Into the Cool: Energy Flow, Thermodynamics, and Life [New ed.] 0226739376, 9780226739373

Scientists, theologians, and philosophers have all sought to answer the questions of why we are here and where we are go

107 36 30MB

English Pages 362 [380] Year 2006

Report DMCA / Copyright

DOWNLOAD PDF FILE

Table of contents :
Cover
Back Cover
Epigraph
Contents
Preface
Acknowledgments
Introduction: Trouble at the EPA
Confessions of a Government Worker
The New Thermodynamics
Life as a Manifestation of the Second Law
Part I: The Energetic
1. The Schrodinger Paradox
The Material Basis of Life
Order from Disorder
Information
2. Simplicity
Nature's Computers
Energy, Work Heat
Chaos and Confusion
Exergy
3. Eyes of Fire: Classical Energy Science
The Secrets of Heat
Burning at Both Ends
Carnot's Waterfall
A Fluid of No Substance
Clunk Goes the Clockwork Cosmos
4. The Cosmic Casino: Statistical Mechanics
Predictable Probabilities
Gravity and Entropy
Seeing the Forest, Not the Trees
Time Waits for No One
Boltzmann's View of Energy and Natural Selection
Maxwell's Demons and Angels
Matter and Mind: Gradients Perceived
Boltzmann Dies
Josiah Willard Gibbs
5. Nature Abhors a Gradient
6. The River Must Flow: Open Systems
Toward a Science of Creative Destruction
The Stable and the Metastable: Onsager's Realm
Prigogine’s Dissipative Structures
Mousetraps and Dynamite
“Other-Organized” Systems
Shock Waves
A Word on Nanotechnology
Thermodynamics: It's Not Just a Good Idea — It's the Law
Kauffman's Search
7. Too Much, Not Enough: Cycles
Morowitz's "Fourth Law”
The Midnight Sun
BZ Reactions
Eigen’s Hypercycles
In the Loop: Ulanowicz and Autocatalysis
Erich Jantsch's Self-Organizing Universe
Wicken's World: The Second Law Powers Life
Part II: The Complex
8. Swirl World
The Fluidity of Self
Benard’s Hexagons
Irreducible Complexity
The Rayleigh Number
Complexity without Selection
Koschmieder and Spirals under Sapphire
Function from Flux
9. Physics’ Own “Organisms”
Waves and Vortices
Taylor's Tests
Evolution and Memory
10. Whirlpools and Weather
Tornado in a Bottle
Wild Winds: Cyclones, Hurricanes, and Tornadoes
The Solar Gradient and Global Currents
Jupiter’s Great Red Spot
Part III: The Living
11. Thermodynamics and Life
Final Liberation
Bergson's Vitalism
Lotka’s Legacy
Maximum Power
Gradient World versus Historical Contingency
Propagation Postponed
Thermodynamics and Sex
Nonhuman Intelligences
The Kantian Challenge
12. Brimstone Beginnings
Schrodinger’s New Cat
Out of the Depths
Supernovas and Stellar Gradients: A Violent Start
Brimstone Bubbles: A Safe Place to Begin Life's Troubles
13. Blue Planet Blues
Orphaned Science
Succession unto Climax
Hutchinson's School and the Rise of Energy Ecology
Ecology in the National Interest
Leaky Ecosystems
Climax Ecosystems
14. Regress under Stress
Going Back in Ecosystem Time
Radioactive Bombardment
Oil Stress
Hubbard Brook
Nuclear Runoff: A Tale of Two Creeks
15. The Secret of Trees
An Ancient Relationship
Looking for the Light
16. Into the Cool
Not-So-Remote Sensing
Ecosystem Temperatures
Flying Low
17. Trends in Evolution
The Theater and the Play
Thermodynamics Selects
Species Proliferation
Mass Extinctions and Serene Seas
Progress and Prediction
Part IV: The Human
18. Health, Vigor, and Longevity
Thermo-Darwinian Medicine
Between Burning Out and Fading Away
Cellular Stress and Senescence
The Human Thermodynamic System
19. Economics
Gradient-Tracking Markets and the Casualty of Truth
Blackjack, the Internet, and the Wealth of Nations
Cities and Amoebae
Sustainability and Long-Term Survival
20. Purpose in Life
Teleology and Its Discontents: A Brief History of Purpose in Science and Religion
Function as Natural
From Log Cabins to Life: Simple versus Complex End-Directed Systems
Sex and Death
Different Kinds of Purpose
Tubes
Extraterrestrial Life
Selves and Groups
Ancient and Modem Causes
Intelligent Design
Thermodynamic Complexity (and the Limits of Natural Selection)
Behe and the Proton Rotary Motor
William Dembski
Cunning and Forgetting
Temporal Gradients, Black Holes, and Reversed Time
“I Am God”
Appendix: Principles of Open Thermodynamic Systems
References
Index
Recommend Papers

