127 64 3MB
English Pages 133 [155] Year 2020
TEFLIN TEACHER DEVELOPMENT SERIES Series Editors: Willy A Renandya & Nur Hayati
TEFLIN Teacher Development Series contains short practical resource booklets for English language teachers in Asia published by TEFLIN (The Association for the Teaching of English as a Foreign Language in Indonesia) through its Publication Division. Titles in the series (2020) include: Introducing Task-based Language Teaching by Rod Ellis Evaluating, Adapting and Developing Materials for Learners of English as an International Language by Brian Tomlinson Cooperative Learning in Language Education by George M Jacobs & Willy A Renandya Teaching Pragmatics in EFL Classrooms by Nguyen Thi Thuy Minh & Le Van Canh Implementing a Text-based Approach in English Language Teaching by Helena Agustien Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms edited by Flora Debora Floris & Willy A Renandya Feedback in L2 Writing Classrooms by Icy Lee Instructed SLA: A Practical Guide for Teachers by Eun Sung Park
If you have any queries, please contact: TEFLIN Publication Division Email: [email protected]
Copyright © 2020 TEFLIN Publication Division in collaboration with Bintang Sejahtera Press c/o Jurusan Sastra Inggris, Fakultas Sastra, Universitas Negeri Malang Jalan Semarang 5 Malang, East Java, Indonesia, 65145 http://www.journal.teflin.org
ISBN: 978-602-1150-41-2
First published 2020 Book Illustrator: Stefany Christiana Dewi Cover Designer: Himawan Prakosa Formatting: Ibnuz Zaki
INSPIRATIONAL STORIES FROM ENGLISH LANGUAGE CLASSROOMS
Edited by Flora Debora Floris & Willy A Renandya
TEFLIN Teacher Development Series published by TEFLIN Publication Division
Teacher training aims to equip teachers with basic knowledge and skills. But to achieve depth, maturity and teacher wisdom, we need the additional catalyst of lived experience. This book offers teachers just that – a rich resource of other teachers’ stories to activate reflection on their own teaching values and practices. This will be a must for teacher development groups and for individual teachers to reflect on too. (Prof. Alan Maley – The C Group, UK)
Through meticulous editing, this volume Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms offers a fascinating collection of 40 stories and classroom activities written by English teachers from 20 countries. As part of TEFLIN series, this book has been especially prepared for those who wish to use stories as motivating and engaging teaching stimuli for a wide range of institutional contexts. This book will be particularly useful for English teachers, trainees, and curriculum or materials developers. The professional expertise of the editors has enriched the book content, ensured by the association, TEFLIN. (Prof. Utami Widiati, M.A., Ph.D – State University of Malang, Indonesia)
I
t is a great pleasure for TEFLIN to publish this Teacher Development Series, a series which provides useful and affordable resources for English language teachers and teacher educators in Asia. The booklets in the series cover various topics pertaining to ELT and are written by experts in the field. Teachers and teacher educators will enjoy reading the series as the booklets are written in a friendly and accessible style. Throughout more than sixty years of TEFLIN, we have shown our full commitment towards teacher training and education and teacher professional development in the field of ELT by means of various programs. We have organized conferences and academic forums for English language teachers both nationally and internationally, and collaborated with different organizations to provide support for teachers in developing their professionalism, such as, by giving scholarships to attend conferences and conducting teacher training. Through the TEFLIN Publication Division, we have published volumes of the TEFLIN Journal, a peer-reviewed journal indexed in Scopus and fully accredited with an “A” rating by the Indonesian Ministry of Research and Higher Education. The journal contains both research and concept papers in the field of ELT. This TEFLIN Teacher Development Series is another project of the division and is yet another form of our commitment to giving continued support to the development of English language teaching in Indonesia and in the wider region. This year we are aiming to launch five books of the series, and are committed to publishing more titles in the following years to support teachers’ sustainable professional development. We are indebted to Dr. Willy A Renandya for sharing with us his brilliant ideas and for giving his utmost effort and lending his expertise to this project. Without his capacity and networking, this project would not be possible. We also
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms iii
Teacher Development Series
a
gratefully thank all the experts who have contributed to the series. Their contribution is invaluable. We hope this series will serve its purpose, to empower English teachers and facilitate their professional development through quality and accessible resources.
Joko Nurkamto
Yazid Basthomi
President of TEFLIN
Coordinator of TEFLIN Publication Division
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms iv
’
T
he TEFLIN Teacher Development Series is a series of short practical resource booklets for English language teachers in Asia as part of a collaborative project with the Publication Division of TEFLIN (The Association for the Teaching of English as a Foreign Language in Indonesia). The booklets (or modules) are intended to be used by teachers (both pre-service and in-service) and teacher educators as a learning resource and as the basis for organizing workshops, in-service courses and various other purposes of teaching and learning and teacher professional development. The booklets in the Series are written in an accessible and teacher-friendly style and cover both principles and techniques and include different topics relevant to ELT and teacher professional development. Each booklet contains practical ways for teachers to apply new ideas in their own teaching as well as reflective tasks that provide opportunities for the users to reflect on their own classroom practices. For the second batch of the series, we have had a great honor and pleasure to work with experts in various areas of ELT. One of them is Flora Debora Floris, a productive young scholar in the field, who generously shares her knowledge and expertise in editing and also contributing her own story to this great collection of inspirational stories from English language classrooms. We extend our utmost gratitude to Flora Debora Floris as well as other experts for helping make this project happen. We are committed to publishing more quality booklets in the coming years in order to meet the needs of English teachers and teacher educators in Asia. We hope to collaborate with many more experts in various areas of ELT and bring out booklets that are affordable and beneficial for the development of ELT and teacher professionalism particularly in the Asian region. Willy A Renandya Nur Hayati Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms v
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms is a collection of inspirational stories contributed by language teachers working in a wide range of contexts in different parts of the world. The book is part of TEFLIN Teacher Development Series, a collaborative project with the Publication Division of TEFLIN (The Association for the Teaching of English as a Foreign Language in Indonesia). This book is for English teachers, trainees, scholars, administrators, as well as policy makers who are interested in motivating and empowering their students through short-stories. This book also serves as a resource book for pre-service teachers who are doing their micro-teaching/practicum or pursuing their higher degree education. The book contains classroom stories and suggested teaching/learning activities that can be used in language classrooms, teacher training and teacher professional development programs for pedagogical purposes. The stories brought by 44 contributors from 20 different countries in Asia and beyond are based on their authentic teaching experiences; and the suggested classroom activities presented in this book can be used as a model on how these stories might be used to enhance language learning and teacher learning. This book originated from a simple idea, i.e., we love telling stories. We become story tellers and story listeners since young. Narrative conventions such as folk tales, novels, films, the story of one’s life, or family stories around the dinner table have always enchanted and fascinated children as well as adults. Throughout the history of mankind, storytelling has been one of our most innate and fundamental communication forms. Geoffrey Berwind, a professional storytelling consultant believes that “stories powerfully connect us to our listeners” (in Duncan, 2014, par. 6). Stories build relationships and are very powerful “for reducing the distance among teachers, self, and peers” (Ling-Chen, 1992, p. 970). Furthermore, sharing one’s real-life stories enables our interlocutors to “feel that they get to know us as authentic people” (Berwind in Duncan, 2014, par. 6). Stories bring out genuine human connection which is a fundamental element in any human interaction. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms vi
Teacher Development Series
a
For the past decades, studies have shown the benefits of the use of stories as a powerful pedagogical instrument from pre-school through to university level classrooms. Stories help language learners develop the four language skills of speaking, listening, reading and writing and activate their thinking skill (McRae, 1991). “Stories allow instructors to teach the four language skills to all levels of language proficiency and can enhance ELT courses for learners if selected and exploited appropriately” (Murdoch, 2002, p. 9). Wajnryb (2003) argues that the content and meaning of stories have impact in engaging learners in their learning process and developing their target language skills. Similarly, Wright (in Floris, 2016, p. 112) states “above all stories offer the language learner an opportunity of experiencing language rather than studying it”. In addition, other positive values which are embedded in stories “can contribute a great deal to the socio-cultural, emotional, cognitive and personal growth of EFL learners” (Pathan, 2013, p. 21). Our real teaching experiences are stories that may appeal to many students and teachers as what we have experienced might be relevant and familiar to the listeners or readers. Our stories therefore have the potential to be used as an instrument to develop students’ language proficiency and also to help us become more reflective practitioners. This book is divided into 5 sections and 40 chapters. As you read the stories in this book, consider how you might adopt—or adapt—the experience and the insight that these texts convey for both you and your students. We hope that this book will inspire you to develop and use your own story as a catalyst or a springboard for teaching language skills.
References: • Duncan, R. (2014) Tap the power of storytelling. Retrieved 1 November 2018 from http://www.forbes.com/sites/rodgerdeanduncan/2014/01/04/tap-thepower-of-storytelling/#74f8abf614ab • Floris, F. D. (2016) Because everyone has a story to tell: Interview with Andrew Wright. RELC, 47(1), 111- 114. • Ling-Chen, Pu (1992) Storytelling in the language classroom. Far East Journal, 20(4), 967-971. • McRae, J. (1991). Literature with a small 'l'. London: Macmillan Education. • Murdoch, G. (2002). Exploiting well-known short stories for language skills development. IATEFL LCS SIG Newsletter, 23, 9-17.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms vii
Teacher Development Series
a
• Pathan, M. M. (2013). Use of short-stories in EFL classroom: Advantages and implications. An International Refereed Journal of Postmodern Studies, 4(2), 21-26. • Wajnryb, R. (2003). Stories: Narrative activities in the language classroom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms viii
W
e would like to acknowledge the help of all the people involved in this book project.
First of all, we are highly indebted to each one of the book authors for their excellent contributions. Without their contributions, this book would not have become a reality. We also wish to acknowledge the valuable support provided by the Publication Division of TEFLIN (The Association for the Teaching of English as a Foreign Language in Indonesia) regarding the improvement of the quality and the publication of chapters. We really appreciate it. Our thanks and appreciations also go to our colleagues who have willingly helped us out in developing the project such as sharing our Call for Chapters or submitting their proposals. We would like to extend our sincere thanks to all of them. Finally, our acknowledgement would be incomplete without thanking our families who have provided their unwavering love and encouragement at all times. Their support was worth more than we can express on paper.
Flora Debora Floris Willy Ardian Renandya
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms ix
Andriyani Marentek is a lecturer at Universitas Sam Ratulangi, ManadoIndonesia. She teaches English and ELT subjects to both undergraduates and post-graduates and does research in the field of Applied Linguistics. Beatrix Burghardt, a native of Hungary, teaches second language studies at Indiana University Bloomington. She has extensive experience teaching general and academic ESL courses and training language teachers. Benjamin Luke Moorhouse is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Education Studies at Hong Kong Baptist University. He promotes learner choice in his courses and publications. Cherie Brown is an Assistant Professor at Akita International University, Japan. She is co-author of resource books, academic articles and co-winner of NZ’s International Excellence in Tertiary Teaching Award. Cherie researches teacher development, vocabulary and classroom collaboration. Clay Williams is an associate professor at Akita International University, where he teaches in a graduate-level English language teacher training program and researches cross-linguistic word identification process development. Curtis Kelly has developed learner-centered approaches for students with low ability, low confidence, and low motivation. He has written over 30 books and made over 300 presentations on adult education, motivation, brain science, and teaching writing. Daniel Dusza is a teacher/researcher living and studying in Japan. His research examines orthographic influences on learning English in Japan. Telling and writing stories are his inseparable partners. Dang Arif Hartono teaches English and academic writing at Podomoro University. He earned his M.A. in TESOL from Michigan State University. Dat Bao is a senior lecturer in Monash University. His latest book (related to task design) is Creativity and Innovations in ELT Material Development: Looking beyond the Current Design (2018). Erina M. Hunt teaches at Otago University, New Zealand. She is co-recipient of an Education NZ International Excellence Award and has experience in
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms x
Teacher Development Series
a
journalism, bi-literacy, teacher training, curriculum development, resource writing and multi-media education. Flora Debora Floris is a senior lecturer at Petra Christian University, Indonesia. Her main interests include language teacher professional development, teaching English as an International Language, and technology-enhanced language learning. Francisco Perlas Dumanig is an Assistant Professor at the English Department, University of Hawaii at Hilo, Hawaii, USA. His research interests are in TESL, World Englishes and Discourse Analysis. George E. K. Whitehead is an assistant professor in the Graduate School of TESOL at Hankuk University of Foreign Studies, South Korea. His main research interests include language teacher education and development, language teacher leadership, critical second language pedagogy, and the development of context-specific language teaching and learning practices. George Jacobs has authored many publications on education and other social change topics. Many of these publications can be read at http:// georgejacobs.net. Grant Eckstein is an assistant professor of Linguistics at Brigham Young University. He teaches graduate courses in ESL teaching and L2 language skills. He researches L2 writing, pedagogy, and curriculum. Hanna Juliaty is a lecturer at the Department of English, Universitas Kristen Krida Wacana, Jakarta. Her passions include language teaching, writing and conducting research. In her free time, she also enjoys working with children. John Sivell is an emeritus professor of Applied Linguistics at Brock University (Canada). He has taught EFL, ESL and TESL Methodology in Canada, Europe, the Middle East, and Asia. Malu Sciamarelli has been a teacher and teacher trainer since 1993. Currently, she is the coordinator of The C Group and a graduate student at the University of Oxford. María D. García-Pastor is Professor in TEFL at the University of Valencia. Her research interests are within TEFL and SLTE with a focus on learner and teacher identity and foreign language anxiety. Maria Heron is a practising teacher and teacher trainer with 30 years’ experience. She is a Senior Trainer at NILE in the UK and a member of the Creativity Group.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xi
Teacher Development Series
a
Maya Khemlani David is an Honorary Professor of the Asia-Europe Institute, university of Malaya, Malaysia. She has special interest in discourse analysis and minority languages. Moonyoung Park is an Assistant Professor in the Faculty of Education at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. His research has focused on aviation English, CALL, TBLT, and teacher education. Nguyen Thi Thuy Loan is an English lecturer at Kalasin University, Thailand. Her research interests include genre-analysis, English written-discourse, second language writing instruction and research, citations and reporting verbs. Paul Hullah has authored EFL materials, poetry, and literary criticism. He received the 2013 Asia-Pacific LIP Award for Paramount Contribution to the Education of Students in Asia. Péter Medgyes is Professor Emeritus of Applied Linguistics and Language Pedagogy. He was a plenary speaker in over fifty countries and author of numerous books and papers. Phil Chappell is a language teacher educator and Applied Linguistics and TESOL researcher at Macquarie University, Australia. He spent many years teaching and managing English language programs in Southeast Asia. Radhika De Silva is senior lecturer in the Department of Language Studies at the Open University of Sri Lanka. She obtained her PhD in language education from University of Reading, UK. Her research interests include writing strategy instruction, language testing, open and distance learning, and teacher education Richard W. Hallett is a professor of linguistics at Northeastern Illinois University in Chicago. His areas of specialization include second language acquisition, world Englishes, and the discourse of tourism. Rob Waring is an acknowledged expert in Extensive Reading and second language vocabulary acquisition. He is an Executive Board member of the Extensive Reading Foundation. Sakae Onoda is a certified Oxford Teachers’ Academy trainer and frequently conducts seminars with secondary school teachers. His research addresses English teacher education, speaking fluency development, and self-regulated language learning. Shakina Rajendram is a lecturer at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto, Canada. Her teaching and research focus on supporting multilingual learners through translanguaging and multiliteracies pedagogies. Sharlene G. Gotico teaches English and media arts at Central Philippine University, Iloilo, Philippines. She taught Tagalog at Stanford University as a Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xii
Teacher Development Series
a
Fulbright Fellow and English at Korea University of Media Arts as an exchange professor. Soe Marlar Lwin teaches courses on discourse analysis and TESOL Methods in the undergraduate and postgraduate applied linguistics programmes. Her research interests include Asian folktales and the use of stories/storytelling for language teaching. Spenser Edward Lemaich has worked in ELT in Indonesia since 2010. His research interests relate to culture instruction in the language classroom, non-nativespeaker teachers, and the use of learners’ mother-tongue in class. Stefanus Angga B. Prima is currently teaching at Podomoro University, Jakarta. With Fulbright scholarship, he obtained his M.A. in TESL from Minnesota State University, Mankato. He has been teaching EFL classes since 2008. Stephen J. Hall is Professor and Head, Centre for English Language Studies, Sunway University, Malaysia. He has been involved in TESOL for over 40 years and is passionate about teaching and learning in this digital time, as an ongoing learner. Susi Pearson has been a teacher and teacher trainer for over 20 years, working in both the UK and abroad. She is currently a Senior Trainer at NILE, Norwich, UK. Theresa Tan has been teaching in the primary level in Singapore since 2000. She is passionate about children’s literature and early literacy. She also believes in the magic of stories. Thi Ngoc Yen Dang obtained her PhD from Victoria University of Wellington and is a Lecturer at University of Leeds. Her research interests include vocabulary, corpus linguistics, and English for Academic/Specific Purposes. Weiyu Zhang is a Ph.D. candidate in applied linguistics at Nanyang Technological University (NTU), Singapore. She has many years of experience in teaching English as a foreign language at university level. Willy Ardian Renandya is an experienced language teacher educator currently teaching at the National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. He maintains an active language teacher professional development forum called ELT in Asia and Beyond (https://www.facebook.com/groups/ELTAsia) Yin Ling Cheung is Associate Dean, Outreach and Engagement at the National Institute of Education, NTU. She is an applied linguist who specializes in academic writing and writing instruction.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xiii
Teacher Development Series
a
Yu-Hsiu Liu received her Ph.D. from The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA. She is an assistant professor in the Department of Foreign Languages and Literature at Huafan University in Taiwan. Zinonos Vasiliki is a PhD holder in Curriculum and Instruction with specialization in ESL. She currently works as an EAP and Language Teacher to BA & MA international students at the University of Sheffield UK. She also works as MA TESOL supervisor and her research interests revolve around ESL listening comprehension, EAP and ESL teaching methodologies and ESL proofreading.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xiv
Foreword from the Publisher ................................................................................ iii Series Editors’ Preface ............................................................................................ v Notes from the Book Editors ................................................................................. vi Acknowledgments ................................................................................................. ix Contributors ............................................................................................................. x Table of Contents ...................................................................................................xv SECTION 1 Becoming a Professional English Teacher CHAPTER 1
You are the Professional .............................................................. 1 Péter Medgyes
CHAPTER 2
Standing at the Crossroads: Teacher Dilemmas......................... 5 Clay Williams
CHAPTER 3
The Makings of a Language Teacher .......................................... 8 George E.K. Whitehead
CHAPTER 4
A Life-Changing Experience: Ornela’s Story ............................. 10 Maria Heron & Susi Pearson
CHAPTER 5
When in Rome, Do as the Romans Do ..................................... 13 Nguyen Thi Thuy Loan
CHAPTER 6
Life is Like a Box of Chocolate ................................................... 17 Weiyu Zhang & Yin Ling Cheung
CHAPTER 7
My Way is not the Only Way ..................................................... 20 Yu-Hsiu Liu
SECTION 2 Building Rapport CHAPTER 8
I Love My Family and Friends.................................................... 22 Sharlene G. Gotico
CHAPTER 9
Do Not Let Your Circumstances Change Who You Are ............ 26 Daniel George Dusza Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xv
Teacher Development Series
a
CHAPTER 10 Do Not Jump into Conclusion ................................................... 30 Andriyani Marentek CHAPTER 11 I Can Make a Difference ............................................................ 33 Willy Ardian Renandya & Flora Debora Floris CHAPTER 12 The Power of Language ............................................................. 37 Maya Khemlani David & Francisco P. Dumanig CHAPTER 13 Keep Reading ............................................................................. 40 Theresa Tan CHAPTER 14 Do Not Let Others Bring You Down .......................................... 43 Zinonos Vasiliki CHAPTER 15 Little Things Go a Long Way ...................................................... 47 Radhika De Silva SECTION 3 Learning from Others’ Culture CHAPTER 16 Holding up a Mirror to International ESL Student-Teachers ... 52 Beatrix Burghardt CHAPTER 17 Intercultural Understanding: Inspiration from a Pet Sound .... 55 Dat Bao CHAPTER 18 Changing Perspective ................................................................ 59 Hanna Juliaty CHAPTER 19 Sharing the Joy of Literature ..................................................... 62 John Sivell CHAPTER 20 Courage (My Quiet Star) ........................................................... 65 Paul Hullah CHAPTER 21 Student to the Rescue: Teaching Vocabulary with Care .......... 68 Phil Chappell CHAPTER 22 Critical Teaching Reflection on the “N-Word”.......................... 72 Richard W. Hallett CHAPTER 23 Positioning Students as Language Experts through Multilingual Storytelling Activities ............................................ 75 Shakina Rajendram CHAPTER 24 In Our Country ........................................................................... 79 Soe Marlar Lwin CHAPTER 25 Easy for Teacher, but Not for Students ..................................... 82 Spenser Edward Lemaich Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xvi
Teacher Development Series
a
SECTION 4 Engaging Students in Meaningful Activities CHAPTER 26 Practice before Speed ............................................................... 86 Grant Eckstein CHAPTER 27 My Students Always Sigh when I Assign Homework ............... 90 Benjamin Moorhouse CHAPTER 28 Facing Disruptive Behaviour ..................................................... 93 María D. García-Pastor CHAPTER 29 Impassioning Reluctant Writers ................................................ 96 Erina M. Hunt CHAPTER 30 Why don't You Like That Task? .................................................. 99 Thi Ngoc Yen Dang CHAPTER 31 The Most Important Homework of the Year .......................... 101 Rob Waring CHAPTER 32 Fake It till You Make It ............................................................. 104 Cherie J. Brown CHAPTER 33 Speak Up .................................................................................. 107 Stefanus Angga B. Prima & Dang Arif Hartono CHAPTER 34 Understanding Learners’ Innermost Feelings ........................ 110 Sakae Onoda CHAPTER 35 Yes, You can Doodle................................................................. 113 Malu Sciamarelli CHAPTER 36 Facing Up to Your Digital Footprint......................................... 117 Stephen J. Hall CHAPTER 37 Time to Rethink Our Use of Technology in the Classroom .... 120 Moonyoung Park Section 5 Going Beyond the Classroom CHAPTER 38 Shakespeare and Stereotypes................................................. 124 Cherie J. Brown CHAPTER 39 Why Is It So Hard To Say “Thank You”?................................... 127 George M. Jacobs CHAPTER 40 Seeing through Different Eyes ................................................ 131 Curtis Kelly
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms xvii
Becoming a Professional English Teacher
CHAPTER ONE YOU ARE THE PROFESSIONAL Péter Medgyes Eötvös Loránd University Budapest, Hungary
My career as a teacher of English began in the late 1960s at a secondary school in Budapest. Since I found the one and only compulsory course book terribly boring, I supplemented it with Geoffrey Broughton’s Success with English, a much more inspiring and entertaining series. With time, I sent the compulsory book to the top shelf to gather dust, and Broughton became our staple food. One day an elderly colleague warned me that my unlawful practice had come to the knowledge of ministry officials and, as a consequence, I might have to face disciplinary measures. After some hesitation, I decided to go to the school principal and make a clean breast of my disobedience. After listening to my report, he asked, “Are you sure that that British book is better than the compulsory one?” “Much better,” I replied. “Well, you’re the professional, Péter. It’s your responsibility to decide what works best for your students – and not mine. So feel free to use the book of your choice.” “But…but what about the ministry?” I stammered. “That’s my responsibility. I’ll deal with it, if necessary.” Whether it was necessary or not, I have never found out. However, emboldened by my principal’s support I continued to teach from Broughton and other excellent books for many more years. And most of my students graduated from secondary school with flying colors in English.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 1
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To consider the limits of professional freedom. 2. To draw attention to the close relationship between responsibility, professionalism and decision-making. 3. To reflect upon the advantages and disadvantages of homegrown versus imported course materials.
