202 36 1MB
English Pages 224 [232] Year 2002
Politics and the American Press The Rise of Objectivity, 1865±1920
Politics and the American Press takes a fresh look at the origins of modern journalism's ideals and political practices. In particular, Richard Kaplan addresses the professional ethic of political independence and objectivity widely adopted by the US press. He shows how this philosophy emerged from a strikingly different ethic of avid formal partisanship in the early twentieth century. The book also provides fresh insights into the economics of journalism and uses business papers and personal letters of publishers to explore the in¯uence of competition, advertising, and an explosion in readership on the market strategies of the press. Kaplan documents the changes in political content of the press by a systematic content analysis of newspaper news and editorials over a span of 55 years. The book concludes by exploring the question of what should be the appropriate political role and professional ethics of journalists in a modern democracy. r i c h a r d k a p l a n is Lecturer in the Sociology Department at the University of California, Santa Barbara. His work on media history has received the Catherine Covert Prize for best published article in Mass Communications History (1996). He has published in Journalism History; Media, Culture, and Society; and American Journalism.
Politics and the American Press The Rise of Objectivity, 1865±1920 Richard L. Kaplan
published by the press syndicate of the university of cambridge The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom cambridge university press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK 40 West 20th Street, New York NY 10011±4211, USA 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia Ruiz de AlarcoÂn 13, 28014 Madrid, Spain Dock House, The Waterfront, Cape Town 8001, South Africa http://www.cambridge.org # Richard L. Kaplan 2002 This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 2002 Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge Typeface Plantin 10/12 pt System 3b2 [ce] A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data Kaplan, Richard L. (Richard Lee), 1955± Politics and the American Press: the rise of objectivity, 1865±1920 / Richard L. Kaplan. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0 521 62151 8 (hb.) ISBN 0 521 00602 3 (pb.) 1. Press and politics ± United States ± History ± 19th century. 2. Press and politics ± United States ± History ± 20th century. 3. Journalism ± Objectivity ± United States ± History ± 19th century. 4. Journalism ± Objectivity ± United States ± History ± 20th century. I. Title. PN4888.P6 K37 2001 071'.3'09034 ± dc21 2001025240 CIP isbn 0 521 62151 8 hardback isbn 0 521 00602 3 paperback
For my mother and father
Contents
Acknowledgments
page viii
Introduction
1
1 Partisan news in the early Reconstruction Era: AfricanAmericans in the vortex of political publicity
22
2 Economic engines of partisanship
55
3 Rituals of partisanship: American journalism in the Gilded Age
72
4 The two revolutions in urban newspaper economics, 1873 and 1888
104
5 1896 and the political revolution in Detroit journalism
140
Conclusion
184
Methodological appendix References Index
200 204 221
vii
Acknowledgments
Debts, debts, debts. In writing this book, I have accumulated a heavy burden of debts. To the following people I am deeply grateful for their advice and support. I am beholden to Michael Rogin whose lectures and writings inspired my explorations into American cultural history. To Ann Swidler I owe a special debt of gratitude for her impressive care and guidance as I began this project. She kibitzed and quibbled over many a detail, all the while recalling me to the larger issues at stake in this study. And I thank Kim Voss for her persistent concern with the nuts and bolts of sociology ± the logic of argument and the methodology of research ± and her always friendly smile. I am obliged to the following sagacious media scholars for having read and commented on various parts of this book: Thomas Leonard, James W. Carey, Jon Cruz, and Michael Schudson. Colleagues and friends at the University of California, Berkeley spread their own version of moist, enriching fertilizer over this volume. Thanks particularly to Orville Lee, Lyn Spillman, Paul Lichterman, Arlene Stein, and Nina Eliasoph. Finally let me express my appreciation to Simonetta Falasca Zamponi ± wife, cook, general caretaker, or should I rather say colleague, taskmaster, critic? Without her love and assistance doubtless this book would still be sitting on the desk a confused pile of notes and computer disks. To my parents, Netta and Marvin Kaplan, I am permanently indebted for their special combination of caring hearts and critical minds. This book is dedicated to them.
viii
Free Press
en masse ! " #
$ % !
&' ( )
*
+ , + $ $ $
'
# # $
$ - " . # $ /
% # $ Free Press " $ % ! ' Free Press0 # . $
, ! #
% 1 $ / # . $ % *
" $ / $
1
0
$ - . + 1 0 $
2
' %
# 1 " 0 . $ 1 # % $ 3 0 0
## $ " 1 # # $
# 1 %
"
4 $ - 55! 00 # . 1 $ - 1 #
$ % " #
$ % $ 1
# # $ #
$ #
# $
# . #
1 # $ ' 1 # . $ " . % 627$ # !!# 1
$ 8 " % * # 9 : 9 %
; ; 9 % ! . " 1 0 $ ) 55 $00 ) % 0
. * ; # " ; # $2 0 # ! $ ?
. 0 # # . $ @ $
* $ @ , # # 0
$ # # 0 $
$ % 55 00 ! # 55 00 1 $< # $ # 0 # $ * 0 # * # # $ " # # 1 # $ > , + * $
A
' %
1 "
. $A B " * " $ 3 # . # $ @ " ; ' ; # ! $ 1 #
1 !
. $ # % $ 4 # $ " $ " #
# 55
00 # $ + ; ! # # 1 0 ! $ The democratic public sphere and the press + # # $ : 55 009 55% 00 /$ /$ 55 # + $00 )
+ ! $ 55 % 00 . #
$ + 55 00 " ## # 1
$C # 1 " !
# $ - $ 4 # # $ *
, # $ - a priori !. #
# "
$ # $ 55 $00 3D 8 Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere .
55 # # # # $00 : 8 #
$ ! # ! #
$ . $ #
$ >
# + $ > ' 0 "
1 + Veritas non auctoritas facit legem ; " $ )
#
1 +
$ 4 0 # #
$ ; ; * $
$ # # # # " * # $6 . $7
1
# # $ % % . , #
$ :
. . # $
' %
* # $ @ 8 # $ B
/ 1 # 0 $2 )
8 #
, # * 0
0 $ @ ; ; @ %
# ! 1 55
00 "
! 1
$<
. ! " * 0 .
