Gothic architecture and scholasticism 9780529020925

Citation preview

Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism

Gothic Architecture

and Scholasticism

by Erwin Panofsky

oe MERIDIAN BOOKS New York — 1957

Erwin Panofsky Erwin Panofsky was born in Germany in 1892. Educated at Berlin, Munich, and Freiburg universities, he became a lecturer in the history of art at Hamburg University in 1921. He was a professor there from 1926 until 1933. From 1931 to 1933 he was also a visiting professor at New York University. In 1934 he was a visiting lecturer at Princeton Uni-

versity, where he has been since 1935 a professor at the Institute for Advanced Study. He was Charles Eliot Norton Professor of Poetry at Harvard University during 1947-48. Among his other works in English are Studies in Iconology (1939), The Codex Huyghens and Leonardo da Vinci's Art Theory (1940), Albrecht Durer Cfrst edition, 1943), Abbot Sirger on the Abbey Church of St. Denis and Its Art Treasures (1946), Early Netherlandish Painting: Its Origin and Character (1953), and Galileo as a Critic of the Visual Arts (1954).

Meridian Books Edition published March 1957 First printing February 1957 Copyright © 1951 and 1957 by Saint Vincent Archabbey Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 57-6681

Manufactured in the United States of America

Foreword Proressor Erwin Panofsky’s study, Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism, captured and holds an eminent

place in a series that is not without distinction, the Wimmer Lectures. Established in memory of the founder of the Benedictine Order in America, Boniface Wimmer, the series has brought to St. Vincent College such fine scholars as Jacques Maritain (Man's

Approach to God”), William F. Albright (“Toward a Theistic Humanism”), Helen C. White C“Prayer and Poetry”), and Elias A. Lowe (“The Finest Book in the World”). Boniface Wimmer would surely have approved the

matter and the manner of this lecture. In a letter written nearly a hundred years ago he said: In a country like America... religion and art must work together to give our liturgy an outward splendor, great

dignity, and even grandeur.... Therefore the monasteries have a solemn duty to foster art, especially religious

art, to improve it and to spread it, because our shopkeepers and our farmers will never do that. I am firmly

vi Foreword convinced that a monastic school which does not strive to

advance art as much as science and religion will be deficient in its work. In scientific matters shortcomings may be more readily condoned, at least in the beginning, but neglect in the promotion of art must be censured.

Nine decades have not diminished the force of these words.

Professor Panofsky represents that firm, mature, and humane learning that is the ideal and the despair of so many. Since 1935 he has been associated with the School of Humanistic Studies at The Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, New Jersey. His career before that took him from his native Hanover to the

universities of Berlin, Munich, Freiburg, and Hamburg. An authority on iconology, medieval, renaissance,

and baroque art, and Dutch and Flemish book illumination, he has been a lecturer or professor at various universities in the United States. Knowledge as comprehensive in its grasp and diver-

sification as it is precise and sure in detail, brilliant insight and penetrating analysis, stimulating, radiant,

Foreword Vii and artistic presentation—these are qualities it is cus-

tomary to take for granted in a study by Professor Panotsky. It is a source of satisfaction to see his provocative lecture made available to a wider public through

Meridian Books. Extremely heavy demands upon Professor Panofsky’s time have prevented him from introducing into the text revisions he would now consider

desirable. We do not hesitate to issue the text in its original form, quite willing to let it stand on its own merits.

- Quentin L. Scuaurt, O.S.B.

List of Illustrations Figure 1.

Tombstone of the Architect Hugues Libergier (died 1263), Reims Cathedral. Figure 2.

Autun Cathedral, west portal. Ca. 1130. Figure 3.

Paris, Notre-Dame, central portal of the west facade (much restored). Ca. 1216-1220. Figure 4.

Henry I of France bestowing privileges upon the Priory of St.-Martin-des-Champs. Book illumination between

1079 and 1096, London, British Museum, ms. Add. 1162, fol. 4. Figure 5.

Henry I of France bestowing privileges upon the Priory

of St.-Martin-des-Champs. Book illumination of ca. 1250, Paris, Bibliothéque Nationale, ms. Nouv. Acq.

lat. 139, fol. 1. Figure 6.

Philip I of France bestowing privileges upon the Priory of St.-Martin-des-Champs. Book illumination between 1X

Illustrations 1079 and 1096, London, British Museum, ms. Add. 1162, fol. ¢ v. Figure 7.

Philip I of France bestowing privileges upon the Priory

of St.-Martin-des-Champs. Book illumination of ca. 1250, Paris, Bibliothéque Nationale, ms. Nouv. Acq. lat. 1359, fol. 6. Figure 8.

Maria Laach, Abbey Church from the northwest. 10931166, Figure 9.

Pima (Saxony), Marienkirche, interior. Begun 1502. Figure 10.

Cluny, Third Abbey Church, groundplan, 1088-ca. 1120; narthex ca. 1120—ca. 1150. (After K. J. Conant,

‘The Third Church of Cluny,’’ Medieval Studies in Memory of A. Kingsley Porter, Cambridge, 1939.) Figure 11.

Amiens Cathedral, groundplan. Begun 1220. Figure 12.

Sens Cathedral, groundplan. Constructed ca. 1140-ca. 1168. (After E. Gall, Die gotische Baukunst in Frankreich und Deutschland, Leipzig, 1925). Figure 13.

Laon Cathedral, groundplan. Begun ca. 1160. x

Illustrations Figure 14.

Laon Cathedral from the northwest. Begun ca. 1160. Figure 15.

Reims Cathedral from the northwest. Begun 1211. Figure 16.

Amiens Cathedral from the northeast. Begun 1220, Figure 17.

Lessay (Normandy), Abbey Church, interior. End of the XIth century. Figure 18.

Laon Cathedral, interior of the choir. Begun after 1205 in conformity with elevation designed ca. 1160. Figure 19.

Chartres Cathedral, interior of the nave. Begun shortly after 1194. Figure 20.

Reims Cathedral, interior of the nave. Begun 1211. Figure 21.

Amiens Cathedral, interior of the nave. Begun 1220. Figure 22.

St.-Denis, interior of the nave. Begun 1231. Figure 23.

Caen, St.-Etienne, vaults of the northern transept. Ca. 1110. (After E. Gall, op. cit.) x1

Illustrations Figure 24.

Soissons Cathedral, vaults of the southern side aisle in course of restoration after World War I. Beginning of the XIllth century. Figure 25.

Soissons Cathedral, section of the northern nave wall damaged during World War I. Beginning of the XIIlth century. Figure 26.

Chartres Cathedral, flying buttress of the nave. Design established shortly after 1194. Figure 27.

Reims Cathedral, Madonna in the right hand portal of the northern transept. Ca. 1211-1212. Figure 28.

Durham Cathedral, concealed flying buttresses. End of the XIth century. (After R. W. Billings, Architectural Illustrations and Description of the Cathedral Church of Dur-

ham, London, 1843.) Figure 29.

Reims Cathedral, open flying buttresses of the nave. Design established ca. 1211. Figure 30.

St.-Denis, west facade. Dedicated 1140. (After an enX11

Illustrations graving by A. and E. Rouargue, executed before the restoration of 1833-1837.) Figure 31.

Paris, Notre-Dame, west facade. Begun shortly after 1200; clerestory ca. 1220. Figure 32.

Laon Cathedral, west fagade. Designed ca. 1160; executed from ca. 1190. Figure 33.

Amiens, west facade. Begun 1220; clerestory completed 1236; tracery of the rose ca. 1500. Figure 34.

Reims, St.-Nicaise (destroyed), west facade. Between ca. 1230 and 1263; rose restored ca. 1550. (After an engraving by N. de Son, of 1625.) Figure 35.

Reims, St.-Nicaise (destroyed), rose in the west facade (partial reconstruction). Figure 36.

Reims Cathedral, nave window. Designed ca. 1211. Figure 37.

Caen, Ste.-Trinité, triforium. Ca. 1110. Figure 38.

Sens Cathedral, triforium galleries. Towards 1150. X1li

Illustrations Figure 39.

Noyon Cathedral, nave galleries and triforium. Design established ca. 1170; eastern bay executed between 1170 and 118.5, rest later. Figure 40.

Chalons-sur-Marne, Notre-Dame-en-Vaux, choir galleries and triforium. Ca. 1185. Figure 41.

Chartres Cathedral, nave triforium. Design established ca. 1194. Figure 42.

Reims Cathedral, nave triforium. Design established ca. 1211. Figure 43.

Villard de Honnecourt, interior elevation of Reims Cathedral. Drawing of ca. 1235, Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale (enlarged detail). Figure 44.

Amiens Cathedral, nave triforium. Design established Ca. 1220. Figure 45.

St.-Denis, nave triforium, Design established ca. 1231. Figure 46.

Canterbury Cathedral, choir piers. 1174-1178. X1V

Illustrations Figure 47.

Chartres Cathedral, capital of nave pier. Design established ca. 1194. Figure 48.

Reims Cathedral, capital of nave pier. Design established ca. 1211. Figure 49.

Amiens Cathedral, capital of nave pier. Design established ca. 1220. Figure 50.

St.-Denis, capital of nave pier. Design established ca. 1231. Figure 51.

Amiens Cathedral, cross section of pier in relation to wall and vault-ribs. Design established ca. 1220. Figure §2.

St.-Denis, cross section of pier in relation to wall and vault-ribs. Design established ca. 1231. Figure 53.

Cologne Cathedral, cross section of pier in relation to wall and vault-ribs. Design established ca. 1248. Figure 54.

Canterbury Cathedral, capital of pier. 1174-1178 (diagram). XV

Illustrations Figure 55.

Chartres Cathedral, capital of pier. Design established shortly after 1194 (diagram). Figure 56.

Reims Cathedral, capital of pier. Design established ca. 1211 (diagram). Figure 57.

Amiens Cathedral, capital of pier. Design established ca. 1220 (diagram). Figure 58.

Beauvais Cathedral, capital of pier. Design established ca. 1247 (diagram). Figure 59.

St.-Denis, capital of pier. Design established ca. 1231 (diagram). Figure 60.

Villard de Honnecourt, ideal groundplan of a chevet resulting from his discussion with Pierre de Corbie. Drawing of ca. 1235, Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale.

Xv1

Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism HE HISTORIAN CANNOT HELP DIVIDING

his material into ‘‘periods,’’ nicely defined in the Oxford Dictionary as ‘‘dis-

tinguishable portions of history.’’ To be distinguishable, each of these portions has to have a certain unity; and if the historian wishes to verify this unity instead of merely presupposing it, he must needs try to discover intrinsic analogies between such overtly disparate phenomena as the

arts, literature, philosophy, social and political currents, religious movements, etc. This effort, laudable and even indispensable in itself, has led to

a pursuit of “‘parallels’’ the hazards of which are ]

Gothic Architecture

only too obvious. No man can master more than one fairly limited field; every man has to rely on incomplete and often secondary information whenever he ventures ultra crepidam. Few men can resist

the temptation of either ignoring or slightly deflecting such lines as refuse to run parallel, and even

a genuine parallelism does not make us really happy if we cannot imagine how it came about. Small wonder, then, that another diffident attempt at correlating Gothic architecture and Scholasticism’ is bound to be looked upon with suspicion by both historians of art and historians of philosophy. Yet, setting aside for the moment all intrinsic analogies, there exists between Gothic architecture and Scholasticism a palpable and hardly accidental concurrence in the purely factual domain of time and place—a concurrence so inescapable that the historians of mediaeval philosophy, uninfluenced by ulterior considerations, have been led to period2

And Scholasticism

ize their material in precisely the same way as do the art historians theirs. I

To the Carolingian revival of the arts there corresponds, in philosophy, the phenomenon of John

the Scot (ca. 810-877), equally magnificent, equally unexpected, and equally charged with po-

tentialities not to be realized until a much later date. About a hundred years of fermentation in both fields were followed, in art, by the variety and

contrariety of Romanesque which ranges from the planar simplicity of the Hirsau school and the severe

structuralism of Normandy and England to the rich proto-classicism of southern France and Italy; and,

in theology and philosophy, by a similar multiplic-

ity of divergent currents, from uncompromising fideism (Peter Damian, Manegold of Lautenbach and, ultimately, St. Bernard) and ruthless rational3

Gothic Architecture

ism (Berenger of Tours, Roscellinus) to the proto-

humanism of Hildebert of Lavardin, Marbod of Rennes and the school of Chartres. Lanfranc and Anselm of Bec (the former died in

1089, the latter in 1109) made a heroic attempt to settle the conflict between reason and faith before

the principles of such a settlement had been explored and formulated. This exploration and formu-

lation was initiated by Gilbert de la Porrée (died 1154) and Abelard (died 1142). Thus Early Scholasticism was born at the same moment and in the same environment in which Early Gothic architec-

ture was born in Suger’s Saint-Denis. For both the new style of thinking and the new style of build-

ing (opus Francigenum)—though brought about by

‘“many masters from different nations,’’ as Suger said of his artisans, and soon developing into truly international movements—spread from an area com4

And Scholasticism

prised within a circle drawn around Paris with a radius of less than a hundred miles. And they con-

tinued to be centered in this area for about one century and a half. Here High Scholasticism is generally assumed to

begin with the turn of the twelfth century, precisely when the High Gothic system achieved its first triumphs in Chartres and Soissons; and here a ‘‘classic’’ or climactic phase was reached in both fields during the reign of St. Louis (1226-1270). It was in this period that there flourished such High

Scholastic philosophers as Alexander of Hales, Albert the Great, William of Auvergne, St. Bonaventure, and St. Thomas Aquinas and such High Gothic architects as Jean le Loup, Jean d’Orbais,

Robert de Luzarches, Jean de Chelles, Hugues Libergier, and Pierre de Montereau; and the distinctive features of High—as opposed to Early— 5

Gothic Architecture

Scholasticism are remarkably analogous to those which characterize High—as opposed to Early— Gothic art. It has justly been remarked that the gentle ani-

mation that distinguishes the Early Gothic figures in the west facade of Chartres from their Roman-

esque predecessors reflects the renewal of an interest in psychology which had been dormant for several centuries;? but this psychology was still based upon the Biblical—and Augustinian—dichot-

omy between the ‘“breath of life’’ and the “‘dust of

the ground.’’ The infinitely more lifelike—though

not, as yet, portraitlike—High Gothic statues of Reims and Amiens, Strassburg and Naumburg and

the natural—though not, as yet, naturalistic— fauna and flora of High Gothic ornament proclaim

the victory of Aristotelianism. The human soul, though recognized as immortal, was now held to be the organizing and unifying principle of the body 6

And Scholasticism

itself rather than a substance independent thereof.

A plant was thought to exist as a plant and not as the copy of the idea of a plant. The existence of God was believed to be demonstrable from His creation rather than a priori.3 In formal organization, too, the High Scholastic Summa differs from the less comprehensive, less strictly organized, and much less uniform encyclopedias and Libri Sententiarum of the eleventh and twelfth centuries much in the same way as does the

High Gothic style from its ancestry. In fact, the very word summa (first used as a book title by the jurists) did not change its meaning from a ‘‘brief compendium’’ (singulorum brevis comprehensio or compendiosa collectio, as Robert of Melun defined it

in 110) to a presentation both exhaustive and systematic, from ‘‘summary’’ to summa as we know it,

until the final lustra of the twelfth century.+ The earliest fully developed specimen of this new kind, 7

Gothic Architecture the Summa Theologiae by Alexander of Hales, which,

according to Roger Bacon, ‘weighed about as much

as one horse can carry,’’ was begun in 1231, the very year in which Pierre de Montereau began the new nave of St.-Denis.

The fifty or sixty years after the death of Saint Louis in 1270 (or, if we prefer, that of St. Bona-

venture and St. Thomas in 1274) mark what is called the end phase of High Scholasticism by the historians of philosophy, and the end phase of High Gothic by the historians of art—phases in which the various developments, however important, do not as yet add up to a fundamental change in attitude but rather manifest themselves in a gradual decomposition of the existing system. Both in in-

tellectual and in artistic life—including music, which from about 1170 had been dominated by the school of Notre-Dame in Paris—we can observe a

growing trend towards decentralization. The cre8

And Scholasticism

ative impulses tended to shift from what had been

the center to what had been the periphery: to South France, to Italy, to the Germanic countries, and to England, which, in the thirteenth century had shown a tendency toward splendid isolation.§ A decrease of confidence in the supremely syn-

thetic power of reason which had triumphed in Thomas Aquinas may be discerned, and this resulted in a resurgence—on an entirely different level, to be sure—of currents suppressed during the ‘‘classic’’ phase. The Summa was again displaced

by less systematic and ambitious types of presenta-

tion. Pre-Scholastic Augustinianism (asserting, among other things, the independence of the will from the intellect) was vigorously revived in oppo-

sition to Thomas, and Thomas’s anti-Augustinian tenets were solemnly condemned three years after his death. Similarly, the ‘‘classic’’ cathedral type was abandoned in favor of other, less perfectly sys9

Gothic Architecture

tematized and often somewhat archaic solutions; and in the plastic arts we can observe the revival of

a pre-Gothic tendency toward the abstract and the linear.

The doctrines of ‘‘classic’’ High Scholasticism either stiffened into school traditions, or were subjected to vulgarization in popular treatises such as the Somme-le-Roy (1279) and the Tesoretto by Bru-

netto Latini, or were elaborated and subtilized to the limits of human capacity (not without reason

does the greatest representative of this period, Duns Scotus, who died in 1308, bear the agnomen Doctor Subtilis). Similarly, “‘classic’’ High Gothic either became doctrinaire, to use Dehio’s phrase,

or was reduced and simplified (especially in the mendicant orders), or was refined and complicated into the harpwork of Strassburg, the embroidery of

Freiburg, and the flowing tracery of Hawton or Lincoln. But it was not until the end of this period 10

And Scholasticism

that a basic change announced itself; and it was not

until the middle of the fourteenth century—in histories of philosophy the conventional date for the shift from High to Late Scholasticism is 1340, when the teachings of William of Ockham had made so much headway that they had to be condemned—that this change became thoroughly and universally effective. By this time the energies of High Scholasticism—

setting aside the ossified schools of Thomists and

Scotists that persisted much as academic painting survived and survives after Manet—had either been

channelled into poetry and, ultimately, humanism through Guido Cavalcanti, Dante, and Petrarch; or into anti-rational mysticism through Master Eckhart and his followers. And insofar as philosophy remained Scholasticism in the strict sense of the term, it tended to become agnostic. Apart from the Averroists—who became more and more an iso1]

Gothic Architecture

lated sect as time went on—this happened in that mighty movement, rightly called *“‘modern’’ by the

later schoolmen, which began with Peter Aureolus (ca. 1280-1323) and came to fruition in William of

Ockham (ca. 1295-1349 or 1350): in critical nom-

inalism (‘‘critical’’ as opposed to the dogmatic, pre-Scholastic nominalism associated with the name of Roscellinus and apparently quite dead for nearly 200 years). In contrast even to the Aristotelian, the nominalist denies all real existence to universals and grants it only to particulars, so that the nightmare of the High Scholastics—the problem of the principium individuationis by virtue of which The

Universal Cat materializes into an infinite number of particular cats—dissolved into nothingness. As Peter Aureolus puts it, “everything is individual by virtue of itself and by nothing else’’ (omnis res est se ipsa singularis et per nihil aliud).

On the other hand, there reappeared the eternal 12

And Scholasticism

dilemma of empiricism: since the quality of reality

belongs exclusively to that which can be apprehended by notitia intuitiva, that is, to the particular ‘‘things’’ directly perceived by the senses, and to

the particular psychological states or acts (joy, grief, willing, etc.) directly known through inner experience, all that which is real, viz., the world of

physical objects and the world of psychological processes, can never be rational, while all that which is rational, viz., the concepts distilled from these two worlds by notitia abstractiva, can never be

real; so that all metaphysical and theological problems—including the existence of God, the immortality of the soul, and in at least one case (Nicholas of Autrecourt) even causation—can be discussed only in terms of probability.° The common denominator of these new currents is, of course, subjectivism—aesthetic subjectivism in the case of the poet and humanist, religious sub13

Gothic Architecture

jectivism in that of the mystic, and epistemological

subjectivism in that of the nominalist. In fact, these two extremes, mysticism and nominalism, are, in a sense, nothing but opposite aspects of the same thing. Both mysticism and nominalism cut the tie between reason and faith. But mysticism—much

more emphatically divorced from Scholasticism in

the generation of Tauler, Suso, and John of Ruysbroeck than in that of Master Eckhart—does so in

order to save the integrity of religious sentiment, while nominalism seeks to preserve the integrity of rational thought and empirical observation (Ockham explicitly denounces as ‘‘temerarious’’ any attempt to subject “‘logic, physics, and grammar’”’ to the control of theology). Both mysticism and nominalism throw the individual back upon the resources of private sensory and psychological experience; intuitus is a favorite term and central concept of Master Eckhart as well 14

And Scholasticism

as of Ockham. But the mystic depends on his senses as purveyors of visual images and emotional stimuli,

whereas the nominalist relies on them as conveyors

of reality; and the intuitus of the mystic is focused

upon a unity beyond the distinction even between man and God and even between the Persons of the

Trinity, whereas the intuitus of the nominalist is focused upon the multiplicity of particular things and psychological processes. Both mysticism and nominalism end up with abolishing the borderline between the finite and the infinite. But the mystic tends to infinitize the ego because he believes in the self-extinction of the human soul in God, whereas

the nominalist tends to infinitize the physical world because he sees no logical contradiction in the idea

of an infinite physical universe and no longer ac-

cepts the theological objections thereto. Small wonder that the nominalistic school of the fourteenth century anticipated the heliocentric system 15

Gothic Architecture

of Copernicus, the geometrical analysis of Descartes, and the mechanics of Galileo and Newton. Similarly, Late Gothic art broke up into a variety

of styles reflecting these regional and ideological differences. But this variety, too, is unified by a subjectivism which, in the visual sphere, corresponds to what can be observed in intellectual life. The most characteristic expression of this subjectivism is the emergence of a perspective interpretation of space which, originating with Giotto and Duccio, began to be accepted everywhere from

1330-40. In redefining the material painting or drawing surface as an immaterial projection plane, perspective—however imperfectly handled at the beginning—renders account, not only of what is seen but also of the way it is seen under particular conditions. It records, to borrow Ockham’s term, the direct intuitus from subject to object, thus paving the way for modern “‘naturalism’’ and lending 16

And Scholasticism

visual expression to the concept of the infinite; for the perspective vanishing point can be defined only as ‘‘the projection of the point in which parallels

intersect.’ We understandably think of perspective as a device of only the two-dimensional arts. However,

this new way of seeing—or, rather, of designing with reference to the very process of sight—was bound to change the other arts as well. The sculptors and architects also began to conceive of the forms they shaped, not so much in terms of isolated

solids as in terms of a comprehensive ‘‘picture space,’ although this ‘picture space’’ constitutes itself in the beholder’s eye instead of being presented to him in a prefabricated projection. The three-dimensional media, too, supply, as it were, material for a pictorial experience. This is true of

all Late Gothic sculpture—even if the pictorial principle is not carried so far as in Claus Sluter’s 17

Gothic Architecture

stagelike portal of Champmol, the typical fifteenth-

century ‘‘Schnitzaltar,’’ or those trick figures that look up a spire or down from a balcony; and it is also true of ‘‘Perpendicular’’ architecture in England and of the new types of hall church and semihall church in the Germanic countries.

All this applies not only to those innovations which may be said to reflect the empiristic and particularistic spirit of nominalism: the landscape and

the interior with concomitant emphasis on genre features, and the autonomous and completely individualized portrait which represents the sitter, as Peter Aureolus would say, as ‘‘something individual by virtue of itself and nothing else,’’ where somewhat earlier likenesses merely superimpose, as it were, a Scotian haecceitas upon a still typified image. It also applies to those new Andachtsbilder which are commonly associated with mysticism: 18

And Scholasticism

the Pietd, St. John on the Bosom of the Lord, the

Man of Sorrows, Christ in the Winepress, etc. In their own way, such ‘‘images for worship by empathy,’’ as the term may be paraphrased, are no less

‘‘naturalistic,’’ often to the point of gruesomeness,

than are the portraits, landscapes, and interiors which have been mentioned; and where the portraits, landscapes, and interiors induce a sense of infinity by making the beholder aware of the unend-

ing variety and limitlessness of God’s creation, the Andachtsbilder induce a sense of infinity by permit-

ting the beholder to submerge his being in the boundlessness of the Creator Himself. Once more nominalism and mysticism prove to be les extrémes

qui se touchent. We can easily see that these appar-

ently irreconcilable tendencies could variously in-

terpenetrate in the fourteenth century and ultimately merge, for one glorious moment, in the 19

Gothic Architecture —

painting of the great Flemings, much as they did in the philosophy of their admirer, Nicholas of Cusa, who died in the same year as Roger van der Weyden. il

During the “‘concentrated’’ phase of this aston-

ishingly synchronous development, viz., in the period between about 1130-40 and about 1270, we can observe, it seems to me, a connection between Gothic art and Scholasticism which is more concrete than a mere “‘parallelism’’ and yet more general than those individual (and very important)

‘influences’? which are inevitably exerted on painters, sculptors, or architects by erudite advisers. In contrast to a mere parallelism, the connection which I have in mind is a genuine cause-andeffect relation; but in contrast to an individual influence, this cause-and-effect relation comes about by diffusion rather than by direct impact. It comes 20

And Scholasticism

about by the spreading of what may be called, for

want of a better term, a mental habit—reducing this overworked cliché to its precise Scholastic sense as a ‘‘principle that regulates the act,’’ principium importans ordinem ad actum.? Such mental habits are at work in all and every civilization. All modern writing on history is permeated by the idea

of evolution (an idea the evolution of which needs much more study than it has received thus far and seems to enter a critical phase right now); and all of us, without a thorough knowledge of biochemistry or psychoanalysis, speak with the greatest of ease of vitamin deficiencies, allergies, mother fixations, and inferiority complexes.

Often it is difficult or impossible to single out one habit-forming force from many others and to imagine the channels of transmission. However, the period from about 1130—40 to about 1270 and the

‘“too-mile zone around Paris’’ constitute an ex21

Gothic Architecture

ception. In this tight little sphere Scholasticism possessed what amounted to a monopoly in education. By and large, intellectual training shifted from

the monastic schools to institutions urban rather than rural, cosmopolitan rather than regional, and, so to speak, only half ecclesiastic: to the cathedral schools, the universities, and the studia of the new

mendicant orders—nearly all of them products of the thirteenth century—whose members played an increasingly important role within the universities themselves. And as the Scholastic movement, prepared by Benedictine learning and initiated by Lan-

franc and Anselm of Bec, was carried on and brought to fruition by the Dominicans and Francis-

cans, so did the Gothic style, prepared in Benedictine monasteries and initiated by Suger of St.Denis, achieve its culmination in the great city churches. It is significant that during the Romanesque period the greatest names in architectural 22

And Scholasticism

history are those of Benedictine abbeys, in the High Gothic period those of cathedrals, and in the Late Gothic periods those of parish churches. It is not very probable that the builders of Gothic

structures read Gilbert de la Porree or Thomas Aquinas in the original. But they were exposed to the Scholastic point of view in innumerable other ways, quite apart from the fact that their own work automatically brought them into a working association with those who devised the liturgical and

iconographic programs. They had gone to school;

they listened to sermons; they could attend the public disputationes de quolibet which, dealing as they did with all imaginable questions of the day, had

developed into social events not unlike our operas, concerts, or public lectures ;* and they could come

into profitable contact with the learned on many

other occasions. The very fact that neither the natural sciences nor the humanities nor even 23

Gothic Architecture

mathematics had evolved their special esoteric methods and terminologies kept the whole of human knowledge within the range of the normal, non-specialized intellect; and—perhaps the most

important point—the entire social system was rapidly changing toward an urban professionalism.

Not as yet hardened into the later guild and ‘‘Bau-

hiitten’’ systems, it provided a meeting ground where the priest and the layman, the poet and the lawyer, the scholar and the artisan could get together on terms of near-equality. There appeared the professional, town-dwelling publisher (stationarius, hence our “‘stationer’’), who, more or less strictly supervised by a university, produced manuscript books en masse with the aid of hired scribes,

together with the bookseller (mentioned from about 1170), the book-lender, the bookbinder, and the book-illuminator (by the end of the thirteenth 24

And Scholasticism

century the enlumineurs already occupied a whole

street in Paris); the professional, town-dwelling painter, sculptor, and jeweller; the professional, town-dwelling scholar who, though usually a cleric, yet devoted the substance of his life to writing and teaching (hence the words “‘scholastic’’ and ‘‘scholasticism’’); and, last but not least, the professional, town-dwelling architect. This professional architect—‘‘professional’’ in

contradistinction to the monastic equivalent of what in modern times is called the gentleman archi-

tect—would rise from the ranks and supervise the work in person. In doing so he grew into a man of the world, widely travelled, often well read, and enjoying a social prestige unequalled before and unsurpassed since. Freely selected propter sagacitatem ingenii, he drew a salary envied by the lower

clergy and would appear at the site, “‘carrying 25

Gothic Architecture

gloves and a rod”’ (virga), to give those curt orders that became a byword in French literature whenever a writer wished to describe a man who does things well and with superior assurance: ‘*Par cy me le taille.’’? His portrait would figure together

with that of the founding bishop in the “‘labyrinths’’ of the great cathedrals. After Hugues Liber-

gier, the master of the lost St.-Nicaise in Reims, had died in 1263, he was accorded the unheard-of honor of being immortalized in an effigy that shows

him not only clad in something like academic garb but also carrying a model of “‘his’’ church—a privilege previously accorded only to princely donors

(ig. 1). And Pierre de Montereau—indeed the most logical architect who ever lived—is designated on his tombstone in St.-Germain-des-Preés as

‘‘Doctor Lathomorum’’: by 1267, it seems, the architect himself had come to be looked upon as a kind of Scholastic. 26

And Scholasticism

Il When asking in what manner the mental habit induced by Early and High Scholasticism may have

affected the formation of Early and High Gothic

architecture, we shall do well to disregard the notional content of the doctrine and to concentrate, to borrow a term from the schoolmen themselves, upon its modus operandi. The changing tenets in such matters as the relation between soul and

body or the problem of universals vs. particulars naturally were reflected in the representational arts rather than in architecture. True, the architect

lived in close contact with the sculptors, glass painters, wood carvers, etc., whose work he studied wherever he went (witness the ‘‘Album’’ of

Villard de Honnecourt), whom he engaged and supervised in his own enterprises, and to whom he had to transmit an iconographic program which,

we remember, he could work out only in close 27

Gothic Architecture

cooperation with a scholastic adviser. But in doing

all this, he assimilated and conveyed rather than applied the substance of contemporary thought. What he who “‘devised the form of the building while not himself manipulating its matter’’!° could

and did apply, directly and qua architect, was rather that peculiar method of procedure which must have been the first thing to impress itself upon the mind of the layman whenever it came in touch with that of the schoolman.

This method of procedure follows, as every modus operandi does, from a modus essendi ;"' it fol-

lows from the very raison d’étre of Early and High

Scholasticism, which is to establish the unity of truth. The men of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries attempted a task not yet clearly envisaged by their forerunners and ruefully to be abandoned by their successors, the mystics and the nominalists:

the task of writing a permanent peace treaty be28

And Scholasticism

tween faith and reason. ‘‘Sacred doctrine,’’ says Thomas Aquinas, ‘“makes use of human reason, not

to prove faith but to make clear (manifestare) whatever else is set forth in this doctrine.’’!? This means

that human reason can never hope to furnish direct

proof of such articles of faith as the tri-personal structure of the Trinity, the Incarnation, the tem-

porality of Creation, etc.; but that it can, and does, elucidate or clarify these articles. First, human reason can furnish direct and com-

plete proof for whatever can be deduced from principles other than revelation, that is, for all ethical, physical, and metaphysical tenets including

the very praeambula fidei, such as the existence (though not the essence) of God, which can be proved by an argument from effect to cause.'3 Sec-

ond, it can elucidate the content of revelation itself; by argument, though merely negatively, it can

refute all rational objections against the Articles of 29

Gothic Architecture

Faith—objections that must of necessity be either false or inconclusive ;'4 and positively, though not

by argument, it can supply similitudines which ‘“manifest’’ the mysteries by way of analogy, as when the relation between the Three Persons of the Trinity is likened to that between being, knowledge and love in our own mind,'5 or divine creation

to the work of the human artist." Manifestatio, then, elucidation or clarification, is

what I would call the first controlling principle of Early and High Scholasticism.'? But in order to put this principle into operation on the highest possible plane—elucidation of faith by reason—it had to be applied to reason itself: if faith had to be ‘‘manifested’’ through a system of thought complete and self-sufficient within its own limits yet setting itself apart from the realm of revelation, it became neces-

sary to ‘‘manifest’’ the completeness, self-sufh30

And Scholasticism

ciency, and limitedness of the system of thought. And this could be done only by a scheme of literary

presentation that would elucidate the very processes of reasoning to the reader’s imagination just as reasoning was supposed to elucidate the very nature of faith to his intellect. Hence the much derided schematism or formalism of Scholastic

writing which reached its climax in the classic Summa'® with its three requirements of (1) totality (sufficient enumeration), (2) arrangement accord-

ing to a system of homologous parts and parts of parts (sufficient articulation), and (3) distinctness and deductive cogency (sufficient interrelation)—

all this enhanced by the literary equivalent of Thomas Aquinas’s similitudines: suggestive terminology, parallelismus membrorum, and rhyme. A well-

known instance of the two latter devices—both artistic as well as mnemonic—is St. Bonaventure’s 3]

Gothic Architecture

succinct defense of religious images which he declares admissible ‘‘propter simplicium ruditatem, propter

affectuum tarditatem, propter memoriae labilitatem.’’'9

We take it for granted that major works of schol-

arship, especially systems of philosophy and doctoral theses, are organized according to a scheme

of division and subdivision, condensable into a table of contents or synopsis, where all parts denoted by numbers or letters of the same class are on the same logical level; so that the same relation of subordination obtains between, say, sub-section (a), section (1), chapter (I) and book (A) as does between, say, sub-section (b), section (5), chapter (IV) and book (C). However, this kind of system-

atic articulation was quite unknown until the advent of Scholasticism.”° Classical writings (except

perhaps for those that consisted of denumerable items such as collections of short poems or treatises on mathematics) were merely divided into “‘books.”’ 32

And Scholasticism

When we wish to give what we, unsuspecting heirs

to Scholasticism, call an exact quotation, we must either refer to the pages of a printed edition conventionally accepted as authoritative (as we do with Plato and Aristotle), or to a scheme introduced by some humanist of the Renaissance as when we quote

a Vitruvius passage as ‘‘VII, 1, 3.”’

It was, it seems, not until the earlier part of the Middle Ages that ‘“books’’ were divided into num-

bered “‘chapters’’ the sequence of which did not, however, imply or reflect a system of logical subor-

dination; and it was not until the thirteenth century that the great treatises were organized according to an overall plan secundum ordinem disciplinae*’

so that the reader is led, step by step, from one proposition to the other and is always kept informed as to the progress of this process. The whole is divided into partes which—like the Second Part of Thomas Aquinas’s Summa Theologiae—could be 33

Gothic Architecture

divided into smaller partes; the partes into membra, quaestiones or distinctiones, and these into articuli.??

Within the articuli, the discussion proceeds according to a dialectical scheme involving further subdi-

vision, and almost every concept is split up into two or more meanings (intendi potest dupliciter, tripliciter, etc.) according to its varying relation to others. On the other hand, a number of membra, quaestiones, or distinctiones are often tied together into a group. The first of the three partes that con-

stitute Thomas Aquinas’s Summa Theologiae, a veritable orgy both of logic and Trinitarian symbolism, is an excellent case in point.?3 All this does not mean, of course, that the Scho-

lastics thought in more orderly and logical fashion

than Plato and Aristotle; but it does mean that they, in contrast to Plato and Aristotle, felt compelled to make the orderliness and logic of their thought palpably explicit—that the principle of 34

And Scholasticism

manifestatio which determined the direction and scope of their thinking also controlled its exposition

and subjected this exposition to what may be termed the POSTULATE OF CLARIFICATION FOR CLARIFICATION’ S SAKE,

IV

Within Scholasticism itself this principle resulted not only in the explicit unfolding of what, though necessary, might have been allowed to remain implicit, but also, occasionally, in the introduction of what was not necessary at all, or in the neglect of a natural order of presentation in favor of an artificial symmetry. In the very Prologue of the Summa Theologiae, Thomas Aquinas complains, with

an eye on his forerunners, of “‘the multiplication of useless questions, articles, and arguments’”’ and of a tendency to present the subject “‘not according to

the order of the discipline itself but rather accord35

Gothic Architecture

ing to the requirements of literary exposition.’’ However, the passion for “‘clarification’’ imparted

itself{—quite naturally in view of the educational

monopoly of Scholasticism—to virtually every mind engaged in cultural pursuits; it grew into a ‘“mental habit.’’

Whether we read a treatise on medicine, a hand-

book of classical mythology such as Ridewall’s Fulgentius Metaforalis, a political propaganda sheet,

the eulogy of a ruler, or a biography of Ovid,*+ we always find the same obsession with systematic divi-

sion and subdivision, methodical demonstration, terminology, parallelismus membrorum, and rhyme.

Dante’s Divina Commedia is Scholastic, not only in

much of its content but also in its deliberately Trinitarian form.?5 In the Vita Nuova the poet himself goes out of his way to analyze the tenor of each sonnet and canzone by ‘‘parts’’ and ‘“parts of parts’

in perfectly Scholastic fashion, whereas Petrarch, 36

And Scholasticism

half a century later, was to conceive of the structure of his songs in terms of euphony rather than logic, “‘I thought of changing the order of the four stanzas so that the first quatrain and the first terzina

would have come second and vice versa,’’ he remarks of one sonnet, “‘but I gave it up because then the fuller sound would have been in the middle and

the hollower at the beginning and the end.’’”® What applies to prose and poetry applies no less

emphatically to the arts. Modern Gestalt psychology, in contrast to the doctrine of the nineteenth century and very much in harmony with that of the thirteenth, ‘‘refuses to reserve the capacity of synthesis to the higher faculties of the human mind”’ and stresses ‘‘the formative powers of the sensory processes.’ Perception itself is now credited—and I quote—with a kind of “‘intelligence’’ that ‘‘organizes the sensory material under the pattern of simple, ‘good’ Gestalten’’ in an ‘‘effort of the organ37

Gothic Architecture ism to assimilate stimuli to its own organization’’ ;?? all

of which is the modern way of expressing precisely what Thomas Aquinas meant when he wrote: ‘“‘the

senses delight in things duly proportioned as in something akin to them; for, the sense, too, is a kind of reason as is every cognitive power’’ (°‘sensus delectantur

in rebus debite proportionatis sicut in sibi similibus ; nam et sensus ratio quaedam est, et omnis virtus cognoscitiva’’),?8

Small wonder, then, that a mentality which deemed it necessary to make faith ‘‘clearer’’ by an appeal to reason and to make reason ‘‘clearer’’ by an appeal to imagination, also felt bound to make imagination “‘clearer’’ by an appeal to the senses. Indirectly, this preoccupation affected even philosophical and theological literature in that the intel-

lectual articulation of the subject matter implies the acoustic articulation of speech by recurrent phrases, and the visual articulation of the written 38

And Scholasticism

page by rubrics, numbers, and paragraphs. Directly, it affected all the arts. As music became articulated

through an exact and systematic division of time (it was the Paris school of the thirteenth century that introduced the mensural notation still in use

and still referred to, in England at least, by the original terms of ‘‘breve,’’ “‘semibreve,’’ ‘‘minim,’’ etc.), so did the visual arts become articulated through an exact and systematic division of space, resulting in a “‘clarification for clarification’s

sake’’ of narrative contexts in the representational arts, and of functional contexts in architecture. In the field of the representational arts this might be demonstrated by an analysis of almost any single

figure; but it is still more evident in the arrangement of ensembles. Barring such accidents as happened at Magdeburg or Bamberg, the composition of a High Gothic portal, for example, tends to be subjected to a strict and fairly standardized scheme 39

Gothic Architecture

which, in imposing order upon the formal arrangement, simultaneously clarifies the narrative content. Suffice it to compare the beautiful but as yet

not “‘clarified’’ Last Judgement portal of Autun (fig. 2) with those of Paris or Amiens (fig. 3) where —in spite of an even greater wealth of motifs—con-

summate clarity prevails. The tympanum is sharply

divided into three registers (a device unknown in Romanesque save only such well-motivated exceptions as St.-Ursin-de-Bourges and Pompierre), the Deésis being separated from the Damned and the Elect, and these again from the Resurrected. The Apostles, precariously included in the tympanum at Autun, are placed in the embrasures where they surmount the twelve Virtues and their ‘counter-

parts (developed from the customary heptad by a Scholastically correct subdivision of Justice) in such a manner that Fortitude corresponds to St. Peter, the “‘rock,’’ and Charity to St. Paul, the 40

And Scholasticism

author of J Corinthians, 13; and the Wise and Foolish Virgins, antetypes of the Elect and the Damned,

have been added in the doorposts by way of a marginal gloss.

In painting, we can observe the process of clarifi-

cation in vitro, so to speak. We can compare, by an

extraordinary chance, a series of miniatures of about 1250 with their direct models, produced in the latter half of the eleventh century probably after 1079 and certainly before 1096 (fig. 4—7).?9 The two best known (fig. 6 and 7) represent King Philip I conferring privileges and donations, among

them the church of St.-Samson, upon the Priory of St.-Martin-des-Champs. But where the Early Ro-

manesque prototype, an unframed pen drawing, shows a jumble of figures, buildings, and inscriptions, the High Gothic copy is a carefully organized picture. It pulls the whole together by a frame (adding, in a new feeling for realism and communal 4]

Gothic Architecture

dignity, a consecration ceremony at the bottom). Neatly segregating the different elements, it divides

the area within the frame into four sharply delimited fields which correspond to the categories of the King, the Ecclesiastical Structures, the Episcopate, and the Secular Nobility. The two buildings—

St.-Martin itself and St.-Samson—are not only brought up to the same level but also represented in pure side elevation instead of being shown in

mixed projection. The fact that the dignitaries, formerly unattended and uniformly frontalized, are accompanied by some minor personages and have acquired the faculties of movement and intercom-

munication enhances rather than weakens their individual significance; and the only ecclesiastic who, for good reasons, has found his place among

the counts and princes, Archdeacon Drogo of Paris, is clearly set off against them by his chasuble and mitre. 42

And Scholasticism

It was, however, in architecture that the habit of

clarification achieved its greatest triumphs. As High Scholasticism was governed by the principle of manifestatio, so was High Gothic architecture

dominated—as already observed by Suger—by what may be called the ‘‘principle of transparency.”’

Pre-Scholasticism had insulated faith from reason

by an impervious barrier much as a Romanesque structure (fig. 8) conveys the impression of a space

determinate and impenetrable, whether we find ourselves inside or outside the edifice. Mysticism was to drown reason in faith, and nominalism was

to completely disconnect one from the other; and both these attitudes may be said to find expression in the Late Gothic hall church. Its barnlike shell

encloses an often wildly pictorial and always apparently boundless interior (fig. 9) and thus creates a space determinate and impenetrable from without

but indeterminate and penetrable from within. 43

Gothic Architecture

High Scholastic philosophy, however, severely limited the sanctuary of faith from the sphere of rational knowledge yet insisted that the content of this sanctuary remain clearly discernible. And so did High Gothic architecture delimit interior volume from exterior space yet insist that it project itself, as it were, through the encompassing struc-

ture (fig. 15 and 16); so that, for example, the cross section of the nave can be read off from the facade (fig. 34). Like the High Scholastic Summa, the High Gothic

cathedral aimed, first of all, at “‘totality’’ and there-

fore tended to approximate, by synthesis as well as elimination, one perfect and final solution ; we may therefore speak of the High Gothic plan or the High

Gothic system with much more confidence than would be possible in any other period. In its imagery, the High Gothic cathedral sought to embody

the whole of Christian knowledge, theological, 44

And Scholasticism

moral, natural, and historical, with everything in its place and that which no longer found its place, suppressed. In structural design, it similarly sought

to synthesize all major motifs handed down by separate channels and finally achieved an unparalleled balance between the basilica and the central

plan type, suppressing all elements that might endanger this balance, such as the crypt, the galler-

ies, and towers other than the two in front. The second requirement of Scholastic writing, ‘“arrangement according to a system of homologous

parts and parts of parts,’’ is most graphically expressed in the uniform division and subdivision of the whole structure. Instead of the Romanesque variety of western and eastern vaulting forms, often

appearing in one and the same building (groin vaults, rib vaults, barrels, domes, and half-domes), we have the newly developed rib vault exclusively so that the vaults of even the apse, the chapels and 45

Gothic Architecture

the ambulatory no longer differ in kind from those

of the nave and transept (fig. 10 and 11). Since Amiens, rounded surfaces were entirely eliminated,

except, of course, for the webbing of the vaults. Instead of the contrast that normally existed between tripartite naves and undivided transepts (or quinquepartite naves and tripartite transepts) we have tripartition in both cases; and instead of the disparity (either in size, or in the type of covering, or in both) between the bays of the high nave and

those of the side aisles, we have the ‘‘uniform travee,’’ in which one rib-vaulted central bay connects with one rib-vaulted aisle bay on either side. The whole is thus composed of smallest units—one might almost speak of articulimwhich are homologous in that they are all triangular in groundplan and in that each of these triangles shares its sides with its neighbors. 46

And Scholasticism

As a result of this homology we perceive what corresponds to the hierarchy of “‘logical levels’’ in a well-organized Scholastic treatise. Dividing the entire structure, as was customary in the period itself, into three main parts, the nave, the transept, and the chevet (which in turn comprises the forechoir and the choir proper), and distinguishing, within these parts, between high nave and sideaisles, on the one hand, and between apse, ambulatory, and hemicycle of chapels, on the other, we can observe analogous relations to obtain: first, between each central bay, the whole of the central nave, and the entire nave, transept or fore-choir, respectively; second, between each side aisle bay, the whole of each side aisle, and the entire nave,

transept or fore-choir, respectively; third, between each sector of the apse, the whole apse, and the entire choir; fourth, between each section 47

Gothic Architecture

of the ambulatory, the whole ambulatory and the entire choir; and fifth, between each chapel, the whole hemicycle of chapels, and the entire choir. It is not possible here—nor is it necessary—to describe how this principle of progressive divisibility (or, to look at it the other way, multiplicability) increasingly affected the entire edifice down to the smallest detail. At the height of the development, supports were divided and subdivided into main piers, major shafts, minor shafts, and still minor shafts; the tracery of windows, triforia, and blind arcades into primary, secondary, and tertiary mullions and profiles; ribs and arches into a series of moldings (fig. 22). It may be mentioned, however, that the very principle of homology that controls the whole process implies and accounts for the rela-

tive uniformity which distinguishes the High Gothic vocabulary from the Romanesque. All parts

that are on the same “‘logical level’’—and this is 48

And Scholasticism

especially noticeable in those decorative and representational features which, in architecture, correspond to Thomas Aquinas’s similitudines—came to be conceived of as members of one class, so that the

enormous variety in, for instance, the shape of canopies, the decoration of socles and archevaults, and, above all, the form of piers and capitals tended

to be suppressed in favor of standard types admit-

ting only of such variations as would occur in nature among individuals of one species. Even in the world of fashion the thirteenth century is dis-

tinguished by a reasonableness and uniformity (even as far as the difference between masculine and feminine costumes is concerned) which was equally foreign to the preceding and to the following period. The theoretically illimited fractionization of the edifice is limited by what corresponds to the third

requirement of Scholastic writing: “‘distinctness 49

Gothic Architecture

and deductive cogency.’’ According to classic High

Gothic standards the individual elements, while

forming an indiscerptible whole, yet must proclaim their identity by remaining clearly separated from each other—the shafts from the wall or the

core of the pier, the ribs from their neighbors, all

vertical members from their arches; and there must be an unequivocal correlation between them. We must be able to tell which element belongs to

which, from which results what might be called a ‘postulate of mutual inferability’’—not in dimensions, as in classical architecture, but in conformation. While Late Gothic permitted, even delighted in, flowing transitions and interpenetrations, and

loved to defy the rule of correlation by, for instance, over-membrification of the ceiling and under-membrification of the supports (fig. 9), the classic style demands that we be able to infer, not only the interior from the exterior or the shape of 50

And Scholasticism

the side aisles from that of the central nave but also, say, the organization of the whole system from the cross section of one pier. The last-named instance is especially instructive. In order to establish uniformity among all the supports, including those in the rond-point (and also, perhaps, in deference to a latent classicizing impulse), the builders of the most important structures after Senlis, Noyon, and Sens had abandoned

the compound pier and had sprung the nave arcades from monocylindrical piers (fig. 18).3° This,

of course, made it impossible to ‘‘express,’’ as it were, the superstructure in the conformation of the supports. In order to accomplish this and yet

preserve the now accepted form, there was invented the pilier cantonné, the columnar pier with four applied colonnettes (fig. 19-21). However, while this type, adopted in Chartres, Reims, and

Amiens,3' permitted the ‘‘expression’’ of the >]

Gothic Architecture

transverse ribs of the nave and side aisles as well

as the longitudinal arches of the nave arcades, it did not permit the “‘expression’’ of the diagonals (fig. 51). The final solution was found (in St.Denis) by the resumption of the compound pier, reorganized, however, in such a way that it “‘expressed’’ every feature of a High Gothic superstructure (fig. 22). The inner profile of the nave arches is taken up by a strong colonnette, their outer profile by a slighter one, the transverse and diagonal ribs of the nave by three tall shafts (the central one stronger than the two others) to which correspond three analogous colonnettes for the transverse and diagonal ribs of the side-aisles; and even what remains of the nave wall—the only ele-

ment that stubbornly persisted in being “‘wall’’— is “‘manifested’’ in the rectangular, still ‘‘mural’’ core of the pier itself (fig. 52).3? This is indeed ‘‘rationalism.’’ It is not quite the 52

And Scholasticism

rationalism conceived by Choisy and Viollet-leDuc,33 for the compound piers of St.-Denis have no functional, let alone economic, advantages over

the piliers cantonnés of Reims or Amiens; but neither is it—as Pol Abraham would have us believe—‘illusionism.’’34 From the point of view of the modern archaeologist this famous quarrel between Pol Abraham and the functionalists can be settled by the reasonable compromise proposed by Marcel Aubert and Henri Focillon and, as a matter of fact, already envisaged by Ernst Gall. 35

No doubt Pol Abraham is wrong in denying the practical value of even such features as ribs and flying buttresses. The skeleton of ‘‘independently constructed ribs’’ (arcus singulariter voluti),3° much

heavier and more robust than their graceful profiles

lead us to believe (fig. 24), did have considerable technical advantages in that it made it possible to vault the webs in freehand (which saved much wood 53

Gothic Architecture

and labor for centering) and to reduce their thickness ; for according to complicated modern calculations, the simple result of which was so well known,

empirically, to the Gothic builders that they took

it for granted in their writings,37 an arch twice as thick as another is, ceteris paribus, just twice as

strong; which means that ribs do reinforce the vault. That Gothic vaults have been known to sur-

vive when the ribs were blasted away by artillery fire in World War I does not prove that they would have survived had they been deprived of their ribs after seven weeks instead of after seven centuries;

for ancient masonry will hold together by sheer cohesion so that major portions even of the walls may be seen hanging, as it were, in position after the loss of their supports (fig. 25).3°

Buttresses and flying buttresses do counteract the deformative forces which threaten the stability

of every vault.39 And that the Gothic masters— 54

And Scholasticism

excepting only those headstrong Milanese ignoramuses who blandly contended that “‘no thrust upon

the buttresses is exerted by vaults with pointed arches’’—-were fully aware of this is documented

by several texts and attested to by their very trade expressions such as contrefort, bouterec (hence our

‘‘buttress’’), arc-boutant, or the German strebe (hence, interestingly enough, the Spanish estribo),

all of which denote the function of a thrust or counterthrust.4° The upper range of flying buttresses—subsequently added in Chartres but planned from the outset in Reims and in most major edifices after that—may well have been intended to lend support to the steeper, heavier roofs and, possibly, to resist the wind pressure against them.*' Even tracery has a certain practical value in that it facilitates the installation and aids the preservation of glass.