Into the Cool: Energy Flow, Thermodynamics, and Life [New ed.]
 0226739376, 9780226739373

  • Commentary
  • +OCR +bookmarked
  • 0 0 0
  • Like this paper and download? You can publish your own PDF file online for free in a few minutes! Sign Up
File loading please wait...
Citation preview

>\

\

- - -; -.. t- r -r-7,-r»—,~ •. - .

X5

C5

n A C O uO

V c G

\

Q Z 93

Heat

o o 0-

x|

CM o o

Herbivores I

T

Che


47 organic molecules: absorption by membrane surfaces, 181; meteorites and, 174, 179; solar energy stored in, 220; in submarine vent environment, 180 organisms: gradient reduction, 210, 211, 271; machines compared, 325; as open systems, 311-12, 321-22; selfhood of, 311-12; as tubes, 30910. See also life organization: crowding effect on, 288; economics and, 279, 283-84, 288; by energy, 310; functional, 302; open nonequilibrium systems and, 32829; order compared, 16, 20; selforganization, 32-33, 84-85, 175, 264, 329; as term for life, 16, 36 Orgel, Leslie, 162 overpopulation, 281, 297, 298 oxidative stress, 269-71 oxygen, 172-74, 209-10, 220, 263 269, 282,287,318 ozone production, 164 Pagels, Heinz, 320 Paley, William, 315

358

Index

The Panda's Thumb (Gould), 170 paramecium, 85-86 parasites, 169 Parmenides, 53 passenger pigeons, 243 Pasteur, Louis, 16) P/B ratio. See production/biomass (P/B) ratio Peacocke, Arthur, 87 Pearson, R. A., 1 19 pendulum, as example o f energy transformation, 27, perception, difference from reality, 277-78, 286, 289 perpetual-motion machine, 36, 6 6 Perspectives in Ecological Theory (Margalef), 194 phosphorus, 186-87, 2 3 » 2 97 photoautotrophy, 186 photons, 107, 220, 330 photosynthesis, 220-21, 244, 296, 330 phototropism, 329 phytoplankton, 191, 195,212 piston, 42, 42f Planck, Max, 67, 9 0 plants: dissipative processes, 157, 22324, 329; evolution, 155; intelligences, 55, 156; recycling o f chemical elements by, 186; transpiration, 221-23, 229; trees, 216-24 platelets, 267 Plato, 37, 58, 300, 307 Poincard, Jules-Henri, 47, 56-58 poker analogy, 237 pollution, 285-86 polyaminomalonitrile, 184 Popper, Karl, 102, 162, 181, 277, 286, 316 population dynamics, 147 population ecology, 188, 191 positive feedback system, 9 6 power: conservation of, 328; maximum power principle, 148 pressure, barometric, 132-33, 136 pressure gradient, 75f, 125-30; wind systems and, 132—36, i34f

pressure-volume-temperaturerelationships, 41-42, 54, 132 price differentials, 276, 278, 289 Prigogine, Ilya, 58, 76, 81-82, 189, 313 principle o f spite, 7 6 probability theory, Boltzmann and, 47-49 production/biomass (P/B) ratio, 201, 203, 212-13 proton gradient, 318 proton rotary motor, 317-19 purpose in life, 299—326; gradient reduction, 302-6, 308-11, 314; history o f thought on, 300-301; religion and, 300-301, 303, 306-7, 309, 314-15, 317-22, 325-26; teleology, 301, 3067> 3*3* 3 J 9; pyrite, 177, 182-83 Pythagoras, 37