0 , $A Social histories of the American press 1 0 $ # # 0 !
#
$
* , $ 0 ,
$ ! 1
0 # #$ " # $ # # . # # $ 8 $ > " , # # * * $ # # $
C
# ! 55
00 # 55 00 $ # $ $ )
% $ % # # # $ ) ! +
,
1 # $ Progressive historiography /# $ $
' # 1 #
## , 1 # $ ) 677
+ #
55 E F $00C
$ $ G 55 00
0
# $ " . # ; ;
1 $ % . # 1 $
#
. E
F E F$ 0 #
; .
! 1
* $ # 1 # % $6 ' # ?
' %
55 $00 # # *
! $27 ' #
#
$ 3 0 # ; #
; , $ Baldasty's economic history of the news H )0 # # # ' # 0 % 1 $ G The Commercialization of the News in the Nineteenth Century $ # ) . # $ 8
1 # $ # # + ! $ 4 !
H % # !
# $ )
1 55 * $00 8
# # $ @ )
$ # # # # $ ) 77
55 ! 00 $2 )0
551 # 00 $ % * *
* $22 ) $ 8 #
* " 1 $ ) # ' # )
6
$ > E
F $ 2< 8 $ %
! ! * $ $ $ &:( #
" E ! F $
!
# ! $ ) +
$2A
) , * + 1 $ 8 55 00 $ 8
"
1. 1 $ % 2 " . $ % ! . # $
" . #
* $ ! # +
1 $ : ! . * 0 # !
+ 1
$ ' #
" " $ ' 1 # $ 0 # $ % !
= ! 1 0 # $ 0 E F$ 1
# ! * $ Depending . " 0
# # $2 . )0 ! 1 0 * !
%
7
' %
1
$ . 0 E # F # " $ )0 #
, H % $ Schudson's Consensus history ? 0 Discovering the News % # #
$ % ' # 0 0 # 1 ! . * # %
A ! 1 # % $ B " # 0
, $ 4 # # !
$ !
1 $ > # !
0 $ 55
00 6 , #
$ # 1 # $ #
' # /$ " 1 0
$ 8 1 # #
9 8 ,
1 # " 9
! 0 " , 9 8 "0 ; 1 * 0 $ 0 0 # 1 #
! $
' %
notes >$ H
62$ 2 8 ? # 6A $ < >$ 6 AA;$ A 1 55 00 E6C 6F$ " " $ % 55 00 #
$ @ # " $ > + " $ # 55 00 55 00 " #
$ >$ ) 662 2;C= 6C2$ : 1 )
, " $
)
6$
A$ 6C 2$ C J 6$ 8 6CA A6= 66$ @ 8 0
8 6$ 6
) 6C $ A= 8 66 ;$ - 66$ ? 55 00 # 6$ % ; !
; ,
# $ 0 $ 4 6C $ 2= ? 66= I* 66= : * 62$ # # # # $ ? H 6$ ? > " E6 55 8 00F$ 8 *
55 " 00 E$ 2F$ 8
$ ) 6C 6C$ ) . ! $
#
I 62 3 66 ) 62 $ = 4 : " : " 6 H
* E
)" 6 " E> 66 $ 2F$ ? H 6 6 A C;$ '
1 # $ * ## $ # #
$ @ L 55 # 00 55 00
AA A A AC
A A6 7
2
E66CF$ %
) 62$ : * 62$ >$ ! 55 00 ' 6C$ ? H .
E $ ? > " 6 ;6F$ $ $ 6;$ 55 00 0 1 # $ 4 E # " F $ 4 8 0 1 + # E
*" 6 ;CF$ >$ '* " 6 ) 6A ;A$ >$ ) 66= 6A $ 6= 6$ % 4 J 4 # C2 " $ J # E + F =
A@ # 4 " $ $ ) & % ) " 4 $
" % 8 $ & '
> " ) " & 2 % $ # 7 * " 7 # # " 7 " # 3 $ 0 # 7 $ $
# $ $ # 4 $
& ' / / " & ' . " / & '
" & & & '
A@
3
! * $ $ * " & & &
' 8 $ $ $ * $ & ' 8 +M # & #=!1' 1 .B9-'= ' # " " " & * $ " $ 8 $
& $ % # " - ' $
% & C $ 66# 44 $ # - 1 1 & & & = # . $ & # - 5 ( & ' " ' C *& ' $ $ $ $ & 2 ( " & " D ( " E & .= =(=-' ( 'C - !''=& # ' =N9B' (BI (# 2 'C 'C= 9'!-' 1(? #=(1=& # *$ " & ' & ' % & ' & J & 3 " $ & ' & # " " " " $ & 1 $ % & & & C " $ & =8 $ $ " & H F & ' 1 ,
' ! ' $ + * $ $ $ D E & & & D' E / $ $ $ $ " & & & ' $ " " "
$ * " 0 $* " $ $ $ $ $
& & &
($ % " 5
A
5 $ 8 4 $ & " : $ ; & # " $ 8&< ' 66' 1 44 8 I3B= ' #2 1 ' C 3* C 9 # & # $
A ,@
, ,,
, ,
AA
' 8 1" 2 & J A , ,5A& ! A ,@7 F ! ! A@ 8 & ! A& A $ $ * 8 " / & 3 ,@ & A > ,& .4 % ) A A7 . AA, >5& ' $ $ & - . " & ! $ 8 /& ' $ $ & - $ : 66 $44 # ; * @7 - AA A, 7 ! ,7 ?& A7 ?& A7 F & >A @
@
, & > A,& * * & , @ & > @ 66' * &44 F ,& F A, * & > A, ,& ! & 1 & . A@A H& , , & ! & " ! > ,&
& A& F , ,& 8 4 + 66- - 3 44 F & A, ,& & :& > A; & ' ! . " ! & ! ( "& A, . * A> 5, , > & ,&
@
! & ,> & 8 66 " 44 & 7 & > A,7 & @7 & A& 1 & -& ,5& ' ! :& A ; % # # 7 ! & , $ $ O
J 7 " # $ & 1 $ 4
$ 66 * &44 ! -& ,> & & 7 & > 7 & > 7 " ,7 & > ,& < ! A @57 A5 >,7 - A 5 . & " +
& - " + " ' " "
%/
( + " :&
A " . ** ++ 5" H" 2& + & **
" " " "++>8 ' " . C H $ 5 .