On the other hand, it is equally true that the 55

Gothic Architecture

earliest genuine ribs appear in connection with heavy groin vaults, where they could not have been

constructed ‘‘independently’’? and thus would neither have saved centering nor would have had much statical value afterwards (fig. 23);*? it is also

true that the flying buttresses of Chartres, their functional importance notwithstanding, appealed to the aesthetic sense so much so that the master

of the beautiful Madonna in the north transept of Reims Cathedral repeated them, en miniature, in the Madonna’s aedicule (fig. 26 and 27). The admirable architect of St.-Ouen in Rouen, whose

design most closely approximates the modern standards of statical efficiency,43 managed without an upper range of flying buttresses. And on no account could there have been any practical reason for that elaboration of the buttressing system which transforms it into a filigree of colonnettes, tabernacles, pinnacles, and tracery (fig. 29). The largest 56

And Scholasticism

of all stained glass windows, the west window of Chartres, has survived seven centuries without any tracery; and that the blind tracery applied to solid surfaces has no technical importance whatsoever goes without saying.

However, this whole discussion is not to the point. With reference to twelfth and thirteenth century architecture, the alternative, “‘all is function—all is illusion,’’ is as little valid as would be,

with reference to twelfth and thirteenth century philosophy, the alternative “‘all is search for truth —all is intellectual gymnastics and oratory.’’ The ribs of Caen and Durham, not as yet singulariter voluti, began by saying something before being able

to do it. The flying buttresses of Caen and Durham,

still hidden beneath the roofs of the side aisles (fig. 28), began by doing something before being

permitted to say so. Ultimately, the flying buttress learned to talk, the rib learned to work, and 57

Gothic Architecture

both learned to proclaim what they were doing in language more circumstantial, explicit, and ornate than was necessary for mere efficiency; and this applies also to the conformation of the piers and the tracery which had been talking as well as work-

ing all the time. We are faced neither with “‘rationalism’’ in a

purely functionalistic sense nor with “‘illusion’’ in the sense of modern I’art pour I’art aesthetics. We are faced with what may be termed a ‘‘visual logic’’ illustrative of Thomas Aquinas’s nam et sensus ratio quaedam est. A man imbued with the

Scholastic habit would look upon the mode of architectural presentation, just as he looked upon the mode of literary presentation, from the point of view of manifestatio. He would have taken it for

granted that the primary purpose of the many elements that compose a cathedral was to ensure

stability, just as he took it for granted that the 58

And Scholasticism

primary purpose of the many elements that constitute a Summa was to ensure validity. But he would not have been satisfied had not the

membrification of the edifice permitted him to re-

experience the very processes of architectural composition just as the membrification of the Summa permitted him to re-experience the very processes of cogitation. To him, the panoply of shafts, ribs, buttresses, tracery, pinnacles, and crockets was a self-analysis and self-explication of

architecture much as the customary apparatus of parts, distinctions, questions, and articles was, to him, a self-analysis and self-explication of reason. Where the humanistic mind demanded a maximum

of ‘‘harmony’’ (impeccable diction in writing, impeccable proportion, so sorely missed in Gothic structures by Vasari,+4 in architecture), the Scholastic mind demanded a maximum of explicitness. It accepted and insisted upon a gratuitous clarifica59

Gothic Architecture

tion of function through form just as it accepted

and insisted upon a gratuitous clarification of thought through language. Vv

To reach its classic phase the Gothic style needed

no more than a hundred years—from Suger’s St.Denis to Pierre de Montereau’s; and we should expect to see this rapid and uniquely concentrated development proceed with unparalleled consistency

and directness. Such, however, is not the case. Consistent the development is, but it is not direct.

On the contrary, when observing the evolution from the beginning to the “‘final solutions,’’ we receive the impression that it went on almost after the fashion of a ““jumping procession,’’ taking two

steps. forward and then one backward, as though the builders were deliberately placing obstacles in their own way. And this can be observed not only 60

And Scholasticism

under such adverse financial or geographical condi-

tions as normally produce a retrogression by default, so to speak, but in monuments of the very first rank.

The ‘“final’’ solution of the general plan was reached, we remember, in a basilica having a tripartite nave; a transept, likewise tripartite and distinctly projecting from the nave but merging, as it were, into the quinquepartite fore-choir; a concentric chevet with ambulatory and radiating chapels; and only two towers in front (fig. 11 and 16). At first glance, the natural thing would have been a rectilinear development starting from St.Germer and St.-Lucien-de-Beauvais which anticipate nearly all these features in the early twelfth century. Instead, we find a dramatic struggle between two contrasting solutions each of which

seems to lead away from the ultimate result. Suger’s St.-Denis and Sens Cathedral (fig. 12) pro61

Gothic Architecture

vided a strictly longitudinal model, with only two towers in front and the transept either stunted or entirely omitted—a plan adopted in Notre-Dame of Paris and Mantes, and still retained in the High Gothic Cathedral of Bourges.45 As though in protest

against this, the masters of Laon (fig. 13 and 14)—

possibly swayed by the unique location of their cathedral on the crest of a hill—reverted to the Germanic idea of a multinomial group with a pro-

jecting, tripartite transept and many towers (as exemplified by the Cathedral of Tournai), and it took the succeeding generations two more cathedrals to get rid of the extra towers surmounting the transept and the crossing. Chartres was planned with no less than nine towers; Reims, like Laon

itself, with seven (fig. 15); and it was not until Amiens (fig. 16) that the disposition with only two front towers was reinstated. Similarly, the ‘‘final’’ solution of the nave com62

And Scholasticism

position (fig. 19-22) implied, in plan, a succession of uniform, oblong, quadrupartite vaults and uniform, articulated piers; and, in elevation, a triadic

sequence of arcades, triforium, and clerestory. Again it would seem that this solution might have been reached by going ahead, straightforwardly, from such early twelfth-century prototypes as St.Etienne-de-Beauvais or Lessay in Normandy (fig. 17). Instead, all major structures prior to Soissons

and Chartres sport sixpartite vaults over monocylindrical piers (fig. 18) or even revert to the antiquated ‘‘alternating system.’’ Their elevation shows galleries which, in the most important build-

ings later than Noyon, are combined with a triforium (or, as in Notre-Dame-de-Paris, with the equivalent thereof) into a four-story arrangement (fig. 18).4°

In retrospect, it is easy to see that what seems to be an arbitrary deviation from the direct road is in 63

Gothic Architecture

reality an indispensable prerequisite of the ‘‘final’’

solution. Had it not been for the adoption of the many-towered group in Laon, no balance would have been achieved between the longitudinal and the centralizing tendencies, much less a unification

of a fully developed chevet with an equally fully developed tripartite transept. Had it not been for the adoption of sixpartite vaults and a four-story elevation, it would not have been possible to recon-

cile the ideal of a uniform progression from west to east with the ideals of transparency and verticalism. In both cases the “‘final’’ solutions were arrived at by the ACCEPTANCE AND ULTIMATE RECONCILIATION OF CONTRADICTORY POSSIBILITIES.47 Here we

come upon the second controlling principle of Scholasticism. And if the first—manifestatio— helped us to understand how classic High Gothic looks, this second—concordantia—may help us to understand how classic High Gothic came about. 64

And Scholasticism

All that mediaeval man could know about divine

revelation, and much of what he held to be true in

other respects, was transmitted by the authorities (auctoritates): primarily, by the canonical books of

the Bible which furnished arguments “‘intrinsic and irrefutable’’ (proprie et ex necessitate); secondarily, by the teachings of the Fathers of the Church,

which furnished arguments “‘intrinsic’’ though merely ‘‘probable,’’ and of the “‘philosophers’’ which furnished arguments “‘not intrinsic’’ (extranea) and merely probable for this very reason.* Now, it could not escape notice that these authorities, even passages of Scripture itself, often conflicted with one another. There was no other way out than to accept them just the same and to interpret and reinterpret them over and over again until they could be reconciled. This had been done by theologians from the earliest days. But the problem was not posed as a matter of principle until Abe65

Gothic Architecture

lard wrote his famous Sic et Non, wherein he showed the authorities, including Scripture, disagreeing on 158 important points—from the initial problem whether or not faith ought to seek support in human reason down to such special questions as

the permissibility of suicide (155) or concubinage (124). Such a systematic collection and confrontation of conflicting authorities had long been a prac-

tice of the canonists; but law, though God-given, was, after all, man-made. Abelard showed himself

very conscious of his boldness in exposing the ‘differences or even contradictions’’ (ab invicem diversa, verum etiam invicem adversa) within the very

sources of revelation when he wrote that this ‘“would stimulate the reader all the more vigorously to inquire into the truth the more the authority of Scripture is extolled.’’49 After having laid down, in his splendid introduc-

tion, the basic principles of textual criticism (in66

And Scholasticism

cluding the possibility of clerical error in even a Gospel, such as the ascription of a prophesy of Zacharias to Jeremias in Matthew, xxvul, 9), Abelard

mischievously refrained from proposing solutions. But it was inevitable that such solutions should be worked out, and this procedure became a more and

more important part, perhaps the most important

part, of the Scholastic method. Roger Bacon, shrewdly observing the diverse origins of this Scho-

lastic method, reduced it to three components: ‘‘division into many parts as do the dialecticians; rhythmical consonances as do the grammarians; and forced harmonizations (concordiae violentes) as

used by the jurists.’’5°

It was this technique of reconciling the seemingly irreconcilable, perfected intoa fine art through

the assimilation of Aristotelian logic, that determined the form of academic instruction, the ritual of the public disputationes de quolibet already men67

Gothic Architecture

tioned, and, above all, the process of argumentation in the Scholastic writings themselves. Every topic (e.g., the content of every articulus in the Summa Theologiae) had to be formulated as a quaestio

the discussion of which begins with the alignment of one set of authorities (videtur quod . . .) against the other (sed contra . . .), proceeds to the solution

(respondeo dicendum . . .), and is followed by an individual critique of the arguments rejected (ad primum, ad secundum, etc.)—rejected, that is, only insofar as the interpretation, not the validity, of the authorities is concerned. Needless to say, this principle was bound to form

a mental habit no less decisive and all-embracing than that of unconditional clarification. Combative

though they were in dealing with each other, the Scholastics of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries were unanimous in accepting the authorities and prided themselves on their skill in understanding 68

And Scholasticism

and exploiting them rather than on the originality of their own thought. One feels the breath of a new era when William of Ockham, whose nominalism was to cut the ties between reason and faith and

who could say: ‘‘What Aristotle thought about this, I don’t care,’’5' goes out of his way to deny the influence of his most important forerunner, Peter Aureolus. 5”

An attitude similar to that of High Scholasticism

must be presupposed in the builders of the High Gothic cathedrals. For these architects the great structures of the past had an auctoritas quite similar

to that which the Fathers had for the schoolmen.

Of two apparently contradictory motifs, both of them sanctioned by authority, one could not simply

be rejected in favor of the other. They had to be worked through to the limit and they had to be reconciled in the end; much as a saying of St. Augustine had ultimately to be reconciled with one of 69

Gothic Architecture

St. Ambrose. And this, I believe, accounts to some

extent for the apparently erratic yet stubbornly consistent evolution of Early and High Gothic archi-

tecture ; it, too, proceeded according to the scheme: videtur quod—sed contra—respondeo dicendum. )

I should like to illustrate this, most cursorily, by

three characteristic Gothic ‘*problems’’—or, as we might say, quaestiones: the rose window in the west facade, the organization of the wall beneath

the clerestory, and the conformation of the nave piers.

So far as we know, west facades were pierced by normal windows, and not by roses, until Suger— perhaps impressed by the magnificent specimen in

the north transept of St.-Etienne in Beauvais— chose to adopt the motif for the west fagade of St.Denis, superimposing a magnificent Non upon the Sic of the big window beneath it (fig. 30). The fur-

ther development of this innovation was fraught 70

And Scholasticism

with great difficulties.53 If the diameter of the rose remained comparatively small or was even reduced (as in Senlis), an awkward and ‘‘un-Gothic’’ space of wall was left on either side as well as underneath.

If the rose was enlarged to approximately the full

width of the nave, it tended to conflict with the nave vaults when seen from within and required on the exterior as wide an interval as possible between

the buttresses of the facade, thus uncomfortably diminishing the space available for side portals. Apart from this, the very concept of an isolated, circular unit conflicted with the ideals of Gothic

taste in general, and with the ideal of a Gothic facade—adequate representation of the interior— in particular. Small wonder that Normandy and—with a very

few exceptions—England plainly rejected the whole idea and simply enlarged the traditional win-

dow until it filled the available space (while Italy, 71

Gothic Architecture

characteristically, greeted the rose with enthusiasm because of its au fond anti-Gothic character).5+ The

architects of the Royal Domain and Champagne, however, felt bound to accept a motif sanctioned by the authority of St.-Denis, and it is almost amus-

ing to observe their perplexities. The architect of Notre-Dame (fig. 31) was lucky in that he had a quinquepartite nave. Courageously

though not quite honestly ignoring this fact, he built a tripartite facade the lateral sections of which

were so wide in comparison to the middle that all problems were easily solved, The master of Mantes,

however, had to make the distance between the buttresses considerably smaller than the width of the nave (as small, in fact, as was technically possi-

ble); and even then the space for the side portals was far from ample. The master of Laon, who wanted both a full-sized rose and generous side portals, resorted to a trick; he broke the buttresses 72.

And Scholasticism

so that their lower sections, framing the central portal, are closer together than the upper ones that frame the rose; and then he concealed the break by the enormous fig-leaf of his porch (fig. 32). The

masters of Amiens, finally, with their inordinately slender nave, needed two galleries (one with kings,

the other without) to fill the space between the rose and the portals (fig. 33).

It was not until 1240-50 that the school of Reims, culminating in St.-Nicaise, discovered the

““final’’ solution (fig. 34 and 35): the rose was inscribed within the pointed arch of'a huge window,

thereby becoming elastic, as it were. It could be lowered so as not to conflict with the vaults; the space beneath it could be filled with mullions and glass. The whole arrangement mirrored the cross section of the nave, and yet the window remained a window and the rosea rose. For the window-androse combination of St.-Nicaise is not, as might be 73

Gothic Architecture

thought, a simple enlargement of a bipartite bartracery window as seen, for the first time, in Reims

Cathedral (fig. 36). In such a window the circular element surmounting the openings is not, as is the

rose, a centrifugal but a centripetal form: not a wheel, with spokes radiating from a hub, but a roundel with cusps converging from a rim. Hugues

Libergier could never have arrived at his solution by merely magnifying a motif already extant; his is a genuine reconciliation of a videtur quod with a sed contra, +5

Concerning the problem of organizing the wall beneath the clerestory (unless this wall was eliminated by genuine, independently lighted galleries) the Romanesque style had offered, roughly speaking, two contrasting solutions, one emphasizing the two-dimensional surface and horizontal continuity,

the other depth and vertical articulation. On the one hand, the wall could be enlivened by a contin74

And Scholasticism

uous band of small, evenly spaced wall arches as in

Ste.-Trinite in Caen (fig. 37), St.-Martin-de-Boscherville, Le Mans, and the churches of the ClunyAutun type; on the other, by a sequence of major arches (mostly two to each bay and subdivided by colonnettes so as to constitute dead windows, so to

speak) which open onto the roof space above the side aisles as in Mont-St.-Michel, the narthex of Cluny, Sens (fig. 38), etc.

The genuine triforium, introduced in Noyon about 1170 (fig. 39), is a first synthesis of these two

types: it combines horizontal continuity with an emphasis on shadowy depth. But vertical articulation

within the bay was entirely suppressed, and this was bound to be felt all the more keenly as the clerestory windows had begun to be divided into two lights. Thus in the choir of St.-Remi at Reims and in Notre-Dame-en-Vaux at Chalons-sur-Marne

(fig. 40), a shaft or shafts (two in St.-Remi, one in 75

Gothic Architecture

Chalons) were carried from the lower ledge of the triforium right up into the clerestory, where they serve as frames for the windows, trisecting or bisecting the triforium itself. Such a solution was,

however, rejected in Laon (fig. 18) as well as, about the turn of the century, in Chartres (fig. 41) and Soissons. In these first High Gothic churches, where galleries were dropped for good and the two

lights of the windows were unified into one bipartite plate-tracery window, the triforium still— or, rather, again—consists of perfectly equal interstices separated by perfectly equal colonnettes; horizontal continuity rules supreme, all the more

so because the string courses overlap the wall shafts.

A reaction against this unmitigated horizontalism

set in at Reims where the vertical axis of the triforium bays was emphasized by thickening the cen-

tral colonnettes so that they might correspond to 76

And Scholasticism

the mullions above them (fig. 42). This was done so discreetly that the modern visitor is likely to overlook it. But the master’s colleagues did perceive the innovation and thought it important: in his sketch of the inner elevation of Reims Cathedral

Villard de Honnecourt so enormously exaggerated the slightly stouter proportions of the central col-

onnette that no one can help noticing it (fig. 43).5 What had been a mere hint in Reims became an

explicit and emphatic statement in Amiens (fig. 44). Here the triforium bay was actually bisected, as had been the case in Chalons-sur-Marne and, at

an earlier stage of evolution, in Sens: it was cut apart into two separate units, with the central colonnette transformed into a clustered pier the main shaft of which connects with the central mullion of the window.

However, in doing this, the masters of Amiens almost negated the whole idea of the triforium, 77

Gothic Architecture

dividing as they did each bay into two “‘blind windows’’ and transforming the even sequence of colonnettes into an alternation of members different

in kind, viz., colonnettes and clustered piers. As though to counteract this overemphasis on vertical

articulation, they accelerated the rhythm of the triforium and made it independent of that of the clerestory. Each of the two ‘‘blind windows’’ that constitute a triforium bay is divided into three sections, whereas each of the two lights that constitute

a clerestory window is divided into two. The horizontal element is further stressed by the elaboration of the lower string course into a band of floral ornament. It was left to Pierre de Montereau to say the final respondeo dicendum: as in Soissons and Chartres, the

triforium of St.-Denis (fig. 45) is a continuous sequence of four equal openings, separated by mem-

bers of the same species, However—and this is 78

And Scholasticism

where Amiens comes in—all of these members are

now clustered piers instead of colonnettes, the one

in the center somewhat stronger than the others; and all of them are carried up into the quadrupartite window, the central pier by means of three shafts connecting with the primary mullion, the others by means of one shaft connecting with the secondaries. Pierre de Montereau’s triforium is not only the first to be glazed but also the first to effect

a perfect reconciliation of the Sic of Chartres and Soissons (or, if you like, Ste.-Trinite-de-Caen and Autun) with the Non of Amiens (or, if you like, Chalons-sur-Marne and Sens). Now, finally, the big

wall shafts could be carried over the string courses without fear of disrupting the horizontal continuity of the triforium ; and this brings us to the last of our

‘‘problems,’’ the conformation of the nave piers. The earliest genuine piliers cantonnés occur, so far as I know, in Chartres Cathedral (begun 1194) 79

Gothic Architecture

where they are, however, not as yet composed of homogeneous elements—a cylindrical core and cylindrical colonnettes—but show, in alternation, a combination of a cylindrical core with octagonal colonnettes and a combination of cylindrical colon-

nettes with an octagonal core. This latter motif would seem to indicate that the master of Chartres was familiar with a movement, apparently originat-

ing in the borderline district between France and the Netherlands, which has left its most important traces in the choir of Canterbury Cathedral. Here William of Sens, magister operis from 1174 to 1178,

had almost playfully indulged in inventing all kinds

of variations on a modish theme enthusiastically received in England but hardly ever utilized in

Prance—the theme of piers in which a core of light-colored masonry is picturesquely contrasted with completely detached and monolithic shafts fashioned of darkest marble.57 He had produced 80

And Scholasticism

what may be called a sample card of fancy pier types, and one of these consisted, like the alternate

supports at Chartres, of an octagonal core and cylindrical shafts (fig. 46, third pier from left; hg. 54). The master of Chartres adopted this idea but de-

veloped it in an altogether different spirit. He retransformed the detached, monolithic shafts into

engaged colonnettes constructed of ordinary masonry; he substituted in every second pair of piers

a cylindrical core for the octagonal one; and, above all, he employed the pilier cantonné, not as an

interesting variant but as the basic element of the whole system. And all the first master of Reims had

to do was to eliminate the charming but not quite logical difference in shape between the colonnettes and the core. In this perfected form, the pilier cantonné is in itself a Sic et Non solution in that it shows colonnettes, 8|

Gothic Architecture

originally applied only to angular elements (splay-

ings or piers), in combination with a cylindrical nucleus. But as the early type of triforium tended to suppress vertical articulation in favor of horizontal continuity, so did the early type of pilier

cantonné tend to remain columnar rather than ‘‘mural,’’ Like a column, it ended with a capital

whereas, in a compound pier, the colonnettes facing the nave were carried through to the spring-

ings of the vaults. This created problems which gave rise to a zigzag development similar to that which could be observed in the treatment of the triforium.

First, since Gothic capitals are proportioned to

the diameter rather than to the height of their shafts, 5® there came about a combination of one big

capital (that of the nucleus) with four small ones (those of the colonnettes) only half as high. Second, 82,

And Scholasticism

and more important, the three—or even five—wall shafts rising into the vaults still started afresh above

the capitals as had been the case when the piers were monocylindrical, and it became imperative to establish a visible connection between at least the central wall shaft and what I shall call for short

the ‘‘nave colonnette,’’ viz., that colonnette of the pier which faces the nave and not the side aisle

or the neighboring pier. The master of Chartres sought to achieve this end by omitting the capital of the ‘‘nave colonnette,’’ which thus continues up

to the base of the central wall shaft (fig. 47 and 55). Far from pursuing the same course, the masters of Reims reverted to the earlier form, 5? leaving

the ‘‘nave colonnette’’ in possession of its capital,

and concentrated instead on the other problem, the inequality of the capitals’ heights. They solved it by providing each colonnette with two capitals, 83

Gothic Architecture

one superimposed upon the other, whose combined

heights equalled the height of the pier capital (fg.

48 and 56).° Amiens, on the contrary, reverted to the Char-

tres type, taking, however, one step farther in the same direction in that not only the capital of the “‘nave colonnette’’ but also the base of the central wall shaft was eliminated, so that the ‘‘nave

colonnette’’ continues into the central wall shaft itself, not only into its base as in Chartres (fig. 49 and 57). The older piers of Beauvais are generally similar to those of Amiens, but revert to the preAmiens tradition in restoring the base to the central wall shaft; and this renewed interruption of vertical coherence is further emphasized by decorative foliage (fig. 58).

Yet, when the choir of Beauvais was built, the

Gordian knot had already been cut by Pierre de Montereau’s bold revival of the compound pier 84

And Scholasticism

which solved all difficulties in that the big pier capital and the single ‘nave colonnette’’ no longer

existed (fig. 50 and 59). The three tall shafts required by the main vaults could be run from the floor bases to the springings without interruption, cutting right through the capitals of the nave arcades (fig. 22). However, Pierre de Montereau endorsed the Non rather than reconciled it with the Sic. Wisely subordinating the minor problem of the pier to the major problem of the whole system, he chose to sacrifice the columnar principle rather than to renounce that adequate ‘‘representation’’ of the nave wall by the core of the pier which

has been mentioned (fig. 52). In this case, the respondeo dicendum was to be spoken by the French-

trained master of Cologne who combined the cylin-

drical, four-shafted pilier cantonné of Amiens with

the tall, continuous shafts and subsidiary colonnettes of Pierre de Montereau’s compound pier.* 85

Gothic Architecture

But he sacrificed thereby the logical correspondence between the nave wall and the supports. Seen

in a diagram, the ground plan of the nave wall again arbitrarily intersects that of the core of the pier instead of coinciding with it (fig. 53). The gentle reader may feel about all this as Dr.

Watson felt about the phylogenetic theories of Sherlock Holmes: ‘‘It is surely rather fanciful.’’

And he may object that the development here sketched amounts to nothing but a natural evolution after the Hegelian scheme of ‘‘thesis, antithesis, and synthesis’’—a scheme that might fit other processes (for instance, the development of Quattrocento painting in Florence or even that of individual artists) just as well as it does the progress from Early to High Gothic in the heart of France. However, what distinguishes the development of French Gothic architecture from comparable phenomena is, first, its extraordinary consistency ; 86

And Scholasticism

second, the fact that the principle, videtur quod, sed contra, respondeo dicendum, seems to have been applied

with perfect consciousness.

There is one scrap of evidence—well known, to be sure, but not as yet considered in this particular light—which shows that at least some of the French

thirteenth-century architects did think and act in strictly Scholastic terms. In Villard de Honnecourt’s ‘‘Album’’ there is to be found the groundplan of an ‘‘ideal’’ chevet which he and another master, Pierre de Corbie, had devised, according to the slightly later inscription, inter se disputando (fig. 60).°? Here, then, we have two High Gothic architects discussing a quaestio, and a third one referring to this discussion by the specifically Scholastic term disputare instead of colloqui, deliberare, or the like. And what is the result of this disputatio? A chevet which combines, as it were, all possible

Sics with all possible Nons. It has a double ambu87

Gothic Architecture

latory combined with a continuous hemicycle of fully developed chapels, all nearly equal in depth. The groundplan of these chapels is alternately semi-

circular and—Cistercian fashion—square. And while the square chapels are vaulted separately, as was the usual thing, the semicircular ones are vaulted under one keystone with the adjacent sec-

tors of the outer ambulatory as in Soissons and its derivatives.°3 Here Scholastic dialectics has driven architectural thinking to a point where it almost ceased to be architectural.

88

Notes

Notes 1. To trace the development of this parallel in modern literature would require a separate study; suffice it to refer to the beautiful pages in Charles R. Morey’s Mediaeval Art, New York, 1942, pp. 255-267.

2. Cf. W. Koehler, ““Byzantine Art in the West,’’ Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 1, 1941, pp. 85 f£. 3. Cf. M. Dvordk, Idealismus und Naturalismus in der gotischen Skulptur und Malerei, Munich, 1918 (originally in Historische

Zeitschrift, 3rd ser., XXIII), passim; E. Panofsky, Deutsche Plastik des elften bis dreizehnten Jahrhunderts, Munich, 1924, pp. 65 ff. We can easily see that the ecclesiastical authorities found it hard to acquiesce in this new, Aristotelian point of view. As late as 1215 the University of Paris endorsed the

resolution of the Synod of Paris of 1210 which had condemned Aristotle’s Metaphysics and Naturalia (and even abridgments thereof) together with such outright heretics as David of Dinant and Amaury de Béne who taught the unity of God with His creation. In 1231 Pope Gregory IX tacitly admitted the Metaphysics but reiterated the prohibi9]

Notes tion of the Naturalia as long as they had not been ‘‘censored and expurgated of errors.’’ He even set up a commission for

this purpose; but by this time the moment for effective countermeasures had passed. 4. The word compendium (originally ‘‘a hoard,’’ ‘‘a saving’ ’) had come to mean “‘a shortcut’’ (compendia montis) and, still

more figuratively, a literary ‘‘abridgment’’ (compendium docendi). In the resolutions of 1210 and 1215 mentioned in note 3, the word summa is still used in this sense: ‘‘Non legantur libri Aristotelis de metaphysica et naturali historia, nec summa de iisdem.’’ According to general assumption the first instance of a Summa Theologiae in the now current sense

is that by Robert de Courzon of 1202 (not as yet published

in full). It is, however, probable that the Summae by Prévostin and Stephen Langton (likewise active at Paris)

precede it by some ten or fifteen years; cf. E. Lesne, Histoire de la propriété ecclésiastique en France, V (Les Ecoles

de la fin du VIII’ siecle a la fin du XII°) Lille, 1940, especially pp. 249 251, 676.

5. Cf. Robert Grosseteste, Roger Bacon, also William Shyreswood.

6. For Ockham, cf. the recent book by R. Guelluy, Philosophie et Théologie chez Guillaume d’Ockham, Louvain, 1947; 92

Notes

for Nicholas of Autrecourt, J. R. Weinberg, Nicolaus of Autrecourt, a Study in 14th Century Thought, Princeton, 1948.

7. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae (hereafter quoted as

S. Th.), I-II, qu. 49, art. 3, c. 8. M. de Wulf, History of Mediaeval Philosophy, 3rd English

ed. (E. C. Messenger, tr.), London, II, 1938, p. 9. g. “‘Here’s where you cut it for me.’’ For the proverbial use of this famous phrase (Nicolas de Briart, reprinted in V. Mortet and P. Deschamps, Recueil de textes relatifs a I’ histoire

de l’architecture, Paris, II, 1929, p. 290), cf. G. P. in: Romania, XVIII, 1889, p. 288.

ro. S. Th., I, qu. 1, art. 6, c. 11. [bidem, qu. 89, art. 1, c. 12. Ibidem, qu. 1, art. 8, ad 2.

13. [bidem, qu. 2, art. 2, ¢.

14. Ibidem, qu. 1, art. 8, c: ‘“‘Cum enim fides infallibili veritati innitatur, impossibile autem sit de vero demonstrari contrarium, manifestum est probationes quae contra fidem inducuntur, non esse demonstrationes, sed solubilia argumenta.’’ Cf. also the passage quoted in F, Ueberweg, 93

Notes Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie, 11th ed., Berlin, HI,

1928, p. 429.

15. S. Th., qu. 32, art. 1, ad 2; qu. 27, art. 1 and 3. As is well known, St. Augustine had already likened the relation between the Three Persons, by way of a similitudo, to that between memory, intelligence, and love (De Trinitate, XV, 41-42, reprinted in Patrologia Latina, vol. 42, col. 1088 ff.).

16. Ibidem, qu. 27, art. 1, ad 3, and passim, for instance, qu. 14, art. 3, ad 4. 17. This general characterization does not, of course, fully apply to a thinker such as St. Bonaventure, just as a general

characterization of the High Gothic style does not fully apply to a monument such as the Cathedral of Bourges. In both cases we are faced with monumental exceptions in which earlier, essentially anti-Scholastic—or, respectively, anti-Gothic—traditions and tendencies are developed within the framework of a High Scholastic—or, respectively, HighGothic—style. As Augustinian mysticism (as cultivated in the twelfth century) survives in St. Bonaventure, so does the Early Christian concept of a transeptless or nearly transeptless basilica (as exemplified by Sens Cathedral, the contemplated nave of Suger’s St.-Denis, Mantes, and Notre-Damede-Paris) survive in the Cathedral of Bourges (cf. S. McK. 94

Notes Crosby, ‘‘New Excavations in the Abbey Church of Saint Denis,’’ Gazette des Beaux-Arts, 6th ser., XXVI, 1944, pp. 115

ff. and below, pp. 61 ff.). Characteristically, both St. Bonaventure’s philosophy and Bourges Cathedral (which may be called an Augustinian church) remained without a following in some of their most significant aspects: even the Franciscans, however critical of Thomism, could not maintain St. Bonaventure’s persistence in an anti-Aristotelian attitude ; even those architects who did not subscribe to the ideals of

Reims and Amiens could not accept the Bourges master’s retention of sixpartite vaults. 18. Cf., e.g., A. Dempf, Die Hauptform mittelalterlicher Weltanschauung ; eine geisteswissenschaftliche Studie uber die Summa,

Munich and Berlin, 1925. 19. Bonaventure, In Lib. III Sent., dist., 9, art. 1, qu. 2. For Bacon’s criticism of such rhetorical devices, cf. below, p. 67.

20. Cf, again below, pp. 67 ff. 21. S. Th., Prologue.

22. Alexander of Hales, apparently the first to introduce this elaborate articulation, divides partes into membra and articuli; Thomas in S, Th. divides partes into quaestiones and

95

Notes articuli, Commentaries upon the Sentences generally divide the partes into distinctiones, these being subdivided into quaestiones and articuli.

23. This First Part, dealing with God and the order of creation, is organized as follows:

I. Essence (qu. 2-26); a. Whether God exists (qu. 2); 1. Whether the proposition of His existence is evident (art. 1); 2. Whether it is demonstrable (art. 2); 3. Whether He does exist (art. 3); b. How He exists or, rather, does not exist (qu. 3-13); 1. How He is not (qu. 3-11); 2. How He is known to us (qu. 12); 3. How He is named (qu. 13); c. His operation (qu. 14-26); 1. His knowledge (qu. 14-18); 2. His will (qu. 19-24); 3. His power (qu. 25-26); II. Distinction of Persons (qu. 27-43); a. Origin or procession (qu. 27); b. Relations of origin (qu. 28); c. The Persons as such (qu. 29-43); Ill. Procession of creatures (qu. 44—end) ;

a. Production of creatures (qu. 44-46); 96

Notes

b. Distinction of creatures (qu. 47-102); c. Government of creatures (qu. 103—end). 24. A characteristic masterpiece of a Scholastic eulogy is a Collatio in honor of Charles IV by Pope Clement VI (R. Salomon, M.G.H., Leges, IV, 8, pp. 143 ff.), where Charles is parallelized with Solomon under the headings: Comparatur, Collocatur, Approbatur, Sublimatur, each heading being subdivided as follows:

A, Comparatur. Solomon I, in aliquibus profecit :

a. in latriae magnitudine ; b. in prudentiae certitudine ;

c. in iustitiae rectitudine; d. in clementiae dulcedine. I]. In aliquibus excessit :

a. in sapientiae limpitudine ; b. in abundantiae plenitudine ; c. in facundiae amplitudine ; d. in quietae vitae pulchritudine. II. in aliquibus defecit : a. in luxuriae turpitudine ; b. in perseverantiae longitudine ; c. in idolatriae multitudine;

d. in rei bellicae fortitudine, etc., etc. Ridewall’s mythographical treatise was edited by H. Liebe97

Notes schutz, Fulgentius Metaforalis (Studien der Bibliothek Warburg,

IV, Leipzig and Berlin, 1926); For the scholastic systematization of Ovid’s Metamorphoses (naturalis, spiritualis, magica, moralis, and de re animata in rem inanimatam, de re inanimata in rem inanimatam, de re inanimata in rem animatam, de re animata

in rem animatam), cf, F, Ghisalberti, “‘Mediaeval Biographies of Ovid,’’ Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, IX,

1946, pp. ro ff., especially p. 42.

25. The early manuscripts, editions, and commentaries show perfect awareness of the fact that the first Cantica really begins with Canto 2 (so that it would comprise 33 Canti like the others). In the Trivulziana manuscript of 1 337 (L. Rocca, ed., Milan, 1921) as well as in such incunabula as Wendelin of Speyer’s Venice edition, we find the follow-

ing rubrics: ‘‘Comincia il canto primo de la prima parte nelaquale fae proemio a tutta l’opera’’ and **Canto secondo dela prima parte nela quale fae proemio ala prima canticha solamente, cioé ala prima parte di questo libro solamente.”’ Cf, Jacopo della Lana’s Commentary (reprinted in L. Scarabelli’s edition of the Divina Commedia of 1866, pp. 107 and

118): “‘In questi due primieri Capitoli . . . fa proemio e mostra sua disposizione. . . . Qui (scil., in Canto 2) segue suo proema pregando la scienzia che lo aiuti a trattare tale poetria, sicome é usanza delli poeti in li principii delli suoi trattati, e li oratori in li principii delle sue arenghe.’’ 98

Notes 26. T. E. Mommsen (Intr.), Petrarch, Sonnets and Songs, New

York, 1946, p. xxvii. 27. R. Arnheim, “‘Gestalt and Art,’’ Journal of Aesthetics and

Art Criticism, 1943, pp. 71 ff.; idem, ‘‘Perceptual Abstraction and Art,’’ Psychological Review, LIV, 1947, pp. 66 ft., especially p. 79.

28. S. Th. 1, qu. 5, art. 4, ad r. 29. Paris, Bibl. Nat., Nouv. Acq. 1359 and London, Brit. Mus., Add. 11662 (cf. M. Prou, “‘Desseins du XI* siécle et peintures du XIII° siécle,’’ Revue de ]’Art Chrétien, XXIII, 1890, pp. 122 ff.; also M. Schild-Bunim, Space in Mediaeval

Painting, New York, 1940, p. 115).

30. Exceptions: Fécamp (after 1168), having compound piers throughout ; the eastern bay of St.-Leu d’Esserent (ca.

1190) having an alternating system; St.-Yved-de-Braine (after 1200), having compound piers in the chevet; Longpont, having monocylindrical piers. 31. The experiments in the seventh and ninth pair of nave piers in the Cathedral of Laon had no appreciable effect upon the subsequent development; and the piers of Soissons, cyl-

inders with only one colonnette facing the nave, are in my opinion a reduction of the full-fledged Chartres pilier cantonné with colonnettes on all four sides. Perfunctorily imi99

Notes

tated in Notre-Dame-de-Paris (second pair of piers from the west), this type is chiefly important for its influence upon

provincial structures erected after the middle of the thirteenth century (cf. note 61), and upon the supports in the rond-point—and in the rond-point only—of Reims and Beauvais Cathedrals. For the development of the pilier cantonné

see pp. 79 ft.

32. Some architectural historians are inclined to identify the climactic phase of the Gothic style with Reims and Amiens (nave), and to consider the radical elimination of the wall in the nave of St.-Denis, the Sainte-Chapelle, St.Nicaise-de-Reims, or St.-Urbain-de-Troyes as the beginning of a disintegration or decadence (‘‘Gothique rayonnant’’ as opposed to *'Gothique classique’’). This is, of course, a matter

of definition (cf. P. Frankl, “‘A French Gothic Cathedral: Amiens,’’ Art in America, XXXV, 1947, pp. 294. ff.). But it

would seem that the Gothic style, measured by its own standards of perfection, only fulfills itself where the wall is reduced to the limit of technical possibilities while, at the same time, a maximum of ‘‘inferability’’ is reached. I even

suspect that the above-mentioned view has some purely verbal foundation in that the expressions ‘“‘classic High Gothic’’ or “‘Gothique classique’ automatically suggest the

plastic standards of Greek and Roman, but not Gothic, 100

Notes ‘“classicality.’’ In fact the masters of Amiens themselves eagerly adopted the glazed triforium of St.-Denis as soon as they had become familiar with it (transept and chevet). 33. Viollet-le-Duc’s interpretation is carried to an extreme in L. Lemaire, “‘La logique du style Gothique,’’ Revue néoscolastique, XVII, 1910, pp. 234 ff. 34. P. Abraham, Viollet-le-Duc et Ie rationalisme mediéval, Paris, 1935 (cf. the discussion in Bulletin de I’ office international des Instituts d’ archéologie et d’ histoire de J’art, II, 1935).

35. E. Gall, Niederrheinische und normdnnische Architektur im Zeitalter der Frithgotik, Berlin, 1915; idem, Die gotische Baukunst in Frankreich und Deutschland, 1, Leipzig, 1925. Further

literature concerning the Pol Abraham controversy is cited in G. Kubler, “‘A Late Gothic Computation of Rib Vault Thrusts,’’ Gazette des Beaux-Arts, 6th ser., XXVI, 1944, pp. 135 ff.; to be added: Pol Abraham, ‘‘Archéologie et résistance des matériaux,’’ La Construction Moderne, L, 1934-35,

pp. 788 ff. (kindly brought to my attention by Prof. M. Schapiro). 36. Abbot Suger on the Abbey Church of Saint-Denis and Its

Art Treasures (E. Panofsky, ed.), Princeton, 1946, p. 108, 8; for the emendation of veluti into voluti, see E. Panofsky, ‘Postlogium Sugerianum,’’ Art Bulletin, XXIX, 1947, p. 119.

10]

Notes 37. See G. Kubler, loc. cit.

38. Cf. E. Brunet, “‘La restauration de la Cathédrale de Soissons,’’ Bulletin Monumental, LXXXVII, 1928, pp. 65 ff.

39. Cf. H. Masson, ‘‘Le rationalisme dans |’architecture du Moyen-Age, ’ Bulletin Monumental, XCIV, 1935, pp. 29 ff.

40. See, for instance, the treatise convincingly interpreted by Kubler, Joc. cit., or the French expert Mignot’s violent

and justified objections to the outrageous theory of his Milanese confreres according to which ‘‘archi spiguti non dant impulzam contrafortibus’’ (cf. now J. S. Ackerman, ‘* “Ars Sine Scientia Nihil Est’ ; Gothic Theory of Architecture

at the Cathedral of Milan,’’ Art Bulletin, XXXI, 1949, pp. 84 ff.). As evidenced by the Milan texts (reprinted in Acker-

man, loc. cit., pp. 108 ff.), the terms contrefort and arcboutant (“‘archi butanti’’) were familiar even in Latin and Italian by the end of the fourteenth century, and both were used in a figurative sense as early as in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries (Dictionnaire historique de la langue franacise publié par I’ Académie Francaise, lll, Paris, 1888, pp. 575 ff.; E. Littré, Dictionnaire de la langue francaise, 1, Paris, 1863,

p. 185; La Curne de la Palaye, Dictionnaire historique de T’ ancienne langue francaise, 1V, Paris and Niort, 1877, p. 227). The term bouterec (F. Godefroy, Lexique de l’ancien Francais,

Paris, 1901, p. 62) must have been in use before 1388 when 102

Notes ‘“‘buttress’’ occurs in English, and estribo is constantly em-

ployed in the treatise interpreted by Kubler, loc. cit. 41. Since this upper range of flying buttresses is superfluous as far as the stability of the vaults is concerned, its presence has even been accounted for by mere “‘timidity’’ (J. Guadet, Eléments de théorie d’ architecture, Paris, n.d., Ill, p. 188). To

explain it as a countermeasure against wind pressure was proposed by K. J. Conant, “‘Observations on the Vaulting Problems of the Period 1088~—1211,’’ Gazette des Beaux-Arts,

6th ser., XXVI, 1944, pp. 127 f. 42. See E. Gall, opp. cit., especially Die gotische Baukunst, pp. 31 ff.

43. See J. Gaudet, op. cit., pp. 200 ff., fig. 1076. 44. G. Vasari, Le Vite dei piu eccellenti pittori, scultori e archi-

tetti, If Part, Proemio: ‘‘Perché nelle colonne non osservarono (scil., the Gothic masters) quella misura e proporzione che richiedeva l’arte, ma a la mescolata con una loro regola senza regola faccendole grosse grosse o sottili sottili, come tornava lor meglio.’’ In thus observing that the scale

of the members in a Gothic edifice is not determined by anthropomorphic considerations, and that their proportions can change within one and the same building, Vasari—his acumen sharpened by hostility—has hit upon a fundamental 103

Notes

principle distinguishing Gothic from Classical as well as from Renaissance and Baroque architecture. Cf. C. Neumann, “‘Die Wahl des Platzes fur Michelangelos David in Florenz im Jahr 1504; zur Geschichte des Massstabproblems,’’ Repertorium fur Kunstwissenschaft, XXXVIII, 1916, pp.

1 ff. Also E. Panofsky, ““Das erste Blatt aus dem ‘Libro’ Giorgio Vasaris ; eine Studie uber die Beurteilung der Gotik in der italienischen Renaissance,’’ Stadeljahrbuch, VI, 1929, pp. 4 ff., especially pp. 42 ff. 45. See S. McK. Crosby, loc. cit.; for Bourges, cf. above, note 17.

46. Until fairly recently, the first instance of a four-story arrangement was believed to occur in Tournai (ca. 1100). Two very slightly earlier though much more primitive instances—again demonstrating the close interrelation between Flanders and England—have, however, been discovered in Tewkesbury (founded in 1087) and Pershore (founded

between 1090 and 1100); cf. J. Bony, ‘“Tewkesbury et Pershore, deux élévations a quatre étages de la fin du XI® siécle,’’ Bulletin Monumental, 1937, pp. 281 ff., 503 ff. 47. The addition of secondary side aisles in Cologne Cathedral (otherwise closely following the plan of Amiens Cathedral) represents a sacrifice of the major consideration (in

this case, balance between centralistic and longitudinal 104

Notes

tendencies) to the minor one (in this case, conformity of nave and choir) not unlike that which can be observed in the

treatment of the supports (cf., pp. 85 ff.).

48. S. Th. I, qu. 1, art. 8, ad 2. 49. Patrologia Latina, vol. 178, cols. 1339 ff.

50. Roger Bacon, Opus minus as quoted in H. Felder, Geschichte der wissenschaftlichen Studien im Franziskanerorden, Frei-

burg, 1904, p. 515: ‘‘Quae fiunt in textu principaliter legendo et praedicando, sunt tria principaliter; scilicet, divisiones per membra varia, sicut artistae faciunt, concordantiae violentes, sicut legistae utuntur, et consonantiae rhythmicae, sicut grammatici.’’ For the anticipation of the Sic et Non method by the canonists (Ivo of Chartes, Bernold of Constance), see M. Grabmann, Die Geschichte der scholastischen Methode, Freiburg, 1909, I, pp. 234 ff. ; land II, passim.

51, William of Ockham, Quodlibeta, 1, qu. 10, as quoted in

Ueberweg, op. cit., p. 581: ‘‘Quidquid de hoc senserit Aristoteles, non curo, quia ubique dubitative videtur loqui.”’

52. William of Ockham, In / sent., dist. 27, qu. 3, quoted ibidem, pp. 574 f.: ‘‘Pauca vidi de dictis illius doctoris. Si enim omnes vices, quibus respexi dicta sua, simul congregarentur, non complerent spatium unius diei naturalis . . . 105

Notes quam materiam tractavi, et fere omnes alias in primo libro, antequam vidi opinionem hic recitatam.”’

