A Third Century Etruscan Tomb 9781607244455, 1607244454

Citation preview

A Third Century Etruscan Tomb

A n a l e c t a Gorgiana

216 Series Editor George Kiraz

Analecta Gorgiana is a collection of long essays and

short

monographs which are consistently cited by modern scholars but previously difficult to find because of their original appearance in obscure publications. Carefully selected by a team of scholars based on their relevance to modern scholarship, these essays can now be fully utili2ed by scholars and proudly owned by libraries.

A Third Century Etruscan T o m b

L. G. Eldridge

w 1 gorgias press 2009

Gorgias Press LLC, 180 Centennial Ave., Piscataway, NJ, 08854, USA www.gorgiaspress.com Copyright © 2009 by Gorgias Press LLC Originally published in All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise without the prior written permission of Gorgias Press LLC. 2009

1

ISBN 978-1-60724-445-5

ISSN 1935-6854

Extract from The A^merican Journal of Archaeology, vol. 22 (1918).

Printed in the LTnited States of America

Srtfweologital institute of America

A

THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB1

THE objects here published were acquired in 1913 by the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. They are said to have constituted the complete equipment of a tomb at Chiusi. Since nothing in the nature of the objects contradicts this statement, it may be accepted as a working basis. I . T H E CINERARY URN The urn (No. 13.2860)2 is of the usual late Etruscan form (Figs. 1 and 2). The material is travertine, the lid being smoother and less porous than the chest. The chest is 51.5 cm. high, 71 by 36 cm. at the bottom, 63 by 30 cm. at the top, and the lid 75.7 cm. long, 34.7 cm. wide, and 52.5 cm. high. A small spot on the back of the lid is restored and the ends of the chest below the panels are slightly damaged. Otherwise the condition of the urn is excellent and a great deal of the paint remains. On the lid a woman wearing a low necked, sleeveless tunic held in by a belt reclines upon two cushions. A veil falls from her head over her shoulders, her right hand holds the folds of a mantle which is draped over her legs, and on her right foot, which protrudes slightly beyond the edge of the lid, is a sandal. Her waved hair is parted in front and held back by a narrow band. Around her neck is a torque and on her right arm two twisted bracelets; the one above the elbow is composed of two parallel rings, the one below, a spiral bracelet with S-shaped ends, encircles the wrist twice. A slight ridge on the third finger of the left hand may indicate a ring. An incised inscription extends across the front and part of the left end of the lid. On the front of the chest in a sunk panel is a winged monster resting on a projecting base. It has the body of a youth and, instead of legs, two coiled fish-tails ending in double fins and covered at their juncture with the body with a fin-like girdle. On its forehead is a pair of small wings, in its left hand a sword, in its right a stone (?). Painted on the moulding above the panel is an egg-and-dart pattern; on each side a fluted column. A patera in a sunk panel decorates each end. The portion below the panels, on both front and 1 1 am deeply indebted to Mr. L. D. Caskey, Curator of Classical Antiquities in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, for permission to publish this material, for his untiring assistance while I was studying the objects, and for most valuable suggestions. I also wish to thank Professor George H. Chase of Harvard University for his unfailing aid at every difficult point and for carefully reading the manuscript, and Miss G. M. A. Richter of the Metropolitan Museum, New York, whose keen criticism was most helpful. 2 The numbers are those of the registry of the museum.

American Journal of Archaeology, Second Series. Journal of the Archaeological Institute of America, Vol. X X I I (1918), No. 3. 2

OKI

252

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

ends, is hewn into the form of a double scroll. The back of the chest is unadorned. The color is distributed as follows: black, the background of the panels, t h e retreating areas below the scrolls at the bottom, the outline of the egg-and-dart pattern; brown, the woman's eyes and brows, the monster's hair, the outline of the capitals; vivid sea-green, the monster's fish-tails, the lower half of his wings and a border around the upper half, the wings on his forehead, the fluting of the columns, a broad band over the left end of each cushion, four (?) of t h e eggs on the moulding; red, the woman's hair, lips, and nostrils, the monster's lips, nostrils, eyes, and eyebrows, a longitudinal stripe on each fish-tail, t h e fins in which they terminate, two sections of the egg pattern, the background of the columns, parts of the capitals, the pattern on the scrolls below the relief, the letters of the inscription; fink, the veil, the mantle, two stripes enclosing the blue band on the cushions, the upper part of the monster's wings, t h e coiled extremities of his girdle, two sections of the egg pattern. There is no trace of color on the remaining portions.

As is well known, urns of this type, which are merely diminutive copies of the sarcophagi of the same period and are often found in the same tomb with them, were exceedingly popular in Southern Etruria during the third and second centuries B.C. The material was usually the local stone, which in the neighborhood of Chiusi is travertine, though terra-cotta was also used for both urns and sarcophagi. Comparatively few of the former are more than 80 cm. in length, the greater part ranging between 50 and 70 cm. Our urn is therefore exceptionally large. The projection of the lid beyond the ash-chest is not significant, for lids very often fail to fit the top of the urn upon which they rest. 1 Scenes borrowed from Greek legends form the subject of the reliefs on fully three-fourths of the Etruscan urns and sarcophagi, a few portray scenes from real life, but monsters of all sorts, which played an important rôle in the Etruscan conception of death, likewise occur frequently. Commonest among these is the type found on our urn, although the body is usually that of a woman.2 They sometimes carry symbols of the sea, as an oar or a trident, or perhaps, as on our urn, a rock, a sword, or other weapon. These fish-legged monsters, whether of Etruscan or of Greek invention, 3 1

Dennis is doubtless correct in assuming that dealers kept a large supply of ash-chests on hand and t h a t only the covers were made to order. Even these were perhaps blocked out roughly and finished when required (Cities and Cemeteries of Etruria, I, p. 480; cf. also Martha, L'Art Étrusque, pp. 366 ff.). 2 Cf. Dennis, op. cit. II, pp. 171 f. For another example of a male cf. Dennis, op. cit. II, p. 160 = Martha, op. tit. p. 167, fig. 135. 3 Cf. Dennis, op. cit. II, p. 172; Chase, in A.J.A. XV, p. 477; G. Matthies, Die Praenestinischen Spiegel, p. 108.

A THIRD CENTURY ETRUSCAN

TOMB

FIGURE 1.—ETRUSCAN CINERARY U R N : NO.

253

13.2860.

appeared in Italian art late in the fourth or early in the third century B.C. and probably have as prototype the serpent-legged giant of which at least one example belongs to the end of the fifth century. 1 1 Cf. Winnefeld,Festschr.fur Benndorf,pp.72 ff.,pl.I; Matthies,op.cit.p. 108.

254

L. O.

ELDBIDGE

Columns frequently enclose the relief on the front of both urns and sarcophagi, and the egg-and-dart pattern is common both above and below the scene, but these decorations seem usually to have been worked out in relief. There is no uniform type of capital used on urns; the only point of general resemblance is the regular appearance of volutes. The patera is a very common ornamental feature on these monuments. The back was rarely decorated, since it was designed to stand against a wall. The effigy on the lid of our urn, a young woman of mature and graceful form and comely features, reclines, as these figures invariably do, on the left elbow as if at a banquet, 1 but it differs from most of those hitherto published in two important respects: first, the body is much better proportioned; second, the head is turned so as almost to present the profile when viewed from the front of the urn. I know of but one example that is analogous to ours in these two respects, namely, an urn in the Museo Archeologico in Florence (Alinari, No. 17065). Its effigy presents a very close parallel but is not quite so well executed. Most of these figures face the front; some even look toward the right. Like all other figures on urns and sarcophagi of good workmanship, this one also is surely a portrait of the person whose remains were contained in the chest. The woman seems to have been painted to the life, a practice which was not unusual with figures that were we'll executed. If her flesh was tinted, as sometimes happened, the color has disappeared. 2 The paint on our urn is, however, much better preserved than is generally the case.3 Our urn then is not only larger and much better preserved than most of these monuments, but it is also of a distinctly superior type of workmanship. The proportions of the figure on the lid are excellent and the position natural and easy, characteristics which form a striking contrast to the grotesquely disproportionate effigies on the great mass of Etruscan urns. A quiet refinement of taste expressed in the dignified simplicity of dress and ornament separates our figure widely from most effigies of this kind with their burden of gaudy jewelry, and incongruous, conspicuous ob1

Cf. Dennis, op. tit. I, p. 475, etc. Cf. Dennis, op. cil. I, p. 477, II, p. 376. 3 The polychrome system is best observed on the urns from Cetona, Città della Pieve, and Perugia, Cf. Dennis, op. tit. II, pp. 302, 360, 376, 446. 2

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

FIGURE 2.—ETRUSCAN CINERARY URN: NO.

13.2860.

255

256

L. G.

ELDBIDGE

jects in their hands, and a pensive expression of pathos and resignation lends to the face a singular charm. The Inscription.—The inscription reads as follows: FASTIA VELSI LARZL VELUS PUIA.

Fastia is a feminine praenomen which usually appears in the form Fasti.1 The praenomen regularly occupies the first place in the proper name on an epitaph. 2 Velsi, the second word, as both position and form 3 suggest, is the family name of the woman's father. The patronyiric always appears in the names of Etruscan women with the suffix i added. 4 But the form Vels, which would here represent the gentile name, if i had been added with no further change, does not seem to appear as such in any known inscription. 5 The i then of Velsi must be either a contraction of the final i of the gentile name with the suffix i, or the former has been supplanted by the latter, a change which occasionally takes place. 6 The third word, Larzl,7 probably represents Larz and the suffix al with a omitted. The name which often stands third or fourth and ends in the suffix al is usually the mother's family name. Here, however, it appears to be the mother's praenomen. 8 The form Larz may be regarded as another spelling for LarS9 and is probably an abbreviated form of the full name Larza, just as Lard represents Larda, Lardia, or Lardi.]" The suffix al sig1