, + " # & " $ 5 . , . + " + -
3 + " 5 . 7 **< " " " '" " " " ! " " " " " " @ "++>/ ! G>%%%% " . 5 " H / 5
. & " 3 ? ** E "" F
E "" F"++% , . ! " ! & " . & 7
%
; (
.
" $ # & " 0
" " "
$ . ! " 5 . ! 6 " . & ' & ' &"> 5 5 .
; - 0+ " ( / &
5 . '
: /> />" 3 5 - ! 3 "8 : // , . + 2 $ - . + 7 ) EF =8 . . / " . , 5" . !
7
A . " " " , 5" .
! "=
, .
& 3 " (
. &
' ! & " $ > + ' " ( = #
3 " . + ! " : ' 6 . ; ( "
"" % > = /%
4 =%% 8=%% %%%% %% %%%
=%%% 8%% =%% /%%% >%%%% %%%
8%% =%% 8%% %% CD7E%%%F =8% =%%% >%/%%
>%% >%% C D ! >%%% >%%%%
2 ; /%% =%% %% 8%% =8%% /%%
. +
- **' ++
" ( @ .
& 0 &
" ( "
C "D" 0 ' ** "++/
# & & " " 5
0 '
** ++ & " 0+ "% ? ' ! & &
" & " @ . + ! ' &
" . + ! "
. - ' '
- " . +
& %" :
>
; (
">" % $ # % 3
=8 G"%8 "%8
% G"%8 "%8
8 G"%8 "%>
% G"%8 "%>
8 G"% "%>
/% G"% "%>
/8 G"% "%>
/%% G"% "%
/%8 G"%> "%
3
G"8
"
">
"=
"
"
">
"8
"=
">
"
"/ "=
" "
>" "8
>" "
>" "8
>" %"
"> %"=
;
& !
&+ " 8 "= & "/ & C ">D"> . + 3 %
" .
& />" 8
" ) ' + - 7 **@ . % %
3 + L
? 3 +
? CMDLL
@B?+ CMDLLL
=%%% %%%% =%%% >%=%%% >=%%% ==%%% //%%%
@( >%%% %%% >%=%% 8%% >/>>%% 8>%%%
@( %"% 8"> 8"8 8"% =>" 8>"
% " >" >" " />"8 =">
L $ ? />" LL ? & ( N %4/% 5 /% /% # " 9 & "= . /=% "= ) ! ! ! " "=8 + #
. + & ; - 0"
3 "== 3 . - & ' 7 ** 3 " ?
3 "++= : + K $ . +
" 1 % ! # . & " 0 3 + - +
=
; (
" ! "= " " ) + 4
#
" " " 0 @ # E F " " " @+ 4 & ! "/>
9 6 > / A . 7 3 , 4 % E F " .
"
& ! " '
" " " 3 **
@+ ! & ++ 5 @ ( K/
.& , 4 & & 4 5 7
>
0 EF
!
EF
! " " " & &
! "/
6 , .
4 ** ' >8 "++/8 2 $ 7 " " " & 6" , 5" . # EF " " " /=
( ( ,
. " 1 5
" 3 5 " ** ++
' "/ 5
2 5
- & ? " 5 . " ? # .
"
! " ?
,+ &" ' - " - 4
" $ 5 . %" & + " . = + ! & ! 8
>>
; (
/"
" ?
/ /"= / 8"8 // =% /%/"/ ** ++ " 3 %
: &+ ;
" "// ) ," H" 0 ?" 6 + 3 !" 0 "%% /%
" 1. !
& " ? & !' " & ! ! -
&" C
- D & "% ' ! , . + " )
"
3 + **! ++ ! " : ' " 0 " (
" ' " $ /
/"
" ; 5 . A 4/ C %D ' "
"%> )
,+ %"
>
$ 9
7 ' " : ' " ' "
3 + # " .
& 0+ 3 + ! ! ** ++ &" **' ++ " $ ! " ; + " !
& A ' 4
" 5
0 & &" /% 1. 3 & ** ++ ' "% ( 0 1.
: 5 /%% " ( 5 5 1. ) : : ** /%"++% ( /%> 6 6
; (
& ' " " "++%8 ) & 0 # " ? #
&" @ ** ++
" 0 3 C ( D & 4
4 0" 5 & 0 + "
**) ( ++ - A' !
- &" )
**) ++
! - &" 5 7 & "
" 1 '
" 5
& # + !' A' -
" B " 2
"
"
" : -
" ? 1. ? . , O
" 5 1. & -
& &
" ? # ) "%=
>8
! # 7 1. &K :
** ++ 4 & A 4 K ( - '
& ** "++% 1. ; /= " !
" , ** ++ " ' + "% . ' (
! ' " : 3 ( ) " A
( - "%/ , . / & - " ? ! # # 7 " : " " " " ' " " " " " " : #
! " " " " " " %
. 5 . /%>
" **E(F #
>=
; (
' - '
+ "++ 0 0+ '" 3 ! ! 7 + # A 1.+ & "> ( " # " : !
" : & & " & " 9 # "
' 7 " .
0 " ( 6 ** "++ 9
& " @ & !" @
" & &
" (
& " ( 0 . 4 6=%/ /%/" $
> // >%% />" 3 + & / . " ! ! ' //" ;
'
/>> 0 " ' & . -
" ! 3 " /%8 . P " #
3 ? " 0& ) 66
" . + A # " /%= 5 . ! " ( 3 ! " /8 + " ) ! " " ) 3
( " ' /=%" /% 3 + ! "/
" ( # " ' " ) ' % ; -+ & ' /% 3
>
; (
-">% ( 6 )
; -+ 7 + ">> :
& " , . + ! " 5 . !
