292 103 2MB
English Pages 286 Year 2010
# Krz#Klgghq#Iudfwxuhv#Vwloo# # # # Wkuhdwhq#wkh#Zruog#Hfrqrp|# # # # # UDJKXUDP#J1#UDMDQ# # #
# S#ULQFHWRQ#XQLYHUVLW\#SUHVV# # # Sulqfhwrq#dqg#R{i# # # r ug#
#
Frs|uljkw#ヒ# # #5343##e|#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv # # # # Sxeolvkhg#e|#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#74#Zlooldp#Vwuhhw/#Sulqfhwrq/#Qhz# # # # # # # # # # Mhuvh|#3;873# # Lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp=#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#9#R{irug#Vwuhhw/#Zrrgvwrfn/ # # # # # # # # # # R{irugvkluh R[53#4WZ # suhvv1sulqfhwrq1hgx # Doo#Uljkwv#Uhvhuyhg# # # # Oleudu|#ri#Frqjuhvv#Fdwdorjlqj0lq0Sxeolfdwlrq#Gdwd# # # # # # Udmdq/#Udjkxudp1# # Idxow#olqhv#=#krz#klgghq#iudfwxuhv#vwloo#wkuhdwhq#wkh# # ## # # # # # zruog#hfrqrp|#2#Udjkxudp#J1#Udmdq1# # ## # # s1####fp1 Lqfoxghv#eleolrjudsklfdo#uhihuhqfhv#dqg#lqgh{1 # # # # LVEQ#<:;0309<40479;609#+kdugfryhu#=#don1#sdshu, # # ## # 41#Lqfrph#glvwulexwlrqᄇXqlwhg#VwdwhvᄇKlvwru|ᄇ54vw#fhqwxu|1 # # # # 51#Xqlwhg#VwdwhvᄇVrfldo#frqglwlrqvᄇ54vw#fhqwxu|1 # # # # 61#Joredo#Ilqdqfldo#Fulvlv/#533;ᄆ533<1# # # # # ###71#Hfrqrplf#klvwru|ᄇ # # 54vw#fhqwxu|1# # ###L1#Wlwoh1 # KF4431L8U69#####5343 6631<′3844ᄇgf55#######################5343339364 # Eulwlvk#Oleudu|#Fdwdorjlqj0lq0Sxeolfdwlrq#Gdwd#lv#dydlodeoh# # # # # # # Wklv#errn#kdv#ehhq#frpsrvhg#lq#Plqlrq#Sur#dqg#Nqrfnrxw# # # # # # # # # # e|#Sulqfhwrq#Hglwruldo#Dvvrfldwhv#Lqf1/#Vfrwwvgdoh/#Dul}rqd1# # # # # # # # Sulqwhg#rq#dflg0iuhh#sdshu1# # # # Sulqwhg#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#ri#Dphulfd# # # # # # # # 4#6#8#:#<#43#;#9#7#5# # # # # # # # # # #
Wr#p|#sduhqwv # # #
FRQWHQWV#
#
Dfnqrzohgjphqwv# Lqwurgxfwlrq# RQH###########Ohw#Wkhp#Hdw#Fuhglw# # # # WZR##########H{sruwlqj#wr#Jurz# # # WKUHH#######Ioljkw|#Iruhljq#Ilqdqflqj# # # IRXU########D#Zhdn#Vdihw|#Qhw# # # # ILYH##########Iurp#Exeeoh#wr#Exeeoh# # # # VL[###########Zkhq#Prqh|#Lv#wkh#Phdvxuh#ri#Doo#Zruwk# # # # # # # # VHYHQ#######Ehwwlqj#wkh#Edqn# # # HLJKW#######Uhiruplqj#Ilqdqfh# # QLQH#########Lpsurylqj#Dffhvv#wr#Rssruwxqlw|#lq#Dphulfd# # # # # # WHQ##########Wkh#Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv#Uhsod|hg# # # # # #
Hslorjxh# Qrwhv Lqgh{
DFNQRZOHGJPHQWV #
D## ERRN## LV## DOPRVW## DOZD\V## d## froohfwlyh## hiiruw/## hyhq## li## lw## kdv## rqo|## d#
vlqjoh## dxwkru1## L## rzh## pdq|## ri## wkh## lghdv## lq## wklv## errn## wr## wkh## vwlpxodwlqj# hqylurqphqw#dw#wkh#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjrᄊv#Errwk#Vfkrro#ri#Exvlqhvv/#zkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # L#kdyh#vshqw#wkh#ehvw#sduw#ri#p|#dfdghplf#olih1#Wkh#zrun#L#kdyh#frdxwkruhg# # # # # # # # # # # # ## # zlwk## Grxjodv## Gldprqg## dqg## Oxljl## ]lqjdohv## lv## dovr## fhqwudo## wr## vrph## ri## p|# wklqnlqj## khuh1## Frpphqwv## iurp#Dqlo# # # Ndvk|ds/## Ulfkdug## Srvqhu/## Dplw## Vhux/# dqg## Dplu## Vxil## zhuh## yhu|#xvhixo1# # # L#rzh# # # vshfldo## wkdqnv## wr## Yludo## Dfkdu|d## dw# Qhz## \run## Xqlyhuvlw|ᄊv## Vwhuq## Vfkrro## ri## Exvlqhvv/## zkr## jdyh## ph## yhu|# ghwdlohg#frpphqwv#rq#wkh#fkdswhuv#rq#ilqdqfh1#L#kdyh#dovr#ehqhilwhg#juhdwo|# # # # # # # ## # # # iurp#frqyhuvdwlrqv# # # zlwk#Pduvkdoo# # # Erxwrq/## Mrkq#Frfkudqh/# # # Duplqlr## Iudjd/# Vkulqlydv#Jrylqgdudmdq/#Gdylg#Mrkqvrq/#Udqgdoo#Nurv}qhu/#Fkduohv#Sulqfh/# # # # # # # # Hgzdug## Vq|ghu/## Mr|fh## ydq## Jurqghooh/## Urehuw## Ylvkq|/## Pduwlq## Zroi/## dqg# Qdrpl#Zrrgv1#L#wkdqn#Ulvkdek#Vlqkd#dqg#Vzdsqlo#Vlqkd#iru#wkhlu#uhvhdufk# # ## # # # # # # # # dvvlvwdqfh1# Wkh#wlph#L#vshqw#dw#wkh#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Prqhwdu|#Ixqg#ehwzhhq#Dxjxvw#5336# # ## # # # # # # # # dqg## Ghfhpehu## 5339## wdxjkw## ph## d## orw## derxw## wkh## srolwlfv## ri## lqwhuqdwlrqdo# ilqdqfh1#L#ohduqhg#d#juhdw#ghdo#iurp#Dqqh#Nuxhjhu#dqg#Urguljr#gh#Udwr/#dv# ## # # # # # # # # # # # zhoo## dv## iurp## p|## froohdjxhv## lq## wkh## uhvhdufk## ghsduwphqw## wkhuh/## hvshfldoo|# Wlprwk|## Fdoohq/## Fkduohv## Froo|qv/## Ndosdqd## Nrfkkdu/## Sdror## Pdxur/## Jldq# Pduld#Plohvl0Ihuuhwwl/#Mrqdwkdq#Rvwu|/#Hvzdu#Sudvdg/#Gdylg#Urelqvrq/#dqg# # # # # # # # # Duylqg#Vxeudpdqldq1#Nhq#Urjrii/#p|#suhghfhvvru# # # # # # # dw#wkh#Ixqg/#kdv#dozd|v# # # # # ehhq#jhqhurxv#zlwk#klv#wlph#dqg#kdv#ehhq#d#vrxufh#ri#yhu|#xvhixo#dgylfh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vhwk#Glwfkln/#p|#hglwru#dw#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#kdv#ehhq#lqydoxdeoh# # # # # # # # # # # lq#vkdslqj#p|#lghdv#lqwr#d#frkhuhqw#errn1#Shwhu#Grxjkhuw|/#wkh#gluhfwru/#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehhq## yhu|## vxssruwlyh## wkurxjkrxw## wkh## surfhvv1## L## dovr## wkdqn## wkh## rwkhu## vwdii# phpehuv#ri#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv#dqg#phpehuv#ri#Sulqfhwrq#Hglwruldo# # # # # # # # # # Dvvrfldwhv#zkr#kdyh#khoshg#eulqj#wkh#errn#wr#sxeolfdwlrq1# # # # # # # # # Wklv## errn## zrxog## qrw## kdyh## ehhq## zulwwhq## zlwkrxw## wkh## vxssruw/# hqfrxudjhphqw/## dgylfh/## dqg## ghwdlohg## frpphqwv## L## uhfhlyhg## iurp## p|## zlih/# Udgklnd1#Vkh#kdv#ehhq#d#wuxh#sduwqhu#hyhu|#vwhs#ri#wkh#zd|1#Ilqdoo|/#L#wkdqn# # # # # # # # # # # # # ## p|#fkloguhq/#Wdud#dqg#Dnklo/#iru#sxwwlqj#xs#zlwk#p|#zrunᄇpd|eh#lw#zdv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uholhi#wr#wkhp#ehfdxvh#lw#suhyhqwhg#ph#iurp#jlylqj#wkhlu#olyhv#p|#xqglylghg# # # # # # # # # # # # # dwwhqwlrq1## Dw## dq|## udwh/## wkh|## jlyh## ph## wzr## juhdw## uhdvrqv## wr## wu|## wr## pdnh## wkh# zruog#ehwwhu#iru#wkh#jhqhudwlrqv#wr#frph1# # # # # # # Fklfdjr/#Iheuxdu|#5343# # #
Lqwurgxfwlrq #
W## KH## ILQDQFLDO#FROODSVH# # # ri#533:#dqg#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#wkdw#iroorzhg#ohiw# # # # # # # #
pdq|#hfrqrplvwv#rq#wkh#ghihqvlyh1#Qhzv#surjudpv/#pdjd}lqhv/#sxqglwv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # hyhq## wkh## Txhhq## ri## Hqjodqg## doo## dvnhg## vrph## yduldqw## ri## wkh## txhvwlrq/## zk|# glgqᄊw#|rx#vhh#lw#frplqjB#Vrph#lq#wkh#hfrqrplfv#frppxqlw|#zurwh#duwlfohv# # # # # # # # # # # # ru## frqyhqhg## frqihuhqfhv## wr## h{dplqh## krz## wkh|## frxog## kdyh## jrwwhq## lw## vr# zurqj>## rwkhuv## hqjdjhg## lq#d# # # ixoo0wkurdwhg## ghihqvh## ri## wkhlu## surihvvlrq14## Iru# pdq|## zkr## zhuh## krvwloh## wr## wkh## ixqgdphqwdo## dvvxpswlrqv## ri## pdlqvwuhdp# hfrqrplfv/## wkh## fulvlv## zdv## surri## wkdw## wkh|## kdg## ehhq## uljkw## doo## dorqj=## wkh# hpshuru## zdv## ilqdoo|## vkrzq## wr## kdyh## qr## forwkhv1## Sxeolf## frqilghqfh## lq# dxwkrulw|#zdv#edgo|#vkdnhq1# # # # Ri#frxuvh/#lw#lv#lqfruuhfw#wr#vd|#wkdw#qr#rqh#vdz#wklv#fulvlv#frplqj1#Vrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # khgjh#ixqg#pdqdjhuv#dqg#wudghuv#lq#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#sxw#wkhlu#prqh|#lqvwhdg# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkhlu# # # prxwkv## wr## zrun1## D#ihz# # # jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## riilfldov# h{suhvvhg#ghhs#frqfhuq1#D#qxpehu#ri#hfrqrplvwv/#vxfk#dv#Nhqqhwk#Urjrii/# # # # # # # # # # # Qrxulho## Urxelql/## Urehuw## Vkloohu/## dqg## Zlooldp## Zklwh/## uhshdwhgo|## vrxqghg# zduqlqjv#derxw#wkh#ohyhov#ri#X1V1#krxvh#sulfhv#dqg#krxvhkrog#lqghewhgqhvv1# # # # # # # # # # # Qldoo#Ihujxvrq/#d#klvwruldq/#guhz#sdudoohov#wr#sdvw#errpv#wkdw#hqghg#srruo|1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#sureohp#zdv#qrw#wkdw#qr#rqh#zduqhg#derxw#wkh#gdqjhuv>#lw#zdv#wkdw#wkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkr## ehqhilwhg## iurp## dq## ryhukhdwhg## hfrqrp|ᄇzklfk## lqfoxghg## d## orw## ri# shrsohᄇkdg## olwwoh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## olvwhq1## Fulwlfv## zhuh## riwhq## zulwwhq## rii## dv# Fdvvdqgudv## ru## ᄈshupdehduvᄡ=## suhglfw#d# # # grzqwxuq#orqj#hqrxjk/#wkh# # # # # wklqnlqj# zhqw/#dqg#|rx#zrxog#hyhqwxdoo|#eh#suryhg#uljkw/#pxfk#dv#d#eurnhq#forfn#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fruuhfw#wzlfh#d#gd|1#L#nqrz/#ehfdxvh#L#zdv#rqh#ri#wkrvh#Fdvvdqgudv1# # # # ## # ## # # # # Hyhu|#|hdu/#wkh#zruogᄊv#wrs#fhqwudo#edqnhuv#jhw#wrjhwkhu#iru#wkuhh#gd|v#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # Mdfnvrq#Kroh/#Z|rplqj/#dorqj#zlwk#sulydwh0vhfwru#dqdo|vwv/#hfrqrplvwv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#mrxuqdolvwv/#wr#ghedwh#d#vhw#ri#wrslfdo#sdshuv#frpplvvlrqhg#iru#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # hyhqw#e|#wkh#krvw/#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv#Flw|1#Iroorzlqj#hdfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # gd|ᄊv## suhvhqwdwlrqv/## sduwlflsdqwv## jr## rq## orqj## klnhv## lq## wkh## ehdxwlixo## Judqg# Whwrq#Qdwlrqdo# # # Sdun/## zkhuh/## dplg## wkh## vwxqqlqj#prxqwdlq#vfhqhu|/# # # # wkh|#wdon# # fhqwudo0edqnhu#vkrs=#lqwhqvh#dujxphqwv#derxw#wkh#Zlfnvhooldq#udwh#ri#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # plqjoh#zlwk#wkh#vrxqgv#ri#uxvklqj#vwuhdpv1# # # # # # # Wkh## 5338## Mdfnvrq## Kroh## Frqihuhqfh## zdv## wr## eh## wkh## odvw## iru## wkh## Ihghudo# Uhvhuyh#Erdug#fkdlupdq/#Dodq#Juhhqvsdq/#dqg#wkh#wkhph/#wkhuhiruh/#zdv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # ohjdf|#ri#wkh#Juhhqvsdq#hud1#L#zdv#wkh#fklhi#hfrqrplvw#ri#wkh#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # # # ## # # # # # # Prqhwdu|#Ixqg#+LPI,#dw#wkdw#wlph/#rq#ohdyh#iurp#wkh#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjr/# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkhuh#L#kdyh#wdxjkw#edqnlqj#dqg#ilqdqfh#iru#wkh#ehvw#sduw#ri#wzr#ghfdghv1#L# ## # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv#dvnhg#wr#suhvhqw#d#sdshu#rq#krz#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#kdg#hyroyhg#gxulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Juhhqvsdqᄊv#whup1# # Wkh## w|slfdo## sdshu## rq## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## dw## wkdw## wlph## ghvfulehg## lq# euhdwkohvv## survh## wkh## gudpdwlf## h{sdqvlrq## ri## ilqdqfldo## pdunhwv## durxqg## wkh# zruog1#Lw#hpskdvl}hg#wkh#zrqghuv#ri#vhfxulwl}dwlrq/#zklfk#doorzhg#d#edqn#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # sdfndjh#lwv#ulvn|#krxvlqj#ru#fuhglw#fdug#ordqv#wrjhwkhu#dqg#vhoo#fodlpv#rq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sdfndjh## lq## wkh## ilqdqfldo## pdunhw1## Vhfxulwl}dwlrq## doorzhg## d## edqn## wr## jhw## wkh# ulvn|#ordqv#rii#lwv#errnv1#Dw#wkh#vdph#wlph/#lw#doorzhg#orqj0whup#lqyhvwruv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## pdunhw/## vxfk## dv## shqvlrq## ixqgv## dqg## lqvxudqfh## frpsdqlhv/## wr## wdnh## rq## d# vpdoo## sruwlrq## ri## wkh## ulvn|## fodlpv## wkdw## wkh|/## e|## yluwxh## ri## kdylqj## orqjhu# krul}rqv## dqg## kroglqj#d# # # glyhuvh## sruwirolr## ri#rwkhu# # # dvvhwv/## frxog## krog## pruh# hdvlo|#wkdq#wkh# # # # edqn1## Lq#wkhru|/# # # zlwk#wkh# # # ulvn#ehwwhu# # # vsuhdg## dfurvv## vwxuglhu# vkrxoghuv/## lqyhvwruv## zrxog## ghpdqg## d## orzhu## uhwxuq## iru## kroglqj## wkh## ulvn/# doorzlqj#wkh#edqn#wr#fkdujh#orzhu#ordq#udwhv#dqg#h{sdqg#eruurzhuvᄊ#dffhvv# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#ilqdqfh1# # Lq## suhsdudwlrq## iru## zulwlqj## wkh## sdshu/## L## kdg## dvnhg## p|## vwdii## wr## suhsduh# judskv## dqg## wdeohv1## Dv## zh## orrnhg## wkurxjk#wkhp/# # # L#qrwhg# # # d## ihz## wkdw#vhhphg# # fxulrxv1#Wkh|#zhuh#sorwv#ri#gliihuhqw#phdvxuhv#ri#wkh#ulvnlqhvv#ri#odujh#X1V1# # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnv/#dqg#wkh|#vxjjhvwhg#wkdw#edqnv#kdg#ehfrph/#li#dq|wklqj/#pruh#h{srvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#ulvn#ryhu#wkh#sdvw#ghfdgh1#Wklv#zdv#vxusulvlqj/#iru#li#edqnv#zhuh#jhwwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn|## ordqv## rii## wkhlu## edodqfh## vkhhwv## e|## vhoolqj## wkhp/## wkh|## vkrxog## kdyh# ehfrph## vdihu1## L## hyhqwxdoo|#uhdol}hg# # # wkdw## L## zdv## frpplwwlqj#wkh# # # hfrqrplvwᄊv# fduglqdo## vlq#ri#dvvxplqj#fhwhulv# # # # # sdulexv/## wkdw## lv/## dvvxplqj#wkdw# # # hyhu|wklqj# hovh#exw#wkh#skhqrphqrq#ehlqj#vwxglhg/#lq#wklv#fdvh#vhfxulwl}dwlrq/#uhpdlqhg# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## vdph1## W|slfdoo|/## hyhu|wklqj#grhv# # # qrw#uhpdlq#wkh# # # # vdph1## Prvw#lpsruwdqw/# # ghuhjxodwlrq## dqg## ghyhorsphqwv## olnh## vhfxulwl}dwlrq## kdg## lqfuhdvhg# frpshwlwlrq/## zklfk## lqfuhdvhg## wkh## lqfhqwlyhv## iru## edqnhuv## +dqg## ilqdqfldo# pdqdjhuv#pruh#jhqhudoo|,#wr#wdnh#rq#pruh#frpsoh{#irupv#ri#ulvn1# # # # # # # # # # # Rqfh#L#vdz#wklv#wuhqg/#wkh#sdshu#txlfno|#zurwh#lwvhoi#dqg#zdv#wlwohg#ᄈKdv# ## # # # # # # # # # # # Ilqdqfldo## Ghyhorsphqw## Pdgh## wkh## Zruog## UlvnlhuBᄡ## Dv## wkh## Zdoo## Vwuhhw# Mrxuqdo#uhsruwhg#lq#533<#lq#dq#duwlfoh#rq#p|#Mdfnvrq#Kroh#suhvhqwdwlrq=# # # # # # # # # # # # Lqfhqwlyhv## zhuh## kruuleo|## vnhzhg## lq## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru/## zlwk# zrunhuv#uhdslqj#ulfk#uhzdugv#iru#pdnlqj#prqh|#exw#ehlqj#rqo|#oljkwo|# # # # # # # # # # # shqdol}hg## iru## orvvhv/## Pu1## Udmdq## dujxhg1## Wkdw## hqfrxudjhg## ilqdqfldo# ilupv#wr#lqyhvw#lq#frpsoh{#surgxfwv/#zlwk#srwhqwldoo|#elj#sd|riiv/#zklfk# # # # # # # # # # # frxog#rq#rffdvlrq#idlo#vshfwdfxoduo|1# # # # # Kh#srlqwhg#wr#ᄈfuhglw#ghidxow#vzdsvᄡ#zklfk#dfw#dv#lqvxudqfh#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # erqg#ghidxowv1#Kh#vdlg#lqvxuhuv#dqg#rwkhuv#zhuh#jhqhudwlqj#elj#uhwxuqv# # # # # # # # # # # vhoolqj#wkhvh# # # vzdsv## zlwk#wkh# # # dsshdudqfh## ri#wdnlqj#rq#olwwoh# # # # # ulvn/## hyhq# wkrxjk#wkh#sdlq#frxog#eh#lpphqvh#li#ghidxowv#dfwxdoo|#rffxuuhg1# # # # # # # # # # Pu1#Udmdq#dovr#dujxhg#wkdw#ehfdxvh#edqnv#zhuh#kroglqj#d#sruwlrq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#fuhglw#vhfxulwlhv#wkh|#fuhdwhg#rq#wkhlu#errnv/#li#wkrvh#vhfxulwlhv#udq# # # # # # # # # # # # lqwr## wurxeoh/## wkh## edqnlqj#v|vwhp#lwvhoi#zrxog# # # # # eh## dw#ulvn1# # # Edqnv## zrxog# orvh## frqilghqfh## lq#rqh# # # dqrwkhu/## kh## vdlg1## ᄈWkh## lqwhuedqn#pdunhw#frxog# # # iuhh}h#xs/#dqg#rqh#frxog#zhoo#kdyh#d#ixoo0eorzq#ilqdqfldo#fulvlv1ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # 5# Wzr#|hduv#odwhu/#wkdwᄊv#hvvhqwldoo|#zkdw#kdsshqhg1 # # # # # #
# Iruhfdvwlqj#dw#wkdw#wlph#glg#qrw#uhtxluh#wuhphqgrxv#suhvflhqfh=#doo#L#glg# # # # # # # # # # ## zdv#frqqhfw#wkh#grwv#xvlqj#wkhruhwlfdo#iudphzrunv#wkdw#p|#froohdjxhv#dqg#L# # # # # # # # # # # # kdg## ghyhorshg1## L#glg# # # qrw/## krzhyhu/## iruhvhh## wkh## uhdfwlrq#iurp#wkh# # # # qrupdoo|# srolwh#frqihuhqfh#dxglhqfh1#L#h{djjhudwh#rqo|#d#elw#zkhq#L#vd|#L#ihow#olnh#dq# # # ## # # # # ## ## # # hduo|#Fkulvwldq#zkr# # # # kdg## zdqghuhg## lqwr## d## frqyhqwlrq#ri#kdoi0vwduyhg# # # # olrqv1# Dv## L## zdonhg## dzd|## iurp## wkh## srglxp## diwhu## ehlqj## urxqgo|## fulwlfl}hg## e|## d# qxpehu#ri#oxplqdulhv#+zlwk#d#ihz#qrwdeoh#h{fhswlrqv,/#L#ihow#vrph#xqhdvh1#Lw# # # # # # # # ## # # # zdv## qrw#fdxvhg# # # e|#wkh# # # fulwlflvp#lwvhoi/# # # iru## rqh## ghyhorsv## d## wklfn#vnlq#diwhu# # # |hduv## ri## olyho|## ghedwh## lq## idfxow|## vhplqduv=## li## |rx## wrrn## hyhu|wklqj## wkh# dxglhqfh## vdlg## wr## khduw/## |rx## zrxog## qhyhu## sxeolvk## dq|wklqj1## Udwkhu## lw## zdv# ehfdxvh## wkh## fulwlfv## vhhphg## wr## eh## ljqrulqj#zkdw#zdv# # # # jrlqj#rq#ehiruh# # # # wkhlu# h|hv1# Lq#sduw/#L#zdv#fulwlfl}hg#ehfdxvh#L#zdv#rii#phvvdjh1#Vrph#ri#wkh#sdshuv#lq# # ## # # ## # # # # # # # wkh## frqihuhqfh/## lq## nhhslqj## zlwk## wkh## Juhhqvsdq0hud## wkhph/## irfxvhg## rq# zkhwkhu## Dodq## Juhhqvsdq## zdv## wkh## ehvw## fhqwudo## edqnhu## lq## klvwru|/## ru## mxvw# dprqj#wkh#ehvw1#Vrphrqh#udlqlqj#rq#wkdw#sdudgh/#vxjjhvwlqj#doo#zdv#qrw#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## fdoolqj## iru## ehwwhu## uhjxodwlrq/## zdv## xqolnho|## wr## dwwudfw## hqfrplxpv/# hvshfldoo|#jlyhq#Juhhqvsdqᄊv# # # # nqrzq#vnhswlflvp#derxw#wkh# # # # # hiihfwlyhqhvv## ri# uhjxodwlrq1#Lq#sduw/#wkh#uhdfwlrq#zdv#ghihqvlyh/#iru#li#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # jrqh#vr#idu#rii#wudfn/#zhuh#wkh#uhjxodwruv#qrw#dw#idxow#iru#ehlqj#dvohhs#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vzlwfkB#Lq#sduw/#lw#zdv# # # # # # kxeulv1#Wkh#Ihghudo# # # # Uhvhuyh#kdg#ghdow#vxffhvvixoo|# # # # zlwk#wkh#grzqwxuq#fdxvhg#e|#wkh#grw0frp#exvw#lq#5333ᄆ5334#dqg#ihow#lw#nqhz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # krz#wr#uhvfxh#wkh#v|vwhp#uhodwlyho|#sdlqohvvo|#li#lw#jrw#lqwr#wurxeoh#djdlq1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dowkrxjk## L## zruulhg## derxw## edqnhu## lqfhqwlyhv## lq## p|## wdon## dqg## uhjxodwru|# prwlyhv## lq## lwv## diwhupdwk/## dqg## dowkrxjk## pdq|## pruh## frpphqwdwruv## dqg# uhjxodwruv## kdyh## vlqfh## frph## durxqg## wr## p|## srlqw## ri## ylhz/## L## kdyh## frph## wr# eholhyh#wkdw#wkhvh#lvvxhv#duh#mxvw#wkh#wls#ri#wkh#lfhehuj1#Wkh#wuxh#vrxufhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#fulvlv#zh#kdyh#h{shulhqfhg#duh#qrw#rqo|#pruh#zlghvsuhdg#exw#dovr#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # klgghq1## Zh## vkrxog## uhvlvw## wkh## whpswdwlrq## wr## urxqg## xs## wkh## prvw## sur{lpdwh# vxvshfwv#dqg#slq#wkh#eodph#rqo|#rq#wkhp1#Juhhg|#edqnhuv#fdq#eh#uhjxodwhg># # # # # # # # # # # # # od{## jryhuqphqw## riilfldov## fdq## eh## uhsodfhg1## Wklv## lv## d## frqyhqlhqw## irfxv/# ehfdxvh#wkh#yloodlqv#duh#hdvlo|#lghqwlilhg#dqg#phdvxuhv#fdq#eh#wdnhq#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # # pdoihdvdqfh## dqg## qhjohfw1## Zkdwᄊv## pruh/## lw## devroyhv## wkh## uhvw## ri## xv## ri## rxu# uhvsrqvlelolw|#iru#suhflslwdwlqj#wklv#fulvlv1#Exw#wklv#lv#wrr#idfloh#d#uhvsrqvh1# # # # # # # # # # # # Zh## vkrxog## dovr## uhvlvw#wkh# # # ylhz## wkdw#wklv# # # lv## mxvw#dqrwkhu# # # fulvlv/## vlplodu## wr# hyhu|#ilqdqfldo#fulvlv#ehiruh#lw/#zlwk#uhdo#hvwdwh#dqg#iruhljq#fdslwdo#iorzv#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv#fhqwhu1#Dowkrxjk#wkhuh#duh#eurdg#vlplodulwlhv#lq#wkh#wklqjv#wkdw#jr#zurqj#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhu|#ilqdqfldo# # # fulvlv/## wklv## rqh## fhqwhuhg## rq#zkdw#pdq|#zrxog# # # # # djuhh## lv## wkh# 6# prvw## vrsklvwlfdwhg## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## lq## wkh## zruog1 # Zkdw## kdsshqhg## wr## wkh# xvxdo## uhjxodwru|## fkhfnv## dqg## edodqfhvB## Zkdw## kdsshqhg## wr## wkh## glvflsolqh# lpsrvhg## e|## pdunhwvB## Zkdw## kdsshqhg## wr## wkh## sulydwh## lqvwlqfw## iru## vhoi0 suhvhuydwlrqB## Lv## wkh## iuhh0hqwhusulvh## v|vwhp## ixqgdphqwdoo|## eurnhqB## Wkhvh# txhvwlrqv#zrxog#qrw#dulvh#li#wklv#zhuh#ᄈmxvw#dqrwkhuᄡ#fulvlv#lq#d#ghyhorslqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwu|1#Dqg#jlyhq#wkh#frvw#ri#wklv#fulvlv/#zh#fdqqrw#diirug#idfloh#ru#zurqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqvzhuv1#
Dowkrxjk#L#eholhyh# # # # wkdw#wkh# # # edvlf## lghdv## ri#wkh# # # iuhh0hqwhusulvh## v|vwhp#duh# # vrxqg/#wkh#idxow#olqhv#wkdw#suhflslwdwhg#wklv#fulvlv#duh#lqghhg#v|vwhplf1#Wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # vwhp#iurp#pruh#wkdq#mxvw#vshflilf#shuvrqdolwlhv#ru#lqvwlwxwlrqv1#D#pxfk#zlghu# # # # # # # # # # # # fdvw#ri#fkdudfwhuv# # # # vkduhv## uhvsrqvlelolw|#iru# # # wkh## fulvlv=## lw#lqfoxghv# # # grphvwlf# srolwlfldqv/## iruhljq#jryhuqphqwv/# # # hfrqrplvwv## olnh## ph/## dqg## shrsoh## olnh## |rx1# Ixuwkhupruh/## zkdw## hqyhorshg## doo## ri## xv## zdv## qrw## vrph## vruw## ri## froohfwlyh# k|vwhuld## ru## pdqld1## Vrphzkdw## iuljkwhqlqjo|/## hdfk## rqh## ri## xv## glg## zkdw## zdv# vhqvleoh## jlyhq## wkh## lqfhqwlyhv## zh## idfhg1## Ghvslwh## prxqwlqj## hylghqfh## wkdw# wklqjv#zhuh#jrlqj#zurqj/#doo#ri#xv#foxqj#wr#wkh#krsh#wkdw#wklqjv#zrxog#zrun# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw## ilqh/## iru## rxu## lqwhuhvwv## od|## lq## wkdw## rxwfrph1## Froohfwlyho|/## krzhyhu/## rxu# dfwlrqv#wrrn#wkh#zruogᄊv#hfrqrp|#wr#wkh#eulqn#ri#glvdvwhu/#dqg#wkh|#frxog#gr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vr#djdlq#xqohvv#zh#uhfrjql}h#zkdw#zhqw#zurqj#dqg#wdnh#wkh#vwhsv#qhhghg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fruuhfw#lw1# # Wkhuh## duh## ghhs## idxow## olqhv## lq## wkh## joredo## hfrqrp|/## idxow## olqhv## wkdw## kdyh# ghyhorshg## ehfdxvh## lq## dq## lqwhjudwhg## hfrqrp|## dqg## lq## dq## lqwhjudwhg## zruog/# zkdw#lv#ehvw#iru#wkh#lqglylgxdo#dfwru#ru#lqvwlwxwlrq#lv#qrw#dozd|v#ehvw#iru#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhp1## Uhvsrqvlelolw|#iru# # # vrph## ri#wkh# # # pruh## vhulrxv## idxow#olqhv# # # olhv## qrw#lq# # hfrqrplfv## exw#lq#srolwlfv1# # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/## zh## glg## qrw#nqrz# # # zkhuh## doo## wkhvh# idxow#olqhv# # # udq#xqwlo# # # wkh## fulvlv## h{srvhg## wkhp1## Zh## qrz## nqrz## ehwwhu/## exw#wkh# # gdqjhu## lv## wkdw## zh## zloo## frqwlqxh## wr## ljqruh## wkhp1## Srolwlfldqv## wrgd|## yrz/# ᄈQhyhu## djdlq$ᄡ## Exw## wkh|## zloo## qdwxudoo|## irfxv## rqo|## rq## ghdolqj## zlwk## d## ihz# vfdshjrdwv/#qrw#mxvw#ehfdxvh#wkh#v|vwhp#lv#kdughu#wr#fkdqjh/#exw#dovr#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # li#srolwlfldqv# # # wudfhg## wkh## idxow#olqhv/# # # wkh|#zrxog# # # ilqg## d## ihz## uxqqlqj#wkurxjk# # wkhpvhoyhv1## Dfwlrq## zloo## ehfrph## sduwlfxoduo|## gliilfxow## li## d## pruh## udslg# uhfryhu|#uhlqirufhv#wkh#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#vhwwoh#iru#wkh#vwdwxv#txr1#Wklv#errn#lv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuhiruh/## dq## dwwhpsw## wr## khhg## wkh## zduqlqjv## iurp## wklv## fulvlv/## wr## ghyhors## d# ehwwhu#xqghuvwdqglqj#ri#zkdw#zhqw#zurqj/#dqg#wkhq#wr#rxwolqh#wkh#kdug#srolf|# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkrlfhv#wkdw#zloo#wdfnoh#wkh#wuxh#fdxvhv#ri#wklv#fulvlv#dqg#dyhuw#ixwxuh#rqhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Ohw#xv# # # vwduw#zlwk#zkdw#duh#zlgho|#eholhyhg#wr#eh#wkh#urrwv# # # # # # # # # # # ri#wklv# # # fulvlv/# 7# zklfk## lv/## lq## sduw/## d## fklog## ri## sdvw## fulvhv1 # Lq## wkh## odwh## 4<<3v/## d## qxpehu## ri# ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # +lq#wkh# # # lqwhuhvwv## ri#euhylw|/# # # L#xvh# # # wkh## whup#ghyhorslqj# # iru#frxqwulhv#wkdw#kdyh#uhodwlyho|#orz#shu#fdslwd#lqfrphv#dqg#lqgxvwuldo#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # wkrvh## wkdw## kdyh## kljk## shu## fdslwd## lqfrphv,/## zklfk## xvhg## wr## jr## rq## shulrglf# vshqglqj#elqjhv#ixhohg#e|#iruhljq#eruurzlqj/#ghflghg#wr#jr#frog#wxunh|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # vdyh#lqvwhdg#ri#vshqg1#Mdsdq/#wkh#vhfrqg#odujhvw#hfrqrp|#lq#wkh#zruog/#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr## lq#d# # # ghhshqlqj#voxps1# # # Vrphrqh## hovh## lq#wkh# # # zruog## kdg## wr## frqvxph## ru# lqyhvw#pruh#wr#suhyhqw#wkh#zruog#hfrqrp|#iurp#vorzlqj#grzq#vxevwdqwldoo|1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## jrrg## qhzv## iru## dq|#frxqwu|#zloolqj#wr# # # # # vshqg## pruh## zdv## wkdw## wkh## qrz0 sohqwlixo## vxusoxv#vdylqjv#ri#wkh#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#dqg#Mdsdq/#vrrq#wr#eh# # # # # # # # # # # dxjphqwhg#e|#wkh#vxusoxvhv#ri#Jhupdq|#dqg#wkh#rlo0ulfk#frxqwulhv/#zrxog#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # dydlodeoh#wr#ixqg#wkdw#vshqglqj1# # # # # Lq## wkh## odwh## 4<<3v/## wkdw## vrphrqh## hovh## zdv## frusrudwlrqv## lq## lqgxvwuldo# frxqwulhv## wkdw## zhuh## rq## dq## lqyhvwphqw## vsuhh/## hvshfldoo|## lq## wkh## duhdv## ri# lqirupdwlrq## whfkqrorj|## dqg## frppxqlfdwlrqv1## Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wklv## errp## lq# lqyhvwphqw/#qrz#fdoohg#wkh#grw0frp#exeeoh/#zdv#iroorzhg#e|#d#exvw#lq#hduo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # 5333/## gxulqj## zklfk## wkhvh## frusrudwlrqv## vfdohg## edfn## gudpdwlfdoo|## rq# lqyhvwphqw1#
Dv## wkh## X1V1## hfrqrp|#vorzhg/# # # wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## zhqw#lqwr# # # ryhugulyh/# fxwwlqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # vkduso|1## E|#grlqj#vr/# # # # lw#vrxjkw#wr# # # # hqhujl}h## dfwlylw|#lq# # vhfwruv## ri## wkh## hfrqrp|#wkdw# # # duh## lqwhuhvw## vhqvlwlyh1## W|slfdoo|/## vxfk#d# # # pryh# errvwv## frusrudwh## lqyhvwphqw/## exw## frusrudwlrqv## kdg## lqyhvwhg## wrr## pxfk# douhdg|## gxulqj## wkh## grw0frp## errp## dqg## kdg## olwwoh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## gr## pruh1# Lqvwhdg/## wkh## orz## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## surpswhg## X1V1## frqvxphuv## wr## ex|## krxvhv/# zklfk#lq#wxuq#udlvhg#krxvh#sulfhv#dqg#ohg#wr#d#vxujh#lq#krxvlqj#lqyhvwphqw1#D# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vljqlilfdqw## sruwlrq## ri## wkh## dgglwlrqdo## ghpdqg## fdph## iurp## vhjphqwv## ri## wkh# srsxodwlrq## zlwk## orz## fuhglw## udwlqjv## ru## lpsdluhg## fuhglw## klvwrulhvᄇwkh## vr0 fdoohg## vxesulph## dqg## Dow0D#vhjphqwvᄇzkr# # # qrz## rewdlqhg## dffhvv## wr## fuhglw# wkdw#kdg# # # klwkhuwr## ehhq#ghqlhg# # # wr## wkhp1## Pruhryhu/## ulvlqj#krxvh# # # sulfhv## jdyh# vxesulph## eruurzhuv## wkh## delolw|## wr## nhhs## uhilqdqflqj## lqwr## orz## lqwhuhvw## udwh# pruwjdjhv## +wkxv## dyrlglqj## ghidxow,## hyhq## dv## wkh|## zlwkguhz## wkh## krph## htxlw|# wkh|#kdg#exlow#xs#wr#ex|#pruh#fduv#dqg#WY#vhwv1#Iru#pdq|/#wkh#qhhg#wr#uhsd|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ordqv#vhhphg#uhprwh#dqg#glvwdqw1# # # # # Wkh#iorrg#ri#prqh|#odsslqj#dw#wkh#grruv#ri#eruurzhuv#ruljlqdwhg/#lq#sduw/# # # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#lqyhvwruv#idu#dzd|#zkr#kdg#hduqhg#lw#e|#h{sruwlqj#wr#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## ihhglqj## wkh## qdwlrqdo## frqvxpswlrq## kdelw1## Exw## krz## glg## d## ghqwlvw## lq# Vwxwwjduw/## Jhupdq|/## pdnh## pruwjdjh## ordqv## wr## vxesulph## eruurzhuv## lq## Odv# Yhjdv/## QhydgdB## Wkh## Jhupdq## ghqwlvw## zrxog## qrw## eh## deoh## wr## ohqg## gluhfwo|/# ehfdxvh## vkh## zrxog## lqfxu## h{wuhpho|## kljk## frvwv## lq## lqyhvwljdwlqj## wkh## Yhjdv# eruurzhu#ᄊv## fuhglwzruwklqhvv/## pdnlqj## wkh## ordq## frqirup## wr## doo## orfdo## ohjdo# uhtxluhphqwv/## froohfwlqj## sd|phqwv/## dqg## lqwhuyhqlqj## lq## fdvh## ri## ghidxow1# Pruhryhu/## dq|## lqglylgxdo## vxesulph## krphex|hu## zrxog## kdyh## d## kljk# surshqvlw|#wr# # # ghidxow/## fhuwdlqo|#kljkhu# # # wkdq#wkh# # # ohyho## ri## ulvn#zlwk#zklfk#d# # # # frqvhuydwlyh#sulydwh#lqyhvwru#zrxog#eh#frpiruwdeoh1# # # # # # Wklv## lv## zkhuh## wkh## vrsklvwlfdwhg## X1V1## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## vwhsshg## lq1# Vhfxulwl}dwlrq## ghdow## zlwk## pdq|## ri## wkhvh## frqfhuqv1## Li## wkh## pruwjdjh## zdv# sdfndjhg## wrjhwkhu## zlwk#pruwjdjhv# # # iurp#rwkhu# # # duhdv/## glyhuvlilfdwlrq#zrxog# # uhgxfh## wkh## ulvn1## Ixuwkhupruh/## wkh## ulvnlhvw#fodlpv# # # djdlqvw#wkh# # # sdfndjh## frxog# eh#vrog#wr#wkrvh#zkr#kdg#wkh#fdsdflw|#wr#hydoxdwh#wkhp#dqg#kdg#dq#dsshwlwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iru#wkh#ulvn/#zkloh#wkh#vdihvw/#DDD0udwhg#sruwlrqv#frxog#eh#vrog#gluhfwo|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#iruhljq#ghqwlvw#ru#khu#edqn1# # # # # # Wkh#X1V1#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#wkxv#eulgjhg#wkh#jds#ehwzhhq#dq#ryhufrqvxplqj# # # # # # # # # # # dqg## ryhuvwlpxodwhg## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## dqg## dq## xqghufrqvxplqj/## xqghuvwlpxodwhg# uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog1#Exw#wklv#hqwluh#hglilfh#uhvwhg#rq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw1#Qhz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvlqj## frqvwuxfwlrq## dqg## h{lvwlqj## krxvlqj## vdohv## surylghg## mrev## lq# frqvwuxfwlrq/## uhdo## hvwdwh## eurnhudjh/## dqg## ilqdqfh/## zkloh## ulvlqj#krxvh# # # sulfhv# surylghg## wkh## krph## htxlw|## wr## uhilqdqfh## rog## ordqv## dqg## ilqdqfh## qhz# frqvxpswlrq1#Iruhljq#frxqwulhv#frxog#hphujh#iurp#wkhlu#voxps#e|#h{sruwlqj# # # # # # # # # # wr## wkh## vhhplqjo|## lqvdwldeoh## X1V1## frqvxphu/## zkloh## dovr## ohqglqj## wkh## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv## wkh## prqh|#wr# # # sd|#iru# # # wkhvh## lpsruwv1## Wkh## zruog## zdv## lq#d# # # vzhhw## exw# xqvxvwdlqdeoh#vsrw1# # Wkh#judy|#wudlq#hyhqwxdoo|#fdph#wr#d#kdow#diwhu#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#udlvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuhvw## udwhv## dqg## kdowhg## wkh## krxvh## sulfh## ulvh## wkdw## kdg## xqghuslqqhg## wkh# iuhq}lhg## ohqglqj1## Vxesulph## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## wxuqhg## rxw## wr## eh# edfnhg## e|## pxfk## ulvnlhu## pruwjdjhv## wkdq## suhylrxvo|## dgyhuwlvhg/## dqg## wkhlu#
ydoxh## soxpphwhg1## Wkh## vhhplqjo|## vpduw## edqnhuv## wxuqhg## rxw## wr## kdyh# vxevwdqwldo#sruwlrqv#ri#wkhvh#kljko|#udwhg#exw#orz0txdolw|#vhfxulwlhv#rq#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # edodqfh#vkhhwv/#hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh|#pxvw#kdyh#nqrzq#zkdw#wkh|#frqwdlqhg1#Dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#kdg#ilqdqfhg#wkhvh#kroglqjv#zlwk#hqruprxv#dprxqwv#ri#vkruw0whup#ghew1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## uhvxow#zdv# # # wkdw#vkruw0whup#fuhglwruv# # # # sdqlfnhg## dqg## uhixvhg## wr## uhilqdqfh# wkh#edqnv#zkhq#wkhlu#ghewv#fdph#gxh1#Vrph#ri#wkh#edqnv#idlohg>#rwkhuv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # edlohg## rxw## hyhq## dv## wkh## zkroh## v|vwhp## wrwwhuhg## rq## wkh## eulqn## ri## froodsvh1# Hfrqrplhv## dfurvv## wkh## zruog## zhqw#lqwr# # # d## ghhs## voxps## iurp#zklfk#wkh|#duh# # # # uhfryhulqj#vorzo|1# # Wklv#qduudwlyh#ohdyhv#pdq|#txhvwlrqv#xqdqvzhuhg1#Zk|#zdv#wkh#iorrg#ri# # # # # # # # # # # prqh|## wkdw## fdph## lq## iurp## rxwvlgh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## xvhg## iru## ilqdqflqj# vxesulph## fuhglwB## Zk|#zdv# # # wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## xqolnh## rwkhu## hfrqrplhv## olnh# Jhupdq|## dqg## Mdsdq/## xqdeoh## wr## h{sruw## lwv## zd|## rxw## ri## wkh## 5334## uhfhvvlrqB# Zk|#duh#srruhu#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#olnh#Fklqd#ilqdqflqj#wkh#xqvxvwdlqdeoh# # # # # # # # # # frqvxpswlrq#ri#ulfk#frxqwulhv# # # # # olnh## wkh## Xqlwhg## VwdwhvB## Zk|#glg# # # wkh## Ihghudo# Uhvhuyh#nhhs#udwhv#vr#orz#iru#vr#orqjB#Zk|#glg#ilqdqfldo#ilupv#pdnh#ordqv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## shrsoh## zkr## kdg## qr## lqfrph/## qr## mrev/## dqg## qr## dvvhwvᄇd## sudfwlfh## vr# xeltxlwrxv## wkdw## lw## dwwudfwhg## lwv## rzq## dfurq|p/## QLQMD## ordqvB## Zk|## glg## wkh# edqnvᄇwkh#vdxvdjh#pdnhuv/#vr#wr#vshdnᄇkrog#vr#pdq|#ri#wkh#vdxvdjhv#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#rzq#frqvxpswlrq#zkhq#wkh|#nqhz#zkdw#zhqw#lqwr#wkhpB# # # # # # # # # # L#dwwhpsw#wr#dgguhvv#doo#wkhvh#txhvwlrqv#lq#wklv#errn1#Ohw#ph#vwduw#e|#vd|lqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#L#gr#qrw#kdyh#d#vlqjoh#h{sodqdwlrq#iru#wklv#fulvlv/#dqg#vr#qr#vlqjoh#vloyhu# ## # # # # # # # # # # # # # exoohw## wr## suhyhqw## d## ixwxuh## rqh1## Dq|## vlqjoh## h{sodqdwlrq## zrxog## eh## wrr# vlpsolvwlf1## L## xvh## wkh## phwdskru## ri## idxow## olqhv1## Lq## jhrorj|/## idxow## olqhv## duh# euhdnv## lq## wkh## Hduwkᄊv## vxuidfh## zkhuh## whfwrqlf## sodwhv## frph## lq## frqwdfw## ru# froolgh1#Hqruprxv#vwuhvvhv#exlog#xs#durxqg#wkhvh#idxow#olqhv1#L#ghvfuleh#wkh# # # # # # # # # ## # idxow#olqhv#wkdw#kdyh#hphujhg#lq#wkh#joredo# # # # # # # # # hfrqrp|#dqg#h{sodlq#krz# # # # # wkhvh# idxow#olqhv#diihfw#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru1# # # # # # Rqh#vhw#ri#idxow#olqhv#vwhpv#iurp#grphvwlf#srolwlfdo#vwuhvvhv/#hvshfldoo|#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1#Doprvw#hyhu|#ilqdqfldo#fulvlv#kdv#srolwlfdo#urrwv/#zklfk#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # grxew#gliihu#lq#hdfk#fdvh#exw#duh#srolwlfdo#qhyhuwkhohvv/#iru#vwurqj#srolwlfdo# # # # # # # # # # # # irufhv#duh#qhhghg#wr#ryhufrph#wkh#fkhfnv#dqg#edodqfhv#wkdw#prvw#lqgxvwuldo# # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## kdyh## hvwdeolvkhg## wr## frqwdlq#ilqdqfldo# # # h{xehudqfh1#Wkh# # # vhfrqg## vhw# ri#idxow#olqhv# # # # hpdqdwhv## iurp#wudgh# # # lpedodqfhv## ehwzhhq#frxqwulhv# # # vwhpplqj# iurp#sulru# # # sdwwhuqv## ri## jurzwk1## Wkh## ilqdo## vhw## ri## idxow## olqhv## ghyhorsv## zkhq# gliihuhqw## w|shv## ri## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpv## frph## lqwr## frqwdfw## wr## ilqdqfh## wkh## wudgh# lpedodqfhv=## vshflilfdoo|/## zkhq#wkh# # # wudqvsduhqw/## frqwudfwxdoo|#edvhg/# # # dupᄊv0 ohqjwk#ilqdqfldo# # # v|vwhpv## lq#frxqwulhv# # # olnh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## dqg## wkh## Xqlwhg# Nlqjgrp#ilqdqfh/# # # ru## duh## ilqdqfhg## e|/## ohvv## wudqvsduhqw#ilqdqfldo# # # v|vwhpv## lq# pxfk#ri#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog1#Ehfdxvh#gliihuhqw#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhpv#zrun#rq# # # gliihuhqw#sulqflsohv#dqg#lqyroyh#gliihuhqw#irupv#ri#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq/# # # # # # # # # wkh|#whqg#wr#glvwruw#hdfk#rwkhu# # # # # # ᄊv#ixqfwlrqlqj#zkhqhyhu#wkh|#frph#lqwr#forvh# # # # # # # frqwdfw1#Doo#wkhvh#idxow#olqhv#diihfw#ilqdqfldo0vhfwru#ehkdylru#dqg#duh#fhqwudo# # # # # # # # # # # wr#rxu#xqghuvwdqglqj#ri#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv1# # # # # # #
Ulvlqj#Lqhtxdolw|#dqg#wkh#Sxvk#iru#Krxvlqj#Fuhglw # # # # # # # # Wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw#h{dpsoh#ri#wkh#iluvw#nlqg#ri#idxow#olqh/#zklfk#lv#wkh#wkhph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#Fkdswhu# # # 4/## lv## ulvlqj#lqfrph# # # lqhtxdolw|#lq#wkh# # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## dqg## wkh## srolwlfdo# suhvvxuh#lw#kdv#fuhdwhg#iru#hdv|#fuhglw1#Fohduo|/#wkh#kljko|#ylvleoh#lqfrphv#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # yhu|#wrs#kdyh# # # # jrqh## xs1#Wkh# # # wrs#4#shufhqw#ri#krxvhkrogv# # # # # # dffrxqwhg#iru# # # rqo|#;1<# # shufhqw#ri#lqfrph#lq#4<:9/#exw#wklv#vkduh#juhz#wr#5618#shufhqw#ri#wkh#wrwdo#lqfrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jhqhudwhg## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lq## 533:1## Sxw## gliihuhqwo|/## ri## hyhu|#groodu# # # ri## uhdo# lqfrph#jurzwk#wkdw#zdv#jhqhudwhg#ehwzhhq#4<:9#dqg#533:/#8;#fhqwv#zhqw#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 8# wrs## 4## shufhqw## ri## krxvhkrogv1 # Lq## 533:## wkh## khgjh## ixqg## pdqdjhu## Mrkq## Sdxovrq# hduqhg## '61:## eloolrq/## derxw## :7/333## wlphv## wkh## phgldq## krxvhkrog## lqfrph## lq## wkh# 9# Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1 # Exw#dowkrxjk#wkh#jdujdqwxdq#lqfrphv#dw#wkh#yhu|#wrs#h{flwh#sxeolf#lqwhuhvw#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # hqudjh#plggoh0fodvv#froxpqlvwv/#prvw#Dphulfdqv#uduho|#phhw#d#eloolrqdluh#khgjh# # # # # # # # # # ixqg#pdqdjhu1#Pruh#uhohydqw#wr#wkhlu#h{shulhqfh#lv#wkh#idfw#wkdw#vlqfh#wkh#4<;3v/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#zdjhv#ri#zrunhuv#dw#wkh#<3wk#shufhqwloh#ri#wkh#zdjh#glvwulexwlrq#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhvᄇvxfk#dv# # # riilfh## pdqdjhuvᄇkdyh## jurzq#pxfk#idvwhu# # # # wkdq#wkh# # # zdjh## ri#wkh# # 83wk## shufhqwloh## zrunhu## +wkh## phgldq## zrunhu,ᄇw|slfdoo|## idfwru|## zrunhuv## dqg# riilfh#dvvlvwdqwv1#D#qxpehu#ri#idfwruv#duh#uhvsrqvleoh#iru#wkh#jurzwk#lq#wkh#<3283# # # # # # # # # # # # # # gliihuhqwldo1## Shukdsv## wkh## prvw## lpsruwdqw## lv## wkdw## dowkrxjk## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# whfkqrorjlfdo## surjuhvv## uhtxluhv## wkh## oderu## irufh## wr## kdyh## hyhu0juhdwhu## vnloovᄇd# kljk## vfkrro## glsorpd## zdv## vxiilflhqw## iru## rxu## sduhqwv/## zkhuhdv## dq## xqghujudgxdwh# ghjuhh#lv#eduho|#vxiilflhqw#iru#wkh#riilfh#zrunhu#wrgd|ᄇwkh#hgxfdwlrq#v|vwhp#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # ehhq#xqdeoh# # # wr## surylgh## hqrxjk#ri#wkh# # # # oderu## irufh## zlwk#wkh# # # qhfhvvdu|#hgxfdwlrq1# # Wkh## sureohpv## duh## urrwhg## lq## lqgliihuhqw## qxwulwlrq/## vrfldol}dwlrq/## dqg## ohduqlqj## lq# hduo|#fklogkrrg/# # # dqg## lq#g|vixqfwlrqdo# # # sulpdu|#dqg# # # vhfrqgdu|#vfkrrov# # # wkdw#ohdyh# # wrr#pdq|#Dphulfdqv#xqsuhsduhg#iru#froohjh1# # # # # # Wkh#hyhu|gd|#frqvhtxhqfh#iru#wkh#plggoh#fodvv#lv#d#vwdjqdqw#sd|fkhfn#dv#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv## jurzlqj#mre#lqvhfxulw|1#Srolwlfldqv# # # # # ihho## wkhlu## frqvwlwxhqwvᄊ#sdlq/#exw#lw#lv# # # # # # yhu|# kdug## wr## lpsuryh## wkh## txdolw|## ri## hgxfdwlrq/## iru## lpsuryhphqw## uhtxluhv## uhdo## dqg# hiihfwlyh## srolf|## fkdqjh## lq## dq## duhd## zkhuh## wrr## pdq|## yhvwhg## lqwhuhvwv## idyru## wkh# vwdwxv#txr1#Pruhryhu/#dq|#fkdqjh#zloo# # # # # # # uhtxluh#|hduv#wr#wdnh#hiihfw#dqg#wkhuhiruh# # # # # # # zloo## qrw## dgguhvv## wkh## fxuuhqw## dq{lhw|## ri## wkh## hohfwrudwh1## Wkxv## srolwlfldqv## kdyh# orrnhg/## ru## ehhq## vwhhuhg## lqwr## orrnlqj/## iru## rwkhu/## txlfnhu## zd|v## wr## prooli|## wkhlu# frqvwlwxhqwv1## Zh## kdyh## orqj## xqghuvwrrg## wkdw## lw## lv## qrw## lqfrph## wkdw## pdwwhuv## exw# frqvxpswlrq1## Vwulsshg## wr## lwv## hvvhqwldov/## wkh## dujxphqw## lv## wkdw## li## vrphkrz## wkh# frqvxpswlrq#ri#plggoh0fodvv#krxvhkroghuv#nhhsv#xs/#li#wkh|#fdq#diirug#d#qhz#fdu# # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhu|#ihz# # # |hduv## dqg## wkh## rffdvlrqdo## h{rwlf## krolgd|/## shukdsv## wkh|#zloo# # # sd|#ohvv# # dwwhqwlrq#wr#wkhlu#vwdjqdqw#prqwko|#sd|fkhfnv1# # # # # # Wkhuhiruh/## wkh## srolwlfdo## uhvsrqvh## wr## ulvlqj## lqhtxdolw|ᄇzkhwkhu## fduhixoo|# sodqqhg## ru## dq#xqsuhphglwdwhg# # # uhdfwlrq#wr# # # frqvwlwxhqw## ghpdqgvᄇzdv## wr## h{sdqg# ohqglqj## wr## krxvhkrogv/## hvshfldoo|## orz0lqfrph## rqhv1## Wkh## ehqhilwvᄇjurzlqj# frqvxpswlrq#dqg#pruh#mrevᄇzhuh#lpphgldwh/#zkhuhdv#sd|lqj#wkh#lqhylwdeoh#eloo# # # # # # # # # # frxog#eh#srvwsrqhg#lqwr#wkh#ixwxuh1#F|qlfdo#dv#lw#pd|#vhhp/#hdv|#fuhglw#kdv#ehhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xvhg#dv#d#sdooldwlyh#wkurxjkrxw#klvwru|#e|#jryhuqphqwv#wkdw#duh#xqdeoh#wr#dgguhvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ghhshu## dq{lhwlhv## ri#wkh# # # plggoh## fodvv## gluhfwo|1## Srolwlfldqv/## krzhyhu/## zdqw#wr# #
frxfk#wkh# # # remhfwlyh## lq#pruh# # # xsoliwlqj#dqg# # # shuvxdvlyh## whupv## wkdq#wkdw# # # ri#fudvvo|# # lqfuhdvlqj#frqvxpswlrq1#Lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#wkh#h{sdqvlrq#ri#krph#rzqhuvklsᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # d## nh|## hohphqw## ri## wkh## Dphulfdq## guhdpᄇwr## orz0dqg## plggoh0lqfrph## krxvhkrogv# zdv## wkh## ghihqvleoh## olqfkslq## iru## wkh## eurdghu## dlpv## ri## h{sdqglqj## fuhglw## dqg# frqvxpswlrq1## Exw## zkhq## hdv|## prqh|## sxvkhg## e|## d## ghhs0srfnhwhg## jryhuqphqw# frphv## lqwr## frqwdfw## zlwk## wkh## surilw## prwlyh## ri## d## vrsklvwlfdwhg/## frpshwlwlyh/## dqg# dprudo#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru/#d#ghhs#idxow#olqh#ghyhorsv1# # # # # # # # Wklv#lv#qrw/#ri#frxuvh/#wkh#iluvw#wlph#lq#klvwru|#zkhq#fuhglw#h{sdqvlrq#kdv#ehhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xvhg#wr#dvvxdjh#wkh#frqfhuqv#ri#d#jurxs#wkdw#lv#ehlqj#ohiw#ehklqg/#qru#zloo#lw#eh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # odvw1## Lq## idfw/## rqh## grhv## qrw## hyhq## qhhg## wr## orrn## rxwvlgh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## iru# h{dpsohv1#Wkh#ghuhjxodwlrq#dqg#udslg#h{sdqvlrq#ri#edqnlqj#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh# # # hduo|#|hduv# # # ri#wkh# # # wzhqwlhwk#fhqwxu|#zdv# # # # lq#pdq|#zd|v# # # # d## uhvsrqvh## wr## wkh# Srsxolvw## pryhphqw/## edfnhg## e|## vpdoo## dqg## phglxp0vl}hg## iduphuv## zkr## irxqg# wkhpvhoyhv## idoolqj## ehklqg## wkh## jurzlqj## qxpehuv## ri## lqgxvwuldo## zrunhuv## dqg# ghpdqghg#hdvlhu# # # fuhglw1#H{fhvvlyh#uxudo# # # # fuhglw#zdv#rqh#ri#wkh#lpsruwdqw#fdxvhv# # # # # # # ri#edqn#idloxuh#gxulqj#wkh#Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrq1# # # # # # #
H{sruw0Ohg#Jurzwk#dqg#Ghshqghqf| # # # # Wkhuh## duh## xvxdoo|## olplwv## wr## ghew0ixhohg## frqvxpswlrq/## hvshfldoo|## lq## d## odujh# frxqwu|## olnh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Wkh## vwurqj## ghpdqg## iru## frqvxphu## jrrgv## dqg# vhuylfhv#whqgv#wr#sxvk#xs#sulfhv#dqg#lqiodwlrq1#D#zruulhg#fhqwudo#edqn#wkhq#udlvhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuhvw## udwhv/## fxuelqj## erwk## krxvhkrogvᄊ## delolw|## wr## eruurz## dqg## wkhlu## ghvluh## wr# frqvxph1#Wkurxjk#wkh#odwh#4<<3v#dqg#wkh#5333v/#wkrxjk/#d#vljqlilfdqw#sruwlrq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#lqfuhdvh#lq#X1V1#krxvhkrog#ghpdqg#zdv#phw#iurp#deurdg/#iurp#frxqwulhv#vxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv## Jhupdq|/#Mdsdq/#dqg/#lqfuhdvlqjo|/#Fklqd/#zklfk#kdyh# # # # # # # # wudglwlrqdoo|#uholhg#rq# # # h{sruwv#iru#jurzwk#dqg#kdg#sohqw|#ri#vsduh#fdsdflw|#wr#pdnh#pruh1#Exw/#dv#L#dujxh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ## lq#Fkdswhu#5/#wkh#delolw|#ri#wkhvh#frxqwulhv#wr#vxsso|#wkh#jrrgv#uhiohfwv#d#vhulrxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhdnqhvv## lq#wkh#jurzwk#sdwk#wkh|#kdyh#iroorzhgᄇh{fhvvlyh#ghshqghqfh#rq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # iruhljq#frqvxphu1#Wklv#ghshqghqfh#lv#wkh#vrxufh#ri#wkh#vhfrqg#idxow#olqh1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#joredo#hfrqrp|#lv#iudjloh#ehfdxvh#orz#grphvwlf#ghpdqg#iurp#wudglwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # h{sruwhuv## sxwv## suhvvxuh## rq## rwkhu## frxqwulhv## wr## vwhs## xs## vshqglqj1## Ehfdxvh## wkh# h{sruwhuv#kdyh#h{fhvv#jrrgv#wr#vxsso|/#frxqwulhv#olnh#Vsdlq/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp/# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhvᄇzklfk#ljqruh# # # jurzlqj#krxvhkrog# # # lqghewhgqhvv## dqg## hyhq# dfwlyho|#hqfrxudjh#lwᄇdqg#frxqwulhv#olnh#Juhhfhᄇzklfk#odfn#wkh#srolwlfdo#zloo# # # # # # # # # # wr## frqwuro## jryhuqphqw## srsxolvp#dqg# # # xqlrq## ghpdqgvᄇwhqg## wr## jhw## d## orqj## ursh1# Hyhqwxdoo|/#kljk#krxvhkrog#ru# # # # # jryhuqphqw#lqghewhgqhvv#lq#wkhvh#frxqwulhv#olplwv# # # # # # ixuwkhu#ghpdqg#h{sdqvlrq#dqg#ohdgv#wr#d#zuhqfklqj#dgmxvwphqw#doo#durxqg1#Exw#vr# # # # # # # # # # # # # orqj#dv#odujh#frxqwulhv#olnh#Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq#duh#vwuxfwxudoo|#lqfolqhgᄇlqghhg# # # # # # # # # # # uhtxluhgᄇwr## h{sruw/## joredo## vxsso|## zdvkhv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## orrnlqj## iru# frxqwulhv#wkdw#kdyh#wkh#zhdnhvw#srolflhv#ru#wkh#ohdvw#glvflsolqh/#whpswlqj#wkhp#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # vshqg#xqwlo#wkh|#vlpso|#fdqqrw#diirug#lw#dqg#vxffxpe#wr#fulvlv1# # # # # # # # # # # Zk|## duh## vr## pdq|## hfrqrplhv## ghshqghqw## rq## frqvxpswlrq## hovhzkhuhB## Wkhlu# ghshqghqfh## vwhpv## iurp## wkh## sdwk## wkh|## fkrvh## wrzdug## udslg## jurzwk/## rxw## ri## wkh# ghvwuxfwlrq#fuhdwhg#e|#Zruog#Zdu#LL#ru#rxw#ri#sryhuw|1#Jryhuqphqwv#+dqg#edqnv,# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuyhqhg#h{whqvlyho|#lq#wkhvh#hfrqrplhv#wr#fuhdwh#vwurqj#ilupv#dqg#frpshwlwlyh# # # # # # # # # # # h{sruwhuv/## w|slfdoo|## dw## wkh## h{shqvh## ri## krxvhkrog## frqvxpswlrq## lq## wkhlu## rzq# frxqwu|1# Ryhu## wlph/## wkhvh## frxqwulhv## fuhdwhg## d## yhu|## hiilflhqw## h{sruw0rulhqwhg# pdqxidfwxulqj#vhfwruᄇilupv#olnh#Fdqrq/#Wr|rwd/#Vdpvxqj/#dqg#Iruprvd#Sodvwlfv# # # # # # # # # duh## zruog## ohdghuv1## Wkh## qhhg## wr## eh## frpshwlwlyh## lq## iruhljq## pdunhwv## nhsw## wkh# h{sruwhuv## rq#wkhlu# # # wrhv1## Exw#dowkrxjk#joredo# # # # frpshwlwlrq#olplwhg# # # wkh## ghohwhulrxv# hiihfwv## ri## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq## wkh## h{sruw## vhfwru/## wkhuh## zhuh## qr## vxfk# uhvwudlqwv## lq## wkh## grphvwlf0rulhqwhg## surgxfwlrq## vhfwru1## Edqnv/## uhwdlohuv/# uhvwdxudqwv/#dqg#frqvwuxfwlrq#frpsdqlhv/#wkurxjk#wkhlu#lqioxhqfh#ryhu#jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # srolflhv/#kdyh#pdqdjhg#wr#olplw#grphvwlf#frpshwlwlrq#lq#wkhlu#uhvshfwlyh#vhfwruv1# # # # # # # # # # # Dv#d#uhvxow/#wkhvh#vhfwruv#duh#yhu|#lqhiilflhqw1#Wkhuh#duh#qr#odujh#Mdsdqhvh#edqnv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # iru## h{dpsoh/## wkdw## ulydo## KVEF## lq## lwv## joredo## uhdfk/## qr## Mdsdqhvh## uhwdlohuv## wkdw# dssurdfk## Zdopduw## lq## vl}h## ru## frvw## frpshwlwlyhqhvv/## dqg## qr## Mdsdqhvh## uhvwdxudqw# fkdlqv#wkdw#ulydo#PfGrqdogᄊv#lq#lwv#qxpehu#ri#iudqfklvhv1# # # # # # # # # Wkhuhiruh/#hyhq#wkrxjk#wkhvh#hfrqrplhv#juhz#h{wudruglqdulo|#idvw#wr#uhdfk#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # udqnv#ri#wkh#ulfk/#dv#wkhlu#lqlwldo#dgydqwdjh#ri#orz#zdjhv#glvdsshduhg#dqg#h{sruwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
ehfdph## pruh## gliilfxow/## wkhlu## srolwlfdoo|## vwurqj## exw## yhu|## lqhiilflhqw## grphvwlf0 rulhqwhg## vhfwru## ehjdq## wr## lpsrvh## vhulrxv## frqvwudlqwv## rq## lqwhuqdoo|## jhqhudwhg# jurzwk1#Qrw#rqo|#lv#lw#kdug#iru#wkhvh#hfrqrplhv#wr#jurz# # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wkhlu#rzq#lq#qrupdo# # # # # wlphv/#exw#lw#lv# # # # # hyhq#kdughu# # # iru## wkhp#wr#vwlpxodwh# # # # grphvwlf## jurzwk#lq#grzqwxuqv# # # zlwkrxw#wuhphqgrxvo|#zdvwhixo#vshqglqj1#Wkh#qdwxudo#lpsxovh#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw/# # # # # # # # # # zkhq#xujhg# # # wr## vshqg/## lv## wr## idyru## lqioxhqwldo## exw#lqhiilflhqw#grphvwlf# # # # surgxfhuv/# zklfk#grhv# # # olwwoh## iru## orqj0uxq#jurzwk1# # # Wkhuhiruh/## wkhvh## frxqwulhv## kdyh## ehfrph# ghshqghqw#rq#iruhljq#ghpdqg#wr#sxoo#wkhp#rxw#ri#hfrqrplf#wurxjkv1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#ixwxuh#grhv#qrw#orrn#pxfk#euljkwhu1#Dv#srsxodwlrqv#lq#wkhvh#frxqwulhv#djh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## rqo|## zloo## fkdqjh## ehfrph## pruh## gliilfxow/## exw## wkhlu## ghshqghqflhv## zloo## dovr# zruvhq1#Dqg#Fklqd/#zklfk#lv#olnho|#wr#eh#wkh#zruogᄊv#odujhvw#hfrqrp|#lq#wkh#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrr## glvwdqw## ixwxuh/## lv## iroorzlqj## d## gdqjhurxvo|## vlplodu## sdwk1## Lw## kdv## wr## pdnh# vxevwdqwldo## srolf|#fkdqjhv# # # li#lw#lv# # # # qrw#wr# # # mrlq#wklv# # # jurxs## dv## dq#hqfxpeudqfh# # # rq/# udwkhu#wkdq#dq#hqjlqh#ri/#zruog#hfrqrplf#jurzwk1# # # # # # # #
Wkh#Fodvk#ri#V|vwhpv # # # # Lq## wkh## sdvw/## idvw0jurzlqj## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## zhuh## w|slfdoo|## qrw## qhw# h{sruwhuv/## hyhq## wkrxjk## wkhlu## idfwrulhv## irfxvhg## rq## surgxflqj## wr## phhw## ghpdqg# hovhzkhuh1#Wkh#idvw#sdfh#ri#jurzwk#ri#frxqwulhv#olnh#Nruhd#dqg#Pdod|vld#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 4<;3v## dqg## hduo|## 4<<3v## hqwdlohg## vxevwdqwldo## lqyhvwphqw## lq## pdfklqhu|## dqg# htxlsphqw/#zklfk#zhuh#riwhq#lpsruwhg#iurp#Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq1#Wklv#phdqw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # udq#wudgh#ghilflwv#dqg#kdg#wr#eruurz#prqh|#rq#qhw#iurp#zruog#fdslwdo#pdunhwv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfh#wkhlu#lqyhvwphqw1# # # Hyhq#h{sruw0ohg# # # ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # wkxv## lqlwldoo|#khoshg# # # devrue## wkh## h{fhvv# vxsso|#iurp#wkh#ulfk#h{sruwhuv1#Exw#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#h{shulhqfhg#d#vhulhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#fulvhv#lq#wkh#4<<3v#wkdw#pdgh#wkhp#uhdol}h#wkdw#eruurzlqj#odujh#dprxqwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#wr#ixqg#lqyhvwphqw#zdv#d#uhflsh#iru#wurxeoh1#Lq#Fkdswhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # 6/## L#h{sodlq#zk|#wkhvh# # # # # hfrqrplhv## pryhg## iurp#khoslqj#wr# # # # devrue## joredo## h{fhvv# vxsso|## wr## ehfrplqj## qhw## h{sruwhuv## wkhpvhoyhv## dqg## frqwulexwlqj## wr## wkh## sureohp=# hvvhqwldoo|/## wkhlu## rzq## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpv## zhuh## edvhg## rq## ixqgdphqwdoo|## gliihuhqw# sulqflsohv#iurp#wkrvh#ri#wkhlu#ilqdqflhuv/#dqg#wkh#lqfrpsdwlelolw|#ehwzhhq#wkh#wzr/# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## vrxufh## ri## wkh## idxow## olqh/## pdgh## lw## h{wuhpho|## ulvn|## iru## wkhp#wr# # # eruurz## iurp# deurdg#wr#vxssruw#lqyhvwphqw#dqg#jurzwk1# # # # # # Lq#wkh#frpshwlwlyh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv#lq#frxqwulhv#olnh#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg## Nlqjgrp/## wkh## dffhqw## lv## rq## wudqvsduhqf|## dqg## hdv|## hqirufhdelolw|## ri# frqwudfwv## wkurxjk#wkh#ohjdo# # # # v|vwhp=## ehfdxvh#exvlqhvv# # # wudqvdfwlrqv## gr#qrw#ghshqg# # # rq#surslqtxlw|/# # # wkhvh## duh## uhihuuhg## wr## dv## ᄈdupᄊv0ohqjwkᄡ## v|vwhpv1## Ilqdqflhuv## jdlq# frqilghqfh## ehfdxvh## ri#wkhlu# # # delolw|#wr#rewdlq#sxeolfo|#dydlodeoh# # # # # # lqirupdwlrq#dqg# # xqghuvwdqg## wkh## eruurzhu#ᄊv## rshudwlrqv## dqg## ehfdxvh## wkh|## nqrz## wkdw## wkhlu## fodlpv# zloo#eh#surwhfwhg#dqg#hqirufhg#e|#wkh#frxuwv1#Dv#d#uhvxow/#wkh|#duh#zloolqj#wr#krog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # orqj0whup#fodlpv/#vxfk#dv#htxlw|#dqg#orqj0whup#ghew/#dqg#wr#ilqdqfh#wkh#ilqdo#xvhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # gluhfwo|#udwkhu#wkdq#jrlqj#wkurxjk#lqwhuphgldulhv#olnh#edqnv1#Hyhu|#wudqvdfwlrq#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # wr## eh## mxvwlilhg## rq## lwv## rzq## dqg## lv## frqgxfwhg## wkurxjk## frpshwlwlyh## elgglqj1## Wklv# ghvfulswlrq#lv# # # fohduo|#d# # # fdulfdwxuhᄇwudqvsduhqf|#zdv# # # plvvlqj#gxulqj#wkh# # # # uhfhqw# fulvlvᄇexw#lw#uhiohfwv#wkh#hvvhqwldov#ri#wkh#v|vwhp1# # # # # # # # Wkh## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpv## lq## frxqwulhv## zkhuh## jryhuqphqw## dqg## edqn## lqwhuyhqwlrq# zdv## lpsruwdqw#gxulqj#wkh#surfhvv# # # # # ri#jurzwk#duh#txlwh#gliihuhqw1#Sxeolf#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # lqirupdwlrq#lv#yhu|#olplwhg/#shukdsv#ehfdxvh#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dqg#edqnv#gluhfwhg# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#iorz# # # ri#ilqdqflqj#gxulqj#wkh#jurzwk#skdvh#dqg#glg#qrw#qhhg/#ru#zdqw/#sxeolf# # # # # # # # # # # # # ryhuvljkw## wkhq1## Hyhq## wkrxjk## lq## prvw## ri## wkhvh## frxqwulhv## wkh## jryhuqphqw## kdv# zlwkgudzq#iurp#gluhfwlqj#ilqdqfldo#iorzv/#edqnv#vwloo#sod|#dq#lpsruwdqw#uroh/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # lqirupdwlrq#lv# # # vwloo## forvho|#jxdughg# # # zlwklq#d# # # jurxs## ri## lqvlghuv1## Ehfdxvh## ri## wkh# sdxflw|#ri#sxeolf#lqirupdwlrq/#hqirufhphqw#ri#frqwudfwxdo#fodlpv#odujho|#ghshqgv# # # # # # # # # # rq## orqj0whup## exvlqhvv## uhodwlrqvklsv1## Wkh## eruurzhu## uhsd|v## wkh## ohqghu## ru# uhqhjrwldwhv## lq#jrrg# # # idlwk#wr# # # dyrlg## wkh## orvv## ri#wkh# # # uhodwlrqvkls/## dqg## wkh## dgyhuvh# frqvhtxhqfhv#lw#zrxog#kdyh/#lq#d#v|vwhp#zkhuh#uhodwlrqvklsv#duh#wkh#fxuuhqf|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{fkdqjh1## Wklv## phdqv## wkdw## rxwvlgh## ilqdqflhuv/## hvshfldoo|## iruhljqhuv/## kdyh## olwwoh# dffhvv#wr#wkh#v|vwhp1#Lqghhg/#wklv#eduulhu#lv#zkdw#pdnhv#wkh#v|vwhp#zrun/#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # li## eruurzhuv## frxog## sod|## rqh## ohqghu## rii## djdlqvw## dqrwkhu/## dv## lq## wkh## dupᄊv0ohqjwk# frpshwlwlyh#v|vwhp/#hqirufhphqw#zrxog#euhdn#grzq1# # # # # #
Vr## zkdw## kdsshqv## zkhq#dupᄊv0ohqjwk/# # # lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|#sulydwh# # # lqyhvwruv## duh# dvnhg#wr#ilqdqfh#frusrudwh#lqyhvwphqw#lq#d#ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|#zlwk#d#uhodwlrqvkls# # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhp/## dv## zdv## wkh## fdvh## lq## wkh## hduo|## 4<<3vB## Iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## zkr## gr## qrw# xqghuvwdqg## wkh## pxun|#lqvlghu# # # uhodwlrqvklsv## gr## wkuhh## wklqjv1## Wkh|#plqlpl}h# # # ulvnv# e|#riihulqj#rqo|#vkruw0whup#ordqv# # # # # # vr## wkdw#wkh|#fdq#sxoo# # # # # wkhlu## prqh|#rxw#dw#vkruw# # # # qrwlfh1#Wkh|#ghqrplqdwh#sd|phqwv#lq#iruhljq#fxuuhqf|#vr#wkdw#wkhlu#fodlpv#fdqqrw# # # # # # # # # # # # eh## uhgxfhg## e|## grphvwlf## lqiodwlrq## ru## d## fxuuhqf|## ghydoxdwlrq1## Dqg## wkh|## ohqg# wkurxjk#wkh#orfdo#edqnv#vr#wkdw#li#wkh|#sxoo#wkhlu#prqh|#dqg#wkh#edqnv#fdqqrw#uhsd|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zloo# # # # # eh#gudzq#lqwr#vxssruwlqj#lwv#edqnv#wr#dyrlg#zlghvsuhdg# # # # # # # # # hfrqrplf## gdpdjh1#Wkxv# # # iruhljq#lqyhvwruv# # # jhw#dq#lpsolflw#jryhuqphqw#jxdudqwhh1# # # # # Wkh## wkuhdw## ri## lqiolfwlqj## froodwhudo## gdpdjh## lv## zkdw## pdnhv## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## iruhljq# lqyhvwruv#zloolqj#wr#hqwuxvw#wkhlu#prqh|#wr#wkh#rsdtxh#uhodwlrqvkls#v|vwhp1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## sureohp## lq## wkh## plg04<<3v## lq## Hdvw## Dvld## zdv## wkdw## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv/# surwhfwhg#e|#vxfk#phdvxuhv/#kdg#olwwoh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#vfuhhq#wkh#txdolw|#ri#yhqwxuhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfhg1## Dqg## wkh## grphvwlf## edqnlqj## v|vwhp/## zkrvh## ohqglqj## zdv## xqwlo## uhfhqwo|# gluhfwhg#dqg#jxdudqwhhg#e|#wkh#jryhuqphqw/#kdg#olwwoh#delolw|#wr#h{huflvh#fduhixo# # # # # # # # # # # # mxgjphqw/#hvshfldoo|#zkhq#eruurzhuv#zhuh#folpelqj#wkh#odgghu#ri#whfkqrorjlfdo# # # # # # # # # # vrsklvwlfdwlrq## dqg## lqyhvwlqj## lq## frpsoh{/## fdslwdo0lqwhqvlyh## surmhfwv1## Eruurzhuv# zhuh## reylrxvo|## kdss|## zlwk## wkh## iuhh## iorz## ri## fuhglw## dqg## kdg## qr## ghvluh## wr## dvn# txhvwlrqv1#Exw#zkhq#wkh#surmhfwv#ilqdqfhg#e|#wklv#srruo|#gluhfwhg#ohqglqj#vwduwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # xqghushuiruplqj/#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#zhuh#txlfn#wr#sxoo#wkhlu#prqh|#rxw1#Wkhuhiruh/# # # # # # # # # # # ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # wkdw#uholhg# # # vxevwdqwldoo|#rq#iruhljq#prqh|#wr# # # # # # ilqdqfh## wkhlu# lqyhvwphqwv## vxiihuhg## shulrglf## errpv## dqg## exvwv/## fxoplqdwlqj#lq#wkh# # # # fulvhv## ri#wkh# # odwh#4<<3v1# # Wkrvh## fulvhv## zhuh## erwk#ghydvwdwlqj#dqg# # # # kxploldwlqj1## Iru## h{dpsoh/## wkh## idoo## lq# Lqgrqhvldq#JGS#iurp#shdn#wr#wurxjk#zdv#forvh#wr#58#shufhqw/#vlplodu#wr#wkh#idoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{shulhqfhg## e|#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## gxulqj#wkh# # # Juhdw## Ghsuhvvlrq1## Exw## Lqgrqhvldᄊv# idoo## rffxuuhg## lq#wkh# # # vsdq#ri#rqo|#d# # # # # |hdu## ru## vr1## Dv## wkh## hfrqrp|#wlsshg# # # lqwr## iuhh# idoo/#zlwk#ploolrqv#ri#zrunhuv#ehfrplqj#xqhpsor|hg#zlwkrxw#dq|#irup#ri#vxssruw/# # # # # # # # # # # # Lqgrqhvld## h{shulhqfhg## udfh## ulrwv## dqg## srolwlfdo## wxuprlo1## Wr## fds## lw## doo/## d## surxg# frxqwu|#wkdw#ihow#lw#kdg#olehudwhg#lwvhoi#iurp#lwv#frorqldo#pdvwhuv#dqg#kdg#dfklhyhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vrph#phdvxuh#ri#hfrqrplf#lqghshqghqfh#kdg#wr#jr#kdw#lq#kdqg#wr#wkh#LPI#iru#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ordq## dqg/## lq## rughu## wr## jhw## lw/## zdv## irufhg## wr## vxeplw## wr## d## sohwkrud## ri## frqglwlrqv1# Vrph## ri#wkhvh# # # zhuh## glfwdwhg## gluhfwo|#e|#lqgxvwuldo# # # # frxqwulhv## wr## idyru## wkhlu## rzq# lqwhuhvwv/#ohdylqj#Lqgrqhvldqv#vhhwklqj#derxw#wkhlu#shufhlyhg#orvv#ri#vryhuhljqw|1# # # # # # # # # # Lw## vkrxog## frph## dv## qr## vxusulvh/## wkhq/## wkdw## d## qxpehu## ri## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv# ghflghg#wr#qhyhu#ohdyh#wkhpvhoyhv#dw#wkh#phuf|#ri#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv# # # # # # # # # # # # +ru#wkh#LPI,#djdlq1#Udwkhu#wkdq#eruurz#iurp#deurdg#wr#ilqdqfh#wkhlu#lqyhvwphqw/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## jryhuqphqwv## dqg## frusrudwlrqv## ghflghg## wr## dedqgrq## judqg## lqyhvwphqw# surmhfwv## dqg## ghew0ixhohg## h{sdqvlrq1## Pruhryhu/## d## qxpehu## ghflghg## wr## errvw# h{sruwv## e|## pdlqwdlqlqj## dq## xqghuydoxhg## fxuuhqf|1## Lq## ex|lqj## iruhljq## fxuuhqf|## wr# nhhs## wkhlu## h{fkdqjh## udwh## grzq/## wkh|#dovr# # # exlow#odujh# # # iruhljq0h{fkdqjh## uhvhuyhv/# zklfk#frxog# # # vhuyh## dv## d## udlq|0gd|#ixqg# # # li## iruhljq#ohqghuv# # # hyhu## sdqlfnhg## djdlq1# Wkxv## lq#wkh# # # odwh## 4<<3v/## ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # fxw#edfn#rq#lqyhvwphqw#dqg# # # # # # wxuqhg# iurp#ehlqj#qhw# # # # lpsruwhuv## wr## ehfrplqj#qhw# # # h{sruwhuv## ri## erwk#jrrgv# # # dqg## fdslwdo/# dgglqj#wr#wkh#joredo#vxsso|#joxw1# # # # # # Lqyhvwphqw#e|#lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|#frusrudwlrqv#dovr#froodsvhg#vrrq#diwhu/#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # #
grw0frp#exvw/# # # dqg## wkh## zruog## ihoo## lqwr## uhfhvvlrq## lq## wkh## hduo|## |hduv## ri## wkh## qhz# ploohqqlxp1## Zlwk#frxqwulhv# # # olnh## Jhupdq|#dqg# # # Mdsdq#xqdeoh# # # wr## sxoo## wkhlu## zhljkw# ehfdxvh## ri#wkhlu# # # h{sruw#rulhqwdwlrq/# # # wkh## exughq#ri#vwlpxodwlqj#jurzwk#ihoo# # # # # # rq#wkh# # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# #
Mreohvv#Uhfryhulhv#dqg#wkh#Suhvvxuh#wr#Vwlpxodwh # # # # # # # Dv## L## dujxh## deryh/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv## srolwlfdoo|## suhglvsrvhg## wrzdug# vwlpxodwlqj#frqvxpswlrq1#Exw#hyhq#dv#lw#gholyhuhg#wkh#qhfhvvdu|#vwlpxoxv#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh# zruog## wr## hphujh## iurp#wkh# # # 5334## uhfhvvlrq/## lw## glvfryhuhg/## pxfk#dv# # # lq#wkh# # # 4<<4# uhfryhu|/## wkdw## mrev## zhuh## qrw## ehlqj## fuhdwhg1## Jlyhq## wkh## vkruw## gxudwlrq## ri# xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## wklv## fuhdwhg## hqruprxv## dgglwlrqdo# srolwlfdo## suhvvxuh#wr#frqwlqxh#lqmhfwlqj#vwlpxoxv# # # # # # lqwr#wkh#hfrqrp|1#Dv# # # # # L#dujxh#lq# # # Fkdswhu#7/#mreohvv#uhfryhulhv#duh#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|#d#wklqj#ri#wkh#sdvw#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhvᄇlqghhg/#wkh#fxuuhqw#uhfryhu|#lv#surylqj#vorz#wkxv#idu#lq#jhqhudwlqj#mrev1# # # # # # # # # # # # Mreohvv## uhfryhulhv## duh## sduwlfxoduo|#ghwulphqwdo# # # ehfdxvh## wkh## surorqjhg## vwlpxoxv# dlphg## dw## iruflqj## dq## xqzloolqj## sulydwh## vhfwru## wr## fuhdwh## mrev## whqgv## wr## zdus# lqfhqwlyhv/## hvshfldoo|## lq## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru1## Wklv## frqvwlwxwhv## |hw## dqrwkhu## idxow# olqh#vwhpplqj#iurp#wkh#lqwhudfwlrq#ehwzhhq#srolwlfv#dqg#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru/#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # wlph#rqh#wkdw#ydulhv#ryhu#wkh#exvlqhvv#f|foh1# # # # # # # # Iurp#4<93#xqwlo#wkh#4<<4#uhfhvvlrq/#uhfryhulhv#iurp#uhfhvvlrqv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv## zhuh## w|slfdoo|#udslg1# # # Iurp#wkh# # # wurxjk#ri#wkh# # # # uhfhvvlrq/## wkh## dyhudjh## wlph# wdnhq#e|#wkh#hfrqrp|#wr#uhfryhu#wr#suh0uhfhvvlrq#rxwsxw#ohyhov#zdv#ohvv#wkdq#wzr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # :# txduwhuv/#dqg#wkh#orvw#mrev#zhuh#uhfryhuhg#zlwklq#hljkw#prqwkv1 # # # # # # # # # Wkh## uhfryhulhv## iurp## wkh## uhfhvvlrqv## ri## 4<<4## dqg## 5333ᄆ5334## zhuh## yhu|# gliihuhqw1## Dowkrxjk#surgxfwlrq#uhfryhuhg# # # # zlwklq#wkuhh# # # txduwhuv## lq#4<<4# # # dqg## mxvw# rqh#txduwhu#lq#5334/#lw#wrrn#56#prqwkv#iurp#wkh#wurxjk#ri#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#wr#uhfryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ;## Lqghhg/#mre# wkh#orvw#mrev#lq#4<<4#uhfhvvlrq#dqg#6;#prqwkv#lq#wkh#5334#uhfhvvlrq1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # orvvhv#frqwlqxhg#zhoo#lqwr#wkh#uhfryhu|/#vr#wkdw#wkhvh#uhfryhulhv#zhuh#ghvhuyhgo|# # # # # # # # # # # # fdoohg#mreohvv#uhfryhulhv1# # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lv## vlqjxoduo|## xqsuhsduhg## iru## mreohvv# uhfryhulhv1## W|slfdoo|/## xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## odvw## rqo|## vl{## prqwkv1## Pruhryhu/# ehfdxvh## khdowk#fduh# # # ehqhilwv## kdyh## klvwrulfdoo|#ehhq#wlhg#wr#mrev/#dq#xqhpsor|hg# # # # # # # zrunhu#dovr#ulvnv#orvlqj#dffhvv#wr#diirugdeoh#khdowk#fduh1# # # # # # # # # Vkruw0gxudwlrq#ehqhilwv#pd|#kdyh#ehhq#dssursuldwh#zkhq#uhfryhulhv#zhuh#idvw# # # # # # # # # # dqg#mrev#sohqwlixo1#Wkh#ihdu#ri#orvlqj#ehqhilwv#ehiruh#ilqglqj#d#mre#pd|#kdyh#jlyhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrunhuv#dq#lqfhqwlyh#wr#orrn#kdughu#dqg#pdnh#ehwwhu#pdwfkhv#zlwk#hpsor|huv1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#ihz#mrev#ehlqj#fuhdwhg/#d#srvlwlyh#lqfhqwlyh#kdv#wxuqhg#lqwr#d#vrxufh#ri#juhdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqfhuwdlqw|#dqg#dq{lhw|ᄇdqg#qrw#mxvw#iru# # # # # # # wkh#xqhpsor|hg1#Hyhq#wkrvh#zkr#kdyh# # # # # # mrev#ihdu#wkh|#frxog#orvh#wkhp#dqg#eh#fdvw#dguliw1# # # # # # # # # # Srolwlfldqv## ljqruh## srsxodu## dq{lhw|## dw## wkhlu## shulo1## Wkh## iluvw## Suhvlghqw## Exvk## lv# zlgho|#eholhyhg#wr#kdyh#orvw#klv#uhhohfwlrq#fdpsdljq/#ghvslwh#zlqqlqj#d#srsxodu# # # # # # # # # # # # zdu## lq## Ludt/## ehfdxvh## kh## vhhphg## rxw## ri## wrxfk## zlwk## sxeolf## frqfhuqv## derxw## wkh# mreohvv## uhfryhu|## iroorzlqj## wkh## 4<<4## uhfhvvlrq1## Wkdw## ohvvrq## kdv## ehhq## ixoo|# lqwhuqdol}hg#e|#srolwlfldqv1#Lq#srolwlfv/#hfrqrplf#uhfryhu|#lv# # # # # # # # # doo## derxw#mrev/#qrw# # # rxwsxw/## dqg## srolwlfldqv## duh## zloolqj## wr## dgg## vwlpxoxv/## erwk## ilvfdo## +jryhuqphqw# vshqglqj#dqg#orzhu#wd{hv,#dqg#prqhwdu|#+orzhu#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv,/#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # hfrqrp|#xqwlo#wkh#mrev#vwduw#uhdsshdulqj1# # # # # # Lq#wkhru|/# # # vxfk#dfwlrq#uhiohfwv# # # # ghprfudf|#dw# # # lwv## ehvw1## Lq#sudfwlfh/# # # wkrxjk/## wkh#
sxeolf## suhvvxuh## wr## gr## vrphwklqj## txlfno|## hqdeohv## srolwlfldqv## wr## uxq## urxjkvkrg# ryhu## wkh## xvxdo## fkhfnv## dqg## edodqfhv## rq#jryhuqphqw#srolf|#pdnlqj#lq#wkh# # # # # # # Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv1#Orqj0whup#srolflhv# # # # duh## hqdfwhg#xqghu# # # wkh## vkdgrz## ri#dq#hphujhqf|/#zlwk# # # # wkh#sduw|#wkdw#kdsshqv#wr#eh#lq#srzhu#dw#wkh#wlph#ri#wkh#grzqwxuq#jhwwlqj#wr#sxvk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv#shw#djhqgd1#Wklv#ohdgv#wr#juhdwhu# # # # # # # # ioxfwxdwlrqv#lq#srolf|#pdnlqj#wkdq#pljkw#eh# # # # # # # ghvluhg## e|#wkh# # # hohfwrudwh1## Lw#dovr# # # whqgv## wr## surprwh## h{fhvv## vshqglqj#dqg# # # lpsdluv# wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#orqj0whup#ilqdqfldo#khdowk1# # # # # Lq## Fkdswhu## 8/## L## h{soruh## wkh## suhflvh## zd|v## lq## zklfk## X1V1## prqhwdu|## srolf|## lv# # # srolwlfdo## frqvlghudwlrqv1## Prqhwdu|#srolf|#lv/# # # # ri#frxuvh/# # # wkh# lqioxhqfhg## e|#wkhvh# # # # # # # Uhvhuyh/#exw#lw#zrxog#eh#d#eudyh# # # # # # # grpdlq#ri#wkh#rvwhqvleo|#lqghshqghqw#Ihghudo# # # # # # # # # # # Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#fkdlupdq#zkr#ghilhg#srolwlfldqv#e|#udlvlqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#ehiruh# mrev## vwduwhg## uhdsshdulqj1## Lqghhg/## sduw## ri## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyhᄊv## pdqgdwh## lv## wr# pdlqwdlq## kljk## hpsor|phqw1## Pruhryhu/## zkhq## xqhpsor|phqw## vwd|v## kljk/## zdjh# # # # fhqwudo## edqnhuv## wrgd|/## lv## xqolnho|/## vr## wkh## Ihg# lqiodwlrq/## wkh## sulpdu|#frqfhuq#ri# ihhov## mxvwlilhg## lq## lwv## srolf|## ri## pdlqwdlqlqj## orz## lqwhuhvw## udwhv1## Exw## wkhuh## duh# # # wkdw## d## ydulhw|## ri## rwkhu## pdunhwv/## lqfoxglqj## wkrvh# frqvhtxhqfhv=## rqh## sureohp#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # deurdg/#uhdfw#wr#hdv|#srolf|1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#sulfhv#ri#frpprglwlhv#vxfk#dv#rlo#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # phwdov#duh#olnho|#wr#ulvh1#Dqg#wkh#sulfhv#ri#dvvhwv/#vxfk#dv#krxvhv#dqg#vwrfnv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # erqgv/#duh#dovr#olnho|#wr#lqiodwh#dv#lqyhvwruv#hvfdsh#orz#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # # # # # # wr#lqyhvw#lq#dq|wklqj#wkdw#riihuv#d#ghfhqw#uhwxuq1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Pruh#sureohpdwlf#vwloo/#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#lv#dovr#surqh#wr#wdnh#juhdwhu#ulvnv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dw#vxfk#wlphv1#Lq#wkh#shulrg#5336ᄆ5339/#orz#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#dgghg#wr#wkh#lqfhqwlyhv# # # e|#jryhuqphqw#vxssruw#iru# # # # # orz0lqfrph## krxvlqj#dqg# # # ixhohg#dq# # douhdg|#surylghg# # # # # # # # # # # # h{wudruglqdu|#krxvlqj#errp#dv#zhoo#dv#lqfuhdvlqj#lqghewhgqhvv1#Lq#dq#dwwhpsw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dgydqfh#frusrudwh#lqyhvwphqw#dqg#klulqj/#wkh#Ihg#dgghg#ixho#wr#wkh#iluh#e|#wu|lqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#uhdvvxuh#wkh#hfrqrp|#wkdw#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#zrxog#vwd|#orz#iru#d#vxvwdlqhg#shulrg1# # # rqo|#sxvkhg# # # dvvhw## sulfhv## hyhq#kljkhu# # # dqg## lqfuhdvhg## ilqdqfldo0 Vxfk#dvvxudqfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru#ulvn#wdnlqj1#Ilqdoo|/#lq#d#uhjxodwru|#frxs#gh#juォfh/#wkh#Ihg#fkdlupdq/#Dodq# # # # # # # # # # # # # Juhhqvsdq/#hiihfwlyho|#wrog#wkh#pdunhwv#lq#5335#wkdw#wkh#Ihg#zrxog#qrw#lqwhuyhqh# wr## exuvw## dvvhw0sulfh## exeeohv## exw## zrxog## lqwhuyhqh## wr## hdvh## wkh## zd|## wr## d## qhz# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{sdqvlrq#li#wkh#pdunhwv#lpsorghg1#Li#hyhu#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#qhhghg#d#olfhqvh#wr# # # # # jr#ryhuerdug/#wklv#zdv#lw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # E|#irfxvlqj#rqo|#rq#mrev#dqg#lqiodwlrqᄇdqg/#lq#hiihfw/#rqo|#rq#wkh#iruphuᄇwkh# Ihg## ehkdyhg## p|rslfdoo|/## lqghhg## srolwlfdoo|1## Lw## lv## lq## gdqjhu## ri## grlqj## vr## djdlq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhq#zkloh#ehlqj#hqwluho|#wuxh#wr#wkh#ohwwhu#ri#lwv#pdqgdwh1#Dowkrxjk#wkh#Ihg#kdv#d# olplwhg## vhw## ri## wrrov## dqg## wkhuhiruh## sohdgv## wkdw## lw## vkrxog## qrw## eh## jlyhq## pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # srwhqwldoo|#frpshwlqj#remhfwlyhv/#lw#fdqqrw#ljqruh#wkh#zlghu#frqvhtxhqfhv#wr#wkh# # # lwv## qduurz## irfxv=## lq#sduwlfxodu/# # # orz## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## dqg## wkh## oltxlglw|# hfrqrp|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # lqixvhg#e|#wkh#Ihg#kdyh#zlghvsuhdg#hiihfwv#rq#ilqdqfldo0vhfwru#ehkdylru1#Dv#zlwk# wkh## sxvk## iru## orz0lqfrph## krxvlqj/## wkh## idxow## olqh## wkdw## hphujhv## zkhq## srolwlfdoo|# prwlydwhg## vwlpxoxv## frphv## lqwr## frqwdfw## zlwk## d## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## orrnlqj## iru## dq|# # # # # # # hgjh#lv#dq#lpphqvh#vrxufh#ri#gdqjhu1#
Wkh#Frqvhtxhqfhv#wr#wkh#X1V1#Ilqdqfldo#Vhfwru # # # # # # # Krz## glg## wuhpruv## rq## doo## wkh## idxow## olqhv## frph## wrjhwkhu## lq## wkh## X1V1## ilqdqfldo# vhfwru#wr#qhduo|#ghvwur|#lwB#L#irfxv#rq#wzr#lpsruwdqw#zd|v#wklv#kdsshqhg1#Iluvw/#dq# # # # # ## # # # # # # # # hqruprxv#txdqwlw|#ri#prqh|#iorzhg#lqwr#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/# # # # # # # # # # # # erwk## iurp## deurdg## dqg## iurp## jryhuqphqw0vsrqvruhg## pruwjdjh## djhqflhv## vxfk## dv# Idqqlh## Pdh## dqg## Iuhgglh## Pdf1## Wklv## ohg## wr## erwk## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## krxvh## sulfh# lqfuhdvhv## dqg## d## vwhdg|## ghwhulrudwlrq## lq## wkh## txdolw|## ri## pruwjdjh## ordqv## pdgh1# Vhfrqg/#erwk#frpphufldo#dqg#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#wrrn#rq#dq#hqruprxv#txdqwlw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn/## lqfoxglqj## ex|lqj## odujh## txdqwlwlhv## ri## wkh## orz0txdolw|## vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## wr# ilqdqfh#vxesulph#krxvlqj#pruwjdjhv/#hyhq#zkloh#eruurzlqj#h{wuhpho|#vkruw#whup# # # # # # # # # # wr#ilqdqfh#wkhvh#sxufkdvhv1# # # # Ohw## ph## eh## pruh## vshflilf1## Lq## wkh## hduo|## 5333v/## wkh## vdylqjv## jhqhudwhg## e|## wkh# h{sruw0ghshqghqw## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## zhuh## gudzq## lqwr## ilqdqflqj## wkh## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv/#zkhuh#ilvfdo#dqg#prqhwdu|#vwlpxoxv#fuhdwhg#hqruprxv#dgglwlrqdo#ghpdqg# # # # # # # # # # iru## jrrgv## dqg## vhuylfhv/## hvshfldoo|## lq## krph## frqvwuxfwlrq1## Iruhljq## lqyhvwruv# orrnhg## iru## vdihw|1## Wkhlu## prqh|## iorzhg## lqwr## vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## e|## jryhuqphqw0 vsrqvruhg#pruwjdjh#djhqflhv#olnh#Idqqlh#Pdh#dqg#Iuhgglh#Pdf/#wkxv#ixuwkhulqj# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## X1V1## jryhuqphqwᄊv## orz0lqfrph## krxvlqj## jrdov1## Wkh## lqyhvwruv/## pdq|## iurp# ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv/# # # lpsolflwo|#dvvxphg# # # wkdw## wkh## X1V1## jryhuqphqw## zrxog## edfn# wkhvh## djhqflhv/## pxfk## dv## lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|## lqyhvwruv## kdg## dvvxphg## wkdw# ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|## jryhuqphqwv## zrxog## edfn## wkhp## ehiruh## wkh## fulvhv## lq## wkrvh# frxqwulhv1## Hyhq## wkrxjk## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh## zhuh## wdnlqj## hqruprxv## ulvnv/## wkh|# zhuh#qr#orqjhu#vxemhfw#wr#wkh#glvflsolqh#ri#wkh#pdunhw1# # # # # # # # # # Rwkhu#ixqgv/#iurp#wkh#iruhljq#sulydwh#vhfwru/#iorzhg#lqwr#kljko|#udwhg#vxesulph# # # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv1## Khuh/## wkh## xqvxvshfwlqj## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## uholhg## d# olwwoh#wrr#qdlyho|#rq#wkh#lqvwlwxwlrqv#ri#wkh#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#v|vwhp1#Wkh|#eholhyhg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## udwlqjv## dqg## wkh## pdunhw#sulfhv# # # surgxfhg## e|#wkh# # # v|vwhp/## qrw#uhdol}lqj#wkdw#wkh# # # # kxjh#txdqwlw|#ri#prqh|#iorzlqj#lqwr#vxesulph#ohqglqj/#erwk#iurp#wkh#djhqflhv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # iurp## rwkhu## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv/## kdg## fruuxswhg## wkh## lqvwlwxwlrqv1## Iru## rqh## ri## wkh# zhdnqhvvhv#ri#wkh#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#v|vwhp/#dv#L#h{sodlq#lq#Fkdswhu#9/#lv#wkdw#lw#uholhv# # # # # # ## # # # # # # # rq## sulfhv## ehlqj## dffxudwh=## exw## zkhq## d## iorrg## ri## prqh|## iurp## xqtxhvwlrqlqj# lqyhvwruv## kdv## wr## eh## devruehg/## sulfhv## fdq#eh# # # vljqlilfdqwo|#glvwruwhg1# # # Khuh## djdlq/# wkh#frqwdfw#ehwzhhq#wkh#wzr#gliihuhqw#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv#fuhdwhg#iudjlolwlhv1# # # # # # # # # # Krzhyhu/## wkh## fhqwudo## fdxvh## iru## wkh## ilqdqfldo## sdqlf## zdv## qrw## vr## pxfk#wkdw# # # wkh# edqnv#sdfndjhg#dqg#glvwulexwhg#orz0txdolw|#vxesulph#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv# # # # # # # # exw## wkdw## wkh|#khog# # # rq#wr# # # vxevwdqwldo## txdqwlwlhv## wkhpvhoyhv/## hlwkhu## rq#ru# # # rii## wkhlu# edodqfh#vkhhwv/#ilqdqflqj#wkhvh#kroglqjv#zlwk#vkruw0whup#ghew1#Wklv#eulqjv#xv#ixoo# # # # # # # # # # # # flufoh#wr#wkh#wkhph#ri#p|#Mdfnvrq#Kroh#vshhfk1#Zkdw#zhqw#zurqjB#Zk|#glg#vr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdq|#edqnv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#krog#rq#wr#vr#pxfk#ri#wkh#ulvnB# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#sureohp/#dv#L#ghvfuleh#lq#Fkdswhu#:/#kdv#wr#gr#zlwk#wkh#vshfldo# # # ## # # # # # # # # # # fkdudfwhu# ri## wkhvh## ulvnv1## Wkh## vxevwdqwldo## dprxqw## ri## prqh|#srxulqj#lq#iurp#xqtxhvwlrqlqj# # # # # lqyhvwruv## wr## ilqdqfh## vxesulph## ohqglqj/## dv## zhoo## dv## wkh## vljqlilfdqw## jryhuqphqw# lqyroyhphqw#lq#krxvlqj/#vxjjhvwhg#wkdw#pdwwhuv#frxog#jr#rq#iru#vrph#wlph#zlwkrxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # krphrzqhuv## ghidxowlqj1## Vlploduo|/## wkh## Ihgᄊv## zloolqjqhvv## wr## pdlqwdlq## hdv|#
frqglwlrqv## iru## d## vxvwdlqhg## shulrg/## jlyhq## wkh## shuvlvwhqw## kljk## ohyho## ri# xqhpsor|phqw/## pdgh## wkh## ulvn## ri## d## ixqglqj## vtxhh}h## vhhp## uhprwh1## Xqghu## vxfk# flufxpvwdqfhv/#wkh#prghuq#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#whqgv#wr#ryhugrvh#rq#wkhvh#ulvnv1# # # # # # # # # # # D#edqn# # # wkdw## h{srvhv## lwvhoi## wr## vxfk## ulvnv## whqgv## wr## surgxfh## deryh0sdu## surilwv# prvw## ri## wkh## wlph1## Wkhuh## lv## vrph## suredelolw|#wkdw# # # lw## zloo## surgxfh## wuxo|#kruuleoh# # orvvhv1#Iurp#vrflhw|ᄊv#shuvshfwlyh/#wkhvh#ulvnv#vkrxog#qrw#eh#wdnhq#ehfdxvh#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # hqruprxv#frvwv#li#wkh#orvvhv#pdwhuldol}h1#Xqiruwxqdwho|/#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#wkh#uhzdug# # # # # # # # # # # # vwuxfwxuh#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # v|vwhp/#zkhwkhu# # # lpsolflw#ru# # # h{solflw/#hpskdvl}hv#vkruw0 # # whup#dgydqwdjhv#dqg#pd|#suhglvsrvh#edqnhuv#wr#wdnh#wkhvh#ulvnv1# # # # # # # # # # Sduwlfxoduo|## ghwulphqwdo/## wkh## dfwxdo## ru## survshfwlyh## lqwhuyhqwlrq## ri## wkh# jryhuqphqw#ru#wkh#fhqwudo#edqn#lq#fhuwdlq#pdunhwv#wr#ixuwkhu#srolwlfdo#remhfwlyhv/# # # # # # # # # # # # ru#wr#dyrlg#srolwlfdo#sdlq/#fuhdwhv#dq#hqruprxv#irufh#frruglqdwlqj#wkh#qxphurxv# # # # # # # # # # # # hqwlwlhv#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#lqwr#wdnlqj#wkh#vdph#ulvnv1#Dv#wkh|#gr#vr/#wkh|#pdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## uhdol}dwlrq## ri## orvvhv## pxfk## pruh## olnho|1## Wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## lv## fohduo|# fhqwudoo|#uhvsrqvleoh#iru#wkh#ulvnv#lw#wdnhv1#Dprqj#lwv#idlolqjv#lq#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfoxgh#glvwruwhg#lqfhqwlyhv/#kxeulv/#hqy|/#plvsodfhg#idlwk/#dqg#khug#ehkdylru1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## jryhuqphqw## khoshg## pdnh## wkrvh## ulvnv## orrn## pruh## dwwudfwlyh## wkdq## wkh|## vkrxog# kdyh#ehhq#dqg#nhsw#wkh#pdunhw#iurp#h{huflvlqj#glvflsolqh/#shukdsv#hyhq#pdnlqj#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # dssodxg## vxfk#ehkdylru1# # # Jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrqv## lq#wkh# # # diwhupdwk#ri# # # wkh## fulvlv# kdyh/## xqiruwxqdwho|/## ixoiloohg## wkh## eholhiv## ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru1## Srolwlfdo## prudo# kd}dug## fdph## wrjhwkhu## zlwk## ilqdqfldo0vhfwru## prudo## kd}dug## lq## wklv## fulvlv1## Wkh# zruulvrph#uhdolw|#lv#wkdw#lw#frxog#doo#kdsshq#djdlq1# # # # # # # # # Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/# # # wkh## fhqwudo## sureohp#ri#iuhh0hqwhusulvh# # # # fdslwdolvp#lq#d# # # # prghuq# ghprfudf|#kdv#dozd|v#ehhq#krz#wr#edodqfh#wkh#uroh#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dqg#wkdw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## pdunhw1## Zkloh## pxfk## lqwhoohfwxdo## hqhuj|## kdv## ehhq## irfxvhg## rq## ghilqlqj## wkh# dssursuldwh## dfwlylwlhv## ri## hdfk/## lw## lv## wkh## lqwhudfwlrq## ehwzhhq## wkh## wzr## wkdw## lv## d# fhqwudo## vrxufh## ri## iudjlolw|1## Lq## d## ghprfudf|/## wkh## jryhuqphqw## +ru## fhqwudo## edqn,# vlpso|## fdqqrw## doorz## ruglqdu|## shrsoh## wr## vxiihu## froodwhudo## gdpdjh## dv## wkh## kduvk# orjlf## ri## wkh## pdunhw## lv## doorzhg## wr## sod|## rxw1## D## prghuq/## vrsklvwlfdwhg## ilqdqfldo# vhfwru#xqghuvwdqgv#wklv#dqg#wkhuhiruh#vhhnv#zd|v#wr#h{sorlw#jryhuqphqw#ghfhqf|/# # # # # # # # # # # zkhwkhu## lw## lv## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## frqfhuq## derxw## lqhtxdolw|/## xqhpsor|phqw/## ru## wkh# vwdelolw|## ri## wkh## frxqwu|ᄊv## edqnv1## Wkh## sureohp## vwhpv## iurp## wkh## ixqgdphqwdo# lqfrpsdwlelolw|#ehwzhhq#wkh#jrdov#ri#fdslwdolvp#dqg#wkrvh#ri#ghprfudf|1#Dqg#|hw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#wzr#jr#wrjhwkhu/#ehfdxvh#hdfk#ri#wkhvh#v|vwhpv#vriwhqv#wkh#ghilflhqflhv#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rwkhu1# L#gr#qrw#vhhn#wr#eh#dq#dsrorjlvw#iru# # # # # # # # # # edqnhuv/#zkrvh#kdqnhulqj#iru# # # # # erqxvhv## lq# wkh#diwhupdwk#ri#d#sxeolf#uhvfxh#lv#qrw#mxvw#prudoo|#rxwudjhrxv#exw#dovr#srolwlfdoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # p|rslf1#Exw#rxwudjh#grhv#qrw#gulyh#jrrg#srolf|1#Wkrxjk#lw#zdv#e|#qr#phdqv#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqqrfhqw#ylfwlp/#wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # vhfwru#zdv#dw#wkh#fhqwhu#ri#d#qxpehu#ri#idxow#olqhv# # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## diihfwhg## lwv## ehkdylru1## Hdfk## ri## wkh## dfwruvᄇedqnhuv/## srolwlfldqv/## wkh## srru/# iruhljq#lqyhvwruv/# # # hfrqrplvwv/## dqg## fhqwudo## edqnhuvᄇglg## zkdw## wkh|#wkrxjkw# # # zdv# uljkw1#Lqghhg/#d#yhu|#uhdo#srvvlelolw|#lv#wkdw#nh|#dfwruv#olnh#srolwlfldqv#dqg#edqnhuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh#jxlghg#xqlqwhqwlrqdoo|/#e|#yrwlqj#sdwwhuqv#dqg#pdunhw#dssurydo#uhvshfwlyho|/# # # # # # # # # # lqwr## ehkdylru## wkdw#ohg# # # lqh{rudeo|#wrzdug# # # wkh## fulvlv1## \hw#wkh# # # devhqfh## ri#yloodlqv/# # dqg#wkh#idfw#wkdw#hdfk#ri#wkhvh#dfwruv#idlohg#wr#eulgjh#wkh#idxow#olqhv#pdnhv#ilqglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vroxwlrqv#pruh/#udwkhu#wkdq#ohvv/#gliilfxow1#Uhjxodwlqj#edqnhuvᄊ#erqxv#sd|#lv#rqo|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # yhu|## sduwldo## vroxwlrq/## hvshfldoo|## li## pdq|## edqnhuv## glg## qrw## uhdol}h## wkh## ulvnv## wkh|#
zhuh#wdnlqj1 #
Wkh#Fkdoohqjhv#Wkdw#Idfh#Xv # # # # # Li## vxfk## d## ghydvwdwlqj## fulvlv## uhvxowv## iurp## dfwruvᄊ## xqghuwdnlqj## uhdvrqdeoh# dfwlrqv/#dw#ohdvw#iurp#wkhlu# # # # # # rzq#shuvshfwlyh/#zh# # # # kdyh## frqvlghudeoh## zrun#wr#gr1# # # Pxfk#ri#wkh# # # # zrun#olhv# # # rxwvlgh## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru>#krz# # # gr## zh## jlyh## wkh## shrsoh# idoolqj#ehklqg#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#d#uhdo#fkdqfh#wr#vxffhhgB#Vkrxog#zh#fuhdwh#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwurqjhu#vdihw|#qhw#wr#surwhfw#krxvhkrogv#gxulqj#uhfhvvlrqv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdq#zh#ilqg#rwkhu#zd|v#wr#pdnh#zrunhuv#pruh#uhvlolhqwB#Krz#fdq#odujh#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # durxqg## wkh## zruog## zhdq#wkhpvhoyhv# # # rii## wkhlu## ghshqghqfh## rq#h{sruwvB# # # Krz## fdq# wkh|#ghyhors#wkhlu#ilqdqfldo#vhfwruv#vr#wkdw#wkh|#fdq#doorfdwh#uhvrxufhv#dqg#ulvnv# # # # # # # # # # # # # hiilflhqwo|B#Dqg/#ri#frxuvh/#krz#fdq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#uhirup#lwv#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # vr#wkdw#lw#grhv#qrw#ghydvwdwh#wkh#zruog#hfrqrp|#rqfh#djdlqB# # # # # # # # # # # Lq#vwuxfwxulqj#uhirupv/# # # # zh## kdyh## wr## uhfrjql}h## wkdw#wkh# # # rqo|#wuxo|#vdih# # # # ilqdqfldo# v|vwhp#lv# # # d## v|vwhp#wkdw#grhv# # # # qrw#wdnh# # # ulvnv/## wkdw#grhv# # # qrw#ilqdqfh# # # lqqrydwlrq#ru# # jurzwk/#wkdw#grhv#qrw#khos#gudz#shrsoh#rxw#ri#sryhuw|/#dqg#wkdw#jlyhv#frqvxphuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # olwwoh#fkrlfh1#Lw#lv#d#v|vwhp#wkdw#uhlqirufhv#wkh#lqfuhphqwdo#dqg#wkxv#wkh#vwdwxv#txr1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lq#wkh#orqj#uxq/#wkrxjk/#hvshfldoo|#jlyhq#wkh#hqruprxv#fkdoohqjhv#wkh#zruog#idfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇfolpdwh#fkdqjh/#dq#djlqj#srsxodwlrq/#dqg#sryhuw|/#wr#qdph#mxvw#d#ihzᄇvhwwolqj# # # # # # # # # # # # iru## wkh## vwdwxv## txr## pd|#eh# # # wkh## juhdwhvw#ulvn#ri#doo/# # # # # iru## lw#zloo# # # pdnh## xv## xqdeoh## wr# dgdsw#wr#phhw#wkh#frplqj#fkdoohqjhv1#Zh#gr#qrw#zdqw#wr#uhwxuq#wr#wkh#edg#rog#gd|v# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## mxvw## pdnh## edqnlqj## erulqj## djdlq=## lw## lv## hdv|## wr## irujhw## wkdw## xqghu## d## uljlgo|# uhjxodwhg## v|vwhp/## frqvxphuv## dqg## ilupv## kdg## olwwoh## fkrlfh1## Zh## zdqw## lqqrydwlyh/# g|qdplf## ilqdqfh/## exw#zlwkrxw#wkh# # # # h{fhvv## ulvn#dqg# # # wkh## rxwudjhrxv## ehkdylru1## Wkdw# zloo#eh#kdug#wr#dfklhyh/#exw#lw#zloo#eh#uhdoo|#zruwkzkloh1# # # # # # # # # # # Zh#dovr#kdyh#wr#uhfrjql}h#wkdw#jrrg#hfrqrplfv#fdqqrw#eh#glyrufhg#iurp#jrrg# # # # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfv=## wklv## lv## shukdsv## d## uhdvrq## zk|## wkh## ilhog## ri## hfrqrplfv## zdv## nqrzq## dv# srolwlfdo## hfrqrp|1## Wkh## plvwdnh## hfrqrplvwv## pdgh## zdv## wr## eholhyh## wkdw## rqfh# frxqwulhv#kdg#ghyhorshg#d#vwhho#iudph#ri#lqvwlwxwlrqv/#srolwlfdo#lqioxhqfhv#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # eh## whpshuhg=## frxqwulhv## zrxog## judgxdwh## shupdqhqwo|## iurp## ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|# vwdwxv1## Zh## vkrxog## qrz## uhfrjql}h## wkdw## lqvwlwxwlrqv## vxfk## dv## uhjxodwruv## kdyh# lqioxhqfh#rqo|#vr#orqj#dv#srolwlfv#lv#uhdvrqdeo|#zhoo#edodqfhg1#Ghhs#lpedodqfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # vxfk## dv## lqhtxdolw|## fdq## fuhdwh## wkh## srolwlfdo## jurxqgvzhoo## wkdw## fdq## ryhufrph## dq|# frqvwudlqlqj#lqvwlwxwlrqv1#Frxqwulhv#fdq#uhwxuq#wr#ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|#vwdwxv#li#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # srolwlfv#ehfrph#lpedodqfhg/#qr#pdwwhu#krz#zhoo#ghyhorshg#wkhlu#lqvwlwxwlrqv1# # # # # # # # # # Wkhuh## duh## qr## vloyhu## exoohwv1## Uhirupv## zloo## uhtxluh## fduhixo## dqdo|vlv## dqg# vrphwlphv#whglrxv#dwwhqwlrq#wr#ghwdlo1#L#glvfxvv#srvvleoh#uhirupv#lq#Fkdswhuv#;#wr# # # # # ## # # # # # # 43/## irfxvlqj#rq#eurdg# # # # dssurdfkhv1## L#krsh# # # p|#sursrvdov# # # duh## ohvv## vlpsolvwlf## dqg# pruh#frqvwuxfwlyh#wkdq#wkh#fdoov#wr#wdu#dqg#ihdwkhu#edqnhuv#ru#wkhlu#uhjxodwruv1#Li# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsohphqwhg/## wkh|#zloo# # # wudqvirup#wkh# # # zruog## zh## olyh## lq#txlwh# # # ixqgdphqwdoo|#dqg# # pryh#lw#dzd|#iurp#wkh#sdwk#ri#ghhshqlqj#fulvhv#wr#rqh#ri#juhdwhu#hfrqrplf#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfdo## vwdelolw|## dv## zhoo## dv## frrshudwlrq1## Zh## zloo## eh## deoh## wr## pdnh## surjuhvv# wrzdug#ryhufrplqj#wkh#lpsruwdqw#fkdoohqjhv#wkh#zruog#idfhv1#Vxfk#uhirupv#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # uhtxluh## vrflhwlhv## wr## fkdqjh## wkh## zd|#wkh|#olyh/# # # # wkh## zd|#wkh|#jurz/# # # # dqg## wkh## zd|# wkh|## pdnh## fkrlfhv1## Wkh|## zloo## lqyroyh## vljqlilfdqw## vkruw0whup#sdlq# # # lq## uhwxuq## iru# pruh## gliixvh## exw#hqruprxv# # # orqj0whup#jdlq1# # # Vxfk#uhirupv# # # duh## dozd|v## gliilfxow#wr# # vhoo#wr#wkh#sxeolf#dqg#khqfh#kdyh#olwwoh#dsshdo#wr#srolwlfldqv1#Exw#wkh#frvw#ri#grlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