53. See H. Kunze, Das Fassadenproblem der franzésischen Frith- und Hochgotik, Strassburg, 1912.

54. Germany, generally averse to roses in the west facade (except for Strassburg and its sphere of influence, in contrast to Cologne, etc.), accepted the rose-and-window combination for the longitudinal walls of hall churches when elaborated into facades as in Minden, Oppenheim, St. Catherine’s in Brandenburg.

55. Libergier’s solution was obviously inspired by the transepts of Reims Cathedral (before 1241), where the big roses are already inscribed within pointed arches; but here the whole does not, as yet, constitute a “‘window.”’ The spandrels above and below the roses are not, as yet, glazed, and no vertical connection exists between the roses and the windows beneath them. 56. Villard de Honnecourt, Kritische Gesamtausgabe (H. R.

Hahnloser, ed.), Vienna, 1935, pp. 165 ff., pl. 62. 57. Cf. now J. Bony, ‘’French Influences on the Origins of English Gothic Architecture,’’ Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, XII, 1949, pp. 1 ff., especially pp. 8 ff. 106

Notes 58. See, e.g., A. Kingsley Porter, Medieval Architecture, New

Haven, 1912, Il, p. 272. Occasionally, as in St.-Martin-deBoscherville or St.-Etienne-de-Caen (galleries), this principle had already been applied in Romanesque structures; but it became “‘standard,’’ it seems, only after Sens, where three different thicknesses are “‘expressed’’ by capitals of three different sizes. There was, however, always an inclination to overlook minor differences in thickness in order to preserve uniformity among several adjacent capitals.

59. In Soissons, St.-Leu-d’Esserent, etc., we find an even more emphatic reversion to the original Canterbury type: a “‘nave colonnette’’ with an individual capital half as high as that of the pier. 60. This applies also to the capitals of the major and minor colonnettes of the west portals which thus form a significant contrast to the corresponding ones in Amiens. 61. Asimilar adaptation of a continuous shaft to the concept of a pilier cantonné can be observed in the later piers of Beau-

vais (1284 ff.), in the piers of Séez (ca. 1260) and in the later piers of Huy (1311 ff.). In the two latter instances, however, the colonnettes facing the arcades and the side aisles are omitted as though the idea of a continuous shaft had been superimposed, not upon the normal pilier cantonné 107

Notes (with four colonnettes) but upon the Soissons pier (which has only one); cf. note 31.

62. Villard de Honnecourt, op. cit., pp. 69 ff., pl. 29; the inscription, “‘Istud bresbiterium inuenerunt Ulardus de Hunecort et Petrus de Corbeia inter se disputando,’’ was added by a disciple of Villard known as ‘‘Master 2.”’ 63. The only superficially similar alternation of chapels vaulted separately and chapels vaulted, Soissons fashion, under one keystone with the adjacent sector of the outer ambulatory can be observed in Chartres, where this arrange-

ment is motivated by the necessity of re-using the foundations of the eleventh-century choir with its three deep and widely separated chapels. But in Chartres the Soissons-like chapels are really nothing but shallow protuberances of the outer ambulatory, so that all the seven keystones could be placed on the same perimeter. In Villard de Honnecourt’s and Pierre de Corbie’s ideal plan they are fully developed units, their keystones placed, not in the center but on the periphery of the adjacent sector of the outer ambulatory.

108

Illustrations

.- .: eo. “ws Bin oS ee NE , ae .Oy ae ..es Ee ees: oe ea moe Go=an gEwi EeSue ai EL oo. “eS ie gE ..:SO Seer ak, ee SRR SRE Sy Be RE . Eos “e .*,-Re & ae. a: ‘3a |). | Se eR aWE at Ae TERE SeeoEe age OT ; . wo aig . aS Ee PERE SS ae

. fag ih Ses “~ Sete aseeeBs Rie. ges&Mis AE 2 BSS, shes . “ey Re .Os : nbieobings: abe 0Rass _ . :. , oy oe! neOBR hinge Me eeeBee ome RY’Shae TM OhceegSe 0 we kes:e eres . BRS asBBS 3 oe : oF 2s vs%. “ed gg RR“ae 7 s, eeree S, Bee. af ro 23oS g —we $ ee & Kegee x B . ee Bo Fmech at (ge owe, eeePE “ RERSO TEeS RE . :

eS+ea5ee, 8 Poza, 2 Bye SSsgSS a rs ae &ESyySe Beer Se. Key 1, he SPSS ROE 8 Ra BP Rewe SoeOS oe By Bees w Os B- SS, SRE a&angen ares ie we os .

DEN ac eccndnai. “ .+ RRetn neBalen SINS RS Ste te. Sec2noe. BO SS eS Sf SS 7 ee oesae Beee seak re Se F: :: *a -: eet aiitsaetet < SSR ea a Be? outta an Sa: ghecbteatineaitn, * bP Ss es Seed noes Statice. lateRai aeee iktoes eit RS osPySB. OoSEER. SERGE NS OTS Osa Poi Sipsan ; NORRIS ‘crea vstees ee ms BO STEERER Baoe inceainneg :pepe Spr raht oc pe” ee Bei, SP" ROM WoSi, cestgtereemcni aaa SiS BONN Be ReRoe ogESR. Re> Kane seg Sk Sires SS. wBRR eee Seo RR ES.¥”BRR Bipot eisai eC AN ereRES Seen Re ee een < mac Soi oe‘< 58 a.

See RR
BY a IRAN DERrtSC Sere ii oF roe er Soe EROE Pe CES ee SesadeRe eeecene1Say MEETaAL BEN ee Wee

DUSTER Peg ingle oe Se age IO OST SE SRS NORE ee te wae PS Sees BRR Be RRO RRR Na RON 7 SS es +

tie Uh ER gernSE patra Sc z Se vor A eae secateareets ERO Loba tf :Ritter Co ToSoil RRR See 7 OM a Rpt Tag erRE PR Eeoe oN ee etgh SUL SUR ROR RAS SR IO SRE 0. SURES RON aLee aeatten Soon Roe BEE ie es Me TD NERE Tag gee oo OeRiae eeBE ayBe e &4 SORES gh gate ae ee LON STO LE gE IERIE SBS Js,BRS GER US 4 weCRE oy ORE eRe haat. -SSage %ater Bae TRTN NER Bae RRO TR" SEES Aowee P's BRS EES ss SyreSee ee. On«oS EERO PSE BR Dad ‘5 Soames GEE RRR % Sh. . esos fg fey a beAF Le eeage Bas SSO oe Eeae weNg ees Saree Peis % SoeSSee eee Soa OlaesRIO RRO 2 TR RR EERO ai REE SpaEreae, A SSSahi Bien RES# =oe BA

Sane nnAS AI ERRRR °aieRE Bier xRR ae i. SIRE TTR RR Ons. geSe 85... RSBe, eg SERRA Stein ES SIRE TRS SR se eS aS Se, NS SO CS 2SsBea viet. Eee 2S. ee ELE TES LLyeti SCOR Treen nee| RS apea TIESHE SRR: SCORER. Seen OL-ee Ra os . CISR Se OS raat i.ORS oP RRR PIR Ri ONiES Sy oe BES Si, a oe UT, UE. Reeorereenriaen gg RE BS EE Gieaeeeeyans See SoeheSees ten aeeeROG 0aaksSeSars ow SS 3, SE PBeegee apepee a eae aa SasSsyve! een es Pyy Ey oe -es co " he tyBE RE. vookets % x AY “eas CEE Cue nas ers, shay Sia SR es.he Sa HE cee be SES, oe a SoREPS Rie “58Br ORR %OT KERR et Pt COURSES GRRE LR aaaCeO RR CONES a ARN ZEN EOE. | RRM Ss RR RRC BYpase PaGt 6 RS eee i,vcARE RS OR i Re BRE 8 Be SR Sass Wt RSE, Mes Sacbser OCD, C7 1 ROR Ss TB SO RRO ES EESRee fp Poe MESSRS?>RES SSS fo ie Soa ie Ne ea SS a AR gSSee " “he

ae SARS BRUGES SE CORN” SR: LORIE. aNSARE snesRtreC7. Re Oe. SEOSESE I oe RR SOS SRis IES Snes. & Cy 22roSee RRMO SRRateRET | OeOD. RK. ogee el,LAER, MR hh Tae iy $5$ ys Na colton Miner amenoeoe teste AY. a SRRR S. PEE TS MI I OITae Bienes akeBER dieCOS: OBS RS20 ER Oh ames RE NS PRIN . ASROSES SRSAaitURED ON RON NRE Le ADP Erinn Bones eeSCRE HE, “8 Po ORO Cees AERa Sr ooeeaeTEER GagATS seeBRD Bk BR RSPR eee he SES SRC Sea 2 eeAh a cig . stn RR ERY SMESBe SBN SE RON ee TRESS A RE a aE ee TEoa Se OE Be BeAR Ke PREP age BRea SRBF Se RRR ENS ky sig Bes $;. Sas Fe pod ee PRL gage SESS a ROR git cae ey £Sone Mere Ce Ee ae RSS RE,RN RE LRT Ee, SOS EER heSRR ie SOR tai S SBaReaearaee Ceeeee SSaE a JSEEKER agra Te aaa Tare RE Is a SNL UESa Ga EEE EES SS a a RgEe aS ty Raet eS it + Se +a RRS ROS SD ee TD : BESOROSSRIOSEEEOODDS aes SaiSRE Perens prone aShh SE SR CURES ed ak. 0B. PeTreewt : .mod - 3 aotRSSE RS GR Mca ae

patie: Meese oy NEE mtg QUE ESAS tsoatoe cree aan re esed;mo.eS :sotEE Os neneneaeee Se eee Sa Lenn ER Te WIE eee oteg gg Tee DOLE a oeSEIU wee WAR Reg etspee wat SSO oo.RRR SaaS Bea Se Se. ve toe nT a Ray SRSANE Soin SESS SRRime Be ogo BE SE SS aR PE EIS AD RI OER a eee rete os 2 aRRBee ae

SUSE LADUE EE OSS aS DLT RToeosLee Bee gee md fea oyoe, Done -t Set SoaRNR NERRGRnSYaef BOEIOK oe: Pee eee Sisco uP Se ARIS ISRAELS gah rrES! oe 2SOIR NSE UES a ag gh E RRS RRSRe Soe anwe Tiny Soa .. Lt SORE ee.

ESAS in En tis ee 2SeSecrest SSEESE SSE Ne REE) “ : Reema Eo poRSS aeshg SOLER US OUR ett SSIS ESLas eeRe TR oeSSS eS EEfee ERS RE. Ss SCOR NERS Peake, S“Seve SEEer ae :oe OTD RAE NOS SOC CESS SORe EON A Tee RE £7 ee)LESS, WO, a BE .: :.¢.geSES °wRwoos Re Re Pee eEo PORE ISL. USES ite ha bt or] Seeeee: Sebi aeeroetnee sai boot ce Hig GAen Beh - . Seer ee ae Seeam oe SE ROE DUESS eS PEEReR ecSEED ER a Shee 2 ETT SEEREEOAE: “SRR es EL EEie. : oo sot pee estefat Sea. ioe eccrine eee, ecto

TEE te ee ED ag SERIES Bene capers coe: Jen ee ie Ca Pe ee

Pp REE ERS SSR SR SE SSNS hc ee SEEMEE. Ta Se 1p ATS RR aie Ress a ar ee .* : : SERRE Rea ae ai motte nee Sie Raa

Pai A wo SSR Ee BREAD RaeIEICE Pr ER Pong To SERRA ae eSRR penne a a Re 2eet, SREa,aE RR ERREN NOOR Sanaa SEE Sct tUS., st CONSE ugha EEE a AaCRSA DOSES SR Sh aseeRoemer OB: fete fotCORO eeeee. Sehnert ioecas is en aRese Roane nena NISCe Po OTE ARSE Se SSsyaeSEERLIIAP ae SSIS BERR Sea EEE Te tie SaRY Reece BROOK USSR ST 1” Ge ee ne io. eee ae i OEE POE 0 eM R a hater WASTES Seco RANE Cre SeAMe me : : Ld RRS IES SS Le SRE RES. COREE ose SSSRSoSS OPES SEBess See ee 7riet DEES EeooSoe eeEeROPE: RS RRO EEaR LP won. +. RRS ete teSS ee,a SNORE Si Siaadeonabersta sass

OCI ESeee SSCSS aR SES Bg Eee Tt ESES BR = ge - otBes Br,a” ae re Se Fog ee ea geg gin cedine naanuidgs aS - PPS STSeema PS, Eg 1. FERS Sec SOCCe Se RES Dp Orr eSB EE SO a DPSS Mere ReSusts SEGRE bySes DSSS ot SS resoR 2 WED en, : se | - Soe SRS Soe at ee ees 9& SUR ype TEREST DSRS SERRE AS ESE 0 EESSe EERO BS ESS eaagd . . . SRR Soe eae Saas oan pe ss SIE 0 SEES SSS a 20 EEETAGE Saas ETT Sinnenantey ad4,aLoeb er : .sort ‘ SRS cSt SAT Sot SeSas ARERR SaCO SeSo RES

aco MENS enoneEE «oeBae VER vb PER SEE ea aeieants 2 tee Moor :RS a - SIED Seesoe ER EtDe Stee RO i ae en Teter arEEE eS.cinerea Doc SSem SORES a ee a .DL . - TRESTLE ueSe a etic aE eee TE Sher} Uist Rarsemonnmeeraminon s 8.Beene eeith TERE SIS Sot. SRS ge Seeemee : oe fg SAI

PR ee ionnn saetemenrmnenaness ocrapons i: TEA SRIMIS AE SS St SE a eee oeTsORLAEESIE, a RE Lo.a Ain a SERS raeLe. ,ale ” Pan ESRMD RRS SRE SOc aSsa3 Pen by SERRE ap otShe eesieroe SR Sage “SERS LS >nits Spee oe RL rsSoe Routan ataN. nok np gee aeSRS SRE Lo 7JaOP ULTRAY SE pried ergaSAREE: Eeec SPSee See SERENE OEE EESSE Lo - : es ° ess +Sta | FRR eo aeeenrc aeRO. SSSR aaa ean 2Sel OER oS eae erent eS PLSEE LL ESSSeE Do SEES i 5 Rie lr a ees oot o. Sea em ee Sees RRR PONENTS SC TEDRESR SRS Sc SE Sets RRR ea SRE AGE OES Ls BRR as i ama Ty fat oa poiieuuanicuten nara aar an ee RRR eT J& od ULES Sees ee Se DEG pee eee BAS ey BPUS eA B.S oh BRR eae Ese i Stele Seti nneacowvnne, -_Stov-ne SRR R RR SERRE REET EORPOL SK SORES: :Lek PERERA EM on Tceesrontiior meer nen bmeinapemmnmameee Sy cncSenos oa SR SEE UBSEE RE eReRae SIR meee DN eT oo, neg oneReena meee ERT RRR ~ NES A SSONET D SRR 70 SEM UESSSESTEE S Oe eg 2 ACTER BsBARRE ES eetooe S “ere aves ooo pees See ee ae A Ce 3

GS Sos Oa Se eeSECIS REEecrenee SHS SERRE. Litas & a RRR a Ros 3S Se SRS .De DiS SuSORA EEESTAE. Bc eneoD: FONoS Nc RES ES EB heseae Oa >eeermmmmemnnnees of RAO, PAARL AR Ae nvote le ee PLE aspayeOe an Le Jeeaa EO Oeiti, MORN RESO Set Oe Oe 2SDeep SR ee IOSARE DORIA LEAL SEMEL EE IES cnnnct ne nee a) ETO REeee ereIER tSne: Seam names SUPT LUT Danity GSE i eae aaaPOD poe nndeiebonoosecoooooooosoooiess weal - ae RES NSBR. SoARRIRIOA I DR ae«ster ann BM NAR RRR AIEEE NINE COON OMG 8 ELS INS SER CES oF So EDR ROSEN eRSEE SSRN nooaciuaeeneenn VOILA KARA: RIAL ELS TO _ Nantes ela serauieELE SERIES Raa Reaeean a ccaR Saran ste Ree VLA UESoy RISERS sane SB Snasinar ites seaniabe tae phrases iodeoed mehipceaie, Wee?oe . ok pheiwereeneeieadts a1tnne OS St, ERR an Re, " rs Bin» SB * psRe Sas os:BiaepeTS ere, Se ae aM Sa sy LiesDee ~Soe ie 3F¢*Se se gi SP PRige, yee5 eySey er ees See < ee ae. See et REA pe ater e3 oe pen ggisteae Pere.FBS guy os GRO BERR A en ee Fee A ah. SUR O OS S t eR 5MAS of

- yee ae i os Cras aw RO tS Be SR tee Pe: beg” Op RS a a, BE Bok %, GReR ee MES ee Brick ¥.,. "See

we. } Sie aohe ‘aed ‘ 2‘éRr , aOC ¥ eeaS Sie aes Bree: BES dos, rr.PR.OREO SPR. OS SSPRE. EeSea BS ooeee eeS| Se . a—AS ie ig, ig. SisR ae °AEE eo SESE Ak RBA eSee OS By OM ce esoe eeaoO ee +. BenUE yn S As[3 BR eS Se AA or a “2 ges ee Seam eae RO SF RSE: pi |esge RAS oe ae -wg OO SET OM. Bon Rages % Pi ihad ‘ oS ks fe A See Sey = ay. es Seag? aieag gd ooo, SR reSP Be esSam FS&Seys 2Se.ah &xe Ree Fey, af * gr bas isk See =+ Sp See eSeESOP 2pS‘PSN :ai , ag ai ei se « | woe SR ee $e SPE . BRS SE RE Eh TAN PS ae:

. vs 3 TS aoe Re: ee 3 FS Seed Sep RR Ny a reece Acd00, OE SS. RR TASS SY ‘SRR Se Soe, Fes See. EBS: >:

. $30 ; Pee aes Oks SERRE sm. eM Sos SF ABE RC ee ST Be Do SES BS SRE cee See ei abers ‘ Ah OEE = SO Ae > > EY tax - a. (See S Bs os SEN fe Quod oy nn Sly Bc RR

. RE ASE ond fos # BSP oe Se see PS Re ee in Ben EN ode ARERR EMA SS S ae oDitSRR: eet — es Dale we . 338 ate EEE OG 3Ss‘hySe *By aeat SRRE ee Ee RO Se ONE ERB Itt, “Uygy Bae Cis eaeRae. pee nee POSe RS gM aRE Paws ke2Oh 2FRY eB AF Seg ohSi ESah Ge oS ORES nach Saree. So Be o> aaa RES OX See 7% SM Ny, .EB ERE ae “RR Bip, FP TS, SN PE Sigh nsCN BS 3 OE RE TRE SSSes oR MES. Beyes ENRere RRRAE ES 73aee “Gee S J OR eeWB Fmee eS Bs ::BR 4 Be oeSES in,ECE Bann tien cab CRS TEL NO PIERR : |33 ee See Bey5. 5 ee ca Pe} iSE SeeoeOX os S: eS pe SIS Be, Bd, ROR 8 ee ee Peat oles er BERS atk aeeee apieaSS PRES ae as ee on ey ee a os:

rSB % SOS A ne, Se anette, ¢. Sew Fy 3 Cap, Bee 4 | Ricco TEE SER Ao | SR SS Ee SP "Roots. Se oS Rael ey ae SR Se oy Be oe ree ee

Be Sie ee £5 m3SRC,” Re Sere EY os,BC edRSS, TNTSR eS eee a>RO ie TUNTE eee SES SRLN es ON as SRS me eee aeogbeROi te yet:. iaSER Sys Re | RRR So SNgig: ee DOr ERE, OS{Gee SP ee?% BES RCSbaNreLL PELE rx Saasse3°" gees 3 ig pe aes

SAGs ts seVis Reese Be ES AORSO HEERG Dond Tn DiyaE. ERSRS Ooers SR GEERT 4 rhe BARRO BK RY RESyk Eterm eee ». pe OP eR a 2 Ee Oe SIPS ge pe .aR- aPRR, : Pee a td. eS eRc:oes SE: SE eitOS e eee = PRS BRS = eR Bae ee ebRRR ‘reeSy aeSemen : ae

PES RS cS wee sae Alias Heo SS Ee cite ams igonce eeaesSE .naeee Oe SEG ee pe 7h me: mie ee~ Sx ore ANE ee Rk ea SSe Pear 3oP Ab Ie RR FEeeFa. SS Fefe ERE Bs an A Aees | RBRGN Siac ai RSS oresce aeroRE, pene tia aeennos Sionee tian“GR aan it eeettony es Sak ei eeSa Ee Sha |5:9 oN ete ig SEESa ee Oe Lo RTE a pete RE ee ia tes. Ee ER Se ao Se ceESX Boke ae:tseeens Jeger’ vee fTa ee ertcaeeeBact ee,Pus2 OES SaulLOees! “aMES ="Snes So SEALS co es 7 > ok co reeapsn ONSRRP COE pes: Sleees Seatge Weaeee ear SSiF as SSMS Sm ome S00 Sem” anaes Bs Sie es EEi+See

BeaaS Ee Sees eeoe aES SFR SF, ae.2ake 7EGOS FERS ite.CRON 5s 7 aee£9 epee Pompey wa SESe mnte Se eySTSee URN 3 #5 et eta BM a Eis A Be ae aera ae a ae Seis Soe ESegy eegsey 2.8 SO ON te Rage De, FO SP EO. 5S PRS HOFSS in . ap aoee Ree 3 ee a a pans ge a BS SER, EyeAS: y= ee aoat Dee, ga ne . ELS MG Ey ei Bis OSCoN AN eS on AES ES, gee «3 : ner SSee ae Teas 5 psSoe. Sot Re a. SeeSOR So 2.ey: NEY ne gene > ee .fe ” FRR. fn. ® SS. SRORT ~ tes Bs LEER Se aees ag OR a ROS waste | BR gasoot“2--ee me“oe POS @SSAE "SRenPees Bes Rl EN eGrr}“oy coon Aa3¢ se ERE aa eee, es seeeet, es NSA eenOB oe Re. 4 oe ee

hit eS oe ee eee > " 2EP ee SFE Se. Boge OU ONS ¢RE SeenOE Se BER Theeee fy oe ys Bae Se Ae we TOR peerSan eee YER SiS OT _ ae ees ae re eer ee SRY ee Poon, See ReSOOO. > See BeRe mae a,ETER SA IEAoS RE: : osOo? os aBOR ete oY ee , pees Sswaa at 4okSe § Ree gOSE GRO : AS PORER Fa aNSSR. 82keSO sien Peis. Reser. 3:Ee 3 Fee nS aeesBee ARR aeSR Pr lle I RS NeBPO” [Sd BA BRN pSSS RESee gas" fr esac a ae ae Pere cae ° rn SeneSe i.Oe PR eee AS * »RES 2BBRE OS ERS Sal x Yee Baek hee

—a56 ofeas , iN | >Sea. oge Pee aleeSee Ee Sed CES, Be eee|3. "oe os Bae , Ese . eg Bae ew ae aooo “PES xBBs” wg SegaeBE Ps Sia eee [iice 4TeeeePERE feae “eSee s.PROP - Fe. See SB giaae he -- AS SS~ ACG yen aSeu Meee. > Samaras ae i oni a, Oy aie ra oe en te gee § eter ESSaeee Uke.. SP Sng aseetoe og LS Soe Dee ae SS ty an Re tA ae > a3 ES SCRE, Oo ewe Sheen, BRS WR oY Seon oaON BRS PR Ref. eee Ls Sy Se LS EE RS LS SRS ERS:%SSee ae oe a ee: R> pitas ee Re Se Seah,See 33 icy > Orie Sane Mee GRRE Seen Coe Saeren SSL2 3s SeeMor es "age OS Re: PE, Re ar BS Sabet ae ‘oe 2M OU ¥ CREAR AeaRaC a cigs Say *YB we\aeeges OS, R.SS yeaSaae eee :Peep Say : ee oeercer Wen fee eee fe Se>aGes: “ie See PURGES Ye PeeSteen: 2 pOTNP SRORS EL SSNS tO pre | BekF Sees f: TE deOrg “oy 3pg TheSER IRSS So SSE ee eee ie; haan ee eeEeeGO ioeAe SUS Ra RAR ees Sit a Se Roae SORES eae TRO” Sn. Cy Senne See, See Seren, SERS SOS se$M NIee US Se W538 oo eS weSetar IS Sy Poet Eso St ECD SOMERS Set kt eS 3 Ree. eee. Sean REESE © So Re ea Be ee sy . x eae ca ame oe Sorrganes, vee yaa, i y ° po eke te ge So eae 3 es ee ees eee es Stan ers Ly +} “St eS a tas ee Re EE Ren sige as oye RR ea EERE. Spe NS BAIS. RES eee RE jee SOUR Pee oe fe See re See SO Re TR A > ae Sa Boi gS es Se a eae SEES wel. ae) eee Re oe BPS Be Pe Seeee ss Sonn eed peace Grae t eae eer. 20} fee Vas Sexe See 73 ‘aa ae oe a a ee SB ASS ER A ron La BR GER Re & 2 wo Mage Set xO Resear eS ae Ss ee iz = Sys “seem, OS ae me s ae Bis eae

oe Saat ‘aE ORS OR eee Shee SES BRE Esch3 TRE 1 eR PoE Sa agian ees OS IND saewe ERS ee . FESo StAG RO.pS . 35 2 SSa Sc - BEER ee Reg MOriendeeow COE¢ OES SesCart: SieteRB “teers: REE eR be, eras ae ated SARS SER Beg pas Beas oo ee pores f° AIS esteatfg Cee ee ESRYSo SLNEPA ene ceBe Ses PeSoee wie 4SESEe Pe a Eyee ae eee otets ONS ae oe pA A ReDyes OS Ex:eee a BSes SSE BE iifng BS Sg en SESEES A ageae Meera 1 a oe SSCOOGEE Saxe aoe pt. BROS Rees PORRSE PRS SOet EHR ESSERE HS -” eae 2. +TORRES - * Saaibibeemennanenes SUSE SEES a a. oeeeoo OS aSeieeee eeeaeHes capes etgte, a Pt ties sree SR ee EMESIS A eee meme | BS OS Boies aseti nck, ose, ee oo ’BE : a“oaks Saeet %.a> ¢ .ee 2 TEESE eM TEthIS ok et a EECe sRe eSoe Sone Se. BB Beene Ss es Rey 5 ge, Est Siit axe bo Do: egies Sani CEERORERE eee kL Be cotins Cesie® SEO, LR BEET 6 ae. SB Bye ne oe oe i ae POR oo eee

og ee gee EE ee aN | Bee EEO 3 og eee et Mp ea es oe ee ed eer * ns ee

og pO es Lee Ree:Means 7 5 RIES, Stier cots San Sao, Say oe: serors TR $50.3 Sees ERS SRP*NaS BO taSRE oR inetnie 3h Me eee, SC ee ees |Ry RNSSees AERO, ty OO SEO ae Sire Sam| Sake: yee Ye ‘ae PeeUES eS ee

ee Se ae x S i 3 BO PED SOE Lae epee Se on a ee

ees. xfyeee gore5 Fe ies ee«ifamet aa peGC ae By rag ERE oe ABB ERE * 2ti,OR Bete. yyBh, 4 *: eee SS ae Bn -8{BES BE CR Se LAS Sed eee ee be ie ee eeeBae aX SeeeaeBOR eS Caner.Lei | Seen eo4 gee = SsBC Bs Re 9 ae aa5aPig Sane) ESRD Ee ee

Ek Seecoe socEES a Rsa pet ee Be SEE ee ee: £ SES Se ESS be. 8Seee- ee eeseeeeEN Se SOS SE See heeee é es EBa BS SepSe ORS Os Sees 5. Satine cette

BESS Se ees eee Sores: ~ Boece eee 3 BRS SRS ees Sec... $ Neue Spree Beas Caan ian Say ae SRR LE: 5 as See ae ee >: Saas Resonenocansocen tee Senna nants aeee ee Oe ees © Soai:See BeeRamee } ees. Bees geoBee Soe!See Sane eenoer amen ene 3Wo 2S 22 ri S33 a ea eeeiesa teee$5eews Bae Some Sek:Bae Rees ices Reese Bees Sh Se ae eee te ee ee

SRE REED SERRE 5 SEI at So as 2 Fees Seer50k, eee Be Rt Soepesooes ReoeS Reatremaanes resent,Soeaaan S Seek oe " Ps Se Sok: a ee tas Rees ars Seen Ses ee pee Co Bee 4 SS & See SEES

EROS Oh Be RS RRC IO RETIRE GESA LO Ss. ROR, fing: FERRO, SAIS Pye ee RRR S AanE¥ Rte REEY f°. Se 6an aaa ae aereesenm ace ES as¥SUS oe eeTOONS Cae onan eetaSees severed SeonSOO ge ORE ey Oe A &\ CEEE sae sey ESSE BS.oe FBR sh Sa gsBe tS Ses ee oe eee esaaian seibesconassien Si Res.Seana Rate eae 3 koses ch aSS Se Goa GS Sinesace eee eee Sa

Remsen: bate tS seek... Bae Bo iy Sap oe a yay eas oe dee Ca icc Banas aerecagig usa Uneaten i Be toe megs inmate SERS Re SEeeEee Eee ee ee Seas

Roecmtomiies Bose st “Seip ie. | + BYP SB Be Bee Eto Ere oar ache augue mene nen te oe Sa ee Py Pains Rens 2 < . RE BES. oe. “$2 Fs Bows SAAC SEO senodeoanontemnaa Eee none, OORT IIRT Ree oppo eRe Pires - SS Le SES he 5” Sateen SEO RRRRRS 27.. SRS. Soeeaiaasaas DORR a Ss Sg

DE ae be ges | J Be Paes SS Ses See een emer Reem | ae Ete § Pe eee Be e

MRSIae : seSale eB2gee Ses Bee Sseaten meRee Sees Tones Sm &eae 35Seater eon Secs, mE”eek| Soccen Sa a ceeeiee ne aeeeea ERE Sk ties 32 Be Beene or eee Seeneemnename Piety enact. a 5, “5 Ei PF Beh ee eee cone fs tees ‘Goes es | ses ore kee SOS So ee Fe oe A ae g 7 ES So if Be * Be Soe eee Sophie: Senaeey Seaenben pS nents ESE ES: SE SRORSREREOR ORK |S" aooS ae Seon SENS Pegs 2 Sicha Seneca SOOMNRAIE A SUNN LSE ENE

Rees somes ; oe eee Oe Ee Be coe Tt Os pears Gees pe RR ee ees eeeemmnas i cones oe Rees Sek eon See § Ee serene SURFER TSS cee Sees ae * ae BE +333 Se Be ee a —— Se | es eee See oe Ray 4ee a

ESSE pee ‘38 Seeman 7 5 BRS Sea RE eee Sees | Seen Boo nanaeannss rea: Sees Setearae Roa ees Sates 4 pS VS Se Ss

cee A' “aaaarcsec Ce BE Ee eee ee Rohm: Sie. ESS 2 eS eS SERRE. af oakee Sg SEERgs SR RS SS ESS RNS. SSR MES SO! MB riesSikes EER BR oh re ccncate,sosce MERON s amen Se 8 SAS SALI ee eg 1Pe 6Gia,eese.ee eeey Rpecmnonene aSOS cSRER Seca eee Se Sant Seca eons ae Ze Saree Soh $a aa eaten OeaeteSteeSESE

DSSS ce | pennnanane es othe, :S socaenannsinnnonaeccsscancueniennias Sean cee EA Bere cs ERS BreaUSSaoree eres 22 bsee Somme” A CON PTO|ETS AO oe . Kes Asse Otenesaconamnmiaan ceaeeNieiians SEE Ee OE POE SSRs Su ee ei EE EE SO OS mee pemmemnemmnrn tment apo EE ag « LESoe iy. DAL i HORM Mamunninaiin meni ingm et cee aig Ae Serres Enns Se eaSe

ieS #= a ston oe cnAnRSeiner “aes FP4ghise YEOH 36oP tS tare Ollie 3bag eeORT eeSee eeSSE re ee eee RE Tenoltum oO ee RIE Se ee o% pl tESmarine Bos hefertT? % rite TK EERE tt Sub homineein te ae ee oo = filets cnn taaortstes sx 90 Dob OS SOHO LAKEARERILINN, We IROCB OSA ata ae sbesesepesasegesesenena seas “a eS inate MN ane etce e See meee

es Se ee TE Rg nete e ne paseeneaanenacat eats asinncaoapaata nes pape ~ am smicsunmaenpen enn: HS ibinnien e SaSe DESL SSS

pies Cee Woe SOE oe oo es eee a aags ee ineSTE See SnSULh Pig hne tSt noneTELE ed aitatnTEX negara Sh |aeEe ASE ie OESashes ES SeyEERIE Te EES Sve ee ee 6KES: Year crinttriur sannna ris th eee eeOiPe ree meee Ohana TRCOUOT: atte LE QIate quite tlie Po oe =: Ve t £ CREST. £2 Crute meee ements batere. oo oo iEeeeies povperer ficdl wa rr —EC ee i 3 (Se ee is RSS SED ct hc SRQSue tee THESEUS SiS Sass Sk TRIER CUE ee Se a ES Thitmne I x SIEELNL QUES. SESS es § ee He oe Ks eee ee Renee e 2 EES

SS PE ere ae ee he ee SS: Se ee ee RRS ate eee

- br - aeSrnrecie Wess ees Se Son See ecu ee rr UGE ALONE FORT THETORUD~ iis site Bstarnimabtiiriplis ce — COHfo nines eS gw OG ik. Se ee ee re BES Oe bonauemnes “wx «2Scia es £2-E2: £5 ct PEER Be Cie toe oH eeee reEB eeee eeeRe ee eete ee Se bates EREIIE 33h PEEL OIOY FE 8es orem prettierRC spasioees ep OsED cassisaigs is Ca cea ee USES SES SSR eae eee ae neenieieare Fee ene oe Be Osearn Sts Sx a SE FORO CEE SE SE Ueno Te SE| EY I ah SS erone SRS eae eae ISTE] ecuner. SReares SR&I oa SEA, Nee DBs CR, wseeOthe « LPAI Particle MeTITS ee FR OREO SesSEEEEE IU SUES ISS DEENESS 0h LE iiiceST ee aapeace. OFiteat some ae; pSeet&ECE! es‘£ -23 %RESePas re tmHen Ree ey. Kc i DEES ee DEES eeSohn. ee ee

JESSIE SS&RENO aaey St ESR. SROeeToSeo OSDec eh dbana ae iy ese Ren eens eSSee ee 2 eee geeaeneRES a 22S § peersOS Se Sees, 4 § Ae ee . ane seg SOR: Ce gugkag sanieunite sui Concent aierons cae naiBETA ong eae ae Se

Reece A re eee See Sood Shoton ns nroscoroe coi ERER RR beara craps SS a COS NO EEE Se eS ee

eeegs Se— ee..ee=CCtsits 0 eee OIDeeSte q ees Ss_o c —-— ee i ES i Se aeEEEee ee Pe ees: pg Gi ee ee eee$ee° os PASS SSEes Seemann Sto [AER noanee, sie hs 2Pe ER os SSRsee’ eee Wp eR eas egeeeae Pee CR oe Ee, eg%ee a

ee pS ge ee ae ee fhe ee

oe es se ee, ee Bee eR EROSION weet p apaalioseey: . x Gaye ow kebbe SRE Aa ase eat SRRSee eons Ee mL eeON Rccenames os ik Som, art eeAN ee ‘% ae? feohSe,Be Re ees ges Seated: ieee a Be oe ee 2Seneo PeTestis peremeenmes AeEM, 5oeSa so SeBegigee Soe ¢ ORE CE ©25 shee oeSereSee ee ee eeSSE Be ee |

ee a ts ee ee : 2 2 ee ee ee ee Pete ey. € oe LL Menearemes gr! 2% Te |” 3 SE ea &> SSaR ees: Sen eee sia ie earn Rintonatet Same ie nen gee ae Seoeenemens 5 Seem wees Th HR. 5’ Bg ERR Bees ae Se Be ee q 4 ee ey Ce gee a Sir ctenseanenn ERIE aan oS ane RSE Speen sans anaemia SES Shree Secbeeneeney & Season Be Soe: Bepens ert Se One ee pets SEE es

ig {fo Ep eeskeee psi. sare HRS ESSeesSeegSee.» SeenMeee Oe Egy eg See PSE NaeHA a SSE gee teren Peamemeers 5 5, Papers oS See Sy SERS cance cerca es Ronee sasSSO teas ee Gee eesae8SEE Se ee OSee Re eee ae Be pieces BTesSenet ISES gerne tances, hateESS sien, eeS. i Bei SS ee” ee Sea ae. Se ee og aea Ste eeSS BeSee eee areeee Sears peeoS | SEE Re BR Ee See ov Sees 5 ees Ben SES See SOE LS

rere OR ag ee Gees BE Seea eeee,Se Seeee yseee” Eb oes eb eeeoie | Bo esrae 2POS: ee OR: MR oe Pg ee ee eee pe hee ee SR ee Bk 8 Ree SS BU eb be ees eee ex, ees tee es SEE @ go BB, ROE xi tenes Bee RS. Soreness cane OES neg Samet Tee; ae © Gees oe ee ees ROR RRR fe Sea cere 23 Be SBS ELE oe 5 See Ges SS So St? Be Ce oooo2 Serene Ss ay fs | SRR eee See. Se cece 2 - Sit 33 Sicha ng seek me eeaaanee Series cemenonetaet Se 2 aS ae somes, tae St” Reena. ees eae. SR SS aE Se SES EM is ERSTE ge Sig ag ORR > Se Sass, Smaart % BUS Semen Po mieecerS Racesoae oceania 7 Seen sere GP oi Gee s poe a ERB we PS EE a GaN cee! Oe Bee eS 5G sie sae Fl ae PEO ee Me RRB ee a a ae Re AR py IE eg ER an ON ee eee, oe ee Re nO ge Sa Soe” % Sameees © Cees © ES ee ee Soy eee eee

RN SS Noe ce Sere Se Se eS Sa RS SE i j y BR Soe St once” S|, Bee oe See 2 me: bo ancy: EOS Big ge ee ag 2 ees , CoReoeass SER SSE S SEN eek Soe weit 3 Bah,

. [gates ema etee REE ae PaeeoYGSN eeGsbge heecophieeey en aeMager in oy, ae oe. SeaKeer! Sas ae fg ONE OR: Te SR ee: want taf atts:OO Wiseduisrt.| aeeweey Mes NADEEM cp CeAnlorey (0 teres OOE a, herent (arenes SE USE REO SEO AR COTS So, A | Oe Sa RamEOnSS yee Soares v~oo ae ON Le IRE son cat ose woes Se FE Fee ee es

SSE OD aR’. RE, RR a ES 2 a Se oa? Se SERED 5. 2oTO t, ONO o> SN. SORES TS Se RS, CGC eee Sacro ONO OCS tr Oe emeiee ae miertato corn iisnabitsckag SESE: Ee KS Re fie Sates iS Ce ere cesPEER hase TO MeBS RNRR OEEeESRI EEeeSO I, Y ail. 2s cee,OS Eeeeeeeo ee: ierght Mee come, hee”v EEE =O me ey xMESSRS OAR a eee oe gy “CERO es BR = 2SEED. go : Si : Pee. regPes ‘J iNeto a oy é a eS va>3eesaN ae adge’ ete or gi.RESSEREEE pe CAN _UUR ole :SSaaoe: ARSee s BOF NERS el Et OO i ‘QRS Se ee .-OF ER ‘, ©, eoS%SeA. ge XX. QA Re- NUIT

ci aeraOR peeAe gaEe, eekSEMEN ot eae a ie Sy SeSr neti ar: en Rersieay RO (caeEB aisere? SaeeeS ke & ogg... USE BR. ARS Pe Bs on? aN Ea og eae ib os nt RB og

Re pO Ae eee ee 1 AEE SE RC SE Ta : . aD Oe he 2 Ss Ses MDS EEE Ug SEE Oo so” F. Sn TALS “ Sheieeees fon

“os FeAP ECan SR CEL SS eSee pe EEE Neeeeereennn’ eee) / Ry Ne ay iN Oe tee! Beep. 3 BEnae Caf ce.Naf Ry, AC . og ef Dy eIEN NN eee SU Ae oD RESPOMBE RRC: Sen an ee RED 0 FS «meeps Seer eA NWRB eros gtoeen frak ameoret Sa or tM ccna a a Jind ARON eee ge RET SR ge eh ae oo aR dParnShe ne ARE +SyMoon ERI

Mig SREB IG Saa aaN RE ERROR” RETR q FELIS OS ot en geSoa NEb5Ng oegsSet GA fo hy. ; .nine NE yeh ORS: Be TBESOS BE 57°ESS ROS ORES CR RS FR 3S gg ie BeeSSERE To FE PANE Oat) Bag Sa ow $3pofeng TE” peFe LA RS: gg RS§thSo FINE, Es Se ec RSOS oe PRUN | ilcler Seta Be eres edEa yO See YER . eeeeS Spee OEE TR (EE PRESSE aeee a4OE yng Sacco eM Pgés fe nae a ORL ieRE eenSEG IF Lo eroo teBS Pa tasteAY wR PAS AE SRM ERR a EE eo©aeME Theso LOE ooASF». ee eR, Giese PARTE GeBETES eeor:eS.

Sy a eS ERC | CREE C79 Oe O'ER iron: ce Me Ne Wh egies. 2 «gece SR ae EE ee EE Se

KioSIC ORR See. .aeSee meee ae Ry REE pete AS) ia Sh es Be EA eee. ks Gee megala? a OS: eee . ORES eer 2aon Be. Bue Roni onsaes: eras ee ni geben «geswegen Bis! & 5eae Gaon eee tes V, Bee aS ee ONGin a ESa. ga ERE We FELT i NReatRR aot hoy Se Re co, Satees Sem we. BRR EC eo oS. macs > See ED AEeo x a2 ne cou ooSeMMR 2 ape Aooeee OS ee ce. eee 2) iy Cores eM ofCoeSO cesSSB NE aeeSees, eS eee) CoeS: Re ese ee fers ioe toed bean! os ee ofr as a ‘ Sc" y Ror. aa oo” al ih, SR eT SEEN, SCOE Sion: SS SEE SSRe. eo aeAB CO aE

eee SS oe See lS we EE ee Pie Rtas Seige. en ee coe: nn

ee £5 SS ae vy gag . io a SE ee SE ES, hte BRB ba Ek ote OF ERRORS akab Sae tens ener SAE oY CEN BF rete Sn o : ear 8. Se A he Se eS: fe Se Sg IN gh Ba oe ee ea eS aay vs, of eo Sf wes 2 tm a anLfos XS Se SP eee Re ee Bee - Se ee: Pe Sues nt. -4 . risweer” SS SFB.S: #3 Bate. a cnBO: = Sewee : . sor ae So) ageS°SS JORGE SL Sate I po 2RRO RE SEESS RS f. > HY: 3:£SR Sesme See Mihi. es ames ee pgeS BBSee Senn

pues © oO ae ee PS UL es Na ora fe Ve ee ECR Bk Pa ee ONE

PE ©: SER oe RRR CeROee RRS SRS ee0S feos aSs.ee. aeRe Sees Sse Seanre large ORS aSeSee RR eS SF ReSe:“ee pig

“ Kacy SO ORS Nee ae ae Ses Se re FEOL eS ES EON RE SN SEM REO a aa 5noe ae.ans SYian‘oh ee as 1 Re eS Oe SRSS> Beier pT ay Ses BE ba . et:gee er Seen : 5 py SESeas SP.-#>BE eeeeeaaaePSShe SESSIP Gieeer SecaRS 5 eeCU, Lo .|

.Laee~sy a 17a RS.” Sens eee . ... Ree S: Se S _Pog Bes Reg PeeteSKS eae Gee es ee

neA i 3.Sarhe. ieSesixeer hl’: ce: e- .Sa,me So eeSsEORY AED coSRE ee Doras eens te ao +. 0| 7et See ., =F Ty ee. BRS :2RS 3eee +, SSS a ak Se Bas OE: Osee eas Cee oeea Ol ae mee ere CV DE ©Se: bd | res? ae “Ne ae re ec. Ses see eee bP Ebb Sa Wes ll aS i : ian An " § ae oi": ERS SS SSeS Se Mime? £ eee 3 er rere } be BS ~ aan BONE OE y : re BARR Sere, —°. | RaSen SoeJAMES 0S +Sr ls . Cone a ay a RR cre a nae, we ne on OOS «LYS OBE OE cpa 9 Snes we we an : ON EE Ro Re : Lo MLR eRe Rpomocnomnaanage a + pan S RRR RRR BORN SITIES | ASR BPR oe. aes &, ea tee

ji Philip I of F b ivil he Pri f

Figure 7. Philip I of France bestowing privileges upon the Priory o

St.-Martin-des-Ch Book illuminati Paris, t.-Martin-des-Champs. booK lUlumination OF ca.f120, Faris,Bibli Diblio-

he National N A ] fol

theque Nationale, ms. Nouv. Acq. lat. 1399, tol. 6.