Procedure: 1. In your country, are teachers obliged to use compulsory course books? If they are, what happens to the teacher who decides to get round this law? 2. What do you think of my ‘rebellious behavior’? Do you agree or disagree with it? Why? Argue for and against in small groups. 3. Suppose you were my school principal, how would you respond to my report? “I would: a. downright forbid you to use any book other than the compulsory one in the future. b. insist that you use the compulsory book as the main course material, but permit you to supplement it from ‘illicit’ sources. c. warn you that you should face the consequences if you were caught adopting this illegal practice. d. encourage you to break this ‘stupid’ law. e. do as your principal did. Having considered the alternatives, choose the one with which you agree most and the one that you would certainly reject. Perhaps you have some other option? Discuss your choice in small groups and then report back to the whole group. 4. The compulsory book I referred to had been written by Hungarian authors whereas my preferred book by a British author. In your experience, are imported books generally better than homegrown ones? Jot down the pros and cons of both options. There will be two teams facing each other: the members in Team A are in favor of imported books, whereas Team B rather supports homegrown materials. Join the team whose opinion you find closer to yours. Members can voice their views at any point in the course of the debate.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 2
Teacher Development Series
a
5. My school principal used three words: professional(ism), responsibility and decision-making. How would you define these words in a teaching context? In what way do you think they are linked? Discuss with a partner and then report back to the whole group.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 3
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: With hindsight, I realize that my principal let me use the book I thought was better, because he trusted my professional judgment. His advice and support strengthened my self-confidence and filled me with an overwhelming sense of freedom. However, it also made me aware that freedom comes with a price: once you are granted full rein, the burden of responsibility can no longer be shared – it is on your shoulders alone. I often wonder how I would have responded if my school principal had been less permissive and less trustful. The more I think about it the more I am convinced that I would have left the classroom a long time ago and chosen a profession offering me more breathing space. As a teacher and teacher trainer for many years, I have endeavored to pass on the message I learnt as a young teacher: only free-spirited and responsible teachers are capable of turning young people into free-spirited and responsible citizens. This is what I mean by empowerment.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 4
CHAPTER TWO STANDING AT THE CROSSROADS: TEACHER DILEMMAS Clay Williams Akita International University, Japan
The young teacher’s cheeks burned with righteous indignation as the scope of the problem became clear. Mr. Smith had just realized that nearly three quarters of the class were complicit in a sophisticated cheating scheme. Thoughts of retaliatory possibilities filled his head. Stop! Breathe! In… Out… The signs were there, but why? What had caused so many students to resort to malfeasance? At this moment, Mr. Smith stood at a crossroads that all teachers will arrive at from time to time. Is it more important to take swift disciplinary action or to identify the root cause of the widespread cheating in order to intervene by giving students the skills to avoid the temptation to cheat in the future? While a responsible case could be built for either option, Mr. Smith decided to choose the second one. Over the next two weeks, he conducted interviews and one-on-one examinations with the learners in his class, and to his surprise, he determined that the core issue that his university students were struggling with was an almost complete lack of English word decoding skills which had made his written exams nearly impossible for most of the students to decipher. While he was aware that this class already had a reputation for being difficult and poor students of English, he was amazed and chagrined by the revelation that, despite lacking such foundational skills, the students had been passed along from one teacher to the next. Instead of confronting the problem by reviewing basic reading skills, one teacher after another had simply tagged them with the label of “poor learners.” Mr. Smith stood at another crossroad. This cycle stops here! Mr. Smith resolved that his students would finally receive the remedial literacy instruction they had been deprived of for so many years.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 5
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: To develop awareness of the impact of situational ethics in the teaching dilemmas, including: 1. The interplay between classroom management (i.e., discipline) and pedagogical effectiveness. 2. The factors impacting the extent to which curricular reform and pedagogical interventions can be undertaken as necessary (e.g., how much class time can be dedicated to filling in learning gaps if the class is legally mandated to cover a certain amount of material within the term).
Procedure: 1. Have the students read the story aloud in class and discuss: a. Have you ever been at a “teaching crossroads” as a teacher/learner? What was the situation? How was it resolved? b. In such a scenario of wide-spread cheating, when would it be more important to take disciplinary action, and when would it be incumbent upon the teacher to focus more on root causes and pedagogical intervention? Is there a clear divide between the two responses? c. What would have been the probable results if Mr. Smith had taken disciplinary action instead of the action he chose? How do you think this impacted his decision? d. Once the underlying problem of poor literacy skills was exposed, Mr. Smith was at “another crossroad.” Why would it possibly be a difficult decision to embark on a corrective teaching plan to review and reteach skills that should have been mastered by students long before? • How do you think Mr. Smith’s decision impacted his syllabus and schedule? • How do you think students who were already competent readers might have reacted to Mr. Smith’s change in focus? • Can you think of any problems which Mr. Smith might face at an administrative or departmental level in implementing his corrective course of action? 2. As a homework, have the students devise a 1 month teaching plan (with two 75 minute periods per week) featuring an intervention of the sort in the story (i.e., teaching a basic skill in the context of a more advanced class). Make sure to try to balance the needs of high and low skill learners, as well as to not delay the basic pace of normal activities in your class while still attempting to introduce and reinforce the basic skill. Try to be creative in Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 6
Teacher Development Series
a
combining new and old skills. You can use lesson plans from your in-service class, if applicable.
Reflection: The teaching profession is replete with difficult decisions over what to do in response to specific problems. While most of us would like to say that beneficial learner development is the first and last consideration impacting our pedagogical choices, all too often, our options are complicated by a host of other factors, such as time and resource availability. In the above story, Mr. Smith is faced with the question of how to respond to widespread cheating in his class. While he would have been justified in disciplining students for the academic infraction, in-so-doing, he would have never realized the learning deficit which afflicted his students. Still, diagnosing the problem, as well as any attempt at remediation, would entail substantial sacrifice from Mr. Smith as measured by time and other resources invested, and might create more problems down the road. This problem of balancing conflicting aims while confronting teaching dilemmas is a familiar problem to practicing educators. The classroom discussion and homework in this section are designed to initiate reflection by teachers-intraining, leading then to formulate their own philosophies regarding how to handle such teaching dilemmas in the face of competing classroom and life priorities.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 7
CHAPTER THREE THE MAKINGS OF A LANGUAGE TEACHER George E.K. Whitehead Hankuk University of Foreign Studies, South Korea When I was 21 years old, the career path I was on took a significant turn. I was in my second year of college in pursuit of a degree in Kinesiology; a major that I had chosen because of future earning potential in the field. Feeling stressed out about my studies, I decided to take a trip to Japan during the winter break to visit my uncle and clear my head. I never knew how much that 3-month stay with him would affect my life. His 500-year-old house was located amidst beautiful green tea fields in the mountains just outside of Tokyo. The house did not have internet or cable and was heated by kerosene heaters (which I feared was either going to burn the house down or poison me in my sleep). My uncle had been in Japan for many years working as a textile artist as well as an English teacher in his own small one-room school next to his house. About a month into my stay I was already running low on money. It was then that my uncle suggested earning some extra cash by taking on some of his English classes with local residents during the evenings. I agreed. I remember the first day of teaching. My uncle walked me to class, quickly introduced me to the students, handed me a book, and left. I stood there blankly staring at four elderly women as they eagerly stared back at me. I remember being at a complete loss about what to do and how to start the lesson. It was then that one of the ladies shyly smiled at me and said, “Would you like some tea?” This broke the ice and was followed by an hour of casual questioning from the four ladies who were very curious about me and my background. From this class on, my life would never be the same. We met together for an hour every evening for two months learning and laughing, while at the same time building lifelong memories and positive relationships. That is what made me fall in love with teaching language: the interaction with wonderful people, and the bridging of cultures, backgrounds, age groups, and understandings. The experience impacted me so strongly that I changed my major from Kinesiology to Linguistics when I returned to Canada. Having been in the language teaching field for nearly 20 years now, I can honestly say that the reasons why I initially fell in love with language teaching continue to drive me today. What drives you? Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 8
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop and foster self-awareness of career choice. 2. To develop personal narrative writing skills.
Procedure: 1. Have the students read the story. 2. Ask the students to interview 2 or more of their peers and write down what/ who influenced their choice to become a language teacher. 3. Ask the students to watch the TED Talk “How Great Leaders Inspire Action” by Simon Sinek (especially the first 6 minutes focusing on the golden circle). 4. Discuss the video with students, ensuring they have a clear understanding of the Why, How, and What. 5. Discuss with them how this relates to career choice and job satisfaction. 6. Get the students to think and write down their ‘Why’ in relation to becoming a language teacher. 7. Wrap up the class by discussing important things to consider other than money when choosing a career. 8. Explain to the students that the ‘Why’ writing reflection is something that they can reflect on and revise throughout their careers.
Reflection: Many people these days work in jobs that they really don’t like. Some even dread waking up in the morning to go to work. This is often because the job they are doing does not align with their own passion or personal interests. By stepping back and reassessing one’s career or future career, one may be able to find deeper fulfillment in their job or discover alternate routes that lead to a more personally rewarding occupation.
Reference: • Sinek, S. (2011). Start with why: How great leaders inspire everyone to take action. London: Penguin.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 9
CHAPTER FOUR A LIFE-CHANGING EXPERIENCE: ORNELA’S STORY Maria Heron Norwich Institute for Language Education, UK Susi Pearson Norwich Institute for Language Education, UK Ornela was a young primary teacher from Chile who came to our institution in the cold winter of 2018. She was sent to the UK for five weeks to improve her English and to learn how to teach her subjects in English. She was practically a complete beginner when she arrived. Ornela was part of a group of sixteen other Chilean subject teachers with a similar level of English. In the first couple of weeks Ornela kept a very low profile in the classroom. She was a willing participant in pair and group work but was usually very reliant on her partner, never said anything in open class feedback and she looked frightened and worried despite our best efforts to create a safe and comfortable environment in the classroom and encourage everyone to contribute. Suddenly in the fourth week, Ornela started to change. She was more forthcoming, making a real effort to communicate her thoughts and feelings in the class, and managing to share some simple but moving experiences of her, both as a person and as a young teacher. Ornela told us that her time with us had been a complex and challenging experience and as a result, she became a different person and a different professional. She felt she had gained in confidence, stopped being afraid of making a fool of herself, improved her vocabulary considerably and was motivated to continue to learn and develop. When asked what had caused this change in her, she said it had been the warm atmosphere in the classroom, the engaging lessons, the patience and understanding that her teachers had shown and their commitment to education. Ornela hopes to take this experience with her back to her educational community in Chile. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 10
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To raise awareness of how low level students can feel in a classroom. 2. To think of ways to engage and support this kind of learner. 3. To reflect on the use of reading tasks which develop cognitive skills.
Procedure: Pre-text work 1. Ask the trainees: a. How would you feel if you arrived in a country far from home and you didn’t speak the language? b. What issues might you have? c. What strategies you would use to deal with these issues? 2. Elicit/provide an example. 3. Give individual thinking time, then peer sharing and finally whole class feedback in plenary.
Focus on the text 1. The trainees read Ornela’s story and answer these questions: a. In what ways has Ornela changed as a person and a professional as a result of this experience? b. What do you think Ornela meant when she said that her teachers had shown a “commitment to education”? 2. Peer share and then whole class feedback in plenary. 3. Ask the trainees to think about these questions: a. What kind of thinking skills do the questions require? Is there a right/wrong answer? b. What might be the advantages of these kinds of questions following a text? 4. Show Freda Mishan quote: Mishan (2010b, p 357) talks about “the substituting of ‘content-laden’ questions, that is, the classic language teacher wh-questions … and polar questions (such as true-false or multiple-choice options) with questions that stimulate thought processes”.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 11
Teacher Development Series
a
Methodology reflection 1. Divide the trainees into two groups. 2. Each group is required to make a poster to answer the following question: a. Group A: Think about A0 or low A1 learners, what elements would they need to make their learning fun and engaging? b. Group B: Think about A0 or low A1 learners, how can we make these students feel comfortable and supported in the classroom? 3. Each group makes a poster on their topic and presents to other group. This is followed by plenary discussion after each poster where other groups can suggest further ideas, and the teacher feeds in his/her own suggestions. 4. Instead of the presentations, the trainees could do a gallery walk. The trainees are asked to display their posters. In each group, half the trainees stay to explain the posters while the other half walk around and listen (and make notes on the ideas). They then swap roles. At the end, they get back into their groups and discuss which they think were the most effective ideas (for both questions). The teacher then leads a plenary discussion and feeds in his/her own suggestions.
Reflection: Affect is important and key to successful learning. Our story reflects this and we hope that by using this story and the accompanying tasks we will promote reflection on this key aspect of language learning and raise awareness among the trainees of some strategies to promote engagement and offer support to low level learners. As Briony Beaven, teacher trainer, says: “Telling stories of professional experience can be a powerful form of development for teachers and teacher educators. It can help teachers to understand and make more informed decisions about their classroom practices” (2016, par. 1).
References: • Briony Beaven – Teacher Stories. (2016, 11 August). Retrieved on 17/4/18 from http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/article/briony-beaven-teacherstories-0 • Mishan, F. (2010). ‘Withstanding washback: thinking outside the box in materials development’. In B. Tomlinson & H. Masuhara (eds.) Research for materials development in language learning evidence for best practice (pp. 353-368). London: Continuum International Publishing Group. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 12
Teacher Development Series
a
CHAPTER FIVE WHEN IN ROME, DO AS THE ROMANS DO Nguyen Thi Thuy Loan Kalasin University, Thailand
A Vietnamese lecturer of English was assigned to teach a paragraph-writing course to four groups of third-year English-major students at a university in Thailand. Due to their class-time constraint, low-level of English proficiency and unfamiliarity with English writing, the students were required to prepare the lessons in the coursebook and write paragraphs at home, and then submit them to the teacher in the following class. For those who did not do their homework, 1% was deducted from their final summative score, and a zero was given to a late submission. To avoid such punishments, several students in each group kept inventing excuses for their late submission or not completing their homework. Although the teacher patiently reminded them to be more responsible for their study and that using such excuses would not help them progress academically, the students kept using this strategy. This led the teacher to a direct approach to stop them from being lazy by replying “I-don’t-care!” whenever the students resorted to an excuse for not doing their homework. That tactic would work, the teacher thought, as she didn’t hear any excuses from her students since then. Appallingly, however, she was dismayed at the end of the course on receiving the result of the students’ evaluation on her performance. It said that she did not understand Thai cultures, and she was rude and heartless saying those bold words to their faces, and those proved that she did not meet a certain code of ethics for teachers in Thailand; she should not be allowed to teach in Thailand.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 13
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To raise awareness of different socio-cultural expectations. 2. To get prepared for possible socio-cultural differences.
Procedure: Warm-up activities 1. Have the students think of any difficulties/problems they may have if they work as a teacher in another country and then share them with friends in class. 2. The teacher then chooses the suggested difficulties/problems related to socio-cultural differences and ask the students to think of specific ways to deal with them.
Main activities 1. Have the students read the story carefully and discuss the following questions: a. Was the teacher in the story unqualified as claimed by the students? Why/Why not? b. Do you think the teacher was rude to her students? c. What should the teacher have said to stop her students from justifying for their laziness instead of “I-don’t-care”? d. If you were the teacher in the story, what would you do to make your students serious about their study? e. In your opinion, what made this teacher choose to say that to her students? f. What do you think her students expect her to say in that case? g. Why did these students quietly hold grudges against their teacher rather than letting her know that these words didn’t sound right to them? h. What should this teacher have prepared to function better in Thailand?
Post-activities 1. As homework, the students are asked to choose one foreign country where they would like to work in the future, and then find out about their potential students’ expectations which stem from their own cultures. Then, compare them with those in their own country.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 14
Teacher Development Series
a
2. Make a list of suggestions on what to prepare for students who would like to work as teachers in that foreign country, so they may teach and communicate more effectively with their future students. 3. Search for stories about students’ misunderstanding/mis-interpreting of their foreign teachers’ intended instructions and suggest what to do for each case. 4. Share the stories and suggestions for further recommendations/solutions to the stories.
Reflection: When teachers and students come from different cultures, many perplexities can arise. This could be due to many factors, one of them is that visiting teachers often bring their own teaching-cultures to the host environments. The teacher in this story is a good example for that. Although Thai and Vietnamese educational systems share the large Power-Distance culture in which teachers are highly-respected, and students are expected to be compliant, obedient and deferring to their teachers, subtle differences between these two systems exist. As stated by the Teachers Council of Thailand (Khurusapa, 2005, p. 6), teachers “shall care for, be merciful to” their students, and this client-centered ethics matches with the femininity aspect of Thai cultures which stems from ThaiBuddhist views (Wisadavet, 2003). Accordingly, teachers in Thailand are expected to use soft, gentle and polite words while their Vietnamese counterparts could act as students’ parents to reprimand their children with strong language. Despite being used with a mere-intention of making them more responsible for their study, “I-don’t-care” went against these Thai students’ expectations, and consequently the teacher was considered unqualified. Furthermore, forcing the students to complete every assignment before class tended to contradict the Buddhist-principle of not attaching strongly to things, which is believed to make Thai students quite flexible and pragmatic in their study (Wisadavet, 2003). Conversely, Vietnamese students appreciate their teachers’ orders which benefit their study. This story thus shows the influence of a nation’s culture on students’ learning styles and expectations. To function well in another culture, educators should understand how difference is produced and eliminated within unequal powerrelations because the more they know about cultural differences, the better they are at teaching and communicating with students.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 15
Teacher Development Series
a
References: • Khurusapa. (2005). Regulation of the teachers council of Thailand on professional standards and ethics. Retrieved on 1 December 2018 from http://teachercodes.iiep.unesco.org/teachercodes/codes/Asia/Thailand.pdf • Wisadavet, W. (2003). The Buddhist philosophy of education: Approaches and problems. The Chulalongkorn Journal of Buddhist Studies, 2(2), 1-30
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 16
CHAPTER SIX LIFE IS LIKE A BOX OF CHOCOLATE Weiyu Zhang Nanyang Technological University, Singapore Yin Ling Cheung Nanyang Technological University, Singapore Anne has been teaching English at a university for over six years. As a language learner herself, being proficient in the English language opens many doors for her. She has great enthusiasm for language teaching. She hopes that all her students can master the English language skills and exploit the amazing opportunities they will bring. However, no matter how hard she works to make the lessons relevant and interesting to students, not all of them can achieve satisfactory performance. This makes her feel a lack of accomplishment. She gets a little disheartened and starts to question herself. She considers it a failure that a language teacher cannot help the students improve their language proficiency. The bad feeling of Anne does not last long though. She occasionally receives emails and phone messages from her students to ask for advice, to share feelings, to talk about their life and work experiences. She feels that the students do not just think of her as someone who teaches them English, but someone who can also motivate and help them in other aspects of life. Some students confess that they are still bad in English after the lessons, but they become more motivated and willing to spend more time and effort. Some said that the inspirational language learning stories shared by Anne inspired them to pursue their own interest, not necessarily learning a language. The words from the students make Anne realize that the impacts teachers can make on students are not restricted to the subject they teach. This gives Anne a great sense of accomplishment and motivation to language teaching. It is just like what the quote says, “Life is like a box of chocolate, you never know what you’re going to get.” While you will not always get the flavor you want, you may get some new delights that you did not expect.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 17
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To encourage students to appreciate the different flavors life offers us. 2. To develop students’ speaking and writing skills. 3. To develop students’ ability to produce multimodal texts.
Procedure: 1. Ask students to read the story and discuss the following questions in small groups. This is to exploit the educational and linguistic benefits of the story. a. How do you interpret the quote “Life is like a box of chocolate, you never know what you’re going to get”? Can you think of any alternative interpretation? b. Have you experienced similar situations where you did not get what you wanted but something equally pleasant instead? c. How can this story inspire you or other people? d. Can you think of a similar story that you can share? e. Make a list of useful vocabulary and linguistic structures in the story. Compare the list with your group members and discuss how to make use of them to form new sentences. 2. Ask students to think of one story with a similar theme, either real-life or imaginary, and write it up. The writing product will serve as the script for a digital storytelling project. The story writing will follow the writing process including the following five stages: 1) 2) 3) 4) 5)
Pre-writing: discuss purpose, audience, context, and culture of the story. Drafting: write up the first draft of the story. Revising: revise the story based on teacher- and peer feedback. Editing: correct spelling, grammatical, and punctuation errors. Publishing: share the story using a free online application.
