa ] _ej_e] k^pi _kjda_eiajpko _nao_ajpao a `aoraj`] oacna`ko j]pqn]eolknmqa`ere`aoeopai]pe_]iajpa]j]pqnav]ai_]ilko`ak^fapko$boe_ko(mqie) _ko( ^ekh ce_ko( ]opnkjie_ko( ap_*% mqa( lkn oq] rav( ok jkr]iajpa `ere`e`ko ai k^fapko _]`]ravi]eol]n_e]eo(aopq`]`koai_kj`e ao_qe`]`ko]iajpa_kjpnkh]`]o*=aooanaolae) pk(ko_eajpeop]o@]re`OqvqgeaLapanGjq`opkj(jqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]Dbkqf`^Î@lkÜfqlp bkqob^bkdbke^of^dbkqf`^blps^ilobperj^klp(ao_narai6 %+++& ^p bumif`^ bp `fbkqÛ`^p al jrkal k^qro^i pl kb`bpp^of^jbkqb co^djbkq* of^p)mlfp^`fk`f^bpq`lkabk^a^^sbo^k^qrobw^`ljlrjjlp^f`labm^oqbp`lj* mlkbkqbp)^o_fqo^of^jbkqbabÛkfa^p+Lpjqlalpa^`fk`f^plfk`^m^wbpab^_^o`^o^ abpirj_o^kqb`ljmibufa^aba^qlq^ifa^abalppfpqbj^pÎnrbopbqo^qbab`iri^psfs^p) ab`ob_olpmbkp^kqbp)nrboabb`lppfpqbj^p^rqlpprpqbkq^alpa^Ülobpq^qolmf`^i+ Pn]^]hd]j`k_kiaok^na]ol]npao(ko_eajpeop]olk`ai_kilnaaj`anbn]ciajpko`ko oeopai]oj]pqn]eo(i]ojk]pkp]he`]`a`]j]pqnav]*?kik_kjoamqj_e](lk`ai`aoajrkh) ranp_je_]omqa_kjpnkh]i]hcqi]o`]ol]npao(i]omqalk`ai]bap]nkpk`k`ai]jaen] eilnareorah*Kqoaf](]o] aop_je_]olk`ai_kjoacqenabaepkor]jp]fkokook^na_anpkooa) pknao`]j]pqnav]jk_qnpkln]vk(i]o(jkhkjckln]vkal]n]kqpnkooapknao`]j]pqnav]kq l]n] ] j]pqnav] _kik qi pk`k( p]eo ] ao lk`ai narah]n)oa lnafq`e_e]eo( qi] rav mqa ko _eajpeop]ojklk`ailnarankoabaepkobqpqnko`]o]lhe_] ao_eajpÚ_]ook^na]ook_ea`]`ao aok^nakoa_kooeopai]o*@evaiko`keo]qpknao6 Bj jrfqlp `^plp) l ofqjl ^`bibo^al ab ^s^k lp `fbkqÛ`lp b qb`klidf`lp oljmbr klpplbnrfi_ofl`ljljrkalk^qro^i+>qb`klildf^alqlr^bpm`fberj^k^abrjbnrf* s^ibkqbjb` kf`la^mlqk`f^jrp`ri^onrbbu`babbjjrfql^abnr^inrbolrqo^bpm`fb nrbqbke^e^_fq^al^Qboo^+Abr*klplpob`roplpm^o^klpjriqfmif`^ojlpbklp`lksboqbo* jlpk^pmlmri^ bpj^fpkrjbolp^pabj^jcbolpa^Qboo^+Brj^do^kabnr^kqfa^ab ab^qfsfa^abperj^k^p%abpab^^dof`riqro^`ljbo`f^i^q^`lj_rpqlalmbqoiblbal `^osl&^iqbolr^c^`babklpplmi^kbq^abj^kbfo^sfpsbialbpm^ lbuqboflo+
=cajpe_]akolnk^hai]ope_ko
R
0.1
eiko( jk Új]h `k ?]lpqhk 3( mqa( l]n] ko dqi]jko( re`] a iknpa jk ok ]laj]o ]_kjpa_eiajpko ^ekh ce_ko( i]o oei^ he_ko* Lkn eook iaoik( `ao`a ko ia]`ko `k o_qhkTT(kcn]j`a`aoajrkhreiajpk`aqi]_ej_e]`enap]iajpahec]`]re`](] caj pe_](l]ookq]paneilhe_] aope_]oiqepkoecjeÚ_]per]o* @ab]pk(k_]ok`]dbkqf`^a`]bkdbke^of^dbkqf`^(]l]npen`koaopq`ko`kocajaoa`k oqnceiajpk`]opa_jkhkce]ocje_]o(`qlh]iajpaeilknp]jpal]n]j olknmqa(_kikat) lhe_]iOqvqgeaGjq`opkj(]dbkqf`^jlabok^_kjbaneq]kooanaodqi]jkoqicn]j`alk) `anok^na]dana`ep]nea`]`a(pn]vaj`kp_je_]ol]n]_kjda_ankocajao`]oaol_eaoracap]eo a]jei]eo(l]n]`a_ebn]n]oiajo]cajomqie_]o_ebn]`]o`]oikh_qh]ocje_]oa]pl]n] ik`eÚ_]ncaj pelkoej`ere`q]eo*Pioe`kajkniaoko^ajab_eko`aooao_kjda_eiajpkoj] ia`e_ej](j]ej`opne](j]]cne_qhpqn](ik`eÚ_]j`k]reokmqakdkiailkooq]`aoaq hqc]nj]j]pqnav]ÍahajkkÎnae`]?ne]kÏ(i]oqiahkj]iehaj]nahkjcqooei]_]`ae] `]re`]Íaj]ln lne]`aÚjek`kmqaqioandqi]jk* =_flildf^jlib`ri^o(`ao_k^nej`k]knecai`]re`](]^]hkqko]he_an_ao`koiepko(`]o nahece ao(`]o]^a`kne]pn]`e_ekj]ha`kor]hknaodqi]jko*Lkneookiaoik(oqcanamqaop ao oailna_a`ajpaol]n]]pe_](]_kia]nlahkb]pk`amqa(j]ok_ea`]`a_kjpailkn ja](] laomqeo]_eajpÚ_k)pa_jkh ce_]aoq]o]lhe_] aojk`alaj`ai`]rkjp]`aa`]`a_eok`a ej`er`qkoaoei`]ocn]j`ao_knlkn] aoailnao]ne]eoa`]oejopepqe aoiehep]nao$k`lj* mibuljfifq^o*fkarpqof^i(`amqab]h]iko]kaopq`]n]_ej_e]a]p_je_]%(mqalkooqaiko na_qnokoa]lan_e]p_je_]ja_aoonekol]n]oa]lnkraep]n`]ojkr]olaomqeo]oa`]ojkr]o
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
pa_jkhkce]o*Aireop]`k]qiajpk`khq_nka`klk`anekiehep]n(]lnklne]i)oalner]`]iaj) pa`konaoqhp]`ko_eajpÚ_k)pa_jkh ce_ko(i]jpe`ko_kikoacna`ko(a(oailnaop]n_kjp]o] jejcqi(pki]i`a_eo aomqa]bap]ipk`]o]obkni]o`are`]`klh]jap]* Aoo]o`a_eo aoajrkhraiejiankolnk^hai]o(`komq]eor]iko]mqe`aop]_]n`keo6 -*
^obpmlkp^_fifa^abjlo^iblpifjfqbpal`lkeb`fjbkqldbkqf`l`lkqbjmlo kbl6
Ko_kjda_eiajpko`aoajrkhre`kojaoo]na]`ko]^an(]ej`]mqaeiajokoa_eajpeÚ_]) iajpanarkhq_ekjneko(ok]ej`]iqepklamqajkoaej_anpko*Jkajp]jpk(lna_elep]`]iajpa( f pi lnkle_e]`k ] ao ok^na aol_eao racap]eo a ]jei]eo a ok^na k dkiai( oai mqa oa lkoo]lnarankoabaepkobqpqnko`aoo]oejpanraj ao* K_d]i]`k_]ok`]Î`kaj]`]^khd]Ïlk`aoanren`aatailhk]mqe*Komqaokbnai`ao) o]`kaj]lkooqaicn]raolnk^hai]oeiqjkh ce_ko(eopk(oaqknc]jeoikjklnk`qvch ) ^qhko^n]j_komqaoenr]i`a]jpe_knlkomqaklnkpaf]`a]cnaoo ao`kiaek]i^eajpa*L]n] _kjoanr]naire`]aoo]olaook]o(ah]ook_kjÚj]`]o`ao`akj]o_eiajpkai]i^eajpao`a ]ooaloe]lanbaep]a_kilhap]$]Î^khd]Ï%ajkajpn]iai_kjp]pk`enapk_kijajdqi]kqpn] bkni]`are`](jaiiaoikdqi]j]*Paioe`k_kjoe`an]`kqioq_aookqiatlaneiajpk cajpe_kna]hev]`kl]n]]hpan]n]o_hqh]o`]o_ne]j]oj]o_e`]o_kiaooapannrahlnk^hai]( `ai]jaen]mqalkoo]ib]^ne_]nkoch ^qhko^n]j_kokqhaq_ _epkoahar]nqi]re`]jkni]h* Ejbaheviajpa(]hcqi]o`aoo]o_ne]j]o]ckn]aopkiknnaj`klahklnk^hai]_kjpnnek(eopk (lknhaq_aie]kqb]^ne_]kat_aooer]`ahaq_ _epko* Kkqpnkatailhkk`k_d]i]`kÎiehdkpn]jocje_kÏ(eopk(]]hpan]kcajpe_]l]n] ]k^pajk`aqi]aol_ea`aiehdkmqanaoeopa]ln]c]oa`ai]eolnk^hai]o]i^eajp]eo*= `ebqok`]lnk`qk]npeÚ_e]h`aoo]je_]aol_eapaihar]`k]k]^]j`kjk`]oiqep]okqpn]o r]nea`]`aoj]pqn]eo`aiehdk(lkeo(`klkjpk`areop]`kian_]`k(okiajkohq_n]per]o`k mqa]mqah]mqal]na_anaoeopajpa]pk`kokoi]hao*=hi`ko`aoamqeh^neko`koa_kooeopai]o `]onace aoaimqa]okqpn]oaol_eao`aiehdk`aet]n]i`aoan_qhper]`]oa`koneo_ko`aie) one]jaoo]onace aomqaoapknj]n]ieilnk`qper]o(]ej`]lk`aikolanbaep]iajpaoqlknmqa j]`]eila`amqaqilnk^hai]]i^eajp]hjkrk]l]na]a`aopnq]oq^ep]iajpa]aol_eaje) _]`aiehdk*?kik]okqpn]oaol_eaobkn]i]^]j`kj]`]o(pank`ao]l]na_e`kalk`a]_kjpa) _anmqa(qi`e](kiehdk`ao]l]na]`]b]_a`]Pann]a_kiahaka_kooeopai]ajrkhre`k* Paj`kaireop]]lnkheban]k`koracap]eopn]jocje_ko$_kikk_]ok`]okf]a`]h]n]j) f](ajpnakqpnko%ak]^]j`kjk`]^ek`eranoe`]`aj]pqn]hailnkraepk`aaol_eaoje_]o(jk lk`aiko`aet]n`ahar]jp]n]del paoa`a]hpan] ao]i^eajp]eomqalnkrkmqai]atpejk `arne]o`aoo]oaol_eaoje_]o_kiabaepkocec]jpao_kojkokiajpaok^na]re`]dqi]j] $bkia(ieone](`kaj]o(iknpao%(i]ook^napk`kklh]jap]* ?kik`evaiOqvqgeaGjq`opkj6 Bpq^jlp qbkq^kal bumilo^o `lkeb`fjbkqlp ob`j*^anrfofalp pbj qbo) cobnrbkqb* jbkqb)^j^fps^d^fabf^^`bo`^a^p`lkpbnrk`f^p^ilkdlmo^wlabklpp^pqb`klildf^p+ Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]]lhe_]k`ko_kjda_eiajpkolk`aaop]nbanej`kklnej_lekpe_k `]naolkjo]^ehe`]`a* .*
^idrj^pnrbpqbpqf`^ppl_obl`lkqoliba^ebobafq^ofba^ab6
=o]lhe_] ao`]opa_jkhkce]ocje_]okq]ajcajd]ne]cajpe_]_khk_]ilnk^hai]ope) _ko`acn]j`aajranc]`qn]mqajklk`aioanecjkn]`ko(ok^napq`k]l]npen`kikiajpk aimqaoal]ookq]oamqaj_e]nkcajki]dqi]jk*@ab]pk(ko_eajpeop]omqalnapaj`aioa) mqaj_e]nkcajki]dqi]jk]_na`ep]i_dac]n]qi_kjda_eiajpkmqajkoherna`a`knaoa okbneiajpko(_qna`kaj]o(lnkhkjcqa]fqrajpq`aa]`ea]iknpa(cn]]o]k]lanbaek]iaj) pk`]ln lne]aol_eadqi]j]_kik_kjpnkhaok^na]dana`ep]nea`]`a$kb]ikok=@J(mqa _kopqi]oaniaj_ekj]`kalklqh]nev]`kj]oq]bkni]aiejcho(eopk(@J=%* Qi`kolnk^hai]ope_koi]eocn]raopn]ve`kolah]cajpe_]aj_kjpn])oaj]_d]i]`] Îokj`]caicje_]Ï(lkniaek`]mq]hoalnapaj`a`apa_p]n(lknatailhk(laook]omqapane]i
GENOMAßHUMANOßß CONJUNTOßDEßCROMOSSOMOSßß QUEßCONToMßOSßGENESßQUEß OSßASCENDENTESßTRANSMI TEMßAOSßSEUSßDESCENDEN TESßAOßLONGOßDAßHISTvRIAß DEßUMAßESPmCIE $.!ßfCIDOßDESOXIRRIBO NUCLEICO ßmßAßMOLmCULAß QUEßFORMAßAßDUPLAßHmLICEß PORTADORAßDOSßGENESßß bßAßMOLmCULAßHEREDITfRIAß PRINCIPALßNAßMAIORIAßß DASßESPmCIESß
0.2
pe_]a_ej_e]x#!0É45,/ßx
*ORGEß!RA{JO&OLHAß)MAGEM
cajaomqa]olna`eolkne]il]n]]_neiej]he`]`akq]omqapane]icajaomqa]olna`eolkne]i l]n]_anp]o`kaj]ohec]`]o]_anpkopelko`apn]^]hdk*Lkneook(p]eolaook]ojk`arane]ioan ailnac]`]o*Aoo]olaook]ojko pane]ina_a^e`klkndana`ep]nea`]`a]Îpaj`j_e]]k_neiaÏ kq]Îej_]l]_e`]`al]n]qipn]^]hdkÏ(_kik]ej`]]opn]joiepene]i]kooaqo`ao_aj`ajpao* @aoo] i]jaen]( lkn qi] l]n]`kt]h ej) ranok(ajmq]jpk]_ej_e]lnapaj`a]b]op]nko k^op_qhko mqa ] eila`ai `a `kiej]n ] j]) pqnav]$`kijekmqalaniepene]k_kjpnkhadq) i]jkok^na]ja_aooe`]`aj]pqn]ha_khk_]ne] ln]pe_]iajpapq`kok^klk`andqi]jk%(]ca) jpe_]l]na_apn]van`arkhp]]orahd]oe`ae]o`a b]p]he`]`aa`a`aopejk$kq]e`ae]`amqaj]`] lk`aiko _kjpn] ] ja_aooe`]`a j]pqn]h%( lkeo k _neia a ] `kaj] l]oo]i ] oan pe`ko _kik abaepko ja_aooneko `a qi] _]qo]he`]`a j]pq) n]hja_aoone]Í]dana`ep]nea`]`a*@aoo]i]) jaen](lk`an)oa)e]]piaoikb]h]naiÎ`aopejk ^ekh ce_kÏ(pknj]j`kr]ve]o]oe`ae]o`ahe^an`]) `a( naolkjo]^ehe`]`a a ]qpk`apaniej]k `ko ej`er`qko* I]o jk o eook* = e`ae] `a qi oqlkopk Î`aopejk ^ekh ce_kÏ lk`a oan bkjpa `a rekhj) _e] a( lknp]jpk( ikn]hiajpa ej]_aeprah* @a b]pk( aoo] e`ae] lk`ane] ]_]nnap]n ] `eo_neie) j]kok_e]h`]olaook]omqaperaooaikooq) lkopkocajaoÎ_neiejkokoÏ(iaoikmqaf]i]eo pajd]i _kiape`k jajdqi _neia( kq cajao Î`kajpekol]n]koanrekÏ(iaoikmqapajd]i oe`koailnao]q`raeoapn]^]hd]`kn]o*Aaoo] `eo_neiej]klk`ane]c]jd]nlnklkn aoce) c]jpao_]o`arekhj_e]oaoal]oo]ooa]_kjoe) `an]nmqa(oaj`kp]eocajaodana`epneko(]paj) =cne_qhpknaomqaei]iokf]pn]jocje_] `j_e] _neiej]he`]`a kq ej_kilapj_e] `qn]jpai]jebaop]kjkoacqj`k`e] l]n]kpn]^]hdkoane]i_]n]_panope_]o^ekh ce) `]?KL)4$4·?kjbanj_e]`]oL]npao%(`] ?kjrajkok^na@eranoe`]`a>ekh ce_] _]o`kocnqlkook_e]eoaimqap]eoej`er`qko `]KJQ(ai?qnepe^](aii]nk`a.,,2* j]o_ai(reraialnk_ne]i(`aoknpamqa]`eo) _neiej]k]pejcene]cnqlkook_e]eoejpaenko* Kn](]e`ae]`aÎ`aopejk^ekh ce_kÏ_eajpeÚ_]iajpa]^oqn`]*?kikao_naraiOqvqgea Gjq`opkj6 Rj^jbo^ifpq^ab>AK%AK>&aldbklj^abrj^mbppl^mlabof^m^ob`bo^^idrkp rj^sfplmolcqf`^alcrqrolabpp^mbppl^+Klbkq^kql)lpdbkbpobmobpbkq^jpljbkqb rj^a^pafjbkpbpa^fabkqfa^ab_flidf`^abrj^mbppl^)fpql)^Ïk^qrobw^Ð_flildf* `^jbkqb eboa^a^) `ljmlkbkqb a^ bqbok^ bnr^ lÏk^qrobw^*`riqro^Ð) nrb pb bumofjb bjqla^`lfp^sfsbkqb+>l`bkqo^o*pbbu`irpfs^jbkqbbjc^qlobpebobafqoflp)^qjbp* jlrj^prmlpq^Ïplka^dbjdkf`^qlq^iÐal>AK%AK>&abrjfkafsarlmlablcbob`bo mlr`lj^fpalnrbrj^sfpljljbkq kb^a^pj iqfmi^pclo ^pnrbbkqo^jbjgldlkl abpbkslisfjbkqlabrj^sfa^erj^k^+ Qioacqj`klnk^hai](`aner]`k`k]jpanekn(pn]ve`klah]_d]i]`]Îpan]le]cje_] caniej]hÏ( eopk ( mqa ejpanri ai _hqh]o dqi]j]o `] nalnk`qk kq _hqh]o caniej]eo _ki]Új]he`]`a`a_qn]n`kaj]ocajpe_]okq_knnecenÎ`abaepkocajpe_koÏ*D]mqe`keo lnk^hai]ocn]rao(qi`ahaolnklne]iajpa_eajpÚ_kakkqpnk`enap]iajpaikn]h*
0.3
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
-*
mq]hmqan`kaj]cajpe_]o pai`aÚjeklnkreo ne](lkeoqicajamqaklan]lanbae) p]iajpaai_anp]o_kj`e ao`kiaek]i^eajpa(`]]heiajp]k(`k_hei](lk`aklan]n iajko o]peob]pkne]iajpa ai kqpn]o _kj`e ao a eook $mqa oane] pe`k _kik ] `kaj]% lk`aoanl]oo]caenk(^]op]j`knalkn]o_kj`e ao]`amq]`]ol]n]oaqbqj_ekj]iajpk7
.*
diq`]j]obnamqajpaoj]ooamqj_e]o`a=@J$@J=%(_]qo]j`kiqp] ao]ha]p ne]o( naolkjoraeolkn`kaj]o(oaimqaoalkoo]lnarankqÎ_knnecenÏp]eoiqp] aolknejpan) banj_e]j]o_hqh]onalnk`qpkn]o(qi]ravmqa]oiqp] aookeilnareoraeoa`alaj) `ai`aiqepkob]pknao7
/*
_]h_qh])oamqapk`koandqi]jklknp]`kn`a_ej_k]`avcajao`abaepqkokok_qhpko(`a i]jaen]mqap]jpkqiej`er`qklanbaep]iajpao]q`rahlk`aoandan`aenkapn]joieo) okn`aqi]`kaj]_kikp]i^i]ejpanrajkok^na_hqh]ocaniej]eo`aqiej`er) `qkcajape_]iajpa`kajpajkeila`a]_kjoanr]k`kocajao`abaepqkokok_qhpko*
Mq]hklnk^hai]ikn]h;K`]brdbkf^(eopk(]rahd]e`ae]`aÎlqnav]`]n]]Ïkq`alq) neÚ_]k`]aol_ea(aijkia`]mq]hjko oane]ibaep]oejpanraj aoaik`eÚ_] aoj]o _hqh]onalnk`qpkn]o(i]op]i^ioafqopeÚ_]ne]]aheiej]k`koÎeilqnkoÏkq`koÎejbanek) naoÏkq`koÎ`abaepqkokoÏ*Kn](mqai`aÚjaamqai`a_e`akmqaqioandqi]jkÎlanbaepkÏ; ?kimqa`enaepk]hcqjolk`ai`aÚjena`a_e`enok^nakmqaoane]qioandqi]jkoaieilan) bae aoaoai`abaepko;=atlanej_e]`kj]veoikjkoikopn]konaoqhp]`ko`ap]h`a_eok* =hi`eook(lanbaekaeilanbaekokr]hknao_qhpqn]eo(r]ne]j`k`aok_ea`]`al]n] ok_ea`]`aajk_knnan`]deop ne](jklk`aj`koan`aÚje`ko_ki^]oaaiqil]`nk^ek) h ce_kje_k(kmq]h(]heo(p]i^iqil]`nk_qhpqn]h*Mqaifhaqk^ahknki]j_a`a =h`kqoDqthau(>ajfosbijrkalklsl(d`aoahai^n]n`kpannrahlao]`ahkmqa]lna) pajok`alnk`qvenÎoanaodqi]jkolanbaepkoÏ(_]`]mq]h]`amq]`k]qi`apaniej]`kpelk `abqjkj]ok_ea`]`a* A(Új]hiajpa(]hi`kolnk^hai]ope_ko`arekhj_e]ajrkhre`kolah]oamqaj_e]k`k cajki]dqi]jk(dmqaiaj_ekj]nkqpnkabaepk`]ajcajd]ne]cajpe_]amqaoa]lnaoajp] _kik]rekhj_e]aioq]bkni]atpnai](]hckikn]halkhepe_]iajpaej]_aeprah6]lnk`qk `a]ni]o^ekh ce_]o(eopk(kqok`ahe^an]`k`aie_nknc]jeoiko$rnqo(^]_pne]o(bqjcko%kq `aoq^op j_e]op te_]ok^pe`]o`a_hqh]orer]o_kiklnkl oepk`ai]p]nkqej_]l]_ep]noa) naodqi]jko(]jei]eoalh]jp]o*Jqi]l]h]rn](kqokiehep]n`ko_kjda_eiajpkocajpe_ko*
!LBUM!KG IMAGES,ATISNTOCK
Mq]hklnk^hai]_eajpÚ_k;=ejpanrajkok^na_hqh]onalnk`qpkn]ol]n]_qn]n`kaj) ]ocajpe_]ojklk`aoanbaep]oaimqaoapajd]qi]_h]n]alanbaep]`aÚjek`kmqa ]`kaj]*Kn](]cajpe_]]ej`]jklkooqeaoo]`aÚjek*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(klnk^hai] lk`aoan]ooeinaoqie`k6
!LDOUSß(UXLEYßß ¯ ßESCRITORß INGLoS
Qi]^naranabhatk
K
olnk^hai]o]ooej]h]`kooecjeÚ_]ne]imqa`araiko(oqlanope_eko]ab]j]pe_]iajpa( jkoklknejraopec]kcajpe_];@aik`k]hcqi*Ko_kjda_eiajpkojkrkook^na ko cajao jko ]qtehe]nk ] _ki^]pan `kaj]o( okbneiajpko a `knao a ] iahdkn]n ] lnarajkakpn]p]iajpk`aiqep]o`aokn`ajocajpe_]o* =kiaoikpailk(lkni(kmqa`araikoalk`aikoatecennaolkjo]rahiajpa(`aqi h]`k(k`enaepkejbkni]kl^he_]_knnap]ok^na]olaomqeo]o(oq]oÚj]he`]`aoabkni]o`a ]lhe_]k$kqk_ki^]pa]koacna`k%a(`akqpnk(]_h]nav]mq]jpko_kjoamqj_e]o`a_qnpk ln]vkakoneo_ko`ahkjckln]vk*?kikao_naraiOqvqgeaGjq`opkj6 >`fk`f^b^qb`klildf^pllmolarqla^`roflpfa^aberj^k^)lfoobcobsbifjmri* pla^jbkqbm^o^`lkeb`bo)bumilo^o)jra^o+Babsbjlp^ifjbkq^obpp^nr^ifa^ab^qlal fkpq^kqb+ Mloj) q^j_j mob`fp^jlp ob`lkeb`bo nrb e ^ kb`bppfa^ab ab rj m^aol jlo^ibjnrb^`roflpfa^ab`fbkqÛ`^mlpp^bumofjfo*pbpbjbumlo^pmlmri^ bperj^* k^pbpbrp^j_fbkqbp^ofp`lpfk^`bfqsbfpba^klpfoobm^osbfp+
0.4
pe_]a_ej_e]x#!0É45,/ßx
=hcqjolna_aepko`]Cajpe_]
E
jpnk`qvej`k ] l]h]rn] Dbkqf`^( @]re` Oqvqge a Lapan Gjq`opkj lnklqoan]i qi _kj) fqjpk `a lna_aepko pe_ko _ki mqa ko _eajpeop]o a ko haecko kq ko jk aola_e]heop]o ai cajpe_] lk`ai fqhc]n a ]r]he]n ape_]iajpa ]o ]pere`]`ao a ko Újo `aoo] _ej_e] a `]o pa_jkhkce]oajrkhre`]olknah]* Aooaolna_aepkope_kolk`aioan]ooeinaoqie`ko6 -*
ja_aooe`]`a`amqaoa_kjda]lanbaep]iajpa]j]pqnav]`kocajao$knecajo(l]lahjko lnk_aookodana`epneko`]o_hqh]o(lkooe^ehe`]`ao`a_kjpnkh)hko%]jpao`aeje_e]nejpan) raj aocajpe_]o7
.*
arep]n a eila`en ] oeilheÚ_]k lanecko] mqa aop]^aha_a qi] nah]k _]qo]h ajpna ko _kilknp]iajpko`]olaook]oaoqlkopkoÎ`abaepkoÏjk@J=dqi]jk7
/*
]oejbkni] aocajpe_]ook^naqiej`er`qk`araioan_kjda_e`]olknahal]n]mqa lkoo]qo)h]ohernaiajpaajkl]n]mqahdaoaf]ieilkop]ook^]bkni]`anaopne ao( `eo_neiej] aoakqpnkolnafqvko7
0*
]opan]le]ocje_]omqaej_e`aiok^na]o_hqh]ocaniej]eokqnalnk`qpkn]odqi]j]o oaiejbkni]k`apk`]]ok_ea`]`aaoaik_kjoajpeiajpk`apk`]]ok_ea`]`a`arai oanatlhe_ep]iajpalnke^e`]o7
1*
k `aoajrkhreiajpk `a laomqeo]o a ] b]^ne_]k `a ]ni]o ^ekh ce_]o qi] ]lhe_]k ape_]iajpaej]_aeprah`]cajpe_]7
2*
kiaek]i^eajpa$n]eko`aOkh(n]`ek]pere`]`a(oq^op j_e]omqie_]o%lk`a_]qo]niqp]) aomqa]hpan]ikq`aopnkai]ejbkni]kcajpe_]_kjpe`]j]oikh_qh]ocajpe_]o7 _]`]qi`aj opaik`enaepk`ana_a^an]oejbkni] aook^na]o_kj`e ao`kiaek ]i^eajpaapan]naolkjo]^ehe`]`al]n]eila`enoq]`apanekn]kkql]n]iejkn]noaqo abaepkolnafq`e_e]eo7
3*
]pn]jobanj_e]`acajao`aqi]aol_eal]n]kqpn]`araoan_kjoe`an]`]vkj]`alaneck ajk`araoanna]hev]`]]pmqa]_ej_e]pajd]lanbaepk_kjda_eiajpk`k]h_]j_a`k ejpan_ i^ekcajpe_kajpnaaol_eao7
4*
]`eranoe`]`acajpe_]$kq]^ek`eranoe`]`a%p]jpkj]oaol_eaodqi]j]o_kikj]o]je) i]eoaracap]eoqina_qnoklh]japneklna_ekokmqa`araoanlnaoanr]`ka_kjpnkh]`k lknj o7]pkikiajpk(]oaol_eaopn]jocje_]ookqilaneckl]n]]^ek`eranoe`]`a lh]japne]al]n]]re`]7
5*
kiank]_iqhk`a_kjda_eiajpkocajpe_kojkc]n]jpa]o]^a`kne](]lnq`j_e]a] _knnak`ajkoo]o`a_eo aoajklk`aoanejrk_]`kl]n]_kjpnkh]nkooanaodqi]jko7
-,* mqaop aomqalna_eo]ioanlkop]oal]n]]omq]eo]ok_ea`]`alna_eo]^qo_]nnaolkop]o6 ]%
lk`a)oalaniepenmqaej`er`qkolner]`koaailnao]olner]`]opajd]i]lnklnea) `]`aat_hqoer]`]oejbkni] ao_kjpe`]ojkocajki]olnk`qve`kolah]ajcajd]) ne]cajpe_]$kopn]jocje_ko%;
^% lk`a)oalaniepenmqaailnao]o^ekpa_jkh ce_]ob]]i]lhe_] aocajpe_]o$okj) `]caicajpe_](pan]le]cajpe_](_hkj]cai(pn]jocje_ko(ap_*%paj`k_kikÚj]he) `]`a]laj]okhq_nka_qop]`a]ola_pkojkhq_n]perkomqapi]ran_ki]o]`a( ]]heiajp]k(kiaek]i^eajpa; _%
0.5
mqa lnak loe_kh ce_k( ikn]h( _qhpqn]h a lkhpe_k mqanaiko l]c]n oa `a_e`eniko ]lnkr]n k qok `]o pa_jkhkce]o cje_]o jk l]n] _aha^n]n ] `eranoe`]`a cajpe_] ateopajpaajpnakooanaodqi]jko(i]ol]n]eilknqi]`aÚjek]n^epnne]`kmqa oa`araajpaj`anlknÎoandqi]jkÏ;
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
#APqTULOß =re`]lkhpe_]
L]n]`ktko`]lkhpe_] Kornekoqokoaoajpe`ko`]l]h]rn]lkhpe_] Jkn]nkkqreniko`evanmqaÎhqc]n`aaopq`]jpaj]o]h]`a]qh]ajkj]nq]b]vaj) `kl]ooa]p]Ï(kqmqaÎaopq`]jpaaopq`](jkb]vlkhpe_]Ï*I]op]i^ikqreikok_kjpnnek( mq]j`k]hcqi]Úni]mqaÎkoaopq`]jpaoaopk]heaj]`ko(jkoaejpanaoo]ilknlkhpe_]Ï* Jklneiaenk_]ok(_kjoe`an])oa]lkhpe_]qi]]pere`]`aln lne]`a_anp]olaook]oaj_]nnac]) `]o`ab]v)h]$kolkhpe_kolnkÚooekj]eo%(ajmq]jpk(jkoacqj`k(_kjoe`an])oa]lkhpe_]qi ejpanaooaaiaoikqi]k^nec]k`apk`ko*=l]na_a]mqeqilneiaenkl]n]`ktk`]lkhpe_]6 ah]qi]]pere`]`aaola_Ú_]`a]hcqjolnkÚooekj]eo`]ok_ea`]`akq_kj_anja]pk`koj o( lknmqareraikoaiok_ea`]`a; ?kikoak^oanr](qo]iko]l]h]rn]mliqf`^kn]l]n]oecjeÚ_]nqi]]pere`]`aaola_Ú_] $kckranjk%(na]hev]`]lknqi_anpkpelk`alnkÚooekj]h$klkhpe_k%(kn]l]n]oecjeÚ_]nqi] ]k_khaper]$kikreiajpkaopq`]jpehj]onq]o(lknatailhk%`anaerej`e_]k`a]hcqi] _keo](baep]lkniai^nko`]ok_ea`]`aa`enece`]]kockranjkokq]kAop]`k*=Új]h(]lkhpe_] qi]lnkÚookajpnakqpn]okqqi]]kmqapk`kokoej`er`qkona]hev]imq]j`koa nah]_ekj]i_kiklk`an;=lkhpe_]oanabanao]pere`]`ao`ackranjkkq]pk`]]kok_e]h mqapajd]_kik]hrkkq_kikejpanhk_qpknkckranjkkqkAop]`k; Jkajp]jpk(lk`aikoqo]n]l]h]rn]mliqf`^]ej`]aikqpnkoajpe`k*@ab]pk(bnamqaj) paiajpaaj_kjpn]ikoatlnaoo ao_kikÎlkhpe_]qjeranoepne]Ï(Îlkhpe_]`]ao_kh]Ï(Îlkhpe_] `kdkolep]hÏ(Îlkhpe_]`]ailnao]Ï(Îlkhpe_]oej`e_]hÏ*Jaooa_kjfqjpk`aatlnaoo ao(fjk aj_kjpn]iko]nabanj_e]]kckranjkjai]lnkÚooekj]eo`]lkhpe_]* ÎLkhpe_]qjeranoepne]ÏaÎlkhpe_]`]ao_kh]Ïnabanai)oai]jaen]_kikqi]ejopepqek`a ajoejk$l^he_]kqlner]`]%`aÚjaoq]`enakakik`k`al]npe_el]kkqjk`alnkbaooknao aaopq`]jpaoaioq]caopk(]kik`k_kikkona_qnokooankailnac]`ko(]k_qnn_qhk(obkn) i]o`a]r]he]k`ko]hqjkoalnkbaooknao(]kpelk`alaook]mqaoanna_a^e`]_kikaopq`]jpa kq_kik`k_ajpa(_]nnaen]`ko`k_ajpao(]koo]hnekoa(oa]ejopepqekbknlner]`](]k_qopk `]oiajo]he`]`aoai]pn_qh]o(ap_*Aioajpe`kln teik]aooab]h])oa`aÎlkhpe_]`kdkolep]hÏ* FÎlkhpe_]`]ailnao]Ïnabana)oa]kik`k`aknc]jev]ka`ereok`alk`anaonah]perko]ko ejraopeiajpkoa]kohq_nko`aqi]ailnao](`eopne^qek`kooanreko(`ereok`kpn]^]hdk( o`a_eo aook^na]lnk`qka]`eopne^qek`kolnk`qpko(onah] ao_ki]okqpn]oailnao]o( ap_*ÎLkhpe_]`koej`e_]pkÏnabana)oai]jaen]`alnaaj_danko_]ncko`a`enakoej`e_]h(obkn) i]o`analnaoajp]kal]npe_el]k`kooej`e_]hev]`koj]`enak`koej`e_]pk(]ko_kjpa`ko aobkni]o`]onaerej`e_] aoahqp]o`kooej`e_]hev]`koaib]_a`akqpnkolk`anao(ap_* Lk`aiko(ajpk(ej`]c]n6]Új]h(kmqa]lkhpe_];]]pere`]`a`ackranjk;]]`ie) jeopn]k`kmqal^he_k;]lnkÚook`a]hcqjoaola_e]heop]o;]]k_khaper]nabane`] ]kockranjko;Kqpq`kmqaoanaÚn]knc]jev]kacaopk`aqi]ejopepqekl^he_] kqlner]`]; Mq]j`k]nabaneiko]kckranjk(]pere`]`a`a]hcqjolnkÚooekj]eoaonaerej`e_] ao _khaper]okqok_e]eo(qo]iko]l]h]rn]mliqf`^l]n]jkonalknp]niko]] aomqaajrkhrai lk`anao`a`a_eokaoana]hev]ij]obkni]oejopepq_ekj]hev]`]o$Aop]`k(l]npe`kolkhpe_ko( knc]jev] aooej`e_]eo%*
0/,
=re`]lkhpe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Mq]j`kjkonabaneiko]`iejeopn]kacaopk`aejopepqe aol^he_]okqlner]`]o(] l]h]rn]mliqf`^qo]`]l]n]ej`e_]nmqaknc]jev]nacanenqi]ejopepqekajrkhramqaop ao `alk`an*I]olk`aiko(]ckn](lancqjp]n6lkhpe_]`evnaolaepk]pq`kmq]jpkajrkhranah]) ao`alk`ankq]pq`kmq]jpkajrkhraknc]jev]ka]`iejeopn]k`acnqlko; ?kikranaikolkopanekniajpa(k_nao_eiajpk`]o]pne^qe ao_kjbane`]o]kockranjko( j]bkni]`kAop]`k(harkq]qi]]ilhe]k`k_]ilk`]o]pere`]`aolkhpe_]o(mqal]oo]) n]i]]^n]jcanmqaop ao]`iejeopn]per]oaknc]jev]_ekj]eo(`a_eo aoa_kjie_]oaoanreko ok_e]eo*Aoo]]ilhe]k`]o]pne^qe aoaop]p]eo]_]^kqoaaopaj`aj`kl]n]kqpn]oaoban]o`] re`]ok_e]h(har]j`k]qiqokcajan]hev]`k`]l]h]rn]mliqf`^l]n]nabanen)oa]pk`]ik`]he) `]`a`a`enak`acnqlkook_e]eomqaajrkhr]lk`an(]`iejeopn]kaknc]jev]k(p]jpkjk lh]jkl^he_kmq]jpkjklh]jklner]`k* Lk`aiko(ajpnap]jpk(`eopejcqenajpnaaooaqokcajan]hev]`kar]ck`]l]h]rn]mliqf`^a qikqpnk(i]eoaola_Ú_kalna_eok(mqa]l]na_amq]j`k`]iko]ah]pnooecjeÚ_]`kolnej) _el]eoejpan)nah]_ekj]`ko6 -*
koecjeÚ_]`k`ackranjk(ajpaj`e`k_kik`enaka]`iejeopn]k`klk`anl^he_k(j] bkni]`kAop]`k*Koajok_kiqiok_e]hpaj`a]e`ajpeÚ_]nckranjkaAop]`k(i]ockran) jkaAop]`kok`ebanajpao(lkeoklneiaenk`evnaolaepk]lnkcn]i]oalnkfapkomqaqi] l]npa`]ok_ea`]`alnkl al]n]kpk`kmqa]_kil a(ajmq]jpkkoacqj`kbkni]`k lknqi_kjfqjpk`aejopepqe aolani]jajpaomqalaniepai]]k`kockranjko*
-ARCELLOß#ASALß*R!GoNCIAß"RASIL
Qiatailhk`aik^ehev]klkhpe_]k Ikreiajpk`koPn]^]hd]`knaoNqn]eooaiPann]* J]bkpk(ejpacn]jpa`kikreiajpkqo]io_]n] `qn]jpai]jebaop]kj]Aolh]j]`]`ko Iejeopneko(ai>n]ohe](ai]ckopk`a.,,5*
.*
0/-
=k Aop]`k _kjbana)oa ]qpkne`]`a l]n] canenkannekkqbqj`kl^he_klkniaek`a eilkopko(p]t]oapne^qpko(l]n]lnkiqhc]na ]lhe_]n]ohaeomqa`aÚjaiko_kopqiaol) ^he_koh_epkoakoeh_epkokq_neiao(^ai_kik ko`enaepkoa]ok^nec] ao`koiai^nko`] ok_ea`]`a*P]i^ioana_kjda_a_kik]q) pkne`]`a`kAop]`kklk`anl]n]qo]n]bkn] $lkh_e]aatn_epk%_kjpn]]mqahaomqabknai _kjoe`an]`koejeiecko`]ok_ea`]`a$_neie) jkoko_kiqjoa_neiejkokolkhpe_ko%*?kj) bana)oa ecq]hiajpa ]k Aop]`k k lk`an l]n] `a_nap]n]cqann]a]l]v*Ateca)oa`koiai) ^nko`]ok_ea`]`ak^a`ej_e]]kAop]`k(i]o na_kjda_a)oak`enaepk`anaoeopj_e]a`a`a) ok^a`ej_e]mq]j`k]ok_ea`]`afqhc]kck) ranjkkqiaoikkAop]`kejfqopk(ehac]hkq ehacpeik* =lkhpe_](jaooalneiaenkoajpe`k(naba) na)oa( lknp]jpk( ]k `ko ckranj]jpao mqa lkooqai ] ]qpkne`]`a l]n] `enecen ] _khape) re`]`aknc]jev]`]aiAop]`k(^ai_kiko ] ao`]_khapere`]`aai]lkekkq_kjpnne]o ]qpkne`]`ackranj]iajp]haiaoikbkn) i]`kAop]`k7
koecjeÚ_]`k`a]pere`]`ana]hev]`]lknaola_e]heop]o$ko]`iejeopn]`knao%alnkÚooek) j]eo$kolkhpe_ko%(lanpaj_ajpao]qi_anpkpelk`aknc]jev]kok_eklkhpe_]$kol]npe) `ko%(mqa`eolqp]ik`enaepk`ackranj]n(k_ql]j`k_]nckoalkopkojkAop]`k*Jaooa oacqj`k oajpe`k( ] lkhpe_] ]l]na_a _kik ]hck `eop]jpa `] ok_ea`]`a( qi] rav mqa ]pere`]`a`aaola_e]heop]oalnkÚooekj]eomqaoak_ql]iat_hqoer]iajpa_kikAop]`ka klk`an*=lkhpe_]baep]ÎlknahaoÏajkÎlknj oÏ(]ej`]mqaÎahaoÏoa]lnaoajpai_kik nalnaoajp]jpaoÎjkookoÏ7
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
/*
koecjeÚ_]`k(`aner]`k`k]jpanekn(`a_kj`qp]`qre`ko](jkiqepk_kjÚrah(qip]jpk oa_nap](_dae]`aejpanaooaol]npe_qh]nao`eooeiqh]`koabnamqajpaiajpa_kjpnneko]ko ejpanaooaocan]eo`]ok_ea`]`aak^pe`kolkniaekoeh_epkokqehacpeiko*Aooapan_aenk oecjeÚ_]`kki]eo_knnajpal]n]koajok_kiqiok_e]hanaoqhp]jqi]reoklafkn]) per]`]lkhpe_]*Aop]]l]na_a_kikqilk`an`eop]jpa`aj o$l]oo])oajkckranjkkq jkAop]`k%(atan_e`klknlaook]o`ebanajpao`aj o$ko]`iejeopn]`knaoalnkÚooekj]eo `]lkhpe_]%(lkniaek`alnpe_]ooa_nap]omqa^ajaÚ_e]imqaikatan_aalnafq`e_]i knaop]jpa`]ok_ea`]`a*B]h])oaj]lkhpe_]_kikÎi]hja_aoonekÏ(]hckmqalna_eo]iko pkhan]na`kmq]hlna_eo]iko`ao_kjÚ]n*=`ao_kjÚ]j]lk`anabanen)oap]jpk]ko]pq]eo k_ql]jpao`kolkopkoa_]nckolkhpe_ko_kik]cnqlkoaknc]jev] aomqahdaob]vai klkoekalnapaj`ai`annq^)hko(oaf]l]n]k_ql]nkoiaoikolkopkoa_]ncko(oaf] l]n]_ne]nqikqpnkAop]`klkniaek`aqi]narkhqkok_eka_kjie_]alkhpe_]*
Kj`aaop(]ckn](kl]n]`ktk;J]`erancj_e]ajpnaklneiaenkakpan_aenkoajpe`k`] l]h]rn]mliqf`^(lkeoklneiaenkoanabana]]hckcan]h(mqa_kj_anjaok_ea`]`a_kikqi pk`k(`aÚjej`khaeoa_kopqiao(c]n]jpej`k`enaepkoak^nec] ao(_ne]j`kaol]kl]n]_kj) paop] ao ]pn]ro `] naerej`e_]k( `] naoeopj_e] a `] `aok^a`ej_e]( ajmq]jpk k pan_aenk oajpe`k]b]op]]lkhpe_]`ajkook]h_]j_a(b]vaj`k)]oqncen_kik]hcklanranokai]hÚ_k l]n]]ok_ea`]`a*=`erancj_e]ajpnaklneiaenkoecjeÚ_]`kakpan_aenklnkrk_]`]lahkoa) cqj`koecjeÚ_]`k(eopk(]mqahamqana`qv]lkhpe_]]k`aaola_e]heop]oalnkÚooekj]eo*
=hcqjoabaepko`kol]n]`ktko Aoo]oepq]kl]n]`kt]h`]lkhpe_]]_]^]lknb]van)jko]_aep]n_kik ^re]oaran`]`ae) n]o_anp]o]pepq`aoa]Úni] aomqa(oaat]iej]`]oi]eo]bqj`k(oane]ilan_a^e`]o_kik ]^oqn`]o* Pkiaikoqiatailhkna_ajpa`]deop ne]`]lkhpe_]`k>n]oeh*Ai-55/(`qn]jpakfqhc]) iajpk(lahkOqlnaikPne^qj]hBa`an]h$OPB%(`kla`e`k`kat)lnaoe`ajpa`]Nal^he_]Banj]j`k ?khhkn`aIahhk`ajkoqolajok`aoaqo`enaepkolkhpe_ko(kqreikoaipk`]l]npa]]Úni]k `amqakLk`anFq`e_enek$`kmq]hkOqlnaikPne^qj]hBa`an]hk ncki]eo]hpk%o pane]oq] `ecje`]`alnaoanr]`]oakfqhc]iajpk`kla`e`kjkbkooaqiÎfqhc]iajpklkhpe_kÏ* Kj`aaopkl]n]`ktk;Jkb]pk`amqa]Nal^he_]^n]oehaen]_kjopepq`]lknpnolk) `anao mliqf`lp$Ata_qperk( Haceoh]perk(Fq`e_enek%a(lknp]jpk(kOqlnaikPne^qj]hBa`an]h( oaj`kqilk`anlkhpe_k`]Nal^he_]$qilk`an`kAop]`k%(jklk`aÚ_]nbkn]`]lkhpe_]* Mqaoajpe`k(lknp]jpk(lk`ane]pan]e`ae]`amqak ncki]eo]hpk`kLk`anFq`e_enekjk `arafqhc]nlkhepe_]iajpa;?kik`aoaf]nmqaqilk`an`kAop]`k(lknp]jpk(qilk`anlkh) pe_k(jk]pqalkhepe_]iajpa(lkj`k)oabkn]`]lkhpe_]; I]eo l]n]`kt]h( ]ej`]( bke k ik`k _kik ko fqvao( ]l o k fqhc]iajpk( ]r]he]n]i oaq ln lnekpn]^]hdk(`evaj`k6ÎBkeqifqhc]iajpkhac]hajklkhpe_kÏ(mqanaj`koecjeÚ_]nmqa kfqhc]iajpkbkn]baepk`a]_kn`k_ki]haeajk`a]_kn`k_ki]lkhpe_]*Kn]$ajeooknaoe`a kl]n]`ktk%(]haejkbaep]lahkLk`anHaceoh]perk;Jkl]npa`]?kjopepqek`]Nal^he) _];Jkl]npaaooaj_e]h`]lkhpe_];?kik(ajpk(oal]n]nkhac]haklkhpe_koa]haeqi] `]obkni]obqj`]iajp]eo`]]klkhpe_]; J]ran`]`a(mq]j`koaejoeope]aimqakfqhc]iajpkÎjkbkooalkhpe_kÏaoaahkce]r]k fqhc]iajpklknÎpanoe`k]laj]ohac]hÏ(kmqaaop]r]oaj`klnaooqlkopklknpk`ko$ok_ea`]`a afqvao%an]]e`ajpeÚ_]k_kopqiaen]ajpnalkhpe_]aejpanaooaol]npe_qh]naoao_qoko(_kj) pnneko]ko`]i]ekne](mqalkneook`araoanlnkpace`]lah]hae_kjpn]]lkhpe_]*Kl]n]`ktk aopjkb]pk`amqaqi]bkni]aooaj_e]h`]lkhpe_]$]hae%]l]na_a_kiklnkpak_kjpn]] ln lne]lkhpe_](mqaÚ_]na`qve`]]fkck`aejpanaooaoao_qoko* Qi]kqpn]]Úni]kmqa]_aep]ikopn]jmqeh]iajpa]mqah]mqa]_qo]a_nepe_]qi] cnara(`a_h]n]j`kpn]p]n)oa`aÎcnaralkhpe_]Ï*_qnekokmqaqoaiko(oailnk^hai](]at) lnaookÎlkhpe_]oej`e_]hÏa(]kiaoikpailk(]_kj`ajaiko(_nepe_]j`kqi]cnaraok^] ]hac]k`aoanÎlkhpe_]Ï*
0/.
=re`]lkhpe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Ai_anpko_]oko(_kilnaajorahmqa]atlnaookÎcnaralkhpe_]Ï]l]na]_kikqi] ]_qo]k* Mq]j`k( lkn atailhk( oa pn]p] `a pn]^]hd]`knao `a qi] b^ne_] `a ]qpki raeo mqa(aijkia`aiahdknaoo]hneko(ajpn]iaicnara_kjpn]]`enak`]ailnao](_kjoe`a) n])oamqa]cnara_kikpai`aoan(kqoaf](Îoeilhaoiajpaa_kjie_]Ï*=k_nepe_)h]_kik Îcnaralkhpe_]Ï(aop)oamqanaj`k`evanmqakocnareop]o(ok^]]l]nj_e]`aqi]naerej`e_]) ko]h]ne]h(aop]ne]i`abaj`aj`kejpanaooaol]npe_qh]naoao_qokoaehacpeiko(kq^qo_]j`k( `eooeiqh]`]iajpa(r]jp]cajoalk`anaol]n]]hcqjooej`e_]heop]o*=l]h]rn]mliqf`^(]ooei( ailnac]`]l]n]`]nqioajpe`klafkn]perkcnara* D_]oko(lkni(aimqa]atlnaookÎcnaralkhpe_]Ï(qo]`]_kik_npe_]kq]_qo]k( oqnlnaaj`ajpaa`ao_]^e`]*Oqlkjd]iko(lknatailhk(mqakopn]^]hd]`knao`aqil]ob]) ]iqi]cnaracan]h_kjpn]klh]jka_kjie_k`kckranjk*Aopk(lknp]jpk(na_qo]j`kqi] mliqf`^b`lkjf`^a(jaooa_]ok(]cnaraao lk`aoanlkhpe_]*Lknmqa(ajpk(]_qo]nqi] cnaralknah]oankmqaah];Kikperkoeilhao6l]n]koajok_kiqiok_e]h(`evan`a]hcqi] _keo]mqaah]Îlkhpe_]Ïb]vanqi]]_qo]k*=_npe_]o ai]l]nj_e]aop`enece`]_kjpn] ]cnara(lkeo(na]hiajpa(aoprkhp]`]_kjpn]]lkhpe_](ei]cej]`]_kik]hcki]hÚ_k* Aoo]reokcajan]hev]`]`]lkhpe_]_kik]hcklanranok(laneckok(`eop]jpa`aj o$l]oo])oa jk Aop]`k%( ln]pe_]`k lknÎahaoÏ $ko lkhpe_ko lnkÚooekj]eo% _kjpn]Îj oÏ( ok^ k `eob]n_a `a ]cenaiÎlknj oÏ(b]v_kimqaoaf]oajpe`]_kik]hckoa_napka`ao_kjda_e`k(qi]_kj`qp] _]h_qheop]aklknpqjeop](qi]bkn]_knnqlp]a(ailnac]j`k]lkh_e]akatn_epk(qi]bkn] nalnaookn]qo]`]_kjpn]]ok_ea`]`a*
L]n]`ktko`]ei]caii]hbe_]`]lkhpe_]
0//
Aoo]ei]cai`]lkhpe_]_kikqilk`ani]hÚ_k(`kmq]hokikorpei]opkhan]jpao lknmqal]ooer]iajpa_kjoajpeikoaioq]rekhj_e](l]n]`kt]hlahkiajkolkn`keoik) perkolnej_el]eo* Ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqa]lkhpe_]bkeejrajp]`]lahkodqi]jko_kikkik`klahk mq]hlq`aooaiatlnaoo]noq]o`ebanaj]oa_kjÛepkooaipn]jobkni)hkoaicqann]pkp]h( aiqok`]bkn]aatpanijekna_lnk_k*Jqi]l]h]rn](_kikkik`klahkmq]hkodqi]jko( bqcej`k`]rekhj_e](nacqh]iakn`aj]ioaqoejpanaooao_kjÛep]jpao(oaqo`enaepkoak^nec]) ao_kikoanaook_e]eo*?kikatlhe_]n(ajpk(mqa]lkhpe_]oaf]lan_a^e`]_kik`eop]jpa( i]hÚ_]arekhajp]; Aioacqj`khqc]n(lknmqa]lkhpe_]bkeejrajp]`]_kikkik`klahkmq]h]ok_ea`]) `a(ejpanj]iajpa`ere`e`](`eo_qpa(`ahe^an]a`a_e`aai_kiqil]n]]lnkr]nkqnafaep]n]o ] aomqa`evainaolaepk]pk`kokooaqoiai^nko*?kikatlhe_]n(ajpk(mqaoaf]lan_a^e`] _kik ]hck mqa jk jko _kj_anja( i]o jko lnafq`e_]( jk jko b]rkna_a( i]o b]rkna_a ]ko ejpanaooaoao_qokoaeh_epko`akqpnko; Mqa]_kjpa_aq]aoo]ejrajkdqi]j]l]n]pknj]n)oa(l]n]`kt]hiajpa(qib]n`k`k mq]hckop]n]iko`ajkohern]n; ?kpe`e]j]iajpa(fknj]eo(n`eko(pahareo aoikopn]i(jkiqj`kejpaenk(b]pkolkhpe_ko mqanabkn]i]reoklafkn]per]`]lkhpe_]6_knnqlk(bn]q`ao(_neiaoeilqjaoln]pe_]`ko lknlkhpe_ko(iajpen]omqalnkrk_]icqann]ol]n]o]peob]van]koejpanaooaoa_kjie_ko`ko b]^ne_]jpao`a]ni]iajpko(`aoreko`ana_qnokol^he_komqa`arane]ioanqo]`ko_kjpn]] bkia(]o`kaj]o(]lk^nav](]qiajpk`]o`aoecq]h`]`aoa_kjie_]oaok_e]eo(qok`]ohaeo _kiÚj]he`]`aoklkop]o]kok^faperkomqaperan]i]koanaiah]^kn]`]o(ap_* =kh]`k`aooaob]pko(jkl]oo]qi`e]oaimqaraf]ikokik`k`aoqi]jk(]qpknepnek( rekhajpk_kimqabqj_ekjnekol^he_ko(_qfko]hnekl]cklknj o$lkniaek`aeilkopko%( pn]p]i]lklqh]kmqa^qo_]kooanrekol^he_ko*P]i^i_kjpne^qel]n]]reokjac]per]`] lkhpe_]]hejcq]caiaimqa]ohaeoaopkna`ece`]o(pknj]j`k)]oej_kilnaajoraeol]n]]ok_ea) `]`aaatecej`kmqaoaf]iejpanlnap]`]olknaola_e]heop]ooaimqapajd]ikoc]n]jpe]`amqa ]oejpanlnap]i_knnap]iajpa(oakb]vaiaijkookb]rknkqaib]rkn`alnerehcekok_qhpko* K mqa _qnekok( lkni( ]_ajpq]j`k ] ei]cai `] lkhpe_] _kik ]hck l]n]`kt]h( k b]pk`amqao lk`aikoklkn)jko]p]eob]pkoahqp]n_kjpn]ahaolkniaek`]ln lne]lkhpe_](
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
lkeo(iaoikmq]j`koab]vqi]cqann]_erehkqoana]hev]qi]narkhqk(koikperkoak^) faperkook]lkhpe_](eopk(iq`]j]oj]bkni]ajk_kjpa`k`klk`an*Iaoik]oqpkle]o `aai]j_el]k`kcjankdqi]jk_kjpn]pk`]o]oik`]he`]`ao`aoanre`k(ao_n]re`k( ]qpknep]neoik(rekhj_e]aejfqope]_kj_a^aikpniejk`alk`anaoehacpeiko(i]ojkk pniejk`]ln lne]lkhpe_]* =olaook]omqa(`aockopko]oa`a_al_ekj]`]o(jkmqanaikqrenb]h]nailkhpe_](na) _qo]i)oa ] l]npe_el]n `a ]pere`]`ao ok_e]eo mqa lkoo]i pan Új]he`]`a kq _qjdk lkhpe_ko( ]b]op]i)oa`apq`kmq]jpkhai^na]pere`]`aolkhpe_]o(iaoikp]eolaook]o(_kioaqeokh]) iajpkaoq]na_qo](aopkb]vaj`klkhpe_](lkeoaopk`aet]j`kmqa]o_keo]oÚmqai_kik aopka(lknp]jpk(mqa]lkhpe_]ateopajpa_kjpejqap]h_kik*Kl]n]`ktk(lknp]jpk(aopai mqa(]kna_qo]n]lkhpe_](]]l]pe]ok_e]hp]i^iqi]bkni]`ab]vanlkhpe_](]ej`]mqa qi]bkni]l]ooer]*
Krk_]^qhnek`]lkhpe_]
K
deopkne]`kndahajeop]IkoaoBejhau(aopq`]j`k]ook_ea`]`aocnac]anki]j](_kj) _hqeqmqakmqa_d]i]iko`amliqf`^bkeejrajp]`klkncnackoanki]jko* =jpao `a at]iej]niko k mqa bke p]h ejrajk( f lk`aiko _kilnaaj`an ] knecai cna_k)nki]j]`kmqa_d]i]iko`amliqf`^lahkoeilhaoat]ia`krk_]^qhnekqo]`kai lkhpe_]6abjl`o^`f^(^ofpql`o^`f^(lifd^onrf^(qfo^kf^(abpmlqfpjl(^k^onrf^(jlk^onrf^ok l]h]rn]ocnac]omqa`aoecj]inaceiaolkhpe_ko7obm _if`^(fjmofl(mlabo(`fa^ab(afq^aro^( pbk^al(mlsl(pl`fba^ab(m^`ql(`lkpbkplokl]h]rn]oh]pej]omqa`aoecj]inaceiaolkhpe) _ko(]cajpaolkhpe_koabkni]o`a]klkhpe_]* =l]h]rn]mliqf`^cnac]6q^mlifqfh^(rej`]`amifp*Mifp]_e`]`a(jk_kik_kjfqjpk `aa`eb_eko(nq]oaln]]o(aoei_kikÎaol]k_re_kÏ(kqoaf](ajpaj`e`]_kik]_kiqje`]) `aknc]jev]`](bkni]`]lahko_e`]`ko$mlifqfhp%(dkiajohernaoaecq]eoj]o_e`koaioaq pannep nek(lknp]`knao`a`keo`enaepkoejmqaopekjraeo(]fplkljf^$ecq]h`]`alan]jpa]hae%a ]fpbdlof^$]ecq]h`]`ajk`enaepk`aatlkna`eo_qpenail^he_kkleje aook^na] aomqa] _e`]`a`arakqjk`arana]hev]n%* Q^mlifqfh^okkojac _ekol^he_ko`enece`kolahko_e`]`ko6_kopqiao(haeo(annekl) ^he_k(knc]jev]k`]`abao]a`]cqann](]`iejeopn]k`kooanrekol^he_ko$]^anpqn]`a nq]o(aopn]`]oalknpko(_kjopnqk`apailhkoabknpeÚ_] ao(k^n]o`aennec]k(ap_*%a`]o ]pere`]`aoa_kjie_]o`]_e`]`a$ika`](eilkopkoapne^qpko(pn]p]`ko_kian_e]eo(ap_*%* @fsfq^pk_knnaolkj`ajpa(aih]pei(`kcnackmifp(lknp]jpk(]_e`]`a_kikajpal) ^he_ka_khaperkkqajpe`]`a_re_]*@fsfpk_knnaolkj`ajpa`amlifqfhp(eopk(_e`]`k*Obp mr_if`^k_knnaolkj`ajpah]pejk`aq^mlifqfh^aoecjeÚ_](lknp]jpk(kojac _ekol^he_ko `enece`kolahkmlmrirpolj^krp(eopk(kol]pn_ekokq_e`]`kohernaoaecq]eo(j]o_e`kojk okhk`aNki]* Mifpa`fsfq^p_knnaolkj`ai$eilanbaep]iajpa%]kmqa(jkrk_]^qhneklkhpe_kik`an) jk(_d]i]iko`aAop]`k6Îk_kjfqjpk`]oejopepqe aol^he_]o$haeo(annekl^he_k(oanreko l^he_ko%aoq]]`iejeopn]klahkoiai^nko`]_e`]`aÏ* Q^mlifqfh^aobpmr_if`^_knnaolkj`ai$eilanbaep]iajpa%]kmqa`aoecj]ikoik`an) j]iajpa _kikÎlnpe_]o lkhpe_]oÏ( ai nabanj_e] ]k ik`k `a l]npe_el]k jk lk`an( ]ko _kjÛepkoa]_kn`koj]pki]`]`a`a_eo aoaj]`aÚjek`]ohaeoa`aoq]]lhe_]k(jkna_k) jda_eiajpk`ko`enaepkoa`]ok^nec] ao`koiai^nko`]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]ao`a_e) o ao_kj_anjajpao]kannekkqbqj`kl^he_k* @evan mqa ko cnacko a nki]jkoÎejrajp]n]iÏ ] lkhpe_] jk oecjeÚ_] `evan mqa( ]jpao `ahao(jkateope]iklk`ana]]qpkne`]`a(i]omqaejrajp]n]iklk`ana]]qpkne`]`alkh) pe_kolnklne]iajpa`epko*L]n]_kilnaaj`anikokmqaoalnapaj`a`evan_kieook(_kjri at]iej]niko_kikan]_kj_a^e`kaln]pe_]`kklk`anp]jpkj]ook_ea`]`aocna_k)nki]j]o mq]jpkaikqpn]o(]jpao`]ejrajk`]lkhpe_]*
0/0
=re`]lkhpe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Klk`an`aolpe_k
J
FAMqLIAßNAß!NTIGUIDADE ß ±FAMqLIA²ßNjOßERAßOßQUEßmß HOJEßPARAßNvSßPAI ßMjEßEß FILHOS ßMASßERAßUMAßUNI DADEßECONxMICAßCONSTI TUqDAßPELOSßANTEPASSADOSß EßDESCENDENTES ßPAI ßMjE ß FILHOS ßGENROS ßNORAS ßTIOSß EßSOBRINHOS ßESCRAVOS ßANI MAIS ßTERRAS ßEDIFICAlzES ß PLANTAlzES ßBENSßMvVEISß EßIMvVEISß°ßPESSOASßEß COISASßERAMßPROPRIEDADESß DOßPATRIARCAßDESPvTESßOUß PATER FAMILIAS
0/1
]ona]hav]oateopajpao]jpao`kocnacko(jkopannep nekomqarene]i]bkni]n]Cn_e] $na]hav]oie_je_]oa_napajoao%(^ai_kik]omqaateope]ijkopannep nekomqare) ne]i]bkni]nNki]$na]hav]oapnqo_]o%(]ooei_kikjkocn]j`aoeilnekokneajp]eo $Lnoe](Acepk(>]^ehje](æj`e](?dej]%reckn]r]klk`an`aolpe_kkql]pne]n_]h* Aicnack(abpmqbp(a(aih]pei(m^qbo*c^jfif^p(kl]pne]n_]k_daba`ab]ihe]_qf]rkjp]) `a]^okhqp]]hae6Î=mqehkmqa]ln]v]knaepaibkn]`ahaeÏ*Klk`anan]atan_e`klknqi_daba `ab]ihe]kq`ab]ihe]o$_h(pne^k(]h`ae]%(_qf]]qpkne`]`aan]laook]ha]n^epnne](`a_e`ej`k ok^na]re`]a]iknpa`apk`kokoiai^nko`kcnqlk(ok^na]lkooaa`eopne^qek`]onemqav]o( ]cqann]a]l]v(]o]he]j]o$aican]hj]bkni]`a_]o]iajpko%(klnke^e`kaklaniepe`k* Ai^kn](`ab]pk(]knecai`aooalk`anaoperaooaj]lnklnea`]`a`]pann]a`kona^]jdko( oaj`k_dabak`apajpkn`]nemqav](lnk_qn]r])oac]n]jpe)hk_kjpn]narkhp]oa`aok^a`ej_e]o ]Úni]j`k)oaqi]knecaiok^naj]pqn]ha`erej]l]n]aha*=l]na_aj`k_kik`aoecj]`kla) hko`aqoaoa`aoaf]`klknahao(k`apajpkn`klk`anp]i^ian]`apajpkn`klnerehcek`a nah]_ekj]n)oa`enap]iajpa_kik`erejkkq_kiko]cn]`k(_kj_ajpn]j`kaioq]oiko] ]qpkne`]`anaheceko]*Lknoq]nemqav](]qpkne`]`anaheceko]alkooa`]o]ni]o(k`apajpkn`k lk`anan]p]i^ik_dabaiehep]n(_kj_ajpn]j`kaioq]oiko]_daÚ]`koatn_epkoa] `a_eokok^na]cqann]a]l]v*An]k_ki]j`]jpaoqlnaik* K_dabaan]qipbkelo(ajbaet]j`kaioq]oiko]lnklnea`]`a`kokhkapq`kmq]jpk jahadkqraooa$lknp]jpk(]nemqav]`kcnqlk%(]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]aiehep]n(oaj`k(lkneook( nae(oqiko]_an`kpaa_kj`qpkniehep]noqlnaik* ?ki k _nao_eiajpk `aikcnÚ_k $lkn iaek `a ]he]j]o na]hev]`]o lahko _]o]iajpko ajpnab]ihe]once]o%(]atl]jokpannepkne]h$lkniaek`acqann]o`a_kjmqeop]%(]`ereok ok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk$lah]ao_n]rev]k`koraj_e`ko`acqann]alah]obqj ao`kiope_]o`]o iqhdanao%ako]_kn`koiehep]naoaj]r]eoajpnacnqlko(]]qpkne`]`a(ai^kn]_kj_ajpn]`] j]oiko`knae(l]ookq]oan`ahac]`]lknaha]oaqonalnaoajp]jpao$aican]h(iai^nko`a oq]b]ihe]a`]ob]ihe]o]he]`]o%* Oqnceq(]ooei(qi]nal]npek`]obqj ao`a`enakkq`alk`an6]_]op]o]_an`kp]h lkooq]]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]a]`kocqannaenko(]iehep]n*Oajdknao`]opann]o(`koao_n]) rko(`]oiqhdanao(`]o]ni]oa`ko`aqoao(kocnqlko`apajpknao`]]qpkne`]`abkni]r]i] _h]ooa`kiej]jpaa_kjkie_]iajpaa`enecajpa`]_kiqje`]`a(ok^klk`an`knae(]kmq]h lnaop]r]ifqn]iajpk`aha]h`]`aal]c]r]ipne^qpklahkqoqbnqpk`]opann]olanpaj_ajpao ]ahaalknaha_a`e`]o]ko`ai]eo* =lnklnea`]`a`]pann]a`aoaqolnk`qpkoateope]ai`q]obkni]olnej_el]eo6 -*
_kiklnklnea`]`alner]`]`knaea(lknp]jpk(_kik`kijeklaook]h`k_dabakql]) pne]n_]* Aooa l]pneijek kq lnklnea`]`a l]pneikje]h an] _a`e`k( oacqj`k ] rkjp]`a ]n^epnne] `k l]pne]n_]( ]ko _dabao `a _ho a pne^ko( ]ko cnqlko o]_an`kp]eo a iehep]nao( ia`e]jpaoanrekoa+kqpne^qpko*Aican]h(aooapelk`alnklnea`]`alnar]ha_e]j]mqah]o nace aoaimqak_qhperk`]pann]atece]pn]^]hdkoeiajoko`aennec]ka`apn]jolknpa `acq]mqaqilnklneapnekeokh]`kjklk`ane]na]hev]n(jko lknhdab]hp]naina_qn) okol]n]eook(_kikp]i^ilknmqapane]`a]pn]raoo]npann]o`akqpnkolnklneapneko( `araj`kl]c]n)hdaopne^qpkokqb]van)hdaocqann]*=lnklnea`]`a(Ú_]j`kj]lkooa`k nae(laniepe]mqaaopaqo]ooakona_qnokorej`ko`kopne^qpkol]n]]ocn]j`aok^n]o`a ennec]kapn]jolknpa`acq]o(]kiaoikpailkmqalkooq]klk`anl]n]]pn]raoo]n pk`]amq]hmqanpann]l]n]na]hev]n]ok^n]o7
.*
_kiklnklnea`]`a_khaper]`]o]h`ae]okqlnklnea`]`a_kiqj]h`k_daba`]]h`ae](mqa l]c]r]pne^qpko]knaeaipnk_]`alnkpak(oq^iapaj`k)oa]klk`annceka(lknp]jpk( ]qpkne`]`anaheceko]aiehep]n`koajdkn*
Oaf]aiqi_]ok_kikaikqpnk(kl]pne]n_]an]bkn]`k]atan_anqi_kjpnkha_ann]`k ok^na]o_daÚ]ohk_]eoaok^nakomqaqoqbnq]i`]opann]o(lkeo]ona^ahe aoan]ibnamqajpao
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
a]`eolqp]lahklk`an(ejpaniejrah*P]h_kjpnkhaan]baepklknnalnaoajp]jpao`knaemq]j`k lan_knne]i]opann]onaceopn]j`k]lnk`qkana_khdaj`kpne^qpko(lqjej`k_neiao_kia) pe`ko_kjpn]]o`a_eo aoa`a_napkonceko(oqbk_]j`knarkhp]oaeila`ej`kkoqnceiajpk`a ba`an] aoa_kjba`an] ao`a]h`ae]o* ?kieook(knael]ookq]panqi]eiajo]^qnk_n]_e]aeiajokoatn_epko(_qopa]`kola) hko_dabaohk_]eoaoq]o]h`ae]o*Kobqj_ekjnekoncekolna_eo]r]io]^anhan(ao_narana_kjp]n* J]ook_ea`]`ao`amqab]h]iko(aooao_kjda_eiajpkoan]ilnerehcek`aqicnqlk(koo]_an) `kpao*Lknaooaikperk(]jb]oajk_]npano]cn]`kkqnahecekok`klk`anpaj`e]]]qiajp]n ia`e`]mqa]qiajp]r]klk`aneko]_an`kp]h(oqopajp_qhkej`eolajorah`klk`anncek* @aqoaoa]ni]oan]ikoleh]nao`]]qpkne`]`a* =ooei_kjopepq`k(klk`anlkooq]]ooacqejpao_]n]_panope_]o6 abpmqf`llrm^qof^o`^i6an]atan_e`klahk_daba`ab]ihe]ok^naqi_kjfqjpk`ab]i) he]o]ahahec]`]olknh]koa`alaj`j_e]a_kjie_]aiehep]n(lkn]he]j]oi]pneik) je]eo(jqi]nah]klaook]haimqak_dabac]n]jpe]lnkpakakoo`epkokbana_e]i ha]h`]`aak^a`ej_e](fqn]j`k_qilnen]rkjp]`a`klneiaenk7 qlq^i6 k `apajpkn `] ]qpkne`]`a lkooq] lk`an oqlnaik ejmqaopekjrah l]n] `a_e`en mq]jpk]klaniepe`ka]klnke^e`k$]haeatlneia]rkjp]`alaook]h`k_daba%(l]n]aop]) ^aha_ankorj_qhko_kiko]cn]`k(eopk(_kiko`aqoaoa]jpal]oo]`ko$k_daba`api klk`annahecekok%(l]n]`a_e`enmq]jpkcqann]al]v$k_daba`apiklk`aniehep]n%* =pki]`]`a`a_eok_]^e]at_hqoer]iajpa]knae*Aopalkooq]_kjoahdaenko$o]_an`kpao aiehep]nao%(mqakejbkni]r]iahdaoqcane]i_kj`qp]oa] ao(i]o]`a_eok_]^e] ]laj]o]aha*K_kjoahdkan]oa_napk(koikperko`aqi]`a_eokan]ioa_napko(kmqaoa l]oo]r]ajpnaknaeaoaqo_kjoahdaenkoan]oa_napk*Okiajpa]`a_eokpknj]r])oal^he) _](j]bkni]`aqi`a_napkna]h7 fk`lomlo^al lr `lomlofÛ`^al6 k `apajpkn `k lk`an Úcqn]r] ai oaq ln lnek _knlk ]o _]n]_panope_]o`klk`an(]lnaoajp]j`k)oa_kiki]jebaop]k`]ln lne]_kiqje`]`a* Oq]_]^a]aj_]nj]r]]]qpkne`]`amqa`eneca(oaqlaepkaj_]nj]r]]rkjp]`amqakn`a) j](oaqoiai^nkooqlaneknaoaj_]nj]r]iko`ahac]`komqaknalnaoajp]r]i$o]_an`k) pao a iehep]nao%( oaqo iai^nko ejbaneknao aj_]nj]r]i ko o`epko mqa hda k^a`a_e]i* Aoo]Úcqn]k`klk`anjk_knlk`kln lneknaeej`e_]r]]ateopj_e]`aqi]knc]je) v]kok_e]hbknpaiajpadean]nmqev]`](j]mq]h_]`]ej`er`qklkooq]qihqc]nÚtka lna`apaniej]`k(o paj`kateopj_e]ok_e]hcn]]o]aooahqc]n*K_knlk`knaelaniepe] jko Úcqn]n]dean]nmqe]i]op]i^i]bknpa_ajpn]hev]k`]]qpkne`]`a(_kj_ajpn]) `]j]_]^a]ajklaepk`k`enecajpa7 jdf`l6lknna_a^an]]qpkne`]`a`ko`aqoao(k`apajpkn`klk`anlkooq]bkn]ok^na) j]pqn]hkqice_]*Oq]l]h]rn]an]qi_ki]j`kieopanekokmqab]ve]ateopen]mqehkmqa an]`epk$knae`eve]Îb]])oaÏa]o_keo]o]_kjpa_e]ioeilhaoiajpalknmqaaha]od]re] `epka`aoaf]`k%7oaqocaopkoa`aoafkopejd]ibkn]l]n]i]p]na_qn]n(oq]i]h`ek `aopnq]pq`kmq]jpkbkooa]i]h`ek]`klknaha(`aha`alaj`e]i]banpehe`]`a`]pann]( ]rep ne]kq]`annkp]j]cqann](kej_ekkqkÚi`aqi]laopa(bajiajkoiapaknkh ) ce_ko(_]p]_heoiko7 qo^kp`bkabkqb6 lkn oan `a knecai `erej]( k nae an] `erejev]`k a ]_na`ep]r])oa ai oq] eiknp]he`]`a_kik_kj`ek`]lnaoanr]k`]_kiqje`]`a*Aoo]`erejev]kk_khk_]) r]]_ei]abkn]`]_kiqje`]`a*P]hoal]n]khar]r]]_kjoe`an]nmqak`enecajpak_q) l]r]qihqc]npn]jo_aj`ajpa(cn]]o]kmq]hre]pq`k(o]^e]pq`kalk`e]pq`k(paj`kk eilnekpkp]hok^na]_kiqje`]`a7 ebobafqofl6an]pn]joiepe`k]klneikcjepk`knaekq(j]b]hp]`aopa(]qiiai^nk`] b]ihe]na]h*=b]ihe]naej]jpa_kjopepq]qi]hejd]caiaqi]`ej]ope](mqao Új`]r] kqlknb]hp]`adan`aenko`enapkokqlknqoqnl]k`klk`anlknqi]kqpn]b]ihe](mqa `]r]ej_ek]qi]jkr]hejd]caikq`ej]ope]*
0/2
=re`]lkhpe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
=ejrajk`]lkhpe_] Koqnceiajpk`]_e`]`a Mq]j`koa]Úni]mqakocnackoanki]jkoÎejrajp]n]iÏ]lkhpe_](kmqaoa`evmqa `aoÚvan]i]o_]n]_panope_]o`]]qpkne`]`aa`klk`an`apelk`aol pe_kkql]pne]n_]h*Ai) ^kn](jko_kiako(cnackoanki]jkoperaooai_kjda_e`kaooapelk`aknc]jev]ka_kj) ie_k)ok_e]h(qi_kjfqjpk`aia`e`]obkepki]`klahkolneiaenko`enecajpaoÍkoibdfpi^al* obpÍ`aik`k]eila`en]_kj_ajpn]k`kolk`anaoa`]]qpkne`]`aj]oiko`aqinae( oajdkn`]pann](`]fqope]a`]o]ni]o(nalnaoajp]jpa`]`erej`]`a* =lnklnea`]`a`]pann]jkoapknjkqlnklnea`]`ance]kql]pneijeklner]`k`knae( jaioapknjkqlnklnea`]`a_kiqj]hkq`]]h`ae](i]oi]jpara)oa_kiklnklnea`]`a`a b]ihe]oej`alaj`ajpao(_qf]la_qhe]ne`]`aaop]r]aijkbkni]naiqi]_]op]ba_d]`]ai oeiaoi](i]o]^anp]ej_knlkn]k`ajkr]ob]ihe]oa`aej`er`qkokqjklnklneapneko ajnemqa_e`kojk_kin_ek* =lao]n`]o`ebanaj]odeop ne_]oj]bkni]k`]Cn_e]a`aNki](dpno]ola_pko_k) iqjo]]i^]oa`a_eoerkol]n]]ejrajk`]lkhpe_]*Klneiaenk(_kik]ooej]h]ikodlkq) _k(]bkni]`]lnklnea`]`a`]pann]7koacqj`k(kbajiajk`]qn^]jev]k7akpan_aenk( kik`k`a`ereokpannepkne]h`]o_e`]`ao* ?kik]lnklnea`]`a`]pann]jklanpaj_e]]h`ae]jai]knae(i]oob]ihe]oej`a) laj`ajpao(a_kik]ocqann]o]ilhe]r]ik_kjpejcajpa`aao_n]rko(bknikq)oaj]Cn_e]a aiNki]qi]_]i]`]lk^na`a_]ilkjaoaomqaiecn]n]il]n]]o]h`ae]o(]heoaaop]^aha) _an]i_kik]npaokoa_kian_e]jpao(lnkolan]n]i(pn]jobkni]n]i]o]h`ae]oai_ajpnko qn^]jkoal]oo]n]i]`eolqp]nk`enaepk]klk`an_ki]ocn]j`aob]ihe]o]cnne]o*Qi]hqp] `a_h]ooaolanl]oo]]deop ne]cnac]anki]j]atecej`kokhqk* =qn^]jev]koecjeÚ_kqqi]_kilhat]na`a`anah] aoa_kjie_]oaok_e]eomqa_k) hk_]r]ai_kjbnkjpkjko lnklneapneko]cnneko(`aqih]`k(a]npaokoa_kian_e]jpao( `akqpnk(i]op]i^i]i]oo]`a]oo]h]ne]`ko`]lklqh]kqn^]j](kojklnklneapneko( cajane_]iajpa_d]i]`ko`aÎkolk^naoÏ* K_kjÛepk`a_h]ooaoej_hq](]ooei(hqp]oajpnakone_koahqp]oajpnane_koalk^nao*P]eo hqp]oan]i`a_knnajpao`kb]pk`amqapk`kokoej`er`qkol]npe_el]r]i`]ocqann]oatpan) j]o(p]jpkl]n]]atl]jokpannepkne]h_kikl]n]]`abao]`aoq]_e`]`a(bkni]j`k]oieh_e]o `koj]perko`]_kiqje`]`a*Aoo]l]npe_el]kiehep]nb]ve]_kimqapk`kooafqhc]ooaijk `enaepk`aejpanren(`a]hcqiik`k(j]o`a_eo aoa_kjie_]oahac]eo`aoq]o_kiqje`]`ao* =hqp]`]o_h]ooaola`e]qi]okhqk*Aoo]okhqkbke]lkhpe_](mqapn]jobknikq]o_kiq) je`]`aoqn^]j]oai_e`]`aolnklne]iajpa`ep]o* Ko lneiaenko _dabao lkhpe_ko( p]i^i _kjda_e`ko _kik ibdfpi^alobp( ejpnk`qven]i qi]`ereokjkpannep nek`]o_e`]`ao(reo]j`k`eiejqenklk`anek`]ob]ihe]one_]o]cn) ne]o(`ko]npaokoa_kian_e]jpaoqn^]jkone_koao]peob]van]naerej`e_]k`ko_]ilkjaoao lk^nao a `ko ]npaoko a ]oo]h]ne]`ko qn^]jko lk^nao* Ai =paj]o( lkn atailhk( ] mifp bke oq^`ere`e`]aiqje`]`aook_eklkhpe_]o`ajkiej]`]oabjlp7aiNki](aiqof_rp* Mqaij]o_aooajqiabjlpkqjqi]qof_rp(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`aoq]oepq]ka_k) jie_]( pejd] ]ooacqn]`k k `enaepk `a l]npe_el]n `enap] kq ej`enap]iajpa `]o `a_eo ao `] _e`]`a*Jk_]ok`a=paj]o(pk`kokoj]pqn]eo`kabjlppejd]ik`enaepk`al]npe_el]n`enap]) iajpa`klk`an(`kj`aknaceiaoanqi]`aik_n]_e]*AiNki](kojklnklneapnekokqko lk^naobkni]r]i]lha^a(mqal]npe_el]r]ej`enap]iajpa`klk`anlknmqapejd]k`enaepk`a ahacanqinalnaoajp]jpa$kqof_rkla^mib_b%l]n]`abaj`anac]n]jpenkoejpanaooaolha^aqo fqjpk]koejpanaooaoalnerehceko`komqal]npe_el]r]i`enap]iajpa`klk`an(kom^qo`flp( mqa_kjopepq]ikmlmrirpolj^krp*Knaceialkhpe_knki]jkan](]ooei(qi]khec]nmqe]*
Kolnej_el]eopn]ko`]ejrajk`]lkhpe_]
0/3
Nkilaj`k_kiklk`an`aol pe_k(cnackoanki]jkoejrajp]n]iklk`anlkhpe_klknmqa6
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
oal]n]n]i]^rqlofa^abmbppl^imofs^a^`k_daba`ab]ihe]$oajdknekl]pne]n_]hal]pne) ikje]h%akmlabofjmbppl^im _if`l(lanpaj_ajpa_khapere`]`a7oal]n]n]ikmofs^al akm _if`laeila`en]i]e`ajpeÚ_]k`klk`anlkhpe_k_ki]laook]`kckranj]jpa* Jk_]ok`]Cn_e](kolkopko`ackranjkan]ilnaaj_de`kolknahae aoajpnako_e`]) `ko(`aik`kmqaklk`an`aetkq`aoandana`epnek*Jk_]ok`aNki](kolkopko`a`a) _eokÚ_]n]irep]he_e]iajpa_kikl]pne_e]`kaahaper]iajpa_kikopne^qjko`]lha^a( ajmq]jpkkolkopko]`iejeopn]perkooapknj]n]iahaperkoalnaaj_de`kolknao_khd]`k
ncklkhpe_kiteik(kOaj]`k7 oal]n]n]i^rqlofa^abjfifq^oamlabo`fsfi(oq^kn`ej]j`k]lneiaen]]koacqj`k*Eook jkoecjeÚ_]mqaai_anpko_]oko(_kikaiAol]np]aNki](klk`anlkhpe_kjkbkooa p]i^iqilk`aniehep]n(i]ooeimqa]o] aoiehep]nao`are]ioan(lneiaenk(`eo_q) pe`]oa]lnkr]`]olah]]qpkne`]`alkhpe_]$]o]ooai^hae]o(aiAol]np]7kOaj]`k(ai Nki]%ao `alkeona]hev]`]o*Ko_dabaoiehep]naojkan]irep]h_ekojaioaqo_]ncko an]idana`epneko(i]oan]iahaepkolanek`e_]iajpalah]o]ooai^hae]o`ko_e`]`ko(j] Cn_e](alahkOaj]`k(aiNki]7 oal]n]n]i^rqlofa^abjdf`l*obifdflp^amlaboqbjmlo^ii^f`l(eila`ej`kp]jpk]`ere) jev]k`kockranj]jpaomq]jpkoq]pn]jobkni]kaioqiko]_an`kpa*Eookjkoecje) Ú_]mqaklk`anlkhpe_k`aet]ooa`apanh]ko_ki]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]Íkokn_qhko( j]Cn_e](akoqcqnao(aiNki](an]inaolaep]`koÚniaiajpalahklk`anlkhpe_k* OecjeÚ_](lkni(mqako`enecajpao`aoaf]r]i]]lnkr]kalnkpak`ko`aqoaooai mqaeookeilhe_]ooa]`erejev]k`kockranj]jpaoa]oq^ieook`]lkhpe_]]qpkne`]) `ao]_an`kp]h7
fUGURESßSACERDOTESßß ROMANOSßQUEßFAZIAMßß PROFECIASßCOMßBASEßNOß CANTOßEßNOßVOOßDASßAVES
_ne]n]i]e`ae]a]lnpe_] `]ibf _kik atlnaook `a qi] rkjp]`a_khaper]al^he_]( `aÚje`kn]`ko`enaepkoa`aranaol]n]pk`koko_e`]`ko(eila`ej`kmqabkooa_kjbqj) `e`]_ki]rkjp]`alaook]h`aqickranj]jpa*=k_ne]nai]haeak`enaepk(]Úni]n]i] `ebanaj]ajpnaklk`anlkhpe_kapk`kokokqpnkolk`anaoa]qpkne`]`aoateopajpaoj] ok_ea`]`a(lkeo_kjbanen]i]qi]ejop j_e]eilaook]ha_khaper]klk`anat_hqoerk]k qok`]bkn]l]n]lqjen_neiao(nalneiennarkhp]oal]n]rejc]n_ki]iknpa(aijkia `]_khapere`]`a(qi`ahepkfqhc]`kejpkhanrahlknah]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(napen]n]i`ko ej`er`qkolner]`kok`enaepk`ab]vanfqope]_ki]oln lne]oikoa`arejc]nlknoe iaoikoqi]kbajo]kqqi_neia*Kikjkl hek`]bkn](`]rejc]j]a`]rekhj_e] l]ookql]n]kAop]`k(ok^]haeak`enaepk7 _ne]n]iejopepqe aoabqj aol^he_]ol]n]]lhe_]k`]ohaeoac]n]jpe]`ko`enaepko( eopk(koqof_rk^fpakoj^dfpqo^alp7 _ne]n]i]ejopepqek`kbooflm _if`lkq`kcrkalm _if`l(eopk(`ko^ajoana_qnoko mqalanpaj_aiok_ea`]`aaoklknah]]`iejeopn]`kolkniaek`ap]t]o(eilkopkoapne) ^qpko(eila`ej`k]_kj_ajpn]k`]lnklnea`]`aa`]nemqav]j]oiko`ko`enecajpao7 _ne]n]ikbpm^ lmliqf`lkqbpm^ lm _if`l$]=ooai^hae]cnac]akOaj]`knki]jk%(jk mq]hkomqalkooq]i`enaepkoecq]eo`a_e`]`]je]`eo_qpe]ioq]okleje ao(`abaj`e]i oaqoejpanaooao(`ahe^an]r]iai_kjfqjpka`a_e`e]ilkniaek`krkpk(lk`aj`k(p]i) ^ilahkrkpk(narkc]nqi]`a_eokpki]`]*bppbl`lo^ la^fksbk lmliqf`^*@a b]pk(a_kikreiko(]i]n_]`klk`an`aol pe_kkoacna`k(]`ahe^an]ka]`a_eok ] lknp]o ba_d]`]o* = lkhpe_]( ]k _kjpnnek( ejpnk`qv ] lnpe_] `] lq^he_e`]`a( eopk ( ] atecj_e] `a mqa ] ok_ea`]`a oaf] ejbkni]`]( _kjda] ]o `ahe^an] ao a l]npe_ela `] pki]`]`a`a_eok* =hi`eook(]ateopj_e]`kaol]kl^he_k`a`eo_qook(`ahe^an]ka`a_eokoecjeÚ_] mqa]ok_ea`]`aaop]^anp]]ko]_kjpa_eiajpko(mqa]o] aojkbkn]iÚt]`]o`aqi]rav lknpk`]olkn]hcqi]rkjp]`apn]jo_aj`ajpa(mqaannko`a]r]he]ka`a`a_eoklk`ai oan_knnece`ko(mqaqi]]klk`acan]nlnk^hai]ojkrko(jklnareopkojaiei]cej]`ko( mqaatecenkk]l]na_eiajpk`ajkr]ohaeoajkr]oejopepqe ao*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(cnackoa
0/4
=re`]lkhpe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
nki]jkopknj]n]i]lkhpe_]ejoal]nrah`kpailka(_kikreikojk_]ok`]pe_](p]i^i _kj_a^an]i]]klkhpe_]hec]`]jkk`alkoorahkq`alkooe^ehe`]`a*?kieook(jko _kj_a^an]ialn]pe_]n]i]lkhpe_]_kik]kdqi]j]$ajk_kik_qilneiajpk`a`a) _napko`erejkolanajaokqapanjko%(i]op]i^iej]qcqn]n]i]e`ae]a]lnpe_]`]_ne]k _kjpjq]`]na]he`]`aok_e]hkq`aoq]pn]jobkni]k(eopk(]deop ne]*
(OBERMANß#OLECTION#ORBIS ,ATINSTOCK
Koecjebe_]`k`]ejrajk`]lkhpe_]
!LEXANDREßDAß-ACEDxNIAß ßA# ßA# ßOßMAISß CmLEBREßCONQUISTADORßDOß MUNDOßANTIGO ßTAMBmMß CONHECIDOßCOMOßß !LEXANDRE ßOß'RANDE ßOUß !LEXANDREß-AGNO
L]n] naolkj`an o `ebanajpao bkni]o ]ooqie`]o lah]o hqp]o `a _h]ooao( ] lkhpe_] ej) rajp]`]`aqiik`kmqa(]_]`]okhqkaj_kjpn]`](qijkrk_kjÛepkkqqi]jkr]hqp] lk`aioqncen(atecej`kjkr]ookhq ao*Aihqc]n`analneienko_kjÛepkolahkqok`]bkn]a `]rekhj_e]`]o]ni]o(]lkhpe_]]l]na_a_kikpn]^]hdkhacpeik`ko_kjÛepko(`ap]hik`k mqakbn]_]ookjaooapn]^]hdk]_]qo]`kqok`]bkn]a`]rekhj_e]* =`aik_n]_e]]pajeajoaa]okhec]nmqe]o`aAol]np]a`]Nal^he_]nki]j]bqj`]n]i] e`ae]a]lnpe_]`]lkhpe_]j]_qhpqn]k_e`ajp]h*Aeolknmqakodeopkne]`knaocnacko(mq]j`k ]Cn_e]_]eqok^k`kijek`keilnek`a=hat]j`na`]I]_a`je](akodeopkne]`knaonk) i]jko(mq]j`kNki]oq_qi^eq]k`kijek`keilnek`ko_o]nao(b]h]n]iai_knnqlk a`a_]`j_e]`]lkhpe_]6l]n]ahao(k`ao]l]na_eiajpk`]mifpa`]obpmr_if`^oecjeÚ_]r]k napknjk]k`aolkpeoikakÚi`]re`]lkhpe_]lnklne]iajpa`ep]* Are`ajpaiajpa( jk `araiko _]en ai ]j]_nkjeoiko( oqlkj`k mqa cnacko a nki]jko ejopepqn]i qi] ok_ea`]`a a qi] lkhpe_] _qfko r]hknao a lnej_leko bkooai e`jpe_ko ]ko jkooko*Ailneiaenkhqc]n(]a_kjkie]an]]cnne]aao_n]reop](`aoknpamqaqi]l]npa`]ok) _ea`]`a$koao_n]rko%aop]r]at_hq`]`ko`enaepkolkhpe_koa`]re`]lkhpe_]*Aioacqj`khq) c]n(]ok_ea`]`aan]l]pne]n_]ha(_kjoamqajpaiajpa(]oiqhdanaop]i^iaop]r]iat_hq`]o `]_e`]`]je]a`]re`]l^he_]*=at_hqok]pejce]p]i^ikoaopn]jcaenkoakoieoanraeo* =_e`]`]je]an]at_hqoer]`kodkiajo]`qhpkohernaoj]o_e`kojkpannep nek`]_e`]`a* =hi`eook(]`ebanaj]`a_h]ooaok_e]hjqj_]an]]l]c]`](iaoikmqakolk^naoperaooai `enaepko lkhpe_ko* =ooei( l]n] iqepko _]ncko( k ln)namqeoepk `] nemqav] reckn]r] a d]re] iaoik]pere`]`aolknp]`kn]o`alnaopcekmqaokiajpakone_kolk`e]ina]hev]n*An]k_]ok( lknatailhk(`]ifqrodf^dobd^a`kbsbodbqfpjlolj^kl(eopk(`acn]j`ao`k] aoai`e) jdaenk_e`]`al]n]baop]o(_kjopnqk`apailhkoapa]pnko(l]pnk_jek`afkckoaolknperko( `apn]^]hdko]npope_ko(ap_* Kmqalnk_qn]iko]lkjp]njkbke]_ne]k`aqi]ok_ea`]`aoai_h]ooao(fqop]abahev( i]o]ejrajk`]lkhpe_]_kikokhqkanaolkop]mqaqi]ok_ea`]`akbana_al]n]oq]o `ebanaj]o(oaqo_kjÛepkoaoq]o_kjpn]`e ao(oaiao_kj`)hkook^]o]_n]hev]k`klk`ana `kckranj]jpaaoaiba_d]n)oapailkn]he`]`aaoiq`]j]o*
=ok_ea`]`a_kjpn]kAop]`k
A 0/5
t]iej]iko ]p ]mqe `q]o cn]j`ao naolkop]o ok_e]eo ]k lk`an6 ] naolkop] abpmqf`^ a ] mliqf`^* Ai ]i^]o( ] ok_ea`]`a lnk_qn] knc]jev]n)oa a_kjkie_]iajpa $eopk ( `apaniej] ] bkni] `] lnklnea`]`a%( i]jpaj`k a iaoik _ne]j`k `ebanaj]o ok_e]eo lnkbqj`]oajpnalnklneapnekoajklnklneapneko(ne_koalk^nao(hernaoaao_n]rko(dkiajo a iqhdanao* Aoo]o `ebanaj]o ajcaj`n]i hqp]o ejpanj]o( mqa lk`ai har]n `aopnqek `a pk`kokoiai^nko`kcnqlkok_e]h* L]n]nacqh]nko_kjÛepko(`apaniej]nheiepaoohqp]o(c]n]jpenmqakone_ko_kjoanrai oq]o nemqav]o a ko lk^nao ]_aepai oq] lk^nav]( oqnca qi] _daÚ] mqa( _kik reiko( lk`a pki]n`q]o`ena ao6kqk_dabaoapknj]oajdkn`]opann]o(`]o]ni]oa`ko`aqoaoapn]jo) bkni]oq]rkjp]`aaihae(kqklk`anatan_e`klknqi]l]npa`]ok_ea`]`a$ko_e`]`ko%( lkniaek`alnpe_]oaejopepqe aol^he_]obqj`]`]oj]haeajk`enaepk_kikatlnaook`] rkjp]`a_khaper]*Jko`keo_]oko(oqncakAop]`k_kiklk`anoal]n]`k`]ok_ea`]`aaaj_]n) nac]`k`a`enece)h](_ki]j`)h](]n^epn]nko_kjÛepkoaqo]n]bkn]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
ETNOCENTRISMOßAßPALAVRAß ETNOCENTRISMOßmßCOMPOSTAß DEßETNOSßEßCENTROß%TNOSß VEMßDOßGREGOßEßSIGNIFICAß ±OßCONJUNTOßDEßSERESßQUEß POSSUEMßAßMESMAßORI GEMßEßOSßMESMOSßTRAlOS² ß DONDEßDESIGNARßNAljO ß POVO ßRAlAß/ßETNOCENTRIS MOßmßAßVISjOßDEßMUNDOß DAQUELESßQUEßCONSIDERAMß QUEßSUAßETNIAßOUßSEUßß GRUPOßmTNICOßmßSUPERIORß AOSßDEMAISßEßMAISßIMPOR TANTEßDOßQUEßOSßOUTROSß 5MAßVISjOßETNOCoNTRICAßß mßCONSEQUoNCIAßDOßß ETNOCENTRISMO
,ESßbDITIONSßDEß-INUITß !RQUIVOßDAß%DITORA
D(lkni(qipan_aenk_]iejdk* Bkiko]_kopqi]`kolah]pn]`ek]jpnklkh ce_]aqnklae]]_kjoe`an]n]ook_ea`]`ao ateopajpaoj]o=ine_]o_kik]pn]o]`]o(lneieper]oaejbaneknao*Aoo]reokj]o_aq`klnk) _aook`a_khkjev]ka_kjmqeop](eje_e]`kjko_qhkTRE*Ko_kjmqeop]`knaoa_khkjev]`knao mqa]lknp]n]ij]o=ine_]oejpanlnap]n]i]o`ebanaj]oajpnaahaoakoj]perko]iane_]jko _kik`eopejkdeannmqe_]ajpnaoqlaneknaoaejbaneknao6l]n]ahaokoÎj`ekoÏjkpejd]i hae(nae(b(ao_nep](ika`](_kin_ek(deop ne]a(lknp]jpk(an]ioanao`aolnkre`ko`kopn]ko `]mqehkmqa(l]n]kaqnklaq_neopk(o`epk`aikj]nmqe]o(_kjopepq]]_erehev]ka]dq) i]je`]`alnklne]iajpa`ep]* Oai`re`](ko_kjmqeop]`knaoaj_kjpn]n]icn]j`aoeilnekoj]o=ine_]o6ej_]o(]o) pa_]oai]e]o*Lkneook(ko`aopnqn]i]bannkabkck(atpaniej]j`k]ocajpao(lehd]j`k]o nemqav]oaanecej`kecnaf]ook^naoaqopailhko*Pk`]re](at_apklknaooaoeilneko`aopnq) `ko(ko_kjmqeop]`knaoaj_kjpn]n]i]o`ai]eoj] ao]iane_]j]oknc]jev]`]o`ai]jaen] ej_kilnaajorahl]n]kol]`n aoaqnklaqoalkneookejpanlnap]n]ikmqaan]iej_]l]vao `a_kilnaaj`an_kikejbanekne`]`a`ko]iane_]jko*?kjoe`an]j`k)kooahr]cajoa^n^]nko( fqopeÚ_]r]i]ao_n]re`k(]ar]jcahev]kakatpanijek* =reokaqnklae]an]aapjk_jpne_](kqoaf](_kjoe`an]l]`n ao(r]hknaoalnpe_]o`ko ^n]j_ko]`qhpkolnklneapnekoaqnklaqo_kikoabkooaikoje_korhe`ko(oqlaneknao]pk) `kokokqpnkoa`araj`koanren`aik`ahkkq`al]`nkl]n]pk`]o]ook_ea`]`ao(lknmqa oane]i`aÚje`knao`]_erehev]k*Aoo]reokl]ookq]oan_kil]npehd]`]lahko`ao_aj`aj) pao`ko_khkjev]`knao(eopk(lahko^n]j_ko`]opno=ine_]o(aoai]jpi]pko`e]o`a dkfa*J]lanola_per]`kapjk_ajpneoik(koj]perko]iane_]jko$kqko_d]i]`kolkrkoln) )_khki^e]jko(kqoaf](]jpaneknaoore]cajo`a?khki^k%lkooq]ialkooqaiok_ea`]`ao `abaepqko]oj]omq]eob]hp]kmqaeilknp]jpa6c^iq^*iebpkian_]`k$ika`]a_kin_ek%(] ao_nep]$]hb]^pe_]%(]deop ne]akAop]`k*An]iaok(lknp]jpk(ok_ea`]`aopbj`ljo`fl(pbj bp`ofq^(pbjjbjof^apbjmliqf`^* Jko_qhkTT(k]jpnkl hkckbn]j_oLeanna?h]opnaoaopq`kqaoo]ook_ea`]`aolknqi lneoi] _kilhap]iajpa `ebanajpa( hkjca `k apjk_ajpneoik _kopqiaenk* Ikopnkq mqa lko) oqaiao_nep](i]omqaaop]jk]hb]^pe_](jaie`akcnÚ_](jaideankchÚ_]$eopk(jk ]ao_nep]_kjda_e`]lahkok_e`ajp]eoakneajp]eo%(i]ooei^ he_](cn]r]`]jk_knlk`]o laook]olknoej]eoaola_Ú_ko(ejo_nep]_kioej]eoaola_Ú_koaik^fapko`apaniej]`koaai aol]ko`apaniej]`ko*Okikoj omqajko]^aikoh)h]* Ikopnkqp]i^imqalkooqaiiai ne]$iepkoaj]nn]per]o`kolkrko%(pn]joiepe`] kn]hiajpa `a can]k ] can]k( _kjoanr]j`k)oa ]pn]ro `ko pailko( i]o p]i^i pn]jo) bkni]j`k)oamq]j`kiq`]i]o_kj`e ao`are`]`aqicnqlkkq`aqi]can]k*At]ie) j]j`k]oiq`]j]oj]ao_nep]aj]iai ne](ikopnkqmqap]eook_ea`]`aolkooqaideop ne]( i]omqaaop]ejoal]nrah`]nah]k`kolkrko_ki]j]pqnav](`ebanajpaiajpa`]jkoo] deop ne](mqaj]nn]_kikjkooal]n]iko`]j]pqnav]a_kik]`kiej]iko* I]o(ok^napq`k(ikopnkqlknmqaa_kikp]eook_ea`]`aook`lkqo^kian_]`ka`lkqo^ kAop]`k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(jkokok_ea`]`aopbj`ljo`flapbjBpq^al(i]o`lkqoof^p ^bibp* =ook_ea`]`aoej`caj]oaopq`]`]olkn?h]opnaookoqh)]iane_]j]oaaj_kjpn]i)oajqi aopcek]jpanekn]k`]ook_ea`]`aoej`caj]o`]=ine_]`kJknpa$Aop]`koQje`ko(?]j]`a Ite_k%a`kopnocn]j`aoeilnekoikjnmqe_kooepq]`kojkIte_k(j]=ine_]?ajpn]ha jkjknpa`]=ine_]`kOqh$eopk(ej_](]opa_]ai]e]%*Ok(lknp]jpk(ok_ea`]`aomqajkoa knc]jev]n]ij]bkni]`]o_daÚ]ojknpa)]iane_]j]ojai`kocn]j`aoeilnekoikjnmqe) _ko(i]oejrajp]n]iqi]knc]jev]kabif_bo^a^l]n]arep]naoo]o`q]obkni]o`alk`an* =o ok_ea`]`ao ej`caj]o oqh)]iane_]j]o aopq`]`]o lkn ?h]opnao ok pne^]eo kq _kiq) j]eo*Jah]o(jkdlnklnea`]`alner]`]`]pann]a`]onemqav]o(jkd]raj`k(lknp]jpk(_h]o) oaook_e]eojaihqp]`a_h]ooao*=lnklnea`]`apne^]hkq_kiqiakpn]^]hdkoa`ere`alkn oatkae`]`a*Ok`ljrkfa^abpjkoajpe`klhajk`kpanik(eopk(okejpanj]iajpadkikc) ja]o(qj]oaej`ereo]o(j]omq]eopk`kooa_kjda_ailahkjkia(okreopkoqjolahkokqpnko
0IERREß#LASTRESßß ßETNvLOGOßEß ANTROPvLOGOßFRANCoS
00,
=re`]lkhpe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
%GBERTOß.OGUEIRA!BRILß)MAGENS
`e]ne]iajpaalkooqaiqi`aopejk_kiqi*=klkoekak_kjÛepkjkoaaop]^aha_aijk ejpanekn`]_kiqje`]`a(i]oaioaqatpanekn(eopk(j]ooq]onah] ao_ki]okqpn]o_kiq) je`]`ao(lknp]jpk(jkmqaoanabanacqann]ao]he]j]o`ao]jcqalahk_]o]iajpk* Jah]oklk`anjkoa`aop]_]jaioaoal]n](jkbkni]qi]ejop j_e]]_ei]`ah]$_kik kAop]`k(j]lkhpe_](kq_kikk_dabal]pne]n_](jk`aolkpeoik%*Ateopa_daÚ](lkni(jk qilk`an`ai]j`k]mqa]_kiqje`]`ak^a`a_a*K_dabajki]j`]7]_kiqje`]`ajk k^a`a_a*=_kiqje`]`a`a_e`alknoeiaoi](`a]_kn`k_kioq]opn]`e aoaja_aooe`]`ao( nacqh]j`klknoeiaoi]_kjÛepkolaook]eoajpnaoaqoiai^nko*
Ej`caj]_]e]l `] ]h`ae]=qgna(jkL]n( aifqhdk`a-55.*Jk ]jk`aoq]_ne]k $-523%(]Bqj]epejd] qi_]npanapjk_j) pne_k6oq]bqjk an]]`alnkikran ]ejpacn]k`ko lkrkoej`caj]o ok_ea`]`a*
Kmqaakmqab]vk_daba(qi]ravmqajkpai]bqjk`klk`an(lkeoaopalanpaj_a _kiqje`]`aa`ah]jkoaoal]n];K_dabalkooqepnobqj ao6`k]nlnaoajpao(b]van]l]v ab]h]n*=hi`aoo]obqj ao(_]^a_daÚ]nalnaoajp]n]_kiqje`]`alan]jpakqpn]o_kiq) je`]`aoai_]oko`a]he]j]oacqann]o* >al^ labmobpbkqbp+Atlneiej`k]^ajarkhj_e]`ko`aqoaoa]lnkolane`]`a`]_k) iqje`]`a(k_daba`ara(ai_anpkolank`ko`k]jk(kbana_anlnaoajpao]pk`kokoiai) ^nko`]pne^k(eopk(`arkhran]ah]kmqaah]iaoi]lnk`qveq*=`k]k`alnaoajpao ] i]jaen] `ahe^an]`] mqa ] _kiqje`]`a ejrajpkq l]n] eila`en mqa ]hcqi lkoo] _kj_ajpn]n^ajoanemqav]o(pknj]n)oalnklneapneklner]`k(`kiej]nkoeopai]`apnk_]o( _ne]n`aoecq]h`]`aa_kjie_]aok_e]h(`akj`aoqncai]hqp]`a_h]ooaoa]ja_aooe`]`a `klk`an`kAop]`k*=_kiqje`]`aejopepqeqiiaek`lkqo^kian_]`ka`lkqo^]kne) cai`klk`anoal]n]`k* >`lkpbos^ la^m^w+Mq]j`kb]ihe]okqej`er`qkoajpn]iai_kjÛepk(k_daba`ara ejpanren*Jk`eol a`a_ `eckohac]eol]n]]n^epn]nk_kjÛepkaijkia`]hae*Mqab]v aha;=l]v*?kik]k^pi;=lah]j`kl]n]k^kioajok`]ol]npao(]ko^kjooajpeiaj) pko(iai ne]`]_kiqje`]`a(pn]`ek`k^ki_kjrrekajpna]olaook]o*Aioqi]( lkniaek`aha]_kiqje`]`ab]h]l]n]na]Úni]n)oa_kik_kiqje`]`aej`ereo]* >m^i^so^+=hi`]`k]k`alnaoajpao(`]i]jqpajk`]l]vajpnaiai^nko`]_k) iqje`]`a( `] `elhki]_e] l]n] pn]p]n _ki kqpn]o _kiqje`]`ao ]he]`]o a `k `enaepk ] qo]n]bkn](he`an]j`kkocqannaenko`qn]jpa]cqann](]cn]j`abqjk`]_daÚ]oepq])oa j]b]h]kqj]Cn]j`aL]h]rn]*Pk`]o]op]n`ao(k_dabaoa`eneca]qihk_]h`eop]jpa`] ]h`ae](i]oreoraha`akj`alkoo]oankqre`k(a]he`eo_qno]*Ai^kn]kqre`k(jejcqi `ara`]n)hda]pajkakmqaaha`evjkkn`aikq_ki]j`kmqak^necqak^a`ej_e]* Mqa`evaha;@ev]l]h]rn]`klk`an6_]jp]oq]bkn]a_kn]cai(oaqlnaopcek(oq]nah]k _kiko`aqoao(oaqocn]j`aobaepko*I]ojejcqihda`]pajk*Jejcqikao_qp]*
00-
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Kmqaaoo]l]h]rn]alknmqak_daba`aralnkjqj_e)h]`e]ne]iajpa;=Cn]j`aL]h]rn] paioecjeÚ_]`koei^ he_k6]_kiqje`]`ahai^n]]oeiaoi](`e]ne]iajpa(kneo_kaklaneck mqa_knnane]oalkooqooaqi_dabamqahda`aooakn`ajoa]kmq]h`araooak^a`a_an*=Cn]j) `aL]h]rn]oei^khev]]i]jaen]lah]mq]h]_kiqje`]`aeila`ak]`rajpk`klk`an_kik ]hckoal]n]`k`ah]amqa]_ki]j`]ne]lah]_kank`]haea`]o]ni]o*?ki]_aneije]`] Cn]j`aL]h]rn](]ok_ea`]`aoa_khk_]`lkqo^koqnceiajpk`kAop]`k* Pk`] rav mqa k _daba jk na]hev] ]o bqj ao ejpanj]o a ] bqjk atpanj] p]eo _kik ] _kiqje`]`a ]o `aÚja( pk`]o ]o ravao mqa lnapaj`a qo]n oq]o bqj ao l]n] _ne]n k lk`an oal]n]`k(ahaiknpklah]_kiqje`]`a* Are`ajpaiajpa( jkoo] paj`j_e] oan `evan mqa aoo] knc]jev]k ln lne] `a lkrko lkq_k jqiankoko a `a qi] re`] ok_eka_kjie_] iqepk oeilhao( l]na_aj`k)jko( ] j o( iai^nko`aok_ea`]`ao_kilhat]oa`ere`e`]oai_h]ooaook_e]eo(qi]r]c]hai^n]j]qp ) le_]*Leanna?h]opnao(lkni(ej`]c]6lknmqakqpn]o_kiqje`]`ao(iqj`k]bkn](jkbkn]i _]l]vao`aeila`enkoqnceiajpk`]lnklnea`]`alner]`](`]o`ereo aook_e]eo`a_]op]oa _h]ooao(`]o`aoecq]h`]`aoa_kjie_]o`kian_]`kmqanaoqhp]n]ij]ja_aooe`]`a`a_ne]n klk`anoal]n]`k(oaf]_kiklk`an`aol pe_k(oaf]_kiklk`anlkhpe_k;Lknmqa(]Új]h(ko dkiajooq_qi^en]ija_aooe`]`a`a_ne]nkAop]`k_kiklk`an`a_kankok_e]h; Aoo]oej`]c] aoaopkj]knecai`]ÚhkokÚ]lkhpe_](mqa^qo_]naolkop]ol]n]ah]o*
#APqTULOß =obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%
=re`]^k]
M
q]j`khaikokoÚh okbkocnackoanki]jko(k^oanr]ikomqapn]p]i]lkhpe_]_kik qir]hknajk_kikqioeilhaob]pk(_kjoe`an]j`k]ateopj_e]lkhpe_]_kikÚ) j]he`]`aoqlanekn`]re`]dqi]j](_kik]sfa^_l^(ajpaj`e`]_kikn]_ekj]h(bahev afqop](ln lne]`kodkiajohernao* Ai^kn]_kjoe`anai]bkni]i]eo]hp]`are`]]`ko^ek_kjpailh]perk(eopk(`kÚh ok) bk(]Úni]imqa(l]n]kojkÚh okbko(]re`]oqlanekn]`k_e`]`kaah]o oana]hev]j]_e) `]`afqop]*Lkneookiaoik(_]^a]kÚh okbkkbana_anko_kj_aepkoran`]`aenkomqa]qteheai kqj]bkniqh]k`]iahdknlkhpe_]l]n]]_e`]`a(kqj]_kilnaajok`amq]hkiahdkn naceialkhpe_kl]n]qi]_e`]`a`apaniej]`]* Lkhpe_]aÚhkokÚ]j]o_an]ij]iaoi]lk_]*Lknoanai_kjpailkn ja]o(`ev)oamqa Î]ÚhkokÚ]Úhd]`]mifpÏaiqepko`kolneiaenkoÚh okbko$ko_d]i]`koln)ok_npe_ko% bkn]i_dabaolkhpe_koahaceoh]`knao`aoq]o_e`]`ao*Lknoq]knecai(]ÚhkokÚ]jk_aookq `anaÛapenok^nakbajiajklkhpe_k(ah]^kn]j`kpakne]ol]n]atlhe_]n]knecai`aha(oq] Új]he`]`aaoq]obkni]o*=aooaoÚh okbko`araiko]`eopejkajpnamlaboabpmqf`laml* abomliqf`l*
00.
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx
Knecai`]re`]lkhpe_]
A
jpna]oatlhe_] aook^na]knecai`]re`]lkhpe_](pnobkn]i]olnej_el]eoa]oi]eo `qn]`kqn]o6
=oejolen]`]ojkiepk`]oE`]`ao`kDkiai*Aooaiepkna_a^aqejian]orano ao(i]o( aioq]ohejd]ocan]eo(j]nn]oailnakiaoik6jklnej_lek(`qn]jpa]lneiaen]E`]`a `kDkiai(eopk(]E`]`a`aKqnk(kooanaodqi]jkorere]ij]_kil]jde]`ko`aqoao( j]o_e]if]`qhpko`enap]iajpa`]pann](an]ieiknp]eoabahevao(oq]re`]pn]jo_knne] ail]vad]nikje](oaija_aooe`]`a`ahaeoackranjk* Ai_]`]ranok`aooaiepk(j]nn])oa]lan`]kqkÚi`]E`]`a`aKqnk*Ai_]`] qi]`]orano ao(]lan`]`]E`]`a`aKqnkj]nn]`]`aik`k`eranok(lkni(aipk`]o( ]j]nn]per]nah]p]qi]mqa`]`kodqi]jko(mqaok]b]op]`ko`ko`aqoao(pknj]i)oa iknp]eo(reraieokh]`]iajpalah]oÛknaop]o(oairaopqnek(ikn]`e](]heiajp]koa) cqn](oailna]ia]]`kolah]oban]oaejpailneao*Lkq_k]lkq_k(`ao_k^naikbkck $ai]hcqjoiepko(qi`aqo_kil]`a_e`khdao`kbkck%6l]oo]i]_kvanko]heiajpkoa ]pn]^]hd]nkoiap]eo(_kjopnkai_]^]j]o(pa_aikraopqnek(b]^ne_]i]ni]ol]n]_]] alnkpak_kjpn]]jei]eobankvao(bkni]ib]ihe]o*Aopkj]E`]`a`k>nkjvaal]oo]) nk(pailko`alkeo(E`]`a`kBannk(]hpei]`]oe`]`ao* Aican]h(]E`]`a`kBannk`ao_nep]_kik]an]`kodkiajoknc]jev]`koaicnq) lko(b]vaj`kcqann]ajpnaoe*L]n]_aoo]nkaop]`k`acqann](ko`aqoaob]vaij]o_anqi dkiai aiejajpa( mqa na`ecen ]o lneiaen]o haeo a _ne]n k ckranjk* Aooa ao_khde`k a ajre]`k`ko`aqoaokhaceoh]`kn*?kiaha(j]o_a]lkhpe_]* ?kir]ne]jpao(aooaiepkoanqo]`kj]Cn_e]lknLh]pka(aiNki](lkn?_ank( l]n]oei^khev]n]knecai`]lkhpe_]_kik]pere`]`a`]n]vklkniaek`]ohaeoa`]Úcq) n]`khaceoh]`kn*Haeoahaceoh]`knc]n]jpai]knecain]_ekj]h`]re`]lkhpe_](]k^n]`] n]vkoaj`k]kn`ai(]d]nikje]a]_kj_ n`e]ajpnakodqi]jkoj]bkni]`]_e`]`a* =n]vkbqj`]]lkhpe_]*
.*
=oejolen]`]olah]k^n]`klkap]cnackDaok`k(Lqo^_^ielblpaf^p*=ckn](]knecai `]re`]lkhpe_]rej_qh])oa`k]k`kbkck]kodkiajo(baep]lahkoaie`aqoLnkiapaq( mqankq^]kbkck`ko`aqoaoaoanlqje`klknahao$qiinpen`erejkmqaoao]_neÚ_] lahk^ai`kodqi]jko%*Cn]]o]kbkck(kodqi]jkolk`aipn]^]hd]nkoiap]eo(_kvan ko]heiajpko(b]^ne_]nqpajohekoaok^napq`k`ao_k^nen)oa`ebanajpao`ko]jei]eo*Aoo] `ao_k^anp]kohar]]lan_a^anmqarerankiahdknoareranaiai_kiqje`]`a(`ere`ej) `kkopn]^]hdkoa]op]nab]o*Knc]jev]`koai_kiqje`]`ao(_khk_]i)oaok^]lnkpak `ko`aqoao(`amqaina_a^ai]ohaeoa]okneajp] aol]n]kckranjk* Lkq_k ] lkq_k( lkni( `ao_k^nai mqa oq] re`] lkooqe lnk^hai]o a ateca okhq) aomqaokiajpaahaolk`aiajbnajp]naaj_kjpn]n*I]jpaj`k]lea`]`alahko`aq) oao(ajpnap]jpk(_ne]ihaeoaejopepqe aodqi]j]o(`]j`kknecai_kiqje`]`alkhpe_] lnklne]iajpa `ep]* Jk iepk `a Daok`k( ] _kiqje`]`a lkhpe_] j]o_a( lknp]jpk( jk _kikk^n]`aqihaceoh]`knkq`aqibqj`]`knajre]`kolahko`aqoao(i]o_kikqi] _kjrajkajpnadkiajomqa`a_e`aireranai_kiqia_ki^ej]iajpnaoe]onacn]o ajkni]o]mqak^a`a_ank* Aooaiepkhar]pakne]lkhpe_]`abaj`e`]lahkookÚop]o*Jaoo]_kj_alk(k`aoaj) rkhreiajpk`]op_je_]oa`ko_kopqiao_kj`qv]_kjraj aoajpnakodqi]jkol]n]] re`]ai_kiqje`]`aok^haeo*=_kjrajkbqj`]]lkhpe_]*
/*
=opakne]omqa]Úni]imqa]lkhpe_]`a_knna`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]amqa]_e`]`aateopa lknj]pqnav]*Kodqi]jkook(lknj]pqnav](`ebanajpao`ko]jei]eo(lknmqaok`kp]) `ko`kidlp(eopk(`]l]h]rn]_kikb]h]alajo]iajpk*Lknoanai`kp]`ko`]l]h]rn]( okj]pqn]hiajpaok_e]eokq(_kik`ev=neop pahao(okÎ]jei]eolkhpe_koÏ*
0ERSONALITIES4OPHANß0ICTUREPOINT 4OPFOTO+EYSTONE
-*
(ESqODOßSmCß6)))ßA# ß POETAßGREGO
00/
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
J]pakne]lkhpe_]]neopkphe_](jklna_eok^qo_]njko`aqoao(j]ohaeokqj]op_je) _]o]knecai`]_e`]`a6^]op]_kjda_an]j]pqnav]dqi]j]l]n]jah]aj_kjpn]n]_]qo] `]lkhpe_]*Kodqi]jko(b]h]jpaoalajo]jpao(okoanao`a_kiqje_]kaaoo]]_]qo] `]re`]ai_kiqje`]`akq`]re`]lkhpe_]*Jaoo]_kj_alk(]j]pqnav]$_kikj]pq) nav]dqi]j]%bqj`]]lkhpe_]* J] lneiaen] pakne]( ] lkhpe_] k nai`ek mqa ] n]vk aj_kjpn] l]n] ] lan`] `] bahe) _e`]`a `] _kiqje`]`a knecejne]* J] oacqj`]( ] lkhpe_] naoqhp] `k `aoajrkhreiajpk `]o p_je_]oa`ko_kopqiao(oaj`kqi]_kjrajkdqi]j]*J]pan_aen](ajÚi(]lkhpe_]`aÚja ]ln lne]aooj_e]`kdkiai(a]_e`]`a_kjoe`an]`]qi]ejopepqekj]pqn]h*Ajmq]jpk ]o`q]olneiaen]onaah]^kn]in]_ekj]hiajpa]oatlhe_] aoipe_]o(]pan_aen]l]npa`enap]) iajpa`]`aÚjek`]j]pqnav]dqi]j]*
Bej]he`]`a`]re`]lkhpe_]
L
]n]kocnacko(]Új]he`]`a`]re`]lkhpe_]an]]fqope]j]_kiqje`]`a*=jkk`afqo) pe]bkn](eje_e]hiajpa(ah]^kn]`]aipanikoipe_ko_ki^]oaaipnoÚcqn]olnej_e) l]eo6qejfp(]hae`erej]pn]ve`]lah]`aqo]Pdieo(mqaejopepqe]kn`ai`kQjeranok7 hpjlp(]kn`aiqjerano]haop]^aha_e`]lah]hae`erej]7aafh(]fqope]mqa]`aqo]@egejo) pepqeajpna]o_keo]oaajpnakodkiajo(jknaolaepkohaeo`erej]oakn`ai_ oie_]*Lkq_k] lkq_k(]jkk`aafhe`ajpeÚ_])oa_ki]nacn]j]pqn]hl]n]]]k`]o_keo]oa`kodkiajo ak_nepnekl]n]fqhc)h]o* =e`ae]`afqope]oanabana(lknp]jpk(]qi]kn`ai`erej]aj]pqn]h(mqanacqh](fqhc]a lqja]o] ao`]o_keo]oa`kooanaodqi]jko*=fqope]]haea]kn`ai`kiqj`k(eopk( `]j]pqnav]kqmevpfp*Hae$kjlp%(j]pqnav]$mevpfp%akn`ai$hpjlp%_kjopepqai]ooeik _]ilk`]e`ae]`afqope]* =ejrajk`]lkhpe_]ateceqmqa]oatlhe_] aoipe_]obkooai]b]op]`]oÍqejfpaafh `aet]n]i`aoanreop]o_kik`q]o`aqo]omqaeilqjd]ikn`aiahaeo]kiqj`ka]kooanao dqi]jkol]oo]j`k]oecjeÚ_]n]o`^rp^pmqab]vaid]rankn`ai(haeafqope]j]j]pqnav]aj] mifp*Fqopkkmqaoacqa]kn`aij]pqn]hanaolaep]]haej]pqn]h*I]o]mifpateopalknj]pqna) v]kqlkn_kjrajkajpnakodkiajo;=fqope]a]haelkhpe_]okj]pqn]eokq_kjraj_ekj]eo; Aoo]oej`]c] ao_khk_]i(`aqih]`k(kookÚop]o(`abajoknao`k_]npan`lksbk`flk^i`]fqope) ]a`]hae(a(`akqpnk(Lh]pka=neop pahao(`abajoknao`k_]npank^qro^i`]fqope]a`]hae*
=lkoek`kookbeop]o L]n]kookÚop]o(]mifpj]o_alkn_kjrajkajpnakooanaodqi]jkomq]j`klan_a^ai mqahdaoi]eopeh]re`]ai_kiqi`kmqaaieokh]iajpk*?kjraj_ekj]inacn]o`a_kj) rerj_e]mqaoapknj]ihaeo(kjlp*=fqope]k_kjoajokmq]jpkohaeoa]Új]he`]`a`] lkhpe_]_ne]nalnaoanr]naooa_kjoajok* Oa]mifpa]ohaeook_kjraj aodqi]j]o(lk`aiiq`]n(`ao`amqad]f]iq`]j] j]o_en_qjop j_e]o*=fqope]oanjko _kjoanr]n]ohaeo(i]op]i^ilaniepenoq]iq`]j) ]oaimqaeook`aopnq]]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_](a]je_]i]jaen]`ana]hev]niq`]j]ooai `aopnqek`]kn`ailkhpe_]k`a^]pal]n]_dac]n]k_kjoajok(eopk(]atlnaookl^he_] `]rkjp]`a`]i]ekne](k^pe`]lahkrkpk`ko_e`]`konaqje`koai]ooai^hae]* Lknaooaikperk(kookÚop]ooa]lnaoajp]r]i_kiklnkbaooknao`]]npa`]`eo_qooka `]lanoq]oklah]l]h]rn]$obqof`^%*Ia`e]jpanaiqjan]k(ajoej]r]ikofkrajo]`eo_qpen ail^he_k(]`abaj`ana_ki^]pankleje ao(ajoej]j`k)hdao]ncqiajpkolanoq]oerkol]n] koln oako_kjpn]oaipk`]o]omqaop ao* =Új]he`]`a`]lkhpe_]an]]fqope]ajpaj`e`]_kik`lk`oaf^ajpnako_e`]`ko(_kj) oacqe`] j] `eo_qook l^he_] `a kleje ao a ejpanaooao _kjpnneko* K `a^]pa `ko klkopko( ] atlkoeklanoq]oer]`ko]ncqiajpko]jp]cje_ko`are]ihar]nrep ne]`kejpanaooai]eo ^ai]ncqiajp]`k(]lnkr]`klahkrkpk`]i]ekne]*
000
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx
Aiklkoek]kookÚop]o(Lh]pka=neop pahao]Úni]ik_]npanj]pqn]h`]mifpa`]fqo) pe]*Ai^kn]_kj_kn`aijaooa]ola_pk(`ebanaijkik`k_kik_kj_a^ai]ln lne]fqope]*
=lkoek`aLh]pk L]n]Lh]pk(kooanaodqi]jkoa]mifplkooqai]iaoi]aopnqpqn]*Kodqi]jkook `kp]`ko`apno]hi]okqpnolnej_leko`a]pere`]`a6]]hi]_kj_qleo_ajpakq`aoaf]jpa$oe) pq]`]j]oajpn]jd]okqjk^]etkrajpna%(mqa^qo_]o]peob]k`ko]lapepao`k_knlk(p]jpkko ja_aoonekook^narerj_e]_kikkomqa(oeilhaoiajpa(_]qo]iln]van7]]hi]en]o_rahkq _khne_]$oepq]`]jklaepkkqjk_kn]k%(mqa`abaj`ak_knlk_kjpn]]o]cnaoo ao`kiaek ]i^eajpaa`akqpnkodqi]jko(na]cej`k`knj]lnkpak`ajkoo]re`]7a]]hi]n]_ekj]h kqejpaha_pq]h$oepq]`]j]_]^a]%(mqaoa`a`e_]]k_kjda_eiajpk(p]jpkj]bkni]`alan_al) aoakleje aorej`]o`]atlanej_e]_kikj]bkni]`ae`ae]oran`]`aen]o_kjpailh]`]o lahklqnklajo]iajpk* P]i^i]mifplkooqeqi]aopnqpqn]pnel]npepa(bkni]`]lknpno_h]ooaook_e]eo6]_h]o) oaa_kjie_]`kolnklneapneko`apann](]npaokoa_kian_e]jpao(mqac]n]jpa]ok^narerj) _e]i]pane]h`]_e`]`a7]_h]ooaiehep]n`kocqannaenko(naolkjorahlah]`abao]`]_e`]`a7a] _h]ooa`koi]ceopn]`ko(mqac]n]jpakckranjk`]_e`]`aok^]ohaeo* Qidkiai(`evLh]pk(ejfqopkmq]j`k]]hi]_kj_qleo_ajpa$ko]lapepaoaln]vanao% i]eobknpa`kmqa]okqpn]o`q]o(`kiej]j`k)]o*P]i^iejfqopkmq]j`k]]hi]_khne_] $]]cnaooere`]`a%i]eolk`anko]`kmqa]n]_ekj]h(`kiej]j`k)]*Kmqa(lkeo(kdkiai fqopk;=mqaha_qf]]hi]n]_ekj]h$lajo]iajpkarkjp]`a%i]eobknpa`kmqa]okqpn]o`q]o ]hi]o(eilkj`k_kj_qleo_ajpa]renpq`a`]pailan]j]kqik`an]k(a_khne_](]ren) pq`a`]_kn]cai(mqa`ara_kjpnkh]n]_kj_qleo_j_e]*Kdkiaifqopkkdkiairenpqkok7 ]renpq`a(`kijekn]_ekj]hok^nak`aoafka]_ han]*=fqope]pe_]]dean]nmqe]`]o]hi]o( ]n]_ekj]h(oqlanekn(mqa`kiej]]oejbaneknao* Kmqa]fqope]lkhpe_];Aoo]iaoi]dean]nmqe](i]o]lhe_]`]_kiqje`]`aÍkoo^eko haceoh]`knao`araickranj]n(koiehep]nao(oq^kn`ej]`ko]kohaceoh]`knao(`arai`abaj`an] _e`]`a(akoiai^nko`]_h]ooaa_kjie_](oq^kn`ej]`ko]kohaceoh]`knao(`arai]ooacqn]n] ok^narerj_e]`]mifp*?kikna]hev]n]_e`]`afqop];Lah]a`q_]k`ko_e`]`koÍdkiajoa iqhdanao$Lh]pkjkat_hqe]oiqhdanao`]lkhpe_]a_nepe_]kocnackolknat_hq)h]o%* @ao`a]lneiaen]ejb j_e](]mifp`arapki]nl]n]oek_qe`]`kpkp]h`]o_ne]j]o(a`q) _]j`k)]ol]n]]obqj aoja_aoone]o_e`]`a*=a`q_]k`ko_e`]`kooq^iapa]o_ne]j]o ]qi]iaoi]bkni]keje_e]hai_qfkpniejkl]oo]ilknqi]oahak6]oiajko]lp]o oank`aopej]`]o_h]ooaa_kjie_](ajmq]jpk]oi]eo]lp]olnkooacqenkkoaopq`ko*Qi] jkr]oahakoal]n]kofkrajo6koiajko]lpkooank`aopej]`ko_h]ooaiehep]najmq]jpk koi]eo]lpko_kjpejq]nk]oana`q_]`ko*Kjkrk_e_hka`q_]_ekj]hajoej]]o_ej_e]o]ko fkrajoakooq^iapa]qi]hpei]oahak6koiajko]lpkooankko]`iejeopn]`knao`]mifp ajmq]jpkkoi]eo]lpkolnkooacqenkkoaopq`ko*=lnaj`ai(]ckn](]ÚhkokÚ](mqakopn]jo) bkni]naio^ekohaceoh]`knao(l]n]mqaoaf]i]_h]ooa`enecajpa* =_e`]`afqop]ckranj]`]lahkoÚh okbko(]`iejeopn]`]lahko_eajpeop]o(lnkpace`]lahko cqannaenkoai]jpe`]lahkolnk`qpknao*?]`]_h]ooa_qilnenoq]bqjkl]n]k^ai`]mifp( n]_ekj]hiajpa`enece`]lahkoÚh okbko*Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](]_e`]`aejfqop]]mqah]j]mq]hk ckranjkaopj]oiko`kolnklneapneko$mqajklajo]ijk^ai_kiqi`]mifpahqp]nk lknejpanaooaoa_kjie_kol]npe_qh]nao%(kqj]`koiehep]nao$mqaiancqhd]nk]_e`]`aai cqann]ol]n]o]peob]vanoaqo`aoafkol]npe_qh]nao`adkjn]ach ne]%*OkiajpakoÚh okbkopi _kikejpanaooak^aican]h`]mifpaokiajpaahaolk`aickranj)h]_kifqope]*
=lkoek`a=neoppahao
001
=neop pahaoah]^kn]qi]pakne]lkhpe_]`erano]`]`kookÚop]oa`aLh]pk* L]n]`apaniej]nkmqa]fqope](`evaha(lna_eo]iko`eopejcqen`keopelko`a^ajo6ko l]npehdraeoakol]npe_elraeo*Qi^ail]npehdrahmq]j`kqi]nr^kqfa^abmqalk`a oan`ere`e`]a`eopne^q`]$]nemqav]qi^ail]npehdrah%*Qi^ail]npe_elrahmq]j`k
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
qi]nr^ifa^abej`ereorah(mqajklk`aoannal]npe`]jai`eopne^q`](lk`aj`k]laj]ooan l]npe_el]`]$klk`anlkhpe_kqi^ail]npe_elrah%*Ateopai(lkeo(`keopelko`afqope]j] _e`]`a6]`eopne^qper](nabanajpa]ko^ajoa_kjie_kol]npehdraeo7a]l]npe_el]per](nabanaj) pa]klk`anlkhpe_kl]npe_elrah*=_e`]`afqop]o]^an`eopejcqe)h]oana]hev]n]i^]o* =fqope]`eopne^qper]_kjoeopaai`]n]_]`]qikmqa`are`kaoq]bqjk`]n`aoe) cq]hiajpa]ko`aoecq]eol]n]pknj)hkoecq]eo*Oqlkjd]iko(lknatailhk(mqa]mifpaopaf] ]pn]raoo]j`kqilank`k`abkiaai`a_knnj_e]`aoa_]okqaj_dajpaoamqa]`mqen]]he) iajpkol]n]`eopne^q)hko]pk`ko*L]n]oanfqop](]_e`]`ajklk`annal]npe)hko`aik`kecq]h l]n]pk`ko*@ab]pk(]komqaoklk^nao(`ara`k)hko(i]o(]komqaokne_ko(`araraj`)hko( `aik`k]_kjoacqenbqj`kol]n]]mqeoek`ajkrko]heiajpko*Oa`k]n]pk`kokqraj`an] pk`ko(oanejfqop]*P]i^ioanejfqop]oa]pne^qen]pk`ko]oiaoi]omq]jpe`]`ao`a]heiaj) pko(lkeo`]nmq]jpe`]`aoecq]eol]n]b]ihe]o`aoecq]eo(qi]oi]eojqianko]o`kmqakqpn]o* Aioqi](ejfqopkpn]p]necq]hiajpako`aoecq]eoafqopkpn]p]n`aoecq]hiajpako`aoecq]eo l]n]mqana_a^]ikol]npehdraeooacqj`koq]o_kj`e aoaja_aooe`]`ao* =bqjkkqÚj]he`]`a`]fqope]`eopne^qper]oaj`k]`aecq]h]nko`aoecq]eo(`]j`k)hdao `aoecq]hiajpako^ajo(eilhe_]]Úni]nmqajqi]_e`]`aaimqa]`ebanaj]ajpnane_koalk) ^naoiqepkcn]j`ab]vreckn]n]ejfqope](lkeojk`]pk`kokmqahdao`are`k_kikoanao dqi]jko*J]_e`]`aejfqop](]ohaeo(aihqc]n`alaniepenai]kolk^naok]_aookonemqav]o $lkniaek`aheiep] aoeilkop]oatpajok`]lnklnea`]`a(`aÚt]k`]^k]naiqjan]) k`kpn]^]hdk`kopn]^]hd]`knaolk^nao(`aeilkopkoapne^qpkomqana_]e]iok^nakone_ko ]laj]o(ap_*%(ra`]i)hdaop]h`enaepk*Kn](okiajpakomqajkokbkn]`kooh]^qp]oejejpan) nqlp]ol]n]]ok^narerj_e]ok_]l]vao`aqi]re`]lhaj]iajpadqi]j]abahev*=_e`]`a ejfqop](lknp]jpk(eila`amqaqi]l]npa`ko_e`]`kopajd]]ooacqn]`kk`enaepkre`]^k]* Lkn oq] rav( ] fqope] lkhpe_] _kjoeopa ai naolaep]n k ik`k lahk mq]h ] _kiqje`]`a `aÚjeq]l]npe_el]kjklk`an*Aoo]`aÚjek`alaj`a`]mqehkmqa]_e`]`ai]eor]hknev]a konaceiaolkhpe_kor]ne]iaibqjk`kr]hkni]eonaolaep]`klahko_e`]`ko* D_e`]`aomqar]hknev]i]dkjn]$eopk(]dean]nmqe]ok_e]h^]oa]`]jko]jcqa(j]pann] aj]opn]`e ao%afqhc]imqaklk`an]dkjn]i]eo]hp]amqa_]^a]qio 6pai)oa]jl* k^onrf^(j]mq]hfqopkmqaqio l]npe_ela`klk`an*D_e`]`aomqar]hknev]i]renpq`a _kik at_ahj_e] `a _]npan $_kn]cai( ha]h`]`a( Ú`ahe`]`a ]k cnqlk a ]ko ]jpal]oo]`ko% a fqhc]imqaklk`an_]^a]koiahdknao6pai)oa]^ofpql`o^`f^(j]mq]hfqopkmqaokiajpa ]hcqjol]npe_elai`klk`an*D_e`]`aomqar]hknev]i]ecq]h`]`a$okecq]eokomqaok hernao%(_kjoe`an]i]`ebanaj]a_kjie_]ajklkhpe_]ajpnane_koalk^naoafqhc]imqa pk`kolkooqaik`enaepk`al]npe_el]n`klk`an6pai)oa]abjl`o^`f^(j]mq]hfqopkmqa pk`kockranjai* Ajmq]jpkLh]pkoalnak_ql]_ki]a`q_]kabkni]k`k`enecajpalkhpe_k$kckran) j]jpaÚh okbk%(=neop pahaooaejpanaoo]lah]mq]he`]`a`]oejopepqe aolkhpe_]o$]ooai^hae]o( pne^qj]eo(bkni]`]_khap]`aeilkopkoapne^qpko(`eopne^qek`]nemqav](knc]jev]k`k atn_epk(ap_*%*?kieook(]i^kohac]il]n]]opakne]olkhpe_]ooq^oamqajpao`q]oi]jaen]o `a_kj_a^ankj`aoaoepq]]mq]he`]`afqop]`]_e`]`a6lh]pkje_]iajpa(aoo]mq]he`]`a`a) laj`a`]osfoqrabpalafofdbkqb7]neopkpahe_]iajpa(`]osfoqrabpa^pfkpqfqrf bp*
Konaceiaolkhpe_ko
@
keork_^qhkocnackookailnac]`kol]n]_kilkn]ol]h]rn]omqa`aoecj]ikona) ceiaolkhpe_ko6^ohe$ÎkmqaaopbnajpaÏ(Îkmqapai_ki]j`kÏ%aho^qp$Îklk`an kq ]qpkne`]`a oqlnai]Ï%* =o l]h]rn]o _kilkop]o _ki ^ohe $^onrf^% `aoecj]i ] nr^kqfa^ab`komqaaopkjk_ki]j`k*=o_kilkop]o_kiho^qp$`o^`f^%`aoecj]inrbj aopjklk`an* =ooei(`klkjpk`areop]`]^ohe(konaceiaolkhpe_kook6ikj]nmqe]kqckranjk`a qio $jlk^p%(khec]nmqe]kqckranjk`a]hcqjo$lifdf%(lkhe]nmqe]kqckranjk`aiqepko $mlilp%a]j]nmqe]kqckranjk`ajejcqi$^k^%*
002
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx KRATvSßOSßTERMOSßß COMPOSTOSßCOMßCRACIAß SjOßAUTOSß±EUßMESMO² ß ±EUßPRvPRIO² ß±SIßMESMO² ß ARISTOSß±OßMELHOR² ßß ±OßMAISßEXCELENTE² ßß DEMOSß±OßPOVO²
@klkjpk`areop]`kho^qp(konaceiaolkhpe_kook6]qpk_n]_e]$lk`an`aqi]je_] laook]Í^rqpÍ(na_kjda_e`]_kiknae%(]neopk_n]_e]$lk`an`ko^ofpqf(eopk(`koiahdk) nao%(`aik_n]_e]$lk`an`kabjlp(eopk(`klkrk%* J]Cn_e]aj]Nki]]n_]e_]olna`kiej]n]i]oikj]nmqe]o*Jkajp]jpk(ai^kn]ko ]jpeckonaeo]Úni]ooaipanknecai`erej]arkjp]`a]^okhqp](]ok_ea`]`aaop]r]knc]jev]`] `ap]hbkni]mqakckranj]jpalna_eo]r]oq^iapan]o`a_eo ao]qi?kjoahdk`a=j_ekoa ]ooai^hae]`kocqannaenkokq_dabaoiehep]nao*Eookbav_kimqa(lkq_k]lkq_k(knaceia oapknj]ooakhecnmqe_k(Ú_]j`kj]oiko`]ob]ihe]oi]eone_]oaiehep]niajpai]eolk`a) nko]o(_qfkoiai^nkooa_kjoe`an]r]i(lknoaqo]jcqa(b]ihe]ahejd]cai(koÎiahdknaoÏ( `kj`a ] bkni]k `] ]neopk_n]_e] cnac]( kq oa _kjoe`an]r]i oqlaneknao lkn panai _kik ]j_aopn]eokol]eobqj`]`knao`]_e`]`a(`kj`a]bkni]k`kl]pne_e]`knki]jk* Kje_knaceiaran`]`aen]iajpa`aik_npe_kbkek`a=paj]o*J]o`ai]eo_e`]`aocna) c]o a ai Nki]( k naceia lkhpe_k an] khecnmqe_k( oaj`k ]o b]ihe]o ne_]o dana`epne]o jk lk`an(iaoikmq]j`k]`iepe]i]ajpn]`]`ajkrkoiai^nkojkckranjk(lkeo]ojkr]o b]ihe]op]i^ioapknj]r]idana`epne]o* @araiko]Lh]pka]=neop pahaopnoe`ae]olkhpe_]o(ah]^kn]`]o_ki^]oaj]atlanej) _e]lkhpe_]]jpec]6]lneiaen]`ah]o]`eopejkajpnanaceiaolkhpe_koajklkhpe_ko7] oacqj`](]`]_]qo]`]r]ne]k`anaceiaolkhpe_ko7]pan_aen]oanabanapn]jobkni]k`a qinaceialkhpe_kaikqpnk* Afpqfk lbkqobmliqf`lbklmliqf`l+Qinaceiao lkhpe_koabknejopepq`klknqi _knlk`ahaeolq^he_]iajpana_kjda_e`kaok^kmq]hpk`korerai(ckranj]jpaoao`e) pko(ckranj]jpaoa_e`]`ko*Aioqi](lkhpe_kknaceiajkmq]hkockranj]jpaoaopk oq^iape`koohaeo*Mq]j`k]hae_kej_e`a_ki]rkjp]`alaook]ha]n^epnne]`kckran) j]jpa(jkdlkhpe_](i]o`aolkpeoikapen]je]*Mq]j`kjkdhae`aaol_ea]hcqi]( jkdlkhpe_](i]o]j]nmqe]*=lnaoaj]kq]qoj_e]`]hae_kj`qve`ae]`anaceiao lkhpe_koibdqfjlpafibdqfjlp*Qinaceiahacpeikmq]j`k(]hi`ahac]h(fqopk$]o haeookbaep]ooacqj`k]fqope]%7qinaceiaehacpeikmq]j`k]haeejfqop]kqmq]j) `k_kjpnnekhae(eopk(ehac]h(kq(ajÚi(mq]j`kjklkooqehae]hcqi]* S^ofba^ababobdfjbpmliqf`lp*L]n]=neop pahao(]r]ne]k`konaceiaolkhpe_ko`alaj) `a`a`keob]pknaolnej_el]eo6]j]pqnav]kqj`kha`klkrka]atpajok`kpannep nek* =ooei(lknatailhk(qilkrk_qf]j`khakqj]pqnav]paj`aaolkjp]ja]iajpal]n]] ecq]h`]`aa]he^an`]`aa_qf]_e`]`a`alamqaj]atpajokpannepkne]h(j]pqn]hiajpa ejopepqenqi]`aik_n]_e]aoani]h)]reo]`koa]oq^opepqenlknqikqpnknaceia*Ai _kjpn]l]npe`](qilkrk_qf]j`khakqj]pqnav]paj`aaolkjp]ja]iajpal]n]]k^a) `ej_e]]qi]je_]]qpkne`]`aamqarerajqipannep nekatpajok(j]pqn]hiajpaejo) pepqen]ikj]nmqe](oaj`k`ao]reo]`koa]oq^opepqenlknkqpnknaceialkhpe_k*@aoo] i]jaen](koÚh okbkocnackohac]n]i]kK_e`ajpa]e`ae]`aobdfjbpmliqf`lpk^qro^fp( eopk(]e`ae]`amqa]ejopepqek`aqinaceialkhpe_k`alaj`a`ab]pknaolnk`qve`ko lah]j]pqnav]$]j`khaj]pqn]h`aqilkrkakpelk`apannep nekaimqaoaejop]h]%* @loorm lalpobdfjbpmliqf`lp+Konaceiaolkhpe_kooapn]jobkni]iai`a_knnj_e] `aiq`]j]oa_kjie_]o$]qiajpk`kjiank`ane_koa`eiejqek`kjiank`a lk^nao(`eiejqek`kjiank`ane_koa]qiajpk`kjiank`alk^nao%a`anaoqhp]) `ko`acqann]o$_kjmqeop]o`ajkrkopannep nekoalklqh] ao(oq^ieook]raj_a`knao mqa_kjmqeop]i]_e`]`a%*
003
Lnaoaj]kq]qoj_e]`]hae(r]ne]ka_kjie_]aiehep]n`apaniej]i(oacqj`kLh]pk a=neop pahao(]_knnqlkkq`a_]`j_e]`konaceiaolkhpe_ko6]ikj]nmqe]`acajan]aipe) n]je]mq]j`kqio ckranj]l]n]oanren]koejpanaooaolaook]eo7]]neopk_n]_e]`acajan]ai khec]nmqe]`koiqepkne_ko$lhqpk_n]_e]%kq`kocqannaenko$peik_n]_e]%(mqap]i^ickran) j]i]laj]oaiejpanaooaln lnek7]`aik_n]_e]`acajan]ai`ai]ckce]aaop](ai]j]nmqe]* Aican]h(]]j]nmqe]har]pen]je](mq]j`k]ok_ea`]`a(`aockranj]`](]lah]l]n]qidkiai oqlanekn]kokqpnkojki]jafk`]o]ni]oa`ko]ncqiajpko(jaha^qo_]j`k]o]hr]k*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
!LBUMAKG IMAGESLATINSTOCK
=pelkhkce]lh]pje_k)]neopkphe_]`konaceiaolkhpe_kooacqj`kkr]hkn`komqal]npe_e) l]i`klk`ana`]r]nea`]`a`anaceiaooacqj`k]j`khaj]pqn]h`klkrka`]o_kj`e ao j]pqn]eo`kpannep nek(^ai_kik]pakne]`]`a_]`j_e]kq_knnqlk`konaceiaolkhpe_ko( oanki]jpe`]o]pko_qhkTREEE(]l]na_aj`k_kirecknjqi]`]ok^n]olkhpe_]oi]eoei) lknp]jpao`]Ehqopn]k(Lbpmofqla^pibfp(`aIkjpaomqeaq*
pe_]alkhpe_]
O
a]lkhpe_]pai_kikÚj]he`]`a]re`]fqop]abahev(eopk(]re`]lnklne]iajpadqi]j] `ecj]`aoanaohernao(ajpkejoal]nrah`]pe_]* @ab]pk(l]n]kocnackoan]ej_kj_a^rah]pe_]bkn]`]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]Í]mifp _kikhlfklk^kq_kiqje`]`a`koecq]eoÍ(lkeojah]]j]pqnav]kqaooj_e]dqi]j]aj) _kjpn]r]oq]na]hev]ki]eo]hp]* Mq]j`kaopq`]iko]pe_](reikomqa=neop pahao`eopejcqen]ajpnapakne]alnpe_]a( jaop](ajpnab]^ne_]ka]k(eopk(`ebanaj_e]n]mlfbpfp`amoufp*Reikop]i^imqana) oanr]n]moufpqihqc]ni]eo]hpk`kmqab]^ne_]k(`aÚjej`k)]_kik]krkhqjpne] `a qi ]cajpa n]_ekj]h ai reop] `a qi Úi _kjoe`an]`k ^ki* =moufp lkn at_ahj_e] ] lkhpe_]*=aooanaolaepk(j]qf`^^Kf`j^`l(ao_nara=neop pahao6
-ONTESQUIEUßß ßCUJOßNOMEßß ERAß#HARLES ,OUISßDEßß 3ECONDAT ßBARjOßDEßß -ONTESQUIEU ßMORALISTAßß EßFILvSOFOßFRANCoS
Pb)bjklpp^p^ bp)e^idrjÛjnrbabpbg^jlpmlobibjbpjlblplrqolpplab* pbg^alppmlo`^rp^abib)bpbklbp`liebjlpfkabÛkfa^jbkqb^idrj^`lfp^bjsfpq^ab rj^lrqo^%mlfp)kbppb`^pl)fo^jlp^lfkÛkfqlbklpplabpbglpbof^c qfibsl&)bsfabkqb nrbq^iÛjpmlabpbol_bj)lPrjl?bj%+++&+Pb^ppfj)absbjlp^_^o`^o)mbiljbklp bjifke^pdbo^fp)^k^qrobw^alPrjl?bjbafwboabnr^ip^_bobibmolsj+@lkpfabo^* jlpnrbbibabmbkaba^`fk`f^prmobj^b^onrfqbqkf`^mlobu`bik`f^+Lo^)q^i`fk`f^ j^kfcbpq^jbkqb^mliqf`^)mlfpbi^nrbabqbojfk^)bkqoblpp^_bobp)nr^fppllpkb* `bppoflpm^o^^p`fa^abpbnrbqfmlpabp^_bobp`^a^`i^ppbab`fa^alpabsbmlpprfo%+++&+> mliqf`^pbpbosba^plrqo^p`fk`f^pmoqf`^pbibdfpi^pl_oblnrbmob`fplc^wbobalnrb mob`fpl^_pqbo*pb8^ppfjpbkal)lÛj_rp`^almlobi^absbbkdil_^olpÛkpabqla^p^p lrqo^p)alkabpb`lk`irfnrblÛja^mliqf`^l_bjmolmof^jbkqberj^kl+Jbpjlpb elrsbofabkqfa^abbkqobl_bjalfkafsarlbla^`fa^ab)j^kfcbpq^jbkqbrj^q^obc^ jrfqlj^fpfjmloq^kqbbj^fpmbocbfq^`lkeb`bobp^is^dr^oa^ol_bja^`fa^ab)mlfpl _bjklpbdro^jbkqb^jsbijbpjlm^o^rjfkafsarl)j^pj^fp_bilbj^fpafsf* kl^mif`^al^rj^k^ llr `fa^ab+ Lh]pk e`ajpeÚ_]n] ] fqope] jk ej`er`qk a ] fqope] j] mifp* =neop pahao oq^kn`ej] k ^ai`kej`er`qk]k>aiOqlnaik`]mifp*Aooarj_qhkejpanjkajpnape_]alkhpe_]oecje) Ú_]r]mqa]omq]he`]`ao`]ohaeoa`klk`an`alaj`e]i`]omq]he`]`aoikn]eo`ko_e`]`ko are_a)rano](eopk(`]omq]he`]`ao`]_e`]`a`alaj`e]i]orenpq`ao`ko_e`]`ko*Okiajpa j]_e`]`a^k]afqop]kodkiajolk`aioan^kjoafqopko7aokiajpadkiajo^kjoafqopko ok_]l]vao`aejopepqenqi]_e`]`a^k]afqop]*
Nki]jko6]_kjopnqk`klnj_ela
=
l oklneiaenklank`k`aoq]deop ne]lkhpe_](]lk_]]n_]e_]ahaj`ne]`konaeo l]pne]n_]eo(oaie)dqi]jkoaoaie`erejko(Nki]pknj])oaqi]nal^he_]]neopk_npe) _]ckranj]`]lahkocn]j`aooajdknao`apann]o(kol]pn_eko(alahkonalnaoajp]jpao ahaepkolah]lha^a(kopne^qjko`]lha^a*Klk`an_]^a]qi]ejopepqek`aoecj]`]_kikÎOa) j]`kaLkrkNki]jkÏ(mqalk`a(ai_anp]o_en_qjop j_e]olnareop]oj]hae(na_a^anÎdkiajo jkrkoÏ(eopk(kolha^aqomqa(lknoq]onemqav]o(_]o]iajpkokqbaepkoiehep]nao(l]oo]i] b]vanl]npa`kcnqlkckranj]jpa*Nki]qi]nal^he_]lknpnoikperkolnej_el]eo6 -*
kckranjkaopoq^iape`k]haeoao_nep]oeilaook]eo7
004
%RICHß,ESSINGALBUMLATINSTOCK
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx
2OBERTß%MMETß"RIGHTß 0HOTOß2ESEARCHERSLATINSTOCK
*{LIOß#ESARßß ßA# ßA# ßLqDERßß MILITARßEßPOLqTICOßROMANO
!UGUSTOßßA# ßD# ß IMPERADORßROMANO
005
.*
]obpmr_if`^$_keo]l^he_]%kokhkl^he_knki]jk(`eopne^q`kob]ihe]ol]pn_e]o( i]olanpaj_ajpahac]hiajpa]Nki](eopk(]lnklnea`]`a`]pann]_keo]l^he_]_qfk qok_kj_a`e`klahkAop]`k]_e`]`kolner]`ko7
/*
k ckranjk ]`iejeopn] ko bqj`ko l^he_ko $na_qnoko a_kjie_ko lnkrajeajpao `a ei) lkopko(p]t]oapne^qpko%(qo]j`k)kol]n]]_kjopnqk`aaopn]`]o(]mqa`qpko(pailhko( ikjqiajpkoajkr]o_e`]`ao(al]n]]i]jqpajk`koatn_epko*
Jk_ajpnk`kckranjkaop]r]i`keo_joqhao(ahaepkolahkOaj]`kaLkrkNki]jk(]ko mq]eoan]iajpnacqao`keolk`anao6k]`iejeopn]perk$caopk`kobqj`koaoanrekol^he_ko% akfjmbofrj(eopk(klk`anfq`e_enekaiehep]n*KOaj]`knaoanr]r]l]n]oe`q]o]qpkne`]) `ao6k_kjoahdk`koi]ceopn]`koa]]qpkne`]`aikn]hok^na]naheceka]lkhpe_]* Nal^he_]khecnmqe_](Nki]qi]lkpj_e]_kirk_]kiehep]n*Ai_ejmqajp]]jko( _kjmqeop]pk`kkiqj`k_kjda_e`k(_kiat_ak`]æj`e]a`]?dej]*Aooabaepkk^n]iehe) p]n`ko_joqhao(mqa(_kik`eooaiko(bkn]iejraope`ko_kikfjmbofrj$lk`anfq`e_eneka iehep]n%*Okfjmbo^qlobp* Lkq_k]lkq_k(ia`e`]mqaNki]oapknj]qi]lkpj_e]iqj`e]h(]hcqjo`ko_j) oqhao$Fhek?ao]n(Jqi](Lkilaq%naerej`e_]ii]eolk`anai]eo]qpkne`]`a(mqahdaork oaj`k_kj_a`e`kolahkOaj]`kaLkrkNki]jk*Cn]`q]hiajpa(ok^]]l]nj_e]`aqi]na) l^he_]]neopk_npe_](ejop]h])oaqi]nal^he_]ikjnmqe_](mqaoaeje_e]_kiFhek?o]na oa_kjokhe`]j]oiko`a=qcqopk*?kiaopahpeik(]ikj]nmqe]r]elan`aj`kk_]npan nalq^he_]jk]poq^opepqenk_kjoqh]`k(pknj]j`k)oaoajdkne]h(aejopepqen)oa_kiklnej_el]) `k*Klnj_elaeilan]`kn6_dabaiehep]n(`apajpkn`klk`anfq`e_enek(i]ceopn]`k(oajdkn `]opann]o`kEilnekNki]jk(]qpkne`]`aoqlnai]*Lkneookiaoik(rnekolajo]`knaonk) i]jkonalq^he_]jko(_kikP_epk(?_ank(PepkHrek(_kjoe`an]imqa]`a_]`j_e]mliqf`^ `aNki]_kej_e`a_kikikiajpk`aoaqi]eknaolhaj`kna_kjie_kaiehep]n(eopk(k lnej_el]`k(mq]j`kkjkiaÎ?o]nÏ`aet]`ajkia]n]laook]`aFhek?o]nal]oo]]ej`e_]n ]lkoek`kckranj]jpaÍklnj_elaqi`p^o* =iq`]j]`]nal^he_]l]n]klnej_el]`kkq_ao]neoikpn]jol]na_aj]pakne]lkhpe_]* Ai^kn]aop]_kjpejqa]Úni]j`kkor]hknaonalq^he_]jkoÍeilknp j_e]`]ohaeo(`k`enaepk a`]oejopepqe aol^he_]o(l]npe_qh]niajpa`kOaj]`kaLkrkNki]jkÍ(]lnak_ql]k `kopa ne_kooai]jpirkhp]`]l]n]]Úcqn]`klnj_ela* Ejolen]j`k)oajkckranj]jpa)Úh okbk`aLh]pk(kolajo]`knaonki]jkolnk`qvenkk e`a]h`klnj_elalanbaepkkq`k?ljDlsbokl*=jkr]pakne]lkhpe_]i]jpi]e`ae]cnac] `amqa]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]pai_kikÚj]he`]`a]re`]^k]kq]fqope](e`ajpeÚ_]`]_ki ]kn`ai(d]nikje]kq_kj_ n`e]jkejpanekn`]_e`]`a*Jkajp]jpk(]ckn](]fqope]`alaj) `an`]omq]he`]`aoikn]eo`kckranj]jpa*Klnj_ela`araoankik`ahk`]orenpq`aol]n]] _kiqje`]`a(lkeoah]keiep]n* J]ran`]`a(kolajo]`knaonki]jkoren]i)oaajpna`q]opakne]o6]lh]pje_](mqalnapaj) `e]_dac]nlkhpe_]hacpei]afqop]a`q_]j`krenpqko]iajpakockranj]jpao7a]]neopkphe_]( mqalnapaj`e]_dac]nlkhpe_]hacpei]afqop]lnklkj`kmq]he`]`aolkoeper]ol]n]]oejope) pqe ao`]_e`]`a(`]omq]eo`alaj`e]i]orenpq`ao`ko_e`]`ko*Ajpna]o`q]o(konki]jko ao_khdan]i]lh]pje_](i]opaj`an]i]`]niajkneilknp j_e]knc]jev]klkhpe_]`] ok_ea`]`a$]opno_h]ooaolh]pje_]o%ai]ekneilknp j_e]bkni]k`klnj_elarenpqkok* Klnj_ela(_kikpk`koandqi]jk(l]ooekj]han]_ekj]h(lkni(`ebanajpaiajpa`ko kqpnkodqi]jko(jklk`a_a`anol]et ao(]laj]on]vk*Lkneook(`araoana`q_]`kl]n] lkooqenqi_kjfqjpk`arenpq`aomqaokln lne]o`kckranj]jpafqopk(kqoaf](]osfoqrabp mofk`fmbp`^p*Kran`]`aenksfo$Îr]nkÏ(aih]pei%lkooqepnooneao`asfoqrabpkqnr^ifa^abp jlo^fp*=lneiaen]`ah]o_kiqi]pk`kdkiairenpqkok(oaj`k_kjopepq`]lknmq]pnk renpq`aoqjerano]eomqa_]`]qi`aralkooqenoamqeoanoanrenpqkok6p^_balof^lrmorak* `f^( grpqf ^ lr bnrfa^ab( `lo^dbj b qbjmbo^k ^ lr jlabo^ l* = oacqj`] onea _kjopepqe k _kjfqjpk `]o renpq`ao lnklne]iajpa lnej_elao_]o6 elko^abw lr afpmlpf l m^o^ j^kqbo lpmofk`mflpbjqla^p^p`fo`rkpq k`f^p(j^dk^kfjfa^ablr`ibjk`f^(eopk(_]l]_e`]`a l]n]`]nlqjekfqop]al]n]lan`k]n(aif_bo^ifa^ab(eopk(`eolkoekl]n]lnoq]nemqav]
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
]oanrek`klkrk*Bej]hiajpa(]pan_aen]onea`arenpq`aonabana)oa]kok^faperkomqa`arai oan]hiaf]`kolahklnj_elarenpqkok6elko^(diof^ac^j^* ?_ankejoeopaaimqakran`]`aenklnj_ela]mqahamqajqj_]oa`aet]]nn]op]nlkn l]et aomqakpn]jobkniaijqi]^aop]*Jklk`apan]rekhj_e]`khakjai]]op_e]`] n]lko](i]o`ara(aipk`]o]o_en_qjop j_e]o(_kilknp]n)oa_kikdkiai`kp]`k`arkjp]) `an]_ekj]h*Klnj_elaoank>kiCkranjkoabknqi>ki?kjoahdk(eopk(o^ek(`araj`k ^qo_]nk]iknaknaolaepk`koo`epko* Ai_kjpn]lkjpk]k>kiCkranjk(]pakne]lkhpe_]ancqaknapn]pk`kpen]jkkqklnj) _elare_ekok6^aope]h(ejpailan]jpa(l]ooekj]h(ejfqopk(_kr]n`a(eilea`kok(]r]najpkalan`q) hnek(oaidkjn](b]i]kqch ne](k`e]`klknpk`koa`apk`kopaiankok*Ejoacqnkak`e]`k( nk`ae])oa`aokh`]`ko(reraj`keokh]`kaibknp]hav]o(paiaj`k]nq]a]_knpa* =pakne]`k>kiCkranjk`alkoep]j]mbppl^`kckranj]jpa]mq]he`]`a`]lkhpe_]ab]v `aoq]orenpq`aolner]`]orenpq`aol^he_]o*Klnj_elaaj_]nj]]_kiqje`]`aa]aolahd]( oaj`klknah]eiep]`kp]jpkj]renpq`a_kikjkr_ek*
Klk`anpakhce_k)lkhpe_k6k_neope]jeoik =dan]j]da^n]e_]anki]j] L]n] _kilnaaj`aniko ]o pakne]o lkhpe_]o _neopo( lna_eo]iko pan ai iajpa ]o `q]o pn]`e aomqak_neope]jeoikna_a^a_kikdan]j]aok^na]omq]eoah]^kn]noq]oln lne]o e`ae]o6]eb_o^f`^a]olj^k^* Koda^naqo(ai^kn]pajd]i_kjda_e`krne]oik`]he`]`ao`ackranjk$l]pne]n_]o(fq) vao(naeo%(`an]i]klk`an(ok^mq]hmqanbkni]aimqabkooaatan_e`k(qi]i]n_]bqj`]iaj) p]hennarkcrah6k`^oqboqbl`oqf`l*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(_kjoe`an]r]iahaomqaklk`an(ai oq]lhajepq`aaran`]`a(lanpaj_aat_hqoer]iajpa]@aqoamqaaopa(lkniaek`ko]jfkoa`ko lnkbap]o(ahacak`enecajpakqko`enecajpao*Klk`an$ho^qp%lanpaj_a]@aqo$qelp%(`kj`a pak_n]_e](_qf]atlnaooki]eo_h]n]oaaj_kjpn]jqi]l]oo]cai`]>^he](jkHernk`koLnk) rn^eko(kj`aoahmqa@aqo`eooa6ÎLknieinaej]ikonaeoakolnj_elaockranj]iÏ* =hi`eook(koda^naqooaÚvan]i_kjda_anjko _kikLkrk`a@aqo(i]op]i^i _kikLkrk`]Hae$]hae`erej]`]`]lneiaenk]Jk_kikhaeikn]ha(`alkeo(_kilhap]`]a `k]`]]Ikeoo_kikhaenaheceko](lkhpe_]aikn]ha_k`eÚ_]`]lknao_nepk%*=hac]he`]`aan] ]hck pk lnkbqj`k mqa( mq]j`k k _neope]jeoik oa _kjopepqe _kik jkr] nahecek( b]h])oa j] =jpec]Hae$]]he]j]`a@aqo_kiklkrk(lnkiape`]]Jka]=^n]ka`]`]]Ikeoo%aj] Jkr]Hae$]jkr]]he]j]`a@aqo_kiklkrk(]pn]ro`kiaooe]oFaoqo%* @k h]`k nki]jk( k lnk_aook mqa reaiko `ao_naraj`k ]_ei] $l]oo]cai `] nal^he_] ]klnej_el]`kapakne]`k>kiCkranjk%lnkooacqeq(ajklank`kaimqak_neope]jeoik oaatl]j`aaoaaj_kjpn]aire]`aoapknj]nnahecekkÚ_e]h`kEilnekNki]jk(klnj_ela nki]jkfoaaj_kjpn]ejraope`k`ajkrkolk`anao*Oaj`kNki]oajdkn]`kQjeranok(klnj) _elajk]laj]o(_kikoaqjkiaej`e_](Îklneiaenk_e`]`kÏ$mofk`bmp%(i]oeilan]`kn nki]jkapaj`an]oanreopk_kikoajdkn`kQjeranok(k_ql]j`kkpklk`]dean]nmqe]`k iqj`k(ai_qfk_ajpnkaopNki](mqaklkap]Renchek_d]ikq`a?e`]`aApanj]* =keilan]`kn$kq]k_o]n%_]^ai]jpan]d]nikje]a]_kj_ n`e]jkiqj`k(]m^uolj^* k^(c]n]jpe`]lah]bkn]`]o]ni]o*?kieook(klnj_elal]ookq]ajbaet]naioq]oikopk`ko kolk`anao(mqa]jpao_]^e]i]kOaj]`kaLkrkNki]jk(abkeoaj`ko]_n]hev]`k(i]jaen]`k `olkp]kneajp]h(]poan_kjoe`an]`k`erejk(oaj`k)hda]pne^q`kolk`anaomqalanpaj_e]i] Flepan6bqj`]`kn`klkrk(naop]qn]`kn`]kn`aiqjerano]hao]hr]`kn`kQjeranok* L]n] _qilnen oq]o p]nab]o( k lk`an eilane]h _ajpn]hev]`k a dean]nmqev]`k `aoajrkhra qi_kilhatkoeopai]aop]p]haimqalnar]ha_aklk`anek`kobqj_ekjnekoeilane]eo$_ereo aiehep]nao%(mqaoaaopaj`a_kikqi]na`aejpnej_]`]`alamqajkolk`anaolknpk`kkpan) nep nek`kEilnekNki]jk* = ah]^kn]k `] pakne] lkhpe_] _neop _kik qblildf^ mliqf`^ naoqhp]n `] ]lnklne]k `aoo]`qlh]dan]j]lahklk`ana_haoeope_k*
01,
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx
!LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
=ejopepqeka_haoeope_]
#ONSTANTINOß ß IMPERADORßROMANO
01-
Mq]j`kaopq`]iko]pe_](reikomqak_neope]jeoik(`ebanajpaiajpa`]i]ekne]`]o nahece ao]jpec]o(jkoqnca_kiknahecekj]_ekj]hkq`aqilkrkkq`aqiAop]`k`apan) iej]`ko*Jkajp]jpk(aha`arane]panoe`kqi]nahecekj]_ekj]h(qi]ravmqaFaoqooa]lna) oajp]r]_kikkiaooe]oaolan]`klahklkrkfq`]e_k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(oaFaoqoperaooaoe`k repknekok(lnkr]rahiajpapane]oe`k_]lepk(naeao]_an`kpa(lkeoan]]ooeimqakiaooe]od]) re]oe`kei]cej]`kaaolan]`k*@annkp]`klah]ikj]nmqe]fq`]e_](mqaqo]n]klk`an`kEi) lnekNki]jkl]n]fqhc)hka_kj`aj)hk(Faoqonaooqnca$naooqo_ep]%_kikÚcqn]lqn]iajpa aolenepq]h(nae`aqinaejkmqajk`aopaiqj`k*K_neope]jeoikoa_kjopepqe(lknp]jpk( i]ncai`klk`anlkhpe_ka_kjpn]aha(lkeokoÎnaejko`aopaiqj`kÏoank(lkq_k]lkq_k( reopko_kikk^n]`aO]p]jol]n]]lan`ek`kcjankdqi]jk* Oal]n]`k`]kn`ailkhpe_]aop]p]h(k_neope]jeoikoanknc]jev]`k`ai]jaen]oaia) hd]jpa]kqpn]o_naj]onaheceko]ojkkÚ_e]eo6pki]n]bkni]`aqi]oaep]naheceko]*Jaoo] lk_](oaep]onaheceko]oa_knnajpaoÚhko Ú_]omqajklkooq]i]mifp_kiknabanj_e]Í lkeoNki]pq`k`kiej]r]eilane]hiajpaÍjklk`e]ii]eo`enecen)oa]qi]_kiqje`]`a lkhpe_] `apaniej]`]( ] qi lkrk `apaniej]`k( a lkn eook `enece]i)oa ]k oan dqi]jk ai can]h(oai`eopejk`aj]kkqlkrk* Klk`aneilane]hnki]jk_ne]n](oaiko]^an(]e`ae]`kdkiaiqjerano]h(oailpne]a oai_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]*K_neope]jeoikoanqi]oaep]naheceko]`enece`]]kooanaodqi]) jkoaican]h(_ki]lnkiaoo]`ao]hr]kej`ere`q]hapanj]*Çe`ae]lkhpe_]`]haeao_nep]a _k`eÚ_]`]ainacn]ok^faper]o_kjpn]l a]e`ae]`ahaeikn]hejreorah$k`aran(]k^a`ej_e] ]@aqoak]ikn]kln teik%(ejo_nep]lahkL]ejk_kn]k`a_]`]qi* Pk`]re](]oaep]_neopen`ebanaj_e]n)oa`akqpn]olknmqa]dan]j]fq`]e_]$`kolneiae) nko]l opkhko%anki]j]$`kolneiaenkol]`nao%enejÛqaj_e]nkrk_]^qhnekaklajo]iajpk `ko_neopko*@ab]pk(aoo]dan]j]_kj`qvene`ae]`amlsl$`a@aqo%a`aibf$`a@aqo%(eopk (]`q]oe`ae]olnkrajeajpao`krk_]^qhneka`ko_kj_aepko`]mliqf`^*=oaep]_neopqi] `ljrkfa^ab_qfkoiai^nkobkni]ikmlsl`a@aqook^]ibf`a@aqo*Aoo]_kiqje`]`a baep]`aecq]eo$koÚhdko`a@aqona`eie`kolahkBehdk%(mqana_a^aiai_kjfqjpk]L]h]rn] O]cn]`]a(lahk^]peoikalah]aq_]neope](l]npe_el]i`]jkr]hae$]]he]j]`kL]e_kioaq lkrk lah] ia`e]k `k Behdk%* = _kiqje`]`a ] bhhibpf^( eopk ( ] ]ooai^hae] `ko Úeo( ] Fdobg^*Aaop]`aoecj]`]_kikObfklabAbrp*Mlsl(ibf(^ppbj_ibf^aobfkl6aoo]ol]h]rn]o ej`e_]i(lknoeiaoi]o(]rk_]klkhpe_]`k_neope]jeoik(lkeoao_khdal]n]nabanen)oa]oe iaoikkork_^qhko`]pn]`eklkhpe_]fq`]e_]anki]j]* =bhhibpf^knc]jev])oa]l]npen`aqi]]qpkne`]`a_kjopepq`]lahkln lnek?neopkmq]j) `k(j]hpei]_ae](]qpknev]ko]l opkhko]_aha^n]n]aq_]neope]$klkakrejdk_kikoi) ^khko`k_knlkao]jcqa`kiaooe]o%a(jk`e]`aLajpa_kopao(kn`aj])hdaomqalnacqai]k iqj`kejpaenk]jkr]haea]>k]Jkr]$lbs^kdbiel%* =]qpkne`]`a]lkop he_]jkoaheiep]]^]peoik(aq_]neope]aar]jcahev]k*Faoqo`aq ]ko]l opkhkoklk`anl]n]hec]nkodkiajo]@aqoa@aha`aohec)hko(mq]j`khdao`eooa(]pn]) ro`aLa`nk6ÎPqoLa`nkaok^naaop]la`n]a`eÚ_]nae]iejd]ecnaf](a]olknp]o`kejbanjk jklnar]ha_ank_kjpn]ah]*Aqpa`]nae]o?d]rao`kNaejk6kmqahec]naoj]Pann]oanhec]`k jk?q(kmqa`aohec]naoj]Pann]oan`aohec]`kjk?qÏ* Aoo]l]oo]cai`kAr]jcahdk`aI]paqooan_kjda_e`]_kikÎlnej_leklapnjak`]o ?d]raoÏa_kiah]aopbqj`]`]]Ecnaf]_kikejopepqek`alk`an*Aooalk`an(_kikoak^) oanr](pak_npe_k(lkeooq]bkjpakln lnek@aqo$kBehdkmqai`lk`an]La`nk%7a oqlanekn ]k lk`an lkhpe_k pailkn]h( qi] rav mqa aopa oane] lqn]iajpa dqi]jk( bnceh a lana_rah(_ne]`klknoa`qk`aikj]_]* =bhhibpf^(_kiqje`]`a`a^kjoafqopko(oal]n]`]`kAop]`ka`klk`aneilane]h(knc]je) v])oa_kijkni]oanacn]omqaaop]^aha_aidean]nmqe]o`a]qpkne`]`aa`alk`an(bkni]j`k kmqaknki]jkO]jpk=ckopejdk_d]i]n`a@fsfq^pAbf(]?e`]`a`a@aqo(klkop]?e`]`a `koDkiajo(ejfqop]ao]p je_](eopk(Nki]* Aoo]ejopepqeka_haoeope_]_kjoacqen_kjranpan]k_neope]jeoikkeilan]`kn?kjop]j) pejk(mqapn]jobkni]nqi]oaep]ainahecekkÚ_e]h`kEilnekNki]jk*?kieook(]Ecnaf]
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
enejopepq_ekj]hev]n)oanalapej`kkqeiep]j`kaioq]knc]jev]kejpanj]]aopnqpqn]iehe) p]na^qnk_npe_]`kEilnek$knc]jev]kmqalan`qn]]pko`e]o`adkfa%*
Klk`ana_haoeope_k Klk`anek`]Ecnaf]_nao_aia`e`]mqaoaaob]_ah]a`aoiknkj]kEilnekNki]jk* @keoikperkohar]i]aooa_nao_eiajpk6ailneiaenkhqc]n(]atl]jok`kln lnek_neope]jeo) iklah]k^n]`]ar]jcahev]k`kolkrko(na]hev]`]lahkol]`naojkopannep neko`kEilnek Nki]jk a l]n] ]hi `ahao7 ai oacqj`k hqc]n( lknmqa k aob]_ah]iajpk`aNki](`kmq]h naoqhp]n(jkoo_qhkooacqejpao(]bkni]kok_eka_kjie_]_kjda_e`]_kikbaq`]heoik( bn]ciajpkq ] lnklnea`]`a `] pann] $]jpanekniajpa( pe`] _kik l]pneijek `a Nki] a `k eilan]`kn% a bav oqncenai lamqajko lk`anao hk_]eo eokh]`ko( `a oknpa mqa k je_k lk`an _ajpn]hev]`kadkikcaja]iajpaknc]jev]`kan]k`]Ecnaf]* = Ecnaf]$p]jpkaiNki] _kik ai >ev j_ek( eopk ( p]jpk jk K_e) `ajpa_kikjkKneajpa%`apipnolk`anao_nao_ajpao(ia`e`]mqak EilnekNki]jk`a_]e6 -*
klk`annahecekok`ahec]nkodkiajo]@aqoa@aha`aohec)hko7
.*
klk`ana_kjie_k`a_knnajpa`acn]j`aolnklnea`]`aobqj`ene]o ]_qiqh]`]ojk_knnan`arnekoo_qhko(oaf]lknmqakojk^nao`k Eilnek(]koa_kjranpanai(`k]n]ioq]opann]oejopepqeka_ha) oeope_](oaf]lknmqaaop]na_a^an]pann]o_kikna_kilajo]lknoan) rekolnaop]`ko]koeilan]`knao7
/*
k lk`an ejpaha_pq]h( lknmqa ] Ecnaf] oa pknj] cq]n`e a ejpnlnapa je_]`kopatpkoo]cn]`ko$]>^he]%a`apk`kokopatpkolnk`qve) `kolah]_qhpqn]cna_k)nki]j]$`enaepk(ÚhkokÚ](hepan]pqn](pa]pnk( i]jq]eo `a p_je_]o( ap_*%* O]^an han a ao_naran pknjkq)oa lnereh) cek at_hqoerk `] ejopepqek a_haoeope_]* Oan ] Ecnaf]( lknp]jpk( ] bkniqh]`kn]`]opakne]olkhpe_k)_neopol]n]konaejkoaeilneko _neopko*Aoo]opakne]oah]^kn]nk]_kj_alkpakh ce_k)lkhpe_]`k lk`an(eopk(krj_qhkejpanjkajpnanahecekalkhpe_]*
!RCHIVOß)CONOGRAFICOß3!#ORBIS
=opakne]opakhce_k)lkhpe_]o J]ah]^kn]k`]pakhkce]lkhpe_](kopa ne_ko_neopko`eolqjd]i `apnobkjpaolnej_el]eo6]>^he]pn]`qve`]l]n]kh]pei(ko_ `ecko`a haeo`koeilan]`knaonki]jko(_kjda_e`ko_kik@enaepkNki]jk(a]o e`ae]onapen]`]o`a]hcqi]olkq_]ok^n]o_kjda_e`]o`aLh]pk(=neop ) pahaoaok^napq`k?_ank* @a Lh]pk rejd] ] e`ae] `] _kiqje`]`a fqop]( knc]jev]`] dean]nmqe_]iajpa a ckran) j]`]lkno^ekohaceoh]`knao*@a=neop pahaorejd]]e`ae]`amqa]Új]he`]`a`klk`anan]] fqope]_kik^aioqlnaik`]_kiqje`]`a*@a?_ank(]e`ae]`k>kiCkranjk`klnj_ela renpqkok(aolahdkl]n]]_kiqje`]`a*@apk`koahao(]e`ae]`amqa]lkhpe_]an]naoqhp]`k`] j]pqnav]a`]n]vk* Jk ajp]jpk( aoo]o e`ae]o Úhko Ú_]o lna_eo]r]i oan _kj_ehe]`]o _ki ] kqpn] bkjpa `k lajo]iajpklkhpe_k(]>^he]*A]_kj_ehe]kjkan]b_eh(qi]ravmqa]oAo_nepqn]oO]cn]) `]ojk_kjoe`an]iklk`an_kik]hckj]pqn]haknecej]`k`]n]vk(i]olnkrajeajpa`] rkjp]`a`a@aqo(oaj`k(lknp]jpk(pak_npe_k* =>^he](_kikoao]^a(qi_kjfqjpk`apatpko`alnkrajej_e]o(lk_]oa]qpknaoiqepk `ebanajpao(ao_nepkoairne]ohjcq]o$da^n]e_k(]n]i]e_k(cnack(ap_*%(mqabkni]i`keocnq) lkolnej_el]eo(k=jpeckakJkrkPaop]iajpk*=koanpn]`qve`]l]n]kh]pei(kopn]`qpknaoo `eolqjd]i`]hjcq]_qhp]nki]j]a`kopatpkomqabkni]r]ik_d]i]`k@enaepkNki]jk* =pn]`qkranpaqko`ebanajpaopatpkol]n]]hejcq]caih]pej]_hooe_](b]vaj`klnar]ha_an] hjcq]fqn`e_]ahac]hnki]j](_ki^ej]j`k(]ooei(]bknpapn]`ekhac]heop]fq`]e_]a]h]pe)
Lejpqn]`aFaoqo?neopk _kikk>kiL]opkn( `]p]`]`ko_qhkEEE `*?*(j]_]p]_qi^]`a Lneo_eh](Nki]*=jpao `a/.0`*?*(mq]j`kk _neope]jeoikpknjkq)oa nahecekkbe_e]hjk EilnekNki]jk( ko_neopkobkn]i iqepklanoacqe`koa ao_kj`e]i)oaai _]p]_qi^]o*
01.
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx
j]*Aoo]>^he]h]pejev]`]oanren`a^]oal]n]]opakne]olkhpe_]oabknja_anko_nepnekol]n] `a_e`enkmqa]_aep]nakmqana_qo]n`]oe`ae]o`aLh]pk(=neop pahaoa?_ank(_ki^ej]j`k`a i]jaen]_kilhat]a(oravao(lkq_k]_aeprah(]o_kj_al aoÚhko Ú_]oa]opak_npe_]o* =o pakne]o `k lk`an pakh ce_k)lkhpe_k( ai^kn] pajd]i na_a^e`k `ebanajpao bkniqh]) aojk_knnan`]E`]`aI`e](r]ne]j`k_kjbknia]o_kj`e aodeop ne_]oatece]i(]lnaoaj) p]r]ikooacqejpaolkjpkoai_kiqi6 klk`anpak_npe_k(eopk(lanpaj_a]@aqoa@aharai]kodkiajolknAhaao_khde`ko l]n]nalnaoajp)hk*Kbqj`]iajpk`aoo]e`ae]aj_kjpn])oajko jqi]l]oo]cai`k =jpeckPaop]iajpk(mqafiaj_ekj]iko(aimqaoahmqaÎPk`klk`anrai`k=hpk+ lknieinaej]ikonaeoackranj]ikolnj_elaoÏ(_kikp]i^ijqi]l]oo]cai`k Jkrk Paop]iajpk( j] Alopkh] `a Ok L]qhk ]ko Nki]jko( _]lpqhk TEEE( ai mqa oa h mqaÎjkd]qpkne`]`amqajkrajd]`a@aqo(a]omqaateopaibkn]iejopepq`]olkn @aqoÏ*Klk`anqib]rkn`erejkkqqi]cn]]`erej]akckranj]jpajknalnaoajp] kockranj]`ko(i]onalnaoajp]@aqolan]jpakockranj]`ko*Knaceialkhpe_k]ik) j]nmqe]pak_npe_]aimqakikj]n_]obfmbi^do^ ^abAbrp*=_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]oa bkni]lahkm^`qlabpr_jfppl`koo`epko]knae7 knae(lknmqaao_khde`klkn@aqo(@ahana_a^a]hae(kq(_kik`evaikopa hkckofqneop]o(l obfqo^w^ibfbjpbrmbfqlblnrb^mo^w^lobfqbjclo ^abibf*Knae(lknp]jpk(]bkjpa`] haea`]fqope]Í]Úni])oamqal]e`]haeaÚhdk`]fqope]*Oaj`k]qpkn`]haeapaj`kk lk`anlah]cn]]`a@aqo(aop]_ei]`]ohaeoajklk`aoanfqhc]`klknjejcqi(paj`k lk`an]^okhqpk*Kbqj`]iajpk`aoo]e`ae]napen]`k`aqilna_aepk`k@enaepkNki]jk mqa]Úni]6ÎJejcqilk`a`]nkmqajkpaiajejcqilk`apen]nkmqajk`aqÏ* Oaklk`an`]`k]knaelkn@aqo(ajpkjkbkeklkrkmqai`aqklk`an]knae( lkeoklkrkjkpaiklk`an(qi]ravmqaaopa]@aqolanpaj_a(a(lknp]jpk(klkrkp]i) ^ijklk`afqhc]nknaejaipen]n)hdaklk`an*Oaqinaebknpen je_kaejfqopk(jai ]ooeikoo`epkolk`ainaoeopen)hdajai`al)hk(lkeoahaaopjklk`anlah]rkjp]`a`a @aqo(mqa(l]n]lqjenkola_]`ko`klkrk(kb]vokbnanok^qipen]jk*AooaqiÛ]cahk `a@aqo*Lknmqaklk`anrai`k]hpk(lknmqaknael]e`]haeaaop]_ei]`ah](alknmqa koo`epkoÚvan]ikl]_pk`aoq^ieook(knaeejpk_rah7 klnj_ela_neopk`aralkooqenk_kjfqjpk`]orenpq`ao_neopo$b(aolan]j]a_]ne`]) `a%(]orenpq`ao_]n`a]eoak_kjfqjpk`]orenpq`aolnej_elao_]o`aÚje`]olkn?_anka Oja_]_kikln lne]o`k>kiCkranjk*Oaj`kaolahdk`]_kiqje`]`a(aioq]laook] `araiaop]naj_]nj]`]o]omq]he`]`ao_neopomqa]_kiqje`]`a`araeiep]n7 ]_kiqje`]`aaknaebkni]ik`lomlmliqf`l6]_]^a]]_knk]kqknae(klaepk] haceoh]kok^]cq]n`]`koi]ceopn]`koa_kjoahdaenko`knae(koiai^nkooqlaneknao okkooajdknaokq^]n aomqabkni]ikoatn_epko`knaea]ahaaopkhec]`kolknfqn]) iajpk`aÚ`ahe`]`akq`ar]oo]h]cai(akoiai^nkoejbaneknaookklkrkmqapn]^]hd] l]n] k oqopajpk `k _knlk lkhpe_k* = mifp lh]pje_] ( ]ooei( pn]jobkni]`] jk `loml mliqf`lalobf7
01/
]dean]nmqe]lkhpe_]aok_e]h_kjoe`an]`]kn`aj]`]lkn@aqoaj]pqn]h*Kiqj`kqi hpjlp(eopk(qi]kn`aiÚt]`ahqc]naoabqj aomqa_]`]oan$iejan]eo(racap]eo( ]jei]eoadqi]jko%k_ql]ja_aoo]ne]iajpaajkomq]eona]hev]oq]j]pqnav]ln lne]* Kooanao`khpjlpaopk`eopne^q`koaicn]qoakcn]qejbanekn`arak^a`ej_e]]k oqlanekn(oq^iapaj`k)oa]aha* Jk_]ok`]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_](]dean]nmqe]k^a`a_a]ko_nepneko`]obqj aoa `]nemqav](bkni]j`kloabkppl`f^fpa`lomlpkq`lomlo^ bpmqaok ncko`k_knlk lkhpe_k`knae*Jkateopa]e`ae]`aej`er`qk(i]o`akn`aikq_knlkn]k]mqa_]`] qilanpaj_alknrkjp]`a`erej](lknj]pqnav]alkndana`ep]nea`]`a(jejcqilk`aj) `koq^enkq`ao_anj]dean]nmqe]]jkoanlknrkjp]`aatlnaoo]`knae*?]`]qij]o_a( reraaiknnajkiaoikhqc]nok_e]h(pn]joiepej`k)k]ko`ao_aj`ajpao*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Aooal]lah_ajpn]hmqa]opakne]o_kjbanaie`ae]`aqi_koikdeannmqe_kknc]) jev]`kaikn`ajo(hqc]naoabqj aoÚtkonaolkj`a]pnoatecj_e]olnpe_]o6i]jpan ]_kj_alkdeannmqe_]eilane]hnki]j]aa_haoeope_](i]jpan]_kj_alkpak_npe) _]fq`]e_]a(ok^napq`k(kbana_anqi]c]n]jpe]`akn`aiaoacqn]j]pa ne_k)lkhpe_]] qi]ok_ea`]`abn]ciajp]`]ailnklnea`]`aonqn]eoeokh]`]oaaol]hd]`]olahk]jpeck pannep nek `k Eilnek l]n] ]o mq]eo f jk ateopa ] nabanj_e] qn^]j] `a Nki] _kik _ajpnkalkhkknc]jev]`kn`]na]he`]`alkhpe_]*Kiqj`k$k_koik%knc]jev]`kdean]n) mqe_]iajpakoq^opepqpk l]n] ]`ao]l]nek`] knc]jev]k lkhpe_] deannmqe_]`k EilnekNki]jk(`aopnq`kaaob]_ah]`k7 jkpklk`]dean]nmqe]aj_kjpn]i)oakl]l]akeilan]`kn*Klneiaenklkooqeklk`an bpmfofqr^i(koacqj`k(kqbjmlo^i*Ai`a_knnj_e]`]`ao]l]neklkhpe_]`ko_ajpnko qn^]jko$ok^napq`k`aNki]_kik_e`]`aqjerano]h%a`keokh]iajpklnkrk_]`klah] nqn]hev]k`]re`]a_kjie_k)ok_e]haoq]bn]ciajp]k(_]`]naceklkooqeqi_kj) fqjpk `a oajdknao mqa ao_khda qi _daba ajpna oaqo l]nao( c]n]jpej`k)hda Í a oq] `ej]ope]Í]lani]jj_e]ej`aÚje`]jklk`an*Bkni]i)oanaejkolknpk`kkpannep nek `]Aqnkl]ia`ear]h*D(]ooei(lamqajkonaeonacekj]eo_qfklk`ano l]oo]]kqpnkooa knaej]jpaiknnanoaidan`aenk`koatki]o_qhejk(kqoapn]enoaqol]naoabknlknahao `alkopk(kqoadkqranqi]cqann]j]mq]hoaf]`annkp]`kakraj_a`knpajd]bkn]l]n] naerej`e_]nklk`anncek*=]ooai^hae]`konaeooq^kn`ej])oa]kCn]j`aNaekqEila) n]`kn`]Aqnkl]$oajdkn`kO]_nkEilnekNki]jk)Cani je_k(bkni]`klknpk`koko naejko_neopko`]Aqnkl]%(mqalkooqeklk`anpak_npe_k(eopk(ahaao_khde`klkn@aqo ajklahkokqpnkonaeo$aopao(oei(bkn]iao_khde`kolknoaqol]nao(ko^]n ao%7 ]fqope](Új]he`]`a`]_kiqje`]`a_neop(]dean]nmqe]`aoq^ieookak^a`ej_e]`k ejbanekn]koqlanekn(lkeoaoo]]kn`aij]pqn]h_ne]`]lah]hae`erej]*=re`]pailkn]h ejbaneknre`]aolenepq]halkneook]Új]he`]`ai]ekn`kckranj]jpa]o]hr]k`] ]hi]eiknp]h`aoaqoo`epko(lah]mq]hnaolkj`anlan]jpa@aqo* Iaoikmqa_kjoe`ana]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]]hckj]pqn]h$_kik`eve]=neop pahaoa `enkrnekopa hkcko(_kikPkio`a=mqejk%aiaoikmqaoa_kjoe`anamqa]_kiqje) `]`alkhpe_]k^n]`]n]vk$_kik`eve]iLh]pka?_anka]Úni]nkrnekopa hkcko( _kikCqehdania`aK_gd]i%(]ej`]]ooei(]Új]he`]`aoqlnai]`klk`anlkhpe_k(eopk( k^aia]fqope](jkokaopnep]iajpapannajkokqpailkn]eo(i]oaolenepq]eo*Klnj_ela naolkjorahlah]Új]he`]`ai]eo]hp]`]lkhpe_]6]o]hr]kapanj]`aoaqoo`epko*
=q_pknep]oalkpaop]o Krk_]^qhnek`]lkhpe_]nki]j]`eopejcqe]^r`qlofq^pamlqbpq^p6]lneiaen]klk`an jkoajpe`klhajk(eopk(]]qpkne`]`al]n]lnkiqhc]n]ohaeoab]van]fqope]7]oacqj`]k lk`an`ab]pkl]n]]`iejeopn]n_keo]oalaook]o*=lneiaen]bqj`]`kn]`]_kiqje`]`alk) hpe_]7]oacqj`](]]pere`]`aata_qper]*=lkhpe_]_neop(`qn]jpapk`]]E`]`aI`e](req)oa ajrkhre`]jk_kjÛepkajpnaaooao`keolk`anao(lkeoare`ajpamqaqi`ahaoaopoq^kn`ej]) `k]kkqpnkamqa]mlqbpq^pejbanekn^r`qlofq^p* Jkej_ek`]E`]`aI`e]jkd_kjÛepk*Kl]l]lkooqe]]qpkne`]`aaolenepq]h(rkhp]`] l]n]]o]hr]k(ajmq]jpkkeilan]`knlkooqe]]qpkne`]`ahac]ha]lkpj_e]]`iejeopn]per] pailkn]eo*Lkq_k]lkq_k(lkni(k_kjÛepkajpna]o`q]o]qpkne`]`aooaejop]h](atlnaoo]j) `k)oaj]_d]i]`]mqanah]`]oejraope`qn]o* L]`naoa^eolkook]`iejeopn]`knao`]Ecnaf]jkejpanekn`konaejkoa`k_kjfqjpkbkn) i]`klknahao(kO]_nkEilnekNki]jk)Cani je_k*Oaok]`iejeopn]`knao(`araioanfk* sbpqfalpaioaqo_]nckolahkonaeoalahkeilan]`kn*EookoecjeÚ_](lkni(mqanaeoaeilan]) `knl]oo]i]ejpanrenj]]qpkne`]`a`]Ecnaf]a`kl]l](kmqa(l]n]]i^ko(ej]_aeprah*Ko fqneop]oa_haoeope_koah]^kn]iqi]haceoh]k(kafobfql`^kkf`l(l]n]c]n]jpenklk`an`k l]l]j]ejraope`qn]`al]`naoa^eolko*Aoo]ah]^kn]k(cn]`q]hiajpa(har]pakne]`klk`an l]l]h_kik]qpkne`]`aoqlnai]mq]h`araoq^iapan)oakeilan]`kn*
010
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-%x#!0É45,/ßx
=opakne]opakh ce_k)lkhpe_]obkn]iah]^kn]`]ol]n]naokhran`keo_kjÛepkomqa]pn]rao) o]ipk`]]E`]`aI`e]6k_kjÛepkajpnakl]l]akeilan]`kn(`aqih]`k(aajpnakeilan]) `kna]o]ooai^hae]o`ko^]n ao(`akqpnk* K_kjÛepkl]l])eilan]`kn_kjoamqj_e]`]_kj_alkpak_npe_]`klk`an*Oa@aqo ao_khdamqai`arannalnaoajp)hk(`]j`kklk`an]kao_khde`k(mqaiaopa6kl]l]kqk eilan]`kn; =lneiaen]okhqkaj_kjpn]`](]l o]mqanah]`]oejraope`qn]o(bkepn]ve`]lahkofqneop]o `a?]nhkoI]cjk(_ki]pakne]`]`qlh]ejraope`qn]6keilan]`knejraope`kjklk`anpailk) n]hlahkl]l]mqakqjcaak_knk]7kl]l]na_a^a`keilan]`kn]ejraope`qn]`]aol]`](eopk( keilan]`knfqn]`abaj`analnkpacan]Ecnaf](ok^]_kj`ek`amqaaop]jqj_]ejpanÚn]jko ]ooqjpko]`iejeopn]perkoaiehep]nao`kEilnek*=ooei(keilan]`kn`alaj`a`kl]l]l]n] na_a^anklk`anlkhpe_k(i]okl]l]`alaj`a`keilan]`knl]n]i]jpanklk`ana_haoeope_k* K_kjÛepkajpnakeilan]`kna]o]ooai^hae]o`ko^]n aoanaeo`evnaolaepkao_khd] `keilan]`kn*Aooa_kjÛepknarah]klnk^hai]`aqi]lkhpe_]bqj`]`]ai`q]obkjpao]j) p]cje_]o* @a b]pk( ^]n ao a naeo ejrk_]i ] _d]i]`] Hae Nce] Nki]j]( oacqj`k ] mq]h k ckranj]jpana_a^a`klkrkklk`an(oaj`k(lknp]jpk(k_ql]jpaahaepk`klk`an*>]n aoanaeo ]Úni]imqa(`]iaoi]i]jaen](ahacaikeilan]`knamqaokkoejopepqe`knao`keila) n]`kn*Kn](_kikaoo]iaoi]haenki]j]]Úni]mqao lk`apen]n]hcqi]_keo]`a]hcqi ]mqahamqapaiklk`an`a`)h]lknmqa]lkooqe(_kj_hqe)oamqa(oanaeoa^]n aoahacaik eilan]`kn(piklk`anl]n]`]n)hdalk`anap]i^iklk`anl]n]`al)hk*Keilan]`kn( lkni(ejrk_]]>^he]$Îpk`klk`anrai`k=hpkÏ%a]knecaipak_npe_]`klk`an(]Úni]j`k mqaoaqlk`anjkrai`ko^]n aoanaeo(i]o`a@aqo* =okhqkoanpn]ve`]lah]pakne]mqa`eopejcqaajpnabibf lark l*Keilan]`kn(`a b]pk(ahaepklahkol]naol]n]k_]nck(i]oo panklk`anlkniaek`]qjk_ki hakoo]j) pkoÍ]Úni])oamqaqjce`k_kikiaoik hakmqaqjceq@]reaO]hkikÍamqaiqjca keilan]`kn]Ecnaf](eopk(kl]l]*
Ko`keo_knlko`knae
011
?kikoak^oanr](]pakne]`]`qlh]ejraope`qn]a`]`eopejkajpnaahaekaqjk`ae) t] k eilan]`kn ian_ `k l]l]* L]n] bknp]ha_an k eilan]`kn _kjpn] k l]l]( ko naeo a ko ^]n ao(ah]^kn]`]qi]pakne]mqa(i]eop]n`a(oqopajp]n]opakne]o`]ikj]nmqe]]^okhqp] lkn`enaepk`erejk*Pn]p])oa`]pakhkce]lkhpe_]`koalfp`lomlpalobf$eopk(`keilan]`kn%( mqabke]ilh]iajpaaopq`]`]lahkdeopkne]`knAnjopG]jpknkse_vjqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]fqo) p]iajpaLpalfp`lomlpalobf* =pakne]_kia]]Úni]j`kmqaqinae)lah])cn]])`a)@aqo$eopk(qinaeao_khde`ka qjce`klkn@aqo%]eiep]k`aFaoqo?neopk*Faoqolkooqe`q]oj]pqnav]o6]dqi]j](ikn) p]h(a]iope_]kq`erej](eiknp]h*?kikFaoqo(knaepai`keo_knlko6qi_knlkdqi]jk(mqa j]o_a(rera(]`ka_a(ajrahda_aaiknna(aqi_knlkiope_k(lanajaaeiknp]h(oaq_knlklkh) pe_k*K_knlklkhpe_k`knaejkj]o_a(jai]`ka_a(ajrahda_akqiknna*Lkneook(jejcqi( ]jkoan@aqo(lk`ahda`]naooa_knlk(ajejcqi(]jkoan@aqo(lk`apen]n)hdap]h_knlk* Jkkna_a^ajai`ko^]n aoanaeo(jai`kl]l](ajklk`aoan)hdapen]`klahkonaeo(lahko ^]n aokqlahkl]l]* Kmqak_knlklkhpe_k`knae;=_knk](k_apnk(ki]jpk(]aol]`](kpnkjk(]opann]o(]o haeo(koeilkopkoapne^qpkoaoaqo`ao_aj`ajpaokqoq]`ej]ope]*Behdk`]fqope](l]e`]hae( i]ne`k`]pann]a`apq`kkmqajah]ateopa(knaeejrekhrahaapanjklknmqaeiep]k`a ?neopkaei]cai`a@aqo*Jaiahaepkjai`alkopklknjejcqi(jaifqhc]`klknjejcqi( klk`anlkhpe_k`knaek_khk_]bkn]a]_ei]`]_kiqje`]`a(pknj]j`k)kpn]jo_aj`ajpa]ah]* Ainah]k]kl]l](]pakne]`ko`keo_knlko`knae`]keilan]`knqi]bkn]pakh ce_] oaiahd]jpamqah]mqakÎlnej_leklapnjakÏkq]`k]k`]o?d]rao`kNaejk`]r]]kRecnek `a?neopk*Ainah]k]konaeoa^]n ao(]pakne]`]keilan]`kn]ejrekh]^ehe`]`a`k_]ncka( i]eo`kmqaeook(b]v_kimqaoaf]ahak`k]`kn`alk`an]oaqoejbaneknao*Naeoa^]n aopank lk`anlknqib]rkn`keilan]`kn7_kikaopa(na_a^alk`anlknqib]rkn`a@aqo*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
K`q]heoik`klk`an JkÚj]h`]E`]`aI`e](ok^napq`k_ki]napki]`]`]ok^n]o`a=neop pahaolahkopa ) hkcko(d]ranqiaobknkl]n]oal]n]n]?e`]`a`a@aqo$]Ecnaf]%a]?e`]`a`koDkiajo$] _kiqje`]`alkhpe_]%* ?kjoe`an])oamqa]lneiaen]bkeejopepq`]abqj`]`]`enap]iajpalkn@aqo_ki]`k]) k`]o?d]rao`kNaejk]ko]l opkhko(i]o]oacqj`]bkeejopepq`]kqbqj`]`]lah]j]pq) nav](mqabavkdkiaiqioann]_ekj]haqi]jei]hlkhpe_k*Oai`re`](]^k]_e`]`a] ?e`]`a`koDkiajo`ofpq(aid]nikje]_ki]?e`]`a`a@aqo(i]o]oejopepqe aolkhpe_]o `araioan_kjoe`an]`]odqi]j]o(_ne]`]oai_kj_kn` j_e]_ki]kn`aia]haej]pqn]eo( `aner]`]o`]hae`erej]apanj]* Qi`kopa ne_koi]eoeilknp]jpao`]j]pqn]he`]`a`]lkhpe_]kpa hkckPkio`a=mqe) jk(l]n]mqai(oaj`kkdkiaiqi]jei]hok_e]h(]ok_e]^ehe`]`aj]pqn]hfateope]jkL]n]ok( ]jpao`]mqa`]a`]atlqhok`kooanaodqi]jko*=l okla_]`kknecej]h(kooanaodqi]jko jklan`an]ioq]j]pqnav]ok_eraha(lkneook(j]pqn]hiajpaknc]jev]n]i)oaai_kiqje`]) `ao(`an]i)oahaeoaejopepqn]i]onah] ao`ai]j`kak^a`ej_e](_ne]j`kklk`anlkhpe_k* @ebanajpaiajpa`aO]jpk=ckopejdk(l]n]mqaikla_]`kpknj]n]kdkiailanranoka rekhajpk(ejfqopkabqj`]`kn`]?e`]`a`koDkiajo(ejfqop]_kikaha(l]n]Pkio`a=mqejk kodqi]jkolan`an]i]ejk_j_e]knecej]h(i]ojklan`an]i]j]pqnav]knecej]hmqahdao bkn]`]`]lkn@aqo*Lknaooaikperk(jahaolani]ja_aqkoajok`]fqope](ajpaj`e`]_kikk `aran`a`]n]_]`]qikmqahda`are`k(a_kiah]bqj`]n]i]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]* =Új]he`]`a`]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]]kn`ai$kejbanekn`arak^a`a_an]koqlanekn%a] fqope]$`]n]_]`]qioacqj`koq]oja_aooe`]`aoainepko%*Kn`aiafqope]`aÚjai]_kiq) je`]`alkhpe_]_kikkje_kejopnqiajpkdqi]jkhacpeikl]n]]ooacqn]nk_bj`ljrj* J]iaoi]hejd]`aoal]n]kajpnalk`anaolenepq]h`]Ecnaf]alk`anpailkn]h`]_k) iqje`]`alkhpe_]aj_kjpn])oakpa hkckejchoCqehdania`aK_gd]i(mqa(l]n]iahdkn`a) Újen]fqope]ak^ai_kiqi(ejpnk`qv]e`ae]`aafobfqlk^qro^ipr_gbqfsl* L]n]mqa]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]lkoo]na]hev]n]fqope](eopk(`]n]_]`]qikmqahda `are`koacqj`koq]oja_aooe`]`aoaoaqoinepko(lna_eokmqakhaceoh]`knaki]ceopn]`k lkooq]i qi _nepnek kq qi] ia`e`] mqa `aÚj] k fqopk* Aoo] ia`e`] k `enaepk j]pqn]h oq^faperk`a_]`]qia`apk`kokodkiajo_kikk`enaepkre`](_kjo_ej_e]a]ko^ajo i]pane]eoaaolenepq]eoja_aoonekoc]n]jpe]`]re`]a`]_kjo_ej_e]* L]oo])oa(ajpk(]b]h]nai`keocn]j`ao`enaepkoj]pqn]eo6kafobfqlk^qro^il_gbqfsl(mqa ]kn`aij]pqn]hdeannmqe_]qjerano]hejopepq`]lkn@aqokqlah]hae`erej](akafobfqlk^* qro^ipr_gbqfsl(lkooq`klahkej`er`qkj]mq]he`]`a`aoann]_ekj]haherna*Aooao`keo`enae) pkooanrai`a_nepneka`al]`nkl]n]`apaniej]n]hacepeie`]`aafqope]`aqilk`ana`a qi]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_](^ai_kikoq]ehacepeie`]`aaejfqope]mq]j`kjkkooacqai* ?kiPkio`a=mqejkaK_gd]i(jkr]oe`ae]ookpn]ve`]opakne]lkhpe_](]ej`]mqa _kjpejqapakh ce_](eopk(nabane`]rkjp]`aoqlnai]`a@aqo*@e]jpa`]pn]`ekpak_npe_] ia`ear]h(okjkr]o]oe`ae]o`a_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]j]pqn]h(haedqi]j]lkhpe_]a`enaepk j]pqn]h`koej`er`qko_kikoqfaepko`kp]`ko`a_kjo_ej_e]a`arkjp]`a* Ko`keopa hkckoi]jpi]e`ae]`a>kiCkranjk`klnj_ela_neopkrenpqkoka]`a mqa]ikj]nmqe]]bkni]j]pqn]haiahdkn`ackranjk(]i]eo]`amq]`]l]n]na]hev]n] fqope] _kik ^ai _kiqi* ?kjoanr]i p]i^i ] e`ae] `a dean]nmqe] j]pqn]h _ne]`] lah] hae`erej]apanj]a_kj_napev]`]lah]haej]pqn]h*Bej]hiajpa(ejpnk`qvaiklneiaenkao^kk `kmqarene]]oan_kjda_e`k(_ki]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa(_kikkafobfqlabobpfpqk`f^`ko o`epko`kpen]jk* Kockranj]`kojklk`ai`alknjaii]p]nkpen]jk(i]olk`ainaoeopen]aha(^qo_]j) `kejopnqiajpkohac]eomqa_kjpaopaioq]]qpkne`]`a(bkn]j`k)k]]^`e_]n`klk`an*Qi `koejopnqiajpkohac]eoi]eoeilknp]jpaol]n]eook]e`ae]`a`enaepkoq^faperkj]pqn]h6 mq]j`kaoparekh]`klahkckranj]jpa(kckranjkoapknj]ehacpeik(kl]_pk`aoq^ieook lan`a]r]he`]`aakckranj]jpa`ara]^`e_]n`klk`an*
012
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%
Ke`a]hnalq^he_]jk
3ANTIßDIß4ITO0ALAZZOß6ECCHIO ß&LORENlA
Ç
.ICOLAUß-AQUIAVELßß
013
rkhp]`ko_]opahkobaq`]eo(`qn]jpa]E`]`aI`e](bkni]n]i)oa]h`ae]okq^qncko*Aj) mq]jpkj]ok_ea`]`a_kikqipk`klnar]ha_e]]nah]k`ar]oo]h]cai$fqn]iajpk `aÚ`ahe`]`alnaop]`klknqiejbanekn]qioqlaneknmqalnkiape]lnkpacankr]o) o]hk%(jko^qncko(]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdkb]ve]]l]na_anqi]kqpn]knc]jev]kok_e]h( ]`lomlo^ lablc`fl*Pa_ah ao(la`naenko(bannaenko(i`e_ko(]nmqepapko(_kian_e]jpao(ap_* knc]jev]r]i)oaai_kjbn]ne]oj]omq]eokoiai^nkoaop]r]ihec]`kolknqifqn]iajpk`a _kjÚ]j]na_lnk_]* Ai^kn]ejpanj]iajpa]o_knlkn] aop]i^ibkooaideannmqe_]o(an]lkoorah(]l]npen `anacn]o_kjraj_ekj]`]oajpnaoaqoiai^nko(]o_aj`anj]dean]nmqe]*Atpanj]iajpa(j]o nah] ao_kikqpn]o_knlkn] ao(pk`koan]i_kjoe`an]`kohernaoaecq]eo*=o_knlkn] aob]) vaioqncenqi]jkr]_h]ooaok_e]hmqa(jkoo_qhkooacqejpao(r]epknj]n)oaa_kjkie_]iajpa `kiej]jpaa^qo_]np]i^ik`kijeklkhpe_k6]^qncqaoe](j]o_e`]`ko^qncko* @ao`akej_ek`ko_qhkTR(ai_anp]onace ao`]Aqnkl](]o]jpec]o_e`]`ao`kEil) nekNki]jka]ojkr]o_e`]`aooqnce`]o`ko^qnckoia`ear]eoajpn]iai`aoajrkhreiajpk a_kjie_kaok_e]h*Cn]j`aonkp]o_kian_e]eopknj]ilk`anko]o]o_knlkn] aoa]ob]ihe]o `a_kian_e]jpao(ajmq]jpkklk`anek]cnnek`ko^]n ao_kia]]`eiejqen* =o_e`]`aoaopkeje_e]j`kkmqarene]]oan_kjda_e`k_kik`^mfq^ifpjl`ljbo`f^ilr jbo`^kqfi*L]n]`aoajrkhr)hk(jklk`ai_kjpejq]noq^iape`]o]kol]`n ao(onacn]oa]ko pne^qpko`]a_kjkie]baq`]h]cnne](ajpkeje_e]ihqp]olknbn]jmqe]oa_kjie_]o*=ohq) p]o a_kjie_]o `] ^qncqaoe] j]o_ajpa _kjpn] ] jk^nav] baq`]h lnkooacqai j] bkni] `a naerej`e_] aolkhpe_]o6]o_e`]`ao`aoaf]iej`alaj`j_e]aib]_a`a^]n ao(naeo(l]l]oa eilan]`knao* J]Ephe](]na`ao_k^anp]`]ok^n]o`alajo]`knao(]npeop]oap_je_ko`]_qhpqn]cna_k) )nki]j](l]npe_qh]niajpa`]o]jpec]opakne]olkhpe_]o(oqo_ep]qie`a]hlkhpe_kjkrk6k`] he^an`]`analq^he_]j]_kjpn]klk`anpakh ce_k)lkhpe_k`al]l]oaeilan]`knao* Aop]ikojklank`k_kjda_e`k_kikNaj]o_eiajpk(jkmq]hoaaolan]b]vanobk^p`bok lajo]iajpk(]o]npao(]pe_](]op_je_]oa]lkhpe_]mqad]re]ioe`k`aoajrkhre`ko]jpao mqako]^anperaooaoe`k_kjoe`an]`klnerehcek`]Ecnaf]akopa hkckodkqraooai]`mqene`k ]qpkne`]`al]n]`a_e`enkmqalk`ane]akmqajklk`ane]oanlajo]`k(`epkabaepk*Beh okbko( deopkne]`knao(lkap]o(`n]i]pqncko(nap ne_ko(i]paipe_ko(]opnjkiko(i`e_ko(^e hkcko( ]nmqepapko(lejpknao(ioe_ko(pk`koko]qpknao]jpecko_kia]i]panoq]ok^n]ona`ao_k) ^anp]oaejpanlnap]`]o(oaqopatpkol]oo]i]oanpn]`qve`ko(he`ko(_kiajp]`koa]lhe_]`ko* Aol]np](=paj]oaNki]okpki]`]o_kikatailhko`]he^an`]`analq^he_]j]*Eiep)h]o rkhp]n]r]hknev]n]lkhpe_]_kikatlnaooki]eo]hp]`]_]l]_e`]`adqi]j]aancqan]sfq^ ^`qfs^_kjpn]ke`a]h`]sfq^`lkqbjmi^qfs^(r]hknev]`klah]Ecnaf](eopk(]re`]aolenepq]h`k o^ek_kjpailh]perkaokhepnek(mqaoalnak_ql]r]_ki]re`]bqpqn]jkkqpnkiqj`koai oak_ql]n_ki]re`]lnaoajpajaopaiqj`k*B]h])oa(]ckn](j]if_boa^abobmr_if`^k^aj] sfa^mliqf`^_kik]obkni]oi]eo]hp]o`]`ecje`]`adqi]j]* Jaooa]i^eajpa(ajpna-1-/a-1-0(aiBhknaj](ao_nep]]k^n]mqaej]qcqn]klajo]) iajpklkhpe_kik`anjk6Lmok`fmb(`aI]mqe]rah*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=jpao`aKlnj_ela
A
i^kn]`ebanajpaoa(iqep]oravao(_kjpnne]o(]ok^n]olkhpe_]oia`ear]eoanaj]o_aj) peop]oklan]ijqiiqj`k_neopk*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa(l]n]pk`]oah]o(]nah]kajpna lkhpe_] a nahecek qi `]`k `k mq]h jk lk`ai ao_]l]n* ran`]`a mqa ]o pakne]o ia`ear]eookkq`enap]iajpapak_npe_]o$klk`anlanpaj_a]laj]o]@aqo(mqak_kj_a`a ]]hcqilknqib]rknaola_e]h%kqej`enap]iajpapak_npe_]o$]knecai`klk`anaopj] j]pqnav]ok_e]h`kdkiai(i]okbqj`]iajpkhpeik`klk`anlkhpe_kaj_kjpn])oaj]hae `erej]narah]`]%(ajmq]jpk]onaj]o_ajpeop]olnk_qn]iarep]n]e`ae]`amqaklk`anoane] qi]cn]]kqqib]rkn`erejkamqaoaaj_kjpn]`apaniej]`k`enap]iajpalah]hae`erej]* Jk ajp]jpk( ai^kn] na_qoai ] pak_n]_e]( jk lk`ai na_qo]n qi] kqpn] e`ae] _neop( mq]hoaf](]`amqaklk`anlkhpe_ko hacpeikoabknfqopkao oanfqopkoaaoperan`a]_kn) `k_ki]rkjp]`a`a@aqoa]Lnkre`j_e]`erej]*=ooei(ahaiajpko`apakhkce]_kjpejq]i lnaoajpaoj]obkniqh] aopa ne_]o`]lkhpe_]* Lkneook(oa`aet]niko`ah]`kaoo]`ebanaj]ajpnaia`ear]eoanaj]o_ajpeop]o(lk`ana) ikolan_a^an_anpkopn]komqahdaook_kiqjo(lnkrajeajpao`koahaiajpko`apakhkce]6 aj_kjpn]il]n]]lkhpe_]qibqj`]iajpk]jpaneknaatpaneknln lne]lkhpe_]*Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( l]n] ]hcqjo( k bqj`]iajpk `] lkhpe_] aj_kjpn])oa ai Abrp $oaf] j] rkjp]`a`erej](mqa`k]klk`an]kodkiajo(oaf]j]Lnkre`j_e]`erej](mqab]rkna_a klk`an`a]hcqjodkiajo%7l]n]kqpnko(aj_kjpn])oaj]k^qrobw^(eopk(j]kn`aij]) pqn]h(_ne]`]lkn@aqoai_kjbknie`]`a_kik`enaepkj]pqn]hk^faperk(oacqj`k]mq]h kdkiaiqioanj]pqn]hiajpalkhpe_k7a(l]n]]hcqjo(aj_kjpn])oaj]n]vk(eopk( j]e`ae]`amqaateopaqi]n]_ekj]he`]`amqackranj]kiqj`kakodkiajo(pknj])ko n]_ekj]eoakob]vejopepqen]re`]lkhpe_]*D(lkeo(]hckÍ@aqo(j]pqnav]kqn]vkÍ ]jpaneknaatpaneknlkhpe_](oanrej`k`abqj`]iajpk]ah]7 ]Úni]imqa]lkhpe_]ejopepqek`aqi]_kiqje`]`aqj]aej`ereo](_qf]Új]he`]`a na]hev]nk^ai_kiqikqfqope]*=^k]lkhpe_]baep]lah]^k]_kiqje`]`ad]nikjeko]( l]_Ú_]akn`aen]*Hqp]o(_kjÛepkoa`ereo aookreopko_kiklanecko(bnqpko`adkiajolan) ranokoaoa`e_ekokomqa`arai(]mq]hmqanlnak(oan]b]op]`ko`]_kiqje`]`aa`klk`an7 ]ooajp]i]^k]_kiqje`]`aa]^k]lkhpe_]j]Úcqn]`k>kiCkranjk(eopk(jklnj_e) larenpqkokan]_ekj]h(lknp]`kn`]fqope](`]d]nikje]a`]ej`ereok`]_kiqje`]`a7 _h]ooeÚ_]i ko naceiao lkhpe_ko ai fqopko)hacpeiko a ejfqopko)ehacpeiko( _khk_]j`k ] ikj]nmqe] a ] ]neopk_n]_e] dana`epne]o ajpna ko lneiaenko a e`ajpeÚ_]j`k _ki ko oacqj`koklk`ank^pe`klkn_kjmqeop]aqoqnl]k(`ajkiej]j`k)kpen je_k*Aopa _kjoe`an]`k]jpej]pqn]h(enn]_ekj]h(_kjpnnekrkjp]`a`a@aqoafqope](k^n]`aqi ckranj]jpare_ekokalanranok* ?kil]n]`]]aooaopn]ko`]pn]`eklkhpe_](]k^n]`aI]mqe]rah`aikhe`kn]anark) hq_ekjne]*?kiah](j]o_aklajo]iajpklkhpe_kik`anjk*
I]mqe]rhe_k(i]mqe]raheoik
A
op]iko]_kopqi]`ko]kqren]oatlnaoo aoj^nrf^sif`laj^nrf^sbifpjl*Okqo]`]o mq]j`k]hcqi`aoaf]nabanen)oaoaf]lkhpe_]a]kolkhpe_ko(oaf]]_anp]o]pepq`ao `]olaook]o(iaoikmq]j`kjkhec]`]o`enap]iajpa]qi]]klkhpe_]$b]h])oa(lkn atailhk(jqi_kian_e]jpai]mqe]rhe_k(jqi]lnkbaookn]i]mqe]rhe_](jki]mqe]raheo) ik`a_anpkofknj]eo(ap_*%* Aimqaoepq] aokqreikokqailnac]ikoaoo]oatlnaoo ao;Oailnamqalnapaj`a) ikofqhc]n]]kkq]_kj`qp]`a]hcqi`aoha]h(del _nep](Újce`kn(lk`anko]iajpai]h) rkhk(mqa^nej_]_kioajpeiajpkoa`aoafko`kokqpnko(iajpa)hdao(b]v]ahaolnkiaoo]omqa o]^amqajk_qilnen(qo]]^k])b]hdae]aioaqln lneklnkraepk*
014
-ADININ´!RT!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
#LAUDEß,EFORTß ßß FILvSOFOßFRANCoS
B]h]ikojqiÎlk`ani]mqe]rhe_kÏl]n]jkonabaneniko]qilk`anmqa]caoa_nap]) iajpajko^]ope`knao(i]jpaj`koq]oejpaj aoaÚj]he`]`ao`ao_kjda_e`]ol]n]ko_e`]) `ko7mqa]Úni]mqaÎkoÚjofqopeÚ_]ikoiaekoÏaqo]iaekoeikn]eo(rekhajpkoalanranoko l]n]_kjoacqenkmqamqan7mqa`]onacn]o`kfkck(i]oÚ_]oao_kj`e`]o(aolan]j`kmqa kofkc]`knao_]qoai]oeiaoikooq]ln lne]nqj]a`aopnqek* J^nrf^sif`l a j^nrf^sbifpjl b]vai lajo]n ai ]hcqi atpnai]iajpa lk`ankok a lanranok(oa`qpknaajc]j]`kn(mqao]^ahar]n]olaook]o]b]vanat]p]iajpakmqaaha`aoaf]( iaoikmqaoaf]i]jemqeh]`]olkneook*?kikoajkp](j^nrf^sif`laj^nrf^sbifpjl_kn) naolkj`aimqehkmqa(aijkoo]_qhpqn](_kjoe`an]`kaf^_if`l* Aiqi]k^n]ejpepqh]`]J^nrf^sbiÎLqo^_^iela^l_o^(kÚh okbkbn]j_o?h]q`aHabknp ej`]c]kmqapane]ao_nepkI]mqe]rahl]n]mqacajpamqajqj_]haqoq]k^n]amqajaiiaoik o]^amqaahaateopeqqi`e](aiBhknaj](b]haaij^nrf^sif`laj^nrf^sbifpjl*
=narkhqki]mqe]rahe]j]
L
]n] naolkj`an ] aoo] mqaopk( Habknp `eopejcqa ajpna kÎi]mqe]raheoikÏ a kÎlajo]) iajpki]mqe]rahe]jkÏ(eopk(ajpna]ei]cai`aikj]_]`aI]mqe]raha`aoaqlnj) _elaakoajpe`k`]k^n]lkhpe_]`klajo]`knÛknajpejk* @ebanajpaiajpa`kopa hkcko(mqal]npe]i`]>^he]a`k@enaepkNki]jkl]n]bkniq) h]npakne]olkhpe_]o(a`ebanajpaiajpa`ko_kjpailkn jakonaj]o_ajpeop]o(mqal]npe]i`]o k^n]o`koÚh okbkocna_k)nki]jkol]n]_kjopnqenoq]opakne]olkhpe_]o(I]mqe]rahl]npa`] bumbofk`f^ob^i`aoaqpailk* Ahabke`elhki]p]a_kjoahdaenk`kockranj]jpao`aBhknaj](req]ohqp]oaqnklae]o`a _ajpn]hev]kikjnmqe_]$Bn]j](Ejch]pann](Aol]jd](Lknpqc]h%(knaooqnceiajpk`]re`] qn^]j]aqnklae]a(_kiah](]]o_ajok`]^qncqaoe]_kian_e]h`]ocn]j`ao_e`]`ao(aok^na) pq`kreq]bn]ciajp]k`]Ephe](`ere`e`]ainaejko(`q_]`ko(nal^he_]oaEcnaf]*=_ki) lnaajok`aoo]oatlanej_e]odeop ne_]oa]ejpanlnap]k`koajpe`k`ah]ok_kj`qven]i jkk`amqa]oe`ae]olkhpe_]o]jpec]oaia`ear]eojkan]i_]l]vao`a_kilnaaj`anran) `]`aen]iajpakmqaklk`anamqaqi]kls^`lk`bm la^pl`fba^abba^mliqf`^pknj]n])oa ja_aoone](ok^napq`kl]n]]Ephe]a(l]npe_qh]niajpa(l]n]Bhknaj]*L]n]eook(ai-1-/(ao_nara ]k^n]ej]qcqn]h`]ÚhkokÚ]lkhpe_]ik`anj](Lmok`fmb*
'ALLERIAß$EGLIß5FFIZI ß&LORENlA
Mq]j`kJe_kh]q I]mqe]rahao_naraq Klnj_ela(]ejr]ok `aBhknaj]lah] Bn]j]fd]re]oa eilnacj]`kaioq] iai ne]*Aop]_aj]( `]pki]`]`]_e`]`a lahknaebn]j_o ?]nhkoREEE(bke lejp]`]ai-1-4lkn Bn]j_ao_kCn]j]__e*
015
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Aoo]k^n]bqj`]klajo]iajpklkhpe_kik`anjklknmqa^qo_]kbana_annaolkop]ojk) r]o]qi]oepq]kdeop ne_]jkr](mqaoaqo_kjpailkn jakopajp]r]i_kilnaaj`anhaj`k ko]qpknao]jpecko(`aet]j`k`ah]`k]k^oanr]k`enap]`ko]_kjpa_eiajpkomqak_knne]i `e]jpa`aoaqokhdko* Oa_kil]n]nikoklajo]iajpklkhpe_k`aI]mqe]rah_kikomq]pnklkjpkojkomq]eo naoqieiko]_ei]]pn]`eklkhpe_](k^oanr]naikolknkj`al]oo]]nqlpqn]i]mqe]rahe]) j](]ooej]h]`]lkn?h]q`aHabknp6 -*
I]mqe]rahjk]`iepaqibqj`]iajpk]jpaneknaatpaneknlkhpe_]$@aqo(j]pqnav]kq n]vk%*Pk`]_e`]`a(`evahaaiLmok`fmb(aopknecej]ne]iajpa`ere`e`]lkn`keo`aoa) fkoklkopko6labpbglalpdo^kabpablmofjfob`lj^ka^oalabpbglalmlslabklpbo lmofjfalkbj`lj^ka^al*Aoo]`ereokare`aj_e]mqa]_e`]`ajkqi]_kiqje`]`a dkikcja]j]o_e`]`]rkjp]`a`erej](`]kn`aij]pqn]hkq`]n]vkdqi]j]*J]na]) he`]`a(]_e`]`apa_e`]lknhqp]oejpanj]omqa]k^nec]i]ejopepqenqilkhkoqlanekn mqalkoo]qjeÚ_)h]a`]n)hdae`ajpe`]`a*Aooalkhkklk`anlkhpe_k*=ooei(^mliqf`^ k^p`b a^p irq^p pl`f^fp b l_o^ a^ momof^ pl`fba^ab m^o^ a^o ^ pf jbpj^ rkfa^ab b fabkqfa^ab*=lkhpe_]naoqhp]`]]kok_e]h]l]npen`]o`ereo aook_e]eo7
.*
I]mqe]rahjk]_aep]]e`ae]`]^k]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]_kjopepq`]l]n]k^ai_kiqi a]fqope]*?kikreiko(klkjpk`al]npe`]`]lkhpe_]l]n]aha]`ereokok_e]hajpnako cn]j`aoaklkrk*=ok_ea`]`aknecej]ne]iajpa`ere`e`]af]i]eolk`aoanreop]_kikqi] _kiqje`]`aqj](ej`ereo](dkikcja](rkhp]`]l]n]k^ai_kiqi*Aoo]ei]cai`]qje) `]`aa`]ej`ereok(`evI]mqe]rah(qi]io_]n]_kimqakocn]j`aona_k^nai]na]he`]) `aok_e]hl]n]ajc]j]n(klneiena_ki]j`]nklkrk(_kikoakoejpanaooao`kocn]j`aoa`ko lklqh]naobkooaikoiaoikoapk`kobkooaienikoaecq]eojqi]^ah]_kiqje`]`a* =Új]he`]`a`]lkhpe_]jk(_kik`eve]ikolajo]`knaocnacko(nki]jkoa_neo) pko(]fqope]ak^ai_kiqi(i]o(_kikoailnaokq^an]ikolkhpe_ko(^qlj^a^b j^krqbk l al mlabo* K ran`]`aenk lnj_ela ]mqaha mqa o]^a pki]n a _kjoanr]n k lk`anamqa(l]n]eook(f]i]eooa]he]]kocn]j`ao(lkeoaopaookoaqoner]eoamqanai klk`anl]n]oe(i]o`ara]he]n)oa]klkrk(mqaaolan]`kckranj]jpa]eilkoek`a heiepao]k`aoafk`aklnaookai]j`k`kocn]j`ao*=lkhpe_]jk]h ce_]n]_ekj]h`] fqope]a`]pe_](i]o^idf`^a^clo ^qo^kpcloj^a^bjidf`^almlaboba^ibf7
/*
I]mqe]rahna_qo]]Úcqn]`k>kiCkranjkaj_]nj]`]jklnj_elarenpqkok(lknp]`kn `]orenpq`ao_neopo(`]orenpq`aoikn]eoa`]orenpq`aolnej_elao_]o*Klnj_elalna_eo] pansfoq(i]oaop]lnklne]iajpalkhpe_](nabanej`k)oaomq]he`]`ao`k`enecajpal]n] pki]nai]jpanklk`an(iaoikmqal]n]eook`ar]qo]n]rekhj_e](]iajpen](]]op) _e]a]bkn]*=pn]`ek]Úni]r]mqakckranj]jpa`are]oan]i]`kanaolaep]`klahko ckranj]`ko*I]mqe]rah]Úni]mqaklnj_elajklk`aoank`e]`k* Eook oecjeÚ_]( ai lneiaenk hqc]n( mqa k lnj_ela `ara oan naolaep]`k a paie`k Í kmqao lkoorahoajkbknk`e]`k*OecjeÚ_](aioacqj`khqc]n(mqajklna_eo]oan ]i]`k( lkeo eook k b]ne] qi l]e l]n] ] ok_ea`]`a a( o]^aiko( qi l]e _kjda_a ]laj]o qipelk`alk`an(k`aol pe_k*=renpq`alkhpe_]`klnj_ela]l]na_anj]mq]he`]`a`]o ejopepqe aomqaokq^an_ne]nai]jpanaj]_]l]_e`]`amqaperan$cloqrk^kqploqb%l]n] ajbnajp]n]ok_]oe ao]`rano]o7
0*
I]mqe]rahjk]_aep]]`ereok_hooe_]`kopnonaceiaolkhpe_ko$ikj]nmqe](]neopk_n]) _e](`aik_n]_e]%aoq]obkni]o_knnqlp]okqehacpei]o$pen]je](khec]nmqe](`ai]ckce]+ ]j]nmqe]%( _kik jk ]_aep] mqa k naceia hacpeik oaf] k dana`epnek a k ehacpeik( k qoqnl]`klkn_kjmqeop]*Mq]hmqannaceialkhpe_kÍpajd]]bkni]mqaperanapajd]] knecaimqaperanÍlk`anoanhacpeikkqehacpeik*K_nepnek`a]r]he]k(kqkr]hkn mqaia`a]hacepeie`]`aa]ehacepeie`]`a(]if_boa^ab* Pk`k naceia lkhpe_k ai mqa k lk`anek `a klnaook a _ki]j`k `ko cn]j`ao i]ekn`kmqaklk`an`klnj_elaaaoi]c]klkrkehacpeik7_]ok_kjpnnek(hac) peik* =ooei( hacepeie`]`a a ehacepeie`]`a `alaj`ai `k ik`k _kik ]o hqp]o ok_e]eo
02,
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
aj_kjpn]inaolkop]olkhpe_]o_]l]vao`ac]n]jpenkje_klnej_lekmqanaca]lkhpe_]6 lmlaboalmok`fmbabsbpboprmboflo^lalpdo^kabpbbpq^o^pbosf lalmlsl*Klnj_ela lk`aoanikj]n_]dana`epnekkqlkn_kjmqeop]7lk`aoanpk`kqilkrkmqa_kjmqeop]( lah] bkn]( k lk`an a k atan_a `aik_n]pe_]iajpa* Mq]hmqan `aooao naceiao lkhpe_ko oanhacpeikoabknqi]nal^he_]ajk`aolkpeoikkqpen]je](eopk(o hacpeikk naceiajkmq]hklk`anjkaop]oanrek`ko`aoafkoaejpanaooao`aqil]npe_qh]nkq `aqicnqlk`al]npe_qh]nao*
02-
@eooaikomqa]pn]`ekcnac]pknj]n]pe_]alkhpe_]ejoal]nraeo(mqa]pn]`eknki]) j]_khk_]n]aoo]e`ajpe`]`a`]pe_]a`]lkhpe_]j]laook]renpqko]`kckranj]jpaamqa] pn]`ek_neoppn]jobkni]n]]laook]lkhpe_]jqi_knlkiope_ko]_n]hev]`kmqaaj_]nj]r] ]rkjp]`a`a@aqoa]_kiqje`]`adqi]j]*Dana`ep]nea`]`a(lanokj]he`]`aarenpq`abkn) i]r]ik_ajpnk`]lkhpe_](kneajp]`]lah]e`ae]`afqope]a^ai_kiqi*Aooa_kjfqjpk`a e`ae]oaei]cajoabjlifallknI]mqe]rah*Qi`ko]ola_pko`]_kj_alki]mqe]rahe]j] mqaiahdknnarah]aoo]`aikhekaj_kjpn])oaj]Úcqn]`kmok`fmbsfoqrlpl* Mq]j`kaopq`]iko]pe_](reikomqa]mqaopk_ajpn]hlkop]lahkoÚh okbkooailna bkeÎkmqaaopakmqajkaopaijkooklk`anÏ*Reikop]i^imqaÎaop]naijkooklk`anÏ oecjeÚ_]r]]]krkhqjpne]n]_ekj]hherna(ln lne]`]renpq`a(aÎjkaop]naijkooklk`anÏ oecjeÚ_]r]k_kjfqjpk`a_en_qjop j_e]oatpanj]omqa]caiok^naj oa`apaniej]ijkoo] rkjp]`aajkoo]]k*Reiko(]ej`](mqaaooa_kjfqjpk`a_en_qjop j_e]omqajk`alaj`ai `aj ojai`ajkoo]rkjp]`aan]ip]jpk]ohaeoja_aoone]o`]j]pqnav]_kikko]_]okoa] _kjpejcj_e](kqkmqabke_d]i]`klah]pn]`ekÚhko Ú_]`acloqrk^* =klkoeksfoqrab*cloqrk^f]i]eo]^]j`kjkq]pe_]a(_kikaop]oqnce]ejoal]nrah`] lkhpe_](]iaoi]klkoekoabavlnaoajpajklajo]iajpklkhpe_k*Jaopa(kckranj]jparen) pqkokan]]mqaha_qf]orenpq`aoklnkpacai`klk`anek`]_]lne_dko]aej_kjop]jpabknpqj]* I]mqe]rahnapki]aoo]klkoek(i]ohdaeilneiaqioajpe`kejpaen]iajpajkrk*=renp `klnj_elajk_kjoeopajqi_kjfqjpkÚtk`amq]he`]`aoikn]eomqaahaklknbknpqj]( hqp]j`k _kjpn] ah]* = sfoq ] _]l]_e`]`a `k lnj_ela l]n] oan Ûatrah o _en_qjop j_e]o( iq`]j`k_kiah]ol]n]]c]nn]na`kiej]n]bknpqj]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(qilnj_elamqa ]cenoailna`]iaoi]i]jaen]a`a]_kn`k_kikoiaoikolnej_lekoaipk`]o]o_en_qjo) p j_e]obn]_]oo]najkpansfoq]hcqi]* L]n]oanoajdkn`]oknpakq`]o_en_qjop j_e]o`araiq`]n_kiah]oa(_kikah]o(oanrkhrah aej_kjop]jpa(lkeookiajpa]ooeio]^an]c]nn)h]oaraj_)h]o*Ai_anp]o_en_qjop j_e]o(`aran oan_nqah(aikqpn]o(cajankok7ai_anp]ok_]oe ao`araniajpen(aikqpn]o(oandkjn]`k7ai_an) pkoikiajpko(`aran_a`anrkjp]`a`kokqpnko(ai]hcqi]o(oanejÛatrah*Kbqelpkq_]npan `klnj_ela`arar]ne]n_ki]o_en_qjop j_e]o(l]n]mqaoailnaoaf]oajdkn`ah]o* =bknpqj](`evI]mqe]rah(oailnab]rknrah]mqaiokq^an]c]nn)h]*Kbana_a)oa_kik qilnaoajpa]pk`k]mqahamqaperankqo]`e]l]n]`k^n)h]araj_)h]*=ooei(aihqc]n`] pn]`e_ekj]hklkoekajpna]_kjop j_e]`k_]npanrenpqkoka]ej_kjop j_e]`]bknpqj](I]) mqe]rahejpnk`qv]renpq`alkhpe_]_kik^pq `f^b`^m^`fa^abm^o^^a^mq^o*pb p`fo`rkpq k* `f^pb^lpqbjmlp(_kiklrp^af^m^o^^d^oo^o^_l^l`^pflbclo ^m^o^klpbo^oo^pq^al mbi^pjp*Aoo]kqo]`e]l]n]iq`]n`a]pepq`aa`a_kilknp]iajpk]ran`]`aen]lnq`j) _e]lnej_elao_](oajdkn]`]bknpqj]* =h ce_]lkhpe_]j]`]pai]ran_ki]orenpq`aope_]o`koej`er`qkoaioq]re`]lne) r]`]*Kmqalk`ane]oanikn]hj]re`]lner]`]lk`aoanbn]mqav]j]re`]l^he_]are_a)rano]7 kmqalk`ane]oaneikn]h`klkjpk`areop]`]pe_]lner]`]lk`aoansfoqlkhpe_]*Aikqpn]o l]h]rn]o(I]mqe]rahej]qcqn]]e`ae]`ar]hknaolkhpe_koia`e`kolah]bÛ``f^moqf`^alah] rqfifa^abpl`f^i(]b]op]`ko`kol]`n aomqanacqh]i]ikn]he`]`alner]`]`koej`er`qko* Kbqelplkhpe_kakbqelpikn]hplafcbobkqbpajkdbn]mqav]lkhpe_]i]ekn`kmqak ikn]heoikmqaj^p`^o^]h ce_]na]h`klk`an*Dk_]oe aoaimqa]nal^he_]atecamqak lnj_elaoaf]_nqah7kqpn]o(aimqa`araoani]cj jeikaieoane_kn`ekok*=o_en_qjop j_e]o lk`aiatecenmqaahaoaf]]opqpka`eooeiqh]`kn(kq(lahk_kjpnnek(mqaahaoaf]ha]haoej_ank* Oq]renpq`aia`e`]lahkoabaepko^ajÚ_ko`aoq]]kl]n]]nal^he_]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Lknpanej]qcqn]`k]pakne]ik`anj]`]h ce_]`klk`an_kikej`alaj`ajpa`]nahe) cek(`]pe_]a`]kn`aij]pqn]h(I]mqe]raho lk`ane]panoe`kreopk_kikÎi]mqe]rhe_kÏ* =o l]h]rn]o j^nrf^sif`l a j^nrf^sbifpjl( _ne]`]o jk o_qhk TRE a _kjoanr]`]o ]p dkfa( atlneiaikia`kmqaoapai`]lkhpe_]mq]j`kaop]pfjmibpjbkqbmliqf`^(eopk(pbj ^pjp`^o^pa^obifdfl)a^jlo^i)a^o^wlba^k^qrobw^*L]n]kK_e`ajpa_neopk`ko_qhk TRE(klnj_elai]mqe]rahe]jk(jkoaj`kk>kiCkranjkok^]okn`ajo`a@aqoa`]n]vk( o lk`ane]oan`e]^ he_k*Ço]_n]hev]k`klk`an(baep]lah]pakhkce]lkhpe_](o lk`ane]klkn)oa] `aikjev]k*aoo]ei]caio]p je_]`]lkhpe_]_kik]kok_e]hlqn]iajpadqi]j]mqa kopanikoj^nrf^sif`laj^nrf^sbifpjl`aoecj]i*Rk_^qhkomqa(_kikoar(jkatlneiai qi_kjda_eiajpkna]h`]k^n]`aI]mqe]rahaoei]_kj`aj]kpakh ce_]`ah]*
=e`ae]`aok^an]je]
!LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
=
k`aohec]nklk`anlkhpe_k`abqj`]iajpkojklkhpe_ko$@aqo(j]pqnav](n]vk%a]k ]npe_qh)hk`ereokok_e]hajpnakocn]j`aoaklkrk(I]mqe]rah]^neq_]iejdkl]n] qi]`eo_qookaooaj_e]hl]n]klajo]iajpklkhpe_kik`anjk(mq]hoaf](]e`ae]`a ok^an]je](aih]pei(prjj^mlqbpq^p(oqiklk`ankqlk`anoqlnaik* J]pn]`ek(Îok^an]jkÏ`aoecj]]laook]boe_]`kckranj]jpaaoanabana]knaekq]k eilan]`kn*=^]p]hd]`]`qlh]ejraope`qn](mqareiko]jpanekniajpa(nabane])oafqop]iajpa mqaopk`ao]^anmqaian]]laook]ok^an]j](keilan]`knkqkl]l]*@]iaoi]i]jaen]( ]ejrajk`]pakne]`koÎ`keo_knlko`knaeÏlnapaj`e]]ooacqn]nmqaknaebkooaok^an]jk( `eopejcqej`kajpna]bn]mqav](Újepq`aaiknp]he`]`a`aoq]laook]boe_](abkn](lanaje`]) `aaeiknp]he`]`a`aoq]laook]lkhpe_]* Reikop]i^imqaI]mqe]rah]^]j`kjkq]`aÚjek`konaceiaolah]`eopejkajpna kjiank`ackranj]jpao$qi(]hcqjo(pk`ko%alahkr]hkn]pne^q`k]mqaickranj]$dkjn]( renpq`a(he^an`]`a%(mqaan]iko_nepnekorej`ko`]ÚhkokÚ]lkhpe_]]neopkphe_]*Aihqc]n `aoo]`eo_qook(oq]k^n]rkhpkq)oal]n]]e`ae]`aLnej_el]`k$mqalk`ane]oanikjnmqe_k( ]neopk_npe_kkq`aik_npe_k%*Aoo]e`ae]ej`e_]r]mqaaop]r]ai_qnokat]p]iajpa]mqao) pk`]ok^an]je]amqaaop]an]lkop]]`eop j_e]`a`keocn]j`aoner]eo(]Ecnaf]kqkl]l](ako Cn]j`ao(kq]jk^nav]a]^qncqaoe]qn^]j]o_kioq]o_knlkn] ao`akb_ekoaikjkl heko _kian_e]eo* @aoo]i]jaen](]k^n]`aI]mqe]rah_kia]]ej`e_]nmqalpl_bo^klklrj^mbppl^ bpfjlmlabomliqf`lfkabmbkabkqbalmlaboobifdflplbalmlabob`lkjf`l*?kieook(]jqj) _e]]k^n]`klajo]`knbn]j_oFa]j>k`ej(klneiaenk]bkniqh]nik`anj]iajpak_kj_aepk `aok^an]je]*@kn]r]jpa(pl_bo^kljkkckranj]jpaaoeikAop]`k* Aioq]k^n](Lppbfpifsolpa^obm _if`^(lq^he_]`]ai-1.,(>k`ejejpnk`qv]e`ae]`] ok^an]je]_kiklk`anje_k`ahaceoh]na_ki]j`]n(lanpaj_ajpajk]kckranj]jpa$mqa abiank%aoei]kAop]`k$mqalani]jajpaa`qn]`kqnk%*>pl_bo^kf^mbomqr^8ldlsbo* kl)m^pp^dbfol*KAop]`k_kikok^an]jkajpaj`e`k_kikqioeopai]]npe_qh]`kmqanaja qi]kn`aifqn`e_]$k`enaepka]haceoh]k%aqi]]qpkne`]`aej`alaj`ajpa$k_ki]j`ka kqok`]bkn]%*?kieook(>k`ej`eopejcqaklk`anok^an]jk`akqpnkolk`anao$nahecekoko( a_kjie_ko(ok_e]eo%mqao lk`aioanatan_e`kook^]okn`ajoaok^k_kjpnkha`kAop]`k*
*EANß"ODINß ß JURISTAßEßPROFESSORßFRANCoS
Kiqj`k`aokn`aj]`k
=
k^n]`aI]mqe]rah(_nepe_]`]aipk`]l]npa(]p]_]`]lkn_]p he_koalnkpaop]jpao(_kj) oe`an]`]]pae]ao]p je_](pknjkq)oa(lkni(]nabanj_e]k^nec]p ne]`klajo]iajpk lkhpe_kik`anjk*=e`ae]`amqa]Új]he`]`a`]lkhpe_]]pki]`]a_kjoanr]k `klk`anamqaaopajklnkri`a@aqo(jai`]n]vk(jai`aqi]kn`aij]pqn]hbaep]`a dean]nmqe]oÚt]oateceqmqakockranj]jpaofqopeÚ_]ooai]k_ql]k`klk`an*Ai]hcqjo
02.