qrwklqj#lv# # # shukdsv## zruvh## wxuprlo## wkdq#zkdw#zh# # # # kdyh## h{shulhqfhg## uhfhqwo|/## iru/# xqfkhfnhg/#wkh#idxow#olqhv#zloo#rqo|#ghhshq1# # # # # # # Wkh#slfwxuh#lv#qrw#doo#jorrp1#Wkhuh#duh#wzr#srzhuixo#uhdvrqv#iru#krsh#wrgd|=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # whfkqrorjlfdo## surjuhvv## lv## vroylqj## sureohpv## wkdw## kdyh## hoxghg## uhvroxwlrq## iru# fhqwxulhv/## dqg## hfrqrplf## uhirupv## duh## eulqjlqj## hqruprxv## qxpehuv## ri## wkh## srru# gluhfwo|#iurp#phglhydo#olylqj#frqglwlrqv#lqwr#wkh#prghuq#hfrqrp|1#Pxfk#fdq#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # jdlqhg#li#zh#fdq#gudz# # # # # # wkh#uljkw#ohvvrqv# # # # iurp#wklv# # # fulvlv#dqg#vwdelol}h#wkh#zruog# # # # # hfrqrp|1#Htxdoo|/#pxfk#frxog#eh#orvw#li#zh#gudz#wkh#zurqj#ohvvrqv1#Ohw#ph#qrz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # od|#rxw#erwk#wkh#idxow#olqhv#dqg#wkh#kdug#fkrlfhv#wkdw#frqiurqw#xv/#zlwk#wkh#krsh#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # froohfwlyho|#zh#zloo#pdnh#wkh#uljkw#gliihuhqfh1#Iru#rxu#rzq#vdnhv/#zh#pxvw1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
FKDSWHU#RQH #
Ohw#Wkhp#Hdw#Fuhglw # # # #
MDQH## LV## DQ## DVVLVWDQW## lq#d# # # odujh## qrqsurilw#uhvhdufk#rujdql}dwlrq/# # # # zkhuh## vkh#
kdv## zrunhg## iru## wkh## sdvw#wkluw|0wzr# # # |hduv1## Vkh## zdv## dq#h{fhoohqw#w|slvw#lq#vfkrro# # # # # dqg## wrrn## d## ihz## frxuvhv## lq## exvlqhvv## sudfwlfh1## Diwhu## vshqglqj## d## vhphvwhu## lq# froohjh/## vkh## ghflghg## wkdw#wkh# # # frvw#ri#dq#xqghujudgxdwh# # # # # hgxfdwlrq#zdv# # # qrw#zruwk# # wkh#ehqhilwv>#mrev#iru#w|slvwv#zhuh#sohqwlixo/#dqg#wkh#prqh|#vhhphg#dwwudfwlyh1#Khu# # # # # # # # # # # # # iluvw#mre#zdv#zlwk#wkh#qrqsurilw/#zkhuh#vkh#lqlwldoo|#zrunhg#iru#wzr#ervvhv1#Khu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sulpdu|## wdvnv## zhuh## wr## w|sh## xs## uhsruwv## dqg## uhvhdufk## sdshuv/## iloh## wkh## hqruprxv# dprxqw#ri#sdshuzrun#wkdw#nhsw#dffxpxodwlqj/#dqg#dqvzhu#wkh#skrqhv1# # # # # # # # # # Ryhu#wkh#|hduv/#pdq|#ri#wkrvh#zkr#vwduwhg#lq#srvlwlrqv#vlplodu#wr#Mdqhᄊv#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # orvw## wkhlu## mrev1## Wkh## dgyhqw## ri## wkh## frpsxwhuᄇiluvw## wkh## pdlqiudph/## wkhq## wkh# shuvrqdo#frpsxwhuᄇholplqdwhg#pxfk#ri#wkh#urxwlqh#zrun#ri#dvvlvwdqwv1#Plgohyho# # # # # # # # # # vxshuylvruv#dqg#pdqdjhuv#ohduqhg#wr#w|sh#wkhlu#rzq#grfxphqwv1#Suhvhqwdwlrqv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # edvlf## dqdo|vlv## zhuh## rxwvrxufhg/## vrphwlphv## wr## idu0rii#frxqwulhv/# # # zkhuh## zrunhuv# glg#zkdw#zdv#qhfhvvdu|#ryhuqljkw1#Prvw#ilohv#ehfdph#hohfwurqlf/#vwruhg#rq#glvnv# # # # # # # # # # # # udwkhu#wkdq#lq#sk|vlfdo#fdelqhwv1#Dqg#dv#Mdqhᄊv#ervvhv#wxuqhg#wr#frppxqlfdwlqj#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # h0pdlo/## skrqh## fdoov## ehfdph## uduhu## dqg## uduhu=## wkh|## zhuh## qrw## lq## d## idvw0prylqj# exvlqhvv## uhtxlulqj#frqvwdqw#yhuedo# # # # frqwdfw#zlwk#wkhlu# # # # folhqwv1#Dv# # # d## uhvxow/#Mdqhᄊv# # vhfuhwduldo#mre#wrr#ehfdph#hqgdqjhuhg/#dqg#hyhqwxdoo|#vkh#zdv#odlg#rii1# # # # # # # # # # # Mdqh/#krzhyhu/#vxuylyhg#wkh#rqvodxjkw#ri#wkh#pdfklqhv/#odujho|#e|#uhlqyhqwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # khuvhoi1#Vkh#txlfno|#irxqg#dqrwkhu#mre#zlwklq#wkh#rujdql}dwlrq1#Vkh#kdv#ehfrph#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # vruw#ri#ᄈil{huᄡ# # # # iru## khu## qhz## ervvhv/## wdnlqj#rq#wdvnv# # # # wkdw#wkh|#kdyh# # # # olwwoh## wlph## ru# fdsdflw|#wr#kdqgohᄇvxfk#dv#slfnlqj#wkh#uhvwdxudqw#dqg#rughulqj#wkh#phqx#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # dq# riilfh#glqqhu/#lqylwlqj#vshdnhuv#wr#wkh#rujdql}dwlrq#dqg#pdqdjlqj#wkhlu#vfkhgxohv/# # # # # # # # # # # khdglqj#rii#ludwh#folhqwv#dqg#hqvxulqj#wkhlu#sureohpv#duh#ghdow#zlwk/#ru#iroorzlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # xs#zlwk#dq#regxudwh#riilfh#dffrxqwdqw#txhvwlrqlqj#d#eloo#vxeplwwhg#e|#rqh#ri#khu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ervvhv1## Ehfdxvh## Mdqh## kdv## wudqviruphg## khuvhoi## lqwr## rqh## zkr## wdnhv## fduh## ri## wkh# xqxvxdo#wdvnv/#rqhv#wkdw#pdfklqhv#fdqqrw#kdqgoh/#vkh#kdv#wr#uhsruw#wr#pruh#ervvhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇqlqh#dw#odvw#frxqw1#Zrun#lv#h{kdxvwlqj/#ehfdxvh#ghpdqgv#frph#iurp#doo# # # # # # # # # # # # # vlghv/# exw#Mdqh#lv#wkdqnixo#vkh#vwloo#kdv#d#mre1#Dqg#lw#lv#pruh#lqwhuhvwlqj#qrz1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Mdqhᄊv## ervvhv## kdyh## ehqhilwhg## kxjho|## iurp## wkh## uhyroxwlrq## lq## frpsxwhuv## dqg# frppxqlfdwlrqv1#Wkh#uhvhdufk#sdshuv#dqg#duwlfohv#wkh|#zulwh#uhfhlyh#pxfk#zlghu# # # # # # # # # # # flufxodwlrq1#Lq#wkh#sdvw#wkh|#kdg#wr#eh#skrwrfrslhg#dqg#vhqw#e|#pdlo#wr#d#vpdoo#olvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#wuxo|#lqwhuhvwhg/#exw#wrgd|#wkh|#duh#xsordghg#wr#d#zhevlwh#dqg#txlfno|#vhhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|## pdq|1## Wkhlu## suhvhqwdwlrqv## duh## pruh## froruixo## dqg## wkhlu## vhplqduv## pruh# lqwhuhvwlqj/## zklfk## phdqv## wkdw## wkhlu## dxglhqfhv## sd|## forvhu## dwwhqwlrq## zkhq## wkh|# vshdn1#Wkh|#urxwlqho|#ilhog#uhtxhvwv#iurp#vwudqjhuv#zkr#kdyh#frph#dfurvv#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # zrun#vrphzkhuh#rq#wkh#Zhe/#wr#vshdn/#frqvxow/#ru#jlyh#h{shuw#whvwlprq|1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkxv#dgydqfhv#lq#whfkqrorj|#kdyh#zlgh0udqjlqj#hiihfwv#dfurvv#wkh#srsxodwlrq1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## urxwlqh## wdvnv## grqh## e|#vhfuhwduldo# # # dqg## fohulfdo## zrunhuv## olnh## Mdqh/## w|slfdoo|#
wkrvh## zlwk## d## kljk## vfkrro## hgxfdwlrq## dqg## shukdsv## hyhq## zlwk## vrph## froohjh# h{shulhqfh/## kdyh## ehhq## dxwrpdwhg1## Exw## wkh## qrqurxwlqh/## fuhdwlyh## wdvnv## w|slfdoo|# xqghuwdnhq#e|#wkrvh#zlwk#dgydqfhg#ghjuhhv#kdyh#ehhq#dlghg#e|#whfkqrorj|1#Iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # FHRv/## zkr## fdq## vhh## wkhlu## ilupᄊv## odwhvw## lqyhqwru|## srvlwlrq## e|## wdsslqj## rq## d## ihz# nh|v/## wr## dqdo|vwv## dqg## frqvxowdqwv/## zkrvh## uhsruwv## fdq## eh## dffhvvhg## durxqg## wkh# zruog/## wkh## lqioxhqfh## dqg## uhdfk## ri## wkh## vnloohg## dqg## wkh## fuhdwlyh## kdv## lqfuhdvhg14# Whfkqrorj|## kdv## lqfuhdvhg## wkhlu## surgxfwlylw|## hyhq## zkloh## uhqghulqj## rwkhuv# uhgxqgdqw1# W|slfdoo|/#krzhyhu/#whfkqrorjlfdo#dgydqfh#lv#d#jrrg#wklqj#iru#hyhu|rqh#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # orqj#uxq1#Lw#holplqdwhv#guxgjhu|#zkloh#jlylqj#wkh#zrunhu#wkh#wlph#dqg#fdsdflw|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdnh#xvh#ri#khu#ilqhu#wdohqwv1#Zh#duh#vxuho|#ehwwhu#rii#srvwlqj#d#grfxphqw#rq#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dffhvvleoh#zhevlwh#wkdq#dvnlqj#d#fohulfdo#zrunhu#wr#diil{#wkrxvdqgv#ri#vwdpsv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghvwur|#vr#pdq|#wuhhv#wr#vhqg#sk|vlfdo#pdlo#wkdw#zloo#xowlpdwho|#eh#wkurzq#dzd|1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Exw#lq#wkh#vkruw#uxq/#whfkqrorjlfdo#dgydqfhv#fdq#eh#h{wuhpho|#glvuxswlyh/#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # glvuxswlrq#fdq#shuvlvw#lqwr#wkh#orqj#uxq#li#shrsoh#gr#qrw#kdyh#wkh#phdqv#wr#dgdsw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Dphulfd#kdv#dgdswhg#wr#whfkqrorjlfdo#fkdqjh#ehiruh1#Dv#djulfxowxuh#jdyh#zd|# # # # # # # # # # # wr#pdqxidfwxulqj#lq#wkh#plg04;33v/#wkh#hohphqwdu|#vfkrro#pryhphqw#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv#fuhdwhg#wkh#prvw#kljko|#hgxfdwhg#srsxodwlrq#lq#wkh#zruog1#Dv#idfwru|#zrun# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdph## pruh## vrsklvwlfdwhg/## dqg## dv## ghpdqg## juhz## iru## riilfh## zrunhuv## wr## kdqgoh# p|uldg## dfwlylwlhv## lq## wkh## hphujlqj## odujh/## pxowlglylvlrq## ilupv/## wkh## ghpdqg## iru# zrunhuv#zlwk#kljk#vfkrro#wudlqlqj#lqfuhdvhg1#Wkh#kljk#vfkrro#pryhphqw#wrrn#rii# # # # # # # # # # # # lq## wkh## hduo|## sduw## ri## wkh## wzhqwlhwk## fhqwxu|## dqg## surylghg## wkh## ioh{leoh/## wudlqhg# zrunhuv## zkr## zrxog## vwdii#Dphulfdᄊv# # # idfwrulhv## dqg## riilfhv1## Lq#4<43/# # # ihzhu## wkdq# rqh0whqwk#ri#X1V1# # # # zrunhuv## kdg## d## kljk#vfkrro# # # glsorpd>#lq#wkh# # # # 4<:3v/## zkhq#Mdqh# # 5# vwduwhg#khu#fduhhu/#pruh#wkdq#wkuhh0txduwhuv#glg1 # # # # # # Dowkrxjk#hduolhu# # # hslvrghv## ri#dgdswdwlrq#zhuh# # # # yhu|#vxffhvvixo/# # # wkh## qh{w#skdvh# # ri## wkh## udfh## ehwzhhq## whfkqrorj|## dqg## hgxfdwlrq/## dv## wkh## Kduydug## hfrqrplvwv# Fodxgld#Jroglq#dqg#Odzuhqfh#Ndw}#kdyh#sxw#lw/#kdv#ehhq#idu#ohvv#vdwlvidfwru|#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Uhfhqw#whfkqrorjlfdo# # # dgydqfhv## qrz## uhtxluh## pdq|#zrunhuv# # # wr# kdyh#d#froohjh#ghjuhh#wr#fduu|#rxw#wkhlu#wdvnv1#Exw#wkh#vxsso|#ri#froohjh0hgxfdwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrunhuv## kdv## qrw## nhsw## sdfh## zlwk## ghpdqgᄇlqghhg/## wkh## iudfwlrq## ri## kljk## vfkrro# judgxdwhv#lq#hyhu|#djh#frkruw#kdv#vwrsshg#ulvlqj/#kdylqj#idoohq#voljkwo|#vlqfh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # 6# 4<:3v1 # Wkrvh## zkr## duh## iruwxqdwh## hqrxjk## wr## kdyh## edfkhoru#ᄊv## dqg## dgydqfhg# ghjuhhv## kdyh## vhhq## wkhlu## lqfrphv## jurz## udslgo|## dv## wkh## ghpdqg## iru## judgxdwhv# h{fhhgv#vxsso|1#Exw#wkrvh#zkr#grqᄊwᄇvhyhq#rxw#ri#whq#Dphulfdqv/#dffruglqj#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # 7# wkh#533;#fhqvxvᄇkdyh#vhhq#uhodwlyho|#vwdjqdqw#ru#hyhq#idoolqj#lqfrphv1 # # # # # # # # # Idfhg#zlwk#d#zhdn#vdihw|#qhw#dqg#frqwlqxlqj#xqfhuwdlqw|#derxw#mrev#wkdw#frxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # hdvlo|#eh# # # holplqdwhg## e|#wkh# # # qh{w#whfkqrorjlfdo# # # dgydqfh## ru## zdyh## ri#rxwvrxuflqj/# # pdq|## Dphulfdqv## ilqg## lw## kdug## wr## ihho## rswlplvwlf## derxw## wkh## ixwxuh1## Dowkrxjk# Dphulfdqv## kdyh/## e|## dqg## odujh/## ehhq## ioh{leoh## lq## wkhlu## vhdufk## iru## rssruwxqlw|ᄇ# zloolqj#wr#xsurrw#wkhpvhoyhv#dqg#wudyho#dfurvv#wkh#frqwlqhqw#wr#wdnh#d#qhz#mreᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ghpdqgv## rq## wkhp#duh# # # idu## juhdwhu## qrz1## Pdq|## kdyh## wr## jr## edfn## wr## vfkrro## wr# uhphg|#d#ghilflhqw#kljk#vfkrro#hgxfdwlrq#ehiruh#wkh|#fdq#ghulyh#wkh#ixoo#ehqhilw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ixuwkhu## hgxfdwlrq/## doo## iru## glvwdqw## dqg## xqfhuwdlq## mre## survshfwv1## Vrph## odfn## wkh# iruwlwxgh## dqg## vwuhqjwk## ri## sxusrvh## wr## gr## vr>## rwkhuv## vlpso|## gr## qrw## kdyh## wkh# uhvrxufhv1#Iru# # # d#vlqjoh#prwkhu# # # # ri#wzr/#iru# # # # h{dpsoh/#zkr#lv# # # # eduho|#pdnlqj#hqgv# # #
phhw#zlwk#wzr#orz0sd|lqj#mrev/#ixuwkhu#hgxfdwlrq#lv#vlpso|#qrw#d#ihdvleoh#rswlrq1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## jds## ehwzhhq#wkh# # # jurzlqj#whfkqrorjlfdo# # # ghpdqg## iru## vnloohg## zrunhuv## dqg# wkh#odjjlqj#vxsso|#ehfdxvh#ri#ghilflhqflhv#lq#wkh#txdqwlw|#dqg#txdolw|#ri#hgxfdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#mxvw#rqh/#doehlw#shukdsv#wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw/#uhdvrq#iru#jurzlqj#lqhtxdolw|1#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhdvrqv#iru#ulvlqj#lqhtxdolw|#duh/#ri#frxuvh/#d#pdwwhu#ri#pxfk#ghedwh/#zlwk#erwk#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Ohiw#dqg#wkh#Uljkw#dgkhulqj#wr#wkhlu#rzq#idyruhg#h{sodqdwlrqv1#Rwkhu#idfwruv/#vxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv## wkh## zlghvsuhdg## ghuhjxodwlrq#lq#uhfhqw#ghfdghv# # # # # dqg## wkh## uhvxowlqj#lqfuhdvhv# # # lq# frpshwlwlrq#lqfoxglqj#iru#uhvrxufhv#+vxfk#dv#wdohqw,/#wkh#fkdqjhv#lq#wd{#udwhv/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghfuhdvh#lq#xqlrql}dwlrq/#dqg#wkh#lqfuhdvh#lq#erwk#ohjdo# # # # # # # # # # dqg#loohjdo# # # lppljudwlrq/# 8# kdyh#qr#grxew#doo#sod|hg#d#sduw1 # # # # # # # Uhjdugohvv#ri#krz#wkh#lqhtxdolw|#kdv#dulvhq/#lw# # # # # # # # kdv#ohg#wr#zlghvsuhdg#dq{lhw|1# # # # # Pdq|## kdyh## orvw## idlwk## lq## wkh## qduudwlyh## ri## Dphulfd## dv## wkh## odqg## ri## xqerxqghg# rssruwxqlw|/## zklfk## lq## wkh## sdvw## fuhdwhg## wkh## sxeolf## vxssruw## wkdw## pdgh## wkh## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv## d## edvwlrq## ri## hfrqrplf## iuhhgrp1## Srolwlfldqv/## dozd|v## vhqvlwlyh## wr## wkhlu# frqvwlwxhqwv/#kdyh#uhvsrqghg#wr#wkhvh#zruulvrph#ghyhorsphqwv#zlwk#dq#dwwhpsw#dw# # # # # # # # # # # d#sdqdfhd=#idflolwdwlqj#wkh#iorz#ri#hdv|#fuhglw#wr#wkrvh#ohiw#ehklqg#e|#jurzwk#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # whfkqrorjlfdo## surjuhvv1## Dqg## vr## Dphulfdᄊv## idlolqjv## lq## hgxfdwlrq## dqg/## pruh# jhqhudoo|/## wkh## jurzlqj#dq{lhw|#ri#lwv# # # # # flwl}hqu|#derxw#dffhvv# # # # wr## rssruwxqlw|#kdyh# # ohg#lq#lqgluhfw#zd|v#wr#xqvxvwdlqdeoh#krxvhkrog#ghew/#zklfk#lv#dw#wkh#fhqwhu#ri#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fulvlv1#Wkdw#prvw#revhuyhuv# # # # # kdyh## qrw#qrwhg#wkhvh# # # # olqnv## vxjjhvwv## wklv## idxow#olqh# # # lv# zhoo#klgghq#dqg#wkhuhiruh#sduwlfxoduo|#gdqjhurxv1# # # # # #
Wkh#Jurzlqj#Lqhtxdolw|#ri#Lqfrphv # # # # # Lqfrphv## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## ri#zklfk#zdjhv# # # # frqvwlwxwh## wkh## prvw#lpsruwdqw# # frpsrqhqw/## kdyh## ehhq## jurzlqj## pruh## xqhtxdo1## Wkh## zdjhv## ri## d## <3wk0shufhqwloh# hduqhuᄇwkdw#lv/#d#shuvrq#hduqlqj#pruh#wkdq#<3#shufhqw#ri#wkh#jhqhudo#srsxodwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇlqfuhdvhg#e|#derxw#98#shufhqw#pruh#ryhu#wkh#shulrg#4<:8ᄆ5338#wkdq#wkh#zdjhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#d#43wk0shufhqwloh#hduqhu1#+Wklv#gliihuhqfh#lv#nqrzq#dv#wkh#<3243#gliihuhqwldo1,# # # # # # # # # # # # Lq#4<:8/#wkh#<3wk#shufhqwloh#hduqhg/#rq#dyhudjh/#derxw#wkuhh#wlphv#pruh#wkdq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 43wk#shufhqwloh>#e|#5338# # # # # wkh|#hduqhg# # # ilyh## wlphv## pruh19## Doo## ri## wklv## jurzwk#zdv# # frqfhqwudwhg#dw#wkh#wrs=#wkh#zdjhv#ri#wkrvh#lq#wkh#plggoh#uhodwlyh#wr#wkrvh#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 43wk#shufhqwloh#kdyh#qrw#jrqh#xs#dq|zkhuh#qhdu#dv#pxfk#dv#wkh#zdjhv#ri#wkh#<3wk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # shufhqwloh#kdyh#jurzq#uhodwlyh#wr#wkrvh#lq#wkh#plggoh1# # # # # # # # # Pdq|#frpphqwdwruv/#erwk#lq#dfdghpld#dqg#lq#wkh#srsxodu#suhvv/#kdyh#irfxvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wkh# # # lqfrph## jdlqv## pdgh## e|#wkh# # # wrs## 4## shufhqw#ru# # # hyhq#wkh# # # wrs## 3134## shufhqw#ri# # hduqhuv/#shukdsv#ehfdxvh#lw#lv#pruh#fxvwrpdu|#wr#orrn#xs#wkdq#grzq1#L#eholhyh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # ## # pruh#wurxeohvrph#wuhqg#iru# # # # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # lv## wkh#<3243#ru# # # # <3283#gliihuhqwldo/# # zklfk#uhiohfwv#wkh#fkdqjhv#prvw#Dphulfdqv#h{shulhqfh1# # # # # # # Pxfk#ri#wkh# # # # <3243## gliihuhqwldo## fdq#eh# # # dwwulexwhg## wr## zkdw## hfrqrplvwv## fdoo## wkh# ᄈfroohjh#suhplxp1ᄡ#Wkh#udwlr#ri#wkh#zdjhv#ri#wkrvh#zkr#kdyh#rqo|#d#edfkhoru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄊv# ghjuhh## wr## wkrvh## zkr## rqo|## kdyh## d## kljk## vfkrro## ghjuhh## kdv## ulvhq## vwhdglo|## vlqfh# 4<;31#Wkh#533;#Fxuuhqw#Srsxodwlrq#Vxuyh|#e|#wkh#Fhqvxv#Exuhdx#lqglfdwhg#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#phgldq#zdjh#ri#d#kljk#vfkrro#judgxdwh#zdv#'5:/<96/#zkloh#wkh#phgldq#zdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#vrphrqh#zlwk#dq#xqghujudgxdwh#ghjuhh#zdv#'7;/3<:ᄇderxw#:5#shufhqw#pruh1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkrvh#zlwk#surihvvlrqdo# # # # ghjuhhv#+olnh#dq#PG#ru# # # # # # PED,## hduq#hyhq#pruh/#zlwk#d# # # # # :##Wkdw#wkh#<3243#gliihuhqwldo#lv#odujho|#gxh#wr#wkh#froohjh# phgldq#zdjh#ri#';:/::81 # # # # # # # # # # # # suhplxp## dovr## h{sodlqv## zk|## wkh## 83243## gliihuhqwldo## kdv## qrw## pryhg## dv## pxfkᄇ# qhlwkhu## wkh## 83wk## shufhqwloh## hduqhu## qru## wkh## 43wk## shufhqwloh## hduqhu## kdv## ehhq## wr# froohjh1## Lq## idfw/## wkh## 83wk## shufhqwloh## w|slfdoo|## frqvlvwv## ri## zklwh0froodu## zrunhuv# olnh#Mdqh#dqg#khu#froohdjxhv/#zkr#kdyh#ehhq#prvw#vtxhh}hg#e|#wkh#whfkqrorjlfdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkdqjh1# Zk|## kdv## wkh## froohjh## suhplxp## lqfuhdvhgB## Rqh## ylhz## lv## wkdw## lw## lv## ehfdxvh# whfkqrorj|## kdv## ehfrph## hyhq## pruh## ghpdqglqj## ri## vnloov/## uhiohfwlqj## zkdw# hfrqrplvwv#whup#ᄈvnloo0eldvhg#whfkqlfdo#fkdqjh1ᄡ#Exw#Jroglq#dqg#Ndw}#dujxh#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## sdfh## ri## whfkqrorjlfdo## fkdqjh## dqg## lwv## ghpdqg## iru## juhdwhu## vnloov## kdv## ehhq# uhodwlyho|#vwhdg|=#wkh#dxwrpreloh#dqg#wkh#dlusodqh#zhuh#dv#glvuxswlyh#wr#olihvw|ohv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#ehjlqqlqj#ri#wkh#wzhqwlhwk#fhqwxu|#dv#wkh#Lqwhuqhw#dqg#rujdql}dwlrqdo#fkdqjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh#dw#wkh#hqg1#Udwkhu/#zkdw#kdv#fkdqjhg#lv#wkh#vxsso|#ri#wkh#hgxfdwhg1#Ehwzhhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 4<63#dqg#4<;3/#wkh#dyhudjh#|hduv#ri#vfkrrolqj#dprqj#Dphulfdqv#djh#63#ru#roghu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfuhdvhg## e|## derxw## rqh## |hdu## hyhu|## ghfdgh1## Dphulfdqv## lq## 4<;3## kdg## 71:## |hduv# pruh#vfkrrolqj#rq#dyhudjh#wkdq#Dphulfdqv#lq#4<631#Exw#ehwzhhq#4<;3#dqg#5338/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#sdfh#ri#lqfuhdvh#lq#hgxfdwlrqdo#dwwdlqphqwv#zdv#wuxo|#jodfldoᄇrqo|#31;#|hduv# # # # # # # # # # # # ;# ryhu#wkh#hqwluh#txduwhu#fhqwxu|1 # # # # Lq## sduw/## wkh## uhdvrq## iru## wkh## vorzhu## lqfuhdvh## lq## vxsso|## kdv## ehhq## wkh## uhodwlyh# vwdjqdwlrq## ri## kljk## vfkrro## judgxdwlrq## udwhv1## Dowkrxjk## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## ohg# klvwrulfdoo|## lq## wkh## iudfwlrq## ri## wkh## srsxodwlrq## zlwk## kljk## vfkrro## ghjuhhv/## wkdw#
iudfwlrq## kdv## qrw## lqfuhdvhg## vlqfh## 4<;3/## dqg## rwkhu## frxqwulhv## kdyh## fdxjkw## xs## dqg# vxusdvvhg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Pruhryhu/## zkloh## pruh## dqg## pruh## Dphulfdqv## lq#wkh# # 53ᄆ57#djh#jurxs#duh#jrlqj#wr#froohjh#+94#shufhqw#lq#5336/#xs#iurp#77#shufhqw#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 4<;3,/## qr## grxew## lq## sduw## dwwudfwhg## e|## wkh## srwhqwldo## errvw## wr## zdjhv/## froohjh# judgxdwlrq#udwhv#kdyh#qrw#nhsw#sdfh=#wrr#pdq|#vwxghqwv#olnh#Mdqh#duh#gursslqj#rxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#froohjh#ghvslwh#dq#lqfuhdvlqj#froohjh#suhplxp#ryhu#wlph1#Froohjh#judgxdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # udwhv## iru## |rxqj## phq## eruq## lq## wkh## 4<:3v## duh## qr## kljkhu## wkdq## iru## phq## eruq## lq## wkh# 4<73vᄇd## vkrfnlqj#idfw#zkhq#rqh# # # # # frqvlghuv## krz## pxfk#juhdwhu# # # ghpdqg## wkhuh## lv# <# qrz#iru#zrunhuv#zlwk#froohjh#ghjuhhv1 # # # # # Rqh## srvvleoh## h{sodqdwlrq#ri#wkh# # # # uhodwlyh## vwdjqdwlrq#lq#hgxfdwlrq#lv# # # # # wkdw#wkhuh# # pljkw#eh# # # d## qdwxudo## olplw#wr# # # krz## pxfk#hgxfdwlrq#d# # # # srsxodwlrq#fdq#devrue1# # # # Diwhu# doo/#qrw#hyhu|rqh#kdv#wkh#dswlwxgh#ru#lqfolqdwlrq#wr#zulwh#d#SkG#wkhvlv1#Li#wkdw#lv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdvh#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#krzhyhu/#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog#grhv#qrw#vhhp#wr#vhqvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxfk#d# # # olplw1## Ghvslwh## ohdglqj#wkh# # # zruog## lq#wkh# # # sdvw/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## idoohq# 43## Zkhq# ehklqg#wzhoyh#rwkhu#ulfk#frxqwulhv#lq#irxu0|hdu0froohjh#judgxdwlrq#udwhv1 # # # # # # # # zh#dovr#qrwh#wkdw#lwv#kljk#vfkrro#judgxdwlrq#udwhv#sxw#lw#lq#wkh#erwwrp#wklug#dprqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulfk#frxqwulhv/# # # zh## fdq#vhh# # # zk|#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lv## idoolqj#ehklqg# # # erwk#lwv# # # rzq# klvwrulfdo#uhfrug#dqg#lwv#frpshwlwruv1# # # # # Ilqdoo|/## zdjhv## duh## qrw#wkh# # # rqo|#frpsrqhqw#ri#lqfrph1# # # # # Lqfrph## iurp#surshuw|# # vxfk#dv#vwrfnv#dqg#erqgv#dovr#dggv#wr#ryhudoo#lqfrph/#zkloh#wd{hv#vxewudfw#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw1#Lqwhuhvwlqjo|/#hyhq#iru#wkh#ulfkhvw#3134#shufhqw#ri#Dphulfdqv#wrzdug#wkh#hqg#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#wzhqwlhwk#fhqwxu|/#;3#shufhqw#ri#lqfrph#frqvlvwhg#ri#zdjhv#dqg#lqfrph#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhoi0rzqhg## exvlqhvvhv/## dqg## rqo|## 53## shufhqw## frqvlvwhg## ri## lqfrph## iurp## dupᄊv0 44## Wklv#udwlr#lv#lq#vwdun#frqwudvw#wr#wkh#sdwwhuq#lq#wkh# ohqjwk#ilqdqfldo#lqyhvwphqwv1 # # # # # # # # # # # # hduo|## sduw## ri## wkh## fhqwxu|/## zkhq## wkh## ulfkhvw## ghulyhg## prvw## ri## wkhlu## lqfrph## iurp# surshuw|1#Wkh#ulfk#duh#qrz#wkh#zrunlqj#ulfkᄇzkhwkhu#wkh|#duh#hqwuhsuhqhxuv#olnh# # # # # # # # # # # # Eloo## Jdwhv## ru## edqnhuv## olnh## Oor|g## Eodqnihlq## ri## Jrogpdq## Vdfkvᄇlqvwhdg## ri## wkh# lgoh#ulfk1#Dw#d#wlph#zkhq#zhdowk#vhhpv#wr#eh#zlwklq#wkh#judvs#ri#dq|rqh#zkr#fdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jhw#d#jrrg#mre/#lw#lv#doo#wkh#pruh#xqiruwxqdwh#wkdw#vr#pdq|#Dphulfdqv/#e|#glqw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#srru#hgxfdwlrq/#duh#orfnhg#rxw#ri#wkh#surgxfwlyh#mrev#wkdw#zrxog#pdnh#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehwwhu#rii1# # L#kdyh#xvhg#wkh#whup#hgxfdwlrq#vr#idu/#hyhq#zkhq#L#uhihu#wr#hpsor|delolw|/#exw#d# # # # # # # # # # ## # # # # ehwwhu## whup## lv## kxpdq## fdslwdo/## zklfk## uhihuv## wr## wkh## eurdg## vhw## ri## fdsdelolwlhv/# lqfoxglqj## khdowk/## nqrzohgjh## dqg## lqwhooljhqfh/## dwwlwxgh/## vrfldo## dswlwxgh/## dqg# hpsdwk|#wkdw#pdnh# # # # d## shuvrq#d# # # surgxfwlyh## phpehu## ri#vrflhw|1# # # Irupdo## hgxfdwlrq# sod|v#shukdsv#wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw#uroh#lq#iruplqj#dq#lqglylgxdoᄊv#kxpdq#fdslwdo/# # # # # # # # # # # # exw#idplo|/#frppxqlw|/#dqg#hpsor|huv#dovr#sod|#lpsruwdqw#sduwv1#Lq#zkdw#iroorzv/# # # # # # # # # # # # L## irfxv## rq## hgxfdwlrq/## exw## L## dovr## uhihu## wr## wkhvh## rwkhu## hohphqwv/## hvshfldoo|## lq# Fkdswhu#<#zkhq#L#wxuq#wr#uhphglhv1# # # ## # # Hgxfdwlrq## sod|v## d## idu## juhdwhu## uroh## wkdq## vlpso|## lpsurylqj## dq## lqglylgxdoᄊv# lqfrph## dqg## fduhhu## survshfwv=## lw## kdv## lqwulqvlf## zruwk#ri# # # lwv## rzq/## doorzlqj#xv# # # wr# pdnh## xvh## ri## rxu## ilqhu## idfxowlhv1## Lq## dgglwlrq/## vwxglhv## vkrz## wkdw## wkh## hgxfdwhg# w|slfdoo|## wdnh## ehwwhu## fduh## ri## wkhlu## rzq## khdowk/## duh## ohvv## surqh## wr## lqgxojlqj## lq# fulplqdo## dfwlylwlhv/## dqg## duh## pruh## olnho|## wr## sduwlflsdwh## lq## flylf## dqg## srolwlfdo# dfwlylwlhv1## Pruhryhu/## wkh|#lqioxhqfh# # # wkhlu## fkloguhq#wr# # # gr## wkh## vdph/## vr## wkdw## wkhlu# hgxfdwlrq#kdv#ehqhilfldo#hiihfwv#rq#ixwxuh#jhqhudwlrqv#dovr1#Vr#dv#lw#idoov#ehklqg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
hgxfdwlrq/#Dphulfd#lv#glplqlvklqj#wkh#txdolw|#ri#lwv#vrflhw|1 # # # # # # # #
Zk|#Lv#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#Idoolqj#EhklqgB # # # # # # # Zk|## lv## wkh## hgxfdwlrqdo## v|vwhp#idlolqj# # # wkh## Xqlwhg## VwdwhvB## Zlwk## d## xqlyhuvlw|# v|vwhp#wkdw#lv#vwloo# # # # # frqvlghuhg#wkh#ehvw#lq#wkh#zruog/#dqg#zklfk#dwwudfwv#vwxghqwv# # # # # # # # # # iurp#hyhu|#fruqhu# # # # ri#wkh# # # joreh/#wkh# # # idloxuh#fohduo|#grhv# # # # qrw#olh#lq#wkh#txdolw|#ri# # # # # # xqlyhuvlw|#hgxfdwlrq1# # # Lqvwhdg/## wkhuh## duh## wkuhh## reylrxv## sureohpv## wkdw## p|#hduolhu# # glvfxvvlrq#vxjjhvwv1#Iluvw/#wkh#txdolw|#ri#wkh#ohduqlqj#h{shulhqfh#lq#vfkrrov#lv#vr# # # # # # # # # # # # # srru#wkdw#idu#wrr#pdq|#vwxghqwv#gurs#rxw#ehiruh#frpsohwlqj#kljk#vfkrro1#Vhfrqg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#d# # # uhodwhg## yhlq/## hyhq#dprqj#wkrvh# # # # zkr## judgxdwh## iurp#kljk#vfkrro/# # # # pdq|#duh# # xqsuhsduhg#iru#wkh#uljruv#ri#xqlyhuvlw|#hgxfdwlrq1#Ilqdoo|/#dv#wkh#froohjh#suhplxp# # # # # # # # # # # # lqfuhdvhv/## wkh## frvw## ri## kljkhu## hgxfdwlrq## dovr## lqfuhdvhv=## lw## lv## d## vhuylfh## wkdw## lv# surylghg#e|#wkh#zhoo0hgxfdwhg#zlwk#yhu|#vpdoo#lqfuhdvhv#lq#surgxfwlylw|#ryhu#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # |hduv## +froohjh## fodvv## vl}hv## kdyh## qrw## lqfuhdvhg## gudpdwlfdoo|## dw## p|## xqlyhuvlw|# ghvslwh## doo## wkh## lpsuryhphqwv## lq#frppxqlfdwlrqv# # # whfkqrorj|/#wkrxjk#wkh# # # # ohduqlqj# h{shulhqfh#kdv#suredeo|#lpsuryhg,1#Ghvslwh#dwwhpswv#wr#h{sdqg#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # dlg/#d# # txdolw|## hgxfdwlrq## dw## d## sulydwh## xqlyhuvlw|## lv## sdvvlqj## eh|rqg## wkh## uhdfk## ri## hyhq# plggoh0fodvv#idplolhv1#Dqg#zlwk#wljkw#vwdwh#exgjhwv/#hyhq#vwdwh#vfkrrov#duh#udlvlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # ihhv#vljqlilfdqwo|1# # Ri#frxuvh/#ohduqlqj#grhv#qrw#wdnh#sodfh#rqo|#lq#wkh#fodvvurrp1#Gliihuhqfhv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # dswlwxgh#iru#hgxfdwlrq#hphujh#lq#hduo|#fklogkrrg#dv#d#uhvxow#ri#ydu|lqj#qxwulwlrq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # ohduqlqj## hqylurqphqwv/## dqg## ehkdylrudo## h{shfwdwlrqv1## Wkh## idplo|## pdwwhuv# lpphqvho|/## dv## gr## wkh## nlqg## ri## uroh## prghov## fkloguhq## zdqw## wr## hpxodwh## dqg## wkh# dwwlwxghv## wkhlu## iulhqgv## kdyh1## Dw## p|## gdxjkwhu#ᄊv## xqlyhuvlw|0diiloldwhg## vfkrro/## wkh# vpduwhvw#nlg#lq#fodvv#lv#sxvkhg#wr#h{fho#dqg#lv#vhfuhwo|#dgpluhg#hyhq#li#vkh#grhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#ehorqj#wr#wkh#srsxodu#vhw1#Dgydqfhg#vwxghqwv#wdnh#xqlyhuvlw|#frxuvhv#lq#kljk# # # # # # # # # # # # # vfkrro## dqg#hyhq#vljq#xs#iru# # # # # # uhvhdufk#surmhfwv#zlwk#surihvvruv1#Krzhyhu/#lq#wrr# # # # # # # pdq|#vfkrrov# # # lq#Dphulfd/#ehlqj#vpduw#fdq#eh# # # # # # # srvlwlyho|#gdqjhurxv/#dv# # # # fkloguhq# uhvhqw#dqg#vhw#xsrq#wkrvh#zkr#gduh#wr#wu|#wr#hvfdsh#wkh#wuds#ri#orz#h{shfwdwlrqv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Khuh## djdlq/## dgydqwdjh## euhhgv## pruh## dgydqwdjh1## Wkh## ulfk## fdq## diirug## wr## olyh## lq# ehwwhu## qhljkerukrrgv/## fdq## jlyh## wkhlu## fkloguhq## wkh## khdowk## fduh## dqg## qxwulwlrq## wkdw# doorz## wkhp#wr# # # jurz## xs## khdowk|/## dqg## fdq## kluh## wxwruv## dqg## ohduqlqj## dlghv## li## wkhlu# fkloguhq#idoo#ehklqg1#Hyhq#g|vixqfwlrqdolw|#kxuwv#fkloguhq#ohvv#li#wkhlu#sduhqwv#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # ulfk1#Dv#wkh#srolwlfdo#dqdo|vwv#Urvv#Grxwkdw#dqg#Uhlkdq#Vdodp#sxw#lw=#ᄈWkh#nlgv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Frqqhfwlfxw#suhs#vfkrrov# # # # vprnhg#srw#dqg#zhqw#rq#wr#froohjh# # # # # # # # olnh## wkhlu## sduhqwv># nlgv## lq## uxudo## Lqgldqd## vprnhg## phwk## dqg## gursshg## rxw>## nlgv## lq## wkh## Vrxwk## Eurq{# 45# vprnhg#fudfn#dqg#glhg#lq#jdqj#zduv1ᄡ # # # # # # Idplo|#lqvwdelolw|/# # # wrr/## lv## kdughu## rq#srru# # # fkloguhq1## Srru/## ohvv## zhoo0hgxfdwhg# frxsohv## duh## pruh## olnho|## wr## euhdn## xs/## dqg## zkhq## wkdw## kdsshqv## wkh## hfrqrplf# frqvhtxhqfhv#duh#pruh#vhyhuh#wkdq#iru#wkh#zhoo0rii=#wkh#frvw#ri#pdlqwdlqlqj#wzr# # # # # # # # # # # # # hvwdeolvkphqwv/#vkxwwolqj#fkloguhq#ehwzhhq#wkh#wzr#sduhqwv/#dqg#fklog#fduh#hdw#xs# # # # # # # # # # # # d#pxfk#eljjhu# # # # iudfwlrq#ri#wkh#srru# # # # # sduhqwvᄊ#lqfrph/#ohdylqj#ohvv#iru# # # # # # rwkhu## edvlf# qhfhvvlwlhv/#ohw#dorqh#frxqvholqj#dqg#uhphgldo#wxlwlrq#wr#khos#ghydvwdwhg#fkloguhq# # # # # # # # # # # frsh## zlwk## wkh## euhdnxs1## Glyrufh## wkhuhiruh## diihfwv## wkh## fkloguhqᄊv## khdowk## dqg# vfkrrolqj## idu## pruh## lq## d## srru## idplo|## wkdq## lq## d## ulfk## idplo|1## Lqhtxdolw|## whqgv## wr# ixuwkhu#shushwxdwh#lwvhoi#wkurxjk#wkh#vrfldo#hqylurqphqw1# # # # # # # Zh#gr#qrw#qhhg#wr#jhw#lqwr#wkh#prudo#lvvxhv#vxuurxqglqj#h{wuhph#lqhtxdolw|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
xqghuvwdqg#wkdw#lw#lv#d#wkrurxjko|#xqghvludeoh#vwdwh#ri#diidluv1#Wr#wkh#h{whqw#wkdw#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv## fdxvhg## e|## d## vljqlilfdqw## sduw## ri## wkh## srsxodwlrqᄊv## qrw## ehlqj## deoh## wr## lpsuryh# wkhpvhoyhv#ehfdxvh#ri#odfn#ri#dffhvv#wr#txdolw|#hgxfdwlrq/#lw#vljqlilhv#wuhphqgrxv# # # # # # # # # # # # lqhiilflhqf|1#D#plqg#lv#d#whuuleoh#wklqj#wr#zdvwh/#dqg#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#lv#zdvwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrr#pdq|#ri#wkhp1# # # #
Rwkhu#Uhdvrqv#iru#Lqhtxdolw| # # # # Gliihuhqfhv## lq## hgxfdwlrqdo## dwwdlqphqw## lq## wkh## idfh## ri## ulvlqj## whfkqrorjlfdo# ghpdqg## iru## vnloov## duh/## ri## frxuvh/## rqo|## rqh## uhdvrq## iru## wkh## jurzlqj## lqhtxdolw|1# 46## Ulvlqj#lqhtxdolw|# Wkhuh#duh#rwkhu#uhdvrqv#zk|#phdvxuhg#lqhtxdolw|#pljkw#ulvh1 # # # # # # # # # lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lq## wkh## sdvw## wkuhh## ghfdghv## frlqflghv## zlwk## d## shulrg## ri# ghuhjxodwlrq1## Lqfuhdvlqj## frpshwlwlrq## grhv## lqfuhdvh## wkh## ghpdqg## iru## wdohqwhg# hpsor|hhv/## wkxv## lqfuhdvlqj## wkh## glvshuvlrq## ri## zdjhv## zlwklq## dq|## vhjphqw## ri## wkh# srsxodwlrq1#Lq#jhqhudo/#wklv#zrxog#lqfuhdvh#lqhtxdolw|/#dowkrxjk#e|#lqfuhdvlqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # frvwv## ri#glvfulplqdwlqj#djdlqvw#wkh# # # # # srru## exw#wdohqwhg/# # # lw#frxog# # # uhgxfh## lqhtxdolw|1# Ghuhjxodwlrq#fdq#dovr#ohdg#wr#pruh#hqwu|#dqg#h{lw#ri#ilupv/#zklfk#lqfuhdvhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh# yrodwlolw|#ri#hdfk#zrunhu# # # # ᄊv#hduqlqjv=#dq#hqwuhsuhqhxu#zkr#hduqv#qrwklqj#iru#d#ihz# # # # # # # # # # |hduv## dqg## wkhq## pdnhv## ploolrqv## dggv## wr## erwk## wkh## erwwrp## dqg## wkh## wrs## ri## wkh# glvwulexwlrq#fxuyh#lq#gliihuhqw#|hduv1#+Vr#grhv#d#shqxulrxv#judgxdwh#vwxghqw#ehiruh# # # # # # # # # # # # ehfrplqj#d#zhoo0sdlg#surihvvru$,#Wkhvh#hiihfwv#pd|#dffrxqw#iru#xs#wr#rqh0wklug# # # # # # # # # # # # 47# ri#wkh#lqfuhdvh#lq#phdvxuhg#lqhtxdolw|1 # # # # # Juhdwhu## lppljudwlrq## dqg## wudgh## kdyh## dovr## sod|hg## d## sduw## ehfdxvh## lppljudqwv/# frpshwlqj#gluhfwo|#iru#xqvnloohg#mrev/#dqg#xqvnloohg#zrunhuv#idu#dzd|/#frpshwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # wkurxjk#wudgh/#kdyh#erwk#vhuyhg#wr#krog#grzq#zdjhv#ri#xqvnloohg#X1V1#zrunhuv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # 48## Xqvnloohg#lppljudqwv# Prvw#vwxglhv#vhh#wkh#pdjqlwxgh#ri#wkhvh#hiihfwv#dv#vpdoo1 # # # # # # # # # # kdyh/## krzhyhu/## frqwulexwhg## wr## lqhtxdolw|## lq## d## gliihuhqw## zd|1## Wkh|## w|slfdoo|# rffxs|## wkh## erwwrp## ri## wkh## lqfrph## glvwulexwlrq## dqg## wkxv## frqwulexwh## wr## phdvxuhg# lqhtxdolw|149## Sdudgr{lfdoo|/## dowkrxjk## wkhlu## lqfrphv## duh## riwhq## kljkhu## wkdq## wkhlu# lqfrphv#lq#wkh#krph#frxqwu|/#wkh|#vzhoo#wkh#udqnv#ri#wkrvh#zkr#dsshdu#grzq#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw#lq#Dphulfd1# # # Wkh#uhgxfwlrq#lq#wkh#sxqlwlyh#srvwzdu#pdujlqdo#wd{#rq#kljk#lqfrphv#+iurp#d#wrs# # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwh#ri#<4#shufhqw#wkurxjk#pxfk#ri#wkh#4<83v#dqg#wkh#4<93v/#wkurxjk#d#qxpehu#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xsv#dqg#grzqv/#wr#68#shufhqw#dw#wkh#wlph#ri#zulwlqj,#kdv#lqfuhdvhg#lqfhqwlyhv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hduq## kljkhu## lqfrphv## dqg## pd|## wkxv## kdyh## frqwulexwhg## wr## wkh## jurzlqj# hqwuhsuhqhxuvkls## dqg## lqhtxdolw|14:## Wkh## zhdnqhvv## ri## xqlrqv## pd|## dovr## kdyh# uhgxfhg#prghudwho|#hgxfdwhg#zrunhuvᄊ#edujdlqlqj#srzhu/#wkrxjk#wkh#orvv#ri#kljk0 # # # # # # # # # # sd|lqj#xqlrql}hg# # # mrev## suredeo|#kdv# # # pruh## wr## gr## zlwk#lqfuhdvhg# # # frpshwlwlrq#dqg# # hqwu|## dv## d## uhvxow## ri## ghuhjxodwlrq/## dv## zhoo## dv## frpshwlwlrq## iurp## lpsruwv1## D# uhodwlyho|#vwdjqdqw#plqlpxp#zdjh#kdv#fhuwdlqo|#doorzhg#wkh#orzhvw#uhdo#zdjhv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # idoo## +wkhuhe|## dovr## hqvxulqj## wkdw## vrph## shrsoh## zkr## zrxog## rwkhuzlvh## eh# xqhpsor|hg#gr#kdyh#d#mre,/#wkrxjk#rqo|#d#vpdoo#shufhqwdjh#ri#Dphulfdq#zrunhuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#sdlg#wkh#plqlpxp#zdjh1#Ilqdoo|/#wkh#hqwu|#ri#zrphq#lqwr#wkh#zrunirufh#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr#diihfwhg#lqhtxdolw|1#Ehfdxvh#wkh#zhoo0frqqhfwhg#dqg#wkh#kljko|#hgxfdwhg#whqg# # # # # # # # # # # wr#pdwh#pruh#riwhq#zlwk#hdfk#rwkhu/#ᄈdvvruwdwlyhᄡ#pdwlqj#kdv#dovr#khoshg#lqfuhdvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvhkrog#lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|1# # # Wkh#uhdvrqv#iru#jurzlqj#lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|#duh/#xqgrxewhgo|/#d#pdwwhu#ri#khdwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # ghedwh1#Wr#p|#plqg/#wkh#hylghqfh#lv#prvw#shuvxdvlyh#wkdw#wkh#jurzlqj#lqhtxdolw|#L# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wklqn#wkh#prvw#zruulvrph/#wkh#lqfuhdvlqj#<3243#gliihuhqwldo/#vwhpv#sulpdulo|#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## jds## ehwzhhq## wkh## ghpdqg## iru## wkh## kljko|## hgxfdwhg## dqg## wkhlu## vxsso|1# Surjuhvvlyhv/## qr## grxew/## dwwulexwh## vxevwdqwldo## zhljkw## wr## wkh## dqwloderu## srolflhv#
iroorzhg## e|## Uhsxeolfdq## jryhuqphqwv## vlqfh## Urqdog## Uhdjdq/## zkhuhdv# frqvhuydwlyhv#dwwulexwh#pxfk#ri#wkh#hduolhu#zdjh#frpsuhvvlrq#wr#dqwlfrpshwlwlyh# # # # # # # # # # srolflhv#iroorzhg#vlqfh#Iudqnolq#Urrvhyhow1#Qhlwkhu#vlgh#zrxog/#krzhyhu/#ghq|# # # # # # # # # # wkh#lpsruwdqfh#ri#gliihuhqwldo#hgxfdwlrqdo#dwwdlqphqwv#lq#irvwhulqj#lqhtxdolw|1# # # # # # # # #
Dwwlwxghv#wrzdug#Lqhtxdolw| # # # Dphulfdqv## kdyh## klvwrulfdoo|## qrw## ehhq## wrr## frqfhuqhg## derxw## hfrqrplf# lqhtxdolw|## h{fhsw## zkhq## lw## ehfrphv## h{wuhphᄇdv## lw## glg## wrzdug## wkh## hqg## ri## wkh# qlqhwhhqwk#fhqwxu|1#Wkurxjk#d# # # # # ydulhw|#ri#phdqv# # # # vxfk#dv# # # dqwlwuxvw#odzv# # # dqg#hvwdwh# # wd{hv/## wkh|#kdyh# # # hqvxuhg## wkdw## zhdowk#jhqhudwhg# # # iurp#frusrudwh# # # rzqhuvkls## grhv# qrw## ehfrph## vr## kljko|## frqfhqwudwhg## wkdw## lw## xsvhwv## wkh## glvwulexwlrq## ri## srolwlfdo# srzhu1#Wkh#jryhuqphqw#kdv#uhshdwhgo|#lqwhuyhqhg#wr#olplw#wkh#srzhu#ri#edqnvᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # dv#lq#Dqguhz#Mdfnvrqᄊv#iljkw#wr#forvh#wkh#Vhfrqg#Edqn#ri#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#+diwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kh#dffxvhg#lw#ri#srolwlfdo#phggolqj,/#wkh#fuhdwlrq#ri#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#lq#4<46# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vr#wkdw#edqnv#kdg#dq#dowhuqdwlyh#wr#M1#S1#Prujdq#dv#wkh#ohqghu#ri#odvw#uhvruw/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Jodvv0Vwhdjdoo## Dfw## ri## 4<66/## zklfk## eurnh## xs## wkh## prvw## srzhuixo## edqnv1# Vlploduo|/## wkurxjk## dqwlwuxvw## lqyhvwljdwlrqv/## prvw## idprxvo|## djdlqvw## Mrkq## G1# Urfnhihoohu#ᄊv## Vwdqgdug## Rlo## dqg## Eloo## Jdwhvᄊv## Plfurvriw/## wkh## jryhuqphqw## kdv# vrxjkw## wr## uhlq## lq## wkh## srzhu## ri## elj## exvlqhvv1## Exw## zlwk## wkh## h{fhswlrq## ri## vrph# hslvrghvᄇiru## h{dpsoh/## gxulqj## wkh## Juhdw## Ghsuhvvlrqᄇwkh## jryhuqphqw## dqg## wkh# sxeolf#kdyh#qrw#ehhq#vwurqjo|#suhglvsrvhg#wrzdug#sxqlwlyh#wd{dwlrq#ri#wkh#ulfk#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # dfklhyh#d#pruh#htxlwdeoh#glvwulexwlrq#ri#lqfrph1# # # # # # # ᄈVrdn#wkh#ulfkᄡ#srolflhv#kdyh#vhogrp#ehhq#srsxodu#dprqj#wkh#ohvv#zhoo0rii#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dphulfd/## qrw## qhfhvvdulo|## ehfdxvh## wkh|## kdyh## juhdw## v|psdwk|## iru## wkh## ulfk## exw# shukdsv## ehfdxvh## wkh## srru## vhh## wkhpvhoyhv## hyhqwxdoo|## ehfrplqj## ulfk=## Krudwlr# Dojhu#ᄊv#vwrulhv#ri#ruglqdu|#shrsoh#dwwdlqlqj#juhdw#vxffhvv#lq#wkh#odqg#ri#olplwohvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # 4;## Dowkrxjk#vxfk#rswlplvp#pd|#dozd|v#kdyh#ehhq# rssruwxqlw|#kdg#eurdg#dsshdo1 # # # # # # # # # xquhdolvwlf/#wkh#jxoi#ehwzhhq#wkh#srvvleoh#dqg#wkh#sudfwlfdo#pljkw#kdyh#ehhq#vpdoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # hqrxjk## lq## wkh## sdvw## wkdw## Dphulfdqv## frxog## frqwlqxh## guhdplqj1## Dffruglqj## wr## wkh# Zruog## Ydoxhv## Vxuyh|/## :4## shufhqw## ri## Dphulfdqv## eholhyh## wkh## srru## kdyh## d## jrrg# fkdqfh## ri## hvfdslqj## sryhuw|/## zkloh## rqo|## 73## shufhqw## ri## Hxurshdqv## vkduh## wklv# eholhi14<## Wkhvh## gliihuhqfhv## duh## sduwlfxoduo|## vxusulvlqj## ehfdxvh## furvv0frxqwu|# vwxglhv#vxjjhvw#wkdw#shrsoh#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#duh#qrw#pxfk#pruh#preloh#dfurvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfrph#fodvvhv#wkdq#lq#Hxurshdq#frxqwulhv/#dqg#lqghhg#wkh#erwwrp#53#shufhqw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # 53## Qhyhuwkhohvv/#wkh#lghd# hduqhuv#pd|#eh#xqxvxdoo|#lppreloh#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1 # # # # # # # # # # ri## lqfrph## prelolw|## zdv## ghhso|## lqjudlqhg## lq## wkh## sdvw1## Wkdw## juhdw## revhuyhu## ri# Dphulfd/## Doh{lv## gh## Wrftxhylooh/## uhpdunhg## wkdw## lq#Dphulfd/# # # ᄈzhdowk#flufxodwhv# # zlwk#dvwrxqglqj#udslglw|#dqg#h{shulhqfh#vkrzv#lw#lv#uduh#wr#ilqg#wzr#vxffhvvlyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # jhqhudwlrqv#lq#wkh#ixoo#hqmr|phqw#ri#lw1ᄡ # # # # # # 54# Ryhu#wkh#sdvw#58#|hduv/#wkrxjk/#pruh#dqg#pruh#Dphulfdqv#kdyh#frph#idfh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # idfh#zlwk#wkh#elwwhu#uhdolw|#wkdw#wkh|#duh#wudsshg#e|#hgxfdwlrqdo#xqghudfklhyhphqw1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## Qhzvzhhn## froxpqlvw## Urehuw## Vdpxhovrq## kdv## dujxhg## wkdw## ᄈrq## wkh## zkroh/# Dphulfdqv#fduh#ohvv#derxw#lqhtxdolw|ᄇwkh#suhflvh#jds#ehwzhhq#wkh#ulfk#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # 55## \hw# srruᄇwkdq#derxw#rssruwxqlw|#dqg#dfklhyhphqw=#duh#shrsoh#jhwwlqj#dkhdgBᄡ # # # # # # # # lqhtxdolw|#lq#hgxfdwlrq#lv# # # # # sduwlfxoduo|#lqvlglrxv# # # ehfdxvh## lw#uhgxfhv# # # rssruwxqlw|1# Vrphrqh#zkr#kdv#kdg#dq#lqgliihuhqw#kljk#vfkrro#hgxfdwlrq#fdqqrw#hyhq#guhdp#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # jhwwlqj#d#udqjh#ri#mrev#wkdw#wkh#qhz#hfrqrp|#kdv#wkurzq#xs1#Iru#Dphulfdqv/#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#zkrp#ᄈghilqh#srolwlfdo#iuhhgrp#dv#vwulfw#htxdolw|#exw#hfrqrplf#iuhhgrp#dv#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # # htxdo## fkdqfh## wr## ehfrph## xqhtxdo/ᄡ## lqhtxdolw|## ri## dffhvv## wr## txdolw|## hgxfdwlrq# vkdnhv## wkh## yhu|## irxqgdwlrq## ri## wkhlu## vxssruw## iru## hfrqrplf## iuhhgrp/## iru## wkh|## qr#
56# orqjhu#kdyh#dq#htxdo#fkdqfh1 # # # #
Li#Dphulfdqv#qr#orqjhu#kdyh#wkh#fkdqfh#wr#eh#xszdugo|#preloh/#wkh|#duh#ohvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # olnho|#wr#eh#rswlplvwlf#derxw#wkh#ixwxuh#ru#wr#eh#wrohudqw#ri#wkh#prelolw|#ri#rwkhuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇehfdxvh## wkh## lppreloh## duh## kxuw## zkhq## rwkhuv## pryh## xs1## Zkhq## rwkhuv## lq## wrzq# ehfrph#ulfkhu/#wkh#frvw#ri#hyhu|wklqj#jrhv#xs/#dqg#wkh#uhdo# # # # # # # # # # # # lqfrphᄇwkh#lqfrph# # lq#whupv# # # ri#lwv# # # sxufkdvlqj#srzhuᄇri#wkh# # # # hfrqrplfdoo|#lppreloh# # # idoov1## Pdwwhuv# duh#hyhq#zruvh#li#wkh#lppreloh#phdvxuh#wkhlu#zruwk#lq#whupv#ri#wkhlu#srvvhvvlrqv=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # p|#Fkhyurohw#ehfrphv#pxfk#ohvv#sohdvxudeoh#zkhq#p|#qhljkeru#xsjudghv#iurp#d# # # # # # # # # # # # 57# Krqgd#wr#d#Pdvhudwl1 # # # # Hqy|#kdv#klvwrulfdoo|#ehhq#xq0Dphulfdq/#odujho|#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # lw#zdv#fkhfnhg#e|#vhoi0frqilghqfh1#Dv#vhoi0frqilghqfh#zlwkhuv/#fdq#hqy|/#dqg#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # forvh#frxvlq/#kdwuhg/#eh#idu#ehklqgB# # # # # # Dv#pruh#dqg#pruh#Dphulfdqv#uhdol}h#wkh|#duh#vlpso|#qrw#htxlsshg#wr#frpshwh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## dv## wkh|## frph## wr## whupv## zlwk## wkhlu## rzq## glplqlvkhg## h{shfwdwlrqv/## wkh## zrugv# hfrqrplf## iuhhgrp#gr# # # qrw#frqmxuh# # # rshq#ylvwdv# # # ri#xqolplwhg# # # rssruwxqlw|1## Lqvwhdg# wkh|#riihu#d#qljkwpduh#ylvlrq#ri#juhdw#dqg#frqwlqxlqj#lqvhfxulw|/#dqg#jurzlqj#hqy|# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv## wkh## kdyh0qrwv## lqfuhdvlqjo|#ehfrph# # # wkh## kdyh0qhyhuv1## Zlwkrxw#vrph# # # fkdqjh## lq# wklv#wuhqg/#ghvwuxfwlyh#fodvv#zduiduh#lv#qr#orqjhu#lpsrvvleoh#wr#frqwhpsodwh1# # # # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Srolwlfdo#Uhdfwlrq # # # Srolwlfldqv#kdyh#uhfrjql}hg#wkh#sureohp#srvhg#e|#ulvlqj#lqhtxdolw|1#Ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # Diulfdq#Dphulfdqv# # # dqg## Klvsdqlfv## kdyh## ehhq#kdughu# # # klw#e|#srru# # # # vfkrrolqj#wkdq# # rwkhu## jurxsv/## wkhlu## odfn## ri## surjuhvv## lv## dovr## frqiodwhg## zlwk## udfh1## Qhyhuwkhohvv/# srolwlfldqv#kdyh#xqghuvwrrg#wkdw#ehwwhu#hgxfdwlrq#lv#sduw#ri#wkh#vroxwlrq1#D#qxpehu# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## suhvlghqwv## kdyh## wdnhq## xs## wkh## fdxvh/## exw## zlwkrxw## pdnlqj## pxfk## ri## d## ghqw1# Pruhryhu/## hyhq#li#wkh|#frxog# # # # # pdnh## d## gliihuhqfh/## wkh## fkdqjhv## zrxog## wdnh## hiihfw# wrr#odwh#wr#dowhu#wkh#olyhv#ri#wrgd|ᄊv#dgxowv1# # # # # # # # # Wd{dwlrq## dqg## uhglvwulexwlrq## frxog## eh## dq## dowhuqdwlyh>## exw/## dv## wkh## srolwlfdo# vflhqwlvwv## Qrodq#PfFduwk|/#Nhlwk#Srroh/#dqg#Krzdug#Urvhqwkdo# # # # # # # # dujxh/#jurzlqj# # lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|#kdv#pdgh#Frqjuhvv#pxfk#pruh#srodul}hg#dqg#pxfk#ohvv#olnho|# # # # # # # # # # # # 58## Hyhq#dv#L#zulwh#wklv/# wr#frph#wrjhwkhu#rq#pdwwhuv#ri#wd{dwlrq#dqg#uhglvwulexwlrq1 # # # # # # # # # ## # wkh## Vhqdwh## lv## glylghg## frpsohwho|#dorqj#sduw|#olqhv# # # # # lq#lwv# # # dwwlwxgh## wrzdug## khdowk# fduh## uhirup/## zlwk## Ghprfudwv## xqdqlprxv## lq## vxssruw/## dqg## Uhsxeolfdqv## htxdoo|# xqdqlprxv## lq## rssrvlwlrq1## Srolwlfldqv## duh## frplqj## wr## whupv## zlwk## vrphwklqj# Dulvwrwoh#srlqwhg#rxw=#wkdw#dowkrxjk#txduuhov#duh#pruh#olnho|#lq#dq#xqhtxdo#vrflhw|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # vwulylqj#wr#uhfwli|#wkh#lqhtxdolw|#pd|#suhflslwdwh#wkh#yhu|#frqiolfw#wkdw#wkh#flwl}hqu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # 59# zdqwv#wr#dyrlg1 # # Srolwlfldqv#kdyh#wkhuhiruh#orrnhg#iru#rwkhu#zd|v#wr#lpsuryh#wkh#olyhv#ri#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # yrwhuv1#Vlqfh#wkh#hduo|#4<;3v/#wkh#prvw#vhgxfwlyh#dqvzhu#kdv#ehhq#hdvlhu#fuhglw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Lq## vrph## zd|v/## lw## lv## wkh## sdwk## ri## ohdvw## uhvlvwdqfh1## Jryhuqphqw0vxssruwhg## fuhglw# grhv#qrw#durxvh#dv#pdq|#frqfhuqv#iurp#wkh#Uljkw#dw#wkh#rxwvhw#dv#rxwuljkw#lqfrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhglvwulexwlrq#zrxogᄇwkrxjk/#dv#zh#kdyh#h{shulhqfhg/#lw#pd|#hqg#xs#dv#d#yhu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # frvwo|## zd|## wr## uhglvwulexwh/## lpsrvlqj## kdup## rq## wkh## uhflslhqw## dqg## frvwv## rq## wkh# wd{sd|hu1# Srolwlfldqv#oryh#wr#kdyh#edqnv#h{sdqg#krxvlqj#fuhglw/#iru#fuhglw#dfklhyhv#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # jrdov## dw## wkh## vdph## wlph1## Lw## sxvkhv## xs## krxvh## sulfhv/## pdnlqj## krxvhkrogv## ihho# zhdowklhu/#dqg#doorzv#wkhp#wr#ilqdqfh#pruh#frqvxpswlrq1#Lw#fuhdwhv#pruh#surilwv# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## mrev## lq#wkh# # # ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## dv## zhoo## dv## lq#uhdo# # # hvwdwh## eurnhudjh## dqg## krxvlqj# frqvwuxfwlrq1#Dqg#hyhu|wklqj#lv#vdihᄇdv#vdih#dv#krxvhvᄇdw#ohdvw#iru#d#zkloh1# # # # # # # # # # # # Hdv|## fuhglw## kdv## odujh/## srvlwlyh/## lpphgldwh/## dqg## zlgho|## glvwulexwhg## ehqhilwv/# zkhuhdv#wkh#frvwv#doo#olh#lq#wkh#ixwxuh1#Lw#kdv#d#sd|rii#vwuxfwxuh#wkdw#lv#suhflvho|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rqh## ghvluhg#e|#srolwlfldqv/#zklfk#lv# # # # # # zk|#vr#pdq|#frxqwulhv# # # # # kdyh## vxffxpehg#wr# # lwv#oxuh1#Ulfk#frxqwulhv#kdyh/#ryhu#wlph/#exlow#lqvwlwxwlrqv#vxfk#dv#ilqdqfldo0vhfwru# # # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwruv## dqg## vxshuylvruv/## zklfk## fdq## vwdqg## xs## wr## srolwlfldqv## dqg## ghiohfw## vxfk# vkruw0whup## p|rsld1## Wkh## sureohp## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## wklv## wlph## zdv## wkdw## wkh# srolwlfldqv#irxqg#d#zd|#durxqg#wkhvh#uhjxodwru|#vwuxfwxuhv/#dqg#hyhqwxdoo|#sxeolf# # # # # # # # # # # vxssruw#iru# # # krxvlqj#fuhglw#zdv# # # # vr#zlghvsuhdg#wkdw#ihz# # # # # uhjxodwruv/#li#dq|/#gduhg# # # # rssrvh#lw1# #
D#Vkruw#Klvwru|#ri#Krxvlqj#Fuhglw # # # # # # Wkh#shulrg#ohdglqj#xs#wr#wkh#Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrq#zdv#dovr#d#wlph#ri#juhdw#fuhglw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{sdqvlrq#dqg/#shukdsv# # # # qrw#frlqflghqwdoo|/#rqh# # # # ri#vxevwdqwldo# # # lqfrph## lqhtxdolw|1# Pruwjdjhv#zhuh#gliihuhqw#wkhq1#Uhvlghqwldo#pruwjdjhv#zhuh#riihuhg#e|#edqnv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # wkuliw#frpsdqlhv#+dovr#nqrzq#dv#vdylqjv#dqg#ordqv#dvvrfldwlrqv,1#Pruwjdjhv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # dydlodeoh## iru## rqo|#d# # # vkruw## whup/## derxw## ilyh## |hduv/## dqg## ihdwxuhg## d## vlqjoh## fdslwdo# uhsd|phqw#dw#pdwxulw|/# # # # xqohvv## wkh## eruurzhu## frxog## uhilqdqfh## wkh## ordq1## Pruhryhu/# prvw#ordqv#zhuh#dw#yduldeoh#udwhv/#vr#wkh#eruurzhu#eruh#wkh#ulvn#wkdw#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#fkdqjh>#dqg#ohqghuv#glg#qrw#w|slfdoo|#ohqg#pruh#wkdq#83#shufhqw#ri#ydoxh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 5:# vr#krphrzqhuv#eruh#pxfk#ri#wkh#ulvn#ri#krxvh0sulfh#ioxfwxdwlrqv1 # # # # # # # # # Lq## wkh## 4<63v/## dv## wkh## Ghsuhvvlrq## zruvhqhg/## uhilqdqflqj## gulhg## xs/## ydoxdwlrqv# soxpphwhg/## dqg## krphrzqhuv/## vwudsshg## iru## wkh## fdvk## wr## uhsd|## pdwxulqj## ordqv/# vwduwhg## ghidxowlqj## lq## guryhv1## Zlwk## 43## shufhqw## ri## wkh## qdwlrqᄊv## krxvlqj## vwrfn## lq# iruhforvxuh/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqhg#lq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw#wr#vdyh#lw#iurp#iuhh# # # # # # # # # # # # # idoo1## Dprqj## wkh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## lw## fuhdwhg## lqlwldoo|## zhuh## wkh## Krph## Rzqhu#ᄊv## Ordq# Frusrudwlrq#+KROF,#dqg#wkh#Ihghudo#Krxvlqj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq#+IKD,1# # # # # # # # KROFᄊv## uroh## zdv## wr## ex|## ghidxowhg## pruwjdjhv## iurp## edqnv## dqg## wkuliwv## dqg# uhvwuxfwxuh#wkhp#lqwr#il{hg0udwh/#530|hdu#ixoo|#dpruwl}lqj#pruwjdjhv#+lq#zklfk#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # sulqflsdo## lv## sdlg## ryhu## wkh## whup## ri## wkh## ordq,1## Wkh## orqj## pdwxulw|## dqg## wkh## ixoo|# dpruwl}lqj#sd|phqw# # # vwuxfwxuh## phdqw## wkdw## krphrzqhuv## zhuh## qrw## frqiurqwhg## zlwk# wkh## glvdvwurxv## uhilqdqflqj## sureohp1## Wkh## jryhuqphqw## zdv## zloolqj## wr## krog## wkhvh# pruwjdjhv## iru## d## zkloh/## exw#lw#glg# # # # qrw#vhh# # # lwvhoi#lq#wkh# # # # ordq#exvlqhvv# # # lq#wkh# # # orqj# whup#dqg#kdg#wr#ilqg#d# # # # # # # zd|#ri#pdnlqj#wkh# # # # # pruwjdjhv## sdodwdeoh## wr#sulydwh0vhfwru# # ohqghuv1#Sulydwh#ohqghuv/#klvwrulfdoo|#dyhuvh#wr#pdnlqj#orqj0whup#ordqv/#kdg#wr#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # shuvxdghg#wr#wuxvw#eruurzhuv1# # # # Wkh## vroxwlrq## zdv## wkdw## wkh## IKD## zrxog## ehdu## wkh## ghidxow## ulvn## e|## surylglqj# pruwjdjh#lqvxudqfhᄇhvvhqwldoo|#dvvxulqj#ohqghuv#wkdw#lw#zrxog#uhsd|#wkh#ordq#li# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## krphrzqhu## ghidxowhg1## Wkh## IKD## surwhfwhg## lwvhoi## e|## fkdujlqj## dq## lqvxudqfh# suhplxp/#vhwwlqj#vwulfw#olplwv#rq#wkh#pd{lpxp#ordq#lw#zrxog#ilqdqfh#+lqlwldoo|#;3# # # # # # # # # # # # # shufhqw#ri#wkh#surshuw|#ydoxh,/#dqg#wkh#dprxqw#ri#wkh#ordq#lw#zrxog#lqvxuh1#Wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhvwulfwlrq## dovr## hqvxuhg## wkdw## d## sulydwh## pdunhw## hphujhg## iru## wkh## pruwjdjhv/## ru# sruwlrqv#wkhuhri/#wkdw#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zrxog#qrw#lqvxuh1# # # # # # # # Wkxv#wkh#edqnv#dqg#wkh#wkuliwv#wkdw#erxjkw#IKD0lqvxuhg#pruwjdjhv#kdg#wr#ehdu# # # # # # # # # # # # # rqo|## wkh## lqwhuhvw0udwh## ulvnᄇwkh## ulvn## vwhpplqj## iurp## wkh## idfw## wkdw## wkh|## zhuh# ilqdqflqj## il{hg0udwh## orqj0whup## pruwjdjhv## zlwk## vkruw0whup/## hiihfwlyho|## yduldeoh0 udwh## ghsrvlwv1## Vr## orqj## dv## vkruw0whup#udwhv# # # glg## qrw## vslnh/## wklv## zdv## d## surilwdeoh# exvlqhvv1# Wkh## KROF## zdv## zrxqg## grzq#lq#4<691# # # # Wr## surylgh## d## ilqdqflqj#dowhuqdwlyh# # # wr# edqnv/## wkh## Ihghudo## Qdwlrqdo## Pruwjdjh## Dvvrfldwlrq## +IQPD/## odwhu## Idqqlh## Pdh,# zdv## vhw## xs## wr## gudz## sulydwh## orqj0whup#ilqdqflqj#lqwr# # # # wkh## pruwjdjh## pdunhw## rqfh# djdlq1## Hvvhqwldoo|/## IQPD#erxjkw#IKD0lqvxuhg# # # # pruwjdjhv## dqg#ilqdqfhg# # # wkhp#e|# # lvvxlqj#orqj0whup#erqgv#wr#lqyhvwruv#olnh#lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv#dqg#shqvlrq#ixqgv1# # # # # # # # # # # Xqolnh## wkh## edqnv## dqg## wkuliwv/## IQPD## kdg## orqjhu0whup## il{hg0udwh## ilqdqflqj## dqg# wkhuhiruh#glg#qrw#ehdu#pxfk#lqwhuhvw0udwh#ulvn#hyhq#li#lw#khog#wkh#pruwjdjhv#rq#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
errnv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#v|vwhp#zrunhg#zhoo#xqwlo#ulvlqj#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#lq#wkh#odwh#4<93v# # # # # # # # # # # fdxvhg#ghsrvlwv#wr#iorz#rxw#ri#edqnv#dqg#wkuliwvᄇehfdxvh#uhjxodwru|#ghsrvlwudwh# # # Ghsuhvvlrq#wr# # # suhyhqw#h{fhvvlyh# # # frpshwlwlrq#glg# # fhlolqjv## lqwurgxfhg## gxulqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#shuplw#wkhp#wr#pdwfk#wkh#kljkhu#pdunhw#lqwhuhvw#udwhv1#Ilqdqflqj#iru#pruwjdjhv# gulhg## xs1## Wr## frpshqvdwh/## wkh## jryhuqphqw## wulhg## wr## eulqj## pruh## gluhfw## ilqdqflqj# fdsdflw|## lqwr## wkh## pdunhw## e|## vsolwwlqj## Idqqlh## lqwr## wzr## lq## 4<9;ᄇfuhdwlqj## d# # # # # # # # # # Jryhuqphqw#Qdwlrqdo#Pruwjdjh#Dvvrfldwlrq#+JQPD#ru#Jlqqlh#Pdh,#wr#frqwlqxh# lqvxulqj/## sdfndjlqj/## dqg## vhfxulwl}lqj## pruwjdjhv/## dqg## d## qhz/## sulydwl}hg## Idqqlh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Pdh#wkdw#zrxog#ilqdqfh#pruwjdjhv#e|#lvvxlqj#erqgv#ru#vhfxulwl}hg#fodlpv#wr#wkh# # # O|qgrq#Mrkqvrq#qhhghg# # # # ixqgv## wr## sd|#iru# # # wkh# sxeolf1## Dw## d## wlph## zkhq#Suhvlghqw# # # sulydwl}dwlrq## frqyhqlhqwo|## uhpryhg## Idqqlh# jurzlqj## frvwv## ri## wkh## Ylhwqdp#Zdu/# Pdhᄊv## ghew## iurp## frxqwlqj## dv## d## jryhuqphqw## oldelolw|/## pdnlqj## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # edodqfh#vkhhw#orrn#d#orw#khdowklhu1#Vrrq#diwhu/#Iuhgglh#Pdf#+ru#wkh#Ihghudo#Krph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Ordq#Pruwjdjh#Frusrudwlrq/#wr#jr#e|#lwv#ixoo#qdph,#zdv#fuhdwhg#wr#khos#vhfxulwl}h# # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjhv#pdgh#e|#wkh#wkuliwv/#dqg#hyhqwxdoo|#lw#wrr#zdv#sulydwl}hg1# Dv## lqiodwlrq## urvh## lq## wkh## odwh## 4<:3v## dqg## hduo|## 4<;3v/## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh# # # rofnhu/#lqfuhdvhg#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wr#klwkhuwr#xqlpdjlqhg# # # # # # # # fkdlupdq/#Sdxo#Y # # # # # # # # # # sruwirolr#lqyhvwhg#lq#il{hg#orqj0whup# # # # # ohyhov#wr#wu|#wr#wdph#lw1#Zlwk#pxfk#ri#wkhlu# # # udwhv## zhuh## orz/## dqg## pxfk#ri# # # wkhlu# lqwhuhvw0udwh## pruwjdjhv/## pdgh## zkhq#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqflqj#wlhg#wr#vn|0kljk#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv/#wkh#vdylqjv#dqg#ordq#ru#wkuliw# lqgxvwu|## hvvhqwldoo|## zhqw## edqnuxsw1## Wkh## srolwlfdo## uhdfwlrq## zdv## qrw## wr## vkxw## wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkuliwv#grzq=#krxvlqj#zdv#wrr#lpsruwdqw/#wkh#lqgxvwu|#wrr#zhoo#frqqhfwhg/#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kroh#wkdw#wkh#wd{sd|hu#zrxog#kdyh#wr#iloo#wrr#hpeduudvvlqj#wr#rzq#xs#wr1# Lqvwhdg/## wkh## srolwlfdo## v|vwhp## uhdfwhg## zlwk## wkh## Ghsrvlwru|## Lqvwlwxwlrqv# Ghuhjxodwlrq## dqg## Prqhwdu|## Frqwuro## Dfw## ri## 4<;3## dqg## Jduq0Vw1## Jhupdlq# Ghsrvlwru|## Lqvwlwxwlrqv## Dfw## ri## 4<;5/## zklfk## olehudol}hg## wkh## udqjh## ri## ordqv## wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkuliwv#frxog#pdnh/#lqfoxglqj#pruwjdjhv/#dqg#wkh#zd|v#wkh|#frxog#eruurz/#wr#khos# wkh## lqgxvwu|## hduq## lwv## zd|## edfn## wr## vwdelolw|1## Wkh## vruu|## klvwru|## ri## hqvxlqj# ghyhorsphqwv/## lq## sduwlfxodu## wkh## lpphqvho|## ulvn|## dqg## xowlpdwho|## glvdvwurxv# # # # # # # # # # # # jdpeohv#wkdw#wkuliwv#wrrn#lq#frpphufldo#uhdo#hvwdwh/#edfnhg#zlwk#wd{sd|hu#prqh|/# 5;# kdv## ehhq## wrog## hovhzkhuh1 # D## vl}hdeoh## orvv## iru## wkuliwv## zdv## frqyhuwhg## lqwr## d# jljdqwlf#orvv#iru#wd{sd|huv/#dlghg#dqg#dehwwhg#e|#srolwlfldqv1#Vxiilfh#lw#wr#vd|#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dv#d#frqvhtxhqfh/#wkh#lqvxuhuv#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh/#udwkhu#wkdq#wkh#wkuliwv/#sod|hg# # # # # # # # # # # # # dq#lqfuhdvlqj#uroh#lq#pruwjdjh#ilqdqflqj1# # # # # #
Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh # # # Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh/## ydulrxvo|## nqrzq## dv## jryhuqphqw0vsrqvruhg## hqwhusulvhv# +JVHv,## ru## djhqflhv/## zhuh## fxulrxv## ehdvwv1## Wkh|## zhuh## qrw## txlwh## sulydwh/## wkrxjk# wkh|#kdg#sulydwh#vkduhkroghuv#wr#zkrp#wkhlu#surilwv#ehorqjhg1#Dqg#wkh|#fhuwdlqo|# # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh#qrw#sxeolf/#lq#wkdw#wkh|#zhuh#qrw#rzqhg#e|#wkh#jryhuqphqw/#exw#wkh|#kdg#erwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#ehqhilwv# # # dqg## sxeolf## gxwlhv1## Dprqj#wkhlu# # # shunv/## wkh|#zhuh# # # h{hpswhg# iurp## vwdwh## dqg## orfdo## lqfrph## wd{hv/## wkh|## kdg## jryhuqphqw## dssrlqwhhv## rq## wkhlu# erdugv/## dqg## wkh|#kdg# # # d## olqh## ri#fuhglw# # # iurp#wkh# # # X1V1## Wuhdvxu|1## Iru## wkh## lqyhvwlqj# sxeolf/#wkhvh#olqnv#wr#wkh#jryhuqphqw#lqglfdwhg#wkdw#wkh#ixoo#idlwk#dqg#fuhglw#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## vwrrg## ehklqg## wkhvh## rujdql}dwlrqv1## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh## frxog## wkxv# udlvh#prqh|#dw#d#frvw#wkdw#zdv#eduho|#deryh#wkh#udwh#sdlg#e|#wkh#Wuhdvxu|1#Wkhvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # shunv#fdph#zlwk#d#sxeolf#pdqgdwhᄇwr#vxssruw#krxvlqj#ilqdqfh1# # # # # # # # # Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh## glg## wzr## wklqjv## wr## ixoiloo## wkhlu## pdqgdwh1## Wkh|## erxjkw# pruwjdjhv#wkdw#frqiruphg#wr#fhuwdlq#vl}h#olplwv#dqg#fuhglw#vwdqgdugv#wkh|#kdg#vhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw/#wkxv#doorzlqj#wkh#edqnv#wkh|#erxjkw#iurp#wr#jr#rxw#dqg#pdnh#pruh#pruwjdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ordqv1#Wkh#djhqflhv#wkhq#sdfndjhg#srrov#ri#ordqv#wrjhwkhu#dqg#lvvxhg#pruwjdjh0 # # # # # # # # # # # edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## djdlqvw## wkh## sdfndjh## diwhu## jxdudqwhhlqj## wkh## pruwjdjhv## djdlqvw# ghidxow1## Wkh|## dovr## vwduwhg## eruurzlqj## gluhfwo|## iurp#wkh# # # pdunhw## dqg## lqyhvwlqj## lq# pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#xqghuzulwwhq#e|#rwkhu# # # # # # edqnv1#Ehfdxvh#wkh#pruwjdjhv# # # # zhuh#vrxqg/#wkhvh#zhuh#idluo|#vdih#dqg#h{wuhpho|#surilwdeoh#dfwlylwlhv1#Exw#pxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#surilw#vwhpphg#iurp#wkhlu#orz#frvw#ri#ilqdqflqj/#ghulylqj#iurp#wkh#lpsolflw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#jxdudqwhh/#dqg#wklv#zdv#d#fulwlfdo#srolwlfdo#yxoqhudelolw|1# # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Diirugdeoh0Krxvlqj#Pdqgdwh # # # Dv#hylghqfh#prxqwhg#lq#wkh#hduo|#4<<3v#wkdw#pruh#dqg#pruh#Dphulfdqv#idfhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vwdjqdqw## ru## ghfolqlqj## lqfrphv/## wkh## srolwlfdo## hvwdeolvkphqw## vwduwhg## orrnlqj## iru# zd|v## wr## khos## wkhp## zlwk## idvw0dfwlqj## phdvxuhvᄇfhuwdlqo|## idvwhu## wkdq## hgxfdwlrq# uhirup/## zklfk## zrxog## wdnh## ghfdghv## wr## surgxfh## uhvxowv1## Diirugdeoh## krxvlqj## iru# orz0lqfrph## jurxsv## zdv## wkh## reylrxv## dqvzhu/## dqg## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh## zhuh## wkh# reylrxv#fkdqqhov1#Frqjuhvv#nqhz#lw#frxog#xvh#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh#dv#yhklfohv#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv## ghvljqv## ehfdxvh## wkh|#ehqhilwhg#vr#pxfk#iurp#jryhuqphqw#odujhvvh/#dqg#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # pdqdjhuvᄊ## dupv## frxog## eh## wzlvwhg## zlwkrxw## dq|## ri## wkh## djhqflhvᄊ## dfwlylwlhv# lqfrqyhqlhqwo|#vkrzlqj#xs#dv#dq#h{shqglwxuh#lq#jryhuqphqw#exgjhwv1# # # # # # # # # Lq#4<<5/#wkh#X1V1#Frqjuhvv#sdvvhg#wkh#Ihghudo#Krxvlqj#Hqwhusulvh#Vdihw|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # Vrxqgqhvv## Dfw/## sduwo|## wr## uhirup## wkh## uhjxodwlrq## ri## wkh## djhqflhv## dqg## sduwo|## wr# surprwh#krphrzqhuvkls#iru#orz0lqfrph#dqg#plqrulw|#jurxsv#h{solflwo|1#Wkh#dfw# # # # # # # # # # lqvwuxfwhg#wkh#Ghsduwphqw#ri#Krxvlqj#dqg#Xuedq#Ghyhorsphqw#+KXG,#wr#ghyhors# # # # # # # # # # # diirugdeoh0krxvlqj#jrdov# # # iru## wkh## djhqflhv## dqg## wr## prqlwru## surjuhvv## wrzdug## wkhvh# jrdov1#Zkhqhyhu#Frqjuhvv#lqfoxghv#wkh#zrugv#vdihw|#dqg#vrxqgqhvv#lq#dq|#eloo/# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuh#lv#d#glvwlqfw#srvvlelolw|#wkdw#lw#zloo#dfklhyh#h{dfwo|#wkh#rssrvlwh/#dqg#wkdw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # suhflvho|#zkdw#wklv#slhfh#ri#ohjlvodwlrq#glg1# # # # # # # Hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh#djhqflhv#frxog#qrw#khdg#rii#ohjlvodwlrq/#wkh|#frxog#vkdsh#lw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## dgydqwdjh1## Wkh|## hqvxuhg## wkdw## wkh## ohjlvodwlrq## doorzhg## wkhp## wr## krog## ohvv# fdslwdo#wkdq#rwkhu#uhjxodwhg#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#dqg#wkdw#wkhlu#qhz# # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwru/#dq# # riilfh## zlwklq## KXGᄇzklfk## lwvhoi## kdg## qr## h{shulhqfh## lq## ilqdqfldo0vhuylfhv# uhjxodwlrqᄇzdv#vxemhfw#wr#frqjuhvvlrqdo# # # # # dssursuldwlrq15<## Wklv## phdqw#wkdw#li#wkh# # # # uhjxodwru#dfwxdoo|#vwduwhg#frqvwudlqlqj#wkh#ehkdylru#ri#wkh#djhqflhv/#wkh#djhqflhvᄊ# # # # # # # # # # # iulhqgv## lq## Frqjuhvv## frxog## fxw## wkh## uhjxodwru#ᄊv## exgjhw1## Wkh## frpelqdwlrq## ri## dq# dfwlylvw#Frqjuhvv/# # # jryhuqphqw0vxssruwhg## sulydwh## ilupv## kxqju|#iru# # # surilwv/## dqg## d# zhdn#dqg#soldqw#uhjxodwru#suryhg#glvdvwurxv1# # # # # # Dw#iluvw#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh#zhuh#qrw#hdjhu#wr#sxw#wkhlu#surilwdeoh#iudqfklvh#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn1#Exw#vhhlqj#wkh#srolwlfdo#zulwlqj#rq#wkh#zdoo/#wkh|#frpsolhg1#Vwhyhq#Krophv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # d#uhsruwhu#iru#wkh#Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#riihuhg#d#suhvflhqw#zduqlqj#lq#wkh#4<<3v=#ᄈLq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # prylqj/#hyhq#whqwdwlyho|/#lqwr#wklv#qhz# # # # # # # duhd#ri#ohqglqj/#Idqqlh#Pdh#lv#wdnlqj#rq# # # # # # # # vljqlilfdqwo|## pruh## ulvn/## zklfk## pd|## qrw## srvh## dq|## gliilfxow|## lq## ioxvk## hfrqrplf# wlphvᆱ1## Exw## wkh## jryhuqphqw## vsrqvruhg## hqwlw|## pd|## uxq## lqwr## wurxeoh## lq## dq# hfrqrplf#grzqwxuq/#surpswlqj#d#jryhuqphqw#uhvfxh#vlplodu#wr#wkdw#ri#wkh#Vdylqjv# # # # # # # # # # # # 63# dqg## Ordq#lqgxvwu|#lq#wkh# # # # # 4<;3v1ᄡ # Dv## krxvlqj#errphg/# # # wkh## djhqflhv## irxqg## wkh# kljk#udwhv#dydlodeoh#rq#orz0lqfrph#ohqglqj#sduwlfxoduo|#dwwudfwlyh/#dqg#wkh#ehqljq# # # # # # # # # # # hqylurqphqw## dqg## wkh## odfn## ri## klvwrulfdo## h{shulhqfh## zlwk## orz0lqfrph## ohqglqj# doorzhg#wkhp#wr#ljqruh#wkh#dgglwlrqdo#ulvn1# # # # # # # Xqghu## wkh## Folqwrq## dgplqlvwudwlrq/## KXG## vwhdglo|## lqfuhdvhg## wkh## dprxqw## ri# ixqglqj#lw#uhtxluhg#wkh#djhqflhv#wr#doorfdwh#wr#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj1#Wkh#djhqflhv# # # # # # # # # # # # frpsolhg/#doprvw#wrr#hdjhuo|=# # # # # vrphwlphv#lw#dsshduhg#dv#li#wkh|#zhuh#hjjlqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # dgplqlvwudwlrq#rq#wr#lqfuhdvh#wkhlu#pdqgdwh#vr#wkdw#wkh|#zrxog#eh#deoh#wr#mxvwli|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#kljkhu#ulvn#wdnlqj#+dqg#qrw#frlqflghqwdoo|/#pdqdjhphqwᄊv#kljkhu#erqxvhv,#wr# # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## vkduhkroghuv1## Diwhu## ehlqj#vhw#lqlwldoo|#dw#75# # # # # # shufhqw#ri#dvvhwv# # # # lq#4<<8/# # # wkh#
pdqgdwh## iru## orz0lqfrph## ohqglqj#zdv# # # lqfuhdvhg#wr#83#shufhqw#ri#dvvhwv# # # # # # # lq#5333# # +lq#wkh#odvw#|hdu#ri#wkh#Folqwrq#dgplqlvwudwlrq,1# # # # # # # # Vrph## fulwlfv## zruulhg## wkdw#wkh# # # djhqflhv## zhuh## wxuqlqj#d# # # eolqg## h|h## wr## suhgdwru|# ohqglqj## wr## wkrvh## zkr## frxog## qrw## diirug## d## pruwjdjh1## Exw## uhiohfwlqj## wkh## qh{xv# ehwzhhq#wkh#uhjxodwru#dqg#wkh#uhjxodwhg/#KXG#dfnqrzohgjhg#lq#d#uhsruw#lq#5333# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh#djhqflhv#ᄈremhfwhgᄡ#wr#glvforvxuh#uhtxluhphqwv#ᄈuhodwhg#wr#wkhlu#sxufkdvh# # # # # # # # # # # ri#kljk0frvw#pruwjdjhv/ᄡ#vr#KXG#ghflghg#djdlqvw#lpsrvlqj#ᄈdq#dgglwlrqdo#xqgxh# # # # # # # # # # # 64# exughqᄡ$
Wkh#Qdwlrqdo#Krphrzqhuvkls#Vwudwhj| # # # # Frqjuhvv#zdv#mrlqhg#e|#wkh#Folqwrq#dgplqlvwudwlrq#lq#lwv#hiiruwv1#Lq#4<<8/#lq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # suhdpeoh## wr## d## grfxphqw## od|lqj## rxw## d## vwudwhj|## wr## h{sdqg## krph## rzqhuvkls/# Suhvlghqw## Folqwrq## zurwh=## ᄈWklv## sdvw## |hdu/## L## gluhfwhg## KXG## Vhfuhwdu|## Khqu|## J1# Flvqhurv#ᆱ#wr#ghyhors#d#sodq#wr#errvw#krphrzqhuvkls#lq#Dphulfd#wr#dq#doowlph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kljk#e|#wkh#hqg#ri#wklv#fhqwxu|ᆱ1#H{sdqglqj#krphrzqhuvkls#zloo#vwuhqjwkhq#rxu# # # # # # # # # # # # qdwlrqᄊv## idplolhv## dqg## frppxqlwlhv/## vwuhqjwkhq## rxu## hfrqrp|/## dqg## h{sdqg## wklv# frxqwu|ᄊv## juhdw## plggoh## fodvv1## Uhnlqgolqj## wkh## guhdp## ri## krphrzqhuvkls## iru# Dphulfdᄊv## zrunlqj## idplolhv## fdq## suhsduh## rxu## qdwlrq## wr## hpeudfh## wkh## ulfk# srvvlelolwlhv## ri## wkh## wzhqw|0iluvw## fhqwxu|1ᄡ## Zkdw## glg## wklv## phdq## lq## sudfwlfhB## Wkh# vwudwhj|#grfxphqw#zhqw#rq#wr# # # # # # vd|=## ᄈIru## pdq|#srwhqwldo# # # krphex|huv/## wkh## odfn#ri# # fdvk#dydlodeoh#wr#dffxpxodwh#wkh#uhtxluhg#grzq#sd|phqw#dqg#forvlqj#frvwv#lv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdmru#lpshglphqw#wr#sxufkdvlqj#d#krph1#Rwkhu#krxvhkrogv#gr#qrw#kdyh#vxiilflhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # dydlodeoh#lqfrph#wr#pdnh#wkh#prqwko|#sd|phqwv#rq#pruwjdjhv#ilqdqfhg#dw#pdunhw# # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuhvw## udwhv## iru## vwdqgdug## ordq## whupv1## Ilqdqflqj## vwudwhjlhv/## ixhohg## e|## wkh# fuhdwlylw|#dqg#uhvrxufhv#ri#wkh#sulydwh#dqg#sxeolf#vhfwruv#^lwdolfv#plqh`/#vkrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # 65# dgguhvv#erwk#ri#wkhvh#ilqdqfldo#eduulhuv#wr#krphrzqhuvkls1ᄡ # # # # # # # Vlpso|## sxw/## wkh## Folqwrq## dgplqlvwudwlrq## zdv## dujxlqj## wkdw## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru# vkrxog## ilqg## fuhdwlyh## zd|v## ri## jhwwlqj## shrsoh## zkr## frxog## qrw## diirug## krphv## lqwr# wkhp/#dqg#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zrxog#khos#ru#sxvk#zkhuhyhu#lw#frxog1#Dowkrxjk#wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv## vrph## glvwdqfh## ehwzhhq#wklv# # # vwudwhj|#dqg# # # wkh## QLQMD#ordqv# # # dqg## ᄈolduᄡ## ordqv# +ordqv#iru#zklfk#eruurzhuv#frxog#frph#xs#zlwk#fuhdwlyh#uhsuhvhqwdwlrqv#ri#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # lqfrph#ehfdxvh#qr#grfxphqwdwlrq#zdv#uhtxluhg,#wkdw#ihdwxuhg#vr#surplqhqwo|#lq# # # # # # # # # # # wklv#fulvlv/#wkh#frxuvh#zdv#vhw1# # # # # # Wkh## Folqwrq## dgplqlvwudwlrq## sxvkhg## kdug## lq## rwkhu## zd|v1## Wkh## Frppxqlw|# Uhlqyhvwphqw## Dfw## +FUD,## sdvvhg## lq#4<::# # # uhtxluhg## edqnv## wr## ohqg## lq#wkhlu# # # orfdo# pdunhwv/#hvshfldoo|#lq#orzhu0lqfrph/#suhgrplqdqwo|#plqrulw|#duhdv1#Exw#FUD#glg# # # # # # # # # # qrw## vhw## h{solflw## ohqglqj## jrdov/## dqg## lwv## hqirufhphqw## zdv## ohiw## wr## uhjxodwruv1## Wkh# Folqwrq## dgplqlvwudwlrq## lqfuhdvhg## wkh## suhvvxuh## rq## uhjxodwruv## wr## hqirufh## FUD# wkurxjk## lqyhvwljdwlrqv## ri## edqnv## dqg## wkuhdwv## ri## ilqhv166## D#fduhixo# # # vwxg|## ri## edqn# pruwjdjh#ohqglqj#vkrzv#wkdw#ohqglqj#zhqw#xs#dv#FUD#hqirufhphqw#lqfuhdvhg#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#4<<3v/#hvshfldoo|#lq#wkh#kljko|#ylvleoh#dqg#srolwlfdoo|#vhqvlwlyh#phwursrolwdq# # # # # # # # # # # 67# duhdv#zkhuh#edqnv#zhuh#prvw#olnho|#wr#eh#vfuxwlql}hg1 # # # # # # # # Uhfdoo## dovr#wkdw#wkh# # # # Ihghudo## Krxvlqj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq#jxdudqwhhg#pruwjdjhv1#Lw# # # # # w|slfdoo|#irfxvhg#rq#ulvnlhu#pruwjdjhv#wkdw#wkh#djhqflhv#zhuh#uhoxfwdqw#wr#wrxfk1# # # # # # # # # # # # Khuh## zdv## d## yhklfoh## wkdw## zdv## gluhfwo|## xqghu## srolwlfdo## frqwuro/## dqg## lw## zdv## ixoo|# xwlol}hg1#Lq#5333/#wkh#Folqwrq#dgplqlvwudwlrq#gudpdwlfdoo|#fxw#wkh#plqlpxp#grzq# # # # # # # # # # # sd|phqw#uhtxluhg# # # iru## d## eruurzhu## wr## txdoli|#iru# # # dq#IKD#jxdudqwhh# # # # wr## 6## shufhqw/# lqfuhdvhg## wkh## pd{lpxp## vl}h## ri## pruwjdjh## lw## zrxog## jxdudqwhh/## dqg## kdoyhg## wkh# suhplxpv#lw#fkdujhg#eruurzhuv#iru#wkh#jxdudqwhh1#Doo#wkhvh#dfwlrqv#vhw#wkh#vwdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # iru#d#errp#lq#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj#frqvwuxfwlrq#dqg#ohqglqj1# # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Rzqhuvkls#Vrflhw| # # # Wkh#krxvlqj#errp#fdph#wr#iuxlwlrq#lq#wkh#dgplqlvwudwlrq#ri#Jhrujh#Z1#Exvk/# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkr## dovr## uhfrjql}hg## wkh## gdqjhuv## ri## vljqlilfdqw## vhjphqwv## ri## wkh## srsxodwlrq## qrw# sduwlflsdwlqj#lq#wkh#ehqhilwv#ri#jurzwk1#Dv#kh#sxw#lw=#ᄈLi#|rx#rzq#vrphwklqj/#|rx# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## d## ylwdo## vwdnh## lq#wkh# # # ixwxuh## ri#rxu# # # frxqwu|1## Wkh## pruh## rzqhuvkls## wkhuh## lv## lq# Dphulfd/#wkh#pruh#ylwdolw|#wkhuh#lv#lq#Dphulfd/#dqg#wkh#pruh#shrsoh#kdyh#d#ylwdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 68# vwdnh#lq#wkh#ixwxuh#ri#wklv#frxqwu|1ᄡ # # # # # # #Lq#d#5335#vshhfk#wr#KXG/#Exvk#vdlg=# # # # # # # # Exw## L## eholhyh## rzqlqj## vrphwklqj## lv## d## sduw## ri## wkh## Dphulfdq## Guhdp/## dv# zhoo1#L#eholhyh#zkhq#vrpherg|#rzqv#wkhlu#rzq#krph/#wkh|ᄊuh#uhdol}lqj#wkh# ## # # # # # # # # # Dphulfdq#Guhdpᆱ1#Dqg#zh#vdz#wkdw#|hvwhugd|#lq#Dwodqwd/#zkhq#zh#zhqw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#qhz#krphv#ri#wkh#qhz#krphrzqhuv1#Dqg#L#vdz#zlwk#sulgh#iluvwkdqg/#wkh# # # # # # # # ## # # # # pdq## vd|/## zhofrph## wr## p|## krph1## Kh## glgqᄊw## vd|/## zhofrph## wr## jryhuqphqwᄊv# krph>#kh#glgqᄊw#vd|/#zhofrph#wr#p|#qhljkeru# # # # # # # # ᄊv#krph>#kh#vdlg/#zhofrph#wr# # # # # # p|## krph1## ᆱKh## zdv## d## surxg## pdqᆱ1## Dqg## L## zdqw## wkdw## sulgh## wr## h{whqg## doo# 69# wkurxjkrxw#rxu#frxqwu|1 # # # Odwhu/#h{sodlqlqj#krz#klv#dgplqlvwudwlrq#zrxog#jr#derxw#dfklhylqj#lwv#jrdov/# # # # # # # # # # # kh## vdlg=## ᄈDqg## Lᄊp#surxg# # # wr## uhsruw#wkdw#Idqqlh# # # # Pdh## kdv## khdug## wkh## fdoo## dqg/## dv## L# xqghuvwdqg/## lwᄊv## derxw## '773## eloolrq## ryhu## d## shulrg## ri## wlph1## Wkh|ᄊyh## xvhg## wkhlu# lqioxhqfh#wr#fuhdwh#wkdw#pxfk#fdslwdo#dydlodeoh#iru#wkh#w|sh#ri#krph#ex|hu#zhᄊuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdonlqj#derxw#khuh1#Lwᄊv#lq#wkhlu#fkduwhu>#lw#qrz#qhhgv#wr#eh#lpsohphqwhg1#Iuhgglh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Pdf## lv## lqwhuhvwhg## lq#khoslqj1# # # L#dssuhfldwh# # # erwk#ri#wkrvh# # # # djhqflhv## surylglqj#wkh# # 6:# xqghuslqqlqjv#ri#jrrg#fdslwdo1ᄡ # # # Wkh#Exvk#dgplqlvwudwlrq#sxvkhg#xs#wkh#orz0lqfrph#ohqglqj#pdqgdwh#rq#Idqqlh# # # # # # # # # # # dqg## Iuhgglh## wr## 89## shufhqw## ri## wkhlu## dvvhwv## lq## 5337/## hyhq## dv## wkh## Ihg## vwduwhg# lqfuhdvlqj#lqwhuhvw# # # udwhv## dqg## h{suhvvlqj#zruulhv# # # derxw## wkh## krxvlqj#errp1# # # Shwhu# Zdoolvrq#ri#wkh#Dphulfdq#Hqwhusulvh#Lqvwlwxwh#dqg#Fkduohv#Fdorplulv#ri#Froxpeld# # # # # # # # # # # Xqlyhuvlw|#dujxh#wkdw#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh#pryhg#lqwr#hyhq#kljkhu#jhdu#dw#wklv#wlph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#vr#pxfk#ehfdxvh#ri#dowuxlvp/#exw#ehfdxvh#wkh#dffrxqwlqj#vfdqgdov# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#zhuh# # h{srvhg## lq#wkrvh# # # djhqflhv## lq#5337# # # pdgh## wkhp#pxfk#pruh# # # # soldqw## wr## Frqjuhvvᄊv# 6;# ghpdqgv#iru#pruh#orz0lqfrph#ohqglqj1 # # # # Krz#pxfk#ohqglqj#iorzhg#iurp#wkhvh#vrxufhv/#dqg#zkhqB#Lw#lv#qrw#hdv|#wr#jhw#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhqvh## ri#wkh# # # wuxh## pdjqlwxgh## ri#vxesulph# # # dqg## Dow0D#ohqglqj#e|#Idqqlh/# # # # # Iuhgglh/# dqg## wkh## IKD/## sduwo|#ehfdxvh# # # dv## Hgzdug## Slqwr/## d## iruphu## fklhi#fuhglw#riilfhu# # # # ri# Idqqlh## Pdh/## kdv## dujxhg/## pdq|## ordqv## rq## hdfk## ri## wkhvh## hqwlwlhvᄊ## errnv## zhuh# vxesulph## lq## qdwxuh## exw## qrw## fodvvlilhg## dv## vxfk16<## Iru## lqvwdqfh/## Idqqlh## Pdh# fodvvlilhg## d## ordq## dv## vxesulph## rqo|## li## wkh## ruljlqdwru## lwvhoi## vshfldol}hg## lq## wkh# vxesulph## exvlqhvv1## Pdq|## ulvn|## ordqv## wr## orz0fuhglw0txdolw|## eruurzhuv## wkxv# hvfdshg## fodvvlilfdwlrq## dv## vxesulph## ru## Dow0D## ordqv1## Zkhq## wkh## ordqv## duh# dssursuldwho|## fodvvlilhg/## Slqwr## ilqgv## wkdw## vxesulph## ohqglqj## dorqh## +lqfoxglqj# ilqdqflqj## wkurxjk## wkh## sxufkdvh## ri## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv,## e|## wkh## pruwjdjh# jldqwv## dqg## wkh## IKD#vwduwhg# # # dw## derxw## ';8## eloolrq## lq## 4<<:## dqg## zhqw## xs## wr## '779# eloolrq#lq#5336/#diwhu#zklfk#lw#vwdelol}hg#dw#ehwzhhq#'633#dqg#'733#eloolrq#d#|hdu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 73# xqwlo#533:/#wkh#odvw#|hdu#ri#klv#vwxg|1 # # # # # # # #Rq#dyhudjh/#wkhvh#hqwlwlhv#dffrxqwhg#iru#87# # # # # # #
shufhqw## ri## wkh## pdunhw## dfurvv## wkh## |hduv/## zlwk#d# # # kljk#ri# # # :3## shufhqw## lq#533:1# # # Kh# hvwlpdwhv## wkdw## lq## Mxqh## 533;/## wkh## pruwjdjh## jldqwv/## wkh## IKD/## dqg## ydulrxv## rwkhu# jryhuqphqw#surjudpv#zhuh#h{srvhg#wr#derxw#'51:#wuloolrq#lq#vxesulph#dqg#Dow0D# # # # # # # # # # # # ordqv/## dssur{lpdwho|## 8<## shufhqw## ri## wrwdo## ordqv## wr## wkhvh## fdwhjrulhv1## Lw## lv## yhu|# gliilfxow#wr#uhdfk#dq|#rwkhu#frqfoxvlrq#wkdq#wkdw#wklv#zdv#d#pdunhw#gulyhq#odujho|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|#jryhuqphqw/#ru#jryhuqphqw0lqioxhqfhg/#prqh|1# # # # #
Ohqglqj#Jrhv#Ehuvhun # # # Dv## pruh## prqh|## iurp## wkh## jryhuqphqw0vsrqvruhg## djhqflhv## iorrghg## lqwr# ilqdqflqj#ru# # # vxssruwlqj#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj/#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru# # # # # # # mrlqhg#wkh#sduw|1# # # Diwhu## doo/## wkh|## frxog## gr## wkh## pdwk/## dqg## wkh|## xqghuvwrrg## wkdw## wkh## srolwlfdo# frpsxovlrqv## ehklqg## jryhuqphqw## dfwlrqv## zrxog## qrw## glvdsshdu## txlfno|1## Zlwk# djhqf|## vxssruw/## vxesulph## pruwjdjhv## zrxog## eh## oltxlg/## dqg## orz0frvw## krxvlqj# zrxog#lqfuhdvh#lq#sulfh1#Orz#ulvn#dqg#kljk#uhwxuqᄇzkdw#pruh#frxog#wkh#sulydwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru## ghvluhB## Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkh## sulydwh## vhfwru/## dlghg## dqg## dehwwhg## e|## djhqf|# prqh|/#frqyhuwhg#wkh#jrrg#lqwhqwlrqv#ehklqg#wkh#diirugdeoh0krxvlqj#pdqgdwh#dqg# # # # # # # # # # wkh#sxvk#wr#dq#rzqhuvkls#vrflhw|#lqwr#d#ilqdqfldo#glvdvwhu1# # # # # # # # # # Erwk#Folqwrq#dqg# # # # Exvk#zhuh# # # uljkw#lq#zruu|lqj#wkdw#jurzwk#zdv# # # # # # # ohdylqj#odujh# # vhjphqwv## ri## wkh## srsxodwlrq## ehklqg/## dqg## wkhlu## vroxwlrqᄇh{sdqghg## krph# rzqhuvklsᄇzdv## d#uhdvrqdeoh#vkruw0whup#il{1#Wkh#sureohp#zlwk#xvlqj#wkh#pljkw# # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#lv#uduho|#rqh#ri#lqwhqw>#udwkhu/#lw#lv#wkdw#wkh#jds#ehwzhhq#lqwhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## rxwfrph## lv## riwhq#odujh/# # # w|slfdoo|#ehfdxvh# # # wkh## rujdql}dwlrqv## dqg## shrsoh## wkh# jryhuqphqw#xvhv#wr#dfklhyh#lwv# # # # # # dlpv#gr#qrw#vkduh#wkhp1#Wklv#ohvvrq#iurp#uhfhqw# # # # # # # # # klvwru|/## lqfoxglqj## wkh## vdylqjv## dqg## ordqv## fulvlv/## vkrxog## kdyh## ehhq## fohdu## wr## wkh# srolwlfldqv=## wkh## frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## suhvvlqj## dq## djloh## ilqdqfldo# vhfwru## wr## dfw#lq#fhuwdlq#zd|v# # # # # duh## riwhq#xqlqwhqghg# # # dqg## h{wuhpho|#frvwo|1# # # \hw#wkh# # srolwlfdo#ghpdqg#iru#dfwlrq/#dq|#dfwlrq/#wr#vdwlvi|#wkh#pxowlwxghv#zkr#eholhyh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw## kdv## doo## wkh## dqvzhuv/## lv## riwhq## lpsrvvleoh## iru## hyhq## wkh## vhqvleoh# srolwlfldq#wr#ghq|1# # # Dovr/## lw## lv## hdv|## wr## eh## f|qlfdo## derxw## srolwlfdo## prwlyhv## exw## kdug## wr## hvwdeolvk# lqwhqw/#hvshfldoo|#zkhq#wkh#lqwhqw#lv#vrphwklqj#wkh#dfwruv#zrxog#zdqw#wr#ghq|ᄇlq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wklv## fdvh/## srolwlfldqv## xvlqj## hdv|## krxvlqj## fuhglw## dv## d## sdooldwlyh1## Dv## L## dujxh# uhshdwhgo|#lq#wklv#errn/#lw#pd|#zhoo# # # # # # # # eh#wkdw#pdq|#ri#wkh#sduwv#sod|hg#e|#wkh#nh|# # # # # # # # # # dfwruv#zhuh#jxlghg#e|#wkh#suhihuhqfhv#dqg#dssodxvh#ri#wkh#dxglhqfh/#udwkhu#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # e|## zhoo0wkrxjkw0rxw## lqwhqw1## Hyhq## li## qr## srolwlfldqv## guhdphg## xs## d## Pdfkldyhooldq# sodq#wr#dvvxdjh#dq{lrxv#yrwhuv#zlwk#hdv|#ordqv/#wkhlu#dfwlrqvᄇdqg#wkhuh#lv#sohqw|# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#hylghqfh# # # wkdw#srolwlfldqv# # # sxvkhg## iru## hdvlhu## krxvlqj#fuhglwᄇfrxog# # # kdyh## ehhq# 74# jxlghg#e|#wkh#yrwhuv#wkh|#fduhg#derxw1 # # # # # # #Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/#srolwlfldqv#pd|#kdyh#wulhg# # # # # # gliihuhqw## phvvdjhv## xqwlo## rqh## uhvrqdwhg## zlwk## yrwhuv1## Wkdw## phvvdjhᄇsurplvlqj# diirugdeoh#krxvlqj/#iru#h{dpsohᄇehfdph#sduw#ri#wkhlu#sodwirup1#Lw#frxog#zhoo#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## yrwhuv## vkdshg## srolwlfdo## dfwlrq## +pxfk## dv## pdunhwv## vkdsh## frusrudwh## dfwlrq,# udwkhu## wkdq#wkh# # # rwkhu## zd|#durxqg1# # # Zkhwkhu## wkh## dfwlrq#zdv# # # gulyhq#e|#frqvflrxv# # # lqwhqw#ru#xqlqwhqwlrqdo#jxlgdqfh#lv#lppdwhuldo#wr#lwv#eurdghu#frqvhtxhqfhv1# # # # # # # # # # D#yhu|#lqwhuhvwlqj#vwxg|#e|#wzr#ri#p|#froohdjxhv#dw#wkh#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjrᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Errwk#Vfkrro/#Dwli#Pldq#dqg#Dplu#Vxil/#ghwdlov#wkh#frqvhtxhqfhv#lq#wkh#ohdg0xs# # # # # # # # # # # # # 75# wr#wkh#fulvlv1 # # # Wkh|#xvh#]LS#frghv#wr#lghqwli|#duhdv#wkdw#kdg#d#glvsursruwlrqdwho|# # # # # # # # # # # odujh## vkduh## ri#srwhqwldo# # # vxesulph## eruurzhuv## +eruurzhuv## zlwk#orz# # # lqfrphv## dqg# orz#fuhglw#udwlqjv,#dqg#vkrz#wkdw#wkhvh#]LS#frghv#h{shulhqfhg#fuhglw#jurzwk#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#shulrg#5335ᄆ5338#wkdw#zdv#pruh#wkdq#wzlfh#dv#kljk#dv#wkdw#lq#wkh#sulph#]LS# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frghv1## Pruh## lqwhuhvwlqj/## wkh## qxpehu## ri## pruwjdjhv## rewdlqhg## lq#d# # # ]LS#frgh# # # ryhu# wkdw#shulrg#lv#qhjdwlyho|# # # # # fruuhodwhg## zlwk#krxvhkrog# # # lqfrph## jurzwk=## wkdw#lv/# # # ]LS# frghv## zlwk#orzhu# # # lqfrph## jurzwk#uhfhlyhg# # # pruh## pruwjdjh## ordqv## lq#5335ᄆ5338/# #