3. Ask students, in pairs or small groups, to come up with a digital storytelling project using free online application such as Storybird or UtellStory. The purpose of the project is to develop students’ digital literacy, which has become increasingly important in modern day communication via digital technologies. Through the project, the students will not only be able to practice speaking, writing, and thinking skills, but also the creation of multimodal text, which is a combination of various modes of communication such as speech, written text, and image. The project will include the following:
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 18
Teacher Development Series
a
a. A workshop for students to learn about the potential digital tools available to complete the project. b. An oral presentation section for students to share their plans of how to integrate multiple modes in telling their stories and to receive feedback from teachers and peers. c. Students creating and editing their stories. d. A session for students to share their final work. Their digital storytelling projects will be evaluated by their teacher and peers.
Reflection: Life may not always turn out the way we expected. We cannot decide what inside the box of chocolate life offers. But we can try to make the best out of it. While Anne’s hard work in teaching does not make her what she considers to be a successful language teacher, she unexpectedly succeeds in becoming an inspirational life tutor. This unexpectedness is part of the beauty of life, and we should learn to appreciate it.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 19
CHAPTER SEVEN MY WAY IS NOT THE ONLY WAY Yu-Hsiu Liu Huafan University, Taiwan Mr. K., a native speaker of English, was a new instructor teaching English to university students in an urban area of Asia. He believed that he had a sense of humor and decided to bring laughter to his class, making learning more fun for his students. In his conversation classes, he would present various topics for class discussion and encourage his students to express their opinions in class. His humorous comments would then follow after the students’ presentation of their ideas. At the end of Mr. K.’s first semester of teaching, he received his students’ written feedback on his teaching. Despite some positive feedback, many students indicated that they, sometimes, didn’t understand his humor. Several students even pointed out having been offended by his jokes. Discouraged and uncertain, Mr. K. told his colleagues about the students’ feedback. He wondered whether he should follow his teaching philosophy, or just make some changes instead. Is it true that his way was not the only way for his students?
Objectives: 1. To build cross-cultural awareness through reading jokes written in English. 2. To develop joke writing skill.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read Mr. K.’s story and then have them discuss the following questions: a. Have you had experiences similar to Mr. K.’s students? b. What are the problems facing Mr. K. and his students?
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 20
Teacher Development Series
a
c. What would you do if you were Mr. K.? d. Is it easy to understand jokes of other cultures? e. What prevents us from understanding and appreciating those jokes? 2. Have the students read a collection of jokes written in English. 3. Form the students into several groups and ask each group to (1) interpret the jokes in their own words, (2) rate the jokes based on funniness and comprehension difficulty, and (3) explore factors preventing them from understanding and appreciating the jokes. 4. Have each group share their discussion results with the class. 5. Explain to the students that humor appreciation is culturally specific and that they need to be aware of the role culture has played in cross-cultural communication. 6. As a homework assignment, have the students write down the best joke they have ever heard or, if they prefer, invent their own jokes in English.
Reflection: The trend of globalization has made it imperative for teachers to help students develop cross-cultural awareness as they interact with citizens outside their community. The “My Way Is Not the Only Way” story timely addresses this need and further shows culture as a shaping force in the way people understand and appreciate humor (Schmitz, 2002). Engaging in discussion and reading activities, students can learn to be respectful of other cultures. The follow-up joke writing and sharing activities help students understand that humor appreciation is subject to individual and cultural differences (Andrew, 2010) and that, in most cases, our way is not the only way.
References: • Andrew, R. (2010). Intercultural communication and the essence of humour.. Journal of the Faculty of International Studies, Utsunomiya University, 29, 2334. • Schmitz, J. R. (2002). Humor as a pedagogical tool in foreign language and translation courses. Humor: International Journal of Humor Research, 15(1), 89-113.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 21
Building Rapport
Teacher Development Series
a
CHAPTER EIGHT I LOVE MY FAMILY AND FRIENDS Sharlene G. Gotico Central Philippine University, Republic of the Philippines
In an English class at a university in South Korea, the teacher, Prof. Anne, asked, “Why do you want to learn English?” Almost two-thirds of the 34 students in class replied about English being useful to them in their future careers. “I will be a flight attendant in an international airline in the future, so I need to speak English to the passengers,” Park Yu Jin said. This was the same answer given by some 15 others. “I am majoring in production design, and I want to work in Hollywood,” was Lee Jin Ju’s answer. Apparently, there were at least five students in class who were majoring in media-related studies - cinematography, photography, broadcasting - and so they had similar answers. They wanted to learn English because working in international media calls for being proficient in the said language. The remaining one-third of the students have plans of studying in Canada, Australia, or the United States either for post-graduate education or short-term enhancement courses. “My dream is to study film in the US,” was Lee Sobin’s eager answer. She’s majoring in production and direction and wants to become an independent filmmaker someday. “I want to take my post-graduate studies in Canada,” Cho Min Hyuk said. One student, Yeo Se Rin, interrupted this eager class discussion by saying, “I am learning English so I can communicate with my younger brother who was adopted by an American family. I miss him.” This declaration silenced the entire class, including Prof. Anne. Suddenly, no other reason for learning English became more important than Yeo Se Rin’s answer.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 22
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness on the value of family relations and friendships. 2. To develop skills in personal correspondence.
Procedure: 1. Prior to the class, each student would be asked to draw their family. Students form pairs and share their output with one another. Some students may be asked to share their work with the whole class. 2. Let students read the story and discuss the following: a. What are the students’ reasons for learning English? What about you? b. What are the students’ future plans? What are your plans for the future? c. What do you think are Yeo Se Rin’s feelings when she spoke about her brother? d. Do you have family members, relatives, or friends whom you have not seen for a long time? Where are they? When was the last time you saw them? e. How do you feel about not seeing them for a long time? Do you miss them? Do you communicate with them? How often do you communicate with them? f. How important is family to you? 3. As a homework, students may be asked to do any one or both of the two activities, depending on the availability of materials/technology, their language ability, or the macro-skill that the teacher wants to develop: a. Option 1: This activity is aimed at developing students’ writing skills. Each one is given a postcard (or an e-card). The task is to write a note (in English) to a relative/friend/loved one who is living abroad. The note may be short, but it should contain what they want to tell the recipient. The note should also allow them to share a little update about their lives. The actual postcard may then be mailed to the recipient. b. Option 2: This activity is aimed at developing students’ speaking skills. Each one will be tasked to create a short video greeting (in English) for a relative/friend/loved one whom they have not seen for a long time. The video may be 30 to 60 seconds long. Students may then be asked to send the actual video to recipient via any social media platform.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 23
Teacher Development Series
a
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 24
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: In almost all cultures, the family is an integral part of an individual’s life. We all value our parents and siblings, and whenever they are away from us, or we have not seen them for a long time, we miss them, and we feel the need to communicate with them. The reading on this lesson reminds us of the value of family and our inherent emotional need to connect with our loved ones. The activities in the lesson, including the discussion questions, are personal in nature and thus encourage students to share about themselves and their relationships with their family and friends. Students tend to be more open to sharing (and therefore use the target language) when topics are about personal experiences and emotions.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 25
CHAPTER NINE DO NOT LET YOUR CIRCUMSTANCES CHANGE WHO YOU ARE (Inspired by The Monk and the Scorpion) Daniel George Dusza Kanda Gaigo Gakuen, Japan
One day, a seasoned teacher was having trouble motivating her students to complete their assignment task, an email exchange. The students were given examples, explicit instructions about writing emails and the marking rubric, and ample supervised practice. However, as the deadline approached, it was evident that many students were only half interested in completing the task. Desperate to remedy the problem, she asked some teachers what they did in previous years. Some said, “Just warn the students they will fail.” Others advised her not to worry because it is only worth 15%. A few suggested lowering the expectation and providing a model for students to follow. Some warned her, “You might get a bad student rating. So, don’t bother yourself.” Not satisfied, the teacher asked her husband for advice. He told her a story about a priest, who was trying to cross a river. While wading waist-deep in the torrent, he noticed a scorpion drowning in the water. He tried to help the scorpion, but each time it would sting his hand. His friend yelled, “Why bother? Let it drown. You’ll only get hurt.” Eventually, however, the priest made it to the other side, and, with his hand swollen from poison, he carefully let the scorpion down. His friend asked, “Why didn’t you just let it drown?” In pain, but still smiling, the priest replied, “It’s my nature to help, and the scorpion’s to sting. We can’t change what we truly are.” The following day, the teacher returned to work and collected the assignments, many were poorly attended to.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 26
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of proactive teaching methods. 2. To develop assessment methods that encourage students’ critical-thinking skills. 3. To develop a framework to promote student self-assessment.
Procedure: Introduction 1. Tell a story of a similar experience from your past, explaining what motivational methods you tried, or wished you knew, at that time. 2. Introduce the main story. 3. Have the class relay-read the story in small-groups. 4. Check for meaning and understanding, asking about a. the characters and their roles, b. the sequence of events in the teacher’s story, and c. the moral of ‘The Priest and the Scorpion.’
Discussion 1. Draw attention to the link between the priest’s story and the teacher’s actions (i.e. her (priest) nature was to try to help the (scorpion) students, regardless of their attitudes or the advice she got from her (priest’s friend) workmates). 2. Ask the groups, to discuss what she did after gathering the assignments. 3. Have the class discuss their pedagogical solutions and write them on posters, or some other collaborative feedback device. 4. Allow the groups to see and discuss each-other’s solutions.
Learning from assessment 1. Introduce the general-concepts and benefits of student self-assessment (refer to Sanchez, et al., 2017). 2. Discuss with the groups, how to teach students to analyze rubrics so they can reflect and give informed and honest self-assessments.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 27
Teacher Development Series
a
3. Explain the importance of the self-assessment and partner’s assessment Likert-grading scale, making connections to the story (i.e. not blaming your partner for their shortcomings). 4. Explain the qualitative feedback section. It requires about 10-minutes to complete. Students may write in their native language. It asks questions like: a. What did you learn about email writing? b. What improvements could be made in the future? c. How do you feel about your effort in this course so far? 5. Explain the importance of students believing that this feedback will help improve this activity for future students. 6. Show some examples of student feedback to the groups and how student performance improved in subsequent assignments.
Reflection: The moral behind the teacher’s story reflects that of the priest’s. Both stories illustrate how many people react adversely to adversity. When we don’t know what to do, who doesn’t succumb to panic, complain, blame, or search for a quick fix? The parable of the priest and the scorpion reminds us that whatever the circumstance, there is always something that is the best thing to do. The resulting action of the teacher was to do the best thing. She designed the self-assessment activity, which transformed the painful task of just receiving a grade, into a collaborative activity that became a valuable student learning experience. The students learned that every action yields a result. Working through the reflection as a group activated not only their meta-linguistic awareness of content and language, but also an awareness of their social and cultural place in the learning community. The supervised self-assessment activity, which stands at the pedagogical core of this story, provides an ideal framework for both task-based and content based learning instruction. It provided adequate opportunity for scaffolding and time to focus on vocabulary and form. Using an online survey device for reflectivefeedback gave students the feeling of autonomy and anonymity. The technology provided a buffer between the teacher and students’ emotions. It also provided information that students and teachers could both use for reflection and corrective actions in the future. The student self-assessment and partner assessment bolstered their appreciation of being part of a learningcommunity, not in assessment-competition.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 28
Teacher Development Series
a
In the end, the best thing to do was inspired by ‘a bit of magic’, namely, a well told story (Spaulding, 2011).
References: • Sanchez, C. E., Atkinson, K. M., Koenka, A. C., Moshontz, H., & Cooper, H. (2017). Self-grading and peer-grading for formative and summative assessments in 3rd through 12th grade classrooms: A meta-analysis. Journal of Educational Psychology, 109(8), 1049. • Spaulding, A. E. (2011). The art of storytelling: Telling truths through telling stories. Lanham, MA: Scarecrow Press.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 29
CHAPTER TEN DO NOT JUMP INTO CONCLUSION Andriyani Marentek Universitas Sam Ratulangi, Indonesia
A second year student, Aditya, came hurriedly into a class where Ms. Morindenga was teaching a written English subject. Worryingly, he said to her, “Good morning, Ma’am. I’m very sorry for being late again, but may I still join the class?” Looking a bit upset, Ms. Morindenga replied, “You have been coming late for three consecutive meetings, Aditya. Last time you said it was because of the traffic jam. The other time it was due to a family problem. I wonder what your excuse will be this time.” With a sad face, he said, “Ma’am, may I talk with you about this later?” Realizing all his classmates were staring at them, she said, “Okay, we need to talk about this after the class. Please have a seat now.” After the class Aditya did see Ms. Morindenga and told her what had actually happened. It turned out that Aditya had a full-time job as a shop attendant in a bookstore. This was due to his single parent/mother, a seamstress, who could not provide for him and his siblings anymore because of her illness. Other families were reluctant to help out; therefore as the oldest child, he felt compelled to find a job. However, his job required him to work full-time, but at the same time he still wanted to continue his study; he promised his father before his passing that he would finish his study and be the first graduate in his family. Upon hearing this, Ms. Morindenga almost burst into tears as she had thought how lazy and indifferent Aditya had been and had prepared for some discipline towards him; she had jumped into conclusion about him. Since then, Ms. Morindenga had become more lenient towards Aditya and even tried to talk with his employer to give him more time to be more focused on his study.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 30
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To cultivate empathy towards others; 2. To promote critical thinking towards a particular situation; 3. To develop students’ English writing skills by telling an authentic story.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to answer the following questions before reading the story: a. Have you ever misunderstood a person for what they did to you? What was it? b. What did you do when that happened? c. What did you do when you knew the real story? d. What did you learn from the situation? 2. Ask the students to read the story and answer the following questions: a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. j.
Who is Aditya and why did he look worried? Who is Ms. Morindenga and why did she feel upset with Aditya? What was the cause of Aditya’s situation? How did Aditya handle his problem? How did Ms. Morindenga feel when she knew Aditya’s real situation? Why? How did Ms. Morindenga resolve the problem? Did Ms. Morindenga do the right thing? Why? What would you do if you were in Aditya’s situation? What actions would you take if you were Ms. Morindenga? What can you learn from the story?
3. Ask the students to write their own story when they misunderstood or was misunderstood. If they haven’t experienced one, please ask them to interview someone who has such experience. In their writing, the students need to include the following details: a. b. c. d. e.
When it happened and what the real problem was; How they felt about it; How the other person reacted to the situation; How they resolved the situation; What moral lessons they learned.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 31
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: This story is a reminder that teachers in the classroom face students from all different backgrounds, sometimes very different from their own. Empathy—the power to understand other’s perspectives— should become an essential skill to master and an important set of teaching strategies that teachers should focus on because empathy builds positive classroom culture.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 32
CHAPTER 11 I CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE (inspired by Starfish story) Willy Ardian Renandya National Institute of Education, Singapore Flora Debora Floris Petra Christian University, Indonesia
A young female English teacher, Ms. Hana Lee, was walking by a classroom and saw a more senior teacher, Mrs. Kyung-Ja Kim, tutoring a student. Ms. Lee knew the student, Young-Hee, who was also in her class and was known to be falling behind. She had tried to help him and then gave up because he did not seem to make any progress. So she thought that she'd better pay more attention to the brighter students in her class. She said to herself, “It is a waste of my time. There is no way I could make a difference to this student; and there were many students like Young-Hee in the school”. The next day, she ran into Mrs. Kim in the corridor and said to her, 'Mrs. Kim, I hope you don’t mind me saying this, but I think you are wasting your time. I know the student you are tutoring. He is hopeless and you're just wasting your time. Also there are so many students like Young-Hee in the school. You cannot possibly make a difference." The senior teacher listened patiently and then said calmly, "I know I cannot possibly make a difference to every student. But I can make a difference to Young-Hee, Ms. Hana Lee."
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 33
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of pro-social behavior. 2. To develop story writing skill.
Procedure: 1. Have the students read the following quote “Be kind. It is hardly ever the wrong thing to do” (Unknown) and thought about how one kind act could bring positive effects and make a difference to one person. 2. Ask the students to read the story and answer or discuss the following questions: a. Do you know anyone like Young-Hee? Or Mrs. Kyung-Ja Kim? b. Have you ever experienced a situation like Young-Hee, a weak student described in this story? How did Young-Hee (or you) feel – afraid, hopeless? c. What or who helped you to feel different? d. How did it/she/he made you feel different? e. Why would Mrs. Kyung-Ja Kim want to make a positive difference in the academic life of her weak student? f. What can you do to make a difference? How can you be ‘Mrs. Kyung-Ja Kim’? g. How do we create more ‘Mrs. Kyung-Ja Kim’ in our community? Please list several ideas for acts of kindness. h. Can you think of a specific person you can help? How are you going to help him/her? How will it impact his/her life? How will it personally impact your life? i. Do you have your own I can make a Difference (Starfish) story? 3. As homework or out-of-class assignment, have students work in pairs and come up with an animated video story sharing one of their I can Make a Difference (Starfish) stories. The aim of the video is to share one’s real experience and to remind us all that there is the power within each of us to make a difference to someone else's life even in small ways. a. The animated videos are made using a free online application such as PowToon. b. Each video consists of 2 parts: 1) the story and 2) the reflection. c. The story should be in the Past Tense and the reflection is in the Present Tense. d. Each pair is asked to develop a video script first. e. Each pair needs to meet the teacher regularly to consult their script. f. Upload the animated videos on YouTube to reach a wider audience.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 34
Teacher Development Series
a
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 35
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: In today’s world, it is easy to be discouraged and to question the extent to which we can make a difference in the life of another especially if we feel that we are not rich or smart enough to act. The story I can Make a Difference is actually a reminder of the important role we play in our lives. It is a reminder that we should help each other whenever we can even in small ways. The classroom discussions encourage the students to take their time to remember that they have made and they can keep making small changes in their own context. The activity of making an animated video aims to offer the students opportunities to practice writing a short story that might inspire their classmates, teachers and people outside their classroom.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 36
CHAPTER TWELVE THE POWER OF LANGUAGE Maya Khemlani David Asia-Europe Institute University of Malaya, Malaysia Francisco P. Dumanig University of Hawaii at Hilo, USA
Even though this event occurred years ago, it remains very fresh in my mind and I recollect this incident as if it just occurred yesterday. I had just completed my English for Specific Purpose (ESP) class for the final year undergraduates at University of Malaya and was walking out of the classroom and down a steep flight of stairs when I heard someone rushing after me and calling out to me. I stopped and looked around. It was Ahmad Mosdeen one of the quietest boys in my class who seldom spoke. He stammered and asked me desperately - “Will I ever pass?” I wondered what had brought on his need to ask this question. I paused for a while reflecting on his question. And then responded that if he had been studying and coming for all the classes he would surely pass. “Why do you ask me this question?” I asked. His response shocked and upset me. He said my predecessor had called him stupid. My response was swift. “You are definitely not stupid. You will pass your exams if you come for classes regularly, pay attention and do your homework,” I said in a calm voice and walked away briskly, as I did not want to reveal or disclose my annoyance at the previous teacher.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 37
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of the power of language. 2. To develop listening and responding skills.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the quote by Nelson Mandela “If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head. If you talk to him in his language that goes to his heart.” 2. Provide at least 10 minutes discussion about the quote and ask students about their thoughts about it. Ask the students the following guide questions: a. What does it mean, when we say, “If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head”? b. Can you think of any situation that can help you to illustrate the statement clearly? c. What is the difference between the first statement, “If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head,” and the second statement, “If you talk to him in his language that goes to his heart”? d. Can you think of any situation that can help you to illustrate the second statement clearly? 3. Group the students with three (3) members in each group and ask them to read the story silently. 4. After reading, ask the students to discuss the story with their group members using the following guide questions: a. What do you think the student had in mind when he asked the teacher, “Will I ever pass?” b. Do you think the student asked the question because he was afraid to fail or because he wanted assurance that he was not really stupid? c. Do you think it was appropriate for the teacher to respond to the student with this question; “Why do you ask?” Why? d. Why do you think the teacher did not answer the student immediately? e. If you were the student, will you also seek assurance in this manner? f. If you were the teacher, how would you respond to the question? g. Based on the teacher’s answer, what will the boy think about himself? h. Will the teacher’s answer encourage the student to persevere with his studies? i. How does the use of language impact on someone else?
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 38
Teacher Development Series
a
j. Do you think that the way you listen to and react to a person’s question can affect him positively or negatively? Explain. k. As a student teacher, do you think that the way you listen and respond to your students can influence their lives? Explain. 5. After the students’ discussion, each group must present in class the conclusions they reach at the end of their discussion.
Reflection: Language has power. What we say and how we say it has the potential to destroy or uplift the spirit of our students. As teachers or student teachers, we must be careful in how we express ourselves because what comes out from our mouth will either build or damage our students. What comes out from our mouth is the product of our thinking and what we think is the result of how we interpret the message that we receive. Therefore, it is essential to listen carefully to others and we should carefully pause and reflect before responding. Teachers must give students the opportunity to express what they feel about the class, the subject matter and problems that affect themselves and their studies. When teachers listen, they can figure out how to best respond to each student and to resolve issues that may occur. It is important that before saying anything, teachers must think first what words will be used and how they will be structured to benefit those students who listen. This means, as a teacher our main objective is to help students to get over from whatever issues or problems they have encountered. Encouraging and motivating words will build the students’ confidence. It is good to inculcate on our minds what Nelson Mandela said, “If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head. If you talk to him in his language, that goes to his heart.”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 39
CHAPTER THIRTEEN KEEP READING Theresa Tan Kuo Chuan Presbyterian Primary School, Singapore
Coming up the flight of stairs and onto the walkway, I could see Miss Sukanya, a student-teacher I had mentored earlier in the year, in her Primary One classroom. She had her six and seven-year-olds gathered on the floor in front of her. Their eyes were glued to the book she was holding up. It was a scene which gave me a tender fuzzy feeling. I strolled past her class with a smile on my face. I couldn’t help it. A day later, I met her as she stepped out of her classroom. I told her about that happy scene I had witnessed the day before. With a bright smile and a twinkle in her eyes, she said enthusiastically, “You know, that’s my favourite part! But I still have a lot I want to learn from you. You’re really knowledgeable about authors and I think that really gives the children a lot more.” I nodded and gave her a knowing look. “I know… that really helps to engage the children, doesn’t it? Don’t stop reading to your kids, okay? Don’t get too caught up with the main curriculum. This is where we bring our love for books and reading to the children. Keep that up!” As I walked away, I felt really good knowing that this young teacher has caught on the passion of early literacy and has allowed herself to take off with it.