Cf. Fabretti, Glossarium Italicum, eols. 446 f.; Primo Suppl. 173, 187, etc.; Martha La Langue Etrusque, pp. 149, 75 f. 2 Cf. Müller, Die Etrusker, I, p. 508; Martha, op. cit. pp. 121 ff. 3 Cf. Müller, op. cit. II, p. 471; Martha, op. cit. pp. 75 f., 122. 4 Cf. Martha, op. cit. pp. 76, 122 f. 6 In the single instance in which this form occurs Fabretti, Gloss. Ital. col. 1918, thinks it may stand for Velsi. 6 Cf. Martha, op. cit. p. 76. 7 A small dot between r and z painted on the flat surface of the stone, not in a hollow chiselled for that purpose, may probably be attributed to carelessness on the part of the person who applied the paint, although words are occasionally separated into parts. Cf. e.g. Fabretti, Corpus Inscriptionum Italicarum, Nos. 1025, 1838. 8 Cf. Müller, op. cit. I, p. 508; Martha, op. cit. pp. 122 f. Lar ei seems in a few inscriptions to denote the gentile name. Cf. Fabretti, Gloss. Ital. col, 1010; Martha, op. cit. p. 142. 9 Cf. Müller, op. cit. I, p. 463; Martha, op. cit. pp. 52, 194. 10 Cf. Fabretti, Gloss. Ital. cols. 1004, 1006, 1007, 1010; Müller, op. cit. I, p. 463. The praenomen L/aris with the feminine form Larisa is very closely related to this group. Cf. Fabretti, Gloss. Ital. cols. 1014 f.; Müller, op. cit. I, p. 464, No. 16; Martha, op. cit. pp. 77, 123.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

257

nifies derivation or source and its use as the termination of the metronymic in epitaphs is extremely common.1 Fastia Velsi then was the daughter of Larza. The omission of the a of the suffix is possibly an example of syncope but probably simply an abbreviation. 2 The fourth word is composed of Vel, a form which appears very frequently as a masculine praenomen (sometimes written Vele),3 and the suffix us which has the same value as the genitive case in an inflected language. This relationship is ordinarily indicated by the ending s alone, but in some cases—regularly with Vel— a vowel is inserted. 4 Vel or Vele would seem then to be the praenomen of Fastia's husband. But the husband's family name, with or without his praenomen, not his praenomen alone, was the form regularly used in the epitaph of a married woman.5 Therefore, although I find no certain example of the employment of the simple form Vel or Vele with "genitive" in us as the name of a gens, 6 1 hold it more probable that this is a rare instance of such a use than that it is a praenomen used alone. Puia, the last word, is fairly common on the tombs of women and in most cases, as here, apparently means "wife". 7 The entire inscription, then, is to be interpreted as follows: Fastia, daughter of a Velsi and of Larza, and wife of a Vel. II.

SILVER

A.

MIRRORS

1.—Box-mirrors: Two box-mirrors presenting t h e same scene in relief, t h e larger mirror (No. 13.2875) 14.3 cm. in diameter, the smaller (No. 13.2876) 11.3 cm., are of very thin silver plate, a n d in very good condition. T h e cover of each is bent back a t the edge, forming a narrow rim which fits over the disk. T h e rim of the disk is also bent back and the under side is concave. The scene on the larger mirror (Fig. 3) is enclosed by a decorative border in low relief, consisting of a scroll pattern on a punctuated background outside of a moulding with rope p a t t e r n . T h e scene presents three figures in high relief going toward t h e left on a crescent. In t h e centre is Dionysus. His hair is twisted in a roll around his face and 1

Cf. Müller, op. cit. I, p. 504, b, II, p. 493; M a r t h a , op. cit. pp. 4-7. Cf. Müller, op. cit. I, p. 462, No. 15, II, pp. 343 f., 391 f. 3 Cf. Fabretti, Gloss. Ital. cols. 1903, 1906; Müller, op. cit. I, pp. 451 ff. 4 Cf. M a r t h a , op. cit. pp. 28, 92; Müller, op. cit. I, p. 504. 6 Cf. Müller, op. cit. I, p. 452; M a r t h a , op. cit. pp. 122 f. 6 Cf., however, Fabretti, Corpus Inscriptionum, Italicarum, No. 2455. 7 Cf. Fabretti Gloss. Ital. cols. 1476 f.; Müller, op. cit. I, p. 503 c., II, p. 477; Martha, op. cit. pp. 2, 30, 149 ff. 2

258

L. O.

ELDRIDGE

down on his neck. Back of the roll a band encircles his head. He looks to the right and supports himself upon two smaller figures with his arms around their necks. On his feet are endromides. At the right is Eros, his hair arranged like that of Dionysus towards whom he turns his face, and in his left hand, extended behind him, an inverted torch. His right arm and right leg disappear behind Dionysus, whose l e f t h a n d is spread out over Eros' breast. A ridge just above t h e left ankle seems to mark the top of a shoe. To the left of Dionysus is a little, bald papposilenus playing a double flute. His head is marked by punctuation and crowned w i t h an i v y w r e a t h . Over his shoulders hangs a narrow skin. Two grooves around h i s left ankle suggest a shoe top, but the foot seems to b e cloven. His right foot however, looks human. A coating Figtire 3 . — S i l v e r B o x - M i r r o b : No. 13.2875. of gilt remains on the decorative border, on the hair of all the figures, on Dionysus' boots, on the animal skin over Silenus' shoulders, on the flame of the torch, and on Eros' wings. A hinge, into the joint of which the ends of a handle for suspension are inserted, is attached to the rim of the disk alone, not to the cover as well so as to properly join the two portions. The rim has a few cracks and a very small piece is broken out. The relief on the smaller mirror (Fig. 4) is on a separate disk 8.7 cm. in diameter which is made fast in a slightly retreating area on the convex surface of the lid. The execution is exceedingly poor, so that all details are lost. Con-

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

259

siderable patches of gold leaf indicate that the figures' heads and the animal skin over Silenus' shoulders were originally gilded. Eros' wing appears also to have been indicated by gilding. The portion of the cover surrounding the emblema is thickly covered with green encrustation. The disk, from which two small pieces are broken, is very thin. There is no hinge.

The Etruscan box-mir-

^^^^^^^^^

j S « »

ror. Barely a hundred specFIGTJRE 4 . — S I L V E R B O X - M I R R O R : N O . 1 3 . 2 8 7 6 . imens are known. 3 Like the Greek box-mirrors, it consists of a lower portion on which fits a lid with or without decorative relief, 4 and it may or may not contain a separate polished disk. The two portions of the box may be joined by a hinge opposite which, 1 Cf. Martha, L'Art Étrusque, p. 542; Brit. Mus. Cat. of Bronzes, Introd. p. 1. Martha, p. 543, thinks it possible that some of the relief mirrors found in Italy are of Greek origin. Square box-mirrors, as well as round, appeared in Etruria; cf. Daremberg et Saglio, s. v. 'Speculum,' p. 1427; Martha, op. cit. p. 199, fig. 155. 2 Cf. Brit. Mus. Cat. of Bronzes, I. c. 3 Cf. Daremb. et Sagl., I. c. 4 On two Etruscan mirrors a relief adorns both faces; cf. 'Eip. 'Apx- 1893, pi. X V ; de Ridder, Bronzes d'Athènes, pp. 45 f., Nos. 161-2. The relief is sometimes wrought on the cover itself, sometimes on an attached disk, cf. Arch. Ztg. 1S80, p. 39; Dumont et Chaplain, Céramiques de la Grhce, I I , pp. 174, 208; Arch. Anz. 1891, p. 123, No. 6; Schumacher, Beschreibung d. ant. Bronzen zu Karlsruhe, pp. 41 f., No. 253; de Ridder, Les Bronzes Antiques du Louvre, p. 118; Richter, Metrop. Museum, Greek, Etruscan, and Roman Bronzes, p. 257.

260

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

on the cover, a ring for opening sometimes appears. When the enclosed disk is lacking, one or both of the interior surfaces are polished for reflection. 1 Our mirrors, therefore, present no peculiarities in form or manner of decoration. The use of silver, however, instead of bronze is most unusual. I find no record of any other silver box-mirrors.2 The plate is so exceedingly thin in our mirrors that they could hardly have served a practical purpose, but were doubtless designed as gifts for the dead. This may account for the careless way in which the hinge on the larger mirror is attached. But this defect is perhaps due to modern restoration, for a slight disfiguration on the rim of the cover above the scene very possibly marks the place where one side of the hinge was originally attached. The appearance of the same scene on both mirrors is not strange, for models were easy to transport and to reproduce and duplicates seem to have occurred frequently. 3 The Bacchic group here presented belongs to a class for which Greek reliefmirrors offered numerous prototypes. 4 Both Eros and Silenus frequently accompany Dionysus on this class of monuments. The inversion of the torch, an attribute which was very rarely given to Eros before the third century, 5 has here, of course, no significance. The reliefs on Etruscan mirrors, as on the Greek, seem for the most part to have been hammered, only the poorest being cast. 6 The relief on our larger mirror, which is very clearly and distinctly executed, was certainly hammered, but the other is very poor and was probably cast. 2 —Mirrors with handles: Two mirrors with handles (Fig. 5) are also of very thin plate. The larger (No. 13.2877) is 12.3 cm. in diameter and 24 cm. 1 Cf. Martha, op. cit. p. 542; de Ridder, Bronzes d'Athene», pp. 41 ff.; Daremb. et Sagl., I. c. pp. 1425 ff.; Brit. Mus. Cat. of Bronzes, Introd. p. xliv; Furtwangler und Reichhold, Gr. Vasenmalereill, p. 42; Richter, op. cit. p. 257; de Ridder, Bronzes ant. du Louvre, p. 115. The interior faces of Etruscan boxmirrors seem never to have been decorated with engraved scenes. Cf. de Ridder, op. cit. p.118. 2 Martha (op. cit. p. 542) refers to two silver relief-mirrors and to fragments of others, but these are apparently not box-mirrors. 3 Cf. Martha, op. cit. p. 543; Rom. Mitt. V, pp. 92 if. 4 Cf. Daremb. et Sagl., I. c. 6 Cf. Furtwangler, Eros in der Vasenmalerei, pp. 71 f. 6 Cf. Daremb. et Sagl., I. c.: de Ridder, Bronzes Ant. du Louvre, p. 118.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

261

long including the handle. The disk is round and slightly convex. The edge of both disk and handle is turned back at right angles to the surface. The handle, which is broad at the top and heart-shaped at the end, is reattached. There are two cracks in the rim. The convex surface and the handle are thickly encrusted. The smaller mirror (No. 13.2878) is 11.6 cm. in diameter and 22 cm. long including the handle. Excepting the extension with its four sharp corners, this mirror has practically the same form as the larger one, but the rim is not bent

Figure 5.—8ilyek Mirrors and Steigils: Xos. 13.2877-78 and 13.2873-74,

262

L. G.

ELDRIDOE

back. It is put together from many pieces and two small portions of the rim are lost. Both surfaces are considerably encrusted.

The shape of these mirrors is the usual one for Etruscan bronze engraved mirrors of the period,1 but the use of silver for mirrors of this form seems to have been almost as rare as it was for the box type. Except the silver relief-mirrors mentioned above,2 I know of only one other specimen, the mirror cited below from the tomb of Seianti Thanunia.3 Probably these fragile objects, like the two box-mirrors, were designed for burial. In any case, Fastia's set of four silver mirrors appears to be entirely without parallel. B.