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
_]oko(_kikj]Bn]j]aj]Lnooe](oqncen]pakne]`k`enaepk`erejk`konaeo(^]oa]`]j] nabkniqh]kfqn`e_]`]]jpec]pakhkce]lkhpe_]`kÎnaelah]cn]]`erej]Ïa`koÎ`keo_knlko `knaeÏ*J]i]ekne]`kol]oao(lkni(]_kj_alkpak_npe_]jkbkei]jpe`]a(l]npej`k`a I]mqe]rah(kopa ne_koperan]i`aah]^kn]njkr]opakne]olkhpe_]o* L]n]_kilnaaj`anikoko_kj_aepkomqabqj`]nkaoo]ojkr]opakne]olna_eo]iko_kj) oe`an]n]hcqjo]_kjpa_eiajpkodeop ne_komqaiq`]n]i]b]_aa_kjie_]aok_e]h`]Aqnkl] ajpnakoo_qhkoTRaTREE* F iaj_ekj]iko( ]k pn]p]n `k e`a]h nalq^he_]jk( k jkrk l]lah `]o _e`]`ao a `] jkr] _h]ooaok_e]h$]^qncqaoe]%jklh]jka_kjie_k(ok_e]halkhpe_k*Kqpnkob]pknao(]hi`k_nao) _eiajpk`]o_knlkn] ao`akb_eka`k_kin_ek(okp]i^ieilknp]jpaol]n]kbknp]ha_e) iajpk`aoo]jkr]_h]ooa6 ]`a_]`j_e]anqj]`aejian]ob]ihe]o]neopk_npe_]o(_qf]onemqav]obkn]i_kjoqie) `]oj]ocqann]o`]o?nqv]`]o_kjpn]kon]^aoa_qf]opann]oÚ_]n]i]^]j`kj]`]olkn) mqaoaqojk^naooajdknaol]npen]il]n]]cqann]a]heiknnan]ioai`aet]ndan`aenko* Kqpnko(]k_kjpn]en`re`]o_ki]?knk]l]n]_kiln]`a]ni]iajpkoal]c]iajpk`a atn_epkol]n]]o?nqv]`]o(peran]ioq]opann]o_kjÚo_]`]olahknael]n]_k^nen]o`re) `]o*Kooanrko`]cha^](mqapn]^]hd]r]ijaoo]olnklnea`]`ao(^ai_kikko_]ilkja) oaolk^naoahernao(mqa]o]nnaj`]r]iaipnk_]`aoanreko(iecn]r]il]n]]o_e`]`ao( pknj]j`k)oaiai^nko`]o_knlkn] ao`akb_ekokqoanrkoqn^]jko`ab]ihe]ojk^nao mqal]oo]n]i]oa`a`e_]n]k_kin_ek7 ]`a_]`j_e]]cnne]bke]_ahan]`]p]i^ilknqi]cn]j`alaopamqa]ookhkq]Aqnkl] jkÚj]h`]E`]`aI`e]$]_d]i]`]Îlaopajacn]Ï%(mqa`eveikqcajpa(c]`ka_khdaep]o( ]nnqej]j`k]jk^nav]bqj`ene]a_]qo]j`kiecn] aol]n]]o_e`]`ao7 ]re`]qn^]j]lnkrk_kqk_nao_eiajpk`a]pere`]`ao]npao]j]eoa(_kiah]o(k`aoajrkh) reiajpk_kian_e]hl]n]_kiln]araj`]`kolnk`qpko(_ne]j`kaola_e]he`]`aonacekj]eo akejpan_ i^ek_kian_e]haipk`]]Aqnkl]7 ]o cn]j`ao nkp]o `k _kin_ek _ki k Kneajpa( `kiej]`]o lneiaenk lah]o _e`]`ao ep]) he]j]oa`alkeolahkoeilnekoqhpn]i]nejko`aLknpqc]h(Aol]jd](Ejch]pann]aBn]j]( ]npe_qh]`]oonkp]o_kian_e]eojkejpanekn`]ln lne]Aqnkl]aqn^]jev]k(`an]i knecai]qijkrkpelk`anemqav](k_]lep]h(^]oa]`kjkhq_nk]`rej`k`]atlhkn]k`k pn]^]hdk`kodkiajolk^naoahernaomqad]re]iiecn]`kl]n]]o_e`]`aoaj]atlhkn]) k`kpn]^]hdkao_n]rk`aj`ekoajacnkoj]o=ine_]o* J]o_e`]`ao(lneiaenk(ajk_]ilk(`alkeo(]ieone]a]olooei]o_kj`e ao`apn]^]hdk a`are`]har]n]iko_]ilkjaoaolk^nao]narkhp]o_kjpn]kone_ko*Jk_]ilk(p]eonarkhp]o bkn]iqi`koabaepko`]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa(mqa]_qo]n]]Ecnaf]a]jk^nav]]cnne]`a_k) iapanaikla_]`k`]]i^ek(atlhkn]j`kaklneiej`kkolk^nao*J]o_e`]`ao(]onarkhp]o lklqh]naoan]ip]i^iqiabaepk`]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa(mqad]re]`a_h]n]`k]ecq]h`]`a aolenepq]h`kooanaodqi]jko(^Ûoj^kal`ljlmofk`fm^isfoqrablqo^_^ielbmofk`fm^is`fl ^mobdrf ^Í]o_h]ooaolklqh]naoqn^]j]o_kjoe`an]n]imqa]ecq]h`]`ajkan]^mbk^p bpmfofqr^i(i]oq^j_jpl`f^i(ahqp]r]i_kjpn]]oejfqope]o`kone_kook^nakolk^nao* K`aoajrkhreiajpka_kjie_k`]o_e`]`ao(koqnceiajpk`]^qncqaoe]_kian_e]jpakq ian_]jpeh(k_nao_eiajpk`]_h]ooa`kopn]^]hd]`knaolk^naoi]ohernao$eopk(oaih]ko`a oanre`k_kikooajdknaobaq`]eo%(]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpa(mqamqaopekj]n]klk`ana_kjie_k alkhpe_k`]Ecnaf](]onarkhp]olklqh]nao(]ocqann]oajpnalkpj_e]olahk`kijek`koi]nao a`kojkrkopannep neko`ao_k^anpko(]mqa`]`anaeoa`ab]ihe]o`]jk^nav](]]o_ajok`a b]ihe]o`a_kian_e]jpaoa`ajkrkonaeomqa]ob]rkna_e]i_kjpn]kojk^nao(pk`koaooaob]pko are`aj_e]r]imqa]e`ae]_neop(dan`]`]`kEilnekNki]jka_kjokhe`]`]lah]Ecnaf]Nki]) j](`aqiiqj`k_kjopepq`kj]pqn]hiajpalkndean]nmqe]oÚt]o(an]qi]e`ae]mqajk_kn) naolkj`e]na]he`]`a*=]jpec]e`ae]`k`enaepkj]pqn]hk^faperk_kikkn`aiÚt]`]j]pqnav]a `]ok_ea`]`alan`an]oajpe`k`e]jpa`apk`]oaoo]oiq`]j]ook_e]eo(a_kjie_]oap_je_]o*
02/
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=jkr]oepq]kdeop ne_]b]ve]]l]na_an`keob]pkomqajklk`e]ioanjac]`ko6 -*
]ateopj_e]`aej`er`qkoÍqi^qncqoaqipn]^]hd]`knjklk`e]iejrk_]no]j) cqa(b]ihe](hejd]caia`ej]ope]l]n]atlhe_]nlknmqaateope]ialknmqad]re]iiq) `]`k`alkoekok_e]h(i]oo lk`e]iejrk_]n^pfjbpjlp_kikej`er`qko_qf]]k lnk`qven] ] iq`]j] `a oq] oepq]k a `a oq] lkoek a_kjie_k)ok_e]h* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( k oqnceiajpk `a `q]o jkr]o _h]ooao ok_e]eo $] ^qncqaoe] a ko pn]^]hd]`knao hernao%are`aj_e]r]mqalan`an]oajpe`k]e`ae]`amqa_]`]qioa`aÚjalah]b]ihe]a lahkcnqlk]mqalanpaj_aalahkhqc]nj]pqn]h`aoo]b]ihe]kq`aooacnqlkj]kn`ai deannmqe_]aÚt]`kQjeranok7
.*
]ateopj_e]`a_kjÛepkoajpnaej`er`qkoacnqlko`aej`er`qkolah]lkooa`anemqa) v]o(_]ncko(lkopkoalk`anao]jqh]r]p]jpk]lnpe_]ia`ear]h`]oq^ieookj]pqn]h`k ejbanekn]koqlanekn$eopk(]lnpe_]`]r]oo]h]cai(mqaoqopajp]n]ka`eb_ekok_e]halk) hpe_k`]E`]`aI`e]%_kik]ei]cai`]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_]qj](ej`ereo]abn]panj]( p]h_kikd]re]oe`k_kj_a^e`]lah]pn]`ek_neop*
K
_kj_aepk`aaop]`k`aj]pqnav]kq`a_kj`ekj]pqn]hpai]bqjk`aatlhe_]n ] oepq]k ln)ok_e]h j] mq]h ko ej`er`qko ateopai eokh]`]iajpa* @q]o bkn]i ]o lnej_el]eo_kj_al ao`kaop]`k`aj]pqnav]6
-*
]_kj_alk`aPdki]oDk^^ao$jko_qhkTREE%(oacqj`k]mq]h(aiaop]`k`aj]pq) nav](koej`er`qkoreraieokh]`koaaihqp]lani]jajpa(reckn]j`k]cqann]`apk`ko _kjpn]pk`kokqÎkdkiaihk^k`kdkiaiÏ*Jaooaaop]`knaej]kjbala(lnej_el]h) iajpa(kdo^kabjbal6k`]iknparekhajp]*L]n]oalnkpacanaiqjo`kokqpnko(kodq) i]jkoejrajp]n]i]o]ni]oa_an_]n]i]opann]omqak_ql]r]i*Aoo]o`q]o]pepq`ao okejpaeo(lkeooailnad]ran]hcqii]eobknpamqaraj_anki]eobn]_kak_ql]n ]opann]o_an_]`]o*=re`]jkpaic]n]jpe]o7]lkooajkpaina_kjda_eiajpka(lknp]j) pk(jkateopa7]je_]hae]bkn]`ki]eobknpa(mqalk`apq`kmq]jpkpajd]bkn]l]n] _kjmqeop]na_kjoanr]n7
.*
]_kj_alk`aFa]j)F]_mqaoNkqooa]q$jko_qhkTREEE%(oacqj`k]mq]h(aiaop]`k`a j]pqnav](koej`er`qkoreraieokh]`kolah]oÛknaop]o(ok^nareraj`k_kikmqa]j]pq) nav]hdao`(`ao_kjda_aj`khqp]oa_kiqje_]j`k)oalahkcaopk(lahkcnepkalahk_]jpk( jqi]hejcq]caicajanko]a^ajarkhajpa*Aooaaop]`k`aÎbahe_e`]`aknecej]hÏ(jkmq]h kodqi]jkoateopaij]_kj`ek`aÏ_ljpbis^dbjÐfkl`bkqb(paniej]mq]j`k]hcqi _an_]qipannajka`ev6ÎiaqÏ*=`ereokajpnaÎkiaqÏaÎkpaqÏ(eopk(koqnceiajpk`] lnklnea`]`alner]`](`knecai]kaop]`k`aok_ea`]`a(jkmq]hlnar]ha_a]cqann]`a pk`ko_kjpn]pk`ko*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(lbpq^alabpl`fba^abolrppb^rfpq^`loobpmlkab ^lbpq^alabk^qrobw^el__bpf^kl*
Kaop]`k`aj]pqnav]`aDk^^aoakaop]`k`aok_ea`]`a`aNkqooa]qare`aj_e]iqi] lan_alk`kok_e]h_kikhqp]ajpnabn]_koabknpao(reckn]j`kklk`an`]bkn]kq]rkjp]`a `ki]eobknpa*Aipk`]l]npanaej]i]ejoacqn]j](]hqp](kia`ka]iknpa*L]n]b]van_aoo]n aooaaop]`k`are`]]ia]]`kna]ia]]`kkodqi]jko`a_e`ail]oo]n`fsfq^pkqok_ea) `]`a_ereh(eopk(]kbpq^al`fsfi(_ne]j`kklk`anlkhpe_ka]ohaeo*
4HOMASß(OBBESßß ßFILvSOFOßß MATERIALISTAßINGLoS
4HEß'ALLERYß#OLLECTION#ORBISß ,ATINSTOCK
Aop]`k`aj]pqnav](_kjpn]pkok_e]h(aop]`k_ereh
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
Kopa ne_kolna_eo]r]i(lknp]jpk(atlhe_]nkmqaan]ikoej`er`qkoalknmqahqp]r]i iknp]hiajpaqjo_kjpn]kokqpnko(]hi`alna_eo]naikbana_anpakne]o_]l]vao`aokhq_ek) j]nko_kjÛepkoa]ocqann]ook_e]eo*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(bkn]ibkn]`ko]ej`]c]nmq]h] knecai`]ok_ea`]`aa`]lkhpe_]*Lknmqaej`er`qkoeokh]`kobkni]iqi]ok_ea`]`a;Lkn mqaej`er`qkoej`alaj`ajpao]_aep]ioq^iapan)oa]klk`anlkhpe_kaohaeo; =naolkop]]aoo]o`q]olancqjp]o_kj`qv(lneiaen]iajpa(e`ae]`apl_bo^kf^alBpq^* al(mqareikojaopap le_k(a(]oacqen(oe`ae]o`abpq^alabk^qrobw^abpq^al`fsfi*
*EAN *ACQUESß2OUSSEAUß ßFILvSOFOßEßß ESCRITORßFRANCoS
020
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
Kl]_pkkq_kjpn]pkok_e]h =l]oo]cai`kaop]`k`aj]pqnav]]kaop]`k_erehkqok_ea`]`a_erehoa`lkniaek `aqil]_pkok_e]hkq_kjpn]pkok_e]h(lahkmq]hkoej`er`qko_kj_kn`]iainajqj_e]n he^an`]`aj]pqn]h$kqklk`anl]n]b]vanpq`kkmqaoamqan(`ao`amqajajdqik^op_qhk eila]]]k%alkooaj]pqn]h`a^ajoa]ni]oaaipn]jobanen]qipan_aenkÍkok^an]jk Íklk`anl]n]_ne]na]lhe_]n]ohaeo$`apaniej]j`kkhac]hakehac]h(kfqopkakejfqopk(klan) iepe`kaklnke^e`k%(qo]n]bkn]$aj_]nnac]j`k)oa(aijkia`apk`ko(`arejc]nko_neiao%( `a_h]n]n]cqann]a]l]v*K_kjpn]pkok_e]hbqj`]]ok^an]je]aejopepqe]]qpkne`]`alkhpe_]( eopk(]mifpkq]`fsfq^p*ejopepq`k(lknp]jpk(kaop]`k_ereh(mqa`aralnqiÚiohqp]o iknp]eo`kaop]`k`aj]pqnav]$dk^^aoe]jk%kq`kaop]`k`aok_ea`]`a$nkqooa]qeop]%* ?kiklkoorahk_kjpn]pkkqkl]_pkok_e]h;Mq]hoq]hacepeie`]`a;Kopa ne_koej) rk_]nkqi]_hqoqh]`k@enaepkNki]jkÍÎJejcqilk`a`]nkmqajkpaiajejcqi lk`apen]nkmqajk`aqÏÍa]HaeNce]nki]j]ÍÎKlk`anlanpaj_a]klkrkalknaha _kjbane`k]kok^an]jkÏÍl]n]hacepei]n]pakne]`k_kjpn]pkkq`kl]_pkok_e]h*
Kfqoj]pqn]heoik Klkjpk`al]npe`]`]opakne]o`k_kjpn]pkk_kj_aepk`a`enaepkj]pqn]h6mlok^qrobw^( pk`kej`er`qkpai`enaepkre`](]kmqaja_aoonekok^narerj_e]`aoaq_knlk(ahe^an) `]`a*Mlok^qrobw^(pk`kookhernao(]ej`]mqa(mlok^qrobw^(qjooaf]ii]eobknpaoakqpnko i]eobn]_ko*Qi_kjpn]pkkqqil]_pk(`eve]]pakne]fqn`e_]nki]j](o pair]he`]`aoa]o l]npao_kjpn]p]jpaobknaihernaoaecq]eoaoarkhqjpne]ahernaiajpa`anaioaq_kjoajpe) iajpk]kmqaaopoaj`kl]_pq]`k* =pakne]`k`enaepkj]pqn]hkqkfqoj]pqn]heoik$`enaepk(aih]pei(oa`evgrp(`kj`a Îfqope]Ï aÎfqopkÏ% c]n]jpa aoo]o `q]o _kj`e ao l]n] r]he`]n k _kjpn]pk ok_e]h kq k l]_pk lkhpe_k*@ab]pk(oa]ol]npao_kjpn]p]jpaolkooqaikoiaoiko`enaepkoj]pqn]eoaokhernao( ajpklkooqaik`enaepkaklk`anl]n]pn]jobanen]he^an`]`a]qipan_aenk7aoa_kjoajpai rkhqjpne] a hernaiajpa jeook( ajpk ah]o `k ]k ok^an]jk ]hck mqa lkooqai( `a i]jaen] mqaklk`an`]ok^an]je]hacpeiklknmqaj]o_a`]`k]kkqpn]jobanj_e]rkhqjpne]`a `enaepko`koej`er`qko*=ooei(lkniaek`k`enaepkj]pqn]h(koej`er`qkob]vaiqil]_pk `a reran ai _kiqi oai _]qo]n `]jk qjo ]ko kqpnko* ?ki eook bkni]i hernaiajpa qi] rkjp]`aok_e]hmqakohar]]pn]jobanen]kok^an]jkklk`anl]n]ckranj)hko* L]n]Dk^^ao(kodkiajonaqje`kojqi]jriqfal`aej`er`qko(lahkl]_pk(l]oo]i] _kjopepqenqi_knlklkhpe_k(qi]laook]]npeÚ_e]h_ne]`]lah]]kdqi]j]amqaoa_d]i] Aop]`k*L]n]Nkqooa]q(koej`er`qkoj]pqn]eookmbppl^pjlo^fp(mqa(lahkl]_pk(_ne]i] slkq^abdbo^i_kik_knlkikn]h_khaperkkqAop]`k* =pakne]`k`enaepkj]pqn]ha`k_kjpn]pk(kqfqoj]pqn]heoik(are`aj_e]qi]ejkr]k`a cn]j`aeilknp j_e]6lmbkp^jbkqlmliqf`lgklc^i^bj`ljrkfa^ab)j^pbjpl`fba^ab* =e`ae]`a`ljrkfa^ablnaooql aqicnqlkdqi]jkqjk(dkikcjak(ej`ereok(_kil]npe) hd]j`kkoiaoiko^ajo(]oiaoi]o_naj]oae`ae]o(koiaoiko_kopqiaoalkooqej`kqi `aopejk _kiqi* = e`ae] `a pl`fba^ab( ]k _kjpnnek( lnaooql a ] ateopj_e] `a ej`er`qko ej`alaj`ajpaoaeokh]`ko(`kp]`ko`a`enaepkoj]pqn]eoaej`ere`q]eo(mqa`a_e`ai(lknqi ]pkrkhqjpnek(pknj]nai)oao _ekokq]ook_e]`kol]n]r]jp]caina_lnk_]alknejpanaooao na_lnk_ko*=_kiqje`]`a]e`ae]`aqi]_khapere`]`aj]pqn]hkq`erej]7]ok_ea`]`a(]`a qi]_khapere`]`arkhqjpne](deop ne_]adqi]j]*
KAop]`k
021
=ok_ea`]`a_erehkAop]`klnklne]iajpa`epk*Pn]p])oa`]ok_ea`]`amqareraok^k `enaepk_ereh(eopk(ok^k`enaepklkoeperkj]bkni]`]ohaeolnkiqhc]`]oa]lhe_]`]olahk ok^an]jk*Baepkkl]_pkkqk_kjpn]pk(ko_kjpn]p]jpaopn]jobanaik`enaepkj]pqn]h]kok^a) n]jka_kieookk]qpknev]i]pn]jobkni)hkai`enaepk_erehkq`enaepklkoeperk(c]n]jpej`k ]re`](]he^an`]`aa]lnklnea`]`alner]`]`kockranj]`ko*Aijkia`]oacqn]j]a`]
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
l]v(koej`er`qkopn]jobanai]kok^an]jkk`enaepkat_hqoerk]kqok`]bkn]a`]rekhj_e]( `]rejc]j]_kjpn]ko_neiao(`]nacqh]iajp]k`ko_kjpn]pkoa_kjie_ko(eopk(]ejope) pqekfqn`e_]`]lnklnea`]`alner]`]a`akqpnko_kjpn]pkook_e]eo$_kik(lknatailhk(k _]o]iajpk_ereh(]haceoh]kok^na]dan]j](ap_*%* Mqaikok^an]jk;Dk^^aoaNkqooa]q`ebanaij]naolkop]]aoo]lancqjp]* L]n]Dk^^ao(kok^an]jklk`aoanqinae(qicnqlk`a]neopk_n]p]okqqi]]ooai^hae] `aik_npe_]*?kikl]n]>k`ej(p]i^il]n]Dk^^aokbqj`]iajp]hjkkjiank`ko ckranj]jpaojai]bkni]`knaceialkhpe_k$ikj]nmqe](]neopk_n]_e](`aik_n]_e]%(i]o] `apaniej]k`amqailkooqeklk`ankq]ok^an]je]*Aop]lanpaj_a`aik`k]^okhqpk]k Aop]`k(mqa(lkniaek`]oejopepqe aol^he_]o(paiklk`anl]n]lnkiqhc]na]lhe_]n]ohaeo( `aÚjenac]n]jpen]lnklnea`]`alner]`]aatecenk^a`ej_e]ej_kj`e_ekj]h`kockranj]`ko( `ao`amqanaolaepa`keo`enaepkoj]pqn]eoejpn]jobanraeo6kafobfql sfa^akafobfql m^w( lkeobkelknahaomqakok^an]jkbke_ne]`k*Kok^an]jk`api]aol]`]a]hae7kockranj]`ko( ]re`]a]lnklnea`]`a`ko^ajo* L]n]Nkqooa]q(kok^an]jkklkrk(ajpaj`e`k_kikrkjp]`acan]h(laook]ikn]h_kha) per]hernaa_knlklkhpe_k`a_e`]`ko*Koej`er`qko(lahk_kjpn]pk(_ne]n]i)oa]oeiaoiko _kiklkrka]aopamqapn]jobanaiko`enaepkoj]pqn]eol]n]mqaoaf]ipn]jobkni]`koai `enaepko_ereo*=ooeioaj`k(kckranj]jpajkkok^an]jk(i]okobmobpbkq^kqb`]ok^an]je] lklqh]n*Koej`er`qko]_aep]ilan`an]he^an`]`aj]pqn]hlah]he^an`]`a_ereh7]_aep]ilan) `ank`enaepklkooaj]pqn]h`a^ajol]n]c]jd]n]ej`ere`q]he`]`a_ereh(eopk(]_e`]`]je] a(_kiah](k`enaepk_erehlnklnea`]`a`a^ajo*Ajmq]jpk_ne]i]ok^an]je]ajah]oab]vai nalnaoajp]n(ok`fa^alp*Ajmq]jpkoaoq^iapaiohaeoa]qpkne`]`a`kckranj]jpamqa konalnaoajp](_d]i]i)oap afqlp*Ok(lkeo(_e`]`ko`kAop]`kao`epko`]ohaeo* ?kikl]n]Dk^^ao]ok^an]je]lanpaj_amqaha]mqaik`enaepkj]pqn]hbkepn]jobane`k l]n]mqa]ooacqnal]vaoacqn]j](knaceialkhpe_kmqahdal]na_ai]eo_]l]v`ana]hev]n aoo]Új]he`]`a]jlk^onrf^*=k_kjpnnek(l]n]Nkqooa]q(oaj`k]ok^an]je]oailnalklq) h]nkq`klkrk(knaceiamqaiahdknna]hev]ne]]oÚj]he`]`ao`k_kjpn]pkok_e]h]abjl`o^* `f^afobq^lrm^oqf`fm^qfs^*
=pakne]he^an]h =^qncqaoe]a]lnklnea`]`alner]`] Jklajo]iajpklkhpe_k`aDk^^aoa`aNkqooa]q(]lnklnea`]`alner]`]jkqi`e) naepkj]pqn]h(i]o_ereh*@epk`akqpnkik`k(iaoikmqajkaop]`k`aj]pqnav]$aiDk^^ao% ajkaop]`k`aok_ea`]`a$aiNkqooa]q%koej`er`qkooa]lkooai`apann]o(`akqpnkodk) iajoa`a^ajo(aoo]lkooakiaoikmqaj]`](lkeojkateopaihaeol]n]c]n]jpe)h]o*?]`] qilna_eo]]ni]n)oal]n]lnkpac)h](oaic]n]jpe]`amqak_kjoacqen*K`enaepk_ereh(]k _kjpnnek(]ooacqn]]lkooalkniaek`]ohaeoa]hacepei]j]bkni]`alnklnea`]`alner]`]* Aop](lknp]jpk(qiabaepk`k_kjpn]pkok_e]haqi`a_napk`kok^an]jk* Aoo]pakne]`]hacepeie`]`a_ereh`]lnklnea`]`alner]`](lkni(jkan]oqÚ_eajpal]n] ]^qncqaoe]ai]o_ajok(_qfklk`analnaopcekaop]r]ibqj`]`koj]lnklnea`]`alner]`] `]nemqav]* @ab]pk(ai^kn]k_]lep]heoikaoperaooaaire]`a_kjokhe`]kaklk`aneka_kjie_k `]^qncqaoe]bkooaej_kjpaopa(aipk`]l]npaknaceialkhpe_klani]ja_e]ikjnmqe_ka( _kieook(klk`aneklkhpe_k`]na]hav]aklnaopcekok_e]h`]jk^nav]p]i^i*L]n]mqak mlabob`lkjf`la^_rodrbpf^lq`aooaajbnajp]nkmlabomliqf`lalpobfpba^pkl_obw^p] ^qncqaoe]lna_eo]r]`aqi]pakne]mqahda`aooaqi]hacepeie`]`apkcn]j`akqi]ekn`k mqako]jcqaa]dana`ep]nea`]`a`]r]ina]hav]ajk^nav]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]ooei _kiko]jcqaadana`ep]nea`]`a`]r]ina]hav]ajk^nav]qibqj`]iajpkj]pqn]hl]n]k lk`anaklnaopcek(]^qncqaoe]lna_eo]r]`aqi]pakne]mqa`aooa]koaqlk`ana_kjie_k p]i^iqibqj`]iajpkj]pqn]h(_]l]v`aofs^ifw^o_kiklk`anlkhpe_k`]na]hav]aklnao)
022
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
*OHNß,OCKEß ß FILvSOFOßINGLoS
pcekok_e]h`]jk^nav](a]piaoikoqlh]jp)hko*Aoo]pakne]oan]`]lnklnea`]`alner]`] _kik`enaepkj]pqn]haoq]lneiaen]bkniqh]k_kanajpaoanbaep]lahkÚh okbkejchoFkdj Hk_ga(jkÚj]h`ko_qhkTREEaej_ek`ko_qhkTREEE* Hk_gal]npa`]`aÚjek`k`enaepkj]pqn]h_kik`enaepkre`](he^an`]`aa]ko^ajo ja_aoonekol]n]]_kjoanr]k`a]i^]o*Aooao^ajook_kjoacqe`kolahkpn]^]hdk* ?kikb]van`kpn]^]hdkkhacepei]`kn`]lnklnea`]`alner]`]ajmq]jpk`enaepkj]pqn]h; @aqo( ao_nara Hk_ga( qi ]npÚ_a( qi k^naenk( ]nmqepapk a ajcajdaenk mqa bav qi] k^n]6kiqj`k*Aopa(_kikk^n]`kpn]^]hd]`kn`erejk(]ahalanpaj_a*oaq`kijekaoq] lnklnea`]`a*@aqo_nekqkdkiaioq]ei]caiaoaiahd]j](`aq)hdakiqj`kl]n]mqa jahanaej]ooaa(]katlqho)hk`kL]n]ok(jkhdanapenkqk`kijek`kiqj`k(i]ohda`eooa mqakpane]_kikoqkn`aoaqnkopk*Lknpk`koaooaoikperko(@aqoejopepqeq(jkikiajpk `]_ne]k`kiqj`ka`kdkiai(k`enaepklnklnea`]`alner]`]_kikbnqpkhacpeik`k pn]^]hdk*Lkneook(`aknecai`erej](ah]qi`enaepkj]pqn]h* KAop]`kateopa]l]npen`k_kjpn]pkok_e]h*Pai]obqj aomqaDk^^aohda]pne^qe(i]o oq]lnej_el]hÚj]he`]`ac]n]jpenk`enaepkj]pqn]h`alnklnea`]`a* @aoo]i]jaen](]^qncqaoe]oarejpaen]iajpaibdfqfj^a^lan]jpa]na]hav]a]jk^nav] a(i]eo`kmqaeook(oqnca_kikprmboflo]ah]o(qi]ravmqak^qncqo]_na`ep]mqalnk) lneapnekcn]]o]koaqln lnekpn]^]hdk(ajmq]jpknaeoajk^naookl]n]oep]o`]ok_ea`]`a kq`kpn]^]hdk]hdaek* K ^qncqo jk oa na_kjda_a ]laj]o _kik oqlanekn ok_e]h a ikn]hiajpa ]ko jk^nao( i]op]i^i_kikoqlanekn]kolk^nao*@ab]pk(oa@aqobavpk`kokodkiajoecq]eo(oa] pk`ko`aq]ieook`apn]^]hd]na]pk`ko_kj_a`aqk`enaepklnklnea`]`alner]`](ajpk( kolk^nao(eopk(kopn]^]hd]`knaomqajk_kjoacqaipknj]n)oalnklneapnekolner]`ko(ok `rim^alplknoq]_kj`ekejbanekn*Oklk^nao(jkoklnklneapnekoapi]k^nec]k`a pn]^]hd]nl]n]kqpnko(oaf]lknmqaoklan`qhneko(c]op]j`kko]hnekairav`a]_qiqh)hk l]n]]`mqenenlnklnea`]`ao(oaf]lknmqaoklnacqekokoajkpn]^]hd]ikoqÚ_eajpal]n] _kjoacqenqi]lnklnea`]`a*
KAop]`khe^an]h Oa]bqjk`kAop]`kjk]`a_ne]nkqejopepqen]lnklnea`]`alner]`](i]o`ac]n]jpe)h] a`abaj`)h]_kjpn]]jk^nav]akolk^nao(mq]hklk`an`kok^an]jk; =pakne]he^an]h(lneiaenk_kiHk_ga(`alkeo_kikona]hev]`knao`]Ej`alaj`j_e]jkn) pa)]iane_]j]a`]NarkhqkBn]j_ao](ajko_qhkTT(_kilajo]`knao_kikI]tSa^an( `enmqa]bqjk`kAop]`kpnlhe_a6 -*
023
lkniaek`]ohaeoa`kqokhac]h`]rekhj_e]$atn_epkalkh_e]%(c]n]jpenk`enaepkj]) pqn]h `a lnklnea`]`a( oai ejpanbanen j] re`] a_kjie_]( lkeo( jk paj`k ejopepq`k ] lnklnea`]`a(kAop]`kjkpailk`anl]n]jah]ejpanbanen* L]n]ajpaj`anikok]h_]j_a`aoo]e`ae](lna_eo]ikohai^n]nmqak_]lep]heoik(ai oq]bkni]eje_e]h(pejd]jk_kin_ekoaqlkjpki]eoeilknp]jpal]n]]]_qiqh]k`k_]) lep]h*Aoo]bkni](_kjda_e`]_kikjbo`^kqfifpjl(harkqo`ao_k^anp]oi]npei]oabkn) i]k`kocn]j`aoeilnekoqhpn]i]nejko*Ai`a_knnj_e]`]bkni]lkhpe_]ikjnmqe_]( konaeokq]o_knk]oaqnklae]ol]oo]n]i]_kjpnkh]npk`kaooa_kin_ek(mqaan]]bkjpa`a oqopajp]k`aoaqlk`anlkhpe_k*Aooa_kjpnkhaan]baepklahkikjkl heka_kjie_k(atan) _e`klahkonaeo*@aopao`alaj`e]i]o_kj_aoo aol]n]re]cajoaatlhkn]k`ajkr]opann]o( lnako`kolnk`qpko(p]neb]o(eilkopkoaat_hqoere`]`ao$_]`]ikj]nmqe]naerej`e_]r]l]n] oekikjkl hekat_hqoerkj]_kian_e]hev]k`a`apaniej]`kolnk`qpko%*Kikjkl hekn) cekan]qik^op_qhk]k`aoajrkhreiajpka_kjie_k`]^qncqaoe](mqanaerej`e_]r]he^an) `]`al]n]]lnk`qki]jqb]pqnaen]a_kian_e]hev]k`kolnk`qpko*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o( ]^qncqaoe]atece]]he^an`]`a`aian_]`kl]n]k`aoajrkhreiajpk`k_]lep]heoik* Aoo]atecj_e]kmqapn]jol]na_aj]i]jaen]_kik]pakne]lkhpe_]he^an]hjac] ]kAop]`kklk`anl]n]ejpanbanenj]a_kjkie]*Aeolknmqaaoo]pakne]_d]i]`]he^an]h
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
kqhe^an]heoik(lkeol]n]ah]kAop]`k`aranaolaep]n]he^an`]`aa_kjie_]`kolnk) lneapnekolner]`ko(`aet]j`kmqab]]i]onacn]oa]ojkni]o`]o]pere`]`aoa_kjie) _]ooacqj`k]oja_aooe`]`ao`kln lnekian_]`kkq`]ln lne]a_kjkie]7 .*
reopkmqakolnklneapnekolner]`kook_]l]vao`aaop]^aha_an]onacn]oa]ojkni]o`] re`]a_kjie_]kq`kian_]`kamqakb]vai]cej`kjqi]aoban]mqajkaop]p]ha oeiok_e]h(ajpnakAop]`kakej`er`qkejpan_]h])oaqi]aoban]ok_e]h(]ok_ea`]`a_ereh( ok^na ] mq]h k Aop]`k jk pai lk`an ejopepqejpa( i]o ]laj]o ] bqjk `a c]n]jpe`kn `]onah] aook_e]eoa`an^epnk`ko_kjÛepkojah]ateopajpao*KAop]`kpai]bqjk`a ]n^epn]n(lkniaek`]ohaeoa`]bkn](ko_kjÛepko`]ok_ea`]`a_ereh* =mqe(jkr]iajpa(]Úni])oakhe^an]heoik(]k_kjoe`an]nmqa]ok_ea`]`a_ereh`ara panhe^an`]`al]n]oaknc]jev]nal]n]na]hev]n]o] aook_e]eooaiejpanbanj_e]`klk) `an`aAop]`kj]onah] aook_e]eo(mqajkokl^he_]oaoeilner]`]o*Okiajpamq]j) `k]onah] aook_e]eoajpnaej`er`qkolner]`koejbnejcen]ohaeol^he_]okqlnafq`e_]nk mqal^he_k(kAop]`klk`aejpanren7
/*
kAop]`kpaik`enaepk`ahaceoh]n(laniepenalnke^enpq`kmq]jpklanpaj]aoban]`] re`] l^he_]( i]o jk paik`enaepk`aejpanrenok^na]aoban]lner]`](eopk(ok^na ] `lkp`fk`f^`kockranj]`ko*KAop]`k`arac]n]jpen]he^an`]`a`a_kjo_ej_e](kqoaf]( ]he^an`]`a`alajo]iajpk`apk`kokockranj]`ko(ao lk`anatan_an_ajoqn]jko _]okoaimqaoaaiep]ikleje aooa`e_eko]omqalkjd]iaineo_kkln lnekAop]`k*
He^an`]`a`aian_]`kkqhe^an`]`al]n]]o] aoa_kjie_]obqj`]`]oj]lnklnea`]`a lner]`](he^an`]`a`aknc]jev]k`]ok_ea`]`a_erehkqhe^an`]`a`]onah] aook_e]eoajpna ej`er`qkolner]`kohernaoaecq]eo(ahe^an`]`a`a_kjo_ej_e]okkolkjpkojkomq]eokhe^a) n]heoikoa]Úni]a_kikomq]eoabifjfq^klk`an`kAop]`k* J]Ejch]pann](khe^an]heoikoa_kjokhe`]ai-244(_ki]_d]i]`]NarkhqkChkneko]* Jk naop]jpa `] Aqnkl]( oane] lna_eok ]cq]n`]n ] Narkhqk Bn]j_ao]( `a -345* Jko Aop]`ko Qje`ko(_kjokhe`])oaai-332(_ki]hqp]lah]ej`alaj`j_e]*
He^an]heoikabei`k=jpeckNaceia
=
oe`ae]olkhpe_]ohe^an]eopi_kikl]jk`abqj`k]hqp]_kjpn]]oikj]nmqe]o]^ok) hqp]olkn`enaepk`erejk`konaeo(`aner]`]o`]_kj_alkpak_npe_]`klk`an*Khe^a) n]heoik_kjokhe`])oa_kiko]_kjpa_eiajpko`a-345(j]Bn]j](eopk(]Narkhqk Bn]j_ao](mqa`annq^kqk=jpeckNaceia* >kqfdl(ailneiaenkhqc]n(lknmqalkhepe_]iajpapak_npe_ka]^okhqpeop]* >kqfdl(ai oacqj`khqc]n(lknmqaok_e]hiajpabqj`]`kj]e`ae]`adean]nmqe]`erej](j]pqn]haok_e]ha j]knc]jev]kbaq`]h(^]oa]`]jkl]_pk`aoq^ieook`kor]oo]hkokqo`epko]koajdkn* ?ki]oe`ae]o`a`enaepkj]pqn]h`koej`er`qkoa`aok_ea`]`a_ereh$nah] aoajpnaej`e) r`qkohernaoaecq]eolknj]pqnav]%(mqa^n])oa]e`ae]`adean]nmqe]*?ki]e`ae]`a_kjpn]pk ok_e]h$l]oo]cai`]e`ae]`al]_pk`aoq^ieook`al]_pkok_e]hajpnaej`er`qkohernaoa ecq]eo%mqa^n])oa]e`ae]`]knecai`erej]`klk`ana`]fqope]bqj`]`]j]orenpq`ao`k^ki ckranj]jpa* Kpniejk`k=jpeckNaceiaoa_kjoqi]mq]j`k]pakne]lkhpe_]_kjo]cn]]lnklnea`]) `alner]`]_kik`enaepkj]pqn]h`koej`er`qko(`aob]vaj`k]ei]cai`knae_kikÎi]ne`k`] pann]Ï(oajdkn`ko^ajoa`]onemqav]o`knaejk(`a_e`ej`koacqj`koq]rkjp]`aaoaq_]lne_dk mq]jpk]eilkopko(pne^qpkoap]t]o*=lnklnea`]`akqej`ere`q]halner]`](kqaop]p]hal) ^he_](f]i]eol]pneijeklaook]h`kikj]n_]*Klk`anpai]bkni]`aqiBpq^alobmr_if`^kl fjmbppl^ilknmqa]`a_eokok^naeilkopko(pne^qpkoap]t]opki]`]lknqil]nh]iajpkÍ kLk`anHaceoh]perkÍ(_kjopepq`klahkonalnaoajp]jpao`kolnklneapnekolner]`ko* =opakne]olkhpe_]ohe^an]eo]Úni]i(lknp]jpk(mqakej`er`qk]knecaiak`aopej]) pnek`klk`anlkhpe_k(j]o_e`k`aqi_kjpn]pkok_e]hrkhqjpnek(jkmq]hko_kjpn]p]jpao
024
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
_a`ailk`anao(i]ojk_a`aioq]ej`ere`q]he`]`a$re`](he^an`]`aalnklnea`]`a%*Kej`e) r`qk k_e`]`k* =Úni]ip]i^i]ateopj_e]`aqi]aoban]`anah] aook_e]eooal]n]`]o`]re`]lne) r]`]a`]re`]lkhpe_](]pl`fba^ab`fsfilod^kfw^a^(j]mq]hlnklneapnekolner]`koapn]^]) hd]`knao_ne]ioq]oknc]jev] ao`a_h]ooao(na]hev]i_kjpn]pko(`eolqp]iejpanaooaoalkoe) aooaimqakAop]`klkoo]]ejpanren(]jkoanmqaqi]`]ol]npaohdala]l]n]]n^epn]n ko_kjÛepkokqmqaqi]`]ol]npao]f]`aik`kmqal]na]laneckokl]n]]i]jqpajk`] ln lne]ok_ea`]`a* =Úni]ik`^oqboobmr_if`^kl`klk`an(eopk(kAop]`kklk`anl^he_kajahako ejpanaooao`kolnklneapneko`araiaop]nnalnaoajp]`kolkniaek`kL]nh]iajpka`kLk`an Fq`e_enek(konalnaoajp]jpao`araioanahaepkolknoaqol]nao*Mq]jpk]kLk`anAta_qperk( ai_]ok`aikj]nmqe](lk`aoandana`epnek(i]oknaeaopoq^iape`kohaeo_kikko`a) i]eoo`epko*Ai_]ok`a`aik_n]_e](oanahaepklknslql`bkpfqofl(eopk(okahaepknaokq _e`]`kolhajko]laj]okomqalkooqnaiqi]_anp]naj`]kqnemqav]* KAop]`k(lkniaek`]haea`]bkn](paiklk`anl]n]`kiej]n$atecenk^a`ej_e]%al]n] nalneien$lqjenkmqa]hae`aÚj]_kik_neia%*Oaql]lah]d^o^kqf^a^loabjm _if`^(p]h _kik`aÚje`]lahkolnklneapnekolner]`koaoaqonalnaoajp]jpao*
=_e`]`]je]he^an]h
K
APARTHEIDßAßVITvRIAßDEß -ANDELA ßNAßÆFRICAßDOß 3UL ßRESULTAßDEßLONGAßEß SANGRENTAßLUTAßCONTRAßOß APARTHEID ßAßSEGREGAljOß EßEXCLUSjOßIMPOSTAßPELOSß BRANCOSßCOLONIZADORESßAOSß NEGROS
025
Aop]`khe^an]hoa]lnaoajp]_kiknal^he_]nalnaoajp]per]_kjopepq`]`apnolk) `anao6kAta_qperk$aj_]nnac]`k`]]`iejeopn]k`kojac _ekoaoanrekol^he_ko%( kHaceoh]perk$l]nh]iajpkaj_]nnac]`k`aejopepqen]ohaeo%akFq`e_enek$i]ceopn]) pqn]o`alnkÚooekj]eo`k`enaepk(aj_]nnac]`ko`a]lhe_]n]ohaeo%*Lkooqeqi_knlk`aiehep]) naolnkÚooekj]eomqabkni]i]obkn]o]ni]`]o$atn_epkalkh_e]%(aj_]nnac]`]o`]kn`ai ejpanj] a `] `abao]( kq ]p]mqa( atpanjk* Lkooqe p]i^i qi _knlk `a oanre`knao kq bqj) _ekjnekol^he_ko(mqabkni]i]^qnk_n]_e](aj_]nnac]`]`a_qilnen]o`a_eo ao`kopno lk`anaolan]jpako_e`]`ko* KAop]`khe^an]hfqhc]r]ej_kj_a^rahmqaqijklnklneapneklq`aooak_ql]nqi_]n) ck`analnaoajp]jpajqi`kopnolk`anao*=k]Úni]nmqako_e`]`koan]ikodkiajohe) rnaoaej`alaj`ajpao(kohe^an]eomqane]i`evan_kieookmqaan]i`alaj`ajpaoajkhernao komqajklkooqooailnklnea`]`alner]`]*@aoo]i]jaen](aop]r]iat_hq`ko`]_e`]`]je] a`klk`anlkhpe_kkopn]^]hd]`knaoa]oiqhdanao(eopk(]i]ekne]`]ok_ea`]`a* Hqp]olklqh]naoejpajo]o(`ao`ako_qhkTREEE]pjkooko`e]o(bkn]n]ikAop]`khe^a) n]h]pknj]n)oaqi]nal^he_]`aik_npe_]nalnaoajp]per](]ilhe]j`k]_e`]`]je]lkhpe_]* ?kiat_ak`koAop]`koQje`ko(kj`akopn]^]hd]`knao^n]j_kobkn]i_kjoe`an]`ko_e`]) `ko`ao`ako_qhkTREEE(jko`ai]eol]oao]_e`]`]je]lhaj]akoqbncekqjerano]ho rea) n]i]ateopen_kilhap]iajpajko_qhkTT(_kik_kj_hqok`aqihkjcklnk_aook`ahqp]o ok_e]eo(lklqh]naoalkhpe_]oaimqa]_e`]`]je]bke_kjmqeop]`]lknap]l]o* Jk`aet]`aoanaol]jpkokkb]pk`amqa(ai`q]o`]oi]eknaolkpj_e]oiqj`e]eo( Ejch]pann] a Bn]j]( ]o iqhdanao o ]h_]j]n]i lhaj] _e`]`]je] ai -502( ]l o ] Oacqj`] Cqann]Iqj`e]h*Lk`a)oa]r]he]n_kikbke`qn](lajko]ahajp]aoo]_kjmqeop]lklqh]n(_kj) oe`an]j`k)oamqa(lknatailhk(kojacnko`koqh`koAop]`koQje`koo oapknj]n]i_e`]`ko jko]jko-52,*P]i^ieilknp]jpahai^n]nmqaail]oao`]=ine_]H]pej](ok^]`a) ik_n]_e]he^an]h(koj`ekoÚ_]n]iat_hq`ko`]_e`]`]je]amqakojacnko`]ãbne_]`kOqh rkp]n]ilah]lneiaen]ravokiajpaai-550*=ohqp]oej`caj]o(aijkook_kjpejajpa(a]o ]bne_]j]o_kjpejq]i]pjkooko`e]o* Lk`aikok^oanr]n(lknp]jpk(mqa]e`ae]`a_kjpn]pkok_e]h(lahkmq]hkoej`er`qkoeokh]) `kooapn]jobkni]iaiiqhpe`kaaop]oapn]jobkni]ai_knlklkhpe_k`a_e`]`ko(jklna) re]k`enaepk_e`]`]je]l]n]pk`ko(i]oabifjfq^s^k_kjpn]pkkqkl]_pk]qi]_h]ooaok_e]h(] `kolnklneapnekolner]`kokq^qncqaoe]a(aipanikopje_ko(]kodkiajo^n]j_ko]`qhpko*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=e`ae]`anarkhqk
=
lkhpe_]he^an]hbkeknaoqhp]`k`a]_kjpa_eiajpkoa_kjie_koaok_e]eomqaeilqoa) n]iiq`]j]oj]_kj_alk`klk`an`kAop]`k(_kjoe`an]`kejopepq`klahk_kj) oajpeiajpk`koej`er`qkolkniaek`k_kjpn]pkok_e]h*P]eo]_kjpa_eiajpkoÚ_]n]i _kjda_e`ko_kikjkia`anarkhq ao^qncqao]o(eopk(iq`]j]oj]aopnqpqn]a_kjie) _](j]ok_ea`]`aaj]lkhpe_](abapq]`]olknqi]jkr]_h]ooaok_e]h(]^qncqaoe]*
=l]h]rn]narkhqk Kqok`]l]h]rn]obslir ll]n]`aoecj]np]eoiq`]j]o_qnekok*@ab]pk(aoo]l]h]rn] lnkri`krk_]^qhnek`]]opnkjkie]aoecjeÚ_]Îkikreiajpk_en_qh]n_kilhapkmqaqi ]opnkna]hev]]krkhp]n]koaqlkjpk`al]npe`]Ï*Qi]narkhqkoaabapq]mq]j`kkikreiaj) pkpkp]h`aqi]opnkb]v_kej_e`enaioaqlkjpk`al]npe`]aoaqlkjpk`a_dac]`]*Obslir l `aoecj]Îikreiajpk_en_qh]n__he_kÏ(eopk(nalapek_kjpjq]`aqiiaoiklan_qnokai mqaoanapknj]]klkjpk`al]npe`]* ?kikajpaj`anmqaaoo]l]h]rn]pajd]ajpn]`kl]n]krk_]^qhneklkhpe_k_kikoecje) Ú_]`k`aiq`]j]oa]hpan] aolnkbqj`]oj]onah] aook_e]eoajklk`an;?kikajpaj`an mqa(airav`aoecjeÚ_]nÎnapknjk_en_qh]na__he_k]klkjpk`al]npe`]Ï(oecjeÚmqaat]p]) iajpak_kjpnnek(kqoaf](Îlan_qnoknqik]kpailkjkrkaok_ea`]`ajkr]Ï; L]n] naolkj`an ] aoo]o lancqjp]o( lna_eo]iko at]iej]n qi lkq_k i]eo `a lanpk ]o narkhq ao^qncqao]o(eopk(]NarkhqkEjchao]`a-244(]Narkhqk=iane_]j]`a-332a] NarkhqkBn]j_ao]`a-345* Ai^kn]aipk`]oah]oknaoqhp]`kpajd]oe`kkiaoik(mq]hoaf](]oq^e`]a]_kjokhe`]k lkhpe_]`]^qncqaoe]_kik_h]ooa`kiej]jpa(j]opnodkqrakmqaqideopkne]`kn`ajkiejkq `aÎnarkhqkj]narkhqkÏ(ej`e_]j`k_kieook]ateopj_e]`arjjlsfjbkqlmlmri^oo^af`^i klfkqbofloa^obslir l_rodrbp^(kq]c^`babjl`oqf`^bfdr^ifqof^a^obslir l(`annkp]`] lah]^qncqaoe]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(j]opnonarkhq ao(]^qncqaoe]lnapaj`aqa_kjoacqeq`an) nkp]n]na]hav]a]jk^nav](l]ookq]`kiej]nkAop]`kafqhckq_kieookpaniej]`]]p]nab]`]o iq`]j]o(ajmq]jpk]o_h]ooaolklqh]nao(mqal]npe_el]n]i`]mqah]rep ne](`aoaf]r]iiqepk i]eo6]joe]r]iejopepqenqi]ok_ea`]`aejpaen]iajpajkr](fqop](hernaabahev* Kn](]o_h]ooaolklqh]naojklkooq]ipakne]olkhpe_]o`apelkÚhko Ú_ka_eajpÚ_k* L]n]atlhe_]nkiqj`kaimqarere]iakiqj`kmqa`aoaf]r]i(`eolqjd]i`aqi]je_] bkjpa6]>^he]*Lkniaek`]nahecek(lkooq]i`q]onabanj_e]o`afqope]a`abahe_e`]`a6] ei]cai`kL]n]okpannaopna$jk=jpeckPaop]iajpk%akNaejk`a@aqoj]Pann]kqJkr] Fanqo]hi$jkJkrkPaop]iajpk%(mqanaop]qn]ne]kL]n]ok`alkeomqa?neopkreaooa]kiqj) `klah]oacqj`]rav$_kikaopao_nepkjk=lk_]heloa`aOkFkk%a(jkÚi`kopailkokq Îpailk`kÚiÏ(`annkp]ooal]n]oailnakI]h*=o_h]ooaolklqh]naonarkhq_ekjne]o`eolq) jd]i(lknp]jpk(`aqiei]cejnekjbppf kf`lajfibk^ofpq^(lknmqahec]`ke`ae]`aqi] lnkiaoo]o]hr]`kn]kq`]]k`aqio]hr]`knmqahern]ne]kodkiajo`koi]haoa`]olaj]o $l]n]]o_h]ooaolklqh]naonarkhq_ekjne]o(kIaooe]oan]iah]oiaoi]oj]_kj`ek`ana) lnaoajp]jpao`]fqope]lnkiape`]lahk?neopk%*Iehaj]neop]lknmqa]lke]`kj]e`ae]`amqa oq]]k`]ne]ateopj_e]Fanqo]hiPannaopnakqJkr]Fanqo]hi(kNaejk`a@aqoj]Pann]( kmq]h`qn]ne]ieh]jko`abahe_e`]`a(]^qj` j_e]afqope](]pmqa(jkÚi`kopailko(?neo) pk`annkp]ooal]n]oailnak=jpe_neopkadkqraooakFqvkBej]h(_ki]_kj`aj]k`koi]qo a]ajpn]`]`ko^kjoafqopkoj]Fanqo]hi?ahaopa(apanj]* =k hqp]nai lkhepe_]iajpa( ]o _h]ooao lklqh]nao khd]r]i l]n] k l]oo]`k $k lkjpk `a l]npe`]`kodkiajojkL]n]ok%al]n]kbqpqnk$klkjpk`a_dac]`]`kodkiajoj]Jkr] Fanqo]hiPannaopna%*Khd]r]il]n]kpailkbqpqnkajkrk$]ok_ea`]`a`kofqopkoj]Pann]%( mqaoane]]naopepqekkqnaop]qn]k`kpailkl]oo]`kknecej]h$kL]n]ok%*Lknmqaklkjpk `a _dac]`] a k lkjpk `a l]npe`] `k ikreiajpk lkhpe_k _kej_e`e]i _ki ] ateopj_e] `] fqope]a`]bahe_e`]`a(kbqpqnkakl]oo]`koaaj_kjpn]r]i(ba_d]j`kk_e_hkak_n_qhk`] ateopj_e]dqi]j](cn]]o]k`klnaoajpa*Lkneook(`aoecj]n]iko]_kjpa_eiajpko`a mqaan]ikooqfaepkoakolnkp]ckjeop]o_ki]l]h]rn]obslir l*
6EJAßNOßCAPqTULOßßDESTAß 5NIDADEßAßEXPLICAljOß MAISßDETALHADAßß DOßMILENARISMOßEßß DOßMESSIANISMO
03,
=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%x#!0É45,/ßx
?kil]n]j`khe^an]heoikaikreiajpkonarkhq_ekjneko Oa_kil]n]nikokoikreiajpkonarkhq_ekjneko`koo_qhkoTREEaTREEE_ki]pakne] lkhpe_]he^an]h(jkp]naikoqi]`ebanaj]eilknp]jpaajpnaahao* @ab]pk(^pqblof^pif_bo^fppbm^o^jlBpq^alb^pl`fba^ab`fsfi*Klneiaenk]l]na_a_kik ejop j_e]eilaook]h`a`kiej]k$eil ak^a`ej_e]lkniaek`aqiejopnqiajpkeilao) ok]h(]hae(alkniaek`]bkn](katn_epka]lkh_e]%*KAop]`k(reopk_kiknal^he_](]ejo) p j_e]l^he_]`aaop]^aha_eiajpka]lhe_]k`]ohaeo(kc]n]jpe`kn`]kn`ailkniaek`kqok hac]h`]rekhj_e]l]n]lqjenpk`k_neia`aÚje`klah]ohaeo(akn^epnk`ko_kjÛepkook_e]eo* =ok_ea`]`a_ereh(lknoaqpqnjk(]l]na_a_kikqi_kjfqjpk`anah] aook_e]eo`eranoe) Ú_]`]oajpna_h]ooaoacnqlkook_e]eo_qfkoejpanaooaoa`enaepkolk`ai_kej_e`enkqklkn)oa* Jah]ateopai]onah] aoa_kjie_]o`alnk`qk(`eopne^qek(]_qiqh]k`anemqav]oa _kjoqik`alnk`qpkomqa_en_qh]ijkian_]`k* L`bkqola^pl`fba^ab`fsfi^molmofba^abmofs^a^(mqa`ebanaj_e]ej`er`qko(cnqlko a_h]ooaook_e]eo(al`bkqolalBpq^al^d^o^kqf^abpp^molmofba^ab(oai_kjpq`kiao_h]n lkhpe_]aok_ea`]`a*L`lo^ lalif_bo^ifpjl^afcbobk ^b^afpq k`f^bkqobBpq^albpl`fb* a^ab(lkeoaoo]`eop j_e]mqahdalaniepa`abaj`an]e`ae]`ahe^an`]`aa_kjie_]$kq`a ian_]`k%a`ahe^an`]`a`a]kok_e]h`eopejp]`]]kl^he_]kqlkhpe_]* Kn](]onarkhq aoa(ok^napq`k(]c^`bmlmri^o`]onarkhq aoklan]iat]p]iajpa_ki ]ej`eopejkajpnaAop]`kaok_ea`]`a(ajpna]klkhpe_]anah] aook_e]eo*=onarkhq ao lnapaj`ai`annq^]nklk`anateopajpakqkAop]`klknmqaklan_a^ai_kiknaolkjorahkq _ilhe_a`]o`aoecq]h`]`aoaejfqope]oateopajpaoj]ok_ea`]`a*@epk`akqpn]bkni](^mbo* `bm labfkgrpqf ^ppl`f^fpibs^ p^ bpmliqf`^p*Qi]narkhqklk`a_kia]n_kikhqp] ok_e]hmqa`aoai^k_]j]hqp]lkhpe_]_kjpn]klk`ankqlk`a_kia]n_kikhqp]lkhpe_] mqa`aoai^k_]j]hqp]lknqi]kqpn]ok_ea`]`a* Aeolknmqa(aipk`]o]onarkhq ao^qncqao]o(raikooailna]_kjpa_ankiaoiklnk) _aook6]^qncqaoe]aopeiqh]]l]npe_el]klklqh]nlknmqalna_eo]mqa]ok_ea`]`apk`]hqpa _kjpn]klk`anateopajpa7_kjokhe`]`]]iq`]j]lkhpe_](_ki]l]oo]cai`klk`an`]ik) j]nmqe]nal^he_](]^qncqaoe]_kjoe`an]]narkhqkpaniej]`]7]o_h]ooaolklqh]nao(lkni( ]lnkooacqai(lkeo]olen]i]klk`an`aik_npe_ka`aoaf]iiq`]j]ook_e]eo7]^qncqaoe] repkneko]l]oo]ajpk]nalneien]o_h]ooaolklqh]naonarkhq_ekjne]o(`ao]ni]klkrkmqaah] ln lne]]ni]n](lnaj`a(pknpqn]ai]p]ko_dabaolklqh]naoaaj_ann](lah]bkn](klnk_aook narkhq_ekjnek(c]n]jpej`k(_kikhe^an]heoik(]oal]n]kajpnaAop]`kaok_ea`]`a*
Oecjebe_]`klkhpe_k`]onarkhq ao
Q
i] narkhqk( oaf] ah] ^qncqao]( oaf] lklqh]n( lkooqe qi oecjeÚ_]`k lkhpe_k `] i]eo]hp]eilknp j_e](lknmqa`aoraj`]]aopnqpqn]a]knc]jev]k`]ok_ea`]`aa `kAop]`k*?kikatlhe_]kÚh okbkbn]j_o?h]q`aHabknp(ah]are`aj_e]6
]`ereokok_e]halkhpe_](j]bkni]`aqi]lkh]nev]kajpnaqi]hpkklnaooknaqi ^]etkklneie`k7 ]lan_alk`k]hpklahk^]etk`]ok_ea`]`a_kikqilk`anmqajkj]pqn]hjai ja_aoonek(i]onaoqhp]`k`aqi]]kdqi]j]amqa(_kikp]h(lk`aoan`annq^]`ka na_kjopnq`k`akqpn]i]jaen]7 ]_kilnaajok`amqako]cajpaook_e]eookoqfaepkolkhpe_koa(_kikp]eo(`kp]`ko`a `enaepko*=_kjo_ej_e]`ko`enaepkob]v_kimqakooqfaepkook_eklkhpe_koatef]ina_k) jda_eiajpkac]n]jpe]`aoaqo`enaepkolah]ok_ea`]`aalahklk`anlkhpe_k*Aeolknmqa pk`]o ]o narkhq ao _qhiej]i jqi] `a_h]n]k l^he_] _kjda_e`] _kik @a_h]n]k Qjerano]h`ko@enaepko`ko?e`]`ko7
03-
lah]re]`]`a_h]n]k`ko`enaepko(qi]narkhqknal a]nah]kajpnalk`anlkhpe_k afqope]ok_e]h(i]o_kiqi]jkre`]`aln lne]`kiqj`kik`anjk(lkeo]fqope]jk
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
`alaj`ai]eo`]Úcqn]`k>kiCkranjkkq`klnj_elarenpqkok(aoei`aejopepqe ao l^he_]omqao]peob]]i`ai]j`]`ko_e`]`ko]kAop]`k*?]^a]kjkrklk`anlkhpe) _k_ne]nejopepqe aomqalkoo]io]peob]vanac]n]jpen]hqp]narkhq_ekjne]lkn`enaepko*
=onarkhq aook_e]eo
=
2OLLSß0RESS0OPPERFOTO'ETTYß)MAGES
_]^]iko`aranmqa]onarkhq aoik`anj]olkooqai`q]ob]_ao6]c^`b_rodrbp^ if_bo^i$]narkhqklkhpe_](reo]j`kpki]`]`klk`anaejopepqek`kAop]`k _kiknal^he_]a nckoal]n]`k`]ok_ea`]`a_ereh%a]c^`bmlmri^o$]narkhqk lkhpe_]bok_e]h(reo]j`k_ne]k`a`enaepkoaejopepqek`klk`an`aik_npe_kmqac]) n]jp]qi]jkr]ok_ea`]`afqop]abahev%* Reikop]i^imqa(j]onarkhq aoik`anj]o(]b]_alklqh]noqbk_]`]lah]b]_ahe) ^an]h( ai^kn] aop] hpei] oaf] k^nec]`] ] ejpnk`qven a c]n]jpen ]hcqjo `enaepko lkhpe_ko a ok_e]eol]n]klkrk(`aik`k]_kjoacqeni]jpan]kn`aiaarep]n]atlhkok_kjpjq]`a narkhp]olklqh]nao* =b]_alklqh]nraj_e`]jk`ao]l]na_a*Naooqncalanek`e_]iajpaaihqp]oeokh]`]olkn iahdknao_kj`e ao`are`](`apn]^]hdk(`ao]hnekoa_kinaerej`e_] aoeokh]`]o`al]n) pe_el]klkhpe_]*Aoo]b]_alklqh]npaj`a]_nao_ana]i]jebaop]n)oaaijkr]onarkhq ao $`annkp]`]o%`qn]jpapk`kko_qhkTET(ia`e`]mqaoa`aoajrkhrak_]lep]heoikej`qopne]h a]o_h]ooaolklqh]naooapknj]iqi]_h]ooaok_e]h`alanÚhiqepk`aÚje`k6komolibqoflpkq qo^_^ie^alobpfkarpqof^fp* ?knnaolkj`aj`kaiancj_e]a`aÚjek`]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]lnkhapne]aoq] ]klkhpe_]ainarkhq aolklqh]nao`a_]npanlkhpe_k)ok_e]h(oqncaijkr]opakne]olkh) pe_]o6]orne]opakne]ook_e]heop]o* =opakne]ook_e]heop]opki]iklnkhap]ne]`k_kikoqfaepklkhpe_kadeopne_kalnk) _qn]iÚcqn]nqi]jkr]ok_ea`]`aaqi]jkr]lkhpe_]j]omq]eo]atlhkn]k`kopn]^]hd]) `knao(]`kiej]klkhpe_]]mqaaopkoq^iape`koa]oat_hqo aook_e]eoa_qhpqn]eo]mqa okbkn]`ko`aetai`aateopen*Lknmqaoaqoqfaepklkhpe_kokkopn]^]hd]`knao(aoo]opakne]o lkhpe_]opaj`ai]Úcqn]n]ok_ea`]`abqpqn]_kikecq]hepne](baep]`a]^qj` j_e](fqope]a bahe_e`]`a*?kiklan_a^ai]_qilhe_e`]`aajpnakAop]`ka]_h]ooaa_kjkie_]iajpa`kie) j]jpa(fqhc]imqa]ateopj_e]`klneiaenkoa`ara]laj]ooja_aooe`]`aoa_kjie_]o`] ^qncqaoe]alkneook]Úni]imqa(j]ok_ea`]`abqpqn](mq]j`kjkd]ran`ereokok_e]h`a _h]ooaojai`aoecq]h`]`ao(]lkhpe_]jk`alaj`an`kAop]`k*Ok(lknp]jpk(pakne]o]jpeao) p]p]eo(mqa]lkop]ij]_]l]_e`]`a`a]qpkckranjkkq`a]qpkcaopk`]ok_ea`]`a*
Be`ah?]opnk]_aj] l]n]]iqhpe`kjko lneiaenko`e]o`] narkhqk_q^]j](ai -515*
03.
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
#APqTULOß =lkhpe_]_kjpn]] oanre`krkhqjp ne] =pn]`ekhe^anpne]
=
opakne]ook_e]heop]oik`anj]ookdan`aen]o`]pn]`ekhe^anpne](eopk(`]ohqp]o ok_e]eoalkhpe_]olklqh]naolknhe^an`]`aafqope]_kjpn]]klnaook`kolk`ankoko*
=opn]`e aolklqh]nao
ANTICRISTOßEMßGERAL ßOß ANTICRISTOßERAßIDENTIFICADOß gßPESSOAßDEßUMßGOVER NANTEßTIRhNICOßPAPAS ßREIS ß IMPERADORESß#ONTRAßELE ß OSßPOBRESßSEßREUNIAMßEMß COMUNIDADESßIGUALITfRIAS ß ARMAVAM SEßEßPARTIAMß PARAßAßLUTA ßPOISßDEVERIAMß PREPARARßOßMUNDOßPARAßAß CHEGADAßTRIUNFALßDEß#RISTO ß QUEßVENCERIAßDEFINITIVA MENTEßOßANTICRISTO
Jaoo]pn]`ekaj_kjpn]i)oa]onarkhp]o_]ilkjao]oa`ko]npaoko`kÚj]h`]E`]`a I`e](`kej_ek`]Nabkni]Lnkpaop]jpaa`]NarkhqkEjchao]`a-244*Aoo]onarkhp]ook _kjda_e`]o_kikiehaj]neop]o(lkeo(_kikreiko(]o_h]ooaolklqh]naolkooqai_kikna) banaj_e]hl]n]_kilnaaj`anafqhc]n]lkhpe_]]oei]cajo^^he_]o`kL]n]ok(`]Jkr]Fanq) o]hiPannaopnaa`kÎpailk`kÚiÏ(mq]j`kk>airaj_anlanlapq]iajpakI]h(ejop]q) n]j`kkNaejk`koIeh=jko`abahe_e`]`aafqope]*J]NarkhqkEjchao](kolk^naopejd]i _anpav]`amqa_dac]n]kÎpailk`kÚiÏaoa]lnktei]r]kiehjek*Re]ikooej]eo`kÚi6 bkia(laopa(cqann]o(a_heloao(_kiap]o(lnk`cekoejatlhe_raeo(mqa]jqj_e]r]i]rej`]`k ]jpe_neopkaatece]imqabkooa_ki^]pe`klahkofqopkoa^kjo*=aolan]j]iehaj]neop]oai) lnareq]hqp]lkhpe_]_kik_kjÛ]cn]k_ oie_]ajpna]hqva]pnar](kfqopkakejfqopk(k ^aiaki]h*
K`eo_qnok`]oanre`krkhqjpne]
P
03/
]i^ij]pn]`ekhe^anpne]aj_kjpn])oa]k^n]`aqifkraiÚh okbkbn]j_o(H]>kpea( ao_nep]jko_qhkTRE(`alkeo`]`annkp]lklqh]n_kjpn]koatn_epkoaÚo_]eo`knae( mqarejd]i_k^n]nqijkrkeilkopkok^nako]h*Jaoo]k^n](ejpepqh]`]Afp`ropla^ pbosfalslirkqof^(H]>kpeaej`]c]_kiklkoorahmqa^qnckoejpaenko(_e`]`aoejpaen]o( j] aoejpaen]ooaoq^iap]irkjp]`a`aqio (aican]hki]eo_kr]n`aapaiankok`a pk`ko*@akj`arjppen]klk`anl]n]aoi]c]nqlalplplrqolp; @q]ook]onaolkop]o*J]lneiaen](H]>kpeaikopn]mqajklknia`kmqak^a`a_a) ikorkjp]`a`aqio (i]olknmqa`aoaf]iko]pen]je]*?kikatlhe_]nmqakpen]jk(_qfk _knlkecq]h]kjkook(pajd]_nao_e`kp]jpk(_kiiehkhdkoaiehkqre`kol]n]jkoaolekj]n( ieh^k_]ol]n]jkoajc]j]n(iehikol]n]jkoaoc]j]n(iehlol]n]jkoleokpa]n;Mqai hda`aqkokhdkoakokqre`ko`koaole ao(]o^k_]o`koi]ceopn]`ko(]oikoakolo`ko okh`]`ko;Kln lneklkrk* =ok_ea`]`a_kikqi]eiajo]len ie`a`apen]japaomqaoaaoi]c]iqjo]kokqpnko6 k_knlk`kpen]jkbkni]`klahkooaeomqak]_kjoahd]i(lahkooaooajp]mqalnkpacaiko oaeo(lahkooaeo_ajpkomqa`abaj`aikooaooajp](lahkooaeoiehmqaoanrai]kooaeo_ajpkoa lahkooaeoiehd aomqak^a`a_ai]kooaeoieh(j]aolan]j]`a_kjoacqenklk`anl]n]i]j) `]naikqpnko*=lneiaen]naolkop]jko`evmqaklk`an`aqio ok^napk`kobke`]`k]k pen]jklknjkook`aoafk`aoanikopen]jkop]i^i* =oacqj`]naolkop](lkni(r]ei]eobqj`k*H]>kpeaej`]c]6`akj`araikln lnek `aoafk`apen]je];Anaolkj`a6`k`aoafk`apan^ajoanemqav]o(`k`aoafk`aoanlnklneapnek*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
UTOPIAßAßPALAVRAßUTOPIAßFOIß EMPREGADAßPELAßPRIMEIRAß VEZßPELOßFILvSOFOßINGLoSß 4HOMASß-ORUSßNOßLIVROß 5TOPIA ßAßCIDADEßATUALßPER FEITAß!ßPALAVRAßmßUMAßCOM POSIljOßDEßPALAVRASßGREGASß E ßRIGOROSAMENTE ßSIGNIFICAß ±EMßLUGARßNENHUM² ß±LUGARß INEXISTENTE² ß±IMAGINfRIO²ß 0ORßESSEßMOTIVO ßESTAMOSß ACOSTUMADOSßAßIDENTIFI CARßUTOPIAßEßUTvPICOßCOMß IMPOSSqVEL ßAQUILOßQUEßSvß EXISTEßEMßNOSSOßDESEJOßEß IMAGINAljOßEßQUEßNjOßEN CONTRARfßNUNCAßCONDIlzESß OBJETIVASßPARAßSEßREALIZAR
!LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
I]o(ej`]c]ahajkr]iajpa(`akj`araiaooa`aoafk`aqbo(`amlppb;Anaolkj`a6`k`aolnavk lah]he^an`]`a*Oa`aoafooaikoran`]`aen]iajpa]he^an`]`a(f]i]eo]pnk_]n]ikolah]lkooa `a^ajo(mqajkoao_n]rev]i]kokqpnkoajkooq^iapairkjp]`a`koi]eobknpaoapen]jko* =kpnk_]nk`enaepkhe^an`]`alahk`aoafk`alkooa(]_aep]iko]hckpannrah6]oanre`k rkhqjpne]*Aoo]atlnaookl]n]`kt]h(aopn]jd]*@ab]pk(oailnaokq^aikomqa]rkjp]`a hernaamqakooanrkookbkn]`kooq^ieook*Kqoaf](jqj_]kqreiko`evanmqa]rkjp]`a lq`aooa mqanan oq] jac]k( eopk ( ] oanre`k* H] >kpea ailnac] aoo] pannrah atlnaook l]n]ej`e_]nmqa]pen]je]ateopaalanoeopalknmqajkokikok^nec]`ko]k^a`a_an]kpen]jk a]kooaqonalnaoajp]jpao(i]oabpbg^jlpslirkq^of^jbkqbpbosf*ilplknmqa`ahaoaolan]iko ^ajoa]c]n]jpe]`ajkoo]olkooao*Qo]ikojkoo]he^an`]`al]n]jkopknj]nikooanrko* ?kik`annq^]nqipen]jkana_kjmqeop]n]he^an`]`a;=naolkop]`aH]>kpeaaol]jpk) o]6^]op]jk`]n]kpen]jkkmqaahala`aaateca*Jklna_eokpki]n`]o]ni]oab]van)hda ]cqann]*>]op]mqajkoaf]`]`kkmqaaha`aoaf]aoan`annq^]`k* Mqamqanaha;Jkoo]_kjo_ej_e]ajkoo]he^an`]`a(]oanaipnk_]`]okqjack_e]`]olah] lnkiaoo]`ao]peob]k`ajkook`aoafk`alkooaoa`ai]j`k*Oajkpnk_]nikojkoo]_kjo) _ej_e]lah]lkooa`a^ajoaoajkpnk_]nikojkoo]he^an`]`alahk`aoafk`ai]j`k(j]`] `]naiko]kpen]jk*Oaj]`]hda`aniko(ahalan`a]bkjpa`alk`anmqakoqopajp]a(oai lk`an(_]en_kikqi`khk`a^]nnk* @]oirq^pmlmri^obpa`]oqo^af bpif_boqof^pj]o_ai]opakne]ook_e]heop]oik`anj]o( `aoajrkhre`]o]l]npen`ko_qhkTET_kiknaolkop]]k_]lep]heoikej`qopne]haook_ea`]`ao qn^]j]ocan]`]olknaha*
=opakne]ook_e]heop]o 3AINT 3IMON ßCONDEßDEß ßFILvSOFOßEßß ECONOMISTAßFRANCoSß
!LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
?
kikkln lnekjkiaej`e_](]opakne]ook_e]heop]ook]mqah]omqaoabqj`]ij]onah]) aook_e]eoaj]o] aook_e]eo(eopk(mqana_qo]i]oal]n]khe^an]hajpnaok_ea`]`a aAop]`kalnk_qn]ij]]pere`]`aok_e]hkobqj`]iajpko`klk`ana]klkhpe_ko* Okpno]olnej_el]eo_knnajpaook_e]heop]oik`anj]o*Raf]iko(]oacqen(kmqa_]`]qi] `abaj`a*
Ok_e]heoikqple_k
=j]nmqeoik Klnej_el]hpa ne_k`aoo]_knnajpaok_e]heop]bkeknqook>]gqjej(ejolen]`kj]oe`ae]ook) _e]heop]o`aLnkq`dkj*Oaqlkjpk`al]npe`]]_npe_]`kej`ere`q]heoik^qncqoa`kAop]`k he^an]h(_kjoe`an]`k]qpknepneka]jpej]pqn]h*?kikNkqooa]q(ko]j]nmqeop]o]_na`ep]ij] he^an`]`aj]pqn]haj]^kj`]`aj]pqn]h`kooanaodqi]jkoaaioq]_]l]_e`]`al]n]reranba) hevaoai_kiqje`]`ao*=pne^qai]knecai`]ok_ea`]`a(eopk(]ateopj_e]`aej`er`qkoeok) h]`ko(lna_]ne]iajpa]ook_e]`koaaihqp]lani]jajpa(lnklnea`]`alner]`]aatlhkn]k
0ROUDHONß ß FILvSOFOßPOLqTICOßEßß ECONOMISTAßFRANCoS !LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
Aoo]_knnajpaok_e]heop]r]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]_kik`aolkooq`](klneie`]acan]`kn] `]nemqav]ok_e]hoai`ah]`aobnqp]n*L]n]ah](kopa ne_koei]cej]iqi]jkr]ok_ea`]`aj] mq]hjkateop]i]lnklnea`]`alner]`](khq_nk`ko_]lep]heop]o(]atlhkn]k`kpn]^]hdka ]`aoecq]h`]`aa_kjie_](ok_e]halkhpe_]*Ei]cej]ijkr]o_e`]`ao(knc]jev]`]oaicn]j) `ao_kklan]per]ocane`]olahkopn]^]hd]`knaoaj]omq]eod]f]ao_kh]l]n]pk`ko(he^an`]`a`a lajo]iajpka`aatlnaook(ecq]h`]`a`a`enaepkook_e]eo$ikn]`e](]heiajp]k(pn]jolknpa( o]`a%(]^qj` j_e](fqope]abahe_e`]`a* Aoo]o_e`]`aook_kj_a^e`]o_kik_kiqje`]`ao`alaook]ohernaoaecq]eomqaoa]q) pkckranj]i*Lknoanai_e`]`aolanbaep]o(mqajkateopaiail]npa]hcqi](i]omqaoank _ne]`]olah]rkjp]`aherna`ko`aolkooq`ko(`ev)oamqaokÎ_e`]`aoqp le_]oÏa]opakne]o mqa]o_ne]n]iok_d]i]`]o`aqpkle]o*Kolnej_el]eook_e]heop]oqp le_kobkn]ikobn]j_a) oaoO]ejp)Oeikj(Bkqnean(Lnkq`dkj(Hkqeo>h]j_a>h]jmqe(akejchoKsaj*
"AKUNINß ßß TEvRICOßPOLqTICOßRUSSOßEß UMßDOSßEXPOENTESßDOß ANARQUISMO
030
!LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
WWWANARCA BOLOCHß !RQUIVOßDAß%DITORA
+ROPOTKINß ß ßGEvGRAFOßEßESCRITORßRUSSO
`kpn]^]hdk(a]knecai`kAop]`k]klk`an`koi]eobknpao$kolnklneapnekolner]`ko%ok^na kobn]_ko$kopn]^]hd]`knao%*Ok_ea`]`aaAop]`kok^kqfk^qro^fplknmqaoakl aipaj`j) _e]j]pqn]h`kodkiajo]reranecq]hepne]ahernaiajpaai_kiqje`]`ao]qpkckranj]`]o* Lkneookiaoik(_kjpn]k]npeÚ_e]heoik`]ok_ea`]`aa`kAop]`k(ko]j]nmqeop]olnk) l aiknapknjkre`]ai_kiqje`]`ao]qpkckranj]`]o(oaijajdqi]dean]nmqe]aoai ejopepqenjajdqi]]qpkne`]`a_kilk`an`ai]j`ka`enak*=Úni]i`keocn]j`aor]hk) nao6]if_boa^aba]obpmlkp^_fifa^ab(ai_qfkjkialnkl ai]`ao_ajpn]hev]kok_e]halkh) pe_](]l]npe_el]k`enap]`apk`koj]o`a_eo ao`]_kiqje`]`a(]bkni]k`aknc]jev] ao `a^]ennk(`ab^ne_](`aa`q_]k(ikn]`e](o]`a(pn]jolknpa(ap_*Lnkl aip]i^imqaao) o]oknc]jev] ao_kiqjepne]ol]npe_el]per]obkniaiba`an] aoj]_ekj]eoaejpanj]_ekj]eo l]n]]pki]`]`a`a_eo aochk^]eo(arep]j`k(lkni(]bkni]l]nh]iajp]n`analnaoajp]k ac]n]jpej`k]`aik_n]_e]`enap]* =o _kiqje`]`ao a ]o knc]jev] ao _kiqjepne]o ajre]i `ahac]`ko o ba`an] ao* Ko `ahac]`kookahaepkol]n]qii]j`]pknabanajpaat_hqoer]iajpa]k]ooqjpkmqaoanpn]) p]`klah]]ooai^hae]`]ba`an]k7paniej]`]]]ooai^hae](ki]j`]pkp]i^ipaniej]( `aoknpamqajkdnalnaoajp]jpaolani]jajpao*Reopkmqak`ahac]`klkooqeqii]j`]pk l]n]atlkna`abaj`anlan]jpa]ba`an]k]okleje aoa`a_eo ao`aoq]_kiqje`]`a(oajk _qilnenkmqahdabke`ahac]`koaqi]j`]pkoannarkc]`kaqikqpnk`ahac]`kahaepk* ?kikoak^oanr](ko]j]nmqeop]olnk_qn]ieila`enkoqnceiajpk`a]l]nahdko`alk) `anmqa_kj`qv]ibkni]k`kAop]`k*Na_qo]i(lkneook(]ateopj_e]`aatn_epkolnkÚo) oekj]eoa`abaj`ai]paoa`klkrk]ni]`kkq`]oieh_e]olklqh]nao(mqaoabkni]ijqi] aiancj_e]aoa`eookhraipkhkckklnk^hai]pajd]oe`knaokhre`k*?kjoe`an]ikAop]`k j]_ekj]hk^n]`k]qpknep]neoika`]klnaook_]lep]heop]a(lkneook(_kjpn]aha(`abaj`aik ejpanj]_ekj]heoikoaibnkjpaen]o(lkeoÎo k_]lep]hpailpne]Ïakopn]^]hd]`knaookÎ_e`]) `ko`kiqj`kÏ* Ko]j]nmqeop]ook_kjda_e`ko_kikif_boqoflp(lkeohqp]i_kjpn]pk`]o]obkni]o`a ]qpkne`]`a a `a ]qpknep]neoik* =hi `a >]gqjej( kqpnko eilknp]jpao ]j]nmqeop]o bkn]i6 Gnklkpgej(Ai]Ckh`i]j(Pkhop e(I]h]paop]aCakncaKnsahh(]qpkn`khernk.651*
?kiqjeoikkqok_e]heoik_eajpbe_k
-ALATESTAß ßß TEvRICOßEßATIVISTAß ßANARQUISTAßITALIANO
Aoo]lkoek_npe_]jko `kAop]`khe^an]h(i]op]i^i`kok_e]heoikqp le_ka`k ]j]nmqeoik*Aj_kjpn])oa`aoajrkhre`]j]ok^n]o`aG]nhI]ntaBnea`ne_dAjcaho*
)NDEXß3TOCKß)MAGES,ATINSTOCK
=lanola_per]i]nteop]
?
+ARLß-ARXß ßß FILvSOFO ßECONOMISTA ßß HISTORIADORßEßREVOLUCIO NfRIOßALEMjO ßFUNDADORß DOßCOMUNISMOß3UAßOBRAß INFLUENCIOUßVfRIASßfREASß DASßCIoNCIASßSOCIAIS
031
ki]k^n]`aI]nt(aop]iko`e]jpa`aqi]_kjpa_eiajpk_kil]nrah]laj]o]k`a I]mqe]rah*Ai^kn]oq]opakne]ooaf]i_kilhap]iajpa`ebanajpao(lkeonaolkj`ai] atlanej_e]odeop ne_]oa]lnk^hai]o`ebanajpao(]i^konalnaoajp]iqi]iq`]j) ]`a_eoer]jkik`k`a_kj_a^an]lkhpe_]a]nah]kajpnaok_ea`]`aalk`an*J^nrf^sbi abpjfpqfÛ`lr^qblildf^mliqf`^blobmr_if`^kfpjlfq^if^kl(mqaoeilhaoiajpalnapaj`e] eiep]ncnackoanki]jkoairav`a_kilnaaj`anoaqln lneklnaoajpa*J^ouabpjfpqfÛ`lr ^mliqf`^if_bo^i* I]ntl]npa`]_npe_]`]a_kjkie]lkhpe_]*
=a_kjkie]lkhpe_] =atlnaookÎa_kjkie]lkhpe_]Ï_qneko]*?kiabaepk(]l]h]rn]b`lkljf^rai`kcna) cklfhlklj^(_kilkop]`a`keork_^qhko(lfhpakjlp*LfhpÎ_]o]ÏkqÎb]ihe]Ï(ajpaj) `e`]_kikoeopai]`a]he]j]oal]najpao_k$]o_aj`ajpao(`ao_aj`ajpao(]he]`ko(l]eo(Úhdko( l]najpaoaao_n]rko%aqje`]`a`alnk`qk$]pere`]`ao`a]cne_qhpqn](l]opknaek(a`eÚ_] ao( ]npao]j]pk(pnk_]o`a^ajoajpnab]ihe]okqpnk_]o`a^ajolknika`](ap_*%*KjlpoecjeÚ_] Înacn]Ï(Î]_kn`k_kjraj_ekj]`kajpnaoanaodqi]jkoalknahaonaolaep]`kj]onah] aook_e]eoÏ*
!DAMß3MITHß ß ECONOMISTAßEßFILvSOFOß ESCOCoS
!LBUMß!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
Lfhlklj^(lknp]jpk(k_kjfqjpk`ajkni]o`a]`iejeopn]k`]lnklnea`]`al]pneikje]h kqlner]`]`enece`]lahk_daba`]b]ihe](kabpmlqp* Reikomqakocnackoejrajp]n]i]lkhpe_]lknmqaoal]n]n]ikaol]klner]`k$]lf* hlklj^%akaol]kl^he_k`]ohaeoa`k`enaepk$]mifp%*?kik(ajpk(b]h]naiÎa_kjkie] lkhpe_]Ï;Ko`keopanikojkoaat_hqaina_elnk_]iajpa;Lknmqaaoo]atlnaookl]ookq] oanqo]`]j]ik`anje`]`a; Lknmqa( l]n] oal]n]n ok_ea`]`a _ereh a Aop]`k( ]o pakne]o lkhpe_]o he^an]eo lna_eo]n]i ]`iepenmqa]a_kjkie]oanabana pl`fba^ab `fsfi fkqbfo^7 mqa jk oa na`qvo ]pere`]`ao a_kjie_]o`ab]ihe]oacnqlkob]iehe]naooal]n]`ko`]aoban]lkhpe_](i]o_kj_anjao ]pere`]`ao`alnk`qkapnk_]`aej`er`qko_qf]ateopj_e]jk`aÚje`]lknoq]oepq]k b]iehe]naoeilknoq]ejoankok_e]hj]lnk`qka_kjie_]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(kpanik Îlkhpe_]Ï(qo]`klahkohe^an]eol]n]mq]heÚ_]n]a_kjkie](jkoanabanap]jpk]kAop]`k(i]o ]kb]pk`amqa]ok_ea`]`a_erehqiaol]k_khaperkbkni]`klknej`er`qkoeokh]`komqaoa nah]_ekj]ilkniaek`]o]pere`]`aoa_kjie_]o* @ab]pk(]a_kjkie]lkhpe_]oqnca_kik_ej_e]jkÚj]h`ko_qhkTREEEaej_ek`kTET( j] Bn]j] a j] Ejch]pann]( l]n] _ki^]pan ]o heiep] ao mqa k =jpeck Naceia eilqjd] ]k _]lep]heoik*=onaopne aoa_kjie_]oln lne]o`]ok_ea`]`abaq`]hak_kjpnkha`]]pere`]`a ian_]jpehlahkAop]`kikjnmqe_kan]ireopko_kiklnafq`e_e]eo]k`aoajrkhreiajpk`] Înemqav]`]oj] aoÏ*>]oa]j`k)oajkoiaoikolnej_leko`khe^an]heoiklkhpe_k$]lnklnea) `]`alner]`]_kik`enaepkj]pqn]h(]he^an`]`a_kik`enaepkj]pqn]h(]heiep]k`]aoban]`k lk`anaop]p]h%(]a_kjkie]lkhpe_]ah]^kn]`]_kikhe^an]heoika_kjie_k* @ebanajpaiajpa`kocnacko(mqa`aÚjen]ikdkiai_kikÎ]jei]hlkhpe_kÏ(a`ebanaj) paiajpa`koia`ear]eo(mqa`aÚjen]ikdkiai_kikÎoanok_erahÏ(]a_kjkie]lkhpe_] `aÚjakdkiai_kikÎej`er`qkmqa^qo_]]o]peob]k`aoq]oja_aooe`]`ao(_kjoqiej`k kmqa]j]pqnav]hdakbana_akqpn]^]hd]j`kl]n]k^pannemqav]oa^ai)aop]nÏ*Lknoan]re`] ai_kiqii]eor]jp]fko]]koej`er`qko(aopaom^`qr^jl]n]_ne]n]ok_ea`]`aakAop]`k* =oe`ae]o`aAop]`k(`aj]pqnav]a`a`enaepkj]pqn]h_kj`qven]i]`q]ojk aoaooaj) _e]eoa_kjkie]lkhpe_]6]lneiaen]]jkk`akn`aij]pqn]hn]_ekj]h(mqac]n]jpa]pk`ko koej`er`qko]o]peob]k`aoq]oja_aooe`]`aoa`aoaq^ai)aop]n7]oacqj`]]jkk`a mqa(oaf]lkn^kj`]`aj]pqn]h(oaf]lknackoik(kodkiajo]caiaioaqln lnek^ajab_ek aejpanaooaa(]ooeib]vaj`k(_kjpne^qail]n]k^ai_khaperkkqok_e]h*=lnklnea`]`alner]) `]j]pqn]hapehok_e]hiajpa(]hi`ahacpei]ikn]hiajpa(lknmqaaopeiqh]kpn]^]hdka _ki^]pakr_ek`]lnacqe]* =a_kjkie]lkhpe_]^qo_]n]ohaeo`kobajiajkoa_kjie_koj]j]pqnav]dqi]j]ako abaepko`]o_]qo]oa_kjie_]ook^na]re`]ok_e]h*Reopkmqa]kn`aij]pqn]hn]_ekj]hamqako oanaodqi]jkolkooqaihe^an`]`aj]pqn]h(]a_kjkie]lkhpe_]`aranc]n]jpenmqa]n]_ekj]) he`]`aj]pqn]ha]he^an`]`adqi]j]oana]hevailknoeiaoi]o(oaiajpn]raoaoaiheiepao* L]n]]hcqjoa_kjkieop]olkhpe_ko`ko_qhkTET(_kik=`]iOiepd(]_kj_knnj_e]$kq haea_kjie_]`]kbanp]a`]lnk_qn]%naolkjorahlah]nemqav]ok_e]halah]d]nikje]aj) pnaejpanaooalner]`kaejpanaooa_khaperk*L]n]kqpnko(_kik@]re`Ne_]n`k(]ohaeoa_kjie) _]onarah]i]jp]ckjeoikoajpnakornekoejpanaooao`kocnqlkook_e]eo*=ooei(lknatailhk( ]`ebanaj]ajpnaklnak`]oian_]`kne]oakoo]hnekoej`e_]qi]klkoek`aejpanaooao j] ok_ea`]`a( `a ik`k mqa ] _kj_knnj_e] atlneia aooao _kjÛepko ok_e]eo* Ai ]i^ko ko _]oko(lkni(]a_kjkie]oana]hev]_kikok_ea`]`a_ereh_]l]v`aoa]qpknnacqh]n(oaimqa kAop]`k`ar]ejpanbanenj]oq]he^an`]`a*Raiko(]ooei(mqaai^kn]khe^an]heoiklkhpe_k pajd]oe`kbkniqh]`k]jpao`khe^an]heoika_kjie_k(`klkjpk`areop]h ce_k$ajk_nkjk) h ce_k%(khe^an]heoika_kjie_kmqa`kobqj`]iajpkol]n]khe^an]heoiklkhpe_k*Aopa qi]atlnaook`]mqaha*
!LBUMß!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
$AVIDß2ICARDOß ß ECONOMISTAßINGLoS
=_npe_]`]a_kjkie]lkhpe_] =_npe_]`]a_kjkie]lkhpe_]_kjoeopa(fqop]iajpa(aiikopn]nmqa(]lao]n`]o]Úni]) aocna_k)nki]j]oahe^an]eo`aoal]n]kajpna]aoban]lner]`]`]lnklnea`]`aa]aoban]
032
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
033
l^he_]`klk`an(]lkhpe_]f]i]eo_kjoacqeqna]hev]n]`ebanaj]ajpna]i^]o*Jailk`ane]*K lk`anlkhpe_koailnabke]i]jaen]hac]hafqn`e_]lah]mq]h]_h]ooaa_kjkie_]iajpa`kie) j]jpa`aqi]ok_ea`]`ai]jparaoaq`kijekok^na]okqpn]o_h]ooaook_e]eo*=mifp(]`fsfq^p( kAop]`kjqj_]lq`an]ioal]n]nklk`anlner]`k`koa_kjkie_]iajpa`kiej]jpaoaklk`an l^he_kkqlkhpe_k*K]l]n]pkhac]hafqn`e_k]laj]o`eooeiqh]kaooaj_e]h6mqaklk`anlkhpe) _kateopa_kiklk`anek`koa_kjkie_]iajpalk`ankoko(l]n]oanrenoaqoejpanaooaoalnereh) cekoac]n]jpen)hdao]`kiej]kok_e]h*@ere`e`]oajpnalnklneapnekoajklnklneapneko$pn]) ^]hd]`knaohernaolk^nao(ao_n]rko(oanrko%(]ook_ea`]`aof]i]eobkn]i_kiqje`]`ao`aecq]eo af]i]eolaniepen]imqaklk`anlkhpe_kbkooa_kil]npehd]`k_kikojklnklneapneko* I]ntej`]c]6kmqa]ok_ea`]`a_ereh`amqab]h]ikoa_kjkieop]oapa ne_kolkhpe_ko he^an]eo;Anaolkj`a6jk]i]jebaop]k`aqi]kn`aij]pqn]hn]_ekj]hjaik]chkia) n]`k_kjÛep]jpa`aej`er`qko(b]ihe]o(cnqlkoa_knlkn] ao(_qfkoejpanaooao]jp]cje_ko oank_kj_ehe]`kolahk_kjpn]pkok_e]h(lkniaek`kmq]hoane]ejopepq`]]]knacqh]`kn]a kn`aj]`kn]`kAop]`k_kikatlnaook`kejpanaooaa`]rkjp]`acan]eo*Jk_]lep]heoik(] ok_ea`]`a_ereh(bqj`]`]j]oal]n]kajpna]lnklnea`]`alner]`]`koiaeko`alnk`qka kpn]^]hdk(koeopai]`anah] aook_e]eomqaknc]jev]]lnk`qka_kjie_]$]cne_qhpqn]( ej`opne]a_kin_ek%(na]hev]j`k)oalkniaek`aejopepqe aook_e]eoaj_]nnac]`]o`analnk) `qve)hk$b]ihe](ecnaf]o(ao_kh]o(lkh_e](l]npe`kolkhpe_ko(iaeko`a_kiqje_]k(ap_*%*k aol]kjkmq]h]onah] aook_e]eoaoq]obkni]oa_kjie_]oaejopepq_ekj]eooklajo]`]o( ejpanlnap]`]oanalnaoajp]`]olknqi_kjfqjpk`ae`ae]oikn]eo(naheceko]o(fqn`e_]o(la`]) c ce_]o(]npope_]o(_eajpÚ_k)Úhko Ú_]oalkhpe_]o* =ok_ea`]`a_erehklnk_aook`a_kjopepqekanalkoek`]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo`] lnk`qka_kjie_]lah]omq]eookajcaj`n]`]o]o_h]ooaook_e]eo6kolnklneapnekolner]) `ko`koiaeko`alnk`qkakopn]^]hd]`knaokqjklnklneapneko(mqaraj`aioq]bkn] `apn]^]hdk_kikian_]`kne]oq^iape`]hae`]kbanp]a`]lnk_qn]jkian_]`k`aik `ak^n]*Aoo]o_h]ooaook_e]eook]jp]cje_]oaoaqo_kjÛepkonarah]iqi]_kjpn]`eklnk) bqj`]ajpnakoejpanaooaoenna_kj_eheraeo`a_]`]qi]`ah]o(eopk(]ok_ea`]`a_erehjk qi]chkian]`k`aej`er`qkoaoeiqi]afsfplpl`f^iab`i^ppbpaoana]hev]_kikirq^ab `i^ppbp*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(kmqakopa ne_ko`kfqoj]pqn]heoik_d]i]r]i`aaop]`k`aj]) pqnav]jkoajk]ok_ea`]`a_ereh(al]n]oanren]koejpanaooao`aqi]`]o_h]ooaook_e]eo mqakAop]`kejopepq`k* Oai`re`](kohe^an]eoaopk_anpkomq]j`k]Úni]imqa]ok_ea`]`a_ereh(lknoanaoba) n]a_kjie_](]aoban]`koejpanaooaolner]`ko(lkeoat]p]iajpaeookkmqaah]*>pl`fb* a^ab`fsfi^b`lkljf^abjbo`^al`^mfq^ifpq^*Kmqa(lkni(kAop]`k; Hkjca`a`ebanaj_e]n)oa`]ok_ea`]`a_ereha`aoal]n]n)oa`ah](hkjca`aoan]atlnaook `]rkjp]`acan]ha`kejpanaooacan]h(kAop]`k]atlnaookhac]h$fqn`e_]alkhe_e]h%`ko ejpanaooao`aqi]_h]ooaok_e]hl]npe_qh]n(]_h]ooa`kolnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`a lnk`qkkq_h]ooa`kiej]jpa*AkAop]`kjkqi]eilkoek`erej]]kodkiajojai knaoqhp]`k`aqil]_pkkq_kjpn]pkok_e]h(i]o]i]jaen]lah]mq]h]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa `aqi]lk_]a`aqi]ok_ea`]`a`apaniej]`]oc]n]jpaoaqoejpanaooaoaoq]`kiej]k ok^nakpk`kok_e]h* KAop]`k]atlnaooklkhpe_]`]hqp]a_kjie_k)ok_e]h`]o_h]ooao(]iknpa_e`]lahk ]l]n]pk`]loabj$fqn`e_]%a`]clo ^m _if`^$lkhe_e]haiehep]n%*Jk(i]o^m^ob`b_kik qilk`anl^he_k`eop]jpaaoal]n]`k`]ok_ea`]`a_ereh*Jklkn]_]ok(khe^an]heoik`aÚja kAop]`k_kikc]n]jpe`kn`k`enaepk`alnklnea`]`alner]`]a(jklkn]_]ok(na`qv]_e`]`]) je]]ko`enaepko`kolnklneapnekolner]`ko$reikomqa]]ilhe]k`]_e`]`]je]bkebnqpk`a hqp]olklqh]nao_kjpn]]oe`ae]oalnpe_]ohe^an]eo%* =a_kjkie](lknp]jpk(g^j^fp`aetkq`aoanlkhpe_]*Oeilhaoiajpa(jk_]lep]heoik(k rj_qhkejpanjkaja_aoonekajpnaa_kjkie]alkhpe_]pknjkq)oaare`ajpa* Jkajp]jpk(oalancqjp]nikoolaook]omqareraijkAop]`khe^an]h_]lep]heop]oa(l]n] ah]o(are`ajpap]hrj_qhk(_anp]iajpa`enkmqajk*Lknmqakrj_qhkejpanjkajpnaklk) `ana_kjie_kaklk`anlkhpe_klani]ja_aejreorah]kokhdko`]i]ekne];
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
L]n]naolkj`an]aoo]mqaopk(I]ntb]v`q]okqpn]oej`]c] ao6 -*
?kikoqnceqkAop]`k;Eopk(_kikkodkiajol]oo]n]i`]oq^ieook]klk`anlaook]h reorah`aqioajdknk^a`ej_e]]klk`aneilaook]hejreorah`aqiAop]`k;
.*
Lknmqakrj_qhkajpnaklk`ana_kjie_kaklk`anlkhpe_kjklan_a^e`klah]ok) _ea`]`aa(ok^napq`k(lknmqajklan_a^e`klahkomqajkpilk`ana_kjie_kjai lkhpe_k;
=_kil]jdaikoklan_qnok`klajo]iajpk`aI]ntl]n]_kilnaaj`aniko]i]jaen] _kiknaolkj`an]aoo]o`q]omqaop ao*
=jpa_a`ajpao`]pakne]i]nteop]
=
jpao`aat]iej]niko]onaolkop]o`aI]nt]aoo]oej`]c] ao(`araikohai^n]nqi _kjfqjpk`ae`ae]oa`ab]pkoateopajpaomq]j`kahaeje_ekqoaqpn]^]hdkpa ne_k* @klkjpk`areop]`kob]pko(aop]ikoj]an]`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`k_]lep]heoikej`qo) pne]h(_ki]]ilhe]k`]_]l]_e`]`apa_jkh ce_]`a`kijek`]j]pqnav]lahkpn]^]hdka lah]p_je_]*Aoo]]ilhe]k]qiajp]p]i^ik_]ilk`a]k`k_]lep]h(mqal]oo]]]^) oknran_kjpejcajpao_]`]ravi]eknao`alaook]ojkian_]`k`]ik`ak^n]a`k_kjoqik( nqi]j`kl]n]kian_]`k_]lep]heop]iqj`e]h* =^qncqaoe]oaknc]jev]lkniaek`kAop]`khe^an]h(ajmq]jpkkopn]^]hd]`knaoej`qo) pne]eo kq lnkhapneko oa knc]jev]i ai ]ook_e] ao lnkÚooekj]eo a oej`e_]pko l]n] ]o hqp]o a_kjie_]o$o]hneko(fknj]`]`apn]^]hdk%(ok_e]eo$_kj`e ao`are`]%alkhpe_]o$naerej`e_]) k`a_e`]`]je]%*Cnarao(narkhp]oanarkhq aoa_hk`aiaipk`]l]npa(]oi]eoeilknp]jpao rej`k]k_knnanj]Bn]j]ai-4/,(-404a-43-*Jk>n]oeh(ai-414(a_hk`a]lneiaen]cnara `ko pn]^]hd]`knao qn^]jko a( ai -434( ] lneiaen] cnara `ko pn]^]hd]`knao `k _]ilk( ai =il]nk$aop]`k`aOkL]qhk%* Oeiqhp]ja]iajpa(_kjokhe`])oa$ai]hcqjol]oao%kqeje_e])oa$aikqpnko%kAop]`kj]) _ekj]hqjeÚ_]`ka_ajpn]hev]`k(`aÚje`klah]qje`]`apannepkne]halah]e`ajpe`]`a`ahjcq]( nahecek( n]] a _kopqiao* K _]lep]h lna_eo] `a oqlknpao pannepkne]eo a lkn eook har] _kjo) pepqek`]oj] ao(bkn]j`k(lah]ocqann]oalahk`enaepkejpanj]_ekj]h(]`aheiep]ka] c]n]jpe]`abnkjpaen]oa(lahk]l]n]pkfqn`e_k(lkhe_e]haao_kh]n(]qje`]`a`ahjcq](nahecek a_kopqiao*Aioqi](ejrajp])oa]lpne]kqj]kj]bkni]`aAop]`kj]_ekj]h*?kikoa k^oanr](^k^ lklk^qro^ikbjbufpqbabpabpbjmob)j^pclffksbkq^a^mbil`^mfq^ifpjl klp`rilUFU* @klkjpk`areop]`]oe`ae]o(]hi`]opakne]ohe^an]eoaok_e]heop]oa`]a_kjkie]lkhpe) _](Dacahlnkl aqi]ÚhkokÚ]lkhpe_](]ÚhkokÚ]`k`enaepk* Dacahatlhe_]]cjaoa`kAop]`kik`anjkoaina_knnanpakne]`k`enaepkj]pqn]ha`k _kjpn]pkok_e]h*L]n]aha(kAop]`koqnca_kikoqlan]kn]_ekj]h`]oheiep] aomqa^hkmqa]) r]ik`aoajrkhreiajpk`kaolnepkdqi]jk6keokh]iajpk`koej`er`qkoj]b]ihe]a]o hqp]o`koejpanaooaolner]`koj]ok_ea`]`a_ereh*KAop]`k]^oknraapn]jobkni]]b]ihe]a ]ok_ea`]`a_erehjqi]pkp]he`]`an]_ekj]h(i]eo]hp]alanbaep](mqaatlneiakejpanaooaa] rkjp]`acan]eo*Lkneook(]na]hev]ki]eoeilknp]jpaÍa]hpei]Í`]n]vkj]deop ne]( qi]ravmqaoqlan]kol]npe_qh]neoikojqi]qje`]`aqjerano]h(mqa(lahk`enaepk(c]n]jpa] kn`ai(]l]v(]ikn]he`]`a(]he^an`]`aa]lanbaek`kaolnepkdqi]jk* =deop ne]]l]oo]cai`]b]ihe]ok_ea`]`a_ereha`aop]]kAop]`k(pniejk`klnk) _aookdeop ne_k*Aooalnk_aook_kj_a^e`k_kikna]hev]k`]_qhpqn](eopk(`]`ebanaj]a `]oal]n]kajpnaj]pqnav]aAolnepka_kik]^oknk`]lneiaen]lahkoacqj`k*Klnk) _aookdeop ne_k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]_kjo_ej_e](mqaoapknj]_]`]ravi]eo_kjo_eajpa`a oelah]ok^n]oaolenepq]eo`]_qhpqn](eopk(`]oe`ae]omqaoai]pane]hev]iaiejopepqe ao ok_e]eo(naheceko]o(]npope_]o(_eajpÚ_k)Úhko Ú_]oalkhpe_]o*KAop]`k]ojpaoaÚj]h`]_ne]) kn]_ekj]hkqaolenepq]h(atlnaooki]eo]hp]`]e`ae]kq`kAolnepk*
!LBUMß!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
ßNAß&RANlAßSmRIEßDEß REVOLUlzESßNAß%UROPAßß CENTRALßEßORIENTAL ßDEßß CARfTERßDEMOCRfTICO ßß LIBERALßEßSOCIALISTA ßQUEß FICOUßCONHECIDAßCOMOßß 0RIMAVERAßDOSß0OVOS (ULTON $EUTSCH#OLLECTION#ORBIS ,ATINSTOCK
ßNAß&RANlAßINSURREIljOß CONHECIDAßCOMOß#OMUNAß DEß0ARIS ßQUEßEMßßß INSTITUIUßUMAßDITADURAß PROLETfRIA ßESMAGADAßß PELASßTROPASßFRANCESASßß NOßMESMOßANO
034
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
He^an]heoiklkhpe_k(he^an]heoika_kjie_kkqa_kjkie]lkhpe_]ae`a]heoiklkhpe_k dacahe]jkbkni]ikl]jk`abqj`k`klajo]iajpk`aI]nt(rkhp]`kl]n]]_kilnaajok `k_]lep]heoika`]ohqp]olnkhapne]o* ?kjpn]khe^an]heoiklkhpe_k(I]ntikopn]nmqa]lnklnea`]`alner]`]jkqi`e) naepkj]pqn]hakAop]`kjknaoqhp]`k`aqi_kjpn]pkok_e]h*?kjpn]]a_kjkie]lkhpe_]( ikopn]n mqa ] a_kjkie] jk atlnaook `a qi] kn`ai j]pqn]h n]_ekj]h* ?kjpn] Dacah( ikopn]nmqakAop]`kjk]e`ae]kqkAolnepkaj_]nj]`kojkna]hamqa]deop ne]jkk ikreiajpk`]_kjo_ej_e]aoq]oe`ae]o*
C jaoa`]ok_ea`]`aa`kAop]`k
=
Úni]iko]jpanekniajpamqaI]ntej`]c]_kikkodkiajol]oo]n]i`]oq^ieook ]klk`anlaook]h`aqioajdknk^a`ej_e]`klk`aneilaook]h`kAop]`k*L]n]nao) lkj`an]aoo]ej`]c]k(lna_eok`aoraj`]n]cjaoa`kAop]`k*
Koik`ko`alnk`qk
035
Kooanaodqi]jko(ao_naraiI]ntaAjcaho(`eopejcqai)oa`ko]jei]eojklknmqaoa) f]i`kp]`ko`a_kjo_ej_e]$]jei]eon]_ekj]eo%(jailknmqaoaf]ij]pqn]hiajpaok_eraeo alkhpe_ko$]jei]eolkhpe_ko%(i]olknmqaok_]l]vao`amolarwfo]o_kj`e ao`aoq]ateo) pj_e]i]pane]haejpaha_pq]h*Kooanaodqi]jkooklnk`qpknao6oklnrblnk`qvaiaok `ljllnk`qvai*=lnk`qk`]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eoaejpaha_pq]eo`]ateopj_e]jkao) _khde`]hernaiajpalahkooanaodqi]jko(i]oaop`]`]k^faper]iajpa(ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa `ajkoo]rkjp]`a*AeolknmqaI]nt`evmqakodkiajob]vaioq]ln lne]deop ne](i]ojk ]b]vaiai_kj`e aoao_khde`]olknahao*Okdeopkne_]iajpa`apaniej]`kolah]o_kj`e) aoaimqalnk`qvaioq]re`]* =lnk`qki]pane]haejpaha_pq]h`]ateopj_e]dqi]j]`alaj`a`a_kj`e aoj]pqn]eo $]o`kiaek]i^eajpaa]o^ekh ce_]o`]aol_eadqi]j]%a`]lnk_ne]k*Aop]jk]laj]oqi `]`k^ekh ce_k$]`ebanaj]oatq]hja_aoone]l]n]]nalnk`qk%(i]ofok_e]h(lkeo`a_knna `]i]jaen]_kikoa`kejpan_ i^eka]_kklan]kajpnakodqi]jkoa`kik`k_kik oei^khev]`]loe_kh ce_]a_qhpqn]hiajpa]`ebanaj]`kooatko*Lknoaqpqnjk(]i]jaen]_kik kodqi]jkoejpanlnap]iana]hev]i]`ebanaj]oatq]h`apaniej]kik`k_kikb]nk]`ere) okok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk(`eopejcqej`kpn]^]hdkoi]o_qhejko(baiejejko(ejb]jpeoa`koe`koko* =lnk`qka]nalnk`qk`]o_kj`e ao`aateopj_e]oana]hev]i(lknp]jpk(lkniaek `k pn]^]hdk $nah]k _ki ] j]pqnav]%( `] `ereok ok_e]h `k pn]^]hdk $ejpan_ i^ek a _kkla) n]k%( `] lnk_ne]k $oatq]he`]`a a ejopepqek `] b]ihe]% a `k ik`k `a ]lnklne]k `] j]pqnav]$]lnklnea`]`a%* Aooa_kjfqjpk`a_kj`e aobkni](ai_]`]lk_](]ok_ea`]`aakoeopai]`]obkni]o lnk`qper]omqa]nacqh]i(oacqj`k]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk* Aoo]`ereok(mqa_kia]j]b]ihe](_ki]`ebanaj]oatq]h`]op]nab]o(lnkooacqaj]`eo) pejkajpna]cne_qhpqn]al]opknaek(ajpna]i^]oak_kin_ek(_kj`qvej`koal]n]kajpna k_]ilka]_e`]`a*Ai_]`]qi]`]o`eopej aoklan]ijkr]o`ereo aook_e]eo`kpn]^]hdk*= `ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdkjkqi]oeilhao`ereok`ap]nab]o(i]o]i]jebaop]k`]ateo) pj_e]`]lnklnea`]`a(kqoaf](]oal]n]kajpna]lnklnea`]`a(mqa]lkooa`]o_kj`e aoa `koejopnqiajpko`kpn]^]hdk(akln lnekpn]^]hdk(ej_e`ej`k(]oacqen(ok^na]bkni]`a`eopne) ^qek`kolnk`qpko`kpn]^]hdk*=lnklnea`]`aejpnk`qv]ateopj_e]`koiaeko`alnk`qk $_kj`e aoaejopnqiajpko`apn]^]hdk%_kik]hck`ebanajpa`]obkn]olnk`qper]o$pn]^]hdk%* =j]heo]j`k]o`ebanajpaobkni]o`alnklnea`]`a(]o`ebanajpaobkni]o`anah]kajpna iaeko`alnk`qkabkn]olnk`qper]o(]o`ebanajpaobkni]o`a`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk `a_knnajpao`]obkni]o`alnklnea`]`aa`]onah] aoajpnakoiaeko`alnk`qka]obkn]o lnk`qper]o(lkoorahlan_a^an]oamqj_e]`klnk_aookdeop ne_ka]o`ebanajpaoik`]he`]) `ao`aok_ea`]`a*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=lnklnea`]`a_kia]_kikmolmofba^abqof_^ia]ok_ea`]`apai]bkni]`aqi]_k) iqje`]`a^]oa]`]j]b]ihe]$]_kiqje`]`areop]_kik]b]ihe]]ilhe]`]mq]hlanpaj) _aipk`kokoiai^nko`kcnqlk%*Jah]lnar]ha_a]dean]nmqe]`aÚje`]lknp]nab]o(bqj ao( lk`anaoa_kjoqik*Aoo]bkni]`]lnklnea`]`aoapn]jobkni]jqi]kqpn](]molmofba^ab bpq^q^i( kq oaf]( lnklnea`]`a `k Aop]`k( _qfk `enecajpa `apaniej] k ik`k `a nah] ao `ko oqfaepko_kiah]6ai_anpko_]oko$_kikj]æj`e](j]?dej](j]Lnoe]%(kAop]`kklnklnea) pnekje_kalaniepa]o]pere`]`aoa_kjie_]oia`e]jpal]c]iajpk`apne^qpko(eilkopko ap]t]o7aikqpnko$Cn_e](Nki]%(kAop]`k_a`a(ia`e]jpa_anp]onacn]o(]lnklnea`]`ao cn]j`aob]ihe]o(mqaoapknj]ilnklneapne]olner]`]o* =ok_ea`]`aoa`ere`a(]ckn](ajpnaoajdknaoaao_n]rko*Jkocn]j`aoeilnekokneajp]eo( kooajdknaooak_ql]i`]cqann]a`]nahecek7j]Cn_e]aaiNki](pknj]i)oa_e`]`koa k_ql]i)oa`]lkhpe_](]hi`alkooqnailnerehcekoiehep]naoanahecekoko7reraij]o_e) `]`aoaaihqp]lani]jajpaajpnakomqalani]ja_an]ijk_]ilk(^ai_kik_kikodk) iajohernaomqapn]^]hd]ij]o]pere`]`aoqn^]j]o$]npao]j]pka_kin_ek%a_kikoao_n]rko $`k_]ilka`]_e`]`a%* =pan_aen]bkni]`alnklnea`]`a]cbra^i(]lnaoajp]j`k)oa_kiklnklnea`]`alner]`] `]pann]lahkooajdknaoalnklnea`]`a`koejopnqiajpko`apn]^]hdklahko]npaokohernao( iai^nko`]o_knlkn] ao`ko^qncko*=pann]pn]^]hd]`]lknoanrko`]cha^]a]ok_ea`]) `aoaaopnqpqn]lah]`ereokajpnajk^nav]bqj`ene]aoanrko$jk_]ilk%a]npaokohernaoa ]lnaj`evao$j]_e`]`a%*Ajpnaahaooqncaqi]Úcqn]ejpania`ene]6k_kian_e]jpa*=ohqp]o ajpna_kian_e]jpaoajk^nao(k`aoajrkhreiajpk`ko^qncko(`k]npao]j]pka`]]pere`]`a _kian_e]h_kj`qvaiiq`]j]mqa_kjda_aiko6]molmofba^abmofs^a^`^mfq^ifpq^* Aoo]jkr]bkni]`alnklnea`]`alkooqe`^o^`qbopqf`^pfkafq^paqi]ran`]`aen]na) rkhqk a_kjie_]( lknmqa ob^ifw^ ^ pbm^o^ l fkqbdo^i bkqob molmofbqoflp alp jbflp ab molar lbclo ^pmolarqfs^p(eopk(ajpna]o_kj`e aoakoejopnqiajpko`apn]^]hdkak ln lnekpn]^]hdk*Kolnklneapnekolner]`kolkooqaiiaeko(_kj`e aoaejopnqiajpko`k pn]^]hdk( lkooqai k _kjpnkha `] `eopne^qek a `k _kjoqik `ko lnk`qpko* Jk kqpnk lkhk ok_e]haj_kjpn]i)oakopn]^]hd]`knao_kiki]oo]`a]oo]h]ne]`koejpaen]iajpaatlnklne]) `]`koiaeko`alnk`qk(lkooqej`k]laj]o]bkn]`kpn]^]hdk(_khk_]`]`eolkoek`ko lnklneapneko`koiaeko`alnk`qk(jkian_]`k`a_kiln]araj`]`]ik`ak^n]* Aoo]o`ebanajpaobkni]o`]lnklnea`]`a`koiaeko`alnk`qka`]onah] ao_ki]o bkn]o lnk`qper]o kq `a `apaniej] ao ok_e]eo `a_knnajpao `] `ereok ok_e]h `k pn]^]hdk _kjopepqaikojlalpabmolar l*
Ki]pane]heoikdeopne_k I]ntaAjcahok^oanr]n]imqa(]_]`]ik`k`alnk`qk(]_kjo_ej_e]`kooanaodq) i]jkooapn]jobkni]*@ao_k^nen]imqaaoo]opn]jobkni] ao_kjopepqai]i]jaen]_kik( ai_]`]lk_](]_kjo_ej_e]ejpanlnap](_kilnaaj`aanalnaoajp]l]n]oeiaoi]kmqaoa l]oo] j]o _kj`e ao i]pane]eo `a lnk`qk a nalnk`qk `] ateopj_e]* Lkn aooa ikperk( I]ntaAjcaho]Úni]n]imqa(]k_kjpnnek`kmqaoalajo](jkok]oe`ae]odqi]j]omqa ikrai]deop ne](i]ook]o_kj`e aodeop ne_]omqalnk`qvai]oe`ae]o* J]k^n]@lkqof_rf l `oqf`^a^b`lkljf^mliqf`^(I]ntao_nara6 L`lkgrkqla^pobi^ bpabmolar l%nrb`loobpmlkab^ldo^rababpbkslisfjbkql a^pclo ^pmolarqfs^pj^qbof^fp&`lkpqfqrf^bpqorqro^b`lkjf`^a^pl`fba^ab)^_^pb `lk`obq^pl_ob^nr^ipbbibs^rj^prmbobpqorqro^groaf`^bmliqf`^b nr^i`loobpmlk* abjabqbojfk^a^pcloj^pab`lkp`fk`f^pl`f^i+Ljlalabobmolar labsfa^j^qb* of^iabqbojfk^labpbkslisfjbkqla^sfa^pl`f^i)mliqf`^bfkqbib`qr^ibjdbo^i+Kl^ `lkp`fk`f^alpeljbkpnrbabqbojfk^lpbrpbo8lpbrpbopl`f^inrb)fksbop^jbkqb) abqbojfk^pr^`lkp`fk`f^+ lkn]Úni]nmqa]ok_ea`]`aoa_kjopepqe]l]npen`a_kj`e aoi]pane]eo`alnk`qk a`]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdkmqa]oiq`]j]odeop ne_]ook`apaniej]`]olah]oik`eÚ)
04,
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx MATERIALISMOßAßNOljOßDEß MATERIALISMOßSURGE ßPELAß PRIMEIRAßVEZ ßNAßFILOSOFIAß GREGAß!SßESCOLASßFILOSv FICASßESTOICAßEßEPICURISTAß AFIRMARAM ßCONTRAß0LATjO ß !RISTvTELESßEßNEOPLATxNI COS ßQUEßSvßEXISTEMßCORPOSß OUßAßMATmRIAß/SßEPICURIS TAS ßRETOMANDOßIDEIASßDOSß PRm SOCRfTICOSßATOMISTASß ,EUCIPOßEß$EMvCRITO ß AFIRMARAMßQUEßOßESPqRITOß ERAßfTOMOßMATERIALßSUTILßEß DIfFANOß.OSßSmCULOSß86))ß Eß86))) ßREAGINDOßCONTRAß OßESPIRITUALISMOßCRISTjO ß MUITOSßFILvSOFOSßSEßDISSE RAMßMATERIALISTAS ßQUE RENDOßCOMßISSOßDIZERßQUEß SvßEXISTEßAßNATUREZAßEßQUEß ESTAßmßMATmRIAßfTOMOS ß MOVIMENTO ßMASSA ßFIGU RA ßETC ß#OMOßVIVEMOSß EMßSOCIEDADESßCRISTjSß MESMOßQUEßHAJAßOUTRASß RELIGIzESßMINORITfRIAS ßOß MATERIALISMOßSEMPREßFOIß CONSIDERADOßBLASFoMIAß EßHERESIAßPORQUEßNEGAßAß EXISToNCIAßDEßPUROSßESPq RITOS ßAßIMORTALIDADEßDAß ALMAßEßAßSEPARAljOßENTREß $EUSßEßNATUREZAß/ßSENSOß COMUMßSOCIAL ßABSORVEN DOßAßCRqTICAßESPIRITUALISTA ß FALAßEMß±MATERIALISMO²ß PARAßREFERIR SEßAßPESSOASß QUEßSvßACREDITAMßNESTAß VIDAßTERRENA ßEGOqSTASßEß AMBICIOSAS ßSEMßPREO CUPAljOßCOMßAßSALVAljOß ETERNAßEßCOMßOßBEMßEßAß SALVAljOßDOßPRvXIMOß/ß ±MATERIALISTA²ßmßOßQUEß GOSTAßDEßPRAZERES ßRIQUE ZASßEßLUXOßRIGOROSAMENTE ß PORTANTO ßDEVER SE IAßDIZERß QUEßOSßBURGUESESßSjOß ±MATERIALISTAS² ßEMBORAßSEß DIGAMßCRISTjOSßESPIRITUA LISTAS ß1UANDOß-ARXßFALAß EMß±MATERIALISMO² ßAßMA TmRIAßgßQUALßSEßREFEREßNjOß SjOßOSßCORPOSßFqSICOS ßOSß fTOMOS ßOSßSERESßNATURAIS ß EßSIMßASßRELAlzESßSOCIAISßß DEßPRODUljOßECONxMICAßß 3EUßMATERIALISMOßVISAß OPOR SEßAOßIDEALISMOßß ESPIRITUALISTAßHEGELIANO ß PARAßOßQUALßAßFORlAßQUEß MOVEßAßHISTvRIAßmßAßIDEIA ßß OßESPqRITO ßAßCONSCIoNCIA
04-
_] aoj]mqah]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eoaj]mqah]`ereok`kpn]^]hdk7a(]ej`](lkn]Úni]nmqa ]_kjo_ej_e]dqi]j]`apaniej]`]]lajo]n]oe`ae]omqalajo]lkn_]qo]`]o_kj`e ao i]pane]eoejopepq`]olah]ok_ea`]`amqaklajo]iajpk`aI]ntaAjcaho_d]i]`k`ai]) pane]heoikdeopne_k* J^qbof^ifpjllknmqaokikokmqa]o`lkaf bpj^qbof^fp$]onah] aook_e]eo`alnk`q) k%jko`apaniej]i]oana]lajo]n*Efpqof`llknmqa]ok_ea`]`aa]lkhpe_]jkoqncai `a`a_napko`erejkojaij]o_ai`]kn`aij]pqn]h(i]o`alaj`aia^^ l`lk`obq^alp pbobperj^klpklqbjml* =deop ne]jkqilnkcnaookheja]na_kjpjqk(qi]oamqj_e]`a_]qo]oaabaepko(i]o rj mol`bppl ab qo^kpcloj^ bp pl`f^fp abqbojfk^a^p mbi^p `lkqo^af bp bkqob lp jbflp ab molar l$]bkni]`]lnklnea`]`a%b^pclo ^pmolarqfs^p$kpn]^]hdk(oaqoejopnqiajpko(]o p_je_]o%*=hqp]`a_h]ooaoatlneiap]eo_kjpn]`e aoakikpkn`]deop ne]*Lkn]Úni]nmqa klnk_aookdeop ne_kikre`klkn_kjpn]`e aook_e]eo(ki]pane]heoikdeop ne_k`e]h pe_k*
=c jaoa`kAop]`k =onah] aook_e]eo`alnk`qkjkoknaolkjoraeo]laj]olah]cjaoa`]ok_ea`]`a( i]op]i^ilah]`kAop]`k(mqaI]nt`aoecj]_kikoqlanaopnqpqn]fqn`e_]alkhpe_]( _knnaolkj`ajpaaopnqpqn]a_kjie_]`]ok_ea`]`a* Mq]h]cjaoa`kAop]`k;?kjÛepkoajpnalnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`alnk`qk a_kjpn]`e aoajpnaahaoakojklnklneapneko$ao_n]rko(oanrko(pn]^]hd]`knaohernao%*Ko _kjÛepkoajpnalnklneapnekoa]o_kjpn]`e aoajpnalnklneapnekoajklnklneapneko^m^* ob`bjl]n]]_kjo_ej_e]ok_e]hj]bkni]`a_kjÛepkoa_kjpn]`e aoajpnaejpanaooaol]npe) _qh]naoaejpanaooacan]h*>m^ob`bj`aoo]i]jaen](i]oklplob^ijbkqbkmqa]l]najp]i* Ai kqpn]o l]h]rn]o( kj`a d lnklnea`]`a lner]`]( d ejpanaooa lner]`k a jk lk`a d]ran ejpanaooa_khaperkkqcan]h* Ko lnklneapneko `ko iaeko `a lnk`qk lk`ai pan ejpanaooao _kiqjo( lkeo ja_aooe) p]i`kejpan_ i^eka`]_kklan]kl]n]i]jpanab]van_nao_an]lnklnea`]`a`a_]`]qi* =ooei(ai^kn]aopaf]iai_kj_knnj_e]a_kilapek(lna_eo]iaop]^aha_an_anp]onacn]o lah]o mq]eo jk oa `aopnq]i na_elnk_]iajpa( jai o oq]o lnklnea`]`ao* O]^ai p]i^i mqajklk`anknaokhran]o_kjpn]`e ao_kikojklnklneapnekoamqaaopaolk`ai(lkn narkhp]oanarkhq aolklqh]nao(`aopnqen]lnklnea`]`alner]`]*lna_eok(lknp]jpk(mqako ejpanaooao_kiqjoajpnakolnklneapneko`koiaeko`alnk`qka]bkn]l]n]`kiej]nko jklnklneapnekooaf]iaop]^aha_e`ko`ai]jaen]p]hmqal]na]i_knnapko(hacpeikoar) he`kol]n]pk`ko*L]n]eook(_ne]ikAop]`k_kiklk`anoal]n]`k`]ok_ea`]`a(lknp]`kn`k `enaepka`]ohaeo(`kp]`k`abkn]l]n]qo]n]rekhj_e]j]nalnaook`apq`kmq]jpkl]na] laneckokaopnqpqn]a_kjie_]ateopajpa* Jk_]ok`klk`an`aol pe_k(]hacepei]kbaep]lah]`erejev]k`koajdkn6k`apajpkn `klk`an$qiej`er`qk(qi]b]ihe]kqqicnqlk`ab]ihe]o%]lnaoajp])oa_kikÚhdk`a qidqi]jka`aqi]`erej`]`a(eopk(oaqj]o_eiajpkat_al_ekj]hfqopeÚ_]oaqlk`anek* Jk_]ok`klk`anpak_npe_k(]hacepei]kbaep]lah]o]_n]hev]k`kckranj]jpa6k`apajpkn `klk`ankna_a^a`enap]iajpa`a@aqo(oaj`kqiao_khde`k`a@aqo*Jk_]ok`]onal^he_]o $`aik_n]_e]cnac](kOaj]`kaLkrkNki]jk%(]hacepei]kbaep]lah]ejopepqek`k`enaepk a`]ohaeo(mqa`aÚjaimqailk`aoan_e`]`kal]npe_el]n`kckranjk* Jkopno_]oko(]`ereokok_e]h]l]na_a_kikdean]nmqe]`erej]a+kqj]pqn]h(mqafqope) Ú_]]at_hqok`kojklnklneapneko`klk`anaok^napq`kaop]^aha_alnej_leko$`erejkokq j]pqn]eo%l]n]]oq^ieooka]k^a`ej_e](pn]jobkni]`]oaik^nec] ao* Jk_]ok`kAop]`kik`anjk(_kikreiko(]oe`ae]o`aaop]`k`aj]pqnav](`enaepkj]pq) n]h(_kjpn]pkok_e]ha`enaepk_erehbqj`]iklk`anlkhpe_kj]rkjp]`a`kolnklneapneko`ko iaeko`alnk`qk(mqaoa]lnaoajp]i_kikej`er`qkohernaoaecq]eomqapn]jobanaioaqo `enaepkoj]pqn]eo]klk`anlkhpe_k(ejopepqej`k]]qpkne`]`a`kAop]`ka`]ohaeo* AeolknmqakAop]`klna_eo]^m^ob`bo_kikatlnaook`kejpanaooacan]hajk_kik oajdknekl]npe_qh]n`a]hcqjolk`ankoko*Kojklnklneapnekolk`aina_qo]n(_kikÚvan]i
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
ejian]oravaoj]deop ne](klk`anlaook]hreorah`aqioajdkn(i]ojkkb]vaimq]j`k oapn]p]`aqilk`an`eop]jpa(oal]n]`k(ejreorahaeilaook]h_kikk`kAop]`k*Fqhc]j`k mqaaopaoaaj_kjpn]]oanrek`k^ai_kiqi(`]fqope](`]kn`ai(`]hae(`]l]va`]oacq) n]j](]_aep]i]`kiej]k(lkeojk]lan_a^ai_kikp]h* Naop]]oacqj`]ej`]c]k`aI]nt(mq]hoaf]6lknmqakooqfaepkook_e]eojklan_a^ai krj_qhkajpnaklk`ana_kjie_kaklk`anlkhpe_k;
E`akhkce] =]heaj]ka_kjie_] Mq]j`k _ep]iko k patpk `] @lkqof_rf l `oqf`^ a^ b`lkljf^ mliqf`^( reiko mqa I]nt]Úni]mqa^`lkp`fk`f^erj^k^pbjmobpl`f^ibefpqof`^(eopk(`apaniej]`]lah]o _kj`e ao_kj_nap]o`ajkoo]ateopj_e]* Eook jk oecjeÚ_]( lkni( mqa jkoo]o e`ae]o nalnaoajpai ] na]he`]`a p]h _kik aop] aioeiaoi]*Oa]ooeibkooa(oane]ej_kilnaajorahmqakooanaodqi]jko(_kjda_aj`k]o _]qo]o `] atlhkn]k( `] `kiej]k( `] ieone] a `] ejfqope] j]`] Úvaooai _kjpn] ah]o* Jkoo]oe`ae]o(deopkne_]iajpa`apaniej]`]o(pi]la_qhe]ne`]`a`aj]o_an]l]npen`ajkoo] atlanej_e]ok_e]h`enap]aaop]oailnaoakbana_a_kikqi]atlhe_]k`]i]jaen]_kik ]re`]ok_e]hjko^m^ob`bkqp]h_kikah]jkom^ob`bpbo*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]atlanej_e] ok_e]heia`e]p]kq`enap]atlhe_]]ok_ea`]`aa]onah] aook_e]eo]l]npen`aoq]o^m^ok`f^p( _kikoabkooai]na]he`]`a* Jko eook*=o]l]nj_e]o$kqkÎ]l]na_anok_e]h_kjo_ej_e]Ï%ok]l]nj_e]ofqop]) iajpalknmqajkokbana_aikiqj`k`a_]^a]l]n]^]etk6kmqa_]qo]l]na_aoanabaepk( kmqaabaepkl]na_aoan_]qo]*Eookjkoa`]laj]ojklh]jk`]_kjo_ej_e]ej`ere`q]h( i]ook^napq`kjk`]_kjo_ej_e]ok_e]h(eopk(jk_kjfqjpk`ae`ae]oaatlhe_] aomqaqi] ok_ea`]`akbana_aok^naoeiaoi]* Baqan^]_d(_kikreiko(aopq`]n]aooabajiajkj]nahecek(`aoecj]j`k)k_kik_kj) _aepk`a^ifbk^ l*I]ntejpanaoo])oalknaooabajiajklknmqaklan_a^aqaikqpn]oaoba) n]o`]re`]ok_e]h(lknatailhk(j]lkhpe_](mqa(_kik]j]heo]ikodlkq_k(har]kooqfaepko ok_e]eo]]_aep]n]`kiej]kaop]p]hlknmqajkna_kjda_aimqaiokkoran`]`aenko_ne]) `knao`kAop]`k* Ahakk^oanrkqp]i^ij]aoban]`]a_kjkie]*Jk_]lep]heoik(kopn]^]hd]`knaolnk) `qvaipk`kokok^fapkoateopajpaojkian_]`k(eopk(pk`]o]oian_]`kne]o7]l od]r)h]o lnk`qve`k(ajpnac]i)j]o]kolnklneapneko`koiaeko`alnk`qk(ia`e]jpaqio]hnek7ko lnklneapneko`koiaeko`alnk`qkraj`ai]oian_]`kne]o]ko_kian_e]jpao(mqa]o_khk) _]ijkian_]`k`a_kjoqik7akopn]^]hd]`knaokqlnk`qpknao`aoo]oian_]`kne]o(mq]j`k rk]kian_]`k`a_kjoqik(jk_kjoacqai_kiln)h]o*Komqalnk`qven]ipa_e`koankq) l]okhd]iklnak`ko]heiajpkoalan_a^aimqa_kioaqo]hnekjklk`ai_kiln]nmq]oa j]`]7komqalnk`qven]i]heiajpkokhd]ikolnako`]onkql]oalan_a^aimqaoaqo]h) neko `l]n]_kiln]n]hcqi]ola]o`a^]et]mq]he`]`a7komqalnk`qven]ira_qhkojk _kjoacqai_kiln]npk`]o]onkql]oapk`koko]heiajpkomqackop]ne]i`apanlknmqaoaq o]hnek^]etk7akomqalnk`qven]i]heiajpkoankql]ojklk`ai_kiln]nqi]qpki rah* A ]ooei lkn `e]jpa* Ko lnk`qpknao `]o ian_]`kne]o khd]i ko lnako( _kjp]i k `ejdaenk a rkhp]il]n]_]o]`aikor]ve]o(_kikoaklnak`]oian_]`kne]oateopeooamlopfjbpjla _kikoaah]oaoperaooairaj`]lknmqaoqncen]ialk^a^a]hcqi]o`a_e`eqraj`an* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ai^kn]ko`ebanajpaopn]^]hd]`knaoo]e^]imqalnk`qven]i]o`e) banajpao ian_]`kne]o( jk lan_a^ai mqa( _kik _h]ooa ok_e]h( lnk`qven]i pk`]o ah]o( eopk (mqakolnk`qpknao`apa_e`ko(nkql]o(]heiajpko(ra_qhkoapk`kokokqpnkolnk`qpkook iai^nko`]iaoi]_h]ooaok_e]h*Kopn]^]hd]`knaooaraai_kikej`er`qkoeokh]`ko$_]`] mq]h_kioq]b]ihe](oaqol]najpaoa]iecko%mqa_kjda_aioaqln lnekpn]^]hdk(i]oec) jkn]ikopn]^]hdko`]okqpn]o_]packne]o`apn]^]hd]`knao(eopk(klpbmbo`b_bj_kikbkn)
&EUERBACHßVERßCAPqTULOßß DAß5NIDADEß
04.
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
i]j`kqi]_h]ooaok_e]hje_](lnk`qpkn]`apk`]o]oian_]`kne]oateopajpaojkian_]`k* Lknaooaikperk(mqailnk`qveqpa_e`kjklan_a^amqabkep]i^iqipn]^]hd]`knmqa lnk`qveqqira_qhkamqaqikqpnklnk`qveqqi]heiajpk*Lknjkoalan_a^anai_kik _h]ooaok_e]haoei_kikej`er`qkoeokh]`ko(jko jkoana_kjda_ai_kik]qpknaokq lnk`qpknao`]oian_]`kne]o(i]o]ej`]]_na`ep]imqar]haiklnakmqa_qop]ijkian_]) `k`a_kjoqikamqajklk`aipanp]eoian_]`kne]olknmqaah]or]haii]eo`kmqaahao* Lknjkoalan_a^anai_kik_h]ooaok_e]h(klpbob`lkeb`bj_kiklnk`qpknao`]nemqav]a `]o_keo]o*Oaio]^an(rerai]atlanej_e]`]]heaj]ka_kjie_](eopk(]_naj]`amqa ]oian_]`kne]ook_keo]omqaateopaiej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`kpn]^]hdkl]n]lnk`qve)h]oa mqalkooqaiqir]hknbjpfjbpj^p(r]hknmqa]l]na_ajklnakmqahdaobke`]`k* I]nt(ajpnap]jpk(jkoa_kjpajpkqai_kjop]p]nkbajiajk`]]heaj]k(i]olan) cqjpkqmq]hoane]oq]_]qo]*=naolkop]]aoo]ej`]c]kkharkq]bkniqh]nk_kj_aepk`a e`akhkce]* =e`akhkce]qibajiajkdeop ne_k)ok_e]h`a_knnajpa`kik`k`alnk`qka_kj) ie_k*qi]na`a`aei]cajoa`ae`ae]okqqi_kjfqjpk`aobmobpbkq^ bpok^nakooanao dqi]jkoaoq]onah] ao(ok^na]o_keo]o(ok^nak^aiaki]h(kfqopkakejfqopk(ko^kjoa koi]qo_kopqiao(ap_*
=c jaoa`]e`akhkce]
04/
Çia`e`]mqa(jqi]bkni]kok_e]h(oaaop]^ehev](oaÚt]aoanalapaqi]bkni]`apanie) j]`]`]`ereokok_e]h(_]`]ej`er`qkl]oo]]panqi]]pere`]`a`apaniej]`]aat_hqoer]mqa hda]pne^q`]lahk_kjfqjpk`]onah] aook_e]eo(lahkaopcek`]obkn]olnk`qper]oalah]bkn) i]`]lnklnea`]`a*?]`]qi(lkn_]qo]`]Úte`ava`]nalapek`aoaqhqc]na`aoq]]pere`]`a( paj`a]jklan_a^)hko_kikfkpqfqralppl`f^ijbkqba]_kjoe`an)hkok^qro^fp$lknatailhk( mq]j`k]hcqifqhc]mqab]vkmqab]vlknmqapaip]hajpkkqrk_]kj]pqn]hl]n]eook7mq]j) `k]hcqifqhc]mqa(lknj]pqnav](kojacnkobkn]ibaepkol]n]oanaiao_n]rko7mq]j`k]hcqi fqhc]mqa(lknj]pqnav](]oiqhdanaobkn]ibaep]ol]n]]i]panje`]`aakpn]^]hdk`kiope_k%* = atlanej_e] `] `ereok ok_e]h `]o ]pere`]`ao rere`]( lknp]jpk( _ki j]pqn]he`]`a6 ]_na`ep])oamqa(]ooei_kik]j]pqnav]lnk`qvneko(i]nao(_qo(Ûknaop]oa]opnko(ah]p]i) ^i lnk`qv nah] ao ok_e]eo( `a i]jaen] mqa d oajdknao lkn j]pqnav]( ao_n]rko lkn j]) pqnav](_e`]`kolknj]pqnav](lnklneapnekolknj]pqnav](]oo]h]ne]`kolknj]pqnav](ap_*= j]pqn]hev]koqncaj]bkni]`ae`ae]omqa]Úni]ioanai]ook_ea`]`ao_kikoklknmqa j]pqn]hmqa]ooeioaf]i*=onah] aook_e]eo(reop]o_kikj]pqn]eo(l]oo]i]oan_kjoe`an]) `]oateopajpaobjpfbmlopf(ajk_kiknaoqhp]`kodeop ne_ko`]]kdqi]j]*J]ia`e`] aimqa]j]pqnav]reop]_kik]_]qo]`]onah] aook_e]eo(]ok_ea`]`aoqnca_kikqi] bkn]j]pqn]haopn]jd]alk`anko](mqab]v_kimqapq`koaf]ja_aoo]ne]iajpa_kik* =`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk(eje_e]`]j]b]ihe](lnkooacqaj]ok_ea`]`aa(ia`e`]mqa aop]oapknj]i]eo_kilhat](har]]qi]`ereokajpna`keopelkobqj`]iajp]eo`apn]^]hdk6l qo^_^ielj^qbof^iabmolar lab`lfp^pblqo^_^ielfkqbib`qr^iabmolar labfabf^p*Jkej) _ek(aoo]oacqj`]bkni]`apn]^]hdkok_e]h$lnk`qk`ae`ae]o%lnerehcek`koo]_an`kpao7`a) lkeo(pknj])oabqjk`alnkbaooknaoaao_nepknao(]npeop]oa_eajpeop]o(lajo]`knaoaÚh okbko* Ko mqa lnk`qvai e`ae]o oal]n]i)oa `ko mqa lnk`qvai _keo]o( bkni]j`k qi cnqlk l]npa*Lkq_k]lkq_k(ia`e`]mqarkÚ_]j`k_]`]ravi]eo`eop]jpaoaoal]n]`ko`ko pn]^]hd]`knaoi]pane]eo(komqalnk`qvaie`ae]o_kia]i]]_na`ep]nmqa]_kjo_ej_e]a klajo]iajpkaopk(aioealknoeiaoiko(pbm^o^alp`]o_keo]oi]pane]eo(ateopej`kai oe a lkn oe iaoiko* Kq oaf]( _kik pi ] atlanej_e] `a bkni]n qi cnqlk ok_e]h m^oqb( fqhc]i)oaej`alaj`ajpao`]ln lne]ok_ea`]`aal]oo]i]]_na`ep]nj]ej`alaj`j_e]ajpna ]_kjo_ej_e]akiqj`ki]pane]h(ajpnaklajo]iajpka]o_keo]olnk`qve`]ook_e]hiajpa* ?kjbanai ^rqlkljf^ _kjo_ej_e] a o e`ae]o a( Új]hiajpa( fqhc]i mqa ]o e`ae]o jk o atlhe_]i]na]he`]`a(i]o]lnk`qvai*Oqnca]e`akhkce]_kik]Úni]k`]ej`alaj`j_e] `]oe`ae]oa`]_]l]_e`]`a`a]oe`ae]o_ne]nai]na]he`]`a(kq(_kikiqepko_kopqi]i`e) van(j]_naj]`amqaÎ]oe`ae]omqaikraikiqj`kÏ*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Kn](kcnqlk`komqalnk`qvaie`ae]o$o]_an`kpao(lnkbaooknao(]npeop]o(Úh okbko(_eaj) peop]o% jk j]o_aq `k j]`]* J]o_aq jk o `] `ereok ok_e]h `k pn]^]hdk( i]o p]i^i `a qi]`ereokjkejpanekn`]_h]ooa`kolnklneapnekokq_h]ooa`kiej]jpa`aqi]ok_ea`]`a( eopk(kolneiaenkolnk`qpknao`ae`ae]oan]iiai^nko`]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa_qf]ob]ihe]o `ere`en]iklk`anajpnacqannaenkoao]_an`kpao(kqajpnakomqa`kiej]r]iko_knlko(lkn iaek`]o]ni]o(akomqa`kiej]r]ikoaolnepko(lkniaek`]o_naj]o*Lkniaek`aao_kh]o a ]pere`]`ao aola_e]hev]`]o( k cnqlk o]_an`kp]h bke c]jd]j`k ej`alaj`j_e] a lk`an l]n] bkni]noaqoln lnekoiai^nko* Kcnqlklajo]jpa$koejpaha_pq]eo%`aqi]ok_ea`]`a(lknlanpaj_an_h]ooa`kiej]jpa kqlknaop]nqje`k]ah]lkniaek`]a`q_]kaola_e]hev]`](lajo]_ki]oe`ae]o`ko`kiej]j) pao7fqhc](lkni(mqap]eoe`ae]ookran`]`aen]oaioeiaoi]oapn]jobkni]]oe`ae]o`aqi] _h]ooaok_e]h`apaniej]`]aie`ae]orkfsbop^fpakb`bppof^p(rhe`]ol]n]]ok_ea`]`aejpaen]* ?kikkcnqlklnk`qpkn`ae`ae]o$kofabildlp%`kiej]]_kjo_ej_e]ok_e]h(paiklk) `an`apn]joiepen]oe`ae]o`kiej]jpaol]n]pk`]]ok_ea`]`alkniaek`]nahecek(`]o]npao( `]ao_kh](`]_ej_e](`]ÚhkokÚ](`ko_kopqiao(`]ohaeoa`k`enaepk(ikh`]j`k]_kjo_ej_e] `apk`]o]o_h]ooaook_e]eoaqjebkniev]j`kklajo]iajpk`apk`]o]o_h]ooao* Koe`a hkckookiai^nko`]_h]ooa`kiej]jpaa`]o_h]ooao]he]`]o]ah](mqa(_kikejpa) ha_pq]eo(oeopai]pev]i]oei]cajoa]oe`ae]ook_e]eo`]_h]ooa`kiej]jpaainalnaoajp] ao _khaper]o(can]eoaqjerano]eo(rhe`]ol]n]pk`koajk]laj]ol]n]koln lneko`kiej]jpao* Aoo]oei]cajoae`ae]ojkatlneiai]na]he`]`aok_e]h(i]oobmobpbkq^j]]l]nj_e]ok_e]h `klkjpk`areop]`ko`kiej]jpaoÍokkmqako`kiej]jpaolajo]iok^na]ok_ea`]`aa jkkmqa]ok_ea`]`aabaper]iajpa*=oe`ae]o]ooeilnk`qve`]ook_kjoe`an]`]ona]he`]`ao ]qpjki]omqalnk`qvai]na]he`]`ai]pane]hkqok_e]h*Okei]cajoae`ae]olkop]o_kik rkfsbop^fpa(lknp]jpk(oke`ae]o^_pqo^q^p(qi]ravmqa(_kj_nap]iajpa(jk_knnaolkj`ai na]he`]`aok_e]h(`ere`e`]ai_h]ooaook_e]eo]jp]cje_]o*=ooei(lknatailhk(ateopaij] ok_ea`]`a_]lep]heop](_kj_nap]iajpa(]_h]ooa`kolnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`alnk) `qk$ko_]lep]heop]o%a]_h]ooa`ko]oo]h]ne]`ko$kopn]^]hd]`knao%(i]oj]e`akhkce]]l]na_a ]^opn]p]iajpaqiqjerano]h(leljbj*Aopa(j]ran`]`a(qi]e`ae]mqaatlneia]i]jaen] _kikko`kiej]jpaooaraai]oeiaoiko_kikik`ahkl]n]pk`kokooanaodqi]jko* =e`akhkce]pknj])oalnklne]iajpae`akhkce]mq]j`kjk]l]na_aj]bkni]`kiepk(`] naheceka`]pakhkce]*?kiabaepk(jaopao(]atlhe_]kok^na]knecai`kooanaodqi]jko( `]ok_ea`]`aa`klk`anlkhpe_kaj_kjpn]]_]qo]_ne]`kn]kqlnk`qpkn]clo^a^kqbp`ko ln lnekodqi]jkoa`aoq]]k(hk_]hev]j`k]_]qo]knecejne]j]o`erej`]`ao*=e`akhkce] lnklne]iajpa`ep]oqncamq]j`k(jkhqc]n`a`erej`]`ao(aj_kjpn]ikofabf^p_kik_]qo]o `]ok_ea`]`aa`]onah] aook_e]eo6kdkiai(]lpne](]b]ihe](]ao_kh](klnkcnaook(]_ej) _e](kAop]`k(k^ai(kfqopk(ap_* ?kieook(lk`aiko`evanmqa^fablildf^rjcbkjbkljlabokl(oq^opepqej`kkl]) lah mqa( ]jpao `ah]( pejd]i ko iepko a ]o pakhkce]o* ?ki ] e`akhkce]( ] atlhe_]k ok^na ] knecai`kodkiajo(`]ok_ea`]`aa`]lkhpe_]aj_kjpn])oaj]o] aodqi]j]o(ajpaj`e`]o _kiki]jebaop]k`]_kjo_ej_e]kq`]oe`ae]o*=ooei(lknatailhk(fqhc]nmqakAop]`k jk oa knecej] `] rkjp]`a `a @aqo( i]o `]o e`ae]o `a aop]`k `a j]pqnav]( `enaepk j]pqn]h( _kjpn]pkok_e]ha`enaepk_erehoqlknmqa]_kjo_ej_e]dqi]j](ej`alaj`ajpaiajpa`]o _kj`e aodeop ne_]oi]pane]eo(lajokqjaoo]oe`ae]o(fqhckq)]o_knnap]oal]ookq]]cenlkn ah]o(_ne]j`k]na]he`]`a`aoecj]`]analnaoajp]`]lknah]o*
=klan]ke`akhce_] Mqab]v]e`akhkce];Kbana_a]qi]ok_ea`]`a`ere`e`]ai_h]ooaook_e]eo]jp]cje_]o( amqareraij]bkni]`]hqp]`a_h]ooao(rj^fj^dbjnrbmbojfq^^rkfÛ`^ lb^fabkqf* Û`^ lpl`f^iÍqi]hjcq](qi]nahecek(qi]apje](qi]j]k(qi]lpne](qiAop]`k( qi]dqi]je`]`a(iaoiko_kopqiao*=ooei(]bqjklneikn`e]h`]e`akhkce]l`riq^o] knecai`]ok_ea`]`a$nah] ao`alnk`qk_kiknah] aoajpnaiaeko`alnk`qkabkn]o lnk`qper]ook^]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk%(afppfjri^o]lnaoaj]`]hqp]`a_h]ooao$`ki)
040
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
!ERP!RQUIVOßDAßEDITORA
jekaatlhkn]k`kojklnklneapnekolahkolnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`alnk`qk%( jac]n]o`aoecq]h`]`aook_e]eo$okei]cej]`]o_kikoabkooai_kjoamqj_e]`ap]hajpko`e) banajpao(`]lnacqe]kq`]`eo_elhej]h]^kneko]%alcbob`bo]ei]caiehqo ne]`]_kiqje`]`a $kAop]`k%knecej]`]`k_kjpn]pkok_e]hajpnadkiajohernaoaecq]eo*=e`akhkce] ]hce_] `]`kiej]kok_e]halkhpe_]* Lknmqaj]o_aikoaokiko_ne]`ko_kiaoo]oe`ae]oajaooaei]cejnekok_e]h(jklan) _a^aiko]ran`]`aen]j]pqnav]`a_h]ooa`kAop]`k*=naolkop]oacqj`]lancqjp]`aI]nt( mq]hoaf](lknmqa]ok_ea`]`ajklan_a^akrj_qhkejpanjkajpnalk`ana_kjie_kalk`an lkhpe_k(lk`aoannaolkj`e`]]ckn]6lkn_]qo]`]e`akhkce]*
?]np]v`]=ooaookne] Aola_e]h`aNah] ao L^he_]o$=anl%`k ckranjkI`e_e $-525)-530%*
Lnteoanarkhqk Kpn]^]hdk
041
Mq]j`kaopq`]iko]pe_](reiko=neop pahaoaop]^aha_anqi]`eopejkmqabkei]j) pe`]jklajo]iajpkk_e`ajp]h6]`ebanaj]ajpnamlfbpfp(]kb]^ne_]`kn]$kpn]^]hdka]o p_je_]o%(amoufp$]]kherna`k]cajpaikn]ha`koqfaepklkhpe_k%*Reikop]i^imqa =neop pahaor]hknev]r]iqepki]eo]moufp`kmqa]mlfbpfp(kmqa_kilnaajorah*@ab]pk( ]ok_ea`]`acnac](j]mq]hrere]=neop pahao(an]ao_n]reop](`aor]hknev]j`kkpn]^]hdk_kik ]pere`]`aejbanekn(oa_kil]n]`]]kherna`k_e`]`k(eopk(`kolnklneapneko$`apann]( `k]npao]j]pka`k_kin_ek%*He^an`]`a(`eve]icnackoanki]jko(jklna_eo]nk_ql]n)oa _ki]o]pere`]`ao`aok^narerj_e](i]o`eolkn`a _ekl]n]_qe`]n`]_keo]l^he_]* K`aolnavklahkpn]^]hdk]l]na_aairnekooejpki]ooecjeÚ_]perko6jkd(j]hjcq] cnac](qi]l]h]rn]l]n]`aoecj]nqo^_^iel$qo])oa]l]h]rn]bodlk(Îk^n]Ï7kq]l]h]rn]ml* klp(Îaobknklajkoka`khknkokÏ%7]l]h]rn]h]pej]`]mq]hqo^_^iel`aner]qofm^ifrj(qi ejopnqiajpk`apnoaop]_]o(`aopej]`k]lnaj`an^keoa_]r]hko`eb_aeo`abann]n(lknp]jpk qiejopnqiajpk`apknpqn]*=kqpn]l]h]rn]h]pej]ailnac]`]l]n]`aoecj]npn]^]hdki^* _lo(mqa_knnaolkj`a]kcnackmlklp(lknp]jpkej`e_]Îlaj]Ï(Îb]`ec]Ï(Î_]jo]kÏ(Î`knÏ(a jaooaoajpe`kmqaoab]h]aiÎpn]^]hdk`al]npkÏ*Kodkiajohernao`eol ai`alqfrj$h]van% akojkhernaoaopkjkkbd*lqfrj$jac]k`a _ek(pn]^]hdk%* Klnkpaop]jpeoik(k_]lep]heoikakhe^an]heoikjklk`aii]jpanaoo]ei]cai`kdk) iaiherna_kikdkiai`aok_ql]`k(lknmqa(_kikreiko(b]vaik`enaepk`alnklnea`]`a nalkqo]nok^nakpn]^]hdkÍpn]^]hdk`a@aqo(b]vaj`kkiqj`k(lnklnea`]`a`k]npÚ_a`e) rejk7apn]^]hdk`kdkiai(ejopepqej`k]hacepeie`]`a`]lnklnea`]`alner]`]`koiaeko`a lnk`qk(eopk(`]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo`kpn]^]hdk*Kjac_ek]]hi]`k_]lep]heoik* Jkajp]jpk(]hck_qnekok]_kjpa_a*=lao]n`]r]hknev]k`kpn]^]hdka]lao]n`]e`ak) hkce]`k`enaepkj]pqn]h(mqa]Úni]oanaipk`kokodkiajohernaoaecq]eo(jkikiajpk`a `aÚjenmqaipai`enaepk]klk`anlkhpe_k(]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa(_kikreiko(bpnrb`b]Î`ecje) `]`a`kpn]^]hdkÏa`a_h]n]klk`anlkhpe_kqi`enaepkat_hqoerk`kodkiajoej`alaj`ajpao kqhernao(eopk(`komqajk`alaj`ai`akqpnkol]n]reran*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]_e`]`]je] lanpaj_a]komqajklna_eo]ipn]^]hd]n*@klkjpk`areop]ikn]h(r]hknev])oakpn]^]hdkÍ ahamqa`eo_elhej]ko]lapepaoa`aoafkoeik`an]`ko`kooanaodqi]jkoÍ(i]o(`klkjpk`a reop]lkhpe_k(jkpair]hkn]hcqi*J]lkhpe_](]moufp_kjpejq]oaj`k]cna_k)nki]j]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
I]nt_nepe_]]e`akhkce]`]moufphe^an]ha]_kj_alklnkpaop]jpa`kpn]^]hdk_kik aobknk(`eo_elhej]a_kjpnkhaikn]h`koej`er`qko*Koandqi]jkmoufp*Aop]ok_e]ha deop ne_]*kpn]^]hdk* Mqakpn]^]hdk; Kpn]^]hdk(_kikreiko]kaopq`]nk_kj_aepk`a_qhpqn](]nah]k`kooanaodqi]jko _ki]j]pqnav]aajpnaoe(j]lnk`qk`]o_kj`e ao`aoq]ateopj_e]*Lahkpn]^]hdk(kooa) naodqi]jkojk_kjokiai`enap]iajpa]j]pqnav]jaioa]lnklne]i`enap]iajpa`ah]( i]o]pn]jobkni]iai]hckdqi]jkp]i^i* = oq^fapere`]`a dqi]j] oa atlneia jqi k^fapk lnk`qve`k lkn ah] a ] k^fapere`]`a `k lnk`qpk ] i]pane]hev]k atpanj] `] oq^fapere`]`a `k pn]^]hd]`kn kq lnk`qpkn* Lahk pn]^]hdk( ko oanao dqi]jkoaopaj`ai oq] dqi]je`]`a j]pqnav]* jaooaoajpe`kmqak pn]^]hdkmoufp6]kaimqak]cajpaaklnk`qpk`aoq]]koke`jpe_ko(lkeok]cajpa oaatpaneknev]j]]klnk`qpkn]ajklnk`qpk(]kiaoikpailkmqaaopaejpaneknev]qi] _]l]_e`]`a_ne]`kn]dqi]j](kq]oq^fapere`]`a*
=e`akhkce]^qncqao]akpn]^]hdk Reikomqa(l]n]I]nt(jkoo]_kjo_ej_e]abqbojfk^a^lah]o_kj`e aodeop ne_]oai mqareraiko*Reikop]i^imqa(l]n]aha(kooanaodqi]jkob]vai]oq]ln lne]deop ne] $okkooqfaepkolnpe_ko`ah]%(i]ojk]b]vaiai_kj`e aoao_khde`]orkhqjp]ne]iajpa lknahao*EookoecjeÚ_]mqa]moufpoana]hev]ai_kj`e aodeop ne_]o`]`]oa(_kiko]^aiko( ]o_kj`e aooklkop]olah]afsfplpl`f^ialqo^_^iel(lah]oobi^ bpabmolar l$nah]k ajpnaiaeko`alnk`qkabkn]olnk`qper]o%(lknp]jpk(lah]bkni]`]lnklnea`]`aalah] `ereokok_e]h`]o_h]ooao* Reiko(ajÚi(mqa(ai^kn]]_kjo_ej_e]oaf]`apaniej]`]lah]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo aimqarera(]oe`ae]ojknalnaoajp]i]na]he`]`aq^i`ljlaoeiq^i`ljlm^ob`b(`]j`k ajoafk]koqnceiajpk`kfj^dfkoflpl`f^ia(_ki]`ereokajpnapn]^]hdki]pane]haejpaha_) pq]h(]koqnceiajpk`]fablildf^* Jk_]ok`kik`k`alnk`qk_]lep]heop](]e`akhkce](mqa^qncqao](qpehev]]e`ae]`k pn]^]hdk`a`q]oi]jaen]o*=lneiaen](_kikreiko(kailnack`aoo]e`ae]l]n]ibdfqfj^o ]lnklnea`]`alner]`]_]lep]heop]*=oacqj`](oaqqokl]n] ibdfqfj^o]e`ae]`a_kjpn]pk ok_e]ha`a_kjpn]pk`apn]^]hdk* ?kiabaepk(]e`ae]`a_kjpn]pkrai`k@enaepkNki]jk(mqaateca(l]n]r]he`]nqi] nah]k_kjpn]pq]h(mqa]ol]npao_kjpn]p]jpaooaf]ihernaoaecq]eo*L]n]]Úni]nmqa]ok) _ea`]`aakAop]`kj]o_ai`aqi_kjpn]pkok_e]h(]e`akhkce]^qncqao]lna_eo]]Úni]nmqa qlalpkodkiajoj]o_aihernaoaecq]eo(ai^kn]]j]pqnav]kob]]`aoecq]eoaip]hajpkoa ]ok_ea`]`akob]]`aoecq]eoa_kjkie_]iajpa*=e`akhkce]^qncqao]lna_eo](lknp]jpk(`] e`ae]`apn]^]hd]`knherna*Lknoq]rav(ko]hneko ]l]na_an_kikhacpeikoanaoqhp]n`aqi _kjpn]pk`apn]^]hdkajpnakoecq]eoahernao* Oacqj`kI]nt(k_]lep]heoik abaper]iajpa lnk`qveq k pn]^]hd]`knÎhernaÏ6 aopÎhe^a) n]`kÏ `a pk`ko ko iaeko a ejopnqiajpko `a lnk`qk( `a pk`]o ]o lkooao a lnklnea`]`ao( naop]j`k)hda]laj]o]Îhe^an`]`aÏ`araj`anoq]bkn]`apn]^]hdk*Kpn]^]hd]`knmqa]e`ak) hkce]`aoecj]_kikpn]^]hd]`knhernakpn]^]hd]`knna]hiajpaatlnklne]`k(k]oo]h]ne]`k oq^iape`konacn]o`kik`k`alnk`qk_]lep]heop](_kjraj_e`k`amqak_kjpn]pk`apn]) ^]hdkpknj]oaqo]hnekhac]h(hacpeikafqopk* =ooei(jqilneiaenkikiajpk(kmq]`nkkbana_e`klknI]ntlaooeieop]*Ai^kn]k oandqi]jkoaf]moufpaaop]oaf]kpn]^]hdk(klnk_aookdeop ne_k`aoÚcqn]kpn]^]hdkak pn]^]hd]`kn(]heaj]kopn]^]hd]`knao(mqa(jkoalan_a^aj`k_kikqi]_h]ooaok_e]h(jkoa na_kjda_aijkolnk`qpko`aoaqopn]^]hdko*=e`akhkce]^qncqao](lknoq]rav(_ne]]e`ae] `aDkiaiQjerano]h(hernaaecq]h(`)hdaknkopk`kolnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`a lnk`qkalanoq]`akopn]^]hd]`knao`amqap]i^iokaooaDkiaiQjerano]h(ai^kn] rer]iieoan]rahiajpa* Jkajp]jpk(oa]moufpok_e]hiajpa`apaniej]`](oa]_kjo_ej_e]`apaniej]`]la) h]o_kj`e aook_e]eo`kpn]^]hdk(jaipq`kaoplan`e`k*Lahk_kjpnnek*
042
=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne]x#!0É45,/ßx
?kjo_e j_e]`a_h]ooaalnteolkhpe_]
043
@ebanajpaiajpa `a kqpnko ik`ko `a lnk`qk( jko mq]eo ko pn]^]hd]`knao $ao_n]rko( oanrko a dkiajo lk^nao hernao% pn]^]hd]r]i eokh]`]iajpa a jk lk`e]i lan_a^an)oa bkn) i]j`kqi]_h]ooaok_e]h(jk_]lep]heoikej`qopne]h]o_kj`e ao`apn]^]hdk$]ob^ne_]o(]o cn]j`aoailnao]o_kian_e]eo(kocn]j`ao^]j_ko(ap_*%bkn]ikopn]^]hd]`knao]pn]^]hd]n fqjpkoa]_kjreranaioaqhk_]h`apn]^]hdk* Lk`ank(lkneook(ren]oalan_a^anai_kikqi_kjfqjpkok_e]h`apaniej]`k(eopk(_kik qi]`i^ppbpl`f^i(]ooei_kiklk`ankren]lan_a^anmqad_h]ooaook_e]eo_qfkoejpanaooaojk okkoiaoikoaoei_kjpnneko(alk`ankren]lan_a^anaioq]re`]`ene]mqakmqa]e`akhk) ce]hdaoajoej]_kikran`]`ab]hok*Lknatailhk(]e`akhkce]hdao`evmqaokhernao(i]ojk pihe^an`]`al]n]ao_khdankkb_ek(l]n]`aÚjenko]hnek(l]n]Út]n]fknj]`]`apn]^]hdk*= e`akhkce]hdao`evmqapk`kokodkiajookecq]eo(i]olan_a^aimqajklk`aipanikn]`e]( raopqnek(pn]jolknpa(a`q_]k(o]`a(_kikkooaqol]pn ao*=ooei(lah]oln lne]o_kj`e ao `aoq]moufp_kpe`e]j](pi_kj`e aol]n]_kia]n]`qre`]n`kmqahdao`epkaajoej]`k* Lk`ai(lkni(ren]oan_]l]vao`a]hcki]eo*K_]lep]hqi]lnklnea`]`alner]`]`eba) najpa`apk`]o]okqpn]omqaateopen]ij]deop ne]*@ab]pk(]okqpn]obkni]o`alnklnea`]`a `]r]inemqav]o]kooaqolnklneapneko(i]ojk`]r]ihq_nk*Kqoaf](]okqpn]obkni]o`a nemqav]jk_nao_e]ijaioa]_qiqh]r]i6l]n]d]ran_nao_eiajpka]_iqhk(an]lna_eok lehd]nkqnkq^]n]nemqav]`aqikqpnkdkiai(`aqikqpnknaejk(`aqikqpnklkrk*K_]le) p]h(lkni(pai]la_qhe]ne`]`a`a_nao_an(`a]_qiqh]n)oaanalnk`qven)oa*?kikhq_nkk^pe`k j]raj`]`kolnk`qpko`kpn]^]hdk(k_]lep]hoa]_qiqh](_nao_a(oa`aoajrkhraaoa]ilhe]* Mbi^mofjbfo^sbwk^efpqof^(oqncaqi]bkni]`]lnklnea`]`alner]`]_]l]v`a]qiaj) p]na`aoajrkhran)oa*Kopn]^]hd]`knaolk`anklancqjp]n6]Új]h(`akj`araiaoo]_]l]_e`]`a aol]jpko]`a_nao_eiajpk`k_]lep]h;@evaikoe`a hkckomqaaooa]qiajpkrai`k_kin) _ek(_qfkohq_nkookejraope`koj]lnk`qk*Jaooa_]ok(lknmqako_]lep]heop]ojkejraopai pq`kjk_kin_ek(airav`aejraopenlneknep]ne]iajpaj]ej`opne]aj]]cnkej`opne]; mqa(atlhe_]I]nt(khq_nkjkrai`]_kian_e]hev]k`kolnk`qpkol]n]k_kjoqik( j^pk^p`bk^momof^bpcbo^a^molar l(eopk(naoqhp]`]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdka`k pailkok_e]hiajpaja_aoonekl]n]lnk`qven]hcqi]_keo]* Kmqakik`k`alnk`qk_]lep]heop];=lnk`qk`aian_]`kne]o(eopk(`alnk`qpko _qfkr]hknjk`apaniej]`klknoaqqok(i]olahkoaqr]hkn`apnk_]*Aopa`apaniej]`k lahk_qopkpkp]hl]n]lnk`qvenqi]ian_]`kne]$_qopk`]i]pne])lnei](`koejopnqiajpko`a pn]^]hdk(`ko_kjda_eiajpkop_je_koa`koo]hneko%(_qopk_]h_qh]`k]l]npen`kqbjmlpl`f^i* jbkqbkb`bppofll]n]lnk`qve)h]$dkn]o`apn]^]hdk(dkn]o`apn]jolknpa(dkn]o`a`ao_]jok l]n]nalkoek`]obkn]o(dkn]oja_aoone]ol]n]]atpn]k`]i]pne])lnei]aoaqpn]jolknpa( dkn]oja_aoone]ol]n]]b]^ne_]k`]oimqej]oakqpnkoejopnqiajpko`apn]^]hdk(ap_*%* Mqailnk`qv]oian_]`kne]o;Kopn]^]hd]`knao]oo]h]ne]`ko(mqasbkabjoq]bkn]`a pn]^]hdk]kolnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`alnk`qk*?kik]oraj`ai;?kikqi] ian_]`kne]`ajpnakqpn]o*Mq]hklnk_a`eiajpkmqanacqh]]_kiln]araj`]`]bkn]`apn]) ^]hdk;K_kjpn]pk`apn]^]hdk(mqa(oaj`kqi_kjpn]pk(lnaooql amqa]ol]npao_kjpn]p]j) paooaf]ihernaoaecq]eo(a(lknp]jpk(mqalknhernaaaolkjp ja]rkjp]`amqakpn]^]hd]`kn raj`aoq]bkn]`apn]^]hdklahko]hnek* Kmqako]hnek;Kmqal]ck]kpn]^]hd]`knl]n]c]n]jpenoq]pr_pfpqk`f^a]obmol* ar labpr^clo ^abqo^_^iel$]heiajp]k(ikn]`e](raopqneka_kj`e aol]n]lnk_ne]n%* Mq]jpk r]ha ] jbo`^alof^*qo^_^ie^alo( eopk ( mq]jpk r]ha k o]hnek; = a_kjkie] lkhpe_] ]Úni] mqa k o]hnek _knnaolkj`a ]ko _qopko a ]k lnak `] lnk`qk `a qi] ian_]`kne]* ?]h_qh])oa(]ooei(kmqakpn]^]hd]`knlna_eo]l]n]i]jpan)oaanalnk`qven)oa(`a`qvej`k)oa aooaikjp]jpa`k_qopkpkp]h`]lnk`qka`apaniej]j`kko]hnek* J]na]he`]`a(lkni(jkkmqak_knna*L]n]lnk`qvenqi]`apaniej]`]ian_]`kne]( qipn]^]hd]`knlna_eo]`aqi_anpkjiank`adkn]o$oqlkjd]iko(lknatailhk(mq]pnk dkn]o%aoaqo]hnekoan_]h_qh]`k]l]npen`aooapailk7ajpnap]jpk(`ab]pk(kpn]^]hd]`kn pn]^]hd]`qn]jpaiqepki]eopailk$oqlkjd]iko(kepkdkn]o%a(_kjoamqajpaiajpa(lnk)
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
'ERMANOß,UDERS%DITORAß!BRIL
`qvk`k^nk`aian_]`kne]o7aop]o(lkni(jkok_kilqp]`]ol]n]k_h_qhk`ko]hnek( lkeoaopa_knnaolkj`an]laj]oian_]`kne]mqakpn]^]hd]`knlnk`qvaiqi_anpkj) iank`adkn]o$jkjkookatailhk(aimq]pnkdkn]o%*EookoecjeÚ_]mqakpn]^]hd]`knna]hev] i]eopn]^]hdk`kmqako]hnekhdal]c](kqoaf](dqiqo^_^ielbu`babkqbjkl]ck(eopk( jk_k^anpklahko]hnek*Aooalnk_a`eiajpkk_knnaaipk`]ej`opne](j]]cne_qhpqn]ajk _kin_ek(`ai]jaen]mqa]j^pp^pl`f^ialpp^ioflpabqlalplp^pp^i^of^alp_knnaolkj`a ]laj]o]rj^m^oqb`kpailkok_e]hiajpaja_aoonekl]n]]lnk`qk`]oian_]`kne]o(kq oaf](jk_knnaolkj`apkp]he`]`a`apailk`apn]^]hdk`eolaj`e`kna]hiajpalahkopn]^]) hd]`knao(mqalnk`qvaii]eo`kmqako]hnekhdaol]c]*=kqpn]l]npa`kpn]^]hdk(]mqa lani]ja_ajkl]c](bkni]qi]cec]jpao_]i]oo]ok_e]h`ai]eo)r]he]$kr]hkn`kpn]^]hdk at_a`ajpajkl]ck%*^j^fp*s^if^nrbcloj^lir`ol)bkl^`ljbo`f^ifw^ lalpmolarqlp+ Aaooahq_nkmqaoanejraope`kj]lnk`qk`aian_]`kne]ol]n]]qiajp]nk_]lep]h* =ooei(aoo]lnklnea`]`alner]`]aol]jpko](k_]lep]h(mqal]na_aice_]lknmqal]na_a _nao_anokvejd](]qiajp]j`k_kikoalkooqooaqibaniajpkejpanjk(j]na]he`]`aoa]_q) iqh]aoanalnk`qv(oa]ilhe]aoaaopaj`aiqj`k]bkn]lknmqaoabqj`]j]bumilo^ lpl`f^i a^j^pp^alp^pp^i^of^alp* Oakopn]^]hd]`knaolq`anai`ao_k^nen(lah]_kilnaajok`klnk_aook`apn]^]hdk(mqa kooajdknao`k_]lep]hk^pikhq_nklah]atlhkn]k`kpn]^]hdk(mqaoaikpn]^]hdkjk l]ckjkd]rane]_]lep]hamqa]e`akhkce]akAop]`k_]lep]heop]oateopail]n]eila`e)hko `ap]hlan_alk(oq]_kjo_ej_e]oan`lkeb`fjbkqlsboa^abfola^ob^ifa^abpl`f^i*Pank] _ej_e]`aoq]moufp* Oaperanaiaoo]_ej_e](oa_kjoacqenaiqjen)oaaknc]jev]n)oal]n]pn]jobkni]n]ok_ea) `]`aa_ne]nkqpn]oai]`ereoka]hqp]`a_h]ooao(l]oo]nklnteolkhpe_]*
Hejd]`aikjp]) caij]b^ne_]`a ]qpki raeoBe]p(ai >apei(Iej]oCan]eo*
=narkhqk Reopkmqa]^qncqaoe]`eol a`apk`kokona_qnokoi]pane]eo(ejpaha_pq]eo(fqn`e_ko(lk) hpe_koaiehep]naol]n]_kjoanr]nklk`aneka_kjie_kaaop]p]h(ah]^qo_]neila`en]moufp lkhpe_]`kopn]^]hd]`knaoaaopaojkpankkqpn]o]`]oajk]mqah]mqaoailnabkeqo]`] lah]o_h]ooaolklqh]naoejoq^ieoo]oan]`e_]eo6]narkhqk* = pakne] i]nteop] `] narkhqk jk oa _kjbqj`a( lknp]jpk( _ki ]o pakne]o qp le_]o a he^anpne]o(lknmqajkoa^]oae]j]ieone](j]ejbahe_e`]`aaj]ejfqope]]mqaaopkoq^) iape`kokopn]^]hd]`knao(i]ooabqj`]iajp]j]^kifpb`fbkqÛ`^`]ok_ea`]`a_]lep]heop] $j]oÎhaeoÏ `k _]lep]h kq `] a_kjkie] lkhpe_]% a jah] aj_kjpn] ]o i]jaen]o lah]o mq]eo ko pn]^]hd]`knao(_kjo_eajpaoaknc]jev]`ko(na]hev]ioq]ln lne]ai]j_el]k*Lkneook(I]nt
044
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
aAjcaho`eooan]imqa]ai]j_el]k`kopn]^]hd]`knaopan`aoank^n]deop ne_]`koln ) lnekopn]^]hd]`knao* =ok_ea`]`a_kiqjeop](oailnklnea`]`alner]`]`koiaeko`alnk`qk(oaiatlhkn]) k`kpn]^]hdk(oai_h]ooaook_e]eo(oailk`anaop]p]h(hernaaecq]hepne](naoqhp](lknp]jpk( `]moufpnarkhq_ekjne]`]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]* Jqi_ha^nal]jÛapklkhpe_k(kJ^kfcbpql`ljrkfpq^(mqa_kj_h]i]r]kolnkhapneko `kiqj`kpk`k]oaqjenaia]oaknc]jev]nail]n]]hkjc]hqp]_kjpn]k_]lep]h(I]ntaAj) caho_kjoe`an]r]imqa]c^pbÛk^i`k_ki^]palnkhapnekoane]]narkhqkamqaaop](]jpao `a_dac]nok_ea`]`a_kiqjeop](pane]`a`aikhenk]l]n]pkaop]p]h$fqn`e_k(^qnk_npe_k( lkhe_e]haiehep]n%^qncqo* Aoo]`aikhekbke`aoecj]`]lknahao_ki]atlnaookÎ`ep]`qn]`klnkhap]ne]`kÏ(pk) i]j`k]l]h]rn]afq^aro^`krk_]^qhneklkhpe_k`konki]jko*Aopao(pk`]ravmqaNki] ]pn]raoo]r]qi]_neoamqalk`ane]`aopnq)h](_kjrk_]r]iqidkiaiehqopnaahda`]r]i( lknqilank`k`apaniej]`k(klk`anl]n]nab]van]ohaeoalqjenkoejeiecko`aNki](na) pen]j`k)hdaklk`an]ooeimqa]_neoaaoperaooaoqlan]`]*Qi]`ep]`qn](j]hejcq]caiaj] lkhpe_] nki]j]o( oecjeÚ_]r] qi lk`an `a `qn]k `apaniej]`] kq `a _qnp] `qn]k* J] lanola_per]`aI]ntaAjcaho(]`ep]`qn]`klnkhap]ne]`koane]qi^naralank`k`apailk aimqa(jkateopej`k]ej`]]ok_ea`]`aoaiAop]`kafjkateopej`kkAop]`k^qncqo(ko lnkhapneko$lknp]jpk(qi]_h]ooaok_e]h%ckranj]ne]ipaj`kaireop]`aob]vanpk`kokoia) _]jeoikoa_kjie_koalkhpe_konaolkjoraeolah]ateopj_e]`a_h]ooaook_e]eoa(lknp]jpk( _]qo]`knao`]atlhkn]kok_e]h*Okiajpa`alkeo`a`aikhe`]]aopnqpqn]a_kjie_]_]lep]) heop]a]oqlanaopnqpqn]lkhpe_]afqn`e_]`kAop]`k_]lep]heop]mqaoane]]^khe`]]`ep]`qn] `klnkhap]ne]`k(`]j`kej_ekok_ea`]`a_kiqjeop]* Fqhc]r]I]ntmqaaoo]oane]] iqfj^narkhqklklqh]n*Lknmqa]hpei];Lknmqa]^k) hene]]`^rp^`apk`]o]onarkhq aomqa]o]jpaneknaojkd]re]i_kjoacqe`k]^khen6]lnk) lnea`]`alner]`]`koiaeko`alnk`qk*O ]ooeikpn]^]hdklk`ane]oanran`]`aen]iajpa moufpdqi]j]_ne]`kn]*
#APqTULOß =oatlane j_e]olkhpe_]o `ko_qhkTT =Narkhqk`aKqpq^nk
A 045
ikqpq^nk`a-5-3(_kjpn]pk`]atla_p]per]i]nteop](paihqc]n]NarkhqkNqoo](ok^ ]he`an]j]`kL]npe`k>kh_daremqa* LknmqaÎ_kjpn]pk`]atla_p]per]i]nteop]Ï;LknmqaI]ntfqhc]n]mqa]narkhqklnk) hapne]o lk`ane]na]hev]n)oamq]j`k]o_kjpn]`e aoejpanj]o]k_]lep]heoikaockp]ooai]o lkooe^ehe`]`aoa_kjie_]oalkhpe_]o`]^qncqaoe](aklnkhap]ne]`k(lkniaek`]narkhqk( ejop]qn]ooa]jkr]ok_ea`]`a_kiqjeop]*Aipanikoi]nteop]o(]narkhqklnkhapne]`ara) ne]]_kjpa_anjkol]oao`a_]lep]heoik]r]j]`k(_kik]Ejch]pann](]Bn]j](]=hai]jd]*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
@ab]pk(an]aooaj_e]hl]n]]pakne]`]moufpnarkhq_ekjne]klhajk`aoajrkhreiajpk `k_]lep]heoik(lkeoeookoecjeÚ_]r]mqa]ejbn]aopnqpqn]a_kjie_](k]r]jkpa_jkh ce_ka kcn]q`aknc]jev]k`]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]lnal]n]ne]i]cn]j`aiq`]j]deop ne_]*Jk an]_kj_a^rah(lknp]jpk(]narkhqkj]Nooe](mqarere]ok^k=jpeckNaceia$]ikj]nmqe] lkn`enaepk`erejk(]^okhqp]kq_v]neop]%(an]i]fknep]ne]iajpaln)_]lep]heop](_kilamqajk `aoajrkhreiajpk`k_]lep]heoikai]hcqjo_ajpnkoqn^]jko(lnkikre`kjklah]^qncqaoe] $mq]oa ejateopajpa%( i]o lahk ln lnek Aop]`k a lahk _]lep]h atpanjk $ejcho( bn]j_o a ]ha) ik%(oaibknpa_kjo_ej_e]aknc]jev]klnkhapne]o* Bke]he(lkni(mqa]_kjpa_aq]lneiaen]narkhqklnkhapne](]jpa_a`e`]lkn`q]onark) hq aoiajknao6]`a-5,1(mqaejop]qnkqkl]nh]iajpk(_kil]npe`kolkhpe_ko`]^qncqaoe] he^an]h(a]`abaranaenk`a-5-3(mqalnk_h]ikq]nal^he_]a_kjrk_kqqi]]ooai^hae]_kjo) pepqejpa(i]o_qfkckranjklnkreo nekjkna]hevkq]onabkni]olnkiape`]oalnkooacqeqj] cqann]_kjpn]]=hai]jd](lnkrk_]j`kna]klklqh]nana^ahek`]opnkl]o* J]o_en_qjop j_e]onqoo]o(kcn]j`aoqfaepknarkhq_ekjnekjkl`aoan]_h]ooalnkha) pne]knc]jev]`]$mq]oaejateopajpa%(i]opara`aoanqi]r]jcq]n`]lkhpe_](he`an]`]lkn ejpaha_pq]eo]_kopqi]`koohqp]o_h]j`aopej]o(kL]npe`k>kh_daremqakq]bn]ki]fknep) ne]`kL]npe`kOk_e]h)@aik_n]p]Nqook(mqaene]pknj]n)oakL]npe`k?kiqjeop]Nqook*Bkeaoo] r]jcq]n`]mqana]hevkq]Narkhqk`aKqpq^nk`a-5-3* Mqa`eÚ_qh`]`aoajbnajpkq]Narkhqk`aKqpq^nk; ]o`eÚ_qh`]`aolnareoraeo(mqapk`]narkhqk_kiqjeop]ajbnajp]ne](eopk(]na]k iehep]naa_kjie_]`k_]lep]h(j]bkni]`acqann]_ereha`a^ke_kpaa_kjie_kejpan) j]_ekj]h7 ]ateopj_e]`]Lneiaen]Cqann]Iqj`e]h(mqajko `al]qlankq]lna_ne]a_kjkie] nqoo](i]op]i^ilaniepeqmqakolk`anao_]lep]heop]oejpanj]_ekj]eoajre]ooaipnk) l]ol]n]]qtehe]n]_kjpn]nnarkhqk(k_d]i]`kAtn_epk`ko>n]j_ko(mqa_ki^]pe]k atn_epknarkhq_ekjnekkqkAtn_epkRaniahdk7 k bn]_]ook`] narkhqk _kiqjeop] ]hai( ai -5-5( `] mq]h oa aolan]r]jko ]lkek l]n]k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]ok_ea`]`aok_e]heop]nqoo](i]op]i^imqabkooakaopk) lei`]narkhqklnkhapne]iqj`e]h7aop](oak_knnaooa(hern]ne]]NarkhqkNqoo]`k eokh]iajpk( `k ^ke_kpa _]lep]heop] ejpanj]_ekj]h a `] ]ia]] lani]jajpa `a ejr]ok iehep]n_]lep]heop]7 ]]qoj_e]`abknpa_kjo_ej_e]lkhpe_]aknc]jev]kklanne]ojqil]oi]fknep]ne]) iajpa_]ilkjoajkmq]h]o]pere`]`aolkhpe_]opejd]ioe`kja_aoo]ne]iajpak^n]`a cnqlko_h]j`aopejko(bkni]`kook^napq`klknejpaha_pq]eoaaopq`]jpao*K_kjpejcajpa narkhq_ekjnek i]eo oecjeÚ_]perk mqa ko ^kh_daremqao _kjoacqen]i jk raek `k lnk) hap]ne]`kknc]jev]`k(i]o`]opnkl]o$atn_epkai]nejd]%na^ah]`]o_kjpn]]Lneiaen] Cqann]Iqj`e]h(eje_e]`]ai-5-0*=iehep]nev]k(ejareprahaipk`]narkhqk(jk_]ok `]NarkhqkNqoo]ejopepq_ekj]hevkq)oa_kikknc]jev]k`kL]npe`k>kh_daremqa7 ]]qoj_e]`aa_kjkie]_]lep]heop]`aoajrkhre`]mqadkqraooalnal]n]`k]ejbn]aopnq) pqn]a_kjie_]a]knc]jev]kok_eklkhpe_]l]n]]jkr]ok_ea`]`a*=narkhqkpara `a na]hev]n `q]o narkhq ao jqi] o 6 ] ^qncqao]( `a `aopnqek `k =jpeck Naceia( a ]_kiqjeop](_kjpn]]^qncqaoe]*Aoo]oepq]k(i]eo]nqj]a_kjie_]_]qo]`]lah] cqann]alah]_kjpejq]k`]cqann]_ereh(^ai_kikk^ke_kpa`k_]lep]heoikejpanj]) _ekj]h(k^nec]n]i]k_d]i]`kÎ_kiqjeoik`acqann]Ï(mqapn]jobknikq]Î`ep]`qn]`k lnkhap]ne]`kÏai`ep]`qn]`kL]npe`k>kh_daremqa*Aoo]`ep]`qn](aihqc]n`alnkikran koqnceiajpk`]ok_ea`]`a_kiqjeop](ejop]qnkqqi]jkr]bkni]ejaolan]`]`a_]le) p]heoik(k`^mfq^ifpjlabBpq^al(_kjoe`an]`kÎap]l]ok_e]heop]Ïl]n]]bqpqn]ok_ea`]`a _kiqjeop]*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]aop]pev]k`]a_kjkie]oq^opepqeq]]^khek`kAo) p]`k(lnareop]lahkJ^kfcbpql@ljrkfpq^*
05,
!LBUMß!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
%VERETTß#OLLECTION,ATINSTOCK
4ROTSKIß ßß INTELECTUALßMARXISTAßEßß REVOLUCIONfRIOßRUSSO
,ENINß ßREVO LUCIONfRIOßRUSSO ßLqDERßDOß 0ARTIDOß#OMUNISTAßEßPRI MEIROßPRESIDENTEßDOß#ON SELHOßDOSß#OMISSfRIOSßDOß 0OVOßDAß5NIjOß3OVImTICA
05-
$IVULGAljO
*ERRYß4AVIN%VERETTß#OLLECTION ,ATINSTOCK
3TALINß
=ooajdkn]j`k)oa`kAop]`k(kL]npe`k>kh_daremqa_nekqqilk`ankok]l]n]pkiehep]n a^qnk_npe_k(mqa(are`ajpaiajpa(ajpnkqai_kjÛepk_kiko_kjoahdkolklqh]nao`akla) nneko(_]ilkjaoaoaokh`]`ko(koplsfbqbp(lkeoaopaod]re]i)oaknc]jev]`kl]n]na]hev]nk ]qpkckranjk`aqi]ok_ea`]`aoaiAop]`k*Kookreapaobkn]ioaj`k`evei]`koaoq^opepq) `kolkn ncko`kL]npe`k>kh_daremqa(`ahaonaop]j`k]laj]okjkia(mqaoane]Î_kh]`kÏ]k `anal^he_]ok_e]heop]6Nal^he_]Ok_e]heop]Okrepe_]*=`ep]`qn]`kL]npe`k>kh_daremqaoa na]hev]r]lkniaek`k]l]n]pkiehep]n(lkhe_e]ha^qnk_npe_k`kAop]`k* Ai -5./( k L]npe`k >kh_daremqa aop]r] lnkbqj`]iajpa `ere`e`k ajpna ] lkoek `a PnkpogeÍmqa_nepe_]r]]^qnk_n]pev]kalnklqjd]]paoa`]obslir lmboj^kbkqbÍa ]`aOp]hej(mqa_kjoacqen]c]hc]nklkopk`aoa_napnek)can]h`kl]npe`k(]_qiqh]j`kajkn) iaolk`anaoaioq]oiko*@kajpa(Hajej(mqaaoperan]bnajpa`]narkhqk(ao_naraqqi paop]iajpklkhpe_kjkmq]hoqcane]k]b]op]iajpk`aOp]hej(]hanp]j`kl]n]klaneck`aoaq ]qpknep]neoik*Jkbke(lkni(]paj`e`k*Iknnaqaif]jaenk`a-5.0* R]haj`k)oa`k_]ncka_khk_]j`k]`enakl]npe`ne]_kjpn]Pnkpoge(Op]hej]ooqieqk lk`an`kAop]`k*Ok^oq]kneajp]k$ai^kn]Ú_]ooajko^]ope`knao%(]olnej_el]eohe`an]j]o `]narkhqkbkn]iatlqho]o`kl]npe`k7Pnkpogebke^]je`ka(ai-50,(]oo]ooej]`klknqi ]cajpaop]hejeop](jkIte_k* ?ki ] paoaÎok_e]heoik jqi o l]oÏ $lknp]jpk( klkop] paoa i]nteop] `k ejpanj]) _ekj]heoik lnkhapnek a `] narkhqk iqj`e]h%( Op]hej eilh]jpkq bkn] ] _khaperev]k `] a_kjkie]( ok^ ] `enak `k Aop]`k a `k l]npe`k* Atan_aq _kjpnkha iehep]n( lkhe_e]h a e`akh ce_kok^napk`]]ok_ea`]`a(ejopepqeqkÎ_qhpklanokj]he`]`aÏa(ai-5/2(_kia) kqkocn]j`aoatlqnckolkhpe_ko(_kjda_e`ko_kikÎlnk_aooko`aIko_kqÏ*Oailnajko ^]ope`knao(_kjoacqeqmqaoaqo]he]`kobknf]ooaipk`kpelk`a]_qo]k_kjpn]he`an]j]o lkhpe_]o`aklkoek(har]j`k)]o_kj`aj]k(iknpakqlneoklanlpq]ai_]ilko `a_kj_ajpn]k*Bknp]ha_aq]lkh_e]oa_nap]a_kjokhe`kqkpkp]hep]neoik$`amqab]h]na) iko]oacqen%* =hi `] _khaperev]k a_kjie_]( Op]hejlh]jafkq]a_kjkie]l]n]ejraope) iajpkoj]ej`opne]lao]`](o]_neÚ_]j`k ]lnk`qk`a^ajo`a_kjoqikakooan) rekol^he_kook_e]eo*Lnaraj`k]Oacqj) `]Cqann]Iqj`e]h(kneajpkq]a_kjkie] l]n]]ej`opne]^he_](mqie_]lao]`]a ajance] ahpne_]( lnk`qvej`k( _qop] `a ajkniaoo]_neb_ekoalner] ao`]lklq) h]k( k i]ekn _nao_eiajpk a_kjie_k `]deop ne]`]Nooe](mqaoapknjkqlk) pj_e]a_kjie_]aiehep]niqj`e]h*
?aj]`kbehiaKokhajc]j]`kn(`a -550(aimqak`enapknnqookJegep] Iegd]hgkratl a]`aokneajp]k `]lklqh]kokrepe_]j]`_]`]`a -5/,`e]jpa`]pen]je]`kop]hejeoik*
!LBUMß#INEMA,ATINSTOCK
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
=oatlane j_e]opkp]hepne]o6b]o_eoikaj]veoik
k ^kqfif_bo^ifpjl6 jk _kik ]Úni]k `k ok_e]heoik( a oei _kik `abao] `] pkp]h ej) panrajk `k Aop]`k j] a_kjkie] a j] ok_ea`]`a _ereh* Ai oq] b]_a eje_e]h( ]i^ko oa ]lnaoajp]i_kjpn]]kn`ai^qncqao]he^an]ha_kjoacqai]]`aok`]i]ekne]`]_h]ooa pn]^]hd]`kn](mqaokbne]]oieone]o`]na_aooka`k`aoailnack7 ]`li^_lo^ lab`i^ppb6]Úni]k`amqak_]lep]hakpn]^]hdkjkok_kjpnnekojai _kjpn]`ep neko( i]o lk`ai a `arai _kh]^kn]n ai d]nikje] l]n] k ^ai `] _khapere) `]`a*Jkhqc]n`]o_h]ooaook_e]eo(lnkl ai$a_ne]i%]o_knlkn] ao`akb_eka`a_]) packne](`amqal]npe_el]r]il]pn aoa]oo]h]ne]`ko(`aik`k]k_qhp]n]`ereokajpna k _]lep]h a k pn]^]hdk* = e`ae] `a Aop]`k ?knlkn]perk d]re] oe`k ah]^kn]`] lah] Ecnaf] _]p he_]aatlkop]j]^qh]`kl]l]HakTEEE(OborjKls^orj(ao_nep]_kjpn]ok_e]heop]o a_kiqjeop]o7 ^if^k ^`ljl`^mfq^ifkarpqof^ijlklmlifpq^bÛk^k`bfol6eopk(_kikooapknao`k_]le) p]h_qf]rk_]kfjmbof^ifpq^(atecej`k]_kjmqeop]`ajkrkopannep nekol]n]]]ilhe]) k`kian_]`kak]_iqhk`k_]lep]h7 k^`flk^ifpjl6]na]he`]`aok_e]h]j]k(ajpaj`e`]_kikqje`]`apannepkne]hae`ajpe) `]`an]_e]h(hejcqope_](`a_kopqiaoapn]`e ao*=j]kkaolnepk`klkrk(]mqof^* *jb`ko]jpal]oo]`ko`ao]jcqa(qj](je_]aej`ereo]7 `lomlo^qfsfpjl6]ok_ea`]`a(_kiklnklqjd]kl]l]HakTEEE(`araoanknc]jev]`]lahk Aop]`k ok^ ] bkni] `a _knlkn] ao `k pn]^]hdk a `k _]lep]h( dean]nmqev]`]o lkn oq]o bqj aoad]nikjev]`]olah]lkhpe_]a_kjie_]`kAop]`k7 m^oqfal kf`lnrblod^kfw^^pj^pp^p6aihqc]n`a_h]ooaook_e]eo(]j]kreop]_kik _kjopepq`]lahklkrkaaopa]i]oo]knc]jev]`]lahkl]npe`kje_k(mqa]atlneiaa nalnaoajp]*Kl]npe`kknc]jev]]ok_ea`]`ajko aioej`e_]pko_knlkn]perko(i]op]i)
!DOLFß(ITLERß ß LqDERßDOß0ARTIDOß.ACIONALß 3OCIALISTAß!LEMjO NAZISMOßESSAßPALAVRAßmß AßABREVIAljOßDOßNOMEßDEß UMßPARTIDOßPOLqTICOßAOß QUALß(ITLERßSEßFILIOUß)NICIAL MENTE ßOßPARTIDOßDENOMI NAVA SEß0ARTIDOß/PERfRIOß !LEMjO ßMASß(ITLERßPROPxSß QUEßFOSSEßDENOMINADOß 0ARTIDOß/PERfRIOß!LEMjOß .ACIONAL 3OCIALISTAß.ATIO NALSOZIALISTISCHEß°ß.AZI ß /PERfRIO ßPARAßINDICARßAß OPOSIljOßAOSßLIBERAIS ßMASß NACIONAL SOCIALISTAßPARAß INDICARßAßOPOSIljOßAOSß COMUNISTASßEßSOCIALISTASß CRqTICOSßDOßNACIONALISMOß PORßSERßESTEßUMAßIDEOLOGIAß NECESSfRIAßAOßCAPITAL !LBUM!KG IMAGES ,ATINSTOCK
K
o_qhkTT(`qn]jpako`a_jeko`a-5.,)-50,(req]_kjpa_anqi]atlanej_e]lkhpe_] oailna_a`ajpao6kpkp]hep]neoik(na]hev]`klkn`q]olnpe_]olkhpe_]o(kb]o_eoik $knecej]`kj]Ephe]%akj]veoikkqj]_ekj]h)ok_e]heoik$knecej]`kj]=hai]jd]%* ==hai]jd](`annkp]`]j]Lneiaen]Cqann]Iqj`e]h(lan`aqpannep nekoabkek^nec]`]] l]c]noki]orqhpko]o]koraj_a`knaol]n]naoo]n_e)hko`kolnafqvko`]cqann]*=a_kjkie] aop]r]`aopnk]`](naej]r]ik`aoailnack(]na_aooka]ejÛ]kc]hkl]jpa*=_neoa]ooq) ieqlnklkn ao_]p]opn Ú_]omq]j`k(ai-5.5(dkqra]mqa^n]$Î`o^peÏ%`]>kho]`aR]hknao `aJkr]Ukng(har]j`knqj]^k]l]npa`k_]lep]hiqj`e]h* L]npej`k`]_npe_]i]nteop]]khe^an]heoik(i]ona_qo]j`k]e`ae]`anarkhqklnkhapne] _kiqjeop](k]qopn]_k=`khbDephanoakbana_aq^qncqaoe]a_h]ooai`e]]haiol]n]o]hr)h]o `]narkhqkklanne]*Ahalnkloknaancqeiajpk`]=hai]jd]lkniaek`kbknp]ha_eiajpk`k Aop]`k(`kj]_ekj]heoikcaklkhpe_k$]j]kkÎaol]krep]hÏ`klkrk(mqa`ara_kjmqeop]na i]jpanpannep nekoja_aooneko]koaq`aoajrkhreiajpka_kjie_k%a`]]he]j]_kikooapk) nao_kjoanr]`knao`k_]lep]hej`qopne]haok^napq`k`k_]lep]hÚj]j_aenk*Dephanbkeahaepk(ai ahae aohernaoa`enap]o(l]n]kL]nh]iajpka(aioacqe`](`aqkckhla`aAop]`kj]veop]* =Ephe](ai^kn]aoperaooa`kh]`k`koraj_a`knao`]Lneiaen]Cqann]Iqj`e]h(Ú_kqej) o]peobaep]_ki]o_kilajo] aomqahdabkn]i`]`]oa(]kiaoikpailk(pajp]r]i]jpan)oa a_kjkie_]iajpalah]atlhkn]k`a_khje]oj]ãbne_]*>ajepkIqookheje(_kikDephan(l]n) peq`]_npe_]i]nteop]]khe^an]heoik(i]o(_kikDephan(na_qo]r]]e`ae]`anarkhqklnk) hapne]_kiqjeop]*Airav`ah](lnklokbknp]ha_eiajpk`kAop]`kj]_ekj]h(]]he]j]_ki oapknao_kjoanr]`knao`k_]lep]hej`qopne]haÚj]j_aenk(]cqann]`a_kjmqeop]`apannep neko akj]_ekj]heoik^]oa]`kj]och ne]o`k]jpeckEilnekNki]jk* Ai^kn]`aknecaiaoecjeÚ_]k`ebanajpao(k^wfpjlac^p`fpjllkooqai]ola_pko_k) iqjo6
"ENITOß-USSOLINIßß ßLqDERßDOßß 0ARTIDOß.ACIONALß&ASCISTAß NAß)TfLIA FASCISMOßAßPALAVRAßFASCIS MOßFOIßINVENTADAßPORß-US SOLINIßAßPARTIRßDOßVOCfBULOß ITALIANOßFASCIO ß±FEIXE²ßbß DUPLAßAßSIGNIFICAljOßDEßFAS CIOßPORßUMßLADO ßREFERE SEß AOßCONJUNTOßDEßMACHADOSß REUNIDOSßPORßMEIOßDEßUMß FEIXEßDEßVARAS ßCARREGADOSß PORßFUNCIONfRIOSßQUEßPRE CEDIAMßAßAPARIljOßP{BLICAß DOSßMAGISTRADOSßNAßANTIGAß 2OMA ßOSßMACHADOSßSIGNI FICANDOßOßPODERßDOß%STADOß PARAßDECAPITARßCRIMINOSOS ß EßASßVARAS ßAßUNIDADEßDOß POVOßROMANOßEMßTORNOßDOß %STADOßPORßOUTRO ßREFERE SEß AßUMAßTRADIljOßPOPULARßDOß SmCULOß8)8 ßEMßQUEßCERTASß COMUNIDADES ßLUTANDOß PORßSEUSßINTERESSESßEßDI REITOS ßSIMBOLIZAVAMßSUAß LUTAßEßUNIDADEßPELOSßFASCIß -USSOLINIßSEßAPROPRIAßDOß SqMBOLOßROMANOßEßPOPULAR ß CRIANDOßPORßTODAßAß)TfLIAßOSß FASCIßDEßCOMBATE
05.
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
^iai]ook_e] ao6`afkrajo(`aiqhdanao(`a_ne]j]o(`a]npeop]o(ao_nepknao(_eajpeo) p]o(`a^]ennk(`acejope_]a`]j](`aioe_](ap_*=nah]kajpna]ok_ea`]`a$]j]k% akAop]`kbaep]lah]ia`e]k`kl]npe`k7
(ULTONß$EUTSCHß#OLLECTION
fablildf^ab`i^ppbjaf^lrmbnrbkl*_rodrbp^6jkik`k`alnk`qk_]lep]heop](d qi]_]i]`]ok_e]hmqajklnkhapne])_]ilkjao](jai]lnklneapne]lner]`]`ko iaeko`alnk`qk(jai^qncqao]7pn]p])oa`]_h]ooai`e]kqlamqaj]^qncqaoe]( _kjopepq`] lkn _kian_e]jpao( lnkÚooekj]eo he^an]eo( ejpaha_pq]eo( ]npeop]o( ]npaoko ej) `alaj`ajpao a bqj_ekjneko l^he_ko* Aoo] _h]ooa ]`ana _kilhap]iajpa ]ko r]hknao a ]ko_kopqiao`]^qncqaoe]apaia]lnkhap]nev]k(oaj`klkneook]jpeook_e]heop]a]j) pe_kiqjeop]* Ai^kn] ]`iena ] ^qncqaoe]( naooajpa)oa lkn jk lkooqen ] nemqav] a ko lnerehceko^qncqaoao* ?kiabaepk(]_h]ooai`e]kqlamqaj]^qncqaoe]]_na`ep]jkej`ere`q]heoik_ki) lapeperk(j]e`ae]`kÎdkiaimqaoab]vokvejdkÏcn]]o`eo_elhej](^k]b]ihe](]ko ^kjo_kopqiaoa]kpn]^]hdk*I]o(]k_kjpnnek`aoq]oatla_p]per]o(jk_kjoacqa(]la) o]n`koaobknko(Îoq^enj]re`]Ï(anaolkjo]^ehev]]Î_k^e]`kone_koÏlknoq]oepq]k ejbaneknev]`](]pne^qej`k)]`aokn`ai`khe^an]heoik*Lknaoo]o_]n]_panope_]o(]_h]ooa i`e]kqlamqaj]^qncqaoe]_kjoanr]`kn]ana]_ekjne](paj`klna`ehaklknlnk) lkop]olkhpe_]omqahdalnkiap]iknc]jev]nkAop]`ka]a_kjkie]`ap]hik`kmqa `ao]l]na]ikhe^an]heoikakneo_k`kok_e]heoik)_kiqjeoik*k`aopej]pneklnere) hace]`kalnabane`k`kj]veoika`kb]o_eoik$a`apk`]o]olkhpe_]o]jpeook_e]heop]oa ]jpe_kiqjeop]o%7 fjmbof^ifpjl _bif`fpq^6 lah] ]he]j] _ki k _]lep]h ik) jklkheop] a Új]j_aenk( lah] e`akhkce] j]_ekj]heop] at) l]joekjeop](lah]e`akhkce]`a_h]ooai`e]kqlamqaj] ^qncqaoe](mqaaolan]`]o_kjmqeop]oiehep]naoiahdk) ne] `a oq]o _kj`e ao ok_e]eo( j]veoik a b]o_eoik ok lkhpe_]o`acqann]a`a_kjmqeop]*Dephanb]h]n`ko]j) cqacani je_kmqa_knnaj]orae]o`kolkrko`]Aqnkl] _ajpn]ha`aranoanÎna_kj`qve`kÏlpne])ia]hai lah]cqann]*Iqookhejeb]h]nj]och ne]o`kEilnekNk) i]jkaaioq]na_kjmqeop]lah]ocqann]oep]he]j]o7 bar`^ l jlo^i b `sf`^6 l]n] c]n]jpen ] ]`aok `]o i]oo]o e`akhkce] j]veb]o_eop]( k Aop]`k ejpnk`qv ] a`q_]k ikn]h a _re_]( lah] mq]h _ne]j]o a ]`khao) _ajpao ]lnaj`ank ko r]hknao j]veb]o_eop]o `a lpne]( `eo_elhej](bkn]`k_]npan(bkni]k`a_knlko^ahko( o]q`raeo( lk`ankoko( ja_aooneko ]ko cqannaenko `ko jkrkoeilneko7
?ne]j]qo]`]_kik i]o_kpa`kob]o_eop]oai qi_ki_ek`aIqookheje aiNki](ai-5/.*
05/
molm^d^ka^ ab j^pp^6 k j]veb]o_eoik ejpnk`qv( lah] lneiaen] rav j] deop ne]( ] lnpe_] $dkfa _kpe`e]j] a ^]j]h%`]lnkl]c]j`]`enece`]oi]oo]o*Aoo]lnkl]) c]j`]lkhpe_](rkhp]`]l]n]]i]jebaop]k`aoajpe) iajpko(aik aoal]et ao(`aor]hknev]j`k]n]vk(k lajo]iajpka]_kjo_ej_e]_npe_]*Lkniaek`kn`ek a`]eilnajo](`a_]np]vao(`aoÚhao(^]j`]o(fkcko]ph) pe_ko(Úhiao(kj]veb]o_eoiklnk_qn]ej_qpenj]i]oo] ]`arkkej_kj`e_ekj]hlpne]a]ko_dabao(k]ikn dean]nmqe](`eo_elhej]acqann]7
moqf`^a^`bkpro^ba^abi^ l6kAop]`k(]pn]ro`kl]npe`k(`]o]ook_e] aoa`a]l]na) hdkoaola_e]hev]`ko$lkhe_e]eoaiehep]nao%(_kjpnkh]klajo]iajpk(]o_ej_e]oa]o]npao
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
lkniaek`]_ajoqn](mqaei]j`khernkoak^n]o`a]npaÎ_kjpnnekoÏlpne]a]ko_dabao( lnaj`aj`kapknpqn]j`kko`eooe`ajpao(lanoacqej`kkoÎejeieckoejpanjkoÏ*Aopeiqh] p]i^i( ok^napq`k ai _ne]j]o a fkrajo( ] lnpe_] `] `ah]k _kjpn] ko `eooe`ajpao( Î`aore]jpaoÏaÎejeieckoejpanjkoÏ`kAop]`k7 o^`fpjl6iajkobknpajkb]o_eoik(qi_kilkjajpaaooaj_e]h`kj]veoik(mqaejrajp] ]e`ae]`aÎn]]]ne]j]ÏkqÎn]]j n`e_]Ï(oqlanekn]pk`]o]okqpn]o(`araj`k_kjmqeop]n ]hcqi]ol]n]mqa]oenr]ia]jemqeh]nkqpn]o(lknmqaÎejoanrraeoÏaÎlanecko]oÏ*=e`ae] `a]jemqeh]k`]oÎn]]oejbaneknaoÏb]v`kcajk_`ekqi]lkhpe_]`kAop]`k*Kj]veo) ik_kjoe`ankqkojacnko]bne_]jko(kolkhkjaoao(p_da_ko(djc]nko(nkiajko(_nk]p]o( onrekoa`ai]eo^n]j_koaqnklaqo_kikÎn]]oejbaneknaoÏ]oanai_kjmqeop]`]ol]n] na]hev]nkpn]^]hdk^n]]hl]n]]n]]oqlanekn*?kjoe`ankq_ec]jkoafq`aqo_kikn]]o ]oanaiaheiej]`]o$atpaniejkq_ec]jkoaoaeoiehd ao`afq`aqo%7 bpq^qfpjl6 _kjpn] k Aop]`k he^an]h $_kjoe`an]`k _] pe_k% a _kjpn] ]o narkhq ao ok_e]) heop]oa_kiqjeop]o$mqana_qo]ikAop]`k%(kj]veb]o_eoik_ne]kAop]`kbknpa(_ajpn]) hev]`k]`iejeopn]per]iajpa(iehep]nev]`k(mqa_kjpnkh]pk`]]ok_ea`]`alkniaek`k l]npe`k(`]oieh_e]o`afkrajo(`]a`q_]kikn]ha_re_](`]lnkl]c]j`](`]_ajoqn]a `]`ah]k*Ateopa]laj]okAop]`k_kikpkp]he`]`amqaajchk^]aioaqejpaneknkpk`k `]ok_ea`]`a* Pkp]hep]neoik( lknp]jpk(oecjeÚ_]Aop]`kpkp]h(mqa]^oknraaioaq ejpanekna ai oq]knc]jev]kkpk`k`]ok_ea`]`aaoq]oejopepqe ao(_kjpnkh]j`k)]lknejpaenk* Kj]veb]o_eoiklnkhebankqlknpk`]l]npa*Bkerepknekokjk]laj]oj]Ephe]aj]=hai]) jd](i]o(_kir]ne] ao(pkikqklk`anj]Aol]jd]$`aBn]j_k%(aiLknpqc]h$_kiO]h]v]n% aairnekol]oao`]Aqnkl]kneajp]h* ?kjoacqeqpanl]npe`kooecjeÚ_]perkoail]oao_kikBn]j](Ejch]pann](>hce_](ãqopne]( =ncajpej]*Jk>n]oeh(`aqknecai=kEjpacn]heop]>n]oehaen](_ne]`]lknLhjekO]hc]`k*
A
i^kn]kpkp]hep]neoiknqookaopaf]hec]`kej`eookhqrahiajpa]kjkia`aOp]hej(eook jkoecjeÚ_]mqapajd]paniej]`k_kioq]iknpa* =p]_d]i]`]di^pklpq$Îpn]jol]nj_e]Ï%(lnklkop]jko]jko-54,lknIegd]ehCkn^]_dar( ateopeqkop]hejeoikoaiOp]hej(kqoaf](kpkp]hep]neoikj]at)QjekOkrepe_]* Iqepkopn]ko`kop]hejeoikokoaiahd]jpao]ko`kj]veb]o_eoik$_ajpn]hev]kaop]p]h( l]npe`k je_k _ki _kjpnkha pkp]h ok^na ] ok_ea`]`a( iehep]nev]k( j]_ekj]heoik( eilane]) heoik(_ajoqn]`klajo]iajpka`]atlnaook(lnkl]c]j`]aop]p]hjkhqc]n`]ejbkni]k( _]ilko`a_kj_ajpn]k(ejrajk_kjpjq]`koÎejeieckoejpanjkoÏ%(i]o]`ebanaj]bqj) `]iajp]hapnce_]ajpnaahaoaopjkb]pk`amqakop]hejeoikoqbk_kq]lneiaen]narkhqk _kiqjeop] a `abknikq lnkbqj`]iajpa k i]nteoik( i]n_]j`k _ki k oahk pkp]hepnek ko l]npe`ko_kiqjeop]o`kiqj`kejpaenk* =ocn]j`aopaoao`aI]ntbkn]i`aopnq`]olah]opaoaoop]hejeop]o6 paoai]nteop]`]narkhqklnkhapne]iqj`e]h(kop]hejeoik_kjpn]lo]paoa`kok_e]heo) ikjqio l]o(pn]jobkni]j`k)]ai`enapnevk^nec]p ne]l]n]kol]npe`ko_kiqjeop]o`k iqj`kejpaenk*EookoecjeÚ_kqmqap]eol]npe`ko`arane]i]^]j`kj]nlnpe_]onarkhq_ek) jne]oaioaqol]oaol]n]jklnafq`e_]n]onah] aoejpanj]_ekj]eo`]QjekOkrepe_]* An]iaopeiqh]`]o(lkni(]ocqann]o`ahe^anp]kj]_ekj]h_kjpn]kol]oao_khkje]heop]o oailnamqaeookbkooa`kejpanaooaa_kjie_kacaklkhpe_k`kookrepe_ko7 paoai]nteop]`]`ep]`qn]`klnkhap]ne]`kl]n]]`annq^]`]`kAop]`k(kop]hejeoik _kjpn]lo]`ep]`qn]`kl]npe`kje_ka`kAop]`kbknpa7
GLASNOSTßEßPERESTROIKAßOß CONCEITOßDEßGLASNOSTßSEß ASSOCIAßAßLIBERDADEßDEßß EXPRESSjOßEßABERTURAßß POLqTICAßNAßEX 5NIjOßß 3OVImTICAß0ERESTROIKAßß ±REESTRUTURAljO² ßSEßß ASSOCIAßgßABERTURAßß ECONxMICA !LBUM!+' )MAGES,ATINSTOCK
Kpkp]hep]neoikop]hejeop]
-IKHAILß'ORBACHEVß ß FOIßOß{LTIMOßSECRETfRIO ß
GERALßDOß0ARTIDOß#OMU NISTAßDAß5NIjOß3OVImTICA
050
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
paoai]nteop]`]]^khek`kAop]`kj]ok_ea`]`a_kiqjeop]oai_h]ooaook_e]eo(_kj) pn]lok]cec]jp]iajpk`kAop]`k(]]^oknk`]ok_ea`]`alahk]l]nahdkaop]p]hala) hko ncko`kl]npe`k(_qf]^qnk_n]_e]_kjopepqeq)oajqi]jkr]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa(_ki ejpanaooaoalnerehcekoln lneko7 paoai]nteop]`]hqp]lnkhapne]_kjpn]]^qncqaoe]a]lamqaj]^qncqaoe](^ai_kik `]]Úni]k`amqa(aiiqepkolnk_aookonarkhq_ekjneko(l]npa`]^qncqaoe]a`]la) mqaj]^qncqaoe]oa]he]i]klnkhap]ne]`ki]ok]^]j`kj]i]l]npen`a_anpklkjpk( `araj`kahalnkooacqenokvejdkj]]knarkhq_ekjne](kop]hejeoik_kjpn]lo]paoa klknpqjeop]`]Îaopn]pce]Ïa`]Îppe_]Ï(oacqj`k]mq]h(ai_anpko_]oko(klnkhap]ne]`k b]ne]]he]j]oajah]olani]ja_ane]a(aikqpnko(jkb]ne]]he]j]]hcqi](oaeookjk bkooa`kejpanaooa`]r]jcq]n`]l]npe`ne]7 paoai]nteop]`kejpanj]_ekj]heoiklnkhapnek$ÎLnkhapneko`apk`kokol]oao(qje)rkoÏ( `eve]kJ^kfcbpql@ljrkfpq^%(_kjpn]lokj]_ekj]heoikakeilane]heoiknqooko(lne) iaenkejr]`ej`ka`kiej]j`k]Aqnkl]kneajp]ha`alkeokol]oao]oepe_kojk`kie) j]`kolah]?dej]7 paoai]nteop]`kl]npe`klkhpe_k_kikejopnqiajpk`aknc]jev]k`]_h]ooapn]^]) hd]`kn] a atlnaook lnpe_] `a oq]o e`ae]o a hqp]o( _kjpn]lo ] ^qnk_n]_e] l]npe`ne] _kikr]jcq]n`]lkhpe_](mqajko Înalnaoajp]Ïkoejpanaooaolnkhapnekoi]okoaj) _]nj]ako`ena_ekj](lkeo`apajpkn]`klk`ana`ko]^an7 paoai]nteop]`]nah]kej`eookhrahajpna]oe`ae]oa]o_kj`e aoi]pane]eo(eopk( ajpnapakne]alnpe_](mqalaniepe]k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]_kjo_ej_e]_npe_]`]_h]ooa pn]^]hd]`kn](_kjpn]lo]lnkl]c]j`]aop]p]h(]e`akhkce]`k_daba_kikÎl]e`kolk) rkoÏ(k_kjpnkha`]a`q_]ka`koiaeko`a_kiqje_]klahkl]npe`kalahkAop]`k7 paoa`aI]nt`amqa]pakne]a]lnpe_]aopkjqi]nah]k`e]hpe_](mqak_kjda_e) iajpkdeop ne_kaqilnk_aookejpaniejrah`a]jheoaa_kilnaajok`]o_kj`e ao _kj_nap]olkop]olah]na]he`]`aok_e]h(kop]hejeoik_kjpn]loqi]ejrajk(kAf^j^q $i]pane]heoik`e]hpe_k%(eopk(ki]nteoik_kikalrqofk^])deop ne_](Út]`]ai`kc) i]oatlkopkook^]bkni]`a_]pa_eoiko`arqhc]nev]k`]e`akhkce]op]hejeop]*Bkepk hkjcajeook(mqa_kjoe`ankqbqjk`kAop]`k`aÚjenkmbkp^jbkql`loobql* L]n]p]jpk(koejpaha_pq]eo`kl]npe`kbkn]iaj_]nnac]`ko`a`apaniej]n]ohejd]o Î_knnap]oÏl]n]]ÚhkokÚ](]o_ej_e]oa]o]npao*Ejopepqeq)oa]loe_khkce]kÚ_e]h(]ia`e) _ej]a]cajpe_]kÚ_e]eo(]hepan]pqn](]lejpqn](]ioe_]ak_ejai]kÚ_e]eo(]ÚhkokÚ]a ]_ej_e]kÚ_e]eo(aj_]nnac]j`k)oa]lkh_e]oa_nap]`amqaei]nk^n]o(lnaj`an(pknpqn]n( ]oo]ooej]nkqajre]nl]n]_]ilko`a_kj_ajpn]kkoÎ`eooe`ajpaoÏkqÎ`aore]jpaoÏ*Ko dan`aenko`aOp]hejbkn]ii]eohkjca6_kjoe`an]n]imqa(_kikkl]npe`kakAop]`k`e) vai]ran`]`a]^okhqp](koÎ`aorekoÏejpaha_pq]eo(]npope_koalkhpe_koan]ioejpki]o`a `eopn^ekolomqe_koa`ahkq_qn](aajre]r]i(lkneook(koÎ`eooe`ajpaoÏl]n]dkolep]eo loemqepne_ko7 paoai]nteop]`amqa]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]oqfaepk`aoq]ln lne]deop ne]mq]j`k pki] _kjo_ej_e] `a oq] oepq]k a hqp] _kjpn] ah]( ]lnaj`aj`k _ki ] iai ne] `ko _ki^]paoa]pn]`ek`]o`annkp]o(kop]hejeoik_kjpn]lo]e`ae]`adeop ne]kÚ_e]h`] _h]ooalnkhapne](e`ajpeÚ_]`]_ki]deop ne]`kL]npe`k?kiqjeop]a_ki]ejpanlnap]) k`]`]lknaopahpeik]ko]_kjpa_eiajpkodeop ne_ko(nkq^]j`k]ooei`kopn]^]hd]) `knaok`enaepkiai ne]7
051
paoai]nteop]`amqakoejeiecko`]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]jkokej`er`qko`aoo]kq `]mqah] _h]ooa( i]o `a qi] kqpn] _h]ooa ok_e]h ajmq]jpk _h]ooa( _kjpn]lo ] e`ae] `a Îejeiecko`klkrko]`ko`koaek`kln lneklkrkÏ_kikejeiecko`aoq]ln lne]_h]ooa( lknmqaokÎ]cajpaoaopn]jcaenkoejÚhpn]`kojkoaek`klkrkqjk(ej`ereok(^kiadk) ikcjakÏ7
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
paoa`aI]nt`]jkr]ok_ea`]`a_kik_kj_napev]k`]he^an`]`a(`]ecq]h`]`a(`] ]^qj` j_e]( `] fqope] a `] bahe_e`]`a( k op]hejeoik _kjpn]lo kÎklannek ik`ahkÏ a kÎiehep]jpaatailh]nÏ(]_kopqi]`kok^a`ej_e]_ac]]ko_ki]j`ko`kAop]`ka`k l]npe`kadean]nmqe]ok_e]heilkop]lknahao*Reran mbilam^o^kAop]`kakl]npe`k pknj]n]i)oaoejjeiko`abahe_e`]`a(he^an`]`aafqope]* =pn]jobkni]k`]oe`ae]oalnpe_]oop]hejeop]oaifkpqfqrf bppl`f^fpbav_kimqak op]hejeoikjkbkooaqi]_kjpa_eiajpk`aoqlanb_ea(mqalq`aooaoan]l]c]`k_ki]ikn) pa`aOp]hej*Lahk_kjpnnek*Kop]hejeoikejopepqeqqi]jkr]cloj^ lpl`f^i(mqaik`ahkq _knlko(_kn] aoaiajpaoamqao `ao]l]na_aq(l]n_e]hiajpa(jkÚi`ko]jko-54,aej_ek `ko]jko-55,(lknmqa]_neoaa_kjie_](lnkrk_]`]lahk`ahnek]ni]iajpeop](bavaiance) nai_kjpn]`e aooqbk_]`]o`qn]jpaoapajp]]jko*
=ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]
@
keo]_kjpa_eiajpkolkhpe_koi]n_]n]iklank`klkopaneknOacqj`]Cqann]Iqj) `e]h6]drboo^cof^akoqnceiajpk`kBpq^alal?bj*Bpq^oPl`f^i$Tbic^obPq^qb%(kq] ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]*JkÚj]h`ko_qhkTT(ejop]hkq)oakjakhe^an]heoik*
=drboo^cof^bke]`ereokcaklkhpe_](a_kjie_]aiehep]najpna`keocn]j`ao^hk_ko6 k^hk_k_]lep]heop](ok^]`enak`koAop]`koQje`ko$ej_hqej`k]opno=ine_]o(]Aqnkl] K_e`ajp]ha]o_khje]oaqnklae]oj]ãbne_](jkKneajpaI`ekaj]ãoe]%(ak^hk_k_kiqjeo) p](ok^]`enak`]QjekOkrepe_]a`]?dej]$ej_hqej`kkol]oao`]Aqnkl]?ajpn]ha`k Haopa%*Qi]`]olnej_el]eon]v aol]n]aoo]`ereokbkeiehep]n(eopk(]ejrajk`]^ki^] ]pie_]( mqa ]hpan]r] `a ik`k ennaranorah ] j]pqnav] `ko ]noaj]eo ^he_ko( lkj`k Úi o cqann]o_kjraj_ekj]eo* K oi^khk `aoo] cqann] bke ] `ereok `] =hai]jd] ai L`fabkq^i( k_ql]`] lah]o bkn]o iehep]nao _]lep]heop]o `] _d]i]`] Knc]jev]k `k Pn]p]`k `k =ph jpe_k Jkn) pa $Kp]j%( a Lofbkq^i( k_ql]`] lah]o bkn]o okrepe_]o `k _d]i]`k L]_pk `a R]no re] $eopk ( `ko l]oao `] Aqnkl] kneajp]hoq^iape`koQjekOkrepe_]%*Aooaoi^khk_kj) _napevkq)oajkÎIqnk`a>anheiÏ(]iqn]hd]ancqe`]lahko nqookol]n]eila`en]l]oo]cai`ko]haiao`]=hai]jd] Kneajp]hl]n]]K_e`ajp]hal]n]_kjpnkh]n]ajpn]`]ao]`] `alaook]o`]=hai]jd]K_e`ajp]hl]n]]Kneajp]h* Eje_e]hiajpa(_]`]^hk_kfqhc]r]mqa]lkooa`a]ni]) iajpkojq_ha]naohda`]ne]i]eolk`anl]n]aheiej]nkkq) pnk*Lkq_k]lkq_k(lkni(]_d]i]`]Î_knne`]]ni]iaj) peop]Ï `aetkq `a reo]n `enap]iajpa cqann]( rkhp]j`k)oa l]n] ] ejpeie`]k na_lnk_] `ko ]`ranoneko( heiep]j`k oq]o] aoeilane]heop]o*Bej]hiajpa(lan_a^aq)oamqaqi] cqann] jk _kjraj_ekj]h kq jq_ha]n pane] naoqhp]`k vank( kqoaf](jkpane]raj_a`knao(lkeoklh]jap]oane]ejpaen]) iajpa `aopnq`k* = cqann] pane] `a oan( lknp]jpk( cqann] bne]Íaolekj]cai(Új]j_e]iajpk`acqann]ohk_]hev]`]o( ]lkek okrepe_k ] cqann]o ]jpe_khkje]eo( `aoaop]^ehev]k jknpa)]iane_]j]`anaceiaook_e]heop]oejopepq`koj]na] `alk`an`koAop]`koQje`ko(ap_*=cqann]bne]`aÚjeq(lkn mq]oa_ejmqajp]]jko(k]hejd]iajpklkhpe_kaa_kjie) _k`apk`kokol]oaorkhp]`ko`keo^hk_kodacaije_ko*
?aj]`kbehia R]ilenko`a]hi]o( `a-512(`enece`klkn @kjOeacah*@qn]jpa ]l]n]jke]]jpe_k) iqjeop]j]`_]`] `a-51,(kobehiao`a be_k_eajpbe_]lnk) `qve`kojkoAop]`ko Qje`ko]ook_e]r]i] atl]jokokrepe_]] ejr]o aoi]n_e]j]o* $IVULGAljO
=cqann]bne]
052
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
Ok^]]k`aIegd]ehCkn^]_dar(]cqann]bne]paniejkq_kikÚi`knaceiaokrepe_k( _ki]di^pklpqb]mbobpqolfh^oaj`keilhaiajp]`]o*J]ran`]`a(knaceiapaniejkq_kik _kjoamqj_e]`]nqj]a_kjie_]`]QjekOkrepe_](mqajko i]jparalh]jkoa_kjie) _kohec]`koej`opne]^he_](_kikjk`aoajrkhraq]ojkr]opa_jkhkce]o`alkjp]atece`]o lah]an]`]ahapnje_]a`]ejbknipe_]*K]pn]oka_kjie_k(]ohqp]onacekj]eolknej`alaj) `j_e]$lknl]npa`kol]oao]jat]`ko]k^hk_kokrepe_k]l o]Oacqj`]Cqann]Iqj`e]h%( ] aop]cj]k ok_e]h a _qhpqn]h( ]o _kjpn]`e ao ejpanj]o ok_ea`]`a okrepe_]( ]o ]ia]]o _kjpjq]o`acqann]_ki]?dej](]iq`]j]j]bkni]`k_]lep]h$k]`rajpk`k_d]i]`k kblif_bo^ifpjl%a]dacaikje]e`akh ce_]_]lep]heop]bkn]i]hcqjo`kob]pknaomqahar]n]i lkhpe_]`aCkn^]_dara]k`aoi]jpah]iajpkl]n_e]h`kpkp]hep]neoikop]hejeop]*
!LBUM!KG IMAGES,ATINSTOCK
=ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]akAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h
*OHNß+EYNESß
@ao`aiqepk_a`k(ajpnakoi]nteop]o(oqnceqqi]ej`]c]k6]l]oo]cai`k_]lep]heo) ik]k_kiqjeoik`arane]oanbaep]ja_aoo]ne]iajpalknqi]narkhqkkqlk`ane]oanna]) hev]`]lknqi_kjfqjpk_nao_ajpa`anabkni]o(_ki]omq]eoklk`anl]oo]ne]`]oiko`] ^qncqaoe]l]n]]o`klnkhap]ne]`k;=`eo_qookÎnabkni]kqnarkhqk;Ï`aqknecaie`ae] `aap]l]odeop ne_]ol]n]]l]oo]cai]k_kiqjeoik7]lnej_el]h`aoo]oap]l]oan]kok_e]heo) ik(ajpaj`e`k_kikl]oo]caicn]`q]h]k_kiqjeoiklkniaek`anabkni]ojk_]lep]heo) ik*=lkhpe_]ok_e]heop]an]lnklkop]lknl]npe`komqaoa`ajkiej]r]ipl`f^i*abjl`o^q^p( oaj`k]atlnaookÎok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]Ïej`e_]`kn]`]lkhpe_]`]aomqan`]nabknieop]* Ai^kn](]jpao`]Oacqj`]Cqann](rne]oatlanej_e]o`apelkok_e]h)`aik_n]p]pajd]i oe`kna]hev]`]ojkol]oaoao_]j`ej]rko$Oq_e](@ej]i]n_]%aj]Ejch]pann]$_kikL]npe`k Pn]^]hdeop]%(lk`a)oab]h]njqi]lnaoaj]i]eoÚniaa]ilh]`]ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]_kik lkhpe_]`]aomqan`]nabknieop]okiajpa]l]npen`kÚj]h`]mqah]cqann](lknp]jpk(]l]npen `kÚj]h`ko]jko-50,*Lknaoo]k_]oek(]ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]ejopepqeq)oa_kiklkhpe_]`k Aop]`k`a>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h$Tbic^obPq^qb%(eilh]jp]`kjkol]oao_]lep]heop]o]r]j]`ko`k daieobnekjknpa_kik`abao]`k_]lep]heoik_kjpn]klaneck`knapknjk`kj]veb]o_eoika `]narkhqk_kiqjeop]* =_neoaa_kjie_]can]`]lah]cqann](]o_npe_]oj]veb]o_eop]a_kiqjeop]]khe^an]heo) ik(]ohqp]o`kopn]^]hd]`knaolkn`enaepkoa_kjie_koaok_e]eobqj`]`]oj]ei]cai`] ok_ea`]`aok_e]heop]ai_kjopnqkj]QjekOkrepe_]aj]?dej](b]vaj`k_kimqakopn]) ^]hd]`knaoaj_kjpn]ooaijah]o$ecjkn]j`kkmqa]hena]hiajpaoal]oo]r]%qi_kjpn]lkjpk l]n]]o`aoecq]h`]`aoaejfqope]o`k_]lep]heoik(pq`keookharkqja_aooe`]`a`anabkni]n ]a_kjkie]a`a]hpan]n]]k`kAop]`k(_knnecej`kkolnk^hai]oa_kjie_koaok_e]eo*= aoo]p]nab]`a`e_kq)oa]ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]lkniaek`kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h$p]i^i _d]i]`k`aAop]`kLnkre`j_e]%* Ejolen]j`k)oaj]oe`ae]o`ka_kjkieop]ejchoFkdjGaujao(]ok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]l]ookq ]_ki^]pan]]j]nmqe]a_kjie_]he^an]hlkniaek`kAop]`k*Aopa(aihqc]n`aoankn^epnk `a _kjÛepko( lkop]`k ]_ei] `] ok_ea`]`a _ereh $ i]jaen] he^an]h%( l]oo] ] fkqbosfo j] a_k) jkie](ejraopej`kaiej`opne]oaop]p]eo(oq^oe`e]j`kailnao]olner]`]oj]ej`opne](j] ]cne_qhpqn]ajk_kin_ek(atan_aj`k_kjpnkhaok^nalnako(o]hnekoap]t]o`afqnko*=ooq) ial]n]oeqi_kjfqjpk`aaj_]nckook_e]eokqoanrekol^he_ko(ajpaj`e`ko_kikafobfqlp pl`f^fpnaerej`e_]`kolah]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn]6o]`a(a`q_]k(ikn]`e](pn]jolknpa(lnare) `j_e] ok_e]h( o]hnek)`aoailnack( o]hnek)b]ihe]( ap_* =hi `ko `enaepko ok_e]eo( p]i^i ]paj`aabj^ka^pab`fa^a^kf^mliqf`^(_kikkoqbncekqjerano]h$lkeoaopaan]ln]pe_]`k ailkq_kol]oao(iaoikko`epko`aik_npe_ko%* =a_kjkie]lkhpe_]mqaoqopajp]r]kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]hlkooq](dolppljlal( pno_]n]_panope_]olnej_el]eo6 -*
053
kbkn`eoikj]lnk`qk(eopk(]ocn]j`aoÎlh]jp]oej`qopne]eoÏmqana]hev]r]i]]pere`]`a a_kjie_]`ao`a]lnk`qk`]i]pne])lnei]]poq]`eopne^qekjkian_]`k`a^ajoa `a_kjoqik(_kjpnkh]r]i(lkniaek`klh]jaf]iajpka`]_d]i]`]Îcanj_e]_eajpÚ_]Ï( ]knc]jev]k`kpn]^]hdk(]lnk`qk`acn]j`aoaopkmqaoak_kjpnkha`kolnako7
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
]ej_hqok_nao_ajpa`koej`er`qkojkian_]`k`apn]^]hdk(kneajp]j`k)oalah]e`ae]`a lhajkailnack7
/*
ikjklhekoakhecklhekomqa(ai^kn]pn]joj]_ekj]eokqiqhpej]_ekj]eo(pejd]i_kik nabanj_e]nacqh]`kn]kAop]`kj]_ekj]h*L]n]mqaaoo]a_kjkie]na]hev]ooak^ai)aop]n( bkelna_eokmqakAop]`kjah]ejpanreaooa_kikobdri^aloa_kikm^o`bfol(kmqabkebaepk lah]_ne]k`kbqj`kl^he_k* ?kikklan]kbqj`kl^he_k; ?kikatlhe_]kok_e hkckaa_kjkieop]^n]oehaenkBn]j_eo_k`aKheraen](jkhernkLp afobfqlpal^kqfs^iloÍ>b`lkljf^mliqf`^a^ebdbjlkf^fjmbocbfq^(kbqj`kl^he_k klan]`a`q]oi]jaen]olnej_el]eo6]%lahkÚj]j_e]iajpkoeiqhp jak`]]_qiqh]k `k_]lep]h$koc]opkol^he_ko_ki]lnk`qk(`ao`aoq^o`ekol]n]]]cne_qhpqn](]ej) `opne]ak_kin_ek]poq^o`ekol]n]]_ej_e]a]pa_jkhkce](bkni]j`k]ilhkooapk) naolnk`qperkoaop]p]eomqa`ao]cq]n]ijk_ha^na_kilhatkiehep]n)ej`qopne]h(]hi `]r]hknev]kÚj]j_aen]`k_]lep]hlkniaek`]`re`]l^he_](ap_*%7a^%lahkÚj]j) _e]iajpk`]nalnk`qk`]bkn]`apn]^]hdk(]h_]j]j`kpk`]]lklqh]klkniaek `koc]opkook_e]eo$a`q_]kcn]pqep](ia`e_ej]ok_e]hev]`](lnare`j_e]ok_e]h(oacqnk) )`aoailnack(oq^o`ekol]n]pn]jolknpa(]heiajp]kad]^ep]k(oq^o`ekol]n]_qhpq) n]ah]van(o]hnek)b]ihe](ap_*%*
=]k`a`qlhkÚj]j_e]iajpk(`evBn]j_eo_k`aKheraen](cankqqioacqj`ko]hnek(k o]hnekej`enapk(]kh]`k`ko]hnek`enapk$k`enapk]mqahal]cklner]`]iajpa]kpn]^]hdk a k ej`enapk ]mqaha l]ck lq^he_]iajpa ]ko _e`]`ko l]n] ] nalnk`qk `a oq] bkn] `a pn]^]hdk%*Knaoqhp]`kbkek]qiajpk`]_]l]_e`]`a`a_kjoqik`]o_h]ooaook_e]eo(l]npe_q) h]niajpa`]_h]ooai`e]a`]_h]ooapn]^]hd]`kn](`]j`kajoafk]k_kjoqik`ai]oo]* Aioqi](kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]hejpnk`qveq]nal^he_]ajpaj`e`]aopnqpqn]hiajpa _kikdbpqlalpcrkalpm _if`lp(komq]eooapknj]ilna_kj`ek`]]_qiqh]k(`]nalnk`q) k`k_]lep]h$a`]bkni]k`]p]t]`ahq_nk%a`]nalnk`qk`]bkn]`apn]^]hdklkniaek `]o`aolao]ook_e]eo*Jqi]l]h]rn](dkqra]ok_e]hev]k`ko_qopko`]lnk`qka]i]jqpaj) k`]]lnklne]klner]`]`kohq_nkokq`]naj`]$eopk(]nemqav]jkbkeok_e]hev]`]%* Lkniaek`]cqann]bne]a`kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h(k^hk_k_]lep]heop]lnk_qnkq eila`en(jkol]oaoa_kjkie_]iajpaoq^`aoajrkhre`kokq`kajpk`ajkiej]`kPan_aenk Iqj`k $=ine_] H]pej]( ãbne_]( Kneajpa I`ek%( na^ahe ao lklqh]nao mqa `aoai^k_]ooai ainarkhq ao_kiqjeop]o* K laneck `aoo]o narkhq ao ateope] lkn `keo ikperko lnej_el]eo6 kq lknmqa ko l]oao `kPan_aenkIqj`kan]i_khje]o`kol]oao_]lep]heop]o$jko]jko-51,a-52,(ko_]oko`] cqann] `] =nche] a `k Reapj _kjpn] k _khkje]heoik bn]j_o pknj]r]i iqepk lnaoajpao ] e`ae]`anarkhqk%(kqlknmqajahao]`aoecq]h`]`aa_kjie_k)ok_e]h(]ieone]a]oejfqope) ]oan]i`ap]hikjp]mqa(j]o_khje]o(cqann]o`ahe^anp]kj]_ekj]ha(jko`ai]eol]oao( na^ahe aolklqh]naolk`e]i]_kjpa_an]mq]hmqanikiajpkapn]jobkni]n)oaainarkhq ao $k_]ok`a?q^](ai-515(are`aj_ekqaoo]lkooe^ehe`]`a%* Kol]oaoi]eobknpao`k^hk_k_]lep]heop]]`kp]n]i`q]oia`e`]o6lkniaek`k>]j_kIqj) `e]ha`kBqj`kIkjapnekEjpanj]_ekj]h$BIE%(Úvan]iailnopeiko]koAop]`ko`kPan_aenk Iqj`kl]n]ejraopenjkooanrekook_e]eoaaiailnao]oaop]p]eo7a(lkniaek`kooanreko`aao) lekj]caia`]obkn]o]ni]`]o(kbana_an]iÎ]fq`]Ïiehep]nl]n]nalneiennarkhp]oanarkhq ao* ?kieook(aopeiqh]n]i(ok^napq`k]l]npen`ko]jko-52,(]lnkheban]k`a`ep]`qn]oiehep]nao anaceiao]qpknepnekojaoo]onace ao(_kikbkek_]ok`k>n]oeh(`k?dehaa`]=ncajpej]*
4ERCEIROß-UNDOßTERMI NOLOGIAßMUITOßEMßVOGAß DURANTEßAßGUERRAßFRIAßPARAß DIFERENCIARßOß0RIMEIROß -UNDOßCAPITALISTA ßDOß 3EGUNDOß-UNDOßSOCIA LISTA ßMASßQUEßVEMßSENDOß SUBSTITUqDAßNOSß{LTIMOSß ANOSßPELASßEXPRESSzESß ±PAqSESßEMERGENTES²ßOUß ±EMßDESENVOLVIMENTO²
"ETTMANN#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
.*
Kjakhe^an]heoik
K
mqa_d]i]iko`akblif_bo^ifpjlqi]pakne]a_kjie_k)lkhpe_]bkniqh]`]lkn qicnqlk`aa_kjkieop]o( _eajpeop]o lkhpe_ko a Úh okbko mqa( ai-503( naqjeq)oa aiIkjpO]ejpLhanej(j]Oq](aipknjk`ka_kjkieop]]qopn]_kBna`ane_gD]uag
&REDERICKß(AYEKß
054
"ROOKSß+RAFT#ORBIS,ATINSTOCK
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
-ILTONß&RIEDMANß
055
a`kjknpa)]iane_]jkIehpkjBnea`i]j*Aooacnqlkklqjd])oa]koqnceiajpk`kAop]`k`a >ai)Aop]nOk_e]h`aaopehkgaujaoe]jkaok_e]h)`aik_n]p]* J]rac]j`k_kjpn]]_knnajpa`]o`_]`]o`a-51,a-52,(aooacnqlkah]^knkqqi`ap]) hd]`klnkfapka_kjie_kalkhpe_kjkmq]h]p]_]r]kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h_kioaqo aj_]nckook_e]eoa_ki]bqjk`anacqh]`kn`]o]pere`]`ao`kian_]`k*=Úni]r]mqaaooa pelk`aatlanej_e]`aopnq]]he^an`]`a`ko_e`]`koa]_kilapek(oai]omq]eojkd lnkolane`]`a* Aoo]o e`ae]o lani]ja_an]i _kik hapn] iknp] ]p ] _neoa _]lep]heop] `k ej_ek `ko ]jko -53,(mq]j`kk_]lep]heoik_kjda_aq(lah]lneiaen]rav(qipelk`aoepq]keilnareorah(eopk (^]et]op]t]o`a_nao_eiajpka_kjie_ka]hp]op]t]o`aejÛ]k6]`ajkiej]`]bpq^dÜ^ l* Kcnqlk`kIkjpO]ejpLhanejl]ookq]oankqre`k_kinaolaepk(lknmqakbana_e]]oq) lkop]atlhe_]kl]n]]_neoa6aop](`eve]iahao(bkn]_]qo]`]lahklk`anat_aooerk`kooej`e) _]pkoa`koikreiajpkoklanneko(mqad]re]ilnaooekj]`klkn]qiajpkoo]h]ne]eoaatece) `kk]qiajpk`koaj_]nckook_e]eo`kAop]`k*Pane]i(`aoo]i]jaen](`aopnq`kkojraeo`a hq_nknamqane`kolah]oailnao]oa`aoaj_]`a]`kkolnk_aookoejÛ]_ekjnekoej_kjpnkhraeo* Baepkk`e]cj ope_k(kcnqlk`kIkjpO]ejpLhanejlnklokpn]p]iajpk6 -*
qi Aop]`k bknpa l]n] mqa^n]n k lk`an `ko oej`e_]pko a ikreiajpko klanneko( l]n] _kjpnkh]nk`ejdaenkl^he_ka_knp]n`n]ope_]iajpakoaj_]nckook_e]eoakoejraopeiaj) pkoj]a_kjkie]7
.*
qiAop]`k_qf]iap]lnej_el]h`arane]oan]aop]^ehe`]`aikjapne](mqa_kjpiko c]opkook_e]eoanaop]qn]]p]t]`a`aoailnackja_aoone]l]n]bkni]nqiatn_epkej) `qopne]h`anaoanr](mqa^n]j`kklk`anek`kooej`e_]pko7
/*
qiAop]`kmqana]hev]ooaqi]nabkni]Úo_]hl]n]ej_ajper]nkoejraopeiajpkolner]`ko a(lknp]jpk(mqana`qveooakoeilkopkook^nak_]lep]ha]obknpqj]o(]qiajp]j`kkoei) lkopkook^na]naj`]ej`ere`q]ha(lknp]jpk(ok^nakpn]^]hdk(k_kjoqikak_kin_ek7
0*
qiAop]`kmqaoa]b]op]ooa`]nacqh]k`]a_kjkie](`aet]j`kmqakln lnekian_]) `k(_kioq]n]_ekj]he`]`aln lne](klan]ooa]`aonacqh]k7aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]^khe) k`koejraopeiajpkoaop]p]eoj]lnk`qk(]^khek`k_kjpnkhaaop]p]hok^nakÛqtk Új]j_aenk(`nope_]haceoh]k]jpecnaraar]opklnkcn]i]`alner]pev]k*
Kik`ahkbke]lhe_]`k(lneiaenk(jk?deha(`alkeoj]Ejch]pann]ajkoAop]`koQje`ko( atl]j`ej`k)oal]n]pk`kkiqj`k_]lep]heop]a(`alkeo`]Îmqa`]`kIqnk`a>anheiÏ(l]n] kHaopaaqnklaq* J]ran`]`a(`a]_kn`k_kiBn]j_eo_k`aKheraen](jkbkn]i]oe`ae]o`koa_kjkieop]o `aIkjpO]ejpLhanejmqalqoan]iaii]n_d]kjakhe^an]heoik(aoei]o_kjpn]`e ao`k bqj`kl^he_keilh]jp]`klahkAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h(mqahar]n]i]koaq_kh]loka lnklkop]jakhe^an]h* ?kiabaepk(l]n]c]n]jpenoeiqhp]ja]iajpa]]_qiqh]kanalnk`qk`k_]lep]ha] `]bkn]`apn]^]hdk(kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]haj`ere`kq)oaaajpnkqjqilnk_aook`a `re`]l^he_]_kjda_e`k_kikabÛ`fqÚo_]hkqÎ_neoaÚo_]h`kAop]`kÏ*Aoo]_neoapknj])oa ej_kjpknjrah_ki]ejpanj]_ekj]hev]kkheckl he_]`]lnk`qka`]Új]j](lkeokokhe) ckl hekoiqhpej]_ekj]eojkajre]i]kooaqol]oao`aknecaikoc]jdkok^pe`kobkn]`a oq]o bnkjpaen]o a( lknp]jpk( jk ]heiajp]i k bqj`k l^he_k j]_ekj]h( mqa `ara _kjpejq]n Új]j_e]j`kk_]lep]ha]bkn]`apn]^]hdk*eookk_d]i]`kÎ_kh]lok`]ik`anjev]kÏa] knecai`]]lhe_]k`]lkhpe_]jakhe^an]h(mqalnkl aÎajtqc]nÏkqÎaj_khdanÏkAop]`k* Bn]j_eo_k`aKheraen]atlhe_]p]i^ilknmqa]pakne]jakhe^an]hlnkl akaj_khdeiaj) pk`kAop]`k*?kioq]lnaoaj]j]bkni]`ko]hnekej`enapk(kbqj`kl^he_k`ao]pkqkh]k mqalnaj`e]k_]lep]hbkn]`apn]^]hdk$eopk(]nah]kajpna_]lep]hao]hnek`enapk%*Aoo] ]i]nn]an]kmqa(jkl]oo]`k(b]ve]]ejkr]kp_je_]lahk_]lep]hoanqi]na]k]k]qiaj) pkna]h`ao]hneka(`aobaepkkh]k(keilqhokejkr]kpa_jkh ce_]pknjkq)oaln]pe_]iajpa eheiep]`k(lnkrk_]j`katl]jok`koejraopeiajpkoa]cec]jp]iajpk`]obkn]olnk`qper]o
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
_qf] hemqe`av eilnaooekj]jpa( i]o _qfk hq_nk jk oqÚ_eajpa l]n] _kj_napev]n pk`]o ]o lkooe^ehe`]`aopa_jkh ce_]o*Lkneookiaoik(k_]lep]hlna_eo]`al]n_ah]o`]nemqav]l^he) _](eopk(`kbqj`kl^he_k(j]mq]he`]`a`aÚj]j_e]`kn`aoo]_kj_napev]k*L]n]p]jpk( lna_eokmqa`ao]l]na]kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h(kqoaf](pk`koko^ajab_ekook_e]eomqa `enecaikbqj`kl^he_kl]n]]c]n]jpe]`a`enaepkook_e]eo* Aoo]pakne]jakhe^an]hpknjkq)oakoqlknpae`akh ce_k`]iq`]j]j]bkni]`]]_qiq) h]k`k_]lep]h(dkfa_kjda_e`]_kikÎ]_qiqh]kÛatrahÏ* =pia]`ko`ko]jko-53,(]ok_ea`]`a_]lep]heop]an]kneajp]`]lkn`keocn]j`aolnej) _leko6lmofk`mflabHbvkbp`aejpanrajk`kAop]`kj]a_kjkie]lkniaek`aejraopeiaj) pkoaaj`ere`]iajpkl]n]`eopne^qek`]naj`]alnkikk`k^ai)aop]nok_e]h(reo]j`k `eiejqen]o`aoecq]h`]`ao7almofk`mflabEbkovCloa`aknc]jev]kej`qopne]h^]oa]`]jk lh]jaf]iajpk(j]bqj_ekj]he`]`aajkhkjckln]vk`kpn]^]hdkej`qopne]h(_ki]_ajpn]hev]) karanpe_]hev]k`]olh]jp]oej`qopne]eo(cn]j`aohejd]o`aikjp]cajo_kj_ajpn]`]ojqi je_kaol]k(bkni]k`acn]j`aoaopkmqaoakneajp]`klah]oe`ae]o`an]_ekj]he`]`aa`q) n]^ehe`]`a`kolnk`qpko(a`alkhpe_]o]h]ne]halnkik_ekj]hreo]j`k]qiajp]n]_]l]_e`]`a `a_kjoqik`kopn]^]hd]`knao* Ai_kjpn]l]npe`](_kiklk`aiko_]n]_panev]nk_]lep]heoik]pq]h;Oaqolnej_el]eopn]) kolk`aioan]ooeinaoqie`ko6 k`aoailnackpknjkq)oaaopnqpqn]h(`aet]j`k`aoan]_e`ajp]hkqatlnaook`aqi] _neoa`lkgrkqro^i(lknmqa]bkni]_kjpailkn ja]`k_]lep]heoik(]k_kjpnnek`aoq] bkni]_hooe_](jkklan]mlofk`irpl`apk`]]ok_ea`]`ajkian_]`k`apn]^]hdka`a _kjoqik(i]omlobu`irpl*Aoo]at_hqokoab]vjko lah]ejpnk`qk`]]qpki]k( i]op]i^ilah]rahk_e`]`a`]nkp]pere`]`a`]ik`ak^n](mqaoapknj]`aomq]heÚ) _]`]ak^okhap]iqepkn]le`]iajpaai`a_knnj_e]`]rahk_e`]`a`]oiq`]j]opa_) jkh ce_]o*?kik_kjoamqj_e](pai)oa]lan`]`alk`an`kooej`e_]pkoak]qiajpk`] lk^nav]]^okhqp]7
-*
k ikjap]neoik a k _]lep]h Új]j_aenkpknj]n]i)oa k _kn]k a k _ajpnk janrkok `k _]lep]heoik(]ilhe]j`k]`aor]hknev]k`kpn]^]hdklnk`qperkalnerehace]j`k]i]eo ]^opn]p]`]oian_]`kne]o(lafkebfol*Klk`anek`k_]lep]hÚj]j_aenk`apaniej](`e]ne]) iajpa(]olkhpe_]o`kornekoAop]`kolknmqaaopao(ok^napq`kko]ckn]_d]i]`kol]) oaoai`aoajrkhreiajpk$]jpeckPan_aenkIqj`k%(`alaj`ai`]rkjp]`a`ko^]j_ko a`]oÚj]j_aen]o`apn]jobanenlanek`e_]iajpakona_qnokol]n]qi`apaniej]`kl]o( ]^]j`kj]j`kkqpnk7 !LEXß!LMEIDA&OLHAß)MAGEM
.*
CRISEßFINANCEIRAßMUNDIALß DEßßEMßMEADOSßDEß ßUMAßCRISEßDEß ß ABRANGoNCIAßMUNDIAL ß ßPROVOCADAßINICIALMENTEß PELOSßCHAMADOSß ßSUBPRIMESßEMPRmSTIMOSß IMOBILIfRIOSßß NORTE AMERICANOSßSEMß GARANTIAßDEßPAGAMENTO ß AFETOUßOßMERCADOß ßFINANCEIROß&OIßAßPRIMEIRAß DEMONSTRAljOßMAISßSmRIAß DEßCOLAPSOßNAßECONOMIAß DEßMERCADOßDESDEßAßCRISEß DEß
Klan]`knaok^oanr]i j`e_aoail]ejah `]>kraol](aiOk L]qhk(j]olneiae) n]oi]jebaop] ao `]_neoabej]j_aen] iqj`e]h(aikqpq^nk `a.,,4*
1,,
=oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko_qhkTTx#!0É45,/ßx
GLOBALIZAljOßPROCESSOß INICIADOßNAßSEGUNDAß METADEßDOßSmCULOß88ßEß INTENSIFICADOßNOSßANOSß ßCOMßOßUSOßCRESCENTEß DASßNOVASßTECNOLOGIASßDAß INFORMAljO ßQUEßCONDUZßgß INTEGRAljOßDASßECONOMIASß EßDASßSOCIEDADESßDEßßVfRIOSß PAqSESßCOMßRELAljOßgß PRODUljOßDEßMERCADORIASß EßSERVIlOS ßgßCONEXjOßDOSß MERCADOSßFINANCEIROSßEßgß DIFUSjOßDASßINFORMAlzES
/*
]pan_aenev]k(eopk(k]qiajpk`koapkn`aoanrekopknjkq)oaaopnqpqn]h(`aet]j`k`a oanqioqlhaiajpklnk`qklknmqa(]ckn](]lnk`qkjki]eooana]hev]jk]jpeck ik`ahkbkn`eop]`]ocn]j`aolh]jp]oej`qopne]eo(mqa_kj_ajpn]r]ipk`]o]oap]l]o`] lnk`qk$`]]mqeoek`]i]pne])lnei]`eopne^qek`kolnk`qpko%(i]oklan]lkn co^djbkq^ laafpmbopl`apk`]o]oaoban]oaap]l]o`]lnk`qk(_ki]_kiln]`a oanrekojkiqj`kejpaenk*?kik_kjoamqj_e](`ao]l]na_aipk`]o]oobcbok`f^pj^* qbof^fpmqalaniepe]i_h]ooaklanne]lan_a^an)oa_kik_h]ooaahqp]n_kik_h]ooaok) _e]h(ajbn]mqa_aj`k)oa]koa`eolano]nj]olamqaj]oqje`]`aopan_aenev]`]oaol]hd]`]o lahklh]jap]7
0*
]_ej_e]a]pa_jkhkce]pknj]n]i)oabkn]olnk`qper]o(`aet]j`k`aoaniankoqlknpa `k_]lep]hl]n]oa_kjranpanai]cajpao`aoq]]_qiqh]k*?kjoamqajpaiajpa(iq) `kqkik`k`aejoank`ko_eajpeop]oap_je_koj]ok_ea`]`a(lknmqaaopaopknj]n]i)oa ^dbkqbpb`lkjf`lpafobqlpa]bkn]aklk`an_]lep]heop]oaj_kjpn]i)oajkjlklmifl alp`lkeb`fjbkqlpba^fkcloj^ l7
1*
`ebanajpaiajpa`]bkni]ok_e]h)`aik_n]p](mqa`ao`akl o)Oacqj`]Cqann]d]re]`a) Úje`kkAop]`k_kik]cajpaa_kjie_kl]n]nacqh]k`kian_]`ka]cajpaÚo_]hmqa ailnac] ] pne^qp]k l]n] lnkikran ejraopeiajpko j]o lkhpe_]o `a `enaepko ok_e]eo( ]ckn]k_]lep]heoikafpmbkp^aobgbfq^]lnaoaj]aop]p]hjko jkian_]`ki]op]i) ^ij]olkhpe_]ook_e]eo(`aoknpamqa]lner]pev]k(p]jpk`aailnao]omq]jpk`aoan) rekol^he_ko(p]i^ioapknjkqaopnqpqn]h*@eooknaoqhp]mqa^fabf^abafobfqlppl`f^fp `ljlmobpprmlpqlbd^o^kqf^alpafobfqlp`fsfplrmliqf`lpqbkab^abp^m^ob`bo)mlfpl nrbbo^rjafobfql`lksboqb*pbkrjpbosf lmofs^alobdri^almbiljbo`^alb)mloq^kql) qlok^*pbrj^jbo`^alof^]laj]ol]n]komqapilk`an]mqeoeperkl]n]]`mqene)h]7
2*
]pn]joj]_ekj]hev]k`]a_kjkie]pknj]`aoja_aoone]]Úcqn]`kAop]`kj]_ekj]h _kikbk`i^sbqboofqlof^im^o^l`^mfq^ia`eolajo]]obkni]o_hooe_]o`keilane]heoik $_khkje]heoik lkhpe_k)iehep]n( caklkhpe_] `a na]o `a ejÛqj_e]( ap_*%( `a oknpa mqa k _ajpnka_kjie_k(fqn`e_kalkhpe_k)lh]japnekaj_kjpn])oajkBIEajk>]j_kIqj) `e]h*Aopaoklan]i_kiqije_k`kci](lnklkopklahkcnqlkbqj`]`kn`kjakhe^a) n]heoik(mq]hoaf]6bpq^_fifa^abb`lkjf`^a`loqbalaÛ`fqm _if`l(kqoaf](_knpaj]o ]lhe_] aook_e]eo`kbqj`kl^he_k7
3*
]]jpec]`eopejkajpnal]oao`aLneiaenkIqj`kaPan_aenkIqj`kpaj`a]oanoq^o) pepq`]lah]ateopj_e](ai_]`]l]o(`aqi]`ereokajpna^kho ao`anemqav]]^okhqp] a`aieone]]^okhqp](eopk(]mli^ofw^ lab`i^ppbp]l]na_a_kiklkh]nev]kajpna] lmrik`f^^_plirq^a]fkafdk`f^^_plirq^*D(ai_]`]l]o(qiÎlneiaenkiqj`kÏa qiÎpan_aenkiqj`kÏ(jko]jpeckopaniko* Jkajp]jpk(iq`]n]ikopaniko(i]ojkiq`]]na]he`]`a*=`ebanaj]aop]la) j]ojkjiank`alaook]omqalanpaj_ai]qi`aooaoÎiqj`koÏ(ain]vk`ko`eolk) oeperkook_e]eoahac]eo`a`eopne^qek`]naj`](c]n]jpe]`a`enaepkook_e]eo_kjokhe`]`ko a`]lkhpe_]pne^qpne]*
Lk`aikonaoqien]pakne]a]lnpe_]jakhe^an]eo`evaj`kmqa(_kiah]o(`)oakaj) _khdeiajpk`kaol]kl^he_k`ko`enaepkook_e]eoak]h]nc]iajpk`kaol]klner]`k `koejpanaooao`aian_]`k*_kiaoo]oepq]kmqa]`aik_n]_e]_kjpailkn ja]pai `ahe`]n*
1,-
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
#APqTULOß =mqaopk`aik_n pe_]
=`aik_n]_e]_kike`akhkce]
J
k_ajpnk`k`eo_qnoklkhpe_k_]lep]heop]aj_kjpn])oa]`abao]`]`aik_n]_e]* Reikomqa]obkni] aook_e]eopkp]hepne]o_nao_an]ioki^n]`]_npe_]`aik_n]_e] he^an]h(_kjoe`an]`]naolkjorahlah]`aokn`aia_]kook_eka_kjie_ko(lknmqa]^]j`kj]] ok_ea`]`a_k^e]eheiep]`]`kone_koalk`ankoko*=`aik_n]_e]ki]h* Lknoaqpqnjk(j]hqp]_kjpn]kopkp]hep]neoiko(koAop]`ko_]lep]heop]o]Úni]n]ipn]p]n)oa `k_ki^]paajpna]klnaooka]he^an`]`a(]`ep]`qn]a]`aik_n]_e]*=`aik_n]_e]k^ai* Jko`keo_]oko(]`aik_n]_e](ancqe`]kn]_kikki]h(kn]_kikk^ai(`aet]r]`aoan aj_]n]`]_kikbkni]`]re`]ok_e]hl]n]pknj]n)oaqipelk`ackranjkaqiejopnqiajpk e`akh ce_kl]n]ao_kj`ankmqaah](aijkia`kmqaah]Îr]haÏ*P]jpk]ooei(mqakocn]j`ao Aop]`ko_]lep]heop]o(_]ila ao`]`aik_n]_e](jkperan]i`re`]ai]qtehe]n]eilh]jp]k `anaceiao]qpknepneko$lknp]jpk]jpe`aik_npe_ko%pk`]ravmqahdaol]na_aq_kjrajeajpa* Ai^kn]he^an]heoikaAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h$kqok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]%oaf]i`ebanaj) paomq]jpkmqaopk`ko`enaepkoÍklneiaenkheiep]ko`enaepko_e`]`]je]lkhpe_]`aÚje) `]lah]_h]ooa`kiej]jpa(koacqj`k]ilhe]]_e`]`]je]lkhpe_]a]_khda]e`ae]`a`enaepko ok_e]eoÍ(jkmqap]jca`aik_n]_e]ahaookoaiahd]jpao*?kik]i^ko]`aÚjai`ab]pk; ?kikobdfjba^ibfba^loabjm^o^^d^o^kqf^a^pif_boa^abpfkafsfar^fp* Kmqaeookmqan`evan; Ailneiaenkhqc]n(mqae`ajpeÚ_]iif_boa^aba`ljmbqf lÍp]jpk]_kilapeka_k) jie_]`]_d]i]`]Îhernaeje_e]per]Ïmq]jpk]_kilapeklkhpe_]ajpnal]npe`komqa`eo) lqp]iahae ao* Aioacqj`khqc]n(mqae`ajpeÚ_]i^ibf_ki^mlqk`f^graf`fof^m^o^ifjfq^olmlabo mliqf`l(`abaj`aj`k]ok_ea`]`a_kjpn]]pen]je](lkeo]haec]n]jpakockranjkoao_khde`ko lah]rkjp]`a`]i]ekne]* Aipan_aenkhqc]n(mqae`ajpeÚ_]i^loabj_ki^mlqk`f^alBub`rqfslbalGraf`fofl m^o^`lkqbobifjfq^olp`lkÜfqlppl`f^fp(eila`ej`kk`aoajrkhreiajpk`]hqp]`a_h]ooao( oaf]lah]nalnaook(oaf]lahk]paj`eiajpk`]o`ai]j`]olkn`enaepkook_e]eo$ailnack(^k]o _kj`e ao`apn]^]hdkao]hnek(a`q_]k(ikn]`e](o]`a(pn]jolknpa(h]van%* Aimq]npkhqc]n(mqa(ai^kn]]`aik_n]_e]]l]na]fqopeÚ_]`]_kikÎr]hknÏkq_kik Î^aiÏ(aj_]n]`](`ab]pk(lahk_nepnek`]bÛ``f^*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(`abaj`ai]`aik) _n]_e]lknmqahdaol]na_aqinaceiab]rknrah]l]pe]lkhpe_]$]lkhpe_]oane]]ooqjpk`ko nalnaoajp]jpao(mqaoklkhpe_kolnkÚooekj]eo%(mqa(lknoaqpqnjk(b]rkna_a]bkni]k`a qi]ahepa`aq`kf`lp`ljmbqbkqbp]komq]eo_]^a]`enak`kAop]`k(arep]j`k(`aoo]i]) jaen](qi]l]npe_el]klkhpe_]mqapn]ne]_aj]koÎatpnaieop]oÏaÎn]`e_]eoÏ`]ok_ea`]`a( eopk(koÎej_kilapajpaoÏ* =`aik_n]_e](]ooei(na`qve`]]qinaceialkhpe_kaÚ_]v(^]oa]`kj]e`ae]`a_e`]) `]je]knc]jev]`]ail]npe`kolkhpe_ko(mqaoai]jebaop]jklnk_aookahaepkn]h`aao_khd] `konalnaoajp]jpao(j]nkp]pere`]`a`kockranj]jpaoaj]ookhq aop_je_]o$ajklkhpe_]o% l]n]kolnk^hai]ook_e]eo*
1,.