Objectives: To nurture the love of reading in young learners through high-interest picture books.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 40
Teacher Development Series
a
Procedure: 1. Ask the students or the student-teachers to read the story above and answer the following question: What seemed to be the author’s purpose in creating this text? 2. Ask the students or the student-teachers to share their reading experience: a. What was your favorite book or story when you were a kid? b. Who was your favorite character? c. Who asked or encouraged you to read? d. Is it important for children to learn reading in the early years of school? e. What did your teacher do to encourage his/her students’ love of reading? f. What do you do in your classroom to encourage a love of reading? g. What has worked for you to nurture a love of reading in your students or children? 3. Ask the students to come up with some plans to make reading fun and to cultivate the students’ love of reading. The following lesson plan might serve as a model. Start with a ‘hook’. It could be a nursery rhyme, a jingle, a song or even a question. It should be a trigger to tap on the children’s prior knowledge of the content or theme in the selected book. Introduce the story by reading the title, the author and illustrator’s name, the book blurb etc. Ask the children to predict what they think the book is about. The visible thinking strategy, see-think-wonder, is a great strategy to use at this stage. Read the story aloud using appropriate tone and expression. Stop and ask more predictive and interactive questions along the way to elicit responses from the children. This helps to engage them and sustain their interest too. At the end of the reading, ask the children to reflect and share their thoughts about the theme/story. Create a space in the classroom for the children to revisit the book later for independent reading. If the book has been made into a movie, screening a short extract of the movie can also increase interest. Encourage the children to watch the movie and invite them to compare the book with the movie.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 41
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: Early literacy starts with stories. A teacher who loves books and stories can make a tremendous impact on her students. This is especially true for reluctant readers. In today’s busy classroom where the curriculum is rigorous and there is a strong emphasis on achievement, it is often easy for the teaching of the English language to be relegated to mechanical grammar worksheets or meaningless comprehension passages. It does not have to be that way but teachers have to have the courage to sometimes defy the odds and read books that are not in the syllabus. My story is a reminder to adults, who love reading as a child, to bring that love into the classroom. It is the best gift you can give to any child. There are so many things children can learn from stories; and a good story does bond people together. This is my appeal to all language teachers: keep reading!
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 42
CHAPTER FOURTEEN DO NOT LET OTHERS BRING YOU DOWN Zinonos Vasiliki University of Sheffield, English Language Teaching Centre, UK “Sophie, can you help us with the reading today please?” Miss Tania asked. “Yes, Miss.” Laughter broke out in the background. “Pfff… we are going to take ages again!” Bob exclaimed. “Can we sleep now?” Jen whispered to her classmates sitting at the back having a laugh with them. “We never understand what she reads. It is better someone else reads, Miss” Khaled said bluntly. “It’s okay Miss” Sophie rushed to say, “Someone else can read. I don’t want to make the lesson boring. I’m not good they’re right. My reading and accent is terrible”. “Everyone stop talking immediately! Your behaviour is offensive and improper!” Miss Tania instructed angrily. “Sophie please go and wait in my office until the bell rings for break and I’ll talk to you then. Listen children, you need to understand that this is unacceptable behaviour. Do you know what this is? This is called bullying and it has serious consequences! I’ll give you an example. Bob and Jen say you’re bad singers and you were asked to sing in front of the class and someone suddenly jumps in and says ‘Oh my God our ears are going to hurt now, can we use earplugs?’ And the class laughed at you. How would you feel? Would you like that?” “No, Miss!” Both said lowering their heads. ““Okay then, why do you do something to someone, when you wouldn’t want it to be done to you? Wouldn’t you feel incompetent, sad and ashamed?” “Yes, Miss!” the whole class replied. “Alright then. Listen children, bullying -either willingly or unwillingly- is wrong because it is intimidation of someone who is vulnerable. This can destroy the
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 43
Teacher Development Series
a
emotional world of the person being mocked, which may lead to delinquency, dropping out of school, leaving home or even suicide.” “Aaah….” everybody responded shockingly as a sign of realization. “Would you want something bad like this to happen to Sophie?” “No, way Miss” “Okay then. So, let’s all try something different. Instead of putting her down, let’s try to encourage her with her reading skill. I’m sure that you will all see great improvement in her after your support. Please remember we rise only by lifting other people up and not the contrary”.
Objectives: 1. To raise students’ awareness that bullying can exist in the language classroom due to pronunciation difficulties of students learning English as a Second Language. 2. To raise awareness about the problems that students of different ethnical backgrounds might face with the language barrier. 3. To raise awareness that more focus should be given to teaching pronunciation in the class in terms of phonetics and phonology.
Procedure: 1. Have the teachers read the story aloud and discuss the following questions: a. Have you ever come across such a situation as a teacher? What happened and how did you deal with it? b. In such occurrence, what is the best route a teacher should follow: discipline students, provide pastoral support or both? c. Which route will have more effect and why? d. If Miss Tania had not reacted the way she did (excusing the bullied student and advising the students by example) what do you think would have been the aftermath? e. Do you think pronunciation skills are an area where most language learners feel less confident about? f. Should second language curricula focus more on this aspect of language? If yes, what should change in the language curriculum? 2. Have teachers prepare questionnaires for their students to fill in, gather the results and make a brief presentation of 7 minutes in class with their findings and thoughts, asking them the following questions:
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 44
Teacher Development Series
a
a. Rate your reading skills from 1-5 (1 being the lowest, 5 being the highest) b. Rate your English pronunciation skills from 1-5 (1 being the lowest, 5 being the highest) c. Have you ever felt bad about your accent or your reading? Yes/No d. Have you ever being made fun of your accent or reading? Yes/No e. Do you understand the pronunciation of your English teacher? Yes/No/Pretty much f. Do you understand the pronunciation in your listening exercises? Yes/No/Pretty much g. Would you like your teacher to show you ways you can improve your pronunciation? Yes/No h. Would you feel more confident if your improved your accent? Yes/No 3. As an extra activity, have teachers read the following extract and write a reflection of 300 words on how important accent and pronunciation is to facilitate comprehension and how important it is to avoid bullying in the classroom. Additionally, make suggestions of how this aspect can be improved and what methodologies can be used to facilitate pronunciation and comprehension, which in turn will help avoid bullying. Goh, (1999) states that “accented speech, has been picked out as the factor most contributing to unintelligibility or comprehension difficulty (p.61). Accent constitutes an incredibly significant variable in listening comprehension. There is research that favours the idea of listeners benefitting when they are familiar or share the accent of the speaker (Abeywickrama, 2013, p. 61). Specifically, a study by Gass and Varonis (1984) showed that familiarity with speaker’s accent facilitates comprehension (p.71).
Reflection: Bullying is a widespread phenomenon. Bullying with regards to pronunciation and reading abilities is often not perceived or ignored in the second language classroom. Most students feel ashamed and incompetent to perform in this aspect; that is why they choose to be silent. Teachers should be aware of this issue and try to help students whose native language is not English to overcome it. One way is to suggest incorporating in the curriculum teaching phonetics and phonology, which is often disregarded. In this way both reading and comprehension abilities will be improved and students’ confidence will increase so that they are not made fun of for their reading performance.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 45
Teacher Development Series
a
Conducting small surveys will help them identify the extent of the issue at hand and realise that action should be taken. Reading the extract gives the teachers the awareness that research for the pronunciation of English in second language curricula is an issue which concerns a lot of scholars and that maybe we, as teachers are ignorant of it. Reflecting on the extract provides the teachers with the stimuli to find ways to improve their teaching methodologies in this aspect, so that students build their confidence and are not being bullied .
References: • Abeywickrama, P. (2013). Why not non-native varieties of English as listening comprehension test input? RELC Journal, 44(1), 59-74. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F0033688212473270 • Gass S., & Varonis E. M. (1984). The effect of familiarity on non-native speech. Language Learning, 34, 65–89. https://doi:10.1111/j.14671770.1984.tb00996.x • Goh, C. (1999). Teaching listening in the language classroom. Singapore: SEAMEO Regional Language Centre.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 46
CHAPTER FIFTEEN LITTLE THINGS GO A LONG WAY Radhika De Silva Open University of Sri Lanka, Sri Lanka
Ranga was a Grade 10 student in a big school in a city. He was a child from a broken family and his mother had gone abroad leaving Ranga with his grandmother when he was three years old. Ranga’s grandmother paid little attention to Ranga as she had to do all household activities by herself. At school, Ranga preferred to sit at the back of the class and he neither listened to teachers when they taught in class nor did any activities assigned by them. Ranga’s behaviour was very unpredictable, so the teachers did not like to keep him in the classroom. They often sent him out of the class and made him kneel down in the corridor. Some male teachers who passed by teased him by hitting him on the head or squeezing his ears and the students in nearby classes made fun of him. One day, when he was kneeling down in the corridor, his teacher of English passed by. She stopped for a while and caressed Ranga’s head and left a picturestory book near him and walked away without uttering a single word. Next day in class, the teacher asked for a volunteer to tell a story and to her amazement, Ranga was among the few students who raised their hands. The teacher gave Ranga the first chance. Ranga narrated a story with great interest and enthusiasm. That was the story in the book which his English teacher left near him while he was kneeling down in the corridor, the previous day. A few weeks later the school had its English Day Competitions. The English teacher could not hide her tears when the presenter announced, “The best speaker award in English goes to Ranga Perera of Grade 10.”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 47
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of good teacher qualities 2. To enhance students’ (or teacher trainees’) language skills i.e. dialogue writing skills, essay writing skills, debating and their ability to act out a short play.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the story. Get them to discuss about the following in groups. a. What do you think are the reasons for Ranga’s disruptive behavior in class? b. Do you agree with the punishment given by teachers? c. What do you think of the English teacher’s action? d. What may be the reason for leaving the book with Ranga without saying anything? 2. Get the students to work in pairs. Distribute cards with one of the following situations written on them. Instruct the pairs to develop a dialogue. a. Ranga meets his English teacher after the award ceremony. b. Ranga and his grandmother on the day he received the story book. c. English teacher and the Math teacher discussing about Ranga’s unruly behavior in class. d. Ranga meets his English teacher 10 years later. 3. Get the volunteers to act their dialogues out in front of others. The students select the best dialogues and produce a short play. This is done as group work. The groups meet the teacher regularly and get their scripts refined. The best play is staged on the Activity Day. 4. Ask the students to write an essay on the topic of “A teacher is a life changer” in 500 words. Ask the students to include at least three examples of such situations in their school life. 5. Group students into two groups. Give them the topic “The main duty of a teacher is to teach the relevant subject right.” Do you agree/ disagree?” They discuss the position given to them in their groups and select a team of 5 members for the Debating Team. The debate can be made open to teachers, teacher trainers and principals.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 48
Teacher Development Series
a
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 49
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: Schools around the world are becoming more and more exam-oriented and the main expectation of teachers is to produce good results at examinations. Some teachers believe that their job is to keep the classroom quiet and to teach many lessons as possible so that they can complete the syllabus early and prepare their students for examinations. They may satisfy the needs of a few studious students in the classroom, but there are students who come to school with other needs and expectations as well. A story like “Little things go a long way” is a stimulating and inspiring story for teacher trainees as it makes them understand the value of a teacher who can be a life-changing agent of her/his students. It also shows the importance of a simple act of kindness like the one done by the English teacher in the story in transforming the life of a neglected child. The suggested activities aim to develop a range of skills in teacher trainees. The trainees learn the characteristics of a good teacher and they understand the role of a teacher as a changing agent and a facilitator. Since there are pair and group activities, co-operative and collaborative learning takes place. Language skills of the trainees such as speaking, essay writing, and debating are developed as well. The plays produced by teacher trainees may be sources of inspiration for students, parents and especially for both current and future teachers.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 50
Learning from Others’ Culture
CHAPTER SIXTEEN HOLDING UP A MIRROR TO INTERNATIONAL ESL STUDENT-TEACHERS Beatrix Burghardt Indiana University Bloomington, US
Once, I was an international student in the US. Today, I am international faculty. I teach students preparing to become language teachers. In my classes, I often share stories of my learning experiences. I have always hoped that this common international background will one day allow me to connect with my students beyond teaching them ESL methods. Juansi and Wenqin are only two of my international students, who have frequently come to office hours to discuss assignments since their first year. This year, though, I noticed that they often stop by just to chat and laugh. During their recent visit, I jokingly asked why they keep coming back. Juansi quickly replied, “I trust you a lot.” When I asked what she meant, she said, “It is a personal feeling. Closeness.” Wenqin added, “You know how it feels to not know. Because English is your second language and you had difficulties, too.” Wenqin also mentioned an example: “I came here with a purpose. I need to work. […] when I was working on my paper, I had no idea about the topic. But you said “I will teach you” and that’s what happened. You trusted me before. You gave me the feeling I could do it.” At this moment, I realized the power of my stories. Sharing my stories allowed them to see that I have walked in their shoes. I also came with a purpose as an international graduate student and I had to overcome the same obstacles that they are facing now. Such empathy may lead to trust, which in turn may empower my international students to uphold the image of future success and further motivate them.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 52
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To identify possible motivational roles of language teachers. 2. To practice motivational strategies in language teaching. 3. To explain the relationship between L2 motivation-related concepts by utilizing research skills.
Procedure: Pre Stage 1. Students find a partner and discuss the demographic traits of their future class. 2. Ask the students to do free-writing for five minutes using the following prompt: Do you think it is the teacher’s job to motivate their students? 3. Ask the students to define the following words in their own teaching context: a. international student, b. motivation, c. trust, d. empathy, e. office hour.
Whilst Stage 1. Ask the students to predict what the story is about by reading the following statement: “Once, I was an international student in the US. Today, I am international faculty.” 2. Ask the students to read the story and answer/discuss these questions: a. What is the central idea of this story? b. Where does the story take place? c. What do you know about the author of the story? Identify all possible roles and traits. d. What do you know about the students of the story? Identify all possible roles and traits. e. What is the teacher’s attitude towards language teaching and learning? f. What is the students’ attitude towards language teaching and learning? g. What does Juansi mean by the word ‘trust’? h. What does Wenqin mean by saying “You know how it feels to not know”?
Post Stage 1. Ask the students to find out the meaning or the message of the story. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 53
Teacher Development Series
a
2. The author claims that “my stories allowed them to see that I have walked in their shoes.” What do you think the author’s stories were about? 3. Ask the students to imagine that they are interviewing the author. Prepare 4 questions to ask during an interview. 4. Ask the students to choose one of the following options as their homework. a. Group work: Find two motivational strategies utilized in language classrooms. Prepare a video recording in which you explain the strategy and demonstrate it through an activity. Share your video with the class. b. Individual work: Think of a teaching situation (formal or informal) that motivated you or that you created to motivate someone else. Prepare a video recording in which you explain the motivational strategy and its impact on you, and explain how you can use it in your future language teaching practice. Share you video with the class.
Reflection: The story is inspired by Dörnyei’s (2009) model of the L2 motivational selfsystem. It is an authentic story describing the author’s practice based on her diary notes. It aims to raise awareness of how non-native speaker ESL teachers in particular can evoke the L2 ideal self in their students by sharing their own academic experience across academic cultures (Taguchi, Magid, & Papi, 2009). Dörnyei’s work is applicable not only to studying L2 learner motivation, but it also allows for reflection by ESL practitioners. The before-reading activities prime teachers to motivation-related concepts specific to the L2 instructional context. The during-reading activities ask teachers to discover the social aspects of the language classroom and the role of language in building relationships while teaching language. The after-reading activities offer an extension by personalizing the topic, directing teachers to discover the literature and trying out motivational strategies specific to L2 language teaching.
References: • Dörnyei, Z. (2009). The L2 motivational self-system. In Z. Dörnyei & E. Ushioda (Eds.), Motivation, language identity and the L2 self (pp. 9-42). Bristol: Multilingual Matters. • Taguchi, T. Magid, M., & Papi, M. (2009). The L2 motivational self-system among Japanese, Chinese and Iranian learners of English: A comparative study. In Z. Dörnyei & E. Ushioda (Eds.), Motivation, language identity and the L2 self (pp. 66-97). Bristol: Multilingual Matters.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 54
CHAPTER SEVENTEEN INTERCULTURAL UNDERSTANDING: INSPIRATION FROM A PET SOUND Dat Bao Monash University, Australia
It happened in one of my lessons where students are of international background. Class members come from 14 countries in Asia, Africa, Europe, and Australia. While discussing the language-culture relationship, one student raised the question why the sound of dog’s bark is described so differently in different languages, and why we humans cannot create a common word that represents the actual barking made by dogs. When each student shared how dog barks in their mother tongue, we discovered that dog’s bark is transcribed as ‘woofwoof’ in English, ‘wang-wang’ in Mandarin, ‘hund-hund’ in German, ‘gae-gae’ in Korean, ‘eey-eey’ in Somali, and so on. When I asked the class which sound they think most resembles a dog’s real bark, everyone answered that their language had the most truthful sound and the barking sound from other languages felt so strange that it made them laugh. This response somehow demonstrates the reality that the human mind tends to view what they are familiar with as the most important reality that makes most sense; while the perspectives of others tend to be ‘weird’ and ‘it was hard to figure out how dogs sound like that!’
Objectives: 1. To develop intercultural understanding. 2. To raise tolerance towards differences.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 55
Teacher Development Series
a
Procedure: 1. Bring into class a box of oranges. Invite each student to take one and go back to their seat, study it carefully and then put it back into the box after making sure that they can later recognise their orange and will be able take it out when they search for it from the box. This activity raises the awareness that everyone is important and unique, and this fact may be unknown to outsiders of the language and culture. The fact that only the owner of the orange recognises it means that subjectivity, familiarity, observation, and understanding play a part in the acceptance of others. 2. Read the above story. Ask students to think of an incident in their life, a conversation from someone from another culture, or an observation when they watch movies, or even a speculated example, to show that what they see as natural, important, and polite in their culture, seems to mean very little to someone from another culture. Some examples would be wearing a headscarf, giving a name card with both hands, not opening a gift in front of the giver, and so on. 3. Ask students to share their examples and discuss why people have different views of what shapes good manner, politeness, respect, and normal behaviour. Explain that such differences come from the history of living together and developing specific ways of getting along in each society. 4. Present the following dialogues and have students choose the best response in their culture. One interesting way to do this could be showing only the first line of each dialogue and invite students to come up with the most appropriate response in their thinking. Once the class has offered a few responses, the teacher then begins to show some options.
Dialogue 1 Guest: Your food is just delicious! Really? Please have some more Not at all! I’m still learning how to cook Thank you (Do you have another response?)
Dialogue 2 Classmate: You’ve done so well in your test! I just don’t know how to catch up with you. No. You’re kidding again! You’re doing just fine! Thank you. I think I just perform well this time.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 56
Teacher Development Series
a I didn’t know what I was doing then. (Other responses?)
Dialogue 3 Friend: You haven’t changed a bit. You still look so young! No. I’ve aged a great deal! Neither have you. Is it you who have not changed a bit! Really? Thank you. I don’t believe you! (Other responses?) 5. Invite individuals in the class to come up with a line that potentially evokes various responses from different culture. Then invite the rest of the class to shout out their responses. Such lines may be ‘thank you’, a compliment, a comment on appearance, a personal or controversial question, etc.
Reflection: The way we communicate often reflect our own, specific culture, whether we can see that clearly or not. When we speak, the listener will find out many aspects of our culture such as beliefs, values, behaviour, lifestyle, world view, emotion, and status. For example, in England, Liverpool accent is considered ‘less noble’ than London accent and many people from Liverpool cannot get jobs in London unless they change their accent. The same thing happens in the US, some people from South Carolina who went to Boston to study were judged as ‘less intelligent’ simply because they do not sound like Boston people. All of these perceptions are in many cases built upon subjective habits and individual bias. One important achievement in English learning is to become generous and tolerant towards other cultures. Instead of laughing at others for being too different, we can learn to walk in their shoes to understand and adapt to new ways of communicating. Much of language competence has to do with such intercultural flexibility. According to Hall (1973), the meaning and value of a message may be decoded or interpreted in different ways depending on individuals’ sociocultural background and experiences. He maintains that collectively, many members of a society might be capable of changing the commonly accepted meaning of a message. In fact, identity is shaped by the relationship between the individual and society. It is important to temporarily modify our identity when we step beyond our own culture when communicating with others. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 57
Teacher Development Series
a
Reference: • Hall (1973). S. Encoding and decoding in the television discourse. Paper for the Council of Europe Colloquy on Training in the Critical Reading of Television Language. Birmingham: Centre for Cultural Studies, University of Birmingham, 507-17.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 58
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN CHANGING PERSPECTIVE Hanna Juliaty Universitas Kristen Krida Wacana, Indonesia In an international classroom in England, university students from different countries were having an English Reading and Writing class. Earlier, the lecturer had introduced a classic children story titled The Three Little Pigs to the class through a short movie clip. Since the story is very popular worldwide, most students admitted that they have read or heard about the story a few times and were familiar with its content. “Which one is the antagonist in the story?”, asked the lecturer at the end of the short movie. “The Wolf”, the students answered in unison. “I will now give you another version of the Three Little Pigs story as told by the Wolf himself,” said the lecturer. “You need to read the short story carefully, and once you are finished, tell me whether or not you change your mind about the antagonist.” Many students showed an interested expression on their face. It was very clear to the lecturer that the students had never read or heard The Three Little Pigs story being told in another version than the original one. A while later, when the students had finished reading the story, the lecturer asked the question again. “Which one is the antagonist in the story?” To everyone’s surprised, the class was now divided into two big groups: a group who thought the Wolf was the antagonist and another group who thought the Wolf was innocent. Later after the class just ended, a student walked up to the lecturer and said, “Today’s reading is very insightful for me. The simple story wasn’t only engaging—it also raised my awareness to be critical and reflective when looking at text while reading.” The teacher smiled and replied, “I’m glad you learned something valuable today.”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 59
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of critical reading. 2. To develop writing skills using poster as media of communication.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the story and discuss the following questions: a. Why did the students at first agree that the Wolf was bad, but at the second time, half of them thought he was innocent? What could possibly make this group of students change their mind? b. If you have a chance to read the other version of the Three Little Pigs as told in the Wolf’s perspective, would you change your mind about the antagonist? Why or why not? c. The story shows how people may respond differently to the text they read. What do you focus on when reading different types of text (e.g. descriptive, narrative, persuasive, or argumentative)? d. Do you think it is important to consider a text from different perspectives? Why or why not? e. How can you be critical when reading? What aspects do you need to consider when reading in order to be critical? f. Share one text that you have read recently. What is it about? How would you respond to it? How would your peers respond to it? g. The lecturer in the story used children’s literature to teach critical reading skills. What other media can you use to practice critical reading skills? Do different media offer different benefits? Why or why not? 2. As an assignment, the teacher can have the students practice applying critical reading skills and organising written information for poster presentation: a. Ask the students to work in small groups (3-4 people). b. Assign each group to find three different short texts (150-300 words) of the same specific topic (e.g. news or magazine articles that report or discuss the same local, national or international trending issue). c. Ask the students to work together in their group to analyse the texts by identifying the writer’s intention and bias (including the use of writer’s language, tone and mood), along with the evidence shown or implied in each text. d. Ask the students to draw a conclusion from their group analysis and share their personal perspective and response to the texts.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 60
Teacher Development Series
a
e. Ask the students to report their findings in a digital poster presentation using a free online application (e.g. Canva or Piktochart) and share it with the class.