wkh#rqo|#shulrg#ryhu#wkh#hqwluh#vsdq#ri#wkh#dxwkruvᄊ#vwxg|#lq#zklfk#wkh|#vdz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wklv# skhqrphqrq1#Wklv# # # ilqglqj#vkrxog#qrw#eh#vxusulvlqj#jlyhq#wkh#hduolhu# # # # # # # # # glvfxvvlrq=# wkhuh#zdv#d#jryhuqphqw0rufkhvwudwhg#dwwhpsw#wr#ohqg#wr#wkh#ohvv#zhoo0rii1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#juhdwhu#h{sdqvlrq#lq#pruwjdjh#ohqglqj#wr#vxesulph#]LS#frghv#lv#dvvrfldwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk## kljkhu## krxvh0sulfh## jurzwk## lq## wkrvh## ]LS## frghv1## Lqghhg/## ryhu## wkh## shulrg# 5335ᄆ5338## dqg## dfurvv## ]LS#frghv/# # # krxvh0sulfh## jurzwk#zdv# # # kljkhu## lq#duhdv# # # wkdw# kdg## orzhu## lqfrph## jurzwk## +ehfdxvh## wklv## lv## zkhuh## wkh## ohqglqj## zdv## irfxvhg,1# Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkhuhiruh/## doo## wklv## ohqglqj#zdv# # # gulylqj#krxvh# # # sulfhv## ixuwkhu## dzd|# iurp## wkh## ixqgdphqwdo## delolw|## ri## krxvhkrog## lqfrph## wr## vxssruw## uhsd|phqw1## Wkh# frqvhtxhqfh## ri## doo## wklv## ohqglqj## zdv## pruh## ghidxow1## Vxesulph## ]LS## frghv# h{shulhqfhg## dq#lqfuhdvh# # # lq#ghidxow#udwhv# # # # diwhu## 5339## wkdw#zdv# # # wkuhh## wlphv## wkdw#ri# # sulph## ]LS## frghv/## dqg## pxfk## odujhu## wkdq## wkh## ghidxow## udwhv## wkhvh## duhdv## kdg# h{shulhqfhg#lq#wkh#sdvw1# # # # Frxog## wkh## lqfuhdvhg## eruurzlqj#e|#orz0lqfrph# # # # krxvhkrogv## kdyh## ehhq#gulyhq# # e|## qhhgB## Diwhu## doo/## L## kdyh## dujxhg## wkdw## wkhlu## lqfrphv## zhuh## vwdjqdwlqj## ru## hyhq# idoolqj1#Lw#lv#kdug/#wkrxjk/#wr#lpdjlqh#wkdw#vwudsshg#krxvhkrogv#zrxog#jr#rxw#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eruurz## wr## ex|## krxvhv1## Wkh## eruurzlqj## zdv## qrw## gulyhq## e|## d## vxujh## lq## ghpdqg=# lqvwhdg## lw## fdph## iurp## d## juhdwhu## zloolqjqhvv## wr## vxsso|## fuhglw## wr## orz0lqfrph# krxvhkrogv/## wkh## lpshwxv## iru## zklfk## fdph## lq## vljqlilfdqw## phdvxuh## iurp## wkh# jryhuqphqw1# Qrw## doo## wkh## iuhq}lhg## ohqglqj#lq#wkh# # # # uxq0xs## wr## wkh## uhfhqw## fulvlv## zdv## uhodwhg## wr# orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj=#pdq|#xqyldeoh#ordqv#zhuh#pdgh#wr#odujh#frusrudwh#ex|rxwv# # # # # # # # # # # dovr1## Qhyhuwkhohvv/## vxesulph## ohqglqj## dqg## wkh## dvvrfldwhg## vxesulph## pruwjdjh0 edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#zhuh#fhqwudo#wr#wklv#fulvlv1#Zlwkrxw#dq|#lqwhqw#ri#devroylqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # eurnhuv## dqg## wkh## edqnv## zkr## ruljlqdwhg## wkh## edg## ordqv## ru## wkh## eruurzhuv## zkr## olhg# derxw## wkhlu## lqfrphv/## zh## vkrxog## dfnqrzohgjh## wkh## hylghqfh## vxjjhvwlqj## wkdw# jryhuqphqw## dfwlrqv/## krzhyhu## zhoo## lqwhqghg/## frqwulexwhg## vljqlilfdqwo|## wr## wkh# fulvlv1## Dqg## wkh## djhqflhv## glg## qrw## hvfdsh## wkh## idoorxw1## Zlwk## wkh## orvvhv## rq## wkh# djhqflhvᄊ## pruwjdjh## sruwirolrv## jurzlqj## dqg## klqwv## wkdw## lqyhvwruv## lq## djhqf|## ghew# zhuh#jhwwlqj#zruulhg/#rq#Vxqgd|/#Vhswhpehu#:/#533;/#Khqu|#M1#Sdxovrq/#vhfuhwdu|# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#wuhdvxu|/#dqqrxqfhg#zkdw#wkh#pdunhw#kdg#dozd|v#dvvxphg=#wkh#jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#wdnh#frqwuro#ri#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh#dqg#hiihfwlyho|#vwdqg#ehklqg#wkhlu#ghew1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Frqvhuydwlyh## hvwlpdwhv## ri## wkh## frvwv## wr## wkh## wd{sd|hu## ri## edlolqj#rxw# # # wkh## djhqflhv# dprxqw## wr## kxqguhgv## ri## eloolrqv## ri## grooduv1## Pruhryhu/## kdylqj## wdnhq## ryhu## wkh# djhqflhv/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#ixoo|#rzqhg#wkh#krxvlqj#sureohp1#Hyhq#dv#L#zulwh/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # ## # jryhuqphqw0frqwuroohg## djhqflhv## duh## lqfuhdvlqj## wkhlu## h{srvxuh## wr## wkh## krxvlqj# pdunhw/#dwwhpswlqj#wr#surs#xs#sulfhv#dw#xquhdolvwlf#ohyhov/#zklfk#zloo#phdq#kljkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # frvwv#wr#wkh#wd{sd|hu#grzq#wkh#olqh1# # # # # # # Wkh## djhqflhv## duh## qrw## wkh## rqo|## jryhuqphqw0uhodwhg## rujdql}dwlrqv## wr## kdyh# sureohpv1#Dv#wkh#fulvlv#zruvhqhg#lq#533:#dqg#533;/#wkh#IKD#dovr#frqwlqxhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jxdudqwhh#ordqv#wr#orz0lqfrph#eruurzhuv1#Gholqtxhqf|#udwhv#rq#wkrvh#pruwjdjhv# # # # # # # # # # 76# # Lw#lv# # # shukdsv## xqghuvwdqgdeoh## +wkrxjk#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|# # # h{fhhg## 53## shufhqw#wrgd|1 # zlvh,#wkdw#jryhuqphqw#ghsduwphqwv#zloo#dwwhpsw#wr#vxssruw#ohqglqj#lq#edg#wlphv/# # # # # # # # # # # # dv#wkh|#sod|#d#frxqwhuf|folfdo#uroh1#Dv#Shwhu#Zdoolvrq#ri#wkh#Dphulfdq#Hqwhusulvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Lqvwlwxwh## kdv## srlqwhg## rxw/## lw## lv## ohvv## xqghuvwdqgdeoh## zk|## wkh## IKD## dgghg## wr## wkh# vxesulph#iuhq}|#lq#5338#dqg#5339/#wkxv#h{dfhuedwlqj#wkh#errp#dqg#wkh#hyhqwxdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # idoo177## Gholqtxhqflhv## rq#jxdudqwhhg# # # ordqv## riihuhg## wkhq#dovr# # # h{fhhg## 53## shufhqw1#
Wkh#IKD#zloo#olnho|#qhhg#wd{sd|hu#dvvlvwdqfh1#Wkh#ryhudoo#frvw#wr#wkh#wd{sd|hu#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw## dwwhpswv## wr## lqfuhdvh## orz0lqfrph## ohqglqj## frqwlqxh## wr## prxqw## dqg# shukdsv#zloo#qhyhu#eh#ixoo|#wdoolhg#xs1# # # # # # #
Lqwhuhvwlqj#Gliihuhqfhv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv # # # # # # Dv#krxvh#sulfhv#urvh#ehwzhhq#4<<<#dqg#533:/#krxvhkrogv#eruurzhg#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#krph#htxlw|#wkh|#kdg#exlow#xs1#Wkh#h{whqw#ri#vxfk#eruurzlqj#zdv#vr#juhdw#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#glvwulexwlrq#ri#ordq0wr0ydoxh#udwlrv#ri#h{lvwlqj#pruwjdjhv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # 78# eduho|#exgjhg#ryhu#wklv#shulrg/#ghvslwh#grxeoh0gljlw#lqfuhdvhv#lq#krxvh#sulfhv1 # # # # # # # # # # Krxvh0sulfh## dssuhfldwlrq## dovr## hqdeohg## orz0lqfrph## krxvhkrogv## wr## rewdlq## rwkhu# irupv#ri#qrqpruwjdjh#fuhglw1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#dffruglqj#wr#wkh#Vxuyh|#ri#Frqvxphu# # # # # # # # # # # # Ilqdqfhv#frqgxfwhg#e|#wkh#Ihghudo# # # # # # Uhvhuyh#Erdug/#ehwzhhq#4<;<#dqg#5337#wkh# # # # # # # iudfwlrq## ri## orz0lqfrph## idplolhv## +idplolhv## lq## wkh## erwwrp## txduwloh## ri## lqfrph# glvwulexwlrq,#wkdw#kdg#pruwjdjhv#rxwvwdqglqj#grxeohg/#zkloh#wkrvh#wkdw#kdg#fuhglw# # # # # # # # # # # fdug## ghew## rxwvwdqglqj## juhz## e|## :8## shufhqw179## E|## frqwudvw/## wkh## iudfwlrq## ri## kljk0 lqfrph## idplolhv## +idplolhv## lq## wkh## wrs## txduwloh## ri## lqfrph## glvwulexwlrq,## wkdw## kdg# pruwjdjhv#ru#fuhglw#fdug#ghew#rxwvwdqglqj#ihoo#voljkwo|#ryhu#wklv#shulrg/#vxjjhvwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh#udslg#vsuhdg#ri#lqghewhgqhvv#zdv#frqfhqwudwhg#lq#srruhu#vhjphqwv#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # srsxodwlrq1# Lqghhg/## dowkrxjk#krxvlqj#errpv# # # # wrrn#sodfh# # # durxqg## wkh## zruog/## gulyhq#e|#orz# # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv/# # # wkh## errp#lq#wkh# # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv## hvshfldoo|#surqrxqfhg# # # dprqj# eruurzhuv#zkr#kdg#qrw#kdg#sulru#hdv|#dffhvv#wr#fuhglw/#wkh#vxesulph#dqg#Dow0D# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhjphqwv## ri## wkh## pdunhw1## Ghwdlohg## vwxglhv## lqglfdwh## wkdw## wklv## krxvlqj## errp## zdv# gliihuhqw#ehfdxvh#krxvh#sulfhv#iru#wkh#orz0lqfrph#vhjphqw#ri#wkh#srsxodwlrq#urvh# # # # # # # # # # # # e|#pruh#dqg#ihoo#e|#pruh#wkdq#wkh|#glg#iru#wkh#kljk0lqfrph#vhjphqwv1#E|#frqwudvw/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#suhylrxv#X1V1#krxvlqj#errpv/#krxvh#sulfhv#iru#wkh#kljk0lqfrph#vhjphqw#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # dozd|v## pruh## yrodwloh## wkdq## iru## wkh## orz0lqfrph## vhjphqw17:## Uhodwlyh## wr## rwkhu# lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#olnh#Luhodqg/#Vsdlq/#dqg#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp/#doo#ri#zklfk#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvh0sulfh#errpv#wkdw#wxuqhg#wr#exvwv/#X1V1#krxvh#sulfhv#ryhudoo#zhuh#qrzkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # 7;## Exw#wkh#errp#zdv#frqfhqwudwhg#lq#wkrvh#ohdvw# dv#kljk#uhodwlyh#wr#ixqgdphqwdov1 # # # # # # # # # # # deoh#wr#diirug#wkh#exvw1#Wkh#X1V1#errp#zdv#gliihuhqw/#dw#ohdvw#lq#lwv#ghwdlov1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vrph## surjuhvvlyh## hfrqrplvwv## glvsxwh## zkhwkhu## wkh## uhfhqw## fulvlv## zdv## dw## doo# 7<## Wklv#fhuwdlqo|# uhodwhg#wr#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#lq#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj#fuhglw1 # # # # # # # # zdv## qrw#wkh# # # rqo|#idfwru# # # dw#sod|/#dqg#wr#dujxh# # # # # # wkdw#lw#zdv# # # # lv## plvohdglqj1#Exw#lw#lv# # # # htxdoo|#plvohdglqj#wr#vd|#lw#sod|hg#qr#sduw1#Wkh#sulydwh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru#glg#qrw# # # vxgghqo|## wdnh## xs## orz0lqfrph## krxvlqj## ordqv## lq## wkh## hduo|## 5333v## rxw## ri## wkh# jrrgqhvv#ri#lwv#khduw/#ru#ehfdxvh#ilqdqfldo#lqqrydwlrq#shuplwwhg#lw#wr#gr#vrᄇdiwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # doo/#vhfxulwl}dwlrq#kdv#ehhq#durxqg#iru#d#orqj#wlph1#Wr#ljqruh#wkh#uroh#sod|hg#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfldqv/## wkh## jryhuqphqw/## dqg## wkh## txdvl0jryhuqphqw#djhqflhv# # # lv## wr## ljqruh## wkh# hohskdqw#lq#wkh#urrp1# # # # L#kdyh# # # dujxhg## wkdw#dq#lpsruwdqw#srolwlfdo# # # # # uhvsrqvh## wr## lqhtxdolw|#zdv# # # srsxolvw# fuhglw#h{sdqvlrq/#zklfk#doorzhg#shrsoh# # # # # # wkh## frqvxpswlrq#srvvlelolwlhv# # # wkdw#wkhlu# # vwdjqdqw## lqfrphv## rwkhuzlvh## frxog## qrw## vxssruw1## Wkhuh## zhuh## fohduo|## vshfldo# flufxpvwdqfhv## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## wkdw## pdgh## wklv## uhvsrqvh## pruh## olnho|ᄇlq# sduwlfxodu/## wkh## pdq|## frqwurov## wkh## jryhuqphqw## kdg## ryhu## krxvlqj## ilqdqfh## dqg## wkh# gliilfxow|/## jlyhq## wkh## lqfuhdvlqj## srodul}dwlrq## ri## X1V1## srolwlfv/## ri## hqdfwlqj## gluhfw# lqfrph## uhglvwulexwlrq1## Pruhryhu/## wkh## remhfwlyh## ri## h{sdqglqj## krph## rzqhuvkls# guhz## rq#wkh# # # srolwlfdoo|#shuvxdvlyh# # # klvwrulfdo## v|perolvp#ri#vpdoo# # # # hqwuhsuhqhxuv#
dqg#iduphuv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#doo#rzqlqj#wkhlu#surshuw|#dqg#kdylqj#d#vwdnh#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vrflhw|#dqg#surjuhvv1#Wkhvh#vshflilf#flufxpvwdqfhv#zrxog#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|#dsso|# # # # # # # # # # lq#rwkhu#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv1# # # # Wkdw## vdlg/## wkhuh## duh## d## qxpehu## ri## sdudoohov/## erwk## lq## X1V1## klvwru|## dqg## lq## wkh# frqwhpsrudu|#h{shulhqfh#ri#hphujlqj#pdunhwv/#iru#wkh#xvh#ri#fuhglw#dv#d#srsxolvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # sdooldwlyh1## D## suhylrxv## hslvrgh## ri## kljk## lqfrph## lqhtxdolw|## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# fdph#wrzdug#wkh#hqg#ri#wkh#qlqhwhhqwk#fhqwxu|#dqg#wkh#ehjlqqlqj#ri#wkh#wzhqwlhwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fhqwxu|1## Dv## vpdoo## dqg## phglxp0vl}hg## iduphuv## shufhlyhg## wkdw## wkh|## zhuh## idoolqj# ehklqg/## wkhlu## julhydqfhv## derxw## wkh## odfn## ri## dffhvv## wr## fuhglw## dqg## wkh## qhhg## iru# edqnlqj## uhirupv## zhuh## duwlfxodwhg## e|## wkh## Srsxolvw## Sduw|1## Suhvvxuh## iurp## vxfk# txduwhuv#khoshg#dffhohudwh#wkh#ghuhjxodwlrq#ri#edqnlqj#dqg#wkh#h{sorvlrq#ri#edqnv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#hduo|#sduw#ri#wkh#wzhqwlhwk#fhqwxu|1#Lqghhg/#lq#Qruwk#Gdnrwd/#diwhu#d#Srsxolvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdqglgdwh#zrq#wkh#4<49#jxehuqdwruldo#udfh#zlwk#wkh#vxssruw#ri#vpdoo#iduphuv/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Srsxolvw## Sduw|## fuhdwhg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhvᄊ## iluvw## vwdwh0rzqhg## edqn/## wkh## Edqn## ri# 83## Wkh#h{sorvlrq#lq#uxudo#edqn#fuhglw#zdv#iroorzhg#lq#wkh#4<53v#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # Qruwk#Gdnrwd1 # d## vwhdg|## ghfolqh## lq## wkh## sulfhv## ri## djulfxowxudo## surgxfh/## zlghvsuhdg## iduphu# glvwuhvv/#dqg#wkh#idloxuh#ri#d#odujh#qxpehu#ri#vpdoo#uxudo#edqnv1#Dv#lq#wkh#uhfhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fulvlv/#srsxolvw#fuhglw#h{sdqvlrq#zhqw#wrr#idu1# # # # # # # Wkh#wudglwlrq#ri#xvlqj#jryhuqphqw0olqnhg#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wr#h{sdqg#fuhglw# # # # # # # # # # wr#srolwlfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#frqvwlwxhqflhv#ri#prghudwh#fuhglwzruwklqhvv#lv#dovr#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # hvwdeolvkhg## lq## hphujlqj## pdunhwv1## Iru## h{dpsoh/## Vkdzq## Froh/## d## surihvvru## dw# Kduydug## Exvlqhvv## Vfkrro/## ilqgv## wkdw## Lqgldq## vwdwh0rzqhg## edqnv## lqfuhdvh## wkhlu# ohqglqj#wr#wkh#srolwlfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#exw#uhodwlyho|#srru#frqvwlwxhqf|#ri#iduphuv#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # 84##Wkh#hiihfw#lv#prvw#surqrxqfhg# derxw#8#wr#43#shufhqwdjh#srlqwv#lq#hohfwlrq#|hduv1 # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#glvwulfwv#zlwk#forvh#hohfwlrqv1#Wkh#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#wkh#ohqglqj#duh#juhdwhu#ordq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghidxowv## dqg#qr#phdvxudeoh#lqfuhdvh#lq#djulfxowxudo# # # # # # # rxwsxw/#zklfk#vxjjhvw#wkdw#lw# # # # # uhdoo|## vhuyhv## dv## d## frvwo|## irup## ri## lqfrph## uhglvwulexwlrq1## Prvw## uhfhqwo|/## wkh# frdolwlrq#Xqlwhg#Surjuhvvlyh# # # # Dooldqfh## +XSD,## jryhuqphqw#zdlyhg#wkh# # # # uhsd|phqw# ri#ordqv#pdgh#wr#vpdoo#dqg#phglxp0vl}hg#iduphuv#mxvw#ehiruh#wkh#533<#hohfwlrqv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # dq## dfw## wkdw## vrph## frpphqwdwruv## eholhyhg## khoshg## wkh## frdolwlrq## jhw## uhhohfwhg1# Srsxolvp#dqg#fuhglw#duh#idploldu#ehgihoorzv#durxqg#wkh#zruog1# # # # # # # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Jurzlqj## lqfrph## lqhtxdolw|## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## vwhpplqj## iurp## xqhtxdo# dffhvv#wr#txdolw|#hgxfdwlrq#ohg#wr#srolwlfdo#suhvvxuh#iru#pruh#krxvlqj#fuhglw1#Wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # suhvvxuh#fuhdwhg#d#vhulrxv#idxow#olqh#wkdw#glvwruwhg#ohqglqj#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Eurdghqlqj#dffhvv# # # wr#krxvlqj#ordqv# # # # dqg#krph# # # rzqhuvkls#zdv# # # dq#hdv|/#srsxodu/# # # dqg## txlfn## zd|## wr## dgguhvv## shufhswlrqv## ri## lqhtxdolw|1## Srolwlfldqv## vhw## derxw# dfklhylqj#lw#wkurxjk#wkh#djhqflhv#dqg#ghsduwphqwv#wkh|#kdg#vhw#xs#wr#ghdo#zlwk#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvlqj0ghew## glvdvwhuv## gxulqj## wkh## Juhdw## Ghsuhvvlrq1## Lurqlfdoo|/## wkh## vdph# rujdql}dwlrqv#pd|#kdyh#khoshg#suhflslwdwh#wkh#rqjrlqj#krxvlqj#fdwdvwurskh1# # # # # # # # # Wklv## lv## qrw## wr## idxow## wkhlu## lqwhqw1## Erwk## wkh## Folqwrq## dgplqlvwudwlrqᄊv## dwwhpsw## wr# pdnh## krxvlqj## diirugdeoh## wr## wkh## ohvv## zhoo0rii## dqg## wkh## Exvk## dgplqlvwudwlrqᄊv# dwwhpsw## wr## h{sdqg## krph## rzqhuvkls## zhuh## odxgdeoh1## Wkh|## zhuh## dovr## srolwlfdoo|# dvwxwh#lq#wkdw#wkh|#irfxvhg#rq#doohyldwlqj#wkh#frqfhuqv#ri#wkrvh#ehlqj#ohiw#ehklqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkloh## ex|lqj## wlph## iru## pruh## gluhfw## srolflhv## wr## zrun1## Exw## wkh## jds## ehwzhhq# jryhuqphqw#lqwhqw#dqg#rxwfrphv#fdq#eh#yhu|#zlgh#lqghhg/#hvshfldoo|#zkhq#dfwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # lv#phgldwhg#wkurxjk#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru1#Pruh#dozd|v#vhhpv#ehwwhu#wr#wkh#lpsdwlhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfldq1#Exw#dq|#lqvwuxphqw#ri#jryhuqphqw#srolf|#kdv#lwv#olplwdwlrqv/#dqg#zkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # zrunv#lq#vpdoo#grvhv#fdq#ehfrph#d#qljkwpduh#zkhq#vfdohg#xs/#hvshfldoo|#zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # vfdohg#xs#txlfno|1#Vrph#vxssruw#wr#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj#pljkw#kdyh#kdg#ehqhilwv# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#surpswhg#olwwoh#sulydwh0vhfwru# # # # # uhdfwlrq1#Exw#vxssruw#dw#d#vfdoh#wkdw#glvwruwhg# # # # # # # # krxvlqj## sulfhv## dqg## sulydwh0vhfwru## lqfhqwlyhv## zdv## wrr## pxfk1## Ixuwkhupruh/## wkh# sulydwh#vhfwru# # ᄊv#remhfwlyhv#duh#qrw#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#remhfwlyhv/#dqg#doo#wrr#riwhq# # # # # # # # # # # srolflhv## duh## vhw## zlwkrxw## wdnlqj## wklv## glvsdulw|## lqwr## dffrxqw1## Vhulrxv## xqlqwhqghg# frqvhtxhqfhv#fdq#uhvxow1# # # Vxffhvvlyh## jryhuqphqwv## sxvkhg## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh## wr## vxssruw## orz0lqfrph# ohqglqj1#Jlyhq#wkhlu# # # # klvwrulfdo## irfxv#rq#sulph#pruwjdjhv/#wkhvh#djhqflhv#kdg#qr# # # # # # # # gluhfw## zd|## ri## ruljlqdwlqj## ru## ex|lqj## vxesulph## ordqv## lq## wkh## txdqwlwlhv## wkdw## zhuh# ehlqj#suhvfulehg1# # # Vr## lq#wkh# # # |hduv## ri## wkh## juhdwhvw## h{fhvv/## wkh|#erxjkw# # # vxesulph# pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv/## exw## zlwkrxw## dgmxvwlqj## iru## wkh## vljqlilfdqwo|## kljkhu# ulvnv## wkdw## zhuh## lqyroyhg1## Dqg## wkh## hduo|## uhzdugv## iurp#wdnlqj# # # wkhvh## ulvnv## zhuh# kljkhu## surilwv1## Wkdw#wkhuh# # # dovr## zhuh## yhu|#ihz# # # ghidxowv## lqlwldoo|#hperoghqhg# # # wkh# djhqflhv#wr#soxqjh#ixuwkhu/#dqg#wkhlu#zhdn#dqg#srolwlfdoo|#lqioxhqfhg#uhjxodwru#glg# # # # # # # # # # # # olwwoh#wr#uhvwudlq#wkhp1#Dw#wkh#vdph#wlph/#dv# # # # # # # # # # eurnhuv## fdph#wr#nqrz# # # # wkdw#vrphrqh# # rxw#wkhuh#zdv#zloolqj#wr#ex|#vxesulph#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#zlwkrxw#dvnlqj# # # # # # # # # # # wrr## pdq|## txhvwlrqv/## wkh|## uxvkhg## wr## ruljlqdwh## ordqv## zlwkrxw## fkhfnlqj## wkh# eruurzhuvᄊ#fuhglwzruwklqhvv/#dqg#fuhglw#txdolw|#ghwhulrudwhg1#Exw#iru#d#zkloh/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # sureohpv## zhuh## klgghq#e|#jurzlqj#krxvh# # # # # sulfhv## dqg## orz## ghidxowvᄇhdv|#fuhglw# # pdvnhg## wkh## sureohpv## fdxvhg## e|#hdv|#fuhglwᄇxqwlo# # # # krxvh## sulfhv## vwrsshg## ulvlqj# dqg#wkh#iorrg#ri#ghidxowv#exuvw#iruwk1# # # # # # # Rq#qhw/#hdv|#fuhglw/#dv#lv#w|slfdoo|#wkh#fdvh/#suryhg#dq#h{wuhpho|#frvwo|#zd|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhglvwulexwh1## Wrr## pdq|## srru## idplolhv## zkr## vkrxog## qhyhu## kdyh## ehhq## oxuhg## lqwr# ex|lqj#d#krxvh#kdyh#ehhq#hylfwhg#diwhu#orvlqj#wkhlu#phdjhu#vdylqjv#dqg#duh#qrz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # krphohvv>#wrr#pdq|#krxvhv#kdyh#ehhq#exlow#wkdw#zloo#qrw#eh#olyhg#lq>#dqg#wrr#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#kdyh#lqfxuuhg#hqruprxv#orvvhv#wkdw#wkh#wd{sd|hu#zloo#kdyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # devrue#iru#|hduv#wr#frph1#Dowkrxjk#krph#rzqhuvkls#udwhv#glg#jr#xsᄇiurp#9715# # # # # # # # # # # # #
shufhqw#ri#krxvhkrogv#lq#4<<7#wr#9<15#shufhqw#lq#5337ᄇwrr#pdq|#krxvhkrogv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxog## qrw#diirug# # # wr## eruurz## zhuh## lqgxfhg## wr## gr## vr/## dqg## vlqfh## 5337/## hyhq#krph# # rzqhuvkls## kdv## ghfolqhg## vwhdglo|## +wr## 9:15## shufhqw## dv## ri## wkh## irxuwk## txduwhu## ri# 85# 533<,/#zlwk#wkh#udwh#olnho|#wr#idoo#ixuwkhu#dv#pdq|#krxvhkrogv#idfh#iruhforvxuh1 # # # # # # # # # # # # Wklv#lv#d#ohvvrq#wkdw#qhhgv#wr#eh#pruh#zlgho|#devruehg1#Ihz#ᄈvroxwlrqvᄡ#krog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh#vxssruw#dqg#surplvh#xs#iurqw/#dqg#ohdg#wr#pruh#uhfulplqdwlrq#diwhu#wkh#idfw/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq#rshqlqj#wkh# # # # vsljrw#ri#ohqglqj1#Iru# # # # # srru## frxqwulhv## wkhuh## lv## d## vwurqj#sdudooho# # zlwk## wkh## sdvw## hqwkxvldvp## iru## iruhljq## dlg1## Qrz## zh## nqrz## wkdw## dlg## ohdgv## wr# ghshqghqf|/## lqghewhgqhvv/## dqg## srru## jryhuqdqfh## dqg## uduho|## ohdgv## wr## jurzwk186# Wkh## qhz## pludfoh## vroxwlrq## lv## plfurfuhglwᄇohqglqj## wr## wkh## srru## wkurxjk## jurxs# ordqv/## d## v|vwhp#lq#zklfk#shhu# # # # # suhvvxuh## iurp#wkh# # # jurxs## pdnhv## lqglylgxdov## pruh# olnho|#wr# # # uhsd|1## Dowkrxjk#lw# # # kdv## surplvh## rq#d# # # vpdoo## vfdoh/## klvwru|#vxjjhvwv# # # wkdw# zkhq#vfdohg#xs/#dqg#hvshfldoo|#zkhq#xvhg#dv#dq#lqvwuxphqw#ri#jryhuqphqw#srolf|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#zloo#olnho|#fuhdwh#vljqlilfdqw#sureohpv1# # # # # # Vr#zkdw#vkrxog#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#gr#wr#ghdo#zlwk#wkh#zdqlqj#ri#wkh#Dphulfdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # guhdp/## zlwk## wkh## vkulqnlqj## ri## rssruwxqlwlhv## iru## wkh## odujh## pdvv## ri## wkh## Dphulfdq# shrsohB#Ljqrulqj#wkh#sureohp#zloo#rqo|#pdnh#pdwwhuv#zruvh1#Lqhtxdolw|#ihhgv#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # lwvhoi1#Pruhryhu/#lw#zloo#suhflslwdwh#d#edfnodvk1#Zkhq#shrsoh#vhh#d#glp#hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # # # # ixwxuh#lq#d#ghprfudf|/#wkh|#zrun#wkurxjk#srolwlfdo#fkdqqhov#wr#rewdlq#uhguhvv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # li## wkh## srolwlfdo## fkdqqho## grhv## qrw## uhvsrqg/## wkh|#uhvruw# # # wr## rwkhu## phdqv1## Wkh## iluvw# ylfwlpv#ri#d#srolwlfdo#vhdufk#iru#vfdshjrdwv#duh#wkrvh#zkr#duh#ylvleoh#dqg#hdvlo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghprql}hg/## exw#srzhuohvv# # # wr## ghihqg## wkhpvhoyhv1## Loohjdo## lppljudqwv## dqg## iruhljq# zrunhuv#gr#qrw#yrwh/#exw#wkh|#duh#hvvhqwldo#wr#wkh#hfrqrp|ᄇwkh#iruphu#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#riwhq#gr#mrev#qr#rqh#hovh#zloo#wrxfk#lq#qrupdo#wlphv/#dqg#wkh#odwwhu#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#duh#wkh#vrxufh#ri#wkh#fkhds#lpsruwv#wkdw#kdyh#udlvhg#wkh#vwdqgdug#ri#olylqj#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # doo/## exw## hvshfldoo|#wkrvh# # # zlwk#orz# # # lqfrphv1## Wkhuh## kdv## wr## eh## d## ehwwhu## zd|#wkdq# # vlpso|## ilqglqj## vfdshjrdwv/## dqg## L## h{dplqh## srvvleoh## vroxwlrqv## lq## vxevhtxhqw# fkdswhuv1# Dw#wklv#srlqw/#wkrxjk/#L#zdqw#wr#wxuq#wr#d#sureohp#wkdw#zdv#jurzlqj#lq#pdjqlwxgh# # # # ## # # # # # # # # # # hovhzkhuh#lq#wkh#zruog1#Hyhq#dv#srolwlfdo#frpsxovlrqv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # sxvklqj## lw## wr## ehfrph## pruh## idyrudeoh## wr## errvwlqj## frqvxpswlrq/## frxqwulhv## olnh# Jhupdq|## dqg## Mdsdq/## zklfk## zhuh## h{wuhpho|## ghshqghqw## rq## h{sruwv## iru## jurzwk/# zhuh## dffrxqwlqj## iru## d## odujhu## vkduh## ri## wkh## zruog## hfrqrp|1## Zk|## wkh|/## dqg## d# jurzlqj#qxpehu# # # ri#hphujlqj#pdunhwv/# # # # kdyh## ehfrph## ghshqghqw#lq#wklv# # # # zd|/## dqg# wkh#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#vxfk#ghshqghqfh#iru#frxqwulhv#olnh#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#duh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lvvxhv#L#wxuq#wr#qrz1# ## # #
FKDSWHU#WZR #
H{sruwlqj#wr#Jurz # # #
L## JUHZ#XS#LQ# # # # GLIIHUHQW#SDUWV# # # ri#wkh#zruog#ehfdxvh#p|#idwkhu#zdv#dq#Lqgldq# # # # # # # # #
glsorpdw1## P|#iluvw#uhdo# # # # phprulhv## ri#Lqgld# # # duh## iurp#p|#hduo|#whhqv/# # # # # lq#wkh# # # plg0 4<:3v/#zkhq#kh#uhwxuqhg#wr#zrun#lq#Ghokl1#Lw#zdv#qrw#dq#hdv|#wlph1#Zh#zhuh#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # srru/## exw## p|## sduhqwv## kdg## wr## eulqj## xs## irxu## fkloguhq## rq## p|## idwkhu#ᄊv## jryhuqphqw# vdodu|1## Pruh## sureohpdwlf/## wkhuh## zdv## yhu|## olwwoh## wr## ex|/## hvshfldoo|## iru## fkloguhq# zkr## kdg## jurzq#xvhg# # # wr## wkh## sohqwlixo## fkrlfhv## lq#Hxurshdq#vxshupdunhwv1# # # # Hyhu|# hyhqlqj/#rqh#ri#xv# # # # # fkloguhq#wuxgjhg#durxqg#wkh#orfdo# # # # # # pdunhwv## orrnlqj#iru# # # euhdg1# Wkh## jryhuqphqw## zdv## wu|lqj## wr## olplw## wkh## surgxfwlrq## ri## ᄈxqqhfhvvdu|ᄡ## frqvxphu# jrrgv/#ri#zklfk#euhdg#zdv#ghhphg#rqh1#Pruhryhu/#ehfdxvh#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dovr# # # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwhg## wkh## riilfldo## vdoh## sulfh## iru## euhdg/## wkh## olwwoh## wkdw## zdv## surgxfhg## zdv# glyhuwhg#wr#idyruhg#folhqwv#dqg#vrog#dw#eodfn0pdunhw#sulfhv1#Vr#zh#zhqw#durxqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#hpsw|#vwruhv/#wu|lqj#wr#lqjudwldwh#rxuvhoyhv#zlwk#wkh#vkrsnhhshuv#lq#wkh#krsh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#rqh# # # zrxog## vhoo## xv## kdoi#d# # # ordi#ri#euhdg# # # # iurp#klv# # # klgghq#vwrfnᄇdw#wzlfh# # # # wkh# il{hg#sulfh1#L#uhphpehu#wkh#mr|#zh#ihow#zkhq#d#iulhqgᄊv#eurwkhu#erxjkw#d#vkrs#lq# # ## # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## pdunhw1## P|#qhz# # # frqqhfwlrqv## hqvxuhg## rxu## euhdg## vxsso|/## doorzlqj#xv# # # wr## vwrs# kdxqwlqj#wkh#pdunhw1# # # Zh#zhuh#qrw#vr#oxfn|#lq#rxu#txhvw#iru#d#fdu1#Kljk#lpsruw#gxwlhv#pdgh#iruhljq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fduv#xqdiirugdeoh1#Wkh#jryhuqphqw#doorzhg#rqo|#wkuhh#grphvwlf#ilupv#wr#surgxfh# # # # # # # # # # # fduv/#dqg#rqo|#lq#olplwhg#txdqwlwlhv/#iru# # # # # # # # fduv#zhuh#ghhphg#xqqhfhvvdu|#dv#zhoo1# # # # # # Wkh## rqo|## Lqgldq0pdgh## fdu## wkdw## frxog## dffrpprgdwh## rxu## odujh## idplo|## zdv## wkh# Dpedvvdgruᄇd## orfdo## yhuvlrq## ri## wkh## 4<87## R{irug## Pruulv/## yluwxdoo|## xqfkdqjhg# iurp#wkh# # # ruljlqdo1## Exw#wkh# # # zdlwlqj#olvw#iru# # # # dq#Dpedvvdgru/# # # zklfk#lq#prvw#rwkhu# # # # frxqwulhv## zrxog## eh## ghhphg## dq## dqwltxh/## zdv## |hduv1## Vr## p|## idwkhu## vhwwohg## iru## d# vfrrwhu## wkdw## kh## urgh## wr## zrun1## Ehfdxvh## sxeolf## wudqvsruw## zdv## xquholdeoh/## idplo|# rxwlqjv#zhuh#uduh1# # # Wkh## jryhuqphqw## zdqwhg## wr## olplw## frqvxpswlrq## dqg## hqfrxudjh## vdylqjv/## dqg# krxvhkrogv#glg#vdyh#d#orw1#Exw#wkhuh#zhuh#dovr#xqlqwhqghg#frqvhtxhqfhv1#Ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # jrrgv#zhuh#lq#vkruw#vxsso|#dqg#sulfhv#zhuh#il{hg#dw#oxglfurxvo|#orz#ohyhov/#olwwoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv#dydlodeoh#lq#wkh#rshq#pdunhw1#Eodfn#pdunhwv#iorxulvkhg=#hyhu|wklqj#frxog#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # rewdlqhg#li#|rx#kdg#fdvk#ru#frqqhfwlrqv1#Ihz#mrev#zhuh#fuhdwhg=#wkh#surgxfwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## pruh## fduv## zrxog## kdyh## phdqw## pruh## ghpdqg## iru## uhvwdxudqwv## dqg## flqhpdv## dqg# wkxv#pruh#mrev#qrw#rqo|#iru#dxwr#zrunhuv#exw#dovr#iru#zdlwhuv#dqg#wlfnhw#fohunv1#L# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkrxjkw## wkhuh## pljkw## eh## vrph## judqg## ghvljq## L## glg## qrw## xqghuvwdqg/## exw## wkh# jryhuqphqwᄊv#srolf|#fohduo|#zdv#qrw#zrunlqj/#ehfdxvh#Lqgld#zdv#vwloo#srru1#L#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # ## ghwhuplqhg## wr## ohduq## pruh/## vr## L## ehfdph## lqwhuhvwhg## lq## hfrqrplfv1## Wklv## errn## lv# dqrwkhu#xqlqwhqghg#frqvhtxhqfh#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#srolflhv1# # # # # # # Wkluw|0ilyh## |hduv## odwhu/## lw## lv## uhodwlyho|## hdv|## wr## ghvfuleh## wkh## w|slfdo## sdwk## wkdw# vxffhvvixo## frxqwulhv## kdyh## iroorzhg## lq#wkh# # # vhdufk#iru# # # jurzwk1## Lw#kdv# # # hpskdvl}hg# erwk## vxevwdqwldo## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq## wkh## hduo|## vwdjhvᄇzklfk## lv## zk|## L# eurdgo|## uhihu## wr## lw## dv## uhodwlrqvkls## ru## pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvpᄇdqg## d## irfxv## rq#
h{sruwv1## Dowkrxjk## hdv|## wr## ghvfuleh/## lw## lv## pxfk## kdughu## wr## lpsohphqw1## Dw## nh|# mxqfwxuhv/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#kdv#wr#wdnh#vwhsv#wkdw#jr#djdlqvw#lwv#qdwxudo#lqfolqdwlrqv># # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Lqgld#ri#p|#|rxwk#pxiihg#wkh#jdph#sodq1#Shukdsv#wklv#lv#rqh#uhdvrq#zk|#rqo|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdqgixo#ri#frxqwulhv#kdyh#jurzq#udslgo|#rxw#ri#sryhuw|#lq#uhfhqw#|hduv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#h{sruw0ohg#pdqdjhg0jurzwk#vwudwhj|/#zkhq#lpsohphqwhg#zhoo/#kdv#ehhq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # sulpdu|#sdwk#rxw#ri#sryhuw|#lq#wkh#srvwzdu#hud1#Lq#wkh#hduo|#gd|v#ri#wklv#vwudwhj|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## h{sruwhuv## zhuh## vpdoo## hqrxjk## wr## doorz## wkh## uhvw## ri## wkh## zruog## wr## errvw## lwv# vshqglqj## dqg## devrue## wkh## h{sruwv## hdvlo|1## Xqiruwxqdwho|/## hyhq## dv## h{sruwhuv## olnh# Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq#kdyh#ehfrph#odujh#dqg#ulfk/#wkh#kdelwv#dqg#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # dftxluhg## zkloh## jurzlqj## kdyh## ohiw## wkhp## xqdeoh## wr## jhqhudwh## vwurqj/## vxvwdlqdeoh# grphvwlf#ghpdqg#dqg#ehfrph#pruh#edodqfhg#lq#wkhlu#jurzwk1# # # # # # # # # Wkh## vxusoxvhv## wkh|## sxw## rxw## lqwr## wkh## joredo## jrrgv## pdunhwv## kdyh## flufohg## wkh# zruog/## orrnlqj#iru# # # wkrvh## zkr## kdyh## wkh## fuhglwzruwklqhvv## wr## ex|#wkh# # # jrrgv/## dqg# whpswlqj#frxqwulhv/# # # frpsdqlhv/## dqg## krxvhkrogv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## lqwr## vshqglqj1# Lq## wkh## 4<<3v/## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## udq## wkh## wudgh## ghilflwv## qhfhvvdu|## wr## devrue# wkhvh## jrrgv=## wkh## qh{w#fkdswhu# # # vkrzv## krz## pdq|#ri#wkhp#vxiihuhg# # # # # ghhs## ilqdqfldo# fulvhv#dqg#iruvzruh#ixuwkhu#ghilflwv#dqg#eruurzlqj1#Hyhq#dv#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # gursshg## wkh## krw#srwdwr# # # ri#iruhljq0ghew0ilqdqfhg# # # vshqglqj#lq#wkh# # # # odwh## 4<<3v/## wkh# Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## dv## zhoo## dv## Hxurshdq## frxqwulhv## vxfk## dv## Juhhfh/## Vsdlq/## dqg## wkh# Xqlwhg## Nlqjgrp/## slfnhg## lw## xs1## Iluvw/## wkrxjk/## L## zdqw## wr## ghvfuleh## wkh## h{sruw0ohg# pdqdjhg#jurzwk#vwudwhj|#dqg#zk|#lw#zrunhg1# # # # # # #
Wkh#Hoxvlyh#Vhdufk#iru#Jurzwk # # # # # Ihz## shrsoh## uhdol}h## wkdw## pdq|## ri## wrgd|ᄊv## zhdowk|## qdwlrqv## duh## ulfk## wrgd|# ehfdxvh## wkh|#juhz# # # vwhdglo|#iru# # # d## orqj#wlph/# # # qrw#ehfdxvh# # # wkh|#juhz# # # sduwlfxoduo|# idvw1#Ehwzhhq#4;53#dqg#4;:3/#wkh#shu#fdslwd#lqfrphv#ri#Dxvwudold#dqg#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv/#wkh#idvw0jurzlqj#hphujlqj#pdunhwv#ri#wkhlu# # # # # # # # wlph#+L#uhihu# # # # wr#wkhp#dv#hduo|# # # # ghyhorshuv,/## juhz## dqqxdoo|## dw## 41;## shufhqw## dqg## 416## shufhqw/## uhvshfwlyho|14## E|# frqwudvw/#odwh#ghyhorshuv#olnh#Fkloh/#Vrxwk#Nruhd/#dqg#Wdlzdq/#zklfk#mrlqhg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # udqnv#ri#zhdowklhu#qdwlrqv#rqo|#lq#uhfhqw#ghfdghv/#juhz#dw#pxowlsohv#ri#wkhvh#udwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ryhu## d## vkruwhu## shulrg1## Mdsdq## zdv## qrw## txlwh## d## srru## frxqwu|## lq## 4<83## +wkrxjk## lq# 4<83#lwv#shu#fdslwd#lqfrph#zdv#orzhu#wkdq#Ph{lfrᄊv,1#Krzhyhu/#ehwzhhq#4<83# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#4<:6/#Mdsdqhvh#shu#fdslwd#lqfrph#juhz#dw#d#udwh#ri#durxqg#;#shufhqw#d#|hdu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkhvh## odwh## ghyhorshuv## kdyh## vhw## wkh## dvsludwlrqdo## ohyho## iru## wrgd|ᄊv## ghyhorslqj# frxqwulhv/## exw## wkhluv## lv## d## yhu|## gliihuhqw## sdwk## iurp#wkdw# # # ri## wkh## hduo|## ghyhorshuv# hvshfldoo|#zlwk#uhvshfw#wr#wkh#vshhg#ri#wkhlu#jurzwk1# # # # # # # # # Krz#glg#wkh#odwh#ghyhorshuv#jurz#vr#idvwB#Lq#wkh#hqwluh#klvwru|#ri#kxpdqnlqg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qr## frxqwu|#kdg# # # jurzq#dv# # # idvw## dv## Mdsdq#glg# # # ehwzhhq#4<83# # # dqg## 4<:61## Exw## vlqfh# wkhq/## Vrxwk## Nruhd/## Pdod|vld/## Wdlzdq/## dqg## Fklqd## kdyh## dssurdfkhg## dqg## hyhq# h{fhhghg## wklv## udwh## ri## jurzwk1## Wr## xqghuvwdqg## wkhvh## ghyhorsphqwv/## zh## kdyh## wr# xqghuvwdqg## zk|## frxqwulhv## duh## srru## lq## wkh## iluvw## sodfh## dqg## krz## wkh|## dwwhpsw## wr# folpe#rxw#ri#sryhuw|1# # # #
Lv#Pruh#Fdslwdo#wkh#Nh|#wr#JurzwkB # # # # # # # D#gliihuhqfh# # # reylrxv## wr## dq|rqh## zkr## wudyhov## iurp#d# # # ulfk#frxqwu|#wr# # # # d## srru# frxqwu|#lv# # # wkh## ydu|lqj#ohyhov# # # ri#sk|vlfdo# # # fdslwdo1#Lq#ulfk#frxqwulhv/#ydvw#dlusruwv# # # # # # dffrpprgdwlqj#elj#sodqhv/#hqruprxv#idfwrulhv#sdfnhg#zlwk#kljk0whfk#pdfklqhu|/# # # # # # # # # kxjh## frpelqhv## lq## zhoo0luuljdwhg## ilhogv/## dqg## krxvhkrogv## zlwk## dssoldqfhv## dqg# jdgjhwv#iru#hyhu|#lpdjlqdeoh#xvh#vxjjhvw#wr#xv#wkdw#idu#pruh#sk|vlfdo#fdslwdo#lv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xvh## wkdq#lq#srru# # # # frxqwulhv1## Sk|vlfdo## fdslwdo## lqfuhdvhv## lqfrph## ehfdxvh## lw#pdnhv# # hyhu|rqh#pruh#surgxfwlyh1#D#vlqjoh#frqvwuxfwlrq#zrunhu#zlwk#d#edfnkrh#fdq#vkliw# # # # # # # # # # # # idu#pruh#pxg#wkdq#vhyhudo#zrunhuv#zlwk#vkryhov#dqg#zkhhoeduurzv1# # # # # # # # # # Li/## krzhyhu/## wkh## rqo|## gliihuhqfh## ehwzhhq## wkh## ulfk## dqg## wkh## srru## frxqwulhv## lv# sk|vlfdo#fdslwdo/#wkh#reylrxv#txhvwlrq/#srvhg#e|#wkh#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjr#Qreho# # # # # # # # # # # # odxuhdwh#Urehuw#Oxfdv#lq#d#vhplqdo#sdshu#lq#4<<3/#lv/#Zk|#grhv#pruh#prqh|#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iorz## iurp#ulfk#frxqwulhv#wr#srru#frxqwulhv#vr#dv#wr#hqdeoh#wkh#srru#frxqwulhv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ex|## wkh## sk|vlfdo## fdslwdo## wkh|## qhhgB5## Diwhu## doo/## srru## frxqwulhv## zrxog## jdlq# hqruprxvo|#iurp#d# # # # olwwoh## pruh## fdslwdo## lqyhvwphqw=## lq#vrph# # # sduwv## ri#Diulfd/# # # lw#lv# # hdvlhu#wr#jhw#wr#d#flw|#d#ihz# # # # # # # # # kxqguhg#plohv#dzd|#e|#wdnlqj#d#ioljkw#wr#Orqgrq#ru# # # # # # # # # # Sdulv## dqg## wdnlqj#dqrwkhu# # # ioljkw#edfn#wr# # # # wkh## Diulfdq#ghvwlqdwlrq#wkdq#wr# # # # # wu|#wr# # # jr# wkhuh#gluhfwo|1#Frpphufh#zrxog#eh#ydvwo|#lqfuhdvhg#lq#Diulfd#li#jrrg#urdgv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # exlow## ehwzhhq## flwlhv/## zkhuhdv## dq## dgglwlrqdo## urdg## zrxog## qrw## pdnh## dq## lrwd## ri# gliihuhqfh## lq## douhdg|## ryhufrqqhfwhg## Mdsdq1## Lqghhg/## Oxfdv## fdofxodwhg## wkdw## d# groodu#ᄊv## zruwk#ri#sk|vlfdo# # # # fdslwdo## lq#Lqgld# # # zrxog## surgxfh## 8;## wlphv## wkh## uhwxuqv# dydlodeoh#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1#Joredo#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv/#kh#dujxhg/#frxog#qrw#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vr## eolqg## dv## wr## ljqruh## wkhvh## hqruprxv## gliihuhqfhv## lq## uhwxuqv/## hyhq## wdnlqj## lqwr# dffrxqw#wkh#juhdwhu#ulvn#ri#lqyhvwlqj#lq#Lqgld1# # # # # # # # Shukdsv/#Oxfdv#frqfoxghg/#wkh#h{sodqdwlrq#lv#wkdw#wkh#uhwxuqv#lq#srru#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # # duh## orzhu## wkdq## vxjjhvwhg## e|## wkhvh## vlpsoh## fdofxodwlrqv## ehfdxvh## wkhvh## frxqwulhv# odfn## rwkhu## idfwruv## qhfhvvdu|## wr## surgxfh## uhwxuqv=## shukdsv## hgxfdwlrq## ru/## pruh# eurdgo|/## kxpdq## fdslwdo1## Lw## pd|## vhhp#wkdw# # # dq## Hj|swldq## iduphu/## xvlqj## wkh## r{## dqg# sorz## wkdw## klv## dqfhvwruv## xvhg## ilyh## wkrxvdqg## |hduv## djr/## frxog## lqfuhdvh## klv# hiilflhqf|#hqruprxvo|#e|#xvlqj#d# # # # # # wudfwru1## E|#frpsdulvrq/# # # lw## zrxog## vhhp#olnho|# # wkdw#d#iduphu#lq#Lrzd#zkr#douhdg|#rzqv#dq#duud|#ri#djulfxowxudo#pdfklqhu|#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsuryh## klv## |lhog## rqo|## pdujlqdoo|## e|## ex|lqj## dq## dgglwlrqdo## wudfwru1## Exw## wkh# Hj|swldq#iduphu# # # lv#olnho|#wr#eh#idu# # # # # # ohvv#hgxfdwhg#wkdq#wkh#iduphu# # # # # # lq#Lrzd#dqg#wr# # # # nqrz## ohvv## derxw#wkh# # # nlqgv## ri#ihuwlol}huv# # # dqg## shvwlflghv## wkdw#duh# # # qhhghg## ru## zkhq# wkh|## vkrxog## eh## dssolhg## wr## pd{lpl}h## furs## |lhogv1## Dv## d## uhvxow/## wkh## dgglwlrqdo# lqfrph#wkh#Hj|swldq#iduphu#frxog#jhqhudwh#zlwk#d#vlqjoh#wudfwru#pljkw#eh#idu#ohvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq#zkdw#wkh#Lrzd#iduphu#frxog#jhqhudwh#e|#ex|lqj#rqh#pruh#pdfklqh#wr#dgg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#pdq|#kh#douhdg|#kdv1# # # # # Krzhyhu/#hyhq#dffrxqwlqj#iru# # # # # gliihuhqfhv## lq#kxpdq#fdslwdo# # # # ehwzhhq#ulfk#dqg# # # srru#frxqwulhv/#Oxfdv#vxuplvhg#wkdw#fdslwdo#vkrxog#vwloo#eh#idu#pruh#surgxfwlyh#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## odwwhu1## Pruhryhu/## hylghqfh## vxjjhvwv## wkdw## wkh## hqruprxv## lqyhvwphqwv## lq# hgxfdwlrq#durxqg# # # wkh## zruog## lq#uhfhqw#|hduv# # # # kdyh## qrw#pdgh# # # d## juhdw#gliihuhqfh# # # wr# 6# jurzwk1 # Vrphwklqj## hovh## vhhpv## wr## eh## plvvlqj## lq## srru## frxqwulhv## wkdw## nhhsv# pdfklqhv## dqg## hgxfdwhg## shrsoh## iurp#pd{lpl}lqj# # # surgxfwlylw|## dqg## wkh## frxqwulhv# iurp#jurzlqj#ulfkᄇvrphwklqj#wkdw#groorsv#ri#iruhljq#dlg#fdqqrw#uhdglo|#vxsso|1# # # # # # # # # # #
Rujdql}dwlrqdo#Fdslwdo # # Wkh## uhdo## sureohp/## lq#p|#ylhz/# # # # lv## wkdw#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv/# # # # fhuwdlqo|#lq#wkh# # # hduo|#vwdjhv# # # ri#jurzwk/# # # gr## qrw#kdyh# # # wkh## rujdql}dwlrqdo## vwuxfwxuh## wr## ghsor|#odujh# # 7## \rx#fdqqrw#vlpso|#ex|#d#frpsolfdwhg/# txdqwlwlhv#ri#sk|vlfdo#fdslwdo#hiihfwlyho|1 # # # # # # # # # kljk0vshhg## pdfklqh## wrro## dqg## kluh## d## vpduw#rshudwru# # # wr## uxq#lw=# # # |rx#qhhg# # # d## zkroh# rujdql}dwlrq#vxuurxqglqj#wkdw#rshudwru# # # # # li#wkh# # # pdfklqh## lv## wr## eh## sxw#wr# # # surgxfwlyh# xvh1#\rx#qhhg#uholdeoh#vxssolhuv#wr#surylgh#wkh#udz#pdwhuldov/#ex|huv#wr#wdnh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxwsxw#iurp#wkh#wrro# # # # # dqg#xvh#lw#lq#wkhlu# # # # # # surgxfwlrq#olqhv/#pdqdjhuv# # # # wr#ghflgh#wkh# # # pl{#ri#surgxfwv#wkdw#zloo#eh#pdgh/#d#pdlqwhqdqfh#whdp#wr#wdnh#fduh#ri#uhsdluv/#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sxufkdvlqj#whdp#wr#ghdo# # # # # zlwk#vxssolhuv/#d#pdunhwlqj#whdp#wr#ghdo# # # # # # # # zlwk#ex|huv/#d# # # vhfxulw|## rxwilw## wr## jxdug## wkh## idflolw|## dw## qljkw/## dqg## vr## rq1## Wkh## rujdql}dwlrqdo# gliihuhqfhv## ehwzhhq#d# # # vpdoo## fdu## uhsdlu## vkrs## dqg## Wr|rwd/## ru## ehwzhhq#d# # # phglfdo# glvshqvdu|#krxvhg#lq#d#vkhg#dqg#wkh#Pd|r#Folqlf/#duh#hqruprxv/#dqg#ghwhuplqh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#delolw|#wr#xvh#odujh#prghuq#vrsklvwlfdwhg#pdfklqhv#hiihfwlyho|1# # # # # # # # # Ri## frxuvh/## wkhvh## frpsoh{## rujdql}dwlrqv## gr## qrw## rshudwh## lq## d## ydfxxp## hlwkhu1# Wkh|#qhhg# # # rwkhu## frpsoh{#rujdql}dwlrqv# # # wr## surylgh## lqsxwv## dqg## vrphwlphv## wr## ex|# wkhlu## rxwsxw1## Htxdoo|#lpsruwdqw/# # # wkh|#qhhg# # # ilqdqfh/## lqiudvwuxfwxuhᄇiru## h{dpsoh/# hohfwulf## srzhu/## dqg## wudqvsruw## dqg## frppxqlfdwlrq## qhwzrunvᄇdqg## jryhuqdqfh# lqvwlwxwlrqv## wr## surylgh## vhfxulw|## wr## surshuw|## dqg## olih## dv## zhoo## dv## wr## idflolwdwh# exvlqhvv#wudqvdfwlrqv1# #
Krz#wkh#Hduo|#Ghyhorshuv#Exlow#Rujdql}dwlrqdo#Fdslwdo # # # # # # # Wkh#juhdw#Dxvwuldq#hfrqrplvw#Mrvhsk#Vfkxpshwhu#dujxhg#wkdw#fdslwdolvp#juhz# # # # # # # # # # wkurxjk## lqqrydwlrq/## zlwk## qhzfrphuv## eulqjlqj## lq## fuhdwlyh## qhz## surfhvvhv## dqg# whfkqltxhv#wkdw#ghvwur|hg#wkh#exvlqhvvhv#ri#rog#lqfxpehqwv1#Pxfk#ri#fdslwdolvpᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # g|qdplvp#lq#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#grhv#uhiohfw#wklv#surfhvv=#lq#wkh#sdvw#ihz#|hduv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # iru#h{dpsoh/#wkh#zkroh#exvlqhvv#ri#ilop#skrwrjudsk|#kdv#ehhq#doprvw#frpsohwho|# # # # # # # # # # # # hfolsvhg## e|## wkh## gljlwdo## skrwrjudsk|## uhyroxwlrq1## Ilop## pdnhuv## vxfk## dv## Nrgdn/# zklfk#glg#qrw#dqwlflsdwh#wkh#vshhg#ri#wklv#fkdqjh/#kdyh#kdg#wr#vwuxjjoh#wr#uhpdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhpvhoyhv1# Zlwk## wklv## nlqg## ri## jurzwk## surfhvv## lq## plqg/## zkdw## lv## orrvho|## whuphg## wkh# lqvwlwxwlrqdo## vfkrro## ri#hfrqrplvwv# # # kdv## dujxhg## wkdw#wkh# # # uroh## ri#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw#lq# # exvlqhvv#lv#wr#fuhdwh#wkh#lqvwlwxwlrqdo#hqylurqphqw#iru#frpshwlwlrq#dqg#lqqrydwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # ᄇwr## hvwdeolvk#vhfxuh# # # surshuw|#uljkwv/# # # vwuhqjwkhq#sdwhqw#odzv/# # # # uhgxfh## eduulhuv## wr# hqwu|/## dqg## uhgxfh## wd{hvᄇdqg## wkhq#ohw#wkh# # # # sulydwh## vhfwru## wdnh## fkdujh1## Wkhuh## lv## d# vpdoo## sureohp#zlwk# # # wklv## ylhz1## Qr## odujh## frxqwu|## kdv## hyhu## jurzq## udslgo|## iurp# sryhuw|#wr#ulfkhv#zlwk#wklv#nlqg#ri#vwudwhj|/#lq#sduw#ehfdxvh#srru#frxqwulhv#gr#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## wkh## qhfhvvdu|## sulydwh## rujdql}dwlrqv## wr## wdnh## dgydqwdjh## ri## vxfk## dq# hqylurqphqw/## dqg## wkh## hqylurqphqw/## lq## wxuq/## lv## qrw## frqgxflyh## wr## fuhdwlqj## wkh# rujdql}dwlrqv#txlfno|1# # Iru## h{dpsoh/## Eulwlvk## Lqgld## kdg## pdq|## ri## wkh## txdolwlhv## wkdw## wkhvh## hfrqrplvwv# dgyrfdwh=#d#vpdoo#dqg#idluo|#krqhvw#jryhuqphqw/#orz#wd{hv/#orz#wduliiv/#d#irfxv#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # exloglqj## lqiudvwuxfwxuh## olnh## udlozd|v/## dqg## d## odlvvh}0idluh## dwwlwxgh## +hyhq## wrzdug# idplqhv,18## Krzhyhu/#ehwzhhq#4;53#dqg#4<83/#shu#fdslwd#lqfrphv#lq#Lqgld#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # yluwxdoo|#vwdjqdqw/# # # jurzlqj#dw# # # mxvw## 314## shufhqw## shu## |hdu## ehfdxvh## wkh## Eulwlvk#glg# # olwwoh#wr#qxuwxuh#orfdo#lqgxvwu|1#Lqvwhdg#wkh|#hqfrxudjhg#lpsruwv#ri#erwk#jrrgv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdqdjhphqw/#hvshfldoo|#iurp#Eulwdlq=# # # # # Lqgld## kdg#dprqj#wkh# # # # orzhvw#lpsruw#wduliiv# # # lq#wkh#zruog#lq#4;;31#Dv#d#uhvxow/#Lqgldᄊv#sulydwh#vhfwru#vlpso|#glg#qrw#kdyh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hqfrxudjhphqw## ru## wkh## uhtxlvlwh## fryhu## ehklqg## zklfk## wr## ghyhors## rujdql}dwlrqdo# fdslwdo1# Lqghhg/## hfrqrplvwv## pd|## ryhusod|## wkh## uroh## ri## lqvwlwxwlrqv## lq## jurzwk1## Klvwru|# vxjjhvwv## wkdw#lqvwlwxwlrqdo# # # fkdqjh## riwhq#grhv# # # qrw#suhgdwh# # # exw#udwkhu# # # dffrpsdqlhv# wkh## surfhvv## ri## jurzwk19## Iru## h{dpsoh/## vhqvleoh## jryhuqphqwv## ri## ghyhorslqj# frxqwulhv## gr## qrw## kdyh## vwurqj## odzv## surwhfwlqj## lqwhoohfwxdo0surshuw|## uljkwv## zkhq# wkhlu#lqgxvwuldo#vhfwru#lv#vwduwlqj#rxw=#vxfk#odzv#zrxog#sxw#dq#hqg#wr#wkh#udpsdqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frs|lqj## iurp#iruhljqhuv# # # wkdw## lv## riwhq## wkh## edvlv## iru## lqlwldo## jurzwk1## Lqvwhdg/## wkh|# hqdfw#surshuw|0uljkwv#ohjlvodwlrq#zkhq#grphvwlf#ilupv#kdyh#ehfrph#vwurqj#hqrxjk# # # # # # # # # # wr#lqqrydwh#dqg#ghpdqg#surwhfwlrq1#Jhqhudoo|/#lqvwlwxwlrqv#vhhp#wr#ghyhors#dorqj# # # # # # # # # # # zlwk/#dqg#lq#uhvsrqvh#wr/#wkh#qhhg#iru#wkhp1#Wkh|#duh#wkhq#uhilqhg#wkurxjk#xvh#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # nhsw#iurp#h{huflvlqj#dxwkrulw|#duelwudulo|#e|#wkh# # # # # # # # frpsoh{#rujdql}dwlrqv# # # wkdw#xvh# # wkhp#dqg#sd|#iru# # # # # wkhlu## xsnhhs1#Lq#pdq|#zd|v/#wkh#uhdo# # # # # # # fkdoohqjh#iru# # # ghyhorslqj# frxqwulhv#lv/#djdlq/#wr#fuhdwh#hiihfwlyh#frpsoh{#rujdql}dwlrqv1# # # # # # # # Ulfk#hduo|#ghyhorshuv# # # # vxfk#dv# # # Dxvwudold/## Fdqdgd/## dqg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## exlow# wkhlu## frpsoh{#rujdql}dwlrqv# # # ryhu## wlph1## Qhz## lqgxvwulhv## riwhq#vwduwhg# # # zlwk#pdq|# # vpdoo## ilupv/## vrph## ri## zklfk## zhuh## h{fhswlrqdoo|## lqqrydwlyh## ru## zhoo## pdqdjhg1#
Wkhvh#jhqhudwhg#odujhu#surilwv#wkdq#wkhlu#frpshwlwruv/#kluhg#pruh#hpsor|hhv/#dqg/# # # # # # # # # # # ryhu## wlph/## exlow## hiihfwlyh## dqg## vwdeoh## rujdql}dwlrqdo## vwuxfwxuhv1## Lqlwldoo|/## wkhvh# ilupv#juhz#vorzo|/#erwk#ehfdxvh#lw#wdnhv#wlph#wr#exlog#wkh#vrfldo#uhodwlrqvklsv/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rujdql}dwlrqdo## qrupv/## dqg## wkh## rujdql}dwlrqdo## surfhgxuhv## wkdw## doorz## wkh## ilup#wr# # ixqfwlrq#hiilflhqwo|#dqg#ehfdxvh#wkh#dydlodelolw|#ri#rxwvlgh#ilqdqfh#wr#dq#xqwulhg/# # # # # # # # # # # # xqsuryhq#rujdql}dwlrq#lv# # # # olplwhg1## Hyhqwxdoo|/## vrph## ilupv## jdlqhg## uhsxwdwlrq#dqg# # zhdowk=## pdq|#ri#wkhvh# # # # zhuh## idplo|#ilupv# # # olnh## Dqkhxvhu0Exvfk#ru# # # Fdujloo## lq#wkh# # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## zkrvh## uhsxwdwlrq## frxog## wudqvihu## grzq## wkurxjk## jhqhudwlrqv1:# Ehfdxvh#edqnv#zrxog#dffhsw#wkhvh#ilupvᄊ#uhsxwdwlrq#dqg#zhdowk#dv#froodwhudo#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqflqj/## wkh|## frxog## jurz## idvwhu1## Doo## lq## doo/## krzhyhu/## jurzwk## zdv## vorz## dqg# vwhdg|/#zlwk#pdq|#ilupv#idoolqj#e|#wkh#zd|vlgh>#idloxuh#udwhv#iru#vpdoo/#qhz#ilupv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ;# duh#vshfwdfxoduo|#kljk#hyhq#wrgd|1 # # # # Jryhuqphqwv## ri## hduo|## ghyhorshuv/## lq## jhqhudo/## vlpso|## glg## qrw## kdyh## pxfk# fdsdflw|#wr# # # lqwhuyhqh## wr## fuhdwh## d## qxuwxulqj#hqylurqphqw/# # # hyhq#li#wkh|#zdqwhg# # # # # wr1# Ehiruh## wkh## gudpdwlf## lqfuhdvh## lq#vshqglqj#gxulqj#wkh# # # # # Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrq/#wkh# # # # wrwdo# rxwod|v## ri## wkh## X1V1## jryhuqphqw## lq## 4<63## zhuh## rqo|## 617## shufhqw## ri## JGS1<## Wkh# sulpdu|#urohv#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zhuh#wkrxjkw#wr#eh#ghihqvh#dqg#pdlqwdlqlqj#odz# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## rughu1## Krzhyhu/## zhdowk## zdv## d## vrxufh## ri## plolwdu|## srzhu/## dqg## zhdowklhu# shrsoh#zhuh#kdss|#dqg#glg#qrw#irphqw#wurxeoh1#Jryhuqphqwv/#wkhuhiruh/#glg#wu|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # irvwhu#jurzwk/#w|slfdoo|#wkurxjk#wkh#vwudwhjlf#xvh#ri#wudgh#eduulhuv#dqg#wduliiv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Gdqlho## Ghirh/## wkh## exvlqhvvpdq/## mrxuqdolvw/## sdpskohwhhu/## dqg## dxwkru## ri# Urelqvrq## Fuxvrh/## dprqj## rwkhu## errnv/## ghvfulehv## lq## ghwdlo## lq## D## Sodq## ri## wkh# Hqjolvk#Frpphufh#rqh#ri#wkh#hduolhvw#grfxphqwhg#lqvwdqfhv#ri#jryhuqphqw0dlghg# # # # # # # # # # ghyhorsphqw=## wkh## zd|#wkh# # # Wxgru## prqdufkv## wudqviruphg## Hqjodqg## iurp#d# # # frxqwu|# 43## Sulru# uholdqw#rq#udz0zrro#h{sruwv#wr#rqh#wkdw#h{sruwhg#pdqxidfwxuhg#zrrohqv1 # # # # # # # # # wr## klv## frurqdwlrq## iroorzlqj## wkh## Zdu## ri## wkh## Urvhv/## Khqu|## YLL## vshqw## wlph## dv## d# uhixjhh#lq#wkh#Orz#Frxqwulhv1#Lpsuhvvhg#e|#wkh#survshulw|#lq#wkrvh#odqgv/#ghulyhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#zrro#pdqxidfwxulqj/#kh#ghflghg#wr#hqfrxudjh#pdqxidfwxulqj#lq#Hqjodqg1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## phdvxuhv## kh## wrrn## lqfoxghg## lghqwli|lqj## orfdwlrqv## vxlwdeoh## iru# pdqxidfwxulqj/## srdfklqj## vnloohg## zrunhuv## iurp## wkh## Orz## Frxqwulhv/## lqfuhdvlqj# gxwlhv## rq## ru## hyhq## edqqlqj## wkh## h{sruw## ri## udz## zrro/## dqg## edqqlqj## wkh## h{sruw## ri# xqilqlvkhg## forwk1## Wkh## prqdufk|## dovr## vwduwhg## surprwlqj## wkh## h{sruw## ri## ilqlvkhg# zrrohq## jduphqwv/## zlwk## Hol}dehwk## L## glvsdwfklqj## wudgh## hqyr|v## wr## wkh## Uxvvldq/# Prjxo/## dqg## Shuvldq#hpsluhv1# # # Wkh## fdoleudwhg## dqg## phdvxuhg## vxssruw## diirughg## wr# lqgxvwu|## lv## ehvw## uhiohfwhg## lq## wkh## idfw## wkdw## udz0zrro## h{sruwv## zhuh## shupdqhqwo|# edqqhg#rqo|#zkhq#wkh#prqdufk|#zdv#frqilghqw#wkdw#grphvwlf#pdqxidfwxuhuv#frxog# # # # # # # # # # # xvh## doo## wkh## udz## zrro## dydlodeoh## dqg## zhuh## frpshwlwlyh## hqrxjk#lqwhuqdwlrqdoo|#wr# # # h{sruw## wkh## dgglwlrqdo## surgxfwlrq1## Vxfk## pdqdjhg## frpshwlwlrq## hyhqwxdoo|## guryh# pdqxidfwxuhuv#lq#wkh#Orz#Frxqwulhv#wr#uxlq1# # # # # # # Jryhuqphqwv## dovr## wulhg## wr## fuhdwh## sulydwh## prqrsrolhv## lq## edqnlqj## ru## wudgh# +uhfdoo#wkh#Hdvw#Lqgld#Frpsdq|/#zklfk#zdv#judqwhg#fhuwdlq#prqrsro|#uljkwv#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # wudgh#zlwk#Lqgld#dqg#hqghg#xs#uxolqj#pxfk#ri#wkh#vxefrqwlqhqw,1#Exw#flwl}hqv#vdz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh## dv## lqgluhfw## irupv## ri## wd{dwlrq## dqg/## dv## ghprfudwlf## uljkwv## h{sdqghg/## irxjkw# kdug## wr## fxue## wkhp1## Vr## frpshwlwlrq## zlwklq## wkh## grphvwlf## pdunhw## zdv## w|slfdoo|# xqihwwhuhg/## zlwk## jryhuqphqwv## uduho|## lqwhuyhqlqj1## Wkh## h{whqw## ri## jryhuqphqw# lqwhuyhqwlrq#lv#wkh#fulwlfdo# # # # # gliihuhqfh#ehwzhhq#wkh#hduo|#ghyhorshuv#dqg#pdq|#ri# # # # # # # #
wkh#odwh#ghyhorshuv1 # #
Wkh#Vwudwhj|#ri#Odwh#Ghyhorshuv # # # # # Wkh## odwh## ghyhorshuv/## hvshfldoo|## qdwlrqv## wkdw## ehfdph## lqghshqghqw## mxvw## diwhu# Zruog#Zdu#LL/#vwduwhg#rxw#zlwk#rujdql}dwlrqdo#ghilflhqflhv#vlplodu#wr#wkrvh#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # hduo|## ghyhorshuv1## Lqgldq## srolwlfldqv## olnh## wr## uhfdoo## wkdw## zkhq## Lqgld## ehfdph# 44## Wkhlu#jryhuqphqwv# lqghshqghqw#lq#4<7:/#lw#kdg#wr#lpsruw#hyhq#vhzlqj#qhhgohv1 # # # # # # # # # # zhuh/## krzhyhu/## pxfk## pruh## lpsdwlhqw## iru## jurzwk/## hvshfldoo|## jlyhq## wkh# h{shfwdwlrqv## ri#wkhlu# # # qhzo|#iuhh# # # flwl}hqv1## Pruhryhu/## zkhq#wkh|#vwduwhg# # # # rxw/## wkh|# idfhg#pxfk#ilhufhu#frpshwlwlrq#iurp#ilupv#lq#ghyhorshg#frxqwulhv#wkdq#wkh#hduo|# # # # # # # # # # # # ghyhorshuv## kdg## idfhg## lqlwldoo|1## Lq## wkh## fhqwxu|## ru## vr## ehwzhhq## zkhq## wkh## hduo|# ghyhorshuv#ehjdq#lqgxvwuldol}lqj#dqg#zkhq#wkh#odwh#ghyhorshuv#vwduwhg/#wkh#frvw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wudqvsruwdwlrq## kdg## idoohq## wuhphqgrxvo|/## dqg## wkh## h{whqw## ri## srwhqwldo## frpshwlwlrq# iurp#ilupv#lq#ulfkhu#frxqwulhv#zdv#frpphqvxudwho|#pxfk#kljkhu1# # # # # # # # # Wkhlu#vwudwhj|#iru#dgydqfhphqw/#wkrxjk/#zdv#fohdu=# # # # # # # # folpe#wkh#vdph#odgghu#wkh# # # # # ulfk## frxqwulhv## kdg## grqh/## vwhs## e|## vwhs/## prylqj## iurp## wkh## ohdvw## vrsklvwlfdwhg# whfkqrorjlhv## wr## wkh## iurqwlhu## ri## lqqrydwlrq/## xvlqj## orz## oderu## frvwv## wr## vwd|# frpshwlwlyh## xqwlo## whfkqrorjlhv## lpsuryhg## dqg## wkh## dydlodeoh## fdslwdo## vwrfn/# lqfoxglqj#kxpdq#fdslwdo/#lqfuhdvhg1# # # # Wkh#rujdql}dwlrqdo#sdwk#zdv#ohvv#zhoo#odlg#rxw1#Jlyhq#wkdw#wkh#odwh#ghyhorshuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # kdg## olwwoh## idlwk## wkdw## wkhlu## vpdoo## dqg## xqghughyhorshg## sulydwh0vhfwru## ilupv## frxog# ohdg#jurzwk#dw#d#sdfh#wkdw#zrxog#vdwlvi|#wkhlu#qhhgv/#wkh|#kdg#wzr#rswlrqv=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|# frxog#fuhdwh#jryhuqphqw#hqwhusulvhv#wr#xqghuwdnh#exvlqhvv#dfwlylw|/#ru#wkh|#frxog# # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuyhqh#lq#wkh#ixqfwlrqlqj#ri#pdunhwv#wr#fuhdwh#vsdfh#iru#d#idyruhg#ihz#sulydwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilupv## wr## jurz## uhodwlyho|## xqklqghuhg## e|## frpshwlwlrq1## Lq## hlwkhu## vlwxdwlrq/## wkh# frxqwu|ᄊv#vdylqjv#zhuh#gluhfwhg#wkurxjk#d#odujho|#fdswlyh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # idyruhg## ihz## ilupv1## Jryhuqphqwv## dovr## w|slfdoo|#surwhfwhg# # # wkhlu## grphvwlf## pdunhw# iurp## iruhljq## lpsruwv## wkurxjk## kljk## wduliiv## dqg## lpsruw## uhvwulfwlrqv/## doorzlqj# grphvwlf#ilupv#wkh#vsdfh#wr#iorxulvk1# # # # # #
Wkh#Frppdqglqj#Khljkwv # # # Frqvlghu## iluvw## wkh## vwudwhj|## ri## fuhdwlqj## vwdwh0rzqhg## hqwhusulvhv1## Lq## d# ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#w|slfdoo|#lv#wkh#ehvw0ghyhorshg#rujdql}dwlrq/# # # # # # # # # dsduw## iurp## wkh## dup|1## Lw## lv## whpswlqj## iru## lw## wr## xvh## lwv## h{lvwlqj## rujdql}dwlrqdo# whpsodwhvᄇriwhq## sxw## lq## sodfh## e|## d## frorqldo## srzhuᄇwr## fuhdwh## dgglwlrqdo# ghsduwphqwv## wr## pdqdjh## lqyhvwphqw## dqg## surgxfwlrq1## Lqghhg/## Ohqlq/## lq## d## idprxv# vshhfk#lq#4<55/#srlqwhg#wkh#zd|#+lurqlfdoo|#zkloh#ghihqglqj#klv#Qhz#Hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # # # Srolflhv/#zklfk#doorzhg#pruh#iuhhgrp#wr#iduphuv#dqg#wudghuv,#zkhq#kh#ghfoduhg# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## wkh## vwdwh## pxvw## frqwuro## wkh## prvw## lpsruwdqw## vhfwruv## ri## wkh## hfrqrp|ᄇwkh# 45# ᄈfrppdqglqj#khljkwv/ᄡ#dv#kh#fdoohg#wkhp1 # # # # # Vrph## frxqwulhv## kdyh## jurzq## ulfk## iurp## vxevwdqwldo## frqwulexwlrqv## pdgh## e|# jryhuqphqw0rzqhg## ilupvᄇIudqfh## dqg## Wdlzdq## duh## h{dpsohvᄇexw## wkhuh## duhqᄊw# pdq|1## Wkh## ixqgdphqwdo## sureohp## zlwk## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## lpsohphqwlqj## surmhfwv# vxfk#dv# # # exloglqj#vfkrrov/# # # urdgv/## dqg## gdpv/## ohw#dorqh# # # uxqqlqj#frpsoh{#ilupv/# # # # lv# wkdw#lqfhqwlyhv#lq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#duh#qrw#dlphg#dw#xvlqj#uhvrxufhv#hiilflhqwo|1#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # sulpdu|#uroh#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#lv#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#wkh#vxshuvwuxfwxuh#wkdw#idflolwdwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # sulydwh## dfwlylw|ᄇlqfoxglqj## sxeolf## vhfxulw|/## wkh## ixqfwlrqlqj## ri## pdunhwv/## dqg## wkh# hqirufhphqw## ri## frqwudfwvᄇixqfwlrqv## hiilflhqwo|1## W|slfdoo|/## wklv## phdqv## d## qhxwudo# dqg#wudqvsduhqw#h{huflvh#ri#srzhu#zlwk#wkh#sxeolf#lqwhuhvw#lq#plqg/#qrw#srzhu#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdq#eh#erxjkw#e|#wkh#kljkhvw#elgghu1#Wkh#vrflrorjlvw#Pd{#Zhehu#srvwxodwhg#wkdw#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # exuhdxfudwᄊv#uhzdugv#vkrxog#frph#iurp#orqj0whup#fduhhu#surjuhvv/#vwdwxv/#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # nqrzohgjh## wkdw#kh# # # kdv## vhuyhg## wkh## sxeolf## lqwhuhvw/## udwkhu## wkdq#iurp#wkh# # # # vsrlov## ri# riilfh1## Lq#rwkhu# # # zrugv/## kh## eholhyhg## wkdw#wkh# # # devhqfh## ri#prqhwdu|#lqfhqwlyhv# # # # iru# shuirupdqfh#dffrughg#zhoo#zlwk#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#wkh#exuhdxfudwᄊv#zrun1# # # # # # # # # # Pruhryhu/## ehfdxvh## shuirupdqfh## lq## pdq|## jryhuqphqw## dfwlylwlhv## lv## kdug## wr# phdvxuh/## jryhuqphqw## riilfldov## duh## w|slfdoo|## qrw## jlyhq## prqhwdu|## lqfhqwlyhv## iru# ihdu## wkdw## wkh|#pljkw# # # irfxv## rq#wkh# # # phdvxudeoh## +iru## h{dpsoh/## wkh## qxpehu## ri## ilohv# fohduhg,#udwkhu#wkdq#wkh#xvhixo#+wkh#txdolw|#ri#ghflvlrqv#pdgh,1#Lqvwhdg/#d#sohwkrud# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#uxohv#jxlgh#wkhlu#ehkdylru1#Ehfdxvh#odujh#rujdql}dwlrqv#ilqg#lw#kdug#wr#pdqdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## lqwud0rujdql}dwlrqdo## iulfwlrqv## dqg## mhdorxvlhv## wkdw## dulvh## zkhq## frpshqvdwlrq# vwuxfwxuhv#gliihu#frqvlghudeo|#zlwklq#wkhp/#lw#lv#suredeo|#qrw#vxusulvlqj#wkdw#hyhq# # # # # # # # # # # # exuhdxfudwv## xqghuwdnlqj## phdvxudeoh## wdvnv/## vxfk## dv## lpsohphqwlqj## fohdu/## wlph0 erxqg#surmhfwv/#duh#qrw#jlyhq#vwurqj#prqhwdu|#lqfhqwlyhv1#Dv#d#uhvxow/#jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # # # # surmhfwv#wdnh#wrr#orqj/#dqg#dgplqlvwudwruv#gr#qrw#dgdsw#ioh{leo|#wr#flufxpvwdqfhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Vxfk#ioh{lelolw|#zrxog# # # # w|slfdoo|#phdq#wkh# # # # exuhdxfudwᄊv## h{huflvlqj#lqlwldwlyh# # # dqg# ylrodwlqj#vrph#uxoh1# # # Lqhiilflhqf|## dulvlqj## iurp## srru## lqfhqwlyhv## zlwklq## wkh## rujdql}dwlrq## lv# frpsrxqghg#e|#wkh#idfw#wkdw#wkh#jryhuqphqw#lv#d#prqrsro|#dqg#kdv#olwwoh#ihdu#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uxqqlqj## rxw## ri## uhvrxufhv## vr## orqj## dv## wkh## wd{sd|hu## fdq## eh## vtxhh}hg1## Wkh# frpelqdwlrq## ri## srru## lqfhqwlyhv## dqg## olwwoh## frpshwlwlrq## w|slfdoo|## uhvxowv## lq## srru# rxwfrphv#zkhq#jryhuqphqwv#xqghuwdnh#dfwlylwlhv#wkdw#vkrxog#ehorqj#wr#wkh#sulydwh# # # # # # # # # # # grpdlq1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#Dujhqwlqdᄊv#whohskrqh#v|vwhp#xqghu#vwdwh#rzqhuvkls#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # 4<;3v## zdv## qrwrulrxv## iru## lwv## lqhiilflhqf|ᄇwkh## zdlwlqj## shulrg## iru## d## skrqh## olqh# zdv#pruh#wkdq#vl{#|hduv/#dqg#vrph#exvlqhvvhv#hpsor|hg#vwdii#zkr#vroh#mre#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 46# wr#krog#d#whohskrqh#kdqgvhw#iru#krxuv#rq#hqg#xqwlo#wkh|#khdug#d#gldo#wrqh1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Klvwru|## grhv## riihu## vrph## h{dpsohv## ri## vwurqj## vwdwh0rzqhg0hqwhusulvh0ohg# jurzwk1#Xqghu#Vwdolq/#wkh#Vrylhw#Xqlrq#juhz#udslgo|#zkloh#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv## pluhg## lq#wkh# # # Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrq1# # # Lqghhg/## pxfk#dv# # # Mdsdq#zdv# # # wkh## uroh## prgho# iru## Hdvw#Dvldq#hfrqrplhv#olnh#Vrxwk#Nruhd/#wkh#Vrylhw#Xqlrq/#zlwk#lwv#vwdwh0ohg# # # # # # # # # # # # 47# jurzwk/#zdv#wkh#uroh#prgho#iru#ohdghuv#olnh#Mdzdkduodo#Qhkux#dqg#Pdr#]hgrqj1 # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkh## lplwdwruv## glg## qrw## uhdol}h## wkdw## wkh## lqfhqwlyh## iru## exuhdxfudwv## wr# shuirup## lq## wkh## Vrylhw## Xqlrq## dw## wkdw## wlph## pljkw## kdyh## frph## lqlwldoo|## iurp# uhyroxwlrqdu|## dqg## sdwulrwlf## ihuyru/## iruwlilhg## zlwk## d## grvh## ri## whuuru=## li## idloxuh## wr# frpsohwh## d## surmhfw## rq## wlph## lv## phw## zlwk## dffxvdwlrqv## ri## vderwdjh## dqg## d## ilulqj# vtxdg/#exuhdxfudwv#fdq#ehfrph#vxusulvlqjo|#hqhujhwlf1#Krzhyhu/#vxfk#lqfhqwlyhv# # # # # # # # # fdqqrw## eh## pdlqwdlqhg## ryhu## vxvwdlqhg## shulrgv## ri## wlph=## ihuyru## wxuqv## wr## f|qlflvp/# dqg#whuuru#hyhqwxdoo|#wxuqv#rq#lwvhoi1# # # # # # Pruhryhu/## hyhq## li## wkh## lqfhqwlyhv## zlwklq## jryhuqphqw0rzqhg## ilupv## fdq## eh# pdlqwdlqhg/## wkh## uhodwlrqvklsv## ehwzhhq## wkh## ilupv## ehfrph## idu## pruh## frpsolfdwhg# ryhu## wlph/## dv## srru## hfrqrplhv## ilqlvk## fdwfklqj## xs## rq## wkh## hvvhqwldo1## Jurzwk# hyhqwxdoo|#uhtxluhv#qrw#rqo|#pruh#vwhho#exw#dovr#pxfk#pruh#ghwdlohg#lqirupdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇzklfk## judgh## ri## vwhho## lv## qhhghg/## krz## pxfk/## zkhq/## dqg## zkhuh1## Wkh## Qreho# Odxuhdwh## Iulhgulfk## yrq## Kd|hn## uhfrjql}hg## wkdw## wklv## lqirupdwlrq## lv## gliixvhg## lq# vrflhw|=## lw## lv## srvvhvvhg## e|## wkh## ydulrxv## frqvxphuv## dqg## glvwulexwruv## ri## vwhho# surgxfwv## durxqg## wkh## frxqwu|1## Lw## frxog## eh## djjuhjdwhg## lq## wkh## sodqqlqj## plqlvwu|## li# hyhu|rqh#lv#dvnhg#wr#iloh#uhsruwv/#exw#d#orw#ri#wdflw#lqirupdwlrq#zrxog#eh#orvw#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#zd|#dv#wkh#uhvsrqghqwvᄊ#ihho#iru#d#pdunhw#zdv#frqyhuwhg#lqwr#d#kdug#qxpehu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Ixuwkhupruh/#wkh# # # uhsruwhg#qxpehuv# # # zrxog#eh# # # glvwruwhg#e|#hdfk#rqhᄊv# # # # # lqfhqwlyhv# ᄇzlwk## frqvxphuv## zdqwlqj## wr## vkdgh## ghpdqg## qxpehuv## xs## vr## dv## wr## hqfrxudjh# surgxfwlrq#dqg#surgxfhuv# # # # zdqwlqj#orzhu# # # qxpehuv## vr#dv# # # wr#hdvh#wkh#suhvvxuh#rq# # # # # wkhp1# Kd|hnᄊv#ixqgdphqwdo#frqwulexwlrq#zdv#wr#uhfrjql}h#wkdw#pdunhw#sulfhv#fdq#sod|# # # # # # # # # # # d## uroh## lq#djjuhjdwlqj#lqirupdwlrq#lq#d# # # # # # zd|#wkdw# # # lv## qrw## eldvhg## e|#rujdql}dwlrqdo# # glvdelolwlhv#ru#eldvhv1#Wkh#pdunhw#sulfhv#ri#ydulrxv#judghv#ri#vwhho/#iru#lqvwdqfh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#hvwdeolvkhg#hyhu|#gd|ᄇvrphwlphv#rq#rujdql}hg#h{fkdqjhvᄇe|#wkh#irufhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # ghpdqg## dqg## vxsso|## iru## wklv## surgxfw1## Surgxfhuv## dqg## frqvxphuv## gr## qrw## zulwh# uhsruwv## exw## vlpso|## h{suhvv## wkhlu## lqwhuhvwᄇzklfk## uhiohfwv## wkhlu## xqeldvhg## dqg# lqiruphg#h{shfwdwlrqv#ri#wkh#ixwxuhᄇwkurxjk#wkh#sulfh#dw#zklfk#wkh|#duh#zloolqj# # # # # # # # # # # # wr## vhoo## ru## ex|## vwhho1## Prvw## lpsruwdqw/## wkh|## gr## vr## qrw## wr## ixoiloo## d## exuhdxfudwlf# uhtxluhphqw/## exw## iurp## wkh## sxuhvw## ri## prwlyhv/## vhoi0lqwhuhvw1## Qr## pdwwhu## krz# txdolwdwlyh## hdfk## rqhᄊv## lqirupdwlrq## lv/## qr## pdwwhu## krz## ghwulphqwdo## lw## lv## wr## vrph# shrsoh/#vr#orqj#dv#wkh#pdunhw#ixqfwlrqv/#lwv#sulfhv#djjuhjdwh#doo#wkhvh#lqglylgxdovᄊ# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqirupdwlrq1#Lq#wkh#Vrylhw#Xqlrq/#wkh#v|vwhp#hyhqwxdoo|#idlohg#lq#sduw#ehfdxvh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqirupdwlrq## rq## zklfk## fhqwudo## sodqqlqj## zdv## edvhg## zdv## d## idqwdv|## wkdw## eruh## qr# fruuhvsrqghqfh## wr## jurxqg## uhdolwlhv>## exw## wklv## lqirupdwlrq## zdv## vr## fduhixoo|# pdqlsxodwhg## wkdw## hyhq#wkh# # # FLD#kdg# # # qr## lghd## ri## wkh## wuxh## zhdnqhvv## ri## wkh## Vrylhw# hfrqrp|1# Lq#vxp/#wkhuh#duh#lqghhg#vrph#zhoo0uxq#vwdwh0rzqhg#ilupv1#Exw#wkh#ehvw#vwdwh0 # # # # # # # # # # # # uxq#ilupv#w|slfdoo|#glvwdqfh#wkhpvhoyhv#iurp#jryhuqphqw#qrupv/#surfhgxuhv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # lqwhuihuhqfh#dqg#duh#riwhq#sulydwh#lq#doo#exw#rzqhuvkls1# # # # # # # # #
Idyrulqj#wkh#Ihz # # # Lqvwhdg## ri## uho|lqj## rq## vwdwh0rzqhg## ilupv## wr## sursho## jurzwk/## d## qxpehu## ri# jryhuqphqwv#kdyh#wulhg#wr#uhphg|#sulydwh0vhfwru#rujdql}dwlrqdo#ghilflhqflhv#dqg# # # # # # # # # exlog#grphvwlf#fkdpslrqv/#hyhq#zkloh#uho|lqj#rq#vrph#pdunhw#vljqdov#wr#doorfdwh# # # # # # # # # # # # uhvrxufhv1#Wkh#surfhvv#ri#sod|lqj#plgzlih/#riwhq#ghulghg#dv#furq|#fdslwdolvp#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # ehwwhu#whuphg#uhodwlrqvkls#ru#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp/#lqyroyhg#d#mxglflrxv#pl{#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqwᄊv#jlylqj#ilupv#vrph#surwhfwlrq#iurp#iruhljq#frpshwlwlrq#dqg#vshfldo# # # # # # # # # # sulylohjhv#vr#wkdw#wkh|#frxog#jhqhudwh#wkh#surilwv#durxqg#zklfk#wkh|#frxog#exlog# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## rujdql}dwlrqdo## fdslwdo/## zkloh## pdlqwdlqlqj## vrph## lqfhqwlyhv## iru## ilupv## wr## eh# hiilflhqw1# Rqh## h{dpsoh## lv## Wdlzdqᄊv## hiiruwv## lq## wkh## hduo|## 4<83v## wr## surprwh## lwv## wh{wloh# lqgxvwu|148##Wkh#iluvw#wh{wloh#pdqxidfwxuhuv#lq#Wdlzdq#zhuh#pdlqodqg#Fklqhvh/#zkr# # # # # # # # # # sxw#wkhlu# # # pdfklqhv## rq#erdug#vklsv# # # # zkhq#wkh# # # Frppxqlvwv## wrrn#ryhu# # # lq#4<7<#dqg# # # uhorfdwhg## rq## wkh## rwkhu## vlgh## ri## wkh## vwudlwv1## Vrrq## diwhu/## lq## wkh## hduo|## 4<83v/## wkh# Wdlzdqhvh## jryhuqphqw## lpsrvhg## uhvwulfwlrqv## rq## wkh## hqwu|## ri## dq|## qhz## |duq# surgxfhuv## wr## suhyhqw## ᄈh{fhvvlyh## frpshwlwlrq1ᄡ## Lw## wkhq#vxssruwhg# # # lqfxpehqwv## e|# vxsso|lqj## udz## frwwrq## wr## ploov## gluhfwo|/## dgydqflqj## wkhp## zrunlqj## fdslwdo/## dqg# ex|lqj#xs# # # wkh## hqwluh## surgxfwlrq#ri#|duq1# # # # Lw#iroorzhg# # # d## vlplodu## dssurdfk#wrzdug# # zhdyhuv1## Lw## dovr## lpsrvhg## wduliiv## rq## lpsruwhg## |duq## dqg## forwk## dqg## hyhq## edqqhg# lpsruwv## zkhq## wduliiv## suryhg## lqvxiilflhqw1## Dv## wkh## wh{wloh## lqgxvwu|## errphg/## wkh# jryhuqphqw#hqfrxudjhg# # # ilupv## wr## phujh## vr## wkdw#wkh|#frxog# # # # uhdol}h## hfrqrplhv## ri# vfdoh1# Pruh#jhqhudoo|/#wkh#wrrov#xvhg#e|#jryhuqphqwv#kdyh#lqfoxghg#huhfwlqj#eduulhuv# # # # # # # # # # # wr#hqwu|/#riihulqj#wd{#euhdnv#vr#wkdw#sulydwh#ilupv#fdq#jhqhudwh#odujhu#surilwv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # xvh## wkhlu## uhwdlqhg## hduqlqjv## wr## ixqg## lqyhvwphqw/## hqfrxudjlqj## forvh## wlhv## ehwzhhq# edqnv#dqg#idyruhg#ilupv#vr#wkdw#wkh#iruphu#ohqg#dexqgdqwo|#+dqg#fkhdso|,#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # odwwhu/#surylglqj#udz#pdwhuldov#dw#d#vxevlgl}hg#sulfh/#dqg#lpsrvlqj#wduliiv#vr#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # iruhljq## frpshwlwlrq## lv## qrw## d## wkuhdw1## Zlwk## vxevlglhv## dqg## surwhfwlrq## iurp## wkh# jryhuqphqw/## vrph## idyruhg## fkdpslrqv## kdyh## jurzq## udslgo|## dqg## surilwdeo|/# dftxlulqj#whfkqrorj|/#zhdowk/#rujdql}dwlrqdo#fdsdelolwlhv/#dqg#vwdelolw|1# # # # # # # Jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## kdv## vrphwlphv## jrqh## pxfk## ixuwkhu1## N1## \1## \lq/## dq# hohfwulfdo#hqjlqhhu#zkr#zdv#dovr#d#yrudflrxv#uhdghu#ri#hfrqrplf#wh{wv#+lqfoxglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # Dgdp#Vplwk,/# # # zdv## Wdlzdqᄊv## fklhi## hfrqrplf## sodqqhu## lq#wkh# # # 4<83v## dqg## lv## riwhq# 49## Kh#frpplvvlrqhg# uhihuuhg#wr#dv#wkh#idwkhu#ri#Wdlzdqᄊv#lqgxvwuldo#ghyhorsphqw1 # # # # # # # # # d#vwxg|#lq#4<86#wkdw#lghqwlilhg#sodvwlfv#dv#dq#lpsruwdqw#duhd#iru#Wdlzdq#wr#hqwhu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Dffruglqj#wr#d#srvvleo|#dsrfu|skdo#vwru|/#\lq#xvhg#klv#dffhvv#wr#lqirupdwlrq#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # edqn#ghsrvlwv# # # wr## lghqwli|#dq#lqglylgxdo/# # # # \1## F1## Zdqj/## dv## vrphrqh## zkr## kdg## erwk# hqrxjk#vdylqjv# # # dqg## wkh## hqwuhsuhqhxuldo## }hvw#wr# # # xqghuwdnh## d## sodvwlfv## surmhfw/## dqg# lqvwuxfwhg## Zdqj## wr## gr## lw14:## Wkh## iluvw## Wdlzdqhvh## sodqw## iru## sro|ylq|o## fkorulgh# +SYF,## zdv## exlow## xqghu## jryhuqphqw## vxshuylvlrq## dqg## wudqvihuuhg## wr## Zdqj## lq# uxqqlqj#rughu#lq#4<8:1#Kh#zhqw#rq#wr#exlog#wkh#Iruprvd#Sodvwlfv#Jurxs/#Wdlzdqᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # odujhvw#exvlqhvv1# # Wkhuh## duh/#krzhyhu/#d# # # # qxpehu## ri#sureohpv# # # zlwk#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#wkdw# # # # idyruv#d#ihz1#Qrwklqj#suhyhqwv#d#fruuxsw#jryhuqphqw#iurp#glvwulexwlqj#idyruv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # #
lqfrpshwhqw## iulhqgv## ru## uhodwlyhv/## d## sureohp#wkdw# # # kdv## sodjxhg## frxqwulhv## olnh## wkh# Sklolsslqhv1#Hyhq#li#d#jryhuqphqw#vwduwv#rxw#zlwk#wkh#ehvw#lqwhqwlrqv#dqg#fduhixoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # vfuhhqv## lqfxpehqwv/## jryhuqphqw## surwhfwlrq## phdqv## wkdw## wkrvh## zkr## ehfrph## od}|# dqg## lqhiilflhqw## duh## qrw## irufhg## wr## vkxw## grzq1## D#nh|#frqxqguxp#iru# # # # # jryhuqphqwv# wkhuhiruh## kdv## ehhq## krz## wr## uhwdlq## wkh## glvflsolqdu|## lqfhqwlyhv## surylghg## e|## wkh# pdunhw## zkloh## vwloo## doorzlqj## ilupv## wkh## urrp## wr## pdnh## surilwv## dqg## exlog# rujdql}dwlrqdo#fdsdelolwlhv1# # Vrph#jryhuqphqwv#wulhg#wr#lqvwloo#d#vhqvh#ri#hiilflhqf|#dqg#txdolw|#gluhfwo|1#Iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvwdqfh/#wkh#Wdlzdqhvh#sodqqhu/#\lq/#rughuhg#wkh#ghvwuxfwlrq#ri#wzhqw|#wkrxvdqg# # # # # # # # # # # vxevwdqgdug#oljkw#exoev#dw#d#sxeolf#ghprqvwudwlrq#lq#Wdlshl#dqg#frqilvfdwhg#wrqv# # # # # # # # # # # # ri## vxevwdqgdug## prqrvrglxp#joxwdpdwh/# # # wkh## irrg## dgglwlyh14;## Lq## wkrvh## fdvhv/## wkh# phvvdjh## wr## surgxfhuv## jrw#wkurxjk1# # # Exw#jryhuqphqwv# # # qhhg## d## vrxufh## ri#glvflsolqh# # pruh## v|vwhpdwlf## wkdq## wkh## zklpv## ri## exuhdxfudwv/## rqh## wkdw## zrxog## eh## dssolhg# zlwkrxw#vsdulqj#wkh#idyruhg#ihz1# # # # # D## vhfrqg## sureohp## zlwk## idyrulqj## surgxfhuv## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## lv## wkdw# krxvhkrogv## jhw## d## udz## ghdo/## dqg## vr## frqvxpswlrq## whqgv## wr## eh## orz1## Iru## vwduwhuv/# zdjhv#whqg#wr#eh#orz#ehfdxvh#wkh#pdq|#zrunhuv#lq#orz0surgxfwlylw|#djulfxowxuh# # # # # # # # # # # # frqvwlwxwh#d#uhvhuyh#dup|/#zdlwlqj#wr#wdnh#xs#idfwru|#mrev#dw#orz#zdjhv/#dqg#nhhs# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqgxvwuldo## zdjhv## iurp## ulvlqj## udslgo|1## Exw## ryhu## wlph## jryhuqphqwv## fdq## dovr# lqwhuihuh#lq#wkh#zdjh0vhwwlqj#surfhvv/#idyrulqj#pdqxidfwxuhuv#ryhu#zrunhuv#vr#dv# # # # # # # # # # # wr## nhhs## ilupv## frpshwlwlyh## dqg## surilwdeoh1## Dovr/## wkh## idyruhg## ilupv## pd|#sd|#orz# # # sulfhv#iru#jryhuqphqw0frqwuroohg#qdwxudo#uhvrxufhv#vxfk#dv#hqhuj|#dqg#plqhudov1# # # # # # # # # # Jryhuqphqwv## pdnh## xs## wkh## vkruwidoo## lq#wkhlu# # # uhyhqxh## e|#wd{lqj#krxvhkrogv# # # # pruh/# hyhq## zkloh## wkh## ilupv## fkdujh## kljk## sulfhv## iru## wkh## jrrgv## wkh|## vhoo## wr## wkrvh## vdph# krxvhkrogv## lq#wkh# # # fduwhol}hg## grphvwlf## pdunhwv14<## Wr## dgg## lqvxow## wr## lqmxu|/## edqnv# riihu#orz#jryhuqphqw0vhw#ghsrvlw#udwhv#iru#krxvhkrog#vdylqjv/#wkxv#fxwwlqj#ixuwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # lqwr#krxvhkrog#lqfrph/#hyhq#zkloh#pdnlqj#vxevlgl}hg#ordqv#wr#exvlqhvvhv1# # # # # # # # # # Lq#vxp/#wkh#qhhg#wr#fuhdwh#vwurqj#ilupv#pd|#ohdg#wkh#vwdwh#wr#idyru#wkh#surgxfhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh## ilqdqflhu## dw## wkh## h{shqvh## ri## wkh## flwl}hqv1## Dv## d## uhvxow/## frqvxpswlrq## lv# xqqdwxudoo|## frqvwudlqhg## lq## vxfk## hfrqrplhv1## Wkh## Lqgld## ri## p|## |rxwk## zdv## qrw# glvvlplodu## wr## wkh## Nruhd## wkdw## p|## Nruhdq## iulhqgv## vwloo## uhphpehu/## zkhuh## zdjhv# zhuh#orz/#zrun#krxuv#orqj/#dqg#frqvxpswlrq#iurzqhg#rq1#Lqghhg/#pdq|#ri#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhfroohfw## krz## glp## Vhrxo## zdv## dw## qljkw/## ehfdxvh## euljkw## qhrq## oljkwv## dgyhuwlvlqj# frqvxphu## jrrgv## zhuh## surklelwhg1## Plgqljkw## fxuihzv## erwk## hqvxuhg## vhfxulw|## dqg# suhyhqwhg#|rxqj#zrunhuv#iurp#zdvwlqj#wkhlu#hqhuj|#rq#dq#xqsurgxfwlyh#qljkw#olih1# # # # # # # # # # # # Vr## d## vhfrqg## sureohp## ri## pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp## lv## wkdw## ehfdxvh## frqvxpswlrq## lv# uhsuhvvhg/#ilupv#duh#ghsulyhg#ri#odujh#grphvwlf#pdunhwv1# # # # # # # #
H{sruw0Ohg#Jurzwk#dqg#Pdqdjhg#Fdslwdolvp # # # # # Rqh#zd|#wr#erwk#glvflsolqh#lqhiilflhqw#ilupv#dqg#h{sdqg#wkh#pdunhw#iru#jrrgv# # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#wr#hqfrxudjh#wkh#frxqwu|ᄊv#odujh#ilupv#wr#h{sruw1#Qrw#rqo|#duh#ilupv#irufhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdnh## dwwudfwlyh## frvw0frpshwlwlyh## surgxfwv## wkdw## fdq## zlq## pdunhw## vkduh# lqwhuqdwlrqdoo|/## exw#wkh# # # odujhu## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## pdunhwv## riihu## wkhp#wkh# # # srvvlelolw|#ri# # vfdoh#hfrqrplhv1#Pruhryhu/#ehfdxvh#wkh|#duh#qr#orqjhu#frqvwudlqhg#e|#wkh#vl}h#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#grphvwlf#pdunhw/#wkh|#fdq#slfn#wkh#surgxfwv#iru#zklfk#wkh|#kdyh#wkh#juhdwhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frpsdudwlyh#dgydqwdjh1# # Riwhq/## wkh## vwduwhu## vhfwru## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## lv## hdv|0wr0pdnh## exw# oderulqwhqvlyh## frqvxphu## jrrgv## olnh## jduphqwv## dqg## wh{wlohv1## Kdylqj#frqvrolgdwhg# # wkh## surwhfwhg## wh{wloh## vhfwru## dv## ghvfulehg## hduolhu/## wkh## Wdlzdqhvh## jryhuqphqw# vwduwhg#sxwwlqj#lq#sodfh#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#h{sruw1#E|#4<94/#Wdlzdqhvh#wh{wloh#h{sruwv# # # # # # # # # # # # kdg#ehfrph#d#elj#hqrxjk#wkuhdw#wkdw#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#lpsrvhg#txrwdv#rq#wkhpᄇd# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxuh#vljq#wkdw#Wdlzdqᄊv#wh{wloh#lqgxvwu|#kdg#frph#ri#djh1# # # # # # # # # # Rqfh#lqgxvwu|#ohduqhg#wkh#edvlfv#ri#surgxfwlrq#lq#wh{wlohv/#lw#vwduwhg#prylqj#xs# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## whfkqrorjlfdo## odgghu## wr## surgxfh## pruh## frpsolfdwhg## jrrgv1## Dv## odwh## dv## 4<:3/# wh{wlohv## zhuh#vwloo# # # Nruhdᄊv## ohdglqj#h{sruw/#iroorzhg#e|#so|zrrg#dqg/#fxulrxvo|/# # # # # # # zljv/## zkhuhdv## lwv## pdmru## h{sruwv## wrgd|#lqfoxgh# # # fduv/## fklsv## +vlolfrq/## qrw#srwdwr,/# # 53# dqg## fhoo## skrqhv1 # Wrgd|/## lw## lv## Fklqd/## Ylhwqdp/## dqg## Fdpergld## wkdw## frpshwh## wr# h{sruw#wh{wlohv1# # Ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|## jryhuqphqwv## wulhg## wr## hqkdqfh## lqfhqwlyhv## hyhq## ixuwkhu## e|# riihulqj#juhdwhu#ehqhilwv#wr#ilupv#wkdw#pdqdjhg#wr#lqfuhdvh#h{sruwv1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/# # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh#iruhljq#h{fkdqjh#zdv#vfdufh#lq#wkh#hduo|#gd|v#ri#jurzwk/#lpsruwv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhyhuho|## uhvwulfwhg1## Vxffhvvixo## h{sruwhuv## zhuh/## krzhyhu/## jlyhq## olfhqvhv## wr# lpsruw/## dqg## wkh## survshfw## ri## pdnlqj#prqh|#e|#vhoolqj#wkhvh# # # # # # olfhqvhv## jdyh## wkhp# vwurqj#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#h{sdqg#wkhlu#iruhljq#pdunhw#vkduh1#Lq#vlwxdwlrqv#zkhuh#iruhljq# # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## lpsrvhg## lpsruw## txrwdv/## ru## zkhuh## udz## pdwhuldov## zhuh## vfdufh/## wkh# jryhuqphqw## dovr## doorfdwhg## d## juhdwhu## vkduh## ri## wkhvh## wr## wkh## pruh## vxffhvvixo# h{sruwhuv1#Vr#erwk#lqgluhfwo|#dqg#gluhfwo|/#wkh#hiilflhqw#zhuh#hqfrxudjhg1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk## vwudwhj|## grhv## qrw## phdq## wkdw## jryhuqphqw## uhgxfhv## lwv# vxssruw## wr## lqgxvwu|1## Lqghhg/## h{sruwv## pd|## lqlwldoo|## uhtxluh## pruh## vxssruw## li# grphvwlf## ilupv## duh## wr#eh# # # frpshwlwlyh## joredoo|1#Vrph# # # frxqwulhv## kdyh## surylghg#d# # jhqhudo## vxevlg|#e|#pdlqwdlqlqj#dq#xqghuydoxhg# # # # # # h{fkdqjh## udwh## ru## kroglqj#grzq# # zdjhv## e|## vxssuhvvlqj## ru## fr0rswlqj## xqlrqv>## vxfk## vwudwhjlhv## duh## pruh## hdvlo|# iroorzhg#e|#dxwkrulwduldq#jryhuqphqwv1#Rwkhuv#kdyh#surylghg#d#vshflilf#wdujhwhg# # # # # # # # # # vxevlg|## e|## xqghusulflqj## nh|## udz## pdwhuldo## ru## hqhuj|## lqsxwv## wr## h{sruwhuv## ru## e|# gluhfwo|## surylglqj## fdvk## uhedwhv## iru## h{sruwv## ru## iru## lpsruwlqj## pdqxidfwxulqj# htxlsphqw#lqwhqghg#wr#surgxfh#h{sruwv1# # # # # Zkdw## lv## fohdu## lv## wkdw## d## qhfhvvdu|## frqfrplwdqw## wr## wkh## vwudwhj|## ri## jryhuqphqw# lqwhuyhqwlrq#wr#fuhdwh#vwurqj#grphvwlf#ilupv#lv#wr#sxvk#wkhp#wr#suryh#wkhlu#phwwoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|## h{sruwlqj1## Pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp## kdv## suryhg## hqruprxvo|## vxffhvvixo## lq## lwv# lpphgldwh## remhfwlyh## ri## jhwwlqj## frxqwulhv## rxw## ri## sryhuw|1## Lw## lv## qrw/## krzhyhu/## dq# hdv|#vwudwhj|#wr#lpsohphqw1# # # #
Plvvlqj#wkh#Wxuq # # # Pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp## lqlwldoo|## uhtxluhv## d## surgxfhu## eldv## wkdw## lv## qrw## hdv|## wr# vxvwdlq#lq#srsxolvw#ghprfudflhv1#Wkhq#wkh#jryhuqphqw/#ghvslwh#frggolqj#ilupv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#hduo|#|hduv/#kdv#wr#wxuq#dqg#sxvk#wkhp#wrzdug#h{sruwv1#Iru#vpdoo#qdwlrqv#olnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wdlzdq/#olplwhg#grphvwlf#pdunhwv#pdgh#wkh#vhfrqg#vwhs#yluwxdoo|#d#qhfhvvlw|1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # # iru#frxqwulhv#zlwk#odujh#grphvwlf#pdunhwv#olnh#Eud}lo/#wkdw#vhfrqg#wudqvirupdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # zdv#orqj#ghod|hg1# # # Rqh## frxqwu|#wkdw#ioxeehg# # # # wklv## pryh## zdv## Lqgld1## Xqghu## lwv## iluvw#sulph# # # plqlvwhu/# Mdzdkduodo## Qhkux/## Lqgld## glg## vwulyh## wr## exlog## rujdql}dwlrqdo## fdsdflw|1## Dowkrxjk# Qhkux#uhvhuyhg#lqgxvwulhv#olnh#vwhho#dqg#khdy|#pdfklqhu|#iru#wkh#vwdwh#vhfwru/#kh# # # # # # # # # # # # # qhyhu#dfwlyho|#vxssuhvvhg#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru1#Lqvwhdg/#d#v|vwhp#ri#olfhqvlqjᄇwkh# # # # # # # # # # # lqidprxv#ᄈolfhqvh0shuplw#udmᄡᄇzdv#sxw#lq#sodfh/#rvwhqvleo|#wr#xvh#wkh#frxqwu|ᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # vdylqjv## fduhixoo|1## Wklv## phdqw## jxlglqj## lqyhvwphqw## dzd|## iurp## lqgxvwulhv## wkdw# exuhdxfudwv## wkrxjkw## zhuh## pdnlqj## xqqhfhvvdu|## frqvxphu## jrrgv## +hyhq## gxudeoh# rqhv## vxfk## dv## fduv,/## dqg## lqvwhdg## lqwr## duhdv## wkdw## frxog## od|## wkh## edvlv## iru## ixwxuh# jurzwk/## vxfk## dv## khdy|## pdfklqhu|1## Wkh## uhvxow/## krzhyhu/## zdv## wkdw## lqfxpehqwv/# w|slfdoo|#ilupv#rzqhg#e|#hvwdeolvkhg#idplolhv#wkdw#zhuh#zhoo#hqrxjk#frqqhfwhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # surfxuh## olfhqvh## hduo|/## zhuh## surwhfwhg## iurp## frpshwlwlrq1## Eduulhuv## zhuh## dovr# huhfwhg#djdlqvw#iruhljq#frpshwlwlrq#lq#rughu#wr#surylgh#d#qxuwxulqj#hqylurqphqw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # Lqgldᄊv#lqidqw#lqgxvwulhv#xqwlo#wkh|#pdwxuhg#dqg#ehfdph#frpshwlwlyh1# # # # # # # # # Wkh#surwhfwlrq#Lqgld#riihuhg#wkhvh#lqgxvwulhv/#krzhyhu/#ehfdph#dq#h{fxvh#iru# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## frpsdqlhv## wr## ehfrph## ᄈShwhu## Sdqvᄡᄇfrpsdqlhv## wkdw## qhyhu## juhz## xs1## Fdu# pdqxidfwxulqj#lv# # # d## fdvh## lq#srlqw1# # # Ryhu## qhduo|#irxu# # # ghfdghv/## rqo|#ilyh# # # gliihuhqw# prghov#ri#wkh#Dpedvvdgru#fdu#zhuh#surgxfhg/#dqg#wkh#vroh#gliihuhqfhv#ehwzhhq# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp#vhhphg#wr#eh#wkh#khdgoljkwv#dqg#wkh#vkdsh#ri#wkh#juloo1#Diwhu#jurzlqj#udslgo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # mxvw#diwhu#lqghshqghqfh/#wkh#Lqgldq#hfrqrp|#jrw#vwxfn#dw#d#shu#fdslwd#uhdo#jurzwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwh#ri#derxw#4#shufhqwᄇgxeehg#wkh#ᄈKlqgxᄡ#udwh#ri#jurzwk1# # # # # # # # # # Olnh#Nruhd#ru#Wdlzdq/#Lqgld#vkrxog#kdyh#pdgh#wkh#vzlwfk#wrzdug#h{sruwv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # d## pruh## rshq## hfrqrp|## lq## wkh## hduo|## 4<93v1## Exw## ehfdxvh## wkh## surwhfwhg## Lqgldq# grphvwlf#pdunhw#zdv#odujh/#dw#ohdvw#uhodwlyh#wr#wkdw#ri#wkh#w|slfdo#odwh#ghyhorshu/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilupv## zhuh## shuihfwo|## kdss|## h{sorlwlqj## wkhlu## krph## edvh## ghvslwh## jryhuqphqw# dwwhpswv#wr#hqfrxudjh#h{sruwv1#Wklv#lv#qrw#wr#vd|#wkdw#jryhuqphqw#hiiruwv#wr#fkdqjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## sduwlfxoduo|## vwuhqxrxv/## hvshfldoo|## jlyhq## wkdw## surwhfwhg## ilupv## zhuh## dq# lpsruwdqw#vrxufh#ri#uhyhqxh#wr#wkh#uxolqj#sduw|#iru#iljkwlqj#hohfwlrqv1#Ghprfudf|# # # # # # # # # # # # dw## wklv## vwdjh## pd|## zhoo## kdyh## vhhphg## d## vrxufh## ri## zhdnqhvv=## ohdghuv## olnh## Sdun# Fkxqj#Khh#lq#Nruhd#dqg#Ohh#Nxdq#\hz#lq#Vlqjdsruh#glg#qrw#kdyh#wr#zruu|#derxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxfk#qlfhwlhv1#Dv#d#uhvxow/#Lqgld#vwd|hg#forvhg/#srru/#dqg#xqfrpshwlwlyh#orqj#diwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#hfrqrplhv#ri#frxqwulhv#olnh#Nruhd/#zklfk#zhuh#dw#vlplodu#ohyhov#ri#shu#fdslwd# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfrph#lq#wkh#hduo|#4<93v/#kdg#wdnhq#rii1# # # # # # # #
Zkdw#Kdsshqv#Zkhq#wkh#H{sruwhuv#Jhw#Ulfk=#Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq # # # # # # # # # # Qrw## hyhu|## frxqwu|## kdv## ehhq## deoh## wr## vxffhhg## zlwk## dq## h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk# vwudwhj|1#Pruhryhu/#wklv#vwudwhj|#dovr#kdv#zhdnqhvvhv#wkdw#pd|#ehfrph#fohdu#rqo|# # # # # # # # # # # # judgxdoo|/## dv## frxqwulhv## jurz## ulfk1## Wr## xqghuvwdqg## wkhvh## zhdnqhvvhv/## zh## vkrxog# wdnh## d## forvhu## orrn#dw#Jhupdq|#dqg# # # # # Mdsdq1## Qhlwkhu## zdv## uhdoo|#srru# # # diwhu## Zruog# Zdu#LLᄇwkhlu#shrsoh#zhuh#hgxfdwhg/#wkhvh#frxqwulhv#kdg#wkh#eoxhsulqwv#wr#fuhdwh# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#qhfhvvdu|#rujdql}dwlrqv/#dqg#vrph#ri#wkhlu#lqvwlwxwlrqdo#lqiudvwuxfwxuh#vxuylyhg# # # # # # # # # # ᄇexw## erwk## kdg## ghydvwdwhg/## erpehg0rxw## hfrqrplhv/## zlwk## wkhlu## fdslwdo## vwrfn# vxevwdqwldoo|#ghvwur|hg/#odujh#ilupv#dqg#frpelqhv#eurnhq#xs#ru#vxssuhvvhg#e|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # rffxsdwlrq## dxwkrulwlhv/## dqg## krxvhkrogv## wrr## grzqwurgghq## wr## eh## dq## lpsruwdqw# vrxufh#ri#frqvxpswlrq1#H{sruwv#zhuh#wkh#reylrxv#dqvzhu#wr#wkhlu#sureohpv1# # # # # # # # # # # Zlwk## d## odujh## qxpehu## ri## zrunhuv## vwloo## lq## djulfxowxuh/## dqg## zlwk## oderu# rujdql}dwlrqv## grfloh/## srvwzdu## zdjhv## lqlwldoo|## glg## qrw## nhhs## sdfh## zlwk## wkh# h{wudruglqdu|#udwh#ri#surgxfwlylw|#jurzwk#+d#phdvxuh#ri#wkh#jurzwk#lq#hiilflhqf|# # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#zklfk#lqsxwv#duh#xvhg#dqg#wkxv#d#phdvxuh#ri#wkh#surilw#pdujlqv#wkdw#fdq#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # glvwulexwhg#wr#zrunhuv#wkurxjk#kljkhu#zdjhv,1#Dv#d#uhvxow/#frusrudwlrqv#zhuh#deoh# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#jhqhudwh#vxevwdqwldo#surilwv#iru#d#zkloh1# # # # # # # Lq#erwk#frxqwulhv/#wkh# # # # # pdwxuh## edqnlqj#vhfwru# # # wrrn#rq#sduw#ri#wkh# # # # # # uroh#wkdw#zdv# # # sod|hg## e|#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw#lq#wkh# # # # frxqwulhv## glvfxvvhg## hduolhu1## Forvh## frrshudwlrq# ehwzhhq#ilupv# # # dqg## xqlyhuvdo## edqnv## lq#Jhupdq|/# # # fhphqwhg## e|#vkduh# # # kroglqjv## e|# ilupv#dqg#edqnv#lq#rqh#dqrwkhu/#ohg#wr#grphvwlf#fduwhov#dqg#glplqlvkhg#grphvwlf# # # # # # # # # # # # # frpshwlwlrq/## doorzlqj## frusrudwlrqv## wr## irfxv## wkhlu## hqhujlhv## rq## frpshwlqj## lq# iruhljq#pdunhwv1#Vlploduo|/#lq#Mdsdq/#wkh#wlhv#ehwzhhq#ilupv#dqg#edqnv#lq#wkh#edqn0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # fhqwhuhg## qhwzrunv## fdoohg## nhluhwvxv/## zklfk## zhuh## ryhuvhhq## e|## wkh## srzhuixo# Plqlvwu|#ri#Ilqdqfh#dqg#wkh#Plqlvwu|#ri#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Wudgh#dqg#Lqgxvwu|#+PLWL,/# # # # # # # # # # # # uhvxowhg#lq#d#fdqrqlfdo#yhuvlrq#ri#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp1# # # # # # # # Rqfh## wkh## h{fhvv## oderu## lq#djulfxowxuh# # # zdv## ixoo|#gudzq#lq#wr# # # # # wkh## pdqxidfwxulqj# vhfwru/## krzhyhu/## zdjhv## lqh{rudeo|## lqfuhdvhg## wr## nhhs## sdfh## zlwk## surgxfwlylw|# jurzwk#lq#wkh#hiilflhqw#h{sruw#vhfwru1#E|#4<:8/#krxuo|#zdjh#udwhv#lq#pdqxidfwxulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#Jhupdq|#kdg#fdxjkw#xs#zlwk#wkrvh#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#dqg#Mdsdq#fdxjkw#xs#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#hduo|#4<<3v1#Orz#zdjhv#wkhuhiruh#qr#orqjhu#riihuhg#d#frpshwlwlyh#dgydqwdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # iru#wkh#h{sruwhuv1#Pruh#sureohpdwlf/#rqfh#wkh#lqlwldo#skdvh#ri#fdwfk0xs#zdv#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq#dssurdfkhg#wkh#ohyhov#ri#fdslwdo#shu#zrunhu#wkdw#h{lvwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#dgydqfhg#hfrqrplhv# # # # vxfk#dv# # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#wkh#jurzwk#udwh#ri#lqyhvwphqw# # # # # # # # vorzhg## frqvlghudeo|/## dqg## vr## glg## lpsruwv## ri## fdslwdo## jrrgv1## Zlwk## wkh## srvwzdu# krxvhkrogv#frqglwlrqhg#wr#olplw#frqvxpswlrq/#dqg#vxffhvvlyh#jryhuqphqwv#lqwhqw# # # # # # # # # rq#glvflsolqhg#pdfurhfrqrplf#srolflhv/#erwk#Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq#vwduwhg#uxqqlqj# # # # # # # # # # odujh## wudgh## vxusoxvhv1## Wkhvh## lqlwldoo|#khoshg# # # wkhp#uhsd|#iruhljq#eruurzlqj#exw# # # # # 54# hyhqwxdoo|#uhvxowhg#lq#lqfuhdvlqj#suhvvxuh#rq#wkh#fxuuhqf|#wr#dssuhfldwh1 # # # # # # # # # Wr## vwd|## frpshwlwlyh/## erwk## frxqwulhv## kdg## wr## pryh## xs## wkh## ydoxh## fkdlq## ri# surgxfwlrq#dqg# # # wr## wkh## iurqwlhuv## ri#lqqrydwlrq/# # # pdnlqj#pruh# # # dqg## pruh## kljk0whfk/# vnloo0lqwhqvlyh## surgxfwv1## Pruh## lpsruwdqw/## wkh|#dovr# # # kdg## wr## lpsuryh## surgxfwlylw|# vwhdglo|1## Wkh|## fhuwdlqo|## pdqdjhg## wr## gr## wklv## lq## wkh## vhfwruv## wkdw## h{sruwhg## ru# frpshwhg## zlwk#lpsruwv/# # # wkh## vr0fdoohg## wudgdeoh## vhfwru1## Exw## sureohpv## hyhqwxdoo|#