VASES

1.—A flask-shaped vase (No. 13.2864) with extremely delicate walls is 12 cm. in height and 6.2 cm. in diameter at the base. The entire surface is covered with ornamentation in very low relief with incised details (Fig. 6) .4 The decoration falls into six bands. Around the upper band, which encircles the neck and is enclosed between two dotted lines, runs a laurel wreath on a very finely punctuated background. The leaves are arranged in pairs and extend from a point presumably designed as the back in opposite directions, meeting at the front. Between each pair of leaves a pair of heavy stems ending in a dotted circle, doubtless designed to represent a berry, springs from the main stalk. A group of four of these berries marks the point at which the two ends of the stalk meet. Below this is a band covered with four rows of delicate feather pattern. Between the ends of each pair of feathers is a dot. The vanes are marked with very fine incised strokes. Next is a narrow band around the shoulder with a guilloche pattern. The fourth band is filled with three rows of feather pattern like that above. A broad band around the middle of the body is ornamented by a waved ivy wreath on a finely punctuated background. The slightly conventionalized leaves are arranged in pairs which turn alternately upward and downward. The lowest and broadest band is encircled by a festoon enclosing three bucrania above and three large acanthus leaves below, on a background of fine feathers like those on the second and fourth bands. The elevated portions of the festoon are ornamented with dotted circles. The looped portions are filled with tiny, upturned leaves in which only the midribs are indicated. A fillet wound around the garland 1 The heart-shaped extremities of the handles is a degenerate form of the animal head in which the handles of Etruscan and Praenestine mirrors of the latest period regularly terminated. Cf. G. Matthies, op. cit. p. 6. 2 Page 260, note 2. 3 In the Roman period silver mirrors seem-to have been more common, and even gold ones were in use. Cf. e.g. Friederich, Berlins Antike Bildwerke, pp. 85 f.; Daremb. et Sagl., I. c. p. 1429; Richter, op. cit. p. 288. A silver mirror disk was found in Banias, Syria; de Ridder, Coll. de Clercq, III, p. 324, No. 533. 4 1 am indebted to the kindness of Mr. Caskey for this excellent restoration.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

263

FIGURE 6.—SILVER V A S E : NO. 1 3 . 2 8 6 4 .

separates the portions with different decoration and also defines the point, at the bottom of each loop, from which the leaves turn in opposite directions. A narrow fillet is attached to each horn of the bucrania. The spreading acanthus leaves are composed of several members springing from a central rib which is ornamented by a row of dots. On the entire vase the feather decoration is slightly graduated, each row being a trifle smaller than the row below. The first, third, and fifth bands and the festoon are gilded. The extremely delicate texture of the walls of this vase is equalled by the exquisite fineness of the execution. It is in a fragmentary state and has been only partially restored. About two fifths is lost. 2.—A vase designed for suspension (No. 13.2867), the walls of which are also very thin, is 12.3 cm. high, not including the chain (Fig. 7, A).1 A band with a zigzag pattern encircles the neck. The shoulder, which bends outward abruptly from the neck, is covered with four rows of small feathers like those on No. 1. 1

The chain in the reproduction does not belong to this vase.

264

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

The body tapers from the sharp angle which it forms with the shoulder to a blunted point. It is divided into two fields by a narrow band enclosed betweefti two punctuated lines and decorated with a wave pattern on a background punched, not with a pointed, but an edged instrument. A narrow band around the top of the body is marked with a zigzag pattern and defined at its lower edge by a punctuated line. From this band are looped three "necklace" patterns suspended by fillets with two long ends. At the bottom of each pendant is a group of three dots. In each of the fields above the necklace patterns is an ornament suggesting a much conventionalized bucranium with a fillet suspended from each horn. In the lowest field three slender, veined

A

U

FIGURE 7 . — S I L V E R VASES: A, NO. 1 3 . 2 8 6 7 ; c, No. 13.2868.

C B, NO.

13.2866;

leaves with edges defined by punctuated lines spring from the tip of the vase to the horizontal band. Alternating with these leaves at their upper extremities are three leaves without veins. Their outline and midribs are indicated by a series of short, horizontal strokes between two parallel lines. Between each pair of leaves is a flower indicated by three dots on the end of a punctuated stem. A slight projection on one side of the vase just below the shoulder marks the point at which one of the chains for suspension was attached. The surface is badly encrusted, especially the neck and shoulder, and part of the mouth is broken away. No certain traces of gilt remain. Although this vase is less delicate in execution and less rich in ornamentation than No. 1, yet it is an excellent specimen of silversmith's work.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

265

TOMB

3.—A third vase (No. 13.2869) also of very thin plate and designed to be suspended, is circular with a conical cover (Fig. S, A). I t is 7.3 cm. in diameter at the bottom and 7 cm. high including the cover. Around the top and bottom of the box are mouldings, and on each side an ear for the attachment of

A FIGURE 8 . — S I L V E B

C AND G L A S S V A S E S : A, N O .

c, No. 13.2900.

8 13.2889;

B, NO.

13 2865;

a chain is soldered on. A festoon in four loops is employed as decoration. The right half of each loop is filled with upward pointed leaves on which both midrib and veins are roughly indicated, the left half with circles with indented centres. A fillet wound around the garland at the four points of elevation and at the bottom of each loop separates the two varieties of decoration. Diverging from the top of the lid, four large acanthus leaves extend to the horizontal rim. Their midribs are indicated by punctuated lines between two grooves, and veins are suggested by ridges. Alternating with these leaves are four smooth-edged leaves. The midribs, which are like those just described, are enclosed between a pair of raised ribs. Between each pair of leaves is a group of three dots, and placed more or less at random over the surface of the smoothedged leaves are dots in pairs. The garland and the midribs of the acanthus leaves are covered with gilt, which almost everywhere overlaps the pattern. The execution is much less delicate and careful than that of the preceding vases. No chain is now attached. A tiny piece is broken out of the cover and in some places the surface is slightly corroded. Otherwise the box is splendidly preserved. 4.—Another vase designed for suspension (No. 13.2868) of the same general form as No. 2, but somewhat heavier and with flaring mouth and foot and more sloping, rounded shoulder, is 11 cm. in height (Fig. 7, c). Around the neck run two parallel grooves. Two bands with wave pattern encircle the vase, one on the shoulder, the other on the top of the body. Below the lower band and suspended so as to meet it at four points is a festoon, of which the first and third loops are filled with dotted circles, the second and fourth, with crudely rendered leaves. The festoon is suspended by fillets with two long ends. In each field above the festoon is an ornament consisting of four leaves. All

266

L.

G. ELD

RIDGE

parts of the decorative pattern are gilded. T w o perforations in the lip admit rings to which chains are attached. 1 The mouth of the vase and the rings are covered with greenish blue encrustation. A patch of encrustation disfigures one side of the shoulder. Otherwise the vase is in excellent condition. This vase, distinctly inferior in execution to N o . 1 and N o . 2, is also coarser than N o . 3. 5.—Another circular box with conical cover (No. 13.2866), resembling N o . 3 in form, is 7 cm. in height including the cover and 5.8 cm. in diameter at the bottom (Fig. 7, B). T h e cover had a ring, presumably for the attachment of a chain. Ears soldered to each side serve to attach twisted chains in two sections. A t the top the chains are joined by a slender handle. A waved band of carelessly applied gilt leaf encircles the box in three loops and similar gilt bands cross the lid twice in one direction and once in the other. Considerable patches of light green encrustation fleck the surface. About half of the gilt leaf has disappeared and the ring on t h e c o v e r is broken. Otherwise the box is excellently preserved. 6.—A circular box with conical lid (No. 13.2865) is 5.4 cm. in diameter at the bottom and 7.5 cm. high including the lid (Fig. 8, B) . A ring on the cover probably served to attach a chain. The lower edge is encircled by a moulding. T h e surface of the box is rather rough, the entire lid thickly encrusted, and a number of cracks are patched. FIGURE 9.—SILVER VASE: N o . 13.2862.

7 , — A jug-shaped vase (No. 13.2862) is 13.5 cm.

high with a base 5.7 cm. in diameter (Fig. 9). A flat cover closes the mouth. A broad crack across the top of the vase splits it almost half w a y to the base. Other Cracks are patched. T h e neck was broken off but is reattached on one side. Much of the surface is thickly encrusted. 1 T h e handle and chains shown in Fig. 7c do not belong to this vase. They are wired on and a fragment of the original chain, which was twisted, is still attached to one of the rings. T h e handle is covered with green encrustation.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

267

8.—A cauldron-shaped receptacle (No. 13.2863) is 10.2 cm. high, 13 cm. in diameter, and 11 cm. across the top, including the narrow horizontal rim (Fig. 10, B). A thin, flat strip of silver constitutes a swinging handle, the hookshaped ends of which are inserted into rings formed from wires passed through a pair of perforations in the rim and bent back on the under side. One of these rings is broken and portions of the handle are missing. The remainder of the handle is attached to the rim through corrosion. Numerous cracks are patched and much of the outer surface is badly encrusted. 9.—A second cauldron (No. 13.2861) is 10.3 cm. high, 12.3 cm. in diameter, and 10 cm. across the top including the horizontal rim (Fig. 10, A). In contrast

FIGUHE

10.—SILVER

CAULDRONS

to the oval contour of the preceding cauldron, this presents a more pronounced shoulder from which the body tapers gradually to the bottom. The handle is similar in form to that of No. 8, but it is broader and heavier and the ends are bent up so as to form long hooks passing through heavy ears which were attached to the under surface of the rim. The handle is repaired in several places and is now in two parts. The ears have come off and two portions of the rim are broken away. Many cracks are patched and a large part of the surface both inside and out is covered with thick encrustation. 10.—The presence of several loose rings and fragments of chain, and of six more handles, 1 either entire or fragmentary and, in some cases, with portions of 1 The two heaviest handles, the only ones intact, are silver; the others may be bronze.

3

268

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

twisted chains attached, apparently indicates that at least five vases for suspension have disappeared; one of the handles may belong to No. 3.