-
"> 9 & ** ++ ** ++ !
-" (
- "> " ' ">8 ; " ; " 2 ( & ">=
" @ 5 . ** "++ 5" H" 2&
#& " 2& + /%%" ; "> $ & ( " ( ;
: - ! " : + +
" -
"
>/
**
& 4 4 "++> % /% **' ++ ( " H
4 - " 9 & 3 ' & " ( " (
+
- + ">/ ' -
" ? "% ; -
" ( '
" & !& " :
& 4 " @ " < & ! & & " ;
'" "> +
" 0 &
!
%
; (
" $ !
' ' &
" 1 & ! " ) 62 - " 0
"
" ) 62
# ' C62 /=7 " 8D" " ) /7 >=%4/" - " . &
& " 0 /% @ B& # />"8 " ) @ B& & H /7 3 2 ;" =7 >/D" . & **: . 5 @++ ! (" > " ) . /7 " J /7 " " 9
.
/" $ /=%7 " ; . 3
7 0 )" ) . ' " 0 ! - " (
" $ )+ 6 ' & !
6 + - & '" 5
" )
** ++ ' " ( & &" 9 ) ** A " " " ! "++ 0 2 6" . . /7 4" : . & ) - " ?" . O /87 >4" ; ) ** ++ - (
>
>8
>= >
> >/ %
>
8 = /
%
; (
. ) /" ; /=7 %" ( C( / / $ 0 ?
D # . 7 ** & & 7 & "++ 2& + 2& & % " ; $ + ) " 2& $ H =7 >/4%" H 5 . , . 6 >> / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" P $ /=%7 %" 9 . **E.F E F ++ C. /==7 4D" 9 # 6? /87 /4% CD " "* ( $ C%D . /==7 84= +%% $ C%D" . & 6? /87 " >4" 5 />7 >/> >/=4 /" $ /=%7 = 5 />7 >/=4 /4 . /==7 ==4" ?" . /==7 %" $ //7 2 2" $ ; C$ 0
?
D" . /" 84> .
/7 >4" :& & 1. $ ? " 38 3 3%
" ) &+ O - />7 >>4%"
&
&" ( 7 CD &
CD &
CD & CD # " $ />7 >
" 84>" ( . & /87 4 " 8 . /==7 4 ? /7 /4 >" 0 2 # ! 7 2 ( & & " . 2 /= /7 8 8" 9 0 & 62 /=7 >4 B
- /=87 " /7 ; - >=4 = . /=7 >>4" 9 . + # . /==7 4" )
5 />7 " >% >/= >48" :+ ** ++ . @ " # '
" ; > H
/ / $ @ H /4/ C? & ( D" ?" I
/" / . $ //" 8% $ //>7 84= >> //7 4>" 8 9 ** & ++ $ /8/" 9 & $ />7 /4> . & /87 4" & , >4 " 3 + 3 & , >4 " 9 ? + @ /" 8> , > 7 >" ( # A " 8 6? /87 %" , . ! A & " 8 ?" . /=7 >> 4 4 88 $ # ; /=7 =>4" @ /8" 8= H /7 =84 > > >4/" ( . /=7 4" H
" 8 O - />7 %=" 8 3 + % 3 4 % "
& % " 0 % " 9 % /%
" 8/ ) 1. . /=7 4> 8" =% .
"7 ! 5 " 5 ' 8 % 5 & %4/>%" C( & & O - />7 %="D . 3 C @ B&D" 9 " " = H H /8/ E/>/F7 8" => 3 7 3
/7 >>%4" = $ //>7 " = $ //% => + " ?" H //87 4/ $ //>7 4/"
8
=8 . $ //>" == . ?
3 " . 5 . + ; 5" 5 % 5 . " . 5 />7 >/ . /==7 8" 0+ ! " ,' 3 " 0+ +
1. . " 0 ,'
! 3 & " . . /=" ; - 3 " 0 ! & /= & 3 " ?" 62 /=7 >4 >/ >8 5 />7 >%" = . - /=7 " . -+ !
" $ 3 C D ? &" 3 3 , /7 %/48" = ? **. ! 4/>++ 2 $" ? ; C$ 0 ?
D 48" =/ ) /% 3 " ?" , " / 3 " % 5' . + ! 7 H 5 :" . , . )" / H 5 :" . 2 $ )" >% / H 5 :" . 2 $ )" >8 / H 5 . , . 6 >> / C
2 2" $ ; E$ 0 ?
FD 6? /87 = " " .
. ( " 3 C D ! & " H , 5" . 2 2" $ , /= C? & ( D" (
. $ " > ( # ; /=7 =>4" H 5 . , . 6 >> / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" 9 ?
& ? /7 /4" 6? /87 = " " 8 H 5 . , . 6 >> / 2 2" $
=
= / % >
8 =
/ /% / /> / / /8
; (
; C$ 0 ?
D" ) ' ! & H 5 :" . , . )" / H 5 :" . 2 $ )" >% / H 5 :" . , . )" / H )" >8 / C
2 2" $ ; E$ 0 ?
FD" . % /% C/7 " D" , H //7 84/" . /> E/%F7 >" H H /8/ E/>/F7 " %" . . /=7 48" ?" ? /7 4> $ />7 >=84 ? />=7 8>/" ?" $ />7 >" " >" ?" .1 /=7 //4% " .& /8 )
/>7 /"
+ " ' +
" H , . 5 . ." # . /==7 8 H //7 " ?" ; : + A 7 : //7 " > . /==7 =% =4% >%%4" 2 $ **H& $&++ C// D 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" 9 $+ ; /= 6? /87 4/" $ ; /=7 >4 >4% =" 6? /87 " "
2 $ **H& $&++ C// D 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" H 5 :" . 2 $ ( / / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" ; " H 5 . , . 6 % / 5 . 2 $ 6 >> / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" H 5 :" . , . 6 > / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" H 5' , . 5 :" . 6 / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" H 5 . , . 6 > / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" H 5 :" . , . 6 > / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" 6 H 5 . , . 9" 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D"
/= 2 $ **H& $&++ C// D 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" / H 5 . 2 $ ." > / 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" / ; 4/%= **P ++ 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" . 4= ; /=7 %" . J //8 ! - 1. H /7 4/ " 9
/7 /=" . ' - : /=7 %" 2 ! //" 2 ! / />%" // . H //7 " =4> >" %% ; /=7 2 $ **H& $&++ C// D 2 2" $ ; C$ 0 ?