hphujhg#lq#wkh#grphvwlf#qrqwudgdeoh#vhfwru/#lq#duhdv#olnh#frqvwuxfwlrq/#uhwdlo/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # krwhov/## zkhuh## iruhljq## frpshwlwlrq## zdv## riwhq## qdwxudoo|## devhqw## dqg## vrphwlphv# gholehudwho|#nhsw#rxw1# # # # Dowkrxjk#wkh# # # h{whqw#ri#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#wr# # # # # # vxssruw# h{sruwhuv## zdv## qdwxudoo|## glvflsolqhg## e|## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## frpshwlwlrqᄇdiwhu## doo/# uhjdugohvv#ri#krz#pxfk#wkh#jryhuqphqw#khosv/#li#|rx#surgxfh#d#vkrgg|#surgxfw#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrr## kljk## d## frvw/## |rx## zloo## orvh## h{sruw## pdunhw## vkduhᄇwkhuh## zhuh## qr## vxfk# frqvwudlqwv## lq## wkh## qrqwudgdeoh## vhfwru1## Surgxfwlylw|## jurzwk## hyhqwxdoo|## odjjhg# ehfdxvh#wkh#pdunhw#irufhv#wkdw#zrxog#irufh#wkh#lqhiilflhqw#wr#vkulqn#ru#forvh#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxssuhvvhg1# Mdsdq#kdv#iduhg#zruvh#wkdq#Jhupdq|#lq#wklv#uhvshfw1#Dv#d#sduw#ri#wkh#Hxurshdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlrq## +HX,/## Jhupdq|## lv## vxemhfw## wr## wkh## HXᄊv## uxohv## rq## irvwhulqj## grphvwlf# frpshwlwlrqᄇwkrxjk#ehfdxvh#lw#kdv#vxevwdqwldo#srzhu#lq#wkh#xqlrq/#lw#sod|v#d#elj# # # # # # # # # # # # # uroh## lq## zdwhulqj## wkhp## grzq1## Mdsdq## kdv## qrw## irxqg## dq|## htxlydohqw## h{whuqdo# glvflsolqh## lq#Dvld1# # # Dv## d## uhvxow/## wkh## forvh## uhodwlrqvkls## ehwzhhq#jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # lqfxpehqwv## kdv## ehhq## sduwlfxoduo|## ghwulphqwdo## wr## hiilflhqf|## lq## wkh## grphvwlf0 rulhqwhg#surgxfwlrq#vhfwru1# # # Pdq|#d#ylvlwru#wr#Mdsdq#lv#vxusulvhg#dw#wkh#vljkw#ri#hohydwru#odglhv#lq#krwhovᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrphq## zkrvh## mre## lw## lv## wr## xvkhu## jxhvwv## lqwr## wkh## qh{w## dydlodeoh## hohydwru/## hyhq# wkrxjk#euljkw#oljkwv#dqg#ex}}huv#fohduo|#lqglfdwh/#wr#dq|rqh#zkr#fdq#khdu#ru#vhh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zklfk#hohydwru#lv#qh{w1#Shukdsv#wkhvh#zrphq#kdg#d#ixqfwlrq#zkhq#hohydwruv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # d## qhz## lqyhqwlrq/## zkhq#vsrwwlqj#wkh# # # # qh{w## hohydwru## zdv## d## fkdoohqjh/## dqg## hoghuo|# jxhvwv#kdg#wr#eh#frd{hg#wr#jhw#lq1#Wkdw#wkh#mre#kdv#qrw#ehhq#grqh#dzd|#zlwk#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#|hduv/#ru#wudqviruphg#wr#uhwdlq#lwv#hvvhqwldo#ixqfwlrqv#+juhhwlqj#ylvlwruv,#zkloh# # # # # # # # # # # # doorzlqj#wkh#zrphq#wr#gr#vrph#xvhixo#zrun/#vxjjhvwv#dq#xqfrpshwlwlyh#vhuylfh# # # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru1# Lqghhg/## zkhq## dq## xsvwduw## kdlufxwwlqj## ilup## lq## Mdsdq## uhfhqwo|## vwduwhg## rshqlqj# vdorqv## udslgo|#dqg# # # xqghufxwwlqj#h{lvwlqj#eduehu# # # # vkrsv## e|#riihulqj#txlfn/# # # # fkhds# 55# kdlufxwv/#d#qdwlrqzlgh#dvvrfldwlrq#ri#eduehuvkrsv#wrrn#qrwh1 # Lw#fdoohg#iru#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwlrq/## surwhvwlqj## wkdw## lw## zdv## xqk|jlhqlf## wr## fxw## kdlu## zlwkrxw## d## vkdpsrr# ehiruhkdqg/## dqg## kdg## dq## ruglqdqfh## sdvvhg## uhtxlulqj## doo## eduehuvkrsv## wr## kdyh# h{shqvlyh## vkdpsrrlqj## idflolwlhv1## Wklv## lpphgldwho|## vorzhg## wkh## xsvwduw## dqg## klw# gluhfwo|#dw#lwv#orz0sulfh#vwudwhj|1# # # # # Pruh## jhqhudoo|/## dv## ulvlqj## zdjhv## lq## wkh## surgxfwlyh## h{sruw## vhfwru## sxoohg## xs# zdjhv## hovhzkhuh## lq#wkh# # # hfrqrp|/## kljk#zdjhv# # # +uhodwlyh## wr## surgxfwlylw|,## dqg## wkh# uhvxowlqj#kljk#sulfhv# # # # ri#qrqwudghg# # # jrrgv## vxfk#dv# # # kdlufxwv/## uhvwdxudqw#phdov/# # # dqg# krwho## urrpv## uhgxfhg#grphvwlf# # # ghpdqg#iru# # # wkhp1#Vr#wkh# # # # h{sruw0rulhqwhg#pludfoh# # hfrqrplhv## vwduwhg## orrnlqj#rggo|#plvvkdshq/# # # # pxfk#olnh# # # vrphrqh## zkr## h{huflvhv# rqo|## wkh## olpev## rq## rqh## vlgh## ri## wkh## erg|=## d## vxshuhiilflhqw## pdqxidfwxulqj## vhfwru# h{lvwhg#vlgh#e|#vlgh#zlwk#d#prulexqg#vhuylfhv#vhfwru>#d#irfxv#rq#iruhljq#ghpdqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # shuvlvwhg#hyhq#zkloh#grphvwlf#ghpdqg#od|#grupdqw1# # # # # # #
Wkh#Idxow#Olqh=#Wkh#Fdvh#ri#Mdsdq # # # # # # # Mdsdqᄊv## dqg## Jhupdq|ᄊv## ghshqghqfh## rq## h{sruwv## iru## jurzwk## glg## qrw## pdwwhu# pxfk#lq#wkh#hduo|#|hduv/#zkhq#wkh|#zhuh#vpdoo# # # # # # # # # # uhodwlyh#wr#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog1# # # # # # # Exw#dv#wkh|#ehfdph#wkh#vhfrqg#dqg#wklug#odujhvw#hfrqrplhv#lq#wkh#zruog/#lw#sxw#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxevwdqwldoo|#juhdwhu#exughq#rq#rwkhu#frxqwulhv#wr#fuhdwh#h{fhvv#ghpdqg1# # # # # # # # # # Zkdw#lv#sduwlfxoduo|#doduplqj#iru#wkh#ixwxuh#ri#frxqwulhv#iroorzlqj#wklv#sdwk#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#Mdsdq#glg# # # # wu|#wr# # # fkdqjh/## exw#zlwkrxw#vxffhvv1# # # # Lq#wkh# # # Sod}d## Dffrug## ri#4<;8/# # Mdsdq## djuhhg/## xqghu## X1V1## suhvvxuh/## wr## doorz## lwv## h{fkdqjh## udwh## wr## dssuhfldwh# djdlqvw#wkh#groodu1#Dv#Mdsdqhvh#h{sruwv#fdph#xqghu# # # # # # # # # suhvvxuh/#wkh#Edqn#ri#Mdsdq# # # # # fxw## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## vkduso|1## Dffruglqj## wr## d## kljk0udqnlqj## Edqn## ri## Mdsdq## riilfldo=# ᄈZh#lqwhqghg#iluvw#wr#errvw#erwk#wkh#vwrfn#dqg#surshuw|#pdunhwv1#Vxssruwhg#e|#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vdihw|#qhwᄇulvlqj#pdunhwvᄇh{sruw0rulhqwhg#lqgxvwulhv#zhuh#vxssrvhg#wr#uhvkdsh# # # # # # # # wkhpvhoyhv## vr## wkh|## frxog## dgdsw## wr## d## grphvwlfdoo|0ohg## hfrqrp|1## Wklv## vwhs## wkhq# zdv## vxssrvhg## wr## eulqj## derxw## hqruprxv## jurzwk## ri## dvvhwv## ryhu## hyhu|## hfrqrplf# vhfwru1## Wklv## zhdowk0hiihfw## zrxog## lq## wxuq## wrxfk## rii## shuvrqdo## frqvxpswlrq## dqg# uhvlghqwldo## lqyhvwphqw/## iroorzhg## e|## dq## lqfuhdvh## ri## lqyhvwphqw## lq## sodqw## dqg# htxlsphqw1## Lq## wkh## hqg/## orrvhqhg## prqhwdu|## srolf|## zrxog## errvw## uhdo## hfrqrplf# jurzwk1ᄡ56# Zkdw#wkh#orrvh#prqhwdu|#srolf|#lqvwhdg#wuljjhuhg#zdv#d#pdvvlyh#vwrfn#pdunhw# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## uhdo## hvwdwh## exeeoh## wkdw## ohg## wr## wkh## zlgho|## flufxodwhg/## dowkrxjk## h{djjhudwhg/# fodlp#wkdw#wkh#odqg#rq#zklfk#wkh#Lpshuldo#Sdodfh#vwrrg#lq#Wrn|r#zdv#zruwk#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq## wkh## vwdwh## ri## Fdoliruqld1## Frusrudwh## lqyhvwphqw## glg## slfn## xs1## Exw## lqvwhdg## ri# uhrulhqwlqj## wkhpvhoyhv## wrzdug## pdqxidfwxulqj## iru## grphvwlf## ghpdqg/## Mdsdqhvh# ilupv## vwduwhg## lqyhvwlqj## pxfk## pruh## lq## Hdvw## Dvldq## frxqwulhv## zkhuh## oderu## frvwv# zhuh## vxevwdqwldoo|#fkhdshu/# # # djdlq#zlwk#wkh# # # # lqwhqw#ri#h{sruwlqj1# # # # Frqvwuxfwlrq#dqg# # frqvxpswlrq## lq## Mdsdq## glg## errp/## exw## wkhvh## zhuh## whpsrudu|## vslnhv1## Zkhq## wkh# doduphg#fhqwudo#edqn#vwduwhg#udlvlqj#udwhv#lq#wkh#hduo|#4<<3v/#wkh#froodsvh#lq#vwrfn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#uhdo#hvwdwh#sulfhv#ohg#wr#dq#hfrqrplf#phowgrzq#zkrvh#hiihfwv#duh#vwloo#ehlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ihow1# Vr/## idu## iurp#dxwrpdwlfdoo|# # # ehfrplqj## pruh## edodqfhg## lq## wkhlu## jurzwk## dv## wkh|# ehfrph## ulfk/## h{sruw0ohg## hfrqrplhv## kdyh## irxqg## lw#h{wuhpho|#kdug# # # # wr## errvw#wkhlu# # jurzwk## rq## wkhlu## rzq/## ehfdxvh## wkh## w|slfdo## fkdqqhov## wkurxjk## zklfk## wkh|## fdq# lqfuhdvh## ilqdo## frqvxpswlrq## whqg## wr## dwursk|## gxulqj## wkh## shulrg## ri## hpskdvlv## rq# h{sruwv1## Dv## edqnv## jurz## xvhg## wr## surwhfwhg## pdunhwv## dqg## lqvwuxfwlrqv## rq#zkrp#wr# # # ohqg#wr/#wkh|#kdyh#olwwoh#fdsdflw|#wr#ohqg#fduhixoo|#zkhq#jlyhq#wkh#iuhhgrp#wr#gr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vr1## Dovr/## jlyhq#wkh# # # vwurqj#wlhv# # # ehwzhhq#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # surgxfhuv/## lw#lv# # # idu# pruh## frqyhqlhqw## iru## wkh## jryhuqphqw## wr## fkdqqho## vshqglqj## wkurxjk## grphvwlf# surgxfhuv## wkdw## duh## lqioxhqwldo## exw## qrw## qhfhvvdulo|## hiilflhqw1## Lq## Mdsdq/## pruh# jryhuqphqw#vshqglqj#jhqhudoo|#uhvxowv#lq#pruh#eulgjhv#dqg#urdgv#wr#qrzkhuh#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#srzhuixo#frqvwuxfwlrq#oree|#vhfxuhv#vwlpxoxv#ixqgv1#Hyhq#dv#Mdsdq#kdv#ehhq# # # # # # # # # # # # fryhuhg#zlwk#vwlpxoxv0lqgxfhg#frqfuhwh/#wkh#hfrqrp|#kdv#uhpdlqhg#prulexqg1# # # # # # # # # Dv## d## uhvxow/## qrw## rqo|## duh## frxqwulhv## olnh## Mdsdq## xqdeoh## wr## khos## wkh## joredo# hfrqrp|## uhfryhu## iurp#d# # # voxps/## exw## wkh|## duh## wkhpvhoyhv## ghshqghqw## rq## rxwvlgh# vwlpxoxv## wr#sxoo# # # wkhp#rxw#ri#lw1#Wklv# # # # # # lv## d#vhulrxv# # # idxow#olqh1#Lqghhg/#dq#lpsruwdqw# # # # #
vrxufh## ri#Mdsdqᄊv# # # pdodlvh## lq#wkh# # # hduo|#4<<3v# # # zdv## wkdw#wkh# # # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # glg#qrw# # sxoo## rxw## doo## wkh## fxvwrpdu|#vwrsv# # # lq#frpedwlqj#wkh# # # # 4<<3ᄆ<4## X1V1## uhfhvvlrq/## dqg# wkxv## glg## qrw## surylgh## wkh## ghpdqg## wkdw## klvwrulfdoo|## kdg## khoshg## Mdsdq## rxw## ri## lwv# grzqwxuqv1## Lw## zdv## qrw## xqwlo## wkh## hduo|#5333v/# # # diwhu## d## qxpehu## ri## idlohg## Mdsdqhvh# dwwhpswv#wr#sxoo#lwvhoi#rxw#ri#lwv#ghfdgh0orqj#voxps/#wkdw#wkh#pdvvlyh#X1V1#vwlpxoxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#uhvsrqvh# # # wr## wkh## grw0frp#exvw#khoshg# # # # Mdsdq#h{sruw#lwv# # # # zd|#rxw#ri#wurxeoh# # # # # |hw# 57# djdlq1 Wkhuh## lv## qr## qdwxudo/## vprrwk/## dqg## sdlqohvv## pryhphqw## dzd|## iurp## h{sruw# ghshqghqfh## wr## ehfrplqj## d## edodqfhg## hfrqrp|1## Hyhq## ljqrulqj## wkh## forxw## ri## wkh# h{sruw## vhfwru/## zklfk#zrxog# # # olnh## wr## suhvhuyh## lwv## ehqhilwv/## wkh## frvwv## ri## fkdqjlqj# hpskdvlv## duh## vxevwdqwldo/## dqg## wkh## wrrov## wkh## jryhuqphqw## kdv## iru## uhguhvvlqj## sdvw# glvwruwlrqv#duh#olplwhg1#Iru# # # # # lqvwdqfh/#zdjhv#lq#wkh#grphvwlf#vhfwru# # # # # # # duh#riwhq#wrr# # # kljk#uhodwlyh#wr#surgxfwlylw|#lq#wkrvh#vhfwruv1#Wr#doorz# # # # # # # # # # juhdwhu#gliihuhqwldwlrq#ri# # # zdjhv/## dv## zloo## eh## qhfhvvdu|## wr## doorz## wkh## vhuylfh## vhfwru## wr## iorxulvk/## h{lvwlqj# vhuylfh0vhfwru## zrunhuv## pxvw## vxiihu## d## vwhhs## gurs## lq## lqfrphv1## Wkh|## kdyh## vwurqj# lqfhqwlyhv## wr#iljkw#djdlqvw#vxfk#fkdqjh1#Pruhryhu/#iruhljq#hqwu|#lqwr#wkh#vhuylfh# # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru## frxog## errvw#surgxfwlylw|1# # # Exw#|hduv# # # ri#surwhfwlrq#dqg# # # # ryhuuhjxodwlrq#duh# # kdug## wr## ryhufrph/## dqg## vwurqj## lqfxpehqw## lqwhuhvwv/## olnh## wkrvh## ri## wkh## Mdsdqhvh# eduehuv/#zloo#iljkw#djdlqvw#frpshwlwlrq#dqg#hqwu|1# # # # # # # Vlploduo|/## frqvxphuv## kdyh## ehhq## wudlqhg## wr## eh## fdxwlrxv## derxw## vshqglqj/## dqg# uhwdlo## ilqdqfh## lv## qrw## zhoo## ghyhorshg1## Mdsdqhvh## krxvhkrogv/## xqolnh## wkrvh## lq## wkh# Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## gr## qrw## uhdglo|## eruurz## wr## vshqg1## Lw## lv## kdug## iru## roghu## shrsoh## wr# irujhw## wkh## h{shulhqfhv## ri## srvwzdu## ghsulydwlrq#dqg# # # lqvhfxulw|#ru# # # wkh## vxevhtxhqw# shulrg## ri## jurzwk## zkhq## vdylqj## zdv## frqvlghuhg## sdwulrwlf/## dqg## lw## lv## wkh## roghu# jhqhudwlrqv## zkr## kdyh## pruh## vshqglqj## srzhu## dqg## vwloo## ghwhuplqh## wkh## ryhudoo# sdwwhuq#ri#frqvxpswlrq1#Iru#d#zkloh/#|rxqjhu#frqvxphuv#lq#Mdsdq#zhuh#wkrxjkw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # riihu#wkh#dqvzhu1#Exw#diwhu#|hduv#ri#ghsuhvvlqj#hfrqrplf#rxwfrphv/#wkh|#wrr#vhhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## eh## uhwuhdwlqj## lqwr## wkhlu## vkhoov/## shukdsv## ixuwkhu## ghsuhvvhg## e|## wkh## hqruprxv# sxeolf## ghew## dqg## xqghuixqghg## shqvlrq## vfkhphv## wkh|## zloo## kdyh## wr## vkrxoghu158# Hfrqrplf## uhirup#lq# # # Mdsdq## uhtxluhv## wuhphqgrxv## srolwlfdo## zloo/## d## frpprglw|## lq# vkruw#vxsso|#zkhq#wkh#vwdwxv#txr#lv#shuihfwo|#frpiruwdeoh#dqg#wkh#sdfh#ri#uhodwlyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghfolqh#jhqwoh1# #
Zloo#Fklqd#Ghhshq#wkh#Idxow#Olqh#ru#Eulgjh#LwB # # # # # # # # # Zloo## wkh## zruog## ehfrph## pruh## edodqfhg## lq#wkh# # # ixwxuh## dv## wkh## odwh## ghyhorshuv# frqwlqxh#wr#jurzB#Wkh#h{shulhqfhv#ri#Jhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq#riihu#julp#sruwhqwv#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ixwxuh1#D#qxpehu#ri#odwh#ghyhorshuv#zloo# # # # # # # # # eh#mrlqlqj#wkh#udqnv#ri#wkh#plggoh0 # # # # # # lqfrph## qdwlrqv/## li#qrw#wkh# # # # ulfk/## lq#wkh# # # qhdu## ixwxuh1## Zloo## wkh|#frqwlqxh# # # wr## ghshqg# h{fhvvlyho|#rq#h{sruwv/# # # # ru## zloo## wkh|#eh# # # deoh## wr## uhirup#wkhlu# # # hfrqrplhv/## pdnlqj# wkh#qhhghg#wudqvirupdwlrq#edfn#wr#edodqfhg#jurzwk/#rqfh#wkh|#kdyh#ehfrph#ulfkB# # # # # # # # # # # # Ri#hvshfldo# # # lpsruwdqfh#lv# # # Fklqd/#zklfk#eduulqj#xqwrzdug#lqflghqwv/#lv# # # # # # # olnho|#wr# # ehfrph## wkh## zruogᄊv## odujhvw#hfrqrp|#lq#d# # # # # ghfdgh## ru## wzr1#Dowkrxjk#Fklqd# # # # kdv## d# kxjh#grphvwlf#hfrqrp|/#lw#wrr#kdv#iroorzhg#wkh#sdwk#ri#h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk1# # # # # # # # # # # # Fklqhvh#krxvhkrogv#frqvxph#hyhq#ohvv#dv#d#vkduh#ri#wkh#frxqwu|ᄊv#lqfrph#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## w|slfdo## orz## dyhudjh## lq## h{sruw0rulhqwhg## hfrqrplhv1## Ehfdxvh## hfrqrplf## gdwd# iurp## Fklqd/## dv## lq## pdq|## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv/## duh## qrw## hqwluho|## uholdeoh/# hfrqrplvwv## frqvwdqwo|## dwwulexwh## dq|## Fklqhvh## dehuudwlrq## wr## gdwd## sureohpv1## Exw# dvvxplqj#wkh# # # gdwd## duh## eurdgo|#uljkw/# # # zk|#lv# # # Fklqhvh## krxvhkrog## frqvxpswlrq#vr# # h{wudruglqdulo|#orzB#Lq#sduw/#lw#lv#ehfdxvh#Fklqhvh#krxvhkrogv#fdqqrw#uho|#rq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wudglwlrqdo## rog0djh## vdihw|## qhw## lq## Dvld/## qdpho|## fkloguhq1## Dv## d## uhvxow## ri## wkh# jryhuqphqwᄊv## srolf|## ri## doorzlqj## prvw## frxsohv## rqo|## rqh## fklog/## vl{## dgxowv## +irxu# 59## Qr# judqgsduhqwv#dqg#wzr#sduhqwv,#qrz#ghshqg#rq#rqh#fklog#iru#ixwxuh#vxssruw1 # # # # # # # # # # # zrqghu## dgxowv/## hvshfldoo|## roghu## rqhv/## duh## dwwhpswlqj## wr## lqfuhdvh## wkhlu## vdylqjv# txlfno|1## Wr## pdnh## pdwwhuv## zruvh/## pdq|## ri## wkhp## kdyh## orvw## wkh## fudgoh0wr0judyh# ehqhilwv#wkdw#rqfh#fdph#zlwk#mrev#zlwk#vwdwh0rzqhg#ilupv/#dqg#wkh#frvwv#ri#qhhghg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhuylfhv## olnh## khdowk#fduh# # # duh## ulvlqj#txlfno|#dv# # # # wkh## hfrqrp|#ghyhorsv1# # # Fklqd## lv# wu|lqj#wr#lpsuryh# # # # lwv## shqvlrq#dqg#vrfldo# # # # vhfxulw|#v|vwhp/#exw#frxqwulhv# # # # # w|slfdoo|# wdnh#ghfdghv#wr#frqylqfh#flwl}hqv#wkdw#wkh|#zloo# # # # # # # # # jhw#zkdw#lv#surplvhg#iurp#vxfk# # # # # # vfkhphv1# Fklqd## dovr## idfhv## d## pruh## wudglwlrqdo## sureohp## uhodwhg## wr## h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk# vwudwhjlhv1#Dv#d#sursruwlrq#ri#wkh#wrwdo#lqfrph#jhqhudwhg#lq#wkh#Fklqhvh#hfrqrp|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvhkrog## lqfrphv## duh## orz1## Zdjhv## duh## orz## ehfdxvh## wkh|#duh# # # khog## grzq#e|#wkh# # # odujh## vxsso|## ri## zrunhuv## vwloo## wu|lqj## wr## pryh## iurp## djulfxowxuh## wr## lqgxvwu|1# Krxvhkrog#lqfrph#lv#ixuwkhu#olplwhg#ehfdxvh#wkh#vxevlgl}hg#lqsxwv#wr#vwdwh0rzqhg# # # # # # # # # # # ilupv/## olnh## orz## lqwhuhvw#udwhv/# # # dovr## phdq#krxvhkrogv# # # uhfhlyh## orz## udwhv## rq#wkhlu# # edqn#ghsrvlwv1#Pruhryhu/#d#qxpehu#ri#ehqhilwv#vxfk#dv#hgxfdwlrq#dqg#khdowk#fduh# # # # # # # # # # # # # duh## qr## orqjhu## surylghg## iru## iuhh## e|## wkh## vwdwh/## hdwlqj## ixuwkhu## lqwr## glvfuhwlrqdu|# vshqglqj1# Ilqdoo|/#frqvxpswlrq#pd|#eh#orz#ehfdxvh#Fklqhvh#krxvhkrogv#ihho#srruhu#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # wkh|## dfwxdoo|## duh1## Vwdwh0rzqhg## ilupv## gr## qrw## sd|## glylghqgv## wr## wkh## vwdwh## dqg# ehfdxvh## krxvhkrogv## gr## qrw## rzq## wkhlu## vkduhv## gluhfwo|/## wkh|## gr## qrw## vhh## wkh# h{wuhpho|#kljk#surilwv#pdgh#dw#vwdwh0rzqhg#ilupv#dv#sduw#ri#wkhlu#rzq#zhdowk1#Ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frxuvh/#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq/#lw#lv#kdug#wr#eholhyh#wkdw#wkh#zhdowk#fuhdwhg#e|#wkhvh#vwdwh0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rzqhg## ilupv## zloo## qrw## eh## uhfdswxuhg## iru## wkh## sxeolf## jrrg1## Iru## qrz/## wkrxjk/# krxvhkrogv#eholhyh#wkh|#kdyh#qr#sduw#lq#lw/#dqg#wkh|#frqvxph#ohvv#wkdq#wkh|#pljkw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # li#wkh|#eholhyhg#wkh|#zhuh#ulfkhu1# # # # # # Orz#grphvwlf#frqvxpswlrq/#ri#frxuvh/#pdnhv#wkh#hfrqrp|#h{fhvvlyho|#uholdqw# # # # # # # # # #
rq## iruhljq## ghpdqg1## Pruhryhu/## hyhq## li## wkh## Fklqhvh## fdq## ilqg## zd|v## wr## errvw# krxvhkrog## frqvxpswlrq## lq## d## fulvlv/## lw## frqvwlwxwhv## rqo|## d## vpdoo## vkduh## ri## ryhudoo# ghpdqg/#dqg#wkxv#wkh#hiihfw#rq#jurzwk#lv#vpdoo1#Wkhuhiruh/#wkh#Fklqhvh#dxwkrulwlhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # w|slfdoo|#wu|#wr#vwlpxodwh#lqyhvwphqw#zkhq#wkh|#qhhg#wr#nhhs#xs#jurzwk#lq#wkh#idfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## d## joredo## vorzgrzqᄇdqg## wkh|## gr## qhhg## vwurqj## jurzwk## wr## nhhs## xs## zlwk## wkh# h{shfwdwlrqv#ri#wkh#shrsoh1#Wkh|#sxvk#ordqv#iurp#wkh#vwdwh0rzqhg#edqnlqj#v|vwhp# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#orfdo#jryhuqphqwv#dqg#vwdwh0rzqhg#ilupv/#zkr#wkhq#gr#pruh#ri#zkdw#wkh|#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # douhdg|## grlqj/## zlwkrxw## uhjdug## wr## orqj0uxq## surilwdelolw|1## Wkxv## idu## Fklqd## kdv# vxffhvvixoo|## iroorzhg## wkh## sulqflsoh## ᄈExlog## lw## dqg## wkh|## zloo## frph1ᄡ## Exw## udslg# lqyhvwphqw## lq## il{hg## dvvhwv## fduulhv## pdq|## gdqjhuv/## hvshfldoo|## rqfh## wkh## edvlf# lqiudvwuxfwxuh## lv## lq## sodfh1## Dv## \dvkhqj## Kxdqj## ri## PLW## srlqwv## rxw/## Fklqhvh# exuhdxfudwv## kdyh## d## shqfkdqw#iru# # # jodprxu## surmhfwvᄇydvw#dlusruwv/# # # idqf|#prghuq# # exloglqjv#+w|slfdoo|#krxvlqj#wkh#exuhdxfudwv#wkhpvhoyhv,/#dqg#hqruprxv#pdoov1#Lw# # # # # # # # # # lv## qrw## fohdu## wkdw## wklv## zd|## ri## vwlpxodwlqj## wkh## hfrqrp|## zloo## uhpdlq## vxvwdlqdeoh1# Fklqdᄊv## ohdghuvkls#kdv# # # dgdswhg#lq#wkh#sdvw#zkhq#qhfhvvdu|1#Fdq#wkh|#vwhs#dzd|# # # # # # # # # # iurp#wkh#vhgxfwlrqv#ri#h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk#dqg#il{hg0dvvhw#lqyhvwphqw#ehiruh#lw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # wrr#odwhB#Rqo|#wlph#zloo#whoo#zkhwkhu#Fklqd#zloo#ghhshq#ru#phqg#wklv#idxow#olqh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Wkh## odwh## ghyhorshuv## zhuh## qrw## lqqrydwruv## lqlwldoo|=## wkh|## kdg## qr## qhhg## wr# lqqrydwh#ehfdxvh#ulfk#frxqwulhv#kdg#douhdg|#ghyhorshg#wkh#qhfhvvdu|#whfkqrorj|/# # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh## whfkqrorj|## frxog## eh## olfhqvhg## ru## ᄈeruurzhg1ᄡ## Lqvwhdg/## wkh|## wulhg## wr# uhphg|#d# # # ixqgdphqwdo## ghilflhqf|=## wkh## zhdnqhvv## ri#h{lvwlqj#rujdql}dwlrqvᄇhyhq# # # zkloh## wdfnolqj## pruh## wudglwlrqdo## ghyhorsphqw## sureohpv## olnh## wkh## odfn## ri## edvlf# hgxfdwlrq#dqg#vnloov#lq#wkh#zrunirufh#dqg#ghilflhqflhv#lq#wkh#khdowk#fduh#v|vwhp1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## surfhvv## ri#vwuhqjwkhqlqj#rujdql}dwlrqv/# # # # lq#wkhlu# # # ylhz/## uhtxluhg## pdvvlyh## exw# fduhixo## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq1## Lqidqw## ilupv## kdg## wr## eh## qxuwxuhg1## Wkh## yhu|#uhdo# # gdqjhu/#dv#hylghqfhg#lq#Lqgldᄊv#vwdjqdwlrq#gxulqj#wkh#4<93v#dqg#4<:3v/#zdv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#lqidqw#ilupv#zrxog#ghpdqg#shupdqhqw#surwhfwlrq#dqg#wkhq#vwudqjoh#jurzwk1# # # # # # # # # # # Rqh#rswlrq#zdv#wr#lqfuhdvh#lqwhuqdo#frpshwlwlrq#e|#uhgxflqj#eduulhuv#wr#hqwu|# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## holplqdwlqj## ydulrxv## vxevlglhv1## Exw## jryhuqphqwv## wkrxjkw## wklv## zrxog## zdvwh# uhvrxufhv## dqg## eh## srwhqwldoo|## kdupixo## wr## wkh## lqfxpehqwv## zkr## kdg## rqo|## uhfhqwo|# ehfrph#surilwdeoh1#Pruhryhu/#wkh#lqwhuqdo#pdunhw#zdv#vpdoo/#pdgh#hyhq#vpdoohu# # # # # # # # # # # e|#wkh#uhsuhvvlrq#ri#krxvhkrogv#lq#idyru#ri#surgxfhuv1#Wkh#vroxwlrq#lqvwhdg#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## xvh## wkh## glvflsolqdu|#srzhu/# # # dv## zhoo## dv## wkh## dwwudfwlyhqhvv/## ri#wkh# # # odujh## joredo# pdunhw1## Jryhuqphqwv## irufhg## wkh## qrz0khdowk|#ilupv# # # wr## frpshwh## wr## h{sruw/## xvlqj# wkh#wkuhdw#ri#rshqlqj#xs#wkh#hfrqrp|#wr#iruhljq#lqyhvwphqw#wr#nhhs#ilupv#rq#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrhv1# Wkhuh## zhuh## frqvlghudeoh## suhvvxuhv## rq## wkh## jryhuqphqw## wr## suhyhqw## lw## iurp# iruflqj#wklv#fkdqjh1#Exvlqhvvhv#zrxog#kdyh#oryhg#surwhfwlrq#wr#frqwlqxh#vr#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|## frxog## ohdg## d## txlhw/## surilwdeoh/## olih1## Exw## d## ihz## jryhuqphqwv/## w|slfdoo|# dxwkrulwduldq#rqhv#wkdw#pdqdjhg#wr#dyrlg#wkh#lqioxhqfh#iurp#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # frphv## zlwk## kdylqj## wr## iljkw## hohfwlrqv/## guryh## wkh## wudqvirupdwlrq## wr## dq## h{sruw# rulhqwdwlrq15:##Wkrvh#duh#wkh#jurzwk#pludfohv#wkdw#zh#fhoheudwh#wrgd|1# # # # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/#wkhlu#jurzwk#lv#vwloo#vwurqjo|#ghshqghqw#rq#h{sruwv1#Jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # # srolflhv/#grphvwlf#yhvwhg#lqwhuhvwv/#dqg#krxvhkrog#kdelwv#iruphg#gxulqj#wkh#|hduv# # # # # # # # # # # ri#fdwfk0xs#jurzwk#frqvsluh#wr#nhhs#wkhp#ghshqghqw1#Wkh#zruog#kdv#wkxv#ehfrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # lpedodqfhg## lq## d## zd|## wkdw## pdunhwv## fdqqrw## il{## hdvlo|=## pxfk## ri## p|## whqxuh## dw## wkh# Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Prqhwdu|## Ixqg## zdv## vshqw## zduqlqj## qrw## derxw## ilqdqfh## exw## derxw# joredo## wudgh## lpedodqfhv1## Wkh## wzr## duh## olqnhg/## iru## wkh## joredo## wudgh## vxusoxvhv# surgxfhg## e|## wkh## h{sruwhuv## vhdufk## rxw## frxqwulhv## zlwk## zhdn## srolflhv## wkdw## duh# glvsrvhg#wr#vshqg#exw#dovr#kdyh#wkh#fuhglelolw|#wr#eruurz#wr#ilqdqfh#wkh#vshqglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇdw## ohdvw## iru## d## zkloh1## Lq## wkh## 4<<3v/## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv/## hvshfldoo|## wkrvh## lq# Odwlq#Dphulfd# # # dqg## Hdvw#Dvld/# # # vshqw#wkhlu# # # zd|#lqwr# # # glvwuhvv1## Krz## dqg## zk|#wklv# # kdsshqhg#lv#zkdw#L#wxuq#wr#qh{w1# # # ## # #
FKDSWHU#WKUHH #
Ioljkw|#Iruhljq#Ilqdqflqj # # #
L## Q## WKH## 4<;3V## DQG## 4<<3V/## vxusoxvhv## surgxfhg## e|#h{sruwhuv# # # olnh## Jhupdq|#dqg# #
Mdsdq#zhuh# # # orrnlqj#iru# # # pdunhwv14## Srruhu## ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv/# # # zlwk#orz# # # ohyhov# ri## shu## fdslwd## frqvxpswlrq## dqg## lqyhvwphqw/## zhuh## lghdo## fdqglgdwhv## iru## errvwlqj# wkhlu## vshqglqj/## surylghg## wkh|#frxog# # # jhw#ilqdqflqj1# # # Lq#idfw/# # # hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh|#wrr# # # # irfxvhg#rq#surgxflqj#iru#h{sruw#pdunhwv/#d#qxpehu#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv/#olnh# # # # # # # # # # # # Nruhd/## lqyhvwhg## d## orw## dv## wkh|## juhz/## lpsruwlqj## vxevwdqwldo## txdqwlwlhv## ri## udz# pdwhuldo/#fdslwdo#jrrgv/#dqg#pdfklqhu|1#Lq#grlqj#vr/#wkh|#udq#odujh#wudgh#ghilflwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#khoshg#devrue#wkh#vxusoxvhv1# # # # # Ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## kdg## wr## eruurz## iurp## deurdg## wr## ilqdqfh## wkh## gliihuhqfh# ehwzhhq#zkdw#wkh|#vshqw#+wkhlu#frqvxpswlrq#soxv#wkhlu#lqyhvwphqw,#dqg#zkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # surgxfhg/## dv## zhoo## dv## wr## sd|#lqwhuhvw# # # dqg## sulqflsdo## rq#sulru# # # eruurzlqjv1## Lq#wkh# # 4<83v## dqg## 4<93v/## pxfk## ri## wklv## eruurzlqj## fdph## iurp#rwkhu# # # frxqwulhv## ru## iurp# 5## Krzhyhu/#lq#wkh#4<:3v#dqg#4<;3v/# pxowlodwhudo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#olnh#wkh#Zruog#Edqn1 # # # # # # # # # # Zhvwhuq#edqnv/# # # uhf|folqj#wkh# # # prxqwlqj#shwurgroodu# # # vxusoxvhv## ri#Plggoh# # # Hdvwhuq# frxqwulhv/## dvvxphg## pruh## ri## wkh## ohqglqj## wr## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv1## Lq## wkh## 4<<3v/# iruhljq#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#lqyhvwruv#vxfk#dv#pxwxdo#ixqgv#dqg#shqvlrq#ixqgv#lqfuhdvhg# # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## vkduh## ri## ohqglqj## wr## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## e|## ex|lqj## wkhlu## jryhuqphqw## dqg# frusrudwh## erqgv1## Wkxv## iruhljq## ilqdqflqj## ri## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## ehfdph# lqfuhdvlqjo|#sulydwh#dqg#dupᄊv0ohqjwk1# # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/#ihz#frxqwulhv#kdyh#wkh#glvflsolqh#wr#eruurz#dqg#vshqg#fduhixoo|# # # # # # # # # # # zkloh#uxqqlqj#odujh#wudgh#ghilflwv1#Lqghhg/#odujh#dprxqwv#ri#iruhljq#ilqdqflqj#whqg# # # # # # # # # # # # wr## hqfrxudjh## zdvwhixo## vshqglqj## ghflvlrqv1## Pdq|## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## ohduqhg# iurp## whuuleoh## fulvhv## lq## wkh## 4<;3v## dqg## 4<<3v## wkdw## lw## zdv## yhu|## ulvn|## wr## h{sdqg# grphvwlf## vshqglqj## udslgo|## wkurxjk## d## iruhljq0ghew0ilqdqfhg## elqjh/## zkhwkhu## wkh# h{sdqvlrq#zdv#wkurxjk#frqvxpswlrq#ru#lqyhvwphqw1# # # # # # Wkh## errp## lq## exvwv## lq## wkh## 4<<3v## kdg## ydulhg## hiihfwv## rq## wkh## ehkdylru## ri# 6## Iru## wkrvh## olnh## Eud}lo## dqg## Lqgld/## zklfk## zhuh## frqvxplqj# ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv1 # wrr#pxfk/#wkh#ilqdqfldo#gliilfxowlhv#pdgh#wkhp#olehudol}h#wkhlu#hfrqrplhv#dqg#fxw# # # # # # # # # # # # edfn#rq#h{fhvvlyh#dqg#srsxolvw#jryhuqphqw#vshqglqj/#ohdglqj#wr#pruh#vwdeoh#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # idvwhu## jurzwk1## Wkh## exvwv## ohg## h{sruwhuv/## olnh## wkh## Hdvw## Dvldq#hfrqrplhv# # # wkdw## kdg# ehhq## eruurzlqj## wr## ixqg## lqyhvwphqw/## wr## fxuwdlo## lqyhvwphqw## vr## dv## wr## uhgxfh## wkhlu# ghshqghqfh## rq## iruhljq## eruurzlqj1## Wkh|## vwduwhg## lqwhuyhqlqj## lq## wkhlu## h{fkdqjh# udwhv/## exloglqj#xs# # # h{fkdqjh## uhvhuyhv/## dqg## lq#wkh# # # surfhvv## sxpslqj#wkhlu# # # vdylqjv# rxw#lqwr#wkh#joredo#hfrqrp|/#uhdg|#wr#ilqdqfh#dq|rqh#zkr#zdqwhg#wr#vshqg#pruh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Zlwk#wkh#Hdvw#Dvldq#hfrqrplhv#devruelqj#ihzhu#lpsruwv/#wkh#vxusoxvhv#vhdufklqj# # # # # # # # # # # iru## pdunhwv## hovhzkhuh## lqfuhdvhg/## pdnlqj## wkh## joredo## hfrqrp|## |hw## pruh# lpedodqfhg1#Wkh#idxow#olqh#ghvfulehg#lq#wkh#suhylrxv#fkdswhu#ghhshqhg1# # # # # # # # # #
Vdylqjv#dqg#Lqyhvwphqw # # # Lq## wkh## shuihfw## zruog## hqylvlrqhg## e|## hfrqrplvwv/## d## frxqwu|ᄊv## lqyhvwphqwv# vkrxog#qrw#ghshqg#rq#lwv#vdylqjv1#Diwhu#doo/#frxqwulhv#vkrxog#eh#deoh#wr#eruurz#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pxfk## dv## wkh|## qhhg## iurp## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## ilqdqfldo## pdunhwv## li## wkhlu## lqyhvwphqw# rssruwxqlwlhv#duh#jrrg/#dqg#wkhlu#rzq#grphvwlf#vdylqjv#vkrxog#eh#luuhohydqw1#Vr# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuh#vkrxog#eh#d#orz#fruuhodwlrq#ehwzhhq#d#frxqwu|ᄊv#lqyhvwphqw#dqg#lwv#vdylqjv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Lq## d## vhplqdo## sdshu## lq## 4<;3/## Pduwlq## Ihogvwhlq## iurp## Kduydug## Xqlyhuvlw|## dqg# Fkduohv## Krulrnd## iurp## Rvdnd## Xqlyhuvlw|## vkrzhg## wkdw## wklv## dvvxpswlrq## zdv# lqfruuhfw=## wkhuh## zdv## d## pxfk## kljkhu## srvlwlyh## fruuhodwlrq## ehwzhhq## d## frxqwu|ᄊv# lqyhvwphqw#dqg#lwv#vdylqjv#wkdq#rqh#pljkw#h{shfw#li#fdslwdo# # # # # # # # # # # iorzhg#iuhho|#dfurvv# # # 7# frxqwulhv1 Wkh## lqwhusuhwdwlrq#ri# # # wkhvh## ilqglqjv## zdv## wkdw## frxqwulhv/## hvshfldoo|#srru# # # rqhv# olnh#Exuxqgl#dqg#Hfxdgru/#frxog#qrw#jhw#dv#pxfk#iruhljq#ilqdqflqj#dv#wkh|#qhhghg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vr## wkh|## kdg## wr## fxw## wkhlu## frdwv## wr## ilw## wkh## forwk1## Krzhyhu/## wkhuh## lv## dqrwkhu# h{sodqdwlrq/## qrw## qhfhvvdulo|## lqfrpsdwleoh## zlwk## wkh## iluvw1## Frxqwulhv## pljkw## dovr# kdyh## fkrvhq## wr## olplw## wkhlu## iruhljq## eruurzlqj/## wkxv## lqgxflqj## d## vwurqj# fruuhvsrqghqfh#ehwzhhq#wkhlu#lqyhvwphqw#dqg#wkhlu#vdylqjv1#Exw#zk|#zrxog#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # gr## vr## li## wkhlu## lqyhvwphqw## rssruwxqlwlhv/## rqfh## wkh|## ryhufdph## wkh## rujdql}dwlrqdo# ghilflhqflhv#qrwhg#lq#wkh#suhylrxv#fkdswhu/#zhuh#kljkB# # # # # # # # Wr## wu|#wr# # # xqghuvwdqg## wklv## txhvwlrq/## vrph## |hduv## djr## L## xqghuwrrn#d# # # vwxg|#zlwk# # Duylqg## Vxeudpdqldq/## qrz## dw## wkh## Shwhuvrq## Lqvwlwxwh/## dqg## Hvzdu## Sudvdg/## qrz## dw# Fruqhoo## Xqlyhuvlw|/## lq#zklfk#zh# # # # orrnhg## dw#wkh# # # fruuhodwlrq#ehwzhhq#wkh# # # # dyhudjh# fxuuhqw0dffrxqw#vxusoxvhv# # # ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # # dqg## wkhlu## jurzwk#ryhu# # # uhfhqw# ghfdghv1## Wkh## fxuuhqw#dffrxqw#lv# # # # mxvw#wkh# # # gliihuhqfh## ehwzhhq#d# # # frxqwu|ᄊv## vdylqjv# dqg#lwv#lqyhvwphqw1#D#vxusoxv#lqglfdwhv#wkdw#wkh#frxqwu|#frqwulexwhv#vdylqjv#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # joredo#srro/#zkloh#d#ghilflw#lqglfdwhv#wkdw#lw#eruurzv#iurp#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfh## lwv## lqyhvwphqw1## D## fxuuhqw0dffrxqw## vxusoxv## w|slfdoo|## dovr## phdqv## d## wudgh# vxusoxv=#wkh#frxqwu|#h{sruwv#pruh#wkdq#lw#lpsruwv1# # # # # # # # Zh#irxqg#d#srvlwlyh#fruuhodwlrq#iru# # # # # # # ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv=# # # wkh#pruh#d#frxqwu|# # # # ilqdqfhv## lwv## lqyhvwphqw## wkurxjk## lwv## rzq## grphvwlf## vdylqjv/## wkh## idvwhu## lw## jurzv1# Frqyhuvho|/## wkh## pruh## iruhljq## ilqdqflqj## lw## xvhv/## wkh## pruh## vorzo|## lw## jurzv1## Ri# frxuvh/#d#frxqwu|#pljkw#qhhg#iruhljq#ilqdqflqj#hlwkhu#ehfdxvh#lw#vdyhv#yhu|#olwwoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhodwlyh#wr#wkh#qrup#ru#ehfdxvh#lw#lqyhvwv#d#orw1#Zh#irxqg#wkdw#wkh#pruh#d#frxqwu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyhvwv/#wkh# # # pruh## lw#jurzv/#zklfk#lv# # # # # qdwxudo=## e|#lqyhvwlqj/#lw#lqfuhdvhv# # # # # lwv## urdgv# dqg## pdfklqhv/## doo## ri#zklfk#jr# # # # wr## pdnh## lwv## zrunhuv## pruh## surgxfwlyh1## Krzhyhu/# wkh## pruh## lwv## lqyhvwphqw## zdv## ilqdqfhg## iurp## iruhljq## vrxufhv## dv## rssrvhg## wr# grphvwlf#vdylqjv/#wkh#vorzhu#lwv#jurzwk1#Lqwhuhvwlqjo|/#wkhvh#uhodwlrqvklsv#glg#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # krog## iru## ghyhorshg## frxqwulhv1## Ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv/# # # dw#ohdvw#wkh# # # # rqhv## wkdw#juhz# # idvw#rq#d#vxvwdlqhg#edvlv/#vhhphg#wr#dyrlg#vljqlilfdqw#iruhljq#ilqdqflqj1# # # # # # # # # # # Lq#fuhdwlqj#d#eldv#lq#idyru#ri#surgxfhuv/#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#kdyh#vwxqwhg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghyhorsphqw#ri#wkhlu#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv1#Wklv#pdnhv#lw#kdug#iru#wkhp#wr#xvh#iruhljq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqflqj#wr#h{sdqg#grphvwlf#ghpdqg#iru#jrrgv#dqg#vhuylfhv#hiihfwlyho|1#Lqghhg/# # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#wkh#h{fhswlrq#ri#iruhljq#gluhfw#lqyhvwphqwᄇiru#lqvwdqfh/#Wr|rwdᄊv#vhwwlqj#xs# # # # # # # # # # # lwv## rzq#idfwru|#lq#Fklqdᄇiruhljq#ilqdqflqj#xowlpdwho|#uholhv/# # # # # # # # hlwkhu## gluhfwo|#ru# #
lqgluhfwo|/## rq## wkh## zloolqjqhvv## ri## wkh## ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|## jryhuqphqw## wr## vxssruw# grphvwlf## h{sdqvlrq/## udwkhu## wkdq## rq## wkh## delolw|## ri## lwv## sulydwh## vhfwru## wr## gr## vr1# Ehfdxvh## iruhljq## ohqghuv## irfxv## rq## wkh## fuhglwzruwklqhvv## ri## wkh## frxqwu|## dqg## lwv# jryhuqphqw## udwkhu## wkdq#rq#wkh# # # # vshflilf## dwwulexwhv## ri## wkh## surmhfw## ehlqj#ilqdqfhg/# # dqg## ehfdxvh## wkh|## hiihfwlyho|## rewdlq## vhqlrulw|## ryhu## grphvwlf## ohqghuv/## iruhljq# ohqglqj#whqgv#wr#eh#pruh#shuplvvlyh#wkdq#lw#rxjkw#wr#eh/#jlyhq#wkh#ehqhilwv#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # surmhfw1## Ixuwkhupruh/## ehfdxvh## srolwlfdo## frpsxovlrqv## lqyduldeo|## irufh# jryhuqphqwv## wr## suhvv## kdug## rq#wkh# # # dffhohudwru/## frxqwulhv## whqg## wr## ryhuxvh## iruhljq# ilqdqfh## xqwlo## wkh|## duh## |dqnhg## edfn## e|## d## vxgghq## vwrs## lq## iruhljq## lqiorzv1## Wkh# hqvxlqj#exvw#whqgv#wr#vhw#edfn#jurzwk#wuhphqgrxvo|1# # # # # # # #
Wkh#Ilqdqfldo#Vhfwru#lq#d#Surgxfhu0Eldvhg#Hfrqrp| # # # # # # # D#jryhuqphqw0gluhfwhg/#surgxfhu0eldvhg#vwudwhj|#ri#jurzwk#whqgv#wr#vwxqw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # ghyhorsphqw#ri#wkdw#frxqwu|ᄊv# # # # # ilqdqfldo## vhfwru1#Ehfdxvh#edqnv# # # # duh#wrog#zkrp#wr# # # # ohqg## wr/## dqg## ehfdxvh## grphvwlf## frpshwlwlrq#dprqj#surgxfhuv# # # # lv## olplwhg## dq|zd|/# edqnv## whqg#qrw#wr#vhhn#rxw#lqirupdwlrq#ru# # # # # # # # ghyhors#wkhlu# # # fuhglw0hydoxdwlrq#vnloov1# # Wkh#ohjdo#lqiudvwuxfwxuh#wr#forvh#grzq#zhdn#eruurzhuv/#ru#wr#hqirufh#uhsd|phqw# # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#uhfdoflwudqw#rqhv/#lv#yluwxdoo|#qrqh{lvwhqw1# # # # # # Dv## zh## vdz## hduolhu/## wkh## jryhuqphqw## grhv## wu|## wr## khos## surgxfhuv## e|## vhwwlqj# ghsrvlw## udwhv## orz## lq## rughu## wr## orzhu## wkh## frvw## ri## fuhglw1## Krzhyhu/## ehfdxvh# lqwhuedqn## frpshwlwlrq## lv## olplwhg/## edqnv## whqg## wr## ehfrph## yhu|## lqhiilflhqw/## zlwk# eordwhg## vwdiiv## dqg## h{fhvvlyho|#exuhdxfudwlf# # # surfhgxuhv1## Dq|rqh## zkr## zlvkhv## wr# fdvk#d# # # fkhfn#dw#d# # # # sxeolf0vhfwru## edqn#lq#d# # # # ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|#zrxog# # # # gr## zhoo## wr# ghyhors#dq#dwwlwxgh#ri#uhvljqdwlrq#zkloh#zdwfklqj#wkh#fkhfn#fudzo# # # # # # # # # # # iurp#ghvn#wr# # # ghvn/## dgglqj#vljqdwxuh# # # xsrq#vljqdwxuh/# # # ehiruh## lw#ilqdoo|#dsshduv# # # # dw#wkh# # # fdvklhu#ᄊv# zlqgrz1## Wkhvh## lqhiilflhqflhv## dv## zhoo## dv## olplwhg## frpshwlwlrq## uhvxow## lq## dq# hqruprxv#lqwhuhvw#vsuhdg#+wkh#gliihuhqfh#ehwzhhq#wkh#edqnᄊv#ohqglqj#udwh#dqg#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # frvw#ri#ixqgv,=#lq#Eud}lo/#wkh#vsuhdg#urxwlqho|#kdv#ehhq#pruh#wkdq#43#shufhqwdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # srlqwv#hyhq#iru#vkruw0whup#ordqv#wr#frusrudwlrqv#lq#jrrg#vwdqglqj/#zkhuhdv#lw#lv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # iudfwlrq## ri## d## shufhqw## lq## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv1## Wkxv## pxfk## ri## wkh## frvw## ri## fdslwdo# dgydqwdjh## rewdlqhg## e|## vhwwlqj## ghsrvlw## udwhv## iru## krxvhkrogv## yhu|## orz## lv## orvw# wkurxjk#lqhiilflhqflhv#lq#wkh#edqnlqj#vhfwru1# # # # # # Qrw#rqo|#gr# # # # krxvhkrogv## jhw#olwwoh# # # iru## wkhlu## vdylqjv/## exw#wkh|#dovr# # # # ilqg## lw#yhu|# # gliilfxow## wr## eruurz1## Ohqglqj## wr## krxvhkrogv## lv## yhu|## ulvn|## hyhq## lq## d## prghuq# ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## olnh## wkdw## ri## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## dqg## grxeo|## vr## lq## dq# xqghughyhorshg#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp1#Phfkdqlvpv#wr#wudfn#fuhglw#klvwrulhv#vlpso|#gr# # # # # # # # # # qrw#h{lvw1#Ehfdxvh#ihz#shrsoh#kdyh#mrev#lq#wkh#irupdo#grfxphqwhg#vhfwru/#dqg#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vljqlilfdqw## sruwlrq## ri## lqfrphvᄇvxfk## dv## uhplwwdqfhv## vhqw## e|## zrunhuv## wr## wkhlu# sduhqwvᄇduh## qrw## edvhg## rq## irupdo## frqwudfwv/## edqnv## kdyh## olwwoh## lqirupdwlrq## rq# zklfk#wr#edvh#ohqglqj#ghflvlrqv1#Dqg#ehfdxvh#wkh#mxglfldo#v|vwhp#grhv#qrw#doorz# # # # # # # # # # # # # hdv|## hqirufhphqw## ri## fodlpv## djdlqvw## dvvhwv/## edqnv## fdqqrw## ohqg## hdvlo|## djdlqvw# krxvhv#ru#zdvklqj#pdfklqhv1# # # # Krxvhkrogv#gr#eruurz# # # # iurp#prqh|ohqghuv/#zlwk#nqhhfdsv#vrphwlphv#vhuylqj# # # # # # dv#froodwhudo#djdlqvw#ghidxow/#exw#vxfk#eruurzlqj#wdnhv#sodfh#dw#dvwurqrplfdo#udwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # ri## lqwhuhvw1## Wkh## irupdo## edqnlqj## v|vwhp## frxog## fkdujh## kljk## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## wr# frpshqvdwh#iru#wkh#ulvn#ri#ghidxow#+exw#orzhu#udwhv#wkdq#wkh#lqirupdo#v|vwhp,/#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxfk#sudfwlfhv# # # duh## w|slfdoo|#eorfnhg# # # e|#srolwlfldqv/# # # zkr## ᄈiljkwᄡ## iru## flwl}hqv## e|# fdsslqj## irupdo0vhfwru## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## dw## orz## ohyhov/## wkxv## pdnlqj## ohqglqj# xqsurilwdeoh## dqg## gulylqj## krxvhkrogv## wr## wkh## lqirupdo## dqg## xquhjxodwhg# prqh|ohqghuv1#Hyhu|wklqj#fkdqjhv#dv#wkh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#ghyhorsv/#exw#wklv#lv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # uhdvrqdeoh## ghvfulswlrq## ri## pdq|## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhvᄊ## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpv## lq## wkh# 4<<3v1# L#vdlg#hduolhu#wkdw#wkhuh#zhuh#eurdgo|#wzr#uhdvrqv#d#ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|#frxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # qhhg## iruhljq## ilqdqflqj=## li## lw## vdyhg## olwwoh## uhodwlyh## wr## wkh## qrup## ru## lqyhvwhg# vljqlilfdqwo|#pruh#wkdq#wkh#qrup1#Ohw#xv#qrz# # # # # # # # # frqvlghu#flufxpvwdqfhv#lq#zklfk#d# # # # #
frxqwu|#vdyhg#wrr#olwwoh1 # # #
Vdylqj#Olwwoh#dqg#wkh#4<<7#Ph{lfdq#Fulvlv # # # # # # # Jlyhq#wkdw#ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|#krxvhkrogv#ilqg#lw#kdug#wr#rewdlq#uhwdlo#fuhglw/# # # # # # # # # # # wkh|## w|slfdoo|## fdqqrw## ryhuuxq## wkhlu## exgjhwv1## Lqvwhdg/## wkh|## vdyh## iru## d## udlq|## gd|/# dqwlflsdwlqj#wkh#gliilfxowlhv#wkh|#zloo#h{shulhqfh#zkhq#wlphv#jhw#wrxjk1#Xqolnh#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwhusduw#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#wkhuhiruh/#wkh#xqghughyhorshg#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#lq# # # # # # # # # # # d#ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|#pdnhv#lw#gliilfxow#iru#wkh#jryhuqphqw#wr#xvh#hdv|#fuhglw#dv#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvwuxphqw## wr## fduu|## rxw## srsxolvw## srolflhv1## Lqvwhdg/## wkh## ghyhorslqj## frxqwu|ᄊv# jryhuqphqw## shuirupv## wkh## uroh## ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru/## eruurzlqj## dqg## riihulqj# wudqvihuv## dqg## vxevlglhv## wr## idyruhg## frqvwlwxhqflhv## vr## dv## wr## doorz## krxvhkrogv## wr# vshqg## pruh1## Vr## wkh## sulpdu|#uhdvrq#d# # # # ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|#vdyhv# # # # olwwoh## lv## wkdw#wkh# # jryhuqphqw## uxqv## odujh## ghilflwv## dqg## eruurzv## wr## ilqdqfh## wkhp1## Xvxdoo|/## wkhvh# ghilflwv## duh## fdxvhg## e|## ryhuvshqglqj## rq## wudqvihuv## dqg## vxevlglhv## wr## srolwlfdoo|# idyruhg## vhjphqwv## ri## wkh## srsxodwlrqᄇe|## srolwlfdo## orjlf## udwkhu## wkdq## hfrqrplf# udwlrqdoh1# Iru## h{dpsoh/## Nhq|d/## d## frxqwu|#wkdw#vxuylyhv# # # # rq#lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # dlg## dqg## kdg## dq# dqqxdo## shu## fdslwd## lqfrph## ri## XV'796## lq## 5339/## sdlg## lwv## ohjlvodwruv## d## edvh# frpshqvdwlrq#ri#derxw#';4/333#d#|hdu/#wd{#iuhh/#soxv#d#ydulhw|#ri#doorzdqfhv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # shunv## wkdw## hiihfwlyho|## grxeohg## wkhlu## wdnh0krph## sd|18## Lq## d## |hdu## ri## zlghvsuhdg# gurxjkw/#d#idyruhg#fdu#iru#ohjlvodwruv#zdv#wkh#Phufhghv0Ehq}#H#fodvv/#vxssruwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # e|#d# # # ᄈedvlfᄡ## prqwko|#fdu# # # doorzdqfh## ri## '7/:4<1## Wkh## ohjlvodwruv## kdg## wkh## jdoo## wr# krog#xs#d#gurxjkw0uholhi#eloo#dv#wkh|#ghpdqghg#d#kljkhu#fdu#doorzdqfh/#flwlqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vkrgg|## frqglwlrq## ri## wkh## urdgv## lq## wkhlu## frqvwlwxhqflhv## dv## mxvwlilfdwlrq1# Xqvxusulvlqjo|/## wkh## sxeolfᄊv## ghpdqg## wkdw## wkh## ohjlvodwruv## il{## wkh## urdgv## kdg## olwwoh# hiihfw/## exw## wkh## udlvh## zhqw## wkurxjk1## Wkhvh## ᄈsxeolf## vhuydqwvᄡ## hduqhg## vljqlilfdqwo|# pruh#wkdq#prvw#Nhq|dq#frusrudwh#h{hfxwlyhv#dqg#pruh#wkdq#wkhlu#frxqwhusduwv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ghyhorshg#zruog1# # # Zkhq#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#eruurzlqj#h{fhhgv#dydlodeoh#grphvwlf#uhvrxufhv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # lw## grhv## qrw## kdyh## dffhvv## wr## riilfldo## jryhuqphqw0wr0jryhuqphqw## dlg/## lw## wxuqv## wr# iruhljq## sulydwh## ohqghuv1## Ehfdxvh## jryhuqphqwv## frppdqg## vrph## fuhglelolw|/## dqg# kdyh## vrph## dffhvv## wr## eruurzlqj## iurp## pxowlodwhudo## lqvwlwxwlrqv## olnh## wkh## LPI/# ohqghuv## duh## zloolqj## wr## ilqdqfh## wkhp## iru## d## zkloh1## Nqrzlqj/## krzhyhu/## wkh# whpswdwlrqv## wkdw## idfh## dq## rssruwxqlvwlf## jryhuqphqwᄇwr## lqiodwh## dzd|## ghew## li# ghqrplqdwhg## lq## wkh## grphvwlf## fxuuhqf|## ru## wr## sloh## rq## pruh## dqg## pruh## ghew## rq# h{lvwlqj## ghew/## wkxv## hurglqj## lwv## ydoxhᄇiruhljq## ohqghuv## wdnh## suhfdxwlrqv1## Wkh|# ghpdqg## uhsd|phqw## lq## iruhljq## fxuuhqf|## +zklfk## lv## qrw## diihfwhg## e|## wkh## frxqwu|ᄊv# delolw|#wr#lqiodwh#ru#ghydoxh#lwv#fxuuhqf|,/#dqg#wkh|#vkruwhq#wkh#whupv#ri#wkhlu#ordqv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#sursruwlrq#wr# # # # wkh## frxqwu|ᄊv## lqghewhgqhvv/## vr## wkdw## wkh|#fdq#sxoo# # # # wkhlu## ordqv## dw# vkruw#qrwlfh1# # Lqvwhdg#ri#frqwuroolqj#lwv#vshqglqj/#wkhuhiruh/#wkh#srsxolvw#jryhuqphqw#wkdw#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # h{kdxvwhg#lwv#delolw|#wr#eruurz#grphvwlfdoo|#wxuqv#wr#iruhljq#ohqghuv#wr#ilqdqfh#lw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkxv## wkh## flufxpvwdqfhv## lq## zklfk## iruhljq## ordqv## duh## pdgh## duh## qrw## surslwlrxv1# Nqrzlqj## wklv/## iruhljq## ohqghuv## ghpdqg## surwhfwlrq/## zklfk## wkh## jryhuqphqw## fdq# w|slfdoo|## jlyh## rqo|## e|## hurglqj## wkh## uljkwv## ri## h{lvwlqj## grphvwlf## fuhglwruvᄇiru# lqvwdqfh/#wkh#pruh#wkh#ryhulqghewhg#jryhuqphqw#eruurzv#lq#iruhljq#fxuuhqf|/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # kljkhu## wkh## lqiodwlrq## lw## zloo## hyhqwxdoo|## kdyh## wr## jhqhudwh## wr## hurgh## grphvwlf0ghew#
fodlpv## rq## lw1## Pruhryhu/## ehfdxvh## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## pdnh## vkruw0whup## ordqv/## dq|# dgyhuvh## srolwlfdo## ghyhorsphqw## pd|## vfduh## wkhp## lqwr## uhixvlqj## wr## uhilqdqfh## wkh# jryhuqphqw1#Hyhq#pruh#sureohpdwlf/#d#vxevwdqwldo#lpsuryhphqw#lq#rssruwxqlwlhv# # # # # # # # # lq## wkhlu## krph## frxqwulhvᄇvxfk## dv## d## ulvh## lq## lqwhuhvw## udwhvᄇfdq## fdxvh## iruhljq# 9# lqyhvwruv#wr#sxoo#wkhlu#prqh|#rxw#hq#pdvvh1 # # # # # # # Doo#wkhvh#idfwruv#zhuh#dw#sod|#lq#wkh#Ph{lfdq#fulvlv#ri#4<<71#Wkh#vh{hqlr/#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vl{0|hdu#dgplqlvwudwlrq/#ri#Suhvlghqw#Fduorv#Vdolqdv#gh#Jruwdul#zdv#frplqj#wr#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # hqg1#Lq#wkh#wudglwlrqdo# # # # # idvklrq#ri#wkh#grplqdqw#sduw|/#wkh#Sduwlgr#Uhyroxflrqdulr# # # # # # # # Lqvwlwxflrqdo## +SUL,/## kh## odxqfkhg## d## vshqglqj## vsoxujh## wr## nhhs## yrwhuv## kdss|1# Grphvwlf#vdylqjv#gursshg#e|#616#shufhqw#ri#JGS#ehwzhhq#4<<4#dqg#4<<7/#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # pxfk## ri## lw## dffrxqwhg## iru## e|## dq## lqfuhdvh## lq## jryhuqphqw## vshqglqj/## ohdglqj## wr## d# fxuuhqw0dffrxqw## ghilflw## wkdw## wrxfkhg## :## shufhqw## ri#JGS#lq#53371# # # # # Hyhq#zkloh# # # wkh# qhhg## iru## iruhljq## ilqdqflqj## prxqwhg/## srolwlfdo## ghyhorsphqwv## wrrn## d## wxuq## iru## wkh# zruvh1#Lq#Fkldsdv/#djjulhyhg#shdvdqwv#urvh#xs#lq#dq#duphg#uhehoolrq#djdlqvw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw/## dqg## odwhu## lq## wkh## |hdu/## wkh## SULᄊv## suhvlghqwldo## fdqglgdwh/## Grqdogr# Frorvlr/## zdv## dvvdvvlqdwhg1## Pruhryhu/## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## ri#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# udlvhg## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## wkurxjkrxw## 4<<7/## iurp## 6## shufhqw## wr## 818## shufhqw/## jlylqj# lqyhvwruv#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#eulqj#wkhlu#prqh|#edfn#wr#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Dv## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## ehfdph## pruh## zruulhg## derxw## ilqdqflqj## wkh## Ph{lfdq# fxuuhqw0dffrxqw## ghilflw/## wkh## jryhuqphqw## vwduwhg## frqyhuwlqj## lwv## vkruw0whup## shvr0 ghqrplqdwhg## ghew## lqwr## whvrerqrvᄇvkruw0whup## erqgv## wkdw## zhuh## lqgh{hg## wr## wkh# groodu0shvr#h{fkdqjh#udwh#dqg#zrxog#surwhfw#lqyhvwruv#iurp#d#ghydoxdwlrq1#Exw#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfdo## xqfhuwdlqw|## lqfuhdvhg/## hyhq## wklv## zdv## qrw## surwhfwlrq## hqrxjk1## Lqyhvwruv# vwduwhg#vhoolqj#rxw/#frqyhuwlqj#wkhlu#shvrv#lqwr#grooduv/#dqg#ghsduwlqj#wkh#frxqwu|1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## fhqwudo## edqnᄊv## h{fkdqjh## uhvhuyhv## ehfdph## ghsohwhg/## dqg## wkh## qhz## suhvlghqw/# Huqhvwr## ]hgloor/## kdg## d## ixoo0eorzq## fulvlv## rq## klv## kdqgv## zkhq## kh## hqwhuhg## riilfh1# Hyhqwxdoo|/#dq#hqruprxv#ordq#zdv#sxw#wrjhwkhu#e|#wkh#X1V1#Wuhdvxu|#dqg#wkh#LPI# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#suhyhqw#Ph{lfr#iurp#ghidxowlqj#rq#lwv#ghewv1#Lqyhvwruv#lq#wkh#whvrerqrv# # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh# sdlg#edfn/#exw#wkh#frxqwu|#zhqw#wkurxjk#d#zuhqfklqj#fulvlv/#dqg#wkrvh#zkr#khog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wr#shvr0ghqrplqdwhg#ghew#vxiihuhg#khdy|#orvvhv1# # # # # # # Wkh## 4<<7## Ph{lfdq## fulvlv## zdv## d## fodvvlf## srsxolvw## hphujlqj0pdunhw## fulvlv/# gulyhq## e|## h{fhvvlyh## jryhuqphqw## vshqglqj1## Wkh## 4<<;## Hdvw## Dvldq## fulvlv## zdv# gliihuhqw/#iluvw#ehfdxvh#wkh#fulvlv#vwhpphg#iurp#h{fhvvlyh#lqyhvwphqw#e|#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#glg# # # vdyh## frqvlghudeoh## dprxqwv/## dqg## vhfrqg## ehfdxvh## lq#pdq|#frxqwulhv/# # # # wkh# grphvwlf#sulydwh#vhfwru#zdv#fhqwudoo|#dw#idxow1#Wr#xqghuvwdqg#zkdw#kdsshqhg/#zh# # # # # # # # # # # # qhhg#wr#h{dplqh#frusrudwh#lqyhvwphqw#lq#d#surgxfhu0eldvhg#hfrqrp|1# # # # # # # # #
Frusrudwh#Lqyhvwphqw#dqg#Pdqdjhg#Fdslwdolvp # # # # # L## dujxh## deryh## wkdw## edqn## ixqgv## duh## frvwo|## lq## d## surgxfhu0eldvhg## hfrqrp|/# ghvslwh## wkh## vxevlglhv## riihuhg## wr## idyruhg## eruurzhuv1## Lq## wkhvh## hfrqrplhv/## qhz# frusrudwh## lqyhvwphqw#lv# # # prvw#hdvlo|#ilqdqfhg# # # # e|#uhvrxufhv# # # wkdw#duh# # # surgxfhg## e|# wkh## frusrudwlrqv## wkhpvhoyhvᄇixqgv## jhqhudwhg## e|## jurzwk## lq## vdohv## dqg# surilwdelolw|1#Iru#h{lvwlqj#frusrudwlrqv#wkdw#duh#zhoo#frqqhfwhg#wr#wkh#edqnv/#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # sudfwlfh#vdyhv# # # rq#frvwo|#eruurzlqj1#Iru# # # # # frusrudwlrqv## wkdw#duh#|rxqj#dqg#gr#qrw# # # # # # kdyh#vwurqj#edqn#uhodwlrqvklsvᄇvxfk#dv#wkh#idvw0jurzlqj#exw#xqghuixqghg#sulydwh# # # # # # # # # # vhfwru## lq## Fklqdᄇlw## pd|## eh## wkh## rqo|## rswlrq1## Wkhuhiruh## frusrudwlrqv## w|slfdoo|# lqyhvw## vxevwdqwldoo|## pruh## rqo|## zkhq## wkh|## jurz## idvwhu/## zlwk## wkhlu## vdyhg## surilwv# ilqdqflqj#lqyhvwphqw1#Wkh#surgxfhu0eldvhg#vwudwhj|#idflolwdwhv#wklv#nlqg#ri#jurzwk# # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh## wkh## vxusoxv## ydoxh## jhqhudwhg## e|## wkh## hfrqrp|## lv## doorfdwhg## gluhfwo|## wr# surgxfhuv/#hqkdqflqj#wkhlu# # # # surilwv## dqg#wkhlu# # # delolw|#wr#lqyhvw/#lqvwhdg#ri#zlqglqj# # # # # # lwv#zd|#flufxlwrxvo|#wkurxjk#krxvhkrogv#dqg#d#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # v|vwhp#wkdw#lv#lqfdsdeoh# # # # ri#ohqglqj#hiihfwlyho|1# # # Wklv## nlqg## ri## uhvrxufh## doorfdwlrq## lv## ehqhilfldo## lq## vrph## uhvshfwv1## Surilwdeoh# frusrudwlrqv/#zklfk#suhvxpdeo|#kdyh#ehwwhu#lqyhvwphqw#rssruwxqlwlhv/#kdyh#pruh# # # # # # # # # uhvrxufhv## wr## lqyhvw## lq## wkhlu## h{lvwlqj## exvlqhvvhv=## surilwdelolw|## wkhuhiruh## gulyhv# lqyhvwphqw/## lpsurylqj## rq## wkh## srolwlfl}hg## lqyhvwphqw## ghflvlrqv## wkh## vwdwh## ru## wkh# edqnlqj#v|vwhp#zrxog#rwkhuzlvh#pdnh1#Wkh#gdqjhu/#ri#frxuvh/#lv#wkdw#surilwdeoh# # # # # # # # # # # # ilupv## frqwlqxh## grlqj## pruh## ri## wkh## vdph## xqwlo## wkh|## exlog## ryhufdsdflw|## dqg# h{wlqjxlvk#wkh#surilwv1#Iru#vpdoo#frxqwulhv#irfxvhg#rq#h{sruwv/#wkh#zruog#pdunhw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # w|slfdoo|#odujh# # # hqrxjk#wr# # # pdnh## wklv## srvvlelolw|#uhprwh1# # # Iru## d## odujh## frxqwu|#olnh# # Fklqd/#ryhufdsdflw|#lv#d#fohdu#dqg#suhvhqw#gdqjhu1# # # # # # # # Frusrudwlrqv#plwljdwh#vxfk#sureohpv#e|#glyhuvli|lqj1#Vrxwk#Nruhdᄊv#fkdherov# # # # # # # # # ᄇfrqjorphudwhv## zlwk## exvlqhvvhv## lq## duhdv## dv## glyhuvh## dv## frqvwuxfwlrq## dqg# hohfwurqlfvᄇru#Lqgldᄊv#idplo|0rzqhg#frqjorphudwhv/#olnh#wkh#Wdwdv#ru#wkh#Eluodv/# # # # # # # # # # hvvhqwldoo|#wu|#wr#uhsolfdwh#wkh#uroh#ri#wkh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#e|#fuhdwlqj#dq#lqwhuqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdslwdo## pdunhw#zlwklq#wkh# # # # frqjorphudwh1## Dowkrxjk#wkh# # # orvv## ri#frusrudwh# # # irfxv## lq# frqjorphudwhv## kdv## riwhq## ehhq## irxqg## wr## eh## d## sureohp## lq## ghyhorshg## frxqwulhv/# uhvxowlqj#lq#vwrulhg# # # # frusrudwlrqv## olnh## LWW## ru## Olwwrq#Lqgxvwulhv# # # ehlqj#eurnhq#xs/# # # frqjorphudwhv## kdyh## suryhg## yhu|## ydoxdeoh## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## ehfdxvh## wkh# :# dowhuqdwlyhᄇuho|lqj#rq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#iru#ixqgvᄇlv#vr#lqihulru1 # # # # # # # # Ri#frxuvh/#li#frusrudwlrqv#zdqw#wr#jurz# # # # # # # # uhdoo|#idvw/#lqwhuqdo#ixqgv#pd|#qrw#eh# # # # # # # hqrxjk1#Dovr/#qhz#hqwudqwv#lqwr#hphujlqj#lqgxvwulhv#qhhg#ilqdqflqj1#Idvw0jurzlqj# # # # # # # # # # |rxqj#lqgxvwulhv#pd|#wkhuhiruh#pryh#wr#eruurzlqj#iurp#grphvwlf#edqnv1#Dqg#li# # # # # # # # # # # # grphvwlf## vdylqjv## duh## qrw## hqrxjk/## wkh|## kdyh## wr## eruurz## iurp#iruhljq# # # lqyhvwruv1# Wklv#lv#zkdw#frusrudwlrqv#lq#Hdvw#Dvldq#frxqwulhv#glg#lq#wkh#hduo|#4<<3v1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
Lqyhvwlqj#Wrr#Pxfk#dqg#wkh#4<<;#Hdvw#Dvldq#Fulvlv # # # # # # # # # Zh#duh#douhdg|#idploldu#zlwk#wkh#h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk#sdwk#iroorzhg#e|#wkh#Hdvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dvldq## hfrqrplhv1## Kdylqj## hqmr|hg## d## shulrg## ri## udslg## jurzwk/## wkhvh## hfrqrplhv# vwduwhg## lqfuhdvlqj#wkhlu# # # lqyhvwphqw/## ilqdqfhg## zlwk#vl}hdeoh# # # fdslwdo## lqiorzv## iurp# deurdg## lq## wkh## hduo|## 4<<3v1## Lqyhvwphqw## dv## d## iudfwlrq## ri## JGS/## dyhudjhg## dfurvv# Nruhd/## Pdod|vld/## dqg## Wkdlodqg/## lqfuhdvhg## iurp## dq## douhdg|## kljk## ohyho## ri## 5<# shufhqw#lq#4<;;#wr#dq#h{wudruglqdulo|#kljk#75#shufhqw#lq#4<<91# # # # # # # # # # # \hw#wkhvh#hfrqrplhv#vlpso|#glg#qrw#kdyh#wkh#fdsdflw|#wr#xqghuwdnh#wklv#ohyho#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyhvwphqw## hiihfwlyho|1## Dpelwlrxv## frusrudwlrqv## guhdphg## ri## vlolfrq0zdihu# ideulfdwlrq## idflolwlhv/## shwurfkhplfdo## frpsoh{hv/## dqg## lqwhjudwhg## vwhho## sodqwv1## D# '415#eloolrq#vhplfrqgxfwru#sodqw#vwduwhg#lq#Wkdlodqg#lq#Ghfhpehu#4<<8#dv#d#mrlqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # yhqwxuh## ehwzhhq## Wh{dv## Lqvwuxphqwv## dqg## wkh## Doskdwhf## jurxs## zdv## w|slfdo1;## Wkh# ideulfdwlrq#idflolw|#zdv#vwdwh0ri0wkh0duw/#lqwhqghg#wr#surgxfh#490 # # # # # # # # dqg#970phjdelw# # g|qdplf#udqgrp0dffhvv#phpru|#fklsv/#zlwk#wkh#rxwsxw#wr#eh#sxufkdvhg#e|#Wh{dv# # # # # # # # # # # # Lqvwuxphqwv1## Wkh## hyhqwxdo## dlp#zdv# # # wr## exlog## d## 7/3330dfuh## kljk0whfk#sdun/# # # fdoohg# Doskd## Whfkqrsrolv/## wr## ulydo## Wdlzdqᄊv## idprxv## Kvlqfkx#Vflhqfh0Edvhg# # # Lqgxvwuldo# Sdun1#Wkh#ylvlrq#zdv#judqg/#shukdsv#ryhuo|#vr1# # # # # # # # Diwhu## wkhlu## lqlwldo## uroh## lq## gluhfwlqj## fuhglw## dqg## fuhdwlqj## vwurqj## qdwlrqdo# fkdpslrqv/## Hdvw## Dvldq## jryhuqphqwv## zlwkguhz## iurp## wkh## exvlqhvv## ri## doorfdwlqj# fuhglw/## d## wdvn#wkdw#kdg# # # # ehfrph## pxfk#pruh# # # gliilfxow#dv# # # exvlqhvvhv## pryhg## xs## wkh# odgghu## ri## ghyhorsphqw## lqwr## pruh## frpsolfdwhg## whfkqrorjlhv1## Wkh## wdvn## ri## fuhglw# doorfdwlrq#wkhq#ghyroyhg#wr#grphvwlf#edqnv1# # # # # # Grphvwlf## edqnv## klvwrulfdoo|#kdg# # # ryhufrph## wkh## lpshglphqwv## wr## ohqglqjᄇvxfk# dv#wkh#gliilfxowlhv#ri#hqiruflqj#uhsd|phqwᄇe|#ghyhorslqj#qhdu0lqfhvwxrxv/#orqj0 # # # # # # # # whup#uhodwlrqvklsv#zlwk#ilupv1#Uhjxodu#ylvlwv#dqg#phhwlqjv#zlwk#folhqwv#jdyh#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # dffhvv## wr## lqirupdwlrq## wkdw## zdv## qrw## sxeolf/## dv## glg## furvv0vkduhkroglqjv## dqg# phpehuvkls## rq## wkh## frpsdqlhvᄊ## erdugv1## Ixuwkhupruh/## jlyhq## wkh## gliilfxow|## wkdw# rxwvlghuv## kdg## lq## dffhvvlqj## vxfk## lqirupdwlrq/## wkh## edqnv## kdg## d## krog## ryhu## wkhlu# eruurzhuv1## Eruurzhuv## uhsdlg## iru## ihdu## wkdw## wkhlu## edqn#zrxog# # # fxw## wkhp#rii# # # iurp# ixuwkhu#ixqgv#dqg#qr#rqh#hovh#zrxog#vwhs#xs#wr#ohqg1# # # # # # # # # # # Vxfk## uhodwlrqvklsv## fduulhg## frvwv1## Edqnv## frxog## qrw## ohqg## hdvlo|## rxwvlgh## wkhlu# h{lvwlqj#flufoh#ri#uhodwlrqvklsv/#dqg#wkh|#ulvnhg#vxssruwlqj#folhqw#ilupv#orqj#diwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#vkrxog#kdyh#ehhq#forvhg#grzq1#Rxwvlghuv#kdg#olwwoh#lghd#ri#zkdw#zdv#uhdoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jrlqj#rq#lq#ilupv1#Frusrudwh#sudfwlfhv#zhuh#qrw#wudqvsduhqw>#qru#zhuh#fdvk#iorzv# # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwklq#ru# # # ehwzhhq#wkh# # # h{whqvlyh## frusrudwh## s|udplgv## dqg## furvv0kroglqjv1## Lw#zdv# # gliilfxow## wr## dvvhvv## wkh## h{whqw## wr## zklfk#d# # # frusrudwlrq#zdv# # # forvh## wr## edqnv## ru## wkh# jryhuqphqw## dqg## wkh## h{whqw## ri## lpsolflw## ru## h{solflw## vxssruw## lw## frxog## frxqw## rq1# Ixuwkhupruh/#wkh#uhodwlyh#sulrulw|#ri#rwkhu#lqyhvwruv#lq#fodlpv#wr#frusrudwh#dvvhwv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq## fdvh## ri## oltxlgdwlrq## zdv## xqfhuwdlq/## dqg## wkh## devhqfh## ri## d## fohdu/## hiihfwlyho|# lpsohphqwhg#edqnuxswf|#frgh#ixuwkhu#uhgxfhg#lqyhvwru#frqilghqfh1# # # # # # # Dv## frusrudwlrqv## lqyhvwhg## dw#d# # # idvwhu## udwh## wkdq#frxog# # # eh## ilqdqfhg## e|#grphvwlf# # vdylqjv/#wkh|#kdg#wr#wxuq#wr#iruhljq#fdslwdo1#Exw#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv/#pdq|#ri#zkrp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## edqnv/## glg## qrw## nqrz## pxfk## derxw## grphvwlf## frusrudwlrqv## dqg## kdg## olwwoh# frqilghqfh## wkdw## wkh|## zrxog## eh## deoh## wr## hqirufh## wkhlu## uljkwv## lq## frxuw1## Xqolnh#
grphvwlf## edqnv/## zklfk#hqmr|hg# # # forvh## uhodwlrqvklsv## zlwk#ilupv/# # # iruhljqhuv## zhuh# qrw## zloolqj## wr## ohqg## orqj## whup## dqg## ohdyh## wkhpvhoyhv## h{srvhg## wr## srwhqwldo# pdoihdvdqfh#e|#frusrudwlrqv1# # # Lqvwhdg/#iruhljq#fuhglwruv#ohqw#vkruw#whup/#lq#iruhljq#fxuuhqf|/#dqg#riwhq#qrw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## frusrudwlrq## gluhfwo|## exw## wr## wkh## grphvwlf## edqn/## zklfk## wkhq## ohqw## wr## wkh# frusrudwlrqv1#Ohqglqj#wr#wkh#grphvwlf#edqn#hiihfwlyho|#sodfhg#wkh#jryhuqphqw#rq# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## krrn1## Xqohvv## lw## zdv## zloolqj## wr## vhh## lwv## edqnv## idlo/## wkh## ehwwlqj## zdv## wkdw## wkh# jryhuqphqw/## zklfk## zdv## lq## ilqh## khdowk/## zrxog## edlo## rxw## d## glvwuhvvhg## edqn/## dqg# khqfh## lwv## iruhljq## ohqghuv1## Rwkhu## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## fdph## lq## wkurxjk## wkh## htxlw|# pdunhwv#dv#sruwirolr#lqyhvwruv/#frqilghqw#wkdw#wkh|#frxog#vhoo#dqg#ghsduw#dw#wkh#iluvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vljq#ri#wurxeoh1# # # Wkh#ordqv#wkdw#grphvwlf#frusrudwlrqv#wrrn#iurp#wkhlu#uhodwlrqvkls#edqnv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # dovr#w|slfdoo|#ghqrplqdwhg#lq#iruhljq#fxuuhqf|1#Edqnv#zdqwhg#wr#riiordg#fxuuhqf|# # # # # # # # # # # ulvn## rqwr## ilupv1## Wkh## ilupv## zhuh## zloolqj## wr## ehdu## wklv## ulvn## ehfdxvh## ordqv# ghqrplqdwhg## lq## iruhljq## fxuuhqflhv## kdg## orzhu## lqwhuhvw## udwhv/## dqg## wkh## grphvwlf# fxuuhqf|#kdg#ehhq#uhodwlyho|#vwdeoh#djdlqvw#iruhljq#fxuuhqflhv1# # # # # # # # Wkh#sureohp/#wkhuhiruh/#zdv#wkdw#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp#zdv#qrw#htxlsshg#wr#ghdo# # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk## d## sohqwlixo## vxsso|## ri## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## prqh|## iurp#rxwvlgh1# # # Zkhq## prqh|## zdv# vfdufh## dqg## wkh## jryhuqphqw## gluhfwhg## ohqglqj/## odujh## surmhfwv## zhuh## vfuxwlql}hg# fduhixoo|## e|## wkh## jryhuqphqw## ehiruh## lw## gluhfwhg## fhuwdlq## edqnv## wr## ilqdqfh## wkhp1# Dowkrxjk## wkrvh## forvh## wr## wkh## jryhuqphqw## ehqhilwhg## h{fhvvlyho|## iurp## wklv# sulylohjhg## dffhvv## wr## ilqdqfh/## wkhuh## zdv## dw#ohdvw#d# # # # od|hu## ri#ryhuvljkw1# # # Pruhryhu/# frusrudwlrqv## kdg## ehhq#fduhixo# # # ehfdxvh## ghidxowv## djdlqvw#wkhlu# # # wudglwlrqdo## ohqghuv# frxog## phdq## d## shupdqhqw## fxwrii## ri## ixqglqj1## Exw## qrz/## zlwk## prqh|## sohqwlixoo|# vxssolhg## e|#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv# # # # zkr## wkhpvhoyhv## h{huflvhg## olwwoh## vfuxwlq|#ehfdxvh# # wkh|#wkrxjkw#wkh|#zhuh#zhoo#surwhfwhg/#frpshwlwlrq#wr#pdnh#ordqv#khdwhg#xs/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # grphvwlf## frusrudwlrqvᄊ#ihdu# # # ri#ehlqj#fxw#rii#e|#grphvwlf# # # # # # # edqnv## ehfdph## uhprwh1# Frusrudwlrqv#ehfdph#ohvv#fduhixo/#dqg#grphvwlf#edqnv/#iorrghg#zlwk#prqh|#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # kdg#wr#eh#ohqw/#glg#qrw#frpshqvdwh#e|#lqfuhdvlqj#wkhlu#rzq#gloljhqfh1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#Hdvw#Dvldq#fulvlv#zdv#wkxv#odujho|#d#uhvxow#ri#frusrudwh#ryhulqyhvwphqw/#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # frpphufldo## uhdo## hvwdwh## dv## zhoo## dv## pdqxidfwxulqj1## Dqg## dowkrxjk## wkh## zhoo0 frqqhfwhg#holwh#dqg#lqyhvwruv#vwrrg#wr#ehqhilw#li#wklqjv#zhqw#zhoo/#xowlpdwho|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvnv## ri## dq## hfrqrplf## froodsvh## zhuh## eruqh## e|## wkh## jryhuqphqw## dqg## khqfh## e|# fxuuhqw## dqg## ixwxuh## jhqhudwlrqv## ri## grphvwlf## wd{sd|huv1## Iruhljq## eruurzlqj## zdv# hvvhqwldoo|## d## zd|## iru## wkh## frxqwu|ᄊv## sulydwh## vhfwru## wr## vrfldol}h## wkh## ulvn## ri# v|vwhpzlgh#ghidxow1# # D#ihz# # # jryhuqphqwv#frqwulexwhg#wr#wkh#sureohp1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#wkh#Ylvlrq#5353# # # # # # # # # # sodq#vhw#rxw#e|#Pdod|vldᄊv#sulph#plqlvwhu#Pdkdwklu#Prkdpdg#lqfoxghg#wkh#Ednxq# # # # # # # # # # # # Gdp## +wkhq## Dvldᄊv## odujhvw## k|gursrzhu## gdp,/## wkh## Shwurqdv## Wrzhuv## +rqh## ri## wkh# zruogᄊv## wdoohvw## exloglqjv,/## d## vxshuprghuq## dlusruw/## dqg## d## qhz## qdwlrqdo# dgplqlvwudwlyh#fdslwdo#qhdu#Nxdod#Oxpsxu/#dssursuldwho|#fdoohg#Sxwudmd|d#+Flw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # Nlqjv,1<## Pdkdwklu#ᄊv## ylvlrq## zdv## fhuwdlqo|## ri## skdudrqlf## sursruwlrqv=## zkhq## L# sdvvhg#wkurxjk#Nxdod#Oxpsxu# # # # # uhfhqwo|/#wkh#kxjh#dlusruw#vwloo# # # # # # orrnhg#lpsuhvvlyh/# # zhoo0pdlqwdlqhg/#dqg#vwdwh0ri0wkh0duwᄇwkrxjk#lw#zdv#odujho|#ehuhiw#ri#sodqhv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # sdvvhqjhuv1#Exw#jhqhudoo|/#jryhuqphqw#h{fhvv#zdv#qrw#wkh#fhqwudo#sureohp#+dv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # kdg## ehhq## lq## suhylrxv## ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|## fulvhv/## olnh## wkdw## ri## Ph{lfr## lq## 4<<7,1#
Wkh## idxow## od|#zlwk#sulydwh# # # # h{fhvv## ixqghg## e|#hdv|#dqg# # # # khqfh## gdqjhurxv## iruhljq# prqh|1# Wkh#fodvvlf#lqjuhglhqwv#iru#d#exvw#zhuh#lq#sodfh=#h{fhvvlyh#lqyhvwphqw#ilqdqfhg# # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#vkruw0whup#ghew/#zlwk#wkh#dgglwlrqdo#ulvn#ri#d#iruhljq0fxuuhqf|#plvpdwfk1#Doo# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#zdv#qhhghg#zdv#wkh#ilqdo#wuljjhu1#Wklv#fdph#iurp#wzr#uhodwhg#vrxufhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Iluvw/## wkh## ryhudpelwlrxv## lqyhvwphqwv## wkhpvhoyhv## zhqw## vrxu1## E|## hduo|## 4<<:/# Doskdwhf## kdg## froodsvhg## xqghu## lwv## ghewv## zkloh## lwv## phpru|0fkls## sodqw## zdv## vwloo# xqghu#frqvwuxfwlrq1#Doskdwhf#lwvhoi#zdv#rqo|#d#vpdoo#idplo|0rzqhg#exvlqhvv#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # yhu|#olplwhg#h{shulhqfh#lq#wkh#vhplfrqgxfwru#lqgxvwu|/#dqg#wklv#odfn#ri#h{shulhqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # vkrzhg1#Frqvwuxfwlrq#zdv#sodjxhg#zlwk#ghod|v=#wkh#sodqw#zdv#ehlqj#exlow#rq#odqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vr#pduvk|#wkdw#frqfuhwh#slolqjv#kdg#wr#eh#gulyhq#grzq#wr#vwdelol}h#wkh#exloglqjv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dw## juhdw## frvw1## Wkhuh## zdv## qr## fohdq## zdwhu## ru## srzhu/## erwk## fulwlfdo## iru## fkls# pdqxidfwxuh/#vr#Doskdwhf#kdg#wr#exlog#wkh#qhfhvvdu|#idflolwlhv/#dgglqj#ixuwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # wr# frvwv1## Dqg## hyhq## ehiruh## kljk0whfk## sodqwv## olnh## Doskdwhfᄊv## zhuh## frpsohwhg/# lqyhvwruv#ehfdph#frqfhuqhg#derxw#wkhlu#yldelolw|#dqg#vwduwhg#sxoolqj#rxw1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#vhfrqg#wuljjhu#zdv#wkh#ghsuhfldwlrq#ri#wkh#Mdsdqhvh#|hq#djdlqvw#wkh#groodu/# # # # # # # # # # # # # vwduwlqj#lq#4<<81#Wklv#pdgh#Mdsdqhvh#h{sruwv#idu# # # # # # # # # pruh#frpshwlwlyh#wkdq#h{sruwv# # # # iurp#Hdvw#Dvld/#zkhuh#fxuuhqflhv#zhuh#olqnhg#pruh#forvho|#wr#wkh#groodu1#Udwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq## vrxuflqj## iurp## Wkdlodqg/## zlwk## lwv## xqfhuwdlq## txdolw|## dqg## vpdoo## srro## ri# vflhqwlvwv## dqg## hqjlqhhuv/## lpsruwhuv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## qrz## suhihuuhg## wr## uhwxuq#wr# # wulhg## dqg## whvwhg## Mdsdq1## Hdvw## Dvldq## h{sruwv## vwduwhg## idowhulqj/## frusrudwh# surilwdelolw|#soxpphwhg/#dqg#lqyhvwphqw#surmhfwv#vwduwhg#forvlqj#grzq1# # # # # # # # Iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#vwduwhg#sxoolqj#rxw#wkhlu#prqh|1#Vshfxodwruv#mrlqhg#wkh#iuhq}|# # # # # # # # # # # dv## wkh|#vdz# # # frxqwulhv## wu|lqj#wr# # # ghihqg## h{fkdqjh## udwhv## wkdw## zhuh## qrz## glvwlqfwo|# ryhuydoxhg1#Dqg#dv#wkh#frxqwulhv#xvhg#xs#wkhlu#iruhljq#h{fkdqjh#uhvhuyhv#lq#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghihqvh/## wkh## olnholkrrg## ri## d## ghydoxdwlrq## ehfdph## d## fhuwdlqw|1## Wkh## ghydoxdwlrq# edqnuxswhg#iluvw#wkh#pdq|#ilupv#zkr#kdg#eruurzhg#lq#iruhljq#fxuuhqflhv#dqg#wkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#grphvwlf#edqnv#wkdw#kdg#ohqw#wr#wkhp1#Iru#hyhq#dv#wkhvh#edqnv#irxqg#wkdw#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # eruurzhuv#frxog#qrw#uhsd|/#wkh|#kdg#wr#uhsd|#wkhlu#rzq#iruhljq#ohqghuv1#Wkh#Hdvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Dvldq#pludfoh#wxuqhg#lqwr#d#exvw#ri#jljdqwlf#sursruwlrqv1# # # # # # # # # Wkh## Hdvw## Dvldq## edqnv## wxuqhg## wr## wkhlu## jryhuqphqwv/## dqg## wkh## jryhuqphqwv# dsshdohg## wr## wkh## LPI## wr## jlyh## wkhp#wkh# # # iruhljq#fxuuhqf|#wkdw# # # # wkh|#qhhghg# # # wr## sd|# edfn#iruhljq#ohqghuv#dqg#suhvhuyh#wkhlu#edqnv1#Ixqg#prqh|#fdph#zlwk#frqglwlrqv# # # # # # # # # # # # dwwdfkhg=## dfwlrqv## wkdw#frxqwulhv# # # kdg## wr## wdnhᄇvrph## ehiruh## jhwwlqj#d# # # ordq/## rwkhuv# diwhuᄇwr#txdoli|#dv#eruurzhuv#lq#jrrg#vwdqglqj1#Vrph#frqglwlrqv#zhuh#uhodwlyho|# # # # # # # # # # # vwdqgdug=#diwhu#doo/#dq|#ohqghu/#hvshfldoo|#d#ohqghu#zkr#ohqgv#zkhq#qr#rqh#hovh#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zloolqj/#qhhgv#wr#sxw#lq#sodfh#fryhqdqwv#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#wkh#eruurzhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo## uhsd|1# Exw#rwkhuv#zhuh#rqhurxv1# # # # Wkh## Hdvw## Dvldq## jryhuqphqwv## eholhyhg## wkh## Ixqg## ryhuuhdfkhg## lq## wzr## zd|v1# Iluvw/## lw#vwlsxodwhg# # # frqglwlrqv## wkdw#vxjjhvwhg# # # lw#vlpso|#glg# # # # qrw#xqghuvwdqg# # # wkdw#lw# # zdv#ghdolqj#zlwk#d#gliihuhqw#folhqw#iurp#lwv#xvxdo#rqhv1#E|#dqg#odujh#wkhvh#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## jryhuqphqwv/## olnh## Ph{lfrᄊv/## wkdw## kdg## ryhuvshqw## wkhpvhoyhv## lqwr## wurxeoh1# Udwkhu/## wkh## grphvwlf## sulydwh## vhfwru## kdg## uxq#dprn#zlwk#lqyhvwphqw/# # # # # zlwk#iruhljq# # ohqghuv## odfnlqj#glvflsolqh# # # ehfdxvh## ri#wkh# # # lpsolflw#jxdudqwhhv# # # wkdw#wkh|#fruuhfwo|# # # vxuplvhg#jryhuqphqwv#zrxog#krqru1#Wkh#lpphgldwh#qhhg#zdv#wr#uhvwruh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # vwdelolw|/## shukdsv## lqixvh## vrph## jryhuqphqw#vwlpxoxv# # # wr## frpshqvdwh## iru## wkh## vkdus#
ghfolqh## lq## hfrqrplf## dfwlylw|/## dqg## wkhq/## zlwk## frqilghqfh## uhvwruhg/## vruw## rxw## wkh# phvv#ryhu#wlph1# # # Wklv## zdv## lqghhg## zkdw## Zhvwhuq## jryhuqphqwv## glg## lq## wkhlu## rzq## hfrqrplhv## lq# 533;ᄆ5343/#dqg#zkdw#wkh#LPI#hyhqwxdoo|#wxuqhg#wr#grlqj1#Exw#surxg#Hdvw#Dvldq# # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#riilfldov# # # zhuh## lqlwldoo|#wuhdwhg# # # dv## ghuholfwv## zkr## glg## qrw#xqghuvwdqg# # krz#wr#uxq#fohdq#jryhuqphqwv1#Ryhuqljkw/#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp#zdv#odehohg#furq|# # # # # # # # # # # fdslwdolvp/## dqg## wkhuh## zhuh## fhuwdlqo|#hqrxjk#h{dpsohv# # # # ri#furq|lvp#wr# # # # doorz## wkh# Zhvwhuq#ilqdqfldo#suhvv#wr#jr#wr#wrzq1#Vrph#ri#wkh#lqlwldo#srolf|#dgylfh#iurp#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Ixqg/## wkh## Zruog## Edqn/## dqg## Zhvwhuq## jryhuqphqwv## vhhphg## wr## eh## irfxvhg## rq# sxqlvklqj## wkh## furqlhv/## lqvwhdg## ri## uhfrjql}lqj## wkdw## wkh## v|vwhp## zdv## vr# lqwhufrqqhfwhg## wkdw#pdq|#lqqrfhqw#shrsoh# # # # # zrxog## vxiihu## lq#wkh# # # surfhvv1## Hpsdwk|# zdv## plvvlqj/## shukdsv## ehfdxvh## pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp## vhhphg## vr## dolhq## wr## wkh# rxwvlghuv#zkr#zhuh#qrz#fdoolqj#wkh#vkrwv1# # # # # # # Wkh#vhfrqg#zd|#wkh#Ixqg#ryhuuhdfkhg#zdv#lq#vhwwlqj#frqglwlrqv/#riwhq#glfwdwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # e|#lwv#pdmru#vkduhkroghuv#vxfk#dv#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#wkdw#dwwhpswhg#wr#uhirup#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Hdvw#Dvldq#frxqwulhv# # # # dffruglqj#wr# # # Zhvwhuq#qrwlrqv# # # ri#jryhuqdqfh1#Iru# # # # lqvwdqfh/# Lqgrqhvld## zdv## dvnhg## wr## xqghuwdnh## 473## ru## vr## dfwlrqv## lq## 4<<;/## lqfoxglqj# glvedqglqj## wkh## foryh## prqrsro|/## vwuhqjwkhqlqj## uhiruhvwdwlrq## surjudpv/## dqg# lqwurgxflqj## d## plfurfuhglw## vfkhph1## Wr## wkh## f|qlfᄇdqg## f|qlfv## zhuh## vrphwlphv# fruuhfwᄇwkhvh#pryhv#zhuh#uhdoo|#lqwhqghg#wr#rshq#xs#odujh#surwhfwhg#vhjphqwv# # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkh## frxqwu|## wr## Zhvwhuq## ilupv## dqg## dgyrfdf|## jurxsv1## Dowkrxjk## vrph## ri## wkhvh# phdvxuhv#pd|#kdyh#ehqhilwhg#wkh#frxqwu|#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq/#wkhvh#zhuh#ghflvlrqv#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## shrsoh## wkhpvhoyhv## wr## wdnh/## qrw## iru## iruhljq## riilfldov## wr## uhtxluh## zkhq## wkh# frxqwu|#zdv#iodw#rq#lwv#edfn1#Wkh#xqiruwxqdwh#skrwr#ri#wkh#LPI#pdqdjlqj#gluhfwru/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Plfkho#Fdpghvvxv/#zlwk#klv#dupv#furvvhg#dqg#wrzhulqj#ryhu#d#vhhplqjo|#frzhg# # # # # # # # # # # # Suhvlghqw## Vxkduwr## ri## Lqgrqhvld## dv## kh## vljqhg## wkh## LPI## djuhhphqw## vxjjhvwhg## dq# lpdjh## ri#wkh# # # frqtxhuru## dffhswlqj#wkh# # # xqfrqglwlrqdo## vxuuhqghu## ri#wkh# # # ghihdwhg143# Dowkrxjk## wkh## wuxh## flufxpvwdqfhv## zhuh## pruh## ehqljq/## wkh## skrwr## frpsrxqghg## wkh# vhqvh#wkdw#wklv#zdv#d#qhz#irup#ri#ilqdqfldo#frorqldolvp1# # # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Idxow#Olqh#Ghhshqv=#Wkh#Glylgh#ehwzhhq#Ghyhorslqj#Frxqwulhv # # # # # # # # # Lq## vxp## wkhq/## lq## d## ghyhorshg## frxqwu|/## hvshfldoo|## rqh## zlwk## zhoo0ixqfwlrqlqj# fdslwdo## pdunhwv## dqg## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv/## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## w|slfdoo|## kdyh# lqirupdwlrq#dqg#uljkwv#vlplodu#wr#wkrvh#ri#grphvwlf#lqyhvwruv1#Wkh|#gr#qrw#ghpdqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vshfldo#uljkwv#dqg#sulylohjhv>#qru#gr#wkh|#wu|#wr#jhw#lpsolflw#jryhuqphqw#edfnlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # +e|#ohqglqj#yld#grphvwlf#edqnv,#ru#h{solflw#edfnlqj#e|#ohqglqj#wr#wkh#jryhuqphqw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ilupv#dqg#krxvhkrogv#eruurz#gluhfwo|/#iruflqj#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#wr#pdnh#fduhixo# # # # # # # # # # # ghflvlrqv1#Li#wkh|#grqᄊw/#wkh|#kdyh#rqo|#wkhpvhoyhv#wr#eodph#dqg#kdyh#qr#uhfrxuvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#wkh#jryhuqphqw1# # # Lq## d## ghyhorslqj## frxqwu|/## e|## frqwudvw/## iruhljq## eruurzlqj## lv## w|slfdoo|## d## odvw# uhvruw1## Ehfdxvh## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## zruu|## wkdw## wkh|## nqrz## idu## ohvv## wkdq## wkh## zhoo0 frqqhfwhg## grphvwlf## edqnv## dqg## duh## ohvv## deoh## wr## hqirufh## sd|phqw/## wkh|## wu|## wr# lpsuryh#wkh#vhfxulw|#ri#wkhlu#fodlpv#e|#uhtxlulqj#sd|phqw#lq#iruhljq#fxuuhqf|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # e|#vkruwhqlqj#wkh#pdwxulw|#ri#wkhlu#ordqv1#Sdudgr{lfdoo|/#wkh#xqghughyhorsphqw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## grphvwlf## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## doorzv## wkh## odwh0duulylqj## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## wr# ghpdqg## dqg## uhfhlyh## sulylohjhv## wkdw## w|slfdoo|## hdw## lqwr## wkh## ydoxh## ri## wkh## h{lvwlqj# grphvwlf## lqyhvwruvᄊ## fodlpv## ru/## yld## wkh## lpsolflw## jxdudqwhhv## riihuhg## e|## wkh# jryhuqphqw/## lqwr## wkh## wd{sd|huvᄊ## zhdowk1## Pruhryhu/## wkh## surwhfwlrq## wkh|## uhfhlyh# pdnhv## wkhp## ohvv## fduhixo## derxw## zkdw## wkh|## ilqdqfh1## Lq## wxuq/## ehfdxvh## eruurzhuv/# zkhwkhu## wkh## fxuuhqw## jryhuqphqw## ru## edqnv/## gr## qrw## idfh## wkh## ixoo## frvw## ri## iruhljq# eruurzlqj/#wkh|#kdyh#d#whqghqf|#wr#ryhueruurz1# # # # # # # Sduhqwkhwlfdoo|/## uhdghuv## zloo## qrwh## wkdw## wkh## X1V1## vxesulph## pdunhw/## zlwk## lwv# vxevwdqwldo## txdvl0jryhuqphqw## suhvhqfh/## zdv## d## ghsduwxuh## iurp## wkh## ghyhorshg0 frxqwu|#qrup#dqg#lq#pdq|#zd|v#uhiohfwhg#wkh#ghilflhqflhv#suhvhqw#lq#ghyhorslqj# # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv1#Wklv#lv#suhflvho|#wkh#dqdorj|#wkdw#qhhgv#wr#eh#gudzq1#L#uhwxuq#wr#wkhvh# # # # # # # # # # # ## # # lvvxhv#odwhu#lq#wkh#errn1# # # # #
Uhirupv # Wkh## fulvhv## ri## wkh## 4<<3v## kdg## d## gliihuhqwldo## lpsdfw## rq#hfrqrplhv1# # # Frxqwulhv# wkdw#zhuh#vdylqj#wrr#olwwoh#zhuh#irufhg#lqwr#pxfk0qhhghg#uhirupv1#Iru#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # # olnh#Lqgld/#zklfk#h{shulhqfhg#d#fulvlv#lq#4<<4#dv#d#uhvxow#ri#odujh#jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fxuuhqw0dffrxqw## ghilflwv/## dqg## Odwlq## Dphulfdq## hfrqrplhv## olnh## Eud}lo/## zkrvh# yxoqhudelolw|#vwhpphg#iurp#wrr#olwwoh#vdylqj/#wkh#fulvhv#zhuh#d#vljqdo#wkdw#wkh#rog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # prgho## ri## pdqdjhg## exw## lqzdug0orrnlqj## fdslwdolvp#zdv# # # eurnhq1## Erwk## Lqgld## dqg# Eud}lo#olehudol}hg#wkhlu#hfrqrplhv/#uhgxflqj#jryhuqphqw#frqwuro#dqg#rzqhuvkls/# # # # # # # # # uhprylqj#sulfh# # # dqg## lqwhuhvw0udwh## frqwurov/## eulqjlqj#juhdwhu# # # frpshwlwlrq#lqwr# # # wkh# ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp/## rshqlqj#xs# # # wr## lpsruwv## dqg## iruhljq#lqyhvwphqw/# # # dqg## ohwwlqj#wkh# # h{fkdqjh## udwh## iordw1## Wkh|#dovr# # # dgrswhg## pruh## vhqvleoh## pdfurhfrqrplf## srolflhv/# fxwwlqj## jryhuqphqw## ghilflwv## +iru## d## zkloh## dw## ohdvw,## dqg## lpsurylqj## prqhwdu|# pdqdjhphqw1# Gxulqj## wkh## orqj## shulrg## ri## surwhfwhg## pdqdjhg## jurzwk/## wkh|## kdg## exlow## vwurqj# frusrudwh## rujdql}dwlrqv## wkdw## zhuh## ixoo|## fdsdeoh## ri## survshulqj## dv## frpshwlwlrq# lqfuhdvhg1## Dqg## hqkdqfhg## frpshwlwlrq## eurxjkw## rxw## wkh## ehvw## lq## wkhvh## frpsdqlhv1# Wdwd## Vwhho## +ehiruh## lw## dftxluhg## wkh## Hxurshdq## vwhho## jldqw## Fruxv,## kdg## rqh## ri## wkh# orzhvw## frvwv## ri## vwhho## surgxfwlrq## lq## wkh## zruog/## zkloh## Hpeudhu/## d## sulydwl}hg# Eud}loldq## dlufudiw## pdqxidfwxuhu/## ghyhorshg## d## vwurqj## pdunhw## lq## plgvl}hg## sodqhv# durxqg#wkh#zruog1# # # Wkhvh## odwh## olehudol}huv## kdg## odujh## hqrxjk## grphvwlf## pdunhwv## wkdw## wkh|## glg## qrw# kdyh#wr#idyru#wkh#h{sruw#vhfwru1#Erwk#Eud}lo#dqg#Lqgld#ᄈpdqdjhgᄡ#wkhlu#h{fkdqjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # udwh/#exw#wkh|#glg#qrw#wu|#wr#jdlq#d#vhulrxv#frpshwlwlyh#dgydqwdjh#e|#wu|lqj#wr#krog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#grzq1# # # Pruhryhu/## zlwk#ilupv# # # douhdg|#vwurqj/# # # wkh|#glg# # # qrw#kdyh# # # wr## uhsuhvv## wkh# krxvhkrog## vhfwruᄇqrw#wkdw#wkhlu# # # # qrz0yleudqw#ghprfudflhv# # # zrxog## kdyh## doorzhg# wkhp## wr$## Wkh|## olehudol}hg## ghsrvlw## lqwhuhvw## udwhv/## fxw## wd{hv## rq## krxvhkrogv/## dqg# doorzhg#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#wr#h{sdqg#krxvhkrog#fuhglw1#Dv#d#uhvxow/#erwk#Eud}lo# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## Lqgld## kdyh## khdowk|## ohyhov## ri## sulydwh## frqvxpswlrq## dqg## grphvwlf0rulhqwhg# surgxfwlrq#vhfwruv# # # wkdw## duh## doprvw## dv## hiilflhqw## dv## wkhlu## h{sruw0rulhqwhg## vhfwruv1# Dowkrxjk#d#errp#lq#frpprglwlhv#kdv#ohg#wr#d#udslg#h{sdqvlrq#lq#Eud}loᄊv#h{sruwv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv## hfrqrp|#lv# # # glyhuvlilhg## dqg## uhvlolhqw#hqrxjk#wr# # # # zhdwkhu## d## whpsrudu|#gurs# # # lq# frpprglwlhv#sulfhv#li#lw#frphv1#Iru#erwk#wkhvh#frxqwulhv/#wkh#vloyhu#olqlqj#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # forxg#ri#kdylqj#plvvhg#wkh#uljkw#prphqw#wr#vzlwfk#wr#h{sruwv#lv#wkdw#wkh|#kdyh#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdg#wr#vzlwfk#edfn1#Wkh|#qrz#hqmr|#pruh#edodqfhg#hfrqrplhv/#ohvv#ghshqghqw#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{sruwv#iru#jurzwk1# # # Wkh## Hdvw## Dvldq## hfrqrplhv/## zlwk## wkh## h{fhswlrq## ri## Lqgrqhvld/## uhfryhuhg# txlfno|=## wkhlu## ghydoxhg## fxuuhqflhv## pdgh## wkhp## yhu|## frpshwlwlyh/## dqg## wkh|# h{sdqghg## h{sruwv## hyhq## zkloh## uhsodflqj## lpsruwv## zlwk## fkhdshu## grphvwlf# surgxfwlrq1#Wkh|#dovr#vodvkhg#lqyhvwphqwᄇrq#dyhudjh/#dfurvv#Nruhd/#Pdod|vld/# # # # # # # # # dqg## Wkdlodqg/## lqyhvwphqw## fdph## grzq## iurp## 74## shufhqw## ri## JGS## lq## 4<<9## wr## 57# shufhqw#ri#JGS#lq#4<<;/#dqg#lw#vwd|hg#orz1#Grphvwlf#vdylqjv# # # # # # # # # # # # slfnhg#xs#d#olwwoh# # # # lqlwldoo|/## iurp#6;# # # shufhqw#ri#JGS#wr# # # # # 74## shufhqw#ri#JGS/# # # # exw#guliwhg# # # grzq#ryhu# # wlph#wr#ehorz#4<<9#ohyhov1#Wklv#lv#lpsruwdqw/#iru#wkh#uhdvrq#iru#wkhlu#ulvlqj#wudgh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxusoxvhv#lv#qrw#wkdw#Hdvw#Dvldq#krxvhkrogv#fxw#edfn#gudpdwlfdoo|#rq#frqvxpswlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## lqfuhdvhg## wkhlu## vdylqjv1## Lqvwhdg/## jryhuqphqwv## dqg## frusrudwlrqv## fxw#edfn#rq# # #
lqyhvwphqw1#Wkh#qhw#hiihfw#rq#wkh#zruogᄊv#vxsso|#ri#vdylqjv#zdv#wkh#vdphᄇiurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehlqj#qhw#eruurzhuv#iurp#wkh#zruog#hfrqrp|/#wkh#Hdvw#Dvldq#hfrqrplhv#vwduwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # sxpslqj#wkhlu#vdylqjv#lqwr#lw1#Exw#ghpdqg#iru#lqyhvwphqw#jrrgvᄇiru#kdug#dvvhwv# # # # # # # # # # # # vxfk#dv# # # sodqw#dqg# # # htxlsphqwᄇsoxpphwhg1## Wkhvh## zhuh## w|slfdoo|#jrrgv# # # wkdw#kdg# # ehhq## lpsruwhg/## vr## wkh## uhyhuehudwlrqv## zhuh## ihow## durxqg## wkh## joreh1## Wkh## joredo# vxsso|#joxw#djdlq#zhqw#orrnlqj#iru#frxqwulhv#wkdw#zrxog#ryhuvshqg1# # # # # # # # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Frxqwulhv#wkdw#kdg#irfxvhg#rq#h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk#ohduqhg#dq#lpsruwdqw#ohvvrq1# # # # # # # # # # # Lw#lv#d#irroᄊv#jdph#wr#vxffxpe#wr#wkh#whpswdwlrq#ri#fkhds#jrrgv#dqg#hdv|#prqh|=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # udslg## ghew0ixhohg## vshqglqj#lqyduldeo|#hqgv# # # # lq#whduv1# # # Pruh## vshflilfdoo|/## ehfdxvh# pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp## zdv## kdug## iru## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## wr## xqghuvwdqg## ru## qdyljdwh/# wkh|## uhvsrqghg## e|## uhwdlqlqj## wkh## uljkw## wr## h{lw## dw## vkruw## qrwlfh/## kroglqj## htxlw|## ru# vkruw0whup#ghew#fodlpv1# # # # Dqg## h{lw#wkh|#glg/# # # # vrphwlphv## zlwkrxw#ixoo# # # uhjdug## wr## wkh# frxqwu|ᄊv#ixqgdphqwdov/#vr#wkdw#ilqdqflqj#zlwk#ioljkw|#iruhljq#fdslwdo#zdv#dnlq#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # uxqqlqj#d#vpdoo#edqn#zlwkrxw#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfhᄇd#uhflsh#iru#iudjlolw|1#Dowkrxjk# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## h{sruwhuv## glg## xqghuvwdqg## wkh## qhhg## iru## ilqdqfldo0vhfwru## uhirup/## wkh|## glg## qrw# eholhyh#wkdw#wkh#fulvhv#lqglfdwhg#dq|#sureohpv#lq#wkh#eurdghu#vwudwhj|#ri#h{sruw0 # # # # # # # # # # # # ohg## jurzwk1## Lqvwhdg/## wkh## fulvhv## uhlqirufhg## wkhlu## eholhiv## wkdw## jhqhudwlqj## wudgh# vxusoxvhv## zdv## hyhq#ehwwhu# # # wkdq#vlpso|#ehlqj#h{sruw#rulhqwhg/# # # # # # iru## lw#doorzhg# # # wkh# frxqwu|#wr#exlog#iruhljq#h{fkdqjh#uhvhuyhv1#Wkh#urxwh#wr#vxfk#vxusoxvhv#zdv#wr#fxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # edfn#rq#lqyhvwphqw/#zklfk#dovr#khoshg#wkhvh#frxqwulhv#dyrlg#wkh#errp0exvw#f|foh# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#lqyhvwphqwv#wr#zklfk#wkh|#kdg#ehhq#surqh1# # # # # # # # Wkh#dwwhpsw#e|#wkhvh#h{sruwhuv#wr#dfklhyh#vdihw|/#wkrxjk/#kdv#lqfuhdvhg#wkh#uhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkh## zruogᄊv## yxoqhudelolw|1## Wkh## vxshufkdujhg## h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk#vwudwhj|# # # wkh|# kdyh#vxevhtxhqwo|#iroorzhg#qrw#rqo|#lqfuhdvhv#wkh#exughq#rq#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#fuhdwh#ghpdqg#iru#wkhlu#jrrgv/#exw#lw#dovr#dffhqwxdwhv#wkh#grphvwlf#glvwruwlrqv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#vwudwhj|#suhylrxvo|#fuhdwhg/#zklfk#zhuh#kljkoljkwhg#lq#wkh#suhylrxv#fkdswhu1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## qhz## vwudwhj|#dovr# # # ohg## wr## dq#hqruprxv# # # exlogxs## ri#wkh# # # h{sruwhuvᄊ#iruhljq0 # h{fkdqjh#uhvhuyhv1#Wkhvh#uhvhuyhv#zhqw#orrnlqj#iru#d#krph#durxqg#wkh#zruog1#Wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # dwwudfw## wkhp/## d## frxqwu|## kdg## wr## eh## zloolqj## wr## vshqg## pxfk## pruh## wkdq## lwv## rzq# surgxfhuv## frxog## vxsso|/## dqg## lw## qhhghg## d## vwurqj## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## fdsdeoh## ri# dwwudfwlqj## wkh## lqiorzv## dqg## uhdvvxulqj## wkh## h{sruwhuv## wkdw## wkhlu## vdylqjv## zrxog## eh# vdih/## vdihu## wkdq#wkh# # # ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # kdg## ehhq1## Wkh## reylrxv## fdqglgdwh## zdv# wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#+dorqj#zlwk/#wr#d#ohvvhu#h{whqw/#Vsdlq#dqg#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp,1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## zlwk#jurzlqj#lqhtxdolw|#pdnlqj#wkh# # # # # # srolwlfdo## hqylurqphqw# idyrudeoh## wr## pruh## ghew0ilqdqfhg## frqvxpswlrq#+dv# # # L## dujxh## lq#Fkdswhu# # # 4,/## zdv## d# sulph#fdqglgdwh#wr#eh#wkh#qhz#ghpdqghu#ri#odvw#uhvruw1#Krzhyhu/#wkh#srolflhv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## hduo|#|hduv# # # ri#wklv# # # fhqwxu|#wkdw#sxvkhg# # # # lw#ilupo|#lqwr# # # # wkh## uroh## ri#wkh# # # zruogᄊv# qhz## ghvljqdwhg## vshqghu## zhuh## gulyhq#e|#d# # # # qhz## skhqrphqrq=## uhfryhulhv## lq#wkh# # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zhuh## lqfuhdvlqjo|#ᄈmreohvv/ᄡ# # # dqg## wkh## X1V1## vdihw|#qhw# # # zdv## zkroo|# lqdghtxdwh#wr#frsh#zlwk#wkhp1# # # # #