=mqaopk`aik_npe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Reop]lknaooalneoi](na]hiajpaqi]e`akhkce]lkhpe_]afqopeÚ_]]_npe_]mqahda `eneceqI]nt]knabanen)oa]kbkni]heoikfqn`e_kmqalnaoe`a]e`ae]`a`enaepko`k_e`]`k* Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(`ao`a]NarkhqkBn]j_ao]`a-345(aoo]`aik_n]_e]`a_h]n]ko`enaepko qjerano]eo`kdkiaia`k_e`]`k(i]o]ok_ea`]`aaopaopnqpqn]`]`ap]hi]jaen]mqa p]eo`enaepkojklk`aiateopen_kj_nap]iajpal]n]]i]ekne]`]lklqh]k*>abjl`o^`f^ cloj^i)kl`lk`obq^*
=ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]
R
eiko mqa qi] e`akhkce] jk j]o_a `k j]`] jai nalkqo] jk r]vek( i]o atlneia( `ai]jaen]ejranpe`](`eooeiqh]`]aei]cejne](]moufpok_e]hadeop ne_]_kj_nap]o* Eookoa]lhe_]fablildf^abjl`oqf`^*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(d(j]lnpe_]`aik_npe_] aj]oe`ae]o`aik_npe_]o(qi]lnkbqj`e`]`aaqi]ran`]`aiqepki]eknaoaoqlaneknao]k mqa]e`akhkce]`aik_npe_]lan_a^aa`aet]lan_a^an* MqaoecjeÚ_]i]oahae ao;Iqepki]eo`kmqa]ian]nkp]pere`]`a`ackranjkokq] ]hpanj j_e]jklk`an*Oei^khev]ikaooaj_e]h`]`aik_n]_e]6mqaklk`anjkoae`ajpeÚ_] _kikok_ql]jpao`kckranjk(kliebpmboqbk`b(i]ooailnaqihqc]nr]vekmqako_e`]) `ko(lanek`e_]iajpa(lnaaj_dai_kiqinalnaoajp]jpa(lk`aj`knarkc]noaqi]j`]pkoa jk_qilnenkmqahdabke`ahac]`kl]n]nalnaoajp]n* MqaoecjeÚ_]i]oe`ae]o`apfqr^ lalmlpf l(j^flof^ajfklof^(_qf]orkjp]`ao`arai oannaolaep]`]oac]n]jpe`]olah]hae;Ah]orkiqepk]hi`aoo]]l]nj_e]*OecjeÚ_]imqa]ok) _ea`]`ajkqi]_kiqje`]`aqj]aej`ereo]rkhp]`]l]n]k^ai_kiqik^pe`klkn_kjoaj) ok(i]o(]k_kjpnnek(mqaaopfkqbok^jbkqbafsfafa^amqa]o`ereo aookibdqfj^pa`arai atlnaoo]n)oalq^he_]iajpa*=`aik_n]_e]]je_]bkni]lkhpe_]mqa_kjoe`an]k_kjÛepk hacpeikahac]h(laniepej`kmqaoaf]qo^_^ie^almlifqf`^jbkqblah]ln lne]ok_ea`]`a* @]iaoi]i]jaen](]oe`ae]o`afdr^ia^abaif_boa^ab_kik`enaepko_ereo`ko_e`]`ko rkiqepk]hi`aoq]nacqh]iajp]kfqn`e_]bkni]h*OecjeÚ_]imqako_e`]`kookoq) faepko`a`enaepkoamqa(kj`ap]eo`enaepkojkateop]ijaiaopaf]ic]n]jpe`ko(pai)oak `enaepk`ahqp]nlknahaoaatece)hko*aooak_anja`]`aik_n]_e]* Qi`enaepk`ebana`aqi]ja_aooe`]`akq_]nj_e]a`aqiejpanaooa* Qi]ja_aooe`]`akq_]nj_e]]hckl]npe_qh]naaola_Ú_k*=hcqilk`apanja_aooe`]`a `acq](kqpnk(`a_kie`]*Qicnqlkok_e]hlk`apan_]nj_e]`apn]jolknpao(kqpnk(`adkole) p]eo*Dp]jp]oja_aooe`]`aomq]jpkej`er`qko(p]jp]o_]nj_e]omq]jpkcnqlkook_e]eo* Qiejpanaooap]i^i]hckl]npe_qh]naaola_Ú_k*Koejpanaooao`koaopq`]jpao^n]oe) haenkolk`aioan`ebanajpao`koejpanaooao`koaopq`]jpao]ncajpejko*Koejpanaooao`ko]cne) _qhpknaolk`aioan`ebanajpao`koejpanaooao`ko_kian_e]jpao*Ko`ko^]j_neko(`ebanajpao `koejpanaooao`ko^]jmqaenko*Ko`koej`caj]o(`ebanajpao`koejpanaooao`koc]neilaenko* Ja_aooe`]`ao kq _]nj_e]o lk`ai oan _kjÛep]jpao* Oqlkjd]iko mqa( lkn atailhk( jqi]nacek`aqi]cn]j`a_e`]`a(]oiqhdanaopn]^]hd]`kn]opajd]ija_aooe`]`akq_]) nj_e]`a_na_daol]n]oaqoÚhdkoamqa(j]iaoi]nacek(qikqpnkcnqlkok_e]h(b]rah]`ko( pajd]_]nj_e]`aikn]`e]*Kckranjkiqje_el]h`eol a`ana_qnokol]n]]paj`an]qi]`]o _]nj_e]o(i]ojk]]i^]o(`aoknpamqanaokhranqi]oecjeÚ_]n]^]j`kj]n]kqpn]* Ejpanaooaop]i^ilk`aioan_kjÛep]jpao*Oqlkjd]iko(lknatailhk(mqaejpanaooa] cn]j`aolnklneapneko`apann]o`aet)h]oej]per]oaolan]j`k]r]hknev]keik^ehene](i]o mqaejpanaooa]pn]^]hd]`knaonqn]eooai)pann]k_qhperk`a]heiajpkol]n]]ok^narerj_e]7 paiko]qi_kjÛepk`aejpanaooao*Oqlkjd]ikomqaejpanaooa]kolnklneapneko`aailna) o]o_kian_e]eoaop]^aha_anqidknnek`apn]^]hdkmqa]qiajpa]oraj`]o(i]omqaejpanao) oa]ko_kian_enekoqikqpnkdknnek(jkmq]hlkoo]i`eolkn`adkn]ol]n]aopq`]n(_qe`]n `]b]ihe]a`ao_]jo]n*Paiko]mqeqikqpnk_kjÛepk`aejpanaooao* Qi`enaepk(]k_kjpnnek`aja_aooe`]`ao(_]nj_e]oaejpanaooao(jkl]npe_qh]naaola) _Ú_k(i]ocan]haqjerano]h(rhe`kl]n]pk`kokoej`er`qko(cnqlkoa_h]ooaook_e]eo*=ooei(
1,/
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
lknatailhk(]_]nj_e]`acq]a`a_kie`]i]jebaop]]hcki]eolnkbqj`k6k`enaepkre`]* =_]nj_e]`aikn]`e]kq`apn]jolknpap]i^ii]jebaop]]hcki]eolnkbqj`k6k`enaepk] ^k]o_kj`e ao`are`]*Kejpanaooa`koaopq`]jpao(k`enaepka`q_]kaejbkni]k*K ejpanaooa`kooai)pann](k`enaepk]kpn]^]hdk*K`ko_kian_eneko(k`enaepk]^k]o_kj`e ao `apn]^]hdk* @evaiko mqa qi] ok_ea`]`a $a jk qi oeilhao naceia `a ckranjk% `aik_npe_] mq]j`k(]hi`aahae ao(l]npe`kolkhpe_ko(`ereok`kopnolk`anao`]nal^he_](naolaepk rkjp]`a`]i]ekne]a`]oiejkne]o(ejopepqe]hcki]eolnkbqj`k(mqa_kj`ek`kln lnek naceialkhepe_k(kqoaf](mq]j`kejopepqe`enaepko*
=_ne]k`a`enaepko Mq]j`k]`aik_n]_e]bkeejrajp]`]lahko]pajeajoao(_nekq)oa]pn]`ek`aik_npe_] _kikejopepqek`apno`enaepkobqj`]iajp]eomqa`aÚje]ik_e`]`k6ecq]h`]`a(he^an`]) `aal]npe_el]kjklk`an*At]iejaikokoecjeÚ_]`k`aooaopno`enaepkoj]Cn_e]]jpec]* -*
Fdr^ia^aboecjeÚ_]r](lan]jpa]ohaeoako_kopqiao`]mifp(mqapk`koko_e`]`kolko) oq]ikoiaoiko`enaepkoa`are]ioanpn]p]`ko`]iaoi]i]jaen]*Lknaooaikperk( =neop pahao]Úni]r]mqa]lneiaen]p]nab]`]fqope]an]ecq]h]nko`aoecq]eo(oaf]lah] na`eopne^qek`]nemqav]ok_e]h(oaf]lah]c]n]jpe]`al]npe_el]kjkckranjk*P]i^i lahkiaoikikperk(I]nt]Úni]r]mqa]ecq]h`]`ao oapknj]ne]qi`enaepk_kj_napk mq]j`kjkdkqraooaao_n]rko(oanrkoa]oo]h]ne]`koatlhkn]`ko(i]obkooa`]`k]_]`] qioacqj`koq]oja_aooe`]`aoaoacqj`koaqpn]^]hdk* =k^oanr]k`a=neop pahaoa(`alkeo(]`aI]nt(ej`e_]i]hcklna_eok6^jbo^ab* `i^o^ lalafobfql fdr^ia^abklc^wbufpqfolpfdr^fp)j^p^_obl`^jmlm^o^^`of^* la^fdr^ia^abmlojbfla^pbufdk`f^pbabj^ka^palpprgbfqlppl`f^fp*Aikqpn]o l]h]rn]o(`a_h]n]`kk`enaepkecq]h`]`a(]ok_ea`]`alk`aejopepqenbkni]o`anaerej`e) _]kl]n]_ne)hk_kik`enaepkna]h*
.*
If_boa^aboecjeÚ_]r]mqapk`k_e`]`kpaik`enaepk`aatlknail^he_koaqoejpanao) oaoaoq]okleje ao(r)hko`a^]pe`kolahko`ai]eoa]lnkr]`kokqnafaep]`kolah]i]ek) ne](`araj`k]_]p]n]`a_eokpki]`]lq^he_]iajpa*J]ik`anje`]`a(_ki]Narkhqk Ejchao]`a-200a]NarkhqkBn]j_ao]`a-345(k`enaepkhe^an`]`a]ilhekq)oa*=hi `]he^an`]`a`alajo]iajpka`aatlnaook(l]ookq]oecjeÚ_]nk`enaepkej`alaj`j) _e]l]n]ao_khdankkb_ek(khk_]h`aikn]`e](kpelk`aa`q_]k(k_jfqca(aioqi](] na_qo]`]odean]nmqe]oÚt]o(oqlkop]iajpa`erej]okqj]pqn]eo* =eook]_nao_ajpkq)oa(ai-345(qi`enaepk`aajkniaeilknp j_e](mq]hoaf](k`a mqapk`kej`er`qkejk_ajpa]plnkr]ai_kjpnnek(mqa]lnkr]`araoanaop]^aha) _e`]lan]jpaqipne^qj]hamqa]he^an]kkqlqjek`araioan`]`]ooacqj`k]hae* ?kikoikreiajpkook_e]heop]o(]hqp]ok_e]hlknhe^an`]`a]ilhekq]ej`]i]eoaooa `enaepk(]_nao_ajp]j`k)hdak`enaepk`ahqp]n_kjpn]pk`]o]obkni]o`apen]je](_ajoqn] apknpqn]a_kjpn]pk`]o]obkni]o`aatlhkn]ka`kiej]kok_e]h(a_kjie_](_qh) pqn]halkhpe_]* K^oanr]iko ]mqe k iaoik mqa j] ecq]h`]`a6 ^ pfjmibp ab`i^o^ l al afobfql if_boa^abkl^fkpqfqrf`lk`obq^jbkqb)j^p^_obl`^jmlefpqof`lm^o^^`of^ labppb afobfqlmbi^lnteoerj^k^*
/*
M^oqf`fm^ lklmlabooecjeÚ_]r]mqapk`koko_e`]`kopik`enaepk`al]npe_el]n`]o `eo_qoo aoa`ahe^an] aol^he_]o`]mifp(rkp]j`kkqnarkc]j`k`a_eo ao*Aooa`enaepk lkooq] qi oajpe`k iqepk lna_eok* Jaha ]Úni]r])oa mqa( `k lkjpk `a reop] lkhpe_k( pk`ko ko _e`]`ko pi _kilapj_e] l]n] klej]n a `a_e`en( lkeo ] lkhpe_] jk qi] mqaopk p_je_] $aÚ__e] ]`iejeopn]per] a iehep]n% jai _eajpÚ_] $_kjda_eiajpko ao) la_e]hev]`kook^na]`iejeopn]kacqann]%(i]o]k_khaper](eopk(`a_eok_khaper] mq]jpk]koejpanaooaoa`enaepko`]ln lne]mifp*
1,0
=mqaopk`aik_npe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
=`aik_n]_e]]pajeajoa(_kikoar(an]afobq^*=ik`anj](lkni(obmobpbkq^qfs^*K `enaepkl]npe_el]kpknjkq)oa(lknp]jpk(ej`enapk(lkniaek`]ao_khd]`analnaoajp]jpao* =k_kjpnnek`kokqpnko`keo`enaepko(aopahpeikl]na_apanokbne`k`eiejqekaihqc]n`a ]ilhe]k*Aoo]]l]nj_e]b]ho]aran`]`aen]* C^ip^ lknmqa ] `aik_n]_e] ik`anj] bke ejopepq`] j] hqp] _kjpn] k =jpeck Naceia a( lknp]jpk(ainah]k]aooahpeik(]ilhekq]l]npe_el]k`ko_e`]`kojklk`an(]ej`]mqa ok^]bkni]`]nalnaoajp]k* Sboa^abfo^lknmqa(_kikreiko(]nal^he_]he^an]hpaj`aq]heiep]nko`enaepkolkhpe_ko ]kolnklneapnekolner]`ko`koiaeko`alnk`qka]kolnkÚooekj]eohe^an]eo`]_h]ooai) `e](]kodkiajo]`qhpkoÎej`alaj`ajpaoÏ*Pk`]re](]ohqp]ook_e]heop]oalklqh]naobkn]n]i ]]ilhe]k`ko`enaepkolkhpe_ko_ki]_ne]k`kprcodflrkfsbop^i$pk`kook_e`]`ko ahaepknao6dkiajo(iqhdanao(fkrajo(jacnko(]j]hb]^apko(pn]^]hd]`knao(j`eko%a]c]n]jpe] `]ahace^ehe`]`a`amq]hmqanqimqa(jkaop]j`kok^oqolaep]`a_neia(oa]lnaoajpa]qi _]nckahaperk* Raiko]mqe(lknp]jpk(kiaoikmqajko`enaepko]jpaneknao6irq^ppl`f^fpnrbqo^kpcloj^j ^pfjmibpab`i^o^ labrjafobfqlbjafobfqlob^i)lrpbg^)sbjlp^nrf^`of^ labrjafobfql*
MINORIASßPODEßPARECERßES TRANHOßFALARßEMß±MINORIA²ß PARAßREFERIR SEßAßMULHERES ß NEGROS ßIDOSOS ßCRIANlAS ß POISßQUANTITATIVAMENTEß FORMAMßAßMAIORIAßbßQUEß AßPALAVRAßMINORIAßNjOßmß USADAßEMßSENTIDOßQUAN TITATIVO ßMASßQUALITATIVOß 1UANDOßOßPENSAMENTOß POLqTICOßLIBERALßDEFINIUßOSß QUEßTERIAMßDIREITOßgßCIDA DANIA ßUSOUßCOMOßCRITmRIOß AßIDEIAßDEßMAIORIDADEß RACIONALßSERIAMßCIDADjOSß AQUELESßQUEßHOUVESSEMß ALCANlADOßOßPLENOßUSOßDAß RAZjOß!LCANlARAMßOßPLENOß USOßDAßRAZjOßOUßAßMAIORI DADEßRACIONALßOSßQUEßSjOß INDEPENDENTES ßISTOßm ßNjOß DEPENDEMßDEßOUTROSßPARAß VIVERß3jOßINDEPENDENTESß OSßPROPRIETfRIOSßPRIVADOSß DOSßMEIOSßDEßPRODUljOß EßOSßPROFISSIONAISßLIBE RAISß3jOßDEPENDENTESßE ß PORTANTO ßEMßESTADOßDEß MINORIDADEßRACIONALßASß MULHERES ßASßCRIANlAS ßOSß ADOLESCENTES ßOSßTRABA LHADORESßEßOSß±SELVAGENSß PRIMITIVOS²ßAFRICANOSßEß INDqGENAS ß&ORMAMßAß MINORIAß#OMOßHfßOUTROSß GRUPOSßCUJOSßDIREITOSßNjOß SjOßRECONHECIDOSßPORß EXEMPLO ßOSßHOMOSSEXUAIS ß FALA SEßEMß±MINORIAS²ß !ß±MAIORIDADE²ßLIBERALß REFERE SE ßPOIS ßAOßHOMEMß ADULTOßBRANCOßPROPRIETfRIOß OUßPROFISSIONALßLIBERAL
1,1
=ohqp]olknecq]h`]`aahe^an`]`a]ilhe]n]iko`enaepkolkhpe_ko$_ereo%a(]l]npen`aopao( _ne]n]iko`enaepkook_e]eo$pn]^]hdk(ikn]`e](o]`a(pn]jolknpa(a`q_]k(h]van(_qhpqn]%(ko`e) naepko`]o_d]i]`]oÎiejkne]oÏ$iqhdanao(e`koko(jacnko(dkikooatq]eo(_ne]j]o(`aÚ_eajpao( ej`caj]o%ak`enaepkoacqn]j]lh]japne]$]ohqp]oa_kh ce_]oa_kjpn]]o]ni]ojq_ha]nao%* =ohqp]olklqh]naolknl]npe_el]klkhpe_]]ilhe]n]iko`enaepko_ereo6`enaepk`aklkn)oa pen]je](_ajoqn](pknpqn](`enaepk`aÚo_]hev]nkAop]`klkniaek`aknc]jev] ao`]ok_ea) `]`a$]ook_e] ao(oej`e_]pko(l]npe`kolkhpe_ko%7`enaepkejbkni]klah]lq^he_e`]`a`]o `a_eo aoaop]p]eo* = ok_ea`]`a `aik_npe_] ejopepqe `enaepko lah] ]^anpqn] `k _]ilk ok_e]h `of^ l ab afobfqlpob^fp(^jmif^ labafobfqlpbufpqbkqbpa`of^ labklslpafobfqlp*?kieook(`keo pn]ko`eopejcqai]`aik_n]_e]`apk`]o]okqpn]obkni]ook_e]eoalkhpe_]o6 -*
]`aik_n]_e]]je_]ok_ea`]`aakje_knaceialkhpe_kmqa_kjoe`an]k_kjÛepk hacpeik* Jk o pn]^]hd] lkhepe_]iajpa ko _kjÛepko `a ja_aooe`]`ao a `a ejpanaooao $`eolqp]oajpnakol]npe`kolkhpe_koaahae ao`ackranj]jpaolanpaj_ajpao]l]npe`ko klkopko%(i]olnk_qn]ejopepq)hko_kik`enaepkoa(_kikp]eo(atecamqaoaf]ina_kjda) _e`koanaolaep]`ko*I]eo`kmqaeook(j]ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_](ej`er`qkoacnqlko knc]jev]i)oa ai ]ook_e] ao( ikreiajpko ok_e]eo a lklqh]nao( _h]ooao oa knc]jev]i aioej`e_]pkoal]npe`ko(_ne]j`kqi_kjpn]lk`anok_e]hmqa(`enap]kqej`enap]iajpa( heiep]klk`an`kAop]`k7
.*
]`aik_n]_e]]ok_ea`]`aran`]`aen]iajpadeopne_](eopk(]^anp]]kpailk(]klkoo) rah(opn]jobkni] aoa]kjkrk*?kiabaepk(lah]_ne]k`ajkrko`enaepkoalah]ateopj) _e]`ko_kjpn]lk`anaook_e]eo(]ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]jkaopÚt]`]jqi]bkni]l]n] oailna`apaniej]`](kqoaf](jk_aoo]`apn]^]hd]noq]o`ereo aoa`ebanaj]oejpanj]o( `akneajp]n)oalah]lkooe^ehe`]`ak^faper]$]he^an`]`a%a`a]hpan]n)oalah]ln lne]moufp*
Kok^op_qhko`aik_n]_e] He^an`]`a(ecq]h`]`aal]npe_el]k_kj`qven]i_ha^nabkniqh]k`]lkhpe_]`aik) _npe_]_kikÎckranjk`klkrk(lahklkrkal]n]klkrkÏ*Ajpnap]jpk(klkrk`]ok_ea`]`a `aik_npe_]aop`ere`e`kai_h]ooaook_e]eoÍoaf]ikone_koakolk^nao$=neop pahao%(oaf]i kocn]j`aoaklkrk$I]mqe]rah%(oaf]i]o_h]ooaook_e]eo]jp]cje_]o$I]nt%* ran`]`amqa]ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]]mqah]mqajkao_kj`aoq]o`ereo ao(i]o lnk_qn]Îpn]^]hd)h]oÏlah]oejopepqe aoalah]ohaeo*Pk`]re](jk_]lep]heoik(okeiajokoko k^op_qhko`aik_n]_e](lkeok_kjÛepk`aejpanaooaolkopklah]atlhkn]k`aqi]_h]ooa ok_e]hlknkqpn](iaoikmqa]e`akhkce]]Úniamqapk`kookhernaoaecq]eo*
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
Fkraihoak`a _h]ooebe_]`ko`aai) lnackoai?qnepe^]( jkiomqai]n_kq ]a_hkok`]_neoa bej]j_aen]iqj`e]h6 kqpq^nk`a.,,4* 'IULIANOß'OMES&OLHAPRESS
ran`]`amqa]ohqp]olklqh]naojkol]oao`a_]lep]heoik]r]j]`k]ilhe]n]iko`e) naepko`ko_e`]`koamqa]atlhkn]k`kopn]^]hd]`knao`eiejqeqiqepk(ok^napq`k_kik Aop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h*Jkajp]jpk(dkqraqilnak]l]c]n6]atlhkn]ki]eorekhajp] `kpn]^]hdklahk_]lep]hna_]eqj]o_kop]o`kopn]^]hd]`knao`kol]oao`kajpk_d]i]`k Pan_aenkIqj`k* Dkqra qi] `ereok ejpanj]_ekj]h `k pn]^]hdk a `] atlhkn]k mqa( ]k iahdkn]n ] ecq]h`]`aa]he^an`]`a`kopn]^]hd]`knao`aqi]l]npa`kiqj`k(]cn]rkq]o_kj`e ao`a re`]a`apn]^]hdk`]kqpn]l]npa*Ajkbkelkn]_]okmqa(ajmq]jpkjkol]oao_]lep]heop]o ]r]j]`ko_nao_e]ikAop]`k`a>ai)Aop]nOk_e]ha]`aik_n]_e]ok_e]h(jkPan_aenkIqj`k an]ieilh]jp]`]o`ep]`qn]oanaceiao]qpknepneko(_kikomq]eoko_]lep]heop]o`aooaol]) oaooa]he]r]i* =oepq]k`k`enaepk`aecq]h`]`aa`ahe^an`]`ap]i^iiqepkbncehjko`e]o]pq]eo( lknmqa(_kikreiko]jpanekniajpa(kjlalabmolar l`^mfq^ifpq^l]ookqlknqi]iq) `]j]lnkbqj`]*P]hiq`]j]k_knnaq]l]npen`kikiajpkaimqakik`k`alnk`qk _]lep]heop]l]ookq]ajbnajp]n]_neoa`kAop]`k`k>ai)Aop]nOk_e]hna_knnaj`k]kjakhe^an]) heoikae`ae]he^an]h`a^rql`lkqolib`]a_kjkie]lahkian_]`k_]lep]heop](]b]op]j`k(lkn) p]jpk(]lnaoaj]`kAop]`kjklh]jaf]iajpka_kjie_kaj]]lhe_]k`kobqj`kol^he_ko l]n]c]n]jpe]`a`enaepkook_e]eo* K]^]j`kjk`]olkhpe_]ook_e]eo_d]i])oalner]pev]kak`klh]jaf]iajpka_kjie) _k(`aonacqh]k*=i^kokopaniko]ooaran]imqak_]lep]ho^`flk^ialk`a(lknoeiaoik( naokhrankolnk^hai]oa_kjie_koaok_e]eo*=hi`eook(k`aoajrkhreiajpkaol]jpkok`]o jkr]opa_jkhkce]oahapnje_]opnkqta]rahk_e`]`a`]_kiqje_]ka`]ejbkni]ka]]qpk) i]k`]lnk`qka`eopne^qek`kolnk`qpko*Aoo]iq`]j]j]obkn]olnk`qper]o$lkeo] pa_jkhkce]]hpankqklnk_aookok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk%(_kikreiko(rai_]qo]j`kk`aoailnack aii]oo](ikreiajpkon]_eop]o_kjpn]eiecn]jpaoaiecn]jpao(at_hqokok_e]h(lkhpe_]a _qhpqn]h`acn]j`aoi]oo]o`]lklqh]k*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(ko`enaepkoa_kjie_koaok) _e]eo_kjmqeop]`kolah]ohqp]olklqh]naoaopkailaneck_ki]lner]pev]k(_kikaj_khde) iajpk`]aoban]l^he_]a_kik]h]nc]iajpk`]aoban]`koejpanaooaolner]`ko*Dkfa(_kik reiko]_ei](k_]lep]hlk`a]_qiqh]n)oaanalnk`qven)oaat_hqej`k_]`]ravi]eo]olaook]o `kian_]`k`apn]^]hdka`a_kjoqik*Jklna_eo]i]eo`acn]j`aoi]oo]opn]^]hd]`kn]oa _kjoqie`kn]o(lk`a]ilhe]n)oacn]]o]k`aoailnackaii]oo]ajklna_eo]lnak_ql]n)oa aic]n]jpen`enaepkoa_kjie_koaok_e]eo]kopn]^]hd]`knaolknmqajkja_aooep]`aoaqo pn]^]hdkoaoanreko* K `enaepk l]npe_el]k lkh) pe_] p]i^i aj_kjpn] k^op_qhko* @a b]pk( jk _]lep]heoik `] oacqj`] iap]`a`ko_qhkTT(]knc]jev]k ej`qopne]h `k pn]^]hdk bke baep]_ki ^]oaaiqi]`ereokok_e]hjkr]6] oal]n]kajpna`enecajpaoaata_q) p]jpao*Kolneiaenkookkomqana_a) ^ai]a`q_]k_eajpÚ_]apa_jkh ) ce_](ok_kjoe`an]`kolknp]`knao`a o]^anaomqakopknj]i`ljmbqbkqbp alkneook_kilk`an`ai]j`k*Ko ata_qp]jpao ok ]mqahao mqa jk lkooqai_kjda_eiajpkopa_jkh ce) _koa_eajpÚ_ko(o]^ai]laj]oata) _qp]np]nab]o(oai_kjda_an]on]v ao a]oÚj]he`]`ao`aoq]]k*Oklkn eook _kjoe`an]`ko fk`ljmbqbkqbp a `aopej]`ko]k^a`a_an*
1,2
=mqaopk`aik_npe_]x#!0É45,/ßx
Aoo]bkni]`aknc]jev]k`]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdklnkl]ckq)oal]n]]ok_ea`]`a ejpaen]*Jk_kin_ek(j]]cne_qhpqn](j]oao_kh]o(jkodkolep]eo(j]oqjeranoe`]`ao(jkooan) rekol^he_ko(j]o]npao(pk`koaopkoal]n]`koajpnaÎ_kilapajpaoÏmqao]^aiaÎej_ki) lapajpaoÏmqaata_qp]i*Aikqpn]ol]h]rn]o(]lkooa`a_anpko_kjda_eiajpkoaola_Ú_ko pknjkq)oaqilk`anl]n]i]j`]na`a_e`en* Aoo]`ereokok_e]h_kjranpaq)oajqi]e`akhkce]6]e`akhkce]`]_kilapj_e]p _je_k) )_eajpÚ_](eopk(j]e`ae]`amqamqailkooqe_kjda_eiajpkoaopj]pqn]hiajpa`kp]`k`a lk`an`ai]j`ka`enak*Aoo]e`akhkce](bknp]ha_e`]lahkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo] mqa]aopeiqh]i`e]ne]iajpa(ejr]`eq]lkhpe_]6aop]l]ookq]oan_kjoe`an]`]qi]]pere) `]`a naoanr]`] l]n] p_je_ko kq ]`iejeopn]`knao lkhpe_ko _kilapajpao( a jk qi] ]k _khaper]`apk`koko_e`]`ko* Jko k`enaepknalnaoajp]klkhpe_]$oannalnaoajp]jpa%`eiejqelknmqaoanaopnej) ca]ko_kilapajpao(_kik]ej`]]e`akhkce]`]_kilapj_e]k_qhp]a`eooeiqh]kb]pk`a mqa(l]n]oanÎ_kilapajpaÏ(lna_eokpanna_qnokoa_kjie_kol]n]aopq`]na]`mqenen_k) jda_eiajpko*Kqoaf](koÎ_kilapajpaoÏlanpaj_ai_h]ooaa_kjkie_]iajpa`kiej]jpa( mqa(]ooei(`eneca]lkhpe_]oacqj`koaqoejpanaooaoajk`a]_kn`k_ki]qjerano]he`]`a `ko`enaepko* Qikqpnkk^op_qhk]k`enaepkl]npe_el]klkhpe_]lkopklahkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]) k`ai]oo]*O lk`aikol]npe_el]n`a`eo_qoo aoa`a_eo aolkhpe_]ooalkooqenikoejbkn) i] ao_knnap]ook^na]mqehkmqar]iko`eo_qpena`a_e`en*Kn](_kikfreiko(koiaeko`a _kiqje_]k`ai]oo]jkejbkni]i(`aoejbkni]i*Kqiahdkn(pn]joiepai]oejbkni]) ao`a]_kn`k_kikoejpanaooao`aoaqolnklneapnekoa`]o]he]j]oa_kjie_]oalkhpe_]o `aopao_kicnqlko`apajpknao`alk`ana_kjie_kalkhpe_k*=ooei(lknjkd]rannaolaepk ]k`enaepk`aejbkni]k(jkd_kiknaolaep]nk`enaepkran`]`aen]l]npe_el]klkhpe_]* Kok^op_qhko`aik_n]_e]jkejre]^ehev]i]ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]*Lahk_kjpnnek*Ok) iajpajah]okiko_]l]vao`alan_a^anp]eok^op_qhkoahqp]n_kjpn]ahao*
@ebe_qh`]`aol]n]]`aik_n]_e]jk>n]oeh
L
anek`e_]iajpako^n]oehaenko]Úni]imqareraikojqi]`aik_n]_e](`alkeo`a_kj) _hq`]qi]b]oa`a]qpknep]neoik*Lkn`aik_n]_e]ajpaj`ai]ateopj_e]`aahae ao( `al]npe`kolkhpe_koa`]`ereoknalq^he_]j]`kopnolk`anao(]hi`]he^an`]`a`a lajo]iajpka`aatlnaook*Lkn]qpknep]neoikajpaj`aiqinaceia`ackranjkaimqa kAop]`kk_ql]`klkniaek`aqickhla$aican]hiehep]nkq_ki]lkekiehep]n%(jkd ahae aojail]npe`kolkhpe_ko(kLk`anAta_qperk`kiej]kHaceoh]perkakFq`e_enek(d _ajoqn]`klajo]iajpka`]atlnaook(]hi`alneok$lknravao_kipknpqn]aiknpa%`ko ejeieckolkhpe_ko*Aioqi](`aik_n]_e]a]qpknep]neoikokreopko_kik]hckmqaoana]hev] j]aoban]`kAop]`kaaopae`ajpeÚ_]`k_ki]bkni]`ackranjk* Aoo]reok_ac]l]n]]hckajn]ev]`kj]ok_ea`]`a^n]oehaen]6k]qpknep]neoikok_e]h* Jkoo] ok_ea`]`a ]qpknepne] lknmqa efboonrf`^( lkeo `ere`a ]o laook]o( ai mq]hmqan _en_qjop j_e]( ai ejbaneknao( mqa `arai k^a`a_an( a oqlaneknao( mqa `arai i]j`]n* Jk d lan_alk jai lnpe_] `] ecq]h`]`a _kik qi `enaepk* Jkoo] ok_ea`]`a p]i^i ]q) pknepne]lknmqarekhajp]$jkopanikoaimqa(jkaopq`k`]pe_](`aÚjeiko]rekhj_e]%6 jah]reckn]in]_eoik(i]_deoik(`eo_neiej]knaheceko]a`a_h]ooaok_e]h(`aoecq]h`]`ao a_kjie_]omqaaopkajpna]oi]eknao`kiqj`k(at_hqo ao_qhpqn]eoalkhpe_]o*Jkd lan_alkjailnpe_]`k`enaepkhe^an`]`a* K]qpknep]neoikok_e]ha]o`aoecq]h`]`aoa_kjie_]ob]vai_kimqa]ok_ea`]`a^n]) oehaen]aopaf]lkh]nev]`]ajpna]o_]nj_e]o`]o_]i]`]olklqh]naoakoejpanaooao`]o_h]ooao ]^]op]`]oa`kiej]jpao(oai_kjoacqenqhpn]l]oo]naoo]o_]nj_e]oaejpanaooaoa]h_]j]n] aoban]`ko`enaepko*Koejpanaooao(lknmqajkoapn]jobkni]iai`enaepko(pknj]i)oalnereh) ceko`a]hcqjo(`aoknpamqa]lkh]nev]kok_e]hoaabapq]ajpnako`aolkooq`ko$ko_]najpao%
1,3
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
a ko lnerehace]`ko* Aopao( lknmqa ok lknp]`knao `ko _kjda_eiajpko p_je_ko a _eajpÚ_ko( okkoÎ_kilapajpaoÏ(_]^aj`k)hdao]`enak`]ok_ea`]`a* ?kikreiko(qi]_]nj_e]oailnaaola_Ú_](oai_kjoacqencajan]hev]n)oajqiej) panaooa _kiqi jai qjerano]hev]n)oa jqi `enaepk* Qi lnerehcek( lkn `aÚjek( oailna l]npe_qh]n( jk lk`aj`k cajan]hev]n)oa jqi ejpanaooa _kiqi jai qjerano]hev]n)oa jqi `enaepk(lkeo(oap]hk_knnaooa(`aet]ne]`aoanlnerehcek*Kn](]`aik_n]_e]_ne]kac]n]jpe] `a`enaepko*Jkoo]ok_ea`]`a(lkh]nev]`]ajpna]_]nj_e]aklnerehcek(jk_kjoacqaoan`a) ik_npe_](lkeojkaj_kjpn]iaekol]n]eook* Aooa _kjfqjpk `a abqbojfk^ bp pl`f^fp i]jebaop])oa j] aoban] lkhpe_]* Ai hqc]n `a `aik_n]_e](paikoejopepqe aorej`]o`ah](i]omqaklan]i`aik`k]qpknepnek*=ooei( lknatailhk(kol]npe`kolkhpe_ko_kopqi]ioan`apnopelko6ko`ifbkqbifpq^p(mqai]jpi nah] ao`ab]rkn_kioaqoahaepknao(kos^kdr^oafpq^p(mqaoq^opepqaioaqoahaepknaolah] rkjp]`a`ko`enecajpaol]npe`neko(akomlmrifpq^p(mqapn]p]ioaqoahaepknao_kikqil]e `ab]ihe]$kabpmqbp%pn]p]oaqoÚhdkoiajknao* B]rkn(oq^opepqekal]panj]heoikare`aj_e]imqa]lnpe_]`]l]npe_el]klkhpe_]( lkniaek`analnaoajp]jpao(jk_kjoacqaoana]hev]njk>n]oeh*Konalnaoajp]jpao(aihqc]n `a_qilnenki]j`]pkmqahdaobke`]`klahkonalnaoajp]`ko(oqncai_kik_dabao(i]j) `]jpao(`apajpknao`ab]rknaoalk`anao(oq^iapaj`kkonalnaoajp]`ko(pn]jobkni]j`k)ko ai_heajpaomqana_a^aib]rknao`koi]j`]jpao* =Îej`opne]lkhpe_]Ï(]he]`]aopnqpqn]ok_e]h`kl]o(]heiajp]qiei]cejneklkhpe_k ]qpknepnek*=ohe`an]j]olkhpe_]ookoailnaei]cej]`]o_kik_dabaoo]hr]`knao`]j]k( ran`]`aenkoiaooe]oao_khde`kolkn@aqoanabanaj`]`kolahkrkpk`koahaepknao*J]ran`]`a( jkokikona]hiajpaahaepknao$komqaao_khdai%(i]oiankorkp]jpao$komqa`kkrkpk l]n]]hcqi%* =ei]cailklqheop]aiaooe je_]`kockranj]jpaoej`e_]mqa]_kj_alkpak_npe_] `klk`anjk`ao]l]na_aq6]ej`]oa]_na`ep]jkckranj]jpa_kikajre]`k`]o`erej`]`ao $kjiank`alkhpe_kohec]`ko]]opn hkckoare`ajpaob]h]lknoeiaoik%amqaoq]rkjp]`a paibkn]`ahae* =o haeo( lknmqa atlneiai kq ko lnerehceko `ko lk`ankoko kq ] rkjp]`a laook]h `ko ckranj]jpao(jkokreop]o_kikatlnaook`a`enaepkojai`arkjp]`aoa`a_eo aol^he_]o _khaper]o*KLk`anFq`e_enek]l]na_a_kikieopanekok(ajrkhpkjqio]^anej_kilnaajorah ajqi]]qpkne`]`amq]oaiope_]*Lkneookiaoik(]_aep])oamqa]hac]he`]`aoaf](lknqi h]`k(ej_kilnaajorah(a(lknkqpnk(ejaÚ_eajpa$]eilqje`]`ajknaej]hernaaokhp];%amqa ]je_]nah]klkoorah_kiah]oaf]]`]pn]jocnaook$kb]ikokÎfaepejdkÏ%* ?kikoak^oanr](]`aik_n]_e](jk>n]oeh(]ej`]aoplknoanejrajp]`]*
IND{STRIAßPOLqTICAßAßß CRIAljOßDAßIMAGEMßDOSß POLqTICOSßPELOSßMEIOSßDEß COMUNICAljOßDEßMASSAß PARAßAßVENDAßDOßPOLqTICOß AOSßELEITORES CONSUMI DORES
1,4
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
15%34¬%3
#!0É45,/ß =_qhpqn] -* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]hcqi]_keo]j]pqn]hkqlkn j]pqnav]; .* Kmqaoamqan`evanmq]j`koab]h]aij]pqnav]dq) i]j]; /* @]hcqjoatailhko`a]^oqn`ko`a_knnajpao`]j]) pqn]hev]k`ko_kilknp]iajpko(e`ae]oar]hknao`ko oanaodqi]jko* 0* Lknmqaejoqopajprah]e`ae]`aqi]j]pqnav]dq) i]j]qjerano]haejpailkn]h; 1* @atailhko`kornekooajpe`ko_kimqaqo]iko] l]h]rn]_qhpqn]aijkook_kpe`e]jk* 2* Ajqianakolnej_el]eooajpe`ko`]l]h]rn]j]pqnav]* 3* Ajqiana ko lnej_el]eo oajpe`ko `] l]h]rn] _qhpqn] j]=jpecqe`]`a* 4* Lknmqa(j]=jpecqe`]`a(_qhpqn]aj]pqnav]jkoa klqjd]i; 5* Kmqaoaajpaj`alkn_qhpqn]]l]npen`ko_qhkTREEE; -,* Lknmqa]_qhpqn]paj`a]oanlajo]`]_kik_erehev]) k]l]npen`ko_qhkTREEE; --* Mq]h]`ebanaj]aooaj_e]hmqakolajo]`knao]lkj) p]iajpnaj]pqnav]a_qhpqn]; -.* Aimqaikiajpk]_qhpqn]oapknj]oej jeik`adeo) p ne]; -/* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnakpailkj]j]pqnav]akpai) lkj]_qhpqn]kqj]deop ne]; -0* Lknmqaiqepkolajo]`knao_kjoe`an]imqa]_qhpq) n]_kia]mq]j`kkodkiajoejrajp]ikpn]^]hdk; -1* Atlhemqa]`eopejkg]jpe]j]ajpnanaejk`]ja_aooe) `]`aanaejk`]he^an`]`a* -2* LknmqaDacahfqhc]mqaLh]pka=neop pahaooaajc]) j]n]imq]jpk eilkooe^ehe`]`a`]_kjpn]`ekjk iqj`kna]h; -3* Mq]eo]o`q]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`]_kjpn]`e) k`e]hpe_]oacqj`kDacah; -4* Atlhemqa]jac]kejpanj]* -5* KmqaDacah_d]i]`aAolnepk; .,* AtlhemqakmqaoecjeÚ_]koqnceiajpk`]_kjo_ej) _e]kq`kÎl]n]oeÏjkmqa`evnaolaepk]koqnceiaj) pk`]_qhpqn]* .-* Kmqa]_qhpqn]l]n]I]nt; ..* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnakaolenepq]heoik`aDacahak i]pane]heoik`aI]nt; ./* Oacqj`kko]jpnkl hkcko(mq]eo]o`q]ohaeomqa`k ej_ek _qhpqn]; .0* Kmqaqi]haedqi]j];
1,5
.1* Atlhemqakmqakn`aioei^ he_]alknmqa]_qhpqn] ]ejopepqe* .2* Mq]eokolnej_el]eooajpe`ko`a_qhpqn]; .3* Mq]hkoajpe`knaopnepk`a_qhpqn];
#!0É45,/ßßß =atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`ka ]ejopepqek`]nahecek -* Lknmqalk`aiko]pne^qen _kjo_ej_e]]_]qo]lne) ikn`e]h`koqnceiajpk`]nahecekoe`]`a; .* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqaÎpaiko_kjo_ej_e]`kpai) lkÏ;?kikjkoo]nah]k_kikpailkjkpn]^]hdk; Aj]iai ne]; /* Lknmqa]_kjo_ej_e]`kpailkjkohar] _kjo_ej) _e]`]iknpa;Mq]hkl]lah`aoo]_kjo_ej_e]jkoqn) ceiajpk`]nahecekoe`]`a; 0* Kmqa]atlanej_e]`ko]cn]`k; 1* Kmqakaj_]jp]iajpk`kiqj`k; 2* Kmqako]cn]`k;Kmqapknj]]hcqi]_keo]kq]h) cqioano]cn]`ko; 3* Lknmqa]nahecekrj_qhk;Kmqaah]rej_qh]; 4* Atlhemqa_kik(airne]o_qhpqn]o(]hec]kajpnak o]cn]`k a k lnkb]jk oei^khev]`] jk ikiajpk `a bqj`]k`aqi]]h`ae]kq_e`]`a* 5* AtailheÚmqaqi_]ok`a_anei je]naheceko]aimqa ]l]na_a]hec]kbqj`]`kn]kq]nahecek* -,* Mqakaol]ko]cn]`k;?kikoa`eopejcqa`kaol]k lnkb]jk; --* Kmqakpailko]cn]`k; -.* Kmqakiepka]deop ne]o]cn]`]j]nn]i;Kmqalna) paj`aiatlhe_]n; -/* Kmqapakckje]; -0* Kmqa_koikckje]; -1* ?kikkpailko]cn]`k; -2* Lknmqa]nahecekoa`eneca oaik ao;Lknmqala`a okiajpabalea`]`a; -3* Lknmqaok_ne]`kokonepko; -4* Kmqaqinepk; -5* @kmqa`alaj`a]aÚ__e]`aqinepk; .,* Kmqaqik^fapkp]^q;@atailhko`ap]^qo* .-* Kmqaokkoai^hai]o;@atailhko`aai^hai]o `a`aqoao* ..* Mqaoknahece ao`]i]jebaop]k; ./* Mqaoknahece ao`]narah]k; .0* ?kik]onahece ao_kj_a^aiko`aqoaokqk`aqo; .1* ?kik]rkjp]`a`erej]lk`apknj]n)oa_kjda_e`]`ko dkiajo;
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_] ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
.2* Atlhemqa]`ebanaj]ajpnanahece ao`]narah]k`]o haeoanahece ao`]ehqiej]kiope_]* .3* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnakpn]joa`kolnkbap]oare`aj) paoakpn]joa`ktp]oaiope_k; .4* Lknmqafq`]oik(_neope]jeoikaeoh]ieoikokÎna) hece ao`khernkÏ; .5* Lknmqako`aqoaooailnab]h]ilknajeci]o(l]n) ^kh]oakn_qhko; /,* ?kik]onahece aoatlhe_]i]knecaikq]_]qo]`] iknpadqi]j]; /-* ?kik ]o nahece ao lnkiapai eiknp]he`]`a kq re`] ]l o]iknpa; /.* Lknmqa]onahece aolkooqainepq]eobqjanneko; //* ?kik]onahece ao`kaj_]jp]iajpk_kj_a^ai]re`] ]l o]iknpa; /0* ?kik]onahece ao`]o]hr]k_kj_a^ai]re`]]l o ]iknpa; /1* Mq]h]knecai`kiehaj]neoik_neopk; /2* Kmqakiehaj]neoik_neopk; /3* Lknmqakiehaj]neoik_kopqi]oan]naheceklklq) h]n`komqahqp]ilknfqope]abahe_e`]`a;@atai) lhko`aikreiajpkolkhpe_koiehaj]neop]o* /4* ?kikokk>aiakI]hj]onahece aolkhepaop]o(`q]) heop]oaikjkpaop]o; /5* Lknmqajkfq`]oik(_neope]jeoikaeoh]ieoik]kne) cai`kI]hqilnk^hai]; 0,* Lknmqajkfq`]oikajk_neope]jeoik]knecai`k I]haj_kjpn])oaj]o_ne]pqn]o;KmqakI]hjaoo]o nahece ao; 0-* Atlhemqakmqaoknahece ao`]atpanekne`]`a* 0.* Atlhemqakmqaoknahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`a* 0/* ?kik]onahece ao`]atpanekne`]`a_kj_a^ai]b]hp] dqi]j];?kik]b]hp]lqje`]alan`k]`]; 00* ?kik]onahece ao`]ejpanekne`]`a_kj_a^ai]b]hp]kq kla_]`kdqi]jk;?kik]b]hp]lqje`]alan`k]`]; 01* Mq]h]_]qo]`]b]hp]kq`kla_]`kj]onahece ao`] atpanekne`]`a; 02* Mq]h]_]qo]`]b]hp]kq`kla_]`kj]onahece ao`] ejpanekne`]`a; 03* Kmqakla_]`kjkfq`]oik; 04* Kmqakla_]`kjkeoh]ieoik; 05* Kmqakla_]`kknecej]h; 1,* Lknmqakla_]`kqilnk^hai]pakh ce_kejokhrah l]n]k_neope]jeoik; 1-* Mqaoknahece ao`]ei]jj_e]kql]jpaop]o; 1.* Mqaoknahece ao`]pn]jo_aj`j_e]kqpaop]o; 1/* ?kik k _neope]jeoik ejpnk`qv ] reoep]k `erej] `a i]jaen]]oqlan]n]o`eÚ_qh`]`aopakh ce_]o`aoo]re) oep]k; 10* ?kik a lkn mqa ko aj_]nnac]`ko `] ejpanlnap]k `]o i]jebaop] ao `erej]o a `ko nepq]eo oa pknj]i qicnqlk`alk`anjkejpanekn`]ook_ea`]`ao; 11* Lknmqa]]qpkne`]`anaheceko]]l]na_a_kik`apaj) pkn]`klnerehcek`ko]^an;Mqalk`anaolkooqe;
12* Lknmqa]o`kqpnej]onaheceko]opaj`ai]ejopepqen] e`ae]`adean]nmqe];Mq]h]ejÛqj_e]ok^na]knc]je) v]k`]ok_ea`]`a; 13* ?kikkoo]_an`kpaoatan_ai]rekhj_e]o]cn]`]; 14* Mq]eokoiaekoalnk_a`eiajpko`koo]_an`kpao_neo) pkol]n]atan_an]rekhj_e]o]cn]`]; 15* Mqa]danaoe];Mq]eoko_]iejdko`]ejopepqeko]) _an`kp]hl]n]lqjendanaoe]o; 2,* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eoÚj]he`]`ao`]nahecek; 2-* Mq]eo]o_npe_]omqakoÚh okbko]jpeckoÚvan]i na) hecek; 2.* ?kik(_ki^]oaj]oqlanopek(Aolejko]_nepe_]]o nahece ao; 2/* Mqabke]nahecekj]pqn]hkqk`aoik; 20* KmqaBaqan^]_dajpaj`aqlkn]heaj]knaheceko]; 21* K mqa I]nt mqeo `evan _kiÎ] nahecek k lek `k lkrkÏ; 22* KmqaI]ntmqeo`evan_kiÎ]nahecekh ce_]aaj_e) _hkl`e]lklqh]n(aolnepk`aqiiqj`koaiaolnepkÏ; 23* =lnaoajpa]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o`kiepk*Atlhe) mqa_kii]eo`ap]hdao`q]o`ah]o* 24* =lnaoajpa]hcqi]o`ebanaj]oajpnakiepkakÎhckoÏ* 25* =lnaoajpa]hcqi]o`ebanaj]oajpnak_najpaakÚh ) okbkjkpk_]jpa]kolnej_el]eopai]o`]nahecek* 3,* Kmqa]pakhkce]; 3-* Mqaokieopnekoa`kci]o`]b; 3.* @ atailhko `a ej_kil]pe^ehe`]`ao ajpna ran`]`ao `]baran`]`aoÚhko Ú_]okq_eajpÚ_]o* 3/* ?kikG]jplnk_qnkq_kj_ehe]nÚhkokÚ]anahecek; 30* ?kikDacahpn]p]]nah]kajpnanahecekaÚhkokÚ]; 31* ?kik]bajkiajkhkce]pn]p]]`ebanaj]ajpna]]pe) pq`anaheceko]a]]pepq`aÚhko Ú_];
#!0É45,/ßß Kqjeranok`]o]npao -* Kmqa(aican]h(]olaook]oajpaj`ailkn]npeop]; .* Kmqa(aican]h(]olaook]oajpaj`ailknk^n]`a ]npa; /* Kmqa(aican]h(]olaook]o`evaioajpen`e]jpa`]o k^n]o`a]npa;Lknmq; 0* Mq]eookkopno]ola_pkook^na]ok^n]o`a]npamqa aopklnaoajpaojklkjpk`areop]`kaola_p]`kn; 1* AtlhemqakmqaoecjeÚ_]]]lnktei]kmqaiqepko aop]^aha_aiajpnak^n]`a]npaa]npao]j]pk* 2* AtlhemqakmqaoecjeÚ_]]nah]kmqaiqepkoaop]^a) ha_aiajpnak^n]`a]npaa]jpecqe`]`a* 3* Atlhemqalknmqa]k^n]`a]npa]qjek`kapanjka `kjkrk* 4* Kmqak]npeop]^qo_]atlneienjqi]k^n]; 5* Kmqa]]npa(oacqj`kBannaen]Cqhh]n; -,* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna]b]h]b]h]`]kqejopepq`]a] b]h]b]h]jpakqejopepqejpa;
1-,
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
--* Atlhemqalknmqa]o]npaook]l]oo]cai`kejopepq) `k]kejopepqejpa* -.* Lknmqa]o]npaoj]o_aijkejpanekn`]re`]naheceko]; -/* Lknmqakolneiaenkok^fapko]npope_koan]iice_ko kqbape_daoako]npeop]oan]ibaepe_aenko; -0* Mqa oecjeÚ_] `evan mqa ko k^fapko b]^ne_]`ko lahko ]npeop]opejd]ir]hkn`a_qhpk; -1* Lknmqa(j]olneiaen]o_qhpqn]o(k]npeop]an]qii]ck( qieje_e]`kaiieopnekoaqikÚ_e]jpa`a_qhpko; -2* @ao_nar]_kikko]npeop]oa]npaokoaop]r]ioq^ia) pe`ko ]qpkne`]`anaheceko]kq ]qpkne`]`alkhpe_]* -3* Mqa oecjeÚ_] `evan mqa j]o ok_ea`]`ao ]jpec]o jk d]re]]]qpkjkie]`]o]npao; -4* Atlhemqakoajpe`k`]ol]h]rn]o]noapgdja* -5* Mq]hkoajpe`k]ilhk`a]nokqpgdja;Mq]hkoaq oajpe`kaopnepk;Mq]hkoaqoajpe`kcan]h; .,* Mq]h]`eopejk`]o]npaoaiLh]pk; .-* Mq]h]`eopejkbaep]lkn=neop pahaoajpna_ej_e]a ]npa; ..* Mq]h ] `eopejk baep] lkn =neop pahao jk _]ilk `] lnpe_] dqi]j]; Atlhemqa ] `eopejk ajpna ]k a b]^ne_]k* ./* Mq]eo]o`eopej ao]_nao_ajp]`]olahkojaklh]p je) _ko o`eopej ao]neopkphe_]o; .0* Lknmqa]o]npaobkn]i`ere`e`]oaihe^an]eoaoanreo; Mq]eoan]i]o]npaohe^an]eo;Mq]eo]ooanreokqia) _je_]o;Lknmqa]ohe^an]eoan]i_kjoe`an]`]ooqla) neknao oia_je_]o; .1* Mqamqan`evanÎia_je_]Ï(l]h]rn]qo]`]l]n]naba) nen)oa o]npaoi]jq]eo; .2* Lknmqa`qn]jpa]Naj]o_aj]dkqra]hqp]lah]r]hk) nev]k`]o]npaoia_je_]o; .3* Atlhemqa]`eopejk`]o]npaooacqj`kk_nepnek`k peha`k^ahk* .4* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo_kjoamqj_e]o`]oal]n]kaj) pna]npao`]qpehe`]`aa]npao`]^ahav]; .5* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa]o]npaookatlnaook_ne]`k) n]apn]^]hdkatlnaooerk; /,* AtailheÚmqa]i]jaen]_kikj]]npa_kjpailkn) ja]]npaap_je_]oa_kiqje_]iaoanah]_ekj]i* /-* Lknmqa(]l]npen`ko_qhkTT(]obnkjpaen]omqaoal]) n]i]npaap_je_]oapknj]n]iiqepkpjqao; /.* Mq]eo]olnej_el]eo`ebanaj]oajpnaqik^fapkp_je) _kaqi]k^n]`a]npa; //* Kmqa>ajf]iejajpaj`alknÎ]qn]Ï; /0* Mq]j`kqi]k^n]`a]npa]qnpe_]; /1* Mq]j`kalknmqa]ok^n]o`a]npalan`an]i]]qn]; /2* Naoqi]]olnej_el]eoe`ae]o`a>ajf]iejok^nakr]) hkn`a_qhpkakr]hkn`aatlkoek`]ok^n]o`a]npa* /3* Kmqa]]npalkpe_];Lknmqalnao_neper]kqjkn) i]per]; /4* Kmqaaoppe_];Mq]j`koqncanah]_ekj]`]_ki]o ]npao;
1--
/5* Mq]h k oajpe`k eje_e]h `] aoppe_]; Mq]h oaq oajpe`k ]pq]h; 0,* ?kik Hq_ Bannu atlhe_] k oqnceiajpk `] aoppe_] _kik`eo_elhej]Úhko Ú_]; 0-* Mq]eo an]i ko lnej_el]eo lnaooqlkopko `] aoppe_] jkoo_qhkoTREEEaTET;@kooaeolnaooqlkopkoajq) ian]`ko(ao_khd]`keoaatlhemqa)ko* 0.* KmqaoecjeÚ_]r]]`eopejkmqa]aoppe_]aop]^aha) _aqajpnak^ahkakran`]`aenk; 0/* Kmqakfqvk`ackopk; 00* Mq]h ] `eopejk baep] lkn G]jp ajpna `eolqp] a `eo) _qook;Lknmqakckopka]k^n]`a]npalk`aioan `eo_qpe`ko; 01* Lknmqa(]k]Úni]nmqakoajpeiajpk`k^ahkqje) rano]h(G]jpikopn]mqakfqvk`ackopklkoorah; 02* Atlhemqa_kik]k^n]`a]npalajo]`]j]ok_ea`]`a _kjpailknja]iajko_kiklnk`qka_kjpailh]) k `aoejpanaoo]`] `] ^ahav] a i]eo _kik pn]^]hdk `]atlnaook* 03* Atlhemqakmqa=neop pahaoajpaj`e]lkniiaoeo*Lkn mqa]k^n]`a]npaan]qi]iiaoeo; 04* Mq]j`k ] ÚhkokÚ] l]ookq ] `aÚjen ] k^n] `a ]npa _kik _ne]k oq^faper]; Mq]j`k l]ookq ] b]h]n ai ejolen]k; 05* Mq]j`k]aoppe_]oanabane] k^n]`a]npa_kik_ne]) krej`]`]ejolen]k(_kikre]k]npeop]; 1,* Atlhemqa_kik(l]n]]aoppe_](]k^n]`a]npa`aet] `aoanreop]_kikeiep]k`]j]pqnav]al]oo]]oan reop]_kikhe^an]k`e]jpa`]j]pqnav]* 1-* MqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqa(l]n]]ÚhkokÚ]`]]npa_kj) pailknja](]]npa_kj_a^e`]_kikpn]^]hdk`]at) lnaooka`]_kjopnqk; 1.* ?kik]aoppe_]_kjpailknja]_kj_a^ak]npeop]; 1/* Atlhemqalknmqa]aoppe_]_kjpailknja]oq^hejd] ]k^n]`a]npa_kikÚ_k* 10* L]npej`k`]`eopejkajpnaiqj`koajorahaejpahe) crahaajpna]npaoeiep]per]oafq`e_]per]o(_kikLh]) pk_kj_a^a]nah]kajpna]npaao]^an; 11* Lkn mqa ] _kj_alk lh]p je_] napki]`] a nabkn) iqh]`]`qn]jpa]Naj]o_aj]; 12* Mq]eo ]o pno i]jaen]o lah]o mq]eo k Nki]jpeoik _kj_a^a]]npa_kikkejopnqiajpkcan]h`]ÚhkokÚ]; 13* L]npej`k `] `eopejk ajpna pakne] a lnpe_]( _kik =neop pahao_kj_a^a]nah]kajpna]npaao]^an; 14* Kmqa]_kj_alkla`]c ce_]`]]npa; 15* LknmqaLh]pkat_hqe`]_e`]`alanbaep]]o]npaoeie) p]per]o; 2,* Kmqa=neop pahaoajpaj`e]lkn_]p]noa;Mq]hoaql]) lahpe_k; 2-* ?kik ] _kj_alk la`]c ce_] `] ]npa ]l]na_a ai G]jp; 2.* ?kikDacah]lnaoajp]oq]_kj_alkla`]c ce_]`] ]npa;
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_] ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
2/* Lknmqa]oaomqan`]o_kj_a^ai]o]npao`]j`k)hdao Új]he`]`ala`]c ce_]; 20* Kmqa]_kj_alkatlnaooer]`]]npa; 21* Atlhemqalknmqa]]npa_kj_a^e`]_kikatlnaooer] reop]_kikoei^ he_]* 22* Atlhemqalknmqa]]npa_kj_a^e`]_kikatlnaooer] reop]_kik]hac ne_]* 23* Mq]eo]o`q]oik`]he`]`ao`aiq`]j]omqa]bap]i ]o]npao; 24* Mqamqan`evanmqa]o]npaookok_e]hiajpa`apanie) j]`]o;Mq]eook]o`apaniej] aook_e]eo`]o]npao; 25* Atlhemqa]lkoek`komqab]h]iai]npalqn]kqj] ]npalah]]npa* 3,* Atlhemqakmqalajo]ikomqa`abaj`ai]]npaajc]) f]`]* 3-* Mq]eokolnk^hai]oa]o_kjoamqj_e]o`aoo]o`q]o _kj_al ao; 3.* Mq]j`klk`aiko`evanmqaqi]k^n]`a]npacn]j) `aa`qn]`kqn];
#!0É45,/ßß =_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h -* Atlhemqa lkn mqa k oqnceiajpk `ko Aop]`ko j]_ek) j]eo a `] e`ae] `a j]k lnkrk_] k j]o_eiajpk `]o e`ae]o`a]npaa_qhpqn]lklqh]nao* .* Atlhemqa lkn mqa oa `aq ] `ereok `] _qhpqn] a `]o ]npaoaianq`ep]alklqh]n*Atlhemqakmqaok_]`] qi]`ah]o* /* Kmqaoaajpaj`alknbkh_hkna; 0* Mq]h ] `ebanaj] ajpna bkh_hkna a ]npa kq _qhpqn] `a ahepakqanq`ep]; 1* Mq]eo ]o lnej_el]eo `ebanaj]o ]lkjp]`]o ajpna _qh) pqn]+]npaanq`ep]a_qhpqn]+]npalklqh]n;@alkeo`a ajqian)h]o(ao_khd]`q]oaatlhemqa)]o* 2* Mq]eo]o`q]o_kjoamqj_e]o_qhpqn]eoa]npope_]o`] rej`]`kopn]^]hd]`knaonqn]eol]n]]o_e`]`ao_kik klannekoej`qopne]eo; 3* Mqaan]kaj_]jp]iajpk`kiqj`k;Mqabkek`aoaj) _]jp]iajpk`kiqj`k;Mq]h]oq]_kjoamqj_e]l]n] ]o]npao; 4* Lknmqa>ajf]iejan]kpeieop]]kb]h]nj]`aopnqek `]]qn]kqj]nalnk`qkp_je_]`]ok^n]o`a]npa; 5* Lknmqa]pn]`qkaeilnaook`]>^he]lk`ane]fqo) peÚ_]nkkpeieoik`a>ajf]iej; -,* KmqaoecjeÚ_]]atlnaookÎej`opne]_qhpqn]hÏ;Mq]h oq]nah]k_kik_]lep]heoik; --* Oacqj`k=`knjkaDkngdaeian(mqapn]jobkni]k] ej`opne]_qhpqn]heil o o]npao; -.* Mq]eokoneo_komqa]o]npao_knnaiok^koabaepko`] i]ooeÚ_]k`]_qhpqn]lah]ej`opne]_qhpqn]h; -/* Kmqa`aik_n]_e]_qhpqn]h; -0* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnai]ooeÚ_]k_qhpqn]ha`aik) _n]pev]k`]_qhpqn];
-1* Atlhemqalknmqa]i]ooeÚ_]kna]hev]kklkopk`] `aik_n]pev]k_qhpqn]h* -2* KmqaoecjeÚ_]]atlnaookÎiaeko`a_kiqje_]k `ai]oo]Ï; -3* KmqaoecjeÚ_]]l]h]rn]i`e]; -4* Mqa`ebanaj]oI_Hqd]j]lkjp]ajpna]a`q_]kao) _kh]n j] =jpecqe`]`a a j] E`]`a I`e] a ai jkoo] lk_]; -5* Lknmqalk`aikob]h]naiÎejr]ok_qhpqn]hÏi]eo`k mqaaiejbkni]klahkoiaeko`a_kiqje_]k; .,* Kmqamqan`evan]l]h]rn]lnkl]c]j`];A]l]h]rn] lq^he_e`]`a; .-* Mq]eokoiaekoailnac]`kolah]lnkl]c]j`]_kian) _e]hl]n]raj`ankolnk`qpko; ..* Kmqa]lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]hlna_eo]b]vanl]n]oan aÚ_]v; ./* Mq]eo ]o `ebanaj]o ajpna ] lnkl]c]j`] `k o_qhk TETaej_ek`ko_qhkTTa]]pq]h; .0* =lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]hl]ookq]raj`anei]cajoa oecjko*Atlhemqaaoo]]Úni]k* .1* ?kik]lnkl]c]j`]_kian_e]hi]jelqh]ko`aoafko `]olaook]o; .2* ?kikoa`]_kilapeklkniaek`]_kjopnqk`a ei]cajo`kej`er`qk; .3* @atailhko`]bkn]`]opn]joieoo aon]`ekb je_]o* .4* Atlhemqakmqak>ec>nkpdan$Cn]j`aEnik%(mqa ]l]na_ajknki]j_a`aCakncaKnsahh(-540*?kikoa `aq]^]j]hev]k`aoo]Úcqn]lah]pahareok; .5* Atlhemqa ]o `ereo ao `a l^he_k( dknneko a _kjpa) `ko`kolnkcn]i]o`apahareokl]n]]paj`an oate) cj_e]o`kol]pnk_ej]`knao* /,* Lkn mqa ko jkpe_eneko `a pahareok jk ejbkni]i; ?kikpn]p]ikaol]k;Akpailk; /-* ?kik]opahajkrah]oklan]il]n]lnk`qvenkoajpe) iajpkehqo nek`ana]he`]`a; /.* Atlhemqa]`eolanok_]qo]`]lahkoiaeko`a_kiq) je_]k* //* Atlhemqa ] ejb]jpehev]k lnk`qve`] lahko iaeko `a _kiqje_]k* /0* ?kiklk`aikolan_a^ank]qpknep]neoik`koiaeko `a_kiqje_]k;Lknmqalk`aikob]h]naiÎejpeie) `]kok_e]hÏaaiÎej_qh_]kÏ; /1* Atlhemqalknmqa(`klkjpk`areop]a_kj ie_k(]paha) reok(aijkoo]ok_ea`]`a(jklk`aoan`aik_npe_]* /2* Oacqj`kI]j`an(mq]eo]oheiep] aopa_jkh ce_]o`] pn]joieookpahareoer];@alkeo`aajqian)h]o(ao_k) hd]qi]`ah]oaatlhemqa)]* /3* Oacqj`kI]j`an(kmqaÎpahareokj]^aiÏakmqaÎjk pahareokj]^aiÏ;Mqa_kj_hqo aolk`aikopen]n`ao) o]]jheoa; /4* Kmqa]pahareokaijkoo]ok_ea`]`a; /5* Kmqak_ejai];Mqabqjkaha_qilnaaijkoo] ok_ea`]`a; 0,* Mq]eo]o`q]olnej_el]eo`ebanaj]oajpnak_ejai]a ]pahareok;
1-.
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
0-* Ao_khd]qiÚhiamqark_pajd]reopkjkmq]h]bkn) i]ak_kjpa`kokran`]`aen]ona]hev] ao]npope) _]o*B]]qi^nara_kiajpnekok^naaha* 0.* ?kik=`]iO_d]bb`ebanaj_e]ko]jpeckok^fapkop_) je_ko`kojkrkok^fapkopa_jkh ce_ko; 0/* Kmqamqan`evanÎejbknipe_]Ï; 00* Kj`aoaaj_kjpn]ikojkrkok^fapkopa_jkh ce_kokq ]qp i]pkoejbknipe_ko; 01* Lknmqa]ejbknipe_]lnk`qv]Î_kilnaookaol]) kpailkn]hÏ;@atailhko* 02* KmqaájcahkOk]nao_d]i]`aÎiepk`k_kilqp]`kn ^kiÏ;Kmqaaooaiepkk_qhp]; 03* Mq]eokolnk^hai]o_khk_]`kolah]hejcq]caiejbkn) ipe_]; 04* Kmqaklk`anejbknipe_k; 05* Mq]eokolanecko`klk`anejbknipe_k;
#!0É45,/ß =ateopj_e] pe_] -* Mqakoajokikn]h;@]hcqjoatailhko* .* Mqa]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h;@]hcqjoatailhko* /* =mqaoanabanaikoajokikn]ha]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h; 0* Mq]h k lnej_el]h lnaooqlkopk `k oajok ikn]h a `] _kjo_ej_e]ikn]h;Lknmq; 1* Mqaqifqvk`ab]pk;@atailhko* 2* Mqaqifqvk`ar]hkn;@atailhko* 3* Lknmqakofqvko`ar]hknokjkni]perko; 4* Mq]h]knecai`]`ebanaj]ajpnafqvko`ab]pkafq) vko`ar]hkn;Atlhemqa* 5* Kmqa]j]pqn]hev]k`]re`]ikn]h;Lknmqaah] ]_kjpa_a; -,* Atlhemqakoajpe`k`]ol]h]rn]oikn]hape_]* --* =lao]n`]o`ebanaj]o_qhpqn]eoadeop ne_]o]naolae) pk`]rekhj_e](mqa`aÚjekcan]hlk`aiko`]n`] rekhj_e](rhe`]aipk`]o]o_qhpqn]o; -.* Mq]eokolnej_el]eo]ola_pko`kmqajkoo]_qhpqn]a ok_ea`]`aajpaj`ailknrekhj_e]; -/* Lknmqa]pe_]_kj`aj]alnk^a]rekhj_e]; -0* ?kikoai]jebaop]]_kjo_ej_e]ikn]h; -1* Kmqa]rkjp]`a;?kikah]`araoanl]n]oanpe_]; -2* Mq]eo]o_kj`e aol]n]mqad]f]qi]laook]ikn]h; -3* Atlhemqa]`ebanaj]ajpnal]ooere`]`aa]pere`]`a* -4* Kmqaok]orenpq`ao;=lao]n`]o`ebanaj]o_qhpq) n]eo( k mqa pk`]o ]o _qhpqn]o _kjoe`an]i mqa oaf] ] renpq`a; -5* Lknmqaj]pe_]jkoa]lhe_] atlnaookÎkoÚjofqo) peÚ_]ikoiaekoÏ;
1-/
#!0É45,/ßß =ÚhkokÚ]ikn]h -* ?kjoe`an]j`k)oa ko `keo oajpe`ko `] l]h]rn] cnac] pdko(mq]j`kj]o_a]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]hkq]`eo_elhej] Úh okÚ_]`ajkiej]`]pe_]; .* LknmqaO _n]paoej_kik`]r]ko]pajeajoao; /* Lknmqa]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]hkq]pe_]oaeje_e]_kiO ) _n]pao; 0* K mqa =neop pahao ajpaj`e] lkn ln teo; ?kik ] `eo) pejcqe]`]p_je_]; 1* Oacqj`k=neop pahao(mq]hk_]ilk`]o] aope_]o; Lknmqaaoo]_kj_alkat_hqekja_aoonekak_kj) pejcajpa `k _]ilk pe_k a ]Úni] ] eilknpj_e] `k lkoorah; 2* Atlhemqa ] `eopejk ]neopkphe_] ajpna k mqa Îlkn j]pqnav]ÏakmqaÎlknrkjp]`aÏ* 3* Kmqakdkiailnq`ajpa(oacqj`k=neop pahao; 4* Mq]hkhac]`kpe_k`koÚh okbko]jpecko; 5* ?kik ko ]jpecko _kj_a^e]i ] re`] pe_]; Lkn mqa( l]n]ahao(]rkjp]`aan]pkeilknp]jpa; -,* Mq]eo ko pno ]ola_pko lnej_el]eo `] pe_] `ko ]jpe) cko;Ao_khd]`keo`ahaoaatlhemqa)ko* --* Mq]eo]oiq`]j]oj]pe_]]jpec]pn]ve`]olahk_neo) pe]jeoik; -.* Atlhemqa]_kj_alk_neop`k`aran* -/* Mq]eook]orenpq`ao_neopo; -0* Mq]eookkola_]`ko_]lep]eo; -1* Mq]eokopelko`a_kj`qp]`aÚje`kolahk_neope]jeo) ik; -2* Kmqa]_kj_alk_neop`]ejpajk; -3* ?kikNkqooa]qlnk_qn]naokhranklnk^hai]`]nah]) kajpna]he^an`]`a`]rkjp]`aak`aran;Atlhemqa _kioq]ol]h]rn]okmqa]Îikn]h`k_kn]kÏ* -4* Mqa`ebanaj]G]jpaop]^aha_aajpnan]vklqn]pa ) ne_]an]vklqn]lnpe_]; -5* K mqa G]jp _d]i] `aÎnaejk `] ja_aooe`]`aÏ; A `a Înaejk`]he^an`]`aÏ; .,* Oacqj`kG]jp(kmqak`aran; .-* Mqa`ebanaj]G]jpaop]^aha_aajpnaejpanaooaa`aran; ..* Kmqakeilan]perk_]pac ne_k; ./* Mq]eook]oitei]oikn]eo(oacqj`kG]jp;Atlhe) mqa)]o* .0* KmqaG]jp_d]i]`aÎrkjp]`a^k]Ï; .1* Ao_khd]qiatailhkjkmq]h]oitei]oikn]eoa keilan]perk_]pac ne_koknaolaep]`kolahk]cajpa ikn]h* .2* Ao_khd]qiatailhkaimqa]oitei]oikn]eoak eilan]perk_]pac ne_kjkoknaolaep]`kolahk]caj) paikn]h* .3* Mq]eo]o_npe_]o`aDacah]Nkqooa]qa]G]jp; .4* KmqaDacah_d]i]`arkjp]`ak^faper]; .5* KmqaDacahajpaj`alknikn]he`]`a;Lknmqa]ik) n]he`]`a_qhpqn]hadeop ne_];
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_] ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
/,* Oacqj`kDacah(kmqa]re`]pe_];Mq]j`kah]oa na]hev]lhaj]iajpa; /-* Oacqj`kDacah(aimqaikiajpkqi]ikn]hajpn] ai`a_hjek;@qiatailhk* /.* Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpnaikn]h]^anp]aikn]hba_d]`]( oacqj`k>ancokj; //* =lkjpa]hcqi]o`ebanaj]oajpna]pe_]]neopkphe_] a]pe_]_neop* /0* ?kikAolejko]`aÚjako]bapko;Mq]h]`ebanaj]ajpna ]bapkol]ooerkokql]et aoa]bapko]perkokq] ao; /1* LknmqaAolejko]fqhc]]ol]et aoj]pqn]eo;Mq]eook ]opnol]et aoknecejne]okqlneieper]o; /2* Atlhemqa k mqa qi] l]etk pneopa a qi] l]etk ]hacna* /3* Oacqj`kAolejko](kmqaoanre`kdqi]j]; /4* Oacqj`kAolejko](kmqa]renpq`a; /5* Oacqj`k Aolejko]( _kik l]oo]iko `]o l]et ao o ] ao(`]oanre`k he^an`]`a; 0,* ?kikI]_Ejpuna_kj_a^a]renpq`a;Lknmqa]renpq) `alnkle_e]qje`]`aa_kanj_e] jkoo]re`]pe_]; 0-* Oacqj`kI]_Ejpuna(aimqaikiajpkoa`]iq) `]j]pe_]; 0.* Atlhemqa]`eopejkpe_]ajpnan]_ekj]haenn]_ekj]h* Lknmqa]pknpqn]enn]_ekj]ha(lknp]jpk(eikn]h; 0/* Mq]hkamqrk_k`aoaoqlknmqadqi]lhqn]he`]`a `ape_]ojkejpanekn`aqi]iaoi]ok_ea`]`a;Lkn mqaai_]`]ok_ea`]`ad]laj]oqi]pe_]; 00* K mqa k n]_ekj]heoik pe_k; L]n] k n]_ekj]heoik pe_k(kmqa]ÚhkokÚ]ikn]h; 01* Kmqakejpaha_pq]heoikpe_k; 02* Kmqakrkhqjp]neoikpe_k; 03* Mq]eo]o`ebanaj]oajpnarkjp]`aa`aoafk; 04* Kmqakaikpereoikpe_k; 05* =lnaoajpa pno `ajpna ]o rne]o e`ae]o `a Jeapvo_da `aoajrkhre`]oj]k^n]Caja]hkce]`]ikn]h* 1,* Atlhemqa ] `ebanaj] jeapvo_de]j] ajpna ikn]h `ko ao_n]rkoaikn]h`kooajdknao* 1-* Mqa_npe_]oJeapvo_da(Bnaq`aI]ntÚvan]i ikn]h recajpaj]lk_]aimqareran]i; 1.* Lknmqa]`ao_k^anp]`kej_kjo_eajpalknBnaq`lk) `ane] _kilnkiapan ] e`ae] `] pe_] _kik atan__ek herna`]_kjo_ej_e]a`]rkjp]`a; 1/* Lknmqa(`ab]pk(]loe_]jheoa(_ki]lnpe_]`k]q) pk_kjda_eiajpka_ki]atlhe_]k`]knecaia`ko lnk^hai]o`kÎe`a]h`kackÏ(jkeila`a]pe_]aoei ]b]v]r]j]n]klnklknqi]jkr]ikn]hoatq]h;
#!0É45,/ßß =he^an`]`a -* Atlhemqa ] klkoek ajpna ja_aooe`]`a a he^an`]`a* Lknmqa]ja_aooe`]`akqb]p]he`]`al]na_aat_hqen] he^an`]`a; .* Atlhemqa]klkoekajpna_kjpejcj_e]ahe^an`]`a*
Lkn mqa ] _kjpejcj_e] kq k ]_]ok l]na_a at_hqen ] he^an`]`a; /* Bkniqha _ki oq]o l]h]rn]o qi atailhk ai mqa ] ja_aooe`]`al]na_aeila`en]he^an`]`a* 0* Bkniqha _ki oq]o l]h]rn]o qi atailhk ai mqa ] _kjpejcj_e]kq]_]okl]na_aeila`en]he^an`]`a* 1* Atlhemqalknmqajai]ja_aooe`]`ajai]_kjpej) cj_e]eila`aina]hiajpa]he^an`]`a* 2* Atlhemqa]_kj_alk]neopkphe_]`ahe^an`]`a* 3* Atlhemqa]_kj_alko]npne]j]`ahe^an`]`a*Kmqa O]npnamqeo`evan]k]Úni]nmqaÎaop]iko_kj`aj]) `ko he^an`]`aÏ; 4* Atlhemqa_kioq]ol]h]rn]o]i]jaen]_kikaopke_ko( Aolejko]aDacaharep]iklknhe^an`]`aaja_aooe`]) `a(]Úni]j`kmqa]he^an`]`ajkqilk`anrkhqj) pnek`aao_khd]aoei]]kja_aoone]`kpk`k* 5* Atlhemqa_kikkoaopke_koaDacah`aÚjai]he^an`]) `adqi]j]* -,* Atlhemqa_kikAolejko]`aÚja]he^an`]`adqi]j]* --* ?kikDacahatlhe_]koqnceiajpkdeop ne_k`]Úcqn] `kej`er`qkherna; -.* Atlhemqa]_kj_alk`]he^an`]`a_kikÎlk`anb]) vanÏa_kikÎlkooe^ehe`]`ak^faper]Ï* -/* Atlhemqa ] jkk `aÎlkoorahÏ a ] _kj_alk `] he) ^an`]`a _kik ]^anpqn] pailkn]h kq _kik nah]k _kiklkoorah* -0* ?kiajpakpatpk`aIanha]q)Lkjpuaimqa]he^an`]) `aoa]lnaoajp]_kiklkooe^ehe`]`ak^faper]ejo_nep] jkln lnekiqj`k* -1* Lknmqalk`aiko`evanmqa]he^an`]`ajkooklk) `anl]n]`]nqioajpe`kjkrk o_kj`e ao`ab]pk`a jkoo]ore`]o; -2* Atlhemqa lkn mqa( l]n] ko oanao dqi]jko( re`] a iknpaok]_kjpa_eiajpkooei^ he_ko*
#!0É45,/ßßßß pe_]a_ej_e] -* Atlhemqalknmqa(aijkoo]_qhpqn](k_]ilk`kja) _aoonekl]na_apan`eiejq`kajmq]jpkk_]ilk`k lkoorahl]na_apan]qiajp]`k* .* Lkn mqa ]o atlhe_] ao _eajpÚ_]o( ia`e`] mqa oa pknj]ii]eo]_qn]`]o(pknj]i)oap]i^ii]eoao) la_Ú_]oai]eobn]ciajp]`]o;Mq]eo]o_kjoamqj) _e]o`eook; /* Lkn mqa ] cajpe_] a ] ajcajd]ne] cajpe_] ok ei) lknp]jpaol]n]j o; 0* Lknmqaklk`anek`]oailnao]olner]`]oa`k_ki) lhatkej`qopne]hiehep]nb]vai_kimqa]olaomqeo]o aicajpe_]aajcajd]ne]cajpe_]_neaionekolnk) ^hai]ope_ko; 1* Atlhemqaklnk^hai]`]naolkjo]^ehe`]`aikn]hjk pk_]jpa ]k qok `k _kjda_eiajpk cajpe_k _kjpai) lknjak*
1-0
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
2* Atlhemqakolnk^hai]ope_kopn]ve`kolah]e`ae]`a _kjpnkha`]dana`ep]nea`]`a* 3* Lknmqajklk`aiko]_aep]n]e`ae]`aÎ`kaj]caj) pe_]Ïp]jpk`klkjpk`areop]_eajpÚ_k_kik`klkjpk `areop]ikn]h; 4* Iaj_ekjakolna_aepko`]Cajpe_](bkniqh]`kolkn OqvqgeaGjq`opkj* 5* Ao_khd]pno`kolna_aepko`]Cajpe_]aatlhe_epa)ko*
#!0É45,/ß =re`]lkhpe_] -* Aimqaoajpe`ko_kopqi]ikoqo]n]l]h]rn]lkhpe) _];Atlhemqa)ko* .* ?epa kqpnko oajpe`ko mqa _kiqiajpa ]pne^qiko lkhpe_]aatlhemqa)ko* /* Kmqamqanaiko`evanmq]j`knah]_ekj]iko]lkhpe) _] o]pere`]`ao`kckranjk; 0* J]arkhqk`]ook_ea`]`ao(kmqak_nao_eiajpk`]o ]pne^qe ao`kockranjko]_]nnapkq o]pere`]`aolk) hpe_]ojkpk_]jpa caopk`a ncko]`iejeopn]perko aknc]jev]_ekj]eo; 1* Kmqaajpaj`aikolknlkhpe_]mq]j`k]]ook_e]iko] ]pere`]`aoatan_e`]olknaola_e]heop]oalnkÚooekj]eo; 2* Mq]h k oecjeÚ_]`k `] lkhpe_] i]eo _knnajpa l]n] k oajok_kiqiaok_e]h;Atlhemqa)k* 3* Mqal]n]`ktkateopaajpnakoajpe`k`]lkhpe_]_kik `aÚje`kn]`ahaeoa_kopqiao(`enaepkoak^nec] ao( _ne]`kn] `a aol]ko l]n] _kjpaop]k( naoeopj_e] a `aok^a`ej_e](akoajpe`klanranokai]hÚ_kl]n] ]ok_ea`]`a; 4* @qiatailhk`kabaepk`kl]n]`ktkateopajpaaj) pnakooajpe`ko`]lkhpe_]* 5* Atlhemqalknmqa]ei]cai`]lkhpe_]_kikqilk) `ani]hÚ_k(ah]ln lne](l]n]`kt]h* -,* Mqa b]pko _kjpne^qai l]n] mqa( ai can]h( oa pajd] qi]reokjac]per]`]lkhpe_]; --* Mqa ]ncqiajpk l]n]`kt]h lk`aiko qo]n _kjpn] ko b]pkojac]perko`]lkhpe_]; -.* Mq]h]knecaiakoecjeÚ_]`k`]l]h]rn]lkhpe_]; -/* Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`kopanikolheoa_erep]o; -0* Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`kopanikop]lkhepeg]anaolq^he_]; -1* Kmqaoamqan`evanmq]j`koa]Úni]mqakocnackoa konki]jkoejrajp]n]i]lkhpe_]p]h_kik]_kjda) _aikodkfaai`e]; -2* Mqapelk`alk`anateope]]jpao`]ook_ea`]`aocna) _k)nki]j]o;?epa_]n]_panope_]o`aooapelk`alk`an* -3* Aop]^aha]qil]n]hahkajpna]_kj_alk`ab]ihe] j]=jpecqe`]`aaaijkoo]lk_]* -4* ?ki^]oaj]nah]k`alk`anaoj]ok_ea`]`al]pne]n) _]h(atlhemqa]oacqejpaatlnaook6Î=mqehkmqa]ln]v ]knaepaibkn]`ahaeÏ* -5* Aimqa_kjoeope]]lnklnea`]`a`apann]j]ok_ea`]`a l]pne]n_]h;
1-1
.,* Mqa_]n]_panope_]opejd]klk`anj]ok_ea`]`al]) pne]n_]h; .-* Mqa]ola_pkopknj]n]ilnkl_e]]ejrajk`]lkh) pe_]; ..* Aimqaia`e`]]lnklnea`]`a`apann]olnkle_ekqk oqnceiajpk`]lkhpe_]; ./* Aimqaia`e`]]qn^]jev]klnkle_ekqkoqnceiaj) pk`]lkhpe_]; .0* Aimqaia`e`]]`ereokpannepkne]hoqo_epkqkoqnce) iajpk`]lkhpe_]; .1* ?epa ]hcqjo pn]ko mqa lkooe^ehep]n]i ]ko cnacko a ]konki]jkoejrajp]naiklk`anlkhpe_k* .2* Mq]h]eilknpj_e]`kaol]kl^he_kl]n]]_kjokhe) `]k`]lkhpe_]j]ok_ea`]`acna_k)nki]j]; .3* Mqa_kjpn]`e aod]re]j]ok_ea`]`acna_k)nki]j]( `klkjpk`areop]`]lkhpe_]; .4* =khkjck`]deop ne](]ok_ea`]`al]pne]n_]ha]lkhpe) _]bkn]i`q]onaolkop]ook_e]eo omqaop ao`klk`an* =hi`aoo]o`q]obkni]o(mqakqpnk_]iejdkbkelnk) lkopk]aoo]omqaop ao(jko_qhkTT(mqaikaopq`kq abkniqhkqamq]eooq]olnej_el]eo_]n]_panope_]o; .5* ?kik]pn]`ek]jpnklkh ce_]aqnklae]re]]ook_ea) `]`aoateopajpaoj]o=ine_]o(j]lk_]`aoaq`ao) _k^neiajpk; /,* Mqaapjk_ajpneoik; /-* Mq]eo]o]pne^qe ao`k_dabajqi]ok_ea`]`a_kiq) jepne];
#!0É45,/ßß =oÚhkokÚ]olkhpe_]o$-% -* Mq]eobkn]i]opnoatlhe_] aolnej_el]eoai]eo`q) n]`kqn]ook^na]knecai`]re`]lkhpe_]; .* Atlhemqa]atlnaookÎ]n]vkbqj`]]lkhpe_]Ï* /* Atlhemqa]atlnaookÎ]_kjrajkbqj`]]lkhpe_]Ï* 0* Atlhemqa]atlnaookÎ]j]pqnav]bqj`]]lkhpe_]Ï* 1* L]n]kocnacko(mq]han]]Új]he`]`a`]re`]lkhpe_]; 2* =oej`]c] aook^na]cjaoa`]lheokl aikookÚo) p]o$`abajoknao`k_]npan_kjraj_ekj]h`]fqope]%] Lh]pka=neop pahao$`abajoknao`k_]npanj]pqn]h`] fqope]a`]hae%*Atlhemqajkmqa_kjoeope]]lkoek `a_]`]qi* 3* KmqaoecjeÚ_]ikork_^qhkocnacko]ngdagn]po( mqaaopkj]bkni]k`]ol]h]rn]omqa`aoecj]iko naceiaolkhpe_ko; 4* Mqa ok ikj]nmqe]( khec]nmqe]( lkhe]nmqe] a ]j]n) mqe]; 5* Mqaok]qpk_n]_e](]neopk_n]_e]a`aik_n]_e]; -,* Mq]eook]opnoe`ae]olkhpe_]oah]^kn]`]olknLh]) pka=neop pahaomqapilkn^]oa]atlanej_e]lkh) pe_]]jpec];?kiajpa)]o* --* Aimqak^n]lkhpe_]eilknp]jpa`]Ehqopn]k]pelk) hkce]`aLh]pka=neop pahao]l]na_a_kireckn;
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_] ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
-.* ?epa `keo ikperko lkn mqa oa lk`a `evan mqa Nki] an]qi]nal^he_]* -/* Mqa an]( j] Nki] ]jpec]( k e`a]h `k lnj_ela kq k >kiCkranjk; -0* Atlhemqa]opn]`e aoda^n]e_]anki]j]ok^]lano) la_per]`kj]o_ajpa_neope]jeoik* -1* Mq]han]]bqjk`keilan]`knkq_o]njkEilnek Nki]jk; -2* Aimqa_kjpatpka`amqabkni]oa_kjopepqeqk_neo) pe]jeoik; -3* Aimqaia`e`]]oaep]_neopoa`ebanaj_ekq`akqpn]o oaep]o;Lknmq; -4* ?epaaatlhemqa]o^]oaoaimqabkebqj`]`]]nahecek _neopa_kikah]oapknjkq]nahecekkÚ_e]h`kEil) nekNki]jk* -5* Lknmqa( ia`e`]mqakEilnekNki]jkoaaob]_ah]) r](klk`anek`]Ecnaf]_nao_e]; .,* Mq]eokopnolk`anaomqa]Ecnaf]]`mqena_kikl]o) o]n`ko]jkoainah]k]kEilnekNki]jk; .-* Mqaan]]>^he]; ..* =opakne]opakh ce_k)lkhpe_]o$krj_qhkejpanjkajpna nahecek a lkhpe_]%( ai^kn] peraooai `ebanajpao bkn) iqh] ao jk _knnan `] E`]`a I`e]( ]lnaoajp]r]i lkjpkoai_kiqjo*?epapno`ahaoa_kiajpa)ko* ./* Kmqabke]Îmqanah]`]oejraope`qn]oÏ; .0* ?kik]Îmqanah]`]oejraope`qn]oÏbkeokhq_ekj]`]; .1* Aimqaoa^]oa]r]kaobknkl]n]oal]n]n]Ecnaf]`k lk`anpailkn]h`]_kiqje`]`alkhpe_](jkÚj]h`] E`]`aI`e];Mqapa hkckoaop]r]iajrkhre`kojao) o]mqaopkamqae`ae]o`abaj`e]i; .2* Mqaokk`enaepkj]pqn]hk^faperkak`enaepkj]pqn]h oq^faperk;L]n]mqaoanrai; .3* Mq]eo]o_kjoamqj_e]o`klajo]iajpk`aPkio`a =mqejkaCqehdania`aK_gd]il]n]]pakne]lkh) pe_]; .4* Kmqaan]k`enaepk`anaoeopj_e]`koo`epko`kpe) n]jk;
#!0É45,/ßß =oÚhkokÚ]olkhpe_]o$.% -* ?epa]hcqjob]pkomqalnkle_e]n]ikoqnceiajpk`k e`a]h nalq^he_]jk _kjpn] k lk`an lkhpe_k)pakh ce_k `kol]l]oaeilan]`knao(jkÚj]h`]E`]`aI`e]* .* MqabkekNaj]o_eiajpk; /* Mqanah]kd]re]ajpna]oe`ae]ooqnce`]ojkNaj]o) _eiajpka]=jpecqe`]`acna_k)nki]j]; 0* ?kil]na]opakne]oia`ear]eoa]opakne]onaj]o_aj) peop]ojkpk_]jpa lkhpe_]a nahecek* 1* Ai^kn]`erancajpao(]opakne]oia`ear]eoa]opakne]o naj]o_ajpeop]opejd]ip]i^ilkjpkoai_kiqi* ?epa`keo`ahaoa_kiajpa)ko* 2* Aimqaoepq] aokqreiko]oatlnaoo aoi]mqe]r) he_kai]mqe]raheoik;
3* MqaibkeJe_kh]qI]mqe]rah; 4* AimqaJe_kh]qI]mqe]rahbke`ebanajpa`kopa hkcko ia`ear]eoa`aoaqo_kjpailknjakonaj]o_ajpeop]o l]n]bqj`]iajp]noaqlajo]iajpk; 5* Mq]h]eilknpj_e]`]k^n]Klnj_ela(`aI]mqe]rah; -,* Ai mqa _kjoeopa ] nqlpqn] `] k^n] i]mqe]rahe]j] ainah]k pn]`eklkhpe_]; --* Oacqj`kKlnj_ela(pk`]_e`]`aaop`ere`e`]ai`keo `aoafkoklkopko*Mqa`aoafkookaooao;Atlhemqa)ko* -.* Mq]h(l]n]I]mqe]rah(klkjpk`al]npe`]`]lkhpe) _];Atlhemqa* -/* Mq]h(l]n]I]mqe]rah(]Új]he`]`a`]lkhpe_]; -0* Mq]h(l]n]I]mqe]r]h(]h ce_]`]lkhpe_]; -1* Kmqalajo]r]I]mqe]rah]naolaepk`]e`ae]`k>ki Ckranjkaj_]nj]`]jklnj_elarenpqkok;Atlhemqa* -2* Kmqalajo]I]mqe]rah`]hacepeie`]`aa`]ehacepe) ie`]`a`amqai`apiklk`an; -3* Mqae`ae]oI]mqe]rah`aikha_kioq]k^n]; -4* Kmqaan]]klkoekrenpq`a)bknpqj]; -5* @amqai]jaen]I]mqe]rahnapki]]klkoekrenpq) `a)bknpqj];Mqajkrkooajpe`koaha`]aoo]klkoek; .,* KmqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqaÎ]h ce_]lkhpe_]j]`]pai ] ran _ki ]o renpq`ao pe_]o `ko ej`er`qko ai oq] re`]lner]`]Ï;Mqa_kj_aepkoI]mqe]rahej]qcqn]]k lna_kjev]np]eoe`ae]o; .-* Ai b]_a `]o naolkop]o ]jpaneknao ok^na I]mqe]rah( lknmqaahabkereopk_kikÎi]mqe]rhe_kÏ(jkoajpe) `klafkn]perkmqadkfa_kiqiajpaailnaop]iko] aoo]l]h]rn];Kmqa(]Új]h(mqanai`evankopaniko i]mqe]rhe_kai]mqe]raheoik; ..* Ai mqa _kjoeope] ] e`ae] `a ok^an]je] $oqii] lk) paop]o%(pn]ve`]l]n]]`eo_qooklknI]mqe]rah;Mqa lajo]`knen`aoajrkhrank_kj_aepk`aok^an]je]j] ik`anje`]`a; ./* ?kiajpakolnej_el]eolkjpko`]pakne]`aFa]j>k) `ej]kbkniqh]n]e`ae]`aok^an]je]* .0* Mqa_kjoamqj_e]oklajo]iajpk`aI]mqe]rahpara ok^na]pakne]lkhpe_]; .1* ?epakolnej_el]eob]pkook_eklkhpe_koaa_kj ie_komqa k_knne]ijkiqj`kk_e`ajp]hjkoo_qhkoTRaTRE* Mqaabaepkoperan]iok^na]ook_ea`]`ao`]lk_]; .2* Mqajkrkob]pkok_kjpatpkok_eklkhpe_kaa_kj ie) _k`koo_qhkoTRaTREoqo_epkq; .3* Mqaan]kaop]`k`aj]pqnav]kq_kj`ekj]pqn]h; .4* ?kikoa`aq]l]oo]cai`kaop]`k`aj]pqnav]l]n] kaop]`k_erehkqok_ea`]`a_ereh; .5* Mqaan]kfqoj]pqn]heoikkq`enaepkj]pqn]h; /,* Mq]h k oecjeÚ_]`k `a ok_ea`]`a _ereh( ]k pailk `a Dk^^aoaNkqooa]q; /-* L]n]Dk^^ao(mqaian]kok^an]jk; /.* L]n]Nkqooa]q(mqaian]kok^an]jk; //* Mqalajo]r]iDk^^aoaNkqooa]q]naolaepk`]lnk) lnea`]`alner]`];
1-2
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
/0* Atlhemqaklajo]iajpk`aFkdjHk_ga_kinah]k lnklnea`]`alner]`]_kik`enaepkj]pqn]hpaj`klkn ^]oakpn]^]hdk* /1* Mqa_kjoamqj_e]o]pakne]`]lnklnea`]`alner]`] _kik`enaepkj]pqn]h(lnklkop]lknFkdjHk_ga(pnkq) tal]n]]ok_ea`]`ak_e`ajp]h; /2* Mq]h]bqjk`kAop]`koacqj`k]pakne]he^an]h; /3* Mq]h k oecjeÚ_]`k `aÎ]jpeckÏ j] atlnaook =jpeck Naceia; /4* Aimqaikiajpklk`aiko`evanmqapaiÚik=j) peckNaceia;Mqab]pkok_kilnkr]i; /5* ?kikoa`(j]lnpe_](]]pq]k`kAop]`khe^an]h; 0,* Mqab]pkoejÛqaj_e]n]ikAop]`khe^an]h(]ilhe]j`k ]_e`]`]je]lkhpe_]; 0-* Mqabkn]i]onarkhq ao^qncqao]o; 0.* Mq]hkoajpe`kknecej]h`]l]h]rn]narkhq k;?kik ah]l]ookq]b]vanl]npa`krk_]^qhneklkhpe_k; 0/* Kmqamqan`evan]atlnaookÎnarkhqkj]narkhq) kÏ; 00* =o_h]ooaolklqh]naojklkooq]ipakne]olkhpe_]o`a pelkÚhko Ú_ka_eajpÚ_k*Mq]eoan]ioq]obkjpao`a nabanj_e]ol]n]atlhe_]nkiqj`kaimqarere]i; 01* Aimqa_kjoeope]kei]cejnekiaooeje_kaiehaj]) neop]`]o_h]ooaolklqh]nao; 02* ?kik lk`aiko `aÚjen ] aooj_e] `k he^an]heoik; Mqa`eopej aoaoo]pakne]aop]^aha_e]ajpnaok_ea`]) `a_erehaAop]`k; 03* Har]j`kai_kjp]]naolkop]`]mqaopk]jpanekn(_kik lk`aikoatlhe_]n]b]_alklqh]n`]onarkhq ao; 04* ?epapnooecjeÚ_]`kolkhpe_ko`]onarkhq ao(oacqj) `kkÚh okbkbn]j_o?h]q`aHabknp* 05* Atlhemqa]b]_a^qncqao]he^an]ha]b]_alklqh]n`]o narkhq aoik`anj]o* 1,* Koqnceiajpk`]Úcqn]`klnkhapnekkqpn]^]hd]`kn ej`qopne]hb]rkna_ak]l]na_eiajpk`]opakne]ook_e]) heop]o*Mqa`eve]iaoo]opakne]o;Aimqaoa^]oa]r]i;
#!0É45,/ßßß =lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`krkhqjpne] -* Kmqaoaajpaj`alknpn]`ekhe^anpne]; .* Kmqabkn]i]onarkhp]oiehaj]neop]o; /* Atlhemqa]`eo_qook`]oanre`krkhqjpne]lnklko) p]lahkÚh okbkbn]j_oH]>kpea* 0* Reiko mqa ]o pakne]o ok_e]heop]o ok ]mqah]o mqa oa bqj`]ij]onah] aook_e]eoaj]o] aook_e]eo(eopk (mqana_qo]i]oal]n]khe^an]hajpnaok_ea`]`aa Aop]`kalnk_qn]ij]]pere`]`aok_e]hkobqj`]iaj) pko `k lk`an a]klkhpe_ko* Mq]eook ]opno_kn) najpaook_e]heop]oik`anj]o; 1* Mqaok_e]heoikqp le_k; 2* Atlhemqakoajpe`k`]l]h]rn]qpkle]* 3* Mqa]j]nmqeoik;
1-3
4* Mqaok_e]heoik_eajpÚ_k;Mq]eobkn]ioaqolnej_e) l]eopa ne_ko; 5* Mqal]n]hahklk`aikoaop]^aha_anajpnaI]mqe]raha I]nt; -,* Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`aÎa_kjkie]lkhpe_]Ï;Aimqaoa ^]oa]r]ioq]obkniqh] ao; --* Aimqa_kjoeope]i]o_npe_]o a_kjkie]lkhpe_]kq he^an]heoika_kj ie_k; -.* Mqa`eve]I]nt`khe^an]heoika_kj ie_k; -/* =ej`]j]hejd]`an]_ek_jek`]o_npe_]o]khe^an]heo) ika_kj ie_k(mqaan]kAop]`kjko_qhkTET; -0* ?ki^]oaj]opnomqaop ao]jpaneknao(kmqaoalk`a `a`qven`]nah]kajpnaa_kjkie]alkhpe_]; -1* ?kikDacahatlhe_]]cjaoa`kAop]`kik`anjk; -2* KmqaI]ntmqan`evan]k]Úni]nmqaÎkodkiajook deopkne_]iajpa`apaniej]`koÏ; -3* ?kikk_knnaj]lnpe_]]`ereokok_e]h`kpn]^]hdk; -4* Jk`a_knnan`]deop ne](_kikoa`ajkiej]i]olnk) lnea`]`ao`a]_kn`k_kikoik`ko`alnk`qk;At) lhemqa^naraiajpa_]`]qi]`ah]o* -5* Mqa i]pane]heoik deop ne_k; Lkn mqaÎi]pane]heo) ikÏ;AlknmqaÎdeop ne_kÏ; .,* Aimqaikiajpkoqncalah]lneiaen]ravk_kj_aepk `ai]pane]heoik; .-* KmqaoecjeÚ_]`evanmqaki]pane]heoikdeop ne_k `e]hpe_k; ..* Atlhemqak_kj_aepki]nteop]`a]heaj]k* ./* Mqae`akhkce](oacqj`kI]nt; .0* Aimqaia`e`]]e`akhkce]lkop]]oanrek`]_h]ooa `kiej]jpajqi]ok_ea`]`a; .1* Aimqaikiajpk`]deop ne]oqnca]e`akhkce]; .2* Lknmqalk`aiko`evanmqa]e`akhkce]qibaj ia) jkik`anjk; .3* Mq]h]bqjklneikn`e]h`]e`akhkce]; .4* Lknmqalk`aiko`evanmqa(ainah]k]kpn]^]hdk( ateopaqi]_kjpn]`ekajpnakmqaklnkpaop]jpeoik( k_]lep]heoikakhe^an]heoiklna_kjev]ia]ln teo har]`]]abaepklah]lkhpe_]jko_qhkTET; .5* Mqapn]^]hdk(oacqj`k]opaoaoi]nteop]o; /,* @amqai]jaen]]e`akhkce]qpehev]]e`ae]`aÎpn]) ^]hdkÏ; /-* ?kikI]ntr]nah]kajpnak_]lep]heoikakpn]) ^]hd]`kn; /.* Mqa_kjpn]`e aoateopaiajpnakmqalna_kjev]i] e`akhkce]^qncqao]ak_kpe`e]jk`kpn]^]hd]`kn; //* Mqae`ae]k_kj_aepk`a_]lep]hej]qcqn]j]deop ne]; /0* Atlhemqa]]Úni]k`aI]ntoacqj`k]mq]hkr]) hkn`]oian_]`kne]ojk`apaniej]`klahkoaqqok( i]olahkoaqr]hkn`apnk_]* /1* Mqa l]lah ko pn]^]hd]`knao ]oo]h]ne]`ko `aoaila) jd]i jk ik`k `a lnk`qk _]lep]heop]( oacqj`k I]nt; /2* Mqako]hnek(j]_kj_alki]nteop]; /3* Mq]jpkr]ha]ian_]`kne])pn]^]hd]`kn;
x5.)$!$%ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_] ßxKiqj`k`]lnpe_]
/4* Mqai]eo)r]he]; /5* Lknmqajkoalk`a_kjbqj`en]pakne]i]nteop]_ki ]opakne]oqp le_]oahe^anpne]o; 0,* Ai mqa _kjoeopa ] ok_ea`]`a _kiqjeop]( oacqj`k I]ntaAjcaho; 0-* KmqaoecjeÚ_]]atlnaookÎ`ep]`qn]`klnkhap]ne]) `kÏ; 0.* LknmqaI]nt_kjoe`an]r]mqa]narkhqk_kiqjeo) p]oane]]hpei]narkhqklklqh]n;
#!0É45,/ß =oatlanej_e]olkhpe_]o`ko _qhkTT -* Lknmqa]NarkhqkNqoo]`a-5-3_kjpn]ne]r]]h ce) _]kncje_]`]opaoaoi]nteop]o; .* Mqaibkekoqfaepk`]NarkhqkNqoo](qi]ravmqa ]_h]ooalnkhapne]knc]jev]`]j]Nooe]an]mq]oaeja) teopajpa; /* Mqa`eÚ_qh`]`aoajbnajpkq]Narkhqk`aKqpq^nk; 0* Mqaan]ikookreapao; 1* Mqa`aoecj]]atlnaookÎnarkhqklani]jajpaÏ; 2* Mqaia`e`]o]`kpkqOp]hej]k]ooqienklk`an(ai -5.0; 3* Mqakpkp]hep]neoik; 4* Mqakb]o_eoik; 5* Mqakj]veoik; -,* Mqa]ola_pko_kiqjolkooqaikj]veoikakb]o_eoik; --* Mqa]jpehe^an]heoik; -.* Mqaj]_ekj]heoik; -/* Mqa_knlkn]pereoik; -0* ?kikkbqj_ekj]iajpk`aqi]ok_ea`]`aj]mq]h qije_kl]npe`kknc]jev]]oi]oo]o; -1* MqaoecjeÚ_]]atlnaookÎe`akhkce]`a_h]ooai`e] kqlamqajk)^qncqao]Ï; -2* Kmqakeilane]heoik^ahe_eop]; -3* Aimqaeilhe_]]Îa`q_]kikn]ha_re_]Ï; -4* Mqalnkl]c]j`]`ai]oo]; -5* ?kikoa`]lnpe_]`]_ajoqn]a`]`ah]kj]ook) _ea`]`aopkp]hepne]o; .,* Mqan]_eoik; .-* Mqaaop]peoik; ..* Mq]eoko]ola_pkolnej_el]eo`kop]hejeoik; ./* @a mqa bkni] k op]hejeoik _kilnkiapaq ]o paoao i]nteop]o;?epapno]ola_pkoaimqaeookk_knnaq* .0* Mq]eo ]o _kjoamqj_e]o `k op]hejeoik j] ]jpec] QjekOkrepe_]; .1* Kmqabke]cqann]bne];Lknmqapejd]aooajkia; .2* KmqaÚ_kqoaj`kkoi^khk`]cqann]bne]; .3* Kmqaan]]_d]i]`]Î_knne`]]ni]iajpeop]Ï; .4* ?kikpaniejkq]cqann]bne]; .5* Mqaan]i]ch]ojkopa]lanaopnkeg]; /,* Kmqa`aoecj]]atlnaookÎok_e]h)`aik_n]_e]Ï; /-* KmqabkekAop]`k`a>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h$Sahb]naOp]pa%; @amqabkni]bkeeilhaiajp]`k; /.* Mq]eoan]i]o^]oao`kAop]`k`a>ai)Aop]nOk_e]h;
//* ?kik klan]r]i ko bqj`ko l^he_ko; K mqa aooao bqj`konalnaoajp]n]ij]lnpe_]; /0* Lknmqad]re]laneck`anarkhq ao_kiqjeop]ojko l]oao`kajpk_d]i]`kPan_aenkIqj`k; /1* Mqaia`e`]okol]oao`k^hk_k_]lep]heop]]`kp]n]i l]n]eila`en]onarkhq aojkajpkPan_aenkIqj`k; /2* Mqa k jakhe^an]heoik; K mqa aha nalnaoajpkq j] lnpe_](`ao`amqabkeeilhaiajp]`k; /3* Mqaaop]cÛ]k; /4* Ai mqa oa ^]oakq k jakhe^an]heoik ]l o ] _neoa `a -53,; /5* L]n] k a_kjkieop] ^n]oehaenk Bn]j_eo_k `a Kheraen]( mqab]pkobkn]ib]rknraeo]koqnceiajpk`kjakhe) ^an]heoik; 0,* =ej`]oacqj`kBn]j_eo_k`aKheraen](lknmqa]pakne] jakhe^an]hlnkl okaj_khdeiajpk`kAop]`k; 0-* Mqalnej_lekokneajp]n]i]ok_ea`]`a_]lep]heop]`k ej_ek`ko_qhkTT]pko]jko-53,; 0.* Atlhemqaainle`]ol]h]rn]okolnej_el]eo]ola_pko `k_]lep]heoikj]]pq]he`]`a*
#!0É45,/ßßß =mqaopk`aik_npe_] -* P]jpkkhe^an]heoik_kikkAop]`k`a>ai)Aop]nOk) _e]h `aÚjai ] `aik_n]_e] _kik naceia `] hae a `] kn`ail]n]]c]n]jpe]`]ohe^an`]`aoej`ere`q]eo*K mqaeookoecjeÚ_]; .* K mqa oa mqan `evan mq]j`k oa ]Úni] mqa( `ao`a ] Narkhqk Bn]j_ao]( Î] `aik_n]_e] bkni]h( jk _kj_nap]Ï; /* Kmqaoamqan`evanmq]j`koa]Úni]mqaÎ]e`akhk) ce] jk j]o_a `k j]`] jai nalkqo] jk r]vek( i]o atlneia(`ai]jaen]ejranpe`](`eooeiqh]`]aei]ce) jne](]ln teook_e]hadeop ne_]_kj_nap]oÏ; 0* Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`]oahae aojqi]`aik_n]_e]; 1* Jqi]`aik_n]_e](mqaoecjeÚ_]i]oe`ae]o`aoepq]) kaklkoek(`ai]ekne]aiejkne]; 2* MqaoecjeÚ_]]Úni]nmqa]oe`ae]o`aecq]h`]`aahe) ^an`]`a_kik`enaepko_ereo`ko_e`]`korkiqepk ]hi`aoq]nacqh]iajp]kfqn`e_]bkni]h; 3* Atlhemqaaimqaia`e`]qi`enaepk`ebana`aqi] ja_aooe`]`akq_]nj_e]kq`aqiejpanaooa* 4* ?ki ^]oa j] naolkop] `] mqaopk ]jpanekn( ai mqa ikiajpklk`aiko`evanmqaqi]ok_ea`]`a$ajk qioeilhaonaceia`ackranjk%`aik_npe_]; 5* Mq]eokopno`enaepkobqj`]iajp]eomqa`aÚje]ik _e`]`kj]Cn_e]]jpec]; -,* Mqa oecjeÚ_]r] ] ecq]h`]`a j] Cn_e] ]jpec]; Mqa ]Úni]r]I]nt]aooanaolaepk; --* Kmqaj]ran`]`aaoplknpno`]ob]h]o`a=neop pa) haoa`aI]nt(]naolaepk`]ecq]h`]`a; -.* Mq]hkoecjeÚ_]`k`]he^an`]`aj]Cn_e]]jpec]; -/* Mq]eo]o_kjoamqj_e]o(jk`a_qnok`]deop ne](`k_kj) _aepk`ahe^an`]`ap]h_kikkocnackokajpaj`e]i;
1-4
=_qhpqn]x#!0É45,/ßx
-0* Ecq]hiajpa_kikk_knna_ki]jkk`aecq]h`]`a( ateopaqi`ao_kil]ookajpna]`a_h]n]k`k`enaepk
he^an`]`a a ] oq] ejopepqek _kj_nap]* ?kik aoo] `erancj_e]oanaokhraj]lnpe_]ok_e]h; -1* KmqaoecjeÚ_]r]]l]npe_el]kjklk`an(j]Cn_e] ]jpec]; -2* = `aik_n]_e] cnac] an] `enap]7 ] ik`anj] nalna) oajp]per]*KmqaeookoecjeÚ_]; -3* Mqaoaajpaj`alknÎ`enaepkook_e]eoÏ; -4* MqaokÎiejkne]oÏ; -5* =ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]ejopepqe`enaepkolah]]^an) pqn] `k _]ilk ok_e]h _ne]k `a `enaepko na]eo( ]ilhe]k`a`enaepkoateopajpaoa _ne]k`ajkrko `enaepko(kmqa_kjbana]ah]pn]komqa]`eopejcqai `apk`]o]okqpn]obkni]ook_e]eoalkhpe_]oateopaj) paojk`a_qnok`]deop ne]*Mqapn]kookaooao; .,* Mqalner]pev]k;A`aonacqh]k;Aimqaia`e`] aop]olnpe_]o]bap]ikik`k`alnk`qk_]lep]heop]; .-* Mq]eokoabaepko`knle`k`aoajrkhreiajpk`]ona) _ajpao pa_jkhkce]o ahapn je_]o `] ejbkni]k jk iqj`k_kjpailknjak; ..* ?ki k jakhe^an]heoik( dkqra qi aj_khdeiajpk `] aoban]l^he_]aqi]h]nc]iajpk`]aoban]lner]`]* Kmqaeooknalnaoajp]j]lnpe_];
./* Atlhemqa]oal]n]kajpna`enecajpaoaata_qp]jpao j]knc]jev]kej`qopne]h`kpn]^]hdkmqaoak^oanr] j]]pq]h`ereokok_e]h* .0* Mqa]e`akhkce]`]_kilapj_e]p_je_k)_eajpÚ_]; ?kikah]ejpanbanaj]lkhpe_];Mqa_kjpn]`e aopn]v _kjoeck; .1* @amqabkni]koiaeko`a_kiqje_]k`ai]oo]oa _kjopepqaijqik^op_qhk]k`enaepk l]npe_el]k lkhpe_]; .2* Lknmqalk`aiko]Úni]nmqakok^op_qhko `aik) _n]_e]jkejre]^ehev]i]ok_ea`]`a`aik_npe_]; .3* Lknmqalk`aiko`evanmqa]ok_ea`]`a^n]oehaen] ]qpknepne]; .4* Ain]vk`aoaq]qpknep]neoikok_e]ha`aoq]o`aoe) cq]h`]`aoa_kj ie_]o(aimqa^]oaoaop]ooajp]`] ]ok_ea`]`a^n]oehaen]; .5* Atlhemqa`amqaik`k(j]lnpe_](]ok_ea`]`a^n]oe) haen]jk_kjoacqaoan`aik_npe_]* /,* Mqaoaajpaj`alknÎej`opne]lkhpe_]Ï; /-* Kmqaaoplknpno`]ei]cailklqheop]aiaooeje) _]`kockranj]jpao; /.* ?kikokreop]o]ohaeoaijkoo]ok_ea`]`a;
,EITURASßRECOMENDADAS =`knjk6Iof`^bpl`fba^ab7Jfkfj^jlo^if^ =`knjkaDkngdaeian6Af^iqf`^albp`i^ob`fjbkql =neoppahao6qf`^^Kf`j^`l7Mliqf`^ >]_kj6KlslLod^klk7Kls^>qi kqfa^ >ajf]iej6>l_o^ab^oqbk^ml`^abpr^obmolar lq`kf`^7 Qbpbppl_ob^cfilplcf^a^efpqof^ @ahaqva6Lnrb^cfilplcf^nqjk6Alrkfsboplcfkfql D]^ani]o6Q`kf`^b`fk`f^bknr^kqlfablildf^7@lkp`fk`f^ jlo^ib^dfo`ljrkf`^qfsl Dacah6Molmbarqf`^cfilpcf`^7Lpfpqbj^a^sfa^qf`^7Fkqol* ar l efpqof^a^cfilplcf^ Dae`accan6Lnrbfpql7^cfilplcf^cfilplcf^`ljl`fk`f^ofdlolp^7>fabf^a^cbkljb* klildf^
1-5
G]jp6Molibdjbklp^qla^jbq^cpf`^nrbmobqbka^^mobpbk* q^o*pb`ljl`fk`f^7>obifdflklpifjfqbpa^pfjmibpo^wl7 Molgbqlabm^wmbomqr^ Hae^jev6Afp`roplabjbq^cpf`^7Jlk^alildf^ Hk_ga6@^oq^pl_ob^qlibo k`f^7Pbdrkalqo^q^alpl_obldl* sbokl I]n_qoa6Bolpb`fsfifw^ l7Leljbjrkfafjbkpflk^i I]nt6J^kfcbpqlalm^oqfal`ljrkfpq^7P^iofl)mob lbir`ol7 M^o^^`oqf`^a^b`lkljf^mliqf`^7L.5?orjoflabIrfp ?lk^m^oqb Ianha]q)Lkjpu6Bildfla^cfilplcf^7Llielblbpmofql Ikjp]ecja6Bkp^flp Ikjpaomqeaq6Lbpmofqla^pibfp Jeapov_da6 L k^p`fjbkql a^ qo^daf^7 Dbkb^ildf^ a^ jlo^i7 >ppfjc^ilrW^o^qrpqo^ L]o_]h6Mbkp^jbkqlp Lh]pk6I^nrbp7>mlildf^abP`o^qbp7>Obm _if`^ Nkqooa]q6Bkp^flpl_ob^lofdbja^abpfdr^ia^ab7Bkp^flpl* _ob^lofdbja^pikdr^p7L`lkqo^qlpl`f^i O]npna6Lnrbifqbo^qro^7Nrbpqbpabjqlal O_dklajd]qan6Oahak`apatpkojkrkhqia`]?khakLaj) o]`knao O ja_]6A^sfa^cbifw7A^qo^knrfifa^aba^^ij^ Pdki]oIknqo6>Rqlmf^ Rkhp]ena6@^oq^pfkdibp^p Seppcajopaej6Qo^q^`qrpildf`l*mefilplmef`rp
).$)#!a¬%3ß")",)/'2Æ&)#!3
).$)#!a¬%3ß")",)/'2Æ&)#!3 -*K^n]o`a]lkek =>>=CJ=JK(J*Af`flkoflabcfilplcf^*OkL]qhk6IaopnaFkq( -54.* *Efpqof^a^cfilplcf^*Heo^k]6Lnaoaj](-525*-0r* >NDEAN(A*Efpqof^a^cfilplcf^*OkL]qhk6IaopnaFkq(-533* 2r* ?DáPAHAP(B*$Knc*%*Efpqof^a^cfilplcf^+Fabf^p)alrqofk^p*Nek `aF]jaenk6V]d]n(-530*4r* F=LE=OOQ( D* Af`flkofl ab cfilplcf^* Nek `a F]jaenk6 V]d]n( -55,* H=H=J@A( =* Sl`^_riofl q`kf`l b `oqf`l a^ cfilplcf^* Ok L]qhk6I]npejoBkjpao(-552* .*J]o_eiajpk`]BehkokÚ] F=ACAN(S*M^fabf^7]bkni]k`kdkiaicnack*OkL]qhk6 I]npejoBkjpao(-522* RANJ=JP(F*)L*Jfqlbmbkp^jbkqlbkqoblpdobdlp+Nek`aF]) jaenk6L]vaPann](-55,* SKHBB(B*P`o^qbp+Lploofpla^o^wl+OkL]qhk6>n]oeheajoa( -54.* VEJC=JK(I*Mi^qlb>ofpqqbibp+Lc^p`kfla^Cfilplcf^+Ok L]qhk6K`uooaqo(.,,.* /*K^n]oejpnk`qpne]ook^nakoÚhokbko Na_kiaj`]iko6 korkhqiao`]?khakH cko(`]Ik`anj]7 korkhqiao`]?khakAj_]jpkN]`e_]h(`]>n]oeheajoa7 korkhqiao`a`e_]`koBehkokbe]j]?khakL]ook]L]ook( `]V]d]nA`epknao* 0*K^n]oejpnk`qpne]ook^na]or ne]o`eo_elhej]o ÚhkoÚ_]o =HRAO(N*Cfilplcf^a^`fk`f^+OkL]qhk6>n]oeheajoa(-54.* >=N>KO=( F* ?* L nrb grpqf ^* Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa( -542* $LneiaenkoL]ooko%* >=NPDAO(N*Jfqlildf^p+OkL]qhk6@ebah(-541* >ANJ=N@AP(F*)?*Lnrb`fkbj^+OkL]qhk6>n]oeheajoa(-54,* ?=O=NKPPK( K*7 HAEPA( I* L* O* L nrb mpf`^kifpb+ Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa(-540*$LneiaenkoL]ooko%* ?D=QE(I*Lnrbfablildf^$nar*a]ilh*%*OkL]qhk6>n]oe) heajoa(.,,-*$LneiaenkoL]ooko%* ?KHHE(F*Lnrb^oqb+OkL]qhk6>n]oeheajoa(-54-*$Lneiaenko L]ooko%* ?KOP=( ?* P* L nrb ^k^onrfpjl+ Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa( -54,* AHE=@A( I* L p^do^al b l molc^kl+ > bppk`f^ a^p obifdfbp+ Heo^k]6Hernko`k>n]oeh(o*`* CN=JCAN(C*C*Idf`^bcfilplcf^a^p`fk`f^p+OkL]qhk6Ia) hdkn]iajpko(-511* CQHH=N(B*Pl_ob^oqb+OkL]qhk6=rajen(-54.* DQEOI=J(@*>bpqqf`^+Heo^k]6A`e ao3,(-540*
GNAIAN)I=NEAPPE(=*>qf`^+?]ilej]o6L]lenqo(-545* HA>NQJ(C*Lnrbmlabo+OkL]qhk6>n]oeheajoa(-541*$Lne) iaenkoL]ooko%* HUN= BEHDK( N* L nrb afobfql+ Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa( -55,* $LneiaenkoL]ooko%* IKNEJ(A*@riqro^abj^pp^pklp`rilUU+Lbpmofqlalqbj* ml+Nek`aF]jaenk6Bknajoa(-525* JQJAO( >* Fkqolar l cfilplcf^ a^ ^oqb+ Ok L]qhk6 ãpe_]( -545* KIJåO( N* Cfilplcf^ a^ `fk`f^ `lkqbjmlo kb^+ Ok L]qhk6 A`*`]Qjaol(-552* L=QHK JAPPK( F* L nrb j^oufpjl+ Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa( -542*$LneiaenkoL]ooko%* LEJPK(L*N*I*Fkqolar l idf`^pfj_if`^+>ahkDknevkj) pa6A`*`]QBIC(.,,-* MQENEJK(?*7OKQV=(I*P*O*`a$Knco*%*Lmbkp^jbkqlmliqf`l `ippf`l+ J^nrf^sbi) El__bp) Il`hb) Jlkqbpnrfbr) Olrp* pb^r+OkL]qhk6P*=*Mqaenkv(-54,* NQ>U( ?* Fkqolar l cfilplcf^ mliqf`^+ Ok L]qhk6 A`epkn] `]Qjaol(-554* O=JPKO( F* B* L nrb mp*jlabokl+ Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa( -54/* OK=NAO( =* O* L nrb fkclojqf`^+ Ok L]qhk6 >n]oeheajoa( -544*$LneiaenkoL]ooko%* R=HHO(=*Lnrbqf`^+OkL]qhk6>n]oeheajoa(-542*$Lneiae) nkoL]ooko%* R=OMQAV( =* O* qf`^+ Nek `a F]jaenk6 ?erehev]k >n]oehaen]( -542* 1*?khapja]o`aoahaao`apatpko(_ki]lnaoajp]k a_kiajp neko >KNJDAEI(C*=*$Knc*%*Lpcfiplclpmo*pl`oqf`lp+OkL]qhk6 ?qhpnet(-533* HEI=(H*?*$Knc*%*Qblof^a^`riqro^abj^pp^+Nek`aF]jaenk6 L]vaPann](-534* I=N?KJ@AO BEHDK( @* $Knc*%* Qbuqlp _pf`lp ab cfilplcf^+ Alp mo*pl`oqf`lp^Tfqqdbkpqbfk+Nek`aF]jaenk6FkncaV]d]n( -555* SABBKNP(B*$Knc*%*Lp`ippf`lpa^mliqf`^+OkL]qhk6ãpe_]( -55-* 2*Patpko`koÚhokbko Na_kiaj`]iko6 ] _khak Ko Lajo]`knao( `] Jkr] ?qhpqn]h( Ok L]qhk* Ko rkhqiao rk `ao`a ko beh okbko ln)ok_npe_ko ]p ko _kjpailkn jako7 ]_khakPatpkoBehko be_ko(`]oA`e ao3,(`aHeo^k](_ki pn]`q ao]jpa_a`e`]o`alamqaj]oejpnk`q ao7 ]opn]`q ao`ak^n]obehko be_]o_hooe_]o(ik`anj]oa_kj) pailkn ja]o`]I]npejoBkjpao(OkL]qhk7 ]opn]`q ao`apatpkobehko be_ko`]_khakPn]raooe]o(`] A`epkn]`]QBIC(`a>ahkDknevkjpa*
1.,
#ONVITEßgß&ILOSOFIA I]nehaj]?d]qe
-ANUALßDOß0ROFESSOR 3FTQPTUBTEBTRVFTU{FT
SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVmkP°1BSBRVFGJMPTPGJB 6OJEBEF°"NFUBGrTJDB 6OJEBEF°"GJMPTPGJB
*OUSPEVmkP°"TJOEBHBm{FTNFUBGrTJDBT
$BQrUVMP°"PSJHFNEBGJMPTPGJB
$BQrUVMP°0OBTDJNFOUPEBNFUBGrTJDB
$BQrUVMP°0OBTDJNFOUPEBGJMPTPGJB
$BQrUVMP°"NFUBGrTJDBEF"SJTUwUFMFT
$BQrUVMP°$BNQPTEFJOWFTUJHBmkPEBGJMPTPGJB
$BQrUVMP°"TBWFOUVSBTEBNFUBGrTJDB
$BQrUVMP°1SJODJQBJTQFSrPEPTEBIJTUwSJBEBGJMPTPGJB
$BQrUVMP°"POUPMPHJBDPOUFNQPSiOFB
$BQrUVMP°"TQFDUPTEBGJMPTPGJBDPOUFNQPSiOFB
$BQrUVMP°"GJMPTPGJBQwTNFUBGrTJDB
6OJEBEF°"SB[kP
6OJEBEF°"DJpODJB
$BQrUVMP°"SB[kP $BQrUVMP°"BUJWJEBEFSBDJPOBM $BQrUVMP°"SB[kPJOBUBPVBERVJSJEB $BQrUVMP°0TQSPCMFNBTEPJOBUJTNPFEPFNQJSJTNP TPMVm{FTGJMPTwGJDBT $BQrUVMP°"SB[kPOBGJMPTPGJBDPOUFNQPSiOFB
$BQrUVMP°"BUJUVEFDJFOUrGJDB $BQrUVMP°"DJpODJBOBIJTUwSJB $BQrUVMP°"TDJpODJBTIVNBOBT $BQrUVMP°0JEFBMDJFOUrGJDPFBSB[kPJOTUSVNFOUBM 6OJEBEF°0NVOEPEBQSgUJDB $BQrUVMP°"DVMUVSB
6OJEBEF°"WFSEBEF $BQrUVMP°*HOPSiODJBFWFSEBEF $BQrUVMP°#VTDBOEPBWFSEBEF
$BQrUVMP°"FYQFSJpODJBEPTBHSBEPFBJOTUJUVJmkP EBSFMJHJkP $BQrUVMP°0VOJWFSTPEBTBSUFT
$BQrUVMP°"TDPODFQm{FTEBWFSEBEF
$BQrUVMP°"DVMUVSBEFNBTTBFBJOE|TUSJB DVMUVSBM
6OJEBEF°"MwHJDB
$BQrUVMP°"GJMPTPGJBNPSBM
$BQrUVMP°"FYJTUpODJBnUJDB $BQrUVMP°0OBTDJNFOUPEBMwHJDB
$BQrUVMP°"MJCFSEBEF
$BQrUVMP°&MFNFOUPTEBMwHJDB
$BQrUVMP°cUJDBFDJpODJB
$BQrUVMP°"MwHJDBTJNCwMJDB
$BQrUVMP°"WJEBQPMrUJDB $BQrUVMP°"TGJMPTPGJBTQPMrUJDBT
6OJEBEF°0DPOIFDJNFOUP
$BQrUVMP°"TGJMPTPGJBTQPMrUJDBT
$BQrUVMP°"QSFPDVQBmkPDPNPDPOIFDJNFOUP
$BQrUVMP°"QPMrUJDBDPOUSBBTFSWJEkPWPMVOUgSJB
$BQrUVMP°"QFSDFQmkP
$BQrUVMP°"TFYQFSJpODJBTQPMrUJDBTEPTnDVMP99
$BQrUVMP°"JNBHJOBmkP
$BQrUVMP°"RVFTUkPEFNPDSgUJDB
$BQrUVMP°"MJOHVBHFN $BQrUVMP°0QFOTBNFOUP $BQrUVMP°"DPOTDJpODJBQPEFDPOIFDFSUVEP
.
Manual do Professor
3FTQPTUBTEBTRVFTU{FT )NTRODUljOßßßL]n]mqabehkokbe]; 2VFRVFSEJ[FSBQBMBWSBDSrUJDB $SrUJDBWFNEPHSFHPFQPTTVJUSpTTFOUJEPTQSJODJQBJT DB QBDJEBEFQBSBKVMHBS EJTDFSOJSFEFDJEJSDPSSFUBNFOUF FYBNF SBDJPOBMEFUPEBTBTDPJTBTTFNQSFDPODFJUPFTFNQSFKVMHB NFOUP BUJWJEBEFEFFYBNJOBSFBWBMJBSEFUBMIBEBNFOUFVNB JEFJB VNWBMPS VNDPTUVNF VNDPNQPSUBNFOUP VNBPCSB BSUrTUJDBPVDJFOUrGJDB 2 VBOE PQBTT BN PTEBBUJU VE FDPTU VN FJS BhBUJU VE FGJ MPTwGJDB /PNPNFOUPFNRVFPRVFFSBPCKFUPEFDSFOmBBQBSFDF DPNPBMHPDPOUSBEJUwSJPPVQSPCMFNgUJDPFQPSJTTPTFUSBOTGPS NBFNJOEBHBmkPPVJOUFSSPHBmkP&TTBNVEBOmBEFBUJUVEF nFYQSFTTBQFMPEFTFKPEFTBCFS JTUPn PEFTDPOUFOUBNFOUP DPNBTDSFOmBTPVPQJOJ{FTQSFFTUBCFMFDJEBT BQFSDFQmkPEF DPOUSBEJm{FTFJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFTFOUSFFMBT BCVTDBEFDPN QSFFOTkPEPRVFFMBTTkPFEPQPSRVFTkPQSPCMFNgUJDBT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBGJMPTPGJBTFWPMUBQSFGFSFODJBMNFO UFQBSBPTNPNFOUPTEFDSJTFPVDSrUJDPT 1SPGFTTPS B BRVJTFQPEFFTQFSBSRVFPFTUVEBOUFQSPEV[B VNBSFTQPTUBRVFBQSFTFOUFVNBSFGMFYkPFMBCPSBEBDPNCBTF OBTJEFJBTEBTEVBTRVFTU{FTBOUFSJPSFT"SFTQPTUBQPEFTFS BQSFTFOUBEBDPNFTTBJEFJB"TTJNDPNPDBEBVNEFOwT RVBO EPQPTTVJEFTFKPEFTBCFS WBJFNEJSFmkPhBUJUVEFGJMPTwGJDBBP QFSDFCFSDPOUSBEJm{FT JODPFSpODJBT BNCJHVJEBEFTPVJODPN QBUJCJMJEBEFTFOUSFOPTTBTDSFOmBTDPUJEJBOBT BTTJNUBNCnN BGJMPTPGJBUFNFTQFDJBMJOUFSFTTFQFMPTNPNFOUPTEFDSJTFPV NPNFOUPTDSrUJDPT RVBOEPTJTUFNBTSFMJHJPTPT nUJDPT QPMrUJ DPT DJFOUrGJDPTFBSUrTUJDPTFTUBCFMFDJEPTTFFOWPMWFNFNDPO USBEJm{FTJOUFSOBTPVDPOUSBEJ[FNTFVOTBPTPVUSPTFCVTDBN USBOTGPSNBm{FTFNVEBOmBTDVKPTFOUJEPBJOEBOkPFTUgDMBSPF QSFDJTBTFSDPNQSFFOEJEPcOFTTFTNPNFOUPTDSrUJDPTRVFTF NBOJGFTUBNBJTDMBSBNFOUFBFYJHpODJBEFGVOEBNFOUBmkPEBT JEFJBT EPTEJTDVSTPTFEBTQSgUJDBT 1PSRVFTFQFSHVOUB²1BSBRVFGJMPTPGJB ³ &NOPTTBDVMUVSB DPTUVNBNPTDPOTJEFSBSRVFBMHVNBDPJ TBTwUFNPEJSFJUPEFFYJTUJSTFUJWFSBMHVNBGJOBMJEBEFQSgUJDB NVJUPWJTrWFMFEFVUJMJEBEFJNFEJBUB/PDBTPEBGJMPTPGJB FTUB QFSHVOUBBQSFTFOUBTFDPNVNBGBMTBQFSUJOpODJB QPJTQBSB NVJUBTQFTTPBTBGJMPTPGJBOkPUFNVUJMJEBEFOVNNVOEPNBS DBEPQFMBQSgUJDBFQFMPDPOTVNPJNFEJBUP 2VBJTBTUSpTQSJODJQBJTQFSHVOUBTRVFDBSBDUFSJ[BNBBUJ UVEFGJMPTwGJDB %JSJHJOEPTFBPNVOEPRVFOPTSPEFJB DPJTB WBMPS JEFJB DPNQPSUBNFOUP FhTSFMBm{FTRVFNBOUFNPTDPNFMF BBUJUV EFGJMPTwGJDBDBSBDUFSJ[BTFQFMBTQFSHVOUBT²0RVFn ³ ²$PNP n ³F²1PSRVFn ³ 0RVFnFDPNPnBSFGMFYkPGJMPTwGJDB cPQFOTBNFOUPJOUFSSPHBOEPTFBTJNFTNPPVQFOTBO EPTFBTJNFTNP"MnNEJTTP BSFGMFYkPGJMPTwGJDBUBNCnNTF WPMUBQBSBDPNQSFFOEFSPRVFTFQBTTBFNOwTOBTSFMBm{FTRVF NBOUFNPTDPNBSFBMJEBEFDJSDVOEBOUF
/
2VBJTPTUSpTDPOKVOUPTEFRVFTU{FTRVFPSHBOJ[BNBSFGMF YkPGJMPTwGJDB ²1PSRVFQFOTBNPTPRVFQFOTBNPT EJ[FNPTPRVFEJ [FNPTFGB[FNPTPRVFGB[FNPT ³ ²0RVFRVFSFNPTQFOTBS RVBOEPQFOTBNPT PRVFRVFSFNPTEJ[FSRVBOEPGBMBNPT P RVFRVFSFNPTGB[FSRVBOEPBHJNPT ³ ²1BSBRVFQFOTBNPT PRVFQFOTBNPT EJ[FNPTPRVFEJ[FNPT GB[FNPTPRVFGB [FNPT ³ &YQMJRVFPRVFnBGJMPTPGJBDPNPTBCFSBSFTQFJUPEBSFBMJ EBEFFYUFSOBBPQFOTBNFOUPFBDFSDBEBSFBMJEBEFJOUFSOB BPTTFSFTIVNBOPT "GJMPTPGJBnVNBBUJUVEFRVFJOEBHBTPCSFBFTTpODJB PRVF n
BTJHOJGJDBmkPPVFTUSVUVSB DPNPn
BPSJHFN QPSRVF n FBGJOBMJEBEF QBSBRVFn EFUPEBTBTDPJTBT&NPVUSBT QBMBWSBT BGJMPTPGJBnVNBSFGMFYkPRVFJOEBHB²1PSRVp ³ ²0 RVp ³ ²1BSBRVp ³ EJSJHJOEPTFBPQFOTBNFOUP hMJOHVBHFN FhBmkPEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBGJMPTPGJBnVNQFOTBNFOUPTJTUF NgUJDPPVVNBJOUFSSPHBmkPTJTUFNgUJDB 4JHOJGJDBRVFBGJMPTPGJBUSBCBMIBDPNFOVODJBEPTQSFDJTPTF SJHPSPTPT CVTDBFODBEFBNFOUPTMwHJDPTFOUSFPTFOVODJBEPT PQFSBDPNDPODFJUPTPVJEFJBTPCUJEPTQPSQSPDFEJNFOUPTEF EFNPOTUSBmkPFQSPWB FYJHFBGVOEBNFOUBmkPSBDJPOBMEPRVF nFOVODJBEPFQFOTBEP &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBTUSpTQSJODJQBJTEFGJOJm{FTEFGJMP TPGJBRVFOkPQPEFNPTBDFJUBSJOUFJSBNFOUF $PNPWJTkPEFNVOEPEFVNQPWP EFVNBDJWJMJ[BmkP PVEFVNBDVMUVSB/FTTBEFGJOJmkP BGJMPTPGJBDPSSFTQPOEFSJB EFNPEPWBHPFHFSBM BPDPOKVOUPEFJEFJBT WBMPSFTFQSgUJDBT QFMPTRVBJTVNBTPDJFEBEFBQSFFOEFFDPNQSFFOEFPNVOEP FBTJNFTNB EFGJOJOEPQBSBTJPUFNQPFPFTQBmP PTBHSBEP FPQSPGBOP PCPNFPNBV PKVTUPFPJOKVTUP PCFMPFPGFJP P WFSEBEFJSPFPGBMTP PQPTTrWFMFPJNQPTTrWFM PDPOUJOHFOUFF POFDFTTgSJP0QSPCMFNBEFTTBEFGJOJmkPnRVF QPSVNMBEP FMBTFQBSFDFDPNBOPmkPEF²NJOIBGJMPTPGJB³PV²BGJMPTPGJB EBFNQSFTB³QPSPVUSP FMBnUkPHFOnSJDBFUkPBNQMBRVFOkP QFSNJUF QPSFYFNQMP EJTUJOHVJSGJMPTPGJBEFSFMJHJkP BSUF EF DJpODJB/BWFSEBEF FTTBEFGJOJmkPJEFOUJGJDBGJMPTPGJBFDVMUV SB QPJTFTUBnVNBWJTkPEFNVOEPDPMFUJWBRVFTFFYQSJNF FNJEFJBT WBMPSFTFQSgUJDBTEFVNBTPDJFEBEFEFUFSNJOB EB $PNPTBCFEPSJBEFWJEB/FTTBEFGJOJmkP BGJMPTPGJBn JEFOUJGJDBEBDPNBBUJWJEBEFEFBMHVNBTQFTTPBTRVFQFOTBN TPCSFBWJEBNPSBM EFEJDBOEPTFhDPOUFNQMBmkPEPNVOEPF EPTPVUSPTTFSFTIVNBOPTQBSBBQSFOEFSFFOTJOBSBDPOUSPMBS TFVTEFTFKPT TFOUJNFOUPTFJNQVMTPTFBEJSJHJSTVBTWJEBT EFNPEPnUJDPFTgCJP&TTBEFGJOJmkP QPSnN OPTEJ[ EFNP EPWBHP PRVFTFFTQFSBEBGJMPTPGJB BTBCFEPSJBJOUFSJPS
NBTOkPPRVFnFPRVFGB[BGJMPTPGJBF QPSJTTP UBNCnN OkPQPEFNPTBDFJUgMB NBTBQFOBTSFDPOIFDFSRVFOFMBFTUg QSFTFOUFVNEPTBTQFDUPTEPUSBCBMIPGJMPTwGJDP $PNPFT GPSmPSBDJPOBMQBSBDPODFCFSP6OJWFSTPDPNPVNBUPUBMJEBEF PSEFOBEBFEPUBEBEFTFOUJEP/FTTBEFGJOJmkP BUSJCVJTFh GJMPTPGJBBUBSFGBEFDPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEFJOUFJSB QSPWBOEP RVFP6OJWFSTPnVNBUPUBMJEBEF JTUPn BMHPFTUSVUVSBEPPV PSEFOBEPQPSSFMBm{FTEFDBVTBFFGFJUP FRVFFTTBUPUBMJEBEF nSBDJPOBM PVTFKB QPTTVJTFOUJEPFGJOBMJEBEFDPNQSFFOTrWFJT QFMPQFOTBNFOUPIVNBOP 0TRVFBEPUBNFTTBEFGJOJmkPQSFDJTBNDPNFmBSEJTUJOHVJO EPFOUSFGJMPTPGJBFSFMJHJkPFBUnNFTNPPQPOEPVNBhPVUSB
| U NIDADE 1 |
A filosofia
PJTBNCBTQPTTVFNPNFTNPPCKFUP DPNQSFFOEFSP6OJWFSTP
Q NBTBQSJNFJSBPGB[QPSNFJPEPFTGPSmPSBDJPOBM FORVBOUPB TFHVOEB QPSNFJPEBDPOGJBOmB Gn OVNBSFWFMBmkPEJWJOB0V TFKB BGJMPTPGJBQSPDVSBEJTDVUJSBUnPGJNPTFOUJEPFPGVOEBNFO UPEBSFBMJEBEF FORVBOUPBDPOTDJpODJBSFMJHJPTBTFCBTFJBOVN EBEPQSJNFJSPFJORVFTUJPOgWFM RVFnBSFWFMBmkPEJWJOB PCKFUP EFGn FJOEFNPOTUSgWFMQFMBFQBSBBSB[kPIVNBOB1FMBGn B 3FMJHJkPBDFJUBQSJODrQJPTJOEFNPOTUSgWFJTFBUnNFTNPBRVFMFT RVFQPEFNTFSDPOTJEFSBEPTJSSBDJPOBJTQFMPQFOTBNFOUP FO RVBOUPBGJMPTPGJBOkPBENJUFJOEFNPOTUSBCJMJEBEFFJSSBDJPOB MJEBEFEFDPJTBBMHVNB1FMPDPOUSgSJP PQFOTBNFOUPGJMPTwGJDP QSPDVSBFYQMJDBSFDPNQSFFOEFSNFTNPPRVFQBSFDFTFSJSSB DJPOBMFJORVFTUJPOgWFM&TTBEFGJOJmkPUBNCnNnQSPCMFNgUJDB QPSRVFEghGJMPTPGJBBUBSFGBEFPGFSFDFSVNBFYQMJDBmkPFVNB DPNQSFFOTkPUPUBJTTPCSFP6OJWFSTP FMBCPSBOEPVNTJTUFNB VOJWFSTBMPVVNTJTUFNBEPNVOEP NBTTBCFNPT IPKF RVFFTTB UBSFGBnJNQPTTrWFM &YQMJRVFBEFGJOJmkPEBGJMPTPGJBDPNPGVOEBNFOUBmkPUFw SJDBFDSrUJDBEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTFEBTQSgUJDBT 1SPGFTTPS B OFTUB RVFTUkP n JNQPSUBOUF RVF P BMVOP BQSFTFOUFVNBSFGMFYkPQFTTPBMRVFFYQSFTTFBDPNQSFFOTkP EBEFGJOJmkPEBGJMPTPGJBDPNPGVOEBNFOUBmkPUFwSJDBFDSrUJDB EPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTFEBTQSgUJDBT"MHVOTBTQFDUPTFYQMJDBUJ WPTRVFQPEFNDPNQBSFDFSOBSFTQPTUBTkP"GJMPTPGJBDPNP CBTFPVQSJODrQJP%FUFSNJOBEBQFMPQFOTBNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP "UJWJEBEFEFFYBNJOBmkPFBWBMJBmkPEFUBMIBEB5FNQPSPCKFUP PDPOIFDJNFOUP IVNBOPFEPNVOEP F QPSJTTP JOWFTUJHBF JOUFSQSFUBPTJHOJGJDBEPEFJEFJBTHFSBJTDPNPSFBMJEBEF OBUV SF[BFWFSEBEF &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBBUJWJEBEFGJMPTwGJDBnVNBBOgMJTF VNB SFGMFYkPFVNBDSrUJDB cVNBBOgMJTFQPSDBSBDUFSJ[BSTFQFMBJOEBHBmkP ²PRVF n ³ ²DPNPn ³ ²QPSRVFn ³ ²QBSBRVFn ³
QPSDPMPDBSFO USFQBSpOUFTFTOPTTBTDSFOmBT QBSBQPEFSJOUFSSPHBSRVBJTTkP TVBTDBVTBTFRVBMnTFVTFOUJEPcVNBSFGMFYkPQPSDBSBDUFSJ [BSTFQPSVNNPWJNFOUPEPQFOTBNFOUPTPCSFTJNFTNP QBSB DPOIFDFSDPNPnQPTTrWFMPQSwQSJPQFOTBNFOUPPVPQSwQSJP DPOIFDJNFOUPcVNBDSrUJDBQPSDBSBDUFSJ[BSTFQFMPFYBNFSB DJPOBMEFUPEBTBTDPJTBTTFNQSFDPODFJUPTFTFNQSFKVMHBNFO UPT CVTDBOEPBFMBCPSBmkPEFVNDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP 2VBJTBTJOEBHBm{FTEBGJMPTPGJBTFHVOEP,BOU "JOEBHBmkPTPCSFPTGVOEBNFOUPTEPQFOTBNFOUP²2VF QPEFNPTTBCFS ³"JOEBHBmkPTPCSFPTGVOEBNFOUPTEBnUJDB ²2VFQPEFNPTGB[FS ³"JOEBHBmkPTPCSFPTGVOEBNFOUPTEB SFMJHJkP²2VFQPEFNPTFTQFSBS ³ 2VBMBVUJMJEBEFEBGJMPTPGJB "GJMPTPGJBQPEFTFSPNBJT|UJMEPTTBCFSFTBPOPTGB[FS BCBOEPOBSBJOHFOVJEBEFFPTQSFDPODFJUPTEPTFOTPDPNVN BPOPTGB[FSDSrUJDPTFNSFMBmkPhTJEFJBTEPNJOBOUFTFBPTQP EFSFTFTUBCFMFDJEPT BPOPTJOTUJHBSBDPNQSFFOEFSBTJHOJGJDB mkPEPNVOEP EBDVMUVSBFEBIJTUwSJB BPOPTFMVDJEBSPTFOUJEP EBTDSJBm{FTIVNBOBTOBTBSUFT OBTDJpODJBTFOBQPMrUJDB BP EBSBDBEBVNEFOwTFhOPTTBTPDJFEBEFPTNFJPTQBSBTFSNPT DPOTDJFOUFTEFOwTFEFOPTTBTBm{FTOVNBQSgUJDBRVFCVTDB BMJCFSEBEFFBGFMJDJEBEFQBSBUPEPT 2VFTUkPPQDJPOBM QBSBFTUVEBOUFTFQSPGFTTPSFTRVFUF OIBNWJTUPPGJMNF.BUSJY 2VBJTPTQBSBMFMPTRVFQPEF
NPTFTUBCFMFDFSFOUSFBQFSTPOBHFN/FP EPGJMNF.BUSJY FPGJMwTPGP4wDSBUFT "MHVOTQBSBMFMPTQPTTrWFJT4wDSBUFTF/FPSFDFCFSBNVN PSgDVMP ²$POIFDFUFBUJNFTNP³/PTDFUFJQTVN 4FNFMIBO UFB4wDSBUFT /FPUBNCnNTFTFOUFJNQFMJEPBEFTDPCSJSBFT TpODJBEBTDPJTBT4wDSBUFTF/FPMJEBNDPNB.BUSJY"NCPT SFBMJ[BNDPNCBUFTNFOUBJT
5NIDADEßßßß=behkokbe] #APqTULOß߯ß=knecai`]behkokbe] 2VFRVFSEJ[FSQIJMPTPQIrB "RVFNTFBUSJCVJBJOWFOmkP EFTTBQBMBWSB 1IJMPTPQIrBnVNBQBMBWSBHSFHBDPNQPTUBEFEVBTPVUSBT QIJMP ²BRVFMFPVBRVFMBRVFUFNVNTFOUJNFOUPBNJHgWFM³ F TPQIrB ²TBCFEPSJB³%BrGJMPTPGJBTJHOJGJDBS²BNJ[BEFQFMBTB CFEPSJB³PV²BNPSFSFTQFJUPQFMPTBCFS³"JOWFOmkPEFTTB QBMBWSBnBUSJCVrEBB1JUgHPSBTEF4BNPT TnDVMP7B$
RVF UFSJBBGJSNBEPRVFBTBCFEPSJBQMFOBFDPNQMFUBQFSUFODFBPT EFVTFT NBTRVFPTIPNFOTQPEFNEFTFKgMBPVBNgMB UPS OBOEPTFGJMwTPGPT 0RVF1JUgHPSBTRVFSJBEJ[FSBPTFSFGFSJShTQFTTPBTRVF DPNQBSFDFNBPT+PHPT0MrNQJDPT 2VFPGJMwTPGPOkPnNPWJEPQPSJOUFSFTTFTDPNFSDJBJTPV GJOBODFJSPT DPNPPTDPNFSDJBOUFT5BNCnNOkPnNPWJEPQF MPEFTFKPEFDPNQFUJS DPNPPTBUMFUBTPVBSUJTUBT.BT DPNP BTQFTTPBTRVFJBNQBSBBTTJTUJSBPTKPHPT PGJMwTPGPnNPWJEP QFMPEFTFKPEFPCTFSWBS DPOUFNQMBS KVMHBSFBWBMJBSBTDPJTBT BTBm{FT BTQFTTPBT PTBDPOUFDJNFOUPT BWJEB 0RVFNPWFVBMHVOTHSFHPThGJMPTPGJB "BUJUVEFEFFTQBOUPFBENJSBmkPEJBOUFEBSFBMJEBEF GSV UPEBJOTBUJTGBmkPDPNBTFYQMJDBm{FTUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUFEBEBT QFMBTEJWJOEBEFT"DPOTUBUBmkPEFRVFPNVOEPFPTTFSFT IVNBOPT PTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTOBUVSBJTFBTDPJTBTEBOBUVSF[B PTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTIVNBOPTFBTBm{FTEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTQP EJBNTFSDPOIFDJEPTQFMBSB[kPIVNBOB FRVFBQSwQSJBSB[kP FSBDBQB[EFDPOIFDFSTFBTJNFTNB &OVNFSFPTQSJODJQBJTUSBmPTEBGJMPTPGJBOBTDFOUF 5FOEpODJBhSBDJPOBMJEBEF 3FDVTBEFFYQMJDBm{FT QSFFTUBCFMFDJEBT 5FOEpODJBhBSHVNFOUBmkPFBPEFCBUF $BQBDJEBEFEFHFOFSBMJ[BmkP $BQBDJEBEFEFEJGFSFODJB mkP 2VFnBUFOEpODJBhSBDJPOBMJEBEF 4JHOJGJDBRVFBSB[kPIVNBOB USBmPEJTUJOUJWPFNSFMBmkP BPTPVUSPTTFSFT PVPQFOTBNFOUPnBDPOEJmkPEFUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPFQPSJTTPBQSwQSJBSB[kPPVPQSwQSJP QFOTBNFOUPEFWFDPOIFDFSBTMFJT SFHSBT QSJODrQJPTFOPSNBT EFTVBTPQFSBm{FTFEFTFVFYFSDrDJPDPSSFUP 2VFnTrOUFTF &BOgMJTF 4rOUFTFWFNEPHSFHPFTJHOJGJDB²SFVOJkPPVGVTkPEFWg SJBTDPJTBTOVNBVOJkPrOUJNBQBSBGPSNBSVNUPEP³5SBUBTF EFVNBDBQBDJEBEFSBDJPOBMEFHFOFSBMJ[BmkPQPSNFJPEBRVBM
0
Manual do Professor
PQFOTBNFOUPEFTDPCSFTFNFMIBOmBTFJEFOUJEBEFT EFNPOT USBOEPRVFVNBFYQMJDBmkPUFNWBMJEBEFQBSBNVJUBTDPJTBTEJ GFSFOUFT"OgMJTF UBNCnNEPHSFHP TJHOJGJDB²BmkPEFEFTMJHBS FTFQBSBSVNUPEPFNTVBTQBSUFT³cBDBQBDJEBEFSBDJPOBMEF EJGFSFODJBmkPRVFQFSNJUFDPNQSFFOEFSEJGFSFOmBTPOEFQBSF DFIBWFSTFNFMIBOmBPVJEFOUJEBEF EFNPOTUSBOEPRVFGBUPT PVDPJTBTRVFBQBSFDFNDPNPJHVBJTPVTFNFMIBOUFTTkP OB WFSEBEF EJGFSFOUFT 2VBMnBOPmkPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPUSB[JEBQFMB GJMPTPGJBOBTDFOUF "JEFJBEFRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPEFWFFODPOUSBS BTMFJTFPTQSJODrQJPTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJPTEPPCKFUPDP OIFDJEPFEFWFEFNPOTUSBSTVBWFSEBEFQPSNFJPEFQSPWBTPV BSHVNFOUPTSBDJPOBJT 2VFTJHOJGJDBBGJSNBSRVFBSB[kPFPQFOTBNFOUPPQFSBN PCFEFDFOEPBMFJT QSJODrQJPTFSFHSBTVOJWFSTBJT 2VF QPSTFSNPTSBDJPOBJT OPTTPQFOTBNFOUPnDPFSFOUF FDBQB[EFDPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEFQPSRVFTFHVFMFJTMwHJDBTEF GVODJPOBNFOUP 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPBDBTPOBOBUVSF[BFPQPTTrWFMOBT Bm{FTIVNBOBT 0BDBTPnPRVFQPEFPVOkPBDPOUFDFS DPOUJOHpODJB OPT BDPOUFDJNFOUPTEBOBUVSF[BPQPTTrWFMnPRVFQPEFPVOkP BDPOUFDFS DPOUJOHpODJB OBTBm{FTIVNBOBT"EJGFSFOmBGVO EBNFOUBMDPOTJTUFOPGBUPEFRVFPBDBTPnPRVFOkPFTUgFN OPTTPQPEFSFTDPMIFSPQPTTrWFM BPDPOUSgSJPEPBDBTP FEP OFDFTTgSJP
nFYBUBNFOUFPRVFUFNPTQPEFSEFFTDPMIFSFGB [FS nPRVFFTUgFNOPTTPQPEFS 1BSBBBmkPIVNBOB RVBMnBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFOFDFTTJEBEF DPOUJOHpODJBFQPTTrWFM 0OFDFTTgSJPnPRVFOkPFTUgFNOPTTPQPEFSFTDPMIFS QPJTBDPOUFDFFBDPOUFDFSgTFNQSF JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEF OPTTBWPOUBEFPDPOUJOHFOUFnPRVFQPEFPVOkPBDPOUFDFS FOUSFPTIPNFOTPQPTTrWFMnPRVFUFNPTQPEFSEFFTDPMIFS FGB[FS 3FTVNBPTQSJODJQBJTMFHBEPTEBGJMPTPGJBHSFHBQBSBPQFO TBNFOUPPDJEFOUBM 0DPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPEFWFFODPOUSBSBTMFJTFPTQSJO DrQJPTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJPTEPPCKFUPDPOIFDJEPFEFWFEF NPOTUSBSTVBWFSEBEFQPSNFJPEFQSPWBTPVBSHVNFOUPTSBDJP OBJT"OBUVSF[BTFHVFVNBPSEFNOFDFTTgSJB FOkPDBTVBMPV BDJEFOUBM"TMFJTOFDFTTgSJBTFVOJWFSTBJTEBOBUVSF[BQPEFN TFSQMFOBNFOUFDPOIFDJEBTQFMPOPTTPQFOTBNFOUP"SB[kP UBNCnNPQFSBPCFEFDFOEPBQSJODrQJPT MFJT SFHSBTFOPSNBT VOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJBT DPNBTRVBJTQPEFNPTEJTUJOHVJSP WFSEBEFJSPEPGBMTP0BHJSIVNBOPFYQSJNFBDPOEVUBEFVN TFSSBDJPOBMEPUBEPEFWPOUBEFFEFMJCFSEBEF0TBDPOUFDJNFO UPTOBUVSBJTFIVNBOPTTkPOFDFTTgSJPT QPSRVFPCFEFDFNB MFJT OBUVSBJTPVEBOBUVSF[BIVNBOB
NBTJTUPOkPFYDMVJB DPNQSFFOTkPEFFTTFTBDPOUFDJNFOUPT FNDFSUBTDJSDVOTUiO DJBTFTPCDFSUBTDPOEJm{FT UBNCnNQPEFSFNTFSBDJEFOUBJT TFKBQPSRVFVNDPODVSTPEFDJSDVOTUiODJBTPTGB[PDPSSFSQPS BDBTPOBOBUVSF[B TFKBQPSRVFBTBm{FTIVNBOBTEFQFOEFN EBTFTDPMIBTFEFMJCFSBm{FTEPTIPNFOT FNDPOEJm{FTEFUFS NJOBEBT
1
#APqTULOß߯ßKj]o_eiajpk`]behkokbe] 2VFQFSHVOUBTGJ[FSBNPTQSJNFJSPTGJMwTPGPTHSFHPT ²1PSRVFPTTFSFTOBTDFNFNPSSFN ³²1PSRVFPTTFNF MIBOUFTEkPPSJHFNBPTTFNFMIBOUFTFPTEJGFSFOUFTEkPPSJHFN BPTEJGFSFOUFT ³²1PSRVFUVEPNVEB ³²1PSRVFBEPFOmBJO WBEFPTDPSQPT ³²1PSRVFPRVFQBSFDJBVOPTFNVMUJQMJDBFN UBOUPTPVUSPT ³²1PSRVFBTDPJTBTTFUPSOBNPQPTUBTBPRVF FSBN ³²1PSRVFOBEBQFSNBOFDFJEpOUJDPBTJNFTNP ³²%F POEFWpNPTTFSFT ³²1BSBPOEFWkP RVBOEPEFTBQBSFDFN ³ ²1PSRVFTFUSBOTGPSNBN ³²1PSRVFTFEJGFSFODJBNVOTEPT PVUSPT ³²1PSRVFUVEPQBSFDFSFQFUJSTF ³ 0RVFEJ[JBNPTEFGFOTPSFTEB²UFTFPSJFOUBMJTUB³TPCSFB PSJHFNEBGJMPTPGJB 0TKVEFVT QBSBWBMPSJ[BSTFVQFOTBNFOUPBUSBWnTEPSF DPOIFDJNFOUPDMgTTJDPEBGJMPTPGJBHSFHB EJ[JBNRVFPQFO TBNFOUPEFGJMwTPGPTJNQPSUBOUFT DPNP1MBUkP UJOIBTVSHJEP OP&HJUP POEFUBNCnNTFPSJHJOBSBPQFOTBNFOUPEF.PJTnT SFMBDJPOBOEPBGJMPTPGJBHSFHBFB#rCMJB0TDSJTUkPTEJ[JBNRVF PTGJMwTPGPTHSFHPTFTUBWBNGJMJBEPTBDPSSFOUFTEFQFOTBNFOUP NrTUJDPFPSJFOUBMF EFTTBNBOFJSB FTUBSJBNQSwYJNPTEPDSJT UJBOJTNP RVFnVNBSFMJHJkPPSJFOUBM 0RVFEJ[JBNPTEFGFOTPSFTEBUFTFEP²NJMBHSFHSFHP³TP CSFBPSJHFNEBGJMPTPGJB %J[JBNRVFBGJMPTPGJBTVSHJVJOFTQFSBEBFFTQBOUPTBNFOUF OB(SnDJB TFNRVFOBEBBOUFSJPSBQSFQBSBTTFRVFBGJMPTPGJB HSFHBGPJVNBDPOUFDJNFOUPFTQPOUiOFP |OJDPFTFNQBS DPNP nQSwQSJPEFVNNJMBHSFRVFPTHSFHPTGPSBNVNQPWPFYDFQ DJPOBMFRVF QPSJTTP TPNFOUFFMFTQPEFSJBNUFSTJEPDBQB[FT EFDSJBSBGJMPTPGJB 0RVFIgEFWFSEBEFJSPOBTUFTFTPSJFOUBMJTUBFEPNJMBHSFHSF HP 3FUJSBEPTPTFYBHFSPTEPPSJFOUBMJTNP QPEFTFSFDPOIFDFS BJNQPSUiODJBEBTWJBHFOTRVFDPMPDBSBNPTHSFHPTFNDPOUB UPDPNPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTQSPEV[JEPTQPSPVUSPTQPWPT0VUSP GBUPnRVFPTEPJTNBJPSFTGPSNBEPSFTEBDVMUVSBHSFHBBOUJHB PTQPFUBT)PNFSPF)FTrPEP FODPOUSBSBNOPTNJUPTFOBTSF MJHJ{FTEPTQPWPTPSJFOUBJT CFNDPNPOBTDVMUVSBTRVFQSFDF EFSBNBHSFHB PTFMFNFOUPTQBSBFMBCPSBSBNJUPMPHJBHSFHB RVF EFQPJT TFSJBUSBOTGPSNBEBSBDJPOBMNFOUFQFMPTGJMwTPGPT &NSFMBmkPhUFTFEP²NJMBHSFHSFHP³ PRVFIgEFWFSEBEFJSP nPGBUPEFRVFPTHSFHPTJNQSJNJSBNNVEBOmBTEFRVBMJEB EFUkPQSPGVOEBTOPRVFSFDFCFSBNEP0SJFOUFFEBTDVMUVSBT QSFDFEFOUFT RVFBUnQPEFSJBQBSFDFSUFSFNDSJBEPTVBQSwQSJB DVMUVSBBQBSUJSEFTJNFTNPT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFPTHSFHPTJOWFOUBSBNBDJpODJB B QPMrUJDBFBJEFJBEFSB[kP &NSFMBmkPhDJpODJB TJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFUSBOTGPSNBSBNOVN DPOIFDJNFOUPBCTUSBUPFVOJWFSTBMBRVJMPRVFFSBNFMFNFOUPT EFVNBTBCFEPSJBQSgUJDBQBSBPVTPEJSFUPEBWJEB&NSFMBmkP hQPMrUJDB RVFTFQBSBSBNPQPEFSQSJWBEPFPQPEFSQ|CMJDPF EJTUJOHVJSBNFTUFEPQPEFSSFMJHJPTP GB[FOEPEFTTBGPSNBDPN RVFBTEFDJT{FTQBTTBTTFNBTFSUPNBEBTFSFWPHBEBTDPNCB TFFNEJTDVTT{FTFEFCBUFTQ|CMJDPTRVFFTUBCFMFDFSBNJOT UJUVJm{FTQ|CMJDBT USJCVOBJT BTTFNCMFJBT RVFDSJBSBNBJEFJB EBMFJFEBKVTUJmBDPNPFYQSFTT{FTEBWPOUBEFDPMFUJWBQ|CMJDB $PNSFMBmkPhJEFJBEFSB[kP RVFJOWFOUBSBNVNQFOTBNFOUP
| U NIDADE 1 |
A filosofia
TJTUFNgUJDPRVFTFHVFOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFSFHSBT OPSNBTFMFJT VOJWFSTBJT
DJPOBM1PSRVFWBMPSJ[PVPIVNBOP PQFOTBNFOUP BEJTDVTTkP BQFSTVBTkP PQFOTBNFOUPSBDJPOBMFQPSRVFDSJPVDPOEJm{FT QBSBRVFTVSHJTTFPEJTDVSTPPVBQBMBWSBGJMPTwGJDB
0RVFnPNJUP 1PSRVFNFSFDJBDPOGJBOmBFFSBJORVFTUJPOg WFM .JUPnVNBOBSSBUJWBTPCSFBPSJHFNEFBMHVNBDPJTB PSJ HFNEPNVOEP EPCFNFEPNBM EBNPSUF FUD 1BSBPTHSF HPT NFSFDJBDPOGJBOmBQPSRVFFSBGFJUPQPSBMHVnNDPNBVUP SJEBEFSFMJHJPTB2VFNOBSSBWBPNJUPFSBPQPFUBSBQTPEP VN FTDPMIJEPQFMPTEFVTFT RVFMIFNPTUSBWBNPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPT QBTTBEPTFQFSNJUJBNRVFFMFWJTTFBPSJHFNEFUPEPTPTTFSFT FEFUPEBTBTDPJTBT%FWJEPBFTTBSFWFMBmkPEJWJOB BQBMBWSB EPQPFUBFSBTBHSBEBF QPSUBOUP JORVFTUJPOgWFM 2VBJTBTNBOFJSBTQFMBTRVBJTPNJUPOBSSBBPSJHFNEBT DPJTBT &ODPOUSBOEPPQBJFBNkFEBTDPJTBTFEPTTFSFT&ODPO USBOEPVNBSJWBMJEBEFPVVNBBMJBOmBFOUSFPTEFVTFTRVFGB [FNTVSHJSBMHVNBDPJTBOPNVOEP&ODPOUSBOEPBTSFDPNQFO TBTPVPTDBTUJHPTRVFPTEFVTFTEkPBRVFNMIFTEFTPCFEFDF PVBRVFNMIFTPCFEFDF 2VFFYQMJDBm{FTGPSBNEBEBTTPCSFBDPOUJOVBmkPPVSVQUV SBEBGJMPTPGJBDPNSFMBmkPhDPTNPHPOJBFhUFPHPOJB 2VBM BFYQMJDBmkPIPKFBDFJUB 4PCSFBSVQUVSB EJ[JBTFOPTGJOTEPTnDVMP9*9FDPNFmPEP TnDVMP99RVFBGJMPTPGJBUFSJBTJEPBQSJNFJSBFYQMJDBmkPDJFOUrGJ DBEBSFBMJEBEFQSPEV[JEBQFMP0DJEFOUF4PCSFBDPOUJOVBmkP EBGJMPTPGJBDPNSFMBmkPhDPTNPHPOJBFhUFPHPOJB EJ[JBTF B QBSUJSEFNFBEPTEPTnDVMP99 RVFPTHSFHPT DPNPRVBMRVFS PVUSPQPWP BDSFEJUBWBNFNTFVTNJUPTFRVFBGJMPTPGJBOBT DFV WBHBSPTBFHSBEVBMNFOUF EPTQSwQSJPTNJUPT DPNPVNB SBDJPOBMJ[BmkPEFMFT 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFGJMPTPGJBFNJUP 0NJUPQSFUFOEJBOBSSBSDPNPBTDPJTBTFSBNPVUJOIBNTJ EPOPQBTTBEPJNFNPSJBM MPOHrORVPFGBCVMPTPBGJMPTPGJBTF QSFPDVQBFNFYQMJDBSDPNPFQPSRVF OPQBTTBEP OPQSFTFOUF FOPGVUVSP BTDPJTBTTkPDPNPTkP0NJUPOBSSBWBBPSJHFNQPS NFJPEFHFOFBMPHJBTFSJWBMJEBEFTPVBMJBOmBTFOUSFGPSmBTEJWJ OBTFTPCSFOBUVSBJTBGJMPTPGJBFYQMJDBBQSPEVmkPOBUVSBMEBT DPJTBTQPSNFJPEFDBVTBTOBUVSBJTFJNQFTTPBJT0NJUPOkPTF JNQPSUBWBDPNDPOUSBEJm{FT DPNPGBCVMPTPFPJODPNQSFFO TrWFMBGJMPTPGJBOkPBENJUFDPOUSBEJm{FT GBCVMBmkPFDPJTBT JODPNQSFFOTrWFJT NBTFYJHFRVFBFYQMJDBmkPTFKBDPFSFOUF MwHJDBFSBDJPOBM±BMnNEJTTP BBVUPSJEBEFEBFYQMJDBmkPOkP WFNEBQFTTPBEPGJMwTPGP NBTEBSB[kP RVFnBNFTNBFN UPEPTPTTFSFTIVNBOPT 2VBJTBTDPOEJm{FTIJTUwSJDBTRVFQSPQJDJBSBNPTVSHJNFO UPEBGJMPTPGJBOB(SnDJB "TWJBHFOTNBSrUJNBTBJOWFOmkPEPDBMFOEgSJPBJOWFOmkP EBNPFEBPTVSHJNFOUPEBWJEBVSCBOBFEFVNBOPWBDMBTTF TPDJBMBJOWFOmkPEBFTDSJUBBMGBCnUJDBBJOWFOmkPEBQPMrUJ DBDPNBJOUSPEVmkPEFUSpTOPWPTFEFDJTJWPTBTQFDUPTQBSB BWJEBQ|CMJDBBJEFJBEBMFJ PVTPEBQBMBWSBFPFTUrNVMPBP QFOTBNFOUP 1PSRVFBJOWFOmkPEBQPMrUJDBGPJEFDJTJWBQBSBPOBTDJNFO UPEBGJMPTPGJB 1PSRVFTFSWJVEFNPEFMPQBSBBGJMPTPGJBQSPQPSPBTQFDUP MFHJTMBEP SFHVMBEPFPSEFOBEPEPNVOEPDPNPVNNVOEPSB
#APqTULOß߯ßß?]ilko`aejraopec]k`] behkokbe] 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTQFSrPEPTEBGJMPTPGJBHSFHB 1FSrPEPQSnTPDSgUJDPPVDPTNPMwHJDP EPGJOBMEPTnDVMP7** BPGJOBMEPTnDVMP7B$QFSrPEPTPDSgUJDPPVBOUSPQPMwHJDP EP GJOBMEPTnDVMP7FUPEPPTnDVMP*7B$QFSrPEPTJTUFNgUJDP EP GJOBMEPTnDVMP*7BPGJOBMEPTnDVMP***B$QFSrPEPIFMFOrTUJDP PVHSFDPSPNBOP EPGJOBMEPTnDVMP***B$BUnPTnDVMP7*E$ 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTUSBmPTEBDPTNPMPHJBQSnTPDSgUJDB &T DPMIBVNEFMFTFPFYQMJRVF "DPTNPMPHJBQSnTPDSgUJDBnVNBFYQMJDBmkPSBDJPOBMFTJT UFNgUJDBTPCSFBPSJHFN PSEFNFUSBOTGPSNBmkPEBOBUVSF[B EBRVBMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTGB[FNQBSUF/kPBENJUFBDSJBmkP EPNVOEPBQBSUJSEPOBEB NBTBGJSNBBHFSBmkPEFUPEBTBT DPJTBTQPSVNQSJODrQJPOBUVSBMEFPOEFUVEPWFNFQBSBPOEF UVEPSFUPSOB BQIZTJT
EBrBCVTDBEPTQSJNFJSPTGJMwTPGPTQPS FTTFQSJODrQJPOBUVSBM FUFSOP JNQFSFDrWFMFJNPSUBM HFSBEPSEF UPEPTPTTFSFT"GJSNBRVF FNCPSBBQIZTJTTFKBJNQFSFDrWFM FMBEgPSJHFNBUPEPTPTTFSFTJOGJOJUBNFOUFWBSJBEPTFEJGFSFO UFTEPNVOEP RVFTkP BPDPOUSgSJP QFSFDrWFJT"GJSNBUBNCnN RVF FNCPSBBQIZTJTTFKBJNVUgWFM PTTFSFTGrTJDPTPVOBUVSBJT HFSBEPTQPSFMB BMnNEFNPSUBJT TkPNVUgWFJTPVTFSFTFN DPOUrOVBUSBOTGPSNBmkP 1SPGFTTPS B OFTUBSFTQPTUB PBMVOPQPEFFTDPMIFSRVBM RVFSVNEPTUSBmPTBDJNBQBSBDPNQMFNFOUBSTVBFYQMJDBmkP $PNPP|MUJNPUSBmPTFSgFYQMJDBEPOBSFTQPTUBTFHVJOUF TV HFSJNPT DPNPFYFNQMP BFYQMJDBmkPEPTJHOJGJDBEPEBQIZTJT QBSBPTQSJNFJSPTGJMwTPGPT/PQFSrPEPDPTNPMwHJDP PTGJMw TPGPTBENJUJBNBFYJTUpODJBEFVNQSJODrQJPFUFSOPFJNVUgWFM QIZTJT
BMHPRVFFTUgOBPSJHFNEBOBUVSF[BFEFTVBTUSBOT GPSNBm{FT0TQSJNFJSPTGJMwTPGPTPDPODFCJBNDPNPBMHPRVF OkPQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEPQFMBQFSDFQmkPTFOTPSJBM NBTTwQFMP QFOTBNFOUP1PSJTTP DBEBGJMwTPGPFODPOUSPVNPUJWPTFSB[{FT QBSBEFUFSNJOBSPRVFFSBBQIZTJT 2VFnLrOFTJTPVPEFWJS 1PSRVFFTTBJEFJBnDFOUSBMOP QFOTBNFOUPQSnTPDSgUJDP ,rOFTJT FNHSFHP TJHOJGJDB²NPWJNFOUP³1PSNPWJNFOUP PTHSFHPTOkPFOUFOEFNBQFOBTBNVEBOmBEFMVHBSPVBMPDP NPmkP NBTUPEBFRVBMRVFSBMUFSBmkPPVNVEBOmBRVBMJUBUJWB FPVRVBOUJUBUJWBEFVNTFS CFNDPNPTFVOBTDJNFOUPFTFV QFSFDJNFOUP&TTFNPWJNFOUPEBTDPJTBTFEPNVOEPDIBNB TFEFWJSFTFHVFMFJTSJHPSPTBT MFJTEFUFSNJOBEBTQFMBQIZTJT RVFPQFOTBNFOUPDPOIFDF&TTBJEFJBnDFOUSBMQBSBPQFOTB NFOUPQSnTPDSgUJDPQPSRVFOFTTFQFSrPEPBGJMPTPGJBTFPDVQB GVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFDPNBPSJHFNEPNVOEPFBTDBVTBTEBT USBOTGPSNBm{FTOBOBUVSF[B 2VBMBNVEBOmBOBFEVDBmkPEPTKPWFOTHSFHPTOBQBTTB HFNEBBSJTUPDSBDJBQBSBBEFNPDSBDJB /BBSJTUPDSBDJB BFEVDBmkPEPTKPWFOTCBTFBWBTFOBJEFJB EPHVFSSFJSPCFMPFCPN/BEFNPDSBDJB PBOUJHPJEFBMFEVDB UJWPKgOkPBUFOEJBhTFYJHpODJBTEBTPDJFEBEFHSFHBFQBTTPV BTFSTVCTUJUVrEPQFMBGPSNBmkPEPCPNDJEBEkP BRVFMFRVF TBCJBGBMBSFNQ|CMJDPFQFSTVBEJSPTPVUSPTOBQPMrUJDB
2
Manual do Professor
2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBTQBSBBGJMPTPGJBEBNVEBOmBOBFEV DBmkPEPTKPWFOTHSFHPT 1SJNFJSBNFOUF PBQBSFDJNFOUPEPTTPGJTUBT RVFQBT TBSBNBEBSBPTKPWFOTFTTBOPWBFEVDBmkP TVCTUJUVJOEPB FEVDBmkPBOUJHBEPTQPFUBT"MnNEJTTP PDPSSFVVNBNV EBOmBOPFOGPRVFEBGJMPTPGJBQSPUBHPOJ[BEBQPS4wDSBUFT RVFEFJYPVEFTFPDVQBSGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFDPNBPSJHFNEP NVOEPFBTDBVTBTEBTUSBOTGPSNBm{FTEBOBUVSF[B DPTNP MPHJB
QBTTBOEPBPDVQBSTFDPNBJOWFTUJHBmkPEBTRVFT U{FTIVNBOBT EPBVUPDPOIFDJNFOUPPVEPDPOIFDJNFOUP RVFPTIPNFOTUpNEFTJNFTNPT BOUSPQPMPHJB
QBSUJDV MBSNFOUFEFTFVFTQrSJUPFEFTVBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBDPOIFDFS BWFSEBEF 2VFFOTJOBWBNPTTPGJTUBT &OTJOBWBNUnDOJDBTEFQFSTVBTkPQBSBPTKPWFOTEFNPEP RVF OVNBBTTFNCMFJB TPVCFTTFNUFSGPSUFTBSHVNFOUPT 2VFQSPQVOIB4wDSBUFTDPOUSBPTTPGJTUBT "OUFTEFRVFSFSQFSTVBEJSPTPVUSPT DBEBVNEFWFSJB QSJ NFJSPFBOUFTEFUVEP DPOIFDFSTFBTJNFTNP $PNP1MBUkPEFTDSFWF4wDSBUFT $PNPVNIPNFNRVFBOEBWBQFMBTSVBTFQSBmBTEF"UF OBT QFMPNFSDBEPFQFMB"TTFNCMFJBRVFTUJPOBOEPBTQFTTPBT TPCSFTVBTDSFOmBT TVBTBGJSNBm{FT TPCSFBRVJMPRVFFMBT BDIBWBNRVFDPOIFDJBN TPCSFBFTTpODJBEBTDPJTBTGrTJDBTF FTQJSJUVBJT 0RVF4wDSBUFTQSFUFOEJBBPCVTDBSBFTTpODJBFPDPODFJ UP 1SFUFOEJBCVTDBSBWFSEBEFEFVNBDPJTB EFVNBJEFJB EF VNWBMPS"PGB[FSTVBTQFSHVOUBTSFGFSJOEPTFBJEFJBT WBMPSFT QSgUJDBTFDPNQPSUBNFOUPTRVFKVMHBWBNDFSUPTFWFSEBEFJSPT GB[JBDPNRVFPTBUFOJFOTFTEFTDPCSJTTFN TVSQSFTPT RVFOkP TBCJBNSFTQPOEFSFRVFOVODBUJOIBNQFOTBEPFNTVBTDSFOmBT TFVTWBMPSFTFTVBTJEFJBT%FTTBNBOFJSB TVTDJUBOEPE|WJEBT GB[JBPTQFOTBSOkPTwTPCSFTJNFTNPTNBTUBNCnNTPCSFB QwMJT
HBm{FT FUBJTRVFTU{FTCVTDBWBNDPNQSFFOEFSRVBMFSBPMVHBS EPIPNFNOPNVOEP &YQMJRVFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPTFOTrWFMFPJOUFMJHrWFMFTUB CFMFDJEBQPS1MBUkP 0TFOTrWFMTkPBTDPJTBTNBUFSJBJTPVDPSQwSFBTDVKPDP OIFDJNFOUPOPTnEBEPQPSNFJPEFOPTTPDPSQPOBFYQFSJpODJB TFOTPSJBMPVEPTwSHkPTEPTTFOUJEPTFQFMBMJOHVBHFNCBTFBEB OFTTFTEBEPTOPTEgJNBHFOTEBTDPJTBTUBJTDPNPOPTBQB SFDFNFOPTQBSFDFN TFNBMDBOmBSBSFBMJEBEFPVBFTTpODJB WFSEBEFJSBEFMBT0JOUFMJHrWFMnPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPRVF BMDBOmBNPTFYDMVTJWBNFOUFQFMPQFOTBNFOUPTkPBTJEFJBT JNBUFSJBJTFJODPSQwSFBTEFUPEPTPTTFSFTPVBTFTTpODJBTSFBJT FWFSEBEFJSBTEBTDPJTBT $PNCBTFOBBGJSNBmkPEF"SJTUwUFMFTEFRVFBGJMPTPGJBnB UPUBMJEBEFEFUPEBTBTDJpODJBTFUPNBOEPBEJTUJOmkPFOUSF DPOUFNQMBmkPFBmkP FYQPOIBCSFWFNFOUFBDMBTTJGJDBmkP BSJTUPUnMJDBEBTDJpODJBT $JpODJBTQSPEVUJWBTFTUVEBNBTQSgUJDBTQSPEVUJWBTPV BTUnDOJDBT JTUPn BTBm{FTIVNBOBTDVKBGJOBMJEBEFFTUgQBSB BMnNEBQSwQSJBBmkP QPJTBGJOBMJEBEFnBQSPEVmkPEFVNPCKF UP EFVNBPCSBBSRVJUFUVSB FDPOPNJB NFEJDJOB$JpODJBTQSg UJDBTFTUVEBNBTQSgUJDBTIVNBOBTFORVBOUPBm{FTRVFUpN OFMBTNFTNBTTFVQSwQSJPGJN JTUPn BGJOBMJEBEFEBBmkPOkP nDIFHBSBVNQSPEVUPEJGFSFOUFEPBHFOUF FTJNBSFBMJ[BmkP EPQSwQSJPBHFOUFnUJDBFQPMrUJDB$JpODJBTUFPSnUJDBTPVDPO UFNQMBUJWBTFTUVEBNDPJTBTRVFFYJTUFNJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EPTIPNFOTFEFTVBTBm{FT JTUPn BTDPJTBTEBOBUVSF[BFBT DPJTBTEJWJOBTQTJDPMPHJB NBUFNgUJDB EFVNMBEP FNFUBGrTJDB FUFPMPHJB EFPVUSP &YQPOIBBDMBTTJGJDBmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBEBTDJpODJBTUFPSnUJDBT PVDPOUFNQMBUJWBT
"PQJOJkPWBSJBEFQFTTPBQBSBQFTTPB EFMVHBSQBSBMVHBS EFnQPDBQBSBnQPDBcJOTUgWFM NVUgWFM EFQFOEFEFDBEBVN EFTFVTHPTUPTFQSFGFSpODJBT0DPODFJUPnVNBWFSEBEFJOUFN QPSBM VOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJB
"SJTUwUFMFT DMBTTJGJDB FTTBT DJpODJBT QPS HSBVT EF TV QFSJPSJEBEF JOEPEBNBJTJOGFSJPShTVQFSJPS$JpODJBTEBT DPJTBTOBUVSBJTTVCNFUJEBThNVEBOmBPVBPEFWJSGrTJDB CJPMPHJB NFUFPSPMPHJB QTJDPMPHJB$JpODJBTEBTDPJTBTOB UVSBJTRVFOkPFTUkPTVCNFUJEBThNVEBOmBPVBPEFWJSBT NBUFNgUJDBTFBBTUSPOPNJB$JpODJBEBSFBMJEBEFQVSB RVF OkPnOFNOBUVSBMNVUgWFM OFNOBUVSBMJNVUgWFM OFNSFTVM UBEPEBBmkPIVNBOB OFNSFTVMUBEPEBGBCSJDBmkPIVNBOB ±nPRVF"SJTUwUFMFTDIBNBEFTFSPVTVCTUiODJBEFUVEP PRVFFYJTUF$JpODJBEBTDPJTBTEJWJOBTRVFTkPBDBVTBF BGJOBMJEBEFEFUVEPPRVFFYJTUFOBOBUVSF[BFOPIPNFN DIBNBEBEFUFPMPHJB
1PSRVF"UFOBTDPOEFOPV4wDSBUFThNPSUF
2VFRVFSEJ[FSNFUBGrTJDB
1PSRVF BPGB[FSBKVWFOUVEFQFOTBS FMFTFUPSOBSBVNQF SJHPQBSBRVFNEFUJOIBPQPEFS
&NHSFHP NFUBTJHOJGJDB²PRVFWFNEFQPJT PRVFFTUg MnN³5SBUBTFEBDJpODJBUFPSnUJDBRVFFTUVEBPTFSQVSP P B TFSFORVBOUPTFS
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPQJOJkPFDPODFJUP
1PSRVFBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBGJMPTPGJBOPQFSrPEP TPDSgUJDPJOEJDBNRVFBQSJODJQBMQSFPDVQBmkPGJMPTwGJDBn DPNPIPNFN 1PSRVF BPDPOUSgSJPEPQFSrPEPBOUFSJPS DPTNPMwHJDP
OP VBMPTGJMwTPGPTCVTDBWBNDPOIFDFSBTDBVTBTFPSJHFOTEBOB R UVSF[B OPQFSrPEPTPDSgUJDP OPRVBMTFDPOTPMJEPVBBTDFOTkP EFVNBOPWBDMBTTFTPDJBMEFDBSgUFSEFNPDSgUJDP BTRVFTU{FT IVNBOBTQBTTBSBNBTFSPDFOUSPEBTQSFPDVQBm{FTFJOWFTUJ
3
1BSUJOEPEF"SJTUwUFMFT RVBJTTkPPTUSpTHSBOEFTDBNQPT EBJOWFTUJHBmkPGJMPTwGJDB 0EPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPTFS JTUPn EBSFBMJEBEFGVOEBNFOUBM FQSJNPSEJBMEFUPEBTBTDPJTBTPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBTBm{FT IVNBOBTPVEPTWBMPSFTFEBTGJOBMJEBEFTEBBmkPIVNBOBP EPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBDBQBDJEBEFIVNBOBEFDPOIFDFS JTUPn P DPOIFDJNFOUPEPQSwQSJPQFOTBNFOUPFNFYFSDrDJP
| U NIDADE 1 |
A filosofia
2VFRVFSEJ[FSPOUPMPHJB 0DBNQPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPGPSNBEPQFMPDPOKVOUPEBNFUB GrTJDBFEBUFPMPHJBRVFJOWFTUJHBPTFS BSFBMJEBEFGVOEBNFOUBM FQSJNPSEJBMEFUPEBTBTDPJTBT
#APqTULOß߯ßßLnej_el]eolank`ko`]deopne] `]behkokbe] 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBGJMPTPGJBFTUgOBIJTUwSJBFUFN VNBIJTUwSJB "GJMPTPGJBFTUgOBIJTUwSJBQPSRVFNBOJGFTUBFFYQSJNFPT QSPCMFNBTFBTRVFTU{FTRVF FNDBEBnQPDBEFVNBTPDJFEB EF PTIPNFOTDPMPDBNQBSBTJNFTNPTEJBOUFEPRVFnOPWP FBJOEBOkPGPJDPNQSFFOEJEP&BGJMPTPGJBUFNVNBIJTUwSJB QPSRVFBTSFTQPTUBT TPMVm{FTFOPWBTQFSHVOUBTPGFSFDJEBT EJBOUFEFDBEBnQPDBUPSOBNTFTBCFSFTBERVJSJEPTRVFPVUSPT GJMwTPGPTQSPTTFHVFNPV GSFRVFOUFNFOUF UPSOBNTFOPWPT QSPCMFNBTRVFPVUSPTGJMwTPGPTUFOUBNSFTPMWFS 2VFJEFJBTOPWBTBQBUSrTUJDBJOUSPEV[JVOBGJMPTPGJBHSFHB 1PSRVFTkPEPHNBT "JEFJBEFDSJBmkPEPNVOEPBQBSUJSEPOBEB EFQFDBEP PSJHJOBMEPIPNFN EF%FVTDPNPUSJOEBEFVOB EFFODBSOBmkP FNPSUFEF%FVT EFKVr[PGJOBMPVEFGJNEPTUFNQPTFSFTTVSSFJ mkPEPTNPSUPT FUD5BNCnNFYQMJDPVDPNPPNBMQPEFFYJTUJS OPNVOEP KgRVFUVEPGPJDSJBEPQPS%FVT RVFnQVSBQFSGFJmkP FCPOEBEF*OUSPEV[JVBJEFJBEF²IPNFNJOUFSJPS³ JTUPn EB DPOTDJpODJBNPSBMFEPMJWSFBSCrUSJPEBWPOUBEF&TTBTJEFJBT TkPEPHNBTQPSTFSFNDPODFCJEBTDPNPWFSEBEFTSFWFMBEBT QPS%FVTFQPSUBOUPJSSFGVUgWFJTFJORVFTUJPOgWFJT 2VBMBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFBTWFSEBEFTJOUSPEV[JEBTQFMBQB USrTUJDB "EJTUJOmkPFOUSFWFSEBEFTTPCSFOBUVSBJTFWFSEBEFTOB UVSBJT TFOEPRVFBTQSJNFJSBTJOUSPEV[FNBOPmkPEFDPOIF DJNFOUPSFDFCJEPQPSVNBHSBmBEJWJOB TVQFSJPSBPTJNQMFT DPOIFDJNFOUPSBDJPOBM 2VBJTBTQPTJm{FTEPTGJMwTPGPTDSJTUkPTTPCSFBTSFMBm{FT FOUSFGnFSB[kP )BWJBPTRVFKVMHBWBNGnFSB[kPJSSFDPODJMJgWFJTFBGnTVQF SJPShSB[kP PTRVFKVMHBWBNGnFSB[kPDPODJMJgWFJT NBTTVCPS EJOBWBNBSB[kPhGn FPTRVFKVMHBWBNSB[kPFGnJODPODJMJgWFJT NBTBGJSNBWBNRVFDBEBVNBEFMBTUFNTFVDBNQPQSwQSJPEF DPOIFDJNFOUPFOkPEFWFNTFNJTUVSBS 2VBJTPTHSBOEFTUFNBTEBGJMPTPGJBNFEJFWBM "EJGFSFOmBFBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFJOGJOJUP %FVT FGJOJUP IP NFN NVOEP BEJGFSFOmBFOUSFSB[kPFGn BQSJNFJSBEFWFTV CPSEJOBSTFhTFHVOEB BEJGFSFOmBFBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFDPSQP NBUnSJB FBMNB FTQrSJUP P6OJWFSTPDPNPVNBIJFSBSRVJBEF TFSFT POEFPTTVQFSJPSFTEPNJOBNFHPWFSOBNPTJOGFSJPSFT BTVCPSEJOBmkPEPQPEFSUFNQPSBMEPTSFJTFCBS{FTBPQPEFS FTQJSJUVBMEFQBQBTFCJTQPT 0RVFFSBPQSJODrQJPEFBVUPSJEBEF &SBPFNCBTBNFOUPEFVNBJEFJBOPTBSHVNFOUPTEFVNB BVUPSJEBEFSFDPOIFDJEB #rCMJB 1MBUkP "SJTUwUFMFT VNQBQB VNTBOUP QBSBRVFTwBTTJNGPTTFDPOTJEFSBEBWFSEBEFJSB
3FTVNBBTUSpTHSBOEFTMJOIBTEBGJMPTPGJBEB3FOBTDFOmBF FYQMJRVFQPSRVFFYQSJNFNPIVNBOJTNPSFOBTDFOUJTUB 1SJNFJSPBMJOIBQSPWFOJFOUFEBMFJUVSBEFUSpTEJgMPHPTEF 1MBUkP #BORVFUF 'nEPO 'FESP
EBTPCSBTEPTGJMwTPGPTOFP QMBUyOJDPTFEBEFTDPCFSUBEPDPOKVOUPEPTMJWSPTEPIFSNFUJT NPPVEFNBHJBOBUVSBM/FMB BOBUVSF[BFSBDPODFCJEBDPNP VNHSBOEFTFSWJWP EPUBEBEFVNBBMNBVOJWFSTBMFOUSFMBmBEB DPNUPEBTBTDPJTBT TFOEPPIPNFNDPODFCJEPDPNPQBSUF EFTTBOBUVSF[B4FHVOEPBMJOIBPSJHJOgSJBEPTQFOTBEPSFT GMPSFOUJOPT RVFWBMPSJ[BWBBWJEBBUJWB BQPMrUJDB FEFGFOEJBB MJCFSEBEFEBTDJEBEFTJUBMJBOBTDPOUSBP*NQnSJP3PNBOP(FS NiOJDP&UFSDFJSPBRVFMBRVFQSPQVOIBPJEFBMEPIPNFNDP NPBSUrGJDFEFTFVQSwQSJPEFTUJOP UBOUPQPSNFJPEPTDPOIFDJ NFOUPTRVBOUPQPSNFJPEBQPMrUJDB EBTUnDOJDBTFEBTBSUFT 1PSRVF OPJOrDJPEBNPEFSOJEBEF WJHPSPVPDFUJDJTNP 1PSRVFKgOkPTFQPEJBBENJUJSRVFBSB[kPIVNBOBGPTTF DBQB[EFDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPFRVFBWFSEBEFGPTTFVOJ WFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJB TPCSFUVEPEFWJEPhTHVFSSBTSFMJHJPTBT hT EFTDPCFSUBTEFQPWPTJOUFJSBNFOUFEJGFSFOUFTEPTFVSPQFVT hT EJTQVUBTFRVFSFMBTGJMPTwGJDBTFUFPMwHJDBT &YQMJRVFPRVFGPJPTVSHJNFOUPEPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP OBGJMPTPGJBNPEFSOB 5SBUBTFEFVNBEBTNVEBOmBTUFwSJDBTGVOEBNFOUBJTEB GJMPTPGJBNPEFSOBQBSBWFODFSPDFUJDJTNP$POTJEFSBOEPBE| WJEBEBDBQBDJEBEFEBSB[kPIVNBOBQBSBDPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEF FYUFSJPSFPIPNFN PQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBGJMPTPGJBQBTTBBTFSB SFGMFYkP JTUPn PTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWPMUBTFQBSBTJNFT NPQBSBTBCFSTFnDBQB[EFDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP4PNFO UFEFQPJTEFDPOIFDFSTFBTJNFTNPnRVFPTVKFJUPTFWPMUB QBSBBTDPJTBTBDPOIFDFSPVPTPCKFUPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUP $PNPFSBDPODFCJEBBOBUVSF[BOBGJMPTPGJBNPEFSOB 1PS RVFFTTBDPODFQmkPMFWBhTJEFJBTEFFYQFSJNFOUBmkPDJFO UrGJDBFEFUFDOPMPHJB "OBUVSF[B BQBSUJSEF(BMJMFV nDPODFCJEBDPNPVNTJT UFNBPSEFOBEPEFDBVTBTFFGFJUPTOFDFTTgSJPTDVKBFTUSVUV SBQSPGVOEBFJOWJTrWFMnNBUFNgUJDB&TTBDPODFQmkPMFWBhT JEFJBTEFFYQFSJNFOUBmkPDJFOUrGJDBFEFUFDOPMPHJBQPSRVF QP EFOEPTFFYQMJDBSFSFQSFTFOUBSNBUFNBUJDBNFOUFBTSFMBm{FT EFDBVTBFFGFJUPRVFQSPEV[FN DPOTFSWBNPVEFTUSPFNUPEBT BTDPJTBTFUPEPTPTGBUPTEBSFBMJEBEF 1PSRVFQPEFNPTDIBNBSBGJMPTPGJBNPEFSOBEFSBDJPOBMJT NP 1PSRVFOBGJMPTPGJBNPEFSOBIgVNBFOPSNFDPOGJBOmBOBT DBQBDJEBEFTFOPTQPEFSFTEBSB[kPIVNBOB EFWJEPhDPOWJDmkP EFTFQPEFSFYQMJDBSP6OJWFSTPNFDiOJDBFNBUFNBUJDBNFOUF 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTBGJSNBm{FTEBGJMPTPGJBEBT-V[FT 1FMBSB[kP PIPNFNQPEFDPORVJTUBSBMJCFSEBEFFBGFMJ DJEBEFTPDJBMFQPMrUJDB"SB[kPnDBQB[EFBQFSGFJmPBNFOUPF QSPHSFTTP FPIPNFNnVNTFSQFSGFDUrWFM0BQFSGFJmPBNFOUP EBSB[kPTFSFBMJ[BQFMPQSPHSFTTPEBTDJWJMJ[Bm{FT)gEJGFSFOmB FOUSFOBUVSF[BFDJWJMJ[BmkP JTUPn BOBUVSF[BnPSFJOPEBTSFMB m{FTOFDFTTgSJBTEFDBVTBFFGFJUPPVEBTMFJTOBUVSBJTVOJWFS TBJTFJNVUgWFJT FORVBOUPBDJWJMJ[BmkPnPSFJOPEBMJCFSEBEFF EBGJOBMJEBEFQSPQPTUBQFMBWPOUBEFMJWSFEPTIPNFOT FNTFV BQFSGFJmPBNFOUPNPSBM UnDOJDPFQPMrUJDP
4
Manual do Professor
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFGJTJPDSBUBTFNFSDBOUJMJTUBT 0TGJTJPDSBUBTDPOTJEFSBNRVFBBHSJDVMUVSBnBGPOUFQSJODJ QBMEBTSJRVF[BTPTNFSDBOUJMJTUBTDPOTJEFSBNRVFPDPNnSDJP nBGPOUFQSJODJQBMEBSJRVF[BEBTOBm{FT
#APqTULOß߯ßß=ola_pko`]behkokbe] _kjpailknja] $PNPPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP9*9 )FHFMF$PNUF FOUFOEJBN BIJTUwSJB )FHFMBGJSNBWBRVFBIJTUwSJBnBSFBMJEBEF RVFBSB[kP B WFSEBEFFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTkPFTTFODJBMFOFDFTTBSJBNFOUF IJTUwSJDPT$PNCBTFOFTTBDPODFQmkP BIJTUwSJBQBTTPVBTFS FOUFOEJEBCBTJDBNFOUFQFMBJEFJBEFQSPHSFTTP RVF$PNUFBUSJ CVrBBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTDJpODJBT BTRVBJTQFSNJUJSJBNBPT TFSFTIVNBOPT²TBCFSQBSBQSFWFS QSFWFSQBSBQSPWFS³/FTTF TFOUJEP PEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTPDJBMTFGBSJBQFMPBVNFOUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUPDJFOUrGJDPFEPDPOUSPMFDJFOUrGJDPEBTPDJFEBEF $PNPPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP99QBTTBSBNBQFOTBSBIJTUw SJB /PTnDVMP99 BNFTNBBGJSNBmkPEBIJTUPSJDJEBEFEPTTF SFTIVNBOPT EBSB[kPFEBTPDJFEBEFMFWPVhJEFJBEFRVFBIJT UwSJBnEFTDPOUrOVBFOkPQSPHSFTTJWB EFRVFDBEBTPDJFEBEF UFNTVBIJTUwSJBQSwQSJBFNWF[EFTFSBQFOBTVNBFUBQBOVNB IJTUwSJBVOJWFSTBMEBTDJWJMJ[Bm{FT"QBSUJSEFFOUkP BJEFJBEF QSPHSFTTPQBTTPVBTFSDSJUJDBEB $PNPFSBPPUJNJTNPEPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP9*9DPNSFMBmkP hTDJpODJBTFhTUnDOJDBT "GJSNBWBTFBDPOGJBOmBQMFOBFUPUBMOPTBCFSDJFOUrGJDPF OBUFDOPMPHJBQBSBEPNJOBSFDPOUSPMBSBOBUVSF[B BTPDJFEBEF FPTJOEJWrEVPT"DSFEJUBWBTFRVFBTPDJPMPHJBPGFSFDFSJBVN TBCFSTFHVSPFEFGJOJUJWPTPCSFPNPEPEFGVODJPOBNFOUPEBT TPDJFEBEFT FRVFBQTJDPMPHJBFOTJOBSJBEFGJOJUJWBNFOUFDPNP GVODJPOBBQTJRVFIVNBOB RVBJTBTDBVTBTEPTDPNQPSUBNFO UPTFPTNFJPTEFDPOUSPMgMPT FRVFTFSJBQPTTrWFMVNBQFEB HPHJBCBTFBEBFNDPOIFDJNFOUPTDJFOUrGJDPTRVFQFSNJUJSJB FOUSFPVUSBTDPJTBT FEVDBSBTDSJBOmBTTFHVOEPTVBTWPDBm{FT FQPUFODJBMJEBEFTQTJDPMwHJDBT 1PSRVFOPTnDVMP99EFTBQBSFDFVPPUJNJTNPDPNSFMBmkP hTDJpODJBTFhTUnDOJDBT "GJMPTPGJBQBTTPVBEFTDPOGJBSEPPUJNJTNPEPTnDVMPBOUF SJPSEFWJEPBWgSJPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTHVFSSBTEFTFRVJMrCSJPFDP MwHJDPQSPCMFNBTnUJDPTFQPMrUJDPTBJODPSQPSBmkPEBTDJpO DJBTFEBTUnDOJDBTBHSBOEFTDPNQMFYPTJOEVTUSJBJTFNJMJUBSFT TFNTVCPSEJOBm{FTHPWFSOBNFOUBJTPVQ|CMJDBTPQFSBOEPEF BDPSEPDPNJOUFSFTTFTQSwQSJPT DPNBVUPOPNJBFNSFMBmkPBP RVFEFWFTFSQFTRVJTBEPFDPNPTFSkPVUJMJ[BEPTPTSFTVMUBEPT EFTFODBEFBOEPHVFSSBT EJUBEVSBT WJPMpODJBTFNUPEBQBSUF RVBOEPJTTPDPOWnNhTTVBTGJOBMJEBEFT &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPGFJUBQFMB&TDPMBEF'SBOLGVSUFOUSFSB [kPJOTUSVNFOUBMFSB[kPDSrUJDB "SB[kPJOTUSVNFOUBMnBSB[kPUnDOJDPDJFOUrGJDB RVFGB[ EBTDJpODJBTFEBTUnDOJDBTOkPVNNFJPEFMJCFSBmkPEPTTFSFT IVNBOPT NBTVNNFJPEFJOUJNJEBmkP NFEP UFSSPSFEFTFTQF SP"PDPOUSgSJP BSB[kPDSrUJDBnBRVFMBRVFBOBMJTBFJOUFSQSFUB PTMJNJUFTFPTQFSJHPTEPQFOTBNFOUPJOTUSVNFOUBMFBGJSNB RVFBTNVEBOmBTTPDJBJT QPMrUJDBTFDVMUVSBJTTwTFSFBMJ[BSkP
5
WFSEBEFJSBNFOUFTFUJWFSFNDPNPGJOBMJEBEFBFNBODJQBmkPEP HpOFSPIVNBOPFOkPBTJEFJBTEFDPOUSPMFFEPNrOJPUnDOJDP DJFOUrGJDPTPCSFBOBUVSF[B BTPDJFEBEFFBDVMUVSB 1PSRVFPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP99OkPNBOUJWFSBNPPUJNJT NPEPTnDVMP9*9DPNSFMBmkPhTSFWPMVm{FTTPDJBJTFQP MrUJDBT 1PSRVFEJBOUFEPTVSHJNFOUPEBTDIBNBEBTTPDJFEBEFTUP UBMJUgSJBTPVEPTSFHJNFTUPUBMJUgSJPT GBTDJTNP OB[JTNP TUBMJ OJTNP NBPJTNP FEJBOUFEPBVNFOUPEPQPEFSEBTTPDJFEBEFT BVUPSJUgSJBTPVEJUBUPSJBJT OB"NnSJDB-BUJOB OBT'JMJQJOBTFOB ÇGSJDBEP4VM
BGJMPTPGJBQBTTPVBJOEBHBSTFPTTFSFTIVNBOPT PTFYQMPSBEPTFPTEPNJOBEPT TFSJBNDBQB[FTEFDSJBSFNBO UFSVNBTPDJFEBEFOPWB KVTUBFGFMJ[ $PNPBGJMPTPGJBEPTnDVMP9*9EFGJOJVBDVMUVSB $PNPVNNPEPQSwQSJPFFTQFDrGJDPEBFYJTUpODJBEPTTFSFT IVNBOPT&NDPOTPOiODJBDPNBJEFJBEFQSPHSFTTPEBIVNBOJ EBEFFEFVNBIJTUwSJBVOJWFSTBMEBTDJWJMJ[Bm{FT IBWFSJBVNB |OJDBHSBOEFDVMUVSBFNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPPVFNQSPHSFTTP EB RVBMBTEJGFSFOUFTDVMUVSBTTFSJBNGBTFTPVFUBQBT 2VBMBDPODFQmkPEPTQFOTBEPSFTSPNiOUJDPTTPCSFBDVMUV SB 5SBUBTFEFVNBDPODFQmkPCBTFBEBOBJEFJBEFDVMUVSBT QBSUJDVMBSFTRVFOkPGPSNBWBNVNBTFRVpODJBVOJWFSTBMQSP HSFTTJWB%FTTBGPSNB PNBJTJNQPSUBOUFEFVNBDVMUVSBOkP TFFODPOUSBSJBFNTFVGVUVSP OPTFVQSPHSFTTP
NBTOPTFV QBTTBEP JTUPn OBTUSBEJm{FT OPGPMDMPSFOBDJPOBM $PNPPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP99DPODFCFNBDVMUVSB "GJSNBNRVFOkPIgBDVMUVSB VOJWFSTBMPVOBDJPOBM
NBT DVMUVSBTEJGFSFOUFT FRVFBQMVSBMJEBEFEFDVMUVSBTFBTEJGF SFOmBTFOUSFFMBTOkPTFEFWFNhOBmkP QPJTBJEFJBEFOBmkP nVNBDSJBmkPDVMUVSBMFOkPBDBVTBEBTEJGFSFOmBTDVMUVSBJT $BEBDVMUVSBJOWFOUBTFVNPEPEFSFMBDJPOBSTFDPNPUFNQP EFDSJBSTVBMJOHVBHFN EFFMBCPSBSTFVTNJUPTFTVBTDSFOmBT EFPSHBOJ[BSPUSBCBMIPFBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJT EFDSJBSBTPCSBT EFQFOTBNFOUPFEFBSUF$BEBVNB FNEFDPSSpODJBEBTDPO EJm{FTIJTUwSJDBT HFPHSgGJDBTFQPMrUJDBTFNRVFTFGPSNB UFN TFVNPEPQSwQSJPEFPSHBOJ[BSPQPEFSFBBVUPSJEBEF EFQSP EV[JSTFVTWBMPSFT 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP9*9FPTEP TnDVMP99RVBOUPBPEFTBQBSFDJNFOUPEBGJMPTPGJB &ORVBOUPPTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP9*9TVQVOIBNRVF OP GVUVSP TwIBWFSJBDJpODJBT FRVFUPEPTPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTF FYQMJDBm{FTTFSJBNEBEPTQPSFMBT OkPIBWFOEP QPSUBOUP NPUJWPQBSBBFYJTUpODJBEBGJMPTPGJB PTGJMwTPGPTEPTnDVMP 99 BPDPOUSgSJP NPTUSBNRVFBTDJpODJBTOkPQPTTVFNQSJO DrQJPTUPUBMNFOUFDFSUPT TFHVSPTFSJHPSPTPTQBSBBTJOWFTUJ HBm{FT RVFPTSFTVMUBEPTQPEFNTFSEVWJEPTPTFQSFDgSJPT FRVF GSFRVFOUFNFOUF VNBDJpODJBEFTDPOIFDFBUnPOEFQP EFJSFRVBOEPFTUgFOUSBOEPOPDBNQPEFJOWFTUJHBmkPEF VNBPVUSB$PNJTTP BGJMPTPGJBWPMUPVBBGJSNBSTFVQBQFMEF DPNQSFFOTkPFJOUFSQSFUBmkPDSrUJDBEBTDJpODJBT EJTDVUJOEP BWBMJEBEFEFTFVTQSJODrQJPT QSPDFEJNFOUPTEFQFTRVJTBF SFTVMUBEPT EFTVBTGPSNBTEFFYQPTJmkPEPTEBEPTFEBTDPO DMVT{FT FUD
| U NIDADE 1 |
A filosofia
1PSRVFBEFTDPCFSUBEBJEFPMPHJB QPS.BSY FBEPJODPOT DJFOUF QPS'SFVE RVFTUJPOBSBNPPUJNJTNPSBDJPOBMJTUBEP TnDVMP9*9 0PUJNJTNPSBDJPOBMJTUBEPTnDVMP9*9TFBQPJBWBOBJEFJB EFRVFBSB[kPTFEFTFOWPMWFSBQMFOBNFOUF EFNPEPRVFPDP OIFDJNFOUPDPNQMFUPEBSFBMJEBEFFEBTBm{FTIVNBOBTQPEJB TFSBUJOHJEP&OUSFUBOUP BEFTDPCFSUBEBJEFPMPHJB QPS.BSY FBEPJODPOTDJFOUF QPS'SFVE NPTUSBSBNRVF NVJUBTWF[FT PRVFKVMHBNPTQFOTBSDPNOPTTBQSwQSJBDBCFmBOkPQBTTB EFJMVT{FTDSJBEBTQPSVNQPEFSTPDJBMJOWJTrWFMRVFOPTGPSmBB QFOTBSFBHJSEFUBMNPEPFPVQPSVNQPEFS QTrRVJDPFTPDJBM
RVFBUVBTPCSFOPTTBDPOTDJpODJBTFNRVFFMBPTBJCB "QSFTFOUFBMHVOTFYFNQMPTEPJOUFSFTTFQFMPGJOJUPPVQFMB GJOJUVEFOBTGJMPTPGJBTEPTnDVMP99 6NFYFNQMPnPFYJTUFODJBMJTNP DPSSFOUFGJMPTwGJDBRVF EFGJOJVPIVNBOPPVPIPNFNDPNP²VNTFSQBSBBNPSUF³ JTUPn VNTFSRVFTBCFRVFnUFNQPSBM RVFUFNVNGJN FRVF QSFDJTBFODPOUSBSFNTJNFTNPPTFOUJEPEFTVBFYJTUpODJB6N PVUSPFYFNQMPnBGJMPTPGJBEBEJGFSFOmB RVFTFJOUFSFTTBNFOPT QFMBTTFNFMIBOmBTFJEFOUJEBEFTFNBJTQFMBTJOHVMBSJEBEFF QBSUJDVMBSJEBEF
2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDSrUJDBTQwTNPEFSOBThNPEFSOJEB EF 0QwTNPEFSOJTNPDPOTJEFSBJOGVOEBEBTFJMVTwSJBTBT QSFUFOT{FTEBSB[kPOPDPOIFDJNFOUPFOBQSgUJDBKVMHBRVF PDPOIFDJNFOUPOkPTFEFGJOFQPSQSPDFEJNFOUPTBSUJDVMBEPTh EJTUJOmkPFOUSFBWFSEBEFFBGBMTJEBEF FTJNQFMPTDSJUnSJPTEB VUJMJEBEFFEBFGJDgDJBDPOTJEFSBJOGVOEBEBBEJTUJOmkPFOUSF TVKFJUPFPCKFUP QPJTUBOUPBTGJMPTPGJBTDPNPBTDJpODJBTTkP DPOTUSVm{FTTVCKFUJWBTEFTFVTPCKFUPT PTRVBJTTwFYJTUFN DPNPSFTVMUBEPEBTPQFSBm{FTUFwSJDBTFUnDOJDBTOkPBENJUF BEJTUJOmkPFOUSFPSEFNOBUVSBMOFDFTTgSJBFPSEFNIJTUwSJDB PVDVMUVSBMJOTUJUVrEBQFMPTIPNFOTBNCBTTkPJOWFOm{FTPV JOTUJUVJm{FTIVNBOBT DPOUJOHFOUFT FGpNFSBT QBTTBHFJSBT OkPBENJUFBEFGJOJmkPEPTFSIVNBOPDPNPBOJNBMSBDJPOBM EPUBEPEFWPOUBEFMJWSF NBTPDPODFCFDPNPVNTFSQBTTJPOBM EFTFKBOUF RVFBHFNPWJEPQPSJNQVMTPTFJOTUJOUPT FNCPSB BPNFTNPUFNQP JOTUJUVBVNBPSEFNTPDJBMRVFSFQSJNFTFVT EFTFKPTFQBJY{FTEFTDPOGJBEBQPMrUJDB EBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFP Q|CMJDPFPQSJWBEPFEgJNQPSUiODJBhFTGFSBEBJOUJNJEBEFJOEJ WJEVBMEgJNQPSUiODJBhJEFJBEFEJGFSFOmB DPODFCFOEPPTPDJBM DPNPVNBUFJBGSBHNFOUBEBFHSVQPTRVFTFEJGFSFODJBNQPS FUOJB HpOFSP SFMJHJkP DPTUVNFT DPNQPSUBNFOUPT HPTUPTF QSFGFSpODJBT
0RVFEFGJOJBBNPEFSOJEBEFOPDBNQPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP $POGJBOmBOPQPEFSEBSB[kPQBSBEJTUJOHVJSFOUSFBQBSpODJB FSFBMJEBEFFQBSBDPOIFDFSFUSBOTGPSNBSBSFBMJEBEF%JTUJO mkPFOUSFJOUFSJPSFFYUFSJPSPVFOUSFTVKFJUPFPCKFUP"GJSNBmkP EBDBQBDJEBEFIVNBOBQBSBDPOIFDFSBFTTpODJBEFUPEPTPT TFSFT EFGJOJOEPBTDBVTBTFDPOEJm{FTQBSBBEFUFSNJOBmkPEB JEFOUJEBEFEFMFT EFNPOTUSBOEPBTSFMBm{FTOFDFTTgSJBTFOUSF FMBTFPGFSFDFOEPBTMFJTOFDFTTgSJBTEFNVEBOmBPVBMUFSBmkP EFUPEBTBTDPJTBT 0RVFEFGJOJBBNPEFSOJEBEFOPDBNQPEBQSgUJDB "BGJSNBmkPEBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBOFDFTTJEBEFRVFSFHF BPSEFNOBUVSBMPVBTMFJTEBOBUVSF[BFBPSEFNIVNBOBEB DVMUVSB nUJDB QPMrUJDB BSUFT
QPJTOFTUBBTSFHSBTFOPSNBT EFQFOEFNEBBmkPFDPOyNJDB TPDJBMFQPMrUJDBEPTQSwQSJPT IPNFOT"BGJSNBmkPEFRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTkPJOEJWrEVPT FBHFOUFTMJWSFTQPSRVFTkPTFSFTSBDJPOBJTEPUBEPTEFWPOUBEF FSFTQPOTgWFJTQPSTVBTFTDPMIBTFBm{FT"EJTUJOmkPFOUSFQ| CMJDPFQSJWBEP"BGJSNBmkPEPTJEFBJTEB3FWPMVmkP'SBODFTB° JHVBMEBEF MJCFSEBEFFGSBUFSOJEBEF0SFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFVNB FTGFSBEFEJSFJUPTDJWJT°PDBNQPEBDJEBEBOJB°FBNQMJBmkP EFTTFTJEFBJTQFMBBGJSNBmkPEFEJSFJUPTTPDJBJT"BGJSNBmkPEF VNTFOUJEPQSPHSFTTJWPEBIJTUwSJBPVEFJEFBJTSFWPMVDJPOgSJPT EFFNBODJQBmkPEPHpOFSPIVNBOP $PNPWFJPTFOEPHFTUBEPPQwTNPEFSOJTNPOPJOUFSJPS EBNPEFSOJEBEF 1PSNFJPEFVNNPWJNFOUPEFDPOUFTUBmkPEJBOUFEPPUJ NJTNPSBDJPOBMJTUB RVFQPEFTFSJEFOUJGJDBEPOBDSrUJDBEBT JEFPMPHJBT EBEFTDPCFSUBGSFVEJBOBEPJODPOTDJFOUF EBDSrUJDB EBIJTUwSJB EBVOJEBEFEBDVMUVSBPVEFTVBQMVSBMJEBEFOB DJPOBM EPTCFOFGrDJPTEBTDJpODJBTFEBTUnDOJDBT"JEFJBEB NFUBGrTJDBDPNPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBSFBMJEBEF|MUJNBEPTTFSFT GPJDPOUFTUBEBFGPJDFEFOEPMVHBSBPQBQFMEBMJOHVBHFNOB JOWFOmkPEPTQSwQSJPTTFSFTFEPTPCKFUPTEFDPOIFDJNFOUP "DPOUFTUBmkPEBJEFJBEFUPEPPVUPUBMJEBEFQPSNFJPEBBGJS NBmkPEPTMJNJUFTEBGJMPTPGJBFEBTDJpODJBTQBSBDPOIFDFSBT QSwQSJBTDPJTBT
2VFNVEBOmBTGJMPTwGJDBTPDPSSFSBNDPNBDSrUJDBEF,BOU hNFUBGrTJDB %JBOUFEBJEFJBEFRVFOPTTBSB[kPQPEFDPOIFDFSBTDPJTBT U BJTDPNPTkPFNTJNFTNBT ,BOUBGJSNPVRVFTwDPOIFDFNPT BTDPJTBTUBJTDPNPTkPPSHBOJ[BEBTQFMBFTUSVUVSBJOUFSOBF VOJWFSTBMEFOPTTBSB[kP NBTOVODBTBCFSFNPTTFUBMPSHBOJ [BmkPDPSSFTQPOEFPVOkPhPSHBOJ[BmkPFNTJEBQSwQSJBSFBMJ EBEF1PSUBOUP EFJYBOEPEFTFSNFUBGrTJDB BGJMPTPGJBUPSOPVTF VNBUFPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP PVVNBUFPSJBTPCSFBDBQBDJEBEF FBQPTTJCJMJEBEFIVNBOBTEFDPOIFDFS FVNBnUJDB PVFTUVEP EBTDPOEJm{FTEFQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBBmkPNPSBMFORVBOUPSFBMJ [BEBQPSMJCFSEBEFFQPSEFWFS 1PSRVF DPNPQPTJUJWJTNPEF"VHVTUP$PNUF BGJMPTPGJB TFSFEV[JBhFQJTUFNPMPHJB 1PSRVF EFBDPSEPDPNPQPTJUJWJTNP PDPOIFDJNFOUPFSB PCKFUPEBTDJpODJBT TFOEPSFTFSWBEPhGJMPTPGJBBQFOBTVNB SFGMFYkPTPCSFPTJHOJGJDBEPEPUSBCBMIPDJFOUrGJDP JTUPn VNB BOgMJTFFVNBJOUFSQSFUBmkPEPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTPVEBTNFUP EPMPHJBTVTBEBTQFMBTDJpODJBTFVNBBWBMJBmkPEPTSFTVMUBEPT PCUJEPT PVTFKB VNBFQJTUFNPMPHJB UFPSJBEBTDJpODJBT 2VBJTPTDBNQPTQSwQSJPTEBJOWFTUJHBmkPGJMPTwGJDB &Y QMJRVFUSpTEFMFT 0OUPMPHJBPVNFUBGrTJDBMwHJDBFQJTUFNPMPHJBUFPSJBEP DPOIFDJNFOUP nUJDB GJMPTPGJB QPMrUJDB GJMPTPGJB EB IJTUwSJB GJMPTPGJBEBBSUFPVFTUnUJDBGJMPTPGJBEBMJOHVBHFNIJTUwSJBEB GJMPTPGJB 5FPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFTUVEPEBTEJGFSFOUFTNPEBMJEB EFT DBQBDJEBEFTFQPTTJCJMJEBEFTEFDPOIFDJNFOUPIVNBOP &QJTUFNPMPHJBBOgMJTFDSrUJDBEBTDJpODJBT UBOUPBTDJpO DJBTFYBUBTPVNBUFNgUJDBTRVBOUPBTOBUVSBJTFBTIVNBOBT BWBMJBmkPEPTNnUPEPTFEPTSFTVMUBEPTEBTDJpODJBTDPNQB UJCJMJEBEFTFJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFTFOUSFBTDJpODJBTGPSNBTEF SFMBmkPFOUSFBTDJpODJBT FUD cUJDBFTUVEPEPTWBMPSFTNPSBJT BTWJSUVEFT
EBSFMBmkP FOUSFWPOUBEFFQBJYkP WPOUBEFFSB[kPGJOBMJEBEFTFWBMPSFT
-,
Manual do Professor
EBBmkPNPSBMJEFJBTEFMJCFSEBEF SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF EFWFS PCSJHBmkP FUD
&OVNFSFPTQSJODrQJPTBRVFBSB[kPPCFEFDF 1SJODrQJPEBJEFOUJEBEFQSJODrQJPEBOkPDPOUSBEJmkPPV QSJODrQJPEBDPOUSBEJmkPQSJODrQJPEPUFSDFJSPFYDMVrEPQSJODr QJPEBSB[kPTVGJDJFOUFPVQSJODrQJPEFDBVTBMJEBEF &YQMJRVFPQSJODrQJPEFJEFOUJEBEF
5NIDADEßßßß=n]vk #APqTULOß߯ßß=n]vk &YFNQMJGJRVFPTWgSJPTTFOUJEPTFNRVFBQBMBWSBSB[kPn VTBEBDPUJEJBOBNFOUF /PEJBBEJBVTBNPTBQBMBWSBSB[kPDPNEJGFSFOUFTTFO UJEPTDFSUF[B MVDJEF[ NPUJWP DBVTB"PEJ[FSNPT²WPDpUFN SB[kP³ BENJUJNPTRVFPPVUSPFTUgDFSUPEFBMHVNBDPJTBBP EJ[FS²WPDpFTUgOFSWPTBEFNBJT QFSEFVBSB[kP³ SB[kPnVUJMJ [BEBOPTFOUJEPEFMVDJEF[FNGSBTFTDPNP²TFWPDpNFEJTTFS TVBTSB[{FT TPVDBQB[EFGB[FSPRVFWPDpNFQFEF³ RVFSF NPTEJ[FSRVFRVFSFNPTPVWJSPTNPUJWPTRVFBMHVnNUFNF BPQFSHVOUBSNPT²RVBMnBSB[kPEJTTP ³ CVTDBNPTBDBVTB EFBMHVNBDPJTB 2VFRVFSEJ[FS1BTDBMBPBGJSNBSRVF²PDPSBmkPUFNSB[{FT RVFBSB[kPEFTDPOIFDF³ 2VFBTFNPm{FT PTTFOUJNFOUPTPVBTQBJY{FTTkPNPUJWPT FDBVTBTEFNVJUPEPRVFGB[FNPT EJ[FNPT RVFSFNPTFQFOTB NPT"PEJ[FSRVFBSB[kPEFTDPOIFDF²BTSB[{FTEPDPSBmkP³ 1BTDBMFTUgBGJSNBOEPRVFBDPOTDJpODJBJOUFMFDUVBMFNPSBMn EJGFSFOUFEBTQBJY{FTFEPTTFOUJNFOUPT 0RVFnSB[kPPCKFUJWB &SB[kPTVCKFUJWB 3B[kPPCKFUJWBnBBGJSNBmkPEFRVFPPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJ NFOUPPVBSFBMJEBEFnSBDJPOBMBSB[kPTVCKFUJWBnBBGJSNBmkP EFRVFPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFEBBmkPnSBDJPOBM $POTJEFSBOEPRVFSB[kPWFNEPHSFHPMwHPTFEPMBUJNSBUJP FYQMJRVFPRVFFMBTJHOJGJDBEFTEFTVBPSJHFN "NCBTBTQBMBWSBT MwHPTFSBUJP
FNCPSBEFPSJHFOTEJGF SFOUFT FUJNPMPHJDBNFOUFUpNVNTFOUJEPNVJUPQBSFDJEPDPO UBS SFVOJS KVOUBS DBMDVMBS NFEJS TFQBSBS"TTJN EFTEFBTVB PSJHFNBQBMBWSBSB[kPnBDBQBDJEBEFJOUFMFDUVBMEFQFOTBSF FYQSJNJSTFDPSSFUBFDMBSBNFOUF QBSBQFOTBSFEJ[FSBTDPJTBT UBJTDPNPTkP"SB[kPnVNBNBOFJSBEFPSHBOJ[BSBSFBMJEBEF NFEJS SFVOJS KVOUBS TFQBSBS DPOUBS DBMDVMBS QFMBRVBMFTUB TFUPSOBDPNQSFFOTrWFM
&TUFQSJODrQJPBGJSNBRVFVNBDPJTB TFKBFMBRVBMGPS VN TFSEBOBUVSF[B VNBGJHVSBHFPNnUSJDB VNTFSIVNBOP VNB PCSBEFBSUF VNBBmkP
TwQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEBFQFOTBEBTF GPSQFSDFCJEBFDPOTFSWBEBTVBJEFOUJEBEF PVTFKB DBEBDPJTB nDPOIFDJEBBUSBWnTEFTVBJEFOUJGJDBmkPDPNTVBEFGJOJmkP&N PVUSBTQBMBWSBT ²PRVFn n³ &YQMJRVFPQSJODrQJPEFDPOUSBEJmkP &TTFQSJODrQJPBGJSNBRVFVNBDPJTBPVVNBJEFJBEBRVBM BMHPnBGJSNBEPFOFHBEPBPNFTNPUFNQPFOBNFTNBSFMB mkPTkPDPJTBTPVJEFJBTRVFTFOFHBNBTJNFTNBTFRVFQPS JTTPTFBVUPEFTUSPFN EFTBQBSFDFN EFJYBNEFFYJTUJS PVTFKB BGJSNBRVFBTDPJTBTFBTJEFJBTDPOUSBEJUwSJBTTkPJNQFOTgWFJT FJNQPTTrWFJT &YQMJRVFPQSJODrQJPEFSB[kPTVGJDJFOUF &TTFQSJODrQJPBGJSNBRVFUVEPPRVFFYJTUFFUVEPPRVF BDPOUFDFUFNVNBSB[kP DBVTBPVNPUJWP QBSBFYJTUJSPVQBSB BDPOUFDFS FRVFUBMSB[kP DBVTBPVNPUJWP QPEFTFSDPOIFDJ EBQFMBOPTTBSB[kP0VTFKB BGJSNBBFYJTUpODJBEFSFMBm{FTPV DPOFY{FTJOUFSOBTFOUSFBTDPJTBT FOUSFGBUPTPVFOUSFBm{FTF BDPOUFDJNFOUPTTFN DPNJTTP OFHBSPBDBTPPVPTBDPOUFDJ NFOUPTBDJEFOUBJT 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBSB[kP "SB[kPOkPQPTTVJVNDPOUF|EPEFUFSNJOBEP NBTGPSNBT RVFJOEJDBNDPNPBTDPJTBTEFWFNTFSQFOTBEBTFTTBTGPSNBT QSJODrQJPT QPTTVFNWBMJEBEFVOJWFSTBM JTUPn POEFIPVWFS SB[kP OPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFOBTDPJTBT OPTGBUPTFBDPOUFDJ NFOUPT
FNUPEPUFNQPFFNUPEPMVHBS UBJTQSJODrQJPTTkPWFS EBEFJSPTFFNQSFHBEPTQPSUPEPT PTIVNBOPT FPCFEFDJEPT QPSUPEPT DPJTBT GBUPT BDPOUFDJNFOUPT FTkPOFDFTTgSJPT JOEJTQFOTgWFJT JTUPn JOEJDBNRVFBMHPnBTTJNFOkPQPEFTFS EFPVUSBNBOFJSB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=]pere`]`an]_ekj]h &YQMJRVFDPNPPQFSBBSB[kPEJTDVSTJWBPVPSBDJPDrOJP "SB[kPEJTDVSTJWBPVPSBDJPDrOJPnVNBNPEBMJEBEFEFDP OIFDJNFOUPEFVNBSFBMJEBEFPVVNPCKFUPRVFTFEgQPSNFJP EFWgSJBTFUBQBTTVDFTTJWBTEFDPOIFDJNFOUPBUnDPOTFHVJS DBQUgMPQPSVNDPODFJUPPVEFGJOJmkP
2VBJTTkPBTBUJUVEFTNFOUBJTPQPTUBThSB[kP 0DPOIFDJNFOUPJMVTwSJP JTUPn PDPOIFDJNFOUPEBNFSB BQBSpODJBEBTDPJTBTRVFOkPBMDBOmBBSFBMJEBEFPVBWFSEB EFEFMBTBTFNPm{FT TFOUJNFOUPT QBJY{FT RVFTkPDFHBT DBwUJDBT EFTPSEFOBEBT DPOUSgSJBTVNBThTPVUSBTBDSFOmB SFMJHJPTB QPJT OFTUB BWFSEBEFOPTnEBEBQFMBGnOVNBSF WFMBmkPEJWJOB OkPEFQFOEFOEPEPUSBCBMIPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP SFBMJ[BEPQFMBOPTTBJOUFMJHpODJBPVQFMPOPTTPJOUFMFDUPPpY UBTFNrTUJDP EPTTBOUPT QSPGFUBT
OPRVBMPFTQrSJUPBDSFEJUB FOUSBSFNSFMBmkPEJSFUBDPNPTFSEJWJOPFQBSUJDJQBSEFMF TFN OFOIVNBJOUFSWFOmkPEPJOUFMFDUPPVEBJOUFMJHpODJB OFNEB WPOUBEF
--
&YQMJRVFDPNPPQFSBBSB[kPJOUVJUJWB "PDPOUSgSJPEBSB[kPEJTDVSTJWB BSB[kPJOUVJUJWBDBQUBQPS JOUFJSPFDPNQMFUBNFOUFPPCKFUP EFVNBTwWF[5SBUBTF QPS UBOUP EFVNBWJTkPEJSFUBFJNFEJBUBEPPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFO UP VNDPOUBUPEJSFUPFJNFEJBUPDPNFMF TFNOFDFTTJEBEFEF QSPWBTPVEFNPOTUSBm{FTQBSBTBCFSPRVFDPOIFDF 0RVFnBJOUVJmkP %pVNFYFNQMPQFTTPBMEFVNDPOIFDJ NFOUPJOUVJUJWP "QBMBWSBJOUVJmkPEFSJWBEFVNWFSCPMBUJOP JOUVFSF RVF TJHOJGJDB²PMIBSBUFOUBNFOUF DPOUFNQMBS WFSDMBSBNFOUF³"JO
| U NIDADE 2
|
A razão
UVJmkPnVNBDPNQSFFOTkPHMPCBMFDPNQMFUBEFVNBWFSEBEF EFVNPCKFUP EFVNGBUP 1SPGFTTPS B nJNQPSUBOUFRVFPBMVOPDPOTJHBBQSFTFOUBS VNFYFNQMPQFTTPBMEBTVBWJEBDPUJEJBOBCBTFBEPOBEFGJOJ mkPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUVJUJWP0FYFNQMPDMgTTJDPnPEF*TBBD /FXUPO RVFEJ[UFSDPNQSFFOEJEPBFYJTUpODJBEBMFJEBHSBWJ EBEFBPWFSVNBNBmkDBJSEFVNBgSWPSF 2VBOUPTUJQPTEFJOUVJmkPFYJTUFN "JOUVJmkPSBDJPOBMQPEFTFSEFEPJTUJQPTJOUVJmkPTFOTrWFM PVFNQrSJDBFJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM 2VBJTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBJOUVJmkPFNQrSJDBPVTFOTrWFM "JOUVJmkPFNQrSJDBPVTFOTrWFMnPDPOIFDJNFOUPRVFUF NPTBUPEPNPNFOUPEFOPTTBWJEB4FEgQPSNFJPEBTRVBMJ EBEFTTFOTrWFJTEPTPCKFUPTDPS TBCPS PEPS TPN UFYUVSBEF OPTTPDPOUBUPTFOTPSJBMDPNBTDPJTBTMFNCSBOmBT EFTFKPT TFOUJNFOUPT JNBHFOTBJOUVJmkPFNQrSJDBPVTFOTrWFMnQTJDP MwHJDB JTUPn SFGFSFTFBPTFTUBEPTEPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP DPNPTFSDPSQPSBMFQTrRVJDPJOEJWJEVBM TFOTBm{FT MFNCSBO mBT EFTFKPTFQFSDFQm{FT BNBSDBEBJOUVJmkPFNQrSJDBnTVB TJOHVMBSJEBEFQPSVNMBEP FTUgMJHBEBhTJOHVMBSJEBEFEPPCKF UPJOUVrEP BPRVFnPGFSFDJEPhTFOTBmkPFhQFSDFQmkP F QPS PVUSP FTUgMJHBEBhTJOHVMBSJEBEFEPTVKFJUPRVFJOUVJ BPTNFVT FTUBEPTQTrRVJDPT hTNJOIBTFYQFSJpODJBT BJOUVJmkPFNQrSJDB OkPDBQUBPPCKFUPOBTVBVOJWFSTBMJEBEFFOkPnUSBOTGFSrWFM QBSBVNPVUSPPCKFUP 2VBJTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM "JOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBMEJGFSFEBTFOTrWFMKVTUBNFOUFQPSTVB VOJWFSTBMJEBEFFOFDFTTJEBEFcPDPOIFDJNFOUPEJSFUPFJNF EJBUPEPTQSJODrQJPTEBSB[kP JEFOUJEBEF DPOUSBEJmkP UFSDFJSP FYDMVrEP SB[kPTVGJDJFOUF
PTRVBJT QPSTFSFNQSJODrQJPT OkP QPEFNTFSEFNPOTUSBEPTnPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBTJEFJBTTJN QMFT JTUPn EBRVFMBTRVFOkPTkPDPNQPTUBTEFPVUSBTFOkP QSFDJTBNEFPVUSBTQBSBTFSFNDPOIFDJEBTFMBnUBNCnNB BQSFFOTkPJOUFMFDUVBMEBTSFMBm{FTOFDFTTgSJBTFOUSFBTJEFJBT FFOUSFPTTFSFTFFOUSFBTJEFJBTFBTDPJTBTEFRVFTkPJEFJBT &YQPOIBBJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBMEF%FTDBSUFTPVP²DwHJUP DBSUFTJBOP³ 0DwHJUPDBSUFTJBOPCBTFJBTFOVNBFWJEpODJBRVFEJTQFOTB QSPWBTPVEFNPOTUSBm{FTF QPSEFQFOEFSFYDMVTJWBNFOUFEB JOUFMJHpODJB TFNSFDPSSFSBOFOIVNDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFMPV TFOTPSJBM USBUBTFEFVNBJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM7FKBNPTRVBO EPQFOTP TFJRVFFTUPVQFOTBOEPFOkPnQSFDJTPQSPWBSPVEF NPOTUSBS QPJT QBSBJTTP FVUBNCnNQSFDJTP QSJNFJSP QFOTBS FTBCFSRVFQFOTP1BSBQFOTBSnQSFDJTPRVFBMHVnNSFBMJ[FP BUPEFQFOTBNFOUPF QPSUBOUP BRVFMFRVFQFOTBFYJTUFOFDFT TBSJBNFOUFBPQFOTBSPVFORVBOUPQFOTB QPJT EPDPOUSgSJP OkPIBWFSJBPBUPEFQFOTBS&OUkP ²QFOTP MPHPFYJTUP³
DBTPEFVNBSFDFJUBDVMJOgSJBRVF BPTFSQSFQBSBEB TFSWJEBF QSPWBEB JNFEJBUBNFOUFQFSDFCFTFRVFEFUFSNJOBEPEFUBMIF nRVFSFBMmBPTBCPSPVRVFFTUFPVBRVFMFUFNQFSPQPEFBQSJ NPSBSBJOEBNBJTPQSBUP 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBEFEVmkPSFBMJ[BVNBJOGFSpODJBF VNBJODMVTkP %pBGwSNVMBEBEFEVmkP 4JHOJGJDBRVF QFMBEFEVmkP QPEFNTFUJSBSDPODMVT{FTCB TFBEBTFNWFSEBEFTVOJWFSTBJTFFYJTUFOUFTTPCSFDBTPTQBSUJ DVMBSFTEFNPOTUSBOEPRVFBFMFTTFBQMJDBNUPEBTBTMFJT SF HSBTFWFSEBEFTVOJWFSTBJTFYJTUFOUFT$PTUVNBTFSFQSFTFOUBS BEFEVmkPQFMBTFHVJOUFGwSNVMB 5PEPTPTYTkPZ "nZ 1PSUBOUP "nY $PNPTFSFBMJ[BBJOEVmkP %pVNFYFNQMP /BJOEVmkP QBSUJNPTEFDBTPTQBSUJDVMBSFTJHVBJTPVTFNF MIBOUFTFQSPDVSBNPTBMFJHFSBM BEFGJOJmkPHFSBMPVBUFPSJB HFSBMRVFFYQMJDBFTVCPSEJOBUPEPTFTTFTDBTPTQBSUJDVMBSFT 1PSFYFNQMP 5FSSB .BSUF 7pOVT 4BUVSOP /FUVOPTkPUPEPTQMBOFUBT 5FSSB .BSUF 7pOVT 4BUVSOP /FUVOPOkPCSJMIBNDPNMV[ QSwQSJB 1PSUBOUP PTQMBOFUBTOkPCSJMIBNDPNMV[QSwQSJB 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBJOGFSpODJBEFEVUJWBFBJOEVUJWB /BEFEVmkP EFVNBRVFTUkPHFSBM UJSPDPODMVT{FTQBSUJDV MBSFT PVTFKB EBEP9 EFGJOJmkPPVUFPSJB
JOGJSP DPODMVP B C D E PTDBTPTQBSUJDVMBSFT /BJOEVmkP PQSPDFTTPnJOWFSTPEF DBTPTQBSUJDVMBSFT UJSBTFVNBDPODMVTkPHFSBM PVTFKB EBEPT B C D E PTDBTPTQBSUJDVMBSFT JOGJSP DPODMVP 9 EFGJOJmkPPV UFPSJBHFSBM 0RVFnBCEVmkP &YFNQMJGJRVFDPNVNBIJTUwSJBEFEFUF UJWFRVFWPDpDPOIFDF "BCEVmkPnVNBFTQnDJFEFJOUVJmkP NBTRVFOkPTFEgEF VNBTwWF[ JOEPQBTTPBQBTTPQBSBDIFHBSBVNBDPODMVTkP "BCEVmkPnBCVTDBEFVNBDPODMVTkPQFMBJOUFSQSFUBmkPSB DJPOBMEFTJOBJT EFJOErDJPT EFTJHOPT.VJUPTTkPPTDBTPTEF BCEVmkPOPDBNQPEBJOWFTUJHBmkPQPMJDJBM DPNPPTFYFNQMPT EPTSPNBODFTQPMJDJBJT6NCPNFYFNQMPEFBCEVmkPQPEFTFS PGJMNF0TIPXEF5SVNBO EJSFmkPEF1FUFS8FJS &6"
OP RVBMPQFSTPOBHFNQSJODJQBMWBJDPMFUBOEPJOErDJPTFTJOBJTBUn DPNQSFFOEFSJOUFJSBNFOUFPRVFTFQBTTBDPNFMF 0RVFnP3FBMJTNP $IBNBTF3FBMJTNPBQPTJmkPGJMPTwGJDBRVFBGJSNBBFYJT UpODJBPCKFUJWBPVFNTJEBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSOBDPNPVNBSFBMJ EBEFSBDJPOBMFNTJFQPSTJNFTNBF QPSUBOUP RVFBGJSNBB FYJTUpODJBEBSB[kPPCKFUJWB
%pVNFYFNQMPQFTTPBMEFSBDJPDrOJPFNQrSJDPSFBMJ[BEPFN TVBWJEBDPUJEJBOB
0RVFnP*EFBMJTNP
1SPGFTTPS B OFTUBSFTQPTUB DBEBBMVOPQPEFSgBQSFTFO UBSPTNBJTEJGFSFOUFTFYFNQMPTEFTVBWJEBEPNnTUJDB QSP GJTTJPOBM BGFUJWB FUD0JNQPSUBOUFnEFTUBDBSOPTFYFNQMPTB DPNQSFFOTkPUPUBM EJSFUBFJNFEJBUBRVFTFBQSFTFOUBQPSNFJP EPTTFOUJEPTPVTFOTPSJBMNFOUF QFSNJUJOEPBQFSDFQmkPEFVN DBNJOIPQBSBBTPMVmkPEFVNQSPCMFNBQSgUJDP1PEFTFSP
*EFBMJTNPnBQPTJmkPGJMPTwGJDBRVFFTUBCFMFDFVNBEJGF SFOmBFOUSFBSFBMJEBEFFPDPOIFDJNFOUPSBDJPOBMRVFEFMBUF NPT#BTFBEPOBFYJTUpODJBEBSB[kPTVCKFUJWB P*EFBMJTNPBGJS NBRVF FNCPSBBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSOBFYJTUBFNTJFQPSTJNFTNB TwQPEFNPTDPOIFDpMBUBMDPNPOPTTBTJEFJBTBGPSNVMBNFB PSHBOJ[BN FOkPDPNPFMBTFSJBFNTJNFTNB
-.