Reflection: In this modern era, people have more freedom to express their opinions, be it through spoken or written words, or through other kinds of expressions. Especially with various digital platforms that can be accessed and used easily, freely and immediately, more people now have the opportunities to display information, share ideas and express opinions to a much wider audience than in the past. On the one hand, this may result in various positive impacts, but on the other hand, this could trigger irresponsible and unreliable productions of overly-biased judgments, as often manifested in misleading information and fake news. It is very important for students in higher education to learn evaluating numerous texts and sources they read, online and printed, critically. The story Changing Perspective gives us a peek into a university classroom where students learned to employ critical reading skills in learning and how it impacted their perspective not only on the text they were reading, but also on their overall daily reading practice. The discussion questions and assignment are also designed to facilitate students to raise awareness of the importance of critical reading in everyday life.
Reference: • Scieszka, J. (1989). The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs! New York: Viking Penguin.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 61
CHAPTER NINETEEN SHARING THE JOY OF LITERATURE John Sivell Brock University, Canada
A teacher from Britain was working at a Syrian university. Although he knew that many British students were unconfident with literature, his Syrian students seemed to be different. For example, they always went to public readings of Arabic poetry. Perhaps that enjoyment could include English literature, too. Through careful trial and error, he learned that short stories in English were the best choice. His classes especially appreciated Hemingway’s “A good café in the Place St. Michel.” That story describes a youthful American author writing all alone in a Paris café. A beautiful young woman catches his attention, but he focuses only on his work. When he finally looks up from his notebook, the mysterious girl is gone. Hemingway’s picture of a famous and faraway city fascinated the Syrian students. One group of classmates even joined together to translate it. They hung their work in the corridor for fellow students who did not know English. Above the title they added (in both English and Arabic): Please read this story – We LOVE it! Before returning to Britain, the teacher left a forwarding address. However, that was in the 1970s. Email and social media did not exist. So, he feared he would lose contact with his students, and at first nothing reached him. Then, after three years, he found a postcard in his mailbox. Its stamp had been cancelled in Paris. The message was from one of the Syrian students who had read Hemingway in his class. She began by saying, “I’m writing this card to you from a good café in the Place St. Michel…”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 62
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop inferential reading skills, leading into discussion and writing. 2. To enhance intercultural understanding and appreciation through literature and the Internet.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read this quote: “Books transported her … all over the world while sitting in her little room in an English village” (Dahl, 1988, p. 15). Invite them to think about how literature can open up the whole world; ask them to name a novel, story or poem that had this effect on them, and explain why. 2. Ask the students to write a 50-80 word description of the impact of that novel, story or poem, also indicating how to locate a copy in a library or online. 3. Invite small groups to exchange the above descriptions and talk about the power of literature to inspire readers’ imagination about other places or cultures. 4. Based on that discussion, have the same small groups compile a list of recommended literature titles with a one- or two-line explanation of the appeal of each and with information on how to find a copy. Upload those lists to a blog site. 5. Ask the students to read the above story and respond to the following questions: a. How do you think the British teacher felt when working in Syria? b. Why do you think that teacher was interested in his Syrian students’ enjoyment of poetry? Do you also enjoy poetry or other literature? c. Why do you think those students were attracted to Hemingway’s story about the young author in Paris? d. Back in Britain, how do you think the teacher felt when he saw the stamp on the postcard? Why? e. Why would the Syrian student begin her message with, “I’m writing this card to you from a good café in the Place St. Michel…”? f. What does this story show about the power of literature? What makes you say that?
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 63
Teacher Development Series
a 6. As homework, assign the students to:
a. read Hemingway’s entire story (1,637 words) or the shorter, selfcontained segment from paragraphs 5 to 10 inclusive (“It was a pleasant café … But I felt sad.” – 499 words) (available at http://fadedpage.com/ books/ 20141111/html.php#ch01). b. compose an approximately 500-word summary (or 250 words for just the segment) to reflect what they believe are the most meaningful details. c. upload their summaries to the blog site. d. read each other’s online summaries and add their own comments.
Reflection: Today’s students are exposed to more powerful intercultural influences than ever before. That impact comes largely from access to the Internet, which can be fine although Internet communication is not always deeply reflective. By contrast, Sharing the Joy of Literature foregrounds the special potential of literature to evoke imaginatively rich understanding of others, not only by depicting events and situations experienced by culturally different individuals, but also by creating a community of readers who exchange ideas about what they have read. In that context, sharing on the Internet can expand the reading experience in highly constructive ways. This set of activities begins with two traditional elements: discussion and composition about literature. But then it expands the students’ engagement by encouraging them to use an online platform to display their insights and to comment on the views of others (Alrubail, 2015).
References: • Alrubail, A. (2015, March 16). Blogging for English-Language Learners. Edutopia: George Lucas Educational Foundation. Retrieved on 1 December 2018 from http://www.edutopia.org/blog/blogging-for-english-languagelearners-rusul-alrubail • Dahl, R. (1988). Matilda. London, UK: Penguin.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 64
CHAPTER TWENTY COURAGE (MY QUIET STAR) Paul Hullah Meiji Gakuin University, Japan
Yūki arrived at class before anyone else, and always sat alone. He didn’t say much, but, when he spoke, his contributions were original, imaginative and insightful. Yūki reacted to poems — I taught poetry to a class of Japanese university English majors — in an instinctive way. He would quickly find messages, deep meaning in everything we read. He expressed his thoughts vividly and freely, and I encouraged that. “You have a gift, Yūki,” I said. “Use it!” Yūki was my star pupil: my ‘quiet star’. “You’re a still river, running deep!” I once said in class. When I explained the meaning of that English saying, we all agreed that it described Yūki perfectly. His classmates liked Yūki. His thoughtful comments inspired them. “He is a poet!”, they laughed. They told me the character used for writing Yūki’s name means ‘courage’ in Japanese. They said they thought that was kind of poetic too. Yūki had a dream. After graduation, he wanted to live in an English-speaking country. I told him he was gifted, could achieve whatever he wanted. I urged him to aim high, follow his dream. The day he graduated, top student in his year, I shook hands with him at the graduation ceremony. It was the last time we spoke. ‘Follow that dream!’ I said. ‘I will,’ he replied. A year later, a postcard arrived. It was from Yūki, and postmarked ‘London’. “I’m living in the UK”’ he wrote, “six months here now! I’m so happy. My dream came true! Your poetry class changed my life, gave me courage to express myself. When I speak to people now, they do not just hear that I can speak English. They do not just see that I am blind. They know who I am.”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 65
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop self-awareness and self-confidence by fostering attentiveness to and empathy with the actions and circumstances of one’s self and of others. 2. To develop linguistic awareness and expressive competence by fostering confidence in recognising differing registers and skills in using different varieties of language.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the story and answer or discuss the following: a. Yūki wrote: “They know who I am”. What does it mean? b. Yūki means ‘courage’. Does your (or a friend’s or pet’s) name have a meaning? In what ways does that meaning suit you/him/her, or not? If you could choose a different name for yourself, what name would you choose, and why? c. Describe a situation in your life where you wish you had expressed yourself better, and explain how you would handle it differently if you had another chance. d. Using a maximum of 100 words, explain what impact this teacher’s class had upon Yūki. e. Is it always important to ‘aim high’? Why, or why not? Give examples from your own experience to support your opinion. f. Share a story (either an episode from your own life, or a story you have heard) in which ‘courage’ plays an important part. g. Yūki made his dream come true. What’s your dream? How will you achieve it? h. Yūki inspired others, and changed the way they thought. Who has inspired you, or changed your way of thinking? Share a story of someone who inspires you with your classmates. 2. Ask the students to work in groups to discuss these questions: a. Do you think Yūki’s English class influenced him as it did because it was a poetry class, or might other kinds of class have produced the same effect? Why? b. What study materials and methods are good for learning English? Which materials and methods are not so good? Why? 3. Poetry finds deeper meanings or ‘messages’ in ordinary scenes and situations. Using ‘rules’ for ‘haiku’ writing (3 lines, of 5, 7, and 5 syllables respectively), have the students compose haiku that take an everyday scene or occurrence and bring out its deeper meaning. Have them present their haiku out loud, then invite comments from classmates. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 66
Teacher Development Series
a
4. Ask the students the meaning of ‘You’re a still river, running deep!’ If the students do not know or cannot guess, explain that describing someone in that way indicates that we perceive hidden depths beneath their calm exterior. This figurative expression uses a visual image to illustrate an impression. 5. Have the students guess and consider the meaning of some other common English figurative expressions that describe a person’s personality (‘wet blanket’, ‘down to earth’, ‘social butterfly’ etc.). 6. Ask the students: a. Do you know any similar expressions (in English, or in your own language)? b. Explain how they work, and give examples of these expressions in use.
Reflection: This story encourages us to pay attention, not only to people and things around us, but also to the language we use to describe these people and things and how we think and feel about them. Delving deeper than surfaces, we see the world more fully, more clearly. Yūki’s disability (his blindness) makes it tempting for people to ‘read’ and react to him in a certain way, but the story reminds us that we shouldn’t ‘judge a book by its cover’. We need to look at life more carefully. Just as persons we encounter in our daily lives might have hidden depths and talents, language also works on levels that are all too easily overlooked. Words do not simply signify objects; the particular words and phrases we choose to use in any given situation simultaneously communicate an attitude and convey our feelings about the topics we describe and discuss. The story of Yūki also deals with modes of expression. Control of expressive utterance (building confidence in mastering style as well as content) affords speakers greater control over self-presentation, impressions made on others, and thus identity itself. Exposure to and consideration of figurative ‘poetic’ aspects of everyday phrases/expressions attunes us to potencies of language beyond basic communication. We can express the same idea in different ways, and the realization that how something is said can be just as important as what is said is a vital stage in becoming an empowered language user. Being adept at choosing words to best suit a situation is a skill that proficient language learners should be encouraged to acquire and develop at secondary and university level.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 67
CHAPTER TWENTY ONE STUDENT TO THE RESCUE: TEACHING VOCABULARY WITH CARE Phil Chappell Macquarie University, Australia This is a story about an Australian English language teacher teaching English in a language school in Bangkok, Thailand. That person is me. The story is set in my first year of being a teacher. I was working six days a week at the school, thoroughly enjoying myself, meeting so many wonderful students, developing my skills and knowledge alongside many great teachers. I was finally at that stage of a new teacher's career where I was writing brief lesson plans in list form, rather than the comprehensive ones that I had learned to use on my initial training course. I was learning to be more spontaneous, to respond to the students, rather than focusing on what I was doing up there in front of class. One morning in a two-hour class of university students taking summer holiday English lessons, I had assigned a reading task about home remedies for common ailments. Garlic and honey for a sore throat. Cucumbers for tired eyes. Vinegar for bee stings. Vinegar. That word to this day takes me back to that lesson. _________________ A hand goes up: "Teacher, what's vinegar?" Not having been asked this before, my mind starts racing. What's the best way to teach this word? Should I mime it? Draw it? Explain it? It's kind of like wine, so I'll start there. I then proceed to explain that vinegar is like wine. I draw casks and pipes on the board. I am getting into fermentation and all kinds of concepts. The students (they are all listening and watching by now) just look blank. Nothing I say makes any sense. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 68
Teacher Development Series
a Then a voice to my right. "Nam som sai choo."
Everyone smiles, laughs, nods in understanding. I smile at the student. "What did you say?", I asked with sweat on my brow. "I said the Thai word for vinegar." "Oh, thanks. So now we all know what vinegar is?" "Yes teacher."
Objectives: 1. To raise the awareness of the role of the students’ first language in the English language classroom. 2. To introduce vocabulary teaching strategies for different kinds of vocabulary.
Procedure: 1. Assign the students (teacher trainees) to small groups. 2. Ask the groups to consider what went wrong with the teacher’s explanation of vinegar. What would they do differently? 3. After eliciting feedback from the groups, ask them to discuss the following two questions for a few minutes. a. Is it appropriate for the students to use their first language (mother tongue) in the English language classroom? If so, for what purposes? If not, why? b. Is it appropriate for the teacher to use the students' first language in the English language classroom? If so, for what purposes? If not, why? 4. After eliciting feedback from the groups, write the following words on the board, or include them in a handout. Ask the groups to come up with an effective strategy for conveying the meaning of each word. a. b. c. d. e.
Run Blue Anxious Generalisation Chocolate
5. If the group is of appropriate size (20-25), call the group together and ask each small group to peer-teach their vocabulary to the class. Or, if the group Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 69
Teacher Development Series
a
is larger, re-mix small groups and ask each individual in the group to peerteach their vocabulary to their small group. 6. Lead a discussion of different types of words and different ways to convey meaning. For example, if it is an action verb, you can often mime the action; if it is an adjective for a concrete object, you can use realia, or you could simply use the L1 form and function of the word; if it is an abstract adjective describing someone’s state of mind, you can tell a story, or you can use an L1 equivalent if one exists. 7. If appropriate, assign a follow up activity for teachers to keep a reflective journal of the strategies they use to teach vocabulary in their lessons. This could be used later on for a follow up meeting, or for participants to share with their colleagues on a blog, in a newsletter, at a meeting, or in the staff room.
Reflection: Early career teachers often find themselves in hot water over unanticipated problems that arise during lessons. These can be powerful learning opportunities and should be viewed as such, rather than as a point of failure. In this case, as the teacher, I began a journey of learning about the uses of the L1 (and the debates surrounding this), and I also learned that not all words can be treated equally. The students' first language is an abundant source of knowledge about language that can be used strategically in the classroom. Teachers need to think critically about how the L1 can support the language learning process in the classroom, and also identify the times that it constrains language learning. One important area where L1 can be used efficiently and effectively is teaching vocabulary. Teaching the word vinegar by explaining how it is made is neither efficient nor effective. It took up too much time in the reading lesson, and it didn’t achieve the desired learning result. A simple use of the L1 equivalent in this case would have been both efficient and effective. Different kinds of words require different teaching strategies, and there are many excellent resources to follow this up, e.g. Nation (2008). On the other hand, if the learning aim is to develop fluency in spoken English, then the use of L1 should be discouraged in many instances. Fluency development involves speaking without too many hesitations, using comprehensible rhythm and intonation patterns, while at the same time expressing one’s thoughts. This is best done in the classroom using the target language as much as possible in a task or activity.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 70
Teacher Development Series
a
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 71
CHAPTER TWENTY TWO CRITICAL TEACHING REFLECTION ON THE “N-WORD” Richard W. Hallett Northeastern Illinois University, USA
Four years after Lithuania gained its independence from the USSR, I taught English as a Foreign Language (EFL) at a secondary school in Kaunas. Due to budget constraints, I was given a photocopy of an old Soviet-era English language textbook to use in all of my sections of tenth grade English grammar classes, Anglų Kalbos Vadovėlis [English Language Tutorial], and asked to work through the text, keeping pace with the other two sophomore-level English teachers. Dutifully, I worked my way through the text while smirking at all of the Soviet propaganda presented in the textbook. When I reached Lesson Seven, which contained an abridgement of Dorothy Parker’s (1927) “Arrangement in Black and White,” I was stunned to see the word nigger in the text without an accompanying gloss. However, the word “Virginia” was glossed at the end of the story: “a state in the U.S.A. The percentage of the Negro population there is 25%. The land aristocracy is a violent supporter of race discrimination.” I deviated from the book for a day, giving my students a brief history of the “n-word,” stressing how deeply offensive it is to many native speakers of American English. I ended my lecture by saying that I was not going to use the word and did not want to hear it. After one lesson, a very bright girl asked me, “Are there any Communists in America?” When I responded in the affirmative, she continued, “Are there any Black Communists?” When I said probably, she quickly asked, “Are most Black people Communists?” I then asked her why she was asking me these questions. She responded, “In Soviet times, we were told that all Black people wanted to be Communists because they knew that was the only way they would be treated equally.” Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 72
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To get students (teacher trainees) to examine their teaching materials in a critical manner. 2. To reflect on their own pre-conceived ideas about the hegemonic positioning of the English language.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to read the above story and respond to the following questions: a. What was the most interesting thing you learned from this text? b. Was there anything you just read that surprised you? c. What do you think is the purpose/aim of this text? 2. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to refer to required reading texts, especially those from state-mandated curricula or textbooks, that they used in their class and try to answer the following questions by or for themselves: a. Why has this passage been included in the textbook? b. What issue is raised in this passage? c. How is the issue discussed/addressed, e.g. through an argumentative essay, personal anecdote, a reproduction of a newspaper article, a wellknown piece of fiction, etc.? d. What assumptions (both explicit and implicit) does the author make? e. What are the main results, findings, or conclusions? f. How universal is the interpretation of the text? Could students from other cultures have different “take-away” points from the texts? If so, are these interpretations based on different socio-cultural-historical impressions or lessons? 3. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to refer to their classroom experience in answering the following questions: a. Did your students have the expected reactions after reading the assigned materials? If not, why not? b. Did the students appear to grasp the issue(s) addressed or brought up by the text? What evidence is there of this understanding? c. How could the text be addressed differently the next time it is taught? For example, should it be presented along with a companion piece that offers a different perspective? d. Should the text be taught again? Why/why not?
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 73
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: The above story, which I experienced about twenty-five years ago, has not only remained with me throughout my teaching career – from teaching high school EFL in Kaunas to teaching graduate linguistics classes in Chicago – but has also influenced the type of research I have chosen to engage in. Larsen-Freeman (2018, p. 67) notes, “Part of knowing about the world is knowing about the power dynamics and inequalities that revolve around access to and use of other languages/dialects in different contexts for different purposes.” That specific encounter with that particularly bright student led me to rethink what I thought I knew about the dominant roles of the United States and the English language around the world. That reorientation led me to the discovery of the concepts of hegemony and critical sociolinguistics. My forays into those areas of study have most recently led me to discover the area of critical teaching reflection. For Brookfield (2017), critical reflection is “the sustained and intentional process of identifying and checking the accuracy and validity of our teaching assumptions.” Moreover, it is a way of uncovering hegemony (p. 3). Critical teaching reflection causes teachers to update their teaching practices and beliefs continually based on their experiences and their students’ experiences. The goal of this inspirational story is to show how a slight deviation from an assigned reading to address a socially-relevant issue can activate not only a change in one’s pedagogy but also a change in one’s research and, perhaps, worldview.
References: • Brookfield, S.D. (2017). Becoming a critically reflective teacher, 2nd ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. • Larsen-Freeman, D. (2018). Looking ahead: Future directions in, and future research into, second language acquisition. Foreign Language Annals, 51(1), 55-72.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 74
CHAPTER TWENTY THREE POSITIONING STUDENTS AS LANGUAGE EXPERTS THROUGH MULTILINGUAL STORYTELLING ACTIVITIES Shakina Rajendram University of Toronto, Canada
I first met 11-year old Vishva when I was doing my doctoral research in Malaysia. Vishva had been abandoned as a child, so he lived with his grandmother. Part of his scalp had been burned off when a pot of boiling water tipped over on him as a child, so he looked different from the other children his age, but he always greeted me with the biggest, brightest smile. Vishva had come back to school after missing a few years of schooling because his grandmother had not been able to afford his school fees. Because of all the schooling he had missed, Vishva could not read or write in English well and he was failing his exams. During his English lessons, Vishva was always quiet and did not participate in any of the activities. However, I saw from the look of his face that he really wanted to join in, but did not feel confident enough in himself. I asked Vishva if he could teach me Tamil, and that in exchange I would help him with his English. Since Tamil was his first language and he spoke it well, his face lit up and he nodded eagerly. Over the next few months, Vishva and I worked together on multilingual storytelling activities such as reading bilingual Tamil-English storybooks, and creating dual-language storybooks. In all our activities, I reminded Vishva that he was the language expert and I was there to learn from him. This helped him to take ownership over his learning and to improve his English. One day, a new boy joined the class. I watched Vishva, my heart full of pride and joy, as he walked up to the boy confidently and said “Hi, I’m Vishva. Would you like me to help you with your English?”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 75
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop multilingual students’ reading, writing and oral communication skills. 2. To develop students’ collaboration skills. 3. To encourage a love for reading among students and develop their creative thinking.
Procedure: 1. Prior to the class: Ask the students to bring their favorite storybooks from home. The storybooks can be in English or in other languages the students can read. 2. Read the above story and answer the following questions: a. b. c. d.