30 6 - 8 * 3 I 2 “*4

quantum mechanics, 67, 6 8 The Quarkand the Jaguar (Gell-Mann), 23 radiation gradient, 107 rain forest, 227-28, 229, 235, 242, 248, 304 Randall, Merle, 69-70 randomness, 47-48, 5 0 Ray, Tom, 160 Rayleigh, Lord, 1 16, 1 18 Rayleigh number, 117, 121 reality versus perception, 277-78, 286, 289 reciprocity relationships, 80, 86 recurrence theorem, 56, 5 7 recycling: by ecosystems, 187, 202—3; sustainability and, 197 Redi, Francesco, 161 redox gradient, 43-45, 118, 279, 297, 318 reducing environment, 170-72 reflexivity, 278 relativity theory, 58 religion, 300-301, 303, 306-7, 309, 31415,317-22,325-26 remote sensing, 232-34

Index replication: connection to metabolism, 165-69; errors, 239; genetic takeover, 165, 177; nucleotide, 165; origin of, 163; as process o f stable gradient degradation, 117 repopulation, o f damaged ecosystems, 2 reproduction: chemical, 303; complexity and, 236; error tolerance, 169; genetic takeover, 165, 177; as means o f gradient reduction, 84, 239; meiosis, 241; sex, 154-55; Taylor vortices, 130; thermodynamic basis of, 106-7 reptiles, 268 respiration, 254, 255 287 reversibility paradox, 56 ribozymes, 167 Rifkin, Jeremy, 189, 285 RNA: as laboratory-made life, 160; origin of, 163; replication, 98, 168; selfcatalysis, 167; selfish, 168 RNA world, 163, 167 Rohde, K., 251-52 Rosen, Robert, 139 Rossler, Otto E., 64 rotational pressure gradient, 125-30 Ruse, Michael, 315 Rutherford, Lord, 6 7 Salvador!, Neri, 286 Saunders, Howard, 248 Savonarola effect, 287 scanning tunneling microscope ($TM), 64 Schrodinger, Erwin: biography of, 1 1 12; Dublin lectures (1943), 11-19, 166, 325; influence o n Watson and Crick, xiv; life as a material system, n-15; negative entropy, 15, 17-19, 165, 189; order from disorder, 1519, 165; paradox, 15, 19; What Is Life? xiv, 7, 147, 165, 325 Schrodinger’s cat, 12 Schumpeter, Joseph, 285 Schwartzman, David, 257 scientific method, 176 The Second L a w (Atkins), 21

359

second law o f thermodynamics: economics and, 285-86; evolution and, 237-41, 251-52; fourth law o f thermodynamics and, 91-92; history, 36, 44, 90; irreversible processes and, 72-74; life as manifestation of, xivxv, 7-8, 82-84, I O 5”7» 3°°» nonequilibrium thermodynamics (NET) and, 51; probabilistic nature of, 60-61; purpose in life and, 321, 323; Schrodinger paradox and, 1518; teleomatics of, 307-8; timedirectionality and, 57; unification and simplification of, 75 selection: directionality, 254; thermodynamics and, 238-41, 251-52; units of, 239-40. See also natural selection self, concept of, 1 1 1-12, 311-12 selfish genes, 1 1 1, 167 self-organization, 32-33, 84-85, 175, 264,329 The Self-Organizing Universe (Jantsch), 103 Sellers, Pierre, 229 Selye, Hans, 270 senescence, 264-66 sensible heat, 226, 231, 233 Sepkoski, John, 242f SETi (search for extraterresterial intelligence) sex, thermodynamics and, 154-55, 3°5 sexual selection, 150-51 Shakespeare, William, 131 Shannon, Claude, 20 Sherman, Kenneth, 207 shock, 270 shock waves, 86-87 Silent Spring (Carlson), 192 silicon, 172 simplicity, 25 sinusoidal wave, cyclic, 95 slime mold, 155-56, 295 Smil, Vaclav, 144, 160 Smith, Adam, 293 Smolin, Lee, 55, 59, 303 Smoluchowski, Marian von, 64