Manual do Professor
#APqTULOß߯ßß=n]vk6ej]p]kq]`mqene`]; 2VFnPJOBUJTNP 0JOBUJTNPBGJSNBRVF BPOBTDFSNPT USB[FNPTFNOPTTB JOUFMJHpODJBOkPTwPTQSJODrQJPTSBDJPOBJT NBTUBNCnNBMHV NBTJEFJBTWFSEBEFJSBT±BTJEFJBTJOBUBT4FHVOEP%FTDBSUFT JEFJBTJOBUBTTkPBRVFMBTRVFTFDPODFCFNFNSB[kPEBQSwQSJB OBUVSF[BEPFTQrSJUP BRVFMBTRVFUSB[FNPTQPSOBUVSF[B RVF TkPDPOHpOJUBTBOwT 2VFnPFNQJSJTNP 0FNQJSJTNP BPDPOUSgSJPEPJOBUJTNP BGJSNBRVFBSB[kP DPNTFVTQSJODrQJPT TFVTQSPDFEJNFOUPTFTVBTJEFJBT nBERVJ SJEBQPSOwTQFMBFYQFSJpODJB 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEP.JUPEF&S OBSSBEPQPS1MBUkPOB3F Q|CMJDB 0.JUPEF&SnVUJMJ[BEPQPS1MBUkPQBSBFYQMJDBSBUFPSJBEB SFNJOJTDpODJB RVFEFGFOEFBUFTFEPJOBUJTNP1BSB1MBUkP QPS NFJPEPNJUP WFNPTRVFDPOIFDFSnSFDPSEBSBTJEFJBTWFSEB EFJSBT SFNJOJTDpODJBT RVFKgFYJTUFNFNOwTnEFTQFSUBSB SB[kPQBSBRVFFMBTFFYFSmBQPSTJNFTNB $PNP%FTDBSUFTFYQMJDBBTJEFJBTJOBUBT BEWFOUrDJBTFGJD UrDJBT %FTDBSUFTDIBNBEFJEFJBTBEWFOUrDJBTBTRVFTFPSJHJOBN EFOPTTBTTFOTBm{FT QFSDFQm{FT MFNCSBOmBT TFOUJEPT4kP UBNCnNBTPQJOJ{FTGPSNVMBEBTBQBSUJSEFTTBTJEFJBTPVOPT TBTJEFJBTDPUJEJBOBTFDPTUVNFJSBT HFSBMNFOUFFOHBOPTBTPV GBMTBT JTUPn TkPPQJOJ{FTSFDFCJEBTFRVFOPSNBMNFOUFOkP DPSSFTQPOEFNhSFBMJEBEFEBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT*EFJBTGJDUrDJBT TkPBTRVFDSJBNPTFNOPTTBGBOUBTJBFJNBHJOBmkP DPNQPOEP TFSFTJOFYJTUFOUFTDPNQFEBmPTPVQBSUFTEFJEFJBTBEWFOUrDJBT RVFFTUkPFNOPTTBNFNwSJB&TTBTJEFJBTOVODBTkPWFSEBEFJ SBT QPJTOkPDPSSFTQPOEFNBOBEBRVFFYJTUBSFBMNFOUFFTB CFNPTRVFGPSBNJOWFOUBEBT%JGFSFOUFNFOUF BTJEFJBTJOBUBT OkPQPEFSJBNWJSEFOPTTBFYQFSJpODJBTFOTPSJBM OFNQPEFSJBN WJSEFOPTTBGBOUBTJB4kPJOUFJSBNFOUFSBDJPOBJTFTwQPEFN FYJTUJSQPSRVFKgOBTDFNPTDPNFMBT QPSPCSBEP$SJBEPS1PS FTTFNPUJWP TFSkPTFNQSFWFSEBEFJSBT JTUPn TFNQSFDPSSFT QPOEFSkPJOUFHSBMNFOUFhTDPJTBTBRVFTFSFGFSFN F HSBmBTB FMBT QPEFNPTKVMHBSRVBOEPVNBJEFJBBEWFOUrDJBnWFSEBEFJSB PVGBMTBFTBCFSRVFBTJEFJBTGJDUrDJBTTkPTFNQSFGBMTBT Tw FYJTUFNFNOPTTBJNBHJOBmkP $PNPPTFNQJSJTUBTFYQMJDBNBBUJWJEBEFEPDPOIFDJNFO UP 0TFNQJSJTUBTBGJSNBNRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPnBERVJSJEPQF MBFYQFSJpODJB"OUFTEBFYQFSJpODJB EJ[FNFMFT OPTTBSB[kPn DPNPVNB²GPMIBFNCSBODP³ POEFOBEBGPJFTDSJUPVNBUgCVMB SBTBPOEFOBEBGPJHSBWBEP4PNPTUPEPTDPNPVNBDFSBTFN GPSNBFTFNOBEBJNQSFTTPOFMB BUnRVFBFYQFSJpODJBWFOIB FTDSFWFSOBGPMIB HSBWBSOBUgCVMB EBSGPSNBhDFSB"SB[kPn VNBNBOFJSBEFDPOIFDFSFBBERVJSJNPT QPSNFJPEBFYQFSJpO DJBTFOTPSJBM OPEFDPSSFSEBWJEB 1PSRVF%BWJE)VNFBGJSNBRVFPQSJODrQJPEFDBVTBMJEBEF FNQSFHBEPOBTDJpODJBTFOBGJMPTPGJB OkPnJOBUPFTJNBE RVJSJEPQPSFYQFSJpODJB 1PSRVF QBSB)VNF BTSFMBm{FTFOUSFBTDPJTBTQPEFNTFS QFSDFCJEBTQFMBFYQFSJpODJBFhNFEJEBRVFWkPTFSFQFUJOEP EBNFTNBNBOFJSB DSJBN FNOwT PIgCJUPEFBTTPDJBSNPT
-/
JEFJBT%FTTBGPSNB )VNFOkPFTUgEJ[FOEPBQFOBTRVFBT JEFJBTEBSB[kPTFPSJHJOBNEBFYQFSJpODJB NBTFTUgBGJSNBO EPUBNCnNRVFPTQSwQSJPTQSJODrQJPTEBSBDJPOBMJEBEFTkP EFSJWBEPTEBFYQFSJpODJB+gOkPTFQPEFBENJUJSBVOJWFSTB MJEBEFFBOFDFTTJEBEFQSFUFOEJEBTQFMBSB[kP0VOJWFSTBMn BQFOBTVNOPNFPVVNBQBMBWSBHFSBMRVFVTBNPTQBSBOPT SFGFSJShSFQFUJmkPEFTFNFMIBOmBTQFSDFCJEBTFBTTPDJBEBT 0OFDFTTgSJPnBQFOBTPOPNFPVVNBQBMBWSBHFSBMRVFVTB NPTQBSBOPTSFGFSJShSFQFUJmkPEBTQFSDFQm{FTTVDFTTJWBT OPUFNQP0VOJWFSTBM POFDFTTgSJP BDBVTBMJEBEFTkPNFSPT IgCJUPTQTrRVJDPT 2VBJTPTQSPCMFNBTEPJOBUJTNP "QSwQSJBSB[kP JTUPn PTDPOIFDJNFOUPTTPCSFBSFBMJEBEF FPIPNFN QPEFNVEBSPDPOUF|EPEFJEFJBTRVFGPSBNDPOTJ EFSBEBTVOJWFSTBJTFWFSEBEFJSBT nPDBTPEBJEFJBQMBUyOJDBEF KVTUJmB BQSwQSJBSB[kP JTUPn PTQSPDFEJNFOUPTEFSBDJPDrOJP QPEFQSPWBSRVFJEFJBTDPOTJEFSBEBTSBDJPOBJTQPEFN OBSFBMJ EBEF TFSGBMTBT nPDBTPEFWgSJBTJEFJBTEBGrTJDBDBSUFTJBOB 2VBJTPTQSPCMFNBTEPFNQJSJTNP "JNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPDPOIFDJNFOUPPCKFUJWPEBSFBMJEBEF QPJT TFBTDJpODJBTTkPBQFOBTIgCJUPTQTJDPMwHJDPTEFBTTPDJBS QFSDFQm{FTFJEFJBTQPSTFNFMIBOmBFEJGFSFOmB CFNDPNPQPS DPOUJHVJEBEFFTQBDJBMPVTVDFTTkPUFNQPSBM FOUkPBTDJpODJBT OkPQPTTVFNWFSEBEFBMHVNB OkPFYQMJDBNSFBMJEBEFBMHVNB OkPOPTEkPDFSUF[BBMHVNBTPCSFBSFBMJEBEF OkPBMDBOmBNPT PCKFUPTUBJTDPNPTkPFNTJNFTNPTFUBJTDPNPGVODJPOBNPV PQFSBNSFBMNFOUF&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT PTDPOIFDJNFOUPTOkP QPTTVFNPCKFUJWJEBEF QPJTTkPBQFOBTIgCJUPTTVCKFUJWPT 1PSRVFPTQSPCMFNBTEPJOBUJTNPFEPFNQJSJTNPTVTDJUBN PBQBSFDJNFOUPEPDFUJDJTNP 1PSRVFEkPNBSHFNBE|WJEBTTPCSFBDBQBDJEBEFEBSB[kP IVNBOBEFDPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEF QPEFOEPKVTUJGJDBSBUnNFTNP BSFO|ODJBhWFSEBEF
#APqTULOß߯ßßKolnk^hai]o`kej]peoika`k aileneoik6okhqaobehkobe_]o 2VBJTPTUJQPTEFWFSEBEFTEJTUJOHVJEBTQPS-FJCOJ[ 7FSEBEFTEFSB[kPFOVODJBNRVFVNBDPJTBnPRVFFMB n OFDFTTgSJBFVOJWFSTBMNFOUF OkPQPEFOEPEFNPEPBMHVN TFSEJGFSFOUFEPRVFnFEFDPNPn"TWFSEBEFTEFSB[kPTkP JOBUBT JTUPn OBTDFNPTDPNVNBDBQBDJEBEFSBDJPOBM QVSB NFOUFJOUFMFDUVBM QBSBDPOIFDFSJEFJBTRVFOkPEFQFOEFNEB FYQFSJpODJBQBSBTFSFNGPSNVMBEBTFQBSBTFSFNWFSEBEFJSBT 7FSEBEFTEFGBUPEFQFOEFNEBFYQFSJpODJB QPJTFOVODJBN JEFJBTRVFTkPPCUJEBTQPSNFJPEBTFOTBmkP EBQFSDFQmkPF EBNFNwSJB $PNP-FJCOJ[EFGJOFPQSJODrQJPEFSB[kPTVGJDJFOUFFFY QMJDBRVFFMFHBSBOUFBOFDFTTJEBEFFVOJWFSTBMJEBEFEBT JEFJBT 1BSB-FJCOJ[ PQSJODrQJPEFSB[kPTVGJDJFOUFPVBJEFJBEF DBVTBMJEBEFVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJBQFSNJUFNBOUFSBTJEFJBT JOBUBTFBTJEFJBTFNQrSJDBT%FBDPSEPDPNPQSJODrQJPEFSB[kP TVGJDJFOUF UVEPPRVFFYJTUF UVEPPRVFQFSDFCFNPTFUVEP BRVJMPEFRVFUFNPTFYQFSJpODJBQPTTVJVNBDBVTBEFUFSNJ OBEBFFTTBDBVTBQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEB1BSB-FJCOJ[ QPSNFJP EFTTFQSJODrQJPUPEBTBTWFSEBEFTEFGBUP BRVFMBTRVFEFQFO
| U NIDADE 2
|
A razão
EFNEBFYQFSJpODJB QPEFSkP FNDFSUBTDPOEJm{FT UPSOBSTF VNEJBWFSEBEFTOFDFTTgSJBTFTFSFNDPOTJEFSBEBTWFSEBEFT EFSB[kP*TUPn QPEFNPTEFTFOWPMWFSQSPDFEJNFOUPTQFMPT RVBJTEFTDPCSJNPTRVFBFYQFSJpODJBFTUgPGFSFDFOEPSFMBm{FT DBVTBJTOFDFTTgSJBTFOUSFBTDPJTBT 0RVFGPJB²SFWPMVmkPDPQFSOJDBOB³FNBTUSPOPNJB $PNBQVCMJDBmkPEBPCSB%BTSFWPMVm{FTEPTPSCFTDFMFT UFT FN PBTUSyOPNP/JDPMBV$PQnSOJDPEFNPOTUSPVRVF BDPODFQmkPUSBEJDJPOBMBOUJHBFNFEJFWBM RVFDPOTJEFSBWBRVF PNVOEPQPTTVrBMJNJUFT OkPEBWBDPOUBEPTNPWJNFOUPTDF MFTUFTFEFNVJUPTPVUSPTGFOyNFOPTBTUSPOyNJDPT$PQnSOJDP FYQMJDPVRVFFTUBDPODFQmkP TJTUFNBHFPDpOUSJDP OkPUJOIB NPUJWPSBDJPOBMQBSBEJ[FSRVFP$nVTFNPWFFB5FSSBFTUgJNw WFM QPJTQPEFSJBTFSPDPOUSgSJPPV BUnNFTNP QPEFSJBEBSTF RVFBNCPTFTUJWFTTFNFNNPWJNFOUP$PQnSOJDPQSPQyT BT TJN PTJTUFNBIFMJPDpOUSJDP TFHVOEPPRVBMB5FSSBHJSBFN UPSOPEP4PM 2VBMBDSrUJDBEF,BOUBPTGJMwTPGPTJOBUJTUBTFFNQJSJTUBT
,BOUSFTPMWFPJNQBTTFFOUSFPJOBUJTNPFPFNQJSJTNP "QPOUBOEPPFOHBOPEPTJOBUJTUBT RVFTVQVOIBNRVFPT DPOUF|EPTPVBNBUnSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPTkPJOBUPT FBQPO UBOEPPFOHBOPEPTFNQJSJTUBT RVFTVQVOIBNRVFBFTUSV UVSBEBSB[kPnBERVJSJEBQPSFYQFSJpODJBPVDBVTBEBQFMBFY QFSJpODJB"TPMVmkPBQSFTFOUBEBQPS,BOUQBSBFTTFJNQBTTF nBEFRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPnBTrOUFTFRVFBSB[kP FTUBTJN VNBFTUSVUVSBJOBUB SFBMJ[BFOUSFVNBGPSNBVOJWFSTBMJOBUB FVNDPOUF|EPQBSUJDVMBSPGFSFDJEPQFMBFYQFSJpODJB RVFQP EFNWBSJBSOPUFNQPFOPFTQBmP USBOTGPSNBSTFDPNOPWBT FYQFSJpODJBTFNFTNPTFSFWFMBSFNGBMTPT HSBmBTBFYQFSJpO DJBTOPWBT 4FHVOEP,BOU RVBJTTkPBTFTUSVUVSBTBQSJPSJRVFDPOTUJ UVFNBSB[kPIVNBOB "SB[kPnDPOTUJUVrEBQPSUSpTFTUSVUVSBTBQSJPSJBFTUSV UVSBPVGPSNBEBTFOTJCJMJEBEF JTUPn BFTUSVUVSBPVGPSNBEB QFSDFQmkPTFOTrWFMPVTFOTPSJBMBFTUSVUVSBPVGPSNBEPFOUFO EJNFOUP JTUPn EPJOUFMFDUPPVEBJOUFMJHpODJBBFTUSVUVSBPV GPSNBEBSB[kPQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUB RVBOEPFTUBOkPTFSFMBDJPOB OFNDPNPTDPOUF|EPTEBTFOTJCJMJEBEFOFNDPNPTDPOUF|EPT EPFOUFOEJNFOUP NBTBQFOBTDPOTJHPNFTNB
, BOUEJ[RVFPTGJMwTPGPTJOBUJTUBTFFNQJSJTUBTQBSFDFNTFS DPNPPTBTUSyOPNPTHFPDpOUSJDPT CVTDBOEPVNDFOUSPRVF OkPnWFSEBEFJSP0SB EJ[,BOU ²PQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBGJMPTPGJB OkPQPEFTFSBSFBMJEBEF JOUFSJPS OPDBTPEPTJOBUJTUBT PVFY UFSJPS OPDBTPEPTFNQJSJTUBT
FTJNPFTUVEPEBQSwQSJBGBDVM EBEFEFDPOIFDFS PVPFTUVEPEBSB[kP³
2VBJTTkPBTGPSNBTBQSJPSJEBTFOTJCJMJEBEF
0RVFGPJB²SFWPMVmkPDPQFSOJDBOB³FNGJMPTPGJB
2VBJTTkPBTDBUFHPSJBTBQSJPSJEPFOUFOEJNFOUP 0RVF TkPFMBT
5SBUBTFEBQSPQPTUBEFNVEBOmBOBDPODFQmkPEFDPOIFDJ NFOUPGFJUBQPS,BOUFNTVBPCSB$SrUJDBEBSB[kPQVSB TFHVOEP BRVBM FNWF[EFOPTTPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFWFSTFSSFHVMBEPQFMPT PCKFUPT DPNPTFBENJUJBOBnQPDB PTPCKFUPTnRVFEFWJBN SFHVMBSTFQFMPOPTTPDPOIFDJNFOUP«NBOFJSBDPQFSOJDBOB QSPTTFHVF,BOU ²EFNPOTUSFNPT UBNCnNEFNBOFJSBVOJWFS TBMFOFDFTTgSJB RVFPTPCKFUPTTFBEBQUBNBPDPOIFDJNFOUP FOkPPDPOIFDJNFOUPBPTPCKFUPT³ 0RVF,BOUFOUFOEFQPSUSBOTDFOEFOUBM 7PDpTBCFSJBEJGF SFODJBSUSBOTDFOEFOUFFUSBOTDFOEFOUBM 1BSB,BOU ²USBOTDFOEFOUBM³n²UPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPRVF FN HFSBM TFPDVQBNFOPTEPTPCKFUPTFNBJTEFOPTTPNPEPEF DPOIFDFS OBNFEJEBFNRVFFTUFEFWFTFSBQSJPSJ ³²5SBOTDFO EFOUF³SFGFSFTFBPRVFWBJBMnNEBSFBMJEBEFFTQBmPUFNQPSBM PTVQSBTTFOTrWFMnVNBRVBMJGJDBmkPRVFEFTJHOBBRVJMPRVFn JOEFQFOEFOUFPVBOUFSJPShFYQFSJpODJB
4FHVOEP,BOU PFTQBmPFPUFNQP
4kPPTFMFNFOUPTTFNPTRVBJTOkPQPEFIBWFSDPOIFDJ NFOUPJOUFMFDUVBM QPJTTkPBTDPOEJm{FTRVFPSHBOJ[BNPTDPO UF|EPTFNQrSJDPTQBSBUBMDPOIFDJNFOUP4kPFMBTBRVBMJEBEF BDBVTBMJEBEF BGJOBMJEBEF BWFSEBEF BGBMTJEBEF BVOJWFSTBMJ EBEF BQBSUJDVMBSJEBEF 1PSRVFBSB[kPLBOUJBOBnTVCKFUJWB 1PSRVFOkPFTUgOBTDPJTBT NBTOPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFO UP1BSB,BOU BSB[kPnTFNQSFSB[kPTVCKFUJWBFOkPQPEFQSF UFOEFSDPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEFUBMDPNPFMBTFSJBFNTJNFTNB OFNQPEFQSFUFOEFSRVFFYJTUBVNBSB[kPPCKFUJWBHPWFSOBOEP BTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPLBOUJBOBFOUSFOyVNFOPFGFOyNF OP
0RVFRVFSEJ[FSBQSJPSJ &BQPTUFSJPSJ
/yVNFOPnBEFOPNJOBmkPLBOUJBOBEBEBhSFBMJEBEFFN TJGFOyNFOPnBEFOPNJOBmkPEBEBQFMPGJMwTPGPhSFBMJEBEFUBM DPNPnPSHBOJ[BEBQFMBSB[kP RVFTVCNFUFPTDPOUF|EPTEB FYQFSJpODJBhTFTUSVUVSBTEBTFOTJCJMJEBEFFEPFOUFOEJNFOUP
"QSJPSJPRVFnBOUFSJPShFYQFSJpODJBFOkPQSPWnNEFMBB QPTUFSJPSJPRVFnQPTUFSJPShFYQFSJpODJBFEFQFOEFOUFEFMB
0RVF)FHFMDSJUJDPVOBTGJMPTPGJBTBOUFSJPSFThTVB
2VBMBSFMBmkPFTUBCFMFDJEBQPS,BOUFOUSFSB[kPBQSJPSJF FYQFSJpODJBBQPTUFSJPSJ
"DSrUJDBEF)FHFMBUPEBTBTGJMPTPGJBTBOUFSJPSFThTVBGPJOP TFOUJEPEFOkPIBWFSFNDPNQSFFOEJEPPRVFIgEFNBJTGVOEB NFOUBMFEFNBJTFTTFODJBMOBSB[kPBSB[kPnIJTUwSJDB
%PQPOUPEFWJTUBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP BSB[kPnVNBFTUSVUV SBBQSJPSJ JTUPn BOUFSJPShFYQFSJpODJBFJOEFQFOEFOUFEFMBc VNBFTUSVUVSBWB[JB VNBGPSNBQVSBTFNDPOUF|EPT1PSnN PTDPOUF|EPTRVFBSB[kPDPOIFDFFOPTRVBJTFMBQFOTB FTUFT TJNEFQFOEFNEBFYQFSJpODJB"TTJN BFYQFSJpODJBGPSOFDFB NBUnSJB PTDPOUF|EPTBQPTUFSJPSJ EPDPOIFDJNFOUPQBSBBSB [kPFFTUB QPSTVBWF[ GPSOFDFBGPSNB VOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJB EPDPOIFDJNFOUP
2VFRVFSEJ[FSBTFOUFOmB²"SB[kPnIJTUwSJBFnUFNQP³ $PNUBMBGJSNBmkP )FHFMSPNQFDPNBDPODFQmkPEFJOUFN QPSBMJEBEFBUnFOUkPBUSJCVrEBhSB[kP&MFOkPFTUgEJ[FOEP RVFBSB[kPnBMHPSFMBUJWP RVFWBMFIPKFFOkPWBMFBNBOIk RVFTFSWFBRVJFOkPTFSWFBMJ0RVF)FHFMFTUgEJ[FOEPnRVFB NVEBOmB BUSBOTGPSNBmkPEBSB[kPFEFTFVTDPOUF|EPTnPCSB SBDJPOBMEBQSwQSJBSB[kP"SB[kPOkPnVNBWrUJNBEPUFNQP
-0
Manual do Professor
RVFMIFSPVCBSJBBWFSEBEF BVOJWFSTBMJEBEF BOFDFTTJEBEF" SB[kPOkPFTUgOBIJTUwSJBFMBnBIJTUwSJB"SB[kPOkPFTUgOP UFNQPFMBnPUFNQP&MBEgTFOUJEPBPUFNQP 2VBJTBTDSrUJDBTEF)FHFMBJOBUJTUBT FNQJSJTUBTFB,BOU $PNSFMBmkPBPTJOBUJTUBTFFNQJSJTUBT )FHFMGB[VNBDSr UJDBNVJUPTFNFMIBOUFhEF,BOU EJ[FOEPRVFTFFOHBOBSBN QPSFYDFTTPEFPCKFUJWJTNP JTUPn QPSKVMHBSFNRVFPDPOIFDJ NFOUPSBDJPOBMEFQFOEFSJBJOUFJSBNFOUFEPTPCKFUPTEPDPOIF DJNFOUP TFKBQPSRVFEFQFOEFSJBEBFYQFSJpODJB TFKBQPSRVF EFQFOEFSJBEBDBQBDJEBEFEBTJEFJBTQBSBSFQSPEV[JSBSFBMJ EBEFFNTJEBTDPJTBT&NSFMBmkPBPLBOUJTNP DSJUJDPVBWJTkP TVCKFUJWBEBSB[kPEJ[FOEPRVFUBNCnNTFFOHBOPVQPSRVFOkP GPJDBQB[EFDPNQSFFOEFSRVFBSB[kPnTVKFJUPFPCKFUP 0RVFnFDPNPnBSB[kPQBSB)FHFM 1BSB)FHFM BSB[kPOkPnOFNFYDMVTJWBNFOUFTVCKFUJWB DPNPEJ[PLBOUJTNP OFNFYDMVTJWBNFOUFPCKFUJWB DPNPEJ[P JOBUJTNPFPFNQJSJTNP NBTBVOJEBEFOFDFTTgSJBEPPCKFUJWP FEPTVCKFUJWP1BSB)FHFM BSB[kPnTVCKFUJWB PDPOKVOUPEBT MFJTEPQFOTBNFOUP JTUPn PTQSJODrQJPT PTQSPDFEJNFOUPTEP SBDJPDrOJP BTGPSNBTFBTFTUSVUVSBTOFDFTTgSJBTQBSBQFOTBSBT DBUFHPSJBT BTJEFJBT PCKFUJWB BPSEFN BPSHBOJ[BmkP PFODB EFBNFOUPFBTSFMBm{FTEBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT JTUPn BSFBMJEBEF PCKFUJWBFSBDJPOBM TVCKFUJWBFPCKFUJWB BSFMBmkPJOUFSOBF OFDFTTgSJBFOUSFBTMFJTEPQFOTBNFOUPFBTMFJTEPSFBM &MBnB VOJEBEFEBSB[kPTVCKFUJWBFEBSB[kPPCKFUJWB"FTTBVOJEBEF )FHFMEgPOPNFEF&TQrSJUP"CTPMVUP $PNP)FHFMEFTDSFWFPDBNJOIPQFSDPSSJEPQFMBSB[kP
2VBJTBTDSrUJDBTEB&TDPMBEF'SBOLGVSUB)FHFM 0TGSBOLGVSUJBOPTDPOTJEFSBNRVF)FHFMFTUgFOHBOBEP BPTVQPSRVFBSB[kPTFKBVNBGPSmBIJTUwSJDBBVUyOPNB JTUP n OkPDPOEJDJPOBEBQFMBTJUVBmkPNBUFSJBMPVFDPOyNJDB TP DJBMFQPMrUJDBEFVNBnQPDB FUBNCnNBPTVQPSRVFBSB[kP TFKBBGPSmBIJTUwSJDBRVFDSJBBQSwQSJBTPDJFEBEF BQPMrUJDB BDVMUVSB1BSBFMFT BSB[kPOkPEFUFSNJOBOFNDPOEJDJPOBB TPDJFEBEF NBTnEFUFSNJOBEBFDPOEJDJPOBEBQFMBTPDJFEBEF FQPSTVBTNVEBOmBT 2VBJTTkPBTEVBTNPEBMJEBEFTEBSB[kPBQSFTFOUBEBTQFMB 5FPSJB$SrUJDB "SB[kPJOTUSVNFOUBMPVSB[kPUnDOJDPDJFOUrGJDB RVFFTUg BTFSWJmPEBFYQMPSBmkPFEBEPNJOBmkP EBPQSFTTkPFEBWJP MpODJB FBSB[kPDSrUJDBPVGJMPTwGJDB RVFSFGMFUFTPCSFBTDPO USBEJm{FTFPTDPOGMJUPTTPDJBJTFQPMrUJDPTFTFBQSFTFOUBDPNP VNBGPSmBMJCFSUBEPSB 2VBMBQPTJmkPEPTGJMwTPGPTFTUSVUVSBMJTUBTRVBOUPhIJTUP SJDJEBEFEBSB[kP 1BSBPTGJMwTPGPTFTUSVUVSBMJTUBT BSB[kPnIJTUwSJDB±JTUP n NVEBUFNQPSBMNFOUF± NBTFTTBIJTUwSJBOkPnDVNVMBUJWB FWPMVUJWB QSPHSFTTJWBFDPOUrOVB1FMPDPOUSgSJP nEFTDPOUr OVB SFBMJ[BTFQPSTBMUPT FDBEBFTUSVUVSBOPWBEBSB[kPQPTTVJ VNTFOUJEPQSwQSJP WgMJEPBQFOBTQBSBFMB 1PSRVFPTFTUSVUVSBMJTUBTSFDVTBNBJEFJBEFQSPHSFTTPUFw SJDPFUnDOJDP
%FTDSFWFDPNPVNDBNJOIPRVFnGFJUPEFWFSEBEFTQBS DJBJTRVFWkPTFOEPSFVOJEBTBUnRVFTFDIFHVFBVNBWFS EBEFUPUBMJ[BEPSBRVFBTFOHMPCB&NDBEBNPNFOUPEFTVB IJTUwSJB BSB[kPQSPEV[JVVNBUFTFBSFTQFJUPEFTJNFTNBF MPHPBTFHVJS VNBUFTFDPOUSgSJBhQSJNFJSB PVVNBBOUrUFTF $BEBUFTFFDBEBBOUrUFTFGPSBNWFSEBEFJSBT NBTQBSDJBJT 1PSNFJPEFVNBTrOUFTFFOUSFBTDPOUSBEJm{FTBQSFTFOUBEBT BSB[kPNPTUSBPOEFFTUgBWFSEBEFEFDBEBVNBEFMBTFDPO TFSWBFTUBWFSEBEF
1PSRVF OkPTFOEPQPTTrWFMGBMBSFNDPOUJOVJEBEFIJTUwSJ DB OkPIgDPNPOFNQPSRVFDPNQBSBSFKVMHBSBTUFPSJBTFBT UnDOJDBTDPNPBUSBTBEBTPVBEJBOUBEBT"OPWJEBEFTJHOJGJDB KVTUBNFOUFRVFTFUSBUBEFBMHPUkPOPWP UkPEJGFSFOUFFUkP PVUSPRVFTFSgBCTVSEPGBMBSFNDPOUJOVJEBEFFBWBOmP1PS UBOUP OkPIgDPNPEJ[FSRVFBTUFPSJBTFUnDOJDBTQBTTBEBTTkP GBMTBT FSSBEBTPVBUSBTBEBTFMBTTJNQMFTNFOUFTkPEJGFSFOUFT EBTBUVBJTQPSRVFTFCBTFJBNFNQSJODrQJPT JOUFSQSFUBm{FTF DPODFJUPTOPWPT
#APqTULOß߯ßß=n]vkj]behkokbe]
$PNP5IPNBT,VIOGPSNVMBBIJTUwSJBEBDJpODJBFNQSFHBO EPBTJEFJBTEFQBSBEJHNBFDSJTFEFQBSBEJHNBT
_kjpailknja] 2VFRVFSEJ[FSGFOPNFOPMPHJB 1BSB)FHFM nBOBSSBUJWBEBTFYQFSJpODJBTEBDPOTDJpODJB OBIJTUwSJBQBSB)VTTFSM BEFTDSJmkPEBTFYQFSJpODJBTEBDPOT DJpODJBDPNPBUJWJEBEFEFDPOIFDJNFOUP"GFOPNFOPMPHJBTVS HJVBQBSUJSEBQSFPDVQBmkPEF)VTTFSMDPNPUSBOTDFOEFOUBM JT UPn BCVTDBEBTDPOEJm{FTBQSJPSJEFQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBGJMPTPGJB DPNPDJpODJBSJHPSPTBcPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPRVFBQBSFDFPVTF NBOJGFTUBhDPOTDJpODJB FNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNBFTUSVUVSBEB QSwQSJBDPOTDJpODJB
1BSB5IPNBT,VIO BIJTUwSJBEBDJpODJBnNBSDBEBQPSTBM UPTPVSFWPMVm{FT"DBEBnQPDB BTUFPSJBTDJFOUrGJDBTJOTUJUVFN NnUPEPTFEFGJOJm{FTEFTFVTPCKFUPTDPOTUJUVJOEPNBUSJ[FTEF JOWFTUJHBmkPFEFQFOTBNFOUP NPEFMPT QBSBEJHNBT &OUSF UBOUP BQBSUJSEFDFSUPTNPNFOUPT PQBSBEJHNBFYJTUFOUFOkP TFSWFNBJTFFOUSBFNDSJTF JTUPn DPNFmBBOkPEBSDPOUBEF TFVTPCKFUPTPVDFSUPTPCKFUPTOPWPTBQBSFDFN QBSBPTRVBJT PQBSBEJHNBFYJTUFOUFOkPTFSWF PRVFSFRVFSBJOTUJUVJmkPEF VNOPWPQBSBEJHNB
0RVFnBFQPDIpIVTTFSMJBOB
2VFEJ[FNPTGJMwTPGPTQwTNPEFSOPTTPCSFBTQSFUFOT{FT EBSB[kP
4FHVOEP)VTTFSM BFQPDIpDPOTJTUFFN²DPMPDBS´FOUSF BSpOUFTFTμOPTTBDSFOmBOBFYJTUpODJBEBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSJPS Q FEFTDSFWFSBTBUJWJEBEFTEBDPOTDJpODJBPVEBSB[kPDPNPVN QPEFSBQSJPSJEFDPOTUJUVJmkPEBQSwQSJBSFBMJEBEF³$PNJTTP FMFRVJTEJ[FSRVFBSFBMJEBEFnVNTJTUFNBEFTJHOJGJDBm{FTRVF EFQFOEFNEBFTUSVUVSBEBQSwQSJBDPOTDJpODJB
%J[FNRVFTFUSBUBEFVNBQSFUFOTkPJOGVOEBEBFJSSFBMJ [gWFM QPSRVFBSB[kPUFNBQSFUFOTkPEFTFSPDPOIFDJNFO UPWFSEBEFJSPEBSFBMJEBEF NBTFTUBOkPFYJTUF QPJTOkPIg GBUPT EBEPTPVDPJTBTFTJNNBOFJSBTEFGBMBSPV²KPHPTEF MJOHVBHFN³DPNRVFJOWFOUBNPTNFJPTQBSBFYQSJNJSPRVF QFOTBNPTFTFOUJNPT
-1
| U NIDADE 3
|
A verdade
1PSRVFNBOUFNPTPJEFBMEBSBDJPOBMJEBEFBQFTBSEBTNV EBOmBTIJTUwSJDBTEBJEFJBEFSB[kP
EVWJEBSEFMBT OFOIVNNPUJWPQBSBEFTDPOGJBSEFMBTF DPOTF RVFOUFNFOUF BDIBTFRVFTFTBCFUVEPPRVFIgQBSBTBCFS
1PSRVFNBOUFNPTVNBJEFJBRVFnFTTFODJBMhOPmkPPDJ EFOUBMEFSB[kP JTUPn EFRVFBSFBMJEBEF PNVOEPOBUVSBM FDVMUVSBM PTTFSFTIVNBOPT TVBTBm{FTFPCSBTUpNTFOUJEP FFTTFTFOUJEPQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEP NFTNPRVFJTTPJNQMJRVF NPEJGJDBSBOPmkPEFSB[kPFBNQMJgMB
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFJHOPSiODJBFJODFSUF[B
2VFnBSB[kPDPNPDSJUnSJPEFDPFSpODJB cBQSwQSJBSB[kPDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPRVFKVMHBBWBMJEBEF EFVNQFOTBNFOUPPVEFVNBUFPSJB KVMHBOEP FMBNFTNB TVBDPFSpODJBPVJODPFSpODJB PVTFKB RVBOEPVNQFOTBNFO UPPVVNBUFPSJBTFQSPQ{FNBPGFSFDFSVNDPOIFDJNFOUP TJ NVMUBOFBNFOUFUBNCnNPGFSFDFNPTQSJODrQJPT PTDPODFJUPT FPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTRVFTVTUFOUBNBFYQMJDBmkPBQSFTFOUBEB 2VBOEPOkPIgDPNQBUJCJMJEBEFFOUSFBFYQMJDBmkPFPTQSJO DrQJPT PTDPODFJUPTFPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTPGFSFDJEPT EJ[FNPT RVFOkPIgDPFSpODJBFRVFPQFOTBNFOUPPVBUFPSJBOkPTkP SBDJPOBJT 2VFTJHOJGJDBDPOTJEFSBSBSB[kPVNJOTUSVNFOUPDSrUJDPQB SBBWBMJBSBTDPOEJm{FTEFWJEBEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT 4JHOJGJDBBENJUJSRVFBSB[kPUFNVNQPUFODJBMBUJWPFUSBOT GPSNBEPSEJBOUFEBTDPOEJm{FTEFWJEBEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT TFO EPVNJOTUSVNFOUPDSrUJDPQBSBBDPNQSFFOTkPEBTDJSDVOTUiO DJBTFNRVFTFWJWF QBSBNVEgMBTPVNFMIPSgMBT $POTJEFSBOEPPQPUFODJBMDSrUJDPFQPMrUJDPEBSB[kP QPEF FMBDPNCBUFSUFPSJBTRVFUpNBQFOBTBBQBSpODJBEFSBDJP OBMJEBEF NBTOkPTkPSBDJPOBJT 5BOUPPQPUFODJBMDSrUJDPFQPMrUJDPEBSB[kPRVBOUPBDPF SpODJBJOUFSOBEFVNQFOTBNFOUPPVEFVNBUFPSJBBKVEBNB DPNCBUFSUFPSJBTRVFUpNBQFOBTBBQBSpODJBEFSBDJPOBMJEBEF DPNPOPDBTPEBTUFPSJBTSBDJTUBT 1PSRVFBTDSJTFTEBSB[kPTkPPNFMIPSBOUrEPUPDPOUSBP EPHNBUJTNP 0RVFnPEPHNBUJTNP %PHNBUJTNPWFNEPHSFHPEPHNB RVFTJHOJGJDB²VNBPQJ OJkPFTUBCFMFDJEBQPSEFDSFUPFFOTJOBEBDPNPVNBEPVUSJOB TFNDPOUFTUBmkP³1PSTFSVNBPQJOJkPEFDSFUBEBPVVNBEPV USJOBJORVFTUJPOBEB VNEPHNBnUPNBEPDPNPVNBWFSEBEF RVFOkPQPEFTFSDPOUFTUBEBOFNDSJUJDBEB"TDSJTFTEBSB[kP TkPVNBOUrEPUPBJTTPKVTUBNFOUFQPSJOEJDBSVNBBUJUVEFSFGMF YJWB DSrUJDBF°QPSRVFOkP °JOTVCPSEJOBEB QSwQSJBEBSBDJP OBMJEBEF EFTUBDBOEPBJNQPSUiODJBGVOEBNFOUBMEBMJCFSEBEF EFQFOTBNFOUPQBSBBQSwQSJBSB[kPFQBSBBGJMPTPGJB
5NIDADEßßßß=ran`]`a #APqTULOß߯ßßEcjknj_e]aran`]`a 2VFnBJHOPSiODJB *HOPSiODJBnPFTUBEPFNRVFTFFODPOUSBBMHVnNRVFOkP TBCFRVFOkPTBCF JTUPn RVBOEPBTDSFOmBTFPQJOJ{FTRVF TFQPTTVFNQBSBWJWFSFBHJSOPNVOEPTFDPOTFSWBNDPNP FGJDB[FTF|UFJT EFNPEPRVFOkPTFUFNNPUJWPOFOIVNQBSB
&ORVBOUPOBJHOPSiODJBBDIBNPTRVFTBCFNPTUVEPPRVF IgQBSBTBCFS DPNBJODFSUF[BEFTDPCSJNPTRVFTPNPTJHOP SBOUFT RVFOPTTBTDSFOmBTFPQJOJ{FTQBSFDFNOkPEBSDPOUB EBSFBMJEBEF RVFIgGBMIBTOBRVJMPFNRVFBDSFEJUBNPTFRVF EVSBOUFNVJUPUFNQPOPTTFSWJVEFSFGFSpODJBQBSBQFOTBSF BHJS&OUkP UFNPTE|WJEBT GJDBNPTDIFJPTEFQFSQMFYJEBEFF TPNPTUPNBEPTQFMBJOTFHVSBOmB 1PSRVFBE|WJEB BEFDFQmkPFPFTQBOUPQPEFNEFTQFSUBS PEFTFKPEBWFSEBEF 1PSRVFOPTGB[FNRVFSFSTBCFSPRVFOkPTBCrBNPT OPTGB [FNRVFSFSTBJSEPFTUBEPEFJOTFHVSBOmBPVEFFODBOUBNFOUP OPTGB[FNQFSDFCFSOPTTBJHOPSiODJB DSJBOEP BTTJN PEFTFKP EFTVQFSBSBJODFSUF[BFBNFOUJSBFFODPOUSBSBWFSEBEFDPNP BMHPOPWPFJOTwMJUP 1PSRVFFNOPTTBTPDJFEBEFnEJGrDJMEFTQFSUBSPEFTFKPEB WFSEBEF 1PSDBVTBEFWgSJPTGBUPSFTPFYDFTTPEFJOGPSNBmkP RVF VMUSBQBTTBBFYQFSJpODJBWJWJEBQFMBTQFTTPBT FTUBTGJDBNTFN NFJPTQBSBBWBMJBSPRVFSFDFCFN BDPOGJBOmBOBTQBMBWSBT EFPVUSBTQFTTPBT KPSOBMJTUBT QSPGFTTPSFT QPMJDJBM
RVFDSJB VNTFOUJNFOUPEFTFHVSBOmBFDPOGJBOmB JOJCJOEPBJODFSUF[BF NBOUFOEPBJHOPSiODJBBQSPQBHBOEB RVFUSBUBUPEBTBTQFT TPBTDPNPJOHpOVBTFDSnEVMBTQPSNFJPEFVNFUFSOP²GB[EF DPOUB³BBUJUVEFEPTQPMrUJDPT OPTRVBJTBTQFTTPBTDPOGJBN FQFMPTRVBJTBDBCBNTFOEPMVEJCSJBEBTBDPSSVQmkPFPNBV VTPEPEJOIFJSPQ|CMJDPPDSFTDJNFOUPEBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTFEBT JOKVTUJmBT EBNJTnSJBFEBWJPMpODJB FUD&TTFTGBUPSFTMFWBNBT QFTTPBThEFTDSFOmBFBPDFUJDJTNP $PNPGVODJPOBBQSPQBHBOEB "QSPQBHBOEBOVODBWFOEFVNQSPEVUPEJ[FOEPPRVFFMFn FQBSBRVFTFSWF&MBWFOEFVNBJNBHFN EFGFMJDJEBEF EFTV DFTTP EFKVWFOUVEF EFTB|EF EFSJRVF[B EFCFMF[B FUD RVF nUSBOTNJUJEBQPSNFJPEPQSPEVUP SPEFBOEPPEFNBHJBT CF MF[BT EBOEPMIFRVBMJEBEFTRVFTkPEFPVUSBTDPJTBT BDSJBOmB TBVEgWFM PKPWFNCPOJUP PBEVMUPJOUFMJHFOUF PJEPTPGFMJ[ B DBTBBHSBEgWFM FUD
QSPEV[JOEPVNFUFSOP²GB[EFDPOUB³ 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFPEFTFKPEBWFSEBEFQPEFTFSEFTQFS UBEPQFMPTQSwQSJPTPCTUgDVMPThWFSEBEFDSJBEPTQPSOPTTB TPDJFEBEF 4JHOJGJDBRVFFTTBTEJGJDVMEBEFTUBNCnNQPEFNTVTDJUBS FN NVJUBTQFTTPBT E|WJEBT JODFSUF[BT EFTDPOGJBOmBTFEFTJMVT{FT RVFBTGBmBNCVTDBSBWFSEBEF&TTBCVTDBOBTDFOkPTwEBE| WJEBFEBJODFSUF[B NBTUBNCnNEBBmkPEFMJCFSBEBDPOUSBPT QSFDPODFJUPT DPOUSBBTJEFJBTFPQJOJ{FTFTUBCFMFDJEBT DPOUSB BTDSFOmBTRVFQBSBMJTBNBDBQBDJEBEFEFQFOTBSFEFBHJSMJWSF NFOUF 2VBJTTkPPTEPJTUJQPTEFCVTDBEBWFSEBEF 0QSJNFJSPnPRVFOBTDFEBEFDFQmkP EBJODFSUF[BFEBJO TFHVSBOmBF QPSTJNFTNP FYJHFRVFTBJBNPTEFUBMTJUVBmkP SFBERVJSJOEPDFSUF[BT0TFHVOEPnPRVFOBTDFEBEFMJCFSBmkP PVEFDJTkPEFOkPBDFJUBSBTDFSUF[BTFDSFOmBTFTUBCFMFDJEBT EFJSBMnNEFMBTFEFFODPOUSBSFYQMJDBm{FT JOUFSQSFUBm{FTF TJHOJGJDBEPTQBSBBSFBMJEBEFRVFOPTDFSDB
-2
Manual do Professor
0RVFnB²E|WJEBNFUwEJDB³EF%FTDBSUFT 5SBUBTFEBEFDJTkPEF%FTDBSUFTEFTVCNFUFSBVNFYBNF DSrUJDPUPEPTPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTFYJTUFOUFTFNTVBnQPDBFPT TFVTQSwQSJPT EFDMBSBOEPRVFTwBDFJUBSJBVNDPOIFDJNFOUP VNBJEFJB VNGBUPPVVNBPQJOJkPTF QBTTBEPTQFMPDSJWPEB E|WJEB SFWFMBSFNTFJOEVCJUgWFJTQBSBPQFOTBNFOUPQVSP 0RVFnP²BSHVNFOUPEPTPOIP³EF%FTDBSUFT 4FHVOEP%FTDBSUFT RVBOEPTPOIBNPT FTUBNPTDPOWFO DJEPTEFRVFBSFBMJEBEFTPOIBEBFYJTUFFRVFBDPOIFDFNPT UBMDPNPn EFNBOFJSBRVFOkPIgEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBQFSDFQmkP EBSFBMJEBEFQFMPTPOIBEPSFBQFSDFQmkPEPNVOEPQPSBRVFMF RVFFTUgEFTQFSUP0VTFKB OkPQPTTVrNPTDSJUnSJPTQBSBEJTUJO HVJSPTPOIPEBWJHrMJBF QPSUBOUP OkPUFNPTOFOIVNDSJUnSJP SBDJPOBMQBSBBGJSNBSRVFPNVOEPFYJTUFPVRVFFMFOkPnVN TPOIP 2VBMBQSJNFJSBWFSEBEFJOEVCJUgWFMFODPOUSBEBQPS%FT DBSUFT &YQMJRVFDPNPFMFDIFHPVBFMB "QSJNFJSBWFSEBEFJOEVCJUgWFMFODPOUSBEBQPS%FTDBSUFT GPJ²&VQFOTP³1BSBFMF BDBQBDJEBEFEFEVWJEBSnVNBGPSNB EFQFOTBSF QPSUBOUP RVBOEPFTUPVEVWJEBOEP FTUPVQFOTBO EP²FVEVWJEP³TJHOJGJDB²FVQFOTP³&OkPQPTTPEVWJEBSEF RVFQFOTP"DPOTDJpODJBEPQFOTBNFOUPBQBSFDF BTTJN DPNP BQSJNFJSBWFSEBEFJOEVCJUgWFM RVFTFSgPBMJDFSDFQBSBUPEPT PTDPOIFDJNFOUPTGVUVSPT
#APqTULOß߯ßß>qo_]j`k]ran`]`a 0RVFnPEPHNBUJTNP %PHNBUJTNPnVNBBUJUVEFOBUVSBMFFTQPOUiOFBRVFUF NPTEFTEFDSJBOmBTcOPTTBDSFOmBEFRVFPNVOEPFYJTUFF RVFnFYBUBNFOUFEBGPSNBDPNPPQFSDFCFNPT5FNPTFTTB DSFOmBQPSRVFTPNPTTFSFTQSgUJDPT JTUPn OPTSFMBDJPOBNPT DPNBSFBMJEBEFDPNPTFFMBGPTTFVNDPOKVOUPEFDPJTBT GBUPT FQFTTPBTRVFTkP|UFJTPVJO|UFJTQBSBOPTTBTPCSFWJWpODJB 0RVFnBBUJUVEFEPHNgUJDB 1PSRVFnDPOTFSWBEPSB /BBUJUVEFEPHNgUJDB UPNBNPTPNVOEPDPNPKgEBEP Kg GFJUP KgQFOTBEP KgUSBOTGPSNBEP"SFBMJEBEFOBUVSBM TPDJBM QPMrUJDBFDVMUVSBMGPSNBVNBFTQnDJFEFNPMEVSBEFVNRVBESP FNDVKPJOUFSJPSOPTJOTUBMBNPTFPOEFFYJTUJNPT&TTBBUJUVEF nDPOTFSWBEPSBQPSOkPSPNQFSDPNPFTUBCFMFDJEP QPSSFTJT UJShJOPWBmkPFDPOGJBSFYDFTTJWBNFOUFOBSFBMJEBEFUBMDPNP FMBBQBSFDF NBOUFOEPVNDMJNBEFGBNJMJBSJEBEF TFHVSBOmBF TPTTFHP 2VBOEPTFSPNQFBBUJUVEFEPHNgUJDB "BUJUVEFEPHNgUJDBPVOBUVSBMTFSPNQFRVBOEPTPNPT DBQB[FTEFVNBBUJUVEFEFFTUSBOIBNFOUPEJBOUFEBTDPJTBT RVFOPTQBSFDJBNGBNJMJBSFT
2VFE|WJEBTFQFSQMFYJEBEFTBMJOHVBHFNQSPWPDBFNOwT %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPT 4FHVJOEPPDPOTFMIPEBEPQPS%SVNNPOEFNVNQPFNB EFRVFDBEBQBMBWSB²UFNNJMGBDFTTFDSFUBTTPCBGBDFOFVUSB³ QPEFNPTBENJUJSRVFVNBHSBOEFDBSBDUFSrTUJDBEBMJOHVBHFNn BBNCJHVJEBEFRVFDBEBQBMBWSBUFN GB[FOEPDPNRVFOkPIBKB TFNQSFVNTFOUJEPwCWJPF|OJDP QFSNJUJOEPMJUFSBUVSB NBMFO UFOEJEPFDPOUSPWnSTJBT&TTFQPEFSNJTUJGJDBEPSEBMJOHVBHFN nRVFQSPWPDBFNOwTE|WJEBTDPNPBTTVTDJUBEBTOBUSBHnEJB 0UFMP EF4IBLFTQFBSF.BTBMJOHVBHFNUBNCnNQSPWPDBQFS QMFYJEBEF1PEFNPTFODPOUSBSFTTFFYFNQMPOPUSBEJDJPOBMJT NPKVEBJDP OPRVBMBQBMBWSBTBHSBEBDIFHBWBBUFSUBOUPQPEFS RVFPOPNFEF%FVTFSBDPOTJEFSBEPJNQSPOVODJgWFM
#APqTULOß߯ßß=o_kj_alao`]ran`]`a 0RVFnBWFSEBEFDPNPBMnUIFJB $PNPBMnUIFJB POkPFTRVFDJEP
BWFSEBEFnBNBOJGFTUBmkP EBRVJMPRVFnSFBMNFOUFPVEPRVFFYJTUFSFBMNFOUFUBMDPNPTF NBOJGFTUBPVTFNPTUSB5SBUBTFEFVNBRVBMJEBEFEBTQSwQSJBT DPJTBT PNBOJGFTUBSTFPVNPTUSBSTFBTJNFTNBT
FPWFSEBEFJ SPFTUgOBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBTRVBOEPPRVFFMBTNBOJGFTUBNnTVB SFBMJEBEFQSwQSJB FOkPBNFSBBQBSpODJB RVFnBGBMTJEBEF 0RVFnBWFSEBEFDPNPWFSJUBT $PNPWFSJUBT BWFSEBEFSFGFSFTFhQSFDJTkP BPSJHPSFh FYBUJEkPEFVNSFMBUP OPRVBMTFEJ[DPNEFUBMIFT QPSNFOPSFT FGJEFMJEBEFPRVFSFBMNFOUFBDPOUFDFV7FSEBEFJSPTFSFGFSF QPSUBOUP hMJOHVBHFNDPNPOBSSBUJWBEFGBUPTBDPOUFDJEPT SF GFSFTFBFOVODJBEPTRVFEJ[FNGJFMNFOUFBTDPJTBTDPNPGPSBN PVBDPOUFDFSBN/PUFRVFOFTTFDBTPBWFSEBEFOkPTFSFGFSF hTQSwQSJBTDPJTBTFBPTQSwQSJPTGBUPT DPNPBDPOUFDFOBBMn UIFJB
NBTBPSFMBUPFBPFOVODJBEP hMJOHVBHFN 0RVFnBWFSEBEFDPNPFNVOBI $PNPFNVOBI ²BTTJNTFKB³
BWFSEBEFTFSFMBDJPOBDPNB QSFTFOmBEFBMHVnN %FVTPVIVNBOP FDPNBFTQFSBEFRVF BRVJMPRVFGPJQSPNFUJEPWBJDVNQSJSTFPVBDPOUFDFS/FTTF DBTP BWFSEBEFnVNBDSFOmBGVOEBEBOBFTQFSBOmBFOBDPO GJBOmBFNVNBQSPNFTTB FTUBOEPSFGFSJEBBPGVUVSP BPRVF TFSgPVWJSg4VBGPSNBNBJTFMFWBEBnBSFWFMBmkPEJWJOBFTVB FYQSFTTkPNBJTQFSGFJUBnBQSPGFDJB 2VBMBNBSDBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPOBBMnUIFJB 2VF nBEFRVBmkP "NBSDBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPOBBMnUIFJBnBFWJ EpODJB JTUPn BWJTkPJOUFMFDUVBMFSBDJPOBMEBSFBMJEBEFUBMDP NPnFNTJNFTNBFBMDBOmBEBQFMBTPQFSBm{FTEFOPTTBSB[kP PVEFOPTTPJOUFMFDUP/FTTFTFOUJEP BBEFRVBmkPnPDSJUnSJP EFWFSEBEF JTUPn RVBOEPBTJEFJBTDPSSFTQPOEFNFGFUJWBNFO UFhTDPJTBTSFQSFTFOUBEBTQPSFMBTPVRVBOEPBTDPJTBTDPSSFT QPOEFNFGFUJWBNFOUFhTJEFJBTRVFBTSFQSFTFOUBN
%pVNFYFNQMP UJSBEPEFTVBWJEBQFTTPBM EBMJUFSBUVSBPV EPDJOFNB EFFTUSBOIBNFOUPEJBOUFEFBMHVNBDPJTBPVEF BMHVNGBUPRVFQBSFDJBNTJNQMFTFOBUVSBJT
2VBMnBNBSDBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPOBWFSJUBT 2VF nWFSBDJEBEF
1SPGFTTPS B FTUBSFTQPTUBnQFTTPBMFQPEFTFSCBTFBEB OBTNBJTEJGFSFOUFTDJSDVOTUiODJBTKgWJWFODJBEBTPVDPOIFDJ EBTQFMPBMVOP3FTTBMUBNPTBQFOBTRVFOPiNCJUPEPDJOFNB FEBMJUFSBUVSBIgVNBHSBOEFWBSJFEBEFEFPCSBTRVFGJ[FSBN EPFTUSBOIBNFOUPFEPFTQBOUPPNPUJWPDPOEVUPSEFTVBTOBS SBUJWBT
"NBSDBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPOBWFSJUBTnBWBMJEBEF MwHJDBEPTBSHVNFOUPTBQSFTFOUBEPT/FTTFDBTP PDSJUnSJPEF WFSEBEFnBWFSBDJEBEF JTUPn RVBOEPBMJOHVBHFNFOVODJBSJ HPSPTBNFOUF PCFEFDFOEPBQSJODrQJPT OPSNBTFSFHSBT
DPN FYBUJEkPFEFUBMIFT OPTTPQFOTBNFOUPPVOPTTBTJEFJBTFPT BDPOUFDJNFOUPTPVGBUPTFYUFSJPSFTBOwT
-3
| U NIDADE 3
|
A verdade
2VBMnBNBSDBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPOBFNVOBI " NBSD B EP DPO IFD JN FOU P WFSE BE FJS P OB FNVO BI n PDPOT FOT PFPQBDU PEFDPOGJBOm BFOUSFPTNFNCSPTEF VNBEFUFSNJOBEBDPNVOJEBEF RVFEFGJOFNVNDPOKVOUP EFDPOWFOm{FTVOJWFSTBJTRVFEFWFTFNQSFTFSSFTQFJUBEP QPSUPEPT &YQMJRVFQPSRVFOPTTBDPODFQmkPEBWFSEBEFnVNBTrOUFTF EBBMnUIFJB EBWFSJUBTFEBFNVOBI 1PSRVFBOPTTBDPODFQmkPEFWFSEBEFBCSBOHFPRVFn B SFBMJEBEF
PRVFGPJ PTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTQBTTBEPT FPRVFTF Sg BTBm{FTFBDPOUFDJNFOUPTGVUVSPT 3FGFSFTF QPSUBOUP h QSwQSJBSFBMJEBEF DPNPOBBMnUIFJB
hMJOHVBHFN DPNPOBWF SJUBT FhDPOGJBOmBFTQFSBOmB DPNPOBFNVOBI 2VBJTPTQSJODrQJPTFNRVFTFGVOEBBJEFJBEFDPOTFOTP 2VFTPNPTTFSFTSBDJPOBJTFOPTTPQFOTBNFOUPPCFEFDF BPTRVBUSPQSJODrQJPTEBSB[kPRVFTPNPTTFSFTEPUBEPTEF MJOHVBHFNFRVFFMBGVODJPOBTFHVOEPSFHSBTMwHJDBTDPOWFO DJPOBEBTFBDFJUBTQPSVNBDPNVOJEBEFRVFPTSFTVMUBEPTEF VNBJOWFTUJHBmkPEFWFNTFSTVCNFUJEPThEJTDVTTkPFBWBMJB mkPQFMPTNFNCSPTEBDPNVOJEBEFEFJOWFTUJHBEPSFTRVFMIF BUSJCVJSkPPVOkPPWBMPSEFWFSEBEF $PNPBUFPSJBQSBHNgUJDBDPODFCFBWFSEBEF "DPODFQmkPEFWFSEBEFQBSBBUFPSJBQSBHNgUJDBCBTFJBTF OBWFSJGJDBCJMJEBEFEPTSFTVMUBEPTEBTBm{FTFOBFGJDgDJBEFTVB BQMJDBmkP/FTTFDBTP PDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPTFEFGJOF QPSVNDSJUnSJPRVFOkPnUFwSJDPFTJNQSgUJDP "QSFTFOUFTFNFMIBOmBTFEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFBTRVBUSPDPO DFQm{FTEFWFSEBEF 4FNFMIBOmBT"UFPSJBQSBHNgUJDBFBUFPSJBEBDPSSFT QPOEpODJBFOUSFDPJTBFJEFJB BMnUIFJB
QPJTPSFTVMUBEP QSgUJDPFTQFSBEPQFMBQSJNFJSB OBNBJPSJBEBTWF[FT nDPO TFHVJEPQPSRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPBMDBOmPVBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT FQPEFBHJSTPCSFFMBTBUFPSJBEBDPOWFOmkP FNVOBI FB UFPSJBEBDPFSpODJBJOUFSOB WFSJUBT
QPJTBTDPOWFOm{FTPV DPOTFOTPTWFSEBEFJSPTDPTUVNBNTFSCBTFBEPTFNQSJODr QJPTFBSHVNFOUPTMJOHVrTUJDPTFMwHJDPT QSJODrQJPTFBSHV NFOUPTEBMJOHVBHFN EPEJTDVSTPFEBDPNVOJDBmkP%JGF SFOmBTOBUFPSJBEBDPSSFTQPOEpODJB BMnUIFJB
BTDPJTBTFBT JEFJBTTkPDPOTJEFSBEBTWFSEBEFJSBTPVGBMTBT NBT OBUFPSJB EBDPFSpODJB WFSJUBT FOBUFPSJBEPDPOTFOTP FNVOBI
PT FOVODJBEPT PTBSHVNFOUPTFBTJEFJBTnRVFTkPKVMHBEPT WFSEBEFJSPTPVGBMTPTF OBUFPSJBQSBHNgUJDB QSBHNBUJLwT
TkPPTSFTVMUBEPTRVFQPEFNTFSGBMTPTPVWFSEBEFJSPT4F NFMIBOmBTFEJGFSFOmBTOBUFPSJBEBDPSSFTQPOEpODJB BMn UIFJB FOBUFPSJBQSBHNgUJDB QSBHNBUJLwT
BWFSEBEFnP BDPSEPFOUSFPQFOTBNFOUPFBSFBMJEBEFOBUFPSJBEBDPF SpODJB WFSJUBT FOBUFPSJBEPDPOTFOTP FNVOBI
BWFSEBEF nPBDPSEPEPQFOTBNFOUPFEBMJOHVBHFNDPOTJHPNFTNPT DPNCBTFFNSFHSBTFQSJODrQJPTRVFPQFOTBNFOUPFBMJO HVBHFNEFSBNBTJNFTNPT PVEFGJOJEBDPNPBNFTNBQBSB UPEPTQPSVNDPOTFOTP $PNPPTGJMwTPGPTHSFHPTFYQMJDBWBNPFSSPFBGBMTJEBEF 1SJNFJSBNFOUF QBSBPTGJMwTPGPTHSFHPT PFSSPFBGBMTJ EBEFnOkPWFSPTTFSFTDPNPTkP nOkPGBMBSEFMFTUBMDPNP
TkP*TTPPDPSSFRVBOEPOkPDPOTFHVJNPTBMDBOmBSBFTTpODJB EBTSFBMJEBEFTF QPSFSSPFGBMTJEBEF OPTSFGFSJNPThBQBSpO DJBTVQFSGJDJBMFJMVTwSJBEBTDPJTBTPVEPTTFSFTEJ[FNPTEF BMHVNTFSBRVJMPRVFFMFOkPn RVBOEPMIFBUSJCVrNPTRVB MJEBEFTPVQSPQSJFEBEFTRVFFMFOkPQPTTVJPVRVBOEPMIF OFHBNPTRVBMJEBEFTPVQSPQSJFEBEFTRVFFMFQPTTVJ)g QP SnN VNBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPFSSPFBGBMTJEBEF&ORVBOUPFTUBn VNKVr[PEFMJCFSBEBNFOUFFSSBEPTPCSFBMHVNBDPJTB BRVFMF nVNFOHBOPEPKVr[PRVBOEPEFTDPOIFDFNPTBFTTpODJBEF VNTFS 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPQJOJkPFWFSEBEF &FOUSFBQBSpO DJBFFTTpODJB "TPQJOJ{FT EFWJEPBPTFVDBSgUFSEFJODPOTUiODJBFWBSJB CJMJEBEF WBSJBNEFMVHBSQBSBMVHBS EFnQPDBQBSBnQPDB EF TPDJFEBEFQBSBTPDJFEBEF EFQFTTPBQBSBQFTTPB
EFNPOT USBNPEFTDPOIFDJNFOUPEBFTTpODJBEPTTFSFT FORVBOUPBWFS EBEF TFOEPPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBFTTpODJBSFBMFQSPGVOEBEPT TFSFT nTFNQSFVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJB&OUkP QPEFNPTEJ[FS RVFBPQJOJkPCBTFJBTFOBTBQBSpODJBT JMVT{FTQSPEV[JEBTQF MPTOPTTPTwSHkPTEPTTFOUJEPT
FORVBOUPBWFSEBEFCBTFJBTF OBTFTTpODJBT JTUPn OBRVJMPRVFBTDPJTBTTkPFRVFQPEFNPT DPOIFDFSQPSJOUVJmkP EFEVmkPPVJOEVmkP $PNSFMBmkPBPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFM RVBMBEJGFSFOmB FOUSF EFVNMBEP BTQPTJm{FTEF4wDSBUFT 1MBUkPF%FT DBSUFT F EFPVUSP BEF"SJTUwUFMFT %FBDPSEPDPNBTQPTJm{FTEF4wDSBUFT 1MBUkPF%FTDBS UFT TPNFOUFPJOUFMFDUPWpPTFSWFSEBEFJSPF QPSUBOUP EFWF NPTBCBOEPOBSBTTFOTBm{FTFORVBOUPBQPTJmkPEF"SJTUw UFMFTnEFRVFPJOUFMFDUPQVSJGJDBPUFTUFNVOIPTFOTPSJBMF QPSUBOUP EFWFNPTBDFJUBSPTBTQFDUPTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTg SJPTEBTFOTBmkP $PNPTkPDPODFCJEPTPFSSPFBGBMTJEBEFOBDPODFQmkPEB WFSEBEFDPNPWFSJUBT 0WFSEBEFJSPFPGBMTPFTUkPNFOPTOPBUPEFWFS DPNPT MIPTEPDPSQPPVDPNPTPMIPTEPFTQrSJUP FNBJTOPBUPEFEJ P [FSFEFQFOEFN BMnNEFOPTTPQFOTBNFOUP EFOPTTBWPOUBEF "QBSUJSEJTTP QBTTBOEPQFMPDSJTUJBOJTNP PFSSPFBGBMTJEBEF UFOEFSJBNBQSFWBMFDFSDPOUSBBWFSEBEFQPSRVFOPTTBJOUFMJ HpODJBPVOPTTPJOUFMFDUPnNBJTGSBDPEPRVFOPTTBWPOUBEFF FTUBQPEFGPSmgMPBPFSSPFBPGBMTP 1PSRVF OBDPODFQmkPEBWFSEBEFDPNPWFSJUBT BWPOUBEFn VNFMFNFOUPJNQPSUBOUFQBSBFOUFOEFSNPTPFSSP PGBMTPF PWFSEBEFJSP 2VFEJ[PDSJTUJBOJTNPBFTTFSFTQFJUP 1PSRVF TFBWFSEBEFFTUgOPEJTDVSTPPVOBMJOHVBHFN OkPEFQFOEFBQFOBTEPQFOTBNFOUPFEBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT NBT UBNCnNEFOPTTBWPOUBEFQBSBEJ[pMB TJMFODJgMBPVEFGPSNg MB FYQSFTTBOEP EFTTBGPSNB PFSSP PGBMTPPVPWFSEBEFJSP 0DSJTUJBOJTNPBGJSNBRVFBWPOUBEFMJWSFGPJSFTQPOTgWFMQFMP QFDBEPPSJHJOBMFRVFBWPOUBEF DSJBEBCPBQPS%FVT GPJQFS WFSUJEBQFMPQSJNFJSPIPNFNFUPSOPVTFNgWPOUBEF"TTJN TFOEP BNFOUJSB PFSSPFPGBMTPUFOEFSJBNBQSFWBMFDFSDPOUSB BWFSEBEFQPSRVFOPTTBJOUFMJHpODJBPVOPTTPJOUFMFDUPnNBJT GSBDPEPRVFOPTTBWPOUBEF FFTUBQPEFGPSmgMPBPFSSPFBP GBMTP
-4
Manual do Professor
2VBMBFYJHpODJBGFJUBQFMP(SBOEF3BDJPOBMJTNPEPTnDVMP 97**RVBOUPBPQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBGJMPTPGJB "FYJHpODJBnBMJCFSBmkPEPOPTTPFTQrSJUPPVOPTTBDPOT DJpODJBEPTQSFDPODFJUPT EPTEPHNBUJTNPTEBPQJOJkPFEBFY QFSJpODJBDPUJEJBOB&TTBMJCFSBmkPQPEFTFSGFJUBQPSNFJPEB QSPQPTUBEF#BDPO DPNCBUFBPTrEPMPT
JTUPn DPNCBUFBPT QSFDPODFJUPT FQPSNFJPEBE|WJEBNFUwEJDBDBSUFTJBOB%FTTB GPSNB BDPOTDJpODJBQVSJGJDBEB RVFnPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFO UP QPEFSg FOUkP BMDBOmBSBTFWJEpODJBT QPSJOUVJmkP EFEVmkP PVJOEVmkP FGPSNVMBSKVr[PTWFSEBEFJSPTBPTRVBJTBWPOUBEF EFWFSgTFTVCNFUFS 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTQPOUPTEBDPODFQmkPEBWFSEBEFOP (SBOEF3BDJPOBMJTNPEP4nDVMP97** "WFSEBEFnDPOIFDJEBQPSFWJEpODJBTFFYQSJNFOPKVr[P RVBOEPOFMFBJEFJBFTUgFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNPTFSEBTDPJTBT PVDPNPTGBUPTQPSSFGFSJSTFhFTTpODJBEBTDPJTBTEPTTFSFT nTFNQSFVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJB 0RVFnKVr[PBOBMrUJDP &TJOUnUJDP 6NKVr[PnBOBMrUJDPRVBOEPPQSFEJDBEPPVPTQSFEJDBEPT EPFOVODJBEPOBEBNBJTTkPEPRVFBFYQMJDJUBmkPEPDPOUF|EP EPTVKFJUPEPFOVODJBEP1PEFNPTEJ[FSRVFPQSFEJDBEPnVN TJOyOJNPEPTVKFJUPPVRVFFMFBOBMJTBPDPOUF|EPEPTVKFJUP 1BSB,BOU PKVr[PBOBMrUJDPnFYQMJDBUJWP QPJTOBEBFYQSJNFOP QSFEJDBEPRVFKgOkPUFOIBTJEPQFOTBEPOPDPODFJUPEPTVKFJ UP6NKVr[PnTJOUnUJDPRVBOEPPQSFEJDBEPPGFSFDFJOGPSNB m{FTOPWBTTPCSFPTVKFJUP JTUPn GPSNVMBVNBTrOUFTFFOUSFVN QSFEJDBEPFVNTVKFJUP1BSB,BOU PKVr[PTJOUnUJDPnBNQMJBUJWP QPJTBVNFOUBOPTTPDPOIFDJNFOUP 0RVFnKVr[PTJOUnUJDPBQSJPSJ %FBDPSEPDPNBSFGMFYkPEF,BOU VNKVr[PTJOUnUJDPKB NBJTQPEFSJBQSFUFOEFSTFSWFSEBEFJSPEFNPEPVOJWFSTBM FOFDFTTgSJPQPSRVFEFQFOEFSJBEBFYQFSJpODJBWBSJgWFMEF DBEBVNEFOwT OkPTFOEPOFDFTTgSJPOFNWFSEBEFJSP%BrB JOUSPEVmkPEBJEFJBEFKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTBQSJPSJ JTUPn EFKVr [PTTJOUnUJDPTOPTRVBJTBTrOUFTFEPTVKFJUPFEPQSFEJDBEP EFQFOEFEBFTUSVUVSBVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJBEFOPTTBSB[kP FOkPEBWBSJBCJMJEBEFJOEJWJEVBMEFOPTTBTFYQFSJpODJBT1B SB,BOU PTKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTBQSJPSJFYQSJNFNPNPEPDPNP OFDFTTBSJBNFOUFOPTTPQFOTBNFOUPSFMBDJPOBFDPOIFDFB SFBMJEBEF 0 RVF n B WFSEBEF QBSB B GJMPTPGJB JEFBMJTUB EF ,BOU F )VTTFSM /BQFSTQFDUJWBJEFBMJTUB TFKBLBOUJBOB TFKBIVTTFSMJBOB OkPQPEFNPTNBJTEJ[FSRVFBWFSEBEFnBDPOGPSNJEBEFEP QFOTBNFOUPDPNBTDPJTBTPVBDPSSFTQPOEpODJBFOUSFBJEFJB FPPCKFUP"WFSEBEFnPFODBEFBNFOUPJOUFSOPFSJHPSPTPEBT JEFJBTPVEPTDPODFJUPT ,BOU
PVEBTTJHOJGJDBm{FT )VTTFSM
TVBDPFSpODJBMwHJDBFTVBOFDFTTJEBEF"WFSEBEFnVNBDPO UFDJNFOUPJOUFSOPBPOPTTPJOUFMFDUPPVhOPTTBDPOTDJpODJB F QPSUBOUP BDPSSFTQPOEpODJBFOUSFJEFJBTFDPJTBTEFQFOEF JOUFJSBNFOUFEBTQSwQSJBTJEFJBT VNBWF[RVFTkPFMBTBTSFT QPOTgWFJTQFMPPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP 1BSB,BOUF)VTTFSMPFSSPTFFODPOUSBOP3FBMJTNP&Y QMJRVF 0SFBMJTNPnBQPTJmkPGJMPTwGJDBRVFBGJSNBBFYJTUpODJBPC KFUJWBPVFNTJEBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSOBDPNPVNBSFBMJEBEFSBDJPOBM
-5
FNTJFQPSTJNFTNB1BSB,BOUFQBSB)VTTFSM OJTTPFODPOUSBTF PFSSPOBTVQPTJmkPEFRVFPTDPODFJUPTPVBTTJHOJGJDBm{FTTF SFGJSBNBVNBSFBMJEBEFFNTJ JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEPTVKFJUP EPDPOIFDJNFOUP1BSB,BOUFQBSB)VTTFSM FNCPSBBSFBMJEBEF FYUFSOBFYJTUBFNTJFQPSTJNFTNB TwQPEFNPTDPOIFDpMBUBM DPNPOPTTBTJEFJBTBGPSNVMBNFBPSHBOJ[BN FOkPUBMDPNP FMBTFSJBFNTJNFTNB $PNPBGJMPTPGJBBOBMrUJDBDPODFCFBMJOHVBHFN $PNPVNNFJPEFNBOJGFTUBmkPEBWFSEBEF 2VBMGPJBQSJNFJSBDPODFQmkPEFWFSEBEFOBGJMPTPGJBBOB MrUJDB "DPOGPSNJEBEFPVDPSSFTQPOEpODJBFOUSFPTFOVODJBEPT EBMJOHVBHFNFPTGBUPTFDPJTBT&TTBDPOGPSNJEBEFPVDPSSFT QPOEpODJBTFSJBJOBEFRVBEBFJNQSFDJTBOBMJOHVBHFNOBUVSBM FOVODJBEPTPVTFOUFOmBTEPTFOTPDPNVNPVEBWJEBDPUJEJBOB FTFSJBBEFRVBEBFQSFDJTBOBMJOHVBHFNDPSSFUBFSJHPSPTBEBT DJpODJBT 0RVFBGJMPTPGJBBOBMrUJDBFOUFOEFQFMBWFSEBEFDPNPDPF SpODJB "WFSEBEFOkPFTUgOBTDPJTBTOFNOBTJEFJBT OFNOBTSFMB m{FTEFDPSSFTQPOEpODJBFOUSFDPJTBTFJEFJBT$PNPDPFSpODJB BWFSEBEFNBOUnNPTQSFDFJUPTFTUJQVMBEPTQPSTVBMJOHVBHFN JTUPn VNFOVODJBEPPVBSHVNFOUPTkPWFSEBEFJSPTRVBOEP SFTQFJUBNBTOPSNBTFDSJUnSJPTEFGVODJPOBNFOUPEFTVBMJO HVBHFN &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBDPODFQmkPQSBHNgUJDBEBWFSEB EF 0QSBHNBUJTNPDPODPSEBDPNBDPODFQmkPRVFPFNQJSJT NPUFNEBWFSEBEF JTUPn RVFBWFSEBEFnTFNQSFWFSEBEFEF GBUPFnPCUJEBQPSJOEVmkPFQPSFYQFSJNFOUBmkP.BT BMnN EJTTP PQSBHNBUJTNPBDSFTDFOUBRVFBFGJDgDJBFBVUJMJEBEF TkPDSJUnSJPTEFWFSEBEF%FTTBGPSNB VNDPOIFDJNFOUPnWFS EBEFJSPOkPTwRVBOEPFYQMJDBBMHVNBDPJTBPVBMHVNGBUP NBTTPCSFUVEPRVBOEPQFSNJUFPCUFSDPOTFRVpODJBTQSgUJDBT FBQMJDgWFJT &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBTNVEBOmBTOBDPODFQmkPEBWFSEB EFFNEFDPSSpODJBEFNVEBOmBTTPDJBJTFIJTUwSJDBT «NFEJEBRVFIJTUPSJDBNFOUFBTPDJFEBEFNVEB UBNCnN BDPODFQmkPEFWFSEBEFNVEB%FTTBGPSNB OB"OUJHVJEBEF FSBJNQFOTBEBBJEFJBQSBHNgUJDBEFWFSEBEF CBTFBEBOBVUJ MJEBEFFFGJDgDJBQSgUJDB QPJTPUSBCBMIPFSBBUSJCVJmkPTPNFOUF EPTFTDSBWPTFBCVTDBEBWFSEBEFFSBDPOTJEFSBEBBSFBMJ[BmkP TVQFSJPSEPFTQrSJUPIVNBOP QPSUBOUP EFTMJHBEBEPUSBCBMIP FEBTUnDOJDBT1PSnN DPNBTVCTUJUVJmkPEPUSBCBMIPFTDSBWP QFMPUSBCBMIPBTTBMBSJBEPEFWJEPBPTVSHJNFOUPEPDBQJUBMJTNP F DPOTFRVFOUFNFOUF PJEFBMEBQSPEVUJWJEBEF BWFSEBEFUFO EFSgBTFSBDFJUBDPNPVUJMJEBEFFFGJDgDJB PVTFKB DPNPBMHP RVFUFOIBVTPQSgUJDPFWFSJGJDgWFM &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBTNVEBOmBTOBDPODFQmkPEBWFSEB EFFNEFDPSSpODJBEFNVEBOmBTJOUFSOBThGJMPTPGJB "TNVEBOmBTEBTQFSTQFDUJWBTGJMPTwGJDBTUBNCnNJOGMVFO DJBNOBNVEBOmBEBDPODFQmkPEFWFSEBEF4F OBTQFSTQFDUJ WBTSFBMJTUBFJEFBMJTUB BWFSEBEFFSBDPODFCJEBDPNPDPSSFT QPOEpODJBFOUSFDPJTBFJEFJB DBEBVNBhTVBNBOFJSB DPNB QFSTQFDUJWBEBGJMPTPGJBBOBMrUJDB BPDPOUSgSJP BDPODFQmkPEB WFSEBEFDPNPDPFSpODJBJOUFSOBBSUJDVMBTFhDSrUJDBEPSFBMJTNP
| U NIDADE 4
|
A lógica
FNGJMPTPGJBFEBTVQPTJmkP OBTDJpODJBT EFRVFPDPOIFDJNFO UPDJFOUrGJDPTFCBTFJBOBPCTFSWBmkPEPTGBUPT QPJTBTDJpODJBT DPOTUSPFNTFVTPCKFUPTJOTUJUVJOEPMJOHVBHFOTDPFSFOUFTQBSB FMFT
5NIDADEßßßß=h ce_] #APqTULOß߯ßßKj]o_eiajpk`]hce_] 0RVFnTJHOJGJDBEPOPVTPDPUJEJBOPRVFGB[FNPTEBTQBMB WSBTMwHJDBFMwHJDP 2VFOPm{FTFTUkPQSFTTVQPTUBTOFTTF VTP "PVTBSNPTBTQBMBWSBTMwHJDBFMwHJDP FTUBNPTEJ[FOEPRVF EFUFSNJOBEBDPJTBnFWJEFOUFF QPSUBOUP BFYQSFTTkPBQBSFDF DPNPTFGPTTFBDPODMVTkPEFVNSBDJPDrOJPJNQMrDJUP DPNQBSUJ MIBEPQFMPTJOUFSMPDVUPSFTEPEJTDVSTP%FTTBGPSNB FTUkPJN QMJDJUBNFOUFQSFTTVQPTUBTBTOPm{FTEFJOGFSpODJB DPFSpODJB DPODMVTkPTFNDPOUSBEJm{FTFDPODMVTkPDPNCBTFFNDPOIFDJ NFOUPTTVGJDJFOUFT 2VBMGPJPDPOGMJUPFOUSFBGJMPTPGJBEF)FSgDMJUPFBEF1BS NpOJEFT 0DPOGMJUPCBTFBWBTFOBQSFPDVQBmkPDPNBPSJHFN USBOT GPSNBmkPFEFTBQBSFDJNFOUPEPTTFSFT)FSgDMJUPBGJSNBWBRVF TPNFOUFBNVEBOmBnSFBMFBQFSNBOpODJBJMVTwSJB PVTFKB P NVOEPnVNGMVYPQFSQnUVPPOEFOBEBQFSNBOFDFJEpOUJDPB TJNFTNP NBTUVEPTFUSBOTGPSNBOPTFVDPOUSgSJP1BSNpOJ EFT FNDPOUSBQBSUJEB BGJSNBWBRVFTPNFOUFBJEFOUJEBEFFB QFSNBOpODJBFSBNSFBJTFBNVEBOmB JMVTwSJBJTUPn PEFWJS P GMVYPEPTDPOUSgSJPT nBBQBSpODJBTFOTrWFM NFSBPQJOJkPRVF GPSNBNPTQPSRVFDPOGVOEJNPTBSFBMJEBEFDPNBTOPTTBTTFO TBm{FT QFSDFQm{FTFMFNCSBOmBT 1PSRVFPTDPOGMJUPTFOUSFBTGJMPTPGJBTEF)FSgDMJUPFEF1BS NpOJEFTTVTDJUBSBNPBQBSFDJNFOUPEBMwHJDB 1PSRVFPDPOGMJUPFOUSF)FSgDMJUPF1BSNpOJEFTUPSOPVTF VNQSPCMFNBQBSBBIJTUwSJBEBGJMPTPGJBHSFHBFSFRVFSJBVNB TPMVmkPRVFQSPWBTTFRVFBNVEBOmBFPTDPOUSgSJPTFYJTUFN FQPEFNTFSQFOTBEPT NBTRVF BPNFTNPUFNQP QSPWBTTF RVFBJEFOUJEBEFPVQFSNBOpODJBEPTTFSFTUBNCnNFYJTUF n WFSEBEFJSBFQPEFTFSQFOTBEB'PJBQBSUJSEBCVTDBEFTTBTP MVmkPRVFTVSHJVBMwHJDBFUBNCnNBNFUBGrTJDB 0RVFnBEJBMnUJDBQMBUyOJDB "EJBMnUJDBQMBUyOJDBnVNQSPDFEJNFOUPJOUFMFDUVBMFMJO HVrTUJDPRVFQBSUFEFBMHVNBDPJTBRVFEFWFTFSTFQBSBEB PVEJWJEJEBFNEPJTPVEVBTQBSUFTDPOUSgSJBTPVPQPTUBT EFNPEPRVFTFDPOIFmBTVBDPOUSBEJmkPFTFQPTTBEFUFS NJOBSRVBMEPTDPOUSgSJPTnWFSEBEFJSPFRVBMnGBMTP"DBEB EJWJTkPTVSHFVNQBSEFDPOUSgSJPT RVFEFWFNTFSTFQBSB EPTFOPWBNFOUFEJWJEJEPT BUnRVFTFDIFHVFBVNUFSNP JOEJWJTrWFM JTUPn OkPGPSNBEPQPSOFOIVNBPQPTJmkPPV DPOUSBEJmkPFRVFTFSgBJEFJBWFSEBEFJSBPVBFTTpODJBEB DPJTBJOWFTUJHBEB 0RVFnBBOBMrUJDBPVMwHJDBBSJTUPUnMJDB "BOBMrUJDBPVBMwHJDBBSJTUPUnMJDBnVNDPOKVOUPEFQSPDFEJ NFOUPTEFEFNPOTUSBmkPFQSPWB5SBUBTFEFVNBWJBBMUFSOBUJ
WBhEJBMnUJDBQMBUyOJDB RVF QBSB"SJTUwUFMFT OkPnVNQSPDFEJ NFOUPTFHVSPQBSBPQFOTBNFOUPFQBSBBMJOHVBHFNEBGJMPTPGJB FEBDJpODJB QPJTUFNDPNPQPOUPEFQBSUJEBBTNFSBTPQJOJ{FT DPOUSgSJBTEPTEFCBUFEPSFT FBFTDPMIBEFVNBPQJOJkPFNWF[ EFPVUSBOkPHBSBOUFRVFTFQPTTBDIFHBShFTTpODJBEBDPJTB JOWFTUJHBEB 2VBJTBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFBEJBMnUJDBQMBUyOJDBFBOBMrUJDB PVMwHJDBBSJTUPUnMJDB &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS BEJBMnUJDBQMBUyOJDBnPFYFSDrDJPEJSFUP EPQFOTBNFOUPFEBMJOHVBHFN VNNPEPEFQFOTBSRVFPQF SBDPNPTDPOUF|EPTEPQFOTBNFOUPFEPEJTDVSTP"MwHJDB BSJTUPUnMJDBnVNJOTUSVNFOUPQBSBPFYFSDrDJPEPQFOTBNFOUP FEBMJOHVBHFN PGFSFDFOEPMIFTNFJPTQBSBSFBMJ[BSPDPOIF DJNFOUPFPEJTDVSTP1BSB1MBUkP BEJBMnUJDBnVNNPEPEF DPOIFDFS1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT BMwHJDBnVNJOTUSVNFOUPQBSBP DPOIFDFS&NTFHVOEPMVHBS BEJBMnUJDBQMBUyOJDBnVNBBUJ WJEBEFJOUFMFDUVBMEFTUJOBEBBUSBCBMIBSPQJOJ{FTDPOUSgSJBTF DPOUSBEJm{FTQBSBTVQFSgMBT DIFHBOEPhJEFOUJEBEFEBFT TpODJBPVEBJEFJBJNVUgWFM"MwHJDBBSJTUPUnMJDBPGFSFDFQSP DFEJNFOUPTRVFEFWFNTFSFNQSFHBEPTOBRVFMFTSBDJPDrOJPT RVFTFSFGFSFNBUPEBTBTDPJTBTEBTRVBJTQPTTBNPTUFSVN DPOIFDJNFOUPVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJP FTFVQPOUPEFQBSUJEB OkPTkPBTPQJOJ{FTDPOUSgSJBT NBTPTQSJODrQJPT SFHSBTFMFJT OFDFTTgSJPTFVOJWFSTBJTEPQFOTBNFOUP
#APqTULOß߯ßßAhaiajpko`]hce_] 1PSRVFBMwHJDBOkPFOUSBOBDMBTTJGJDBmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBEBT DJpODJBT 1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT BMwHJDBOkPFSBVNBDJpODJBUFPSnUJDB OFN QSgUJDBOFNQSPEVUJWB NBTVNJOTUSVNFOUPQBSBBTDJpODJBT &JTQPSRVFPDPOKVOUPEBTPCSBTMwHJDBTBSJTUPUnMJDBTSFDFCFVP OPNFEFÎSHBOPO QBMBWSBHSFHBRVFTJHOJGJDB²JOTUSVNFOUP³ /PQFOTBNFOUPBSJTUPUnMJDP RVBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrT UJDBTEBMwHJDB *OTUSVNFOUBMnPJOTUSVNFOUPEPQFOTBNFOUPFEBMJO HVBHFNDPSSFUPTGPSNBMPDVQBTFBQFOBTDPNBGPSNBQVSB FHFSBMEPTQFOTBNFOUPT FYQSFTTPTQPSNFJPEBMJOHVBHFN QSPQFEpVUJDBPVQSFMJNJOBSnPRVFEFWFNPTDPOIFDFSBOUFT EFJOJDJBSVNBJOWFTUJHBmkPDJFOUrGJDBPVQSFMJNJOBSOPSNBUJWB GPSOFDFQSJODrQJPT MFJT SFHSBTFOPSNBTEPVUSJOBEBQSPWBFT UBCFMFDFBTDPOEJm{FTFPTGVOEBNFOUPTOFDFTTgSJPTEFUPEBT BTEFNPOTUSBm{FTHFSBMFBUFNQPSBMBTGPSNBTEPQFOTBNFO UPTkPVOJWFSTBJT OFDFTTgSJBTFJNVUgWFJT 2VBMnPPCKFUPEBMwHJDB 0PCKFUPEBMwHJDBnBQSPQPTJmkP BUSJCVJmkPEFVNQSFEJ DBEPBVNTVKFJUP4n1
RVFFYQSJNF QPSNFJPEBMJOHVBHFN PTKVr[PTGPSNVMBEPTQFMPQFOTBNFOUP 2VFTkPFRVBJTTkPBTDBUFHPSJBT "SJTUwUFMFTEFGJOFBTDBUFHPSJBTPVUFSNPTDPNP²BRVJMPRVF TFSWFQBSBEFTJHOBSVNBDPJTB³4kPQBMBWSBTOkPDPNCJOBEBT DPNPVUSBTFRVFBQBSFDFNFNUVEPRVBOUPQFOTBNPTFEJ[FNPT EFVNBDPJTBJNFEJBUBFEJSFUBNFOUFTFNQSFDJTBSEFOFOIVNB EFNPOTUSBmkP4kPEF[BTDBUFHPSJBTTVCTUiODJB RVBOUJEBEF RVBMJEBEF SFMBmkP MVHBS UFNQP QPTJmkP QPTTF BmkP QBJYkPPV QBTTJWJEBEF
.,
Manual do Professor
2VBJTTkPBTEVBTQSPQSJFEBEFTEBTDBUFHPSJBTMwHJDBT &Y QMJRVFBT "FYUFOTkPFBDPNQSFFOTkP&YUFOTkPnPDPOKVOUPEFPC KFUPTEFTJHOBEPTQPSVNUFSNPPVVNBDBUFHPSJB$PNQSFFO TkPnPDPOKVOUPEFQSPQSJFEBEFTRVFFTTFNFTNPUFSNPPV FTTBDBUFHPSJBEFTJHOB
QBSUFEFTTBFTTpODJB²5PEPUSJiOHVMPnVNBGJHVSBEFUSpTMB EPT³ OkPOFDFTTgSJBTPVJNQPTTrWFJT RVBOEPPQSFEJDBEP OkPQPEF EFNPEPBMHVN TFSBUSJCVrEPBPTVKFJUP²/FOIVN USJiOHVMPnGJHVSBEFRVBUSPMBEPT³ QPTTrWFJT RVBOEPPQSF EJDBEPQPEFTFSPVEFJYBSEFTFSBUSJCVrEPBPTVKFJUP²"MHVOT IPNFOTTkPKVTUPT³
2VBMBDMBTTJGJDBmkPEBTDBUFHPSJBTTFHVOEPBFYUFOTkPF BDPNQSFFOTkP
$PNPBTQSPQPTJm{FTTFDMBTTJGJDBNEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEB SFMBmkP
1PEFNPTDMBTTJGJDBSBTDBUFHPSJBTTFHVOEPBFYUFOTkPF BDPNQSFFOTkPFNUSpTUJQPT(pOFSPFYUFOTkPNBJPS DPN QSFFOTkPNFOPSFTQnDJFFYUFOTkPNnEJBFDPNQSFFOTkPNn EJBJOEJWrEVPFYUFOTkPNFOPS DPNQSFFOTkPNBJPS
$MBTTJGJDBNTFFNDPOUSBEJUwSJBT RVBOEPUFNPTPNFTNP TVKFJUPFPNFTNPQSFEJDBEP VNBEBTQSPQPTJm{FTnVOJWFSTBM BGJSNBUJWBFBPVUSBnQBSUJDVMBSOFHBUJWB²5PEPTPTGJMwTPGPTTkP TgCJPT³F²"MHVOTGJMwTPGPTOkPTkPTgCJPT³PVRVBOEPTFUFN VNBVOJWFSTBMOFHBUJWBFVNBQBSUJDVMBSBGJSNBUJWB²/FOIVN FVSPQFVnBGSJDBOP³F²"MHVOTFVSPQFVTTkPBGSJDBOPT³ DPO USgSJBT RVBOEP UFOEPPNFTNPTVKFJUPFPNFTNPQSFEJDBEP VNBEBTQSPQPTJm{FTnVOJWFSTBMBGJSNBUJWBFBPVUSBnVOJWFSTBM OFHBUJWB²5PEPTPTMBHBSUPTTkPSnQUFJT³F²/FOIVNMBHBSUPn SnQUJM³PVRVBOEPVNBEBTQSPQPTJm{FTnQBSUJDVMBSBGJSNBUJWB FBPVUSBnQBSUJDVMBSOFHBUJWB²"MHVOTQPMrUJDPTTkPDPSSVQUPT³ F²"MHVOTQPMrUJDPTOkPTkPDPSSVQUPT³ TVCBMUFSOBT RVBOEP VNBVOJWFSTBMBGJSNBUJWBTVCPSEJOBVNBQBSUJDVMBSBGJSNBUJWBEF NFTNPTVKFJUPFQSFEJDBEP²5PEPTPTCSBTJMFJSPTTkPTVMBNF SJDBOPT³F²"MHVOTCSBTJMFJSPTTkPTVMBNFSJDBOPT³PVRVBOEP VNBVOJWFSTBMOFHBUJWBTVCPSEJOBVNBQBSUJDVMBSOFHBUJWBEF NFTNPTVKFJUPFQSFEJDBEP²/FOIVNBKPJBnCBSBUB³F²"MHV NBTKPJBTOkPTkPCBSBUBT³
0RVFnVNBQSPQPTJmkP 2VBJTTkPTFVTFMFNFOUPT "QSPQPTJmkPnVNEJTDVSTPEFDMBSBUJWP DPOTUJUVrEPQPS UFSNPTPVDBUFHPSJBT RVFFOVODJBPVEFDMBSBWFSCBMNFOUFP RVFGPJQFOTBEPFSFMBDJPOBEPQFMPKVr[P"QSPQPTJmkPSF| OFPVTFQBSBWFSCBMNFOUFPRVFPKVr[PSFVOJVPVTFQBSPV NFOUBMNFOUF4FVTFMFNFOUPTTkPTVKFJUP BDBUFHPSJBEB TVCTUiODJB QSFEJDBEPBUSJCVrEPBPTVKFJUP BTEFNBJTDBUF HPSJBT WFSCPEFMJHBmkPTFS GB[BBUSJCVJmkPPVQSFEJDBmkP EPTVKFJUP 0RVFTkPBWFSEBEFFBGBMTJEBEFMwHJDBTEFVNBQSPQP TJmkP 7FSEBEFMwHJDBnRVBOEPPRVFGPJSFVOJEPPVTFQBSBEP FNQFOTBNFOUPFOBMJOHVBHFNFTUgFGFUJWBNFOUFSFVOJEP PVTFQBSBEPOBSFBMJEBEFGBMTJEBEFMwHJDBnRVBOEPPRVFGPJ SFVOJEPPVTFQBSBEPFNQFOTBNFOUPFOBMJOHVBHFNOkPFTUg FGFUJWBNFOUFSFVOJEPPVTFQBSBEPOBSFBMJEBEF 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFQSPQPTJmkPFYJTUFODJBMFQSPQPTJmkP QSFEJDBUJWB "QSPQPTJmkPFYJTUFODJBMEFDMBSBBFYJTUpODJB QPTJmkP BmkP PVQBJYkPEPTVKFJUP²6NIPNFNn FYJTUF ³"QSPQPTJmkPQSF EJDBUJWBEFDMBSBBBUSJCVJmkPEFBMHVNBDPJTBBVNTVKFJUPQPS NFJPEPWFSCPEFMJHBmkPn²6NIPNFNnKVTUP³ $PNPBTQSPQPTJm{FTTFDMBTTJGJDBNEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEB RVBMJEBEF $MBTTJGJDBNTFFNBGJSNBUJWBT BTRVFBUSJCVFNBMHVNB DPJTBBVNTVKFJUP4n1
OFHBUJWBT BTRVFTFQBSBNPTVKFJUP EFBMHVNBDPJTB4OkPn1 $PNPBTQSPQPTJm{FTTFDMBTTJGJDBNEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEB RVBOUJEBEF $MBTTJGJDBNTFFNVOJWFSTBJT RVBOEPPQSFEJDBEPTFSF GFSFhFYUFOTkPUPUBMEPTVKFJUP BGJSNBUJWBNFOUF²5PEPTPT 4TkP1³± PVOFHBUJWBNFOUF²/FOIVN4n1³ QBSUJDVMBSFT RVBOEPPQSFEJDBEPnBUSJCVrEPBVNBQBSUFEBFYUFOTkPEP TVKFJUP BGJSNBUJWBNFOUF²"MHVOT4TkP1³ PVOFHBUJWBNFOUF ²"MHVOT4OkPTkP1³ TJOHVMBSFT RVBOEPPQSFEJDBEPnBUSJ CVrEPBVN|OJDPJOEJWrEVP BGJSNBUJWBNFOUF²&TUF4n1³ PV OFHBUJWBNFOUF²&TUF4OkPn1³ $PNPBTQSPQPTJm{FTTFDMBTTJGJDBNEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEB NPEBMJEBEF $MBTTJGJDBNTFFNOFDFTTgSJBT RVBOEPPQSFEJDBEPFT UgJODMVrEPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFOBFTTpODJBEPTVKFJUP GB[FOEP
.-
&YQMJRVFPRVFTkPKVr[PBQPErUJDP IJQPUnUJDPFEJTKVO UJWP 2VBOEPBQSPQPTJmkPnVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJB TFKBBGJSNBUJ WB TFKBOFHBUJWB
EJ[TFRVFFMBEFDMBSBVNKVr[PBQPErUJDP1PS FYFNQMP²5PEPTPTMBHBSUPTTkPSnQUFJT³FBQSPQPTJmkP²/F OIVNQgTTBSPnNBNrGFSP³2VBOEPBQSPQPTJmkPnVOJWFSTBM QPTTrWFMPVQBSUJDVMBSQPTTrWFM BGJSNBUJWBPVOFHBUJWB
EJ[TF RVFFMBEFDMBSBVNKVr[PIJQPUnUJDP DVKBGPSNVMBmkPn²4F FOUkP³1PSFYFNQMP²4FGJ[FSTPM JSFJhQSBJB³2VBOEPBQSP QPTJmkPnVOJWFSTBMPVQBSUJDVMBS BGJSNBUJWBPVOFHBUJWB FDPN QPSUBVNBBMUFSOBUJWBRVFEFQFOEFEPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTPVEBT DJSDVOTUiODJBT EJ[TFRVFFMBEFDMBSBVNKVr[PEJTKVOUJWP DVKB GPSNVMBmkPn²PVPV³1PSFYFNQMP²0VDIPWFSgBNBOIk PVOkPDIPWFSgBNBOIk³ 1PSRVFPSBDJPDrOJPnVNBJOGFSpODJBNFEJBUB 1PSRVFTwQPEFNPTDPOIFDFSBMHVNBDPJTB BDPODMVTkP QPSNFJPPVQFMBNFEJBmkPEFPVUSBTDPJTBT&TUBnBUFPSJBEP SBDJPDrOJPFMBCPSBEBQPS"SJTUwUFMFTRVFFTUgCBTFBEBOBJOGF SpODJB PCUFOmkPEFVNBQSPQPTJmkPDPNPDPODMVTkPEFVNB PVUSBPVEFWgSJBTPVUSBTQSPQPTJm{FTRVFBBOUFDFEFNFTkP TVBFYQMJDBmkPPVTVBDBVTB 2VFnVNTJMPHJTNP 5FPSJBEFGPSNVMBmkPEPSBDJPDrOJPCBTFBEBFNPQFSBm{FT EPQFOTBNFOUPRVFTkPSFBMJ[BEBTBUSBWnTEFKVr[PTFFOVODJB EBTQPSNFJPEFQSPQPTJm{FTFODBEFBEBT JOGFSpODJBT 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEPTJMPHJTNP 0TJMPHJTNPQPTTVJUSpTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTQSJODJQBJTnNFEJBUP FYJHFVNQFSDVSTPEFQFOTBNFOUPFEFMJOHVBHFNQBSBRVFTF QPTTBDIFHBSBVNBDPODMVTkP nEFNPOTUSBUJWP°EFEVUJWPPV
| U NIDADE 4
|
A lógica
JOEVUJWP NPWJNFOUPEFQFOTBNFOUPFEFMJOHVBHFNRVFQBSUF EFDFSUBTBGJSNBm{FTWFSEBEFJSBTQBSBDIFHBSBPVUSBTUBNCnN WFSEBEFJSBTFRVFEFQFOEFNOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFEBTQSJNFJSBTn OFDFTTgSJP QPSRVFnEFNPOTUSBUJWP JTUPn BTDPOTFRVpODJBTB RVFTFDIFHBOBDPODMVTkPSFTVMUBNOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFEBWFSEB EFDPNPQPOUPEFQBSUJEB $PNPnDPOTUJUVrEPVNTJMPHJTNP 6NTJMPHJTNPnDPOTUJUVrEPQPSUSpTQSPQPTJm{FT"QSJNFJSB nDIBNBEBEFQSFNJTTBNBJPS BTFHVOEB EFQSFNJTTBNFOPSF BUFSDFJSB EFDPODMVTkP"DPODMVTkPnJOGFSJEBEBTQSFNJTTBT QFMBNFEJBmkPEFVNUFSNPDIBNBEPUFSNPNnEJP 2VFTkPUFSNPNBJPS NFOPSFNnEJP 2VBMnBGVOmkPEP UFSNPNnEJP 0UFSNPNBJPSJOUFHSBBQSFNJTTBNBJPSFnBTTJNEFTJHOB EPQPSRVFnBRVFMFRVFUFNNBJTFYUFOTkP/BDPODMVTkPPDVQB TFNQSFPMVHBSEFQSFEJDBEP0UFSNPNFOPSJOUFHSBBQSFNJTTB NFOPSFnBRVFMFRVFUFNNFOPTFYUFOTkP/BDPODMVTkP TFN QSFBQBSFDFDPNPTVKFJUP0UFSNPNnEJPSFQFUFTFOBTEVBT QSFNJTTBT TFOEPPJOUFSNFEJgSJPFOUSFPUFSNPNBJPSFPUFSNP NFOPS FOkPBQBSFDFOBDPODMVTkP"GVOmkPEPUFSNPNnEJPn MJHBSPTUFSNPTNBJPSFNFOPS FYUSFNPT &TTBMJHBmkPnBJOGF SpODJB FTFNFMBOkPIgSBDJPDrOJPOFNEFNPOTUSBmkP 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTSFHSBTEPTJMPHJTNPWFSEBEFJSP "QSFNJTTBNBJPSEFWFDPOUFSPUFSNPFYUSFNPNBJPSFP UFSNPNnEJPBQSFNJTTBNFOPSEFWFDPOUFSPUFSNPFYUSFNP NFOPSFPUFSNPNnEJPBDPODMVTkPEFWFDPOUFSPNBJPSFP NFOPSFKBNBJTEFWFDPOUFSPUFSNPNnEJP 1PSRVFPTJMPHJTNPEFDMBSBVNBJOFSpODJB 1PSTFSVNTJTUFNBEFJODMVT{FT PVFYDMVT{FT FOUSFTV KFJUPTFQSFEJDBEPT PTJMPHJTNPnBEFDMBSBmkPEBJOFSpODJBEP QSFEJDBEPBPTVKFJUP JOFSpODJBBGJSNBUJWB RVBOEPPQSFEJDBEP FTUgJODMVrEPOPTVKFJUPJOFSpODJBOFHBUJWB RVBOEPPQSFEJDB EPFTUgFYDMVrEPEPTVKFJUP 2VFSFHSBTEFJOGFSpODJBPTJMPHJTNPEFWFPCFEFDFS "JOGFSpODJBTJMPHrTUJDBEFWFPCFEFDFSBPJUPSFHSBTVN TJMPHJTNPEFWFUFSVNUFSNPNBJPS VNNFOPSFVNNnEJPF TPNFOUFUSpTUFSNPT OFNNBJTOFNNFOPTPUFSNPNnEJP EFWFBQBSFDFSOBTEVBTQSFNJTTBTFKBNBJTBQBSFDFSOBDPO DMVTkPEFWFTFSUPNBEPFNUPEBBTVBFYUFOTkP JTUPn DPNP VNVOJWFSTBM QFMPNFOPTVNBWF[OFOIVNUFSNPQPEFTFS NBJTFYUFOTPOBDPODMVTkPEPRVFOBTQSFNJTTBTBDPODMVTkP OkPQPEFDPOUFSPUFSNPNnEJPEFEVBTQSFNJTTBTOFHBUJWBT OBEBQPEFTFSDPODMVrEPEFEVBTQSFNJTTBTQBSUJDVMBSFTOBEB QPEFSgTFSDPODMVrEPEVBTQSFNJTTBTBGJSNBUJWBTEFWFNUFSB DPODMVTkPBGJSNBUJWBBDPODMVTkPTFNQSFBDPNQBOIBBQBSUF NBJTGSBDB JTUPn TFIPVWFSVNBQSFNJTTBOFHBUJWB BDPODMVTkP TFSgOFHBUJWBTFIPVWFSVNBQSFNJTTBQBSUJDVMBS BDPODMV TkPTFSgQBSUJDVMBSTFIPVWFSVNBQSFNJTTBQBSUJDVMBSOFHBUJWB BDPODMVTkPTFSgVNBQBSUJDVMBSOFHBUJWB 2VFTkPGJHVSBTFNPEPTEPTJMPHJTNP "TGJHVSBTTkPRVBUSPFTFSFGFSFNhQPTJmkPPDVQBEBQF MPUFSNPNnEJPOBTQSFNJTTBT TVKFJUPFNBNCBT QSFEJDBEP FNBNCBT TVKFJUPOBNBJPS QSFEJDBEPOBNFOPS QSFEJDBEPOB NBJPS TVKFJUPOBNFOPS 0TNPEPTTkP FNCPSBTPNFOUF EF[TFKBNDPOTJEFSBEPTWgMJEPT FTFSFGFSFNBPTUJQPTFQSP QPTJm{FTRVFDPOTUJUVFNBTQSFNJTTBT VOJWFSTBJTBGJSNBUJWBT
FNBNCBT QBSUJDVMBSFTOFHBUJWBTFNBNCBT QBSUJDVMBSFTBGJS NBUJWBTFNBNCBT QBSUJDVMBSFTOFHBUJWBTFNBNCBT VOJWFSTBM BGJSNBUJWBOBNBJPSFQBSUJDVMBSBGJSNBUJWBOBNFOPS FUD 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFTJMPHJTNPEJBMnUJDPFDJFOUrGJDP 1PS RVFPTJMPHJTNPEJBMnUJDPnQSwQSJPEBSFUwSJDB 0TTJMPHJTNPTDJFOUrGJDPTTkPBRVFMFTRVFTFSFGFSFNBPRVF nVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJP BPRVFnEFVNBNBOFJSBFOkPQP EFEFJYBSEFTFSUBMDPNPn BPRVFBDPOUFDFTFNQSFFTFNQSF BDPOUFDFEBNFTNBNBOFJSB/kPBENJUFQSFNJTTBTDPOUSBEJUw SJBT4VBTQSFNJTTBTTkPBQPErUJDBTFTVBDPODMVTkPUBNCnNn BQPErUJDB0TTJMPHJTNPTEJBMnUJDPTTkPBRVFMFTDVKBTQSFNJTTBT TFSFGFSFNBPRVFnBQFOBTQPTTrWFMPVQSPWgWFM BPRVFQPEF TFSEFVNBNBOFJSBPVEFVNBNBOFJSBDPOUSgSJBFPQPTUB BP RVFQPEFBDPOUFDFSPVEFJYBSEFBDPOUFDFS4VBTQSFNJTTBTTkP IJQPUnUJDBTFQPSJTTPTVBDPODMVTkPUBNCnNnIJQPUnUJDB1FMP GBUPEFPTJMPHJTNPEJBMnUJDPDPNQPSUBSBSHVNFOUBm{FTCBTFB EBTFNPQJOJ{FTTPCSFDPJTBTPVGBUPTQPTTrWFJTPVQSPWgWFJT RVFOkPTkPPCKFUPTEBDJpODJB
WJTBUPDBSBTFNPm{FTFQBJ Y{FTEPTPVWJOUFTFOkPPSBDJPDrOJPPVBJOUFMJHpODJBEFMFT EBr TVBOBUVSF[BSFUwSJDB JTUPn FMFnQFSTVBTJWPNBTOkPOFDFT TBSJBNFOUFWFSEBEFJSP 2VBJTBTSFHSBTEPTJMPHJTNPDJFOUrGJDP 0TJMPHJTNPDJFOUrGJDPEFWFPCFEFDFSBRVBUSPSFHSBT TFN BTRVBJTTVBEFNPOTUSBmkPOkPUFNWBMPSBTQSFNJTTBTEF WFNTFSWFSEBEFJSBTBTQSFNJTTBTEFWFNTFSQSJNgSJBTPV QSJNFJSBT JTUPn JOEFNPOTUSgWFJTBTQSFNJTTBTEFWFNTFS NBJTJOUFMJHrWFJTEPRVFBDPODMVTkPBTQSFNJTTBTEFWFNTFS DBVTBEBDPODMVTkP JTUPn EFWFNFTUBCFMFDFSBTDPJTBTPV PTGBUPTRVFDBVTBNBDPODMVTkPFRVFBFYQMJDBN EFUBMNB OFJSBRVF BPDPOIFDpMBT FTUBNPTPCFEFDFOEPhTDBVTBTEB DPODMVTkP &YQMJRVFPRVFTkPPTUSpTUJQPTEFQSFNJTTBTEPTJMPHJTNP DJFOUrGJDP 4kPWFSEBEFTJOEFNPOTUSgWFJT FWJEFOUFTFDBVTBJT4kPEF U SpTUJQPTBYJPNBT WFSEBEFTJOEFNPOTUSgWFJTRVFTFSWFNEF CBTFQBSBUPEBTBTEFNPOTUSBm{FTEFVNBDJpODJB QPTUVMBEPT QSFTTVQPTUPTEFRVFTFWBMFVNBDJpODJBQBSBJOJDJBSPFTUVEP EFTFVTPCKFUPT EFGJOJm{FT EFWFNEJ[FSPRVFBDPJTBFTUVEB EBn DPNPn QPSRVFn FTPCRVBJTDPOEJm{FTFMBn %FBDPSEPDPN"SJTUwUFMFT DPNPVNBDJpODJBWBJEPHpOFSP hTFTQnDJFTFEFTUBTBPTJOEJWrEVPT "QBTTBHFNEPHpOFSPhFTQnDJFTJOHVMBSTFGB[QPSVNB DBEFJBEFEVUJWBPVDBEFJBTJMPHrTUJDBOBRVBMDBEBFTQnDJF GVODJPOBDPNPHpOFSPQBSBTVBTTVCPSEJOBEBT FDBEBVNB EFMBTTFEJTUJOHVFEBTPVUSBTQPSVNBEJGFSFOmBFTQFDrGJDB &ODPOUSBSBEJGFSFOmBFTQFDrGJDBFOUSFTFSFTEPNFTNPHpOFSP nEFGJOJS"UBSFGBEBEFGJOJmkPnEFMJNJUBSPHpOFSPFBEJGFSFO mBFTQFDrGJDBFTTFODJBMRVFEJTUJOHVFVNBFTQnDJFEFPVUSB "EFNPOTUSBmkP PTJMPHJTNP QBSUJSgEPHpOFSP PGFSFDFSgB EFGJOJmkPEBFTQnDJFFJODMVJSgPJOEJWrEVPOBFTQnDJFFOP HpOFSP EFTPSUFRVFBFTTpODJBPVPDPODFJUPEPJOEJWrEVP OBEBNBJTnEPRVFTVBJODMVTkPPVTVBJOFSpODJBhFTQnDJF FBPHpOFSP 2VBJTBTFYJHpODJBTGFJUBTQBSBRVFVNTJMPHJTNPDJFOUrGJDP DIFHVFBPDPODFJUPWFSEBEFJSPEFVNBDPJTB %FWFSFTQFJUBS BMnNEBTSFHSBTHFSBJTEPTJMPHJTNP RVBUSP FYJHpODJBTSFMBUJWBThTTVBTQSFNJTTBTEFWFNTFSQSFNJTTBT
..
Manual do Professor
WFSEBEFJSBTQBSBUPEPTPTDBTPTEFTFVTVKFJUPEFWFNTFSQSF NJTTBTFTTFODJBJT JTUPn BSFMBmkPFOUSFPTVKFJUPFPQSFEJDBEP EFWFTFSTFNQSFOFDFTTgSJB JOFSpODJBEPQSFEJDBEPhFTTpODJB EPTVKFJUP EFWFNTFSQSFNJTTBTQSwQSJBT JTUPn SFGFSJSTFFY DMVTJWBNFOUFBPTVKFJUPEBRVFMBDJpODJBFEFOFOIVNBPVUSB EFWFNTFSQSFNJTTBTHFSBJT JTUPn OVODBEFWFNSFGFSJSTFBPT JOEJWrEVPT NBTBPTHpOFSPTFhTFTQnDJFT QPJTPJOEJWrEVPEF GJOFTFQPSFMFT FOkPFMFTQFMPJOEJWrEVP "QSPQPTJmkPTFHVJOUFnWFSEBEFJSBPVGBMTB "FYUFOTkPEPUFSNP²BTUSP³nNBJPSEPRVFBEPUFSNP ²QMBOFUB5FSSB³ &YQMJRVFQPSRVp "QSPQPTJmkPnWFSEBEFJSBQPSRVFPTUFSNPTHFSBJTUpN VNBFYUFOTkPNBJPSEPRVFPTUFSNPTQBSUJDVMBSFT "QSPQPTJmkPTFHVJOUFnWFSEBEFJSBPVGBMTB "DPNQSFFOTkPEPUFSNP²CPJ³nNFOPSEPRVFBEPUFSNP ²BOJNBM³ &YQMJRVFQPSRVp "QSPQPTJmkPnGBMTBQPSRVFBDPNQSFFOTkPEPTUFSNPT FTQFDrGJDPTnNBJPSEPRVFBEPTUFSNPTHFSBJT %JHB TF Ig PV OkP DPOUSBEJmkP FOUSF BT TFHVJOUFT QSPQPTJm{FTFFYQMJRVFQPSRVp B 5PEPTPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTkPSBDJPOBJT 1FESPnJSSBDJPOBM C /FOIVNQMBOFUBUFNMV[QSwQSJB 7pOVTJMVNJOBTFBTJNFTNP D 5PEBTBTDJpODJBTEFTFKBNDPOIFDFSBWFSEBEF "CJPMPHJBnPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPEPTGFOyNFOPT SFMBDJPOBEPThWJEB "TQSPQPTJm{FTOPDBTPB TkPDPOUSBEJUwSJBTQPSRVFVNB EFMBTnVOJWFSTBMBGJSNBUJWB NBTBPVUSBnBQBSUJDVMBSOFHBUJWB OFHBOEPQBSBVNIVNBOPPQSFEJDBEPRVFGPJVOJWFSTBMNFOUF BGJSNBEPEFUPEPTPTIVNBOPT"TQSPQPTJm{FTEPDBTPC TkP DPOUSBEJUwSJBTQPSRVFVNBEFMBTnVOJWFSTBMOFHBUJWB NBT BPVUSBnQBSUJDVMBSBGJSNBUJWB BGJSNBOEPQBSBVNQMBOFUBP QSFEJDBEPRVFGPJVOJWFSTBMNFOUFOFHBEPEFUPEPTPTQMBOFUBT "TQSPQPTJm{FTEPDBTPD OkPTkPDPOUSBEJUwSJBT QPJTBQBSUJDV MBSBGJSNBUJWBBGJSNBQBSBVNBDJpODJBPNFTNPQSFEJDBEPRVFB VOJWFSTBMBGJSNBUJWBBGJSNBQBSBUPEBTBTDJpODJBT
QSPQPTJmkP FDPNBTPQFSBm{FTJOUFMFDUVBJTEPTVKFJUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUP BFTUSVUVSBEPQFOTBNFOUP 0RVFBMwHJDBGPSNBMEFTDSFWF %FTDSFWFBTGPSNBT BTQSPQSJFEBEFTFBTSFMBm{FTEBTQSP QPTJm{FT HSBmBThDPOTUSVmkPEFVNTJNCPMJTNPSFHVMBEPF PSEFOBEPRVFQFSNJUFEJGFSFODJBSBMJOHVBHFNDPUJEJBOBEBMJO HVBHFNMwHJDBGPSNBMJ[BEB 1PSRVF BPQBTTBSEBDPODFQmkPJOUVJUJWBhDPOTUSVUJWB B NBUFNgUJDBTFBQSPYJNPVEBMwHJDB 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVF BNBUFNgUJDBnVNBMJOHVBHFNTJNCwMJDBQFSGFJUB "PEFJY BSEFTFSDPOD FC JE BDPN PDJpOD JBEFWFSEBE FT BCTPMVUBT VOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJBTRVFFYJTUJSJBNDPNPV TFNPTIPNFOT FQBTTBSBTFSDPODFCJEBDPNPVNBDJpODJB RVFSFTVMUBEFVNBDPOTUSVmkPJOUFMFDUVBM VNBJOWFOmkP EPFTQrSJUPIVNBOP TFNRVFTVBTFOUJEBEFTTFKBNFYJTUFO UFTFNTJFQPSTJNFTNBT BNBUFNgUJDBFTUSFJUPVBSFMBmkP DPNBMwHJDBQFMPGBUPEFBNCBTBEPUBSFNVNNPEFMPEF EJTDVSTPRVFnFMBCPSBEPQFMPFTQrSJUPIVNBOPBUSBWnTEP FNQSFHPGPSNBMEBMJOHVBHFN FOkPQPSNFJPEFVNQFO TBNFOUPJOUVJUJWPRVFDPOUFNQMBSJBFOUJEBEFTQFSGFJUBTF FUFSOBT FYJTUFOUFTFNTJNFTNBT"NBUFNgUJDBnVNBMJO HVBHFNQFSGFJUBQPSRVFTVBTGPSNBTFDgMDVMPTQVSPTTkP PSHBOJ[BEPTDPNCBTFFNTrNCPMPTDPNVN|OJDPTFOUJEP BMHPSJUNP 2VFGPJPQTJDPMPHJTNPMwHJDP 'PJBDPSSFOUFMwHJDBRVFBMFHBWBRVFPTQSPHSFTTPTEBDJpO DJBQTJDPMwHJDBJSJBNEFGJOJSBTSFHSBTVOJWFSTBJTBRVFUPEPF RVBMRVFSQFOTBNFOUPTFTVCNFUF FRVFBMwHJDBTFSJBBQFOBT VNSBNPEBQTJDPMPHJB BRVFMFRVFFTUVEBDPNPGVODJPOBPQFO TBNFOUPDJFOUrGJDP 1PSRVFBMwHJDBOkPTFDPOGVOEFDPNBQTJDPMPHJBOFNDPN BUFPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP 1PSRVFTFVPCKFUPnPQFOTBNFOUPDPNPPQFSBmkPEF NPOTUSBUJWB RVFTFHVFSFHSBTPSJFOUBEBTQBSBEFUFSNJOBSTFB EFNPOTUSBmkPnWFSEBEFJSBPVGBMTBEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEPQSw QSJPQFOTBNFOUP JTUPn TFBEFNPOTUSBmkPPCFEFDFVPVOkP BPTQSJODrQJPTMwHJDPT 2VFOrWFJTEFMJOHVBHFNBMwHJDBEJTUJOHVF
#APqTULOß߯ßß=hce_]oei^he_] 2VBMPPCKFUJWPEBMwHJDBTJNCwMJDB 5PSOBSTFQMFOBNFOUFGPSNBM TFSVNBMJOHVBHFNQFSGFJUB UPUBMNFOUFQVSJGJDBEBEBTBNCJHVJEBEFTFDPOUSBTTFOTPTEB MJOHVBHFNDPUJEJBOB 1PSRVFBMwHJDBBSJTUPUnMJDBOkPFSBQMFOBNFOUFGPSNBM 1PSRVFOkPFSBJOEJGFSFOUFBPTDPOUF|EPTEBTQSPQPTJm{FT OFNhTPQFSBm{FTJOUFMFDUVBJTEPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP" GPSNBMwHJDBSFDFCJBPWBMPSEFWFSEBEFPVGBMTJEBEFDPNCBTF OBWFSEBEFPVGBMTJEBEFEPTBUPTEFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPTVKFJUPF OBSFBMJEBEFPVJSSFBMJEBEFEPTPCKFUPTDPOIFDJEPT 1PSRVFBMwHJDBDPOUFNQPSiOFBUPSOPVTFQMFOBNFOUFGPS NBM 1PSRVFQSFPDVQBTFDBEBWF[NFOPTDPNPDPOUF|EPNB UFSJBMEBTQSPQPTJm{FT BSFBMJEBEFEPTPCKFUPTSFGFSJEPTQFMB
./
"MwHJDBEJTUJOHVFEPJTOrWFJTEFMJOHVBHFNMJOHVBHFNOB UVSBM BRVFMBRVFVTBNPTFNOPTTBWJEBDPUJEJBOB OBTBSUFT OB QPMrUJDB OBGJMPTPGJBMJOHVBHFNGPSNBM BRVFMBRVFnDPOTUSVrEB TFHVOEPQSJODrQJPTFSFHSBTEFUFSNJOBEPTRVFEFTDSFWFNVN UJQPFTQFDrGJDPEFPCKFUP PPCKFUPEBTDJpODJBT 2VBJTPTEPJTUJQPTEFMJOHVBHFNTJNCwMJDB 2VBJTTkPTVBT EJGFSFOmBT -JOHVBHFNTJNCwMJDBDVMUVSBM BMJOHVBHFN²OBUVSBM³
RVFVTBTJHOPT NFUgGPSBT BOBMPHJBT FTRVFNBT4VBQSJODJ QBMDBSBDUFSrTUJDBnTFSDPOPUBUJWB JTUPn PTTrNCPMPTDBSSFHBN NVJUPTTFOUJEPTFSFGFSFNTFBNVJUBTTJHOJGJDBm{FT QPMJTTF NJB -JOHVBHFNTJNCwMJDBMwHJDPDJFOUrGJDB BMJOHVBHFN ²DPOTUSVrEB³
RVFVTBVNTJTUFNBGFDIBEPEFTJHOPTPVTrN CPMPT BMHPSJUNP
FNRVFDBEBTrNCPMPnTrNCPMPEFVNB|OJ DBDPJTBFDPSSFTQPOEFBVNB|OJDBTJHOJGJDBmkP4VBQSJODJQBM DBSBDUFSrTUJDBnTFSFTTFODJBMNFOUFVNTJNCPMJTNPEFOPUBUJWP PVJOEJDBUJWP VOrWPDP
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
1PSRVFBMwHJDBnVNBNFUBMJOHVBHFN 1PSTFSVNEJTDVSTPPVVNBMJOHVBHFNRVFGBMBEFPVUSP EJTDVSTPPVEFPVUSBMJOHVBHFN
JTUPn RVFOkPDPOUnNFMFNFOUPBMHVNFDVKPTrNCPMPnBEB DMBTTFDPNQMFNFOUBS"μEF" GPSNBEBQPSUPEPTPTFMFNFOUPT RVFOkPQFSUFODFNB"
2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTUFTFTEF8JUUHFOTUFJO
0RVFnBMwHJDBEBTSFMBm{FT
2VBMRVFSQSPQPTJmkPRVFUFOIBTJHOJGJDBEPnDPNQPTUB QPSQSPQPTJm{FTFMFNFOUBSFT OBTRVBJTTFFODPOUSBBWFSEBEF PVGBMTJEBEFEBQSPQPTJmkPDPNTJHOJGJDBEP BTQSPQPTJm{FT FMFNFOUBSFTBERVJSFNTJHOJGJDBEPQPSRVFBGJHVSBN SFUSBUBN PNVOEPOkPDPNPGBUPTFDPJTBT NBTDPNP²FTUBEPEFDPJ TBT³ BTQSPQPTJm{FTEBMwHJDBTkPWFSEBEFJSBTJOEFQFOEFO UFNFOUFEBTOPm{FTEF²TJHOJGJDBEP³FEF²FTUBEPTEFDPJTBT³ QPSRVF SJHPSPTBNFOUF OkPGBMBNEFOBEB QPJTSFGFSFNTF BRVBMRVFSGBUP TJHOJGJDBEPPVFTUBEPEFDPJTBTRVFQPTTBN PDPSSFSPVOkPOP6OJWFSTP"TQSPQPTJm{FTEBMwHJDBTkPWFS EBEFTWB[JBT SFGFSJEBTBQFOBTBPQSwQSJPVTPEBTDPOWFOm{FT MwHJDBT
"MwHJDBEBTSFMBm{FTPDVQBTFEBTSFMBm{FTFOUSFDPOKVO UPTEFPCKFUPTNBJPSEPRVF NFOPSEPRVF QFSUPEF MPOHFEF NBJTWFMIPRVF NBJTOPWPRVF DBVTBEF EJGFSFOUFEF FUD"T SFMBm{FTQPEFNBCSBOHFSEPJTPVNBJTPCKFUPT TFOEPCJOgSJBT UFSOgSJBT RVBUFSOgSJBT FUD
$PNPTFEJTUJOHVFNWFSEBEFFWBMJEBEFJOGFSFODJBM 7BMJEBEFJOGFSFODJBMOkPnTJOyOJNPEFWFSEBEF5SBUBTF EFVNBJOGFSpODJBSFBMJ[BEBDPSSFUBNFOUFBQBSUJSEFBSHVNFO UPTDVKBTTFOUFOmBTQPEFNTFSQFSTVBTJWBTPVEFNPOTUSBUJWBT NBTOkPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFWFSEBEFJSBT %pBMHVOTUJQPTEFQSPQPTJm{FTFNRVFPTVKFJUPFPQSFEJ DBEPFTUkPRVBOUJGJDBEPT 1SPGFTTPS B OFTUBSFTQPTUBPBMVOPQPEFEBSBMHVOTEPT PJUPUJQPTEFQSPQPTJm{FTFNRVFPTVKFJUPFPQSFEJDBEPFTUkP RVBOUJGJDBEPT"GJSNBUJWBTUPUPUPUBJT 5PEP4nUPEP1 BGJSNB UJWBTUPUPQBSDJBJT 5PEP4nBMHVN1 BGJSNBUJWBTQBSUJUPUBJT "M HVOT4TkPUPEPT1 BGJSNBUJWBTQBSUJQBSDJBJT "MHVN4nBMHVN 1 OFHBUJWBTUPUPUPUBJT /FOIVN4nOFOIVN1 OFHBUJWBTUP UPQBSDJBJT /FOIVN4nBMHVN1 OFHBUJWBTQBSUJUPUBJT "MHVN 4OkPnOFOIVN1 OFHBUJWBTQBSUJQBSDJBJT "MHVOT4OkPTkP BMHVOT1 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBJOFSpODJBBSJTUPUnMJDBFPDgMDVMP MwHJDPEFQSPQPTJm{FT %FBDPSEPDPNBJOFSpODJBBSJTUPUnMJDB PSBDJPDrOJPnVN TJTUFNBEFJODMVT{FT PVFYDMVT{FT FOUSFTVKFJUPTFQSFEJDB EPT/PDgMDVMPMwHJDPEFQSPQPTJm{FT BTQSPQPTJm{FTQPEF SJBNDPOWFSUFSTFTJNQMFTNFOUFVNBTOBTPVUSBTF GJOBMNFOUF VNBQSPQPTJmkPFSBBQFOBTVNBFRVBmkPFOUSFVNTVKFJUPF VNQSFEJDBEP$PNJTTP PSBDJPDrOJPKgOkPDPOTJTUJBFNGB[FS VNBOPmkPFOUSBSFNPVUSB NBTTFSDBQB[EFTVCTUJUVJSPVUSB FRVJWBMFOUF FNQSPQPTJm{FTEBEBT EFTPSUFRVFQSPQPTJm{FT VTBOEPQBMBWSBTDPNPIPNFN BOJNBM NPSUBM FUDQPEFSJBN TFSUSBUBEBTDPNPSBDJPDrOJPTNBUFNgUJDPTRVFVTBNTrNCPMPT DPNPY ZF[ -FWBOEPFNDPOTJEFSBmkPPQSFEJDBEPDPNPDMBTTFFDPNP GVOmkP PRVFnBMwHJDBEPTQSFEJDBEPT "DPOTUSVmkPEFVNTJNCPMJTNPRVFQFSNJUFEFGJOJSBTGVO m{FTEPQSFEJDBEP JOUSPEV[JOEPOPWPTRVBOUJGJDBEPSFTDPNPT RVBJTBGVOmkPnDBMDVMBEB 2VFPQFSBm{FTQPEFNTFSSFBMJ[BEBTDPNBTDMBTTFT 4kPTFJTBTPQFSBm{FTRVFQPEFNTFSSFBMJ[BEBTDPNBT DMBTTFTJODMVTkPEFVNBDMBTTFFNPVUSB"#SFVOJkPEF WgSJBTDMBTTFT%./JOUFSTFDmkPEFWgSJBTDMBTTFTDPN FMFNFOUPTDPNVOT"#$BEBDMBTTFVOJWFSTBMRVFBCSBO HFUPEPTPTFMFNFOUPTFDVKPTrNCPMPnBEBDMBTTFWB[JB
2VBJTBTQSPQSJFEBEFTDBMDVMgWFJTEBTSFMBm{FT 5SBOTJUJWB EBEPTY ZF[FEBEBTY3ZFZ3[ IgVNBSFMBmkP Y3[ OkPUSBOTJUJWB EBEPTY Z [FEBEBTY3ZFZ3[ OkPTFQP EFUFSY3Z FNCPSBIBKBVNBSFMBmkPFOUSF[FY JOUSBOTJUJWB EBEPTY ZF[FEBEBTY3ZFZ3[ OkPnQPTTrWFMEFUFSNJOBS RVBMTFSJBBSFMBmkPFOUSFYF[ TJNFUSJB Y3ZnPNFTNPRVF Z3Y BTTJNFUSJB RVBOEPTFUFNY3ZOkPTFQPEFUFSZ3Y SFGMF YJWB FTUBCFMFDFTFFOUSFVNBSFMBmkPUSBOTJUJWBFVNBSFMBmkP TJNnUSJDB JSSFGMFYJWB FTUBCFMFDFTFFOUSFSFMBm{FTJOUSBOTJUJWBT FBTTJNnUSJDBT JOWFSTB VNBSFMBmkPnJOWFSTB 4 BVNBPVUSB SFMBmkP 3
RVBOEPQBSBUPEPTPTPCKFUPTY Z F[ WFSJGJDBTFY3Z TF FTPNFOUFTF IPVWFSZ3Y 0RVFnDgMDVMPQSPQPTJDJPOBM cPQSPDFEJNFOUPQFMPRVBMQPEFNPTEFUFSNJOBSBWFSEBEF PVBGBMTJEBEFEFVNBQSPQPTJmkP EFBDPSEPDPNTVBMJHBmkP DPNPVUSBPVPVUSBT FOUFOEFOEPQPSWFSEBEFBWBMJEBEFEB MJHBmkPFQPSGBMTJEBEFBJOWBMJEBEFEBMJHBmkP
5NIDADEßßßßK_kjda_eiajpk #APqTULOß߯ßß=lnak_ql]k_ki k_kjda_eiajpk 2VFRVFSEJ[FSDPTNPMPHJB &POUPMPHJB $PTNPMPHJBnPFTUVEPRVFDBSBDUFSJ[PVBGJMPTPGJBOBTDFO UFRVBOEPPTQSJNFJSPTGJMwTPGPTPDVQBWBNTFDPNBPSJHFNF BPSEFNEPNVOEP PLwTNPT&OUSFUBOUP QPVDPBQPVDP FTTB GJMPTPGJBOBTDFOUFUPSOPVTFVNBPOUPMPHJB PVTFKB QBTTPVTF BJOEBHBSPRVFFSBPQSwQSJPLwTNPT RVBMFSBPQSJODrQJPFUFS OPRVFPSEFOBWBUPEBTBTDPJTBTFRVFQFSNBOFDJBJNVUgWFM TPCBNVMUJQMJDJEBEFFUSBOTGPSNBmkPEFMBT&TTFQSJODrQJP DPO DFCJEPDPNPGVOEPJNQFSFDrWFMQSFTFOUFFNUPEBTBTDPJTBT GB[FOEPBTFYJTUJSUBJTDPNPTkP nP4FS"TTJN QBTTPVTFB QFSHVOUBSPRVFFSBP4FS UxwO TVCKBDFOUFBUPEPTPTTFSFT &NRVF)FSgDMJUPF1BSNpOJEFTEJTDPSEBN &NRVFDPO DPSEBN 1BSB)FSgDMJUP UPEPTPTTFSFTFTUkPFNVNQSPDFTTPEF NVEBOmBQFSQnUVB FNCPSBOPTTBQFSDFQmkPOPTPGFSFmBBT DPJTBTDPNPTFGPTTFNFTUgWFJT1PSJTTP JOEJDBWBBEJGFSFOmB FOUSFPDPOIFDJNFOUPRVFOPTTPTTFOUJEPTOPTPGFSFDFNFPDP OIFDJNFOUPRVFOPTTPQFOTBNFOUPBMDBOmB1BSB1BSNpOJEFT OPTTPTTFOUJEPTnRVFPGFSFDFNBJNBHFNEFVNNVOEPFN JODFTTBOUFNVEBOmB POEFOBEBQFSNBOFDFJEpOUJDPBTJNFT NP POEFUVEPTFUPSOBDPOUSgSJPBTJNFTNP&OUSFUBOUP BNCPT DPODPSEBNRVFQFSDFCFSFQFOTBSTkPDPJTBTEJGFSFOUFT
.0
Manual do Professor
$PNP%FNwDSJUPFYQMJDBBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFQFSDFQmkPFQFO TBNFOUP %FNwDSJUPDPODPSEBWBRVFIgVNBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPRVF DPOIFDFNPTQPSNFJPEFOPTTBQFSDFQmkPFPRVFDPOIFDFNPT BQFOBTQFMPQFOTBNFOUP&OUSFUBOUP QBSBFMF EFBDPSEPDPNB UFPSJBBUPNJTUB UPEPTPTTFSFTTkPDPOTUJUVrEPTQPSQBSUrDVMBT JOEJWJTrWFJT gUPNPT
RVF EFWJEPhTTVBTEJGFSFOmBTFBPTNP EPTEJGFSFOUFTEFDPNCJOBmkPFOUSFTJ QSPEV[FNBWBSJFEBEF EPTTFSFTFEFTFOTBm{FT FNCPSBFNTJNFTNBTOkPUFOIBN RVBMJEBEFOFOIVNBcQPSJTTPRVF%FNwDSJUPOkPDPOTJEFSBWB BQFSDFQmkPJMVTwSJB NBTBQFOBTVNFGFJUPEBSFBMJEBEFTPCSF OwT 2VBMBQPTJmkPEPTTPGJTUBTBSFTQFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP %FBDPSEPDPNPTTPGJTUBT OkPQPEFNPTDPOIFDFSP4FS NBTTwQPEFNPTUFSPQJOJ{FTTVCKFUJWBTTPCSFBSFBMJEBEF1PS JTTP QBSBTFSFMBDJPOBSFNDPNPNVOEPFDPNPTPVUSPTIV NBOPT PTIPNFOTEFWFNWBMFSTFEFVNJOTUSVNFOUP°BMJO HVBHFN°QBSBQFSTVBEJSPTPVUSPTEFTVBTQSwQSJBTJEFJBTF PQJOJ{FT"WFSEBEFnVNBRVFTUkPEFPQJOJkPFEFQFSTVBTkP FBMJOHVBHFNnNBJTJNQPSUBOUFEPRVFBQFSDFQmkPFPQFO TBNFOUP 1PSRVF4wDSBUFTTFPQ{FBPTTPGJTUBT 1PSRVF BPDPOUSgSJPEPTTPGJTUBT 4wDSBUFTBGJSNBRVFB WFSEBEFQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEBFRVFQBSBJTTPnQSFDJTPDPNF mBSBGBTUBOEPBTJMVT{FTEPTTFOUJEPTFEBTQBMBWSBTPVEBT PQJOJ{FT0TTFOUJEPTOPTEkPBTBQBSpODJBTEBTDPJTBTBTQB MBWSBT NFSBTPQJOJ{FTTPCSFFMBTRVFQPEFNWBSJBSEFQFTTPB QBSBQFTTPBFBUnTFDPOUSBEJ[FS1BSB4wDSBUFT DPOIFDFSOkP nBQFOBTQFSTVBEJS NBTUBNCnNFYBNJOBSBTDPOUSBEJm{FTEBT BQBSpODJBTFEBTPQJOJ{FTQBSBQPEFSBCBOEPOgMBTFQBTTBSEB BQBSpODJBhFTTpODJB EBPQJOJkPBPDPODFJUP
0DPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFM DSFOmBFPQJOJkP BMDBOmBBNFSB BQBSpODJBEBTDPJTBT PDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMJHrWFM SBDJPDrOJPF JOUVJmkP BMDBOmBBFTTpODJBEBTDPJTBT BTJEFJBT 2VBJTPTHSBVTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPQBSB"SJTUwUFMFT "SJTUwUFMFTEJTUJOHVFTFUFGPSNBTPVHSBVTEFDPOIFDJNFO UPTFOTBmkP QFSDFQmkP JNBHJOBmkP NFNwSJB SBDJPDrOJP MJO HVBHFNFJOUVJmkP 4FHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT PRVFDPOIFDFNPTFNDBEBHSBVEF DPOIFDJNFOUP $PNPTFEJTUJOHVFNFTFSFMBDJPOBNPT HSBVTEPDPOIFDJNFOUP 4FHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT FNDBEBHSBVTkPPGFSFDJEPTUJQPTEF DPOIFDJNFOUPEJGFSFOUFTRVFWkPGPSNBOEPFFOSJRVFDFOEPP DPOIFDJNFOUPQPSBDVNVMBmkPEBTJOGPSNBm{FTUSB[JEBTQPS UPEPTPTHSBVT&NDBEBVNEFMFTUFNPTBDFTTPBVNBTQFDUP EP4FSPVEBSFBMJEBEF IBWFOEPVNBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFPTTFJT QSJNFJSPTFP|MUJNPHSBV BJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM&TTBTFQBSB mkPEFDPSSFEBEJGFSFOmBEPPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP JTUPn PT TFJTQSJNFJSPTHSBVTDPOIFDFNPCKFUPTRVFTFPGFSFDFNBOwT OBTFOTBmkP OBJNBHJOBmkP OPSBDJPDrOJP FORVBOUPPTnUJNP MJEBDPNQSJODrQJPT JTUPn DPNPRVFTwQPEFTFSBMDBOmBEPQFMP QFOTBNFOUPQVSP0VTFKB OPTPVUSPTHSBVT PDPOIFDJNFOUPn PCUJEPQPSJOEVmkPPVQPSEFEVmkP QPSEFNPOTUSBm{FTFQSP WBT NBTOP|MUJNPHSBVDPOIFDFNPTPRVFnJOEFNPOTUSgWFMF RVFnDPOEJmkPEFUPEBTBTEFNPOTUSBm{FTFSBDJPDrOJPT 4FHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT PRVFDPOIFDFNPTQPSJOUVJmkPJO UFMFDUVBM /BJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBMUFNPTPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPTQSJODrQJPT VOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJPTEPQFOTBNFOUP JEFOUJEBEF OkPDPO USBEJmkP UFSDFJSPFYDMVrEP FEBSFBMJEBEFPVEP4FS TVCTUiODJB RVBMJEBEF RVBOUJEBEF DBVTBMJEBEF GJOBMJEBEF NBUnSJB GPSNB FUD
0RVFTkPBJSPOJBFBNBJpVUJDBTPDSgUJDBT "JSPOJBFSBVNQSPDFEJNFOUPVTBEPQPS4wDSBUFTOPFYBNF EBTPQJOJ{FTFDPNPRVBMFMFDPOTFHVJBRVFTFVTJOUFSMPDVUP SFTSFDPOIFDFTTFNRVFOkPTBCJBNPRVFJNBHJOBWBNTBCFS &NTFHVJEB QPSNFJPEBNBJpVUJDB QBMBWSBHSFHBRVFTJHOJGJDB ²QBSUP³
DPNQFSHVOUBTBEFRVBEBT4wDSBUFTDPOTFHVJBGB[FS RVFTFVTJOUFSMPDVUPSFTDIFHBTTFNBVNBJEFJBWFSEBEFJSBPV hFTTpODJBEBTDPJTBT 2VBJTPTHSBVTEFDPOIFDJNFOUPQBSB1MBUkP 1MBUkPEJTUJOHVFRVBUSPGPSNBTPVHSBVTEFDPOIFDJNFOUP RVFWkPEPHSBVJOGFSJPSBPTVQFSJPSDSFOmB PQJOJkP SBDJPDrOJP FJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM 4FHVOEP1MBUkP PRVFDPOIFDFNPTFNDBEBHSBVEPDP OIFDJNFOUP 0TEPJTQSJNFJSPTHSBVTTkPPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFJNBHFOTF EFWFNTFSBGBTUBEPTEBGJMPTPGJB TkPDPOIFDJNFOUPTJMVTwSJPTPV EBTBQBSpODJBT DPNPPTEPTQSJTJPOFJSPTEBDBWFSOB RVFDPOIF DFNBQFOBTBTJNBHFOTPVBTTPNCSBTEBTDPJTBTSFBJT TPNFO UFPTEPJT|MUJNPTEFWFNTFSDPOTJEFSBEPTWgMJEPT0SBDJPDrOJP USFJOBFFYFSDJUBOPTTPQFOTBNFOUP QVSJGJDBPEBTTFOTBm{FTF PQJOJ{FTFPQSFQBSBQBSBBJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM RVFDPOIFDFBT JEFJBTPVBTFTTpODJBT &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPQMBUyOJDBFOUSFDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFM FDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMJHrWFM
.1
"QSFTFOUFBMHVOTEPTQSJODrQJPTHFSBJTTPCSFPDPOIFDJ NFOUPGPSNVMBEPTQFMPQFOTBNFOUPHSFHP 1SPGFTTPS B SFMBDJPOBNPTBTFHVJSPTQSJODrQJPTHFSBJTEP DPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPGPSNVMBEPTQFMPTGJMwTPGPTHSFHPT $BCFBPBMVOPFTDPMIpMPTFBQSFTFOUgMPT%FUFSNJOBmkPEBT GPOUFTFGPSNBTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTBmkP QFSDFQmkP JNB HJOBmkP NFNwSJB MJOHVBHFN SBDJPDrOJPFJOUVJmkPJOUFMFDUVBM EJTUJOmkPFOUSFPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFMFPDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUF MFDUVBMQBQFMEBMJOHVBHFNOPDPOIFDJNFOUPEJGFSFOmBFOUSF PQJOJkPFTBCFSPVDPOIFDJNFOUPEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBQBSpODJBF FTTpODJBEFGJOJmkPEPTQSJODrQJPTEPQFOTBNFOUPWFSEBEFJ SP JEFOUJEBEF OkPDPOUSBEJmkP UFSDFJSPFYDMVrEP
EBGPSNB EPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP JEFJBT DPODFJUPTFKVr[PT FEPT QSPDFEJNFOUPTQBSBBMDBOmBSPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP JO EVmkP EFEVmkP JOUVJmkP FTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEFQSPDFEJNFOUPT DPSSFUPTFNWJTUBEFDPOIFDJNFOUPTWFSEBEFJSPTEJTUJOmkPEPT DBNQPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFNUSpTSBNPTUFPSnUJDP QSgUJDPF UnDOJDP 2VBJTPTUSpTQSJODJQBJTDBNQPTEPTBCFSGPSNVMBEPTQPS "SJTUwUFMFT 5FPSnUJDPSFGFSFOUFBPTTFSFTRVFBQFOBTQPEFNPTDPO UFNQMBSPVPCTFSWBS TFNBHJSTPCSFFMFTPVOFMFTJOUFSGFSJS 1SgUJDPSFGFSFOUFhTBm{FTIVNBOBTnUJDB QPMrUJDBFFDPOPNJB 5nDOJDPSFGFSFOUFhGBCSJDBmkPFBPUSBCBMIPIVNBOP RVF QPEFJOUFSGFSJSOPDVSTPEBOBUVSF[B DPNPBBHSJDVMUVSBFBNF
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
EJDJOB FDSJBSJOTUSVNFOUPTPVBSUFGBUPT DPNPPTBSUFTBOBUPT BBSRVJUFUVSB BFTDVMUVSB BQPFTJB BSFUwSJDB FUD $PNPPDSJTUJBOJTNPDPODFCFPTTFSFTIVNBOPT %JGFSFOUFNFOUFEBDPODFQmkPEPTGJMwTPGPTBOUJHPT RVF DPOTJEFSBWBNPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFOUFTQBSUJDJQBOUFTEFUPEBT BTGPSNBTEFSFBMJEBEF QBSBPDSJTUJBOJTNPPTFSIVNBOPGPJDSJB EPDPNVNBJOUFMJHpODJBQFSGFJUBFVNBWPOUBEFMJWSF&OUSFUBOUP BUSBWnTEPQSJNFJSPIPNFNFEBQSJNFJSBNVMIFS PTFSIVNBOP JOGSJOHJVBMFJEJWJOBRVFMIFQSPJCJBPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPCFNF EPNBMF QVOJEPQPSJTTP QFSEFVBQFSGFJmkPEBJOUFMJHpODJBF EBWPOUBEF DBJOEPOPFSSPFOBJMVTkPRVFTFUPSOBSBNQBSUFEB OBUVSF[BIVNBOB 2VFQSPCMFNBTOPWPTQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUPGPSBNUSB[JEPT QFMPDSJTUJBOJTNP "PFTUBCFMFDFSBOPmkPEFQFDBEPPSJHJOBM PDSJTUJBOJTNP JOUSPEV[JVBJEFJBEFTFQBSBmkPSBEJDBMFOUSFPTIVNBOPT QFS WFSUJEPTFGJOJUPT FBEJWJOEBEF QFSGFJUBFJOGJOJUB $PNJTTP GF[TVSHJSBQFSHVOUBDPNPPGJOJUP IVNBOP QPEFDPOIFDFSB WFSEBEF JOGJOJUBFEJWJOB
1PSRVFBGnBTTVNJVVNMVHBSUkPJNQPSUBOUFQBSBPDPOIF DJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP 1PSRVFFSBQPSNFJPEBGnRVFPTQSPCMFNBTUSB[JEPTQFMP DSJTUJBOJTNPQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUPFSBNSFTQPOEJEPT$SFSOP 'JMIPEF%FVT FOWJBEPQBSBTBMWBSBIVNBOJEBEF nBTVQSFNB WJSUVEF BGn RVFJMVNJOBOPTTPJOUFMFDUPFHVJBOPTTBWPOUBEF QFSNJUJOEPhSB[kPPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPRVFFTUgBPTFVBMDBODF BPNFTNPUFNQPRVFOPTTBBMNBBDFJUBBTWFSEBEFTTVQFSJP SFT SFWFMBEBTQPS%FVTFDPOUJEBTOBT&TDSJUVSBT4BHSBEBT &YQMJRVFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFWFSEBEFTEFGnFWFSEBEFT EFSB[kP %FBDPSEPDPNBQFSTQFDUJWBDSJTUk BTWFSEBEFTEFGnTkP SFWFMBEBTQPS%FVT JMVNJOBNPJOUFMFDUPIVNBOPFHVJBNB WPOUBEFIVNBOB QFSNJUJOEPhSB[kPPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPRVF FTUgBPTFVBMDBODF"TWFSEBEFTEFSB[kPTkPDBSBDUFSJ[BEBT QFMPFSSPFQFMBJMVTkPF QPSUBOUP TkPTVCPSEJOBEBThTWFSEB EFTEFGn NFTNPRVFOkPEFQFOEBNEBGn &YQMJRVFPRVFPDSJTUJBOJTNPFOUFOEFQPSQFTTPBFBTDPO TFRVpODJBTEFTTBJEFJBQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUP 0DSJTUJBOJTNPFOUFOEFRVFDBEBTFSIVNBOPnVNBQFTTPB SFTQPOTgWFMQPSTFVTBUPTFQFOTBNFOUPT"TTJN DBEBQFTTPB nVNBDPOTDJpODJBEPUBEBEFWPOUBEF JNBHJOBmkP NFNwSJBF JOUFMJHpODJB"WPOUBEFnMJWSFFQPEFNFSHVMIBSOBJMVTkPFOP FSSP&TUBSOPFSSPPVOBWFSEBEFEFQFOEF QPSUBOUP EBWPO UBEFEFDBEBQFTTPB&OUSFUBOUP WBMFOEPTFEFTTBJEFJB PT QSJNFJSPTGJMwTPGPTDSJTUkPTFPTNFEJFWBJTBGJSNBSBNRVFQP EFNPTDPOIFDFSBWFSEBEFEFTEFRVFBSB[kPOkPDPOUSBEJHBB GnFTFTVCNFUBBFMBOPUPDBOUFhTWFSEBEFTQSJODJQBJT 1PSRVFBQFSHVOUBHSFHBTPCSFPDPOIFDJNFOUPFSB²DPNP TkPQPTTrWFJTPFSSPFBJMVTkP³ 1PSRVF QBSBPTHSFHPT BWFSEBEFFSBDPODFCJEBDPNPQSF TFOmBFNBOJGFTUBmkPEPWFSEBEFJSPBPTOPTTPTTFOUJEPTPVBP OPTTPJOUFMFDUP PVTFKB TFPWFSEBEFJSPnPQSwQSJP4FSGB[FO EPTFWFSFNUPEBTDPJTBT QSFTFOUFFNOPTTBTQFSDFQm{FT FN OPTTBTQBMBWSBT FNOPTTPTQFOTBNFOUPT DPNPPGBMTPnQPT TrWFM TFPGBMTPnEJ[FSFQFOTBSRVFFYJTUFPRVFOkPFYJTUF
1PSRVFBQFSHVOUBNPEFSOBTPCSFPDPOIFDJNFOUPn²DPNP PDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPnQPTTrWFM³ 1PSRVF QBSBPTNPEFSOPT PEFTBGJPDPOTJTUFOPFTDMBSF DJNFOUPEFDPNPQPEFNPTDPNQSFFOEFSFFYQMJDBSPRVFTF QBTTBWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFOBSFBMJEBEF EFWJEPhEJGJDVMEBEFEFTF DIFHBShWFSEBEFOPTUFSNPTFNRVFFSBDPOTJEFSBEB PVTFKB WFSEBEFEFGn RVFEFQFOEFEBSFWFMBmkPEJWJOBFTwnDPOIFDJ EBQFMBGn QPSRVFOPTTBSB[kPOkPQPEFFOUFOEpMBFWFSEBEF EFSB[kP RVFUBNCnNOkPQPEFNPTDPOIFDFS WJTUPRVFOPTTP JOUFMFDUPMJNJUBEPGPJQFSWFSUJEPQFMBOPTTBWPOUBEFQFDBEPSB 1PSRVFBBVUPSJEBEFUJOIBQBQFMQSFQPOEFSBOUFOBDPO DFQmkPNFEJFWBMEBWFSEBEF 1PSRVFBWFSEBEFEFQFOEJBEBSFWFMBmkPEJWJOBFBSB[kP FSBTVCPSEJOBEBhGn%FWJEPhJOGMVpODJBEPDSJTUJBOJTNP BDPO DFQmkPNFEJFWBMEBWFSEBEFFSBWJODVMBEBhOPmkPEFSFWFMBmkP EJWJOB TwBMDBOmBEBQPSNFJPEBGn 2VFGJ[FSBNPTGJMwTPGPTNPEFSOPTEJBOUFEPQBQFMEBBV UPSJEBEFOPDPOIFDJNFOUP 3FDVTBSBNPQBQFMEBBVUPSJEBEFOPDPOIFDJNFOUP TFKB BBVUPSJEBEFEB*HSFKB TFKBBEBTFTDPMBTFEPTMJWSPT$PNF mBN QPSJTTP TFQBSBOEPGnEFSB[kP DPOTJEFSBOEPDBEBVNB EFMBTWPMUBEBQBSBDPOIFDJNFOUPTEJGFSFOUFTFTFNRVFVNB EFWBTVCPSEJOBSTFhPVUSB&QSPTTFHVFNGB[FOEPBDSrUJDBEB BVUPSJEBEFBUSJCVrEBhUSBEJmkP BPTMJWSPTEPTBOUJHPTFBPFO TJOBNFOUPEBTFTDPMBT 1PSRVFPTGJMwTPGPTNPEFSOPTDPNFmBNQFMBUFPSJBEPDP OIFDJNFOUP 1PSRVFFMFTRVFSJBNDPNQSFFOEFSFFYQMJDBS²DPNPBWFS EBEFnQPTTrWFM³0QSPCMFNBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPUPSOBTF BTTJN DSVDJBM FQBSBFMVDJEgMPBGJMPTPGJBQSFDJTBDPNFmBSQFMPFYB NFEBDBQBDJEBEFIVNBOBEFDPOIFDFS QFMPFOUFOEJNFOUP 0TEPJTGJMwTPGPTRVFJOJDJBNFTTFUSBCBMIPTkPPJOHMpT'SBODJT #BDPOFPGSBODpT3FOn%FTDBSUFT 4FHVOEP'SBODJT#BDPO RVBJTTkPFPRVFTkPPTrEPMPT %FBDPSEPDPN#BDPO rEPMPTTkPJNBHFOTRVFGPSNBN PQJOJ{FTDSJTUBMJ[BEBTFQSFDPODFJUPTRVFJNQFEFNPDPOIFDJ NFOUPEBWFSEBEF4kPEFRVBUSPUJQPTrEPMPTEBDBWFSOB BT PQJOJ{FTRVFTFGPSNBNFNOwTQPSFSSPTFEFGFJUPTEFOPTTPT wSHkPTEPTTFOUJEPT rEPMPTEPGwSVN BTPQJOJ{FTRVFTFGPS NBNFNOwTDPNPDPOTFRVpODJBEBMJOHVBHFNFEFOPTTBTSF MBm{FTDPNPTPVUSPT rEPMPTEPUFBUSP TkPBTPQJOJ{FTGPSNB EBTFNOwTFNEFDPSSpODJBEPTQPEFSFTEBTBVUPSJEBEFTRVF OPTJNQ{FNTFVTQPOUPTEFWJTUBFPTUSBOTGPSNBNFNEFDSFUPT FMFJTJORVFTUJPOgWFJT rEPMPTEBUSJCP TkPBTPQJOJ{FTRVFTF GPSNBNFNOwTFNEFDPSSpODJBEBOBUVSF[BIVNBOB 1BSB#BDPO RVBJTBTQSJODJQBJTGJOBMJEBEFTEPNnUPEP 0SHBOJ[BSFDPOUSPMBSPTEBEPTSFDFCJEPTEBFYQFSJpODJB TFOTrWFM HSBmBTBQSPDFEJNFOUPTBEFRVBEPTEFPCTFSWBmkPF FYQFSJNFOUBmkPPSHBOJ[BSFDPOUSPMBSPTSFTVMUBEPTQBSBDIF HBSBPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTOPWPTPVhGPSNVMBmkPEFUFPSJBTWFS EBEFJSBTEFTFOWPMWFSQSPDFEJNFOUPTBEFRVBEPThBQMJDBmkP QSgUJDBEPTSFTVMUBEPTUFwSJDPT0NnUPEP EJ[#BDPO nPNPEP TFHVSPFDFSUPEF²BQMJDBSBSB[kPhFYQFSJpODJB³ 4FHVOEP%FTDBSUFT RVBJTPTEPJTQSJODJQBJTQSFDPODFJUPT RVFJNQFEFNPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP
.2
Manual do Professor
"QSFWFOmkP RVFnBGBDJMJEBEFDPNRVFOPTTPFTQrSJUPTF EFJYBMFWBSQFMBTPQJOJ{FTFJEFJBTBMIFJBT TFNTFQSFPDVQBS FNWFSJGJDBSTFTkPPVOkPWFSEBEFJSBT DSJTUBMJ[BOEPTFFN OPTTPQFOTBNFOUP JNQFEJOEPOPTEFQFOTBSFJOWFTUJHBSFB QSFDJQJUBmkP RVFnBGBDJMJEBEFFBWFMPDJEBEFDPNRVFOPTTB WPOUBEFOPTGB[FNJUJSKVr[PTTPCSFBTDPJTBTBOUFTEFWFSJGJDBS NPTTFOPTTBTJEFJBTTkPPVOkPTkPWFSEBEFJSBT 1PSRVF%FTDBSUFTKVMHBPNnUPEPOFDFTTgSJP 1PSRVF GFJUBTBTDSrUJDBThBVUPSJEBEFEBTFTDPMBTFEPT MJWSPT EBUSBEJmkPFEPTQSFDPODFJUPTJOGBOUJT PTVKFJUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUPEFTDPCSFTFDPNPVNBDPOTDJpODJBRVFQBSFDFOkP QPEFSDPOUBSDPNPBVYrMJPEPNVOEPQBSBHVJgMP EFTDPOGJBEPT DPOIFDJNFOUPTTFOTrWFJTFEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTIFSEBEPT&TUg Tw$POUBBQFOBTDPNTFVQSwQSJPQFOTBNFOUP4VBTPMJEkPUPS OBJOEJTQFOTgWFMVNNnUPEPRVFQPTTBHVJBSPQFOTBNFOUPFN EJSFmkPBPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTWFSEBEFJSPTFEJTUJOHVJMPTEPTGBM TPT 0RVF%FTDBSUFTFOUFOEFQPSNnUPEP 2VBJTBTUSpTDBSBD UFSrTUJDBTQSJODJQBJTEBTSFHSBTEPNnUPEP %FTDBSUFTFOUFOEFQPSNnUPEPSFHSBTDFSUBTFGgDFJTHSBmBT hTRVBJTUPEPTPTRVFBTPCTFSWFNKBNBJTUPNBSkPDPNPWFSEB EFJSPBRVJMPRVFnGBMTPFDIFHBSkP TFNTFDBOTBSDPNFTGPSmPT JO|UFJTFBVNFOUBOEPQSPHSFTTJWBNFOUFTVBDJpODJB BPDPOIF DJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPEFUVEPPRVFMIFTnQPTTrWFMFTQFSBS 2VBJTPTPCKFUJWPTEPNnUPEPDBSUFTJBOP "TTFHVSBSBSFGPSNBEPJOUFMFDUPQBSBRVFFTUFTJHBPDB NJOIPTFHVSPEBWFSEBEFPGFSFDFSQSPDFEJNFOUPTQFMPTRVBJT BSB[kPQPTTBDPOUSPMBSTFBTJNFTNBEVSBOUFPQSPDFTTPEF DPOIFDJNFOUP TBCFOEPRVFDBNJOIPQFSDPSSFSFTBCFOEPSF DPOIFDFSTFVNSFTVMUBEPPCUJEPnWFSEBEFJSPPVOkPQFSNJUJS BBNQMJBmkPPVPBVNFOUPEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPT HSBmBTBQSP DFEJNFOUPTTFHVSPTRVFQFSNJUBNQBTTBSEPKgDPOIFDJEPBP EFTDPOIFDJEPPGFSFDFSPTNFJPTQBSBRVFPTOPWPTDPOIFDJ NFOUPTQPTTBNTFSBQMJDBEPT 2VBJTTkPBTSFHSBTEPNnUPEPDBSUFTJBOP 3FHSBEBFWJEpODJBTwBENJUJSDPNPWFSEBEFJSPVNDPOIF DJNFOUPFWJEFOUF JTUPn OPRVBMFTPCSFPRVBMOkPDBJCBB NFOPSE|WJEBSFHSBEBEJWJTkPQBSBDPOIFDFSNPTSFBMJEBEFT DPNQMFYBTQSFDJTBNPTEJWJEJSBTEJGJDVMEBEFTFPTQSPCMFNBT FNTVBTQBSDFMBTNBJTTJNQMFT FYBNJOBOEPDBEBVNBEFMBT FNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNBSFHSBEBFWJEpODJBSFHSBEBPSEFNPT QFOTBNFOUPTEFWFNTFSPSEFOBEPTFNTnSJFTRVFWkPEPTNBJT TJNQMFTBPTNBJTDPNQMFYPT EPTNBJTGgDFJTBPTNBJTEJGrDFJT QPJTBPSEFNDPOTJTUFFNEJTUSJCVJSPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTEFUBM NBOFJSBRVFQPTTBNPTQBTTBSEPDPOIFDJEPBPEFTDPOIFDJEP SFHSBEBFOVNFSBmkPBDBEBDPOIFDJNFOUPOPWPPCUJEP GB[FS BSFWJTkPDPNQMFUBEPTQBTTPTEBEPT EPTSFTVMUBEPTQBSDJBJT FEPTFODBEFBNFOUPTRVFQFSNJUJSBNDIFHBSBPOPWPDPOIF DJNFOUP 2VFnBE|WJEBNFUwEJDB %|WJEBNFUwEJDBnBEFDJTkPEFOkPBDFJUBSOFOIVNQFO TBNFOUPPVOFOIVNBJEFJBFNRVFQPTTBIBWFSBNFOPSE|WJ EB1PSNFJPEFTTFQSPDFEJNFOUP PTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP BOBMJTBOEPDBEBVNEFTFVTDPOIFDJNFOUPT DPOIFDFFBWBMJB BTGPOUFTFBTDBVTBTEFDBEBVN BGPSNBFPDPOUF|EPEFDBEB VN BGBMTJEBEFFBWFSEBEFEFDBEBVNFFODPOUSBNFJPTQBSB MJWSBSTFEFUVEPRVBOUPTFKBEVWJEPTPQFSBOUFPQFOTBNFOUP
.3
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSF%FTDBSUFTF-PDLF $PNP1MBUkP %FTDBSUFTBGBTUBBFYQFSJpODJBTFOTrWFMPVP DPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFMEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP DPODFCJ EPDPNPQVSBNFOUFJOUFMFDUVBM"PDPOUSgSJP DPNP"SJTUwUFMFT -PDLFDPOTJEFSBRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFSFBMJ[BQPSHSBVTDPOUr OVPT QBSUJOEPEBTFOTBmkPBUnDIFHBShTJEFJBT 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSF-PDLFF"SJTUwUFMFT 1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT PTQSJODrQJPTEPQFOTBNFOUPFEBSFBMJEB EFOkPTkPDPOIFDJEPTQPSFYQFSJpODJBOFNQSPDFEFNEBFYQF SJpODJB NBTTkPDPOIFDJEPTBQFOBTQFMPQVSPQFOTBNFOUP1B SB-PDLF UPEBTBTJEFJBTFUPEPTPTQSJODrQJPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUP EFSJWBNEBFYQFSJpODJBTFOTrWFM&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT PJOUFMFDUP SFDFCFEBFYQFSJpODJBUPEPPNBUFSJBMEPDPOIFDJNFOUP $PNP-PDLFFYQMJDBBGPSNBmkPEBTJEFJBT 1FMBTTFOTBm{FT SFDFCFNPTBTJNQSFTT{FTEBTDPJTBTFY UFSOBT PVPRVF-PDLFDIBNBEFJEFJBTTJNQMFT&TTBTJNQSFT T{FTPVJEFJBTTJNQMFTTFBTTPDJBNQPSTFNFMIBOmBTFEJGFSFO mBTOBTQFSDFQm{FT GPSNBOEPJEFJBTDPNQMFYBTPVDPNQPTUBT &TTBTJEFJBTTFUPSOBSkPJEFJBTNBJTDPNQMFYBTOBSB[kP RVF GPSNBJEFJBTDPNPBTEFTVCTUiODJB DPSQP BMNB %FVT OBUV SF[B FUD CFNDPNPJEFJBTEFSFMBm{FTFOUSFFTTBTJEFJBTDPN QMFYBT DPNPBTJEFJBTEFJEFOUJEBEF DBVTBMJEBEF GJOBMJEBEF FUD*TTPnVNQSPDFTTPEFBCTUSBmkPQFMPRVBM BDBEBQBTTP FMJNJOBNPTBTEJGFSFOmBTQBSBGJDBSDPNBTTFNFMIBOmBTFPT USBmPTDPNVOT DVKPDPOKVOUPGPSNBVNBJEFJBDPNQMFYBPVVOJ WFSTBM 1PSRVF-PDLFnVNFNQJSJTUB 1PSRVFDPODFCFPDPOIFDJNFOUPDPNPQSPEVUPEBFYQF SJpODJBTFOTrWFM PVTFKB BQBSUJSEBTTFOTBm{FT GPSNBNPTQFS DFQm{FTSBDJPOBJTRVF TFQBSBEBT BTTPDJBEBTPVDPNCJOBEBT GPSNBNBTJEFJBTRVFUFNPTEBTDPJTBT 1PSRVF-PDLFnVNOPNJOBMJTUB 1PSRVF TFHVOEPTVBTJEFJBT WJTUPRVFBFYQFSJpODJBOPT NPTUSBFOPTEgBQFOBTDPJTBTQBSUJDVMBSFTPVTJOHVMBSFT TP NFOUFFMBTFYJTUFN1BSB-PDLF BTJEFJBTHFSBJTPVVOJWFSTBJT OkPDPSSFTQPOEFNBSFBMJEBEFTPVBFTTpODJBTFYJTUFOUFT NBT TkPOPNFTRVFJOTUJUVrNPTQPSDPOWFOmkPQBSBPSHBOJ[BSOPT TPTQFOTBNFOUPTFOPTTPTEJTDVSTPT 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBQSJODJQBMFOUSFFNQJSJTNPFSBDJPOBMJT NP 1BSBPSBDJPOBMJTNP BGPOUFEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP nBSB[kPPQFSBOEPQPSTJNFTNB TFNPBVYrMJPEBFYQFSJpODJB TFOTrWFMFDPOUSPMBOEPBQSwQSJBFYQFSJpODJBTFOTrWFM1BSBP FNQJSJTNP BGPOUFEFUPEPFRVBMRVFSDPOIFDJNFOUPnBFYQF SJpODJBTFOTrWFM SFTQPOTgWFMQFMBTJEFJBTEBSB[kPFDPOUSPMBO EPPUSBCBMIPEBQSwQSJBSB[kP 0RVFnBDPOTDJpODJBEFTJSFGMFYJWBPVPTVKFJUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUP cPTVKFJUPRVFTFSFDPOIFDFDPNPEJGFSFOUFEPTPCKFUPT RVFDSJBFPVEFTDPCSFTJHOJGJDBm{FT JOTUJUVJTFOUJEPT FMBCPSB DPODFJUPT JEFJBT KVr[PTFUFPSJBT"MnNEJTTP PTVKFJUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUPnVNBDPOTDJpODJBEFTJSFGMFYJWBQPSRVFnEPUBEP EFDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOIFDFSTFBTJNFTNPOPBUPEPDPOIFDJ NFOUP PVTFKB nDBQB[EFSFGMFYkP
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
0RVFnBDPOTDJpODJBEFTJDPNPDPOTDJpODJBQTJDPMwHJ DB cPTFOUJNFOUPEFOPTTBQSwQSJBJEFOUJEBEFnPFV BRVFMB QFSDFQmkPJOEJWJEVBMRVFQFSNJUFBBMHVnNEJ[FS²NFVDPSQP³ ²NJOIBSB[kP³ ²NJOIBTMFNCSBOmBT³FRVFnGPSNBEBQPSOPT TBTWJWpODJBT JTUPn BNBOFJSBJOEJWJEVBMFQSwQSJBDPNRVF DBEBVNEFOwTQFSDFCF JNBHJOB MFNCSB PQJOB EFTFKB BHF BNBFPEFJB TFOUFQSB[FSFEPS UPNBQPTJmkPEJBOUFEBTDPJTBT FEPTPVUSPT EFDJEF TFOUFTFGFMJ[PVJOGFMJ[ 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFPFV QTJDPMwHJDP "PDPOUSgSJPEPFV PTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPOkPnVNB FYQFSJpODJBJOEJWJEVBM NBTBTQJSBhVOJWFSTBMJEBEF PVTFKB hDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOIFDJNFOUPRVFTFKBJEpOUJDBFNUPEPTPT TFSFTIVNBOPTFDPNWBMJEBEFQBSBUPEPTPTTFSFTIVNBOPT FNUPEPTPTUFNQPTFMVHBSFT%FTTBNBOFJSB FORVBOUPPFV QTJDPMwHJDPnDBSBDUFSJ[BEPQFMBNBOFJSBQSwQSJBDPNPDBEBVN JNBHJOB TFOUF EFTFKB FUD PTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPnDB SBDUFSJ[BEPTFHVOEPMFJT OPSNBT QSJODrQJPTEFFTUSVUVSBmkPF PSHBOJ[BmkPRVFTkPPTNFTNPTQBSBUPEPTPTTVKFJUPTQFSDF CFEPSFT
"MnNEPTFYFNQMPTEBEPT QPEFNPTBDSFTDFOUBSBTJUVBmkP OBRVBMUFNPTBJNQSFTTkPEFKgDPOIFDFSPMVHBSFNRVFFTUB NPTQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[ PVPDBTPEBDSJBOmBRVFGB[VNFTDiOEB MPEJBOUFEFVNBWJUSJOFDPNVNCSJORVFEPDBSrTTJNPRVFEFTFKB JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBDPOEJmkPGJOBODFJSBEPTQBJT DPOTDJpO DJBQBTTJWB POBNPSBEPRVFQFEFEFWPMUBPTQSFTFOUFTEBEPT hOBNPSBEBRVBOEPUFSNJOBPSFMBDJPOBNFOUP DPOTDJpODJBWJWJ EB NBTOkPSFGMFYJWB BQFTTPBRVFSFDPOIFDFRVF²OPNVOEP IgEJOIFJSPTVGJDJFOUFQBSBBUFOEFShOFDFTTJEBEFEFNVJUPT NBTOkPIgEJOIFJSPTVGJDJFOUFQBSBTBUJTGB[FSPJOUFSFTTFEF QPVDPT³°(BOEIJ DPOTDJpODJBBUJWBFSFGMFYJWB %FBDPSEPDPNBGFOPNFOPMPHJB PRVFnBJOUFODJPOBMJEB EFEBDPOTDJpODJB "JOUFODJPOBMJEBEFEBDPOTDJpODJBTkPPTDPOUF|EPTPVTJH OJGJDBm{FTWJTBEPTQFMPTBUPTRVFBDPOTDJpODJBSFBMJ[B QFSDF CFS MFNCSBS JNBHJOBS GBMBS SFGMFUJS QFOTBS /FTTFTFOUJEP UPEBDPOTDJpODJB EJ[BGFOPNFOPMPHJB nTFNQSFDPOTDJpODJBEF BMHVNBDPJTB WJTBTFNQSFBBMHP EFUBMNBOFJSBRVFQFSDFCFS nTFNQSFQFSDFCFSBMHVNBDPJTB JNBHJOBSnTFNQSFJNBHJOBS BMHVNBDPJTB MFNCSBSnTFNQSFMFNCSBSBMHVNBDPJTB EJ[FSn TFNQSFEJ[FSBMHVNBDPJTB QFOTBSnTFNQSFQFOTBSBMHVNB DPJTB
0RVFnBDPOTDJpODJBEFTJNPSBMPVnUJDB cBFTQPOUBOFJEBEFMJWSFFSBDJPOBMQBSBFTDPMIFS EFMJCFSBS FBHJSFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNBMJCFSEBEF PTEJSFJUPTBMIFJPTFP EFWFScBQFTTPBEPUBEBEFWPOUBEFMJWSFFEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEB EFcBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBDPNQSFFOEFSFJOUFSQSFUBSTVBTJUVBmkP FTVBDPOEJmkP GrTJDB NFOUBM TPDJBM DVMUVSBM IJTUwSJDB
WJWFS OBDPNQBOIJBEFPVUSPTTFHVOEPBTOPSNBTFPTWBMPSFTNPSBJT EFGJOJEPTQPSTVBTPDJFEBEF BHJSUFOEPFNWJTUBGJOTFTDPMIJ EPTQPSEFMJCFSBmkPFEFDJTkP SFBMJ[BSBTWJSUVEFTF RVBOEP OFDFTTgSJP DPOUSBQPSTFFPQPSTFBPTWBMPSFTFTUBCFMFDJEPT FNOPNFEFPVUSPTDPOTJEFSBEPTNBJTBEFRVBEPThMJCFSEBEF FhSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF 0RVFnBDPOTDJpODJBEFTJQPMrUJDB cPDJEBEkP PJOEJWrEVPTJUVBEPOPUFDJEPEBTSFMBm{FTTP DJBJTDPNPQPSUBEPSEFEJSFJUPTFEFWFSFTEFGJOJEPTOBFTGFSB Q|CMJDB SFMBDJPOBOEPTFDPNPQPEFSQPMrUJDPFBTMFJT 2VBJTTkPPTHSBVTEBDPOTDJpODJB $POTDJpODJBQBTTJWBBRVFMBOBRVBMUFNPTVNBWBHBF DPOGVTBQFSDFQmkPEFOwTNFTNPTFEPRVFTFQBTTBhOPTTB WPMUB DPNPOPEFWBOFJP OPEFTQFSUBS OBBOFTUFTJBPVRVBO EPTPNPTNVJUPDSJBOmBTPVNVJUPJEPTPTDPOTDJpODJBWJWJEB NBTOkPSFGMFYJWBnOPTTBDPOTDJpODJBBGFUJWB RVFUFNBQFDV MJBSJEBEFEFTFSFHPDpOUSJDB JTUPn EFQFSDFCFSPTPVUSPTFBT DPJTBTCBTFBEPTBQFOBTFNOPTTPTTFOUJNFOUPTDPNSFMBmkP BFMFTUrQJDP QPSFYFNQMP EBTQFTTPBTBQBJYPOBEBTQBSBBT RVBJTPNVOEPTwFYJTUFBQBSUJSEPTTFVTTFOUJNFOUPTEFBNPS wEJP DwMFSB BMFHSJB USJTUF[B FUDDPOTDJpODJBBUJWBFSFGMFYJWB BRVFMBRVFSFDPOIFDFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPJOUFSJPSFPFYUFSJPS FOUSFTJFPTPVUSPT FOUSFTJFBTDPJTBT±FTTFHSBVEFDPOT DJpODJBnPRVFQFSNJUFBFYJTUpODJBEBDPOTDJpODJBFNTVBT RVBUSPNPEBMJEBEFT JTUPn FV QFTTPB DJEBEkPFTVKFJUP %pFYFNQMPTEFEJGFSFOUFTHSBVTEFDPOTDJpODJB 1SPGFTTPS B PTFYFNQMPTEBEPTQFMPTBMVOPTQPEFNTFS CFNWBSJBEPT0JNQPSUBOUFnRVFIBKBVNBEJTUJOmkPCBTFBEB OPTDPODFJUPTEFHSBVTEFDPOTDJpODJBBQSFTFOUBEPT
#APqTULOß߯ßß=lan_alk 2VFnBTFOTBmkP "TFOTBmkPnPRVFOPTEgBTRVBMJEBEFTFYUFSJPSFTFJOUF SJPSFT JTUPn BTRVBMJEBEFTEPTPCKFUPTFPTFGFJUPTJOUFSOPT EFTTBTRVBMJEBEFTTPCSFOwT/BTTFOTBm{FTWFNPT UPDBNPT TFOUJNPT PVWJNPTRVBMJEBEFTQVSBTFEJSFUBTEBTDPJTBTDP SFT PEPSFT TBCPSFT UFYUVSBT TPOT UFNQFSBUVSBT4FOUJNPTP RVFOUFFPGSJP PEPDFFPBNBSHP PMJTPFPSVHPTP PWFSNFMIP FPWFSEF FUD4FOUJNPTUBNCnNRVBMJEBEFTJOUFSOBT JTUPn RVFTFQBTTBNFNOPTTPDPSQPPVFNOPTTBNFOUFQSB[FS EFTQSB[FS EPS BHSBEP EFTBHSBEP 1PSRVFBTFOTBmkPnBNCrHVB 1PSRVFPTFOTrWFMn BPNFTNPUFNQP BRVBMJEBEFRVFFT UgOPPCKFUPFYUFSOPFPTFOUJNFOUPJOUFSOPRVFOPTTPDPSQP QPTTVJEBTRVBMJEBEFTTFOUJEBT TFNRVFTFKBQPTTrWFMEJTUJO HVJS OPBUPEBTFOTBmkP PFTUrNVMPFYUFSJPSFPTFOUJNFOUP JOUFSJPS 1PSRVFTFEJ[RVFBQFSDFQmkPnTrOUFTFEFNVJUBTTFOTB m{FTTJNVMUiOFBT 1PSRVF BPTFOUJSNPTBTRVBMJEBEFTEBTDPJTBT OkPPGB [FNPTTFQBSBEBNFOUF NBTTFOUJNPTUPEBTBPNFTNPUFNQP .FTNPRVFGBmBNPTSFGFSpODJBBBQFOBTVNBRVBMJEBEF gHVB RVFOUF DnVB[VM BMJNFOUPBNBSHP
KVOUBNFOUFDPNFTTBTFO TBmkPUFNPTPVUSBT/BSFBMJEBEF TwUFNPTTFOTBm{FTOBGPSNB EFQFSDFQm{FT JTUPn EFTrOUFTFTEFWgSJBTTFOTBm{FT $PNPPTFNQJSJTUBTFYQMJDBNBTFOTBmkP 1BSBPTFNQJSJTUBT BTFOTBmkPEFQFOEFEBTDPJTBTFYUFSJP SFT JTUPn nDBVTBEBQPSFTUrNVMPTFYUFSOPTRVFBPUPDBSVN EPTwSHkPTEPTTFOUJEPTGB[VNQFSDVSTPOPJOUFSJPSEFOPTTP DPSQP JOEPBPDnSFCSPFWPMUBOEPhTFYUSFNJEBEFTTFOTPSJBJT %FTTBGPSNB QPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFBTFOTBmkPnVNFGFJUPQBTTJ WPEFVNBBUJWJEBEFEPTDPSQPTFYUFSJPSFTTPCSFPOPTTPDPSQP " MnNEJTTP DBEBTFOTBmkPnJOEFQFOEFOUFEBTPVUSBT DBCFO
.4
Manual do Professor
EPhQFSDFQmkPVOJGJDgMBTFPSHBOJ[gMBTOVNBTrOUFTF%FTTBT QFSDFQm{FTnRVFQSPWpNBTJEFJBT $PNPPTJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBTFYQMJDBNBTFOTBmkP 1BSBPTJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBT BTFOTBmkPFBQFSDFQmkPEFQFO EFNEPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFBDPJTBFYUFSJPSnBQFOBTB PDBTJkPQBSBRVFUFOIBNPTBTFOTBmkPPVBQFSDFQmkP/FTTF DBTP PTVKFJUPnBUJWPFBDPJTBFYUFSOBnQBTTJWB PVTFKB TFO UJSFQFSDFCFSTkPGFOyNFOPTRVFEFQFOEFNEBDBQBDJEBEFEP TVKFJUPQBSBEFDPNQPSVNPCKFUPFNTVBTRVBMJEBEFTTJNQMFT BTFOTBmkP FEFSFDPNQyMPDPNPVNUPEP EBOEPMIFPSHB OJ[BmkPFTJHOJGJDBmkP BQFSDFQmkP 2VBJTBTDSrUJDBTRVFBQTJDPMPHJBEBGPSNBFBGFOPNFOP MPHJBGJ[FSBNBFNQJSJTUBTFJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBTOPUPDBOUFh TFOTBmkPFhQFSDFQmkP $POUSBPFNQJSJTNP EJTTFSBNRVFBTFOTBmkPOkPnVNB SFTQPTUBGrTJDPGJTJPMwHJDBQPOUVBMBVNFTUrNVMPFYUFSOPUBN CnNQPOUVBM&MBOkPnVNSFGMFYPQPOUVBMDPOUSBPJOUFMFDUVB MJTNP EJTTFSBNRVFBQFSDFQmkPOkPnVNBBUJWJEBEFEFTrOUF TFEBTTFOTBm{FTSFBMJ[BEBTQFMPQFOTBNFOUPDPOUSBBNCPT EJTTFSBNRVFOkPIgEJGFSFOmBFOUSFTFOTBmkPFQFSDFQmkP $PNPBHFTUBMUFBGFOPNFOPMPHJBFYQMJDBNBTFOTBmkPFB QFSDFQmkP .PTUSBNRVFOkPIgEJGFSFOmBFOUSFTFOTBmkPFQFSDFQmkP PJTOVODBUFNPTTFOTBm{FTQBSDJBJT QPOUVBJTPVFMFNFOUB Q SFT JTUPn TFOTBm{FTTFQBSBEBTEFDBEBRVBMJEBEFRVFEFQPJT PFTQrSJUPKVOUBSJBFPSHBOJ[BSJBDPNPQFSDFQmkPEFVN|OJDP PCKFUP4FOUJNPTFQFSDFCFNPTGPSNBT JTUPn UPUBMJEBEFTFT USVUVSBEBTEPUBEBTEFTFOUJEPPVEFTJHOJGJDBmkP 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBQFSDFQmkP cPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTPSJBMEFGPSNBTPVEFUPUBMJEBEFT PSHBOJ[BEBTFEPUBEBTEFTFOUJEP FOkPVNBTPNBEFTFOTB m{FTFMFNFOUBSFTQFSDFQmkPFTFOTBmkPTkPBNFTNBDPJ TBnPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFVNTVKFJUPDPSQPSBMBMnNEPPCKFUP QFSDFCJEPnTFNQSFVNBFYQFSJpODJBEPUBEBEFTJHOJGJDBmkP FNOPTTBIJTUwSJBEFWJEBBTGPSNBTFTFOUJEPTEPNVOEP TkPJOTFQBSgWFJTEPTVKFJUPEBQFSDFQmkPnVNBSFMBmkPEP TVKFJUPDPNPNVOEPFYUFSJPSPNVOEPQFSDFCJEPnRVBMJUB UJWP TJHOJGJDBUJWP FTUSVUVSBEPFFTUBNPTOFMFDPNPTVKFJUPT BUJWPT JTUPn EBNPThTDPJTBTQFSDFCJEBTOPWPTTFOUJEPTF OPWPTWBMPSFTPNVOEPQFSDFCJEPnVNNVOEPJOUFSDPSQPSBM PVTFKB BTSFMBm{FTTFFTUBCFMFDFNFOUSFOPTTPDPSQP PTDPS QPTEPTPVUSPTTVKFJUPTFPTDPSQPTEBTDPJTBTBQFSDFQmkP EFQFOEFEBTDPJTBTFEFOPTTPDPSQPFOWPMWFUPEPPOPTTP TFSFOWPMWFOPTTBWJEBTPDJBMOPTPSJFOUBQBSBBBmkPDPUJEJB OBFQBSBBTBm{FTUnDOJDBTNBJTTJNQMFTnVNBNBOFJSBEF UFSJEFJBTTFOTrWFJTPVTJHOJGJDBm{FTQFSDFQUJWBTFTUgTVKFJUB BPFSSPEFWJEPhJMVTkP &TDPMIBBMHVNBTEBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBQFSDFQmkPFFYQMJ RVFBT 1SPGFTTPS B DBEBBMVOPQPEFSgFTDPMIFSRVBJTRVFSEBT DBSBDUFSrTUJDBTBQSFTFOUBEBTFFYQMJDgMBT0NBJTJNQPSUBOUFn OPUBSRVFOkPIgEJGFSFOmBFOUSFTFOTBmkPFQFSDFQmkP PVTFKB TFOUJNPTFQFSDFCFNPTGPSNBT QFSGJTPVQFSTQFDUJWBT JTUPn UPUBMJEBEFTFTUSVUVSBEBT TVKFJUPPCKFUP JOUFSJPSFYUFSJPS DPS QPNVOEP EPUBEBTEFTFOUJEPPVEFTJHOJGJDBmkP
.5
2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVF²IgVN´NVOEPQFSDFCJEPμ RVFUF NPTJEFJBTTFOTrWFJTPVTJHOJGJDBm{FTQFSDFQUJWBT³ $PNBGFOPNFOPMPHJBFBQTJDPMPHJBEBGPSNB BDPODFQmkP EPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFMQBTTPVBTFCBTFBSOPQSFTTVQPTUP EFRVFOkPIgEJGFSFOmBFOUSFTFOTBmkPFQFSDFQmkP*TUPTJH OJGJDBRVF OBQFSDFQmkP PNVOEPQPTTVJGPSNBFTFOUJEPF BNCPTTkPJOTFQBSgWFJTEPTVKFJUPEBQFSDFQmkPIgVN²NVO EPQFSDFCJEP³QFMBSFMBmkPEPTVKFJUPDPNPNVOEPFYUFSJPS &TTBSFMBmkPEgTFOUJEPBPQFSDFCJEP NVOEP FBPQFSDFCFEPS TVKFJUP
FVNOkPFYJTUFTFNPPVUSPcBQBSUJSEFTTBSFMBmkP RVFUFNPTJEFJBTTFOTrWFJTPVTJHOJGJDBm{FTQFSDFQUJWBT PVTF KB VNBDPNVOJDBmkP VNBJOUFSQSFUBmkPFVNBWBMPSBmkPEP NVOEPBQBSUJSEBFTUSVUVSBEFSFMBm{FTFOUSFOwTFBTDPJTBT FOUSFOPTTPDPSQPFPNVOEP %PQPOUPEFWJTUBEBUFPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP RVBJTTkPBT QSJODJQBJTUFPSJBTTPCSFBQFSDFQmkP 5FPSJBFNQJSJTUBBQFSDFQmkPnB|OJDBGPOUFEFDPOIF DJNFOUP FTUBOEPOBPSJHFNEBTJEFJBTGPSNVMBEBTQFMPQFO TBNFOUPOVNQSPDFTTPEFBCTUSBmkPRVFFYDMVJBTEJGFSFOmBT QFSDFCJEBTFSF|OFBTTFNFMIBOmBTFOUSFWgSJBTTFOTBm{FTF QFSDFQm{FTUFPSJBSBDJPOBMJTUBJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBBQFSDFQmkPn DPOTJEFSBEBOkPNVJUPDPOGJgWFMQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUPQPSRVF EFQFOEFEBTDPOEJm{FTQBSUJDVMBSFTEFRVFNQFSDFCFFFTUg QSPQFOTBBJMVT{FTUFPSJBGFOPNFOPMwHJDBBQFSDFQmkPnDPO TJEFSBEBPSJHJOgSJBFQBSUFQSJODJQBMEPDPOIFDJNFOUPIVNBOP NBTEJGFSFOUFEFVNBJEFJBPVEFVNQFOTBNFOUP 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFQFSDFQmkPFQFOTBNFOUP "QFSDFQmkPTFNQSFTFSFBMJ[BQPSQFSGJTPVQFSTQFDUJWBT JTUPn OVODBQPEFNPTQFSDFCFSEFVNBTwWF[VNPCKFUP QPJT TPNFOUFQFSDFCFNPTBMHVNBTEFTVBTGBDFTEFDBEBWF[P QFOTBNFOUPPQFSBDPNJEFJBTOPTTPJOUFMFDUPDPNQSFFOEF VNBJEFJBEFVNBTwWF[FQPSJOUFJSP JTUPn DBQUBNPTBUP UBMJEBEFEPTFOUJEPEFVNBJEFJBEFVNBTwWF[ TFNQSFDJTBS FYBNJOBSDBEBVNBEFTVBT²GBDFT³&OUSFUBOUP QPEFNPTEJ[FS RVFBQFSDFQmkPnEJGFSFOUFEPQFOTBNFOUP NBTOkPJOGFSJPS BFMF
#APqTULOß߯ßß=ei]cej]k $PNPPTFNQJSJTUBTDPODFCFNBJNBHJOBmkP $PNPVNSFGMFYPNFOUBMEBTQFSDFQm{FTPVEBTJNQSFT T{FT DVKPTUSBmPTGPSBNHSBWBEPTOPDnSFCSP"JNBHFNTFSJB QPSUBOUP BSFQSPEVmkPQSFTFOUFRVFGBmPEFDPJTBTPVTJUVB m{FTQSFTFOUFT4FSJBVNBQFSDFQmkPFOGSBRVFDJEB RVF BTTP DJBEBBPVUSBT GPSNBSJBBTJEFJBTOPQFOTBNFOUP $PNPPTJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBTDPODFCFNBJNBHJOBmkP 0TJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBTUBNCnNDPOTJEFSBWBNBJNBHJOBmkP VNBGPSNBFOGSBRVFDJEBEBQFSDFQmkPFNFSBNFOUFSFQSPEV UPSBEFDPJTBTKgQFSDFCJEBT1PSDPOTJEFSBSFNBQFSDFQmkP BQSJODJQBMDBVTBEFOPTTPTFSSPT UBNCnNKVMHBWBNBJNBHJ OBmkPGPOUFEFFOHBOPTFFSSPT1BSBFMFT BJNBHJOBmkPTFSJB EJSFUBNFOUFSFQSPEVUPSBEBQFSDFQmkP OPDBNQPEPDPOIFDJ NFOUP FJOEJSFUBNFOUFSFQSPEVUPSBEBQFSDFQmkP OPDBNQP EBGBOUBTJB 1PSRVF OBUSBEJmkPGJMPTwGJDB BJNBHJOBmkPFSBDPOTJEFSB EBVNBQFSDFQmkPFOGSBRVFDJEB .FODJPOFBMHVOTQSPCMF NBTRVFFTTBDPODFQmkPOkPQPEJBSFTPMWFS
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
2VBOEPPGB[FNPTQBSBDSJBSVNPVUSPNVOEPBPRVBMPVUSPT TFSFTIVNBOPTUBNCnNUpNBDFTTP BJNBHJOBmkPQBTTBEP TPOIPhPCSBEFBSUF2VBOEPPGB[FNPTQBSBDSJBSVNPVUSP NVOEPTwOPTTPBPRVBMOJOHVnNNBJTQPEFUFSBDFTTP BJNB HJOBmkPQBTTBEPTPOIPhMPVDVSB
1PSRVFOBUSBEJmkPGJMPTwGJDBDPTUVNBWBTFVTBSBQBMBWSB JNBHJOBmkPDPNPTJOyOJNPEFQFSDFQmkPPVDPNPVNBTQFDUP EBQFSDFQmkP TVQPOEPTFRVFFOUSFBQFSDFQmkPFBJNBHJOBmkP FOUSFPQFSDFCJEPFBJNBHFNIBWFSJBBQFOBTVNBEJGFSFOmBEF HSBVPVEFJOUFOTJEBEF BJNBHFNTFSJBVNBQFSDFQmkPGSBDBFB QFSDFQmkPTFSJBBJNBHFNGPSUF &OUSFUBOUP FTTBDPODFQmkPOkP QPEJBSFTPMWFSPQSPCMFNBEFRVF FNOPTTBWJEB OkPDPOGVOEJ NPTQFSDFQmkPFJNBHFNOkPDPOGVOEJNPTQFSDFCFSFJNBHJOBS TPNPTDBQB[FTEFEJTUJOHVJSOPTTBQFSDFQmkPFBJNBHJOBmkPEF VNBPVUSBQFTTPB
*NBHJOBmkPSFQSPEVUPSBJNBHJOBmkPFWPDBEPSBJNBHJOB mkPJSSFBMJ[BEPSBJNBHJOBmkPGBCVMBEPSBJNBHJOBmkPDSJBEP SB
$PNPBGFOPNFOPMPHJBDPODFCFBJNBHJOBmkP
&TDPMIBUSpTNPEBMJEBEFTEFJNBHJOBmkPFFYQMJRVFBT
"GFOPNFOPMPHJBGBMBFNDPOTDJpODJBJNBHJOBUJWBRVFUFN DPNPBUPJNBHJOBS FTFVDPOUF|EPnPJNBHJOBEPPVPPCKFUP FNJNBHFN"JNBHJOBmkPnBDBQBDJEBEFEBDPOTDJpODJBQBSB GB[FSTVSHJSPTPCKFUPTJNBHJOgSJPTPVPCKFUPTFNJNBHFNQFS NJUJOEPOPTSFMBDJPOBSNPTDPNPBVTFOUFFDPNPJOFYJTUFOUF *NBHJOBSVNMJWSPnSFMBDJPOBSTFDPNBJNBHFNEPMJWSP JTUPn DPNVNMJWSPFYJTUFOUF NBTBVTFOUF HVBSEBEPOVNBCJCMJP UFDB
PVDPNVNMJWSPBVTFOUFQPSRVFBJOEBJOFYJTUFOUF OkP FTDSJUPFRVFnBQFOBTVNMJWSPQPTTrWFM
1SPGFTTPS B EBNPTBCBJYPBFYQMJDBmkPQBSBDBEBVNB EBTNPEBMJEBEFTEFJNBHJOBmkP DVKBFTDPMIBGJDBSgBDBSHPEP BMVOP*NBHJOBmkPSFQSPEVUPSBUPNBTVBTJNBHFOTEBQFSDFQ mkPFEBNFNwSJBJNBHJOBmkPFWPDBEPSBQSFTFOUJGJDBPBVTFO UFQFMBGPSmBEPTTFOUJNFOUPTJNBHJOBmkPJSSFBMJ[BEPSBUPSOBP BVTFOUFQSFTFOUFFOPTDPMPDBNBHJDBNFOUFFNPVUSBSFBMJEBEF QBSUJDVMBSJNBHJOBmkPGBCVMBEPSBEFDBSgUFSTPDJBMPVDPMFUJWP UFNVNBGPSUFDBSBDUFSrTUJDBSFMJHJPTBQPSDSJBSNJUPTFMFOEBT QFMPTRVBJTVNBTPDJFEBEF VNHSVQPTPDJBMPVVNBDPNVOJEB EFJNBHJOBNTVBQSwQSJBPSJHFNFBPSJHFNEFUPEBTBTDPJTBT PGFSFDFOEPVNBFYQMJDBmkPQBSBTFVQSFTFOUFFTPCSFUVEPQBSB BNPSUFJNBHJOBmkPDSJBEPSBJOWFOUBPOPWPOBTBSUFT OBT DJpODJBT OBTUnDOJDBTFOBGJMPTPGJBBQBSUJSEBDPNCJOBmkPEF FMFNFOUPTBGFUJWPT JOUFMFDUVBJTFDVMUVSBJT
2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBJNBHJOBmkPEJGFSFEBQFSDFQmkP QPSRVFBJNBHJOBmkPOkPPCTFSWBFPJNBHJOBEPOkPnPC TFSWgWFM 4JHOJGJDBRVFQFMBJNBHJOBmkPGB[FNPTVNBJNBHFNEBT QFTTPBT EBTTJUVBm{FT EBTDPJTBTRVFSFQSFTFOUB EFVNBTw WF[ PPCKFUPQPSJOUFJSPDPNPFMFTFBQSFTFOUB1PSJTTP QPEF NPTEJ[FSRVFPJNBHJOBEPOkPnPCTFSWgWFMQPSRVFOkPQFSNJ UFPCTFSWBSPTPCKFUPTQPSQFSGJT GBDFTFQFSTQFDUJWBTEJGFSFO UFTRVFWkPTFOEPBSUJDVMBEBTVNBThTPVUSBT OVNQSPDFTTP QFSNBOFOUFEF²DPNQMFNFOUBmkP³EPQFSDFCJEPDPNOPWPT EBEPTPVBTQFDUPT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBJNBHJOBmkPEJGFSFEBQFSDFQmkP QPSRVFBJNBHFNnVNBOgMPHPEPBVTFOUF 4JHOJGJDBRVFBJNBHFNnEJGFSFOUFEPQFSDFCJEPNBTRVF OkPIgEFTQSPQPSmkPFOUSFFMBFBRVJMPEFRVFFMBnJNBHFN RVFFMBHVBSEBBMHVNBQSPQPSmkPPVTFNFMIBOmBDPNBRVJMPEF RVFnJNBHFNRVFFOUSFFMBFBRVJMPEFRVFnJNBHFNIgBMHP FNDPNVN BQFTBSEBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFFMFT &YQMJRVFFFYFNQMJGJRVFBDBQBDJEBEFJSSFBMJ[BEPSBEBJNB HJOBmkP "DBQBDJEBEFJSSFBMJ[BEPSBEBJNBHJOBmkPEFTGB[BQFSDFQ mkPUPEPTPTPCKFUPT UPEBTBTQFTTPBTFUPEPTPTMVHBSFTOBEB UpNBWFSDPNTFVTFOUJEPQFSDFCJEP NBTSFNFUFNBPVUSPT TFOUJEPT DSJBNTFOUJEPTJOFYJTUFOUFTPVQSFTFOUJGJDBNPBVTFO UF&TTBDBQBDJEBEFQPEFTFSFYFNQMJGJDBEBDPNBDSJBOmBRVF nDBQB[EFUPSOBSBVTFOUFPRVFFTUgQSFTFOUF BDSJBOmBRVF EFTGB[PTFOUJEPEFVNBSNgSJPRVFEFJYBEFFTUBSQSFTFOUF
EFUPSOBSQSFTFOUFPBVTFOUF BQFSDFQmkPEFTGFJUBEPBSNgSJP nSFNFUJEBBPVUSPTFOUJEP VNOBWJPRVFTFUPSOBQSFTFOUF FDSJBSJOUFJSBNFOUFPJOFYJTUFOUF VNBBWFOUVSBOPTNBSFTB CPSEPEPOBWJPJSSFBM 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFTPOIP BSUFFMPVDVSB 1PSNFJPEPTPOIP BJNBHJOBmkPQPEFDSJBSVNNVOEPJS SFBMRVFKVMHBNPTNFMIPSEPRVFPOPTTP*SSFBMJ[BOEPPNVOEP QFSDFCJEPFSFBMJ[BOEPPTPOIP BJNBHJOBmkPQPEFPDVQBSP MVHBSEBQFSDFQmkPFQBTTBNPTBQFSDFCFSJNBHJOBSJBNFOUF
2VBJTTkPPTUJQPTPVNPEBMJEBEFTEFJNBHJOBmkP
2VBMPQBQFMEBJNBHJOBmkPQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUP &NWJTUBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP BJNBHJOBmkPEF TFNQFOIBVNEVQMPQBQFMPEFBVYJMJBSQSFDJPTP DPNP QPS FYFNQMP OPDBTPEBJNBHJOBmkPDSJBEPSBRVFPQFSBDPNBJO WFOmkPEPOPWP PVEFEFTWJPQFSJHPTP DPNPOPDBTPEBJNB HJOBmkPSFQSPEVUPSBRVFPQFSBDPNJMVT{FT
#APqTULOß߯ßß=hejcq]cai &YQPOIBBTJEFJBTEFBMHVOTGJMwTPGPTTPCSFBJNQPSUiODJB EBMJOHVBHFN 1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT BMJOHVBHFNnRVFDBSBDUFSJ[BPIPNFN DPNPVNTFSTPDJBMFDrWJDP EJTUJOHVJOEPPEPTPVUSPTBOJNBJT 1BSB3PVTTFBV BMnNEFTTBEJTUJOmkP BJNQPSUiODJBEBMJO HVBHFNTFEFWFhOFDFTTJEBEFFBPEFTFKPRVFPTFSIVNBOP EFTFOWPMWFVEFTFDPNVOJDBS)KFNTMFWBDSFTDFOUBBJOEBRVF ²BMJOHVBHFNnJOTFQBSgWFMEPIPNFN TFHVFPFNUPEPTPT TFVTBUPT³ OkPTFOEPBQFOBTVNTJNQMFTBDPNQBOIBNFOUPEP QFOTBNFOUP ²NBTTJNVNGJPQSPGVOEBNFOUFUFDJEPOBUSBNB EPQFOTBNFOUP³"MJOHVBHFNn BTTJN BGPSNBQSPQSJBNFOUF IVNBOBEBDPNVOJDBmkP EBSFMBmkPDPNPNVOEPFDPNPTPV USPT EBWJEBTPDJBMFQPMrUJDB EPQFOTBNFOUPFEBTBSUFT 1PSRVF1MBUkPTFSFGFSFhMJOHVBHFNDPNPQIgSNBLPO "PTFSFGFSJShQBMBWSBMJOHVBHFNDPNPQIgSNBLPO 1MBUkP DPOTJEFSBWBRVFBMJOHVBHFNQPEFTFSVNNFEJDBNFOUPPVVN SFNnEJPQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUP QPJTQFMPEJgMPHPFQFMBDPNVOJ DBmkPDPOTFHVJNPTEFTDPCSJSOPTTBJHOPSiODJBFBQSFOEFSDPN PTPVUSPT1PEF QPSnN TFSVNWFOFOPRVBOEP QFMBTFEVmkP EBTQBMBWSBT OPTGB[BDFJUBSGBTDJOBEPTPRVFWJNPTPVMFNPT TFNRVFJOEBHVFNPTTFUBJTQBMBWSBTTkPWFSEBEFJSBTPVGBMTBT &OGJN BMJOHVBHFNQPEFTFSDPTNnUJDP NBRVJBHFNPVNgTDB SBQBSBEJTTJNVMBSPVPDVMUBSBWFSEBEFTPCBTQBMBWSBT
/,
Manual do Professor
2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEPNJUPCrCMJDPEB5PSSFEF#BCFM
&YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFMJOHVBHFNFMrOHVBT
&TTFNJUPNPTUSBRVFBMJOHVBHFNQPEFTFSDPOIFDJNFOUP DPNVOJDBmkP NBTUBNCnNQPEFTFSEJTTJNVMBmkPEFTDPOIF DJNFOUPSFQSFTFOUBEBQFMBJEFJBEBDPOGVTkPMBOmBEBQPS%FVT FOUSFPTIPNFOT GB[FOEPDPNRVFQFSEFTTFNBMrOHVBDPNVN FQBTTBTTFNBGBMBSMrOHVBTEJGFSFOUFT RVFJNQFEJBNVNBPCSB FNDPNVNFBCSJBNBTQPSUBTQBSBUPEPTPTEFTFOUFOEJNFOUPT FHVFSSBT
"MJOHVBHFNDPNPDBQBDJEBEFEFFYQSFTTkPEPTTFSFTIV NBOPTnOBUVSBM JTUPn PTIVNBOPTOBTDFNDPNVNBBQBSF MIBHFNGrTJDB BOBUyNJDBFGJTJPMwHJDBRVFMIFTQFSNJUFFYQSFT TBSFNTFQFMBQBMBWSBNBTBTMrOHVBTTkPDPOWFODJPOBJT JTUP n TVSHFNEFDPOEJm{FTIJTUwSJDBT HFPHSgGJDBT FDPOyNJDBTF QPMrUJDBTEFUFSNJOBEBT PV FNPVUSPTUFSNPT TkPGBUPTDVM UVSBJT
2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFPNJUPNBOJGFTUBBGPSmBSFBMJ[BEPSB EBMJOHVBHFN
2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTSFTQPTUBTQBSBBQFSHVOUBTPCSFBPSJ HFNEBMJOHVBHFN
4JHOJGJDBRVF QPSNFJPEPTNJUPT OBSSBUJWBT
PTTFSFTIV NBOPTPSHBOJ[BNBSFBMJEBEFFBJOUFSQSFUBN GB[FOEPDPNRVF BTDPJTBTTFKBNUBJTDPNPTkPEJUBTPVQSPOVODJBEBT0NFMIPS FYFNQMPEFTTBGPSmBSFBMJ[BEPSBEBMJOHVBHFNQPEFTFSFODPO USBEPOPQSJNFJSPDBQrUVMPEPMJWSPEP(pOFTJTEB#rCMJBKVEBJ DPDSJTUk FNRVF%FVTDSJBPNVOEPEPOBEBBQFOBTVTBOEPB MJOHVBHFN²&%FVTEJTTFGBmBTF³ FGPJGFJUP
"MJOHVBHFNOBTDFEBJNJUBmkP JTUPn PTIVNBOPTJNJ UBN QFMBWP[ PTTPOTEBOBUVSF[BBMJOHVBHFNOBTDFQPS JNJUBmkPEPTHFTUPT RVFQPVDPBQPVDPQBTTBSBNBTFSBDPN QBOIBEPTEFTPOTFFTUFTTFUPSOBSBNHSBEVBMNFOUFQBMB WSBT TVCTUJUVJOEPPTHFTUPTBMJOHVBHFNOBTDFEBTOFDFTTJ EBEFT DPNPBTVCTJTUpODJB BQSPUFmkP BEFGFTB RVFMFWBSBN hDSJBmkPEFQBMBWSBT GPSNBOEPVNWPDBCVMgSJPFMFNFOUBSF SVEJNFOUBS RVF HSBEBUJWBNFOUF UPSOPVTFNBJTDPNQMFYP FUSBOTGPSNPVTFOVNBMrOHVBBMJOHVBHFNOBTDFEBTFNP m{FT QBSUJDVMBSNFOUFEPHSJUP NFEP TVSQSFTBPVBMFHSJB
EPDIPSP EPS NFEP DPNQBJYkP FEPSJTP QSB[FS CFNFTUBS GFMJDJEBEF
2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBMJOHVBHFNUFNVNQPEFSFODBOUB UwSJP $PNPFTTFQPEFSTFNBOJGFTUB 4JHOJGJDBRVFFMBUFNVNBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBSFVOJSPTBHSBEP FPQSPGBOP USB[FSPTEFVTFTFBTGPSmBTDwTNJDBTQBSBPNFJP EPNVOEP PV DPNPBDPOUFDFDPNPTNrTUJDPTFNPSBmkP UFN PQPEFSEFMFWBSPTIVNBOPTBUnPJOUFSJPSEPTBHSBEP&TTF QPEFSTFNBOJGFTUBQPSNFJPEFQFTTPBTFTDPMIJEBT QSPGFUBT PSgDVMPT FUD QBSBUSBOTNJUJSNFOTBHFOTEJWJOBTBPTIPNFOT 5BNCnNBQBSFDFOPTSJUVBJTEFGFJUJmBSJB OPTDPOUPTJOGBOUJT FOPTUBCVT
0RVFnBMJOHVBHFN "MJOHVBHFNnVNTJTUFNBEFTJHOPTPVTJOBJTVTBEPTQBSB JOEJDBSDPJTBT QBSBBDPNVOJDBmkPFOUSFQFTTPBTFQBSBBFY QSFTTkPEFJEFJBT WBMPSFTFTFOUJNFOUPT
2VFTkPQBMBWSBTUBCVT %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPT
&YQMJRVFQPSRVFBMJOHVBHFNnVNTJTUFNB
4kPFYQSFTT{FTRVFOkPQPEFNTFSEJUBT DIFHBOEPBUnB TFSJNQSPOVODJgWFJT DPNPPOPNFEF%FVT *BIXFI
OBUSBEJ mkPKVEBJDB&NHFSBMFYJTUFNOPNFJPSFMJHJPTP1PSFYFNQMP FNNVJUBTTPDJFEBEFTOkPTFQPEFQSPOVODJBSBQBMBWSBEFNy OJPPVEJBCP.BTUBNCnNBQBSFDFNOBTCSJODBEFJSBTJOGBOUJT RVBOEPDFSUBTQBMBWSBTTkPQSPJCJEBTPV BJOEB OBWJEBTPDJBM TPCPTFGFJUPTEBSFQSFTTkPEPTDPTUVNFT TPCSFUVEPPTRVF TFSFGFSFNBQSgUJDBTTFYVBJTPVhHFOJUBMJEBEFTFYP QVUB NBTUVSCBmkP FUD5BNCnNQBMBWSBTEFDVOIPQPMrUJDPUFOEFN BUPSOBSTFRVBTFUBCVTSFWPMVDJPOgSJP UFSSPSJTUB HVFSSJMIFJSP TPDJBMJTUB DPNVOJTUB FUD
"MJOHVBHFNnVNTJTUFNBQPSRVFnVNBUPUBMJEBEFFTUSVUV SBEB DPNQSJODrQJPTFMFJTQSwQSJBT FQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEB
1PSRVFOPEJSFJUPBOUJHPBQBSFDJBPQPEFSNgHJDPSFMJHJPTP EBMJOHVBHFN 1PSRVFOBPSJHFNPEJSFJUPOkPFSBVNDwEJHPEFMFJT NBT VNBUPTPMFOFOPRVBMPKVJ[QSPOVODJBWBVNBGwSNVMBQFMB RVBMEVBTQBSUFTFNDPOGMJUPGB[JBNBTQB[FT0EJSFJUPFSBVNB MJOHVBHFNTPMFOFRVFFNQSFHBWBGwSNVMBTDPOIFDJEBTQFMP gSCJUSPFSFDPOIFDJEBTQFMBTQBSUFTFNMJUrHJP&SBPKVSBNFO UPQSPOVODJBEPQFMPKVJ[FBDBUBEPQFMBTQBSUFT EPOEFBTFY QSFTT{FT²%PVNJOIBQBMBWSB³PV²&MFEFVTVBQBMBWSB³QBSB JOEJDBSPKVSBNFOUPGFJUPFB²QBMBWSBFNQFOIBEB³PV²QBMBWSB EFIPOSB³ 2VFRVFSEJ[FSMwHPT -wHPTnVNBTrOUFTFEFUSpTJEFJBT²GBMBQBMBWSB³ ²QFOTB NFOUPJEFJB³F²SFBMJEBEFTFS³-wHPTnBQBMBWSBSBDJPOBMFN RVFTFFYQSJNFPQFOTBNFOUPRVFDPOIFDFPSFBMcEJTDVSTP PVTFKB BSHVNFOUPFQSPWB
QFOTBNFOUP PVTFKB SBDJPDrOJP FEFNPOTUSBmkP FSFBMJEBEF PVTFKB BTDPJTBTFPTOFYPTF MJHBm{FTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJPTFOUSFPTTFSFT
/-
&YQMJRVFPRVFTkPPTTJHOPT 4JHOPTTkPPCKFUPTRVFJOEJDBNPVUSPT EFTJHOBNPVUSPT PVSFQSFTFOUBNPVUSPT1PSFYFNQMP BGVNBmBnVNTJHOPPV TJOBMEFGPHP EFUFSNJOBEBTNBODIBTOBQFMFTkPTJHOPTEFTB SBNQPPVEFDBUBQPSB FUD/PDBTPEBMJOHVBHFN PTTJHOPTTkP QBMBWSBTFPTDPNQPOFOUFTEBTQBMBWSBT TPOTPVMFUSBT &YQMJRVFBTGVOm{FTEFOPUBUJWB DPOPUBUJWBFDPNVOJDBUJWB EBMJOHVBHFN 1PSNFJPEBGVOmkPEFOPUBUJWBBMJOHVBHFNJOEJDBDPJTBT BTQBMBWSBTDPNPRVFBQPOUBNQBSBBTDPJTBTRVFTJHOJGJDBN QPSNFJPEBGVOmkPDPOPUBUJWBBMJOHVBHFNFYQSJNFQFOTB NFOUPT TFOUJNFOUPTFWBMPSFT±VNBNFTNBQBMBWSBQPEF FYQSJNJSTFOUJEPTPVTJHOJGJDBEPTEJGFSFOUFT EFQFOEFOEPEP TVKFJUPRVFBFNQSFHB EPTVKFJUPRVFBPVWFFMp EBTDPOEJ m{FTPVDJSDVOTUiODJBTFNRVFGPJFNQSFHBEBPVEPDPOUFYUP FNRVFnVTBEBQPSNFJPEBGVOmkPDPNVOJDBUJWBBMJOHVBHFN FTUBCFMFDFBDPNVOJDBmkPFOUSFPTTFSFTIVNBOPT JTUPn QPS NFJPEBTQBMBWSBTFOUSBNPTFNSFMBmkPDPNPTPVUSPT EJBMP HBNPT BSHVNFOUBNPT QFSTVBEJNPT SFMBUBNPT FOTJOBNPT BQSFOEFNPT FUD $PNPPFNQJSJTUBFYQMJDBBMJOHVBHFN 1BSBPFNQJSJTUB BMJOHVBHFNFTUgFNOPTTPDPSQPcVN DPOKVOUPEFJNBHFOTDPSQPSBJTFNFOUBJTGPSNBEBTQPSBTTP DJBmkPFSFQFUJmkPFRVFDPOTUJUVFNJNBHFOTWFSCBJT JTUPn BTQBMBWSBT
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
1PSRVFPTEJTU|SCJPTEFMJOHVBHFNGPSBNJNQPSUBOUFTQB SBPTFNQJSJTUBT 1PSRVFBQBSUJSEPFTUVEPEFTTBTQFSUVSCBm{FTnRVFTF DPODMVJVRVFBMJOHVBHFNFSBVNGFOyNFOPGrTJDP BOBUyNJDP FGJTJPMwHJDP EPRVBMOkPUFNPTDPOTDJpODJB EFTDPOIFDFNPT TVBTDBVTBT
NBTEFDVKPTFGFJUPTUFNPTDPOTDJpODJB JTUPn GBMBNPT PVWJNPT FTDSFWFNPT MFNPTFDPNQSFFOEFNPTPTFO UJEPEBTQBMBWSBT $PNPPTJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBTFYQMJDBNBMJOHVBHFN &MFTBGJSNBNRVFBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBBMJOHVBHFNnVN GBUPEPOPTTPQFOTBNFOUPPVEBOPTTBDPOTDJpODJB"MJOHVB HFNnVNJOTUSVNFOUPEPQFOTBNFOUPQBSBFYQSJNJSDPODFJ UPTFTrNCPMPT QBSBUSBOTNJUJSFDPNVOJDBSJEFJBTBCTUSBUBT FWBMPSFT"QBMBWSB EJ[FNFMFT nVNBSFQSFTFOUBmkPEFVN QFOTBNFOUP EFVNBJEFJBPVEFWBMPSFT TFOEPQSPEV[JEB QFMPTVKFJUPQFOTBOUFRVFVTBPTTPOTFBTMFUSBTDPNFTTB GJOBMJEBEF 1PSRVFPDBTPEF)FMFO,FMMFSGPJJNQPSUBOUFQBSBPTJO UFMFDUVBMJTUBT 1PSRVFTFUPSOPVVNBDPNQSPWBmkPEFRVFPEFTFOWPMWJ NFOUPEBMJOHVBHFNOkPEFQFOEFFYDMVTJWBNFOUFEFNFDB OJTNPTFEJTQPTJm{FTDPSQPSBJT DPNPBGJSNBWBPFNQJSJTNP &QPSEFNPOTUSBSRVF MPOHFEFTFSVNNFDBOJTNPJOTUJOUJWPF CJPMwHJDP BMJOHVBHFNTFSJBVNGBUPQVSPEBJOUFMJHpODJB VNB BUJWJEBEFJOUFMFDUVBMTJNCwMJDBFEFDPNQSFFOTkP VNBQVSB USBEVmkPEFQFOTBNFOUPT 2VBJTPTQPOUPTDPNVOTOBTDPODFQm{FTEFMJOHVBHFN EFFNQJSJTUBTFJOUFMFDUVBMJTUBT $PNPFTTBTDPODFQm{FT DPOTJEFSBNPBTQFDUPDPOPUBUJWPEBMJOHVBHFN "NCBTDPOTJEFSBNBMJOHVBHFNGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFJOEJDB UJWBPVEFOPUBUJWB JTUPn PTTJHOPTMJOHVrTUJDPTPVBTQBMBWSBT TFSWFNBQFOBTQBSBJOEJDBSDPJTBTBNCBTDPOTJEFSBNBMJOHVB HFNVNJOTUSVNFOUPEFSFQSFTFOUBmkPEBTDPJTBTFEBTJEFJBT PVTFKB BTQBMBWSBTUpNBQFOBTVNBGVOmkPPVVNVTPJOTUSV NFOUBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWP&TTBTEVBTDPODFQm{FTDPOTJEFSBNB GVOmkPDPOPUBUJWBEBMJOHVBHFNBMHPQFSUVSCBEPSFOFHBUJWP QPJTQBSBFMFTBTQBMBWSBTEFWFSJBNUFSTFNQSFVNTwFNFTNP TFOUJEPQBSBJOEJDBSDMBSBNFOUFBTDPJTBTFSFQSFTFOUBSDMBSB NFOUFBTJEFJBTTFNBNCJHVJEBEFT &NRVFTFCBTFBWBPQPTJUJWJTNPMwHJDPQBSBQSPQPSVNB QVSJGJDBmkPEBMJOHVBHFN #BTFBWBTFOBEJTUJOmkPEFEVBTMJOHVBHFOTBMJOHVBHFN OBUVSBM JTUPn BRVFMBVTBEBOPDPUJEJBOPFRVFnJNQSFDJTB DPOGVTB NFTDMBEFFMFNFOUPTBGFUJWPT WPMJUJWPT QFSDFQUJWPT FJNBHJOBUJWPTBMJOHVBHFNMwHJDB JTUPn VNBMJOHVBHFNQV SJGJDBEB GPSNBMJ[BEB JOTQJSBEBOBNBUFNgUJDBFTPCSFUVEPOB GrTJDB 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFPQPTJUJWJTNPMwHJDPEBWBpOGBTFh TJOUBYFMwHJDB 1PSNFJPEBTJOUBYFMwHJDB PQPTJUJWJTNPMwHJDPEFTFOWPM WFVVNBHBSBOUJBQBSBBWFSEBEFSFQSFTFOUBUJWBFJOEJDBUJWBEB MJOHVBHFN PVTFKB PTFOVODJBEPTEBMJOHVBHFNQPEJBNTFS BWBMJBEPTDPNFYBUJEkPDPNPWFSEBEFJSPTPVGBMTPTQPSNFJP EFQSJODrQJPTFSFHSBTMwHJDBTQSFDJTPT
2VBJTBTMJNJUBm{FTFPTFRVrWPDPTEPQPTJUJWJTNPMwHJDP )gFYQSFTT{FTMJOHVrTUJDBTRVFOkPQPTTVFNDBSgUFSEF OPUBUJWP JOEJDBUJWP OFNSFQSFTFOUBUJWP F BQFTBSEJTTP TkP WFSEBEFJSBTIgJO|NFSBTGPSNBTEFMJOHVBHFNRVFOkPQPEFN TFSSFEV[JEBTBPTFOVODJBEPTMwHJDPTEFUJQPNBUFNgUJDPFGrTJ DPDFSUBTFYQSFTT{FTEBMJOHVBHFNOkPQPTTVFNEFOPUBmkP BSFEVmkPEBMJOHVBHFNBPDgMDVMPTJNCwMJDPPVMwHJDPJOWBMJ EBVNBEJWFSTJEBEFEFDPOIFDJNFOUPT POUPMPHJB MJUFSBUVSB IJTUwSJB FUD
MJOHVBHFOTQSPGVOEBNFOUFDPOPUBUJWBTQBSBBT RVBJTBNVMUJQMJDJEBEFEFTFOUJEPEBTQBMBWSBTFEBTDPJTBTn TVBQSwQSJBSB[kPEFTFS 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTJEFJBTEBMJOHVrTUJDB "MJOHVBHFNnDPOTUJUVrEBQFMBMrOHVBFQFMBGBMBPVQBMBWSB nVNBUPUBMJEBEFPVVNBFTUSVUVSBOVNBMrOHVB EJTUJOHVFNTF PTJHOJGJDBOUFFPTJHOJGJDBEPBSFMBmkPEPTTJHOPTFTJHOJGJDBO UFTDPNBTDPJTBTnDPOWFODJPOBEBQBSBUPEPTPTGBMBOUFTEB MrOHVBnVNDwEJHPFTFSFBMJ[BQPSNFJPEFNFOTBHFOTRVF QPTTVFNVNFNJTTPSFVNSFDFQUPSPTVKFJUPGBMBOUFQPTTVJ EVBTDBQBDJEBEFTDPNQFUpODJBFEFTFNQFOIPBMrOHVBnQSB UJDBEBEFNBOFJSBOkPDPOTDJFOUF &TDPMIBUSpTJEFJBTEBMJOHVrTUJDBFFYQMJRVFBT 1SPGFTTPS B PDSJUnSJPEFFTDPMIBnBMFBUwSJP"QSFTFOUB NPTBCBJYPBMHVNBTJEFJBTEBMJOHVrTUJDBRVFEFNPOTUSBNB JOUFHSBmkPRVFIgFOUSFFMBT "MJOH VBH FNnDPOTU JU VrE BQFM BMrOH VBFQFM BGBM BPV QBMBWSB"MrOHVB JOTUJUVrEBTPDJBMNFOUF nVNBFTUSVUVSB PCK FU JW BFFYJTU FDPNT VBTSFH SBTFQSJODrQ JPTQSwQ SJPTB GBMBPVQBMBWSBnBFYQSFTTkPTVCKFUJWBEBMJOHVBHFN JTUP n BNBOFJSBDPNPDBEBTVKFJUPGBMBOUFEBMrOHVBTFBQSPQSJB EFMBFBFNQSFHB"QFTBSEFTTFDBSgUFSQFTTPBMEBQBMBWSB BSFMBmkPEFMBDPNBTDPJTBTJOEJDBEBTUPSOBTFVNBSFMB mkPOFDFTTgSJBRVFnDPOWFODJPOBEBQBSBUPEPTPTGBMBOUFT EBMrOH VB"MrOH VBnVNDwE JH P DPOK VOU PEFSFH SBTRVF QFSNJUFNQSPEV[JSJOGPSNBmkPFDPNVOJDBmkP FTFSFBMJ[B QFM BGBM BQBM BW SBEPTTVK FJU PTRVFWFJD VM BNJOG PSN Bm {FT FTFDPNVOJDBN NFOTBHFOT EFNPEPFTQFDrGJDPFQBSUJ DVMBSPFNJTTPS BRVFMFRVFFNJUFPVFOWJBBNFOTBHFN FPSFD FQU PS BRVFM FRVFSFD FC FFEFD PE JG JD B FOU FOE F B NFOTBHFN &YQMJRVFPRVFnVNTJHOPMJOHVrTUJDPPVWFSCBM 0TJHOPMJOHVrTUJDPPVWFSCBM BQBMBWSB nVNTrNCPMP BMHP RVFJOEJDB SFQSFTFOUB FYQSJNFBMHVNBDPJTBRVFnEFOBUVSF [BEJGFSFOUFEFMF RVFOPTSFNFUFBDPJTBTRVFOkPTkPWFSCBJT OkPTkPQBMBWSBT DPJTBTNBUFSJBJT JEFJBT QFTTPBT WBMPSFT TFSFTJOFYJTUFOUFT FUD 0RVFFSBBDPODFQmkPCJOgSJBEPTJHOPPVEBMJOHVBHFN 4FHVOEPBDPODFQmkPCJOgSJB BMJOHVBHFNTFDPOTUJUVrBEB SFMBmkPFOUSFEPJTUFSNPTTJHOPFDPJTBJOEJDBEB SFBMJEBEF F TJHOPFJEFJB DPODFJUP WBMPS QFOTBNFOUP "TTJN BGVOmkPEB MJOHVBHFNFSBBQFOBTJOEJDBUJWBPVEFOPUBUJWB JTUPn BDBEB TJHOPDPSSFTQPOEJBVNBSFBMJEBEFPVVNBJEFJBPVDPODFJUPOP QFOTBNFOUP FWJDFWFSTB 2VBMPQBQFMEPTFOUJEPFEBTTJHOJGJDBm{FTQBSBTFQBT TBSEFVNBDPODFQmkPCJOgSJBEBMJOHVBHFNhDPODFQmkP UFSOgSJB OBRVBMTFDPNQSFFOEFRVFIgVNBJOUFSSFMBmkP DPOUrOVBFOUSFQBMBWSBT SFBMJEBEFFQFOTBNFOUPT
/.