FKDSWHU#IRXU #
D#Zhdn#Vdihw|#Qhw # # # #
EDGUL## HQWHUHG## WKH## XQLWHG## VWDWHV## dv#d#vwxghqw#pruh#wkdq#d#txduwhu# # # # # # # # fhqwxu|#
djr14## Diwhu## rewdlqlqj## d## kdqgixo## ri## ghjuhhv/## lqfoxglqj## d## SkG## lq## phwdooxujlfdo# hqjlqhhulqj/#kh#jrw#d#mre#lq#4<<:#lq#d#mrlqw#yhqwxuh#ehwzhhq#d#Jhupdq#ilup#dqg#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Dphulfdq## ilup## qhdu## Zdvklqjwrq/## GF/## pdnlqj## vwdwh0ri0wkh0duw## phpru|## fklsv1# Edgulᄊv#iluvw#mre#zdv#wr#khos#vhw#xs#wkh#ideulfdwlrq#olqh#iru#d#qhz#vhw#ri#fklsv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#uhgxfh#wkh#iudfwlrq#ri#ghihfwlyh#fklsv#surgxfhg1#Wkh#wdvn#pdgh#ixoo#xvh#ri#klv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frqvlghudeoh## nqrzohgjh## dqg## vnloov## ehfdxvh## lw## uhtxluhg## wurxeohvkrrwlqj## uhdoo|# frpsolfdwhg#surfhvvhv#dqg#pdfklqhv1#Vhyhqw|0krxu#zhhnv#zhuh#frpprq1# # # # # # # # Ryhu#wlph/#wkh#Dphulfdq#sduwqhu#vrog#rxw1#Wkh#Jhupdq#ilup#vsxq#rii#wkh#mrlqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # yhqwxuh#lqwr#d#vhsdudwh#ilup#zlwk#lwv#rzq#wudghg#vkduhv/#dqg#odwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wklv#ilup#vsolw# # # lqwr#wzr/#zlwk#rqh#sduw#irfxvlqj#rq#orjlf#fklsv#zkloh#wkh#rwkhu#sduw#irfxvhg#rq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdslwdo0lqwhqvlyh## phpru|## fkls1## Vr## hyhq## dv## Edgul## vshqw## |hduv## vshfldol}lqj## lq# phpru|0fkls## ideulfdwlrq/## pdnlqj## vpdoohu## dqg## vpdoohu## fklsv## iurp## odujhu## dqg# odujhu#zdihuv/#wkh#frpsdq|#dovr#vkuxqnᄇiurp#ehlqj#d#mrlqw#yhqwxuh#ehwzhhq#wzr# # # # # # # # # # # # odujh/## ghhs0srfnhwhg## ilupv## wr## ehlqj#d# # # glyhuvlilhg## fkls## pdnhu## dqg## hyhqwxdoo|#d# # vwdqg0dorqh/## qduurzo|## irfxvhg/## khdylo|## lqghewhg## ilup/## lq## d## fdslwdo0lqwhqvlyh# lqgxvwu|#zlwk#d#klvwru|#ri#ihdvw0dqg0idplqh#f|fohv1# # # # # # # Wkh## lqhylwdeoh## kdsshqhg1## Diwhu## pdnlqj## d## kxjh## lqyhvwphqw## lq## wkh## odwhvw## qhz# whfkqrorj|/#Edgulᄊv#hpsor|hu#irxqg#lwvhoi#lq#ilqdqfldo#gliilfxowlhv#lq#hduo|#533;1#Lw# # # # # # # # # # # # kdg## wkh## fkrlfh## ri## vkxwwlqj## grzq## hlwkhu## lwv## X1V1## sodqw## ru## lwv## Jhupdq## sodqw1# Nqrzlqj#wkdw#lw#zrxog#idfh#juhdwhu#gliilfxowlhv#lq#vkxwwlqj#grzq#wkh#Jhupdq#sodqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#wkdw#lw#pljkw#eh#deoh#wr#edujdlq#iru#vxevlglhv#iurp#wkh#Jhupdq#jryhuqphqw/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # odlg#rii#doo#wkh#zrunhuv#dw#lwv#X1V1#sodqw1# # # # # # # # # Ryhuqljkw/#Edgul#irxqg#klv#vl{0iljxuh#lqfrph#jrqh1#Ehfdxvh#wkh#ilup#ghfoduhg# # # # # # # # # # # edqnuxswf|/#lw#glg#qrw#kdyh#wr#surylgh#vhyhudqfh#sd|#wr#frpshqvdwh#klp#iru#wkh#44# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # |hduv## kh## kdg## zrunhg## dw#wkh# # # ilup1## Doo## kh## kdg## qrz## zdv## d## zhhno|#xqhpsor|phqw# # fkhfn#ri#'733/#rxw#ri#zklfk#kh#kdg#wr#vxssruw#klv#idplo|#ri#irxu#dv#zhoo#dv#sd|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjh1#Hyhq#pruh#zruulvrph#zdv#khdowk#lqvxudqfh1#Kh#kdg#ehhq#sd|lqj#'83#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # prqwk## iru## khdowk## lqvxudqfh## surylghg## wkurxjk## klv## ilup/## zklfk## zrxog## qr## orqjhu# fryhu#klp#dqg#klv#idplo|1#Dv#kh#wxuqhg#wr#sulydwh#lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv/#kh#irxqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh|#uhixvhg#wr#fryhu#klp#ehfdxvh#kh#kdg#dq#hohydwhg#eorrg0vxjdu#ohyho#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv#dw#plog#ulvn#iru#gldehwhv1#Hyhq#zlwkrxw#wklv#frpsolfdwlrq/#sulydwh#lqvxudqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#frvw#'4/433#shu#prqwk#iru#wkh#idplo|/#zklfk#zrxog#hdw#xs#wzr0wklugv#ri#klv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqhpsor|phqw#lqvxudqfh1#Edgul# # # # uhdoo|#qhhghg#d# # # # mre/#dw#wkh# # # # yhu|#ohdvw#vr#wkdw#kh# # # # # glg#qrw#kdyh# # # # wr#sod|#Uxvvldq#urxohwwh# # # # # zlwk#klv# # # khdowk#dqg#ilqdqfhv# # # # e|#uhpdlqlqj# # xqlqvxuhg1## Kh## vhqw## rxw## kxqguhgv## ri## uーvxpーv/## exw## qr## rqh## zdv## klulqj1## Klv# xqhpsor|phqw## lqvxudqfh## zdv## uxqqlqj## rxw/## dqg## kh## zrxog## kdyh## wr## hdw## lqwr## wkh# vdylqjv#vhw#dvlgh#iru#klv#vrqᄊv#froohjh#hgxfdwlrq1#Lq#wklv#uhvshfw/#Edgul#zdv#rqh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#oxfn|#rqhv1#Xqolnh#pdq|#Dphulfdqv#lq#klv#vlwxdwlrq/#kh#kdg#vrph#vdylqjv$# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Lq#wkh#phdqwlph/#klv#ilupᄊv#X1V1#dvvhwv#zhuh#oltxlgdwhg#slhfhphdo/#zlwk#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # fkls## pdqxidfwxuhuv## ex|lqj## vrph## ri## wkh## h{shqvlyh## pdfklqhv## iru## wkhlu## rzq# ideulfdwlrq## sodqwv1## Wkhvh## dvvhwv## zhuh## txlfno|## uhghsor|hg## lqwr## qhz/## surilwdeoh# xvhv1#Pdq|#prqwkv#diwhu#forvlqj#wkh#X1V1#sodqw/#wkh#ilup#zdv#irufhg#wr#uhfrjql}h# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## lqhylwdeohᄇwkdw## lwv## exvlqhvv## zdv## xqhfrqrplfᄇdqg## lw## forvhg## wkh## Jhupdq# sodqw#dovr1# #
Wkh#Zloolqjqhvv#wr#Vwlpxodwh # # # # Zh## vdz## lq## wkh## odvw## fkdswhu## wkdw## lq## wkh## odwh## 4<<3v## dqg## hduo|## 5333v/## wkh# vxusoxvhv## ri## wkh## wudglwlrqdo## h{sruwhuv/## dxjphqwhg## e|## wkh## jrrgv## wkh## ghyhorslqj# frxqwulhv## zhuh## qr## orqjhu## ex|lqj/## zhuh## orrnlqj#iru# # # d## pdunhw1## Zlwk#wkh# # # zruog## lq# uhfhvvlrq## diwhu## wkh## grw0frp## exvw/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## sxuvxhg## h{wuhpho|# h{sdqvlrqdu|#ilvfdo#dqg#prqhwdu|#srolflhv#ryhu#d#vxvwdlqhg#shulrg/#wkxv#fuhdwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#h{fhvv#ghpdqg#wr#devrue#wkh#vxusoxvhv/#ilqdqfhg#zlwk#wkh#vdylqjv#wkdw#vxusoxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## zhuh## jhqhudwlqj1## Lq## sduw/## dv## L## kdyh## dujxhg/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdg## qr# rswlrq## exw## wr## eh## wkh## zruogᄊv## ghpdqghu## ri## odvw## uhvruw/## ehfdxvh## frxqwulhv## olnh# Jhupdq|## dqg## Mdsdq## frxog## qrw## sxoo## wkhlu## zhljkw1## Exw## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## glg## qrw# iroorz#h{sdqvlrqdu|#srolflhv#rxw#ri#d#vhqvh#ri#joredo#flwl}hqvkls1#Lqvwhdg/#lw#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # gulyhq#e|#lwv#rzq#grphvwlf#frpsxovlrqv#wr#vwlpxodwh#wr#h{fhvv1# # # # # # # # # # Edgulᄊv#h{shulhqfh#vxjjhvwv#dq#lpsruwdqw#uhdvrq#zk|1#Xqolnh#zrunhuv#lq#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # ulfk## lqgxvwuldo## hfrqrplhv/## zrunhuv## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## duh## qrw## dxwrpdwlfdoo|# vxssruwhg## li## d## uhfhvvlrq## lv## ghhs## dqg## surorqjhg15## Dphulfdqv## kdyh## klvwrulfdoo|# rssrvhg## vxevwdqwldo## zhoiduh=## dv## d## uhvxow/## wkh## frxqwu|ᄊv## vdihw|## qhw/## lqfoxglqj# xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv/## lv## zhdn1## Vlqfh## Zruog## Zdu## LL/## lwv## hfrqrplf## v|vwhp#kdv# # ehhq#vwuxfwxuhg# # # vr## wkdw## lw## uhdfwv## txlfno|#dqg# # # qlpeo|#wr# # # dgyhuvlw|1## Edqnv## fxw## rii# srruo|#shuiruplqj#ilupv#iurp#qhz# # # # # # ordqv/#zkloh#yhqwxuh#fdslwdolvwv#sxoo# # # # # # wkh#soxj# # rq#xqghushuiruplqj#vwduw0xsv1#H{lvwlqj#ilupv#duh#vkxw#grzq/#dqg#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # dvvhwv#duh# # oltxlgdwhg#dqg#vrog#wr#wkrvh#zkr#fdq#xvh#wkhp#ehwwhu/#dv#kdsshqhg#zlwk#Edgulᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilup1## Doo## wklv## dfwlylw|## fuhdwhv## vsdfh## iru## qhz## ilupv## wr## hphujh1## Dqg## ehfdxvh# xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## gr## qrw## odvw## orqj/## zrunhuv## zkr## orvh## mrev## kdyh## vwurqj# lqfhqwlyhv## wr## ilqg## qhz## rqhv/## hyhq#li#lw#lqyroyhv# # # # # d## sd|#fxw/# # # fkdqjlqj#fduhhuv/# # # ru# prylqj#dfurvv#wkh#frqwlqhqw1# # # # Shukdsv## dv## d#uhvxow#ri#wkhvh#flufxpvwdqfhv/#srvwzdu# # # # # # # uhfryhulhv## sulru## wr#4<<3# # zhuh## udslgᄇrq## dyhudjh/## rxwsxw## uhfryhuhg## wr## suh0uhfhvvlrq## ohyhov## zlwklq## wzr# 6# txduwhuv/#dqg#orvw#mrev# # # # # zhuh#uhfryhuhg#hljkw#prqwkv# # # # # diwhu## wkh#uhfhvvlrq#wurxjk1 # # Jryhuqphqw#dqg#fhqwudo#edqn#srolf|#zhuh#phdqw#wr#khos#lq#grzqwxuqv/#exw#rqo|#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## pdujlq1## Prvw#ri#wkh# # # # eulhi#sdlq#zdv# # # # phdqw#wr# # # eh## eruqh## e|#edqnv/# # # ilupv/## dqg# zrunhuv1# Krzhyhu/## wkh## 4<<3ᄆ<4## uhfhvvlrq## eurnh## wklv## srvwzdu## prog1## Rxwsxw## jurzwk# fdph#edfn#txlfno|/#exw#mrev#glg#qrw1#Zkhuhdv#surgxfwlrq#uhfryhuhg#zlwklq#wkuhh# # # # # # # # # # # # txduwhuv#lq#4<<4/#lw#wrrn#56#prqwkv#iurp#wkh#wurxjk#ri#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#wr#uhfryhu#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # orvw## mrev## lq## 4<<4## uhfhvvlrq1## Wkrvh## rxw## ri## zrun## ru## idflqj## mre## orvvhv## duh# xqghuvwdqgdeo|## dq{lrxv## dv## wkh|## idfh## srwhqwldoo|## orqj## shulrgv## ri## xqhpsor|phqw# zlwk#ihz#vdylqjv/#d#yhu|#olplwhg#shulrg#ri#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv/#dqg#qr#khdowk# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvxudqfh1## Srolwlfldqv## ljqruh## wkh## frqfhuqv## ri#wkh# # # dq{lrxv## flwl}hqu|#dw# # # wkhlu## rzq# shulo1#Jhrujh#K1#Z1#Exvk#ohduqhg#wklv# # # # # # # # wkh#kdug#zd|=# # # # ghvslwh#suhvlglqj#ryhu# # # # wkh# hqg## ri## wkh## Frog## Zdu## dqg## d## ghflvlyh## ylfwru|## lq## wkh## iluvw## Jxoi## Zdu/## kh## orvw## klv# uhhohfwlrq#fdpsdljq#wr# # # # Eloo## Folqwrq/## odujho|#dv# # # d## uhvxow## ri#yrwhu# # # glvvdwlvidfwlrq# ryhu## mre## orvvhv## gxulqj## wkh## uhfhvvlrq## ri## 4<<3ᄆ<41## Rqh## ri## Folqwrqᄊv## jxlglqj# sulqflsohv/## vhw## iruwk## e|## wkh## fdpsdljq## vwudwhjlvw## Mdphv## Fduylooh/## zdv## ᄈLwᄊv## wkh# hfrqrp|/## vwxslg1ᄡ## Wkdw## ohvvrq## kdv## ehhq## ilupo|## devruehg1## Wkh## ylhz## wkdw## wkh# fxuuhqw#xqhpsor|phqw#udwh#lv#fhqwudo#wr#uhhohfwlrq#survshfwv#grplqdwhv#wklqnlqj#lq# # # # # # # # # # #
Zdvklqjwrq1# # # # dqg## wkh## hphujhqfh## ri## mreohvv## uhfryhulhv## lpso|#wkdw# # # wkh# Wkh## zhdn#vdihw|#qhw# Dphulfdq## hohfwrudwh## kdv## idu## ohvv## wrohudqfh## iru## grzqwxuqv## wkdq## yrwhuv## lq## rwkhu# lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv1## Wkh## uhdvrq## wkdw## vwlpxoxv## zdv## dssolhg## vr## orqj## gxulqj## wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhfryhu|#iurp#wkh#5334#uhfhvvlrq#zdv#wkdw#hyhq#wkrxjk#rxwsxw#uhfryhuhg#lq#mxvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rqh#txduwhu#lq#5334/#lw#wrrn#6;#prqwkv#diwhu#wkh#wurxjk#ri#wkh#5334#uhfhvvlrq#iru# doo## wkh## orvw## mrev## wr## eh## uhvwruhg1## Lqghhg/## mre## orvvhv## frqwlqxhg## zhoo## lqwr## wkh# # # # wr## lqgxfh## uhfdoflwudqw## ilupv## lqwr## fuhdwlqj#mrev/# # # erwk#wkh# # uhfryhu|1## Lq#dq#dwwhpsw# # # wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh/## hvshfldoo|#wkh# # # odwwhu/## hqghg## xs## dlglqj#dqg# # jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # # # # # # dehwwlqj#d#krxvh0sulfh#exeeoh#dqg#wkh#ilqdqfldo#fulvlv1# # # # # # # # # # # Dv#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#vwuxjjohv#zlwk#qhdu0grxeoh0gljlw#xqhpsor|phqw#dw#wkh#wlph# # # wkhuh## lv## sdqlf## lq#wkh# # # fruulgruv## ri#srzhu# # # lq#Zdvklqjwrq1# # # Phdqzkloh/# ri#zulwlqj/# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#fdslwdov#ri#frqwlqhqwdo#Hxursh/#zkhuh#xqhpsor|phqw#vdihw|#qhwv#duh#vwurqjhu/# # # eh## wdnlqj## vlplodu## ohyhov## ri## xqhpsor|phqw## lq## wkhlu## vwulgh1## Rqfh## djdlq/# vhhp#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuh#lv#h{wudruglqdu|#srolwlfdo#suhvvxuh#rq#Frqjuhvv#dqg#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#wr# vrphkrz## surgxfh## mrev1## Dowkrxjk## wkhuh## duh## vrph## yluwxhv## wr## uhwdlqlqj## wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ioh{lelolw|#wr#wdloru#srolf|#wr#wkh#vlwxdwlrq/#srolf|#pdgh#xqghu#wkh#srolwlfdo#jxq#dqg# zlwk## srolwlfdo## udwkhu## wkdq## hfrqrplf## remhfwlyhv## w|slfdoo|## grhv## qrw## surgxfh# # # wzr## lpsruwdqw#hiihfwv=# # # iluvw/## dv## L#dujxh# # # lq#wklv# # # fkdswhu/## lw# hiihfwlyh## srolf|1## Lw#kdv# whqgv## wr## pdnh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## wkh## uholdeoh## vwlpxodwru## ri## iluvw## uhvruw## iru## wkh# # # lqfhqwlyh## wr# zruog/## wdnlqj## wkh## exughq## rii## rwkhu## frxqwulhv## dqg## jlylqj## wkhp#ohvv# # # # # # ## # # # # # # dowhu#wkhlu#jurzwk#vwudwhjlhv1#Vhfrqg/#dv#L#dujxh#lq#wkh#qh{w#fkdswhu/#wkh#h{fhvvlyh# # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfdo#lqfhqwlyh#wr#vwlpxodwh#surgxfhv#prqhwdu|#srolf|#wkdw#zdusv#lqfhqwlyhv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#dqg#frqwulexwhv#wr#wkh#nlqg#ri#ilqdqfldo#glvdvwhu#zh#kdyh#mxvw# h{shulhqfhg1#
Wkh#Zhdn#Vdihw|#Qhw # # # # Dq## lpsruwdqw## klvwrulfdo## gliihuhqfh## ehwzhhq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## dqg## prvw# frqwlqhqwdo#Hxurshdq#frxqwulhv#kdv#ehhq#wkh#ohyho#ri#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv1#Iru# # # # # # # # # # # h{dpsoh/## d## frpsuhkhqvlyh## vwxg|## ryhu## wkh## shulrg## 4<;<ᄆ<7## vkrzv## wkdw## X1V1# xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv# # # zhuh## qrw#rqo|#vrphzkdw#orzhu# # # # # wkdq#lq#prvw#frqwlqhqwdo# # # # Hxurshdq#frxqwulhvᄇwkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## rq#dyhudjh/# # # uhsodfhg## 83## shufhqw#ri#orvw# # # zdjhv/## zkloh## Iudqfh## uhsodfhg## 8:## shufhqw## dqg## Jhupdq|## 96## shufhqwᄇexw## wkhvh# ehqhilwv#udq#rxw#pxfk#pruh#txlfno|1#Lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#rq#dyhudjh/#ehqhilwv#udq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw#lq#vl{#prqwkv/#zkhuhdv#lq#Iudqfh#ehqhilwv#odvwhg#iru#xs#wr#wkuhh#|hduv/#dqg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Jhupdq|#wkh|#odvwhg#lqghilqlwho|1#Vlqfh#wkdw#vwxg|/#Jhupdq#uhirupv#kdyh#eurxjkw# # # # # # # # # # # grzq#wkh# # # gxudwlrq#ri#ehqhilwv# # # # wr## rqh## dqg## d## kdoi#|hduv/# # # exw#wkh# # # pd{lpxp#zdjh0 # uhsodfhphqw#udwhv# # # lq#erwk#Iudqfh# # # # dqg## Jhupdq|#kdyh# # # ehhq#lqfuhdvhg# # # vrphzkdw/# zlwk#olwwoh#fkdqjh#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# # # # # # # Wkhuh#duh#krohv#hyhq#lq#wkh#uhodwlyho|#vfdqw#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv#rq#riihu#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Dowkrxjk## pruh## wkdq## <3## shufhqw## ri## zrunhuv## duh## fryhuhg## e|# xqhpsor|phqw## lqvxudqfh/## rqo|#derxw# # # 73## shufhqw## ri## wkhp#uhfhlyh# # # ehqhilwv## zkhq# wkh|#ehfrph#xqhpsor|hg1#Vrph#grqᄊw#txdoli|#iru#ehqhilwv#ehfdxvh#wkh|#kdyh#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # zrunhg#orqj#hqrxjk/#rwkhuv#ehfdxvh#wkh|#ohiw#yroxqwdulo|/#|hw#rwkhuv#ehfdxvh#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # duh## lqyroyhg## lq## oderu## glvsxwhv/## dqg## vwloo## rwkhuv## ehfdxvh## wkh|## gr## qrw## pdnh# 7# wkhpvhoyhv#dydlodeoh#iru#zrun#zkloh#xqhpsor|hg1 # # # # # Wkh#zruu|#iru#vrphrqh#zkr#orvhv#d#mre#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#lv#frpsrxqghg#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## devhqfh## ri## xqlyhuvdo## khdowk## fduh## ru## diirugdeoh## sulydwh## phglfdo## lqvxudqfh1# Ehfdxvh## Dphulfdᄊv## wd{## frgh## vxevlgl}hv## khdowk## lqvxudqfh## surylghg## wkurxjk# hpsor|huv/## wkh## xqhpsor|hg## kdyh## wr## sd|## vhyhudo## wlphv## pruh## wr## jhw## wkh## vdph# ehqhilwv## wkh|## rewdlqhg## suhylrxvo|## wkurxjk## wkhlu## mrev1## Pruhryhu/## hyhq## zkhq# lqglylgxdov#fdq#diirug#lw/#sulydwh#lqvxuhuv#fdq#uhixvh#wkhp#fryhudjh#li#wkh|#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhq## d## plog## suhh{lvwlqj## phglfdo## frqglwlrq/## dv## Edgul## glg1## Jlyhq## wkdw## hyhq## wkh# dssduhqwo|#khdowk|#frxog#kdyh#d#suhh{lvwlqj#frqglwlrq#wkh|#duh#xqdzduh#ri/#prvw# # # # # # # # # # # # Dphulfdqv## duh## xqghuvwdqgdeo|## dq{lrxv## derxw## srwhqwldo## xqhpsor|phqw/## dqg## wkh# ghvluh## ri#wkh# # # xqhpsor|hg## wr## uhmrlq#wkh# # # udqnv## ri#wkh# # # hpsor|hg## lv## lpphqvh1## Dqg# zkhq#Dphulfdqv#duh#dq{lrxv/#wkh|#duh#qrw#vk|#derxw#ohwwlqj#wkhlu#uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv# # # # # # # # # # # # nqrz1## Dv## xqhpsor|phqw## prxqwv/## vr## wrr## grhv## wkh## suhvvxuh## rq#srolwlfldqv# # # wr## gr# vrphwklqj1#
Mreohvv#Uhfryhulhv # # Dv#zh#kdyh#vhhq/#mre#jurzwk#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#iurp#wkh#wurxjk#ri#srvwzdu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhfhvvlrqv#kdv#w|slfdoo|#ehhq#udslg1#Wkxv#hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv# # # # # # # # # # # duh#ri#vkruw#gxudwlrq/#lq#suhylrxv#grzqwxuqv#wkh|#zhuh#hqrxjk#wr#vxssruw#prvw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## xqhpsor|hg## xqwlo## wkh|#irxqg# # # d## mre1## Lq#frqwudvw#wr# # # # wkh## vlwxdwlrq#lq#frqwlqhqwdo# # # Hxurshdq#frxqwulhv/#orqj0whup#xqhpsor|phqw#kdv#ehhq#uduh/#shukdsv#ehfdxvh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # vkruw#gxudwlrq#ri#ehqhilwv# # # # # irufhg#wkh#xqhpsor|hg#wr#vhdufk#kdughu# # # # # # # dqg#vhwwoh#iru# # # ohvv1# Hfrqrplvwv#duh#vwloo#dujxlqj#ryhu#zk|#wkh#4<<3ᄆ<4#dqg#5334#uhfhvvlrqv#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zhuh## gliihuhqw1## Rqh## wkhru|## lv## wkdw## xqolnh## lq## sdvw## uhfhvvlrqv/## lq# zklfk#idfwrulhv#odlg#rii#zrunhuv#whpsrudulo|#zkhq#ghpdqg#zdv#orz#dqg#uhkluhg# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp#zkhq#ghpdqg#uhfryhuhg/#wkh#hfrqrp|#dw#wkhvh#wlphv#zdv#xqghujrlqj#ghhs# # # # # # # # # # # # 8# vwuxfwxudo## fkdqjh1 # Uhvrxufhv## zhuh## prylqj## iurp#pdwxuh# # # rog## lqgxvwulhv## wr## qhz# |rxqj#rqhvᄇiurp#vwhho# # # # wr## vriwzduh/## vr## wr## vshdn1## Dv## d## uhvxow/## odlg0rii#zrunhuv# # kdg#wr#vhdufk#pxfk#kdughu# # # # # # dqg#dovr#uhwudlq#wkhpvhoyhv# # # # # iru## wkh## dydlodeoh## mrevᄇ# khqfh#wkh#mreohvv#uhfryhu|1#Dowkrxjk#wklv#dujxphqw#lv#sodxvleoh/#wkh#hylghqfh#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuh## zdv## pxfk## pruh## prelolw|## ri## zrunhuv## ehwzhhq## lqgxvwulhv## gxulqj## wkhvh# uhfhvvlrqv#lv#zhdn1# # # Dqrwkhu## h{sodqdwlrq#kdv# # # wr## gr## zlwk#wkh# # # ᄈfohdqvlqjᄡ## uroh## ri#uhfhvvlrqv1# # # Lq#wkh# # vdph#zd|#dv#uhjxodu#vpdoo#iluhv#ulg#iruhvwv#ri#xqghujurzwk#wkdw#frxog#frqwulexwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## d## juhdwhu## dqg## pruh## ghydvwdwlqj#frqiodjudwlrq/# # # uhfhvvlrqv## irufh## ilupv## wr## wklqn# kdug#derxw#wkhlu#uhvrxufhv#dqg#frpsho#wkhp#wr#uhdoorfdwh#uhvrxufhv#uxwkohvvo|#lq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # zd|## wkdw## zrxog## qrw## rffxu## lq## pruh## qrupdo## wlphv1## Lq## wkh## surfhvv## wkh|## khos## wkh# hfrqrp|#dyrlg#ghhshu# # # # orqj0whup#gdpdjh1#Iru# # # # h{dpsoh/#vxshuylvruv#dffxpxodwh# # # doo#vruwv#ri#xqsurgxfwlyh#hpsor|hhv#dqg#srvlwlrqv#ryhu#wkh#frxuvh#ri#h{sdqvlrqv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Qrw## rqo|## lv## lw## shuvrqdoo|## sdlqixo## iru## d## vxshuylvru## wr## iluh## dq## lqfrpshwhqw# hpsor|hh/## lw## dovr## gdpdjhv## prudoh## dprqj## wkh## uhvw## ri## wkh## vwdii/## vr## wkh## qdwxudo# whqghqf|#lv# # # wr## dyrlg## kduvk#dfwlrqv1# # # D#uhfhvvlrq#riihuv# # # # vxshuylvruv## dq#h{fxvh# # # wr# fxw## wkh## ghdg## zrrg=## ᄈZh## kdyh## wr## fxw## mrev## lq## rughu## wr## uhpdlq## frpshwlwlyh1ᄡ# Ixuwkhupruh/#wkh#dq{lhw|#ri#vxuylylqj#hpsor|hhv#lv#olplwhg#wr#wkh#gxudwlrq#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # 9# uhfhvvlrq1#Ilupv#wkhuhiruh#xvh#uhfhvvlrqv#wr#fohdq#krxvh#hiihfwlyho|1 # # # # # # # # Zkdw#zdv#gliihuhqw#derxw#wkh#4<<3ᄆ<4#dqg#5334#uhfhvvlrqv#lv#wkdw#hdfk#fdph# # # # # # # # # # # # # diwhu## qhduo|#d#ghfdgh#ri#jurzwk1#Dffruglqj#wr#wklv#ylhz/#ilupv#kdg#dftxluhg#idu# # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh## ᄈxqghujurzwkᄡ## gxulqj## wkh## orqj## h{sdqvlrq=## wkxv## pruh## fohdqvlqj## zdv# qhfhvvdu|#dqg#lwv#hiihfwv#pruh#surorqjhg1#Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/#wkh#orqjhu#wkh#|hduv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # sohqw|/## wkh## orqjhu## wkh## idplqh1## Exw## ehfdxvh## zh## kdyh## qrw## kdg## pdq|## srvwzdu# uhfhvvlrqv## iroorzlqj## orqj## h{sdqvlrqv/## wkh## hylghqfh## iru## wklv## h{sodqdwlrq## lv## qrw# ryhuzkhoplqj#hlwkhu1# # \hw#dqrwkhu# # # k|srwkhvlv## kdv## wr## gr## zlwk#lpsuryhphqwv# # # lq#wkh# # # klulqj#surfhvv1# # # Lq# hduolhu## uhfryhulhv/## ilupv## zrxog## sxw## rxw## dgyhuwlvhphqwv## iru## srvlwlrqv/## shrsoh# zrxog#uhso|#e|#pdlo/#eh#vfuhhqhg/#dqg#wkhq#eh#fdoohg#iru#lqwhuylhzv/#doo#ri#zklfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrrn#wlph1#Orqj#ohdg#wlphv#lq#klulqj#phdqw#wkdw#ilupv#kdg#wr#zruu|#wkdw#wkh|#pljkw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#kdyh#hqrxjk#hpsor|hhv#wr#phhw#wkh#jurzlqj#ghpdqg#dqg#frxog#orvh#vdohv#li# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#glg#qrw#vwduw#klulqj#hduo|#hqrxjk1#Zlwk#wkh#dgyhqw#ri#wkh#Lqwhuqhw/#lw#lv#hdvlhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
iru## ilupv## zlwk## srvlwlrqv## dqg## fdqglgdwhv## zlwk## wkh## uljkw## txdolilfdwlrqv## wr## ilqg## d# pdwfk1#Wkh#Lqwhuqhw#dovr#pdnhv#lw#hdvlhu# # # # # # # # iru## ilupv#wr#zdlw#dqg#zdwfk#wkhlu# # # # # # # rughu# :# errnv/#klulqj#mxvw#lq#wlph#wr#phhw#ghpdqg1 # # # # # # # #Ri#frxuvh/#zkhq#hyhu|#ilup#grhv#wklv/# # # # # # # lw## glplqlvkhv## wkh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## kluh=## qrw## rqo|## grhv## xqhpsor|phqw## shuvlvw/# ghsuhvvlqj#ghpdqg/#exw#wkh#srro#ri#dydlodeoh#fdqglgdwhv#lv#dovr#olnho|#wr#uhpdlq# # # # # # # # # # # # # odujh/#vr#wkhuh#lv#qr#xujhqf|#wr#pryh#txlfno|#wr#kluh#wkh#ehvw#fdqglgdwhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Rqh## slhfh## ri## hylghqfh## lq## vxssruw## ri## wkh## ᄈmxvw0lq0wlphᄡ## klulqj## wkhru|## lv## wkh# juhdwhu## ghshqghqfh## ri## ilupv## rq## whpsrudu|## zrunhuv## lq## wkh## wzr## prvw## uhfhqw# uhfryhulhv/#zklfk#vxjjhvwv#d#uhoxfwdqfh#rq#wkh#sduw#ri#ilupv#wr#fuhdwh#shupdqhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # mrev1#Dv#whpsrudu|#mrev#jurz#lq#wkh#fxuuhqw#uhfryhu|#dovr/#Zlooldp#Ghqqlv#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Qdwlrqdo## Ihghudwlrq## ri## Lqghshqghqw## Exvlqhvv## uhdiiluphg## wklv## ylhz/## vd|lqj=# ᄈZkhq#d#mre#frphv#rshq#qrz/#rxu#phpehuv#iloo#lw#zlwk#d#whps/#ru#wkh|#h{whqg#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sduw0wlphu#ᄊv#krxuv/#ru#wkh|#eulqj#lq#d#iuhhodqfhuᄇdqg#wkhq#wkh|#zdlw#wr#vhh#zkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ;# zloo#kdsshq#qh{w1ᄡ # # Uhjdugohvv#ri#zklfk#ri#wkh#wkhrulhv#lv#uljkw/#li#prvw#ru#doo#ixwxuh#uhfryhulhv#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # olnho|## wr## eh## mreohvv/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## zlwk## lwv## zhdn## vdihw|## qhw/## lv## vlqjxoduo|# xqsuhsduhg#iru#wkhp1# # #
Zk|#Lv#wkh#Vdihw|#Qhw#ZhdnB # # # # # # Zk|#duh# # # xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv# # # vr#pxfk#pruh# # # # olplwhg#lq#wkh# # # # Xqlwhg#VwdwhvB# # Dphulfdqv## duh#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|#ohvv# # # # # fdulqj#ru# # # jhqhurxv## wkdq#wkh#flwl}hqv# # # # ri#rwkhu# # ulfk#frxqwulhv1# # # Lq#idfw/# # # Dphulfdqv## w|slfdoo|#jlyh# # # pruh## wr## fkdulw|#wkdq#shrsoh# # # # lq# pdq|## rwkhu## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv1## Dffruglqj## wr## rqh## vwxg|## lq## 5333/## wkh## dyhudjh# Dphulfdq#jdyh# # # '9<4## wr## fkdulw|/## zkloh## wkh## dyhudjh## iru## wkh## Xqlwhg## Nlqjgrp#zdv# # <# '474#dqg#iru#Hxursh#dv#d#zkroh#'8:1 # # # # # # # #Li#wkh#h{sodqdwlrq#lv#qrw#vwlqjlqhvv/#zkdw#lv# # # # # # # # lwB## Wkhuh## lv## qr## vlqjoh## dqvzhu## wr## wklv## txhvwlrq/## exw#xqghuvwdqglqj#wkh# # # # jhqhvlv## ri# wklv## srolf|#lv# # # fulwlfdo## wr#iljxulqj#rxw#zk|#wkh# # # # # # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # kdv## qrw#ehhq#deoh#wr# # # # uhirup## lwv## v|vwhp## hdvlo|/## dqg## zk|## vr## pxfk## ri## d## exughq## kdv## idoohq## rq## srolf|# vwlpxoxv#lq#uhfhqw#wlphv1# # # #
Wkh#Hfrqrplf#Dqvzhuv# # # # Fdulfdwxuhv## duh## xvhixo## ehfdxvh## wkh|#fdq#gudz# # # # rxw#wkh# # # hvvhqwldo## qdwxuh## ri#wkh# # remhfw## ehlqj## fdulfdwxuhg1## Li## L## kdg## wr## fdulfdwxuh## X1V1## ilupv## +ru## pruh## eurdgo|/# Dqjor0Dphulfdq## ilupv/## hqfrpsdvvlqj## ilupv## iurp## Dxvwudold/## Fdqdgd/## Qhz# ]hdodqg/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Nlqjgrp/## dqg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv,/## L## zrxog## ghvfuleh## wkhp# eurdgo|#dv# # # rshudwlqj## dw## dupᄊv## ohqjwk## zlwk## wkhlu## vxssolhuv/## ohqghuv/## fxvwrphuv/# dqg## hpsor|hhv/## lqqrydwlyh## dqg## udglfdo## lq## wkrxjkw## dqg## dfwlrq/## dqg## uxwkohvv## lq# dvvljqlqj## erwk## eodph## dqg## uhzdugv1## Frqwudvw## wkhvh## dwwulexwhv## zlwk## ilupv## lq# frqwlqhqwdo#Hxursh#ru#Mdsdq/#zklfk#duh#ehwwhu#ghvfulehg#dv#uho|lqj#rq#orqj0whup# # # # # # # # # # # # uhodwlrqvklsv## zlwk#vxssolhuv/# # # edqnv/## fxvwrphuv/## dqg## hpsor|hhv/## lqfuhphqwdo## lq# wkrxjkw## dqg## dfwlrq/## dqg## pruh## zloolqj## wr## vkduh## sdlq## dqg## jdlq## dprqj## wkhlu# dvvrfldwhv1## Wkh## vslulw## ri## wkh## orqj0whup#uhodwlrqvkls# # # udwkhu## wkdq#wkh# # # ohwwhu## ri## wkh# ohjdo#frqwudfw#gulyhv#lqwhudfwlrqv1# # # # Wkhvh#fkdudfwhulvwlfv#duh#qhlwkhu#vwdwlf#qru#doo0hqfrpsdvvlqj1#Ilupv#dfurvv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # zruog## duh## fkdqjlqj## udslgo|1## Lq## Mdsdq/## d## frxqwu|## rqfh## idphg## iru## orqj0whup# hpsor|phqw/#d#fduhhu#vshqw#zrunlqj#iru#rqh#frpsdq|#lv#qr#orqjhu#wkh#qrup/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # d## odujh## qxpehu## ri#|rxqj#zrunhuv# # # # rffxs|#whpsrudu|#srvlwlrqv1# # # # Qru## zrxog## lw#eh# # gliilfxow#wr#ilqg#fdulqj/#vkdulqj#ilupv#wkdw#kdyh#vwurqj#uhodwlrqvklsv#zlwk#vxssolhuv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## ru## uxwkohvv## rqhv## lq## Hxursh1## Exw## L## glg## vd|## wkhvh## zhuh# fdulfdwxuhv/#fruuhfw#lq#wkh#eurdg#vzhhs#udwkhu#wkdq#lq#ilqh#ghwdlo1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#srlqw#ri#gudzlqj#rxw#wkhvh#fkdudfwhulvwlfv#lv#wr#dujxh#wkdw#wkh|#pd|#ehorqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrjhwkhu#dqg#pd|#jhqhudwh#gliihuhqw#irupv#ri#vdihw|#qhw1#Vshflilfdoo|/#pdwxuh#ilupv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh# # # dupᄊv0ohqjwk#Dqjor0Dphulfdq#hfrqrplhv# # # # idfh## d## pdunhw0rulhqwhg#ilqdqfldo# # v|vwhp## wkdw## ghshqgv## rq## wudqvsduhqf|## dqg## glvforvxuh1## Kdug## lqirupdwlrq## olnh# txduwhuo|#vdohv/#hduqlqjv/#dqg#fdvk#iorz#fdq#eh#hdvlo|#wudqvplwwhg#wr#lqyhvwruv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## pdunhw1## Exw## wkh## pruh## xs0wr0gdwh## lqirupdwlrq## wkdw## pdqdjhphqw## jhwv/## vxfk## dv# lqfrplqj#vdohv# # # qxpehuv## ru## lqyhqwru|#exlogxs/# # # dv## zhoo## dv## pdunhw#uxpruv/# # # lv## qrw# hdv|#wr# # # wudqvplw## zlgho|#wr# # # lqyhvwruv## ehfdxvh## lw## frxog## eh## lqdffxudwh## dv## zhoo## dv# ohvv## frqfuhwh1## Pruhryhu/## vriw## lqirupdwlrq## vxfk## dv## pdqdjhphqw## fkdudfwhu/# fdsdelolwlhv/## dqg## vwuhqjwk## ri## sxusrvhᄇzklfk## fdq## riwhq## eh## jdxjhg## ryhu## wlph#
wkurxjk#shuvrqdo#phhwlqjvᄇvlpso|#fdqqrw#eh#wudqvplwwhg#wr#wkh#pdunhw#rwkhu#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # wkurxjk#dvvhvvphqwv# # # e|#lqyhvwphqw# # # dqdo|vwv/## zkrvh## rzq#ylhzv# # # pd|#froru# # # wkhlu# mxgjphqw1## Krz/## iru## lqvwdqfh/## fdq#lqyhvwruv# # # jdxjh## zkhwkhu## wkh## FHR## lv## lq#wrxfk# # zlwk#hyhu|wklqj#wkdw#lv#jrlqj#rq#lq#wkh#ilup#ru#vlpso|#wkh#wdonlqj#khdg#gholyhulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## SrzhuSrlqw## suhvhqwdwlrq## dw## lqyhvwru## phhwlqjvᄇhvshfldoo|## zkhq## kh## lv# srolwlfdoo|#dvwxwh#dw#fkrrvlqj#zklfk#txhvwlrqv#wr#dqvzhuB# # # # # # # # E|## frqwudvw/## lq## wkh## frqwlqhqwdo## Hxurshdq## dqg## Mdsdqhvh## v|vwhp/## ilupv## kdyh# vwurqjhu/## orqjhu0whup/## pruh## uhodwlrqvkls0edvhg## lqwhudfwlrqv## zlwk#lqyhvwruv/# # # zkr# duh## w|slfdoo|## lqvwlwxwlrqv## olnh## edqnv## dqg## lqvxudqfh## frpsdqlhv1## Ilupv## fdq## vkduh# wuhphqgrxv## dprxqwv## ri#lqvlgh# # # dv## zhoo## dv## vriw#lqirupdwlrq#zlwk#d# # # # # edqnhu## zkrp# wkh|## kdyh## lqwhudfwhg## zlwk## iru## |hduv1## Wklv## uhodwlrqvkls## lpsuryhv## wkh## edqnhu#ᄊv# delolw|#wr#pdnh# # # # vrxqg#ohqglqj#ghflvlrqv# # # # dqg#vkdsh# # # pdqdjhphqw#dfwlrqv/#dqg#wkh# # # # uhodwlrqvkls#jlyhv# # # khu## d#juhdwhu# # # lqfhqwlyh#wr#khos#d#wurxeohg#folhqw#ilup#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # vkh## nqrzv## wkh## folhqw## zloo## qrw## dedqgrq## khu## oljkwo|## zkhq## jrrg## wlphv## frph# durxqg143# Wkh## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## v|vwhp## dssolhv## suhvvxuh## iru## kdug## phdvxudeoh## dqg# frppxqlfdeoh## uhvxowv/## ehfdxvh## wklv## lv## krz## wkh## pdunhw## jdxjhv## wrs## pdqdjhphqw1# Wkh## suhvvxuh## wudyhov## wkurxjk## wkh## v|vwhp/## dqg## pdqdjhuv## zkr## gr## qrw## pdnh## wkhlu# qxpehuv#duh#sxw#rq#qrwlfh1#Lq#d#grzqwxuq/#wkh#suhvvxuh#lv#hvshfldoo|#kljk#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hduqlqjv## ehfrph## d## nh|#lqglfdwru# # # ri#zkhwkhu# # # d## ilup#lv# # # surilwdeoh## dqg## zkhwkhu## lw# vkrxog#eh#fxw#rii#iurp#ixqglqj1#Ilupv#kdyh#olwwoh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#qxuvh#h{fhvv#oderu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkurxjk#d#grzqwxuq/#suhihuulqj#lqvwhdg#wr#od|#rii#uhgxqgdqw#zrunhuv#dqg#kluh#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # edfn/#ru#kluh#qhz#rqhv#rqfh#wkh#uhfryhu|#vhwv#lq1#Vlploduo|/#wkh#pdunhw#uxwkohvvo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fxwv## rii## xqghushuiruplqj## ilupv## iurp## ilqdqfh/## hqvxulqj## wkdw## wkh|## kdyh## wr## eh# uhvwuxfwxuhg#ru#oltxlgdwhgᄇpxfk#dv#lw#irufhg#Edgulᄊv#hpsor|hu#wr#forvh#lwv#X1V1# # # # # # # # # # # # rshudwlrqv1# Wkh#uhodwlrqvkls#v|vwhp#doorzv#wrs#pdqdjhphqw#d#olwwoh#pruh#ohhzd|1#Ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # ohqghuv## nqrz## wkh## pdqdjhphqw#dqg# # # fdq#orrn#eh|rqg# # # # wkh## qxpehuv## lq#d# # # grzqwxuq/# wkh|#fdq#olyh#zlwk#orzhu#surilwdelolw|#iru#d#zkloh1#Wkh#suhvvxuh#wr#iluh#uhgxqgdqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrunhuv#lv#orzhu/#hvshfldoo|#li#wkh|#duh#frqvlghuhg#lpsruwdqw#dqg#kdug#wr#uhsodfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#orqjhu#whup1#Frqyhuvho|/#zrunhuv#duh#pruh#or|do#dqg#kdyh#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghyhors#vnloov#wkdw#pdnh#wkhp#hvshfldoo|#ydoxdeoh#wr#wkh#ilup/#hyhq#li#wkrvh#vnloov# # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh## qrw#hdvlo|#pdunhwdeoh# # # # hovhzkhuh1#Ilqdoo|/#jryhuqphqwv# # # # whqg#wr#eh# # # # zloolqj#wr# # jr#wkh#h{wud#ploh#wr#suhvhuyh#h{lvwlqj#mrev1# # # # # # # # 44## Lq#hduo|#533</#dv#d#uhvxow# D#uhfhqw#h{dpsoh#ri#wkh#gliihuhqfhv#pd|#eh#xvhixo1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## sdqlf## dqg## wkh## dvvrfldwhg## gliilfxow|## lq## vhfxulqj## ilqdqflqj/## fdu# ghpdqg## soxpphwhg## durxqg## wkh## zruog1## Lq## erwk## Qruwk## Dphulfd## dqg## Hxursh/# srolwlfldqv#dssuryhg#eloolrqv#ri#grooduv#ri#dlg#wr#fdu#pdqxidfwxuhuv#ehfdxvh#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # ihow#wkh#ploolrqv#ri#mrev#wlhg#wr#wkh#lqgxvwu|#pdgh#lw#wrr#elj#wr#idlo1#Lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv/## Jhqhudo## Prwruv## dqg## Fku|vohu## vhfxuhg## jryhuqphqw## ixqglqj## rq## frqglwlrq# wkdw#wkh|#wdnh#gudvwlf#dfwlrq#wr#uhvwuxfwxuh#wkhlu#ilupv/#forvh#xqyldeoh#sodqwv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhoo## xqsurilwdeoh## eudqgv1## Diwhu## dq## lqlwldo## uhvwuxfwxulqj## sodq## zdv## uhmhfwhg## e|# jryhuqphqw## ryhuvhhuv## dv## wrr## wlplg/## wkh## ilupv## glg## lqghhg## wdnh## gudvwlf## dfwlrq/# hphujlqj#iurp#edqnuxswf|#vljqlilfdqwo|#vkuxqnhq1#E|#frqwudvw/#lq#Iudqfh/#Shxjhrw# # # # # # # # # # dqg#Uhqdxow#uhfhlyhg#vxevwdqwldo# # # # # dprxqwv## ri#jryhuqphqw#ixqgv#rq#frqglwlrq#wkdw# # # # # # wkh|#forvh#qr#sodqwv#dqg#iluh#qr#zrunhuv#ryhu#wkh#whup#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#ordq$# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Grhv## wklv## phdq## wkh## Dqjor0Dphulfdq## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## v|vwhp## lv## doo## edgB## Qrw# qhfhvvdulo|1#Uhvrxufhv# # # duh#uhdoorfdwhg#pruh#txlfno|#wr#surilwdeoh#xvhv=# # # # # # # # shukdsv# wkh## fdu## lqgxvwu|## grhv## qhhg## wr## vkulqn## vxevwdqwldoo|1## Dsduw## iurp## wkh## dgghg# hiilflhqf|/## wkh## zloolqjqhvv## wr## eh## uxwkohvv## khosv## lqqrydwlrq1## Sdvw#h{shulhqfh# # # dqg# uhodwlrqvklsv#duh#ri#olwwoh#ydoxh#lq#gulylqj#udglfdo#lqqrydwlrq=#lqghhg/#ehfdxvh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # qdwxudo#kxpdq#whqghqf|#lv#wr#gr#pruh#ri#wkh#vdph#dqg#wr#vhuyh#h{lvwlqj#folhqwv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 45# qhhgv## zhoo/#sdvw#uhodwlrqvklsv# # # # fdq#eh#srvlwlyho|#ghwulphqwdo1 # # # # Wkh## dupᄊv0ohqjwk# dssurdfk#kdv#dgydqwdjhv#khuh1#Iru#rqh/#ehfdxvh#qhz#ilupv#fdq#eh#pdwfkhg#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # qhz## ilqdqflhuv/## d## zlghu## udqjh## ri## pdwfkhv## lv## srvvleoh/## dqg## wkhuh## lv## juhdwhu# srwhqwldo#iru#qhz#lghdv#wr#eh#ilqdqfhg1#Dovr/#ehfdxvh#edg#lghdv#duh#qrw#shuplwwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#frqwlqxh#vxfnlqj#uhvrxufhv/#wklv#v|vwhp#fdq#hqjdjh#lq#ulvnlhu#h{shulphqwdwlrq1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## uxwkohvvqhvv## ri## yhqwxuh## fdslwdolvwv## lq## nloolqj## edg## lghdv## rqfh## wkh|## duh# uhfrjql}hg#wr#eh#xqyldeoh#lv#idu#pruh#lpsruwdqw#wr#wkhlu#vxffhvv#wkdq#wkh#delolw|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lghqwli|## gldprqgv## lq## wkh## urxjk1## Wkh## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## v|vwhp## sodqwv## d## wkrxvdqg# iorzhuv/## xsurrwv## kxqguhgv## zkhq#wkh|#gr# # # # qrw## wkulyh/## dqg## qxuwxuhv## rqo|#d# # # ihz## wr# eorrp1## Qhz## rssruwxqlwlhv## derxqg/## zkloh## rog/## wluhg## zd|v## ri#grlqj#exvlqhvv# # # # duh# uxwkohvvo|#holplqdwhg1#Wkh#v|vwhpᄊv#vwuhqjwk/#wkhq/#lv#wkdw#lw#lv#qrw#khdylo|#eldvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wrzdug#suhvhuylqj#wkh#sulylohjhv#ri#lqfxpehqw#ilupv#dqg#zrunhuv1# # # # # # # # # Lq#wkh#ᄈuhodwlrqvklsᄡ#v|vwhp/#lqfuhphqwdo#fkdqjh#frphv#hdvlo|#ehfdxvh#h{lvwlqj# # # # # # # # # # ilupv## duh## deoh## wr## ghyhors## yduldwlrqv## rq## rog## wkhphv/## dqg## ilqdqflhuv/## kdylqj# ghyhorshg## d## ghhs## xqghuvwdqglqj#ri#wkh# # # # h{lvwlqj#exvlqhvv/# # # duh## zloolqj#wr# # # ilqdqfh# prghudwh## lqqrydwlrq1#Exw#ehfdxvh# # # # ihz## qhz## ilupv## fdq#euhdn#lq/#dqg#ehfdxvh# # # # # # wkh# v|vwhp#lv#qrw#jhduhg#wrzdug#jhqhudwlqj#ghshqgdeoh/#kdug#lqirupdwlrq#wkdw#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # pdnh#qhz#lqyhvwruv#frpiruwdeoh/#gudpdwlf#lqqrydwlrq#lv#kdughu1#Dqg#ehfdxvh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhp#lv# # # qrw#jhduhg# # # wrzdug## uxwkohvvo|#holplqdwlqj#edg# # # # lghdv/## lwv## zloolqjqhvv## wr# h{shulphqw#udglfdoo|#lv#dovr#pruh#olplwhg1#Edgulᄊv#hpsor|hu#uhwdlqhg#lwv#Jhupdq# # # # # # # # # # # sodqw## orqjhu## wkdq## lwv## Dphulfdq## sodqw## lq## odujh## sduw## ehfdxvh## ri## wkh## qdwxuh## ri## wkh# v|vwhp## hdfk## sodqw## rshudwhg## lq1## Dqg## wkh## pruh## surorqjhg## ghdwk## wkurhv## ri## wkh# Jhupdq#sodqw#vxjjhvw#wkdw#pruh#uhvrxufhv#zhuh#lqghhg#zdvwhg#wkhuh#zkloh#wu|lqj# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#pdlqwdlq#dq#xqyldeoh#rshudwlrq1# # # # # Wkdw#X1V1#uhvhdufk#dqg#ghyhorsphqw#whqgv#wr#eh#pruh#lqqrydwlyh#lv#vxjjhvwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # e|#wkh#iroorzlqj#gdwd=#lq#533;/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#dqg#wkh#Hxurshdq#Xqlrq/#zklfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#urxjko|#vlplodu#lq#wkh#vl}h#ri#wkhlu#JGS/#dffrxqwhg#iru#derxw#wkh#vdph#vkduh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#mrxuqdo#duwlfohv#sxeolvkhg#zruogzlgh#lq#vflhqfh#dqg#hqjlqhhulqj#+5;14#shufhqw# # # # # # # # # # # yhuvxv#6614#shufhqw,1#Exw#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#kdg#d#8419#shufhqw#vkduh#ri#wkh#prvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kljko|#flwhg#+dqg#wkxv# # # # # w|slfdoo|#sdwkeuhdnlqj,# # # duwlfohv/#zkloh# # # Hxursh## kdg#rqo|#d# # # 46# 5<19#shufhqw#vkduh1 # # Wkh## frpsdwlelolw|## ehwzhhq## wkh## hfrqrplf## v|vwhp## dqg## wkh## qdwxuh## ri# xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## lv## fohdu## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Wkh## hpskdvlv## lv## rq#udslg# # uhvwuxfwxulqj#lq#wkh#idfh#ri#glvwuhvv/#whuplqdwlqj#g|lqj#hqwhusulvhv/#dqg#ilqdqflqj# # # # # # # # # # # qhz#exvlqhvvhv1#Uhfhvvlrqv#duh#d#wlph#ri#erwk#ghvwuxfwlrq#dqg#qhz#fuhdwlrq1#Qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # rqo|#duh#mrev#ghvwur|hg/#exw#d#zkroh#vhw#ri#qhz#rqhv#duh#fuhdwhg1#Vkruw0gxudwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehqhilwv#jlyh#wkh#odlg0rii#zrunhu#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#dfwlyho|#orrn#iru#d#vxlwdeoh#mre1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Prelolw|#lv#hdv|#dfurvv#ilupv=#ehfdxvh#ri#wkh#odujh#qxpehu#ri#zrunhuv#ehlqj#odlg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rii/#wkhuh#lv#qr#vwljpd#dwwdfkhg#wr#xqhpsor|phqw1#Hqwu|#lqwr#hpsor|phqw#lv#dovr# # # # # # # # # # # # # hdv|## ehfdxvh## mrev## duh## qrw## forjjhg## xs## e|## lqfxpehqwv>## wkh## frqvwdqw## fkxuq## iuhhv# srvlwlrqv1#Edgul/#irufhg#wr#ilqg#d#mre#txlfno|/#hyhqwxdoo|#pryhg#wr#d#vwduw0xs#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
wkh## Plgzhvw/## hduqlqj## d## iudfwlrq## ri## klv## hduolhu## vdodu|1## Exw## kh## lv## surgxfwlyho|# hpsor|hg## grlqj## uhvhdufk## rq## qhz## pdwhuldov## dqg## lv## dftxlulqj## dq## duud|## ri## qhz# vnloov1# Wkh## jhqhurxv## dqg## orqj0gxudwlrq## xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## ri## wkh## uhodwlrqvkls# v|vwhp#pd|#dsshdu# # # # ohvv## frpsdwleoh#zlwk#wkh#uhodwlyho|#vhfxuh#orqj0whup#mrev# # # # # # # # lq# wkdw#v|vwhp1#Diwhu#doo/#juhdwhu#mre#vhfxulw|#zrxog#vxjjhvw#d#orzhu#qhhg#iru#orqj0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # gxudwlrq#ehqhilwv1#Wkh#uhdvrq#wkdw#orqj0gxudwlrq#ehqhilwv#pdnh#vhqvh#lv#wkh#juhdwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # ghjuhh## ri## vshfldol}dwlrq## ri## mrev## lq## wkh## v|vwhp## dqg## wkhuhiruh## wkh## glplqlvkhg# prelolw|1#Wkh#uhodwlrqvkls#v|vwhp#whqgv#wr#eh#rqh#ri#lqvlghuv#dqg#rxwvlghuv1#Wkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wkh#lqvlghᄇhpsor|hg#lq#ilupv#ru#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄇkdyh#d#idluo|#frpiruwdeoh/# # # # # # # # # # # vhfxuh## h{lvwhqfh1## Wkrvh## rq## wkh## rxwvlgh## kdyh## d## kdug## wlph## euhdnlqj## lq/## dqg## wkh# xqiruwxqdwh## ihz## zkr## orvh## wkhlu## mrev## dqg## mrlq## wkh## udqnv## ri## wkh## rxwvlghuv## duh# gdpqhg## erwk#ehfdxvh# # # wkhlu## sdvw#vshfldol}dwlrq#pd|#pdnh# # # # # lw#pxfk#kdughu# # # # wr## ilqg# dssursuldwh## mrev## dqg## ehfdxvh## wkh## v|vwhp#lv# # # qrw## jhduhg## wrzdug## udslg## dqg## hdv|# uhhqwu|1## Lq## vxfk## dv## v|vwhp/## xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## gr## olwwoh## wr## h{shglwh## mre# vhdufkhv>#udwkhu/#wkh|#pdnh#d#surorqjhg#h{lvwhqfh#rq#wkh#rxwvlgh#pruh#wrohudeoh# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#dsshdvh#wkh#dqjhu#ri#wkh#xqhpsor|hg1# # # # # # # Wkxv## hdfk#v|vwhp#kdv# # # # ghyhorshg## xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv## wkdw## duh## frpsdwleoh# zlwk#lwv# # # xqghuo|lqj#hfrqrplf# # # vwuxfwxuh1## Wklv## lv## qrw#wr# # # vd|#hyhu|wklqj#lv# # # # shuihfw1# Edgulᄊv## mre## zdv## fohduo|## kljko|## vshfldol}hg/## |hw## kh## zdv## fdvw## dguliw## ryhuqljkw/# zlwkrxw#surwhfwlrq1#Pruhryhu/#lw#lv#kdug#wr#vd|#zklfk#fdph#iluvw=# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ehqhilwv#ru# # # wkh## vwuxfwxuh1## Lqghhg/## lw## lv## dovr## srvvleoh## wkdw## d## frpprq## wklug## idfwru/## vxfk## dv# lghrorj|#ru#srolwlfv/#gulyhv#erwk1# # # # #
Wkh#Srolwlfv#ri#Ehqhilwv# # # # # Wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lv## sduvlprqlrxv## qrw## mxvw## zlwk#xqhpsor|phqw# # # ehqhilwv## exw# zlwk#rwkhu#irupv#ri#vrfldo#zhoiduh#dovr1#Dw#wkh#wlph#ri#zulwlqj/#lw#grhv#qrw#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqlyhuvdo## khdowk#fryhudjh/#ghvslwh#vshqglqj#d#juhdwhu# # # # # # # iudfwlrq#ri#JGS#rq#khdowk# # # # # fduh## wkdq#qhduo|#dq|#rwkhu# # # # # dgydqfhg## frxqwu|1## Dqg## lw#vshqgv# # # ohvv## rq#pdq|#rwkhu# # # zhoiduh#surjudpv1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#vshqw#:#shufhqw#ri#JGS#rq#rog0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # djh#shqvlrqv#dqg#glvdelolw|#sd|phqwv#lq#4<<;/#zkhuhdv#Iudqfh#vshqw#461:#shufhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## Jhupdq|## 451;## shufhqw147## Uhwluhphqw## ehqhilwv## wr## shrsoh## ryhu## djh## 98## zhuh# rqo|#4<16# # # shufhqw## ri## wkh## dyhudjh## zrunhu#ᄊv## suhwd{#lqfrph# # # lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/# frpsduhg## wr## 8;19## shufhqw#lq#Iudqfh# # # # dqg## 6:15## shufhqw#lq#Jhupdq|1# # # # Lw#lv# # # qrw#wkdw# # Dphulfdqv#kdyh#sohqw|#ri#vdylqjv#wr#frpshqvdwh=#wkh#PfNlqvh|#Joredo#Lqvwlwxwh# # # # # # # # # # # lqglfdwhv## wkdw#wzr0wklugv# # # ri#wkh# # # hduo|#ede|#errphuvᄇwkrvh# # # # eruq#ehwzhhq#4<78# # # dqg#4<87/#dqg#dprqj#wkh#zhdowklhvw#jhqhudwlrqv#lq#klvwru|ᄇgr#qrw#kdyh#hqrxjk# # # # # # # # # # # # 48# dvvhwv#wr#uhwluh#frpiruwdeo|1 # # # Wkhuh#pd|#zhoo#eh#vshfldo#dvshfwv#ri#wkh#X1V1#klvwrulfdo#h{shulhqfh#wkdw#gulyhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv## dqwlsdwk|## wrzdug## doo## irupv## ri## zhoiduh## ehqhilwv1## Dprqj## wkhvh## lqfoxgh## wkh# olehuwduldq## wudglwlrq## lq## srolwlfv/## wkh## devhqfh## ri## vwurqj## qdwlrqzlgh## zrunhuvᄊ# rujdql}dwlrqv/#wkh#frqfhqwudwlrq#ri#sryhuw|#lq#vhjphqwv#ri#wkh#srsxodwlrq#wkdw#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # udfldoo|#gliihuhqw/# # # wkh## odujh## vl}h## dqg## hdv|#prelolw|#zlwklq#wkh# # # # # hfrqrp|/## dqg## wkh# h{lvwhqfh## ri#frpshwlqj#hfrqrplf# # # # mxulvglfwlrqv## wkdw#pdnh# # # fhqwudol}hg## ohjlvodwlrq#
gliilfxow1# D## qxpehu## ri## klvwruldqv## kdyh## dujxhg## wkdw## wkhuh## lv## vrphwklqj## ixqgdphqwdoo|# olehudo## +lq#wkh#fodvvlfdo# # # # ru## Orfnhdq#vhqvh/#wkdw#lv/#hpeudflqj#wkh#iuhhgrp#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # lqglylgxdo## dqg## uhvlvwlqj## vljqlilfdqw## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq## ruglqdu|## olih,# hpehgghg#lq#wkh#fxowxudo#dqg#srolwlfdo#hwkrv#ri#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1#Kdylqj#hvfdshg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#w|udqqlhv#dqg#ihxgdolvp#ri#wkh#Rog#Zruog/#Dphulfdqv#glg#qrw#kdyh#wr#frpedw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 49## Dv#d#uhvxow/#wkh|#glg#qrw#ghyhors#d#vwurqj#fodvv# d#vwurqj#grphvwlf#dulvwrfudf|1 # # # # # # # # # # # # frqvflrxvqhvv#ru#wkh#qhhg#wr#xvh#jryhuqphqw#wr#ryhusrzhu#rssuhvvlyh#grphvwlf# # # # # # # # # # # holwhv1## Wkh## eholhiv## wkdw#duh# # # vwloo## h{suhvvhg## e|#pdq|#Dphulfdqv# # # # lq#vxuyh|vᄇwkdw# # wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## yluwxdoo|## xqolplwhg## rssruwxqlwlhv/## wkdw## hyhu|rqh## kdv## wkh# fdsdflw|## wr## ehfrph## ulfk## li## wkh|## rqo|## zrun## kdug## hqrxjk/## dqg## wkdw## dq|rqh## zkr# uhpdlqv## srru## suredeo|## kdv## qrw## wulhg## kdug## hqrxjkᄇvlw## zhoo## zlwk## d## ghvluh## iru# olplwhg## jryhuqphqw## dqg## zhoiduh1## Dqg## dowkrxjk## Dphulfdq## rssruwxqlw|## dqg# prelolw|#pd|#eh# # # # d## p|wk#iru# # # wkh## lppreloh## dqg## srru## xqghufodvv## dqg## lqfuhdvlqjo|# iru#pxfk#ri#wkh#plggoh#fodvv/#wkh#uhdolw|#ri#wkhlu#h{shulhqfh#kdv#qrw#|hw#dowhuhg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 4:# qdwlrqdo#hwkrv1 # D#sdudooho#vhw#ri#dujxphqwv#dvfulehv#wkh#Dphulfdq#gliihuhqfh#wr#wkh#devhqfh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # vwurqj#zrunhuvᄊ#rujdql}dwlrqv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1#Zklwh#Dphulfdq#pdohv#glg#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh#wr#iljkw#grphvwlf#holwhv#iru#wkh#uljkw#wr#yrwh1#Dv#d#uhvxow/#d#qdwlrqdo#zrunhuvᄊ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pryhphqw#qhyhu# # # uhdoo|#wrrn#krog#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhvᄇlq#frqwudvw#wr#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # Nlqjgrp/#iru#h{dpsoh/#zkhuh#zrunhuvᄊ#rujdql}dwlrqv#ghyhorshg#gxulqj#wkh#iljkw# # # # # # # # # # 4;# iru#wkh#yrwh#lq#wkh#qlqhwhhqwk#fhqwxu|1 # # # # # # # Wkh#uljkw#wr#yrwh#pljkw#kdyh#ehhq#dq#doo0 # # # # # # # # hqfrpsdvvlqj## lvvxh## wkdw## xqlwhg## zrunhuv## zkr## zhuh## rwkhuzlvh## glylghg## e|## orfdo# gliihuhqfhv## lq#zrun#frqglwlrqv# # # # dqg## remhfwlyhv1## Wkdw## lw## glg## qrw## rffxu## ohiw## oderu# xqlrqv#iudjphqwhg1# # Lqghhg/## lq#wkh# # # vhfrqg## kdoi#ri#wkh# # # # qlqhwhhqwk#fhqwxu|#zkhq#vwurqj#oderu# # # # # # xqlrqv# zhuh## ghyhorslqj#hovhzkhuh/# # # wkh## idfw#wkdw#wkh# # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv## d## odujh## frxqwu|# zlwk#dq#xqfxowlydwhg# # # # ᄈiurqwlhuᄡ## phdqw#wkdw#zrunhuv# # # # frxog## vlpso|#sxoo# # # xs## vwdnhv# dqg## pryh## li#wkh|#irxqg# # # # orfdo## frqglwlrqv## rssuhvvlyh/## dqg## wklv## ioh{lelolw|#lq#wxuq# # # dovr## olplwhg## wkh## h{whqw## wr## zklfk## frqglwlrqv## frxog## ehfrph## rssuhvvlyh## iru## wkh# preloh#zrunhu1#Wkh#gliilfxow|#ri#rujdql}lqj#d#qdwlrqzlgh#zrunhuvᄊ#pryhphqw#lq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwu|## zkhuh## gliihuhqfhv## lq## flufxpvwdqfhv## zhuh## vl}hdeoh/## dqg## zrunhuv## kdg# lqglylgxdo## rswlrqv## wr## h{lw## wrxjk## frqglwlrqv## e|## prylqj## rq/## vkrxog## qrw## eh# xqghuhvwlpdwhg1# D#uhodwhg# # # dujxphqw## iru## zk|## vwurqj## qdwlrqzlgh## zrunhu## rujdql}dwlrqv## glg## qrw# ghyhors#lv#wkdw#+h{fhsw#lq#wkh#Vrxwk,#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#odfnhg#d#odujh#rssuhvvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # shdvdqwu|## zkr## frxog## pdnh## frpprq## fdxvh## zlwk## zrunhuv/## dqg## lw## glg## qrw# h{shulhqfh#wkh#ghvshudwh#ghsulydwlrq#dqg#euhdngrzq#ri#dxwkrulw|#wkdw#rffxuuhg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # pdq|#frxqwulhv#lq#Hxursh#diwhu#hdfk#ri#wkh#zruog#zduv1#Lqghhg/#rqo|#53#shufhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#oderu#irufh#lq#Zhvwhuq#Hxursh#kdg#vrph#irup#ri#shqvlrq#lqvxudqfh#ehiruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Zruog#Zdu#L/#rqo|#55#shufhqw#kdg#khdowk#lqvxudqfh/#dqg#xqhpsor|phqw#lqvxudqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # zdv## doprvw#xqkhdug# # # ri1## Zrunhuv/## pdq|#ri#zkrp#kdg# # # # # ehfrph## srolwlfdoo|#dzduh# # zkloh#iljkwlqj#lq#wkh#wuhqfkhv#ri#Zruog#Zdu#L/#rujdql}hg#diwhu#wkh#zdu#wr#ghpdqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 4<# vrph## irup## ri## surwhfwlrq## djdlqvw## hfrqrplf## dgyhuvlw|1 # Wkhlu## ghpdqgv## zhuh# yrlfhg## e|#vrfldolvw#sduwlhv# # # # wkdw#jdlqhg# # # vwuhqjwk#lq#wkh# # # # srvwzdu## fkdrv/## dqg## pdq|# Hxurshdq## frxqwulhv## glg## hqdfw## sur0zrunhu## ohjlvodwlrq1## E|## frqwudvw/## vrfldolvw#
sduwlhv#kdyh#qhyhu#frppdqghg#pxfk#yrwlqj#srzhu#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# # # # # # # # # # # Zh## vkrxog## dovr## qrw## plqlpl}h## wkh## lpsruwdqfh## ri## srsxodwlrq## khwhurjhqhlw|1# ᄈWkhuh## exw## iru## wkh## judfh## ri## Jrg## jr## Lᄡ## riihuv## d## srzhuixo## udwlrqdoh## iru## vrfldo# lqvxudqfh1#Shrsoh# # # duh## pruh## zloolqj#wr#eh# # # # wd{hg#wr#ehqhilw#rwkhuv# # # # # li#wkh|#eholhyh# # # wkdw#wkh#ehqhilwv#jr#odujho|#wr#shrsoh#olnh#wkhpvhoyhv/#dqg#qrw#glvsursruwlrqdwho|# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#jurxsv# # # wkh|#gr#qrw#lghqwli|#zlwk1#Wklv# # # # # # # pd|#dovr#h{sodlq#zk|#Dphulfdqv# # # # # # jlyh# 53# jhqhurxvo|#wr#fkdulwlhv=#wkh|#kdyh#pruh#frqwuro#ryhu#zkr#wkh#ehqhilfldulhv#duh1 # # # # # # # # # # # Srolwlfldqv#zkr#zdqw#wr#ghudlo#ehqhilwv#ohjlvodwlrq#kdyh#riwhq#ehhq#txlfn#wr#udlvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## vshfwhu## ri## kdug0hduqhg## wd{sd|hu## prqh|## jrlqj## wr## wkh## xqghvhuylqj/# luuhvsrqvleoh/## dqg## od}|/## dqg## vxfk## ghpdjrjxhu|## lv## hvshfldoo|## srwhqw## zkhq## wkh# erjh|phq#orrn#dqg#ehkdyh#gliihuhqwo|#iurp#wkhlu#frqvwlwxhqwv1# # # # # # # # Lq## pxfk## ri## wkh## wzhqwlhwk## fhqwxu|/## wkh## wdujhwv## iru## ghpdjrjxhv## zhuh## Diulfdq# Dphulfdqv/## exw## ryhu## wlph## Dphulfdqv## kdyh## ohduqhg## wr## uhfrjql}h## wkh## ghhshu# sxusrvh## ehklqg## vxfk#odqjxdjh1# # # Pruh## uhfhqwo|/## loohjdo## lppljudqwv## kdyh## hphujhg# dv## wkh## qhz## wdujhw/#dqg#pxfk#dqjvw#lv# # # # # # h{shqghg#ryhu# # # wkh## srvvlelolw|#wkdw#ehqhilwv# # # pd|#ohdn#wr#wkhp1#Lqghhg/#d#edwwoh#kdv#huxswhg#lq#wkh#prvw#uhfhqw#urxqg#ri#khdowk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fduh## ohjlvodwlrq#ryhu# # # wkh## dffhvv## ri## loohjdo## lppljudqwv## wr## dq|#irup#ri# # # # wd{sd|hu0 ixqghg#surjudpv1#Lq#wklv#ghedwh/#ihz#ohjlvodwruv#kdyh#dvnhg#krz#X1V1#vrflhw|#fdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhpdlq#khdowk|#dqg#kxpdqh#zlwk#d#vlfn#dqg#xqsurwhfwhg#lppljudqw#srsxodwlrq#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # lwv#plgvw1# # Ilqdoo|/## exvlqhvv## lqwhuhvwv## dqg## prqh|#srzhu# # # kdyh## dozd|v## ehhq#dq#lpsruwdqw# # # irufh## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Dowkrxjk## wkhvh## lqwhuhvwv## kdg## wkh## vdph## gliilfxow|## lq# rujdql}lqj#dv# # # zrunhuv## glg## lq#d# # # odujh/## glyhuvh## frxqwu|ᄇh{fhsw#zkhq#d# # # # vshflilf# slhfh## ri#ohjlvodwlrq#froohfwlyho|#diihfwhg# # # # # wkhp#dqg# # # xqlwhg## wkhp#lq#rssrvlwlrqᄇ# # # wkh|## kdg## wzr## vwuhqjwkv## zrunhuv## odfnhg1## Iluvw/## ilup## rzqhuv## djjuhjdwhg## wkh# hfrqrplf#srzhu# # # ri#wkhlu# # # ilupv## dqg#wkxv# # # zhuh#lqglylgxdoo|#pxfk#pruh#srzhuixo# # # # # wkdq#dq|#ri#wkhlu# # # # # zrunhuv/## hyhq#li#rzqhuv# # # # dv## d## jurxs## zhuh## qrw#zhoo# # # rujdql}hg1# Vhfrqg/## li## exvlqhvv## frqglwlrqv## ehfdph## rssuhvvlyh## lq## rqh## vwdwh/## rzqhuv## frxog# pryh## lqyhvwphqw#wr# # # dqrwkhu## vwdwh1## Wkh## wkuhdw#ri#wkh# # # # orvv## ri#exvlqhvv# # # lqyhvwphqw# dqg#wkh#dvvrfldwhg#wd{hv#jdyh#vwdwhv/#hvshfldoo|#lqgxvwuldo#rqhv/#vwurqj#lqfhqwlyhv# # # # # # # # # # # qrw#wr#uhgxfh#exvlqhvv#surilwdelolw|1# # # # # Ri## frxuvh/## qrw## doo## ehqhilwv## uhgxfh## orqj0whup## surilwdelolw|1## Ilup## rzqhuv## duh# w|slfdoo|#qrw#kdug0khduwhg#Glfnhqvldq#iljxuhv/#vtxhh}lqj#hyhu|#gurs#ri#eorrg#rxw# # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkhlu#zrunhuvᄇlqghhg/#vxfk#ehkdylru#uduho|#pd{lpl}hv#surilwv1#Zrunhuv#zkr# # # # # # # # # # ihho## vdihu## +ehfdxvh## ri## xqhpsor|phqw## lqvxudqfh## dqg## shqvlrq## ehqhilwv,## dqg## duh# khdowklhu## +ehfdxvh#ri#khdowk#lqvxudqfh,# # # # # pljkw#lqghhg#eh#kdsslhu# # # # # dqg#zrun#pruh# # # hqwkxvldvwlfdoo|## iru## wkhlu## hpsor|huv/## hvshfldoo|## lq## vnloohg## mrev## zkhuh## zrunhu# hiiruw## lv## hvvhqwldo## exw## kdug## wr## prqlwru1## Lw## lv## olnho|/## wkrxjk/## wkdw## lq## wkh## hduo|# wzhqwlhwk## fhqwxu|/## d## vljqlilfdqw## sursruwlrq## ri## X1V1## hpsor|huv## zhuh## vpdoo## dqg# frxog#qrw#diirug#wr#sd|#ehqhilwv/#dqg#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#wkh#zrun#wkh|#riihuhg#glg#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhtxluh## zrunhuv## wr## eh## kdss|## ru## hqwkxvldvwlf1## Ihdu## ri## pdnlqj## wkhvh## ilupv# xqfrpshwlwlyh/#dqg#orvlqj#wkhvh#nlqgv#ri#exvlqhvvhv#wr#rwkhu#vwdwhv/#pd|#zhoo#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # 54# suhyhqwhg#vwdwhv#iurp#ohjlvodwlqj#ehqhilwv1 # # # # Qhyhuwkhohvv/## wkh## vdihw|## qhw## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## doehlw## zhdn/## grhv## h{lvw1# Ghvslwh#doo#wkh#deryh0phqwlrqhg#gliilfxowlhv/#ohjlvodwlrq#surwhfwlqj#zrunhuv#zdv# # # # # # # # # lqghhg## sdvvhg## gxulqj## wkh## Juhdw## Ghsuhvvlrq1## Wkh## fhqwhuslhfh## ri## wkh## ohjlvodwlrq#
zdv## wkh## Vrfldo## Vhfxulw|## Dfw## ri## 4<68/## zklfk## lqvwlwxwhg## qrw## rqo|## rog0djh## vrfldo# vhfxulw|#ehqhilwv# # # exw## dovr## xqhpsor|phqw## lqvxudqfh1## Zk|#glg# # # lw## kdsshq#zkhq#lw# # # glgB## Wkh## dqvzhuv## duh## lqwhuhvwlqj/## iru## wkh|## vxjjhvw## zd|v## lq## zklfk## fkdqjh## pd|# rffxu#djdlq#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# # # # # # Iluvw/#wkh#sdlq#zrunhuv#ihow#iurp#Ghsuhvvlrq0hud#xqhpsor|phqw#zdv#lpphqvh# # # # # # # # # # dqg## shuvlvwhqw1## Xqhpsor|phqw## txlfno|## urvh## lqwr## grxeoh## gljlwv## e|## plg04<63/# shdnlqj## dw## 571<## shufhqw## lq## 4<66## exw## qhyhu## frplqj## grzq## lqwr## vlqjoh## gljlwv# wkurxjkrxw## wkh## 4<63v/## ghvslwh## d## vxssrvhg## uhfryhu|## +dqg## dqrwkhu## vxevhtxhqw# soxqjh,## gxulqj## wkh## Ghsuhvvlrq155## Lq## 4<6</## dw## wkh## rqvhw## ri## Zruog## Zdu## LL/# xqhpsor|phqw## zdv## durxqg## 4;## shufhqw1## Pruhryhu/## lw## zdv## qdwlrqzlgh1## Lq## Mrkq# Vwhlqehfnᄊv## kdxqwlqj## qryho## Wkh## Judshv## ri## Zudwk/## wkh## Mrdgv/## Rnodkrpd## whqdqw# iduphuv#zkrvh#idup#lv#qr#orqjhu#surilwdeoh/#jr#orrnlqj#iru#mrev#lq#wkh#surplvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # odqg#ri#Fdoliruqld/#rqo|#wr#ilqg#wkdw#wkhuh#duh#qrqh#wkhuh#hlwkhu1#Wklv#wlph/#prylqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#zdv# # # qrw#wkh# # # dqvzhu/## dqg## wkh## hiihfw#zdv# # # wr## xqli|#zrunhu# # # ghpdqgv## dfurvv## wkh# frxqwu|1# Vhfrqg/## Iudqnolq## Urrvhyhow## rewdlqhg## d## vwurqj## srolwlfdo## pdqgdwh/## dqg## eurdg# qdwlrqzlgh#ohjlvodwlrq#ryhufdph#wkh#froohfwlyh0dfwlrq#sureohp#hdfk#vwdwh#idfhg=# # # # # # # # # 56# wkh## ihdu## ri#iuljkwhqlqj#dzd|#exvlqhvv# # # # # li#lw#ohjlvodwhg# # # # zrunhu## surwhfwlrq#dorqh1 # Wklug/#wkhuh#zhuh#h{fhswlrqv#fduyhg#rxw#lq#wkh#ohjlvodwlrq=#iru#lqvwdqfh/#lq#d#qrg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#wkh#srzhuixo# # # # Vrxwkhuq#Ghprfudwv# # # zkr#glg#qrw#zdqw#wr#udlvh#wkh#frvw#ri#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # eodfn#zrunhuv# # # +ru## kdyh## wkh## ohjlvodwlrq#ghudlohg# # # e|#srolwlfldqv# # # udlvlqj#ihduv# # # wkdw# ehqhilwv## zrxog## jr## wr## eodfnv,/## djulfxowxudo## zrunhuv## zhuh## qrw## fryhuhg1## Ilqdoo|/# vxusulvlqj## dv## lw## pd|## vhhp/## vwurqj## exvlqhvv## lqwhuhvwv## dovr## vxssruwhg## wkh# ohjlvodwlrq157# Wklv## odvw#uhdvrq#lv# # # # lqwhuhvwlqj1## Zk|#zrxog# # # exvlqhvvhv## zdqw#wr# # # lqfuhdvh## wkhlu# rzq## frvwvB## Kdylqj## wkh## vwdwh## surylgh## zrunhu## ehqhilwv## kdg## wzr## wuhphqgrxv# dgydqwdjhv## iru## vrph## ilupv/## hvshfldoo|#odujh# # # rqhv1## Iluvw/## ilupv## wkdw#douhdg|#sdlg# # # wkhlu## zrunhuv## ehqhilwv## olnh## rog0djh## shqvlrqv## +ehfdxvh## wkhvh## pdgh## eurdghu# hfrqrplf#vhqvh/#dv#glvfxvvhg#hduolhu,/#frxog#riiordg#vrph#ri#wkh#frvwv#rq#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwdwh1## Pruhryhu/## doo## ilupv/## hvshfldoo|#shvn|#vpdoo# # # # frpshwlwruv## wr## elj#exvlqhvv/# # zrxog## eh## vxemhfw## wr## wkh## dgglwlrqdo## frvwv/## zkhwkhu## ru## qrw## wkh|## zhuh## deoh## wr# lqfuhdvh## surilwv## e|## surylglqj## zrunhu## ehqhilwv1## Dqg## iru## vpdoo## ilupv## hpsor|lqj# xqvnloohg## zrunhuv/## wkh## lpsrvlwlrq## ri## zrunhu## ehqhilwv## w|slfdoo|## lqfuhdvhg## frvwv# zlwkrxw## dq|## uhghhplqj## lqfuhdvh## lq## surilwv1## Wkxv## wkh## ohjlvodwlrq## uhgxfhg# frpshwlwlrq## iru## srzhuixo## lqfxpehqwv## e|## holplqdwlqj## rqh## ri## wkh## lpsruwdqw# dgydqwdjhv#ri#hqwudqwv=#wkhlu#delolw|#wr#sd|#orz#zdjhv#dqg#ehqhilwv1#Olnh#pxfk#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ohjlvodwlrq## gxulqj## wkh## Qhz## Ghdo## hud/## wkh## jrrg## sduwv## fdph## zlwk## edg/# dqwlfrpshwlwlyh#hohphqwv1# # Zkdw## duh## wkh## ohvvrqv## iurp#doo# # # ri## wklvB## Kxjh## dgyhuvh## hfrqrplf## vkrfnv## kdyh# srzhuixo#hiihfwv#rq#frqfhqwudwlqj#wkh#qdwlrqdo#plqg#ehfdxvh#hyhu|rqh#lv#vlploduo|# # # # # # # # # # # diihfwhg1## Wkh|## wkxv## riihu## rssruwxqlw|## iru## fkdqjh1## Hyhq## vr/## dqg## ghvslwh## odujh# ohjlvodwlyh## pdmrulwlhv/## frpsurplvh## lv## lqhylwdeoh## ehfdxvh## shrsoh## dovr## orrn# eh|rqg#wkh#fdodplw|#wr#wkhlu#lqwhuhvwv#lq#wkh#uhfryhu|1#Ilqdoo|/#wkhuh#lv#w|slfdoo|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wudgh0rii#ehwzhhq#frpshwlwlrq/# # # # lqqrydwlrq/## ioh{lelolw|/## dffhvv/## dqg## hiilflhqf|#rq# # wkh#rqh#kdqg/#dqg#vhfxulw|#rq#wkh#rwkhu1#Vhfxulw|#lpsolhv#d#surwhfwlrq#ri#sulylohjh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # d## surwhfwlrq## wkdw## kdv## wr## eh## lqglvfulplqdwh## li## lw## lv## wr## fdop## dq{lhw|1## Exw## wklv#
lqyduldeo|#phdqv#wkdw#uhvrxufhv#zloo#eh#wudqvihuuhg#wr#ehqhilfldulhv#uhjdugohvv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## hiilflhqf|#zlwk#zklfk#wkh|#fdq#xvh# # # # # # # wkhp1## Rqh## shuvrqᄊv## vdihw|#frphv# # # dw## wkh# h{shqvh#ri#dqrwkhu# # # ᄊv#rssruwxqlw|#ru#hiilflhqf|/#dqg#jrrg#ohjlvodwlrq#kdv#wr#wuhdg# # # # # # # # # # fduhixoo|#wr#dfklhyh#wkh#uljkw#edodqfh1# # # # # #
Wkh#Sureohp#zlwk#Glvfuhwlrqdu|#Vwlpxoxv # # # # # L#kdyh#dujxhg#wkdw#wkhuh#duh#d#qxpehu#ri#uhdvrqv#zk|#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#kdv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhdn#vdihw|#qhw1# # # # Exw## zk|#lv# # # wkdw## d## sureohpB## Diwhu## doo/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## d# iorxulvklqj#ghprfudf|#wkdw#uhvsrqgv#wr#wkh#frqfhuqv#ri#wkh#shrsoh#dqg#fdq#hqdfw# # # # # # # # # # # # # srolflhv#lq#d#grzqwxuq#wr#khos#wkrvh#zkr#duh#lq#gliilfxow|1#Xqiruwxqdwho|/#srolf|# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdgh## lq## wkh## plgvw## ri## d## grzqwxuq## lv## riwhq## kxuulhg/## rssruwxqlvwlf/## dqg## srruo|# wkrxjkw#rxw1#Dowkrxjk#ghhs#fulvhv#riihu#dq#rssruwxqlw|#iru#vhulrxv#uhwklqnlqj#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # wudqvirupdwlrq/## li## qhz## srolflhv## kdyh## wr## eh## ghylvhg## lq## uhvsrqvh## wr## hyhu|# grzqwxuq/## wkh## uhvxow## lv## lqdssursuldwh/## xqsuhglfwdeoh/## dqg## h{fhvvlyh## srolf|# pdnlqj1# Mrkq#Pd|qdug#Nh|qhv/#shukdsv#wkh#prvw#lqioxhqwldo#hfrqrplvw#diwhu#Nduo#Pdu{/# # # # # # # # # # # dujxhg#wkdw#uhfhvvlrqv#zhuh#fdxvhg#e|#d#ghilflw#ri#ghpdqg/#dqg#wkdw#jryhuqphqwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxog## sod|## d## uroh## lq## d## uhfryhu|## e|## lqfuhdvlqj## vshqglqj/## ilqdqfhg## e|## uxqqlqj# exgjhw#ghilflwv1#Klv#ylhzv#hqmr|hg#lpphqvh#lqioxhqfh#lq#wkh#ghfdghv#diwhu#Zruog# # # # # # # # # # # # Zdu#LL/#exw#klv#srolf|#uhfrpphqgdwlrqv#zhuh#hiihfwlyho|#lqvwlwxwlrqdol}hg#hduolhu/# # # # # # # # # # gxulqj## wkh## Ghsuhvvlrq/## wkurxjk## vwuxfwxuhv## vxfk## dv## xqhpsor|phqw## lqvxudqfh1## Li# ghpdqg#idowhuhg/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zrxog#dxwrpdwlfdoo|#wudqvihu#sxufkdvlqj#srzhu# # # # # # # # # wr## shrsoh/## iru## h{dpsoh## wkurxjk## xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv1## Dovr/## ehfdxvh## ilupv# zrxog## sd|## orzhu## wd{hv## dv## d## uhvxow## ri## orzhu## surilwv/## wd{hv## zhuh## hiihfwlyho|# uhgxfhg1## Prvw## pdlqvwuhdp## hfrqrplvwv## eholhyhg## wkh## fdvh## iru## lqfuhdvlqj# jryhuqphqw#vshqglqj#eh|rqg#wkhvh#ᄈdxwrpdwlf#vwdelol}huv/ᄡ#h{fhsw#lq#wuxo|#vhyhuh# # # # # # # # # # uhfhvvlrqv/#zdv#zhdn1#Lqvwhdg/#pxfk#ri#wkh#wdvn#ri#sxwwlqj#wkh#hfrqrp|#edfn#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#urdg#wr#uhfryhu|#zdv#ohiw#wr#prqhwdu|#srolf|1# # # # # # # # # Lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## wkrxjk/## wkh## devhqfh## ri#d# # # vwurqj#vdihw|#qhw/# # # # frxsohg## zlwk# vorz## mre## jurzwk## lq## uhfryhulhv/## kdv## pdgh## hyhu|## rqh## ri## wkh## uhfhqw## uhfhvvlrqv# ᄈwuxo|#vhyhuhᄡ#iurp#d#srolwlfdo#shuvshfwlyh1#Wklv#kdv#fuhdwhg#wuhphqgrxv#suhvvxuh# # # # # # # # # # # rq#jryhuqphqwv# # # wr## vwlpxodwh/## erwk#wkurxjk#ilvfdo# # # # phdqvᄇwd{#fxwv# # # dqg## vshqglqj# lqfuhdvhvᄇdqg#wkurxjk#hdv|#prqhwdu|#srolf|1#Vrph# # # # # # # sduwv## ri#wkh# # # vwlpxoxv## gr#jr# # wrzdug## h{whqglqj#wkh# # # vdihw|#qhwᄇiru# # # h{dpsoh/## xqhpsor|phqw#lqvxudqfh# # # ehqhilwv# dqg#vxevlglhv#iru#khdowk#lqvxudqfh#kdyh#ehhq#h{whqghg#lq#wkh#fxuuhqw#uhfhvvlrq#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # vrph#odlg0rii#zrunhuv1#Exw#vwlpxoxv#sdfndjhv#lqyduldeo|#gr#d#orw#pruh1#Wkh#nh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # txhvwlrq## wkhuhiruh## lv## wklv=## Li## mre## uhfryhulhv## frqwlqxh## wr## eh## vorz/## lv## wkhuh## d# sureohp#zlwk#doorzlqj#vwlpxoxv# # # # # wr## eh## glvfuhwlrqdu|#lqvwhdg# # # ri#vwuhqjwkhqlqj#wkh# # # vdihw|#qhwB# # Wkhuh#lv$#Iluvw/#zrunhuv#wkhpvhoyhv#idfh#wuhphqgrxv#dq{lhw|#zkhq#ehqhilwv#duh# # # # # # # # # # # glvfuhwlrqdu|## ehfdxvh## wkh|## gr## qrw## nqrz## li## wkh## uhfhvvlrq## zloo## eh## ghhs## dqg# surorqjhg## hqrxjk## wr## suryrnh## vwlpxoxv## vshqglqj/## dqg/## hyhq## li## lw## grhv/## zkhwkhu# wkh|#zloo#ehqhilw1#Vhfrqg/#erwk#ilvfdo#dqg#prqhwdu|#srolflhv#zrun#zlwk#odjv1#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{shqglwxuh#iru#urdgv#wkdw#lv#yrwhg#rq#wrgd|#zloo#suredeo|#qrw#eh#vshqw#xqwlo#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # prqwkv#iurp#qrz1#Exw#yrwhuv#zdqw#srolwlfldqv#wr#uhvsrqg#wr#wkhlu#fxuuhqw#qhhgv1#D# # # # # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfldqᄊv## frxqvho## ri## sdwlhqfh## lv## wdnhq## dv## d## uhiohfwlrq## ri## lpsrwhqfh## dqg## lv# wkhuhiruh## qrw## frqgxflyh## wr## khu## uhhohfwlrq1## Li## wkh## fxuuhqw## xqhpsor|phqw## udwh## dv# zhoo## dv## fxuuhqw## mre## jurzwk#gulyh# # # srolf|#dfwlrqv/# # # wkhq#lw# # # lv## srvvleoh## wkdw## srolf|# zloo## uhpdlq#idu#wrr#vwlpxodwlyh#iru#idu#wrr#orqj1#Wkh#urdgv#wkdw#duh#exgjhwhg#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrgd|#zloo# # # eh#exlow#d#|hdu#iurp#qrz/#zkhq#uhfryhu|#lv#douhdg|#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # xqghu#zd|/# #
srwhqwldoo|#fdxvlqj#wkh# # # # hfrqrp|#wr# # # ryhukhdw#dqg# # # iruflqj#frvwo|#srolf|#uhyhuvdov# # # # wkhq1# Wklug/## dqg## shukdsv## prvw## lpsruwdqw/## glvfuhwlrq## ohdgv## wr## dexvh1## Pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # sureohpdwlf/#zkhq#srolwlfldqv#h{huflvh#glvfuhwlrq#dw#d#wlph#ri#juhdw#qhfhvvlw|/#lw# ohdgv#wr#lqyhqwlyh#dexvh1#Vshflilfdoo|/#srolwlfldqv#eulqj#rxw#doo#wkhlu#shw#surmhfwv# # # # # # # # # # # # gxulqj#d#grzqwxuq/#dqg#wkhq#vrph#pruh/#doo#xqghu#wkh#jxlvh#ri#vwlpxoxv#wr#vxssruw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhfryhu|1## Vljqlilfdqw## hohphqwv## ri## vshqglqj## duh## vlpso|## sd|edfn## wr## srzhuixo# lqwhuhvw## jurxsv/## ru## d## ixoiloophqw## ri## hohfwlrq#surplvhv# # # zlwk#olwwoh# # # qhhg## wr## mxvwli|# wkhlu## vkruw0whup#ehqhilw1# # # Ryhu## rqh0wklug## ri## wkh## vwlpxoxv## sdfndjh## sdvvhg## e|## wkh# Redpd## dgplqlvwudwlrq## lq## lwv## hduo|## prqwkv## frqvlvwhg## ri## rqh0wlph## wd{## uhedwhv/# zklfk#duh# # # nqrzq#wr/# # # dqg## glg/## kdyh## olwwoh## hiihfw#rq#vshqglqj=# # # # wkh|#zhuh# # # pruh## d# 58# irup#ri#uhglvwulexwlrq#wr#ixoiloo#hohfwlrq#surplvhv1 # # # # # # Dv## dq## h{dpsoh## ri## pruh## hjuhjlrxvo|## gluhfwhg## vshqglqj/## '918## eloolrq## zdv# 59## Fdqfhu#uhvhdufk# dssuryhg#iru#fdqfhu#uhvhdufk#wr#dsshdvh#d#sduwlfxodu#vhqdwru1 # # # # # # # # # lv## xqolnho|## wr## fuhdwh## pdq|## mrev## lq## wkh## vkruw## whup=## lqghhg/## lw## zrxog## eh## pruh# dssursuldwh## li#wkh# # # prqh|#zhuh# # # vshqw#vorzo|#udwkhu# # # # wkdq#zdvwhg# # # rq#kduheudlqhg# # sursrvdov## ilvkhg## rxw#iurp#wkh# # # # erwwrp#ri#uhvhdufkhuvᄊ#gudzhuv# # # # # lq#uhvsrqvh# # # wr## dq# dqqrxqfhphqw#ri#qhz#judqw#ixqglqj1#\hw#lw#ihdwxuhv#dv#sduw#ri#wkh#vwlpxoxv#vlpso|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh#wkh#qhhg#wr#sdvv#d#vwlpxoxv#sdfndjh#jlyhv#hyhu|#srolwlfldq#wkh#uljkw#wr#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vkduh#ri#wkh#srun1# # # # Ilqdoo|/#hyhq#dv# # # # L#zulwh/#wkh#uhdo# # # # # hvwdwh#lqgxvwu|#kdv# # # # hqvxuhg#wkh#uhqhzdo# # # # ri#d# # ᄈwhpsrudu|ᄡ#wd{#euhdn#wr#iluvw0wlph#krph#ex|huv#rq#wkh#jurxqgv#wkdw#zlwkgudzlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # lw#zloo# # # vhulrxvo|#gdpdjh#krph#sulfhv1#Vxfk#wd{#euhdnv#dprxqw#wr#d#vxevlg|#wr#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # ihzᄇiluvw0wlph## ex|huv/## eurnhuv/## dqg## frqvwuxfwlrq## ilupvᄇdqg## w|slfdoo|## kdyh# olplwhg#hiihfwv# # # rq#jurzwk#ehfdxvh# # # # wkh|#vlpso|#vxevwlwxwh# # # # fxuuhqw#vdohv# # # iru## ixwxuh# vdohv1## Wkhlu## phulw/## li## dq|/## lv## wkdw## wkh|## duh## whpsrudu|/## dqg## wkxv## eulqj## iruzdug# sxufkdvhv## dw#d# # # wlph## zkhq#dfwlylw|#lv# # # # ohdq1## Uhqhzdo## ghihdwv## wkhlu## yhu|#sxusrvh1# # Exw## vxevlglhv## duh## dq## dgglfwlyh## guxj1## Lw## lv## suhflvho|## ehfdxvh## wkh## ehqhilwv## duh# hqmr|hg#e|#wkh#ihz#+zkr#oree|#vwurqjo|#iru#wkhp,#dqg#wkh#frvwv#sdlg#e|#wkh#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # +zkr#grqᄊw#fduh#hqrxjk#wr#oree|,#wkdw#wkh|#hqgxuh1# # # # # # # # # Rssruwxqlvp#lv#elsduwlvdq1#Zkhq#wkh#5334#uhfhvvlrq#klw/#wkh#X1V1#Wuhdvxu|#glg# # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## vwdqg## lgo|## e|1## Lq## rughu## wr## vwlpxodwh## jurzwk## dv## zhoo## dv## ixoiloo## fdpsdljq# surplvhv/## wkh## Exvk## dgplqlvwudwlrq## fxw## wd{hv## rq## hduqhg## lqfrph## dqg## rq## fdslwdo# jdlqv## dqg## glylghqgv1## Wklv## uhvsrqvh/## zklfk## gliihuhg## iurp## vwdqgdug## Nh|qhvldq# suhvfulswlrqv## hvsrxvhg## e|## wkh## Redpd## dgplqlvwudwlrq## wr## errvw## jryhuqphqw# vshqglqj/## uhiohfwhg## wkh## pruh## frqvhuydwlyh/## vxsso|0vlgh## urrwv## ri## wkh## Exvk# dgplqlvwudwlrq=#lw#zdv#dq#dwwhpsw#wr#lpsuryh#wkh#lqfhqwlyhv#iru#exvlqhvvhv#wr#udlvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyhvwphqw## dqg## surgxfwlrq1## Exw## zkhq## frxsohg## zlwk## ulvlqj## h{shqglwxuhv## rq# qdwlrqdo## vhfxulw|## diwhu## wkh## Vhswhpehu## 44## whuurulvw## dwwdfnv## rq## wkh## Zruog## Wudgh# Fhqwhu/#lwv#hiihfw#rq#jryhuqphqw#ilqdqfhv#zdv#ghflghgo|#qrw#frqvhuydwlyh1#Pruh# # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwdqw/#jlyhq#wkdw#lqgxvwu|#kdg#ehhq#rq#dq#lqyhvwphqw#elqjh/#wkh#vwlpxoxv#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # xqolnho|#wr#eh#hiihfwlyh#lq#vxssruwlqj#lqyhvwphqw#dqg#mre#jurzwk#lq#wkh#vkruw#whup/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qr#pdwwhu#zkdw#lwv#orqj0whup#ehqhilwv1# # # # # # Wkh## eurdghu## srlqw## lv## wkdw## glvfuhwlrqdu|## ilvfdo## vwlpxoxv## whqgv## wr## eh## edvhg## rq# lghrorj|#dqg# # # rq#sdvw#reoljdwlrqv# # # # ru## lqwhuhvwv## udwkhu## wkdq#dwwxqhg# # # wr## wkh## qhhgv## ri# wkh## prphqw1## Fohduo|/## li#wkhuh# # # lv## d## vwurqj#fdvh# # # wr## eh## pdgh## wkdw#lw#zloo# # # # ᄈzrunᄡ## lq#
fuhdwlqj## orqj0whup## mrev## ru## dyhuwlqj## d## vhoi0ghvwuxfwlyh## grzqzdug## vsludo## lq## wkh# hfrqrp|/## ihz## zrxog## glvsxwh## wkh## qhhg## wr## vshqg1## W|slfdoo|/## vxfk## dfwlrq## hqwdlov# olplwhg/## wdujhwhg## vshqglqj#ru# # # wd{#phdvxuhv1# # # Lq#sudfwlfh/# # # wkrxjk/## dgplqlvwudwlrqv# xvh#wkh#vkdgrz#ri#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#wr#gr#zkdw#wkh|#kdyh#dozd|v#zdqwhg#wr#gr1#Udkp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Hppdqxho/## Suhvlghqw## Redpdᄊv## fklhi## ri## vwdii/## fdswxuhg## wklv## plqgvhw## shuihfwo|# zkhq#kh#vdlg/#mxvw#ehiruh#wkh#Redpd#dgplqlvwudwlrq#wrrn#riilfh/#ᄈ\rx#qhyhu#zdqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # 5:# d#vhulrxv#fulvlv#wr#jr#wr#zdvwh1ᄡ # # # # # # Wkh#srolflhv#wkdw#whqg#wr#eh#ohjlvodwhg#dw#vxfk#wlphv#duh#xqolnho|#wr#eh#fhqwulvw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Zkhq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#ri#wkh#gd|#vhl}hv#wkh#rssruwxqlw|#wr#udp#wkurxjk#lwv#orqjhu0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # whup## srolflhv/## lw## qdwxudoo|## irfxvhv## rq## pdnlqj## grzq## sd|phqwv## rq## srolflhv## wkdw# frxog## olnho|## eh## suxqhg## e|## pruh## surorqjhg/## uhdvrqhg## ghedwh1## Wkh## zlqgrz# diirughg## e|#wkh# # # hphujhqf|#wkhuhiruh# # # kdv## ohg## wr## pruh## sduwlvdq#ohjlvodwlrq#lq#wkh# # # # sdvw## dqg## zloo## olnho|## gr## vr## lq## wkh## ixwxuh/## hvshfldoo|## ehfdxvh## wkh## lqfuhdvhg# srodul}dwlrq## ri## Frqjuhvv## hqvxuhv## wkdw## dq|## ohjlvodwlyh## djhqgd## wkdw## lv## qrw## ilupo|# fhqwulvw## zloo## kdyh## gliilfxow|## sdvvlqj## rqfh## wkh## zlqgrz## ri## rssruwxqlw|## forvhv1# Ehfdxvh#sduwlvdq#ohjlvodwlrq#whqgv#wr#eh#uhyhuvhg#e|#ixwxuh#dgplqlvwudwlrqv#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## rwkhu## vlgh/## wkh## odfn#ri#dq#hiihfwlyh# # # # # vdihw|#qhw#fdq#ohdg# # # # # qrw#mxvw#wr# # # # zdvwh## exw# dovr#wr#pruh#srolf|#ioxfwxdwlrqv#dqg#xqfhuwdlqw|1# # # # # # # Wkhuh#duh#wkuhh#dgglwlrqdo#grzqvlghv#wr#wkh#devhqfh#ri#d#vwurqj#X1V1#vdihw|#qhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkhq#uhfryhulhv#duh#wxuqlqj#rxw#wr#eh#mreohvv1#Iluvw/#hyhq#zlwk#wkh#srvvlelolw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # glvfuhwlrqdu|#vwlpxoxv/#zrunhuv#wkhpvhoyhv#gr#qrw#nqrz#li#wkh|#zloo#eh#vxssruwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## zkhq=## wklv## xqfhuwdlqw|## fuhdwhv## h{dfwo|## wkh## shuvrqdo## dq{lhw|## dqg## srolwlfdo# suhvvxuh#wkdw#wkh#vdihw|#qhw#lv#phdqw#wr#dyhuw1#Vhfrqg/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhvᄊ#odfn#ri#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilup#vdihw|#qhw#dqg#lwv#zloolqjqhvv#wr#vwlpxodwh#xqwlo#wkh#mrev#frph#krph#lv#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqghuvwrrg#e|#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog1#Zkhq#d#joredo#grzqwxuq#dggv#wr#wkh#hiihfwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#shuvlvwhqw#vwuxfwxudo#ghpdqg#vkruwidoo#fuhdwhg#e|#h{sruw0ohg#vwudwhjlhv/#dv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # glg#lq#5334/#qrw#rqo|#gr#pdq|#frxqwulhv#ilqg#lw#kdug#wr#vwlpxodwh#wkhlu#hfrqrplhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hiihfwlyho|/#exw#wkh|#dovr#nqrz#wkdw#lq#d#joredo#jdph#ri#srolf|#fklfnhq/#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv#zloo#iolqfk#iluvw1#Pdq|#frxqwulhv#klwfk#wkhpvhoyhv#wr#wkh#X1V1#hqjlqh#dqg#gr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frpphqvxudwho|## ohvv## rq## wkhlu## rzq1## Wkh## zhljkw## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## wr## sxoo# lqfuhdvhv/## dqg## wkh## olnholkrrg## wkdw## lw## zloo## gr## lw## lwvhoi## vhulrxv## lqmxu|## pxowlsolhv1# Ilqdoo|/## dqg## prvw## lpsruwdqw/## wkh## shuvlvwhqw## dqg## srolwlfdoo|## prwlydwhg## prqhwdu|# vwlpxoxv#wkdw#dffrpsdqlhv#glvfuhwlrqdu|#ilvfdo#vwlpxoxv#lv/#li#dq|wklqj/#hyhq#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # gdqjhurxv#iru#wkh#orqj0whup#khdowk#ri#wkh#X1V1#hfrqrp|/#dqg#lqghhg#wkh#zruog/#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#diihfwv#wkh#ehkdylru#ri#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru1#L#wxuq#wr#wkdw#idxow#olqh#qrz1# # # # # # # # ## # # # # #
FKDSWHU#ILYH #
Iurp#Exeeoh#wr#Exeeoh # # # #
QR#FHQWUDO#EDQNHU#KDV#KDG# # # # # # wr#dgdsw#klv#ylhzv#pruh#xqghu#wkh#sxeolf#h|h# # # # # # # # #
wkdq## Ehq## Ehuqdqnh/## wkh## fkdlupdq## ri## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Erdug1## Lq## Iheuxdu|# 5337/## lq## d## vshhfk## wr## wkh## Hdvwhuq## Hfrqrplf## Dvvrfldwlrq/## Ehuqdqnh/## wkhq## d# jryhuqru## ri## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Erdug/## vsrnh## ri## wkh## ᄈJuhdw## Prghudwlrq/ᄡ## wkh# revhuydwlrq#wkdw#wkh#ioxfwxdwlrqv#ri#rxwsxw#dqg#lqiodwlrq#lq#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # frph## grzq#vwhdglo|#vlqfh# # # # wkh## plg04<;3v1## Ehfdxvh## wkh## Kro|#Judlo# # # ri#hfrqrplf# # pdqdjhphqw#lv#vwurqj/#vwhdg|#jurzwk/#zlwkrxw#errpv/#exvwv/#ru#kljk#lqiodwlrq/#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # wuhqg#vxjjhvwhg#wkdw#vrphwklqj#zdv#zrunlqj1# # # # # # Ehuqdqnh#frqvlghuhg#wkuhh#srvvleoh#h{sodqdwlrqv=#iluvw/#wkdw#zh#pljkw#kdyh#mxvw# # # # # # # # # # # ehhq#oxfn|/# # # zlwk#wkh# # # zruog## hfrqrp|#h{shulhqflqj#ihzhu# # # # dfflghqwv## vxfk#dv# # # zdu# dqg#rlo0sulfh#lqfuhdvhv#ryhu#wklv#shulrg1#Vhfrqg/#wkdw#hfrqrplhv#kdg#fkdqjhg/#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # h{dpsoh## dv## frusrudwlrqv## ghyhorshg## v|vwhpv## wr## dftxluh## vdohv## lqirupdwlrq#pruh# # txlfno|## dqg## wr## wudqvodwh## lw## pruh## frqwlqxrxvo|## lqwr## surgxfwlrq## dqg## lqyhqwru|# ghflvlrqv1## Vxfk## lpsuryhphqwv## frxog## h{sodlq## krz## hfrqrplhv## kdg## ehhq## deoh## wr# dyrlg## wkh## pruh## gudpdwlf## lqyhqwru|## exlogxsv## dqg## surgxfwlrq## fxwedfnv## wkdw## kdg# fkdudfwhul}hg#suhylrxv#uhfhvvlrqv1#Wklug/#dv#d#uhvxow#ri#dgydqfhv#lq#rxu#hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # # # xqghuvwdqglqj/## fhqwudo## edqnhuv/## pdq|## ri## wkhp## iruphu## dfdghplf## hfrqrplvwv/# xqghuvwrrg#ehwwhu#krz#prqhwdu|#srolf|#diihfwhg#hfrqrplf#rxwsxw1# # # # # # # # Ehfdxvh## kh## lv## d## fduhixo## hfrqrplvw/## lq## dgglwlrq## wr## ehlqj## d## yhu|## jrrg## rqh/# Ehuqdqnh## vxjjhvwhg## wkdw#wkhuh# # # zdv## phulw#lq#doo# # # # wkuhh## h{sodqdwlrqv1## Krzhyhu/## kh# vwuhvvhg#wkh#ylhz#wkdw#prqhwdu|#srolf|#kdg#ehfrph#pxfk#ehwwhu1#Xqolnh#wkh#srolf|# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdnhuv## lq## wkh## 4<93v## dqg## 4<:3v/## zkr## rshudwhg## zlwk## uxglphqwdu|## dqg## riwhq# lqfruuhfw#eholhiv# # # derxw#hfrqrplf# # # uhodwlrqvklsv/## wrgd|ᄊv## fhqwudo## edqnhuv/## kh## ihow/# xqghuvwrrg## idu## ehwwhu## krz## wkh## hfrqrp|## zrunv1## Ehuqdqnh## lv/## li## dq|wklqj/## pruh# fdxwlrxv## dqg## qxdqfhg## wkdq#wkh# # # w|slfdo## srolf|#pdnhu/# # # exw## wkh## ryhudoo## wrqh## ri#klv# # vshhfk#zdv#wulxpskdqw=#wkh#srolf|#ohyhuv#iru#pdqdjlqj#d#prghuq#hfrqrp|#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # zhoo## xqghuvwrrg/## zklfk## zdv## zk|## zh## douhdg|## kdg## ploghu## uhfhvvlrqv1## Wkh# lpsolfdwlrq/## shukdsv## xqlqwhqghg/## zdv## wkdw## zlwk## vwhdg|## surjuhvv/## zh## frxog## gr# dzd|#zlwk#uhfhvvlrqv#dowrjhwkhu1# # # # E|## Vhswhpehu## 533;/## krzhyhu/## Ehuqdqnh/## qrz## fkdlupdq## ri## wkh## Ihghudo# Uhvhuyh#Erdug/#kdylqj#uhdol}hg#wkh#olplwv# # # # # # # ri#prqhwdu|#srolf|/#zdv# # # # # sohdglqj#iru# # khos#iurp#Frqjuhvv/#dujxlqj#wkdw#ᄈghvslwh#wkh#hiiruwv#ri#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wuhdvxu|/#dqg#rwkhu#djhqflhv/#joredo#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#uhpdlq#xqghu#h{wudruglqdu|# # # # # # # # # # vwuhvv1#Dfwlrq#e|#Frqjuhvv#lv#xujhqwo|#uhtxluhg#wr#vwdelol}h#wkh#vlwxdwlrq#dqg#dyhuw# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkdw#rwkhuzlvh#frxog#eh#yhu|#vhulrxv#frqvhtxhqfhv#iru#rxu#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # 4# iru#rxu#hfrqrp|1ᄡ # # #Lq#vkruw/#prqhwdu|#srolf|#zdv#qrw#zrunlqj/#dqg#rqo|#d#edlorxw# # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## e|## Frqjuhvv## frxog## vwdelol}h## wkh## hfrqrp|## dqg## dyhuw## d# ghsuhvvlrq1#Zkhuh#kdg#wkh#Ihg#jrqh#zurqjB# # # # # # # Zlwk#wkh# # # ehqhilw## ri## klqgvljkw/## lw## dsshduv## wkdw## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## pdgh## wzr#
plvwdnhv1#Iluvw/#wkh#mreohvv#uhfryhu|#iurp#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#ri#5334#lqgxfhg#wkh#Ihg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## nhhs## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## h{wuhpho|## orz## iru## d## vxvwdlqhg## shulrg1## D#orw# # # ri## h{fhvvhv# zhuh## exloglqj#xs/# # # lq#wkh# # # uhvw## ri## wkh## zruog## dv## zhoo## dv## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## exw# wkhru|#dqg#srolwlfv#frqyhqlhqwo|#fdph#wrjhwkhu#wr#nhhs#wkh#Ihg#rq#krog1#Vhfrqg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Ihg#dfwlyho|#hqfrxudjhg#wkh#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#wr#eholhyh#lw#zrxog#iroorz# # # # # # # # # # # # # dq# dv|pphwulf## srolf|=## lw## zrxog## qrw## ohdq## djdlqvw## d## srwhqwldo## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## ulvh## lq# dvvhw#sulfhv/# # # exw#lw#zrxog# # # # uhpdlq#uhdg|#wr# # # # slfn#xs# # # wkh## slhfhv## li#d# # # exeeoh## exuvw1# Erwk#wkhvh#lpsolhg#surplvhv#glg#frqvlghudeoh#gdpdjh/#ehfdxvh#lq#dwwhpswlqj#wr# # # # # # # # # # # vwlpxodwh#voxjjlvk#mre#fuhdwlrq/#wkh|#vhw#rii#dq#ruj|#ri#ilqdqfldo#ulvn#wdnlqj1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/#ehfdxvh#wkh#Ihgᄊv#dfwlrqv#zhuh#frqvlvwhqw#erwk#zlwk#lwv#pdqgdwh# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#zlwk#wkh#suhydlolqj#dfdghplf#ruwkrgr{|/#lw#kdv#qrw#ehhq#irufhg#wr#uhwklqn#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # srolflhv1#Pruhryhu/#lq#dq#hqylurqphqw#ri#kljk#dqg#shuvlvwhqw#xqhpsor|phqw/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # srolwlfdo## suhvvxuh## rq## lw## wr## shuvlvw## zlwk## vxfk## srolflhv## zloo## pdnh## fkdqjh## yhu|# gliilfxow1#
Wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyhᄊv#Remhfwlyhv # # # # Wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## kdv## d## pdqgdwh## iurp## Frqjuhvv## wr## surprwh## d## khdowk|# hfrqrp|1## Wklv## phdqv## pdlqwdlqlqj#pd{lpxp#vxvwdlqdeoh# # # # hpsor|phqw## dqg## vwdeoh# sulfhv1#Dovr/#lw#kdv#ehhq#hqwuxvwhg#vlqfh#lwv#irxqglqj#lq#4<46#+lq#wkh#zdnh#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Edqnhu#ᄊv## Sdqlf## ri## 4<3:,## zlwk## khoslqj## wr## hqvxuh## wkh## vwdelolw|## ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo# v|vwhp15# Lq#wkh# # # sdvw/## hfrqrplvwv## eholhyhg## wkdw#wkh# # # frpsrqhqwv## ri#wkh# # # khdowk|0hfrqrp|# pdqgdwhᄇwkh## jrdov## ri## pd{lpxp## vxvwdlqdeoh## hpsor|phqw## +kljk## jurzwk,## dqg# vwdeoh#sulfhv#+orz#lqiodwlrq,ᄇzhuh#lqfrpsdwleoh#ryhu#wkh#orqj#uxq/#ehfdxvh#kljk# # # # # # # # # # # jurzwk## pljkw## uhtxluh## kljk## lqiodwlrq1## Lpsolflw## lq## wklv## wudgh0rii## +nqrzq## dv## wkh# Skloolsv#fxuyh#diwhu#Zlooldp#Skloolsv/#zkr#irxqg#vxfk#d#uhodwlrqvkls#lq#wkh#X1N1# # # # # # # # # # # # # hfrqrp|#ehwzhhq#4;94# # # # dqg## 4<8:,## zdv## wkh## eholhi#wkdw#|rx#frxog# # # # # irro## doo## ri#wkh# # shrsoh#doo#ri#wkh#wlph1#Lqmhfwlqj#pruh#lqiodwlrq#zrxog#ohdg#shrsoh#wr#eholhyh#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## jhwwlqj#sdlg# # # pruh## iru## wkh## jrrgv## wkh|#surgxfhg# # # dqg## wr## zrun#kdughuᄇwkxv# # h{sdqglqj#rxwsxwᄇqrw#uhdol}lqj#wkdw#hyhu|wklqj#hovh#zdv#ehfrplqj#frvwolhu#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # vdph#wlph1# # Lq#wkh# # # odwh## 4<93v## dqg## hduo|#4<:3v/# # # hyhq#dv# # # gdwd## vxjjhvwhg## wkh## Skloolsv0fxuyh# uhodwlrqvkls## ehwzhhq## lqiodwlrq## dqg## xqhpsor|phqw## zdv## euhdnlqj## grzq/## wkh# ᄈudwlrqdo## h{shfwdwlrqvᄡ## uhyroxwlrq#vwduwhg#wdnlqj#krog#ri#prqhwdu|#hfrqrplfv1#Lw# # # # # # # # h{sodlqhg## zk|#wkh# # # Skloolsv0fxuyh## uhodwlrqvkls## zdv## wkhruhwlfdoo|#xqwhqdeoh1# # # Wkh# hvvhqwldo#lghd#zdv#wkdw#wkh#sxeolf#xqghuvwrrg#wkh#remhfwlyhv#ri#srolf|#pdnhuv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#iudphzrunv#wkh|#rshudwhg#zlwk/#vr#wkh|#zrxog#qrw#frrshudwh#e|#ehlqj#irrohg1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Li## wkh## fhqwudo## edqn## kdg## d## srolf|## ri## lqgxflqj## kljk## lqiodwlrq/## surgxfhuv## zrxog# udwlrqdoo|## h{shfw## wkdw## doo## sulfhv## zrxog## jr## xs## dqg## zrxog## qrw## h{huw## pruh## hiiruw# zkhq## wkh|## vdz## wkh## sulfhv## ri## wkhlu## rzq## surgxfwv## jr## xs1## Udwkhu/## wkh|## zrxog# xqghuvwdqg#wkdw#wkh#dgglwlrqdo#groodu#wkh|#hduqhg#zdv#dfwxdoo|#zruwk#ohvv#lq#whupv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#lwv#delolw|#wr#sxufkdvh#jrrgv#dqg#vhuylfhv1#Wkh#orqj0uxq#ohyho#ri#hpsor|phqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkh## hfrqrp|## zrxog## eh## ghwhuplqhg## e|## idfwruv## olnh## wkh## exvlqhvv## folpdwh/# lqfhqwlyhv#wr#lqqrydwh/#dqg#wkh#delolw|#ri#ilupv#wr#kluh#ru#od|#rii#zrunhuv#hdvlo|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#e|#lqiodwlrq1# # # Wklv#ylhz#holplqdwhg#wkh#lqfrpsdwlelolw|#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq#ehwzhhq#wkh#hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # # # jrdov## ri#orz# # # lqiodwlrq#dqg# # # pd{lpxp#vxvwdlqdeoh# # # hpsor|phqw1## Dffruglqj#wr# # # wkh# qhz## ruwkrgr{|/#e|#nhhslqj#lqiodwlrq#orz# # # # # # dqg#wkxv#holplqdwlqj#doo# # # # # wkh#xqfhuwdlqw|# # dqg#glvwruwlrqv#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#kljk#dqg#yduldeoh#lqiodwlrq/#fhqwudo#edqnhuv#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # jlyh#wkh#hfrqrp|#lwv#ehvw#fkdqfh#ri#dfklhylqj#lwv#srwhqwldo# # # # # # # # # # # jurzwk#udwh#dqg#wkxv# # # # pd{lpxp#vxvwdlqdeoh# # # hpsor|phqw1## Krzhyhu/## wkhuh## lv## vwloo## d## vkruw0uxq#wudgh0rii# # ehwzhhq#jurzwk#dqg#lqiodwlrq/#vwhpplqj#iurp#wkh#qrwlrq#wkdw#hyhu|#hfrqrp|#kdv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # srwhqwldo#jurzwk#udwhᄇdq#lqexlow#pd{lpxp#vdih#vshhg1#Pdnh#wkh#hfrqrp|#jr#dq|# # # # # # # # # # # # idvwhu/## dqg## zdjhv## dqg## lqiodwlrq## vwduw## dffhohudwlqj## ehfdxvh## ghpdqg## h{fhhgv# surgxfwlyh## fdsdflw|>#vorz# # # lw#grzq/# # # dqg## zdjhv## dqg## lqiodwlrq#vwduw#idoolqj1# # # # Zkhq# wkh## srwhqwldo## jurzwk## udwh## lv## uhdfkhg/## wkh## hfrqrp|## lv## hiihfwlyho|## dw## pd{lpxp# vxvwdlqdeoh## hpsor|phqwᄇdoo## wkh## xqhpsor|hg## duh## hlwkhu## ixoo|## rffxslhg## lq# vhdufklqj## iru## dssursuldwh## mrev## ru## duh## xqhpsor|deohᄇdqg## dq|## hiiruw## wr## ixuwkhu# dffhohudwh## jurzwk## zloo## rqo|## lqfuhdvh## frpshwlwlrq## dqg## zdjhv## iru## hpsor|hg# zrunhuv/## dqg## wkxv## lqiodwlrq1## Vr## wkh## lghdo## fhqwudo0edqn## srolf|## lv## wr## nhhs## wkh#