°an : ae .: , Lal oe_O cg|oo Lot — ee3 oe,ae, veeeDnsoeore 7- " ‘|:Piaa; :wtae

Hie adie oe rae SUSE EEE SEESse 5 3ee. OES wea . | - 7 i eeeETS att eaecenaans eee |:'e|| :.:a|os i" se eee ignESE eetoetaiics AERTS 2 SILA SS OEEDES TERED Poa Rs et eeSEs - oS eet, etn in LA DIR 21.eeEee cnn STL aati SEE) TEAEESES wees ener aces ees oe & iZe : See ae :aZe:; CR a. a“¢an : :ie ; ae - ; i" 3 RRA ELIS rere Ines reec SUN st DS Set, REESIS EShae SosaTae Senhey SEES, SEES SUS eeee SSNCEEE Sioacneaneainenas reg Se DiS BNhisa SESSA SHEMET cee SESE EEN Se SESE ae oak BRS i ce : F | : ! ” :hen eee es STRATE Se stee noreee: NSS ESS SRS RE SS ieee 7 EES Soy aes ; ; . fas 7 eZ. . : : & _ |. .s : 8Ue —eteoeSE os Se SORES Bee |,SANTEE Tye re epee Panes Ae howl eS Dwi oe eenDe TED Wena AOI SEES [IESE SEESReece Seesey. noes Z SESE TASTES S; ese {e aed a a - oe — ee aooe oh as Ses ES,eee SaasPORE men SES (aces eet oot SEL eeoe re ee \ aeee . es ‘ : |S. Bee % we

e2eg /SUSEEEAELL =e - ao eeDEAE ae gf a LEEPSSTS we at 2ST TsSeeESE See or SeeRsRed — ne CC Saree eater ce aeeSESE ye |~~.SH4Sp 3, 4Eeaeoe ; oa. ) Dt Se SEESEHE EEA ee3 : ee: | .Aa | xoe— i oe SNES RISSS TILE SIS LL Se Bs SESS ES See Wye a— Series ee :‘ee TUNISETSEE) Sete te mene aio ee SN nel2,ooUSES CRM REn ee olga antes Spee aerate ES fea 3a—— “ ~ : :& : ‘ae:pin. eS can fet TD eaten yee OTIS etc we CO EE passion EELM TIED: pl DD ty Soe als eon Ed Bef oe Reece MASE ent TT “WESSE Tt, ess preeeeinerny Pe apne Gs: 2 : 7 a Z a . 4 = on eas Seng sy ERIE HIPESTEL ISIS SEES SSRI Sits LENE BOa Sate Lavo Pes ie E coc epieettyt fEEet ag SLL SIE 2 ne Snes ESERESLESE SCSEELESS SSUES, Eeieiaements HEB A ee an ee g 3 = S |

Th,Bhai WOES f Soe,OSEESILSTIS Ears ES Pari as ec ee Bae ns thVES Vea Tl STLoe ae SD SFaes DORE Pits SP pene SPREE Saneeon Ripearenreoates eeeee Sod oe: ee: es aa 2—s xoe: DENS SEL SeSa 2s2ee ae eons BS net! SAS Ee “AS cae ee eees om ae oo ae fe .St=atPe oe os22COISEL ee Ae ne fe Song SahMEN MESs LnSEshh PENSE then eae we amoet TSE a SOPRA eeLESS MOS a“ sig uy Pacman ots tetne AS Me, es %, J ey THD TheMiah AROS I SESE TE fee eee SEER fe ttle A SS SIE yA, enSey LIESeOIYPSS cnet fe ns fenLOE te Dee raya, bt teh Seas rennet Sue* AE USES CLE SPORES 2G geet we oeoats ; es Aoe Pe eS 8 ito oo Sas IES DESES TUE IPRS anes othe nee SLEEES TES STE: eloe STE oy PAE tSoe Fe BR: os 2 Cs BATES, SHEE Pores CSEEALIE Soest SUE WEISS SL Sal 22h pened ei,ty HOSTS Ce gas oeiaere siootSen ee LACES ESS Syste Sg i Bs SRAESS SEs STEED Ln elt EERE SES SIE eT iedeet aes toBo SSS SRSA ecco feenone weSoe WEL WtAte “OAs eySU Seoe aeTn eeteTSI ee POSES Mette ei Soo AEE aAOD: HTS “TEESE aes wr. Mies TSE ee es ee eeHie TEE aELSE SSSR wy, eeacer aePe DTS Reet aloe eens nenee Ls yeBo eeSEgee aSELES

Pe, ., ;2- 7eeanena a RS Re ara 2%42 3 2‘ SE # i} me Maefo“ Peg ae ee . / yO > a“ ‘s . a.- a aowne RRR ee TY “a Y tagps s ef,‘ 4Bs pa Ee aSg 2ey Awd , Fasme aee s. ,i ‘);: an ge Fo ge ae eee ae BES REE | an TSR wale: yer’ee .[eyaBe _ ran i oats2 vy. :El i wee Lo7S$& .=voy eh. Oe,” aeeo; &pee FP ¥- Byoa‘ .‘ana a 'a€ee oe.Boao oe oo g: ; 2wta.Mee, .owe mo, ORR LR KR RS 2iS eS eea2aoe i ”*‘ BA? . os3_— The on Re: . rst ee SesSee : wn SNR >Re. asSos oi “..i 4*wey acs s

4 ie oe ee ae i ae OX ie WS 6 Geis 4d rn: er || Ue MY

>.> Boe Fre a. -Bi, 9 Be 4 Sas.4 Ba PPBepO a oN Se. ig re? — *,Fs78neERS — re emrsatRe" Rise. Foe 28, ge % ROE ; PA3:ae ss oes os Bg arg Fas Sees: oaSa + 8EE Reine ee

ae & a aie ha Siig "Mes A a a. ae wd | OE SS eee a aF 0a- -*tet as Tee aa eS

|. Fe Bet | Go 8 ee rr rake ee eR ae ieee ee | 3 . Se et ee oe eee Peg ti Beer eee eee Or

ee aes Ba Sagoe ie Soap See Soe y aesSee Ses Sieh, Se Seem one i, ieee SeSee: Se eS :¥eeasSOS S SoSS go moon * * es SE > es . *rae2 SRae et ESS egSas Boge Seat a ee BOO ta Be ~YO Be ee8ag ee oe2 ageeeBOF SS ee Sag EEE SL aEELS a og eS ae SeRE ei of or3Latinas FPBees AEs, Ost Spee

yo 2Bp Cae *)| 3a 9 R$ Sr ae8ee Boh le ARL lc SS 8LES. 8 fe: fe. Ue ee Na BR RE peeo co ‘ee 7 Fe $%eeoFoe , eeesaeee pe:ee eeeaecaee : Bog = fieGe.» = ; ; —See : : =ee oeSm ats . oe Dog ee EG Sesiiiie ee es ee eee LEE @ ee eae Br Bere ie a co A Re ae Se is ae ee eee os Bie Se oe ee “3 % aoe OSE UES OE RM oe 8 8

aeeespo| Somme BoSie aoe eo eg Roene Se = eee BeSeeeoneeeme Ree oe eeeees. RSS a:See 2 pore ae ee SOOO Ss. OE fie eepg saeoe sete: I Ieee RNSEB eg Seamee eSaoS) ak SS SS Ae. 2, oO FERRE agate Ss CUE arg? rae Se ee wt eeee&eeeee Ee ce ee oe 86 2S eee, Fee Bag he + obs * aw ao ce a e Onwos fe ‘ peal aes or een F ieeeala ,Pn SSN po‘dite ile tril ekees eae

Onto. 5 ete EST = ogo Tes ‘eee Sa ae ein Sean? (3 Bp “He “ oe 3 —— ee arse ein scramabct Hace pormeemeianes «5 4 het PEE Pos! Tag many oa “pee Sy pees Sones aoe cacnancan cay eee 30a Sal ok 5 4 we feo os yg SEE aR . Fe. me area geet ye pga ae tee gt re eee” pag es Jere e. ou GAY, “ro % ek eatetl Cibiieite oe

| high vault WORM ee eee ee apt $00. |S eee mercer: oe Bese > ie ok oes re ee ue ope gece. Od atrrrise ee PE ae aeEE af Ca 7-7| DS NO ea eee wos Y Se oe nee See aepop awe eS oon ateesgear oereeary cetes PRP aoomeocnarecane a oe ee : an See ee a ee Se Bab oe ht ae, eo es pion sein cae age ‘aemecanse bern eee por ¢ as a 2 a on oe a ae op a g # 2

RyeIB Ge tAPUA fp Bae ee a bee ee ag OSSES ee ©seoeGeter es a1 cee |notes (iinBoEg ee LC

TM burt on repaired Ege Bh oe re gp

ops ae |} 8 _ho Petweeh UST rerrenecrerie, a) ae ee ke ee ee cg ee ee ae ree

ce ak eee Zoggs Pore ye eee eee” “amen Saniodt tiaderas than EI 4 BR Sony CED i BEBE 0 EL

fo af Ce ee — note ‘ga ef ees fests Bane Pape hospice 2 £0.03. Lis pg ee panefoe Cote Feta “TARY IS gp bet mae BoEal aeaesTanita ters for lety Brethren. 8.oe le ning? ON Se pe B Ocmmtoms? og eee oA oe e@ fac AR a gp ee oe 1 R possibly enclosed 30 WS ve Lo TS high vault i520, fell 13g;

BO eee is ented nig MK OE ee Se

yas Bele eetntecuees Sane sorcaneened Pee eeeoe “Abas stre ep ane see wed wees dex SO re a bo og. 3. oehts vey oetat sscorettesaaetans ee hE ee a. eh) neth erie cfane :Bhp th és eeMe FOO a wee ee PPS Peeeeeoyhee aoeeee: ae ER shea es.rand C1750 _

eee eGpark TAS A bautted slited Lider a ae ee ee rePaEAB ak Okavo cops later a ee Ok fees SARShextreent anders SEESER ee seo) Ee ul t149-58? ote Co ee a (AS Sos Se wikia aenicdmnin as

ge oh }eeeeEd Seagoes Coon grinhome seb mes a ene ee TE eeeee eeeeeeuPree Bsae feBee penne ieaete ‘ Pg EPScf SEee os ma aes vive ey teseee TI men es osoat EE BB eaeete sUs eeeeemraeee ier a Se pe ,-ee° ee eee ee

oe 8 ce a ee ee ae Ns ii aoeeninel Pas S| cee ae oe ene ES py e Buf Bes Bee es oe oe

Pl oe S|| qteeti _eeO poe pe begun ee crelate aceXlaecent. ee | i: BOR Stower a fe eee EEE co EEE peas eee Ba ST ESE ees: ee 2S Sig EES RS ee eee pee Te rr eM SR pg Fe

ee — 20-28; one “augmented” between 1322 ured 1344

og ORT 10.tower both fat towers largely6built €1220-28; one’ i. evorctod. belwech1798-67833 iat anid 457 ee ide ee ge a8one N?)gew, reimad pores ae:VISIO ‘newstalls 7781, Demolition ey Se Cae oe ang Se: next tla.00s MS, SEES TPCT! ;

"General renavation cizso-cr7bt; new |altars; 88;11203 ra Soe oS reQe Sea 2eeAR lo es URES at EN cerns Srog eeRT er:Ss Gl BB eee ens SE LSE Tee dea SRS aR OO OSS ee ee ee Des? DATE BAR SEESRR ERERA BRS US Sa SiseS 22 eo Ee ese oe eR TRU UEteIe PRE eeSeEE Ege 2 Ce Pe

ae atSEU? iss ree: cae recs kane Se toe AASeh USES Se aee nhDR es, TEASE CSS PencsAL LES SEED NES EgoePeeaeSEeeSR Be aSRE SE See eR ee Oe MS ee

pe EPPUM © ¢+..0—h—UhHDU™!UCUlUmEUC Ol” woe eye SSSEO SORSSOS Na Ee geESeePeGPESBier en Re ae DESDE dice A Eee SRE SaSANTA BeOE a i BE ga iRES ES coe punthaeSee Jaeo) ot kee glee ODES Tce Bg UALS EE USS RUgag SM ree See oda ae A oe ER ee oh

eee Oe ee es Ce ge ee lc LC lr rr Cr CL

SOD TUSSI Ae pe Se A DUES le TESS US CLE amis SE

oem =n | ee oe ee ee re re

ONT ng gaocace anges eSCe, cee. lenisTe, napeSORE. ararae »rene, SEES DORE oe event Sao atc BeBESS ee | aeee. AUee.

ee eee ee ane eee Re ee aePh aESee RDO EE Sl Se eeTeeeeROe USS Ie Sg Reee ee ee eA gai os Ch OAR SE” See ee RISEN “SemeeaieocR A, 5 Saccoosecipoeestoaioee ROOTES. A. ep. Rent. Fe xe Ss

Ue ROR ae aca psa nin rh POR SAN ARN EN RT AA Re no neo ane nn ceapR rl li Sina) SPEEDS Se SESIST EEE ESN RR ES PRE SONS a A athe og ein ages aah sano be senate smnn ne ae wate Rigo eam en Poke ae UES aR RSs Se ee ee Re ee ee ee ee aE ee ee eae ee me ace

SECU,

;Crrr——
* CREARVNU ARTSSANS YSU ELSLE DLE SESS AAeeUE oy!SRS, DS SMa chy hate Tt Ss Ee SE oe We EEE SAS eA ORaaSRS SSIS AI ERE AED ak VO,hee MIIRs Oe, Ld EASLE SL She eS CLAIS Lat stSSVE ATES eeSeer: oRESA a oad (NESSES SUIS EN TigIISSL SE SV eS UR SLES, naePS tn ee RaSS TP DOSE LEE ARtapaeee RRS wen seer peanoh©ee LORIE Rs Re SOREN Tan ten SERS SA ws SESEETAeS LL SEE SEs eeASSES ae oeRST RYTSS SETS Th Ogee S BOS: 3 ERE:

esti Se US ings ESS US SSE Tg SS JESUS LS USSSA, USS nt a OT Se RIE Ere TD ee * Pere: FI BsEELae ee ke ee eee ee er ee a ee LORE: ate. re DORR SRST ARTA Seo Tse ESAS EISELE SS EET ee Se ses SigeeBase om yen ant Sn HIS Rey aDe SsUSER SES EES wee ee Ue Eo ER 8Ms Ee Se SSSOT TRSUSES SSL "RECA Ss5eR RSEeee Ae€ RR eetSZ +: ee oat

OUBISEE SORES Soa SES oie Bie Se eS AEE ERE SO Me ge on Be NS RRR a I Oo pS Seo RR Repeonee Mirman f $peee i Geen e CUBIS NE, SEERITSUIInS EEEILs tthe tad no ee tI Sis SsEE pct ae pit SS SRE esNeten ag S55, OME ag eas Rede 1 stig kNae SQ . oe & s aN [AMEN ESUES ee ance aUE ESiesLEE TESR, Os SE SSWEE SOEs ee eee PBR. eaef,eS oseabt ERR BI=aee yOOP Serer Ee oe oSa?Sey CET IR URIS Sn, SS) TS SSTos SSE STIRS Fo MR ae ‘% y OS .neo a2iiliBE Fae DIE SES SARS Sa OR SE a Oe SE Sa RROOe NE OR a ee SE NO EE Sap eee chk Tom 1 RRR 22 Bee er SND PSELIS OSU ASSETS SUES EST) nce gE eeSn TeSOOT Ge Lis Sig spat Week SR MagyREE wwe Retrnn SS AE RRR eo! SRE SEER “eanASHER SIAL ELier Le Dee MS eR OK RS, 7 A Sicreaan en ieee are BORE aNE: ItnyOE: 2B RR SO ETRE SUA,ial St BET) SETS ieee.1CSTR SY,1SES east & Rae SR eR ET oeCROSSES BE eh, ohRRO ER FES CIDE NU Seon EEO: BSha POO’ kcDOSS MOR The Sate oo eT SS wRBSS ote ped Ge DSU SgIE I eg ETEnestle En SSSUES Og cee noe ceaeo ha Si ge aR aga bet Be “ |cmannneane, manag TEED IG kate h OEEosSB ROTI IReeGR nits”: SPERee RES SETI Se UT SEIILD SE pis Soo SOSA ie Seo Fey SER BPE IED Biot tees OY S. TK egI IAAR eS?zy + Ne 9 9SES 5 a SSR ae ee * HEEL SUBS IStng SSIS St ST aOS SReS ESE ER Spe a NENA PRAIRIES CES ONSSow ee Bd wine coy sg RO ae

WOES, ees, taeSSSR 38 EN sega . alae PETE USSSATenia SOE EpRS UCeR VeSE Caeoa SSR Ce”, non SN aie? Re ak OO BeSeine Ee oS RR 8 SBR aka ie

a SEa Se SSOS on,aBEI ANS oe ee ae ene SS ee RagSRB: cd aeSo: ‘x “ORR Beeise. eee Aa ee SSSUS SUSDRE oh: SteTSaget SenMR Se Re TAGE: ORR, SRR as EN a OO MeBeecee eee: 2 =

(SMES ACESLSS OAS) SRE PLS eeEe SOO Se S Cite: voydep SAMS, ceeAD a PeOAM ee PARR U6,ig RR rs ANT ae ake to Mae 3 ase be SUR ER Sn ULL Aa Re hig SeER EoSS 2 ae ABO ES.Bin EE ea 3 De g, EER Ds one tetera tet ce An Roe et 7b es y Bo, ERBE SUR 0ESS erneeieee eek oe Pan rna,£8. % Rook SS *e Byie SPs DahSer SMD USSU, Scene UTS SUES, TEGetee Eee SES Be SEE RO Gs Se aénan Bites ~aSRO oe MeSRD, meee TTT wees" RES Se aFase, TiS Wiad) og iEe FeeR Sa ED POS, SE see: ROPES eepape. OySRT } SD Sos eeENS SER EAe (Base weg A ET a perpen “aeZSeaoe REE Poh Si, LE i SRS ie ee ES cn: a oe SEES We LS 2 Ne ON ed ted agg SE AU USELESS GE. DSS RS PETS SEE PELE. a cnaccm ware. Se sr RRRORET BR BON ae SS Fae Sls “eRe wee 3 aBers ~ woe UAE OSS SITE oD SEER Se BB 7 YER Ae a NO. SPE RS ee gee Meee 3 EER es ONS RY ol Gk. DU RL SnPie LR Syl gs SEs SEUSS ee “S TERR Re entree 5 SRR. OUTS SE AY oc«|* “Sea RCPS:RRR AS. 425% vk BRB atan - FRESS ind ES SS, ee SSeS a BER REROR DRUM aahss MEE a ORCA Ie an - ENG YI AUSSI TES 7Een Beatiprnennait so "Sates ON 5: ROR.” * SOR STREET.Be ROESeah NaS ts Seaed SRO . Snes COTES TLS hr D8 So STE ES pprmemoremamee css Set\1SSRE ce DREISER ate ConA+OS reece oR BS2S:APRA WPLUSyD Ua. SE i,Se DU BeoeeeOR annPAS REST ON MN: TEeeRe1betant CR ONG v. tyi ps8 DEA EET VME SSE AESSe, SS SESE EE DR SO RRO SOODSRSOE ANY BE. BES TY eee ge Rane A OF SPREE St S. — ae: - ~ © pq Vil wane TEA DS SS eS Sei bkreays > , i PENG ie WR Sh Eg CLS eAy Monessen i oe een a ae: x: ESD ONE Do SUE ee Oociel SReeSeana BoNERS Sig eTSu ane aeees Spee EOE RR Wgheht SS eeate ENG RyMPR Ge pe EOE ESEa IE eeeEEK MeyBern, St RSisitiy, ees aeRe a Se

ea eR ca a SRC ee es RLeee EIRone nT cata RTE Seen CLI, URE ER RAT SETAE. as RROe neRace Seis OR AerTe ig 2s le SLE SERSee URS SaSeDe Be eevee eI ea 7 SRRcanna i AROS reeeg SFEei tg, SESS

OURS GSS. CUS NOS SR SSS eS SR cA ee CNN e Nef ROR RECO OOENE REE Sgt CB RRS EE cai bg

ty PEERS Sg SS Se ae eee Sane SERN ene eS 2 Reaper eeae saanYPN cn SRCSwaa Be" $3ret Ro eM IK et 28 Baned a STRESS a eee iti eng RE LS RE ee Dhaene STR IR RS ETES cee Nb ingic, CSIs Ung TS SURE, SSSS Tee SEER ei Be .SsANN, “* Sas SSUES, DNSERS oe Ti SEE SECO SES TSE EES Eo SE SreeSSS ennOS encn ne rR AS. TL, NE wad me 2Sr er SSSI SUS oR SL EE Fe See a ey ty. «7 TESTERS SIDS ce DRED ESE SS SE ESE ESE SE So a SESS Oe Se pref: Sy SyUSES Ting Sieeeee Sta EelsAITEES JUS SE ee peSEE ee NE any Be ag ee PETER OSE LS SEE Se RS SERS CRE OOS: tSpaae (PROTESTS US TR ee RST SST OR RIS RRC RR SRE TES OeSS, SE RS OR: CRUEL US SU SENS cS SES STMeA Ee Besa on eeSS SCSPS Ra CRSe Sarto CORES REET RSE SS ROcer REE ROSE SER PRERRRSO RS SORIA SE SS ae uo mes %RM SEED SL SUS SR etna ene SMa RSESSEE EERRR RCE CS RTE, TR

AEE So Se iS SE ee EEE Se SE SRS SR LOSE STAR SES SS ME USS ne aESAS TSE SRS SSee SSOe SES eg iiooe eeee RIS CSTE, MOLES SESS Bia OS SeRee SSR i ee es SeaS age ee SEES URy SERS EISL ott Ei AUS Sea SDSia EI Sg SESE Sa a EEE eS SeSoS ee ee See Se aie x AR) BB ost Le Ee SMES ASST Oo Ge SE URSCR SS SESS Se cee rit RA Do Oh EEE PERE SERENE ES SE EES eR SUR BESS RISER eS POD LO OEE. .” CAI: ee eee ee ee ee ee ee es eer cee Whe,ee SUISON USN. SEATS Sg) IT VSR SS NOSe SCcoe inceios SSeS a ee SS eee ae Me vei SAT EUS Sk,WINSLET CNEL nese 2c SeVA ee CORES Recent neeme tas: ee BESS ean SREY me S08)AWM VERDUN Sot ER i SCENE SSE EE OSS SEE amare 2 2 SOE TUSSI I SU ns SE BS TET yo gt Se re OEE SEE aiaeneonenntann/ eis sea SRS, Se Se 5 SRR SR Sa * ATHLETE e Tindg TS LEE SESE Ue cae eet aan seats SU SCE SE SRE ISIS vn Rea SE Pa EERE SS Te ORE. BAS Se

SeSED AUD Ug Ton Seet) Ln Sistah SE ie eR Eo cecaSy ERRESS ER SORE EER RORner RRR TES RC REECE 1S ORRIOORS UNT useeTe BeeRRO Sea eRe SRSCORREO, ESO ea eg 239

Bet hh Me Or ES ONE DESIST gy Dc IgSTR SOESe S ee SOS EL Te i ee le pees 5S COE OU OSSD: SEE fhe 2S, SS SS See Sopa Se EES

UIE oS Se IS Sk Si SMI ONS NSE Ronis SE an Sgn eteRE See ey BOE SE ssn Sec RESTEESE RD Ce ec nS eis nnST eR SRN OREEES OR CONC Oueoaaees I ieSok, UTE OU SNE SER Sai Sinan LEE TIS SRE hI ET REA Coegceeea oe\ Bae oe$:°al B PATTI Ea TRS TORENT Ue Ree

Salas aaa Sa BEd me Sony. oe nage eet SL ees pees ett adecettet dead teehee ent + pela cotta eneeite Lath basttagheattie.c iaitiegeet is ategeteven tigated steed aio tie onan hae nee catetnteetettte irae POL 2, aR CSS esasOR ee SEE es on gee fetesce)OMELET ae BESSNE SUL ee anMs SSta SiR INR Sterne ESE eM SASS a PS DIED Spee teWo ErSoha ThRios CLES TE RE NRE CRN ae%EO eNOSySoENE SORE ee rE ee eeTSE RR TRByay 2 erene EE Se sehen Toate SET Ls geenSes eS San feng eee ne ear sienna ReneS a RR Bek.NS TORRE 4. SUS RENT ogeeEERE Dee DDSg CEI ET TUE OSesTe, ee rsh SRSA. ESTSUENEST he COTES tPA Seance SOON ery SRNR O97 a RRC TA pet Sent piPaes cotaeoanaseee essSIS . EES ee CASE Bene uy. Beane eae wae CESS ia ee IMS ESS ELS, eeeROR ee eees S83 nO ORS, © CREIIRRES SUSEN OSS DIRE Daa a un SSE RRR ec SSRIftRS eSUSE eTSINC SE EERE cr ate I RRFRE pS Re 20 UPEEDE OURS si WoL OLR ge SeSSS ISIEES a Tie SES Eere SRR EES hee age gi CORR eS ee eS ei EES SEE ee !NS NEEM eSSeger: sete gee ge See ESERIES LER CR SIE eS RRRaRRS SSCERES cetera ee Wo VRP SRLnee a ee ee Pao, COTE SIRS IOS,SSRN Iga Un eg Cn te BREE Sain ORRe Seaont AESae SOC ORR) 1 RCTSR SS EONS OOBe SSSSHEE Sa Dene a ESS MERE CHEE RS Posh, Bo Se RIS Srage Becesee oe Sore Ta Sees Seen EEtsEe Reo SiSe OS pesag SOSE So ca 2b ERS Seo 4TT Bee oneal IER TES USISD, Sk Sa 1Ee TELS eee SE aRSa is eee Recensnmemanics Sa Se ON RE OE SES SRS OE oeee tien OSLER TISAS SEE SSE eet ri eae cha Ee Sgt

ye Be NG SS S08 cm TN bie sean Se ae SEDcr tho gn SERENE EEee eee aio Eee Penne SSE oo A Deae ae 5 erieeSEES eee SHEE Re SR es BE eeSees ee aSTE ee SEES ARS yo Seer PeSes Rabe senee Sub TSE Re ee a Eichten ioe ieee RET . Sethe.BR. Skream ch a‘2 aang eC a See RS SOE oe 9 SRA a co ements tI Se [SRE es tdi ene PERI E TLOT UNS ses ET oo

PK,

* SR TRS ShEE AO Bee een AR So Sconce serIRenta ca SRO ies SRC A aSE Sa 0eo USry EUS Dei reset

Pa saeee RaeRET On ROR PROMS Sh ie ea epee nen Ne a aenOne Aenean oedag ROS IE Te SESS fe SUIS UNI uit Nc aa or SSG nA MDS SRE.OREN, » Serene SEL cy elem URE Maier, SOS ch age ean RUBSE SeeRES Weyooo ASReLEE SEeSoan eS aaeMeN ace ae SUN CERES

LY SE! SE,oo CS.ER . Sanne BOtay aR RRC ORBoe RY aearene PE SOE aaa SUASFR Tenens BD CUWE LOTTE ES aT ce ER NE OU SRS INS Sg St igi RBA a ESN’ iSE-Ne eo Bo RRR REAR ey RES Se SRS ES RR SUSE ERE Costin RC CEN SSO a ee eeWISICAE Te Th GUE SS iii Soi SS Sire OeUyheres) DS ge SIRS ns 38 NEae Sa, 2SB aeUSER aS 2 See a PERE RES Steen, eee Sai5 0 OREO ER ERESat el A TYR Ree be he SRSn Poeel eRSEE ane?hg TSeee. No Tc SERS CS eran BRR:YR 5, SEP SRENC AC SISOS eM, SUN Rema S tne Nise eR aESG, RRRPLIUNIIAGSEEL ESO Te OCT SOLS OES SESE eesea th wet Pr ae RS BS Foe Sooo er aes < ay ES SEES ESS See Sgaee LES USES Tn “SSS a OB tes Re POR nS CSO ES Seaaae Pp EEE 2 RRR SS, OR, RR RG SEE RES SMC | REDS Sone SOREN LEY CReRS Ct ee fd SE UT ESD ae Ree PS LU cea Minas it I Bt my ee Bs. 5; Sant ape oc Soros cabs Sere ie Se oe rere: comaraaes aaee ae Bie SEELEY neh Soc Sd a ea BS ESS aioe 3 ne. nee ese nen aman Ce a stone |aT 67 SEToSata nS oRey SSR peices. - sae Ak iar Dane Cee DIY we DUES Se SS SOR nceORIOL OR $ SE SOON” a ERE : peSteere Ie Sanae Res ec loehiiee EOS Se _ees ee See ae oo. Aspen eta aes sete orci tani Soeents ie tn ci teeth ae neALAIN SST OREUh SORE SZ SESE DORNMBE ee I I RR DSay SAP DEENRS ingens oo

Be Seas Annee ey 2 EER Deh eg Se ae ea Fd Ci eo RN ages PS Rel MONE at ee Beet ne. < og sess BREE eS Oa sy cee naa Sa EE ee

Tee oS og oe et REI Boa eeEERE ae zt cho SRR iae ce Segee EEeee: Oe Loobe Sm I ees SERRE EL Se or ae eet 5B Ae eeSO IEEA NE EERE RSS ti eg oe. TEE Bo Ee CRE ETS, ae eerie BRP eae ga REISER Ses SR gee SEERE giEERE Re SR 7: Rg 3 EER epOER seneeaee TeSEER site SEN SEE RS eSoes” SEnL eats ona SUA A. ate ROI, SORES SER NEN Tage 0SS RR CSOe RR PESSYESE nna ee Bienen rae an ie oro piinne SMES EE =aSEs go nai Rae os Sen ga

ee Oe RESOMO oePOSE Boeie,RE seCO eeeeeS NR: CRE as:RoadPat age MSREE Pe ovepeiceee geRRS Se gO OR etOn aCe ca Be REET evaCa A ee ie2 SEE tee 2a OL peo On,ae SEE ae ag aoeers 5." haeeeR oe SRE aoe Meee Ss Se Se ce eine: SoGONS NE, SCBOR ek ksBeis CN Ks or.”igwg ee RR Bee SR: SND oa Ba 2 ONEDD TESSSEn Scheid Sk Ree PRS USN Bee eS Ss ee hte STA SE ge S eecmee sae rg TPR ete Mos tae Ns Bek Seer Oa ee tes “2. (Pome ema ae See 2 ace 3

Sel OE BIESSSSS aL On Ee ERR ai eS CR OE RU Og Ra EE a SR SON ie ORE REN RRL ECR ROR SE: 7 “7 RNY CARES ERIE EMRE SORT 9

SR ORAS ZOESeOR gcREnEY oR Poe ORES See MRS iyATES PE ERR BE &:SE”CREE SON Oe CSE ER CS RR oe eee ROREE MRC ORE: GREERSt MRI REDS” “RL©See aD CSEae OSinEO COE CS SR eT RRROe ee} CNR EN RM LOE ar SF AS,RR SO ROIS RS Os DaSAMS eis SaaS § aeRIC 4 J CASAL siten Beier caren BS Sacer es pgORS RISES “ BR, EES CaCR eeSRNR CS aRSERN ORaae one Soeoe” STR Lyeh eee aiaSE FN See eee Re oe bohe LAUU oe oh ee YY Seg eee SG ORs BR ES a Rg PER om Semureinnes momen esSS |” |.nae oer$469 5 oeeAn mySao pe 23 RECO EG hy SS TERE OD SEAR OSSasa Tet

Dh - DS RE A pa ee ae BP ee ges i STE Bees 3 EE SS Bee & bs ee “oh SER PE RS eee. 2 ES Sea eee) CERES S

BieERR 0 EERem REESE SA£igSense Se Re SEES Ed ee NE COMED Se SORE SENG SAIS CRIT SIN SE a. a Sts me PRE SSS 32 x Saag3 NRE rg Se SeOE: ee BO + ERS erregeae ; ee ROE ES ERE esSRS is See Breet aeSac es 2° 9s0eee, PE PES seyACE S ESCs San ESRD Bekea

Pern heSSR ONE RRS Sgneigh Ca ST te SS SeOLS ESMe SElege . gee SeGE Be areas ees Sanat ar ae eS ASae9ESA aa PRON es OS Nae Pay oe aan ee fyyo ares SRSEDR EE,REI WELLL bee Se oe SAR st Se al we ae SE RRS ESS SetRate See” OeRS Ses U”y POSTURE ST ey on eessee eMee ghSRS gece cee aig CHER.“ate 207 SSae. Be aRe a RG Ls ESE Prats CSNY CSS ROS SEER, “9 nn Se a MU ae

aaNE a - SaRES SE SES Se SERED RhSe Taesae pee eaPao, oe LOE aSER Re eeRONEN Es EE RT RS REBT SySn. BBSY Sees ¢ eteee ree arco a a TE as Ee SERS ES Beet RR DEO. Seema na:SBoe BeadOR 5s Re SESE: | ua ta _8 7” "MBSRBSE eer Sa es Rene a RS ROMER URS 305ee sar CREMESapa San COCgi ee ean iS te ENR NOS OK CRUE SG SOS Se > - . .,EER SERUM ara eS SS Sean eee BS Rees Cree Leap Se SOE See SEE I IS) SU a ee ENS PERS &Teg: Se TRS SERAS Re eS ee RO: ORS & ONES easBsoxa Sebi "y as Bo SnSERS eaeSRE eh SE ERR Seg egSg Beg Reeee ee Re Sg By REE Secmeiean tS eg gears. ens Sg CRFey eeSe REOSE 7 See B. ied 2, SCS RRR n RRR ats sommes CARLES SELES TRESS JULES be EE PORES Be tes $eMSO, ee AS:1RRS sie Reg iy eae es Soe2 aa LIER EEE SLUchAES RnFis PeSSR Sa aSie SeaCRS SSSR GgSCR CRA no SE SgALR? Soe Se5 Metoee ia Siro OL aa es a ee wobec “TeSEs gREESE % eaeSB eens ageFace aeeSS Se ESET SSSR > Sts ERENCES: ROC MEREL Dt SS TLR SSLote SIE SES agectog :a.Bo SrERR ORR Ca USS UTS CERES’ Pe eee oes ete Ee YSag praSee iesche Be: EESSRO 45gEEDA, 35 Pyor:SR ISS ES ee et OS IS SI2aS nt:

a eeeeBe EEa SIS A GEE Be es Rk eseeeegeeeaeee ee eee. ee OOS, ee en AR eS Se ee 7 BE OC BOAO, SEE COROR:- Ree VOUS, TEL Tg go Be ee ae ee Be ae Sok Ea: : Py. 2% ete Rane SOD RM wa ORD SERS cg RR So sage be eames aes ae Sop RECN Sone EEBe SRS Ge eoaeeer: tS oe Soe te S$ SkmeD SE So Sp Re So ig ga SUES RES ewe SR SS ao ee ee RRR 38° Reet mper rN ee oC Se x < TRESS SSS LR OR Eg OS eg Esk AE ED “esl 2 ws aes * ARES Bie SLT Foal viet pass RS ghey 5 TR: BS + Bee 4 Soe eSSINS Bc sce See Sageies. go +s.. ee|Ee aS ORME ee >. CUNGEI Sar Seca aRaces SOMES” ~ 2. SS SAME eenEEE oe BERTIER Coen aE * "3 rs 1mete KEP2RR aesa SE , RE F TAR CIES eee” Ee. "Pa Bees oS Soe We gRee Bee raa RSL eR aSea BER Se oS Se 2"BO = bas $e oer) 3 ae ¥ PES we iat RE COE Sy Sees oS LEER $B SES SUE Se me Ree SSRN aBy ROyy BeGRE Be tg SeBea eeSe 9eee RAS RB Se poe ns.Os sess ceegirncis BR *PES. BaPCARES geste Bese Us(ASR aTE Ee=} SRR - EEE ORBeLoe 32,onteway & FR RR £75 3ote. LfBFE Pb CS 4Sections 5 SBS eee .sew tee so +. QUES SEE Ge SE “Ss Coe BEER ES Pe See EREESS SESS Scan te 8S PS . GES eee 8 ty a ote Se. TEL Se ee Sit Eee ed ees AS LEE EEE SOME: RARER CREED, Ig OR A eg ony . a Et es oN» Senge Gey RRR IROR DSRS ee Se hee 3 PS eS Ie ie AS RMS: ot STS. SND URES, RLY OCC EE SIME SIRE C. REE MED aS Se Sloe Xk gm Rhy I Sie OS Se Recie oe 7 GPE ISS OORT es Bek *4 %

Erde DSR ees eos ro (BE Be pos ae SE aS psGyIROSes AE Pees. ON” PEER eetRSAoe teaa Ee POSES eee RE gh hes oS Set SR axié RS fk EES SERRE PERN BB Spe oS hgh RIS Signe, gtiBS ee S BeCRORE a ET7BeQRS SEE DeeS SEUSS. ESEE @Rio Ug eR sn RN aR Sg SieSgt aN SRO GER SER CO Sn. $e, nO Stan voy > aa AVROBEES eee Me RRL ARSE RIES URS Acca : Ere CR ae PASeen Ben 4TIS TOG SEE CL22. Sie, WAS TSE SR See Eee eePERE See . LES. SOS SOMERS SEMI, Oma ae SR CC OLTe: RS MOREE "*:*" .,.....- Shy Soon | NSO ORM ERE Soe ES SERRE GS-2 SESE CURR Te MB Se SYRRR Soni oc ae 1 Se aa See & ¥ aeieEEX: Bee J TEESE che SS ee SR ae te MER UE EE BS oe ao cer EEE Re SOULE Bg oie : S97 Seen eee {ORS ESSE ee eed Sie, aan ies . Se pie ee 0 IIE ON Ree me URES Soh hs ghea 4 Bose} SEULERES (GEESE 7 SG See TES er eee . . . EL. a ane cee OA 2 Pe Pe OPAL 8 AY en 2SORI olURE) SETS tohSn ee 2tore lS, : ,| iBEL NOAA. meSNS ees BEE.” SoyIRS SI RE. IER IG RARE. OR aR ,.8 ee Wiiararnncaonteshecrae ROO RITEUlSenha . TOF ANS * al REBRE RaStg4x) es us7hveSRS > tb iY BO .” eR er ae oaaerrmserres OR Cy usenet Heaney _ eSBES | NE

aacenn ask RE neanentitinnnneen, < - erRR : oan [BT ele Bk Re Ea seeders : ’ ad a RT IR aise . : co r LE ” ERR POneo snwe pone os . < «Ch a ER DCT teehee Nh ee

EResck percresmnere chi aes. .ed“.PITS CIOS nett _ : tenie wes Rew 3Rwatereene, AEE aaNet peeaaaeh acetone -— ORALvn RITonRO De ancmrattcne er TTT EN LOOP RPneeneteeseneapeorteapanae RIOR OR TOC ad Te *eneiti Se, LS «AAT OURAN dn eiesentes:

ineERIE nett hee eA eN i eennnemecea ee TT a °veemna . . eer atest SR 2S Ree20 Sans gt °02, ° NANOS Sid SOG onccmmnne o00GahlRo: BawoRE HYOCORC Waa aupeascanen Talal : ” Se DOP RD. 2 SO ry owtee* Pe I DOOR OLR 2TIED IL

ead - Ng STEER OT ISL i nb ko” DRS CER reer SSeenienmemmmmneermnceme: Dy aco sere pemnmnn m eriremnanenenomeapeece tte ae Td re res Car Aca RRR‘epht NOD aa ; ean CT OEE SNC SEMREE TRae- °. ia . RASA Ra a AR DORIS oc,

Aeros art. RUN artes egos er .os _ o™ 2% at frIORLRE fee RS gg Oy pRusepeees SRR een a wakes », NP Mite etter tea .awesome . °fiOE Bed :oy ne. fort 5PEAS ORY AINE ERED ERE Tah OE aA PSG 6 iOSE °-.é:. ‘ i SEER Spe. Se4aRR eeeX By|ekae peoBese Ee Sage PRS

BEES Bee» Pea po HF a ae Sep ersByer eS ee ee Wey NSSn’. SSORE pe ae eae eee fe5ae BR gS 1hE Be 5d eae ee. §Be SeWS: Sy ee aoa So aa es “ae. BS OS | eseeoe wai FABRE 5:F Rem See eee. SS Cons. SySse,eee SRE ae. Pe a: Bs ee ot. Boot igsPE otis pete “Ry OR“ONE wo ~ee. SNE: SB aesSitter i, 1°Sec SSS sor eee MAS Pe NE Se OS | a eo eee ee : aes | le . 0 Bie: eo ~ Se Bae 3 eee ee SB co eee Gee aS gESe RES SRS Saar a2 eS ar hea ee eece an,ee “ee.eneea, fF”8 3Re. AOS Sore ee od Bee \BB _ | ees2 a: 33 Se eR nee oeSE tkPARR eee a3se aSeaeeee aSosy 2 RRs iESie Sf Saee ae Gy Seema Y Sa i Saar an i Vai O'S See » OES A ES 73 =F See a 3 eX PE ea ea > PRE. Pe TAS ty eo a * we “ae : Ry, a BSS wg Bee Sea & Pecare BOE od BR ie: “S33 a RIES. PROSE Se eS. Se) ns re gee ~ Sag SR lige > foe SS a ge Sob ot 3 By ZiaSgae % ‘ Be. |RS cysee Seeeee poe Ss 333ES aac:Leis, | > corneas a eo aecs.) oe oyes Rs3DeSee es, tewe Se eee BRS: Se et es ee ° Jae ees Oe Ooee.. ts. SE meeeee &oe

eR. ec ee ej a IRS re Od OES ae > Snr to Ties we ty we oF ee os

% - oe i ae eS Bey oe : eae. Be eae 7 "s ES Ne GON. oN tng ov SOARS NS SS ‘an SEX Biber a Seas See. o> | ORE . ;ah con Eeeis=>RRR Apr Ss.ORR SRS. SOE. Se om >3? Ss ae bs 4ee: oyaS =. TS Sea $e See SeWes eeeSSCSRaeS So: ee eee «SRR geee , . EOP Sep are Se" wot aveer ee OR ae ” Se -& @ See cee *- ee. ABS SoS 2xa iSE a7St eae if?)aSYalle OES CaS cea? Pee a.Re 7rs SZ Be Sees oc: "apes ee So Sopa > *cee: SRISetee ae ae SRS ae oS SA, SSoe Bas an 2~2.§Senne eee aeeee 3 ae rs. eg ae Seas eS a Seba ae ee eo i RECN So : i 3S Smee Ss Po. ae a S Sapa & Ss toe 3 Saas coe oS pee og Wael Se arms. + ie {Rimes 7: meee oe SS. . o, ees ae a Se Rae ee coe ae 85 fo oe i al RS - ae ee "OA, aa A 2 : He Somine te Se eer ss some ee

.: Bk 2 Ss RR2 AS. Soa oeSeSoe Ree Si cra es EF . a ee “aN ig Sa gee: mace ge P, $ eB: ae Sa pol Se re :SR eeeee ae SY‘sR ets ae Reece PS Sasa ROLES» EoRS cageae; SS ore Seem ao e3 %oeES * Seare Sook SP Say Fs PS ae See aReSo ge “9Bee 9 es tees:ae: | ia Bee BisseeS "8 Poe

i ee IG ESE AMER Sf ha I ae ere Sg RSS SRE a)? ees ees Oe Se

Sod ee oeOSs Sak:£3 BEE s ROS eae Ses oS G : Ve EESEES Be ate 8o aaree ” I ty, Sekeces Sues ¥ Be. & . ee. RSega RRR a Rl eS Aged eRCAS RS sens eS PSS ORF SEeeBY SoSRER Re RS ge ea: »~os¥ tS Me Bxeee See
RE cee

wat eS RS es oe eee Se2(SOR BRS aSSAPa I Os cree ° S* a ASE is$3Ee . SeREp BSS ESee : a aR rs ak SRS ie aE < oe BESS PS. CaeAF < SUBS a iySEE T2e'S ke 2g ScMeeerece: ae x3Ae oS$aad a s:Bas Sa SS Some: ee.SRR SE4Saeaieeiaas Ra aeay aaaoe oe-Saae toe Ba Cees SORE of Sti 4PORES. aS33 SEE, +eee, SR 5SRB $ieons, SRF BoP aoeBes S Soe ey St.ae 35tRE BES , ae 3 ea Rk igoa Bt -Se- SON Ry,gies OS oe cages ER OG RNaaa At Re Fee oe ors ” *ae ES SR Peewee Senor Be aeaes, RSSero SRS RFS IRRES RSgee y Sees. los See SSy Sentient) contin; OSYSeR SS La 3.33 [PR RS eS eeSESE ioe. ‘. Bs S 35SR ae, ES: RS ‘See ot Sage ee < RaSeman PONYRan 7gOaa wkrepeer %s"CE MRSSEER ee i rey af he pe.Pbk ‘e Me REesRRB Bo”ee ReBoye cs, *3Sees SREB 3 SSSSA Seeee SARC EN. pierSave a a ae 5 SS 3 he eeeSRSsEO RYeSST eC Be S; es Shee: 3 ae Eee 34eceeSK 1aSiioaes Seer Saree Reg 7%"Sete §. SeSRS oe abt! Bee S& Bos SE = BER e oF a Br>eeSee Memes f 2 Be & oeee So:gor SUR OSSN YrFe ae pe od See BR OS go Se BSBros oa SS x >see eaeys UES

ea) ee ef. ¢:PLZe BS Ese ce 2ar2See Be By peeeremy aeSe orese gnen+Sk Bree, V5” “Os - res Rees } $3° Se Ba oo .See ocEBS « Sees ere pad TERE od Se it Shon eeeBeg SoeeeBey Be BeCas So: POLS. ae OSs “ie emer os yo. ‘S Sore aNAy Seecses 3 Ee wee . SeSais ae 9eee SutSR emiy. p> » Sires SarReema 3 akaan oa SES Sao aRE cn Boe oo)24: oe ae Same eriemeters, ae xt) Sian Sat BePass Se BREE Re re:oe UE oeRamee See goes FERRERS ¢ee eee LS S.RE Far agS ieae.ee a oe SN SeeES EARS Beeacs “FSoe 3 |hp ee NE EERE eC Bas Mes Scere a So BERS SESie«.ents ReseSse te BER EAD SONUEEEE SEEPS. es SS, > 26s eared 2)eA See £ en ae og isthe. hs:ies Peon: saat Serene SS.eae ) Bes eam SS POO See SS LASSEOM SeLOO yee xe RRs a 1 We areSees & > Sieaeeancecone «be BEE SEES SP 3Re

F

AR DBS ES: a meee: * Wee nc”.Se7 oes EES. 5 Beene 5 toh Saas =Dae = Sane Dc Ee IERIE ie EES recs Tee PES a 2.On SSS © SeeSas Soe ERO oiScanian Oo OR ES ORES EEae: Soe BeCEE EES S'S eee LSE Raeeeeemne eae TSARBSEED See : oeEen >» Se Ss SS SCRE ORRIN | train NERD SEAS, en SERRE Sows SC.SEE es EgSR MESES ee oe oh | ER>aR SOR SRS te 1 DESDE fe| tS Tgee St OS 3 3 DEERE > oe 3 See es oeSEE eee Se geo Ma a erates NLRs ucaas canes ee SeesStwees ResOS Race Se 5 SERS DEE aren > cesar RRS SS BES SIS aeBie S: $oGaee Seerone S eee ee CEE Aa BRO aSaeaes ee Bese Sati eCGone eee BE: SRE BE&SSS SRS DEERE cAok Ea BsSeo ] eeSSR Ss Sy Gere BeeSESSOROs a pa# SE ee «< ERBeroOe SR Fe ee annii ES SRR ores 2 BEbeget SsaEe SLIME Brae att 3 8caeSaeee 3ktes Sreecanon, PSSSS aoneee a ES. oa\-as tang sisaii Sg AE ULS eranhiae ane SN COTES Suet:RRL eae &SR STSSe en te ReaEE? ene SERS SSEORR Se ERESS OE Lee VASES 2 CRE R Sex. 3S See Ss Saar or Rs iehcagtanst Sees rien

BONE Pe i See ce eae Eager Bs ieee gee Ce Se ae Bae ees ae ees 3 ot Pee ie Apogee eae

eS ke ee COS pe Me S. SEER RRS eee ee eee Beeeises $f 7 Sess 8 Saree Bee ee

ett Sauer Rn OS: ey: SESE eeePee Seems ¢ PE oe eeSas TEESE er CORRS To Eye Ea BORE StesetSeSee Sa,esSe. Eee as ee IS ne ee OS re ESS SALEaesd2 “A 2d SO ESS RES oe Bee: RE Bie S BER EUS = TEESE, SE apes SeSeperecses cee. thes SOARES Bea A i ee See US LE ca Ramee Se cee BesBae 5 ES SSE CeO by CTSA eoo., EeSune ee VoL.

eg ats Le 8 Sees Picea Re eee: , SSS ae é i ese ee es ERE es nna Tansy PP Ss Sees ee: BE eK ae Se eee ear ara eae ARS

ares Seamer can SCtiaaan USEfetBees. Somat ea een FSSBE: SLRRAS Sgegeee SETS a: Sqn tet. SSO BS Se Soren ose PE: te eens meters Sees, aes moe ey) NRE Sag te RASete Cth PRES ste LS yn een Fea Sees Lg 3 fot Bae: See gS ee 5 caeeng, ae eR eaages} Bs Re epee Sta 3 Sp Seeeee at ee Bi eteSa ean esae [Eig THEI at Raa IS Be RSta. Sea oe eaeLESBOS feeeatSee be ‘es on Nae eeDiumemaotice rere SE3S sae Se See Sas Coe DEE ge. SOBs oo YAS ENS Vaaneae Ph) SRS RS SeSa eat i ;2SBee 3 ce i ae Ego sen DOE gee baa,eee > Spies NeS Sena eters 9 Sere Tobe See oe os 3 SSA Seperate Pee ates SE Be ts Ge go --

“EBRAR ES Ng ARES TORE ES “ee rgSesnnan i > pipet©sSree Seen333 | i Sete Be SE Beco erepcas aroma tens § y Sit oe&Basses ee: RS Bae7 2. Op SS Pes de AEn Tied ee SOCCRSY Ss ins ae SR ieeeaSee ees SRE Rrebanentes: ©& Sanco Pee, meat SR 3S RUE Seeee MRLEER mf Te eo Re cee ish gee AIRS

Ren. oe thdSettee Ee ieee ae Ser fees}3 3.3 3 eeeSoeimercene ES ‘§ Rk Tes S Pies Sere2EES 333 oFseeEeSeeoSeatsaepees Soey SEES ee See BoOSUEL erceeane: "DEBS a a ee SecsBohn Reais BBR ETERSfy Rares iaeseieme. See Dg¢ Se STSes Pen 3 SURE Seeee Recess SASS RES Si ae ESE. OTCLS SS COMES | SEEN Ri gee, BREE SIRENS SRO mee oe BokeeoSSE E Sees % ¢ Soeotenes Ree Ce RS peelsTES TURNS ERE: EES SSRIS hc cones SeSEES eR BE eee SURES Borer ¢Seoh 5 a8 a$e “EE Sg SEO SS aggaeeseeCn ae sos Bit Gach: Seow ees = Eee SEE aes SS SESS. sce BOSE SEER SSRes Se2.ERPS EERE Lon REE OES pau OE Sek ETO | SEE eet Se Ree ERTS SurRS a i aertRR Eeee, £3 By SSHge gSRt PSS ESS esSS eeSoin: SS 5 aeecenen heube SS SEOPeESESREEL SC PegaS itheBSE Eos IEE See We VEER USE Ent0Sonne ne SEE a aan SEIS. SE ACTS ees3SOMERS Sst fee “OUUR gee NESeah EES 3Ree 3 oe Semcon SSSaree RB ES a eae ARR RSS wee Se eae, ESBS een SRNR ih. lg “SE gS BRE ESF SR SS SAO S BN Oe Se Saas Far SNR 3 +}. eS 20-5 Sa SRENEEN Tog Ree. bee se Sek SS TSE ode ase Sh aeBe SENS ERTae20ee7aytd ipsSoon Soe Sears Pe ST URRE ER REcas ReXSmee SSSie a ecngeen RES50SRERROR SURES eerSepa ss ae” Seams Rante:ScSee SA SEES ae: SRS acer SORBET LateCGE Be Meee Os oSane Coa ge eeeReaeae. cay RSSx Bae Saree 5tes SoG: Ree ear 2:OE Spares ee 5S Beera See SR Meas RARE ns ER

