Without Guarantees: In Honour of Stuart Hall 1859842879, 9781859842874

Citation preview

HOU丁 G UARANTE巨 S

Vヽ/1丁

IN HONO∪ R OFS丁 ∪ART HALL Edited by Paul Gilroy, Lawrence Grossberg and Angela lr/cRobbie

Contributors: len Ang, Mlchdle Barrett, Wendy Brown, Judith Butler, N6stor Garcia Canclini,

Angie Chabram-Dernersesian, lain Chambers, John Clarke, James Clifford, Paul du

Gay,

Paul Gilroy, Henry A. Giroux, Lawrence Grossberg, Glenn Jordan, Myung Koo Kang, Gail Lewis, Rolf Lindner, Angela McRobbie, Doreen lVassey, Kobena Mercer, David Morley,

Sean Nixon, Flemming Rogilds, Bill Schwarz, David Scott, Ove Sernhede, Joe Sim, Gayatri chakravorty Spivak, Gilane Tawadros, Charles Taylor, Keyan G. Tomaselli, Gail Guthrie Valaskakis, Chris Weedon, Shunya Yoshimi, Lola Young.

Without Guarantees

V

Without Guarantees In Honour of Stuart Hall

Edited by

Paul{Gilroy,Lawrence⊂ )rossberg and Angela McRlobbic

▼

VERSO

London o New York

First

Oh o in hdi

published by Veno 2000

the collection Verso 2000 :u」 contributions the contributorr 2000 All rights reserved

The moral rights of the authors and editors have been asserted Verso UIG 6 Meard Street, London, WIV 3HR US: 180 Varick Street, NewYork, NY 10014-4606 Verso is the imprint of New

kft

Books

ISBN l-85984-762-5 ISBN l-85984-287-9 (pbk)

Bridsh Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the Britigh Ubrary Library of Corgrecs Catalogingirltrbltcation Data Without guarantees: in honour of Stuart Hall ,/ edited b,y Paul Gilroy, Lawrence Grossberg, and Angela McRobbie.

p.cm ISBN l-85984-762-5

(cloth)-ISBN l-85984-287-9 (pbk.)

l. Society-Great Britain.

2. Great Britain-Race relations. 3. Great Britain-Politics and government. 4, Hdl, Stuart. I. Ha[, Stuart. II. Gilroy, Paul. IIL Grossberg, l,awrence. [V. McRobbie, Angela.

HM479.G7W572000 301′ .0941-― dc21

00-028986 Typeset h 10/12%ptrrC New Baskwine by den,Es“ x SeSptems Ltd,S涯 =on W」 P nted by Bidaes Ltd,Cuildford and Kng's Lynn

AII royalties earned on this book will be donated to the Stephen Lawrence Trust

Contents

PREFACE

3

Resisting Left Melancholia

Agencies of Sryle for a Liminal Subject

7 8

At the End of This Sentence a Sail Will Unfurl . . Modernities, Musics and theJourney of Identity Iain Chambm Unfinished Business? Struggles over the Social in Social Welfare John Cln*e

9

Taking Identity Politics Seriously: 'The Contradictory, Stony Ground. . .' James Clifford

10

６ ２

Gi,lray

   

The SugarYou Stir. . . Paul

   

11

Representing'Globalization': Notes on the Discursive Orderings of Economic Life Paul du Gay

３         ７         ３         ４         ３ ５         ６         ８         ９         １

Critical Dialogues on Chicana/o Cultural Studies Angic Chabram-Dmtmesian

   

6

   

N4stor Garcta Canclini,

８ ３

The State of War and the State of Hybridization

   

5

   

Judith Butln

０ ３

4

       

Wmdy Broum

１ ２

Sociology and the Metaphorical Tiger Mi,chlle Barwtt

   

2

   

Identity Blues Im Ang ４ １

I

lX

CONTENTS

vr

12

Public Pedagogy as Cultural Politics: Stuart Hall and the 'Crisis' of Culture Hmry A. Giroux

13

History, Imagination and the Politics of Belonging: Between the Death and the Fear of History Lawrmce Grossberg

14

When the Subalterns Speak, What Do They Cultural Politics in Cardiff Docklands GbnnJmdan and Chri.s

15

Say? Radical

Weed,on

The Second Modernization Failed: Discourse Politics from 'New Korea' to 'Globalization' Myung Koo Kang

16

Stuart Hall and Social Policy: An Encounter of Strangers? Gail Lewis

17

Absolute Beginnings: In Search of a Lost Time Ralf Lindner

18

Stuart Hall: The Universities and the

'Hrrly Burly'

Angela McRnbbit

19

Travelling Thoughts Doreen Massq

20

A Sociography of Diaspora Kobena Msrcer

2l

Cultural Studies and Common Sense: Unresolved Questions Dauid Morlq

22

Intervening in Popular Culture: Cultural Politics and the Art of Translation Sean Nixon

23

Matters of Selfesteem Flzmmi.ng ROgilds

24

BecomingPostcolonial Bill Schwan

25

The Permanence of Pluralism Daaid Scott

26

Exoticism and Death as a Modern Taboo: Gangsta Rap and the Search for Intensity Oue Sernhedc

ｖ

C(0,NTENTS

８ ｌ ３

Against the Punitive Wind: Stuart Hall, the State and the Lessons of the Great Moving Right Show

   

27

Joe Sim

Thinking Cultural Questions in 'Pure' Literary Terms Gayatri Chahrauqrty

５ ３ ３

28

Wr& ８ ５ ３

29 Studies in a Post