Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why.

Citation preview

10/31/2020

Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why | US unions | The Guardian

Sign in Support us

News Opinion Sport Culture Lifestyle The Guardian view Columnists Letters Opinion videos Cartoons Opinion This article is more than 2 years old

Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why Tithi Bhattacharya The spreading teachers strikes are for wages and benefits but they arise from a social landscape scoured by gender and racial inequalities Tue 10 Apr 2018 10.53 EDT

800 166

Close

California residents have certain rights with regard to the sale of personal information to third parties. Guardian News and Media and our partners use information collected through cookies or in other forms to improve experience on our site and pages, analyze how it is used and show personalized advertising. At any point, you can opt out of the sale of all of your personal information by pressing Do not sell my personal information You can find out more in our privacy policy and cookie policy, and manage your choices by going to ‘California resident – Do Not Sell’ at the bottom of any page. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/10/women-teachers-strikes-america

1/5

T

10/31/2020

Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why | US unions | The Guardian

he US is in the grip of a wave of strikes in our public schools. As a national organizer for the International Women’s Strike, which took place on 8 March let me also add: “at last”!

The mainstream US media have been generally supportive of the strikes. They have highlighted how decades of neoliberal cuts to public education have kindled these flames. They have talked about how stagnant salaries mean teachers are unable to keep pace with the rising cost of healthcare. What they have not talked about is this: the strike action is led almost exclusively by women. I have spent many hours talking with striking teachers, chanting with them in their statehouses. This movement has to be recognized as a feminist project, and all feminists need to stand with the teachers. Here’s why: 1. 77% of all public school teachers in the US are women. In some states the percentage is over 80% 2. The prevalence of women in this sector is undergirded by a more complex issue. Teaching is seen as “women’s work”. While the majority of teachers used to be male in the colonial period, the feminization of the sector began around 1900. Indeed, some scholars believe that feminization took place because schools were reluctant to pay the former high wages that male teachers received as the school term got longer with the spread of public education. Other scholars have demonstrated how the preponderance of women “has contributed to pressure to strengthen bureaucratic controls over teacher behaviour and to ‘deskill’ the profession”. Funny how vicious this circle is. Teaching is seen as women’s work and hence teachers are paid badly. Because the vast majority of teachers are women, a formerly male profession suddenly becomes women’s work. 3. Since it is labelled women’s work, teaching then also gets classified as ”care work”. My friend, the economist Nancy Folbre, has done several extensive studies on the devaluation of care work, and she lists teachers, nurses, and childcare workers as the most prominent examples of this devaluation. 4. Women, whether in paid employment or not, do the majority of the actual caregiving at home and in the community. This is reflected in how teachers are conceiving the strikes. A common theme among the strikers is that they are striking for their students. When asked why they were asking for a 20% pay raise, Rebecca Garelli an Arizona teacher framed it beautifully: “our working conditions are Close our student’s learning conditions”. California residents have certain rights with regard to the sale of personal toare thirdhappening in the But for these teachers, “care” extends beyond the classroom. Most of information the strikes parties. Guardian News and Media and our partners use information collected through cookies or in poorest parts of the country. Many students in these teachers’ classrooms get their only hot meal of other forms to improve experience on our site and pages, analyze how it is used and show personalized the day in school. In all strike locations, teachers have organized for their students to have hot advertising. lunches. At any point, you can opt out of the sale of all of your personal information by pressing

Do not sell my the personal information Jackie, a teacher from successful West Virginia strike, who came from a small town in Blacksville, told me You thatcan throughout the theypolicy keptand their citypolicy, hall open whereyour thechoices children cametoin to be fed. find out more in strike our privacy cookie and manage by going resident – Do Not Sell’ at bottom hot of any page.and take them to people’s houses. Teachers‘California are working with churches tothe prepare meals https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/10/women-teachers-strikes-america

2/5

10/31/2020

Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why | US unions | The Guardian