SE aeee pak. EERRRG TE Ee sje aceeeaeeeacemaiaaias ay eS PU ee nna ee eeeSe, eee ce oe eeeeaeeee eoLA BREE fo.2)Geer, Acs oA

DOSER SLSR Ee SR esos St deg TE RE Beg as ee BREE a 2 SE Bicep, Sac {See SESS Sih RN 3 SERS StS eRe 5 io. See Et Seen SER Se a cone SES, AO | CSSRBS ES LES SAE SES Re Sos Ee al ty | RRR F RSS SPE ye ue Bee k Rome. Se 2S ERES Se 3338 Sok E ES Bein & semana a OTR ~ Aes QUESTS deme “SRE Bess Pg Ee ARES ES aceon Hep Bete Sallie EBS eases EEE EEcae SeaRe Syn) URES EMSRSSoeSBES Pas cers Sr Semen a ae aeRe a ge EE Ss EES Eee. SRE TAS SRB CURLS Sihepe i VES ad “RE ws Ssee2.se Se Seer eeree $e SRN sree BEKS) YS 3 ere erEE oa nse oe,ROSE BatSOUS ULES ase ee eee Sear area: SEE Be Say Be RS BER AUS“se SASS OPE Be aa Segoe ee GSmE Pens ea eee eSieee: RNR *oSx.SiSS: FRE § SeSore saa tee oes oS 3aOS Sf Bie. 3 Sees RE EES POP(OR SSEee RRS ees So Be BESTA LETER gs. UE Rot, Sibomtmesreneten ae Pema oes SERRE i po oe ae RS BR ORR tr Res SORE RS ar SEM TRCS Sh Se hee Cae SS is Sarr es ebeopnennae oe-ct Senerana PELASE TE eee Shee, ° Soe WEE i 7 AR

ae See tee 2 gee TCR EEESEI. 2 “Ss -.. Fe>.Seheecetaes = S32 ESSE28RE 2gm3... “a pd : ee ee at8oe" See SEES ee EPS PRESETS Bas-S © See : Peo aE og LES nes Se CEES Eotee Sorento .. oD Rome gill ~ & Se oer} ne EES S See eRe ons apse ech. PeaceOuReeenter” ae ee B Sees Ss SaraofOt ee petirecuennce 4 eT a ca me oF oes es Sie:Sits Bay Sear San EES . aaa“ESE Bek Pe Egon esae Raeomn atCe1g ae Pogeane SS See” SSBS AUB Paras 3s 2: ee ime Sr StAR Neereecen STEER Ag EE: ABS Sh CSRS Li meine erection ryeScans oe es Seaeces AeEES se BO RES See eee IBSEN BoeBg ek ARPS erBost Rane, LL OE paeaant Senanonee nee emeare Rae eee aeSoMe asES SooR ees SS ERT. PEI Ig“ BS caces &Beer ETD SR SS POE x SPREE esBocce Bete eS. ae Sep oestene Sees 3SBee Se ee Bo ibaetnaatee finScie LES= 2oe ~¥. BBR oe Se, oo: See bin eeURRY $3 Bel) foegage eeecs = SIRS ee aaoar + Linger SEES tt aeSeer ot SEcee a Bae TS insaeSOR Be eh. Sees. SEO RSSBES ESE Soph. ee ey “oO par RR PEShe Coen eS TE SESE COREE 0 SERS ac es cree: an voy: f Se = eS Ea SEES |. he o ae ES Fi “SOR i Bi ae See oe: Bee eee Te etsy 3; =~ NOON See Seas Soe as > Baek Scena TSE Ag SRE AL eee Sa f 2S ‘Seana < Sete ecw ee BBE Se ee Y ge ete. SOX ORS B52 Se SER EE og a. SON “\SRBS. CS ES wing ISS ara BAO “eg Seeae: See SyDE SeXo ee aR ass shx oS eeSS AgeEBS SS. “Se peersPa esos > Sener ‘,SHR Ses SRIpeel Se “2 any oo. J :Be GeSnPane BIS SR eaeRRS Se Bien 8 RR Re BR BOURRE L SPS. ARTE ERS RRA: ENED Saar Se aN SS SeerSa sere 3RS3RsSe” oe eee: SS.5 aSe Pee SsSe es Bee aeBY Boe cote BRE ES SBRTeISVNONE BeeSh aes SRR EP Be Re: REAL Re er"3Se. ee aa esoe: 8 Sty So ee [ae Sea SR SR, 3 Sas Tela ge Rp ae RR Pc RO $: SR Ree Rs: SSS" ZB HR. Bae Bex SESE REI SRM SA ae Sere Ot piven. ccc ca 7 I aco a CRN a Reet 2 eine, aaa Se kee Be ame’ SD RR RE

ee ee coSeSee BeSagCRESS 553. 5 Ree ase geheeeoe eee SSeS: oeOR a eee Pe528 ooeee) anaewe pee Di gee eee & BRR RRS Be SE Seetee eR cee PREFvo PH RR Se a3 aM3 23. |F2B te BSS Re Pe© ee es SECERE rs: S35ERED Soeeeeanasa os a CN ae a ees ek ae eg 2 ee Pee REC. OR eo ERE ee Eh RR SS Be RS § $3. Ee SECS Beg SR SESH Sas SR Ss Se F Ro an OO Ie cr aE ed SEE SECS ae ay Beas RE og Sa SAR Se Re ae eg ERR SS

ay oe mW PweeHelens gag SP ESS ae RESo eeeShy SE ces i Oree ES EEBE SS RECON ORES cee ORES RRS USS La eeSemis: ey 7aSEeeRSbelle ek ON SA oa Btey2:ge LR aeee Se ay. rte Ser RRSRee Racal BE > a oe eee = RRS SES Lae 3.8. E ee KEae ge Bee LSSoS SB Sefie iy SaBe a 5 enSOE se BR SOR hehe as Rei a OR i. Sok ue Sree: ae:1SSg eesere Paes *oSSoe Fo ee ES Reena ¥ Pe ee SS ey SERIE a sheeBRR a BeCER SARS foe er eee ge Bae 3 S SIRoeSENames : eos : a. Sigg =e SS oeeee ee cs Oe tsSee: Coe AYRe a ASE SS Sees ooecaePRES 8SS saeoe BEEs SeeSES Re,8 RRS Be Be eS ae nee Rare ess SEES SLs BEN So Qe RE ke BERS oy eS OE og Oe SERRE. 8 See IARN lee Pag a Oe BE SO ie Re ES 3%RO pegaBOLTS oa: elas aed re a-R aeEEaRBRS ee BS Bees Sh Bes agen Re: ¥ Ae SS eeaSp SSRAUABS Ba Bee Cok ean a$SSG Os ,, Oyeee a coal a : . fa SERIE BR SR ER BRS S Sit Se SRS oy ory: aan Soe eo NN oR eS BE RB: REE U7 ge SOE NE Mogg aR. te SRR ee a a :. > ce ete Soca Se. a ae. eee Re aR. RED See Cy? SP Sarg SOr-% BP Raf Sena N -- R orate eg SRA ROIS Aa. Nn Nias en. con ae Pg Sie Re RE es. coe Bees: ic os

se : ksa Re aes 8SESS eo S38Be SORES BE Bie PO. Be.i HS BB Cg eS)See so RS $3 SRP MefessBH a ceSF BESE eeoe a ge GIS SO ORNS assis: ReeEN ee Scot ae Be:SO 3 e.Rc SBZee SeoSe eeeeet TRE 5 ee i RreeBBR Ea barBgteeo te Tne ae, RR IE ee OA SS se BRBeSS aeees EON AS IER ERE et ees : Bp aa esSee % Semronden 5 58Se Sr SR Be ae ee Re SS Bs 2Be SeegSot a SRE eeeaoa BAeene, Be eeSe eeeRe PERRI ee rs OE Rat eR Bane ae a aeEae See ieFe aePou Le 3 E eR)gealSAOIE AER SEE a ea TERE 4 a2iaSes aesROG ae ae SS CR CSsare: eaeo ea eee

Y eee SERS ER ceRc.aagaretts Ne oo: SSE EERE. BAS §ae: Sas ; a ©iS5 eZee NESie SeeReSeet Cs a eo $93 eg efTeN Ei SiO COTE 8Baa3% $bSeok 43eeSa eeoeaeee 8 ae ac Sa a SRRR Ra Paee oe od 4S Soa 1 Be Sree 22wrES Be APsae RE SO eR Se Si eetGar 2 ch eee hemes STORRS 35 oe ee Bid :Ce af iPecan aay . ap PRESS RS eS ReBs eae eee SMR: San ee:7Ree Sts: ey BERR & Santos he Be aSGN a SR To Se Be. Re Sea ee IE Steet7a SB SEReeearnee FRR ah Sh BonarOREN SERRE RRSo KeanNES 8 er Se 8 ey eo iS aaa eae Ks ereES SS Beae eeeie “a Se BS 3ae

2 eeSet: SLR Ce RRmy ESRea “RSS AOR RRoe a RS SSS RRS oe cm ge +2 33One BBaeFY SoeSoe Sam ootSEAas Se Baie #s Br SP RED os 78 acsaes eM aaa Seca: 3: See SS gea 5B SRS eeae 3 RS 3SSapae aa tie Spee eeeae teSi,Sas Beeee. Boo BeRE es ea RReh Se: ES SSBRS ES ROR eas ShSS Se oRSee ee ae Sa. BS: Seeneaeee, 5Soe Os.eeSRS Re 848Se SS...Bee Se 0 Bee Be ioe Re. eeBES eS & SSP YEoe BeER BR eS. Eesociriansese Be ERAS PN, 1 POC Sead et ao “ORS Sines.SS aeae: CCSR” ass re abit au) a

ae: See eee See.Bes22Far8eae a eeBagoe Meee See eeSiei AES IESG Care NS RS eReget eee PES: Sei eae, SARS 8 Rae cage Ze a ee Te BS Ss pe 3 ee ee eek SR eee oe ae ea Sees site 7p Hed ee ieee: See ee ee Bor ee Rg oRSe LS ie

BBY: . SS a. ae RE sok es gs ks: Se A Se Be tae ees eee Pe Seg 3 SE oS TES BS ee See Se ke OR Be Ee ae if ae See eee 9 Sega. Bly gee Sen AN Ne ON SS RE «SR ee eS og eR Re: BRS: BH Bit Bae we Be Bek UR EE SRR SE ees ROE a Seats SS CRORE SUE «A fe: Be SR Se es RE ee ee eee

| oS Se o a a RaREE ert es Se aeeae. FS See Re ie 3RR ae ae SS ae Eee1 BSR Re SSe Ee ae BS:eeeSBie GeTe eesaR ROE ae Rs EASAO DUS Be Se eae ae oe Re ae eee Se RR OgOF § SC RS; ae, 3) SS SARE SSReoeRES Sa aBes ae5Pa en te BS BeBe FBai Be|ee: Sea SsSR ee Sak SRE) eae Se sae ea haeaeS|aeSn eee eaeBee. eae BR Re BR ee MOE BSS RES ER 8ROR aes RESUS Ee Regis Soe eee Re aeS Be 2 an ER Sess23H. A hhVEY Bx OeBoe Be Ke BB OR BS Roe a asRRR pete sa US BRA RS.3a RS OMRe as PERSE SeaoP oyRaed See Sa5)ERR TieSIO Sith 8 OR eS Saag Rae TCR aes eee Be Rae ee Se a Soe Be 7See if FES PRESSE a eeser eesom ee ee es ob e; Se Soe SE&1S SE Re a ee ee SA Be SR OOM BSReae SN Sek eens SRR: BS ER Bee Aerosae Sumas Sasee oe eee See eC SeeeeBeeae Pe Te x - ee

oe iSe RE 2 reScOE Oa ero See oeeeBa BeaRRS Benoe FBS St Nie 3 Sees Sas ee.Bees ee VR ee ney SeeSRaeaEES ee ¥: SeSe : oe ee ax: Se gE: ee aesea 8S TSR SaasRS aes Re SE BRES SRS ae Be RE FE aieont OR 5 eeaes SR Te PR Be MEBa RRCee SOBESe Ce RY SieES aaxes eee ee 2Sepa Seas ee See: RRS anes APsSee - “3 BSSgSS eePR See Be rere’SsEee See oe seen aS See 3Serie repeitrema 4 ee BE aE eeeens: eons RR ee RRs a se Sr SEBS BSaa Re RR:re SRS Re gS ietsSe ae SS ASERR Se eS:Ce SRE gy,ea PRES oad na Be Soca ee See secs“ ae wo aeae aeSS: ae 4, See keRe-a .«RE a iee . :Bet q =RE - RR : 1BRE i ] sDeBe s Seeks: ‘ et: See SMS R24 o>: esFS es SS as Bee aS eeYeere = ee Pntegape: ae DRE Se eo a Be ee aeg aRBS peeco SES Ee Sf SS Be 3 geSee EkeosROE Stee ek SR RS Sone Sct tae aSacer Rae Soe zs eae ae 3Ee Saree soc EESRE RR oe

ae oe Soe 5 See Reeve ck: Se Re Se ee 3 Bee Be Soe See tee a: eae oe? ae eee SE A oe Gk Geen Bay ; ae 2 eet See Bite BS SRY Ceeaa. Bie CHEE Fe SER a RR Se AER SRS RS Se nae 4 Be Sats BPS Rea SSeS Sat Sie Res oes BS. Be Ra SR ooo ae Rte ie Oe tare RES a ac re ES RRs BOR aS oe Pe SRR: ES a ag RRS Sa Be CEE o . @ ee Be. ee ae BER SCR: SSE Pie SR SOR e. BSD BR BS. PIER Ses Dae te RNS Pa RON a Re ese se Reo eeos Sp. & PS > eae SR Oe RO SE BS». Seema. Sie Daeg RS: Rs CO a BRR Sc RNa Se Sa Se OR aR See lear ane: Paras rR Re St eS ES SF Se KS RES: SB tre ee toot $3 Seek Sivas Sos me Hons oe PER ARR Se Sh a SSS RS Se SS BRE Sere Seoaowee Se

— ee ARR BRE SaES Rae Sar Bo SSS Rie ee ea BBS SR PRES SEES: 3ee:SRA RS, sa 53SPR ete BE 5 aN RE Seg BraeBs eis eee oe- Reeaaes a a a orem , osmee | oSeesek ae Rasae 2 ee RS 5OS MEAS SagSear BS BRS aesAD GesSE SRR: cL Se eet Se FS ESPES Spee Beat sarNn eeeSe Sy ee ” SRE. eee Se ee oSeeaegs ge EN. RRSee: eae Oy‘SSS RaeSS NBtae ERS SZeeEe RE SE SRE gO AER ESE eee we Bi“Back. it 5 Sentry” Se.Sipe Sse.: Beas eae ioe a Seeee eee Bo. SO SN AR RR os ao. rs BeBae ee Bs Faster bane ERS ERBR Ce Shee RESBo RS SEO Pe Se OEaaa ee SemeeeeeB -Beas ae tae ee eee Re rie eae, OR “ak, 33 Bias 3 SEES RES $328 os SEE Ce DRS BES RN INS: B83 eaeen eps Sosa we ae Be ge. Bee Se oseeeSie eeOsaaSs Rome. Pa Re 4 iRE.aeRES eae RES i SG Rage 3 Ss RS hse yea SSeS oaBae oe SRS ERRSos cei a Sa SSPEaon > -SaeRE Se ES a RR2SRS Se Ree ae apes: lt ae BS RBet oe be S:. SeSBE Se at BSSAS sods SR Sis aepean Sa oe SOR RROSera Sg gcse | Se Bt ESSE Ee: aSee Be Been oe ieee.” Hea See Boomerang IDS COR wees [RRENR. 4 LS RR, OR 5 RRR. Re. BRS LRT Be See Be. S3 Be. Se-So' Bo SR BS SEES SRS SSBees 5 S54 Fe Sie 2ROR Se Saks = et Pesgarces Bee ae WES ad RRSBaga ES ReES ae seaes fe eee eee See Soa Sas“Re ELSRK RRRSASeARRAS < SEs MR SsOY, EASY eee Rae REieoe -e RCoe Sonne ot ae ttSES peace S03 Secf8g

ae BR es creer aE ee Po PB SeRE ine ens RESeteee cane S a RE SeSet BS ed ae Se ee ees ESE ; oe eeFRC a Sie Sa rare Se: nfs oe RSBee BE ache & Se ae He “4.eg 2 a oy sere a RR BRE BREE Reecas 58Sais BE¥SS Rae a SES Richogaera Bee Sere oa SBSeo: eK Sane ee ee"RS SRR «Ree tian Eyaeee ae SSSRR Beene se San hota ESSRID kaa: eeeae 5 eee, See ae -.Re wae So - See SeeBee ORS. Se«eS ea ae Reef BeceRY SBSee Se ERE RLteEE BySot pe Ghee ROE OEE. oS IY 5OOS SEERSRO SS Ss eS eS moa.Sat Beare

° eee 5 ROS SSR: ee UL SBR oe See as Case. "SRRRNS RESeR pe:RRO ok : are Re IS = Se ASRS 3 ee Sd Sak eS) NSaoe pg ee dente are te ccn a Renee Se ee SeSram a Se eaieeee: “-Seieoaee. oe BS Bae: TERS S 4PRG Bw + Seen Sing ae RRO BRWE ee 3S ORE PRBR PRE 3SAnes SRTSSSSSSwe: BS Sat % Sim siteSeed oe Geeta OC eeea SN “5 Scales SSuhooe S Bec Ba E aR: a SE

BR ne a -SNES ae 5S BoRRR > SR aeSS ceNeeannaee, « * See:Sean Pee OR a Yaeee EE og “3 SBDSa SB: ae BeeSs SS Ses oe aS 3: 3 oeSe a soeanesean See ees Srecneneten ene Se ali 9S ee Bs SERS Be Se Sapo asa. Es$¥aROS: &S Sie SSS aeSS SS bees eeBe —Wes aeee&bo a BS 44 Sea Cees "SRR |. eee nesBanat SECTSeis TaoRememaias "RSRRS oe 2 SRR ARS Co. ERY a NRE Sa BS S Sees 2 BS ESBS MRD es tiatateseresin SEBR SEES Sheena se oeSee BGSee BSUt eas oe E oga _ RON | eeSSS Bae Be: | deaeae: “Sanne GeSx:ASE | SRR SD RE SRneeeeBebe SEOs Seeks ie RSELeite eS Re Sg _ ae

eae eS +. RRR SERS FEES. BERS eeen ReneS. * . SARI Bo OS MRaRRS: aes: aES ORE ERRE BS Se & cian Bee oe SRS oe RISSee Soe eee Rahs Caen 2 CoN PS RS Oe TRO ST SRR Se Se Se. eas eaeBy. Be Seat Scares ges 2ERR: >.BR RR ARR tgSe ae oo aay SES EEE: Peas Oneaeees

RR Se SORE Ser LRNcsRNC oR Nah BRS cere SCAN nat oa ee MEE R RRRE eran SS SeET BEGEER ER Se So SeooEeeeea ee pr SESSA SR ORR RR ee EE SEE es RS BeeNees NE SO EE Ae ESS3 EAA RAS ee aORR ES RARER tte Sana Ree NO eanSS: Stent SOS EEo_o RS aaR “EEEsah tg ESS Pee Be BS ees Beene SRNR aOR SS ESTEAR SRS Ey ae “AS ae Peo eSEERE. Ee hagSeBeEEE SLEc2EeRica SSRs SPER SEOo ERR ENC

tec Be: 2e8 Bo ee Be OR oy Re ee Bees ESSN ROCA i EERO Se eS, EE SES eo We a gE Es ER es

ar as Poe ie See RE Rr ae NT OOSIRS RESERA IR GUN GRD TE RY SeXO ERE BROS 28TooUe SeeSeas Feeie tsOE Rg Se RSRRSRRR ge oe Er 7ae CREEL OEE See Saree ees So Be BOE IOUS SIMON 8 8 RRC ie ECO OR RE Sn BORER See RRR Ot er ae DEES BS ae Cece ee ae AERA RO eo eR NC SON FERRE i eh | CORR ESE Seg REE ESAS SESE ESTER SoBes Sg eos oaRR SAS REN ieDSS RRR fe So Sa PETS IDRS RAL ORR enSade MELON ED AN NE oT aN ROD ERCP SRE NO SA RRS 1 gee RRR SaeRR aeme SER ae SRS SER NER=Ge AS ooee eead gt SNS ER SERE Seer tea Seren SERN BRL eee SES Rs RE RR Re TE AREE! aE Samco ©ER tess SCRE SOE he SSIES SAA ; SSeS ooaeReag ONO R BRE ONES Bye ORM Sapaata NeeRe Ren CR tna RT ion RecSR RRRRR UNERO etree hie nee MES SSE FatsIESE CREE USB SR ng a EEE CELINE IESES SEERO oS: eo hE SEE ESE ER RR ee SRNR eR SANS RC OER ERS RESINS ES RBS oo ROE RUE URSA oes Mak Rsee es RE Ra SR“ fe REE EEEEe SESS

Sehomce Serene or See amen Sur ARESRS aL Pa RORY Sen os Meaney eee PAREN NARa CeO SU pe NR DeaiNO SC BEC SOOT CeeSee EEELoner ES Se Soe PT US ESS OePah $2ee EEE ESS ER oeoo Vn sag ght fey TREE SEES eS SSS Ra PEC SRIRAM N PERE n SE ee 2 eee CRS ESREEDS ee GARI. Gt Shoe CECE RE SE oeents SSeySo [SEs OES Be3 Sis Soe SER Oo eT ee CREE eeLALIS Reaok Se oe Eh SES ee SE oe Se obBe Boas Ree See oy UREN REE SEES SePRON SSeS a rea BRR UNG oie Ses REE AC er ERNY EToy RNS ES NC esRT EGR 2 ERROR oe as Se OS EEBa BOER GREE Dneae ES ER gE Ok SR Seckige CeSocnie 55 ca SAS an athe See ae a ois BxSSO Sie BES RS Teo: DEER goSEO aeOR RNS 2ROSE oe eeBES ORE EP BBE EET ee Pee eeem ear ey: cainMe San Sears oe BROT RUN aN SEO RC PRR Nr one eae PRINS SoRN AMES SesAE GEE Ee nh2sSeOE EeAEE ete cere “, Esaee a eee SRE SOR MRSA it+Sirens CME RRR DTse Ses NPS OREO re eae S OS ROOENC, SPRN RRNA Gog eee aoeSO Se iPERE REE Eg SERGE SEN WEEE sD segs Lo ee Bae Be RS renee Seren BRaeee SG ROR OIRO RE ES SRR SAU EES EGE RES SE Ee Ue Se Rg BE “EES esNema Beye 3Bren ES BOER SREDCN RRC RO eae BiRD EEACCA SERIES AEE Soe Re Re aro: ER PL ERES ERE OSE a CSS ODS eee SMRbpney rae Oeteat SE ST LC ane RCO BKenNE REE SERED Cae 3Due REORDER RE Oe SONA «V2 BRINISOE S ERE SARS RAE Ue SARE Re heRR Repn WOR EER ieee OER & sore ee ot Ree Reeuints Bia Berens SESE EN CER 2 IMME AD ROE RE Se RR ea Ee ha ECR SE ES a Ege Ee SACRE EES SEES Se oS EN te CR Sa SNS Ue ee Ra NUON SN RA ORS 35 SM EE ee as ee te ee en MR Sy (oe ESE us JE EB RRS CEES EAS Sees pees ce SON AR ic sR Ae ROR AON ARRON CRE RCRR GS ORY AN 52 NCR SR OR SS Se See RE SE HSE SR Se eg res Oe ig SRE Se RSE VE | ERS TST RSSSS SEER Sco Re eeSEAS ote ameaS SaAS = BRT oR RSS OU BE SNS RNS URSES ORGSoe 2S “gene UR eeeEE eeeSf TNS CY SESS SSeS EES GRD TTOo TE,FREES Rg SE SRS REISE Be ee Bee RAR OO SN ON aONE a ee RR Se PSS UR Soa aSOee SERENE BROOMS or atic 23K BUD Se Co NS ROL ROR SO ROC DEORE NSS RES CS SR ABS EN LRN Tee: SRR RE RD Sea San gENT REN Bo SRO ROY SRS POTEET EEME ESS EES TOBR CBRE “USSie a So Racer Bs EE: Bee RN oe SRN Nana SRSA ORES RE Sone Seas PE SRA TELE TR es ORE Saas SORRY A RR aT Rae oe fran eon y POE Se EE REE aaaD a MRSS SSSR SSA SOae SRO SN OR Reason SEN Oyo SEEK BEN ACR 35 Aap Re RRUS Ie Oe OR SY SS Se RE OE DoeRR HOSEN s. 3Set SRRe SO ho 9 SnSa aS Aig es Sena ar DRS hen ESE RRR SS DE SR Sa DRS Site heCOS US ReICR Rese URS aL SS NPN POS ae BER RE Tih, “Sig BsaSoa See enOe SRS eeBRN ie SAR OER Rice aeons SOONoeSCR SeBeaeish a CSR ie eaUe eaeapa BSagen ROREER I Se SO Re Rig ES ee OS RS SSURES RENN.LeIGEs

Ree aEaEE ORE CNSR ARNEL SitISRN SU) MALE 7eRe CNS SL SNS . S OR, -. msRRS DA ME aoeDORR St . eCON A Se: OoRN ir ise RRS aSE DIZ SO SEIN 7.2 tea EOESOT, SeJPRS SO ES “US eS pene ReneS eptccetn Soe LORPRE NE RS SR ae aS oa RR NO RIN NN ey REED, SS EER MRR SasRS SEN SSO EME CCE SREY OUR 7: Eggagerc Sy SESE Teh SG SA es eg cera“Se ROSSER PERRI AN NEE SeSERS SRR BROS FES eee TaSLR ReSeaR BeENC [Els Ute, Ree 0)SO REE Scag nok S SESE ean SeeME OSS SES oe Se > Eg BPRS RR SEG SEER SeSe Oye TEES EEE RETae | ERE £8Coe “ONPE SOs eet BS ae ReBe ey bac ME CR RCN ONaatis RS eeoe BRCORN Sara Onan SRORaS RR ES IRR EE SOOSEE SES ACR MRSCoe SOE EROS 2 BSey Osee ERTS 2 En Chee SamsES MDa TD EEISSRE ESSE as BEARS RN RES ER Sy Se RE SRSA ONG ROR A OLD NR a PRE RORY St Be ON ORE RR ER CRON BEE Bis Sea REY SD SoS eA Sa SS Joon RB SRS

me alee tare eer eR es BOS ON SS ee Shots wae SS ae ee pee te ee RR OSE GE oP BS

EOE aSanat So Fe RS SR SONS ORR NY et Re REDON ALgdEE GS TNE PENN SRS ke RS RE TE Ss RR RR ooae ioe te Sn ectees atBRS Sr etaR eee ROLES SASS SRO NOR SE ECR a ae BEES SEES SERRA RR 1eB PES. aeEB bapee ‘ eee I On: eeONO eeRRS SRE Mon Re ESF ORR SNE SSREE ik RAE Seog ng Bite aetna REEE OEea SEES ERSE ago oART ERSEU ENSes Oo Te TAR REELS GEESE ER RE RE Se SON ean See Ue RSS SORE chen SNR SRE ST RSE Se AEN DY ay REMC RER TRS SOLE RE So ESTES SC Sa pbs cer 2 ORES Re OS RR

ChORS SOMERS Ke areR RRR ECENNN a te Re Sepia BNR ee PON SRS OTRAS Rie oki a asySS hice NR DIR De RRC SRE Ss BRE Ga ITRE RR Brg no SREE UTS eStats:gS gigi See 8TS Seeg SEES ee BeeI OR eae ySSSe No ee eR 3 RA PNeeey RE se SRiCOTS Oe ea SSR Oa RC SRae CRESS SRE ESSE a ae CORRE US SRS SULAUESE ESE eae 5 eR nS SREP Ae Mena Neh PRE REESE OeSee eR Seme oeSISSE Pes: Poe Bee SSR Esan eeSo Soe 7tg.BERR se eee TSUESESRES SEES LSU DRS Se BS ee ES RE Remuera Ns SERN INS NGSEG RRR SR ag a eekTae OR EA a ROG RRS PERSE E Eh RE SoeSR a ERE OSONES. ey USER>es SEES Hh HEE gCegnang di nsSSE SEES EEE RRS eseRRO dearer c ntOC eROR SrSN Sa SOC SSBeene SCEoe RES RES, FEI, OYE ag SS SEE SSS oeSR ee. TS BES EES RSS 2 ee SRC Saat ee YEN RRND LORRI ORO IS RS NERS SYSEER SRO ORES EEGR EO SUCRE ERES of ORE Ces Seren RO a SEER OR EYSt MRS CE RIC Sage.OSS SE OR ER RS Bee SORES PS ee eee Sreesanth Se, Es POSS AN SS eeORR SERS Stes ROR aS ae DER ggatBy BERR SSgee SRN ea“Oo RR SRLS RRC CERES RLS ES RS ee EN eitgnapercgente tc nahin COs CES RAD N At RENEE BSR AS aN SEK SS Sek te ease ike Soares PERS ee Bes ONSITE CORO SHERI ONS LR: MEN SENN PE ORR ng. UE ee 2 SRR EES SR Ge ea ee Rene Se ES eeEE Sree St A Rese Re ea REE Ssneek AO ERLE SB SR RsEEES aRRORME St CUE SERRE SRS CEe SSRNESEE SyResse Sores SESE BRR Se EAR a ORE RA SRR ugRUE agSe aaDe Sri SRESR RE RS Baeeo aeaaa SBE Ee TREES SR) SEPES RLS REge. pee meas eee eee ee ae coeRE aac oan Sie aeRO BREN R eta ORO SY aethe SS eecaer’ SEnes Cae SSRN Oe EE GRMN ES SRE PURINE ERE eg see tasetet caso ee SUN Soest RRR SARS SSCRS ROSE SRS ae oR CE SSIS Se SRSea eeON SERS TES ORR, SLSR SETS Pe RRS EPS SEARS herece ec "CoE SESE ee ae SSN ans Se Ean oe CARTCRE sas seen easSOE Pa: Pa RS Aine REeeSARIS Re SETSEE peSORE. EneUoSoe RAE MES eRMRRTSS Re REE

DSA SLU LET Ss ic eae Se eae eee Spe Be ace aPERE ORTON ES ON BS SNUBS NSSoe S SING SP Se SGA Se Rt RRS SIO SSSI: Og Un SP AY ERD FEROS SBE A SRRRE SE OEE CR SSE SO Se SEES BS SESE SES YS SeSERS apa RR Re Ng eo:EEN PEE ee ee SEES Bes Seen aSES SERRE aeRES PORE RE PUTO eg SERS EER SaSS aeSERS eens eg CERISE SESS EOE REE, SESS SUS SES LER CESSES SSE fPIC OSES SSeS CHE SUSE EE Eee Stee ERE BEE Egg Oe RSENS. -SS OES, EE OOD SRG EUS GCESRESESS Sc is SEES REE eee is Baits son Souge SNES SANE ORESee RONEN S SOOO SRRSE SREB CE RR 4 OLVERA RES SRR SEL EN SRR IGMBS oo AcaRR Ee 23

wo ULMIEEE EEN BIS Sep LASS gee Pekan) SESE RI SUUST TERE SEES Berit Rien SonesSESUE ESS ToSS ReCREE Seeciee ‘ TREES SERS. CERT RS COUN ng SSCRI is SES COREE TRhoo SRBRE 2 ag UA SEDER ONS SoSenne SOON IS SOE SSSR SRAS BR CEiyERE RE SRE T Sge EREGS Sa soa ES ot

OSSD ADSSE ELE AES EER et ESS HES AUR SESE CUE ES Heme PNT tea PSES Bae Ae SREP EE: Set Ree SRO SSee nC REET sf REE ene Sy Sees ON") COREY Sas ee Less Ba BO GR ED SE OES ee TEESE RIS SS ERD SERRE Tat ERE See eee ge boas Ses Rss SRE. Se SEE ARSE SER SURLORE CREE ne gn SE, EE SDS With SE: IME ete phe: SORES Sc EUS TYEE Se TS Beichuaa iis Sona ERR EROS SES: a cee San SEO ane SRS ae meats age = ee RO AC 3 1 SOR” aa iio: Ss SE Lage ne

fo OSE BEY SSSute SSCUetne Eh IEEE ATES Rien oats Bearise ReeSET ee Sk eeas + CARERS, IR et OE SEARO RR SRS ReEEEe OS RST EUS DAD MhPORE Reserpine Samar SSoS So ERi"Ee RS ee aCRESS “TRESS SES Loh OALSe UDes” 2 SRSA SEES Sn EEeReece Se a, RUoncm oe ae OSS SSLea a Oa Semen CEP gEESS WO ORR DOS SESE SESSA ESS ESE SP EES SSBEDTIC GS os SE 00 ESE. Tho JUS CRE LS EA Es Eee OEE oR a SR RCS RNS ZB ONICRRO< MR SRRRLELURE wR PES

oS CUE SS EEE SRSine Dee Eanes NS SONS URES eRSERETO SE Boe ee ee SERRS yeRRR ere Soe BN Soe ERE STS SAAEE ee Bogie AE-ESSES SUEEMER CSUSERS ESBE PEsEPS gig ES OUEST) Leth JERE SES SSE Spgs eee ee cee SEESSE EES ae aCEREUS SR ERASE TEES » RBS6OR SE LeeCOE ar SOR 0 0 URStng ISIE LSS RSE ESESE ACES ER eee SERRE ee TR ee SERRE SRS a RE SEES Sakeues Age PE

OOM EEE ADORE IE WS beSSS De ATE OST RIGS ge igiechaees We CER nak SESE RR RR RE SR Secs USELS SEES Seaeeaaierse RE Rs R ee ceeBen nePES ee OR SE ESE BUESE DununSs pelag Oo eS Seiichi UNASee SEE PER ees BR SeeeSU SRSEAS ERRaESos ce ee oeS EES SRR 0 gio’ PESRn: Lo asE RRC A ge nets SEE tent pose Wt, te Mie LONDEN SESS net ep ieee ee Bocsnpsniens a Seopa SSE: Peet eae Be I RE RR SIS TSE SESE EEE PRR St LOS AR et = ES EE LET NS SERS WSLS TASES SEE Sn at IS a we bo, be Tee REPS SRE epee SE a erarins meee BecSree. PSSA LeSt Rag ee ee “BL UBee SMeSS NE SHERI SeUSBMIS af in yt TL feeTR, . osEi, Booed 1 SESS EcEESESS eaRe ERReORR SEER eeeSN aieRae cg REC Ne Ne coIEinSE cinEsTe aa02 1 1, SSR Sehye oa

: poo ESE toe BASU ES Bo Soe RAP HER AtaR SS aoe ony Nap eke he eS ee eg Sor Sena: ee RRS ee A is TURES 336 oe ° RRA RANT Ai aa eae SLRS Rc SePESSSR MSRSusg SNE Ugh 9 fe SS Ss, eee hee PAERUSS LEE ae SR SSS Se oe SSeeeeRON CSREES etc oS SR ee ee USES ui Sle LSE le AESURES ISI i Se onNePS SES BRED Sa ge eee ON, -o SS SSS aeoS RS2ER O? 2SEE UE Cox See oo SReee Se. Eire oe FOOSE NU LLHERE: IESea oSRees ESSERE SE eeSERRE: ee Saari es Aomer Parone ZeeRRR 3 SES RR SS ge Meee Sa "ERED Oe SE SoS ee, WU ye th DURE ey OE CEE RR ReEE SR oonee esSRE cat ee Oeeha ES ats eS ee eeESR ee VEER SSE SUE RSE S cnuny Ti A, CLASS Ss USERS Se Re a CS St ROSES ES ER SS SS oo ootRS cosCR ROSS WED CREE EUs ER ae Bos SO ES OES ON PSs as PROSE 0 CSU Ha ee ESS eR ee a RecoReT GOs 0S. 3: 5 Sees Sie eR RES Ba ee Se Soe “3

22 EEOC ORRSSES SE Rn ESSGAGS Ss LOSDELUS < URE SSRs aRaa Se SS a SRRR a one oeOo BRS eyee$a oor SSSse.ee SR Bah) RO Se ee Se BES CEERI ESE IESUL eS eSIrSSS RR or SS a RS Sk eerie RSE SS BgOD Rees CUUISEEISIRIS LDS OSIMELCInD Sig. cE COSSORERA SRO O oe R ARE SE pcg aeEA ee ge TRESS 20D2 TEER Gis, SUPE SSERDL tee: IRD AIS IOUS EER eg aa ae 3 RSSTe: Oe RRMA SESE geON g £3 Ba RTE SC Rope, BogeSe STSSSR Re Se fe Seg. ee BGs QE EAERR SL na OR Sh Ee a SSR ORR ROCA SRR ie SoS RNa Re Ss 2 Serene aes 8 88 eae Sn SUES age SE Spans Stay ee a ESS

ts EES ERRRS Se Se ee ER ESCH Se GEES DDUSIP tein SEWUE Ue Ei chESSE SSIS LESS SA RRR aa aes. PRR RN CS. oS* SRM 2 SeyRCN are CC ORNS SroSRRR 0. o> 5 ee SnRe aeEES kon PE & SRN See UNESP SSO OREata SRaeRe CAS,

PPE Seta stTMI Spon meet oo. AaSuge eece Pea Re Sa 233 ogg BoSE TAB Sas BaOe Bee 0 See RY ¥“phic: : ° tor Aha SSA >as 02ce OR a Lies Mae RMON nee. RL oeeS gee eea SF eeRees OR SRE RR EE, SE gee ag ce Soot RB B Sf SR Se :: ‘ae tooth ; eee 2 BOE ae (Aeir he yo Sen Sh ES Lae REE “Sas eegee igee OB ROT OER ee 3e 28 Rs Loe at Es baseeee POT Ah 3 oes See DENSE SEAL SESE TE AUS SEES eeeee aaaRee SeORES Uh. CSAS A Seb eeOR igaet SRT RE PA e SS Seg eT ge Re ms, aR nwlwy ooFTA ROMER eee iS PLA |EP ISSR ASSES UT SS EEeS eeae PE OO a SiGe aOE RE tetES Sg TpRete OS Base men seg secre 3 ee ae PRE oo hE OR ne See i RR A RE RR Sy Ce 5 RE et 2 SMM ef SOE RRA eee USES iS iiie SSE U PR ce SRS RD RS Ae de rele gy A BE EL pe ME gS ek H SEO BRE Po .Pe Swe BEDUS edoSeaTag PRC SERRE ReCEL SSDP ca OUR RS SERRE SPER PRRG, OaSR POSE OOS PN BOx .EC TE AES SOO ee a etn wiene Be.MEONY TET, ELOISE GAPSSe TTD SEER OSES EET aEER PROSIES ODIO ‘ ~ SENSES

1 { me 1 ] l ° e

2 S22, I Yenis ] J ure ° ) interior O e nave Begun I221

EER eg perenne eras on nan cae kta Co ERROR RIS Pe VERTIS S oNnape REO SAR SRO SORT, ca ait,=of,Reo dlamimmumaiae ga, cast 5BRSOROS ORES SON ee aR TS PR eeieof SN ee Soe 2.Peoo ee te oa as nate eden it oe angites atitegtee .

Be ioRRR oo BRR ie TOE, OES Se Ses ORs e SRR ONS 500”sD OE esRES SeePNY, RON ROR EEN SR Een os Sor PES SEEN pe. 1dFO Oe ROA asRO Ss a Mr Eee es5See eN RESO CRA RRR.UN Seeee SiN A. SE Roi eR ee RIeeRRNCeat ARS So One aSSRN to SEA AER eeeSOROS OY ON oo. a ot QR Bele SNA: Sr leate .ill : sats PS Nee CaRETRO a BaP ee Peep) ESS

Ber BeOURO gs ag? Se Lee Pps aeRRO? SS. ke CR GRE ESET aeESSRe aeESRRS aerate BAe ieas SL SOS rates TL SR SOSgo Sc aR SRR Ra Ora BeesERP | ERB Ree OR, PETE ESPNS INASTR EESONS OM eect LS PRY SORE OS a. SeSr agTTL SESE osSIS see NSS eR 2 ORDERS 7c ,*a. 22iaaSc eo” Toor OE RES ee SE se“PSS Seed ESEh ate.

BSCR bo «26Pata ROM Oana E SE SR EN TOROS TERN ARG a SO NEOR Die . S| RRM eee ee sn) ing ORR : ‘. ne. SRS ce geet le JI" 7 ade SSS aaaa Reo SRMca ORS a te IR GFag seAaa epgde. SM SateRr: peeks. G75 Rise Sis einai MD -Iaoo LEMAGESEE aeSARS tee aa PERRET Re a poe See RE RE SAS ES aPES BRP ROO Se: hr’ ae ie eS Poe BecLeluhs Mi, iiscL tia wt 7 OMG ro ONES, AROD ESEat Poe, T7539 RES SeerSaeee nsee PORES SORe SRE RG eS SS aS ONCE RS Si, Bae Sakapite COsee AE". SO SEER anSe. SANS :SS te= RET aga ey aS-a«hg 7) SRR BAS

Ramee ss RiSEBR RRS RO seCSG Cac SRE RCS ER SR eS i so 2 RR RRe Ren Oe AES Bs ©TERR oh RRR eee tence So Ee onion ERSIRMN BS BeRE: aesBS aeRG*ARP Sr can 7 Ifos eteSS eae Spt BE SESS Ae . eR Lass Bee FAS ROR IRAve eR Pa RRR Caegett eSSRS MO) Dace 2an ee- _Se RSs ooh ON RD eg Mefoe FO weytoa a1soNGS on? SSR Sea PetaSaSAREE OeUSO eS SE EI Be EE RRR 7° eisersere SPR Soa . Mt RRR ch atte ET SSeS ectsDae pee ae ee ne Rescate reBeatie ieOionOT*aUe Tea ns "aERS

ERs SsSie hare APe FaSacer ge Ege oe RBS RIT Bo 2a eS weee TRWERE i Sec eS eS ee eeeeee BRSisee raeTRAE CE oe BRO EMER: a eee Sy.RR Sa TT

SEAS RE a BES Rr eesco at a Se SOS neck goee S| Bes. 52 Ger, aa Rca settee ee. CRESS SOS ie a 25. RBC 08 SoS a an «1 SREB SR ERS aera Ea eae fk . wos LE BRE. Laer BEERS See ee” SERS Sie OUNCE aBSS LER or Mee te SBE sWARS, ae ORL Bee* .eee oeRES | CER OEE Eon enoSe aes ame SAinSees: RRS CCAR ROME SCE etaMEMES ES SgANan EE ARR Ore Scart AEST ROR SO TEwater Sa eeecd ESSh. ae : CERES Sanaa NO « SRE.Sa RRR CTE REE mee 22> DS SD RRS AS Pe SOS Ee aeRBERS Se ee RE AS mee oeeeage 1ie: GRR oe gc NE OR age > ae Ne , mo Beae

(COTTE Neg ONE SN RR See SN: oro Rn ee wth ENRalle Stat CA RO CE SSNC RREI NM Oa ay" Cosras an uns > CCSn 1 EECA ie aa Me NRE LISN aeraiS cogs Re oS eeePty Soe iS ON feetnor ge aaha neoO ae CAE Ra SERRE SAO aueeRN ettAene tS| Sige. eeetie PaaS 7 ORE ea 38 RMR. --7- "nS ee CR is ESS Soret eS PER Re See BRS Fee Beer EwIGoii eepao ne Become io SOR SUSE TEE ARNea yee OES PesesBeer SEBS Rage BY, EE eas A AR, MMR ot SEED thSR CORO RRMNRRS RRR ScS32, ysSEE RRS BRS x EATERS Ss eo 7 (SABC P Re ee ise Shits A Re ok Sn BOR ER 3 Ee oe ke eR se gs Bet ens Sams Se: Re oer :en“OR Rs Osea Reape Sea £ Se wk Sa OU Sei gi mo LTRS crash oe Laan SET SOR ORONO TCS A at te ae OAS pre oe RS REDS Xo aS DS IER LS SS eS oes Ries ee Snr ooea aS ato SRS aea a ue pSTegtags SEEPS aePgR oeeat ee Sen TRAN SaCa a MORES Re anwr DERE RCE !be Ung PRL ROP oD RSET OE SheDNUae aOye OeBny 3AE Rea Beyong: ee eee Tae |. ee 1 CER EER FEES Sa Sete “ttSugieen BO lec12ee UE eae TSga EsEe aan Re Saar SOOT OL0 RSENS RARER SRee eRe MRR RNR a 78 eS isRE Ri: Nt Lan 1 EeeRace eae

Ee eee POM PA th SS Soe ee Scere eo es eases i gee oeBe ee “ues ee aBeen CBE Re: Ane SE Bescon _ SS Saas REESE agS SNE ebES Ceneee BORE Sitch BOLE a ae aT OIE oeWR ae OTR, re SE OE RECMR NE TERRE StPARR ages ETTe Lo Se SS SESS pe Sarna ee eSLe LTR eT Ea res . SEES OER Re Re ne Oe TNE Sly. SOS aaa PRLS SEE Ee SR a SURLRS ER ae A Le 0 Te RS SS Se ee ee RRR S.. | 8 eee Se aaiee eS FAG SBS REE RSS SN s l ae CMY. " Aaa

SUSUR SSeee ee esEe “tagger 1 tet eee, SERRE a Beeson3S es AERA x SEE Semen RS SR oo AC ae PRR 8c Se Lee Ee BROS a “Raa ome seOESe See SRS a see er CoS. PRA Pee eee nee dyITs FOE SserRR OE: Sagres TAOS SSSpine Prk ea ae as ee sae eee Sy Be Sa Re OeSTRESS Fe MR XS2 Rew Aen

SESE Ss reahhteeccae eek BORER Cn regtRD SEae: ee Oo «Lolls Reece BO ag NE USL an ein eg in ame neon sae:See SE: OS RRP aga REET. ON “2: RARER MRSS aeeIRE ORR 5oeSeCREE Se RR TE pre. a moe BERS geORR caneoh2JESS es BT SEL, ER See EERE a TE, wl OMB,

Ag nee itSo RG AS aRene REY AERO Bee SSEE ee rE TEER -Bis RIDES rae eee SR SACO Se Scone ae ce gies RC, ion Be \ Soares See eae AOS BE oe .SIF PERMA Bes eRSiR a SO hteeOER Rip aespe SE aSBS ee CR SORE aS SP. SER ROSS a a To es ae,Dr. a coae OAS lsRe Do a EES Siar RoeGhesv oatates aSLe NOSED ye ES Re «ee AMMEN MUR Poi See eeA ee aeSegue Rte eae hE an .SER ::coe eae eee TEs Een aeSS oP hsSOR, ee eeaes TEESE SSSR SR eee we Sige aah i ee ee ay mot LS OOS tie TET EE SEIDEL te eee OE Ea a So -ER “ees Berean aesAe HRRe Se a eeond we SE eg ee 1 ORE a ee PRRe RTSME ES;EAS SSE PAPERS: Baas GraeRE LSERe SEN eae aes 8 273 RR FERRE SPet RR A A ee RR PUM So tS TST EE EP RE... Sets eae ee ah Bae ears ec ey Se SL LER se She LT RR te ee ai, Bhosiisntin on TANNA Sot) SEP EEY SYalt nSoT” SERED BPS,SS Botsa REESE EEE Re Sear on ee RRS: SET SEERA Pears ee Cee atON CEs SRR eis ono een ermeeaee a ae™ oN Be0, UES Tg32s ESESE. & bE Ne 2, SRM SS. Ee Bei RS Eng Re, oes See SE SES SK ATS Rake itz, SRR SS $e Rais pats SERIES ag re MIN ORS ROT PERE sr ogg tna este Lo aBec Thee | ae SRR, “OS ey.CY 1ateROS ReSoe eea oo Sos eheEL LARS OEE SIE eg “RR RS ROSS SER PR AIRS F oe pS Be epee RR SM ee Eee oe “ a iS 2-5 OO eg, oy CNS Sn SORES Ei Pee RRR com, Dies “EES eaten pole SS: Se Mie tnt oN CREE SO ce ttesese ey NaN coral etoninanebisienenneettetciecmete . rt 4 POR a pee PEE cage EDS Ue Ena SS Lani BEES tee. gS Sean Moe RN a oS ae Seiwa acini poe Sl PN a CNR or RK Meo TE pk IA. E $e NS SE ERR CARR Se ARE JRaat ee apes TSR eR REIS Bro SER cat 7 Oa. SRR RY FORME Ro DET ey 1 Eup gag cy aan ae SURE Ag Rr Tinh Sey Nan Re BRR Stouree By csiegetetaner oe a S OMNIS eae Ree BR. : ° I ASE RASESE Se CERES OS OEY “NeETS STD Sian ape saraes mene noe nS oe Ihaati gg SAR beAen cy ee Been eaEe Pete CAEP SPs See Sete sD UT aeeon : EROS SIE SeeeFOSS ann. eae OE EO ee sn a:RA PERE LIER Ege Re RE : Se eae SEMEN Se Soon seeo2es SSReS EE RN DEN ae RE neSRR Fee in GRR ne ee eM ge tte ‘op EE ss SORE x apc Sal Taio :aes, pa....°RPS REI NOP cn SRR. naa HER Se Sra Shag Sp Ge AE SSE Soars RR eeeaeet tere OeORS. ekeBat ROA Sa ENBn a Se De ag .° BPN nTSe OS SIT SK tine. SER ASeos eS“AEE IR Seats eaessOiSRAM ERS IESE, CERRITO, SEE te oe mo. : 27 AR OT Ree aae ea le. “..CURRED ee ERS eeeo 250 ag RII asES eraisinane