What is the main idea/gist of the story? What was the turning point of the story? What message did the author want you to get? What lessons did you learn that you can use in your own teaching or learning? e. What would you like to ask the author or one of the characters? 3. Ask each student to choose a storybook that their friends brought to the class. 4. Ask the students to read the storybook. Students can work in pairs or small groups to help each other while reading. 5. After students read the book, have them think about and discuss the characters, setting, plot, conflict, story events, and other aspects of the story. You can use these questions to prompt them: a. Who are the main characters in the story? Who were your most and least favourite characters and why? b. Where and when does the story take place? c. What happened in the story? Why did those things happen? d. What were your most and least favourite parts of the story and why? e. What moral lessons did you learn from the story? f. If you could change the character, setting, or any of the events in story, what changes would you make? g. How would those changes affect the rest of the story?
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 76
Teacher Development Series
a
6. After this discussion, students can work in pairs or small groups to rewrite this story as a multilingual story using English and their first language. To create their multilingual story, students first discuss what changes they would like to make to the plot of the story. This can be based on the discussion in steps 5(f) and (g). Encourage students to also personalize and localize the story, for example by changing the names and physical characteristics of the characters, the places in the story, and the dialogues between characters. 7. Once students have discussed and mapped out the plot of their story, they start writing their story in English and other language(s) spoken by the group members. If there are computers or tablets in your class, students can work on writing and illustrating their stories using applications such as ScribJab, MyStoryBook and Pixton. If not, students can create paper-based books using materials such as construction paper, colored pencils, crayons, markers, and images from colouring books, newspapers and magazines. 8. After creating their story, students practise reading it aloud using oral storytelling techniques such as varying their volume and intonation. They then work together to record a voice-over as they narrate the story. 9. Encourage students to share their multilingual stories by publishing their books on ScribJab or other educational blogs and websites, or sharing their paper-based books in the classroom reading corner and school library.
Reflection: Studies on English language learning have shown that multilingual students benefit from using their first language or home language in the classroom because they are able to transfer the knowledge, skills and concepts from one language to another. Furthermore, knowing that their home language is welcome in the classroom “provides a sense of security and validates the learners' lived experiences, allowing them to express themselves…experiment and take risks with English” (Schweers, 1999, p. 7). Thus, by carving out an important place for home languages in the classroom, teachers can build bridges between what students experience at home and in school and “facilitate the flow of knowledge, ideas, and feelings between home and school and across languages” (Cummins et al., 2005, p. 41). Although the research on language learning has suggested the cognitive, sociocultural, communicative, and affective benefits of multilingualism in the classroom, English language teachers in many contexts still implement Englishonly instruction in their classrooms. This monolingual approach ignores the rich repertoire of language skills and knowledge that students bring to the classroom. Furthermore, it limits the opportunities for students with a shared Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 77
Teacher Development Series
a
first language to support their peers and scaffold each other’s learning during collaborative activities. In my experience as an English teacher in Malaysia and Canada, I have observed that when I planned lessons that incorporated students’ home languages, such as the multilingual story-writing activity, students like Vishva began to feel that they were the language experts in the class, and this built their confidence, and increased their engagement in learning. The interactions between my students were also livelier, as they began to collaborate with each other and help each other learn. Plan lessons that show your students that all their languages and cultures are welcome and valued in the classroom.
References: • Cummins, J., Bismilla, V., Chow, P., Cohen, S., Giampapa, F., Leoni, L., Sandhu, O., & Sastri, P. (2005). Affirming identity in multilingual classrooms. Educational Leadership, 63(1), 38–43. • Schweers, C. W. (1999). Using L1 in the L2 classroom. English Teaching Forum, 37(2), 6–9.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 78
CHAPTER TWENTY FOUR IN OUR COUNTRY (inspired by a Myanmar folktale from Htin Aung, 1962) Soe Marlar Lwin Singapore University of Social Sciences, Singapore
Ms. Marlar had been trying to get her students who were high-school graduates from different EFL countries in Asia mingle and participate more actively in class. “Today we are going to learn how to present a dispute and a judgement. But first let me tell you a story from my country, Myanmar”, announced Ms. Marlar. Once a poor traveller sat under a tree to have lunch which he had brought with him. His simple lunch consisted of plain rice and boiled vegetables. About five meters to the north from where he was sitting, there was a stall selling fried fish. The lady stall-owner watched the traveller eat his meal. When he finished, the stall-owner walked to him and demanded, “Give me a silver quarter, for the fried fish.” The traveller protested, “But I haven’t taken any fried fish.” “Everyone can see that you were enjoying your meal with the smell from my fried fish. Without it, how could your rice and boiled vegetable be so tasty?” the staller-owner insisted. Eventually, the dispute was brought to the Princess Learned-in-the-Law, who passed the following judgement. “Since the wind was indeed blowing from the north to the south, it cannot be denied that the wind did carry the smell of frying fish to the traveller as he sat eating. So, he must pay the price. But let the stall-owner and the traveller go into the sunlight, let the traveller hold out the silver quarter, and let the woman take the shadow cast by that silver quarter. If the price of fried fish is a silver quarter, the price of its smell must be the shadow of a silver quarter.” “In our country, we had a similar story” said one student. “We also have a learned man who’s very clever in solving problems like that, but he was a wise man, not a princess”, said another. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 79
Teacher Development Series
a
“In our country, we don’t use silver quarters. We count money differently”, was heard from another student. What followed was one of the most participative and enjoyable lessons with students sharing about their cultures. What an effective ice-breaker a folktale can be for a class of culturally diverse students.
Objectives: 1. To develop skills in the presentation of a dispute and a judgement. 2. To develop intercultural awareness.
Procedure: 1. Ask students to answer or discuss the following: a. What is a dispute and how is it presented in paragraph 2? How many viewpoints can you identify in the paragraph? Are they conforming to or competing with each other? b. What are the reporting verbs used in paragraph 2? How do they help to achieve the purpose of the paragraph? c. Can we switch the sequence of paragraphs 2 and 3? Why/not? d. Underline the conjunctions used in paragraph 3. What are their functions? How do they help to present a judgement? 2. Have students work in pairs or small groups and come up with either an oral presentation or a written assignment presenting a dispute and a judgement. 3. As a follow-up activity, ask students to make/write an evaluation of the judgement made by their peers. 4. In a classroom with students from different cultures, have students share similar tales from their respective cultures. Follow up with questions to make comparisons such as: a. Does the tale from your culture present the dispute and judgement in a similar pattern? b. Does it contain similar or different narrative contents – e.g. what was the dispute about? What about the characters’ names, action, food, etc.? Does any of these have a special meaning in your culture? Why do you think these types of food, action, money, etc. were featured in the tale? 5. Research on the life and work of a learned person featured prominently in your culture. Present your findings (supported with evidence from sources) to the class.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 80
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: There seems to be a misconception that folktales are only for young children. For more mature learners, folktales can actually be used to develop an understanding of discourse structures and lexico-grammatical features typically used in texts for different purposes. Folktales are brief and their storylines straightforward enough to be told during a lesson. Familiar themes and predictability of their narrative structures could motivate learners to listen or read with confidence and give them more cognitive space to pay attention to language features, such as the writer’s or teller’s choices of verbs, conjunctions, etc. to achieve the purpose of a specific paragraph or text. Folktales can also be used as a pedagogical springboard to provide learners with opportunities to communicate and negotiate each other’s cultural identity or identities in a culturally diverse environment (Lwin, 2016). Through comparisons of narrative structures and contents in the tales with similar themes from different countries, similarities and differences among cultures can be highlighted for discussion as a way to promote learners’ intercultural awareness.
References: • Htin Aung, M. (1962). Burmese law tales. London: Oxford University Press. • Lwin, S. M. (2016). Promoting language learners’ cross-cultural awareness through comparative analysis of Asian folktales. TEFLIN Journal, 27(2), 166181.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 81
CHAPTER TWENTY FIVE EASY FOR TEACHER, BUT NOT FOR STUDENTS Spenser Edward Lemaich Universitas Islam Negeri Antasari, Indonesia
American teacher Sam was teaching Indonesian students at a school. In one class activity, the students had to match “foods” with “meals”. The activity included a list of foods and pictures: waffles, soup, sandwiches, pizza, and more. The students were stuck. Sam thought to himself, “This activity is so easy. Why are they having so much trouble with this?” He wondered how he could help them do the task faster. “Let’s think about this together,” he said. “Maya (he called on a student), what do you usually have for breakfast?” “Fish with rice,” Maya answered. Sam frowned. Fish and rice for breakfast? He was surprised to hear this. He could not imagine eating that for breakfast. He turned to another student and asked, “What do you usually have for lunch?” She answered, “Fish and rice.” Another student spoke up without being asked, “Chicken and rice, Sir!” Confused, Sam asked one more student, “What do you usually have for dinner?” The student answered, “Chicken and rice.” Sam was puzzled. He thought this activity would be so easy for his students. He was starting to realize that the world of his textbooks was based on a different culture than the world of his students, with different habits, and ideas of normal. The daily life described in his textbook was very different from that of his students.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 82
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To identify cultural assumptions in language teaching materials. 2. To raise awareness of the need/opportunity that teachers have to increase students’ cross-cultural competence.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the story and discuss these questions: a. What do you usually have for breakfast/lunch/dinner? b. What do you think Sam usually has for breakfast/lunch/dinner? c. Do you think your daily menu is more similar to Sam’s or that of his students? d. Why might Sam have thought this was an “easy” activity? e. Why was the activity hard for Sam’s students? f. Would you find the activity difficult or easy? Why? g. Culture can be described as ‘what people do,’ and also ‘how people think’. Which of these do you think is relevant to this story about Sam and his students? h. Do you think it is important to discuss culture when teaching a language? Why or why not? Explain your opinion. 2. Ask students for other examples from class (as students or teachers) in which the materials represented a different culture than that of the students in class. Describe the materials and the class setting. 3. Out-of-class assignment: a. Ask the students find a textbook with another example of culturally dependent materials (i.e. clothing/seasons/appliances/chores, etc.). b. Ask them to describe two cultures’ perspective on the topic. 4. Out-of-class task: a. Ask the students to find a film or TV show clip in which someone acts out some cultural assumptions. The cultural assumptions or norms may relate to posture, eye-contact, indirect questions, gender roles, personal/physical space, authority/hierarchy, politeness, or other topics (see Wintergerst & McVeigh, 2011 for a comprehensive list of cultural topics). b. Ask the students to explain what they think the assumption is, and support it with evidence from an online source about the relevant culture.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 83
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: Some ELT practitioners find a fine line between introducing elements of nativeEnglish-speaking cultures in classroom teaching (Wintergerst & McVeigh, 2011) and influencing students to become like citizens of Western countries (Kirkpatrick, 2007). Most teachers would agree that their goal is not to force anyone to think or act like citizens of Western countries but to help students of all cultures better understand each other, and their unique assumptions. As a uniquely international language, using English can facilitate greater crosscultural understanding, as users from different backgrounds communicate, who naturally have unique ways of seeing and understanding the world. Teachers can begin to cultivate this skill of cross-cultural understanding in their students, in the language classroom. A traditional greeting in Indonesia is, “Mau ke mana?,” which can be translated as, “Where are you going?” Many foreigners visiting Indonesia know the literal meaning of the phrase, but do not recognize why they are being asked the question. They do not understand its cultural significance- as a way of recognizing or acknowledging someone. Consequently, foreigners often feel their privacy is being violated, which is not at all the intent of this warm greeting. In this case, and many others, knowing words is not enough. Users must also learn the cultural significance of those words. By helping students to understand cultural assumptions in other parts of the world, teachers empower students to better understand the world in which they live, decide how they will use English on their own, and even determine the way that English will be used in the world of tomorrow.
References: • Kirkpatrick, A. (2007). World Englishes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Wintergerst, A. C., & McVeigh, J. (2011). Tips for teaching culture: Practical approaches to intercultural communication. White Plains, NY: Pearson Longman.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 84
Engaging Students in Meaningful Activities
CHAPTER TWENTY SIX PRACTICE BEFORE SPEED Grant Eckstein Brigham Young University, U.S.A
As a child, I remember watching an episode of a popular cooking show in which the chef had invited two children, a boy and a girl, to help him. They were making gnocchi, potato-based pasta which required the children to roll out long strings of dough with their hands and then chop those strings into several short pieces using a kitchen knife. Being an expert, the chef quickly rolled out his dough, laid it on the counter, and then began chopping it every few centimeters at lightning speed. I was amazed at his talent, and so too were his young helpers. They both rolled out their dough, and then the boy took up his knife and began chopping as fast as he could. It was reckless mayhem! The knife was moving dangerously through the air while making uneven, scattered, and ineffective cut marks on the dough. As a viewer, I was terrified that the boy would cut his fingers or hurt someone. The chef too looked worried, but he handled the situation by calmly and kindly getting the boy to stop. He then knelt down next to the boy and whispered just loud enough for the microphone to pick up his message: “Learn to cut the right way, and then speed will come.” It was a masterful and universal lesson. The chef’s words have inspired me and my students in language learning situations ever since. When I want so desperately to use fluent discourse despite being new to a language, I remind myself to practice language skills and then speed will come. When my students express anguish at their limited English, I remind them that speed is a natural byproduct of careful practice. “In language learning as in cooking,” I say, “practice comes before speed.”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 86
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To empathize with students who struggle with language learning and/or motivation. 2. To develop a personalized message of encouragement to share with English language students.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 87
Teacher Development Series
a
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the story and consider the following questions: a. How did the boy’s skill differ from the skill of the chef? b. How do you think the boy felt when he saw the chef quickly and effortlessly chopping the gnocchi dough? c. How might the boy have felt about his own kitchen skills, especially compared to those of the chef’s? How might he have felt when the chef stopped him and spoke about practicing? d. How was the chef’s reaction to the boy’s behavior an example of good teaching? e. The chef said “Learn to cut the right way, and then speed will come.” What does this quote mean? How can it be related to language learning? How can it be related to language teaching? 2. As a homework assignment, ask the students to develop their own story of struggle and success that they can share with English language students. The writing guideline is presented as follows: a. Think of a time in your life when you used to struggle to do something quickly (e.g., playing a sport, developing a musical talent, learning a language). How did it feel to struggle? What kinds of mistakes or failures did you encounter while practicing? How did it feel comparing yourself to someone with greater proficiency? What did you do and how/what did you practice to become more proficient? What made success possible for you? b. Write down your story of struggle and success, emphasizing your struggle and the feelings that came as part of that struggle. Be honest and revealing about your emotions. c. To help structure the story, use this organizational tool: • Indicate the problem or limitation you experienced as well as the emotions that accompanied it • Explain actions you took to increase your ability (what and how you practiced) as well as the emotions that came with them • Describe the success you felt after you successfully increased your ability as well as the emotions associated with your success • Relate your experience to the language-learning journey of the students you do (or will) teach d. Come to class prepared to share your story with fellow students. e. If you are currently teaching a language class, relate your story to your students and then share how it went with your peers. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 88
Teacher Development Series
a
Reflection: Everyone struggles to develop skills in life, but not everyone takes the time to think about the often long and demanding process associated with gaining proficiency. Furthermore, successful people often emphasize their success rather than the journey that led to their success. The activity presented above helps teachers remember their journey and the accompanying emotions so they can empathize with their students who are currently in the thick of language development. The activity further emphasizes the importance of practice, which is a fundamental part of developing any kind of proficiency.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 89
CHAPTER TWENTY SEVEN MY STUDENTS ALWAYS SIGH WHEN I ASSIGN HOMEWORK Benjamin Moorhouse Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong Kong
This is the story of an English language teacher called Jane. All of Jane’s students loved her lessons. They were always lively and engaging. She provided her students with lots of opportunities to talk and play in English. However, at the end of the lesson, when Jane stopped everyone and assigned them their English language homework, the whole class would sigh. The mood shifted from one of joy to one of sadness. When Jane spoke to other teachers about this, they all said something similar, “Students don’t like English language homework, but they have to do it! It’s good for them!” Jane decided to ask her students why they always sigh when she assigns English language homework. Here’s what they said: Tom said, “The homework is boring!” Sam said, “The homework is too easy!” Tina said, “The homework is too difficult!” Sarah said, “My parents don’t speak English, I have no one to help me at home!” Gary said, “It takes too long!” Eric said, “I don’t know what to do!” Mandy said, “I don’t know why I have to do the homework!” Melanie said, “Homework is always vocabulary and grammar worksheets, I want to do something else!” Natalie said, “I always get a C!”
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 90
Teacher Development Series
a
Jane soon realised that the students all had different reasons for sighing and that she had to reflect on her current practices and think long and hard about how to address them. Then she had an idea – choice! “I’ll provide them with a variety of different homework activities to choose from,” she thought, “Then they can do the homework activities that meet their interests, abilities, time and family support! I’ll call it homework Pick n’ Mix, just like the sweets they like!”
Objectives: 1. To develop students’ (teacher trainees’) awareness of the issues associated with standardised English language homework practices. 2. To increase students’ (teacher trainees’) awareness that there are ways to better cater for different student needs by providing them with different homework activities to choose from.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to discuss how they felt about homework when they were at school and how their students feel about homework now. Discuss why they may feel this way. 2. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to read the story and discuss the following questions: a. Why do the students sigh when Jane assigns them homework? b. Why does Jane assign homework? Why do teachers assign homework? What are the benefits of doing homework? c. Why does each student respond with a different reason? d. Do your students or students you know feel the same way? e. What does Jane hope to achieve by providing her students with choice? 3. Ask the students (teacher trainees) of what some of the issues with standardized homework practices can be (where every student gets the same homework). 4. Introduce the idea of a homework grid with different homework activities of various levels of challenges but have similar learning objectives (see Moorhouse, 2016 for examples). Let the teacher trainees know that by providing students with greater amount of choice they will be more motivated and develop greater learner autonomy. Let them know that not all the activities have to be different. They can also provide the same reading
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 91
Teacher Development Series
a
passage but with different questions or allow students to choose how many questions they answer. 5. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to think of something they are teaching now; it could be a grammar item, vocabulary list, reading passage or anything from their curriculum. Ask them to think of different activities they could assign to their students for homework. 6. Ask the teacher trainees to share their ideas and how they might be able to bring some kinds of choice into their homework practices.
Reflection: Homework is often neglected in English language teacher education programmes, even though it is a common practice around the world (Moorhouse, 2017). Teachers seldom reflect on their homework practices or may feel powerless to make changes to their homework practices. They may spend time thinking about how to improve their lessons and how to help their students in the classroom but not beyond it. This story ‘My students always sigh when I assign homework’ will be familiar to many teachers and will hopefully help them reflect more on their practices. The homework grid provides them with a way to give their students choices of homework activities. Although providing choice may not be an option for everyone, the story can stimulate teachers to think about their homework practices from their students’ perspectives.
References: • Moorhouse, B. (2016). Giving young learners a choice of homework. Modern English Teacher, 25(3), 26-27. • Moorhouse, B. (2017). The importance of including homework in our teacher training programmes. The Teacher Trainer Journal, 31 (3), 2-4.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 92
CHAPTER TWENTY EIGHT FACING DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOUR María D. García-Pastor University of Valencia, Spain Fourteen years ago, I got a summer job at an international school in Calicanto, a small town in the region of Valencia, Spain, to teach children English. There I was my first day with my notes and some worksheets, ready to go. That day was difficult, since I was not familiar with the school, I didn’t know the kids, and it was my first time teaching English to young learners. At the beginning, I was confident that I was going to succeed in making those kids learn English, but soon I became disappointed. The children would be paying attention for one minute, and immediately after, they would start moving around, playing with each other, and being noisy. A few of them would be drawing on their notebooks, and others would even be saying nasty things to each other, which would end up in a fight. I then began to feel upset, and it got to the point that I didn’t feel like going to work. I talked to another teacher in the school and she was very helpful. Soon after, I decided to start from scratch, and I prepared a story to tell the kids the next day. I made them sit in a U-shape, and I acted out the story with puppets. Although they were talking a lot at first, they soon remained silent, listening to my story very attentively, and reacting to it positively. From then on, things got better, and I started to plan my lessons differently.
Objectives: 1. To raise awareness of disruptive behaviour. 2. To develop management strategies. 3. To develop story writing skill.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 93
Teacher Development Series
a
Procedure: 1. Have the students organised in small groups. Ask them to read the story and answer or discuss the following questions: a. b. c. d. e. f. g.
Do you know a teacher like the one in this story? Have you ever felt like this teacher? Did you talk to anyone about it? Who? Was s/he helpful? Please explain. Did you/the teacher you know do something to change the situation? If not, why? If so, what did you/the teacher you know do? Each group should write down suggestions. h. Were you/the teacher you know successful? Please explain 1) which suggestions produced a positive change; 2) which suggestions did not produce a change; and 3) which suggestions produced a negative change. Please note that the same suggestion may fall under more than one category. i. Why do you think the teacher in this story was successful? 2. Ask the students to answer or discuss the following questions: a. b. c. d. e. f.
Do you know children like the ones in this story? How would you define disruptive behaviour? What are its features? Have you ever behaved this way? Why? Did your behaviour change? Please explain. How did you feel? Please explain. How can we deal with disruptive behaviour?
3. As out-of-class assignment, have students work in the same groups. They should come up with a digital story in which each group provides their description of disruptive behaviour, their suggestions to deal with it, and their personal experiences regarding such behaviour. The aim of this activity is to raise awareness of disruptive behaviour (its pervasiveness, its effects (physical and emotional) in people, etc.). The activity also intends to help students develop management strategies and share their experiences. a. The digital stories are made using any video editing program. b. Each digital story consists of: • Overview. The students collect instances of disruptive behaviour (pictures, video/audio excerpts, newspaper highlights, etc.), and offer suggestions to deal with it, as previously discussed. • The personal experience. The students share their experiences concerning disruptive behaviour. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 94
Teacher Development Series
a
• The conclusion. The students reflect upon disruptive behaviour and how to deal with it. c. The overview and the reflection should be in the Present Tense, whilst the personal experience is in the Past Tense. d. Each group is asked to develop a script. e. Each group needs to meet the teacher regularly to consult any aspect of their digital story production and the script. 4. Ask the students to upload the digital stories in social media to reach a wider audience and have the students watch the digital stories in class for a general discussion.