Manual do Professor
0QBQFMEPTFOUJEPFEBTTJHOJGJDBm{FTnBUSJCVJShGVOmkP JOEJDBUJWBPVEFOPUBUJWBEBMJOHVBHFNBGVOmkPDPOPUBUJWB "TTJN BTQBMBWSBTJOEJDBNEFOPUBNBMHVNBDPJTBPVBMHVN QFOTBNFOUP NBTUBNCnNPTDPOPUBN JTUPn SFGFSFNTFBP TFOUJEP hTJHOJGJDBmkPEFTTBDPJTBPVEFTTFQFOTBNFOUP%FT TBGPSNB BTQBMBWSBTBMnNEFUFSFNTFOUJEPBQFOBTEFWJEPh SFMBmkPTJHOPFDPJTB TJHOPFJEFJB JOEJDBOEPEFOPUBOEPFTTF TFOUJEP UBNCnNDSJBNTFOUJEP $POTJEFSBOEPBGPSNBUFSOgSJBEBMJOHVBHFN DPNPQPEF NPTDPODFCpMB "MJOHVBHFNSFGFSFTFBPNVOEPQPSNFJPEBTTJHOJGJDBm{FT F QPSJTTP QPEFNPTOPTSFMBDJPOBSDPNBSFBMJEBEFBUSBWnTEB QBMBWSBSFMBDJPOBTFDPNTFOUJEPTKgFYJTUFOUFTFDSJBTFOUJ EPTOPWPT QPSJTTPQPEFNPTOPTSFMBDJPOBSDPNPQFOTBNFOUP BUSBWnTEBTQBMBWSBTFYQSJNFFEFTDPCSFTJHOJGJDBEPT QPSJTTP QPEFNPTOPTDPNVOJDBSFOPTSFMBDJPOBSDPNPTPVUSPTUFNP QPEFSEFTVTDJUBSTJHOJGJDBm{FT EFFWPDBSSFDPSEBm{FT EFJNB HJOBSPOPWPPVPJOFYJTUFOUF QPSJTTPBMJUFSBUVSBnQPTTrWFM 2VBJTPTRVBUSPGBUPSFTRVFDPOTUJUVFNBMJOHVBHFN 'BUPSFTGrTJDPT BOBUyNJDPT GJTJPMwHJDPT OFVSPMwHJDPT NP USJ[FT TFOTPSJBJT
GBUPSFTTPDJPDVMUVSBJT GBUPSFTQTJDPMwHJDPT FGBUPSFTMJOHVrTUJDPT
%FBDPSEPDPNPTEJDJPOgSJPT PTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTEBQB MBWSBQFOTBSTkP²BQMJDBSBBUJWJEBEFEPFTQrSJUPBPTFMFNFOUPT GPSOFDJEPTQFMPDPOIFDJNFOUP³²GPSNBSFDPNCJOBSJEFJBT³ ²KVMHBS SFGMFUJS SBDJPDJOBS FTQFDVMBS³²FYFSDFSBJOUFMJHpODJB³ 1BSBBQBMBWSBQFOTBNFOUP PTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTTkP²PBUP EFSFGMFUJS NFEJUBS QFOTBS³²BUJWJEBEFRVFUFNQPSPCKFUPP DPOIFDJNFOUP³²DPOTDJpODJB FOUFOEJNFOUP³²QPEFSEFGPS NVMBSJEFJBTFDPODFJUPT³²GBDVMEBEFEFQFOTBSMPHJDBNFOUF SBDJPDrOJP QPOUPEFWJTUB GPSNVMBmkPEFVNKVr[P³ 2VFTJHOJGJDBNPTWFSCPTQFOTBSF DPHJUBSFFJOUFMMJHFSF 2VBOEPSFVOJNPTTFVTTFOUJEPT RVFTJHOJGJDBQFOTBNFO UP 1FOTBSFEFSJWBEPWFSCPMBUJOPQFOEFSF RVFTJHOJGJDB²GJ DBSFNTVTQFOTP FTUBSPVGJDBSQFOEFOUFPVQFOEVSBEP TVT QFOEFS QFTBS QBHBS FYBNJOBS BWBMJBS QPOEFSBS DPNQFO TBS SFDPNQFOTBSFFRVJMJCSBS³$PHJUBSFTJHOJGJDB²DPOTJEFSBS BUFOUBNFOUFFNFEJUBS³*OUFMMJHFSFTJHOJGJDB²FTDPMIFSFOUSF SFVOJSFOUSFWgSJPT BQBOIBS BQSFOEFS DPNQSFFOEFS MFSFOUSF MFSEFOUSPEF³3FVOJEPTPTTFVTTFOUJEPT QFOTBNFOUPTJHOJGJ DBVNBBUJWJEBEFRVFSFRVFSBUFOmkP VNBBUJWJEBEFQFMBRVBM BDPOTDJpODJBPVBJOUFMJHpODJBDPMPDBBMHPEJBOUFEFTJQBSB BUFOUBNFOUFDPOTJEFSBS BWBMJBS QFTBS FRVJMJCSBS SFVOJS DPN QSFFOEFS FTDPMIFS FOUFOEFSFMFSQPSEFOUSP $PNPBQTJDPMPHJBDPODFCFBJOUFMJHpODJB
&TDPMIBEPJTEFTTFTGBUPSFTFFYQMJRVFPT 1SPGFTTPS B &TDPMIBQFTTPBMEPBMVOPFOUSFPTTFHVJOUFT GBUPSFTGrTJDPT BOBUyNJDPT GJTJPMwHJDPT OFVSPMwHJDPT NPUSJ [FT TFOTPSJBJT EFUFSNJOBNQBSBOwTBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFGB MBS FTDVUBSFMFSTPDJPDVMUVSBJTEFUFSNJOBNBEJGFSFOmBFOUSF BTMrOHVBTFFOUSFBTMJOHVBHFOTEPTJOEJWrEVPTQTJDPMwHJDPT FNPDJPOBJT BGFUJWPT QFSDFQUJWPT JNBHJOBUJWPT MFNCSBOmBT JOUFMJHpODJB DSJBNFNOwTBOFDFTTJEBEFFPEFTFKPEBJOGPS NBmkPFEBDPNVOJDBmkP CFNDPNPDSJBNOPTTBDBQBDJEBEF QBSBBQFSGPSNBODFMJOHVrTUJDB TFKBFMBDPUJEJBOB BSUrTUJDB TFKB FMBDJFOUrGJDBPVGJMPTwGJDBMJOHVrTUJDPTQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUPTBFT USVUVSBFPGVODJPOBNFOUPEBMJOHVBHFNRVFEFUFSNJOBNOPTTB DPNQFUpODJBFOPTTBQFSGPSNBODFFORVBOUPTFSFTDBQB[FTEF DSJBSFDPNQSFFOEFSTJHOJGJDBm{FT
"QTJDPMPHJBDPODFCFBJOUFMJHpODJBDPNPVNBBUJWJEBEF FNJOFOUFNFOUFQSgUJDB$PTUVNBEFGJOJMBQPSTVBGVOmkP DPO TJEFSBOEPBVNBBUJWJEBEFQBSBSFBMJ[BSOPTTBBEBQUBmkPBP BNCJFOUFQFMPFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEFSFMBm{FTFOUSFNFJPTFGJOT QBSBBTPMVmkPEFVNQSPCMFNBPVEFVNBEJGJDVMEBEF 2VBJTBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFJOTUJOUPFIgCJUP 0JOTUJOUPnJOBUP PIgCJUPnBERVJSJEP 2VBJTBTTFNFMIBOmBTFOUSFJOTUJOUPFIgCJUP
#APqTULOß߯ßßKlajo]iajpk
*OTUJOUPFIgCJUPTkPGPSNBTEFDPNQPSUBNFOUPDVKBQSJODJ QBMDBSBDUFSrTUJDBnTFSFNFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTPVFTQFDrGJDPT"NCPT FTQFDJBMJ[BNBTGVOm{FT PTNFJPTFPTGJOTFOkPQPTTVFNGMFYJ CJMJEBEFQBSBNVEgMPTPVQBSBBEBQUBSVNNFJPBVNOPWPGJN OFNBVTBSNFJPTOPWPTQBSBVNGJNKgFYJTUFOUF"UFOEpODJB EPJOTUJOUPFEPIgCJUPnBSFQFUJmkPFPBVUPNBUJTNPEBTSFT QPTUBTBPTQSPCMFNBT
0GFSFmBBMHVOTFYFNQMPTEPTWgSJPTTFOUJEPTRVFEBNPThT QBMBWSBTQFOTBNFOUPFQFOTBSFNOPTTBWJEBDPUJEJBOB
$PNPFQPSRVFBJOUFMJHpODJBEJGFSFEPJOTUJOUPFEPIgCJ UP
$PNPBUJWJEBEFTPMJUgSJBFJOWJTrWFM ²%JHBNF FNRVF WPDpFTUgQFOTBOEP ³ CBTFBEPFNTJOBJTDPSQPSBJTFWJTr WFJT ²&VTFJPRVFWPDpFTUgQFOTBOEP³ DPNPTJOyOJNPEF EFMJCFSBmkPFEFEFDJTkP DPNPBMHPRVFSFTVMUBOVNBBmkP ²+gQFOTFJ7BNPTGB[FSPUSBCBMIP³ QSFPDVQBmkP DJTNB E|WJEB ²'JRVFJQBSBEP QFOTBOEP QFOTBOEPPRVFGB[FS OkPTFJ"DIPRVFTFFVGJDBS´FODVDBOEPμEFNBJTWPVGJDBS EPFOUF³ TVQPTJmkPEFCPOTFNBVTQFOTBNFOUPT ²BGBT UBSPTNBVTQFOTBNFOUPT³ BMHPRVFTFQPEFRVFSFSPVOkP RVFSFS BMHPWPMVOUgSJPFEFMJCFSBEP VNBGPSNBEFBUFOmkP FDPODFOUSBmkP ²'BmBNTJMpODJP OkPDPOTJHPQFOTBS³ DP NPJOEJDBmkPEBQSwQSJBFTTpODJBIVNBOB ²0IPNFNnVN DBOJmPQFOTBOUF³
"JOUFMJHpODJBEJGFSFEPJOTUJOUPFEPIgCJUPQPSTVBGMFYJ CJMJEBEF QFMBDBQBDJEBEFEFFODPOUSBSOPWPTNFJPTQBSBVN OPWPGJNPVEFBEBQUBSNFJPTFYJTUFOUFTBVNBGJOBMJEBEFOPWB QFMBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFOGSFOUBSEFNBOFJSBEJGFSFOUFTJUVBm{FT OPWBTFJOWFOUBSOPWBTTPMVm{FTQBSBFMBTQFMBDBQBDJEBEFEF FTDPMIFSFOUSFWgSJPTNFJPTQPTTrWFJTFFOUSFWgSJPTGJOTQPT TrWFJT
2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTRVFPTEJDJPOgSJPTEkPQBSBBT QBMBWSBTQFOTBSFQFOTBNFOUP
//
2VFnBJOUFMJHpODJBQSgUJDBPVJOTUSVNFOUBM cBDBQBDJEBEFEFDSJBSJOTUSVNFOUPT JTUPn EFEBSVNB GVOmkPOPWBFVNTFOUJEPOPWPBDPJTBTKgFYJTUFOUFTQBSBRVF TJSWBNEFNFJPTBOPWPTGJOT $PNPQPEFNPTEFGJOJSBJOUFMJHpODJBFORVBOUPBUJWJEBEF NFOUBMFEFMJOHVBHFN 2VFRVFSFNPTEJ[FSBPGBMBSNPT FN²DPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMJHFOUF³
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
"JOUFMJHpODJBQPEFTFSEFGJOJEBDPNPBDBQBDJEBEFEFFO GSFOUBSPVDPMPDBSEJBOUFEFTJQSPCMFNBTQSgUJDPTFUFwSJDPT QBSBPTRVBJTFODPOUSB FMBCPSBPVDPODFCFTPMVm{FT TFKBQFMB DSJBmkPEFJOTUSVNFOUPTQSgUJDPT BTUnDOJDBT
TFKBQFMBDSJBmkP EFTJHOJGJDBm{FT JEFJBTFDPODFJUPT 0²DPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMJ HFOUF³BQSFFOEFPTFOUJEPEBTQBMBWSBT JOUFSQSFUBP JOWFOUB OPWPTTFOUJEPTQBSBQBMBWSBTBOUJHBTPVDSJBOPWBTQBMBWSBTQB SBOPWPTTFOUJEPT0NPWJNFOUPEPDPOIFDFSn QPJT VNNPWJ NFOUPDVKPDPSQPnBMJOHVBHFN(SBmBTBFMB DPNQBSUJMIBNPT DPNPVUSPTPTOPTTPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTFSFDFCFNPTEFPVUSPT PTDPOIFDJNFOUPT &YQMJRVFQPSRVFPQFOTBNFOUPWBJNBJTMPOHFEPRVFB JOUFMJHpODJB 0QFOTBNFOUPWBJNBJTMPOHFRVFBJOUFMJHpODJBQPSRVF BCTUSBJ TFQBSB PTEBEPTEBTDPOEJm{FTJNFEJBUBTEFOPTTB FYQFSJpODJBFPTFMBCPSBTPCBGPSNBEFDPODFJUPT JEFJBTFKVr [PT FTUBCFMFDFOEPBSUJDVMBm{FTJOUFSOBTFOFDFTTgSJBTFOUSF FMFTQFMPSBDJPDrOJP JOEVmkPFEFEVmkP
QFMBBOgMJTFFQFMB TrOUFTF'PSNVMBUFPSJBT QSPDVSBQSPWgMBTFWFSJGJDgMBT QPJT FTUgWPMUBEPQBSBBWFSEBEFEPDPOIFDJNFOUP 2VFnVNDPODFJUPPVJEFJB 6NDPODFJUPPVJEFJBnVNBSFEFEFTJHOJGJDBm{FTRVFOPT PGFSFDFPTFOUJEPJOUFSOPFFTTFODJBMEBRVJMPBRVFTFSFGFSFPT OFYPTDBVTBJTPVBTSFMBm{FTOFDFTTgSJBTFOUSFTFVTFMFNFOUPT EFTPSUFRVFQPSFMFTDPOIFDFNPTBPSJHFN PTQSJODrQJPT BT DPOTFRVpODJBT BTDBVTBTFPTFGFJUPTEBRVJMPBRVFTFSFGFSF 2VFTkPPTKVr[PT +Vr[PTTkPBTSFMBm{FTFTUBCFMFDJEBTFOUSFBMHP VNTVKFJUP FPRVFTFBGJSNBPVOFHBEFMF QSFEJDBEP %FTTBNBOFJSB BUSB WnTEPTKVr[PTFTUBCFMFDFNPTPTFMPTJOUFSOPTFOFDFTTgSJPT FOUSFVNTFSFBTRVBMJEBEFT BTQSPQSJFEBEFT PTBUSJCVUPTRVF MIFQFSUFODFN BTTJNDPNPBRVFMFTQSFEJDBEPTRVFMIFTkPBDJ EFOUBJTFRVFQPEFNTFSSFUJSBEPTTFNRVFJTTPBGFUFPTFOUJEP FBSFBMJEBEFEFVNTFS 2VBOEPPTKVr[PTDPOTUJUVFNVNBUFPSJB 2VBOEPTFFTUBCFMFDFDPNDMBSF[BVNDBNQPEFPCKFUPTF PTQSPDFEJNFOUPTQBSBDPOIFDpMPTFFOVODJgMPTRVBOEPTF PSHBOJ[BNFTFPSEFOBNPTDPODFJUPTRVBOEPTFBSUJDVMBNF TFEFNPOTUSBNPTKVr[PT WFSJGJDBOEPTFVBDPSEPDPNSFHSBTF QSJODrQJPTEFSBDJPOBMJEBEFFEFNPOTUSBmkP 2VFnVNBUFPSJB %FPOEFFMBOBTDF 6NBUFPSJBnBFYQMJDBmkP EFTDSJmkPFJOUFSQSFUBmkPHFSBM EBTDBVTBT GPSNBT NPEBMJEBEFTFSFMBm{FTEFVNDBNQPEF PCKFUPTFMBCPSBEPTQFMPQFOTBNFOUPBUSBWnTEFQSPDFEJNFO UPTFTQFDrGJDPT NnUPEPT
QSwQSJPThOBUVSF[BEPTPCKFUPT JOWFTUJHBEPT"UFPSJBQPEFPVOkPOBTDFSEFVNBQSgUJDB NBTOkPnFMBRVFQFSNJUFEFUFSNJOBSVNBWFSEBEFPVGBMTJ EBEFUFwSJDB FTJNDSJUnSJPTJOUFSOPThQSwQSJBUFPSJB TFKBTVB DPSSFTQPOEpODJBDPNBTDPJTBTUFPSJ[BEBT TFKBBDPFSpODJB JOUFSOBEFTFVTBSHVNFOUPT TFVTSBDJPDrOJPT TVBTEFNPOT USBm{FTFTVBTQSPWBT TFKB FOGJN BDPOTJTUpODJBMwHJDBEF TVBTTJHOJGJDBm{FT 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTGJOBMJEBEFTEPNnUPEPQBSBPDPOIFDJ NFOUP 1PSRVFTFEJ[RVFFMFUFNVNQBQFMSFHVMBEPS 1SJODJQBJTGJOBMJEBEFTEPNnUPEPDPOEV[JShEFTDPCFSUBEF VNBWFSEBEFBUnFOUkPEFTDPOIFDJEBQFSNJUJSBEFNPOTUSBmkP
FBQSPWBEFVNBWFSEBEFKgDPOIFDJEBQFSNJUJSBWFSJGJDBmkP EFDPOIFDJNFOUPTQBSBBWFSJHVBSTFTkPPVOkPWFSEBEFJSPT0 NnUPEPUFNVNQBQFMSFHVMBEPSEPQFOTBNFOUPQPSRVFnFMF RVFHVJBPUSBCBMIPJOUFMFDUVBM QSPEVmkPEBTJEFJBT EPTFYQF SJNFOUPT EBTUFPSJBT FBWBMJBPTSFTVMUBEPTPCUJEPT &YQMJRVFPRVFTkPNnUPEPEFEVUJWP NnUPEPJOEVUJWPF NnUPEPEFDPNQSFFOTkPFJOUFSQSFUBmkP 0NnUPEPEFEVUJWPnQSwQSJPQBSBPCKFUPTRVFFYJTUFNBQF OBTJEFBMNFOUFFRVFTkPDPOTUSVrEPTJOUFJSBNFOUFQFMPOPTTP QFOTBNFOUPBPDPOUSgSJP PNnUPEPFYQFSJNFOUBM JTUPn JOEV UJWP nQSwQSJPEBTDJpODJBTOBUVSBJT RVFPCTFSWBNTFVTPCKFUPT FSFBMJ[BNFYQFSJNFOUPThTDJpODJBTIVNBOBT DBCFPNnUPEP EFDPNQSFFOTkPFJOUFSQSFUBmkPEPTFOUJEPEBTBm{FT EBTQSg UJDBT EPTDPNQPSUBNFOUPT EBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJTFQPMrUJDBT EPTTFOUJNFOUPT EPTEFTFKPT EBTUSBOTGPSNBm{FTIJTUwSJDBT QPJTPIPNFN PCKFUPEFTTBTDJpODJBT nVNTFSIJTUwSJDPDVM UVSBMRVFQSPEV[BTJOTUJUVJm{FTFPTFOUJEPEFMBT5BMTFOUJEPn PRVFQSFDJTBTFSDPOIFDJEP 1PSRVFPNnUPEPOBTDJpODJBTFYBUBTUBNCnNnDIBNBEP EFBYJPNgUJDP 1PSRVFCBTFJBPDPOIFDJNFOUPOVNDPOKVOUPEFUFSNPT QSJNJUJWPTFEFBYJPNBTJOEFNPOTUSgWFJTRVFTkPPQPOUPEF QBSUJEBEBDPOTUSVmkPFEFNPOTUSBmkPEPTPCKFUPT 1PSRVFPNnUPEPEBTDJpODJBTOBUVSBJTUBNCnNnDIBNBEP EFFYQFSJNFOUBMFIJQPUnUJDP &YQFSJNFOUBM QPSRVF TF CBTFJB FN PCTFSWBm{FT F FN FYQFSJNFOUPT UBOUPQBSBGPSNVMBSRVBOUPQBSBWFSJGJDBSBT UFPSJBT)JQPUnUJDPQPSRVFPTDJFOUJTUBTQBSUFNEFIJQwUFTFT TPCSFPTPCKFUPTRVFHVJBNPTFYQFSJNFOUPTFBBWBMJBmkP EPTSFTVMUBEPT 1PSRVFPNnUPEPOBTDJpODJBTIVNBOBTUBNCnNnDIBNB EPEFDPNQSFFOTJWPJOUFSQSFUBUJWP 1PSRVFTFVPCKFUPTkPBTTJHOJGJDBm{FTPVPTTFOUJEPTEPT DPNQPSUBNFOUPT EBTQSgUJDBTFEBTJOTUJUVJm{FTSFBMJ[BEBTPV QSPEV[JEBTQFMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT 2VBJTPTUSBmPTDPNVOTBPTEJGFSFOUFTNnUPEPTGJMPTwGJ DPT 0NnUPEPnSFGMFYJWP QBSUFEBBVUPBOgMJTFPVEPBVUPDP OIFDJNFOUPEPQFOTBNFOUP DSrUJDP JOWFTUJHBPTGVOEBNFOUPT FBTDPOEJm{FTOFDFTTgSJBTEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPDPOIFDJNFOUP WFSEBEFJSP EBBmkPnUJDB EBDSJBmkPBSUrTUJDBFEBBUJWJEBEFQP MrUJDB EFTDSJUJWP EFTDSFWFBTFTUSVUVSBTJOUFSOBTPVFTTpODJBT EFDBEBDBNQPEFPCKFUPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFEBTGPSNBTEF BmkPIVNBOB JOUFSQSFUBUJWP CVTDBBTGPSNBTEBMJOHVBHFNF BTTJHOJGJDBm{FTPVPTTFOUJEPTEPTPCKFUPT EPTGBUPT EBTQSg UJDBTFEBTJOTUJUVJm{FT TVBTPSJHFOTFUSBOTGPSNBm{FT $PNPBOFVSPMPHJB BBOBUPNJBFBGJTJPMPHJBEPDnSFCSP IVNBOPPEFTDSFWFN 2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEFTTBEFT DSJmkPQBSBEJTUJOHVJSNPTJOEJWrEVPTFDVMUVSBTQFMPUJQPEF QFOTBNFOUPRVFEFTFOWPMWFN .PTUSBNRVFFTTFwSHkPQPTTVJEVBTQBSUFTPVEPJTIFNJT GnSJPT OVNEFMFTMPDBMJ[BOEPTFBMJOHVBHFNFPQFOTBNFOUP TJNCwMJDPTFBGFUJWPT QSPQFOTPTBPNBSBWJMIPTPFhJNBHJOB mkPDSJBEPSB FOPVUSPBMJOHVBHFNFPQFOTBNFOUPDPODFJUVBJT "QBSUJSEFTTBDPODFQmkP BQSFEPNJOiODJBEPQFOTBNFOUP DPODFJUVBMPVEPQFOTBNFOUPNrUJDPFNVNBQFTTPBPVOVNB
/0
Manual do Professor
DVMUVSBEFQFOEF QPSVNMBEP EBTUFOEpODJBTQFTTPBJTFEB IJTUwSJBEFWJEBEPTJOEJWrEVPTF EFPVUSPMBEP EPNPEPDPNP VNBTPDJFEBEFPVVNBDVMUVSBSFDPSSFNNBJTBVNBEPRVFh PVUSBGPSNBQBSBJOUFSQSFUBSBSFBMJEBEF JOUFSWJSOPNVOEPF FYQMJDBSTFBTJNFTNB 4FHVOEP-nWJ4USBVTT RVBJTTkPBTUSpTQSJODJQBJTDBSBD UFSrTUJDBTPVGVOm{FTEPNJUP 'VOmkPFYQMJDBUJWBPQSFTFOUFnFYQMJDBEPQPSBMHVNBBmkP QBTTBEBDVKPTFGFJUPTQFSNBOFDFSBNOPUFNQPGVOmkPPSHBOJ [BUJWBPNJUPPSHBOJ[BBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJT QBSFOUFTDP EFBMJBO mBT EFUSPDBT EFQPEFS EFNPEPBMFHJUJNBSFHBSBOUJSBQFS NBOpODJBEFVNTJTUFNBDPNQMFYPEFQSPJCJm{FTFQFSNJTT{FT GVOmkPDPNQFOTBUwSJBPNJUPOBSSBVNBTJUVBmkPQBTTBEB RVF nBOFHBmkPEPQSFTFOUFFRVFTFSWFUBOUPQBSBDPNQFOTBSPT TFSFTIVNBOPTEFBMHVNBQFSEBDPNPQBSBHBSBOUJSMIFTRVF VNFSSPQBTTBEPGPJDPSSJHJEPOPQSFTFOUF EFNPEPBPGFSFDFS VNBWJTkPFTUBCJMJ[BEBEBOBUVSF[BFEBWJEBDPNVOJUgSJB &TDPMIBVNNJUPFNPTUSFDPNPFMFFYQMJDBVNBSFBMJEB EF 1SPGFTTPS B $BEBBMVOPQPEFBQSFTFOUBSFYFNQMPTEF NJUPTRVFFYQMJDBNEFUFSNJOBEBTSFBMJEBEFTBQBSUJSEFEJWFS TJGJDBEBTUSBEJm{FTHSFHB SPNBOB FHrQDJB JOErHFOB KVEBJDP DSJTUk FUD*NQPSUBRVFFMFDPOTJHBFTUBCFMFDFSBSFMBmkPFOUSF BDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTJNCwMJDBEPTNJUPTFPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTEB SFBMJEBEF/FTTFTFOUJEP VNFYFNQMPDPNVNBQSBUJDBNFOUF UPEBTBTSFMJHJ{FTnPDBTPEPTNJUPTDSJBDJPOJTUBTRVFFYQMJDBN PTVSHJNFOUPEPIPNFN/BUSBEJmkPKVEBJDPDSJTUk JTTPnFY QMJDBEPDPNPNJUPEF"EkPF&WB &YQMJRVFQPSRVFPNJUPnVNBSFEFEFNFUgGPSBTFEFTrN CPMPTRVFQSFDJTBNTFSEFDJGSBEPTPVJOUFSQSFUBEPT 1PSRVFQPSNFJPEBTNFUgGPSBTFEPTTrNCPMPTPNJUPFO DBSOBTFOUJEPTN|MUJQMPTFTJNVMUiOFPTRVFTFSWFNQBSBFYQMJ DBSDPJTBTEJGFSFOUFTPVQBSBTVCTUJUVJSVNBDPJTBQPSPVUSB %FDJGSBSPVJOUFSQSFUBSFTTFTTrNCPMPTNrUJDPTnVNBGPSNBQFMB RVBMPTIPNFOTQPEFNBERVJSJSBMHVNQPEFSQBSBEPNJOBSP EFTDPOIFDJEP DPOUSPMBSBOBUVSF[B FUD&MFGB[JTUPQPSNFJP EBJNJUBmkPOPTSJUVBJT
#APqTULOß߯ßß=_kjo_e j_e]lk`a_kjda_an pq`k; 4FHVOEP'SFVE RVBJTTkPBTUSpTGFSJEBTOBSDrTJDBTRVFP QFOTBNFOUPPDJEFOUBMJNQyTBPTTFSFTIVNBOPT "QSJNFJSBGPJBRVFOPTJOGMJHJV$PQnSOJDP BPQSPWBSRVFB 5FSSBOkPFTUBWBOPDFOUSPEP6OJWFSTPFRVFPTIPNFOTOkP SBNPDFOUSPEPNVOEP"TFHVOEBGPJDBVTBEBQPS%BSXJO F BPQSPWBSRVFPTIPNFOTEFTDFOEFNEFVNQSJNBUBFRVFTkP BQFOBTVNFMPOBFWPMVmkPEBTFTQnDJFTFOkPTFSFTFTQFDJBJT DSJBEPTQPS%FVTQBSBEPNJOBSBOBUVSF[B"UFSDFJSBGPJDBVTB EBQFMPQSwQSJP'SFVEDPNBQTJDBOgMJTF BPNPTUSBSRVFBDPOT DJpODJBnBNFOPSQBSUFFBNBJTGSBDBEFOPTTBWJEBQTrRVJDB 0RVFnJTTPRVF'SFVEDIBNPVEFQTJDBOgMJTF 1TJDBOgMJTFnBBOgMJTFEBWJEBQTrRVJDB'SFVETFSFDVTB BDPOTJEFSBSRVFBDPOTDJpODJBnBFTTpODJBEBWJEBQTrRVJDBF QPSJTTPUPSOBPCKFUPDFOUSBMEBQTJDBOgMJTFPFTUVEPEPJODPOT DJFOUF DVKBGJOBMJEBEFFSBBDVSBEBTQFSUVSCBm{FTFEPFOmBT
/1
NFOUBJTUFOEPQPSNnUPEPBJOUFSQSFUBmkPFDPNPJOTUSVNFOUP BMJOHVBHFN $PNP'SFVEDIFHPVBPDPODFJUPEFJODPOTDJFOUF 'SFVEFTUBWBJOTBUJTGFJUPDPNPTSFTVMUBEPTPCUJEPTOPUSB UBNFOUPEPTEPFOUFTNFOUBJTGFJUPDPNUnDOJDBTEFIJQOPTF FTVHFTUkP&OUkPQBTTPVBVTBSVNOPWPQSPDFEJNFOUPUFSB QpVUJDPEFOPNJOBEP²UnDOJDBEFBTTPDJBmkPMJWSF³"QBSUJSEBr PCTFSWPVFNDPOWFSTBTDPNVNBQBDJFOUFRVFBTSFBm{FTBQSF TFOUBEBTQPSFMB TPOIPT MFNCSBOmBT FNPm{FT TFOUJNFOUPT FUD FSBNEFUFSNJOBEBTQPSVNBWJEBJODPOTDJFOUFEFTDPOIFDJ EB'PJFOUkPRVFFMFDPNQSFFOEFVRVFTPNFOUFJOUFSQSFUBOEP BTQBMBWSBT PTTPOIPT BTMFNCSBOmBTFPTHFTUPTEBQBDJFOUF nRVFDIFHBSJBBFTTBWJEBJODPOTDJFOUF $PNP'SFVEEFTDSFWFBFTUSVUVSBFPGVODJPOBNFOUPEBWJEB QTrRVJDB 4FHVOEP'SFVE BWJEBQTrRVJDBnGPSNBEBQPSUSpTJOTUiO DJBT EVBTEFMBTJODPOTDJFOUFTFBQFOBTVNBDPOTDJFOUF1BSB JOEJDgMBT FMFVTPVPTUFSNPT²JTTP³ ²FV³F²TVQFSFV³ RVF DPTUVNBNBQBSFDFSFNUFSNPTWJOEPTEPMBUJN±PJE PFHPF PTVQFSFHP0JEnBJOTUiODJBJOUFJSBNFOUFJODPOTDJFOUFPFHP BJOTUiODJBDPOTDJFOUFPTVQFSFHPQPTTVJBTQFDUPTJODPOTDJFO UFTFBTQFDUPTDPOTDJFOUFT 2VBJTBTGBTFTEBTFYVBMJEBEFJOGBOUJM TFHVOEP'SFVE 'BTFPSBM RVBOEPPEFTFKPFPQSB[FSMPDBMJ[BNTFQSJNPS EJBMNFOUFOBCPDBFOBJOHFTUkPEFBMJNFOUPTFPTFJPNBUFSOP nPPCKFUPEFQSB[FSBGBTFBOBM RVBOEPPEFTFKPFPQSB[FS MPDBMJ[BNTFQSJNPSEJBMNFOUFOBTFYDSFm{FTFOBTGF[FTFPT PCKFUPTEFQSB[FSTkPCSJODBSDPNNBTTBTFDPNUJOUBT BNBT TBSCBSSPPVBSHJMB DPNFSDPJTBTDSFNPTBT TVKBSTFFBGBTF GgMJDB RVBOEPPEFTFKPFPQSB[FSMPDBMJ[BNTFQSJNPSEJBMNFOUF OPwSHkPHFOJUBMNBTDVMJOP PGBMPPVQpOJT QPJTBDSJBOmB NF OJOPPVNFOJOB TwSFDPOIFDFFTTFwSHkPTFYVBM/FTTBGBTF QBSBPTNFOJOPT BNkFnPPCKFUPEPEFTFKPFEPQSB[FSQBSB BTNFOJOBT nPQBJ 1PSRVFPDPNQMFYPEFcEJQPnPDPNQMFYPOVDMFBSEBTOFV SPTFT 2VBOEPFTUFDPNQMFYPTFEFTFOWPMWF 1PSRVFnFTTFEFTFKPGVOEBNFOUBM EFTFKPJODFTUVPTPQFMB NkFPVQFMPQBJ RVFPSHBOJ[BBUPUBMJEBEFEBWJEBQTrRVJDBF EFUFSNJOBPTFOUJEPEFOPTTBTWJEBT QPJTUVEPEFQFOEFSgEF DPNPBDSJBOmBDPOTFHVJSgPVOkPTVQFSBSFTTFDPNQMFYPRVF TFEFTFOWPMWFOPDFOUSPEPJEEVSBOUFBUFSDFJSBGBTFEPEFTFO WPMWJNFOUPEBTFYVBMJEBEFJOGBOUJM GBTFGgMJDB 1PSRVFPFHPPVBDPOTDJpODJBnVN²QPCSFDPJUBEP³ 1PSRVFFTUgFTQSFNJEPFOUSFUSpTFTDSBWJE{FTPVUSpTTF OIPSFTPTEFTFKPTJOTBDJgWFJTEPJE BTFWFSJEBEFSFQSFTTJWB EPTVQFSFHPFPTQFSJHPTEPNVOEP1PSFTTFNPUJWP BGPSNB GVOEBNFOUBMEBFYJTUpODJBQBSBPTVQFSFHPnBBOH|TUJB 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFDPOUF|EPNBOJGFTUPFDPOUF|EPMB UFOUFEFOPTTPTBUPT HFTUPT QBMBWSBT TPOIPT $POUF|EPNBOJGFTUPnPRVFTFBQSFTFOUBJOEJSFUBNFOUF hOPTTBDPOTDJpODJBBUSBWnTEPTTPOIPT MBQTPT BUPTGBMIPT FUD$POUF|EPMBUFOUFnPDPOUF|EPJODPOTDJFOUFRVFSFBMNFO UFFTUgQPSUSgTEPRVFTPOIBNPT GB[FNPT GBMBNPT FUD PT EFTFKPTTFYVBJT
| U NIDADE 5
|
O conhecimento
$PNPPQFSBPJODPOTDJFOUF JEFTVQFSFHP 2VBMBGVOmkP EPTTPOIPT EPTTJOUPNBTFEBTVCMJNBmkP
FRVFBDBCBNQPSSFWFMBSBFTUSVUVSBGVOEBNFOUBMEBTTPDJFEB EFTDPNPEJWJTkPTPDJBMEBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT
0JODPOTDJFOUFPQFSBBUSBWnTEPJEFEPTVQFSFHP0JEn GPSNBEPQPSJOTUJOUPT JNQVMTPTPSHiOJDPTFEFTFKPTJODPOT DJFOUFT QVMT{FT SFHJEPTQFMPQSJODrQJPEPQSB[FS RVFFYJHF TBUJTGBmkPJNFEJBUB0TVQFSFHPnBDFOTVSBEBTQVMT{FT RVFB TPDJFEBEFFBDVMUVSBJNQ{FNBPJE JNQFEJOEPPEFTBUJTGB[FS QMFOBNFOUFTFVTJOTUJOUPTFEFTFKPTcBSFQSFTTkPNBOJGFT UBEBhDPOTDJpODJB JOEJSFUBNFOUF TPCBGPSNBEBNPSBMFEB FEVDBmkP$PNPPJODPOTDJFOUFFTUgJNQFEJEPEFNBOJGFTUBSTF EJSFUBNFOUFhDPOTDJpODJB PTTPOIPT PTTJOUPNBT OFVSPTFT FQTJDPTFT FBTVCMJNBmkPUpNBGVOmkPEFQFSNJUJSJOEJSFUB NFOUFFTTBNBOJGFTUBmkPTBUJTGB[FOEPPTEFTFKPTJODPOTDJFO UFT JE SFQSJNJEPTQFMBNPSBMTPDJBM TVQFSFHP
1PSRVFBBGJSNBmkP²PTIPNFOTGB[FNBIJTUwSJB NBTOkP TBCFNRVFBGB[FN³BTTJOBMBBFYJTUpODJBEFVNBEVQMB BMJFOBmkPTPDJBM
%JBOUFEPQPEFSEPJODPOTDJFOUF 'SFVEEFGFOEFVBGPSmBEP QFOTBNFOUP1PSRVp 1PSRVFnPQFOTBNFOUPRVFQFSNJUFBUSBWFTTBSQSPJCJm{FT FSFQSFTT{FTFCVTDBSBWFSEBEF OkPGB[FOEPDPODFTT{FThT JEFJBTFTUBCFMFDJEBT hNPSBMWJHFOUF BPTQSFDPODFJUPTFhT PQJOJ{FTEFOPTTBTPDJFEBEF NBTPTFOGSFOUBOEPFNOPNF EBQSwQSJBSB[kPFEPQFOTBNFOUP NFTNPRVFQBSBJTTPTFKB QSFDJTPEFTNPOUBSBCFMBJNBHFNRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTUpN EFTJNFTNPT 0RVFnBMJFOBmkPSFMJHJPTB &BMJFOBmkPFNHFSBM "BMJFOBmkPnPGFOyNFOPQFMPRVBMPTIPNFOTDSJBNPV QSPEV[FNBMHVNBDPJTB EkPJOEFQFOEpODJBBFTTBDSJBUVSB DPNPTFFMBFYJTUJTTFQPSTJNFTNBFFNTJNFTNB EFJYBN TFHPWFSOBSQPSFMBDPNPTFFMBUJWFTTFQPEFSFNTJFQPSTJ NFTNB OkPTFSFDPOIFDFNOBPCSBRVFDSJBSBN GB[FOEPBVN TFSPVUSP TFQBSBEPEPTIPNFOT TVQFSJPSBFMFTFDPNQPEFS TPCSFFMFT%FTTBNBOFJSB BBMJFOBmkPSFMJHJPTBTVSHFEBQSP KFmkPEFVNTFSTVQFSJPSEPUBEPEBTNFMIPSFTRVBMJEBEFTF RVFFYQMJDBBPSJHFNFBGJOBMJEBEFEPNVOEP1PVDPBQPVDP PTIVNBOPTTFFTRVFDFNEFRVFGPSBNPTDSJBEPSFTEFTTFTFS FQBTTBNBBDSFEJUBSOPJOWFSTP PVTFKB RVFFTTFTFSGPJRVFN PTDSJPVFHPWFSOB/kPTFSFDPOIFDFNOFTTFPVUSP BMJFOVT RVFDSJBSBN 2VBMPJOUFSFTTFEF.BSYQFMBBMJFOBmkPTPDJBM BSYJOUFSFTTPVTFFNDPNQSFFOEFSBTDBVTBTQFMBT . RVBJTPTIPNFOTJHOPSBNRVFTkPPTDSJBEPSFTEBTPDJFEBEF EBQPMrUJDB EBDVMUVSBFBHFOUFTEBIJTUwSJB*OUFSFTTPVTF FNDPNQSFFOEFSQPSRVFPTIVNBOPTBDSFEJUBNRVFBTP DJFEBEFOkPGPJJOTUJUVrEBQPSFMFT NBTQPSWPOUBEFFPCSB EPTEFVTFTPVQFMBGPSmBDFHBEBTMFJTEBOBUVSF[B FNWF[ EFQFSDFCFSFNRVFTkPFMFTQSwQSJPTRVF FNDPOEJm{FTIJT UwSJDBTEFUFSNJOBEBT DSJBNBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJT GBNrMJB FTDPMB SFMJHJkP FUD FBTJOTUJUVJm{FTQPMrUJDBT MFJT &TUBEP FYnSDJUP FUD $PNP.BSYFYQMJDBBPSJHFNEBBMJFOBmkPTPDJBMDPNCBTF OBEFTDSJmkPEPTVSHJNFOUPEBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJTFQPMr UJDBTGVOEBEBTOBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT &TUVEBOEPDPNPBTTPDJFEBEFTTkPQSPEV[JEBTIJTUPSJDB NFOUFQFMBQSgYJTEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT .BSYPCTFSWPVRVFB TPDJFEBEFOBTDFQFMBFTUSVUVSBmkPEFVNDPOKVOUPEFEJWJT{FT USBCBMIP QPEFS SJRVF[B CFOT FUD RVFTFUPSOBDBEBWF[NBJT DPNQMFYP JOUSJODBEP OVNFSPTP NVMUJQMJDBOEPTFFNNVJUBT PVUSBTEJWJT{FT TPCBGPSNBEFOVNFSPTBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJT
1PSRVF QPSVNMBEP PTTFSFTIVNBOPTBDSFEJUBNRVFGB [FNPRVFGB[FNFQFOTBNPRVFQFOTBNQPSRVFTkPJOEJWrEVPT MJWSFT BVUyOPNPTFDPNQPEFSQBSBNVEBSPDVSTPEBTDPJTBT DPNPFRVBOEPRVJTFSFN BQFTBSEBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJTFEBT DPOEJm{FTIJTUwSJDBT PVTFKB JHOPSBNRVFBTPDJFEBEFJOTUJUVr EBEFUFSNJOBTFVTQFOTBNFOUPTFBm{FTQPSPVUSPMBEP FBP NFTNPUFNQP PTIPNFOTOkPTFSFDPOIFDFNDPNPBVUPSFTF BHFOUFTEBWJEBTPDJBMDPNTVBTJOTUJUVJm{FT PVTFKB OkPQFS DFCFNRVFJOTUJUVFNBTPDJFEBEF 2VBJTTkPBTUSpTGPSNBTEBBMJFOBmkPOPNPEPEFQSPEV mkPDBQJUBMJTUB " BMJFOBmkP TPDJBM OB RVBM PT IVNBOPT OkP TF SFDP OIFDFNDPNPQSPEVUPSFTEBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJPQPMrUJDBTF PTDJMBNFOUSFEVBTBUJUVEFTBDFJUBNQBTTJWBNFOUFUVEPP RVFFYJTUFPVTFSFCFMBNBDIBOEPRVFBSFBMJEBEFOkPUFN OFOIVNQPEFSTPCSFFMFTBBMJFOBmkPFDPOyNJDB OBRVBM PTQSPEVUPSFTOkPTFSFDPOIFDFNDPNPQSPEVUPSFT OFN TFSFDPOIFDFNOPTPCKFUPTQSPEV[JEPTQPSTFVUSBCBMIPB BMJFOBmkPJOUFMFDUVBM SFTVMUBOUFEBTFQBSBmkPTPDJBMFOUSF USBCBMIPNBUFSJBM RVFQSPEV[NFSDBEPSJB FRVFOkPFYJHF DPOIFDJNFOUPT NBTTwIBCJMJEBEFTNBOVBJT FUSBCBMIPJO UFMFDUVBM RVFQSPEV[JEFJBT
SFTQPOTgWFMFYDMVTJWPQFMPT DPOIFDJNFOUPT 0RVFnJEFPMPHJB $PNPFMBTVSHF "JEFPMPHJBnVNB²UFPSJB³EPDPOIFDJNFOUPFTQPOUiOFB RVFGPSNBPTFOTPDPNVNEBTPDJFEBEF1PSTFVJOUFSNnEJP TkPJNBHJOBEBTFYQMJDBm{FTFKVTUJGJDBUJWBTQBSBBSFBMJEBEFUBM DPNPnEJSFUBNFOUFQFSDFCJEBFWJWJEB&MBTVSHFEFVNBFMBCP SBmkPJOUFMFDUVBMTPCSFBSFBMJEBEF QSPEV[JEBQPSQFOTBEPSFT PVJOUFMFDUVBJTEBTPDJFEBEF TBDFSEPUFT QSPGFTTPSFT KPSOBMJT UBT FUD
RVFEFTDSFWFNFFYQMJDBNPNVOEPBQBSUJSEPQPOUP EFWJTUBEBDMBTTFEPNJOBOUFEFTVBTPDJFEBEF 2VBMBQSJODJQBMGVOmkPEBJEFPMPHJB 2VBMTVBQSJODJQBM GJOBMJEBEF "GVOmkPQSJODJQBMEBJEFPMPHJBnPDVMUBSFEJTTJNVMBSBT EJWJT{FTTPDJBJTFQPMrUJDBT EBOEPMIFTBBQBSpODJBEFJOEJWJ TkPTPDJBMFEFEJGFSFOmBTOBUVSBJTFOUSFPTTFSFTIVNBOPT" QSJODJQBMGJOBMJEBEFnGB[FSDPNRVFUPEBTBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT BDFJUFNBTDPOEJm{FTFNRVFWJWFN KVMHBOEPBTOBUVSBJT OPSNBJT DPSSFUBT KVTUBT TFNQSFUFOEFSUSBOTGPSNgMBTPV DPOIFDpMBTSFBMNFOUF TFNMFWBSFNDPOUBRVFIgVNBDPO USBEJmkPQSPGVOEBFOUSFBTDPOEJm{FTSFBJTFNRVFWJWFNPT FBTJEFJBT &YQMJRVFDPNPJOWFSTkP JNBHJOgSJPTPDJBMFTJMpODJPTkPPT QSJODJQBJTQSPDFEJNFOUPTQBSBBPQFSBmkPEBJEFPMPHJB 1PSNFJPEBJOWFSTkP BJEFPMPHJBPQFSBDPNPPJODPOT DJFOUFRVFGBCSJDBJNBHFOTFTJOUPNBTQBSBTFNBOJGFTUBS Tw RVFGBCSJDBOEPJEFJBTFGBMTBTDBVTBMJEBEFT FNHFSBMDPMP DBOEPPTFGFJUPTOPMVHBSEBTDBVTBTFUSBOTGPSNBOEPFTUBT |MUJNBTFNFGFJUPT6NFYFNQMPEJTTPnBNVMIFSDPNP²EP OBEFDBTB³"USBWnTEPJNBHJOgSJPTPDJBM BJEFPMPHJBSFDPMIF BTJNBHFOTEJSFUBTFJNFEJBUBTEPNPEPDPNPWJWFNPTBT
/2
Manual do Professor
SFMBm{FTTPDJBJTFBTSFQSPEV[DPNPSFQSFTFOUBm{FT OPSNBT FWBMPSFTRVFFYQMJDBNUPEBBSFBMJEBEFFQSFTDSFWFNQBSB UPEBBTPDJFEBEFPRVFFMBEFWFUFSFDPNPEFWFQFOTBS GB MBS TFOUJSFBHJSnPFYFNQMPEBTQSPQBHBOEBTDPNFSDJBJT "USBWnTEPVTPEPTJMpODJP BJEFPMPHJBDSJBVNJNBHJOgSJP TPDJBMEPRVFEFWFTFSTJMFODJBEPnPFYFNQMPEBVOJkPDJWJM IPNPTTFYVBM 2VBJTBTTFNFMIBOmBTFOUSFBJEFPMPHJBFPJODPOTDJFOUF EFTDPCFSUPQFMBQTJDBOgMJTF 0GBUPEFRVFBEPUBNPTDSFOmBT PQJOJ{FTFJEFJBTTFNTB CFSEFPOEFWJFSBN TFNQFOTBSFNTVBTDBVTBTFNPUJWPT TFN BWBMJBSTFTkPPVOkPDPFSFOUFTFWFSEBEFJSBTJEFPMPHJBFJO DPOTDJFOUFPQFSBNQPSNFJPEPJNBHJOgSJP BTSFQSFTFOUBm{FTF SFHSBTTBrEBTEBFYQFSJpODJBJNFEJBUB FEPTJMpODJP SFBMJ[BOEP TFJOEJSFUBNFOUFQFSBOUFBDPOTDJpODJBJODPOTDJFOUFFJEFPMP HJBOkPTkPEFMJCFSBm{FTWPMVOUgSJBT0JODPOTDJFOUFQSFDJTBEF JNBHFOT TVCTUJUVUPT TPOIPT MBQTPT BUPTGBMIPT TVCMJNBmkP QBSBNBOJGFTUBSTFF BPNFTNPUFNQP FTDPOEFSTFEBDPOT DJpODJB"JEFPMPHJBQSFDJTBEBTJEFJBTJNBHFOT EBJOWFSTkPEF DBVTBTFFGFJUPT EPTJMpODJPQBSBNBOJGFTUBSPTJOUFSFTTFTEB DMBTTFEPNJOBOUFFFTDPOEpMPTDPNPJOUFSFTTFEFVNB|OJDB DMBTTFTPDJBM "TEFTDPCFSUBTEF.BSYF'SFVEJOWBMJEBNPUSBCBMIPDPOT DJFOUFEPQFOTBNFOUP 1FMPDPOUSgSJP DSJBSBNDPOEJm{FTQBSBVNBUPNBEBEF DPOTDJpODJBQFMBRVBMPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPQyEFSFDPNF mBSBDSrUJDBEBTJMVT{FTFEPTQSFDPODFJUPTRVFJOJDJBSBEFTEFB (SnDJB NBTBHPSBDPNPDSrUJDBEFTVBTQSwQSJBTJMVT{FTFQSF DPODFJUPT&NMVHBSEFJOWBMJEBSBSB[kP BSFGMFYkP PQFOTB NFOUPFBCVTDBEBWFSEBEF BTEFTDPCFSUBTEPJODPOTDJFOUF FEBJEFPMPHJBGJ[FSBNPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPDPOIFDFSBT DPOEJm{FT±QTrRVJDBT TPDJBJT IJTUwSJDBT±OBTRVBJTPDPOIF DJNFOUPFPQFOTBNFOUPTFSFBMJ[BN
5NIDADEßßßß=iap]boe_] )NTRODUljO߯ßß=oej`]c]aoiap]boe_]o 2VBMnDPOTJEFSBEBBRVFTUkPNFUBGrTJDBGVOEBNFOUBM 1PS RVFTPNPTMFWBEPTBGPSNVMgMB "RVFTUkPNFUBGrTJDBGVOEBNFOUBMnBQFSHVOUB²0RVFn ³ &TUBRVFTUkPnGSVUPEFOPTTBJORVJFUBmkPEJBOUFEBNVEBOmBF EJWFSTJEBEFRVFPDPSSFDPNBTDPJTBT PRVFOPTMFWBBEFTFKBS DPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEF|MUJNBEFUPEPTPTTFSFTPVBFTTpODJBEF UPEBSFBMJEBEF 2VBJTPTTFOUJEPTEPWFSCPnOBQFSHVOUB²0RVFn ³&QPS RVFEFGJOFNPTEPJTUFNBTQSJODJQBJTEBNFUBGrTJDB &TUFnQPTTVJEPJTTFOUJEPTQSJNFJSP TJHOJGJDB²FYJTUF³ EFNPEPRVFBQFSHVOUBTFSFGFSFhFYJTUpODJBEBSFBMJEBEFF QPEFTFSUSBOTDSJUBDPNP²0RVFFYJTUF ³TFHVOEP TJHOJGJDB ²OBUVSF[BQSwQSJBEFBMHVNBDPJTB³ EFNPEPRVFBQFSHVOUB TFSFGFSFhFTTpODJBEBSFBMJEBEF QPEFOEPTFSUSBOTDSJUBDP NP²2VBMnBFTTpODJBEBRVJMPRVFFYJTUF ³1PSUBOUP FYJT UpODJBFFTTpODJBEFGJOFNTFDPNPPTEPJTUFNBTQSJODJQBJT
/3
EBNFUBGrTJDBQPSTFSFGFSJSFNhSFBMJEBEFFNTFVTN|MUJQMPT BTQFDUPT 0RVFBNFUBGrTJDBJOWFTUJHB "NFUBGrTJDBJOWFTUJHBPTGVOEBNFOUPT PTQSJODrQJPTFBT DBVTBTFPTFSrOUJNPEFUPEBTBTDPJTBT JOEBHBOEPQPSRVF FYJTUFNFQPSRVFTkPPRVFTkP 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTQFSrPEPTEBIJTUwSJBEBNFUBGrTJDB 0QFSrPEPRVFWBJEF1MBUkPF"SJTUwUFMFT TnDT*7F***B$ BUn%BWJE)VNF TnD97***E$ PQFSrPEPRVFWBJEF,BOU TnD 97*** BUnBGFOPNFOPMPHJBEF)VTTFSM TnD99 BNFUBGrTJDB PVPOUPMPHJBDPOUFNQPSiOFB BQBSUJSEPTBOPTEPTnDVMP 99 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEPQSJNFJSPQFSrPEPEB NFUBGrTJDB /FTTFQFSrPEPnJOWFTUJHBEBBSFBMJEBEFFNTJNFTNB BRVJ MPRVFnPVFYJTUFnVNDPOIFDJNFOUPSBDJPOBMBQSJPSrTUJDP JTUP n OkPTFCBTFJBOPTEBEPTDPOIFDJEPTEJSFUBNFOUFQFMBFY QFSJpODJBTFOTrWFMPVTFOTPSJBMnVNDPOIFDJNFOUPTJTUFNgUJ DP JTUPn DBEBDPODFJUPEFQFOEFEFPVUSPTFTFSFMBDJPOBDPN PVUSPT GPSNBOEPVNTJTUFNBDPFSFOUFEFJEFJBTMJHBEBTFOUSF TJFYJHFBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFTFSFQBSFDFSPVFOUSFSFBMJEBEFF BQBSpODJB 2VFEJ[)VNF 1PSRVFDPNFMFUFSNJOBPQSJNFJSPQFSrPEP EBNFUBGrTJDB )VNFEJ[RVFPTDPODFJUPTNFUBGrTJDPTTkPNFSPTOPNFT HFSBJTQBSBBTDPJTBT OPNFTRVFOPTWpNQFMPIgCJUPNFOUBM PVQTrRVJDPEFBTTPDJBSFNJEFJBTBTTFOTBm{FT BTQFSDFQ m{FTFBTJNQSFTT{FTEPTTFOUJEPTSFUJEBTOBNFNwSJB" QBSUJSEFTTBBGJSNBmkP )VNFFYQMJDBRVFPTDPODFJUPTNF UBGrTJDPTOkPDPSSFTQPOEFNBOFOIVNBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSOB FYJTUFOUFFNTJNFTNBFJOEFQFOEFOUFEFOwT PRVFUPSOB JNQPTTrWFMBDPOUJOVJEBEFEBNFUBGrTJDBUBMDPNPFYJTUJSB OPQSJNFJSPQFSrPEP EFTEFPTnDVMP*7B$
CBTFBEBOBT BGJSNBm{FTEFRVFBSFBMJEBEFFYJTUFFNTJNFTNBFRVFP JOUFMFDUPIVNBOPQPTTVJPQPEFSQBSBDPOIFDpMBUBMDPNP nFNTJNFTNB 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVF DPN,BOU BNFUBGrTJDBnTVCTUJUVrEB QFMBDSrUJDBEBSB[kPQVSBUFwSJDB ,BOUEFNPOTUSBBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPTDPODFJUPTUSBEJDJP OBJTEBNFUBGrTJDBQBSBBMDBOmBSFDPOIFDFSBSFBMJEBEFFNTJ EBTDPJTBT%FTTBGPSNB PGJMwTPGPQSPQ{FRVFBNFUBGrTJDB TFKBPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFOPTTBQSwQSJBDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOIF DFSUPNBOEPBSFBMJEBEFDPNPBRVJMPRVFFYJTUFQBSBOwTFn PSHBOJ[BEPQPSOPTTBSB[kPFORVBOUPTPNPTPTVKFJUPEPDP OIFDJNFOUP 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBNFUBGrTJDBDPOUFN QPSiOFB *OWFTUJHBPTEJGFSFOUFTNPEPTDPNPPTFOUFTPVPTTFSFT FYJTUFNJOWFTUJHBBFTTpODJBPVPTFOUJEP BTJHOJGJDBmkP F BFTUSVUVSBEFTTFTFOUFTPVTFSFTJOWFTUJHBBSFMBmkPOFDFT TgSJBFOUSFBFYJTUpODJBFBFTTpODJBEPTFOUFTFPNPEPDPNP BQBSFDFNQBSBBOPTTBDPOTDJpODJBUFNVNDBSgUFSEFTDSJUJ WP JTUPn FNWF[EFPGFSFDFSVNBFYQMJDBmkPDBVTBMEBSFB MJEBEF nVNBEFTDSJmkPEBTFTUSVUVSBTEPNVOEPFEPOPTTP QFOTBNFOUP
| U NIDADE 6
|
A metafísica
#APqTULOß߯ßßKj]o_eiajpk`]iap]boe_] 2VBMFSBBQFSHVOUBGJMPTwGJDBGFJUBBUnPTnDVMP97** 2VBM FSBPTJHOJGJDBEPEFTTBQFSHVOUB "QFSHVOUBFSB²0RVFnBSFBMJEBEFRVFOPTTPQFOTBNFO UPDPOIFDF ³0TJHOJGJDBEPEFTTBQFSHVOUBnBDPODFQmkPSFB MJTUBEBGJMPTPGJBRVFTFUJOIBEFTEFPTHSFHPT JTUPn CBTFBEB OBFYJTUpODJBEBSFBMJEBEF 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBGJMPTPGJBOBTDFDPNPDPTNPMPHJB 0RVFFSBBDPTNPMPHJB %FWJEPhBENJSBmkPFFTQBOUPEJBOUFEPNVOEP BGJMPTPGJB TVSHFDPNPCVTDBEFVNBFYQMJDBmkPSBDJPOBMQBSBBPSJHFN EFVNNVOEPPSEFOBEP PDPTNP%BrPTJHOJGJDBEPEBQBMBWSB DPTNPMPHJB DPNPWJNPTOB6OJEBEF²DPOIFDJNFOUPSBDJPOBM EBPSEFNEPNVOEPPVEBOBUVSF[B³ EFDPTNPT RVFTJHOJGJDB ²NVOEPPSEFOBEPFPSHBOJ[BEP³ FMPHJB RVFWFNEBQBMBWSB MPHPTFRVFTJHOJGJDB²QFOTBNFOUPSBDJPOBM EJTDVSTPSBDJPOBM DPOIFDJNFOUP³ 1PSUBOUP BDPTNPMPHJBFSBVNBFYQMJDBmkP SBDJPOBMRVFTFCBTFBWBOBCVTDBEPQSJODrQJP BQIZTJT RVF DBVTBFPSEFOBUVEPRVBOUPFYJTUFOBOBUVSF[BFUVEPRVBOUP OFMBBDPOUFDF 2VBMBPSJHFNEPFNQSFHPEBQBMBWSBNFUBGrTJDB $PNRVF TFOUJEPGPJFNQSFHBEB "QBMBWSBNFUBGrTJDBGPJFNQSFHBEBQSJNFJSBNFOUFQPS"O ESyOJDPEF3PEFT QPSWPMUBEPBOPB$ RVBOEPSFDPMIFVF DMBTTJGJDPVBTPCSBTEF"SJTUwUFMFTRVF EVSBOUFNVJUPTTnDVMPT IBWJBNGJDBEPEJTQFSTBTFQFSEJEBT0TFOUJEPEFNFUBGrTJDB FNQSFHBEPQPS"OESyOJDPEF3PEFTFSBVNBSFGFSpODJBBPDPO KVOUPEFFTDSJUPTEF"SJTUwUFMFTRVFMPDBMJ[BWBNTFBQwTPTUSB UBEPTTPCSFGrTJDBPVTPCSFBOBUVSF[B&NHSFHP BFYQSFTTkP UhNFUBUhQIZTJDBTJHOJGJDBMJUFSBMNFOUF²BRVFMFT FTDSJUPT RVF FTUkP DBUBMPHBEPT BQwTPT FTDSJUPT EBGrTJDB³ 2VFTJHOJGJDBBQBMBWSBPOUPMPHJB 0OUPMPHJBnDPNQPTUBEFEVBTPVUSBTQBMBWSBTHSFHBT POUP FMPHJB FTJHOJGJDB²FTUVEPPVDPOIFDJNFOUPEPTFS EPTFOUFT PVEBTDPJTBTUBJTDPNPTkPFNTJNFTNBT SFBMFWFSEBEFJSB NFOUF DPSSFTQPOEFOEPBPRVF"SJTUwUFMFTDIBNBSBEFGJMPTPGJB QSJNFJSB JTUPn PFTUVEPEP4FSFORVBOUP4FS 3FMBDJPOFBEFGJOJmkPRVF"SJTUwUFMFTEgEBGJMPTPGJB1SJNFJ SBDPNPVTPRVFQPTUFSJPSNFOUFGPJGFJUPEBQBMBWSBPOUP MPHJB "SJTUwUFMFTBGJSNPVRVFBGJMPTPGJB1SJNFJSBFTUVEBP4FS EBTDPJTBT BPVTrB RVFDPSSFTQPOEFFNQPSUVHVpThQBMBWSB FTTpODJB
JTUPn BRVJMPRVFGB[EFVNFOUFPVEFVNBDPJTB VN4FS1PSTFSPFTUVEPEBPVTrBFQPSRVFBPVTrBPGFSFDFP 4FSSFBMFWFSEBEFJSPEFVNFOUF PGFSFDFPPOrOUJNPFQFSFOF nRVFNBJTUBSEFBGJMPTPGJB1SJNFJSBQBTTBSgBTFSEFTJHOBEB DPNBQBMBWSBPOUPMPHJB
1PSRVFBQBMBWSBNFUBGrTJDBGJDPVDPOTBHSBEBQBSBEFTJHOBS BGJMPTPGJB1SJNFJSBPVPOUPMPHJB "QFTBSEFJOJDJBMNFOUFNFUBGrTJDBUFSTJEPFNQSFHBEBQB SBSFGFSJSTFBPMVHBSQPTUFSJPSNFOUFPDVQBEPQFMPTUSBUBEPT EFGrTJDB BQBMBWSBNFUB FNHSFHP TJHOJGJDB²PRVFFTUgBMnN EF PRVFFTUgBDJNBEF PRVFWFNEFQPJT³
BPEFGJOJSBGJMP TPGJB1SJNFJSB"SJTUwUFMFTUBNCnNBGJSNPVRVFFMBFTUVEBPT QSJNFJSPTQSJODrQJPTFBTDBVTBTQSJNFJSBTEFUPEPTPTTFSFT PVEFUPEBTBTFTTpODJBT FTUVEPRVFEFWFWJSBOUFTEFUPEPT PTPVUSPT QPSRVFnDPOEJmkPEFUPEPTFMFT²7JSBOUFT³ QBSB "SJTUwUFMFT TJHOJGJDB²FTUBSBDJNBEPTEFNBJT FTUBSBMnNEP RVFWFNEFQPJT TFSTVQFSJPSBPRVFWFNEFQPJT TFSBDPOEJmkP EBFYJTUpODJBFEPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPRVFWFNEFQPJT³"TTJN NFUBGrTJDBTJHOJGJDBPFTUVEPEFBMHVNBDPJTBRVFFTUgBDJNBF BMnNEBTDPJTBTGrTJDBTPVOBUVSBJTFRVFnBDPOEJmkPEBFYJT UpODJBEFMBT.FUBGrTJDB OFTTFDBTP RVFSEJ[FS²BRVJMPRVFn DPOEJmkPFGVOEBNFOUPEFUVEPPRVFFYJTUFFEFUVEPPRVF QVEFSTFSDPOIFDJEP³ 3FTVNBPTQSJODJQBJTUSBmPTEPQFOTBNFOUPEF1BSNpOJ EFTUPNBOEPDPNPSFGFSpODJBBPQPTJmkPFOUSFSFBMJEBEF FBQBSpODJB 1BSNpOJEFTGPJPQSJNFJSPGJMwTPGPBBGJSNBSRVFPNVOEP QFSDFCJEPQPSOPTTPTTFOUJEPTnJMVTwSJP GFJUPEFBQBSpODJBT TPCSFBTRVBJTGPSNVMBNPTOPTTBTPQJOJ{FTEJBOUFEJTTP DPO USBQyTBJEFJBEFVNQFOTBNFOUPFEFVNEJTDVSTPWFSEBEFJSPT SFGFSJEPThRVJMPRVFnSFBMNFOUF P4FSEBTDPJTBT1BSNpOJEFT GPJPQSJNFJSPBEJ[FSRVFBBQBSpODJBTFOTrWFMEBTDPJTBTEBOB UVSF[BOkPQPTTVJSFBMJEBEF OkPFYJTUFSFBMFWFSEBEFJSBNFOUF OkPn$POUSBQyT BTTJN P4FS PO BP/kP4FS NFPO
EFDMB SBOEP²P4FSnFP/kP4FSOkPn³EJTUJOHVJVBWJBEBWFSEBEF RVFOFHBSFBMJEBEFFDPOIFDJNFOUP EBWJBEBPQJOJkP QPJTFTUB TFPDVQBDPNBTBQBSpODJBT DPNP/kP4FS 1PSRVF1BSNpOJEFTDSJUJDPVBDPTNPMPHJBFPEFWJSFDPN FTTBDSrUJDBEFVPSJHFNBPRVFWJSJBBTFSBPOUPMPHJBPVNF UBGrTJDB "DPTNPMPHJBCVTDBWBBFYQMJDBmkPQBSBPEFWJS JTUPn QBSB BNVEBOmBEBTDPJTBT QBSBBQBTTBHFNEFVNBDPJTBBVNPVUSP NPEPEFFYJTUJS DPOUSgSJPBPRVFQPTTVrB1PSUBOUP BDPTNPMPHJB EFEJDBWBTFhNVMUJQMJDJEBEFEPTTFSFT hNVUBCJMJEBEFEFMFTFhT PQPTJm{FTFOUSFFMFT&OUSFUBOUP BPBGJSNBSRVFPQFOTBNFOUP WFSEBEFJSPFYJHFBJEFOUJEBEF BOkPUSBOTGPSNBmkPFBOkPDPO USBEJmkPEPTFS 1BSNpOJEFTUPSOPVJNQPTTrWFMBDPTNPMPHJB&MF BGJSNBWBRVFP4FSOkPNVEBQPSRVFOkPUFNDPNPOFNQPSRVF NVEBSFOkPUFNOPRVFNVEBS QPJT TFNVEBTTF EFJYBSJBEFTFS P4FS UPSOBOEPTFBTJNFTNPP/kP4FS$POTFRVFOUFNFOUF NPTUSPVRVFPQFOTBNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPOkPBENJUFBNVMUJQMJ DJEBEFPVQMVSBMJEBEFFRVFP4FSnVOPF|OJDPcKVTUBNFOUF BQBSUJSEFTTFTQSJODrQJPT EFJEFOUJEBEF P4FSn FEFOkPDPO USBEJmkP P/kP4FSOkPn RVF1BSNpOJEFTJOUSPEV[BTOPm{FT GVOEBNFOUBJTEPRVFWJSJBBTFSBPOUPMPHJBPVNFUBGrTJDB "QSFTFOUFPTQSJODJQBJTBSHVNFOUPTEB&TDPMB&MFBUB
&YQMJRVFPRVFTJHOJGJDBBGJSNBSRVFBNFUBGrTJDBPVPOUPMP HJBFTUVEB²P4FSFORVBOUP4FS³ "PFTUVEBSP²4FSFORVBOUP4FS³ BNFUBGrTJDBCVTDBBFT TpODJBEFVNFOUFPVEFVNBDPJTB*TTPTJHOJGJDBRVFFMBOkP FTUVEBFTUBPVBRVFMBDPJTB FTUFPVBRVFMFFOUF NBTCVTDB BRVJMPRVFGB[EFVNFOUFPVEFVNBDPJTBVN4FS BQFTBSEBT BQBSpODJBTRVFQPTTBUFSFEBTNVEBOmBTRVFQPTTBTPGSFS
04FSnVOPFOkPQPEFTFSN|MUJQMP QPJT DBTPBENJUBNPT RVFP4FSOkPTFKBVOP NBTN|MUJQMP OFTTFDBTPDBEBTFSnFMF NFTNPFOkPnPTPVUSPTTFSFT1PSUBOUP DBEBTFSnFOkPnBP NFTNPUFNQP PRVFnJNQFOTgWFMPVBCTVSEP 04FSnFUFSOP QPJT DBTPBENJUBNPTRVFP4FSOkPTFKB FUFSOP NBTUFWFVNDPNFmPFUFSgVNGJN BOUFTEFMF PRVF IBWJB 0VUSP4FS /kP QPJTP4FSnVOP0/kP4FS /kP QPJTP
/4
Manual do Professor
/kP4FSnPOBEB1PSUBOUP P4FSOkPQPEFUFSUJEPVNDPNFmP 5FSgVNGJN 4FUJWFS RVFWJSgEFQPJTEFMF 0VUSP4FS /kP QPJT P4FSnVOP0/kP4FS /kP QPJTP/kP4FSnPOBEB1PSUBOUP P4FSOkPQPEFBDBCBS 04FSnJNVUgWFMFPEFWJSnVNBJMVTkPEFOPTTPTTFOUJEPT QPJT DBTPBENJUBNPTRVFP4FSOkPTFKBJNVUgWFM NBTNVUgWFM OPRVFP4FSNVEBSJB 5PSOBSTFJBPVUSP4FS /kP QPJTP4FSn VOP5PSOBSTFJBVN/kP4FS /kP QPJTP/kP4FSnPOBEB1PS UBOUP TFP4FSNVEBTTF UPSOBSTFJB/kP4FSFEFTBQBSFDFSJB &YQMJRVFDPNPFQPSRVF1BSNpOJEFTEJGFSFODJBFOUSFQFS DFCFSFQFOTBS 1BSB1BSNpOJEFT PRVFOwTQFSDFCFNPTTkPBTDPJTBTN|M UJQMBTFNVUgWFJTEBOBUVSF[B RVFTFUSBOTGPSNBNVNBTOBT PVUSBTFTFUPSOBNDPOUSgSJBTBTJNFTNBT0RVFOwTQFOTB NPTnP4FS JTUPn BJEFOUJEBEF BVOJEBEF BJNVUBCJMJEBEFF BFUFSOJEBEFEBRVJMPRVFnFNTJNFTNP"PEJGFSFODJBS EFTTB GPSNB QFOTBSFQFSDFCFS 1BSNpOJEFTRVFSEFNPOTUSBSRVFBP QFSDFCFSWFNPTBQFOBTBTBQBSpODJBTEBTDPJTBT BUSBWnTEB RVBMUFNPTVNBDPNQSFFOTkPFOHBOPTBEBSFBMJEBEF BWJBEB PQJOJkP FOUSFUBOUP BPQFOTBS DPOUFNQMBNPTBSFBMJEBEFDP NPJEpOUJDBBTJNFTNB BUSBWnTEBRVBMUFNPTVNBDPNQSFFO TkPEBFTTpODJBEBSFBMJEBEF BWJBEBWFSEBEF &YQMJRVFBEJWJTkPQMBUyOJDBFOUSFNVOEPTFOTrWFMFNVOEP JOUFMJHrWFM 5SBUBTFEFVNBUFOUBUJWBEFDPODJMJBmkPFOUSFBTDPODFQ m{FTBOUBHyOJDBTEF1BSNpOJEFTF)FSgDMJUP0NVOEPTFOTrWFM CBTFJBTFOBDPODFQmkPEF)FSgDMJUPEPEFWJS EPTDPOUSgSJPT EBNVEBOmB EBBQBSpODJBPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFMCBTFJBTFOB DPODFQmkPEF1BSNpOJEFTEBJEFOUJEBEF EBQFSNBOpODJB EB WFSEBEF DPOIFDJEPQFMPJOUFMFDUPQVSP TFNOFOIVNBJOUFSGF SpODJBEPTTFOUJEPTFEBTPQJOJ{FT0QSJNFJSPnPNVOEPEBT DPJTBT0TFHVOEP PNVOEPEBTJEFJBT EBTFTTpODJBTWFSEB EFJSBT0NVOEPEBTJEFJBTnPNVOEPEP4FSPNVOEPTFOTrWFM EBTBQBSpODJBTnPNVOEPEP/kP4FS0NVOEPTFOTrWFMnVNB TPNCSB VNBDwQJBEFGPSNBEBPVJNQFSGFJUBEPNVOEPJOUFMJ HrWFMEBTJEFJBTPVFTTpODJBT 2VBMBQSJODJQBMEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPQFOTBNFOUPEF1MBUkPF PEF1BSNpOJEFT 1MBUkPF1BSNpOJEFTQPTTVFNVNBDPODFQmkPEJGFSFOUFOP RVFTFSFGFSFBP/kP4FS&ORVBOUPQBSB1BSNpOJEFTP/kP4FS nPOBEB QBSB1MBUkPP/kP4FSnBMHVNBDPJTB VNBTPNCSB EP4FSWFSEBEFJSP.BT BMnNEJTTP VNBEJGFSFOmBJNQPSUBOUF FOUSFPTEPJTGJMwTPGPTEJ[SFTQFJUPhDPODFQmkPQBSNFOJEFBOB EBVOJEBEFVOJDJEBEFEP4FS BRVBMQBSBMJTBWBBGJMPTPGJBOBT TFHVJOUFTBGJSNBm{FT04FSn0/kP4FSOkPn04FSnVOP JEpOUJDP FUFSOPFJNVUgWFM1MBUkPSFTPMWFVFTTFJNQBTTFEFJ YBEPQPS1BSNpOJEFTQPSNFJPEPBQSPGVOEBNFOUPGJMPTwGJDP CBTFBEPOPTFOUJEPEBQBMBWSBTFS 2VBJTBTUSpTBUJUVEFTDPNBTRVBJT1MBUkPSFTPMWFVPJN QBTTFGJMPTwGJDPEFJYBEPQPS1BSNpOJEFT RVFSFEV[JSBB GJMPTPGJBhBGJSNBmkP²P4FSn³FhOFHBmkP²P/kP4FSOkP n³ "QSJNFJSBBUJUVEFnBEJTUJOmkPEFUSpTTFOUJEPTQBSBBQB MBWSBTFSPTFOUJEPEFTVCTUBOUJWP JTUPn EFSFBMJEBEFFYJT UFOUFPTFOUJEPWFSCBMGPSUF FNRVFnTJHOJGJDB²FYJTUF³FTFS RVFSEJ[FS²FYJTUpODJB³FPTFOUJEPWFSCBMNBJTGSBDP FNRVFP
/5
WFSCPTFSnPWFSCPEFMJHBmkP JTUPn PWFSCPRVFQFSNJUFMJHBS TVKFJUPFQSFEJDBEP "TFHVOEBBUJUVEFnBENJUJSRVFFYJTUFNN|MUJQMPTTFSFTF OkPVNTw NBTRVFDBEBVNEFMFTQPTTVJPTBUSJCVUPTEP4FS EF1BSNpOJEFT JEFOUJEBEF VOJEBEF FUFSOJEBEF JNVUBCJMJEB EF &TTFTTFSFTTkPBTJEFJBTPVGPSNBTJOUFMJHrWFJT UPUBMNFO UFJNBUFSJBJT RVFDPOTUJUVFNPNVOEPWFSEBEFJSP PNVOEP JOUFMJHrWFM "UFSDFJSBBUJUVEFnBENJUJSRVFDBEBJEFJBnVNTVKFJUPSFBM RVFQPTTVJVNDPOKVOUPEFQSFEJDBEPTSFBJTPVEFQSPQSJF EBEFTFTTFODJBJTFRVFBGB[FNTFSPRVFFMBnFNTJNFTNB 6NBJEFJBn FYJTUF FVNBJEFJBnVNBFTTpODJBPVDPOKVOUP EFRVBMJEBEFTFTTFODJBJTRVFBGB[FNTFSPRVFFMBnOFDFTTB SJBNFOUF1PSFYFNQMP BKVTUJmBn IgBJEFJBEFKVTUJmB FIg TFSFTRVFTkPKVTUPT QPTTVFNPQSFEJDBEPEBKVTUJmBDPNP QBSUFEFTVBFTTpODJB 2VFTkPBTJEFJBTPVGPSNBTJOUFMJHrWFJT 2VBJTBTTVBT QSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTPVRVBMJEBEFT "TJEFJBTPVGPSNBTJOUFMJHrWFJTTkPTFSFTQFSGFJUPTF QPS TVBQFSGFJmkP UPSOBNTFNPEFMPTJOUFMJHrWFJTPVQBSBEJHNBT JOUFMJHrWFJTQFSGFJUPTRVFBTDPJTBTTFOTrWFJTNBUFSJBJTUFOUBN JNJUBSJNQFSGFJUBNFOUF"MnNEFTFSFTQFSGFJUPTFQBSBEJHNg UJDPT EFBDPSEPDPN1MBUkP BTJEFJBTJOUFMJHrWFJTQPTTVFNBT TFHVJOUFTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTFMBTTkPP4FS UxwO
TkPJNBUFSJBJT DPOTUJUVFNPNVOEPWFSEBEFJSPFDBEBVNBEBTJEFJBTJOUFMJ HrWFJTQPTTVJPTBUSJCVUPTEP4FSEF1BSNpOJEFT JEFOUJEBEF VOJEBEF FUFSOJEBEF JNVUBCJMJEBEF &YQMJRVFDPNPFQPSRVF QBSB1MBUkP BGJMPTPGJBDPOTJTUF FNQBTTBSEBBQBSpODJBTFOTrWFMhFTTpODJBJOUFMJHrWFMEBT DPJTBT EBPQJOJkPhJEFJB 1PSRVF QBSB1MBUkP PDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPFTUgBMnN EBTJNQSFTT{FTTFOTPSJBJTRVFTkPJNQFSGFJUBTFDBSBDUFSJ[BNP NVOEPEBTTPNCSBTFBQBSpODJBTEBTDPJTBT GB[FOEPDPNRVF TFUFOIBBQFOBTVNBPQJOJkPTPCSFBSFBMJEBEF1BSBTFBUJOHJS PDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP PNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM EBTJEFJBTF FTTpODJBT nQSFDJTPUFS²BNPSBPTBCFS³ GJMPTPGJB FOkPBQFOBT ²BNPShTPQJOJ{FT³ GJMPEPYJB 1BSB1MBUkP PDBNJOIPTFHVSP NFUIPEPT QBSBFTTBQBTTBHFNnBEJBMnUJDB RVFOPTDPOEV[ EBTTFOTBm{FT EBTQFSDFQm{FT EBTJNBHFOTFEBTPQJOJ{FTh DPOUFNQMBmkPJOUFMFDUVBMEPTFSSFBMEBTDPJTBT hJEFJBWFSEB EFJSB RVFFYJTUFFNTJNFTNBOPNVOEPEBTQVSBTJEFJBTPVOP NVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM &YQPOIBDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTPRVFEJ[4wDSBUFTOPEJgMPHP0 CBORVFUFFDPNPDPNFMFFYQMJDBRVBMnBFTTpODJBEPBNPS PVBJEFJBWFSEBEFJSBEPBNPS &NWF[EFGB[FSFMPHJPTFMPVWPSFThTJNBHFOTFBQBSpODJBT EPBNPSPVEBSNBJTVNBPQJOJkPTPCSFPBNPS 4wDSBUFTBQSF TFOUBNFUPEPMPHJDBNFOUFBCVTDBEBFTTpODJBEPBNPS FMF JOWFTUJHBBJEFJBEPBNPS1BSUJOEPEPNJUPEF&SPT PGJMwTPGP FYQMJDBRVFPBNPSnPEFTFKPEBQFSGFJmkPJNQFSFDrWFMEBTGPS NBTCFMBT EBRVJMPRVFQFSNBOFDFTFNQSFJEpOUJDPBTJNFTNP EBRVJMPRVFQPEFTFSDPOUFNQMBEPQMFOBNFOUFQFMPJOUFMFDUP FDPOIFDJEPQMFOBNFOUFQFMBJOUFMJHpODJB4FOEPBNPSJOUFMFD UVBMQFMPJOUFMJHrWFMPVQFMBTJEFJBT PBNPSnPEFTFKPEFTBCFS QIJMPTPQIJB BNPSEBTBCFEPSJB1FMPBNPS PJOUFMFDUPIVNBOP QBSUJDJQBEPJOUFMJHrWFM UPNBQBSUFOPNVOEPEBTJEFJBTPVEBT FTTpODJBT DPOIFDFOEPPTFSWFSEBEFJSP
| U NIDADE 6
|
A metafísica
#APqTULOß߯ßß=iap]boe_]`a=neoppahao 2VBJTPTNPUJWPTQFMPTRVBJTBUSJCVFNB"SJTUwUFMFTPOBT DJNFOUPEBNFUBGrTJDB "MnNEFUFSGPSNVMBEPBJEFJBEFVNBDJpODJBPVEJTDJ QMJOBRVFUFNDPNPGJOBMJEBEFQSwQSJBPFTUVEPEP4FS USpT PVUSPTNPUJWPTMFWBNBBUSJCVJSB"SJTUwUFMFTPJOrDJPEBNF UBGrTJDB &NMVHBSEFBGBTUBSBNVMUJQMJDJEBEFFPEFWJSDP NPJMVT{FTPVTPNCSBTEPWFSEBEFJSP4FS "SJTUwUFMFTBGJSNB RVFPTFSEBOBUVSF[BFYJTUF nSFBM RVFTFVNPEPQSwQSJP EFFYJTUJSnBNVEBOmBFRVFFTUBOkPnVNBDPOUSBEJmkPJN QFOTgWFM "SJTUwUFMFTDPOTJEFSBRVFBFTTpODJBWFSEBEFJSB EBTDPJTBTOBUVSBJTFEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFEFTVBTBm{FT OkPFTUgOPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM NBTOBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT OPT QSwQSJPTIPNFOT OBTQSwQSJBTBm{FT FnUBSFGBEBGJMPTPGJB DPOIFDpMBTBMJNFTNPPOEFFYJTUFNFBDPOUFDFN BPTF EFEJDBShNFUBGrTJDB BGJMPTPGJBEFTDPCSFRVFIgEJGFSFOUFT UJQPTEFTFSFTPVFOUFTRVFTFEJGFSFODJBNKVTUBNFOUFQPS TVBTFTTpODJBTFBNVEBOmBnPDSJUnSJPEFTTBEJGFSFODJBmkP EPTTFSFT 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTEBQBMBWSBHSFHBLrOFTJT ,rOFTJT NPWJNFOUP OkPTJHOJGJDBTJNQMFTNFOUFNVEBO mBEFMVHBSPVMPDPNPmkP4JHOJGJDBUPEBFRVBMRVFSNVEBOmB FYQFSJNFOUBEBQPSVNTFSNVEBOmBRVBMJUBUJWB NVEBOmBPV BMUFSBmkPRVBOUJUBUJWB NVEBOmBEFMVHBSPVMPDPNPmkP BMUFSB mkPFNRVFVNTFSQBTTFEBBmkPhQBJYkPPVhQBTTJWJEBEFPV QBTTFEBQBTTJWJEBEFhBUJWJEBEFTJHOJGJDBUBNCnNUPEBHFSB mkPPVOBTDJNFOUPFUPEBDPSSVQmkPPVNPSUFEPTTFSFT 2VBMBQPTJmkPEF"SJTUwUFMFTBSFTQFJUPEBNVEBOmBPVNP WJNFOUP &YQMJRVFDPNPFMFFNQSFHBBJEFJBEFNPWJNFOUP QBSBEJTUJOHVJSPTEJGFSFOUFTUJQPTEFTFSFT "SJTUwUFMFTOFHBRVFNPWJNFOUPF/kP4FSPVJSSFBMJEBEF TFKBNBNFTNBDPJTB&MFEJGFSFODJBSgPTTFSFTDPOGPSNFFTUF KBNPVOkPFNNPWJNFOUP JOWFTUJHBOEPBUSBWnTEBNFUBGrTJDB PRVFnBFTTpODJBFBRVJMPRVFGB[DPNRVFIBKBFTTpODJBTQBS UJDVMBSFTFEJGFSFODJBEBT DPNPBFTTpODJBEPTTFSFTGrTJDPTPV OBUVSBJT RVFTkPFFTUkPFNNPWJNFOUPBFTTpODJBEPTTFSFT NBUFNgUJDPT RVFTkPJNwWFJT OkPFYJTUFNFNTJNFTNPT NBT FYJTUFNDPNPGPSNBTEBTDPJTBTOBUVSBJTBFTTpODJBEFTFSFT DVKBFTTpODJBnJNVUgWFMPVJNwWFM DPNPPTBTUSPT RVFOkP OBTDFN OkPTFUSBOTGPSNBNFOkPQFSFDFN NBTSFBMJ[BNVN NPWJNFOUPMPDBMQFSGFJUPBFTTpODJBEFVNTFSFUFSOP JNVUg WFM JNQFSFDrWFM TFNQSFJEpOUJDPBTJNFTNP QFSGFJUP JNBUF SJBM EPRVBMPNPWJNFOUPFTUgJOUFJSBNFOUFFYDMVrEP FRVFn DPOIFDJEPBQFOBTQFMPJOUFMFDUP±PTFSEJWJOP &YQMJRVFPRVF"SJTUwUFMFTFOUFOEFQPSGJMPTPGJB1SJNFJSB PVNFUBGrTJDB &NCPSB"SJTUwUFMFTBENJUBRVFQBSBDBEBUJQPEFTFSFTVBT FTTpODJBTFYJTUFVNBDJpODJBUFPSnUJDBQSwQSJB GrTJDB CJPMPHJB QTJDPMPHJB NBUFNgUJDB BTUSPOPNJB
FMFUBNCnNEFGFOEFB OFDFTTJEBEFEFVNBDJpODJBHFSBM NBJTBNQMB NBJTVOJWFSTBM BOUFSJPSBUPEBTFTTBT DVKPPCKFUPOkPTFKBFTTFPVBRVFMFUJQP EF4FS FTTBPVBRVFMBNPEBMJEBEFEFFTTpODJB NBTP4FSFN HFSBM BFTTpODJBFNHFSBM&TTBDJpODJB QBSB"SJTUwUFMFT nB GJMPTPGJB1SJNFJSBPVNFUBGrTJDB RVFJOWFTUJHBPRVFnBFTTpODJB FBRVJMPRVFGB[DPNRVFIBKBFTTpODJBTQBSUJDVMBSFTEJGFSFODJB EBT RVFFTUVEBP4FSFORVBOUP4FS
2VBJTTkPPTUSpTFTUVEPTRVFDBCFNhNFUBGrTJDB 0FTUVEPEPTFSEJWJOP PQSJNFJSPNPUPSJNwWFM
BSFB MJEBEFQSJNFJSBFTVQSFNBEBRVBMUPEPPSFTUBOUFQSPDVSB BQSPYJNBSTF JNJUBOEPTVBQFSGFJmkPJNVUgWFMPFTUVEPEPT QSJNFJSPTQSJODrQJPTFDBVTBTQSJNFJSBTEFUPEPTPTTFSFTPV FTTpODJBTFYJTUFOUFTPFTUVEPEBTQSPQSJFEBEFTPVBUSJCVUPT HFSBJTEFUPEPTPTTFSFT TFKBNFMFTRVBJTGPSFN HSBmBTBPT RVBJTQPEFNPTEFUFSNJOBSBFTTpODJBQBSUJDVMBSEFVNTFSQBS UJDVMBSFYJTUFOUF 0RVFTkPFRVBJTTkPPTQSJNFJSPTQSJODrQJPT TFHVOEP"SJT UwUFMFT 4kPPTUSpTQSJODrQJPTMwHJDPTJEFOUJEBEF OkPDPOUSBEJmkP FUFSDFJSPFYDMVrEP0TQSJODrQJPTMwHJDPTTkPPOUPMwHJDPTQPS RVFEFGJOFNBTDPOEJm{FTTFNBTRVBJTVNTFSOkPQPEFFYJTUJS OFNTFSQFOTBEPPTQSJNFJSPTQSJODrQJPTHBSBOUFN TJNVMUB OFBNFOUF BSFBMJEBEFFBSBDJPOBMJEBEFEBTDPJTBT 0RVFTkPFRVBJTTkPBTDBVTBTQSJNFJSBT TFHVOEP"SJTUw UFMFT 4kPBRVFMBTRVFFYQMJDBNPRVFBFTTpODJBnFUBNCnNB PSJHFNFPNPUJWPEBFYJTUpODJBEFVNBFTTpODJB"TDBVTBTQSJ NFJSBTOPTEJ[FNPRVFn DPNPn QPSRVFnFQBSBRVFnVNB DPJTB4kPRVBUSPBTDBVTBTQSJNFJSBTDBVTBNBUFSJBM DBVTB GPSNBM DBVTBFGJDJFOUFPVNPUSJ[FDBVTBGJOBM 0RVFTkPNBUnSJBFGPSNB TFHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT .BUnSJBnPFMFNFOUPEFRVFUPEBTBTDPJTBTTkPGFJUBTTVB QSJODJQBMDBSBDUFSrTUJDBnQPTTVJSWJSUVBMJEBEFTPVDPOUFSFN TJNFTNBQPTTJCJMJEBEFTEFUSBOTGPSNBmkP JTUPn NVEBOmB 'PSNBnPRVFJOEJWJEVBMJ[BFEFUFSNJOBVNBNBUnSJB GB[FOEP FYJTUJSBTDPJTBTPVPTTFSFTQBSUJDVMBSFTTVBQSJODJQBMDBSBDUF SrTUJDBnTFSBRVJMPRVFVNBFTTpODJBn 0RVFTkPQPUpODJBFBUP TFHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT 1PUpODJBnBWJSUVBMJEBEFRVFFTUgDPOUJEBOVNBNBUnSJBF QPEFWJSBFYJTUJS TFGPSBUVBMJ[BEBQPSBMHVNBDBVTBQPSFYFN QMP BDSJBOmBnVNBEVMUPFNQPUpODJBPVVNBEVMUPFNQPUFO DJBMBTFNFOUFnBgSWPSFFNQPUpODJBPVFNQPUFODJBM"UPn BBUVBMJ[BmkPEFVNBNBUnSJBQPSVNBGPSNBFOVNBGPSNBP BUPnBGPSNBRVFBUVBMJ[PVVNBQPUpODJBDPOUJEBOBNBUnSJB 1PSFYFNQMP BgSWPSFnPBUPEBTFNFOUF PBEVMUPnPBUPEB DSJBOmB BNFTBnPBUPEBNBEFJSB FUD 0RVFTkPFTTpODJBFBDJEFOUF TFHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT &TTpODJBnBVOJEBEFJOUFSOBFJOEJTTPM|WFMFOUSFVNBNB UnSJBFVNBGPSNB VOJEBEFRVFMIFEgVNDPOKVOUPEFQSPQSJF EBEFTPVBUSJCVUPTRVFBGB[FNTFSOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFBRVJMPRVF FMBn"DJEFOUFnVNBQSPQSJFEBEFPVBUSJCVUPRVFVNBFTTpO DJBQPEFUFSPVEFJYBSEFUFSTFNQFSEFSTFVTFSQSwQSJP1PS FYFNQMP VNTFSIVNBOPnSBDJPOBMPVNPSUBMQPSFTTpODJB NBT nCBJYPPVBMUP HPSEPPVNBHSP OFHSPPVCSBODP QPSBDJEFOUF "TTJN QPEFNPTDPODMVJSRVFBFTTpODJBnBMHPJNQSFTDJOEr WFMQBSBBEJGFSFODJBmkPEFVNTFSFORVBOUPPBDJEFOUFOVODB BGFUBPTFSEBFTTpODJB"FTTpODJBnPVOJWFSTBMPBDJEFOUFn PQBSUJDVMBS 0RVFnBTVCTUiODJB TFHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT 2VBJTPTEPJT TFOUJEPTFNRVFFMFBFNQSFHB 4VCTUiODJBnBRVJMPFNRVFTFFODPOUSBNBNBUnSJBQPUpO DJB BGPSNBBUP POEFFTUkPPTBUSJCVUPTFTTFODJBJTFBDJEFO UBJT TPCSFPRVBMBHFNBTRVBUSPDBVTBTFNTVNB nP4FS
0,
Manual do Professor
QSPQSJBNFOUFEJUP/VNQSJNFJSPTFOUJEP TVCTUiODJBnPTFS JOEJWJEVBMFYJTUFOUFDPNTVBFTTpODJBFTFVTBDJEFOUFT TVCT UiODJBQSJNFJSB 1PSFYFNQMPPGJMwTPGP4wDSBUFT/VNTFHVO EPTFOUJEP TVCTUiODJBnPHpOFSPPVBFTQnDJFBRVFPTTFSFT JOEJWJEVBJTQFSUFODFNFPDPOKVOUPEBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTHFSBJT RVFQPTTVFN NBTRVFOkPFYJTUFNFNTJNFTNBTFQPSTJNFT NBT NBTTwFYJTUFNFODBSOBEBTOPTJOEJWrEVPT TVCTUiODJB TFHVOEB 1PSFYFNQMP PHpOFSPBOJNBMFBTFTQnDJFTWFSUFCSB EP NBNrGFSPFIVNBOPRVFOkPFYJTUFNFNTJNFTNPT NBT FYJTUFNFN4wDSBUFTPVQPSNFJPEF4wDSBUFT
EBTQVSBTGPSNBTJNBUFSJBJT PTOFPQMBUyOJDPTBGJSNBWBNB FYJTUpODJBEFVNBSFBMJEBEFTVQSFNB TFQBSBEBEFUPEPPSFT UP JOBMDBOmgWFMQFMPJOUFMFDUPIVNBOP MV[QVSBFFTQMFOEPS JNBUFSJBM P6OPPVP#FN1PSTFSVNBMV[ P6OPTFJSSBEJB TVBTJSSBEJBm{FT RVFPTOFPQMBUyOJDPTDIBNBWBNEFFNB OBm{FT GPSNBSBNPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM POEFFTUkPP4FS B *OUFMJHpODJBFB"MNBEP.VOEPF NBJTBGBTUBEBTEP6OPF QPSJTTP JNQFSGFJUBTPNVOEPTFOTrWFMEBNBUnSJB JNBHFN EFDBrEBPVDwQJBJNQFSGFJUBEPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFPRVFnPFTUPJDJTNP
0RVFTkPQSFEJDBEPTPVDBUFHPSJBT TFHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPT 0TQSFEJDBEPTPVDBUFHPSJBTTkPBUSJCVUPTRVFTFSFGFSFNh FTUSVUVSBFBPNPEPEFTFSEBTVCTUiODJBPVEBFTTpODJB RVBOUJ EBEF RVBMJEBEF SFMBmkP MVHBS UFNQP QPTTF BmkP QBJYkP 1P EFNTFSBDJEFOUBJTPVFTTFODJBJT JTUPn QPEFNTFSBMHPRVFVN TFSQPTTVJQPSBDBTPPVRVFMIFBDPOUFDFQPSBDBTP TFNBGFUBS TVBOBUVSF[B PVQPEFNTFSOFDFTTgSJPTFJOEJTQFOTgWFJThOBUV SF[BQSwQSJBEFVNTFS%FTTBGPSNB QPEFTFEJ[FSRVF4wDSBUFT FSBVNTFSIVNBOP TVCTUiODJB
RVFNFEJB N RVBOUJEBEF
RVFFSBUBMFOUPTP RVBMJEBEF
RVFFSBNBJTWFMIPRVF1MBUkP SF MBmkP
RVFWJWJBFN"UFOBT MVHBS
RVFWJWFVOPTnDVMP7B$ UFNQP
RVFGPJNPSUPQPSFOWFOFOBNFOUP QBTTJWJEBEF
FUD 5PNBOEP"SJTUwUFMFTDPNPSFGFSpODJB PRVFBNFUBGrTJDB JOWFTUJHB "NFUBGrTJDBJOWFTUJHBBRVJMPTFNPRVFOkPIgTFSFTOFN DPOIFDJNFOUPEPTTFSFTPTUSpTQSJODrQJPTMwHJDPPOUPMwHJDPT FBTRVBUSPDBVTBTBRVJMPRVFGB[VNTFSTFSOFDFTTBSJBNFOUF PRVFFMFnNBUnSJB QPUpODJB GPSNBFBUPBRVJMPRVFGB[VN TFSTFSOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFDPNPFMFnFTTpODJBFQSFEJDBEPTPV DBUFHPSJBTBRVJMPRVFGB[VNTFSFYJTUJSDPNPBMHPEFUFSNJOB EPBTVCTUiODJBJOEJWJEVBM TVCTUiODJBQSJNFJSB FBTVCTUiODJB DPNPHpOFSPPVFTQnDJF TVCTUiODJBTFHVOEB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=o]rajpqn]o`]iap]boe_] 1PSRVFQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFPDSJTUJBOJTNP DPNPSFMJHJkP OkPQSFDJTBWBEBGJMPTPGJB 4FOEPVNBSFMJHJkPEFTBMWBmkP TFVJOUFSFTTFNBJPSFT UBWBOBNPSBM OBQSgUJDBEPTQSFDFJUPTWJSUVPTPTEFJYBEPT QPS+FTVT FOkPOVNBUFPSJBTPCSFBSFBMJEBEF4FOEPVNB SFMJHJkPWJOEBEPKVEBrTNP KgQPTTVrBVNBJEFJBNVJUPDMBSB EPRVFFSBP4FS QPJT%FVTEJTTFB.PJTnT²&VTPVBRVFMF RVFn GPJFTFSg&VTPVBRVFMFRVFTPV³4FOEPVNBSFMJHJkP TFVJOUFSFTTFNBJPSFTUBWBOBGnFOkPOBSB[kPUFwSJDB OB DSFOmB FOkPOPDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMFDUVBMOBSFWFMBmkP F OkPOBSFGMFYkP 1PSRVF FOUSFUBOUP PDSJTUJBOJTNPGPJMFWBEPBGPSNVMBS VNBNFUBGrTJDB 'PJPEFTFKPEFDPOWFSUFSPTJOUFMFDUVBJTHSFHPTFPTDIF GFT F JNQFSBEPSFT SPNBOPT JTUP n BRVFMFT RVF FTUBWBN BDPTUVNBEPThGJMPTPGJB RVF²FNQVSSPV³PTDSJTUkPTQBSBB NFUBGrTJDB &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFPRVFnPOFPQMBUPOJTNP 0OFPQMBUPOJTNPGPJVNBSFUPNBEBEBGJMPTPGJBQMBUyOJDB NBTDPNVNDPOUF|EPNrTUJDPFFTQJSJUVBMJTUB"MnNEPNVO EPTFOTrWFMEBNBUnSJBPVEPTDPSQPT FEPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM
0-
0FTUPJDJTNPBGJSNBBFYJTUpODJBEFVNB3B[kP6OJWFSTBM PV*OUFMJHpODJB6OJWFSTBM RVFQSPEV[FHPWFSOBUPEBBSFBMJEB EF EFBDPSEPDPNVNQMBOPSBDJPOBMOFDFTTgSJP BRVFEBWBN POPNFEF1SPWJEpODJB0IPNFN FNCPSBJNQVMTJPOBEPQPS JOTUJOUPTDPNPPTBOJNBJT QBSUJDJQBEB3B[kP6OJWFSTBMQFMB BmkPEBWPOUBEFFEBSB[kP JTUPn QFMPEPNrOJPWPMVOUgSJPSB DJPOBMEFUPEPTPTEFTFKPT QFMBSFO|ODJBBUPEPTPTJOTUJOUPT FQFMBBDFJUBmkPEB1SPWJEpODJB &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFPRVFnPHOPTUJDJTNP 0HOPTUJDJTNPnVNEVBMJTNPNFUBGrTJDP JTUPn BGJSNBB FYJTUpODJBEFEPJTQSJODrQJPTTVQSFNPTEFPOEFQSPWnNUPEB BSFBMJEBEFP#FN PVBMV[JNBUFSJBM FP.BM PVBUSFWBNB UFSJBM1BSBPTHOwTUJDPT PNVOEPOBUVSBMPVPNVOEPTFOTrWFM nSFTVMUBEPEBWJUwSJBEP.BMTPCSFP#FNFQPSJTTPBGJSNBN RVFBTBMWBmkPFTUgFNMJCFSUBSTFEBNBUnSJB EPDPSQP BUSB WnTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMFDUVBMRVFQPEF QPSTJNFTNP BM DBOmBSBWFSEBEFQMFOBFUPUBMEP#FN PpYUBTFNrTUJDP F BGBTUBSPTQPEFSFTNBUFSJBJTEP.BM 0RVFPDSJTUJBOJTNPUPNPVEPOFPQMBUPOJTNP "TFQBSBmkPFOUSFNBUFSJBMDPSQPSBMFFTQJSJUVBMJODPSQP SBMBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFP%FVT6OPFPNVOEPNBUFSJBMBUSBOT GPSNBmkPEBQSJNFJSBFNBOBmkPOFPQMBUyOJDB 4FS *OUFMJHpO DJB "MNBEP.VOEP OBJEFJBEB5SJOEBEFEJWJOB 1BJ &TQrSJUP 4BOUPF'JMIP BBGJSNBmkPEFVNBTFHVOEBFNBOBmkP RVF WFNEBMV[EB5SJOEBEFFRVFGPSNBPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFMEBT QVSBTGPSNBTPVJOUFMJHpODJBTJNBUFSJBJTQFSGFJUBT RVFTkPPT BOKPTBNPEJGJDBmkPEBJEFJBOFPQMBUyOJDBRVBOUPBPNVOEP TFOTrWFMQFMBBGJSNBmkPEFRVFPNVOEPTFOTrWFMPVNBUFSJBM OkPnVNBFNBOBmkPEF%FVT NBTVNBDSJBmkPBBENJTTkP EFRVFBBMNBIVNBOBQBSUJDJQBEBEJWJOEBEFQPSHSBmBTBOUJ GJDBOUFFOkPQPSNFJPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMFDUVBM 0RVFPDSJTUJBOJTNPUPNPVEPFTUPJDJTNP "JEFJBEFRVFFYJTUFVNB1SPWJEpODJBEJWJOBSBDJPOBM RVFHPWFSOBUPEBTBTDPJTBTFPIPNFNFBJEFJBEFRVFB QFSGFJmkPIVNBOBEFQFOEFEFBCBOEPOBSUPEPTPTBQFUJUFT JNQVMTPTFEFTFKPTDPSQPSBJTPVDBSOBJT FOUSFHBOEPTFh1SP WJEpODJBBUSBWnTEBBDFJUBmkPEBGnFN$SJTUPFEBHSBmBTBOUJ GJDBOUF EJGFSFOUFNFOUFEBBmkPEFMJCFSBEBEBWPOUBEFHVJBEB QFMBSB[kPDPNPQFOTBWBNPTFTUPJDPT 0RVFPDSJTUJBOJTNPUPNPVEPHOPTUJDJTNP %VBTJEFJBTBEFRVFP.BMFYJTUFSFBMNFOUFnPEFNyOJP FBEFRVFBNBUnSJBPVBDBSOFnPDFOUSPPOEFPEFNyOJP JTUP n P.BM BHFTPCSFPNVOEPFTPCSFPIPNFN "QSFTFOUFBMHVNBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFPQFOTBNFOUPHSFHP FPDSJTUkP
| U NIDADE 6
|
A metafísica
1BSBPTHSFHPT PNVOEP TFOTrWFMFJOUFMJHrWFM nFUFSOP QBSBPTDSJTUkPT PNVOEPGPJDSJBEPQPS%FVTBQBSUJSEPOBEB FUFSNJOBSgOPEJBEP+Vr[P'JOBMQBSBPTHSFHPT BEJWJOEBEF nVNBGPSmBDwTNJDBSBDJPOBMFJNQFTTPBMQBSBPTDSJTUkPT %FVTnQFTTPBM nBVOJEBEFEFUSpTQFTTPBT TVQFSJPSBPIP NFNQFMBPOJTDJpODJBFPOJQPUpODJBQBSBPTHSFHPT PIPNFN nVNTFSOBUVSBM EPUBEPEFDPSQPFBMNBQBSBPTDSJTUkPT P IPNFNnVNTFSNJTUP OBUVSBMQPSTFVDPSQP NBTTPCSFOB UVSBMQPSTVBBMNBJNPSUBMQBSBPTHSFHPT BMJCFSEBEF BUSB WnTEBSB[kP HVJBBWPOUBEFIVNBOBQBSBBFTDPMIBEPCFN QBSBPTDSJTUkPT BMJCFSEBEFnBDBQBDJEBEFEFFTDPMIBFOUSF PCFNFPNBMQBSBPTHSFHPT PDPOIFDJNFOUPnVNBBUJWJEB EFEPJOUFMFDUPQBSBPTDSJTUkPT BSB[kPIVNBOBnMJNJUBEB FJNQFSGFJUB JODBQB[EF QPSTJNFTNBFTP[JOIB BMDBOmBSB WFSEBEF &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFWFSEBEFTEFSB[kPF WFSEBEFTEFGnnPQSJODJQBMQSPCMFNBQBSBBFMBCPSBmkP EFVNBGJMPTPGJBDSJTUk 1PSRVFDBCFSJBhGJMPTPGJBDSJTUkFODPOUSBSVNNFJPQBSB SFVOJSOPWBNFOUFBRVJMPRVF BPOBTDFS BGJMPTPGJBIBWJBTF QBSBEPSB[kPFNJUP 2VBJTPTUSpTBTQFDUPTDPODFSOFOUFTB%FVTRVFDPOT UJUVFNPDFOUSPEBNFUBGrTJDBDSJTUk &YQMJRVFPTCSFWF NFOUF 1SPWBSBFYJTUpODJBEF%FVTBUBSFGBEBNFUBGrTJDBDSJTUk RVFDPOTJTUJBFNDPODJMJBSBDPODFQmkPSBDJPOBMJTUBEPTHSFHPT FBDPODFQmkPSFMJHJPTBEPTDSJTUkPT QSPWBOEPSBDJPOBMNFOUF RVF%FVTFYJTUF NFTNPRVFBDBVTBEFTVBFYJTUpODJBGPTTF VNNJTUnSJPEBGn QSPWBSRVFPNVOEPGPJDSJBEPQPS%FVT DPOTJTUJBOBQSPWBEFRVFPNVOEPSFTVMUBEBWPOUBEFEJWJOB FnHPWFSOBEPQFMB1SPWJEpODJBEJWJOB BRVBMBHFUBOUPQPS NFJPTOBUVSBJT BTMFJTEBOBUVSF[B RVBOUPQPSNFJPTTPCSF OBUVSBJT PTNJMBHSFT QSPWBSRVF%FVTnBDBVTBFGJDJFOUF EFUPEBTBTDPJTBTFNCPSB%FVTTFKBJNBUFSJBMFJOGJOJUP TVB BmkPQPEFUFSFGFJUPTNBUFSJBJTFGJOJUPT DPNPBDSJBmkPEP NVOEPFEPIPNFN NFTNPRVFJTTPTFKBVNNJTUnSJPEBGn RVFBSB[kPnPCSJHBEBBBDFJUBS "MnNEBTQSPWBTSFGFSFOUFTB%FVTFhDSJBmkPEPNVO EP RVFPVUSBTQSPWBTGPSBNJNQPSUBOUFTQBSBBGJMPTPGJB DSJTUk 1SPWBSRVFBBMNBIVNBOBFYJTUFFRVFnJNPSUBM FTUBO EPEFTUJOBEBhTBMWBmkPPVhDPOEFOBmkPFUFSOBT TFHVOEP BWPOUBEFEB1SPWJEpODJBEJWJOBQSPWBSRVFOkPIgDPOUSBEJ mkPFOUSFBMJCFSEBEFIVNBOBFBPOJTDJpODJBPOJQPUpODJBEF %FVTQSPWBSRVFBTJEFJBT QMBUyOJDBT
BTFNBOBm{FT OFP QMBUyOJDBT PVPTHpOFSPTFFTQnDJFT BSJTUPUnMJDPT FYJTUFN TkPTVCTUiODJBTSFBJT DSJBEBTQFMPJOUFMFDUPFQFMBWPOUBEF EF%FVTFFYJTUFNOBNFOUFEJWJOBQSPWBSRVFP4FSTFEJ[PV EFWFTFSFOUFOEJEPEFNPEPEJGFSFOUFDPOGPSNFTFSFGJSBB %FVTPVhTDSJBUVSBTQSPWBSRVFGnFSB[kP SFWFMBmkPFDPOIF DJNFOUPJOUFMFDUVBMOkPTkPJODPNQBUrWFJTOFNDPOUSBEJUwSJPT F RVBOEPPGPSFN BGnPVSFWFMBmkPEFWFTFSDPOTJEFSBEBTV QFSJPShSB[kPFBPJOUFMFDUP RVFEFWFNTVCNFUFSTFBFMB 1PSRVFPTDSJTUkPTOkPQPEJBNNBOUFSBEJTUJOmkPQMBUy OJDBFOUSFPTFOTrWFMFPJOUFMJHrWFM 1BSBPTDSJTUkPT FTUFNVOEPFUVEPPRVFOFMFFYJTUFn PCSBEF%FVT nDSJBUVSBEF%FVTFOkPNFSBBQBSpODJB JNB HFN TPNCSBPVDwQJBJNQFSGFJUB DPNP1MBUkPEJ[JBTFSP
NVOEPTFOTrWFM EJTUJOUPEPNVOEPJOUFMJHrWFM%FTTBGPSNB FSBJNQPTTrWFMQBSBPTDSJTUkPTNBOUFSBEJTUJOmkPQMBUyOJDB FOUSFP/kP4FSFP4FS 2VBJTPTDBNQPTGJMPTwGJDPTTVSHJEPTDPNBBGJSNBmkP DSJTUkEFRVFP4FSOkPQPTTVJPNFTNPTFOUJEPRVBOEP SFGFSJEPB%FVTFhTDSJBUVSBT "UFPMPHJB RVFTFSFGFSFBP4FSDPNPTFSEJWJOPPV%FVT BQTJDPMPHJBSBDJPOBM RVFTFSFGFSFBP4FSDPNPFTTpODJBEB BMNBIVNBOBBDPTNPMPHJBSBDJPOBM RVFTFSFGFSFBP4FSDP NPFTTpODJBEBTDPJTBTOBUVSBJTPVEPNVOEP &YQMJRVFQPSRVFPTGJMwTPGPTNPEFSOPTGBMBNOBJODPN QBUJCJMJEBEFFOUSFGnFSB[kP 0TGJMwTPGPTNPEFSOPTGBMBNEBJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFFOUSF GnFSB[kPQPSUFSFNSPNQJEPDPNBUSBEJmkPEPQFOTBNFOUP QMBUyOJDP BSJTUPUnMJDPFOFPQMBUyOJDPF QPSDPOTFHVJOUF QPS OkPBDFJUBSFNNBJTBUSBEJmkPRVFIBWJBTJEPFMBCPSBEBQFMPT NFEJFWBJT3FKFJUBOEPBBVUPSJEBEFSFMJHJPTB BGJSNBNRVFP QPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBGJMPTPGJBnBUFPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP JTUP n BJOWFTUJHBmkPTPCSFBDBQBDJEBEFIVNBOBQBSBDPOIFDFSB WFSEBEF EFNPEPRVFVNBDPJTBPVVNFOUFTwnDPOTJEFSBEP SFBMTFBSB[kPIVNBOBQVEFSDPOIFDpMP &YQMJRVFBSFEFGJOJmkPNPEFSOBEPDPODFJUPEFTFSPV TVCTUiODJB 0TNPEFSOPTDPOTFSWBNBEFGJOJmkPUSBEJDJPOBMEBTVCT UiODJBDPNPPTFSRVFFYJTUFFNTJFQPSTJNFTNP RVFTVC TJTUFFNTJFQPSTJNFTNP1PSnN FNMVHBSEFDPOTJEFSBSRVF BTVCTUiODJBTFEFGJOFQPSHpOFSPFFTQnDJF IBWFOEPUBOUPT UJQPTEFTVCTUiODJBTRVBOUPTHpOFSPTFFTQnDJFTIPVWFS QBT TBTFBEFGJOJSBTVCTUiODJBMFWBOEPFNDPOTJEFSBmkPTFVT QSFEJDBEPTFTTFODJBJTPVTFVTBUSJCVUPTFTTFODJBJT JTUPn BRVFMBTQSPQSJFEBEFTPVBUSJCVUPTTFNPTRVBJTVNBTVCT UiODJBOkPnPRVFFMBn 2VBJTTkPBTTVCTUiODJBTQBSB%FTDBSUFT &QBSB)PC CFT 1BSB%FTDBSUFTIgTPNFOUFUSpTTVCTUiODJBTBTVCTUiO DJBQFOTBOUF BBMNB
EFGJOJEBQFMPBUSJCVUPEPQFOTBNFOUP BTVCTUiODJBFYUFOTB BNBUnSJBEPTDPSQPT
EFGJOJEBQFMP BUSJCVUPEBFYUFOTkP FBTVCTUiODJBJOGJOJUB %FVT
EFGJOJEB QFMPBUSJCVUPEBJOGJOJUVEF)PCCFTGBMBBQFOBTFNTVCTUiO DJBDPSQwSFB QPJTDPOTJEFSBRVFOkPUFNPTDPNPDPOIFDFSB TVCTUiODJBEJWJOBOFNBTVCTUiODJBBOrNJDBQPSRVFOkPTkP EBEBThFYQFSJpODJBTFOTPSJBM 2VFEJ[&TQJOPTBTPCSFBTVCTUiODJB &TQJOPTBDPOTJEFSBRVFnQSFDJTPMFWBSFNDPOUBBEFGJOJ mkPBSJTUPUnMJDBEFTVCTUiODJB²TVCTUiODJBnBRVJMPRVFFYJTUF FNTJFQPSTJFOkPEFQFOEFEFPVUSPTQBSBFYJTUJS³1PSUBOUP QBSB&TQJOPTB UPEBTBTDPJTBTRVFGPSBNDSJBEBTPVQSPEV [JEBTQPS%FVTOkPQPEFNTFSDIBNBEBTEFTVCTUiODJB QPJT OkPFYJTUFNQPSTJNFTNBTFEFQFOEFNEBBmkPEJWJOBQBSB FYJTUJS$POTFRVFOUFNFOUF EJ[&TQJOPTB OP6OJWFSTPIgVNB |OJDBTVCTUiODJB %FVTPVBOBUVSF[B &YQMJRVFBSFEFGJOJmkPNPEFSOBEPDPODFJUPEFDBVTB MJEBEF 0TNPEFSOPTDPOTJEFSBNRVFDBVTBnBRVJMPRVFQSPEV[ VNFGFJUPEFUFSNJOBEPF QPSJTTP EJGFSFOUFNFOUFEBNFUBGr
0.
Manual do Professor
TJDBBSJTUPUnMJDB BENJUFNBQFOBTEPJTUJQPTEFDBVTBTBFGJ DJFOUFFBGJOBM"DBVTBFGJDJFOUFnBRVFMBOBRVBMVNBBmkP BOUFSJPSEFUFSNJOBDPNPDPOTFRVpODJBOFDFTTgSJBBQSPEVmkP EFVNFGFJUPUFNBMDBODFVOJWFSTBMOBOBUVSF[B$BVTBGJOBMn BRVFMBRVFEFUFSNJOB QBSBPTTFSFTQFOTBOUFT BFTDPMIBEB SFBMJ[BmkPPVOkPSFBMJ[BmkPEFVNBBmkPTwPQFSBOBBmkP EF%FVTFOBTBm{FTEPTIPNFOT 1BSBPTNPEFSOPT PRVFBNFUBGrTJDBFTUVEB "NFUBGrTJDBNPEFSOBFTUVEBBFTTpODJBEPTFSJOGJOJUP %FVT
BFTTpODJBEPTFSQFOTBOUFPVEPQFOTBNFOUP BDPOT DJpODJB
BFTTpODJBEPTFSFYUFOTPPVEBFYUFOTkP BOBUVSF [B FBFTTpODJBEFVNTFSDPNQPTUPEFQFOTBNFOUPFFYUFO TkP JTUPn PIPNFN
0RVFnP²TPOPEPHNgUJDP³ TFHVOEP,BOU &PRVFn EFTQFSUBSEFTTFTPOP ²4POPEPHNgUJDP³nUPNBSDPNPQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBNF UBGrTJDBBJEFJBEFRVFFYJTUFVNBSFBMJEBEFFNTJ %FVT BMNB NVOEP JOGJOJUP GJOJUP NBUnSJB GPSNB TVCTUiODJB DBVTBMJEB EF
RVFQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEBQPSOPTTBSB[kPPV PRVFEgOP NFTNP UPNBSDPNPQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBNFUBGrTJDBBBGJSNB mkPEFRVFBTJEFJBTQSPEV[JEBTQPSOPTTBSB[kPDPSSFTQPO EFNFYBUBNFOUFBVNBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSOB RVFFYJTUFFNTJF QPSTJNFTNB%FTQFSUBSEFTTFTPOPnJOEBHBS BOUFTEFUVEP TFBNFUBGrTJDBnQPTTrWFMF TFGPS FNRVFDPOEJm{FTnQPT TrWFM"QBSUJSEF,BOU JTTPDPSSFTQPOEFhFMBCPSBmkPEFVNB DSrUJDBEBSB[kPUFwSJDB JTUPn VNFTUVEPTPCSFBFTUSVUVSBF PQPEFSEBSB[kPQBSBEFUFSNJOBSPRVFFMBQPEFFPRVFFMB OkPQPEFDPOIFDFSWFSEBEFJSBNFOUF
2VBJTBTUSpTJEFJBTRVFPQFSBNOBNFUBGrTJDBNPEFSOB "JEFJBEPTFSJOGJOJUPDPNPDBVTBFGJDJFOUFEBOBUVSF[BF EPIPNFNBJEFJBEPTFSQFOTBOUFGJOJUPDPNPDBVTBFGJDJFOUF EPTQFOTBNFOUPT DPODFJUPTFBm{FTIVNBOBTBJEFJBEPTFS FYUFOTPPVOBUVSF[BDPNPDBVTBFGJDJFOUFRVF QFMBTSFMBm{FT EFNPWJNFOUPFSFQPVTP QSPEV[UPEPTPTDPSQPT 2VBJTFSBNPTEPJTHSBOEFTQSFTTVQPTUPTEBNFUBGrTJDB &YQMJRVFDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTDPNPFQPSRVF%BWJE)VNF PTDSJUJDB "NFUBGrTJDBCBTFBWBTFOPTQSFTTVQPTUPTEFRVFBSFB MJEBEFFNTJFYJTUFFQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEBFRVFBTJEFJBTPV DPODFJUPTTkPVNDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPEBSFBMJEBEF QPS RVFBWFSEBEFnBDPSSFTQPOEpODJBFOUSFBTDPJTBTFPTQFOTB NFOUPT PVFOUSFPJOUFMFDUPFBSFBMJEBEF)VNFDSJUJDBFTTB DPODFQmkPQPSRVFQBSBFMFPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPPQFSB BTTPDJBOEPTFOTBm{FT QFSDFQm{FTFJNQSFTT{FTSFDFCJEBT QFMPTwSHkPTEPTTFOUJEPTFSFUJEBTOBNFNwSJB%FTTBNBOFJ SB EFBDPSEPDPN)VNF UPEPTPTDPODFJUPTEBNFUBGrTJDBOkP DPSSFTQPOEFNBTFSFTSFBJTFYJTUFOUFTJOEFQFOEFOUFTEPTV KFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP NBTTkPBQFOBTOPNFTHFSBJTDPNRVF PTVKFJUPOPNFJBFJOEJDBTFVTQSwQSJPTIgCJUPTBTTPDJBUJWPT 1BSB)VNF RVFTkPBTJEFJBT 1BSB)VNF BTJEFJBTTkPIgCJUPTNFOUBJTGPSNBEPTQF MBBTTPDJBmkPEFJNQSFTT{FTTFNFMIBOUFTPVEFJNQSFTT{FT TVDFTTJWBT BTQFSDFQm{FTRVFSFTVMUBNEBSFVOJkPEFWgSJBT TFOTBm{FTEJGFSFOUFT 1BSB)VNF RVFnBTVCTUiODJBPVBFTTpODJB 1BSB)VNF BJEFJBEFTVCTUiODJBPVFTTpODJB BUnFOUkP HBSBOUJEBQFMPTQSJODrQJPTEFJEFOUJEBEFFOkPDPOUSBEJmkP JOEJDBVNDPOKVOUPEFJNBHFOTFEFJEFJBTRVFOPTTBDPOT DJpODJBUFNPIgCJUPEFBTTPDJBSQPSDBVTBEBTFNFMIBOmBFO USFFMBT 1BSB)VNF RVFnBDBVTBMJEBEF "JEFJBEFDBVTBMJEBEF RVFBUnFOUkPTFSWJBEFHBSBOUJB QBSBFYQMJDBSBPSJHFNFBGJOBMJEBEFEBTDPJTBT CFNDPNPB SFMBmkPFOUSFPTTFSFT
QBSB)VNF QBTTBBTFSPNFSPIgCJUP RVFOPTTBNFOUFBERVJSFEFFTUBCFMFDFSSFMBm{FTEFDBVTBF FGFJUPFOUSFQFSDFQm{FTFJNQSFTT{FTTVDFTTJWBT DIBNBOEP BTBOUFSJPSFTEFDBVTBTFBTQPTUFSJPSFTEFFGFJUPT"SFQFUJ mkPDPOTUBOUFFSFHVMBSEFJNBHFOTPVJNQSFTT{FTTVDFTTJWBT OPTMFWBhDSFOmBEFRVFIgVNBDBVTBMJEBEFSFBM FYUFSOB QSwQSJBEBTDPJTBTFJOEFQFOEFOUFEFOwT
0/
2VBMnBEJTUJOmkPLBOUJBOBFOUSFKVr[PTBOBMrUJDPTFKVr [PTTJOUnUJDPT 1BSB,BOU OPTKVr[PTBOBMrUJDPTPVFYQMJDBUJWPTPQSFEJDB EPBQFOBTFYQMJDJUBPDPOUF|EPQFOTBEPOPDPODFJUPEPTV KFJUP QPSFYFNQMP ²PUSJiOHVMPnVNBGJHVSBEFUSpTMBEPT³ OPTKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTPVBNQMJBUJWPT PQSFEJDBEPBDSFTDFOUB OPWPTEBEPTRVFOkPFTUBWBNQFOTBEPTOPDPODFJUPEPTV KFJUP QPSFYFNQMP ²4wDSBUFTnGJMwTPGP³ 1PSRVF,BOUBGJSNBRVFTwIgDJpODJBPVTBCFSWFSEBEFJSP TFGPSFNQPTTrWFJTKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTBQSJPSJ &NPVUSBT QBMBWSBT FYQMJRVFDPNP,BOUJEFOUJGJDBDPOIFDFSFGPS NVMBSKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTBQSJPSJ %FBDPSEPDPN,BOU PTKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTnRVFTkPGPO UFEFDPOIFDJNFOUPQPSBDSFTDFOUBSFNOPWPTEBEPTRVFOkP FTUBWBNQFOTBEPTOPDPODFJUPEPTVKFJUPFOUSFUBOUP TFCB TFJBNOPTEBEPTEBFYQFSJpODJBJOEJWJEVBMF QPSUBOUP OkP TkPVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJPTFOkPDPSSFTQPOEFNhSFBMJEBEF PRVFSFEV[PTFVWBMPSDJFOUrGJDPFGJMPTwGJDPPVWBMPSUFwSJDP 1PSFTTFNPUJWP ,BOUQSPQ{FRVFPTKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTOkPQP EFNTFSFNQrSJDPT FTJNEFWFNTFSKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTBQSJPSJ PVTFKB RVFOkPEFQFOEFNEBFYQFSJpODJBJOEJWJEVBM1BSBJT TP ,BOUBQSFTFOUB EFVNMBEP BEJGFSFOmBFOUSFGFOyNFOP B SFBMJEBEFQBSBOPTTPFOUFOEJNFOUP FOyVNFOP BSFBMJEBEF FNTJ
F EFPVUSP BGJSNBRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBSFBMJEBEFn GFOPNpOJDP&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT ,BOUEFNPOTUSPVRVFHSBmBT hTGPSNBTBQSJPSJEBTFOTJCJMJEBEFFEPTDPODFJUPTBQSJPSJEP FOUFOEJNFOUPQPTTVrNPTVNBDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOIFDJNFOUP JOBUB KVr[PTTJOUnUJDPTBQSJPSJ
VOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJBRVF OkPEFQFOEFEBFYQFSJpODJB NBTTFSFBMJ[BQPSPDBTJkPEB FYQFSJpODJBTPCSFPTPCKFUPTRVFFTUBOPTPGFSFDF $PNP,BOUQSPWBRVFOkPTkPQPTTrWFJTKVr[PTTJOUnUJDPT BQSJPSJOBNFUBGrTJDB &NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT DPNP,BOU FYQMJDBQPSRVFOkPQPEFNPTDPOIFDFSPOyVNFOPPVB DPJTBFNTJ RVFFSBPPCKFUPEBNFUBGrTJDB ,BOUEJTUJOHVJVEVBTNPEBMJEBEFTEFSFBMJEBEFBSFBMJEB EFRVFTFPGFSFDFBOwTOBFYQFSJpODJB GFOyNFOP FBSFBMJEB EFRVFOkPTFPGFSFDFhFYQFSJpODJB OyVNFOP 0GFOyNFOP nBDPJTBQBSBOwTPVPPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPQSPQSJBNFOUF EJUP nPPCKFUPFORVBOUPTVKFJUPEPKVr[P0OyVNFOPnBDPJ TBFNTJPVPPCKFUPEBNFUBGrTJDB JTUPn PRVFnEBEPQBSB VNQFOTBNFOUPQVSP TFNSFMBmkPDPNBFYQFSJpODJB0SB Tw IgDPOIFDJNFOUPVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJPEBRVJMPRVFnPSHB OJ[BEPQFMPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPOBTGPSNBTEPFTQBmPF EPUFNQPFEFBDPSEPDPNPTDPODFJUPTEPFOUFOEJNFOUP4F
| U NIDADE 6
|
A metafísica
POyVNFOPnBRVJMPRVFOVODBTFBQSFTFOUBhTFOTJCJMJEBEF OFNBPFOUFOEJNFOUP NBTnBGJSNBEPQFMPQFOTBNFOUPQVSP OkPQPEFTFSDPOIFDJEP 2VBMBNFUBGrTJDBRVFnQPTTrWFMQBSBOPTTPFOUFOEJNFO UP 2VBJTTkPPTPCKFUPTEFJOWFTUJHBmkPNFUBGrTJDBRVF FTUkPBPBMDBODFEFOPTTPFOUFOEJNFOUP "NFUBGrTJDBQPTTrWFMQBSBOPTTPFOUFOEJNFOUPnBRVFMB RVFUFNDPNPPCKFUPBJOWFTUJHBmkPEPTDPODFJUPTVTBEPT QFMBTDJpODJBT±FTQBmP UFNQP RVBOUJEBEF RVBMJEBEF DBV TBMJEBEF TVCTUBODJBMJEBEF VOJWFSTBMJEBEF OFDFTTJEBEF FUD 0VTFKB PFTUVEPEBTDPOEJm{FTBQSJPSJEBFYJTUpODJBEPT PCKFUPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPPFTUVEPEBTDPOEJm{FTVOJWFSTBJT FOFDFTTgSJBTEBPCKFUJWJEBEFFNHFSBMFOkPP²4FSFORVBO UP4FS³ OFN%FVT BMNBFNVOEP OFNTVCTUiODJBJOGJOJUB QFOTBOUFFFYUFOTBPFTUVEPEBTNBOFJSBTQFMBTRVBJTPTV KFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPQ{FBSFBMJEBEF JTUPn FTUBCFMFDFPT PCKFUPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPIVNBOPFEBFYQFSJpODJBIVNBOB PV FNPVUSBTQBMBWSBT EPNPEPDPNPPTTFSFTIVNBOPT FORVBOUPNBOJGFTUBm{FTEP4VKFJUP5SBOTDFOEFOUBM EFGJOFN FFTUBCFMFDFNSFBMJEBEFTF BJOEB VNPCKFUPEFFTUVEPQSg UJDP RVBMTFKB BBmkPIVNBOBDPNPBmkPNPSBM PVPRVF,BOU DIBNBEFBmkPMJWSFQPSEFWFS
#APqTULOß߯ßß=kjpkhkce]_kjpailknja] &YQMJRVFPRVFnPJEFBMJTNPJOBVHVSBEPQPS,BOUFDPNPTF EJGFSFODJBEPSFBMJTNP 1BSB,BOU PDPOIFDJNFOUPOkPWFNEBTDPJTBTQBSBBDPOT DJpODJB SFBMJTNP
NBTWFNEBTJEFJBTEBDPOTDJpODJBQBSBBT DPJTBT JEFBMJTNP /VODBTBCFSFNPTPRVFnFDPNPnBSFBMJEB EFFNTJNFTNB TFQBSBEBFJOEFQFOEFOUFEFOwT$POIFDFNPT BQFOBTBSFBMJEBEFDPNPGFOyNFOP JTUPn PSHBOJ[BEBQFMPTV KFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPTFHVOEPBTGPSNBTEPFTQBmPFEPUFNQP FTFHVOEPPTDPODFJUPTEPFOUFOEJNFOUP"SFBMJEBEFDPOIFDr WFMFDPOIFDJEBnBRVFMBQPTUBQFMBPCKFUJWJEBEFFTUBCFMFDJEB QFMBSB[kPPVQFMP4VKFJUP5SBOTDFOEFOUBM&TTBEJGFSFODJBmkP FNSFMBmkPBPSFBMJTNPCBTFJBTFFNEVBTJOPWBm{FTGVOEBNFO UBJTOBUSBOTGPSNBmkPEBQSwQSJBUFPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFN NFUBGrTJDB DPNPJOWFTUJHBmkPEBTDPOEJm{FTHFSBJTEPDPOIF DJNFOUPVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJPEPTGFOyNFOPTFOPGBUPEFRVF PTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPOkPn DPNPQFOTBSB)VNF PTVKFJUP QTJDPMwHJDPJOEJWJEVBM NBTVNBFTUSVUVSBVOJWFSTBM JEpOUJDBQB SBUPEPTPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFNUPEPTPTUFNQPTFMVHBSFT 2VBJTBTUSpTUBSFGBTRVF)VTTFSMBUSJCVJhGFOPNFOPMPHJB %JTUJOHVJSFTFQBSBSQTJDPMPHJBFGJMPTPGJBBGJSNBSBQSJPSJ EBEFEPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPPVDPOTDJpODJBSFGMFYJWBEJBO UFEPTPCKFUPTFBNQMJBSSFOPWBSPDPODFJUPEFGFOyNFOP 1PSRVF)VTTFSMNPTUSPVRVFBQTJDPMPHJBOkPQPEFSJBTVCT UJUVJSBMwHJDBFBUFPSJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP 2VBMBEJGFSFOmB FOUSFBGJMPTPGJBFBQTJDPMPHJB 1BSB)VTTFSM BQTJDPMPHJBFTUVEBFFYQMJDBGBUPTPCTFSWg WFJT NBTOkPQPEFPGFSFDFSPTGVOEBNFOUPTEFUBJTFTUVEPTF FYQMJDBm{FT QPJTPTGVOEBNFOUPT DPNPPOPNFJOEJDB OkPTkP GBUPTPCTFSWgWFJT/JTTPDPOTJTUFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBGJMPTPGJB FBQTJDPMPHJB&TUBFYQMJDBGBUPTFBRVFMBEFTDSFWFFTTpODJBT EBWJEBQTrRVJDB1PSFYFNQMP FORVBOUPVNQTJDwMPHPQBSUF EBQFSHVOUB²$PNPBDPOUFDFVNBQFSDFQmkP ³ VNGJMwTPGP DPNFmBQFSHVOUBOEP²0RVFnBQFSDFQmkP ³
0RVFnBDPOTDJpODJBSFGMFYJWB 1PSRVFnDPOTDJpODJBUSBOT DFOEFOUBM $POTDJpODJBSFGMFYJWBnPQPEFSRVFPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJ NFOUPUFNEFEBSTJHOJGJDBmkPhSFBMJEBEFcUSBOTDFOEFOUBM QPSRVFnDPOTUJUVrEBDPNPFTUSVUVSBFBUJWJEBEFVOJWFSTBMF OFDFTTgSJBEPTBCFS OkPTFOEPVNBDPJTBOFNVNBTVCTUiO DJB NBTVNBBUJWJEBEF VNBBmkP 0RVFBGFOPNFOPMPHJBFOUFOEFQPSJOUFODJPOBMJEBEFEB DPOTDJpODJB *OUFODJPOBMJEBEFEBDPOTDJpODJBnPBUPEFWJTBSBTDPJTBT FORVBOUPTJHOJGJDBm{FT JTUPn UPEBDPOTDJpODJBnTFNQSFDPOT DJpODJBEFBMHVNBDPJTB 1PSRVF)FHFMGPJPQSJNFJSPBFNQSFHBSBQBMBWSBGFOPNF OPMPHJB 0RVFQSFUFOEFVTJHOJGJDBSDPNFMB 1PSRVFBNQMJPVPDPODFJUPLBOUJBOPEFGFOyNFOP BGJS NBOEPRVFUVEPPRVFBQBSFDFTwQPEFBQBSFDFSQBSBVNB DPOTDJpODJBFRVFBQSwQSJBDPOTDJpODJBNPTUSBTFBTJNFTNB OPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFTJ TFOEPFMBQSwQSJBVNGFOyNFOP%FT TBNBOFJSB )FHFMRVJTJOEJDBSDPNBQBMBWSBGFOPNFOPMPHJBP DPOIFDJNFOUPRVFBDPOTDJpODJBUFNEFTJNFTNBBUSBWnTEPT EFNBJTGFOyNFOPTRVFMIFBQBSFDFN 2VBMBDSrUJDBEF)VTTFSMhDPODFQmkPLBOUJBOBEFGFOyNF OP )VTTFSMEJ[RVF,BOUFRVJWPDPVTFBPEJTUJOHVJSGFOyNFOP FOyVNFOP QPJT DPNFTTBEJTUJOmkP NBOUFWFBWFMIBJEFJB NFUBGrTJDBEBSFBMJEBEFFNTJPVEP²4FSFORVBOUP4FS³ NFTNP RVFEJTTFTTFRVFOkPBQPErBNPTDPOIFDFS$POUSBSJBNFOUF )VTTFSMBGJSNBRVFOkPIgOyVNFOP OkPIgB²DPJTBFNTJ³ JODPHOPTDrWFM5VEPPRVFFYJTUFnGFOyNFOPFTwFYJTUFNGF OyNFOPT 2VBMBDSrUJDBEF)VTTFSMhDPODFQmkPIFHFMJBOBEFGFOy NFOP )VTTFSMEJ[RVF)FHFMBCPMJVBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBDPOTDJpODJB FPNVOEP QPSRVFEJTTFSBRVFFTUFOBEBNBJTnEPRVFPNPEP DPNPBDPOTDJpODJBTFUPSOBBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT UPSOBTFNVOEP FMBNFTNB UVEPTFOEPGFOyNFOPGFOyNFOPJOUFSJPS±BDPOT DJpODJB±FGFOyNFOPFYUFSJPS±PNVOEPDPNPNBOJGFTUBmkP EBDPOTDJpODJBOBTDPJTBT$POUSBSJBNFOUF )VTTFSMBGJSNBRVF BDPOTDJpODJBQPTTVJVNBFTTpODJBEJGFSFOUFEBTFTTpODJBTEPT GFOyNFOPT QPJTFMBnEPBEPSBEFTFOUJEPhTDPJTBTFFTUBTTkP SFDFQUPSBTEFTFOUJEP"DPOTDJpODJBOkPTFFODBSOBOBTDPJTBT OkPTFUPSOBBTQSwQSJBTDPJTBT NBTEgTJHOJGJDBmkPBFMBT QFS NBOFDFOEPEJGFSFOUFEFMBT 0RVF)VTTFSMFOUFOEFQPSGFOyNFOP 1BSB)VTTFSM UVEPPRVFFYJTUFnGFOyNFOP'FOyNFOPn BQSFTFOmBSFBMEFDPJTBTSFBJTEJBOUFEBDPOTDJpODJBnBRVJMP RVFTFBQSFTFOUBEJSFUBNFOUF ²FNQFTTPB³ ²FNDBSOFFPTTP³ hDPOTDJpODJB RVFnBEPBEPSBEFTFOUJEPhTDPJTBT QFSNBOF DFOEPEJGFSFOUFEFMBT BPDPOUSgSJPEPRVFEJ[JB)FHFM&NVNB QBMBWSB GFOyNFOPnBFTTpODJB 2VBMPDBNQPEPTGFOyNFOPT &NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT RVBM PBMBSHBNFOUPEPDPODFJUPEFGFOyNFOPUSB[JEPQPS)VT TFSM 0DBNQPEPTGFOyNFOPTnPDBNQPEBTFTTpODJBTEFUPEBT BTDPJTBT"MnNEBTDPJTBTNBUFSJBJTFEBTDPJTBTOBUVSBJT EF
00
Manual do Professor
BDPSEPDPNPBMBSHBNFOUPEPDPODFJUPEF)VTTFSM QFSUFODFN BPDBNQPEPTGFOyNFOPTBTDPJTBTQVSBNFOUFJEFBJTPVJEFB MJEBEFT DPJTBTRVFFYJTUFNBQFOBTOPQFOTBNFOUP UBJTDPNP O|NFSPT DPODFJUPTDPNPJHVBMEBEF FUD FUBNCnNBTDPJTBT DVMUVSBJT JTUPn BTDPJTBTDSJBEBTQFMBBmkPFQFMBQSgUJDBIV NBOBT UnDOJDBT BSUFT JOTUJUVJm{FT WBMPSFT FUD 0RVF)VTTFSMFOUFOEFQPSSFHJ{FTEPTFS 1PSRVFEFTTB JEFJBTVSHFBEFPOUPMPHJBTSFHJPOBJT 5SBUBTFEBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFPTEJGFSFOUFTUJQPTEFFTTpODJBT PVGFOyNFOPTDPOTJEFSBOEPDBEBVNEFMFTDPNPNBOJGFTUBmkP EFVNUJQPEFSFBMJEBEFEJGFSFOUF VNUJQPEFTFSEJGFSFOUF1PS FYFNQMPSFHJkPEBDPOTDJpODJB SFHJkPEBOBUVSF[B SFHJkPEB BSUF FUD"QBSUJSEFTTBJEFJBTVSHFBJEFJBEFPOUPMPHJBTSF HJPOBJT QPSRVFBNFUBGrTJDBEP²4FSFORVBOUP4FS³FBNFUB GrTJDBEBTTVCTUiODJBT %FVT BMNB NVOEPJOGJOJUP QFOTBOUF FYUFOTB QBTTBWBNBDFEFSMVHBSBPFTUVEPEPTFSEJGFSFODJBEP FNFOUFTEPUBEPTEFFTTpODJBTQSwQSJBTFJSSFEVUrWFJTVOTBPT PVUSPT 0RVFnBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFyOUJDPFPOUPMwHJDPQSPQPTUBQPS )FJEFHHFS ÏOUJDPTFSFGFSFhFTUSVUVSBFhFTTpODJBQSwQSJBEFVNFOUF BRVJMPRVFFMFnFNTJNFTNP TVBJEFOUJEBEF TVBEJGFSFOmBFN GBDFEFPVUSPTFOUFT TVBTSFMBm{FTDPNPVUSPTFOUFT0OUP MwHJDPTFSFGFSFBPFTUVEPGJMPTwGJDPEPTFOUFT hJOWFTUJHBmkP EPTDPODFJUPTRVFOPTQFSNJUBNDPOIFDFSFEFUFSNJOBSQFMP QFOTBNFOUPFNRVFDPOTJTUFNBTNPEBMJEBEFTyOUJDBT RVBJT PTNnUPEPTBEFRVBEPTQBSBPFTUVEPEFDBEBVNBEFMBT RVBJT BTDBUFHPSJBTRVFTFBQMJDBNBDBEBVNBEFMBT 4FHVOEP)FJEFHHFS RVBJTTkPBTDJODPFTUSVUVSBTyOUJDBT EFOPTTBWJEBDPUJEJBOB 0TFOUFTNBUFSJBJTPVOBUVSBJTRVFDIBNBNPTEFDPJTBT S FBJT GSVUBT QFESBT P4PM FUD PTFOUFTNBUFSJBJTBSUJGJDJBJT BRVFUBNCnNDIBNBNPTEFDPJTBTSFBJT NFTBT BVUPNwWFJT SPVQBT UBMIFSFT FUD PTFOUFTJEFBJT JTUPn BRVFMFTRVFOkP TkPDPJTBTNBUFSJBJT NBTJEFJBTHFSBJT DPODFCJEBTQFMPQFO TBNFOUPMwHJDP NBUFNgUJDP DJFOUrGJDP GJMPTwGJDPFBPTRVBJT EBNPTPOPNFEFJEFBMJEBEFT JHVBMEBEF O|NFSP QTrRVJDP FOFSHJB FUD PTFOUFTRVFQPEFNTFSWBMPSJ[BEPTQPTJUJWBPV OFHBUJWBNFOUFFBPTRVBJTEBNPTPOPNFEFWBMPSFT CFMF[B CPN KVTUP WFSEBEFJSP FUD PTFOUFTRVFQFSUFODFNBVNB SFBMJEBEFEJGFSFOUFEBRVFMBBRVFQFSUFODFNBTDPJTBT BTJEFB MJEBEFTFPTWBMPSFTFBPTRVBJTEBNPTPOPNFEFNFUBGrTJDPT BEJWJOEBEFPVPBCTPMVUP PJOGJOJUPFPOBEBBNPSUFFBJNPS UBMJEBEF FUD 4FHVOEP)FJEFHHFS RVBOEPQBTTBNPTEBFYQFSJpODJByO UJDBBPDPOIFDJNFOUPPOUPMwHJDP 2VBOEPBRVJMPRVFGB[QBSUFEFOPTTBWJEBDPUJEJBOBTFUPS OBQSPCMFNgUJDP FTUSBOIP DPOGVTPRVBOEPTPNPTTVSQSFFO EJEPTQFMBTDPJTBTFQFMBTQFTTPBT QPSRVFBDPOUFDFBMHPJOFT QFSBEPPVJNQSFWJTrWFMRVBOEPEFTFKBNPTVTBSDFSUBTDPJTBTF OkPTBCFNPTDPNPMJEBSDPNFMBTFOGJN RVBOEPPTJHOJGJDBEP DPTUVNFJSPEBTDPJTBT EBTBm{FT EPTWBMPSFTPVEBTQFTTPBT QFSEFTFOUJEPPVTFNPTUSBPCTDVSPFDPOGVTP PVRVBOEPP RVFOPTGPJEJUP FOTJOBEPFUSBOTNJUJEPTPCSFFMFTKgOkPOPT TBUJTGB[FRVFSFNPTTBCFSNBJTFNFMIPS
01
0OUPMPHJDBNFOUF PRVFnVNTFSSFBMPVBSFBMJEBEF 0OUPMPHJDBNFOUF VNBDPJTBnDIBNBEBSFBMQPSRVFQFS UFODFBVNDPOKVOUPEFFOUFTRVFQPTTVFNFNDPNVNBNFTNB FTUSVUVSBTkPVNTFS FYJTUFNOPNVOEP GPSBEFOwT TkPVNB SFBMJEBEF FYJTUFNRVFSOwTPTQFSDFCBNPT RVFSOkP RVFSOwT PTVTFNPT RVFSOkP TkPUFNQPSBJT DPNFmBNBFYJTUJS QPT TVFNEVSBmkPFQPEFNEFTBQBSFDFS TkPDBVTBMJEBEFT TF USBOTGPSNBNOPUFNQP TkPQSPEV[JEPTQFMBBmkPEFPVUSPTF QSPEV[FNPVUSPT PCFEFDFOEPBDFSUPTQSJODrQJPT 0OUPMPHJDBNFOUF PRVFnVNTFSJEFBMPVVNBJEFBMJEBEF &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS UBJTFOUFTOkPTkPDPJTBTSFBJTFNTF HVOEPMVHBS OkPDBVTBNVOTBPTPVUSPT NBTTkPFOUFTRVF QPTTVFNVNBEFGJOJmkPQSwQSJB QPEFOEPSFMBDJPOBSTFDPN PVUSPTFNUFSDFJSPMVHBS OkPFYJTUFNEPNFTNPNPEPRVFBT DPJTBT JTUPn OkPDPNFmBNBFYJTUJS USBOTGPSNBNTFFEFTBQB SFDFN*EFBMJEBEF SFMBmkPFBUFNQPSBMJEBEFTkPPTDPODFJUPT POUPMwHJDPTQBSBPTFOUFTJEFBJT 2VBJTPTDPODFJUPTPOUPMwHJDPTQBSBEFTDSFWFSPTFSEPT WBMPSFTPVPTFOUFTRVFTkPWBMPSFT /PDBTPEPTFOUFTRVFTkPWBMPSFT PTDPODFJUPTPOUPMw HJDPTQSJODJQBJTRVFPTEFTDSFWFNTkPBRVBMJEBEF VNWBMPS QPEFTFSBGJSNBUJWPPVOFHBUJWP FBQPMBSJEBEFPVPQPTJmkP PT WBMPSFTTFNQSFTFBQSFTFOUBNDPNPQBSFTPQPTUPTCPNNBV CFMPGFJP KVTUPJOKVTUP WFSEBEFJSPGBMTP FUD 2VBMPEJMFNBFOUSFJEFBMJTNPFSFBMJTNP 0SFBMJTNPBGJSNBRVF TFFMJNJOBSNPTPTVKFJUPPVBDPOTDJpO DJB SFTUBNBTDPJTBTFNTJNFTNBT BSFBMJEBEFWFSEBEFJSB PTFS FNTJ0JEFBMJTNP BPDPOUSgSJP BGJSNBRVF TFFMJNJOBSNPTBTDPJ TBTPVPOyVNFOP SFTUBBDPOTDJpODJBPVPTVKFJUPRVF QPSNFJP EFPQFSBm{FTEPDPOIFDJNFOUP SFWFMBBSFBMJEBEF PPCKFUP 0RVFSFTUBTFSFUJSBSNPTBDPOTDJpODJB 0RVFSFTUBTF FMJNJOBSNPTBTDPJTBT 0RVFEJ[VNBOPWBPOUPMPHJBRVF TFBGBTUBUBOUPEPJEFBMJTNPEBDPOTDJpODJBDPNPEPSFB MJTNPEBTDPJTBT 4FFMJNJOBSNPTBDPOTDJpODJB OkPTPCSBOBEB QPJTBT DPJTBTFYJTUFNQBSBOwT JTUPn QBSBVNBDPOTDJpODJBRVFBT QFSDFCF JNBHJOB RVFEFMBTTFMFNCSB OFMBTQFOTBFRVFBT USBOTGPSNBQFMPUSBCBMIP4FFMJNJOBSNPTBTDPJTBT UBNCnN OkPSFTUBOBEB QPJTOkPQPEFNPTWJWFSTFNPNVOEPOFN GPSBEFMFOkPTPNPTPTDSJBEPSFTEPNVOEP FTJNTFVTIB CJUBOUFT4FNBDPOTDJpODJB OkPIgNVOEPQBSBOwT4FNP NVOEP OkPUFNPTDPNPDPOIFDFSOFNBHJS"OPWBPOUPMP HJBQBSUFEBBGJSNBmkPEFRVFFTUBNPTOPNVOEPFEFRVFP NVOEPnNBJTWFMIPEPRVFOwT NBT TJNVMUBOFBNFOUF EF RVFTPNPTDBQB[FTEFEBSTFOUJEPBPNVOEP DPOIFDpMPF USBOTGPSNgMP 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFTPNPTVNBDPOTDJpODJBFODBSOB EBFUFNQPSBM 0RVFnPNVOEPQBSBTFSFTFODBSOBEPTF UFNQPSBJT 4JHOJGJDBRVFIgVNBJOUFSSFMBmkPFOUSFPDPSQPFBDPOT DJpODJBOPTTPDPSQPOkPnBQFOBTVNBDPJTBOBUVSBM NBTTP NPTVNDPSQPIVNBOP JTUPn IBCJUBEPFBOJNBEPQPSVNB DPOTDJpODJB RVF QPSTVBWF[ OkPDPOGJHVSBOVNQFOTBNFOUP QVSP QPJTnQBSUFEFOPTTPDPSQP1BSBOwT PNVOEPOkPn NFSBNFOUFVNDPOKVOUPEFDPJTBTFGBUPTFTUVEBEPTQFMBTDJpO DJBT NBTVNMVHBSPOEFOBTDFNPTFWJWFNPTDPNPTPVUSPT DPOTDJFOUFTEBNPSUF SPEFBEPTQFMBTDPJTBT
| U NIDADE 6
|
A metafísica
0RVFBOPWBPOUPMPHJBFOUFOEFQPSSFBMJEBEF "SFBMJEBEFnPDBNQPGPSNBEPQPSTFSFTPVFOUFTEJGFSFO DJBEPTFSFMBDJPOBEPTFOUSFTJRVFQPTTVFNTFOUJEPFNTJNFT NPTFRVFUBNCnNSFDFCFNEFOwTPVUSPTFOPWPTTFOUJEPT "SFBMJEBEFPVP4FSOkPnP0CKFUP$PJTB TFNBDPOTDJpODJB .BTUBNCnNOkPnP4VKFJUP$POTDJpODJB TFNBTDPJTBTFPT PVUSPT"SFBMJEBEFPVP4FSnPDSV[BNFOUPFBEJGFSFODJBmkP FOUSFPTFOTrWFMFPJOUFMJHrWFM FOUSFPNBUFSJBMDVMUVSBMFP JEFBMDVMUVSBM FOUSFPRVBMJUBUJWPFPRVBOUJUBUJWP FOUSFPQTr RVJDPFPDPSQPSBM FUD 0RVFBPOUPMPHJBJOWFTUJHB 2VBJTBTTVBTQSJODJQBJTRVFT U{FT "POUPMPHJBJOWFTUJHBBFTTpODJBPVPTFOUJEPEPFOUFGrTJDP PVOBUVSBM EPFOUFQTrRVJDP MwHJDP NBUFNgUJDP FTUnUJDP nUJ DP UFNQPSBM FTQBDJBM FUD*OWFTUJHBBTEJGFSFOmBTFBTSFMBm{FT FOUSFFMFT TFVNPEPQSwQSJPEFFYJTUJS TVBPSJHFN TVBGJOBMJ EBEF4VBTQSJODJQBJTRVFTU{FTTkP0RVFnPNVOEP 0RVFn PFVPVBDPOTDJpODJB 0RVFnPDPSQP 0RVFnPPVUSP 0RVF nPFTQBmPUFNQP 0RVFnBMJOHVBHFN 0RVFnPUSBCBMIP B SFMJHJkP BBSUF BTPDJFEBEF BIJTUwSJB BNPSUF PJOGJOJUP &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBJOWFTUJHBmkPPOUPMwHJDBEBTFTTpODJBT nVNBJOWFTUJHBmkPTPCSFBTTJHOJGJDBm{FT 1PSRVF BMnNEFCVTDBSP4FSPVBFTTpODJBEBTDPJTBT ²P RVFnJTUPRVFn ³
EPTBUPT EPTWBMPSFTIVNBOPT EBWJEB FEBNPSUF EPJOGJOJUPFEPGJOJUP BJOWFTUJHBmkPPOUPMwHJDBn BDSFTDJEBEBQFSHVOUB²1BSBRVFNnJTUPRVFn ³ SFGFSJOEPTF BPTFOUJEPPVhTJHOJGJDBmkPEFTTFTFOUFT "QSFTFOUFDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTBNBOFJSBDPNP.FSMFBV 1POUZJOWFTUJHBBFTTpODJBEFOPTTPDPSQP "PCVTDBSBFTTpODJBEPDPSQP .FSMFBV1POUZEJ[RVF DP NPPCKFUPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPTEBTDJpODJBT PDPSQPQPEFTFS BQFOBTNBJTVNBDPJTBFOUSFBTDPJTBT&OUSFUBOUP PDPSQPEF DBEBQFTTPBOkPnBQFOBTVNBDPJTB VNBNgRVJOBPVVNSF DFQUgDVMPQBSBBDPOTDJpODJBFMFUBNCnNnVNNPEPGVOEB NFOUBMEFTFSFEFFTUBSOPNVOEPDPNPRVBMDBEBQFTTPB TFSFMBDJPOBFDPNBTRVBJTFMFTFSFMBDJPOB$BEBDPSQPnVN TFOTrWFMRVFTFOUFFTFTFOUF RVFTFTBCFTFOUJSFTFTBCFTFO UJOEPcVNBJOUFSJPSJEBEFFYUFSJPSJ[BEBFVNBFYUFSJPSJEBEF JOUFSJPSJ[BEB&TTFnPTFSPVBFTTpODJBEFOPTTPDPSQP &YQPOIB DPN TVBT QBMBWSBT B NBOFJSB DPNP .FSMFBV 1POUZDSJUJDBBTDPODFQm{FTUSBEJDJPOBJTEPUFNQP #BTFBOEPTFOPQSFTTVQPTUPEBOPWBPOUPMPHJB .FSMFBV 1POUZDSJUJDBBTDPODFQm{FTUSBEJDJPOBJTEPUFNQPQPSTFSFN PSBSFBMJTUBTEFNBJT TVDFTTkPEFJOTUBOUFT
PSBJEFBMJTUBT EFNBJT VNDPODFJUPTVCKFUJWPQBSBFTUSVUVSBSPRVFnFYQF SJNFOUBEPDPNPTVDFTTJWP %JSg QPSTVBWF[ RVFPUFNQPn VNFTDPBNFOUPJOUFSOPFFYUFSOP VNGMVJSDPOUrOVP RVFWBJ QSPEV[JOEPEJGFSFOmBTEFOUSPEFTJNFTNPF QPSJTTP ²nVNB EJNFOTkPEFNFVTFS OkPFTUPVOPUFNQP NBTTPVUFNQPSBM FVNBEJNFOTkPEFUPEPTPTFOUFT OkPFTUkPOPUFNQP NBT TkPUFNQPSBJT ³
UFNQPOkPQPTTVJFTTBMJOFBSJEBEF².FVQBTTBEPFNFVGVUVSP OVODBTkPPTNFTNPT$BEBWF[RVFNFMFNCSPEPNFVQBTTB EP FVPGBmPDPNCBTFOPNFVQSFTFOUFF BDBEBWF[ FTUFnEJGF SFOUF GB[FOEPNFSFDPSEBSEFNBOFJSBTEJWFSTBTPRVFQBTTPV $BEBWF[RVFJNBHJOPNFVGVUVSP FVPGBmPDPNCBTFOPNFV QSFTFOUF RVF TFOEPTFNQSFEJGFSFOUF JNBHJOBEJGFSFOUFNFOUF PGVUVSP/kPSFWJWPPQBTTBEP NBTSFNFNPSPUBMDPNPTPVIPKF FNNFVQSFTFOUF/kPWJWPNFVGVUVSP NBTPJNBHJOPUBMDPNP TPVIPKFFNNFVQSFTFOUF0QSFTFOUFnVNBDPOUSBmkPUFN QPSBMRVFBSSBODBPQBTTBEPEPFTRVFDJNFOUPFBCSFPGVUVSP QBSBPQPTTrWFM0QBTTBEPFPGVUVSPTkPEJMBUBm{FTUFNQPSBJT EJTUFOT{FTEPQSFTFOUF³%FTTBNBOFJSBPUFNQPnVNBEJNFO TkPEPTFS OkPFTUPVOPUFNQP NBTTPVUFNQPSBM
PVTFKB nP NPWJNFOUPJOUFSOPEPTFOUFTQBSBSFVOJSFNTFDPOTJHPNFTNPT PQSFTFOUFDPNPDFOUSPRVFCVTDBPQBTTBEPFPGVUVSP FQBSB TFEJGFSFODJBSFNEFTJNFTNPT PQSFTFOUFDPNPEJGFSFOmBRVB MJUBUJWBFNGBDFEPQBTTBEPFEPGVUVSP 0TFSnUFNQP
#APqTULOß߯ßß=behkokbe]lo)iap]boe_] 0RVFnPDJFOUJGJDJTNP 1PSRVF QBSBFMF BNFUBGrTJDBn JNQPTTrWFM $JFOUJGJDJTNPnBDPOGJBOmBOBDBQBDJEBEFEBTDJpODJBT QBSBDPOIFDFSDPNQMFUBNFOUFBSFBMJEBEFUPEBFPUPEPEB SFBMJEBEF 0RVF)BCFSNBTFOUFOEFQPSQBSBEJHNBEBPOUPMPHJB &QPS QBSBEJHNBEBGJMPTPGJBEBDPOTDJpODJB &QPSQBSBEJHNBEB GJMPTPGJBEBMJOHVBHFN 1PSQBSBEJHNBEBPOUPMPHJB )BCFSNBTFOUFOEFBNFUBGr TJDBHSFHBFBDMgTTJDB JTUPn BTNFUBGrTJDBTSFBMJTUBT1PSQBSB EJHNBEBGJMPTPGJBEBDPOTDJpODJB FOUFOEFUBOUPBDSrUJDBLBOUJB OBDPNPBGFOPNFOPMPHJBIVTTFSMJBOB JTUPn BTGJMPTPGJBTRVF EFSBNQSJPSJEBEFBPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPPVhDPOTDJpODJB EFTJSFGMFYJWBFEBTRVBJTQSPWJFSBNNFUBGrTJDBTJEFBMJTUBT1PS QBSBEJHNBEBGJMPTPGJBEBMJOHVBHFNFOUFOEFBQSJPSJEBEFDPO GFSJEBhTFTUSVUVSBTHSBNBUJDBJTFMwHJDBTEBMJOHVBHFNPVEBT MJOHVBHFOTDPNPNBOFJSBTEFPSHBOJ[BSBSFBMJEBEFFEBSMIF TFOUJEP EFQFSNJUJSBBWBMJBmkPEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTDJFOUrGJDPTF EFBTTFHVSBSBQSgUJDBDPNVOJDBUJWBFOUSFPTTFSFTIVNBOPT "QFTBSEBTEJGFSFOmBT RVBMPBTQFDUPDPNVNhGJMPTPGJBEF %FTDBSUFTFhGFOPNFOPMPHJBEF)VTTFSM 5FOEPFNWJTUBFT TFBTQFDUPDPNVN RVBMnPQSFTTVQPTUPNFUBGrTJDPDPNVN BUPEBTBTGJMPTPGJBTEBDPOTDJpODJB 0BTQFDUPDPNVNhGJMPTPGJBEF%FTDBSUFTFhGFOPNFOPMP HJBEF)VTTFSMnPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPEJTUJOUPEBSFBMJEBEF EPPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP&NWJTUBEJTTP PQSFTTVQPTUPNF UBGrTJDPDPNVNBUPEBTBTGJMPTPGJBTEBDPOTDJpODJBnRVF QBSB IBWFSDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSP nOFDFTTgSJPRVFBRVFMFRVF DPOIFDFTFKBBDPOEJmkPEBRVJMPRVFnDPOIFDJEP2VFSDPNP TVCTUiODJB RVFSDPNPBUJWJEBEFBQSJPSJPVBUJWJEBEFQVSB P TVKFJUPFYJTUFFFYJTUFDPNVNNPEPEFTFSEJTUJOUPEPEBTEF NBJTDPJTBT
"QSFTFOUFDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTBEFTDSJmkPRVF.FSMFBV 1POUZPGFSFDFEBFTTpODJBEPUFNQP
$PNPBMJOHVrTUJDBBOBMJTBPTQSPOPNFTQFTTPBJTFVFUV
.FSMFBV1POUZBGJSNBRVFPUFNQPOkPnNFSBNFOUFVNB TVDFTTkPDPOUrOVBEFGBUPTRVFQPEFNTFSDMBTTJGJDBEPTOPBO UFT OPBHPSBFOPEFQPJT PVOPQBTTBEP QSFTFOUFFGVUVSP DPNPTFGPTTFVNSFDFQUgDVMPEFJOTUBOUFT1BSBPGJMwTPGP P
"OBMJTBOEPPTQSPOPNFTFVFUV BMJOHVrTUJDBNPTUSBRVF OkPTFSFGFSFNBTVCTUiODJBT FTTpODJBTPVFOUJEBEFTFYJTUFO UFT NBTTkPBQFOBTSFBMJEBEFTMJOHVrTUJDBT QVSBNFOUFEJTDVS TJWBT QPJTFTTFTQSPOPNFTTkPMPDVm{FTFOkPTFSFT
02
Manual do Professor
2VBJTPTQPOUPTEBBOgMJTFMJOHVrTUJDBEPTQSPOPNFTQFT TPBJTRVFMFWBNBEJ[FSRVFPTVKFJUPPVBTVCKFUJWJEBEFUFN BQFOBTFYJTUpODJBOBMJOHVBHFNPVVNBFYJTUpODJBQVSB NFOUFMJOHVrTUJDB &NOFOIVNBMrOHVB EFRVBMRVFSnQPDBFSFHJkP EFJYBEF IBWFSQSPOPNFTQFTTPBJTBPDPOUSgSJPEPTEFNBJTTJHOPTEB MJOHVBHFN PTQSPOPNFTQFTTPBJTOkPTFSFGFSFNBVNBFT TpODJBJOEJWJEVBM BVNFOUFJOEJWJEVBM BVNBDPJTBTFOTrWFM PVBVNBDPJTBJOUFMJHrWFM NBTSFGFSFNTFBVNBSFBMJEBEFQV SBNFOUFEJTDVSTJWBPQSPOPNFQFTTPBMFVPSHBOJ[BUPEPTPT PVUSPTQSPOPNFT BEKFUJWPT BEWnSCJPTFQSPOPNFTEFNPOTUSB UJWPThWPMUBEPMPDVUPSPSHBOJ[BBUFNQPSBMJEBEFQPSSFGFSpODJB BPQSFTFOUF RVFnPUFNQPFNRVFPFVGBMBNPEJGJDBPTFOUJ EPEPTWFSCPTDPNCBTFOPTWFSCPTRVFJOEJDBNEJTQPTJm{FTF PQFSBm{FTNFOUBJTEPMPDVUPS
1BSB'PVDBVMU PTBCFSOkPnBDVMUVSBEFVNBnQPDBFOkP QSFTTVQ{FBFYJTUpODJBEFVNTVKFJUP FQPSJTTPFMFOkPnBDJpO DJB QPJTOkPnVNDPOIFDJNFOUPEFVNPCKFUPEFUFSNJOBEPQPS VNTVKFJUPEFUFSNJOBEPOkPnBFYQFSJpODJB QPJTOkPnVNB WJWpODJBTVCKFUJWBOkPnPFTQrSJUPEFVNQPWP QPJTOkPnVNB DPOTDJpODJBDPMFUJWBPVVNTVKFJUPDPMFUJWPOkPnBJEFPMPHJB QPJTOkPQSFTTVQ{FVNBDPOTDJpODJBPVJODPOTDJpODJBDPMFUJWB RVFKVTUJGJRVFTVBGPSNBFTVBJOTUBMBmkPOPNVOEP1BSB'PV DBVMU PTBCFSUBNCnNOkPQSFTTVQ{FVNBDPOUJOVJEBEFFOUSF VNFTUBEPMBUFOUFPVWJSUVBMEFDPOIFDJNFOUPTFVNFTUBEP EFDPOIFDJNFOUPTBUVBMJ[BEPT OFNQSFTTVQ{FBDPOUJOVJEBEF FOUSFBEFTBQBSJmkPEFVNBDJpODJBFBQFSNBOpODJBEFSFTr EVPTFWFTUrHJPTEFMBOVNBDJpODJBOPWB0TBCFSFTUgTFNQSF SFGFSJEPBPQSFTFOUFF DPNPUBM OkPQPTTVJVNQBTTBEPOFN VNGVUVSP*TTPTJHOJGJDBRVFFOUSFEVBTGPSNBTEFTBCFSOkPIg DPOUJOVJEBEFFTJNEFTDPOUJOVJEBEF
2VBMBDPODMVTkPGJMPTwGJDBEBBOgMJTFMJOHVrTUJDBRVFBGBTUB BNFUBGrTJDBWJOEBEBTGJMPTPGJBTEBDPOTDJpODJB
0RVF'PVDBVMUFOUFOEFQPSTBCFS &YQPOIBPRVFFMFEJ[ RVFPTBCFSn
"DPODMVTkPEFRVFPTVKFJUPPVBTVCKFUJWJEBEFUFNVN GVOEBNFOUPQVSBNFOUFMJOHVrTUJDPFOkPGrTJDPOFNNFUBGrTJDP PVTFKB EFRVFBNFUBGrTJDBEBTGJMPTPGJBTEBDPOTDJpODJBTJN QMFTNFOUFUSBOTGPSNPVOVNTFSPVOVNNPEPEFTFSBRVJMPRVF OkPnTFOkPVNNPEPEFGBMBS
0TBCFSnPEPNrOJPEFPCKFUPTEFVNBQSgUJDBEJTDVSTJWB PVTFKB PEJTDVSTPnVNBQSgUJDBRVFJOTUJUVJPTQSwQSJPTPCKF UPTFFTTBQSgUJDBnPTBCFSFMFnPFTQBmPOPRVBMVNTVKFJUP QSBUJDBVNEJTDVSTPFTFBQSFTFOUBDPNPTVKFJUPFYBUBNFOUF QPSRVFSFBMJ[BFTTBQSgUJDBEJTDVSTJWB0VTFKB BTTJNDPNPB QSgUJDBEJTDVSTJWBJOTUJUVJPPCKFUP EBNFTNBNBOFJSBJOTUJUVJ PTVKFJUPnVNEJTDVSTPRVFQSPEV[QBSBTJNFTNPBTSFHSBTEF TVBFOVODJBmkPFPNPEPEFPSHBOJ[BmkPEFTFVTFOVODJBEPTP TBCFSnBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVTPFEFBQSPQSJBmkPEFVNEJTDVSTP QPSRVFNQPTTVJPVBERVJSFBDPNQFUpODJBQBSBQSPEV[JSFOVO DJBEPTDPOGPSNFThTSFHSBTEBQSgUJDBEJTDVSTJWBFNWJHPS
0RVF.JDIFM'PVDBVMUFOUFOEFQPSFQJTUFNF 6NBFTUSVUVSBEFDPOIFDJNFOUPTEFUFSNJOBEBQPSVNBSF EFEFDPODFJUPTRVFTkPPTJOTUSVNFOUPTDPNPTRVBJT OVNB EBEBnQPDB PTQFOTBEPSFTJOWFTUJHBNFJOUFSQSFUBNBSFBMJEB EF6NBFQJTUFNFnVNDPOKVOUPEFFOVODJBEPTPVEFEJTDVS TPTCBTFBEPTOVNDFSUPJOTUSVNFOUPDPODFJUVBMRVFPSHBOJ[B BMJOHVBHFNFPQFOTBNFOUPFMIFTEgPTFOUJNFOUPEFRVFBT QBMBWSBTDPSSFTQPOEFNhTDPJTBT $PNP'PVDBVMUEJTUJOHVFBFQJTUFNFEB3FOBTDFOmBFB FQJTUFNFDMgTTJDBPVEPSBDJPOBMJTNPNPEFSOP /BFQJTUFNFEB3FOBTDFOmB EJ['PVDBVMU PDPODFJUPRVF PSHBOJ[BPTEJTDVSTPTnPEFTFNFMIBOmB PVTFKB BDPODFQmkP EFRVFBSFBMJEBEFnVNUFDJEPFVNBUSBNBFNRVFBTDPJTBT TFBSUJDVMBNQPSQPTTVrSFNBTQFDUPTTFDSFUPTFJOWJTrWFJTRVF BTBQSPYJNBNQPSRVFTkPTFNFMIBOUFTPVBTEJTUBODJBNQPS RVFTkPEJGFSFOUFT$PNPSBDJPOBMJTNPDMgTTJDP PDPODFJUP PSHBOJ[BEPSEBMJOHVBHFNFEPQFOTBNFOUPEFJYBEFTFSB TFNFMIBOmBFQBTTBBTFSPVUSBDPJTBBSFQSFTFOUBmkP3FQSF TFOUBSOkPnCVTDBSPTMBmPTTFDSFUPTEFTJNQBUJBFBOUJQBUJB FOUSFBTDPJTBTFTJNBTJEFOUJEBEFTFEJGFSFOmBTSFBJTFOUSF FMBTFBTSFMBm{FTEFDBVTBFFGFJUPFOUSFDPJTBTEBNFTNB OBUVSF[B EJTQPTUBTOVNBPSEFNJOTUJUVrEBQFMPQFOTBNFO UP FNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNVNNnUPEP0SEFOBS JEFOUJGJDBSF EJGFSFODJBSTkPBTPQFSBm{FTEBSFQSFTFOUBmkPFEFGJOFNB FQJTUFNFNPEFSOB $PNP'PVDBVMUEFTDSFWFBFQJTUFNFBQBSUJSEPTnDVMP9*9 "QBSUJSEPTnDVMP9*9 nBIJTUwSJBPVBIJTUPSJDJEBEF FOUFO EJEBDPNPPNPEPEFTFSEBTDPJTBTFEBTQBMBWSBT RVFEFGJOF BFQJTUFNF$POIFDFSnFTUBCFMFDFSBOBMPHJBEFGVOm{FTFOUSF DPJTBTFFOUSFQBMBWSBTFDPJTBT CFNDPNPFTUBCFMFDFSBTVDFT TkPPVBPSEFNEFTVSHJNFOUP EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFEFTBQBSJmkP EBTDPJTBTFEBTQBMBWSBTOPUFNQP 0RVF'PVDBVMUFOUFOEFQPSTBCFS &YQPOIBPRVFFMFEJ[ RVFPTBCFSOkPn
03
0RVF'PVDBVMUFOUFOEFQPSEJTDVSTP &YQPOIBPRVFFMF EJ[RVFPEJTDVSTPOkPn %JTDVSTPOkPnBQBMBWSBPVBGBMB QPJTOkPnBBmkPEFVN TVKFJUPGBMBOUFOkPnPRVFTFSFGFSFBPCKFUPT QPJTPEJTDVSTP OkPnVNBGSBTFJOEJDBUJWBBTJHOJGJDBm{FT OkPnVNDPOKVOUP EFTJHOJGJDBOUFTPVEFTJHOPTPSHBOJ[BEPTQPSVNBDPOTDJpODJB QSPEVUPSBEFTJHOJGJDBm{FT PVBWBMPSFTEFWFSEBEFPVEFGBMTJ EBEF PEJTDVSTPOkPnBQSPQPTJmkPMwHJDBOFNPKVr[PMwHJDP 0RVF'PVDBVMUFOUFOEFQPSEJTDVSTP &YQPOIBPRVFFMF EJ[RVFPEJTDVSTPn %JTDVSTPnVNBSFEFEFFOVODJBEPTPVEFSFMBm{FTRVFUPS OBNQPTTrWFMIBWFSTJHOJGJDBOUFT OPNFT GSBTFT TJHOJGJDBm{FT QSPQPTJm{FT KVr[PT QBMBWSBPVGBMBFPCKFUPT0FOVODJBEPnB GVOmkPEPEJTDVSTPFFTUFFOHFOESBPTFOVODJBEPTEFNBOFJSBT WBSJBEBT TFHVOEPBTSFHSBTRVFDPOTUJUVFN FNDBEBnQPDB VNBGPSNBmkPEJTDVSTJWB 1PSRVFQPEFNPTGBMBSFNQFOTBNFOUPQwTNFUBGrTJDP RVBOEPSFVOJNPTBBOgMJTFMJOHVrTUJDBEPTQSPOPNFTQFT TPBJTFBBOgMJTFGPVDBVMUJBOBEPTBCFSFEPEJTDVSTP %FBDPSEPDPNBBOgMJTFMJOHVrTUJDBBUSBWnTEPFTUVEPEPT QSPOPNFT TBCFNPTRVFPTVKFJUPnVNFGFJUPQSPEV[JEPQFMB MJOHVBHFN&N"BSRVFPMPHJBEPTBCFS 'PVDBVMUOPTFOTJOBRVF TVKFJUPFPCKFUPTkPFGFJUPTQSPEV[JEPTQFMPEJTDVSTP%FTTBNB OFJSB QPEFNPTDPODMVJSRVFPQSJODrQJPEBNFUBGrTJDBSFBMJTUB ±PPCKFUPPVP4FS±FPQSJODrQJPEBNFUBGrTJDBJEFBMJTUB±P TVKFJUPPVBDPOTDJpODJBEFTJ±OkPTkPQSJODrQJPT NBTTJNQMFT FGFJUPTEBMJOHVBHFNFEPEJTDVSTP/kPIBWFOEP QPSUBOUP QBSB BNFUBGrTJDBOPQSFTFOUF VNQSJODrQJPPVVNGVOEBNFOUPOFN SFBMJEBEFTPVTFSFT EFWFTFDPODMVJSRVFFMBQFSUFODFBVNB
| U NIDADE 7
|
A ciência
GPSNBmkPEJTDVSTJWBPVBVNBMJOHVBHFNEFTBQBSFDJEB TFOEP OFDFTTgSJP QPSUBOUP GBMBS OBBUVBMJEBEF FNVNQFOTBNFOUP QwTNFUBGrTJDP
5NIDADEßßßß=_ej_e] #APqTULOß߯ßß=]pepq`a_eajpbe_] %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPTEFDFSUF[BTEPTFOTPDPNVNFTVBSF GVUBmkPQFMBTDJpODJBT 1FMPGBUPEFTFSFNHFSBMVNDPOIFDJNFOUPIFSEBEP BDSrUJDPFOkPSFGMFUJEP PTFOTPDPNVNSFQSPEV[DFSUF[BTTP CSFBTNBJTEJGFSFOUFTDPJTBT"GBNrMJBDPNPVNBDSJBmkPEB OBUVSF[BQBSBHBSBOUJSBTPCSFWJWpODJB BFYJTUpODJBEFSBmB DPNPVNGFOyNFOPQSPEV[JEPQFMBEJGFSFOmBEPTDMJNBT EB BMJNFOUBmkP EBHFPHSBGJBFEBSFQSPEVmkPTFYVBM BDFSUF[B EFRVFBTFTQnDJFTFHpOFSPTEFBOJNBJTTFNQSFFYJTUJSBNUBM DPNPPTDPOIFDFNPT&OUSFUBOUP PDPOIFDJNFOUPFMBCPSB EPQFMBTEJGFSFOUFTDJpODJBTEFNPOTUSBRVFPTHpOFSPTFBT FTQnDJFTEFBOJNBJTTFUSBOTGPSNBSBNMFOUBNFOUFEVSBOUF PQSPDFTTPFWPMVUJWPBTPDJPMPHJBFBBOUSPQPMPHJBNPTUSBN RVFPRVFFOUFOEFNPTQPSGBNrMJBnVNBJOTUJUVJmkPTPDJBM SFDFOUF TnDVMP97
FRVFTFUSBUBEFVNBDSJBmkPIVNBOB EBNFTNBNBOFJSB IJTUPSJBEPSFTFBOUSPQwMPHPTNPTUSBN RVFBJEFJBEFSBmBUBNCnNnSFDFOUF TnDVMP97***
BQMJDB EBQPSQFOTBEPSFTRVFQSPDVSBWBNVNBFYQMJDBmkPQBSBBT EJGFSFOmBTGrTJDBTFDVMUVSBJTFOUSFPTFVSPQFVTFPTQPWPT RVFTFUPSOBSBNDPOIFDJEPTQPSFMFTQPSNFJPEPFYQBOTJP OJTNPNBSrUJNP 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEPTTBCFSFTEPTFOTPDP NVN %FTTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT FTDPMIBUSpTFFYQMJRVFBT 0T TBC FSFT EP TFOT P DPN VN TkP DBS BDU FS J[ BEPT QPS TFSFNTVCKFUJWPTRVBMJUBUJWPTIFUFSPHpOFPTJOEJWJEVB MJ[BEPSFT HFOFSBMJ[BEPSFT WPMUBEPT BP FTUBCFMFDJNFOUP EFDBVTBMJEBEFTDPOGPSNBEPThSFHVMBSJEBEF DPOTUiODJB SFQFUJmkPFEJGFSFOmBEBTDPJTBTNBTBENJSBEPTDPNP|OJ DP PFYUSBPSEJOgSJP PNBSBWJMIPTPPVPNJSBDVMPTPVNB DPODFQmkPNgHJDBEBDJpODJBQSPKFm{FTEFTFOUJNFOUPTOBT DPJTBTFOPNVOEPEJBOUFEPEFTDPOIFDJEPDSJTUBMJ[BEPTFN QSFDPODFJUPTDPNPTRVBJTJOUFSQSFUBNBSFBMJEBEF4kPTVC KFUJWPTQPSFYQSJNJSFNTFOUJNFOUPTFPQJOJ{FTJOEJWJEVBJT FEFHSVQPT WBSJBOEPEFVNBQFTTPBQBSBPVUSB PVEFVN HSVQPQBSBPVUSP EFQFOEFOEPEBTDPOEJm{FTFNRVFWJWF NPTTkPRVBMJUBUJWPTEFWJEPhBOgMJTFTVCKFUJWBRVFOPTMFWB BVNBBWBMJBmkPEBTDPJTBTDPOGPSNFPTFGFJUPTRVFQSPEV [FNFNOPTTPTwSHkPTEPTTFOUJEPTPVDPOGPSNFPTEFTFKPT RVFEFTQFSUBNFNOwTFPUJQPEFGJOBMJEBEFPVEFVTPRVF MIFTBUSJCVrNPTTkPIFUFSPHpOFPTQPSBHSVQBSFNTFPVTF EJTUJOHVJSFNDPOGPSNFBTDPJTBTFPTGBUPTQBSFmBNTFNF MIBOUFTPVEJGFSFOUFT 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPDJFOUr GJDPFNPQPTJmkPBPTFOTPDPNVN %FTTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT FTDPMIBUSpTFFYQMJRVFBT &NPQPTJmkPBPTFOTPDPNVN PDPOIFDJNFOUPDJFOUrGJDPDB SBDUFSJ[BTFQPSTFSPCKFUJWPTFSRVBOUJUBUJWPTFSIPNPHpOFP TFSHFOFSBMJ[BEPSTFSEJGFSFODJBEPSCBTFBSTFOBJOWFTUJHBmkP
BOUFTEFFTUBCFMFDFSSFMBm{FTEFDBVTBMJEBEFTVSQSFFOEFSTF DPNBSFHVMBSJEBEF BDPOTUiODJB BGSFRVpODJB BSFQFUJmkPFB EJGFSFOmBEBTDPJTBTFQSPDVSBSEFNPOTUSBSRVFPNBSBWJMIPTP PFYUSBPSEJOgSJPPVP²NJMBHSPTP³TkPDBTPTQBSUJDVMBSFTEJT UJOHVJSTFEBNBHJBBGJSNBSRVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPMJCFSUBBQSP KFmkPEFTFOUJNFOUPTOBTDPJTBT DPNPnPDBTPEPNFEPFEB TVQFSTUJmkPQSPDVSBSSFOPWBSTFFNPEJGJDBSTFDPOUJOVBNFOUF FWJUBOEPBUSBOTGPSNBmkPEBTUFPSJBTFNEPVUSJOBTFEFTUBTFN QSFDPODFJUPTTPDJBJT0DPOIFDJNFOUPDJFOUrGJDPnPCKFUJWPQPS QSPDVSBSBTFTUSVUVSBTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJBTEBTDPJTBTJOWFT UJHBEBTRVBOUJUBUJWPQPSCVTDBSNFEJEBT QBES{FT DSJUnSJPTEF DPNQBSBmkPFEFBWBMJBmkPQBSBDPJTBTRVFQBSFDFNEJGFSFOUFT nIPNPHpOFPQPSCVTDBSBTMFJTHFSBJTEFGVODJPOBNFOUPEPT GFOyNFOPT RVFTkPBTNFTNBTQBSBGBUPTRVFOPTQBSFDFNEJ GFSFOUFT 1PSRVFFNOPTTBTPDJFEBEFBDJpODJBUFOEFBTFSUPNBEB DPNPTFGPTTFNBHJB 2VBMPFRVrWPDPEJTTP 0GJMwTPGPEBTDJpODJBT (JMFT(BTUPO(SBOHFS BGJSNBRVF ²EPGFJUJDFJSPBPDJFOUJTUBIgBQFOBTVNQFRVFOPQBTTP³%F GBUP OBwUJDBEPTFOTPDPNVNQSFTFOUFFNOPTTBTPDJFEBEF UBOUPBDJpODJBRVBOUPBNBHJBMJEBNDPNPNJTUFSJPTP PPDVM UP PJODPNQSFFOTrWFM DIFHBOEPBPFYUSFNPEFTFDPOTJEFSBSB DJpODJBDPNPQSPUBHPOJTUBEF²NJMBHSFT³NPEFSOPT&OUSFUBO UP FNCPSBBDJpODJBQPTTBUFSDPOTFSWBEP BPTPMIPTEPTFOTP DPNVN VNBBQBSpODJBEFNJTUnSJPFHSBWJEBEFSJUVBM USBUBTF EFVNBJEFOUJGJDBmkPRVFOkPFYJTUF DPNPEJ[(SBOHFS ²QPJT BQFOBTMJCFSUBOEPTFEBNBHJBRVFBDJpODJBQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUB QPEFEFTFOWPMWFSTF³ 2VFBUJWJEBEFTJOUFMFDUVBJTHBSBOUFNSJHPSBPUSBCBMIPDJFO UrGJDP 4FQBSBSPTFMFNFOUPTTVCKFUJWPTFPCKFUJWPTEFVNGFOy NFOPDPOTUSVJSPGFOyNFOPDPNPVNPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUP DPOUSPMgWFM WFSJGJDgWFM JOUFSQSFUgWFMFDBQB[EFTFSSFUJGJDBEP PVDPSSJHJEPQPSOPWBTFMBCPSBm{FTEFNPOTUSBSFQSPWBSPTSF TVMUBEPTPCUJEPTEVSBOUFBJOWFTUJHBmkPSFMBDJPOBSDPNPVUSPT GBUPTVNGBUPJTPMBEP JOUFHSBOEPPOVNBFYQMJDBmkPSBDJPOBM VOJGJDBEBGPSNVMBSVNBUFPSJBHFSBMTPCSFPDPOKVOUPEPTGFOy NFOPTPCTFSWBEPTFEPTGBUPTJOWFTUJHBEPT $PNP"SJTUwUFMFTEFGJOFBDJpODJB $PNP(SBOHFSEFGJOF BDJpODJB 1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT BDJpODJBnVNDPOIFDJNFOUPEBTDBVTBT FQFMBTDBVTBT JTUPn VNDPOIFDJNFOUPEFNPOTUSBUJWP1BSB (SBOHFS BDJpODJBnVNNnUPEPEFQFOTBNFOUPFEFBmkP 2VBJTPTQSnSFRVJTJUPTQBSBBDPOTUJUVJmkPEFVNBDJpO DJB %FMJNJUBSPVEFGJOJSPTGBUPTBJOWFTUJHBS TFQBSBOEPPTEF PVUSPTTFNFMIBOUFTPVEJGFSFOUFTFTUBCFMFDFSPTQSPDFEJNFO UPTNFUPEPMwHJDPTQBSBPCTFSWBmkP FYQFSJNFOUBmkPFWFSJGJDB mkPEPTGBUPTDPOTUSVJSJOTUSVNFOUPTUnDOJDPTFDPOEJm{FTEF MBCPSBUwSJPFTQFDrGJDBTQBSBBQFTRVJTBFMBCPSBSVNDPOKVOUP TJTUFNgUJDPEFDPODFJUPTRVFGPSNFNBUFPSJBHFSBMEPTGFOy NFOPTFTUVEBEPT RVFDPOUSPMFNFHVJFNPBOEBNFOUPEBQFT RVJTB BMnNEFBNQMJgMBDPNOPWBTJOWFTUJHBm{FT FQFSNJUBN BQSFWJTkPEFGBUPTOPWPTDPNCBTFOPTKgDPOIFDJEPT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBDJpODJBnVNQFOTBNFOUPTJTUF NgUJDP
04
Manual do Professor
4JHOJGJDBRVFTFUSBUBEFVNTJTUFNBPSEFOBEPFDPFSFOUF EFQSPQPTJm{FTPVFOVODJBEPTCBTFBEPTFNVNQFRVFOPO| NFSPEFQSJODrQJPTDVKBGJOBMJEBEFnEFTDSFWFS FYQMJDBSFQSFWFS EPNPEPNBJTDPNQMFUPQPTTrWFMVNDPOKVOUPEFGFOyNFOPT PGFSFDFOEPTVBTMFJTOFDFTTgSJBT
#APqTULOß߯ßß=_e j_e]j]deopne]
2VBJTPTQSJODrQJPTEPJEFBMEFDJFOUJGJDJEBEFOBDPODFQmkP DPOTUSVUJWJTUBEFDJpODJB 2VFIBKBDPFSpODJBFOUSFPTQSJODrQJPTRVFPSJFOUBNBUFP SJBRVFPTNPEFMPTEPTPCKFUPTTFKBNDPOTUSVrEPTDPNCBTF OBPCTFSWBmkPFOBFYQFSJNFOUBmkPRVFPTSFTVMUBEPTPCUJEPT QPTTBNOkPTwBMUFSBSPTNPEFMPTDPOTUSVrEPT NBTUBNCnN BMUFSBSPTQSwQSJPTQSJODrQJPTEBUFPSJB DPSSJHJOEPB
2VBJTBTUSpTQSJODJQBJTDPODFQm{FTEFDJpODJB
2VBMBQSJODJQBMEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBDJpODJBBOUJHBFBDJpODJB DMgTTJDBPVNPEFSOB
3BDJPOBMJTUB DVKPNPEFMPEFPCKFUJWJEBEFnBNBUFNgUJ DBFNQJSJTUB RVFUPNBPNPEFMPEFPCKFUJWJEBEFEBNFEJDJOB HSFHBFEBIJTUwSJBOBUVSBMEPTnDVMP97**DPOTUSVUJWJTUB DVKP NPEFMPEFPCKFUJWJEBEFBEWnNEBJEFJBEFSB[kPDPNPDPOIF DJNFOUPBQSPYJNBUJWP
"DJpODJBBOUJHBFSBUFPSnUJDB PVTFKB BQFOBTDPOUFNQMBWB PTTFSFTOBUVSBJT TFNKBNBJTJNBHJOBSJOUFSWJSOFMFTPVTPCSF FMFTQPSNFJPTUnDOJDPTBDJpODJBDMgTTJDBnVNBDJpODJBRVFWJ TBOkPTwBPDPOIFDJNFOUPUFwSJDPNBTTPCSFUVEPhBQMJDBmkP QSgUJDBPVUnDOJDB
&YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBDPODFQmkPSBDJPOBMJTUBEFDJpODJB
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFUnDOJDBFUFDOPMPHJB
"DPODFQmkPSBDJPOBMJTUBBGJSNBRVFBDJpODJBnVNDPOIF DJNFOUPSBDJPOBMEFEVUJWPFEFNPOTUSBUJWPDPNPBNBUFNgUJDB FRVFTFVPCKFUPnBSFQSFTFOUBmkPJOUFMFDUVBMVOJWFSTBM OF DFTTgSJBFWFSEBEFJSBEBTDPJTBTSFQSFTFOUBEBTFDPSSFTQPOEF hQSwQSJBSFBMJEBEF QPSRVFFTUBnSBDJPOBMFJOUFMJHrWFMFNTJ NFTNB/FTTFTFOUJEP BTFYQFSJpODJBTDJFOUrGJDBTTkPSFBMJ[B EBTBQFOBTQBSBWFSJGJDBSFDPOGJSNBSBTEFNPOTUSBm{FTUFwSJ DBT FOkPQBSBQSPEV[JSPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPPCKFUP QPJTFTUFn DPOIFDJEPBQFOBTQFMPQFOTBNFOUP
5nDOJDBnVNDPOIFDJNFOUPFNQrSJDPRVF HSBmBThPCTFS WBmkP FMBCPSBVNDPOKVOUPEFSFDFJUBTFQSgUJDBTQBSBBHJSTP CSFBTDPJTBT5FDOPMPHJBnVNTBCFSUFwSJDPRVFTFBQMJDBOB QSgUJDB
&YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBDPODFQmkPFNQJSJTUBEFDJpODJB "DPODFQmkPFNQJSJTUBBGJSNBRVFBDJpODJBnVNBJOUFSQSF UBmkPEPTGBUPTCBTFBEBFNPCTFSWBm{FTFFYQFSJNFOUPTRVF QFSNJUFNFTUBCFMFDFSJOEVm{FTFRVF BPTFSFNDPNQMFUBEBT PGFSFDFNBEFGJOJmkPEPPCKFUP TVBTQSPQSJFEBEFTFTVBTMFJT EFGVODJPOBNFOUP"TFYQFSJpODJBT QPSUBOUP OkPUpNTJNQMFT NFOUFPQBQFMEFWFSJGJDBSFDPOGJSNBSDPODFJUPT NBTUpNBGVO mkPEFQSPEV[JMPT &YQMJRVFCSFWFNFOUFBDPODFQmkPDPOTUSVUJWJTUBEFDJpO DJB "DPODFQmkPDPOTUSVUJWJTUBDPOTJEFSBBDJpODJBVNBDPOT USVmkPEFNPEFMPTFYQMJDBUJWPTQBSBBSFBMJEBEF FOkPVNB SFQSFTFOUBmkPEBQSwQSJBSFBMJEBEF"EPUBEPSBDJPOBMJTNPP SJHPSNFUPEPMwHJDPFEPFNQJSJTNPBFYQFSJNFOUBmkPDPNP HVJBUSBOTGPSNBEPSBEPTBYJPNBT QPTUVMBEPT EFGJOJm{FTF EFNPOTUSBm{FT"MnNEJTTP BDSFTDFOUBVNUFSDFJSPQSPDFEJ NFOUPQFMPGBUPEFOkPWJTBShBQSFTFOUBmkPEBSFBMJEBEFFN TJNFTNB FTQFSBPGFSFDFSFTUSVUVSBTFNPEFMPTEFGVODJPOB NFOUPEBSFBMJEBEF FYQMJDBOEPPTGFOyNFOPTPCTFSWBEPT/kP FTQFSB QPSUBOUP BQSFTFOUBSVNBWFSEBEFBCTPMVUBFTJNVNB WFSEBEFBQSPYJNBEBRVFQPEFTFSDPSSJHJEB NPEJGJDBEB BCBO EPOBEBQPSPVUSBNBJTBEFRVBEBBPTGFOyNFOPT &YQMJRVFPRVFTJHOJGJDBNBTFYQSFTT{FT²IJQPUnUJDPEFEV UJWP³F²IJQPUnUJDPJOEVUJWP³ ²)JQPUnUJDPEFEVUJWP³ FSB B DBSBDUFSrTUJDB DJFOUrGJDB EB DPODFQmkPSBDJPOBMJTUBRVFEFGJOJBPPCKFUPFTVBTMFJTFEJTTP EFEV[JBQSPQSJFEBEFT FGFJUPTQPTUFSJPSFT QSFWJT{FT²)JQPUn UJDPJOEVUJWP³FSBBDBSBDUFSrTUJDBDJFOUrGJDBEBDPODFQmkPFN QJSJTUBRVFBQSFTFOUBWBTVQPTJm{FTTPCSFPPCKFUP SFBMJ[BWB PCTFSWBm{FTFFYQFSJNFOUPTFDIFHBWBhEFGJOJmkPEPTGBUPT hTTVBTMFJT TVBTQSPQSJFEBEFT TFVTFGFJUPTQPTUFSJPSFTFB QSFWJT{FT
05
&YQMJRVFBTJEFJBTEFQSPHSFTTPFFWPMVmkPDJFOUrGJDPTFB DPODFQmkPEFIJTUwSJBQSFTTVQPTUBQPSFMBT "TJEFJBTEFFWPMVmkPFQSPHSFTTPSFGFSFNTFhDSFOmBOB TVQFSJPSJEBEFEPQSFTFOUFFNSFMBmkPBPQBTTBEPFOBTVQFSJP SJEBEFEPGVUVSPFNSFMBmkPBPQSFTFOUF"TTJN FWPMVJSTJHOJGJDB UPSOBSTFTVQFSJPSFNFMIPSEPRVFTFFSBBOUFT1SPHSFEJSTJHOJ GJDBJSOVNSVNPDBEBWF[NFMIPSOBEJSFmkPEFVNBGJOBMJEBEF TVQFSJPS&TTBOPmkPFTUgDBMDBEBFNVNBDPODFQmkPIJTUwSJDB MJOFBS JTUPn DPOUrOVBFDVNVMBUJWB"DSFEJUBTF EFTTBGPSNB RVFOPEFDPSSFSEPUFNQPPRVFBDPOUFDFEFQPJTnPSFTVMUB EPNFMIPSBEPEPRVFBDPOUFDFVBOUFT TVQPOEPTF BTTJN VN QFSNBOFOUFFTUBEPEFBQFSGFJmPBNFOUPEFUPEPTPTTFSFTRVF KgFTUBSJBDPOUJEPOFMFT EFWFOEPBQFOBTEFTEPCSBSTFOPEF DPSSFSEBIJTUwSJB %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPTRVFJOEJRVFNBEFTDPOUJOVJEBEFEPT DPOIFDJNFOUPTDJFOUrGJDPT "EFTDPOUJOVJEBEFEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTDJFOUrGJDPTQPEFTFS FODPOUSBEBOBDPNQBSBmkPEBHFPNFUSJBDMgTTJDBDPNBHFP NFUSJBDPOUFNQPSiOFB RVFNPTUSBRVFTFUSBUBEFEFNPOT USBm{FTEJTUJOUBT CBTFBEBTFNQSJODrQJPT DPODFJUPT PCKFUPT EJGFSFOUFTUBNCnNOBGrTJDBBJEFJBEFOBUVSF[BQSFTTVQPTUB QPS"SJTUwUFMFT (BMJMFV/FXUPOF&JOTUFJOTkPEJGFSFOUFTFOUSF TJQPSCBTFBSFNTFFNQSJODrQJPT DPODFJUPT EFNPOTUSBm{FT FYQFSJNFOUBm{FTFUFDOPMPHJBTDPNQMFUBNFOUFEJGFSFOUFT%B NFTNBGPSNB BPDPNQBSBSNPTUPEBTBTDJpODJBTFODPOUSBSF NPTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFFMBT QPJTFNDBEBVNBEFMBTPRVFTF EFTFKBDPOIFDFSnEJGFSFOUFEFVNUFNQPQBSBPVUSP EFVNB nQPDBQBSBPVUSB 2VFTJHOJGJDBNBTFYQSFTT{FT²SVQUVSBFQJTUFNPMwHJDB³F ²PCTUgDVMPFQJTUFNPMwHJDP³ DSJBEBTQPS(BTUPO#BDIFMBSE QBSBTFSFGFSJShTNVEBOmBTDJFOUrGJDBT %FBDPSEPDPN#BDIFMBSE ²PCTUgDVMPFQJTUFNPMwHJDP³TkP BTMJNJUBm{FTFODPOUSBEBTQPSEFUFSNJOBEBTUFPSJBT NnUPEPT FUFDOPMPHJBTQBSBFYQMJDBSVNGFOyNFOP"TVQFSBmkPEFTTB MJNJUBmkPSFRVFSVNB²SVQUVSBFQJTUFNPMwHJDB³ JTUPn BOF DFTTJEBEFEFEJ[FS²OkP³hUFPSJBFYJTUFOUFFBPTNnUPEPTF UFDOPMPHJBTFYJTUFOUFT EFNPEPRVFTFKBQPTTrWFMBFMBCPSBmkP EFOPWBTUFPSJBT OPWPTNnUPEPTFUFDOPMPHJBT
| U NIDADE 7
|
A ciência
2VBJTPTUJQPTEFEFTDPOUJOVJEBEFDJFOUrGJDBBQSFTFOUBEPT QPS(SBOHFS
2VFKVTUJGJDBUJWBPGFSFDF,VIOQBSBBENJUJSNPT DPNBMHV NBTSFTUSJm{FT BJEFJBEFQSPHSFTTPDJFOUrGJDP
(SBOHFSQSPQ{FEPJTUJQPTEFEFTDPOUJOVJEBEFDJFOUrGJDB VNBFYUFSOBFPVUSBJOUFSOBcFYUFSOBRVBOEPIgVNIJBUPSB EJDBMFOUSFVNBTJUVBmkPDJFOUrGJDBDBwUJDB FNRVFPTDPOIFDJ NFOUPTFTUkPEJTQFSTPTFTkPJOWFSJGJDgWFJT FPTVSHJNFOUPEF VNBEJTDJQMJOBDJFOUrGJDBDVKPTDPODFJUPT NnUPEPTFUnDOJDBT DPOTFHVFN²QySPSEFNOPDBPT³&TTBEJTDJQMJOBPSEFOBEPSB SJHPSPTBFTJTUFNgUJDBOkPNVEBBDJpODJBBOUFSJPS NBTBQF OBTBSFPSHBOJ[BcJOUFSOBRVBOEP NBOUJEBVNBNFTNBWJTkP PCKFUJWBEFVNDBNQPEFGBUPT UFPSJBTEJGFSFOUFTTFTVDFEFN OPJOUFSJPSEFTTFDBNQP/FTTFDBTP OkPIgVNBSVQUVSBUPUBM QPJT EJ[(SBOHFS DPNPnNBOUJEBBNFTNBWJTkPPCKFUJWBEF VNDBNQPEFGBUPT BUFPSJBBOUFSJPSnJODPSQPSBEBDPNPVN DBTPQBSUJDVMBS hTWF[FTBUnEJNJOVUP EBOPWBUFPSJB NBTVOJ WFSTBM)gEFTDPOUJOVJEBEF NBTOkPIgEFTUSVJmkPEBUFPSJB BOUFSJPS
,VIOEJ[RVFOkPTFQPEFBDFJUBSBWFMIBJEFJBEPQSP HSFTTPOBRVBMTFTVQVOIBRVF DPNPQBTTBSEPUFNQPFP BD|NVMPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPT BDJpODJBTFBQSPYJNBWBDBEB WF[NBJTEBWFSEBEFNBTQPEFTFGBMBSFNQSPHSFTTPUPEB WF[RVFVNOPWPQBSBEJHNBPVVNBOPWBUFPSJBTFNPTUSBN DBQB[FTEFSFTPMWFSVNNBJPSO|NFSPEFQSPCMFNBTEPRVF PTBOUFSJPSFTFEFGB[FSNBJTFNFMIPSFTQSFWJT{FTEPRVF FMFT
0 RVF 5IPNBT ,VIO FOUFOEF QPS SFWPMVmkP DJFOUrGJDB 2VBOEPFMBBDPOUFDF 1PSRVFFMBnVNBSVQUVSBSBEJDBM DPNSFMBmkPhDJpODJBBOUFSJPS 1BSB5IPNBT,VIO VNBSFWPMVmkPDJFOUrGJDBTJHOJGJDBVNB SVQUVSBSBEJDBMDPNDPODFQm{FTDJFOUrGJDBTUSBEJDJPOBMNFO UFBDFJUBTBUSBWnTEBDSJBmkPEFOPWBTUFPSJBT&MBBDPOUFDF RVBOEPPDJFOUJTUBEFTDPCSFRVFPQBSBEJHNBEJTQPOrWFMOkP DPOTFHVFFYQMJDBSVNGFOyNFOPPVVNGBUPOPWP TFOEPOF DFTTgSJPQSPEV[JSVNPVUSPQBSBEJHNB BUnFOUkPJOFYJTUFOUF FDVKBOFDFTTJEBEFOkPFSBTFOUJEBQFMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFT&MB nVNBSVQUVSBSBEJDBMQPSRVFSFRVFSBDSJBmkPEFVNOPWP DBNQPDJFOUrGJDPRVFTVCTUJUVBPNPEFMPEFDJpODJBBOUFSJPS QPSVNBUFPSJBRVFQFSNJUBPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFJO|NFSPTGF OyNFOPT 0RVFnVNQBSBEJHNBDJFOUrGJDPFVNBDJpODJBOPSNBM 1BSBEJHNBDJFOUrGJDPnVNNPEFMPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPFTUB CFMFDJEPRVFFYQMJDBPTGFOyNFOPTDPNCBTFFNVNBUFPSJB ,VIOVTBBFYQSFTTkPDJpODJBOPSNBMQBSBSFGFSJSTFBPUSBCBMIP DJFOUrGJDPOPJOUFSJPSEFVNQBSBEJHNBFTUBCFMFDJEP
$PNP,BSM1PQQFSFYQMJDBBNVEBOmBEFVNBUFPSJBDJFO UrGJDB 1PQQFSBGJSNBRVFBTNVEBOmBTDJFOUrGJDBTTkPVNBDPO TFRVpODJBEBDPODFQmkPEBWFSEBEFDPNPDPFSpODJBUFwSJDB &QSPQ{FRVFVNBUFPSJBDJFOUrGJDBTFKBBWBMJBEBQFMBQPTTJ CJMJEBEFEFTFSGBMTBPVGBMTJGJDBEB"GBMTJGJDBmkPTFBQPJBOB BOUJHBJEFJBEBWFSEBEFDPNPDPSSFTQPOEpODJBFOUSFBTJEFJBT FBTDPJTBT0VTFKB 1PQQFSDPOTJEFSBRVFBBOUJHBOPmkPEF WFSEBEFOkPTFSWFQBSBDPOGJSNBSVNBUFPSJB±VNBUFPSJBTF NBOUnNDPOGJSNBEBHSBmBThTVBDPFSpODJBJOUFSOB± NBT TFSWFQBSBSFGVUBSVNBUFPSJB1PSFYFNQMPVNBUFPSJBDJFOUr GJDBRVFEJTTFSRVF²UPEPTPTDJTOFTTkPCSBODPT³OkPQPEFTFS WFSJGJDBEBPVDPOGJSNBEBQPSRVFOFOIVNTFSIVNBOPKBNBJT WJVPVWFSgUPEPTPTDJTOFTUPEBWJB CBTUBRVFBMHVnNWFKBVN |OJDPDJTOFOFHSPQBSBSFGVUBS PVGBMTJGJDBS FTTBUFPSJB2VBO UPNBJTBCFSUBFTTBUFPSJBFTUJWFSBGBUPTOPWPTRVFQPTTBN UPSOBSGBMTPTPTQSJODrQJPTFPTDPODFJUPTFNRVFTFCBTFBWB NFMIPSFMBTFSg 2VBJTBTDSrUJDBTGFJUBTB1PQQFSQPSPVUSPTGJMwTPGPTEB DJpODJB %J[FNRVFKBNBJTIPVWFVN|OJDPDBTPFNRVFVNGB UPOPWPHBSBOUJTTFBDPFSpODJBEFVNBUFPSJBBTNVEBOmBT UFwSJDBTQSPWPDBEBTQPSGBUPTOPWPTOkP²NFMIPSBSBN³PV ²BQSJNPSBSBN³VNBUFPSJBFYJTUFOUF NBTGJ[FSBNBCBOEP OgMBQPSVNBPVUSBnPWFSEBEFJSPFOkPPGBMTPRVFHVJBP DJFOUJTUB TFKBBWFSEBEFFOUFOEJEBDPNPDPSSFTQPOEpODJB FOUSFJEFJBFDPJTB TFKBFOUFOEJEBDPNPDPFSpODJBJOUFSOB EBTJEFJBT
0RVFnVNBDSJTFEFQBSBEJHNBDJFOUrGJDP &TTBDSJTFPDPSSFRVBOEPVNEFUFSNJOBEPNPEFMPEFDP OIFDJNFOUPOkPDPOTFHVFNBJTFYQMJDBSPTGFOyNFOPTOFNMF WBNBJTBPTSFTVMUBEPTFTQFSBEPTEJBOUFEFGBUPTOPWPT 1PSRVF BQFTBSEBTSVQUVSBTFEFTDPOUJOVJEBEFT DPOUJ OVBNPTBDSFEJUBOEPOPQSPHSFTTPEBTDJpODJBT 1PSEPJTNPUJWPTEPMBEPEPDJFOUJTUB QPSRVFPQSPHSFT TPnVNBWJWpODJBTVCKFUJWB JTUPn FMFTFOUFRVFTBCFNBJT FNFMIPSEPRVFBOUFT KgRVFPQBSBEJHNBBOUFSJPSOkPMIF QFSNJUJBDPOIFDFSDFSUPTPCKFUPTPVGFOyNFOPTEPMBEPEPT OkPDJFOUJTUBT QPSRVFPQSPHSFTTPnVNBDSFOmBJEFPMwHJDB JTUPn WJWFNPTTPCBJEFPMPHJBEPQSPHSFTTPFEBFWPMVmkP EP²OPWP³FEP²GBOUgTUJDP³"MnNEFWFSNPTPTSFTVMUBEPT UFDOPMwHJDPTEBTDJpODJBT EFTEFB"OUJHVJEBEFDPOIFDFS TFNQSFGPJDPOTJEFSBEPPNFJPNBJTQSFDJPTPFFGJDB[QBSB DPNCBUFSPNFEP BTVQFSTUJmkPFBTDSFOEJDFTF EPQPOUP EFWJTUBEPTSFTVMUBEPTQSgUJDPT TFOUJNPTRVFFTUBNPTFN NFMIPSFTDPOEJm{FTRVFPTBOUJHPTFQPSJTTPGBMBNPTFN FWPMVmkPFQSPHSFTTP
2VBJTPTDSJUnSJPTVTBEPTQPS"SJTUwUFMFTQBSBDMBTTJGJDBS BTDJpODJBT 0DSJUnSJPEBBVTpODJBPVQSFTFOmBEBBmkPIVNBOBOPT TFSFTJOWFTUJHBEPTPDSJUnSJPEBJNVUBCJMJEBEFPVQFSNBOpO DJBFEBNVUBCJMJEBEFPVNPWJNFOUPEPTTFSFTJOWFTUJHBEPTP DSJUnSJPEBNPEBMJEBEFQSgUJDB 2VBJTPTDSJUnSJPTVTBEPTBQBSUJSEPTnDVMP97**QBSBDMBT TJGJDBSBTDJpODJBT 0UJQPEFPCKFUPFTUVEBEPPUJQPEFNnUPEPFNQSFHBEPP UJQPEFSFTVMUBEPPCUJEP
#APqTULOß߯ßß=o_e j_e]odqi]j]o 1PSRVFBTJUVBmkPEBTDJpODJBTIVNBOBTnNVJUPFTQFDJBMOP DPOKVOUPEBTDJpODJBT &NQSJNFJSPMVHBSQPSRVFTFVPCKFUPnCBTUBOUFSFDFOUF PIPNFNDPNPPCKFUPDJFOUrGJDPnVNBJEFJBTVSHJEBBQFOBT OPTnDVMP9*9FNTFHVOEPMVHBS QPSRVFBTDJpODJBTIVNBOBT
1,
Manual do Professor
TVSHJSBNEFQPJTRVFBTDJpODJBTOBUVSBJTFNBUFNgUJDBTFTUB WBNDPOTUJUVrEBTF QBSBHBOIBSSFTQFJUBCJMJEBEFDJFOUrGJDB BT EJTDJQMJOBTDPOIFDJEBTDPNPDJpODJBTIVNBOBTQSPDVSBSBNFT UVEBSTFVPCKFUPFNQSFHBOEPDPODFJUPT NnUPEPTFUnDOJDBT QSPQPTUBTQFMBTDJpODJBTEBOBUVSF[BFNUFSDFJSPMVHBS QPSRVF UBNCnNQSPDVSBSBNUSBUBSPPCKFUPIVNBOPVTBOEPPTNPEF MPTIJQPUnUJDPJOEVUJWPTFFYQFSJNFOUBJTEFFTUJMPFNQJSJTUB F CVTDBWBNMFJTDBVTBJTOFDFTTgSJBTFVOJWFSTBJTQBSBPTGFOy NFOPTIVNBOPT 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTPCKFm{FTRVFGPSBNGFJUBThTDJpODJBT IVNBOBT 1FMPGBUPEFRVFBDJpODJBMJEBDPNGBUPTPCTFSWgWFJT QBT TrWFJTEFFYQFSJNFOUBmkPFNDPOEJm{FTFTQFDJBJT DPNPTFSJB QPTTrWFMPCTFSWBSFFYQFSJNFOUBS QPSFYFNQMP BDPOTDJpODJB IVNBOB VNBTPDJFEBEFPVVNBnQPDBQBTTBEB 1FMPGBUPEF RVFBDJpODJBCVTDBBTMFJTPCKFUJWBTHFSBJT VOJWFSTBJTFOFDFT TgSJBTEPTGFOyNFOPT DPNPTFSJBQPTTrWFMFTUBCFMFDFSFTTBT NFTNBTMFJTPCKFUJWBTQBSBPRVFnFTTFODJBMNFOUFTVCKFUJWP DPNPPQTJRVJTNPIVNBOP "MnNEJTTP BDJpODJBPQFSBQPS BOgMJTF EFDPNQPTJmkPEFVNGBUPDPNQMFYP FTrOUFTF SFDPN QPTJmkPEFVNGBUPDPNQMFYP $PNPBOBMJTBSFTJOUFUJ[BSVNB TPDJFEBEF QPSFYFNQMP "DJpODJBMJEBDPNGBUPTSFHJEPTQFMB OFDFTTJEBEFDBVTBMPVQFMPQSJODrQJPEPEFUFSNJOJTNPVOJWFS TBM$PNPEBSVNBFYQMJDBmkPDJFOUrGJDB QPJT hRVJMPRVF QPS FTTpODJB nDPOUJOHFOUF DPNPBWPOUBEFIVNBOB 1PSGJN B DJpODJBMJEBDPNGBUPTPCKFUJWPT JTUPn DPNPTGFOyNFOPTQV SJGJDBEPTEFUPEBTVCKFUJWJEBEF PQJOJ{FT JNQSFTT{FT TFOUJ NFOUPT $PNPUSBOTGPSNBSPTFSIVNBOP RVFnQFSNFBEPQFMB TVCKFUJWJEBEF FNPCKFUJWJEBEFTFNEFTUSVJSFTTBTVBQSJODJQBM DBSBDUFSrTUJDB "OUFTEBDPOTUJUVJmkPEBTDJpODJBTIVNBOBT RVBJTGPSBN PTUSpTQSJODJQBJTQFSrPEPTEFFTUVEPEPIVNBOP 3FTVNB CSFWFNFOUFDBEBVNEFMFT 1FSrPEPEPIVNBOJTNPJOJDJBEPDPNPBOUSPQPDFOUSJTNP SFOBTDFOUJTUB PIPNFNDPNPDFOUSPEP6OJWFSTP
OkPTFQBSB PIPNFNEBOBUVSF[B NBTPDPOTJEFSBVNTFSOBUVSBMEJGFSFOUF EPTEFNBJT1SPTTFHVJOEPOPTTnDVMPT97*F97**DPNPFTUV EPEPIPNFNDPNPBHFOUFNPSBM QPMrUJDPFUnDOJDPBSUrTUJDP DIFHPVBUnPTnDVMP97*** RVBOEPTVSHFBJEFJBEFDJWJMJ[BmkP P IPNFNDPNPBSUrGJDFEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPJOTUJUVDJPOBM 1FSrP EPEPQPTJUJWJTNPJOJDJBTFOPTnDVMP9*9DPN"VHVTUP$PNUF FTFFTUFOEFQFMPTnDVMP99&OGBUJ[BPIPNFNDPNPVNTFS TPDJBMFQSPQ{FPFTUVEPDJFOUrGJDPEBTPDJFEBEFDPNPGBUP BGJS NBOEPRVFPGBUPTPDJBMEFWFTFSUSBUBEPDPNPVNBDPJTBhRVBM TkPBQMJDBEPTPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTEFBOgMJTFFTrOUFTFDSJBEPT QFMBTDJpODJBTOBUVSBJT1FSrPEPEPIJTUPSJDJTNPEFTFOWPMWJEP OPGJOBMEPTnDVMP9*9FJOrDJPEPTnDVMP99 JOTJTUFOBEJGFSFOmB QSPGVOEBFOUSFIPNFNFOBUVSF[BFFOUSFDJpODJBTOBUVSBJTF IVNBOBT%FGFOEFRVFPTGBUPTIVNBOPTTkPIJTUwSJDPT EPUB EPTEFWBMPSFEFTFOUJEP EFTJHOJGJDBmkPFGJOBMJEBEF FEFWFN TFSFTUVEBEPTDPNFTTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTRVFPTEJTUJOHVFNEPT GBUPTOBUVSBJT $PNPPIJTUPSJDJTNPQFOTBWBPTGBUPTIVNBOPT 2VBJTPT QSPCMFNBTEPIJTUPSJDJTNPRVFOkPQVEFSBNTFSSFTPMWJEPT QPSTFVTTFHVJEPSFT 1BSBPIJTUPSJDJTNP PTGBUPTIVNBOPTTVSHFNOPUFNQP FTFUSBOTGPSNBNOPUFNQP EFWFOEPTFSDPNQSFFOEJEPT TJ NVMUBOFBNFOUF DPNPQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFTIJTUwSJDBTPV²WJT{FT
1-
EFNVOEP³FTQFDrGJDBTBVUyOPNBTFDPNPFUBQBTPVGBTFTEP EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPHFSBMEBIVNBOJEBEF QSPHSFTTP 1PSJTTP OkPQPEFNFOkPEFWFNTFSFTUVEBEPTQFMPNnUPEPEBPCTFS WBmkPFYQFSJNFOUBmkPEBTDJpODJBTOBUVSBJT NBTEFWFNDSJBS PNnUPEPEBFYQMJDBmkPFDPNQSFFOTkPEPTFOUJEPEPTGBUPT IVNBOPT FODPOUSBOEPBDBVTBMJEBEFIJTUwSJDBRVFPTHPWFS OB*TTPSFTVMUPVFNEPJTQSPCMFNBTPSFMBUJWJTNP JTUPn BT MFJTDJFOUrGJDBTTwTkPWgMJEBTQBSBVNBEFUFSNJOBEBnQPDBF DVMUVSB OkPQPEFOEPTFSVOJWFSTBMJ[BEBTFBTVCPSEJOBmkPB VNBGJMPTPGJBEBIJTUwSJB JTUPn PTJOEJWrEVPTIVNBOPTFBT JOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJPDVMUVSBJTTwTkPDPNQSFFOTrWFJTTFTFVFTUV EPDJFOUrGJDPTVCPSEJOBSTFBVNBUFPSJBHFSBMEBIJTUwSJBRVF DPOTJEFSFDBEBGPSNBmkPTPDJPDVMUVSBM TFKBDPNP²WJTkPEF NVOEP³QBSUJDVMBS TFKBDPNPFUBQBEFVNQSPDFTTPIJTUwSJDP VOJWFSTBM 2VBMBQSPQPTUBEF.BY8FCFSQBSBTVQFSBSPTQSPCMFNBT EPIJTUPSJDJTNP .BY8FCFSQSPQyTRVFBTDJpODJBTIVNBOBTUSBCBMIBTTFN T FVTPCKFUPTOkPDPNPGBUPTFNQrSJDPT NBTDPNPUJQPTJEFBJT PVTFKB BQBSUJSEFFMBCPSBm{FTDPODFJUVBJTRVFQFSNJUFNDPN QSFFOEFSFJOUFSQSFUBSGBUPTQBSUJDVMBSFTPCTFSWgWFJT 2VBMBQSJODJQBMDPOUSJCVJmkPEBGFOPNFOPMPHJBQBSBBT DJpODJBTIVNBOBT "QBSUJSEBOPmkPEFFTTpODJBPVTJHOJGJDBmkPDPNPVNDPO DFJUPRVFQFSNJUFEJGFSFODJBSJOUFSOBNFOUFVNBSFBMJEBEFEF PVUSBT FODPOUSBOEPTFVTFOUJEP TVBGPSNB TVBTQSPQSJFEB EFT TVBTPSJHFOT BGFOPNFOPMPHJBQFSNJUJVRVFGPTTFGFJUBB EJGFSFOmBFOUSF²OBUVSF[B³F²IPNFN³ UBNCnNEJGFSFODJBEP JOUFSOBNFOUFFNFTTpODJBTEJWFSTBT PQTrRVJDP PTPDJBM PIJT UwSJDP PDVMUVSBM
PRVFHBSBOUJVhTDJpODJBTIVNBOBTBEFMJNJ UBmkPFBEFGJOJmkPEFTFVTPCKFUPT 2VBMBQSJODJQBMDPOUSJCVJmkPEPNBSYJTNPQBSBBTDJpODJBT IVNBOBT 0NBSYJTNPQFSNJUJVDPNQSFFOEFSRVFPTGBUPTIVNBOPT TkPJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJTFIJTUwSJDBTQSPEV[JEBTOkPQFMPFTQr SJUPFQFMBWPOUBEFMJWSFEPTJOEJWrEVPT NBTQFMBTDPOEJm{FT PCKFUJWBTOBTRVBJTBBmkPFPQFOTBNFOUPIVNBOPTEFWFN SFBMJ[BSTF%FTTBGPSNB BTDJpODJBTIVNBOBTQVEFSBNDPN QSFFOEFSRVFBTNVEBOmBTIJTUwSJDBTOkPSFTVMUBNEFBm{FT T|CJUBTFFTQFUBDVMBSFTEFBMHVOTJOEJWrEVPTPVHSVQPTEFJOEJ WrEVPT NBTEFMFOUPTQSPDFTTPTTPDJBJT FDPOyNJDPTFQPMrUJDPT CBTFBEPTOBGPSNBBTTVNJEBQFMBQSPQSJFEBEFEPTNFJPTEF QSPEVmkPFQFMBTSFMBm{FTEFUSBCBMIPRVFHBSBOUFNBJOUFSQSF UBmkPEPTGBUPTIVNBOPTFPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFTVBTMFJT 2VBMBQSJODJQBMDPOUSJCVJmkPEPFTUSVUVSBMJTNPQBSBBT DJpODJBTIVNBOBT %FBDPSEPDPNBDPODFQmkPFTUSVUVSBMJTUB PUPEPOkPnB TPNBEBTQBSUFTOFNVNDPOKVOUPEFSFMBm{FTDBVTBJTFOUSF FMFNFOUPTJTPMgWFJT NBTVNQSJODrQJPPSEFOBEPS EJGFSFODJB EPSFUSBOTGPSNBEPS#BTFBOEPTFQPSUBOUPOBJEFJBEFRVFDB EBFTUSVUVSBnVNBUPUBMJEBEFPSHBOJ[BEBQPSQSJODrQJPTJOUFS OPT PFTUSVUVSBMJTNPQFSNJUJV BTTJN RVFBTDJpODJBTIVNBOBT DSJBTTFNVNBNFUPEPMPHJBQSwQSJBEPFTUVEPEFTFVTPCKFUPT MJWSBOEPBTEBTFYQMJDBm{FTNFDiOJDBTEFDBVTBFFGFJUPTFN RVFQPSJTTPUJWFTTFNEFBCBOEPOBSBJEFJBEFMFJDJFOUrGJDB
| U NIDADE 7
|
A ciência
#APqTULOß߯ßßKe`a]h_eajpbe_ka]n]vk ejopnqiajp]h
EPTPCSFBTDPJTBTFPTIPNFOT EBOEPMIFPMVHBSRVFNVJUPT DPTUVNBNEBShTSFMJHJ{FT JTUPn VNDPOKVOUPEPVUSJOgSJPEF WFSEBEFTJODPOUFTUgWFJT JOUFNQPSBJTFBCTPMVUBT
2VBJTPTGVOEBNFOUPTEBDJpODJBDPOUFNQPSiOFB %FTTFT FTDPMIBUSpTFFYQMJRVFPT
0RVFnBJEFJBEFOFVUSBMJEBEFDJFOUrGJDB
1SPGFTTPS B /BSFTQPTUBEFTUBRVFTUkP FTUBNPTDJUBOEP UPEPTPTGVOEBNFOUPTEBDJpODJBDPOUFNQPSiOFBBQSFTFOUB EPTOPDBQrUVMP$BCFBPBMVOPFTDPMIFSUSpTEFTTFTGVOEBNFO UPTFFYQMJDgMPT"DJpODJBDPOUFNQPSiOFBFTUgGVOEBNFOUBEB OBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFTVKFJUPFPCKFUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPOPVTP EFVNBNFUPEPMPHJBOBBQMJDBmkPEFPQFSBm{FTEFBOgMJTFF TrOUFTFOBJEFJBEFMFJVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJBOPVTPEFJOTUSV NFOUPTUFDOPMwHJDPTOBDSJBmkPEFVNBMJOHVBHFNFTQFDrGJDB FQSwQSJB
"JEFJBEFOFVUSBMJEBEFDJFOUrGJDBDBSBDUFSJ[BTFQFMBTFQBSB mkPFQFMBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPFPPCKFUP FQPSSFUJSBSEPTPCKFUPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPPTFMFNFOUPTTVCKFUJ WPTDPNPPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTDJFOUrGJDPTEFPCTFSWBmkP FYQFSJ NFOUBmkPFJOUFSQSFUBmkPRVFQSPDVSBNBMDBOmBSPPCKFUPSFBMPV PPCKFUPDPOTUSVrEPDPNPNPEFMPBQSPYJNBEPEPSFBMQFMPGBUP EFRVFPTSFTVMUBEPTPCUJEPTQPSVNBDJpODJBOkPEFQFOEFNEB CPBPVNgWPOUBEFEPDJFOUJTUBOFNEFTVBTQBJY{FT NBTEJ[FN PRVFBTDPJTBTTkPFNTJNFTNBT
0RVFnPJEFBMEBDJpODJBDPNPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFTJOUFSFTTB EP
1PSRVFBJNBHFNEBOFVUSBMJEBEFDJFOUrGJDBnJMVTwSJB
5BMJEFBMBGJSNBRVFPWBMPSEFVNBDJpODJBFODPOUSBTFOB RVBMJEBEF OPSJHPSFOBFYBUJEkP OBDPFSpODJBFOBWFSEBEFEF VNBUFPSJB JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFTVBBQMJDBmkPQSgUJDB PV TFKB PVTPEBDJpODJBnDPOTFRVpODJBFOkPDBVTBEPDPOIFDJ NFOUPDJFOUrGJDP 0RVFnBDPODFQmkPVUJMJUBSJTUBEBDJpODJB "PDPOUSgSJPEPJEFBMEBDJpODJBDPNPDPOIFDJNFOUPEF TJOUFSFTTBEP PVUJMJUBSJTNPBGJSNBRVFPWBMPSEFVNBDJpODJB FODPOUSBTFOBRVBOUJEBEFEFBQMJDBm{FTQSgUJDBTRVFQPTTB QFSNJUJS0TDPOIFDJNFOUPTDJFOUrGJDPTTkPQSPDVSBEPTQBSBSF TPMWFSQSPCMFNBTQSgUJDPT FFTUFTEFUFSNJOBNOkPTwPBQBSF DJNFOUPEFVNBDJpODJBNBTUBNCnNTVBTUSBOTGPSNBm{FTOP EFDPSSFSEPUFNQP 1PSRVFQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFBDPODFQmkPEPDPOIFDJNFO UPEFTJOUFSFTTBEPFBEPVUJMJUBSJTNPTkPWFSEBEFJSBTNBT QBSDJBJT "DPODFQmkPEBDJpODJBDPNPJEFBMEPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFTJO UFSFTTBEPnWFSEBEFJSBNBTQBSDJBM4FVNBUFPSJBDJFOUrGJDBOkP GPSDBQB[EFTVTDJUBSBQMJDBm{FT TFOkPGPSDBQB[EFQFSNJUJSP TVSHJNFOUPEFPCKFUPTUnDOJDPTFUFDOPMwHJDPT QPSFYFNQMP TFSFNPTPCSJHBEPTBEJ[FSRVFBUnDOJDBFBUFDOPMPHJBTkPDF HBT JODFSUBT BSSJTDBEBTFQFSJHPTBT QPSRVFTkPQSgUJDBTTFN CBTFTUFwSJDBTTFHVSBT1PSPVUSPMBEP BDPODFQmkPEBDJpODJB DPNPVUJMJUBSJTNPUBNCnNnWFSEBEFJSBNBTQBSDJBM4FVNB UFPSJBDJFOUrGJDBGPTTFFMBCPSBEBBQFOBTQPSTVBTGJOBMJEBEFT QSgUJDBTJNFEJBUBT JO|NFSBTQFTRVJTBTKBNBJTUFSJBNTJEP GFJUBTFJO|NFSPTGFOyNFOPTKBNBJTUFSJBNTJEPDPOIFDJEPT QPJT DPNGSFRVpODJB PTDPOIFDJNFOUPTUFwSJDPTFTUkPNBJT BWBOmBEPTEPRVFBTDBQBDJEBEFTUnDOJDBTEFVNBnQPDBF FN HFSBM TVBBQMJDBmkPTwnQFSDFCJEBFTwnQPTTrWFMNVJUPUFNQP EFQPJTEFIBWFSTJEPFMBCPSBEB 0RVFnPDJFOUJGJDJTNP &YQMJRVFPRVFTkPBJEFPMPHJBEB DJpODJBFBNJUPMPHJBEBDJpODJB $JFOUJGJDJTNPnBDSFOmBJOGVOEBEBEFRVFBDJpODJBQPEFF EFWFDPOIFDFSUVEP RVF EFGBUP DPOIFDFUVEPFnBFYQMJDBmkP DBVTBMEBTMFJTEBSFBMJEBEFUBMDPNPFTUBnFNTJNFTNB&TTF TFOTPDPNVNDJFOUJGJDJTUBUFNVNBSFEVOEiODJBJEFPMwHJDB B JEFPMPHJBEBDJpODJB QPSBDSFEJUBSRVFVNEJBPTDPOIFDJNFO UPTDJFOUrGJDPTFYQMJDBSkPUPUBMNFOUFBSFBMJEBEFFQFSNJUJSkP NBOJQVMgMBUFDOJDBNFOUF TFNMJNJUFTQBSBBBmkPIVNBOB F VNBPVUSBSFEVOEiODJB RVFnNrUJDB NJUPMPHJBEBDJpODJB
QPSBDSFEJUBSOBDJpODJBDPNPTFGPTTFNBHJBFQPEFSJPJMJNJUB
1PSRVF RVBOEPVNDJFOUJTUBFTDPMIFVNBDFSUBEFGJOJmkP EFTFVPCKFUP EFDJEFVTBSVNEFUFSNJOBEPNnUPEPFFTQFSB PCUFSDFSUPTSFTVMUBEPT TVBBUJWJEBEFOkPnOFVUSBOFNJNQBS DJBM NBTGFJUBQPSFTDPMIBTQSFDJTBT $PNPTFSFBMJ[BBQFTRVJTBDJFOUrGJDBDPOUFNQPSiOFB "QFTRVJTBDJFOUrGJDBDPOUFNQPSiOFBnGFJUBDPMFUJWBNFOUF FNFRVJQFT OPTHSBOEFTMBCPSBUwSJPTVOJWFSTJUgSJPT OPTJOTUJ UVUPTEFQFTRVJTBFOBTHSBOEFTFNQSFTBTUSBOTOBDJPOBJTRVF QBSUJDJQBNEFVNTJTUFNBDPOIFDJEPDPNPDPNQMFYPJOEVTUSJBM NJMJUBS&TTBTQFTRVJTBTFYJHFNBMUPTJOWFTUJNFOUPTFDPOyNJ DPTFTkPGJOBODJBEBTQFMP&TUBEP QFMBTFNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTPV QPSBNCPT 0RVFnBSB[kPJOTUSVNFOUBMPVBSB[kPJMVNJOJTUBBQSFTFO UBEBQFMB&TDPMBEF'SBOLGVSU 2VBMBSFMBmkPFOUSFFTTB SB[kPFBJEFJBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPDJFOUrGJDPDPNPQPEFSQBSB BUPSNFOUBSBOBUVSF[B "SB[kPJOTUSVNFOUBMOBTDFRVBOEPPTVKFJUPEPDPOIFDJ NFOUPUPNBBEFDJTkPEFRVFDPOIFDFSnEPNJOBSFDPOUSPMBSB OBUVSF[BFPTTFSFTIVNBOPT#BTFBEPOFTTBOPmkP PDPOIF DJNFOUPDJFOUrGJDPQBTTBBBUPSNFOUBSBOBUVSF[B DSJBOEPBSUJGJ DJBMNFOUFOPTMBCPSBUwSJPTBTDPOEJm{FTQBSBGB[pMBSFBHJSBPT FYQFSJNFOUPT JOWFTUJHBOEPBTGPSNBT DBVTBTFFGFJUPTRVF OkPQPEFSJBNTFSDPOIFDJEPTBQFOBTDPNBBUJWJEBEFFTQPOUi OFBEBOBUVSF[B EFNPEPRVFTFQFSNJUBDPOIFDFSTFVTTFHSF EPTQBSBEPNJOgMBFUSBOTGPSNgMB%FTTBNBOFJSB BDJpODJB WBJEFJYBOEPEFTFSVNBGPSNBEFBDFTTPBPTDPOIFDJNFOUPT WFSEBEFJSPTQBSBUPSOBSTFVNJOTUSVNFOUPEFEPNJOBmkP QP EFSFFYQMPSBmkP 2VFGBUPTFTJUVBm{FTSFMBUJWPThTDJpODJBTTFUPSOBNDPN QSFFOTrWFJTHSBmBThJEFJBEFSB[kPJOTUSVNFOUBM "USBOTGPSNBmkPEFVNBDJpODJBFNJEFPMPHJBFNJUPTPDJBM JTUPn FNTFOTPDPNVNDJFOUJGJDJTUBPGBUPEFRVFBJEFPMPHJB EBDJpODJBOkPTFSFEV[hUSBOTGPSNBmkPEFVNBUFPSJBDJFOUrGJDB FNJEFPMPHJB NBTFODPOUSBTFOBQSwQSJBDJpODJBRVBOEPFTUB nDPODFCJEBDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEFEPNJOBmkP DPOUSPMFFQPEFS TPCSFBOBUVSF[BFBTPDJFEBEFPGBUPEFRVFBTJEFJBTEFQSP HSFTTPUnDOJDPFOFVUSBMJEBEFDJFOUrGJDBQFSUFODFNBPDBNQPEB JEFPMPHJBDJFOUJGJDJTUB 2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEBUFDOPMPHJBQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUP DJFOUrGJDP "QSJNFJSBDPOTFRVpODJBTFSFGFSFBPDPOIFDJNFOUPDJFOUr GJDPRVFnDPODFCJEPDPNPMwHJDBEFJOWFOmkPFDPNPMwHJDBEB
1.