BRON See Fe RNgk ineBe tsar ee RN Ft a ene E ge LSU;eeMMM wat 7° a SEF Phi aoc Mae: SENSE ate Sy oa eterna! ar RCSA SE NORE ee BY, Rae ere SO eB a WEN teroe WOES iene Cie io. gl: RS, Seer ana ik aaMen ca OE ke inact eneNC RR Se Si aes| LS eres © eR Ee wd &tee nooPRR feet i Siieeaeateee eta wf, Te °ce SeBEAR Ee SEEM 1eae yeas es *ge Ce” p3 Rg SERERS Snes eeSec a are eR Re SeoySe pesteric eeetaea ee Sen, aan EE aee dssS SSE SRS $n Spey BRSe ia I.eae CERT SRR Sete ERD gagged oan ee SR -SOE Re deea SO “eae. 1a GREE ces - P. tee, Sa aaRg hia . DO RO Ee EE eR ee BAR Se Sek ge BAS BR rt Be OR ae EOE RS lll are SSE ERE Reh aesgo BRET Se SEDO ORT REL ROIS 5 SSS erar mY . SPes CESS a ARBE bo! ee a. EES Ee ore oe od Boe Bae eee Bee: oS sae Seok .aPe ee -SE aoe Bs oeeie a.:eae mee Bea ehsee ee SRO NAN Sy eRe ese ES Se on oeRS "Ne a Sa A se gee coe poate beetooe” Sg eSalll . we NEBR BOS SE SE eee ip ROR CeBy... eae acee on ik 24 BE il: ES eee ageCER BR PR en Reece RRR NOM CNRcine, Caetano ta ORS SOLON RED RS ot . eS “.wT. Rare 13.2 "ARR AE, Pc ee ee Sees BOs SE ERR Rah alll ; Be ar | PS Be eC a ecco tabRgg PB Lo... oe Pie, te ein te aR OE EER eee ee: wal cla : . mo coat ian P BR eS SORE Ree eS | aa ty ee. | Ea a CRRA Post SSS ip Ce as Sg Ae E of . aii wos . nd eee ne orgs Genii ieas cone SRE OF ee SO Se 2 ES Rea cr er Nee Rane See RES CSUR St, me yaa DT : ppl CS . Se. RRO ae ee oe an” gs a *% Bah eae asbcatees scant abate tee ees SEN eNO Fe ANE, NERS saat " 3 J ao eee tee : : « _. ac—illlaR Mp * a a a“ Senor eR 3 5, SE es eae eisai teneiestateget yt aio wae %~ %, . wea4 4 Bast aeane es ERO RPS ES AEE 2: 38 , er, * . ee: ae ee . EER ee : :¥ae aS Sey BPG > entecmirrarseten So ge Be, cane ee aE Ish age SNR NIPN Ne ns api ekeeee, oO yao * 4 Ss aad SYR RAE RN Se . 7aan tet wn: . Mee - 8 “og & eg CSROA gS Fee Re Peace ree i_TSSESE: easter Doue> Bee SET, -ascas BREN. Speers gSSaRNR 3esa7RINSE geLb: . eR enna Sane SESSeatSee ree reneeaRee ere are

2 OR Sins BOSE * SSR: _ Baers OR ora ee ke LE, eROREN: PR BR 5Oe38eon aoaGee eS Bee Re ES. ER Se PC anCORSE Bit OO 2AEcce ciatesecon magiaSe SeaeeeSE | maekanre — oe _. oo

Coe ane S aR ie orROBie. BENE se SEN a, ee ORBAN eecees ae ceees ee— PeGREER ES ae OER ReSS SO ae iseneeSarak ee ar 1 ae ofee ee ; oege Se BeeS ores StBees odie esnt tienes 0. DatSpeenat ae Ste DNS BORO COEDS Brae hes Rae AGI ne R PURERENS RR SeSe SESSBROS as es eeaaaee ee ee oe Se BS Sie RRR earn ee OR SeeSe ee Be :oR _ c 4 i & = So EESRR ESS RR EES aoS onesSPLOT crates eter tater"5 Betis ost CASES ROS eeee caveat SANeg ee. Ek Parent Sh OSE Rae a ee2 REgg E

ee 3Bci.ike, Soeeeoode_oe.See = =. EE gee . ERSPe BaPees Be ti rr isi LD Bi einsnrcenissean seinen 5 SERS SR Rites Boost sr esontieiencntsteeret Meanie anion RoR seenianeen cee DONE, ICS SERS SOO SIR NG ooh reaastetocneneeete tee PR NARMS CAS ERE sothacey Sina hiaeeaescne ste letetetenesecepy

RC FSoops SRT ROS Sateen nyeeSSeS SEeneSeo eesecne og hsOOBE UR AOR ES Rohan Bon REN LoS OER REEES SRE Coenen one nee eae Nee Spe eee NS SOR a eee otArion RR SSA Pe Pe UNE ASS.aes 7. |a 8 spake |afee 8EMR ;RRR BEBERS BERN BeRE SR Se ane ES Seep aTROLS ee Se stot Ree Te SRE TPRRRORRE RNC enc Re a oe Peer Fosse cetera ise Seepdeaan nine pee OL Sa Renae nee Seneae ce < aaa cognate eee OOS R RORS SO REE. BRS ay at Soni Meet ti EOE MERE NOON

RRR RR on aaahrns i oa Ee “ERE AA aa RoR CSR ON, ho SaPs Se pe en ERENCES RRR: aa RSEpay ee RE Fe eeeye SS RSSone eee NRCS: ae S— a sa Beak nSRUD SERRSS 5 Seana oePTEES RN OS :3 r ae Shes i SaSee eRareeeee Ge SOR Co CESSES SRS Ro Pegsanon Bommeate Sacco Reseet PA Se ON IOS IS 8 a eeeit St Lae RRee RR ee ES ae aaa SS So eeRIESE: Ne SAU Des Nise ee eSalSE BR oo

See esaegis BERS ae ROU RE: eesions ee SS reBRR aSenate Sears eae NA BAe SS oe Ne Sageaieineete SSR RESRae BB LS _SES SR tee Re ea MEAs sates Seen dotSx Seone sina aii SSeS DSI JLEERine 7 RE ENN NCR TS eeeS SSE Bitigs ERY Oo.Me. aa Sen esata atgestae oo ONE LISSROR Ss Te aah Pome eieeeSoy Pe — SSe” . E eke teen ane Reka See Sere Bee aSeRy SyPasian SACSan SeSEE REEpee SoS ame EEE oe RSENS ERE SSSR EES ER PORES eR: BS SEERA.

.BEN oe Reese es BFE. SERS oe : ee Fe oe A eeeSe eneeeeeae SSSESS Keauarepanae Be ES RRRSRA SSMS SEet w bee REESee BR BRSeeASRS OeReeeEEE RcORE > eaeUsRa BADE Se oes

3ReetRs NED,Se SR ee OR SERENE 2 ees Recke OES See a RISES I Fee Ee eeSSes8SESE oe pond : ) ERE fee$E:55 a a.RR3Sg epee ie ite etreiReo BaWitten oeRE Ses SURES HET Saigh “Ree eein Ne ai te a J.IREN RB SEESce CEES MERI tenet ee eanieerertefe SS PSs.aeeeaaa Soitecaeaesien Song iig semeumeeue tues memes eg var ee BAER

- oo gs Se : a Gh Co sg cle a ee ee oo Sars tea ee an eters See ARS Eo r j ia hy ia i: | .. : — eB sheen ae pes oS SSS es ae eu eo nearer saan ea ee MS pt

Br CePRES ERRBesein B 3SRES REaR: eSnut ROMS ee Ce eeRE ESPROS: a RRS See gee Soe"ERE n eR te ee Blogg NE : Seems PRR go cena ee seeee Satan 3 Son ae Cro onan CREAN Prieta gS ae Seed Pog eBEE iyo 3oe. eee ae es ae one. Se a Ro = RRS Dedige cone RS PES Pe Seatiesnea eC RN ok RMN RIG Pe aa feREL PS UA esetaRES PSteegsFike SeaEe E, Pie CONTERIS anaes re Be RARE aS Veo Bacio es)PS eo RaSh eesse PRESSOR Zoe MSs cance SoA Ripon: sant S oeSemmmnaneie es RE See i RN rereees Sigiecenae senna SRR Sri NaNtswo 4 ) | ee | bly ot. E Pay Seer 3 Sh en Sa “SESE S panei Oe Bape oe ne aa ee: SOS, 2 EGR Se ean ean SEE oe See Bg

ooREEgeSESeeSRReee BenokBS 8 Be ek- Rage et 8oheret Se eee _ SeOR aR ai ac 2aes:ARS eee es eee yewa=pics ro pnt Ot RR RO RR PR e+ TLE | ROR gees ca oe Ba Stieeges Such ae nica gene Portes ssSRE aSosaCOR a7QS Ee as eR. EC 2i Beco ;esBo Cea SiEES eae Sh Sa Boaeees ey RE RR45 BRBetis i. BaeSree. Fest Ui OO Eee Sere geese S ee Saas Te ae ieee a ees CGS SNeae SeesEES ae eeISeeeS ee ee ae WY)

Bo cnn eros ee le TES| gcSi,auetaaas BE en eeye?eee OBES OE esa,eae Boasts 3 eet. soem RSE EEae eSOSES SREESSN ES po BERN Ng Gy Sig PR eRe BS eee BS oo ae — RS Be RL O: SEE rece a See aterone esaca Sree eg Re ee Berra Svein SEES ee Ke aOCS 1Seee ee aRR SeCERRO Sy raat 2? reels aSSR SRR SSpaar NSS. PegFEED Se ase aSESS aePF ee OS = a SEIS “l ) mo iggo, mohaaa Pe3 RR CR aa eae SERS Wg aeee Ceieee WER ee eee eeOE ETRE JESS SEnT hie is ee fe Ri ae ae maa Be Ree esa DOSE SES ness sens ao xj Set :oF oF Ba °(ESS) .aooneae Seas Seana eePSS ee RS a! eeeSRE OsssoHee oe Se oes 7. ee fRR .Re :: wees ;SSR oe 2erasae EARS aaKae oe ysis UBER ae DEES aege es3, ee PROBE SP«attSethe Spohn aes PS epee Bes OR oes »TOLREEIS UBS Se Pe Be: REE Pee 0gM ca ee SSR OS atc | Rarer SSS Se we EERO EES eran oe ee a ‘ty PRBS Be ee : oS: EERE CU gS Biron ene ae ee SOR pee ee eek 5 SORES RS : # 5 RRS OR a: ae State ate USES. SRR CRS ene RRR Ra ee Bo eens SEE he Be Aan ee i SEDs

aneFetes ReeCoe cS”RRO as BS Ss.eaeSas : LE Sa in Bs a Sct Be. . RES -Sr . :pen BS RS ioatin See eos. ay WS con Di oe Se ae Wambo . ee: Sat2 ee fas} oe Ss.eee NG, ee SEE eS| Saee |ae |i Sh eeeRita peeSo: SeeAD ee Re ne amen aRe . sTTT Se +os pies, Semper Oe OE IRR SORES teeMere poi.be Bess k. Sang. ee Oe fe aaa a eSSa Bee lat SNe eee SS po 8 ONE BR.AeRS. RoE eee BBR BEERS eo. Tae =hha 2 aes aN sees Sree Rt ose SAL ESSE Ee etee ne wae Paes Se RRS 3meat 3areata Be a OE ON sees SEEN Be : a 5 ERS ee PURSES Os a Geta PER Ct ei os RRS ee ae Bes fo e Bc cq oe 4Se us oS . ee POS ees i esdy regSS egret OPS neop . SeES). eee BE Nie ge Sa ek Bo esBatson eas ae Ben SERree Se aee|Seen SaBe SER ei Re AR O ba : a RSE Ree a Res te oe Sens. gore USP OS ete hk Bs ERS Sc Se Ro 2) ee eee ey a: SRR ee One, aSR Oy Rat eee os eeee eePepe Scape OLRRR ko SR. 2eeSR es aeS a Ree a NS BeOS RE eg” Cum NSgs en Ses Ree ocaS Sa s Oec eeFRR coRE oeaESSoe €e eSeeRN ues Se RR SS See RS BeCS =)

REE REE no RN fs PEN geo a e ’ ~ en . oe a -

Yee. fe. Coe 7g oo we = ny oO

Re sae Nee Re ORR 8 Ce RRR XEAIRE ARTI OA a ENR OE 20 peepee SRS Ries Ste SERED OY SEEN”. een eee 2 ee ae Ee es eS = L

Rae a2 et ce AES oe oa 5 ae FS | Ps a ee “Tee Ss Se Sateneit. ‘Sean See BR Ee ee Yee WY } a

SESE eee ee RES ae rrrrs—~—‘CiC spain od ~~ gas soos “4.CRE ‘nh fedekRRR weg SR rrSnes RN oo SE: aos oe BS ceoe — .oe O~~ 2S a FEC RSS Sena Fo Nene Sienna a Ko ee S Le ee ones EEE Sy Seas Geter ee eet es — — . oo Cl $e pepe cake ake ee @ eee ae SR BE SE Sy say ee . SP eae eee oe ze a Sy eee aesas Re2A es” De RS Bese Sh SR Bae ee ingen eee aPaar Sa Siane RS SOLES SigernSipe SNSE Cunna hig nitrates: eee Bae SS tg0 Beene: Tape A C5“, BEC ian oa oe SSSRN aig 5ES SO Ree ee He cae es ae Suny Beaten f sco ce. | RRR SRR eo es Siesta 2.” Sane So Bettuaitenceiniegeraote Soe a sae a eens Bee cena aa SORES. AC RANGS RRR RRR IN SOURS, = a

Le : 4Seeot oese, See LLORES AIT BR eeSoca eSSee eeNS eeae _eee . See Sh SOR Soa Sete: 2s neonSESE a Ee eee Ser Ea ene RO SO Sa ane See Cees ETRoce SRR. re SN RE SEES ee oar oe eee yp aSEE aES BEE Se SRO Re eee aT Ee ea

Le, Rie SRR RSEERE PR RSSe SRR ORE Genes, Cea Ree eeeiESS SyeeEN gea SS > ,ee | ~ ct Bc Pee Oo aa LES RS RE, tee es AGNI IEEE RRNA SUN Sa ie seein sn aeea So eet RS NS re EEE Ce Se aS Ee ° Cea ee aeeS,a \a mga YS A ee ERR a SR Eee SN neea oo nnsethecosrseartranetater i Scene BE SORE OERSoaSORES GEE

. ceBRE | 2a ee.:eee Se Oo SerRens Pacinacnas OI SIN secre seons LO ORRIN sehen etn eames co ZF;“oo) SARS Ss cea CEN ape Seaerenenis RS Ra$8. Cay Garona, batt oa ead ceORES ONE REe ee Roaches ees fete wtcok esdSe ESaaameeee ee ae eeaes € N Ben: o. ;:YE we Bt >ees ol RAR Sa ‘pear coeaees. EDO ean : Paes Ber3ee os SoSat coge Qo,vos WAL ApOES Loree te REE 1. SRR SeSon UR Sah on Oe SS Sticserefetetet i ll”NS : Sh aaa. Reape Saxena oeeneaes SoreStus oe gE ; --2 +SeRieORD Sie LatsSEE UenSRas RR PEeae SRO «=tarsrtesinoneneeyteets a SOEUR eeeeacee R SoraneaeRabat Bees Sag Bo 7. Lag SeenSemin eee ica ee anaEo re Sos RSE Perea, - a ao Hee Nitemnnnimee saints Seek So SoSee tsatiennenn

TBRcous: RL yoMap ee Cree RRO Sok Rnae oeSg Oe Rue ee eSNees 2D sanSR TRAE eeSR SeeERE Seema “7. GF Re ORS ar ge ona noSe vaeeeSe se w Gee aaRT aDon ee oS 5 areer: SE gS ee eeERR % UW? Oe Aga UP EAGT Sees aoe SaSSSR, Ries "SO ROE |Re cos se 2. Peres ‘ fek PORE ates, econ «BRR eee So ee le, BE QR S30 :nr nan -te ohne FA ees Rr ees PIC eeeAate eeeBe Se enn|.SaaS OUEST oSee ee hn | ; Ri pees en ei: eae Bie Caataea, So net ROSY PERT ereseecoeteematses RR, | wot mL a ataanreete Rn SEER Resi ig a ek Set SOREN RS

ERR Fok: we evr BE TREE RRR Rane C.,, apna BeBe, Seren Semen POET Lattices SE aes Seem IK } a

Baerisere- Bee OF ed FRE RRS ReeSee Sas ca EO,SR ES ee cr ‘ SO = [oe Be Ss A EE so ae Pood a RES: SSK.P SeNS Soh

Se FOS RES oS CLUE Rg va aOR UU SRS Bee aa aoe SO RRS | | Sao ee, See — r—~—s—SCsCSCS bara] ee Oe Sab mosigGe ORO EE pS GARR eRBeNg SUES BCCeara. ae ae ,_ Raeerereae SES eeESE EE ES ee Ba SE Ho MeEe TES ESERIES" ac iema: ce ESSE SasPre Se cdg: SESS _SSEREEES “hee ¢g Seaap” SeeBuide, HoeFai PA aBee onc* SERRE Rae Se SRR eeaRese EEaERS end ee FB ng cee Sitcia ORES PSE EeetSOD 2Ec RR PS EE ee i 3agiSeen enwh DRS poy ad aa PRR Saoe OTS son me Sore 2 aa aEE PE ie SCR eSGeer EOS eae TPe ote ts EES URRE l SR Be RRSS is ee aregems "Re rrerra Sem Seeg cee

ane Be aon a eR: : a a a ceo eae: ae pen eR BER ges ., Se OE EE

Bosse 8opah a: ee ee Bee) a pete es8Ses, asRiee Be LA Bras ga PrER sees IRE Do ape peeef RRE edenen a BRR oe a eae ae eReREEO a Koeae re «a Pf ee oe aarr .gee Shae mely te:ae Rigeianange sg teat RRR “2 RS seen aR ase ses .

a . 2 eas - 7oes = Ree TE 2eee SE : Baie ROE aS ERS iOOOO SRR aaA3eee Gs coatiaeance eeee ee os Se Oca i SE ee Oa CEES, alg ae eee ene Ga 2 ERRORS ene A RE CR BRE IE TORS CORN S. Dc, SOR NRRURO ORR EAI 2 A SR ea Oey

SIRS RMN 2A.Sais RSSeas aasete RRSatseeas-°— a SR BR Sago Senge cet a Sr SOR ee ee NO OSsNEST eR RRS SR OER STON SSS RR Oe iSi 3 SER RRRIRR eR, | SBE cS SEEao” ASUS Saatie Sasa ge ae ee Sa SESS. SareeaSSR RR REED steSe OES SeeEND RO MME Set SeeREE SRR RONEN OE... 2 SS ORR

DU 5SS Be SaaRR naan ahora | RENDSanere SORES SNA RR OS SS.|erRG | Se Sk, OR EOD. .. Teena anesthe RnR ea IS oA OSSas ee aS SRS) SRR gS SS SRS eis Seen SoeSal REERO SRN Reor. Cee ae aeSRR; oe ee ee aina eee ee Fe Coe potas

SORA ik SIR INR SE a a a en nea Ce A eg ge mR eee RE BB Baier Xe Se SRR, “SRR ae Rane SRN RR SK HR REESE RERLGI 17/0, Sa Se

Stereo ae SEER” 7°»eRe, RRCAsatte. eee = Be SSE ORED SERN > SOS RR SRO BIOS OFRak” SRR:Re, SeneM, BR ga Ne.;:SORES - CERRO” SCARS RR Sa aRR RRS a RRS ae eR JSSaE REGS Bes RRR ae.” ERR SoeSsaenneeaan Baas BeeSRS Ra MOR OR aeCORIA One. Str ERRNO Shi SRE Cie ERS: SUM 2RERDR AD RRSerent Ca.onAe. SEE Pee SR: Seee pee ae [hee SRseneeaenas rt rcCatan SaZSGER rteSaas Sens RA 6 RDS Bey Spence. Sierra 3. See ees.aOR & SR eee< Si: a gi BassieR CR ae RR ee SS A TRE 2 ERI Bee Rae Ge MON Spree Se ele So NeRR NOes“Oh: SERRE Soin Ok *,-: ROKR NERS $8:RSS RRRRR aa ei

Bs Sg Rae oe”. Sia. eS: 0 SUN” SR SOME ITN t SER SOE BE GaD ST Sat DONNER INO SR SO, SAS ROR ea SSRSERe RRSRRRO, SAR ORN Seaat SEDER ER aa a ne te cie (S Ees

woeR SESE ea pecs. Seemann Sees 5 OR EIR © REY SH SR Se ag nC ihe euenianies Sa ae SLES Sie Rpcaamone ssa Roa OSes eeiggs 0 Soy 1 EERE:

eS SR Re eRe + Sperm meen SS oe SS See aaa SED. SPS MESRC RON”tN aC Sw A RSBie RRRGOO | a. SORE 3. Ts REO ORRRMREEOR TS “SOR SERIO. RO iy utonmmetyant EN Oat 2 SRR RE 7Sees ERR aBRONCOS ea Bet OR SeoRRR eeReEERE RN Se aie’ SpO SRR ReSERIES, PRE ROR OR 2SORTER SAOR Se a SRC | Re eR DNAS DRE Y SONU" otSE BO NT RSE Se aEON Ses Rea as OO AROS... EET:eS SS: een es, SOO RED ED7AT, en ROE i See RS +Se Re -SRE DSRS: 5"Se SON: eR a RR ORR Sea Se: ORR TERR CRRA SN RrTe a aoe es tye ippiaaipereemanemmemarsercst sy: Siar Sienna. - MRR R RRR aatenS 7 OR RRR

ER Peg Site: San RaeGeieNae Seoesae Sn Re BRS ED os.E.:3: Cc ee ee:eeSe eR «ee ee SA ee S|. ee i oSeR ae. eae aaa RN pi ae sacs SRE BE PRA erinSataas See ae aSee Se RRO ie Secs Pp LORO « o RIT ak ene

ER RS.” Sacer nncenst BEI Soc Se (35s RRR RCS SaSRO Bsce Sick DeakER ARRAN ERR: Sts Ret—. BS aS.a: LNS RE OOM: SRE SESE ROR RO SERRE SES.SCOR SE SMR.” SOONER ERI, cole oT I Seca Seek MER ogRORSSM es aaa etieitheaen SSE: SHIRE PER RPONIN NR SRAN SeleSe pie ee CO, aOR T -S. ae a iBocce. a : ssre *PReres aera eeoeRa RE RMR gees Sr eaS uke See ees oy ROOST SeSANE Gen eee ap Ses eaeRORY SSeS En ARUN SRR DREN ER RCO aS TS Saat it ee MOEN A RE COOLS SRE Air eee ee, SE ee ee MO ie mh ERS Coe ed)

Reon -}, SORE > SRNS . Sacer. de os oS a Ne Rs PROS EEE... OREO See HRS Sen a REE SR Oee SateeseensnEs eae. Se eR ne (S

EAR esfeSES 7: “oan SRDS ORME SPREE GD” - 5 SERGE Sop SREY MORNSCORE Ce kes RRO UE. ARE. CR REN: OSES ESRI SOME ENDET. San « Set nmane a ee ce 3% fee "SSga SieREISS ech SESeR, Slee Rie.es pen Ee Se SeeEP SeePANS AES CRRRRR ORES Serieea ORES $e SE ERre Cee EeaSe RRC Aeae ES ES ONEOESI Se ">, BRSOCSCS.. ae Ap SRB s setae. ees ce, Se areMeee eeecites error c 2)

BE re 3 Ean pcre RGR Soames: S58. ; SO pretenNR entenees Okaee RRee ORS: SEMEN o Skt Rie SOR ae ER ORS ARR O 2.,eee ee ee: , eaennniie.. Nene, aaah ie ToS gg ee c penis * “eae Piabes CE See .) CUR Rie Soe anORR SO oe. ee aeOUEREROS oS: SRE "is Caen i EBLSS Ie Be Pee eee, “ARES SA share naanGorman rameneaante. Be Soee RRR REN A RONAN: NE 93 oF SR paar ek SOO SAC RGSS Saat. CRE, a, ap SanES ae SIGS

[OER RRR REE SRS 2a a aSpe EER SgDU vow eeeSORE cuteeerlake eee toe --5.' 2. eames .% " Saee Se REC,“ aeG, Sues, ena SLR AES n SESS SES oy,ogee “Rieti aceocinae ee - ROCCE SOR. Some Re"aan nnn, One, SES, RR eee eee Bite ES Se ee aaeaERECT Sea REee argCA RO eR ease SEN eeSiar So CO EMRE ARE Se gis ES te ee i, ee Somes. ceneeerEe — a)

SORES " REep RR=k RR RRR Reese OO EERE aNSOCORRO” GROCER . SOOO) OR SESNEER NR ERIER -Fe 2 Seah, aaa,Reaaanaess Sa aa SR CECRRS - GRSDERES SDN SOR aaa BN Sete _—— Nc aSaCoane eeEES ee Bo a RR RR 2REE EIfang faef c ReeRE ORR IS.Re ciannee NS ain ReReRR SSR ME eR EE ae uiSRR Soe Gene | eae co me) Pn eat Re SDN SAKE ARERR ONE “ons hy ERI SORRY Seas teneeann EEE SS SPRITE OCR ES RRS ES OER RR gee eeBRE Sten cc a@ttaies Canad pS GOES PERE agRR NEAR 8 OD aes ees age FREE SESE Bev oaagen Sa Bes og 5 ree Go RO Sk DOSES See ge Se ta SSE Se SERRE eo pecES aaaoeiscionentnienabehemupeneatt gunk octet Saye . oe SP RR 0 3 RSSS aSg erga REa¥-gaBX DigSee RRS SR OCR Aa SRE... fee ae EIR 2 SSE RRR ©e SESE SSS ee os +” SBRBy. SSR RSS eietet ie Sie ee Re RR Ra RIES SRE TNS Jes nant Pee SKS BR i RR oy eR ROR eR Ree re A SRC RO a RRR SD TER pee

eeeReao BRC ee ey EeRRS eaente ereS RAED SOREN ome SSSSE. caese: orRaa a. Sy aeoeSs ee oc RRS Be oR Meo SRRe “SERS SR SE. uae aaah naseoe Tea Ses aSO ORE ROMER ORESSo CSTE 2b SS ORO an SRE SU ERrc SSIR Shan. RNR8 SB. R Nee - RSeRe ESE:enALR Sic: RRR co Sa % Se were ED eng Esa oe es I, SSeS . ++ RSIS 05" oS yee SSR JOSE a Bae

SR 4 Leone Seeee Seeeee “E.RTS eS re “sap Beas SRSBPR Sea” io BeaOS * aes eee i oe oS‘Sete et ree Ns- "SS eke” Seas Zgwaes

BRS Sam 7 Se sao ee SeSeetot. “oF 2. FER. SS aes Se See RORgO ReTE SE eS SeePores 72 SeeegBE Og de See >Sees & Spar ge Bee emer. RRSeeeasSs BOR CCEA.

,. °ttresses

ee Fo] ae: RES: peeSaSlee SSBB EYocORS SSS Ses OB RRS eR fos pees SEN RS Rts SSeS. “eeaes & ie SS RR ok2Speen PRR. Ihe, Be BieReG ESie Seige Ly RG Bee ;

SS: eer ee: «= eee F SPed Se. See :ished 2De 2 ieee Sepete ESSE PR SnS SS hangs ae ene RE roo aoe: .32Ce eR cee THEE By2a at Ba Reames seege GER CORES Bg 3:So Pee ES pee eres 4RRO eee me BF aees Sige See co S : roe S Cgateaee eSpea a Caaeaa Bo oR anRamee Rate Fseca ie.aa EE Sy: Re RRND SERRE 3 SCOR RE «tS aaa’ ae: adl Bk oeeeaein *sees seek ee ae RE ReVRS aes Fg"RRR Oe cs iSs3eeRe

SS AS eee Sees = ee eS SSE eee a oa Nae . :

i al open u j 29. Reims Cathe )in buttre

igure 29.

h Design olf tne nave. e€ gestablished

cd. I211°

i:

Cee ee eae. rr te es Oe oe ee — —“‘“‘“‘“(‘esBac Se osSe Be ae cS Sty EES ¢ me aoe e psSra R285. 8 od“Sr SREBers BRUSte ogee et EeSe. ees Ree 2 : ee N See ee ee eefaee ee:EPL NSS aacBe ELEN Re.osSa xEE & >: “easetaes eink SrESetee OS be i.Reet aeete “EES Sgecen &oo.

. 2Sama Scien. Oe SwBeOto. Pek) TRSURE SERS Se EE aTROT See BesgSeScr: nd eee eeate oe oeoeoe eos . Me ioe See Py, gS ie ire bee ae Sek IES ae eGs Caaeenssn ge oeae are ER 1) aasec at EE 2 gO oe Sine oe :re ee ae =SiON - Bitin, SeI REE, 3Reames ee ER. Sas OR ocCg 2eeye Oe Nees iscethy . By Bg SR IEE ae RSS RE wats REO fo >Me SeteSee i,a aeeenan SRE eas RE esae DR EEL >. eee. WISgoeao EEE napa i .sone SeeVaio SeaR I os gosseate og SER. .peeeeennione Sane Cs - ptoneeahio Ses SES RE, eS eg, 2eSRO BE .me Be!. 3 aE,See See.~aeae Rae,yc Shep. a ae SSSR SS a SRY < CatePOSS a Sch Fev. Seat ee Soon, 2 Ce Bae oeSee ee oSaie oe ce acao

, a oe OK oS gs Vy eek? ree: PRORA -., appears Ss tae oo me - aoe rs cee: Seas al one & Bin, Bin EDs Se a £ cE Ee Ec et es, 5 3 RS SE TES eee i ees Re. Sane aS Pe ae : a SRes see ON eeWakeRS oe ira SS LP eS i3osafooaREeae ee Pernt Se Be: Ei se ROM AT BSye NE: ein RODS GEG seiicontinctss Oto. Sone ec st SERe: Te The: | Sea SS ee Bones se RS ee 7Be 8ae So : oeet——. .: Do a agit a| 1es RRR gs ais SET PROMO ate Seek eS Pe SR Bee ieee whet egpatent Reg SEN pe Ca BeeatSatis ee- gia eS pop ee:Ss: BS | emecey Sie, eeDias ee as Rea SS ytope a ae See : ee eames a See cha hte

2 Soe SEES: Fae fe " . To a Be SRE TEES neBe. ee Saeee, ct an ve see lgSEES SENET 2 RR aes Bn oS RS Reena a SOS ee ES Wt UB eg sen)laSia See Bete ESBon aa a ae . 7 tee ‘ Seek “eSFee TE abies 3 Ee OSS See 9 ORS, ceonconannag S: Gemma: 5S SESoiiescrnns ae BRB ses ees: Soa oesaay a cl de ae eet ES EEE See ene As, * 8 ER KOR 7 RES CEE ch TE peace ae a ES Reicciten 0 ee Seopa ss eee, +3 Spieinmccmean ys: My oo Beaters SASSER, eee oe

PLE ad ROSon LORE SD a aBe: Bet SREBi,ES SE's RSEREESE MM Be28 ORR RR iteche Si pg TRiEN Ss SES gggngigmii $555 2 SRgot SES ehr5hacen ce lh Wy Sag eR AS

Coo. TESMR Fesoe Poco areaTEREST ee ERRaSeLeeee caEO orePe” RSRe a ES Ee SO : eeeo ecg aa ORE acho SEE SR EE eat aR MING tx S Sa ee Se Rs RSA ie Sea ERAL aieee eeeo bee44ai

| OSE ss: tek Read. SET ORE SEE ggppe eek?ER sore BPS cee ee SRE Ee giEga 17 pgROS 2 a Rea asAeWdgreee SEL OBS peasBea3ee:4 ee pee eee REE ecSMe gee aRES apne ya SR Se Sete RO EENBEE SEO” ciate tc SS IRR napeMe Cente 2 Batam, aaNet ee ES PTS. CEES Tho oS Bese went SC, Se PRECMS ORRONEN aan eemibeaia, N Ce SUN USSSS. RRR genes og eS ap: BearSOA gesSoi ee BY FSOrn eee. Ba *LE StsTUN Se SRR ccc: SRNR. = SCOR” SO SON RSS ONO 7 Ad Bes]

. 2 ee SiS agent) PS gg REO EAL RE PORTE So An 8 ON gill Bose L009 RLS RE Se ae a RES SS aS See

a | Ee ae. Koo Hie fee Sees ae FS Sena tk Sane RL RT ESO - epee Soh penageees CREME CS SEMEN. SOR. CRONE? Se fen ch ET SESS Se SS SER | 8 Pre os .. me RERet Se Se peta eee gaan.Ug BE es RO PES pant pa BROS aCS. Bg aS OILSRR APO ek err R Ae Ce SPREE RR oe ee. es ee Arn * QBoe oe: SUES aa “any RRO ESNeSR EEORRORE SY.«OREO COCR 2 So 2: en GOL ELAS. DRO GR RSE ate9Sh a EES ESeo . ae = fens BERRIEN tNISBees ON, aAc i a St a REES|. oO. AT snamR OED eg. SRE 2 SO re Ba aes ee Bt ;. SEES ey as Se SCRE Ss enppREONes aaRe Nyiens «soaps Peek 5 eeSERS Ae ieeeR Cc ame Lepopnte Be ESS, aSaas ERD 5. See “$93 Se SREx ceeope PenRBIS Bee eeET MO Sg esrenes Naa oi. RCal Reae eeeCe ea eine RRMA IOCC RRR 5, RCA SRee 2SES SSL Sneeme s5Bie ON . UES 2S eg gba ER ees Sree aes eS eer poh ee ER UO ERN So RT Op CESSES abe So aia PS DCRR. CCGG Sea SSR O - S ER Be gee a A gala “Sieg “Sy. a SR OER ER CONOR ROIS Des REN hah SSN Be tN a OA Yn

; Jia ee eeeeee OE ose eet OS 3 a teBo ee i So. eee es P Sae ega :. ROSS Se ge. See BR ReSas‘: peSee ae2 ee eeERESSSusieS ae deca sine, eS SIRE REF BO BS ABR, BB. 2c? BRR Se Seaton oo a ae BE 7 BBB reas Seas Ree oa a ne .:. Lo Oe Fett SRS SNS th ete. SZ ed aoeiT) ey ‘eet ' See Baeee NSated TS. RESON ARERR RSSSON RR aSN OSESend IRRRS SS ae oeSaoo ontyt. 3 Oe Gi SR SeRae eeeace ae aeinwSee By.lee: pee«6B rage gSSeiilRE: Se ten Regalos, i na OsORE BRoe a ae

LOE ERIE Se RR as - ; BS es BRR aan = ~Mger e. 3 Bosch” FRR reir See tae ae a ee petis-.'c. < Renaae Se an es

EePOM oy egWee LESEEDERS... ie, CES CONS SES ReesBRC ees,RMR SAE8:a SRE Ht ES BeeSORES. Ree DeSaSgTSE BO ee ROC opsRRR ; | Spent ene era iprrcn Sengy Sak : .ER «SC So: MNCEURES SRR: OBS Ba choy SRR 5 SE Soe eRSee Se avgGovioes OS (a lea ORS gnSg REERK os ae ae are aca Sethe REMe SR Noa): a: BRRUE | DED SeRO RRR Reeneeeeeire - 3DRRR ORR RaaSan URS oe Meret. - SrosSay. | ieBBS oy I OE RMB SME OOO™ | SRRBite A Bee SOR SeaRS nies OSRR LOE RO TEeeSaas ve yt Mg % BA EES BSS ee gerne eee fos MBPT ATER oor SORES © SOUR Ree Reneanten < Snow Sooo nro Bo OR RB ie an ee td oe Rete Magen ee. eaters Saree a: arnESSrSneeaeSESE See Cree esas eR ee simak cree eee Se eae See ee MAAS CEE Se RS ee RO oe Serene, «Bane Bes eee Sees SG ISERNO ER Bhs esa USA ASO SO S00 DT NAEEE SSS aa Re RRO NOS eh we ing ES aS PND EL aE CEL ae

DeREG es fare Bate Soe. |Be es SE “UT eceme < Boye SET osseach “SSIES, ere NS SASESS ee spa ache EanOROR ee eeaeoe SRR RR Rs SRS SEUSS a eee eecay on RIAs ere ean RARER ro incre feSn teh dR Ne aR eae ROM EEN ER ee SeReeR NEAsce cole ‘ OER 7SEE SS oe Bore oo EPSP SE on ae cee eee wens “OTE ea FF aa : MER ©OOOO Gomtcnhts MERRIE. | Btoon Orr Teots ee aAGES rene SEM ereee os ESM ROOT anc.EY feat Se cSt ESR ee SY MRAN ATI aN . SiORME SPR REE. nea BRR EO Ae So MEER oe oeaie AS Ops San gD CRceRRS DESERTS SO Sct ROI ARSN ORE BEER

laaeeEEC A Or ASLAS Bo oats ata.eeS ee CEES oS Se OS re ee SS ee. ae Se ee RR, Sede a YY Lo EEESS ic a a 1 EE ae Sa Bosco toes A; Sy, SES et or Se Bees 3 CR PRISE ISAS TAR 7” ut whee eeSTRESS "= Ok, aa ES RGR SIO Y. LS SP LPT oe * PBS Re OOS aes neCoy ey sae 7. C2RESR SS. SSN SS SORTED SCS 9 Sea =? oo DEInShseres SyeRGRe LIMES a LS,NOFae oFFL Sy“ks. Oe Ss, aay2 © sens a >. aER OeSDRY . So Ree sees:ORERIRN Sonos mritcteenn pita eiAR etaERS CO RIES eens ROR cates2ge Seas

ERS

Lt .,, SEER . ee CrsSE Bi ee ag Pepatcen, Rs«Bon % SASS asIR Beas, BP “B roeSie m5 RRR Say FesRENE RNC earORR Ss ReeipeenCremeee ¥e =eS eeeSR ee eeIR Saas TSE 0 yea ge ;oS IES.SE. UO OS Ak2ENE RRS aeBo Be = Eb des EY RRRSak ERS ee ESS aggateEL, OS ERC ERea RE Mert ES a SeDORR ERS.Dut INRR RS. “SRR aR RESig Si ua ee h$3SOREN ey ieeeyO Sess aoe2 Rea aR Bs 0a RETEST EE I Aa Se Bt aia Bors:SO Sn a Se SERRE BR ae NEU C OR ¢ aeSR le SS BR eeeiaee eg STR MEise ee eae dee SE I aC RRRS SNS,. IRR BR SR oS REyeRARE SCN Raa ne Bie ee. ee ERRSg ETD OO EXER GRE Bs 8 eehg BeSS eeRR Pe OREO ES eed o EEN Si ee ERS 3 eager So asSaSS ama Pie Ey Se wore SORE BET be SE a BER SBSoer So oh RRR Beier oS ee ER 8 |SS EPEE Bg ee RO OIG Se ee ROOD MEMES QUOD RE RS See ROReee ig Se ae, oS RESBaas Re RR

OE eS gas ec. Oe Oe ei ee Je) AS“2, gg Do gS Seg BEERS. EERIE EEL DU SRS. SUL ENB teoN a Seete MERE RG css, ee SS:SERRE ee eae BeFS SeeFO aeCa egWEE SAECReee kt iat ee Oe ee ES ao.SOS ae ee msUe xsPERRO Soe 3 pacing” 4 eee. Se ee POMC SS SER SeeSRRR

- MERON a eee ek: Sage: RaAIR REat:REN LORRSewanee 58etek caeCboS RS RE So reer Cetra Bae RSSo73 SSR ht 2Secs PRN te ERR EMO Sa a NEES Ree ener eesaemreaate Si Raat BENne UTCC ORcabana Gt SoA, aR RRR ty ee SEEN ‘ye 2 TREES RgeaSTR een Banas Saesate-epe Roeeee D aRECARO ORE RED. 0...SaSeSienna eR eR Seas COR Gesae&tknas ames a Bee: od (SEES ehh arcnsceCRASS ONION RSS . Bok See Uncrate > Seia: CRE See SE Se SR UOK Moen Re A a Cameo i Re TZ Pes REESE 50% PONE

CU 0 SES ESE So on IT as a RESORT Rt OURS OI SEER SO ERNE 205, SRO ENN SORE. CORRES SERS Coosa ew kau. Spapnemencaes BS BRS: MR on BE Tk RL Sekai BER ORTON ‘, URES SSR naa ee aroma Sa RR aane” Nene ea RS en SOS ORRoe SU IEEEreae So Ge SOc SONS RRScrs8 rg RRiiaBsteen RRR se 8 er SE ese ees Sn Rican soa BaSon ee UNS A Wea SagRemen St atin,eCERE aR A SengLS eRe DERE Se eR RE Sas SRRSintec NOI SOD SDT StERRORS ogi SESS SNA nl op OOSRR On NE NO “RUAN ioe Ney Bot Seetheniaica

eSEE ee SRE ee eeope eSSrc RRR ee SeeeeRN RNaMaRS Sn ERENT ae Rs Se Re Se Ee, SteeSat NSSateR5-50 RSOS RENN ae aes NeeRD OOOO 5S.Bs ERR i hetceceaeamisnens aa 5, eotncete samen Reet onsSni Oe SER Bes TRCWeer Se SRR areca SLEB.. co Sky See . TESS 5 oe aR eR Setanta

: SURE RR EE SN eeSR cee eae ne aneSRE eetcaueuuaberiet see ai Reearenrste st ME ‘ Beet ieee eseSE se Re RMN ee Lo SIDS a Sg Se SALES Seren See eeoreee GER S UF RR52 anGNEE SBe< ee eae OS os HSER 2te Iaie SSae RR a greta SSS REE RSORG SeahOA a ORS eee SB! SeeCOR RnRee Ces Sa pee

we _cd eae ieepeas SEES SRD aRa ORNS SERRE ae gosneer SES Sie aclES. Se ae EBRRO ee See RE ers ae .pr TER eaRRR LtSeeeoo, gSeeSe eS OM re SEES Ne ReRSET RE RES SER EUONN NCE SOUR AES.” ERROR CN RR *esRe ME ee ee SeGEER ee ee eeCe oS, SE tan ISRBBN Sees ices iinSUS Re SeeSOR RRR NeaShea eae Care ee aesves 2°27¢+¥sRa ~ TRE RS ele SS Oa SPREE. Nr SURE ERIN chs ie SCRE RCS Si See Behn ea See TRO SUR cee aa BES ~ eer SESS Be Co) BERR ESegsc oh Soliant soe re Sa aie gS HEARS BRASS SRO A sR a iaighe ea OUEOREE STIS Sa 2 a SER CRS ft” RR ES See ced sy i Parsee: cae pang SINE ge SE See ee Sea See eSPEEethene SOR SRSS NOTES SESS SE Sa ‘eget SSO eee Soe | “ oe meee I SE Fe OS ITN NO~ pera Olek ae ears NSS. - || Geen aeesRES: ;.Re iis Cen in a ss RETEE GRR REED OTTecyamaameeen EEE T NRO CRONos arePRR om REHERS Sean EM oe eee MERE ara CONN, OR SPLINT condSantee Tee ree,yy Se ela SRRORE OU = "ERR Sa sees Ne Sa

os ER Ee Re Eee oS Se ee ee a er A Be SS a

Co RAL Ea aa Gs OS SS ee Fe A ee ee ea ie eS eee ESSE RUS A Ree es Soe

“PRES _RR aa Scan ee OER eeaeRAE eaeReaD HARASS «. anes ekg IeBn AGS SRE. eei Ssono rRREE OR ETSERMRES, es=Oe 3EMER Bee Se wy eoae SORA SRS cae NRO, Se Sia ee Seterormees ORRINaRoeRSBernaiteree aise aaa aOC antOCP RIN Cate. RSD On Aen oeaRe SER NE: nocRIS 0506...» ae BNR eee an aR SERS 3 CEREMONIES LIERDRESSES Se RR NRE RM RESIN, MERI2 BA Soa RE a CER S:=8 ER SERRE EEA OR eeSSRN SeTROON ny Sitges eee,SeRRR SaSSS Se SE eeORec. Se SaACRE i ees Sek 3 pete Sere 08et oe ostCED) IEEE ISS Sao lala IE a SE Se RAEN. CRC teakEN: See eID Sta Bag nc ee “1 RRS aes SRS ENR ROBE SERENE Scan ip eget herenes eet ee ENE

SE ESS RGh Soe Sr eg Ses eras Boos. SEN*.name IIR amteae ES oaUST “pee? ot 2 DEES ICUS SSeS geDRM SR Pepsin ORES ERR RR auanepmee OREO BSc aie trees Fo fateh fo eee ER, Rae ee egSEIS ae 4 oe RR FREON peers . Sees .SX .«-% cna PRN eae 0 Sine

RNS Sain, - eae OS po GR LIC an ponainceoescageney os 1%SSS gedRAL eeORR, ESWATE & cota a s+eee eeae a eeeee ge ases se. CEE SRO GOO SER Sa toSS RTT ND” OMENS reoe celetet cehatetete tee ORRERE oN a VRE +RRR - _” gas: LER RES EUUe SOON See -.+. eee. 7 Ra:2:SEUSS SESE SERIA Beee ees Baek oe ‘Cita SS NG teat gee ee egeeRe ge = NRE RINSee ST res |—IUI PERE SSS RR aSOROS ahoe SOS TE EL JtSau aR A Fe Di ES an _ otSan Eee ee een S| a Spee a DEEEGE SECREESEES REMSoe RC caiios aa See eae,pe BeAS aA atin CRE So ERR ST RR TRRes eeenonte nathan ea RS ;ane rr “gh ”aSee. 2ooEEE Soe ERATE, soomemae Soe SSeS eeAS ciate SSEEReeonOR nee ieRise ee ee Qokenint nasae cnnl aantyeena | pee SAREE es Cesena ae pk Seater eae See ius TS Sarees eats Ree ae Se a FER SO RE ROSTERS SSSR > euSnnn Sapam pO RES Sen 3 Senge oan duane eens cece een Sanches Ne SOUS SN RE RSEE .. hice eee a Ses Oe ee Bebe ee o RRS os be RRR 5 n, ARATE « Sai oS ee "ee eet | Sa eerecne Sea See RRNT NS) eget SSO a PISS SORRENTO Seana SER. SS ee a a wtp pes

in? SK SRO?” RRS RR SRR eR RRR RRC CO, © SO AGERE: NRT © A SERCO i RDO OR § SINGS ALAS AS RSS ae | epee

SS POO 5) -Rae. Seon”. 9 Siete eeu anh Re DAON / SRR, OREO SRE ORR REESieste RODEN, «5 SOAR RIURGN PRE Sh LL SRR = OS lool: ae SR eae GEES CRG, TREES, SOSTeas R RARE RIERA ay cA. RR ts SOR SoeBe . oe me NES Soe Seana: RRS SAASRRS SRR SRS ENRON RRRESR 82cn SLANT Saas ee ne SN 6 Sie Tees se Same PS SOONER ae ae ESR AN ERG, SEER ERODEN RO te«Roane SePore, POS "ROE, Senate SEMAN RENE sonos73 PRS PROUT SC REI, DESaes SEER . . RROSSRE «See, aa de eee1a pt oh NEON, Soeea nEarcana ER CRO ie RSea E ORR ee Figs eeeea a ee SY ROR, CeSENOS ee iusSRE sane OPAES (ae wtNS oeteMe Reh Se Cesena, ser tene Sega Soe. RS Rs a ca u RRS BS