Reflection: Disruptive behaviour is increasingly common nowadays. It can be found in educational settings and can affect teachers and students. The story Facing Disruptive Behaviour intends to show this reality and convey the idea that we can change such harmful conduct, if we look for help and try. The questions for discussion aim to sensitize the students towards disruptive behaviour and make them reflect upon this kind of social conduct by encouraging them to identify with the teacher in the story, whilst also adopting the perspective of the children. Additionally, they aim to develop behaviours and attitudes that help them be successful in dealing with disruptive behaviour. The production of a digital story can positively contribute to achieving these aims, since it affords learners the opportunity to organise their thoughts and experiences in a coherent and meaningful manner, and practice writing a story that may be helpful to others.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 95
CHAPTER TWENTY NINE IMPASSIONING RELUCTANT WRITERS Erina M. Hunt University of Otago Language Centre, New Zealand
Faisal was typical of many enthusiastic Middle Eastern students with a delightful penchant for the oral narrative, his traditional culture being strongly oral, but the minute pen was put to paper or fingers to keyboard for writing assignments, Faisal found the urgency for an appointment elsewhere. The spoken form as a vehicle, modern mass media and communication technologies, means that given strategic planning, it is quite possible for writing to be avoided. This was Faisal’s specialty; spelling and handwriting were not. The class members were engaged by his energy and he interacted smoothly with all, but his Houdini disappearing acts during writing classes had become an inclass joke. One day, in order to delve further into the critical thinking model while preparing to write on the topic of apartheid, I alighted on a thought that might just capture the wayward Faisal’s interest. I announced that writing class today was only going to include looking at images and collaborative group discussion. I said this while simultaneously displaying a projected Internet-sourced image of five white eggs sporting menacing cartoon faces surrounding a brown egg lying smashed, yolk oozing, at their ‘feet’. There were some muttering, giggling, and occasional words called out. “Discrimination” “Bully” “Sad” “Brown” “Egg” Once the class was arranged into small groups, spirited and passionate discussions ensued as students shared their own experiences and opinions stimulated by the image. Ideas were elicited and shared and the whiteboard became awash with relevant (correctly-spelled) vocabulary as useful prompts for writing.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 96
Teacher Development Series
a
The oral sharing of ideas as a springboard to writing and the support of the specific vocabulary items enabled Faisal to launch into writing a critical response with far less resistance than ever before. His animation infected us all and resulted in a published display of his work on the classroom wall.
Objectives: 1. To consider ways in which reluctant writers can be motivated 2. To energise the collective classroom by stimulating critical thinking and the production of written work through oral discussion and role-play 3. To raise confidence in enabling learners to write more academically about fundamental concepts using extended vocabulary
Procedure: 1. Prior to reading, discuss as a whole class reasons why a student may be reluctant to write. Elicit the ideas and list these on the board. Also list suggestions as to how this could be resolved. 2. Read the story and identify the key players: the teacher, Faisal (reluctant writer) and the additional classmates (non-reluctant writers). Highlight any of the ideas previously elicited that might have had similar bearing on Faisal’s reluctance and his teacher’s decision to employ the use of an image as a prompt. 3. Arrange the learners in groups of 4 or 5. Randomly issue ‘role’ cards (groups will have 2 or 3 ‘classmates’ depending on the size of group, 1 teacher, and a ‘Faisal’); the teacher is also issued a prop. 4. Allow them time in their groups to prepare a role-play that identifies and highlights the following parts of the narrative, using wh- questioning: a. The background (to Faisal’s reluctance) b. The issue (in class) c. The solution (decided by the teacher) d. The result (for everyone) 5. Decide if your student group is able to do this ‘off the cuff’ or will require the support of preparatory scripting. If scripting is needed (this reinforces the objective of writing with a purpose), then factor a time allowance. 6. Ask the groups to perform their role-play in front of the whole class. 7. Homework: a. Issue the image used above to all learners to reflect on and respond to using one of these two tasks:
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 97
Teacher Development Series
a
b. Write a response about the challenges of writing and how images and the procedure the teacher undertook may incite critical thinking. c. Write your own critical response to the image. Go beyond the superficiality of what you see to what issues you think the image is portraying. Use personal anecdote if relevant.
Reflection: There is a need to encourage reluctant writers, and those learners unfamiliar with ‘free-voice’ to express their ideas (any ideas!) safely and without judgment. There is also a need to stimulate a depth of critical thinking beyond the superficiality of ‘what I can see or know’ or ‘what I think the teacher wants to read or hear’. This can be implemented at any level and in any classroom, simply and successfully. By not focusing on mechanical controlled composition, process (apart from editing), outcomes or assessment, this activity employs meaning –focused input and meaning-focused output by responding, not evaluating and by understanding the challenges faced by some learners and ways to inspire confidence in using personal ‘voice’ on paper. Reluctant writers often do not know where to start. They often feel they lack the vocabulary needed to express their ideas (feeling lost for words), or worry their ideas will not be ‘right’ or agreed upon by the teacher. This creates a fear or anxiety, particularly of grammatical inaccuracies. One biggest bugbear is that students can often express themselves satisfactorily in L1 but are dissatisfied with the transfer of ideas to L2 (writer’s block). However, the power of images can call on shared experiences, act as a springboard to elicit common vocabulary and language forms, stimulate learners’ attention leading to shared discussion and thus more meaningful writing content. “Pictures work really well as spurs to written production. They incite and stimulate” (Harmer, 2004, p.67)
Reference: • Harmer, J. (2004). How to teach writing. London: Pearson Education Ltd.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 98
CHAPTER THIRTY WHY DON’T YOU LIKE THAT TASK? Thi Ngoc Yen Dang University of Leeds, UK
One day I asked the students in my General English class to write a passage about a person that they admired. As I started the marking, I was very surprised when reading Nam’s assignment. Instead of completing the task, he wrote: ‘Sorry Teacher. I love English, but I don’t like this task at all’. In the next class, Nam seemed to be worried that I would be upset and would embarrass him by telling his case to other students. Understanding this, I delivered the lesson as normal without mentioning it. During the break, I came to talk with Nam. Because I usually chatted with students during the break, the other students did not notice that I was going to have a serious talk with Nam. “Why don’t you like the writing task?” I asked. “Because I didn’t like writing in my first language let alone in a foreign language”, Nam said, “and I don’t like the topic”. “Well, what is your dream? Would you like to work in a multinational company after graduation?” I asked. “Yes, of course,” Nam replied excitedly, “I want to earn a lot of money”. “To get that job, you’ll need to join an interview in English. People may ask about a person that you admire so that they can understand more about you,” I said, “now, do you see? Is the topic useful?” “Yeah,” Nam replied. “And how will you communicate with your non-Vietnamese colleagues? Do you need to write emails and reports in English?” I asked. “Yeah,” Nam replied. “So you need to practise writing in English, don’t you?” Nam did not reply. However, to my surprise, now, whenever I give the class a writing task, he completes it enthusiastically. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 99
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of various pedagogical scenarios. 2. To develop interview, oral presentation, and writing skills.
Procedure: 1. Inform the students that they are going to listen to a pedagogical scenario which they may have encountered or are going to encounter in their future teaching. 2. Tell the students the first part of the story and ask them to discuss the following questions: a. Have you ever experienced or do you know anyone having experienced a situation like the teacher in the story? b. If so, how did you or that person deal with this situation? c. If not, what would you do? 3. Tell the students the second part of the story and ask them to discuss the following questions: a. What do you think about the way that the teacher dealt with the situation? b. Based on your learning and teaching experience, do you have similar stories? Please share. 4. For the homework, have the students collect pedagogical scenarios and share them with their classmates. The students need to interview experienced teachers that they know to collect pedagogical scenarios. 5. In the next class, make a presentation about these scenarios and let the students vote for the most interesting scenario.
Reflection: There are always reasons for students’ lack of motivation to complete a learning task. The story is a reminder of the need for teachers to understand these reasons and to make students realize the importance of learning tasks and their relevance to students’ learning or career goals. In this way, students will be motivated to complete the tasks. The class discussion generates students’ ideas of how they will deal with the pedagogical scenario, which they may encounter in their future teaching. The activities of collecting pedagogical scenarios from experienced teachers, presenting them to their classmates, and writing reflections offer students opportunities to improve their interview, oral presentation, and writing skills as well as providing themselves with a set of pedagogical scenarios that they may need to deal with in their future teaching. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 100
Teacher Development Series
a
CHAPTER THIRTY ONE THE MOST IMPORTANT HOMEWORK OF THE YEAR Rob Waring Notre Dame Seishin University, Japan I first met Airi at orientation some years ago. Even then I could tell she had an ‘air’ about her. She didn’t quite fit into my class and wasn’t quite like the others. Maybe she seemed a bit too combative for Japanese society. I did not know. She was a puzzle. But my intuition told me something was wrong and this might be a tough year. That night, I got a call from my daughter: Mariko. She, like Airi, had just finished her first day of classes at her university. She called to say thank you. “For what?” I asked. “Daddy, I know what it’s taken for you to get me to university, how much you have worked and saved to give me my chance.” This caught my breath. As a father, I couldn’t help but cry. So in the next class, I told my freshmen what my daughter had said, and how it made me feel. I reminded the students how much it cost to send someone to university, and that if ever they felt like skipping class, or not doing homework, to remember that mum and dad were not skipping work to get the money to pay for their education. I told them their homework that night was to go home armed with some cakes or flowers, to sit their parents down, and make them cry. Airi did not come to class the rest of the week, but she came to see me at lunchtime on the Monday. I can tell she had been crying. Something was different, she seemed calm. Airi told me the week before she had started school, she had been fighting with her mother over wanting the latest new phone as a congratulations present, but her mother had said no. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 101
Teacher Development Series
a
But Mariko’s gesture made her think. She then told me that that evening after she had done her ‘homework,’ she watched her mother cry hopelessly for ten minutes. Airi had no idea a few words could mean so much. She had found out it would have cost all her mother’s earnings that month and she only wanted it just because her best friend didn’t have one. She stopped for a few seconds and cried a little, muttering “I’m the worst daughter in the world.” Airi told me that her mother had given up all hope that she cared about her family and thought she was ungrateful for what her parents had done for her. She apologized to me for being absent the previous week, but explained she had some important real ‘home’ work to do. She’d been spending all her time discovering a mother she never really knew. They could now talk as a mother and daughter for the first time in five years. Mission accomplished. Last month, I was invited to Airi’s wedding by her parents. They wanted to thank me. But really, they should want to meet Mariko.
Objectives: 1. To raise awareness of what people do for others. 2. To raise our own awareness of how we affect others.
Procedure: 1. Have the students list up all the things people have done for them in their lives, e.g. parents give them food and shelter; the basketball coach helped with their skills. They share some of these on the board. 2. Have them read (or read aloud to them) the above text. Then ask them to discuss the following questions: a. What was Airi like before she joined university? How do you think she became that way? b. Why did the author cry? c. Why had Airi’s mother given up on her? d. What did Airi have done to make her mother feel this way? e. Why had Airi been crying? f. What was Airi’s ‘home’ work? g. Who was Mariko? h. Why should she have been the one to be thanked? 3. Ask the students to look again at the list of things people had done for them. Can they add some more? Do they know what it costs to go to university / graduate from school etc.? List up all the things that need to be paid for. How long will it take them to save (not earn) this money? 4. Ask the students to write short stories with the theme of gratitude. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 102
Teacher Development Series
a
5. Ask them to share their stories with each other in the next class, and discuss how to write a “caring manifesto” for helping others and for being considerate and appreciative.
Reflection: It is easy to forget those that help us. Sometimes we also need to be taught, to be made aware of what we do and how we treat others as we go through our lives. Sometimes we learn from others, our teachers, our children and even ourselves. We need to look for a spark that needs to be encouraged. While we cannot predict what the future will hold even five years ahead, our students and teachers must be prepared for what the world will bring to us. Mindfulness training is a vital skill to develop in these busy times and a life skill to take forward into an uncertain future. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 103
Teacher Development Series
a
CHAPTER THIRTY TWO FAKE IT TILL YOU MAKE IT Cherie J. Brown Akita International University, Japan
Each student had to participate, using pre-taught strategies, in a whole-class discussion about a video they had watched. Participation would be assessed, the score counting towards the final grade. But Kei’s fear controlled her. After many tears, and tissues, she finally spoke “What can I do?” I recommended watching two powerful TED Talks, Amy Cuddy’s, “Your Body Language May Shape Who You Are”, and Susan Cain’s, “The Power of Introverts”, then return to see me. Cuddy’s talk explains the connection between body stance, brain chemistry and self-confidence. She suggests “Fake it until we make it.” In other words, we should imagine we are actors. This talk would help Kei, because although she felt nervous when being herself, she also belonged to the drama club, and had no problems performing as a different character. Cain’s talk explains that introversion is a normal personality trait. Kei needed to develop the belief that her contribution was as important as that of others. That she could ‘do it’. Next visit, a determined Kei arrived. However, she needed some practical strategies. The discussion would last for 30 minutes. Kei decided to participate three times, at predetermined points. She practiced useful interjection and opinion phrases, then, in class, applied her strategies very mechanically. The important thing was that she decided what to do, and how. She sought help, pushed through her fear, had a practical plan, and finally passed the course. Well done, Kei.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 104
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To demonstrate how body posture affects self-confidence and speaking performance.
Procedure: 1. Elicit and write up words describing emotions (e.g. fear, confidence etc.). 2. In pairs, the students take turns to pose, using their body to demonstrate each word. 3. Ask the students: a. Which poses made you feel confident? Which poses, less so? b. How did your body position affect your emotions? 4. Ask the students to read the above story and discuss the following questions: a. b. c. d.
How did Kei feel before the class discussion? What did Kei do to improve things? How did Kei feel after making her plan? Who was responsible for Kei’s success?
5. Tell the students that they will be ‘actors’ (Kei, ‘before’ and ‘after’). They should take turns to read the following passages to their partner.
Passage One (Kei, before) At first, I felt very nervous. I didn’t think I could speak in English in front of my classmates. I felt very worried and unhappy. I knew I had to take part in the discussion or I would lose points and perhaps I would also fail the course. I didn’t know what to do, so I cried and cried.
Passage Two (Kei, after) After I spoke to my teacher, I watched some videos. The first one showed me how to use my body confidently. The second one reminded me that I have good ideas and to share these. I decided to hold my head high and to relax my body. I also decided to take part three times in the discussion. I practiced before class, then watched the clock during the discussion so I knew when to speak. I did it!
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 105
Teacher Development Series
a
6. For the students with Passage One, they should: a. look only at the paper, hold it close to your body. b. make themselves as small as possible. c. not look at their partner. d. speak in a very quiet voice. 7. For the students with Passage Two, they should: a. hold the paper far away from their body. b. breathe deeply before beginning c. use a strong voice d. make themselves as large as possible e. look directly at their partner. f. smile 8. Finally, ask the students discuss which poses made them feel more confident and try to figure out the relationship between body posture and speaking confidence.
Reflection: Affective factors are as important in language learning as knowledge of the mechanics and vocabulary of that language. When learners lack of confidence, they can use this acting technique to ‘fake it’ (pretend to feel confident) until they ‘make it’ (actually feel confident). All learners have something worthwhile to contribute. It is our job to ensure everyone is supported in their journey to find their own ‘voice’ in the target language and to see that extroverts do not dominate classroom activities at the expense of more introverted learners. The story and activity presented here should be implemented with a sense of fun. Allow learners to experiment as much as possible, and to be noisy if they wish. You could follow up with reflective writing to allow each learner to express how the ideas in the lesson can help them become more confident English speakers. This is a preparatory lesson, useful before introducing large group discussions and when preparing for presentations and speeches. The story of Kei is a true story (though her name has been changed). Working with Kei, and seeing her determination to pass my course, was one of the most memorable experiences I have had as a teacher. I hope her story inspires you and your learners too.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 106
Teacher Development Series
a
CHAPTER THIRTY-THREE SPEAK UP Stefanus Angga B. Prima Universitas Agung Podomoro, Indonesia Dang Arif Hartono Universitas Agung Podomoro, Indonesia
Ms. Athalia, an English lecturer, was observing a small group discussion in her public speaking class. Suddenly, there was a little heated argument between two students in one of the small groups. This forced her to come closer to them and asked, “What is happening here?” “Glenn is always correcting my grammar and pronunciation whenever I make a mistake,” Candra, a student, replied. Glenn then shrugged his shoulders and said, “I’m just making sure that he won’t confuse native speakers with his grammar or pronunciation mistakes.” Glenn is known for his fluent English because he has ever lived in Europe when his father was working there. In contrast, Candra’s English was not as fluent as Glenn’s and Ms. Athalia knew that Candra was a bold student as he always tried to participate to speak up in class despite of his average English fluency and accuracy skill. After giving a little bit of a thought, Ms. Athalia told the two students, “That’s good that you know how to spot English grammar or pronunciation errors, Glenn. But, you might want to see if the errors would significantly change the message that Candra was trying to deliver. For this small group discussion, my focus is to encourage students to talk in English with classmates. If you got paused every time you make a mistake, I’m afraid it’ll discourage students from speaking up. We’ll focus on that ‘grammar and pronunciation’ in another occasion.” Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 107
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To promote students’ (teacher trainees’) awareness of giving encouragement to speak up in speaking class 2. To develop lesson or teaching plan to encourage students to speak up.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students (teacher trainees) about their opinion or experience of correcting students’ grammar or pronunciation errors. 2. After discussing that, ask the trainees to read the story and discuss the following questions: a. Do you ever have a student like Glenn? b. What is the best approach to correct students’ pronunciation and grammar errors? What are your considerations? c. How important is ‘native-like’ English pronunciation for your class? d. Would you answer differently if you were the teacher in the story? e. What is your preferred approach on teaching speaking and pronunciation or grammar in speaking class? 3. Give a short explanation on corrective feedback and ask the students (trainees) to read Types of Corrective Feedback by Tedick, Gortari, and Glen (1998). 4. Ask the students (trainees) to make a group of four to create a lesson plan for a speaking class where its students are encouraged to speak up.
Reflection: Sometimes, as English teachers, we are obsessed to teach our students to sound like native speakers of English. To achieve that, some of us give them corrective feedback quite liberally and without us knowing, some of the students will refrain themselves from speaking up. They might become discouraged as their flow of sentences are cut by our explicit corrections. By reading the story above, teachers’ candidate will hopefully realize that intelligibility should be the focus, not only that perfect ‘native-like’ English. Teachers candidate will also be more aware of the right timing to give invasive corrective feedbacks. In short, in a speaking class, encouraging students to speak up without being paused of invasive corrective feedbacks would contribute more positively to their speaking fluency. Knowing which corrective feedbacks to use, or when to Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 108
Teacher Development Series
a
refrain ourselves from giving too frequent ones, would also improve the students’ confidence to speak.
Reference: • Tedick, D. J., De Gortari, B., & Glen, F. (1998). Research on error correction and implications for classroom teaching. ACIE Newsletter (1)3, 1-6.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 109
CHAPTER THIRTY FOUR UNDERSTANDING LEARNERS’ INNERMOST FEELINGS Sakae Onoda Juntendo University, Japan
Shota Onoda taught high school English in Japan. With extensive experience in the US, he was confident about teaching advanced students. Soon after Shota began teaching, he noticed that one student, Yuji, kept looking at him with sharp eyes. Shota thought that Yuji was interested in English, but when he asked Yuji for his opinion, Yuji looked nervous and ignored him. This happened repeatedly. Shota asked another teacher about Yuji. She answered: “He’s hard to please; ignore him.” Shota followed her suggestion and tried not to pay any attention to Yuji. One day, Shota came across Yuji at the swimming pool. Yuji had won a swimming competition. As soon as their eyes met, Shota said: “Congratulations, Yuji. That was amazing.” Yuji's face radiated with pleasure, and he began talking to Shota about many things, including learning English, as if he were a different person. Through this casual talk, Shota found out that Yuji had spent several years in the US and had high English skills. He wanted to talk to Shota because he thought they shared similar experiences. What prevented him from speaking was his miserable experience of isolation in his classes because of his fluent English. He said, “Mr. Onoda, I’m sorry I didn’t answer your questions, but don’t get me wrong: I don’t want to stand out and for others to look askance at me.” Shota said: “Don’t worry; you can speak your mind. I’ll use discussions in class so that everyone can speak freely. I want you to help me teach the students in English.” Yuji gladly accepted the offer. Soon, he began actively participating in class and expressing his views. His classmates appreciated his help, looked up to him, and learned from him, and he was well-liked by all the other teachers. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 110
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To help students make predictions and inferences and adjusting these as they read. 2. To help students enjoy easy but inspirational anecdotes, understand their appealing features, and learn how they can retell them effectively to readers and listeners.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to form pairs and discuss the question: “What makes students unwilling to actively participate in class?” 2. Ask the students to listen to Paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 read by the teacher, and discuss the nature of Yuji's problem in groups of three. 3. Ask groups of students to report their ideas to the class, write them on the board, and elicit comments to be shared with the class. 4. Ask the students in groups of three to read the first sentence of Paragraph 4 (“Through this casual talk...”) and discuss what caused Yuji's classroom behavior, what suggestions Shota made, and how Yuji's attitude changed. They report their ideas to the class, listen to the teacher’s narration, and check their predictions. 5. Students write in 10 minutes about their learning difficulties, any low motivation that may result, and how they solve these problems. Then, they form pairs and talk about what they wrote with their partner for 3 minutes and elicit the partner’s response. This story-telling is repeated with two other partners.
Reflection: In Japan, learners are often not interested in reading activities because they require substantial grammar and vocabulary knowledge and teachers teach reading mainly for exams. One solution is an extensive reading program that encourages learners to read interesting stories with only a few new words (Nation, 2013). An inspirational story based on an anecdote is highly suitable because it draws readers’ attention and engages them emotionally. Inspirational narratives also help improve speaking and writing fluency. This can be assisted by repeated story-telling based on anecdotes because frequent exposure to vocabulary facilitates automatization and helps improve fluency. It also enhances learners’ self-efficacy, the willingness to communicate in English, and interactional skills (Onoda, 2017). Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 111
Teacher Development Series
a
The effects of inspirational story-telling on L2 learning should be explained to pre- and in-service teachers as this knowledge will expand their teaching potential and in turn help them foster autonomous learners.