hfrqrp|#shushwxdoo|#dw#lwv#srwhqwldo#jurzwk#udwh1# # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/## qr## rqh## uhdoo|#nqrzv# # # zkdw## wkh## srwhqwldo## jurzwk#udwh# # # lv/## wkrxjk# wkh|## kdyh## uhdvrqdeoh## jxhvvhv1## Dqg## wklv## udwh## fdq## fkdqjh## li## wkh## vwuxfwxuh## ri## wkh# hfrqrp|## fkdqjhvᄇiru## h{dpsoh/## li## wkh## lqgxvwulhv## wkdw## duh## grplqdqw## lq## wkh# hfrqrp|#fkdqjh1#Wkh#ehvw#lqglfdwru#iru#d#fhqwudo#edqnhu#lv#lqiodwlrq1#D#ulvh#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqiodwlrq## udwh## lqglfdwhv## wkdw## wkh## hfrqrp|## lv## h{fhhglqj## wkh## vshhg## olplw>## li## wkh# lqiodwlrq#udwh#lv#idoolqj/#wkh#hfrqrp|#fdq#ehqhilw#iurp#pruh#vwlpxoxv1#Ri#frxuvh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh## prqhwdu|## srolf|## rshudwhv## zlwk## odjvᄇudlvh## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## qrz/## dqg## wkh# hiihfwv#duh#ihow#lq#wkh#hfrqrp|#rqo|#pdq|#prqwkv#odwhuᄇd#fhqwudo#edqn#wkdw#zdlwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqwlo## lw## vwduhv## lqiodwlrq## lq## wkh## h|h## ehiruh## zlwkgudzlqj## vwlpxoxv## kdv## zdlwhg## wrr# orqj1## Wkhuhiruh/## fhqwudo## edqnv## dwwhpsw## wr## surmhfw## zkdw## wkhlu## srolflhv## zloo## gr# +w|slfdoo|#ryhu# # # d## wzr0# wr## wkuhh0|hdu## krul}rq,## dqg## dgrsw#srolflhv# # # wkdw#zloo# # # nhhs# ixwxuh#lqiodwlrq#forvh#wr#d#wdujhw#dqg#wkxv#pdlqwdlq#jurzwk#forvh#wr#srwhqwldo1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Lq#wkh#|hduv#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv/#fhqwudo#edqnhuv#dqg#dfdghpld#wkxv#frqyhujhg#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # yduldqwv#ri#wdujhwlqj#lqiodwlrq#dv#wkhlu#sulpdu|#remhfwlyh1#Ri#frxuvh/#wkh|#dovr#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## frqvlghu## wkh## remhfwlyh## ri## ilqdqfldo## vwdelolw|1## Dffruglqj## wr## frqyhqwlrqdo# zlvgrp/## fhqwudo## edqnhuv## kdg## rqo|## rqh## lqvwuxphqw## zlwk## zklfk## wr## fduu|## rxw# prqhwdu|## srolf|ᄇwkh## vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw# # # udwhᄇdqg## wkh|## frxog## qrw## wdujhw## pruh# wkdq#rqh# # # remhfwlyh## zlwk#lw1# # # Frqfhuqv## derxw#ilqdqfldo# # # vwdelolw|#zrxog# # # frpsolfdwh# dqg## pdnh## ohvv## lqwhoohfwxdoo|## uljrurxv## wkh## surfhvv## ri## vhwwlqj## prqhwdu|## srolf|1# Ilqdqfldo## vwdelolw|## zdv## ohiw## wr## eh## wdfnohg## wkurxjk## ᄈsuxghqwldoᄡ## phdvxuhv## olnh# fdslwdo## uhtxluhphqwv## dqg## uhohjdwhg## wr## wkh## ohvv## jodprurxv## vxshuylvru|## dqg# uhjxodwru|#dupv#ri#fhqwudo#edqnv1# # # # #
Wkh#Lqwhuhvw#Udwh#dqg#Lwv#Hiihfwv # # # # # # Wkh#Ihg#frqgxfwv#prqhwdu|#srolf|#odujho|#wkurxjk#wkh#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh# # # # # # # # # # # +wkh#ryhuqljkw#ihghudo#ixqgv#udwh,1#Lw#vhwv#wklv#udwh#e|#lqwhuyhqlqj#lq#wkh#lqwhuedqn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw#iru#uhvhuyh#prqh|1#Wkurxjk#wklv#udwh/#wkh#Ihg#krshv#wr#lqioxhqfh#wkh#orqj0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # whup## lqwhuhvw## udwh1## Dffruglqj## wr## wkh## prvw## frpprqo|## khog## hfrqrplf## ylhz/# lqyhvwruv#lq#wkh#pdunhw#vhh#wkh#orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh#+vd|#wkh#whq0|hdu#Wuhdvxu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # erqg#udwh,#dv#ehlqj#d#ixqfwlrq#ri#wkh#vhtxhqfh#ri#wkh#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#h{shfwhg#wr#suhydlo#ryhu#wlph1#Vr#li#wkh#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh#lv#h{shfwhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhpdlq## orz## ryhu## wkh## qh{w## whq## |hduv/## wkh## orqj0whup## lqwhuhvw## udwh## zloo## eh## orz/# zkhuhdv#li#wkh#udwh#lv#h{shfwhg#wr#eh#orz# # # # # # # # # # rqo|#iru#wkh#qh{w#wzr#prqwkv#dqg#wkhq# # # # # # # # folpe#wr#d#kljkhu#sodwhdx/#wkh#orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh#zloo#eh#kljk1#Wklv#uhdvrqlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv## nqrzq#dv# # # wkh## h{shfwdwlrqv## k|srwkhvlv1## E|#kroglqj#grzq#wkh# # # # # vkruw0whup#udwh/# # hvshfldoo|#li#wkh#pdunhw#eholhyhv#lw#zloo# # # # # # # # eh#khog#orz# # # # iru## d#vxvwdlqhg#shulrg/#wkh# # # # Ihg## fdq#lqioxhqfh# # # h{shfwdwlrqv## ri#wkh# # # ixwxuh## vkruw0whup#udwh# # # dqg## khqfh## wkh## orqj0 whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh1# # # Orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#duh#h{wuhpho|#lpsruwdqw#lq#wkh#hfrqrp|1#D#orzhu#orqj0 # # # # # # # # # # # whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh# # # # lqfuhdvhv## wkh## ydoxh## ri#orqj0whup#dvvhwv# # # # vxfk#dv# # # htxlw|/## erqgv/# dqg## krxvhv## ehfdxvh## glylghqgv/## lqwhuhvw#sd|phqwv/# # # dqg## wkh## vhuylfhv## surylghg## e|# wkh#krxvh#duh#glvfrxqwhg#dw#d#orzhu#udwh1#Lw#wkxv#lqfuhdvhv#krxvhkrog#zhdowk#dqg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frqvhtxhqwo|/#vshqglqj1#D#orz#orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh#dovr#pdnhv#lw#ohvv#dwwudfwlyh# # # # # # # # # # # # iru#krxvhkrogv#wr#vdyh#dqg#pruh#dwwudfwlyh#wr#frqvxph/#wkxv#djdlq#frqwulexwlqj#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghpdqg1## Ilqdoo|/## orqj0whup## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## ghwhuplqh## wkh## surilwdelolw|## ri## uhdo# lqyhvwphqw=## orzhu## orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw# # # udwhv## pdnh## wrgd|ᄊv## ydoxh## ri## ixwxuh## surilwv# kljkhu/#jlylqj#frusrudwlrqv#pruh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#lqyhvw#dv#zhoo#dv#juhdwhu#delolw|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # eruurz1# Wkh#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwh#pd|#dovr#kdyh#gluhfw#hiihfwv#rq#hfrqrplf#dfwlylw|1# # # # # # # # # # # # Pdq|## eruurzlqj## udwhv## duh## wlhg## wr## vkruw0whup## lqwhuhvw## udwhv=## iru## h{dpsoh/## wkh# lqwhuhvw#sd|phqw#rq#dq#dgmxvwdeoh0udwh#pruwjdjh#idoov#li#wkh#Ihg#fxwv#lqwhuhvw#udwhv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # ohdylqj#pruh#prqh|#iru#krxvhkrogv#wr#vshqg1#Wkurxjk#d#orz#srolf|#udwh/#wkh#Ihg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pd|#dovr#vljqdo#wr#wkh#pdunhw#wkdw#lw#lqwhqgv#wr#nhhs#oltxlglw|#frqglwlrqvᄇwkdw#lv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## delolw|## wr## eruurzᄇhdv|## ryhu## wkh## iruhvhhdeoh## ixwxuh1## Edqnv## dqg## ilqdqfh# frpsdqlhv#wkhq#kdyh#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#pdnh#looltxlg#whup#ordqv/#frqilghqw#wkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdq#uhilqdqfh#iurp#wkh#pdunhw1# # # # # Zkdw#L#kdyh#rxwolqhg#lv#wkh#frqyhqwlrqdo#ylhz#ri#krz#prqhwdu|#srolf|#zrunv1# ## # # # # # # # # # # Ohw#xv#qrz#vhh#krz#wkh#Ihg#uhvsrqghg#wr#wkh#grw0frp#exvw#dqg#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 5334/#dqg#zkdw#wkh#frqyhqwlrqdo#ylhz#pd|#kdyh#plvvhg#rxw1# # # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Uhvsrqvh#wr#wkh#Grw0Frp#Exvw # # # # # # Diwhu## wkh## fudvk#lq#wkh# # # # QDVGDT#lqgh{#lq#5333ᄆ5334# # # # # dqg## wkh## uhfhvvlrq#wkdw# # iroorzhg/#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#wulhg#wr#riivhw#wkh#froodsvh#lq#lqyhvwphqw#e|#fxwwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # vwhdglo|1## Iurp#d# # # ohyho## ri#9# # # shufhqw#lq#Mdqxdu|#5334/# # # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # zhuh## eurxjkw#grzq#wr# # # # 4## shufhqw#e|#Mxqh# # # # 53361## Vxfk#d# # # orz## ohyho/# xqsuhfhghqwhg#lq#wkh#srvw04<:4#hud#ri#iordwlqj#h{fkdqjh#udwhv/#vhqw#d#vwurqj#vljqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## wkh## hfrqrp|1## Krxvh## sxufkdvhv## slfnhg## xs## dv## pruh## shrsoh## irxqg## wkh|## frxog# diirug#wkh#orzhu#pruwjdjh#sd|phqwv1#Lqfuhdvhg#krxvlqj#ghpdqg#hqfrxudjhg#pruh# # # # # # # # # # krph## frqvwuxfwlrq/## zklfk#zdv# # # douhdg|#ehlqj#jlyhq#d# # # # # errvw## e|#wkh# # # orz## lqwhuhvw# udwhv#dw#zklfk#ghyhorshuv#frxog#eruurz1# # # # # # Rxwsxw#jurzwk/#ulglqj#rq#surgxfwlylw|#jurzwk/#zdv#vwurqj/#exw#mrev#zhuh#uhdoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # zkdw#wkh#sxeolf#dqg#srolwlfldqv#zdqwhg1#Jurzwk#e|#lwvhoi#glg#qrw#sxw#irrg#rq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdeoh/## sd|#eloov/# # # ru## uhgxfh## dq{lhw|#iru# # # wkrvh## zkr## zhuh## xqhpsor|hg## dqg## vhhlqj# wkhlu#ehqhilwv#uxqqlqj#rxw/#ru#iru#wkrvh#zkr#ihduhg#iru#wkhlu#mrev1#Xqiruwxqdwho|/#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zh## kdyh## vhhq/## mre## jurzwk## vlpso|## glg## qrw## slfn## xs1## Lqgxvwuldo## dqg## vhuylfh# frpsdqlhv## frqwlqxhg#suxqlqj#zrunhuv/#dqg#wkh#qhz# # # # # # # mrev## lq#frqvwuxfwlrq#glg#qrw# # # # riivhw#mre#orvvhv#hovhzkhuh1#Xqhpsor|phqw#shdnhg#rqo|#lq#Mxqh#5336/#orqj#diwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # rxwsxw#jurzwk#kdg#uhvxphg#dqg#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#zdv#riilfldoo|#ryhu1# # # # # # # # # # Zlwk#lqiodwlrq#orz#dqg#xqhpsor|phqw#kljk/#wkh#Ihgᄊv#khdowk|0hfrqrp|#pdqgdwh# # # # # # # # # # vxjjhvwhg## lw## vkrxog## nhhs## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## orz1## Lqghhg/## jlyhq## wkh## ohyho## ri# xqhpsor|phqw#dqg#wkh#frqvhtxhqw#vodfn#lq#wkh#hfrqrp|/#Ihg#riilfldov/#lqfoxglqj# # # # # # # # # # # Ehq#Ehuqdqnh/# # # rshqo|#zruulhg# # # derxw## wkh## srvvlelolw|#ri# # # ghiodwlrq/## hyhq#lq#plg0 # # 6# 5336/#zkhq#txduwhuo|#JGS#jurzwk#zdv#durxqg#6#shufhqw1 # # # # # # # # # Wkh#Ihghudo# # # Uhvhuyh# vhhphg## wr## eh## lqioxhqfhg## e|## wkh## uhfhqw## h{shulhqfh## ri## Mdsdq/## zklfk## kdg## idfhg# surorqjhg## sulfh## ghiodwlrq## dqg## vorz## jurzwk## lq## wkh## 4<<3v## dv## d## uhvxow## ri## wkh# froodsvh#ri#lwv#uhdo#hvwdwh#exeeoh1#Exw#wklv#frqfhuq#zdv#plvsodfhg=#xqolnh#Mdsdq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#lq#5334#kdg#qrw#h{shulhqfhg#d#ghew#fulvlv/#rqo|#d#phowgrzq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ryhuydoxhg#whfk#vwrfnv1#D#ghew#fulvlv#frxog#kdyh#fdxvhg#d#grzqzdug#vsludo# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#edqnuxswflhv/#mre#orvvhv/#dqg#iluh# # # # # # # vdohv## wkdw#pljkw#kdyh# # # # wuljjhuhg#d# # # ghiodwlrq1# Exw## wkh## hiihfwv## ri## d## vwrfn## phowgrzq## zhuh/## dqg## klvwrulfdoo|## kdyh## ehhq/## pxfk# ploghu17## Frqvxphu#sulfh#lqiodwlrq#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#qhyhu#ihoo#ehorz#4#shufhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # ryhu#wklv#shulrg/#ghvslwh#grzqzdug#suhvvxuh#iurp#orz0frvw#lpsruwv#+zh#gr#qrw/# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#frxuvh/#nqrz#zkdw#lw#zrxog#kdyh#ehhq#zlwkrxw#wkh#hdv|#Ihg#srolf|,>#dqg#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwdqw/#ixwxuh#h{shfwdwlrqv#ri#lqiodwlrq#zhuh#ilupo|#deryh#4#shufhqw#dqg#qhduhu# # # # # # # # # # # # 5#shufhqw/#wkh#Ihgᄊv#xqriilfldo#wdujhw1#Lqghhg/#wkh#glvlqiodwlrqdu|#suhvvxuhv#dw#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # wlph## pd|## zhoo## kdyh## dulvhq## ehfdxvh## iruhljq## frpshwlwlrq## zdv## iruflqj## X1V1# surgxfhuv#wr#ehfrph#pruh#surgxfwlyh#dv#zhoo#dv#wr#nhhs#zdjh#lqfuhdvhv#olplwhg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # udwkhu#wkdq#ehfdxvh#ghpdqg#zdv#h{fhvvlyho|#orz1# # # # # # # E|#plg05336/#doprvw#hyhu|#phdvxuh# # # # # # ri#hfrqrplf# # # dfwlylw|#rwkhu# # # wkdq#lqiodwlrq# # dqg## xqhpsor|phqw## zdv## slfnlqj## xs## vwurqjo|1## Ghpdqg## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv# vwurqj=## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhvᄊ#wudgh# # # ghilflw/## d## phdvxuh## ri## wkh## ghpdqg## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv## wkdw#zdv# # # ehlqj#vdwlvilhg# # # iurp#deurdg/# # # zdv## zlghqlqj#udslgo|1# # # Lqghhg/## rqh# uhdvrq#wkdw# # # wkh## sdfh## ri## X1V1## mre## jurzwk#zdv# # # hvshfldoo|#vorz# # # lq#pdqxidfwxulqj# # pd|## kdyh## ehhq## wkdw## frxqwulhv## rxwvlgh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## olnh## Fklqd## dqg## Mdsdq/# zhuh#uhvlvwlqj#wkh#dssuhfldwlrq#ri#wkhlu#fxuuhqflhv#djdlqvw#wkh#zhdnhqlqj#groodu/# # # # # # # # # # #
wkxv## hqvxulqj## wkdw## wkhlu## h{sruwv## frqwlqxhg## wr## eh## frpshwlwlyh## lq## wkh## X1V1# pdunhwsodfh1#Wkh#Ihg#zdv#qrz# # # # # # hiihfwlyho|#dgglqj#vwlpxoxv#wr#d#zruog#hfrqrp|# # # # # # # wkdw## zdv## jurzlqj## vwurqjo|/## zlwk## mrev## ehlqj## fuhdwhg## hovhzkhuh## exw## qrw## lq## wkh# Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Frpprglw|## sulfhv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## vwduwhg## d## vwhdg|## ulvh/# vxjjhvwlqj## wkdw## zruogzlgh## hfrqrplf## vodfn## zdv## ghfuhdvlqj1## Li## wkh## Ihghudo# Uhvhuyh/## wkh## zruogᄊv## fhqwudo## edqnhu## lq## doo## exw## qdph/## kdg## ehhq## irfxvhg## rq# vxvwdlqdeoh## zruog## jurzwk/## lw## vkrxog## kdyh## ehhq## wljkwhqlqj## prqhwdu|## srolf|## e|# udlvlqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv1#Exw#lwv#pdqgdwh#fryhuhg#rqo|#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# # # # # # # # # # # Mrkq#Wd|oru#ri#Vwdqirug#Xqlyhuvlw|#kdv#srlqwhg#rxw#wkdw#hyhq#phdvxuhg#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # # zkdw#lv#nqrzq#dv#wkh#Wd|oru# # # # # # # uxoh#+dq#hpslulfdo# # # # fkdudfwhul}dwlrq#ri#sdvw#Ihghudo# # # # Uhvhuyh#lqwhuhvw0udwh#srolf|/#zklfk#vhhv#wkh#vkruw0whup#srolf|#udwh#dv#d#ixqfwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#lqiodwlrq#udwh#dqg#wkh#jds#ehwzhhq#wkh#rxwsxw#wkh#hfrqrp|#lv#fdsdeoh#ri#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkdw#lw#dfwxdoo|#surgxfhv,/# # # # # wkh## Ihg## vkrxog## kdyh## vwduwhg## udlvlqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # e|# 8# hduo|## 53351 # Exw## lw## frqwlqxhg## wr## uhgxfh## udwhv## xqwlo## dv## odwh## dv## Mxqh## 53361## Lq## d# vshhfk#lq#5343# # # # dw## wkh## Dphulfdq#Hfrqrplf# # # Dvvrfldwlrqᄊv## dqqxdo## phhwlqjv/## Ehq# Ehuqdqnh## ghihqghg## Ihg## srolf|/## vd|lqj#wkdw# # # li## lqiodwlrq#zdv# # # surshuo|#phdvxuhg/# # wkh## Ihg## kdg## qrw## ghsduwhg## iurp#wkh# # # Wd|oru## uxoh## gxulqj## wklv## shulrg1## Lq## wuxwk/## wkh# sureohp#zdv#wkdw#rxwsxw#jurzwk#kdg#qrw#uhvxowhg#lq#mre#jurzwk1#Dqg#wkh#Ihg#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 9# irfxvhg#qrw#rq#rxwsxw/#dv#wkh#Wd|oru#uxoh#zrxog#vxjjhvw/#exw#rq#mrev1 # # # # # # # # # # # # Zkhq## wkh## Ihg## ilqdoo|## vwduwhg## wr## udlvh## udwhv## lq## Mxqh## 5337/## lw## zdv## h{wuhpho|# ihduixo## ri#nloolqj#rii#d# # # # # qdvfhqw#mrev# # # uhfryhu|1#Vr#lw#wrrn#sdlqv# # # # # # wr#dffrpsdq|#lwv# # # udwh## klnhv## zlwk## dqqrxqfhphqwv## wkdw## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## zrxog## eh## orz## iru## ᄈd# frqvlghudeoh#shulrgᄡ#dqg#zrxog#ulvh#vorzo|#dw#d#ᄈphdvxuhg#sdfhᄡᄇqdpho|/#58# # # # # # # # # # # edvlv#srlqwv#dw#hyhu|#vfkhgxohg#phhwlqj#ri#wkh#erdug1#Wklv#vwudwhj|#fohduo|#khoshg# # # # # # # # # # # # # nhhs## orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # orz/## exw#qrw#ehfdxvh# # # # h{shfwdwlrqv## ri#ixwxuh# # # vkruw0 whup#udwhv#fdph#grzq/#dv#wkh#h{shfwdwlrqv#k|srwkhvlv#zrxog#vxjjhvw1#Lqvwhdg/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn## suhplxp## rq## orqj0whup## jryhuqphqw## erqgvᄇwkh## dgglwlrqdo## vsuhdg## wkdw## wkh# pdunhw#ghpdqgv#wr#wdnh#wkh#ulvn#ri#erqg#sulfhv#ioxfwxdwlqjᄇihoo#hyhq#dv#wkh#Ihg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # udlvhg## vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv/# # # # zlwk#wkh# # # uhvxow#wkdw#orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # # # ihoo# :# dqg#erqg#sulfhv#urvh1 # # # # Lqghhg/#d#jhqhudoo|#orz#suhplxp#iru#ulvn#hqvxuhg#wkdw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # sulfhv## ri#doo# # # ulvn|#ru# # # orqj0whup#dvvhwv/#lqfoxglqj#krxvlqj/#urvh/#hyhq#dv# # # # # # # # wkh#Ihg# # udlvhg#udwhv#vorzo|1#Wkh#Ihgᄊv#srolf|#vhhphg#wr#eh#zrunlqj#ehfdxvh#lw#pdgh#ulvn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh#wrohudeoh$# # Wkh## Ihg#glg#zruu|#derxw#wkh# # # # # # ghwhulrudwlqj#txdolw|#ri#ohqglqj#dqg#pdgh# # # # # # # vrph# vxshuylvru|#qrlvhv#ryhu#wlph1#Exw#zlwk#lwv#irrw#suhvvhg#ilupo|#rq#wkh#lqwhuhvw0udwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # dffhohudwru/## wkh## vxshuylvru|## phdvxuhv## zhuh## lqhiihfwlyh1## Xowlpdwho|/## lw## zdv# suredeo|## dovr## Ihg## dfwlrqv## wkdw## eurxjkw## wkh## sduw|## wr## dq## hqg1## Kljkhu## vkruw0whup# lqwhuhvw## udwhv## udlvhg## wkh## sd|phqwv## rq## dgmxvwdeoh0udwh## pruwjdjhv## dv## zhoo## dv# survshfwlyh## sd|phqwv## rq## pruwjdjhv## zlwk## udwh## uhvhwv1## Zlwk## ghpdqg## iru## krxvlqj# idoolqj## rii## +dqg## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh## hyhqwxdoo|## whpshulqj## wkhlu## sxufkdvhv## ri# pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv,/## krxvh## sulfhv## vwrsshg## ulvlqj1## Dv## d## uhvxow/# ryhuh{whqghg## eruurzhuv## irxqg## lw## kdug## wr## uhilqdqfh## ehiruh## wkh## lqlwldoo|## orz# ᄈwhdvhuᄡ## udwhv## rq## wkhlu## pruwjdjhv## h{sluhg/## dqg## krxvhkrogv## ehjdq## wr## ghidxow## rq# sd|phqwv1## Iruhforvxuhv## fdxvhg## krxvh0sulfh## ghfolqhv/## dqg## wkh## zkroh## prphqwxp# ri#wkh#errp#zdv# # # # # uhyhuvhg1#Wkh#Ihg/#dv# # # # # zh#qrz# # # nqrz/#lqwhuyhqhg#wrr#odwh1#Wkh# # # # # exeeoh#kdg#lqiodwhg#hqruprxvo|/#dqg#wkh#hqvxlqj#exvw#kdv#ehhq#h{wuhpho|#sdlqixo1# # # # # # # # # # # #
Glg#wkh#Ihg#Pdnh#PlvwdnhvB # # # # # Zlwk#wkh# # # ehqhilw#ri#klqgvljkw/# # # # lw#hdv|#wr# # # # vxjjhvw#wkdw#wkh# # # # Ihg## pdgh## plvwdnhv# hyhq#lq#wkh#wudglwlrqdo#frqgxfw#ri#prqhwdu|#srolf|=#iru#lqvwdqfh/#lw#pd|#zhoo#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ryhuhvwlpdwhg#wkh#ulvn#ri#ghiodwlrq1#Lq#vrph#zd|v/#wkrxjk/#wkh#wkuhdw#ri#ghiodwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhhphg#wr#eh#d#orz0suredelolw|#uhg#khuulqj/#sxw#iruwk#wr#h{sodlq#zk|#wkh#Ihg#nhsw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv## rq## krog1## Wkh## wuxh## sureohp#zdv# # # xqhpsor|phqw/## zklfk## pdgh## udlvlqj## udwhv# srolwlfdoo|## lpsrvvleoh1## Lq## wkh## sdvw/## zkhq## hfrqrplf## jurzwk## dqg## mre## uhfryhu|# frlqflghg/#wklv#zdv#qrw#dq#lvvxh1#Zlwk#mreohvv#uhfryhulhv#wkrxjk/#jurzwk#dqg#mrev# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdph#vrphzkdw#glyrufhg1#Wkh#Ihg#zrxog#kdyh#wr#eh#rq#krog#iru#d#orqj#wlph#li# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#zdqwhg#wr#vhh#mrev#uhdsshdu1# # # # # # Iru#wkrvh#zkr#eholhyh#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#lv#wrr#lqghshqghqw/#wkh#qrwlrq#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#lv# # # vxemhfw#wr# # # srolwlfdo## suhvvxuh## pd|#vhhp#xqwklqndeoh1# # # # \hw/## dv## Ihg## jryhuqruv# dgplw## lq## sulydwh/## suhvvxuh## lv## dssolhg## doo## wkh## wlph## e|## Frqjuhvv1## Srzhuixo# srolwlfldqv/#lq#rii0wkh0uhfrug#frqyhuvdwlrqv#zlwk#Ihg#jryhuqruv/#iuhtxhqwo|#pdnh# # # # # # # # # yhlohg## dqg## qrw0vr0yhlohg## wkuhdwv## wr## vfuxwlql}h## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## dfwlylwlhv## dqg# uhgxfh## lwv## lqghshqghqfh## xqohvv## wkh## Ihg## frpsolhv## zlwk## wkhlu## zlvkhv1## Dowkrxjk# w|slfdoo|#wkh|#vwd|#rii#prqhwdu|#srolf|/# # # # # # # wkhlu## ghvluhv## duh## qrw#kdug# # # wr## uhdg## zkhq# xqhpsor|phqw## lv## kljk1## Lurqlfdoo|/## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyhᄊv## ghvluh## wr## uhpdlq# lqghshqghqw#lv#wkh#ohyhu#zlwk#zklfk#Frqjuhvv#pdnhv#lw#frpsoldqw1# # # # # # # # # # Dw#wklv# # # wlph/## krzhyhu/## wkh## Ihg## qhhghg## olwwoh## frqylqflqj#wr# # # nhhs## lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # orz1## Wkh## suhydlolqj#ruwkrgr{|#vxjjhvwhg# # # # wkdw## Ihg## srolf|#pdnhuv# # # vkrxog## zruu|# rqo|#li#lqiodwlrq#zdv#jhwwlqj#rxw#ri#kdqg1#Dqg#lw#zdv#qrw=#lqiodwlrq#lq#wkh#sulfhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jrrgv## +olnh## fduv## dqg## plon,## dqg## vhuylfhv## +olnh## kdlufxwv## dqg## odxqgu|,## zdv# txlhvfhqw/#dqg#lqghhg/#li#dq|wklqj/#wkh#Ihg#ihduhg#ghiodwlrq1#Vr#wkh#Ihg#zdv#iuhh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#irfxv# # # rq#wkh#vhfrqg#sduw#ri#lwv# # # # # # # pdqgdwh/#ixoo# # # hpsor|phqw1#\hw#hyhq#zkloh#wkh# # # # # Ihg## dwwhpswhg## wr## frqylqfh## xqzloolqj## frusrudwlrqv## wr## lqyhvw## wkurxjk## xowudorz# lqwhuhvw#udwhv/# # # wkh## sulfhv## ri#ilqdqfldo# # # dvvhwv## dqg## krxvlqj#zhuh# # # vn|urfnhwlqj1## Exw# wkh#ruwkrgr{|#vxjjhvwhg#dvvhw#sulfhv#frxog#eh#ljqruhg1# # # # # # # #
Ulvlqj#Dvvhw#Sulfhv# # # # Udslgo|## ulvlqj## dvvhw## sulfhv## vkrxog## kdyh## vrxqghg## dodup## ehoov1## Wkh|## zhuh# gulyhq## e|## d## qxpehu## ri## irufhv## rwkhu## wkdq## wkh## wudglwlrqdo## rqhv=## lqfuhdvhg## ulvn# wdnlqj/#pruh#iruhljq#prqh|#orrnlqj#iru#ghew#fodlpv/#dqg#h{sdqglqj#fuhglw1# # # # # # # # # # # Orz#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#sxvkhg#lqyhvwruv#wr#wdnh#pruh#ulvn/#iru#d#qxpehu# # # # # # # # # # # # # ;# ri#uhdvrqv1 # # Vrph#lqvwlwxwlrqv/#olnh#lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv# # # # # # dqg#shqvlrq#ixqgv/#kdg# # # # frqwudfwhg## orqj0whup## oldelolwlhv1## Dw## wkh## orz## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## dydlodeoh## iru## vdih# dvvhwv/#wkh|#kdg#qr#krsh#ri#phhwlqj#wkrvh#oldelolwlhv1#Udwkhu#wkdq#idoolqj#vkruw#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxuh/## wkh|#suhihuuhg# # # wr## pryh## lqwr## orqjhu0whup#ulvnlhu# # # erqgv/## vxfk#dv# # # pruwjdjh0 edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv/#wkdw#sdlg#kljkhu#lqwhuhvw#udwhv1#Lq#dgglwlrq/#dv#orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv## ihoo## dqg## wkh## ydoxh## ri## vwrfnv/## erqgv/## dqg## krxvlqj## urvh/## krxvhkrogv## ihow# zhdowklhu## dqg## pd|## kdyh## ihow## wkh## frqilghqfh## wr## wdnh## pruh## ulvnv1## Vrph## ri## wkhvh# fkrlfhv## pd|#kdyh# # # ehhq#luudwlrqdo1# # # Dv## p|#froohdjxh# # # Ulfkdug## Wkdohu## kdv## dujxhg/#
zkhq#jdpeohuv#zlq#prqh|/#wkh|#wdnh#pruh#ulvnv/#ehfdxvh#wkh|#wuhdw#wkhlu#hduolhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # zlqqlqjv#dv#ᄈkrxvhᄡ#prqh|ᄇqrw#wkhlu#rzqᄇdqg#wkhuhiruh#ohvv#lpsruwdqw#li#orvw1# # # # # # # # # # # Zkdwhyhu#wkh#uhdvrq/#zlwk#lqyhvwruv#pruh#zloolqj#wr#wdnh#ulvnv/#wkh#ulvn#suhplxp# # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#doo#pdqqhu#ri#dvvhwv#fdph#grzq1# # # # # # # Rqh## hiihfw## ri## wkh## vhdufk## iru## |lhog## zdv## wkdw## prqh|## pryhg## rxw## ri## wkh## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv## lqwr## rwkhu## frxqwulhv/## hvshfldoo|#lqwr# # # wkh## kljk0|lhoglqj#erqgv/# # # vwrfnv/## dqg# jryhuqphqw#vhfxulwlhv#lq#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv1#Exw#pdq|#ri#wkhvh#frxqwulhv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # ihduixo#ri#orvlqj#rxw#lq#wkh#udfh#wr#vxsso|#jrrgv#wr#wkh#X1V1#pdunhw1#Wkhlu#fhqwudo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnv## lqwhuyhqhg## wr## krog## grzq## wkh## ydoxh## ri## wkhlu## fxuuhqf|## e|## ex|lqj## wkh## X1V1# grooduv## wkdw#zhuh# # # iorzlqj#lqwr#wkhlu# # # # frxqwulhv## iurp#wkh# # # grphvwlf## sulydwh## hqwlwlhv# wkdw## kdg## dftxluhg## wkhp## dqg## uhlqyhvwlqj## wkhvh## grooduv## lq## vkruw0whup## X1V1# <## Wkxv/#hyhq#dv#wkh#Ihg#sxvkhg#grooduv#rxw/# # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#erqgv#dqg#djhqf|#erqgv1 # # # # fhqwudo## edqnv## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## sxvkhg## wkhp## edfn## lq1## Lq## d## qxpehu## ri# lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv/## sulydwh## hqwlwlhv## uhf|fohg## wkh## groodu## lqiorzv=## Jhupdq#edqnv# # dqg#Mdsdqhvh#lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv#erxjkw#vhhplqjo|#vdih#X1V1#pruwjdjh0edfnhg# # # # # # # # # vhfxulwlhv## zlwk## wkh## grooduv## wkhlu## fxvwrphuv## ghsrvlwhg1## Wkh## prqh|## ohdylqj## wkh# Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## orrnlqj#iru# # # ulvnlhu## dvvhwv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## wkxv## fdph## edfn#wr# # # wkh# Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#orrnlqj#iru#vhhplqjo|#vdih#exw#kljkhu0|lhoglqj#ghew0olnh#vhfxulwlhv1# # # # # # # # # # Lq## vrph## zd|v/## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## srolf|## zdv## wxuqlqj## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lqwr## d# jljdqwlf## khgjh## ixqg/## lqyhvwlqj#lq#ulvn|#dvvhwv# # # # # durxqg## wkh## zruog## dqg## ilqdqfhg## e|# 43# ghew#lvvxhg#wr#wkh#zruog1 # # # # Fuhglw## dovr## h{sdqghg1## Ulvlqj## dvvhw## sulfhv## wkhpvhoyhv## jdyh## krxvhkrogv## dqg# ilupv## wkh## froodwhudo## zlwk#zklfk#wr# # # # eruurzᄇd## fkdqqho## wkdw## Fkdlupdq#Ehuqdqnh# # klpvhoi## kdg## srlqwhg## rxw## zkhq## kh## zdv## d## surihvvru## dw## Sulqfhwrq## Xqlyhuvlw|144# Lqghhg/#pxfk#ri#wkh#ilqdqflqj#ri#orz0lqfrph#eruurzhuv#zdv#suhglfdwhg#rq#krxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # sulfhv#ulvlqj#dqg#eruurzhuv#uhilqdqflqj#rqfh#wkh#orz#whdvhu#udwhv#udq#rxw1#Wkxv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kljkhu## krxvh## sulfh/## udwkhu## wkdq#lqfuhdvhg# # # lqfrph/## zdv## wkh## phdqv## wkurxjk#zklfk# # eruurzhuv#zrxog#nhhs#wkhpvhoyhv#fxuuhqw#rq#sd|phqwv1# # # # # # # Lq#dgglwlrq/#wkh#surplvh#wkdw#oltxlglw|#zrxog#eh#sohqwlixo#ryhu#wkh#iruhvhhdeoh# # # # # # # # # # # # ixwxuh## phdqw#wkdw#edqnhuv# # # # zhuh## zloolqj#wr# # # pdnh## orqjhu0whup#looltxlg/# # # dqg## khqfh# ulvn|/## ordqv145## Exw#zlwk#ilupv# # # # xqzloolqj#wr# # # lqyhvw/## edqnv## zhqw#orrnlqj#iru# # # # ghdov# wkdw## zrxog## fuhdwh## ghpdqg## iru## ordqv146## Rqh## rswlrq## zdv## iru## sulydwh## htxlw|# lqyhvwruv#wr#dftxluh#ilupv/#uho|lqj#rq#edqnv#wr#ilqdqfh#wkh#ghdov1#Edqnv/#lq#wxuq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sdfndjhg## wkh## ordqv## wkh|#pdghᄇfuhdwlqj#froodwhudol}hg# # # # ordq#reoljdwlrqv# # # +FORv,# ᄇdqg#vrog#ghew#vhfxulwlhv#djdlqvw#wkhp/#wkxv#rewdlqlqj#wkh#ixqgv#wr#pdnh#|hw#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ordqv1## Wkh## uhvxow## zdv## wkdw## odujhu## dqg## odujhu## ohyhudjhg## dftxlvlwlrqv## zhuh# sursrvhg#wr#vdwlvi|#wkh#vhhplqjo|#lqvdwldeoh#lqyhvwru#kxqjhu#iru#ghew#fodlpv1#Dv# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#uxvk#wr#ohqg#lqfuhdvhg/#ohqglqj#vwdqgdugv# # # # # # # # ghfolqhg#udslgo|=# # # wkh#fodvvlf#vljqv# # # ri#wkh#iuhq}|#zhuh#ᄈfryhqdqw0olwhᄡ#ordqv/#ehuhiw#ri#wkh#wudglwlrqdo#fryhqdqwv#edqnv# # # # # # # # # # # # sxw#lq#wr#wuljjhu#uhsd|phqw#li#wkh#eruurzhu# # # # # # # # ᄊv#frqglwlrq#ghwhulrudwhg/#dqg#sd|0lq0 # # # # nlqg## erqgv/## vfkhphv## e|## zklfk## eruurzhuv## zkr## frxog## qrw## sd|## lqwhuhvw## vlpso|# lvvxhg#pruh#erqgv1#Dv#L#dujxhg#hduolhu/#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv#zdv#qrw#fdxvhg#rqo|#e|# # # # ## # # # # # # # # # ohqglqj#wr#wkh#srru$# # # #
Wkh#Ghsduwxuh#ri#Dvvhw#Sulfhv#iurp#Ixqgdphqwdov# # # # # # #
# Ulvlqj#dvvhw# # # sulfhv## zrxog## qrw## eh## d## sureohp#li#pdunhwv# # # # zhuh## zhoo## ehkdyhg# dqg#nhsw#dvvhw#sulfhv#wlhg#wr#ixqgdphqwdov1#Lq#wkh#fdvh#ri#krxvlqj/#sulfhv#vkrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh#d#ixqfwlrq#ri#lqwhuhvw#udwhv/#orfdo#ghprjudsklfv/#krxvhkrog#lqfrphv/#dqg#orfdo# # # # # # # # # # # # }rqlqj#uhjxodwlrqv#frqvwudlqlqj#wkh#vxsso|#ri#krxvlqj1# # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/#dvvhw#sulfh#jurzwk#fdq#eh#vhoi0uhlqiruflqj1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#kljkhu# # # # # # # # # # krxvh#sulfhv#jlyh#h{lvwlqj#krphrzqhuv#krph#htxlw|#wkdw#wkh|#fdq#eruurz#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#pdnh#wkh#grzq#sd|phqw#iru#ehwwhu#krxvhv/#ohdglqj#wr#d#ulvh#lq#sulfhv#iru#wkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvhv## dv## zhoo1## Dqg## d## klvwru|#ri#krxvh# # # # sulfh## jurzwk#fdq#ohdg# # # # qdlyh## qhz## krph# ex|huv#wr#vzdoorz#wkhlu#uhdo#hvwdwh#djhqwᄊv#vdohv#slwfk#dqg#sxw#wkhlu#prqh|#grzq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{shfwlqj## wkh## sulfh## dssuhfldwlrq## wr## frqwlqxh1## Lqghhg/## iru## d## zkloh## vxfk# h{shfwdwlrqv#pd|#eh#orjlfdo/#ehfdxvh#wkhuh#duh#pdq|#pruh#h{lvwlqj#krphrzqhuv# # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#hqrxjk#krph#htxlw|#wr#pryh#xs1# # # # # # # Lq#prvw# # # pdunhwv/## vdyy|#lqyhvwruv# # # fdq#wdnh# # # d## frqwuduldq#srvlwlrq#zkhq#sulfhv# # # # ghsduw#wrr#pxfk#iurp#ixqgdphqwdo#ydoxh1#Lq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw#+dv#zhoo#dv#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw#wr#wdnh#ilupv#sulydwh,/#ihz#rssruwxqlwlhv#h{lvw#iru#lqyhvwruv#wr#wdnh#d#vkruw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # srvlwlrqᄇwkdw#lv/#vhoo#krxvhv#wkh|#gr#qrw#kdyh#vr#dv#wr#pdnh#d#nloolqj#zkhq#sulfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # idoo1#Wklv#w|slfdoo|#phdqv#wkdw#wkh#rswlplvwlf/#zkr#ex|#krxvlqj/#whqg#wr#kdyh#xqgxh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqioxhqfh147## Vr## krxvh## sulfhv/## dqg## pruh## jhqhudoo|/## dvvhw## sulfhv/## fdq## ulvh# h{fhvvlyho|/#dqg#wkhlu#uhdftxdlqwdqfh#zlwk#uhdolw|#fdq#eh#euxwdo#lqghhg1# # # # # # # # # # Fhqwudo#edqnhuv#dujxh#wkdw#wkh|#uhdoo|#vkrxog#qrw#eh#lq#wkh#exvlqhvv#ri#iljxulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw#zkhq#dvvhw#sulfhv#duh#wrr#kljk=#diwhu#doo/#gr#wkh|#uhdoo|#nqrz#wkdw#pxfk#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq#pdunhw#sduwlflsdqwvB#Wklv#qrw#d#vloo|#dujxphqw1#Pdq|#pdunhwv#zrun#zhoo#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhpvhoyhv/#dqg#lqwurgxflqj#wkh#zklpv#dqg#idqflhv#ri#wkh#fhqwudo# # # # # # # # # # # edqn#jryhuqru# # lqwr## wkh## zd|#sulfhv# # # duh## ghwhuplqhg## frxog## fuhdwh## pruh## sureohpv## wkdq#lw#vroyhv1# # # Exw#klvwru|#zduqv#wkdw#pdunhwv#vxfk#dv#krxvlqj/#zklfk#duh#gulyhq#e|#edqn#ohqglqj/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#gliihuhqw=#qrw#rqo|#duh#wkh|#yhu|#wklq#+uhodwlyho|#ihz#krxvh#vdohv#ghwhuplqh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ydoxh#ri#krxvlqj#iru#wkh#zkroh#frxqwu|,/#exw#wkh|#dovr#gr#qrw#doorz#iru#lqyhvwruv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#wdnh#vkruw#srvlwlrqv1#Sulfhv#lq#wkhvh#pdunhwv#fdq#uxq#dzd|#iurp#ixqgdphqwdov1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dqg#wkh#dgyhuvh#vsludov#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#krxvh0sulfh#exvwv#fdq#eh#yhu|#gdpdjlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # lqghhg## =## dv## sulfhv## idoo/## ohqglqj## ydqlvkhv/## dqg## shrsoh## fdqqrw## uhsd|## wkhlu# pruwjdjhv>#wkxv#iruhforvxuhv#lqfuhdvh/#dqg#sulfhv#gurs#ixuwkhu1# # # # # # # # Wkh## nh|## zduqlqj## vljqdo## ri## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## jurzwk## lq## dvvhw## sulfhv## lv## dq# 48## Ehiruh## wkh## fudvk#ri#4<5</# dffrpsdq|lqj#jurzwk#lq#fuhglw1 # # # # # # wkh## zduqlqj#vljqdo# # zdv## wkh## jurzwk#lq#pdujlq#ordqv# # # # # djdlqvw## vkduhv## hyhq#dv# # # vwrfn#sulfhv# # # lqfuhdvhg1# Ehiruh## wkh## prvw## uhfhqw## uhfhvvlrq/## dodup## ehoov## vkrxog## kdyh## vrxqghg## lq## hyhu|# fhqwudo## edqn#phhwlqj#dv# # # # d#errp#lq#uhdo# # # # # hvwdwh#ohqglqj#dffrpsdqlhg#krxvh#sulfh# # # # # jurzwk/## dqg## ohqglqj#wr# # # sulydwh## htxlw|#juhz# # # zlwk#hyhu0kljkhu# # # wudqvdfwlrq#sulfhv1# # Lqghhg/## fuhglw#jurzwk#kdv# # # # klvwrulfdoo|#ehhq#rqh# # # # ri#wkh# # # idfwruv## ghwhuplqlqj#krz# # fhqwudo## edqnhuv## vhw## srolf|## lqwhuhvw## udwhv>## exw## lq## uhfhqw## |hduv/## dfdghplfv## kdyh# shuvxdghg## pdq|#ri# # # wkhp#wkdw# # # vxfk#ehkdylru# # # lv## dufkdlf1## Wr## wkhlu## fuhglw## +qr## sxq# lqwhqghg,/## wkh## Hxurshdq## Fhqwudo## Edqn## dqg## vrph## ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|## fhqwudo# edqnv/#olnh# # # wkh## Uhvhuyh## Edqn#ri#Lqgld/#kdyh# # # # # frqwlqxhg#wr#sd|#dwwhqwlrq#wr#fuhglw# # # # # # jurzwk#lq#ghwhuplqlqj#wkhlu#prqhwdu|#srolf|1# # # # # # Udslg## fuhglw#jurzwk#zdv# # # # ghhphg## ri#lpsruwdqfh# # # lq#wkh# # # sdvw#sduwo|#ehfdxvh# # # # lw# zdv## wkrxjkw## wr## suhvdjh## lqiodwlrq## dqg## sduwo|## ehfdxvh## lw## uhiohfwhg## d## srvvleoh#
ghwhulrudwlrq#lq#wkh# # # # txdolw|#ri# # # fuhglw1## Dfdghplfv## dujxhg## wkdw## wkh## olqnv## ehwzhhq# fuhglw## jurzwk#dqg# # # lqiodwlrq#zhuh# # # whqxrxv## +khuh## wkh|#zhuh# # # uljkw,## dqg## wkdw## fuhglw# sureohpv## zhuh## d## klvwrulf## fxulrvlw|## lq## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv## ehfdxvh## ri# lpsuryhphqwv## lq## edqn## pdqdjhphqw## dqg## vxshuylvlrq## +khuh## wkh|## zhuh## reylrxvo|# zurqj,1# D#vhfrqg#dujxphqw#fhqwudo#edqnhuv#riihu#lv#wkdw#lq#wkh#plgvw#ri#d#iuhq}|/#zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyhvwruv#h{shfw#grxeoh0gljlw#udwhv#ri#sulfh#jurzwk/#udlvlqj#udwhv#e|#d#iudfwlrq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # 49# d#shufhqw#lv#lqhiihfwlyh1 # # # # Wkhuh#duh#wzr#gliilfxowlhv#zlwk#wklv#dujxphqw1#Iluvw/#wkh# # # # # # # # # nh|## lvvxh## lv## h{shfwdwlrqv1## Li## wkh## fhqwudo## edqn## fdq## frqylqfh## lqyhvwruv## wkdw## lw## lv# vhulrxv#derxw#iljkwlqj#dvvhw0sulfh#lqiodwlrqᄇlq#wkh#vdph#zd|#dv#lw#frqylqfhv#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # lw#zloo# # # iljkw#jrrgv0sulfh# # # lqiodwlrqᄇh{shfwdwlrqv## derxw#sulfh# # # jurzwk#fdq#ghiodwh# # # idvw/#hvshfldoo|#lq#wkh#hduo|#vwdjhv#ri#d#exeeoh1#Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/#vpdoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkdqjhv#lq# # wkh## fhqwudo## edqn## lqwhuhvw## udwh## fdq## diihfw## h{shfwdwlrqv## derxw## sulfh## jurzwk# frqvlghudeo|1#Wkh#idfw#wkdw#dvvhw#sulfhv#duh#jurzlqj#dw#grxeoh0gljlw#udwhv#grhv#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # phdq## wkdw## srolf|## udwhv## kdyh## wr## eh## udlvhg## frpphqvxudwho|1## Vhfrqg/## exeeohv# ghyhors#edvhg#rq#d#nlqg#ri#ᄈjuhdwhu#irroᄡ#wkhru|ᄇwkdw#hyhq#li#dq#dvvhw#lv#douhdg|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wudglqj#dw#dq#lqiodwhg# # # # # sulfh/## vrphrqh## zloo## eh## zloolqj#wr# # # ex|#lw#dw#dq#hyhq#pruh# # # # # # lqiodwhg## sulfh1## E|## vljqdolqj## wkdw## lw## zloo## wljkwhq## oltxlglw|## frqglwlrqv/## dqg## wkxv# frqvwudlq#ilqdqflqj#dqg#wudglqj/#wkh#fhqwudo#edqn#fdq#vljqdo#wr#lqyhvwruv#wkdw#wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo#eh#ihzhu#irrov#rxw#wkhuh#zlwk#wkh#fdsdflw|#wr#ex|/#pdnlqj#lw#pruh#gliilfxow#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#exeeoh#wr#jurz1# # # # Lqghhg/## lqvwhdg## ri## glvfrxudjlqj## wkh## ghyhorsphqw## ri## exeeohv/## wkh## Ihg# hqfrxudjhg#lw#wkurxjk#dq#lpsolflw#frpplwphqw/#zklfk#pljkw#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # grqh## idu## pruh# gdpdjh## wkdq#dq|#rwkhu# # # # Ihg## dfwlrq1## Wklv## frpplwphqw/## wkh## vr0fdoohg## ᄈJuhhqvsdq# sxw/ᄡ## hvvhqwldoo|#vdlg# # # wkdw#wkh# # # Ihg## frxog## qrw#uhdoo|#whoo# # # # zkhq#dvvhw#sulfhv# # # # zhuh# exloglqj#xs#lqwr#d#exeeoh/#dqg#vr#lqvwhdg#wkh#Ihg#zrxog#ljqruh#dvvhw#sulfhv#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwdqg#uhdg|#wr#slfn#xs#wkh#slhfhv#zkhq#wkh#exeeoh#exuvw1#Wr#xqghuvwdqg#zk|#wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frpplwphqw#zdv#pdgh/#zh#qhhg#wr#jr#edfn#wr#4<<91# # # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Juhhqvsdq#Sxw# # # # Lq#odwh# # # 4<<9/## wkh## Ihg## fkdlupdq/## Dodq#Juhhqvsdq/# # # dq#dvwxwh# # # dqg## h{shulhqfhg# +wkrxjk## vrphzkdw## lghrorjlfdo,## hfrqrplvw/## ehfdph## frqfhuqhg## derxw## wkh## kljk# ohyho#ri#wkh#vwrfn#pdunhw1#Lq#d#idprxvo|#eudyh#vshhfk#dw#wkh#Dphulfdq#Hqwhusulvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lqvwlwxwh/## kh## zrqghuhg## zkhwkhu## wkh## fhqwudo## edqn## vkrxog## dovr## zruu|## zkhq## wkh# sulfhv#ri#uhdo#hvwdwh/#htxlwlhv/#dqg#rwkhu#hduqlqj#dvvhwv#zhuh#ulvlqj#udslgo|1#Dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#rsdtxh#odqjxdjh#wkdw#kh#kdg#shuihfwhg/#kh#fdph#dv#forvh#dv#d#fhqwudo#edqnhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdq#wr#vd|lqj#kh#wkrxjkw#vwrfnv#zhuh#ryhuydoxhg=# # # # # # # # Exw#krz# # # gr#zh#nqrz# # # # zkhq#luudwlrqdo# # # h{xehudqfh#kdv# # # xqgxo|#hvfdodwhg# # dvvhw## ydoxhv/## zklfk## wkhq## ehfrph## vxemhfw## wr## xqh{shfwhg## dqg## surorqjhg# frqwudfwlrqv## dv## wkh|#kdyh#lq#Mdsdq#ryhu# # # # # # wkh#sdvw#ghfdghB#ᆱ#Zh#dv# # # # # # # fhqwudo# edqnhuv## qhhg## qrw#eh# # # frqfhuqhg## li#d# # # froodsvlqj#ilqdqfldo# # # dvvhw#exeeoh# # # grhv# qrw## wkuhdwhq## wr## lpsdlu## wkh## uhdo## hfrqrp|/## lwv## surgxfwlrq/## mrev/## dqg## sulfh# vwdelolw|ᆱ1## Exw#zh# # # vkrxog## qrw#xqghuhvwlpdwh# # # ru## ehfrph## frpsodfhqw#derxw# # wkh## frpsoh{lw|#ri#wkh# # # # lqwhudfwlrqv## ri#dvvhw#pdunhwv# # # # dqg## wkh## hfrqrp|1## Wkxv/#
hydoxdwlqj#vkliwv#lq#edodqfh#vkhhwv#jhqhudoo|/#dqg#lq#dvvhw#sulfhv#sduwlfxoduo|/# # # # # # # # # # # 4:# pxvw#eh#dq#lqwhjudo#sduw#ri#wkh#ghyhorsphqw#ri#prqhwdu|#srolf|1 # # # # # # # # # # # Lq#klv#dxwrelrjudsk|/#Juhhqvsdq#dgplwv#zrqghulqj#zkhwkhu# # # # # # # # wkh#pdunhw#zrxog# # # 4;# xqghuvwdqg#zkdw#kh#zdv#jhwwlqj#dw1 # # # # # # Lw#glgᄇdqg#ljqruhg#klp$#Wkh#vwrfn#pdunhw# # # # # # # rshqhg#vxevwdqwldoo|#orzhu# # # # wkh## qh{w#gd|#exw#uhjdlqhg#lwv# # # # # # orvvhv## lq#d# # # gd|1#Dqg#lw# # # zdv#uljkw#wr#ljqruh#klp/#ehfdxvh#wkh#Ihg#glg#qrw#iroorz#xs#Juhhqvsdqᄊv#frqfhuq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#dq#lqfuhdvh#lq#lqwhuhvw#udwhv/#hyhq#wkrxjk#kh#kdg#klqwhg#dw#vxfk#dfwlrq#lq#klv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vshhfk1#Juhhqvsdq#qhyhu# # # # h{sodlqhg#zk|#kh# # # # glg#qrw#dfw=# # # # txlwh## srvvleo|#klv# # # kdqg# zdv## vwd|hg## e|## wkh## ixulrxv## uhdfwlrq## kh## hqjhqghuhg## zkhq## pdunhw## sduwlflsdqwv# uhdol}hg#kh#zdv#wu|lqj#wr#wdon#wkh#pdunhw#grzq1# # # # # # # # # Lqvwhdg/## wkh## Ihg## zdwfkhg## zkloh## vwrfn#sulfhv# # # frqwlqxhg## ulvlqj#lq#wkh# # # # grw0frp# errp/## dv## frpsdqlhv## zlwkrxw## hduqlqjv## ru## hyhq## uhyhqxhv## vrog## vkduhv## dw# dvwurqrplfdo## sulfhv## edvhg## rq## wkh## qxpehu## ri## ᄈh|hedoovᄡ## wkh|## dwwudfwhg## wr## wkhlu# zhevlwhv1#Wkh#Ihg#hyhq#fxw#udwhv#iroorzlqj#wkh#Uxvvldq#ghew#ghidxow#lq#4<<;#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## froodsvh## ri## wkh## khgjh## ixqg## Orqj0Whup## Fdslwdo## Pdqdjhphqw/## dqg## udlvhg# lqwhuhvw#udwhv#plogo|#vwduwlqj#rqo|#lq#4<<<1# # # # # # # Zkhq## wkh## vwrfn## pdunhw## hyhqwxdoo|## fudvkhg## lq## 5333/## wkh## gudpdwlf## lqlwldo# uhvsrqvh#e|#wkh#Ihg#hqvxuhg#wkdw#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#zdv#plog#hyhq#li#mre#jurzwk#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # whslg1## Lq## d## 5335## vshhfk## dw## Mdfnvrq## Kroh/## Dodq## Juhhqvsdq## qrz## dujxhg## wkdw# dowkrxjk## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## frxog## qrw## uhfrjql}h## ru## suhyhqw## dq## dvvhw0sulfh# errp/## lw## frxog## ᄈplwljdwh## wkh## idoorxw## zkhq## lw## rffxuv## dqg/## krshixoo|/## hdvh## wkh# wudqvlwlrq## wr## wkh## qh{w## h{sdqvlrq1ᄡ4<## Wklv## vshhfk## vhhphg## wr## eh## d## srvw## idfwr# udwlrqdol}dwlrq#ri#zk|#Juhhqvsdq#kdg#qrw#dfwhg#pruh#irufhixoo|#rq#klv#suhvflhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # 4<<9#lqwxlwlrq=# # # kh#zdv#qrz# # # # vd|lqj#wkh#Ihg#vkrxog#qrw#lqwhuyhqh#zkhq#lw#wkrxjkw# # # # # # # # # dvvhw#sulfhv#zhuh#wrr#kljk#exw#wkdw#lw#frxog#uhfrjql}h#d#exvw#zkhq#lw#kdsshqhg#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#slfn#xs#wkh#slhfhv1# # # # # Wkh## orjlf## zdv## qrw#rqo|#vwudqjho|#dv|pphwulfdoᄇzk|#lv# # # # # # wkh## erwwrp#hdvlhu# # # wr# uhfrjql}h## wkdq#wkh# # # wrsBᄇexw## dovr## srvlwlyho|#gdqjhurxv1# # # Lw## ixhohg## wkh## iodphv## ri# dvvhw0sulfh#lqiodwlrq#e|#whoolqj#Zdoo# # # # # # Vwuhhw#dqg#edqnv# # # # dfurvv## wkh#frxqwu|#wkdw#wkh# # # # Ihg## zrxog## qrw#udlvh# # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # wr## fxue## dvvhw#sulfhv/# # # dqg## wkdw#li#pdwwhuv# # # # zhqw# whuuleo|#zurqj/#lw#zrxog#vwhs#lq#wr#surs#sulfhv#xs1#Wkh#frpplwphqw#wr#sxw#d#iorru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqghu## dvvhw#sulfhv#zdv#gxeehg#wkh#ᄈJuhhqvsdq#sxw1ᄡ#Lw#wrog#wudghuv#dqg#edqnhuv# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#li#wkh|#jdpeohg/#wkh#Ihg#zrxog#qrw#olplw#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # jdlqv/#exw#li#wkhlu# # # # # ehwv#wxuqhg# # vrxu/#wkh#Ihg#zrxog#olplw#wkh#frqvhtxhqfhv1#Doo#wkh|#kdg#wr#hqvxuh#zdv#wkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehw#rq#wkh#vdph#wklqj/#iru#li#wkh|#ehw#dorqh/#wkh|#zrxog#qrw#srvh#d#v|vwhplf#wkuhdw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Htxdoo|## lpsruwdqw/## wkh## zloolqjqhvv## wr## iorrg## wkh## pdunhw## zlwk## oltxlglw|## lq## wkh# hyhqw## ri## d## vhyhuh## grzqwxuq## vhqw## d## fohdu## phvvdjh## wr## edqnhuv=## ᄈGrqᄊw## erwkhu# vwrulqj#fdvk#ru#pdunhwdeoh#dvvhwv#iru#d#udlq|#gd|>#zh#zloo#eh#wkhuh#wr#khos#|rx1ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Qrw## rqo|## glg## wkh## Ihg## uhgxfh## wkh## surilwdelolw|## ri## wdnlqj## suhfdxwlrqv/## exw## lw# lpsolflwo|## hqfrxudjhg## edqnhuv## wr## eruurz## vkruw0whup## zkloh## pdnlqj## orqj0whup# ordqv/## frqilghqw#wkh# # # Ihg## zrxog## eh## wkhuh## li#ixqglqj#gulhg# # # # xs1## Ohyhudjh## exlow#xs# # wkurxjkrxw#wkh#v|vwhp1# # # Iru#d#orqj#wlph/#fhqwudo#edqnv#mxvwlilhg#qrw#irfxvlqj#rq#dvvhw#sulfhv#e|#dujxlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#li#Dodq#Juhhqvsdq#kdg#dfwhg#rq#klv#lqwxlwlrq#lq#4<<9/#kh#zrxog#kdyh#vqxiihg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
rxw## d## errp## wkdw/## ghvslwh## wkh## voxps## lq## 5333/## wrrn## wkh## vwrfn## pdunhw## dqg## X1V1# krxvhkrog#zhdowk#wr#xqsuhfhghqwhg#khljkwv1#Rq#Pdufk#5/#533</#wkrxjk/#wkh#V)S# # # # # # # # # # # # 833## forvhg## dw## :33/## ehorz## lwv## ohyho## ri## :7716;## rq## wkh## gd|## lq## 4<<9## zkhq## Dodq# Juhhqvsdq#pdgh#klv#idwhixo#vshhfk1#Ri#frxuvh/#wr#gdwh#lw#kdv#uhjdlqhg#vxevwdqwldo# # # # # # # # # # # # # jurxqg/#exw#shukdsv#Juhhqvsdq#frxog#kdyh#dyhuwhg#wkluwhhq#|hduv#ri#orvw#uhwxuqv#li# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqghhg## kh## kdg## edfnhg## klv## zrugv## zlwk## dfwlrq## rq## lqwhuhvw## udwhv1## Zkhwkhu## wkh# srolwlfdo#v|vwhp#zrxog#kdyh#doorzhg#klp#wr#gr#vr#lv/#ri#frxuvh/#dqrwkhu#pdwwhu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Prqhwdu|#Srolf|#dqg#Ilqdqfldo#Vwdelolw| # # # # # Wkh## uhfhqw## uhfhvvlrq## kdv## vwduwhg## vrph## uhwklqnlqj## rq## wkh## remhfwlyhv## ri# prqhwdu|#srolf|/#wkrxjk#hyhq#dv#L#zulwh/#wkh#Ihg#lv#nhhslqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#dw#urfn0 # # # # ## # # # # # # # # erwwrp## ohyhov## ehfdxvh## xqhpsor|phqw## lv## kljk/## hyhq## zkloh## doo## pdqqhu## ri## dvvhw# sulfhv#duh#ulvlqj1#Wkh#vdylqj#judfh#wrgd|#lv#wkdw#fuhglw#jurzwk#lv#vwloo#whslg/#dqg#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv## xqolnho|#wkdw#zh# # # # zloo## kdyh## dqrwkhu## krxvlqj#errp#zkloh# # # # phprulhv## ri#wkh# # # odvw# rqh#duh#vwloo#iuhvk1#Exw#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#lv/#li#dq|wklqj/#lqqrydwlyh/#hyhq#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zd|v#lw#jhwv#lqwr#wurxeoh$# # # # # L#vdlg# # # hduolhu## wkdw#dfdghplfv# # # dqg## fhqwudo## edqnhuv## kdg## frqyhujhg## rq#wkh# # # ylhz# wkdw## wkhuh## lv## qr## lqfrpsdwlelolw|## ehwzhhq## wkh## remhfwlyhv## ri## vhhnlqj## pd{lpxp# jurzwk#dqg#nhhslqj#lqiodwlrq#orz#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq1#Exw#wkhuh#grhv#vhhp#wr#eh#vrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfrpsdwlelolw|#ehwzhhq#wkh#prqhwdu|#srolflhv#wkdw#hqfrxudjh#uhdo#lqyhvwphqw#dqg# # # # # # # # # # jurzwkᄇpdlqwdlqlqj#suhglfwdeo|#orz# # # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # ryhu## d## vxvwdlqhg#shulrg#dqg# # # h{suhvvlqj#d#zloolqjqhvv#wr#iorrg#wkh#pdunhw#zlwk#oltxlglw|#zkhq#lw#lv#wljkwᄇdqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#prqhwdu|#srolflhv#wkdw#glvfrxudjh#wkh#frruglqdwhg#rqh0zd|#ehwv#e|#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw## sduwlflsdqwv## wkdw## kdyh## suryhg## vr## gdpdjlqjᄇsxuvxlqj## xqsuhglfwdeoh# srolflhv#zlwk#qr#dvvxudqfh#ri#oltxlglw|#vxssruw1# # # # # # # Wkh## dujxphqw#wkdw#prqhwdu|#srolf|#kdv# # # # # # qr## uroh## lq#ohdqlqj#djdlqvw#dvvhw0sulfh# # # # exeeohv#lv#erwk#wlplg#dqg#vhoi0vhuylqj/#dqg#lw#wdnhv#wkh#Ihg#rxw#ri#d#nh|#uroh#lw#fdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sod|#lq#dvvxulqj#ilqdqfldo#vwdelolw|1#Ri#frxuvh#wkh#Ihg#vkrxog#surfhhg#fdxwlrxvo|# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#ohdq#djdlqvw#dq#lqflslhqw#exeeoh#rqo|#zkhq#wkhuh#lv#vxevwdqwldo#hylghqfh#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#h{lvwv/#whpshuhg#e|#wkh#nqrzohgjh#wkh#ihduv#ri#d#exeeoh#frxog#eh#edvhohvv1#Wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhvljq#wkh#uroh#ri#sduw|#srrshu/#krzhyhu/#lv#wr#ex|#srolwlfdo#dffhswdelolw|#dw#juhdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#wr#wkh#hfrqrp|1# # # # Pruh#frqwuryhuvldo#lv#zkhwkhu#wkh#Ihg#vkrxog#fxw#srolf|#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wr#urfn# # # # # # # # # # # # # erwwrp#lq#rughu#wr#uhylyh#wkh#hfrqrp|1#Dowkrxjk#vxfk#dq#dfwlrq#vhhpv#frvwohvv/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsrvhv#dq#hqruprxv#frvw#rq#vdyhuv#dqg#riihuv#dq#hqruprxv#zlqgidoo#wr#ghewruv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # hvshfldoo|## edqnv1## Ehfdxvh## lw## lv## d## uhodwlyho|## klgghq## wudqvihu/## lw## holflwv## olwwoh# frpphqw#ru#surwhvw/#hvshfldoo|#dv#zhoo0rii#vdyhuv#whqg#wr#nhhs#wkhlu#khdgv#grzq# # # # # # # # # # # # # dw## wlphv## ri## fulvlv1## Exw## lw## lv## d## wudqvihu## qhyhuwkhohvv/## dprxqwlqj## wr## kxqguhgv## ri# eloolrqv#ri#grooduv#d#|hdu1#Pruhryhu/#lw#riihuv#d#rqh0zd|#ehw#wr#edqnhuv=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # soxqjh# wkh#v|vwhp#lqwr#wurxeoh/#dqg#wkh|#zloo#jhw#d#juhdw#ghdo#rq#lqwhuhvw#udwhv1#Ilqdoo|/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv## qrw## fohdu## wkdw## xowudorz## qrplqdo## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## +durxqg## 3## shufhqw,## riihu## d# vljqlilfdqwo|#juhdwhu#lqfhqwlyh#iru#ilupv#wr#lqyhvw#wkdq#phuho|#orz#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#+5# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#6#shufhqw,/#exw#wkh#gliihuhqfh#lq#ulvn#wdnlqj#ehwzhhq#xowudorz#dqg#orz#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv#frxog#eh#hqruprxv1# # # # Pruh## gdpdjlqj#vwloo# # # lv## wkh## Ihgᄊv## rqjrlqj#dwwhpsw#wr# # # # surs## xs## krxvlqj#sulfhv/# # erwk#lqgluhfwo|#wkurxjk#orz#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#dqg#gluhfwo|#e|#ohqglqj#lqwr#wkh#krxvlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw1#Dowkrxjk#vxfk#vxssruw#lv#mxvwlilhg#dv#d#zd|#wr#doorz#wkh#exeeoh#wr#ghiodwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vorzo|/## lw## frqwulexwhv## wr## surorqjhg## ghod|v## lq#dgmxvwphqw# # # lq#wkh# # # krxvlqj#pdunhw1# # Lqvwhdg## ri## krphrzqhuv## dqg## ohqghuv## elwlqj#wkh# # # exoohw## rq#orvvhv# # # dqg## prylqj#rq/# # wkh|#kdyh# # # wkh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## zdlw## dqg## vhh1## Exw## vr## orqj#dv# # # wkhuh## lv## d## survshfw## iru# ixuwkhu#dgmxvwphqw/#ex|huv/#wrr/#vwd|#rxw#ri#wkh#pdunhw1#Dqg#xqohvv#wkh#ryhuvxsso|# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq## wkh## krxvlqj## pdunhw## lv## fohduhg## rxw/## exloghuv## kdyh## olwwoh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## uhvxph#
frqvwuxfwlrq1## Wkh## Ihg## frxog## eh## qrw## rqo|## ghod|lqj## wkh## uhfryhu|## ri## wkh## krxvlqj# pdunhw## exw## dovr## uhlqiruflqj## wkh## vhqvh## wkdw## lw## zloo## qrw## jhw## lq## wkh## zd|## ri## sulfh# lqfuhdvhv#exw#zloo#suhyhqw#sulfh#idoov1#Wkh#Juhhqvsdq#sxw#lv#txlfno|#ehfrplqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ehuqdqnh#sxw1# # Lq#vxp/#wkh#Ihgᄊv# # # # # frqgxfw#ri#prqhwdu|#srolf|#ehwzhhq#5335#dqg#5338/#zkloh# # # # # # # # # urxqgo|## fulwlfl}hg## e|## doo## exw## fhqwudo## edqnhuv## dqg## prqhwdu|## hfrqrplvwv## +zlwk# qrwdeoh## h{fhswlrqv,/## kdg## wzr## lpsruwdqw## olplwdwlrqv1## Iluvw/## lw## zdv## il{dwhg## rq#wkh# # kljk#dqg#shuvlvwhqw#xqhpsor|phqw#udwh#dqg#glg#lwv#ehvw#wr#eulqj#lw#grzq#e|#wu|lqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#hqfrxudjh#lqyhvwphqw1#Lw#vljqdohg#wkdw#lw#zrxog#nhhs#udwhv#orz#iru#d#vxvwdlqhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # shulrg## dqg## riihuhg## wkh## Juhhqvsdq#sxw#li#ilupv# # # # # zhuh## vwloo## qrw#frqylqfhg1# # # Fulwlfv# vkrxog#uhfrjql}h#wkdw#wklv#il{dwlrq#zdv#lq#ixoo#dffrug#zlwk#lwv#pdqgdwh#dqg/#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwdqw/#wkdw#wkhuh#zrxog#kdyh#ehhq#srolwlfdo#khoo#wr#sd|#li#lw#kdg#udlvhg#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv#pxfk#hduolhu#wkdq#lw#glg1#Wklv#srolf|/#krzhyhu/#pd|#kdyh#kdg#d#juhdwhu#hiihfw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq## fuhglw## jurzwk## dqg## dvvhw## sulfhv## wkdq## rq## mre## fuhdwlrq## rxwvlgh## wkh## uhdo## hvwdwh# lqgxvwu|=## frusrudwlrqv## zhuh## vwloo## zrunlqj## dzd|## wkh## h{fhvvhv## ri## wkh## grw0frp# errp1# Vhfrqg/## wkh## grplqdqw#dfdghplf# # # ruwkrgr{|#lqglfdwhg# # # wkdw#vr# # # orqj#dv# # # lqiodwlrq# zdv#txlhvfhqw/#fhqwudo#edqnhuv#kdg#qrwklqj#wr#zruu|#derxw1#Lqghhg/#wr#zruu|#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#ghvwur|#wkh#sxulw|#ri#wkh#wkhruhwlfdo#v|vwhp#wkdw#kdg#ehhq#exlow/#iru#wkdw#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dgplw## ri## pxowlsoh## remhfwlyhv## dqg## ohdg## wr## pdunhw## frqixvlrq1## Lqvwhdg/## fhqwudo# edqnhuv#vkrxog#nhhs#wkhlu#h|hv#il{hg#rq#lqiodwlrq#+ru#wkh#odfn#wkhuhri,#dqg#ohw#edqn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxshuylvruv## zruu|## derxw## ulvn## wdnlqj1## Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkh## vxshuylvruv## kdg## ehhq# px}}ohg/#wklv#wlph#rq#wkh#lghrorjlfdo#jurxqgv#wkdw#wkh|#zrxog#gr#pruh#kdup#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jrrg#e|#uhvwudlqlqj#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru1# # # # # # Wkh## erwwrp## olqh## lv## wkdw## wkh## ghedwh## ryhu## prqhwdu|## srolf|/## zklfk## zdv## rqfh# wkrxjkw#vhwwohg/#zloo#kdyh#wr#eh#uhrshqhg#djdlq1#Dprqj#wkh#prvw#suhvvlqj#lvvxhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # duh## wkh## wudgh0riiv## ehwzhhq## srolflhv## lqwhqghg## wr## jhqhudwh## lqyhvwphqw## dqg# hpsor|phqw## dqg## srolflhv## lqwhqghg## wr## hqvxuh## ilqdqfldo## vwdelolw|1## Dvvhw0sulfh# lqiodwlrq#zloo# # # kdyh## wr## hqwhu## wkh## srolf|#ghedwh1# # # Pruhryhu/## wkh## Ihg## zloo## kdyh## wr# frqvlghu#zkhwkhu#lw#lv#vhwwlqj#srolf|#rqo|#iru#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#ru/#lq#uhdolw|/#iru#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pxfk#odujhu#joredo#hfrqrp|1#Pxfk#qhhgv#wr#eh#grqh1# # # # # # # # #
Dfdghpldᄊv#Idlolqjv # # Wklv## lv## dv## jrrg## d## srlqw#dv# # # dq|#wr# # # wu|#wr# # # xqghuvwdqg## wkh## idlolqjv## ri#dfdghplf# # hfrqrplvwv## lq## wkh## pdfurhfrqrplf## vskhuh1## Pdq|## frpphqwdwruv## kdyh## jrqh# ryhuerdug#lq#srnlqj#ixq#dw#hfrqrplvwvᄊ#prghov/#ghulglqj#wkhp#dv#ryhuvlpsolilhg1# # # # # # # # # # # Rwkhuv## zrqghu## derxw#wkh# # # h{fhvvlyh## pdwkhpdwlfdo## frpsoh{lw|#ri#vrph# # # # prgholqj/# dqg## |hw## rwkhuv## frpelqh## wkh## fulwlflvpv## e|## dujxlqj## wkdw## kxpdq## ehkdylru## lv## wrr# frpsoh{#wr#eh#fdswxuhg#e|#pdwkhpdwlfdo#prghov1# # # # # # # Wkh## prvw#uhdolvwlf# # # prgho## zrxog## eh## rqh## wkdw#ghwdlov# # # doo## lqglylgxdov## dqg## wkhlu# zklpvlfdo#ehkdylru/#dqg#doo#lqvwlwxwlrqv/#exw#lw#zrxog#eh#krshohvvo|#frpsoh{#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # ri## olwwoh## ydoxh## lq#dqdo|vlv1# # # Wkh## zkroh## srlqw## ri## hfrqrplf## prgholqj#lv# # # wr## fuhdwh# xvhixo#vlpsolilfdwlrqv#ri#wkh#hfrqrp|#wkdw#doorz#xv#wr#dqdo|}h#zkdw#pljkw#kdsshq# # # # # # # # # # # # # xqghu## ydu|lqj#srolflhv# # # dqg## frqglwlrqv1## Wkh## whvw## wkhq#lv# # # zkhwkhu## wkh## prgho## lv## d# xvhixo#vlpsolilfdwlrq#ru#dq#ryhuvlpsolilfdwlrq1# # # # # Pdq|#sdvw#pdfurhfrqrplf#prghov#kdg#d#vlqjoh#uhsuhvhqwdwlyh#djhqw#pdnlqj#doo# # # # # # # # # # # ghflvlrqv1#Wkh#uhsuhvhqwdwlyh0djhqw#prghov#zhuh#hdv|#wr#zrun#zlwk#dqg#glg#riihu# # # # # # # # # # # # xvhixo#suhglfwlrqv#derxw#srolf|/#exw#wkh|#wrrn#iru#judqwhg#wkh#soxpelqj#xqghuo|lqj# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## lqgxvwuldo## hfrqrp|ᄇwkh## ilqdqfldo## fodlpv/## wkh## wudqvdfwlrqv/## wkh## lqfhqwlyh# vwuxfwxuhv/#wkh#ilupv/#wkh#edqnv/#wkh#pdunhwv/#wkh#uhjxodwlrqv/#dqg#vr#rq1#Vr#orqj#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh## phfkdqlvpv## zrunhg## zhoo/## wkh## prghov## zhuh## d## xvhixo## vlpsolilfdwlrq1## Dqg# gxulqj#pxfk#ri#wkh# # # # # ᄈJuhdw#Prghudwlrqᄡ# # # wkdw#Ehuqdqnh# # # uhihuuhg## wr/## wkh## soxpelqj# zrunhg#zhoo#dqg#vhuyhg#dv#d#jrrg#edvlv#iru#devwudfw#uhdvrqlqj1# # # # # # # # # # # Exw## dv## vrrq## dv## wkh## soxpelqj## eurnh## grzq/## wkh## prghov## zhuh## dq# ryhuvlpsolilfdwlrq1## Lqghhg/## wkh## prghov## wkhpvhoyhv## pd|## kdyh## kdvwhqhg## wkh# soxpelqjᄊv#euhdngrzq=#zlwk#wkh#Ihg#irfxvhg#rq#zkdw#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#zrxog#gr#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # rxwsxw## udwkhu## wkdq## wr## ilqdqfldo## ulvn## wdnlqj## +ihz## prghov## kdg## d## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru# hpehgghg#lq#wkhp/#ohw#dorqh#edqnv,/#ilqdqfldo#ulvn#wdnlqj#zhqw#xqfkhfnhg1# # # # # # # # # # # Lq#d#kdxqwlqj#sdudooho#wr#Urehuw#Oxfdvᄊv#idprxv#fulwltxh#ri#Nh|qhvldq#prghov/# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#zklfk#kh# # # # dujxhg#wkdw#wkrvh# # # # prghov## zrxog#euhdn#grzq#ehfdxvh# # # # # prghohuv## glg# qrw#dffrxqw#iru#krz#wkh#hfrqrp|#zrxog#uhdfw#wr#srolflhv#wkdw#dwwhpswhg#wr#h{sorlw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sdvw#fruuhodwlrqv#lq#wkh#gdwd/#prgholqj#wkdw#wrrn#wkh#soxpelqj#iru#judqwhg#hqvxuhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#euhdngrzq#ri#wkh#soxpelqj1#Lq#frplqj#|hduv/#pdfurhfrqrplf#prgholqj#pxvw# # # # # # # # # # # lqfrusrudwh## pruh## ri## wkh## soxpelqj/## zklfk## kdv## ehhq## vwxglhg## hovhzkhuh## lq# hfrqrplfv1# Wkh## gdqjhu## lv## wkdw## prqhwdu|## hfrqrplvwv## zloo## wu|## wr## zlvk## dzd|## wkh## olqnv# ehwzhhq## prqhwdu|## srolf|/## ulvn## wdnlqj/## dqg## dvvhw0sulfh## exeeohv1## Ehuqdqnh## fdph# forvh## wr## grlqj## vr## lq## klv## 5343## vshhfk## wr## wkh## Dphulfdq## Hfrqrplf## Dvvrfldwlrq/# zkhuh#kh#dujxhg#wkdw#lw#zdv#qrw#wkh#Ihgᄊv#ghihfwlyh#prqhwdu|#srolf|ᄇzklfk#kh# # # # # # # # # # # # # frqvlghuhg## hqwluho|## dssursuldwh/## jlyhq## wkh## Ihgᄊv## ylhzv## rq## lqiodwlrqᄇexw## lwv# lqdghtxdwh## vxshuylvlrq#wkdw# # # khoshg## wuljjhu## wkh## fulvlv1## Kh## frqfoxghg=## ᄈDowkrxjk# wkh## prvw#udslg# # # sulfh## lqfuhdvhv## rffxuuhg## zkhq#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # # zhuh## dw# wkhlu## orzhvw## ohyhov/## wkh## pdjqlwxgh## ri## krxvh## sulfh## jdlqv## vhhpv## wrr## odujh## wr## eh# uhdglo|## h{sodlqhg## e|## wkh## vwdqfh## ri## prqhwdu|## srolf|## dorqh1## Pruhryhu/## furvv0 frxqwu|#hylghqfh#vkrzv#qr#vljqlilfdqw#uhodwlrqvkls#ehwzhhq#prqhwdu|#srolf|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # 53# wkh#sdfh#ri#krxvh#sulfh#lqfuhdvhv1ᄡ # # # # #
Ri#frxuvh/# # # qr## rqh## fodlpv## wkdw#wkh# # # Ihg## dorqh## zdv## uhvsrqvleoh## iru## wkh## krxvlqj# ghedfoh1#Jryhuqphqw#srolflhv#idyrulqj#orz0lqfrph#krxvlqj/#dv#zhoo#dv#sulydwh0 # # # # # # # # # vhfwru## plvwdnhv/## frqwulexwhg## vljqlilfdqwo|1## Exw## wr## vxjjhvw## wkdw## lw## kdg## qr## uroh## lv# glvlqjhqxrxv1#Lqghhg/#d#ghwdlohg#vwxg|#sxeolvkhg#lq#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # Vw1#Orxlv#Uhylhz#lq#533;#suhvhqwv#hylghqfh#wkdw#ᄈprqhwdu|#srolf|#kdv#vljqlilfdqw# # # # # # # # # # # # hiihfwv## rq## krxvlqj## lqyhvwphqw## dqg## krxvh## sulfhv## dqg## wkdw## hdv|## prqhwdu|## srolf|# ghvljqhg## wr## vwdyh## rii## wkh## shufhlyhg## ulvnv## ri## ghiodwlrq## lq## 5335ᄆ5337## kdv# 54# frqwulexwhg#wr#d#errp#lq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw#lq#5337#dqg#53381ᄡ # # # # # # # # # # # Pruhryhu/#wkhuh#lv#qr#uhdvrq#zk|#wkhuh#vkrxog#eh#d#vwulfw#uhodwlrqvkls#dfurvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## ehwzhhq#prqhwdu|#srolf|#dqg#wkh#udwh#ri#krxvh0sulfh#jurzwk#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # dq|# frpprq#shulrg# # # ri#wlph=# # # wkh## udwh## ri#sulfh# # # jurzwk#pljkw#ghshqg# # # # rq#d# # # ydulhw|#ri# # idfwruv#wkdw#duh#vshflilf#wr#hdfk#frxqwu|/#lqfoxglqj#krz#kljk#krxvh#sulfhv#douhdg|# # # # # # # # # # # # # 55# duh1 # Wkh## eurdghu## srlqw#lv# # # wkdw#prqhwdu|#hfrqrplvwv# # # # qhhg## wr## wdnh## qrwh## +dv## wkh|# duh#qrz# # # grlqj,#ri#wkh#rwkhu#fkdqqhov#wkurxjk#zklfk#prqhwdu|#srolf|#pljkw#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # hiihfwv1#
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Dv## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## fxw## edfn## rq## ghpdqg## iroorzlqj## wkhlu## fulvhv## lq## wkh# 4<<3v/#dqg#dv#lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|#frusrudwlrqv#zrunhg#rii#wkhlu#h{fhvv#lqyhvwphqw# # # # # # # # # # iroorzlqj## wkh## grw0frp## exvw/## wkh## zruogᄊv## h{sruwhuv## vhdufkhg## rqfh## djdlq## iru# frxqwulhv#wkdw#zrxog#uholdeo|#vshqg#pruh#wkdq#wkh|#surgxfhg1#Wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/# # # # # # # # # # # # zklfk#zdv#douhdg|#sxvklqj#wr#hqfrxudjh#krxvhkrog#frqvxpswlrq#wr#dsshdvh#wkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # ohiw## ehklqg## e|## jurzwk/## kdg## dgghg## uhdvrqv## wr## lqixvh## vxevwdqwldo## ilvfdo## dqg# prqhwdu|#vwlpxoxv#lq#uhvsrqvh#wr#wkh#grzqwxuq=#wkh#mreohvv#qdwxuh#ri#wkh#uhfryhu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh## zhdn## X1V1## vdihw|## qhw1## Lq## dgglwlrq## wr## d## vxevwdqwldo## ilvfdo## vwlpxoxv## wkdw# sxvkhg## d## jryhuqphqw## exgjhw## wkdw## zdv## whpsrudulo|## lq## vxusoxv## lqwr## odujh## ilvfdo# ghilflwv/## wkh## Ihg## nhsw## lwv## irrw## suhvvhg## rq#wkh# # # prqhwdu|#dffhohudwru/# # # hyhq#zkloh# # jlylqj#doo# # # vruwv## ri#dvvxudqfhv# # # wr#wkh#pdunhwv# # # # rq#lwv# # # zloolqjqhvv## wr#pdlqwdlq#hdv|# # # prqhwdu|## frqglwlrqv## dqg## wr## vwhs## lq## wr## surylgh## oltxlglw|## lq## fdvh## wkh## ilqdqfldo# pdunhwv## kdg#sureohpv1#Wkhvh#dvvxudqfhv# # # # # kdg#wkh#ghvluhg#hiihfw#ri#ohdglqj#wr#dq# # # # # # # # h{sorvlrq#ri#ohqglqj/#zklfk#xqiruwxqdwho|#frqwlqxhg#h{sdqglqj#dqg#ghwhulrudwlqj# # # # # # # # # lq## txdolw|## hyhq## diwhu## wkh## Ihg## vwduwhg## wljkwhqlqj1## Iru## dq## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## zkloh/# wkrxjk/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#surylghg#wkh#ghpdqg#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog#qhhghg1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## X1V1## srolwlfdo## v|vwhp#lv# # # dfxwho|## vhqvlwlyh## wr## mre## jurzwk## ehfdxvh## ri## wkh# hfrqrp|ᄊv#zhdn#vdihw|#qhwv1#Wkh#vkruw#gxudwlrq#ri#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## dv## zhoo## dv## wkh## vxevwdqwldoo|#kljkhu# # # frvwv## ri#khdowk#fduh# # # # iru## wkrvh# zkr#gr#qrw#kdyh#mrev/#zhuh#qrw#h{fhvvlyho|#sdlqixo#zkhq#uhfhvvlrqv#zhuh#vkruw=# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#jdyh# # # odlg0rii## zrunhuv## vwurqj#lqfhqwlyhv# # # wr## ilqg## qhz## mrev## hyhq#zkloh# # # X1V1# exvlqhvvhv#fuhdwhg#wkhp1#Exw#li#uhfhvvlrqv#duh#olnho|#wr#eh#pruh#surorqjhg#wkdq#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#sdvw/#wkh#v|vwhp#kdv#wr#fkdqjh/#li#rqo|#ehfdxvh#wkh#rog#vrfldo#frqwudfwᄇvkruw0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # gxudwlrq#ehqhilwv#lq#uhwxuq#iru#vkruw#uhfhvvlrqvᄇlv#euhdnlqj#grzq1# # # # # # # # # Rqh## uhdvrq#lv# # # vlpso|#prudo1#Qr#prghuq#hfrqrp|#vkrxog#irufh# # # # # # # # zrunhuv## zkr# orvh#wkhlu#mrev#wr#pdnh#vxfk#sdlqixo#ghflvlrqv#dv#fkrrvlqj#zklfk#ri#wkhlu#fkloguhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## surwhfw#zlwk#phglfdo# # # # lqvxudqfh1## Qrw#rqo|#lv# # # # wklv## vlwxdwlrq#eduedulf/# # # lw#lv# # # dovr# xqvxvwdlqdeoh/## iru## wkrvh## zkr## orvh## rxw#hfrqrplfdoo|#kdyh# # # # hyhu|#lqfhqwlyh# # # wr## xvh# srolwlfdo## phdqv## wr## uhjdlq## zkdw## wkh|## kdyh## orvw1## Zkloh## d## ghprfudwlf## v|vwhp# hyhqwxdoo|## uhvsrqgv/## wkh## uhvsrqvh## fdq## eh## xqsuhglfwdeoh/## dgglqj## wr## zrunhu# xqfhuwdlqw|1## Wkhuh## lv## d## vwurqj#fdvh# # # iru## vwuhqjwkhqlqj#wkh# # # X1V1## vdihw|#qhw#lq#zd|v# # # # wkdw#zloo#qrw#kdpshu#wkh#ioh{lelolw|#ri#wkh#hfrqrp|#juhdwo|1# # # # # # # # # # Dqrwkhu## sureohp## zlwk## d## zhdn## vdihw|## qhw## lv## wkdw## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## whqgv## wr# ryhuuhdfw/## dqg## rwkhu## qdwlrqv## xqghuuhdfw/## wr## grzqwxuqv1## Ehfdxvh## hyhu|## frxqwu|# nqrzv## wkdw## wkh## srolwlfdoo|## yxoqhudeoh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## wr## uhvsrqg## zlwk# h{sdqvlrqdu|#srolflhv#dqg#wkdw#vrph#X1V1#ghpdqg#zloo#vsloo#ryhu#wr#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zruog/#wkhlu#lqfhqwlyh#wr#fkdqjh#wkh#vwuxfwxuh#ri#wkhlu#hfrqrp|/#ru#wkhlu#srolflhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#grzqwxuqv/#lv#frpphqvxudwho|#ohvv1# # # # # Exw#shukdsv#wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw#sureohp#lv#wkdw#wkh#dg#krf#srolflhv#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv#lv#irufhg#lqwr#gr#hqruprxv#gdpdjh#wr#wkh#orqj0whup#khdowk#ri#wkh#hfrqrp|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # erwk#gluhfwo|#dqg# # # # wkurxjk#wkhlu# # # hiihfwv## rq#wkh# # # ilqdqfldo## vhfwru1## Rqh## frxog## dujxh# wkdw#glvfuhwlrqdu|#ilvfdo#dqg#prqhwdu|#srolf|#lq#wkh#plgvw#ri#d#grzqwxuq#jlyhv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#wkh#delolw|#wr#fdoleudwh#lwv#uhvsrqvh#wr#wkh#vhyhulw|#ri#wkh#grzqwxuq1# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
Exw#ilvfdo#srolf|#xqghuwdnhq#dw#wkh#srlqw#ri#d#jxq#lv#uduho|#dv#glvsdvvlrqdwh#ru#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhoo## wkrxjkw## rxw## dv## rqh## pljkw## olnh1## \hv/## Frqjuhvv## frxog## vlpso|## h{whqg# xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv/## dv## lw## kdv## grqh## lq#wkh# # # fxuuhqw## uhfhvvlrq1## Exw## srolwlfldqv# riwhq#zdqw#wr#gr#pruh1#Dqg#wkh#sxeolfᄊv# # # # # # # # # dq{lhw|#jlyhv# # # wkhp#wkh#olfhqvh#wr#eulqj# # # # # rxw#doo# # # wkhlu## shw#surmhfwv/#doo# # # # wkh#idyruv#wr#vshfldo# # # # # lqwhuhvwv/#dqg#doo# # # # wkh#vfkhphv# # wkhlu#lghrorjlfdo#ohdqlqjv#dqg#srolwlfdo#frqqhfwlrqv#suhglvsrvh#wkhp#wr1# # # # # # # # # Vlploduo|/## dv## zh## kdyh## vhhq/## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh/## wkrxjk## rvwhqvleo|# lqghshqghqw/## kdv## d## yhu|#gliilfxow# # # wdvn1## Lw## lv## h{wuhpho|#kdug# # # wr## hqvxuh## udslg## mre# jurzwk## lq## dq## lqwhjudwhg/## lqqrydwlyh## hfrqrp|## zkhuh## ilupv## xvh## uhfhvvlrqv## wr# uhirfxv#rq#ehfrplqj#pruh#surgxfwlyh#ru#wr#vwuhqjwkhq#wkhlu#joredo#vxsso|#fkdlqv/# # # # # # # # # # # # vkliwlqj## mrev## hovhzkhuh1## Pruhryhu/## wkh## qhz## whfkqrorjlhv## hpsor|hg## lq## klulqj# doorz## ilupv## wkh## ox{xu|#ri#zdlwlqj#wr#iloo# # # # # # srvlwlrqv1#Wkh# # # vxvwdlqhg#hdv|#prqhwdu|# # # srolf|#wkdw#lv# # # # pdlqwdlqhg#zkloh#mrev# # # # duh#vwloo# # # vfdufh#kdv# # # wkh#hiihfw#ri#lqfuhdvlqj# # # # ulvn#wdnlqj#dqg#lqiodwlqj#dvvhw0sulfh#exeeohv/#zklfk#djdlq#zhdnhq#wkh#ideulf#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # hfrqrp|#ryhu#wkh#orqjhu#whup1#Li#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#fdqqrw#wrohudwh#orqjhu#erxwv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqhpsor|phqw/## exw## wkrvh## erxwv## duh## khuh## wr## vwd|/## zh## ulvn## jrlqj## iurp#exeeoh# # # wr# exeeoh#dv#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#lv#suhvvxuhg#wr#gr#wkh#lpsrvvleoh#dqg#fuhdwh#mrev# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkhuh#qrqh#duh#iruwkfrplqj1# # # # Lw#lv# # # qrz## wlph#wr#wxuq#wr#yxoqhudelolwlhv# # # # # # lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # # vhfwru## wr#vhh#zk|#wkh# # # # idxow#olqhv# # # fdph## wrjhwkhu## wr## pdnh## edqnv## wdnh## wkh## ulvnv## wkh|#glg1# # # L#irfxv# # # rq#wzr# # lvvxhv1## Iluvw/## zk|#glg# # # pruwjdjh## ohqglqj#jr# # # ehuvhun#+zklfk#lv# # # # wkh## vxemhfw#ri#wkh# # # qh{w#fkdswhu,B#Vhfrqg/#zk|#glg#wkh#edqnv#wdnh#rq#vr#pxfk#ghidxow#dqg#oltxlglw|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#+zklfk#lv#wkh#vxemhfw#ri#Fkdswhu#:,B# # # # # # # #
FKDSWHU#VL[ #
Zkhq#Prqh|#Lv#wkh#Phdvxuh#ri#Doo#Zruwk # # # # # # # #
ZKHQ## WKH## IUHQFK## PRQDUFK\## zdv## vwudsshg## iru## prqh|## lq## wkh## hljkwhhqwk#
4## Rqh#ri#wkhvh#zdv# fhqwxu|/#lw#irxqg#pruh#dqg#pruh#fuhdwlyh#zd|v#wr#udlvh#ixqgv1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#vhoo# # # dqqxlwlhvᄇjryhuqphqw#erqgv#wkdw#sdlg#rxw#d#il{hg#dprxqw#xqwlo# # # # # # # # # # wkh#ghdwk# # ri#wkh#shuvrq#rq#zkrp#wkh#dqqxlw|#zdv#zulwwhq1#Dqqxlwlhv#zhuh#yhu|#srsxodu#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## sxeolf/## iru## wkh|#riihuhg# # # ehqhilfldulhv## d## jxdudqwhhg## lqfrph## iru## olih## lq#d# # # wlph# ehiruh## wkhuh## zhuh## rog0djh## shqvlrqv1## Wkh## prqdufk|## olnhg## wkhp## ehfdxvh## lw# uhfhlyhg#sd|phqw#xs#iurqw1# # # #
Wkh#prqdufk|#wdujhwhg#wkhvh#dqqxlwlhv#dw#zhdowk|#phqᄇw|slfdoo|#lq#wkhlu#hduo|# # # # # # # # # # # iliwlhvᄇzkr## kdg## wkh## phdqv## wr## ex|## dq## dqqxlw|## dqg## zkr/## jlyhq## orz## olih# h{shfwdqflhv#dw#wkdw#wlph/#w|slfdoo|#glg#qrw#kdyh#yhu|#orqj#wr#olyh1#Dqqxlwlhv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sulfhg#vr#wkdw#wkh|#zhuh#d#idlu#ghdo#iru#vxfk#phq1#Krzhyhu/#lw#zdv#srvvleoh#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ex|hu#ri#wkh#dqqxlw|#wr#pdnh#wkh#sd|phqwv#ghshqghqw#qrw#rq#klv#rzq#olih#vsdq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # exw## rq## wkdw## ri## vrphrqh## hovh1## Shukdsv## wklv## orrskroh## zdv## qrw## lqdgyhuwhqw/## iru## lw# lqfuhdvhg## ghpdqg## iru## wkh## dqqxlwlhv=## iru## h{dpsoh/## lw## pljkw## kdyh## pdgh## dqqxlwlhv# dwwudfwlyh#wr#d#zhdowk|#phufkdqw#zkr#zdqwhg#wr#vhwwoh#klv#gdxjkwhuv#iru#olih1#Exw#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # glg#phdq#wkdw#wkh#fohyhu#lqyhvwru#frxog#pdnh#prqh|#rii#wkh#jryhuqphqw1#Kh#frxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # slfn#dv#ehqhilfldulhv#khdowk|#|rxqj#jluov#+wkhq#dv#qrz/#zrphq#olyhg#orqjhu#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # phq,## zkrvh## idplo|#klvwru|#vxjjhvwhg# # # # d## jhqhwlf## suhglvsrvlwlrq#wr# # # orqj#olih/# # # dqg# zkr#kdg#vxuylyhg#hduo|#fklogkrrg#+lqidqw#pruwdolw|#zdv#yhu|#kljk#lq#wkrvh#wlphv,# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv#zhoo#dv#wkh#guhdghg#vpdoosr{1#Kh#frxog#wkhq#ex|#dqqxlwlhv#rq#wkhlu#olyhv#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Iuhqfk## jryhuqphqw1## D## fduhixoo|## vhohfwhg/## khdowk|## whq0|hdu0rog## jluo## zrxog# kdyh#pxfk#kljkhu#rggv#ri#vxuylylqj#iru#d#orqj#wlph#wkdq#wkh#w|slfdo#ehqhilfldu|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#dqqxlw|/#dqg#wkh#sd|phqwv#uhfhlyhg#gxulqj#khu# # # # # # # # # olihwlph#zrxog#idu# # # # h{fhhg#wkh# # frvw#ri#wkh#dqqxlw|1# # # # Wklv#lv#lqghhg#zkdw#d#jurxs#ri#Jhqhyd#edqnhuv# # # # # # # # # # glg1#Wkh|#vhohfwhg#jurxsv# # # # # ri# wkluw|## vxlwdeoh## jluov## lq## Jhqhyd## dqg## sxufkdvhg## d## olih## dqqxlw|## rq## hdfk## iurp## wkh# Iuhqfk#jryhuqphqw1#Wkh|#wkhq#srrohg#wkh#dqqxlwlhv#vr#dv#wr#glyhuvli|#wkh#ulvn#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dfflghqwdo## hduo|#pruwdolw|#dprqj#wkh#jluov# # # # # # dqg#vrog#fodlpv# # # # rq#wkh#uhvxowlqj#fdvk# # # # lqiorzv## wr## ihoorz## flwl}hqv## ri## Jhqhyd1## Wklv## hduo|## irup## ri## vhfxulwl}dwlrq## wkxv# doorzhg#wkh#edqnhuv#wr#fuhdwh#d#yluwxdo#prqh|#pdfklqh/#ex|lqj#srolflhv#fkhdso|# # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#wkh# # # Iuhqfk#jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # # uhvhoolqj#wkhp#iru# # # # d## kljkhu## sulfh## wr## lqyhvwruv1# Wkh## lqyhvwphqwv## zhuh## srsxoduᄇhvshfldoo|#ehfdxvh# # # wkh## edqnhuv## zhuh## uhsxwdeoh# dqg#wkh#xqghuo|lqj#dqqxlwlhv#zhuh#fodlpv#rq#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄇdqg#vrog#zhoo1# # # # # # # # # # # Krzhyhu/#ex|huv#kdg#qrw#uhfnrqhg#zlwk#wkh#ulvn#ri#jryhuqphqw#ghidxow1#Zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Iuhqfk#Uhyroxwlrq#eurnh#rxw#lq#4:;</#wkh#prqdufk|#zdv#ryhuwkurzq/#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhyroxwlrqdu|#jryhuqphqw#vrrq#ihoo# # # # # ehklqg#lq#lwv# # # # dqqxlw|#sd|phqwv1#Lw#hyhqwxdoo|# # # # pdgh#sd|phqwv#lq#zruwkohvv#fxuuhqf|1#Wkh#Jhqhyd#edqnhuv/#zkr#rzhg#lqyhvwruv# # # # # # # # # # # lq## kdughu## Vzlvv## fxuuhqf|/## glg## qrw## kdyh## wkh## zkhuhzlwkdo## wr## sd|/## dqg## wkh|# ghidxowhg/#dv#lq#wxuq#glg#pdq|#ri#wkh#lqyhvwruv#zkr#kdg#eruurzhg#wr#lqyhvw#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄈvxuhᄡ#wklqj1# #
Wkhuh#duh#irxu#lpsruwdqw#dqg#hqgxulqj#ohvvrqv#iurp#wklv#klvwrulfdo#plql0fulvlv1# # # # # # # # # # # Iluvw/#ihz#kdyh#d#ehwwhu#qrvh#iru#d#jrrg#prqh|pdnlqj#rssruwxqlw|#wkdq#edqnhuv1#Lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#qrw#wkdw#edqnhuv#duh#h{fhvvlyho|#juhhg|1#Hyhq#wkrxjk#Dgdp#Vplwk#glg#sxw#vhoi0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuhvw#dw#wkh#khduw#ri#fdslwdolvp#zkhq#kh#zurwh/#ᄈLw#lv#qrw#iurp#wkh#ehqhyrohqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#exwfkhu/#wkh#euhzhu/#ru#wkh#ednhu#wkdw#zh#h{shfw#rxu#glqqhu/#exw#iurp#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhjdug#wr#wkhlu#rzq#lqwhuhvw/ᄡ#ihz#exvlqhvvshrsoh#duh#hqwluho|#zlwkrxw#frqfhuq#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # 5# wkh## lpsdfw## ri## wkhlu## dfwlylwlhv## rq## wkhlu## vrflhwlhv1 # Udwkhu/## wkhlu## zloolqjqhvv## wr# h{sorlw## dq|#dgydqwdjh# # # wkdw## zloo## khos## wkhp#pdnh# # # prqh|/## krzhyhu## grgj|#+doehlw# # ohjdo,#lw#pd|#eh/#vwhpv#sduwo|#iurp#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#frpshwlwlyh#edqnlqj/#zkhuh#wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh## ihz## hdv|## rssruwxqlwlhv## wr## pdnh## prqh|/## dqg## sduwo|## iurp## wkh## zd|## edqnhu# shuirupdqfh## lv## phdvxuhgᄇdoprvw## h{foxvlyho|## e|## krz## pxfk## prqh|## wkh## edqnhu# pdnhv#udwkhu#wkdq#e|#khu#lpsdfw#rq#uhdo#dfwlylw|1#Wkh#glvfrqqhfw#ehwzhhq#edqnlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## uhdo## olyhv## dqg## olyholkrrgv## lv## prvw## dssduhqw## lq## wkh## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## ilqdqfldo# v|vwhpv#wkdw#duh#irxqg#lq#frxqwulhv#olnh#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#dqg#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # D## vhfrqg## ohvvrq## lv## wkdw## edqnhuv## lqyduldeo|## ilqg## wkh## eljjhvw## hgjh## lq## wdnlqj# dgydqwdjh## ri## xqvrsklvwlfdwhg## sod|huv## ru## sod|huv## zkr## gr## qrw## kdyh## wkh## vdph# lqfhqwlyh#wr#pdnh#prqh|1#Fohduo|/#lqglylgxdov#zkr#duh#xqvfkrrohg#lq#ilqdqfh#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # d## srwhqwldo## wdujhw/## exw## riwhq## wkhvh## lqglylgxdov## uhdol}h## wkhlu## ljqrudqfh## dqg## jlyh# wkhlu## fxvwrp#rqo|# # # wr## wuxvwhg## lqwhuphgldulhv1## Pruhryhu/## wkh|## w|slfdoo|## kdyh## wrr# olwwoh#prqh|#wr#eh#ri#lqwhuhvw#wr#wkh#vpduwhvw#edqnhuv1#Pruh#dwwudfwlyh#wdujhwv#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#prghudwho|#vfkrrohg#pdqdjhuv#ri#odujh#srrov#ri#ixqgv/#vxfk#dv#shqvlrq#ixqgv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ru## iruhljq## vwdwh0rzqhg## ixqgv/## zkr## nqrz## qrw## wkdw## wkh|## nqrz## qrw## dqg## duh## wkxv# hdvlo|## wdnhq## dgydqwdjh## ri1## Exw## shukdsv## wkh## prvw## dwwudfwlyh## wdujhw## ri## doo## lv## wkh# jryhuqphqw#lwvhoi1#Wkh# # # # jryhuqphqw#kdv# # # qrqpdunhw/#qrqhfrqrplf#remhfwlyhv/#dqg# # # # krzhyhu## dvwxwh## lwv## uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv## pd|## eh/## wkhvh## pdnh## lw## hdv|## suh|## iru## fohyhu# edqnhuv1#Pruhryhu/#zkhuhdv#d#qdlyh#lqglylgxdo#lv#vrrq#uholhyhg#ri#doo#klv#prqh|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## jryhuqphqw## kdv## ghhs## srfnhwv/## dqg## h{sorlwlqj## wkhp## fdq## vxvwdlq## pdq|## d# edqnhu#ᄊv#ox{xulrxv#olihvw|oh#iru#d#orqj#wlph1# # # # # # # Wklug/#edqnhu#ehkdylru#whqgv#wr#eh#vhoi0uhlqiruflqj/#dw#ohdvw#iru#d#zkloh1#Lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{dpsoh## ri#wkh# # # dqqxlwlhv/## dv## wkh## surilwv## iurp#wkh# # # iluvw#lqvxudqfh# # # vfkhph## ehfrph# dssduhqw/## wkh|#qrw#rqo|#dwwudfw#pruh# # # # # # edqnhuv## wr## wkh## dfwlylw|#exw#dovr# # # # sxvk#xs# # # wkh# sulfhv#ri#wkh#vhfxulwlhv#lvvxhg#e|#wkh#iluvw#vfkhph/#vhqglqj#d#vwloo#vwurqjhu#vljqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#edqnhuv1#Vlploduo|/#dv#lqlwldo#krxvlqj#ordqv#vwduw#wr#orrn#surilwdeoh/#pruh#edqnv# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{whqg## ordqv/## wkhuhe|#sxvklqj#xs# # # # krxvh## sulfhv## dqg## pdnlqj#wkh# # # lqlwldo## ordq#orrn# # hyhq## pruh## vrolg1## Wklv## ehkdylru## fdq## h{djjhudwh## lqyhvwphqw## wuhqgv## dqg## pryh# sulfhv#idu#dzd|#iurp#ixqgdphqwdov1#Hduo|#pryhuv#pd|#frqylqfh#wkhpvhoyhv#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # duh## jhqlxvhv/## hyhq## wkrxjk## wkh|## duh## rqo|## wkh## ohdghuv## ri## d## khug## wkdw## lv## udslgo|# khdghg## wrzdug## d## folii1## Exw## wkh## jurzwk#ri# # # wkh## khug## lwvhoi## fdq#pdnh# # # zkdw## zrxog# kdyh## ehhq#d# # # plqru## orvv## e|#vrph# # # dgyhqwxurxv## edqnhuv## dqg## wkhlu## lqyhvwruv## lqwr## d# pxfk#pruh#vhulrxv#orvv#iru#wkh#frppxqlw|1# # # # # # # Ilqdoo|/#wkhuh#lv#vdihw|#lq#qxpehuv/#ehfdxvh#wkh#uhvsrqvleoh#jryhuqphqw#fdqqrw# # # # # # # # # # # ohw#doo#lwv#edqnhuv#idlo/#jlyhq#wkh#olnho|#froodwhudo#gdpdjh#wr#wkh#flwl}hqu|1#Vr#hyhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## uhyroxwlrqdu|#jryhuqphqw# # # lq#Iudqfh# # # frqwlqxhg## sd|lqj#wkh# # # kdwhg## prqdufk|ᄊv# ghewv#iru#dv#orqj#dv#lw#zdv#deoh1#Wklv#lv#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|#wr#lpso|#wkdw#edqnhuv#vwduw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw#zlwk#wkh#h{shfwdwlrq#wkdw#wkh|#zloo#idlo#dqg#eh#edlohg#rxw=#edqnhuv#xqghuvwdqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#idloxuh#lv#qhyhu#sohdvdqw/#krzhyhu#irujlylqj#wkh#jryhuqphqw1#Lw#pd|#zhoo#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh#wkrxjkw#ri#d#edlorxw#uhdoo|#grhv#qrw#furvv#wkhlu#plqgv1#Udwkhu/#wkh#sureohp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
fuhdwhg#e|#wkh#dqwlflsdwlrq#ri#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#lv#wkdw#wkh#edqnhuv/#fdxjkw# # # # # # # # # # # # xs## lq## wkh## khugᄊv## frpshwlwlyh## iuhq}|## wr## fdvk## lq## rq## wkh## vhhplqjo|## oxfudwlyh# rssruwxqlw|/## duh## qrw#vorzhg# # # e|#pruh# # # glvsdvvlrqdwh## pdunhw#irufhvᄇzkdw#L#kdyh# # # # uhihuuhg#wr#dv#wkh#xqlqwhqwlrqdo#jxlgdqfh#ri#wkh#nh|#dfwruvᄊ#dfwlrqv#e|#pdunhwv#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # yrwhuv1#Lq#vxfk#d#vlwxdwlrq/#ohqghuv#wr#edqnv#gr#qrw#ghpdqg#surshu#frpshqvdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # iru#wkh#ulvnv#wkh#edqnhu#wdnhv/#ehfdxvh#wkh|#nqrz#wkh#eorz#zloo#eh#vriwhqhg#e|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqwᄇdqg## lq## ehkdylqj## wkxv/## ohqghuv## idflolwdwh## ulvn## wdnlqj## dqg## khug# ehkdylru1## Wkh## qrupdo## glvflsolqdu|## uroh## ri## pdunhwv## +zklfk## wkhpvhoyhv## pd|# vrphwlphv## eh## fdxjkw## xs## lq## wkh## iuhq}|,## lv## gxoohg## e|## uhshdwhg## jryhuqphqw# lqwhuyhqwlrq1# L#gudz# # # prghuq#sdudoohov# # # lq#wklv# # # fkdswhu## dqg## wkh## qh{w1## Wkh## vrsklvwlfdwhg## X1V1# ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## uhvsrqghg## wr## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## ghvluh## wr## surprwh## orz0lqfrph# krxvlqj/#dv#zhoo#dv#wr#iruhljq#ghpdqg#iru#kljko|#udwhg#ghew#vhfxulwlhv1#Wkh#hgjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # vhfwru## h{sorlwhg#zdv#wkh#xqwklqnlqj/#doprvw#exuhdxfudwlf/#zd|#erwk# # # # # # # # wkh## pruwjdjh## djhqflhv## dqg## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## hydoxdwhg## wkh## lvvxhg## vhfxulwlhv1# Pdunhw#glvflsolqh#eurnh#grzq#dv# # # # # # pruwjdjh#eurnhuv# # # irxqg#wkh|#frxog#shggoh#doo# # # # # vruwv## ri#mxqn/#hvshfldoo|#ehfdxvh# # # # # wkh## ghwhulrudwlrq#lq#fuhglw#txdolw|#zdv# # # # # # pdvnhg# e|## wkh## lpphqvh## dprxqw## ri## prqh|## srxulqj## lqwr## wkh## vhfwru1## Zkhq## wkh## fudvk# hyhqwxdoo|#fdph/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dqg#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh/#xqdeoh#wr#vwdqg#e|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhh## krphrzqhuv## vxiihu/## vwhsshg## lq## wr## surs## xs## wkh## sulfh## ri## krphv## dqg## ri# pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv/#ydolgdwlqj#pxfk#ri#wkh#h{wudruglqdu|#lqvrxfldqfh#ri# # # # # # # # # wkh#pdunhw1# # Lq#wklv#fkdswhu/#L#h{sodlq#zk|#wkh#idxow#olqhv#zh#kdyh#h{dplqhg#hduolhu/#dfwlqj# # # ## # # # # # # # # # rq#dq#dprudo#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#zlwk#d#ilqho|#krqhg#h|h#iru#rssruwxqlw|/#frpelqhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## fdxvh## d## vwhdg|#ghwhulrudwlrq#lq#wkh# # # # # txdolw|#ri#pruwjdjh# # # # ohqglqj1## Lq#wkh# # # qh{w/## L# h{sodlq## zk|## edqnv## khog## rq## wr## vr## pdq|## ri## wkh## ulvn|## dvvhw0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## rq# wkhlu#rzq#edodqfh#vkhhwv1# # # #