D" ; />/7 " . /7 =4" % 9
/7 /4" ( ? /%" %> ; H /7 48" , 1
/>8 /= ' % $ ' C/7 >8D" H /7 =4 . /=" $ **H& $&++7 **E F & " ; G"=% %% > " / "++ % . /=" % 0 0 :
/8 5 />7 >" %8 H 6 6 /%> , 5" . @ H />4/% C? & ( D" 6" % 9 H " 9 . /7 >4" 9 //4% $ //>7 >=4 848" 9 + " =8" $
+ !
>"8 %% =" + " > 2& /7 /8 >"
! " # $ % ! & &&& & ' ( ! & ! & ! (
) * + ,
- . && ( & $& /& & 0$ , 1 ( /& & ! 1 & / 2
$ ! ) ,& 2 & 0 ! * ! ) 34 & ! $ ! 5 & ) ! & &0 .! "
& & ! - * ! ( !0 ! !
& $ ! $ 6 77 && 0 (( & 89
8
$ & :1 0 0 ) & ( ! /& 0 - & 0 & ; & & & 6 $ ( ! ( ! - & ! ! ( 0 ! (
! & ! 77 ! ((
& & ( 6
0 ( 6 &
" ( ! 6! 0 ! 6 ! ! $ " ( & ! (
8>
-
99 $& && & & !
3 & 2 & 1 ( 2 $& 3 &( & B & ( & '
& ! 3 2 & E )
= =
! & 3 2 >>
1 & * ! & A , 1
$ / * ! $ & * ! / 1
& ! C 0 5!$ 9 ! & & ! ! & , & & $&
& ) . 1 & & 2 77A
!$ ( & & &
! & & * & B & & 0!
& & ( & B ( B
8C
( & 34 2( $ A ! B
& 6
&
!$ ( ! ! 89
! ! % & 99 0 & ! 6 99 6 ! & & 0 !
8 6 !
& !
/ & & !$ ( - , L 3 + 0 & 2 3 3 ' 77F& G 6 B 0 & ! & * ! + ( ) ,& 2 77 I & & 0 $ &K & . % B ! & & - & ! & 9 >A A>
0 $ 0 & 6 - & / * /
6 $ " ! $ !! ! & ! ( & 1 6 ! $& &
& 0
+ 3 &@ + $ ! @ ) 0 * ! 3 & AA 98 0$ 0 &. ! & 3 & & & * ! ( 0
$ 0 ) ! & & 0 - &0 = ! ! 5 & 2
! $ 0 & ! &
6 & & $ !$ 98 3 & & ) ! &
0 ( /6 0 !.& ( $ ! 77
(( 6 ! 2 & $ & &/ & 0 & & 3 0!
& &
& /
& 0 6 & ! 0 A8 & 6 * 3% $ 0 A
3 &
$ & * ! $ ! ! A $ & 77 (( !
>
-
& $ ' - )
!& < ( ! - & ! ! 0 -$AC ! , 1 ! 0 . & ! ' 77,& -$ & & F G $ B ((A 98 &! < & ( ! * ! ! ! & & & 77 (( I K & ! * ! & & &&
' &! . ! ! % & & ! & ( & & & 0 < * !
? $ & & &
&/ /& 3 & < ! & ! 3 < ! $ ) L . $ 77+ , (( E 3 < & & 6 & F G8
< 6!
& & 98 $& & & ; ; !$& 77 (( < & & & & && !
& &
! & ! & 6 & /& & <( ? - & '
!0 & ? ! !
8
-
! & & ! & $ & * ! -
*
&
& /
& B & *
( .' & ! 3 *
! ! ! ! ! ! 3 & * ! !
& & ! 8>
) ! - *
! ! ? & '
& 77 - - ((8A
! ! *
3 & / $ 0 & 77 ! ! & <
& & *
((88 ! & *
( ! 0
& / & 77 ! 0 F G((8 < 0 * ! " & * ! ! $& $ & & & 3 & 2 & 98 77 ! & ! 3 & &
& (( 77 & $& ! ((8 < * ! 77& $&(( /& & 0 ! &
! !$ * ! 1 1 ) 1 &' %( !H & &' -$( ! 3 & &H ! *
! & &' ( & *
(( ) F1 G /
' 77 3 < !! < F G8C
$ * !( ' + -
F* ! 1 G 2 # & & 0 $ &
& * ! I K
!
! & " & $ $ 77 & (( ! *
< &
&
! 8
+ & < &! &. $ !
& &. < 6 !0 & < & ! 6& B ! 6 ! & ! B && ( B & & & $ <' 77- ! - (( < 77# & # ! ! ! < #: *= 1EL=1 < = +=* -* # ) +: -*"%-E= #: *= -* += )*1 4" < 3%+"= (( 1 & $& $ ! . ( & / & ! & $ 77! (( + $ - & = & /
& & ! ! 77 6 & $ & ((8
?
-
- & !
& - &( &
. # - & & ! 1 1$ $ 6 & ; ; 0!/ / 0 &. )
0 * ! - & I K (
&& 0 9 !
! ( ! 1 & !. ( ! &
98 ! & $ 0 & I & ( ! ! K 98 0 *
( 3 & *
& A999 -$( A8999 6 + &! * < >>A999 * ! ( >8999 & & 6 C999 I K ! ! 999 !$ & & &
& >
&
& * ! 0 ! A 3
! 60- *
( * ! ) *
( !B - & > 3 &( * !0
* ! - & 8 2 > & ; & -
C
< $ & - & ! & & & ( 5 & $ & 6
/ . & 98 < / ( &
! 77 ((
9A * !0 & 6 &
) * ! & !