None of the articles from the tomb are of more importance or of greater interest than the silver vases. They are doubtless all toilet receptacles, including Nos. 7, 8, and 9 which, although somewhat larger than the rest, probably served to hold liquids of some sort used at the bath. But several of them are so extremely fragile that it is most unlikely that they were made for daily use. So presumably these objects, like the silver mirrors, belonged to a funerary equipment. From the standpoint of technique the vases fall into two groups, the ornamented (Nos. 1-5) and the plain (Nos. 6-9). In general the ornamented group is of distinctly finer quality and more careful execution than the plain, but among the decorated vases there is also a wide divergence in the quality of workmanship. Far surpassing all of the others in richness and originality of design, in elaboration of detail, and in fineness and delicacy of finish, No. 1 occupies a unique position in the group. In form also it is without analogy among the other vases. Very close parallels, however, are found in five bronze vases, all from Italian soil. These are published as follows: (a) Mon. Ant. IX, col. 694, fig. 231; (b) Ibid. pi. VIII, 8; (c) Mus. Greg. I, pi. LIX, 3 (left) 2 ; (d) Ibid. 3 (right); (e) Schumacher, Ant. Bronzen zu Karlsruhe, pp. 33 f., No. 221, pi. IV, 17. The decoration on all of these vases is arranged, as on our vase, in horizontal bands. The feather pattern, which on our vase predominates, also appears on all, but only on the neck. An ivy wreath on a punctuated background, almost identical with the one on our vase, encircles three of the bronze vases (a, b, d). On all of them the surface is almost or entirely covered with decoration, and on three at least (a, b, e) portions of the decorative surface were coated with silver, just as on our vase gilding was employed. But the tongue, the wave, and the leaf-and-dart patterns, which predominate on the bronze vases, do not appear on the silver vase, nor is the conventional ornamentation of the bronze vases relieved by any touch of Hellenistic freedom, such as is produced by the festoons, bucrania, and acanthus leaves on the lowest band of the silver vase, and by the abundant employment of the feather pattern. 1 2

This is the only one of these five vases that has feet or a chain. The references are to the first edition of the Museo Etrusco Gregoriano.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

269

Brizio argues convincingly t h a t the necropolis from which a and b came belonged to the Senonian Gauls. 1 The vases, therefore cannot be later t h a n 283 B.C., the year in which the Gauls were expelled by the Romans. Watzinger includes c and d in a group of vases, some of which were found in a t o m b containing a coin of Parisades. 2 The coin, at any rate, cannot be earlier t h a n 285 B.C. Watzinger places the vases in the middle of the third century. Schumacher designates e as "Etruskisch des V-IV Jahrh." The striking resemblance among these five vases in form, technique, and ornamentation leaves no doubt t h a t they all belong to the same period. Therefore, if Brizio is correct, c and d cannot be included in Watzinger's group above mentioned, the remaining examples of which apparently belong, as he states, to the middle of the third century, but are probably as early as the beginning of t h a t century and to be included among the first examples of metal vases upon which low relief was combined with engraving, a process representing a phase in the gradual development from decoration in engraving alone to the employment of high relief. 3 In respect to form, to the general scheme of band decoration, and t o t h e encircling ivy wreath, our vase is an imitation and a continuation of the type represented by the bronze vases. But its technique and certain features in the decorative system, particularly the acanthus leaves springing from the bottom, link it to Watzinger's group referred to above. 4 The purely Hellenistic elements appearing on the lowest band and the lavish use of the feather pattern 5 also place our vase distinctly later than the bronze vases. 1

Mon. Ant. IX, cols. 711 ff. Ath. Mitt. XXVI, pp. 98 f. 3 Watzinger, op. cit. 4 It is in this class of metal vases that we find the origin of the leaf motive which, springing out from the base, was at first confined to the lower part of the vase, but in its further development, as is most conspicuously illustrated by the "Megarian" bowls, spread over practically the entire surface. Cf. Watzinger, op. cit. p. 97; Arch. Am. 1897, pp. 128 ff. 6 The same type of feather pattern appears on a gold rhyton of the fourth century from Turgan (Compte-Rendu 1877, pi. I, No. 7) and on a silver-gilt plate from Rhodes (Brit. Mas. Cat. Jewellery, p. 234, fig. 66). The capital of a bronze candelabrum in Cairo (Cat. Mus. Caire, Creek Bronzes, pi. XIV, No. 27.800 a and 6) and a silver vase in Petrograd (Ant. d. Bos. Cirri, pi. XL) offer interesting examples of the employment of this pattern in later times. 2

270

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

The adoption of the bucraniuni as a decorative motive for vases must be a reflection of its use in architecture, where it would logically develop, both sculptured and painted, from the custom of displaying the heads of sacrificed victims on altars and temples. It was not a feature of classic Greek architecture, if the evidence of preserved buildings is regarded as conclusive. A round temple in Samothrace built in the beginning of the third century B.C. seems to be the earliest known structure on which the sculptured bucranium appears. 1 But a gem published by Furtwangler (Antike Gemmen, pi. XXXI, No. 1) among Greek stones of the fifth to fourth centuries is engraved with a bucranium, and one also decorates the extension of a Praenestine mirror which has been assigned to the first half of the fourth c e n t u r y . 2 Probably earlier than either of these, and extremely interesting as a direct imitation in miniature of monumental sculpture, is a little Greek vase in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, with a slender, finely proportioned black bucranium in relief on a red background (Fig. II). 3 The horns are long and gracefully curved, and the hair is indicated by delicately incised curved strokes. No fillets mar its classic outline. Such objects may be regarded as evidence of the existence of this sort of architectural decoration before the time of Alexander, for in all of these instances the use of the bucranium was surely suggested by monumental art. But it does not appear in common use until the third century B.C. The first indication of the adoption of the woven garland in the place of the simple branch appears in scenes on red-figured 1

Cf. Altmann, Architektur und Ornamentik der antiken Sarkophage, p. 62; Conze, Hauser, Benndorf, Untersuchungen auf Samothrake, pi. LXI, etc. 2 Cf. Matthies, op. cit. pp. 77 f.; 117. On the extension of a later mirror from Teano the same decoration appears. Cf. Mon. Ant. X X , cols. 135-6, fig. 103. 3 No. 95.55, Collection Van Branteghem, No. 261. This long, slender bucranium is in marked contrast to the broad, stumpy form which is usual in the later Greek type that presents the entire head. Cf. Altmann, op. cit. pp. 62 f.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

271

vases of the second half of the fourth century. 1 The first illustration that I know of the employment in architecture of the heavy, compact, genuinely Hellenistic festoon, 2 such as our vase presents in a somewhat conventionalized form is on a painted altar of the first half of the third century now in the museum of Alexandria. Here the garland is suspended by fillets.3 The earliest monument in architecture thus far recorded upon which festoons appear suspended by bucrania is the temple of Artemis in Magnesia erected between 220 and 205 B.C.4 Leroux regards the style of decoration found on the Large North Portico at Delos, built at the end of the third century, as the specific forerunner of this combination of bucranium and festoon. The decoration of the portico consists of bucrania alone on the triglyphs of the façade and appears, Leroux argues, not complete in itself but designed as a background for actual garlands which were suspended on the bucrania. Very likely on this structure and on others of the same period, on which bucrania alone appeared, festoons were suspended from them. The employment of this form of decoration in sculpture on contemporary monuments practically proves it. But I regard it as much more probable that originally bucrania sculptured on monuments without an adequate architectural setting were designed not as mere supports for festoons but as motives with an individual significance which enclosing festoons should serve to emphasize and enhance. As the victim offered to the god was the significant feature, and not the wreaths with which it was decked, so the victim's head attached to the altar or temple of the god, and not the garland, was the object of importance. Therefore the festoons which were employed to furnish a setting for the bucrania were doubtless originally attached between them by means of fillets or rosettes or perhaps invisibly. On the temple in Samothrace cited above as an early example of the employment of the bucranium in architecture, a plain waved band passing below the bucrania and above a rosette placed between 1

Cf. Daremb. et Sag!., s. v. 'Serta,' p. 1258 and fig. 6379. Cf. Daremb. et Sag!., p. 1259. 3 Cf. G. Leroux, Lagynos, p. 123. 4 Cf. Leroux, op. cit. p. 125; Humann, Kohte, Watzinger, Magnesia Meander, p. 81, figs. 76, 77. 2

am

272

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

each pair was presumably suggested by this use of the festoon, or may have been designed to be covered by a garland.1 I t is therefore this style of architectural decoration that doubtless inspired the combination of the bucranium2 and the Hellenistic festoon in the form used on our vase, a combination which apparently never acquired popularity, for Hellenistic pottery bears no evidence of its general use.3 In fact I know of no contemporary parallel for this part of the decorative scheme on No. 1. Nos. 3 and 4 and particularly the circular box from the tomb of Thanunia show very close relationship to it, but I regard these rather as evidence of the influence on a declining industry of the superior type which No. 1 represents than as inferior products of the same date. No. 1 seems, therefore, to be as rare in style of decoration as it is in quality of execution. The other vases from the tomb are of great interest as illustrations of the gradual decadence of art in the third century. Not only do they preserve many characteristics of the products of the early third century, but their manifest relationship to late third and early second-century material clearly indicates their relative position between the two. The fact that most of these vases were designed to be suspended, and the presence in the tomb of numerous handles and pieces of chain indicate the popularity of this style of receptacle. Vases for suspension were no novelty. From the earliest Egyptian period vases were suspended in some form or other. In the Villanova period a small, tureen-shaped vase provided with chains was a very common type.4 On some of these at least the 1 It is rather interesting to observe that the acanthus leaves on capitals in this temple are of exactly the same form as those on our vase (Conze, etc. op. cit. pi. L X ) ; also that a cone-shaped architectural ornament which adorned some part of the temple is covered with a scale pattern strongly suggesting the feather pattern on the vase (op. cit. pi. LIX). 2 Our bucranium, like the relief on the vase in Boston, is much more slender than is usual in the type that presents the head in its natural form. Cf. p. 270, note 3. 3 The festoon alone in Hellenistic form appears on a certain class of late vases with dark decoration on white background (cf. Daremb. et Sagl., op. cit. p. 1259; Leroux, op. cit. p. 114). In the Roman period lions' heads, masks, etc., very commonly occupied the space above festoons, which had then become a favorite decorative motive in every class of art (cf. Altmann, op. cit. p. 60; Daremb. et Sagl., I. c.). 4 Cf. Mm. Ant., V, col. 302, pis. IX, 21, X I I I , 19; Not. Scav. 1882, pi. X I I , 7; 1889, pi. I, 12.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

273

chains that supported the vase, as well as a third chain attached to the cover, were joined at the top by a fibula.1 Possibly the handles on our vases, the common third-century type, represent a development of this yse of the fibula. But the form might have been readily suggested by the handles on situlae, box-

mirrors, etc. Very possibly No. 5, and perhaps some of the others, had a third chain attached to the cover.2 A bronze toilet receptacle in Karlsruhe offers a good illustration of this type. 3 Vases in the form of a human head suspended by chains 1 Cf. Not. Scav. 1882, pi. XII, 7. Probably Nos. 1 and 2 and perhaps also No. 4 were originally provided with covers. A fragment of a silver cap like the lid on No. 7 may have belonged to No. 1. 8 Cf. Schumacher, op. cit. p. 34, No. 222, pi. IV, 19. 2