SS RT. 3 SiS SRR Ui SE, HEE Sy UEC OR OND So oe fete emer MTree eRe, Ca © os cee ee ee | > gi

ices Myf CURE SOE ee era - _ | RSIS RES. Sanaa SESSEA EAR Nog erent aaa CRIES. OUR ON ADO 7 SO REET SS SOA ac OR

BOR aeEEINE SEES eaSTERURN .iaORR,” SERRE.” SERRE Get cance Sint, "ST 27h |ROSS Sua 3a08ERR RR $s apstene 1.SoSR eS ReeDe sae ees OESe a EE AR No pe : RRS - BORA Se TSO SERRE, Ts :MR ZN 7 SEUSS ee ORRER SRDS OLSEN oeEER SEER KN scrian BESS Pane . rnDo RECA ROS NI GotaONER MeN DONOR ROR ERIE, SS eae eees Soca aeCROR REN BaieSES aaaYSERA? Re oe2... SC| a 0ESaeisSS BAC PERO NS Set Ginn SERS Sy Oe CORO RRR Ta. BRB RE Borti: Sere ee ree SoSURRCS SEs Seca ne aT

Pees. BE See pcERE poo eS Te ea* |rree re SEUEEEN? : Ses RN See SENS +se RE oa eS es RE ee mee Riise nce Lson EE3 EIS OR,ae 5AS ROR I CTS o> ee aSRC SHR NOEIRCN DCO anaeCa SSO Sa |seganenieaees RRS ERE, Ske «|S. aa Rape ES Bell SS Bee. Co,OR :eee SSeS RINNE DUN RAEN «=Baa aan. =F Caen, OREN Sai Sse tenet antiotoe etinatin gee eee .Way of ieae oem RR iment ei eae ue, aes it, Ese Cieit eetae eee eeePrey, aeon nS tS : PR fe SR es NRF ReBee LD, :TE MERC : PASCO baig conten SER Do IRS iecums Sess SRO SSR aa Oeilaeie: .meee EN Seae Soh TEER Ro - *. .Ss ee ena : ie ae be What, BN RR Shchkieauini >tS Saeco ee SOE RN Sear SA; . She Sen cea ECT, Se: Nees Tee, Ni aM i RO 3 Res >. LTRS RRO ER, SRE EONS it 222 SERRE ences

ees a. eee i «PRS RS- eeEE esSemen eTSteere aeBES Uk eeee oePe enBei"a SRE A ioes he RE MERE NOOOfe RIES Lope Re "Sith, RN «Sn se ee PSTES Re |Oe EEGs oeBoo Or seg x - Kes Se eas SRaeart aeBoa ae ey etme PORES et 23 RRSRRRSS Doaiereeeea aSe atoenesaae ee MER eerie ea g . oo,eSRae RNS Aeae 9 Sn Sie Ne eS SENS |) RRR ee irranae ae eet apacar Re ay Ra : RB | Sip eeeeireeeepreememenemares 3| BRR ?ttWe a ae ?REE ;NOOR” Rea Ser SgTee CES ae aeSUM is iS. ee Oe SeeSN ene pense ae

ee EROS. OTS I eg SSS OBB Sy RAE BBSSRN RE SRI SOR ENS RO ERS Ee Sy GLDh SRREE Be Sruminonernnntneronmanars «ot: AB SOUR nTLk Loe SEBORNE STEEL PCH ODORS ORS SRG agnets CES cot ache ki RMR onceBee es PSR COR See RTE.” Le . SIRE IQR EAS SoySEE le SeyCee suk m.: Le)TE SeraaERSRE SK Seah St:SS 5 7e. eS BREAU ER eS a teade sa arieier cet etna he SSSR eee st eeie EE Se: ee ton Bae as SRR yoy na RSS oS See*, po Leen, ac Coaateannepoe ON SSReeee 23 Seeaeee FS OEE Se waoFcng A GERRI RESee ern eee i eremeRenemeeti th: RI A Se RS eR ag hee Bs tae ee oe BREE Tk 7 . wBhtes Tit DEEP oT TE Se oe.” Sages AE Steen REET Nae ag ES Ose SEE ANG pe RS ORE Fe eh BECOMES OB Oe eC Se eae Crees: . Seer ed a EASTER URED RES PUENTE oon SPORE pees Es EL SO Tae gee as PX ASR By 4ties By SeeSee REIPe A 5S. SitesRot Fs Soe 0: ae 3 SBS. ee Seite, w; PEE SUE Ree: OO Sopoapee ROE eS ter © ek eSASA ge peu eee, aeeee Sout nc eatnoe Ee Ff eee0 PO es eeeaSeee ASS SGgene eRe Be pay BI Be CESS Som PRe oeBice | SERS Rest ara ; hone ih i asBui eaegkAER NO SagSES aS.eee SSSaeSEEN See Frese santos ee CREO S RSSBo Seas anes RSE ae.a ae oh "SEMA SEC ek O°oehatte aREN Se rh ee 7REMI S85 ORES Ye er Res? >. Bonk Sethe sae utny«We See ee aneEa eaeeee ohse RR RRO a Men

ee BeeSe oe yasERS ee oaee oeeee Ce ee eeeee,Co eeFtSee ee eS oe eee See ING: Geaesae eeeeee re oe. eeeee ee

“TEU aN Serer eae "hes NEES Ss SED SE So Ee a ene a 3 eeeepecorees Fey eo oi See ea sR F058 re OU SE Bcf Rage a, és RS b: SoS Sarena: 3a 2d S54 Soe RES EES CA SS SRS ER "PRR RRS: 5 RRS Pe a RR ioe erat om _. eer te a BES

pee ee 3 Pe “ ” xs Saree RS OES ia. Ray camera 4 ne . Se EE Ree 3 oe oeee EREee 22Seae ee: £me egiieceeiie Bean 2 nee See. ees a 2See xs ReSEP RR SoFSasec eSSoS a iSao_ SaONE po ene Be AEA 3 he ES woo eee RR IS Sas & Re a atee': SE 0" Rae ge Seth. RRR Re Bee aS Bs ee eeeeg 4 ee ni ned toe es eos pi Pe See Ree Bia 04 Se SN Rees OU Bi Se eae ra RR Sa Be gad Bk Re BeNNoeSRD DP A bs see net EROS... 7 pe peepee: oS a ae a “og BSSeca. ee%eae aea Be aoeSoi| ae ac: ; Spee.+2 SRTBs, See © RRR ee Oat nai Nate gi MEN «SORA SEER SS Sees SeisSURES OE LEEED eee Soe RS SP Sane. no RR

. . é = ee you ce ne ee oo @ pa ues c a GEES eaee pe afte oS AREER CESS afHSESs See a Se SE oo age Sena on Dak

PR SBme TQoe. SS& Bt See PER ae nes Ie RON Daisies St Sabin SLE Ry va Sheen Sinton atest rsCEES aR - So SSL,Eee SUEoF SOE SS Reeo: eaeBeemepeentes K SB 5 Spommos hs, aSy ee 3PO eres ERE eek gsteencche Sete PRSRae ee Ppeeese “? ose. « oe aTe. SERS ReES eeeORES Psd eet. ee :roa OL re rncenna ecg oe Gad SUE cao 35 Ie SeRad Se. BR 2° RDS. 5 BEE Gaoe regs "eae. BR 9 WA Gee Sook. , coe ae: Ze Si" ee fae

i sscduamnsenaedi cg gi ce iBRE SEERaRT ae ee. TE ae BRoO Re Eee” Se ae :ae a ee oh oe si Se: SY. oe RRSoe PRE : : CATER oh Be ahES&seeeeewe eeeSRO pee ee eeety ekeceeae Bt pee See ere. Ren SSeS Seis ASRS Sa CB SRAPRSRORS S22 BS HS aos eS COR Sn RS Afanat: Stes RR RE EE ee ee eeEN ee Se oc age oS eR 3 ee

Sh ~ TESS pagepegen ES es pbaRE SagERE. Pg 48BIG a : AS Ss 2S ee ERE OR 22RS * RRS RRRSENS Se 3 ysSFG Pe! SRE & Ab SeteRett, 2 oe ALES a SS Re |FR SEPT 3 ee SBS ee. SBE 3 5 ee ee, 2s eSSRE ORS. % oe xiaBeene Fen re TS Ee ee ae see bao: Sie" wey Ree eee re Lo eee 3 song & ae Ct mel ok “Be 5a Soa peg nang © ae i oe SE, ee Be :

IE rotaRoo) es 3 SOE eo slits aa ee seenvi ae ES FES Beenes otoe >Sn Be OR fol ke sgaccasaack:: SagemSoa oe Le Sass OCs PBN z Beko s Maen RARER L,SOU 23 SRS RRS ee!eee os". €poe aneaSent veRe Bp go appa ate SIR SIS ROY Datagy wee Mgnene ngAee aae aaeee ae patie hee BRS cc RMR Ce Ree 5eeSES ae ane: goers Se2oRRR oe AR SEER SS elaweonaeuegeen ie ROSSER PERE | 5 Fae ROLES ae BRIER See BSSCR yt a oa asesappein ae SORT REFierce oe ay acemem wee a oot. eeeSSS Recher ee ee CSS PPR gn a Rta 2. eeraRa ee a REA Ne SES Rod eee bake : SEA es Sewanee ARES ES eyeeSo: fc aneeee

ES Bee eres ae Ie : eee eo pete Se Re = &- ens Saoa oeSRess ees foSac : enn a ee ee ae ESE Be Becca :eeiSmaf eee ee ISeA DE sn SO Ss eee amsapeee RReR. - . Sigusssian as Sie aSI CIDA Seerdd oe es HE BEE aw eon Se SSS, WBE + oe Jostein 20g 0, eR a TM ae poe gefasSaat ao IS accent geen Sena eh aeee OSee aesSER Seon SN Doi Le Soiree SPOR BSEME te aT CSkeen pearate ee pes co PEO RN ee Racecar sents eer aes SES PUBIOSALSS SSSEES Re SESE ES SSS atcomaneeay Se TR See Sa “see SAS Sane RINEoe aSRY eae UE aS AEDES

oeCefe Se ee eee§L eeOhcrygie e”rtr—r—Ssri—“ co aer TER Re

Beee eedae Se gs ee aa: Se ee AEE SATs We ne Beet Ug MAM PERLE SUR REE oe cee ad SRT SEE IS Son Sahat ie Bee ne SARIS SSI TO SR SE gee SE Ge tO tna SE AS oot. ae ORB

$55.3 oiimiccscameeae eae vipidndecnar ins PtgRE eT Ee es SERNEDU Pte ORE ENS SEES EeSESS STLSe SED A reheat SR EES EeESD Sk EE i ais SEER Rgeeeeau p5 Sree Soe peer WINS I. Sai CEESOS SPV SEER TO USE PS Wei Ra RS CMebie ULE LEE ls seh da, : BI tee tn Saat

¢ SS See ethane BRS CCS Sa he Ue RE ESS "eo ee ieee SLL ge) Pts ne, ESEED oe —,rrrtrti—“(—s—s~s~”:~—~—~s~™SC:~”~”~—~—S—S ae ee ee eeAE a nea eS ee eT ,

etUE ee IS, oS(PGS ES Se EPERIEGAS Se ML SopAPTS eS TE EE Tne ES SESS LT SE Sg ena & 4: eee Po WEee OSE EE,OU DASE CE ISS HOLE AY TEESE TSSARS wht Sey IE TieBETTIS SE Bn MOMME TAne LgSER Lon ants PE =, he OS ER eeBEES os

> clerestory complete Fi igure iens, 33. miens, west‘ facade. Begun 12203 ¢d he rose rose cca. 1500. 1236; tracery of the .

ee oe

SRE : : ee: rete tie +VRC . eS “BSCS Sion: » C0 NS MERA Sena ce Sng RERERAS OOOO Miggtcsea MCR Mt Ll cee ARS tn ets q ae :uh :: .°: wos | -. ;“ae -STEELE oeELIE lee Re eeeR ® eA NaS eaSESS aan SRR ae SEES LESAGE ASR Se ae shige enter EOS 2: TS CSV RG UU ERE SeeeSe Chogecieis Segoe EE sages Leena a CRA SET ALE So RS NSE ey as SS eee SRR. EGON BEE oS eS . - -_a:aa. eesSe aeaRS SOR eae etOG erURS aaRID peSE crprcccmencne eae SSS Stlpie. tee SER yoOR Nee Ang TUN . ne woteeGe a Se SSeS EASE DSS goed Se hg2 OR ALS ESR nhesoeReSeaaa Maths Sek

es . (ok oo ku A sag ESETeehoe cate StS Ney oS RE ORESEygOS SSS MI oe oe ANTS CRESS SUSE, UFRSED pipeecarr ee ©ice soe teat ee: ; SEAS ee DUEL Spo0 hy LS SSS Tt SSE AT DREN SACEE ew oe NAoSBe Cte ng he AeShs ag ee” USIS eniiehane aS Ie Donan BRE JLo CEE SUELO Ste eeTP CSR SRE aUEE ONTEE ey y 3:WL Si ELD nSWANS eweNS. JIL Een. vA Tea .. aee7SOURCES SO; neeUS ec ESE Red Oofoe OE SHR OTLISESEEAS LSE Osa gS EEDee Vn Re iveAANO Sh BS CE EEE ggg EO lg Ua Be oh, MEngg gh 2 NE AGN Bet DOERR ASty ES ent teeSSE “EEE&Ads giBER Te SSS BoEa oe TEAS CT ASA ee RSeg ee A Senet ES. | aUE hee ORR ERS wee 0 SE See BAR SSE EE ee PeUSS Jog aeEEE cocenaneaen SRR . ee: . . foe : Rock GES cee 3 S SS ESE pee SE SSS WARS ID Sees aes CES OR, Eee Spt te pei Leeks nana tag Ba SE TT SO a ee 20 Diop VEaewb GEREN A aps od Be HIE Dee hs PE wee ot” Petre treat. Faea Qo es en tateae Boe TL a we Che, TU eth on SUR TOS Is ASAE et Jee ac RUST Shan OEERE UD BRARR SosOUP ne MAME Late AE SALES Sy BESTEST

ee ee ee te ee ee Ee AE Sal EE ge US a eee

Me Se DE. : : : : ~ aa wa ee Dn Wi RR SESS SESS OT BILE SP LOSE URES SESIGERLEM, DWN han ESTs ay SERRE ei | TEs + ASEM LIL DSA RE RS

SEE a Lege a OIee Tiel ae ae Tle ABE ES “ hee 5 FAMERS SES SULoe Bs Sete CSVES oeeS ios Oe ON EERne coorSESE Pee sie ee ee oer ee ae a.:et 4vis:Ci:ESE ee pecae ne ame ene Set eR fe RASS Sigh Jin ee ag ORE eget A ude Sa SEEPS A te eeRe aeee ae USS anAge ge ARS US ENS. aEUR LPR ELAS SSE“UNSER So SSE Se Aa . aa as: a: ae Boe SL re TSeu.Se WEN ESSE Bo UESSSE VeeCEESSE ie Pg Re SERSPSS MEL oa

MSS ye Og nied ee ee eet ee ee eee a: ee ae ee ee ee 3 7 ee ee Be eee tes COSTA Ee WE Coen, TR 2 Ma PERS oe COP RES BS es Red A ES Cee RN ee

. ae : wee CL LAR SEERA cgTS COPE USES Be O38 SESE I ASEES ERE foaD. cfg EPS ey 00ln USAERIS WLS TStSOg SEED 9Ee CNT Belo) Si Ts FALL SE EASeo EUs TVS PGES TS ROU TEE Bre TEESE TREn DNi Ee ENEacces RIES

.: poe ce eR: ethers Bo EIN MDEE ESCUGR SPR I vst Sg TER INSU Sb.cd erty AR oe WEP opaE 7 En : 7 :les Voownh Ta.TUSES 7i0y 0 hs Te:7 Sek ihe;ASIEN SATUSCaP ae Tae fil LY EM Sr geen fe SUSE OPES LB aR ERE th TT” SSSR SESS Se eee Ny ee SS

| | : | . CUES SEES Bae ee es eon ee DEN OO A BR eS Beery gh 7 Rete aR ERS RCAC.

.. Ls Der Tht MME wh SEEDS LSS5RR) cage i Stina A BRE I et eS SELES) BAS Se SAO JRESRRhOS : oe: :.oe Tee Shaye WEE Eos APS eo Suv ERR ce taeHo SRESE fo tee, UEBe SSS TE, EEL Seac EELS SENS . Lk SOT Bena ROR 0 Be She ee ERS . ae:mK ; we, AEARS Fede oeEen, JRA SES RE ee Ee EESBh SeboESRGT SUS Tis RS US A EINES AISTge Ps So Ra cay aan gaSS ne 2 Se ted SLES aie ee ees

: re EE ORES tab ge) Wee MELAS oe ee. Seni 7 Sha HEE SUS a PRS SCSMES CEEStege Se IEeeSACRE SUTE aSSR eS . .re TatD0 eee eeehse Se Egg STL eeBRR VSR oo:LO ueBBS . et ”Dog Coos JSS URL LSND aeLay cs Scie tte SSUES Rs SS ee SR BEE ee neSAE at SHE OS

.os er ©as ouoes ae =DRee ee a pH RN nyi BRR Tce aASSERT ESESESOES “ : oes2 Doe ened Ui Pacha cageee Sune Es TSS STENDEC eS ESSEIAS ape es BR RO EE oo SS See

. oa. a. .PSR ANE Pa dei? ESS ay Rt EEE ATEN no'sEMSS OE SRE TOES ohana eae ah: 2TEBEEES gegee ByTOSSES RO SEAS: SayDUE SOG he SERN SEs aygeey . ct thy Coe TRULE DAS SS SSSEeo 7SSSNECIRIY Seg SS INSTA BILE SEES ISAe TRESS TIPS SaBRR pCREB, SoSISine SRSSE Se SIE cee ASEeg : . Re DOS 00D LSS ae aSag EE SSMIE Ee SOREL ge REET STIS LS) ES oe SOIT Dy INNoui gs Ns shag teint

“BeSEE SEU Ss oeESS SEES AVES ts ge Tae eBBB CeSSeam aaoeRE OnRese oe ee ae oeaeoan : ee-—a Bae ps7wees SS TESTE ES SUEDE Soest SEOgiEES Pies ES Beeapene

wood ee,Tsfo. :EE) SES ht RR oS DESTRESS Do Be CRE SePeSER SEES Sepce eons SUR SSS SS eg uh: se MA SoukEs URESCO, GRE UESE ReoSR RRoes Sig WhO coi TREES Wh SIA LEES TRON EB JREU2 Ss ae Seg Ie aren 2 Re es RR Escomencpacr oneSE oe PTS RBM ee SES Tn ERS tioSEee Ce ER ae Be BE POD, SES ERE ne at — 7ee a7 |LOY | : 4. :UHR Bitte. Beste te : EERE Ee asRESET LASSE SG: Ree ene - Een Sam SITLL ning utente tein SS Reerpoccretnoente oeeae & . : ee Gerotine g EL RNR Rene LEER Mn hth sviSac SEES wei, Ae ETDSeer sie Set: diet 2Uno EESPSO OR. SR a RTS SUNRISE THT DISSE SS

o . .mAM et ES GRE RS aS Se Se REI DES DESS REDROS SS BeLS Qe Big oe I Be a a ets Shh)LeBLO in Semet whet .7 we no :nO TO Ee ER BEWOM SoSELASSIE es SySS SS cs : oe ST Sie eeea a .oea 8 .Ts : mo Pes DASE SE SRL SS anne Soe ease es neeke et onEE . ee BOT nnee Seea & eS SOLaeer en nt Tu UIE ThsSB Sune ce 4 OSE EES PASE oye | SS Log cg 4 SES ls EE SE re ee ae BIER ES eee eS Ne rae: . . oe od go i i ea ee ee ETRE A Bee Bee EE OR Ee he BR a ob Ise aeMiEE EY esi CISPR PR 8 | :..os;.*7-ne:87.eovecee oR aLye. ee.ris.TIRED 2 Ay CRASS es SE SE ae SEES Sono Cur aiihssscccg LNDAES ttc % ba eee 3reBe Ge PES SedSar &SS RBG ie SSOR Pe OSE EEBRIO aSGD SyIe xiv Seeces yea Oe oe "Us SELES Ls eg ntJ ERs ohh UES oeRa : oo OMRON ee fdRRS MEP Sh! SEV DT SEED SES REE REee SoS Onaanr Ter1)Lane whi RR Le Se UMges igeetng SR OR enERED SR TE SSSETEESSS Tete bs Bs RR oR Sg esMATBD eh SE Deh UuSp STL Su Sse ae eae

5 ah, ee SE ee et AG Ce ee nr Tr eee ST NA ae SEN.oeSO ORS: BRCan 4 DPR ABR2SR De i Choy a. ao Sess geaCe BeVRAIS SBERNER 7a os ee ae SES nSaBR Ee oe RR ges we MUS Eeene Seer CIEE UD DY Atenee sg Saas Ce 4 eeee ee RR LS PSB ABR Softedkenk ages ee

ee eeUSeeeT oe TSS SISESe RS a |SRS a eeepeeBae SPREE RR oo :RN | : pap : aoe FOS Se 5Berens popee Res2>Saas ng Ros Be LEER aS Esee PSUS SEMSSeS Poss: Seeehes cy Eee oes: a sare ee ee eee roess Scar oe a4 TES ee J2.RES 7SORE & ES &ORE i eee came a «:Sees Sakceiiee sosSign Reeoees DE enSSBenge enae Bae: 8 BsSEES See See SST Seeks Re €. SORES - Siteteers 3SeeS SORES

SB sy SAS. etna OSB YS ca! Sic RR ea aa nS “aps atest Spe ees VO RNG SI ella aN, TAR SEAR . al#83 ay Serna, “ge pe commas” TY SREB ” (eae >. SRNRater ances Teenie: Bh SR So SORE: SORES SSL oN oa PE eS gS feces) eee see if BA gee fy Seer: Nna4 er,Poe “ Sipeeieterennes 3: Loni if a S Sook. Siemens: Sarees Cee SE SESE SE [EERO ae wee eeiia 37 ae ReeCS ba eo SEE Ee Ssod re ee | Ae es S Rees ae tee vena ORS SOTERA DOOR IE ana Ni RE ar nn eS ER gg REECE SF races: DS SsAin i NR I eeeerwtMeee CS |RES, ponoae See ©. Area Coe Domenie fy “tg.CR. FSRR ee 2gt ereBeg Be cere or.fA came. i RBRA SeeMe? Dn gees x Se C3 ile aed eas See ae Peper Bos gens teenies PeSo eee 6 SeSees See arr Ge Pe. a a eee Seay Coe. LORS SEY Bape es ee RR RR eee See eR Bag gs Bae ghee Romer Sek “Seperate. Seat SER CC NC, SE Noes}: A as ¢ Bek 3 acti, ict ero Canta RR = Ss Sees pape So Of A ER ee Se RRESS oo eee ge SP RReSOES oeBees Dereon Ss Bat Goeetoy, Rese (oes See ERO Yee BS Se PUES oF res SERIES Se eS FREES gt ae Rone s ER Re . re ee ee nC SEES. POSED R henere : ee, ee. Sees ey Sse eee SeIrSaORme Races, £3RE PdPO ecSe: SRUS ©SS SGPReSeneR Ser ote aN RSS gr SoeNeeeS, a Bee Paper ETO aoecanoee te SE SS oats, Bo Sie Bee Brees ba ae ta rie aprSo 9 OS RR. anaes See” FS Rae ReeSREk:: Be Se. Pea SRI ER x Barres Eee oe * as >. "Rib, See. 5 eesBOS nietRg Ss.Fee. "Ba eee SRee Ske F "easier Be Beek Semone Bie oeee Ceee eeesiStar esSee af“ Sasenens oF fe Pie 8EEYE SE Piso meats Hee Pa eee EL |Mens aeeee nrrere tals Satay fens Saas See Pog at eS « eee ea S80 EELS SS RCE 3 a . Beers | St "pee 9 Me Se eseee Bis: er Seas Seen Be Rr i ged Ser oh > RS: Seas Baws Somes ve. Noe: L cipentine : = eR ge oe So ie sin: 33 eis the FS og Soares Sig. Poe teeOR AeoSGee, S Seeretien «| cae 3s ee $3 ats eo Bae See ae eeaOe. ge sea ee SR Re sr£33. Sriram Kies coe oes SeeAe eo See Pasa Se BARE Ee Be 4

nem %, eae ge ES ip NR a Re. S:BRR Be ERROR, Be EES ae Sr Bo: aS £3 aa Fi eee ng Ces a ce. fee See. Gaps. pe:EeRRR enLoe ssee aN St SE. SS i3 2© Onea ss Dek BieRe oceete SER ae RRR, BSBays EERaee Rae tS£eS aSIREN ee TS eeeeeee £ReneBee Be 8 eeeS ee eek Me ae2a aafree Cee mene eseee See EC par eeeeeee aa a SR Re g..” Bae hi ann’ ES “SRE aereeaeemeee patie. Cea Rig ANE Se ce Some RES. 333 OSE EER SRS OR: : SS a3 as a RRR pS ee “pares F oe 3 Say

Oo es eS ee Re ee ES ee GS Bee eee de SRS OS SE

DE SI _.'FSR piaeceatera 5 nearer a, a.poy ORR.8SRE. Bs Sete $B Seer 8. 2aRa aie Sy ee eee coe Se Snes oe ee ae Boece. omenatBe Sag5.ieanee “So3.3 Sia aaa ny. S Sia ee So esPte Sees SeReman a Bae a Ss aeSoSoe SRF aoR te SMe er Seen, ete... 4 RE Se aa ee: OSRresSpas & 12BS ROEDER he eee Se PsFOG FREE el BS ee OS ae a aSee Nia WDD aeEe anne a RS at nes i dir ae See RSRRS | SESS. a

yO Byae3SeRe Be:Cees. ee SS. %. ad pe ae (oe + OBS BeSaeco tgs ReRes ee SBR SRR ee eeBOO eee aeSkeek SYS Rss FvBER gy ae SS, ie Ok eammeenE he ie.RS eeeoS. eenS atone 3 TS ES3 a RS So Sey enna * h. Someneeee fmt.ater | ene, : "SBS BF BS eeRae ame Ne SORES SA SEMIN aa eee eBRE nS,eaten Se aneShs 3 | = ,_aes | eg. e‘eo ERS ee ee SSS eee eas SRS iS ana. RSCaReseatinee. 5 “ Me SEE SES RRS SOSA,

y- "RMR SSE is8aman 54 -SeJee RR se ee £Shoe RaSas Ox Sone RR a Sea RET ke at Seas oe 5 RR a See. Fem Soi. BRR Re:Re Se Stee. Seo ears.” ARNO SIIi RORROORN Sie: Sane - ee2 eS. aoe eee ee oe ekSSR eeeSEEN | ies TN aSRE NIPee llS eee aitucs Dees

7 7 eae oe i oe Bx Eee - ”aeneat. ea “Be a alSe g Say gonaestie: etae seas Se: t Se

a S —Rae . ma:2 2. Cee “BS eS BesRe BeeSe “3areas fs SRRCee Senna Re Se, Boece Re Ty tykeBREA EL ee KS VEE: Se&ee SER ee esas SORnae, eseeieee ReoSRSear pers eeSR Pasyore ee Ree eae eS eess

ta ee: Sk Ree 2 eS Sa 8 ees ge Se a Soe ee oy aes ai RR SS S59 gre Sar a BESS Sans oe Soares Rg Dee nr |aRSfgpa ae eeRE22 Cae seSaRRS Dae See ee tepoe Ree FSR oases See poi eesSRE RE ave ge Norco OS Ue SSS wee,pat SEO Soy on Se os. Sas eS RePeete ES Se ar Soet oS aSerer: RS Pp BE Se aie.SS eeeates oe EARS SEee Sara . Te“TEM a 2SStiSR teres BoaeSRB See Sik “Sees eon cee. Se. Ia eee coe ts OE ES RR BeSa

;: a: en Te EERE * Sek Coe- eee Ne, RBS. Oe ee: Je Seas oe Be ae EC geet SR. en: Sai Rn SOS heesSRE RBiesa ae pe ee sig a ee he Snghey oeaSee eee Se cn aOR 2st Seon RYOS RPS. Beame, Be ee Siete. (EE Ot ln, BR ERSeeOSE reeRS BR ESS Bee Bo SR eS Sones 2 fee eee Bee FS ee of Soe ae BRS gee ee TS een a Tye SI ELLCESS TEN od aNish LAIST gt SLES tet SRve BRB . aE RS SS le& See.peas ae ae ae ee ae Seaieety Se Doane eee:ee Rie,i See ee SRR Te CUE le sage yeas itiRES. emia EES SS RE oo ae ee Se aL3)a

. CSS TEINS te Sn US EE! SOWIE he SOTERA See SS pe Be Sea Beato toners sonceass Ek :: |) Sapo ee BR a SES ae SO. Sieseas see see me ee See SOE eecigeaneas Sag RE A ee gt rere oe eeeBe eeees ee ae oie eee Soe oeeae pea cc Bee eo 4 Bee ee Bhraens ee onesES oe Ses Tage! eeenoe SSoe RS GE ESfo PS peBepee EG SUS ef

ae ge ee oeeee Seeee et.ee Seeee ESS: REE See ae eae Cone OCR esaeee Bae ee ES$ ee Ps es SS ee aee3 RS ee Pe a fe ESEaeens wars See

aa vee ON er aD hg ee TADEINRT le DESI, SPN OS et I RL tc PE GeT DDSI ety J OSUREE gt ADRS: Set Set PRE ieee ps CAEL UIE, SLs: LOSS SEES “ETRE. Ba Sg opts ee Bt ocgmumneneniin cs Sane ne Sos

ee aeea ee SESE AS SE SSS Ses DG Dag AE Shoe RS) es QOS Seon sey SI psecSESE Rien Roe ExCE SSE: te wes, ge SESE SSE TERE ‘ eg acm AEHERE wiles eRegTEE SRB OTBS: van RO, ee TBS MEE oe Ses ak aeeaeALI seeEe EEO ee a Ley SLESe SE LETte EN. eB ae SHEE PS WE URS ES OOS Teh ES SESR Be SRR eae cee

eA CORRES SeOaths 2S AEA ESS AY NS HEUER PoSeen eeSESS ee Searen ere EEE aes a Seoat aeaARS M TS Wt UO ERR VRS) OUSSTIISMES TD.ee Ses ta “Cage Si OSVEE SSS Ran LSE BONS) guaSd cvaeT OnOE SPUN SORES SS Se oo Sa ogedBags TSEneeo2 SE OASIS is aT oh Wey ne Bos NRBESESSS CUS nSPOSSESS SSS ES oe AEMRA COONS SS ES SESE ULE . Joe UE UE Sead Se Be ee, Ea “LARBisa yy nigra CREP SEE PBeee ER SS Sh la Ld Se teES ca Seen fe PA erPDS Seublby ee,27TERS oSSsae eeSEESIS ee PePEE SRCEA RESoEy BOSE be eee eS

oe pe ee oe ee ee ee a ee aa he BUSSES Dy pe RS Ee Pes i CLES, ESSE De) DM. STERN Ss Sooke See Ss : Serna Pes ire see ho he DS DELP TESS Bo ae pa Rs 4

a no esSue Daeaie roc,SUS «ReaUL 2 DSS SER aTS - rane Seas ree CERCCRRIS, theSos BEESige Se Sr oes Moe SO OnRRR ere Oe SSE Shean tee Sammars SAESTALSS ivi ScCc nay ine feiienecnneet Sey a Senet Tog. fees BR es a “ha UISTDR shEB QnShe ate SS ageEES SES

. . ‘| es XRe 4 OhEPA, oe re CTL SS te Bose eC soos. eS -e eeeSaas ee TE ere ha On a .\ ON, Fexiecesibess eanes ERS De ES LESTER URES UIE DAaK a°a OLB aR Na Bet ghee PaO Se Sone Saree OEYih E oeSSS es.EELee ee SeSSE RBs ER seRES ieSSss, ieMBER GESeanESS eon ARS RR eiSQUTSEt RS ai rn ee --Bee cuesPE re eee ee ee a (OEE SSS Soe ples) SRS. Reece om SRS BU Sy BE ER sg Semecoc %Soa ees es ARR gg See cee MES, SES QUI ies alice Seeca eens 3k: oe, ae oe ane LU eg 2 eased Sebte-ee aaee edon Pee Se Ag oe afo°See Sa ee Ofee gg we: .| : Po Be} See sae SPgs StSE eSBee aeGe a ae - Neg 8Be: CS iS aes MO oogees fs es eee pe5See See ae SS SeeRe a riche = eee Soe ee: ae Pg se ee: cSeg Coa eSJy ees ty:Sean ce omenrses ee oe ee. i ee Sees Sees fe See SES oe PSEcoe StasEge SORES oe os eee SEEN ae eee aeae* Baie Bo Bomenes.: Se ee eeBEES esee S:Sapte a: ae os odFe —,Seee Oy aes: - Sees ARS rated les, Pest anisnonn eta Se Sy See Se UES ge a SRR ty . saetoesmennc one... eo Bye oo. cs See ee Bes eee 5 peg oe Ses Pe ee Gin ie ee aa a ae? Fe ES Boaae acer PeeSy ae _ eee PBR eee Tee eeSee esBcaeaaSe. SSSie:oS Cae SeaeST oeeege rycSPe

oe 3 Bg ge ae oe ie ae : Fg pe ee ZL Soe , " £8 fos

es SESE ecu soe oe ° oe ee oo aa ae eeBees: gee eo~~ : Sooo 5 pesercre seem | Sey Sameera IRE cseS SRB 7. Poea :Bae PERSER Be Re Pope Seeks. SePaes ei Seon gies Perrererss 2a Rees eee | Be re“ fe Lee fg SiaaeeG Se‘eee Pea aan Se a Se ae POSES Seas 2 eS Sg PEE se SeaSree CEES Seer” - ee SySee Sooaene a, Seen: POO aren. Seana & :RS gee Bee nthe’ 34 wofee Lge SE2gtaSSE AE eer SEE Bago MoeCn gyVite Reis= Sass Remco a RESSEOD eens Sgt =”Se Ree panna OF * Meee t = UES TASES weeny EES igShales fos: 2% Be See i cma RSE ORSBee os arrest otsaaa” 3 Sateen. ae Seman 7.BN. hf “ee 2,sgRS ee ae >. po erBROS ae Shee ee«Te S eee: Tae ¢we Se Cag ag aes Rite Sareeeeer: Se 2g Bae. ee ee oy ae 2 Sa es soomeene ees Peg Be Pe a Sy Reaee io see ee a ~~ {pe nye ee SESE So RS ee Be ees ae ho 3 Ff eee Ses ee (a: a es Rak. tee eo eee Se oa * eee aes SURES

Ba Be ee: oo Bree g eee Sean i aes Poo pga ee, ° me {tiie Sree. eg aS eR

wo: oh tee age SS Serre hy SEES Beer ae Soecsa -Se! eeeEo see Bee = en.Rees ray e eee pce age a eee Ee s eePeg ¥ aerate 7 ee eee eee a Racacss SS eae BS ae SgSOE es ee oe Ee ices. EES agoemec Bee Seer mevishat ee Soca : eeSn pSpoe #x 2=cena Seen Sree Seer sa : eo ee oe ae Oe. SSSR Rae! ats a esSaERIS et aees - aot See sng Seen no SOM eeeSeer. o Sates. SyonFSSaSees Seset eg ae er BRS eS See ae Rrcny Rey) Seana fen BS:SOROS eae a aesONS os pies Sa aes: Bee Sermase eesa ae peer. ey #. SeSeo 2 * Seeman eee Srespaeen sRges re ig saeeast x Sennen hele CEES Ee Se Se pone eto Sage ce Sie 2 EY See, gue aaa S46 ee gee Ree Seep ge emo” $< Renee Oe See eae Bese Saar: Beh. Sa SRE ES o: eae oy Soe = ee

Soe Re msBereos: SN. ’ aaa Saree Cea) an tae Bares Son See SRSoe ion eens Es tS Cr SRECL bap Say 33 pacSeer snes ae oe Severoatee. Pee aeSoe ESSReet, BS BESS Sree Bees See Seted Bates: ae See RS seeseerheeencd Saeco Cae Sees ee tiagg eSee. See Pee ees.uae oes ES, USE SSEES Ss BeSaagSeER ee come See Soa seen Cr ee Seen eooeFee ei SeeeeBS Seeeeeee ae. Pe aeRea

eer Sots ea Be. a ne ; = oe [if =. foe eg : xf 2 Sepa Seen. ee aE ee Ris

BETS RE see eae oe: eae ee hoes eee eeeSRT aSion Woes ee pemee oe awEgeee piece se.cone Rees:Sane tanie ios Spteeaesoreness, Se“agence psc SEN EEE DoSLES SEESE SRE: “e Seen ee RIESE ee gsSe SSeS ee StSaee sae .eessa ge Sepinned Pies es Beene omensoases esBe eee oe 4 = Se SEI OEE ai Se tt aaa Fe+ Tg Sager zSg TS Sears EE ees aee Seie eepent: sane: ae Oe < eeRs me:Pe pate winnerBassas: Se sets i OReS

oePepsa.eeseS, eee Le A a ee ee Gee Pon 2S fee ee oe eee |. ARS ge. See OF ao Se SE eesinee BESS SEL S Pee ee oS Sees = Saat oa ae Se 2 ag ES ee ee ca Pau ee coe ‘St LAGE RES Be eee ee eae ees oie + Seam Se Coe, BeeS eee Be SB seenSie eee pecoet BESS eg gS Rae = a fe DOU Ly Seema tig ee ST eeSoci ee SapiSees oa Jee SSoesaan st Saee Sessere jeae er PetSeer icc rae Seater Beeeee Sesser ESSoe peneRess i aa

eal JERE BeBe a cae peter sae es ieeetnes: es 2eRee a see ae ee pe Bb ee soe ae peeeoeai hr hLrhrtC PES SoeoSRee Beoe Sree BR ae PS ts oe Og Re Pe ae SoS ee Ra ot FS Sere eeei Se eR SEE eee OO

a Sam fetes ne IE ee. ie Reh seca SMa aches DS Sania Retreat” *. Rn Saaeeaa Nae TD ae oS Se Se eee ae are ee Seer. ROO RNAP a ar oe Scomteeeen Rae sot Ba ie ar aes spose CE SE ER SS Papin Se Sa f ag EE, PERS OS aes PIE 8 : ee _ ee " oS See Se Be. ee Bees aR 2 Pe 8S See Br as _ 5 eae :eS oeaes ESS SESS ae ae area EES ES ff egPees 2yr ee 8 eae pmee sees Bs eo ee 2oSee seg aeefg FoR oY ateeSee Poe eoeeeooRs es3G. oe3Sr~~ “ae yy Fe Saree e oe eectSeay eeeaee Re eee eres See aoe Fees Re Sees ee Bibeeeat eae 5 SeesPERT “3 ERR. Senet: 3 x a Seger - . |.SOS Sore DOs LES segetnens St BT BAe me PORpetiiCs SES Sean ae” "Sa ae Sean an > Seeoe SaaS Saat, ets eR.Stee aieSe eas SS NSS>eters os heeSea as piresenss LRP oe NEES peace SU cae Sar See Sains a.S,TE ESET Sole ges pepee reteng eee SSShawne ReSRT Bee eeoe¥Sac Beota Stee BS es 5Seer SS ES SOiehon Seen siemens SL ES Ses Roe Ses ai ioe ae22Bo SohBP Se See ot ier BiMR ee nae: a Pep PEERS SeeSeen TESS a“EEE ake ISR ESfg a.eefee es Seemann bees Seen ee eaeee ene Scaeeas Rae Seeeat— ache on rae Pe LesesPoa ens aa ae BerStenomernare ESS oe se ee eee Spee arcane Ss Ree Se os aMR foeEten mS oh ee een. Fe : ae: eeSe " Spee Sais a SAEED ESS EE sy een x 2 ee cigs SRE oh 2a fF eae eae. Sa BB te eee, Sere se ERS. See oie eee os ee ears Sarena soe we PERERA: SENS SES one” = Eg Seer Bas ae Pe ee Bee ie Sa. ee" eo ge rs Beg : See Soe =

Bo as eee oe 2 ae a ‘ 2 foe oe See, ae ee oe Cs gh Re aes aoe . gers

wag BRE RE URE: Ee Sa ES ane eee ee rt ae tees eee 5 eee - eS Bee yee Be eee ¢ pais eS eos ges

ee a “3 - oe BE BR OSE ae fos -f oF Pe eee ee

caer Ses ERS ORES. ee deers eaeES fs eg poy aes Ps Se: 2sere = i ES — ee eaeSaas Bacar ee ags So ae ce TEES LAE ee eeeages SeeSE Sarai Saas ee ees Roemer ea. & Seer 3 , Se . eee. > eee

PremeraRES SSeS a Sree Sey PEEsae Ce een Te ere See SES geceaaes PaCS i aae Ree: Si eee eS eae ae eae Para e.eee conewe Se See Heme Fen ees ee Reywe specge See ee eSateaBey apemoe COREESE ee rrere PRS =.Be peere Bee SS SoSSesSetar SS 3 Sees eeaena SESSR RRR AO. Soa ae Senn SEES rts Sg peice Por: sie deme ariaae ae § See CSEGees nS es ene See. 1Bn sake” ee canny,Se aes Sees has eee ae REO, aie? - SS Be LSE Bane ee aesRca SES PFSra ee PREne 2peoae. feeae eaees Bee ee oF See.:SeeSe os Seg SocCsaMee po ge aca Bese DEE ee ee Be Ce =eeaner: oe ee aeeee RS5 Soe RRR ie CBee ee See aeBae Baeee ay a gee re ae

BE eo SUSREIIASESS Saree SORES eng BR Lex a Re Pine 8 Be co ca eee: ieee ees Spee Seat os Soa oe ZR ences rT ee OC Bey Rare x Bee Bey 2 ESSE Se es oe ae “ee Sof Senne: oe ef ee oo cg es Best ee ES Bere ee eee LA Sao Beige SEES oe eeeae oeestes me Pe2s aan SoeSOURS ees peer:pains aaa 3 eee : Seeoe $79HB tia... >Tie & 2& fF - «|. fee 2.3. he #8i gee -'iij# e283 | §o eee & FH, fseeA y/ eeSe 2gee ee zg. fir Cee Ses? Cee oe eee ee.. ee fe Pe oe : fF ; Cee eres Eee ee, ne eee: fee

ERSoa rk BgSees a dB oldagen ee aei ee ee a ee iPe wee. ceeBoe + en ea Re ORse 2eeapate A san .: i © Some foe wart gee ee Ue. oe ie ee ee Be Sen wee a Mee A

.22eye 2. ne ee oe Pte | a eer a a feeBee oeree SS eee By ge. itl eT OCee))hClUOZZK.ti(‘“‘(‘(‘(‘(‘(‘ Ga CRS SSReamer St CRneER BO SRE ag et gSaes eeBRR oe ee ot: Dares if 8 Rs A RO Bae hk Tg SR ee eee. Sovee ooEe RSC ee SR eanRR ee eeeg te Oro ee ee 38 ses RANE CR oe FEE

SRI CR RR eR eee Dake x SUMREn pn eait: Sat, SRR ROO nE Oth Sten sh een > Saree BEES SECON BRR ae Be RSE eoteeers ahs MS IS 7 RI SE RE SPs + Saeed Py:

RaORS eS SRR em oe egaeicNeo areTERRORS ey eo ieee ee BeRRNES ot See\SCO Sa .EEE RS ce REEeMC ee. aeeeakee eeSS9 ED CeMRO ty BSR SRRgato ee RRS, ES ee RRBeS a CR ROREENS TEREST TOE cae: 2 o

OO NC ee ee eS ae ee 2 AY Bf ;

Beer: hs hee AE RES Se RR FR RR Sc: ORS pai eetiean Stare a SOA aSS BE ROK SoS SER RES SONCRES. UE MMO MER SEL Gtitnieet °C Sasa Saker ena a 2 ae MOE 5 RES eee ee i Reese eae SeRnR EeSORES ES aeaneieON, Reet et SeeROOTS. RR. GngPERE aaa eee ettaeete Fis TBRBe BRS, RR oR RR SR eae RRS fee oo RRSoe RESBe SE Be Sen CREDO ROE. tk, SS SRRENO aS oeae Samelt BAe +:§Sy£2 meee -$ 79 1

BOs.» Alas eae 2 eee oe ee ee a ee ee o's a CUR ae oe Phe Oe i: Be Be ae % ee ee iis eee 4 Be aa ROR: On PSA ES 3 Shae Oe Gee Oo Sees Sees eS ; SSR ra ao 4 es .comeeS SOMES ee SEM oe SOR SS Rg aoe

ERR ESR RRFAY, OR oR Beg ye OR RgBP ae a RO AR a tote NP ey ag Sc BSREee ae, a Re po ee Ee Boys &Be Od ee IN Bya Re ReRAB EUpehSO Raed 8 bd Ee

RA eR BO ROR Se MR Ct) eS: SRE SESS’, ORG Cece SE RESER. OU: Caaa-- Sea RRn Ceety, Nt SRRRRSNS TING, SBD ROOM CDRS SOR SERED - BREE oR eg ood gS ea geo SR Sa

TE A AB Fre ‘Be CU ee ce a ite .. EB > Tio selek ae) aa ae Se nae Veen” of SaaS Fooee S, TEE SR oe gp VE ag es Dy oss ce 8 rea Pek 7:5 SY eS ee Se ESS “FEE &: ried SG. FS eS ReenGce. Se SRR SERRE OU SSK Scemaer Sc Sat caer SRO att oo: Saran CR Ser ok 2 “Sea PERO fk MOR PTT LENS AY” © gS Sen | RS SES SSR MMOD 7 RR SR Se

(SRR SES SeeROR. SR SEER GR Ro ESE REESE RRR Rte, CNEL SERN. SOR RS Seen ORE BRSen OO SCF oe Meant, Be eyB See: LOTS SRD SMES £.SAE AS as arabs Faas RE wyOw Beh.) -.” See Rese SRM SOR ERR . PRINS PGeNUEN SueBO SOND SERRE RARaa- «AB TERNROR aS \. IRCCS CORRES ine2Soe SS FSR US SANREY fe AB RounaE 5: Bt oO aSk: EROS BORE FD ARES 3. Ressoae SOROS 25°: Sata MRM ARR. On", SOL.SRO SRR RREEN Seca OO? 5: SROSane IS He: -SURES | eR SeMtaeBkPKS:

csSaSeen Sear a tetas SeesSeeg BS Sark get RNi PREM a ee «BR Bee Eee PR Beg ORL EN aS SES nARB Ree aaa tee co2 > nea SE) Skod SOREN SOMME Co.or Xfog Naa SUS Sep NON ch cain en:FES SES. Be CRS SS RS eS eS RR ee Re hg a ert eee ea se Be ee she Bad SSaaS. Scan og otpone wl $3: ee ss :SACs See Se a BOS Sith x: Sine Rene aes 74 aesRe Bacoe: socameien:. ak SPR. atesSPR f5BSR RSES ag Be. hos igh ng ae OES ScSeer: : Seema = eeAyAX 4p eeWe ee aame. Be& te gg Sg eae Saco Seg Ree. Ree peas Be ae” Seem ees BLK Soar eaa Roe eeRR Ss = RRR. Se Sai |aSOR eaSree oR a REET ORO CSE: | Sumer S|. seRoenaenen Ss cS aes eee eae aSak eee |Sane aa eeeSS, ane eR BREMEN ine PRRRS SL RO. SDRC regen tO 6SS: SRRaaa ANEBaas: SO Seas: XRT I cs| >, ce rs Mcreeeanattatea BIE fg ee

Reva es C= A lA ee cr Wilit sorrow i itifft| # # BNN GLETES S/A ENN GT ti) 447 Oo

Figure 43. Villard de Honnecourt, interior elevation of Reims Cathedral. Drawing of ca. 1235, Paris, Bibliothéque Nationale (enlarged detail).