& / & 3 - ! ! & 0 L 4( $ &
&
& / ( 98
/ $ 3 ! & ! &
& & & & B 0 ! ! ! /0$
! ! !( $ & ! 776 (( 98 !& '
! F G !
$
& / & &0 & ! $
! $
-
& .
$
& 0
$ !& & & / / 6 ! & $ C
! & 9 & & / & ( & ! ! + ! 1 98 ! ( ! ! ? ! 0 )
& !& & ! . % &. & & $ & + 1 ( & & 6 3 E& 6 0 ( B/ & & 770B/(( 0 & ! ? & 6 77/ (( & ( & 77 3 E& & & & ! ! ! (( & < 77- 1 (( & &
!9 B 77 & B
$ 0 ((
( B ' FG ! $ & !
& . B
! ! / ! >
" ! &
, ! ! ( + & 1 &. ! ! & ! . ! & ! I ! $ & KA B & ! . / $ & B & & & ! 3 & ! = 2
! (
' 77) &
$ ! ! & ; B & & ((8 5 $ $ & ?
98 >A 0 ! !. 6 (
! $ ( & !? ! / $
&. * ,( & !.& ! 1
& & ! ; 77 ((C ! ! $ & ! !& ! ! & !
& $ ! 77)
F G !@(( 77=
9
-
$&
! + "!@
& ? ! & ! $& & & & ((
! & && (
& - / & & ! & .
& (
$& / & ! ! &. /& & * !0 ! $ 6 0 & & $ & ! ! &. . ! 0 ! & ! - & $ ! " !
& H
! -
! .& ! & & ) 2 $ - & = H & (
! . 0$& . ! ! $ & && 4& E! - 9 9C9 & /& ( ( 0 ( ! & ? 77 ! ((
! & ! ! H & ! & & & ! CA
B ! ! ! . . & 0 ( 6 & & $ . & & ( ? & $ 6 ! ! ! & C8 2
& ) .& ! ! & $ . 4 $ 77 F G / !(( ! 77 6 ((C ! $& ! ! & !&& .( $ & ! ! &.0 $ & ? ( ( ; $&
>
-
; /
/ " & !
/ ! 6 ! C & & 0 - $0 $& &. & ) 77!
(( 77& (( 77! (( 77 (( $ 2 && ! & & (
!
! & &/ & 0 2
& ( & 0! H
! ( & & ! & !$ 60
!&
! 0
CC * ! & 0 ,
&
& 0 0
& / 0 .
1 '
77 !(( ! F5! G ) & & + !
$ 77 & (( 0 & + 3 !
77" $M(( 77" $ $@ - !
& & ( ! $ ! ( ! F$G((C
! $$ & B $ $ 0
$ 0( 0
- & &. & & 0 1 & ! ! $ 6 & C 2
A
& ' / !
/ 0 . & 99 & ! & ! & 6 N
. ! & & & &.0 & & 2 & & ( ! $& & & & $ ! &
! ! 9
& & & ! 6 $ & & 0!
. ! . & ! ! & ! & ! !
, ( 0 ! ! ! & < - 1 I;A>K - & = ! $ ! & > , = 1 , 1
! 5 & 2
- & A # ! ! . ) - & !! B$ !
8
-
! &
3 & ! 5 & 5 2
6& ( ! 9 2
& 3 &( & 00 , 1 ! 2
0 & & &
8 2
$ !!& & & 0 & 1 + & 0 - & 2
( ! ! ; & & ! ; (
5 & 2
( 77 ! (( ! 2
! ! ' & ? / /
& / &
& / & 3$ 1=*L= ! / H
&
+ !
! =' 77) !
& !& &
& & & &(( 2
( ! - & + ! 0 ( < 6 9 2
! = & & ! & + ! =( ! # & 3( % $ &' F#G $ F G & !
&
+ 77" & ! ! & ! ! $ ! & $ & & FG &! ((C ! &
& 2
+ .
(
& & && & 0 " $ ! &
! ! 0 ! 2
= 1 & /
0 - &
! & ! - & 0 ! ! & 2
& = 2
!$ 77 &
! !$ $
((9 $ = 2
&
/& ' 77) / ! (( 5 & 2
. 77F (G ?
/ ! ! &
& ((>
2
( 6 ' )! C' 8 2 ! $ & I2 ' 8C 8C 8C8; 8A 9AH 2 C>' >8;K
C
-
, = 1 A I)$ & %!
$ K > - 8 A + 8 1 $ ' AA>; 1 ( 77 (( , > ' > E & 8' 9 C ( & , C' >C>;H 1 ' 9;H 2 C>' >8; +
! $ 2 = 1 3 & L3 & ;C9 E& 98' 9 2 ' 88C > >;8 >9 & & , AH % A 2( B , E &( 2( % 5 IE & 8' ;9K > 2 ' H ! & 98 >> B % - 77 1 , = 1 (( A9C I%0 !
$ K , C' CK >A ! A >8 2 C9' 8 > 3 8' % 2 8' > 4 9' A; 9>;H 4 C' C9; >>9; >C E * $$ CH 6 ' >;A>H 2 >' 8>;AH 4 >' 8;9 > 6 & ' IK . ! ;- H I>K & & & ! 0 H IAK & I 35( ! KH I8K 3$$& ( 6 IE K > 3 & " &0 C8;> ? & & & $0 3 3 &0 0 & & / 5H , C A9 2 C9' 8 A 2 C9' ;> & ;>9 ;>9A L ! 98 9 2 ' >A;
A>
AA
A8 A A
AC A A
CC
& ! ! ! 1 ! . ! ! & 1
! 5 99 9 89 % 2 >' A;C * &0 9 >9 + ! * 3% $( " # $ 1 0 " # $ * ! &
+ ! & ! ! 6 0 * ! I3% $ K & & 1 1$ $ * ! & & !& & ! 0 & - $ *
6 ! $ ! I1$ $ ' C;CK
0 ! 9 77- (( I +! 8' 9 A8;H 1 K 1
!