Manual do Professor
DPOTUSVmkP HSBmBThQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFTUVEBSPTGFOyNFOPTTFN EFQFOEFSBQFOBTEPTSFDVSTPTEFOPTTBQFSDFQmkPFEFOPTTBJO UFMJHpODJB"TFHVOEBDPOTFRVpODJBEJ[SFTQFJUPBPFTUBUVUPEPT PCKFUPTUnDOJDPTRVFTkPDSJBEPTQFMBDJpODJBDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPT EFBVYrMJPBPUSBCBMIPIVNBOP NgRVJOBTQBSBEPNJOBSBOBUVSF [BFBTPDJFEBEF JOTUSVNFOUPTEFQSFDJTkPQBSBPDPOIFDJNFOUP DJFOUrGJDPF TPCSFUVEP FNTVBGPSNBDPOUFNQPSiOFB DPNPBV UyNBUPT 0RVFnVNPCKFUPUFDOPMwHJDP 0TPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPTTkPDPOIFDJNFOUPDJFOUrGJDPPCKFUJ WBEP JTUPn EFQPTJUBEPFDPODSFUJ[BEPOVNPCKFUPTkPPCKFUPT RVFQPTTVFNFNTJNFTNPTPQSJODrQJPEFTVBSFHVMBmkP NB OVUFOmkPFUSBOTGPSNBmkPDPNPDPOTFRVpODJB OkPTkPQSP QSJBNFOUFVNPCKFUPTJOHVMBSPVJOEJWJEVBM NBTVNTJTUFNB EFPCKFUPTJOUFSMJHBEPTQPSDPNBOEPTSFDrQSPDPTTkPTJTUFNBT RVF VNBWF[QSPHSBNBEPT SFBMJ[BNPQFSBm{FTUFwSJDBTDPN QMFYBTRVFNPEJGJDBNPDPOUF|EPEPTQSwQSJPTDPOIFDJNFOUPT DJFOUrGJDPT JTUPn PTPCKFUPTUnDOJDPUFDOPMwHJDPTGB[FNQBSUF EPUSBCBMIPUFwSJDP 1PSRVFMVUBNPTQBSBQPTTVJSPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPTFOkP QBSBUFSPDPOUSPMFEBTJOWFTUJHBm{FTDJFOUrGJDBT 1PSRVFOkPQFSDFCFNPTPQPEFSJPFDPOyNJDPEBTDJpODJBT DVKBTQFTRVJTBTDJFOUrGJDBTTkPGJOBODJBEBTQPSFNQSFTBTFHP WFSOPT EFNBOEBOEPHSBOEFTTPNBTEFSFDVSTPTRVFSFUPSOBN OBGPSNBEFMVDSPFQPEFSQBSBPTBHFOUFTGJOBODJBEPSFT 2VBJTPTQSPCMFNBTnUJDPT FDPOyNJDPTFQPMrUJDPTRVFTVS HJSBNDPNPVTPEBTDJpODJBT "JOGMVpODJBRVFBDJpODJBFYFSDFOPTNPEPTEFPSHBOJ[BSP USBCBMIPJOEVTUSJBMFPTTFSWJmPT EFTUSVJOEPQSPGJTT{FTFDSJBO EPPDVQBm{FTOPWBT NPEJGJDBOEPFTUJMPTEFWJEB5BNCnNRVF BDJpODJBQBTTPVBGB[FSQBSUFEPQPEFSQPMrUJDPQPSNFJPEBEFT UJOBmkPEFWFSCBTQ|CMJDBTQBSBPGJOBODJBNFOUPEFQFTRVJTBT DJWJTFNJMJUBSFT0VUSPQSPCMFNBnUJDPnRVFPTQFTRVJTBEPSFT NVJUBTWF[FTOFNTFRVFSJNBHJOBNFNRVFTVBUFPSJBUFSgBQMJ DBmkPQSgUJDB QPEFOEPTFVVTPFTUBSGPSBEFTFVDPOUSPMFF TVKFJUPBPTJOUFSFTTFTEPTGJOBODJBEPSFT
IVNBOBT DFSUPTTFOUJNFOUPT DPNQPSUBNFOUPT JEFJBTFWBMP SFTTFSJBNOBUVSBJTQBSBUPEPTPTIVNBOPT %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPTEFBCTVSEPTEFDPSSFOUFTEBOBUVSBMJ [BmkPEPTDPNQPSUBNFOUPT JEFJBTFWBMPSFTEPTTFSFTIV NBOPT &YQSFTT{FTDPNP²DIPSBSnQSwQSJPEBOBUVSF[BIVNBOB³ ²nEFTOBUVSBEBBNVMIFSRVFOkPDSJBPTGJMIPT³ ²BNVMIFSnVN TFSGSgHJMFTFOTrWFM³ ²PTOFHSPTTkPJOEPMFOUFT QSFHVJmPTPTF NBMBOESPT³ FUD 1PSRVFnJOTVTUFOUgWFMBJEFJBEFVNBOBUVSF[BIVNBOB VOJWFSTBMFJOUFNQPSBM 1PSRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTWBSJBNFNDPOTFRVpODJBEBT DPOEJm{FTTPDJBJT FDPOyNJDBT QPMrUJDBT IJTUwSJDBTFNRVFWJ WFN1PSRVFTPNPTTFSFTDVMUVSBJTPVIJTUwSJDPT %pFYFNQMPTEPTWgSJPTTFOUJEPTDPNRVFVTBNPTBQBMBWSB DVMUVSBFNOPTTPDPUJEJBOP 0TFOUJEPEFUFSPVOkPUFSDFSUPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTEFRVB MJGJDBmkPEFQSFTUrHJPFSFTQFJUPEFRVBMJEBEFEFVNBDPMFUJ WJEBEFEFDVMUVSBEFNBTTBFDVMUVSBEFFMJUFEFJEFOUJEBEF EFVNQPWP &OVNFSFPTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTEBQBMBWSBOBUVSF[B 1SJODrQJPEFWJEBRVFBOJNBFNPWJNFOUBPTTFSFTFTTpODJB QSwQSJBEFVNTFSPSHBOJ[BmkPVOJWFSTBMFOFDFTTgSJBEPTTFSFT TFHVOEPVNBPSEFNSFHJEBQPSMFJTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJBT UVEPPRVFFYJTUFOP6OJWFSTPTFNBJOUFSWFOmkPEBWPOUBEFF EBBmkPIVNBOBTDPOKVOUPEFUVEPRVBOUPFYJTUFFnQFSDFCJEP QFMPTIVNBOPTDPNPPNFJPBNCJFOUFOPRVBMWJWFN &OVNFSFPTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTEBQBMBWSBDVMUVSBOB"O UJHVJEBEF $VJEBEPEPIPNFNDPNBOBUVSF[BDVJEBEPEPTIPNFOT DPNPTEFVTFTDVJEBEPDPNBBMNBFPDPSQPEBTDSJBOmBT 1PSRVF OB"OUJHVJEBEF DVMUVSBFOBUVSF[BOkPTFPQV OIBN 1PSRVF OFTTFQFSrPEP PTIVNBOPTTkPDPOTJEFSBEPTTF SFTOBUVSBJTFBDVMUVSBnVNBTFHVOEBOBUVSF[BRVFBFEVDBmkP FPTDPTUVNFTBDSFTDFOUBNhOBUVSF[BEFDBEBVN
5NIDADEßßßßKiqj`k`]lnpe_] #APqTULOß߯ßß=_qhpqn] 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBMHVNBDPJTBnOBUVSBMPVQPSOBUV SF[B 4JHOJGJDBRVFFTTBDPJTBFYJTUFOFDFTTgSJBFVOJWFSTBMNFOUF QPSRVFFMBnFGFJUPEFVNBDBVTBOFDFTTgSJBFVOJWFSTBM&TTB DBVTBnBOBUVSF[B RVFnTFNQSFBNFTNBFNUPEBQBSUF4JH OJGJDB QPSUBOUP RVFQPSTFSOBUVSBMFTTBDPJTBOkPEFQFOEFEB BmkPFJOUFOmkPIVNBOBT FTJNEBTPQFSBm{FTOFDFTTgSJBTF VOJWFSTBJTSFBMJ[BEBTQFMBOBUVSF[B 0RVFTFRVFSEJ[FSRVBOEPTFGBMBFNOBUVSF[BIVNBOB 2VF EBNFTNBNBOFJSBRVFNVJUBTDPJTBTFYJTUFNQPS OBUVSF[B UBNCnNIgVNBOBUVSF[BIVNBOBOFDFTTgSJBFVOJ WFSTBM PVTFKB JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBEFDJTkPPVJOUFSWFOmkP
1/
0RVFTFFOUFOEFQPSDVMUVSBBQBSUJSEPTnDVMP97*** "QBSUJSEPTnDVMP97***DVMUVSBBERVJSJVPTFOUJEPEFDJWJMJ[B mkP BNBOJGFTUBmkPIVNBOBOBTGPSNBTEFPSHBOJ[BmkPEBWJEB TPDJBMFQPMrUJDB"QBSUJSEBr DVMUVSBEFJYBEFTFSVNBTFHVOEB OBUVSF[BFUPSOBTFQSPEVUPEBBmkPIVNBOB RVFBHFFTDP MIFOEPMJWSFNFOUFTFVTBUPT EBOEPBFMFTTFOUJEP GJOBMJEBEF FWBMPS1BTTPVUBNCnNBTFSFOUFOEJEBDPNPBSFMBmkPRVFPT TFSFTIVNBOPTTPDJBMNFOUFPSHBOJ[BEPTFTUBCFMFDFNDPNP UFNQPFDPNPFTQBmP DPNPTPVUSPTTFSFTFDPNBOBUVSF[B $VMUVSBUPSOBTF BTTJN TJOyOJNPEFIJTUwSJB 1PSRVFBDVMUVSBUFOEFBTFSQFOTBEBDPNPDJWJMJ[BmkPB QBSUJSEPTnDVMP97*** 1PSRVFPTQFOTBEPSFTKVMHBWBNRVFPTSFTVMUBEPTEBGPS NBmkPFEVDBmkPTFNBOJGFTUBNDPNNBJPSDMBSF[BFOJUJEF[OBT GPSNBTEFPSHBOJ[BmkPEBWJEBTPDJBMFQPMrUJDBPVOBWJEBDJWJM "QBMBWSBDJWJMWFNEPMBUJNDJWFT ²DJEBEkP³
EFPOEFWFNDJ WJUBT BDJEBEF&TUBEP EPOEFDJWJMJ[BmkP
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFTTFODJBMRVFPTQFOTBEPSFTBQPOUBNFO USFOBUVSF[BFDVMUVSB "OBUVSF[BPQFSBQPSDBVTBMJEBEFOFDFTTgSJBPVEFBDPSEP DPNMFJTOFDFTTgSJBTEFDBVTBFFGFJUP NBTPTFSIVNBOPnEP UBEPEFMJCFSEBEFFSB[kP BHJOEPQPSFTDPMIB EFBDPSEPDPN WBMPSFTFGJOTFTUBCFMFDJEPTQPSFMFQSwQSJP DVMUVSB &NRVFNPNFOUPBDVMUVSBTFUPSOBTJOyOJNPEFIJTUwSJB /PNPNFOUPFNRVFQBTTBBTJHOJGJDBSUBNCnNBSFMBmkP RVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTPDJBMNFOUFPSHBOJ[BEPTFTUBCFMFDFN DPNPUFNQPFDPNPFTQBmP DPNPTPVUSPTTFSFTFDPNBOBUV SF[B SFMBm{FTRVFTFUSBOTGPSNBNOPUFNQPFWBSJBNDPOGPSNF BTDPOEJm{FTEPNFJPBNCJFOUF 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPUFNQPOBOBUVSF[BFPUFNQPOB DVMUVSBPVOBIJTUwSJB /BOBUVSF[B PUFNQPnSFQFUJmkP PEJBTFNQSFTVDFEFhOPJUF BTFTUBm{FTTFTVDFEFNTFNQSFEBNFTNBNBOFJSB BTFTQnDJFT TFSFQSPEV[FNTFNQSFEBNFTNBNBOFJSB OBDVMUVSB PUFNQPn USBOTGPSNBmkP NVEBOmBTOPTDPTUVNFT OBTMFJT OBTFNPm{FT OPTQFOTBNFOUPT OBTUnDOJDBT OPWFTUVgSJP OBTJOTUJUVJm{FT 1PSRVFNVJUPTQFOTBEPSFTDPOTJEFSBNRVFBDVMUVSBDP NFmBRVBOEPPTIPNFOTJOWFOUBNPUSBCBMIP 1PSRVFnQFMBBmkPEPUSBCBMIPRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTJOJ DJBNTFVQSPDFTTPDJWJMJ[BUwSJP QSPEV[JOEPBTQSJNFJSBTUSBOT GPSNBm{FTOBOBUVSF[B FFTUSVUVSBNUPEPPTFVEFTFOWPMWJNFO UPQSPEV[FNPCKFUPTJOFYJTUFOUFTOBOBUVSF[B PSHBOJ[BNTF TPDJBMNFOUF JOWFOUBNBSNBTQBSBTFQSPUFHFS JOWPDBNFBEP SBNGPSmBTEJWJOBT EFTFOWPMWFNPDPNnSDJP DSJBNEFTJHVBMEB EFTFJOTUJUVFNPQPEFS &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPLBOUJBOBFOUSFSFJOPEBOFDFTTJEBEF FSFJOPEBMJCFSEBEF cBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFOBUVSF[BFDVMUVSB,BOUDIBNBEFSFJOP EBOFDFTTJEBEFBTDPJTBTRVFFTUkPTVCNFUJEBThTMFJTOBUVSBJT EFDBVTBMJEBEF RVFTkPVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJBT FDIBNBSFJ OPEBMJCFSEBEFBTBm{FTIVNBOBTSFBMJ[BEBTQPSVNBFTDPMIB WPMVOUgSJBPVQPSMJCFSEBEFFTFHVOEPGJOBMJEBEFTSBDJPOBJT 1PSRVF)FHFMKVMHBRVF1MBUkPF"SJTUwUFMFTTFFOHBOBSBN RVBOUPhJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBDPOUSBEJmkPOPNVOEPSFBM 1PSRVFBNCPTPTGJMwTPGPTQSFTTVQVOIBNRVFQPEFNPT BMDBOmBSBSFBMJEBEFFBWFSEBEFQFMBFMJNJOBmkPEPTDPOUSBEJ UwSJPT&OUSFUBOUP )FHFMDPNQSFFOEFRVFPSFBMFPWFSEBEFJ SPOBEBNBJTTkPEPRVFPNPWJNFOUPJOUFSOPEBDPOUSBEJmkP JTUPn BSFBMJEBEFnPGMVYPEPTDPOUSBEJUwSJPT DPNPEJTTFSB )FSgDMJUP 2VBJTBTEVBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBDPOUSBEJmkPEJB MnUJDBTFHVOEP)FHFM 1SJNFJSP PTUFSNPTDPOUSBEJUwSJPTOkPTkPEPJTUFSNPTQP TJUJWPTDPOUSgSJPTPVPQPTUPT NBTEPJTQSFEJDBEPTDPOUSBEJUw SJPTEPNFTNPTVKFJUPFRVFTwFYJTUFNOFHBOEPVNBPPVUSP &NMVHBSEFEJ[FSRVFOUFGSJP EJBMFUJDBNFOUF nQSFDJTPEJ[FS RVFOUFOkPRVFOUF4FHVOEP POFHBUJWP POkPEFOkPEPDF OkPGSJP FUD
QPSUBOUP OkPnVNUFSNPQPTJUJWPDPOUSgSJPBPV USPQPTJUJWP NBTnWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFPOFHBUJWPEFVNQPTJUJWP )FHFMDIBNBJTTPEFOFHBmkPJOUFSOB JTUPn PUFSNPOFHBEP OkPnVNPVUSPRVBMRVFS NBTPPVUSPEPTVKFJUPPVPTFVPV
USP1PSUBOUP nEJGFSFOUFEJ[FS²PDBEFSOPOkPnBgSWPSF³F²P DBEFSOPnBOkPgSWPSF³/FTUB|MUJNBBGJSNBmkPnRVFUFNPTB DPOUSBEJmkPQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUBFBEJBMnUJDB &YQMJRVFBOFHBmkPJOUFSOB /BOFHBmkPJOUFSOB PUFSNPOFHBEPOkPnVNPVUSPRVBM RVFS NBTPPVUSPEPTVKFJUPPVPTFVPVUSP1PSFYFNQMP TB CFNPTRVFVNDBEFSOPnGFJUPEFQBQFMFRVFPQBQFMWFNEBT gSWPSFTEJBMFUJDBNFOUF OkPEJSFNPT²PDBEFSOPOkPnBgSWP SF³ FTJNRVF²PDBEFSOPnBOkPgSWPSF³ 0RVF)FHFMDIBNBEF&TQrSJUP )FHFMDIBNBEF&TQrSJUPPTVKFJUPRVFSFBMJ[BPNPWJNFOUP EBQPTJmkPFTVQFSBmkPEFQSFEJDBEPTDPOUSBEJUwSJPTPVEBT DPOUSBEJm{FT &YQMJRVFPRVFTJHOJGJDBPTVSHJNFOUPEBDPOTDJpODJBPVEP ²QBSBTJ³OPRVFSFTQFJUBBPTVSHJNFOUPEBDVMUVSB 7JTUPRVFBDPOTDJpODJBnSFGMFYJWB nFMBRVFGBWPSFDFPTVS HJNFOUPEBDVMUVSBEFWJEPBPQSPDFTTPEPFTQrSJUPOFHBOEPTF DPNPOBUVSF[B PVTFKB BQBTTBHFNEBDPJTBFNTJ QPSFYFN QMP VNBNPOUBOIBOBUVSBM QBSBBOkPDPJTB BTJHOJGJDBmkPEB NPOUBOIBFNOPTTBDPOTDJpODJB nRVFQFSNJUFPTVSHJNFOUPEB DVMUVSB 0RVFnBDVMUVSBQBSB.BSY 1BSB.BSY BDVMUVSBnPNPEPDPNP FNDPOEJm{FTEFUFS NJOBEBTFOkPFTDPMIJEBTQPSFMFT PTIPNFOTQSPEV[FNNB UFSJBMNFOUF QFMPUSBCBMIP QFMBPSHBOJ[BmkPFDPOyNJDB TVB FYJTUpODJBFEkPTFOUJEPBFTTBQSPEVmkPNBUFSJBM 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPFTQJSJUVBMJTNPEF)FHFMFPNBUF SJBMJTNPEF.BSY %FBDPSEPDPNPFTQJSJUVBMJTNPIFHFMJBOP BIJTUwSJBOkPn VNBTFRVpODJBUFNQPSBMEFBDPOUFDJNFOUPTFEFDBVTBTFFGFJ UPT NBTBWJEBEP&TQrSJUPRVFTFFYUFSJPSJ[BOBOBUVSF[BFTF JOUFSJPSJ[BOBDVMUVSB1BSBPNBUFSJBMJTNPNBSYJTUB BIJTUwSJB OkPOBSSBFTTFNPWJNFOUPEP&TQrSJUP NBTBTMVUBTSFBJTEPT TFSFTIVNBOPTSFBJTRVFQSPEV[FNFSFQSPEV[FNTVBTDPOEJ m{FTNBUFSJBJTEFFYJTUpODJB JTUPn QSPEV[FNFSFQSPEV[FNBT SFMBm{FTTPDJBJT QFMBTRVBJTTFEJTUJOHVFNEBOBUVSF[BFOBT RVBJTTkPJOTUJUVrEBTBTEJWJT{FTTPDJBJT JTUPn BTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT DPOUSBEJUwSJBT 4FHVOEPPTBOUSPQwMPHPT RVBJTBTEVBTMFJTRVFEkPJOr DJPhDVMUVSB %FBDPSEPDPNPTBOUSPQwMPHPT BEJGFSFOmBFOUSFIPNFN FOBUVSF[B RVFEgPSJHFNhDVMUVSB TVSHFDPNBMFJEBQSPJ CJmkPEPJODFTUP MFJJOFYJTUFOUFFOUSFPTBOJNBJT"MnNEFTTB MFJ BEJGFSFOmBFOUSFIPNFNFOBUVSF[BUBNCnNnFTUBCFMFDJEB RVBOEPPTIVNBOPTEFGJOFNVNBPVUSBMFJRVF TFUSBOTHSFEJ EB DBVTBBSVrOBEBDPNVOJEBEFFEPJOEJWrEVPBMFJRVFTFQBSB PDSVFPDP[JEP MFJUBNCnNJOFYJTUFOUFFOUSFPTBOJNBJT 0RVFnVNBMFJIVNBOB "MFJIVNBOBnVNNBOEBNFOUPTPDJBMRVFPSHBOJ[BUPEBB WJEBEPTJOEJWrEVPTFEBDPNVOJEBEF UBOUPQPSRVFEFUFSNJOB PNPEPEFFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEPTDPTUVNFTFEFTVBUSBOTNJTTkP EFHFSBmkPBHFSBmkPDPNPQPSRVFQSFTJEFBTBm{FTRVFDSJBN BTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJTSFMJHJkP GBNrMJB GPSNBTEFUSBCBMIP GPS NBTEFQPEFS FUD
10
Manual do Professor
&YQMJRVFPRVFnPSEFNTJNCwMJDBFQPSRVFBDVMUVSBBJOT UJUVJ "PSEFNTJNCwMJDBDPOTJTUFOBDBQBDJEBEFIVNBOBQBSB EBShTDPJTBTVNTFOUJEPRVFFTUgBMnNEFTVBQSFTFOmBNBUF SJBM JTUPn OBDBQBDJEBEFEFBUSJCVJSTJHOJGJDBm{FTFWBMPSFThT DPJTBTFBPTIPNFOT EJTUJOHVJOEPFOUSFCFNFNBM WFSEBEFF GBMTJEBEF CFMF[BFGFJ|SBFEFUFSNJOBOEPTFVNBDPJTBPVVNB BmkPnKVTUBPVJOKVTUB MFHrUJNBPVJMFHrUJNB QPTTrWFMPVJN QPTTrWFM"DVMUVSBBJOTUJUVJQPSRVFSFQSFTFOUBVNBBGJSNBmkP EFRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTkPDBQB[FTEFDSJBSVNBPSEFNEF FYJTUpODJBRVFOkPnTJNQMFTNFOUFOBUVSBM 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTTFOUJEPTEFDVMUVSB $SJBmkPEFVNBPSEFNTJNCwMJDBEBMFJ JTUPn EFTJTUFNBT EFJOUFSEJm{FTFPCSJHBm{FTFTUBCFMFDJEPTBQBSUJSEBBUSJCVJmkP EFWBMPSFThTDPJTBT BPTIVNBOPTFTVBTSFMBm{FT BPTBDPOUF DJNFOUPTDSJBmkPEFVNBPSEFNTJNCwMJDBEBTFYVBMJEBEF EB MJOHVBHFN EPUSBCBMIP EPFTQBmP EPUFNQP EPTBHSBEPFEP QSPGBOP EPWJTrWFMFEPJOWJTrWFMDPOKVOUPEFQSgUJDBT DPNQPSUB NFOUPT Bm{FTFJOTUJUVJm{FTQFMBTRVBJTPTIVNBOPTTFSFMBDJP OBNFOUSFTJFDPNBOBUVSF[BFEFMBTFEJTUJOHVFN BHJOEPTPCSF FMBPVQPSNFJPEFMB NPEJGJDBOEPB SJUVBJTEPUSBCBMIP SJUVBJT SFMJHJPTPT DPOTUSVmkPEFIBCJUBm{FT EBOmB WFTUVgSJP FUD 2VBMnPTFOUJEPSFTUSJUPEFDVMUVSB 0TFOUJEPSFTUSJUPEFDVMUVSBnQSPWFOJFOUFEPBOUJHPTFO UJEPEFDVMUJWPEPFTQrSJUPFBDPOTJEFSBDPNPDSJBmkPEFPCSBT EBTFOTJCJMJEBEFFEBJNBHJOBmkP±BTPCSBTEFBSUF±FDPNP DSJBmkPEFPCSBTEBJOUFMJHpODJBFEBSFGMFYkP±BTPCSBTEF QFOTBNFOUP JTUPn BDJpODJBFBGJMPTPGJB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=atlane j_e]`ko]cn]`ka] ejopepqek`]nahecek
1PSRVFQPEFNPTBUSJCVJShDPOTDJpODJBBDBVTBQSJNPSEJBM EPTVSHJNFOUPEBSFMJHJPTJEBEF 1PSRVFnQPSNFJPEBDPOTDJpODJBRVFPTFSIVNBOPTFEFT DPCSFEJGFSFOUFEPTPVUSPTTFSFTFEFTFOWPMWFBQFSDFQmkPEB SFBMJEBEFFYUFSJPSDPNPBMHPJOEFQFOEFOUFEBBmkPIVNBOB0V TFKB PTTFSFTIVNBOPTTkPDBQB[FTEFQFSDFCFSSFHVMBSJEBEFT OBOBUVSF[BFTBCFNRVFOkPTkPBDBVTBEFMBTQFSDFCFNUBN CnNRVFIgOBOBUVSF[BDPJTBT|UFJTFOPDJWBT CPBTFBNFBmB EPSBTFSFDPOIFDFNRVFUBNCnNOkPTkPPTDSJBEPSFTEFMBT &TTBDPOTDJpODJBEFRVFIgVNBPSEFNFYUFSOBFEFDPJTBTEF RVFQPEFNPTOPTBQPTTBSQBSBPVTPPVEFRVFEFWFNPTGVHJS QPSRVFTkPEFTUSVUJWBTOPTDPOEV[hDSFOmBFNQPEFSFTTVQF SJPSFTBPIVNBOPFhCVTDBEFNFJPTQBSBDPNVOJDBSOPTDPN FMFTQBSBRVFTFKBNQSPQrDJPThOPTTBWJEBIVNBOB/BTDF BT TJN BDSFOmBOB T EJWJOEBEF T 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVF²UFNPTDPOTDJpODJBEPUFNQP³ $PNP nOPTTBSFMBmkPDPNPUFNQPOPUSBCBMIP &OBNFNwSJB 5FNPTDPOTDJpODJBEPUFNQPQPSRVFTPNPTDBQB[FTEFEJ GFSFODJBSOPJOUFSJPSEFOPTTBWJEBPRVFKgBDPOUFDFVFPRVF FTUgBDPOUFDFOEP&NOPTTBSFMBmkPDPNPUFNQPOPUSBCBMIP QFSDFCFNPTRVFPUFNQPOkPnPQSFTFOUF FTJNPGVUVSP QPJTP USBCBMIPnGFJUPFNWJTUBEFBMHPRVFBJOEBOkPFYJTUFOPQSFTFOUF FRVFWJSgBFYJTUJSOPGVUVSP2VBOUPhOPTTBSFMBmkPDPNPUFNQP OBNFNwSJB EFTQFSUBNPTPTFOUJNFOUPEBJEFOUJEBEFQFTTPBMF EBDPOUJOVJEBEFEFVNBWJEBRVFUSBOTDPSSFOPUFNQP
11
1PSRVFBDPOTDJpODJBEPUFNQPOPTMFWBhDPOTDJpODJBEB NPSUF 2VBMPQBQFMEFTTBDPOTDJpODJBOPTVSHJNFOUPEB SFMJHJPTJEBEF 1PSNFJPEBDPOTDJpODJBEPUFNQP PTTFSFTIVNBOPTTB CFNRVFIgTFSFTFDPJTBTRVFTVSHFNFEFTBQBSFDFNOPUFNQP FRVFFMFTQFSNBOFDFNQPSVNDFSUPUFNQPQPSRVFTkPDBQB [FTEFMJHBSQBTTBEP QSFTFOUFFGVUVSP&OUSFUBOUP UBNCnN TBCFNRVFQPEFNEFTBQBSFDFSVNEJB PVTFKB UpNDPOTDJpO DJBEFRVFFMFTUBNCnNNPSSFN&TTBDPOTDJpODJBEPUFNQP DPNPVNBQSFTFOmB PQSFTFOUF TJUVBEBFOUSFEVBTBVTpODJBT PQBTTBEPFPGVUVSP FEBOPTTBJEFOUJEBEFFEBJEFOUJEBEF EPTPVUSPTOPTMFWBBDPODFCFSBQFSNBOpODJBEFTTBJEFOUJEB EFOVNUFNQPGVUVSP JTUPn BDPODFCFSVNBFYJTUpODJBGVUVSB OVNPVUSPMVHBSPVOVNPVUSPNVOEP QBSBPOEFWBNPTBQwT BNPSUF&TTBFYJTUpODJBBQwTBNPSUFFNVNPVUSPMVHBSnP RVFEFGJOF FNQBSUF PO|DMFPEBSFMJHJPTJEBEFIVNBOBRVFTF FYQSJNFOBFYQFSJpODJBEPTBHSBEP 0RVFnBFYQFSJpODJBEPTBHSBEP cBQSFTFOmBEFVNBQPUpODJBPVEFVNBGPSmBTPCSFOBUVSBM RVFIBCJUBBMHVNTFS QMBOUB BOJNBM QFTTPB GPHP FUD DPNP VNQPEFSRVFQFSUFODFQSwQSJBFEFGJOJUJWBNFOUFBFTTFEFUFS NJOBEPTFSPVDPNPBMHPRVFFMFQPEFQPTTVJSFQFSEFS OkP UFSFBERVJSJS"FYQFSJpODJBEPTBHSBEPUBNCnNTFNBOJGFTUB OBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPTTFSFT OBTVQFSJPSJEBEFEFBMHVOTTPCSF PVUSPT±TVQFSJPSJEBEFFQPEFSTFOUJEPTDPNPFTQBOUPTPT NJTUFSJPTPT EFTFKBEPT UFNJEPT 0RVFnPFODBOUBNFOUPEPNVOEP cBNBOJGFTUBmkPEPTBHSBEPDPNPGPSmBTPCSFOBUVSBMRVF IBCJUBPNVOEPFBHFEFGPSNBNBSBWJMIPTBFDPNQPEFSFTBE NJSgWFJT 0RVFnPTBHSBEP 0RVFUPSOBBMHVNBDPJTBPVBMHVNTFS TBHSBEPT 4BHSBEPnBRVBMJEBEFFYDFQDJPOBM±CPBPVNg CFOnGJ DBPVNBMnGJDB QSPUFUPSBPVBNFBmBEPSB±RVFVNTFSQPT TVJFRVFPEJTUJOHVFEFUPEPTPTPVUSPT FNCPSB FNNVJUBT DVMUVSBT UPEPTPTTFSFTQPTTVBNBMHPTBHSBEP QFMPRVFTF EJGFSFODJBNVOTEPTPVUSPT0RVFUPSOBVNTFSTBHSBEPnB GPSmBPVQPUpODJBQBSBSFBMJ[BSBRVJMPRVFPTIVNBOPTKVMHBN JNQPTTrWFMFGFUVBSDPOUBOEPBQFOBTDPNBTGPSmBTFDBQBDJEB EFTIVNBOBT 1PSRVFBSFMJHJkPnWrODVMP 0RVFFMBWJODVMB "SFMJHJkPnVNWrODVMPQPSRVFWJTB²VOJSEFOPWP³PNVO EPQSPGBOPFPNVOEPTBHSBEP PNVOEPOBUVSBM gHVB GPHP BOJNBJT IVNBOPT FPNVOEPTPCSFOBUVSBM BTEJWJOEBEFTRVF IBCJUBNBOBUVSF[B &YQMJRVFDPNP FNWgSJBTDVMUVSBT BMJHBmkPFOUSFPTBHSBEP FPQSPGBOPnTJNCPMJ[BEBOPNPNFOUPEFGVOEBmkPEFVNB BMEFJBPVDJEBEF 0HVJBSFMJHJPTPUSBmBGJHVSBTOPDIkP DrSDVMP RVBESBEP USJiOHVMP FSFQFUFPNFTNPHFTUPOPBS OBEJSFmkPEPDnV PVEPNBS PVEBGMPSFTUB PVEPEFTFSUP &TTFTEPJTHFTUPT EFMJNJUBNVNFTQBmPOPWP TBHSBEP OPBS FDPOTBHSBEP OP TPMP /FTTFOPWPFTQBmPFSHVFNTFPTBOUVgSJPFhTVBWPMUB PTFEJGrDJPTEBOPWBDPNVOJEBEF
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
&YFNQMJGJRVFVNDBTPEFDFSJNyOJBSFMJHJPTBFNRVFBQBSF DFBMJHBmkPGVOEBEPSBPVBSFMJHJP 1PSFYFNQMP RVBOEP+FPWgEPBBPQPWPPMVHBSPOEFEFWF IBCJUBS±B5FSSB1SPNFUJEB± JOEJDBPFTQBmPPOEFPUFNQMP EFWFSgTFSFEJGJDBEPOPDSJTUJBOJTNP BQBSFDFOBWFSTkPMBUJ OBEP/PWP5FTUBNFOUP RVBOEPPBQwTUPMP4JNkPQBTTBBTFS DIBNBEPEF1FESP FNMBUJN 1FUSVT QBSBTJNCPMJ[BSBQFESB FNMBUJN QFUSB TPCSFBRVBMnGVOEBEBBDJEBEFDSJTUk JTUPn B*HSFKB+FTVTEJTTFB1FESP²5VnT1FESPFTPCSFFTTBQFESB FEJGJDBSFJBNJOIBJHSFKBFBTQPSUBTEPJOGFSOPOkPQSFWBMFDFSkP DPOUSBFMB³ 2VFnPFTQBmPTBHSBEP $PNPTFEJTUJOHVFEPFTQBmPQSP GBOP &TQBmPTBHSBEPTkPMVHBSFTDPOTBHSBEPTQPSTFSFNBNP SBEBEPTEFVTFTPVMVHBSFTPOEFPEFVTTFNBOJGFTUB&TTF FTQBmPEJTUJOHVFTFEPFTQBmPQSPGBOPQPSSFDFCFSEBSFMJHJkP RVBMJEBEFTIVNBOBTPVRVBMJEBEFTDVMUVSBJTEJWFSTBTEBTTJN QMFTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTOBUVSBJTnPMVHBSPOEFWJWFNPTEFVTFT TkPGFJUBTBTDFSJNyOJBTEFDVMUP TkPUSB[JEBTPGFSFOEBTFGFJUBT QSFDFTDPNQFEJEPThTEJWJOEBEFT 0RVFnPUFNQPTBHSBEP 0 UFNQP TBHSBEP n VNB OBSSBUJWB /BSSB B PSJHFN EPT EFVTFTF QFMBBmkPEBTEJWJOEBEFT BPSJHFNEBTDPJTBT EBT QMBOUBT EPTBOJNBJTFEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT1PSJTTP BOBSSBUJWB SFMJHJPTBTFNQSFDPNFmBDPNBMHVNBFYQSFTTkPEPUJQP²OP QSJODrQJP³ ²OPDPNFmP³ ²RVBOEPPEFVTYFTUBWBOB5FSSB³ ²RVBOEPBEFVTBZWJVQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[³ FUD 0RVFPNJUPFBIJTUwSJBTBHSBEBOBSSBN 0RVFQSFUFO EFNFYQMJDBS /kPTFUSBUBEFVNBGBCVMBmkPJMVTwSJB VNBGBOUBTJBTFN DPOTDJpODJB NBTBNBOFJSBQFMBRVBMVNBTPDJFEBEFOBSSBQBSB TJNFTNBTFVDPNFmPFPEFUPEBBSFBMJEBEF%FTTBNBOFJSB QSFUFOEFNFYQMJDBSBPSEFNOBUVSBMFIVNBOBPTVSHJNFOUPEP NVOEP BPSJHFNEPTGFOyNFOPTOBUVSBJTFEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT PDPNFmPPVOBTDJNFOUPEPTQSwQSJPTEFVTFT BPSEFNOPNVO EP POBTDJNFOUPFQFSFDJNFOUPEFUPEPTPTTFSFT
"SFMJHJkPTFEJSJHFhTFNPm{FTQPSRVFFMBOkPnGJMPTPGJB OFNDJpODJBF QPSUBOUP OkPnPCKFUPEPJOUFMFDUP NBTEPT TFOUJNFOUPTF QPSJTTP TFFOEFSFmBBPDPSBmkP EFTQFSUBOEP FNPm{FTFTFOUJNFOUPTBENJSBmkP FTQBOUP BDPNPEBmkP FT QFSBOmB BNPS NFEP DPOGPSUP%FTTBNBOFJSB BSFMJHJkPQFEF GnBPDSFOUFQBSBRVFBDFJUFQMFOBNFOUFPRVFMIFnNBOJGFTUB EPDPNPBmkPEBEJWJOEBEFTFNDPOUFTUBmkP FQFEFQJFEBEF SFTQFJUPQFMPTEFVTFTFQFMPTBOUFQBTTBEPT 1PSRVFTkPDSJBEPTPTSJUPT 1PSRVFBSFMJHJkPMJHBIVNBOPTFEJWJOEBEF PSHBOJ[BPFT QBmPFPUFNQP FQPSRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTQSFDJTBNHBSBOUJS RVFBMJHBmkPFBPSHBOJ[BmkPTFNBOUFOIBNFTFKBNTFNQSF QSPQrDJBT 0RVFnVNSJUP cVNBDFSJNyOJBFNRVFHFTUPTEFUFSNJOBEPT QBMBWSBT EFUFSNJOBEBT PCKFUPTEFUFSNJOBEPT QFTTPBTEFUFSNJOBEBT FFNPm{FTEFUFSNJOBEBTBERVJSFNPQPEFSNJTUFSJPTPEFQSF TFOUJGJDBSPMBmPFOUSFPTIVNBOPTFBEJWJOEBEF %PRVFEFQFOEFBFGJDgDJBEFVNSJUP %FQFOEFEBSFQFUJmkPNJOVDJPTBFQFSGFJUB UBMDPNPGPJ QSBUJDBEPOBQSJNFJSBWF[ QPSRVFOFMBPTQSwQSJPTEFVTFT PSJFOUBSBNPTHFTUPTFBTQBMBWSBTEPTIVNBOPT 0RVFnVNPCKFUPUBCV %pFYFNQMPTEFUBCVT 4kPDPJTBTUSBOTGPSNBEBTFNTrNCPMPTTBHSBEPTRVFOkP QPEFNTFSUPDBEBTOFNNBOJQVMBEBTQPSOJOHVnNRVFOkPFT UFKBSFMJHJPTBNFOUFBVUPSJ[BEBQBSBJTTP/FTTFTFOUJEP TkP UBCVTBWBDBOBÊOEJB PDPSEFJSPQFSGFJUPDPOTBHSBEPQBSBP TBDSJGrDJPEB1gTDPBKVEBJDB PQkPFPWJOIPDPOTBHSBEPTQFMP QBESFDSJTUkP 0RVFTkPPTFNCMFNBT %pFYFNQMPTEFFNCMFNBTEF EFVTFT
5FPHPOJB EPHSFHP5IFPT ²EFVT³HPOJB ²HFSBmkP³ n VNBOBSSBUJWBNrUJDBEBHFSBmkPPVOBTDJNFOUPEPTEFVTFT TFNJEFVTFTFIFSwJT
4kPGJHVSBm{FTEPTBHSBEPRVFBNQMJBNTFVDBNQPTJNCw MJDP"TTJN PFNCMFNBEBEFVTB'PSUVOBFSBVNBSPEB BWFMB FOGVOBEBEFVNOBWJPFVNBDPSOVDwQJBPEBEFVTB"UFOB P DBQBDFUFFBFTQBEBPEF)FSNFT BTFSQFOUFFBTCPUBTBMB EBTPEF0YwTTJ BTTFUFGMFDIBTFTQBMIBEBTQFMPDPSQPPEF *FNBOKg PWFTUJEPCSBODP BTgHVBTEPNBSFPTDBCFMPTBP WFOUPPEF+FTVT BDSV[ BDPSPBEFFTQJOIPT PDPSQPHMPSJPTP FNBTDFOTkP
0RVFnDPTNPHPOJB
2VFTkPSFMJHJ{FTEBNBOJGFTUBmkP
$PTNPHPOJB EPHSFHPLwTNPT ²NVOEP³ FHPOJB ²HFSB mkP³ nVNBOBSSBUJWBNrUJDBTPCSFPOBTDJNFOUP BGJOBMJEBEFF PQFSFDJNFOUPEPTTFSFTTPCBBmkPEPTEFVTFT
4kPSFMJHJ{FTFNRVFPTEFVTFTTFNBOJGFTUBNTVSHFN EJBOUFEPTIVNBOPTFNCFMF[B FTQMFOEPS QFSGFJmkPFQPEFSF PTMFWBNBWFSVNBPVUSBSFBMJEBEF FTDPOEJEBTPCBSFBMJEBEF DPUJEJBOB OBRVBMPFTQBmP PUFNQP BTGPSNBTEPTTFSFT PT TPOTFBTDPSFT PTFMFNFOUPTFODPOUSBNTFPSHBOJ[BEPTFEJT QPTUPTEFVNBPVUSBNBOFJSB TFDSFUBFWFSEBEFJSB
0RVFnUFPHPOJB
$PNPnPUFNQPTBHSBEP "TTJNDPNPIgEPJTFTQBmPT IgEPJTUFNQPTPBOUFSJPSh DSJBmkPPVHpOFTFEPTEFVTFTFEBTDPJTBT±UFNQPEPWB[JP FEPDBPT±FPUFNQPPSJHJOgSJPEBHpOFTFEFUVEPRVBOUP FYJTUF±UFNQPEPQMFOPFEBPSEFN/FTTFUFNQPTBHSBEPEB PSEFN OPWBNFOUFVNBEJWJTkPPUFNQPQSJNJUJWP JOUFJSBNFO UFEJWJOP RVBOEPUVEPGPJDSJBEP FPUFNQPEPBHPSB QSPGBOP FNRVFWJWFNPTTFSFTOBUVSBJT JODMVJOEPPTIPNFOT 1PSRVFBSFMJHJkPTFEJSJHFhTFNPm{FT 1PSRVFQFEFTP NFOUFGnFQJFEBEF
2VFTkPSFMJHJ{FTEBSFWFMBmkP 4kPSFMJHJ{FTFNRVFPEFVTSFWFMBBTVBWPOUBEF OBRVBM PDSFOUFDPOGJBFDVKPTEFTrHOJPTFMFDVNQSF0DSFOUFQPEFUFS TPOIPTFWJT{FT NBTPGVOEBNFOUBMnPVWJSPRVFBEJWJOEBEF MIFEJ[ QPSRVFEFMBQSPWnNPTFOUJEPQSJNFJSPF|MUJNPEFUP EBTDPJTBTFEPEFTUJOPIVNBOP $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTDPODFCFNPTEFVTFTPVPEFVT
12
Manual do Professor
0TEFVTFTTkPQPEFSFTNJTUFSJPTPT4kPGPSmBTQFSTPOJGJ DBEBTFQPSJTTPTkPWPOUBEFT4kPNJTUFSJPTPTQPSRVFTVBT EFDJT{FTTkPJNQSFWJTrWFJTF NVJUBTWF[FT JODPNQSFFOTrWFJT QBSBPTDSJUnSJPTIVNBOPTEFBWBMJBmkP&TkPWPOUBEFTQPSRVF PRVFBDPOUFDFOPNVOEPNBOJGFTUBVNRVFSFSQFTTPBM TVQSF NPFJORVFTUJPOgWFM
SFMBDJPOBSTFDPNPTWJWPT0VUSBTSFMJHJ{FTBDSFEJUBNRVFP DPSQPnNPSUBM NBTIBCJUBEPQPSVNBFOUJEBEF±FTQrSJUP BM NB TPNCSBJNBUFSJBM TPQSP± RVFTFSgJNPSUBMTFPTEFDSFUPT EJWJOPTFPTSJUVBJTUJWFSFNTJEPSFTQFJUBEPTQFMPGJFMPV OPDBTP EPKVEBrTNPFEPDSJTUJBOJTNP TFBMnNEJTTPPHpOFSPIVNBOP UJWFSSFDFCJEPPQFSEkPEJWJOPQFMPQFDBEPEPTBODFTUSBJT
$PNPBWPOUBEFEJWJOBQPEFUPSOBSTFDPOIFDJEBEPTIP NFOT
1PSRVFBTSFMJHJ{FTQPTTVFNSJUVBJTGVOFSgSJPT
/BGPSNBEFMFJT JTUPn EFDSFUPT NBOEBNFOUPT PSEFOB NFOUPT DPNBOEPTFNBOBEPTEBEJWJOEBEF &YQMJRVFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFSFMJHJ{FTEBSFWFMBmkPEBTMFJT FSFMJHJ{FTEBJMVNJOBmkPNrTUJDB /BTSFMJHJ{FTEBSFWFMBmkPEBTMFJTBEJWJOEBEFVUJMJ[BJOUFS NFEJgSJPTQBSBSFWFMBSBMFJ JOUFSQSFUgMBTFGB[pMBTDVNQSJSc PDBTPEBNBJPSJBEBTSFMJHJ{FTEFUSBEJmkPPDJEFOUBM/BTSFMJ HJ{FTEBJMVNJOBmkPNrTUJDB PTEFVTFTNBOJGFTUBNTVBMFJEJ SFUBNFOUF TFNSFDPSSFSBJOUFSNFEJgSJPT JTUPn TFNQSFDJTBS EFJOUnSQSFUFTcPDBTPEBNBJPSJBEBTSFMJHJ{FTEFUSBEJmkP PSJFOUBM 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPUSBOTFEPTQSPGFUBTFWJEFOUFTFP USBOTFEPpYUBTFNrTUJDP /PQSJNFJSP PJOEJWrEVPUFNBDFTTPBVNDPOIFDJNFOUP RVFQPEFDPNQSFFOEFS NFTNPDPNHSBOEFEJGJDVMEBEF FQPS JTTPQPEFUSBOTNJUJMPBPTPVUSPTOPTFHVOEP OkPIgDPOIFDJ NFOUPOFNBUJWJEBEFJOUFMFDUVBMRVFEFQPJTTFKBUSBOTNJTTrWFM BPVUSPT NBTIgNFSHVMIPFGVTkPEPJOEJWrEVPOBEJWJOEBEF OVNBFYQFSJpODJBJOUSBEV[rWFMFJOUSBOTNJTTrWFM 1PSRVFKVEBrTNP DSJTUJBOJTNPFJTMBNJTNPTkP²SFMJHJ{FT EPMJWSP³ 1PSRVF OFTTBTSFMJHJ{FT BSFWFMBmkPEJWJOBSFDFCJEBFNWJ T{FTFTPOIPTQPSQSPGFUBTFWJEFOUFTGPJDPOTJHOBEBQPSFTDSJUP PVBQwTBNPSUFEBRVFMFRVFBSFDFCFVQBSBRVFJOUFHSBTTFPT UFYUPTEBIJTUwSJBTBHSBEB 1PSRVFPTEFVTFTTFNQSFGBMBNQPSFOJHNBT QBSgCPMBT FPSgDVMPT 1BSBRVFPDBSgUFSUSBOTDFOEFOUBMFNJTUFSJPTPEBWPOUBEF EJWJOBTFKBQSFTFSWBEP $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTFYQMJDBNBPSJHFNPVBDBVTBEBNPSUF IVNBOB /BNBJPSJBEBTSFMJHJ{FTPNJTUnSJPEBNPSUFnTFNQSFFY QMJDBEPDPNPDPOTFRVpODJBEFBMHVNBGBMUBDPNFUJEBDPOUSB BMHVNEFVTPVEFBMHVNBPGFOTBRVFPTIPNFOTGJ[FSBNBPT EFVTFT/PQSJODrQJPPTIPNFOTFSBNJNPSUBJTFWJWJBNOBDPN QBOIJBEPTEFVTFTPVEF%FVTBTFHVJS BMHVnNPVBMHVOTDP NFUFNVNBUSBOTHSFTTkPJNQFSEPgWFMFDPNFMBWFNBHSBOEF QVOJmkPBNPSUBMJEBEFQBSBUPEPT $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTQSPNFUFNJNPSUBMJEBEFPVWJEBBQwT BNPSUF "JNPSUBMJEBEFnQSPNFUJEBQFMPTEFVTFT PVQPS%FVT EFT EFRVF OBWJEBQSFTFOUF PTIVNBOPTSFTQFJUFNBWPOUBEFF BMFJEJWJOBT"MHVNBTSFMJHJ{FTBGJSNBNFTTBJNPSUBMJEBEFEP DPSQPIVNBOPBTTFHVSBOEPRVFFMFQPTTVJVNEVQMP GFJUPEF PVUSBNBUnSJB RVFQFSNBOFDFBQwTBNPSUF FRVF QPSTFSGFJUP EFNBUnSJBTVUJM QPEFQFOFUSBSOPDPSQPEFPVUSPTTFSFTQBSB
13
1PSRVFBDSFEJUBNOBWJEBBQwTBNPSUF WJTBOEP BTTJN HBSBOUJSBFOUSBEBOBPVUSBWJEB $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTEPFODBOUBNFOUPDPODFCFNBWJEBBQwT BNPSUF 1BSBBTSFMJHJ{FTEPFODBOUBNFOUP BNPSUFnDPODFCJEBEF EJWFSTBTNBOFJSBT NBTFNUPEBTFMBTPNPSUPGJDBFODBOUBEP JTUPn UPSOBTFBMHPNgHJDP&NBMHVNBT PNPSUPEFJYBTFV DPSQPQBSBFOUSBSOVNPVUSPFQFSNBOFDFSOPNVOEP TPCGPS NBTWBSJBEBTPVEFJYBTFVDPSQPFTFVFTQrSJUPQFSNBOFDFSOP NVOEP BHJUBOEPPTWFOUPT BTgHVBT PGPHP FOTJOBOEPDBOUP BPTQgTTBSPT QSPUFHFOEPBTDSJBOmBT FOTJOBOEPPTNBJTWF MIPT FTDPOEFOEPFBDIBOEPDPJTBT&NPVUSBT PNPSUPUFNTVB JNBHFNPVTFVFTQrSJUPMFWBEPBPNVOEPEJWJOP BMJEFTGSVUBO EPEBTEFMrDJBTEFVNBWJEBQFSFOFNFOUFQFSGFJUBFCFMBTF QPSnN TVBTGBMUBTUFSSFOBTGPSBNUBOUBTFUBJTRVFOkPQyEFTFS QFSEPBEP TVBJNBHFNPVFTQrSJUPWBHBSgFUFSOBNFOUFQFMBT USFWBT TFNSFQPVTPFTFNEFTDBOTP0NFTNPMIFBDPOUFDFSg TFPTSJUVBJTG|OFCSFTOkPQVEFSFNTFSSFBMJ[BEPTPVTFOkP UJWFSFNTJEPSFBMJ[BEPTBEFRVBEBNFOUF $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTEBTBMWBmkPDPODFCFNBWJEBBQwTB NPSUF /BTSFMJHJ{FTEFTBMWBmkP BFUFSOJEBEFBQwTBNPSUFEFDPS SFEFVNBEFDJTkPEJWJOBRVFEFWFSgBUJOHJSBUPEPTPTIVNBOPT TFBDSFEJUBSFNFSFTQFJUBSFNBMFJEJWJOBFTDSJUBOPTUFYUPTTB HSBEPTFTFHVBSEBSFNBFTQFSBOmBOBQSPNFTTBEFTBMWBmkP GFJUBQPS%FVTFBTTFHVSBEBQPSVNSFEFOUPSFOWJBEPQPSFMFF RVFUFSJBTFTBDSJGJDBEPQFMPTIVNBOPT 2VBMBPSJHFNEPNJMFOBSJTNPDSJTUkP #BTFBEPTFNQSPGFDJBTEPTQSPGFUBT%BOJFMF*TBrBT OP "QPDBMJQTFEF4kP+PkPFOBTQSFEJm{FTEFNBHPTFTJCJMBT HSVQPTQPQVMBSFTDSJTUkPT EVSBOUFB*EBEF.nEJB FTQFSBWBTF RVF$SJTUPWPMUBTTFQFMBTFHVOEBWF[ DPNCBUFTTFPTNBMFT±B QFTUF BGPNF BHVFSSBFBNPSUF± WFODFTTFPEFNyOJPFODBS OBEPOVNHPWFSOBOUFQFSWFSTP PBOUJDSJTUP FJOTUJUVrTTFPSFJ OPEF%FVTOB5FSSB DPNEVSBmkPEFNJMBOPTEFBCVOEiODJB KVTUJmBFGFMJDJEBEF"PGJNEFNJMBOPT IBWFSJBBSFTTVSSFJmkP EPTNPSUPT P+Vr[P'JOBMFPGJNEPNVOEPUFSSFOP 0RVFnPNJMFOBSJTNPDSJTUkP cBDSFOmBOVN3FJOPEF.JM"OPTRVFBOUFDFEFFQSFQBSB PGJNEPNVOEP BPDBCPEPRVBMTFJOJDJBBWJEBFUFSOBEPT FMFJUPTQPS%FVT 1PSRVFPNJMFOBSJTNPDPTUVNBTFSBSFMJHJkPQPQVMBSEPT RVFMVUBNQPSKVTUJmBFGFMJDJEBEF %pFYFNQMPTEFNPWJ NFOUPTQPMrUJDPTNJMFOBSJTUBT 1PSRVFSFQSFTFOUBBFTQFSBOmBEBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTNBS DBEBTQPSEFTJHVBMEBEFT JOKVTUJmBT FYDMVTkPFNJTnSJBOVN UFNQPGVUVSPOPRVBMPTIPNFOTTFSkPGFMJ[FTQBSBTFNQSF B EPS BNJTnSJB BJOKVTUJmBFBNBMEBEFUFSNJOBSkPFOBEBNBJT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
BDPOUFDFSg'PJBTTJNDPN"OUyOJP$POTFMIFJSPOB3FWPMUBEF $BOVEPT OPTFSUkPOPSEFTUJOP FUBNCnNDPNP²NPOHF³+PTn .BSJB OB(VFSSBEP$POUFTUBEP $PNPTkPPCFNFPNBMOBTSFMJHJ{FTQPMJUFrTUBT EVBMJTUBT FNPOPUFrTUBT /BTSFMJHJ{FTQPMJUFrTUBTPCFNFPNBMNBOJGFTUBNTFOPT JO|NFSPTEFVTFT BMHVOTCPOT PVUSPTNBVT PVBUnNFTNP DBEBEFVTQPEFOEPTFSPSBCPN PSBNBVOBTSFMJHJ{FTEVB MJTUBT PCFNFPNBMFTUkPFODBSOBEPTFGJHVSBEPTFNEVBT EJWJOEBEFTBOUBHyOJDBTRVFOkPDFTTBNEFDPNCBUFSTFOBT SFMJHJ{FTNPOPUFrTUBT PCFNFPNBMNBOJGFTUBNTFOPNFTNP EFVT FYDFUPOPDBTPEPNPOPUFrTNPKVEBJDPDSJTUkPFJTMiNJDP RVFDPOTJEFSBPCFNDPNPWJSUVEFEJWJOBFPNBMQSPWFOJFOUF EFTVBTDSJBUVSBT BOKPTFTFSFTIVNBOPT
RVFPDSJBNQPSMJ WSFBSCrUSJP 1PSRVFOPKVEBrTNP DSJTUJBOJTNPFJTMBNJTNPBPSJHFNEP NBMnVNQSPCMFNB "EJWJOEBEFKVEBJDPDSJTUkFJTMiNJDBnEFGJOJEBUFPMPHJDB NFOUFDPNPVNTFSQFSGFJUPQPSFYDFMpODJBcPQSwQSJPCFN FFTUFnFUFSOPDPNP&MF"TTJN TFPCFNnFUFSOPFJOGJOJUP DPNPTVSHJVPNBM "MnNEJTTP UVEPPRVFFYJTUFnPCSBEF %FVT RVFPTDSJPVEPOBEB4FPNBMFYJTUF TFSJBPCSBEF%FVT &OUSFUBOUP VNTFSQFSGFJUP CPN OkPQPEFSJBDSJBSBMHPJNQFS GFJUP NBV %FTTBNBOFJSB UPSOBTFVNQSPCMFNBFYQMJDBSB PSJHFNEPNBM 1PSRVFOPKVEBrTNPFOPDSJTUJBOJTNPBPSJHFNEPNBMFO DPOUSBTFOBTDSJBUVSBT 0RVFnPNBMOFTTBTSFMJHJ{FT $PNP%FVTnVNTFSQFSGFJUPFFUFSOBNFOUFCPN &MFOkP QPEFSJBDSJBSPNBV&OUkP BFYQMJDBmkPQBSBBPSJHFNEPNBMn BUSJCVrEBhTDSJBUVSBT JOUFMJHpODJBTJNBUFSJBJTQFSGFJUBT PTBO KPT RVFBTQJSBNBUFSPNFTNPQPEFSFPNFTNPTBCFSEJWJOP MVUBOEPDPOUSB%FVT&OUSFUBOUP NFOPTQPEFSPTPTFNFOPT TgCJPT TkPWFODJEPTFFYQVMTPTEBQSFTFOmBEJWJOB$PNPWJO HBOmB PTBOKPTWBMFNTFEBMJCFSEBEFEBEBBPTFSIVNBOPFP DPSSPNQFN GB[FOEPPNBMFOUSBSOPNVOEP&TTFNBMnPQFDB EP JTUPn BUSBOTHSFTTkPEBMFJEJWJOBRVFPQSJNFJSPIPNFNF BQSJNFJSBNVMIFSQSBUJDBSBN &YQMJRVFPRVFTkPSFMJHJ{FTEBFYUFSJPSJEBEF 4kPBRVFMBTFNRVFPTEFVTFTQPTTVFNGPSNBWJTrWFM IV NBOB BOJNBM WFHFUBMPVNJOFSBM FTFEJSJHFNhTBm{FTFYUFS OBTFWJTrWFJTEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTOFMB BTPSEFOTFPTNBO EBNFOUPTTFSFGFSFNBDPNQPSUBNFOUPTEJWJOPTFIVNBOPT FYUFSOPTFWJTrWFJT FBSFMBmkPEPTIPNFOTDPNPTEFVTFTTF FYQSJNFOPTSJUPTFOBTDFSJNyOJBT &YQMJRVFPRVFTkPSFMJHJ{FTEBJOUFSJPSJEBEF 4kPBRVFMBTFNRVFBEJWJOEBEFnDPODFCJEBDPNPQVSP FTQrSJUP JOWJTrWFMQBSBPTPMIPTEFOPTTPDPSQP FTFEJSJHFBP DPSBmkP BPFTQrSJUP hBMNBEPDSFOUF GBMBOEPhTVBDPOTDJpODJB FKVMHBOEPPTBUPTIVNBOPTBQBSUJSEBTJOUFOm{FTJOUFSJPSFTEP BHFOUF"MnNEFDVMUVBSBEJWJOEBEFDPNSJUPTFDFSJNyOJBT OB SFMJHJkPEBJOUFSJPSJEBEFBSFMBmkPGVOEBNFOUBMEPIPNFNDPN P T EFVT FT nEFFTQrSJUPQBSBFTQrSJUP $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTEBFYUFSJPSJEBEFDPODFCFNBGBMUBIV NBOB $PNPBGBMUBnQVOJEBFQFSEPBEB
"GBMUBIVNBOBnDPODFCJEBDPNPVNBJSSFWFSpODJBWFS HPOIPTB JTUPn VNBBmkPFYUFSOBWJTrWFM DPNFUJEBWPMVOUg SJBPVJOWPMVOUBSJBNFOUFDPOUSBBEJWJOEBEFQFMBWJPMBmkPEF VNUBCVPVQFMBNgSFBMJ[BmkPEFVNSJUPQPEFTFSUBNCnN VNBDVMQBDBVTBEB TFKBQPSRVFPQFDBEPSFTUgQPTTVrEP QPSEFNyOJPT FOGFJUJmBEPQPSNBVTFTQrSJUPT TFKBQPSRVF PQFDBEPSTFUPSOBEFTNFEJEP EJ[PRVFOkPEFWF GB[PRVF OkPEFWF EFTFKBPRVFOkPQPEFEFTFKBSOFNUFS"GBMUB IVNBOBnQVOJEBDPNBJNQVSF[BRVFDPOUBNJOBPGBMUPTP FPHSVQP FYJHJOEP QBSBTFSQFSEPBEB SJUVBJTEFQVSJGJDB mkP TBDSJGrDJPTFYQJBUwSJPT FYPSDJTNPTFQVSJGJDBm{FTJOEJ WJEVBJT&OUSFUBOUP JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEJTTP BEJWJOEBEF QPEFPVOkPQFSEPBS $PNPBTSFMJHJ{FTEBJOUFSJPSJEBEFDPODFCFNBGBMUBPVP QFDBEPIVNBOP $PNPBGBMUBnQVOJEBFQFSEPBEB "GBMUBIVNBOBnVNBPGFOTBDPNFUJEBDPOUSB%FVTQPS FJPEFVNBBmkPJOUFSOBJOWJTrWFM±BJOUFOmkP± RVFTF N NBOJGFTUBOVNBUPFYUFSOPWJTrWFM UFOEPDPNPDBVTBPVVNB WPOUBEFNgPVVNFOUFOEJNFOUPFRVJWPDBEP"GBMUBIVNB OBnQVOJEBDPNBDVMQB FYJHJOEPFYQJBmkPJOEJWJEVBM1BSB SFDFCFSBHSBmBEJWJOBEPQFSEkP PQFDBEPSQSFDJTBGB[FS VNBFYQFSJpODJBEFBSSFQFOEJNFOUP JTUPn SFDPOIFDFSB GBMUBFQSBUJDBSBm{FTRVFNBOJGFTUFNFYUFSOBNFOUFBEJT QPTJmkPJOUFSJPSEFBSSFQFOEJEPBUSBWnTEFQSFDFT PSBm{FT PVTBDSJGrDJPT 2VBMBDBVTBEBGBMUBPVEPQFDBEPOBTSFMJHJ{FTEBFYUF SJPSJEBEF /BNBJPSJBEBTSFMJHJ{FTEBFYUFSJPSJEBEF BGBMUBPVQFDBEP nVNBGBUBMJEBEF0GBUVN ²EFTUJOP³ FNMBUJN²GBEP³ FNQPS UVHVpT PVBNPJSB ²EFTUJOPGBUBM³ FNHSFHP EFUFSNJOBSBN EFTEFTFNQSFRVFFMFTFSJBDPNFUJEPQPSBMHVnN QBSBEFTHSBmB TVBFEFTFVHSVQP"GBMUBOkPEFQFOEFEBWPOUBEFEPBHFOUF NBTEFVNBEFDJTkPEJWJOB PVEBQPTTFTTkPFFOGFJUJmBNFOUP EPQFDBEPS PVEFRVFFMFQFSEFVBNFEJEBEPRVFnQFSNJUJEP BPTIVNBOPT 2VBMBDBVTBEBGBMUBPVEPQFDBEPOBTSFMJHJ{FTEBJOUF SJPSJEBEF /BTSFMJHJ{FTEBJOUFSJPSJEBEF±DPNPnPDBTPEPKVEBrTNP FEPDSJTUJBOJTNP± BGBMUBOBTDFEBMJCFSEBEFEPBHFOUF RVF DPOIFDFOEPPCFNFPNBM BMFJEJWJOB
USBOTHSJEFDPOTDJFOUF FWPMVOUBSJBNFOUFPEFDSFUPEF%FVT 0RVFnPQFDBEPOPKVEBrTNP /PKVEBrTNP PQFDBEPnBJOGSBmkPh5PSBI JTUPn BMFJEJWJ OBSFWFMBEB$PNPPQFDBEPDPOUBNJOBPHSVQP PQFDBEPSEFWF OkPTwBDFJUBS NBTQFEJSB%FVTQVOJmkPFTPGSJNFOUPTQFMPT RVBJTFYQJFBDVMQB QVSJGJRVFBTJNFTNPFBPHSVQP%FTTB NBOFJSB PKVEBrTNPFOGBUJ[BBTJEFJBTEFDPOGJTTkP BSSFQFO EJNFOUPFQFOJUpODJB 0RVFnPQFDBEPOPJTMBNJTNP /PJTMBNJTNP PHSBOEFQFDBEPnBJEPMBUSJB GB[FSJNBHFOT EF"Mg FPQPMJUFrTNP0TEFNBJTQFDBEPTTkPPTNFTNPTEP KVEBrTNP VNBWF[RVFP*TMkSFDPOIFDFBMFJEJWJOBSFWFMBEBB .PJTnT0DSFOUFnTBMWP BQFTBSEFTFVTQFDBEPT QFMBDPOTUiO DJB QFMBGn QFMBTPCSBTFBDJNBEFUVEPQPSTFVBSSFQFOEJNFOUP FQFOJUpODJB
14
Manual do Professor
0RVFnPQFDBEPPSJHJOBM cPFTUBEPEFQFDBEPRVFNBSDBBOBUVSF[BIVNBOBFN DPOTFRVpODJBEFTVBPSJHFN PVTFKB EFNFNCSPEFVNHpOFSP EFTFSFT PHpOFSPIVNBOP DVKPBODFTUSBMQFDPVFQPMVJVUPEB BEFTDFOEpODJBIVNBOBQPSEFTFKBSQPTTVJSPNFTNPTBCFSF PNFTNPQPEFSEF%FVT 1PSRVFPQFDBEPnVNQSPCMFNBUFPMwHJDPJOTPM|WFMQBSB PDSJTUJBOJTNP 1PSRVF TFOBQSwQSJBFTTpODJBEP%FVTDSJTUkPFTUkPBPOJ QPUpODJBFBPOJTDJpODJB RVFTkPBTRVBMJEBEFTEFUVEPTBCFS EFTEFBFUFSOJEBEFFEF QPSUBOUP DPOIFDFSQSFWJBNFOUFP QFDBEPS QPSRVFQVOFPQFDBEPSTFTBCJBRVFPQFDBEPTFSJB DPNFUJEP /kPFTUBSJBTFOEPJOKVTUPQPSOkPJNQFEJSRVFPQF DBEPGPTTFDPNFUJEP 4FDPOIFDFFUFSOBNFOUFRVFNQFDBSgF RVFNOkPQFDBSg OkPFTUBSJBBHJOEPDPNPPGBUVNFBNPJSB RVFOkPPGFSFDFNFTDPMIBBPTIPNFOT 0V DPNPQPEFNPT GBMBSFNMJCFSEBEFPVMJWSFBSCrUSJPEPQFDBEPSTF EFTEFBFUFS OJEBEF %FVTKgTBCJBRVFFMFQFDBSJB 2VFTkPSFMJHJ{FTEBJNBOpODJBPVQBOUFrTUBT 4kPSFMJHJ{FTRVFDPODFCFNRVFPTTFSFTFPCKFUPTTBDSPT IBCJUBNPOPTTPNVOEP RVFUVEPTkPEFVTFTFRVFFTUFTFTUkP FNUPEBQBSUF FTQBMIBEPTQFMBOBUVSF[B 2VFTkPSFMJHJ{FTEBUSBOTDFOEpODJBPVUFrTUBT /BTSFMJHJ{FTEBUSBOTDFOEpODJBPVUFrTUBT PTEFVTFTFTUkP TFQBSBEPTEPNVOEPOBUVSBMFIVNBOP WJWFNOPVUSPNVOEP FBHFNTPCSFPOPTTP $PNPPDSJTUJBOJTNPJOUSPEV[BWJTJUBmkPEJWJOBEFNBOFJSB BTVQFSBSBTEJGJDVMEBEFTUFPMwHJDBTEFTTBWJTJUBmkP 0DSJTUJBOJTNPGBMBOBWJTJUBmkPEJWJOBQPSNFJPEPTBOKPTF TBOUPT FOBJOTQJSBmkPEP&TQrSJUP4BOUP FOWJBEPQFMP1BJ $PNPFQPSRVFPTFODBSSFHBEPTEBJOUFSQSFUBmkPEBTNB OJGFTUBm{FTEJWJOBTFEPTSJUVBJTTFUPSOBNVNHSVQPEF QPEFSOPJOUFSJPSEBTTPDJFEBEFT "TQFTTPBTFODBSSFHBEBTEFUSB[FSPTBHSBEPQBSBBTPDJF EBEFFBrDPOTFSWgMPBPTQPVDPTGPSNBNVNHSVQPTFQBSBEP VNBDMBTTFTPDJBM DPNFYJHpODJBTFQPEFSFTQSwQSJPT QSJWBOEP BDPNVOJEBEFEBQSFTFOmBEJSFUBEPTBHSBEPFEJTUPSDFOEPB GVOmkPPSJHJOgSJBRVFQPTTVrBN USBOTGPSNBOEPBFNEPNrOJPF QPEFSTPCSFBDPNVOJEBEF%FTTBNBOFJSB UPSOBNTFVNHSVQP EFQPEFSOPJOUFSJPSEBTTPDJFEBEFTQPSRVFTFDPMPDBNDPNP QPSUBEPSFTTJNCwMJDPTEPTBHSBEPFNFEJBEPSFTJOEJTQFOTgWFJT EFMF 1PSRVFBBVUPSJEBEFSFMJHJPTBBQBSFDFDPNPEFUFOUPSBEP QSJWJMnHJPEPTBCFS 2VFQPEFSFTQPTTVJ 1PSRVFDPOIFDFBWPOUBEFEJWJOBFTVBTMFJT1PTTVJPTQP EFSFTNgHJDP TkPPT|OJDPTRVFDPOIFDFNFTBCFNNBOJQVMBS PTWrODVMPTTFDSFUPTFOUSFBTDPJTBT
EJWJOBUwSJPPVBEJWJOIB UwSJP TkPPT|OJDPTDBQB[FTEFQSFWFSPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTQFMB JOUFSQSFUBmkP FQSPQJDJBUwSJP TkPPT|OJDPTDBQB[FTEFSFBMJ[BS PTSJUPTEFNBOFJSBDPSSFUBFBEFRVBEBQBSBPCUFOmkPEPTGB WPSFTEJWJOPT 1PSRVFBTEPVUSJOBTSFMJHJPTBTUFOEFNBJOTUJUVJSBJEFJB EFIJFSBSRVJB 2VBMBJOGMVpODJBTPCSFBPSHBOJ[BmkPEB TPDJFEBEF
15
1PSRVFBOPmkPEFIJFSBSRVJBJOUSPEV[BTOPm{FTEFTVQF SJPSFJOGFSJPS EFGJOJOEPBSFMBmkPFOUSFBNCPTQFMPNBOEPF QFMBPCFEJpODJB*TTPJOGMVFODJBOBPSHBOJ[BmkPEPNVOEPFEB TPDJFEBEF FWJEFODJBOEPRVFPTRVFTFPDVQBNDPNBTDPJTBT TBHSBEBTFTUkPOPUPQPEBIJFSBSRVJBIVNBOBFUPEPTPTPVUSPT MIFTEFWFNPCFEJpODJB $PNPPTTBDFSEPUFTFYFSDFNBWJPMpODJBTBHSBEB "WJPMpODJBTBHSBEBnFYFSDJEBOkPTwTPCSFPDPSQPFPDPN QPSUBNFOUPEPTGJnJT NBTTPCSFUVEPTPCSFBTBMNBT 2VBJTPTNFJPTFQSPDFEJNFOUPTEPTTBDFSEPUFTDSJTUkPT QBSBFYFSDFSBWJPMpODJBTBHSBEB 0QSJNFJSPnBDPOGJTTkPEBTGBMUBTPVEPTQFDBEPT GFJUB QFSBOUFPTBDFSEPUF RVFUFNPQPEFSQBSBQFSEPBSPVBCTPMWFS NFEJBOUFPBSSFQFOEJNFOUPEPQFDBEPSFEBTQFOJUpODJBTRVF MIFTkPJNQPTUBT0TFHVOEPQSPDFEJNFOUPnPFYBNFTBDFSEP UBMEBTJEFJBTFEBTPQJOJ{FTEPTGJnJTRVFOkPQPEFNUSBOTHSF EJSOFNEJTDPSEBSEBTWFSEBEFTSFWFMBEBT 2VFnBIFSFTJB 2VBJTPTDBNJOIPTEBJOTUJUVJmkPTBDFS EPUBMQBSBQVOJSIFSFTJBT )FSFTJBnVNBQBMBWSBHSFHBRVFTJHOJGJDB²PQJOJkPEJTDPS EBOUF³4kPEFGJOJEPTDPNPIFSFTJBTPTQFOTBNFOUPTPVBT JEFJBTRVFRVFTUJPOBNPVQSPQ{FNVNDPOUF|EPPVTJHOJGJDBEP EJGFSFOUFEBTWFSEBEFTSFWFMBEBTFTUBCFMFDJEBTQFMBEPVUSJOB TBHSBEB 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTGJOBMJEBEFTEBSFMJHJkP 1SPUFHFSPTTFSFTIVNBOPTDPOUSBPNFEPEBOBUVSF[B OF MBFODPOUSBOEPGPSmBTCFOnGJDBT DPOUSBQPTUBThTNBMnGJDBTF EFTUSVJEPSBTEBSBPTIVNBOPTVNBDFTTPhWFSEBEFEPNVO EP FODPOUSBOEPFYQMJDBm{FTQBSBBPSJHFN BGPSNB BWJEBFB NPSUFEFUPEPTPTTFSFTFEPTQSwQSJPTIVNBOPTPGFSFDFSBPT IVNBOPTBFTQFSBOmBEFWJEBBQwTBNPSUFPGFSFDFSDPOTPMP BPTBGMJUPT EBOEPMIFTVNBFYQMJDBmkPQBSBBEPSGrTJDBFQTr RVJDBHBSBOUJSPSFTQFJUPhTOPSNBT hTSFHSBTFBPTWBMPSFTEB NPSBMJEBEFFTUBCFMFDJEBQFMBTPDJFEBEF 2VBJTBTDSrUJDBTRVFPTGJMwTPGPTBOUJHPTGJ[FSBNhSFMJ HJkP $SJUJDBSBNPQPMJUFrTNP BGJSNBOEPRVF EPQPOUPEFWJTUB EBSB[kP BQMVSBMJEBEFEPTEFVTFTnBCTVSEB QPJTBFTTpODJB EBEJWJOEBEFnBQMFOJUVEFJOGJOJUB OkPQPEFOEPIBWFSTFOkP VNBQPUpODJBEJWJOB%FDMBSBSBNUBNCnNBCTVSEPPBOUSPQP NPSGJTNP RVFBUSJCVJBPTEFVTFTRVBMJEBEFTFQSPQSJFEBEFT DPNPTFGPTTFNTVQFSIPNFOT"SB[kP QPSnN TBCFRVFFTTBT RVBMJEBEFTFQSPQSJFEBEFTEFWFNTFSTVQSBIVNBOBT PVTFKB OkPQPEFNDPOGVOEJSTFDPNBTEBOBUVSF[BIVNBOB%JTTFSBN BJOEBRVFBSFMJHJkPnGBCVMBmkPJMVTwSJB OBTDJEBEPNFEPEB NPSUFFEBOBUVSF[BRVFnTVQFSTUJmkP $PNP DPNCBTFOBTVQFSTUJmkP &TQJOPTBDSJUJDBBTSFMJ HJ{FT 1BSB&TQJOPTB BTSFMJHJ{FTTkPDSJBEBTQBSBBMJNFOUBSB DSFOmBEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT RVFKVMHBNRVFBPSJHFNEPTNB MFTFCFOTTFFODPOUSBFNGPSmBTDBQSJDIPTBT DPNPBTPSUFF BGPSUVOB OBTRVBJTQBTTBNBBDSFEJUBSDPNPQPEFSFTRVFPT HPWFSOBNBSCJUSBSJBNFOUF&OUSFUBOUP QBSBDPOTFSWBSTFVEP NrOJPTPCSFPTIPNFOT BSFMJHJkPJOTUJUVJVNQPEFSJPQPMrUJDP SFMJHJPTPEJSJHJEPFDPNBOEBEPQFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTSFMJHJPTBT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
RVFGB[FNDSFSRVFBTMFJTQPMrUJDBTTkPWPOUBEFEF%FVTPV EPTEFVTFTSFWFMBEBBBMHVOTRVF QPSJTTP UpNPEJSFJUPEJWJ OPEFEPNJOBSFDPNBOEBSPTEFNBJT&OUkP OBTDJEBEPNFEP TVQFSTUJDJPTP BSFMJHJkPFTUg QPSUBOUP BTFSWJmPEBUJSBOJB F FTUBnUBOUPNBJTGPSUFRVBOUPNBJTPTIPNFOTGPSFNEFJYBEPT OBJHOPSiODJBEBWFSEBEFJSBOBUVSF[BEF%FVT EBTWFSEBEFJSBT DBVTBTEFUPEBTBTDPJTBTFEBPSJHFNIVNBOBEPQPEFSQPMr UJDPFEBTMFJT 2VFGPJBSFMJHJkPOBUVSBMPVPEFrTNP "JEFJBEFVNBSFMJHJkPOBUVSBMPVEFrTNPTVSHJVOPTTnDV MPT97**F97***7PMUBOEPTFDPOUSBBSFMJHJkPSFWFMBEBFJOTUJUV DJPOBMJ[BEBDPNPQPEFSFDMFTJgTUJDPFQPEFSUFPMwHJDPQPMrUJDP PTGJMwTPGPTBGJSNBSBNBFYJTUpODJBEFVN%FVTRVFnVNBGPSmB PVVNBFOFSHJBJOUFMJHFOUF JNBOFOUFhOBUVSF[B DPOIFDJEPQF MBSB[kPFDPOUSgSJPhTVQFSTUJmkP 0RVF'FVFSCBDIFOUFOEFVQPSBMJFOBmkPSFMJHJPTB %FBDPSEPDPN'FVFSCBDI BSFMJHJkPTVSHFEBOFDFTTJEBEF EFPTFSIVNBOPFYQMJDBSTVBSFMBmkPDPNBOBUVSF[B EBrBDSJB mkPEPTEFVTFT DPOTUJUVrEPTEFQPEFSFTRVFFYQSJNFNEFTFKPT IVNBOPTFRVFMPHPQBTTBNBTFSDPODFCJEPTDPNPDSJBEPSFTF HPWFSOBOUFTEBSFBMJEBEFDPNGPSmBTFQPEFSFTNBJPSFTRVFPT IVNBOPT&OUSFUBOUP OPEFDPSSFSEPUFNQP PTTFSFTIVNBOPT FTRVFDFNRVFGPSBNPTDSJBEPSFTEFTTBEJWJOEBEF&TTFMPOHP QSPDFTTPQFMPRVBMPTIPNFOTOkPTFSFDPOIFDFNOPQSPEVUP EFTVBQSwQSJBDSJBmkP USBOTGPSNBOEPPOVNPVUSP BMJFOVT
FTUSBOIP EJTUBOUF QPEFSPTPFEPNJOBEPS nBBMJFOBmkPSFMJ HJPTBPEPNrOJPEBDSJBUVSB EFVTFT TPCSFTFVTDSJBEPSFT IP NFOT 0RVF.BSYRVJTEJ[FSDPN²BSFMJHJkPnPwQJPEPQPWP³ $PNFTTBBGJSNBmkP .BSYQSFUFOEFVNPTUSBSRVFBSFMJHJkP ±SFGFSJOEPTFBPKVEBrTNP BPDSJTUJBOJTNPFBPJTMBNJTNP JT UPn hTSFMJHJ{FTEFTBMWBmkP±BNPSUFDFBDPNCBUJWJEBEFEPT PQSJNJEPTFFYQMPSBEPTQPSRVFMIFTQSPNFUFVNBWJEBGFMJ[OP GVUVSPFOVNPVUSPNVOEP 0RVF.BSYRVJTEJ[FSDPN²BSFMJHJkPnMwHJDBFFODJDMPQn EJBQPQVMBS FTQrSJUPEFVNNVOEPTFNFTQrSJUP³ .BSYQSPDVSPVEFNPOTUSBSDPNFTTBFYQSFTTkPRVFBSF MJHJkPnVNBGPSNBEFDPOIFDJNFOUPFEFFYQMJDBmkPEBSFBMJ EBEFVTBEBQFMBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFT±MwHJDBFFODJDMPQnEJB ±QBSBEBSTFOUJEPhTDPJTBT hTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTFQPMrUJDBT FODPOUSBOEPTJHOJGJDBm{FT±PFTQrSJUPOPNVOEPTFNFTQrSJ UP±RVFMIFTQFSNJUBN QFSJPEJDBNFOUF MVUBSDPOUSBPTQP EFSFTUJSiOJDPT "QSFTFOUFBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEPNJUP&YQMJRVF DPNNBJTEFUBMIFTEVBTEFMBT cVNBGBMB VNSFMBUPPVVNBOBSSBUJWBDVKPUFNBQSJODJQBM nBPSJHFN EPNVOEP EPTIPNFOT EPTEFVTFT OkPTFEFGJ OFQFMPPCKFUPEBOBSSBUJWBPVEPSFMBUP NBTQFMPNPEPDPNP OBSSBPVQFMPNPEPDPNPQSPGFSFBNFOTBHFNDSJBVNBDPN QFOTBmkPTJNCwMJDBFJNBHJOgSJBQBSBEJGJDVMEBEFT UFOT{FTF MVUBTSFBJTUJEBTDPNPJOTPM|WFJTnFMBCPSBEPQBSBPDVMUBSB FYQFSJpODJBEBIJTUwSJBPVEPUFNQPBPNFTNPUFNQPRVFSF TVMUBEFTJUVBm{FTTPDJBJT DPOGMJUPT UFOT{FT MVUBT
nDBVTBEF FGFJUPTTPDJBJT JOTUJUVJm{FT DPNQPSUBNFOUPT TFOUJNFOUPT VMUSBQBTTBBTGSPOUFJSBTEBTPDJFEBEFPOEFGPJTVTDJUBEPSFWFMB VNBFTUSVUVSBJODPOTDJFOUFVOJWFSTBMEBTPDJFEBEFPQFSBQPS BTTPDJBmkPFSFVOJkPEFGSBHNFOUPTIFUFSPHpOFPTVNNFTNP
TJHOJGJDBOUFNrUJDPQPEFUFSVNO|NFSPJNFOTPEFTJHOJGJDBm{FT PVTFOUJEPT "QSFTFOUFBMHVNBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFPNJUPFP²MwHPT³ 0MwHPTCVTDBBDPFSpODJB DPOTUSVJOEPDPODFJUVBMNFOUF TFVPCKFUP FORVBOUPPNJUPGBCSJDBTFVPCKFUPQFMBSFVOJkPF DPNQPTJmkPEFGSBHNFOUPTErTQBSFTFEJTQBSBUBEPTEPNVOEP FYJTUFOUF EBOEPMIFTVOJEBEFOVNOPWPTJTUFNBFYQMJDBUJWPOP RVBMBERVJSFNTJHOJGJDBEPTJNCwMJDP0MwHPTQSPDVSBBVOJEBEF TPCBEJWFSTJEBEFFBNVMUJQMJDJEBEFPNJUPGB[FYBUBNFOUFP PQPTUP JTUPn QSPDVSBBNVMUJQMJDJEBEFFBEJWFSTJEBEFTPCB VOJEBEF0NJUPnVNQFOTBNFOUPFNQrSJDPDPODSFUPPMwHPTn VNQFOTBNFOUPDPODFJUVBMFBCTUSBUP "QSFTFOUFBMHVNBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFPDSFOUFFPGJMwTPGP OPUPDBOUFBPTQSJODJQBJTUFNBTEBSFMJHJkP 1BSBPDSFOUF IgVN%FVTQBSBPGJMwTPGP nQSFDJTPQSPWBSB FYJTUpODJBEBEJWJOEBEFQBSBPDSFOUF %FVTnVNFOUFQFSGFJUP CPNFNJTFSJDPSEJPTP NBTKVTUP QVOJOEPPTNBVTFSFDPNQFO TBOEPPTCPOTQBSBPGJMwTPGP %FVTnVNBTVCTUiODJBJOGJOJUB NBTnQSFDJTPQSPWBSRVFTVBFTTpODJBnDPOTUJUVrEBQPSVNJO UFMFDUPPOJTDJFOUFFVNBWPOUBEFPOJQPUFOUFQBSBPDSFOUF B FTQJSJUVBMJEBEFEJWJOBOkPnJODPNQBUrWFMDPNBFTQFSBOmBEF QPEFSWFS%FVTBUVBSNBUFSJBMNFOUFTPCSFPNVOEP SFBMJ[BOEP NJMBHSFTQBSBPGJMwTPGP nQSFDJTPQSPWBSSBDJPOBMNFOUFRVFn QPTTrWFMVNBBmkPEPFTQrSJUPTPCSFBNBUnSJBQPSRVF TFOEP %FVTPOJTDJFOUF GB[FOEPNJMBHSFT TVTQFOEFSJBBPSEFOBmkP OFDFTTgSJBEPNVOEPRVF&MFQSwQSJPFTUBCFMFDFVQBSBPGJFM BBMNBnJNPSUBMFEFTUJOBEBBVNBWJEBGVUVSBQBSBPGJMwTPGP DBCFPGFSFDFSQSPWBTRVFEFNPOTUSFNBJNPSUBMJEBEFPDSFOUF FYQFSJNFOUBBGVTkPQMFOBOPTFJPEF%FVT TFOUFFTUBSOFMFF OFMFWJWFSQBSBPGJMwTPGP OkPTFOUJNPT%FVT NBT0DPOIFDF NPTQFMBSB[kP 0RVFnBUFPMPHJB 5FPMPHJBnBDJpODJBTPCSF%FVT/BTDFVEBOFDFTTJEBEFEF BSFMJHJkPBQSFTFOUBSTFOBGPSNBEFQSPWBTSBDJPOBJT DPODFJ UPT UFTFTFUFPSJBTQBSBDPNQFUJSDPNBGJMPTPGJBFTVQMBOUgMB 2VFTkPNJTUnSJPTFEPHNBTEBGn .JTUnSJPTTkPWFSEBEFTEBGnFEPHNBTTkPWFSEBEFTJO RVFTUJPOgWFJT"NCBTTkPDSFOmBTSFMJHJPTBTRVFKBNBJTQPEF SkPTFSUSBOTGPSNBEBTFNUFTFTFEFNPOTUSBm{FTSBDJPOBJT %pFYFNQMPTEFJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFTFOUSFWFSEBEFTEBGnF WFSEBEFTGJMPTwGJDBTPVDJFOUrGJDBT 6NFYFNQMPEBJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFFOUSFWFSEBEFTEBGn FWFSEBEFTEBSB[kPnBIJTUwSJBTBHSBEBOBSSBEBOP"OUJHP 5FTUBNFOUPRVFQSFTTVQ{FRVFP4PMTFNPWJNFOUBFNUPSOP EB5FSSBFRVFFTUBQFSNBOFDFJNwWFM DPOUSBQPTUBhFYQMJDB mkPGJMPTwGJDPDJFOUrGJDBIFMJPDpOUSJDBEF$PQnSOJDP6NPVUSP FYFNQMPnBEFTDSJmkPCrCMJDBEBDSJBmkPEPIPNFNEJSFUB NFOUFQPS%FVT DPOUSBQPTUBhUFPSJBEBFWPMVmkPEF%BSXJO RVFEFNPOTUSBBPSJHFNEPIPNFNBQBSUJSEFQSJNBUBT6N |MUJNPFYFNQMPEFTTBJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFnPTJHOJGJDBEPMJU|S HJDPEBNJTTB RVF DPNPWFSEBEFDSJTUk nBQSFTFOUBEBDPNP VNDPOKVOUP|OJDPFOPWPEFFWFOUPTSFMBUJWPThWJEB QBJYkP FNPSUFEF+FTVT PDPSEFJSPJNPMBEP SFQFUJEPFSFNFNPSBEP QPSNFJPEPQkPFEPWJOIP&OUSFUBOUP IJTUPSJBEPSFT MJOHVJT UBTFBOUSPQwMPHPTGJ[FSBNFTUVEPTEFNPOTUSBOEPRVFFTTB TJNCPMPHJBKgFSBBOUFSJPSNFOUFVUJMJ[BEBQPSDVMUVSBTEFVNB
2,
Manual do Professor
TPDJFEBEFBHSgSJB DPNSJUPTEFGFSUJMJEBEFEB5FSSBFEPTBOJ NBJT RVFSFBMJ[BWBNDFSJNyOJBTNVJUPTFNFMIBOUFT
2VBJTTkPPTUSpTBTQFDUPTTPCSFBTPCSBTEFBSUFRVFFTUkP QSFTFOUFTOPQPOUPEFWJTUBEPFTQFDUBEPS
$PNP,BOUQSPDVSPVDPODJMJBSGJMPTPGJBFSFMJHJkP
0USBCBMIPBSUrTUJDPnGFJUPQPSVNBTwQFTTPBBPCSBEFBSUF WBMFFNTJFQPSTJNFTNBDPNPVNBQFmB|OJDBPFTQFDUBEPS UFNBDFTTPJOEJSFUPBFMB
#BTFBOEPTFOBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFGFOyNFOPFOyVNFOP ,BOU EJSJHFTVBDSrUJDBhGJMPTPGJBRVBOEPEJ[RVFBNFUBGrTJDBOkPn DPOIFDJNFOUPEBFTTpODJBFNTJEF%FVT EBBMNBFEPNVOEP DBNQPOPRVBMBSB[kPnJNQFEJEBEFUFPSJ[BS"SFMJHJkP QPSTVB WF[ OkPnUFPMPHJB OkPnUFPSJBTPCSF%FVT BMNBFNVOEP NBT SFTQPTUBBVNBQFSHVOUBRVFBSB[kPOkPQPEFSFTQPOEFSUFPSJ DBNFOUF²0RVFQPEFNPTFTQFSBS ³$BCFhSFMJHJkPPGFSFDFS QSJODrQJPThBmkPNPSBMFGPSUBMFDFSBFTQFSBOmBOVNEFTUJOP TVQFSJPSEBBMNBIVNBOB $PNP)FHFMUSBUBBSFMBmkPFOUSFSFMJHJkPFGJMPTPGJB &NMVHBSEFPQPSSFMJHJkPFGJMPTPGJB )FHFMGB[EBSFMJHJkPVN NPNFOUPEBIJTUwSJBEPFTQrSJUPPVEF%FVTFVNBFUBQBQSFQB SBUwSJBEBGJMPTPGJB OBRVBM%FVTTFSFDPOIFDFBTJNFTNPDPNP %FVT $PNPBGFOPNFOPMPHJBUSBUBBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBBUJUVEFSF MJHJPTBFBBUJUVEFGJMPTwGJDB %FBDPSEPDPNBGFOPNFOPMPHJB BBUJUVEFSFMJHJPTBFBBUJ UVEFGJMPTwGJDBTkPEJGFSFOUFTGPSNBTEBJOUFODJPOBMJEBEFEB DPOTDJpODJBEPBSTFOUJEPhSFBMJEBEF"TTJNDPNPFYJTUFBBUJ UVEFOBUVSBM BDSFOmBSFBMJTUBJOHpOVBOBFYJTUpODJBEBTDPJTBT FBBUJUVEFGJMPTwGJDB BSFGMFYkP
IgUBNCnNBBUJUVEFSFMJHJPTB SFMBmkPDPNPNVOEPQPSNFJPEFOPm{FTFQSgUJDBTMJHBEBTBP TBHSBEP %FTTFNPEP BDPOTDJpODJBQPEFSFMBDJPOBSTFDPN PNVOEPEFNBOFJSBTWBSJBEBT±TFOTPDPNVN DJpODJB GJMP TPGJB BSUFTFSFMJHJkP± EFTPSUFRVFOkPIgPQPTJmkPOFNFY DMVTkPFOUSFFMBT NBTEJGFSFOmBT*TTPTJHOJGJDBRVFBPQPTJmkP FOUSFFTTBTBUJUVEFTTwTVSHJSgRVBOEPBDPOTDJpODJB FTUBOEP OVNBBUJUVEF QSFUFOEFSSFMBDJPOBSTFDPNPNVOEPVUJMJ[BOEP TJHOJGJDBm{FTFQSgUJDBTEFVNBPVUSBBUJUVEF
#APqTULOß߯ßßKqjeranok`]o]npao 0RVF FNHFSBM BTQFTTPBTFOUFOEFNQPSBSUJTUB &NHFSBMBTQFTTPBTWFFNDPNPBSUJTUBPBUPS EFUFBUSP EF UFMFWJTkP EFDJOFNB
PDPNQPTJUPSNVTJDBMFPDBOUPSFFNBM HVOTDBTPTPTCBJMBSJOPT0VTFKB BRVFMFRVFSFBMJ[BVNFTQF UgDVMP 0RVF FNHFSBM BTQFTTPBTFOUFOEFNQPSPCSBEFBSUF 1PSPCSBEFBSUFBTQFTTPBTFOUFOEFNRVFTkPPTRVBESPT BTFTDVMUVSBT BTTPOBUBT BTwQFSBTPVBMHVNBQFmBEFCBMn 0VTFKB FNHFSBMJEFOUJGJDBNPCSBEFBSUFDPNPBMHPBRVFQPV DPTUpNBDFTTP DSJBEPOPQBTTBEP DPOTFSWBEPFNNVTFVTPV BQSFTFOUBEPFNJNQPSUBOUFTUFBUSPTQBSBVNQ|CMJDPSFTUSJUP TFKBQPSRVFTkPQPVDPTPTRVFPDPNQSFFOEFN TFKBQPSRVF TkPQPVDPTPTRVFEJTQ{FNEFSFDVSTPTQBSBGSVrMP 0RVF FNHFSBM BTQFTTPBTEJ[FNTFOUJSEJBOUFEBTPCSBT EFBSUF 1PSRVp &NHFSBMTFOUFNSFTQFJUP FNPDJPOBNTFDPNBCFMF[BEB PCSBFTkPUPNBEBTEFSFTQFJUPQFMPBSUJTUBRVFBDSJPV&YQFSJ NFOUBNFTTFTFOUJNFOUPQPSRVFFNOPTTBTPDJFEBEFBBSUFn WJTUBDPNPBMHPTVQFSJPS FMBCPSBEPQPSQFTTPBTRVFQPTTVFN BMHVNEPNPVUnDOJDBBQVSBEBFNBMHVNPGrDJPRVFPTEJTUJO HVFEPUSBCBMIPCVSPDSgUJDPFNFDiOJDPEBWJEBEJgSJB
2-
&YQMJRVFPRVFTJHOJGJDBBBQSPYJNBmkPRVFNVJUPTFTUBCF MFDFNFOUSFPCSBEFBSUFFBSUFTBOBUP 5BOUPBPCSBEFBSUFRVBOUPPBSUFTBOBUPTkPUSBCBMIPT GFJUPTQPSVNB|OJDBQFTTPB PVTFKB TkPDSJBm{FTJOEJWJEVBJT FYQSJNFNBJOUFOmkP BIBCJMJEBEFFPUBMFOUPEFRVFNBTSFB MJ[B QPSnNBPCSBEFBSUFQPTTVJNBJPSDPNQMFYJEBEFFWBSJF EBEFEFQSPDFEJNFOUPTEPRVFPTFNQSFHBEPTQFMPBSUFTkP "MnNEJTTP PBSUFTkPDPTUVNBGBCSJDBSWgSJPTFYFNQMBSFTEP NFTNPPCKFUP FORVBOUPPBSUJTUBUFOEFBQSPEV[JSBQFOBT VN |OJDP &YQMJRVFPRVFTJHOJGJDBBSFMBmkPRVFNVJUPTFTUBCFMFDFN FOUSFPCSBEFBSUFFBOUJHVJEBEF &YJTUFBrBJEFJBEFRVFBTHSBOEFTPCSBTEFBSUFGPSBNSFB MJ[BEBTOPQBTTBEPFDPOTFSWBEBTQFMBIVNBOJEBEFDPNPVN CFNDPMFUJWP0VTFKB RVFGPSBNSFUJSBEBTEPDJSDVJUPEPVTPF EPDPTUVNFQBSBWBMPSJ[gMBTFQSFTFSWgMBT &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBPCSBEFBSUFnBVOJkPEPFUFSOPFEPOP WP 1PSRVFUSB[VNNVOEPFUFSOBNFOUFOPWPFUFSOBNFOUF QPSRVFUkPBOUJHPFQFSFOFRVBOUPBQFSDFQmkPIVNBOBFOP WPQPSRVFPBSUJTUBPQFSDFCFDPNPOVODBGPSBQFSDFCJEPBOUFT QFMPTEFNBJTIPNFOT 0RVFPBSUJTUBCVTDBFYQSJNJSOVNBPCSB 0BSUJTUBCVTDBFYQSJNJSPNVOEPFNRVFWJWFNPTFRVF QFSDFCFNPTTFNOPTEBSNPTDPOUBEFMFFEFOwTNFTNPT OFM F#VTD BFYQ SJN JSPRVFTFNQ SFWJN PTTFNWFS PRVF TFNQ SFPVW JN PTTFNPVW JS PRVFTFNQ SFTFOU JN PTTFN TFOUJS PRVFTFNQSFQFOTBNPTTFNQFOTBS PRVFTFNQSF EJTTFNPTTFNEJ[FS/BPCSBEFBSUF BSFBMJEBEFTFSFWFMB DPN PTFKBN BJTBUJW nTT FN PTWJTU P PVW JE P EJU P TFOU JE P PVQFOTBEP 0RVFnBBSUF TFHVOEP'FSSFJSB(VMMBS 1BSB'FSSFJSB(VMMBS ²BBSUFnNVJUBTDPJTBT6NBEBTDPJTBT RVFBBSUFn QBSFDF nVNBUSBOTGPSNBmkPTJNCwMJDBEPNVOEP 2VFSEJ[FSPBSUJTUBDSJBVNNVOEPPVUSP±NBJTCPOJUPPVNBJT JOUFOTPPVNBJTTJHOJGJDBUJWP PVNBJTPSEFOBEP±QPSDJNBEB SFBMJEBEFJNFEJBUB/BUVSBMNFOUF FTTFNVOEPPVUSPRVFPBS UJTUBDSJBPVJOWFOUBOBTDFEFTVBDVMUVSB EFTVBFYQFSJpODJBEF WJEB EBTJEFJBTRVFFMFUFNOBDBCFmB FOGJN EFTVBWJTkPEF NVOEP³ 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBGBMBGBMBEBPVJOTUJUVrEBFBGBMB GBMBOUFPVJOTUJUVJOUF "MJOHVBHFNRVFGBMBNPTDPUJEJBOBNFOUFnBMJOHVBHFN JOTUJUVrEB VNB²GBMBGBMBEB³ FNRVFSFQSPEV[JNPTBTTJHOJGJDB m{FTEBTQBMBWSBTTFNQFOTBSOFMBT"MJOHVBHFNEPQPFUB EP SPNBODJTUB EPDPOUJTUBnVNBMJOHVBHFNJOTUJUVJOUF DSJBEPSB JOWFOUPSBEFTJHOJGJDBm{FTOPWBT VNB²GBMBGBMBOUF³ &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBTBSUFTTkPBQBTTBHFNEPJOTUJUVrEPBP JOTUJUVJOUF
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
"MJUFSBUVSB DPNPBQJOUVSB BN|TJDB BFTDVMUVSBFRVBM RVFSEBTBSUFT nBQBTTBHFNEPJOTUJUVrEPBPJOTUJUVJOUF PV TFKB VNBUSBOTGJHVSBmkPEPFYJTUFOUFOVNBPVUSBSFBMJEBEF RVFPGB[SFOBTDFSFTFSEFNBOFJSBJOUFJSBNFOUFOPWB"USBOT GPSNBmkPPVUSBOTGJHVSBmkPEBSFBMJEBEFOVNBPVUSB OPWBF FYJTUFOUFBQFOBTOPUSBCBMIPSFBMJ[BEPQFMPBSUJTUB DIBNBTF PCSB 1PSRVFBTBSUFTOBTDFNOPJOUFSJPSEBWJEBSFMJHJPTB 1PSRVFPRVFIPKFDIBNBNPTCFMBTBSUFT QJOUVSB FTDVM UVSB EBOmB N|TJDB OBTDFVIgNJMpOJPTOPJOUFSJPSEPTDVMUPT SFMJHJPTPTFQBSBTFSWJMPT0TQSJNFJSPTPCKFUPTBSUrTUJDPTFSBN PCKFUPTNgHJDPT DPOTJEFSBEPTVNBFODBSOBmkPEPTEFVTFT&T TFTQSJNFJSPTPCKFUPTFSBNPTGFUJDIFTFPTBSUJTUBTPVBSUFTkPT RVFPTQSPEV[JBNFSBNPTGFJUJDFJSPT$PNPUFNQP PTPCKFUPT GBCSJDBEPTDPNPPCKFUJWPEBTBDSBMJEBEFQBTTBSBNBUFSWBMPS EFDVMUP 1PSRVFPTQSJNFJSPTPCKFUPTBSUrTUJDPTFSBNNgHJDPTPV GFUJDIFTFPTBSUJTUBTFSBNGFJUJDFJSPT 1PSRVFFTTFTQSJNFJSPTPCKFUPTBSUrTUJDPT FTUBUVFUBT QJO UVSBTOBTQBSFEFTEFDBWFSOBT TPOTPCUJEPTQPSQFSDVTTkP OkPFSBNUJEPTTPNFOUFDPNPVNBSFQSFTFOUBmkPPVVNBJOWP DBmkPBPTEFVTFT NBTBFODBSOBmkPEFMFTBDSFEJUBWBTFRVF BTGPSmBTEJWJOBTFTUBWBNOFMFT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFPTPCKFUPTGBCSJDBEPTQFMPTBSUJTUBT UJOIBNWBMPSEFDVMUP «NFEJEBRVFBTSFMJHJ{FTGPSBNTFPSHBOJ[BOEPOPJOUFSJPS EBTTPDJFEBEFT QBTTPVTFhJEFJBEFRVFMVHBSFTFDPJTBTEFT UJOBEPThTBDSBMJEBEFPVhWJEBSFMJHJPTBIBWJBNTJEPFTDPMIJEPT QFMPTQSwQSJPTEFVTFTFRVFMPDBJTFPCKFUPTBTTJNFTDPMIJEPT EFWFSJBNGJDBSTFQBSBEPTEFUPEPPSFTUP SFTFSWBEPTFYDMVTJWB NFOUFQBSBIPOSBSPTEFVTFTEFNBOFJSBTEFUFSNJOBEBTQFMPT QSwQSJPTEFVTFT JTUPn FNDVMUPT 1PSRVF OBTQSJNFJSBTDVMUVSBT PBSUJTUBFSBVNNBHP VN JOJDJBEPFNNJTUnSJPTFVNPGJDJBOUFEFDVMUPT &SBVNNBHPQPSRVFDPOIFDJBPTNJTUnSJPTTBHSBEPTFSB VNPGJDJBOUFEFDVMUPTQPSRVFSFBMJ[BWBPSJUVBMQPSNFJPEFQB MBWSBT HFTUPT TPOTFEBOmBTGJYBEPTQFMBUSBEJmkPFQFMBBVUPSJ EBEFSFMJHJPTBFFSBVNJOJDJBEPFNNJTUnSJPTQPSRVFBQSFOEJB BDPOIFDFSBNBUnSJBQSJNBQSFFTUBCFMFDJEBQBSBPFYFSDrDJP EFTVBBSUF BVTBSVUFOTrMJPTFJOTUSVNFOUPTQSFFTUBCFMFDJEPT QBSBBTVBBmkP BSFBMJ[BSHFTUPT QSPOVODJBSQBMBWSBT VUJMJ[BS DPSFT NBOJQVMBSFSWBTTFHVOEPVNSFDFJUVgSJPGJYPFTFDSFUP DPOIFDJEPBQFOBTQFMPTJOJDJBEPT %FTDSFWBDPNPPTBSUJTUBTFBSUFTkPTFTUBWBNTVCNFUJEPT hBVUPSJEBEFSFMJHJPTBPVhBVUPSJEBEFQPMrUJDB &TUBWBNTVCNFUJEPThBVUPSJEBEFSFMJHJPTBRVBOEP QPS FYFNQMP FSBNFODBSSFHBEPTEFUFDFSPTWFTUVgSJPT GBCSJ DBSBTKPJBT QSPEV[JSPTPCKFUPTFPTJOTUSVNFOUPT DPOTUSVJS PTMVHBSFTEPTDVMUPT FSHVFSBMUBSFT FTDVMQJSPVQJOUBSBT GJHVSBTEPTEFVTFTFEFTFVTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT QSPEV[JSBT N|TJDBT PTDBOUPTFPTJOTUSVNFOUPTNVTJDBJT SFBMJ[BSBT EBOmBT"THSBOEFTPCSBTEFBSUFEBTTPDJFEBEFTBOUJHBTF EBTPDJFEBEFDSJTUkNFEJFWBM BTTJNDPNPEBDVMUVSBKVEBJ DBFEBDVMUVSBJTMiNJDB TkPSFMJHJPTBTUFNQMPT DBUFESBJT QBMgDJPT DgMJDFT UBmBT NBOUPT U|OJDBT DIBQnVT DPMBSFT QVMTFJSBT BOnJT FTUgUVBT RVBESPT FUD&FTUBWBNTVCNF UJEPThBVUPSJEBEFQPMrUJDB QSJODJQBMNFOUFOBTTPDJFEBEFT
HSFHBFSPNBOBBOUJHBT RVBOEPBPTBSUrGJDFTFSBNFODPNFO EBEPTFEJGrDJPT PCKFUPT WFTUVgSJPT NPCJMJgSJPT KPJBT BEPS OPT FTUgUVBTFQJOUVSBT 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFOBTTPDJFEBEFTBOUJHBTOkPIBWJBB BVUPOPNJBEBTBSUFT 4JHOJGJDBWBRVFPGB[FSBSUrTUJDPFTUBWBUPUBMNFOUFBUSFMB EPBPQPEFSSFMJHJPTPFFNQBSUFBPQPEFSQPMrUJDP1BSBRVF BBVUPOPNJBEBTBSUFTWJFTTFBBDPOUFDFS GPJQSFDJTPRVFP NPEPEFQSPEVmkPDBQJUBMJTUBEFTTBDSBMJ[BTTFPNVOEPFMBJ DJ[BTTFUPEBBDVMUVSB MBOmBOEPUPEBTBTBUJWJEBEFTIVNBOBT OPNFSDBEP &YQMJRVFPTFOUJEPEBTQBMBWSBTBSTFUnLIOF "STFUnLIOFFTUkPOBPSJHFNEBQBMBWSBBSUF"QBMBWSBBSUF WFNEPMBUJNBSTFDPSSFTQPOEFBPUFSNPHSFHPUnLIOF ²UnDOJ DB³ TJHOJGJDBOEP²UPEBBUJWJEBEFIVNBOBTVCNFUJEBBSFHSBT FNWJTUBEBGBCSJDBmkPEFBMHVNBDPJTB³ 2VBMPTFOUJEPBNQMPEFBSTPVUnLIOF 2VBMPTFVTFOUJEP FTUSJUP 2VBMPTFVTFOUJEPHFSBM &NTFOUJEPBNQMP BSTPVUnLIOFTJHOJGJDBWBIBCJMJEBEFF BHJMJEBEFQBSBJOWFOUBSNFJPTQBSBWFODFSVNBEJGJDVMEBEFPV VNPCTUgDVMPQPTUPTQFMBOBUVSF[B&NTFOUJEPFTUSJUP TJHOJGJ DBWBPBQSFOEJ[BEPFBQSgUJDBEFVNPGrDJPRVFQPTTVJSFHSBT QSPDFEJNFOUPTFJOTUSVNFOUPTQSwQSJPT"STPVUnLIOFFSBVN TBCFSQSgUJDP 2VBMBEJTUJOmkPEBTBSUFTFN1MBUkP 1MBUkPOkPEJTUJOHVJBBBSUFEBTDJpODJBTOFNBEJTUJOHVJBEB GJMPTPGJB VNBWF[RVFUPEBTFMBTTkPBUJWJEBEFTIVNBOBTPSEF OBEBTFSFHSBEBT"EJTUJOmkPQMBUyOJDBFSBGFJUBFOUSFEPJTUJQPT EFBSUFTPVUnDOJDBTBTKVEJDBUJWBT JTUPn EFEJDBEBTBQFOBTBP DPOIFDJNFOUP FBTEJTQPTJUJWBTPVJNQFSBUJWBT WPMUBEBTQBSB VNBBmkPQSgUJDB 2VBMBEJTUJOmkPGFJUBQPS"SJTUwUFMFTFOUSFDJpODJBFBSUF 1BSBFMF BDJpODJBnVNTBCFSUFwSJDPRVFTFSFGFSFBPOF DFTTgSJP JTUPn BPRVFOkPQPEFTFSEJGFSFOUFEPRVFnQPSTFS FGFJUPEFDBVTBTOBUVSBJTOFDFTTgSJBT
FORVBOUPBBSUFPVUnD OJDBnVNTBCFSQSgUJDPRVFPQFSBOPDBNQPEPDPOUJOHFOUFPV EPQPTTrWFM JTUPn EPRVFQPEFTFSEJGFSFOUFEPRVFnQPSTFS FGFJUPEFVNBEFMJCFSBmkPPVEFDJTkPIVNBOB 2VBMBEJTUJOmkPGFJUBQPS"SJTUwUFMFTOPDBNQPEBQSgUJDB IVNBOB &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFBmkPFGBCSJDBmkP 1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT BBmkP FNHSFHPQSgYJT nBRVFMBBUJWJEB EFIVNBOBFNRVFPBHFOUF PBUPRVFFMFSFBMJ[BFBGJOBMJEBEF CVTDBEBQPSFMFTkPJEpOUJDPT±BQSgYJTEFGJOFBBmkPnUJDBFB BmkPQPMrUJDB BTTJN QPSFYFNQMP PIPNFNRVFBHFWJSUVPTB NFOUFnWJSUVPTPFBWJSUVEFnBBmkPRVFFMFSFBMJ[B EFNBOFJSB RVFOkPTFQPEFTFQBSBSPBHFOUFWJSUVPTP PBUPWJSUVPTPFB WJSUVEFPVGJOBMJEBEFEBBmkP "GBCSJDBmkP FNHSFHPQwJFTJT nBRVFMBBUJWJEBEFIVNBOBOBRVBMPBHFOUF PBSUFTkPPVBSUJT UB
BBmkPRVFFMFSFBMJ[B BTSFHSBTFQSPDFEJNFOUPTTFHVJEPT QPSFMF FBGJOBMJEBEFCVTDBEB BPCSB TkPEJGFSFOUFTFEJTUJO UPT±BQwJFTJTEFGJOFBTBSUFTPVUnDOJDBTDPNPBUJWJEBEFTEF GBCSJDBmkP BTTJN QPSFYFNQMP PNnEJDP BBmkPEFDVSBSFB TB|EFSFDPORVJTUBEBOkPTkPJEpOUJDPTEBNFTNBNBOFJSB P FTDVMUPS PDJO[FMFPNgSNPSF BTSFHSBTEBFTDVMUVSBFBFTUgUVB OkPTkPJEpOUJDPT
2.
Manual do Professor
2VBJTBTEJTUJOm{FTBDSFTDFOUBEBTQFMPTOFPQMBUyOJDPThT EJTUJOm{FTBSJTUPUnMJDBT %JTUJOHVJSBNBTUnDOJDBTPVBSUFTDVKBGJOBMJEBEFnBVYJMJBS BOBUVSF[B±DPNPBNFEJDJOB BBHSJDVMUVSB±EBRVFMBTDVKB GJOBMJEBEFnGBCSJDBSVNPCKFUPDPNPTNBUFSJBJTPGFSFDJEPTQFMB OBUVSF[B±PBSUFTBOBUPQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUP%JTUJOHVJSBNUBN CnNVNPVUSPDPOKVOUPEFBSUFTFUnDOJDBTRVFOkPTFSFMBDJP OBNDPNBOBUVSF[B NBTBQFOBTDPNPQSwQSJPIPNFN QBSB UPSOgMPNFMIPSPVQJPSN|TJDB EBOmB QPFTJBFSFUwSJDB 1PSRVFBTBSUFTGPSBNEJWJEJEBTFNMJCFSBJTFTFSWJT 2VBJT FSBNBTBSUFTMJCFSBJT 2VBJTBTTFSWJTPVNFDiOJDBT 1PS RVFBTMJCFSBJTFSBNDPOTJEFSBEBTTVQFSJPSFThTNFDiOJ DBT "DMBTTJGJDBmkPEBTBSUFTPVUnDOJDBTTFHVJVVNQBESkPRVF GPJEFUFSNJOBEPQFMBFTUSVUVSBEBTPDJFEBEFBOUJHBF QPSUBOUP QFMBPSHBOJ[BmkPTPDJBMGVOEBEBOBFTDSBWJEkP"EJWJTkPTPDJBM FOUSFIPNFOTMJWSFTFFTDSBWPT JNQPOEPBFTUFTUPEBTBTPDV QBm{FTFUPEPTPTUSBCBMIPTNBOVBJTFSFTFSWBOEPhRVFMFTBT BUJWJEBEFTOkPNBOVBJT MFWBWBBVNBDVMUVSBRVFEFTQSF[BWB PUSBCBMIPNBOVBM"PCSB"TO|QDJBTEF.FSD|SJPF'JMPMPHJB FTDSJUBQFMPIJTUPSJBEPSSPNBOP7BSSkP PGFSFDFBDMBTTJGJDBmkP RVFQFSEVSBSgEPTnDVMP**E$BPTnDVMP97 EJWJEJOEPBTBSUFT FNBSUFTMJCFSBJT PVEJHOBTEPIPNFNMJWSF FBSUFTTFSWJTPV NFDiOJDBT QSwQSJBTEPUSBCBMIBEPSNBOVBM &SBNBSUFTMJCF SBJTHSBNgUJDB SFUwSJDB MwHJDB BSJUNnUJDB HFPNFUSJB BTUSPOP NJBFN|TJDB DPNQPOEPPDVSSrDVMPFTDPMBSEPTIPNFOTMJWSFT &SBNBSUFTNFDiOJDBTUPEBTBTPVUSBTBUJWJEBEFTUnDOJDBTBHSJ DVMUVSB DBmB QFTDB NFEJDJOB FOHFOIBSJB BSRVJUFUVSB OBWF HBmkP QJOUVSB FTDVMUVSB PMBSJB DBSQJOUBSJB NBSDFOBSJB GJBmkP FUFDFMBHFN FUD&TTBDMBTTJGJDBmkPTFSgKVTUJGJDBEBQPS4BOUP 5PNgTEF"RVJOPEVSBOUFB*EBEF.nEJBDPNPEJGFSFOmBFOUSF BTBSUFTRVFEJSJHFNPUSBCBMIPEBSB[kP PVBTBSUFTMJCFSBJT FBTRVFEJSJHFNPUSBCBMIPEBTNkPT PVBTBSUFTNFDiOJDBT 7JTUPRVF OVNBQFSTQFDUJWBSFMJHJPTBDSJTUk TPNFOUFBBMNB nMJWSFFPDPSQPnQBSBFMBVNBQSJTkP DPODMVJTFRVFBTBSUFT MJCFSBJTTkPTVQFSJPSFThTBSUFTNFDiOJDBT 2VFRVFSEJ[FS²NFDiOJDB³ QBMBWSBVTBEBQBSBSFGFSJSTF hTBSUFTNBOVBJT "TQBMBWSBTHSFHBTNFDIgOF NFDiOJDB FNgDIFOB NgRVJ OB TJHOJGJDBN²JOWFOmkPFOHFOIPTB FTUSBUBHFNBBTUVDJPTP³ FFSBNVTBEBT JOJDJBMNFOUF QBSBTFSFGFSJSFNBFTUSBUBHFNBT EFHVFSSBFOBNPOUBHFNEFDFOgSJPTEFUFBUSP1PVDPBQPVDP QBTTBSBNBTJHOJGJDBSUBNCnNUPEPFYQFEJFOUFIBCJMJEPTPQBSB SFTPMWFSVNBEJGJDVMEBEFDPSQPSBMPVQBSBTVQFSBSVNPCTUgDV MPhBmkPEPDPSQPIVNBOP 1PSRVFEVSBOUFB3FOBTDFOmBIPVWFBMVUBQFMBWBMPSJ[B mkPEBTBSUFTNFDiOJDBT 1PSEVBTSB[{FTQSJODJQBJTFNQSJNFJSPMVHBS QPSRVF DPNFmBBTVSHJSPJEFBMEBWJEBBUJWB RVFWBMPSJ[BBBQMJDB mkPQSgUJDBPVUnDOJDBEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTUFwSJDPT DPNPTF WpFN-FPOBSEPEB7JODJDPNTVBTJOWFOm{FTEFNgRVJOBT EFUPEPUJQPFDPNPTFWpUBNCnNDPNBJNQPSUiODJBEPT PCKFUPTUnDOJDPTRVFQFSNJUJSBNBSFBMJ[BmkPEBTHSBOEFT OBWFHBm{FTFPTEFTDPCSJNFOUPTNBSrUJNPT FNTFHVOEP QPSRVFPIVNBOJTNPSFOBTDFOUJTUBEJHOJGJDBPDPSQPIVNB OPFFTTBEJHOJEBEFTFUSBEV[OBDIBNBEB²CBUBMIBQFMBEJH OJEBEFEBTBSUFTNFDiOJDBT³QBSBMIFTEBSBNFTNBDPOEJmkP EBTBSUFTMJCFSBJT"MnNEJTTP FTUBNPTBHPSBOPJOrDJPEP DBQJUBMJTNPF hNFEJEBRVFFTUFTFEFTFOWPMWF PUSBCBMIP
2/
QBTTBBTFSDPOTJEFSBEPGPOUFFDBVTBEBTSJRVF[BT TFOEP QPSJTTPWBMPSJ[BEP"WBMPSJ[BmkPEPUSBCBMIPBDBSSFUBBEBT BSUFTNFDiOJDBT &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPEBTBSUFTTFHVOEPPDSJUnSJPEP|UJM FEPCFMP "QBSUJSEPTnDVMP97*** EJTUJOHVJSBNTFBTGJOBMJEBEFTEBT WgSJBTBSUFTNFDiOJDBT JTUPn BTRVFUpNDPNPGJNPRVFn |UJMBPTIPNFOT±NFEJDJOB BHSJDVMUVSB FOHFOIBSJB BSRVJ UFUVSB DVMJOgSJBFPTBSUFTBOBUPTPMBSJB NBSDFOBSJB GJBmkP UFDFMBHFN UBQFmBSJB KPBMIFSJB WJESBSJB KBSEJOBHFN FUD±F BRVFMBTDVKPGJNnQSPEV[JSPCFMPFQSPWPDBSPTFOUJNFOUPEB CFMF[B±QJOUVSB FTDVMUVSB QPFTJB PVMJUFSBUVSB
N|TJDB UFBUSPFEBOmB$PNBJEFJBEFVUJMJEBEF VNBQBSUFEBTBSUFT NFDiOJDBTUPSOPVTFFGFUJWBNFOUFMJCFSBMFDPNJTTPTVSHJSBN BTDIBNBEBTQSPGJTT{FTMJCFSBJT DPNPPNnEJDP PFOHFOIFJ SP PBEWPHBEP PBSRVJUFUP PQSPGFTTPS FUD $PNBJEFJBEF CFMF[B VNBQBSUFEBTBSUFTNFDiOJDBTUSBOTGPSNPVTFOBT DIBNBEBTCFMBTBSUFT NPEPQFMPRVBMOwTGPNPTBDPTUVNB EPTBFOUFOEFSBBSUF 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTDPOTFRVpODJBTEBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFBS UFTEBVUJMJEBEFFBSUFTEBCFMF[B "EJTUJOmkPFOUSFBSUFTEBVUJMJEBEFFBSUFTEBCFMF[BBDBS SFUPVVNBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFUnDOJDB P|UJM FBSUF PCFMP
MFWBO EPhJNBHFNEBBSUFDPNPBmkPJOEJWJEVBMFTQPOUiOFB WJOEB EBTFOTJCJMJEBEFFEBGBOUBTJBEPBSUJTUBDPNPHpOJPDSJBEPS &ORVBOUPPUnDOJDPnWJTUPDPNPBQMJDBEPSEFSFHSBTFQSPDFEJ NFOUPTWJOEPTEBUSBEJmkPPVEBDJpODJB PBSUJTUBnWJTUPDPNP EPUBEPEFJOTQJSBmkP FOUFOEJEBDPNPVNBFTQnDJFEFJMVNJ OBmkPJOUFSJPSFFTQJSJUVBMNJTUFSJPTBRVFMFWBPHpOJPBDSJBS BPCSB 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFBTBSUFTTkPFYQSFTTkPDSJBEPSBF USBCBMIPFYQSFTTJWP 4JHOJGJDBRVFBTBSUFTQBTTBSBNBTFSDPODFCJEBTNFOPT DPNPDSJBmkPHFOJBMNJTUFSJPTBFNBJTDPNPFYQSFTTkPDSJBEP SB JTUPn DPNPUSBOTGJHVSBmkPEPNVOEPFNPCSBBSUrTUJDB"T BSUFTTkPWJTUBTDPNPUSBCBMIPEBFYQSFTTkPFNPTUSBNRVF EFTEFRVFTVSHJSBNQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[ GPSBNJOTFQBSgWFJTEB DJpODJBFEBUnDOJDB"TTJN QPSFYFNQMP BFTDVMUVSBHSFHBUFSJB TJEPJNQPTTrWFMTFNBHFPNFUSJBBQJOUVSBFBBSRVJUFUVSBEB 3FOBTDFOmBTkPJODPNQSFFOTrWFJTTFNBNBUFNgUJDBFBUFPSJB EBIBSNPOJBFEBTQSPQPSm{FTBQJOUVSBJNQSFTTJPOJTUB JODPN QSFFOTrWFMTFNBGrTJDBFBwQUJDB JTUPn TFNBUFPSJBEBTDPSFT FUD"OPWJEBEFEPGJOBMEPTnDVMP9*9FEFUPEPPTnDVMP99FTUg OPGBUPEFRVF BHPSB BTBSUFTOkPPDVMUBNFTTBTSFMBm{FT PT BSUJTUBTTFSFGFSFNFYQMJDJUBNFOUFBFMBTFCVTDBNOBTDJpODJBT FOBTUnDOJDBTSFTQPTUBTFTPMVm{FTQBSBQSPCMFNBTBSUrTUJDPT "PTFUPNBSFNBTBSUFTDPNPFYQSFTTkPDSJBEPSBFDPNPUSBCB MIPFYQSFTTJWP OkPTFRVFSEJ[FSRVFFMBTQFSEFSBNPWrODVMP DPNBJEFJBEFCFMF[B FTJNRVFBTVCPSEJOBSBNBVNPVUSP WBMPS BWFSEBEF"PCSBEFBSUFCVTDBDBNJOIPTEFBDFTTPBP SFBMFEFFYQSFTTkPEBWFSEBEF&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BTBSUFT QSFUFOEFNFYQSJNJSQPSNFJPTBSUrTUJDPTBQSwQSJBSFBMJEBEF &YQSJNJSTJHOJGJDB²JOUFSQSFUBS³ PVTFKB FODPOUSBSPVSFWFMBSP TFOUJEPEBTDPJTBTFEPNVOEP0QJOUPSEFTFKBSFWFMBSPRVF nBWJTJCJMJEBEFJOUFSQSFUBOEPPNVOEPWJTrWFMPN|TJDP PRVF nBTPOPSJEBEF JOUFSQSFUBOEPPNVOEPTPOPSPPEBOmBSJOP P RVFnBNPCJMJEBEFDPSQPSBM JOUFSQSFUBOEPPNVOEPEPNPWJ NFOUPPFTDSJUPS PRVFnBQBMBWSB JOUFSQSFUBOEPPNVOEPEB MJOHVBHFNPFTDVMUPS PRVFnNBUFSJBMJEBEFEPUBEBEFGPSNB JOUFSQSFUBOEPPNVOEPEBNBUnSJBFEBGPSNB1BSBGB[pMP SF
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
DPSSFNhTUnDOJDBTFBPTJOTUSVNFOUPTUnDOJDPT DPNP BMJgT TFNQSFGJ[FSBN BQFTBSEBJNBHFNEPHpOJPDSJBEPSJOTQJSBEP RVFUJSBEFEFOUSPEFTJBPCSB &YFNQMJGJRVFBNBOFJSBDPNPOBBSUFDPOUFNQPSiOFBBSUF FUnDOJDBTFDPNVOJDBNFTFSFMBDJPOBN 1PEFNPTEBSDPNPFYFNQMPUSpTNBOJGFTUBm{FTBSUrTUJDBT DPOUFNQPSiOFBTRVFJMVTUSBNPNPEPDPNPBSUFFUnDOJDBTF FODPOUSBNFTFDPNVOJDBNBGPUPHSBGJB PDJOFNBFPEFTJHO 'PUPHSBGJBFDJOFNBTVSHFN JOJDJBMNFOUF DPNPUnDOJDBTEFSF QSPEVmkPEBSFBMJEBEF1PVDPBQPVDP QPSnN UPSOBNTFJOUFS QSFUBm{FTEBSFBMJEBEFFDPNJTTPTVSHFNDPNPBSUFTEBFYQSFT TkP0EFTJHO QPSTVBWF[ JOUSPEV[BTBSUFTQMgTUJDBT QJOUVSB FTDVMUVSB BSRVJUFUVSB OPEFTFOIPFOBQSPEVmkPEFJOTUSVNFO UPTUnDOJDPT VTBEPTOBJOE|TUSJB OPTMBCPSBUwSJPTDJFOUrGJDPT OPTIPTQJUBJT FNDPOTVMUwSJPTNnEJDPTFEFOUgSJPT FUD FEF VUFOTrMJPTDPUJEJBOPT JOEPEFTEFBVUPNwWFJTFBWJ{FTBUnNg RVJOBTEPNnTUJDBTPVFMFUSPEPNnTUJDPT NPCJMJgSJP MVNJOgSJBT UBMIFSFT DPQPT QSBUPT YrDBSBT MgQJT DBOFUBT UFDJEPTQBSBNw WFJTFDPSUJOBT KPJBTFCJKVUFSJBT DBMmBEPT FUD 1PSRVF BQBSUJSEPTnDVMP99 BTGSPOUFJSBTRVFTFQBSBN BSUFFUnDOJDBTFUPSOBSBNNVJUPUpOVFT *TTPTFEFVFNSB[kPEBTOFDFTTJEBEFTJOUSrOTFDBTBDBEB FYQSFTTkPBSUrTUJDB1PSFYFNQMPnQSFDJTPVNBQFMrDVMBUFD OJDBNFOUFQFSGFJUBQBSBBGPUPHSBGJBBSUrTUJDBFQBSBPDJOFNB EFBSUFnQSFDJTPVNNBUFSJBMUFDOJDBNFOUFQFSGFJUPQBSBRVF VNEJTDPQPTTBSFQSPEV[JSVNDPODFSUPnQSFDJTPFRVJQBNFO UPTUnDOJDPTEFBMUBRVBMJEBEFFQSFDJTkPQBSBQSPEV[JSGPUPT GJMNFT EJTDPT WrEFPT DFOgSJPTFJMVNJOBmkPUFBUSBJT"UnDOJ DBEFGBCSJDBmkPEPTJOTUSVNFOUPTNVTJDBJTFBJOWFOmkPEF BQBSFMIPTFMFUSyOJDPTQBSBN|TJDB BTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTUnDOJDBT EFOPWBTUJOUBTFDPSFT HSBmBTBPTNBUFSJBJTTJOUnUJDPT NPEJ GJDBOEPBQJOUVSB BTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTUnDOJDBTEFOPWPTNBUF SJBJTEFDPOTUSVmkP NPEJGJDBOEPBBSRVJUFUVSB PTVSHJNFOUP EFOPWPTNBUFSJBJTTJOUnUJDPT NPEJGJDBOEPBFTDVMUVSB TkP BMHVOTFYFNQMPTEBSFMBmkPJOUFSOBFOUSFBUJWJEBEFBSUrTUJDB FJOWFOmkPUnDOJDPUFDOPMwHJDB&TTBSFMBmkPUPSOPVTFUkP FTUSFJUBRVFBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFBSUFFSVEJUBFBSUFQPQVMBSTF CBTFJBOBQSFTFOmBEBUFDOPMPHJBEFQPOUBOBQSJNFJSBFOB BVTpODJBEFTTBUFDOPMPHJB OBTFHVOEBPVTFKB BBSUFQP QVMBSnBSUFTBOBMBFSVEJUB UFDOPMwHJDB5BNCnNDPOGJSNB BHSBOEFQSPYJNJEBEFFOUSFBSUFTFUFDOPMPHJBPGBUPEFRVF NVJUPTBSUJTUBTDIFHBNBBQSFTFOUBSDPNPPCSBEFBSUFVNB JOUFSQSFUBmkPEPTQSwQSJPTPCKFUPTFJOTUSVNFOUPTUnDOJDPT &OkPNFOPTTJHOJGJDBUJWPnPGBUPEFBMHVNBTUnDOJDBT RVF TFSWJBNEFJOTUSVNFOUPTQBSBBTBSUFT UFSFNTFUPSOBEP FMBT QSwQSJBT GPSNBTEFBSUF DPNPGPJPDBTPEBTDIBNBEBTBSUFT HSgGJDBT OBTDJEBTEBTUnDOJDBTEFJNQSFOTBQBSBBSFQSPEVmkP EFPCSBTEFBSUF 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFVNPCKFUPUnDOJDPF VNBPCSBEFBSUF "EJGFSFOmBFOUSFBPCSBEFBSUFFPTPCKFUPTUnDOJDPTFT UgFNTVBTGJOBMJEBEFTBPCSBEFBSUFnFYQSFTTJWB PPCKFUP UnDOJDP BJOEBRVFCFMP nGVODJPOBM&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT OPT PCKFUPTUnDOJDPTOBTDJEPTEPEFTJHOPTNBUFSJBJTFBTGPSNBT FTUkPTVCPSEJOBEPThGVOmkPRVFEFWFNQSFFODIFS VNBDB EFJSBEFWFTFSDPOGPSUgWFMQBSBTFOUBSVNBDBOFUB BEFRVBEB QBSBFTDSFWFSVNBVUPNwWFM BEFRVBEPQBSBBMPDPNPmkP VNBHFMBEFJSB BEFRVBEBQBSBBDPOTFSWBmkPEPTBMJNFOUPT VNBMVNJOgSJB BEFRVBEBQBSBBEJTUSJCVJmkPPVDPODFOUSB mkPEFMV[ FUD %BPCSBEFBSUF QPSnN OkPTFFTQFSBOFNTF
FYJHFGVODJPOBMJEBEF IBWFOEPOFMBQMFOBMJCFSEBEFQBSBMJEBS DPNGPSNBTFNBUFSJBJT DPSFTFNPWJNFOUPT TPOTFHFTUPT TJMpODJPTFQBMBWSBTEPTRVBJTTFFTQFSBRVFFYQSJNBNTJHOJ GJDBm{FTFWFSEBEFT FDVKBCFMF[BEFDPSSFKVTUBNFOUFEFTFV QPEFSFYQSFTTJWP 0RVF#FOKBNJOFOUFOEFQPS²BVSB³ 1BSB #FOKBNJO BVSB n B BCTPMVUB TJOHVMBSJEBEF EF VN TFS±OBUVSBMPVBSUrTUJDP± TVBDPOEJmkPEFFYFNQMBS|OJDP RVFTFPGFSFDFOVNBRVJFBHPSB²JSSFQFUrWFM³ TVBRVBMJEBEF EFFUFSOJEBEFFGVHBDJEBEFTJNVMUiOFBT TFVQFSUFODJNFOUP OFDFTTgSJPBPDPOUFYUPFNRVFTFFODPOUSBFTVBQBSUJDJQBmkP OVNBUSBEJmkPRVFMIFEgTFOUJEPc OPDBTPEBPCSBEFBSUF TVBBVUFOUJDJEBEF JTUPn PWrODVMPJOUFSOPFOUSFTVBVOJEBEF FTVBEVSBCJMJEBEF 2VBOEPVNBPCSBEFBSUFnBVSgUJDB "PCSBEFBSUFQPTTVJBVSBPVnBVSgUJDBRVBOEPQPTTVJBT TFHVJOUFTRVBMJEBEFTn|OJDB VOB JSSFQFUrWFM EVSBEPVSBF FGpNFSB OPWBFQBSUJDJQBOUFEFVNBUSBEJmkP DBQB[EFUPSOBS EJTUBOUFPRVFFTUgQFSUPFFTUSBOIPPRVFQBSFDJBGBNJMJBSQPS RVFUSBOTGJHVSBBSFBMJEBEF 2VBOEPFQPSRVFBTPCSBTEFBSUFQFSEFSBNBBVSB 4FHVOEP8BMUFS#FOKBNJO ²nGgDJMJEFOUJGJDBSPTGBUPSFT TPDJBJTFTQFDrGJDPTRVFDPOEJDJPOBNPEFDMrOJPBUVBMEBBVSB &MFEFSJWBEFEVBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT FTUSFJUBNFOUFMJHBEBThDSFT DFOUFEJGVTkPFJOUFOTJEBEFEPTNPWJNFOUPTEFNBTTBT'B[FS BTDPJTBT´GJDBSFNNBJTQSwYJNBTμnVNBQSFPDVQBmkPUkPBQBJ YPOBEBEBTNBTTBTNPEFSOBTDPNPTVBUFOEpODJBBTVQFSBSP DBSgUFS|OJDPEFUPEPTPTGBUPTBUSBWnTEBTVBSFQSPEVUJCJMJEB EF$BEBEJBGJDBNBJTJSSFTJTUrWFMBOFDFTTJEBEFEFQPTTVJSP PCKFUP UkPQFSUPRVBOUPQPTTrWFM FNJNBHFN PVBOUFT OBTVB DwQJB OBTVBSFQSPEVmkP$BEBEJBGJDBNBJTOrUJEBBEJGFSFOmB FOUSFBSFQSPEVmkP DPNPFMBOPTnPGFSFDJEBQFMBTSFWJTUBTJMVT USBEBTFQFMPTEPDVNFOUgSJPTDJOFNBUPHSgGJDPT FBJNBHFN /FTUB BVOJEBEFFBEVSBCJMJEBEFTFBTTPDJBNUkPJOUJNBNFOUF DPNP OBSFQSPEVmkP BUSBOTJUPSJFEBEFFBSFQFUJCJMJEBEF3F UJSBSPPCKFUPEPTFVJOWwMVDSP EFTUSVJSTVBBVSB nBDBSBDUFSrT UJDBEFVNBGPSNBEFQFSDFQmkPDVKBDBQBDJEBEFEFDBQUBS´P TFNFMIBOUFOPNVOEPμnUkPBHVEBRVF HSBmBThSFQSPEVmkP FMBDPOTFHVFDBQUgMPBUnOPGFOyNFOP|OJDP³ "BSUF QBSB#FOKBNJO TFNQSFGPJSFQSPEVUrWFM CBTUBOEP WFSEJTDrQVMPTJNJUBOEPPTNFTUSFT"RVFTUkPOkPFTUgOPGBUP EBSFQSPEVmkP FTJNOBOPWBNPEBMJEBEFEFSFQSPEV[JSBSF QSPEVmkPUnDOJDB RVFQFSNJUFBFYJTUpODJBEPPCKFUPBSUrTUJDP FNTnSJFFRVF FNDFSUPTDBTPT DPNPOBGPUPHSBGJB OPEJTDP FOPDJOFNB UPSOBJNQPTTrWFMEJTUJOHVJSPSJHJOBMEFDwQJB JTUP n EFTGB[FOEPBTQSwQSJBTJEFJBTEFPSJHJOBMFDwQJBcOFTTF TFOUJEPRVFTFGBMBFNQFSEBEBBVSB& TFOEPBTTJN USBUBTF EFVNGFOyNFOPRVFTFJOJDJPVDPNBTJOWFOm{FTEPTEJTQPTJ UJWPTEFSFQSPEVUJCJMJEBEF RVFUFWFJOrDJPDPN(VUFOCFSHFTF BDFOUVPVOPTnDVMP99 3FTVNBBTQSJODJQBJTJEFJBTEF#FOKBNJOTPCSFPWBMPSEF DVMUPFPWBMPSEFFYQPTJmkPEBTPCSBTEFBSUF "EFTUSVJmkPEBBVSBFTUgQSFGJHVSBEBOBQSwQSJBFTTpODJB EBPCSBEFBSUFDPNPBMHPQPTTrWFMQPSRVFFMBQPTTVJEPJTWB MPSFTPEFDVMUPFPEFFYQPTJmkP0WBMPSEFFYQPTJmkPTVTDJ UBBSFQSPEVUJCJMJEBEFRVBOEPBTDPOEJm{FTTwDJPIJTUwSJDBTB FYJHJSFNFBQPTTJCJMJUBSFNBSFQSPEVmkPBSUrTUJDBDPNFmBDPN JNBHFOTBTFSWJmPEBNBHJB±PRVFJNQPSUB OFTTBTJNBHFOT
20
Manual do Professor
nRVFFYJTUBN FOkPRVFTFKBNWJTUBT0WBMPSEFDVMUPRVBTF PCSJHBBNBOUFSTFDSFUBTBTPCSBTEFBSUFTDFSUBTFTUgUVBTEJWJ OBTTPNFOUFTkPBDFTTrWFJTBPTVNPTBDFSEPUF«NFEJEBRVF BTPCSBTEFBSUFTFFNBODJQBNEPTFVVTPSJUVBM BVNFOUBNBT PDBTJ{FTQBSBRVFTFKBNFYQPTUBT"FYQPOJCJMJEBEFEFVNCVT UP RVFQPEFTFSEFTMPDBEPEFVNMVHBSQBSBPVUSP nNBJPSRVF BEFVNBFTUgUVBEJWJOB RVFUFNTVBTFEFGJYBOPJOUFSJPSEFVN UFNQMP"FYQPOJCJMJEBEFEFVNRVBESPnNBJPSRVFBEFVNNP TBJDPPVEFVNBGSFTDP RVFPQSFDFEFSBN&TFBFYQPOJCJMJEBEF EFVNBNJTTB QPSTVBQSwQSJBOBUVSF[B OkPFSBUBMWF[NFOPS RVFBEFVNBTJOGPOJB FTUBTVSHJVOVNNPNFOUPFNRVFTVB FYQPOJCJMJEBEFQSPNFUJBTFSNBJPSRVFBEBNJTTB"FYQPOJCJ MJEBEFEFVNBPCSBEFBSUFDSFTDFVFNUBMFTDBMB DPNPTWgSJPT NnUPEPTEFTVBSFQSPEVUJCJMJEBEFUnDOJDB RVFBNVEBOmBEF pOGBTFEFVNQPMPQBSBPVUSPDPSSFTQPOEFBVNBNVEBOmBRVB MJUBUJWBDPNQBSgWFMhRVFPDPSSFVOBQSnIJTUwSJB$PNFGFJUP BTTJNDPNPOBQSnIJTUwSJBBQSFQPOEFSiODJBBCTPMVUBEPWBMPS EFDVMUPDPOGFSJEPhPCSBMFWPVBBTFSDPODFCJEBFNQSJNFJSP MVHBSDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPNgHJDP FTwNBJTUBSEFDPNPPCSBEF BSUF EPNFTNPNPEPBQSFQPOEFSiODJBBCTPMVUBDPOGFSJEBIPKF BTFVWBMPSEFFYQPTJmkPBUSJCVJMIFGVOm{FTJOUFJSBNFOUFOPWBT FOUSFBTRVBJTB²BSUrTUJDB³ B|OJDBEFRVFUFNPTDPOTDJpODJB F RVFUBMWF[TFSFWFMFGVUVSBNFOUFDPNPTFDVOEgSJB 0RVFnBBSUFQPnUJDB 1PSRVFnQSFTDSJUJWBPVOPSNBUJ WB "SUFQPnUJDBnPOPNFEFVNBPCSBBSJTUPUnMJDBTPCSFBTBS UFTEBQBMBWSBGBMBEBFFTDSJUB EPDBOUPFEBEBOmBBQPFTJBF PUFBUSP USBHnEJBFDPNnEJB 0WPDgCVMPQPnUJDBnBUSBEVmkP QBSBQwJFTJT QPSUBOUP QBSB²GBCSJDBmkP³"BSUFQPnUJDBFTUV EBBTPCSBTEFBSUFDPNPGBCSJDBmkPEFTFSFT Bm{FTFHFTUPT BSUJGJDJBJT JTUPn QSPEV[JEPTQFMPTBSUrGJDFTPVBSUJTUBT0VTFKB BGrTJDBFTUVEBPTTFSFTFBTBm{FTQSPEV[JEPTQFMBOBUVSF[BB QPnUJDB PTGBCSJDBEPTQFMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT 0RVFnFTUnUJDB 2VBOEPTVSHFSFMBDJPOBEBDPNBTBS UFT &TUnUJDBWFNEPHSFHPBFTUIFTJT RVFTJHOJGJDB²DPOIFDJ NFOUPTFOTPSJBM FYQFSJpODJBTFOTrWFM TFOTJCJMJEBEF³'PJFN QSFHBEBQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[QBSBSFGFSJSTFhTBSUFTQFMPBMFNkP #BVNHBSUFO QPSWPMUBEF QPSUBOUPFNQMFOBNPEFSOJ EBEF 2 VBM P TFOUJEP JOJDJBM EB FTUnUJDB 2VBM TFV TFOUJEP BUVBM &NTFVVTPJOJDJBM BFTUnUJDBTFSFGFSJBBPFTUVEPEBTPCSBT EFBSUFFORVBOUPDSJBm{FTEBTFOTJCJMJEBEF JTUPn EBTFYQF SJpODJBTEPTDJODPTFOUJEPTFEPTTFOUJNFOUPTDBVTBEPTQPS FMBT
UFOEPDPNPGJOBMJEBEFPCFMP1PVDPBQPVDP TVCTUJUVJV BOPmkPEFBSUFQPnUJDBFQBTTPVBEFTJHOBSUPEBJOWFTUJHBmkP GJMPTwGJDBRVFUFOIBQPSPCKFUPBTBSUFTPVVNBBSUF%PMBEPEP BSUJTUBFEBPCSB BFTUnUJDBCVTDBDPNQSFFOEFSDPNPTFEgB SFBMJ[BmkPEBCFMF[BEPMBEPEPFTQFDUBEPSFSFDFQUPS CVTDB JOUFSQSFUBSBSFBmkPhPCSBEFBSUFTPCBGPSNBEPKVr[PEFHPTUP PVEPCPNHPTUP $PNP-VD'FSSZFYQMJDBPTVSHJNFOUPEBFTUnUJDBDPNPEJT DJQMJOBGJMPTwGJDB 1BSB-VD'FSSZ ²POBTDJNFOUPEBFTUnUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOB GJMPTwGJDBFTUgJOEJTTPMVWFMNFOUFMJHBEPhNVUBmkPSBEJDBMRVF JOUFSWnNOBSFQSFTFOUBmkPEPCFMPRVBOEPFTUFnQFOTBEPFN UFSNPTEFHPTUPQPSUBOUP BQBSUJSEPRVFOPIPNFNWBJMP
21
HPBQBSFDFSDPNPBFTTpODJBNFTNBEBTVCKFUJWJEBEF DPNP PNBJTTVCKFUJWPEPTVKFJUP$PNPDPODFJUPEFHPTUP FGFUJWB NFOUF PCFMPnMJHBEPUkPJOUJNBNFOUFhTVCKFUJWJEBEFIVNB OBRVFTFEFGJOF OPMJNJUF QFMPQSB[FSRVFQSPQPSDJPOB QFMBT TFOTBm{FTPVQFMPTTFOUJNFOUPTRVFTVTDJUBFNOwT $PN POBTDJNFOUPEPHPTUP BBOUJHBGJMPTPGJBEBBSUFEFWF QPSUBOUP DFEFSMVHBSBVNBUFPSJBEBTFOTJCJMJEBEF³ 2VBJTFSBNPTQSJODJQBJTQSFTTVQPTUPTEBFTUnUJDBOPTTn DVMPT97***F9*9 %PTTFJTQSFTTVQPTUPTFOVNFSBEPT FT DPMIBEPJTFFYQMJRVFPT "BSUFnVNBBUJWJEBEFIVNBOBBVUyOPNB JTUPn OkP FTUgBTFSWJmPEBSFMJHJkPOFNEBQPMrUJDB NBTQPTTVJGJOB MJEBEFQSwQSJB "BSUFnQSPEVUPEBFYQFSJpODJBTFOTPSJBM PVQFSDFQUJWB EBJNBHJOBmkPFEBJOTQJSBmkPEPBSUJTUBDPNP DSJBEPSBVUyOPNPPVMJWSF "GJOBMJEBEFEBBSUFnEFTJOUFSFT TBEBPVDPOUFNQMBUJWB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BPCSBEFBSUFOkP FTUgBTFSWJmPEPDVMUP OFNEBQPMrUJDB OFNEBQSgUJDBNPSBM EBTWJSUVEFT BTTJNDPNPOkPFTUgEFTUJOBEBBQSPEV[JSPC KFUPTEFVTPFEFDPOTVNP FTJNBQSPQJDJBSBDPOUFNQMBmkP EBCFMF[B "DPOUFNQMBmkP EPMBEPEPBSUJTUB nBCVTDBEP CFMP FOkPEP|UJM OFNEPBHSBEgWFM F EPMBEPEPQ|CMJDP n BBWBMJBmkPPVPKVMHBNFOUPEPWBMPSEFCFMF[BBUJOHJEPQFMB PCSB QPSNFJPEPKVr[PEFHPTUP 0CFMPnEJGFSFOUFEPCPN FEPWFSEBEFJSP0CFNnPCKFUPEBnUJDBBWFSEBEF PCKFUP EBDJpODJBFEBNFUBGrTJDBFBCFMF[B PPCKFUPQSwQSJPEBFT UnUJDB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT DPOUSBBUSBEJmkPBSJTUPUnMJDB RVF EBWBVNBGJOBMJEBEFNPSBMhTPCSBTEFBSUF BSUJDVMBOEPBTh JEFJBEPCFNFEBWJSUVEF FDPOUSBBUSBEJmkPQMBUyOJDB RVF EBWBVNBGJOBMJEBEFDPHOJUJWBhTBSUFT BSUJDVMBOEPBThJEFJB EBWFSEBEF
BFTUnUJDBBGJSNBBBVUPOPNJBEBTBSUFTQFMBEJT UJOmkPFOUSFCFMF[B CPOEBEFFWFSEBEF $PNPBPCSBEF BSUFOBTDFEBTFOTJCJMJEBEFJOTQJSBEBEPBSUJTUBOBDPOEJmkP EFTVCKFUJWJEBEFDSJBEPSBFMJWSF TFVWBMPSFODPOUSBTFOkPTw OBGPSmBEFTVBCFMF[B NBTUBNCnNFNTVBPSJHJOBMJEBEF&N PVUSBTQBMBWSBT PBSUJTUBWFSEBEFJSPOkPnBRVFMFRVFTFHVF SFHSBTPVQSFDFJUPTGJYBEPTQFMBUSBEJmkPEFTFVPGrDJP OFN BRVFMFRVFUSBEV[FNQBMBWSBT DPSFT GPSNBT HFTUPT NPWJ NFOUPT WPMVNFT NBTTBT USBmPTBMHPKgFYJTUFOUFOBOBUVSF[B PVFNTVBTPDJFEBEF NBTBRVFMFRVFnDBQB[EFVNBDSJBmkP JOnEJUBPVPSJHJOBM 0RVFTJHOJGJDBWBBEJTUJOmkPRVFBFTUnUJDBFTUBCFMFDFV FOUSFPCFMPFPWFSEBEFJSP 4JHOJGJDBRVFPKVr[PFTUnUJDPFPKVr[PDJFOUrGJDPFNFUBGrTJDP TkPEJGFSFOUFT%FGBUP PWFSEBEFJSPnPRVFnDPOIFDJEPQFMPJO UFMFDUPQPSNFJPEFEFNPOTUSBm{FTFQSPWBT BTRVBJTQFSNJUFN QPSNFJPEFDPODFJUPTEPFOUFOEJNFOUPFMFJTMwHJDBT JOGFSJSVN QBSUJDVMBSEFVNVOJWFSTBM EFEVmkP PVJOGFSJSVNVOJWFSTBMEF WgSJPTQBSUJDVMBSFT JOEVmkP 0CFMP BPDPOUSgSJP UFNBQFDVMJB SJEBEFEFQPTTVJSJNFEJBUBNFOUF TFNEFEVmkPFTFNJOEVmkP VNWBMPSVOJWFSTBM FNCPSBBPCSBEFBSUFTFKBFTTFODJBMNFOUF QBSUJDVMBS 0RVFnPKVr[PEFHPTUP "QFDVMJBSJEBEFEPKVr[PEFHPTUPFTUgFNQSPGFSJSVNKVMHB NFOUPEFWBMPSVOJWFSTBMUFOEPDPNPPCKFUPBMHPTJOHVMBSFQBS UJDVMBS0USBUBNFOUPNBJTJNQPSUBOUFEPKVr[PEFHPTUPGPJGFJUP QPS,BOUOVNBPCSBJOUJUVMBEB$SrUJDBEBGBDVMEBEFEFKVMHBS /FTTFFTUVEPPGJMwTPGPDPNFmBEJTDVUJOEPPQSPCMFNBQPTUP QFMPHPTUP JTUPn DPNP²DBEBVNUFNTFVHPTUP³F²HPTUPOkP TFEJTDVUF³ BUPUBMTVCKFUJWJEBEFEPHPTUPOkPQPEFSJBTFSWJS EFDSJUnSJPQBSBPKVMHBNFOUPEBTPCSBTEFBSUFT QPJTUBOUPP
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
HPTUPEPBSUJTUBnJOEJWJEVBMFJODPNQBSgWFMDPNPPTHPTUPTEP Q|CMJDPTkPJOEJWJEVBJTFJODPNQBSgWFJT$PNP QPSUBOUP GBMBS OPKVr[PEFHPTUPDPNPBWBMJBEPSEBTPCSBTEFBSUF &NPVUSBT QBMBWSBT DPNPEBSVOJWFSTBMJEBEFBFTTFKVr[P &NBJTDPNP EBSMIFVOJWFSTBMJEBEFTFNSFDPSSFSBPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTMwHJDPT FDJFOUrGJDPTEFEFNPOTUSBm{FTFQSPWBT 2VBMBEJTUJOmkPGFJUBQPS,BOUFOUSFEJTQVUBFEJTDVTTkP 1PSRVFPHPTUPFBPCSBEFBSUFQPEFNTFSEJTDVUJEPT ,BOUJOUSPEV[VNBNgYJNB²cQPTTrWFMEJTDVUJSPHPTUP³ 6NBEJTDVTTkPnEJGFSFOUFEFVNBEJTQVUB'JMPTPGJDBNFOUF VNBEJTQVUBnVNBCBUBMIBEFBSHVNFOUPTRVFFYJHFNQSP WBT EFNPOTUSBm{FTFFWJEpODJBTBGJNEFRVFVNBPQJOJkP PVVNBJEFJBQSFWBMFmBTPCSFBTRVFMIFTkPDPOUSgSJBT6NB EJTDVTTkPnVNQSPDFTTPEFBGJOBNFOUPEBTPQJOJ{FTDVKBGJ OBMJEBEFnDIFHBSBVNBDPSEPFOUSFBTQBSUFT"TTJN OkPTF EJTQVUBTPCSFPCFMP NBTQPEFTFEJTDVUJMP&TTBEJTDVTTkPn VNBSFGMFYkPDPNBGJOBMJEBEFEFTFDIFHBSBVNKVr[PFTUnUJDP DPNQBSUJMIBEPQPSUPEPT 1PSRVF BPBGJSNBSRVFPTFOUJNFOUPEPCFMPnVOJWFSTBM ,BOUNPTUSBRVFPKVr[PEFHPTUPnQPTTrWFM "TTJNDPNPPFTQBmPFPUFNQPTkPBTGPSNBTVOJWFSTBJTEB TFOTJCJMJEBEFFBTDBUFHPSJBTFPTDPODFJUPTTkPPTVOJWFSTBJT EPFOUFOEJNFOUP BCFMF[BnVNBJEFJBVOJWFSTBMEBSB[kP4FV DPOUF|EPFTVBGPSNBQPEFNWBSJBSTFHVOEPBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT IJTUwSJDBTFTFHVOEPBJOTQJSBmkPFTFOTJCJMJEBEFTVCKFUJWBTEP BSUJTUB NBTPTFOUJNFOUPEPCFMP GVOEBNFOUPEPKVr[PEFHPT UP nVOJWFSTBMQPSRVFBCFMF[BnVNBJEFJBEBSB[kP &YQMJRVFDPNPBPCSBEFBSUFnQFOTBEBOBTPDJFEBEFDPO UFNQPSiOFBNFOPTDPNPQSPEVmkPFDPOUFNQMBmkPEFTJO UFSFTTBEBEBCFMF[BFNBJTDPNPUSBCBMIPEBFYQSFTTkP %FGBUP BTBSUFTEFJYBSBNEFTFSQFOTBEBTQFMBGJMPTPGJB FQFMBDSrUJDBEFBSUFFYDMVTJWBNFOUFEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEBQSP EVmkPFDPOUFNQMBmkPEFTJOUFSFTTBEBTEBCFMF[BQBSBTFSFN WJTUBTTPCPVUSBTQFSTQFDUJWBT UBJTDPNPFYQSFTTkPEFFNP m{FTFEFTFKPT JOUFSQSFUBmkPFDSrUJDBEBSFBMJEBEFTPDJBM BUJ WJEBEFJOWFOUPSBEFQSPDFEJNFOUPTJOnEJUPTQBSBBDPOTUSVmkP EFPCKFUPTBSUrTUJDPT FUD&TTBNVEBOmBGF[DPNRVFBTJEFJBT EFCPNHPTUPFEFCFMF[BQFSEFTTFNPQSJWJMnHJPFTUnUJDPFRVF BFTUnUJDBTFBQSPYJNBTTFDBEBWF[NBJTEBJEFJBEFQPnUJDB QPSUBOUP EBBSUFDPNPUSBCBMIP FOkPDPNPDPOUFNQMBmkPF TFOTJCJMJEBEF GBOUBTJBFJMVTkP &YQMJRVFPRVF"SJTUwUFMFTFOUFOEJBQPSNrNFTJT1PSRVF BPCSBEFBSUFFSBVNBNrNFTJT 1BSB "SJTUwUFMFT JNJUBS OkP TJHOJGJDB DPNP TJHOJGJDBWB QBSB1MBUkP DPQJBS NBTSFQSFTFOUBSBSFBMJEBEFQPSNFJPEB GBOUBTJBFEBPCFEJpODJBBSFHSBTFQSFDFJUPTQBSBRVFBPCSB GJHVSFBMHVNTFS OBUVSBMPVTPCSFOBUVSBM
BMHVNTFOUJNFOUP PVFNPmkP BMHVNGBUP BDPOUFDJEPPVJOWFOUBEP )BSNPOJBF QSPQPSmkPEBTGPSNBT EPTSJUNPT EBTDPSFT EBTQBMBWSBTPV EPTTPOTPGFSFDFNPTNFJPTOFDFTTgSJPTQBSBRVFBGJOBMJEBEF TFKBBMDBOmBEB EFTEFRVFPBSUJTUBTJHBBTOPSNBT BTSFHSBT PTQSPDFEJNFOUPTFQSFDFJUPTEFTFVPGrDJP/BTBSUFT JNJUBS FYQMJDB"SJTUwUFMFT nTJNVMBS.BTBTJNVMBmkPTwnBSUrTUJDBTF GPSTFOUJEBFQFSDFCJEBDPNPSFQSFTFOUBOEPBMHPSFBM 2VBOEPBGJMPTPGJBQBTTPVBEFGJOJSBPCSBEFBSUFDPNP DSJBmkPTVCKFUJWB 2VBOEPQBTTPVBGBMBSFNJOTQJSBmkP
"EFGJOJmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBEBBSUFDPNPBmkPEFJNJUBSBOB UVSF[BGPJDPOTFSWBEBEVSBOUFTnDVMPT PVTFKB BUnPTVSHJ NFOUPEP3PNBOUJTNP OPGJOBMEPTnDVMP97***FJOrDJPEPTnDVMP 9*9"QBSUJSEP3PNBOUJTNP BGJMPTPGJBQBTTBBEFGJOJSBPCSBEF BSUFDPNPDSJBmkPTVCKFUJWB&ORVBOUPOBDPODFQmkPBOUFSJPS PVDPODFQmkPQPnUJDB OPTFOUJEPEFQwJFTJT JTUPn EPGB[FS PVEPGBCSJDBS
PWBMPSEBPCSBFODPOUSBWBTFOBDPSSFmkPEP BSUJTUBFNTFHVJSPTQSFDFJUPTFOBRVBMJEBEFPVEJHOJEBEFEP PCKFUPQSPEV[JEP OBDPODFQmkPFTUnUJDBPWBMPSnDPMPDBEPOB GJHVSBEPBSUJTUBDPNPHpOJPFJNBHJOBmkPDSJBEPSB&NMVHBSEF JNJUBmkP QBTTBTFBGBMBSFNJOTQJSBmkP 2VBOEPBFTUnUJDBTFSFGFSJBhPCSBEFBSUFDPNPDSJBmkP WJOEBEBJOTQJSBmkP DPNPWJBPBSUJTUB 0BSUJTUBFSBWJTUPDPNPVN²FV³ JTUPn DPNPJOUFSJPSJEB EFFTVCKFUJWJEBEFFTQFDJBJTRVFOBTDFNDPNBEJTQPTJmkPFY USBPSEJOgSJBQBSBSFDFCFSVNBFTQnDJFEFTPQSPTPCSFOBUVSBM RVFPJNQFMFBDSJBSBPCSB &YQMJRVFDPNP QBSBBFTUnUJDB BPCSBEFBSUFEFJYBEFTFS WJTUBDPNPJNJUBmkPEBOBUVSF[BFQBTTBBTFSWJTUBDPNP MJCFSBmkPEJBOUFEBOBUVSF[B 1FMBBUJWJEBEFMJWSFEPBSUJTUB JTUPn QPSNFJPEFTVBGBOUB TJBDSJBEPSB PTIPNFOTTFJHVBMBNhBmkPDSJBEPSBEF%FVT&T TBDPODFQmkPEBBSUFDPNPJOTQJSBmkPFDPNPDSJBmkPFTQJSJUVBM RVFMJCFSBPIPNFNEPQFTPEBOBUVSF[BnDPOUFNQPSiOFB OB GJMPTPGJB BPNPNFOUPFNRVFTFEgBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFIPNFN FOBUVSF[BDPNPOBTDJNFOUPEBJEFJBEFDVMUVSBc QPSUBOUP DPOUFNQPSiOFBhJEFJBLBOUJBOBEFEJGFSFOmBFOUSFPSFJOPOBUV SBMEBDBVTBMJEBEFOFDFTTgSJBFPSFJOPIVNBOPEBMJCFSEBEFF EPTGJOT FhJEFJBIFHFMJBOBEPFTQrSJUPDPNPDVMUVSBFIJTUwSJB DPNPJOUFSJPSJEBEFFNPQPTJmkPhFYUFSJPSJEBEFFhDBVTBMJEBEF OFDFTTgSJBEBOBUVSF[B 2VFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFQBSBBGJMPTPGJBEBBSUFDPOUFNQP SiOFBBBSUFnDPODFCJEBDPNPUSBCBMIPEBFYQSFTTkPF DPOTUSVmkP 4JHOJGJDBRVFBPCSBEFBSUFOkPnQVSBDSJBUJWJEBEFFTQJ SJUVBMFTQPOUiOFBFMJWSF NBTVNUSBCBMIPQBSBBFYQSFTTkP EFVNTFOUJEPOPWP FTDPOEJEPOPNVOEP FVNQSPDFTTPEF DPOTUSVmkPEPPCKFUPBSUrTUJDP FNRVFPBSUJTUBDPMBCPSBDPNB OBUVSF[B PVMVUBDPNFMBFDPOUSBFMB TFQBSBTFEFMBPVWPMUB BFMB WFODFBSFTJTUpODJBEFMBPVEPCSBTFhTFYJHpODJBTEFMB "BSUFnUSBCBMIPEBFYQSFTTkPRVFDPOTUSwJVNTFOUJEPOPWP B PCSB FPJOTUJUVJDPNPQBSUFEBDVMUVSB $PNPBFTUnUJDBDPOUFNQPSiOFBDPODFCFPBSUJTUB 0BSUJTUBOkPnVNHpOJPTPMJUgSJPFFYDFQDJPOBM NBTVN TFSTPDJBMRVFCVTDBFYQSJNJSTFVNPEPEFFTUBSOPNVOEPOB DPNQBOIJBEPTPVUSPTTFSFTIVNBOPT OVNFNCBUFDPOUrOVP DPNBOBUVSF[B DPNBTPDJFEBEFFDPOTJHPNFTNPcBMHVnN RVF BMnNEFWPMUBSTFQBSBTJNFTNPQBSBDPNQSFFOEFSTF QPSNFJPEBPCSBRVFFYQSJNFTFVUSBCBMIPEFDPNQSFFOTkP UBNCnNSFGMFUFTPCSFBTPDJFEBEF FQPSNFJPEBPCSBWPMUBTF QBSBPTPDJBM TFKBQBSBDSJUJDgMP TFKBQBSBBGJSNgMP TFKBQBSB TVQFSgMP &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBFTUnUJDBDPOUFNQPSiOFBTVCMJOIBBPCSB EFBSUFDPNPGJDmkP "QBMBWSBGJDmkPWFNEPWFSCPMBUJOP GJOHFSF RVFTJHOJGJDB ²FTDVMQJS QJOUBS DPNQPSVNBPCSB SFQSFTFOUBS BSSVNBSPVBS SBOKBSBTDPJTBT JNBHJOBS NBRVJOBS GPSKBS³F QPSFYUFOTkP
22
Manual do Professor
²EJTGBSmBS EJTTJNVMBS FODPCSJSFGJOHJS³$PNPTFPCTFSWB P TFOUJEPQSJNFJSPEFTTBQBMBWSBFTUgEJSFUBNFOUFSFGFSJEPhTBS UFTFTUBTTkPVNGJOHJNFOUP OkPOPTFOUJEPEFVNBNFOUJSBPV EFVNBJMVTkP FTJNOPTFOUJEPEFPGFSFDFSVNBPVUSBSFBMJEBEF JOFYJTUFOUFOPNVOEPEBEP DPNPVNBFTUgUVB VNRVBESPPV VNQPFNB 1BSUJOEPEBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFNVOEPTFOTrWFMFJOUFMJHrWFMF FOUSFBSUFTJNJUBUJWBTFKVEJDBUJWBT DPNP1MBUkPDPODFCF BSFMBmkPFOUSFBSUFFTBCFS "DPODFQmkPQMBUyOJDB RVFTPGSFSgBMUFSBm{FTOPDVSTPEB IJTUwSJBTPDJPDVMUVSBMEPPDJEFOUFFVSPQFV DPOTJEFSBBBSUF VNBGPSNBEPDPOIFDJNFOUPIVNBOPF QPSUBOUP SFMBDJPOBEB DPNBWFSEBEF 1PSRVFBDPODFQmkPQMBUyOJDBnSFUPNBEBFSFGPSNVMBEB EVSBOUFB3FOBTDFOmB 1PSRVFTFBGJSNB BHPSB RVFNFTNPBTBSUFTJNJUBUJWBT QBSUJDVMBSNFOUFBQJOUVSB BFTDVMUVSBFBQPFTJB TkP KVO UBNFOUFDPNBTBSUFTKVEJDBUJWBTFEJTQPTJUJWBT VNBEBTGPS NBTBMUBTEFBDFTTPBPDPOIFDJNFOUPWFSEBEFJSPFhTDPJTBT EJWJOBT GJDBOEPBCBJYPBQFOBTEBGJMPTPGJBFEPpYUBTFNrTUJDP &TTBNVEBOmBTFEFWFBPGBUPEFRVF EVSBOUFPTTnDVMPT97 F97* PTQMBUyOJDPTEB3FOBTDFOmBSFEFTDPCSJSBNPTFTDSJUPT IFSNnUJDPTFEFNBHJBOBUVSBM BUSJCVrEPT FRVJWPDBEBNFOUF BPTBOUJHPTFHrQDJPT DVKBTBCFEPSJBGPJFMPHJBEBQPS1MBUkPFN WgSJPTEFTFVTEJgMPHPT0SB OFTTFTFTDSJUPTnBGJSNBEPRVF %FVTDSJPVPIPNFNEBOEPMIFBDBQBDJEBEFEFDSJBSOPWPT NVOEPT QPSRVFMIFEFVBDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOIFDFSBTGPSNBT TFDSFUBTFJOWJTrWFJTEBTDPJTBT JTUPn TVBTFTTpODJBTPVJEFJBT QVSBT0BDFTTPBFTTBTGPSNBTnDPOTFHVJEPQPSNFJPEBTBSUFT FFTUBTTkP QPSUBOUP PJOTUSVNFOUPQSJWJMFHJBEPQBSBQBTTBSEP DPOIFDJNFOUPTFOTrWFMBPDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFMJHrWFM DIFHBOEP hGJMPTPGJB 2VBJTBTUSpTNBOFJSBTQFMBTRVBJTP3PNBOUJTNPDPODFCF BBSUFDPNPPJOTUSVNFOUPHFSBMEBGJMPTPGJB
OBGPSNBmkPEPDPSQPFEBBMNB JTUPn EPDBSgUFSEBTDSJBO mBTFEPTBEPMFTDFOUFT"TTJN PDSJUnSJPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPF PEBQFEBHPHJB PVGPSNBmkPEPDBSgUFS FYDMVFNEBDJEBEF QFSGFJUBUSpTEBTGVUVSBTCFMBTBSUFT QPFTJB QJOUVSBFFTDVM UVSB FDPOTFSWBNBQFOBTEVBTEFMBT N|TJDBFEBOmB 1PS TVBWF[ "SJTUwUFMFT OB"SUFQPnUJDB EFTFOWPMWFMPOHBNFOUF PQBQFMQFEBHwHJDPEBTBSUFT QBSUJDVMBSNFOUFBUSBHnEJB RVF TFHVOEPPGJMwTPGP UFNBGVOmkPEFQSPEV[JSBDBUBSTF JTUPn B QVSJGJDBmkPFTQJSJUVBMEPTFTQFDUBEPSFT DPNPWJEPTFBQBWPSB EPTDPNBG|SJB PIPSSPSFBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEBTQBJY{FTRVF NPWFNBTQFSTPOBHFOTUSgHJDBT"DPODFQmkPQFEBHwHJDBEB BSUFSFBQBSFDFFN,BOURVBOEPBGJSNBRVFBGVOmkPNBJTBMUB EBBSUFnQSPEV[JSPTFOUJNFOUPEPTVCMJNF JTUPn BFMFWBmkP FPBSSFCBUBNFOUPEFOPTTPFTQrSJUPEJBOUFEBCFMF[B5BNCnN )FHFMJOTJTUFOPQBQFMFEVDBUJWPEBBSUF"QFEBHPHJBBSUrTUJDB QBSBFMFTFFGFUVBTPCEVBTNPEBMJEBEFTTVDFTTJWBTOBQSJ NFJSB BBSUFnPNFJPQBSBBFEVDBmkPNPSBMEBTPDJFEBEFOB TFHVOEB HSBmBThNBOFJSBDPNPEFTUSwJBCSVUBMJEBEFEBNB UnSJB JNQPOEPMIFBQVSF[BEBGPSNB FEVDBBTPDJFEBEFQBSB QBTTBSEPOBUVSBMFEPNBUFSJBMBPBSUrTUJDPF EFTUF hGPSNB NBJTBMUBEBSFMJHJkP BSFMJHJkPFTQJSJUVBMPVEBJOUFSJPSJEBEF 1BSB)FHFM BFTQJSJUVBMJ[BmkPQSPHSFTTJWBEBTBSUFT PVBQBT TBHFNEBQSFQPOEFSiODJBEBEBOmB EBQJOUVSBFEBFTDVMUVSB QBSBPQSFEPNrOJPEBN|TJDBFEBMJUFSBUVSB FYQSJNFPNPWJ NFOUPQFEBHwHJDPEFQBTTBHFNEBSFMJHJkPEBFYUFSJPSJEBEF PTEFVTFTFFTQrSJUPTFTUkPWJTrWFJTOBOBUVSF[BFTFGB[FN WJTrWFJTQPSTVBTSFQSFTFOUBm{FTOBTBSUFTQMgTUJDBT JTUPn QJOUVSBFFTDVMUVSB hSFMJHJkPEBJOUFSJPSJEBEF PTFSEJWJOPn P&TQrSJUP"CTPMVUP JTUPn BSB[kPFBWFSEBEF DVKBJNBUFSJB MJEBEFTFFYQSJNFBEFRVBEBNFOUFOBN|TJDBFOBMJUFSBUVSB 1PSFTUBCFMFDFSVNBSFMBmkPJOUSrOTFDBFOUSFBSUFFTPDJFEBEF PQFOTBNFOUPFTUnUJDPEFFTRVFSEBUBNCnNBUSJCVJGJOBMJEB EFQFEBHwHJDBhTBSUFT EBOEPMIFBUBSFGBEFDSrUJDBTPDJBMF QPMrUJDB JOUFSQSFUBmkPEPQSFTFOUFFJNBHJOBmkPEBTPDJFEBEF GVUVSB"BSUFEFWFTFSFOHBKBEBPVDPNQSPNFUJEB JTUPn FTUBS BTFSWJmPEBFNBODJQBmkPEPHpOFSPIVNBOP PGFSFDFOEPTF DPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEPFTGPSmPEFMJCFSUBmkP
1BSBBMHVOT BTBSUFTTkPB|OJDBWJBEFBDFTTPBPVOJWFSTBM FBPBCTPMVUPQBSBPVUSPT DPNP)FHFM BTBSUFTTkPBQSJNFJ SBFUBQBEBWJEBDPOTDJFOUFEPFTQrSJUP QSFQBSBOEPPBEWFOUP EBSFMJHJkPFEBGJMPTPGJBFPVUSPT FOGJN BTDPODFCFNDPNPP |OJDPDBNJOIPQBSBSFVOJSPTJOHVMBSFPVOJWFSTBM PQBSUJDVMBS FPHFSBM QPJT QPSNFJPEBTJOHVMBSJEBEFEFVNBPCSBBSUrTUJDB UFNPTBDFTTPBPTJHOJGJDBEPVOJWFSTBMEFBMHVNBSFBMJEBEF
1PSRVF1MBUkPFYDMVJEBDJEBEFQFSGFJUBBTBSUFTJNJUBUJ WBT
1BSUJOEPEBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFUFPSJBFQSgUJDB DPNP"SJTUwUF MFTDPODFCFBSFMBmkPFOUSFBSUFFTBCFS
0RVF"SJTUwUFMFTFOUFOEJBQPSDBUBSTF 2VBMTFVQBQFM nUJDP
"DPODFQmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBUPNBBBSUFDPNPBUJWJEBEFQSg UJDBIVNBOB
"QVSJGJDBmkPFTQJSJUVBMEPTFTQFDUBEPSFT DPNPWJEPTF BQBWPSBEPTDPNBG|SJB PIPSSPSFBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEBTQBJ Y{FTRVFNPWFNBTQFSTPOBHFOTUSgHJDBT
0RVFnBDPODFQmkPQFEBHwHJDBEBBSUF "DPODFQmkPQFEBHwHJDBFODPOUSBTVBQSJNFJSBGPSNVMB mkPFN1MBUkPF"SJTUwUFMFT/B3FQ|CMJDB FYQPOEPBQFEB HPHJBQBSBBDSJBmkPEBDJEBEFQFSGFJUB 1MBUkPFYDMVJEBQwMJT QFSGFJUBPTQSBUJDBOUFTEBTBSUFTJNJUBUJWBT JTUPn QPFUBT QJO UPSFTFFTDVMUPSFT QPSRVF DPNPWJNPT DPQJBNDwQJBT JTUP n JNJUBNBTDPJTBTTFOTrWFJTFPGFSFDFNVNBJNBHFNEFT SFTQFJUPTBEPEJWJOPFEBTDPJTBTEJWJOBT QPJTBQSFTFOUBNPT EFVTFTDPNPIVNBOPTFBSSFCBUBEPTQPSQBJY{FTIVNBOBT 5PEBWJB PGJMwTPGPDPMPDBUSpTBSUFTEJTQPTJUJWBT±BEBOmB B N|TJDBFBFTUSBUnHJB±FUSpTBSUFTKVEJDBUJWBT±BHSBNgUJDB BNBUFNgUJDBFBEJBMnUJDB±DPNPEJTDJQMJOBTGVOEBNFOUBJT
23
1PSRVF DPNPWJNPT DPQJBNDwQJBT JTUPn JNJUBNBTDPJ TBTTFOTrWFJTFPGFSFDFNVNBJNBHFNEFTSFTQFJUPTBEPEJWJOP FEBTDPJTBTEJWJOBT QPJTBQSFTFOUBNPTEFVTFTDPNPIVNB OPTFBSSFCBUBEPTQPSQBJY{FTIVNBOBT
$PNPBDPODFQmkPQFEBHwHJDBEBBSUFBQBSFDFFN,BOU /PNPNFOUPFNRVFBGJSNBRVFBGVOmkPNBJTBMUBEBBSUF nQSPEV[JSPTFOUJNFOUPEPTVCMJNF JTUPn BFMFWBmkPFPBSSF CBUBNFOUPEFOPTTPFTQrSJUPEJBOUFEBCFMF[B $PNP)FHFMBQSFTFOUBTVBDPODFQmkPQFEBHwHJDBEBBS UF 1BSB)FHFM BQFEBHPHJBBSUrTUJDBTFFGFUVBTPCEVBTNPEB MJEBEFTTVDFTTJWBTOBQSJNFJSB BBSUFnPNFJPQBSBBFEVDBmkP NPSBMEBTPDJFEBEFOBTFHVOEB HSBmBThNBOFJSBDPNPEFT USwJBCSVUBMJEBEFEBNBUnSJB JNQPOEPMIFBQVSF[BEBGPSNB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
FEVDBBTPDJFEBEFQBSBQBTTBSEPOBUVSBMFEPNBUFSJBMBPBSUrT UJDPF EFTUF hGPSNBNBJTBMUBEBSFMJHJkP BSFMJHJkPFTQJSJUVBM PVEBJOUFSJPSJEBEF1BSB)FHFM BFTQJSJUVBMJ[BmkPQSPHSFTTJWB EBTBSUFTFYQSJNFPNPWJNFOUPQFEBHwHJDPEFQBTTBHFNEB SFMJHJkPEBFYUFSJPSJEBEFhSFMJHJkPEBJOUFSJPSJEBEF 1PSRVFBTFTRVFSEBTDPODFCFNBTBSUFTEBOEPMIFTGJOB MJEBEFQFEBHwHJDB 1PSRVFFTUBCFMFDFNVNBSFMBmkPJOUSrOTFDBFOUSFBSUFF TPDJFEBEF EBOEPMIFBUBSFGBEFDSrUJDBTPDJBMFQPMrUJDB JOUFS QSFUBmkPEPQSFTFOUFFJNBHJOBmkPEBTPDJFEBEFGVUVSB"BSUF EFWFTFSFOHBKBEBPVDPNQSPNFUJEB JTUPn FTUBSBTFSWJmPEB FNBODJQBmkPEPHpOFSPIVNBOP PGFSFDFOEPTFDPNPJOTUSV NFOUPEPFTGPSmPEFMJCFSUBmkP 0RVFnBDPODFQmkPFYQSFTTJWBEBBSUF cBRVFMBOBRVBMBBSUFnDPODFCJEBDPNPFYQSFTTkP RVF USBOTGPSNBOVNGJNBRVJMPRVFQBSBBTPVUSBTBUJWJEBEFTIV NBOBTnVNNFJPcBTTJNRVFTFEJ[RVFBQJOUVSBFBFTDVMUV SBGB[FNWFSBWJTkP BMJUFSBUVSBGB[GBMBSBMJOHVBHFN BN|TJDB GB[PVWJSBBVEJmkP BEBOmBGB[TFOUJSPDPSQP0VTFKB QJOUVSB FFTDVMUVSBOPTFOTJOBNPRVFnWFSBN|TJDBOPTFOTJOBP RVFnPVWJSBEBOmBOPTFOTJOBPRVFnNPWFSTFFQPTTVJSVN DPSQPBMJUFSBUVSBOPTFOTJOBPRVFnBMJOHVBHFNFBTTJNQPS EJBOUF"BSUFnSFWFMBmkPFNBOJGFTUBmkPEBFTTpODJBEBSFB MJEBEF RVFFTUgBNPSUFDJEBFFTRVFDJEBFNOPTTBFYJTUpODJB DPUJEJBOB BTTJNDPNPFTUgSFEV[JEBBDPODFJUPTOBTDJpODJBT FOBGJMPTPGJB FUSBOTGPSNBEBFNJOTUSVNFOUPOBUnDOJDBFOB FDPOPNJB &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBBSUFDPODFCJEBDPNPFYQSFTTJWBnWJTUB DPNPTJNCwMJDB $PNPFYQSFTTkP BTBSUFTUSBOTGJHVSBNBSFBMJEBEFQBSB RVFUFOIBNPTBDFTTPWFSEBEFJSPBFMB%FTFRVJMJCSBPFTUB CFMFDJEPPVPJOTUJUVrEP EFTDFOUSBNPWJNFOUPT TPOT GPSNBT DPSFTFQBMBWSBT SFUJSBOEPPTEPDPOUFYUPDPTUVNFJSPQBSBGB [FSOPTDPOIFDpMPTOVNBPVUSBEJNFOTkP BEJNFOTkPDSJB EPSBPVJOTUJUVJOUFEPOPWP"BSUFJOWFOUBVNNVOEPEFDP SFT GPSNBT WPMVNFT NBTTBT TPOT HFTUPT UFYUVSBT SJUNPT NPWJNFOUPT QBMBWSBT QBSBOPTEBSBDPOIFDFSOPTTPQSwQSJP NVOEP1PSTFSFYQSFTTJWB nTJNCwMJDBFBMFHwSJDB"QBMBWSB TrNCPMPWFNEPHSFHPFTJHOJGJDB²PRVFVOF KVOUB TJOUFUJ[B OVNBVOJEBEFPTEJGFSFOUFT EBOEPMIFTVNTFOUJEP|OJDPF OPWPRVFOkPQPTTVrBNRVBOEPTFQBSBEPT³6NTrNCPMPnVN TJHOPPVVNTJOBMRVFQPTTVJVNBGBDFNBUFSJBM VNTPN VN USBmP VNBDPS FVNBGBDFJNBUFSJBMPVNFOUBM PTFOUJEP&N PVUSBTQBMBWSBT DPNPUPEPTJHOP PTrNCPMPnVNTJHOJGJDBOUF TFVBTQFDUPNBUFSJBM FVNTJHOJGJDBEP TFVBTQFDUPNFOUBM " QFDVMJBSJEBEFEPTrNCPMPFTUgOPGBUPEFRVFFMFnVNTJHOPEJ GFSFOUFEFPVUSPTQPSRVFVNTJHOPnVNTJOBMF QPSUBOUP nVNB JOEJDBmkPPVnJOEJDBUJWP EFOPUBUJWP
BQPOUBOEPEJSFUBNFOUF BDPJTBTJOBMJ[BEBPVJOEJDBEB NBTOPTrNCPMPOkPQSFEPNJOB PBTQFDUPJOEJDBUJWPFTJNBBGJSNBmkPEFVNTJHOJGJDBEPRVF VTBPTJOBMQBSBTJHOJGJDBSVNBDPJTBEJGFSFOUFEBRVFMBRVFTFSJB TJNQMFTNFOUFJOEJDBEB &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBBSUFDPODFCJEBDPNPFYQSFTTJWBnWJTUB DPNPBMFHwSJDB "QBMBWSBBMFHPSJBUBNCnNWFNEPHSFHPFTJHOJGJDB²PRVF FTUgOPMVHBSEFVNBPVUSBDPJTB³PV²PRVFBQSFTFOUBJOEJ SFUBNFOUFVNBDPJTBQPSNFJPEFVNBPVUSB³PV²PGBMBSEF VNBDPJTBQPSNFJPEFPVUSB³/FTUFBTQFDUP UPEBBMFHPSJBn
TJNCwMJDB VNBWF[RVFPTrNCPMPTFSFGFSFhTDPJTBTQPSNFJP EFPVUSBTRVF FNTJNFTNBT OkPJOEJDBNBDPJTB NBTBTJHOJ GJDBNPVBFYQSJNFN"EJGFSFOmBFOUSFBBMFHPSJBFPTrNCPMPn BQFOBTEFHSBV JTUPn BBMFHPSJBPQFSBDPNWgSJPTTrNCPMPTTJ NVMUiOFPT FOkPDPNVNBQFOBT6NFYFNQMPDMgTTJDPEFBMF HPSJBnBQFmBMJUFSgSJBDPOUJEBOB3FQ|CMJDBEF1MBUkPP.JUP PV"MFHPSJBEB$BWFSOB RVFWJNPTBPJOJDJBSFTUFMJWSP /FMBP GJMwTPGPOkPOBSSBVNBDPOUFDJNFOUPSFBMFTJNBMFHPSJ[BFTJN CPMJ[BPNPWJNFOUPEBBMNBIVNBOBQBTTBOEPEBTUSFWBTEB JHOPSiODJB BDBWFSOB hMV[EPDPOIFDJNFOUP hMV[EP4PM 6N PVUSPFYFNQMPEFBMFHPSJB UBNCnNGBNPTP nBDFOBEPGJMNF EF$IBSMFT$IBQMJO 5FNQPTNPEFSOPT OBRVBMPPQFSgSJPUFN TFVDPSQPFTFVTNPWJNFOUPTJOUFJSBNFOUFDPOUSPMBEPTQFMBT NgRVJOBTFnEFWPSBEPQPSVNBEFMBT"RVJ UBNCnN $IBQMJO OkPFTUgOBSSBOEPVNGBUPPVVNBBDPOUFDJNFOUPFTJNBMFHP SJ[BOEPPVTJNCPMJ[BOEPBWJPMpODJBEPUSBCBMIPJOEVTUSJBM%B NFTNBNBOFJSB PGJMNF.BUSJY DPNRVFBCSJNPTFTUFMJWSP BMFHPSJ[BPTSJTDPTFQFSJHPTRVFBNFBmBNBIVNBOJEBEFDPN PQPEFSJPEPTDPNQVUBEPSFT NgRVJOBTEFQSPEV[JSJMVT{FTPV SFBMJEBEFTJSSFBJT JTUPn WJSUVBJT 2VBJTBTEVBTNPEBMJEBEFTEFNVEBOmBTRVFBGFUBNBT BSUFT %FVNMBEP NVEBOmBTRVBOUPBPGB[FSBSUrTUJDP EJGFSFO DJBOEPTFFNFTDPMBTEFBSUFPVFTUJMPTBSUrTUJDPT±DMgTTJDP HwUJDP SFOBTDFOUJTUB CBSSPDP SPDPDw SPNiOUJDP JNQSFTTJP OJTUB SFBMJTUB FYQSFTTJPOJTUB BCTUSBUP DPOTUSVUJWJTUB TVSSFB MJTUB FUD%FPVUSPMBEP DPODFSOFNhEFUFSNJOBmkPTPDJBMEB BUJWJEBEFBSUrTUJDB 2VFRVFSEJ[FSRVFBTBSUFTTkPTPDJBMNFOUFEFUFSNJOB EBT 2VBJTTkPBTEFUFSNJOBm{FTTPDJBJTEBTBSUFT 2VFSEJ[FSRVFBTTVBTNVEBOmBTOkPEFQFOEFNBQFOBT EFVNBIJTUwSJBJOUFSOBEPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTBSUrTUJDPTFTJN EBJOTFSmkPEBTBSUFTOBWJEBTPDJBM"BSUFnTPDJBMNFOUFEF UFSNJOBEB QFMBGJOBMJEBEFTPDJBMEBTPCSBTFTUBWBNEFT UJOBEBTBPDVMUPSFMJHJPTP OB"OUJHVJEBEFFSBNGFJUBTQBSB EBSQSFTUrHJPBTFVTQBUSPDJOBEPSFT OB3FOBTDFOmBFIPKF FTUkPEFTUJOBEBTBQFSDPSSFSPDJSDVJUPEPNFSDBEPEFBSUF QFMPMVHBSTPDJBMPDVQBEPQFMPBSUJTUBNBHPBSUFTkPPGJ DJBOUFEFSJUPT OB"OUJHVJEBEFGJOBODJBEPFQSPUFHJEPQPS VNNFDFOBT OB3FOBTDFOmBQSPGJTTJPOBMMJCFSBMEFQFOEFOUF EPNFSDBEPEFBSUF OPTEJBTEFIPKF QFMBTDPOEJm{FTEF SFDFQmkPEBPCSBEFBSUFBDPNVOJEBEFEFGJnJT OB"OUJHVJ EBEFVNBFMJUFSJDB DVMUJWBEBFDPNQPEFSQPMrUJDP OB3FOBT DFOmBBDMBTTFFDPOPNJDBNFOUFEPNJOBOUFFQPMJUJDBNFOUF EJSJHFOUF EFVNMBEP FBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTPVBNBTTB EF PVUSP FNOPTTPTEJBT "EJTDVTTkPTPCSFBSFMBmkPBSUFTPDJFEBEFMFWPVBEVBTBUJ UVEFTGJMPTwGJDBTPQPTUBTBRVFBGJSNBRVFBBSUFTwnBSUFTFGPS QVSB JTUPn TFOkPFTUJWFSQSFPDVQBEBDPNBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT IJTUwSJDBT TPDJBJT FDPOyNJDBTFQPMrUJDBT5SBUBTFEBEFGFTB EB²BSUFQFMBBSUF³"PVUSBBGJSNBRVFPWBMPSEBPCSBEFBSUF EFDPSSFEFTFVDPNQSPNJTTPDSrUJDPEJBOUFEBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT QSFTFOUFT5SBUBTFEB²BSUFFOHBKBEB³ OBRVBMPBSUJTUBUPNB QPTJmkPEJBOUFEFTVBTPDJFEBEF MVUBOEPQBSBUSBOTGPSNgMBF NFMIPSgMB FQBSBDPOTDJFOUJ[BSBTQFTTPBTEBTJOKVTUJmBTFEBT PQSFTT{FTEPQSFTFOUF &YQMJRVFBQPTJmkPEPTRVFGBMBNFNBSUFQVSBPVOBBSUF QFMBBSUF "TEVBTDPODFQm{FTTkPQSPCMFNgUJDBT"QSJNFJSBQPSRVF JNBHJOBPBSUJTUBFBPCSBEFBSUFDPNPEFTQSPWJEPTEFSBr[FT
24
Manual do Professor
OPNVOEPFMJWSFTEBTJOGMVpODJBTEBTPDJFEBEFTPCSFFMFT±P RVFnJNQPTTrWFM"TFHVOEBQPSRVFDPSSFPSJTDPEFTBDSJGJDBSP USBCBMIPBSUrTUJDPFNOPNFEBT²NFOTBHFOT³RVFBPCSBEFWF FOWJBShTPDJFEBEFQBSBNVEgMB EBOEPBPBSUJTUBPQBQFMEF DPOTDJpODJBDSrUJDBEPQPWPPQSJNJEP
0RVFTFFOUFOEFQPSGPMDMPSF 'PMDMPSFTkPBTQSPEVm{FTPVDSJBm{FTEPQBTTBEPOBDJP OBM RVFGPSNBNBUSBEJmkPOBDJPOBM BDVMUVSBFBSUFQPQVMB SFT DPOTUJUVrEBTQPSNJUPT MFOEBTFSJUPTQPQVMBSFT EBOmBT SFHJPOBJTQPQVMBSFT N|TJDBTSFHJPOBJTQPQVMBSFT BSUFTBOB UPT FUD
&YQMJRVFPRVFQFOTBNPTRVFEFGFOEFNBBSUFFOHBKBEB 0TBEFQUPTEFTTBDPODFQmkPEFBSUFBGJSNBNRVFPWBMPS EBPCSBEFBSUFEFDPSSFEFTFVDPNQSPNJTTPDSrUJDPEJBOUFEBT DJSDVOTUiODJBTQSFTFOUFT5SBUBTFEBBSUFOBRVBMPBSUJTUBUPNB QPTJmkPEJBOUFEFTVBTPDJFEBEF MVUBOEPQBSBUSBOTGPSNgMBF NFMIPSgMB FUBNCnNQBSBDPOTDJFOUJ[BSBTQFTTPBTTPCSFBT JOKVTUJmBTFBTPQSFTT{FTEPQSFTFOUF 2VBJTPTQSPCMFNBTFBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEFTTBTEVBTDPO DFQm{FT "BSUFQVSBEFTFNCPDBOPDIBNBEPGPSNBMJTNP nBQFSGFJ mkPEBGPSNBRVFDPOUB FOkPPDPOUF|EPEBPCSB "BSUFFOHB KBEB OPDPOUFVEJTNP nB²NFOTBHFN³RVFDPOUB NFTNPRVF BGPSNBEBPCSBTFKBQSFDgSJB EFTDVJEBEB SFQFUJUJWBFTFNGPSmB JOPWBEPSB 2VBOEPQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFVNBPCSBEFBSUFnHSBOEFF EVSBEPVSB 1PEFNPTEJ[FSRVFVNBPCSBEFBSUFnHSBOEFFEVSBEPVSB RVBOEPOFMBBQFSGFJmkPEBGPSNBFBSJRVF[BEBTTJHOJGJDBm{FT EFTFVDPOUF|EPTkPJOTFQBSgWFJT FTUkPBSUJDVMBEBTOVNBVOJ EBEFIBSNPOJPTBRVFBDPOTUJUVJDPNP|OJDB/FMB FUFSOJEBEF FGVHBDJEBEFTkPTJNVMUiOFBT%JBMPHBDPNPNVOEPQSFTFOUF QPSRVFOkPFTDPOEFTFVQFSUFODJNFOUPOFDFTTgSJPBPDPOUFYUP IJTUwSJDPFTPDJBMFNRVFTFFODPOUSBFOPRVBMOBTDFVEJBMPHB DPNPQBTTBEPQPSRVFUBNCnNOkPFTDPOEFTVBQBSUJDJQBmkP OVNBUSBEJmkPRVFMIFEgTFOUJEPFEJBMPHBDPNPGVUVSPQPS RVFTFSgSFUPNBEB USBOTGPSNBEBFTVQFSBEBQPSPVUSBTPCSBT RVFOFMBFODPOUSBSkPVNOPWPQPOUPEFQBSUJEB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=_qhpqn]`ai]oo]a]ej` opne] _qhpqn]h &YQMJRVFQPSRVFPTVSHJNFOUPEPT&TUBEPTOBDJPOBJTFEB JEFJBEFOBmkPQSPWPDBPOBTDJNFOUPEBTJEFJBTEFBSUFF DVMUVSBQPQVMBSFT "TJEFJBTEFBSUFFDVMUVSBQPQVMBSFTFOUFOEJEBTDPNPGPM DMPSFGPSBNBDPOTFRVpODJBEFVNBTJUVBmkPIJTUwSJDBEFUFSNJ OBEBBDPOTPMJEBmkPFPGPSUBMFDJNFOUPEPT&TUBEPTOBDJPOBJT RVFQBTTBSBNBTFSEFGJOJEPTQFMBVOJEBEFEFMrOHVBFSFMJHJkP FQFMBVOJEBEFUFSSJUPSJBMPVQPMrUJDB4VSHFBJEFJBQPMrUJDBEF OBmkPF DPNFMB PGFOyNFOPEPOBDJPOBMJTNP*OUFMFDUVBJTF BSUJTUBTFVSPQFVTGPSNVMBSBN OFTTBnQPDB BOPmkPEFFTQrSJUP EFVNQPWP RVFTFFYQSJNJSJBOBMrOHVBFOBSFMJHJkP OBTBSUFT FOBTUSBEJm{FTOBDJPOBJT &YQMJRVFQPSRVFTFEFVBEJWJTkPEBDVMUVSBFEBTBSUFTFN FSVEJUBFQPQVMBS&YQMJRVFPRVFTkPDBEBVNBEFMBT 1PSRVFBTTPDJFEBEFTEFTTFQFSrPEP FYJTUFOUFTTPCBGPS NBEF&TUBEPTOBDJPOBJTPVEFOBm{FT FSBNTPDJFEBEFTDBQJ UBMJTUBTF DPNPUBJT EJWJEJEBTFNDMBTTFTTPDJBJT BCVSHVFTJB DBQJUBMJTUB BQFRVFOBCVSHVFTJBEFQFRVFOPTQSPQSJFUgSJPT GVODJPOgSJPTQ|CMJDPTFJOUFMFDUVBJTFPQSPMFUBSJBEPPVPTUSB CBMIBEPSFTJOEVTUSJBJTFSVSBJT
25
2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFGPMDMPSFFBSUFPVDVMUVSBEFFMJUFPV FSVEJUB 'PMDMPSFTkPBTQSPEVm{FTPVDSJBm{FTEPQBTTBEPOBDJP OBM GPSNBOEPBUSBEJmkPOBDJPOBM BDVMUVSBFBSUFQPQVMBSFT DPOTUJUVrEBTQPSNJUPT MFOEBTFSJUPTQPQVMBSFT EBOmBTSFHJP OBJTQPQVMBSFT N|TJDBTSFHJPOBJTQPQVMBSFT BSUFTBOBUPT FUD "BSUFPVDVMUVSBFSVEJUB PVEFFMJUF nQSwQSJBEPTJOUFMFDUVBJT FBSUJTUBTEBDMBTTFEPNJOBOUFEBTPDJFEBEFFTTBBSUFQBTTPVB TFSDPOTUJUVrEBQFMBTQSPEVm{FTFDSJBm{FTQSFTFOUFTPVBUVBJT EBTCFMBTBSUFT DPOTVNJEBTQPSVNQ|CMJDPEFMFUSBEPT JTUP n EFQFTTPBTDPNCPNHSBVEFFTDPMBSJ[BmkPFDPOTVNJEPSBT EFBSUF 2VBJTBTQSJODJQBJTEJGFSFOmBTBQPOUBEBTFOUSFDVMUVSBBS UFFSVEJUBFDVMUVSBBSUFQPQVMBS %FQPJTEFFOVNFSgMBT FTDPMIBEVBTFFYQMJRVFBT "EJTUJOmkPFOUSFBSUFQPQVMBSFFSVEJUB FNCPSBGPTTFDPO TFRVpODJBEBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEBTDMBTTFT GPJDPODFCJEB FDPO UJOVBBTpMPBUnIPKF DPNPEJGFSFOmB OBDPNQMFYJEBEFEB FMBCPSBmkP BBSUFQPQVMBSnNBJTTJNQMFTFNFOPTDPNQMFYB EPRVFBFSVEJUB OBSFMBmkPDPNPOPWPFDPNPUFNQP B QPQVMBSUFOEFBTFSUSBEJDJPOBMJTUBFSFQFUJUJWB FORVBOUPB FSVEJUBUFOEFBTFSEFWBOHVBSEBFWPMUBEBQBSBPGVUVSP OBSFMBmkPDPNPQ|CMJDP OBQPQVMBS BSUJTUBTFQ|CMJDPUFO EFNBOkPTFEJTUJOHVJSOBFSVEJUB nDMBSBBEJTUJOmkPFOUSF PBSUJTUBFPQ|CMJDP OPNPEPEFDPNQSFFOTkP OBBSUF QPQVMBS PBSUJTUBFYQSJNFEJSFUBNFOUFPRVFTFQBTTBFNTFV BNCJFOUFFnJNFEJBUBNFOUFDPNQSFFOEJEPQPSUPEPT FO RVBOUPOBFSVEJUBPBSUJTUBDSJBOPWPTNFJPTEFFYQSFTTkP EF NBOFJSBRVFTVBPCSBOkPnJNFEJBUBNFOUFDPNQSFFOTrWFMB OkPTFSQBSBPTFOUFOEJEPTRVF QPSJTTP BJOUFSQSFUBNQBSB PSFTUBOUFEPQ|CMJDP 2VBJTBTEVBTDPOTFRVpODJBTDVMUVSBJTFBSUrTUJDBTEBWJOEB EPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTSVSBJTQBSBBTDJEBEFTDPNPPQFSgSJPT JOEVTUSJBJT 5FOEPTJEPGPSmBEPTBEFJYBSPDBNQP BNBJPSJBEFTTFTUSB CBMIBEPSFTUBNCnNEFJYBWBQBSBUSgTTVBDVMUVSBFTVBBSUF RVF PTJOUFMFDUVBJTIBWJBNEFOPNJOBEPEFGPMDMPSF /BTDJEBEFT EPJTGFOyNFOPTBDPOUFDFSBNQPSVNMBEP FNTFVTCBJSSPTF MPDBJTEFUSBCBMIP PTPQFSgSJPTFTVBTGBNrMJBTGPSBNDSJBOEP VNBDVMUVSBFVNBBSUFQSwQSJBT DIBNBEBTEFQPQVMBSFTQPS PVUSPMBEP QBTTBSBNBGB[FSQBSUFEBHSBOEFNBTTBEFDPOTV NJEPSFTEPTQSPEVUPTJOEVTUSJBJTQBSBPTRVBJTDPNFmBSBNB TFSSFQSPEV[JEBT FNMBSHBFTDBMB WFST{FTTJNQMJGJDBEBTFJOGF SJPSFTEPTQSPEVUPTFDSJBm{FTEBTDIBNBEBTDVMUVSBFBSUFEF FMJUF EBOEPPSJHFNBPRVFWJSJBBTFSDPOIFDJEPDPNPDVMUVSBF BSUFEFNBTTB 2VFFSBPFODBOUBNFOUPEPNVOEP 2VFGPJPEFTFODBOUB NFOUPEPNVOEP 2VBMBTVBDPOTFRVpODJBQBSBBTBSUFT 0FODBOUBNFOUPEPNVOEPFSBPTFOUJNFOUPEFRVFPNVOEP OBUVSBMFIVNBOPFTUgFNSFMBmkPDPNVNNVOEPTPCSFOB UVSBMEFGPSmBTEJWJOBTRVFTFNBOJGFTUBNEFNBOFJSBTWB SJBEBT JOFYQMJDgWFJTFNJTUFSJPTBT0EFTFODBOUBNFOUPEP
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
NVOEPGPJBQBTTBHFNEPNJUPhSB[kP EBNBHJBhDJpODJBF hMwHJDB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT QBTTPVTFEBDSFOmBFNDBVTBT TPCSFOBUVSBJTQBSBPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPThTVBFYQMJDBmkPSB DJPOBMPVhTVBOBUVSBMJ[BmkPFIVNBOJ[BmkP&TTFQSPDFTTP MJCFSPVBTBSUFTEBGVOmkPFGJOBMJEBEFSFMJHJPTBT EBOEPMIFT BVUPOPNJB 1PSRVF#FOKBNJOFSBPUJNJTUBBPGBMBSOBEFTUSVJmkPEBBVSB PVOBSFQSPEVmkPUnDOJDBEBTPCSBTEFBSUF 1PSRVFFMFJNBHJOBWBRVFBSFQSPEVmkPEBTPCSBTEFBSUFQFS NJUJSJBhNBJPSJBEBTQFTTPBTPBDFTTPBDSJBm{FTRVF BUnFOUkP BQFOBTVOTQPVDPTQPEJBNDPOIFDFSFGSVJS&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT #FOKBNJOFTQFSBWBRVFIPVWFTTFEFNPDSBUJ[BmkPEBDVMUVSBF EBTBSUFT 1PSRVFBUSBEVmkPFJNQSFTTkPEB#rCMJBQPEFSJBKVTUJGJDBS PPUJNJTNPEF#FOKBNJO 1PSRVFDPNBUSBEVmkPFBJNQSFTTkPEB#rCMJBIPVWFVN QSPDFTTPEFBMGBCFUJ[BmkPOPTQBrTFTSFGPSNBEPT QBSBRVFUP EPTPTGJnJTQVEFTTFNMFSBT4BHSBEBT&TDSJUVSBT&TTBMFJUVSB GF[DPNRVFDBNQPOFTFT OB"MFNBOIBFOB)PMBOEB BTTJNDP NPUSBCBMIBEPSFTEPDBNQPFEBTDJEBEFT OB*OHMBUFSSB QFSDF CFTTFNRVFTVBTTPDJFEBEFTFTFVTHPWFSOBOUFTOkPTFHVJBN PTFOTJOBNFOUPTCrCMJDPT FSBNJOKVTUPT DSVnJT UJSiOJDPT BO UJDSJTUkPT"MFJUVSBEBT4BHSBEBT&TDSJUVSBTUFWFVNFGFJUPEF DPOTDJFOUJ[BmkPQPQVMBS 0RVFTJHOJGJDBBFYQSFTTkP²JOE|TUSJBDVMUVSBM³ 2VBMTVB SFMBmkPDPNPDBQJUBMJTNP "FYQSFTTkP²JOE|TUSJBDVMUVSBM³TJHOJGJDBRVFBTPCSBTEF BSUFTkPNFSDBEPSJBT DPNPUVEPPRVFFYJTUFOPDBQJUBMJTNP" QBSUJSEBTFHVOEBSFWPMVmkPJOEVTUSJBM OPTnDVMP9*9 FQSPTTF HVJOEPOPRVFIPKFFNEJBTFEFOPNJOBTPDJFEBEFQwTJOEVT USJBMPVQwTNPEFSOB BTBSUFT RVFIBWJBNTFUPSOBEPBVUyOP NBTPVTFMJCFSBEPEBTVCNJTTkPhSFMJHJkP GPSBNTVCNFUJEBT BVNBOPWBTFSWJEkPBTSFHSBTEPNFSDBEPDBQJUBMJTUBFBJEFP MPHJBEBJOE|TUSJBDVMUVSBM FYQSFTTkPDVOIBEBQPS5IFPEPS "EPSOPF.BY)PSLIFJNFSQBSBJOEJDBSVNBDVMUVSBCBTFBEB OBJEFJBFOBQSgUJDBEPDPOTVNPEF²QSPEVUPTDVMUVSBJT³GB CSJDBEPTFNTnSJF 4FHVOEP"EPSOPF)PSLIFJNFS RVFUSBOTGPSNBmkPBJOE|T USJBDVMUVSBMJNQyThTBSUFT 4PCPQPEFSJPEFFNQSFTBTDBQJUBMJTUBT BTPCSBTEFBSUF WFSEBEFJSBNFOUFDSJBEPSBT DSrUJDBTFSBEJDBJTGPSBNFTWB[JB EBTQBSBTFUPSOBSFNFOUSFUFOJNFOUPFPVUSBTPCSBTQBTTBSBN BTFSQSPEV[JEBTQBSBDFMFCSBSPFYJTUFOUF FNMVHBSEFDPN QSFFOEpMP DSJUJDgMPFQSPQPSVNPVUSPGVUVSPQBSBBIVNB OJEBEF"GPSmBEFDPOIFDJNFOUP DSrUJDBFJOWFOmkPEBTBSUFT GJDPVSFEV[JEBBBMHVNBTQSPEVm{FTEBBSUFFSVEJUB FORVBOUP PSFTUBOUFEBQSPEVmkPBSUrTUJDBGPJEFTUJOBEPBVNDPOTVNP SgQJEP USBOTGPSNBOEPTFFNTJOBMEFTUBUVTTPDJBMFQSFTUrHJP QPMrUJDPQBSBBSUJTUBTFTFVTDPOTVNJEPSFTFFNNFJPEFDPOUSP MFDVMUVSBMQPSQBSUFEPTFNQSFTgSJPTFQSPQSJFUgSJPTEPTNFJPT EFDPNVOJDBmkPEFNBTTB 2VBJTPTSJTDPTRVFBTBSUFTDPSSFNTPCPTFGFJUPTEBNBT TJGJDBmkPEBDVMUVSBQFMBJOE|TUSJBDVMUVSBM "TBSUFTDPSSFNPSJTDPEFQFSEFSTVBGPSmBTJNCwMJDBF DPN FMB BMHVNBTEFTVBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEFFYQSFTTJWBT UFOEFNBUPSOBSTFSFQSPEVUJWBTFSFQFUJUJWBTEFUSBCBMIPEF
DSJBmkP UFOEFNBUPSOBSTFFWFOUPTQBSBDPOTVNPEFFYQFSJ NFOUBmkPFJOWFOmkPEPOPWP UFOEFNBUPSOBSTFDPOTBHSBmkP EPDPOTBHSBEPQFMBNPEBFQFMPDPOTVNPEFEVSBEPVSBT UFO EFNBUPSOBSTFQBSUFEPNFSDBEPEBNPEB QBTTBHFJSP FGpNF SP TFNQBTTBEPFTFNGVUVSPEFGPSNBTEFDPOIFDJNFOUPRVF EFTWFOEBNBSFBMJEBEFFBMDBOmBNBWFSEBEF UFOEFNBUPSOBS TFEJTTJNVMBmkPEBSFBMJEBEF JMVTkPGBMTJGJDBEPSB QVCMJDJEBEF FQSPQBHBOEB 0RVFnEFNPDSBDJBDVMUVSBM %FNPDSBDJBDVMUVSBMTJHOJGJDBEJSFJUPEFBDFTTPFEFGSVJmkP EBTPCSBTDVMUVSBJT EJSFJUPhJOGPSNBmkPFhGPSNBmkPDVMUVSBJT EJSFJUPhQSPEVmkPDVMUVSBM 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFNBTTJGJDBmkPDVMUVSBMFEFNPDSBUJ [BmkPEBDVMUVSB .BTTJGJDBSnCBOBMJ[BSBFYQSFTTkPBSUrTUJDBFJOUFMFDUVBM B WVMHBSJ[BmkPEBTBSUFTFEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPT+gEFNPDSBUJ[BmkP EBDVMUVSBnPBUPEFEJGVOEJSFEJWVMHBSBDVMUVSB EFTQFSUBOEP JOUFSFTTFQPSFMB &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBNBTTJGJDBmkPSFBMJ[BPPQPTUPEBEFNP DSBUJ[BmkPDVMUVSBM &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS QPSRVFTFQBSBPTCFOTDVMUVSBJTQFMP TFVTVQPTUPWBMPSEFNFSDBEPIgPCSBTDBSBTFSBSBT EFTUJ OBEBTBPTQSJWJMFHJBEPTRVFQPEFNQBHBSQPSFMBT GPSNBOEP VNBFMJUFDVMUVSBMFIgPCSBTCBSBUBTFDPNVOTEFTUJOBEBTh NBTTB"TTJN FNWF[EFHBSBOUJSPNFTNPEJSFJUPEFUPEPTh UPUBMJEBEFEBQSPEVmkPDVMUVSBM BJOE|TUSJBDVMUVSBMJOUSPEV[ BEJWJTkPTPDJBMFOUSFFMJUFDVMUBFNBTTBJODVMUB&NTFHVO EPMVHBS QPSRVFDSJBBJMVTkPEFRVFUPEPTUpNBDFTTPBPT NFTNPTCFOTDVMUVSBJT DBEBVNFTDPMIFOEPMJWSFNFOUFP RVFEFTFKB DPNPPDPOTVNJEPSOVNTVQFSNFSDBEP/PFO UBOUP CBTUBQSFTUBSNPTBUFOmkPBPTIPSgSJPTEPTQSPHSBNBT EFSgEJPFUFMFWJTkPPVBPRVFnWFOEJEPOBTCBODBTEFKPSOBJT QBSBWFSNPTRVF QFMPTQSFmPT BTFNQSFTBTEFEJWVMHBmkP DVMUVSBMKgTFMFDJPOBSBNEFBOUFNkPPRVFDBEBHSVQPTPDJBM QPEFFEFWFPVWJS WFSPVMFS&NUFSDFJSPMVHBS QPSRVFJOWFOUB VNBGJHVSBDIBNBEB²FTQFDUBEPSNnEJP³ ²PVWJOUFNnEJP³F ²MFJUPSNnEJP³ BPTRVBJTTkPBUSJCVrEBTDFSUBTDBQBDJEBEFT NFOUBJT²NnEJBT³ DFSUPTDPOIFDJNFOUPT²NnEJPT³FDFSUPT HPTUPT²NnEJPT³ PGFSFDFOEPMIFTQSPEVUPTDVMUVSBJT²Nn EJPT³&NRVBSUPMVHBS QPSRVFEFGJOFBDVMUVSBDPNPMB[FS FFOUSFUFOJNFOUP EJWFSTkPFEJTUSBmkP EFNPEPRVFUVEPP RVFOBTPCSBTEFBSUFFEFQFOTBNFOUPTJHOJGJDBUSBCBMIPEB TFOTJCJMJEBEF EBJNBHJOBmkP EBJOUFMJHpODJB EBSFGMFYkPFEB DSrUJDBOkPUFNJOUFSFTTF OkP²WFOEF³ 0RVFTJHOJGJDBBFYQSFTTkP²NFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPEF NBTTB³ "FYQSFTTkP²DPNVOJDBmkPEFNBTTB³GPJDSJBEBQBSB SFGFSJSTFBPTPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPTDBQB[FTEFUSBOTNJUJSB NFTNBJOGPSNBmkPQBSBVNQ|CMJDPNVJUPBNQMP JTUPn QBSB BNBTTB*OJDJBMNFOUF SFGFSJBTFBPSgEJPFBPDJOFNB QPJT BJNQSFOTBQSFTTVQVOIBQFTTPBTBMGBCFUJ[BEBT PRVFOkP FSBSFRVFSJEPQFMPSgEJPOFNQFMPDJOFNBFNTFVTDPNFmPT 1PVDPBQPVDPFTUFOEFVTFQBSBBJNQSFOTB BQVCMJDJEBEF PVQSPQBHBOEB BGPUPHSBGJB PUFMFGPOF PUFMnHSBGP PGPOw HSBGPDPNPTEJTDPTFBUFMFWJTkP&TTFTPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPT TkPPTNFJPTQPSJOUFSNnEJPEPTRVBJTBJOGPSNBmkPnUSBOT NJUJEBPVDPNVOJDBEB
3,
Manual do Professor
0RVFTJHOJGJDBBQBMBWSBNrEJB &NMBUJN NFJPTFEJ[NFEJVNF OPQMVSBM NFJPTTFEJ[NF EJB0TQSJNFJSPTUFwSJDPTEPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPFNQSF HBSBNBQBMBWSBMBUJOBNFEJB$PNPFSBNUFwSJDPTEFMrOHVB JOHMFTB EJ[JBNNBTTNFEJB JTUPn ²PTNFJPTEFNBTTB³"QSP O|ODJB FNJOHMpT EPMBUJNNFEJBn²NrEJB³2VBOEPPTUFwSJDPT EFMrOHVBJOHMFTBEJ[FN²UIFNFEJB³ FTUkPEJ[FOEP²PTNFJPT³ 1PSBQSPQSJBmkPEBUFSNJOPMPHJBEFTTFTUFwSJDPTOP#SBTJM BQB MBWSBNrEJBQBTTPVBTFSFNQSFHBEBDPNPTFGPTTFVNBQBMBWSB GFNJOJOBOPTJOHVMBS±²BNrEJB³ 2VFEJGFSFOmBT.D-VIBOBQPOUBFOUSFBFEVDBmkPFTDPMBS OB"OUJHVJEBEFFOB*EBEF.nEJBFFNOPTTBnQPDB %J[.D-VIBORVF OB"OUJHVJEBEFFOB*EBEF.nEJB PTBMV OPTBQSFOEJBNPVWJOEPPQSPGFTTPSFSFQFUJOEPPRVFFMFEJ [JB JTUPn PFOTJOPFSBGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFPSBMFFYJHJBHSBOEF USBCBMIPEBNFNwSJB IBWFOEPNVJUBTUnDOJDBTFTQFDJBJTQBSB BQSFOEFSBNFNPSJ[BS"MnNEJTTP OPTDVSTPTNBJTBWBOmB EPT BMnNEBTBVMBT PTFTUVEBOUFTDPQJBWBNPVQSPEV[JBN QBSBTFVVTPQFTTPBMNBOVTDSJUPTEFHSBNgUJDB EJDJPOgSJPT FOTJOBNFOUPTCgTJDPTEFBSJUNnUJDBFHFPNFUSJB0FOTJOPF PBQSFOEJ[BEP QPSTFSFNPSBJT FSBNDPMFUJWPT QPJTUPEPTPT FTUVEBOUFTEFQFOEJBNEBBVMBNJOJTUSBEBQFMPQSPGFTTPSFNF NPSJ[BWBNPFOTJOBNFOUPQPSNFJPEFEJTDVTT{FTFEJTQVUBT DPNPTDPMFHBT&TTBTJUVBmkPNVEPVDPNBDIFHBEBEPMJWSP JNQSFTTP QPJTOkPTwPTFTUVEBOUFTQBTTBSBNBUFSBDFTTPBPT NFTNPTNBUFSJBJTRVFPTQSPGFTTPSFT NBTUBNCnNBTBVMBT QBTTBSBNBBQPJBSTFOPTFTDSJUPT FYJHJOEPNFOPTNFNwSJB EFQSPGFTTPSFTFBMVOPT"MnNEJTTP TVSHJVPFOTJOPTPMJUgSJP FJOEJWJEVBMDPNPBMHPNBJTJNQPSUBOUFEPRVFBEJTDVTTkPF BEJTQVUBDPMFUJWBT/BBUVBMJEBEF PTOPWPTNFJPTEFDPNV OJDBmkPTkPWJTVBJTFTPOPSPT VTBNNVJUPQPVDPBFTDSJUBF FTUJNVMBNBPSBMJEBEF"TFTDPMBT DPNPBTEB"OUJHVJEBEFF EB*EBEF.nEJB BEPUBNDBEBWF[NBJTPTSFDVSTPTBVEJPWJTVBJT QBSBPFOTJOPFPBQSFOEJ[BEPFSFJOUSPEV[FNPTUSBCBMIPTEF HSVQPFBTEJTDVTT{FTDPMFUJWBT/FTTFTFOUJEP .D-VIBOGBMB OP²GJOBMEBHBMgYJB(VUFOCFSH³ PVTFKB PGJNEPQSFEPNrOJP EPMJWSPJNQSFTTPOBFEVDBmkP 1PSRVFQPEFNPTGBMBSFN²JOWBTkPDVMUVSBM³ NBJTEPRVF FNJOGPSNBmkPQFMPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkP 1PSRVFPRVFFYJTUFIPKFnKVTUBNFOUFVNBJOWBTkPDVMUVSBM PVTFKB QBDPUFTEFJOGPSNBm{FT JEFJBTFEJWFST{FT.D-VIBO SFGFSJVTFBFTTFGFOyNFOPDPNPBQBTTBHFN²EBQSPEVmkPEF NFSDBEPSJBTFNQBDPUBEBTQBSBPFNQBDPUBNFOUPEBJOGPSNB mkP³1BSBFMF IPKF PTQBrTFTIFHFNyOJDPTJOWBEFNDVMUVSBT JOUFJSBTDPNJOGPSNBmkPFOMBUBEB EJWFSTkPFJEFJBT 0RVFRVFSEJ[FSBQBMBWSBQSPQBHBOEB &BQBMBWSBQV CMJDJEBEF "QBMBWSBQSPQBHBOEBEFSJWBEPWFSCPQSPQBHBS RVFTJHOJ GJDB²NVMUJQMJDBSVNBFTQnDJFQPSNFJPEBSFQSPEVmkP³ ²FTQB MIBSTFQPSVNUFSSJUwSJP³ ²BVNFOUBSOVNFSJDBNFOUFQPSDPO UgHJP³ ²JSSBEJBSTF³ ²EJGVOEJSTF³ F QPSFYUFOTkP ²EJWVMHBS³ "QSPQBHBOEBnVNBEJGVTkPFVNBEJWVMHBmkPEFJEFJBT WBMP SFT PQJOJ{FT JOGPSNBm{FTQBSBPNBJPSO|NFSPEFQFTTPBTOP NBJTBNQMPUFSSJUwSJPQPTTrWFM1VCMJDJEBEFSFGFSFTFBVNDPO DFJUPNBJTBNQMP/BBDFQmkPRVFMIFEgPEJDJPOgSJP"VSnMJP RVFnBRVFOPTJOUFSFTTBBRVJ QVCMJDJEBEF²nBBSUFPVUnDOJDB EFQMBOFKBS DPODFCFS DSJBS FYFDVUBSFWFJDVMBSNFOTBHFOTEF QSPQBHBOEB³"QSPQBHBOEBSFMJHJPTBFBQSPQBHBOEBQPMrUJDB TkPGPSNBTEFQVCMJDJEBEF
3-
2VBJTPTNFJPTFNQSFHBEPTQFMBQSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBM QBSBWFOEFSPTQSPEVUPT "QSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBMVUJMJ[BBTBSUFTHSgGJDBT BGPUPHSB GJB BN|TJDB BEBOmBFBQPFTJBFEJGVOEFBTQPSNFJPEFKPS OBJT SFWJTUBT DBSUB[FT SgEJPFUFMFWJTkP 0RVFBQSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBMQSFDJTBGB[FSQBSBTFSFGJ DB[ 1BSBTFSFGJDB[ BQSPQBHBOEBEFWFSFBMJ[BSEVBTPQFSBm{FT TJNVMUiOFBTQPSVNMBEP EFWFBGJSNBSRVFPQSPEVUPQPTTVJ PTWBMPSFTFTUBCFMFDJEPTQFMBTPDJFEBEFFNRVFTFFODPOUSB PDPOTVNJEPS F QPSPVUSP BMnNEFEFTQFSUBSEFTFKPTRVFP DPOTVNJEPSOkPQPTTVrB QSFDJTB TPCSFUVEP BTTFHVSBSBTB UJTGBmkPEFTTFTEFTFKPT 2VBJTBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFBQSPQBHBOEBEPTnDVMP9*9F JOrDJPEPTnDVMP99FBBUVBM &NTFVTDPNFmPT EFTEFGJOTEPTnDVMP9*9BUnPTNFB EPTEPTnDVMP99 BQSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBMTVCMJOIBWBFFMP HJBWBBTRVBMJEBEFTEPTQSPEVUPT$PNPOBFSBEBTPDJFEBEF JOEVTUSJBMPTQSPEVUPTFSBNWBMPSJ[BEPTQPSTVBEVSBCJMJEB EF BQSPQBHBOEBUFOEJBBJOWFOUBSVNBJNBHFNEVSBEPVSB RVFTFUPSOBWBVNBFTQnDJFEFNBSDBQBSBPSFDPOIFDJNFOUP JNFEJBUPEPQSPEVUPFGBDJMNFOUFSFQFUJEBQPSUPEPT"QSP QBHBOEBUBNCnNCVTDBWBBGJSNBSFHBSBOUJSPQSPEVUPUSB [FOEPPOPNFEPGBCSJDBOUFDPNPQSPWBEBRVBMJEBEF$PN PBEWFOUPEBTPDJFEBEFQwTJOEVTUSJBM DVKPTQSPEVUPTTkP EFTDBSUgWFJT TFNEVSBCJMJEBEFFEFDPOTVNPJNFEJBUP F TPCSFUVEPhNFEJEBRVFQFTRVJTBTEFNFSDBEPJOEJDBNRVF BTWFOEBTEFQFOEFNEBDBQBDJEBEFEFNBOJQVMBSEFTFKPT EPDPOTVNJEPSFBUnNFTNPDSJBSEFTFKPTOFMF BQSPQBHBOEB DPNFSDJBMGPJEFJYBOEPEFBQSFTFOUBSPQSPEVUPQSPQSJBNFO UFEJUPQBSBBGJSNBSPTEFTFKPTRVFFMFSFBMJ[BSJBTVDFTTP QSPTQFSJEBEF TFHVSBOmB KVWFOUVEFFUFSOB CFMF[B BUSBmkP TFYVBM GFMJDJEBEF&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BHSBOEFEJGFSFOmB FOUSFBnQPDBJOJDJBMFBBUVBMnRVFBQSPQBHBOEBPVQVCMJ DJEBEFDPNFSDJBMQBTTPVBWFOEFSJNBHFOTFTJHOPTFOkPBT QSwQSJBTNFSDBEPSJBT "QSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBMQBTTPVBWFOEFSJNBHFOTFTJH OPT&YQMJRVFFTTBBGJSNBmkP 1PSFYFNQMP QBSBWFOEFSVNDFSUPDJHBSSP FNWF[EF BQSFTFOUgMPEJSFUBNFOUF FNTFVMVHBSBQBSFDFNNPUPDJDMF UBT WFMFJSPT DPSSJEBTEFBVUPNwWFJTFPTMPHBO²PTVDFTTP³ 0VTFKB WFOEFTFBJNBHFNEPTVDFTTPQBSBBRVBMPDJHBS SPTFUPSOBJOTUSVNFOUPJOEJTQFOTgWFM"TTJN UBNCnN FN MVHBSEBNBOUFJHBFEBNBSHBSJOBDPNTVBTQSPQSJFEBEFTF RVBMJEBEFT BQBSFDFBGBNrMJBGFMJ[UPNBOEPPDBGnEBNBOIk FDPOTVNJOEPPQSPEVUP JTUPn WFOEFTFBJNBHFNEBGFMJDJ EBEFFEBIBSNPOJBEPNnTUJDBTQBSBBTRVBJTBNBSHBSJOBPV NBOUFJHBnBDPOEJmkPJOEJTQFOTgWFM"QSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBM UBNCnNTFBQSPQSJBEFBUJUVEFT PQJOJ{FTFQPTJm{FTDSrUJDBT FSBEJDBJTFYJTUFOUFTOBTPDJFEBEF FTWB[JBTFVDPOUF|EPTP DJBMFQPMrUJDPFBTJOWFTUFOVNQSPEVUP USBOTGPSNBOEPBTFN NPEBDPOTVNrWFMFQBTTBHFJSB'FNJOJTNP HVFSSJMIBSFWPMV DJPOgSJB NPWJNFOUPTDVMUVSBJTEFQFSJGFSJB MJCFSBmkPTFYVBM EJSFJUPTIVNBOPT FUDTkPUSBOTGPSNBEPTFNRVBMJEBEFTRVF WFOEFNVNQSPEVUP $PNPBQSPQBHBOEBDPNFSDJBMNBOJQVMBPTEFTFKPTEBT QFTTPBT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
1PSFYFNQMP VNBSPVQBPVVNQFSGVNFTkPBTTPDJBEPTB WJBHFOTBQBrTFTEJTUBOUFTFFYwUJDPTPVBVNBSFMBmkPTFYVBM GBOUgTUJDBVNVUFOTrMJPEPNnTUJDPPVVNTBCkPFNQwBQSF TFOUBEPTDPNPBTVQSFNBEFGFTBEPGFNJOJTNP MJCFSBOEPB NVMIFSEBTMJEFTDBTFJSBTVNBMJNFOUPQBSBBTDSJBOmBTnBQSF TFOUBEPDPNPHBSBOUJBEFTB|EFFBMFHSJBJOGBOUJT EFTQFSUBOEP OBDSJBOmBPEFTFKPEFDPOTVNJMPFMFWBOEPBNkFPVPQBJB BERVJSJMPQPSRVFFTQFSBNHBOIBSUSBORVJMJEBEFFDFSUF[BEF CFNBMJNFOUBSPTGJMIPT $PNPTFEgBDPNQFUJmkPQPSNFJPEBDPOTUSVmkPEFJNB HFOTEPJOEJWrEVP $PNPUPEPTPTJOEJWrEVPTTkPNFSDBEPSJBTRVFDPOTPNFN NFSDBEPSJBT BQSPQBHBOEBQBTTBBFTUJNVMBSJNBHFOTEFJOEJ WrEVPTWFODFEPSFTOBDPNQFUJmkPJOTUJUVrEBQFMPNFSDBEPEF USBCBMIPSPVQBT DBMmBEPT CPMTBTFQBTUBTEFHSJGF TBCPOFUFT QFSGVNFTFEFTPEPSBOUFTRVFTVHFSFNSFRVJOUFFHMBNPVS DPT NnUJDPTEFNBSDBTGBNPTBT FUDQBTTBNBDPOTUJUVJSPQSwQSJP DPSQPEPJOEJWrEVP GPSNBNTVBJNBHFNDPNPVNBFTQnDJFEF TFHVOEBOBUVSF[BPVEFNgTDBSBDPMBEBFNTVBQFMF %pFYFNQMPTEBGPSmBEBTUSBOTNJTT{FTSBEJPGyOJDBT %PJTGBUPTQPEFNTFSEBEPTDPNPFYFNQMPTEBGPSmBEBT USBOTNJTT{FTSBEJPGyOJDBTBUSBOTNJTTkPEF"HVFSSBEPT NVOEPT FNNFBEPTEPTBOPT GFJUBQFMPDJOFBTUB0STPO 8FMMFTFCBTFBEBOPSPNBODFEF)(8FMMT RVFNPCJMJ[PVPT OPSUFBNFSJDBOPTQPSUPNBSFNBUSBNB±BJOWBTkPEB5FSSB QPSNBSDJBOPT±DPNPWFSEBEFJSBFBFGJDJpODJBEPVTPEBT NFOTBHFOTSBEJPGyOJDBTQFMPOB[JTNP MFWBEPBFGFJUPOBTEn DBEBTEFF"USBOTNJTTkPEF"HVFSSBEPTNVOEPT NPTUSPVPQPEFSEFQFSTVBTkPFEFDPOWFODJNFOUPEPSgEJP FOPTFYQMJDBPTFHVOEPGBUP TFVVTPDPUJEJBOPFJOUFOTPGFJ UPQFMPQPEFSOB[JTUBBMFNkPDPNGJOBMJEBEFEFQSPQBHBOEB QPMrUJDB &YQMJRVFPRVFnP#JH#SPUIFS RVFBQBSFDFOPSPNBODF EF(FPSHF0SXFMM $PNPTFEFVBCBOBMJ[BmkPEFTTB GJHVSBQFMBUFMFWJTkP #JH#SPUIFS PVP(SBOEF*SNkP nVNBQFSTPOBHFNEPSP NBODFEF(FPSHF0SXFMM 0SPNBODFEFTDSFWFVNBTPDJF EBEFUPUBMJUgSJBOBRVBMUPEPTTkPQFSNBOFOUFNFOUFWJHJBEPT QPSDiNFSBTEFUFMFWJTkP"PJOGSJOHJSFNBMHVNBSFHSBPVMFJ TkPQSFTPTFUPSUVSBEPT DPOEJDJPOBEPTQBSBOkPWPMUBSBFSSBS "TQFTTPBTOkPDPOWJWFNVNBTDPNBTPVUSBT NBTTFOUFNTP MJEkPFOFDFTTJEBEFEFTFDPNVOJDBS1BSBJTTP UPEPTPTEJBT FWgSJBTWF[FTQPSEJB²DPOWFSTBN³DPNVNBUFMBEFUFMFWJTkP OBRVBMIgVNSPTUPCPOEPTP P#JH#SPUIFS P(SBOEF*SNkP RVFPTWJHJBFMIFTGBMB TFNOBWFSEBEFEJ[FSMIFTOBEB BOkP TFSEBSMIFTPSEFOT&TTBIJTUwSJBUFSSrWFMTPCSFPDPOUSPMFEF DPSQPT DPSBm{FTFNFOUFTEBTQFTTPBTQPSTJTUFNBTDSVnJTEF WJHJMiODJBFNTPDJFEBEFTUPUBMJUgSJBTUFWFTFVDPOUF|EPDSrUJDP JOUFJSBNFOUFFTWB[JBEPBPTFSWJSEFNPEFMPQBSBVNQSPHSBNB EFUFMFWJTkP²FOHSBmBEPFEJWFSUJEP³ VNFOUSFUFOJNFOUP DPNP BDPOUFDFDPNUVEPOBJOE|TUSJBDVMUVSBM &YQMJRVFBTEJWJT{FTEFQ|CMJDP IPSgSJPTFDPOUF|EPTEPT QSPHSBNBTEFUFMFWJTkPQBSBBUFOEFShTFYJHpODJBTEPT QBUSPDJOBEPSFT &YJTUFNBTEJWJT{FTEPQ|CMJDPFNDMBTTFT " # $F% FIP SgSJPT BQSPHSBNBmkPTFPSHBOJ[BFNIPSgSJPTFTQFDrGJDPTRVF DPNCJOBNBDMBTTF BPDVQBmkPFPTFYP &TTBEJWJTkPnGFJUB QBSBBUFOEFShTFYJHpODJBTEPTQBUSPDJOBEPSFT RVFGJOBODJBN
PTQSPHSBNBTUFOEPFNWJTUBPTDPOTVNJEPSFTQPUFODJBJTF QPSUBOUP DSJBNBFTQFDJGJDBmkPEPDPOUF|EPFEPIPSgSJPEFDB EBQSPHSBNB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BGPSNBFPIPSgSJPEPQSPHSB NBKgUSB[FNFNTFVQSwQSJPJOUFSJPSBNBSDBEPQBUSPDJOBEPS .VJUBTWF[FTPQBUSPDJOBEPSGJOBODJBVNQSPHSBNBRVFOBEB UFNBWFS EJSFUBNFOUF DPNPDPOUF|EPFBGPSNBWFJDVMBEPT &MFPGB[QPSRVF OFTTFDBTP OkPFTUgWFOEFOEPVNQSPEVUP NBTBJNBHFNEFTVBFNQSFTBcBTTJN QPSFYFNQMP RVFVNB FNQSFTBEFDPTNnUJDPTQPEF FNMVHBSEFQBUSPDJOBSVNQSP HSBNBGFNJOJOP QBUSPDJOBSDPODFSUPTEFN|TJDBDMgTTJDBVNB SFWFOEFEPSBEFNPUPDJDMFUBT FNMVHBSEFQBUSPDJOBSVNQSP HSBNBQBSBBEPMFTDFOUFT QPEFQBUSPDJOBSVNQSPHSBNBTPCSF FDPMPHJB 1PSRVFPTOPUJDJgSJPTEFUFMFWJTkPOkPJOGPSNBN $PNP USBUBNPFTQBmP &PUFNQP 1BSBOkPQFSEFSPDMJFOUF BFNJTTPSBEFSgEJPPVEFUFMF WJTkPOkPWFJDVMBOPUrDJBTEFTGBWPSgWFJTBEFUFSNJOBEPQB USPDJOBEPSF QJPS WFJDVMBTPNFOUFBTRVFMIFTkPGBWPSgWFJT %FTTBNBOFJSB PEJSFJUPhJOGPSNBmkPEFTBQBSFDFFPTPV WJOUFTPVUFMFTQFDUBEPSFTTkPEFTJOGPSNBEPTPVGJDBNNBM JOGPSNBEPT%FNPEPHFSBM BTOPUrDJBTTkPBQSFTFOUBEBTEF NBOFJSBBJNQFEJSRVFPPVWJOUFFPFTQFDUBEPSQPTTBNMPDB MJ[gMBTOPFTQBmPFOPUFNQP'BMUBEFMPDBMJ[BmkPOPFTQBmP PFTQBmPSFBMnPBQBSFMIPEFSgEJPFBUFMBEBUFMFWJTkP RVF UpNBQFDVMJBSJEBEFEFSFUJSBSBTEJGFSFOmBTFEJTUiODJBTHFP HSgGJDBT EFUBMNPEPRVFBMHPPDPSSJEPOB$IJOB OBÊOEJB OP *SBRVF OPT&TUBEPT6OJEPTPVFN$BNQJOB(SBOEFQBSFmB JHVBMNFOUFQSwYJNPFJHVBMNFOUFEJTUBOUF'BMUBEFMPDBMJ[B mkPOPUFNQPPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTTkPSFMBUBEPTDPNPTFOkP UJWFTTFNDBVTBTQBTTBEBTOFNFGFJUPTGVUVSPTTVSHFNDPNP QPOUPTQVSBNFOUFBUVBJTPVQSFTFOUFT TFNDPOUJOVJEBEFOP UFNQP TFNPSJHFNFTFNDPOTFRVpODJBTFYJTUFNFORVBOUP GPSFNPCKFUPTEFUSBOTNJTTkPFEFJYBNEFFYJTUJSTFOkPGPSFN USBOTNJUJEPT $PNPBTUFMFOPWFMBTPQFSBNQBSBQSPEV[JSPTFOUJNFOUP JMVTwSJPEFSFBMJEBEF &MBTPGB[FNVTBOEPUSpTQSPDFEJNFOUPTQSJODJQBJT P UFNQPEPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTUFMFOPWFMrTUJDPTnMFOUPQBSBEBSB JMVTkPEFRVF BDBEBDBQrUVMP QBTTPVTFBQFOBTVNEJBEF OPTTBWJEB PVQBTTBSBNTFBQFOBTBMHVNBTIPSBT UBJTDPNP SFBMNFOUFQBTTBSJBNTFGyTTFNPTOwTBWJWFSPTBDPOUFDJNFO UPTOBSSBEPT BTQFSTPOBHFOT TFVTIgCJUPT TVBMJOHVBHFN TVBTDBTBT TVBTSPVQBT TFVTPCKFUPTTkPBQSFTFOUBEPTDPNP NgYJNPEFSFBMJTNPQPTTrWFM EFNPEPBJNQFEJSRVFOPTTJOUB NPTEJTUBOUFTEFMFT DPNPOPTTFOUJNPTOPDJOFNBFOPUFBUSP DPNPDPOTFRVpODJB BUFMFOPWFMBOPTBQBSFDFDPNPSFMBUPEP SFBM FORVBOUPPOPUJDJgSJPOPTBQBSFDFDPNPJSSFBM±CBTUBPC TFSWBSRVBOEPVNBDPOUFDJNFOUPFTQBOUPTPPDPSSJEPFNPVUSB QBSUFEPNVOEPnBQSFTFOUBEPDPNPTFGPTTFVNDBQrUVMPEF UFMFOPWFMB BPQBTTPRVFIgVNBGBMUBEFSFBmkPEBTQFTTPBT EJBOUFEFDIBDJOBTSFBJT PDPSSJEBTOBTQSPYJNJEBEFTFBQSF TFOUBEBTDPNPOPUJDJgSJP &YQMJRVFBEJTQFSTkPDBVTBEBQFMPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDB mkP 1BSBBUFOEFSBPTJOUFSFTTFTFDPOyNJDPTEPTQBUSPDJOBEP SFT SgEJPFUFMFWJTkPEJWJEFNBQSPHSBNBmkPFNCMPDPTRVFEV SBNEFTFUFBEF[NJOVUPT TFOEPDBEBCMPDPJOUFSSPNQJEPQFMPT DPNFSDJBJT&TTBEJWJTkPEPUFNQPOPTMFWBBDPODFOUSBSBBUFO mkPEVSBOUFPTTFUFPVEF[NJOVUPTEFQSPHSBNBFBEFTDPODFO USgMBEVSBOUFBTQBVTBTQBSBBQVCMJDJEBEF1PVDPBQPVDPJTTP
3.