274

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

were much used in Etruria. 1 A vase found in Pompeii hanging from a ring together with four strigils and a patera, all of bronze, furnishes ample proof of the purpose of such receptacles.2 In this respect a fourth-century Praenestine mirror, published in Gerhard, op. cit. IV, pl. 317 (Fig. 12), and Matthies, op. cit. pp. 90 ff., is also extremely interesting. The vase depicted there suggests in form our Nos. 2 and 4. A somewhat closer parallel to it is presented by a silver vase (A)3 in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.4 This vase together with the silver box (B) found with it, 5 as well as the silver box from Taman (C) and the silver vase from Kertsch (D), published in Antiquités du Bosphore Cimmérien, pis. XXXVII, 36 and XXXI, 3a respectively, should be added to the group of vases placed by Watzinger 7 at the beginning of the third century. Furthermore, I consider it very probable that the decoration of all of the objects in this group, except perhaps the bowl, is hammered in, as noted by Furtwângler in the case of the two silver vases in the Metropolitan Museum, and not simply engraved as stated by Watzinger. 8 This, however, is not incompatible with the date assigned by him, i.e. the early third century. It has already been shown that the prototypes of our vase No. 1, which are decorated in the same technique, belong to this period. In the type of vases represented especially by the four mentioned above as belonging in Watzinger's earlier group, and by Compte-Rendu 1880, pl. IV, 9 from Taman (E) and Arch. Anz. 1899, p. 129, from Boeotia (F) are to be found the prototypes of all of our vases with chains (No. 1 was probably never suspended) and of No. 6. In form No. 2 is very close to A and D, No. 4 1

Cf e.g. Richter, op. cit. p. 194, No. 510 and references. The Boston Museum possesses a number of specimens. 2 Cf. Niccolini, Case di Pompeii, II, 2, pl. LXII. 3 1 employ these designations to facilitate future reference. 4 Cf. Richter, op. cit. pp. 181 f.; Furtwângler in Sitzb. Mun. Akad. 1905, pp. 272 f., pl. IX. 6 Cf. Richter, I. c. ; Furtwângler, I. c. 6 This box is not identical with Compte-Rendu, 1880, pl. II, 23, as Watzinger's publication seems to imply (p. 98, No. 2), and does not belong in the same group. 7 Op. cit. pp. 92 f. 8 1 assume from the reproductions that this is the same technique as that of our vases, i.e. a low relief produced by impressing the outlines from the outside.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

275

presents a splendid parallel to E and F, while Nos. 3, 5, and 6 are manifestly degenerate descendants of B and C. No. 2 reflects all four of the vases which have the form of an amphora in the circlet of upward turned leaves around the bottom. The analogy with A and D is particularly close owing to the likeness in form. The necklace pattern on No. 2 also indicates the closest relationship with A and D, 1 and even more striking is the appearance on both D and No. 2 of the feather pattern. But this pattern in like manner links No. 2 very closely to No. 1, and the bucranium-like pattern above each necklace, as well as the general character of the workmanship, also emphasizes its Hellenistic nature. The festoons on Nos. 3 and 4, filled with leaves and dotted circles, establish a close connection between these vases and No. 1. The leaf ornament on the lid of No. 3 is simply an adaptation by reversing the direction of the decorative scheme on the bottom of several of the vases considered above. The lid of B suggests at once the prototype. But B still preserves the conventional fineness of the classic style, while No. 3 has become free and careless, in a word, Hellenistic. The only point of special interest attaching to No. 5 is the fact that the clear, whitish color of the silver and the color, texture, and mode of application of the gilding find exact counterparts in the smaller box-mirror (Fig. 4). The two objects were certainly made in the same place at the same time. Nos. 6 and 7 merit no further comment except possibly the mention of a jug-shaped bronze bottle of the fourth (?) century and similar bronze bottles of the Roman period in the Metropolitan Museum as fairly good parallels for No. 7 in form. 2 The small cauldrons, Nos. 8 and 9, are of a type which not infrequently appears in women's tombs of the third and second centuries. 3 They are of the same form as the larger utensils used in the kitchen, but since they are so small and sometimes of silver, and since they appear to be found only among toilet ob1

The necklace ornament, a characteristic of several of the vases in Watzinger's group to which A. and D belong (op. cit. pp. 92 ff.), indicates the advent of the Hellenistic tendency to reproduce in sculpture and painting objects as they appeared in reality; cf. Leroux, op. cit. p. 122. 2 Cf. Richter, op. cit. p. 193, No. 506; pp. 195 f., Nos. 514, 515. 3 Cf. Helbig, Rom. Mitt. I, p. 219. By far the finest specimen is the bronze situla from Bolsena presenting The Return of Hephaestus in relief; cf. Heydemann, Hallisches Winckelmannsprogramm, 1879, pp. 99 f., pi. IV, Nos. 3-3b.

276

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

jects I think, as I have stated above, that they belong to the equipment for the toilet or the bath. 1 Almost exact parallels, especially for No. 9, are found in a small bronze cauldron from Perugia 2 and a silver one from the tomb of Seianti Thanunia (Fig. 13) near Chiusi.3 The handle of the latter resembles that of No. 8 in lacking the long, hooked ends.4 In the main, the threads of connection thus far traced in our silver vases lead backward, sometimes many decades backward.

F I G U R E 1 3 . — S I L V E R O B J E C T S PROM T H E T O M B OP S E I A N T I BRITISH MUSEUM.

THANUNIA:

They demonstrate clearly the heritage of these objects from the past. But they are often only single, isolated, and usually broken 1 Cf. e.g. Helbig, Bull. Inst. 1877, p. 202. 2 Cf. Not. Scav. 1900, p. 559, fig. 7. 3 1 am indebted to the great kindness of Mr. Arthur H. Smith, Keeper of Greek and Roman Antiquities in the British Museum, for a photograph of the silver objects from this tomb. Cf. also Not. Scav. 1886, pp. 353 ff.; Rom. Mitt. I, pp. 217 ff.; Ant. Denk. I, pp. 9 f. 4 On a late Etruscan mirror from Bomarzo one of these small cauldrons appears. Gerhard, op. cit. V (Korte), No. 89.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

277

threads. Regarded as a whole, the vases are far more closely related to a later group. A comparison with the silver objects from the tomb of Seianti Thanunia (Fig. 13) affords the most convincing evidence. The small cauldron, as already stated, is almost a duplicate of our No. 9. The circular box with rings for suspension on both body and lid is very similar both in form and in style of decoration to our No. 3. Bucrania are employed as on our No. 1, but they are placed both above and below the festoon and are of an extremely degenerate type. The spherical vase suspended on short chains with a handle 1 and decorated with a band of punctuated wave pattern, although it has no analogy in form among the preserved vases of our group, is of the same general style. The presence of a silver strigil recalls at once our three silver strigils. Finally, the silver mirr&r, although unlike our specimens, establishes a certain relationship, since silver mirrors are so rare. But the articles in the Thanunia tomb are, on the whole, careless and coarse in execution in comparison with our vases.2 They appear to represent a later period in which long used types had become worn out and degenerate. Fortunately we have evidence bearing on the date of these objects. Together with a sarcophagus of exactly the same type and style as Seianti Thanunia's, namely that of Larthia Seianti, also found near Chiusi, was a Roman uncial as which dates the tomb between 217 and 146 B.C. Milani places the Thanunia tomb in the second half of the second century. 3 I see no reason for dating it any later than the Larthia tomb, in which the coin was found, and believe that both belong to the first half of the second century, possibly half a century later than our tomb, but probably less than that. 4 Our vases may, I think, with one exception, be placed in the second half of the third century, probably toward the end. No. 1, however, which is so finely executed, so similar in form to earlier types, and so original in style of decoration, is probably at least 1

The drawing in Ant. Denk. shows this vase with chains and handle. Cf. Not. Scav. 1886, p. 355. 3 Not. Scav. I. c. 4 To the same class and the same period belong doubtless the gold and silver articles from a tomb in Civitella d'Arna described in Not. Scav. 1887, p. 86. Gamurrini dates the tomb in the third century, but the presence on a silver vase of festoons suspended from bucrania renders such an early date highly improbable (cf. above, p. 270). A few silver toilet objects from Larthia's tomb are all of different nature from anything in Fastia's. Cf. Bull. Inst. 1877, pp. 201 f. 2

278

L. G.

EDLRIDGE

as early as the middle of the third century. I also consider it quite possible that it was an importation from the same centre of metal industry1 which produced its bronze prototypes, and that our other vases are of local manufacture. At all events, wherever they were produced, our group of vases is of great significance in representing one phase in a long line of silver manufacture, the exact nature of which we are as yet able to judge only by a comparatively small number of isolated specimens.2

B FIGURE

14.—SILVER C.

STRIGIL:

NO.

13.2872.

STRIGILS

1.—A strigil of the usual Etruscan form (No. 13.2872) is 21.7 cm. long and intact (Fig. 14) ,3 The inside of the handle above the very deeply hollowed surface of the blade is gilded. It is perfectly preserved. 2—Two other strigils (Nos. 13.2873 and 13.2874), similar in form to the first but without gilding, are broken and a few pieces are lost (Fig. 5). The color and texture of both the silver and the gilt of the unbroken strigil indicate that it was produced together with the smaller box-mirror and vase No. 5 (see p. 275). 1 We have no means thus far of determining where the silverware of the third century was produced. Watzinger, on the basis of provenience, suggests the coast of Asia Minor (op. cit. p. 102; cf. also Martha, L'Art Étrusque, p. 517). The early appearance in Asia Minor and on the islands of the Aegean of the Hellenistic motives employed on our vase No. 1 adds force to his suggestion. 2 Cf. Watzinger, op. cit. pp. 100 ff. 3 Fig. 14, A shows it as it was found, attached to a badly oxidized iron nail upon which it had been suspended; Fig. 14, B as it now appears.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

279

Strigils were, of course, in almost daily use by men among both Greeks and Romans, 1 and in Etruria at least they were used by women as well, for they are found in the graves of Etruscan women, and on Etruscan bronze mirrors women are depicted in the act of using them. 2 They are usually of bronze, although other metals were sometimes employed, filver, however, is very rare. Besides the three silver strigils given to Fastia Velsi, I know of only four specimens, all found in women's tombs, but only one in each. 3 D.

BKACELETS.

1.—One bracelet (No. 13.2870), is formed from a solid silver wire with the hooked extremities slightly thinner than the middle and terminating in serpents' heads. Its longest diameter is 8 cm. (Fig. 15, A). 2.—Another bracelet (No. 13.2871), also 8 cm. in diameter, is formed from a hollow tube 6 mm. thick (Fig. 15 B). The ends, which taper into solid wires, overlap and are wound three times around the body of the bracelet.