360

Index

Snow, C . P., 8 societies, selection and, 239-40 Socrates, 3 7 Socratia, 156 solar energy/radiation: absorption by plant tissue, 156-57; capture by trees, 218-20, 219C conversion to biomass, 157; degradation by plants, 220; ecosystem complexity and, 23 it; reradiation into space, 226-27, 227!*, 233ft spectrum, 221; storage in organic molecules, 220; surface receipt of, 221-22, 222ft unequal distribution to Earth’s surface, 232ft 246 solar gradient, 39, 1 18, 304; amount of, 164-65; effect o n global weather, 136-37; reduction, 157, 202, 228 Soros, George, 277-78, 286 Spallanzani, Lazzaro, 161 species: definition, 243-44; distribution of, 244-47; proliferation, 241-52 species diversity, 194, 208, 241-52, 242ft and available energy, 235, 246-47, 251; causes o f large-scale, 2451; decline, human-caused, 241-42; and elevation, 247; and environmental variability, 248; mass extinctions, 252-53; measures of, 244; and organism size, 248-50 spectral flux photometer, 226 Spencer, Herbert, 188 sperm, 218 Spinoza, Baruch, 307 spirals, in Assenheimer-Steinberg experiments, 120-21 stable equilibrium, law of, 75 Stamets, Paul, 242 star formation, 170 steady-state system, 79, 327 steam engines, 37-38 Stehli, Frank, 246 Steinberg, Victor, 120 Stengers, Isabelle, 81 Sterling engine, 45 STM (scanning tunneling microscope), 64

Stoics, 5 3 stomata, 221-22, 329 storm systems, 131-38 stress: cellular, 269-72; ecosystem regression and, 207-15, 2151; global economies and, 295 strokes, 267 The Structure o f Evolutionary Theory (Gould), 313 Strutt, John William (Lord Rayleigh), 116 succession, 189-206, 199ft 2O$f; evolution compared, 235-37 sugars, 174, 217 sulfur hexafluoride, 120-21 sulfur metabolism, 181 sun, thermodynamic cycles and, 94-95. See also solar energy/radiation supernova, 172-73, 253 superoxide, 269 supply and demand, 278, 280, 289, 292-93 surface tension, 116, 119 sustainability, 296-98 Swenson, Rod, 189 swirling systems, metastability in, 1 12 systems theory, 104 Szent-Gyorgyi, Albert von Nagyrapolt, 107 Szilard, Leo, 63, 6 6 Tait, Peter Guthrie, 61 Taper, Mark, 249 Taylor, G . L, 125, 127 Taylor number, 127, 129 Taylor vortices, 125-30, 126ft i28f, 2078,329 Teilhard d e Chardin, Pierre, 314 telecommunications, 289, 290 teleology, 301, 306-7, 313, 319 telomeres, 262 temperature: absolute zero, 41-42, 54, 90, 272; black body, 225; ecosystem, 229-34, 232f,233f temperature gradient, 38, 45, 62, 11 1, 304; Blnard systems, 1 12-15, 1 1 9’>

Index Earth’s pole-to-pole, 136-37; ecological richness and, 225; Fourier’s law and, 327; hurricanes and, 134-35 temporal gradient, 292, 324 thermal infrared multispectral scanner (riMs), 230 thermal noise, 88 thermodiffusion, 80 thermodynamic equilibrium, Schrodinger and, 17 thermodynamics: heat death o f the universe, 5-6; history of, 4-6, 34-46, 72-77; origin o f term, xii; principles in open systems, 327-30; restrictions o n systems under study, 25-26 thermodynamics o f life: contributors to study, 104; deferral o f gradient breakdown, 154; history, 146-59; sex and gradient reduction, 154-55 thermometer, 34-35 thermophiles, 174, 181 thermoscope, 34 thermosphere, 38-39 third law o f thermodynamics, 42, 9 0 Thomas Aquinas, Saint, 300 Thompson, Benjamin (Count Rumford), 39-40 Thompson, D’Arcy, 18-19 Thomson, Baron William (Lord Kelvin), 40, 56, 9 0 Thomson, Sir J. J., 6 7 Thoreau, Henry David, 189 Thorpe, Edward O., 291 thunderstorms, 132-33 time: Augustine and, 48; direction, 4748, 52-53, 57-58; probability theory and, 47-48; recurrence theorem, 56, 57; thermodynamics and, 36-37, 44-46 time’s arrow, 57, 8 2 TIMS (thermal infrared multispectral scanner), 230 Tipler, Frank J., 189 Tolstoy, Leo, 151 tornadoes, 132-34 Tornado in a Bottle, 131-32, i32f