Manual do Professor
TFUPSOBVNIgCJUP6NEPTSFTVMUBEPTEFTTBNVEBOmBNFOUBM USBOTQBSFDFRVBOEPBDSJBOmBFPKPWFNUFOUBNMFSVNMJWSPOkP DPOTFHVFNMFSNBJTEPRVFTFUFBEF[NJOVUPTEFDBEBWF[ OkP DPOTFHVFNTVQPSUBSBBVTpODJBEFJNBHFOTFJMVTUSBm{FTOPUFY UP OkPTVQPSUBNBJEFJBEFQSFDJTBSMFS²VNMJWSPJOUFJSP³/FTTF BTQFDUP BBUFOmkPFBDPODFOUSBmkP BDBQBDJEBEFEFBCTUSBmkP JOUFMFDUVBMFEFFYFSDrDJPEPQFOTBNFOUPGPSBNEFTUSVrEBT &YQMJRVFBJOGBOUJMJ[BmkPQSPEV[JEBQFMPTNFJPTEFDPNV OJDBmkP 6NBQFTTPB DSJBOmBPVOkP nJOGBOUJMRVBOEPOkPDPOTF HVFTVQPSUBSBEJTUiODJBUFNQPSBMFOUSFTFVEFTFKPFBTBUJT GBmkPEFMF"DSJBOmBnJOGBOUJMKVTUBNFOUFQPSRVFQBSBFMBP JOUFSWBMPFOUSFPEFTFKPFBTBUJTGBmkPnJOUPMFSgWFM QPSJTTPB DSJBOmBQFRVFOJOBDIPSBUBOUP 0RVFGB[FNPTNFJPTEFDPNV OJDBmkP 1SPNFUFNFPGFSFDFNHSBUJGJDBmkPJOTUBOUiOFB DSJBO EPFNOwTPTEFTFKPTFPGFSFDFOEPQSPEVUPTQBSBTBUJTGB[pMPT 0PVWJOUFRVFHJSBPEJBMEPBQBSFMIPEFSgEJPDPOUJOVBNFOUF FPUFMFTQFDUBEPSRVFNVEBDPOUJOVBNFOUFEFDBOBMPGB[FN QPSRVFTBCFNRVF FNBMHVNMVHBS TFVEFTFKPTFSgJNFEJBUB NFOUFTBUJTGFJUP"MnNEJTTP DPNPBQSPHSBNBmkPTFEJSJHFBP RVFKgTBCFNPTFKgHPTUBNPT PTNFJPTTBUJTGB[FNJNFEJBUB NFOUFOPTTPTEFTFKPTQPSRVFOkPFYJHFNEFOwTBUFOmkP QFO TBNFOUP SFGMFYkP DSrUJDB QFSUVSCBmkPEFOPTTBTFOTJCJMJEBEF FEFOPTTBGBOUBTJB&NTVNB PTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPOPT TBUJTGB[FNQPSRVFOBEBOPTQFEFN TFOkPRVFQFSNBOFmBNPT QBSBTFNQSFJOGBOUJT $PNPQPEFNPTQFSDFCFSPBVUPSJUBSJTNPEPTNFJPTEFDP NVOJDBmkP 1PSRVFQPEFNPTGBMBSFN²JOUJNJEBmkPTP DJBM³FFN²JODVMDBmkP³
4FHVOEP.BOEFS RVBJTBTMJNJUBm{FT UFDOPMwHJDBTEB USBOTNJTTkPUFMFWJTJWB %FQPJTEFFOVNFSgMBT FTDPMIB VNBEFMBTFFYQMJRVFB "VTpODJBEFTVUJMF[BOBUFMFWJTkP UVEPnSFEV[JEPBP BJTTJNQMFT EFJNBHFOTFTJUVBm{FTBUnTFOUJNFOUPT GB[FOEP N EFTBQBSFDFSBTVUJMF[BEBWJEBJOUFSJPSFFNPDJPOBM 3FEV mkPEBQFSDFQmkPBUFMFWJTkPTwQPEFUSBOTNJUJSTJOBJTWJTVBJT FTPOPSPTBUSBOTNJTTkPEJGJDJMNFOUFDPOTFHVFSFQSPEV[JSB TJNVMUBOFJEBEFEBJNBHFN PVTFKB PTPNOFNTFNQSFFT UgDPOFDUBEPhJNBHFNOBUFMFWJTkP BJNBHFNOkPQPEFUFS QSPGVOEJEBEF QPSRVFnTFNQSFBDIBUBEBPNPWJNFOUPOVODB QPEFTFSWJTUPOPTFVSJUNPQSwQSJP QPSRVFnTFNQSFEJTUPS DJEPFEFGPSNBEP 3FHSBTEFUSBOTNJTTkPFNEFDPSSpODJB EBTMJNJUBm{FTUFDOPMwHJDBTEPNFJP BUFMFWJTkPPCFEFDFBVN DPOKVOUPEFSFHSBTRVFEFUFSNJOBNPRVFnNFMIPSQBSBBUSBOT NJTTkPFPRVFEFWFTFSFWJUBEP 4FHVOEP.BOEFS PRVF²UFMFWJTJPOBCFN³FPRVF²OkP UFMFWJTJPOBCFN³ 2VFDPODMVT{FTQPEFNPTUJSBSEFTTB BOgMJTF 4FHVOEP.BOEFS BHVFSSBUFMFWJTJPOBNFMIPSEPRVFBQB[ BWJPMpODJBUFMFWJTJPOBNFMIPSEPRVFBOkPWJPMpODJBGBUPTFY UFSOPTUFMFWJTJPOBNNFMIPSEPRVFJOGPSNBm{FTDPJTBTUFMFWJ TJPOBNNFMIPSEPRVFTFSFTWJWPTMrEFSFTSFMJHJPTPTFQPMrUJDPT DBSJTNgUJDPTUFMFWJTJPOBNNFMIPSEPRVFPTOkPDBSJTNgUJDPT VNB|OJDBQFTTPBnNBJTCFNUSBOTNJTTrWFMEPRVFNVJUBTPSHB OJ[Bm{FTIJFSgSRVJDBTUFMFWJTJPOBNNFMIPSEPRVFPSHBOJ[Bm{FT EFNPDSgUJDBTBTTVOUPTDVSUPTDPNDPNFmP NFJPFGJNTkPNF MIPSFTQBSBB57EPRVFBTTVOUPTMPOHPTFBQSPGVOEBEPTTFOUJ NFOUPTEFDPOGMJUPUFMFWJTJPOBNNFMIPSEPRVFTFOUJNFOUPTEF EJTDwSEJB QPSJTTP DPNQFUJmkPUFMFWJTJPOBNFMIPSEPRVFDPP QFSBmkP BNCJmkPFDPOTVNPUFMFWJTJPOBNNFMIPSEPRVFFTQJ SJUVBMJEBEFRVBOEPUFMFWJTJPOBS²QPWPTQSJNJUJWPT³ BQSFTFOUF EBOmB DBOUP DBmB QFTDB MVUBTFFWJUFFOUSFWJTUBTTVCKFUJWBTOBT RVBJTTFFYQSJNFNJEFJBT PQJOJ{FT TFOUJNFOUPTDPNQMFYPTP CJ[BSSPFFTUSBOIPUFMFWJTJPOBNVJUPCFNBFYQSFTTkPGBDJBMn NFMIPSEPRVFPTFOUJNFOUPBNPSUFUFMFWJTJPOBNFMIPSEPRVF BWJEB
0BVUPSJUBSJTNPQPEFTFSQFSDFCJEP QPSFYFNQMP TPCB BQBSpODJBEFEFNPDSBDJB6NEPTNFMIPSFTFYFNQMPTFODPO USBTFOPTQSPHSBNBTEFBDPOTFMIBNFOUP6NFTQFDJBMJTUBOPT FOTJOBBWJWFS VNPVUSPOPTFOTJOBBDSJBSPTGJMIPT PVUSPOPT FOTJOBBGB[FSTFYP FBTTJNWkPTFTVDFEFOEPFTQFDJBMJTUBT RVFOPTFOTJOBNBUFSVNDPSQPKVWFOJMFTBVEgWFM CPBTNB OFJSBT KBSEJOBHFN NFEJUBmkPFTQJSJUVBM FOGJN OkPIgVN |OJDPBTQFDUPEFOPTTBFYJTUpODJBRVFEFJYFEFTFSFOTJOBEP QPSVNFTQFDJBMJTUBDPNQFUFOUF0OEFTFFODPOUSBPMBEPBV UPSJUgSJPEFTTFUJQPEFQSPHSBNBmkPFEFQVCMJDBmkP /PGBUP EFRVFGVODJPOBNDPNPJOUJNJEBmkPTPDJBM6NBWF[RVFOPT UPSOBNPTEwDFJTFQBTTJWPT PTQSPHSBNBTEFBDPOTFMIBNFO UP MPOHFEFEJWVMHBSJOGPSNBm{FT DPNPQBSFDFTFSBJOUFOmkP HFOFSPTBEPTFTQFDJBMJTUBT
UPSOBNTFVNQSPDFTTPEFJODVM DBmkPEFWBMPSFT IgCJUPT DPNQPSUBNFOUPTFJEFJBT QPJTOkP FTUBNPTQSFQBSBEPTQBSBQFOTBS BWBMJBSFKVMHBSPRVFWFNPT PVWJNPTFMFNPT1PSJTTP GJDBNPTJOUJNJEBEPT JTUPn QBTTB NPTBDPOTJEFSBSRVFOBEBTBCFNPT RVFTPNPTJODPNQFUFO UFTQBSBWJWFSFBHJSTFOkPTFHVJSNPTBBVUPSJEBEFDPNQFUFOUF EPFTQFDJBMJTUB
&NOPTTBTPDJFEBEF BUFMFWJTkPnVNNFJPUnDOJDPEFDP NVOJDBmkPBEJTUiODJBRVFFNQSFTUBEPKPSOBMJTNPBJEFJBEF SFQPSUBHFNFOPUrDJB EBMJUFSBUVSBBJEFJBEFGPMIFUJNOPWFMFT DP EPUFBUSPBJEFJBEFSFMBmkPDPNPQ|CMJDPQSFTFOUFFEP DJOFNBPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTDPNJNBHFOT%PQPOUPEFWJTUBEP SFDFQUPS PBQBSFMIPUFMFWJTJWPnVNFMFUSPEPNnTUJDP DPNPP MJRVJEJGJDBEPSPVBHFMBEFJSB%PQPOUPEFWJTUBEPQSPEVUPS FMFnVNDFOUSPEFQPEFSFDPOyNJDPFQPMrUJDPFEFDPOUSPMFTP DJBMFDVMUVSBMcVNBNFSDBEPSJBRVFUSBOTNJUFFWFOEFPVUSBT NFSDBEPSJBT
&YQMJRVFQPSRVF EPQPOUPEFWJTUBFDPOyNJDP BUFMFWJTkP FNOPTTBTPDJFEBEF OkPQPEFTFSEFNPDSgUJDB
0RVFnPDJOFNB 2VFGVOmkPFMFDVNQSFFNOPTTBTP DJFEBEF
1PSRVFBTSFEFTEFUFMFWJTkPTkPPVQSPQSJFEBEFTQSJWBEBT PVDPODFTT{FTFTUBUBJTQBSBFNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTRVF DPNPUBJT PQFSBNDPNBTJEFJBTEFMVDSPFEFDPOTFSWBmkPEFTFVQSwQSJP QPEFS$PNPDPOTFRVpODJB BFTDPMIBEPDPOUF|EPEPTQSPHSB NBTnEFUFSNJOBEBQFMPDSJUnSJPEPMVDSPFEBDPOTFSWBmkPEP QPEFSEPTQSPQSJFUgSJPT0VUSPT QPSUBOUP EFDJEFNPRVFQP EFNPTFEFWFNPTWFS4PNPTSFDFQUPSFTFOkPQSPEVUPSFTEF JOGPSNBmkPFEBDPNVOJDBmkP DPNPTFSJBPDBTP TFBUFMFWJTkP GPTTFEFNPDSgUJDB
0DJOFNBnBJOWFOmkPEFVNBGPSNBDPOUFNQPSiOFBEF BSUFBEBJNBHFNTPOPSBFNNPWJNFOUP/FMF BDiNFSBDBQUB VNBTPDJFEBEFDPNQMFYB N|MUJQMBFEJGFSFODJBEB DPNCJOBO EPEFNBOFJSBUPUBMNFOUFOPWBN|TJDB EBOmB MJUFSBUVSB FT DVMUVSB QJOUVSB BSRVJUFUVSB IJTUwSJB FDSJBSFBMJEBEFTOPWBT JOTwMJUBT OVNBJNBHJOBmkPQMgTUJDBJOGJOJUBRVFTwUFNDPSSFT QPOEFOUFFNTPOIPT%FPVUSPQPOUPEFWJTUB PDJOFNBnVNB JOE|TUSJBEFQFOEFEFJOWFTUJNFOUPT NFSDBEPT QSPQBHBOEB QSFPDVQBTFDPNPMVDSP BNPEB PDPOTVNP
3/
0RVFnBUFMFWJTkPFNOPTTBTPDJFEBEF
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
2VBJTBTEVBTQSJODJQBJTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFPDJOFNBFBUF MFWJTkP &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS PDJOFNBOkPFTUgTVCNFUJEPhTMJNJUB m{FTUFDOPMwHJDBTRVFEPNJOBNBUFMFWJTkPFNTFHVOEPMVHBS OPDJOFNBTkPQPTTrWFJTBTQSPEVm{FTJOEFQFOEFOUFT BTPCSBT BSUrTUJDBTFBTSFGMFY{FTDSrUJDBT BVTFOUFTOBUFMFWJTkP &TDPMIBVNGJMNFRVFWPDpUFOIBWJTUPOPRVBMBGPSNBFP DPOUF|EPTkPWFSEBEFJSBTSFBMJ[Bm{FTBSUrTUJDBT'BmBVN CSFWFDPNFOUgSJPTPCSFFMF 3FTQPTUBQFTTPBMEPBMVOP1SPGFTTPS B FNCPSBBFTDPMIB EPGJMNFFTUFKBBDBSHPEPBMVOP BPQmkPEFWFSgDJSDVOTDSF WFSTFBPTDIBNBEPT²GJMNFTEFBSUF³ BRVFMFTFNRVF²BDSJB UJWJEBEFEPEJSFUPSFEFTVBFRVJQFUnDOJDBFBFYQSFTTJWJEBEF ESBNgUJDBPVDyNJDBEPTJOUnSQSFUFTQPEFNNBOJGFTUBSTFDPN TVUJMF[BFEJWFSTJEBEF JEFJBTFPQJOJ{FTQPEFNTFSUSBCBMIB EBT JOUFSQSFUBEBTFUSBOTNJUJEBT PGFSFDFOEPTFQMFOBNFOUF BPQ|CMJDP TFNEJTUJOmkPnUOJDB TFYVBM SFMJHJPTBPVTPDJBM³ $PNP"EBN4DIBGGEJGFSFODJBPTBOUJHPTPCKFUPTUnDOJDPT EPTOPWPTPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPT 1BSB"EBN4DIBGG PTBOUJHPTPCKFUPTUnDOJDPTBNQMJBWBN BGPSmBGrTJDBIVNBOB FORVBOUPPTOPWPTPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPT BNQMJBNBTGPSmBTJOUFMFDUVBJTIVNBOBT 0RVFRVFSEJ[FS²JOGPSNgUJDB³ 0UFSNPJOGPSNgUJDBEFTJHOBPTOPWPTPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJ DPTRVFQSPEV[FNFUSBOTNJUFNJOGPSNBm{FT FNFTQFDJBMPT DPNQVUBEPSFT 0OEFTFFODPOUSBNPTOPWPTPCKFUPTUFDOPMwHJDPTPVBV UyNBUPTJOGPSNgUJDPT 0TDPNQVUBEPSFTFODPOUSBNTFOBTBSNBTFPQFSBm{FTNJ MJUBSFT OPTWPPTFTQBDJBJT OBTPQFSBm{FTEFBFSPQPSUPT EF CBODPTFCPMTBTEFWBMPSFT OPTTJTUFNBTVSCBOPTEFUSgGFHP FEFTFHVSBOmB OPTFEJGrDJPT²JOUFMJHFOUFT³ BMnNEFFTUBSFN QSFTFOUFTOPUSBCBMIPJOEVTUSJBMFOBTPQFSBm{FTFDPOyNJDBT 1PEFNPTWpMPTOPTDBSSPTEF|MUJNPUJQP OPTFTUBCFMFDJNFO UPTDPNFSDJBJT OPTTFUPSFTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTEBTJOTUJUVJm{FT Q|CMJDBTFQSJWBEBT OBTFTDPMBT OBTFEJUPSBTFHSgGJDBT OPT FTDSJUwSJPTEFFOHFOIBSJB BSRVJUFUVSBFBEWPDBDJB OPTDPOTVM UwSJPTNnEJDPTFIPTQJUBJT OBTQSPEVUPSBTDJOFNBUPHSgGJDBT GPOPHSgGJDBT UFMFWJTJWBTFSBEJPGyOJDBT GB[FNQBSUFEPUSBCB MIPEPTFTDSJUPSFT BSUJTUBT QSPGFTTPSFTFFTUVEBOUFT BMnNEF PQFSBSDPNPDPSSFJPFDPNPMB[FSFFOUSFUFOJNFOUP 1PSRVFBJOGPSNgUJDBQSPEV[B²DPNQSFTTkPFTQBmPUFN QPSBM³ %pFYFNQMPT 1PSRVFBUFDOPMPHJBFMFUSyOJDBSFEV[EJTUiODJBT DPNQSJNF PFTQBmP FQPSRVFPSFUPSOPEPMVDSPBPDBQJUBMJOWFTUJEPnSB QJErTTJNP DPNQSJNFPUFNQP
m{FT TkPNBJTQPOEFSBEPTRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTF TFFS SBNPVGBMIBN nQPSBMHVNBJOUFSGFSpODJBJOEFWJEBEFBMHVN TFSIVNBOPNBMJOUFODJPOBEP$PNPPCTFSWB4PBSFT BWJTkP NgHJDBPDVMUBPGBUPEFRVFPDPNQVUBEPSnVNBNgRVJOBF DPNPUBM QSPEV[JEB QSPHSBNBEB DPOTFSWBEBFPQFSBEBQPS TFSFTIVNBOPT 2VBJTPTQSPCMFNBTDPMPDBEPTQFMBMJOHVBHFNJOGPSNgUJ DB "PQSFEPNJOBSOBMJOHVBHFNJOGPSNgUJDBBMrOHVBJOHMFTB P VTPFBQPTTFEPDPNQVUBEPSBQBSFDFNQBSBBTQFTTPBTDPNP TJOBMEFTUBUVTTPDJBM QPEFSFQSFTUrHJP%JTTPSFTVMUBNEVBT DPOTFRVpODJBTQSJODJQBJTPVPTRVFJHOPSBNBMrOHVBJOHMFTB GJDBNFYDMVrEPTEPVTPEPDPNQVUBEPS RVFGVODJPOB QPSUBOUP DPNVNQPEFSEFFYDMVTkPDVMUVSBM PVPTVTVgSJPTTFIBCJUVBN BFNQSFHBSQBMBWSBTDPNPXPSE JOQVU PVUQVU EVNQT EPXO MPBE FNBJM EFMFUF JOTFSU IPNFQBHF FUDTFNUFSBNFOPSJEFJB EPRVFTJHOJGJDBN0VTFKB BPFNQSFHBSDPNOBUVSBMJEBEFVN WPDBCVMgSJPDVKPTFOUJEPMIFFTDBQBFBPSFUFSQBMBWSBTDPNPTF GPTTFNNFSBTPQFSBm{FTEFVNPCKFUPUnDOJDP PVTVgSJPUFOEF BOkPQFSDFCFSPDPNQVUBEPSDPNPVNBNFSDBEPSJBQSPEV[JEB FDPNFSDJBMJ[BEBQPSHSBOEFTNPOPQwMJPTFDPOyNJDPTJOUFSOB DJPOBJTRVFEPNJOBNBDPNQFUJmkPOPNFSDBEPFJNQ{FNTVB MJOHVBHFNFTVBTMFJT4FOEPBTTJN PVTVgSJPEPDPNQVUBEPS UFOEFOkPTwBBGJSNBSJNQMJDJUBNFOUFPDBSgUFSNJTUFSJPTPEP PCKFUPFNQSFHBEP NBTUBNCnNBJHOPSBS EFVNMBEP RVFB FYDMVTkPEFNVJUPTOkPnJOUFMFDUVBMFTJNTPDJBM OkPFTUkPFY DMVrEPTQPSTFSFNJODBQB[FTEFPQFSBSUBMPCKFUPFTJNQPSRVF EFTDPOIFDFNBMrOHVBFNRVFBTPQFSBm{FTGPSBNGJYBEBT F EFPVUSP RVFPVTPBEFRVBEPBDBSSFUBEFQFOEpODJBFDPOyNJ DBFDVMUVSBM 0RVFnPQPEFSJOGPSNgUJDP 0QPEFSJOGPSNgUJDPDPOTUJUVJTFOBQPTTFEFJOGPSNBm{FT DJFOUrGJDBT UnDOJDBT FDPOyNJDBT QPMrUJDBTFNJMJUBSFT DPOGJHV SBOEPVNBTPDJFEBEFOBRVBMUPEBTBTFTGFSBTEBWJEBQ|CMJDB FEBWJEBQSJWBEBFTUkPDPCFSUBTQPSQSPDFTTPTJOGPSNBUJ[BEPT FQPSJOUFMJHpODJBTBSUJGJDJBJT 2VBJTPTQFSJHPTEPQPEFSJOGPSNgUJDP 0QSJNFJSPQFSJHPnPQPEFSEFDPOUSPMFTPCSFBTQFTTPBT %FTTBNBOFJSB BTQFTTPBTQPEFNTFSDPOUSPMBEBTQFMPTQPEF SFTQ|CMJDPT DPNPPQPEFSQPMJDJBMFPQPEFSNJMJUBS 0TFHVO EPQFSJHPnBQPTTFEFJOGPSNBm{FTQPSQFTTPBTOkPBVUPSJ[B EBTRVFFOUSBNFNDPOUBUPDPNJOGPSNBm{FTTJHJMPTBTUBOUP EPTFUPSQ|CMJDPDPNPEBWJEBQSJWBEBEBTQFTTPBT0UFSDFJSP QFSJHPFTUgOBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVTPEFJOGPSNBm{FTQPSQPEF SFTQSJWBEPTQBSBDPOUSPMBSQFTTPBTFJOTUJUVJm{FT BTTJNDPNP QBSBDBVTBSMIFTEBOP±QPSFYFNQMP BFTQJPOBHFNJOEVTUSJBM FQPMrUJDBFBBmkPEPDSJNFPSHBOJ[BEP RVFVTBBTJOGPSNBm{FT QBSBQSBUJDBSTFRVFTUSPT DIBOUBHFOT BTTBTTJOBUPT
0 RVF ÅOHFMP 4PBSFT DIBNB EF ²NJUP EP DPNQVUBEPS CPN³ 0RVFFTTFNJUPPDVMUB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=ateop j_e]pe_]
4FHVOEPFMF USBUBTFEBJEFJBNgHJDBEFVNBNgRVJOB RVFSFTPMWFUVEPTJNQMFTNFOUFDPNPBQFSUBSEFVNCPUkP TFNOVODBFSSBS²0DPNQVUBEPSnVN´TFSPOJQPUFOUFμ CPN SBDJPOBM FGJDJFOUF RVFQFOTBFSFTPMWFUPEPTPTQSPCMFNBT BQSFTFOUBEPTBFMF EFGPSNBJNQBSDJBM JOWFTUJEPEFVNBMUP HSBVEFKVTUJmB³"MJUFSBUVSB PDJOFNBFBUFMFWJTkPBMJNFO UBNFTTFNJUPBPBQSFTFOUBSDPNQVUBEPSFTRVFGBMBN PVWFN TFOUFN UpNWPOUBEF TkPNPWJEPTQPSTFOUJNFOUPTFFNP
2VFnPTFOTPNPSBM %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPT 4FOTPNPSBMnBNBOFJSBDPNPBWBMJBNPTOPTTBTJUVBmkP FBEFOPTTPTTFNFMIBOUFT OPTTPDPNQPSUBNFOUP BDPOEVUB FBBmkPEFPVUSBTQFTTPBTTFHVOEPJEFJBTDPNPBTEFKVTUJmB FJOKVTUJmB DFSUPFFSSBEP EFNnSJUPFHSBOEF[BEFBMNB4kP FYFNQMPTEPTFOTPNPSBMBJOEJHOBmkPRVFTFOUJNPTEJBOUFEF QFTTPBTRVFQBTTBNGPNF POPTTPTFOUJNFOUPEFWFSHPOIB SFNPSTP DVMQBEJBOUFEFDPJTBTRVFKVMHBNPTUFSGFJUPEFFSSB
30
Manual do Professor
EP RVBOEPGJDBNPTDPOUFOUFTFFNPDJPOBEPTEJBOUFEFVNB QFTTPBDVKBTQBMBWSBTFBm{FTNBOJGFTUBNIPOFTUJEBEF IPO SBEF[ FTQrSJUPEFKVTUJmBFBMUSVrTNP 2VFnBDPOTDJpODJBNPSBM %pBMHVOTFYFNQMPT "DPOTDJpODJBNPSBMOkPTFMJNJUBBPTOPTTPTTFOUJNFOUPT PSBJT NBTTFSFGFSFUBNCnNBBWBMJBm{FTEFDPOEVUBRVFOPT N MFWBNBUPNBSEFDJT{FTQPSOwTNFTNPT BBHJSFNDPOGPSNJEB EFDPNFMBTFBSFTQPOEFSQPSFMBTQFSBOUFPTPVUSPTcPRVF PDPSSFRVBOEPFOGSFOUBNPTTJUVBm{FTBOHVTUJBOUFTRVFOPT EFJYBNFNE|WJEBRVBOUPhEFDJTkPBUPNBS DPNPFNDFSUPT DBTPTEFFVUBOgTJB EFBCPSUP EFEFMBmkP "RVFTFSFGFSFNPTFOTPNPSBMFBDPOTDJpODJBNPSBM 0TFOTPNPSBMFBDPOTDJpODJBNPSBMSFGFSFNTFBWBMPSFT KVTUJmB IPOSBEF[ FTQrSJUPEFTBDSJGrDJP JOUFHSJEBEF HFOFSP TJEBEF
BTFOUJNFOUPTQSPWPDBEPTQFMPTWBMPSFT BENJSBmkP WFSHPOIB DVMQB SFNPSTP DPOUFOUBNFOUP DwMFSB BNPS E|WJ EB NFEP FBEFDJT{FTRVFDPOEV[FNBBm{FTDPNDPOTFRVpO DJBTQBSBOwTFQBSBPTPVUSPT 2VBMPQSJODJQBMQSFTTVQPTUPEPTFOTPNPSBMFEBDPOTDJpO DJBNPSBM 1PSRVp 0TFOTPFBDPOTDJpODJBNPSBJTUpNDPNPQSFTTVQPTUP GVOEBNFOUBMBJEFJBEFMJCFSEBEF QPSRVFEFQFOEFNFYDMV TJWBNFOUFEFOwTNFTNPT OBTDFNEFOPTTBDBQBDJEBEFEF BWBMJBSFEFDJEJSQPSOwTNFTNPTFOkPMFWBEPTQPSPVUSPTPV PCSJHBEPTQPSFMFT 2VFnVNKVr[PEFGBUP %pFYFNQMPT +Vr[PTEFGBUPTkPBRVFMFTRVFEJ[FNRVFBMHPnPVFYJTUF FRVFEJ[FNPRVFBTDPJTBTTkP DPNPTkPFQPSRVFTkP1PS FYFNQMP ²FTUgDIPWFOEP³ ²FTUPVDPNGPNF³ ²DSJBOmBTFTUkP CSJODBOEP³ 2VFnVNKVr[PEFWBMPS %pFYFNQMPT +Vr[PTEFWBMPSBWBMJBNDPJTBT QFTTPBT Bm{FT FYQFSJpO DJBT BDPOUFDJNFOUPT TFOUJNFOUPT FTUBEPTEFFTQrSJUP JOUFO m{FTFEFDJT{FTDPNPCPOTPVNBVT EFTFKgWFJTPVJOEFTFKg WFJT/kPTFMJNJUBNBEJ[FSRVFBMHPnPVDPNPBMHPn NBTTF SFGFSFNBPRVFBMHPEFWFTFS1PSFYFNQMP ²BDIVWBnCPBQBSB BTQMBOUBT³ ²DPNFSEFNBJTGB[NBM³ ²DSJBOmBTFTUkPCSJODBO EPDPNDPJTBTnSJB³ 1PSRVFPTKVr[PTEFWBMPSTkPOPSNBUJWPT 0TKVr[PTEFWBMPSTkPOPSNBUJWPTQPSRVFFOVODJBNOPS NBTRVFEJ[FNDPNPEFWFNTFSPTCPOTTFOUJNFOUPT BTCPBT JOUFOm{FTFBTCPBTBm{FT FDPNPEFWFNTFSBTEFDJT{FTF Bm{FTMJWSFT&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT TkPOPSNBTRVFEFUFSNJOBN PEFWFSTFSEFOPTTPTTFOUJNFOUPT OPTTPTBUPT OPTTPTDPN QPSUBNFOUPT4kPQPSJTTPKVr[PTRVFFOVODJBNPCSJHBm{FTF BWBMJBNJOUFOm{FTFBm{FTTFHVOEPPDSJUnSJPEPDPSSFUPFEP JODPSSFUP 2VBMBPSJHFNEBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFKVr[PTEFGBUPFKVr[PTEF WBMPS &YQMJRVF "PSJHFNEBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFKVr[PTEFGBUPFKVr[PTEFWBMPS nBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFOBUVSF[BFDVMUVSB"OBUVSF[BnDPOTUJUVrEB QPSFTUSVUVSBTFQSPDFTTPTOFDFTTgSJPT RVFFYJTUFNFNTJFQPS TJNFTNPT JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFOwTBDIVWB QPSFYFNQMP +gBDVMUVSBOBTDFEBNBOFJSBDPNPPTTFSFTIVNBOPTJOUFS QSFUBNBTJNFTNPTFBTTVBTSFMBm{FTDPNBOBUVSF[B BDSFT
31
DFOUBOEPMIFTFOUJEPTOPWPT JOUFSWJOEPOFMB BMUFSBOEPBQPS NFJPEPUSBCBMIPFEBUnDOJDB EBOEPMIFTJHOJGJDBEPTTJNCwMJ DPTFWBMPSFT1PSFYFNQMP EJ[FSRVFBDIVWBnCFMBQSFTTVQ{F VNBSFMBmkPWBMPSBUJWBEPTIVNBOPTDPNBOBUVSF[B"DIVWB nOBUVSBMRVFTFKBCPBPVCFMBnVNBBWBMJBmkPPVJOUFSQSFUB mkPDVMUVSBM 0RVFnBOBUVSBMJ[BmkPEBWJEBNPSBM 1PSRVFFMBBDPOUFDF "OBUVSBMJ[BmkPEBWJEBNPSBMPDPSSFRVBOEPOkPOPUBNPT BPSJHFNDVMUVSBMEPTWBMPSFTNPSBJT EPTFOTPNPSBMFEBDPOT DJpODJBNPSBMQPSRVFTPNPTFEVDBEPTQBSBFMFTFOFMFT DPNP TFGPTTFNOBUVSBJTPVGgUJDPT FYJTUFOUFTFNTJFQPSTJNFTNPT *TTPBDPOUFDFQPSRVF QBSBHBSBOUJSBNBOVUFOmkPEPTQBES{FT NPSBJTBUSBWnTEPUFNQPFTVBDPOUJOVJEBEFEFHFSBmkPBHFSB mkP BTTPDJFEBEFTUFOEFNBOBUVSBMJ[gMPT JTUPn BGB[FSDPN RVFTFKBNTFHVJEPTFSFTQFJUBEPTDPNPTFGPTTFNVNBTFHVO EBOBUVSF[B &YQMJRVFPTFOUJEPEBTQBMBWSBTNPSBMFnUJDB .PSBMWFNEFVNBQBMBWSBMBUJOB NPT NPSJT RVFRVFSEJ [FS²PDPTUVNF³ FOPQMVSBM NPSFT TJHOJGJDB²PTIgCJUPTEF DPOEVUBPVEFDPNQPSUBNFOUPJOTUJUVrEPTQPSVNBTPDJFEBEF FNDPOEJm{FTIJTUwSJDBTEFUFSNJOBEBT³%BNFTNBNBOFJSB B QBMBWSBnUJDBWFNEFEVBTQBMBWSBTHSFHBTnUIPT RVFTJHOJGJDB ²PDBSgUFSEFBMHVnN³ FpUIPT RVFTJHOJGJDB²PDPOKVOUPEF DPTUVNFTJOTUJUVrEPTQPSVNBTPDJFEBEFQBSBGPSNBS SFHVMBSF DPOUSPMBSBDPOEVUBEFTFVTNFNCSPT³ "QFTBSEBTEJGFSFOmBTDVMUVSBJTFIJTUwSJDBTBSFTQFJUPEB WJPMpODJB RVFEFGJOJmkPHFSBMQPEFNPTEBSEBWJPMpODJB WgMJEBFNUPEBTBTDVMUVSBT 'VOEBNFOUBMNFOUF BWJPMpODJBnQFSDFCJEBDPNPFYFSDr DJPEBGPSmBGrTJDBFEPDPOTUSBOHJNFOUPQTrRVJDPQBSBPCSJHBS MHVnNBBHJSEFNPEPDPOUSgSJPhTVBOBUVSF[BFBPTFVTFS B PVDPOUSBTVBQSwQSJBWPOUBEF1PSNFJPEBGPSmBFEBDPBmkP QTrRVJDB PCSJHBTFBMHVnNBGB[FSBMHPDPOUSgSJPBTJ BPTTFVT JOUFSFTTFTFEFTFKPT BPTFVDPSQPFhTVBDPOTDJpODJB DBVTBO EPMIFEBOPTQSPGVOEPTFJSSFQBSgWFJT DPNPBNPSUF BMPVDVSB BBVUPBHSFTTkPPVBBHSFTTkPBPTPVUSPT 2VBJTPTQSJODJQBJTBTQFDUPTEPRVFOPTTBDVMUVSBFTPDJF EBEFFOUFOEFNQPSWJPMpODJB &NOPTTBDVMUVSBFTPDJFEBEF BWJPMpODJBnFOUFOEJEBDPNP WJPMBmkPEBJOUFHSJEBEFGrTJDBFQTrRVJDBEFBMHVnN EBTVBEJH OJEBEFIVNBOB UPSUVSB FTUVQSP DBM|OJB FUD 5BNCnNDPO TJEFSBNPTWJPMpODJBBQSPGBOBmkPEBTDPJTBTTBHSBEBT DPNP JOWBTkPFSPVCPEFJHSFKBT EFTUSVJmkPEFJNBHFOTTBHSBEBT FUD%BNFTNBNBOFJSB nWJPMpODJBBEJTDSJNJOBmkPTPDJBMF QPMrUJDBEFQFTTPBTQPSTVBTDPOEJm{FTnUOJDBT DSFOmBTSFMJHJP TBT DPOWJDm{FTQPMrUJDBTFQSFGFSpODJBTTFYVBJT TFKBQPSNFJP EFQSJTkP UPSUVSBFNPSUF 1PSRVFBnUJDBDPOEFOBFQSPrCFBWJPMpODJB 5PEPBUPEFWJPMpODJBSFEV[PTFSIVNBOPEFTVKFJUPBPCKF UP&OUSFUBOUP EPQPOUPEFWJTUBnUJDP TPNPTQFTTPBTFOkP QPEFNPTTFSUSBUBEPTDPNPDPJTBT JTUPn DPNPTFSFTJOFSUFT JSSBDJPOBJT EFTUJUVrEPTEFMJOHVBHFNFEFMJCFSEBEF0TWBMP SFTnUJDPTTFPGFSFDFN QPSUBOUP DPNPFYQSFTTkPFHBSBOUJB EFOPTTBDPOEJmkPEFTFSFTIVNBOPTPVEFTVKFJUPTSBDJPOBJT FBHFOUFTMJWSFT QSPJCJOEPNPSBMNFOUFBWJPMpODJB JTUPn UVEP PRVFOPTUSBOTGPSNFFNPCKFUP DPJTBVTBEBFNBOJQVMBEBQPS PVUSPT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
$PNPTFNBOJGFTUBBDPOTDJpODJBNPSBM "DPOTDJpODJBNPSBMNBOJGFTUBTF BOUFTEFUVEP OBDBQB DJEBEFQBSBEFMJCFSBSEJBOUFEFBMUFSOBUJWBTQPTTrWFJT BWBMJBO EPDBEBVNBEFMBTTFHVOEPPTWBMPSFTnUJDPT FQBSBEFDJEJSF FTDPMIFSVNBEFMBTBOUFTEFMBOmBSTFOBBmkP
"GJMPTPGJBNPSBMPVBnUJDBOBTDFRVBOEP BMnNEBTRVFTU{FT TPCSFPTDPTUVNFT UBNCnNTFCVTDBDPNQSFFOEFSPDBSgUFSEF DBEBQFTTPB JTUPn PTFOTPNPSBMFBDPOTDJpODJBNPSBMJOEJWJ EVBJT 1PSRVF4wDSBUFTJODPNPEBWBPTBUFOJFOTFT
4FSDPOTDJFOUFEFTJFEPTPVUSPTTFSEPUBEPEFWPOUBEF TFSSFTQPOTgWFMTFSMJWSF
1PSEPJTNPUJWPTQSJODJQBJTFNQSJNFJSPMVHBS QPSGB[pMPT QFSDFCFSRVFDPOGVOEJBNWBMPSFTNPSBJTDPNPTGBUPTDPOTUB UgWFJTFNTVBWJEBDPUJEJBOB EJ[JBN QPSFYFNQMP ²$PSBHFNn PRVFGF[GVMBOPOBHVFSSBDPOUSBPTQFSTBT³ NBTOkPTBCJBN FYQMJDBSPRVFnBDPSBHFN FNTFHVOEPMVHBS QPSNPTUSBS MIFTRVF JOWFSTBNFOUF UPNBWBNPTGBUPTEBWJEBDPUJEJBOB DPNPTFGPTTFNWBMPSFTNPSBJTFWJEFOUFT EJ[JBN QPSFYFN QMP ²cDFSUPGB[FSUBMBmkP QPSRVFNFVTBOUFQBTTBEPTBGJ[F SBNFNFVTQBSFOUFTBGB[FN³ NBTOkPJOEBHBWBNBPSJHFN FBFTTpODJBEFUBMBmkP &NSFTVNP DPOGVOEJBNGBUPTFWBMP SFT QPJTJHOPSBWBNBTDBVTBTPVSB[{FTQPSRVFWBMPSJ[BWBN DFSUBTDPJTBT DFSUBTQFTTPBTPVDFSUBTBm{FT FEFTQSF[BWBN PVUSBT
&YQMJRVFBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFQBTTJWJEBEFFBUJWJEBEF
1PSRVFBGJMPTPGJBNPSBMPVBnUJDBTFJOJDJBDPN4wDSBUFT
1BTTJWPnPTVKFJUPNPSBMIFUFSyOPNP JTUPn BRVFMFRVF TFEFJYBHPWFSOBSFBSSBTUBSQPSTFVTJNQVMTPT JODMJOBm{FTF QBJY{FT QFMBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT QFMBCPBPVNgTPSUF QFMBPQJ OJkPBMIFJB QFMPNFEPEPTPVUSPT QFMBWPOUBEFEFVNPVUSP OkPFYFSDFOEPTVBQSwQSJBDPOTDJpODJB WPOUBEF MJCFSEBEF FSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF"PDPOUSgSJP nBUJWPPVWJSUVPTPPTVKFJ UPNPSBMBVUyOPNP JTUPn BRVFMFRVFDPOUSPMBJOUFSJPSNFOUF TFVTJNQVMTPT TVBTJODMJOBm{FTFTVBTQBJY{FT EJTDVUFDPO TJHPNFTNPFDPNPTPVUSPTPTFOUJEPEPTWBMPSFTFEPTGJOT FTUBCFMFDJEPT JOEBHBTFEFWFNFDPNPEFWFNTFSSFTQFJUBEPT PVUSBOTHSFEJEPTQPSPVUSPTWBMPSFTFGJOTTVQFSJPSFTBPTFYJT UFOUFT BWBMJBTVBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBEBSBTJNFTNPBTSFHSBTEF DPOEVUB DPOTVMUBTVBSB[kPFTVBWPOUBEFBOUFTEFBHJS UFN DPOTJEFSBmkPQFMPTPVUSPTTFNTVCPSEJOBSTFOFNTVCNFUFS TFDFHBNFOUFBFMFT SFTQPOEFQFMPRVFGB[ KVMHBTVBTQSwQSJBT JOUFOm{FTFSFDVTBBWJPMpODJBDPOUSBTJFDPOUSBPTPVUSPT
1PSRVFBTRVFTU{FTTPDSgUJDBTEFGJOFNPDBNQPOPRVBM WBMPSFTFPCSJHBm{FTNPSBJTQPEFNTFSFTUBCFMFDJEPTQFMB EFUFSNJOBmkPEFTFVQPOUPEFQBSUJEBBDPOTDJpODJBEPBHFO UFNPSBM
0RVFTkPBTWJSUVEFT "QFTBSEBTEJGFSFOmBTDVMUVSBJT P RVFUPEBTBTDVMUVSBTDPOTJEFSBNRVFTFKBBWJSUVEF
4FHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT RVBMnPDBNQPEBTBm{FTnUJDBT 1PS RVFFTTBDPODFQmkPFYDMVJPOFDFTTgSJPFPDPOUJOHFOUFEP DBNQPnUJDPFBGJSNBBJNQPSUiODJBEPQPTTrWFM
0RVFnBWPOUBEF $PNPFMBEFWFTFSQBSBTFSnUJDB "WPOUBEFnPQPEFSEFMJCFSBUJWPFEFDJTwSJPEPBHFOUFNP SBM1BSBTFSnUJDB BWPOUBEFEFWFTFSMJWSF JTUPn OkPQPEFFTUBS TVCNFUJEBhWPOUBEFEFVNPVUSPOFNQPEFFTUBSTVCNFUJEB BPTJOTUJOUPT PVJNQVMTPTOBUVSBJTDFHPT FhTQBJY{FT TFOUJ NFOUPTFFNPm{FTJODPOUSPMgWFJTRVFEPNJOBNPBHFOUF
NBT BPDPOUSgSJP EFWFUFSQPEFSTPCSFFMFTFFMBT EPNJOBOEPPTF DPOUSPMBOEPPT 2VBJTBTDPOEJm{FTQBSBRVFIBKBVNBQFTTPBNPSBM
"TWJSUVEFTTkPDPOTJEFSBEBTPTGJOTEBBmkPnUJDBPVB GJOBMJEBEFEBWJEBNPSBM*OEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEPDPOUF|EPF EBGPSNBRVFDBEBDVMUVSBMIFEg UPEBTBTDVMUVSBTDPOTJEFSBN WJSUVEFBMHPRVFnPNFMIPSDPNPTFOUJNFOUP DPNPDPOEVUB FDPNPBmkP 1PSRVFOBnUJDBOkPTFBQMJDBBFYQSFTTkP²PTGJOTKVTUJGJ DBNPTNFJPT³ 1PSRVFIgNFJPTRVFEFTSFTQFJUBNBDPOTDJpODJBFBMJCFS EBEFEBQFTTPBNPSBM RVFQPEFBHJSQPSDPBmkPFYUFSOBFOkP QPSSFDPOIFDJNFOUPJOUFSJPSFWFSEBEFJSPEPGJNnUJDPcPDBTP QPSFYFNQMP EBQFTTPBEFTFNQSFHBEBRVFTFTVCNFUFBVN USBCBMIPJMrDJUPQBSBHBSBOUJSPTVTUFOUPEBGBNrMJB&OUSFUBOUP OPDBTPEBnUJDB OFNUPEPTPTNFJPTTkPKVTUJGJDgWFJT NBTBQF OBTBRVFMFTRVFFTUkPEFBDPSEPDPNPTGJOTEBQSwQSJBBmkP
#APqTULOß߯ßß=behkokbe]ikn]h $POTJEFSBOEPTFPTEPJTTFOUJEPTEBQBMBWSBHSFHBnUIPT RVBOEPOBTDFBGJMPTPGJBNPSBMPVBEJTDJQMJOBGJMPTwGJDBEF OPNJOBEBBnUJDB
0RVF"SJTUwUFMFTFOUFOEJBQPSQSgYJT $PNPBEJTUJOHVJB EBUnDOJDB /BQSgYJT PBHFOUF BBmkPFBGJOBMJEBEFEPBHJSTkPJOTF QBSgWFJTPVJEpOUJDPT QPJTPBHFOUF PRVFFMFGB[FBGJOBMJEBEF EFTVBBmkPTkPPNFTNP EJ[FSBWFSEBEF QPSFYFNQMP "P DPOUSgSJP OBUnDOJDB EJ["SJTUwUFMFT PBHFOUF BBmkPFBGJOB MJEBEFEBBmkPTkPEJGFSFOUFTFFTUkPTFQBSBEPT TFOEPJOEF QFOEFOUFTVOTEPTPVUSPT PDBSQJOUFJSPRVFGB[BNFTB %FTTB NBOFJSB "SJTUwUFMFTEJTUJOHVFBQSgYJTFBUnDOJDBDPNPQSgUJDBT RVFEJGFSFNQFMPNPEPEFSFMBmkPEPBHFOUFDPNBBmkPFDPN BGJOBMJEBEFEBBmkP
"TBm{FTnUJDBTQFSUFODFNBPDBNQPEBEFMJCFSBmkPFEB EFDJTkPPVFTDPMIB&TTBDPODFQmkPFYDMVJPOFDFTTgSJPFP DPOUJOHFOUFQPSRVFOkPEFMJCFSBNPTTPCSFBRVJMPRVFnSFHJEP QFMBOBUVSF[B BTFTUBm{FTEPBOP QPSFYFNQMP RVFOFDFTTB SJBNFOUFBDPOUFDFN/kPEFMJCFSBNPTTPCSFBRVJMPRVFPDPSSF QPSBDBTP VNWBTPRVFDBJBBDJEFOUBMNFOUFTPCSFOPTTBDBCF mB QPSFYFNQMP RVFnBMHPDPOUJOHFOUF0RVFJNQPSUBnPQPT TrWFM JTUPn BRVJMPTPCSFPRVFEFMJCFSBNPTFEFDJEJNPT RVF QPEFTFSPVEFJYBSEFTFS QPSRVFQBSBTFSFBDPOUFDFSEFQFOEF EFOwT EFOPTTBWPOUBEFFEFOPTTBBmkP &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBFOUSFPRVFn²QPSOBUVSF [B³FPRVFn²QPSWPOUBEF³ ²1PSOBUVSF[B³nBRVJMPDPOGPSNFhQIZTJT JTUPn VNBSFB MJEBEFRVFTFHVFMFJTOFDFTTgSJBTFVOJWFSTBJTEFBDPSEPDPNB TVBOBUVSF[B²QPSWPOUBEF³nBRVJMPDPOGPSNFhMJCFSEBEF JTUP n VNBSFBMJEBEFQPTTrWFMRVFEFQFOEFEBWPOUBEFEPTVKFJUP 0RVFnPIPNFNQSVEFOUF TFHVOEP"SJTUwUFMFT 0IPNFNQSVEFOUFnBRVFMFRVF FNUPEBTBTTJUVBm{FT n DBQB[EFKVMHBSFBWBMJBSRVBMBBUJUVEFFRVBMBBmkPRVFNFMIPS
32
Manual do Professor
SFBMJ[BSkPBGJOBMJEBEFnUJDB PVTFKB FOUSFBTWgSJBTFTDPMIBT QPTTrWFJT RVBMBNBJTBEFRVBEBQBSBRVFPBHFOUFTFKBWJSUVP TPFSFBMJ[FPRVFnCPNQBSBTJFQBSBPTPVUSPT 2VBMPMFHBEPnUJDPEPTGJMwTPGPTBOUJHPT "BGJSNBmkPEFUSpTHSBOEFTQSJODrQJPTEBWJEBNPSBM 1PS OBUVSF[B PTTFSFTIVNBOPTBTQJSBNBPCFNFhGFMJDJEBEF RVF TwQPEFNTFSBMDBOmBEPTQFMBDPOEVUBWJSUVPTB "WJSUVEFn BGPSmBJOUFSJPSEPDBSgUFSRVFDPOTJTUFOBDPOTDJpODJBEPCFNF OBDPOEVUBEFGJOJEBQFMBWPOUBEFHVJBEBQFMBSB[kP QPJTDBCF BFTUB|MUJNBPDPOUSPMFTPCSFJOTUJOUPTFJNQVMTPTJSSBDJPOBJT EFTDPOUSPMBEPT RVFFYJTUFNOBOBUVSF[BEFUPEPTFSIVNBOP "DPOEVUBnUJDBnBRVFMBOBRVBMPBHFOUFTBCFPRVFFTUgFP RVFOkPFTUgFNTFVQPEFSSFBMJ[BS SFGFSJOEPTF QPSUBOUP BP RVFnQPTTrWFMFEFTFKgWFMQBSBVNTFSIVNBOP $PNPPTBOUJHPTDPODFCJBNBWJEBnUJDB 1PSRVF QBSBFMFT BWPOUBEFFSBUkPJNQPSUBOUF 0TGJMwTPGPTBOUJHPTDPOTJEFSBWBNRVFBWJEBnUJDBUSBOTDPS SJBDPNPVNFNCBUFDPOUrOVPFOUSFOPTTPTBQFUJUFTFEFTFKPT ±BTQBJY{FT±FOPTTBSB[kP1PSOBUVSF[B TPNPTQBTTJPOBJT FBUBSFGBQSJNFJSBEBnUJDBnBFEVDBmkPEFOPTTPDBSgUFSPVEF OPTTBOBUVSF[BQBSBTFHVJSNPTBPSJFOUBmkPEBSB[kP"WPOUBEF QPTTVrBVNMVHBSGVOEBNFOUBMOFTTBFEVDBmkP QPJTFSBFMBRVF EFWFSJBTFSGPSUBMFDJEBQBSBQFSNJUJSRVFBSB[kPDPOUSPMBTTFF EPNJOBTTFBTQBJY{FT 2VBJTPTUSpTBTQFDUPTQSJODJQBJTEBnUJDBEPTBOUJHPT &T DPMIBEPJTEFMFTFFYQMJRVFPT 0SBDJPOBMJTNPBWJEBWJSUVPTBnBHJSFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPN BSB[kP RVFDPOIFDFPCFN PEFTFKBFHVJBOPTTBWPOUBEFBUn FMFPOBUVSBMJTNPBWJEBWJSUVPTBnBHJSFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPN BOBUVSF[B PDPTNP FDPNOPTTBOBUVSF[B OPTTPnUIPT
RVFn BQBSUFEPUPEPOBUVSBMBJOTFQBSBCJMJEBEFFOUSFnUJDBFQPMrUJDB JTUPn BJOTFQBSBCJMJEBEFFOUSFBDPOEVUBEPJOEJWrEVPFPTWBMP SFTEBTPDJFEBEF QPJTTPNFOUFOBFYJTUpODJBDPNQBSUJMIBEB DPNPVUSPTFODPOUSBNPTMJCFSEBEF KVTUJmBFGFMJDJEBEF 2VBJTBTNVEBOmBTOBnUJDBBOUJHBUSB[JEBTQFMPDSJTUJBOJT NP &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS BJEFJBEFRVFBWJSUVEFTFEFGJOFQPS OPTTBSFMBmkPDPN%FVTFOkPDPNBDJEBEF BQwMJT OFNDPN PTPVUSPT/PTTBSFMBmkPDPNPTPVUSPTEFQFOEFEBRVBMJEBEF EFOPTTBSFMBmkPDPN%FVT |OJDPNFEJBEPSFOUSFDBEBJOEJWr EVPFPTEFNBJT&NTFHVOEPMVHBS BBGJSNBmkPEFRVFTPNPT EPUBEPTEFWPOUBEFMJWSF±PVMJWSFBSCrUSJP±FRVF FNEFDPS SpODJBEBEFTPCFEJpODJBEPQSJNFJSPIPNFNBPTNBOEBNFOUPT EJWJOPT PVPQFDBEPPSJHJOBMEF"EkPF&WB
OPTTBWPOUBEFTF QFSWFSUFVFOPTTBMJCFSEBEFEJSJHFTFFTQPOUBOFBNFOUFQBSBP NBMFQBSBPQFDBEP JTUPn QBSBBUSBOTHSFTTkPEBTMFJTEJWJOBT EFWJEPhJODBQBDJEBEFEFSFBMJ[BSPCFNFBTWJSUVEFTBQFOBT QFMBGPSmBEBQSwQSJBWPOUBEF &YQMJRVFBDPODFQmkPDSJTUkEPEFWFS "DPODFQmkPDSJTUkEPEFWFSCBTFJBTFOBJEFJBEFRVFB WJSUVEFn PCSJHBUPSJBNFOUF PDVNQSJNFOUPEPRVFnPSEFOBEP QFMBMFJEJWJOB RVFGVODJPOBDPNPVNBVYrMJPhWPOUBEFIVNBOB QFSWFSUJEBQFMPQFDBEP TFOEP BTTJN PDBNJOIPQBSBRVFOPT UPSOFNPTNPSBJT
33
2VBJTTkPBTWJSUVEFTDSJTUkT "TWJSUVEFTUFPMPHBJT JTUPn BTRVFTFSFGFSFNhOPTTB SFMBmkPDPN%FVTGn FTQFSBOmBFDBSJEBEFBTWJSUVEFTDBS EFBJT JTUPn BTRVFTFSFGFSFNBRVBMJEBEFTRVFOPTTBBMNB PVOPTTPFTQrSJUPEFWFNBERVJSJSQBSBTFBQFSGFJmPBSFNFSFDFS BTBMWBmkPQSPNFUJEBQPS%FVTGPSUBMF[B KVTUJmB UFNQFSBOmB FQSVEpODJBBTWJSUVEFTNPSBJT JTUPn BTRVFDPODFSOFNBP OPTTPDPNQPSUBNFOUPFYUFSJPSPVhOPTTBDPOEVUBTPCSJFEB EF QSPEJHBMJEBEF USBCBMIP DBTUJEBEF NBOTJEkP NPEnTUJBF HFOFSPTJEBEF 2VBJTTkPPTQFDBEPTDBQJUBJT (VMB BWBSF[B QSFHVJmB MVY|SJB JSB PVDwMFSB
TPCFSCB PV PSHVMIP FJOWFKB 2VBJTPTUJQPTEFDPOEVUBEFGJOJEPTQFMPDSJTUJBOJTNP $POEVUBNPSBMPVnUJDB RVFTFSFBMJ[BEFBDPSEPDPNBT OPSNBTFBTSFHSBTJNQPTUBTQFMPEFWFSDPOEVUBJNPSBMPV BOUJnUJDB RVFTFSFBMJ[BDPOUSBSJBOEPBTOPSNBTFBTSFHSBTGJYB EBTQFMPEFWFSDPOEVUBJOEJGFSFOUFhNPSBM RVBOEPBHJNPT FNTJUVBm{FTRVFOkPTkPEFGJOJEBTQFMPCFNFQFMPNBM FOBT RVBJTOkPTFJNQ{FNBTOPSNBTFBTSFHSBTEPEFWFS 0RVFnBDPODFQmkPDSJTUkEBJOUFOmkP "DPODFQmkPDSJTUkEBJOUFOmkPCBTFJBTFOBOPmkPEFJOUF SJPSJEBEFEPTVKFJUPNPSBM/BwUJDBDSJTUk BQSJNFJSBSFMBmkP nUJDBTFFTUBCFMFDFFOUSFPDPSBmkPEPJOEJWrEVPF%FVT FOUSF BBMNBJOWJTrWFMFBEJWJOEBEFJOWJTrWFM QPJTBWPOUBEFFBMFJ EJWJOBTOkPFTUkPJOTDSJUBTOBTQFESBTOFNOPTQFSHBNJOIPT NBTJOTDSJUBTOPDPSBmkPEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT"TTJN QBTTPVTF BDPOTJEFSBSDPNPTVCNFUJEPBPKVMHBNFOUPnUJDPUVEPRVBO UP JOWJTrWFMBPTPMIPTIVNBOPT nWJTrWFMBPFTQrSJUPEF%FVT QPSUBOUP UVEPRVBOUPBDPOUFDFFNOPTTPJOUFSJPS FNOPTTP DPSBmkP BTJOUFOm{FTJOWJTrWFJT $PNP3PVTTFBVQSPDVSBSFTPMWFSPQSPCMFNBEBSFMBmkP FOUSFBMJCFSEBEFEBWPOUBEFFPEFWFS &YQMJRVFDPNTVBT QBMBWSBTPRVFnB²NPSBMEPDPSBmkP³ 1BSB3PVTTFBVPTFSIVNBOPOBTDFQVSPFCPN NBTBDBCB QFSWFSUJEPQFMBTPDJFEBEF%JBOUFEJTTP FMFBQSFTFOUBB²NPSBM EPDPSBmkP³CBTFBOEPTFOBJEFJBEFRVFPEFWFSOkPnVNB JNQPTJmkPFYUFSOBhOPTTBDPOTDJpODJB&MFnQSPQPTUPQPSOPT TPDPSBmkP%FBDPSEPDPN3PVTTFBV BDPOTDJpODJBNPSBMFP TFOUJNFOUPEPEFWFSTkPJOBUPT TkP²BWP[EBOBUVSF[B³F²P EFEPEF%FVT³FNOPTTPDPSBmkP0CFEFDFOEPBPEFWFS hMFJ EJWJOBJOTDSJUBOBOBUVSF[BFFNOPTTPDPSBmkP
FTUBNPTPCF EFDFOEPBOwTNFTNPT BPTOPTTPTTFOUJNFOUPTFhTOPTTBT FNPm{FT FOkPhSB[kP QPJTFTUB QSJWJMFHJBOEPBVUJMJEBEFFP JOUFSFTTFJOEJWJEVBJT nSFTQPOTgWFMQFMBTPDJFEBEFFHPrTUBF QFSWFSTBRVFTJMFODJBBCPOEBEFOBUVSBMEPDPSBmkPIVNBOP 2VFEJGFSFOmB,BOUFTUBCFMFDFFOUSFSB[kPQVSBUFwSJDBF SB[kPQVSBQSgUJDB "EJGFSFOmBFODPOUSBTFFNTFVTPCKFUPT,BOUDPOTJEFSB RVFBSB[kPUFwSJDBPVFTQFDVMBUJWBUFNDPNPNBUnSJBPVDPO UF|EPBSFBMJEBEFFYUFSJPSBOwT VNTJTUFNBEFPCKFUPTRVF PQFSBNTFHVOEPMFJTOFDFTTgSJBTEFDBVTBFFGFJUP JOEFQFO EFOUFNFOUFEFOPTTBJOUFSWFOmkPFNDPOTFRVpODJB BSB[kP QSgUJDBOkPDPOUFNQMBVNBDBVTBMJEBEFFYUFSOBOFDFTTgSJB NBTJOTUJUVJTVBQSwQSJBSFBMJEBEF OBRVBMTFFYFSDF&TTBSFB MJEBEFQSgUJDBnKVTUBNFOUFBWJEBNPSBMPVBFYJTUpODJBIVNB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
OBFNTPDJFEBEF FYJTUpODJBRVFEFQFOEFEBBmkPEBWPOUBEF IVNBOB QPJTBTPDJFEBEFnVNBJOTUJUVJmkPDSJBEBQFMPTQSw QSJPTIPNFOT
0RVF,BOUDIBNBEF²WPOUBEFCPB³
0RVF,BOUDIBNBEF²SFJOPEBOFDFTTJEBEF³ &EF²SFJOP EBMJCFSEBEF³
&TDPMIBVNFYFNQMPOPRVBMBTNgYJNBTNPSBJTFPJNQF SBUJWPDBUFHwSJDPTkPSFTQFJUBEPTQFMPBHFOUFNPSBM
"OBUVSF[BnPSFJOPEBOFDFTTJEBEF JTUPn EFBDPOUFDJ NFOUPTSFHJEPTQPSTFRVpODJBTOFDFTTgSJBTEFDBVTBFFGFJUP "QSgYJTIVNBOBnPSFJOPEBMJCFSEBEF OPRVBMBTBm{FTTkP SFBMJ[BEBTSBDJPOBMNFOUFFOkPQPSOFDFTTJEBEFDBVTBM NBT UFOEPFNWJTUBGJOTPVQPSGJOBMJEBEF/BNFEJEBFNRVFPTGJOT TkPFTUBCFMFDJEPTQFMPTQSwQSJPTTFSFTIVNBOPT TkPGSVUPEF FTDPMIBTWPMVOUgSJBTF QPSUBOUP BBmkPQPSGJOBMJEBEFnVNB BmkPWPMVOUgSJBMJWSFPVQPSMJCFSEBEF
"IPOFTUJEBEFnVNFYFNQMPEFDPOEVUBNPSBMRVFBUFOEF hTUSpTNgYJNBT QPSNFJPEPDVNQSJNFOUPEPEFWFS4FOEP IPOFTUP PBHFOUFNPSBMJORVFTUJPOBWFMNFOUFGB[BMHPWgMJEP QBSBUPEPTFNUPEPPUFNQPFMVHBS QSJNFJSBNgYJNB QPSRVF JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEPTJOUFSFTTFT DPOTFSWBBQSwQSJBEJHOJ EBEFFBEPPVUSP TFHVOEBNgYJNB QFMPEFWFSnUJDPJNQPTUP QFMBSB[kPQSgUJDBFRVFTFSWFQBSBUPEPTPTTFSFTSBDJPOBJT UFSDFJSBNgYJNB
4FHVOEP,BOU PRVFnPEFWFS
&TDPMIBVNFYFNQMPFNRVFBTNgYJNBTNPSBJTFPJNQF SBUJWPDBUFHwSJDPOkPTkPSFTQFJUBEPTQFMPBHFOUFNPSBM
1BSB,BOU EFWFSnBFYQSFTTkPEBMFJNPSBMOPTFSIVNBOP QPSNFJPEBJNQPTJmkPEFGJOTFOPSNBTRVFBSB[kPQSgUJDBGB[ BTJNFTNBEBRVJMPRVFFMBQSwQSJBDSJPVWJTBOEPBMDBOmBSGJOT nUJDPT PTWBMPSFTNPSBJT 2VFEJGFSFOmB,BOUFTUBCFMFDFFOUSFJOUFSFTTFFEFWFS $PNPTFSFTOBUVSBJT TPNPTJNQFMJEPTBBHJSQPSJOUFSFTTF NBT DPNPTFSFTSBDJPOBJT TPNPTDBQB[FTEFBHJSQPSEFWFS &TTBEJTUJOmkPnNFMIPSBQSFTFOUBEBQPS,BOUQPSNFJPEBDPO TJEFSBmkPEPJOUFSFTTFDPNPGPSNBOBUVSBMEPFHPrTNP RVF OPTMFWBBVTBSDPJTBTFQFTTPBTDPNPNFJPTFJOTUSVNFOUPT QBSBPRVFEFTFKBNPT"TTJN BHJSQPSJOUFSFTTFnBHJSEFUFS NJOBEPQPSNPUJWBm{FTGrTJDBT QTrRVJDBT WJUBJT hNBOFJSBEPT BOJNBJT&OUSFUBOUP DPNPVTPEBSB[kPQSgUJDBFEBMJCFSEB EF TVQFSBNPTOPTTBQBSUFOBUVSBMFTFJNQ{FOPTTPTFSNPSBM DPNPNBOJGFTUBmkPNBJTBMUBEFOPTTBIVNBOJEBEF GB[FOEP DPNRVFQBTTFNPTEPBHJSCBTFBEPOPJOUFSFTTFQBSBPBHJS CBTFBEPOPEFWFS 0RVFnPJNQFSBUJWPDBUFHwSJDP 0JNQFSBUJWPDBUFHwSJDPnPRVFPSEFOBJODPOEJDJPOBMNFOUF PEFWFSDPNPVNBMFJNPSBMJOUFSJPSWgMJEBQBSBUPEBTBTDJS DVOTUiODJBTEFUPEBTBTBm{FTNPSBJT0JNQFSBUJWPDBUFHwSJDP FYQSJNFTFOVNBGwSNVMBHFSBM²"HFFNDPOGPSNJEBEFBQFOBT DPNBRVFMBNgYJNBQFMBRVBMQPTTBTRVFSFSBPNFTNPUFNQP RVFFMBTFUPSOFVNBMFJVOJWFSTBM³ 2VBJTTkPBTNgYJNBTNPSBJT TFHVOEP,BOU &YQMJRVFBT ²"HFDPNPTFBNgYJNBEFUVBBmkPEFWFTTFTFSFSJHJEB QPSUVBWPOUBEFFNMFJVOJWFSTBMEBOBUVSF[B³&TTBQSJNFJSB NgYJNBBGJSNBBVOJWFSTBMJEBEFEBDPOEVUBnUJDB BRVJMPRVF UPEPFRVBMRVFSTFSIVNBOPSBDJPOBMEFWFGB[FSDPNPTFGPTTF VNBMFJOBUVSBM JTUPn JORVFTUJPOgWFM WgMJEBQBSBUPEPTFN UPEPUFNQPFMVHBS ²"HFEFUBMNBOFJSBRVFUSBUFTBIVNB OJEBEF UBOUPOBUVBQFTTPBDPNPOBQFTTPBEFPVUSFN TFNQSF DPNPVNGJNFOVODBDPNPVNNFJP³&TTBTFHVOEBNgYJNB BGJSNBBEJHOJEBEFEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTDPNPQFTTPBTF QPS UBOUP BFYJHpODJBEFRVFTFKBNUSBUBEPTDPNPGJNEBBmkPF KBNBJTDPNPNFJPPVDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPQBSBOPTTPTJOUFSFT TFT ²"HFDPNPTFBNgYJNBEFUVBBmkPEFWFTTFTFSWJSEFMFJ VOJWFSTBMQBSBUPEPTPTTFSFTSBDJPOBJT³&TTBUFSDFJSBNgYJNB BGJSNBRVFBWPOUBEFRVFBHFQPSEFWFSJOTUJUVJVNSFJOPIVNB OPEFTFSFTNPSBJTQPSRVFSBDJPOBJTF QPSUBOUP EPUBEPTEF VNBWPOUBEFMFHJTMBEPSBMJWSFPVBVUyOPNB
,BOUDIBNBEF²WPOUBEFCPB³PBDPSEPFOUSFWPOUBEFFEF WFS
1PSNFJPEBNFOUJSBPBHFOUFNPSBMGFSFBTFHVOEBNgYJNB QPSOkPSFTQFJUBSFNTVBQFTTPBFOBEPPVUSPBIVNBOJEBEF DPOTDJpODJB SBDJPOBMJEBEFFMJCFSEBEF
QSBUJDBVNBWJPMpODJB FTDPOEFOEPEFVNPVUSPTFSIVNBOPVNBJOGPSNBmkPWFSEBEFJ SBF QPSNFJPEPFOHBOP VTBBCPBGnEPPVUSP5BNCnNOkP SFTQFJUBBUFSDFJSBNgYJNB QPJT TFBNFOUJSBQVEFTTFVOJWFSTB MJ[BSTF PHpOFSPIVNBOPEFWFSJBBCEJDBSEBSB[kPFEPDPOIF DJNFOUP EBSFGMFYkPFEBDSrUJDB EBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBEFMJCFSBS FFTDPMIFS WJWFOEPOBNBJTDPNQMFUBJHOPSiODJB OPFSSPFOB JMVTkP1PSUBOUP BNFOUJSBnBMHPJOEFTFKgWFMEPQPOUPEFWJTUB EBVOJWFSTBMJEBEFEBDPOEVUBnUJDB QSJNFJSBNgYJNB 2VBJTBTDSrUJDBTEF)FHFMB3PVTTFBVFB,BOU )FHFMDSJUJDB3PVTTFBVF,BOUQPSEPJTNPUJWPT&NQSJNFJSP MVHBS QPSUFSFNEBEPNBJTBUFOmkPhSFMBmkPFOUSFTVKFJUPIVNB OPFOBUVSF[B JTUPn hSFMBmkPFOUSFSB[kPFQBJY{FT EPRVFh SFMBmkPFOUSFTVKFJUPIVNBOPFDVMUVSBPVIJTUwSJB&NTFHVOEP MVHBS )FHFMPTDSJUJDBQPSUFSFNBENJUJEPBSFMBmkPFOUSFBnUJDB FBTPDJBCJMJEBEFEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTDPNCBTFFNMBmPTNVJUP GSgHFJT JTUPn QPSUFSFNDPODFCJEPBTPDJBCJMJEBEFDPNPSFMB m{FTQFTTPBJTEJSFUBTFOUSFJOEJWrEVPT RVBOEPEFWFSJBNUpMB UPNBEPDPNCBTFOPTMBmPTGPSUFTEBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJT GJYBEBT QFMBTJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJT GBNrMJB TPDJFEBEFDJWJM &TUBEP 0RVF)FHFMDIBNBEFWPOUBEFPCKFUJWB "WPOUBEFPCKFUJWBnVNBWPOUBEFJNQFTTPBM DPMFUJWB TP DJBM Q|CMJDBFIJTUPSJDBNFOUFEFUFSNJOBEB&TTBWPOUBEFOkPn BQFOBTVNBGPSNBEPRVFSFS DPNPFN,BOU FTJNVNDPOKVOUP EFDPOUF|EPTEFUFSNJOBEPT GJOT WBMPSFT OPSNBTEPUBEPTEF DPOUF|EPTEFUFSNJOBEPTQFMBTJOTUJUVJm{FTPVQFMBDVMUVSB 0RVF)FHFMFOUFOEFQPSNPSBMJEBEF 1PSRVFBNPSBMJEB EFnDVMUVSBMFIJTUwSJDB 1BSB)FHFM BNPSBMJEBEFnVNTJTUFNBSFHVMBEPSEBWJEB DPMFUJWBDSJBEBBQBSUJSEBWPOUBEFPCKFUJWB&MBnDVMUVSBMFIJT UwSJDBQPSRVFnVNBUPUBMJEBEFGPSNBEBQFMBTJOTUJUVJm{FT GB NrMJB SFMJHJkP BSUFT UnDOJDBT DJpODJBT SFMBm{FTEFUSBCBMIP PSHBOJ[BmkPQPMrUJDB FUD
RVFPCFEFDFN UPEBT BPTNFTNPT WBMPSFTFBPTNFTNPTDPTUVNFTEFVNBTPDJFEBEF OVNBnQP DBEFUFSNJOBEB FEVDBOEPPTJOEJWrEVPTQBSBJOUFSJPSJ[BSFNB WPOUBEFPCKFUJWBEFTVBTPDJFEBEFFEFTVBDVMUVSB 4FHVOEP)FHFM PRVFnBWJEBnUJDB 2VBOEPFMBTFSFBMJ[B QMFOBNFOUF
34
Manual do Professor
"WJEBnUJDBnPBDPSEPFBIBSNPOJBFOUSFBWPOUBEFTVCKF UJWBJOEJWJEVBMFBWPOUBEFPCKFUJWBDVMUVSBM3FBMJ[BTFQMFOB NFOUFRVBOEPJOUFSJPSJ[BNPTOPTTBDVMUVSB EFUBMNBOFJSBRVF QSBUJDBNPTFTQPOUiOFBFMJWSFNFOUFTFVTDPTUVNFTFWBMPSFT TFNOFMFTQFOTBSNPT TFNPTEJTDVUJSNPT TFNEFMFEVWJEBS NPT QPSRVFTkPDPNPOPTTBQSwQSJBWPOUBEFPTEFTFKB 4FHVOEP)FHFM FNRVFNPNFOUPVNBNPSBMFOUSBFNEF DMrOJP %pVNFYFNQMP /PNPNFOUPFNRVFPTNFNCSPTEFVNBTPDJFEBEFFEF VNBDVMUVSBDPOUFTUBNBNPSBMJEBEFWJHFOUF DPOUFTUBNPTWB MPSFTFBTOPSNBTJOTUJUVrEPT TFOUFNTFPQSJNJEPTFFTNBHB EPTQPSFMFTFBHFNEFNPEPBUSBOTHSFEJMPT/FTTFTFOUJEP TkPFYFNQMPTEFTUBDBEPTQPS)FHFMBQBTTBHFNEBBSJTUPDSB DJBhEFNPDSBDJB OB(SnDJB FBQBTTBHFNEBDPNVOJEBEFNF EJFWBMhTPDJFEBEFNPEFSOB 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFNPSBMBCFSUBFNPSBMGFDIBEB TF HVOEP#FSHTPO "NPSBMGFDIBEBnPBDPSEPFOUSFPTWBMPSFTFPTDPTUVNFT EFVNBTPDJFEBEFFPTTFOUJNFOUPTFBTBm{FTEPTJOEJWrEVPT RVFOFMBWJWFNcBNPSBMSFQFUJUJWB IBCJUVBM SFTQFJUBEBRVBTF BVUPNBUJDBNFOUFQPSOwT&NDPOUSBQBSUJEB BNPSBMBCFSUBn VNBDSJBmkPEFOPWPTWBMPSFTFOPWBTDPOEVUBT RVFSPNQFNB NPSBMGFDIBEB JOTUBVSBOEPVNBnUJDBOPWB "QPOUFBMHVNBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFBnUJDBBSJTUPUnMJDBFB nUJDBDSJTUk 0DSJTUJBOJTNPBDSFTDFOUBOPWBTWJSUVEFTDPODFSOFOUFThSF MBmkPEPDSFOUFDPN%FVTFRVFTkPEFTDPOIFDJEBTQPS"SJTUwUF MFT Gn FTQFSBOmBFDBSJEBEF
hQPTJmkPEBKVTUJmBFEBQSVEpO DJBDPNPWJSUVEFTQBSUJDVMBSFT WJSUVEFTRVF QBSB"SJTUwUFMFT OkPFSBNQBSUJDVMBSFT QPJTBKVTUJmBnPSFTVMUBEPEBWJSUVEFF OkPVNBEBTWJSUVEFT FBQSVEpODJBnBDPOEJmkPEFUPEBTBT WJSUVEFT
hTVCTUJUVJmkPEBBNJ[BEFQFMBDBSJEBEF FOUFOEJEB DPNPBNPSBPQSwYJNPFFTTFBNPSDPNPSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFQF MBTBMWBmkPEPPVUSP 2VBOUPhTWJSUVEFTNPSBJT FODPOUSBNPT FOUSFFMBTVNBRVF QBSB"SJTUwUFMFT FSBVNWrDJP±BNPEnTUJB ± BMnNEFWFSJGJDBSNPTPBQBSFDJNFOUPEFWJSUVEFTJHOPSBEBT PVEFTDPOIFDJEBTQPS"SJTUwUFMFT DPNPBIVNJMEBEFFBDBTUJ EBEF0DSJTUJBOJTNPUSBOTGPSNBFNWJSUVEFPUSBCBMIP RVFQBSB VNHSFHPKBNBJTTFSJBVNBWJSUVEF FUSBOTGPSNBFNWrDJPPwDJP QSFHVJmB
RVFQBSBPTHSFHPTFSBDPOEJmkPQBSBPFYFSDrDJPEB GJMPTPGJBFEBQPMrUJDB $PNP&TQJOPTBEFGJOFPTBGFUPT 2VBMBEJGFSFOmBFOUSF BGFUPTQBTTJWPTPVQBJY{FTFBGFUPTBUJWPTPVBm{FT 1BSB&TQJOPTB PTBGFUPTPVTFOUJNFOUPTTkPDPOTUJUVUJWPT EBSFMBmkPEFOPTTBBMNBDPNOPTTPDPSQP PVTFKB OPTTBBM NBFYQSJNFOPTTBTBGFDm{FTDPSQPSBJT RVBOEPOPTTPDPSQPn BGFUBEPQPSPVUSPTDPSQPTPVBGFUBPVUSPTDPSQPT QPSNFJPEPT BGFUPTFTFOUJNFOUPT0TBGFUPTQPEFNTFSQBJY{FTPVBm{FT" EJGFSFOmBFOUSFFMFTnRVFBTQBJY{FT PTBGFUPTQBTTJWPT TkP DBVTBEBTQPSGPSmBTPVDPJTBTFYUFSOBTBTBm{FT PTBGFUPTBUJ WPT
QPSOPTTBGPSmBJOUFSOB 1PSRVF&TQJOPTBKVMHBBTQBJY{FTOBUVSBJT 2VBJTTkPBT USpTQBJY{FTPSJHJOBJTPVQSJNJUJWBT 1BSB&TQJOPTB TPNPTOBUVSBMNFOUFQBTTJPOBJTQPSRVFTP GSFNPTBBmkPEFDBVTBTFYUFSJPSFTBOwT&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT TFSQBTTJPOBMnTFSQBTTJWP EFJYBOEPTFDPOEV[JSQPSGPSmBT FYUFSJPSFTBPOPTTPDPSQPFhOPTTBBMNB0SB OBUVSBMNFOUF
35
WJWFNPTSPEFBEPTQPSPVUSPTTFSFT NBJTGPSUFTEPRVFOwT RVFBHFNTPCSFOwT1PSJTTP EJ[&TQJOPTB BTQBJY{FTOkPTkP CPBTOFNNgT TJNQMFTNFOUFTkPOBUVSBJT/kPTkPWrDJPTEB OBUVSF[BIVNBOB FTJNBNBOFJSBDPNPFYJTUJNPTSFDFCFOEP FTPGSFOEPBBmkPEFDBVTBTFYUFSOBT6NBQBJYkPJOEJDBBGPS mBPVBGSBRVF[BEFOPTTPTFS OPTTPDPSQPFOPTTBBMNB QBSB FYJTUJSFQFOTBS"TQBJY{FTPSJHJOBJTPVQSJNJUJWBTTkPBBMF HSJB BUSJTUF[BFPEFTFKP"TEFNBJTEFSJWBNTFEFTUBT"TTJN EBQBJYkPEFBMFHSJBOBTDFNBTEFBNPS EFWPmkP FTQFSBOmB TFHVSBOmB DPOUFOUBNFOUP NJTFSJDwSEJB HMwSJBEBQBJYkPEF USJTUF[BTVSHFNBTEFwEJP JOWFKB PSHVMIP BSSFQFOEJNFOUP NPEnTUJB IVNJMEBEF NFEP EFTFTQFSPEBQBJYkPEPEFTFKP DPOGPSNFFTUFTFDPNCJOFDPNBBMFHSJBPVDPNBUSJTUF[B QSP WpNBHSBUJEkP BHMwSJB BCFOFWPMpODJB BDwMFSB BDSVFMEBEF B WJOHBOmB BBNCJmkP PUFNPS BPVTBEJB BMVY|SJB BBWBSF[B &YQMJRVFPRVFnVNBQBJYkPUSJTUFFVNBQBJYkPBMFHSF 6NBQBJYkPUSJTUFnBRVFMBRVFFYQFSJNFOUBNPTRVBOEP TFOUJNPTBEJNJOVJmkPEBDBQBDJEBEFEFTFSFBHJSEFOPTTP DPSQPFEFOPTTBBMNB±nQPSUSJTUF[BRVFPEJBNPTPRVF KVMHBNPTRVFOPTFOGSBRVFDF BTTJNDPNPnQPSUSJTUF[BRVF TFOUJNPTQBJY{FTDPNPPNFEPFPEFTFTQFSP RVFOPTMFWBN BGVHJSEBTDPJTBTFEPTPVUSPTPVBRVFSFSEFTUSVrMPT"PDPO USgSJP VNBQBJYkPBMFHSFnFYQFSJNFOUBEBRVBOEPTFOUJNPTP BVNFOUPEBDBQBDJEBEFEFFYJTUJSFBHJSEFOPTTPDPSQPFEF OPTTBBMNB±nQPSBMFHSJBRVFBNBNPTPRVFKVMHBNPTRVF OPTGPSUBMFDF BTTJNDPNPnQPSBMFHSJBRVFTFOUJNPTBNJ[BEFF HFOFSPTJEBEFQPSBRVFMFTRVFBVNFOUBNOPTTBGPSmBWJUBM 4FHVOEP&TQJOPTB PRVFnTFSWJEkPIVNBOB 4FHVOEP&TQJOPTB TPNPTTFSWPTRVBOEPOPTTBTQBJY{FT EFUFSNJOBNOPTTBWJEBF QPSUBOUP OkPTPNPTMJWSFT NBTWJ WFNPTTPCPQPEFSFYUFSOPEBTDPJTBTFEFPVUSPT RVFOPTBS SBTUBNQBSBPOEFRVFSFN 4FHVOEP&TQJOPTB PRVFnBWJSUVEF /kPnDVNQSJSEFWFSFTFPCSJHBm{FT NBTTFSBDBVTBJOUFS OBEFOPTTPTTFOUJNFOUPT BUPTFQFOTBNFOUPT0VTFKB TFS MJWSFnUFSGPSmBJOUFSJPSQBSBQBTTBSEBQBTTJWJEBEFBGFUJWB TVC NJTTkPBDBVTBTFYUFSOBT hBUJWJEBEFBGFUJWB TFSDBVTBJOUFSOB EPTBGFUPT EPTQFOTBNFOUPTFEBTDPOEVUBT 4FHVOEP&TQJOPTB DPNPQBTTBNPTEBTQBJY{FThTBm{FT EBTFSWJEkPhMJCFSEBEF "QBTTBHFNTFEgOPJOUFSJPSEBTQBJY{FTFHSBmBTBFMBT« NFEJEBRVFBTQBJY{FTEFBMFHSJBFEFEFTFKPBMFHSFOPTGPSUBMF DFN WBNPTBERVJSJOEPQPEFSTPCSFOwTNFTNPTFEJNJOVJOEP PQPEFSJPEBTGPSmBTFYUFSOBT2VBOEPOPTTBSB[kPTFUPSOB DBQB[EFTFSWJWJEBQPSOwTFGFUJWBNFOUF JTUPn RVBOEPFYQF SJNFOUBNPTRVFDPOIFDFSnNBJTGPSUFEPRVFJHOPSBSFRVFP DPOIFDJNFOUPnBGPSmBQSwQSJBEFOPTTBBMNB OPTTBBUJWJEBEF SBDJPOBMTFUPSOBBMFHSJB KgOkPEFQFOEFEFDBVTBTFYUFSOBT NBTFYDMVTJWBNFOUFEBGPSmBJOUFSOBEFOPTTBSB[kP&NPVUSBT QBMBWSBT QBTTBNPTEBQBJYkPhBmkP EBTFSWJEkPhMJCFSEBEF USBOTGPSNBOEPBTQBJY{FTBMFHSFTFBTEFTFKBOUFTOBTDJEBTEB BMFHSJBFNBUJWJEBEFTEFRVFTPNPTBDBVTB $PNP.BD*OUZSFDPODFCFBWJSUVEF 1PSRVFBWJSUVEFQSP QJDJBVOJEBEFFDPFSpODJBhOPTTBWJEBnUJDB .BD*OUZSF JOTQJSBOEPTFFN"SJTUwUFMFT DPODFCFBWJS UVEFDPNPQSgYJT QPSUBOUP DPNPBRVFMBBmkPPVDPOEVUBOB RVBMPBHFOUF PBUPFBGJOBMJEBEFTkPJOTFQBSgWFJTFNFTNP
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
JEpOUJDPT1PSJTTPBDPODFCFDPNPVNBRVBMJEBEFIVNBOB BERVJSJEBRVF FNRVBMRVFSFTGFSBEFWJEBFBUJWJEBEF OPT UPSOBDBQB[FTEFBMDBOmBSVNCFNJOUFSOPhQSwQSJBQSgUJDB PVhQSwQSJBDPOEVUB JTUPn JOTFQBSgWFMEBBmkPRVFPCVTDB FPSFBMJ[B"WJSUVEFQSPQJDJBVOJEBEFFDPFSpODJBhOPTTBWJ EBnUJDBQPSRVF DPNPFYQMJDB.BD*OUZSF BVOJEBEFnUJDBEF OPTTBWJEBnDPNPBVOJEBEFEFVNBOBSSBUJWB DPNDPNFmP NFJPFGJN OBRVBMQPEFNPTJEFOUJGJDBSVNBTwFNFTNBWJEB WJWJEBPVOBSSBEB VNTwFNFTNPFVPVVNTwFNFTNPTV KFJUPOPEFDPSSFSEPUFNQPFOBTEJGFSFOUFTBm{FT DPOEVUBT FDPNQPSUBNFOUPT 4FHVOEP.BD*OUZSF FNRVFNPNFOUPTFEgBNVEBOmB nUJDB "NVEBOmBnUJDBTFEgOPNPNFOUPFNRVFVNBUSBEJmkP FTUgNPSUB PVTFKB RVBOEPEFGJOFWJSUVEFTRVFJNQFEFNBPT JOEJWrEVPTBSFBMJ[BmkPEBWJSUVEFDPNPDPFSpODJBFVOJEBEFEF WJEBFEFDPOEVUBTPVRVFJNQFEFNBCVTDBEFOPWBTQPTTJCJMJ EBEFTEFFYJTUpODJBJOEJWJEVBMPVDPMFUJWB%JBOUFEJTTP BWJEB nUJDBTwQPEFSgSFBMJ[BSTFJOTUJUVJOEPOPSNBT WBMPSFT DPOEV UBTFDPNQPSUBNFOUPTDBQB[FTEFJOTUJUVJSVNBUSBEJmkPOPWBF WJWBDBQB[EFQFSNJUJSBDBEBVNBDPFSpODJBEFWJEBFBJOUFJSF[B EFDBSgUFS &YQMJRVFBEJTUJOmkPnUJDBFOUSFSBDJPOBMFJSSBDJPOBM1PS RVFBUPSUVSBnJSSBDJPOBMF QPSUBOUP JNPSBM "EJTUJOmkPnUJDBFOUSFSBDJPOBMFJSSBDJPOBMCBTFJBTFOB JEFJBEFSBUJP QBMBWSBMBUJOBRVFTFMp²SgDJP³
FOUFOEJEBDP NP²QSPQPSmkPFOUSFEPJTPVNBJTUFSNPT³/FTTBQFSTQFDUJWB VNBnUJDBnSBDJPOBMRVBOEPOFMBIgQSPQPSmkPPVIPNPHFOFJ EBEFFOUSFPTNFJPTFPTGJOTEBBmkP FJSSBDJPOBMRVBOEPOkP FYJTUFFTTBQSPQPSmkP JTUPn NFJPTFGJOTTkPIFUFSPHpOFPT PVEFOBUVSF[BEJGFSFOUF%FTTBNBOFJSB BSBDJPOBMJEBEFnP BWFTTPEBJSSBDJPOBMJEBEF BVTpODJBEFQSPQPSmkPPVEFIP NPHFOFJEBEFFOUSFNFJPTFGJOT RVFJNQPTTJCJMJUBBQSgYJTF BWJSUVEF JTUPn NFJPTJNPSBJTTkPIFUFSPHpOFPTBGJOTNPSBJT FJODBQB[FTEFSFBMJ[gMPT4FOEPBTTJN BUPSUVSBFNQSFHBEB QPSVNBTPDJFEBEFnJNPSBMQPSRVFnJSSBDJPOBM QPJTOkPDPO TFHVFFTUBCFMFDFSVNBSFMBmkPQSPQPSDJPOBMPVVNBSBUJPFOUSF NFJPT UPSUVSB FGJOT BEFTkPWPMVOUgSJBEPUPSUVSBEPhWPOUBEF EPUPSUVSBEPS 2VBMPFRVrWPDPEFTFTVQPSRVFIgVNBQMVSBMJEBEFEF nUJDBTOPJOUFSJPSEFVNBNFTNBTPDJFEBEF 1PSRVFFN DBEBTPDJFEBEFIgBQFOBTVNBnUJDB $PNPBTPDJFEBEFnGPSNBEBQPSVNDPOKVOUPEFJOTUJUVJ m{FT PFRVrWPDPTVSHFEBTVQPTJmkPEFRVFDBEBVNBEFTTBT JOTUJUVJm{FTEFWFSJBUFSVNBnUJDBFTQFDrGJDBcRVFTFDPOGVOEF PFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTOPSNBTRVFTFSFGFSFNh GVODJPOBMJEBEFFhFGJDgDJBQBSBPEFTFNQFOIPBEFRVBEPPV FTQFSBEPEFVNBBmkP FNQSFTBSJBM QSPGJTTJPOBM DPNBRVBMJ EBEFEPTDPNQPSUBNFOUPTEFTFKgWFJTEFUPEBTPDJFEBEF1PS UBOUP FTTBTOPSNBTOkPTkPnUJDBTPVNPSBJT NBTPSHBOJ[B DJPOBJTFBENJOJTUSBUJWBTFQPEFNFTUBSPVOkPEFBDPSEPDPN PTWBMPSFTnUJDPTEBTPDJFEBEFOBRVBMFYJTUFN1PSJTTPnRVF IgFNDBEBTPDJFEBEFBQFOBTVNBnUJDBRVFnEFGJOJEBFEFUFS NJOBEBFNDPOEJm{FTIJTUwSJDBTEBEBT QPSNFJPEBRVBMBWB MJBNPTBRVBMJEBEFNPSBMEBTBm{FTSFBMJ[BEBTOBTEJGFSFOUFT JOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJT QPMrUJDBTFQSPGJTTJPOBJT EFNBOFJSBRVF TFKBBTTFHVSBEBBVOJEBEFFBDPFSpODJBEFWJEB
0RVFnPSBDJPOBMJTNPnUJDP 1BSBPSBDJPOBMJTNPnUJDP P RVFnBGJMPTPGJBNPSBM 0SBDJPOBMJTNPnUJDPBUSJCVJhSB[kPIVNBOBPMVHBSDFOUSBM OBWJEBnUJDB1BSBFMF BGJMPTPGJBNPSBMnPDPOIFDJNFOUPEBT NPUJWBm{FTFJOUFOm{FT RVFNPWFNJOUFSJPSNFOUFPTVKFJUP NPSBM FEPTNFJPTFGJOTEBBmkPNPSBMDBQB[FTEFDPODSFUJ[BS BRVFMBTNPUJWBm{FTFJOUFOm{FT 0RVFnPJOUFMFDUVBMJTNPnUJDP %FBDPSEPDPNPJOUFMFDUVBMJTNP BWJEBnUJDBPVWJEBWJS UVPTBEFQFOEFEPDPOIFDJNFOUP QPJTnTPNFOUFQPSJHOPSiO DJBRVFGB[FNPTPNBMFOPTEFJYBNPTBSSBTUBSQPSJNQVMTPTF QBJY{FTDPOUSgSJPThWJSUVEFFBPCFN0TFSIVNBOP TFOEP FTTFODJBMNFOUFSBDJPOBM EFWFGB[FSDPNRVFTVBSB[kPPVJOUF MJHpODJBDPOIFmBPTGJOTNPSBJT PTNFJPTNPSBJTFBEJGFSFOmB FOUSFPCFNFPNBM EFNPEPBDPOEV[JSBWPOUBEFOPNPNFOUP EBEFMJCFSBmkPFEBEFDJTkP"WJEBnUJDBEFQFOEFEPEFTFO WPMWJNFOUPEBJOUFMJHpODJBPVSB[kP TFNBRVBMBWPOUBEFOkP QPEFSgBUVBS 0RVFnPWPMVOUBSJTNPnUJDP %FBDPSEPDPNPWPMVOUBSJTNP BWJEBnUJDBPVNPSBMEF QFOEFFTTFODJBMNFOUFEBOPTTBWPOUBEF QPSRVFEFMBEFQFO EFOPTTPBHJSFQPSRVFFMBQPEFRVFSFSPVOkPRVFSFSPRVFB JOUFMJHpODJBMIFPSEFOB4FBWPOUBEFGPSCPB TFSFNPTWJSUVP TPTTFGPSNg TFSFNPTWJDJPTPT"WPOUBEFCPBPSJFOUBOPTTB JOUFMJHpODJBOPNPNFOUPEBFTDPMIBEFVNBBmkP FORVBOUPB WPOUBEFNgEFTWJBOPTTBSB[kPEBCPBFTDPMIB OPNPNFOUPEF EFMJCFSBSFEFBHJS"WJEBnUJDBEFQFOEFEBRVBMJEBEFEFOPT TBWPOUBEFFEBEJTDJQMJOBQBSBGPSmgMBSVNPBPCFN0EFWFS FEVDBBWPOUBEFQBSBRVFTFUPSOFSFUBFCPB 2VBJTBTEJGFSFOmBTFOUSFWPOUBEFFEFTFKP 0EFTFKPnQBJYkP"WPOUBEF EFDJTkP0EFTFKPOBTDFEB JNBHJOBmkP"WPOUBEFTFBSUJDVMBhSFGMFYkP0EFTFKPOkPTV QPSUBPUFNQP PVTFKB EFTFKBSnRVFSFSBTBUJTGBmkPJNFEJBUBF PQSB[FSJNFEJBUP"WPOUBEF BPDPOUSgSJP SFBMJ[BTFOPUFNQP PFTGPSmPFBQPOEFSBmkPUSBCBMIBNDPNBSFMBmkPFOUSFNFJPT FGJOTFBDFJUBNBEFNPSBEBTBUJTGBmkP.BTnPEFTFKPRVF PGFSFDFhWPOUBEFPTNPUJWPTJOUFSJPSFTFPTGJOTFYUFSJPSFTEB BmkP«WPOUBEFDBCFBFEVDBmkPNPSBMEPEFTFKP/BDPODFQ mkPJOUFMFDUVBMJTUB BJOUFMJHpODJBPSJFOUBBWPOUBEFQBSBRVF FTUBFEVRVFPEFTFKP/BDPODFQmkPWPMVOUBSJTUB BWPOUBEF CPBUFNPQPEFSEFFEVDBSPEFTFKP FORVBOUPBWPOUBEFNg TVCNFUFTFBFMFFQPEF FNNVJUPTDBTPT QFSWFSUpMP 0RVFnPFNPUJWJTNPnUJDP 1BSBPFNPUJWJTNPnUJDP PGVOEBNFOUPEBWJEBNPSBMOkP nBSB[kP NBTBFNPmkP/PTTPTTFOUJNFOUPTTkPDBVTBTEBT OPSNBT F EPT WBMPSFT *OTQJSBOEPTF FN 3PVTTFBV BMHVOT FNPUJWJTUBTBGJSNBNBCPOEBEFOBUVSBMEFOPTTPTTFOUJNFO UPTFOPTTBTQBJY{FT RVFTkP QPSJTTP BGPSNBFPDPOUF|EP EBFYJTUpODJBNPSBMDPNPSFMBmkPJOUFSTVCKFUJWBFJOUFSQFTTPBM 0VUSPTFNPUJWJTUBTTBMJFOUBNBVUJMJEBEFEPTTFOUJNFOUPTPV EBTFNPm{FTQBSBOPTTBTPCSFWJWpODJBFQBSBOPTTBTSFMBm{FT DPNPTPVUSPT DBCFOEPhnUJDBPSJFOUBSFTTBVUJMJEBEFEFNPEP BJNQFEJSBWJPMpODJBFHBSBOUJSSFMBm{FTKVTUBTFOUSFPTTFSFT IVNBOPT "QSFTFOUFUSpTEFOUSFBTWgSJBTJEFJBTEF/JFU[TDIFEFTFO WPMWJEBTOBPCSB(FOFBMPHJBEBNPSBM
4,
Manual do Professor
1SPGFTTPS B DJUBNPT BMFBUPSJBNFOUF USpTJEFJBTEBPCSB OJFU[TDIJBOB$BEBBMVOPQPEFPQUBSQPSPVUSBTJEFJBTRVFOkP BTBRVJNFODJPOBEBT "NPSBMSBDJPOBMJTUBGPJFSHVJEBDPN GJOBMJEBEFSFQSFTTPSBFOkPQBSBHBSBOUJSPFYFSDrDJPEBMJCFS EBEF "NPSBMSBDJPOBMJTUBGPJJOWFOUBEBQFMPTGSBDPTQBSB DPOUSPMBSFEPNJOBSPTGPSUFT DVKPTEFTFKPT QBJY{FTFWPOUBEF BGJSNBNBWJEB NFTNPOBDSVFMEBEFFOBBHSFTTJWJEBEF1PS NFEPEBGPSmBWJUBMEPTGPSUFT PTGSBDPTDPOEFOBSBNQBJY{FT FEFTFKPT TVCNFUFSBNBWPOUBEFhSB[kP JOWFOUBSBNPEFWFS FJNQVTFSBNDBTUJHPTBPTUSBOTHSFTTPSFT "NPSBMEPTSFT TFOUJEPT CBTFBEBOPNFEPFOPwEJPhWJEB hTQBJY{FT BPTEF TFKPT hWPOUBEFGPSUF
JOWFOUBVNBPVUSBWJEB GVUVSB FUFSOB JODPSQwSFB RVFTFSgEBEBDPNPSFDPNQFOTBBPTRVFTBDSJGJDB SFNTFVTJNQVMTPTWJUBJTFBDFJUBSFNPTWBMPSFTEPTGSBDPT &YQMJRVFBEJGFSFOmBOJFU[TDIJBOBFOUSFNPSBMEPTFTDSB WPTFNPSBMEPTTFOIPSFT "NPSBMEPTFTDSBWPTnBNPSBMSBDJPOBMJTUBPVEPTGSBDPTF SFTTFOUJEPTRVFUFNFNBWJEB PDPSQP PEFTFKPFBTQBJY{FT EPTRVFSFOVODJBNhWFSEBEFJSBMJCFSEBEFnUJDB"PDPOUSgSJP B NPSBMEPTTFOIPSFTFTUgGVOEBEBOPTJOTUJOUPTWJUBJT OPTEFTF KPTFOBRVJMPRVF/JFU[TDIFDIBNBEFWPOUBEFEFQPUpODJB DVKP NPEFMPTFFODPOUSBOPTHVFSSFJSPTCFMPTFCPOTEBTTPDJFEBEFT BOUJHBT CBTFBEBTOBHVFSSB OPTDPNCBUFTFOPTKPHPT OBTEJT QVUBTQFMBHMwSJBFQFMBGBNB OBCVTDBEBIPOSBFEBDPSBHFN 2VFDSrUJDBT/JFU[TDIF 'SFVEF.BSYGJ[FSBNhNPSBMWJHFO UFOBnQPDBFNRVFWJWFSBN "GJSNBNRVFBQSwQSJBnUJDB OBTDJEBDPNPUSBCBMIPEFVNB TPDJFEBEFQBSBEFMJNJUBSFDPOUSPMBSBWJPMpODJB JTUPn PVTP EBGPSmBDPOUSBTJNFTNPFPVUSFN UPSOPVTFGPSNBQFSGFJUB EFWJPMpODJBQPSTFSUSBOTGPSNBEBFNDPTUVNFT QSFDPODFJUPT DSJTUBMJ[BEPTFTPCSFUVEPFNDPOGJBOmBOBDBQBDJEBEFBQB[J HVBEPSBEBSB[kP%JBOUFEJTTP EFGFOEFNPWBMPSEFVNBWJP MpODJBOPWBFQVSJGJDBEPSB±BQPUpODJBPVBGPSmBEPTJOTUJOUPT ± DPOTJEFSBEBMJCFSUBEPSBQPS/JFU[TDIFQSPQ{FNVNBnUJDB RVFMJCFSFPEFTFKPEBSFQSFTTkPBRVFBTPDJFEBEFPTVCNFUFV SFQSFTTkPDBVTBEPSBEFQTJDPTFT OFVSPTFT BOH|TUJBTFEFTFT QFSPT EFBDPSEPDPNBUFPSJBGSFVEJBOBDPOTJEFSBWBNPTWBMP SFTEBNPSBMWJHFOUFIJQwDSJUBTQPSRVF DPNPEJ[JB.BSY FSBN JSSFBMJ[gWFJTFJNQPTTrWFJTOVNBTPDJFEBEFWJPMFOUB CBTFBEB OBFYQMPSBmkPEPUSBCBMIP OBEFTJHVBMEBEFTPDJBMFFDPOyNJDB OBFYDMVTkPEFVNBQBSUFEBTPDJFEBEFEPTEJSFJUPTQPMrUJDPTF DVMUVSBJT EFNPEPRVFGJDBWBJNQFEJEBBFYJTUpODJBQMFOBEF VNTFSIVNBOPRVFSFBMJ[FPTWBMPSFTnUJDPT 1PSRVFBEFTDPCFSUBEPJODPOTDJFOUFQPS'SFVEQPEFSJB DPNQSPNFUFSBJEFJBEBnUJDBDPNPFYFSDrDJPMJWSFEBDPOT DJpODJBFEBWPOUBEF
"PQSPQPSVNBOPWBNPSBMTFYVBMWJTBOEPBIBSNPOJ[BmkP FOUSFPTEFTFKPTJODPOTDJFOUFT BTGPSNBTEFTBUJTGB[pMPTFB WJEBTPDJBM BQTJDBOgMJTFSFJOTUJUVJBJNQPSUiODJBEBDPOTDJpODJB FEBWPOUBEFMJWSFRVFTkPGPSUBMFDJEBTDPNPNPEFSBEPSBTFO USFBTBUJTGBmkPFBSFQSFTTkP*TTPTJHOJGJDBVNBWBOmPQPSRVF OPTUPSOBFUJDBNFOUFMJWSFTFSFTQPOTgWFJTOkPQPSRVFQPEF NPTGB[FSUVEPRVBOUPRVFSFNPT OFNQPSRVFRVFSFNPTUVEP RVBOUPQPEFNPTGB[FS NBTQPSRVFBQSFOEFNPTBEJTDSJNJOBS BTGSPOUFJSBTFOUSFPQFSNJUJEPFPQSPJCJEP UFOEPDPNPDSJUnSJP JEFBMBBVTpODJBEBWJPMpODJBJOUFSOBFFYUFSOB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=he^an`]`a &YQMJRVFBPQPTJmkPFOUSFOFDFTTJEBEFFMJCFSEBEF1PSRVF BOFDFTTJEBEFPVGBUBMJEBEFQBSFDFFYDMVJSBMJCFSEBEF "OFDFTTJEBEFTFPQ{FhMJCFSEBEFQPSRVFTFSFGFSFBPUP EPEBSFBMJEBEF FYJTUFOUFFNTJFQPSTJ RVFBHFTFNOwTF OPTJOTFSFFNTVBSFEFEFDBVTBTFFGFJUPT DPOEJm{FTFDPOTF RVpODJBT JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEPQPEFSEFOPTTBWPOUBEF EF OPTTPEFTFKP EFOPTTBDPOTDJpODJB"OFDFTTJEBEFPVGBUBMJEB EFQBSFDFNFYDMVJSBMJCFSEBEFQPSRVFBQSFTFOUBNPDVSTPEBT DPJTBTFEFOPTTBWJEBDPOEJDJPOBEPTFYUFSOBNFOUF TFNRVF OFMFQPTTBNPTJOUFSWJS &YQMJRVFBPQPTJmkPFOUSFDPOUJOHpODJBFMJCFSEBEF1PSRVF BDPOUJOHpODJBPVPBDBTPQBSFDFFYDMVJSBMJCFSEBEF $POUJOHpODJBPVBDBTPTJHOJGJDBNRVFBSFBMJEBEFnJNQSF WJTrWFMFNVUgWFM PRVFKVTUJGJDBVNBPQPTJmkPhMJCFSEBEFEFWJ EPhJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFEFMJCFSBmkPFEFDJTkPSBDJPOBJT%FTTB NBOFJSB BDPOUJOHpODJBPVBDBTPQBSFDFFYDMVJSBMJCFSEBEF QPSRVFTJHOJGJDBRVFOkPIgDVSTPBMHVNEBTDPJTBTFEFOPT TBWJEBTPCSFPRVBMQPTTBNPTJOUFSWJS/PNVOEPDPOUJOHFOUF UVEPBDPOUFDFQPSBDBTPPVBDJEFOUF FOFMFTPNPTVNGSgHJM CBSRVJOIPQFSEJEPOVNNBSUFNQFTUVPTP MFWBEPFNUPEBTBT EJSFm{FT BPTBCPSEBTWBHBTFEPTWFOUPT 'PSNVMFDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTVNFYFNQMPFNRVFBOFDFTTJ EBEFQBSFDFJNQFEJSBMJCFSEBEF 1SPGFTTPS B /FTUBSFTQPTUB DBEBFTUVEBOUFGPSNVMBSg PTFVQSwQSJPFYFNQMPcJNQPSUBOUFBQFOBTRVFGJRVFDMBSPP SFGFSFODJBMUFwSJDPOPRVBMEFWFNTFCBTFBSPTFYFNQMPT PV TFKB DBSBDUFSJ[BEPTQPSBTQFDUPTOFDFTTgSJPT JOFWJUgWFJT RVF JOEFQFOEFNEFOPTTBWPOUBEFFRVFMJNJUBNOPTTBMJCFSEBEF KVTUBNFOUFQPSOkPUFSNPTFTDPMIBEJBOUFEFMFT 'PSNVMFDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTVNFYFNQMPFNRVFBDPOUJO HpODJBPVBDBTPQBSFDFJNQFEJSBMJCFSEBEF 1SPGFTTPS B /FTUBSFTQPTUB DBEBFTUVEBOUFGPSNVMBSg PTFVQSwQSJPFYFNQMPcJNQPSUBOUFBQFOBTRVFGJRVFDMBSPP SFGFSFODJBMUFwSJDPOPRVBMEFWFNTFCBTFBSPTFYFNQMPT PV TFKB DBSBDUFSJ[BEPTQPSBTQFDUPTJNQSFWJTrWFJTRVF QPSBDBTP JNQPTTJCJMJUBSBNVNBFTDPMIBSBDJPOBMFNVNEFUFSNJOBEPNP NFOUP OVNBEBEBDJSDVOTUiODJB
1PSRVF TF DPNPSFWFMBBQTJDBOgMJTF TPNPTOPTTPTJNQVM TPTFEFTFKPTJODPOTDJFOUFTFTFFTUFTEFTDPOIFDFNCBSSFJSBTF MJNJUFTQBSBBCVTDBEBTBUJTGBmkPF TPCSFUVEP TFDPOTFHVFN BTBUJTGBmkPCVSMBOEPFFOHBOBOEPBDPOTDJpODJB GJDBEJGrDJMTVT UFOUBSBJEFJBEFWPOUBEFMJWSFRVFBHFQPSEFWFS"MnNEJTTP TF PRVFTFQBTTBFNOPTTBDPOTDJpODJBnTJNQMFTFGFJUPEJTGBSmBEP DVKBTDBVTBTSFBJTTkPJODPOTDJFOUFTFFTDPOEJEBT UBNCnNGJDB DPNQSPNFUJEBBDPODFQmkPEFVNBDPOTDJpODJBSFTQPOTgWFM
&YQMJRVFQPSRVFOFNBOFDFTTJEBEFOFNBDPOUJOHpODJB JNQFEFNSFBMNFOUFBMJCFSEBEF
1PSRVF EFGBUP BQTJDBOgMJTF DPNBQSgUJDBEPBVUPDPOIF DJNFOUPFDPNBFYQMJDBmkPEBPSJHFNFEPTQSPCMFNBTEP ²JEFBMEPFHP³ OkPJNQFEFBnUJDBFTJNBGB[BWBOmBSBP QSPQPSVNBOPWBNPSBMTFYVBM
/FNBOFDFTTJEBEFOFNBDPOUJOHpODJBJNQFEFNSFBMNFO UFBMJCFSEBEFQPSRVFIgVNDBNQPEBMJCFSEBEFQPTTrWFM PV TFKB FNWF[EFGJDBSNPTSFTJHOBEPT QBTTJWPT DPOGPSNBEPTF PNJTTPTEJBOUFEBSFBMJEBEF JOUFSFTTBJOEBHBSPRVFGB[FNPT
4-
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
BMJCFSEBEF DPNPRVFRVJTFSBNGB[FSDPOPTDP BOFDFTTJEBEF FBDPOUJOHpODJB &YQMJRVFBDPODFQmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBEFMJCFSEBEF %FBDPSEPDPNBDPODFQmkPBSJTUPUnMJDB BMJCFSEBEFTF Q{FBPRVFnDPOEJDJPOBEPFYUFSOBNFOUF OFDFTTJEBEF FBP P RVFBDPOUFDFTFNFTDPMIBEFMJCFSBEB DPOUJOHpODJB cMJWSF BRVFMFRVFUFNFNTJNFTNPPQSJODrQJPQBSBBHJSPVOkPBHJS JTUPn BRVFMFRVFnDBVTBJOUFSOBEFTVBBmkPPVEBEFDJTkPEF OkPBHJS"MJCFSEBEFnDPODFCJEBDPNPPQPEFSQMFOPFJODPO EJDJPOBMEBWPOUBEFQBSBEFUFSNJOBSBTJNFTNB JTUPn QBSBBV UPEFUFSNJOBSTFcQFOTBEB UBNCnN DPNPBVTpODJBEFDPOT USBOHJNFOUPTFYUFSOPTFJOUFSOPT JTUPn DPNPVNBDBQBDJEBEF RVFOkPFODPOUSBPCTUgDVMPTQBSBTFSFBMJ[BSOFNnGPSmBEBQPS DPJTBBMHVNBQBSBBHJS5SBUBTFEBFTQPOUBOFJEBEFQMFOBEP BHFOUF RVFEgBTJNFTNPPTNPUJWPTFPTGJOTEFTVBBmkPTFN TFSDPOTUSBOHJEPPVGPSmBEPQPSOBEBFQPSOJOHVnN &YQMJRVFBDPODFQmkPTBSUSFBOBEFMJCFSEBEF0RVF4BSUSF RVJTEJ[FSBPBGJSNBSRVF²FTUBNPTDPOEFOBEPThMJCFSEB EF³ 4BSUSFMFWPVBPQPOUPMJNJUFBDPODFQmkPBSJTUPUnMJDBEFRVF BMJCFSEBEFnJODPOEJDJPOBEBFEFUFSNJOBEBBQFOBTQFMBSB[kP PVQFMBJOUFMJHpODJB1BSBFMF BMJCFSEBEFnBFTDPMIBJODPO EJDJPOBMRVFPQSwQSJPIPNFNGB[EFTFVTFSFEFTFVNVOEP 2VBOEPKVMHBNPTFTUBSTPCPQPEFSEFGPSmBTFYUFSOBTNBJT QPEFSPTBTEPRVFBOPTTBWPOUBEF FTTFKVMHBNFOUPnVNBEF DJTkPMJWSF QPJTPVUSPTIPNFOT OBTNFTNBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT OkPTFDVSWBSBNOFNTFSFTJHOBSBN1PSJTTP QBSFDFQBSBEPYBM BBGJSNBmkPEF4BSUSFBPEJ[FSRVF²FTUBNPTDPOEFOBEPThMJ CFSEBEF³ JTUPn BJEFOUJGJDBmkPEFEPJTUFSNPTJODPNQBUrWFJT ²DPOEFOBmkP³F²MJCFSEBEF³&MFRVJTEJ[FSDPNJTTPRVF DPNP BOFDFTTJEBEFFBGBUBMJEBEF JOFWJUBWFMNFOUFTPNPTMJWSFTQBSB FTDPMIFS PVTFKB BHJSPVOPTSFTJHOBS &YQMJRVFDPNTVBTQBMBWSBTBNBOFJSBDPNPFTUPJDPT &TQJ OPTBF)FHFMFWJUBNPQPSMJCFSEBEFFOFDFTTJEBEF BGJSNBO EPRVFBMJCFSEBEFOkPnVNQPEFSWPMVOUgSJPEFFTDPMIBF TJNBBmkPOFDFTTgSJBEPUPEP &TTFTGJMwTPGPTDPMPDBNBMJCFSEBEFOBBUJWJEBEFEFDBEB VNFORVBOUPQBSUFEFVNUPEPOFDFTTgSJP PRVBMBHFMJWSFNFO UFQPSRVFBHFOFDFTTBSJBNFOUF*TTPRVFSEJ[FSRVFBTBm{FT MJWSFTOkPTkPEFUFSNJOBEBTFYUFSOBNFOUF NBTUBNCnNOkP EFQFOEFNFYDMVTJWBNFOUFEBFTDPMIBJOEJWJEVBM"TBm{FTMJ WSFTTkPEFDPSSFOUFTOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFEBFTTpODJBJOUFSOBEB UPUBMJEBEFEPTTFSFT1PSJTTPFTTBDPODFQmkPOkPNBOUnNB PQPTJmkPFOUSFMJCFSEBEFFOFDFTTJEBEF NBTBGJSNBRVFBOF DFTTJEBEF BTMFJTEBOBUVSF[B BTOPSNBTFSFHSBTEBDVMUVSB BT MFJTEBIJTUwSJB nBNBOFJSBQFMBRVBMBMJCFSEBEFEPUPEPTFNB OJGFTUB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BUPUBMJEBEFnMJWSFQPSRVFTFQ{FB TJNFTNBOBFYJTUpODJBFEFGJOFQPSTJNFTNBBTMFJTFSFHSBTEF TVBBUJWJEBEFFnOFDFTTgSJBQPSRVFUBJTMFJTFSFHSBTFYQSJNFN OFDFTTBSJBNFOUFPRVFFMBnFGB[-JCFSEBEFOkPnFTDPMIFSF EFMJCFSBS NBTBHJSPVGB[FSBMHVNBDPJTBFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPN BOBUVSF[BEPBHFOUFRVF OPDBTP nPUPEP &YQMJRVFDPNPPTFTUPJDPTF)FHFMEFGJOFNBMJCFSEBEFIV NBOB 0TFTUPJDPTF)FHFMBGJSNBNRVFPUPEPnSBDJPOBMFRVF TVBTQBSUFTUBNCnNPTkP%FTTBNBOFJSB BMJCFSEBEFIVNBOB TFNBOJGFTUBRVBOEPBHFFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNBTMFJTEPUPEP QBSBPCFNEBUPUBMJEBEF
&YQMJRVFDPNP&TQJOPTBEFGJOFBMJCFSEBEFIVNBOB &TQJOPTBBGJSNBRVFBTQBSUFTTkPEFNFTNBFTTpODJBRVF PUPEPF QPSUBOUP TkPSBDJPOBJTFMJWSFTDPNPFMF EPUBEBTEF GPSmBJOUFSJPSQBSBBHJSQPSTJNFTNBT EFTPSUFRVFBMJCFSEBEF nUPNBSQBSUFBUJWBOBBUJWJEBEFEPUPEP $PNP)FHFMFYQMJDBPTVSHJNFOUPIJTUwSJDPEBGJHVSBEPJO EJWrEVPMJWSF 0TVSHJNFOUPIJTUwSJDPEBGJHVSBEPJOEJWrEVPMJWSFBQBSFDF EFEVBTGPSNBTQSJODJQBJT1SJNFJSP DPJODJEJOEPDPNPTVSHJ NFOUPEBDVMUVSB PVTFKB nMJWSFPIPNFNRVFOkPTFEFJYB EPNJOBSQFMBTGPSmBTEBOBUVSF[BFRVFBTWFODF EPCSBOEPBT hTVBWPOUBEFQPSNFJPEPUSBCBMIP EBMJOHVBHFNFEBTBSUFT &NTVBPVUSBGPSNB FNVNQSJNFJSPNPNFOUP DPSSFTQPOEFBP TVSHJNFOUPEBJOUFSJPSJEBEFDSJTUkRVFEFTDPCSFBDPOTDJpODJB DPNPDPOTDJpODJBEFTJF OVNTFHVOEPNPNFOUP BPTVSHJNFO UPEBJOEJWJEVBMJEBEFSBDJPOBMNPEFSOBPVEPJOEJWrEVPDPNP DPOTDJpODJBEFTJSFGMFYJWB JTUPn DPNPSB[kPFWPOUBEFJOEFQFO EFOUFTEBOBUVSF[BPVEBOFDFTTJEBEFOBUVSBMFJOEFQFOEFOUF EBDPBmkPEFBVUPSJEBEFTFYUFSOBTOBEFGJOJmkPEFTFVQFOTB NFOUPFEFTVBWPOUBEF &YQMJRVFBDPODFQmkPEBMJCFSEBEFDPNP²QPEFSGB[FS³F DPNP²QPTTJCJMJEBEFPCKFUJWB³ $POTJEFSBOEPRVFOPTTBTFTDPMIBTTkPDPOEJDJPOBEBTQF MBTDJSDVOTUiODJBTOBUVSBJT QTrRVJDBT DVMUVSBJTFIJTUwSJDBTFN RVFWJWFNPTFRVFBMJCFSEBEFnVNBUPEFFTDPMIB TPNPTMJWSFT RVBOEPFYFSDFNPTPQPEFSEFGB[FSBMHVNBDPJTBFOkPTJN QMFTNFOUFEFRVFSFSBMHVNBDPJTB&TTBDPODFQmkPCBTFJBTF OBOPmkPEF²QPTTJCJMJEBEFPCKFUJWB³ JTUPn PDVSTPEFVNB TJUVBmkPQPEFTFSNVEBEPQPSOwT FNDFSUBTEJSFm{FTFTPC DFSUBTDPOEJm{FT"MJCFSEBEFnBDBQBDJEBEFQBSBQFSDFCFS UBJTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTFPQPEFSQBSBSFBMJ[BSBRVFMBTBm{FTRVF NVEBNPDVSTPEBTDPJTBT EBOEPMIFTPVUSBEJSFmkPPVPVUSP TFOUJEP &YQMJRVFBOPmkPEF²QPTTrWFM³FBDPODFQmkPEB²MJCFSEB EF³DPNPBCFSUVSBUFNQPSBMPVDPNPSFMBmkPDPNPQPT TrWFM 1PTTrWFMnBRVJMPDSJBEPQFMBOPTTBQSwQSJBBmkPcPRVF WFNhFYJTUpODJBHSBmBTBPOPTTPBHJS/PFOUBOUP OkPTVSHF DPNP²gSWPSFNJMBHSPTB³ FTJNDPNPBRVJMPRVFBTDJSDVOTUiO DJBTBCSJSBNQBSBBOPTTBBmkP"TTJN BMJCFSEBEFFODPOUSBTF OBEJTQPTJmkPQBSBJOUFSQSFUBSFEFDJGSBSBTMJOIBTEFGPSmBF EJSFm{FTEPDBNQPQSFTFOUFTDPNPQPTTJCJMJEBEFTPCKFUJWBT JTUPn DPNPBCFSUVSBEFOPWBTEJSFm{FTFEFOPWPTTFOUJEPT DPNCBTFOPRVFFTUgEBEP1PSJTTPBMJCFSEBEFnBDPOTDJpODJB TJNVMUiOFBEBTDJSDVOTUiODJBTFYJTUFOUFTFEBTBm{FTRVF TVT DJUBEBTQPSUBJTDJSDVOTUiODJBT OPTQFSNJUFNVMUSBQBTTgMBT EBOEPMIFTPVUSPSVNPFVNOPWPTFOUJEP RVFOkPUFSJBNTFN BOPTTBBmkP $PNFOUFPUFYUPEF.FSMFBV1POUZFNRVFBMJCFSEBEFTF BQSFTFOUBDPNPQPTTJCJMJEBEFPCKFUJWBJOTDSJUBOPQSwQSJP NVOEP .FSMFBV1POUZOPTEJ[RVFTPNPTVNBFTUSVUVSBQTJDPMwHJDB FIJTUwSJDB&YJTUJNPTTPCBTDPOEJm{FTEFUFSNJOBEBTQFMPNVO EPFTPCPRVFGB[FNPTDPNFMBT1PSJTTP OkPIgOFDFTTJEBEF BCTPMVUBOFNFTDPMIBBCTPMVUB KBNBJTTPNPTDPNPVNBDPJTB EFUFSNJOBEBFKBNBJTTPNPTVNBDPOTDJpODJBEFUFSNJOBOUF"P NFTNPUFNQPRVFPNVOEPOPTFTDPMIF FTDPMIFNPTPOPTTP NVOEPFQPSJTTP²BMJCFSEBEFnTFNQSFPFODPOUSPEFOPTTP
4.
Manual do Professor
JOUFSJPSDPNPFYUFSJPS³"TTJN BMJCFSEBEFDPNPQPTTJCJMJEBEF PCKFUJWBJOTDSJUBOPQSwQSJPNVOEPnFTTBGPSmBUSBOTGPSNBEPSB RVF FNCPSBTFKBDPOEJDJPOBEBIJTUPSJDBNFOUF OkPnPCTUgDVMP hMJCFSEBEF FTJNPNFJPQFMPRVBMFMBQPEFFYFSDFSTF 1PSRVFQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFBMJCFSEBEFnOPTTPQPEFSQB SBEBSVNTFOUJEPOPWPhTDPOEJm{FTEFGBUPEFOPTTBTWJ EBT 1PSRVF FNCPSBOkPTFKBNPTMJWSFTQBSBFTDPMIFSUPUBM NFOUFPRVFOPTBDPOUFDF TPNPTMJWSFTQBSBFTDPMIFSPRVF GB[FSDPNPRVFOPTBDPOUFDF*TTPTJHOJGJDBRVFPOFDFTTgSJP OkPnVNBGBUBMJEBEFCSVUBOFNRVFPQPTTrWFMnQVSBDPO UJOHpODJBPVBDBTP0QPTTrWFMnPRVFTFFODPOUSBBCFSUPOP DPSBmkPEPOFDFTTgSJPFRVFOPTTBMJCFSEBEFBHBSSBQBSBGB[FS TFMJCFSEBEF/FTTFNPNFOUP BMJCFSEBEFTFBGJSNBDPNPVN QPEFSUSBOTGPSNBEPSQPSNFJPEBEFDJTkPEFBHJSFEBFTDPMIB EPTNFJPTQPTTrWFJTQBSBUSBOTGPSNBSVNBTJUVBmkPEFGBUPOV NBSFBMJEBEFOPWB &YQMJRVFQPSRVF QBSBPTTFSFTIVNBOPT WJEBFNPSUFTkP BDPOUFDJNFOUPTTJNCwMJDPT 4kPBDPOUFDJNFOUPTTJNCwMJDPTQPSRVFOkPTFMJNJUBNBTJN QMFTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTCJPMwHJDPT4wQBSBPTTFSFTIVNBOPTBWJEB FBNPSUFUpNTJHOJGJDBm{FT QPTTVFNTFOUJEPFGB[FNTFOUJEP0 TFOUJEPEFOPTTBWJEB QPSFYFNQMP DPNPEJTTF.POUBJHOF OkP SFTJEFOBRVBOUJEBEFEFEVSBmkP FTJNOPFNQSFHPEBEPBFMB
#APqTULOß߯ßßpe_]a_e j_e] &YQMJRVFQPSRVF FNOPTTBDVMUVSB PDBNQPEPOFDFTTgSJP QBSFDFUFSEJNJOVrEPFORVBOUPPDBNQPEPQPTTrWFMQBSFDF UFSBVNFOUBEP 1PSRVFPTBCFSDJFOUrGJDPUFDOPMwHJDPQBSFDFEPNJOBSBT GPSmBTOBUVSBJTEFNPEPDBEBWF[NBJTBNQMPFDSFTDFOUF TF KBQFMBDBQBDJEBEFEFQSFWFSPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTOBUVSBJT TFKB QPSNFJPEFJOUFSWFOm{FTRVFNVEBNPQSwQSJPDVSTPEBOB UVSF[B 1PSRVFBTFYQMJDBm{FTDJFOUrGJDBT hNFEJEBRVFTFUPSOBN NBJTBDVSBEBT UPSOBNTFUBNCnNNBJTFTQFDrGJDBTFNBJT GSBHNFOUBEBT 2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEJTTP "DJpODJBFTUgDPOEFOBEBBWFSBOBUVSF[BDPNPVNNPTBJ DPEFQBSUFTDPNQPOFOUFT BSCJUSBSJBNFOUFEFGJOJEBT«NFEJEB RVFTFEFTFOWPMWF UFOEFBWFSPTPCKFUPTDBEBWF[NBJTGSBH NFOUBEPT QSPDVSBOEPBTTJNDPOUSPMBSNBJTDVJEBEPTBNFOUF BTDPOEJm{FTOBTRVBJTFMFTTFNBOJGFTUBN&OUSFUBOUP DPNP DPOTFRVpODJB QPEFEFTFOWPMWFSUnDOJDBTRVFDPOUSPMBNBMHV NBTEBTQBSUFT NBTRVFQPEFNBGFUBSPUPEPEFNBOFJSBJN QSFWJTrWFM 1PSRVFBHFOnUJDBFBFOHFOIBSJBHFOnUJDBTkPJNQPSUBOUFT QBSBOwT 1PSRVFDPOGFSJSBNBPTTFSFTIVNBOPTVNHSBOEFQPEFS TPCSFBIFSFEJUBSJFEBEF USB[FOEPUnDOJDBTQBSBDPOIFDFSPT HFOFTEBTFTQnDJFTWFHFUBJTFBOJNBJT QBSBEFDJGSBSBTNFO TBHFOTRVrNJDBTDJGSBEBTEBTNPMnDVMBTHpOJDBTFBUnQBSBNP EJGJDBSHFOwUJQPTJOEJWJEVBJT5pNTJEPFOPSNFTPTCFOFGrDJPT EFTTFTDPOIFDJNFOUPTOBNFEJDJOB OBJOE|TUSJB OBBHSJDVMUV SB NPEJGJDBOEPBWJTkPRVFPIPNFNQPTTVrBEFTFVMVHBSOB OBUVSF[B±FMFOkPnP²SFJEBDSJBmkP³ NBTVNFMPOBNJMFOBS
4/
FMPOHVrTTJNBDBEFJBEBWJEB±FOBQSwQSJBEFGJOJmkPEPRVF nTFSIVNBOP 1PSRVFPQPEFSJPEBTFNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTFEPDPNQMFYPJO EVTUSJBMNJMJUBSGB[FNDPNRVFBTQFTRVJTBTFNHFOnUJDBF FOHFOIBSJBHFOnUJDBTVTDJUFNTnSJPTQSPCMFNBTnUJDPT 1PSRVF FNWJTUBEPBVNFOUPEPMVDSPFEPQPEFSJPNJMJUBS FTTBTFNQSFTBTFFTTBTJOTUiODJBTJOEVTUSJBJTNJMJUBSFTBQSP QSJBNTF EFNPEPQBSUJDVMBS QSJWBEP EPTSFTVMUBEPTDJFOUrGJ DPUFDOPMwHJDPTNBOUJEPTDPNPTFHSFEPTF TFNQSFTUBSDPOUBT BOJOHVnN UPNBNEFDJT{FTRVFBGFUBNUPEBTBTGPSNBTEFWJEB EPQMBOFUB &YQMJRVFPQSPCMFNBEBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFNPSBMOPUPDBOUF BPTVTPTEPDPOIFDJNFOUPHFOnUJDPDPOUFNQPSiOFP 0QSPCMFNBnRVF BJOEBRVFJNFOTPTFDJFOUJGJDBNFOUF SFWPMVDJPOgSJPT PTDPOIFDJNFOUPTEFTFOWPMWJEPTOFTTBgSFB EPTBCFSTkPBJOEBNVJUPQFRVFOPTFJODFSUPTBDFSDBEBTDPO TFRVpODJBTBMPOHPQSB[P%FTTBNBOFJSB BBQMJDBCJMJEBEF JNFEJBUBEFTTFTDPOIFDJNFOUPTUFNVNBJNQMJDBmkPnUJDBOP DBNQPEBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFDPNPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTFBTHF SBm{FTGVUVSBTTPCSFPTRVBJT GSFRVFOUFNFOUF OkPTFUFNB NBJTWBHBJEFJB &YQMJRVFPTQSPCMFNBTnUJDPTUSB[JEPTQFMBJEFJBEFDPOUSPMF EBIFSFEJUBSJFEBEF 6NEPTQSPCMFNBTnUJDPTNBJTHSBWFTFODPOUSBTFOBDIB NBEB²TPOEBHFNHpOJDB³ QPSNFJPEBRVBMTFQSFUFOEFJEFO UJGJDBSQFTTPBTRVFUFSJBNHFOFTRVFBTQSFEJTQPSJBNBPDSJNF PVBDFSUBTEPFOmBTMJHBEBTBDFSUPTUJQPTEFUSBCBMIP$PO TFRVFOUFNFOUF PDSJNFFBEPFOmBQBTTBNBTFSUJEPTDPNP FGFJUPTOFDFTTgSJPTEFVNBDBVTBMJEBEFOBUVSBMOFDFTTgSJB±B IFSFEJUBSJFEBEF%FTTBNBOFJSB QPEFSTFJBBUnNFTNPGBMBS FN²EFTUJOPCJPMwHJDP³ UPSOBOEPWB[JBTBTJEFJBTEFMJCFSEB EF SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFFBVUPEFUFSNJOBmkPEPTJOEJWrEVPT"MnN EJTTP QPEFSJBIBWFSBEJTDSJNJOBmkPTPDJBMEBTQFTTPBTRVF UJWFTTFNFTTFTTVQPTUPTHFOFT²DSJNJOPTPT³PV²EPFOUJPTQBSB PTFSWJmP³6NPVUSPQSPCMFNBnEFDPSSFOUFEBDIBNBEB²UFSB QJBHpOJDBHFSNJOBM³ JTUPn RVFJOUFSWnNFNDnMVMBTIVNBOBT EBSFQSPEVmkPPVDnMVMBTHFSNJOBJTDPNBGJOBMJEBEFEFDVSBS EPFOmBTHFOnUJDBTPVDPSSJHJS²EFGFJUPTHFOnUJDPT³5SBUBTFEB FVHFOJB JTUPn BWFMIBJEFJBEF²QVSF[BEBSBmB³PVEFQVSJGJDB mkPEBFTQnDJFDPNBFMJNJOBmkPEPT²JNQVSPT³PVEPT²JOGF SJPSFT³PVEPT²EFGFJUVPTPT³&OUSFUBOUP FTTBnVNBEFGJOJmkP RVFEFQFOEFEFWBMPSFTDVMUVSBJTFOkPCJPMwHJDPT"JOEBVN PVUSPQSPCMFNBTFSJBBQSPEVmkPEFBSNBTCJPMwHJDBT JTUPn P VTPEFMJCFSBEPEFNJDSPSHBOJTNPT WrSVT CBDUnSJBT GVOHPT PV EFTVCTUiODJBTUwYJDBTPCUJEBTEFDnMVMBTWJWBTDPNPQSPQwTJUP EFNBUBSPVJODBQBDJUBSTFSFTIVNBOPT 1PSRVFOkPQPEFNPTBDFJUBSBJEFJBEF²EPFOmBHFOnUJDB³ UBOUPEPQPOUPEFWJTUBDJFOUrGJDPDPNPEPQPOUPEFWJTUB NPSBM "JEFJBEF²EPFOmBHFOnUJDB³nJOBDFJUgWFMEPQPOUPEFWJTUB DJFOUrGJDPQPSRVFUSB[EFWPMUBBTWFMIBTJEFJBTEFGBUBMJEBEFFEF EFTUJOP PVBJEFJBEFRVFOBEBQPEFNPTDPOUSBBOFDFTTJEBEF OBUVSBM
DPNPTFBTEPFOmBTGPTTFNFGFJUPTOFDFTTgSJPTEFVNB DBVTBMJEBEFOBUVSBMOFDFTTgSJB±BIFSFEJUBSJFEBEF5BNCnN nJOBDFJUgWFMEPQPOUPEFWJTUBNPSBMQPSRVFFTTBJEFJBQPEFSJB BDBSSFUBSBEJTDSJNJOBmkPTPDJBMEBTQFTTPBTRVFUJWFTTFNEF UFSNJOBEPTHFOFT PVTFKB VNBWJPMpODJBEBTPDJFEBEFDPOUSB FTTBTQFTTPBT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
.FODJPOFPTQSFDFJUPTEB(FOcUJDB GPSNVMBEPTQPS4V[VLJ F,OVETUPO /FDFTTJEBEFEFDPOIFDFSPTHFOFTBOUFTEFJOUFSWJSHFOF UJDBNFOUFFWJUBSFJNQFEJSBSFMBmkPDBVTBMFOUSF²EFGFJUPT³ HFOnUJDPTFDPNQPSUBNFOUPTIVNBOPTBTJOGPSNBm{FTHFOn UJDBTTPCSFVNJOEJWrEVPEFWFNTFSVTBEBTQPSFMFMJWSFNFOUF BTUFSBQJBTHpOJDBTRVFJODJEFNTPCSFBTDnMVMBTHFSNJOBJTPV SFQSPEVUPSBTIVNBOBTTFNBJOGPSNBmkPFPDPOTFOUJNFOUPEB TPDJFEBEFEFWFNTFSQSPJCJEBTnFUJDBNFOUFJOBDFJUgWFMPEF TFOWPMWJNFOUPEFQFTRVJTBTFBQSPEVmkPEFBSNBTCJPMwHJDBT DBEBQFTTPBUFNPEJSFJUPEFSFDFCFSBTJOGPSNBm{FTTPCSFBT DPOEJm{FTEPNFJPBNCJFOUFRVFQPEFNDBVTBSNVUBm{FTPV QSFKVEJDBSBJOGPSNBmkPHFOnUJDBDPOUJEBOBTNPMnDVMBTBUSBOT GFSpODJBEFHFOFTFOUSFFTQnDJFTn[POBEFQFSJHPBCJPEJWFSTJ EBEFBOJNBMFWFHFUBMEFWFTFSQSFTFSWBEBPNFSPBD|NVMPEF DPOIFDJNFOUPTHFOnUJDPTOkPHBSBOUFBTBCFEPSJB BQSVEpODJB FBDPSSFmkPEFOPTTBTEFDJT{FTBMHVNBTRVFTU{FTBJOEBQSFDJ TBNEFSFTQPTUBT DPNPBBQSPQSJBmkPQSJWBEBEPDwEJHPHFOnUJ DP BPCUFOmkPEFMVDSPDPNBBQMJDBmkPEFTTFTDPOIFDJNFOUPT FPQSFmPRVFIVNBOBNFOUFRVFSFNPTQBHBSDPNBTEFGJOJm{FT CBTFBEBTOPVTPEBTUFDOPMPHJBTHpOJDBT &TDPMIBUSpTEPTQSFDFJUPTEB(FOcUJDBFFYQMJDJUFPT 1SPGFTTPS B $BEBBMVOPQPEFSgFTDPMIFSUSpTFOUSFPTQSF DFJUPTBQSFTFOUBEPTcJOUFSFTTBOUFEFTUBDBSRVFFNUPEPTFMFT IgVNGPSUFSFTQBMEPCBTFBEPOPTQSFTTVQPTUPTnUJDPTEJTDVUJ EPTFNUPEBB6OJEBEF
#APqTULOß߯ßß=re`]lkhpe_] &NRVFTFOUJEPTDPTUVNBNPTVTBSBQBMBWSBQPMrUJDB &Y QMJRVFPT 6TBNPTBQBMBWSBQPMrUJDBPSBQBSBTJHOJGJDBSVNBBUJWJEBEF FTQFDrGJDB±PHPWFSOP± SFBMJ[BEBQPSVNDFSUPUJQPEFQSPGJT TJPOBM±PQPMrUJDP± PSBQBSBTJHOJGJDBSVNBBmkPDPMFUJWB±P NPWJNFOUPFTUVEBOUJMOBTSVBT QPSFYFNQMP±EFSFJWJOEJDB mkPEFBMHVNBDPJTB GFJUBQPSNFNCSPTEBTPDJFEBEFFEJSJHJEB BPTHPWFSOPTPVBP&TUBEP $JUFPVUSPTTFOUJEPTRVFDPNVNFOUFBUSJCVrNPThQPMrUJDB FFYQMJRVFPT $PNPRVBOEP QPSFYFNQMP VTBNPTFYQSFTT{FTDPNP ²QPMrUJDB VOJWFSTJUgSJB³ ²QPMrUJDB EB FTDPMB³ ²QPMrUJDB EP IPTQJUBM³ ²QPMrUJDBEBFNQSFTB³ ²QPMrUJDBTJOEJDBM³/FTTF DPOKVOUPEFFYQSFTT{FT KgOkPFODPOUSBNPTBSFGFSpODJBBP HPWFSOPOFNBPTQSPGJTTJPOBJTEBQPMrUJDB²1PMrUJDBVOJWFSTJ UgSJB³F²QPMrUJDBEBFTDPMB³SFGFSFNTFhNBOFJSBDPNPVNB JOTUJUVJmkPEFFOTJOP Q|CMJDBPVQSJWBEB EFGJOFTVBEJSFmkP FPNPEPEFQBSUJDJQBmkPPVOkPEFQSPGFTTPSFTFFTUVEBOUFT FNTVBHFTUkP BPNPEPDPNPPTSFDVSTPTTFSkPFNQSFHBEPT BPDVSSrDVMP hTGPSNBTEFBWBMJBmkPEPTBMVOPTFQSPGFTTPSFT BPUJQPEFQFTTPBRVFTFSgSFDFCJEBDPNPFTUVEBOUFPVDPNP EPDFOUF hDBSSFJSBEPTEPDFOUFT BPTTBMgSJPT F TFBJOTUJUVJ mkPGPSQSJWBEB BPDVTUPEBTNFOTBMJEBEFTFNBUSrDVMBT FUD &NTFOUJEPQSwYJNPBFTTFGBMBTFEF²QPMrUJDBEPIPTQJUBM³ +g²QPMrUJDBEBFNQSFTB³SFGFSFTFBPNPEPEFPSHBOJ[BmkPF EJWJTkPEFQPEFSFTSFMBUJWPTBPTJOWFTUJNFOUPTFBPTMVDSPT EFVNBFNQSFTB hEJTUSJCVJmkPEPTTFSWJmPT hEJWJTkPEP USBCBMIP hTEFDJT{FTTPCSFBQSPEVmkPFBEJTUSJCVJmkPEPT QSPEVUPT hTSFMBm{FTDPNBTPVUSBTFNQSFTBT FUD²1PMrUJDB EPTJOEJDBUP³SFGFSFTFhNBOFJSBEFQSFFODIFSPTDBSHPTEF
EJSFmkPTJOEJDBM hTGPSNBTEFSFQSFTFOUBmkPFQBSUJDJQBmkP EPTTJOEJDBMJ[BEPTOBEJSFmkPEPTJOEJDBUP BPTDPOUF|EPTFhT GPSNBTEBTSFJWJOEJDBm{FTFMVUBTEPTTJOEJDBMJ[BEPTFNGBDF EFPVUSPTQPEFSFT FUD 0RVFRVFSFNPTEJ[FSRVBOEPSFMBDJPOBNPTBQPMrUJDBhT BUJWJEBEFTEPHPWFSOP 2VBOEPBSFMBDJPOBNPTBBUJWJEBEFTEPHPWFSOP VTBNPT QPMrUJDBQBSBOPTSFQPSUBSNPTBBm{FTRVFFOWPMWFNQPEFSFTEF EFDJTkPFTFSFBMJ[BNOBTGPSNBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BEBT &TUBEP QBSUJEPTQPMrUJDPT PSHBOJ[Bm{FTTJOEJDBJT 2VBOEPOPTSFGFSJ NPThBENJOJTUSBmkPFHFTUkPEFJOTUJUVJm{FTQ|CMJDBTPVQSJWB EBT BQBMBWSBQPMrUJDBnVTBEBQBSBJOEJDBSRVFPSHBOJ[BSFHFSJS VNBJOTUJUVJmkPFOWPMWFRVFTU{FTEFQPEFS /BFWPMVmkPEBTTPDJFEBEFT PRVFPDSFTDJNFOUPEBTBUSJ CVJm{FTEPTHPWFSOPTBDBSSFUPVhTBUJWJEBEFTQPMrUJDBTOP UPDBOUFhHFTUkPEFwSHkPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFPSHBOJ[BDJP OBJT 0DSFTDJNFOUPEBTBUSJCVJm{FTDPOGFSJEBTBPTHPWFSOPT OB GPSNBEP&TUBEP MFWPVBVNBBNQMJBmkPEPDBNQPEBTBUJWJEB EFTQPMrUJDBT RVFQBTTBSBNBBCSBOHFSRVFTU{FTBENJOJTUSBUJ WBTFPSHBOJ[BDJPOBJT EFDJT{FTFDPOyNJDBTFTFSWJmPTTPDJBJT &TTBBNQMJBmkPEBTBUSJCVJm{FTFTUBUBJTBDBCPVTFFTUFOEFOEP BPVUSBTFTGFSBTEBWJEBTPDJBM MFWBOEPBVNVTPHFOFSBMJ[BEP EBQBMBWSBQPMrUJDBQBSBSFGFSJSTFBUPEBNPEBMJEBEFEFEJSFmkP EFHSVQPTTPDJBJTRVFFOWPMWBQPEFS BENJOJTUSBmkPFPSHBOJ[B mkP UBOUPOPQMBOPQ|CMJDPRVBOUPOPQMBOPQSJWBEP 0RVFFOUFOEFNPTQPSQPMrUJDBRVBOEPBBTTPDJBNPTBBUJWJ EBEFTFYFSDJEBTQPSFTQFDJBMJTUBTFQSPGJTTJPOBJT "BUJWJEBEFSFBMJ[BEBQPSBENJOJTUSBEPSFTFQPMrUJDPTQFS UFODFOUFTBVNDFSUPUJQPEFPSHBOJ[BmkPTPDJPQPMrUJDB±PT QBSUJEPT± RVFEJTQVUBNPEJSFJUPEFHPWFSOBS PDVQBOEP DBSHPTFQPTUPTOP&TUBEP/FTTFTFOUJEP BQPMrUJDBBQBSFDF DPNPBMHPEJTUBOUFEBTPDJFEBEF VNBWF[RVFnBBUJWJEBEF EFFTQFDJBMJTUBTFQSPGJTTJPOBJTRVFTFPDVQBNFYDMVTJWBNFOUF DPNP&TUBEPFPQPEFS"QPMrUJDBnGFJUB²QPSFMFT³FOkP²QPS OwT³ BJOEBRVF²FMFT³TFBQSFTFOUFNDPNPSFQSFTFOUBOUFT ²OPTTPT³ 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEBQPMrUJDBNBJTDPSSFOUFQBSBPTFOTP DPNVNFTPDJBM &YQMJRVFP 0TJHOJGJDBEPEFDPOEVUBEVWJEPTB OkPNVJUPDPOGJgWFM VN UBOUPTFDSFUB DIFJBEFJOUFSFTTFTQBSUJDVMBSFTEJTTJNVMBEPTF GSFRVFOUFNFOUFDPOUSgSJPTBPTJOUFSFTTFTHFSBJTEBTPDJFEBEF FPCUJEPTQPSNFJPTJMrDJUPTPVJMFHrUJNPT&TUFTJHOJGJDBEPSFTVMUB OVNBWJTkPQFKPSBUJWBEBQPMrUJDB RVFBQBSFDFDPNPVNQPEFS EJTUBOUFEFOwT QBTTBTFOPHPWFSOPPVOP&TUBEP
FYFSDJEP QPSQFTTPBTEJGFSFOUFTEFOwT PTBENJOJTUSBEPSFTFQSPGJTTJP OBJTEBQPMrUJDB
QPSNFJPEFQSgUJDBTTFDSFUBTRVFCFOFGJDJBN RVFNPFYFSDFFQSFKVEJDBNPSFTUBOUFEBTPDJFEBEF'BMBTF OBQPMrUJDBDPNP²NBMOFDFTTgSJP³ RVFQSFDJTBNPTUPMFSBSFEP RVBMQSFDJTBNPTEFTDPOGJBS"EFTDPOGJBOmBQPEFSFGFSJSTFUBO UPBPTBUVBJTPDVQBOUFTEPTQPTUPTFDBSHPTQPMrUJDPTDPNPB HSVQPTFPSHBOJ[Bm{FTRVFMIFTGB[FNPQPTJmkPFQSFUFOEFN EFSSVCgMPT TFKBQBSBPDVQBSPTNFTNPTQPTUPTFDBSHPT TFKB QBSBDSJBSVNPVUSP&TUBEP QPSNFJPEFVNBSFWPMVmkPTPDJPF DPOyNJDBFQPMrUJDB 2VFQBSBEPYPFYJTUFFOUSFPTFOUJEPEBQPMrUJDBDPNPEFGJ OJEPSBEFMFJTFDPTUVNFT EJSFJUPTFPCSJHBm{FT DSJBEPSBEF
40
Manual do Professor
FTQBmPTQBSBDPOUFTUBmkP SFTJTUpODJBFEFTPCFEJpODJB FP TFOUJEPQFSWFSTPFNBMnGJDPQBSBBTPDJFEBEF /BEJWFSHpODJBFOUSFPTFOUJEPRVFBEFGJOFDPNPBMHPSFBM RVFDPODFSOFhTPDJFEBEFDPNPVNUPEP EFGJOJOEPMFJTFDPT UVNFT HBSBOUJOEPEJSFJUPTFPCSJHBm{FT DSJBOEPFTQBmPQBSB DPOUFTUBm{FTQPSNFJPEBSFJWJOEJDBmkP EBSFTJTUpODJBFEBEF TPCFEJpODJB FBRVFMFRVFBGBTUBBQPMrUJDBEFOPTTPBMDBODF GB [FOEPBTVSHJSDPNPBMHPQFSWFSTPFNBMnGJDPQBSBBTPDJFEBEF "EJWFSHpODJBFOUSFFTTFTTJHOJGJDBEPTnQSPWPDBEBQFMPTFVPV USPTFOUJEP BRVFMFRVFSFEV[BQPMrUJDBhBmkPEFFTQFDJBMJTUBT FQSPGJTTJPOBJT %pVNFYFNQMPEPFGFJUPEPQBSBEPYPFYJTUFOUFFOUSFPT TFOUJEPTEBQPMrUJDB 1PSFYFNQMP RVBOEPTFDSJUJDBVNBHSFWF EFDMBSBOEPUSB UBSTFEF²HSFWFQPMrUJDB³cDVSJPTPRVFVTFNPT TFNQSPCMFNB BFYQSFTTkP²QPMrUJDBTJOEJDBM³F BPNFTNPUFNQP BDPOEFOF NPT DSJUJDBOEPVNBHSFWFTPCBBMFHBmkPEFTFS²QPMrUJDB³ &YQMJRVFQPSRVFBJNBHFNEBQPMrUJDBDPNPVNQPEFSNB MnGJDPn FMBQSwQSJB QBSBEPYBM &NQSJNFJSPMVHBSQPSRVFBQPMrUJDBGPJJOWFOUBEBQFMPTIV NBOPTDPNPPNPEPQFMPRVBMQVEFTTFNFYQSFTTBSTVBTEJGF SFOmBTFDPOGMJUPTTFNUSBOTGPSNgMPTFNHVFSSBUPUBM FNVTP EBGPSmBFFYUFSNrOJPSFDrQSPDP/VNBQBMBWSB DPNPPNPEP QFMPRVBMPTIVNBOPT GVHJOEPEBWJPMpODJB SFHVMBNFPSEFOBN TFVTJOUFSFTTFTDPOGMJUBOUFT TFVTEJSFJUPTFPCSJHBm{FTDPNP TFSFTTPDJBJT$PNPFYQMJDBS FOUkP RVFBQPMrUJDBTFKBQFSDFCJ EBDPNPEJTUBOUF NBMnGJDBFWJPMFOUB &NTFHVOEPMVHBSQPSRVFBQPMrUJDBGPJJOWFOUBEBDPNPP NPEPQFMPRVBMBTPDJFEBEF JOUFSOBNFOUFEJWJEJEB EJTDVUF EFMJCFSBFEFDJEFFNDPNVNQBSBBQSPWBSPVSFKFJUBSBTBm{FT RVFEJ[FNSFTQFJUPBUPEPTPTTFVTNFNCSPT$PNPFYQMJDBS FOUkP RVFTFKBQFSDFCJEBDPNPBMHPRVFOkPOPTDPODFSOF NBTOPTQSFKVEJDB OkPOPTGBWPSFDF NBTGBWPSFDFBPTJOUFSFT TFTFTDVTPTFJMrDJUPTEFPVUSPT 2VFGBUPTDPOUSJCVFNQBSBRVF FNHFSBM TFUFOIBVNB WJTkPOFHBUJWBEBQPMrUJDB $PUJEJBOBNFOUF KPSOBJT SgEJPT UFMFWJT{FTNPTUSBN OP NVOEPJOUFJSP GBUPTQPMrUJDPTRVFSFGPSmBNBWJTkPQFKPSBUJWB EBQPMrUJDBDPSSVQmkP GSBVEFT DSJNFTJNQVOFTQSBUJDBEPTQPS QPMrUJDPT NFOUJSBTQSPWPDBOEPHVFSSBTQBSBTBUJTGB[FSBPTJO UFSFTTFTFDPOyNJDPTEPTGBCSJDBOUFTEFBSNBNFOUPT EFTWJPT EFSFDVSTPTQ|CMJDPTRVFEFWFSJBNTFSVTBEPTDPOUSBBGPNF BT EPFOmBT BQPCSF[B BVNFOUPEBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTFDPOyNJDBTF TPDJBJT VTPEBTMFJTDPNGJOBMJEBEFTPQPTUBTBPTPCKFUJWPTRVF UJWFSBNBPTFSFNFMBCPSBEBT FUD 2VFBSHVNFOUPQBSBEPYBMQPEFNPTVTBSDPOUSBPTGBUPT OFHBUJWPTEBQPMrUJDB 0BSHVNFOUPEFRVFTwQPEFNPTOPTPQPSBPTGBUPTOFHB UJWPTEBQPMrUJDBFMVUBSDPOUSBFMFTQPSNFJPEBQSwQSJBQPMrUJDB QPJT NFTNPRVBOEPTFGB[VNBHVFSSBDJWJMPVTFSFBMJ[BVNB SFWPMVmkP PTNPUJWPTFPCKFUJWPTTkPBQPMrUJDB JTUPn NVEBO mBTOBGPSNBFOPDPOUF|EPEPQPEFS.FTNPBTVUPQJBTEF FNBODJQBmkPEPHpOFSPIVNBOPDPOUSBUPEBTBTNPEBMJEBEFT EFTFSWJEkP FTDSBWJEkP BVUPSJUBSJTNP WJPMpODJBFJOKVTUJmB DPODFCFNPUnSNJOPEFQPEFSFTJMFHrUJNPT NBTOkPPUnSNJOP EBQSwQSJBQPMrUJDB
41
2VBMBPSJHFNFPTJHOJGJDBEPEBQBMBWSBQPMrUJDB "QBMBWSBQPMrUJDBnHSFHBUBQPMJUJLB WJOEBEFQwMJT1wMJT nBDJEBEF OkPDPNPDPOKVOUPEFFEJGrDJPT SVBTFQSBmBT F TJNDPNPFTQBmPDrWJDP PVTFKB FOUFOEJEBDPNPBDPNVOJEB EFPSHBOJ[BEB GPSNBEBQFMPTDJEBEkPT QPMJUJLPT
JTUPn QFMPT IPNFOTMJWSFTFJHVBJTOBTDJEPTFNTFVUFSSJUwSJP QPSUBEPSFTEF EPJTEJSFJUPTJORVFTUJPOgWFJT BJTPOPNJB JHVBMEBEFQFSBOUFB MFJ FBJTFHPSJB BJHVBMEBEFOPEJSFJUPEFFYQPSFEJTDVUJSFN Q|CMJDPPQJOJ{FTTPCSFBm{FTRVFBDJEBEFEFWFPVOkPEFWF SFBMJ[BS 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEPTUFSNPTQwMJTFDJWJUBT $JWJUBTnPDPSSFTQPOEFOUF FNMBUJN EPHSFHPQwMJTQPS UBOUP BDJEBEFDPNPFOUFQ|CMJDPFDPMFUJWPPVFOUJEBEFDrWJDB $JWJTnPDPSSFTQPOEFOUFEFQPMJUJLPT JTUPn DJEBEkP1wMJTF DJWJUBTDPSSFTQPOEFN JNQFSGFJUBNFOUF BPRVF OPWPDBCVMgSJP QPMrUJDPNPEFSOP DIBNBNPTEF&TUBEPPDPOKVOUPEBTJOTUJ UVJm{FTQ|CMJDBT MFJT FSgSJPQ|CMJDP TFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPT FTVB BENJOJTUSBmkPQFMPTNFNCSPTEBDJEBEF 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEPTUFSNPTUBQPMJUJLBFSFTQVCMJDB 5BQPMJUJLBTkPPTOFHwDJPTQ|CMJDPTEJSJHJEPTQFMPTDJEB EkPTDPTUVNFT MFJT FSgSJPQ|CMJDP PSHBOJ[BmkPEBEFGFTBF EBHVFSSB BENJOJTUSBmkPEPTTFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPT BCFSUVSBEF SVBT FTUSBEBTFQPSUPT DPOTUSVmkPEFUFNQMPTFGPSUJGJDBm{FT PCSBTEFJSSJHBmkP FUD FEBTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOyNJDBTEBDJEB EF NPFEB JNQPTUPTFUSJCVUPT USBUBEPTDPNFSDJBJT FUD 3FT QVCMJDBnPDPSSFTQPOEFOUFMBUJOPEFUBQPMJUJLB TJHOJGJDBOEP QPSUBOUP PTOFHwDJPTQ|CMJDPTEJSJHJEPTQFMPQPQVMVTSPNB OVT JTUPn PTQBUSrDJPTPVDJEBEkPTMJWSFTFJHVBJT OBTDJEPT OPTPMPEF3PNB 0RVFTFRVFSEJ[FSRVBOEPTFBGJSNBRVFPTHSFHPTFPT SPNBOPTJOWFOUBSBNBQPMrUJDBUBMDPNPBDPOIFDFNPTIPKF FNEJB %J[FSRVFPTHSFHPTFSPNBOPTJOWFOUBSBNBQPMrUJDBOkP TJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVF BOUFTEFMFT OkPFYJTUJBNPQPEFSFBBV UPSJEBEF NBTTJNRVFJOWFOUBSBNPQPEFSFBBVUPSJEBEFQP MrUJDPTQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUPT2VBOEPTFBGJSNBRVFPTHSFHPTF SPNBOPTJOWFOUBSBNBQPMrUJDB PRVFTFEJ[nRVFEFTGJ[FSBN BRVFMBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEBBVUPSJEBEFFEPQPEFS&NCPSB OPT DPNFmPT HSFHPTFSPNBOPTUJWFTTFNDPOIFDJEPBPSHBOJ[BmkP FDPOyNJDPTPDJBMEFUJQPEFTQwUJDPPVQBUSJBSDBM VNDPOKVOUP EFNFEJEBTGPJUPNBEPQFMPTQSJNFJSPTEJSJHFOUFT±PTMFHJT MBEPSFT±EFNPEPBJNQFEJSBDPODFOUSBmkPEPTQPEFSFTFEB BVUPSJEBEFOBTNkPTEFVNSFJ TFOIPSEBUFSSB EBKVTUJmBFEBT BSNBT SFQSFTFOUBOUFEBEJWJOEBEF 2VFUJQPEFQPEFSFYJTUJBBOUFTEBTTPDJFEBEFTHSFDPSP NBOBT $JUFDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEFTTFUJQPEFQPEFS /BTSFBMF[BTFYJTUFOUFTBOUFTEPTHSFHPT OPTUFSSJUwSJPT RVFWJSJBNBGPSNBSB(SnDJB±SFBMF[BTNJDpOJDBTFDSFUFOTFT ± CFNDPNPOBTRVFFYJTUJBNOPTUFSSJUwSJPTRVFWJSJBNBGPS NBS3PNB±SFBMF[BTFUSVTDBT±FOPTHSBOEFTJNQnSJPTPSJFO UBJT±1nSTJB &HJUP #BCJMyOJB ÊOEJB $IJOB± WJHPSBWBPQPEFS EFTQwUJDPPVQBUSJBSDBM0DIFGFFSBVNTFOIPS FOGFJYBOEPFN TVBTNkPTBQSPQSJFEBEFEPTPMPFUVEPRVBOUPOFMFIPVWFTTF BBVUPSJEBEFSFMJHJPTBFNJMJUBS TFOEP QPSJTTP SFJ TVNPTB DFSEPUFFDPOEVUPSNJMJUBSTVQSFNP$PNPDSFTDJNFOUPEFNP HSgGJDP BFYQBOTkPUFSSJUPSJBM BEJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIPFPT BDPSEPTNJMJUBSFTFOBWBJTFOUSFHSVQPT BBVUPSJEBEF FNCPSB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
DPODFOUSBEBOBTNkPTEPSFJ QBTTPVBTFSEFMFHBEBQPSFMFB TFVTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT &TUBCFMFmBVNQBSBMFMPFOUSFBDPODFQmkPEFGBNrMJBOB "OUJHVJEBEFFFNOPTTBnQPDB /B"OUJHVJEBEF GBNrMJBOkPFSBPRVFnIPKFQBSBOwT QBJ NkFFGJMIPT
NBTFSBVNBVOJEBEFFDPOyNJDBDPOTUJUVrEB QFMPTBOUFQBTTBEPTFEFTDFOEFOUFT QBJ NkF GJMIPT HFOSPT OPSBT UJPTFTPCSJOIPT FTDSBWPT BOJNBJT UFSSBT FEJGJDBm{FT QMBOUBm{FT CFOTNwWFJTFJNwWFJT±QFTTPBTFDPJTBTFSBN QSPQSJFEBEFTEPQBUSJBSDB EFTQPUFTPVQBUFSGBNJMJBT $PNCBTFOBSFMBmkPEFQPEFSFTOBTPDJFEBEFQBUSJBSDBM FYQMJRVFBTFHVJOUFFYQSFTTkP²"RVJMPRVFBQSB[BPSFJ UFNGPSmBEFMFJ³ &TTBFYQSFTTkPTJHOJGJDBRVF OB"OUJHVJEBEF PQPEFSFSB FYFSDJEPQPSVNDIFGFEFGBNrMJBPVEFGBNrMJBT DMk USJCP BM EFJB
DVKBBVUPSJEBEFFSBQFTTPBMFBSCJUSgSJB EFDJEJOEPTPCSF BWJEBFBNPSUFEFUPEPTPTNFNCSPTEPHSVQP TPCSFBQPTTFF EJTUSJCVJmkPEBTSJRVF[BT BHVFSSBFBQB[ BTBMJBOmBT FNHFSBM TPCBGPSNBEFDBTBNFOUPT
PQSPJCJEPFPQFSNJUJEP &NRVFDPOTJTUJBBQSPQSJFEBEFEFUFSSBOBTPDJFEBEFQB USJBSDBM "QSPQSJFEBEFEBUFSSBFEFTFVTQSPEVUPTFYJTUJBTPCEVBT GPSNBTQSJODJQBJT DPNPQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBEPSFJF QPSUBO UP DPNPEPNrOJPQFTTPBMEPDIFGFPVQBUSJBSDB&TTFQBUSJNy OJPPVQSPQSJFEBEFQBUSJNPOJBMFSBDFEJEP TFHVOEPBWPOUBEF BSCJUSgSJBEPQBUSJBSDB BPTDIFGFTEFDMkTFUSJCPT BPTHSVQPT TBDFSEPUBJTFNJMJUBSFT NFEJBOUFTFSWJmPTFPVUSJCVUPT DP NPQSPQSJFEBEFDPMFUJWBEBTBMEFJBTPVQSPQSJFEBEFDPNVOBM EPDIFGFEBBMEFJB RVFQBHBWBUSJCVUPTBPSFJFNUSPDBEFQSP UFmkP TVCNFUFOEPTFBPQPEFSSnHJPF QPSUBOUP hBVUPSJEBEF SFMJHJPTBFNJMJUBSEPTFOIPS 2VFDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTUJOIBPQPEFSOBTPDJFEBEFQBUSJBS DBM /BTPDJFEBEFQBUSJBSDBM PQPEFSFSBEFTQwUJDPPVQBUSJBS DBMFYFSDJEPQFMPDIFGFEFGBNrMJBTPCSFVNDPOKVOUPEFGBNr MJBTBFMFMJHBEBTQPSMBmPTEFEFQFOEpODJBFDPOyNJDBFNJMJUBS QPSBMJBOmBTNBUSJNPOJBJT OVNBSFMBmkPQFTTPBMFNRVFPDIF GFHBSBOUJBQSPUFmkPFPTT|EJUPTPGFSFDJBNMFBMEBEFFPCFEJpO DJB KVSBOEPDVNQSJSBWPOUBEFEPQSJNFJSPUPUBMPEFUFOUPSEB BVUPSJEBEFQPTTVrBQPEFSTVQSFNPJORVFTUJPOgWFMQBSBEFDJEJS RVBOUPBPQFSNJUJEPFBPQSPJCJEP FQBSBFTUBCFMFDFSPTWrODV MPTDPNPTBHSBEPJODPSQPSBEPPVDPSQPSJGJDBEPPEFUFOUPSEP QPEFSGJHVSBWBFNTFVQSwQSJPDPSQPBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTEPQP EFS BQSFTFOUBOEPTFDPNPNBOJGFTUBmkPEBQSwQSJBDPNVOJ EBEFNgHJDPQPSSFDFCFSBBVUPSJEBEFEPTEFVTFT PEFUFOUPS EPQPEFSQPTTVrBGPSmBTPCSFOBUVSBMPVNgHJDBUSBOTDFOEFOUF QPSTFSEFPSJHFNEJWJOB PSFJFSBEJWJOJ[BEPFBDSFEJUBWBTFFN TVBJNPSUBMJEBEFDPNPDPOEJmkPEBQSFTFSWBmkPEBDPNVOJEB EF&TTBEJWJOJ[BmkPPDPMPDBWBBDJNBFGPSBEBDPNVOJEBEF IFSFEJUgSJPFSBUSBOTNJUJEPBPQSJNPHpOJUPEPSFJPV OBGBMUB EFTUF BVNNFNCSPEBGBNrMJBSFBM 2VFBTQFDUPTUPSOBSBNQSPQrDJBBJOWFOmkPEBQPMrUJDB 0QSJNFJSPnBGPSNBEBQSPQSJFEBEFEBUFSSBPTFHVOEP PGFOyNFOPEBVSCBOJ[BmkPFPUFSDFJSP PNPEPEFEJWJTkP UFSSJUPSJBMEBTDJEBEFT
&NRVFNFEJEBBQSPQSJFEBEFEFUFSSBTQSPQJDJPVPTVSHJ NFOUPEBQPMrUJDB $PNPBQSPQSJFEBEFEBUFSSBOkPQFSUFODJBhBMEFJBOFN BPSFJ NBThTGBNrMJBTJOEFQFOEFOUFT FDPNPBTHVFSSBTBN QMJBWBNPDPOUJOHFOUFEFFTDSBWPT GPSNPVTFOB(SnDJBFFN 3PNBVNBDBNBEBQPCSFEFDBNQPOFTFTRVFNJHSBSBNQBSB BTBMEFJBT BMJTFFTUBCFMFDFSBNDPNPBSUFTkPTFDPNFSDJBOUFT QSPTQFSBSBN USBOTGPSNBSBNBTBMEFJBTFNDFOUSPTVSCBOPTF QBTTBSBNBEJTQVUBSPEJSFJUPBPQPEFSDPNBTHSBOEFTGBNrMJBT BHSgSJBT6NBMVUBEFDMBTTFTQFSQBTTBBIJTUwSJBHSFHBFSPNB OBFYJHJOEPTPMVmkP &NRVFNFEJEBBVSCBOJ[BmkPQSPQJDJPVPTVSHJNFOUPEB QPMrUJDB "VSCBOJ[BmkPTJHOJGJDPVVNBDPNQMFYBSFEFEFSFMBm{FT FDPOyNJDBTFTPDJBJTRVFDPMPDBWBFNDPOGSPOUPOkPTwQSP QSJFUgSJPTBHSgSJPT EFVNMBEP FBSUFTkPTFDPNFSDJBOUFT EF PVUSP NBTUBNCnNBNBTTBEFBTTBMBSJBEPTEBQPQVMBmkPVS CBOB PTOkPQSPQSJFUgSJPT HFOFSJDBNFOUFDIBNBEPTEF²PT QPCSFT³"MVUBEFDMBTTFTJODMVrB BTTJN MVUBTFOUSFPTSJDPTF MVUBTFOUSFSJDPTFQPCSFT5BJTMVUBTFSBNEFDPSSFOUFTEPGBUP EFRVFUPEPTPTJOEJWrEVPTQBSUJDJQBWBNEBTHVFSSBTFYUFSOBT UBOUPQBSBBFYQBOTkPUFSSJUPSJBMDPNPQBSBBEFGFTBEFTVB DJEBEF GPSNBOEPBTNJMrDJBTEPTOBUJWPTEBDPNVOJEBEF&TTB QBSUJDJQBmkPNJMJUBSGB[JBDPNRVFUPEPTTFKVMHBTTFNOPEJSFJUP EFJOUFSWJS EFBMHVNNPEP OBTEFDJT{FTFDPOyNJDBTFMFHBJT EFTVBTDPNVOJEBEFT"MVUBEBTDMBTTFTQFEJBVNBTPMVmkP &TTBTPMVmkPGPJBQPMrUJDB RVFUSBOTGPSNPVBTDPNVOJEBEFT VSCBOBTFNDJEBEFTQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUBT &NRVFNFEJEBBEJWJTkPUFSSJUPSJBMTVTDJUPVPTVSHJNFOUP EBQPMrUJDB 0TQSJNFJSPTDIFGFTQPMrUJDPT UBNCnNDPOIFDJEPTDPNP MFHJTMBEPSFT JOUSPEV[JSBNVNBEJWJTkPOPUFSSJUwSJPEBTDJEB EFT WJTBOEPEJNJOVJSPQPEFSJPEBTGBNrMJBTSJDBTBHSgSJBT EPT BSUFTkPTFDPNFSDJBOUFTVSCBOPTSJDPTFTBUJTGB[FSBSFJWJOEJ DBmkPEPTDBNQPOFTFTQPCSFTFEPTBSUFTkPTFBTTBMBSJBEPT VSCBOPTQPCSFT&N"UFOBT QPSFYFNQMP BQwMJTGPJTVCEJWJEJ EBFNVOJEBEFTTPDJPQPMrUJDBTEFOPNJOBEBTEFNPTFN3PNB FNUSJCVT2VFNOBTDFTTFOVNEFNPTPVOVNBUSJCVT JOEF QFOEFOUFNFOUFEFTVBTJUVBmkPFDPOyNJDB UJOIBBTTFHVSBEP PEJSFJUPEFQBSUJDJQBSEJSFUBPVJOEJSFUBNFOUFEBTEFDJT{FT EBDJEBEF/PDBTPEF"UFOBT UPEPTPTOBUVSBJTEPEFNPTUJ OIBNPEJSFJUPEFQBSUJDJQBSEJSFUBNFOUFEPQPEFS EPOEFP SFHJNFTFSVNBEFNPDSBDJB&N3PNB PTOkPQSPQSJFUgSJPT PVPTQPCSFTGPSNBWBNBQMFCF RVFQBSUJDJQBWBJOEJSFUBNFO UFEPQPEFSQPSRVFUJOIBPEJSFJUPEFFMFHFSVNSFQSFTFOUBOUF ±PUSJCVOPEBQMFCF±QBSBEFGFOEFSFHBSBOUJSPTJOUFSFTTFT QMFCFVTQFSBOUFPTJOUFSFTTFTFQSJWJMnHJPTEPTRVFQBSUJDJ QBWBNEJSFUBNFOUFEPQPEFS PTQBUSrDJPT RVFDPOTUJUVrBNP QPQVMVTSPNBOVT0SFHJNFQPMrUJDPSPNBOPFSB BTTJN VNB PMJHBSRVJB $JUFBMHVOTUSBmPTRVFQPTTJCJMJUBSBNBPTHSFHPTFBPTSP NBOPTJOWFOUBSFNPQPEFSQPMrUJDP 3PNQFOEPDPNPQPEFSEFTQwUJDP HSFHPTFSPNBOPTJO WFOUBSBNPQPEFSQPMrUJDPQPSRVFTFQBSBSBNBBVUPSJEBEF QFTTPBMQSJWBEBEPDIFGFEFGBNrMJB±TFOIPSJPQBUSJBSDBMF QBUSJNPOJBM±FPQPEFSJNQFTTPBMQ|CMJDP QFSUFODFOUFhDP MFUJWJEBEFTFQBSBSBNPQSJWBEPFPQ|CMJDPFJNQFEJSBNB JEFOUJGJDBmkPEPQPEFSQPMrUJDPDPNBQFTTPBEPHPWFSOBOUF TFQBSBSBNBVUPSJEBEFNJMJUBSFQPEFSDJWJM TVCPSEJOBOEPB
42
Manual do Professor
QSJNFJSBBPTFHVOEPTFQBSBSBNBVUPSJEBEFNgHJDPSFMJHJP TBFQPEFSUFNQPSBMMBJDP JNQFEJOEPBEJWJOJ[BmkPEPTHP WFSOBOUFTFRVFFTUFTGPTTFNTVNPTTBDFSEPUFTDSJBSBNB JEFJBFBQSgUJDBEBMFJDPNPFYQSFTTkPEFVNBWPOUBEFDP MFUJWBFQ|CMJDB EFGJOJEPSBEPTEJSFJUPTFEFWFSFTQBSBUPEPT PTDJEBEkPT JNQFEJOEPRVFGPTTFDPOGVOEJEBDPNBWPOUBEF QFTTPBMEFVNHPWFSOBOUFDSJBSBNJOTUJUVJm{FTFGVOm{FTQ| CMJDBTQBSBBQMJDBmkPEBTMFJTFHBSBOUJBEPTEJSFJUPT JTUPn PTUSJCVOBJTFPTNBHJTUSBEPTDSJBSBNBJOTUJUVJmkPEPFSgSJP Q|CMJDPPVEPGVOEPQ|CMJDP JTUPn EPTCFOTFSFDVSTPTRVF QFSUFODFNhTPDJFEBEFFTkPQPSFMBBENJOJTUSBEPTQPSNFJP EFUBYBT JNQPTUPTFUSJCVUPT JNQFEJOEPBDPODFOUSBmkPEB QSPQSJFEBEFFEBSJRVF[BOBTNkPTEPTEJSJHFOUFTDSJBSBNP FTQBmPQPMrUJDPPVFTQBmPQ|CMJDP±B"TTFNCMFJBHSFHBFP 4FOBEPSPNBOP± OPRVBMPTRVFQPTTVrBNEJSFJUPTJHVBJT EFDJEBEBOJBEJTDVUJBNTVBTPQJOJ{FT EFGFOEJBNTFVTJOUF SFTTFT EFMJCFSBWBNFNDPOKVOUPFEFDJEJBNQPSNFJPEPWPUP QPEFOEP UBNCnNQFMPWPUP SFWPHBSVNBEFDJTkPUPNBEBc FTTFPDPSBmkPEBJOWFOmkPQPMrUJDB 2VBMBJNQPSUiODJBEPFTQBmPQ|CMJDPQBSBBDPOTPMJEBmkP EBQPMrUJDBOBTPDJFEBEFHSFDPSPNBOB "FYJTUpODJBEPFTQBmPQ|CMJDPEFEJTDVTTkP EFMJCFSBmkP FEFDJTkPTJHOJGJDBRVFBTPDJFEBEFFTUgBCFSUBBPTBDPOUFDJ NFOUPT RVFBTBm{FTOkPGPSBNGJYBEBTEFVNBWF[QPSUPEBT QPSBMHVNBWPOUBEFUSBOTDFOEFOUF RVFFSSPTEFBWBMJBmkPF EFEFDJTkPQPEFNTFSDPSSJHJEPT RVFVNBBmkPQPEFHFSBS QSPCMFNBTOPWPT OkPQSFWJTUPTOFNJNBHJOBEPT RVFFYJHJSkP PBQBSFDJNFOUPEFOPWBTMFJTFOPWBTJOTUJUVJm{FT&NPVUSBT QBMBWSBT HSFHPTFSPNBOPTUPSOBSBNBQPMrUJDBJOTFQBSgWFMEP UFNQPF DPNPWJNPTOPDBTPEBnUJDB UBNCnNDPODFCFSBNB BmkPQPMrUJDBMJHBEBhOPmkPEFQPTTrWFMPVEFQPTTJCJMJEBEF 2VFDPOUSBEJm{FTIBWJBOBTPDJFEBEFHSFDPSPNBOB EP QPOUPEFWJTUBEBQPMrUJDB &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS BFDPOPNJBFSBBHSgSJBFFTDSBWJTUB EF TPSUFRVFVNBQBSUFEBTPDJFEBEF±PTFTDSBWPT±FTUBWB FYDMVrEBEPTEJSFJUPTQPMrUJDPTFEBWJEBQPMrUJDBFNTFHVOEP MVHBS BTPDJFEBEFFSBQBUSJBSDBMF DPOTFRVFOUFNFOUF BTNV MIFSFTUBNCnNFTUBWBNFYDMVrEBTEBDJEBEBOJBFEBWJEBQ|CMJ DB"FYDMVTkPBUJOHJBUBNCnNPTFTUSBOHFJSPTFPTNJTFSgWFJT "DJEBEBOJBFSBFYDMVTJWBEPTIPNFOTBEVMUPTMJWSFTOBTDJEPT OPUFSSJUwSJPEBDJEBEF"MnNEJTTP BEJGFSFOmBEFDMBTTFTPDJBM OVODBFSBBQBHBEB NFTNPRVFPTQPCSFTUJWFTTFNEJSFJUPT QPMrUJDPT "PMPOHPEBIJTUwSJB BTPDJFEBEFQBUSJBSDBMFBQPMrUJDB GPSBNEVBTSFTQPTUBTTPDJBJThTRVFTU{FTEPQPEFS"MnN EFTTBTEVBTGPSNBT RVFPVUSPDBNJOIPGPJQSPQPTUPBFT TBTRVFTU{FT OPTnDVMP99 RVFNPFTUVEPVFGPSNVMPVF RVBJTTVBTQSJODJQBJTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT 6NUFSDFJSPDBNJOIPTFDPOTUJUVJOBGPSNBEFRVFGPNPT BDPTUVNBEPTQFMBUSBEJmkPBOUSPQPMwHJDBFVSPQFJBBDPOTJ EFSBSBTTPDJFEBEFTFYJTUFOUFTOBT"NnSJDBTDPNPBUSBTBEBT QSJNJUJWBTFJOGFSJPSFT&TTBWJTkPOBTDFVEPQSPDFTTPEFDPMP OJ[BmkPFDPORVJTUB JOJDJBEPOPTnDVMP97*0TDPORVJTUBEPSFT FDPMPOJ[BEPSFTRVFBQPSUBSBNOBT"NnSJDBTJOUFSQSFUBSBNBT EJGFSFOmBTFOUSFFMFTFPTOBUJWPTBNFSJDBOPTDPNPEJTUJOmkP IJFSgSRVJDBFOUSFTVQFSJPSFTFJOGFSJPSFTQBSBFMFTPT²rOEJPT³ OkPUJOIBNMFJ SFJ Gn FTDSJUB NPFEB DPNnSDJP IJTUwSJBF QPS UBOUP FSBNTFSFTEFTQSPWJEPTEPTUSBmPTEBRVJMPRVF QBSBP FVSPQFVDSJTUkP T|EJUPEFNPOBSRVJBT DPOTUJUVrBBDJWJMJ[BmkP FBIVNBOJEBEFQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUB
43
$PNPBUSBEJmkPBOUSPQPMwHJDBFVSPQFJBWJBBTTPDJFEBEFT FYJTUFOUFTOBT"NnSJDBT OBnQPDBEFTFVEFTDPCSJNFO UP "WJTkPFVSPQFJBFSBFnFUOPDpOUSJDB PVTFKB DPOTJEFSB QBES{FT WBMPSFTFQSgUJDBTEPTCSBODPTBEVMUPTQSPQSJFUgSJPT FVSPQFVTDPNPTFGPTTFNPT|OJDPTWgMJEPT TVQFSJPSFTBUPEPT PTPVUSPTFEFWFOEPTFSWJSEFNPEFMPPVEFQBESkPQBSBUPEBT BTTPDJFEBEFT QPSRVFTFSJBNEFGJOJEPSFTEBDJWJMJ[BmkP&TTB WJTkPQBTTPVBTFSDPNQBSUJMIBEBQFMPTEFTDFOEFOUFTEPTDPMP OJ[BEPSFT JTUPn QFMPTCSBODPTEBTUSpT"NnSJDBT FTFNBOUnN BUnPTEJBTEFIPKF 2VFnFUOPDFOUSJTNP "QBMBWSBFUOPDFOUSJTNPnDPNQPTUBEFFUOPTFDFOUSP&U OPTWFNEPHSFHPFTJHOJGJDB²PDPOKVOUPEFTFSFTRVFQPTTVFN BNFTNBPSJHFNFPTNFTNPTUSBmPT³ EPOEFEFTJHOBSOBmkP QPWP SBmB0FUOPDFOUSJTNPnBWJTkPEFNVOEPEBRVFMFTRVF DPOTJEFSBNRVFTVBFUOJBPVTFVHSVQPnUOJDPnTVQFSJPSBPT EFNBJTFNBJTJNQPSUBOUFEPRVFPTPVUSPT 2VBJTBTBUSJCVJm{FTEPDIFGFOVNBTPDJFEBEFDPNVOJUg SJB 0DIFGFQPTTVJUSpTGVOm{FTEPBSQSFTFOUFT GB[FSBQB[ FGBMBS"MnNEFTTBTGVOm{FT DBCFhDIFGJBSFQSFTFOUBSBDP NVOJEBEFQFSBOUFPVUSBTDPNVOJEBEFTFNDBTPTEFBMJBOmBT FHVFSSBT5PEBWF[RVFPDIFGFOkPSFBMJ[BBTGVOm{FTJOUFSOBT FBGVOmkPFYUFSOBUBJTDPNPBDPNVOJEBEFBTEFGJOF UPEBTBT WF[FTRVFQSFUFOEFVTBSTVBTGVOm{FTQBSBDSJBSPQPEFSTFQB SBEP FMFnNPSUPQFMBDPNVOJEBEF
#APqTULOß߯ßß=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$-% 2VBJTGPSBNBTUSpTFYQMJDBm{FTQSJODJQBJTFNBJTEVSBEPV SBTTPCSFBPSJHFNEBWJEBQPMrUJDB "TJOTQJSBEBTOPNJUPEBT*EBEFTEP)PNFN&TTFNJUP SFDFCFVJO|NFSBTWFST{FT NBT FNTVBTMJOIBTHFSBJT OBSSB TFNQSFPNFTNPOPQSJODrQJP EVSBOUFBQSJNFJSB*EBEFEP)P NFN JTUPn B*EBEFEF0VSP PTTFSFTIVNBOPTWJWJBNOBDPN QBOIJBEPTEFVTFT OBTDJBNKgBEVMUPTEJSFUBNFOUFEBUFSSB FSBNJNPSUBJTFGFMJ[FT TVBWJEBUSBOTDPSSJBFNQB[FIBSNPOJB TFNOFDFTTJEBEFEFMFJTFHPWFSOP&NDBEBWFSTkPEFTTFNJUP OBSSBTFBQFSEBPVPGJNEB*EBEFEF0VSP&NDBEBVNBEBT WFST{FT BQFSEBEB*EBEFEF0VSPnOBSSBEBEFNPEPEJWFSTP QPSnN FNUPEBT BOBSSBUJWBSFMBUBVNBRVFEBEPTIVNBOPT RVFTkPBGBTUBEPTEPTEFVTFT UPSOBNTFNPSUBJT WJWFNJTPMB EBNFOUFQFMBTGMPSFTUBT TFNWFTUVgSJP NPSBEJB BMJNFOUBmkP TFHVSB TFNQSFBNFBmBEPTQFMBTGFSBTFJOUFNQnSJFT1PVDP BQPVDP EFTDPCSFNPGPHPQBTTBNBDP[FSPTBMJNFOUPTFB USBCBMIBSPTNFUBJT DPOTUSPFNDBCBOBT UFDFNPWFTUVgSJP GBCSJDBNBSNBTQBSBDBmBFQSPUFmkPDPOUSBBOJNBJTGFSP[FT GPSNBNGBNrMJBT&TUkPOB*EBEFEP#SPO[FFQBTTBSkP UFNQPT EFQPJT h*EBEFEP'FSSP B|MUJNBEBTJEBEFT&NHFSBM B*EBEF EP'FSSPnEFTDSJUBDPNPBFSBEPTIPNFOTPSHBOJ[BEPTFNHSV QPT GB[FOEPHVFSSBTFOUSFTJ1BSBDFTTBSPFTUBEPEFHVFSSB PTEFVTFTGB[FNOBTDFSVNIPNFNFNJOFOUF RVFSFEJHJSgBT QSJNFJSBTMFJTFDSJBSgPHPWFSOP&TUFFTDPMIJEPFFOWJBEPEPT EFVTFTnPMFHJTMBEPS$PNFMF OBTDFBQPMrUJDB$PNWBSJBOUFT FTTFNJUPTFSgVTBEPOB(SnDJBQPS1MBUkPF FN3PNB QPS$rDF SP QBSBTJNCPMJ[BSBPSJHFNEBQPMrUJDBDPNPBUJWJEBEFEBSB[kP BUSBWnTEBTMFJTFEBGJHVSBEPMFHJTMBEPS-FJTFMFHJTMBEPSHB SBOUFNBPSJHFNSBDJPOBMEBWJEBQPMrUJDB BPCSBEBSB[kPTFOEP
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
&YQMJRVFBFYQSFTTkP²BDPOWFOmkPGVOEBBQPMrUJDB³
4FBQwMJTFBTMFJTTkPDPOWFOm{FTIVNBOBT QPEFNNV EBS EFTEFRVFIBKBNVEBOmBOBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT"KVTUJmBTFSg OkPTwDPOTFSWBSBTMFJTNBTUBNCnNQFSNJUJSTVBNVEBOmB TFNRVFJTTPEFTUSVBBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDB FB|OJDBNBOFJ SBEFSFBMJ[BSNVEBOmBTTFNEFTUSVJmkPEBPSEFNQPMrUJDBnP EFCBUFQBSBDIFHBSBPDPOTFOTP JTUPn BFYQSFTTkPQ|CMJDBEB WPOUBEFEBNBJPSJB PCUJEBQFMPWPUPEPTDJEBEkPTSFVOJEPT FNBTTFNCMFJB &NPQPTJmkPBPTTPGJTUBT 1MBUkPF"SJTUwUFMFTBGJSNBNP DBSgUFSOBUVSBMEBQwMJTFEBKVTUJmB&NCPSBDPODPSEFNOFTTF BTQFDUP EJGFSFNOPNPEPDPNPDPODFCFNBQSwQSJBKVTUJmB1B SB1MBUkP PTTFSFTIVNBOPTFBQwMJTQPTTVFNBNFTNBFTUSV UVSB0TIVNBOPTTkPEPUBEPTEFUSpTBMNBTPVUSpTQSJODrQJPT EFBUJWJEBEFBBMNBDPODVQJTDFOUFPVEFTFKBOUF TJUVBEBOBT FOUSBOIBTPVOPCBJYPWFOUSF
RVFCVTDBTBUJTGBmkPEPTBQF UJUFTEPDPSQP UBOUPPTOFDFTTgSJPThTPCSFWJWpODJBDPNPPT RVF TJNQMFTNFOUF DBVTBNQSB[FSBBMNBJSBTDrWFMPVDPMnSJDB TJUVBEBOPQFJUPPVOPDPSBmkP
RVFEFGFOEFPDPSQPDPOUSB BTBHSFTT{FTEPNFJPBNCJFOUFFEFPVUSPTIVNBOPT SFBHJOEP hEPSOBQSPUFmkPEFOPTTBWJEBFBBMNBSBDJPOBMPVJOUFMFD UVBM TJUVBEBOBDBCFmB
RVFTFEFEJDBBPDPOIFDJNFOUP UBOUP OBGPSNBEFQFSDFQm{FTFPQJOJ{FTWJOEBTEBFYQFSJpODJBDPNP OBGPSNBEFJEFJBTWFSEBEFJSBTDPOUFNQMBEBTQFMPQVSPQFOTB NFOUP5BNCnNBQwMJTQPTTVJVNBFTUSVUVSBUSJQBSUJUF GPSNBEB QPSUSpTDMBTTFTTPDJBJTBDMBTTFFDPOyNJDBEPTQSPQSJFUgSJPT EFUFSSB BSUFTkPTFDPNFSDJBOUFT RVFHBSBOUFBTPCSFWJWpODJB NBUFSJBMEBDJEBEFBDMBTTFNJMJUBSEPTHVFSSFJSPT SFTQPOTgWFM QFMBEFGFTBEBDJEBEFFBDMBTTFEPTNBHJTUSBEPT RVFHBSBOUFP HPWFSOPEBDJEBEFTPCBTMFJT1BSB"SJTUwUFMFT QBSBEFUFSNJOBS PRVFnBKVTUJmB QSFDJTBNPTEJTUJOHVJSEPJTUJQPTEFCFOTPT QBSUJMIgWFJTFPTQBSUJDJQgWFJT6NCFNnQBSUJMIgWFMRVBOEPn VNBRVBOUJEBEFRVFQPEFTFSEJWJEJEBFEJTUSJCVrEB±BSJRVF [BnVNCFNQBSUJMIgWFM6NCFNnQBSUJDJQgWFMRVBOEPnVNB RVBMJEBEFJOEJWJTrWFM RVFOkPQPEFTFSSFQBSUJEBOFNEJTUSJCVr EB QPEFOEPBQFOBTTFSQBSUJDJQBEB±PQPEFSQPMrUJDPnVN CFNQBSUJDJQgWFM&YJTUFN QPJT EPJTUJQPTEFKVTUJmBOBDJEBEF BEJTUSJCVUJWB SFGFSFOUFBPTCFOTFDPOyNJDPTQBSUJMIgWFJTFB QBSUJDJQBUJWB SFGFSFOUFBPQPEFSQPMrUJDPQBSUJDJQgWFM"DJEBEF KVTUBTBCFSgEJTUJOHVJMBTFSFBMJ[BSBNCBT
0EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTUnDOJDBTFEPTDPTUVNFTDPOEV[B DPOWFOm{FTFOUSFPTIVNBOPTQBSBBWJEBFNDPNVOJEBEFTPC MFJT
0RVFTJHOJGJDBNPTWPDgCVMPTHSFHPTBSLInFLSBUwT RVF FTUkPOBGPSNBmkPEBTQBMBWSBTRVFEFTJHOBNPTSFHJNFT QPMrUJDPT
&YQMJRVFBFYQSFTTkP²BOBUVSF[BGVOEBBQPMrUJDB³ 0TIVNBOPT GBMBOUFTFQFOTBOUFT TkPTFSFTEFDPNVOJ DBmkP FnFTTBBDBVTBEBWJEBFNDPNVOJEBEFPVEBWJEBQP MrUJDB
"SLInTJHOJGJDB²PRVFFTUghGSFOUF PRVFUFNDPNBOEP³F LSBUwT ²PQPEFSPVBVUPSJEBEFTVQSFNB³"TQBMBWSBTDPNQPT UBTDPNBSLIn BSRVJB EFTJHOBNBRVBOUJEBEFEPTRVFFTUkP OPDPNBOEP"TDPNQPTUBTDPNLSBUwT DSBDJB EFTJHOBNRVFN FTUgOPQPEFS
1BSBPTHSFHPT RVBMFSBBGJOBMJEBEFEBWJEBQPMrUJDB
2VFTkPNPOBSRVJB PMJHBSRVJB QPMJBSRVJBFBOBSRVJB
1BSBPTHSFHPT BGJOBMJEBEFEBWJEBQPMrUJDBFSBBKVTUJmBOB DPNVOJEBEF
.POBSRVJB²HPWFSOPEFVNTw³ NPOBT PMJHBSRVJBHP WFSOPEFBMHVOT PMJHwJ QPMJBSRVJBHPWFSOPEFNVJUPT QPMPT BOBSRVJBHPWFSOPEFOJOHVnN BOB
BPSEFN BIBSNPOJBFBDPODwSEJBFOUSFPTIVNBOPTOBGPSNB EBDJEBEF"SB[kPGVOEBBQPMrUJDB "TJOTQJSBEBTQFMBPCSB EPQPFUBHSFHP)FTrPEP 0USBCBMIPFPTEJBT"HPSB BPSJHFN EBWJEBQPMrUJDBWJODVMBTFhEPBmkPEPGPHPBPTIPNFOT GFJUB QFMPTFNJEFVT1SPNFUFV RVFSPVCBPGPHPEPTEFVTFTFTFSg QVOJEPQPSFMFT(SBmBTBPGPHP PTIVNBOPTQPEFNUSBCBMIBS PTNFUBJT DP[FSPTBMJNFOUPT GBCSJDBSVUFOTrMJPTFTPCSFUVEP EFTDPCSJSTFEJGFSFOUFTEPTBOJNBJT&TTBEFTDPCFSUBPTMFWBB QFSDFCFSRVFWJWFSkPNFMIPSTFWJWFSFNFNDPNVOJEBEF EJWJ EJOEPPTUSBCBMIPTFBTUBSFGBT0SHBOJ[BEPTFNDPNVOJEBEFT DPMPDBNTFTPCBQSPUFmkPEPTEFVTFT EFRVFNSFDFCFNBT MFJTFBTPSJFOUBm{FTQBSBPHPWFSOP1PVDPBQPVDP QPSnN EFTDPCSFNRVFTVBWJEBQPTTVJQSPCMFNBTFFYJHFTPMVm{FT RVFTPNFOUFFMFTQPEFNFOGSFOUBSFFODPOUSBS.BOUFOEP BQJFEBEFQFMPTEFVTFT FOUSFUBOUP DSJBNMFJTFJOTUJUVJm{FT IVNBOBT EBOEPPSJHFNhDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDBQSPQSJBNFOUF EJUB&TTFNJUPMFWBhUFPSJBQPMrUJDBEFGFOEJEBQFMPTTPGJTUBT /FTTBDPODFQmkP PEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTUnDOJDBTFEPTDPT UVNFTDPOEV[BDPOWFOm{FTFOUSFPTIVNBOPTQBSBBWJEBFN DPNVOJEBEFTPCMFJT"DPOWFOmkPGVOEBBQPMrUJDB "TUFPSJBT RVFBGJSNBNRVFBQPMrUJDBEFDPSSFEBOBUVSF[BIVNBOBFRVF BDJEBEFFYJTUFQPSOBUVSF[B0TIVNBOPTTkP QPSOBUVSF[B EJGFSFOUFTEPTBOJNBJT QPSRVFTkPEPUBEPTEPMwHPT JTUPn EBQBMBWSBDPNPGBMBFQFOTBNFOUP1PSTFSFNEPUBEPTEBQB MBWSB TkPOBUVSBMNFOUFTPDJBJTPV DPNPEJ["SJTUwUFMFT TkP BOJNBJTQPMrUJDPT/BUFPSJBQPMrUJDBBSJTUPUnMJDB OkPnQSFDJTP CVTDBSOPTEFVTFT OBTMFJTPVOBTUnDOJDBTBPSJHFNEBDJEBEF CBTUBDPOIFDFSBOBUVSF[BIVNBOBQBSBOFMBFODPOUSBSBDBVTB EBQPMrUJDB0TIVNBOPT GBMBOUFTFQFOTBOUFT TkPTFSFTEFDP NVOJDBmkPFnFTTBBDBVTBEBWJEBFNDPNVOJEBEFPVEBWJEB QPMrUJDB/FTTBDPODFQmkP BOBUVSF[B DPNPOBUVSF[BIVNBOB GVOEBBQPMrUJDB &YQMJRVFBFYQSFTTkP²BSB[kPGVOEBBQPMrUJDB³ -FJTFMFHJTMBEPSHBSBOUFNBPSJHFNSBDJPOBMEBWJEBQPMr UJDB BPCSBEBSB[kPTFOEPBPSEFN BIBSNPOJBFBDPODwSEJB FOUSFPTIVNBOPTOBGPSNBEBDJEBEF
"TJOEBHBm{FTTPCSFBHpOFTFEBQwMJTPQ{FNPTTPGJTUBT EFGFOTPSFTEPDBSgUFSDPOWFODJPOBMEBKVTUJmB
F1MBUkPF "SJTUwUFMFT EFGFOTPSFTEPDBSgUFSOBUVSBMEBKVTUJmBFEB MFJ &YQMJRVFOPRVFDPOTJTUJBBQPTJmkPEFDBEBVN 1BSBPTTPGJTUBT BQwMJTOBTDFQPSDPOWFOmkPFOUSFPTTFSFT IVNBOPTRVBOEPQFSDFCFNRVFMIFTnNBJT|UJMBWJEBFNDP NVNEPRVFFNJTPMBNFOUP$POWFODJPOBNSFHSBTEFDPOWJWpO DJBRVFTFUPSOBNMFJT OwNPT"KVTUJmBnPDPOTFOTPRVBOUPhT MFJTFBGJOBMJEBEFEBQPMrUJDBnDSJBSFQSFTFSWBSFTTFDPOTFOTP
2VFTkPBVUPDSBDJB BSJTUPDSBDJBFEFNPDSBDJB "VUPDSBDJBQPEFSEFVNB|OJDBQFTTPB BVUwT SFDPOIFDJ EBDPNPSFJBSJTUPDSBDJBQPEFSEPTBSJTUwJ JTUPn EPTNFMIP SFTEFNPDSBDJBQPEFSEPEFNPT JTUPn EPQPWP 2VBJTTkPBTUSpTJEFJBTQPMrUJDBTFMBCPSBEBTQPS1MBUkPF "SJTUwUFMFTRVFUpNQPSCBTFBFYQFSJpODJBQPMrUJDBBOUJHB $PNFOUFBT
44
Manual do Professor
%JTUJOmkPFOUSFQPMrUJDPFOkPQPMrUJDPVNSFHJNFTwn QPMrUJDPTFGPSJOTUJUVrEPQPSVNDPSQPEFMFJTQVCMJDBNFOUFSF DPOIFDJEBTFTPCBTRVBJTUPEPTWJWFN HPWFSOBOUFTFT|EJUPT HPWFSOBOUFTFDJEBEkPT&NTVNB nQPMrUJDPPSFHJNFOPRVBM PTHPWFSOBOUFTFTUkPTVCNFUJEPThTMFJT 7BSJFEBEFEFSFHJ NFTQPMrUJDPTQBSB"SJTUwUFMFT BWBSJBmkPEPTSFHJNFTQPMrUJDPT EFQFOEFEFEPJTGBUPSFTQSJODJQBJTBOBUVSF[BPVrOEPMFEPQP WPFBFYUFOTkPEPUFSSJUwSJP"TTJN QPSFYFNQMP VNQPWPDVKB rOEPMFPVOBUVSF[BUFOEFFTQPOUBOFBNFOUFQBSBBJHVBMEBEFF BMJCFSEBEFFDVKBDJEBEFnEFQFRVFOBFYUFOTkPUFSSJUPSJBMOB UVSBMNFOUFJOTUJUVJSgVNBEFNPDSBDJBFTFSgNBMBWJTBEBTFB TVCTUJUVJSQPSVNPVUSPSFHJNF&NDPOUSBQBSUJEB VNQPWPDVKB rOEPMFPVOBUVSF[BUFOEFFTQPOUBOFBNFOUFQBSBBPCFEJpODJBB VNB|OJDBBVUPSJEBEFFRVFWJWFOVNUFSSJUwSJPFYUFOTPOBUVSBM NFOUFJOTUJUVJSgBNPOBSRVJB TFOEPEFTBWJTBEBTFBTVCTUJUVJS QPSPVUSPSFHJNFQPMrUJDP%FTTBNBOFJSB PTGJMwTPGPTHSFHPT MFHBSBNBP0DJEFOUFBJEFJBEFSFHJNFTQPMrUJDPTOBUVSBJT JTUP n BJEFJBEFRVFBJOTUJUVJmkPEFVNSFHJNFQPMrUJDPEFQFOEF EFGBUPSFTQSPEV[JEPTQFMBOBUVSF[B $PSSVQmkPEPTSFHJNFT QPMrUJDPTPTSFHJNFTQPMrUJDPTTFUSBOTGPSNBNFNEFDPSSpODJB EFNVEBOmBTFDPOyNJDBTFEFSFTVMUBEPTEFHVFSSBT1SFTFOmB PVBVTpODJBEBMFJ WBSJBmkPFDPOyNJDBFNJMJUBSEFUFSNJOBN TFHVOEP1MBUkPF"SJTUwUFMFT BDPSSVQmkPPVEFDBEpODJBEPT SFHJNFTQPMrUJDPTBNPOBSRVJBEFHFOFSBFNUJSBOJB RVBOEP VNTwHPWFSOBQBSBTFSWJSBPTTFVTJOUFSFTTFTQFTTPBJTBBSJT UPDSBDJBEFHFOFSBFNPMJHBSRVJBEPTNVJUPSJDPT±QMVUPDSBDJB ±PVEPTHVFSSFJSPT±UJNPDSBDJB± RVFUBNCnNHPWFSOBN BQFOBTFNTFVJOUFSFTTFQSwQSJPBEFNPDSBDJBEFHFOFSBFN EFNBHPHJBFFTUB FNBOBSRVJB&NHFSBM BBOBSRVJBMFWBhUJSB OJBRVBOEPBTPDJFEBEF EFTHPWFSOBEB BQFMBQBSBVNIPNFN TVQFSJPSBPTPVUSPTOPNBOFKPEBTBSNBTFEPTBSHVNFOUPT OFMFCVTDBOEPBTBMWBmkP &NRVFPCSBQPMrUJDBJNQPSUBOUFEB*MVTUSBmkPBUJQPMPHJB EF1MBUkPF"SJTUwUFMFTBQBSFDFDPNWJHPS /BPCSB0FTQrSJUPEBTMFJT EF.POUFTRVJFV $JUFEPJTNPUJWPTQPSRVFTFQPEFEJ[FSRVF3PNBFSBVNB SFQ|CMJDB 1SPGFTTPS B 0BMVOPQPEFSgFTDPMIFSEPJTFOUSFPTUSpT NPUJWPTQFMPTRVBJT3PNBFSBDPOTJEFSBEBVNBSFQ|CMJDB PHPWFSOPFTUgTVCNFUJEPBMFJTFTDSJUBTJNQFTTPBJT BSFT QVCMJDB DPJTBQ|CMJDB nPTPMPQ|CMJDPSPNBOP EJTUSJCVrEPhT GBNrMJBTQBUSrDJBT NBTQFSUFODFOUFMFHBMNFOUFB3PNB JTUPn B QSPQSJFEBEFEBUFSSBnDPJTBQ|CMJDBDVKPVTPnDPODFEJEPQFMP &TUBEPBDJEBEkPTQSJWBEPT PHPWFSOPBENJOJTUSBPTGVOEPT Q|CMJDPT SFDVSTPTFDPOyNJDPTQSPWFOJFOUFTEFJNQPTUPT UBYBT FUSJCVUPT
VTBOEPPTQBSBBDPOTUSVmkPEFFTUSBEBT BRVFEV UPT UFNQMPT NPOVNFOUPTFOPWBTDJEBEFT FQBSBBNBOVUFO mkPEPTFYnSDJUPT 2VFFSB OB3PNBBOUJHB PJEFBMEPQSrODJQFPVP#PN(P WFSOP &SBVNBOPWBUFPSJBQPMrUJDBRVFNBOUJOIBBJEFJBHSFHBEF RVFBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDBUFNDPNPGJOBMJEBEFBWJEBCPBPV BKVTUJmB JEFOUJGJDBEBDPNBPSEFN IBSNPOJBPVDPODwSEJBOP JOUFSJPSEBDJEBEF/PFOUBOUP BHPSB BKVTUJmBEFQFOEFSgEBT RVBMJEBEFTNPSBJTEPHPWFSOBOUF0QSrODJQFEFWFTFSPNPEFMP EBTWJSUVEFTQBSBBDPNVOJEBEF QPJTFMBPJNJUBSg0QSrODJQF DPNPUPEPTFSIVNBOP nQBTTJPOBMFSBDJPOBM QPSnN EJGFSFO UFNFOUFEPTPVUSPTIVNBOPT OkPQPEFSgDFEFShTQBJY{FT NBTBQFOBThSB[kP1PSJTTP EFWFTFSFEVDBEPQBSBQPTTVJS VNDPOKVOUPEFWJSUVEFTRVFTkPQSwQSJBTEPHPWFSOBOUFKVTUP
45
"UFPSJBEP#PN(PWFSOPEFQPTJUBOBQFTTPBEPHPWFSOBOUFB RVBMJEBEFEBQPMrUJDBFGB[EFTVBTWJSUVEFTQSJWBEBTWJSUVEFT Q|CMJDBT0QSrODJQFFODBSOBBDPNVOJEBEFFBFTQFMIB TFOEP QPSFMBJNJUBEPUBOUPOBWJSUVEFDPNPOPWrDJP &YQMJRVFBTUSBEJm{FTIFCSBJDBFSPNBOBTPCBQFSTQFDUJWB EPOBTDFOUFDSJTUJBOJTNP 0TIFCSFVTEFSBNBPQPEFS FNRVBMRVFSGPSNBFNRVF GPTTFFYFSDJEP VNBNBSDBGVOEBNFOUBMJSSFWPHgWFMPDBSgUFS UFPDSgUJDP$POTJEFSBWBNFMFTRVFPQPEFSQFSUFODFFYDMVTJ WBNFOUFB%FVTFRVFFTUF QPSNFJPEPTBOKPTFEPTQSPGFUBT FMFHFPEJSJHFOUFPVPTEJSJHFOUFT0QPEFS LSBUwT QFSUFODFB %FVT 5InPT
EPOEFUFPDSBDJB DVKBFYQSFTTkPNBJTDMBSBFO DPOUSBTFOVNBQBTTBHFNEPMJWSPEPT1SPWnSCJPT POEFTFMp RVF%FVTEJTTF²1PSNJNSFJOBNPTSFJTFPTQSrODJQFTHPWFS OBN³"MnNEJTTP PTIFCSFVTTFGJ[FSBNDPOIFDFSOkPTwDPNP 1PWPEF%FVT NBTUBNCnNDPNP1PWPEB-FJ"MFHBMJEBEFFSB BMHPUkPQSPGVOEPRVF RVBOEPPDSJTUJBOJTNPTFDPOTUJUVJDPNP OPWBSFMJHJkP GBMBTFOB"OUJHB-FJ BBMJBOmBEF%FVTDPNPQP WP QSPNFUJEBB/PnFB"CSBkPFEBEBB.PJTnT FOB/PWB-FJ B OPWBBMJBOmBEF%FVTDPNPQPWP BUSBWnTEPNFTTJBT+FTVT %P MBEPSPNBOP BQBTTBHFNEBSFQ|CMJDBBPQSJODJQBEPFUFPSJBEP #PN(PWFSOPQSPTTFHVJVF OPQFSrPEPFNRVFPDSJTUJBOJTNP TFFYQBOEFFTFFODPOUSBFNWJBEFUPSOBSTFSFMJHJkPPGJDJBMEP *NQnSJP3PNBOP PQSrODJQFSPNBOPKgTFFODPOUSBJOWFTUJEP EFOPWPTQPEFSFT4FOEP3PNBTFOIPSBEP6OJWFSTP PQSrODJ QFOkPnBQFOBT DPNPTFVOPNFJOEJDB ²PQSJNFJSPDJEBEkP³ QSJODFQT
NBTnJNQFSBEPSSPNBOPFUFOEFSgBTFSWJTUPDPNP TFOIPSEP6OJWFSTP PDVQBOEPPUPQPEBIJFSBSRVJBEPNVO EP FNDVKPDFOUSPFTUg3PNB RVFPQPFUB7JSHrMJPDIBNPVEF $JEBEF&UFSOB"PJNQFSBEPS±PVBPDnTBS±DBCFNBOUFSB IBSNPOJBFBDPODwSEJBOPNVOEP BQBYSPNBOB HBSBOUJEBQF MBGPSmBEBTBSNBT$PNJTTP PQSrODJQFQBTTPVBFOGFJYBSFN TVBTNkPTUPEPTPTQPEFSFT RVFBOUFTDBCJBNBP4FOBEPFBP 1PWP3PNBOP FGPJTFOEPTBDSBMJ[BEP hNBOFJSBEPEnTQPUB PSJFOUBM BUnTFSDPOTJEFSBEPEJWJOP TFOEPMIFBUSJCVrEPTQPEF SFTRVFQFSUFODJBNB+|QJUFSGVOEBEPSEPQPWP SFTUBVSBEPSEB PSEFNVOJWFSTBMFTBMWBEPSEP6OJWFSTP1BSBDVNQSJSTVBTUBSF GBT PQPEFSJNQFSJBMDFOUSBMJ[BEPFIJFSBSRVJ[BEPEFTFOWPMWF VNDPNQMFYPTJTUFNBFTUBUBMFNRVFQSFWBMFDFPQPEFSJPEPT GVODJPOgSJPTJNQFSJBJT DJWJTFNJMJUBSFT
RVFTFFTUFOEFDPNP VNBSFEFJOUSJODBEBEFQFRVFOPTQPEFSFTQPSUPEPPUFSSJUwSJP EP*NQnSJP3PNBOP"FMBCPSBmkPEBUFPSJBQPMrUJDBDSJTUkDPNP UFPMPHJBQPMrUJDBSFTVMUBSgEBBQSPQSJBmkPEFTTBEVQMBIFSBOmB QFMPQPEFSFDMFTJgTUJDP 2VBMFSBBGVOmkPEPJNQFSBEPSPVDnTBSOP*NQnSJP3PNB OP .BOUFSBIBSNPOJBFBDPODwSEJBOPNVOEP BQBYSPNBOB HBSBOUJEBQFMBGPSmBEBTBSNBT &NRVFDPOUFYUPFEFRVFGPSNBTFDPOTUJUVJVPDSJTUJBOJT NP 0DSJTUJBOJTNPTFDPOTUJUVJhNBSHFNEPQPEFSQPMrUJDPF DPOUSBFMF QPJTPT²SFJOPTEFTUFNVOEP³TFSkP QPVDPBQPV DP WJTUPTDPNPPCSBEF4BUBOgTQBSBBQFSEJmkPEPHpOFSPIV NBOP4FQBSBEPEBPSEFNQPMrUJDBFTUBUBM PDSJTUJBOJTNPTFSg PSHBOJ[BEPEFNBOFJSBTFNFMIBOUFBPVUSBTDSFOmBTSFMJHJPTBT OkPPGJDJBJTUPNBSgBGPSNBEFVNBTFJUBSFMJHJPTB/FTTBnQP DB TFJUBTSFMJHJPTBTFDPSSFOUFTGJMPTwGJDBTRVFOkPQPTTVrBN BQwMJTDPNPSFGFSpODJB±QPJT3PNBUVEPEPNJOBWBJNQFSJBM NFOUF±OkPQPEJBNNBJTTFEJSJHJSBVNBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
EFUFSNJOBEB BVNQPWPEFUFSNJOBEP FQPSJTTPEJSJHJBNTFBP TFSIVNBOPFNHFSBM TFNEJTUJOmkPEFOBmkPPVQPWP &NRVFNFEJEBBTFJUBDSJTUkTFEJGFSFODJPVEFPVUSBTTFJ UBT 1PSRVp "TFJUBDSJTUkJSgTFEJGFSFODJBSEFPVUSBTTFJUBTQPSRVFB IFSBOmBKVEBJDB±EPTQSJNFJSPTBQwTUPMPT±FSPNBOB±EPT QSJNFJSPTQBESFT±JSgJOGMVFODJBSPWPDBCVMgSJPFPQFOTBNFO UPEPTDSJTUkPT%FGBUP FTTBIFSBOmBDPOEV[JSghJEFJBEFQPWP EF%FVT FEFMFJ EF%FVT
JTUPn BTEVBTJEFJBTQSPWFOJFOUFT EPWPDBCVMgSJPFEPTDPODFJUPTEBQPMrUJDB"TFJUBDSJTUknVNB DPNVOJEBEFDVKPTNFNCSPTGPSNBNPQPWPEF%FVTTPCBMFJ EF%FVT&TTBDPNVOJEBEFnGFJUBEFJHVBJT±PTGJMIPTEF%FVT SFEJNJEPTQFMP'JMIP± RVFSFDFCFNFNDPOKVOUPB1BMBWSB 4BHSBEBF QFMPCBUJTNPFFVDBSJTUJB QBSUJDJQBNEBOPWBMFJ±B BMJBOmBEP1BJDPNTFVQPWPQFMBNFEJBmkPEP'JMIP"DPNVOJ EBEFnBFLLMFTJB JTUPn BBTTFNCMFJBEPTGJnJT B*HSFKB&FTUB nEFTJHOBEBDPNP3FJOPEF%FVT1PWP MFJ BTTFNCMFJBFSFJOP FTTBTQBMBWSBTJOEJDBN QPSTJNFTNBT BWPDBmkPQPMrUJDBEP DSJTUJBOJTNP QPJTFTDPMIFQBSBSFGFSJSTFBTJNFTNPPTWPDg CVMPTEBUSBEJmkPQPMrUJDBKVEBJDBFSPNBOB $JUFFFYQMJRVFBTCBTFTFNRVFGPJGVOEBEBBSFMJHJkPDSJTUk FDPNPFMBTFUPSOPVBSFMJHJkPPGJDJBMEP*NQnSJP3PNBOP "BVUPSJEBEFBQPTUwMJDBOkPTFMJNJUBBCBUJTNP FVDBSJTUJB FFWBOHFMJ[BmkP+FTVTEFVBPTBQwTUPMPTPQPEFSQBSBMJHBSPT IPNFOTB%FVTF%FMFEFTMJHgMPTRVBOEPMIFTEJTTF BUSBWnTEF 1FESP²5VnT1FESPFTPCSFFTUBQFESBFEJGJDBSFJBNJOIBJHSFKB FBTQPSUBTEPJOGFSOPOkPQSFWBMFDFSkPDPOUSBFMB&VUFEBSFJBT $IBWFTEP3FJOPPRVFMJHBSFTOB5FSSBTFSgMJHBEPOP$nV PRVF EFTMJHBSFTOB5FSSBTFSgEFTMJHBEPOP$nV³&TTBQBTTBHFNEP &WBOHFMIPEF.BUFVTTFSgDPOIFDJEBDPNP²QSJODrQJPQFUSrOFP EBT$IBWFT³FDPNFMBFTUgGVOEBEBB*HSFKBDPNPJOTUJUVJmkPEF QPEFS&TTFQPEFSnUFPDSgUJDP QPJTTVBGPOUFnPQSwQSJP%FVT nP'JMIPRVFNEgQPEFSB1FESP FnTVQFSJPSBPQPEFSQPMrUJDP UFNQPSBM VNBWF[RVFFTUFTFSJBQVSBNFOUFIVNBOP GSgHJMF QFSFDrWFM DSJBEPQPSTFEVmkPEFNPOrBDB"FLLMFTJB DPNVOJEB EFEFCPOTFKVTUPT TFQBSBEBEP&TUBEPFEPQPEFSJNQFSJBM PSHBOJ[BTFDPNOPSNBTFSFHSBTRVFFTUBCFMFDFNIJFSBSRVJBT EFBVUPSJEBEFFEFQPEFS GPSNBOEPPRVFPSPNBOP4BOUP"HPT UJOIPDIBNBSgEF$JWJUBT%FJ B$JEBEFEF%FVT PQPTUBh$JEBEF EPT)PNFOT JOKVTUBFTBUiOJDB JTUPn 3PNB&TTBJOTUJUVJmkP FDMFTJgTUJDBDPOTFHVJSgDPOWFSUFSBPDSJTUJBOJTNPPJNQFSBEPS $POTUBOUJOP RVFUSBOTGPSNBSgVNBTFJUBFNSFMJHJkPPGJDJBMEP *NQnSJP3PNBOP$PNJTTP B*HSFKBJSgJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BSTFSFQF UJOEPPVJNJUBOEPFNTVBPSHBOJ[BmkPJOUFSOBBFTUSVUVSBNJMJUBS FCVSPDSgUJDBEP*NQnSJP PSHBOJ[BmkPRVFQFSEVSBBUnPTEJBT EFIPKF 1PSRVF hNFEJEBRVFP*NQnSJP3PNBOPTFFTGBDFMBWB P QPEFSJPEB*HSFKBDSFTDJB %PJTNPUJWPTMFWBNBFTTFDSFTDJNFOUP FNQSJNFJSPMV HBS BFYQBOTkPEPQSwQSJPDSJTUJBOJTNPQFMBPCSBEBFWBOHFMJ [BmkPEPTQPWPT SFBMJ[BEBQFMPTQBESFTOPTUFSSJUwSJPTEP*N QnSJP3PNBOPFQBSBBMnNEFMFT FNTFHVOEPMVHBS QPSRVFP FTGBDFMBNFOUPEF3PNB EPRVBMSFTVMUBSg OPTTnDVMPTTFHVJO UFT BGPSNBmkPTPDJPFDPOyNJDBDPOIFDJEBDPNPGFVEBMJTNP GSBHNFOUPVBQSPQSJFEBEFEBUFSSB BOUFSJPSNFOUF UJEBDPNP QBUSJNyOJPEF3PNBFEPJNQFSBEPS FGF[TVSHJSFNQFRVFOPT QPEFSFTMPDBJTJTPMBEPT EFTPSUFRVFP|OJDPQPEFSDFOUSBMJ[B EPFIPNPHFOFBNFOUFPSHBOJ[BEPFSBPEB*HSFKB
2VBJTPTUSpTQPEFSFTRVFB*HSFKBBERVJSFDPNPQBTTBS EPTBOPTFNSFMBmkPBP*NQnSJP3PNBOP 0QPEFSSFMJHJPTPEFMJHBSPTIPNFOTB%FVTF%FMFEFT MJHgMPT PQPEFSFDPOyNJDPEFDPSSFOUFEFHSBOEFTQSPQSJF EBEFTGVOEJgSJBTBDVNVMBEBTOPDPSSFSEFWgSJPTTnDVMPT TFKB QPSRVFPTOPCSFTEP*NQnSJP BPTFDPOWFSUFSFN EPBSBNTVBT UFSSBThJOTUJUVJmkPFDMFTJgTUJDB TFKBQPSRVFFTUBSFDFCFSBUFSSBT DPNPSFDPNQFOTBQPSTFSWJmPTQSFTUBEPTBPTJNQFSBEPSFT PQPEFSJOUFMFDUVBM QPSRVFTFUPSOBHVBSEJkFJOUnSQSFUF|OJDB EPTUFYUPTTBHSBEPT±B#rCMJB±FEFUPEPTPTUFYUPTQSPEV [JEPTQFMBDVMUVSBHSFDPSPNBOB±EJSFJUP GJMPTPGJB MJUFSBUVSB UFBUSP NBOVBJTEFUnDOJDBT FUD4BCFSMFSFFTDSFWFSUPSOPVTF QSJWJMnHJPFYDMVTJWPEBJOTUJUVJmkPFDMFTJgTUJDB4FSgB*HSFKB QPS UBOUP BGPSNVMBEPSBEBTUFPSJBTQPMrUJDBTDSJTUkTQBSBPTSFJOPT FJNQnSJPTDSJTUkPT&TTBTUFPSJBTFMBCPSBSkPBDPODFQmkPUFP MwHJDPQPMrUJDBEPQPEFS JTUPn PWrODVMPJOUFSOPFOUSFSFMJHJkP FQPMrUJDB 2VFFSBB#rCMJB "#rCMJBnVNDPOKVOUPEFUFYUPTEFQSPWFOJpODJBT nQPDBT FBVUPSFTNVJUPEJGFSFOUFT FTDSJUPTFNWgSJBTMrOHVBTRVFGPS NBNEPJTHSVQPTQSJODJQBJT P"OUJHPFP/PWP5FTUBNFOUP"P TFSUSBEV[JEBQBSBPMBUJN PTUSBEVUPSFTTwEJTQVOIBNEBMrO HVBDVMUBSPNBOBFEPTUFYUPTRVFGPSNBWBNPDIBNBEP%JSFJUP 3PNBOP"USBEVmkPWFSUFVPTEJGFSFOUFTUFYUPTQBSBBMJOHVB HFNMBUJOBDMgTTJDB GB[FOEPQSFWBMFDFSBMrOHVBKVSrEJDBFMFHBM SPNBOB DPNCJOBOEP BTTJN BGPSUFUSBEJmkPMFHBMJTUBKVEBJDB FBMBUJOB&TTB#rCMJBMBUJOJ[BEBTFSWJSgEFCBTFQBSBBTUFPSJBT QPMrUJDBTFGPSOFDFSgPTDSJUnSJPTQBSBEFDJEJSPRVFBDFJUBSFP RVFSFDVTBSEBTJEFJBTEF1MBUkP "SJTUwUFMFTF$rDFSP DPNCJ OBOEPEFNBOFJSBDPNQMFYBF hTWF[FT QPVDPBDFJUgWFM BT DPODFQm{FTGJMPTwGJDBTFBTUFPDSgUJDBT "TUFPSJBTUFPMwHJDPQPMrUJDBT PWrODVMPJOUFSOPFOUSFSFMJ HJkPFQPMrUJDB
FNCPSBUJWFTTFNEJGFSFOUFTGPSNVMBm{FT OPDPSSFSEB*EBEF.nEJB BQSFTFOUBWBNQPOUPTFNDP NVN$JUFUSpTEFMFTFDPNFOUFPT 1SPGFTTPS B 0BMVOPEFWFSgFTDPMIFSUSpTEPTQPOUPTDP NVOTBCBJYPFDPNFOUgMPT 0QPEFSnUFPDSgUJDP JTUPn QFS UFODFB%FVTF%FMFWFNBPTIPNFOTQPS&MFFTDPMIJEPTQBSB SFQSFTFOUgMP0GVOEBNFOUPEFTTBJEFJBFODPOUSBTFOkPTw OVNBQBTTBHFNEP"OUJHP5FTUBNFOUP RVFKgNFODJPOBNPT POEFTFMpRVF²5PEPQPEFSWFNEP"MUPQPSNJNSFJOBNPT SFJTFHPWFSOBNPTQSrODJQFT³ DPNPUBNCnNOVNBQBTTBHFN EP/PWP5FTUBNFOUP OB&QrTUPMBEF4kP1BVMPBPT3PNBOPT DBQrUVMP9*** POEFTFMpRVF²OkPIgBVUPSJEBEFRVFOkPWF OIBEF%FVT FBTRVFFYJTUFNGPSBNJOTUJUVrEBTQPS%FVT³0 QPEFSnVNGBWPSEJWJOPPVVNBHSBmBEJWJOB FPHPWFSOBOUF OkPSFQSFTFOUBPTHPWFSOBEPT NBTSFQSFTFOUB%FVTQFSBOUF PTHPWFSOBEPTPSFJ QPSRVFFTDPMIJEPQPS%FVT %FMFSFDFCF BMFJ PV DPNPEJ[FNPTUFwMPHPTKVSJTUBT PSFJUSB[BMFJFN TFVQFJUPFPRVFBQSB[BPSFJUFNGPSmBEFMFJ0SFJn QPSUBOUP BGPOUFEBMFJFEBKVTUJmB4FOEPBVUPSEBMFJFUFOEPPQPEFS QFMBHSBmBEF%FVT FTUgBDJNBEBTMFJTFOkPQPEFTFSKVMHB EPQPSOJOHVnN UFOEPQPEFSBCTPMVUP0GVOEBNFOUPEFTTB JEFJBnSFUJSBEPEFVNQSFDFJUPEP%JSFJUP3PNBOPRVFBGJSNB ²/JOHVnNQPEFEBSPRVFOkPUFNFOJOHVnNQPEFUJSBSPRVF OkPEFV³ 0QSrODJQFDSJTUkPEFWFQPTTVJSPDPOKVOUPEBT WJSUVEFTDSJTUkT BTWJSUVEFTDBSEFBJTFPDPOKVOUPEBTWJSUVEFT QSJODJQFTDBTEFGJOJEBTQPS$rDFSPF4pOFDBDPNPQSwQSJBTEP #PN(PWFSOP4FOEPFTQFMIPEBDPNVOJEBEF FNTVBQFTTPB EFWFNFTUBSFODBSOBEBTBTRVBMJEBEFTDSJTUkTRVFBDPNV
5,
Manual do Professor
OJEBEFEFWFJNJUBS "DPNVOJEBEFFPSFJGPSNBNPDPSQP QPMrUJDPBDBCFmBnBDPSPBPVPSFJ PQFJUPnBMFHJTMBmkPTPC BHVBSEBEPTNBHJTUSBEPTFDPOTFMIFJSPTEPSFJ PTNFNCSPT TVQFSJPSFTTkPPTTFOIPSFTPVCBS{FTRVFGPSNBNPTFYnS DJUPTEPSFJFBFMFFTUkPMJHBEPTQPSKVSBNFOUPEFGJEFMJEBEF PVEFWBTTBMBHFN FPTNFNCSPTJOGFSJPSFTTkPPQPWPRVF USBCBMIBQBSBPTVTUFOUPEPDPSQPQPMrUJDP"QwMJTQMBUyOJDB n BTTJN USBOTGPSNBEBOPDPSQPQPMrUJDPEPSFJ "IJFSBSRVJB QPMrUJDBFTPDJBMnDPOTJEFSBEBPSEFOBEBQPS%FVTFOBUVSBM 0NVOEPnVNLwTNPT JTUPn VNBPSEFNGJYBEFMVHBSFTF GVOm{FTRVFDBEBTFS NJOFSBJT WFHFUBJT BOJNBJTFIVNBOPT PDVQBOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFFOPTRVBJTSFBMJ[BTVBOBUVSF[BQSw QSJB0TTFSFTEPLwTNPTFTUkPEJTUSJCVrEPTFNHSBVT FPHSBV JOGFSJPSEFWFPCFEJpODJBBPTVQFSJPS TVCNFUFOEPTFBFMF /PUPQPEBIJFSBSRVJBFODPOUSBNTFPQBQBFPJNQFSBEPS0 QSJNFJSPQPTTVJPQPEFSFTQJSJUVBMPTFHVOEP PUFNQPSBM&N EFDPSSpODJBEBEFTBQBSJmkPQPMrUJDBEPTDFOUSPTVSCBOPTFFN EFDPSSpODJBEPJTPMBNFOUPQSPWPDBEPQFMBSVSBMJ[BmkPEBWJEB FDPOyNJDPTPDJBMFTVBGSBHNFOUBmkP DBEBSFHJkPQPTTVJVN DPOKVOUPEFTFOIPSFTRVFFTDPMIFVNDIFGFFOUSFTFVTQBSFT HBSBOUJOEPMIF±FhTVBEJOBTUJB±BQFSNBOpODJBJOEFGJOJEB OPQPEFS'PSNBNTFSFJOPTQPSUPEPPUFSSJUwSJPEB&VSPQB NFEJFWBM"BTTFNCMFJBEPTSFJTTVCPSEJOBTFBP(SBOEF3FJ PV*NQFSBEPSEB&VSPQB TFOIPSEP4BDSP*NQnSJP3PNBOP (FSNiOJDP GPSNBEPQPSUPEPTPTSFJOPTDSJTUkPTEB&VSPQB
RVFQPTTVJPQPEFSUFPDSgUJDP JTUPn FMFnFTDPMIJEPQPS%FVT FOkPQFMPTPVUSPTSFJT FTUFT TJN GPSBNFTDPMIJEPTQPSTFVT QBSFT PTCBS{FT "KVTUJmB GJOBMJEBEFEBDPNVOJEBEFDSJT Uk nBIJFSBSRVJBEFTVCNJTTkPFPCFEJpODJBEPJOGFSJPSBP TVQFSJPS QPJTnFTTBBPSEFNOBUVSBMDSJBEBQFMBMFJEJWJOB" WJEBUFNQPSBMnJOGFSJPShWJEBFTQJSJUVBMFQPSJTTPBGJOBMJEB EFNBJPSEPHPWFSOBOUFnBTBMWBmkPEBBMNBJNPSUBMEFTFVT T|EJUPT QFMBRVBMSFTQPOEFSgQFSBOUF%FVT 0RVFGPJB²RVFSFMBEBTJOWFTUJEVSBT³ "²RVFSFMBEBTJOWFTUJEVSBT³DPOTJTUJVOBTFHVJOUFRVFT UkP1BESFTFCJTQPTTkPBENJOJTUSBEPSFTEB*HSFKBOPJOUFSJPS EPTSFJOPTFEPDPOKVOUPGPSNBEPQPSFMFT P4BDSP*NQnSJP3P NBOP(FSNiOJDP4FTkPBENJOJTUSBEPSFT EFWFNTFSJOWFTUJ EPTFNTFVTDBSHPTQFMPTSFJTFQFMPJNQFSBEPS*TTPTJHOJGJDB QPSnN RVFSFJTFJNQFSBEPSQBTTBNBJOUFSWJSOBBVUPSJEBEFEB *HSFKBFEPQBQB PRVF QBSBBNCPT nJOBDFJUgWFM0TKVSJTUBT FDMFTJgTUJDPTFMBCPSBNVNBMFHJTMBmkP PEJSFJUPDBOyOJDP QB SBHBSBOUJSPQPEFSEPQBQBOBJOWFTUJEVSBEFQBESFTFCJTQPT &TTBFMBCPSBmkP HSBEVBMNFOUF MFWBhUFPSJBEPQPEFSQBQBMDP NPBVUPSJEBEFTVQSFNBhRVBMPJNQFSBEPSEFWFTVCNFUFSTF "TUFPSJBTUFPMwHJDPQPMrUJDBTGPSBNFMBCPSBEBTQBSBSFTPMWFS EPJTDPOGMJUPTRVFBUSBWFTTBNUPEBB*EBEF.nEJBPDPOGMJUP FOUSFPQBQBFPJNQFSBEPS EFVNMBEP FFOUSFPJNQFSBEPSF BTBTTFNCMFJBTEPTCBS{FT EFPVUSP $PNPB²RVFSFMBEBTJOWFTUJEVSBT³GPJTPMVDJPOBEB "QSJNFJSBTPMVmkPFODPOUSBEB BQwTBRVFSFMBEBTJOWFTUJ EVSBT GPJUSB[JEBQFMPTKVSJTUBTEF$BSMPT.BHOP DPNBUFPSJB EBEVQMBJOWFTUJEVSBPJNQFSBEPSnJOWFTUJEPOPQPEFSUFNQP SBMQFMPQBQB RVFPVOHFFPDPSPBPQBQBSFDFCFEPJNQFSB EPSBJOWFTUJEVSBEBFTQBEB JTUPn PJNQFSBEPSKVSBEFGFOEFS FQSPUFHFSB*HSFKB TPCBDPOEJmkPEFRVFFTUBOVODBJOUFSGJSB OPTBTTVOUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFNJMJUBSFTEPJNQnSJP"TTJN P JNQFSBEPSEFQFOEFEPQBQBQBSBSFDFCFSPQPEFSQPMrUJDP NBT PQBQBEFQFOEFEPJNQFSBEPSQBSBNBOUFSPQPEFSFDMFTJgTUJ DP0DPOGMJUPFOUSFPJNQFSBEPSFBTBTTFNCMFJBTEPTCBS{FTF
5-
SFJTEJ[SFTQFJUPhFTDPMIBEPJNQFSBEPS&TTFDPOGMJUPSFWFMBP QSPCMFNBEFVNBQPMrUJDBGVOEBEBFNEVBTGPOUFTBOUBHyOJDBT %FGBUP CBS{FTFSFJTJOWPDBNBDIBNBEB-FJ3nHJB3PNBOB TF HVOEPBRVBMPHPWFSOBOUFSFDFCFEPQPWPPQPEFS TFOEP QPS UBOUP PDVQBOUFFMFJUPEPQPEFS#BS{FTFSFJTBGJSNBNRVF EB NFTNBNBOFJSB FMFHFNPJNQFSBEPSFRVFTkPPTJOTUJUVJEPSFT EPJNQFSBEPS0SB DPNPFTTBNFTNBMFJSPNBOBBGJSNBRVFTw QPEFUJSBSBMHVNBDPJTBEFBMHVnNBRVFMFRVFUFNPQPEFSEF EgMBQPSRVFBQPTTVJ DPODMVJTFRVF TFSFJTFCBS{FTFMFHFN PJNQFSBEPS UpNPQPEFSQBSBEBSMIFQPEFSFUBNCnNPQPEFS QBSBEFQyMP0JNQFSBEPS QPSnN JOWPDBB#rCMJB ²UPEPQPEFS WFNEP"MUP³ FBPSJHFNUFPDSgUJDBEPQPEFS BGJSNBOEPRVF TFVQPEFSOkPWFNEPTCBS{FTFSFJT NBTEF%FVT"TPMVmkP TFSgUSB[JEBQFMBUFPSJBRVFEJTUJOHVFFOUSFFMFJmkPFVOmkP0 JNQFSBEPS EFGBUP nFMFJUPQFMPTQBSFTQBSBPDBSHP NBTTw UFSgPQPEFSBUSBWnTEBVOmkPDPNwMFPTTBOUPT±BGJSNBTF RVFnVOHJEPDPNPNFTNPwMFPRVFVOHJV%BWJF4BMPNkP±F RVFNVOHFPJNQFSBEPSnB*HSFKB JTUPn PQBQB &NRVFTFCBTFBWBPFTGPSmPQBSBTFQBSBSB*HSFKBEPQPEFS UFNQPSBMEBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDB OPGJOBMEB*EBEF.n EJB 2VFUFwMPHPTFTUBWBNFOWPMWJEPTOFTTBRVFTUkPF RVFJEFJBTEFGFOEJBN $POTJEFSBTFRVFB*HSFKBGPJJOTUJUVrEBFGVOEBEBEJSFUBNFO UFQPS%FVTDPNBEPBmkPEBT$IBWFTEP3FJOPBPTBQwTUPMPT NBTBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDBGPJJOTUJUVrEBPVGVOEBEBQFMBOBUVSF [B RVFGF[PIPNFNVNTFSSBDJPOBMFVNBOJNBMQPMrUJDP4FN E|WJEB BCPBDJEBEFnB$JEBEFEPT)PNFOTDSJTUk FNIBSNPOJB DPNB$JEBEFEF%FVT NBTBTJOTUJUVJm{FTQPMrUJDBTEFWFNTFS DPOTJEFSBEBTIVNBOBT DSJBEBTFNDPODPSEiODJBDPNBPSEFNF BMFJOBUVSBJT EFSJWBEBTEBMFJEJWJOBFUFSOB6NEPTUFwSJDPTNBJT JNQPSUBOUFTEBOBUVSBMJEBEFEBQPMrUJDBnPUFwMPHP5PNgTEF "RVJOP QBSBRVFN TFOEPPIPNFNVNBOJNBMTPDJBM BTPDJBCJ MJEBEFOBUVSBMKgFYJTUJBOP1BSBrTP BOUFTEBRVFEBFEBFYQVMTkP EPTTFSFTIVNBOPT"QwTPQFDBEPPSJHJOBM PTTFSFTIVNBOPT OkPQFSEFSBNTVBOBUVSF[BTPDJgWFMF QPSJTTP OBUVSBMNFOUF PSHBOJ[BSBNTFFNDPNVOJEBEFT EFSBNTFMFJTFJOTUJUVrSBNBT SFMBm{FTEFNBOEPFPCFEJpODJB DSJBOEPPQPEFSQPMrUJDP%JGF SFOUFNFOUFEF4BOUP"HPTUJOIP QBSBRVFNPQFDBEPUPSOBSBP IPNFNQFSWFSTPFWJPMFOUP JOKVTUPFGVOEBEPSEB$JEBEFEPT)P NFOT JOKVTUBDPNPFMF QBSB5PNgTEF"RVJOPPTIVNBOPTQFS EFSBNBJOPDpODJBPSJHJOBM NBTOkPQFSEFSBNBOBUVSF[BPSJHJOBM RVFMIFTGPSBEBEBQPS%FVT1PSFTTFNPUJWP OFMFTQFSNBOFDFV PTFOTPEBKVTUJmB FOUFOEJEBDPNPPEFWFSEFEBSBDBEBVNP RVFMIFnEFWJEP FDPNFMBGVOEBSBNBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDB 2VFTkPPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMPCKFUJWPFPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMTVCKF UJWP 1BSBRVFTFSWFN 0EJSFJUPOBUVSBMPCKFUJWPnBPSEFNOBUVSBMIJFSgSRVJDBVOJ WFSTBMJOTUJUVrEBQPS%FVTPVQFMBMFJEJWJOBPEJSFJUPOBUVSBM TVCKFUJWPnBRVFMFQPTTVrEPQFMPJOEJWrEVPFORVBOUPTFSSB DJPOBMFMJWSF&TTFTEPJTEJSFJUPTTFSWFNEFDSJUnSJPFEFQBESkP QBSBEFUFSNJOBSBMFHJUJNJEBEFFKVTUJmBEFVNQPEFSFEFVNB DPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDB CFNDPNPTVBJMFHJUJNJEBEFFJOKVTUJmB RVBOEPOkPPTTFHVFN 2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEPQFOTBNFOUPEF5PNgTEF"RVJ OPF(VJMIFSNFEF0DLIBNQBSBBUFPSJBQPMrUJDB $PN5PNgTEF"RVJOPF(VJMIFSNFEF0DLIBN OPWBTJEFJBT TkPUSB[JEBThUFPSJBQPMrUJDB BJOEBRVFDPOUJOVFUFPMwHJDB JT UPn SFGFSJEBhWPOUBEFTVQSFNBEF%FVT%JBOUFEBUSBEJmkP UFPDSgUJDBNFEJFWBM TkPOPWBTBTJEFJBTEFDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJ DBOBUVSBM MFJIVNBOBQPMrUJDBFEJSFJUPOBUVSBMEPTJOEJWrEVPT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
DPNPTVKFJUPTEPUBEPTEFDPOTDJpODJBFEFWPOUBEF0TEPJT UFwMPHPTNBOUpNBJEFJBEF#PN(PWFSOPEPQSrODJQFDSJTUkP WJSUVPTPFBEFRVFBNPOBSRVJBnBGPSNBOBUVSBMFNFMIPSEF HPWFSOP BNBJTBEFRVBEBhSFBMJ[BmkPEBKVTUJmBDPNPCFNDP NVN$POTFSWBNUBNCnNBJEFJBEFIJFSBSRVJBOBUVSBMDSJBEB QFMBMFJEJWJOBFUFSOBFDPODSFUJ[BEBQFMBMFJOBUVSBM'JOBMNFO UF JOUSPEV[FNPQSJNFJSPFTCPmPEPRVFWJSJBBTFSDPOIFDJEP DPNB3FGPSNB1SPUFTUBOUF DPNPPEJSFJUPEFSFTJTUpODJBEPT T|EJUPTEPUJSBOP 0RVFFSBPEJSFJUPEFSFTJTUpODJBEPTT|EJUPTEPUJSBOP 4FHVOEPFTTFEJSFJUP PTHPWFSOBEPTOkPQPEFNEFQPS OFNNBUBSPUJSBOP NBTQPEFNSFTJTUJSBFMF CVTDBOEPJOTUSV NFOUPTMFHBJTRVFDPOUFTUFNTVBBVUPSJEBEF GPSmBOEPPBBC EJDBSEPQPEFS6NEPTJOTUSVNFOUPTMFHBJTNBJTJNQPSUBOUFT QBSBJTTPnBJEFJBEFEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPOBUVSBMRVBOEPFTUFn WJPMBEPQFMPHPWFSOBOUF PHPWFSOPTFUPSOBJMFHrUJNP PQBDUP EFTVCNJTTkPQFSEFBWBMJEBEFFPHPWFSOBOUFEFWFBCEJDBS EPQPEFS
#APqTULOß߯ßß=obehkokbe]olkhpe_]o$.%
EP'BMBTF BHPSB OBMJCFSEBEFSFQVCMJDBOBFOBWJEBQPMrUJDB DPNPBTGPSNBTNBJTBMUBTEBEJHOJEBEFIVNBOB $PNQBSFBTUFPSJBTNFEJFWBJTFBTUFPSJBTSFOBTDFOUJTUBTOP UPDBOUFhQPMrUJDBFhSFMJHJkP &NCPSBEJGFSFOUFTF NVJUBTWF[FT DPOUSgSJBT BTPCSBTQP MrUJDBTNFEJFWBJTFSFOBTDFOUJTUBTPQFSBNOVNNVOEPDSJTUkP *TTPTJHOJGJDBRVF QBSBUPEBTFMBT BSFMBmkPFOUSFQPMrUJDBF SFMJHJkPnVNEBEPEFRVFOkPQPEFNFTDBQBS"TUFPSJBTNF EJFWBJTTkPPVEJSFUBNFOUFUFPDSgUJDBT PQPEFSQFSUFODFBQF OBTB%FVT RVFPDPODFEFBBMHVnNQPSVNGBWPSFTQFDJBM PV JOEJSFUBNFOUFUFPDSgUJDBT BPSJHFNEPQPEFSFTUgOBOBUVSF[B TPDJBMEPIPNFN NBTPGVOEBNFOUP|MUJNPEPQPEFSQPMrUJDP FODPOUSBTFOBMFJEJWJOBSFWFMBEB
FORVBOUPBTSFOBTDFOUJTUBT QSPDVSBNFWJUBSBJEFJBEFRVFPQPEFSTFSJBVNBHSBmBPVVN GBWPSEJWJOPFRVFTFFODPOUSBEFUFSNJOBEPEJSFUBNFOUFQFMB MFJEJWJOB/PFOUBOUP FNCPSBSFDVTFNBUFPDSBDJB OkPQPEFN SFDVTBSVNBPVUSBJEFJBDSJTUk BEFRVFPQPEFSQPMrUJDPTwn MFHrUJNPTFGPSKVTUPFTwTFSgKVTUPTFFTUJWFSEFBDPSEPDPN BWPOUBEFEF%FVTFB1SPWJEpODJBEJWJOB"TTJN FMFNFOUPT EFUFPMPHJBDPOUJOVBNQSFTFOUFTOBTGPSNVMBm{FTUFwSJDBTEB QPMrUJDB
$JUFBMHVOTGBUPTRVFQSPQJDJBSBNPTVSHJNFOUPEPJEFBM SFQVCMJDBOPDPOUSBPQPEFSQPMrUJDPUFPMwHJDPEPTQBQBTF JNQFSBEPSFT OPGJOBMEB*EBEF.nEJB
&NCPSBEJWFSHFOUFT BTUFPSJBTNFEJFWBJTFBTUFPSJBTSF OBTDFOUJTUBTUJOIBNUBNCnNQPOUPTFNDPNVN$JUFEPJT EFMFTFDPNFOUFPT
%FTEFPJOrDJPEPTnDVMP97 FNDFSUBTSFHJ{FTEB&VSPQB BTBOUJHBTDJEBEFTEP*NQnSJP3PNBOPFBTOPWBTDJEBEFTTVS HJEBTEPTCVSHPTNFEJFWBJTFOUSBNFNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDP OyNJDPFTPDJBM(SBOEFTSPUBTDPNFSDJBJTUPSOBNQPEFSPTBTBT DPSQPSBm{FTFBTGBNrMJBTEFDPNFSDJBOUFT FORVBOUPPQPEFSJP BHSgSJPEPTCBS{FTDPNFmBBEJNJOVJS"TDJEBEFTFTUkPJOJDJBO EPPRVFWJSJBBTFSDPOIFDJEPDPNPDBQJUBMJTNPDPNFSDJBMPV NFSDBOUJM"TMVUBTFDPOyNJDBTEBCVSHVFTJBOBTDFOUFDPOUSBB OPCSF[BGFVEBMQSPTTFHVFNOBGPSNBEFSFJWJOEJDBm{FTQPMrUJ DBTBTDJEBEFTEFTFKBNJOEFQFOEpODJBFNGBDFEFCBS{FT SFJT QBQBTFJNQFSBEPSFT/B*UgMJB BSFEFTDPCFSUBEBTPCSBTEF QFOTBEPSFT BSUJTUBTFUnDOJDPTEBDVMUVSBHSFDPSPNBOB QBS UJDVMBSNFOUFEBTBOUJHBTUFPSJBTQPMrUJDBT TVTDJUBNVNJEFBM QPMrUJDPOPWP
'PJVNQFSrPEPOPRVBMTFFTQFSBWBGB[FSSFOBTDFSPQFOTB NFOUP BTBSUFT BnUJDB BTUnDOJDBTFBQPMrUJDBRVFIBWJBNTJEP EFTFOWPMWJEBTBOUFTRVFPTBCFSUJWFTTFTJEPDPOTJEFSBEPQSJWJ MnHJPEB*HSFKBFPTUFwMPHPTIPVWFTTFNBERVJSJEPBVUPSJEBEF QBSBEFDJEJSPRVFQPEFSJBFPRVFOkPQPEFSJBTFSQFOTBEP EJUP FGFJUP'JMwTPGPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT QPFUBT ESBNBUVSHPT SFUwSJ DPT NBUFNgUJDPT BTUSyOPNPT NnEJDPT CJwMPHPT BSRVJUFUPT QJOUPSFT N|TJDPT UPEPTPTBVUPSFTBOUJHPTDPNFmBNBUFSTVBT PCSBTSFEFTDPCFSUBTFJOUFSQSFUBEBT TFVTUFYUPTQBTTBNBTFS USBEV[JEPT MJEPT DPNFOUBEPTFBQMJDBEPT
&ODPOUSBNQBSBBQPMrUJDBVNGVOEBNFOUPBOUFSJPSFFY UFSJPShQSwQSJBQPMrUJDB PVTFKBQBSBBMHVOT PGVOEBNFOUPEB QPMrUJDBFODPOUSBTFFN%FVT TFKBOBWPOUBEFEJWJOB RVFEPB PQPEFSBPTIPNFOT TFKBOB1SPWJEpODJBEJWJOB RVFGBWPSFDFP QPEFSEFBMHVOTIPNFOT QBSBPVUSPT FODPOUSBTFOBOBUVSF [B JTUPn OBPSEFNOBUVSBM DSJBEBQPS%FVTFNDPOGPSNJEBEF DPNPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMPCKFUJWP TFHVOEPBRVBMPIPNFNnVN TFSOBUVSBMNFOUFQPMrUJDPF QBSBPVUSPTBJOEB FODPOUSBTF OBSB[kP JTUPn OBJEFJBEFRVFFYJTUFVNBSBDJPOBMJEBEFRVF HPWFSOBPNVOEPFPTIPNFOT UPSOBPTSBDJPOBJTFPTGB[JOT UJUVJSBWJEBQPMrUJDB)g QPJT BMHP±%FVT OBUVSF[BPVSB[kP ±BOUFSJPSFFYUFSJPShQPMrUJDB TFSWJOEPEFGVOEBNFOUPBFMB BGJSNBNRVFBQPMrUJDBnBJOTUJUVJmkPEFVNBDPNVOJEBEFVOB FJOEJWJTB DVKBGJOBMJEBEFnSFBMJ[BSPCFNDPNVNPVKVTUJmB" CPBQPMrUJDBnGFJUBQFMBCPBDPNVOJEBEFIBSNPOJPTB QBDrGJDBF PSEFJSB-VUBT DPOGMJUPTFEJWJT{FTTkPWJTUPTDPNPQFSJHPT GSV UPTEFIPNFOTQFSWFSTPTFTFEJDJPTPTRVFEFWFN BRVBMRVFS QSFmP TFSBGBTUBEPTEBDPNVOJEBEFFEPQPEFS BTTFOUBNB CPBDPNVOJEBEFFBCPBQPMrUJDBOBGJHVSBEP#PN(PWFSOP JTUP n OPQSrODJQFWJSUVPTPFSBDJPOBM QPSUBEPSEBKVTUJmB EBIBS NPOJBFEBJOEJWJTkPEBDPNVOJEBEF DMBTTJGJDBNPTSFHJNFT QPMrUJDPTFNKVTUPTMFHrUJNPTFJOKVTUPTJMFHrUJNPT DPMPDBOEP BNPOBSRVJBFBBSJTUPDSBDJBIFSFEJUgSJBTFOUSFPTQSJNFJSPTF JEFOUJGJDBOEPDPNPTTFHVOEPTPQPEFSPCUJEPQPSDPORVJTUBF VTVSQBmkP EFOPNJOBOEPPUJSiOJDP&TUFnDPOTJEFSBEPBOUJOB UVSBM JSSBDJPOBM DPOUSgSJPhWPOUBEFEF%FVTFhKVTUJmB PCSBEF VNHPWFSOBOUFWJDJPTPFQFSWFSTP
2VFSFMBmkPIBWJBFOUSFBTJEFJBTTVSHJEBTOP3FOBTDJNFOUP FOB"OUJHVJEBEFHSFDPSPNBOB
&NRVFTJUVBm{FTPVWJNPTBTFYQSFTT{FTNBRVJBWnMJDPF NBRVJBWFMJTNP
/P3FOBTDJNFOUP &TQBSUB "UFOBTF3PNBTkPUPNBEBT DPNPFYFNQMPTEBMJCFSEBEFSFQVCMJDBOB*NJUgMBTnWPMUBSB WBMPSJ[BSBQPMrUJDBDPNPFYQSFTTkPNBJTBMUBEBDBQBDJEBEF IVNBOBFFSHVFSBWJUBBDUJWBDPOUSBPJEFBMEBWJUBDPOUFN QMBUJWB WBMPSJ[BEPQFMB*HSFKB JTUPn BWJEBFTQJSJUVBMEPTgCJP DPOUFNQMBUJWPFTPMJUgSJP RVFTFQSFPDVQBWBDPNBWJEBGVUVSB OPPVUSPNVOEPTFNTFPDVQBSDPNBWJEBQSFTFOUFOFTUFNVO
"TFYQSFTT{FTNBRVJBWnMJDPFNBRVJBWFMJTNPTkPVTBEBT RVBOEPBMHVnNEFTFKBSFGFSJSTFTFKBhQPMrUJDBFBPTQPMrUJDPT TFKBBDFSUBTBUJUVEFTEBTQFTTPBT NFTNPRVFOkPMJHBEBTEJ SFUBNFOUFBVNBBmkPQPMrUJDB GBMBTF QPSFYFNQMP OVNDP NFSDJBOUFNBRVJBWnMJDP OVNBQSPGFTTPSBNBRVJBWnMJDB OP NBRVJBWFMJTNPEFDFSUPTKPSOBJT FUD 4FNQSFRVFQSFUFOEF NPTKVMHBSBBmkPPVBDPOEVUBEFBMHVnNEFTMFBM IJQwDSJUB
2VFGPJP3FOBTDJNFOUP
5.