! I' 6K 3% $ ' 98
* ! & ! 6 ? ! * !
5 +. -&( & & 0 3 & $ ! % & / & * ! 1 &
& -& 77 & B FG (( ; & * ! -&( 9 ! &
- & = I99;K 1 % >' A;89 >H + ' H % ! 8 1 " - - , ' A9; 77 5 - 98(( > 98' > 2 & & ( ; $& $& + / (
$ $
C
-
1 ! B0 $ &
( + !
( ! $ 77 (( !& ! ! 6 & ( ( % ! (
$ E & 6 &
2 & 2 & & (
L
P
89 8 8> 8A 88 8 8 8C 8 8 9 >
A 8
C
1 - *
$ <
=6 * 98' > A 98' 8 C <! >8 A 98' > 98 98' 9 98 98' > A 98' 9 A 98' 9 4 C' C9 1$ $ ' C;C % 4 C' >> % 4
* ! & ! 9>;98 IC' >;AK & <( ( / 9> && *
! < 4 C' A8; % ! 8 4 8 & & 2 CH 4 C $ & & & 1 ) !& 98' A 9 - 1 77 3 * ! 0- 1 ((H ' C 8 98
C
9 98' & L ( %! 5
% .( E& 98' 98 > 8 98' > A 1 6 = ! ( I 98K 8 E = 2
+ 2
3 A A I%!
$ K 98 , ' 8A;H 2 C9' ;C C > 98' >H 1 ! 98' > 98 & 2
9 ! ! ( B 1 - 8' H E 5 & 5 2
= 2
A 9 3 9C I%!
$ K & ! & !
2 C' 9>;8 >A;8 + 0
& 0 C9 2 * ! & :1 1 % & $ I2 ' >;8H >' 8C;9H ' >;C8K ) 2 ! & ! < - 1 - 4 * 3% $ & < - 1 B & & 036 & . $ B & $ & & < !
. $ && / % 8' H L C' ;9H 3% $ ' ;> A; >>>;C >C8;9 C 2 >' A; A &&
! & 0$& ! ! & ! I% -.. AK 0 & ! ! & &. %
! 6 &. 6 ! . ! & B ' &
&. @ + && $' 2 ' >;A9 A A9 A 8;H
9
C> CA C8
C
C CC C C
9 > A 8
C
-
4 ' ;CH % AH * & C' ;>9H & E C' H + % Q ' C 6 % 4 CH 1 & 6 E ( IK E & 77(( ; ; ( & 6 $$& AA E 5 & 2
= 2
, A9 9C I%!
$ 0 K ! ' 77A(( I%!
$ K ! = 2
& 5 * H 2
E 5 & 2
= 2
9 I%!
$ KH - 8' >>8; >A8 1 1 ' >A;8 >; >;C> E 5 & 2
= 2
, 9 9C I%!
$ K & + C
.
&. $ % &
! &
9
> A 8 C
99
! & &. & &
& % 4 H % 8 E = 2
5 & 2
C 9C I%!
$ KH - 8' >C >A; 77F52G & ! !$ ! !&(( I >CK E = 2
5 & 2
>9 9C I%!
$ K - 8' >A - 8' 8; E 2
! ( * / :1 ! $ E 5 & 2
= 2
, A9 9C I%!
$ K E 5 & 2
= 2
, A > I%!
$ KH 2& 8' C;8 E 5 & 2
= 2
, A9 9C I%!
$ K 2
77 1 (( IK' A I%!
$ K & E 5 & 2
= 2
" 8 I%!
$ K - 8' H ! = 2
77A((
! & 5 * I%!
$ K 2 ' > 1 2
( 77 + (( I9KH 77 10 / ) 3 * &(( ICKH 77 3(( IKH - 8' 8CA;A 2
, 2 & 2
( / % 2 $ . 2
% ! ! & 1 % %!
$ 1
+ % ! !$
$& ( !
$ % 0 2
! & %!
$ 1
!! & 6 ( . I2 !H 2& 8' >8> CK E 5 & 2
+ % " C I%!
$ K
! & / ! ! - & * & 0 !& 6 0 ! 0 I* & >H 1 +! /' +! 8K 3& 1 0E & &
>
9 9> 9A 98
9 9 9C 9 9 9
>
- - & . % ! ! $ & ! $& I1 0E CC' K 2
( ! - & ! ! H ! / 99;9 ! ! ! 77/(( 6 ! 0 $ & 0 ) E & & & & &
6 $ & % E 3. >9H E 1 0E CCH , C> C>H C! % C' A 1 .
& ! ! I1 C' 8K % & & 0! ! - & 1 = = I% C' 99K 2 H C>' >;A C H 2 >' >;C $ *& & - 8' >>H 2
! 6 +
89 I % ' A>;8 C < 6 1 0E CC' H + H +! C9' H 2 C9' 8H >' CH 1 C' 8;H + 8 ) 9 $ %
$ & $ 0 & ! & I 35 ' A;CH CK * & ! ! & ! I * & CK >9 + & 0 & & ! 6
B ( .& I+ !' ;K > & E 1 ( C >> %
! " # ! $ " $ % % & ' (
)
* & "! "!
% # + # " , & - +
#
. " / & " 0 " . & 1 '23
'24
1 # " ! 55 !!
+
( + # " + . " ++ 67" / 8 ' "! 9 ( " +' #
) " . + .
/ & % " . +
(
. & ( /
! ! 0 # # % ( ) ( # & ! . + &
'2:
,
) 6 8 ; # .1 55 1
!! 55 1 + )
!!< $ .1 !
1 + ! & *
/ & & 1 +
3 . ! && ! #
% % ! =
% .
/ ) & + . !
/
& > & "
+ % 4 ? + * # /
+ : * ! @ ! # A 6'8 + % ! @ 6;8 ( + @
'2B
6
& ! &
! ,
+ ! . !
? D # " % & %
'CE
,
1 !