Bracelets of all sorts ending in snakes' heads were much used in Hellenistic and Roman times. The heads were sometimes

A FIGURE

15.—SILVER

B BRACELETS:

A, N O .

13.2870;

B, NO.

13.2871.

1 For a discussion of these objects, cf. Richter, op. cit. pp. 293 f. See Not Scav. 1898, p. 398, fig. 4, for a copper strigil. 2 For example, Gerhard, op. cit. IV, 317, fig. 12, 318; V, 154. Aphrodite using a strigil forms the handle of a strigil from Palestrina and of a patera from Vulci, in the British Museum, Cat. of Bronzes, Nos. 665 and 755. In a bath scene on a late red-figured amphora in the Boston Museum (No. 95.21; Rom. Mitt. V I I I , 1893, p. 338, No. 18) two women have strigils in their hands. 3 I t is interesting to note that all of these graves also produced other objects which find parallels in our tomb. Cf. Furtwängler, op. cit. p. 274, fig. 8; Ant. d. Bos. Cim. pi. X N X I , Nos. 2, 3; Ant. Denk. I, p. 9, fig. 3.

280

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

hooked together, as on our specimen1; oftener they formed the extremities of ornate spiral bracelets, such as Fastia wears on her wrist.2 The bracelet with overlapping ends coiled about its body is of interest as an example of a type which originated in remotest times and endured throughout antiquity. The opinion has been expressed that finger rings composed of a piece of wire inserted through an ornament and joined at the ends in the manner of our bracelet, so as to be adjustable to a finger of any size, were the first articles of jewelry employed by man. 3 However that may be,4 the form appeared very early and was soon adopted for bracelets and earrings, but I have found no other specimen of any date that is so neatly moulded as our bracelet. 5 1

Cf. e.g. Mon. Ant. X X , cols. 81f., fig. 49. Cf. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. p. 324, No. 2774 and remarks. It is interesting to observe t h a t both of the bracelets that Fastia wears find exact parallels in the bracelets worn by Seianti Thanunia and Larthia Seianti on their sarcophagi. 3 Cf. Émile Vernier, La Bijouterie et la Joaillerie Égyptiennes, Mémoires publ. par les membres de l'Institut Français d'Archéologie orient, du Caire, Vol. II, p. 81. 4 Cf. e.g. L. Pollak, Klassisch-Antike Goldschmiedearbeiten, Introd. p. v. 6 Following are some examples of this type of circlet from different periods : X I I dynasty, gold rings from Dahshur, publ. Cat. général Mus. du Caire, Vol. X L V I I I (Bijoux et orfèvreries, by Émile Vernier), pis. X X , and X X I I ; Mycenean period, gold earrings from Cyprus, publ. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. pi. III, Nos. 373-379; eleventh to ninth centuries, bronze bracelet from Cumae, publ. Mon. Ant. X X I I , col. 73, fig. 18; ca. ninth century, gold ring from Assarlik, Caria, publ. J.H.S. VIII, p. 71, fig. 13; seventh to sixth centuries, gold earring (?) from Tharros, publ. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. pi. 23, No. 1514; fourth century, many earrings from Carthage, cf. C. R. Acad. Insc. 1900, pp. 192f; ca. 300 B.C., gold earrings from Beirut, publ. L. Pollak, op. cit. pl. XI, Nos. 221, 222, 224; Hellenistic, gold bracelet from Samsun, Amasia, publ. ibid. pl. XVII, No. 404; Graeco-Roman, gold earring, publ. Cal. gén. du Mus. du Caire, Vol. XLVIII, pl. X X X I V , No. 52.552; gold bracelet (same type but much elaborated), publ. ibid. Vol. X X X V I I I , pl. XVI, No. 52.125; Augustan Age, gold bracelet from Bori, Russia, publ. Arch. Am. 1909, p. 146, fig. 7; first to second centuries after Christ, bronze bracelets from Dalmatia, publ. Jh. Oest. Arch. I . X I I , Beiblatt, p. 103, figs. 73, 74; second to third centuries after Christ, gold ring, publ. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. pl. L X I I I , No. 2828. A "pseudo safetyp i n " of bronze from the Argive Heraeum (II, pl. L X X X V I I I , No. 947), and the links used for attaching the handles to a cauldron found in the Dobrudja (Jh. Oest. Arch. I. XV, p. 123, fig. 100) and to a Faliscan bronze vase in t h e Boston Museum of Fine Arts, (No. 98.684) show how popular circlets in this form were for many different purposes. 2

A THIRD CENTURY

FIGURE

16—GOLD

ETRUSCAN

ORNAMENTS:

III. A.

NOS.

TOMB

281

13.2879-2885.

GOLD EARRINGS

1.—A pair of earrings (No. 13.2880-81) is composed of hollow tubes with the usual beadlike enlargement at one end (Fig. 16). They are 1.8 cm. in diameter. T h e " b e a d " is enclosed at each end by a tiny ribbed band of gold imitating fine spiral wires and encircled by a beaded moulding. Both the " b e a d " and the adjoining portion of the ring are ornamented with scale pattern in filigree. Inserted in a link back of the " b e a d " is a tiny beaded hoop. Except t h a t one of the rings has lost this hoop and is slightly bent, both earrings are perfectly preserved.

282

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

2.—A second pair of earrings (No. 13.2883-84) is of the pendant type, the disk of which, 8.5 mm. in diameter, has a sunken convex centre surrounded b y a very finely beaded moulding (Fig. 16). The end of the S-shaped hook at the back, after forming at the bottom of the disk a loop on which a link, probably the attachment for a pendant, is suspended, is twisted twice around the hook at the top of the disk.

The ring-shaped pair of earrings belongs to a type which developed from a Greek form 1 and is common in the graves of Etruscan women of the fourth and third centuries. Most of the Greek earrings of the ring type, as well as some of the earliest Etruscan, terminated at one end in a head of some sort. 2 This soon assumed in the hands of Etruscan jewelers the form of a bead. A chronological arrangement of the different varieties in which this type appears is not now possible.3 Filigree, a form of decoration which attained its height in Greek jewelry of the fifth to third centuries, seems to have been employed rather sparingly by later Etruscan jewelers.4 I believe with Hadaczek 6 that the fact that Etruscan gold earrings of this style regularly fail to have the unornamented end suitably finished for insertion into the ear probably indicates that they were made only for burial.6 Earrings with a hook fastened to the back of a disk from which hung pendants in various forms were much worn in Greece from the sixth century until well into the Christian era. 7 Etruscan bronze and plastic products furnish conclusive evidence that they were also widely used in Etruria, yet very few specimens are preserved. 8 The loss of the pendants leaves no definite clue to the date of our earrings. 1

Cf. Hadaczek, Der Ohrschmuck der Griechen und Etrusker, p. 64. Cf. e.g. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. pis. X X X I , XLIII, Nos. 2206-2210. 3 Cf. Hadaczek, op. cit. p. 66; Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. p. 251, remarks following Nos. 2211-2. The chronology of the Greek earrings of this type is also not clear, ibid. Introd., p. xxxiii. 4 Cf. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. Introd. pp. xxxix f., Iv. But cf. also Martha, op. cit. pp. 568, 570, and several figures on pi. I. 5 Op. cit. p. 65, note 1. 6 Cf. e.g. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. pi. XLIII, especially Nos. 2228, 2229. 7 Cf. Hadaczek, op. cit. pp. 27-45; Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. Introd. pp. xxxiiixxxvi. 8 Cf. Hadaczek, op. cit. pp. 69-73; Martha, op. cit. pi. I, Nos. 1, 5, 7, 9, 10, and p. 570. Both Larthia Seianti and Seianti Thanunia on their sarcophagi wear earrings of this sort. 2

A THIRD

CENTURY B.

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

283

RING

A tiny open ring (No. 13.2882), 1.3 cm. in diameter, is formed from a hollow tube terminating at each end in a granulated knob enclosed by a narrow moulding and a row of three granulated triangles (Fig. 16). The ring is slightly bent.

I find no analogy for this strange little ring. It is too small and too thick for the finger. If it is an earring it is much smaller than most earrings of the ring type and is unique, so far as I know, in having both ends ornamented alike. 1 Perhaps it was employed as an ornament attached to another piece of jewelry. 2 The art of granulation reached its highest degree of perfection in Etruria during the eighth and seventh centuries 3 and was employed more or less from that time on, but it seems to have been used but little on Etruscan jewelry of the fourth and third centuries. 4 On two fourth century (?) Greek earrings and on a fifth century Etruscan earring in the British Museum, Cat. Nos. 1805, 1808, 2207, granulated triangles resemble the decoration on our ring. C.

NECKLACE

A necklace (No. 13.2879) consists of two strings of glass beads held together at intervals by eleven thin gold rectangular plates stamped in squares and bent so as to form two adjacent cylinders 7 to 8 cm. in length (Fig. 16). The color of most of the beads is a dark translucent blue. A few are yellow. In front are four pendants 2.5 cm. long of very thin gold plate stamped in the form of a woman's face with a rosette above and a ribbed cone below ending at the bottom in a globule. The pendants are hollow at the back. The chain is 26 cm. long and has no clasp. All of the pendants are slightly cracked.

A necklace of the early third century from Teano 6 offers excellent parallels for our pendants, which appear to be descendants of an early Etruscan prototype. 6 The gap between the early and the late specimens is wide, but engraved Etruscan and Praenestire mirrors embracing practically the entire interval furnish evidence that necklaces and bracelets adorned with pend1 The two Roman rings in the British Museum, Cat. Jewl. Nos. 2611, 2612 are probably small finger rings instead of earrings. 2 Cf. e.g. the ring suspended on a bracelet, Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. No. 2828. 3 Cf. Karo in Studi et Materiali, Vol. II, p. 279; C. Densmore Curtis, Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome, Vol. I, pp. 63 ff. 4 Cf. Brit. Mus. Cat. Jewl. Introd. p. lv. 5 Mm. Ant. XX, cols. 41-42, fig. 23. 6 The finest examples are two necklaces from Vetulonia in the Archaeological Museum in Florence. Cf. Karo in Studi e Materiali, II, pp. 126 f.