Se ig ee be a ea ed tr a RES Po RS 2 es aes oe ee: ee

Be OSE 0 ORS EES Sie aie SIR See Sa a SE Se Re 3 OR os SOR RRR RS, SRR MRCS Oa OSE RES aE Poa So eR Cem Sees oe tie eRe ere SMM coat g RN eS: RM

Sah Seees Saee a SS RR!eS é SSSR "AS TB SE "RRR piscine Ql east 3! SeenTESTERS & ae am 4 Bi Sete). "> Re StSOR SEE RRRS oe eR EGS BR Rtg ERD SEE SRR oe RR BratBOE Beato BR a Boo SZEGP aI aFas TUN aeBiss gh ce, Tie CR ee Se SR aS PRRR ESRB SsENCE Sit.: «SSSiemens = Pee mes Paes eee Bes Se er ee? eee RR Be:. 2 Bneee ROR oyte) Be al a Bg ee Fsere BF Se ae PSR Be SRR SM4SMES ae SAM SN SSR eT geenfoBS oR SOO SR RRSBR RR CS Re

as. 2S RR Be BR.ieRR BEangeschazeity Yo USAR wontROR SO SERS Ro ce ge Bi RESO SeerSa 8. MR - Seeteny Be BeRSF ROeyRG enRRS SE A SeSES Oeaan SM as, SAREfae RCHe.SeFeRts Sse 2 nS A ~eiBecca aS RM CRESS RCS RE AR Se >RS Se CSR

RR BS Rs ae er 3 oe. ate Ske eet Seek ae a aoe Ses am. See eee | og CRESS. gg EU PO CEA Pe oto SERRE Saga eS ae Ba Se a«Ae aeSR a Sa ee ae aleSsSepee cae: as Seg Paes ee eeeBeottySR ee ge SESE REE ag SERS RR SR i” eSaa gee: RR SR t aeaSneesEEE: Lg CSRS SSS 7 SURES go PSE eS ER Ge SR Be BRSER RB BS: SB See: 2g See ae ae ee eee Seas Se Se ee er ee Be Sooo oo" eee ghd. EE ed Man RSS? Be Be es eee D Bow Sameer. SARS Gee SS eek: Bee stk: 4 % Se Be ie Sas Soe Sone aeSBR at ee See eg ca Sm SSseigee ee i ee, ee ee CO aSeteSE SeSee eee°, Seam as ES. CoE aa © PeAeeC ORME ee So Bee ee See By 3 TERR BRE BO AQ aR RR Bs Mpg TARE " aes SD BS ee ES SRE SRB BR geo ge See Se: See: RE BP oa: a SOR SE TOS SM SK SME SOON OCORRRY SECON Soa MRMESY Sete ee RNS SEEMS. SSCS Joh eo a " to Se Batis Sos eee SOL WERE EO NS ig oe CCE ‘ RSSe os, SS: Re OESe”Be BR BR RRR CeELSEBO SEE Bg Aes RIS SRE oO RRRS.Rg 3-ORMOIRRET? fee SEER SERS tsSE: ERS LR TS 2 Begee a ase3IFBe Ries: ieen Seem: SoeCeo: aen Sea. x nnSess §epee hg a SRST Pa REA Do neh? LAAN ISnag PEERERERRAR RAGES AMMEN IC: MERITS aps ant Saag RR iia SeSERB eeeIReeRSee Site SaSee Seaoe” aie: Me © gee DOE CEESESREEE Sot nah SS” USARREST CSREES gE oe SEER AS9) se SR So NQEERES %: 0PahREREES BCR oe BR DS aR Se Sie Sie «oe Me Se as Se Beans Gees ee ee a ae [0 SERRE Es go 2 ARE 0 gE a EE co ey Pee era Se CORRES JR CEES

BR oe/ iEE. aeSRR: Sie RL Sie See SRR Soa*-isSE=SRN ie Secaeemnabor Oe. SiS “St SSSR. MaesSteen meas Ae kolone 7 CRRRESo Tt Se. ee-eS SeSan) MES SEES MM fae Tos SO ISS SS RAC EMO? | SOMES AP Sa wip ces oe noes ter Gnas on DINGS See INN Ser Es AND 7 Se See te . CSAS: ereES ree etl carers sa ee ‘2 BBO RE a!aeSiS. ie to earns ek aSSoeSEES ApEsSESS PS UBER EE, eee oe i Brepeecti MEET Ser anes ROR. SSENS. MENMIN ir o ESS: OSS & MERME. SeEQS RRR Boo BR NS aR BBE Se a See See Ses Se ae. RE. MRO” SCR See Sey RRS Soo Sa Se ee PROT Sos 0, SE EERE SORA BERG SOONRORS © SRMMRGEN: SORE RMS ERS MMR OS SOREN RRED SOs BS. See Se eee: ESE, BES DeCris ob\Onimear LRA 3 iD sees Sete BURA age SRS.SS Sk,Sh SS Be eS SS "eSAieRR aeBRR heeearea a ataSeni wry erate teeny TNERS Rae eSSte>.. 2° SITE rere celncetae acretgere Be eecomic ee PSR Soca SRSaan RS SSR SSTmeee SRS Ono TOS ST es Oe

Le EHEE Seoe SARK Etrec ne :Ra teeEenace i esaOOOO mameRT einen heehee anemic EERE ace ene ee PS ~ &kc Bah Eeenae REDO OR ON SERwate ORATO ARPog Tg fFS Be 5 et Banco ennies ne y tetegare Oe Sa melee lipiste wae Seite OE eee wate uaa cee atte Soe . SSE eo OB 3 :

A : NEo XSnine apgatta SRSA AR ROR GION IEE. toca ocean , ;tenes ye ae ERE Mets Sets cee ceinn > teesSR tepttegt % : eeORO EE SPage aaaSa: MRRS reTe Iceneei, en a onROR ee Ne ; Bh eesti naseoat Tas Hi BS OT. ifSie, ae ES Sreepenn Sree ee ea 3. eR Beetse CORO einEN ty Ie RENIN styPTE RR Se ROE ee. Seg, ee Game, S|eeSKS (0 ETE PRS ee RE ThRRR Pisce Ses SaaS See16MME eRe ESES a hygo Sr Reccnnere aa EE SDP g eos FS Reit-aMaa TsseRRs aetgaVERS BRR RK SnSeES Oe Be OEGRE aE BEL ee oo0d0es BRO EO A” catia. “Nee XY Say ietioesaeoe g 1 RO law Ue un OY ;eres SLSR CEOOes. GAPS Oe Sse.pe a SRN |: or °

By cena." Ne ieafeeid ° “ERE : Deka de OA Uieo asiJee ee Isa oo Cee Ss MG sak a SS oo. Et ee : SE *RE f«OK, gate sae OSE Sok ae Se “Rs k4 Los eS, aesae Sy ig: a— wey. EE Mecca pleal Seoeahd SE ES? tee ateon TEES SeSEI Rs Set gt ag ¥L igs ? : eeON eygeen BP ape RS: See “Sage (BP SeEE Sho. eeee &eae 3Ce “Se gee BoA so3IE ane beeet anaes d8henge Fis

PIR EE TR gg OR ’ "

=a Se ete eapeO : — SESE SE Ee Se RECS OURONE TS CS ESAT CORSE SS ON SS ra

a oe ee See See 2 ee ne ne ae RO

RAY. | ee RRR UNOS RESee SERS SORSO SaaSBs eSpos ESS a :3YSS Se.SS eeeco RR Se3yfea ERR YE See ANS ee ge Serene «= ataeee ee ER Sa SI aBe ai aee ee ee Soa, ee .— ees aSe ees ERRORS SaES Sena Soo RS ne. iRR areBe Ct 3eae Se |.ee.-3a ce SRR Re: Berk 2 Re aeget Seer.Be Mo.See i a we SeeRG «|. RE 5 eames og oe- ae ae: NEBS eeeSe cS:eeSeema : NO RG. eee eee Sssey ae - Boaccs-. See i eS ROS pce ASSTEU og TOT Tghoe RRS aie each) eee eS aaa Be: Soe SACOMMERES ak «Sawe 2 yan DCRUSEE UST“SSS ere ites:SES cee Re ne apaRS me BN eae Sage bee ag

Fs. a SEIS Rae Se Sa | oSBROS ee ne ORR SS |MRR NE a. Reee TSeea Ls ae ee POG oO SeaKetpS See pets Sg ao. : BeeeS SEE ee2aeoeaeeoveeyeg ge Eas MER BSS ances. ee Oe Shee" s ae a cee ec” lle wets: eee ee RE (SI SR oe aetna tem cmt S a ae ee ae

“as ee aeDR Sh ReSO Bee aaeRO err Se ee Se aea 2SSR ee Segoe. SES FRR. PR gg Toe RRS a CF ee CE 5 RE BOR EER Sa.) 2.) Mme gO Iuo SsSe ee ees ye OB. an4BE PB ee: ROR RRR SBS B88 CRS, ee CEs aeJaaan OR ESE eo ea ae oAS She eoSees Rae RRS. Se eeNC Reeaaa ogee ENE, REY ia 22 ease SPL2OinD peafF0 SOTERA TERRES EGRESS a ce ae bo es eS, ae . aN SOR aS, SGN BBC NetTa BORD ane a_i Reem. 0 ULE 0. ORR Seo TE ES 2ee ESR PPS es. Dae Seeeaea aaee: earROR eesgros Pere So:Se 2. oe ras ESE CE coSLE RR OCTOBRE. BRB ooBeeeeSeegS EL a gesMe pam RBS Stee «ees SRR: 56; OR SNSSe ae 87) weenie) rte 2%, Sag SERRE UTES eee ah, 1 CUS Pet shi Soo eee:eee g

aEe:ee82eee AS One LL ae Ra Les, oe 3 ee Sec) i 2eeSere “SE SEBEE SoSSROSE degen> ete ee ot Etta Gs EES ae Bspepe wa RES aesTERS \ aCe 74:MRR emma. TS,oe 2 Snes CESS ERR CER Rs Le Ee Po cee Fee RET, ALSameter ag oe Ps ce es£ae .GR ae Pete Rs “SRR wetes %nS Nees2SloPO AO yg mieASR OSsASU ee ORE - She, 7 Sapean: BEDcee ALSIS StDeeg Si CNASES PASSER SEUSS SSS Ske Soo PeesPRS f CBS ee:Geek 53

Set8 See Ry SP RRR 2Tho TE ReME eeple ee eS eee: eos aeSOTRE RRR SE SEES SESE ue SSS TSI Ee REE ” Baer me D5 Se RES SE enema SO ace ae: “OSES SESSA - ERR OO OMERN Soe THEA GEESE Uo 3 ees s 3 oh at AOR RR oe Be ee Bey yagtiecean | So ES. Pees: Oe LS aR (PPR OARS rT ree eS. SR OTR OES Set Rr ink |BESS a ARE aCOORD aosPe Ee Se Re2 SEYIR UCSD. |SS ageek

cad. 1220. ~

YY \/

—_» \ Figure §1. Amiens Cathedral, cross

section of pier in relation to wall — A and vault-ribs. Design established oo a

ca. 1220. ee ee Figure 52. St.-Denis, cross section of

| | | pier in relation to wall and vault-ribs.

| Design established ca. 1231.

Figure §3. Cologne Cathedral, cross section of pier in relation to wall and vault-ribs. Design established ca. 1248.

154

= = yy 3 ie y | ) =e yf} aa y/ \ : . oon -* x a : “M4: a i aSP\ 1Ge a es / | ,iB-. ' oh A vi | re ah relay a>i BS | =e— sir SPDT ROT ECT onmespa iid V4 af WW . S33 oma aane —_t = a — ena = =) me» f— Sey 5s. =, = = = So eS 72 _ —, :a = ooeS ES = a: :=a.eo... qin a TAME TIVE 97099-79711! DHREPE, t+ _—_4 eS ee — or

——— Bee Be : el = eB =

Figure 54. Canterbury Cathedral, Figure 55. Chartres Cathedral, capcapital of pier. 1174-1178 (diagram). ital of pier. Design established

“K Wt ‘J23533 ; LA 18 If f . \ > \ \\\ lds 2943 [7 / YA se DP shortly after 1194 (diagram).

"At fe ff, finner \ AgOS \ ~~ (ys~/ /, ‘ Pye. £ \ :.poSe eeif—-

13) a oe ae aAi -7,ALEAVE \A \ere one ~| \ST Siem Se BS a OTE,Get, Ld. A Be ogOe J NeEwowresvrwen’ PPasSane? SOUS — ——- nT 2 AEG Reo Tee Sco] She FT ‘git Orel Ob PN oe ME. Wie : ; yy da tS gE. VF s y gg eg ae SY hy Xe 22.2) Be S SeOr) Sef tells

ay a-26 | SSS ont ae Clan ES 8 SS St=SS = “[-ke AS Sy =| 24S [| 3 sf Tf {7 ~ an iin ~=

Figure 56. Reims Cathedral, capital Figure 57. Amiens Cathedral, capital of pier. Design established ca. 1211 of pier. Design established ca, 1220

(diagram). (diagram). N = 4 c4 :~= a\q :==]\ =x =3m , -= am . +« .

™ | 4 (ep! i: — \\\ E' =bx Ly ieee i3 I i Hy “ = iy

cy es i 5 mn Fim ~ , ; . ‘Ci at BTR =a J enema WLS ds tet weed

.-re-

ag eds QUE BS dv : . :Wg ~ =|Po, i) y 3 y —d ie) ae amuse — 4 —_ | _ ' ~~ a=paw ty }' —— —-{| —=} 7] |.— aR~= . ——F —- —>~ ome FI= —~F ; -—_-———-~nasagl _~ae nt . —_ ban

Figure 58. Beauvais Cathedral, capital Figure 59. St.-Denis, capital of pier. of pier. Design established ca. 1247 Design established ca. 1231 (diagram). (diagram).

Eo OES eign eS ao Re re eh TORRES eee to EE TE Re 2 Mee ete naes eR ppegneg ye so peng NS Soak Ne ee ix oe EE RSSEA SeeRee PEER ISEDN Bos SBeyosSe RE NSU Oo Oe Re ERSESee SEa OS SARS OE ie OS IMM eee oe! 2Raa EERO RR ERD Sn aes PEERS odOE SERS RRe ROE Tok Seed Rep oreRS 3SCOURS Ea A SNe es ORES ET USE SRSialic Pete eo RI Ee Ne, aes Pied eres WSeR SESE OAR TE SAU RaRe SS @hacce Cee SES MEE EEE Octet en eR EES aS SAS TSA eg9 Loa PERESSI SOs SAEs SES NE DN aSE, BES OATES ESS oe Soe ea SE ee DRIES SOS SORES SESSLER, atleae a DS 2Bae TRE SRS oo BBS LLP Sg SioaSees aca egies,ees aga Mase Lae SEDE BAMA SITS Dot aieBERS See gion ee Yee ty EE EPS EOS OS EL eee CEST BOAR LE heREE Bon OB Bo Perera Beer SEA Serm LGR Site pet 5Ton jeisigs eR Mee280 EE a ee SSRIER tins Sa eo Tae? ih TPCT SSIS SCS MOR Nenirs eS a ecgh ane ace a aeeen De Se aR Se RRRALD SERRE NSee SOay ee RenEG RE Ona hy USL 1 SUES DEE RN Sy ie fg DS cE SEES SI TB cee SORT SG EST, SSUES SE eT OO Ee ST UES SRR Re Se SAGES TA As Te ge Oe SEE EE yaeiggpeeeliy Repeater warcatccenstbebeeipas sell Sebiptgitain: SEARS USE Bee ee Tey EES Sn ech A a SSSR ye EE

geeaEES SEES eRH, SE eae NI ceSE SR hatSigee oRae a Se onsae ARERR te SET SENSE INAS NECROSS aeTEE a a tee Ber ee EE RS RSE RRR ATRaTRE SOI 0 Rg Tet ne tre Sen BEIGE Ee gE gt ENTE SAREE SS ROO REO AERSCRE ASDER ESL OU a eR a RENEaSeta SRM SCLees TC STpanes OPEL Sse fo PERS REE RMSaCRORES RNR ESBee Ree a a aOR ne eee en SE:SRNODE pases BEESIRI OR SR Ae Seg d SESE oRISPe Nae ann SSS ty SAG

SSIES LS SARS veer MRR Ss et EES RTS SS ES AEA EL BS OE dn ERE OEE LEER SOO a

EEO CORR SE nega tie sn ih SR Un Se an ES eee SSE Dee nr nr pete te AMG ee ality mage oihisacay se Sgr celnese ee Yn wih Te AE STL ath tec YESS ERS

REIS SEES US Eas a aee a tee Pewe agate nate perecbbiarca banIEE ETS RESEEING OE IT So50ET I DT SUSEAT TTS TURRET Ans peptone ceiIME Snr ia MESSE Ue fal a ue MEgeSsLS SyOr BsSocann CORONER ECR CR SO, ghEE RNneeS RDC lode PTSSee est |

3 SEA heHSE MAEM ye- *CO BEDleBE TRSER ae EEeg A Sg SUS TESS UESS SaSe eoSOIREE Tie) ELSAf SyLSE Sh FEE NS SS 8eye 6 og OU ESS Po nae ita Ran)Oe DED SES eee ckoo sith ae Ste st :MAREN, . hp SR A DEAeeRECCR BRpc eeES a SEE BiaTg todhes ess ba aaly TyeSSthy sos REN Se OT igiOT gob ee :RE SRETEETS COURT EEL BEE BS eeEe eto ES ehghlls DES US SSStg MU teeth JES See ee a 2 Ser Rg oe Sh ie gS i Be ee Pee ek Oe Sake OS eg ity UY ed EERE NT ee Epo Oy, ASSES . ee re Sant Gem cereee E EOS peo US ag Pihanedehe toe ST ee eA EET YT a. ney I SEER

EESE uke CARRE. UD pe cB ped QO eR ee at i ge BOE eo we Ce, .Sen Ol MOET Satie yg ny SieiSTelin eae PetSr2 oS es TP UNE BAG CSS ee REN ESSot OEa ane - : .COMER i es Si SetsCerne cnn. SERS Ee OBSiR SS ee mer ate were BST Bae tas Ba nhTee TeeRE Tye

EASEDSE LAE 2 ye,SRDS Ee? We caer tass neCott, eEEe ts CORE Re NEUE De OOP E Lenee A Oea BO be osoS : Bes Seis BEE oyWESSEL +Pb ee Pg aete‘”a’ iQo nG WERE SOREET ny attes ESgMet peai)SESE SEC SPO 2os,:TC: as nae eae Teeeee ari, eins Sai ie "aegis. rcserroon i ne aMie cn aSey, a.Oo SeeLn Me iTeEU ae

eo Se .Sp a \ fhe . : roe eins Si aEnoe yon.%a!anQF geeos i teOM SEIay us ae TREN : -Biwi rina % ™“, UEOF a ee yh. Ee ce Cc sosSe COM Mot

giaSS, : . : f“YF . . a” * ; 3nyeerean peeSER ee FR nO. 1 se.®e Lo. bay ee aonf & TsaS , ee 2 a fist aes eae ie ms io. “ae ae oO . : . $ . e wees way, . =| an he sy vet os y . * o i a . . 7 mo . . 7 ese SY

sii. “Wibs aan. :aewe : $me . m3a YO : a .;vette FSS Mee Te eta”.geaN. jOP.ees ’ ;aea -2. ms ELEeee PRRES a OEY TESSEUD DSRS AS ena QE Fe a ae Se, Ses pes j : ) — a . q eo oN. 7 B : Bal Pad te rab NUS AES

Cs a TR” . . is Sey ; . 4 ’ : i 2 oe a eats Mee My CIS UT mh eeOR 3 ye ane: ig ea yO: %fearya Sa raaane": cll oerasUP SIS EEL eat wa BO noo : Sr 2ea Ot sot : . ssaea ee : 7 STs oe 2EL ZS La ASSESS Cs a : Is 7 J.4oT 2 : woo or Pg Cae tia aeR A oe OeoS ge RR ne fo fee TSS BE . , a‘NY 7 as OEBoEn ad oe ns reSeSeST a Oe TR St ee a SE 4 bs * aSe=. aOy ; .Oe a So Re SRT” ee . Eo Leoeeee LESSEE eS? eee aSeMey ° aves 7 +ye ee Oe a TSSB ne CF EET benaagt 3 } 1»La 2 EP es

nes : nd % ay wee &° yiCBRE OR OR ec pceseencss, Sige earn eve RN , SA ee Ee Ds 7 ee Se 2 =%:” :cr ee, oyr® odvo Stes Se Sk SO ¥, ONG De awe Pe oeR44 Pg eg, - 6BN TEELE OEE LEEMoe AD YOO OE ETEgBS SSot a a£Faery ae = Rey peweeS TEE Me gfe LS eee PS NOAM ee ER : alree ESton gb ™, .ae ". Ma : PF ?: One Fa OPN ar. Ct $.¢ a aog SCE eeeoe eoBe LRSn eyRE DoscE Suaes SERRE IneRET So Rn Be ee Soo, : Tags, he cee ce % gf 3 ee eS Ee RES SS BES cee TERE Ee Be ye “ 7s Bas cay ican . can i 33 gs re ae \ Be Eas: (4 4 SB Mage ge ne. SG OZ Te BER nna ct SC a 2 ~ = ¥ : “OL we te Rats Mees - rN wag - § " Bs ON Ee EE Ro ae Bese Sea nn

Sg EO Po: .ite Be Aaoo’ EA ENE PSmBeNy CR SHEER ee aa : “ee stBe : :tet ” .d+ :Be Ga, oetirae oelee a: LS ESERIES. SESE SERRE ORE) ing ar Le .SU . Mee we aEENED pigSate ieGEE GMa a i RD AAU eae

Pf ee pe UP Te ee tein yy tole Pf PR PM pene es

On oneeniinet: Rreseggeaeetesi ar Seonenangetniin vinci MnO MnAneneecRaneancnticiiiiowanincaronsinenge ” ebbbarroap vane? ppaecnsenieind.. Saegnmanceene sete I ce Eg ioCEae : Ser a : Rpg ne a a ce 2 me a FP SOE, WC SPer ER ERTS SIRE EE aTTRE

rsaae nk Sane ~a;rcaeaSane f.. $i:: ahat rc!eR : . nee ll. lo. 4 no as 32.4. oe Res STP SERS BO REE ae ae z ~~ “Spnaggeor : § Os. LeAe SESS 2rd uy oe a.:& oecree ee panne “ot .ff ; oe omer ose aep . oS elottA ae “ora, vo* ree eB weet, mo Ne we oo, —! sos -oene;ESaria DADA Sons ee

Pe aeinces: Sm. . 3 os : . 7 Ly ? . an fe aie eee OUTS SEF Ae 29 3 Dee ; a ¢ - ye Doge Bis Se Rie Dhue a eoiaiean coe

vA e oe " 7aanate . mS Raneceene jSOE ME, wal ert SUS ES veEE aege ne, Se :. ;.‘yg - 77Boe No: og eee Sea GAT oraloe Be ‘ OP oyvrornr 7: ae : . ,oe a: =oo ve“ oo . oh ROMA TE ISEB EMINEM oai,OPIS wee ea:aes BB i : :: ey _: ae ~~. ao .,eft ee 4ISLE ee , en eeDELEON Paani aboo § OO SEMA OOD due BP A DO icv ere et i. : a re Se ee ee or ey og TESMB SUSU Peg oN oe PVRS Su OE Qe a ot Se eee ee . DR pete Bie a Lo :ae x OS oN ” : Ula SS aea Soeee ON SeOBtong os: :aan.cars Paote mS . . (SLO a DoESSneRAR 2 SE Eea ise Saf

ae eS ee a ean A : a REG, 20s SE Fetes a

are! ee RO Be etSoe : wn Dg 2 tee , Soe wes Bo et Je ._%Ns .- . » eels Tele ESSE OES De Belge . FO Sot aaoD oPSnare worel! MEER oy A NE Sa ere es ee te ayss eee tge SN ne -ae ei etrita : etlae oN ‘oewa oo ...a Bot. .er ceot : ; IN aaaaCS Stce Sena DEN age! 20 a See ft paaag: Bople Pee ees: si, reeack navey eeEEee SRLAnte TON A Boo By@Ree oe Se OQ A we a . : poo :a cy ee WOE CE ae ok TS : :irre onenens SUL RG SPSL dp MMR OP S ee B MON ok Re Se teas SO See ees Wee Te eet ne es BU eS UL Dadi sha CY BAAS AEDS EAs nt if Mayen Joe RO seh ago ORES Ab on . . . Lote A BR SH Satan eee ee CURIS SS BS BOL SEE TL Sone Se Be Be hn ae ee rn Tee. Tar ce le Pe BO eee

JON SE eg te ON STO neSor rr cee Saran UE BOE aes oeDO aeLAS ee CD US ID Ge Bo] peaeg cE Te ASE Oe9Be ti ren ye SR ete a ee .6.ere See gLDADS ig Coe Tn OORSME Su shgS PeES ELT a :rc ee 2Troe: ore tts PP : : aaagOe Doe SSS

2 SEND te OTLB Seth 2 oo Se ES a TR Sg il BOR OE Wa EET gpagreene POMoc, er eS ae ee neue ut gb SST DFU -°LV eS eBPY beeEND BORE EESN NSS -tee pppemalebnon EY aeOF) SPT og DED Ss peepee eo(JOSEM AOe ESM SS SS IeSAS Ce fe Se Senn SSOSL an oo aeaeLa ee0 eho MieUN osRET eee one rs wo OES SAE gee . art ADUD uth) Le BL let eS ehit. E ee TE io. Iemeee gy Te; ON oy ra : weBasen URE Dt ingSU USE SSrag Lepetid eo de Tena SEES ho. UUs ENS UE ESR EDcngee ” eepoeareneraeeee ff cree Trenton eeeSOE eo tekcese By oi ;4nBO IQS Thy eg

, wel UaCOTES oo A STS SS Ee QS :peer Te ORRs eet 77ma eon ag : UREe TL ag TIS UL tt sha 8 SAB Oh Pe Ari eeere ee0)Uy untANSE eereeey| Ns reMATS ee tULSD eRe a Tyee ee eeSUF ee NED RG Lise oS t SUS ee ee CR ee ah reAS, . DoT Wisner ET RRR Re siSe, te OSWOR el Bat? Seere oe ao Eede Sead

UNS 8 oo SUS oe CUR ge beeen = eefhe recor hkl. LE SE ae LeUt agaR SM i LEGLock ELIE sos SAE EDU CSc, SiaoO ts Sanna SAE neti ’ va Sereee . EUnee on Se : RO BOLD nO Be Ron : :wee ;Tah eo)ae USES. oesNe wo Ln So TSS Se iTenn an VEER Seg ee SSROU oars Te ENS UES . Sot) CRI Sher Tein ed IRA Re PL ene AR BRO ok,hig a ea nen GT POR keSSL Sc ae ieUSES wlCE CATES LSS tae edie ia OE SD ETL Sg ceGee ge LOE SLIM cog Sen Qe” . iaapage a ec ace ae“ arr, ri we aan Air SAMEStet eg

ARS TT SSEE NLSSane icp OBO 2 Tiegh ISOEg. EgeeBear CatORSTEE. na eR nO Ae nS SitWitting” CIS -SERRCOE ws ene a osten - eh EES se “Sop ee: DOS (Re Some ES Cen a nn Oem persee. STE Gi Woe 2s SESFe eg Ne Iwe Saneaitnivins $i ot ee seoer Skids EST UES SR EAS eS ee Se ; eesSTROMEEE® ee OT eng. Ci le a ranaea tee) ESRI, MENGES ovo Tigh ais SR nyctae aaan Cente oRQnRg eR, anne ane aie SE tag BT RETeeo gha eS SNSeines Ee iceSeen Plo ce LSA IMSSENTS gh Thies papincoaien soo inn. ee intok OTR ee il. Pig ce Ey eerSes arene abeeneae MEESS eo es egemeecteesgagareiigge OSCae oN ER eRgee Sas : Wo SisSsasthy bt ARERR Tet et So CaCO OI, Sna Urn Si. ee! ne Br cnn SYRTeoe Me big woe Sane Ae RO oe NE OR ECS ROSS Gr CRN A eeSE EES RR RCE, ORD keRea: OREOyin. INEY See ORES Sc Mh Seen Seven Sy oie URES ACeiner aesftHabeas: EE natinSMES CREO GE women, Moe haWarne ee Say “sine SrSh, SOP RIRER SERGE OREO Se” AER RE fet, Sc ,>«SEED Soa 20k,cek, WhChteaeene WORE UU coe sie Mee SE RRCIES. SadetO aE ROREEEY ne |Oe eas oale©SOY WERE BOER. ge seOg) aE Wath B® hei Ses LU Geen RL, EER GtURES, Sg losScat TIOseven BRS SSNS

or Desh es SE ge SE SL IR gg te See BOE SEU A rg Bg = sane Fo AES ee

PIREONORES Seen’. ERRe OMEEEM. oy SR tent: *OChas” en eC, ‘Searcy Pe BeMERON ene oe EE PR Cad NOS Co ERIS EER on SLBoe Ng ScSeek IgStDl BE Pe ey Qe PT“OSES Be ES, ities QP SOCONEE PERSE Beue SOL geCUbtiren. a Sg SeSoSA TE tT uso Pe See SeaySERB Sees SSORT eeeeeEe. NES Sy ae a C20 2NB SUEUR RQ A ge ae Se Migh a Se SyUgh ress Eeniee. SOMMER SEOT UbeRu alPn SERED semiOPERAS SUSU Sie Pt Sinn eesre ag S wee EC Tiey Ltrs Setaie neereS Mette m Soon ne Sumerian ar Meee eee. cenogee Cs Poneeeceorttt oapt OREEEDO ainass Shee Ete a AG OF eeBe eeeEE PERUSE. RS eR geLe RogER ee erg Poe: Se Sete SOR e ny Seen, Caer, Ase Seite: io Ee ON QQ ES ME EN EE SE ES DM Wa gt OO SR ayteeny eR ee UeEE Aes oe oo PNOCC LS SC ee eeaEEe Seon SET CREE, SEES SEES tetas eae n SOIR SACS cere, MOSSE eos SURES, SCC NN ayBees aca SEED SO SAR SRT eaLRRD See secALS EeSm PT Se Th Sk ee OnE Sane iesHE SEAS IR StkSe WeeSy Ens Sti, SEE OER, SEM CCEA SEER COR ESICED, Suc IUK SSMS-SERS 1Res CONSE REN EEIORS, Sesiter LOOSoca > Senneeee RRMSR eee 3 Se, LOE SeeaRSeen? Semaine ee Sek Cece SCC RR COON a7, itm NgNER al ta SEAR Bote ee SRS ene Se Se Mee Akin, ENat, MSCe SAREE oi ORESSOM, 6 NLS MEE ELEN te COO fae RORY SiR.” + MERERESES SRR DEEN BORPRE Sa menace SEie Shai Reece cea OSaR.Sag Sie Sees

AE

SOL SH DoS EEE Sie ocrVERS PRR Be Be ir a la og UNE EEOER Be ge OeDic ORAS RES SECTS TRIES OMRRETTOS SS SRReE IS. RRA OIE otPn RE a Se es Ee SeeEME RTE SEE SUSE Ming SR gPy aidSITE ‘PaO O RecSRC, Meee EST Ti. StSeSFRS NEMET RES Sees Gee er ee Re REAR TEke SN OCIS eeen Seater e ites “OUNCES SORELY ART eince ee FERRE See, kes Se Caren eas Sais Rina eee Tain PE REE POPES:

PE acales, SCRE Sone CORO, CO EY SEAS RRM JOReD CSS SOR a APES Coe OEE Sane ORS, St OS CORR eee IY Bene ROR REESE Nr {nna nD ange SCORN SOR ESET TTS &

oh LESSIG RQ SSR SN a SS a i Sy I Re COSTE MORE EST e Mints VeOMeeCne Geen, Genome S See SO SMS

Pi REE ee ae RS enone AeeeSeeaIP: SE OESe OSSeen SS TIS ga Se SEmesmnnie EEE CarasMen MCS Neti BS OUST RS OAwe ei Sein, Se geCOROT Ce ge le RY SHOES a coeneectncs OS NR rg gc Re 7enh ea See Canes seycertm a EN ER. CRONE SOROS Sho eee

Bo ORE a Oe ey Cae seSSE. * PR ggMEY AS Bohmena utGeman: RS tne She NS SS Eats 5 sees EE SOE Eh Bo Bing LCS Sele ShiERE see Seeag Oe Ok, keeTE irr Stee Scan. ogi EERE Mean re LySa OMS PERO LEER SERED ROME NG. SRT SARE Je OR shPAS OCIPeas Bo)Bewomantegg cae BLE eeSs:A BP Ao Sp MRE RTCrE Beene eS Rea enGee i FeRS BeRO SeSe gseSRe fie f BURA Be IB ont AR gl ig ee Les a RR Ste eS ERE MeMe SERRE OOS, CSET Rey ae RS EE PNOCRORREE POORER, NCEA ORR BegerEE esStBie ee oeCS OE, EAE Ree OOcoeNS MRD SEY Maen, Cu MRee EE,MERITS SER ONC LIMpay gga Cn: Seiet MAO aOR CR Te Cnt ernest Meee Se ESe ds SN " Mb Cin Sea, MOMS Sina ee ONES SRR CRC SENEICSE SSSR Sein eenn Cone SEDNSD REEDS ih, De ey Peas Steers JRE UE Se A aMi ehOeSeg oeSaeeSa ge PEGE SERS NEST ROR EER LEONG VOTES SRS BERR SOR NO: SeOue Oe Senin ER, anc annLe Se NE “Fo IEA CRE Lat OER. ORO OES,WRT SASSY SEE REI, RNID,REE SOLEUS? SURE CCT, CERINSERED RICE SREN ATOR ROR onPersil Te ~~ ertPOOR ny Sanne: Cs,SDSa A Sic. Ske onNORTE SeaterSECT. nlc ROTOR ONES IRON PEROT Se SeenON, SOR «ORO Oe SeRee ES

ee Cake Sines See QS oe a Sr ene As - EE SELCROR SRE WE SOD AL SO"eRe A nonEE e'?. -Y Steen Sr RRO SENET aU SEER et eee Zt EES SRSRS IRS Tee Ee4 ‘ee ee Se . RR SeSRN MwRRoie EOE AR 5. $0 ce EeReeSE SR

Ronee ARDY ARE SOT, CASS EMRE SSR MRR, OR “ON a Cks Picante esa, Site ier Soe LE EAR EE sn, POS OS EET ONE, SOLE OREO RT cay Er, SP, REY RS PERO Se CUTE SOLS, EAE SCC ene SSS Se ae Ean, WO. Neen Rae Sarno. GY Un onemtemen OCR RRLET ON COaaCy, Geaaee hat aReCnRs TERRE, } ZAI SRO OERER, Ue ENDURO” ARAN, OD C000 aa EOE SOREEP SESY >, SRN TSECRak, hs REEEOE . Gem See RD 85 fia. OMEeget EMRE RE DCCm - SSRO NOD OER WO LS OACSEE SESRES, RA RRR AEETRE REED eS 0, IE ieee PRROTRe, NERERE Rute COCReee CONOOET a> een Sages hteerERROR OeML. cane READE eeON TEL DILL COR ooSis RN Be

ESE EL Sea oe cen pe OS, SCD, 4 Eh Sic Rear epics ee FO REE FO Be es ropes ea

1S EER A UR SS a RE OS OES gag ron > EA ER: S. EE MER MES CEE COE CORRS Oe SOG RE MCR REEE . SARI ASR See ee

REC eR, a eaeFS SeONE Nee SS ioe, Eee odAS Case atee barRRaoe FES be ce SEL ESS: Sey Soe Seem ene aaetoain Camis 1rR IES EEeaine iO ae oiMCS 2See SRS oe Be GEES 5eSBhs SR Re See Coe, SUR Meine ene: SRR gE icieeeS SeoSerer eet eenara OR mE SORE OEBS SORT SAE DeetsghCREE Ee SeeER Sean ee REI EEE,CEP eter R©nae is, Se ESMERE TOG HOw ACCS Ot Sie maaan manaD RE OES SORTA PERSES TES SESnT a agents perce Bee RIT yt ee SE EN ERE RONEES SisSen 5 DACP CEDSUR Ol) Sa SERIEENRELIND ENO RE ORE EN EN Ta ER Da Neste TOOSan SORTS, © LORETO SCRE SeenOEE Lich BS Rept eae 25 SERS a RR VB Qe goss o EN ere ene OR, ECTS SOUR SSG ie tater eee a Se RO EER ERODS, SEES RO I BR, aN a he “SCL 2 ee Ss: ; SROeS By pope RTE. SES SUR 6 TORRE MS SB BE OS Pao Se RO ag Manes x "5

TRESS SEU eo A gO BON he Bee ae SR ge Fe SR Ee RS ee LAL ae [EEE Se Sr smo aes ER Be eo Ng ETE I gee ra 8 74 83 56S Se, REPS, SEE GNU LEER, EEE SRN SSEREEEST SRS SO ee ee Sere So $

eR CR RE SRC REO RE OO CEOS SE SRR I eee Re ee aw SES Meena cee R eS ERO RO, RISRORES - ROUEN SRNR CREE ODORS ReneS C SEBO R STE SORT: SC HESES YER EE SNES ES

SAE SEEING Sout eh eactomsnres So RSS Fe Bo ge Be Es EE SRE RR Ott NEE. SNS MERON, CSE Tees Sane RnR REE as ont TUNES Ra Ss

aS ENS Se TOT Co aL TC ee ee Se. aon SREmEtRe SED, tS ORE DCE Fn RE RC RNC.Rey SEES RN eeSE aeea OSE. SMESOREN SRE Mee RENE nae SineSame DO PS eee SS SheOSPnaaee SESSAeee oe gan SRO” ainceon ean SOR aE pecs os in, Res Soe RERERLEOIOUCS seeeag PALE SESESRD BeSooo, SS Se RES SEE ih, OR EE igSe ee0ashe. EEG S SIPS See Ege nearer ca tNOAS DigNea Mh opine WR Poe Ssseers EE, BERR RT ENED ee EEE EEEO RIES aey CE “SEER gh SeSec ie Ag StS eR ASTI EAE OR SRR Or SEE OT ee Reet SReC SMR St scan OFou ERE CESSESSeRea Sn ee age Os ee aeRMON eo eatieSE SE eo apt RRay entCSR oa ieton RERRSLD™ SSRN MRT ERR, CREED eheta.gne TEN, So So at| 2 38 SRS ge ee ae inn Gas Se ae soca REE, POP da: SEE aE aR os Enea re seen ee aE it ENE, SRR OMERER, SERIO SORE DODROR EUG 20. ka ROSS SERS: ERR eR REy TORE Die tana AO COCR DOC RESNS ne RSERIRE pat orga RRO ORERS ORME, SERRE ine SOU Ae eS CCR et ei Nea enna et tas i ge ee REE ROECOERON we Sate HUERENS ABO REN Ok LOSDy

of SEES Se“AOC eS Fe eesCISC Ete Ya saaeBes Sey PES INT ieee: nnnAcm, EES aan cag SEA SEES ROiYSN Sued BRE et SERIES Sone ISIE, BaeSERRE SRS ETAT Ee esAER y oe RGIS RRR Ge ROC SORES SRat, ERCROR ESSER - GAMECORE PO eRe SESSsteueeeens Ra O” ocean ee ee SeayeG Se, eee Meeear SEL WROTE SOER, ee es eR gh TSAR Ree Sehgal ape ene ReyRMR SE Se EERE. SS piriRNS noes Senee OeNE WERE, Cee TSehPoors ee By Some: DISTR ee SE a 5x onsne HiBAS EY RES RRO ES OTeeRIE oFSeca. SDANY SON OE BE EE EEE EES itg eeswien be BeASE see SOF FAS EESESI ORS ZeAOo Sees Becec RRS ROR. Sone ESear ie Sct. ne ERED AD REST SHORES eennmEee Hemera, Leas SieeeNae OE ESS SO SERCO Sincs tine Be. Ciel cei SER ae gt, CRY ee See eee EERE ON ATR OA Ten DOU EEC COA SUCRE i Case eeers cae Nn a RS RO OR ECE SC EEE SNEED, SGC TEN ERE SOS EN Oe SULA ES SSPE eS SES See RN ORES RE RO TSS SUS: SetsS'S, adSORES ee. SESE SORTER. COREE REOCI es Sree EEOSS: ES Oe pe ay EEE fe REaSSEE AES CEE GOTTESSER soca, gh Conca SotREN TERR Se ee, /“SES DEES RSAE OES RERePR he” BER UES ORE STON SEE REE:Brg - DOSER SRO ERIS: RETO, SORRY ERCRED ERIO, CORR RRLi, ROR NER PSR a eRPowys RRR 7 Se Deyos&§ CRRA Seo ERIM Tat ee Beas RIAN CP Ge RESTO On oe POSE ECTS SS LES, CRORE DES EDNRN ROSES. te Se Baer AACS

RES SECA CG ORE CTY A OS COON La OTR CREEL, SRSONESSS SiON SEER RR ON LORS RN SR DNC, OREO LS Se RMSE EER, COEF NAR RE ante ain, Sieh Stas aE TES ai3 SESE eae 4ROS eeeSOR FN eeI. REE eaeSEO se REE ie aR Segecnttey Say eee en oe ASRR ieeeERB SSRRE Bites cies BoCoO EES: 3erate EAS Eee ROR Ey ORO OERee OME, eT TEENIE RE RRR aT, RARE MORNE See ose ES SheeRED Se KORE a a boat Oe eee Gag Shee eae eS ee. OeSBS PNSRR ORDEO COO Pe gegcnagere crrecpamasscnt ae nnaBeating OA MagiSpeer ta eS Nee 3 Meee aE CORIO SER Sr REO RNGEER it; SRO MEETS SER GOO EN se. Lindel jan SRT NIER aR IT BRIS cA per acumeenenis Stay oR SREK SNES SANA RE AMUN RS SEER Oy om HORRORS Sh |teSEES eee ea pec aes pecans eee ed BEES ere ee Sor Se er eC eres OR pie SER eae oe Sas puacad Bane: 8 TEsen SERRE Sarena SE SESE Se OS ) ER errs ERI, SeRRR RaeSOOM gS a ERC ENAORAL LS Bes ‘7 Seo SPS SSSROaER, Grape ae roeRa ty peo Fd DERE ROIS LKR ORS CORED YS ONT SRRSes REEL Yo, UAT RUE KR OSs SEF OS TS, “REPRO a te ed SS: 4 :DEES : » DERE aReies pg S DSee eyae eater . RoR maaERE BE RE 9 CRESTS 5 REO LIAS on, RS ye eee ee ECO A £8 ek ee See’ EERE OAR EEN Se Ot oe Seeee BOOT tng Re Px, Roy Fu ee Dre oth St ator dy neretay Sh Rae eee Se SD Sate SRR RN Ee SO SC Ay NEAR I on. GES.

eon ORES Y Lane SSOTR Deon i: CORY ROI TRS a ES GOR ORR STSMeST rh NLR SR Cae Lp EREDAR SO SAGE MTRMESRO MES ibid RRU 34, DOSSRY AE OES Oy BaeSESE eho SnrRE RaeRea BANS LR LEE EIT I IE RE ANNIE ie CN OS Br ae RL EN Re ee ole nce pie dad ees: OLED DAS Bp III ate eeece) ns ads

BesaTOR rceee heme aS eed DSRS eR aePEEP x SMES ana “3LOT SRBAS OsOne Roses: : PEE MOS Feeepaik ESS TIA RSPR OLEY S ORDERS ENERED DRREER RIE IND Rona OF CELSS HERE SS < PgSey Pease Dee, SRT RO SONG LEA Sr ug4peas PR MS I pe Se ’ LFS eee ae re hoSe SansPSE

EE RN SSRPDS eo PRN BS a Qik @ SESS TeRe%Ge e 4 rs E> cad ts » td*OER ORR SEE XO S334 & aeERD 3 fete eB TNaNdat Siac Se reRR 46Ratan &: m > 3,”eRBS ve UE 2OR %a Re .ng peSeigeim : %, of 3 ERED SRSS ERR eee 3 i. Nad he ROR BE LESe. Nk Sea nip RY wtig atCBSR.F aah rd oh 9CF 2SPEWS A RE OR ORR ROR etaNe eeeOe yeaaCO BS GE SSO RNS Bee SGT ERE Re

. . .3a?* ..bder e.ry «* g«ca e

Bie AORN CON RRS SOR Meats RT PA OES Seas SS DP ODT fe eee NN ae RSS SAS a a Re arts ESCCR s SONS. 5 at MOE Le MSE OS SORES Bee ee ae ee Se ee EDR ES, REO SLRON AS EVEN oot RnR sae aE SS So Sere a oS TE a 8 BE Arian Boe a ins R an OO CREE ORO TE RR ONO EINU Y SOROS RE EUR MILA MAS MOR SX: ORS YS PRO EE HELE RS BNL ASM OCOD SNORT pee SRNL CON ta Sires PRM he aE EE CBRN Serene Re ean ROE NS = : Se oh GS vst See S Ee RS et 33 ROE SS ee ROR BASEN oe ER RRR eet BScoee “igh te woe rug

igure O. kar e€ fonnecourt, idea groun Pp an Of a C vet ~

resultin rom his discussion wit lerre de orob1e rawinhg oO a

1235 Paris Bibliotheque Nationale

17 Union Square West, New York 3, New York

If you have enjoyed this book, you will want these titles

of related interest. Ask your bookseller for them. M40 ITALIAN PAINTERS OF THE RENAISSANCE by Bernard Berenson.

Illustrations

M41 SIGHTS AND SPECTACLES: Theatre Chronicles, 1937-1956

by Mary McCarthy

M42 MOHAMMED AND CHARLEMAGNE by Henri Pirenne

M43 THE WHEEL OF FIRE by G. Wilson Knight.

Introduction by T. S. Eliot M44 GOTHIC ARCHITECTURE AND SCHOLASTICISM by Erwin Panofsky.

60 illustrations

M45 FREUD AND THE TWENTIETH CENTURY.

Edited by Benjamin Nelson. Meridian Original M46 POLITICS AND THE NOVEL by Irving Howe M47 NEW DIRECTIONS 16: An anthology of new directions in prose

and poetry. American issue

MERIDIAN GIANT MG8 FRANCE AGAINST HERSELF by Herbert Luethy

LIVING AGE BOOKS LA? WHAT MEAN THESE STONES? by Millar Burrows. Illustrations LA8 THE MEANING OF PAUL FOR TODAY by C. H. Dodd LA9 MARTIN LUTHER: ROAD TO REFORMATION

by Heinrich Boehmer LA10 RELIGIOUS DRAMA I. Living Age Original. LAI11 SOCIAL SOURCES OF DENOMINATIONALISM

by H. Richard Niebuhr LAI12 cuHRISTIAN THOUGHT by Ernst Troeltsch

GREENWICH EDITIONS Original Clothbound Publications ON ART AND LITERATURE: 1896-1919 by Marcel Proust.

Translated by Sylvia Townsend Warner ON LOVE: ASPECTS OF A SINGLE THEME by José Ortega y Gasset.

Translated by Toby Talbot

Titles listed here are not necessarily available in the British Empire.

17 Union Square West, New York 3, New York

If you have enjoyed this book, you will want these

titles of related interest. Ask your bookseller for them. ANTHROPOLOGY M15 SEX AND REPRESSION IN SAVAGE SOCIETY

by Bronislaw Malinowski ART AND ART HISTORY M7 THE PHILOSOPHY OF MODERN ART by Herbert Read M8 CREATIVE INTUITION IN ART AND POETRY

by Jacques Maritain M18 NEW piREcTIONS 15: An anthology of new directions in prose and poetry. International issue M33 VISION AND DESIGN by Roger Fry. Illustrations M38 THE ESSENCE OF LAUGHTER AND OTHER ESSAYS ON ART AND LITERA-

TURE by Charles Baudelaire. Edited, selected, and introduced by Peter Quennell. Meridian Original ML2 A DICTIONARY OF CLASSICAL ANTIQUITIES by Oskar Seyffert. Re-

vised and edited by Henry Nettleship and J. E. Sandys. More than 450 illustrations. Meridian Library

CLASSICS M9 OUTLINES O¥ THE HISTORY OF GREEK PHILOSOPHY

by Edward Zeller M23 BYZANTINE CIVILIZATION by Steven Runciman MG3 PROLEGOMENA TO THE STUDY OF GREEK RELIGION

by Jane Harrison. Meridian Giant MG7 piato: The Man and His Work by A. E. Taylor. Meridian Giant

MILI ROMAN SOCIETY FROM NERO TO MARCUS AURELIUS by Samuel

Dill. Meridian Library

MILL2 a DICTIONARY OF CLASSICAL ANTIQUITIES by Oskar Seyffert. Re-

vised and edited by Henry Nettleship and J. E. Sandys. More than 450 illustrations. Meridian Library DRAMA AND THEATER M6 THE PLAYWRIGHT AS THINKER by Eric Bentley MG4 My LIFE IN ART by Constantin Stanislavskt.

Meridian Giant

MG5 THE ROMANTIC AGONY by Mario Praz. Meridian Giant EDUCATION

M31 FREEDOM, EDUCATION AND THE FUND: Essays and Addresses,

1946-1956 by Robert M. Hutchins. Meridian Original MG4 my Lire IN ArT by Constantin Stanislavski. Meridian Giant Titles listed here are not necessarily available in the British Empire.