"
& B . ! 1 > . " % & 0+ ( 1 (
. & + " # & "! ? " +
+ A
'2C: , 'CEE . '2C: $ , * ! 4 , ! ( /
( & &+ % & . & $
" # " % & 1 .
" +
. " ? ! "
'C'
# 'CEE ,
? " ? " , 7 * *
,
% " . ! ? ! " + ,
. @ & / , " 7 ? '; 'C;B $% &
+
? "A # , 'EE &
# )
+ &/ / 2
" ! "! , - & " ? D
)
#
% / . & !
'C;
,
@ "
& D # & / ! " > ! - & ( 55 !! ( )
& 6 55 !! " 8 + & . .
% & ( 55
!! $
" & # ( 55 !! 55!! ( % * + !
= + # % "! & & % # & & ! " ) + && & . & # "! 6 & 1 !8 0 +
'C
. ; '1@> "# 34 7 C & 9: # & ; %! '1A@ 6
(! (' 7 9 " ; ! % " " %4 $ , %,! 3 = ! % '11@ ,* & 7 9 ; '1(( ** % %-- ) .) 5;6 ; $ '1(1 ? +, E 7 !
.?1
; $ 5!6 '1(. ! & , ! +$7 / ; $ '1(A **; -- + = '. ' ; & '18? ! - ! 6&- ! +, E 7 !, , '18( +, E 7 **2 C - % ,-- # C " 5!6 %7 % 9 '188 '%- , +, E 7 = % '1@) @ ? @ (
- .54/1.5C4 7 9 $K '18? # ) $ % 7 '18) **2 %7 & ! -- "# * > 5;6 '188 ** ! - ,-- ) = )) ' 5% 6 '1(@ **2 +, 5;6 '188 ** **2 -- # C 5!6 ' + 8 ./53 7 3 '1(( ) 7 9 '11? ** &7 2 & ! "
+ '(1?-- 6 = . ) 5C 6 3 ! '11A **2 & $ !! -- + = .' . 5%6 '118 **2 ! 7 '(@AD'1.?-- - = '1 > 5 $6 '11( ** ,
.'>
! '1(( " 7 9 " C % 3 ! % $ '11? +, E 7 ! ! 2 '1(@ #
8 ) +, E 7 5 )6 % " ! % 5!6 '1@8 7 +, E 7 ; C '1?) )& +, E 7 ! $ 5, " " G6 '1)1 , )& 7 C % 9 , 2 ! '181 6& +, E 7 C C + + '18) **% % -- # 3 = 5!6 = ' ! 7 % % '18) # ) 7# ! 7 "" 4 C C '18> **$ & % ; ! +,-- , = ' > 5% 6 ! ! " ! '1A1 M'1.1N # +, E 7 ! $ " '1(' ***; ! , ! ,-7 + ./541.544 +, E 7 " >! ! " & % ! C 5!6 '118 + ) " 7 9 " + $ '1(8 **2 " --
= ) ) '11> ** & 9% 7 '81>D'()(-- # C % ! " 5!6 )
"/ 7 9 "
.'A
5!6 '11A 6 ) ) !
97 9 # + ! ! '1() **2 = +,7 2 '1 C ! -- + 1.5C4 +, E 7 , ! 1.544 97 9 # '1(( **9 C / ! 2 & '(8?D'1)?-- + = 8) ) 5"6 **# % ! 4 4 ! % -- ! , % ; % ! '118 ** -- = ) ' 56
'18( % !7 % / ! 9 3 ! ! $ 5!6 '1@@ " ./041.534 97 9 # ! '1)( ** ! -- # & ! , =! =! 5!6 7 9 "
.'@
'1@) ' ! 6 6 8 7 C % 9 ; '1.1 ! 7 ! 4, ! '1(A ! 7 / ! 9 G! " 5 ,6 '(8A 1.//4 7 $ 9 % ! " '1() , +, E 7 % ! $ I '1(A ** " ! 7 " ! 2 + / #! 4 -- '?( 5 6 %
" '11A **2 & -- # ! ! 5!6 "# #% " 7 9 " % ! '1(1 )
$ 7 9 "
.'8
% % ! = % '1A8 7 C % 9 % 4 2 '1(( ** = ; H7 % $ - J-- 9 , = ( ' 56 %
" '188 )
7 9 %0 0! '18' , & 6& ( 7 9 '18A ** " ! $ #! -- **2 ; C % -- ) = @ % , % '1(' 8 "# 9 " - ./221.5C4 ! 7 ! 9 % ! '1(A ! ! , - ./441./54 +, E 7 % '188
- 7 9 % ! '1@) **C ! ! +, '(@8D'1??-- 8
)# = >( > % 2! '1(? **2 '((?D'1??7 C ! ! #L +,-- + = 8 ' 5% 6 % '1)> **% 2-- = .8 > 5%6 % '1(@D(8 ** **2 " ! +,-- &
" .1D>? 5 / 6 %!J & $ '1(( **" 2, ! -- ) .) 5;6 '11> '% " ) % 6 / ! "7 ! 9 % C '1() +, E 7 %, C '1@' +, E 7 % '1@8 +, E 7 % %,! '1(@ ** 7 % ! % -- )# = A' 56 2 ; '1.@ "# +, E 7
.'1
2 ! 5!6 '1A( %(8 % ! 7 ! 2 '1() 8 - 6
- +, E 7 % ; ! 2 J 0 ! '1)A = 'D. +, E 7 = 2 ! 24 '181 **& -- # 24 2 ! ! ' 5"6 C $ '188 **%
! 9% % 7 2 % -- 8
+ = 8 C
" '1(@ - .5>C1.5/0 / ! 7 ! 9 C '18) **2 +, % -- # " 5!6
7 ! "+ '11) "# 6 +, E 7 ; C '1(> ** 7 " " ! & -- # ! C ; 0 ! 2 $ $ 5!6 +, E 7 C ! '1(8 ! 7 $ 9 C C '1)@ & ' ' +, E 7 ""
..?
C I '((( **C $ -- = = 88 5