361

total system throughput, 199, 200, 214-15 Toussaint, Oliver, 269-72 toxicity experiments, 1-2 trade, 276, 279, 281, 283-84, 286, 287, 289-90, 292, 294 transcription, 143-44 transpiration, 157, 221-23, 2 2 7 2 2 9> 2 35» 244,246-47,329 transportation gradient, 293 trees, 216-24; deforestation, 229, 234, 242-43; as dissipative systems, 22324, 329; entropy production, 329; importance of, 217; shape, 219; sizefrequency distribution, 249; solar

energy capture, 218-20, 2i9f; transpiration, 221-23, 2 2 9 Trewavas, Anthony, 156 trophic levels, 191-92, 193 202 Turner, J. Scott, 11 1, 148 Twain, Mark, 189 Two Cultures anda Second Loo (Snow), 8 Tzu, Chuang, vii Ulanowicz, Robert, 99-102, 204, 205, 275,312,329 The Unbearable Lightness of Being (Kundera), 56 unifying principle o f thermodynamics,75 universe, expansion of, 58-59, 324 “use it or lose it” concept, 263-66, 266f, 268, 271 Utricularia, 101 vacuum, nature’s abhorance of, 6 vents, ocean, 177-81, 184 Vernadsky, Vladimir, 145, 153, 196, 281, 288 Victoroff, Jeff, 266, 273 Vienna Circle, 6 7 Volterra, Vito, 147, 194 von Mises, Ludwig, 275, 280 von Neumann, John, 20, 169 vortex, Taylor, 125-30, iz6f, ia8f, 2078,329

362

Index

Wachtershauser, Gunter, 181-83, 2 6 Wagensbcrg, Jorge, 85 waste: heat, 44-45, 85, 186; recycling, 85; use by other organisms, 44; work from, 65 water condensation, 133, 135-36 waterfall analogy, 3 8 water-quality assessment, 1-2 Watts, Alan, 125, 216, 309 wave function, 1 1 wealth, 280, 281 The Wealth of Nations (Smith), 293 weather, 131-38 Weaver, Warren, 2 0 Weber, Bruce, 238 Weinberg, Steven, 25 Weiner, Norbert, 324 West, Geoffrey, 249 Westbroek, Peter, 240 What Evolution Is (Mayr), 254 What Is Life? (Schrodinger), xiv, 7, 147, 165.325 whirlpool, 131-32 Whittaker, Robert J., 250 Wicken, Jeffrey, 16, 105-7, 1 57”5 » I 5» 167-68, 240 Wickramasinghe, Chandra, 175 Wilde, Oscar, 275

Wiley, E . O . , 189 Williams, Garnett, 30 Williams, R. J. P., 163-64 Williamson, Donald, 321 Willis, Katherine, 250 Wilson, E. O., 185, 193, 244, 247, 248 wind systems, 132-36, 133C I34f Woese,Carl, 181 wolves, 187-88 Wbodwell, George, 21 1 work: free energy and, 68-69; gradients and, 38-39; from heat, 38, 45, 73; as method o f energy transfer, 2 7 Wright, David, 247 Wright, Robert, 314 Wright, Scwall, 238 Yates, Eugene, 86, 264-66, 308, 313 Yellowstone National Park, 187-88, 204, 243 Yockey, Hubert, 2 2 Zermelo, Ernst, 57, 67 Zeroth law o f thermodynamics, 9 0 Zhabotinsky, Anatol M., 9 6 zooplankton, 101, 191, 194, 195, 212 Zotin, Alexander, 209, 254-55, 2 55