4

284

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

ants did not go out of fashion in Etruria, 1 and there is no reason to suppose that pendants stamped with human faces, after having been once introduced, did not continue to be used alongside acorn pendants and bullae, for example, of the same technique. 2 The mirrors also indicate that until the fourth century the pendant was short in proportion to its width, like the early examples cited above. During the fourth century the narrow type like those on our necklace came into style but never seems to have supplanted the other. 3 The entire necklace appears usually to have been adorned with pendants, but the mirrors present necklaces similar to ours with pendants only across the front. 4 The pairs of gold cylinders may be compared with a set of 220 gold ornaments of the fourth to third centuries from a tomb in Todi now in the Villa Giulia.6 Exact parallels in form are offered by a third-century necklace from Italy and a late Roman (?) necklace, both in the British Museum. 6 All of these thinwalled cylinders are presumably a makeshift for some more substantial form of bead. D.

Boss

A circular boss (No. 13.2885) of very thin gold, 3.9 cm. in diameter, is stamped with a woman's face looking to the left, and ornamented on the margin, which is perforated at three points, with a row of beading outside of a delicate moulding (Fig. 16). The woman wears a sort of cap with a short flap at the side and a long one at the back, bqth turned up and partially concealed b y her flowing hair. The tip of a flap on the right side of her cap appears below her chin. The execution is careful, the style typically Etruscan, the condition perfect.

The purpose of this boss is not certain. The thin gold plaques of various shapes and sizes, which have been found in graves of all periods from the Mycenean to the Roman and were in most cases probably designed for attachment to burial robes, are usually flat. Convex specimens occur very rarely. The 1 Cf. e.g. Gerhard, op. cii. IV, pi. 292; V (Körte), 36; IV, 363.1, 421; I, 44; IV, 293; II, 233; V, 150. It is sometimes impossible to distinguish between pendants and beads, as the string is very often not indicated. 2 Cf. e.g. two necklaces of the fifth century from Corneto in the British Museum, Cat. Jewl. pi. X X I I I , No. 1458 and pi. XLV, No. 2271. 3 Cf. e.g. Gerhard, op. dt. IV, pi. 347. 4 E.g. Gerhard, op. cit. IV, pi. 319 and V, pi. 105. 6 Cf. Mon. Ant. X X I I I , col. 621, fig. 9. 6 Cat. Jewl. pi. XLVI, No. 2285 and pi. LVI, No. 2699.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

285

British M u s e u m contains t h e following convex examples of different sorts from various periods: a set of fifty-four gold plaques with convex centre (Nos. 692-693) are Mycenaean a n d four of t h e m have perforations for a t t a c h m e n t ; a Greek disk of t h e fifth t o fourth centuries (No. 2109) has three perforations a t t h e edge and a loop at the back; a late E t r u s c a n bulla (No. 2312) is composed of two flimsy convex sheets of gold, each perforated a t four points t o admit the wires t h a t held t h e m together; a gold boss of t h e R o m a n period (No. 2906) has four loops on the edge for attachment. 1 B u t the best parallel for our boss is offered b y a set of t w e n t y ornaments from t h e sarcophagus in Todi which produced t h e gold cylinders mentioned above. Weege believes these t o be b u t t o n covers. Bendinelli argues t h a t t h e y decorated a leather belt or head-dress. 2 I n view of all these examples our boss might be regarded as the t o p of a bulla, of a brooch, or of a b u t t o n from which t h e back was separated and lost, or even as an ornament for a t t a c h m e n t to leather. B u t I consider it far more probable t h a t , whatever sort of ornament of daily use it was supposed to represent, it was designed to be simply sewed a t t h e points of perforation t o a burial robe. Among a number of flat, gold disks published in Ant. Bosph. Cim. pi. X X I , most of which are from the mound of Koul-Oba near Kertsch, Nos. 3 - 7 presenting women's faces in profile are of a t y p e analogous t o ours. B u t our head is much finer and freer in execution t h a n a n y of these. I t excels t h e m all in vigor and freedom of style as far as it is itself excelled in fineness and delicacy b y t h e characteristically Greek face on a similar fourth century disk from Turgan, published in Compte-Rendu, 1877, pi. I, no. 2, p. 7. Excepting the crown, t h e cap worn b y the woman on our boss resembles t h e Phrygian cap. T h e crown is typical of the headdress of m a n y figures on Etruscan mirrors, where it is sometimes t h e crown of a cap, b u t oftener t h e hair itself. All of t h e gold objects, therefore, although of little intrinsic value, are interesting as representing either unusual types, or 1

A Mycenean stud with traces of bronze lining (No. 614), an Early Italian, button (No. 1440) with two rings at the back for attachment, a Greek brooch (No. 2062) of the fourth to third centuries, originally with loop and pin at the back, and a third century Greek boss (No. 2110) are also convex, but without marginal perforations. The two latter at least are sufficiently heavy to haveserved a practical purpose. 2 Cf. Weege in Helbig, Fuhrer3, II, p. 329. Bendinelli, Mori. Ant. X X I I I , cols. 619 {., fig. 7.

286

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

types that had passed the time of their highest development. The tiny ring, as has been seen, appears to be without analogy; the boss is most uncommon; the pair of earrings of the pendant type is one of a very small number of preserved specimens; the cylinder-shaped beads in the necklace are unusual, and the only recorded parallel to the pendants is in a necklace that is not later than the early third century; finally, both filigree and granulated work were probably difficult to procure by the end of the third century. To be sure, it is not impossible that the jewelry is of considerably earlier date than the tomb, but it is not at all probable that such flimsy objects were kept long either in a shop or in a home. They seem rather to be, like most of our vases, exceptionally good illustrations of the decadence of Etruscan art during the third century. IV.

IVORY

1.—Four dice (Nos. 13.2896-9), very well preserved, measure approximately 1 cm. each way (Fig. 17). They are marked by circles with a dot in the centre, except the ace, which has two concentric circles with a dot. The sum of the spots on opposite faces is seven.

The dice represent a common type that has never gone out of use from early antiquity to the present day.1 A die in the form of a parallelopiped was also used in antiquity and appears to have been especially popular in Etruria. The ancients seem generally to have employed the system of marking that prevails at present, which makes the sum of the spots on opposite faces equal to seven,2 but on many Etruscan dice the consecutive numbers are opposed, that is, one is opposite two, etc.3 This seems to be the regular method for parallelopipeds.4 The spots are generally enclosed in a circle or concentric circles. The material is usually bone or ivory.5 The striking prevalence of dice in Etruscan tombs is presumably due rather to their significance as a symbol of the un1 One Greek tradition attributes the invention of the game of dice to Palamedes, another traces it from Egypt or the East. Cf. Daremb. et Sagl., s.v. 'Tessera,' p. 125 and references. 2 Cf. Daremb. et Sagl., p. 126. 3 Only one die is on record that is not marked in one of these two ways. Cf. Skutsch in Pauly-Wissowa, s.v. 'Etrusker,' col. 801. 4 Zannoni, Scavi della Certosa di Bologna, pis. X X X I V , figs. 7-9; X X X X I V , 5; L, 7; L X I I I , 13; CVI, 3, 4. 6 Cf. Dareirb. et Sagl., I. c.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

287

certainty of life than to their popularity as a game. This symbolism would appeal strongly to the Etruscan mind, whereas the monuments which the Etruscans have left, to us in the largest numbers, the engraved bronze mirrors, do not bear evidence that the game formed a prominent feature of their daily life. I know of but one mirror t h a t represents persons at dice.1 On the board here depicted lie two dice, the number legularly used, and apparently two are as a rule found together. Zannoni records

FIGURE

17.—IVORY

DICE,

STICKS, AND

SPOON.

one group of two parallelopipeds and one cubical die,2 but I find no reference to any other tomb containing two pairs as ours does. 2.—Six ivory sticks decorated, with one exception, by horizontal mouldings or incised patterns or both. Apparently all had holes at the top (Fig. 17). The best preserved example (No. 13.2894) is 19.8 cm. long and still retains a high polish on much of its surface. A ring at the top ends on one side in a small, quaintly moulded duck's head attached to the stick between the upturned tips of two delicate, heart-shaped leaves; the other side is lost. A second stick (No. 13.2892) also has much of its surface well preserved but both ends are gone. 1 Cf. Gerhard, op. tit. V (Ivorte), No. 109. life are not frequent on mirrors. 2 Cf. op. cit. pi. CVI, figs. 2-4.

To be sure, scenes from daily

288

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

Three other specimens similar to the last are badly mutilated. A sixth stick undecorated and heavier than the others, is 14.3 cm. long, 8 m m . thick, and has a large, flattened, oval head with a perforation in the centre. A shallow longitudinal groove marks the stick on one side. The tip is gone.

Numerous scenes on Etruscan engraved mirrors make it clear t h a t our ivory sticks belong to a class of articles without which no Etruscan woman's toilet set was complete. They are seen oftenest in the hands of women who are also provided with an alabastron, so we m a y safely infer t h a t they were designed to be dipped into the contents of the vase. In fact the inference is verified by the mirror, Gerhard, op. cit. IV, pi. 282, which shows a woman holding her stick inserted in an alabastron. Again to judge from the evidence of mirrors, these sticks appear to have been used principally in dressing the hair. 1 On the mirror reproduced above (Fig. 12) the crouching figure admiring her fresh coiffure still holds her stick in her hand. The ointment vase is suspended. These sticks were doubtless used not only to apply pomade to the hair, but at the same time to separate and arrange the locks, to form the wonderful rolls or puffs, for example, of which the Etruscans were so fond. 2 Since so many mirror scenes which have nothing to do with the toilet represent women provided with a stick and an alabastron, it looks very much as though the coiffure of Etruscan ladies was rather an unstable, temporary affair, to repair which at any time or place was in complete accordance with society etiquette. 3 1 Cf. for example, Gerhard, op. cit. I, pi. 213; IV, 3181, V, 102, and the cista referred to in Bull. Inst. 1865, p. 56, all representing this manner of employment. The mirror, V, 22, shows a hair-dressing scene in which one of the attendants, with a stick in one hand and an alabastron in the other, is awaiting her turn. 2 This use gave these sticks the name discerniculum or acus discriminalis among the Romans (Daremb. et Sagl., s.v. 'Acus' p. 63 and references in note 32). Roman women apparently extended this use of the discerniculum.. Cf. Juvenal, Sat. II, vss. 93-95. Possibly the stick is employed on the mirror, Gerhard, IV, pi. 319, to apply unguent to Venus' face, but more probably it has just been used on her hair. 3 A most interesting scene in this regard occurs on a late South Italian vase published in Conestabile, Pitture Murali a Fresco e Suppellettili Etr. scop, presso Orvieto, p. 161, on which an Eros with alabastron and stick is busy "touching u p " the hair of a maenad while Bacchus caresses her on his knee. Equally interesting is the mirror, Gerhard, op. cit. I, 82, where a winged goddess with stick and alabastron arranges Zeus' hair in a scene representing the birth of Bacchus. Apparently vanity was not confined to women in those days.