Manual do Professor
GJOHJEPS QPEFSPTBNFOUFNBMnWPMP RVFCSJODBDPNPTTFOUJ NFOUPTFEFTFKPTEPTPVUSPT NFOUFMIFT GB[BFMFTQSPNFTTBT RVFTBCFRVFOkPDVNQSJSg VTBBCPBGnBMIFJBFNTFVQSwQSJP QSPWFJUP'BMBNPTOVN²QPEFSNBRVJBWnMJDP³QBSBOPTSFGFSJS NPTBVNQPEFSRVFBHFTFDSFUBNFOUFOPTCBTUJEPSFT NBO UFOEPTVBTJOUFOm{FTFGJOBMJEBEFTEFTDPOIFDJEBTQBSBPTDJ EBEkPTRVFBGJSNBRVFPTGJOTKVTUJGJDBNPTNFJPTFVTBNFJPT JNPSBJT WJPMFOUPTFQFSWFSTPTQBSBDPOTFHVJSPRVFRVFSRVF EgBTSFHSBTEPKPHPNBTGJDBhTFTDPOEJEBT FTQFSBOEPRVFPT KPHBEPSFTDBVTFNBTJNFTNPTTVBQSwQSJBSVrOBFEFTUSVJmkP .BRVJBWnMJDPFNBRVJBWFMJTNPGB[FNQFOTBSFNBMHVnNFYUSF NBNFOUFQPEFSPTPFQFSWFSTP TFEVUPSFFOHBOBEPS RVFTBCF MFWBSBTQFTTPBTBGB[FSFNFYBUBNFOUFPRVFFMFEFTFKB NFT NPRVFTFKBNBOJRVJMBEBTQPSJTTP$PNPTFOPUB NBRVJBWnMJDP FNBRVJBWFMJTNPDPSSFTQPOEFNhRVJMPRVF FNOPTTBDVMUVSB nDPOTJEFSBEPEJBCwMJDP 2VFNGPJ/JDPMBV.BRVJBWFM .BRVJBWFMGPJEJQMPNBUBFDPOTFMIFJSPEPTHPWFSOBOUFT EF'MPSFOmB7JVBTMVUBTFVSPQFJBTEFDFOUSBMJ[BmkPNPOgSRVJ DB PSFTTVSHJNFOUPEBWJEBVSCBOBFVSPQFJB BBTDFOTkPEB CVSHVFTJBDPNFSDJBMEBTHSBOEFTDJEBEFTF TPCSFUVEP WJVB GSBHNFOUBmkPEB*UgMJB EJWJEJEBFNSFJOPT EVDBEPT SFQ|CMJ DBTF*HSFKB"DPNQSFFOTkPEFTTBTFYQFSJpODJBTIJTUwSJDBTFB JOUFSQSFUBmkPEPTFOUJEPEFMBTPDPOEV[JSBNhJEFJBEFRVFBT DPODFQm{FTQPMrUJDBTBOUJHBTFNFEJFWBJTOkPFSBNDBQB[FTEF DPNQSFFOEFSWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFPRVFnPQPEFSFRVFVNOPWP DPODFJUPEBTPDJFEBEFFEBQPMrUJDBUPSOBSBTFOFDFTTgSJP TP CSFUVEPQBSBB*UgMJBFQBSB'MPSFOmB&N FTDSFWFBPCSB JOBVHVSBMEBGJMPTPGJBQPMrUJDBNPEFSOB 0QSrODJQF &NRVF/JDPMBV.BRVJBWFMGPJEJGFSFOUFEPTUFwMPHPTNFEJF WBJTFEFTFVTDPOUFNQPSiOFPTSFOBTDFOUJTUBTQBSBGVOEB NFOUBSTFVQFOTBNFOUP %JGFSFOUFNFOUFEPTUFwMPHPT RVFQBSUJBNEB#rCMJBFEP %JSFJUP3PNBOPQBSBGPSNVMBSUFPSJBTQPMrUJDBT F EJGFSFOUF NFOUFEPTDPOUFNQPSiOFPTSFOBTDFOUJTUBT RVFQBSUJBNEBT PCSBTEPTGJMwTPGPTHSFDPSPNBOPTQBSBDPOTUSVJSTVBTUFPSJBT QPMrUJDBT .BRVJBWFMQBSUFEBFYQFSJpODJBSFBMEFTFVUFNQP 2VBMBJNQPSUiODJBEF0QSrODJQF &TTBPCSBGVOEBPQFOTBNFOUPQPMrUJDP &NRVFDPOTJTUFBSVQUVSBEBPCSBNBRVJBWFMJBOBFNSFMB mkPhUSBEJmkPQPMrUJDB $POTJTUFFNPGFSFDFSSFTQPTUBTOPWBTBVNBTJUVBmkPIJT UwSJDBOPWB RVFTFVTDPOUFNQPSiOFPTUFOUBWBNDPNQSFFOEFS MFOEPPTBVUPSFTBOUJHPT EFJYBOEPEFMBEPBPCTFSWBmkPEJSFUB EPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTRVFPDPSSJBNEJBOUFEFTFVTPMIPT 4FHVOEP0QSrODJQF UPEBDJEBEFFTUgEJWJEJEBFNEPJTEF TFKPTPQPTUPT2VFEFTFKPTTkPFTTFT &YQMJRVFPT 4kPPEFTFKPEPTHSBOEFTEFPQSJNJSFDPNBOEBSFPEFTF KPEPQPWPEFOkPTFSPQSJNJEPOFNDPNBOEBEP&TTBEJWJTkP FWJEFODJBRVFBDJEBEFOkPnVNBDPNVOJEBEFIPNPHpOFBOBT DJEBEBWPOUBEFEJWJOB EBPSEFNOBUVSBMPVEBSB[kPIVNBOB NBTnUFDJEBQPSMVUBTJOUFSOBTRVFBPCSJHBNBJOTUJUVJSVN QPMPTVQFSJPSRVFQPTTBVOJGJDgMBFEBSMIFJEFOUJEBEF&TTF QPMPnPQPEFSQPMrUJDP"TTJN BQPMrUJDBOBTDFEBTMVUBTTPDJBJT FnPCSBEBQSwQSJBTPDJFEBEFQBSBEBSBTJNFTNBVOJEBEFF JEFOUJEBEF
5/
2VBMn QBSB.BRVJBWFM PQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBQPMrUJDB &YQMJRVF 1BSB.BRVJBWFM PQPOUPEFQBSUJEBEBQPMrUJDBnBEJWJTkP TPDJBMFOUSFPTHSBOEFTFPQPWP"TPDJFEBEFnPSJHJOBSJBNFO UFEJWJEJEBFKBNBJTQPEFTFSWJTUBDPNPVNBDPNVOJEBEFVOB JOEJWJTB IPNPHpOFB WPMUBEBQBSBPCFNDPNVN&TTBJNB HFNEBVOJEBEFFEBJOEJWJTkP EJ[.BRVJBWFM nVNBNgTDBSB DPNRVFPTHSBOEFTSFDPCSFNBSFBMJEBEFTPDJBMQBSBFOHBOBS PQSJNJSFDPNBOEBSPQPWP DPNPTFPTJOUFSFTTFTEPTHSBOEFT FEPTQPQVMBSFTGPTTFNPTNFTNPTFUPEPTGPTTFNJSNkPTF JHVBJTOVNBCFMBDPNVOJEBEF 2VBMn QBSB.BRVJBWFM BGJOBMJEBEFEBQPMrUJDB 1BSB.BRVJBWFM BGJOBMJEBEFEBQPMrUJDBOkPn DPNPEJ[JBN PTQFOTBEPSFTHSFHPT SPNBOPTFDSJTUkPT BKVTUJmBFPCFN DPNVN NBT DPNPTFNQSFTPVCFSBNPTQPMrUJDPT BUPNBEBF BNBOVUFOmkPEPQPEFS 2VBMn QBSB.BRVJBWFM BMwHJDBEBQPMrUJDB 1BSBFMF BQPMrUJDBOkPnBMwHJDBSBDJPOBMEBKVTUJmBFEBnUJDB NBTBMwHJDBEBGPSmBUSBOTGPSNBEBFNMwHJDBEPQPEFSFEBMFJ 0RVFQFOTBWB.BRVJBWFMBSFTQFJUPEBJEFJBEP#PN(P WFSOPFODBSOBEBOPQSrODJQFWJSUVPTP &YQMJRVF .BRVJBWFMSFDVTBBGJHVSBEP#PN(PWFSOPFODBSOBEBOP QSrODJQFWJSUVPTP QPSUBEPSEBTWJSUVEFTDSJTUkT EBTWJSUVEFT NPSBJTFEBTWJSUVEFTQSJODJQFTDBT0QSrODJQFQSFDJTBUFSWJSU} NBTFTUBnQSPQSJBNFOUFQPMrUJDB SFGFSJOEPTFhTRVBMJEBEFTEP EJSJHFOUFQBSBUPNBSFNBOUFSPQPEFS NFTNPRVFQBSBJTTPEFWB VTBSBWJPMpODJB BNFOUJSB BBTU|DJBFBGPSmB"USBEJmkPBGJSNBWB RVFPHPWFSOBOUFEFWJBTFSBNBEPFSFTQFJUBEPQFMPTHPWFSOB EPT.BRVJBWFMBGJSNBRVFPQSrODJQFOkPQPEFTFSPEJBEP*TTP TJHOJGJDBRVFEFWFTFSSFTQFJUBEPFUFNJEPFRVFOkPQSFDJTBTFS BNBEP QPJTJTUPPGBSJBVNQBJQBSBBTPDJFEBEFF TBCFNPT VNQBJDPOIFDFBQFOBTVNUJQPEFQPEFS PEFTQwUJDP"WJSUVEF QPMrUJDBEPQSrODJQFBQBSFDFSgOBRVBMJEBEFEBTJOTUJUVJm{FTRVF TPVCFSDSJBSFNBOUFSFOBDBQBDJEBEFRVFUJWFSQBSBFOGSFOUBS BTPDBTJ{FTBEWFSTBT 0RVFQFOTB.BRVJBWFMEBMFHJUJNJEBEFFEBJMFHJUJNJEBEF EFRVFNEFUnNPQPEFS 1BSB.BRVJBWFM MFHJUJNJEBEFFJMFHJUJNJEBEFEFQFOEFNEP NPEPDPNPBTMVUBTTPDJBJTFODPOUSBNSFTQPTUBTQPMrUJDBTDB QB[FTEFHBSBOUJSP|OJDPQSJODrQJPRVFSFHFBQPMrUJDBPQPEFS EPQSrODJQFEFWFTFSTVQFSJPSBPEPTHSBOEFTFFTUBSBTFSWJ mPEPQPWP0QSrODJQFQPEFTFSNPOBSDBIFSFEJUgSJPPVQPS DPORVJTUBQPEFTFSUPEPVNQPWPRVFDPORVJTUB QFMBGPSmB P QPEFSFPFYFSDFEFNPDSBUJDBNFOUF2VBMRVFSEFTTFTSFHJNFT QPMrUJDPTTFSgMFHrUJNPTFGPSVNBSFQ|CMJDBFOkPEFTQPUJTNP PVUJSBOJB JTUPn TwnMFHrUJNPPSFHJNFOPRVBMPQPEFSOkPFT UgBTFSWJmPEPTEFTFKPTFJOUFSFTTFTEFVNQBSUJDVMBSPVEFVN HSVQPEFQBSUJDVMBSFT 2VFJEFJBT.BRVJBWFMEFNPMFDPNTVBPCSB $PNTVBPCSB .BRVJBWFMEFNPMFBTJEFJBTTFHVOEPBT VBJTBUSBEJmkPHSFHBUPSOBSBnUJDBFQPMrUJDBJOTFQBSgWFJTB R USBEJmkPSPNBOBDPMPDBSBFTTBJEFOUJEBEFEBnUJDBFEBQPMrUJDB OBQFTTPBWJSUVPTBEPHPWFSOBOUFBUSBEJmkPDSJTUkUSBOTGPSNB SBBQFTTPBQPMrUJDBOVNDPSQPNrTUJDPTBDSBMJ[BEPRVFFODBS OBWBBWPOUBEFEF%FVTFBDPNVOJEBEFIVNBOBIFSFEJUBSJF EBEF QFSTPOBMJEBEFFWJSUVEFGPSNBWBNPDFOUSPEBQPMrUJDB PSJFOUBEBQFMBJEFJBEFKVTUJmBFCFNDPNVN
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
0RVFFSBBPQPTJmkPWJSUVEFGPSUVOB 2VBOEPFTUVEBNPTBnUJDB WJNPTRVFBRVFTUkPDFOUSBM QPTUBQFMPTGJMwTPGPTTFNQSFGPJ²PRVFFTUgFPRVFOkPFTUg FNOPTTPQPEFS³ FRVF²FTUBSFNOPTTPQPEFS³TJHOJGJDBWBB BmkPWPMVOUgSJBSBDJPOBMMJWSF QSwQSJBEBWJSUVEF F²OkPFTUBS FNOPTTPQPEFS³TJHOJGJDBWBPDPOKVOUPEFDJSDVOTUiODJBTFYUFS OBTRVFBHFNTPCSFOwTFEFUFSNJOBNOPTTBWPOUBEFFOPTTB BmkP7JNPTUBNCnNRVFFTTFDPOKVOUPEFDJSDVOTUiODJBTRVF OkPEFQFOEFNEFOwTOFNEFOPTTBWPOUBEFFSBNUBOUPBTMFJT OFDFTTgSJBTEBOBUVSF[BDPNPPTBDBTPTFBDPOUJOHpODJB PVP RVFGPJDIBNBEPQFMBUSBEJmkPGJMPTwGJDBEFGPSUVOB"PQPTJmkP WJSUVEFGPSUVOBKBNBJTBCBOEPOPVBnUJDBF DPNPFTUBTVSHJB JOTFQBSgWFMEBQPMrUJDB BNFTNBPQPTJmkPTFGF[QSFTFOUFOP QFOTBNFOUPQPMrUJDP/FTUF PHPWFSOBOUFWJSUVPTPFSBBRVFMF DVKBTWJSUVEFTPQSPUFHFNEPQPEFSJPEBDBQSJDIPTBFJODPOT UBOUFGPSUVOB %FRVFNBOFJSB.BRVJBWFMSFUPNBBPQPTJmkPWJSUVEFGPS UVOB 2VFOPWPTTFOUJEPTFMFEgBFTTBPQPTJmkP .BRVJBWFMSFUPNBBPQPTJmkPWJSUVEFGPSUVOB NBTMIFJN QSJNFVNTFOUJEPJOUFJSBNFOUFOPWP"WJSU}EPQSrODJQFOkP DPOTJTUFOVNDPOKVOUPGJYPEFRVBMJEBEFTNPSBJTRVFFMFPQPSg hGPSUVOB MVUBOEPDPOUSBFMB PVTFKB VNQSrODJQFRVFBHJSTFN QSFEBNFTNBNBOFJSBFEFBDPSEPDPNPTNFTNPTQSJODrQJPT FNUPEBTBTDJSDVOTUiODJBTGSBDBTTBSgFOkPUFSgOFOIVNBWJSU} 1BSBTFSTFOIPSEBTPSUFPVEBTDJSDVOTUiODJBTEFWFNVEBSDPN FMBTF DPNPFMBT TFSWPM|WFMFJODPOTUBOUF QPJTTPNFOUFBTTJN TBCFSgBHBSSgMBTFWFODpMBT&NDFSUBTDJSDVOTUiODJBT EFWF SgTFSDSVFM FNPVUSBT HFOFSPTPFNDFSUBTPDBTJ{FTEFWFSg NFOUJS FNPVUSBT TFSIPOSBEPFNDFSUPTNPNFOUPT EFWFSg DFEFShWPOUBEFEPTPVUSPT FNBMHVOT TFSJOGMFYrWFM0FUIPT PVDBSgUFSEPQSrODJQFEFWFWBSJBSDPNBTDJSDVOTUiODJBTQBSB RVFTFNQSFTFKBTFOIPSEFMBT 0RVFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVF²BMwHJDBQPMrUJDBOBEBUFNBWFS DPNBTWJSUVEFTnUJDBTEPTJOEJWrEVPTFNTVBWJEBQSJWB EB³ 2VFDPODFJUPT.BRVJBWFMJOBVHVSBBPQSFDPOJ[BSUBJT JEFJBT 4JHOJGJDBRVFPRVFQPEFSJBTFSNPSBMOBWJEBQSJWBEBQP EFTFSGSBRVF[BOBWJEBQ|CMJDBFWJDFWFSTBPRVFQPEFSJB TFSJNPSBMEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEBnUJDBQSJWBEBQPEFTFSWJSU} QPMrUJDB$PNUBJTGPSNVMBm{FT .BRVJBWFMJOBVHVSBBJEFJBEF WBMPSFTQPMrUJDPTNFEJEPTQFMBFGJDgDJBQSgUJDBFQFMBVUJMJEB EFTPDJBM BGBTUBEPTEPTQBES{FTRVFSFHVMBNBNPSBMJEBEF QSJWBEBEPTJOEJWrEVPT0FUIPTQPMrUJDPFPFUIPTNPSBMTkP EJGFSFOUFTFOkPIgGSBRVF[BQPMrUJDBNBJPSEPRVFPNPSBMJT NPRVFNBTDBSBBMwHJDBSFBMEPQPEFS)gPDBTJ{FTFNRVFB SFQ|CMJDBFYJHFRVFPQSrODJQFTFKBDSVFMPVUSBT FNRVFEF WFTFSNBHOiOJNPFNJTFSJDPSEJPTP"TDJSDVOTUiODJBTQPEFN FYJHJSRVFFMFTFKBBTUVUPFEJTTJNVMBEPS PV QFMPDPOUSgSJP RVFFMFTFKBMFBMFTJODFSP4VBWJSUVEFnNFEJEBQFMPTFGFJUPT CFOnGJDPTEFTVBBmkPQBSBBSFQ|CMJDB &NGBDFEBTSFTQPTUBTBOUFSJPSFTTPCSF.BRVJBWFM QPSRVF FMFGPJWJTUPDPNP²NBRVJBWnMJDP³ OPTFOUJEPRVFIPKFDP NVNFOUFFNQSFTUBNPTBFTTBQBMBWSB 0RVF BGJOBM RVF SFNEJ[FSPTUFSNPTNBRVJBWnMJDPFNBRVJBWFMJTNP 1PSUFSJOBVHVSBEPBUFPSJBNPEFSOBEBMwHJDBEPQPEFSDP NPJOEFQFOEFOUFEBSFMJHJkP EBnUJDBFEBPSEFNOBUVSBM"TQB MBWSBTNBRVJBWnMJDPFNBRVJBWFMJTNP DSJBEBTOPTnDVMP97*F DPOTFSWBEBTBUnIPKF FYQSJNFNPNFEPRVFTFUFNEBQPMrUJDB
RVBOEPFTUBnTJNQMFTNFOUFQPMrUJDB JTUPn TFNBTNgTDBSBT EBSFMJHJkP EBNPSBM EBSB[kPFEBOBUVSF[B &NRVFDPOTJTUJBBJEFJBEFTPCFSBOJB TVNNBQPUFTUBT
USB[JEBQBSBBEJTDVTTkPQPS.BRVJBWFM 2VFQFOTBEPSJSg EFTFOWPMWFSPDPODFJUPEFTPCFSBOJBOBNPEFSOJEBEF /BUSBEJmkP ²TPCFSBOP³EFTJHOBBQFTTPBGrTJDBEPHPWFS OBOUFFTFSFGFSFBPSFJPVBPJNQFSBEPS"CBUBMIBEBEVQMB JOWFTUJEVSBSFGFSJBTFKVTUBNFOUFhRVFTUkPEFTBCFSRVFN FSBBQFTTPBTPCFSBOB PJNQFSBEPSPVPQBQB%BNFTNB NBOFJSB BJOWFOmkPEBUFPSJBEPT²EPJTDPSQPTEPSFJ³QSFUFO EJBBTTFHVSBSRVFPSFJGPTTFTPCFSBOP EJTUJOHVJOEPFOUSFB GSBRVF[B GJOJUVEFFNPSUBMJEBEFEFTVBQFTTPBGrTJDB FGPSmB QFSFOJEBEFFJNPSUBMJEBEFEFTVBQFTTPBQPMrUJDB.BRVJBWFM BCBOEPOPVBEFGJOJmkPEPTSFHJNFTQFMBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFPO| NFSPEFHPWFSOBOUFTFQFMPWBMPSBUSJCVrEPBRVFNHPWFSOB RVFFSBNPTDSJUnSJPTWJOEPTEBGJMPTPGJBQPMrUJDBBSJTUPUnMJDB &NMVHBSEFTTBEJTDVTTkP TVBPCSBWPMUPVTFQBSBBJEFJBEF 1SJODJQBEP RVFQPEFSJBTFSNPOgSRVJDP BSJTUPDSgUJDPPVEF NPDSgUJDP &TTBJEFJBJOEJDBWBRVFFTUBWBFNDVSTPFYBUB NFOUFBRVFTUkPEBTPCFSBOJBFRVFFTUBFSBQPTUBhEJTUiODJB EFEPJTHSBOEFTSJWBJT B*HSFKBPVPQBQB FPT(SBOEFT PV BOPCSF[BFBCVSHVFTJBVSCBOBTDPNTVBTDPSQPSBm{FTEF PGrDJPTFNPOPQwMJPTDPNFSDJBJT"TTJN BPCSBEF.BRVJBWFM DPNFmBBJOEJDBSRVFPTPCFSBOPOkPnVNBQFTTPBFTJNP QPEFSQPMrUJDPJOEFQFOEFOUFEPQPEFSSFMJHJPTPFEPQPEFS FDPOyNJDP0QSJNFJSPQFOTBEPSBGPSNVMBSNPEFSOBNFOUFP DPODFJUPEFTPCFSBOJBGPJPGSBODpT+FBO#PEJO $PNFOUFPTQSJODJQBJTQPOUPTEBUFPSJBEF+FBO#PEJOBP GPSNVMBSBJEFJBEFTPCFSBOJB &NTVBPCSB 0TTFJTMJWSPTEBSFQ|CMJDB QVCMJDBEBFN #PEJOJOUSPEV[BJEFJBEBTPCFSBOJBDPNPQPEFS|OJDP EFMFHJTMBSFDPNBOEBS QFSUFODFOUFOkPBPHPWFSOBOUF RVFn FGpNFSP FTJNBP&TUBEP RVFnQFSNBOFOUFFEVSBEPVSP " TPCFSBOJBnQFSQnUVBPHPWFSOP QBTTBHFJSP0&TUBEPDPNP TPCFSBOPnFOUFOEJEPDPNPVNTJTUFNBBSUJDVMBEPRVFSF|OF VNBPSEFNKVSrEJDB PEJSFJUPFBMFHJTMBmkP FVNBBVUPSJEBEF JOEFQFOEFOUF PDPNBOEPFPVTPEBGPSmB $PNJTTP #PEJO EJTUJOHVFPQPEFSTPCFSBOPEFPVUSPTQPEFSFT SFMJHJPTPT FDP OyNJDPT TPDJBJT RVFTwQPEFNTFSFYFSDJEPTTPCBTPSEFOTF TPCPDPOUSPMFEP&TUBEP 2VFDPOTFRVpODJBTPQFOTBNFOUPEF.BRVJBWFMUFWFTP CSFBUFPSJBQPMrUJDB "PCSBEF.BRVJBWFMUSPVYFDPNPDPOTFRVpODJBTQBSBP QFOTBNFOUPQPMrUJDPBJEFJBEFRVFBGJOBMJEBEFEBQPMrUJDBnB UPNBEBFBDPOTFSWBmkPEPQPEFSFRVFFTUFOkPQSPWnNEF %FVT OFNEBSB[kP OFNEFVNBPSEFNOBUVSBMGFJUBEFIJFSBS RVJBTGJYBT $JUFPTQSJODJQBJTGBUPTTPDJPQPMrUJDPTFFDPOyNJDPTRVF PDPSSJBNOPNVOEPPDJEFOUBMOPTTnDVMPT97F97*2VF FGFJUPTUJWFSBNTPCSFBTTPDJFEBEFTEBnQPDB 0DSFTDJNFOUPEBTDPSQPSBm{FTEFPGrDJPFEPDPNnSDJP BEFDBEpODJBFBSVrOBEFJO|NFSBTGBNrMJBTBSJTUPDSgUJDBT BEFDBEpODJBBHSgSJBBDFMFSBEBQPSVNBHSBOEFQFTUFRVF BTTPMPVB&VSPQBOPGJNEB*EBEF.nEJBPDSFTDJNFOUPEF BUJWJEBEFTBSUFTBOBJTFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPDPNFSDJBMBSUJDV MBmkPEBTHSBOEFTSPUBTEPDPNnSDJPDPNP0SJFOUF EPNJOB EBTQSJNFJSPQFMBTDJEBEFTJUBMJBOBTFEFQPJTQFMPTJNQnSJPT VMUSBNBSJOPTEF1PSUVHBM &TQBOIB *OHMBUFSSBF'SBOmB EBOEP
50
Manual do Professor
PSJHFNBVNOPWPUJQPEFSJRVF[B PDBQJUBM CBTFBEPOPMV DSPBEWJOEPEBFYQMPSBmkPEPUSBCBMIPEPTIPNFOTQPCSFT FMJWSFTRVFIBWJBNNJHSBEPQBSBBTDJEBEFTFOBFYQMPSBmkP EPUSBCBMIPFTDSBWPEFrOEJPTFOFHSPTOBT"NnSJDBT0EF TFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOyNJDPEBTDJEBEFT PTVSHJNFOUPEBCVS HVFTJBDPNFSDJBOUFPVNFSDBOUJM PDSFTDJNFOUPEBDMBTTFEPT USBCBMIBEPSFTQPCSFTNBTMJWSFT B3FGPSNB1SPUFTUBOUF BT SFWPMUBTQPQVMBSFT BTHVFSSBTFOUSFQPUpODJBTQFMPEPNrOJP EPTNBSFTFEPTOPWPTUFSSJUwSJPTEFTDPCFSUPT BRVFEBEFSFJT FEFGBNrMJBTEBOPCSF[B BBTDFOTkPEFGBNrMJBTEFDPNFSDJBO UFTFEFOPWPTSFJTRVFBTGBWPSFDJBNDPOUSBPTOPCSFT UPEPT FTTFTGBUPTFWJEFODJBWBNRVFBJEFJBDSJTUk IFSEBEBEP*NQn SJP3PNBOPFDPOTPMJEBEBQFMB*HSFKB3PNBOB EFVNNVOEP DPOTUJUVrEPOBUVSBMNFOUFQPSIJFSBSRVJBTGJYBTFSBVNBJEFJB RVFOkPDPSSFTQPOEJBhSFBMJEBEF 2VFOPWPTGBUPTPDPOUFYUPTPDJPQPMrUJDPFFDPOyNJDPEPT TnDVMPT97F97*TVTDJUPV "FYJTUpODJBEFJOEJWrEVPT±VNCVSHVpTFVNUSBCBMIB EPSOkPQPEJBNJOWPDBSTBOHVF GBNrMJB MJOIBHFNFEJOBTUJB QBSBFYQMJDBSQPSRVFFYJTUJBNFQPSRVFIBWJBNNVEBEPEF QPTJmkPTPDJBM NBTTwQPEJBNJOWPDBSBTJNFTNPTDPNPJOEJ WrEVPTDVKBBmkPQSPEV[JSBBNVEBOmBEFTVBTJUVBmkPFEFTVB QPTJmkPFDPOyNJDPTPDJBM&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT PTVSHJNFOUP EFEVBTOPWBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT BCVSHVFTJBFPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT MJWSFT FWJEFODJBWBRVFQFSEFSBTFOUJEPBJEFJBEFRVFDBEBVN TFEFGJOFQFMBGBNrMJBFQFMPHSVQPBRVFQFSUFODFFQFMPMVHBS OBUVSBMEFTTBGBNrMJBPVEFTTFHSVQPOBPSEFNIJFSgSRVJDBF GJYBEP6OJWFSTP "FYJTUpODJBEFDPOGMJUPTFOUSFJOEJWrEVPTF HSVQPTEFJOEJWrEVPTQFMBQPTTFEFSJRVF[BT DBSHPT QPTUPTF QPEFSFTBOVMBWBUBOUPBQSgUJDBNFEJFWBMEBTVCNJTTkPOBUV SBMEPJOGFSJPSBPTVQFSJPS JTUPn BQSgUJDBEBWBTTBMBHFN RVF TVTUFOUBSBPFEJGrDJPTPDJBMFQPMrUJDPEB*EBEF.nEJB DPNPB JNBHFNEBDPNVOJEBEFQPMrUJDBVOB JOEJWJTBFGSBUFSOB UBMDP NPIBWJBTJEPDPODFCJEBQFMBUSBEJmkPDSJTUk 2VFFSBPFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[BPVDPOEJmkPOBUVSBM %VBTGPSBNBTQSJODJQBJTDPODFQm{FTEPFTUBEPEFOBUVSF [BBDPODFQmkPEF5IPNBT)PCCFT OPTnDVMP97**
TFHVOEP BRVBM FNFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[B PTJOEJWrEVPTWJWFNJTPMBEPTF FNMVUBQFSNBOFOUF WJHPSBOEPBHVFSSBEFUPEPTDPOUSBUPEPT PV²PIPNFNMPCPEPIPNFN³BDPODFQmkPEF+FBO+BDRVFT 3PVTTFBV OPTnDVMP97***
TFHVOEPBRVBM FNFTUBEPEFOB UVSF[B PTJOEJWrEVPTWJWFNJTPMBEPTQFMBTGMPSFTUBT TPCSFWJ WFOEPDPNPRVFBOBUVSF[BMIFTEg EFTDPOIFDFOEPMVUBTFDP NVOJDBOEPTFQPSHFTUP HSJUPFDBOUP OVNBMrOHVBHFOFSPTB FCFOFWPMFOUF0FTUBEPEFOBUVSF[BEF)PCCFTFPFTUBEPEF TPDJFEBEFEF3PVTTFBVFWJEFODJBNVNBQFSDFQmkPEPTPDJBM DPNPMVUBFOUSFGSBDPTFGPSUFT WJHPSBOEPPQPEFSEBGPSmBPV BWPOUBEFEPNBJTGPSUF $PNPTFEFVBQBTTBHFNEPFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[BQBSBP FTUBEPDJWJMPVTPDJFEBEFDJWJM "QBTTBHFNEPFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[BBPFTUBEPDJWJMPVh TPDJFEBEFDJWJMTFEgQPSNFJPEFVNQBDUPTPDJBMPVDPOUSBUP TPDJBM QFMPRVBMPTJOEJWrEVPTDPODPSEBNFNSFOVODJBShMJCFS EBEFOBUVSBM PVPQPEFSQBSBGB[FSUVEPRVFTFRVFS EFTEF RVFOFOIVNPCTUgDVMPJNQFmBBBmkP FhQPTTFOBUVSBMEF CFOTFBSNBTFFNUSBOTGFSJSBVNUFSDFJSP±PTPCFSBOP±P QPEFSQBSBDSJBSFBQMJDBSBTMFJT EFUFSNJOBOEPPMFHBMFPJMF HBM PKVTUPFPJOKVTUP PQFSNJUJEPFPQSPJCJEP
VTBSBGPSmB FODBSSFHBOEPTF FNOPNFEFUPEPT EFWJOHBSPTDSJNFT
EFDMBSBSBHVFSSBFBQB[0DPOUSBUPTPDJBMGVOEBBTPCFSBOJB
51
FJOTUJUVJBBVUPSJEBEFQPMrUJDB JTUPn BQwMJTPVBDJWJUBTcJOT UJUVrEP QPSUBOUP PFTUBEPDJWJM RVFEFWFQySVNGJNhTMVUBT NPSUBJTEPFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[B IPCCFTJBOP PVEPFTUBEPEF TPDJFEBEF SPVTTFBVrTUB 2VFFSBPKVTOBUVSBMJTNPPVEJSFJUPOBUVSBM &SBPEJSFJUPTFHVOEPPRVBM QPSOBUVSF[B UPEPJOEJWrEVP UFNEJSFJUPhWJEB BPRVFnOFDFTTgSJPhTPCSFWJWpODJBEFTFV DPSQPFhMJCFSEBEF1PSOBUVSF[B UPEPTTkPMJWSFT BJOEBRVF QPSOBUVSF[B VOTTFKBNNBJTGPSUFTFPVUSPTNBJTGSBDPT 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEFTPDJFEBEFDJWJM BPUFNQPEF)PCCFT F3PVTTFBV "TPDJFEBEFDJWJMnP&TUBEPQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUP5SBUBTFEB TPDJFEBEFWJWFOEPTPCPEJSFJUPDJWJM JTUPn TPCPEJSFJUPQPTJUJWP OBGPSNBEBTMFJTQSPNVMHBEBTFBQMJDBEBTQFMPTPCFSBOP'FJUP PQBDUPPVPDPOUSBUP PTDPOUSBUBOUFTUSBOTGFSJSBNPEJSFJUPOB UVSBMBPTPCFSBOPFDPNJTTPPBVUPSJ[BSBNBUSBOTGPSNgMPFN EJSFJUPDJWJMPVEJSFJUPQPTJUJWP HBSBOUJOEPBWJEB BMJCFSEBEFF BQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBEPTHPWFSOBEPT&NOPNFEBTFHVSBO mBFEBQB[ PTJOEJWrEVPTUSBOTGFSJSBNBPTPCFSBOPPEJSFJUP FYDMVTJWPBPVTPEBGPSmBFEBWJPMpODJB EBWJOHBOmBDPOUSBPT DSJNFT EBSFHVMBNFOUBmkPEPTDPOUSBUPTFDPOyNJDPT JTUPn B JOTUJUVJmkPKVSrEJDBEBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB FEFPVUSPTDPOUSB UPTTPDJBJT DPNP QPSFYFNQMP PDBTBNFOUPDJWJM BMFHJTMBmkP TPCSFBIFSBOmB FUD 1BSB)PCCFT RVFNFSBPTPCFSBOP 1BSB)PCCFT PTPCFSBOPQPEFTFSVNSFJ VNHSVQPEF BSJTUPDSBUBTPVVNBBTTFNCMFJBEFNPDSgUJDB$PNPQBSB#P EJO UBNCnNQBSB)PCCFTPGVOEBNFOUBMOkPnPO|NFSPEPT HPWFSOBOUFTOFNBGPSNBEPSFHJNFQPMrUJDP NBTBEFUFSNJ OBmkPEFRVFNQPTTVJPQPEFSPVBTPCFSBOJB&TUBQFSUFODF EFNPEPBCTPMVUPBP&TUBEP RVF QPSNFJPEBTJOTUJUVJm{FT Q|CMJDBT UFNPQPEFSQBSBQSPNVMHBSFBQMJDBSBTMFJT EFGJOJS FHBSBOUJSBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBFFYJHJSPCFEJpODJBJODPO EJDJPOBMEPTHPWFSOBEPT EFTEFRVFSFTQFJUFEPJTEJSFJUPT OBUVSBJTJOUSBOTGFSrWFJTPEJSFJUPhWJEBFPEJSFJUPhQB[ QPJTGPJQPSFMFTRVFPTPCFSBOPGPJDSJBEP0TPCFSBOPEF UnNBFTQBEBFBMFJPTHPWFSOBEPT BWJEBFBQSPQSJFEBEF EPTCFOT 1BSB3PVTTFBV RVFNFSBPTPCFSBOP 1BSB3PVTTFBV PTPCFSBOPnPQPWP FOUFOEJEPDPNPWPO UBEFHFSBM QFTTPBNPSBMDPMFUJWBMJWSFFDPSQPQPMrUJDPEFDJ EBEkPT0TJOEJWrEVPT QFMPDPOUSBUP DSJBSBNTFBTJNFTNPT DPNPQPWPFnBFTUFRVFUSBOTGFSFNPTEJSFJUPTOBUVSBJTQBSB RVFTFKBNUSBOTGPSNBEPTFNEJSFJUPTDJWJT"TTJNTFOEP PHP WFSOBOUFOkPnPTPCFSBOP NBTPSFQSFTFOUBOUFEBTPCFSBOJB QPQVMBS0TJOEJWrEVPTBDFJUBNQFSEFSBMJCFSEBEFOBUVSBMQF MBMJCFSEBEFDJWJMBDFJUBNQFSEFSPEJSFJUPhQPTTFOBUVSBMEF CFOTQBSBHBOIBSBJOEJWJEVBMJEBEFDJWJM JTUPn BDJEBEBOJBF DPNFMB PEJSFJUPDJWJMhQSPQSJFEBEFEFCFOT2VBOEPDSJBNB TPCFSBOJBFOFMBTFGB[FNSFQSFTFOUBS TkPDJEBEkPT2VBOEP TFTVCNFUFNhTMFJTFhBVUPSJEBEFEPHPWFSOBOUFRVFPTSF QSFTFOUB DIBNBNTFT|EJUPT4kP QPJT DJEBEkPTEP&TUBEPF T|EJUPTEBTMFJT 2VFQFOTBWBN)PCCFTF3PVTTFBVBSFTQFJUPEBQSPQSJF EBEFQSJWBEB 1BSBPTEPJTGJMwTPGPT BQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBOkPnVNEJ SFJUPOBUVSBM NBTDJWJM.FTNPRVFOPFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[B FN
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
)PCCFT FOPFTUBEPEFTPDJFEBEF FN3PVTTFBV PTJOEJWrEVPT TFBQPTTFNEFUFSSBT EFPVUSPTIPNFOTFEFCFOT FTTBQPTTF nPNFTNPRVFOBEB QPJTOkPFYJTUFNMFJTQBSBHBSBOUJMBT$B EBVNQSFDJTBBSNBSTFQBSBQSPUFHpMB TFNHBSBOUJBEFRVF PDPOTFHVJSg0EJSFJUPDJWJM BPDPOUSgSJP BTTFHVSBQPSNFJP EBTMFJTBQPTTFFBMFHJUJNBOBGPSNBEBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB &TUBn QPSUBOUP VNFGFJUPEPDPOUSBUPTPDJBMFVNEFDSFUPEP TPCFSBOP
TwQPEFSgFYFSDFSDFOTVSBOPTDBTPTFNRVFTFFNJUBNPQJ OJ{FTTFEJDJPTBTRVFQPOIBNFNSJTDPPQSwQSJP&TUBEP-J CFSEBEFEFNFSDBEPPVMJCFSEBEFQBSBBTBm{FTFDPOyNJDBT GVOEBEBTOBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB MJCFSEBEFEFPSHBOJ[BmkP EBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMPVMJCFSEBEFEBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTFOUSF JOEJWrEVPTQSJWBEPTMJWSFTFJHVBJT FMJCFSEBEFEFDPOTDJpO DJBTkPPTQPOUPTOPTRVBJTPMJCFSBMJTNPTFBGJSNBFDPNPT RVBJTEFMJNJUBPQPEFSEP&TUBEP
&YQMJRVFPQFOTBNFOUPEF+PIO-PDLFDPNSFMBmkPhQSP QSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDPNPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMUFOEPQPSCBTFP USBCBMIP
2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEF²BOUJHP³OBFYQSFTTkP"OUJHP3F HJNF
-PDLFQBSUFEBEFGJOJmkPEPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMDPNPEJSFJUPh WJEB hMJCFSEBEFFBPTCFOTOFDFTTgSJPTQBSBBDPOTFSWBmkPEF BNCBT&TTFTCFOTTkPDPOTFHVJEPTQFMPUSBCBMIP4FHVOEP FMF %FVTnVNBSUrGJDF VNPCSFJSP BSRVJUFUPFFOHFOIFJSPRVF GF[VNBPCSBPNVOEP&TUF DPNPPCSBEPUSBCBMIBEPSEJWJOP BFMFQFSUFODFcTFVEPNrOJPFTVBQSPQSJFEBEF%FVTDSJPV PIPNFNhTVBJNBHFNFTFNFMIBOmB EFVMIFPNVOEPQBSB RVFOFMFSFJOBTTFF BPFYQVMTgMPEP1BSBrTP OkPMIFSFUJSPVP EPNrOJPEPNVOEP NBTMIFEJTTFRVFPUFSJBDPNPTVPSEFTFV SPTUP1PSUPEPTFTTFTNPUJWPT %FVTJOTUJUVJV OPNPNFOUPEB DSJBmkPEPNVOEPFEPIPNFN PEJSFJUPhQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB DPNPGSVUPMFHrUJNPEPUSBCBMIP1PSJTTP EFPSJHFNEJWJOB FMB nVNEJSFJUPOBUVSBM 2VFDPOTFRVpODJBTBUFPSJBEBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDPNP EJSFJUPOBUVSBM QSPQPTUBQPS+PIO-PDLF USPVYFQBSBBTP DJFEBEFPDJEFOUBM $PNCBTFOBUFPSJBEF-PDLF BCVSHVFTJBTFWpJOUFJSBNFO UFMFHJUJNBEBQFSBOUFBSFBMF[BFBOPCSF[BF NBJTEPRVFJTTP TVSHFDPNPTVQFSJPSBFMBT VNBWF[RVFPCVSHVpTBDSFEJUBRVF nQSPQSJFUgSJPHSBmBTBPTFVQSwQSJPUSBCBMIP FORVBOUPSFJTF OPCSFTTkPQBSBTJUBTEBTPDJFEBEFPVEPUSBCBMIPBMIFJP0CVS HVpTOkPTFSFDPOIFDF TPDJBMFNPSBMNFOUF BQFOBTDPNPTVQF SJPSBPTOPCSFT NBTUBNCnNDPNPTVQFSJPSBPTQPCSFT%FGBUP TF%FVTGF[UPEPTPTIPNFOTJHVBJT TFBUPEPTEFVBNJTTkPEF USBCBMIBSFBUPEPTDPODFEFVPEJSFJUPhQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB FOUkP PTQPCSFT JTUPn PTUSBCBMIBEPSFTRVFOkPDPOTFHVFN TFUPSOBSQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPT TkPDVMQBEPTQPSTVBDPOEJmkP JOGFSJPS4kPQPCSFT OkPTkPQSPQSJFUgSJPTFTkPPCSJHBEPTB USBCBMIBSQBSBPVUSPT TFKBQPSRVFTkPQFSEVMgSJPT HBTUBOEPP TBMgSJPFNWF[EFBDVNVMgMPQBSBBERVJSJSQSPQSJFEBEFT TFKB QPSRVFTkPQSFHVJmPTPTFOkPUSBCBMIBNPTVGJDJFOUFQBSBDPO TFHVJSVNBQSPQSJFEBEF 2VBMnBGVOmkPEP&TUBEPTFHVOEPBUFPSJBMJCFSBM 1PSNFJPEBTMFJTFEPVTPMFHBMEBWJPMpODJB FYnSDJ UPFQPMrDJB
HBSBOUJSPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMEFQSPQSJFEBEFTFN JOUFSGFSJSOBWJEBFDPOyNJDB QPJT OkPUFOEPJOTUJUVrEPB QSPQSJFEBEF P&TUBEPOkPUFNQPEFSQBSBOFMBJOUFSGFSJS WJTUPRVFPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTTkPDBQB[FTEFFTUBCFMF DFSBTSFHSBTFBTOPSNBTEBWJEBFDPOyNJDBPVEPNFSDBEP FRVFPGB[FNBHJOEPOVNBFTGFSBRVFOkPnFTUBUBMFTJN TPDJBM FOUSFP&TUBEPFPJOEJWrEVPJOUFSDBMBTFVNBFTGFSB TPDJBM BTPDJFEBEFDJWJM TPCSFBRVBMP&TUBEPOkPUFNQPEFS JOTUJUVJOUF NBTBQFOBTBGVOmkPEFHBSBOUJEPSEBTSFMBm{FT TPDJBJTFEFgSCJUSPEPTDPOGMJUPTOFMBFYJTUFOUFT P&TUB EPUFNPEJSFJUPEFMFHJTMBS QFSNJUJSFQSPJCJSUVEPRVBOUP QFSUFOmBhFTGFSBEBWJEBQ|CMJDB NBTOkPUFNPEJSFJUPEF JOUFSWJSOBFTGFSBQSJWBEB JTUPn OBDPOTDJpODJBEPTHPWFS OBEPT0&TUBEPEFWFHBSBOUJSBMJCFSEBEFEFDPOTDJpODJB PV TFKB BMJCFSEBEFEFQFOTBNFOUPEFUPEPTPTHPWFSOBEPT F
"OUJHPRVFSEJ[FS FNQSJNFJSPMVHBS ²QPMJUJDBNFOUFUFP DSgUJDPFBCTPMVUJTUB³FNTFHVOEPMVHBS ²TPDJBMNFOUFGVOEB EPOBJEFJBEFIJFSBSRVJBEJWJOB OBUVSBMFTPDJBMFOBPSHBOJ[B mkPGFVEBM CBTFBEBOPQBDUPEFTVCNJTTkPEPTWBTTBMPTPV T|EJUPTBPTFOIPS³ &NRVFNPNFOUPQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFUFNGJNP"OUJHP3F HJNF 2VFGBUPTPDPNQSPWBN 0UnSNJOPEP"OUJHP3FHJNFTFDPOTVNBRVBOEPBUFPSJB QPMrUJDBDPOTBHSBBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDPNPEJSFJUPOBUVSBM EPTJOEJWrEVPT EFTGB[FOEPBJNBHFNEPSFJDPNPNBSJEPEB UFSSB TFOIPSEPTCFOTFSJRVF[BTEPSFJOP EFDJEJOEPTFHVO EPTVBWPOUBEFFTFVDBQSJDIPRVBOUPBJNQPTUPT USJCVUPTF UBYBT $PNPTFEg OBQSgUJDB BBUVBmkPEP&TUBEPMJCFSBM 0&TUBEPMJCFSBMTFBQSFTFOUBDPNPSFQ|CMJDBSFQSFTFOUB UJWBDPOTUJUVrEBEFUSpTQPEFSFTPFYFDVUJWP FODBSSFHBEPEB BENJOJTUSBmkPEPTOFHwDJPTFTFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPT
PMFHJTMBUJWP QBSMBNFOUPFODBSSFHBEPEFJOTUJUVJSBTMFJT FPKVEJDJgSJP NB HJTUSBUVSBTEFQSPGJTTJPOBJTEPEJSFJUP FODBSSFHBEPTEFBQMJDBS BTMFJT 1PTTVJVNDPSQPEFNJMJUBSFTQSPGJTTJPOBJTRVFGPSNBN BTGPSmBTBSNBEBT±FYnSDJUPFQPMrDJB± FODBSSFHBEBTEBPS EFNJOUFSOBFEBEFGFTB PVBUBRVF FYUFSOP1PTTVJUBNCnN VNDPSQPEFTFSWJEPSFTPVGVODJPOgSJPTQ|CMJDPT RVFGPSNBNB CVSPDSBDJB FODBSSFHBEBEFDVNQSJSBTEFDJT{FTEPTUSpTQPEF SFTQFSBOUFPTDJEBEkPT 2VFGBUPTJOGMVFODJBSBNP&TUBEPMJCFSBM BNQMJBOEPBDJ EBEBOJBQPMrUJDB -VUBTQPQVMBSFTJOUFOTBT EFTEFPTnDVMP97***BUnOPTTPT JBT GPSmBSBNP&TUBEPMJCFSBMBUPSOBSTFVNBSFQ|CMJDBEF E NPDSgUJDBSFQSFTFOUBUJWB BNQMJBOEPBDJEBEBOJBQPMrUJDB$PN FYDFmkPEPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT POEFPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTCSBODPT GPSBNDPOTJEFSBEPTDJEBEkPTEFTEFPTnDVMP97*** OPTEFNBJT QBrTFTBDJEBEBOJBQMFOBFPTVGSgHJPVOJWFSTBMTwWJFSBNBFYJT UJSDPNQMFUBNFOUFOPTnDVMP99 DPNPDPODMVTkPEFVNMPOHP QSPDFTTPEFMVUBTTPDJBJT QPQVMBSFTFQPMrUJDBTFNRVFBDJEB EBOJBGPJTFOEPDPOTFHVJEBQPSFUBQBT 2VFGPSBNBTSFWPMVm{FTCVSHVFTBT 'PSBNBDPOUFDJNFOUPTFDPOyNJDPTFTPDJBJTRVFJNQVTF SBNNVEBOmBTOBDPODFQmkPEPQPEFSEP&TUBEP DPOTJEFSBEP JOTUJUVrEPQFMPDPOTFOUJNFOUPEPTJOEJWrEVPTQPSNFJPEPDPO USBUPTPDJBM&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT GPSBNNVEBOmBTOBFTUSVUVSB FDPOyNJDB OBTPDJFEBEFFOBQPMrUJDB FGFUVBEBTQPSVNBOPWB DMBTTFTPDJBM BCVSHVFTJB 2VBMPTFOUJEPPSJHJOBMEBQBMBWSBSFWPMVmkP $PNPFMB QBTTPVBGB[FSQBSUFEPWPDBCVMgSJPQPMrUJDP
52
Manual do Professor
"QBMBWSBSFWPMVmkPQSPWnNEPWPDBCVMgSJPEBBTUSPOPNJB FTJHOJGJDB²PNPWJNFOUPDJSDVMBSDPNQMFUPRVFVNBTUSPSFBMJ [BBPWPMUBSBPTFVQPOUPEFQBSUJEB³&TTBQBMBWSBFOUSPVQBSB PWPDBCVMgSJPQPMrUJDPTJHOJGJDBOEPNVEBOmBTFBMUFSBm{FTQSP GVOEBTOBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTFOPQPEFS PVQFSDVSTPSVNPBVN UFNQPOPWPFBVNBTPDJFEBEFOPWB PVBJOEB NBJTDPOUFYUVB MJ[BEBNFOUF BTVCJEBFBDPOTPMJEBmkPQPMrUJDBEBCVSHVFTJB DPNPDMBTTFEPNJOBOUF 0RVFRVFSEJ[FSBFYQSFTTkP²SFWPMVmkPOBSFWPMVmkP³ ²3FWPMVmkPOBSFWPMVmkP³TJHOJGJDBBFYJTUpODJBEFVNNP WJNFOUPQPQVMBSSBEJDBMOPJOUFSJPSEBSFWPMVmkPCVSHVFTB PV BGBDFEFNPDSgUJDBFJHVBMJUgSJBEBSFWPMVmkP EFSSPUBEBQFMB CVSHVFTJB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT OBTUSpTSFWPMVm{FT *OHMFTB EF "NFSJDBOBEFF'SBODFTBEF
BCVSHVFTJB QSFUFOEFVFDPOTFHVJVEFSSPUBSBSFBMF[BFBOPCSF[B QBTTPV BEPNJOBSP&TUBEPFKVMHPVDPNJTTPUFSNJOBEBBUBSFGBEBT NVEBOmBT FORVBOUPBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFT RVFQBSUJDJQBSBN EBRVFMBWJUwSJB EFTFKBWBNNVJUPNBJTBOTJBWBNJOTUJUVJSVNB TPDJFEBEFJOUFJSBNFOUFOPWB KVTUB MJWSFFGFMJ[ "TDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTOkPQPTTVrBNUFPSJBTQPMrUJDBTEF UJQPGJMPTwGJDPFDJFOUrGJDP2VBJTFSBNTVBTGPOUFTEFSFGF SpODJBTQBSBFYQMJDBSPNVOEPFNRVFWJWJBN "TDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTEJTQVOIBNEFVNB|OJDBGPOUFB#r CMJB1PSNFJPEBSFMJHJkP QPTTVrBNEVBTSFGFSpODJBTEFKVTUJmB FEFGFMJDJEBEFBJNBHFNEP1BSBrTPUFSSFTUSF OP"OUJHP5FTUB NFOUP FP3FJOPEF%FVTOB5FSSBPV/PWB+FSVTBMnN OP/PWP 5FTUBNFOUP
RVFSFTUBVSBSJBP1BSBrTPEFQPJTRVF$SJTUPWJFTTF BPNVOEPQFMBTFHVOEBWF[ DPNPFTUgFTDSJUPOP"QPDBMJQTF EF4kP+PkP F OPGJNEPTUFNQPTPVUFNQPEPGJN EFSSPUBTTF QBSBTFNQSFP.BM"TDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTSFWPMVDJPOgSJBTEJT QVOIBN QPSUBOUP EFVNJNBHJOgSJPNFTTJiOJDPFNJMFOBSJTUB QPSRVFMJHBEPhJEFJBEFVNBQSPNFTTBTBMWBEPSBPVEBBmkPEF VNTBMWBEPSRVFMJWSBSJBPTIPNFOTEPTNBMFTFEBTQFOBT &NRVFDPOTJTUJBPJNBHJOgSJPNFTTJiOJDPFNJMFOBSJTUB EBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFT &SBNJMFOBSJTUBQPSRVFBQPJBEPOBJEFJBEFRVFTVBBmkP EBSJBFYJTUpODJBh+FSVTBMnN5FSSFTUSFPV/PWB+FSVTBMnN P 3FJOPEF%FVTOB5FSSB PRVBMEVSBSJBNJMBOPTEFGFMJDJEBEF BCVOEiODJBFKVTUJmB BUnRVF OPGJNEPTUFNQPT $SJTUPEFSSP UBTTFQBSBTFNQSFP"OUJDSJTUPFIPVWFTTFP+Vr[P'JOBM DPNB DPOEFOBmkPEPTNBVTFBFOUSBEBEPTCPOTFKVTUPTOB+FSVTB MnN$FMFTUF FUFSOB $PNPQPEFNPTEFGJOJSBFTTpODJBEPMJCFSBMJTNP 2VF EJTUJOm{FTFTTBUFPSJBFTUBCFMFDJBFOUSFTPDJFEBEFDJWJM F&TUBEP "FTTpODJBEPMJCFSBMJTNPnBEJGFSFOmBFBEJTUiODJBFOUSF &TUBEPFTPDJFEBEF QPJTnFTTBEJTUiODJBRVFMIFQFSNJUFEF GFOEFSBJEFJBEFMJCFSEBEFFDPOyNJDBFEFMJCFSEBEFEFBmkP TPDJBMEJTUJOUBEBBmkPQ|CMJDBPVQPMrUJDB"TUFPSJBTMJCFSBJT TFQBSBNP&TUBEPFBTPDJFEBEFDJWJM0QSJNFJSPBQBSFDFDPNP JOTUiODJBJNQFTTPBMEFEPNJOBmkP0&TUBEP WJTUPDPNPSFQ| CMJDB nBJOTUiODJBQ|CMJDBEFFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPFBQMJDBmkPEBT MFJT PHBSBOUJEPSEBPSEFNQPSNFJPEPVTPMFHBMEBWJPMpODJB QBSBQVOJSUPEPPDSJNFEFGJOJEPQFMBTMFJT FnPgSCJUSPEPT DPOGMJUPTTPDJBJT"TPDJFEBEFDJWJM QPSTFVUVSOP BQBSFDFDPNP VNDPOKVOUPEFSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTEJWFSTJGJDBEBTFOUSFDMBTTFTF HSVQPTTPDJBJTDVKPTJOUFSFTTFTFEJSFJUPTQPEFNDPJODJEJSPV PQPSTF/FMBFYJTUFNBTSFMBm{FTFDPOyNJDBTEFQSPEVmkP
53
EJTUSJCVJmkP BDVNVMBmkPEFSJRVF[BTFDPOTVNPEFQSPEVUPT RVFDJSDVMBNOPNFSDBEP0DFOUSPEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMnBQSP QSJFEBEFQSJWBEB RVFEJGFSFODJBJOEJWrEVPT HSVQPTFDMBTTFT TPDJBJT FPDFOUSPEP&TUBEPnBHBSBOUJBEFTTBQSPQSJFEBEF TFNDPOUVEPNFTDMBSQPMrUJDBFTPDJFEBEF -FWBOEPFNDPOUBBSFTQPTUBEBRVFTUkPBOUFSJPS DPNP QPEFNPTFYQMJDBSBGBDFQPQVMBSEBTSFWPMVm{FT "TSFWPMVm{FTF TPCSFUVEP BGBDFQPQVMBSEBTSFWPMVm{FT PQFSBNFYBUBNFOUFDPNBJOEJTUJOmkPFOUSF&TUBEPFTPDJFEB EF FOUSFBmkPQPMrUJDBFSFMBm{FTTPDJBJT"TSFWPMVm{FTQSFUFO EFNEFSSVCBSPQPEFSFYJTUFOUFPVP&TUBEPQPSRVFPQFSDFCFN DPNPSFTQPOTgWFMPVD|NQMJDFEBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTFJOKVTUJmBT FYJTUFOUFTOBTPDJFEBEF%JUPEFPVUSBGPSNB BQFSDFQmkPEF JOKVTUJmBTTPDJBJTMFWBhTBm{FTQPMrUJDBT6NBSFWPMVmkPQPEF DPNFmBSDPNPMVUBTPDJBMRVFEFTFNCPDBOBMVUBQPMrUJDBDPOUSB PQPEFSPVQPEFDPNFmBSDPNPMVUBQPMrUJDBRVFEFTFNCPDBOB MVUBQPSVNBPVUSBTPDJFEBEF&JTQPSRVF FNUPEBTBTSFWPMV m{FTCVSHVFTBT WFNPTTFNQSFBDPOUFDFSPNFTNPQSPDFTTP BCVSHVFTJBFTUJNVMBBQBSUJDJQBmkPQPQVMBSQPSRVFQSFDJTBRVF BTPDJFEBEFUPEBMVUFDPOUSBPQPEFSFYJTUFOUFDPOTPMJEBEBB NVEBOmBQPMrUJDB DPNBQBTTBHFNEPQPEFSEBNPOBSRVJBhSF Q|CMJDB BCVSHVFTJBDPOTJEFSBBSFWPMVmkPUFSNJOBEBBTDMBT TFTQPQVMBSFT QPSnN BQSPTTFHVFN QPJTBTQJSBNBPQPEFS EFNPDSgUJDPFEFTFKBNNVEBOmBTTPDJBJTBCVSHVFTJBWJUPSJP TBQBTTBFOUkPBSFQSJNJSBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTSFWPMVDJPOgSJBT EFTBSNBPQPWPRVFFMBQSwQSJBBSNBSB QSFOEF UPSUVSBFNBUB PTDIFGFTQPQVMBSFTFFODFSSB QFMBGPSmB PQSPDFTTPSFWPMVDJP OgSJP HBSBOUJOEP DPNPMJCFSBMJTNP BTFQBSBmkPFOUSF&TUBEP FTPDJFEBEF $JUFUSpTTJHOJGJDBEPTQPMrUJDPTEBTSFWPMVm{FT TFHVOEPP GJMwTPGPGSBODpT$MBVEF-FGPSU 6NBSFWPMVmkP TFKBFMBCVSHVFTB TFKBFMBQPQVMBS QPTTVJ VNTJHOJGJDBEPQPMrUJDPEBNBJTBMUBJNQPSUiODJB QPSRVFEFTWFO EBBFTUSVUVSBFBPSHBOJ[BmkPEBTPDJFEBEFFEP&TUBEP1BSB PGJMwTPGPGSBODpT$MBVEF-FGPSUFMBFWJEFODJB BEJWJTkPTPDJBM FQPMrUJDB OBGPSNBEFVNBQPMBSJ[BmkPFOUSFVNBMUPPQSFTTPS FVNCBJYPPQSJNJEP BQFSDFQmkPEPBMUPQFMPCBJYPEBTP DJFEBEFDPNPVNQPEFSRVFOkPnOBUVSBMOFNOFDFTTgSJP NBT SFTVMUBEPEFVNBBmkPIVNBOBFRVF DPNPUBM QPEFTFSEFSSV CBEPFSFDPOTUSVrEPEFPVUSBNBOFJSB BDPNQSFFOTkPEFRVF PTBHFOUFTTPDJBJTTkPTVKFJUPTQPMrUJDPTF DPNPUBJT EPUBEPT EFEJSFJUPT"DPOTDJpODJBEPTEJSFJUPTGB[DPNRVFPTTVKFJUPT TPDJPQPMrUJDPTFYJKBNSFDPOIFDJNFOUPFHBSBOUJBEFTFVTEJSFJ UPTQFMBTPDJFEBEFFQFMPQPEFSQPMrUJDP&JTQPSRVFUPEBTBT SFWPMVm{FTDVMNJOBNOVNBEFDMBSBmkPQ|CMJDBDPOIFDJEBDPNP %FDMBSBmkP6OJWFSTBMEPT%JSFJUPTEPT$JEBEkPT QFMBWJBEB EFDMBSBmkPEPTEJSFJUPT VNBSFWPMVmkPSFQ{FBSFMBmkPFOUSF QPEFSQPMrUJDPFKVTUJmBTPDJBM NBTDPNVNBOPWJEBEFQSwQSJB EPNVOEPNPEFSOP QPJTBKVTUJmBOkPEFQFOEFNBJTEBGJHVSB EP#PN(PWFSOPPVEPQSrODJQFWJSUVPTPFTJNEFJOTUJUVJm{FTQ| CMJDBTRVFTBUJTGBmBNhEFNBOEBEPTDJEBEkPTBP&TUBEP$BCF BPOPWPQPEFSQPMrUJDPDSJBSJOTUJUVJm{FTRVFQPTTBNTBUJTGB[FS FHBSBOUJSBMVUBSFWPMVDJPOgSJBQPSEJSFJUPT &YQMJRVFBGBDFCVSHVFTBMJCFSBMFBGBDFQPQVMBSEBTSFWP MVm{FTNPEFSOBT /BGBDFCVSHVFTBMJCFSBM BSFWPMVmkPnQPMrUJDB WJTBOEPh UPNBEBEPQPEFSFhJOTUJUVJmkPEP&TUBEPDPNPSFQ|CMJDBFwS HkPTFQBSBEPEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMOBGBDFQPQVMBS BSFWPMVmkP nQPMrUJDBFTPDJBM WJTBOEPhDSJBmkPEFEJSFJUPTFhJOTUJUVJmkP EPQPEFSEFNPDSgUJDPRVFHBSBOUBVNBOPWBTPDJFEBEFKVTUBF
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
GFMJ[/BTSFWPMVm{FTNPEFSOBT BGBDFQPQVMBSnTVGPDBEBQFMB GBDFMJCFSBM FNCPSBFTUB|MUJNBTFKBPCSJHBEBBJOUSPEV[JSFHB SBOUJSBMHVOTEJSFJUPTQPMrUJDPTFTPDJBJTQBSBPQPWP EFNPEPB DPOTFHVJSNBOUFSBPSEFNFFWJUBSBFYQMPTkPDPOUrOVBEFSFWPM UBTQPQVMBSFT"GBDFQPQVMBSWFODJEBOkPEFTBQBSFDF3FTTVS HFQFSJPEJDBNFOUFFNMVUBTJTPMBEBTQPSNFMIPSFTDPOEJm{FT EFWJEB EFUSBCBMIP EFTBMgSJPTFDPNSFJWJOEJDBm{FTJTPMBEBT EFQBSUJDJQBmkPQPMrUJDB&TTBGBDFQPQVMBSUFOEFBDSFTDFSFB NBOJGFTUBSTFFNOPWBTSFWPMVm{FT EFSSPUBEBT EVSBOUFUPEP PTnDVMP9*9 hNFEJEBRVFTFEFTFOWPMWFPDBQJUBMJTNPJOEVT USJBMFBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTTFUPSOBNVNBDMBTTFTPDJBMEFQFSGJM NVJUPEFGJOJEPPTQSPMFUgSJPTPVUSBCBMIBEPSFTJOEVTUSJBJT 0TVSHJNFOUPEBGJHVSBEPQSPMFUgSJPPVUSBCBMIBEPSJOEVT USJBMGBWPSFDFPBQBSFDJNFOUPEBTUFPSJBTTPDJBMJTUBT2VF EJ[JBNFTTBTUFPSJBT &NRVFTFCBTFBWBN "TUFPSJBTTPDJBMJTUBTUPNBNPQSPMFUBSJBEPDPNPTVKFJUPQP MrUJDPFIJTUwSJDPFQSPDVSBNGJHVSBSVNBOPWBTPDJFEBEFFVNB OPWBQPMrUJDBOBRVBMBFYQMPSBmkPEPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT BEPNJOB mkPQPMrUJDBBRVFFTUkPTVCNFUJEPTFBTFYDMVT{FTTPDJBJTFDVM UVSBJTBRVFTkPGPSmBEPTEFJYFNEFFYJTUJS1PSRVFTFVTVKFJUP QPMrUJDPTkPPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT FTTBTUFPSJBTQPMrUJDBTUFOEFNB GJHVSBSBTPDJFEBEFGVUVSBDPNPJHVBMJUgSJB GFJUBEFBCVOEiO DJB KVTUJmBFGFMJDJEBEF$PNPQFSDFCFNBDVNQMJDJEBEFFOUSF P&TUBEPFBDMBTTFFDPOPNJDBNFOUFEPNJOBOUF KVMHBNRVFB FYJTUpODJBEPQSJNFJSPTFEFWFBQFOBThTOFDFTTJEBEFTFDPOy NJDBTEBCVSHVFTJBFQPSJTTPBGJSNBNRVF OBTPDJFEBEFGVUVSB RVBOEPOkPIPVWFSEJWJTkPTPDJBMEFDMBTTFTOFNEFTJHVBMEB EFT BQPMrUJDBOkPEFQFOEFSgEP&TUBEP4kP QPSUBOUP UFPSJBT BOUJFTUBUBJT RVFBQPTUBNOBDBQBDJEBEFEFBVUPHPWFSOPPVEF BVUPHFTUkPEBTPDJFEBEF
#APqTULOß߯ßß=lkhpe_]_kjpn]]oanre`k rkhqjp ne] 0RVFTFFOUFOEFQPS²USBEJmkPMJCFSUgSJB³ 4kPBTMVUBTTPDJBJTFQPMrUJDBTQPQVMBSFTQPSMJCFSEBEFF KVTUJmBDPOUSBBPQSFTTkPEPTQPEFSPTPT
UFJSBT OBm{FTJOUFJSBTTFTVCNFUBNhWPOUBEFEFVNTw FN HFSBMPNBJTDPWBSEFFUFNFSPTPEFUPEPT%FPOEFVNTwUJSB PQPEFSQBSBFTNBHBSUPEPTPTPVUSPT %VBTTkPBTSFTQPTUBT /BQSJNFJSB -B#PnUJFNPTUSBRVFOkPnQPSNFEPRVFPCFEF DFNPThWPOUBEFEFVNTw NBTQPSRVFEFTFKBNPTBUJSBOJB" TPDJFEBEFnDPNPVNBJNFOTBQJSiNJEFEFUJSBOFUFTRVFTFFT NBHBNVOTBPTPVUSPTPDPSQPEPUJSBOPnGPSNBEPQFMPTTFJT RVFPBDPOTFMIBN QFMPTTFTTFOUBRVFQSPUFHFNPTTFJT QFMPT TFJTDFOUPTRVFEFGFOEFNPTTFTTFOUB QFMPTTFJTNJMRVFTFS WFNBPTTFJTDFOUPTFQFMPTTFJTNJMI{FTRVFPCFEFDFNBPTTFJT NJM OBFTQFSBOmBEFDPOTFHVJSPQPEFSQBSBNBOEBSFNPVUSPT "QSJNFJSBSFTQPTUBOPTEJ[RVFPQPEFSEFVNTwTPCSFUPEPTGPJ EBEPBPUJSBOPQPSOPTTPEFTFKPEFTFSNPTUJSBOPTUBNCnN" TFHVOEBSFTQPTUB QPSnN WBJNBJTGVOEP-B#PnUJFJOEBHBEF POEFWFNPQSwQSJPEFTFKPEFUJSBOJB &SFTQPOEFEPEFTFKPEF UFSCFOTFSJRVF[BT EPEFTFKPEFTFSQSPQSJFUgSJP.BT JOEBHB FMFOPWBNFOUF EFPOEFWFNFTTFEFTFKPEFUFS EFQPTTF &SFT QPOEFEPEFTQSF[PQFMBMJCFSEBEF4FEFTFKgTTFNPTWFSEBEFJ SBNFOUFBMJCFSEBEF KBNBJTBUSPDBSrBNPTQFMBQPTTFEFCFOT RVFOPTFTDSBWJ[BNBPTPVUSPTFOPTTVCNFUFNhWPOUBEFEPT NBJTGPSUFTFUJSBOPT"PUSPDBSPEJSFJUPhMJCFSEBEFQFMPEFTFKP EFQPTTF BDFJUBNPTBMHPUFSSrWFMBTFSWJEkPWPMVOUgSJB&TTB FYQSFTTkPnQBSBEPYBM FTUSBOIB%FGBUP TFNQSFTPVCFNPT RVFBWPOUBEFnMJWSFFRVFPTTFSWPTTkPGPSmBEPThTVCNJTTkP 0VTFKB OVODBPVWJNPTEJ[FSRVFBWPOUBEFQVEFTTFRVFSFS TVBOFHBmkP JTUPn BTFSWJEkP-B#PnUJFFNQSFHBFTTBUFSSrWFM FYQSFTTkPQBSBJOEJDBSRVFBUJSBOJBFYJTUFFQFSTJTUFQPSRVF OkPTPNPTPCSJHBEPTBPCFEFDFSBPUJSBOPFBPTTFVTSFQSFTFO UBOUFT NBTEFTFKBNPTWPMVOUBSJBNFOUFTFSWJMPTQPSRVFEFMFT FTQFSBNPTCFOTFBHBSBOUJBEFOPTTBTQPTTFT6TBNPTOPTTB MJCFSEBEFQBSBOPTUPSOBSNPTTFSWPT 7JNPTRVFBTUFPSJBTTPDJBMJTUBTTkPBRVFMBTRVFTFGVOEBN OBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTFOBTBm{FTTPDJBJT JTUPn RVFSFDVTBN BTFQBSBmkPMJCFSBMFOUSFTPDJFEBEFF&TUBEPFQSPDVSBNOB BUJWJEBEFTPDJBMPTGVOEBNFOUPTEPQPEFSFBmkPQPMrUJDPT 2VBJTTkPBTUSpTDPSSFOUFTTPDJBMJTUBTNPEFSOBT 0TPDJBMJTNPVUwQJDP PBOBSRVJTNPFPDPNVOJTNPPVTP DJBMJTNPDJFOUrGJDP
0RVFGPSBNBTSFWPMUBTNJMFOBSJTUBT 'PSBNBTSFWPMUBTDBNQPOFTBTFEPTBSUFTkPTEPGJOBMEB *EBEF.nEJB EPJOrDJPEB3FGPSNB1SPUFTUBOUFFEB3FWPMVmkP *OHMFTBEF&TTBTSFWPMUBTGJDBSBNDPOIFDJEBTDPNPNJMF OBSJTUBT QPSRVFBTDMBTTFTQPQVMBSFTQPTTVFNDPNPSFGFSFO DJBMQBSBDPNQSFFOEFSFKVMHBSBQPMrUJDBBTJNBHFOTCrCMJDBTEP 1BSBrTP EB/PWB+FSVTBMnN5FSSFTUSFFEPUFNQPEPGJN RVBO EPP#FNWFODFSgQFSQFUVBNFOUFP.BM JOTUBVSBOEPP3FJOP EPT.JM"OPTEFGFMJDJEBEFFKVTUJmB/B3FWPMVmkP*OHMFTB PT QPCSFTUJOIBNDFSUF[BEFRVFDIFHBSBPUFNQPEPGJNFTFBQSP YJNBWBPNJMpOJP7JBNPTTJOBJTEPGJNGPNF QFTUF HVFSSBT FDMJQTFT DPNFUBT QSPErHJPTJOFYQMJDgWFJT RVFBOVODJBWBNB WJOEBEPBOUJDSJTUPFFYJHJBNRVFGPTTFDPNCBUJEPQFMPTKVTUPT FCPOT"FTQFSBOmBNJMFOBSJTUBTFNQSFWJVBMVUBQPMrUJDBDPNP DPOGMBHSBmkPDwTNJDBFOUSFBMV[FBUSFWB PKVTUPFPJOKVTUP PCFNFPNBM &YQMJRVFBEJTDVTTkPEBTFSWJEkPWPMVOUgSJBQSPQPTUBQFMP GJMwTPGPGSBODpT-B#PnUJF &NTVBPCSB JOUJUVMBEB%JTDVSTPEBTFSWJEkPWPMVOUgSJB -B #PnUJFJOEBHBDPNPnQPTTrWFMRVFCVSHPTJOUFJSPT DJEBEFTJO
2VFnTPDJBMJTNPVUwQJDP &TTBDPSSFOUFTPDJBMJTUBWpBDMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSBDPNP EFTQPTTVrEB PQSJNJEBFHFSBEPSBEBSJRVF[BTPDJBMTFNEF MBEFTGSVUBS1BSBFTTBDMBTTF PTUFwSJDPTJNBHJOBNVNBOPWB TPDJFEBEFOBRVBMOkPFYJTUBNBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB PMVDSP EPTDBQJUBMJTUBT BFYQMPSBmkPEPUSBCBMIPFBEFTJHVBMEBEF FDPOyNJDB TPDJBMFQPMrUJDB*NBHJOBNOPWBTDJEBEFT PSHBOJ [BEBTFNHSBOEFTDPPQFSBUJWBTHFSJEBTQFMPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTF OBTRVBJTIBKBFTDPMBQBSBUPEPT MJCFSEBEFEFQFOTBNFOUPF EFFYQSFTTkP JHVBMEBEFEFEJSFJUPTTPDJBJT BCVOEiODJB KVTUJmB FGFMJDJEBEF &YQMJRVFPTFOUJEPEBQBMBWSBVUPQJB "QBMBWSBVUPQJBGPJFNQSFHBEBQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[QFMPGJMw TPGPJOHMpT5IPNBT.PSVTOPMJWSP6UPQJB"QBMBWSBnVNBDPN QPTJmkPEFFMFNFOUPTHSFHPTF SJHPSPTBNFOUF TJHOJGJDB²FN MVHBSOFOIVN MVHBSJOFYJTUFOUF JNBHJOgSJP³1PSFTTFNPUJWP FTUBNPTBDPTUVNBEPTBJEFOUJGJDBSVUPQJBFVUwQJDPDPNJNQPT TrWFM BRVJMPRVFTwFYJTUFFNOPTTPEFTFKPFJNBHJOBmkPFRVF OkPFODPOUSBSgOVODBDPOEJm{FTPCKFUJWBTQBSBTFSFBMJ[BS
54
Manual do Professor
2VFnBOBSRVJTNP 0QPOUPEFQBSUJEBEPBOBSRVJTNPnBDSrUJDBEPJOEJWJEVBMJTNP CVSHVpTFEP&TUBEPMJCFSBM DPOTJEFSBEPBVUPSJUgSJPFBOUJOB UVSBM$PNP3PVTTFBV PTBOBSRVJTUBTBDSFEJUBNOBMJCFSEBEF OBUVSBMFOBCPOEBEFOBUVSBMEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFFNTVBDBQB DJEBEFQBSBWJWFSGFMJ[FTFNDPNVOJEBEFT"USJCVFNBPSJHFNEB TPDJFEBEF JTUPn BFYJTUpODJBEFJOEJWrEVPTJTPMBEPT QSFDBSJB NFOUFBTTPDJBEPTFFNMVUBQFSNBOFOUF hQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB FhFYQMPSBmkPEPUSBCBMIP FBPSJHFNEP&TUBEPBPQPEFSEPT NBJTGPSUFTTPCSFPTGSBDPT1BSBPTBOBSRVJTUBT TPDJFEBEFF &TUBEPTkPBOUJOBUVSBJTQPSRVFTFPQ{FNhUFOEpODJBOBUVSBM EPTIPNFOTBWJWFSJHVBMJUgSJBFMJWSFNFOUFFNDPNVOJEBEFTBV UPHPWFSOBEBT0TBOBSRVJTUBTTkPDPOIFDJEPTDPNPMJCFSUgSJPT QPJTMVUBNDPOUSBUPEBTBTGPSNBTEFBVUPSJEBEFFEFBVUPSJUB SJTNP"MnNEF#BLVOJO PVUSPTJNQPSUBOUFTBOBSRVJTUBTGPSBN ,SPQPULJO &NB(PMENBO 5PMTUwJ .BMBUFTUBF(FPSHF0SXFMM BVUPSEPMJWSP 2VFnTPDJBMJTNPDJFOUrGJDP 2VFNGPSBNTFVTQSJODJQBJT UFwSJDPT 5SBUBTFEFVNQPTJDJPOBNFOUPJEFPMwHJDPDSrUJDPOkPTwEP &TUBEPMJCFSBM NBTUBNCnNEPTPDJBMJTNPVUwQJDPFEPBOBS RVJTNP&ODPOUSBTFEFTFOWPMWJEPOBTPCSBTEF,BSM.BSYF 'SJFESJDI&OHFMT 2VF QBSBMFMP QPEFNPT FTUBCFMFDFS FOUSF .BRVJBWFM F .BSY &NCPSBTVBTUFPSJBTTFKBNDPNQMFUBNFOUFEJGFSFOUFT QPJT SFTQPOEFNBFYQFSJpODJBTIJTUwSJDBTFBQSPCMFNBTEJGFSFOUFT BNCPTSFQSFTFOUBNVNBNVEBOmBEFDJTJWBOPNPEPEFDPODF CFSBQPMrUJDBFBSFMBmkPFOUSFTPDJFEBEFFQPEFS.BRVJBWFM EFTNJTUJGJDPVBUFPMPHJBQPMrUJDBFPSFQVCMJDBOJTNPJUBMJBOP RVFTJNQMFTNFOUFQSFUFOEJBJNJUBSHSFHPTFSPNBOPTFNWF[EF DPNQSFFOEFSTFVQSwQSJPQSFTFOUF.BSYEFTNJTUJGJDPVBQPMrUJ DBMJCFSBMQBSUJOEPEBDSrUJDBEBFDPOPNJBQPMrUJDB 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEF²FDPOPNJBQPMrUJDB³ &NRVFTFCB TFBWBNTVBTGPSNVMBm{FT "FDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBTVSHFDPNPDJpODJBOPGJOBMEPTnDVMP 7***FJOrDJPEP9*9 OB'SBOmBFOB*OHMBUFSSB QBSBDPNCBUFS 9 BTMJNJUBm{FTRVFP"OUJHP3FHJNFJNQVOIBBPDBQJUBMJTNP "TSFTUSJm{FTFDPOyNJDBTQSwQSJBTEBTPDJFEBEFGFVEBMFP DPOUSPMFEBBUJWJEBEFNFSDBOUJMQFMP&TUBEPNPOgSRVJDPFSBN WJTUPTDPNPQSFKVEJDJBJTBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEB²SJRVF[BEBT OBm{FT³#BTFBOEPTFOPTNFTNPTQSJODrQJPTEPMJCFSBMJTNP QPMrUJDP BQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDPNPEJSFJUPOBUVSBM BMJCFSEB EFDPNPEJSFJUPOBUVSBM BMJNJUBmkPEBFTGFSBEPQPEFSFTUBUBM
BFDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBnFMBCPSBEBDPNPMJCFSBMJTNPFDPOyNJDP %JGFSFOUFNFOUFEPTHSFHPT RVFEFGJOJSBNPIPNFNDPNPBOJ NBMQPMrUJDP FEJGFSFOUFNFOUFEPTNFEJFWBJT RVFEFGJOJSBNP IPNFNDPNPTFSTPDJgWFM BFDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBEFGJOFPIPNFN DPNPJOEJWrEVPRVFCVTDBBTBUJTGBmkPEFTVBTOFDFTTJEBEFT DPOTVNJOEPPRVFBOBUVSF[BMIFPGFSFDFPVUSBCBMIBOEPQB SBPCUFSSJRVF[BTFCFNFTUBS1PSTFSBWJEBFNDPNVNNBJT WBOUBKPTBBPTJOEJWrEVPT FTUFTQBDUVBNQBSBDSJBSBTPDJFEBEF FP&TUBEP"FDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBCVTDBSgBTMFJTEPTGFOyNF OPTFDPOyNJDPTOBOBUVSF[BIVNBOBFPTFGFJUPTEBTDBVTBT FDPOyNJDBTTPCSFBWJEBTPDJBM7JTUPRVFBPSEFNOBUVSBMn SBDJPOBMFRVFPTTFSFTIVNBOPTQPTTVFNMJCFSEBEFOBUVSBM B FDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBEFWFSgHBSBOUJSRVFBSBDJPOBMJEBEFOBUVSBM
55
FBMJCFSEBEFIVNBOBTFSFBMJ[FNQPSTJNFTNBT TFNFOUSBWFT FTFNMJNJUFT &NRVFDPOTJTUJBNBTDSrUJDBThFDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBPVMJCF SBMJTNPFDPOyNJDP "DSrUJDBhFDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBDPOTJTUJBFNNPTUSBSRVF BQF TBSEBTBGJSNBm{FTHSFDPSPNBOBTFMJCFSBJTEFTFQBSBmkPFOUSF BFTGFSBQSJWBEBEBQSPQSJFEBEFFBFTGFSBQ|CMJDBEPQPEFS B QPMrUJDBKBNBJTDPOTFHVJVSFBMJ[BSBEJGFSFOmBFOUSFBNCBT/FN QPEFSJB0QPEFSQPMrUJDPTFNQSFGPJBNBOFJSBMFHBMFKVSrEJDB QFMBRVBMBDMBTTFFDPOPNJDBNFOUFEPNJOBOUFEFVNBTPDJFEB EFNBOUFWFTFVEPNrOJPTPCSFBTPVUSBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT"Qw MJT BDJWJUBT P&TUBEPOVODBQVEFSBNTFQBSBSPQPEFSQSJWBEP EPTFDPOPNJDBNFOUFEPNJOBOUFTFPQPEFSQ|CMJDPPVQPMrUJDP 0BQBSBUPMFHBMFKVSrEJDPBQFOBTEJTTJNVMBPFTTFODJBMRVFP QPEFSQPMrUJDPFYJTUFDPNPQPEFSJPEPTFDPOPNJDBNFOUFQPEF SPTPT QBSBTFSWJSTFVTJOUFSFTTFTFQSJWJMnHJPTFHBSBOUJSMIFTB EPNJOBmkPTPDJBM%JWJEJEBTFOUSFQSPQSJFUgSJPTFOkPQSPQSJF UgSJPT BTTPDJFEBEFTKBNBJTGPSBNDPNVOJEBEFTEFJHVBJTFKB NBJTQFSNJUJSBNRVFPQPEFSQPMrUJDPGPTTFDPNQBSUJMIBEPDPN PTOkPQSPQSJFUgSJPT 2VFEJ[JB.BSYEPMJCFSBMJTNPFDPOyNJDP .BSYJOEBHBPRVFnBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMEFRVFGBMBNPT FDPOPNJTUBTFUFwSJDPTQPMrUJDPTMJCFSBJT &SFTQPOEFOkPnB NBOJGFTUBmkPEFVNBPSEFNOBUVSBMSBDJPOBMOFNPBHMPNFSB EPDPOGMJUBOUFEFJOEJWrEVPT GBNrMJBT HSVQPTFDPSQPSBm{FT DVKPTJOUFSFTTFTBOUBHyOJDPTTFSkPDPODJMJBEPTQFMPDPOUSBUP TPDJBM QPSNFJPEPRVBMTFSJBJOTUJUVrEBBBmkPSFHVMBEPSBF PSEFOBEPSBEP&TUBEPDPNPFYQSFTTkPEPJOUFSFTTFFEBWPO UBEFHFSBJT"TPDJFEBEFDJWJMnPTJTUFNBEFSFMBm{FTTPDJBJT RVFPSHBOJ[BBQSPEVmkPFDPOyNJDB BHSJDVMUVSB JOE|TUSJBF DPNnSDJP
SFBMJ[BOEPTFBUSBWnTEFJOTUJUVJm{FTTPDJBJTFO DBSSFHBEBTEFSFQSPEV[JMP GBNrMJB JHSFKBT FTDPMBT QPMrDJB QBSUJEPTQPMrUJDPT NFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkP FUD cPFTQBmPOP RVBMBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTFTVBTGPSNBTFDPOyNJDBTFJOTUJUV DJPOBJTTkPQFOTBEBT JOUFSQSFUBEBTFSFQSFTFOUBEBTQPSVN DPOKVOUPEFJEFJBTNPSBJT SFMJHJPTBT KVSrEJDBT QFEBHwHJDBT BSUrTUJDBT DJFOUrGJDPGJMPTwGJDBTFQPMrUJDBT"TPDJFEBEFDJWJMnP QSPDFTTPEFDPOTUJUVJmkPFSFQPTJmkPEBTDPOEJm{FTNBUFSJBJT EBQSPEVmkPFDPOyNJDBQFMBTRVBJTTkPFOHFOESBEBTBTDMBT TFTTPDJBJTPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPF PTUSBCBMIBEPSFTPVOkPQSPQSJFUgSJPT RVFWFOEFNTVBGPSmB EFUSBCBMIPDPNPNFSDBEPSJBTVCNFUJEBhMFJEBPGFSUBFEB QSPDVSBOPNFSDBEPEFNkPEFPCSB&TTBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJTTkP BOUBHyOJDBTFTFVTDPOGMJUPTSFWFMBNVNBDPOUSBEJmkPQSPGVO EBFOUSFPTJOUFSFTTFTJSSFDPODJMJgWFJTEFDBEBVNBEFMBT JTUP n BTPDJFEBEFDJWJMOkPnVNBHMPNFSBEPEFJOEJWrEVPT FTJN VNBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEFDMBTTFTFTFSFBMJ[BDPNPMVUBEFDMBTTFT &NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT PRVFPTUFwSJDPTEPKVTOBUVSBMJTNPDIB NBWBNEFFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[BOkPnTFOkPBTPDJFEBEFDJWJM F nQBSBTFSWJSBPTJOUFSFTTFTEFVNBEBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJTRVFP &TUBEPnJOTUJUVrEP "JOEBOBMJOIBEFSBDJPDrOJPEBTDSrUJDBTBPMJCFSBMJTNPFDP OyNJDP RVFFSBP&TUBEPOPTnDVMP9*9 -POHFEFEJGFSFODJBSTFEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMFEFTFQBSBSTF EFMB MPOHFEFTFSBFYQSFTTkPEBWPOUBEFHFSBMFEPJOUFSFTTF HFSBM P&TUBEPnBFYQSFTTkPMFHBM±KVSrEJDBFQPMJDJBM±EPT JOUFSFTTFTEFVNBDMBTTFTPDJBMQBSUJDVMBS BDMBTTFEPTQSPQSJF UgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPPVDMBTTFEPNJOBOUF &P&TUBEPOkPnVNBJNQPTJmkPEJWJOBBPTIPNFOT OFNnP SFTVMUBEPEFVNQBDUPPVDPOUSBUPTPDJBM NBTnBNBOFJSBQFMB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
VBMBDMBTTFEPNJOBOUFEFVNBnQPDBFEFVNBTPDJFEBEFEF R UFSNJOBEBTHBSBOUFTFVTJOUFSFTTFTFTVBEPNJOBmkPTPCSFP UPEPTPDJBM0&TUBEPnBFYQSFTTkPQPMrUJDBEBMVUBFDPOyNJDP TPDJBMEBTDMBTTFT BNPSUFDJEBQFMPBQBSBUPEBPSEFNFEBGPSmB Q|CMJDB/kPn NBTBQBSFDFDPNPVNQPEFSQ|CMJDPEJTUBOUFF TFQBSBEPEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJM/kPQPSBDBTP PMJCFSBMJTNPEFGJOF P&TUBEPDPNPHBSBOUJEPSEPEJSFJUPEFQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBF OkPQPSBDBTP SFEV[BDJEBEBOJBBPTEJSFJUPTEPTQSPQSJFUgSJPT QSJWBEPT $PNCBTFOBTUSpTRVFTU{FTBOUFSJPSFT PRVFTFQPEFEF EV[JSEBSFMBmkPFOUSFFDPOPNJBFQPMrUJDB 2VFBFDPOPNJBKBNBJTEFJYPVEFTFSQPMrUJDB4JNQMFTNFO UF OPDBQJUBMJTNP PWrODVMPJOUFSOPFOFDFTTgSJPFOUSFFDPOP NJBFQPMrUJDBUPSOPVTFFWJEFOUF/PFOUBOUP TFQFSHVOUBSNPT hTQFTTPBTRVFWJWFNOP&TUBEPMJCFSBMDBQJUBMJTUBTF QBSBFMBT nFWJEFOUFUBMWrODVMP DFSUBNFOUFEJSkPRVFOkP $PNP)FHFMFYQMJDBBHpOFTFEP&TUBEPNPEFSOP )FHFMFYQMJDBBHpOFTFEP&TUBEPNPEFSOPTFNSFDPSSFSh UFPSJBEPEJSFJUPOBUVSBMFEPDPOUSBUPTPDJBM1BSBFMF P&TUBEP TVSHFDPNPTVQFSBmkPSBDJPOBMEBTMJNJUBm{FTRVFCMPRVFBWBN PEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEPFTQrSJUPIVNBOPPJTPMBNFOUPEPTJOEJWr EVPTOBGBNrMJBFBTMVUBTEPTJOUFSFTTFTQSJWBEPTOBTPDJFEBEF DJWJM0&TUBEPBCTPSWFFUSBOTGPSNBBGBNrMJBFBTPDJFEBEFDJWJM OVNBUPUBMJEBEFSBDJPOBM NBJTBMUBFQFSGFJUB RVFFYQSJNFP JOUFSFTTFFBWPOUBEFHFSBJT1PSJTTP nBSFBMJ[BmkPNBJTJNQPS UBOUF±FB|MUJNB±EBSB[kPOBIJTUwSJB VNBWF[RVFTVQFSB PTQBSUJDVMBSJTNPTOVNBVOJEBEFVOJWFSTBM RVF QFMPEJSFJUP HBSBOUFBPSEFN BQB[ BNPSBMJEBEF BMJCFSEBEFFBQFSGFJmkP EPFTQrSJUPIVNBOP 0RVF.BSYRVFSEJ[FSBPBGJSNBSRVF²PTIPNFOTTkPIJT UPSJDBNFOUFEFUFSNJOBEPT³ 0TTFSFTIVNBOPT FTDSFWFN.BSYF&OHFMT EJTUJOHVFNTF EPTBOJNBJTOkPQPSRVFTFKBNEPUBEPTEFDPOTDJpODJB OFN QPSRVFTFKBNOBUVSBMNFOUFTPDJgWFJTFQPMrUJDPT NBTQPSRVF TkPDBQB[FTEFQSPEV[JSBTDPOEJm{FTEFTVBFYJTUpODJBNBUF SJBMFJOUFMFDUVBM0TTFSFTIVNBOPTTkPQSPEVUPSFTTkPPRVF QSPEV[FNFTkPDPNPQSPEV[FN"QSPEVmkPEBTDPOEJm{FT NBUFSJBJTFJOUFMFDUVBJTEBFYJTUpODJBOkPnFTDPMIJEBMJWSFNFO UFQFMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT NBTFTUgEBEBPCKFUJWBNFOUF JOEF QFOEFOUFNFOUFEFOPTTBWPOUBEF&JTQPSRVF.BSYEJ[RVFPT IPNFOTGB[FNTVBQSwQSJBIJTUwSJB NBTOkPBGB[FNFNDPO EJm{FTFTDPMIJEBTQPSFMFT4kPIJTUPSJDBNFOUFEFUFSNJOBEPT QFMBTDPOEJm{FTFNRVFQSPEV[FNTVBWJEB $PNPPDPSSFOBQSgUJDBBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIP &TTBEJWJTkP RVFDPNFmBOBGBNrMJB DPNBEJGFSFOmBTFYVBM EBTUBSFGBT QSPTTFHVFOBEJTUJOmkPFOUSFBHSJDVMUVSBFQBTUP SFJP FOUSFBNCBTFPDPNnSDJP DPOEV[JOEPhTFQBSBmkPFOUSF PDBNQPFBDJEBEF&NDBEBVNBEBTEJTUJOm{FTPQFSBNOPWBT EJWJT{FTTPDJBJTEPUSBCBMIP"EJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIPOkPn VNBTJNQMFTEJWJTkPEFUBSFGBT NBTBNBOJGFTUBmkPEBFYJTUpO DJBEBQSPQSJFEBEF PVTFKB BTFQBSBmkPFOUSFBQSPQSJFEBEF RVFnBQPTTFEBTDPOEJm{FTFEPTJOTUSVNFOUPTEPUSBCBMIP FPQSwQSJPUSBCBMIP JODJEJOEP BTFHVJS TPCSFBGPSNBEFEJT USJCVJmkPEPTQSPEVUPTEPUSBCBMIP"QSPQSJFEBEFJOUSPEV[B FYJTUpODJBEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPDPNPBMHPEJGFSFOUFEBTGPS mBTQSPEVUJWBT
/PEFDPSSFSEBIJTUwSJB DPNPTFEFOPNJOBNBTQSPQSJFEB EFTEFBDPSEPDPNPTNPEPTEFQSPEVmkP &YQMJRVFCSFWF NFOUFDBEBVNBEFMBT "QSPQSJFEBEFDPNFmBDPNPQSPQSJFEBEFUSJCBMFBTPDJF EBEFUFNBGPSNBEFVNBDPNVOJEBEFCBTFBEBOBGBNrMJB/FMB QSFWBMFDFBIJFSBSRVJBEFGJOJEBQPSUBSFGBT GVOm{FT QPEFSFT FDPOTVNP&TTBGPSNBEBQSPQSJFEBEFTFUSBOTGPSNBOVNB PVUSB BQSPQSJFEBEFFTUBUBM PVTFKB QSPQSJFEBEFEP&TUBEP DVKPEJSJHFOUFEFUFSNJOBPNPEPEFSFMBm{FTEPTTVKFJUPTDPN FMBFNDFSUPTDBTPT P&TUBEPnPQSPQSJFUgSJP|OJDPFQFSNJUF BTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOyNJDBTNFEJBOUFQBHBNFOUPEFUSJCVUPT JNQPTUPTFUBYBTFNPVUSPT P&TUBEPDFEF NFEJBOUFDFSUBT SFHSBT BQSPQSJFEBEFhTHSBOEFTGBNrMJBT RVFTFUPSOBNQSP QSJFUgSJBTQSJWBEBT"TPDJFEBEFTFEJWJEF BHPSB FOUSFTFOIP SFTFFTDSBWPT/PTHSBOEFTJNQnSJPTPSJFOUBJT PTTFOIPSFT TFPDVQBNEBHVFSSBFEBSFMJHJkPOB(SnDJBFFN3PNB UPS OBNTFDJEBEkPTFPDVQBNTFEBQPMrUJDB BMnNEFQPTTVrSFN QSJWJMnHJPTNJMJUBSFTFSFMJHJPTPTWJWFNOBTDJEBEFTFFNMVUB QFSNBOFOUFFOUSFPTRVFQFSNBOFDFSBNOPDBNQP CFNDPNP DPNPTIPNFOTMJWSFTRVFUSBCBMIBNOBTBUJWJEBEFTVSCBOBT FDPNPTFTDSBWPT"UFSDFJSBGPSNBEFQSPQSJFEBEFnBGFV EBM BQSFTFOUBOEPTFDPNPQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBEBUFSSBQFMPT TFOIPSFTFQSPQSJFEBEFEPTJOTUSVNFOUPTEFUSBCBMIPQFMPT BSUFTkPTMJWSFT NFNCSPTEBTDPSQPSBm{FTEPTCVSHPT"UFSSB nUSBCBMIBEBQPSTFSWPTEBHMFCBFBTPDJFEBEFTFFTUSVUVSB QFMBEJWJTkPFOUSFOPCSF[BGVOEJgSJBFTFSWPT OPDBNQP FBS UFTkPTMJWSFTFBQSFOEJ[FT OBDJEBEF &OUSFFMFTTVSHFVNB GJHVSBJOUFSNFEJgSJBPDPNFSDJBOUF"TMVUBTFOUSFDPNFSDJBO UFTFOPCSFT PEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEPTCVSHPT EPBSUFTBOBUP FEBBUJWJEBEFDPNFSDJBMDPOEV[FNhNVEBOmBRVFDPOIFDF NPTBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDBQJUBMJTUB&TTBOPWBGPSNBEF QSPQSJFEBEFQPTTVJDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTJOnEJUBTFnVNBWFSEBEFJSB SFWPMVmkPFDPOyNJDB QPSRVFSFBMJ[BBTFQBSBmkPJOUFHSBMFO USFQSPQSJFUgSJPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPFGPSmBTQSPEVUJWBT JTUPn FOUSFBTDPOEJm{FTFPTJOTUSVNFOUPTEFUSBCBMIPFP QSwQSJPUSBCBMIP0TQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTQPTTVFNNFJPT DPOEJm{FTFJOTUSVNFOUPTEPUSBCBMIP QPTTVFNPDPOUSPMFEB EJTUSJCVJmkPFEPDPOTVNPEPTQSPEVUPT/PPVUSPQPMPTPDJBM FODPOUSBNTFPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTDPNPNBTTBEFBTTBMBSJBEPT JOUFJSBNFOUFFYQSPQSJBEBEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP QPTTVJOEP BQFOBTBGPSmBEPUSBCBMIP DPMPDBEBhEJTQPTJmkPEPTQSPQSJF UgSJPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP OPNFSDBEPEFDPNQSBFWFOEB EBNkPEFPCSB 2VFnNBUFSJBMJTNPIJTUwSJDP 1PSRVF²NBUFSJBMJTNP³ & QPSRVF²IJTUwSJDP³ cQPSBGJSNBSRVFBTPDJFEBEFTFDPOTUJUVJBQBSUJSEFDPOEJ m{FTNBUFSJBJTEFQSPEVmkPFEBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIPRVF BTNVEBOmBTIJTUwSJDBTTkPEFUFSNJOBEBTQFMBTNPEJGJDBm{FT OBRVFMBTDPOEJm{FTNBUFSJBJTFOBRVFMBEJWJTkPEPUSBCBMIP FRVFBDPOTDJpODJBIVNBOBnEFUFSNJOBEBBQFOTBSBTJEFJBT RVFQFOTBQPSDBVTBEBTDPOEJm{FTNBUFSJBJTJOTUJUVrEBTQFMB TPDJFEBEFRVFPQFOTBNFOUPEF.BSYF&OHFMTnDIBNBEPEF NBUFSJBMJTNPIJTUwSJDP.BUFSJBMJTNPQPSRVFTPNPTPRVFBT DPOEJm{FTNBUFSJBJT BTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTEFQSPEVmkP OPTEF UFSNJOBNBTFSFBQFOTBS&IJTUwSJDPQPSRVFBTPDJFEBEFFB QPMrUJDBOkPTVSHFNEFEFDSFUPTEJWJOPTOFNOBTDFNEBPSEFN OBUVSBM NBTEFQFOEFNEBBmkPDPODSFUBEPTTFSFTIVNBOPT OPUFNQP &NRVFNPNFOUPTVSHFQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[PDPODFJUPEF NBUFSJBMJTNP
-,,
Manual do Professor
"OPmkPEFNBUFSJBMJTNPTVSHF QFMBQSJNFJSBWF[ OBGJMPTP GJBHSFHB"TFTDPMBTGJMPTwGJDBTFTUPJDBFFQJDVSJTUBBGJSNBSBN DPOUSB1MBUkP "SJTUwUFMFTFPTOFPQMBUyOJDPT RVFTwFYJTUFN DPSQPTPVBNBUnSJB0TFQJDVSJTUBT SFUPNBOEPJEFJBTEPTQSn TPDSgUJDPTBUPNJTUBT BGJSNBSBNRVFPFTQrSJUPFSBgUPNP NB UFSJBM TVUJMFEJgGBOP/PTTnDVMPT97**F97*** SFBHJOEPDPOUSBP FTQJSJUVBMJTNPDSJTUkP NVJUPTGJMwTPGPTTFEJTTFSBNNBUFSJBMJT UBT RVFSFOEPDPNJTTPEJ[FSRVFTwFYJTUFBOBUVSF[BFRVFFTUB nNBUnSJB$PNPWJWFNPTFNTPDJFEBEFTDSJTUkT PNBUFSJBMJTNP TFNQSFGPJDPOTJEFSBEPCMBTGpNJBFIFSFTJBQPSRVFOFHBBFYJT UpODJBEFQVSPTFTQrSJUPT BJNPSUBMJEBEFEBBMNBFBTFQBSBmkP FOUSF%FVTFOBUVSF[B0TFOTPDPNVNTPDJBM BCTPSWFOEPB DSrUJDBFTQJSJUVBMJTUB GBMBFN²NBUFSJBMJTNP³QBSBSFGFSJSTFB QFTTPBTRVFTwBDSFEJUBNOFTUBWJEBUFSSFOB FHPrTUBTFBNCJ DJPTBT TFNQSFPDVQBmkPDPNBTBMWBmkPFUFSOBFDPNPCFNF BTBMWBmkPEPQSwYJNP0²NBUFSJBMJTUB³nPRVFHPTUBEFQSB [FSFT SJRVF[BTFMVYP SJHPSPTBNFOUF QPSUBOUP EFWFSTFJB EJ[FSRVFPTCVSHVFTFTTkP²NBUFSJBMJTUBT³ FNCPSBTFEJHBN DSJTUkPTFTQJSJUVBMJTUBT 2VBOEP.BSYGBMBFNNBUFSJBMJTNP B NBUnSJBhRVBMTFSFGFSFOkPTkPPTDPSQPTGrTJDPT PTgUPNPT PTTFSFTOBUVSBJT FTJNBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTEFQSPEVmkPFDPOy NJDB4FVNBUFSJBMJTNPWJTBPQPSTFBPJEFBMJTNPFTQJSJUVBMJTUB IFHFMJBOP QBSBPRVBMBGPSmBRVFNPWFBIJTUwSJBnBJEFJB P FTQrSJUP BDPOTDJpODJB 0RVFTJHOJGJDBEJ[FSRVFPNBUFSJBMJTNPIJTUwSJDPnEJB MnUJDP 4JHOJGJDBRVFBIJTUwSJBOkPnVNQSPHSFTTPMJOFBSFDPOUr OVP VNBTFRVpODJBEFDBVTBTFFGFJUPT NBTVNQSPDFTTPEF USBOTGPSNBm{FTTPDJBJTEFUFSNJOBEBTQFMBTDPOUSBEJm{FTFOUSF PTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPFBTGPSmBTQSPEVUJWBT"MVUBEFDMBTTFT FYQSJNFUBJTDPOUSBEJm{FTFnPNPUPSEBIJTUwSJB0NBUFSJBMJT NPIJTUwSJDPnEJBMnUJDPKVTUBNFOUFQPSBGJSNBSRVFPQSPDFTTP IJTUwSJDPnNPWJEPQPSDPOUSBEJm{FTTPDJBJT &YQMJRVFPDPODFJUPNBSYJTUBEFBMJFOBmkP /PDBQJUBMJTNP PTUSBCBMIBEPSFTQSPEV[FNUPEPTPTPC KFUPTFYJTUFOUFTOPNFSDBEPBQwTIBWpMPTQSPEV[JEP FOUSF HBNOPTBPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP NFEJBOUF VNTBMgSJPPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPWFOEFN BTNFSDBEPSJBTBPTDPNFSDJBOUFT RVFBTDPMPDBNOPNFSDBEP EFDPOTVNPFPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTPVQSPEVUPSFTEFTTBTNFSDB EPSJBT RVBOEPWkPBPNFSDBEPEFDPOTVNP OkPDPOTFHVFN DPNQSgMBT0VTFKBPTQSPEVUPSFTEBTNFSDBEPSJBTPMIBNPT QSFmPT DPOUBNPEJOIFJSPFWPMUBNQBSBDBTBEFNkPTWB[JBT DPNPTFPQSFmPEBTNFSDBEPSJBTFYJTUJTTFQPSTJNFTNPFDPNP TFFMBTFTUJWFTTFNhWFOEBQPSRVFTVSHJSBNEPOBEBFBMHVnN BTEFDJEJVWFOEFS&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT FNCPSBPTEJGFSFOUFT USBCBMIBEPSFTTBJCBNRVFQSPEV[JSBNBTEJGFSFOUFTNFSDBEP SJBT OkPQFSDFCFNRVF DPNPDMBTTFTPDJBM QSPEV[JSBNUPEBT FMBT0TUSBCBMIBEPSFTTFWFFNDPNPJOEJWrEVPTJTPMBEPTRVF DPOIFDFNTFVQSwQSJPUSBCBMIP NBTJHOPSBNPTUSBCBMIPTEBT PVUSBTDBUFHPSJBTEFUSBCBMIBEPSFT JTUPn OkPTFQFSDFCFN DPNPGPSNBOEPVNBDMBTTFTPDJBM|OJDB QSPEVUPSBEFUPEBT BTNFSDBEPSJBTFYJTUFOUFTOPNFSDBEP1PSFTTFNPUJWP RVFN QSPEV[JVUFDJEPOkPQFSDFCFRVFGPJUBNCnNVNUSBCBMIBEPS RVFQSPEV[JVVNWFrDVMPFRVFVNPVUSPQSPEV[JVVNBMJNFO UP1PSOkPTFQFSDFCFSFNDPNPVNBDMBTTFTPDJBM FTJNDPNP JOEJWrEVPTJTPMBEPT OkPTwOkPTFSFDPOIFDFNDPNPBVUPSFT PVQSPEVUPSFTEBTNFSDBEPSJBT NBTBJOEBBDSFEJUBNRVFWB MFNPQSFmPRVFDVTUBNOPNFSDBEPEFDPOTVNPFRVFOkP QPEFNUpMBTQPSRVFFMBTWBMFNNBJTEPRVFFMFT1PSOkPTF QFSDFCFSFNDPNPDMBTTFTPDJBM OkPTFSFDPOIFDFNDPNPQSP
-,-
EVUPSFTEBSJRVF[BFEBTDPJTBT4FNTBCFS WJWFNBFYQFSJpODJB EBBMJFOBmkPFDPOyNJDB JTUPn BDSFOmBEFRVFBTNFSDBEPSJBT TkPDPJTBTRVFFYJTUFNJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEPUSBCBMIPQBSB QSPEV[JMBTFRVFQPTTVFNVNWBMPSFNTJNFTNBT WBMPSRVF BQBSFDFOPQSFmPRVFMIFTGPJEBEP 2VFnJEFPMPHJB TFHVOEP.BSY "JEFPMPHJB QBSB.BSY nVNGFOyNFOPIJTUwSJDPTPDJBMEF DPSSFOUFEPNPEPEFQSPEVmkPFDPOyNJDPcVNBSFEFEFJNB HFOTFEFJEFJBTPVVNDPOKVOUPEFSFQSFTFOUBm{FTTPCSFPT TFSFTIVNBOPTFTVBTSFMBm{FT TPCSFBTDPJTBT TPCSFPCFNF PNBM PKVTUPFPJOKVTUP PTCPOTFPTNBVTDPTUVNFT FUD &NRVFNFEJEBBJEFPMPHJBnQPTUBBTFSWJmPEBDMBTTFEP NJOBOUFOVNBTPDJFEBEF 0HSVQPQFOTBOUF PTJOUFMFDUVBJT EFVNBTPDJFEBEF QPS QFSUFODFShDMBTTFEPNJOBOUFPVQPSFTUBSVOJEPBFMBQPSNFJP EBFEVDBmkPFTQFDJBMJ[BEB QFOTBDPNBTJEFJBTEPTEPNJOBO UFTKVMHB QPSnN RVFUBJTJEFJBTTkPWFSEBEFJSBTFNTJNFTNBT FUSBOTGPSNBBTJEFJBTEFVNBDMBTTFTPDJBMEFUFSNJOBEBFN JEFJBTVOJWFSTBJTFOFDFTTgSJBT WgMJEBTQBSBBTPDJFEBEFJOUFJ SB$PNPPHSVQPQSPEVUPSEFJEFJBT PTJEFwMPHPT EPNJOBB DPOTDJpODJBTPDJBM UFNPQPEFSEFUSBOTNJUJSBTJEFJBTEPNJ OBOUFTQBSBUPEBBTPDJFEBEF BUSBWnTEBSFMJHJkP EBTBSUFT EBFTDPMB EBDJpODJB EBGJMPTPGJB EPTDPTUVNFT EBTMFJTFEP EJSFJUP NPMEBOEPBDPOTDJpODJBEFUPEBTBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJTF VOJGPSNJ[BOEPPQFOTBNFOUPEFUPEBTBTDMBTTFT &NRVFNPNFOUPEBIJTUwSJBTVSHFBJEFPMPHJB /PNPNFOUPFNRVFOkPBQBSFDFTPCBGPSNBEPNJUP EBSFMJHJkPFEBUFPMPHJB"JEFPMPHJBQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUBTVSHF RVBOEP OPMVHBSEFEJWJOEBEFT FODPOUSBNPTJEFJBTDPNPDBV TBTEBTPDJFEBEFFEBTSFMBm{FTTPDJBJTPIPNFN BQgUSJB BGBNrMJB BFTDPMB PQSPHSFTTP BDJpODJB P&TUBEP PCFN P KVTUP FUD 1PSRVFQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFBJEFPMPHJBnVNGFOyNFOP NPEFSOP $PNBJEFPMPHJB BFYQMJDBmkPTPCSFBPSJHFNEPTIPNFOT EBTPDJFEBEFFEBQPMrUJDBFODPOUSBTFOBTBm{FTIVNBOBT FO UFOEJEBTDPNPNBOJGFTUBmkPEBDPOTDJpODJBPVEBTJEFJBT"T TJN QPSFYFNQMP KVMHBSRVFP&TUBEPOkPTFPSJHJOBEBWPOUBEF EF%FVT NBTEBTJEFJBTEFFTUBEPEFOBUVSF[B EJSFJUPOBUVSBM DPOUSBUPTPDJBMFEJSFJUPDJWJM nTVQPSRVFBDPOTDJpODJBIVNBOB JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBTDPOEJm{FTIJTUwSJDBTNBUFSJBJT QFO TPVOFTTBTJEFJBT KVMHPVBTDPSSFUBTFQBTTPVBBHJSQPSFMBT DSJBOEPBSFBMJEBEFEFTJHOBEBFSFQSFTFOUBEBQPSFMBT 2VBMnBGVOmkPQSJNPSEJBMEBJEFPMPHJB "JEFPMPHJBPGFSFDFBVNBTPDJFEBEFEJWJEJEBFNDMBTTFT TPDJBJTBOUBHyOJDBT FRVFWJWFNOBGPSNBEBMVUBEFDMBTTFT VNBJNBHFNRVFQFSNJUBBVOJGJDBmkPFBJEFOUJGJDBmkPTPDJBM± VNBMrOHVB VNBSFMJHJkP VNBSBmB VNBOBmkP VNBQgUSJB VN &TUBEP VNBIVNBOJEBEF NFTNPTDPTUVNFT"TTJN BGVOmkP QSJNPSEJBMEBJEFPMPHJBnPDVMUBSBPSJHFNEBTPDJFEBEF SFMB m{FTEFQSPEVmkPDPNPSFMBm{FTFOUSFNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPF GPSmBTQSPEVUJWBTTPCBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIP
EJTTJNVMBS BQSFTFOmBEBMVUBEFDMBTTFT EPNrOJPFFYQMPSBmkPEPTOkP QSPQSJFUgSJPTQFMPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEV mkP
OFHBSBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTTPDJBJT TkPJNBHJOBEBTDPNPTF GPTTFNDPOTFRVpODJBEFUBMFOUPTEJGFSFOUFT EBQSFHVJmBPVEB EJTDJQMJOBMBCPSJPTB FPGFSFDFSBJNBHFNJMVTwSJBEBDPNVOJEB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
EF P&TUBEP PSJHJOBEBEPDPOUSBUPTPDJBMFOUSFIPNFOTMJWSFTF JHVBJT"JEFPMPHJBnBMwHJDBEBEPNJOBmkPTPDJBMFQPMrUJDB 1PSRVFQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVF FNSFMBmkPBPUSBCBMIP FYJTUF VNBDPOUSBEJmkPFOUSFPRVFPQSPUFTUBOUJTNP PDBQJUBMJT NPFPMJCFSBMJTNPQSFDPOJ[BNFBQSgYJTMFWBEBBFGFJUP QFMBQPMrUJDBOPTnDVMP9*9 1PSRVF BQFTBSEBWBMPSJ[BmkPEPUSBCBMIPFBQFTBSEBJEFP MPHJBEPEJSFJUPOBUVSBM RVFBGJSNBTFSFNUPEPTPTIPNFOT MJWSFTFJHVBJT OPNPNFOUPEFEFGJOJSRVFNUFNEJSFJUPBP QPEFSQPMrUJDP BDMBTTFEPNJOBOUFFTRVFDFB²EJHOJEBEFEP USBCBMIP³FEFDMBSBPQPEFSQPMrUJDPVNEJSFJUPFYDMVTJWPEPT IPNFOTJOEFQFOEFOUFTPVMJWSFT&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BDJEBEB OJBQFSUFODFBPTRVFOkPQSFDJTBNUSBCBMIBS%PQPOUPEFWJTUB NPSBM WBMPSJ[BTFPUSBCBMIP NBT EPQPOUPEFWJTUBQPMrUJDP FMFOkPUFNWBMPSBMHVN 2VFnUSBCBMIP TFHVOEPBTUFTFTNBSYJTUBT 0USBCBMIPnBSFMBmkPEPTTFSFTIVNBOPTDPNBOBUVSF[B FFOUSFTJ OBQSPEVmkPEBTDPOEJm{FTEFTVBFYJTUpODJB1FMP USBCBMIP PTTFSFTIVNBOPTOkPDPOTPNFNEJSFUBNFOUFBOB UVSF[BOFNTFBQSPQSJBNEJSFUBNFOUFEFMB NBTBUSBOTGPSNBN FNBMHPIVNBOPUBNCnN1FMPUSBCBMIP PTTFSFTIVNBOPTFT UFOEFNTVBIVNBOJEBEFhOBUVSF[BcOFTTFTFOUJEPRVFPUSB CBMIPnQSgYJTBmkPFNRVFPBHFOUFFPQSPEVUPEFTVBBmkP TkPJEpOUJDPT QPJTPBHFOUFTFFYUFSJPSJ[BOBBmkPQSPEVUPSBF OPQSPEVUP BPNFTNPUFNQPRVFFTUFJOUFSJPSJ[BVNBDBQBDJ EBEFDSJBEPSBIVNBOB PVBTVCKFUJWJEBEF %FRVFNBOFJSBBJEFPMPHJBVUJMJ[BBJEFJBEFUSBCBMIP %FEVBTNBOFJSBT"QSJNFJSBnPFNQSFHPEFTTBJEFJBQBSB MFHJUJNBSBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDBQJUBMJTUB"TFHVOEBnTFV VTPQBSBMFHJUJNBSBJEFJBEFDPOUSBUPTPDJBMFEFDPOUSBUPEF USBCBMIP $PNP.BSYWpBSFMBmkPFOUSFPDBQJUBMJTNPFPUSBCBMIB EPS
TFBDVNVMBWBNQBSBIBWFSDSFTDJNFOUPFBD|NVMPFSBQSFDJTP QJMIBSPVSPVCBSBSJRVF[BEFVNPVUSPIPNFN EFVNPVUSP SFJOP EFVNPVUSPQPWP0DBQJUBM QPSnN UFNBQFDVMJBSJEBEF EFDSFTDFS EFBDVNVMBSTFFSFQSPEV[JSTF1FMBQSJNFJSBWF[ OBIJTUwSJBTVSHFVNBGPSNBEBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEBDBQB[EF BVNFOUBSFEFTFOWPMWFSTF &YQMJRVFBBGJSNBmkPEF.BSYTFHVOEPBRVBMPWBMPSEBT NFSDBEPSJBTOkPnEFUFSNJOBEPQFMPTFVVTP NBTQFMPTFV WBMPSEFUSPDB cRVF FYQMJDB.BSY PMVDSPOkPWFNEBDPNFSDJBMJ[BmkPEPT QSPEVUPTQBSBPDPOTVNP NBTOBTDFOBQSwQSJBFTGFSBEBQSP EVmkP JTUPn SFTVMUBEBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIPFEPUFNQP TPDJBMNFOUFOFDFTTgSJPQBSBQSPEV[JSBMHVNBDPJTB&NPVUSBT QBMBWSBT .BSYRVFSEJ[FSRVFPWBMPSEBTNFSDBEPSJBTnEFUFS NJOBEPQFMPDVTUPUPUBMQBSBQSPEV[JSVNBNFSDBEPSJB DVTUP EBNBUnSJBQSJNB EPTJOTUSVNFOUPTEFUSBCBMIP EPTDPOIFDJ NFOUPTUnDOJDPTFEPTTBMgSJPT
DVTUPDBMDVMBEPDPNCBTFOP UFNQPTPDJBMNFOUFOFDFTTgSJPQBSBQSPEV[JMB IPSBTEFUSB CBMIP IPSBTEFUSBOTQPSUF IPSBTEFEFTDBOTPQBSBSFQPTJmkP EBTGPSmBT IPSBTOFDFTTgSJBTQBSBBFYUSBmkPEBNBUnSJBQSJNB FTFVUSBOTQPSUF IPSBTOFDFTTgSJBTQBSBBGBCSJDBmkPEBTNg RVJOBTFPVUSPTJOTUSVNFOUPTEFUSBCBMIP FUD 2VFQBQFMPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTBTTBMBSJBEPTEFTFNQFOIBN OPNPEPEFQSPEVmkPDBQJUBMJTUB TFHVOEP.BSY 1BSB.BSY BTNFSDBEPSJBTTkPQSPEV[JEBTQFMPTUSBCBMIB EPSFTBTTBMBSJBEPT RVFWFOEFNTVBGPSmBEFUSBCBMIPBPTQSP QSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP 2VFnPTBMgSJP OBDPODFQmkPNBSYJTUB cPRVFnQBHPBPUSBCBMIBEPSQBSBHBSBOUJSBTVCTJTUpODJB FBSFQSPEVmkPEFTVBGPSmBEFUSBCBMIP BMJNFOUBmkP NPSBEJB WFTUVgSJPFDPOEJm{FTQBSBQSPDSJBS 2VBOUPWBMFBNFSDBEPSJBUSBCBMIBEPS
&NCPSBBJEFPMPHJBEPTEPNJOBOUFTEJTTJNVMFFTTBDPOEJ mkP PTJOUFSFTTFTEFBNCPTOkPTkPPTNFTNPT FTJNDPOUSg SJPT1PSFYFNQMP BJEFPMPHJBEJ[BPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTRVFTkP MJWSFT NBTOkPUpNMJCFSEBEFQBSBFTDPMIFSPPGrDJP QBSBEFGJOJS PTBMgSJP QBSBGJYBSBKPSOBEBEFUSBCBMIP"JEFPMPHJBMIFTEJ[ RVFUPEPTPTIPNFOTTkPJHVBJT NBTQFSDFCFNRVFOkPQPEFN UFSNPSBEJB WFTUVgSJP USBOTQPSUF FEVDBmkP TB|EFDPNPPT TFVTQBUS{FT
"FDPOPNJBQPMrUJDBBGJSNBRVFPTBMgSJPDPSSFTQPOEFBPT DVTUPTFBPQSFmPEBQSPEVmkPEFVNBNFSDBEPSJB$BMDVMBTF BTTJN PRVFPUSBCBMIBEPSQSFDJTBQBSBNBOUFSTFFSFQSPEV [JSTF EFEV[JOEPTFFTTFNPOUBOUFEPDVTUPUPUBMEBQSPEV mkPFEFUFSNJOBOEPPTBMgSJP/BSFBMJEBEF QPSnN OkPnPRVF PDPSSF1BSBQSPEV[JSVNBEFUFSNJOBEBNFSDBEPSJB VNUSBCB MIBEPSQSFDJTBEFVNDFSUPO|NFSPEFIPSBTFTFVTBMgSJPTFSg DBMDVMBEPBQBSUJSEFTTFUFNQPFOUSFUBOUP EFGBUP PUSBCBMIB EPSUSBCBMIBEVSBOUFNVJUPNBJTUFNQPF DPOTFRVFOUFNFOUF QSPEV[PEPCSPEFNFSDBEPSJBTFTUBT QPSnN OkPTkPDPNQV UBEBTQBSBPDgMDVMPEPTBMgSJP QPJTFTUFDPSSFTQPOEFSgBQFOBT hNFSDBEPSJBRVFPUSBCBMIBEPSQSPEV[FNVNDFSUPO|NFSPEF IPSBT*TTPTJHOJGJDBRVFPUSBCBMIBEPSSFBMJ[BNBJTUSBCBMIPEP RVFPTBMgSJPMIFQBHB PVTFKB IgVNUSBCBMIPFYDFEFOUFOkP QBHP JTUPn OkPDPCFSUPQFMPTBMgSJP&TTFQSPDFEJNFOUPPDPS SFFNUPEBJOE|TUSJB OBBHSJDVMUVSBFOPDPNnSDJP EFNBOFJSB RVFBNBTTBTPDJBMEPTTBMgSJPTEFUPEPTPTBTTBMBSJBEPTDPS SFTQPOEFBQFOBTBVNBQBSUFEPUFNQPTPDJBMNFOUFOFDFTTgSJP QBSBBQSPEVmkPEBTNFSDBEPSJBT PVTFKB OkPDPSSFTQPOEFh UPUBMJEBEFEFUFNQPEFUSBCBMIPEJTQFOEJEPSFBMNFOUFQFMPT USBCBMIBEPSFT RVFQSPEV[FNNBJTEPRVFPTBMgSJPMIFTQBHB
2VFJEFJBPDPODFJUPEFDBQJUBMJOBVHVSBOBIJTUwSJB
2VFnNBJTWBMJB
"OUFTEPDPODFJUPEFDBQJUBM BTPVUSBTGPSNBTEFQSPQSJF EBEFEBWBNSJRVF[BTBPTTFVTQSPQSJFUgSJPT NBTOkPEBWBN MVDSP0VTFKB BTPVUSBTGPSNBTEFSJRVF[BOkPDSFTDJBNOFN
$PNQMFNFOUBOEPBSFTQPTUBEBRVFTUkPBOUFSJPS NBJTWBMJB nPWBMPSEPUSBCBMIPFYDFEFOUFOkPQBHPcBNBJTWBMJBRVFGPS NBPMVDSPFOkPBDPNFSDJBMJ[BmkPEPTQSPEVUPT&nFTTFMVDSP
/VNQSJNFJSPNPNFOUP PRVBESPPGFSFDJEPQPS.BSYnQFT TJNJTUB&NCPSBPTFSIVNBOPTFKBQSgYJTFFTUBTFKBPUSBCBMIP PQSPDFTTPIJTUwSJDPEFTGJHVSBPUSBCBMIPFPUSBCBMIBEPS BMJFOB PTUSBCBMIBEPSFT RVF OkPTFQFSDFCFOEPDPNPVNBDMBTTFTP DJBM OkPTFSFDPOIFDFNOPTQSPEVUPTEFTFVTUSBCBMIPT"JEFP MPHJBCVSHVFTB QPSTVBWF[ DSJBBJEFJBEF)PNFN6OJWFSTBM MJWSFFJHVBM EgMIFPSPTUPEPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPT EFQSPEVmkPFQFSTVBEFPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTEFRVFUBNCnNTkP FTTF)PNFN6OJWFSTBM FNCPSBWJWBNNJTFSBWFMNFOUF 2VFDPOUSBEJm{FTFYJTUFNFOUSFPRVFQSFDPOJ[BNBJEFP MPHJBCVSHVFTBFPDPUJEJBOPEPUSBCBMIBEPS
-,.
Manual do Professor
RVFTFSgJOWFTUJEPOBQSPEVmkPEFNFSDBEPSJBTQBSBBVNFOUBS PDBQJUBM 1PSRVFOkPTFQPEFDPOGVOEJSBUFPSJBNBSYJTUBDPNBT UFPSJBTVUwQJDBTFMJCFSUgSJBT "UFPSJBNBSYJTUBEBSFWPMVmkPOkPTFDPOGVOEFDPNBTUFP SJBTVUwQJDBTFMJCFSUgSJBTQPSRVFOkPTFCBTFJBOBNJTnSJB OB JOGFMJDJEBEFFOBJOKVTUJmBBRVFFTUkPTVCNFUJEPTPTUSBCBMIB EPSFT NBTTFGVOEBNFOUBOBBOgMJTFDJFOUrGJDBEBTPDJFEBEF DBQJUBMJTUB OBT²MFJT³EPDBQJUBMPVEBFDPOPNJBQPMrUJDB FOFMB FODPOUSBBTNBOFJSBTQFMBTRVBJTPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT DPOTDJFO UFTFPSHBOJ[BEPT SFBMJ[BNTVBQSwQSJBFNBODJQBmkP1PSJTTP .BSYF&OHFMTEJTTFSBNRVFBFNBODJQBmkPEPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT UFSgEFTFSPCSBIJTUwSJDBEPTQSwQSJPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT &NRVFDPOTJTUFBTPDJFEBEFDPNVOJTUB TFHVOEP.BSY F&OHFMT "TPDJFEBEFDPNVOJTUB SFTVMUBEPEBQSgYJTSFWPMVDJPOgSJB EBDMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSB TFSJBVNBTPDJFEBEFTFNQSPQSJFEBEF QSJWBEBEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP TFNFYQMPSBmkPEPUSBCBMIP TFNDMBTTFTTPDJBJT TFNQPEFSFTUBUBM MJWSFFJHVBMJUgSJB/VN DnMFCSFQBOGMFUPQPMrUJDP P.BOJGFTUP$PNVOJTUB RVFDPODMB NBWBPTQSPMFUgSJPTEPNVOEPUPEPBTFVOJSFBTFPSHBOJ[BSQB SBBMPOHBMVUBDPOUSBPDBQJUBM .BSYF&OHFMTDPOTJEFSBWBNRVF BGBTFGJOBMEPDPNCBUFQSPMFUgSJPTFSJBBSFWPMVmkPFRVFFTUB BOUFTEFDIFHBShTPDJFEBEFDPNVOJTUB UFSJBEFEFNPMJSPBQB SBUPFTUBUBM KVSrEJDP CVSPDSgUJDP QPMJDJBMFNJMJUBS CVSHVpT 0RVFTJHOJGJDBBFYQSFTTkP²EJUBEVSBEPQSPMFUBSJBEP³ /FTTBFYQSFTTkP BQBMBWSBEJUBEVSBGPJFYUSBrEBEPWPDB CVMgSJPQPMrUJDPEPTSPNBOPT6NBEJUBEVSB OBMJOHVBHFNFOB QPMrUJDBSPNBOBT TJHOJGJDBWBVNQPEFSEFEVSBmkPEFUFSNJOBEB PVEFDVSUBEVSBmkP/BQFSTQFDUJWBEF.BSYF&OHFMT BEJUB EVSBEPQSPMFUBSJBEPTFSJBVNCSFWFQFSrPEPEFUFNQPFNRVF OkPFYJTUJOEPBJOEBBTPDJFEBEFTFN&TUBEPFKgOkPFYJTUJOEPP &TUBEPCVSHVpT PTQSPMFUgSJPTHPWFSOBSJBNOPTFOUJEPEFEFT GB[FSUPEPTPTNFDBOJTNPTFDPOyNJDPTFQPMrUJDPTSFTQPOTg WFJTQFMBFYJTUpODJBEFDMBTTFTTPDJBJTF QPSUBOUP DBVTBEPSFT EBFYQMPSBmkPTPDJBM4PNFOUFEFQPJTEFEFNPMJEBBFTUSVUVSB FDPOyNJDBDBQJUBMJTUBFBTVQFSFTUSVUVSBQPMrUJDBFKVSrEJDBEP &TUBEPDBQJUBMJTUBGJOEBSJBBEJUBEVSBEPQSPMFUBSJBEPFUFSJBJOr DJPBTPDJFEBEFDPNVOJTUB 1PSRVF.BSYDPOTJEFSBWBRVFBSFWPMVmkPDPNVOJTUBTFSJB B|MUJNBSFWPMVmkPQPQVMBS 1PSRVFBCPMJSJBBDBVTBEFUPEBTBTSFWPMVm{FTRVFBTBO UFSJPSFTOkPIBWJBNDPOTFHVJEPBCPMJSBQSPQSJFEBEFQSJWBEB EPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP4wBTTJNPUSBCBMIPQPEFSJBTFSWFSEB EFJSBNFOUFQSgYJTIVNBOBDSJBEPSB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=oatlane j_e]olkhpe_]o`k o_qhkTT 1PSRVFB3FWPMVmkP3VTTBEFDPOUSBSJBWBBMwHJDBPS HiOJDBEBTUFTFTNBSYJTUBT 1PSRVF.BSYKVMHBSBRVFBSFWPMVmkPQSPMFUgSJBTwQPEFSJB SFBMJ[BSTFRVBOEPBTDPOUSBEJm{FTJOUFSOBTBPDBQJUBMJTNPFT HPUBTTFNBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTFDPOyNJDBTFQPMrUJDBTEBCVSHVF TJBFPQSPMFUBSJBEP QPSNFJPEBSFWPMVmkP JOTUBVSBTTFBOPWB TPDJFEBEFDPNVOJTUB&NUFSNPTNBSYJTUBT BSFWPMVmkPQSPMFUg SJBEFWFSJBBDPOUFDFSOPTQBrTFTEFDBQJUBMJTNPBWBOmBEP DPNP
-,/
B*OHMBUFSSB B'SBOmB B"MFNBOIB%FGBUP FSBFTTFODJBMQBSBB UFPSJBEBQSgYJTSFWPMVDJPOgSJBPQMFOPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEPDB QJUBMJTNP QPJTJTTPTJHOJGJDBWBRVFBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBFDPOyNJDB PBWBOmPUFDOPMwHJDPFPHSBVEFPSHBOJ[BmkPEBDMBTTFUSBCB MIBEPSBQSFQBSBSJBNBHSBOEFNVEBOmBIJTUwSJDB/kPFSBDPO DFCrWFM QPSUBOUP BSFWPMVmkPOB3|TTJB RVFWJWJBTPCP"OUJHP 3FHJNF BNPOBSRVJBQPSEJSFJUPEJWJOP BCTPMVUBPVD[BSJTUB
FSBNBKPSJUBSJBNFOUFQSnDBQJUBMJTUB DPNQFRVFOPEFTFOWPMWJ NFOUPEPDBQJUBMJTNPFNBMHVOTDFOUSPTVSCBOPT QSPNPWJEP OkPQFMBCVSHVFTJB RVBTFJOFYJTUFOUF
NBTQFMPQSwQSJP&TUBEP FQFMPDBQJUBMFYUFSOP JOHMpT GSBODpTFBMFNkP
TFNGPSUFDPOT DJpODJBFPSHBOJ[BmkPQSPMFUgSJBT 2VFNGPJPTVKFJUPEB3FWPMVmkP3VTTB VNBWF[RVFBDMBTTF QSPMFUgSJBPSHBOJ[BEBOB3|TTJBFSBRVBTFJOFYJTUFOUF /BTDJSDVOTUiODJBTSVTTBT PHSBOEFTVKFJUPSFWPMVDJPOgSJP OkPQyEFTFSBDMBTTFQSPMFUgSJBPSHBOJ[BEB RVBTFJOFYJTUFOUF
NBTUFWFEFTFSVNBWBOHVBSEBQPMrUJDB MJEFSBEBQPSJOUFMFD UVBJTBDPTUVNBEPThTMVUBTDMBOEFTUJOBT P1BSUJEP#PMDIFWJRVF PVBGSBmkPNBKPSJUgSJBEP1BSUJEP4PDJBM%FNPDSBUB3VTTP RVF JSJBUPSOBSTFP1BSUJEP$PNVOJTUB3VTTP 2VFEJGJDVMEBEFTFOGSFOUPVB3FWPMVmkPEF0VUVCSP "TEJGJDVMEBEFTQSFWJTrWFJTRVFUPEBSFWPMVmkPDPNVOJTUB FOGSFOUBSJB BSFBmkPNJMJUBSFFDPOyNJDBEPDBQJUBM OBGPS NBEFHVFSSBDJWJMFEFCPJDPUFFDPOyNJDPJOUFSOBDJPOBM B FYJTUpODJBEB1SJNFJSB(VFSSB.VOEJBM RVFOkPTwEFQBVQFSPV BQSFDgSJBFDPOPNJBSVTTBNBTUBNCnNQFSNJUJVRVFPTQPEF SFTDBQJUBMJTUBTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTFOWJBTTFNUSPQBTQBSBBVYJMJBSB DPOUSBSSFWPMVmkP PDIBNBEP&YnSDJUPEPT#SBODPT RVFDPNCB UJBPFYnSDJUPSFWPMVDJPOgSJPPVP&YnSDJUP7FSNFMIP PGSBDBT TPEBSFWPMVmkPDPNVOJTUBBMFNk FN EBRVBMTFFTQFSBWB OkPTwBQPJPQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTPDJFEBEFTPDJBMJTUB SVTTB NBTUBNCnNRVFGPTTFPFTUPQJNEBSFWPMVmkPQSPMFUgSJB NVOEJBM BBVTpODJBEFGPSUFDPOTDJpODJBQPMrUJDBFPSHBOJ[B mkPPQFSgSJBTOVNQBrTNBKPSJUBSJBNFOUFDBNQPOpTFOPRVBM BTBUJWJEBEFTQPMrUJDBTUJOIBNTJEPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFPCSBEF HSVQPTDMBOEFTUJOPT GPSNBEPTTPCSFUVEPQPSJOUFMFDUVBJTFFT UVEBOUFT BBVTpODJBEFFDPOPNJBDBQJUBMJTUBEFTFOWPMWJEB RVFIPVWFTTFQSFQBSBEPBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBFDPOyNJDBFBPSHB OJ[BmkPTPDJPQPMrUJDBQBSBBOPWBTPDJFEBEF 2VFFSBNPTTPWJFUFT &SBNPTDPOTFMIPTQPQVMBSFTEFPQFSgSJPT DBNQPOFTFTF TPMEBEPT RVFIBWJBNTFPSHBOJ[BEPQBSBSFBMJ[BSPBVUPHPWFS OPEFVNBTPDJFEBEFTFN&TUBEP0TTPWJFUFTMPHPFOUSBSBN FNDPOGMJUPDPNP1BSUJEP#PMDIFWJRVF RVF BPTFBTTFOIPSFBS EP&TUBEP DSJPVVNQPEFSPTPBQBSBUPNJMJUBSFCVSPDSgUJDPF QSPDVSPVEJ[JNgMPTFTVCTUJUVrMPTQPSwSHkPTEPQSwQSJP1BS UJEP%FMFTSFTUBSBNBQFOBTPOPNF RVFTFSJBBHSFHBEPBPEF SFQ|CMJDBTPDJBMJTUB3FQ|CMJDB4PDJBMJTUB4PWJnUJDB 2VFEFTJHOBBFYQSFTTkP²SFWPMVmkPQFSNBOFOUF³ ²3FWPMVmkPQFSNBOFOUF³ DPNPPQSwQSJPUFSNPJOEJDB EF TJHOBWBBBmkPRVFTFPQVOIBhCVSPDSBUJ[BmkPRVFUPNPVDPOUB EP1BSUJEP#PMDIFWJRVFBTTJNRVFFTUFBTDFOEFVBPQPEFSFQSP QVHOBWBBDPOUJOVBmkPEBSFWPMVmkP DPNUPEBTBTTVBTFUBQBT EFBDPSEPDPNBTUFPSJBTEF.BSY&N PTNFNCSPTEP1BS UJEPFTUBWBNQSPGVOEBNFOUFEJWJEJEPTFOUSFBQPTJmkPEF5SPUTLJ ±PBSBVUPEBSFWPMVmkPQFSNBOFOUFFQSJODJQBMBEWFSTgSJPEP CVSPDSBUJTNP±FBEF4UBMJO RVFDPOTFHVJSBHBMHBSPQPTUPEF
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
TFDSFUgSJPHFSBMEPQBSUJEP BDVNVMBOEPFOPSNFTQPEFSFTFN TVBTNkPT 2VFNFEJEBTBEPUPV4UBMJOBPBTTVNJSPQPEFS FN 4PCBPSJFOUBmkPEF4UBMJO BTQSJODJQBJTMJEFSBOmBTEBSFWP MVmkPGPSBNFYQVMTBTEPQBSUJEP5SPUTLJGPJCBOJEPF FN BTTBTTJOBEPQPSVNBHFOUFTUBMJOJTUB OP.nYJDP$PNBUFTF ²TPDJBMJTNPOVNTwQBrT³ QPSUBOUPPQPTUBhUFTFNBSYJTUBEP JOUFSOBDJPOBMJTNPQSPMFUgSJPFEBSFWPMVmkPNVOEJBM
4UBMJOJN QMBOUPVhGPSmBBDPMFUJWJ[BmkPEBFDPOPNJB TPCBEJSFmkPEP &TUBEPFEPQBSUJEP&YFSDFVDPOUSPMFNJMJUBS QPMJDJBMFJEFPMwHJDP TPCSFUPEBBTPDJFEBEF JOTUJUVJVP²DVMUPhQFSTPOBMJEBEF³F FN DPNFmPVPTHSBOEFTFYQVSHPTQPMrUJDPT DPOIFDJEPTDPNP ²QSPDFTTPTEF.PTDPV³4FNQSFOPTCBTUJEPSFT DPOTFHVJVRVF TFVTBMJBEPTGPSKBTTFNUPEPUJQPEFBDVTBmkPDPOUSBMJEFSBOmBT QPMrUJDBTEFPQPTJmkP MFWBOEPBThDPOEFOBmkPhNPSUF PVh QSJTkPQFSQnUVBFNDBNQPTEFDPODFOUSBmkP'PSUBMFDFVBQP MrDJBTFDSFUBFDPOTPMJEPVPUPUBMJUBSJTNP"MnNEBDPMFUJWJ[BmkP FDPOyNJDB 4UBMJOQMBOFKPVBFDPOPNJBQBSBJOWFTUJNFOUPTOB JOE|TUSJBQFTBEB TBDSJGJDBOEPBQSPEVmkPEFCFOTEFDPOTVNP FPTTFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPTTPDJBJT1SFWFOEPB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VO EJBM PSJFOUPVBFDPOPNJBQBSBBJOE|TUSJBCnMJDB RVrNJDBQFTB EBFFOFSHJBFMnUSJDB QSPEV[JOEP hDVTUBEFFOPSNFTTBDSJGrDJPT FQSJWBm{FTEBQPQVMBmkP PNBJPSDSFTDJNFOUPFDPOyNJDPEB IJTUwSJBEB3|TTJB RVFTFUPSOPVQPUpODJBFDPOyNJDBFNJMJUBS NVOEJBM 2VFnPUPUBMJUBSJTNP 0UFSNPUPUBMJUBSJTNPTJHOJGJDB&TUBEPUPUBM RVFBCTPSWF FNTFVJOUFSJPSFFNTVBPSHBOJ[BmkPPUPEPEBTPDJFEBEFF TVBTJOTUJUVJm{FT DPOUSPMBOEPBQPSJOUFJSP 2VFnPGBTDJTNP 0GBTDJTNPPSJHJOPVTFOB*UgMJB QBrTRVF FNCPSBFTUJWFT TFEPMBEPEPTWFODFEPSFTEB1SJNFJSB(VFSSB.VOEJBM GJDPV JOTBUJTGFJUPDPNBTDPNQFOTBm{FTRVFMIFGPSBNEBEBT"P NFTNPUFNQP UFOUBWBNBOUFSTFFDPOPNJDBNFOUFQFMBFY QMPSBmkPEFDPMyOJBTOBÇGSJDB#FOJUP.VTTPMJOJ DPNP)JUMFS QBSUJVEBDSrUJDBNBSYJTUBBPMJCFSBMJTNP NBT DPNP)JUMFS SF DVTBWBBJEFJBEFSFWPMVmkPQSPMFUgSJBDPNVOJTUB&NWF[EFMB QSPQyTPGPSUBMFDJNFOUPEP&TUBEPOBDJPOBM BBMJBOmBDPNTFUP SFTDPOTFSWBEPSFTEPDBQJUBMJOEVTUSJBMFGJOBODFJSP BHVFSSBEF DPORVJTUBEFUFSSJUwSJPTFPOBDJPOBMJTNPCBTFBEPOBTHMwSJBT EPBOUJHP*NQnSJP3PNBOP"QBMBWSBGBTDJTNPGPJJOWFOUBEBQPS .VTTPMJOJBQBSUJSEPWPDgCVMPJUBMJBOPGBTDJP ²GFJYF³cEVQMB BTJHOJGJDBmkPEFGBTDJPQPSVNMBEP SFGFSFTFBPDPOKVOUPEF NBDIBEPTSFVOJEPTQPSNFJPEFVNGFJYFEFWBSBT DBSSFHBEPT QPSGVODJPOgSJPTRVFQSFDFEJBNBBQBSJmkPQ|CMJDBEPTNBHJT USBEPTOBBOUJHB3PNB PTNBDIBEPTTJHOJGJDBOEPPQPEFSEP &TUBEPQBSBEFDBQJUBSDSJNJOPTPT FBTWBSBT BVOJEBEFEPQPWP SPNBOPFNUPSOPEP&TUBEPQPSPVUSP SFGFSFTFBVNBUSBEJmkP QPQVMBSEPTnDVMP9*9 FNRVFDFSUBTDPNVOJEBEFT MVUBOEP QPSTFVTJOUFSFTTFTFEJSFJUPT TJNCPMJ[BWBNTVBMVUBFVOJEBEF QFMPTGBTDJ.VTTPMJOJTFBQSPQSJBEPTrNCPMPSPNBOPFQPQVMBS DSJBOEPQPSUPEBB*UgMJBPTGBTDJEFDPNCBUF 2VFnPOB[JTNP 0OB[JTNPUFNPSJHFNOB"MFNBOIB QBrTRVF EFSSPUBEP OB1SJNFJSB(VFSSB.VOEJBM QFSEFVUFSSJUwSJPTFGPJPCSJHBEP BQBHBSTPNBTWVMUPTBTBPTWFODFEPSFTQBSBSFTTBSDJMPTEPT QSFKVr[PTEBHVFSSB4VBFDPOPNJBFTUBWBEFTUSPmBEB SFJOB WBNPEFTFNQSFHP BSFDFTTkPFBJOGMBmkPHBMPQBOUF"DSJTF
UPNPVQSPQPSm{FTFYDFTTJWBTFN DPNBRVFCSBEB#PMTB EF/PWB:PSL1BSUJOEPEBDSrUJDBNBSYJTUBBPMJCFSBMJTNP NBT SFDVTBOEPBJEFJBEFSFWPMVmkPQSPMFUgSJBDPNVOJTUB PBVTUSrB DP"EPMG)JUMFSTFPGFSFDFVhCVSHVFTJBFhDMBTTFNnEJBBMFNkT QBSBTBMWgMBTEBSFWPMVmkPPQFSgSJB1SPQ{FPSFFSHVJNFOUPEB "MFNBOIBQPSNFJPEPGPSUBMFDJNFOUPEP&TUBEP EPOBDJPOB MJTNPHFPQPMrUJDP BOBmkPnP²FTQBmPWJUBM³EPQPWP RVFEFWF DPORVJTUBSFNBOUFSUFSSJUwSJPTOFDFTTgSJPTBPTFVEFTFOWPMWJ NFOUPFDPOyNJDP FEBBMJBOmBDPNPTTFUPSFTDPOTFSWBEPSFT EPDBQJUBMJOEVTUSJBMFTPCSFUVEPEPDBQJUBMGJOBODFJSP)JUMFS GPJFMFJUP FNFMFJm{FTMJWSFTFEJSFUBT QBSBP1BSMBNFOUPF B TFHVJS EFVPHPMQFEF&TUBEPOB[JTUB"QBMBWSBOB[JTNPnB BCSFWJBmkPEPOPNFEFVNQBSUJEPQPMrUJDPBPRVBM)JUMFSTF GJMJPV*OJDJBMNFOUF PQBSUJEPEFOPNJOBWBTF1BSUJEP0QFSg SJP"MFNkP NBT)JUMFSQSPQyTRVFGPTTFEFOPNJOBEP1BSUJEP 0QFSgSJP"MFNkP/BDJPOBM4PDJBMJTUB /BUJPOBMTP[JBMJTUJTDIF ±/B[J 0QFSgSJP QBSBJOEJDBSBPQPTJmkPBPTMJCFSBJT NBT OBDJPOBMTPDJBMJTUBQBSBJOEJDBSBPQPTJmkPBPTDPNVOJTUBTF TPDJBMJTUBT DSrUJDPTEPOBDJPOBMJTNPQPSTFSFTUFVNBJEFPMPHJB OFDFTTgSJBBPDBQJUBM 2VFBTQFDUPTDPNVOTQPTTVFNPOB[JTNPFPGBTDJTNP &OUSFPTBTQFDUPTDPNVOTFOUSFPOB[JTNPFPGBTDJTNP QPEFNPTDJUBSPBOUJMJCFSBMJTNPBDPMBCPSBmkPEFDMBTTFB BMJBOmBFOUSFPDBQJUBMJOEVTUSJBMNPOPQPMJTUBFPGJOBODFJSPP OBDJPOBMJTNPPDPSQPSBUJWJTNPPQBSUJEP|OJDPRVFPSHBOJ[B BTNBTTBTBJEFPMPHJBEFDMBTTFNnEJBPVQFRVFOPCVSHVFTB PJNQFSJBMJTNPCFMJDJTUBBEJWVMHBmkPEBFEVDBmkPNPSBMFDrWJ DBBQSPQBHBOEBEFNBTTBBQSgUJDBEBDFOTVSBFEBEFMBmkP PSBDJTNPPFTUBUJTNP 2VFnBOUJMJCFSBMJTNP /POB[JTNPFOPGBTDJTNP EFWFTFFOUFOEFSPBOUJMJCFSB MJTNPOkPDPNPBGJSNBmkPEPTPDJBMJTNP FTJNDPNPEFGFTBEB UPUBMJOUFSWFOmkPEP&TUBEPOBFDPOPNJBFOBTPDJFEBEFDJWJM &NTVBGBTFJOJDJBM BNCPTPTSFHJNFTTFBQSFTFOUBNDPOUSBB PSEFNCVSHVFTBMJCFSBMFDPOTFHVFNBBEFTkPEBNBJPSJBEB DMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSB RVFTPGSJBBTNJTnSJBTEBSFDFTTkPFEP EFTFNQSFHP 2VFnOBDJPOBMJTNP 4FHVOEPBwUJDBUPUBMJUgSJBEFOB[JTUBTFGBTDJTUBT BSFB MJEBEFTPDJBMnBOBmkP FOUFOEJEBDPNPVOJEBEFUFSSJUPSJBMF JEFOUJEBEFSBDJBM MJOHVrTUJDB EFDPTUVNFTFUSBEJm{FT"OBmkP nPFTQrSJUPEPQPWP BQgUSJBNkFEPTBOUFQBTTBEPTEFTBOHVF VOB |OJDBFJOEJWJTB RVFEFWFTFSQSFTFSWBEB 2VFnDPSQPSBUJWJTNP 4FHVOEPPDPSQPSBUJWJTNP BTPDJFEBEF DPNPQSPQVOIBP QBQB-FkP9*** EFWFTFSPSHBOJ[BEBQFMP&TUBEPTPCBGPSNBEF DPSQPSBm{FTEPUSBCBMIPFEPDBQJUBM IJFSBSRVJ[BEBTQPSTVBT GVOm{FTFIBSNPOJ[BEBTQFMBQPMrUJDBFDPOyNJDBEP&TUBEP $PNPnPGVODJPOBNFOUPEFVNBTPDJFEBEFOBRVBMVN|OJ DPQBSUJEPPSHBOJ[BBTNBTTBT /VNBTPDJFEBEFDPNFTTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT FNMVHBSEF DMBTTFTTPDJBJT BOBmkPnWJTUBDPNPDPOTUJUVrEBQFMPQPWPF FTUFnBNBTTBPSHBOJ[BEBQFMPQBSUJEP|OJDP RVFBFYQSJNF FSFQSFTFOUB0QBSUJEPPSHBOJ[BBTPDJFEBEFOkPTwFNTJOEJ DBUPTDPSQPSBUJWPT NBTUBNCnNFNBTTPDJBm{FTEFKPWFOT EFNVMIFSFT EFDSJBOmBT EFBSUJTUBT FTDSJUPSFT DJFOUJTUBT EF
-,0
Manual do Professor
CBJSSP EFHJOgTUJDBFEBOmB EFN|TJDB FUD"SFMBmkPFOUSFBTP DJFEBEF BOBmkP FP&TUBEPnGFJUBQFMBNFEJBmkPEPQBSUJEP 2VFTJHOJGJDBBFYQSFTTkP²JEFPMPHJBEFDMBTTFNnEJBPV QFRVFOPCVSHVFTB³ /PNPEPEFQSPEVmkPDBQJUBMJTUB IgVNBDBNBEBTPDJBM RVFOkPnQSPMFUgSJPDBNQPOFTB OFNnBQSPQSJFUgSJBQSJWBEB EPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkP OFNnCVSHVFTBUSBUBTFEBDMBTTFNn EJBPVQFRVFOBCVSHVFTJB DPOTUJUVrEBQPSDPNFSDJBOUFT QSPGJT TJPOBJTMJCFSBJT JOUFMFDUVBJT BSUJTUBT BSUFTkPTJOEFQFOEFOUFT FGVODJPOgSJPTQ|CMJDPT&TTBDMBTTFBEFSFDPNQMFUBNFOUFBPT WBMPSFTFBPTDPTUVNFTEBCVSHVFTJBFUFNFBQSPMFUBSJ[BmkP TFOEPQPSJTTPBOUJTTPDJBMJTUBFBOUJDPNVOJTUB&NCPSBBENJSF BCVSHVFTJB SFTTFOUFTFQPSOkPQPTTVJSBSJRVF[BFPTQSJWJMn HJPTCVSHVFTFT"DMBTTFNnEJBPVQFRVFOBCVSHVFTJBBDSFEJUB OPJOEJWJEVBMJTNPDPNQFUJUJWP OBJEFJBEP²IPNFNRVFTFGB[ TP[JOIP³HSBmBThEJTDJQMJOB hCPBGBNrMJB BPTCPOTDPTUVNFT FBPUSBCBMIP.BT BPDPOUSgSJPEFTVBTFYQFDUBUJWBT OkPDPO TFHVF BQFTBSEPTFTGPSmPT ²TVCJSOBWJEB³ FSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BB ²DPCJmBEPTSJDPT³QPSTVBTJUVBmkPJOGFSJPSJ[BEB BUSJCVJOEPB hEFTPSEFNEPMJCFSBMJTNP1PSFTTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT BDMBT TFNnEJBPVQFRVFOBCVSHVFTJBnDPOTFSWBEPSBFSFBDJPOgSJB UFOEPQSFEJMFmkPQPSQSPQPTUBTQPMrUJDBTRVFMIFQSPNFUBNPS HBOJ[BSP&TUBEPFBFDPOPNJBEFUBMNPEPRVFEFTBQBSFmBNP MJCFSBMJTNPFPSJTDPEPTPDJBMJTNPDPNVOJTNPcPEFTUJOBUgSJP QSJWJMFHJBEPFQSFGFSJEPEPOB[JTNPFEPGBTDJTNP FEFUPEBTBT QPMrUJDBTBOUJTTPDJBMJTUBTFBOUJDPNVOJTUBT 0RVFnPJNQFSJBMJTNPCFMJDJTUB 0OB[JTNPFPGBTDJTNPTkPQPMrUJDBTEFHVFSSBFEFDPO RVJTUB PVTFKB TkPJNQnSJPTCFMJDJTUBT)JUMFSGBMBSgEPTBOHVF HFSNiOJDPRVFDPSSFOBTWFJBTEPTQPWPTEB&VSPQBDFOUSBMF EFWFSgTFS²SFDPOEV[JEP³hNkFQgUSJBBMFNkQFMBHVFSSB.VT TPMJOJGBMBSgOBTHMwSJBTEP*NQnSJP3PNBOPFFNTVBSFDPO RVJTUBQFMBTHVFSSBTJUBMJBOBT/FTTFTFOUJEP PJNQFSJBMJTNP CFMJDJTUBUFNFOUSFTFVTPCKFUJWPTBDPORVJTUBFBIFHFNPOJB QFMBGPSmBVTBOEPBSHVNFOUPTDPNPBQSFTFSWBmkPEBQVSF[B EBSBmBFPSFTHBUFEBTUSBEJm{FTFEBHMwSJBEPQBTTBEP &NRVFJNQMJDBB²FEVDBmkPNPSBMFDrWJDB³ 1BSBHBSBOUJSBBEFTkPEBTNBTTBThJEFPMPHJBOB[JGBTDJTUB P&TUBEPJOUSPEV[BFEVDBmkPNPSBMFDrWJDB QFMBRVBMDSJBOmBTF BEPMFTDFOUFTBQSFOEFSkPPTWBMPSFTOB[JGBTDJTUBTEFQgUSJB EJT DJQMJOB GPSmBEPDBSgUFS GPSNBmkPEFDPSQPTCFMPT TBVEgWFJT QPEFSPTPT OFDFTTgSJPTBPTHVFSSFJSPTEPTOPWPTJNQnSJPT 2VFnQSPQBHBOEBEFNBTTB *OUSPEV[JEBQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[OBIJTUwSJBQFMPOB[JGBTDJTNP USBUBTFEFQSPQBHBOEBQPMrUJDB WPMUBEBQBSBBNBOJGFTUBmkP EFTFOUJNFOUPT FNPm{FTFQBJY{FT EFTWBMPSJ[BOEPBSB[kP PQFOTBNFOUPFBDPOTDJpODJBDSrUJDB1PSNFJPEPSgEJPFEB JNQSFOTB EFDBSUB[FT EFTGJMFT CBOEBT KPHPTBUMnUJDPT GJMNFT POB[JGBTDJTNPQSPDVSBJODVUJSOBNBTTBBEFWPmkPJODPOEJDJP OBMhQgUSJBFBPTDIFGFT PBNPShIJFSBSRVJB hEJTDJQMJOBFh HVFSSB $PNPTFEgBQSgUJDBEBDFOTVSBFEBEFMBmkPOBTTPDJFEB EFTUPUBMJUgSJBT 0&TUBEP BUSBWnTEPQBSUJEP EBTBTTPDJBm{FTFEFBQBSF MIPTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPT QPMJDJBJTFNJMJUBSFT
DPOUSPMBPQFOTBNFO UP BTDJpODJBTFBTBSUFTQPSNFJPEBDFOTVSB RVFJNBOEPMJWSPT FPCSBTEFBSUF²DPOUSgSJPT³hQgUSJBFBPTDIFGFT QSFOEFOEPF
-,1
UPSUVSBOEPPTEJTTJEFOUFT QFSTFHVJOEPPT²JOJNJHPTJOUFSOPT³ &TUJNVMBUBNCnN TPCSFUVEPFNDSJBOmBTFKPWFOT BQSgUJDBEB EFMBmkPDPOUSBPTEJTTJEFOUFT ²EFTWJBOUFT³F²JOJNJHPTJOUFS OPT³EP&TUBEP 2VFnSBDJTNP .FOPTGPSUFOPGBTDJTNP nVNDPNQPOFOUFFTTFODJBMEP OB[JTNP RVFJOWFOUBBJEFJBEF²SBmBBSJBOB³PV²SBmBOwSEJ DB³ TVQFSJPSBUPEBTBTPVUSBT EFWFOEPDPORVJTUBSBMHVNBT QBSBRVFBTJSWBNFBOJRVJMBSPVUSBT QPSRVF²JOTFSWrWFJT³F ²QFSJHPTBT³"JEFJBEFBOJRVJMBmkPEBT²SBmBTJOGFSJPSFT³GB[ EPHFOPDrEJPVNBQPMrUJDBEP&TUBEP0OB[JTNPDPOTJEFSPV PTOFHSPTBGSJDBOPT QPMPOFTFT UDIFDPT I|OHBSPT SPNFOPT DSPBUBT TnSWJPTFEFNBJTCSBODPTFVSPQFVTDPNPSBmBTJOGFSJP SFTBTFSFNDPORVJTUBEBTQBSBSFBMJ[BSPUSBCBMIPCSBmBMQBSBB SBmBTVQFSJPS$POTJEFSPVDJHBOPTFKVEFVTDPNPSBmBTBTFSFN FMJNJOBEBT FYUFSNJOPVDJHBOPTFTFJTNJMI{FTEFKVEFVT 2VFnFTUBUJTNP cP&TUBEPGPSUF DFOUSBMJ[BEPBENJOJTUSBUJWBNFOUF NJMJUB SJ[BEP RVFDPOUSPMBUPEBBTPDJFEBEFQPSNFJPEPQBSUJEP EBT NJMrDJBTEFKPWFOT EBFEVDBmkPNPSBMFDrWJDB EBQSPQBHBOEB EBDFOTVSBFEBEFMBmkP&YJTUFBQFOBTP&TUBEPDPNPUPUBMJEB EFRVFFOHMPCBFNTFVJOUFSJPSPUPEPEBTPDJFEBEF 2VBJTPTBTQFDUPTQSJODJQBJTEPTUBMJOJTNP .VJUPTUSBmPTEPTUBMJOJTNPTkPTFNFMIBOUFTBPTEPOB[J GBTDJTNP DFOUSBMJ[BmkPFTUBUBM QBSUJEP|OJDPDPNDPOUSPMFUPUBM TPCSFBTPDJFEBEF NJMJUBSJ[BmkP OBDJPOBMJTNP JNQFSJBMJTNP DFOTVSBEPQFOTBNFOUPFEBFYQSFTTkP QSPQBHBOEBFTUBUBMOP MVHBSEBJOGPSNBmkP DBNQPTEFDPODFOUSBmkP JOWFOmkPDPOUr OVBEPT²JOJNJHPTJOUFSOPT³
NBTBEJGFSFOmBGVOEBNFOUBMF USgHJDBFOUSFFMFTFTUgOPGBUPEFRVFPTUBMJOJTNPTVGPDPVBQSJ NFJSBSFWPMVmkPDPNVOJTUBFEFGPSNPVQSPGVOEBNFOUFPNBS YJTNP NBSDBOEPDPNPTFMPUPUBMJUgSJPPTQBSUJEPTDPNVOJTUBT EPNVOEPJOUFJSP %FRVFGPSNBPTUBMJOJTNPDPNQSPNFUFVBTUFTFTNBSYJT UBT $JUFUSpTBTQFDUPTFNRVFJTTPPDPSSFV 1SPGFTTPS B PBMVOPQPEFSgFTDPMIFSUSpTFOUSFPTWgSJPT BTQFDUPTBQSFTFOUBEPT hUFTFNBSYJTUBEBSFWPMVmkPQSP MFUgSJBNVOEJBM PTUBMJOJTNPDPOUSBQyTBUFTFEPTPDJBMJTNP OVNTwQBrT USBOTGPSNBOEPBFNEJSFUSJ[PCSJHBUwSJBQBSBPT QBSUJEPTDPNVOJTUBTEPNVOEPJOUFJSP*TTPTJHOJGJDPVRVFUBJT QBSUJEPTEFWFSJBNBCBOEPOBSQSgUJDBTSFWPMVDJPOgSJBTFNTFVT QBrTFTQBSBOkPQSFKVEJDBSBTSFMBm{FTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTEB6OJkP 4PWJnUJDB&SBNFTUJNVMBEBT QPSnN BTHVFSSBTEFMJCFSUBmkP OBDJPOBMDPOUSBPTQBrTFTDPMPOJBMJTUBTTFNQSFRVFJTTPGPTTF EPJOUFSFTTFFDPOyNJDPFHFPQPMrUJDPEB6344 hUFTFNBS YJTUBEBEJUBEVSBEPQSPMFUBSJBEPQBSBBEFSSVCBEBEP&TUBEP PTUBMJOJTNPDPOUSBQyTBEJUBEVSBEPQBSUJEP|OJDPFEP&TUBEP GPSUF hUFTFNBSYJTUBEBBCPMJmkPEP&TUBEPOBTPDJFEBEF DPNVOJTUBTFNDMBTTFTTPDJBJT DPOUSBQyTPBHJHBOUBNFOUPEP &TUBEP BBCTPSmkPEBTPDJFEBEFQFMPBQBSFMIPFTUBUBMFQF MPTwSHkPTEPQBSUJEP DVKBCVSPDSBDJBDPOTUJUVJVTFOVNBOPWB DMBTTFEPNJOBOUF DPNJOUFSFTTFTFQSJWJMnHJPTQSwQSJPT h UFTFNBSYJTUBEBMVUBQSPMFUgSJBDPOUSBBCVSHVFTJBFBQFRVFOB CVSHVFTJB CFNDPNPEBBGJSNBmkPEFRVF FNNVJUPTQSPDFT TPTSFWPMVDJPOgSJPT QBSUFEBCVSHVFTJBFEBQFRVFOBCVSHVF TJBTFBMJBNBPQSPMFUBSJBEP NBTPBCBOEPOBNBQBSUJSEFDFSUP QPOUP EFWFOEPFMFQSPTTFHVJSTP[JOIPOBBmkPSFWPMVDJPOgSJB PTUBMJOJTNPDPOUSBQyTBUFTFPQPSUVOJTUBEB²FTUSBUnHJB³FEB
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
²UgUJDB³ TFHVOEPBRVBM FNDFSUPTDBTPT PQSPMFUBSJBEPGBSJB BMJBOmBTFOFMBTQFSNBOFDFSJBF FNPVUSPT OkPGBSJBBMJBOmB BMHVNB TFJTTPOkPGPTTFEPJOUFSFTTFEBWBOHVBSEBQBSUJEgSJB hUFTFNBSYJTUBEPJOUFSOBDJPOBMJTNPQSPMFUgSJP DPOUSBQyT POBDJPOBMJTNPFPJNQFSJBMJTNPSVTTPT QSJNFJSPJOWBEJOEPF EPNJOBOEPB&VSPQBPSJFOUBMFEFQPJTPTQBrTFTBTJgUJDPTOkP EPNJOBEPTQFMB$IJOB hUFTFNBSYJTUBEPQBSUJEPQPMrUJDP DPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEFPSHBOJ[BmkPEBDMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSBFFY QSFTTkPQSgUJDBEFTVBTJEFJBTFMVUBT DPOUSBQyTBCVSPDSBDJB QBSUJEgSJBDPNPWBOHVBSEBQPMrUJDB RVFOkPTw²SFQSFTFOUB³PT JOUFSFTTFTQSPMFUgSJPTNBTPTFODBSOBFPTEJSJHF QPJTnEFUFO UPSBEPQPEFSFEPTBCFS hUFTFNBSYJTUBEBSFMBmkPJOEJTTP M|WFMFOUSFBTJEFJBTFBTDPOEJm{FTNBUFSJBJT JTUPn FOUSFUFPSJB FQSgUJDB RVFQFSNJUJBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBDPOTDJpODJBDSrUJDB EBDMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSB DPOUSBQyTBQSPQBHBOEBFTUBUBM BJEFP MPHJBEPDIFGFDPNP²QBJEPTQPWPT³ PDPOUSPMFEBFEVDBmkPF EPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPQFMPQBSUJEPFQFMP&TUBEP hUFTF EF.BSYEFRVFBUFPSJBFBQSgUJDBFTUkPOVNBSFMBmkPEJBMnUJDB RVFPDPOIFDJNFOUPnIJTUwSJDPFVNQSPDFTTPJOUFSNJOgWFMEF BOgMJTFFDPNQSFFOTkPEBTDPOEJm{FTDPODSFUBTQPTUBTQFMB SFBMJEBEFTPDJBM PTUBMJOJTNPDPOUSBQyTVNBJOWFOmkP P%JB NBU NBUFSJBMJTNPEJBMnUJDP
JTUPn PNBSYJTNPDPNPEPVUSJOB BIJTUwSJDB GJYBEBFNEPHNBTFYQPTUPTTPCBGPSNBEFDBUFDJT NPTEFWVMHBSJ[BmkPEBJEFPMPHJBTUBMJOJTUB'PJUkPMPOHFOJTTP RVFDPOTJEFSPVGVOmkPEP&TUBEPEFGJOJSPQFOTBNFOUPDPSSFUP 1BSBUBOUP PTJOUFMFDUVBJTEPQBSUJEPGPSBNFODBSSFHBEPTEF EFUFSNJOBSBTMJOIBT²DPSSFUBT³QBSBBGJMPTPGJB BTDJpODJBTFBT BSUFT*OTUJUVJVTFBQTJDPMPHJBPGJDJBM BNFEJDJOBFBHFOnUJDB PGJDJBJT BMJUFSBUVSB BQJOUVSB BN|TJDBFPDJOFNBPGJDJBJT B GJMPTPGJBFBDJpODJBPGJDJBJT FODBSSFHBOEPTFBQPMrDJBTFDSFUB EFRVFJNBSPCSBT QSFOEFS UPSUVSBS BTTBTTJOBSPVFOWJBSQBSB DBNQPTEFDPODFOUSBmkPPT²EJTTJEFOUFT³PV²EFTWJBOUFT³0T IFSEFJSPTEF4UBMJOGPSBNNBJTMPOHFDPOTJEFSBSBNRVF DPNP PQBSUJEPFP&TUBEPEJ[FNBWFSEBEFBCTPMVUB PT²EFTWJPT³ JOUFMFDUVBJT BSUrTUJDPTFQPMrUJDPTFSBNTJOUPNBTEFEJTU|SCJPT QTrRVJDPTFEFMPVDVSB FOWJBOEPPT²EJTTJEFOUFT³QBSBIPTQJ UBJTQTJRVJgUSJDPT hUFTFNBSYJTUBEFRVFBDMBTTFUSBCBMIB EPSBnTVKFJUPEFTVBQSwQSJBIJTUwSJBRVBOEPUPNBDPOTDJpODJB EFTVBTJUVBmkPFMVUBDPOUSBFMB BQSFOEFOEPDPNBNFNwSJB EPTDPNCBUFTFBUSBEJmkPEBTEFSSPUBT PTUBMJOJTNPDPOUSBQyT BJEFJBEFIJTUwSJBPGJDJBMEBDMBTTFQSPMFUgSJB JEFOUJGJDBEBDPN BIJTUwSJBEPQBSUJEPDPNVOJTUBFDPNBJOUFSQSFUBmkPEBEBQPS FTUF|MUJNPBPTBDPOUFDJNFOUPTIJTUwSJDPT SPVCBOEPBTTJNEPT USBCBMIBEPSFTPEJSFJUPhNFNwSJB hUFTFNBSYJTUBEFRVF PTJOJNJHPTEBDMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSBOkPTkPJOEJWrEVPTEFTTBPV EBRVFMBDMBTTF NBTVNBPVUSBDMBTTFTPDJBMFORVBOUPDMBTTF DPOUSBQyTBJEFJBEF²JOJNJHPTEPQPWPTBrEPTEPTFJPEPQSw QSJPQPWP³DPNPJOJNJHPTEFTVBQSwQSJBDMBTTF QPSRVFTkP ²BHFOUFTFTUSBOHFJSPTJOGJMUSBEPTOPTFJPEPQPWPVOP JOEJWJTP CPNFIPNPHpOFP³ hUFTFEF.BSYEBOPWBTPDJFEBEFDPNP DPODSFUJ[BmkPEBMJCFSEBEF EBJHVBMEBEF EBBCVOEiODJB EB KVTUJmBFEBGFMJDJEBEF PTUBMJOJTNPDPOUSBQyTP²PQFSgSJPNP EFMP³FP²NJMJUBOUFFYFNQMBS³ BDPTUVNBEPThPCFEJpODJBDFHB BPTDPNBOEPTEP&TUBEPFEPQBSUJEPFhIJFSBSRVJBTPDJBMJN QPTUBQPSFMFT7JWFSQFMPFQBSBP&TUBEPFPQBSUJEPUPSOPVTF TJOyOJNPEFGFMJDJEBEF MJCFSEBEFFKVTUJmB 2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBTEPTUBMJOJTNPOBBOUJHB6OJkP4P WJnUJDB 0TUBMJOJTNPJOTUJUVJVVNBOPWBGPSNBmkPTPDJBM RVFNP EFMPVDPSQPT DPSBm{FTFNFOUFTFRVFTwEFTBQBSFDFV QBS DJBMNFOUF OPGJNEPTBOPTFJOrDJPEPTBOPT QPSRVF
BDSJTFFDPOyNJDB QSPWPDBEBQFMPEFMrSJPBSNBNFOUJTUB GF[ FNFSHJSFNDPOUSBEJm{FTTVGPDBEBTEVSBOUFBOPT 0RVFGPJBHVFSSBGSJB 1PSRVFUJOIBFTTFOPNF "HVFSSBGSJBGPJBEJWJTkPHFPQPMrUJDB FDPOyNJDBFNJMJUBS FOUSFEPJTHSBOEFTCMPDPTPCMPDPDBQJUBMJTUB TPCBEJSFmkP EPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT JODMVJOEPBTUSpT"NnSJDBT B&VSPQBPDJ EFOUBMFBTDPMyOJBTFVSPQFJBTOBÇGSJDB OP0SJFOUF.nEJPFOB ÇTJB
FPCMPDPDPNVOJTUB TPCBEJSFmkPEB6OJkP4PWJnUJDB FEB$IJOB JODMVJOEPPTQBrTFTEB&VSPQBDFOUSBMFEP-FTUF 6NBEBTQSJODJQBJTSB[{FTQBSBFTTBEJWJTkPGPJNJMJUBS JTUPn BJOWFOmkPEBCPNCBBUyNJDB RVFQVOIBGJNhTHVFSSBTDPO WFODJPOBJT"HVFSSBUFSJBEFTFS QPSUBOUP HVFSSBGSJB±FTQJP OBHFN GJOBODJBNFOUPEFHVFSSBTMPDBMJ[BEBT BQPJPTPWJnUJDP BHVFSSBTBOUJDPMPOJBJT EFTFTUBCJMJ[BmkPOPSUFBNFSJDBOBEF SFHJNFTTPDJBMJTUBTJOTUJUVrEPTOBgSFBEFQPEFSEPT&TUBEPT 6OJEPT FUD"HVFSSBGSJBEFGJOJV QPSRVBTFBOPT PBMJOIB NFOUPQPMrUJDPFFDPOyNJDPEFUPEPTPTQBrTFThWPMUBEPTEPJT CMPDPTIFHFNyOJDPT 0RVFGJDPVTFOEPPTrNCPMPEBHVFSSBGSJB 0TrNCPMPEFTTBHVFSSBGPJBEJWJTkPEB"MFNBOIBFN0DJ EFOUBM PDVQBEBQFMBTGPSmBTNJMJUBSFTDBQJUBMJTUBTEBDIBNBEB 0SHBOJ[BmkPEP5SBUBEPEP"UMiOUJDP/PSUF 0UBO
F0SJFOUBM PDVQBEBQFMBTGPSmBTTPWJnUJDBTEPDIBNBEP1BDUPEF7BSTw WJB JTUPn EPTQBrTFTEB&VSPQBPSJFOUBMTVCNFUJEPTh6OJkP 4PWJnUJDB &TTFTrNCPMPFSBWJTrWFMDPNBEJWJTkPEBTEVBT"MF NBOIBTQBTTBOEPQFMPJOUFSJPSEBBOUJHBDBQJUBM #FSMJN FFT UBWBGJTJDBNFOUFDPODSFUJ[BEPOP².VSPEF#FSMJN³ BNVSBMIB FSHVJEBQFMPTSVTTPTQBSBJNQFEJSBQBTTBHFNEPTBMFNkFTEB "MFNBOIB0SJFOUBMQBSBB0DJEFOUBMFQBSBDPOUSPMBSBFOUSBEBF TBrEBEFQFTTPBTEB"MFNBOIB0DJEFOUBMQBSBB0SJFOUBM 0RVFFSBBDIBNBEB²DPSSJEBBSNBNFOUJTUB³ *OJDJBMNFOUF DBEBCMPDPKVMHBWBRVFBQPTTFEFBSNBNFO UPTOVDMFBSFTMIFEBSJBNBJTQPEFSQBSBFMJNJOBSPPVUSP1PVDP BQPVDP QPSnN B²DPSSJEBBSNBNFOUJTUB³EFJYPVEFWJTBSEJ SFUBNFOUFhHVFSSB WPMUBOEPTFQBSBBJOUJNJEBmkPSFDrQSPDB EPTBEWFSTgSJPT MJNJUBOEPTVBTBm{FTJNQFSJBMJTUBT QPJTQFS DFCFVTFRVFVNBHVFSSBOkPDPOWFODJPOBMPVOVDMFBSOkPUFSJB WFODFEPSFT QPJTPQMBOFUBTFSJBJOUFJSBNFOUFEFTUSVrEP $PNPUFSNJOPVBHVFSSBGSJB 4PCBBmkPEF.JLIBJM(PSCBDIFW BHVFSSBGSJBUFSNJOPV DPNPGJNEPSFHJNFTPWJnUJDP DPNBHMBTOPTUFBQFSFTUSPJLB TFOEPJNQMFNFOUBEBT/BWFSEBEF PSFHJNFUFSNJOPVDPNP DPOTFRVpODJBEBSVrOBFDPOyNJDBEB6OJkP4PWJnUJDB RVFOkP TwNBOUFWFQMBOPTFDPOyNJDPTMJHBEPThJOE|TUSJBCnMJDBDPNP OkPEFTFOWPMWFVBTOPWBTUFDOPMPHJBTEFQPOUBFYJHJEBTQFMB FSBEBFMFUSyOJDBFEBJOGPSNgUJDB 2VFFSBNBHMBTOPTUFBQFSFTUSPJLB &NGBDFEPBUSBTPFDPOyNJDP EBTMVUBTSFHJPOBJTQPSJOEF QFOEpODJB EBFTUBHOBmkPTPDJBMFDVMUVSBM EBTDPOUSBEJm{FTJO UFSOBThTPDJFEBEFTPWJnUJDB EBTBNFBmBTDPOUrOVBTEFHVFSSB DPNB$IJOB EBNVEBOmBOBGPSNBEPDBQJUBM PDIBNBEPOFPMJCF SBMJTNP FEBIFHFNPOJBJEFPMwHJDBDBQJUBMJTUB IPVWFPEFTNBO UFMBNFOUPQBSDJBMEPUPUBMJUBSJTNPTUBMJOJTUB0TEPJTQSJODJQBJT JOTUSVNFOUPTQPMrUJDPTVTBEPTQPS(PSCBDIFWQBSBJNQMFNFOUBS BTNVEBOmBTGPSBNBHMBTOPTUFBQFSFTUSPJLB1FSFTUSPJLBFN SVTTPRVFSEJ[FS²USBOTQBSpODJB³ PVTFKB VNBSFMBUJWBBCFSUVSB hnQPDB OBTOPSNBTQPMrUJDBTWJHFOUFT DPNNBJPSEJWVM
-,2
Manual do Professor
HBmkPEBTBUJWJEBEFTEPHPWFSOPFBCSBOEBNFOUPEBDFOTVSB $PNPDPOTFRVpODJB PTEJTTJEFOUFTTPWJnUJDPTGPSBNBOJTUJBEPT FWPMUPVBMJCFSEBEFEFDVMUP FOUSFPVUSPTBWBOmPT+gHMBTOPTUGPJ BFYFDVmkPDPODSFUBEBSFGPSNBEPTJTUFNBQPMrUJDPFGJOBODFJSP EB6OJkP4PWJnUJDB 0RVFEFTJHOBBFYQSFTTkP²TPDJBMEFNPDSBDJB³ %FTJHOBBQPMrUJDBEBFTRVFSEBSFGPSNJTUB"EJTDVTTkP²SF GPSNBPVSFWPMVmkP ³EFVPSJHFNhJEFJBEFFUBQBTIJTUwSJDBT QBSBBQBTTBHFNBPDPNVOJTNPBQSJODJQBMEFTTBTFUBQBTFSBP TPDJBMJTNP FOUFOEJEPDPNPQBTTBHFNHSBEVBMBPDPNVOJTNP QPSNFJPEFSFGPSNBTOPDBQJUBMJTNP"QPMrUJDBTPDJBMJTUBFSB QSPQPTUBQPSQBSUJEPTRVFTFEFOPNJOBWBNTPDJBMEFNPDSBUBT ±EPOEFBFYQSFTTkPTPDJBMEFNPDSBDJB 0RVFGPJP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBM 8FMGBSF4UBUF %F RVFGPSNBGPJJNQMFNFOUBEP "TPDJBMEFNPDSBDJBJOTUJUVJVTFDPNPQPMrUJDBEP&TUBEPEF #FN&TUBS4PDJBM 8FMGBSF4UBUF
JNQMBOUBEPOPTQBrTFTDBQJ UBMJTUBTBWBOmBEPTEPIFNJTGnSJPOPSUFDPNPEFGFTBEPDBQJUB MJTNPDPOUSBPQFSJHPEPSFUPSOPEPOB[JGBTDJTNPFEBSFWPMVmkP DPNVOJTUB"DSJTFFDPOyNJDBHFSBEBQFMBHVFSSB BTDSrUJDBT OB[JGBTDJTUBFDPNVOJTUBBPMJCFSBMJTNP BTMVUBTEPTUSBCBMIB EPSFTQPSEJSFJUPTFDPOyNJDPTFTPDJBJTGVOEBEBTOBJNBHFN EBTPDJFEBEFTPDJBMJTUBFNDPOTUSVmkPOB6OJkP4PWJnUJDBFOB $IJOB GB[FOEPDPNRVFPTUSBCBMIBEPSFTFODPOUSBTTFNOFMBT JHOPSBOEPPRVFBMJSFBMNFOUFTFQBTTBWB VNDPOUSBQPOUPQB SBBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTFJOKVTUJmBTEPDBQJUBMJTNP UVEPJTTPMFWPV hOFDFTTJEBEFEFSFGPSNBSBFDPOPNJBFEFBMUFSBSBBmkPEP &TUBEP DPSSJHJOEPPTQSPCMFNBTFDPOyNJDPTFTPDJBJT"FTTB UBSFGBEFEJDPVTFBTPDJBMEFNPDSBDJBQPSNFJPEP&TUBEPEF #FN&TUBS4PDJBM PV8FMGBSF4UBUF*OTQJSBOEPTFOBTJEFJBT EPFDPOPNJTUBJOHMpT+PIO,FZOFT BTPDJBMEFNPDSBDJBQBTTPV BDPNCBUFSBBOBSRVJBFDPOyNJDBMJCFSBMQPSNFJPEP&TUBEP &TUF FNMVHBSEFTFSPgSCJUSPEFDPOGMJUPT QPTUBEPBDJNBEB TPDJFEBEFDJWJM hNBOFJSBMJCFSBM
QBTTBBJOUFSWJSOBFDPOPNJB JOWFTUJOEPFNJOE|TUSJBTFTUBUBJT TVCTJEJBOEPFNQSFTBTQSJWB EBTOBJOE|TUSJB OBBHSJDVMUVSBFOPDPNnSDJP FYFSDFOEPDPO USPMFTPCSFQSFmPT TBMgSJPTFUBYBTEFKVSPT"TTVNFQBSBTJVN DPOKVOUPEFFODBSHPTTPDJBJTPVTFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPT FOUFOEJEPT DPNPEJSFJUPTTPDJBJTSFJWJOEJDBEPTQFMBDMBTTFUSBCBMIBEPSB TB|EF FEVDBmkP NPSBEJB USBOTQPSUF QSFWJEpODJBTPDJBM TBMg SJPEFTFNQSFHP TBMgSJPGBNrMJB FUD"MnNEPTEJSFJUPTTPDJBJT UBNCnNBUFOEFBEFNBOEBTEFDJEBEBOJBQPMrUJDB DPNPPTV GSgHJPVOJWFSTBM 2VBJTFSBNBTCBTFTEP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBM (SPTTPNPEP QPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS 4PDJBMTFGVOEBNFOUBWB OPGPSEJTNPOBQSPEVmkP JTUPn BT HSBOEFTQMBOUBTJOEVTUSJBJTRVFSFBMJ[BWBNBBUJWJEBEFFDPOy NJDBEFTEFBQSPEVmkPEBNBUnSJBQSJNBBUnTVBEJTUSJCVJmkP OPNFSDBEPEFCFOTFEFDPOTVNP DPOUSPMBOEP QPSNFJPEP QMBOFKBNFOUPFEBDIBNBEB²HFSpODJBDJFOUrGJDB³ BPSHBOJ[B mkPEPUSBCBMIP BQSPEVmkPEFHSBOEFTFTUPRVFTFPDPOUSPMF EPTQSFmPT OBJODMVTkPDSFTDFOUFEPTJOEJWrEVPTOPNFSDBEP EFUSBCBMIP PSJFOUBOEPTFQFMBJEFJBEFQMFOPFNQSFHP OPT NPOPQwMJPTFPMJHPQwMJPTRVF FNCPSBUSBOTOBDJPOBJTPVNVM UJOBDJPOBJT UJOIBNDPNPSFGFSpODJBSFHVMBEPSBP&TUBEPOBDJP OBM1BSBRVFFTTBFDPOPNJBSFBMJ[BTTFPCFNFTUBSGPJQSFDJTP RVFP&TUBEPOFMBJOUFSWJFTTFDPNPSFHVMBEPSFDPNPQBSDFJSP PRVFGPJGFJUPQFMBDSJBmkPEPGVOEPQ|CMJDP
-,3
$PNPPQFSBWBNPTGVOEPTQ|CMJDPT 0RVFFTTFTGVOEPT SFQSFTFOUBSBNOBQSgUJDB %FEVBTNBOFJSBTQSJODJQBJT QFMPGJOBODJBNFOUPTJ NVMUiOFPEBBDVNVMBmkPEPDBQJUBM PTHBTUPTQ|CMJDPTDPN BQSPEVmkP EFTEFTVCTrEJPTQBSBBBHSJDVMUVSB BJOE|TUSJBFP DPNnSDJPBUnTVCTrEJPTQBSBBDJpODJBFBUFDOPMPHJB GPSNBOEP BNQMPTTFUPSFTQSPEVUJWPTFTUBUBJTRVFEFTBHVBSBNOPDnMF CSFDPNQMFYPNJMJUBSJOEVTUSJBM BMnNEBWBMPSJ[BmkPGJOBODFJSB EPDBQJUBMQPSNFJPEBErWJEBQ|CMJDB FUD F QFMPGJOBODJB NFOUPEBSFQSPEVmkPEBGPSmBEFUSBCBMIP BMDBOmBOEPUPEB BQPQVMBmkPQPSNFJPEPTHBTUPTTPDJBJT FEVDBmkPHSBUVJUB NFEJDJOBTPDJBMJ[BEB QSFWJEpODJBTPDJBM TFHVSPEFTFNQSFHP TVCTrEJPTQBSBUSBOTQPSUF BMJNFOUBmkPFIBCJUBmkP TVCTrEJPT QBSBDVMUVSBFMB[FS TBMgSJPGBNrMJB TFHVSPEFTFNQSFHP FUD "BmkPEFEVQMPGJOBODJBNFOUPHFSPVVNTFHVOEPTBMgSJP PTB MgSJPJOEJSFUP BPMBEPEPTBMgSJPEJSFUP JTUPn PEJSFUPnBRVF MFQBHPQSJWBEBNFOUFBPUSBCBMIPFPJOEJSFUPnBRVFMFQBHP QVCMJDBNFOUFBPTDJEBEkPTQBSBBSFQSPEVmkPEFTVBGPSmBEF USBCBMIP0SFTVMUBEPGPJPBVNFOUPEBDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOTVNP EBTDMBTTFTTPDJBJT QBSUJDVMBSNFOUFEBDMBTTFNnEJBFEBDMBT TFUSBCBMIBEPSB EBOEPFOTFKPBPDPOTVNPEFNBTTB &NTVNB P&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBMJOUSPEV[JVBSFQ| CMJDBFOUFOEJEBFTUSVUVSBMNFOUFDPNPHFTUkPEPTGVOEPTQ| CMJDPT PTRVBJTTFUPSOBNQSFDPOEJmkPEBBDVNVMBmkPFEB SFQSPEVmkPEPDBQJUBM FEBGPSNBmkPEBUBYBEFMVDSP FEB SFQSPEVmkPEBGPSmBEFUSBCBMIPQPSNFJPEBTEFTQFTBTTPDJBJT /VNBQBMBWSB IPVWFBTPDJBMJ[BmkPEPTDVTUPTEBQSPEVmkPF BNBOVUFOmkPEBBQSPQSJBmkPQSJWBEBEPTMVDSPTPVEBSFOEB JTUPn BSJRVF[BOkPGPJTPDJBMJ[BEB 1PSRVFIBWJBQFSJHPEFSFWPMVm{FTDPNVOJTUBTOPTQBrTFT EP5FSDFJSP.VOEP 0QFSJHPEFTTBTSFWPMVm{FTFYJTUJBQPSEPJTNPUJWPTQSJODJ QBJT PVQPSRVFPTQBrTFTEP5FSDFJSP.VOEPFSBNDPMyOJBT EPTQBrTFTDBQJUBMJTUBT PVQPSRVFOFMFTBEFTJHVBMEBEFFDP OyNJDPTPDJBM BNJTnSJBFBTJOKVTUJmBTFSBNEFUBMNPOUBRVF OBTDPMyOJBT HVFSSBTEFMJCFSUBmkPOBDJPOBMF OPTEFNBJTQBr TFT SFCFMJ{FTQPQVMBSFTQPEJBNBDPOUFDFSBRVBMRVFSNPNFOUP FUSBOTGPSNBSTFFNSFWPMVm{FT 2VFNFEJEBTPTQBrTFTEPCMPDPDBQJUBMJTUBBEPUBSBNQBSB JNQFEJSBTSFWPMVm{FTOP5FSDFJSP.VOEP #BTJDBNFOUFEVBTNFEJEBT QPSNFJPEP#BODP.VOEJBM FEP'VOEP.POFUgSJP*OUFSOBDJPOBM '.* GJ[FSBNFNQSnTUJNPT BPT&TUBEPTEP5FSDFJSP.VOEPQBSBJOWFTUJSOPTTFSWJmPTTP DJBJTFFNFNQSFTBTFTUBUBJT QPSNFJPEPTTFSWJmPTEFFTQJP OBHFNFEBTGPSmBTBSNBEBT PGFSFDFSBN²BKVEB³NJMJUBSQBSB SFQSJNJSSFWPMUBTFSFWPMVm{FT 2VFnPOFPMJCFSBMJTNP 0RVFFMFSFQSFTFOUPVOBQSgUJDB EFTEFRVFGPJJNQMFNFOUBEP 0OFPMJCFSBMJTNPnVNBUFPSJBFDPOyNJDPQPMrUJDBGPSNVMB EBQPSVNHSVQPEFFDPOPNJTUBT DJFOUJTUBTQPMrUJDPTFGJMwTPGPT RVF FN SFVOJVTFFN.POU4BJOU1nMFSJO OB4VrmB hWPMUB EPFDPOPNJTUBBVTUSrBDP)BZFLFEPOPSUFBNFSJDBOP.JMUPO 'SJFENBO&TTFHSVQPPQVOIBTFBPTVSHJNFOUPEP&TUBEPEF #FN&TUBS4PDJBMEFFTUJMPLFZOFTJBOPFTPDJBMEFNPDSBUB/B WFHBOEPDPOUSBBDPSSFOUFEBTEnDBEBTEFF FTTF HSVQPFMBCPSPVVNEFUBMIBEPQSPKFUPFDPOyNJDPFQPMrUJDPOP RVBMBUBDBWBP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBMDPNTFVTFODBSHPT TPDJBJTFDPNBGVOmkPEFSFHVMBEPSEBTBUJWJEBEFTEPNFSDBEP "GJSNBWBRVFFTTFUJQPEFFYQFSJpODJBEFTUSVrBBMJCFSEBEFEPT
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
DJEBEkPTFBDPNQFUJmkP TFNBTRVBJTOkPIgQSPTQFSJEBEF&T TBTJEFJBTQFSNBOFDFSBNDPNPMFUSBNPSUBBUnBDSJTFDBQJUBMJT UBEPJOrDJPEPTBOPT RVBOEPPDBQJUBMJTNPDPOIFDFV QFMB QSJNFJSBWF[ VNUJQPEFTJUVBmkPJNQSFWJTrWFM BEFOPNJOBEB FTUBHGMBmkP1PEFNPTSFTVNJSBUFPSJBFBQSgUJDBOFPMJCFSBJT EJ[FOEPRVF DPNFMBT EgTFPFODPMIJNFOUPEPFTQBmPQ|CMJ DPEPTEJSFJUPTTPDJBJTFPBMBSHBNFOUPEPFTQBmPQSJWBEPEPT JOUFSFTTFTEFNFSDBEP 2VFnFTUBHGMBmkP &TUBHGMBmkPnBTJUVBmkPFNRVFIgCBJYBTUBYBTEFDSFTDJ NFOUPFDPOyNJDPFBMUBTUBYBTEFJOGMBmkP &NRVFTFCBTFPVPOFPMJCFSBMJTNPBQwTBDSJTFEF "FYQMJDBmkPEPHSVQP.POU4BJOU1nMFSJOQBSBBDSJTFEF GPJEFRVFFTUBGPSBDBVTBEBQFMPQPEFSFYDFTTJWPEPTTJO EJDBUPTFEPTNPWJNFOUPTPQFSgSJPT RVFIBWJBNQSFTTJPOBEP QPSBVNFOUPTTBMBSJBJTFFYJHJEPPBVNFOUPEPTFODBSHPTTP DJBJTEP&TUBEP5FSJBN EFTTBNBOFJSB EFTUSVrEPPTOrWFJTEF MVDSPSFRVFSJEPTQFMBTFNQSFTBTFEFTFODBEFBEPPTQSPDFTTPT JOGMBDJPOgSJPTJODPOUSPMgWFJT$PNCBTFOFTTFBSHVNFOUP QSP QyTBTTFHVJOUFTEJSFUSJ[FT VN&TUBEPGPSUFQBSBRVFCSBSP QPEFSEPTTJOEJDBUPTFNPWJNFOUPTPQFSgSJPT QBSBDPOUSPMBS PTEJOIFJSPTQ|CMJDPTFDPSUBSESBTUJDBNFOUFPTFODBSHPTTP DJBJTFPTJOWFTUJNFOUPTOBFDPOPNJB VN&TUBEPDVKBNF UBQSJODJQBMEFWFSJBTFSBFTUBCJMJEBEFNPOFUgSJB DPOUFOEPPT HBTUPTTPDJBJTFSFTUBVSBOEPBUBYBEFEFTFNQSFHPOFDFTTgSJB QBSBGPSNBSVNFYnSDJUPJOEVTUSJBMEFSFTFSWBRVFRVFCSBTTFP QPEFSJPEPTTJOEJDBUPT VN&TUBEPRVFSFBMJ[BTTFVNBSFGPS NBGJTDBMQBSBJODFOUJWBSPTJOWFTUJNFOUPTQSJWBEPTF QPSUBOUP RVFSFEV[JTTFPTJNQPTUPTTPCSFPDBQJUBMFBTGPSUVOBT BVNFO UBOEPPTJNQPTUPTTPCSFBSFOEBJOEJWJEVBMF QPSUBOUP TPCSFP USBCBMIP PDPOTVNPFPDPNnSDJP VN&TUBEPRVFTFBGBTUBT TFEBSFHVMBmkPEBFDPOPNJB EFJYBOEPRVFPQSwQSJPNFSDBEP DPNTVBSBDJPOBMJEBEFQSwQSJB PQFSBTTFBEFTSFHVMBmkPFN PVUSBTQBMBWSBT BCPMJmkPEPTJOWFTUJNFOUPTFTUBUBJTOBQSPEV mkP BCPMJmkPEPDPOUSPMFFTUBUBMTPCSFPGMVYPGJOBODFJSP ESgT UJDBMFHJTMBmkPBOUJHSFWFFWBTUPQSPHSBNBEFQSJWBUJ[BmkP 1BSBPFDPOPNJTUBCSBTJMFJSP'SBODJTDPEF0MJWFJSB RVFGB UPTGPSBNGBWPSgWFJTBPTVSHJNFOUPEPOFPMJCFSBMJTNP %FBDPSEPDPNPFDPOPNJTUBCSBTJMFJSP'SBODJTDPEF0MJWFJ SB OkPGPSBNBTJEFJBTEPTFDPOPNJTUBTEF.POU4BJOU1nMFSJO RVFQVTFSBNFNNBSDIBPOFPMJCFSBMJTNP FTJNBTDPOUSBEJ m{FTEPGVOEPQ|CMJDPJNQMBOUBEPQFMP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS 4PDJBM RVFMFWBSBNBPTFVDPMBQTPFhQSPQPTUBOFPMJCFSBM 1BSBHBSBOUJSTJNVMUBOFBNFOUFBBDVNVMBmkPFSFQSPEVmkPEP DBQJUBMFBEBGPSmBEFUSBCBMIP P&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBM FOEJWJEPVTFFFOUSPVOVNQSPDFTTPEFErWJEBQ|CMJDBDPOIF DJEPDPNPEnGJDJUGJTDBMPV²DSJTFGJTDBMEP&TUBEP³&TTBDSJTF UPSOBTFJODPOUPSOgWFMDPNBJOUFSOBDJPOBMJ[BmkPPMJHPQwMJDB EBQSPEVmkPFEBGJOBOmB QPJTPTPMJHPQwMJPTNVMUJOBDJPOBJT OkPFOWJBNBPTTFVTQBrTFTEFPSJHFNPTHBOIPTPCUJEPTGPSB EFTVBTGSPOUFJSBTF QPSUBOUP OkPBMJNFOUBNPGVOEPQ|CMJDP OBDJPOBM RVFEFWFDPOUJOVBSGJOBODJBOEPPDBQJUBMFBGPSmBEF USBCBMIP "JOEBTFHVOEP'SBODJTDPEF0MJWFJSB QPSRVFBUFPSJBOFP MJCFSBMQSPQyTPFODPMIJNFOUPEP&TUBEP 1PSRVF DPNTVBQSFTFOmBOBGPSNBEPTBMgSJPJOEJSFUP P GVOEPQ|CMJDPEFTBUPVPMBmPRVFQSFOEJBPDBQJUBMhGPSmBEF USBCBMIP&TTBBNBSSBFSBPRVF OPQBTTBEP GB[JBBJOPWBmkP
UnDOJDBQFMPDBQJUBMTFSVNBSFBmkPBPBVNFOUPSFBMEFTBMgSJP F EFTGFJUPPMBmP PJNQVMTPhJOPWBmkPUFDOPMwHJDBUPSOPV TFQSBUJDBNFOUFJMJNJUBEP QSPWPDBOEPFYQBOTkPEPTJOWFTUJ NFOUPTFBHJHBOUBNFOUPEBTGPSmBTQSPEVUJWBTDVKBMJRVJEF[n JNQSFTTJPOBOUF NBTDVKPMVDSPOkPnTVGJDJFOUFQBSBDPODSF UJ[BSUPEBTBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTUFDOPMwHJDBT1PSJTTPNFTNP P DBQJUBMQSFDJTBEFQBSDFMBTEBSJRVF[BQ|CMJDB JTUPn EPGVOEP Q|CMJDP OBRVBMJEBEFEFGJOBODJBEPSEFTTBDPODSFUJ[BmkP1BSB UBOUP nQSFDJTPRVFEFTBQBSFmBP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBM PVTFKB UPEPTPTCFOFGrDJPTTPDJBJTRVFEJSJHFNPGVOEPQ|CMJ DPQBSBBHBSBOUJBEFEJSFJUPTTPDJBJT 2VFQSJODrQJPTPSJFOUBSBNBTPDJFEBEFDBQJUBMJTUBEPJOrDJP EPTnDVMP99BUnPTBOPT #BTJDBNFOUFEPJTHSBOEFTQSJODrQJPT PQSJODrQJPEF,FZ OFTEFJOUFSWFOmkPEP&TUBEPOBFDPOPNJBQPSNFJPEFJOWFTUJ NFOUPTFFOEJWJEBNFOUPQBSBEJTUSJCVJmkPEBSFOEBFQSPNPmkP EPCFNFTUBSTPDJBM WJTBOEPEJNJOVJSBTEFTJHVBMEBEFT P QSJODrQJPEF)FOSZ'PSEEFPSHBOJ[BmkPJOEVTUSJBMCBTFBEBOP QMBOFKBNFOUP OBGVODJPOBMJEBEFFOPMPOHPQSB[PEPUSBCBMIP JOEVTUSJBM DPNBDFOUSBMJ[BmkPFWFSUJDBMJ[BmkPEBTQMBOUBTJO EVTUSJBJT HSBOEFTMJOIBTEFNPOUBHFOTDPODFOUSBEBTOVN|OJDP FTQBmP GPSNBmkPEFHSBOEFTFTUPRVFTFPSJFOUBEPQFMBTJEFJBT EFSBDJPOBMJEBEFFEVSBCJMJEBEFEPTQSPEVUPT FEFQPMrUJDBTBMB SJBMFQSPNPDJPOBMWJTBOEPBVNFOUBSBDBQBDJEBEFEFDPOTVNP EPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT &YQMJRVFFNSgQJEBTQBMBWSBTPTQSJODJQBJTBTQFDUPTEP DBQJUBMJTNPOBBUVBMJEBEF PEFTFNQSFHPUPSOPVTFFTUSVUVSBM EFJYBOEPEFTFSBDJ EFOUBMPVFYQSFTTkPEFVNBDSJTFDPOKVOUVSBM QPSRVFBGPSNB DPOUFNQPSiOFBEPDBQJUBMJTNP BPDPOUSgSJPEFTVBGPSNBDMgT TJDB OkPPQFSBQPSJODMVTkPEFUPEBBTPDJFEBEFOPNFSDBEPEF USBCBMIPFEFDPOTVNP NBTQPSFYDMVTkP PNPOFUBSJTNPFP DBQJUBMGJOBODFJSPUPSOBSBNTFPDPSBmkPFPDFOUSPOFSWPTPEP DBQJUBMJTNP BNQMJBOEPBEFTWBMPSJ[BmkPEPUSBCBMIPQSPEVUJ WPFQSJWJMFHJBOEPBNBJTBCTUSBUBEBTNFSDBEPSJBT PEJOIFJSP BUFSDFJSJ[BmkP JTUPn PBVNFOUPEPTFUPSEFTFSWJmPTUPS OPVTFFTUSVUVSBM EFJYBOEPEFTFSVNTVQMFNFOUPhQSPEVmkP QPSRVF BHPSB BQSPEVmkPOkPNBJTTFSFBMJ[BTPCBBOUJHBGPS NBGPSEJTUBEBTHSBOEFTQMBOUBTJOEVTUSJBJTRVFDPODFOUSBWBN UPEBTBTFUBQBTEBQSPEVmkP±EBBRVJTJmkPEBNBUnSJBQSJNB hEJTUSJCVJmkPEPTQSPEVUPT± NBTPQFSBQPSGSBHNFOUBmkP FEJTQFSTkPEFUPEBTBTFTGFSBTFFUBQBTEBQSPEVmkP DPNB DPNQSBEFTFSWJmPTOPNVOEPJOUFJSP BDJpODJBFBUFDOPMPHJB UPSOBSBNTFGPSmBTQSPEVUJWBT EFJYBOEPEFTFSNFSPTVQPSUF EPDBQJUBMQBSBTFDPOWFSUFSFNBHFOUFTEFTVBBDVNVMBmkP $POTFRVFOUFNFOUF NVEPVPNPEPEFJOTFSmkPEPTDJFOUJTUBT FUnDOJDPTOBTPDJFEBEF QPSRVFFTUFTUPSOBSBNTFBHFOUFT FDPOyNJDPTEJSFUPTFBGPSmBFPQPEFSDBQJUBMJTUBTFODPOUSBN TFOPNPOPQwMJPEPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTFEBJOGPSNBmkP BHPSB PDBQJUBMJTNPEJTQFOTBFSFKFJUBBQSFTFOmBFTUBUBMOkPTwOP NFSDBEP NBTUBNCnNOBTQPMrUJDBTTPDJBJT EFTPSUFRVFBQSJ WBUJ[BmkPUBOUPEFFNQSFTBTRVBOUPEFTFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPTUBN CnNUPSOPVTFFTUSVUVSBM%JTTPSFTVMUBRVFBJEFJBEFEJSFJUPT TPDJBJTDPNPQSFTTVQPTUPFHBSBOUJBEPTEJSFJUPTDJWJTPVQPMrUJ DPTUFOEFBEFTBQBSFDFS BUSBOTOBDJPOBMJ[BmkPEBFDPOPNJB UPSOBEFTOFDFTTgSJBBGJHVSBEP&TUBEPOBDJPOBMDPNPFODMBWF UFSSJUPSJBMQBSBPDBQJUBMFEJTQFOTBBTGPSNBTDMgTTJDBTEPJN QFSJBMJTNP DPMPOJBMJTNPQPMrUJDPNJMJUBS HFPQPMrUJDBEFgSFBT EFJOGMVpODJB FUD
EFTPSUFRVFPDFOUSPFDPOyNJDP KVSrEJDP FQPMrUJDPQMBOFUgSJPFODPOUSBTFOP'.*FOP#BODP.VOEJBM &TUFTPQFSBNDPNVN|OJDPEPHNB QSPQPTUPQFMPHSVQPGVO
-,4
Manual do Professor
EBEPSEPOFPMJCFSBMJTNP RVBMTFKBFTUBCJMJEBEFFDPOyNJDBF DPSUFEPEnGJDJUQ|CMJDP BEJTUJOmkPFOUSFQBrTFTEF1SJNFJSP F5FSDFJSP.VOEPUFOEFBTFSTVCTUJUVrEBQFMBFYJTUpODJB FN DBEBQBrT EFVNBEJWJTkPFOUSFCPMT{FTEFSJRVF[BBCTPMVUBF EFNJTnSJBBCTPMVUB
#APqTULOß߯ßß=mqaopk`aik_n pe_] 5BOUPPMJCFSBMJTNPDPNPP&TUBEPEF#FN&TUBS4PDJBMEF GJOFNBEFNPDSBDJBDPNPSFHJNFEBMFJFEBPSEFNQBSBB HBSBOUJBEBTMJCFSEBEFTJOEJWJEVBJT0RVFJTTPTJHOJGJDB &NQSJNFJSPMVHBS RVFJEFOUJGJDBNMJCFSEBEFFDPNQFUJmkP ±UBOUPBDPNQFUJmkPFDPOyNJDBEBDIBNBEB²MJWSFJOJDJBUJWB³ RVBOUPBDPNQFUJmkPQPMrUJDBFOUSFQBSUJEPTRVFEJTQVUBNFMFJ m{FT&NTFHVOEPMVHBS RVFJEFOUJGJDBNBMFJDPNBQPUpODJB KVEJDJgSJBQBSBMJNJUBSPQPEFSQPMrUJDP EFGFOEFOEPBTPDJFEBEF DPOUSBBUJSBOJB QPJTBMFJHBSBOUFPTHPWFSOPTFTDPMIJEPTQFMB WPOUBEFEBNBJPSJB&NUFSDFJSPMVHBS RVFJEFOUJGJDBNBPSEFN DPNBQPUpODJBEP&YFDVUJWPFEP+VEJDJgSJPQBSBDPOUFSFMJNJUBS PTDPOGMJUPTTPDJBJT JNQFEJOEPPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBMVUBEF DMBTTFT TFKBQFMBSFQSFTTkP TFKBQFMPBUFOEJNFOUPEBTEFNBO EBTQPSEJSFJUPTTPDJBJT FNQSFHP CPBTDPOEJm{FTEFUSBCBMIPF TBMgSJP FEVDBmkP NPSBEJB TB|EF USBOTQPSUF MB[FS &FNRVBS UPMVHBS RVF FNCPSBBEFNPDSBDJBBQBSFmBKVTUJGJDBEBDPNP ²WBMPS³PVDPNP²CFN³ nFODBSBEB EFGBUP QFMPDSJUnSJPEBFGJ DgDJB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT EFGFOEFNBEFNPDSBDJBQPSRVFMIFT QBSFDFVNSFHJNFGBWPSgWFMhBQBUJBQPMrUJDB±BQPMrUJDBTFSJB BTTVOUPEPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT RVFTkPQPMrUJDPTQSPGJTTJPOBJT± RVF QPSTFVUVSOP GBWPSFDFBGPSNBmkPEFVNBFMJUFEFUnDOJ DPTDPNQFUFOUFTBPTRVBJTDBCFBEJSFmkPEP&TUBEP FWJUBOEP EFTTBNBOFJSB VNBQBSUJDJQBmkPQPMrUJDBRVFUSBSJBhDFOBPT ²FYUSFNJTUBT³F²SBEJDBJT³EBTPDJFEBEF JTUPn PT²JODPNQF UFOUFT³"EFNPDSBDJBn BTTJN SFEV[JEBBVNSFHJNFQPMrUJDP FGJDB[ CBTFBEPOBJEFJBEFDJEBEBOJBPSHBOJ[BEBFNQBSUJEPT QPMrUJDPTFNBOJGFTUBOEPTFOPQSPDFTTPFMFJUPSBMEFFTDPMIBEPT SFQSFTFOUBOUFT OBSPUBUJWJEBEFEPTHPWFSOBOUFTFOBTTPMVm{FT UnDOJDBT FOkPQPMrUJDBT QBSBPTQSPCMFNBTTPDJBJT 0RVFTFFTUgRVFSFOEPEJ[FSRVBOEPTFBGJSNBRVF EFTEF B3FWPMVmkP'SBODFTB ²BEFNPDSBDJBnGPSNBM OkPnDPO DSFUB³ 2VF EFTEFB3FWPMVmkP'SBODFTBEF BEFNPDSBDJB EFDMBSBPTEJSFJUPTVOJWFSTBJTEPIPNFNFEPDJEBEkP NBTB TPDJFEBEFFTUgFTUSVUVSBEBEFUBMNBOFJSBRVFUBJTEJSFJUPTOkP QPEFNFYJTUJSDPODSFUBNFOUFQBSBBNBJPSJBEBQPQVMBmkP 0RVFTFRVFSEJ[FSRVBOEPTFBGJSNBRVF²BJEFPMPHJBOkP OBTDFEPOBEBOFNSFQPVTBOPWB[JP NBTFYQSJNF EFNB OFJSBJOWFSUJEB EJTTJNVMBEBFJNBHJOgSJB BQSgYJTTPDJBMF IJTUwSJDBDPODSFUBT³ 2VFIg OBQSgUJDBEFNPDSgUJDBFOBTJEFJBTEFNPDSgUJDBT VNBQSPGVOEJEBEFFVNBWFSEBEFNVJUPNBJPSFTFTVQFSJPSFT BPRVFBJEFPMPHJBEFNPDSgUJDBQFSDFCFFEFJYBQFSDFCFS 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEBTFMFJm{FTOVNBEFNPDSBDJB 4JHOJGJDBNPFTTFODJBMEBEFNPDSBDJBRVFPQPEFSOkPTF JEFOUJGJDBDPNPTPDVQBOUFTEPHPWFSOP OkPMIFTQFSUFODF NBTnTFNQSFVNMVHBSWB[JPRVFPTDJEBEkPT QFSJPEJDBNFOUF QSFFODIFNDPNVNSFQSFTFOUBOUF QPEFOEPSFWPHBSTFVNBO EBUPTFOkPDVNQSJSPRVFMIFGPJEFMFHBEPQBSBSFQSFTFOUBS
-,5
/VNBEFNPDSBDJB RVFTJHOJGJDBNBTJEFJBTEFTJUVBmkPF PQPTJmkP EFNBJPSJBFNJOPSJB 5BJTJEFJBTTJHOJGJDBNRVFBTPDJFEBEFOkPnVNBDPNVOJ EBEFVOBFJOEJWJTBWPMUBEBQBSBPCFNDPNVNPCUJEPQPSDPO TFOTP NBT BPDPOUSgSJP RVFFTUgJOUFSOBNFOUFEJWJEJEBFRVF BTEJWJT{FTTkPMFHrUJNBTFEFWFNFYQSFTTBSTFQVCMJDBNFOUF "EFNPDSBDJBnB|OJDBGPSNBQPMrUJDBRVFDPOTJEFSBPDPOGMJUP MFHrUJNPFMFHBM QFSNJUJOEPRVFTFKBUSBCBMIBEPQPMJUJDBNFOUF QFMBQSwQSJBTPDJFEBEF 2VFTJHOJGJDBBGJSNBSRVFBTJEFJBTEFJHVBMEBEFFMJCFSEB EFDPNPEJSFJUPTDJWJTEPTDJEBEkPTWkPNVJUPBMnNEFTVB SFHVMBNFOUBmkPKVSrEJDBGPSNBM 4JHOJGJDBRVFPTDJEBEkPTTkPTVKFJUPTEFEJSFJUPTFRVF POEFUBJTEJSFJUPTOkPFYJTUBNOFNFTUFKBNHBSBOUJEPT UFN TFPEJSFJUPEFMVUBSQPSFMFTFFYJHJMPTcFTTFPDFSOFEBEF NPDSBDJB &YQMJRVFFNRVFNFEJEBVNEJSFJUPEJGFSFEFVNBOFDFTTJ EBEFPVDBSpODJBPVEFVNJOUFSFTTF 6NBOFDFTTJEBEFPVDBSpODJBnBMHPQBSUJDVMBSFFTQFDrGJ DP"MHVnNQPEFUFSOFDFTTJEBEFEFgHVB PVUSP EFDPNJEB 6NHSVQPTPDJBMQPEFUFSDBSpODJBEFUSBOTQPSUFT PVUSP EF IPTQJUBJT)gUBOUBTOFDFTTJEBEFTRVBOUPJOEJWrEVPT UBOUBT DBSpODJBTRVBOUPHSVQPTTPDJBJT6NJOUFSFTTFUBNCnNnBMHP QBSUJDVMBSFFTQFDrGJDP0TJOUFSFTTFTEPTFTUVEBOUFTCSBTJMFJSPT QPEFNTFSEJGFSFOUFTEPTJOUFSFTTFTEPTFTUVEBOUFTBSHFOUJOPT 0TJOUFSFTTFTEPTBHSJDVMUPSFTQPEFNTFSEJGFSFOUFTEPTJOUFSFT TFTEPTDPNFSDJBOUFT0TEPTCBODgSJPT EJGFSFOUFTEPTJOUFSFT TFTEPTCBORVFJSPT0TEPTrOEJPT EJGFSFOUFTEPTJOUFSFTTFTEPT HBSJNQFJSPT/FDFTTJEBEFTPVDBSpODJBTQPEFNTFSDPOGMJUBOUFT 4VQPOIBNPTRVF QPSFYFNQMP OVNBSFHJkPEFVNBHSBOEFDJ EBEF BTNVMIFSFTUSBCBMIBEPSBTUFOIBNOFDFTTJEBEFPVDBSpO DJBEFDSFDIFTQBSBTFVTGJMIPTFRVF OBNFTNBSFHJkP VNPVUSP HSVQPTPDJBM GBWFMBEPT UFOIBDBSpODJBEFNPSBEJB0HPWFSOP NVOJDJQBMEJTQ{FEFSFDVSTPTQBSBBUFOEFSBVNBEBTDBSpODJBT NBTOkPBBNCBT EFTPSUFRVFSFTPMWFSVNBTJHOJGJDBSgBCBO EPOBSBPVUSB*OUFSFTTFTUBNCnNQPEFNTFSDPOGMJUBOUFT4V QPOIBNPT QPSFYFNQMP RVFJOUFSFTTFBHSBOEFTQSPQSJFUgSJPT EFUFSSBTEFJYgMBTJOBUJWBTFTQFSBOEPBWBMPSJ[BmkPJNPCJMJgSJB NBTRVFJOUFSFTTFBUSBCBMIBEPSFTSVSBJTTFNUFSSBPDVMUJWPEF BMJNFOUPTQBSBBTPCSFWJWpODJBUFNPTBrVNDPOGMJUPEFJOUFSFT TFT4VQPOIBNPTRVFJOUFSFTTFBPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTEFFNQSFTBT DPNFSDJBJTFTUBCFMFDFSVNIPSgSJPEFUSBCBMIPRVFBVNFOUFBT WFOEBT NBTRVFJOUFSFTTFBPTDPNFSDJgSJPTVNPVUSPIPSgSJP OPRVBMQPTTBNEJTQPSEFIPSBTQBSBFTUVEBS DVJEBSEBGBNrMJB FEFTDBOTBS5FNPTBRVJVNPVUSPDPOGMJUPEFJOUFSFTTFT6NEJ SFJUP BPDPOUSgSJPEFOFDFTTJEBEFT DBSpODJBTFJOUFSFTTFT OkP nQBSUJDVMBSFFTQFDrGJDP NBTHFSBMFVOJWFSTBM WgMJEPQBSBUPEPT PTJOEJWrEVPT HSVQPTFDMBTTFTTPDJBJT"TTJN QPSFYFNQMP B DBSpODJBEFgHVBFEFDPNJEBNBOJGFTUBBMHPNBJTQSPGVOEPP EJSFJUPhWJEB"DBSpODJBEFNPSBEJBPVEFUSBOTQPSUFUBNCnN NBOJGFTUBBMHPNBJTQSPGVOEPPEJSFJUPBCPBTDPOEJm{FTEFWJ EB0JOUFSFTTFEPTFTUVEBOUFT PEJSFJUPhFEVDBmkPFhJOGPS NBmkP0JOUFSFTTFEPTTFNUFSSB PEJSFJUPBPUSBCBMIP0EPT DPNFSDJgSJPT PEJSFJUPBCPBTDPOEJm{FTEFUSBCBMIP $PNCBTFOBSFTQPTUBEBRVFTUkPBOUFSJPS FNRVFNPNFO UPQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFVNBTPDJFEBEF±FOkPVNTJNQMFT SFHJNFEFHPWFSOP±nEFNPDSgUJDB %J[FNPTRVFVNBTPDJFEBEF±FOkPVNTJNQMFTSFHJNF EFHPWFSOP±nEFNPDSgUJDBRVBOEP BMnNEFFMFJm{FT QBSUJ
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
EPTQPMrUJDPT EJWJTkPEPTUSpTQPEFSFTEBSFQ|CMJDB SFTQFJUPh WPOUBEFEBNBJPSJBFEBTNJOPSJBT JOTUJUVJBMHPNBJTQSPGVOEP RVFnDPOEJmkPEPQSwQSJPSFHJNFQPMrUJDP PVTFKB RVBOEPJOT UJUVJEJSFJUPT 2VBJTPTUSpTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTRVFEFGJOJBNPDJEBEkP OB(SnDJBBOUJHB *HVBMEBEF MJCFSEBEFFQBSUJDJQBmkPOPQPEFS 2VFTJHOJGJDBWBBJHVBMEBEFOB(SnDJBBOUJHB 2VFBGJSNBWB .BSYBFTTFSFTQFJUP *HVBMEBEFTJHOJGJDBWB QFSBOUFBTMFJTFPTDPTUVNFTEBQwMJT RVFUPEPTPTDJEBEkPTQPTTVFNPTNFTNPTEJSFJUPTFEFWFNTFS USBUBEPTEBNFTNBNBOFJSB1PSFTTFNPUJWP "SJTUwUFMFTBGJSNB WBRVFBQSJNFJSBUBSFGBEBKVTUJmBFSBJHVBMBSPTEFTJHVBJT TFKB QFMBSFEJTUSJCVJmkPEBSJRVF[BTPDJBM TFKBQFMBHBSBOUJBEFQBSUJ DJQBmkPOPHPWFSOP5BNCnNQFMPNFTNPNPUJWP .BSYBGJSNBWB RVFBJHVBMEBEFTwTFUPSOBSJBVNEJSFJUPDPODSFUPRVBOEPOkP IPVWFTTFFTDSBWPT TFSWPTFBTTBMBSJBEPTFYQMPSBEPT NBTGPT TFEBEPBDBEBVNTFHVOEPTVBTOFDFTTJEBEFTFTFHVOEPTFV USBCBMIP 0RVFOBWFSEBEFFTUgQPSUSgTEBTGBMBTEF"SJTUwUFMFTFEF .BSY BSFTQFJUPEBJHVBMEBEF "PCTFSWBmkPEF"SJTUwUFMFTF EFQPJT BEF.BSY JOEJDBN BMHPQSFDJTPBNFSBEFDMBSBmkPEPEJSFJUPhJHVBMEBEFOkPGB[ FYJTUJSPTJHVBJT NBTBCSFPDBNQPQBSBBDSJBmkPEBJHVBMEBEF BUSBWnTEBTFYJHpODJBTFEFNBOEBTEPTTVKFJUPTTPDJBJT&N PVUSBTQBMBWSBT EFDMBSBEPPEJSFJUPhJHVBMEBEF BTPDJFEB EFQPEFJOTUJUVJSGPSNBTEFSFJWJOEJDBmkPQBSBDSJgMPDPNP EJSFJUPSFBM 2VBMPTJHOJGJDBEPEBMJCFSEBEFOB(SnDJBBOUJHB -JCFSEBEFTJHOJGJDBWBRVFUPEPDJEBEkPUFNPEJSFJUPEF FYQPSFNQ|CMJDPTFVTJOUFSFTTFTFTVBTPQJOJ{FT WpMPTEF CBUJEPTQFMPTEFNBJTFBQSPWBEPTPVSFKFJUBEPTQFMBNBJPSJB EFWFOEPBDBUBSBEFDJTkPUPNBEBQVCMJDBNFOUF/BNPEFSOJ EBEF DPNB3FWPMVmkP*OHMFTBEFFB3FWPMVmkP'SBODF TBEF PEJSFJUPhMJCFSEBEFBNQMJPVTF"MnNEBMJCFSEB EFEFQFOTBNFOUPFEFFYQSFTTkP QBTTPVBTJHOJGJDBSPEJSFJUP hJOEFQFOEpODJBQBSBFTDPMIFSPPGrDJP PMPDBMEFNPSBEJB P UJQPEFFEVDBmkP PDyOKVHF FNTVNB BSFDVTBEBTIJFSBS RVJBTGJYBT TVQPTUBNFOUFEJWJOBTPVOBUVSBJT"DSFTDFOUPV TF FN VNEJSFJUPEFFOPSNFJNQPSUiODJB RVBMTFKB P EFRVFUPEPJOEJWrEVPnJOPDFOUFBUnQSPWBFNDPOUSgSJP RVF BQSPWBEFWFTFSFTUBCFMFDJEBQFSBOUFVNUSJCVOBMFRVFBMJ CFSBmkPPVQVOJmkPEFWFNTFSEBEBTTFHVOEPBMFJ$PNPT NPWJNFOUPTTPDJBMJTUBT BMVUBTPDJBMQPSMJCFSEBEFBNQMJPV BJOEBNBJTFTTFEJSFJUP BDSFTDFOUBOEPMIFPEJSFJUPEFMVUBS DPOUSBUPEBTBTGPSNBTEFUJSBOJB DFOTVSBFUPSUVSBFDPOUSB UPEBTBTGPSNBTEFFYQMPSBmkPFEPNJOBmkPTPDJBM FDPOyNJ DB DVMUVSBMFQPMrUJDB 2VBJTBTDPOTFRVpODJBT OPEFDVSTPEBIJTUwSJB EPDPODFJ UPEFMJCFSEBEFUBMDPNPPTHSFHPTPFOUFOEJBN /BNPEFSOJEBEF DPNB3FWPMVmkP*OHMFTBEFFB3F WPMVmkP'SBODFTBEF PEJSFJUPhMJCFSEBEF UBMDPNPPFO UFOEJBNPTHSFHPT UFWFBNQMJBEPPTJHOJGJDBEPEFTFVBMDBODF "MnNEBMJCFSEBEFEFQFOTBNFOUPFEFFYQSFTTkP QBTTPVBTJH OJGJDBSPEJSFJUPhJOEFQFOEpODJBQBSBFTDPMIFSPPGrDJP PMPDBMEF NPSBEJB PUJQPEFFEVDBmkP PDyOKVHF FNTVNB BSFDVTBEBT IJFSBSRVJBTGJYBT TVQPTUBNFOUFEJWJOBTPVOBUVSBJT"DSFTDFO
UPVTF FN VNEJSFJUPEFFOPSNFJNQPSUiODJB RVBMTFKB PEFRVFUPEPJOEJWrEVPnJOPDFOUFBUnQSPWBFNDPOUSgSJP RVF BQSPWBEFWFTFSFTUBCFMFDJEBQFSBOUFVNUSJCVOBMFRVFBMJCF SBmkPPVQVOJmkPEFWFNTFSEBEBTTFHVOEPBMFJ$PNPTNP WJNFOUPTTPDJBMJTUBT BMVUBTPDJBMQPSMJCFSEBEFBNQMJPVBJOEB NBJTFTTFEJSFJUP BDSFTDFOUBOEPMIFPEJSFJUPEFMVUBSDPOUSB UPEBTBTGPSNBTEFUJSBOJB DFOTVSBFUPSUVSBFDPOUSBUPEBTBT GPSNBTEFFYQMPSBmkPFEPNJOBmkPTPDJBM FDPOyNJDB DVMUVSBM FQPMrUJDB *HVBMNFOUFDPNPPDPSSFDPNBOPmkPEFJHVBMEBEF FYJTUF VNEFTDPNQBTTPFOUSFBEFDMBSBmkPEPEJSFJUPhMJCFSEBEF FBTVBJOTUJUVJmkPDPODSFUB$PNPFTTBEJWFSHpODJBTFSF TPMWFOBQSgUJDBTPDJBM %FGBUP BTJNQMFTEFDMBSBmkPEPEJSFJUPhMJCFSEBEFOkP BJOTUJUVJDPODSFUBNFOUF NBTBCSFPDBNQPIJTUwSJDPQBSBB DSJBmkPEFTTFEJSFJUPQFMBQSgYJTIVNBOB±FOJTUPDPOTJTUFB WJBCJMJEBEFEFTVBJNQMFNFOUBmkPOBQSgUJDB 0RVFTJHOJGJDBWBBQBSUJDJQBmkPOPQPEFS OB(SnDJBBOUJHB 4JHOJGJDBWBRVFUPEPTPTDJEBEkPTUpNPEJSFJUPEFQBSUJDJ QBSEBTEJTDVTT{FTFEFMJCFSBm{FTQ|CMJDBTEBQwMJT WPUBOEPPV SFWPHBOEPEFDJT{FT&TTFEJSFJUPQPTTVrBVNTFOUJEPNVJUPQSF DJTP/FMFBGJSNBWBTFRVF EPQPOUPEFWJTUBQPMrUJDP UPEPTPT DJEBEkPTUpNDPNQFUpODJBQBSBPQJOBSFEFDJEJS QPJTBQPMrUJDB OkPnVNBRVFTUkPUnDOJDBOFNDJFOUrGJDB NBTBmkPDPMFUJWB JT UPn EFDJTkPDPMFUJWBRVBOUPBPTJOUFSFTTFTFEJSFJUPTEBQSwQSJB QwMJT "EFNPDSBDJBHSFHBFSBEJSFUBBNPEFSOBnSFQSFTFOUBUJWB 0RVFJTTPTJHOJGJDB 4JHOJGJDBRVFPEJSFJUPhQBSUJDJQBmkPUPSOPVTFJOEJSFUP PV TFKB GFJUPQFMBFTDPMIBEFSFQSFTFOUBOUFT"PDPOUSgSJPEPTPV USPTEPJTEJSFJUPT FTUF|MUJNPQBSFDFUFSTPGSJEPEJNJOVJmkPFN MVHBSEFBNQMJBmkP&TTBBQBSpODJBnGBMTBFWFSEBEFJSB'BMTB QPSRVFBEFNPDSBDJBNPEFSOBGPJJOTUJUVrEBOBMVUBDPOUSBP"O UJHP3FHJNFF QPSUBOUP FNSFMBmkPBFTTF|MUJNP BNQMJPVB QBSUJDJQBmkPEPTDJEBEkPTOPQPEFS BJOEBRVFTPCBGPSNBEB SFQSFTFOUBmkP&WFSEBEFJSBQPSRVFBSFQ|CMJDBMJCFSBMUFOEFVB MJNJUBSPTEJSFJUPTQPMrUJDPTBPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPT EFQSPEVmkPFBPTQSPGJTTJPOBJTMJCFSBJTEBDMBTTFNnEJB BPT IPNFOTBEVMUPT²JOEFQFOEFOUFT³5PEBWJB BTMVUBTTPDJBMJTUBT FQPQVMBSFTGPSmBSBNBBNQMJBmkPEPTEJSFJUPTQPMrUJDPTDPNB DSJBmkPEPTVGSgHJPVOJWFSTBMFBHBSBOUJBEBFMFHJCJMJEBEFEF RVBMRVFSVNRVF OkPFTUBOEPTPCTVTQFJUBEFDSJNF TFBQSF TFOUFBVNDBSHPFMFUJWP 2VFTFFOUFOEFQPSEJSFJUPTTPDJBJT 4kPBRVFMFTEJSFJUPTPSJVOEPTEBTMVUBTQPSJHVBMEBEFFMJ CFSEBEFFRVFTFSFMBDJPOBNBPUSBCBMIP hNPSBEJB hTB|EF BPUSBOTQPSUF hFEVDBmkP BPMB[FSFhDVMUVSB4kPUBNCnNPT EJSFJUPTEBTDIBNBEBT²NJOPSJBT³±NVMIFSFT JEPTPT OFHSPT IPNPTTFYVBJT DSJBOmBT rOEJPT±FPTSFGFSFOUFThTFHVSBOmB QMBOFUgSJB±BTMVUBTFDPMwHJDBTFDPOUSBBTBSNBTOVDMFBSFT 2VFTkP²NJOPSJBT³ "QBMBWSBNJOPSJBOkPnVTBEBFNTFOUJEPRVBOUJUBUJWP NBTRVBMJUBUJWP2VBOEPPQFOTBNFOUPQPMrUJDPMJCFSBMEFGJOJV PTRVFUFSJBNEJSFJUPhDJEBEBOJB VTPVDPNPDSJUnSJPBJEFJBEF NBJPSJEBEFSBDJPOBMTFSJBNDJEBEkPTBRVFMFTRVFIPVWFTTFN BMDBOmBEPPQMFOPVTPEBSB[kP"MDBOmBSBNPQMFOPVTPEB SB[kPPVBNBJPSJEBEFSBDJPOBMPTRVFTkPJOEFQFOEFOUFT JTUP
--,
Manual do Professor
n PTRVFOkPEFQFOEFNEFPVUSPTQBSBWJWFS4kPJOEFQFO EFOUFTPTQSPQSJFUgSJPTQSJWBEPTEPTNFJPTEFQSPEVmkPFPT QSPGJTTJPOBJTMJCFSBJT4kPEFQFOEFOUFTF QPSUBOUP FNFTUBEP EFNJOPSJEBEFSBDJPOBMBTNVMIFSFT BTDSJBOmBT PTBEPMFTDFO UFT PTUSBCBMIBEPSFTFPT²TFMWBHFOTQSJNJUJWPT³ BGSJDBOPTF rOEJPT $PNPIgPVUSPTHSVQPTDVKPTEJSFJUPTOkPTkPSFDPOIF DJEPT QPSFYFNQMP PTIPNPTTFYVBJT
GBMBTFFN²NJOPSJBT³ "²NBJPSJEBEF³MJCFSBMSFGFSFTF QPJT BPIPNFNBEVMUPCSBODP QSPQSJFUgSJPPVQSPGJTTJPOBMMJCFSBM "TPDJFEBEFEFNPDSgUJDBJOTUJUVJEJSFJUPTQFMBBCFSUVSBEP DBNQPTPDJBMhDSJBmkPEFEJSFJUPTSFBJT hBNQMJBmkPEFEJ SFJUPTFYJTUFOUFTFhDSJBmkPEFOPWPTEJSFJUPT PRVFDPOGF SFBFMBUSBmPTRVFBEJTUJOHVFNEFUPEBTBTPVUSBTGPSNBT TPDJBJTFQPMrUJDBTFYJTUFOUFTOPEFDVSTPEBIJTUwSJB2VF USBmPTTkPFTTFT 1PEFNPTJEFOUJGJDBSEPJTUSBmPTJNQPSUBOUFT BEFNPDSB DJBnB|OJDBTPDJFEBEFFP|OJDPSFHJNFQPMrUJDPRVFDPOTJEFSB PDPOGMJUPMFHrUJNP/kPTwUSBCBMIBQPMJUJDBNFOUFPTDPOGMJUPT EFOFDFTTJEBEFTFEFJOUFSFTTFT NBTQSPDVSBJOTUJUVrMPTDPNP EJSFJUPTF DPNPUBJT FYJHFRVFTFKBNSFDPOIFDJEPTFSFTQFJUB EPT.BJTEPRVFJTTP OBTPDJFEBEFEFNPDSgUJDB JOEJWrEVPT FHSVQPTPSHBOJ[BNTFFNBTTPDJBm{FT NPWJNFOUPTTPDJBJT FQPQVMBSFT DMBTTFTTFPSHBOJ[BNFNTJOEJDBUPTFQBSUJEPT DSJBOEPVNDPOUSBQPEFSTPDJBMRVF EJSFUBPVJOEJSFUBNFOUF MJNJUBPQPEFSEP&TUBEP BEFNPDSBDJBnBTPDJFEBEFWFSEB EFJSBNFOUFIJTUwSJDB JTUPn BCFSUBBPUFNQP BPQPTTrWFM hT USBOTGPSNBm{FTFBPOPWP$PNFGFJUP QFMBDSJBmkPEFOPWPT EJSFJUPTFQFMBFYJTUpODJBEPTDPOUSBQPEFSFTTPDJBJT BTPDJF EBEFEFNPDSgUJDBOkPFTUgGJYBEBOVNBGPSNBQBSBTFNQSF EFUFSNJOBEB PVTFKB OkPDFTTBEFUSBCBMIBSTVBTEJWJT{FTF EJGFSFOmBTJOUFSOBT EFPSJFOUBSTFQFMBQPTTJCJMJEBEFPCKFUJWB BMJCFSEBEF FEFBMUFSBSTFQFMBQSwQSJBQSgYJT 2VFnQSJWBUJ[BmkP &EFTSFHVMBmkP &NRVFNFEJEBBGF UBNPNPEPEFQSPEVmkPDBQJUBMJTUB 1SJWBUJ[BmkPnPBCBOEPOPQFMP&TUBEPEBTQPMrUJDBTTP DJBJT EFTSFHVMBmkP P BCBOEPOP UBNCnN QFMP &TUBEP EP QMBOFKBNFOUPFDPOyNJDP"NCPTPTUFSNPTBTTFWFSBNRVFP DBQJUBMnSBDJPOBMFQPEF QPSTJNFTNP SFTPMWFSPTQSPCMFNBT FDPOyNJDPTFTPDJBJT 2VBJTPTFGFJUPTEPSgQJEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTSFDFOUFT UFDOPMPHJBTFMFUSyOJDBTEBJOGPSNBmkPOPNVOEPDPOUFN QPSiOFP "MJBEPhQSJWBUJ[BmkPFhEFTSFHVMBmkP PEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP FTQBOUPTPEBTOPWBTUFDOPMPHJBTFMFUSyOJDBTUSPVYFBWFMPDJEB EFEBDPNVOJDBmkPFEBJOGPSNBmkPFBBVUPNBmkPEBQSPEVmkP FEJTUSJCVJmkPEPTQSPEVUPT&TTBNVEBOmBOBTGPSmBTQSPEV UJWBT QPJTBUFDOPMPHJBBMUFSPVPQSPDFTTPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIP WFNDBVTBOEPPEFTFNQSFHPFNNBTTB NPWJNFOUPTSBDJTUBT DPOUSBJNJHSBOUFTFNJHSBOUFT FYDMVTkPTPDJBM QPMrUJDBFDVMUV SBMEFHSBOEFTNBTTBTEBQPQVMBmkP
TFHSBmBTBPEFTFNQSFHPFNNBTTBFOkPQSFDJTBQSFPDVQBS TFFNHBSBOUJSEJSFJUPTFDPOyNJDPTFTPDJBJTBPTUSBCBMIBEPSFT QPSRVFOkPOFDFTTJUBEFTFVTUSBCBMIPTFTFSWJmPT &YQMJRVFBTFQBSBmkPFOUSFEJSJHFOUFTFFYFDVUBOUFTOB PSHBOJ[BmkPJOEVTUSJBMEPUSBCBMIPRVFTFPCTFSWBOBBUVBM EJWJTkPTPDJBM 0TEJSJHFOUFTTkPPTRVFSFDFCFNBFEVDBmkPDJFOUrGJDBF UFDOPMwHJDB TkPDPOTJEFSBEPTQPSUBEPSFTEFTBCFSFTRVFPT UPSOBNDPNQFUFOUFTFQPSJTTPDPNQPEFSEFNBOEP0TFYF DVUBOUFTTkPBRVFMFTRVFOkPQPTTVFNDPOIFDJNFOUPTUFDOP MwHJDPTFDJFOUrGJDPT NBTTBCFNBQFOBTFYFDVUBSUBSFGBT TFN DPOIFDFSBTSB[{FTFBTGJOBMJEBEFTEFTVBBmkP&TTBGPSNBEF PSHBOJ[BmkPEBEJWJTkPTPDJBMEPUSBCBMIPQSPQBHPVTFQBSB BTPDJFEBEFJOUFJSB/PDPNnSDJP OBBHSJDVMUVSB OBTFTDPMBT OPTIPTQJUBJT OBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT OPTTFSWJmPTQ|CMJDPT OBTBS UFT UPEPTFTUkPTFQBSBEPTFOUSF²DPNQFUFOUFT³RVFTBCFNF ²JODPNQFUFOUFT³RVFFYFDVUBN&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBT BQPTTF EFDFSUPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTFTQFDrGJDPTUPSOPVTFVNQPEFSQBSB NBOEBSFEFDJEJS 2VFnBJEFPMPHJBEBDPNQFUpODJBUnDOJDPDJFOUrGJDB $PNP FMBJOUFSGFSFOBQPMrUJDB 2VFDPOUSBEJm{FTUSB[DPOTJHP cBJEFJBEFRVFRVFNQPTTVJDPOIFDJNFOUPTFTUgOBUVSBM NFOUFEPUBEPEFQPEFSEFNBOEPFEJSFmkP&TTBJEFPMPHJB GPSUBMFDJEBQFMPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPEFNBTTBRVFBFTUJ NVMBNEJBSJBNFOUF JOWBEJVBQPMrUJDB RVFQBTTPVBTFSDPOTJ EFSBEBVNBBUJWJEBEFSFTFSWBEBQBSBUnDOJDPTPVBENJOJTUSB EPSFTQPMrUJDPTDPNQFUFOUFT FOkPVNBBmkPDPMFUJWBEFUPEPT PTDJEBEkPT"DPOUSBEJmkPFTUgFNRVFOkPTwPEJSFJUPhSFQSF TFOUBmkPQPMrUJDBEJNJOVJQPSRVFTFSFTUSJOHFBPTDPNQFUFOUFT DPNPBJOEBBJEFPMPHJBEBDPNQFUpODJBPDVMUBFEJTTJNVMBP GBUPEFRVF QBSBTFS²DPNQFUFOUF³ nQSFDJTPUFSSFDVSTPTFDP OyNJDPTQBSBFTUVEBSFBERVJSJSDPOIFDJNFOUPT0VTFKB PT ²DPNQFUFOUFT³QFSUFODFNhDMBTTFFDPOPNJDBNFOUFEPNJOBO UF RVF BTTJN EJSJHFBQPMrUJDBTFHVOEPTFVTJOUFSFTTFT FOkP EFBDPSEPDPNBVOJWFSTBMJEBEFEPTEJSFJUPT %FRVFGPSNBPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPEFNBTTBTFDPOTUJ UVFNOVNPCTUgDVMPBPEJSFJUPhQBSUJDJQBmkPQPMrUJDB /BTFHVJOUFGPSNBTwQPEFNPTQBSUJDJQBSEFEJTDVTT{FTF EFDJT{FTQPMrUJDBTTFQPTTVJSNPTJOGPSNBm{FTDPSSFUBTTPCSF BRVJMPRVFWBNPTEJTDVUJSFEFDJEJS0SB PTNFJPTEFDPNV OJDBmkPEFNBTTBOkPJOGPSNBNEFTJOGPSNBN0VNFMIPS USBOTNJUFNBTJOGPSNBm{FTEFBDPSEPDPNPTJOUFSFTTFTEF TFVTQSPQSJFUgSJPTFEBTBMJBOmBTFDPOyNJDBTFQPMrUJDBTEFTUFT DPNHSVQPTEFUFOUPSFTEFQPEFSFDPOyNJDPFQPMrUJDP"TTJN QPSOkPIBWFSSFTQFJUPBPEJSFJUPEFJOGPSNBmkP OkPIgDPNP SFTQFJUBSPEJSFJUPhWFSEBEFJSBQBSUJDJQBmkPQPMrUJDB 1PSRVFQPEFNPTBGJSNBSRVFPTPCTUgDVMPThEFNPDSBDJB OkPJOWJBCJMJ[BNBTPDJFEBEFEFNPDSgUJDB 1PSRVF QFMPDPOUSgSJP TPNFOUFOFMBTPNPTDBQB[FTEF QFSDFCFSUBJTPCTUgDVMPTFMVUBSDPOUSBFMFT
$PNPOFPMJCFSBMJTNP IPVWFVNFODPMIJNFOUPEBFTGFSB Q|CMJDBFVNBMBSHBNFOUPEBFTGFSBQSJWBEB0RVFJTTP SFQSFTFOUBOBQSgUJDB
1PSRVFQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFBTPDJFEBEFCSBTJMFJSBnBV UPSJUgSJB
3FQSFTFOUBVNQFSJHPQBSBPTEJSFJUPTFDPOyNJDPTFTPDJBJT DPORVJTUBEPTQFMBTMVUBTQPQVMBSFT)PKFPDBQJUBMQPEFBDV NVMBSTFFSFQSPEV[JSTFFYDMVJOEPDBEBWF[NBJTBTQFTTPBT EPNFSDBEPEFUSBCBMIPFEFDPOTVNP/kPQSFDJTBNBJTEF HSBOEFTNBTTBTUSBCBMIBEPSBTFDPOTVNJEPSBT QPEFBNQMJBS
/PTTBTPDJFEBEFnBVUPSJUgSJBQPSRVFnIJFSgSRVJDB QPJT EJWJEFBTQFTTPBT FNRVBMRVFSDJSDVOTUiODJB FNJOGFSJPSFT RVFEFWFNPCFEFDFS FTVQFSJPSFT RVFEFWFNNBOEBS/kPIg QFSDFQmkPOFNQSgUJDBEBJHVBMEBEFDPNPVNEJSFJUP/PTTBTP DJFEBEFUBNCnNnBVUPSJUgSJBQPSRVFnWJPMFOUB OPTUFSNPTFN
---
| U NIDADE 8
|
O mundo da prática
RVF OPFTUVEPEBnUJDB EFGJOJNPTBWJPMpODJB OFMBWJHPSBNSB DJTNP NBDIJTNP EJTDSJNJOBmkPSFMJHJPTBFEFDMBTTFTPDJBM EF TJHVBMEBEFTFDPOyNJDBTFOUSFBTNBJPSFTEPNVOEP FYDMVT{FT DVMUVSBJTFQPMrUJDBT/kPIgQFSDFQmkPOFNQSgUJDBEPEJSFJUPh MJCFSEBEF &NSB[kPEFTFVBVUPSJUBSJTNPTPDJBMFEFTVBTEFTJHVBMEB EFTFDPOyNJDBT FNRVFCBTFTFTUgBTTFOUBEBBTPDJFEBEF CSBTJMFJSB "TPDJFEBEFCSBTJMFJSBFTUgQPMBSJ[BEBFOUSFBTDBSpODJBT EBTDBNBEBTQPQVMBSFTFPTJOUFSFTTFTEBTDMBTTFTBCBTUBEBTF EPNJOBOUFT TFNDPOTFHVJSVMUSBQBTTBSDBSpODJBTFJOUFSFTTFT FBMDBOmBSBFTGFSBEPTEJSFJUPT0TJOUFSFTTFT QPSRVFOkPTF USBOTGPSNBNFNEJSFJUPT UPSOBNTFQSJWJMnHJPTEFBMHVOT EF TPSUFRVFBQPMBSJ[BmkPTPDJBMTFFGFUVBFOUSFPTEFTQPTTVrEPT PTDBSFOUFT FPTQSJWJMFHJBEPT&TUFT QPSRVFTkPQPSUBEPSFT EPTDPOIFDJNFOUPTUnDOJDPTFDJFOUrGJDPT TkPPT²DPNQFUFO UFT³ DBCFOEPMIFTBEJSFmkPEBTPDJFEBEF &YQMJRVFEFRVFNPEP OBQSgUJDB BTPDJFEBEFCSBTJMFJSB OkPDPOTFHVFTFSEFNPDSgUJDB $PNPWJNPT VNBDBSpODJBnTFNQSFFTQFDrGJDB TFNDPOTF HVJSHFOFSBMJ[BSTFOVNJOUFSFTTFDPNVNOFNVOJWFSTBMJ[BSTF OVNEJSFJUP6NQSJWJMnHJP QPSEFGJOJmkP nTFNQSFQBSUJDVMBS OkPQPEFOEPHFOFSBMJ[BSTFOVNJOUFSFTTFDPNVNOFNVOJ WFSTBMJ[BSTFOVNEJSFJUP QPJT TFUBMPDPSSFTTF EFJYBSJBEFTFS QSJWJMnHJP0SB BEFNPDSBDJBnDSJBmkPFHBSBOUJBEFEJSFJUPT /PTTBTPDJFEBEF QPMBSJ[BEBFOUSFBDBSpODJBFPQSJWJMnHJP OkP DPOTFHVFTFSEFNPDSgUJDB QPJTOkPFODPOUSBNFJPTQBSBJTTP &TTFDPOKVOUPEFEFUFSNJOBm{FTTPDJBJTNBOJGFTUBTFOBFTGFSB QPMrUJDB&NMVHBSEFEFNPDSBDJB UFNPTJOTUJUVJm{FTWJOEBTEFMB NBTPQFSBOEPEFNPEPBVUPSJUgSJP"TTJN QPSFYFNQMP PTQBS UJEPTQPMrUJDPTDPTUVNBNTFSEFUSpTUJQPTPTDMJFOUFMJTUBT RVF NBOUpNSFMBm{FTEFGBWPSDPNTFVTFMFJUPSFT PTWBOHVBSEJTUBT RVFTVCTUJUVFNTFVTFMFJUPSFTQFMBWPOUBEFEPTEJSJHFOUFTQBS
UJEgSJPT FPTQPQVMJTUBT RVFUSBUBNTFVTFMFJUPSFTDPNPVNQBJ EFGBNrMJB PEFTQPUFT USBUBTFVTGJMIPTNFOPSFT'BWPS TVCTUJ UVJmkPFQBUFSOBMJTNPFWJEFODJBNRVFBQSgUJDBEBQBSUJDJQBmkP QPMrUJDB QPSNFJPEFSFQSFTFOUBOUFT OkPDPOTFHVFTFSFBMJ[BS OP#SBTJM0TSFQSFTFOUBOUFT FNMVHBSEFDVNQSJSPNBOEBUP RVFMIFTGPJEBEPQFMPTSFQSFTFOUBEPT TVSHFNDPNPDIFGFT NBOEBOUFT EFUFOUPSFTEFGBWPSFTFQPEFSFT TVCNFUFOEPPT SFQSFTFOUBEPT USBOTGPSNBOEPPTFNDMJFOUFTRVFSFDFCFNGB WPSFTEPTNBOEBOUFT 2VFTFFOUFOEFQPS²JOE|TUSJBQPMrUJDB³ "²JOE|TUSJBQPMrUJDB³nBDSJBmkPEBJNBHFNEPTQPMrUJDPT QFMPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBmkPEFNBTTBQBSBBWFOEBEPQPMrUJDP BPTFMFJUPSFTDPOTVNJEPSFT"TMJEFSBOmBTQPMrUJDBTTkPTFN QSFJNBHJOBEBTDPNPDIFGFTTBMWBEPSFTEBOBmkP WFSEBEFJ SPTNFTTJBTFTDPMIJEPTQPS%FVTFSFGFSFOEBEPTQFMPWPUPEPT FMFJUPSFT 0RVFFTUgQPSUSgTEBJNBHFNQPQVMJTUBFNFTTJiOJDBEPT HPWFSOBOUFT "JNBHFNQPQVMJTUBFNFTTJiOJDBEPTHPWFSOBOUFTJOEJDB RVFBDPODFQmkPUFPDSgUJDBEPQPEFSOkPEFTBQBSFDFVBJOEB TFBDSFEJUBOPHPWFSOBOUFDPNPFOWJBEPEBTEJWJOEBEFT P O|NFSPEFQPMrUJDPTMJHBEPTBBTUSwMPHPTFWJEFOUFTGBMBQPSTJ NFTNP FRVFTVBWPOUBEFUFNGPSmBEFMFJ $PNPTkPWJTUBTBTMFJTFNOPTTBTPDJFEBEF "TMFJT QPSRVFFYQSJNFNPVPTQSJWJMnHJPTEPTQPEFSPTPT PVBWPOUBEFQFTTPBMEPTHPWFSOBOUFT OkPTkPWJTUBTDPNP FYQSFTTkPEFEJSFJUPTOFNEFWPOUBEFTFEFDJT{FTQ|CMJDBTDP MFUJWBT0QPEFSKVEJDJgSJPBQBSFDFDPNPNJTUFSJPTP FOWPMUP OVNTBCFSJODPNQSFFOTrWFMFOVNBBVUPSJEBEFRVBTFNrTUJDB 1PSJTTPNFTNP BDFJUBTFRVFBMFHBMJEBEFTFKB QPSVNMBEP JODPNQSFFOTrWFM F QPSPVUSP JOFGJDJFOUF FRVFB|OJDBSFMBmkP QPTTrWFMDPNFMBTFKBBEBUSBOTHSFTTkP PGBNPTP²KFJUJOIP³
--.
Convite à Filosofia é um marco no ensino da Filosofia no Brasil. Por meio de uma linguagem acessível, trata de forma contextualizada os temas importantes da reflexão filosófica, conduzindo o leitor à profundidade dos grandes pensadores. Razão, Verdade, Conhecimento, Ciência, Ética, Política, Arte, Técnica, Religião, Metafísica, História e Lógica emergem de suas páginas em abordagens que suscitam fecundas discussões sobre o mundo das ideias e sobre a história do pensamento. Marilena Chaui é professora de Filosofia na Universidade de São Paulo e uma das mais prestigiadas intelectuais brasileiras, com presença atuante no debate político nacional e na construção da democracia no Brasil. São frequentes os seus artigos na imprensa, bem como sua participação em congressos, conferências e cursos, no país e no exterior. Em 2003, recebeu o título de doutora honoris causa da Universidade de Paris. É autora de A nervura do real; Introdução à História da Filosofia; Cultura e democracia; Da realidade sem mistérios ao mistério do mundo; Repressão sexual, essa nossa (des)conhecida; Conformismo e resistência: notas sobre cultura popular; Experiência do pensamento; A questão da democracia; Brasil — Mito fundador e sociedade autoritária e O que é ideologia, entre outros livros.
www.atica.com.br