References: • Nation, I. S. P. (2013). What should every ESL teacher know? Tokyo: Compass Publishing. • Onoda, S. (2017). Exploring teaching techniques for encouraging students to use English in class. In R. Raúl & A. Lopes (Eds.), Current issues in language teaching (pp. 111–122). Madrid: Editorial Académica Española.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 112
CHAPTER THIRTY FIVE YES, YOU CAN DOODLE Malu Sciamarelli The C Group, Brazil Claire was only 7 years old when I first saw her in my classroom. Her English learning had been a disaster, at least as far as her past teachers were concerned. She was a disruption to the entire class, one minute with her head down and her long black hair covering her face while fidgeting noisily, then muttering unintelligible utterances, and the next doing something to disturb the other children around her. Claire wasn’t particularly concerned about my reaction as she was used to being told she would never learn English and do well at school by other teachers and her own parents. One day, I realised there were many coloured pencils on her desk. When I got closer to her, I saw she was doodling all over her textbook. She immediately looked at me and said, ‘Don’t worry, Miss. I will erase it all.’ Her doodles were so beautiful! How could I ask her to erase such artwork? She continued, ‘All the other teachers are always mad at me when they see what I do, but I can’t help it.’ I told her not to erase anything and encouraged her to keep on drawing but in a proper notebook. She was so surprised I was not angry and actually liked her work. From that day on, she started to behave differently. Not only did Claire start to pay attention to all classes, but she was also the most participative and talkative of all students. Her English level has improved considerably and she has even written detailed descriptions for the beautiful characters she has drawn over the last two years. Had I not encouraged her drawings on that day, she might still be the same difficult student. Nowadays she is a happy girl who always wants to learn something new.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 113
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To recognise each person has talents 2. To acknowledge the power of encouragement 3. To develop creative writing skills
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 114
Teacher Development Series
a
Procedure: 1. Share the following quote by Ken Robinson: ‘We all have distinctive talents and passions that can inspire us to achieve far more than we may imagine. Understanding this changes everything’ (Robinson and Aronica, 2010, p.8). Have the students discuss in pairs what talents and passions they have and would like to have. 2. Allow time for the students to read the story ‘Yes, You can Doodle’ and discuss their thoughts about the questions below with their partners: a. Do you think Claire should be drawing in her English class? Why / why not? b. What do you think of her previous teachers’ actions? What could have been different? c. Why did the teacher encourage Claire to keep on drawing? d. From your point of view, was it the right thing to do? e. Have you always paid attention to all your classes? Why / why not? f. If you have not, what were you doing? g. What was your teacher’s behaviour? How did you feel about it? h. Has a teacher ever encouraged your talents and passions? 3. As homework, ask each pair of students to choose one story of how a teacher’s support encouraged their talents and passions and have them write it using Storyboardthat. All the stories should be in the Past Tense and should contain at least one inversion. 4. At end of the story, each pair should write a haiku using Think.Read.Write haiku generator thanking their teacher for the encouragement and inspiration. It should be written in the Present Tense. 5. Print out the story boards and the haikus and make a mural in the classroom or create a blog to share all the stories online.
Reflection: The world is changing faster than at any time in human history. As educators, we need to understand the diversity of human talents and passions and the extraordinary potential for growth and development. The story Yes, You can Doodle acknowledges that all educators should create environments where every student is inspired to find their own talents and passions to build their own future. Moreover, the classroom activities and discussions encourage students to look back at specific teachers who have inspired them and changed their lives. Finally, the story and the haiku writing Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 115
Teacher Development Series
a
help students to create a sense of wonder at the world, teach them about life, about themselves and about others. Creative writing is a unique way for students to develop an understanding, respect and appreciation for others and it will inspire not only everyone around them, but also the wider community online.
Reference: • Robinson, K. & Aronica, L. (2010). The Element. How Finding Your Passion Changes Everything. London: Penguin Books
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 116
CHAPTER THIRTY SIX FACING UP TO YOUR DIGITAL FOOTPRINT Stephen J. Hall Sunway University, Malaysia Many English language learners are active in the language on-line. They construct their own ideas of who they are in places like Facebook. In this story, the large part of the learner’s life was and is Facebook. As a teacher I react happily when told that something I taught has changed how a learner appreciates a big part of his or her life, including their online self. Let me use the name Raju, for he who interrupted the start of my lesson on digital literacy in an English for Information Technology class. Raju commented that I was too old to really understand Facebook and being online. Another student chimed in with “Facebook, Snapchat and Instagram are our world sir, not yours”. I replied that language and communication are also about being aware of what we do online with effective vocabulary and well-chosen images. I asked Raju to take over the computer I was using. It had a large screen display, which all the class could see. He then searched on line for himself, including Facebook. There he was and some of it was not very pretty, as he was clearly an active party goer. He switched from Facebook and there were still other images on other platforms- more of the same. I then suggested he search for me as I know I have a structured, carefully designed digital footprint. The class discussion then moved to the differences in what was on-line for each of us and the kind of adjectives and responses the images could create. We describe ourselves with words and images on line. Raju then asked an important question. “Will these words and images of me go away? Can I delete them? If not someone who wants to hire me might find them.” When I replied that it is difficult to erase images and past traces, he replied that he was going to do something about this. In the lesson a week later, Raju said he wanted to show the class what he had done. He had built a website which included positive descriptions of himself as an Information Technology entrepreneur. He had created a new Facebook page Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 117
Teacher Development Series
a
and he shared lots of adjectives describing his self- image with his class mates. He came to me and said that he would never again use age to comment on being digitally literate. He remarked that what we had learnt together helped him to become more aware of himself as an on-line citizen.
Objectives: 1. To develop an awareness of one’s present digital footprint and possible reactions. 2. To reflect on how we see ourselves on line and to use positive adjectives in building an image. 3. To identify, use and create a specific online persona for future professional use.
Procedure: Task 1 Ask the students to read the story and answer the following questions: 1. What did you learn from Raju in the story? 2. If you were the teacher described in this story, what would you have done to Raju and why? 3. Why do you think the author wrote this story?
Task 2 1. Ask the learners to access their Facebook pages on their phones. 2. Write a short sentence or groups of adjectives based on what they see. Then as a class, brainstorm and share personal description adjectives. 3. The teacher can use different colours to show positive and negative qualities. This provides support for those with less vocabulary. 4. For advanced learners there can be discussion on the gradations of positive personal and professional qualities, such as confident, active, outgoing etc, Then, in pairs, get learners to write adjectives or a slogan for what they see on their Facebook socially and publically. 5. Discuss the gaps if any between the ideal and what is on line at present. Stress links between images and words. Share and pair will make for more vocabulary learning focussed on positive descriptive adjectives.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 118
Teacher Development Series
a
Task 3 1. Ask learners to look at a favourite website of a person they admire. Discuss why it appeals. Elicit adjectives which the first page or landing page of the website creates. Describe the importance of accurate language for belief, bonding and buy-in by readers. The role of the look of the page should be balanced with the content. 2. Using the vocabulary from responding to the websites, each learner writes a tagline or three or four adjectives for themselves. They can think about the career they want to have and the qualities needed for that future job.
Task 4 1. If resources permit, learners can create their own revamped Facebook page, blog, website or resume.
Reflection: Few users of Facebook and other social media are aware of how much information is being data mined and are really conscious of how they may be seen. Many younger users may not see the implications for possible careers and may not know how to describe themselves for future employers with wellchosen adjectives. A conscious literacy which links images with self-perception and an understanding of positive adjectives for personal qualities can make a difference. The activities also generate vocabulary for resume writing.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 119
CHAPTER THIRTY SEVEN TIME TO RETHINK OUR USE OF TECHNOLOGY IN THE CLASSROOM Moonyoung Park Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
A young English teacher, Mr. Park, was leaving the principal’s office with a heavy heart. It was already his second time being reprimanded by the principal for wasting class time demonstrating use of online resources. The principal, a former English teacher himself, strongly believed that students learn best from lectures and should be taught to the test. The next day, when planning an upcoming English class on informal letter writing, Mr. Park found himself at a loss for what to do. His original plan was to take the students to a computer lab to find real e-pals from an e-pal website and send the e-pals a self-introduction email. Thinking over the activity, he grew calm and confident, saying to himself, “It is such a pity my students are learning English only for testing purposes. I really want them to experience the joy of using English for authentic communication.” Yet, he was unsure of how this would go over with the principal. By the day of the class, Mr. Park had committed to implementing the e-pal activity idea. He announced the day’s lab session topic and noticed that most of the students seemed to be quite excited about writing emails: that is, all the students except for Minho, who was very sensitive about his grades. He asked, “Mr. Park, does email writing have anything to do with the final exam?” The instructor responded, “Minho, I completely understand your concern, but let’s try together to see what we can accomplish in real-world English.” A few days later, Minho ran into Mr. Park in the corridor and said to him, “I am so excited to have made a new friend in Finland through the email exchange. Thanks for your help.” Mr. Park smiled back at him, content his activity had achieved its intended goal. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 120
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To develop students’ (teacher trainees’) awareness of washback – the effect of a test on learning and teaching. 2. To develop students’ (teacher trainees’) language teaching philosophy. 3. To develop students’ (teacher trainees’) instructional design skill.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to read the following quote “Teachers teach as they were taught” and think about what beliefs about learning and teaching they have and how such beliefs influence their practice of learning and teaching. 2. Ask the students (teacher trainees) to read the story and answer or discuss the following questions: a. List high-stakes tests that you have taken so far. How have you been affected by the decisions from the testing? b. As a student, have you experienced your learning being changed or influenced when you engaged in test preparation? How and why? c. The principal and Mr. Park seem to have different beliefs about English teaching and learning. In what ways are they different? d. Can you think of specific teachers who serve as positive or negative role models? Please describe what you learned from them. e. As a teacher or a teacher trainee, what specific pedagogical beliefs do you have? f. What is the relationship between your pedagogical beliefs and your learning experiences? In what ways are these beliefs and experiences similar or different? g. Although Mr. Park was advised by the principal to teach for the test, he actually did not follow the principal’s advice. If you were in Mr. Park’s shoes, what would you do? 3. As a homework, ask the students (teacher trainees) to access an e-pal website and experience computer-mediated communication (CMC) using email. The teacher will create a technology-mediated English task that will facilitate real-world English communication.
Reflection: Rapid technological advancements and continuing globalization efforts have given rise to serious considerations about the need to promote information and Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 121
Teacher Development Series
a
communication technology (ICT) in various arenas of society; these developments have simultaneously demanded innovative, learner-centered educational approaches to cultivate digital literacy, as well as target subjects, for teachers and students. Unfortunately, despite this being a world-wide phenomenon, a large gap persists between the governments’ vision for and actual implementation of learnercentered, ICT-integrated English language education, seemingly a result of the low-level digital literacy of teachers and administrators, teacher-centered lessons with little consideration of learners’ communication needs, and the significant impact of washback on teaching and learning. The story Time to Rethink Our Use of Technology in the Classroom explicitly illustrates many of the schools and classrooms teacher trainees attended and will be teaching at in the near future. It is also a reminder that we must recognize the potential of ICT and determine ways to take full advantage of using ICT in the classroom while meeting the learning goals. The classroom discussions encourage the students (teacher trainees) to reflect on what specific actions their teachers took based on the underlying pedagogical values and help the students shape their own pedagogical values. The online activities aim to provide the students (with hands on opportunities to explore the potential of ICT resources for teaching and learning as well as to design authentic and engaging English tasks afforded by ICT.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 122
Going Beyond the Classroom
CHAPTER THIRTY EIGHT SHAKESPEARE AND STEREOTYPES Cherie J. Brown Akita International University, Japan Many of my classes consist of students from international backgrounds. It’s interesting to watch them relating to each other, sharing different cultures, beliefs, stories and traditions. Of course, since they all speak different languages, they have to do this in English. Sometimes it’s challenging to explain difficult ideas and opinions in ways they really want to. Patience, and a tolerance of imperfect expression is required by all. On one occasion, a student began expressing an opinion about the native people of a certain country that was less than flattering, demonstrating a degree of racial prejudice. The other students listened politely, but I could see that some disagreed with him and were uncomfortable. I waited for him to finish, then said, hopefully kindly, “You know, we’re all the same.” “What do you mean?” he asked. “Well”, I replied, paraphrasing Shakespeare, “If you cut me, I will bleed.” He looked confused, so I explained, simply, that all humans share similar qualities and that he was expressing a “stereotype”, teaching him the English word. I then provided examples of people from the group he was describing who broke his stereotype. The other students relaxed and began giving their differing opinions. We ended up having a healthy discussion about the dangers of judging others on the basis of ethnicity. We also discussed the fact that good and bad exist in all aspects of human experience, and that it is unwise to generalise from one person to a whole group. I think that young man left that class with a new perspective on our world, and the amazing variety of humans that share it. I certainly hope so.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 124
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: To consider the concept of stereotyping, and suggest ways to avoid stereotyping others
Procedure: If the class has Internet access, 1. In class, ask the students to watch the YouTube video The Lab: Decoy - A portrait session with a twist (available at http://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=F-TyPfYMDK8) 2. The students work in small groups to: a. b. c. d.
identify the six jobs (or backgrounds) the man was said to have had. explain what each photographer was trying to achieve. describe who the man really was. describe the reaction of the photographers when they discovered the truth. e. explain the real purpose of the photography project. 3. Have a class discussion.
If the class has no Internet access, or if you cannot access the video, 1. Gather 10-12 pictures of different kinds of people (different ages, backgrounds and ethnicities). The pictures should give no indication of real jobs or nationality. 2. Label each picture with a number 3. Place them in different spots around the room. 4. Write a numbered list of occupations on the board. This should be the same as the number of pictures the teacher has. The occupations listed should be varied and not use gender-specific terms (e.g. actress, housewife, postman etc.) Instead, choose gender-free words (e.g. homemaker, police officer, firefighter etc.) 5. Ask the students to work in pairs, visiting each picture with paper and pens, discussing which occupation they think each person has, then noting down their decisions. Use the numbers to match occupations listed on the board to each picture. 6. As a class, ask the pairs to say what they decided and why.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 125
Teacher Development Series
a
7. Finally, the teacher needs to explain that there is no correct match for each photograph because men and women both do all kinds of jobs these days.
All classes 1. Ask the students to read the story above. Check their comprehension. 2. Ask the students to work in pairs, discuss the meaning of the word ‘stereotype.’ Think of examples of common stereotypes. Tell each other why these may be incorrect; suggest ways to avoid pre-judging others on the basis of stereotypes. 3. Provide feedback ideas to the whole class and allow time for comments. 4. Ask each learner to write a short paragraph explaining what the activity has taught them. 5. Ask the students to share their writing with their partner, asking and answering questions about it.
Reflection: The primary purpose of this activity is for learners to engage in thoughtful selfreflection and to gently lead them to think more deeply about how they regard people who are different from themselves. The point is to show that fundamentally each of us is human, and therefore of worth, and that we need to learn to relate to others as individuals, on the basis of character, not a label or a stereotype. We should emphasise that we cannot ever know the full truth about a person based on their appearance only, because appearances are misleading. If you have minority students in your class, it is important to ensure that they are not singled out or used as examples in any way. This is why the activity focuses on non-gender-based occupations, not on racial or religious differences between people. In today’s increasingly connected global community, our learners will need to know how to value others as fellow human beings who share many qualities in common. As we seek to build a more peaceful world, we need to find ways to engage sensitively with each other, celebrating our differences rather than criticizing, or fearing others.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 126
CHAPTER THIRTY NINE WHY IS IT SO HARD TO SAY “THANK YOU”? George M. Jacobs James Cook University, Singapore
The 50-minute English lesson in a Secondary 3 classroom on the fourth floor of a neighbourhood secondary school in Singapore was nearing its end. For the past 20 minutes, the students had been sitting in twosomes and telling each other about the books they had been enjoying for extensive reading. For example, Shazwanah Ahmad had been reading Little Ironies, a book of Catherine Lim short stories, and her partner, Ong Hui Min, had been enjoying Malaysian Short Stories by Lloyd Fernando. Just before wrapping up the lesson, the teacher, Mr Suresh, asked the students to, “Please turn to your partner, and say ‘Thank you’”. It was such a simple request. Yet, instead of facing their partners and saying those two pleasant words, “Thank you,” Shazwanah and Hui Min, and at least half their classmates started putting away their English materials in preparation for the next class. These many students acted as though their partners didn’t even exist. Not wishing to let the students see his disappointment at their lack of courtesy to each other, Mr. Suresh collapsed slowly into his chair, looked down at the floor, and emitted a deep but quiet sigh. “What,” he wondered, “Can I do to create a more polite atmosphere in my classes?”
Objectives: 1. To develop awareness of the importance of using social skills regardless of what language is spoken. 2. To help students and teachers develop the habit of using social skills in a natural, automatic way.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 127
Teacher Development Series
a
3. To encourage reflection on how well students and teachers cooperate with others.
Procedure: 1. Ask the students to read the story, and answer or discuss the following questions: a. When was the last time someone thanked you? What was the situation? How did you feel to be thanked? b. When you were little, did your family teach you to thank others who helped you? c. Can you remember a time recently when you thanked someone? What was the situation? How did you feel when you thanked the person? How do you think the person felt? d. Other than saying, “Thank you,” how else can you thank people? What other words and gestures, facial expressions, or other actions can you take to thank others? e. Why is thanking others not just the kind and polite thing for people to do; why is thanking others also the smart thing to do? In other words, how can you benefit from thanking others? • Do you know anyone who is very polite, who frequently thanks others and takes other polite actions? • Can you think of a specific person who you might want to thank more often? What does that person do to deserve your thanks? 2. As homework or an out-of-class assignment, ask the students to compile a Thank You Journal. In this journal, the students make a list of times when they thanked others or others thanked them. The students also describe the situations in which the thanking occurred, as well as how the thanking was done, both the words and actions used by the receivers of thanks and by those who thanked them. Later, the students share with their classmates about what is in their journals and about their experience compiling the journals. 3. The next time the students do an activity in groups, the partners count how often each other says or shows their thanks. For instance, in a group of two, with Partner A and Partner B, Partner A counts how many times Partner B expresses thanks in words and actions, and Partner B does the same for Partner A.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 128
Teacher Development Series
a
a. At the half-way point in the activity, for example, after 10 minutes of a 20minute activity, the partners report to each other about how many expressions of thanks they counted. b. The students count again in the second half of the activity, and see if they can increase the number of times they thanked each other. c. At first, the students may feel strange to thank others so much. Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 129
Teacher Development Series
a
d. The students discuss whether thanking helped their group to be more effective. e. This counting of thanks continues in this and other classes for a few weeks until thanking each other becomes a natural action for students. f. Of course, the teacher should model this by thanking students and his/her fellow teachers.
Reflection: In language education, using social skills has at least two advantages. First, social skills are important language functions that students need to master to be proficient language users (Jacobs, Kimura, & Greliche, 2016). Secondly, with the increasing use of peer interaction activities in language teaching, students need to use social skills to enhance the effectiveness of these peer interactions. The suggested activities described here are for encouraging students to express thanks to others. At the same time, the activities can serve as a model for teaching other social skills. Wouldn’t our world be a happier place if we all used social skills regularly?
Reference: • Jacobs, G. M., Kimura, H., & Greliche, N. (2016). Incivility among group mates in English classes at a Japanese women’s university. TESL-EJ, 19(4), 1-16. Retrieved on 1 November 2018 from http://www.tesl-ej.org/pdf/ej76/a6.pdf
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 130
CHAPTER FORTY SEEING THROUGH DIFFERENT EYES Curtis Kelly Kansai University, Japan One day, I was teaching a class at Kansai University in Japan, a private university. I was teaching a class on human relations and one day, I told my students a story I had read. It was about a Business teacher in America that gave his students a quiz. The quiz just had one question: “What is the name of the lady who cleans this building?” The students were surprised. They asked if this would be a part of their grades. The teacher said it would, because to be social workers, they have to think about the people around them all the time. We discussed that story for the rest of my class. My students realized they did not know the names of even one cleaning person, even though they passed them every day. Not one of the students had ever talked to them. Not one had ever said “Hello.” The students thought those cleaning people were probably poor. They probably never had a chance to go to college. From their perspective, these young men and women all around them, in the latest fashions, were rich kids, from rich homes, in a world they could never be a part of. So it was no surprise the students never talked to them. That picture made my students sad. By then the class was over. We were getting ready to leave. And then something wonderful happened. One of the boys walked up to the board and wrote “To the cleaning person, thank you for keeping our room so nice.” Then another one went up and another. Soon the board was full with messages to the cleaners, saying thank you, telling them about interesting things we had studied in class, and so on. That day, all of us grew a little.
Teacher Development Series
a
Objectives: 1. To increase intercultural/interpersonal understanding 2. To increase willingness to communicate.
Procedure: 1. Have the students read the following quote: “I don't like that man. I must get to know him better” (Abraham Lincoln). Ask the students to get the meaning
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 132
Teacher Development Series
a of the quote.
2. Have them tell each other about people they do not really understand. 3. Ask the students to read the story and answer or discuss the following questions: a. Who cleans this room? b. Do you know the names of any of the cleaning people, the school guards, cafeteria workers or any of the staff? c. Have you or anyone you know ever talked to them? d. How do you think they feel about the students here? e. If you were one of them, what is something a student might do that would make you happy? f. What are some things you could do to show your appreciation to staff? 4. Make action plans of things you will really do to interact with the staff. Then do them and draw a manga cartoon of what you did. Share them. 5. As an additional homework assignment, tell students to start a conversation with a stranger they have never talked to before. This will build their willingness to communicate skills. They should try this with both a student and someone who is not a student. Talking to older people while riding public transportation is usually an easy way to start.
Reflection: Being an international communicator needs more than just language proficiency. You also have to learn how to see the world from the others’ points of view. You need to go into their heads and imagine their lives: their history, their situation, their needs, their worries, their desires, their values, and as a result, why they act the way they do.
Inspirational Stories from English Language Classrooms 133