This is why parents and students have all come out in support of the striking teachers. Olivia Morris one of the strike leaders in Charleston, West Virginia, told me how overwhelmed she was by the support from parents, who told her, “Don’t give up now. You are fighting the good fight for our kids, do not give up.’” That made Olivia want to keep fighting, “because if we didn’t have that, the nitpicking that the legislators [did] here on a daily basis … [would] break you down.” 5. Since women are the caregivers at home, all attacks on healthcare and childcare are women’s issues. We know that Oklahoma, a state where the teachers are still on strike, has, over the years, cut funding for mental health and done away with earned tax credits for the poorest families. It now ranks, along with West Virginia and Montana as leading the country in adverse childhood experiences. In Kentucky, the bill that sparked the strike proposes to cut, along with teacher’s pensions, prekindergarten funding and money for family resources centers. For West Virginia, what set off the strike were the extraordinary changes to the teachers’ health insurance plans: the deductibles had increased 500% with no increase in teachers’ wages. The teachers also had to wear Fitbits and enter data about every bodily measurement and function, including sexual activity. Their premiums were to be decided on how well they did on such metrics. 6. Let us remember that teachers are not just women workers. They carry their gender home even after the last bell. The politicians in the states where the strikes are taking place, have, over the years, shown their deep commitment to generalized misogyny: Oklahoma has the highest rate of female incarceration. Arizona is ranked first for its anti-abortion laws by the leading anti-abortion group Americans United for Life. Kentucky now only has one abortion clinic left to serve the entire state. In West Virginia, the same legislators whose laws led to the strike, are considering a bill to take out the right to abortion from the state’s constitution. Rebecca in Arizona is not just a strike leader, she is the mother of three children under four. Carol Roskos in West Virginia is worried about children who live in abusive homes, but the state has cut funding needed to find alternatives for them. A substitute teacher in Kentucky wrote in a secret Facebook group “I just sit here and think of a 15-month-old baby girl in my family and I am petrified about her future.”

Close

These strikes are for wages and benefits, but they arise from a social landscape scoured by gender and California residents have certain rights with regard to the sale of personal information to only third by conditions of racial inequalities. The leaders of the strikes are thus not simply workers shaped parties. Guardian News and Media and our partners use information collected through cookies or in work: gender marks them. other forms to improve experience on our site and pages, analyze how it is used and show personalized advertising.

These are women fighting for dignity and security in the most commodious sense of those terms. At any point, you can opt out of the sale of all of your personal information by pressing Their gender is not incidental to this strike, their narratives of fear about their families and health, are Do not to sellwhat my personal information not backstories is merely a wage struggle. You can find out more in our privacy policy and cookie policy, and manage your choices by going to resident – Do Not Sell’ at the as bottom of any page. It is time‘California to consider these “backstories” central and constitutive of the strike wave. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/10/women-teachers-strikes-america

3/5

10/31/2020

Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why | US unions | The Guardian

Tithi Bhattacharya is a professor of history at Purdue University and a national organizer for the US International Women’s Strike.

News is under threat … … just when we need it the most. Millions of readers around the world are flocking to the Guardian in search of honest, authoritative, fact-based reporting that can help them understand the biggest challenge we have faced in our lifetime. But at this crucial moment, news organisations are facing a cruel financial double blow: with fewer people able to leave their homes, and fewer news vendors in operation, we’re seeing a reduction in newspaper sales across the UK. Advertising revenue continues to fall steeply meanwhile as businesses feel the pinch. We need you to help fill the gap. We believe every one of us deserves equal access to vital public service journalism. So, unlike many others, we made a different choice: to keep Guardian journalism open for all, regardless of where they live or what they can afford to pay. This would not be possible without financial contributions from those who can afford to pay, who now support our work from 180 countries around the world. Reader financial support has meant we can keep investigating, disentangling and interrogating. It has protected our independence, which has never been so critical. We are so grateful. We need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent. And that is here for the long term. Every reader contribution, however big or small, is so valuable. Support The Guardian from as little as $1 – and it only takes a minute. Thank you. Support The Guardian

Remind me in December

Topics

US unions Opinion West Virginia / Kentucky / comment

comments 166 Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion.

Most popular

Close

California residents have certain rights with regard to the sale of personal information to third

The Guardian view Columnists Opinion videosuseCartoons parties. Guardian News andLetters Media and our partners information collected through cookies or in other forms to improve experience on our site and pages, analyze how it is used and show personalized advertising.

News Opinion Sport Culture Lifestyle

At any point, you can opt out of the sale of all of your personal information by pressing Do not sell my personal information You can find out more in our privacy policy and cookie policy, and manage your choices by going to ‘California resident – Do Not Sell’ at the bottom of any page.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/10/women-teachers-strikes-america

4/5

10/31/2020

Women are leading the wave of strikes in America. Here's why | US unions | The Guardian

Sign up for the Guardian Today email All the day's headlines and highlights from the Guardian, direct to you every morning

Email address

Sign up

About us

All topics

Contact us

All writers

Complaints & corrections

Digital newspaper archive

SecureDrop

Facebook

Work for us

Twitter

California resident – Do Not Sell

Newsletters

Privacy policy Cookie policy Terms & conditions Help Advertise with us Guardian Labs Search jobs Back to top © 2020 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. (modern)

Close

California residents have certain rights with regard to the sale of personal information to third parties. Guardian News and Media and our partners use information collected through cookies or in other forms to improve experience on our site and pages, analyze how it is used and show personalized advertising. At any point, you can opt out of the sale of all of your personal information by pressing Do not sell my personal information You can find out more in our privacy policy and cookie policy, and manage your choices by going to ‘California resident – Do Not Sell’ at the bottom of any page. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/10/women-teachers-strikes-america

5/5