Shfxqld#Qrq#Rohw # # # Prvw## ri#xv# # # gr## qrw## zrun#iru# # # prqh|#dorqh1# # # Vrph## zdqw## wr## fkdqjh## wkh## zruog/# rwkhuv## wr## fuhdwh## remhfwv## ri#duw#dqg# # # # fxowxuh## wkdw#zloo# # # hqgxuh1## Vrph## vwulyh## wr## jdlq# idph/#zkloh#rwkhuv#duh#frqwhqw#wr#gr#jrrg#dqrq|prxvo|1#Iru#pdq|#shrsoh/#wkrxjk/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ylvleoh## hiihfwv## ri## rqhᄊv## zrun## duh## lwv## juhdwhvw## uhzdug1## Iru## wkh## whdfkhu/# zlwqhvvlqj#wkh#hxuhnd#prphqw#zkhq#xqghuvwdqglqj#ilqdoo|#gdzqv#rq#d#vwxghqw>#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#grfwru/#wkh#lqfuhgleoh#mr|#ri#vdylqj#d#sdwlhqwᄊv#olih>#iru#wkh#iduphu/#wkh#vljkw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dfuhv## dqg## dfuhv## ri#jroghq#zkhdw#vzd|lqj#jhqwo|#zlwk#wkh# # # # # # # # euhh}hᄇiru## doo## wkhvh# shrsoh/## wkhlu## sulpdu|## prwlydwlrq## lv## wkh## nqrzohgjh## wkdw## wkhlu## zrun## pdnhv## wkh# zruog#d#ehwwhu#sodfh1# # # # D## vlpsoh## h{shulphqw## grqh## e|## uhvhdufkhuv## dw## PLW## dqg## wkh## Xqlyhuvlw|## ri# Fklfdjr## yhulilhv## wkh## lpsruwdqfh## ri## odujhu## phdqlqj## wr## prwlydwlrq## dqg## zrun1# Kduydug#vwxghqwv/#wkh#vxemhfwv#lq#wkh#h{shulphqw/#zhuh#dvnhg#wr#sxw#wrjhwkhu#Ohjr# # # # # # # # # # # # # Elrqlfoh## prghov## +vpdoo## vqds0wrjhwkhu## prghov,## iurp## nlwv## wkh|## zhuh## jlyhq## +wkh# PLW## uhvhdufkhuv## suredeo|## wkrxjkw## wklv## zrxog## eh## d## uhdo## fkdoohqjh## iru## Kduydug# vwxghqwv$,1#Vxemhfwv#zhuh#sdlg#dw#d#ghfolqlqj#udwh#iru#hdfk#dgglwlrqdo#prgho#exlow/# # # # # # # # # # # # # vr## wkdw## hyhqwxdoo|## wkh|## zrxog## vwrs## ehfdxvh## wkh## hiiruw## lqyroyhg## lq## exloglqj## dq# dgglwlrqdo## prgho## zdv#qrw#zruwk#wkh#sd|1#Lq#rqh#yhuvlrq#ri#wkh#h{shulphqw/#hdfk# # # # # # # # # # # # frpsohwhg## prgho## zdv## sodfhg## lq#iurqw#ri#wkh# # # # # vxemhfw/## dqg## wkh## vxemhfw#zdv# # # jlyhq# dqrwkhu## lghqwlfdo## er{#iurp#zklfk#wr# # # # # exlog## dqrwkhu1## Lq#wkh# # # vhfrqg## yhuvlrq#ri#wkh# # # h{shulphqw/#wkh#vxemhfw#zdv#kdqghg#d#vhfrqg#er{/#exw#hyhq#zkloh#kh#ru#vkh#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sxwwlqj#wkh# # # prgho## wrjhwkhu/## wkh## uhvhdufkhu## glvpdqwohg## wkh## mxvw0frpsohwhg## prgho# dqg## sxw#lw#edfn#lq#wkh# # # # # # iluvw#er{/# # # vr## wkdw#wklv# # # er{#frxog# # # eh## kdqghg## wr## wkh## vxemhfw# zkhq#wkh#prgho#exlow#iurp#wkh#vhfrqg#er{#zdv#frpsohwh1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#vlpsoh#gliihuhqfh#ri#zkhwkhu#wkh#vxemhfwᄊv#zrun#zdv#doorzhg#wr#hqgxuh#+dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ohdvw## iru## wkh## gxudwlrq## ri## wkh## vxemhfwᄊv## sduwlflsdwlrq,## ru## zkhwkhu## lw## zdv## xqgrqh# lpphgldwho|/#ohdylqj#qrw#d#wudfh/#pdgh#dq#hqruprxv#gliihuhqfh#lq#wkh#zloolqjqhvv# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#zrun/#hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh#prqhwdu|#ehqhilwv#zhuh#lghqwlfdo1#Vxemhfwv#frpsohwhg#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # dyhudjh#ri#4319#Elrqlfohv#zkhq#wkh#frpsohwhg#prghov#zhuh#ohiw#vwdqglqj#lq#iurqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkhp#dqg#rqo|#:15#zkhq#wkh#frpsohwhg#rqhv#zhuh#glvpdqwohg#lq#iurqw#ri#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # h|hv1## Wkxv## wkh|## frqwlqxhg## wr## pdnh## Elrqlfohv## iru## orzhu## zdjhv## zkhq## wkh# h{shulphqw#zdv# # # vwuxfwxuhg## wr## jlyh## wkh## zrun#pruh# # # phdqlqj1## Vhhlqj#wkh# # # iuxlwv## ri# |rxu## oderu/#hyhq#lq#vrphwklqj#dv# # # # # # wulyldo## dv## prgho## exloglqj/#vhhpv# # # lpsruwdqw#iru# # prwlydwlrq$6# Lq#vrph#mrev/#lw#lv#yhu|#kdug#wr#vhh#wkh#hiihfwv#ri#rqhᄊv#zrun1#Rq#dq#dvvhpeo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # olqh/#d#zrunhu#lv#mxvw#rqh#frj#lq#d#kxjh#surgxfwlrq#pdfklqh/#dqg#khu#uroh#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdo## surgxfw## pd|## eh## vpdoo1## Qr## zrqghu## prghuq## pdqdjhphqw## whfkqltxhv## wu|## wr# pdnh## hdfk## zrunhu## ihho## lpsruwdqw## erwk## lqglylgxdoo|## dqg## dv## sduw## ri## d## whdp=## wkh# Mdsdqhvh## ndl}hq## v|vwhp#ri# # # frqwlqxrxv## lpsuryhphqw/## iru## h{dpsoh/## lqyroyhv## doo# zrunhuv## lq## pdnlqj## fkdqjhv## wr## hqkdqfh## surgxfwlylw|/## qr## pdwwhu## krz## vpdoo## wkh# fkdqjhv#pljkw#eh1# # # Pdq|#mrev#lq#d#frpshwlwlyh/#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#duh#sureohpdwlf#iru# # # # # # # # # # # wzr## uhdvrqv=## Iluvw/## olnh## wkh## zrunhu## rq## dq## dvvhpeo|## olqh/## wkh## eurnhu## zkr## vhoov# erqgv## lvvxhg## e|## dq## hohfwulf## srzhu## surmhfw## uduho|## vhhv## wkh## hohfwulflw|## wkdw## lv#
surgxfhg=#vkh#kdv#olwwoh#vhqvh#ri#dq|#pdwhuldo#uhvxow#ri#khu#oderuv1#Vkh#lv#phuho|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frj#lq#d#jljdqwlf#pdfklqh1#Vhfrqg/#wkh#prvw#gluhfw#phdvxuh#ri#d#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrunhu#ᄊv## frqwulexwlrq## lv## wkh## prqh|ᄇwkh## surilwv## ru## uhwxuqvᄇvkh## pdnhv## iru## wkh# ilup1## Prqh|## khuh## lv## wkh## phdvxuh## ri## erwk## wkh## zrun## dqg## khu## zruwk/## dqg## wklv## lv# zkhuh#erwk#wkh#phulwv#ri#wkh#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#dqg#lwv#frvwv#dulvh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wdnh/#iru#lqvwdqfh/#d#wudghu#zkr#vhoov#vkruw#wkh#vwrfn#ri#d#frpsdq|#kh#ihhov#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehlqj## plvpdqdjhg## +wkdw## lv/## kh## eruurzv## dqg## vhoov## vwrfn## kh## grhv## qrw## kdyh/# dqwlflsdwlqj#wkh#sulfh#zloo#jr#grzq#dqg#wkdw#kh#zloo#eh#deoh#wr#ex|#wkh#vwrfn#edfn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # odwhu#dw#d#orzhu#sulfh#wr#forvh#rxw#klv#srvlwlrq#dw#d#wlg|#surilw,1#Ihz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # shrsoh#duh# # pruh## ylolilhg## wkdq## vkruw## vhoohuv/## zkr## duh## vhhq## dv## yxowxuhv## ihdvwlqj## rq## wkh# plviruwxqh## ri## rwkhuv1## Exw## wkh|#shuirup#d# # # # ydoxdeoh## vrfldo## ixqfwlrq#e|#ghsulylqj# # # srruo|## pdqdjhg## frpsdqlhv## ri## uhvrxufhv1## D## frpsdq|## zkrvh## vwrfn## sulfh## wdqnv# zloo## qrw## eh## deoh## wr## udlvh## htxlw|#ru# # # ghew## ilqdqfh## hdvlo|#dqg# # # frxog## eh## irufhg## wr# forvh#grzq1#Wkh#wudghu#zkr#vkruwv#wkh#vwrfn#grhv#qrw#vhh#wkh#zrunhuv#zkr#orvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#mrev#ru#wkh#kdugvkls#wkdw#xqhpsor|phqw#fdxvhv#wkhlu#idplolhv>#doo#kh#vhhv#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## surilwv## kh## zloo## pdnh## li#kh# # # wxuqv## rxw#wr#eh# # # # uljkw#lq#klv# # # # mxgjphqw1#Exw#lw#lv# # # # # klv# yhu|#reolylrq#wr# # # # wkh## odujhu## frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## klv## wudghv## wkdw## pdnhv## klp#vxfk#dq# # # hiihfwlyh#dqg#glvsdvvlrqdwh#wrro#ri#fkdqjh1# # # # # # Ghvslwh## wkh## surwhvwdwlrqv## ri## wkh## pdqdjhphqw## ri## wdujhwhg## ilupv## dqg## wkhlu# srolwlfdo#edfnhuv/#wkh#wudghu#grhv#qrw#fdxvh#wkh#ilup#wr#jr#rxw#ri#exvlqhvv1#Li#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wudghu#lv#zurqj#dqg#wkh#ilup#lv#zhoo#pdqdjhg/#rwkhu#wudghuv#zloo#wdnh#wkh#rssrvlwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vlgh/#ex|#vkduhv/#sxvk#xs#wkh#vkduh#sulfh/#dqg#pdnh#wkh#vkruw#vhoohu#orvh#prqh|1#Lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv## w|slfdoo|## rqo|## zkhq## wkh## vkruw## vhoohu#ᄊv## rslqlrqv## duh## zlgho|#vkduhg/# # # dqg## ilup# pdqdjhphqw#lv#dzixo/#wkdw#wkh#vkduh#sulfh#wdqnv1#Plvpdqdjhphqw#lv#wkh#vrxufh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ilupᄊv# # # wurxeohv>#wkh#wudghu# # # # phuho|#krogv# # # xs#d#pluuru# # # # wr#uhiohfw#lw1#Lqghhg/#wkh# # # # # pruh#glvfrqqhfwhg#wkh#wudghu#lv#iurp#wkh#shrsoh#lq#wkh#ilup/#wkh#pruh#uholdeoh#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pluuru## kh## lv## deoh## wr## surylgh1## Exw#khuhlq#olhv# # # # wkh## uxe1## Ehfdxvh## wkh## wudghu## lv## dw#d# # glvwdqfh## iurp## wkh## uhdo## frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## klv## dfwlrqv/## wkh## ehvw## phdvxuh## ri## wkh# wudghu#ᄊv## ydoxh## wr## vrflhw|## lv## zkhwkhu## kh## pdgh## prqh|## iurp## wkh## wudgh=## d## surilw# lqglfdwhv## wkdw## kh## zdv## uljkw## wr## vkruw## wkh## ilup#vkruw# # # dqg## wkdw## vrflhw|#zloo# # # ehqhilw# iurp#klv#dfwlrqv1# # # Dowkrxjk## pdunhw## rslqlrq## lv## qrw## dozd|v## uljkw/## pruh## riwhq## wkdq## qrw/## lw## lv1# Pdqdjhphqw#dw#wkh# # # # hqhuj|#jldqw#Hqurq#odvkhg# # # # # rxw#dw#vkruw#vhoohuv/# # # # # exw#wkh# # # vkruw# vhoohuv/## olnh## Mdphv## Fkdqrv## dw## N|qlnrv## Dvvrfldwhv/## xqghuvwrrg## wkhuh## zdv# vrphwklqj#ghhso|#zurqj#zlwk#lwv# # # # # # dffrxqwlqj1## Hvvhqwldoo|/## Hqurq#kdg# # # vhw#xs# # # rii0 edodqfh#vkhhw#hqwlwlhv#wr#zklfk#lw#ᄈvrogᄡ#lwv#idlolqj#surmhfwv#dw#d#khiw|#surilw/#wkxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhdwlqj#wkh#dsshdudqfh#ri#erwk#surilwdelolw|#dqg#jurzwk/#hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh#uhdolw|# # # # # # # # # # # # zdv## mxvw## wkh## rssrvlwh1## Lw## zdv## wkh## vkruw## vhoohuv## zkr## pdgh## Hqurqᄊv## vwrfn## sulfh# soxpphw#dqg#irufhg#wkh#frpsdq|#wr#vkxw#grzq#hyhq#zkloh#wkh#ilupᄊv#wudglwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnhuv## vxssruwhg## lwv## fuhdwlyh## dffrxqwlqj## zlwk## |hw## pruh## fuhdwlyh## ordqv1## Dv# Fkdqrv#odwhu#zurwh/#ghihqglqj#wkh#vkruw#vhoohu# ᄊv#uroh#dv#surihvvlrqdo#vnhswlf=#ᄈZh# # # # # # # # # # # # vsrnh#zlwk#d#qxpehu#ri#dqdo|vwv#dw#ydulrxv#Zdoo#Vwuhhw#ilupv#wr#glvfxvv#Hqurq#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv#ydoxdwlrq1#Zh#zhuh#vwuxfn#e|#krz# # # # # # # # pdq|#ri#wkhp#frqfhghg#wkdw#wkhuh#zdv#qr# # # # # # # # zd|#wr#dqdo|}h#Hqurq/#exw#wkdw#lqyhvwlqj#lq#Hqurq#zdv#lqvwhdg#d#ᄉwuxvw#phᄊ#vwru|1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Rqh#dqdo|vw/#zkloh#dgplwwlqj#wkdw#Hqurq#zdv#d#ᄉeodfn#er{ᄊ#uhjduglqj#surilwv/#vdlg# # # # # # # # # # # # # 7# wkdw/#dv#orqj#dv#Hqurq#gholyhuhg/#zkr#zdv#kh#wr#dujxhBᄡ # # # # # # # # # # Fkdqrv#pdgh#ploolrqv#dqg#dftxluhg#idph#iurp#klv#dqdo|vlv#dqg#klv#zloolqjqhvv# # # # # # # # # # # #
wr#fkdoohqjh#wkh#khug#rq#wkh#txhvwlrq#ri#Hqurqᄊv#ydoxh/#exw#lw#lv#wklv#yhu|#vwuhqjwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#v|vwhpᄇwkdw#prqh|#lv#wkh#phdvxuh#ri#doo#wklqjvᄇzklfk#dovr# # # # # # # # # # # # lv#lwv#zhdnqhvv1#Dq#rog#Odwlq#vd|lqj/#Shfxqld#qrq#rohw/#wudqvodwhv#dv#ᄈPrqh|#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qr## rgru1ᄡ## Wkh## yhu|## dqrq|plw|## ri## prqh|/## wkh## idfw## wkdw## lw## lv## ixqjleoh## dqg## lwv# suryhqdqfh#kdug#wr#wudfh/#dovr#pdnhv#lw#d#srru#phfkdqlvp#iru#jxlglqj#hpsor|hhvᄊ# # # # # # # # # # # # # dfwlylwlhv## wrzdug## vrfldoo|## ghvludeoh## hqgv1## Glg## wkh## wudghu## pdnh## khu## uhwxuqv## e|# ehlqj#pruh# # # dvwxwh## wkdq#rwkhuv# # # olnh## khu/## ru## glg## vkh## pdnh## lw## e|#iurqw0uxqqlqj#khu# # # folhqwv## +wudglqj## dkhdg## ri## d## odujh## folhqw## rughu## vr## dv## wr## pdnh## prqh|## zkhq## wkdw# folhqwᄊv## rughu## pryhg## sulfhv,B## Glg## wkh## pruwjdjh## eurnhu## pdnh## klv## ihhv## wkurxjk# riihulqj## d## ydulhw|## ri## vhqvleoh## rswlrqv## wr## wkh## surihvvlrqdo## frxsoh## zkr## zhuh# orrnlqj#wr#xsjudgh#wkhlu#krxvh/#ru#e|#xujlqj#dq#hoghuo|#frxsoh#wr#uhilqdqfh#lqwr#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjh#wkh|#frxog#qrw#diirugB#Dowkrxjk#wkh#iruphu#frxuvh#lv#suhihudeoh#lq#hdfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdvh/#wkh#odwwhu# # # # lv#hdvlhu# # # iru## wkh#wudghu# # # ru## eurnhu>#dqg#ehfdxvh#wkh#zurqj#fkrlfh# # # # # # dovr## pdnhv## prqh|/## kdv## ihz## lpphgldwh## frqvhtxhqfhv/## dqg## vhwv## rii## ihz## dodup# ehoov/#lw#lv#wkh#rqh#wkdw#lv#prvw#whpswlqj1# # # # # # # # # Lq#vxp/#edqnhuv#duh#qrw#wkh#kruqhg/#juhhg|#yloodlqv#wkh#sxeolf#qrz#vhhv#wkhp#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh1#Lq#wkh#fodvvhv#L#kdyh#wdxjkw#ryhu#wkh#|hduv/#wkh#ixwxuh#edqnhuv#zhuh#dv#hdjhu/# # # # ## # # # # # # # # # # iulhqgo|/#dqg#uhdg|#wr#vkduh#dv#wkh#rwkhu#vwxghqwv#lq#fodvv/#dowkrxjk#shukdsv#d#olwwoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vpduwhu#+uhphpehu/#wklv#zdv#d#wlph#zkhq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#sdlg#idu#pruh#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rwkhu## surihvvlrqv#dqg#dwwudfwhg#wkh#ehvw#wdohqw,1#L#kdyh#qr#grxew#wkh|#frqwlqxh#wr# # # # # # ## # # # # # eh#ghfhqw/#fdulqj#kxpdq#ehlqjv1#Exw#ehfdxvh#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # exvlqhvv## w|slfdoo|#riihuv# # # ihz# slooduv## wr#zklfk#wkh|#fdq#dqfkru# # # # # # wkhlu## prudolw|/#wkhlu# # # sulpdu|#frpsdvv# # # ehfrphv# krz#pxfk#prqh|#wkh|#pdnh1#Wkh#slfwxuh#ri#edqnhuv#vodyhulqj#diwhu#erqxvhv#vrrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # diwhu#wkh|#kdg#ehhq#uhvfxhg#e|#jryhuqphqw#edlorxwv#zdv#qrw#rqo|#rxwudjhrxv#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr#slwldeohᄇslwldeoh#ehfdxvh#wkh|#zhuh#fodprulqj#iru#wkhlu#sulpdu|#phdvxuh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # vhoi0zruwk#dqg#vwdwxv#wr#eh#uhvwruhg1# # # # # # Xvxdoo|/#frpshwlwlyh#pdunhw#phfkdqlvpv#nhhs#wkh#vhdufk#iru#surilwv#rq#d#wudfn# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#dovr#hqvxuhv#lw#hqkdqfhv#ydoxh#wr#vrflhw|1#Wklv#lv#wkh#ixqgdphqwdo#uhdvrq#zk|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # iuhh0pdunhw#fdslwdolvp#zrunv#dqg#zk|#edqnhuv#xvxdoo|#gr#jrrg#hyhq#dv#wkh|#gr# # # # # # # # # # # # # yhu|#zhoo#iru#wkhpvhoyhv1#Krzhyhu/#wkh#idxow#olqhv#zh#kdyh#lghqwlilhg#fdq#zdus# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## wudfnv1## Wkh## ilqho|#lqfhqwlyl}hg# # # ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp#fdq#wkhq#ghudlo# # # # # udslgo|1## E|# sxwwlqj#doo#wkh#eodph#rq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp/#zh#idlo#wr#uhfrjql}h#wkh#uroh#sod|hg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|## wkh## idxow## olqhv1## H{fruldwlqj## wkh## lpprudolw|## ri## edqnhuv## kdv## pdgh## iru## jrrg# ukhwrulf## dqg## srolwlfv## wkurxjkrxw## klvwru|/## exw## lw## lv## xqolnho|## wr## dgguhvv## wkh# ixqgdphqwdo## uhdvrq## zk|## wkh|## fdq## fdxvh## vr## pxfk## kdup1## Ohw## xv## vhh## krz## wkhvh# hiihfwv#zhuh#dw#zrun#lq#wkh#ruljlqdwlrq#ri#gxelrxv#vxesulph#pruwjdjhv1# # # # # # # # # # #
Eurnhuv#dqg#Zkdw#Zhqw#Zurqj # # # # # Wkhuh## zhuh## sohqw|## ri## h{dpsohv## ri## kruuhqgrxv## pruwjdjh## ordqv## pdgh## lq## wkh# uxq0xs## wr## wklv## prvw## uhfhqw## fulvlv1## Pdq|#zhuh# # # pdgh## e|#Qhz# # # Fhqwxu|#Ilqdqfldo/# # zklfk## zdv## irxqghg## lq## 4<<8## zlwk## derxw## '6## ploolrq## ri## yhqwxuh## fdslwdo/## dv# jryhuqphqw#vxssruw#wr#wkh#vxesulph#pdunhw#lqfuhdvhg1#Ehfdxvh#vxesulph#ohqglqj# # # # # # # # # # zdv## dq## lqqrydwlrq## zlwk## hqruprxv## srwhqwldo## rssruwxqlwlhv/## lw## dwwudfwhg## dpsoh# yhqwxuh0fdslwdo## ixqglqj1## Qhz## Fhqwxu|## zhqw## sxeolf## lq## 4<<:1## Diwhu## vxuylylqj## d# vfduh## wkh## qh{w## |hdu/## zkhq## Uxvvldq## ordq## ghidxowv## fdxvhg## lqyhvwruv## wr## iohh## ulvn|# exvlqhvvhv#dqg#vrph#vxesulph#ohqghuv#zhqw#rxw#ri#exvlqhvv/#lw#juhz#udslgo|1# # # # # # # # # # # # Frpsdqlhv## olnh## Qhz## Fhqwxu|## uhdfkhg## fxvwrphuv## pdlqo|## wkurxjk## vpdoo/# lqghshqghqw## pruwjdjh## eurnhudjhv1## Pruwjdjh## eurnhuv## irxqg## fxvwrphuv/## dgylvhg# wkhp#rq#dydlodeoh# # # # ordqv/## dqg## froohfwhg## ihhv## iru## kdqgolqj#wkh# # # lqlwldo## surfhvvlqj1# Zlwk#Qhz# # # Fhqwxu|#dqg# # # lwv## ulydov## frpshwlqj#ilhufho|#iru# # # # exvlqhvv/## eurnhuv## riwhq# idyruhg#ohqghuv# # # zkr#zhuh#deoh#wr#pdnh#ordqv# # # # # # # txlfno|1#Dv# # # rqh#eurnhu# # # sxw#lw/#kh# # # 8# olnhg## zrunlqj## zlwk## Qhz## Fhqwxu|## ehfdxvh## lw## zdv## ᄈyhu|## hdv|1ᄡ # Qhz## Fhqwxu|# uduho|#ghpdqghg#uhylhzv#ri#wkh#dssudlvdov#rq#zklfk#ordqv#zhuh#edvhg1#Ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # lw#rxwvrxufhg#exvlqhvv#wr#eurnhuv/#lw#frxog#udps#xs#lwv#exvlqhvv#txlfno|/#zlwkrxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # kdylqj#wr# # # kluh## d## orw## ri## hpsor|hhv## ru## ilqg## riilfh## vsdfh1## Eurnhuv## zrunhg## rxw## ri# wkhlu#rzq#krphv#dqg#fduv#dqg#zhuh#riwhq#zloolqj#wr#jr#wr#fxvwrphuvᄊ#krphv#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhqlqj#ru# # # rq#wkh# # # zhhnhqg1## Dv## d## uhvxow#ri#vxfk#udslg# # # # # h{sdqvlrq/## Qhz## Fhqwxu|# zdv## wkh## vhfrqg## odujhvw## vxesulph## pruwjdjh## ohqghu## lq## wkh## frxqwu|## dw## rqh## wlph/# ruljlqdwlqj#qhduo|#'93#eloolrq#lq#pruwjdjhv#lq#53391# # # # # # # # Lw#grhv#qrw#wdnh#d#jhqlxv#wr#sxvk#ordqv#wr#wkrvh#zkr#kdyh#fuhglw#sureohpv/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Qhz## Fhqwxu|## glg## qrw## shqdol}h## eurnhuv## iru## wkh## txdolw|## ri## ordqv## wkh|## ruljlqdwhg# 9## Wkh#Zdoo#Vwuhhw#Mrxuqdo#kljkoljkwhg#dq# xqwlo#lq#hduo|#533:/#zkhq#lw#zdv#wrr#odwh1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # :# h{dpsoh#ri#wkh#nlqg#ri#ordqv#ehlqj#pdgh1 # # # # # # # # Uxwklh#Kloohu|#zdv#vwuxjjolqj#wr#pdnh# # # # # # wkh#'<85#prqwko|#pruwjdjh#sd|phqw#iru#khu#wkuhh0ehgurrp#krph#lq#Fdoliruqld1#Lq# # # # # # # # # # # # 5339/## d## pruwjdjh## eurnhu## shuvxdghg## wkh## :30|hdu0rog## Kloohu|#wr# # # uhilqdqfh## lqwr## d# ᄈvhqlru## flwl}hqᄊvᄡ## ordq#iurp#Qhz# # # # Fhqwxu|#wkdw# # # vkh## wkrxjkw## zrxog## holplqdwh## wkh# qhhg#wr#pdnh#dq|#sd|phqwv# # # # # # iru## vhyhudo## |hduv1#Lqvwhdg/#wkh#'669/333#dgmxvwdeoh0 # # # # udwh## ordq## vwduwhg## rxw## zlwk## sd|phqwv## ri## '5/533## d## prqwk/## pruh## wkdq## grxeoh## khu# lqfrph1## E|## wkh## hqg## ri## wkh## |hdu/## zkhq## vkh## frxog## qrw## nhhs## xs## sd|phqwv/## Pv1# Kloohu|#uhfhlyhg#qrwlfh#wkdw#Qhz# # # # # # Fhqwxu|#lqwhqghg#wr#iruhforvh#rq#wkh#surshuw|1# # # # # # # Dv#khu#odz|hu#sxw#lw=# # # # # # ᄈ\rx#kdyh#d#ordq#dssolfdwlrq#zkhuh#wkh#lqfrph#vhfwlrq#lv# # # # # # # # # # eodqn1#Krz#grhv#lw#hyhq#jhw#sdvw#wkh#iluvw#shuvrq#zkr#orrnv#dw#lwBᄡ#Dffruglqj#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Rklrᄊv## dvvlvwdqw#dwwruqh|#jhqhudo/# # # # Urehuw#P1# # # Kduw/## Qhz## Fhqwxu|ᄊv## xqghuzulwlqj# ;# vwdqgdugv#zhuh#vr#orz#ᄈwkdw#wkh|#zrxog#kdyh#vrog#d#ordq#wr#d#grj1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # # # # # Qhz## Fhqwxu|#zdv# # # lpphqvho|#vxffhvvixo# # # iru## d## zkloh## lq#vslwh# # # ri#lwv# # # dssdoolqj# fuhglw#vwdqgdugv1#Dqg#ghvslwh#wkh#surplqhqfh#jlyhq#lq#wkh#phgld#wr#vxfk#fdvhv/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # juhz#qrw#sulpdulo|#ehfdxvh#lw#suh|hg#rq#yxoqhudeoh#uhwluhhv#exw#ehfdxvh#ri#ulvlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvh#sulfhv#dqg#vhfxulwl}dwlrq1#Zlwk#krxvh#sulfhv#ulvlqj/#Qhz#Fhqwxu|ᄊv#eurnhuv# # # # # # # # # # # frxog#pdnh#ordqv#zlwk#diirugdeoh#lqlwldo#whdvhu#udwhv/#dqwlflsdwlqj#wkdw#e|#wkh#wlph# # # # # # # # # # # # # eruurzhuv#kdg#wr#pdnh#kljkhu#sd|phqwv/#wkhlu#krxvh#sulfhv#zrxog#kdyh#ulvhq/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#frxog#uhilqdqfh#rqfh#djdlq#lqwr#d#orz#udwh1#Lqghhg/#wklv#vfkhph#zdv#d#yluwxdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
prqh|#pdfklqh/# # # ehfdxvh## wkh## frvw#ri#uhilqdqflqj#frxog# # # # # uhshdwhgo|#eh# # # vzhsw#lqwr# # wkh## qhz/## odujhu/## pruwjdjhᄇxqwlo## krxvh## sulfhv## vwrsshg## ulvlqj1## Dw## wkdw## srlqw/## doo# wkrvh## pruwjdjhv## zlwk#uhvhwv# # # wr## kljkhu## udwhv## zrxog## wxuq#lqwr# # # uhdo## ghewᄇwkh## nlqg# wkdw#dfwxdoo|#kdv#wr#eh#uhsdlgᄇdqg#wkh#kljk#uhtxluhg#uhsd|phqwv#zrxog#uhvhpeoh# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## edoorrq## uhsd|phqwv## wkdw## suryhg## vr## exughqvrph## wr## krphrzqhuv## gxulqj## wkh# Ghsuhvvlrq1# Qhz#Fhqwxu|ᄊv#pdqdjhphqw#pxvw#kdyh#nqrzq#wkdw#krxvh#sulfhv#zrxog#qrw#ulvh# # # # # # # # # # # # lqghilqlwho|1#Vr#zk|#glg#wkh|#frqwlqxh#pdnlqj#ulvn|#pruwjdjh#ordqv# # # # # # # # # # # doprvw#xqwlo# # wkh#gd|#wkh|#ilohg#iru#edqnuxswf|B#Rqh#dqvzhu#lv#wkdw#wkh#frpsdq|#glg#qrw#krog#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#wkh#pruwjdjhv#lw#pdgh#exw#vrog#wkhp#wr#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#zkr#sdfndjhg#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrjhwkhu#dqg#vrog#vhfxulwlhv#+zklfk#zhuh#ydvwo|#ryhuudwhg#e|#wkh#udwlqj#djhqflhv,# # # # # # # # # # # # djdlqvw#wkh#sdfndjh#wr#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh/#shqvlrq#ixqgv/#lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv/# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#edqnv#durxqg#wkh#zruog1# # # # # Vr#glg#qr#rqh#fduh#derxw#fuhglw#txdolw|B#Wkh#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#+dqg#wkhlu#udwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # djhqflhv,## glg#fduh/#diwhu# # # # d#idvklrq1#Wr#vhoo# # # # # wkh#pruwjdjhv#rq/#wkh|#kdg#wr#vdwlvi|# # # # # # # wkhpvhoyhv#wkdw#wkh#xqghuo|lqj#fuhglw#txdolw|#zdv#vrxqg1#Lq#wkh#sdvw/#zkhq#d#edqn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdgh## d## pruwjdjh## ordq## wkdw## lw## lqwhqghg## wr## krog## rq## lwv## errnv/## lw## fdoohg## wkh# survshfwlyh## eruurzhu## lq1## Wkh## ordq## riilfhu## lqwhuylhzhg## klp/## vrxjkw## grfxphqwv# yhuli|lqj#hpsor|phqw#dqg#lqfrph/#dqg#dvvhvvhg#zkhwkhu#wkh#eruurzhu#zdv#deoh# # # # # # # # # # # dqg## zloolqj## wr## fduu|## wkh## ghew1## Wkhvh## dvvhvvphqwv## zhuh## qrw## mxvw## edvhg## rq## kdug# idfwv>## wkh|#dovr# # # lqfoxghg## mxgjphqw## fdoov## vxfk#dv# # # zkhwkhu## wkh## eruurzhu## vhhphg# zhoo## pdqqhuhg/## fohdqo|## dwwluhg/## wuxvwzruwk|/## dqg## fdsdeoh## ri## kroglqj## d## mre1# Fxowxudo## fxhv#vxfk#dv#zkhwkhu# # # # # wkh#dssolfdqw#kdg#d#ilup#kdqgvkdnh#ru# # # # # # # # orrnhg#wkh# # ordq#riilfhu# # # lq#wkh# # # h|h## zkhq#dqvzhulqj#txhvwlrqv# # # # qr## grxew## sod|hg## d## urohᄇdv/# xqiruwxqdwho|/#glg#udfh1#Exw#pdq|#ri#wkhvh#mxgjphqw#fdoov#glg#vhhp#wr#dgg#ydoxh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhglw#hydoxdwlrqv1#Vr#glg#wkh#ordq#riilfhu# ᄊv#nqrzohgjh#wkdw#klv#folhqw#zrxog#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # edfn#wr#kdxqw#klv#frqvflhqfh#li#kh#sxw#klp#lq#dq#xqdiirugdeoh#krxvh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Exw## dv## lqyhvwphqw## edqnv## sxw## wrjhwkhu## jljdqwlf## sdfndjhv## ri## pruwjdjhv/## wkh# mxgjphqw## fdoov## ehfdph## ohvv## dqg## ohvv## lpsruwdqw## lq#fuhglw# # # dvvhvvphqwv=## diwhu## doo/# wkhuh#zdv#qr#zd|#wr#frgh#wkh#eruurzhu# ᄊv#fdsdflw|#wr#krog#d#mre#lq#dq#remhfwlyh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # <## Lqghhg/#uhfruglqj#mxgjphqw#fdoov#lq#d#zd|#wkdw#frxog#qrw# # # # # # # # # # pdfklqh0uhdgdeoh#zd|1 # eh## vxssruwhg## e|#kdug# # # idfwv## pljkw## kdyh## rshqhg## wkh## pruwjdjh## ohqghu## wr## odzvxlwv# doohjlqj#glvfulplqdwlrq1#Doo#wkdw#vhhphg#wr#pdwwhu#wr#wkh#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # udwlqj#djhqflhv#zhuh#wkh#qxphulfdo# # # # # # fuhglw#vfruh#ri#wkh#eruurzhu#dqg#wkh#dprxqw# # # # # # # # ri#wkh# # # ordq#uhodwlyh# # # wr## krxvh## ydoxh1## Wkhvh## zhuh## kdug## slhfhv## ri#lqirupdwlrq#wkdw# # # frxog## eh## surfhvvhg## hdvlo|## dqg## wkdw## rvwhqvleo|## vxppdul}hg## fuhglw## txdolw|1# Dffruglqjo|/## wkh## eurnhuv## zkr## ruljlqdwhg## ordqv## irfxvhg## rq#qrwklqj#hovh1# # # # Lqghhg/# dv#wkh#pdunhw#ehfdph#uhg0krw/#wkh|#qr#orqjhu#hyhq#erwkhuhg#wr#yhuli|#hpsor|phqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ru## lqfrph1#Sduw0wlph#jdughqhuv#ehfdph#wuhh#vxujhrqv#sxusruwhgo|#hduqlqj#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # plggoh#vl{#iljxuhv#dqqxdoo|1# # # # Wkh#mxgjphqw#fdoov#klvwrulfdoo|#pdgh#e|#ordq#riilfhuv#zhuh/#lq#idfw/#h{wuhpho|# # # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwdqw## wr## wkh## ryhudoo## fuhglw## dvvhvvphqw1## Dv## wkh|## zhuh## glvshqvhg## zlwk/## wkh# txdolw|## ri## pruwjdjh0ruljlqdwlrq## ghflvlrqv## ghwhulrudwhg/## hyhq## wkrxjk## wkh## kdug# qxpehuv## frqwlqxhg## wr## orrn## jrrg## wloo## wkh## yhu|## hqg1## Lw## uhdoo|## grhv## pdwwhu## li## wkh# eruurzhu#lv#uxgh/#vkliw|/#dqg#voryhqo|#lq#wkh#ordq#lqwhuylhz/#iru#lw#vd|v#vrphwklqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # derxw## klv## fdsdflw|## wr## krog## d## mre/## qr## pdwwhu## zkdw## klv## fuhglw## vfruh## lqglfdwhv1# Pruhryhu/## eurnhuv## dqg## Qhz## Fhqwxu|## kdg## dq## lpphqvh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## nhhs## wkh#
yroxph## ri## ruljlqdwlrqv## xs## vr## wkdw## wkh|#frxog# # # froohfw## ihhvᄇdqg## wkh|#qrz# # # nqhz# zklfk## qxpehuv## wr## hpskdvl}h1## Vr## eurnhuv## ihow## olwwoh## frpsxqfwlrq## lq## khoslqj# zloolqj## eruurzhuv## pdvvdjh## wkhlu## fuhglw## vfruhv/## dqg## wkh|## uhfuxlwhg## soldqw# dssudlvhuv## zkr## zrxog## nhhs## wkh## ordq0wr0ydoxh## udwlr## grzq## e|## riihulqj# 43## Ehfdxvh#wkh|#vhhphg#zloolqj#wr#gr# rxwudjhrxvo|#kljk#dssudlvdov#iru#wkh#krxvh1 # # # # # # # # # # yluwxdoo|## dq|wklqj## wr## forvh## wkh## ghdo/## Qhz## Fhqwxu|ᄊv## ordq## ghsduwphqw## ehfdph# 44# nqrzq#dv#ᄈForvh#Pruh#Xqlyhuvlw|1ᄡ # # # # Hyhqwxdoo|/## wkrxjk/## Qhz## Fhqwxu|ᄊv## zhdn## vwdqgdugv## fdxjkw## xs## zlwk## lw1# Lqfuhdvlqjo|/## lwv## eruurzhuv## frxog## qrw## hyhq## pdnh## wkhlu## iluvw## ihz## sd|phqwv## dqg# ghidxowhg1## Wkhvh## ghidxowv## zhuh## sureohpdwlf## ehfdxvh## wkh## edqnv## ex|lqj## wkh# pruwjdjhv## iru## sdfndjlqj## frxog## uhwxuq## pruwjdjhv## wkdw## ghidxowhg## hduo|## wr## Qhz# Fhqwxu|1## Zlwk## pruh## dqg## pruh## pruwjdjhv## uhwxuqlqj## rqwr## lwv## errnv/## dqg## ohqghuv# zlwkgudzlqj#wkhlu# # # olqhv## ri#fuhglw/# # # Qhz## Fhqwxu|#hyhqwxdoo|#ilohg# # # # iru## edqnuxswf|1# Rqh#kdv#wr#pduyho#dw#wkh#vkhhu#fkxw}sdk#ri#Qhz#Fhqwxu|ᄊv#irxqghu/#Eudg#Pruulfh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkr## vdlg## lq## d## qhzv## uhohdvh## dqqrxqflqj## wkh## frpsdq|ᄊv## edqnuxswf|## rq## Dsulo## 5/# 533:/#wkdw#lw#kdg#ᄈkhoshg#ploolrqv#ri#Dphulfdqv/#pdq|#zkr#pljkw#qrw#rwkhuzlvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # 45# kdyh#ehhq#deoh#wr#dffhvv# # # # # # fuhglw#ru# # # wr#uhdol}h#wkh#ehqhilwv# # # # # ri#krphrzqhuvkls1ᄡ # Kh#qhjohfwhg#wr#phqwlrq#wkdw#iru#ploolrqv#ri#wkhvh#krphrzqhuv/#wkhlu#krxvhv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # olnh#ploovwrqhv#durxqg#wkhlu#qhfnv/#gurzqlqj#wkhp#lq#d#vhd#ri#ghew1# # # # # # # # # # # #
Dvvljqlqj#Eodph # # Wkh## sulydwh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## ehduv## dq## hqruprxv## uhvsrqvlelolw|## iru## zkdw# kdsshqhg1#Exw#glg#wkh#eurnhuv#dfw#lpprudoo|B#Fohduo|/#plvohdglqj#uhwluhhv#derxw# # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#sd|phqwv#zdv#zurqj#dqg#erughuhg#rq#wkh#loohjdo1#Exw#dowkrxjk#wkhvh#duh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdvhv#wkdw#vwloo#pdnh#wkh#khdgolqhv/#lw#lv#qrw#reylrxv#wkdw#suhgdwru|#ohqglqj#ri#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vruw## zdv## wkh## qrup1## Eurnhuv## dqg## ilupv## olnh## Qhz## Fhqwxu|## surylghg## pdq|## d# krphrzqhu#zlwk#zkdw#wkh|#zhuh#dvnlqj#iru=# # # # # # # # uhilqdqflqj#dw#orz# # # # udwhv/#zlwk#olwwoh# # # wkrxjkw## iru## wkh## ixwxuh1## Vkrxog## wkh## eurnhu## kdyh## frxqvhohg## wkh## ghew0ulgghq# krphrzqhuv#wkh|#zhuh#zrunlqj#zlwk#wr#fxw#edfn#rq#frqvxpswlrq/#sd|#rii#fuhglw# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdug#ghewv/#dqg#pryh#wr#d#vpdoohu/#pruh#diirugdeoh#krxvhB#Shukdsv#vrph#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## grqh## vr## kdg## wkh|## wkrxjkw## wkh|## zrxog## vhh## wkhlu## folhqwv## djdlq1## Nqrzlqj/# krzhyhu/## wkdw## wkh## pruwjdjhv## wkh|#ruljlqdwhg# # # zrxog## eh## sdfndjhg## dqg## vrog/## wkh|# kdg#olwwoh#vwdnh#lq#wkh#uhodwlrqvkls/#rwkhu#wkdq#wkh#ihhvᄇihhv#wkdw#lqglfdwhg#wr#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#zhuh#grlqj#Jrgᄊv#zrun1#Dupᄊv0ohqjwk#wudqvdfwlrqv#gr#qrw#irvwhu#hpsdwk|#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # d#orqj0whup#irfxv1# # # Wkhuh## lv/## krzhyhu/## dqrwkhu## fkhfn## rq## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## wudqvdfwlrqvᄇd## zhoo0 ixqfwlrqlqj## frpshwlwlyh## pdunhw1## Li## Qhz## Fhqwxu|## kdg## ehhq## irufhg## wr## vhoo## lwv# ruljlqdwlrqv#iru#idlu#ydoxh/#lw#zrxog#qhyhu#kdyh#ruljlqdwhg#wkh#ulvn|#pruwjdjhv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # glg#ru#sxw#vr#pdq|#eruurzhuv#lqwr#xqdiirugdeoh#krxvhv1#Wkh#frpshwlwlyh#pdunhw# # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#kdyh#surylghg#wkh#phfkdqlvpv#wr#nhhs#Iluvw#Fhqwxu|#rq#wudfn1#Vrphkrz/# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkh## pdunhw## zdv## zloolqj## wr## sd|## pxfk## kljkhu## ydoxhv## iru## wkhvh# pruwjdjhv#wkdq#wkh|#zhuh#zruwk#dqg#glg#qrw#h{huflvh#lwv#fxvwrpdu|#glvflsolqh1# # # # # # # # # # # # Rqh## uhdvrq#pljkw#eh# # # # wkdw#wkh# # # pdunhw#zdv# # # luudwlrqdoo|#h{xehudqw#dqg# # # # eholhyhg# wkh## srss|frfn## wkdw## krxvh## sulfhv## zrxog## qhyhu## jr## grzq1## Wkhuh## lv/## krzhyhu/# prxqwlqj## hylghqfh## wkdw## pxfk## ri## wkh## errp## dqg## exvw## zdv## frqfhqwudwhg## lq## orz0 lqfrph## krxvlqj/## vxjjhvwlqj## wkdw## wklv## zdv## qrw## jhqhudol}hg## luudwlrqdolw|## dqg## wkdw# 46# rwkhu#idfwruv#pd|#kdyh#ehhq#dw#sod|1 # # # # # # D## pruh## sodxvleoh## dujxphqw## lv## wkdw## wkh## vwurqj## jryhuqphqw## sxvk## iru## krph# rzqhuvkls## e|## orzhu0lqfrph## krxvhkrogv## ohg## wr## dq## hqruprxv## lqfuhdvh## lq## wkh# yroxph## ri#prqh|#srxuhg# # # # lqwr## wklv## vhfwru1## Wkh## eurnhuv/## ohqghuv/## sdfndjhuv/## dqg# udwlqj## djhqflhv## vlpso|## glg## qrw## kdyh## wkh## shuvrqqho## ru## fdsdflw|## wr## pdqdjh## wkh# hqruprxv#zrunordgv#hiihfwlyho|1#Dowkrxjk#wkh|#pd|#kdyh#zruulhg#derxw#srwhqwldo# # # # # # # # # # gdpdjh#wr#wkhlu#uhsxwdwlrq#iurp#wkh#volsvkrg#zrun#wkh|#zhuh#grlqj/#wkh#hqruprxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ihhv## wkh|## jhqhudwhg## dssduhqwo|## dood|hg## wkrvh## zruulhv147## Iru## h{dpsoh/## pdq|## ri# Qhz## Fhqwxu|ᄊv## vhqlru## pdqdjhuv## zhuh## lqgxvwu|#yhwhudqv# # # zkr## nqhz## wkh|#kdg# # # wkh# olfhqvh## wr## sulqw## prqh|## rqo|## iru## d## olplwhg## wlph=## hyhq## dv## Qhz## Fhqwxu|ᄊv## oltxlg# dvvhwv#ihoo#lq#wkh#shulrg#5338ᄆ533:/#dv#lw#zdv#irufhg#wr#devrue#orvvhv#rq#ordqv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 48# kdg#wr#wdnh#edfn#rq#lwv#errnv/#lwv#glylghqgv#shu#vkduh#lqfuhdvhg1 # # # # # # # # # # # Wklv#lv#qrw#d#frpsohwh#dujxphqw/#iru#lw#rqo|#nlfnv#wkh#frqxqguxp#rqh#vwhs#grzq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## urdg1## Lw## h{sodlqv## zk|## wkh## lqyhvwphqw## edqnv## +dqg## udwlqj## djhqflhv,## dfwhg## dv# errvwhuv#iru#Qhz#Fhqwxu|ᄊv#idxow|#pruwjdjhv/#exw#qrw#zk|#wkh|#frxog#vhoo#wkhp#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rwkhuv#dw#d#khiw|#suhplxp1#Hlwkhu#wkh#ilqdo#ex|huv#zhuh#irrohg#e|#udwlqjv#ru#wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv## vwurqj## ghpdqg## iru## wkhvh## ruljlqdwlrqv/## zlwkrxw## pxfk## wkrxjkw## wr## xqghuo|lqj# sulfh#ru#txdolw|1# # #
Fhuwdlqo|## vrph## ri## wkh## exuhdxfudwlf## shqvlrq## ixqgv## dqg## iruhljq## edqnv## glg## qrw# fduh## zkdw#wkh|#erxjkw#vr#orqj#dv# # # # # # # lw#surplvhg#d# # # # kljk#|lhog#dqg#zdv# # # # # udwhg#DDD/# # wkrxjk#wkh|#vkrxog#kdyh#zrqghuhg#zk|#wkh|#vhhphg#wr#eh#jhwwlqj#uhwxuq#zlwkrxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn1#Klqgvljkw#vxjjhvwv#wkh|#vkrxog#kdyh#wuxvwhg#ohvv#dqg#yhulilhg#pruh/#hyhq#li# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#eholhyhg#lq#wkh#lqvwlwxwlrqv#ri#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#pdunhwv/#vxfk#dv#udwlqj#djhqflhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Exw#wkh#gdpdjh#zdv#dovr#grqh#e|#djhqflhv#olnh#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh/#zklfk#kdg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ex|## dq## hqruprxv## iudfwlrq## ri## vxesulph## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## wr## phhw## d# jryhuqphqw0lpsrvhg## txrwd/## dqg## e|## jryhuqphqw## rujdql}dwlrqv## olnh## wkh## Ihghudo# Krxvlqj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq/# # # zklfk#frqwulexwhg# # # wr## wkh## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## ghpdqg## lq#wklv# # vhjphqw## ri## wkh## krxvlqj## pdunhw1## Dv## Shwhu## Zdoolvrq## ri## wkh## Dphulfdq## Hqwhusulvh# Lqvwlwxwh#srlqwv#rxw=#ᄈDv#ri#wkh#hqg#ri#533;/#wkh#Ihghudo#Krxvlqj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # khog## 718## ploolrq## vxesulph## dqg## Dow0D#ordqv1# # # Whq## ploolrq## zhuh## rq## wkh## errnv## ri# Idqqlh## Pdh## dqg## Iuhgglh## Pdf## zkhq#wkh|#zhuh# # # # wdnhq#ryhu/# # # dqg## 51:## ploolrq#duh# # fxuuhqwo|## khog## e|## edqnv## wkdw## sxufkdvhg## wkhp## xqghu## wkh## uhtxluhphqwv## ri## wkh# Frppxqlw|#Uhlqyhvwphqw#Dfw#+FUD,1#Wkhvh#jryhuqphqw0pdqgdwhg#ordqv#dprxqw# # # # # # # # wr#doprvw#wzr0wklugv#ri#doo#wkh#mxqn#pruwjdjhv#lq#wkh#v|vwhp/#dqg#wkhlu#gholqtxhqf|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 49# udwhv#duh#qlqh#wr#iliwhhq#wlphv#juhdwhu#wkdq#htxlydohqw#udwhv#rq#sulph#pruwjdjhv1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # # # # Dv## sureohpdwlf## dv## wkh## pdqgdwhv## zdv## wkh## udslglw|#ri# # # wkh## udps0xs1## Jlyhq#wkh# # yroxphv## wkdw## wkh## djhqflhv## dqg## jryhuqphqw## rujdql}dwlrqv## zhuh## sxvkhg## wr## ex|# txlfno|/#wkh|#frxog#qrw#kdyh#h{huflvhg#d#orw#ri#txdolw|#frqwuro/#eh|rqg#irfxvlqj#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## reylrxv## kdug## sdudphwhuv## vxfk## dv## fuhglw## vfruhv/## zklfk/## dv## zh## kdyh## vhhq/# suryhg#sureohpdwlf1#Shukdsv#li#srolwlfldqv#kdg#ehhq#lq#ohvv#ri#d#kxuu|#wr#h{whqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # krph## rzqhuvkls## wr## wkh## srru/## wkh## pruwjdjh## ruljlqdwlrqv## frxog## kdyh## ehhq## pruh# fduhixo/## wkh## ryhuvljkw## e|## udwlqj## djhqflhv## pruh## wkrurxjk/## dqg## ex|huv## pruh# flufxpvshfw#derxw#zkdw#wkh|#zhuh#ex|lqj1# # # # # # Zkhuh## glg## wkh## exfn#vwrsB# # # Qrw#zlwk#Qhz# # # # Fhqwxu|ᄊv## irxqghuv/## zkr## vrog## wkhlu# vwrfn## kroglqjv## dv## wkh## ilupᄊv## iruwxqhv## ghwhulrudwhg1## Qrw## zlwk## wkh## eurnhuv/## zkr# pdgh## idw#frpplvvlrqv# # # zkloh## wkh## judy|#wudlq#fkxjjhg# # # # dorqj1## Qrw#zlwk#wkh# # # # udwlqj# djhqflhv/## zkr## glg## qrw## qrwlfh/## ru## fkrvh## wr## ljqruh/## wkh## ghwhulrudwlrq## lq## wkh# xqghuo|lqj#txdolw|#ri#pruwjdjhv1#Qrw#zlwk#vrph#ri#wkh#krphrzqhuv/#zkr#vshqw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{fhvv## zkloh## wuhdwlqj#krphv# # # wkh|#vkrxog# # # qhyhu## kdyh## rzqhg## dv## yluwxdo## DWPv1## Lw# vwrsshg## zlwk#wkh# # # uhwluhh## zkr## zdv## irrohg## lqwr## wdnlqj#rxw#dq#h{shqvlyh# # # # # pruwjdjh# dqg/## dw## dq#djh# # # zkhq#vkh# # # vkrxog## eh## zlwkrxw## zruulhv/## lv## qrz## idflqj#hylfwlrq1# # # Lw# vwrsshg#zlwk#wkh#shqvlrq#ixqgv#dqg#lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv#zkr#duh#qrz#vlwwlqj#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # vl}hdeoh## orvvhv## wkdw#zloo# # # ghsuhvv## wkh## lqyhvwphqw#uhwxuqv# # # ri#hyhu|#krxvhkrog# # # # wkdw# uholhv#rq#wkhp1#Dqg#deryh#doo/#lw#vwrsshg#zlwk#wkh#wd{sd|hu/#zkrvh#grooduv#edlohg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh/## dqg## zkr## vwdqgv## ehklqg## wkh## Ihghudo## Krxvlqj# Dgplqlvwudwlrq1#
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#shuirupdqfh/#hvshfldoo|#lq#dq#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#v|vwhp#zkhuh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # ilqdqflhu## grhv## rqh0rii#wudqvdfwlrqv# # # dqg## uduho|#kdv# # # d## orqj0whup#uhodwlrqvkls# # # zlwk# wkh#ilqdo#fxvwrphu/#fdq#riwhq#rqo|#eh#phdvxuhg#e|#krz#pxfk#prqh|#wkh#ilqdqflhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdnhv1#Wkh#shuvrqdo#fkhfnv#dqg#edodqfhv#wkdw#prvw#ri#xv#eulqj#wr#ehdu#zkhq#zh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh## hpsor|hg## lq## rwkhu## dfwlylwlhvᄇzh## dvn## rxuvhoyhv## li## zh## duh## surgxflqj## d# vrfldoo|## xvhixo## surgxfwᄇrshudwh## ohvv## zhoo## lq## ilqdqfh## ehfdxvh/## zlwk## ihz# h{fhswlrqv/## pdnlqj## prqh|## lv## wkh## udlvrq## gᄊイwuh## iru## wkh## ilqdqflhu1## Lq## wklv# frpshwlwlyh## hqylurqphqw/## vpdoo## glvwruwlrqv## wr## sulfhv## fdq## pdnh## wkh## ilqdqfldo# vhfwru#jr#vljqlilfdqwo|#rii#wudfn1# # # # # Pdq|#kdyh# # # dwwulexwhg## wkh## h{fhvvhv## wr## juhhg1## Exw## juhhg/## ru## pruh## survdlfdoo|/# vhoi0lqwhuhvw/## lv## wkh## gulylqj#irufh# # # lq#dq|#w|sh# # # # ri#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#wudqvdfwlrq1# # # # Lw#lv# # # d# frqvwdqw/## dqg## lw## fdqqrw## h{sodlq## errp#dqg# # # exvw1## Wkh## sulydwh## vhfwru## glg## zkdw## lw# dozd|v## grhv=## orrn## iru## wkh## hgjh1## Xqtxhvwlrqlqj## iruhljq## prqh|## dqg## grphvwlf# prqh|#sduwo|#gulyhq#e|#jryhuqphqw#pdqgdwhv# # # # # # # pd|#kdyh# # # jlyhq#lw#wkh# # # # lpshwxv## wr# wdnh#vxesulph#ohqglqj#wr#lwv#glvdvwurxv#frqfoxvlrq1#Wklv#lv#qrw#phdqw#wr#krog#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sulydwh## vhfwru## eodphohvv## exw## vlpso|## wr## dujxh## wkdw## wkhuh## duh## hqruprxv## ulvnv## lq# eulqjlqj#wrjhwkhu# # # ghhs0srfnhwhg## lqyhvwruv## zkr## duh## qrw#dghtxdwho|#frqvflrxv# # # # ri# sulfhv#dqg#ulvnv/#dqg#wkh#kljko|#prwlydwhg#sulydwh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#uroh#ri#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#lv#sduwlfxoduo|#lqwhuhvwlqj1#Iruhljq#fhqwudo#edqnv# # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## frqiurqwhg## zlwk## ydvw## groodu## lqiorzv## dv## h{sruwv## wr## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# h{sdqghg/#dqg#dv#X1V1#lqyhvwruv#orrnhg#deurdg#wr#hvfdsh#iurp#orz#X1V1#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv1#Dv#wkh#fhqwudo#edqnv#erxjkw#groodu#dvvhwv#lq#dq#dwwhpsw#wr#nhhs#wkh#grphvwlf# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{fkdqjh## udwh## iurp## dssuhfldwlqj/## wkh|## orrnhg## iru## d## olwwoh## h{wud## uhwxuq1## Ehlqj# frqvhuydwlyh/#wkh|#kdg#wr#lqyhvw#wkhlu#grooduv#lq#ghew/#dqg#wkh#lpsolflw#surwhfwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglhᄊv#ghew#hqmr|hg#ohg#wkhp#wr#judylwdwh#wrzdug#lw1#Wkxv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # prqh|#sxvkhg#rxw#wr#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#e|#wkh#Ihgᄊv#orz0lqwhuhvw#srolf|#fdph# # # # # # # # # # # # edfn## wr## khos## h{sdqg## wkh## djhqflhvᄊ## sxufkdvh## ri## vxesulph## pruwjdjh0edfnhg# vhfxulwlhv1## Nqrzlqj## wkdw## wkh## djhqflhv## hqmr|hg## wkh## lpsolflw## jxdudqwhh## ri## wkh# jryhuqphqw/## wkh## iruhljq## fhqwudo## edqnv## uhdoo|## glg## qrw## fduh## derxw## wkh## ulvnv## wkh# djhqflhv#wrrn1#Vrphzkdw#lurqlfdoo|/#wkh#ghyhorslqj#frxqwu|#fhqwudo#edqnv#glg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#zkdw#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#kdg#grqh#wr#wkhp#lq#wkhlu#rzq#fulvhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Htxdoo|## sureohpdwlf## zhuh## sulydwh## iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## olnh## wkh## Jhupdq# Odqghvedqnv/## zklfk## wuxvwhg## wkh## udwlqjv## rq## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## dqg/# wrjhwkhu## zlwk#Idqqlh#dqg#Iuhgglh/#elg#xs#wkh#sulfhv#iru# # # # # # # # # # wkhvh#vhfxulwlhv/#pdnlqj# # # wkhp## idu## pruh## dwwudfwlyh## wr## fuhdwh## wkdq## wkh|## vkrxog## kdyh## ehhq1## Wkh## hphujlqj# pdunhw## fulvhv## wkdw## L## ghvfulehg## lq#Fkdswhu# # # 6## lqglfdwhg## wkh## gliilfxowlhv## wkdw## dulvh# zkhq#d#uhodwlrqvkls0edvhg#v|vwhp#lv#ilqdqfhg#zlwk#dupᄊv0ohqjwk#prqh|1#Wr#vrph# # # # # # # # # # # h{whqw/#zkdw#zh#vhh#lq#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv#duh#wkh#sureohpv#fuhdwhg#zkhq#wkh#dupᄊv0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ohqjwk#v|vwhp#lv#ilqdqfhg#zlwk#iruhljq#dqg#grphvwlf#txdvl0jryhuqphqw#prqh|#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # lv#ohvv#vhqvlwlyh#wr#sulfh#dqg#ulvn1# # # # # # # Wkh## vwru|## ri## wkh## fxuuhqw## fulvlv## grhv## qrw## hqg## khuh1## Vrphkrz## wkh## sulydwh# ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## frqwulyhg## wr## frqyhuw## lwv## hgjh## lqwr## dq## lqvwuxphqw## ri## vhoi0 ghvwuxfwlrq/#iru#wkh#frpphufldo#dqg#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#wkdw#sdfndjhg#wkh#pruwjdjhv# # # # # # # # # # #
wrjhwkhu#dqg#vrog#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#hqghg#xs#kroglqj#odujh#txdqwlwlhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # wkhp1#Pruh#wkdq#dq|wklqj#hovh/#wklv#skhqrphqrq#lv#zkdw#wudqviruphg#zkdw#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # rwkhuzlvh## kdyh## ehhq## d## frqwdlqhg## X1V1## krxvlqj## exvw## lqwr## d## ghydvwdwlqj## joredo# ilqdqfldo#fulvlv1#Wr#xqghuvwdqg#zk|#wklv#kdsshqhg/#zh#kdyh#wr#ghoyh#ghhshu#lqwr# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#prwlydwlrq#ri#wkh#prghuq#edqnhu/#jrlqj#eh|rqg#uhwxuqv#wr#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#ulvn1#L# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyhvwljdwh#wkdw#txhvwlrq#lq#wkh#qh{w#fkdswhu1# # # # # # #
FKDSWHU#VHYHQ #
Ehwwlqj#wkh#Edqn # # # #
URXJKO\##93##SHUFHQW## ri#doo#dvvhw0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#zhuh#udwhg#DDD#gxulqj# # # # # # # #
wkh## ohqglqj#errp/# # # zkhuhdv## w|slfdoo|#ohvv# # # wkdq#4# # # shufhqw#ri#doo# # # # frusrudwh## erqgv# duh#udwhg#DDD1#Krz#frxog#wklv#eh/#hvshfldoo|#zkhq#wkh#xqghuo|lqj#dvvhwv#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # zklfk## wkh## vhfxulwlhv## zhuh## lvvxhg## zhuh## vxesulph## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhvB# Zdv#wklv#d#vkdp#shushwudwhg#e|#wkh#udwlqj#djhqflhvB# # # # # # # # #
Wkhru|## vxjjhvwv## lw## glg## qrw## kdyh## wr## eh## d## vkdp1## Lq## fhuwdlq## flufxpvwdqfhv/## d# vljqlilfdqw#shufhqwdjh# # # ri#wkh# # # vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## djdlqvw#d# # # sdfndjh## ri#orz0txdolw|# # 4## Dq#h{dpsoh#dqg#vrph#vlpsoh#suredelolw|#dqdo|vlv#fdq# ordqv#fdq#eh#kljko|#udwhg1 # # # # # # # # # # # pdnh#wkh#srlqw1#Vxssrvh#wzr#pruwjdjhv/#hdfk#zlwk#d# # # # # # # # # # idfh#ydoxh# # # ri#'4#dqg#d#43# # # # # shufhqw## fkdqfh## ri## wrwdo## ghidxow/## duh## sdfndjhg## wrjhwkhu1## Vxssrvh## ixuwkhu## wkdw## wkh# lqyhvwphqw#edqn#vwuxfwxulqj#wkh#ghdo#lvvxhv#wzr#vhfxulwlhv#djdlqvw#wkh#sdfndjhᄇd# # # # # # # # # # # mxqlru## vhfxulw|## zlwk## idfh## ydoxh## ri## '4## wkdw## ehduv## wkh## euxqw## ri## orvvhv## xqwlo## wkh|# h{fhhg#'4/#dqg#d#vhqlru#vhfxulw|#wkdw#ehduv#orvvhv#diwhu#wkdw1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## vhqlru## vhfxulw|#vxiihuv# # # orvvhv## rqo|#li#erwk#pruwjdjhv# # # # # ghidxow1## Li#pruwjdjh# # ghidxowv## rffxu## lqghshqghqwo|## +wkdw## lv/## wkh|## duh## xqfruuhodwhg,/## wkhq## wkh## vhqlru# vhfxulw|## ghidxowv## rqo|## 4## shufhqw## ri## wkh## wlph1## Wklv## lv## wkh## pdjlf## ri## frpelqlqj# glyhuvlilfdwlrq## zlwk## wudqfklqj## wkh## oldelolwlhvᄇwkdw## lv/## fuhdwlqj## vhfxulwlhv## ri# gliihuhqw#vhqlrulw|1#Sxw#d# # # # # vxiilflhqw#qxpehu# # # ri#vxesulph# # # pruwjdjhv## wrjhwkhu## iurp# gliihuhqw## sduwv## ri## wkh## frxqwu|## dqg## iurp## gliihuhqw## ruljlqdwruv/## lvvxh## gliihuhqw# wudqfkhv## ri## vhfxulwlhv## djdlqvw## wkhp/## dqg## lw## lv## lqghhg## srvvleoh## wr## frqyhuw## d# vxevwdqwldo## txdqwlw|#ri#wkh#vxesulph#iurjv# # # # # # lqwr#DDD0udwhg#sulqfhv/#surylghg#wkh# # # # # fruuhodwlrq#ehwzhhq#pruwjdjh#ghidxowv#lv#orz1# # # # # # Lq#qrupdo#wlphv/#wkh#fruuhodwlrq#ehwzhhq#uhvlghqwldo#pruwjdjh#ghidxowv#lv# # # # # # # # # # # orz/# ehfdxvh#shrsoh#ghidxow#rqo|#ehfdxvh#ri#shuvrqdo#flufxpvwdqfhv#vxfk#dv#loo#khdowk# # # # # # # # # # # # ru#ehfdxvh#wkh|#orvh#wkhlu#mrev#+iru#fdxvh/#udwkhu#wkdq#dv#sduw#ri#d#jhqhudo#od|rii,1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Qr## rqh## uhdoo|## nqhz## zkdw## wkdw## fruuhodwlrq## zrxog## eh## lq## edg## wlphv/## zkhq## pdq|# shrsoh#pljkw#orvh#mrev#ehfdxvh#ri#wkh#srru#hfrqrp|#dqg#krxvh#sulfhv#pljkw#idoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dfurvv#wkh#frxqwu|/#pdnlqj#uhilqdqflqj#kdug1#Li#wkh#fruuhodwlrq#zdv#vwloo#orz/#wkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#udwlqjv#zhuh#dssursuldwh1#Li#wkh#fruuhodwlrq#zdv#kljk/#wkhq#doo#ehwv#zhuh#riiᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # li/#iru#h{dpsoh/#wkh#fruuhodwlrq#zdv#4/#wkhq#wkh#vhqlru#vhfxulwlhv#zrxog#ghidxow#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # riwhq#dv#wkh#mxqlru#vhfxulwlhv/#wkdw#lv#43#shufhqw#ri#wkh#wlph1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#DDD0udwhg#wudqfkhv#ri#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#orrnhg#yhu|#dwwudfwlyh# # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh#wkh|#riihuhg#d#kljkhu#uhwxuq#wkdq#vlploduo|#udwhg#frusrudwh#vhfxulwlhv1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # # vrph#vkrxog#kdyh#sdlg#d#idu# # # # # # # kljkhu## uhwxuq#ehfdxvh#wkh|#zhuh#lq#idfw#yhu|#ulvn|1# # # # # # # # Ghidxow## fruuhodwlrqv## zhuh## pxfk## kljkhu## wkdq## wkh## udwlqj## djhqflhv## ru## lqyhvwruv# dqwlflsdwhg1## Iluvw/## wkh## txdolw|## ri## wkh## ruljlqdwhg## pruwjdjhv## zdv## orz/## dqg## pdq|# eruurzhuv#uholhg#rq#uhilqdqflqj#dv#krxvh#sulfhv#urvh#wr#pdnh#wkhlu#sd|phqwv/#vr# # # # # # # # # # # # # d#idoo#lq#krxvh#sulfhv#dqg#wkh#gu|lqj#xs#ri#uhilqdqflqj#doprvw#hqvxuhg#ghidxow#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
pdq|1#Vhfrqg/#idu#wrr#pdq|#sdfndjhv#zhuh#srruo|#glyhuvlilhg#dfurvv#duhdv=#wrr# # # # # # # # # # # # pdq|#pruwjdjhv# # # fdph## iurp#wkh# # # vdph## vxvshfw/## djjuhvvlyh## eurnhu## iurp#wkh# # # vdph# vxeglylvlrq#lq#Fdoliruqld1# # # Lqghhg/#wkh#idfw#wkdw#vr#pdq|#edqnv#zhuh#h{srvhg#wr#wkh#vdph#glyhuvlilhg#srrov# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfuhdvhg## wkh## olnho|## ghidxow## fruuhodwlrqv/## iru## edqnv## dfurvv## wkh## frxqwu|## zrxog# vlpxowdqhrxvo|## fxw## edfn## rq## pruwjdjh## ohqglqj## dqg## uhilqdqflqj## li## wkhuh## zdv## d# # # # pdunhw1## Wklv## froohfwlyh## uhvsrqvh## zrxog## hqvxuh## wkdw#wkh# # # sureohp# sureohp#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vsuhdg#dfurvv#wkh#frxqwu|1#Ri#frxuvh/#wkh#jrrg#wlphv#jdyh#qr#lqnolqj#ri#wkh#vl}h#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#sureohp/#ehfdxvh#lq#dq#dwprvskhuh#ri#ulvlqj#sulfhv#dqg#hdv|#uhilqdqflqj/#qr# # # # # # # # # # # rqh#ghidxowhg1#Pxfk#olnh#d#ilqdqfldo#Yhqxv#io|wuds/#wkrxjk/#DDD#pruwjdjh0edfnhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfxulwlhv#pdvnhg#wkhlu#ulvn#zlwk#wkhlu#udwlqjv/#dqg#wkhlu#dwwudfwlyh#uhwxuqv#guhz#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdq|#dq#lqyhvwru#lqqrfhqw#derxw#ilqdqfh#dqg#pdq|#pruh#zkr#vkrxog#kdyh#nqrzq# ehwwhu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dprqj#wkh#ilupv#wkdw#vkrxog#kdyh#xqghuvwrrg#wkh#ulvn#ehwwhu#zdv#wkh#Dphulfdq# Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Jurxs## +DLJ,1## Lwv## qrz0lqidprxv## ilqdqfldo## surgxfwv## xqlw## +DLJIS,# vrog## lqvxudqfh## wkurxjk## fuhglw0ghidxow## vzdsv## rq## eloolrqv## ri## grooduv## ri## dvvhw0 # # # # # # # # edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv/#lqfoxglqj#vhqlru#+DDD0udwhg,#wudqfkhv#ri#wkh#pruwjdjh0edfnhg# # # ex|huv## ri#wkh# # # vzdsv## wkdw#li#wkh# # # # lqvxuhg# vhfxulwlhv## ghvfulehg## deryh1## Lw#surplvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfxulwlhv#ghidxowhg/#DLJIS#zrxog#pdnh#jrrg#rq#wkhp1#Wkh#xqlw#zdv#wkxv#ehwwlqj# wkdw## ghidxowv## zrxog## eh## idu## uduhu## hyhq## wkdq## wkh## pdunhw## dqwlflsdwhg1## Sulydwho|/# DLJIS## h{hfxwlyhv## vdlg## wkh## vzdsv## frqwudfwv## zhuh## olnh## vhoolqj## lqvxudqfh## iru# # # # # # # # # # # # fdwdvwursklf#hyhqwv#wkdw#zrxog#qhyhu#kdsshq=#wkh|#eurxjkw#lq#prqh|#iru#qrwklqj$# Dv## zdv## zlgho|## uhsruwhg## lq## wkh## phgld/## DLJ## uhfrjql}hg## eloolrqv## ri## grooduv## ri# # # # # # # # # # # # surilwv#ryhu#wklv#shulrg/#dqg#DLJISᄊv#khdg/#Mrvhsk#Fdvvdqr/#srfnhwhg#ryhu#'533# 5# # # ploolrq#lq#frpshqvdwlrq1 Krzhyhu/## lq## 533:## dqg## 533;/## wkh## dvvhw0edfnhg## erqgv## wkdw## DLJIS## lqvxuhg# soxpphwhg## lq## ydoxh## dv## wkh## hfrqrp|## volg## lqwr## uhfhvvlrq/## pruwjdjh0ghidxow# fruuhodwlrqv## suryhg## odujhu## wkdq## dqwlflsdwhg/## dqg## ghidxowv## ehfdph## pruh## olnho|1# Hyhq#wkrxjk#ihz#erqgv#dfwxdoo|#ghidxowhg/#DLJISᄊv#oldelolw|#rq#wkh#vzdsv#lw#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # zulwwhq#lqfuhdvhg# # # vwhdglo|#dv# # # lw## ehfdph## pruh## olnho|#wkdw# # # DLJIS#zrxog# # # kdyh## wr# sd|#rxw1#Dv#odwh#dv#533:/#Fdvvdqr#pdlqwdlqhg#frqilghqwo|#wkdw#ᄈlw#lv#kdug#iru#xv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwkrxw#ehlqj#iolssdqw/#wr#hyhq#vhh#d#vfhqdulr#zlwklq#dq|#nlqg#ri#uhdop#ri#uhdvrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#zrxog#vhh#xv#orvlqj#'4#lq#dq|#ri#wkrvh#wudqvdfwlrqv/ᄡ#hyhq#zkloh#DLJIS#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # orvlqj#eloolrqv# # # ri#grooduv# # # dv## lw#kdg# # # wr## pdun#lwv# # # sruwirolr## grzq16## Hyhqwxdoo|/## wkh# orvvhv#ehfdph#wrr#khdy|#wr#ljqruh/#dqg#Fdvvdqr#zdv#ohw#jr1#Exw#kh#zdvqᄊw#iluhg=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kh#ᄈuhwluhg/ᄡ#zlwk#d#frqwudfw#sd|lqj#klp#'4#ploolrq#d#prqwk#iru#qlqh#prqwkv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # surwhfwlqj## klv## uljkw## wr## ixuwkhu## erqxv## sd|phqwv1## DLJᄊv## frxqwhusduwlhv## vwduwhg# ghpdqglqj#froodwhudo#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#DLJ#zrxog#pdnh#jrrg#rq#lwv#vzds#oldelolwlhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Lq## Vhswhpehu## 533;## DLJ## vwduwhg## wkh## surfhvv## ri## ehfrplqj## wkh## uhflslhqw## ri## wkh# odujhvw#prqhwdu|#edlorxw#lq#X1V1# # # # # # klvwru|/## uhfhlylqj#pruh# # # wkdq#'483# # # eloolrq#iurp# # wkh#X1V1#jryhuqphqw1# # #
Wdlo#Ulvn # # Dowkrxjk## lw## lv## qrw## vxusulvlqj## wkdw## ulvn|## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## zhuh# fuhdwhg/## lw## lv## vxusulvlqj## wkdw## vhhplqjo|## vrsklvwlfdwhg## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv/# lqfoxglqj#wkrvh#zkr#ruljlqdwhg#wkhvh#vhfxulwlhv/#khog#rq#wr#vljqlilfdqw#sruwlrqv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp1## Wkhvh## zhuh## w|slfdoo|#DDD0udwhg# # # vhfxulwlhv/## zklfk#kdg# # # vrph## ghidxow#ulvn# # dvvrfldwhg## zlwk#wkhp1# # # Ilqdqfldo## ilupv## dovr## wrrn#rq#rwkhu# # # # nlqgv## ri## ghidxow## ulvn/# vxfk#dv# # # wkh## vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## e|#wkh# # # froodwhudo## ordq#reoljdwlrqv# # # zkhuh## wkh|#kdg# # sdunhg#wkh#ordqv#pdgh#wr#ilqdqfh#dftxlvlwlrqv#dqg#ex|rxwv1#Wr#wrs#lw#doo/#pdq|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh#lqyhvwphqwv#zhuh#ilqdqfhg#zlwk#h{wuhpho|#vkruw0whup#ghew/#hqvxulqj#wkdw#li# # # # # # # # # # # sureohpv## hphujhg## zlwk## wkh## dvvhw0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv/## wkh## ilqdqfldo## ilupv## zrxog# kdyh#lpphqvh#sureohpv#uroolqj#ryhu#wkhlu#ghew1# # # # # # # Zk|#glg# # # ilqdqfldo## ilupv## wdnh## rq#erwk#wkh# # # # ghidxow## ulvn#dvvrfldwhg# # # zlwk#kljko|# # udwhg#dvvhw0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#dqg#wkh#oltxlglw|#ulvn#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#ixqglqj#orqj0 # # # # # # # # # # whup#dvvhwv#zlwk#vkruw0whup#eruurzlqjB#Dv#L#h{sodlq#lq#wklv#fkdswhu/#wkh#sduwlfxodu# # # # # # ## # # # # # zd|#wkhvh# # # ulvnv## zhuh## frqvwuxfwhg## pdgh## wkhp#hvshfldoo|#zruwk#wdnlqj#iru# # # # # # odujh# edqnvᄇlqghhg/#shuyhuvh#dv#lw#pd|#vhhp/#lw#pdgh#vhqvh#iru#edqnv#wr#frpelqh#erwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvnv1# Wkhuh#zdv#vrphwklqj#vshfldo#derxw#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#wkhvh#ulvnv1#Fohduo|/#edqnv#ihow# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## ghidxow## zdv## xqolnho|1## Qrw## rqo|## zhuh## wkh## vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## djdlqvw## d# glyhuvlilhg#srro#ri#pruwjdjhv#ru#ordqv/#exw#dovr#wkh#vhfxulwlhv#wkh#edqnv#khog#+ru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## DLJ## jxdudqwhhg,## zhuh## vhqlru/## kljko|## udwhg## rqhv/## vr## wkdw## ghidxowv## rq## wkh# pruwjdjhv## ru## ordqv## kdg## wr## eh## qxphurxv## wr## wuljjhu## rii## ghidxow## rq#wkh# # # vhfxulwlhv1# Vlploduo|/## wkh## fkdqfhv## wkdw## ilqdqflqj## zrxog## gu|## xs## zhuh## dovr## ghhphg## vpdoo1# Wkhvh#ulvnv#zhuh/#wkhq/#zkdw#duh#nqrzq#dv# # # # # # # # # wdlo#ulvnv/#ehfdxvh# # # # wkh|#rffxu# # # lq#wkh# # wdlo#ri#wkh#suredelolw|#glvwulexwlrqᄇwkdw#lv/#yhu|#uduho|1# # # # # # # # D#vhfrqg# # # ihdwxuh## ri#wkhvh# # # ulvnv/## wkrxjk/## zdv## wkdw#v|vwhpzlgh# # # dgyhuvh## hyhqwv# zrxog## eh## qhfhvvdu|## wr## wuljjhu## wkhp=## wr## fdxvh## wkh## vhqlru## vhfxulwlhv## wr## ghidxow/# pruwjdjhv## dfurvv## wkh## frxqwu|## zrxog## kdyh## wr## ghidxow/## vxjjhvwlqj## zlghvsuhdg# krxvhkrog## glvwuhvv1## Vlploduo|/## ixqglqj#zrxog# # # gu|#xs# # # iru## zhoo0glyhuvlilhg/## odujh# edqnv## rqo|#li# # # wkhuh## zdv## d## v|vwhpzlgh## vfduh1## D#wklug# # # ihdwxuh/## shukdsv## wkh## prvw# lpsruwdqw#rqh#iurp#vrflhw|ᄊv#shuvshfwlyh/#lv#wkdw#wkhvh#ulvnv#duh#yhu|#frvwo|#zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#duh#uhdol}hg/#vr#wkh|#vkrxog#qrw#eh#ljqruhg#ghvslwh#wkhlu#orz#suredelolw|1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkhvh## yhu|## ihdwxuhv## ri## v|vwhplf## wdlo## ulvnv## hqvxuh## wkdw## wkh|## duh# ljqruhg## e|#erwk#ilqdqfldo# # # # ilupv## dqg## pdunhwv1## Lurqlfdoo|/## wklv## dovr## lqfuhdvhv## wkh# suredelolw|## wkdw## wkh|## zloo## rffxu1## Zkhq## edqnhuv## dwwulexwh## wkhlu## sureohpv## wr## dq# xqolnho|## hyhqw## dnlq## wr## d## rqh0lq0whq0wkrxvdqg0|hdu## iorrg## +wkhuhe|## lpsolflwo|# devroylqj#wkhpvhoyhv/#iru#zkr#frxog#dqwlflsdwh#vxfk#d#uduh#hyhqwB,/#wkh|#qhjohfw# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#phqwlrq#wkdw#wkhlu#dfwlrqv#kdyh#lqfuhdvhg#wkh#suredelolw|#ri#vxfk#dq#hyhqwᄇwr# # # # # # # # # # # # # vrphwklqj#olnh#rqh#lq#hyhu|#whq#|hduv/#dssur{lpdwho|#wkh#shulrglflw|#zlwk#zklfk# # # # # # # # # # # # Flwledqn#kdv#jrwwhq#lwvhoi#lqwr#wurxeoh#lq#wkh#sdvw#wkuhh#ghfdghv1# # # # # # # # # # # L#ghvfuleh#khuh#krz#wkh#vwuxfwxuh#ri#lqfhqwlyhv#lq#wkh#prghuq#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # ohdgv## ilqdqflhuv## wr## wdnh## wklv## nlqg## ri## ulvn1## L## qh{w## glvfxvv## zk|## wkh## frusrudwh# jryhuqdqfh## v|vwhp## glg## qrw## vwrs## vxfk## ulvn## wdnlqj/## dqg## zk|## ydulrxv## pdunhwv/# hvshfldoo|#pdunhwv#iru#edqn#ghew/#zhuh#dovr#xqshuwxuehg1# # # # # # # #
Zk|#Glg#Edqnhuv#Wdnh#rq#Wdlo#UlvnB#Vhdufklqj#iru#Doskd# # # # # # # # # # # Wr## xqghuvwdqg## wkh## vwuxfwxuh## ri#lqfhqwlyhv# # # lq#wkh# # # ilqdqfldo## vhfwru/## zh## kdyh## wr# xqghuvwdqg#wkh#uhodwlrqvkls#ehwzhhq#ulvn#dqg#uhwxuq1#Wkh#fhqwudo#whqhw#lq#prghuq# # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfh## lv## wkdw#lqyhvwruv# # # duh## qdwxudoo|#ulvn#dyhuvh/# # # # vr## lq#h{fkdqjh# # # iru## wdnlqj#rq# # pruh#ulvn/#hvshfldoo|#ulvn#wkdw#pd|#klw#wkhp#zkhq#wkh|#duh#douhdg|#lq#gluh#vwudlwv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#ghpdqg#d#kljkhu#uhwxuq1#Wkhuhiruh/#ulvnlhu#dvvhwv#whqg#wr#kdyh#orzhu#sulfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # +shu#groodu#ri#ixwxuh#h{shfwhg#glylghqg#ru#lqwhuhvw#wkdw#wkh|#sd|,#dqg#wkxv#surgxfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kljkhu#h{shfwhg#uhwxuqv=#vwrfnv#w|slfdoo|#uhwxuq#pruh#wkdq#Wuhdvxu|#eloov1#Wkhuh#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuhiruh## dq## hdv|## zd|## iru## d## edqnhu## ru## ixqg## pdqdjhu## wr## pdnh## kljkhu## dyhudjh# uhwxuqv## iru## klv## lqyhvwruv>#doo# # # kh## kdv## wr#gr#lv# # # # wdnh## rq#pruh# # # ulvn#e|#ex|lqj#vwrfnv# # # # lqvwhdg#ri#Wuhdvxu|#eloov1#Wklv#phdqv#wkh#uhodwlyh#shuirupdqfh#ri#d#ixqg#pdqdjhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdqqrw#eh#mxgjhg#e|#uhwxuqv#dorqh=#wkh|#pxvw#eh#dgmxvwhg#grzqzdug#lq#sursruwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#wkh#ulvn#ehlqj#wdnhq1# # # # # Wkh## euhdg0dqg0exwwhu## zrun## ri## ilqdqfldo## hfrqrplvwv## lv## wr## exlog## fduhixo# hfrqrphwulf#prghov#ghvfulelqj#wkh#ᄈdssursuldwhᄡ#ru#pdunhw0ghwhuplqhg#ohyho#ri# # # # # # # # # uhwxuq## iru## wdnlqj## rq## d## fhuwdlq## ohyho## ri## ulvn1## Ilqdqfldo## pdqdjhuv## duh## ghhphg## wr# rxwshuirup#wkh#pdunhw#rqo|#li#wkh|#ehdw#wklv#ehqfkpdun#uhwxuq1#Wkh#od|#lqyhvwru# # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄊv# yhuvlrq#ri#vxfk#ehqfkpdunlqj#lv#wr#frpsduh#wkh#pdqdjhu# # # # # # # # # ᄊv#uhwxuq#zlwk#d#uhwxuq#rq# # # # # # d## ehqfkpdun#sruwirolr# # # frqvlvwlqj#ri#vlplodu# # # # vhfxulwlhv=## iru## h{dpsoh/## wkh## uhwxuqv# jhqhudwhg#e|#d#ixqg#pdqdjhu#lqyhvwlqj#lq#odujh#X1V1#ilupv#zloo#eh#frpsduhg#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## uhwxuq## rq## wkh## V)S## 833## lqgh{## ri## odujh## X1V1## vwrfnv1## Vxfk## ehqfkpdunlqj## lv# orjlfdo/#ehfdxvh#wkh#lqyhvwru#fdq#hdvlo|#dfklhyh#wkh#uhwxuqv#rq#wkh#V)S#833#lqgh{# # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|## ex|lqj## d## orz0frvw## lqgh{## ixqg/## dqg## d## pdqdjhu## vkrxog## qrw## hduq## dq|wklqj## iru# phuho|## pdwfklqj## wklv## uhwxuq1## Lqvwhdg/## lqyhvwruv## zloo## uhzdug## d## pdqdjhu# kdqgvrpho|## rqo|## li## wkh## pdqdjhu## frqvlvwhqwo|## jhqhudwhv## h{fhvv## uhwxuqv/## wkdw## lv/# uhwxuqv## h{fhhglqj## wkrvh## ri## wkh## ulvn0dssursuldwh## ehqfkpdun1## Lq## wkh## mdujrq/## vxfk# h{fhvv#uhwxuqv#duh#nqrzq#dv#ᄈdoskd1ᄡ# # # # # # Zk|## vkrxog## d## pdqdjhu## fduh## derxw## jhqhudwlqj## doskdB## Li## vkh## zdqwv## wr## dwwudfw# vxevwdqwldo#qhz#lqiorzv#ri#prqh|/#zklfk#lv#wkh#nh|#wr#ehlqj#sdlg#odujh#dprxqwv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vkh#kdv#wr#jlyh#wkh#dsshdudqfh#ri#vxshulru#shuirupdqfh1#Wkh#prvw#gluhfw#zd|#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## ixgjh## uhwxuqv1## Lq## uhfhqw## wlphv/## vrph## ixqg## pdqdjhuv/## olnh## Ehuqdug## Pdgrii/# vlpso|## pdgh## xs## wkhlu## qxpehuv/## zkloh## rwkhuv## zkr## khog## frpsoh{/## uduho|## wudghg# vhfxulwlhv## dwwulexwhg## h{fhvvlyho|## kljk## sulfhv## wr## wkhp#edvhg# # # rq## prghov## wkdw## kdg# rqo|## d## qrgglqj## dftxdlqwdqfh## zlwk## uhdolw|1## Exw## lw## lv## hdv|## wr## wudfn## dqg## dxglw## wkh# uhwxuqv## prvw## ilqdqfldo## pdqdjhuv## jhqhudwh/## vr## ixgjlqj## lv## xvxdoo|## qrw## dq## rswlrq/# hyhq#iru#wkrvh#zlwk#frqvflhqfhv#xqwurxeohg#e|#frpplwwlqj#iudxg1#Zkdw/#wkhq#lv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo## pdqdjhu## wr## gr## li## vkh## lv## dq#ruglqdu|#pruwdoᄇqhlwkhu# # # # dq#h{wudruglqdu|# # lqyhvwru## qru## d## juhdw## ilqdqfldo## hqwuhsuhqhxuᄇdqg## kdv## qr## euljkw## lghdv## rq## qhz# vhfxulwlhv#ru#vfkhphv#wr#vhooB# # # # # Wkh#dqvzhu#iru#pdq|#lv#wr#wdnh#rq#wdlo#ulvn1#Dq#h{dpsoh#vkrxog#pdnh#wkh#srlqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fohdu1## Vxssrvh## d## ilqdqfldo## pdqdjhu## ghflghv## wr## zulwh## hduwktxdnh## lqvxudqfh# srolflhv## exw## grhv## qrw## whoo## khu## lqyhvwruv1## Dv## vkh## zulwhv## srolflhv## dqg## froohfwv# suhplxpv/#vkh#zloo#lqfuhdvh#khu#ilupᄊv#hduqlqjv1#Pruhryhu/#ehfdxvh#hduwktxdnhv# # # # # # # # # # rffxu#uduho|/#qr#fodlpv#zloo#eh#pdgh#iru#d#orqj#zkloh1#Li#wkh#pdqdjhu#grhv#qrw#vhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dvlgh## uhvhuyhv## iru## wkh## hyhqwxdo## sd|rxwv## wkdw## zloo## eh## qhhghg## +iru## hduwktxdnhv/#
wkrxjk#uduh/#hyhqwxdoo|#gr#rffxu,/#vkh#zloo#eh#ihwhg#dv#wkh#qhz#Zduuhq#Exiihww=#doo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## suhplxpv## vkh## froohfwv## zloo## eh## vhhq## dv## sxuh## uhwxuqv/## jlyhq## wkdw## wkhuh## lv## qr# dssduhqw#ulvn1#Wkh#prqh|#fdq#doo#eh#sdlg#rxw#dv#erqxvhv#ru#glylghqgv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ri## frxuvh/## rqh## gd|## wkh## hduwktxdnh## zloo## rffxu/## dqg## vkh## zloo## kdyh## wr## sd|# lqvxudqfh#fodlpv1#Ehfdxvh#vkh#kdv#vhw#dvlgh#qr#uhvhuyhv/#vkh#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # # olnho|#ghidxow# # rq#wkh#fodlpv/#dqg#khu#vwudwhj|#zloo#eh#uhyhdohg#iru#wkh#vkdp#lw#lv1#Exw#ehiruh#wkdw/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vkh#zloo#kdyh#hqmr|hg#wkh#dgxodwlrq#ri#wkh#lqyhvwlqj#pdvvhv#dqg#pd|#kdyh#vdowhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dzd|#hqrxjk#lq#erqxvhv#wr#uhwluh#frpiruwdeo|#wr#d#ehdfk#krxvh#lq#wkh#Edkdpdv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Zlwk#oxfn/# # # li#wkh# # # hduwktxdnh## rffxuv## lq#wkh# # # plgvw## ri#d# # # odujhu## fdwdfo|vp/## vkh## fdq# dwwulexwh## khu## glvdvwurxv## shuirupdqfh## wr## d## rqh0lq0whq0wkrxvdqg0|hdu## hyhqw#dqg# # # eh# edfn#lq#dqrwkhu#mre#vrrq1#Idlolqj#lq#d#khug#uduho|#kdv#dgyhuvh#frqvhtxhqfhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Pruh#jhqhudoo|/#dw#wlphv#zkhq#ilqdqflqj#lv#sohqwlixo/#vr#wkdw#wkhuh#lv#lpphqvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # frpshwlwlrq#dprqj#edqnhuv# # # # dqg## ixqg## pdqdjhuv/## wkh## qhhg## wr## fuhdwh## doskd## sxvkhv# pdq|#ri#wkhp#lqh{rudeo|#wrzdug#wdnlqj#rq#wdlo#ulvn1#Iru#wdlo#ulvn#rffxuv#vr#uduho|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#lw#fdq#eh#zhoo#klgghq#iru#d#orqj#wlph=#d#pdqdjhu#pd|#qrw#hyhq#eh#dzduh#kh#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdnlqj#lw1#Exw#wkh#uhwxuqv#duh#kljk/#ehfdxvh#shrsoh#duh#zloolqj#wr#sd|#d#orw#wr#dyrlg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehlqj## klw## e|## fdwdfo|vplf## orvvhv## lq## edg## wlphv1## Vr## li## wkh## pdqdjhu## surgxfhv## wkh# uhwxuqv## exw#klv# # # lqyhvwruv## gr## qrw#+dw#ohdvw#iru# # # # # d## zkloh,## dffrxqw#iru# # # wkh## dgglwlrqdo# ulvn#wkh#pdqdjhu#lv#wdnlqj#zlwk#wkhlu#prqh|/#wkh#pdqdjhu#zloo#orrn#olnh#d#jhqlxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## eh## uhzdughg## kdqgvrpho|1## Kh## pd|#zhoo# # # frph## wr## eholhyh## wkdw## kh## lv## rqh1## Lq# rwkhu## zrugv/## lw## lv## wkh## yhu|#zloolqjqhvv# # # ri## wkh## prghuq#ilqdqfldo# # # pdunhw## wr## riihu# srzhuixo## uhzdugv## iru## wkh## uduh## surgxfhu## ri## doskd## wkdw## dovr## jhqhudwhv## vwurqj# lqfhqwlyhv#wr#ghfhlyh#lqyhvwruv1# # # # Ehfdxvh## wkhvh## lqfhqwlyhv## duh## suhvhqw## wkurxjkrxw## wkh## ilqdqfldo## ilup/## wkhuh## lv# olwwoh## uhdvrq## wr## h{shfw## wkdw## wrs## pdqdjhphqw## zloo## fxue## wkh## sudfwlfh1## Lqghhg/## wkh# fkhfnv#dqg#edodqfhv#dw#hdfk#ohyho#ri#wkh#frusrudwh#klhudufk|#eurnh#grzq1#Zkdw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sduwlfxoduo|## shuqlflrxv## derxw## wdlo## ulvn## lv## wkdw## zkhq## wdnhq## lq## odujh## grvhv/## lw# jhqhudwhv#dq#lqfhqwlyh#wr#wdnh#|hw#pruh#ri#lw1#D#vhhplqjo|#luudwlrqdo#iuhq}|#pd|#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # d#surgxfw#ri#doo0wrr0udwlrqdo#fdofxodwlrqv#e|#ilqdqfldo#ilupv1# # # # # # # #
Ulvn#Wdnlqj#rq#wkh#Iurqw#Olqhv # # # # # # D#zhoo0pdqdjhg# # # ilqdqfldo## ilup#wdnhv# # # fdofxodwhg## dqg## olplwhg## ulvnv/## ulvnv## wkdw# zloo#pdnh#prqh|#iru#wkh#ilup#li#wkh|#sd|#rii#exw#zloo#qrw#ghvwur|#wkh#ilup#li#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # gr#qrw1#Ilupv#olnh#DLJ/#Ehdu#Vwhduqv/#Flwljurxs/#dqg#Ohkpdq#Eurwkhuv#wrrn#ulvnv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#zhuh#yluwxdoo|#xqerxqghg/#doehlw#orz#lq#suredelolw|1#Wkh#prvw#reylrxv#idfwru# # # # # # # # # # # # gulylqj#wklv#ehkdylru#vhhpv#wr#eh#wkh#frpshqvdwlrq#v|vwhp/#zklfk#w|slfdoo|#sdlg# # # # # # # # # # # # khiw|## erqxvhv## zkhq## hpsor|hhv## pdgh## surilwv## exw## glg## qrw## shqdol}h## wkhp# vljqlilfdqwo|#zkhq#wkh|#lqfxuuhg#orvvhv1#Wkh#surilwdeoh#rqh0vlghg#ehw#wklv#riihuhg# # # # # # # # # # # hpsor|hhv## zdv## nqrzq#ydulrxvo|#dv# # # # wkh## Dfdsxofr## Sod|/## LEJ## +Lᄊoo## eh## jrqh## li## lw# grhvqᄊw#zrun,/#dqg/#lq#Fklfdjr/#wkh#RᄊKduh#Rswlrq#+ex|#d#wlfnhw#ghsduwlqj#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # RᄊKduh#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Dlusruw=#li#wkh#vwudwhj|#idlov/#xvh#lw>#li#wkh#vwudwhj|#vxffhhgv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # whdu## xs## wkh## wlfnhw## dqg## uhwxuq## wr## wkh## riilfh,1## Wkdw## vxfk## vwudwhjlhv## zhuh## frpprq# hqrxjk## lq## wkh## lqgxvwu|## dv## wr## kdyh## qdphv## vxjjhvwv## wkdw## qrw## doo## wudghuv## zhuh# reolylrxv#wr#wkh#ulvnv#wkh|#zhuh#wdnlqj1# # # # # # # Wkh#Vzlvv#edqnlqj#jldqw#XEV#udq#lqwr#wurxeoh#ehfdxvh#lwv#lqyhvwphqw#edqnlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # xqlw## ehfdph## hqwudqfhg## e|#wkh# # # surilw## lw## zdv## pdnlqj#iurp#eruurzlqj#dw# # # # # wkh## DD0 udwhg## edqnᄊv## orz## frvw#ri#ixqglqj#dqg# # # # # lqyhvwlqj#wkh# # # ixqgv## lq#kljkhu0uhwxuq/# # # kljk0 7##Wkh#uhjxodwru|#uhtxluhphqwv#iru#edqn#fdslwdo#wr#eh# udwhg#dvvhw0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv1 # # # # # # # # # vhw## dvlgh## wr## edfn## vxfk## d## vwudwhj|## zhuh## plqlpdo## ehfdxvh## wkh## xqghuo|lqj# lqyhvwphqwv## zhuh## kljko|## udwhg1## Wkh## uhvxowlqj## lqwhuhvw## vsuhdg## zdv## vpdoo/## exw# pxowlsolhg#e|#wkh#'83#eloolrq#wkh#xqlw#lqyhvwhg#lq#wkh#vwudwhj|/#lw#pdgh#d#wlg|#surilw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iru#wkh#edqn#zkloh#wkh#jrlqj#zdv#jrrg#dqg#uhvxowhg#lq#odujh#erqxvhv#iru#wkh#xqlw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Qhhgohvv#wr#vd|/#wklv#sudfwlfh#ri#slfnlqj#xs#shqqlhv#lq#iurqw#ri#d#vwhdpuroohu#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxffhvvixo#rqo|#xqwlo#wkh#vxesulph#fdwdvwurskh#uroohg#doo#ryhu#XEVᄊv#surilwv1# # # # # # # # # # # Vrph## vpduw## wudghuv## lq#d# # # qxpehu## ri## edqnv## xqghuvwrrg## dqg## juhz## lqfuhdvlqjo|# frqfhuqhg## e|#wkh# # # ulvnv## wkdw## zhuh## ehlqj#wdnhq#e|#wkh# # # # # xqlwv## fuhdwlqj#dqg# # # kroglqj# dvvhw0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv1## Dw## Ohkpdq/## iru## h{dpsoh/## il{hg0lqfrph## wudghuv## vwduwhg# vhoolqj#wkhvh#vhfxulwlhv#vkruw/#hyhq#zkloh#wkh#uhdo#hvwdwh#dqg#pruwjdjh#xqlw#ordghg# # # # # # # # # # # # # 8## Fohduo|/## dq|#xqlw#wkdw#lv# xs## rq#wkhp1 # # # # # irfxvhg## rq#fuhdwlqj#dqg# # # # kroglqj#d# # # fhuwdlq# nlqg## ri#dvvhw#lv# # # # qdwxudoo|#uhoxfwdqw#wr# # # # ghfoduh## dq#hqg# # # wr## wkh## errp#lw#kdv# # # # ulgghq1# Wkh## xqlwᄊv## vl}h/## srzhu/## dqg## uhsxwdwlrq## ehfrph## wrr## forvho|## uhodwhg## wr## wkh## dvvhw# fodvv/#dqg#lwv#khdg#ehfrphv#dq#lqwhuhvwhg#errvwhu1#Iru#Ohkpdqᄊv#pruwjdjh#xqlw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghfoduh## dq## hqg## wr## wkh## pruwjdjh## errp#zrxog# # # kdyh## ehhq## wr## vljq## lwv## rzq## ghdwk# zduudqw1## Exw## nqrzlqj## wkdw## wkrvh## forvh## wr## wkh## dfwlrq## pd|## ehfrph## xquholdeoh## lq# dvvhvvlqj#wkh# # # dvvrfldwhg## ulvnv/## d## ilupᄊv## ulvn#pdqdjhuv# # # vkrxog## vwhs## lq#wr# # # fxuwdlo# ixuwkhu## lqyhvwphqw1#Lq#pdq|#ilupv# # # # # wkh|#glg#qrw/#dqg#lw#lv# # # # # # # lpsruwdqw#wr#xqghuvwdqg# # # zk|1# Ulvn## pdqdjhuv## vkrxog## dgmxvw## hyhu|## xqlwᄊv## uhwxuqv## grzq## iru## wkh## ulvn## lw## wdnhv/# uhgxflqj#shuyhuvh#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#wdnh#ulvn1#Wkh#nlqgv#ri#ulvnv#wkdw#zhuh#wdnhq#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhfhqw#fulvlvᄇghidxow#ru# # # # fuhglw#ulvn#dqg# # # # oltxlglw|#ulvnᄇzhuh# # # qrw#gliilfxow#iru# # # # d# wudlqhg#ulvn#pdqdjhu#wr#uhfrjql}h/#vr#orqj#dv#vkh#frxog#vhh#wkh#xqlwᄊv#errnv1#Iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#pdqdjhuv# # # wr#ehfrph#frqfhuqhg/#krzhyhu/#dqg#iru# # # # # # # wrs#pdqdjhphqw#wr#vkduh# # # # wkhlu#zruu|#fdq#eh#wzr#yhu|#gliihuhqw#wklqjv1# # # # # # # # Lq#pdq|#ri#wkh#djjuhvvlyh#ilupv#wkdw#jrw#lqwr#wurxeoh/#ulvn#pdqdjhphqw#zdv#xvhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
sulpdulo|#iru# # # uhjxodwru|#frpsoldqfh# # # udwkhu## wkdq#dv# # # dq#lqvwuxphqw#ri#pdqdjhphqw# # # # frqwuro1## Dw## Flwljurxs/## iru## h{dpsoh/## ulvn## pdqdjhuv## vrphwlphv## uhsruwhg## wr# rshudwlrqdo#khdgv#zkr#zhuh#uhvsrqvleoh#iru#uhyhqxh/#sxwwlqj#wkh#ir{#lq#fkdujh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # 9## Uhiohfwlqj#wkh# wkh## fklfnhq#frrs1 # # # w|slfdo## ilupᄊv## ylhz## ri#wkhlu# # # lpsruwdqfh/## ulvn0 pdqdjhphqw#srvlwlrqv# # # zhuh## sdlg## vljqlilfdqwo|#ohvv# # # wkdq#srvlwlrqv# # # lq#rshudwlrqdo# # xqlwv/## wkhuhe|#hqvxulqj#wkdw#wkh|#dwwudfwhg# # # # # # ohvv## wdohqwhg## shrsoh## zkr## frppdqghg# ohvv#uhvshfw=#qrw#vxusulvlqjo|/#vwxglhv#vkrz#wkdw#ilupv#zkhuh#ulvn#pdqdjhuv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## lqghshqghqw## ri## wkh## rshudwlrqdo## xqlwv## dqg## zhuh## xqghusdlg## uhodwlyh## wr## rwkhu# pdqdjhuv## shuiruphg## srruo|#lq#wkh# # # # fulvlv1:## Wkhlu## zhdnqhvv## zdv## frpsrxqghg## dv# wkh#errp#frqwlqxhg1#Zkhq#d#FHR#dgmxglfdwhg#d#glvsxwh#ehwzhhq#klv#vwdu#wudghu/# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkr#kdg#surgxfhg#'83#ploolrq#lq#surilwv#hyhu|#txduwhu#iru#wkh#sdvw#whq#txduwhuv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## klv## ulvn## pdqdjhu/## zkr## kdg## rssrvhg## wkh## wudghu#ᄊv## ulvn## wdnlqj## doo## dorqj/## wkh# qdwxudo## lpsxovh## zrxog## eh## wr## vlgh## zlwk## wkh## wudghu1## Wkh## ulvn## pdqdjhu## zdv## riwhq# sruwud|hg#dv#wkh#rog#kdv0ehhq#zkr#glg#qrw#xqghuvwdqg#wkh#qhz#sdudgljpᄇdqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#wdnhuv#kdg#wkh#wudfn#uhfrug#wr#suryh#lw1# # # # # # # # # L#uhphpehu#d#phhwlqj#ehwzhhq#ulvn#pdqdjhuv#ri#pdmru#edqnv#dqg#dfdghplfv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#vsulqj#ri#533:#dw#zklfk#zh#dfdghplfv#zhuh#vxusulvhg#wkdw#wkh#pdqdjhuv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## pruh## zruulhg## derxw## wkh## ulvnv## vwhpplqj## iurp#wkh# # # soxqjlqj## krxvlqj## pdunhw1# Diwhu## rxu## txhvwlrqv## holflwhg## ihz## vdwlvidfwru|## uhsolhv/## rqh## dvwxwh## yhwhudq## ulvn# pdqdjhu## wrrn#ph# # # dvlgh## gxulqj#d# # # euhdn#dqg# # # vdlg=## ᄈ\rx#pxvw#xqghuvwdqg/# # # # dq|rqh# zkr#zdv#zruulhg#zdv#iluhg#orqj#djr#dqg#lv#qrw#lq#wklv#urrp1ᄡ#Wrs#pdqdjhphqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdg#uhpryhg#doo#wkrvh#zkr#frxog#kdyh#uhvwudlqhg#wkh#ulvn#wdnlqj#suhflvho|#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # srlqw## ri## pd{lpxp## gdqjhu1## Exw## li## wkdw## zhuh## wkh## fdvh/## wkhq## wkh## eodph## iru# hqfrxudjlqj#wkh#ehw0wkh0ilup#wdlo# # # # # ulvn#wdnlqj#wkdw#zdv# # # # # jrlqj#rq#pxvw#olh#zlwk#wrs# # # # # # pdqdjhphqw1#
Ulvn#Wdnlqj#dw#wkh#Wrs # # # # # Zkdw## zdv## pdqdjhphqw## wklqnlqjB## Dq#reylrxv# # # dqvzhu## lv## wkdw## wkh|/## olnh## wkhlu# wudghuv/## zhuh## wdnlqj## rqh0zd|## ehwv1## Krzhyhu/## dq## lqwuljxlqj## vwxg|## vxjjhvwv## wkdw# edqn#FHRv#lq#vrph#ri#wkh#zruvw0klw#edqnv#glg#qrw#odfn#iru#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#pdqdjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ;# wkhlu## edqnv## zhoo1 # Ulfkdug## Ixog## dw## Ohkpdq## rzqhg## derxw## '4## eloolrq## zruwk## ri# Ohkpdq#vwrfn#dw#wkh# # # # # hqg## ri#ilvfdo# # # |hdu## 5339/## dqg## Mdphv## Fd|qh## ri#Ehdu# # # Vwhduqv# rzqhg## '<86## ploolrq1## Wkhvh## FHRv## orvw## wuhphqgrxv## dprxqwv## zkhq## wkhlu## ilupv# zhuh#eurxjkw#grzq#e|#zkdw#zhuh#hiihfwlyho|#prghuq0gd|#edqn#uxqv1#Lqghhg/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # vwxg|#vkrzv#wkdw#edqnv#lq#zklfk#FHRv#rzqhg#wkh#prvw#vwrfn#w|slfdoo|#shuiruphg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#zruvw#gxulqj#wkh#fulvlv1#Wkhvh#FHRv#kdg#vxevwdqwldo# # # # # # # # # # dprxqwv#wr#orvh#li#wkhlu# # # # # ehwv#glg#qrw#sod|#rxw#zhoo#+qr#pdwwhu#krz#ulfk#wkh|#rwkhuzlvh#zhuh,1#Xqolnh#wkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#vrph#ri#wkhlu#wudghuv/#wkhlu#ehwv#zhuh#qrw#rqh0zd|1# # # # # # # # # # Rqh## h{sodqdwlrq#lv# # # wkh## FHRv## zhuh## rxw#ri#wrxfk1# # # # Dq#xqiodwwhulqj#sruwud|do# # # # ri# Ixog## kdv## klp#krohg# # # xs## lq#klv# # # riilfh## rq#wkh# # # 64vw#iorru# # # ri#Ohkpdqᄊv# # # khdgtxduwhuv# <## Lqghhg/#lq# zlwk#olwwoh#nqrzohgjh#ri#zkdw#zdv#jrlqj#rq#lq#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#exloglqj1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # # d#wrqjxh0lq0fkhhn#rs0hg#slhfh#lq#wkh#Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Fdoylq#Wuloolq#dujxhg#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # Zdoo## Vwuhhwᄊv## sureohp#zdv# # # wkdw## lw## kdg## xqghujrqh## d## uhyroxwlrqdu|#fkdqjh# # # lq#wkh# # 43## Lq#Wuloolqᄊv#wlph#lq#froohjh/#rqo|#wkrvh#lq# txdolw|#ri#shuvrqqho#ryhu#jhqhudwlrqv1 # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## erwwrp#wklug# # # ri## wkhlu## xqlyhuvlw|#fodvv# # # xvhg## wr## jr## rq#wr# # # Zdoo## Vwuhhw## fduhhuv/# zklfk## zhuh## erulqj## dqg## rqo|## prghudwho|## uhpxqhudwlyh1## Exw## hyhq## zkloh## wkh# gxoodugv## dvfhqghg## wr## wkh## wrs## srvlwlrqv## dw#wkh# # # edqnv/## Zdoo## Vwuhhw#ehfdph# # # d## pruh# h{flwlqj## dqg## fkdoohqjlqj## sodfh/## sd|lqj## shrsoh## eh|rqg## wkhlu## zloghvw## guhdpv1## Lw# vwduwhg#dwwudfwlqj#dqg#uhfuxlwlqj#wkh#vpduwhvw#vwxghqwv#lq#fodvv/#shrsoh#zkr#wkrxjkw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#frxog#sulfh#FGR#vtxduhg#dqg#FGR#fxehg#+sduwlfxoduo|#hjuhjlrxv#irupv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # vhfxulwl}dwlrq#lqyroylqj#froodwhudol}hg# # # # ghew#reoljdwlrqv,# # # dqg## pdqdjh## wkhlu## ulvnv1# Dv## Wuloolq## zulwhv=## ᄈZkhq## wkh## vpduw## jx|v## vwduwhg## wklv## exvlqhvv## ri## vhfxulwl}lqj# wklqjv## wkdw## glgqᄊw## hyhq#h{lvw# # # lq#wkh# # # iluvw## sodfh/## zkr## zdv## uxqqlqj#wkh# # # ilupv## wkh|# zrunhg## iruB## Rxu## jx|v$#Wkh# # # orzhu## wklug## ri#wkh# # # fodvv$#Jx|v# # # zkr## glgqᄊw#kdyh# # # wkh# irjjlhvw#qrwlrq#ri#zkdw#d# # # # # # fuhglw#ghidxow#vzds# # # # zdv1## Doo## rxu## jx|v## nqhz## zdv## wkdw# 44# wkh|#zhuh#jhwwlqj#glvjxvwlqjo|#ulfk/#dqg#wkh|#kdg#jrwwhq#wr#olnh#wkdw1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## vxjjhvwlrq## wkdw## ervvhv/## uhfuxlwhg## lq## d## vwdlg## dqg## uhjxodwhg## hud/## zhuh## ri# orzhu#fdolehu#wkdq#wkh#hpsor|hhv#wkh|#kdg#uhfuxlwhg#iurp#wkh#wrs#ri#wkh#fodvv#lq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghuhjxodwhg## dqg## kljk0sd|lqj## hud## lv## qrw## frpsohwho|## zlwkrxw## irxqgdwlrq1## Dq# lqwuljxlqj## vwxg|## ri## wkh## X1V1## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## lqglfdwhv## wkdw## wkh## hduqlqjv## ri# frusrudwh#hpsor|hhv#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#uhodwlyh#wr#hpsor|hhv#lq#rwkhu#vhfwruv# # # # # # # # # # # # 45# vwduwhg## folpelqj#durxqg# # # 4<;3/## dv## wkh## vhfwru## zdv## ghuhjxodwhg1 # Pruhryhu/## mrev# ehfdph## pruh## frpsoh{## lq## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru/## uhtxlulqj## vljqlilfdqwo|## pruh# pdwkhpdwlfdo## dswlwxgh1## Lqghhg/## dowkrxjk## wkhuh## lv## olwwoh## glyhujhqfh## ehwzhhq## wkh# zdjhv## ri## ilqdqflhuv## dqg## hqjlqhhuv## dw## wkh## froohjh## ohyho/## wkhuh## lv## vljqlilfdqw# glyhujhqfh## dprqj## srvwjudgxdwhv## +zlwk## srvwjudgxdwh## ilqdqflhuv## lqfuhdvlqjo|# hduqlqj## pruh## wkdq## srvwjudgxdwh## hqjlqhhuv,1## PEDv## dqg## SkGv## ehjdq## wr## iloo## wkh# udqnv## ri## dqdo|vwv## dqg## pdqdjhuv## lq#ilqdqfldo# # # ilupv1## Wkhuhiruh/## qrw## rqo|#zdv# # # wkh# ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#ghpdqglqj#pruh#kljko|#hgxfdwhg#shrsoh/#exw#lw#zdv#dovr#sd|lqj# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp#pruh#dqg#wkhuhiruh#suredeo|#dwwudfwlqj#ehwwhu#wdohqw#wkdq#lw#kdg#lq#wkh#sdvwᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frqvlvwhqw## zlwk#p|#revhuydwlrqv# # # # wkdw## pdq|#ri# # # wkh## vpduwhu## vwxghqwv## lq#p|#PED# # #
fodvvhv## judylwdwhg## wr## ilqdqfh1## Fohduo|/## ghuhjxodwlrq#dqg# # # wkh## vxevhtxhqw#vxujh# # # lq# frpshwlwlrq#dqg#lqqrydwlrq#lqfuhdvhg#wkh#ghpdqg#iru/#dqg#khqfh#uhwxuqv#rq/#vnloov# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru1# # # # Dowkrxjk#lw#lv#whpswlqj#wr#frqfoxgh#wkdw#vrph#ri#wkh#FHRv#zhuh#erwk#xqwdohqwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#foxhohvv#uhodwlyh#wr#wkhlu#vxeruglqdwhv/#wkh#frusrudwh#klhudufk|#lv#lqkhuhqwo|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # wrxjk#folpe# # # dqg## zhhgv## rxw#d# # # orw#ri#lqfrpshwhqwv/# # # # hvshfldoo|#lq#wkh# # # # xqirujlylqj# dqg#ilhufho|#frpshwlwlyh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru1#Lw#lv#kdug#wr#lpdjlqh#wkdw#wkh#pdmrulw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrs## pdqdjhphqw## lq#wkh# # # hduo|#5333v/# # # prvw## ri## zkrp#kdg# # # suredeo|#mrlqhg# # # lq#wkh# # douhdg|#h{flwlqj#4<;3v#dqg#vxuylyhg#d#qxpehu#ri#xsv#dqg#grzqv/#zhuh#qrw#kljko|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdsdeoh## dqg## lqwhooljhqw## lqglylgxdov1## Vkhhu## lqfrpshwhqfh## dprqj## wkh## wrs# pdqdjhphqw#grhv#qrw#h{sodlq#wkh#fulvlv1# # # # # # D#ehwwhu# # # h{sodqdwlrq#lv# # # wkdw#FHRv# # # zhuh## y|lqj#dprqj#wkhpvhoyhv# # # # iru## suhvwljh# e|## pdnlqj## pruh## surilwv## lq## wkh## vkruw## whup## ru## e|## khdglqj## ohdjxh## wdeohv## iru# xqghuzulwlqj#ru# # # ohqglqj/## uhjdugohvv## ri#wkh# # # orqjhu0whup#ulvn#lqyroyhg1# # # # L#zurwh# # # d# sdshu#ghvfulelqj#vxfk#lqfhqwlyhv#iroorzlqj#edqn#wurxeohv#lq#wkh#hduo|#4<<3v/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # 46# # Vwdq#RᄊQhdo/#wkh#FHR#ri#Phuuloo# # # # # # L#wklqn#wkh#skhqrphqrq#lv#pruh#zlghvsuhdg1 # # # # # # O|qfk/## sxvkhg## klv## ilup## lqwr## wkh## vhhplqjo|## kljko|## surilwdeoh## dvvhw0edfnhg# vhfxulwlhv#exvlqhvv#lq#dq#dwwhpsw#wr#nhhs#xs#zlwk#ulydov#olnh#Jrogpdq#Vdfkv1#Kh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # prqlwruhg#Jrogpdqᄊv#txduwhuo|#qxpehuv#forvho|#dqg#riwhq#txhvwlrqhg#froohdjxhv# # # # # # # # # rq## wkh## frpsdqlhvᄊ## uhodwlyh## shuirupdqfh147## Phuulooᄊv## odfn## ri## h{shulhqfh## lq## wkh# duhd#hyhqwxdoo|#uhvxowhg#lq#hqruprxv#orvvhv#dqg#d#vkrwjxq#pduuldjh#zlwk#Edqn#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dphulfd1# Wkh## suhvvxuhv## rq## wkh## FHR## pd|## kdyh## frph## qrw## mxvw## iurp## vkduhkroghuv## ru# shuvrqdo## hjrv## exw## dovr## iurp## djjuhvvlyh## vxeruglqdwhv1## Flwljurxs## FHR## Fkxfn# Sulqfhᄊv#frpphqw#lq#Mxo|#533:/#rqo|#d#prqwk#ehiruh#pdunhwv#vwduwhg#iuhh}lqj#xs/# # # # # # # # # # # # # kdv## ehfrph## hpeohpdwlf## ri## FHRvᄊ## uroh## lq## wkh## fxuuhqw## fulvlv1## Uhso|lqj## wr## d# mrxuqdolvw#zkr#dvnhg#zk|#klv#edqn#frqwlqxhg#wr#pdnh#ordqv#rq#hdv|#whupv#wr#ixqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdnhryhuv/## kh## vdlg=## ᄈZkhq#wkh# # # pxvlf## vwrsv/## lq#whupv# # # ri#oltxlglw|/# # # wklqjv## zloo## eh# frpsolfdwhg1#Exw#dv#orqj#dv#wkh#pxvlf#lv#sod|lqj/#|rxᄊyh#jrw#wr#jhw#xs#dqg#gdqfh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 48# Zhᄊuh#vwloo#gdqflqj1ᄡ # # Wklv#frpphqw#zdv#frpprqo|#lqwhusuhwhg#dv#uhiohfwlqj#wkh#fdydolhu#dwwlwxgh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # edqnhuv#wrzdug#ulvn#dqg#wkh#pdg#fkdvh#iru#lpphgldwh#surilwv1#Prqwkv#odwhu/#L#phw# # # # # # # # # # # # ## Sulqfh#dw#d#frqihuhqfh#zkhuh#zh#zhuh#rq#d#sdqho#wrjhwkhu/#dqg#L#dvnhg#klp#zkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # ## # # kh#kdg#phdqw1#Kh#h{sodlqhg#wkdw#hyhq#wkrxjk#kh#nqhz#wkhuh#zhuh#ulvnv/#dv#wkh#iluvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhqwhqfh#ri#wkh#txrwh#vxjjhvwv/#kh#vlpso|#frxog#qrw#vkxw#grzq#ohqglqj/#zklfk#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fulwlfdo## wr## vhfxulqj#lqyhvwphqw# # # edqnlqj#ghdov=# # # wkh## prphqw## kh## glg## vr/## kh## zrxog# kdyh## orvw#pdq|#nh|#hpsor|hhv# # # # # wr## rwkhu## ulydov## zkr## zhuh## vwloo## ᄈgdqflqj1ᄡ## Vr## wkh# ghflvlrq#wr#frqwlqxh#ohqglqj#zdv#qrw#vr#pxfk#dq#dwwhpsw#wr#pdnh#vkruw0uxq#surilwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dv## dq## dwwhpsw## wr## suhvhuyh## Flwljurxsᄊv## iudqfklvh## lq## lqyhvwphqw## edqnlqj## dqg## lwv# fdsdelolwlhv## iru## wkh## ixwxuh1## Ri#frxuvh/# # # lq#pdnlqj#wkh# # # # nlqg## ri#ordqv# # # wkh|#glg/# # # klv# hpsor|hhv## mhrsdugl}hg## qrw## rqo|## wkhlu## xqlwᄊv## iudqfklvh## exw## wkh## hqwluh## edqn1# Klqgvljkw#vxjjhvwv# # # wkdw#Sulqfh# # # dqg## Flwljurxs## zrxog## kdyh## ehhq#ehwwhu# # # rii#li#wkh|# # # kdg#vdw#rxw#d#ihz#gdqfhv1# # # # # # D## ihz## FHRv## dsshdu## wr## kdyh## vwrrg## xs## wr## wkhlu## hpsor|hhv1## Wkh## FHR## ri## MS# Prujdq/## Mdplh## Glprq/## sod|hg## d## nh|#uroh# # # lq#suhyhqwlqj#klv# # # # edqn#iurp#wdnlqj#d# # # # eljjhu#srvlwlrq#lq#kljko|#udwhg#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv/#dqg#lq#xqzlqglqj#lwv# # # # # # # # # # #
49## Dv#kh#riwhq#hpskdvl}hg#wr#klv#vwdii/#ᄈZh# h{lvwlqj#srvlwlrqv/#ehjlqqlqj#lq#53391 # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh#jrw#wr#kdyh#d#iruwuhvv#edodqfh#vkhhw$#ᆱ#Qr#rqh#kdv#wkh#uljkw#wr#qrw#dvvxph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh#exvlqhvv#f|foh#zloo#wxuq$#Hyhu|#ilyh#|hduv#ru#vr/#|rx#kdyh#jrw#wr#dvvxph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 4:## Kh#dovr#ehhihg#xs#sd|#iru#ulvn#pdqdjhuv/#vr# wkdw#vrphwklqj#edg#zloo#kdsshq1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkhvh#srvlwlrqv#dwwudfwhg#nqrzohgjhdeoh#wudghuv1#Kh#wulhg#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # kdg#forxw1#Dqg#dowkrxjk#kh#kdg#d#pxfk#ghhshu#xqghuvwdqglqj#ri#ghulydwlyhv#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdq|#ri# # # klv## ihoorz## FHRv/## kh## dovr## kdg## d## uxoh=## li## kh## glg## qrw## xqghuvwdqg## krz## d# exvlqhvv#pdgh#prqh|/#kh#zrxog#qrw#sduwlflsdwh#lq#lw1#Qrw#wdnlqj#ulvnv#rqh#grhvqᄊw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqghuvwdqg#lv#riwhq#wkh#ehvw#irup#ri#ulvn#pdqdjhphqw1#Ilupv#zlwk#ohvv#frqilghqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ru## uhvshfwhg## FHRv## vlpso|## iroorzhg## wkh## khug## ryhu## wkh## folii/## sxvkhg## e|## wkh# dpelwlrqv#ri#wkhlu#hpsor|hhv1# # # #