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

289

The hole through- the top of our sticks is doubtless for the insertion of a string. Nothing of the kind appears in the illustrations above noted, but the same is true of the alabastra, which we know were regularly suspended, and it is most unlikely that such apparently indispensable objects could not be hung on the wrist. I find no published specimens with which our nicely carved sticks can be compared. 1 If they are common in collections, no one seems to have considered them worthy of special notice. 3.—A spoon (No. 13.2895) with a heart-shaped bowl has its rectangular handle decorated at the top and bottom by horizontal mouldings, and in the middle by alternating rows of large and small horn-like projections (Fig. 17). It is 13.7 cm. long. The handle is repaired in two places, the tip is missing, and the bowl is reattached.

Spoons substantially like ours of today have been in common use since early antiquity, 2 and their purpose has naturally never varied much. I consider it highly probable that our spoon belonged among the toilet articles designed for mixing liquids or paints, although no ancient author appears to have mentioned this use of the spoon.3 As today, so in antiquity, spoons were made of all sorts of material. Ivory spoons were not rare in Egypt, but. in the Greek and Roman periods bronze and silver seem to have predominated. 4 I find only one Etruscan spoon published, a carved bone specimen from Vulci.6 4.—A group of flat ivory fragments (Fig. 18) consists of the following pieces: fourteen very narrow strips, seven being intact with both ends mitred; fifteen wider strips marked by two longitudinal grooves and presenting two perforations, among which three short pieces are mitred at both ends and several fragments at one end; six fragmentary strips a trifle heavier, with grooves equidistant from the edges; ten strips of varying widths incised with longitudinal and cross lines in which much black paint still remains, for the most part carelessly scratched on the reverse side in hatched or cross-hatched pattern and presenting two perforations with stains of oxidization around one of them; twelve undecorated pieces which constituted rectangular portions, three of which are almost entire; fragments of two thin, undecorated "X-shaped" pieces scratched on the reverse surface with cross-hatching; two disks with central portion raised and perforated by holes into which fit two pegs with coni1

The unornamented stick probably served some other purpose. Cf. C. J. Jackson, 'The Spoon and Its History,' Archaeologia, LIII, pp. 107 ff. s Cf. Not. Scav. XIII, p. 25. 4 Cf. Jackson, op. cit. p. 110. 5 Cf. Jackson, op. cit. p. I l l , fig. 19. 2

290

L. G.

FIGURE

ELDRIDGE

1 8 . — I V O R Y F R A G M E N T S PROM B O X E S .

cal heads indented at the top; a tiny disk in two parts with remains of an iron peg in the central perforation and traces of oxidization on one surface; a fragment of a disk with a considerable portion of an iron peg, including the much oxidized head. Parts of two other small disks also remain.

These fragments presumably constituted the remains of one or more boxes. The pieces are for the most part so thin that they were doubtless provided with a lining of wood to which they were attached by means of glue and pegs. The narrowest strips, of

A THIRD

CENTURY

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

291

which there were probably twelve, might have formed the border for the cover and the upper and lower edges of a square box. The pattern on the widest strips is presumably an imitation of masonry. Perhaps the "X-shaped" fragments were parts of the top of a box with circular openings for separate compartments. 1 The presence of stains on the smallest disks and around the perforation in the widest strip suggests that these disks were attached to the box by iron pegs that held the ivory coating to the lining.

FIGURE

19.—ITORY

MIRROR-HANDLE

AND

CYLINDERS.

The scratched hatching on the reverse side of a number of the pieces was presumably designed to afford a more adhesive surface for the glue. 5.—A hollow mirror handle (No. 13.2901), 9.5 cm. long and 4 cm. in diameter, is encircled by five mouldings (Fig. 19). A large piece is reattached. A small portion is missing and the entire edge at one end slightly damaged. This handle presumably belonged to one of the bronze mirrors which t h e tomb contained. 2 1

Cf. e.g. a cista from Civita Castellana, Cat. Bronzes in Brit. Mus. p. 105, fig. 16. 2 The same sort of handle appears sometimes to have been used on the large Etruscan fans. Cf. Mon. Ant. X X I I I , col. 632, note 2.

292

L. G.

ELDRIDGE

6.—Each member of a series of hollow cylinders (Fig. 19), ranging from 5.1 to 3.2 cm. in length, has its wall on one side perforated in two places, and all but two are encircled near one end by a group of three incised lines, in many of which traces of black paint remain. Two cylinders of the largest size are practically intact, four, somewhat smaller, are injured, and fragments of at least four others remain. Two, 3.1 cm. long and well preserved, have only one lateral perforation. Three, smaller and solid, are provided with terminal mortise and tenon so that they fit together into a symmetrical whole with three lateral mortise-holes sunk over half-way through, three incised rings between each pair of holes, and smoothly polished ends. The entire length is 5.2 cm. One fragment, about 1.2 cm. in diameter and encircled by five incised lines, is split open, revealing an oxidized iron peg running through it longitudinally. A small lateral perforation on each side of the break indicates a repair in antiquity. The remaining objects of this group may be defined as sections of hollow cylinders like those above described, ranging from 2.2 to 1.5 cm. in diameter. Each has one lateral perforation. The largest specimens, of which seven either entire or fragmentary remain, are 1 cm. high, three are 1.3 cm., and the remaining, ten entire and at least fourteen in fragments, are 7 to 8 mm. high.

The purpose of these objects is by no means clear. A few ivory cylinders with mortise-holes, and some hollow like ours, were found in Ephesus. The latter Hogarth calls "joint-pieces." 1 But our cylinders are much more numerous and more homogeneous. It is barely possible t h a t they formed a pair of pipes from which the mouth-pieces, perhaps of wood, have disappeared. The combined length of the existing fragments approximates 85 cm., a measurement which would correspond very well to two ordinary pipes. 2 But there are a great many more holes than could possibly be employed in actual flutes.3 However, the argument could readily be offered t h a t the pipes, like so many other objects in the tomb, were made only for burial. The composition in segments may be in imitation of the bands that were used for closing the holes on flutes in the later stages of their development. 4 As another mere possibility it may be worth while to suggest a necklace, in which case the lateral perforations on the cylinders would presumably have served for the attachment of pendants 1 Cf. British Museum Excavations at Ephesus, pi. X X X I X , Nos. 11, 12, 14, 15; pi. XLI, Nos. 2, 3, 5-15, 17; p. 197. Two bone cylinders similar to two of our types were found in Corneto (Mon. Ined. X, pi. X, d, figs. 20, 20a) but Helbig makes no suggestion as to their use. 2 Cf. Harvard Studies, IV, p. 41; J.H.S. X X X I V , p. 91. 3 Cf. Harv. St. IV, pp. 5 f.; J.H.S. X X X I V , pp. 93 if. 4 Cf. Harv. St. IV, pp. 7 f.; J.H.S. X X X I V , pp. 102 f.

A THIRD

CENTURY.

ETRUSCAN

TOMB

293

or for the insertion of ornaments. Neither the length nor the weight of a necklace thus composed would constitute ground for suspicion, as Etruscan momuments abundantly testify, but I know of no representation of a necklace of such a type. A third possibility, suggested by Miss Richter, is-that they formed part of an ivory staff with a wooden core, to which the cylinders were fastened through the holes. No such staves seem to have been identified among the contents of Etruscan tombs, but there is nothing inherently improbable in their existence. V.

GLASS

1.—A badly damaged alabastron of "Phoenician" glass (No. 13.2900), 6 cm. in length, is decorated with white and yellow on an azure background (Fig. 8, c). Lines encircle the neck, and the upper half of the body is covered with loop pattern.

The vase represents a well known type which, originating in Egypt as an imitation of vases made for daily use of alabaster or clay, spread over the entire ancient world and finally became a great favorite as a burial gift. 1 2.—Twenty hemispherical objects of glass vary from 10 to 12.5 mm. in diameter. One is the color of amethyst and translucent, four are colorless and transparent, four solid black, five sea-green and transparent, six indigo blue and transparent. All have patches of iridescent patina. None bear any trace of paste or glue.2 One is broken.

These objects, which are found in all parts of the ancient world, were doubtless used in some capacity, probably as counters, in some game played with dice. I find no definite record of their occurrence in a tomb where there were no dice, 3 nor, on the other hand, do I know of any certain instance of dice being found without either these tiny hemispheres or similar objects of irregular form. 4 They seem to occur in all quantities, but they are so easily lost t h a t an entire set is doubtless rarely preserved. 6 The material is usually glass or paste. 1

Cf. Kisa, Das Glas irn Altertume, II, pp. 401 ff. Cf. Eisen in A.J.A. XVI, p. 303. 3 Cf. e.g. Zannoni, op. cit. pis. X X X I V , figs. 11, 7; L, 26-7, 28-30, 7; CVI, 5-7, 2-4, p. 372; pi. CXIV, 7. Not. Scav. 1899, p. 163, figs. 13a, 13. Mori. Ant. IX, pi. XI, 5, 4. A statement made by Kisa (op. cit. I, p. 142) seems to imply, however, that this rule is not invariable. He calls them Spielsteirte. 4 Cf. e.g. Zannoni, op. cit. pis. X I I I , figs. 9-10, 19-40; X X X X I V , 5, p. 174; LI, 14-15, 7-13, p. 225; L X I I I , 13, 14-17, p. 247; CXXXVI, 5; p. 397. Rom. Mitt., I, p. 221. 6 The tombs cited above contained from one to twenty-four. 2

294

L. G. VI.

ELDRIDGE BRONZE

1.—Six bronze mirrors, all badly corroded and most of them broken, rangefrom 18 to 7 cm. in diameter. Only three preserve traces of engraving. On t h e largest a scene with four figures, of which only one, an old man at the left partially draped and leaning on a staff, is clearly distinguishable, may be compared in style and composition with Gerhard, op. cit. IV, pi. 374. Two mirrors present a winged Lasa, one nearly effaced, the other in the very common third century form represented by the mirrors in Gerhard, op. cit. pis. 31 ff. A quantity of fragments of bronze plate are presumably the remains of other mirrors. 2.—Six bronze nails, more or less bent and broken, have round, convex heads 1.6 cm. in diameter. 3.—Several pieces of bent bronze wire, four of them 15 to 20 cm. long, are possibly, as suggested by Mr. Caskey, the remains of a wreath, although no leaves are preserved. VII.

LEAD

A number of lead fragments seem to be parts of a vase with a small, flaring mouth. A small lead vase was found in the same tomb with the bronze, cauldron-shaped vase from Perugia mentioned above. Cf. Not. Scav. 1900, pp. 556 ff., fig. 7. L. CAMBRINGE,

MASS.

September, 1917.

G.

ELDRIDGE.