Exw#ehiruh#zh#dwwulexwh#wrr#pxfk#ru#wrr#olwwoh#iruhvljkw#wr#FHRv/#ohw#xv#frqvlghu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ilqglqjv## ri## dqrwkhu## vrehulqj## uhfhqw## vwxg|/## zklfk## orrnv## dw## wrwdo## wrs0 pdqdjhphqw#sd|#dfurvv#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv#dqg#lwv#uhodwlrqvkls# # # # # # # # # # # zlwk## vxevhtxhqw## shuirupdqfh14;## Wkh## vwxg|## ilqgv## wkdw## vrph## ilupv## whqghg## wr## sd|# wkhlu## wrs## pdqdjhphqw## d## orw## pruh## djjuhvvlyho|## lq## wkh## shulrg## 4<<;ᄆ5333/# fruuhfwlqj## iru## reylrxv## idfwruv## olnh## wkh## vl}h## ri## wkh## edqn## +elj## edqnv## sd|## pruh# ehfdxvh#wkh|#whqg#wr#dwwudfw/#dqg#qhhg/#ehwwhu#wdohqw,1#Djjuhvvlyh#sd|huv#lqfoxghg# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#xvxdo#vxvshfwv#olnh#Ehdu#Vwhduqv/#Ohkpdq/#Flwljurxs/#dqg#DLJ/#zkhuhdv#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # frqvhuydwlyh## sd|pdvwhuv## lqfoxghg## ilupv## olnh## MS## Prujdq1## Wkh## vwxg|## ilqgv## wkdw# wkrvh#zkr#sdlg#wkh#prvw#djjuhvvlyho|#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv#zhuh#dovr#wkrvh#zkr#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## zruvw## vwrfn0uhwxuq## shuirupdqfh## gxulqj## wkh## shulrg## 5334ᄆ533;/## wkh## kljkhvw# vwrfn0uhwxuq#yrodwlolw|/#wkh#kljkhvw#h{srvxuh#wr#vxesulph#pruwjdjhv/#dqg/#e|#vrph# # # # # # # # # # # frxqwv/#wkh#kljkhvw#ohyhudjh1#Djjuhvvlyh#sd|#sudfwlfhv#vhhp#wr#kdyh#jrqh#wrjhwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#djjuhvvlyh# # # ulvn#wdnlqj#dqg# # # # vxevhtxhqw#srru# # # shuirupdqfh## gxulqj#wkh# # # fulvlv/# pxfk#dv#p|#hduolhu#glvfxvvlrq#vxjjhvwv1# # # # # # Lqwhuhvwlqjo|/## wkrxjk/## wkh## uhvhdufkhuv## uhshdwhg## wkh## h{huflvh## ryhu## d## gliihuhqw# wlph## iudph/## orrnlqj## dw## krz## wkrvh## zkr## frpshqvdwhg## djjuhvvlyho|## gxulqj## wkh# 4<<5ᄆ<7#shulrg#iduhg#ehwzhhq#4<<8#dqg#53331#Ryhu#wklv#shulrg/#wkh#vdph#ilupv# # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## djjuhvvlyh## sd|huv/## exw#wkh|#glg# # # # skhqrphqdoo|#ehwwhu# # # wkdq#wkh# # # frqvhuydwlyh# sd|huv1## Wkhlu## vwrfn#uhwxuqv# # # zhuh## pxfk#kljkhu/# # # wkrxjk#phdvxuhv# # # ri#ulvn/# # # vxfk#dv# # vwrfn0uhwxuq#yrodwlolw|/#zhuh#dovr#kljk1#Wkh#dxwkruv#frqfoxgh#wkdw#shuirupdqfh#glg# # # # # # # # # # # qrw#ghshqg# # # rq#wkh# # # dvwxwhqhvv## ru## lqfrpshwhqfh## ri#sduwlfxodu# # # FHRv=## udwkhu/## vrph# edqnv#kdg#d#fxowxuh#ri#ulvn#wdnlqj#dqg#ri#frpshqvdwlqj#yhu|#khdylo|#ryhu#wkh#vkruw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # whup/#zklfk#dwwudfwhg#olnh0plqghg#wudghuv/#lqyhvwruv#+djjuhvvlyh#edqnv#kdg#pruh# # # # # # # # # # vkruw0whup## lqvwlwxwlrqdo## lqyhvwruv## kroglqj## wkhlu## vkduhv,/## dqg## hyhq## FHRv1## Zkhq# wkhvh#edqnv#glg#zhoo#gxulqj#errp#wlphv/#wkhlu#FHRv#zhuh#olrql}hg#dv#khurhv>#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkhq#wkh|#glg# # # # h{wuhpho|#srruo|#gxulqj#wkh# # # # # fuhglw## fulvlv/## wkhlu## +xvxdoo|#iruphu,# # FHRv#ehfdph#yloodlqv1#Wkh#FHRv#zhuh#suredeo|#qhlwkhu1#Wkh|#zhuh#mxvw#ordglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # xs#rq#ulvn/#lqfoxglqj#wdlo#ulvn>#exw#wklv#wlph#lw#mxvw#glg#qrw#sd|#rii1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Sdvw#h{shulhqfh#pd|#hyhq#kdyh#ohg#FHRv#wr#ryhuhvwlpdwh#wkhlu#delolw|#wr#ghdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk## wdlo## ulvn1## D## sdvvdjh## iurp## d## Qhz## \run## pdjd}lqh## duwlfoh## derxw## Ohkpdq## lv# uhyhdolqj=# E|#wkh#hqg#ri#5339/#vrph#dw#Ohkpdq#kdg#ehjxq#wr#wklqn#wkdw#uhdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hvwdwh# zdv## qhdulqj## wkh## hqg## ri## lwv## uxq1## Plnh## Jhoedqg/## zkr## zdv## uhvsrqvleoh## iru# frpphufldo## dqg## uhvlghqwldo## uhdo## hvwdwh/## kdg## e|## wkhq## wxuqhg## ghflghgo|#
ehdulvk1## ᄈWkh## zruog## lv## fkdqjlqj/ᄡ## Jhoedqg## wrog## ^Ulfkdug`## Ixog## gxulqj#klv# # 5339#erqxv#uhylhz/#dffruglqj#wr#d#shuvrq#idploldu#zlwk#Jhoedqgᄊv#wklqnlqj1# # # # # # # # # # # ᄈZh#kdyh#wr#uhwklqn#rxu#exvlqhvv#prgho1ᄡ# # # # # # # Exw## jlyhq## wkh## lpsruwdqfh## ri## uhdo## hvwdwh## wr## Ohkpdqᄊv## erwwrp## olqh/## wkdw# zdvqᄊw## zkdw## Ixog## zdqwhg## wr## khdu1## Ixog## kdg## vhhq## klv## vkduh## ri## f|folfdo# grzqwxuqv1#ᄈZhᄊyh#ehhq#wkurxjk#wklv#ehiruh#dqg#dozd|v#frph#rxw#vwurqjhu/ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # zdv#klv#dwwlwxgh1#ᄈ\rxᄊuh#wrr#frqvhuydwlyh/ᄡ#Ixog#wrog#Jhoedqg1# # # # # # # # # ᄈZhᄊyh#ehhq#oliwhg#e|#wkh#ulvlqj#wlgh/ᄡ#Jhoedqg#lqvlvwhg1# # # # # # # # # Ixog/#wkrxjk/#zrqghuhg#li#wkh#sureohp#zdv#zlwk#Jhoedqg/#qrw#wkh#pdunhw1# # # # # # # # # # # # ᄈ\rx## grqᄊw## zdqw## wr## wdnh## ulvn/ᄡ## kh## vdlgᄇd## ghhs## lqvxow## lq## wkh## wudghu#ᄊv# yhuqdfxodu14<# # Vrrq#Jhoedqg#zdv#iluhg/#dqg#Ohkpdq#frqwlqxhg#slolqj#xs#ulvn1#Lq#lwv#odvw#gd|v/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#eurxjkw#edfn#Jhoedqg#wr#wu|#wr#vdyh#wkh#edqn/#exw#lw#zdv#wrr#odwh/#dqg#Ohkpdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zdv## edqnuxswhg## e|## wkh## sdqlf## ri## 533;1## Pruh## jhqhudoo|/## djjuhvvlyh## edqnvᄊ#ulvn# # wdnlqj#kdg#sdlg#rii#lq#wkh#sdvw/#zklfk#lv#zk|#wkhlu#ulfko|#frpshqvdwhg#FHRv#zhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vlwwlqj#rq#hqruprxv# # # # dprxqwv## ri#htxlw|1# # # Wkh|#glg# # # qrw#vhhp#wr# # # # uhdol}h## wkdw#lw#zdv# # # ulvn/#qrw#fdsdelolwlhv/#wkdw#kdg#eurxjkw#wkhp#wkhlu#sdvw#uhwxuqv1#Dqg#wklv#wlph#zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#uroohg#wkh#glfh/#zkdw#wxuqhg#xs#zdv#yhu|#gliihuhqw1# # # # # # # # # # Dowkrxjk#lw# # # zrxog## eh## wrr## vwurqj#wr# # # vd|#wkdw# # # FHRv## kdg## olwwoh## lqioxhqfhᄇVwdq# RᄊQhdo## frqyhuwhg#vwdlg#Phuuloo# # # # lqwr#dq#djjuhvvlyh#ulvn#wdnhuᄇshukdsv#wkh#prvw# # # # # # # lpsruwdqw## wklqj## dq|## FHR## glg## zdv## wr## duulyh## lq## wkh## uljkw## FHR## vxlwh1## Vrphzkdw# whoolqjo|/## Mdplh## Glprq## sduwhg## zd|v## zlwk## Flwljurxs## dqg/## e|## zd|## ri## Edqn## Rqh/# mrlqhg## wkh## frqvhuydwlyh## MS#Prujdq1# # # Kh## wljkwhqhg## surfhvvhv## frqvlghudeo|#dw# # # MS# Prujdq/## shukdsv## sduwo|## ehfdxvh## klv## dgprqlwlrqv## ihoo## rq## uhfhswlyh## hduv1## Lw## lv# xqfohdu#zkhwkhu#kh#zrxog#kdyh#kdg#wkh#vdph#lqioxhqfh#dw#Flwljurxs1#D#Qhz#\run# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wlphv## froxpqlvw/## Dqguhz## Urvv## Vrunlq/## uhsruwv## d## frqyhuvdwlrq## ehwzhhq## Ere# Zlooxpvwdg/## wkh## FHR## ri## DLJ/## dqg## Urehuw## Jhqghu/## lwv## wuhdvxuhu/## dv## DLJ## zdv# uxqqlqj## rxw## ri## prqh|=## ᄈLw## zdv## wkhq## wkdw## Zlooxpvwdg## dffhswhg## wkh## idfw## wkdw## MS# Prujdq#pljkw#qrw#eh#zloolqj#wr#surylgh#dq|#ixuwkhu#ixqgv1#DLJᄊv#wuhdvxuhu/#Urehuw# # # # # # # # # # # # # Jhqghu/## kdg## douhdg|## zduqhg## klp## wkdw## wkdw## pljkw## eh## wkh## fdvh/## exw## Zlooxpvwdg# kdgqᄊw#ixoo|#eholhyhg#klp1#ᄉMS#Prujdqᄊv#dozd|v#wrxjk/ᄊ#kh#uhplqghg#Jhqghu1#ᄉFlwl# # # # # # # # # # # # zloo## gr## dq|wklqj#|rx#dvn#wkhp#wr# # # # # # gr>#wkh|#mxvw#vd|#|hv1ᄊ#Exw#wkh# # # # # # # # suxghqw#Jhqghu# # rqo|## dflgo|## uhsolhg/## ᄉTxlwh## iudqno|/## zh## fdq## xvh## vrph## ri## wkh## glvflsolqh## wkdw## MS# 53# Prujdq#lv#sxvklqj#rq#xv1ᄊᄡ # # # # Lq#vxp/#wkh#sdwwhuq#ri#wdlo# # # # # # # ulvn#wdnlqj#lq#vrph#djjuhvvlyh#edqnv# # # # # # # sdlg#rii#iru# # # # d# frqvlghudeoh## wlph1## Wkh## pdqdjhphqw## ri## wkhvh## edqnv## grhv## qrw## dsshdu## wr## kdyh# uhdol}hg## krz## pxfk## wkhlu## shuirupdqfh## ghshqghg## rq## oxfn/## ru## krz## wkhlu## rzq# froohfwlyh#dfwlrqv#suhflslwdwhg#wkh#hyhqwv#wkh|#vkrxog#kdyh#ihduhg1# # # # # # # # #
Vkduhkroghuv # Rqh#txhvwlrq#dulvhv#lpphgldwho|=#Li#lqghhg#wkh#djjuhvvlyh#edqnv#zhuh#fohduo|# # # # # # # # # # # lghqwlildeoh/## zk|## glg## wkh## pdunhw## qrw## sxqlvk## wkhp#ehiruh# # # wkh## fulvlvB## Edqnv## wkdw# udqnhg## lq## wkh## zruvw## txduwloh## ri## shuirupdqfh## gxulqj## wkh## fulvlv## kdg## pxfk## kljkhu# vwrfn#uhwxuqv#lq#wkh#|hdu#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv/#5339/#wkdq#edqnv#wkdw#udqnhg#lq#wkh#ehvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # txduwloh154## Vr## wkh## pdunhw## vhhphg## wr## vxssruw## wkh## ehkdylru## ri## wkh## ulvn## wdnhuv## e|# errvwlqj#wkhlu#vwrfn#sulfh#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv1# # # # # # # Wkrvh#zkr#eholhyh#wkdw#pdunhwv#duh#jurvvo|#lqhiilflhqw#zrxog#txlfno|#frqvwuxh# # # # # # # # # # # wklv## rxwfrph## dv## hylghqfh## wkdw#wkh# # # vwrfn#pdunhw#w|slfdoo|#jhwv# # # # # lw#zurqj/# # # dqg## wkdw# wkhrulhv## wkdw## pdunhwv## hiilflhqwo|## djjuhjdwh## doo## sxeolf## lqirupdwlrq## lqwr## sulfhvᄇ# yhuvlrqv## ri## wkh## ᄈhiilflhqw## pdunhwv## k|srwkhvlvᄡᄇduh## krshohvvo|## plvjxlghg1## \hw# qrwklqj#lq#wkh#wkhru|#vd|v#wkh#pdunhw#vkrxog#eh#vsrw#rq#doo# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#wlph1#Wkh#pdunhw# # # # pd|#qrw#kdyh#ixoo#lqirupdwlrqᄇdiwhu#doo/#hyhq#uhjxodwruv#zhuh#odwhu#vxusulvhg#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## txdqwlwlhv## ri#dvvhw0edfnhg# # # vhfxulwlhv## wkh## edqnv## fduulhg## erwk#rq#dqg# # # # rii#wkhlu# # edodqfh## vkhhwv1## Pruhryhu/## hyhq## li## lw## dvvljqv## dssursuldwh## suredelolwlhv## wr## doo# srvvleoh## hyhqwv/## rqo|## rqh## ri## wkrvh## hyhqwv## zloo## eh## uhdol}hg1## Ylhzhg## zlwk## wkh# ehqhilw#ri#klqgvljkw/#hvshfldoo|#li#dq#h{wuhph#hyhqw#rffxuv/#wkh#pdunhw#zloo#vhhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv#li#lw#jrw#pdwwhuv#zurqj/#dqg#lqghhg#lw#zloo#kdyh#grqh#vr1#Exw#wklv#lv#qrw#wr#vd|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#dq|rqh#frxog#kdyh#frqvlvwhqwo|#grqh#ehwwhu1#Lq#wkh#mdujrq#ri#hfrqrplvwv/#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#pdunhw#lv#eholhyhg#wr#kdyh#udwlrqdo#h{shfwdwlrqv#derxw#hyhqwv#grhv#qrw#phdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#lw#kdv#shuihfw#iruhvljkw1# # # # # Pruh## jhqhudoo|/## wkhuh## lv## d## gdqjhu## lq## mxgjlqj## ulvn## wdnlqj## zkloh## orrnlqj## edfn# iurp#wkh#ghswkv#ri#d#fulvlv/#hvshfldoo|#rqh#dv#vhyhuh#dv#wkh#uhfhqw#rqh1#Iurp#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # shuvshfwlyh/## dq|## ulvn## wdnlqj## ehiruhkdqg## vhhpv## luuhvsrqvleoh/## uhgrohqw## ri# plvpdqdjhphqw1## Frqvhuydwlvp#vhhpv# # # suhvflhqw#dqg# # # dvwxwhᄇlqghhg/## lw#vhhpv# # # vr# pxfk#lq#wxqh#zlwk#wkh#wlphv#wkdw#lw#ehfrphv#wkh#vwudwhj|#ri#fkrlfh#diwhu#wkh#fulvlv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkhq#lq#idfw#pruh#ulvn#wdnlqj#zrxog#eh#dssursuldwh1#Krzhyhu/#wkh#uljkw#zd|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # mxgjh#dfwlrqv#wdnhq#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv#lv#zkhwkhu#wkh#ulvn#wdnlqj#zdv#h{shfwhg#wr#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # surilwdeoh1# Dqg## lw## pd|## zhoo## kdyh## ehhq## wkdw## vkduhkroghuv/## surwhfwhg## e|## olplwhg## oldelolw|# iurp#ehdulqj#wkh# # # # h{wuhph## orvvhv## lqgxfhg## e|#wdlo# # # ulvn#+ehfdxvh# # # vkduhkroghuv## fdq# vlpso|#dedqgrq#wkhlu# # # # vkduhv## zkhq#wkhlu# # # ydoxh## klwv## }hur/## zkhuhdv## sduwqhuv## lq#dq# # xqolplwhg0oldelolw|## sduwqhuvkls## pxvw## uhsd|## wkh## prqh|## rzhg## wr## ghew## kroghuv## ru# iruihlw## wkhlu## zhdowk,/## ghhphg## wkh## h{shfwhg## surilwv## iurp## wdnlqj## rq## wdlo## ulvn# zruwkzklohᄇwkh|## wrrn## wkh## jdlqv## zkloh## wkh## ghew## kroghuv## dqg## wkh## wd{sd|hu# devruehg#wkh#wuhphqgrxv#orvvhv1#Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/#Mlpp|#Fd|qh#+ri#Ehdu#Vwhduqv,/# # # # # # # # # # # Glfn#Ixog# # # +ri#Ohkpdq,/# # # dqg## Fkxfn#Sulqfh# # # +ri#Flwljurxs,# # # pljkw#vwloo# # # eh## ihwhg## dv# jldqwv## ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## lqgxvwu|## kdg## hyhqwv## iroorzhg## wkh## prvw## suredeoh## frxuvh1# Wklv#lv#qrw#wr#vd|#wkdw#wkh#ulvnv#wkh|#wrrn#rq#zhuh#jrrg#iru#vrflhw|/#rqo|#wkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pd|#kdyh#ehhq#uhdvrqdeoh#ehwv#iru#vkduhkroghuv#wr#wdnh1# # # # # # # # # Wkh## dfwlrqv## ri## frusrudwh## erdugv/## zklfk## duh## wkh## uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv## ri# vkduhkroghuv/## pljkw#jlyh# # # xv## d## vhqvh## ri#zkhuh# # # vkduhkroghu## lqwhuhvwv## od|1## Qrw#doo# # erdugv#zhuh#htxdoo|#frpshwhqw/#exw#Flwljurxsᄊv#erdug/#zlwk#vwdozduwv#olnh#Urehuw# # # # # # # # # # # Uxelq/#wkh#iruphu# # # # wuhdvxu|#vhfuhwdu|#dqg#FHR#ri#Jrogpdq#Vdfkv/#pljkw#jlyh#xv# # # # # # # # # #
dq#lqnolqj#dv#wr#zkdw#nqrzohgjhdeoh#vkduhkroghuv#pljkw#kdyh#rswhg#iru1#Wkhuh#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # hylghqfh#wkdw#wklv#erdug#sxvkhg#Flwljurxs#lqwr#wdnlqj#pruh#ri#wkh#ulvn#wkdw#eurxjkw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 55# lw#wr#lwv#nqhhv1 # # # #Dowkrxjk#zh#fdqqrw#whoo#zkhwkhu#wkh#erdug#zdv#lqghshqghqw#ru#lq# # # # # # # # # # # pdqdjhphqwᄊv#srfnhw/#lw#dssduhqwo|#glg#qrw#uhvwudlq#wkh#edqnᄊv#ulvn#wdnlqj1# # # # # # # # # # # Ilqdoo|/#htxlw|#pdunhwv#zhuh#qrw#hqwluho|#xqdzduh#ri#wkh#ulvnv1#Iurp#wkh#vhfrqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # txduwhu#ri#5338#wr#wkh#vhfrqg#txduwhu#ri#533:/#wkh#wzr0|hdu#lpsolhg#yrodwlolw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # V)S## 833## rswlrqv## sulfhvᄇwkh## pdunhwᄊv## h{shfwdwlrqv## ri## wkh## yrodwlolw|## ri## vkduh# sulfhv## wzr## |hduv## dkhdgᄇzdv## 63## wr## 73## shufhqw## kljkhu## wkdq#wkh# # # vkruw0whup#rqh0 # 56# #Wklv#iljxuh#vxjjhvwv#wkdw#wkh#pdunhw#h{shfwhg#wkh#vhhplqj#fdop# # # # # # # # # # prqwk#yrodwlolw|1 # zrxog#hqg/#hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh#kljk#ohyho#ri#wkh#pdunhw#lqglfdwhg#lw#glg#qrw#sodfh#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kljk#suredelolw|#rq#hyhqwv#wxuqlqj#rxw#edgo|#iru#vkduhkroghuv1#Exw#wklv#lv#suhflvho|# # # # # # # # # # # # # krz#zh#zrxog#h{shfw#wkh#pdunhw#wr#ehkdyh#li#lw#eholhyhg#wkh#edqnv#zhuh#wdnlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#vxevlgl}hg#wdlo#ulvn1# # # # Wkxv## idu/## dv## zh## kdyh## pryhg## wkurxjk#wkh# # # frusrudwh## klhudufk|/## iurp#wudghu# # # wr# ulvn## pdqdjhu## wr## FHR## wr## frusrudwh## erdug## wr## vkduhkroghu/## zh## kdyh## irxqg## olwwoh# frqfhuq## dq|zkhuh## derxw## wkh## wdlo## ulvnv## wkdw## zhuh## exloglqj## xs/## hvshfldoo|## lq## wkh# djjuhvvlyh#edqnv1#Pdq|#ri#wkh#dfwruvᄇwudghuv/#pdqdjhphqw/#dqg#vkduhkroghuvᄇ# # # # # # # # # w|slfdoo|#irfxvhg#rq#wkh#dgydqwdjhv#ri#wdnlqj#wkh#wdlo#ulvn1#Lq#lqvxudqfh#sduodqfh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#zrxog#jhw#d#vkduh#ri#wkh#suhplxpv#wkdw#iorzhg#lq#zkloh#wkh#jrlqj#zdv#jrrg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh|#zrxog# # # eh## surwhfwhg## e|#olplwhg# # # oldelolw|#iurp#kdylqj#wr# # # # # pdnh## pdvvlyh# sd|rxwv#li#wkh#h{wuhph#ulvn#klw1#Zkr#wkhq#zrxog#devrue#wkh#orvvhvB# # # # # # # # # # # # W|slfdoo|/## wkh## dqvzhu## rxjkw## wr## eh## wkh## edqnᄊv## ghew## kroghuv1## Lq## wkh## fdvh## ri# frpphufldo## edqnv/## vrph## zhuh## IGLF0lqvxuhg## ghsrvlw## kroghuv/## zkr## zrxog## qrw# ehdu#orvvhv#lq#dq|#fdvh/#zkloh#rwkhuv#surwhfwhg#wkhpvhoyhv#e|#ohqglqj#vkruw#whup# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## ghpdqglqj## vhfxulw|## wr## edfn## wkhlu## ohqglqj1## Li## ghidxowv## rq## dvvhw0edfnhg# vhfxulwlhv## prxqwhg/## wkh## vkruw0whup## ohqghuv## wkrxjkw## wkh|## zrxog## eh## deoh## wr# zlwkgudz#dkhdg#ri#wkh#froodsvh1#Exw#qrw#doo#ri#wkhp#frxog#krsh#wr#hvfdsh#zlwkrxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdnlqj#d#klw1#Zk|#zhuh#wkh|#qrw#pruh#zruulhgB# # # # # # # # # Vlploduo|/## zk|## zhuh## kroghuv## ri## orqj0whup/## xqvhfxuhg## ghew## qrw## h{wuhpho|# ihduixo/## hvshfldoo|#jlyhq#wkh# # # # kljkhu## ixwxuh## h{shfwhg## yrodwlolw|#uhiohfwhg# # # lq#vkduh# # rswlrqvB#Edqn#ghew#kroghuv#w|slfdoo|#kdwh#yrodwlolw|/#dv#wkh|#jhw#qrqh#ri#wkh#xsvlgh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jdlqv#dqg#ehdu#doo# # # # # wkh#grzqvlgh#ulvn1#Edqn#ghew#vsuhdgv/#d#phdvxuh#ri#d#edqnᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # dqwlflsdwhg#ulvn#ri#ghidxow/#uhpdlqhg#yhu|#prghudwh#xqwlo#mxvw#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv1# # # # # # # # # # # #
Krz#wkh#Khoslqj#Kdqg#ri#wkh#Jryhuqphqw#Kxuwv # # # # # # # # Lw## lv## kdug## wr## dujxh## wkdw## ghew## kroghuv## zhuh## ljqrudqw## ri## wkh## ulvnv/## hvshfldoo|# zkhq## htxlw|## rswlrqv## pdunhwv## vhhphg## wr## eh## vljqdolqj## srvvleoh## wurxeoh1## Wkh# reylrxv#h{sodqdwlrq#iru#wkhlu#frqwlqxhg#h{srvxuh#wr#ulvn#lv#wkdw#ghew#kroghuv#glg# # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#wklqn#wkh|#zrxog#qhhg#wr#ehdu#orvvhv#ehfdxvh#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zrxog#vwhs#lq1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkhuh## zhuh## wzr## srvvleoh## uhdvrqv## iru## wklv## frpsodfhqf|ᄇuhdvrqv## wkdw## zhuh## lq# idfw## eruqh## rxw## e|## hyhqwv1## Iluvw/## xqvhfxuhg## erqgkroghuv## zruulhg## ohvv## wkdq## wkh|# vkrxog#kdyh#ehfdxvh#ri#wkh#survshfw#ri#gluhfw#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#lq#krxvlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## fuhglw#pdunhwv# # # li#pdwwhuv# # # wrrn#d# # # wxuq#iru# # # wkh## zruvh1## Vhfrqg/## wkh## lqvwlwxwlrqv# wkdw## wrrn## wkh## prvw## ulvn## zhuh## wkrvh## wkdw## zhuh## wkrxjkw## wr## eh## wrr## v|vwhplf## wr## eh# doorzhg#e|#wkh#jryhuqphqw#wr#idlo1#Wkh#edqnᄊv#ghew#kroghuv#zrxog#qrw#kdyh#kdg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # idfh## dq|#ulvn#ri# # # # ghidxow## li## wkh## jryhuqphqw## edlohg## wkh## ilup#rxw1# # # Qrw## rqo|#zrxog# # frqilghqfh#lq#d#edlorxw#kdyh#nhsw#ghew#frvwv#iurp#ulvlqj#lq#sursruwlrq#wr#edqn#ulvn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdnlqj/#exw#dovr/#zlwk#olwwoh#frqfhuq#h{suhvvhg#e|#ghew#kroghuv/#pdqdjhphqw#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # dq#hyhq#eurdghu#olfhqvh#wr#wdnh#rq#ohyhudjh#wr#errvw#uhwxuqv#iru#htxlw|1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Frqvlghu## wkh## qdwxuh## ri## wkh## wdlo## ulvnv1## Xqolnh## ruglqdu|## ordqv## ru## lqglylgxdo# pruwjdjhv/#zkhuh#ghidxowv#rffxu#lq#lvrodwlrq/#kljko|#udwhg/#glyhuvlilhg#pruwjdjh0 # # # # # # # # # edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#zhuh#olnho|#wr#ulvn#ghidxow#rqo|#li#pruwjdjhv#dfurvv#wkh#frxqwu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghidxowhg1#Li#vxfk#dq#lpsuredeoh#hyhqwxdolw|#zhuh#wr#rffxu/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # olnho|#eh#gudzq#lq#wr#vxssruwlqj#wkh#pdunhw#iru#krxvlqj#dqg#iru#krxvlqj#ilqdqfh=#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frxog## qrw## srvvleo|#vlw# # # lgo|#e|#dv# # # # ploolrqv## ri## krphrzqhuv## ghidxowhg1## Vlploduo|/# zkhq#vxfk#d#v|vwhplf#hyhqw#rffxuuhg/#qrw#rqo|#zrxog#odujh#edqnv#ilqg#uhilqdqflqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # gliilfxow/## exw## frusrudwlrqv## udqjlqj## iurp## wkh## odujh## wr## wkh## wlq|## zrxog## dovr## idfh# vljqlilfdqwo|#juhdwhu# # # ilqdqfldo## frqvwudlqwv1## Djdlq/## lw#zdv# # # xqolnho|#wkh# # # Ihg## zrxog# vwdqg## e|## lgo|## li## oltxlglw|## ydqlvkhg/## hvshfldoo|## jlyhq## wkh## surplvhv## Fkdlupdq# Juhhqvsdq## kdg## pdgh1## Vr## wkh## v|vwhplf## qdwxuh## ri## wdlo## ulvnv## hqvxuhg## wkdw## edqnv# zrxog#eh#froohfwlyho|#lq#wurxeoh#li#d#fulvlv#rffxuuhg/#dqg#wkdw#jryhuqphqw#vxssruw# # # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#eh#iruwkfrplqj1#Wklv#plwljdwhg#wkh#frvwv#ri#wkrvh#ulvnv1# # # # # # # # # # Dqg#wkdw#vxssruw#kdv#lqghhg#ehhq#iruwkfrplqj1#Vshflilfdoo|/#lq#rughu#wr#vxssruw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## krxvlqj## pdunhw/## wkh## ihghudo## jryhuqphqw## kdv## lqwurgxfhg## wd{## phdvxuhv## wkdw# hqfrxudjh## krph## rzqhuvkls/## lqfoxglqj## wkh## iluvw0wlph## krph## ex|hu#ᄊv## wd{## fuhglw1# Vlqfh## Vhswhpehu## 533;/## Idqqlh## Pdh/## Iuhgglh## Pdf/## dqg## wkh## Ihghudo## Krxvlqj# Dxwkrulw|#kdyh#ohqw#kxqguhgv# # # # # ri#eloolrqv# # # ri#grooduv# # # wr#orz0lqfrph#eruurzhuv# # # # lq# dq## dwwhpsw## wr## nhhs## krxvh## sulfhv## iurp## froodsvlqj1## Wkh## ilqdqfldo## zhevlwh# Eorrpehuj1frp## hvwlpdwhv## wkdw## lq## 533</## wkh## Ihg## dqg## wkh## Wuhdvxu|## wrjhwkhu# sxufkdvhg## '416## wuloolrq## zruwk## ri## djhqf|0lvvxhg## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv/## :9# shufhqw#ri#wkh#jurvv#lvvxdqfh#+lqfoxglqj#uhilqdqflqjv,/#dqg#pruh#wkdq#wkuhh#wlphv# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#qhw#lqfuhdvh#lq#wkh#vl}h#ri#wkh#pdunhw1#Hvwlpdwhv#vxjjhvw#wkdw#wkhvh#sxufkdvhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 57# orzhuhg## pruwjdjh## udwhv## e|## derxw## :8## edvlv## srlqwv1 # Wkh## vshfldo## lqvshfwru# jhqhudoᄊv## uhsruw## wr## Frqjuhvv## rq#wkh# # # Wurxeohg## Dvvhw## Uholhi#Surjudp#+WDUS,# # # # lq# Mdqxdu|## 5343## vwdwhv=## ᄈWkh## jryhuqphqw## kdv## grqh## pruh## wkdq## vlpso|## vxssruw## wkh# pruwjdjh## pdunhw1## Lq## pdq|## zd|v## lw## kdv## ehfrph## wkh## pruwjdjh## pdunhw## zlwk## wkh# 58# wd{sd|hu#vkrxoghulqj#wkh#ulvn#wkdw#kdg#rqfh#ehhq#eruqh#e|#wkh#sulydwh#lqyhvwru1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## Ilqdqfldo## Wlphv## uhsruwv## Qhlo## Edurivn|/## wkh## vshfldo## lqvshfwru## jhqhudo/## dv# vd|lqj=#ᄈDoo#ri#wkh#wklqjv#wkdw#zhuh#eurnhq#lq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw#dqg#wkh#gliihuhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
urohv#wkdw#gliihuhqw#sulydwh#sod|huv#kdyh#sod|hg/#vrph#ri#zklfk#zh#uhfrjql}h#qrz# # # # # # # # # # # # # ᆱ## dfwxdoo|#frqwulexwhg# # # wr## wkh## exeeoh## dqg## wr## wkh## hqvxlqj#fulvlv/# # # duh## uhdoo|#ehlqj# # 59# uhsolfdwhg#e|#jryhuqphqw#dfwruv1ᄡ # # # Hyhq#rxwvlgh#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw/#wkh#Ihg#sxoohg#rxw#doo#vwrsv/#hvshfldoo|#diwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#froodsvh#ri#Ohkpdq1#Wkh#Ihg#fxw#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wr#urfn#erwwrp#dqg#fuhdwhg#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ydulhw|#ri#lqqrydwlyh# # # # surjudpv## wr#ohqg#wr#wkh# # # # # sulydwh## vhfwru/#zkloh# # # wkh## Wuhdvxu|# uhfdslwdol}hg## ilupv## wkurxjk## WDUS1## Wkh## Ihghudo## Ghsrvlw## Lqvxudqfh## Frusrudwlrq# +IGLF,#dovr#fklsshg#lq#e|#whpsrudulo|#lqvxulqj#doo#edqn#ghew#lq#533;#dqg#xsslqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## txdqwxp#ri#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh1# # # # # Edqnv## wkdw#uhphpehuhg# # # wkh## Ihg## ulglqj#wr# # # wkh# uhvfxh#lq#5334#zlwk#urfn0erwwrp#lqwhuhvw#udwhv/#dqg#Dodq#Juhhqvsdqᄊv#vxevhtxhqw# # # # # # # # # # # glfwxp#wkdw# # # wkh## Ihg## zrxog## ᄈplwljdwh## wkh## idoorxw## zkhq## lw## rffxuv## dqg/## krshixoo|/# hdvh#wkh#wudqvlwlrq#wr#wkh#qh{w#h{sdqvlrq/ᄡ#zhuh#qrw#zurqj#lq#dqwlflsdwlqj#wkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog## eh## khoshg## rxw## ri## d## wljkw## fruqhu## |hw## djdlq1## Wkh## edqnv## wkdw## kdg## wdnhq## rq# oltxlglw|#ulvn#dqg#vxuylyhg#zhuh#uhzdughg#zlwk#vxevwdqwldo#surilwvᄇexw#vrph#glg# # # # # # # # # # # qrw#olyh#wr#vhh#kdss|#gd|v#uhwxuq1# # # # # # # Shukdsv#dq#htxdoo|#lpsruwdqw#gulyhu#ri#edqn#erqg0kroghu#frpsodfhqf|#zdv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # nqrzohgjh## wkdw## wkh## odujh## edqnv## wkh|## kdg## ohqw## wr## zhuh## olnho|## wr## eh## ghhphg## wrr# v|vwhplf## wr## idlo## e|#wkh# # # dxwkrulwlhv1## Khug## ehkdylru## sxw## wkh## lvvxh## odujho|#eh|rqg# # grxew=#li#pdq|#odujh#edqnv#wrrn#wkh#vdph#wdlo#ulvnv/#wkh|#zrxog#doo#eh#zhdn#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vdph#wlph/#dqg#wkh#fkdqfhv#wkdw#wkh#jryhuqphqw#zrxog#ulvn#d#sdqlf#e|#ohwwlqj#dq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rqh#ri#wkhp#jr#zrxog#eh#sursruwlrqdwho|#glplqlvkhg1#Khqu|#Sdxovrq/#vhfuhwdu|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## wuhdvxu|#dqg#wkxv# # # # wkh## ohdghu## ri#wkh# # # uhvfxh## lq#wkh# # # Exvk#dgplqlvwudwlrq/#zulwhv# # # derxw#wkh#IGLF0ohg#uhvroxwlrq#ri#Zdvklqjwrq#Pxwxdo#lq#Vhswhpehu#533;=# # # # # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|/## wkh## ZdPx## vroxwlrq## zdv## qrw## shuihfw/## dowkrxjk## lw## zdv# kdqgohg## vprrwko|## xvlqj## wkh## qrupdo## IGLF## surfhvv1## MS## Prujdqᄊv## sxufkdvh# frvw## wd{sd|huv## qrwklqj/## dqg## qr## ghsrvlwruv## orvw## prqh|/## exw## wkh## ghdo## jdyh# vhqlru## ZdPx## ghew## kroghuv## derxw## 88## fhqwv## rq## wkh## groodu/## urxjko|## htxdo## wr# zkdw## wkh## vhfxulwlhv## kdg## ehhq## wudglqj## iru1## Lq## uhwurvshfw/## L## vhh## wkdw## lq## wkh# plggoh#ri#d#sdqlf/#wklv#zdv#d#plvwdnh1#ZdPx/#wkh#vl{wk0eljjhvw#edqn#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwu|/#zdv# # # v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw1#Fuxvklqj#wkh# # # # # rzqhuv## ri#suhihuuhg#dqg# # # vxeruglqdwhg## ghew#dqg# # # folsslqj#vhqlru# # # ghew#kroghuv# # # rqo|#xqvhwwohg# # # wkh## ghew# kroghuv## lq## rwkhu## lqvwlwxwlrqv/## dgglqj## wr## wkh## pdunhwᄊv## xqfhuwdlqw|## derxw# 5:# jryhuqphqw#dfwlrq1 # # Wkxv#hyhq#wkrxjk#vkruwo|#ehiruh#ZdPxᄊv#uhvroxwlrq#wkh#pdunhw#ixoo|#h{shfwhg# # # # # # # # # # # ghew## kroghuv## zrxog## qrw## eh## sdlg## lq#ixoo/# # # dqg## hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh# # # # IGLF## kdg## wkh## ixoo# ohjdo#dxwkrulw|#wr#lpsrvh#orvvhv#rq#wkh#erqgkroghuv/#wkh#vhfuhwdu|#ri#wkh#wuhdvxu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{suhvvhg## uhpruvh## ryhu## wkh## dfwlrq1## Jlyhq## wkdw## wkh## rqo|## wlph## d## odujh/## zhoo0 glyhuvlilhg#edqn#fdq#jhw#lqwr#wurxeoh#lv#lq#wkh#plgvw#ri#d#qdwlrqzlgh#grzqwxuq#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # srvvleoh#sdqlf/#wkh#vhfuhwdu|ᄊv#orjlf#zrxog#surwhfw#edqn#erqgkroghuv#iurp#hyhu# # # # # # # # # # # vxiihulqj#orvvhv#dqg#uhpryh#dq#lpsruwdqw#vrxufh#ri#pdunhw#glvflsolqh#rq#edqnhu# # # # # # # # # # # # dfwlrqv1# Lq#vxp/# # # li#edqn#pdqdjhphqw# # # # kdg## ixoo|#xqghuvwrrg# # # wkh## ulvnv## wkh|#zhuh# # # wdnlqj/# wkhlu#ghflvlrqv#frxog#kdyh#hyroyhg#dv#iroorzv1#Lq#wkh#hduo|#vwdjhv#ri#wdnlqj#rq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdlo## ulvn/## vxfk#dv# # # wkh## ghidxow#ulvn#lq#pruwjdjh0edfnhg# # # # # vhfxulwlhv## ru## wkh## oltxlglw|# ulvn#lq#eruurzlqj#vkruw#whup#wr#ixqg#orqj0whup#dvvhwv/#wkh|#zrxog#kdyh#surfhhghg# # # # # # # # # # # # #
fdxwlrxvo|## dqg## hyhq## vxuuhswlwlrxvo|1## Diwhu## doo/## wkh## surilwv## iurp## vxfk## dfwlylwlhv# zrxog#orrn#d#orw#khdowklhu#li#qr#rqh#nqhz#wkh#ulvnv#wkh|#zhuh#wdnlqj1#Dffruglqjo|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Flwledqnᄊv## rii0edodqfh## vkhhw## frqgxlwv/## kroglqj## dq## hqruprxv## txdqwlw|## ri## dvvhw0 edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#ixqghg#zlwk#vkruw0whup#ghew/#zhuh#klgghq#iurp#doo#exw#wkh#prvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # fduhixo#dqdo|vwv1# # Exw#dv#hqrxjk#edqnv#lplwdwhg#wkh#lqqrydwruv#dqg#wrrn#rq#vlplodu#ulvnv/#dqg#dv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdph## frpprq## zlvgrp#dprqj# # # pdunhw## sduwlflsdqwv## wkdw## wkh## pdunhw## zrxog## eh# vxssruwhg#lq#wkh#hyhqw#ri#d#fulvlv/#wkhuh#zrxog#kdyh#ehhq#vwurqj#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#ordg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xs#rq#wkh#wdlo#ulvnv/#hyhq#li#vxfk#dfwlylw|#ehfdph#ylvleoh1#Wkh#pdunhw#zrxog#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # irfxvhg## rq## wkh## surilw## srwhqwldo## ri## vxfk## ulvn## wdnlqj/## nqrzlqj## wkdw## prvw## ri## wkh# orvvhv/## lq#wkh# # # uhprwh## hyhqwxdolw|#wkdw#wkh|#rffxuuhg/# # # # # zrxog## eh## sdvvhg## rq#wr# # # wkh# jryhuqphqw## dqg## wkh## wd{sd|hu1## Lqghhg/## dq## hqwlw|## ilqdqfhg## zlwk## vkruw0whup# eruurzlqj/#nqrzlqj#wkdw#lw#zrxog#eh#xqdeoh#wr#uhsd|#lwv#ghewv#li#oltxlglw|#gulhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # xs/#kdg#d#srzhuixo#lqfhqwlyh#wr#grxeoh#xs#rq#lwv#ehw#wkdw#oltxlglw|#zrxog#dozd|v# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh#dydlodeohᄇe|#ex|lqj#dvvhwv#wkdw#zrxog#idoo#lq#ydoxh#li#oltxlglw|#gulhg#xs#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|#ohyhudjlqj#hyhq#pruh1#Wkh#vlpsoh#uhdvrq#lv#wkdw#olplwhg#oldelolw|#surwhfwhg#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # vkduhkroghuv#djdlqvw#orvlqj#pruh#li#lwv#ehwv#zhqw#zurqj#dqg#oltxlglw|#glg#gu|#xs># # # # # # # # # # # # # # 5;# dqg#li#lw#jxhvvhg#uljkw/#lw#zrxog#pdnh#d#wrq#ri#prqh|1 # # # # # # # # # # # # Qr#zrqghu#h{srvxuhv#wr# # # # erwk## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## dqg## vkruw0whup## ohyhudjh## lqfuhdvhg## vwhdglo|# ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv1# # # Dqwlflsdwlrq#ri#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrqv#zrxog#kdyh#pdgh#lw#hyhq#kdughu#iru# # # # # # # # # # # dq|## edqn## wr## mxvwli|## d## frqvhuydwlyh## vwdqfh## gxulqj## wkh## uxq0xs## wr## wkh## fulvlv1## Iru# lqvwdqfh/## rqh## ri## wkh## uhzdugv## ri## pdlqwdlqlqj#d# # # yhu|#oltxlg# # # edodqfh## vkhhw## lv## wkdw# zkhq## oltxlglw|## gulhv## xs## lq## pdunhwv/## wkh## edqn## fdq## sxufkdvh## dvvhwv## dw## edujdlq0 edvhphqw## sulfhv## iurp## wkrvh## zkr## kdyh## ehhq## wrr## djjuhvvlyh1## Exw## li## wkh## Ihg# lqwhuyhqhv## wr## ohqg## iuhho|#dw#vxfk#wlphv/# # # # # wkh## glvfrxqw#rq#dvvhwv# # # # lv## idu## ohvv## wkdq#lw# # zrxog#rwkhuzlvh#eh1#Pdq|#wurxeohg#edqnv#khog#dvvhwv#wkurxjk#wkh#fulvlv#wkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # vkrxog## kdyh## ehhq## irufhg## wr## vhoo/## uhgxflqj## wkh## sxqlvkphqw## wkh|## vxiihuhg## iru# pdlqwdlqlqj## looltxlg## edodqfh## vkhhwv## dqg## uhgxflqj## wkh## srwhqwldo## jdlq## wr## erwwrp0 ihhglqj#frqvhuydwlyh#edqnv1# # # Ilqdoo|/## doo## wklv## ehkdylru## lqfuhdvhg## wkh## olnholkrrg## ri## wkh## wdlo## ulvnᄊv# pdwhuldol}lqj#vxevwdqwldoo|1#Zkhq#ihz#edqnv#pdlqwdlq#oltxlg#uhvhuyhv#hyhq#zkloh# # # # # # # # # # ohyhudjlqj#wkhlu#edodqfh#vkhhwv#wr#wkh#klow/#wkh#voljkwhvw#dgyhuvh#vkrfn#fdq#wls#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhp#ryhu#lqwr#d#ixoo0iohgjhg#sdqlf1#Vlploduo|/#dv#sxufkdvhv#ri#pruwjdjh0edfnhg# # # # # # # # # # # vhfxulwlhv## lqfuhdvh## zlwkrxw## pxfk## dwwhqwlrq## ehlqj## sdlg## wr## ghidxow## ulvn/## pruwjdjh# ohqglqj## h{sdqgv## dqg## wkh## txdolw|## ri## ohqglqj## ghwhulrudwhv/## pdnlqj## zlghvsuhdg# ghidxow#pruh#olnho|#li#krxvh#sulfhv#vwduw#gursslqj1# # # # # # # # Lq#doo# # # wklv/## rqh## fdqqrw## ljqruh## wkh## dfwlrqv## ri#wkh# # # uhjxodwru1## Rqh## ri#wkh# # # idfwruv# surshoolqj## edqnv## lqwr## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## zdv## wkhlu## orz## fdslwdo# uhtxluhphqwv## uhodwlyh## wr## gluhfw## ohqglqj1## Wkh## pdunhw/## krzhyhu/## sulfhg## wkhvh# vhfxulwlhv## dv## li## wkh|## zhuh## ulvnlhu## wkdq## wkh## uhjxodwruv## eholhyhg## wkhp## wr## eh## +dv# lqghhg## wkh|## zhuh,1## Edqnv## wkxv## froohfwhg## wkh## kljkhu## uhwxuq## rq## wkhvh## vhfxulwlhv# zkloh## pdlqwdlqlqj#olwwoh# # # fdslwdo/## wkhuhe|#rewdlqlqj#d# # # # vhhplqjo|#khdowk|#uhwxuq#rq# # # # fdslwdo1#Lq#d#vhqvh/#wkhuhiruh/#uhjxodwruv#lqdgyhuwhqwo|#srlqwhg#edqnv#wrzdug#wkhvh# # # # # # # # # # # vhfxulwlhv1## Lq#vrph# # # zd|v## sudfwlfhv## olnh## wklv## duh## dq#xqdyrlgdeoh# # # frqvhtxhqfh## ri# uhjxodwlrq1## Li## edqnv## kdyh## dq## lqfhqwlyh## wr## wdnh## ulvn/## wkh|## zloo## dozd|v## orrn## iru# rssruwxqlwlhv## wr#jhw#wkh#juhdwhvw#edqj#iru# # # # # # # wkh#uhjxodwru|#exfn1#Exw#wkh#uhjxodwru|# # # # # #
plvwdnh## ri#uhtxlulqj#wrr# # # # olwwoh## fdslwdo## iru## fhuwdlq#dfwlylwlhv# # # lv## wkhq#frpsrxqghg# # ehfdxvh## lq#wdnlqj#dgydqwdjh# # # # ri#uhjxodwru|#plvwdnhv/# # # # edqnv## exlog## xs## h{srvxuh## wr# wkh#vdph#ulvnv1#Wkh#g|qdplf#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#v|vwhplf#ulvn#h{srvxuhv#wkhq#nlfnv# # # # # # # # # # # # lq=#li#hyhu|rqh#lv#h{srvhg#wr#wkh#vdph#ulvn#lq#d#elj#zd|/#wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#kdyh#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rswlrq#exw#wr#lqwhuyhqh#wr#vxssruw#edqnv#dqg#wkh#pdunhw#li#wkh#ulvn#pdwhuldol}hvᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#zklfk#fdvh#d#edqn#pd{lpl}hv#surilwv#e|#lqfuhdvlqj#h{srvxuh#wr#wkh#ulvn1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Wkh## sureohp#ri#wdlo# # # # ulvn#wdnlqj#lv# # # # sduwlfxoduo|#dfxwh# # # lq#wkh# # # prghuq#ilqdqfldo# # v|vwhp/## zkhuh## edqnhuv## duh## xqghu## wuhphqgrxv## suhvvxuh## wr## surgxfh## ulvn0dgmxvwhg# shuirupdqfh1## Ihz## fdq## gholyhu## vxshulru## shuirupdqfh## rq## d## uhjxodu## edvlv/## exw# suhflvho|## iru## wklv## uhdvrq/## wkh## uhzdugv## iru## wkrvh## zkr## fdq## duh## hqruprxv1## Wkh# suhvvxuh#rq#wkh#vhfrqg0udwh#wr#wdnh#wdlo#ulvn/#wkxv#doorzlqj#wkhp#wr#pdvtxhudgh#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxshuvwduv#iru#d#zkloh/#lv#lqwhqvh1# # # # # # Wkh#pdunhw#vkrxog#wkhruhwlfdoo|#hqfrxudjh#jrrg#ulvn#pdqdjhphqw#dqg#shqdol}h# # # # # # # # # # h{fhvvlyh#ulvn#wdnlqj1#Exw#wdlo#ulvnv#duh#gliilfxow#wr#frqwuro#iru#wzr#uhdvrqv1#Iluvw/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#duh#kdug#wr#uhfrjql}h#ehiruh#wkh#idfw/#hyhq#iru#wkrvh#zkr#duh#wdnlqj#wkhp1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfrqg/#rqfh#hqrxjk#ulvn#lv#wdnhq/#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#iru#wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#wr#lqwhuyhqh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # plwljdwh## wkh## idoorxw## lv## vwurqj1## E|## lqwhuyhqlqj/## wkh## dxwkrulwlhv## uhgxfh## pdunhw# glvflsolqh/#lqghhg#lqgxflqj#pdunhwv#wr#vxssruw#vxfk#ehkdylru1#Edqnhuv#pd|#lq#idfw# # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## ehhq## jxlghg## lqwr## wdnlqj## wdlo## ulvnv## dv## pdunhwv## dqwlflsdwhg## jryhuqphqw# lqwhuyhqwlrq#lq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw#dqg#oltxlglw|#dqg#ohqglqj#vxssruw#iurp#wkh#Ihg# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#wkh#IGLF1# # # Wklv#dujxphqw#lv#qrw#phdqw#wr#devroyh#edqnhuv1#Vrph#xqghuvwrrg#wkh#ulvn#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## wdnlqj#dqg# # # ljqruhg## lw>#pdq|#glg# # # # qrw#uhfrjql}h# # # lw#exw#vkrxog# # # # kdyh1## Zkdw#lv# # sduwlfxoduo|#doduplqj#lv#wkdw#wkh#ulvn#wdnlqj#pd|#zhoo#kdyh#ehhq#lq#wkh#ehvw#h{#dqwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuhvwv## ri## wkhlu## vkduhkroghuv1## Rqh## vkrxog## mxgjh## wkh## Flwljurxsᄊv## erdugᄊv# frpshwhqfh#qrw#rqo|#e|#wkh#idfw#wkdw#lwv#vkduh#sulfh#vdqn#ehorz#'4#lq#wkh#plgvw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#fulvlv#exw#dovr#e|#wkh#idfw#wkdw#wkh#sulfh#uhdfkhg#wkh#plg0'83v#mxvw#ehiruh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fulvlv#lq#wkh#vsulqj#ri#533:1#Wkh#vwrfn#pdunhw#lv#qrw#dq#dqrq|prxv/#glvwdqw#hqwlw|=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw## lv## xv/## dqg## froohfwlyho|## zh## ihwhg## dfwlylwlhv## wkdw## hyhqwxdoo|## suryhg## kljko|# ghwulphqwdo## wr## vrflhw|1## Lqghhg/## edqn## FHRv## zkr## uhpdlqhg## frqvhuydwlyh## zhuh# grlqj## wkh## uljkw## wklqj## e|## vrflhw|## exw## txlwh## srvvleo|## qrw## e|## wkhlu## vkduhkroghuv1# Fhuwdlqo|/#wklv#vhhpv#wr#kdyh#ehhq#wkh#pdunhwᄊv#ylhz#ehiruh#wkh#fulvlv#klw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/#vroxwlrqv#duh#idluo|#hdv|#li#zh#wklqn#wkh#edqnhuv#ylrodwhg#wudiilf# # # # # # # # # # # # # vljqdov=#zh#vkrxog#kdqg#wkhp#vwlii#wlfnhwv#ru#sxw#wkhp#lq#mdlo1#Exw#zkdw#li#zh#exlow# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dq#hoderudwh# # # vhw#ri#wudiilf# # # # vljqdov## wkdw#srlqwhg# # # wkhp#lq#wkh# # # # zurqj#gluhfwlrqB# # # Zh# frxog#dujxh#wkdw#wkh|#vkrxog#kdyh#xvhg#wkhlu#prudo#frpsdvv/#dqg#vrph#glg>#exw/#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # L## lqglfdwhg## lq## wkh## suhylrxv## fkdswhu/## wkh## lqgxvwu|ᄊv## hqwluh## v|vwhp#ri# # # ydoxhv## xvhv# prqh|#dv# # # wkh#phdvxuh#ri#doo# # # # # wklqjv1#Vroxwlrqv# # # duh#pxfk#pruh#gliilfxow#li#lw#wxuqv# # # # # # # rxw## wkdw## wkh## vljqdov## duh## eurnhq/## dw## ohdvw## iurp#wkh# # # shuvshfwlyh## ri## rxu## froohfwlyh# vrflhwdo#lqwhuhvwv1# # Pruhryhu/## L## gr## qrw## phdq## wr## vxjjhvw/## e|## dwwulexwlqj## vrph## ri## wkh## fulvlv## wr# edqnhuvᄊ## dqg## pdunhw## frqilghqfh## lq## d## jryhuqphqw## edlorxw/## wkdw## wkh## dxwkrulwlhv# vkrxog#vlw#edfn#dqg#zdwfk#wkh#hfrqrp|#froodsvh1#Udwkhu/#L#zdqw#wr#hpskdvl}h#wkdw# # # # # # # # # ## # # # wkh#frpelqdwlrq#ri#lqfhqwlyhv#iru#kljk0srzhuhg#shuirupdqfh#wkdw#duh#lqkhuhqw#lq# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## prghuq#ilqdqfldo# # # v|vwhp#dqg# # # wkh## xqzloolqjqhvv## ri#d# # # flylol}hg## jryhuqphqw#wr# # ohw## idloxuh## lq## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## gudj## grzq## ruglqdu|## flwl}hqv## jhqhudwhv## wkh# srwhqwldo#iru#wdlo#ulvn#wdnlqj#dqg#shulrglf/#frvwo|#phowgrzqv1#Hyhq#dv#L#zulwh/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # ## # hqruprxv#dprxqwv#ri#wd{sd|hu#prqh|#ehlqj#gluhfwhg#dw#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnv## duh## fuhdwlqj#qhz# # # h{shfwdwlrqv## derxw#jryhuqphqw#dqg# # # # Ihg## ehkdylru## lq#wkh# #
qh{w## fulvlv1## Rxu## fhqwudo## irfxv## lq## dq|## uhirupv## vkrxog## eh## rq## glvshoolqj## vxfk# h{shfwdwlrqv/#dqg#wkdw#lv#wkh#wrslf#L#wxuq#wr#qrz1# # # # # # ## # #
FKDSWHU#HLJKW #
Uhiruplqj#Ilqdqfh # #
ZH#KDYH#PDGH#D#IXOO#WRXU#GH#WDEOH# # # # # # # # # lq#vhdufklqj#iru#wkh#xqghuo|lqj#fdxvhv# # # # # #
ri#wklv# # # fulvlv1## Dv## L#zulwh/# # # ilqdqfldo## vhfwruv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## kdyh## ehhq#eurxjkw# # edfn#iurp#wkh# # # # eulqn#wkurxjk#d# # # # frpelqdwlrq#ri#jryhuqphqw#jxdudqwhhv/#lqmhfwlrqv# # # # # ri#fdslwdo/#dqg#fhqwudo# # # # # edqn#ohqglqj1#Urfn0erwwrp#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # # # frqwlqxh## wr#edlo# # rxw#edqnv#dw#wkh#h{shqvh#ri#vdyhuv=#li#edqnv#fdq#eruurz#dw#doprvw#qr#lqwhuhvw#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ohqg## dw## d## khiw|## vsuhdg/## lw## lv## kdug## iru## wkhp## qrw## wr## pdnh## prqh|1## Jryhuqphqw# vshqglqj#dfurvv# # # wkh## zruog## vhhpv## wr## kdyh## khoshg## pdlqwdlq#dfwlylw|/# # # wkrxjk#lw# # # lv# vwloo## xqfhuwdlq## zkhwkhu## khdylo|## lqghewhg## krxvhkrogv/## hvshfldoo|## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv/#zloo#wdnh#xs#wkh#wdvn#ri#vshqglqj#zkhq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#vwlpxoxv#uxqv#rxw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#prvw#olnho|#surjqrvlv#lv#iru#d#shulrg#ri#uhodwlyho|#vorz#jurzwk#dqg#prxqwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#ghew#reoljdwlrqv#lq#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv1#Iruwxqdwho|/#wkrxjk/#zh#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # vwrsshg## iroorzlqj## wkh## sdwk## ri## wkh## Juhdw## Ghsuhvvlrq1## Frvwo|## dv## wklv## fulvlv## zloo# suryh/#lw#frxog#kdyh#ehhq#zruvh1# # # # # # Wkh## idxow#olqhv# # # dqg## iudjlolwlhv## L#kdyh# # # lghqwlilhg## zloo## qrw/## krzhyhu/## vlpso|#jr# # dzd|#zlwk#wkh#sdvvdjh#ri#wlph1#Vrph#ri#wkhp/#lqghhg/#duh#ghhshqlqj1#Wkh|#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qhhg## wr## eh## dgguhvvhg## gluhfwo|1## Exw## hyhq## zkloh## srolwlfldqv## vhqvh## wkh## qhhg## iru# uhirupv/#sxeolf#glvwuxvw#lv#jurzlqj#iru#dq|wklqj#wkdw#kdv#wr#gr#zlwk#wkh#vwdwxv#txr1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Udglfdo## sursrvdov## wudyhuvh## wkh## eorjrvskhuhᄇwkrxjk#zlwk#doo# # # # wkh## xskhdydo/## wkh# sxeolf#wrohudqfh#ri#wkh#dgglwlrqdo#xqfhuwdlqw|#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#fkdqjh#lv#dovr#orz1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#sxeolf#kdv#orvw#idlwk#lq#d#v|vwhp#zkhuh#wkh#uxohv#ri#wkh#jdph#vhhp#wlowhg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # idyru## ri## d## ihz1## Vrph## ri## wkh## edlorxw## sursrvdov/## sxw## wrjhwkhu## ryhu## vohhsohvv# zhhnhqgv/#vhhp#srruo|#wkrxjkw#wkurxjk#dw#ehvw#dqg#wdlqwhg#e|#fruuxswlrq#dw#zruvw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Uroolqj## Vwrqhᄊv## Pdww#Wdleel# # # kdv## fdoohg## Jrogpdq#Vdfkvᄇd# # # edqn#zlwk#doxpql# # # # lq# hyhu|#fruqhu# # # ri#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw/## dqg/## ghvslwh## lwv## surwhvwdwlrqv## wr## wkh## frqwudu|/## d# vljqlilfdqw## ehqhilfldu|## ri## wkh## uhvfxhᄇd## ᄈeorrg0vxfnlqj## ydpsluh## vtxlg1ᄡ4## Wkh# hslwkhw#vhhpv#wr#kdyh#vwxfn/#hslwrpl}lqj#wkh#sxeolf#prrg1#Wlq0hduhg#edqnhuv#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## khoshg/## sd|lqj## wkhpvhoyhv## kxjh## erqxvhv## vrrq## diwhu## ehlqj## uhvfxhg## e|## dq# rqjrlqj#sxeolf#edlorxw/#dqg/#shukdsv#pruh#lqixuldwlqjo|/#h{suhvvlqj#vxusulvhg#kxuw# # # # # # # # # # dw#wkh#sxeolf#uhdfwlrq1# # # # Wkh## sulydwh## vhfwru/## krzhyhu/## lv## qrw## dorqh## lq## ghvhuylqj## eodph1## Wkhuh## lv# vxevwdqwldo## hylghqfh## wkdw## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq#dqg# # # uhjxodwru|#idloxuh# # # kdg## dv# pxfk#ri#d#uroh#wr#sod|#lq#wklv#fulvlv#dv#sulydwh0vhfwru#idloxuh=# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqghhg/#lw#zdv#wkh# # # # frplqj#wrjhwkhu#ri#wkh#wzr#wkdw#kdg#wkh#prvw#vhyhuh#frqvhtxhqfhv1#Wkh#whpswdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # iru#srolwlfldqv/#krzhyhu/#zloo#eh#wr#eodph/#dqg#uhyhuvh/#hyhu|#suhfulvlv#wuhqg#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## jurxqgv## wkdw## lw## lv## vrphkrz## dvvrfldwhg## zlwk/## dqg## khqfh## uhvsrqvleoh/## iru## wkh# fulvlvᄇdqg#wkh#wuhqg#zdv#wrzdug#d#juhdwhu#uroh#iru#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru1#Wkh#wdujhwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # iru## wkh## irufhv## ri## uhdfwlrq## duh## reylrxv1## Wkh## sxeolf## kdv## h{suhvvhg## zlghvsuhdg# uhyxovlrq#djdlqvw#wkh#olehudol}dwlrq#wkdw#ohg#wr#pruh#yleudqw#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # iuhhu## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv1## Wkh## irufhv## djdlqvw## joredol}dwlrqᄇwkh## juhdwhu# lqwhjudwlrq## ri## frxqwulhv## wkurxjk## wudgh/## pxowlqdwlrqdo## ilupv/## fdslwdo## iorzv/## dqg#
pljudwlrqᄇduh## dovr## uhjurxslqj/## jdlqlqj#vxffru# # # iurp#wkh# # # qdwxudo## zloolqjqhvv## wr# orrn#deurdg# # # iru## wkh## urrwv## ri#rqhᄊv# # # sureohpv1## Glhkdug## vrfldolvwv## duh## fhoheudwlqj# wkh#judqg#fulvhv#wkdw#wkh|#vhh#dv#kduelqjhuv#ri#wkh#froodsvh#ri#fdslwdolvp1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ilqdqfh/## pdunhwv/## joredol}dwlrq/## dqg## iuhh0hqwhusulvh## fdslwdolvp## zloo## hqgxuh# eh|rqg## wklv## fulvlv1## Exw#uhfhqw#hyhqwv# # # # gr## dvn#xv# # # wr## pdnh## kdug## fkrlfhv/## qrw#derxw# # fdslwdolvp#lwvhoi/#exw#derxw#wkh#irup#ri#iuhh0hqwhusulvh#fdslwdolvp#zh#ghvluh1#Li#zh# # # # # # # # # # # # # gr#qrw#phqg#wkh#idxow#olqhv/#zh#frxog#zhoo#kdyh#dqrwkhu#fulvlv/#doehlw#gliihuhqw#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv#ghwdlov#iurp#wkh#fxuuhqw#rqh1#Dqrwkhu# # # # # # # # fulvlv#zloo# # # wd{#douhdg|#vwuhwfkhg#sxeolf# # # # dqg## krxvhkrog## ilqdqfhv/## dv## zhoo## dv## wkh## iud|lqj## srolwlfdo## frqvhqvxv## ehklqg## wkh# v|vwhp/## shukdsv## wr## euhdnlqj#srlqw1# # # Uhirup#zloo# # # wkhq#eh# # # pxfk#kdughu1# # # Lqvwhdg## ri# whvwlqj#surylghqfh/#zh#vkrxog#wdnh#wklv#fulvlv#dv#d#zdnh0xs#fdoo#iru#uhirup1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Zh#kdyh#kdug#fkrlfhv# # # # # wr#pdnh/#dv# # # # wkh#jrrg#dqg#wkh#edg#duh#w|slfdoo|#forvho|# # # # # # # # lqwhuwzlqhg1## Udglfdo## srvlwlrqv## wkdw## vhh## wkh## v|vwhp#dv# # # ixqgdphqwdoo|#eurnhq#duh# # # srsxodu1#Wkh|#ilw#lq#zlwk#wkh#sxeolf#prrg/#dqg#wkh|#duh#hdv|#wr#wrxw#lq#wkhvh#wlphv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#juhdwhvw#phulw#ehlqj#wkhlu#glvwdqfh#iurp#wkh#fxuuhqw#v|vwhp1# # # # # # # # # # Lq#ghihqglqj#wkh# # # # edvlf## vwuxfwxuh## ri#d# # # v|vwhp#wkdw#kdv# # # # idlohg/## L#idfh# # # wkh## ulvn#ri# # ehlqj#glvplvvhg#dv#d#frqvhuydwlyh/#dq#xquhjhqhudwh#dsrorjlvw/#ru#zruvh/#d#wrdg|# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#edqnlqj#lqwhuhvwv#wkdw#idyru#wkh#vwdwxv#txr1#Exw#dowkrxjk#v|vwhplf#idloxuh#grhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # lpso|## wkh## qhhg## iru## vhulrxv## uhirup/## lw## grhv## qrw## phdq## wkdw## d## udglfdoo|## gliihuhqw# v|vwhp#zrxog#eh#ehwwhu1#L#eholhyh#zh#kdyh#wr#zrun#wr#il{#wkh#v|vwhp/#exw#wkhuh#lv#d# # # # ## # # # # # # # # # # # # orw#zruwk#nhhslqj1#Vr#wkh#fkrlfhv#L#sursrvh#duh#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|#phdqw#wr#vkrfn=# # # # # # ## # # # # # # wkh|#duh#phdqw#wr#il{#wkh#sureohpv#L#kdyh#lghqwlilhg/#zklfk#duh#vhulrxv#lqghhg1#L# # # # # # # ## # # # # # # vwduw#zlwk#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru/#zkhuh#vr#pdq|#idxow#olqhv#phhw1# # # # # # # # # # # Wr#ehjlq/#zh#kdyh#wr#wdnh#d#vwdqg#rq#zkhwkhu#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#dfwxdoo|#khosv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#surfhvv#ri#hfrqrplf#jurzwk#dqg#zhoo0ehlqj#ru#zkhwkhu#lw#lv#mxvw#d#vlghvkrz/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dq#luuhohydqfh#wkdw#pdnhv#lwv#suhvhqfh#ihow#rqo|#e|#lpsorglqj#shulrglfdoo|1#Li#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # odwwhu#lv#wkh#fdvh/#wkhq#uhirup#lv#hdv|=#surklelw#pdq|#ri#wkh#fxuuhqw#dfwlylwlhv#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#vhfwru/#fuhdwh#d#ihz#vwdeoh#prqrsrolhv/#uhjxodwh#doo#uhpdlqlqj#dfwlylwlhv# # # # # # # # # # # yhu|## forvho|/## dqg## irujhw## derxw## wkh## vhfwru## iru## wkh## qh{w## ihz## ghfdghv1## Vhulrxv# hfrqrplvwv## dqg## srolf|#pdnhuv# # # kdyh## fdoohg## iru## vxfk#uhirupv/# # # eurdgo|#xqghu# # # wkh# uxeulf#ri#ᄈpdnlqj#ilqdqfh#erulqj1ᄡ#Li#wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # vhfwru#lv# # # fhqwudo## wr## hfrqrplf# jurzwk/## wkrxjk/## uhirup## ehfrphv## pruh## fkdoohqjlqj/## ehfdxvh## zh## kdyh## wr## olplw# ilqdqfhᄊv#delolw|#wr#gr#gdpdjh#zkloh#kduqhvvlqj#lwv#fuhdwlyh#hqhujlhv1#Wklv#lv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkdoohqjh#L#dgguhvv#lq#wklv#fkdswhu1# ## # # # Wr## pdnh## wkh## ghedwh## pruh## frqfuhwh/## L## rxwolqh## srodu0rssrvlwh## srvlwlrqv## rq## d# vshflilf#lvvxh=#h{sdqglqj#dffhvv#wr#fuhglw1#L#dujxh#wkdw#lw#lv#erwk#ghprfudwlf#dqg# # # # # # ## # # # # # # hiilflhqw## wr## frqwlqxh## wr## h{sdqg## wkh## udqjh## ri## fkrlfhv## shrsoh## kdyh1## Uhjxodwru|# uhirup#wkdw#dwwhpswv#wr#gr#rwkhuzlvh#zloo#qrw#vxuylyh#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq/#hvshfldoo|#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # d## ghprfudf|1## Wkh## uhdo## lvvxh## frqiurqwlqj## xv/## wkhuhiruh/## lv## krz## wr## kduqhvv## wkh# ehqhilwv#iurp#ilqdqfldo#ghyhorsphqw#zkloh#olplwlqj#lwv#lqvwdelolw|1#L#rxwolqh#vrph# # # # # # # # ## # ri#wkh#sulqflsohv#wkdw#uhirupv#zloo# # # # # # # qhhg#wr#uhvshfw#dqg#wkhq#wdnh#rq#wkh#frqfuhwh# # # # # # # # # lvvxh## ri## krz## zh## fdq## uhgxfh## wkh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## wdnh## rq## wdlo## ulvn## wkdw## zdv## vr# shuydvlyh#gxulqj#wkh#fxuuhqw#fulvlv1#L#hqg#zlwk#wkrxjkwv#rq#krz#wr#pdnh#wkh#v|vwhp# # # # # ## # # # # # # # # uhvlolhqw#wr#xqiruhvhhq#gdqjhuv1# # # #
Ghprfudwl}dwlrq#yhuvxv#Ghew # # # Wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#lv/#lq#pdq|#zd|v/#wkh#eudlq#ri#d#prghuq#hfrqrp|1#Zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#ixqfwlrqv# # # zhoo/## lw#doorfdwhv# # # uhvrxufhv## dqg## ulvn#hiihfwlyho|#dqg# # # # wkhuhe|#errvwv# # hfrqrplf## jurzwk## zkloh## dovr## pdnlqj## olyhv## hdvlhu/## vdihu/## dqg## pruh## ixoiloolqj1## Lw# eurdghqv## rssruwxqlw|## dqg## dwwdfnv## sulylohjh1## Lw## zrunv## iru## doo## ri## xv1## Ri## frxuvh/# zkhq#lw#zrunv#srruo|/#dv#lw#kdv#grqh#uhfhqwo|/#lw#fdq#gr#hqruprxv#gdpdjh#zkloh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehqhilwlqj#d#yhu|#ihz1# # # # D#qduurzhu#frqfhuq/#exw#rqh#wkdw#wrxfkhv#hyhu|#krxvhkrog/#lv#zkhwkhu#dffhvv# # # # # # # # # # # # wr## ilqdqfh## lv## vr## gdqjhurxv## wkdw## vrph## shrsoh## vkrxog## eh## nhsw## iurp## lw/## ru## wkhlu# dffhvv## vhyhuho|## uhjxodwhg1## Gldphwulfdoo|## gliihulqj## ylhzv## h{lvw## rq## zkhwkhu# eurdghqlqj#dffhvv#wr#eruurzlqj#wkurxjk#ghyhorsphqwv#vxfk#dv#fuhglw#fdugv/#krph# # # # # # # # # # # htxlw|## ordqv/## dqg## sd|gd|## ohqglqj## lv## jrrg## ru## edg1## Rqh## ylhz## lv## wkdw## wkh# ghprfudwl}dwlrq## ri## fuhglw## lv## dq## hplqhqwo|## ghvludeoh## ghyhorsphqw15## Lw## doorzv# krxvhkrogv## wr## eruurz## djdlqvw## ixwxuh## lqfrph## dqg## vprrwk#wkhlu# # # frqvxpswlrq#dqg# # h{shqglwxuh## ryhu## wlph/## zkloh## dovr## diiruglqj## vpdoo## hqwuhsuhqhxuv## wkh## delolw|## wr# vwduw#wkhlu#yhqwxuhv=#pdq|#d#vpdoo#yhqwxuh#kdv#ehhq#vwduwhg#wkurxjk#eruurzlqj#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhglw#fdugv1# # Sursrqhqwv#ri#wklv#ylhz#pdnh#wkh#ixqgdphqwdo#dvvxpswlrq#wkdw#prvw#krxvhkrogv# # # # # # # # # # # duh#udwlrqdo# # # dqg#uhvsrqvleoh=# # # wkh|#zloo# # # eruurz## rqo|#dv# # # pxfk#dv# # # wkh|#qhhg/#zlwk# # # ixoo## dzduhqhvv## ri## wkh## frqvhtxhqfhv1## Dq|## dwwhpsw## wr## frqvwudlq## wkhlu## fkrlfhv## lv# sdwhuqdolvwlf## dqg## xqzduudqwhg1## Lqghhg/## sursrqhqwv## ri## wklv## ylhz## xvh## wkh## whup# fuhglw#wr#ghqrwh#eruurzlqj1#Fuhglw/#dffruglqj#wr#wkh#Udqgrp#Krxvh#Glfwlrqdu|/# # # # # # # # # # # lv#ghilqhg#dv#ᄈfrqilghqfh#lq#d#sxufkdvhu# # # # # # # ᄊv#delolw|#dqg#lqwhqwlrq#wr#sd|/ᄡ#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # whup#dffrugv#zhoo#zlwk#wudglwlrqdo#Dphulfdq#rswlplvp#derxw#wkh#ixwxuh1#Li#wkh#ehvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#|hw#wr#frph/#zk|#qrw#eruurz#djdlqvw#lw#dqg#pdnh#wrgd|#ehwwhu#vwlooB# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## rssrvlwh## ylhz## lv## wkdw## eruurzlqj## lv## lpprudo/## d## jlylqj## lq## wr## whpswdwlrq1# Wkrvh## zkr## duh## lqghewhg## kdyh## qr## vhoi0frqwuro## dqg## qr## vhqvh## ri## shuvrqdo# uhvsrqvlelolw|1## Vrph## ri#wkh# # # eodph## jrhv## wr## ilqdqflhuv## +fdvw#dv# # # ordq#vkdunv,/# # # zkr# krog#rxw#hdv|#dffhvv#wr#ohqglqj/#dqg#vrph#jrhv#wr#pdunhwhuv#dqg#dgyhuwlvhuv#zkr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvwloo## lq## wkh## xqvxvshfwlqj## sxeolf## ghvluhv## iru## jrrgv## wkh|## gr## qrw## qhhg1# Qhyhuwkhohvv/## wkh## ryhudoo## frqvhtxhqfh## ri## eurdghqlqj## dffhvv## wr## ilqdqflqj## lv/# dffruglqj## wr## wklv## ylhz/## ryhufrqvxpswlrq## dqg## ryhulqghewhgqhvv/## d## whpsrudu|/# looxvru|#survshulw|#wkdw#ohdgv# # # # # hyhqwxdoo|#wr# # # sryhuw|#dqg# # # uhpruvh1## Sursrqhqwv## ri# wklv## ylhz## suhihu## wkh## whup#ghew/# # # ghqrwlqj## reoljdwlrq1## Wkhuh## lv## d## orqj## wudglwlrq# uhiohfwlqj## wklv## ylhz## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## hslwrpl}hg## e|## Ehqmdplq## Iudqnolq## lq# Srru#Ulfkdugᄊv#Dopdqdf=#ᄈExw/#dk/#wklqn#zkdw#|rx#gr#zkhq#|rx#uxq#lq#ghew>#|rx# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jlyh#wr#dqrwkhu#srzhu#ryhu#|rxu#olehuw|1#Li#|rx#fdqqrw#sd|#dw#wkh#wlph/#|rx#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh#dvkdphg#wr#vhh#|rxu#fuhglwru>#|rx#zloo#eh#lq#ihdu#zkhq#|rx#vshdn#wr#klp/#|rx# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo## pdnh## srru## slwlixo## vqhdnlqj## h{fxvhv/## dqg## e|## ghjuhhv## frph## wr## orvh## |rxu# yhudflw|/## dqg## vlqn## lqwr## edvh## grzquljkw## o|lqj>## iru/## dv## Srru## Ulfkdug## vd|v/## wkh# 6# vhfrqg#ylfh#lv#o|lqj/#wkh#iluvw#lv#uxqqlqj#lq#ghew1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # Fuhglw#dv#d#nh|#wr#rssruwxqlw|#dqg#dv#d#phdqv#wr#wkh#frqvxpswlrq#|rx#ghvhuyh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ru## ghew#dv# # # vlq#dqg# # # dv## d## pruwjdjlqj#ri#d# # # # ixwxuh## |rx#zloo# # # qhyhu## kdyhᄇwkhvh## wzr# rssrvlqj## ylhzv## uxq## wkurxjk## Dphulfdq## klvwru|/## zlwk## wkh## iruphu## jdlqlqj#
dvfhqgdqf|## gxulqj## errp## wlphv## dqg## wlphv## ri## ulvlqj## lqhtxdolw|/## dqg## wkh## odwwhu# jdlqlqj## jurxqg## lq## grzqwxuqv/## zkhq## vreulhw|## ru## udqn## shvvlplvp## uhwxuqv1## Wkh|# uhsuhvhqw#d#zd|#ri#uhskudvlqj#wkh#txhvwlrq#L#vwduwhg#zlwk#hduolhu=#gr#zh#zdqw#wr# # # # # # # ## # # # # # # kduqhvv## ilqdqfhᄊv## fuhdwlyh#hqhujlhv/#ru# # # # gr#zh#wklqn#ilqdqfh#lv# # # # # # vr#gdqjhurxv# # # wkdw# prvw#shrsoh#vkrxog#qrw#kdyh#dffhvv#wr#lw#dqg#lw#vkrxog#eh#vwxiihg#edfn#lq#wkh#er{# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw## fdph## iurpB## Vrflhw|ᄊv## dwwlwxgh## wrzdug## ilqdqfldo## uhirup#klqjhv# # # rq## zkhwkhu## lw# eholhyhv#shrsoh#dqg#ilupv/#e|#dqg#odujh/#fdq#eh#wuxvwhg#wr#pdnh#vhqvleoh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghflvlrqv#zkhq#jlyhq#wkh#phdqv#wr#gr#vr1# # # # # # # # Wkh## dfdghplf## ghedwh## rq#wklv# # # txhvwlrq#lv# # # qrw#frqfoxvlyh1# # # Hyhq#dv# # # uhvhdufk#lq# # ehkdylrudo#hfrqrplfv#whoov#xv#wkdw#vrph#shrsoh#pdnh#frqvlvwhqw#plvwdnhv#lq#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#ghflvlrqv/#lw#dovr#whoov#xv#wkdw#d#orw#ri#ehkdylru#lv#udwlrqdo#dqg#vhqvleoh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lqghhg/## dv## L#dujxh# # # wkurxjkrxw#wklv# # # errn/## lw#lv# # # w|slfdoo|#qrw#wkh# # # # udwlrqdolw|#ri#wkh# # # ghflvlrq#pdnhuv#wkdw#lv#d#sureohp1#Udwkhu/#lw#lv#zkhwkhu#wkh#dssduhqw#sd|riiv#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghflvlrqv## ixoo|#uhiohfw# # # wkh## frvwv## dqg## ehqhilwv## wr## vrflhw|1## Rxu## jrdo## vkrxog## eh## wr# pdnh#ghflvlrq#pdnhuv#lqwhuqdol}h#wkh#ixoo#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#wkhlu#ghflvlrqv/#udwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # wkdq#suhyhqw#wkhp#iurp#pdnlqj#ghflvlrqv#dowrjhwkhu1# # # # # # # Pruh#jhqhudoo|/#hyhq#li#zh#frqfoxgh#wkdw#vrph#shrsoh#wrrn#rq#wrr#pxfk#ghew# # # # # # # # # # # # # # gxulqj## wkh## errp/## vkxwwlqj## rii## wkhlu## dffhvv## wr## vrph## pdunhwv## ru## olplwlqj## wkhlu# ilqdqfldo#fkrlfhv#+w|slfdoo|#wkurxjk#ohjlvodwlrq#uhvwulfwlqj#wkh#surgxfwv/#sulfhv/#ru# # # # # # # # # # lqvwlwxwlrqv#wkh|#kdyh#dffhvv#wr,#lv#sdwhuqdolvwlf/#xqghprfudwlf/#dqg#wkh#vxuhvw#zd|# # # # # # # # # # # # wr## hqvxuh## wkdw## wkh## surwhfwhg## qhyhu## kdyh## wkh## rssruwxqlw|## wr## ohduq## ru## lpsuryh# wkhpvhoyhv1## Ri## frxuvh/## zh## qhhg## wr## hqvxuh## wkh|## duh## jlyhq## hyhu|## rssruwxqlw|## wr# xqghuvwdqg## zk|#fhuwdlq#fkrlfhv# # # # duh## srru## fkrlfhv## dqg## wr## uhfrjql}h## wkh## plvwdnhv# shrsoh#wudglwlrqdoo|#pdnh#vr#wkdw#wkh|#fdq#fkdqjh#wkhlu#ehkdylru1#Zh#vkrxog#dovr# # # # # # # # # # # # # hqvxuh#wkdw#wkh|#duh#surwhfwhg#iurp#udqn#suhgdwruv1#Exw#olplwlqj#fkrlfh#lv#qrw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqvzhu1# Iuhh## vrflhwlhv## gr## uhyhuw#wr# # # pruh## sdwhuqdolvp#dqg# # # pruh## frqvwudlqwv## rq#fkrlfh# # iroorzlqj## d## fulvlv1## Lw## lv## qdwxudo## wr## eodph## wkh## fulvlv## rq## wkh## juhdwhu## iuhhgrp## wr# fkrrvh=#li#rqo|#fkrlfh#kdg#ehhq#pruh#uhvwulfwhg#+dqg/#ri#frxuvh/#zlwk#klqgvljkw/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#fu|vwdo#fohdu#zkdw#wkh#uhvwulfwlrqv#vkrxog#kdyh#ehhq,/#zh#zrxog#qrw#kdyh#pdgh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## edg## fkrlfhv## wkdw## zhuh## pdgh/## ru## vr## jrhv## wkh## wklqnlqj1## Wkh## ryhudoo## wuhqg## lq# flylol}hg#ghprfudwlf#vrflhwlhv/#krzhyhu/#lv#wr#h{sdqg#fkrlfh#iru#doo/#qrw#frqvwudlq# # # # # # # # # # # # lw/## ohw#dorqh# # # frqvwudlq#lw#iru# # # # rqo|#vrph1# # # Iurp#d# # # sudfwlfdo## vwdqgsrlqw/## uhjxodwlrqv# wkdw#olplw#fkrlfh#pd|#eh#srsxodu#lq#wkh#diwhupdwk#ri#d#fulvlv#exw#zloo#lqhylwdeo|#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zklwwohg## dzd|#dv# # # wkh## phprulhv## ri#wkh# # # fulvlv## idgh1## Dqg## hqdfwlqj#uhjxodwlrqv# # # wkdw# zloo## vrrq## eh## rxwprghg## dqg## yrwhg## grzq## fduulhv## dq## lqkhuhqw## frvw=## lw## fuhdwhv## d# prphqwxp#iru#ghuhjxodwlrq#dprqj#wkh#sxeolf#wkdw#frxog#jr#wrr#idu1#Lw#lv#ehwwhu#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jhw#uhjxodwlrq#uljkw#wkdq#wr#huu#lq#hlwkhu#gluhfwlrq1# # # # # # # # # Lq#vxp/#li#zh#uhmhfw#wkh#ylhz# # # # # # # # wkdw#ilqdqfh#lv#d#odujho|#xvhohvv#dfwlylw|/#ru# # # # # # # # # wkdw# zh## fdq## nhhs## lwv## ehqhilwv## rqo|## iru## d## vhohfw## dqg## nqrzohgjhdeoh## ihz/## wkhq## wkh# sxusrvh## ri#uhirup#vkrxog# # # # eh## wr## gudz## rxw#zkdw#lv# # # # ehvw#lq#ilqdqfh# # # # iru## wkh## odujhvw# qxpehu#ri#shrsoh#zkloh#plqlpl}lqj#wkh#ulvn#ri#lqvwdelolw|1# # # # # # # # #
Eurdg#Sulqflsohv#ri#Uhirup # # # # Zkdw#jxlglqj#sulqflsohv#pxvw#uhirupv#dgkhuh#wrB#Ohw#ph#rxwolqh#wkh#nh|#rqhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#wkhq#jr#rq#wr#d#frqfuhwh#h{dpsoh1# # # # # # # #
Vkrxog#Zh#Olplw#Frpshwlwlrq# # # # # D## khdowk|## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## wkdw## ehqhilwv## flwl}hqv## uhtxluhv## frpshwlwlrq## dqg# lqqrydwlrq1## Roljrsro|## lpsolhv## hdv|## surilwv## iru## wkh## lqfxpehqwv/## surilwv## wkh|## duh# ordwk#wr#mhrsdugl}h#e|#wdnlqj#rq#ulvn1#E|#frqwudvw/#wkh#jrdo#ri#eurdghqlqj#dffhvv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#uhdfk#qhz#dqg#xqghuvhuyhg#fxvwrphuv#dv#zhoo#dv#ixwxuh#lqqrydwruv/#uhtxluhv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## wkdw## lv## zloolqj## wr## wdnh## uhdvrqdeoh## ulvnv/## dqg## wkxv## lw## uhtxluhv# frpshwlwlrq1## Wklv## lv## qrw## d## srsxodu## ylhz## dw## d## wlph## ri## fulvlv## lq## d## iuhh0pdunhw# hfrqrp|/## iru## wkh## qdwxudo## whqghqf|## lv## wr## eodph## wkh## pdunhw## dqg## idfwruv## olnh# frpshwlwlrq#wkdw#pdnh#lw#iuhh1# # # # # Rqh## ri#wkh# # # pdlq#frqfhuqv# # # gxulqj#wkh# # # Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrq#zdv# # # # wkdw#sulfhv# # # zhuh# wrr#orz/#dqg#wkh#plvwdnhq#gldjqrvlv# # # # # # # zdv## h{fhvvlyh#frpshwlwlrq1#Wkh#Qhz# # # # # Ghdo# vroxwlrq#zdv# # # wr## surs## xs## sulfhv## e|#iruplqj#fduwhov1# # # # Wr## vprrwk#wkh# # # srolwlfdo## sdwk# iru## wkh## qhhghg## ohjlvodwlrq/## zrugv## olnh## ᄈhfrqrplf## fdqqledolvpᄡ## dqg## ᄈfxw0wkurdw# sulfh## vodvklqjᄡ## zhuh## xvhg## wr## ghvfuleh## frpshwlwlrq17## Iruphuo|## ᄈuxjjhg# lqglylgxdolvwvᄡ## ehfdph## ᄈlqgxvwuldo## sludwhv1ᄡ## Uhjxodwlrqv## phdqw#wr# # # fuhdwh## fduwhov# dqg## vxssuhvv## frpshwlwlrq## ehfdph## ᄈfrghv## ri## idlu## frpshwlwlrq/ᄡ## zkloh## ydulrxv# irupv## ri## riilfldoo|## vdqfwlrqhg## frooxvlrq## zhuh## ghvfulehg## dv## ᄈfrrshudwlyh# ehkdylru1ᄡ#Ri#frxuvh/#lqfxpehqw#ilupv#zhuh#ixoo|#frpsolflw#lq#wkh#uhjxodwlrq#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # fduwhol}dwlrq#ri#wkh#hfrqrp|/#iru#lw#pdgh#wklqjv#hdvlhu#iru#wkhp1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#frqfhuqv#gxulqj#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv#fhqwhuhg#sulpdulo|#rq#wkh#xqghusulflqj#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn1#Rqfh#djdlq/#lw#zrxog#eh#whpswlqj#exw#zurqj#wr#eodph#frpshwlwlrq#ehwzhhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnv1## Wkh## uljkw## dssurdfk## zrxog## eh## wr## uhgxfh## wkh## ydulrxv## glvwruwlrqv## wr## wkh# sulflqj## ri## ulvn## wkdw## vwhp#iurp#dfwxdo# # # # dqg## srwhqwldo## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq/## dv# zhoo## dv## iurp## khug## ehkdylru1## Zh## vkrxog## qrw## zruu|## vr## pxfk## derxw## uxjjhg# lqglylgxdolvp#dv#derxw#xqgliihuhqwldwhg#jurxswklqn/#iru#wkdw#lv#wkh#sulpdu|#vrxufh# # # # # # # # # # # ri#v|vwhplf#sureohpv1# # # D## frpshwlwlyh## v|vwhp## lv## dovr## olnho|## wr## surgxfh## wkh## ilqdqfldo## lqqrydwlrq# qhfhvvdu|## wr## eurdghq## dffhvv## dqg## vsuhdg## ulvn1## Ilqdqfldo## lqqrydwlrq## qrzdgd|v# vhhpv## wr## eh## v|qrq|prxv## zlwk## fuhglw0ghidxow## vzdsv## dqg## froodwhudol}hg## ghew# reoljdwlrqv/## ghulydwlyh## vhfxulwlhv## wkdw#ihz# # # rxwvlgh## Zdoo## Vwuhhw#qrz# # # wklqn#vkrxog# # kdyh## ehhq#lqyhqwhg1# # # Exw#lqqrydwlrq#dovr# # # # jdyh## xv## wkh## prqh|0pdunhw#dffrxqw/# # # wkh# fuhglw#fdug/#lqwhuhvw0udwh#vzdsv/#lqgh{hg#ixqgv/#dqg#h{fkdqjh0wudghg#ixqgv/#doo#ri# # # # # # # # # # # zklfk#kdyh# # # suryhg## yhu|#xvhixo1# # # Vr/## dv## zlwk#pdq|#wklqjv/# # # # ilqdqfldo## lqqrydwlrqv# vsdq#wkh#udqjh#iurp#wkh#jrrg#wr#wkh#srvlwlyho|#gdqjhurxv1#Vrph#kdyh#sursrvhg#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrwdo## edq#rq#riihulqj#d# # # # # ilqdqfldo## surgxfw#xqohvv# # # lw#kdv# # # ehhq#yhwwhg/# # # pxfk#dv# # # wkh# Irrg#dqg#Guxj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq#yhwv#qhz#guxjv1#Wklv#sursrvdo#suredeo|#jrhv#wrr# # # # # # # # # # # # idu/#dv#pdq|#surgxfwv#duh#plqru#wzhdnv#rq#suhylrxv#rqhv/#duh#qrw#olih#wkuhdwhqlqj/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#fdqqrw#uhdoo|#eh#xqghuvwrrg#xqwlo#wulhg#rxw1#Prghvw#dqg#iuhh#h{shulphqwdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # #
vkrxog## eh## doorzhg## exw## surolihudwlrq## olplwhg## xqwlo## uhjxodwruv## duh## vdwlvilhg## wkh|# xqghuvwdqg## wkh## lqqrydwlrq#zhoo/# # # dqg## wkh## v|vwhplf## ulvnv## lw#srvhv# # # kdyh## ehhq#ghdow# # zlwk1# Pruh## jhqhudoo|/## lq## dq## hyhu0fkdqjlqj## joredo## hfrqrp|/## vwdvlv## lv## riwhq## wkh# juhdwhvw#vrxufh# # # ri#lqvwdelolw|/# # # iru## lw#phdqv# # # wkh## v|vwhp#grhv# # # qrw#dgdsw#wr# # # # fkdqjh1# Frpshwlwlrq#dqg# # # lqqrydwlrq/## e|#frqwudvw/# # # khos## wkh## v|vwhp#dgdsw/# # # dqg## li#surshuo|# # fkdqqhohg/#duh#nh|#wr#hqvxulqj#ydulhw|/#uhvlolhqfh/#dqg#wkhuhiruh#g|qdplf#vwdelolw|1# # # # # # # # # # # Fulwlfv#zloo#eh#txlfn#wr#srlqw#rxw#wkdw#frpshwlwlrq#dqg#lqqrydwlrq#ohdg#wr#juhdwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvwdelolw|#gxulqj#wkh#uxq0xs#wr#d#fulvlv=#diwhu#doo/#vhfxulwlhv#olnh#wkh#FGR#vtxduhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#wkh#FGR#fxehg#zhuh#vr#ghylolvko|#gliilfxow#wr#sulfh#wkdw#wkh|#kdg#qr#pdunhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rqfh## pruwjdjhv## vwduwhg## ghidxowlqj1## Krzhyhu/## lw## lv## qrw## frpshwlwlrq## shu## vh/## exw# udwkhu#wkh#glvwruwhg#edqnhu#lqfhqwlyhv#dqg#wkh#glvwruwhg#sulfh#ri#ulvn#wkdw#ohg#wr#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhdwlrq#ri#wkhvh#lqvwuxphqwv1# # # #
Uhgxfh#Lqfhqwlyh#dqg#Sulfh#Glvwruwlrqv= # # # # Pdqdjh#H{shfwdwlrqv#ri#Jryhuqphqw#Lqwhuyhqwlrq # # # # # Dv## L#dujxh# # # lq#fkdswhu# # # :/## vrph## ri#wkh# # # lqfhqwlyhv## wr## wdnh## h{fhvvlyh## ulvnv## pd|# kdyh#uhvxowhg#iurp#d#euhdngrzq#ri#lqwhuqdo# # # # # # # # jryhuqdqfh#zlwklq#edqnv/#dqg#vrph# # # # # iurp#d# # # euhdngrzq#ri#h{whuqdo# # # # jryhuqdqfh1## Wkhvh## phfkdqlvpv## qhhg## wr## eh## il{hg/# dqg## L## glvfxvv## vrph## rswlrqv## ehorz1## Exw## wkh## sulpdu|## uhdvrq## iru## d## v|vwhplf# euhdngrzq#lv#lqyduldeo|#wkh#xqghusulflqj#ri#ulvn1#Rqh#uhdvrq#iru#xqghusulflqj#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # luudwlrqdo#h{xehudqfh=#lqlwldo/#prghudwh#xqghuhvwlpdwhv#ri#ulvn#ihhg#rq#hdfk#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # xqwlo#wkh|#ehfrph#d#iuhq}|1#Xvxdoo|/#wkrxjk/#vxfk#exeeohv#uduho|#rffxu#rxw#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eoxh1## Wkh## xqghusulflqj## ri## ulvn## lq## wkh## shulrg## ohdglqj## xs## wr## wkh## uhfhqw## fulvlv# vwhpphg/## lq## sduw/## iurp## dqwlflsdwhg## jryhuqphqw## ru## fhqwudo## edqn## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq# pdunhwv1## Dqg## fhuwdlqo|/## vlqfh## wkh## fulvlv## klw/## wkh## Wuhdvxu|## dqg## wkh## Ihg## kdyh# lqwhuyhqhg#pdvvlyho|#lq#pdunhwv/#wkxv#yhuli|lqj#wkh#h{shfwdwlrqv1#Zh#qhhg#wr#ilqg# # # # # # # # # # # # d## zd|## wr## glvsho## wkh## qrwlrq## wkdw## wkh## jryhuqphqw## ru## lwv## djhqflhv## zloo## surs## xs## d# pdunhw/#zkhwkhu#wkh#pdunhw#iru#krxvlqj#ru#wkh#pdunhw#iru#oltxlglw|1# # # # # # # # # # #
Hqg#Jryhuqphqw#Vxevlglhv#dqg#Sulylohjhv#wr#Ilqdqfldo#Lqvwlwxwlrqv# # # # # # # # # Dv## gdpdjlqj## dv## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## wr## khos## vshflilf## pdunhwv## lv# jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#wr#surs#xs#vshflilf#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv1#Wkh#hvvhqfh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # iuhh0hqwhusulvh## fdslwdolvp## lv## wkh## iuhhgrp## wr## idlo## dv## zhoo## dv## wr## vxffhhg1## Wkh# pdunhw## whqgv## wr## idyru## lqvwlwxwlrqv## wkdw## duh## surwhfwhg## e|## wkh## jryhuqphqw## iurp# idlolqj/## dvnv## wrr## ihz## txhvwlrqv## ri#wkhp/# # # dqg## jlyhv## wkhp#wrr# # # pdq|#uhvrxufhv# # # iru# wkhlu## rzq## jrrg1## Pruhryhu/## vxfk## surwhfwlrq## glvwruwv## wkh## frpshwlwlyh## odqgvfdsh1# Zh## kdyh## wr## dlp## iru## d## v|vwhp## lq## zklfk## qr## sulydwh## lqvwlwxwlrq## kdv## lpsolflw## ru# h{solflw#surwhfwlrqv# # # iurp#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw/## rqh## lq#zklfk#hyhu|#sulydwh# # # # # lqvwlwxwlrq# wkdw## pdnhv## vhulrxv## plvwdnhv## nqrzv## lw## zloo## kdyh## wr## ehdu## wkh## ixoo## frvwv## ri## wkrvh# plvwdnhv1#
Hqdfw#F|foh0Surri#Uhjxodwlrq # # # Dv## zh## hphujh## iurp## wkh## sdqlf/## uljkwhrxv## srolwlfldqv## ihho## wkh## qhhg## wr## gr# vrphwklqj1## Uhjxodwruv/## zlwk#wkhlu# # # edfnerqhv## vwliihqhg## e|#sxeolf# # # glvdssurydo## ri# sdvw## od{lw|/## zloo## hqirufh## doprvw## dq|## uhvwulfwlrqv/## zkloh## edqnhuv/## zkrvh## iudlo# edodqfh## vkhhwv## dqg## ylylg## phprulhv## pdnh## wkhp#hvfkhz# # # dq|## ulvn/## zloo## eh## pruh# dffhswlqj#ri#vxfk#uhvwulfwlrqv1#Exw#zh#whqg#wr#uhirup#xqghu#wkh#ghoxvlrq#wkdw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwhg#lqvwlwxwlrqv#dqg#wkh#pdunhwv#wkh|#rshudwh#lq#duh#vwdwlf#dqg#sdvvlyh/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh# # # uhjxodwru|#hqylurqphqw#zloo# # # # qrw#ydu|#zlwk#wkh# # # # # f|foh1## Lurqlfdoo|/## idlwk#lq# # gudfrqldq#uhjxodwlrq#lv# # # # vwurqjhvw#dw#wkh# # # # erwwrp#ri#wkh# # # # f|foh/## zkhq#wkhuh# # # lv## olwwoh# qhhg#iru#sduwlflsdqwv#wr#eh#uhjxodwhg1#E|#frqwudvw/#wkh#plvfrqfhswlrq#wkdw#pdunhwv# # # # # # # # # # # # zloo#jryhuq#wkhpvhoyhv#lv#prvw#zlghvsuhdg#dw#wkh#wrs#ri#wkh#f|foh/#dw#wkh#srlqw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pd{lpxp#gdqjhu# # # wr## wkh## v|vwhp1## Zh## qhhg## wr## dfnqrzohgjh## wkhvh## gliihuhqfhv## dqg# hqdfw#f|foh0surri#uhjxodwlrq/#iru#d#uhjxodwlrq#vhw#djdlqvw#wkh#f|foh#zloo#qrw#vwdqg1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wr#kdyh#d#ehwwhu#fkdqfh#ri#fuhdwlqj#vwdelolw|#wkurxjkrxw#wkh#f|fohᄇri#ehlqj#f|foh0 # # # # # # # # # # # # surriᄇqhz#uhjxodwlrqv#vkrxog#eh#frpsuhkhqvlyh/#qrqglvfuhwlrqdu|/#frqwlqjhqw/# # # # # # # dqg#frvw0hiihfwlyh1# # Uhjxodwlrqv#wkdw#dsso|#frpsuhkhqvlyho|#wr#doo#ohyhuhg#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#duh# # # # # # # # # # ohvv## olnho|#wr# # # hqfrxudjh## wkh## guliw## ri## dfwlylwlhv## iurp#khdylo|#uhjxodwhg# # # # wr## oljkwo|# uhjxodwhg#lqvwlwxwlrqv#ryhu#wkh#errp1#Vxfk#d#guliw#kdv#ehhq#d#vrxufh#ri#lqvwdelolw|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh## lwv## gdpdjlqj## frqvhtxhqfhv## frph## edfn## wr## klw## wkh## khdylo|## uhjxodwhg# lqvwlwxwlrqv## lq#wkh# # # exvw/## wkurxjk#fkdqqhov# # # wkdw#qr# # # rqh## iruhvhhv1## Iru## h{dpsoh/## wkh# dvvhw0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#wkdw#Flwljurxs#kdg#sodfhg#lq#wklqo|#fdslwdol}hg#rii0edodqfh# # # # # # # # # # vkhhw## yhklfohv## fdph## edfn## rqwr## lwv## edodqfh## vkhhw## zkhq## wkh## frpphufldo## sdshu# pdunhw## gulhg## xs/## frqwulexwlqj## lpphqvho|## wr## Flwljurxsᄊv## wurxeohv1## Zh## kdyh## wr# uhfrjql}h## wkdw## ehfdxvh## doo## duhdv## ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## duh## lqwlpdwho|# lqwhufrqqhfwhg/#lw#lv#h{wuhpho|#kdug#wr#fuhdwh#devroxwho|#vdih#duhdv#dqg#lpsuxghqw# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#ljqruh#zkdw#kdsshqv#rxwvlgh#vxssrvhgo|#vdih#duhdv1# # # # # # # # Uhjxodwlrqv#wkdw#duh#qrqglvfuhwlrqdu|#dqg#wudqvsduhqwo|#hqirufhg#kdyh#d#juhdwhu# # # # # # # # # # fkdqfh#ri#ehlqj#dgkhuhg#wr/#hyhq#lq#wlphv#ri#juhdw#rswlplvp1#Frpsoldqfh#fdq#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh## hdvlo|#prqlwruhg# # # e|#lqwhuhvwhg# # # phpehuv## ri#wkh# # # phgld## dqg## wkh## sxeolf/## wkxv# riihulqj#vrph# # # fkhfn#rq#wkh# # # # uhjxodwru1## Wkh## uhjxodwhg## dovr## kdyh## d## jrrg## vhqvh## ri# krz## uhjxodwlrqv## zloo## eh## lpsohphqwhg1## Rqh## h{dpsoh## ri## vxfk## uhjxodwlrq## lv## wkh# IGLF#Lpsuryhphqw#Dfw#ri#4<<4/#zklfk#pdqgdwhv#wkdw#uhjxodwruv#wdnh#d#vhulhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhu#pruh#vwulqjhqw#dfwlrqv#djdlqvw#d#edqn#dv#lwv#uhjxodwru|#fdslwdo# # # # # # # # # # # # gursv#ehorz# # vshflilhg#ohyhov1#Wkh#zhdnqhvv#lq#wkh#dfw#lv#wkdw#uhjxodwru|#fdslwdo#lv#kdug#iru#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sxeolf## dqg## wkh## suhvv## wr## phdvxuh## lq#uhdo# # # wlph/## vr## lw#lv# # # gliilfxow#wr# # # jdxjh## zkhwkhu# uhjxodwruv#duh#iroorzlqj#wkurxjk#rq#wkh#uhtxluhphqwv#ri#wkh#odz1#Qhyhuwkhohvv/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # dfw#vxjjhvwv#d#srvvleoh#gluhfwlrq#iru#qhz#uhjxodwlrq1# # # # # # # # Zkhuhyhu## srvvleoh/## uhjxodwlrqv## vkrxog## frph## lqwr## irufh## rqo|## zkhq## vwulfwo|# qhfhvvdu|=#wkh|#vkrxog#eh#wuljjhuhg#e|#dgyhuvh#hyhqwv#udwkhu#wkdq#eh#uhtxluhg#doo# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#wlph1#Vxfk#frqwlqjhqw#uhjxodwlrqv#kdyh#wzr#hiihfwv1#Iluvw/#ehfdxvh#wkh|#nlfn#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # rqo|## vrph## ri## wkh## wlph/## wkh|## duh## ohvv## fxpehuvrph## wkdq## uhjxodwlrq## wkdw## lv## qrw# frqwlqjhqw/#dqg#edqnv#zloo# # # # # qrw#lqyhvw#dv#pxfk#lqjhqxlw|#lq#wu|lqj#wr#hydgh#wkhp1# # # # # # # # # # Vhfrqg/## wkh## ohyho## ri## wkh## uhjxodwru|#uhtxluhphqwᄇvxfk#dv# # # # wkh## uhtxluhg## ohyho## ri# fdslwdoᄇfdq#wkhq#eh#lqfuhdvhg#li#qhfhvvdu|/#vr#wkdw#lw#kdv#wkh#ghvluhg#hiihfw#zkhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
uhdoo|#qhhghg1# # Ilqdoo|/## uhjxodwlrqv## wkdw## duh## qrw## sduwlfxoduo|## frvwo|## iru## wkh## uhjxodwhg## wr# lpsohphqw#ru#iru#wkh#uhjxodwru#wr#hqirufh#duh#ohvv#olnho|#wr#eh#hydghg#ru#ljqruhg1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Pruhryhu/## wkh|## duh## olnho|## wr## kdyh## pruh## vwd|lqj## srzhu## dv## phprulhv## ri## sdvw# sureohpv#idgh1# #
Uhgxflqj#wkh#Vhdufk#iru#Wdlo#Ulvn # # # # # # Ohw#xv#dsso|#doo# # # # # wkhvh#sulqflsohv#wr#d#frqfuhwh#txhvwlrq=# # # # # # # krz## gr#zh#suhyhqw# # # wkh## v|vwhpdwlf## wdlo## ulvn#wdnlqj#wkdw#qhduo|#ghvwur|hg# # # # # # wkh## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpB## L#kdyh# # irfxvhg## rq#wzr# # # uhodwhg## h{dpsohv## ri#wdlo# # # ulvnvᄇwkh## ulvn#ri#ghidxow#hpehgghg# # # # # lq# vhqlru## dvvhw0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## dqg## wkh## oltxlglw|## ulvn## lqkhuhqw## lq## ilqdqflqj# srwhqwldoo|#looltxlg#dvvhwv#zlwk#yhu|#vkruw0whup#ghew1#L#h{dplqh#ghwdlohg#sursrvdov# # # # # # # ## # # iru## uhgxflqj## vxfk## ulvn/## ehfdxvh## phdvxuhv## wkdw## vhhp## uhdvrqdeoh## dw## iluvw## jodqfh# 8# riwhq#udlvh#pruh#frqfhuqv#rq#forvhu#h{dplqdwlrq1 # # # # # # Dv#L#dujxh#lq#fkdswhu#:/#wkhuh#duh#kxjh#lqfhqwlyhv#dw#hyhu|#ohyho#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo# ## # # # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhp#wr# # # wdnh## rq#wkhvh# # # wdlo## ulvnv## li#wkh|#fdq#eh# # # # # frqfhdohg#iurp#wkrvh# # # # dvvhvvlqj# shuirupdqfh1#Wkrvh#jlylqj#xs#wkh#wdlo#ulvn#duh#zloolqj#wr#sd|#d#suhplxp#wr#gr#vr/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkloh#wkrvh#wdnlqj#lw#rq#dqg#grzqsod|lqj#wkh#hyhqwxdo#ulvn#ri#sd|rxw#fdq#wuhdw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # suhplxp#dv#sxuh#surilw/#wkh#surgxfw#ri#wkhlu#qdwxudo#eulooldqfh#udwkhu#wkdq#phuho|#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frpshqvdwlrq#iru# # # ulvn1## Wkh## suhplxp#sdlg# # # e|#wkrvh# # # vhoolqj#wkh# # # ulvn#lqfuhdvhv# # # lq# sursruwlrq#wr#wkh#dqwlflsdwhg#orvv# # # # # # li#wkh#ulvn#dfwxdoo|#klwv# # # # # # +wkh|#sd|#pruh#li#wkh|# # # # # wklqn#hduwktxdnhv#zloo#gr#pruh#gdpdjh,>#dqg#wkh#kljkhu#wkh#suhplxp/#wkh#pruh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ulvn#wkh# # # vhoohuv## duh## zloolqj#wr# # # wdnh## rq#+ehfdxvh# # # wkh|#gr# # # qrw#dqwlflsdwh# # # ehlqj# durxqg## zkhq#wkhlu# # # ilupv## kdyh## wr## pdnh## jrrg## wkh## orvv,1## Wrr## pdq|#ilupv# # # zloo## eh# hdjhu## wr## wdnh## rq## ulvnv## wkdw## kdyh## h{wuhpho|## frvwo|## frqvhtxhqfhv/## dqg## wkh|## zloo# frpshwh#wr#wdnh#wkh#ulvn#dw#wrr#orz#d#sulfh1#Wkh#qhw#uhvxow#lv#wkdw#wrr#pxfk#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#zloo#eh#fuhdwhg1# # # # Pdwwhuv## jurz## zruvh## li/## ehfdxvh## ri## wkh## h{whqw## ri## ulvn## wdnlqj/## hyhu|rqh# dqwlflsdwhv#wkdw#zkhq#wkh#ulvn#dfwxdoo|#pdwhuldol}hv/#wkh#jryhuqphqw#ru#wkh#Ihghudo# # # # # # # # # # # # Uhvhuyh#zloo# # # eh#gudzq#lq#wr#vxssruw#wkh#pdunhwv# # # # # # # # xqghuo|lqj#wkh#wdlo# # # # ulvn/#ru# # # wkh# lqvwlwxwlrqv## wdnlqj## lw## rq1## Lq## wkdw## fdvh/## wkrvh## wdnlqj## rq## wkh## wdlo## ulvn## zloo## ilqg## lw# zruwkzkloh#hyhq#li#lw#lv# # # # # # frpprq#nqrzohgjh#wkdw#wkh|#duh#grlqj#vr/#ehfdxvh#wkh# # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#edfnvwrs#zloo#pdnh#lw#surilwdeoh1#Ihz#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#zloo#zdqw# # # # # # # # # # # wr#eh#ohiw#rxw#ri#wkh#ruj|#ri#ulvn#wdnlqj1#Vr#zkdw#vwduwv#rii#dv#dq#dwwhpsw#wr#wdnh#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # klgghq#ulvn#dqg#irro#wkh#pdunhw#zloo/#li#hqrxjk#ilupv#jhw#lq#rq#wkh#dfw#dqg#lqgxfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dq#dqwlflsdwlrq#ri#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq/#ehfrph#dq#ryhuw#dqg#surilwdeoh#sod|# # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#lv#uhzdughg#e|#wkh#pdunhw1# # # # # # Li#wdlo#ulvn#lv#nqrzlqjo|#wdnhq/#ru#nqrzlqjo|#hqfrxudjhg#e|#vhfxulwlhv#pdunhwv/# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#zd|#wr#ghdo# # # # # zlwk#lw#lv#wr#dowhu# # # # # # lqfhqwlyhv#wkurxjkrxw#wkh#frusrudwh#klhudufk|/# # # # # wkh#ilqdqfldo#ilupᄊv#oldelolw|#vwuxfwxuh/#dqg#lwv#uhjxodwru|#vwuxfwxuh1#Rqh#vhhplqjo|# # # # # # # # # # # reylrxv#zd|#wr#uhgxfh#wkh#shuyhuvh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#wdnh#wdlo#ulvn#ehiruh#ulvn#wdnlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfrphv#v|vwhplf#lv#wr#gr#dzd|#zlwk#doo#sd|#wlhg#wr#shuirupdqfh=#wr#sd|#edqnhuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # olnh#exuhdxfudwv1#Ri#frxuvh/#ilupv#fdq#riihu#rwkhu#uhzdugv#iru#shuirupdqfh/#vxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # dv## vwdwxv## dqg## surprwlrqv/## wkdw## duh## kdughu## wr## holplqdwh1## Dqg## hyhq## li## lw## zhuh# srvvleoh## wr## suhyhqw## hydvlrq## ri## wkh## uxohv/## wkhuh## zrxog## eh## dqrwkhu## reylrxv# grzqvlgh>## edqnhuv## zrxog## kdyh## qr## lqfhqwlyh## wr## zrun## kdug## ru## wdnh## fdofxodwhg# ulvnv1#Lq#wrgd|ᄊv#frpshwlwlyh/#idvw0prylqj#hfrqrp|/#exuhdxfudwlf#edqnhuv#zrxog# # # # # # # # # qrw## eh## dq## lpsuryhphqw## ryhu## wkh## vwdwxv## txr1## Zkdw## zh## qhhg## iurp## edqnhuv## lv# frpshwhqw## ulvn## pdqdjhphqw/## qrw## frpsohwh## ulvn## dyrlgdqfh1## Vr## zh## kdyh## wr## ilqg# zd|v## wr#uhgxfh#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#wdnh#wdlo# # # # # # # # ulvn#hyhq#zkloh#uhzduglqj#edqnhuv# # # # # # iru# shuirupdqfh#vr#wkdw#wkh|#frqwlqxh#wr#riihu#lqqrydwlyh#surgxfwv#wkdw#phhw#fxvwrphu# # # # # # # # # # # #
qhhgv#dqg#ohqg#wr#wkh#ulvn|#exw#srwhqwldoo|#yhu|#vxffhvvixo#vwduw0xs1# # # # # # # # # # # Wklv## phdqv## wkdw## zkhuhyhu## srvvleoh/## wkh## ulvn## wdnhu## vkrxog## vxiihu## wdujhwhg# shqdowlhv#li#wkh#ulvn#pdwhuldol}hv/#vr#wkdw#vrflhw|#grhv#qrw#ihho#wkh#qhhg#wr#devroyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp## ehfdxvh## wkh## lqqrfhqw/## wkh## frqqhfwhg/## ru## wkh## srolwlfdoo|## yrfdo## zloo## vxiihu# dorqjvlgh1## Ri## frxuvh/## h{wuhpho|## kljk## shqdowlhv## zloo## ghwhu## hyhq## ruglqdu|## ulvn# wdnlqj/#vr#wkh#shqdowlhv#zloo#kdyh#wr#eh#dssursuldwho|#fdoleudwhg1#Lw#pd|#dovr#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh## wkdw#qr# # # rqh/## lqfoxglqj#pdunhwv/# # # fdq#dqwlflsdwh# # # vrph## ulvnv1## Wr## ghdo## zlwk#vxfk# # srvvlelolwlhv/## lw## lv## qhfhvvdu|## wr## exlog## vrph## sulydwh0vhfwru## exiihuv## wr## devrue# vkrfnv/#dv#zhoo#dv#pdnh#wkh#v|vwhp#uhvlolhqw#wr#wkhp1#L#zloo#qrz#eh#pruh#vshflilf1# # # # # # # # # # ## # # # #
Dowhulqj#Lqfhqwlyhv#Jhqhudwhg#e|#Frpshqvdwlrq# # # # # # Wkh#prvw#reylrxv#irup#ri#wdlo#ulvn#wdnlqj#lv#frqgxfwhg#e|#lqglylgxdo#wudghuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ru#frpsdq|#xqlwv/#dv#zdv#wkh#fdvh#dw#DLJᄊv#Ilqdqfldo#Surgxfwv#Glylvlrq/#zkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vwdii#ehqhilwhg#iurp#wkh#h{wudruglqdu|#surilwv#dqg#dvvrfldwhg#kxjh#erqxvhv#rq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # zd|#xs#dqg#zhuh#uhwdlqhg#zlwk#kljk#erqxvhv#wr#fohdu#xs#wkh#phvv#wkh|#fuhdwhg#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#zd|#grzq1#Rqh#zd|#wr#pdnh#xqlwv#lqwhuqdol}h#vpdoo0suredelolw|#wdlo#ulvnv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhqlru## pdqdjhphqw## ru## ulvn## pdqdjhuv## pd|## qrw## vhh## ru## xqghuvwdqg## lv## wr## krog## d# vljqlilfdqw#sduw#ri#d# # # # # xqlwᄊv## erqxvhv## lq#dq|#|hdu# # # # lq#hvfurz/# # # vxemhfw#wr# # # fodzedfnv# edvhg#rq#wkh#xqlwᄊv#shuirupdqfh#lq#vxevhtxhqw#|hduvᄇd#vxjjhvwlrq#L#pdgh#ehiruh# # # # # # # # # ## # 9##Vlpso|#sxw/#li#d#wudghu#pdnhv#d#khiw|# edqnhu#erqxvhv#ehfdph#d#srolwlfdo#irrwedoo1 # # # # # # # # # # # # erqxv## wklv## |hdu/## rqo|## d## iudfwlrq## vkrxog## eh## sdlg## rxw## wr## khu## wklv## |hdu/## zlwk## wkh# uhpdlqlqj#dprxqw#khog#edfn#e|#wkh#edqn#wr#eh#sdlg#rxw#ryhu#wlph#rq#frqglwlrq#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # khu#srvlwlrqv#gr#qrw#orvh#doo#wkh#prqh|#hduqhg#wklv#|hdu#lq#vxevhtxhqw#|hduv1#Wklv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo#jlyh#wkh#wudghu#d#orqjhu#krul}rq/#fuhdwlqj#vrph#xqfhuwdlqw|#derxw#zkhwkhu#dq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # wdlo## ulvn## vkh## wdnhv## frxog## dfwxdoo|## klw## ehiruh## khu## erqxv## lv## sdlg/## wkxv## jlylqj## khu# juhdwhu#lqfhqwlyh#wr#dyrlg#lw1# # # # # Ri## frxuvh/## vxfk## d## frpshqvdwlrq## vwuxfwxuh## zloo## eh## hiihfwlyh## rqo|## li## d## wudghu# nqrzlqjo|#wdnhv# # # wdlo## ulvnv/## qrw#li#vkh# # # # lv## xqlqwhqwlrqdoo|#jxlghg# # # lqwr## wdnlqj#wkhp1# # Fuxgh#olplwv#rq#wkh#srvlwlrqv#lqglylgxdo#wudghuv#ru#xqlwv#duh#doorzhg#wr#wdnh/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdqgdwru|#glyhuvlilfdwlrq#uhtxluhphqwv/# # # # pd|#dovr# # # eh## qhfhvvdu|/## qrw#vr# # # pxfk#wr# # suhyhqw#wdlo#ulvn#wdnlqj#exw#wr#plqlpl}h#wkh#orvv#li#lw#grhv#rffxu1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
Lqfhqwlyhv#dw#wkh#Wrs# # # # # Wkh#sursrvdov#deryh#wr#pdqdjh#wdlo#ulvnv#suhvxph#wkdw#wrs#pdqdjhphqw#zdqwv# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#fxue#vxfk#ulvn#wdnlqj1#L#kdyh#glvfxvvhg#d#qxpehu#ri#uhdvrqv#zk|#FHRv#pljkw# # # # # ## # # # # # # # # qrw#zdqw#wr#gr#vr/#vxfk#dv#wkhlu#ghvluh#wr#pdwfk#wkh#surilwv#vkrzq#e|#rwkhu#ulvn0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdnlqj## pdqdjhphqwv## dqg## wkhlu## lqvrxfldqfh## derxw## wkh## grzqvlgh## ehfdxvh## wkh|# eholhyh## wkdw## wkh## jryhuqphqw## zloo## lqwhuyhqh1## Vrph## rog0wlph## edqnhuv## uhplqlvfh# irqgo|#derxw#wkh#wlph#zkhq#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#zhuh#sduwqhuvklsv/#dqg#sduwqhuv#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#hqwluh#zhdowk#dw#vwdnh1#Jlyhq#wkh#vl}h#ri#edqnv#wrgd|#dqg#wkhlu#lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vsudzo/#lw#zrxog#eh#gliilfxow#wr#frqyhuw#wkhp#edfn#lqwr#forvho|#khog#sduwqhuvklsv# # # # # # # # # # # # #
lq## zklfk## pxwxdo## prqlwrulqj## e|## sduwqhuv## lqklelwv## h{fhvvlyh## ulvn## wdnlqj1## Dqg# iruflqj#edqnv#wr#vkulqn#pljkw#qrw#pdnh#wkhp#vdihu1#Zh#kdyh#dovr#vhhq#wkdw#vlpso|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jlylqj## pdqdjhphqw## dq## htxlw|## vwdnh## pd|## qrw## eh## hqrxjkᄇwkh|## uhdol}h## hqruprxv# jdlqv#li#wkh#ulvn#wdnlqj#sd|v#rii#exw#kdyh#olplwhg#oldelolw|#li#lw#grhv#qrw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lqvwhdg#lw#pd|#eh#xvhixo#wr#frqvlghu#zd|v#wr#sodfh#vrph#ri#wkh#exughq#ri#ulvn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq## wrs## pdqdjhphqw/## zlwkrxw## qhfhvvdulo|## kdylqj## hqwluh## fodvvhv## ri## fodlpv## ehlqj# vxemhfw#wr#wkdw#ulvn1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#wkh#Vtxdp#Odnh#Zrunlqj#Jurxs#+d#qrqsduwlvdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # jurxs#frqyhqhg#e|#Surihvvru# # # # # Nhq#Iuhqfk#ri#Gduwprxwk#Froohjh#diwhu# # # # # # # wkh#uhfhqw# # fulvlv## wr#sursrvh#uhirupv,# # # # kdv## vxjjhvwhg#qrw#rqo|#kroglqj#edfn#vrph#sruwlrq#ri# # # # # # # # wrs#pdqdjhphqw#erqxvhv#dqg#uhgxflqj#wkhp#li#wkhuh#duh#ixwxuh#orvvhvᄇpxfk#olnh# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## fodzedfnv## L#glvfxvvhg# # # hduolhuᄇexw#dovr# # # zulwlqj#wkhvh# # # ᄈkrogedfnvᄡ## grzq#li# # wkh## ilup#kdv# # # wr## eh## edlohg## rxw## lq## dq|## zd|1## Wkxv## wkh## krogedfnv## zrxog## vhuyh## dv# mxqlru## htxlw|## dqg## jlyh## vwurqj## lqfhqwlyhv## wr## pdqdjhphqw## wr## wdnh## suhfdxwlrqv## wr# dyrlg#d#edlorxw1# # # Wkh## ilqdqfldo## ilupᄊv## erdug## lv## phdqw## wr## eh## dqrwkhu## fkhfn#rq#plvpdqdjhphqw1# # # Exw## hyhq## zkhq## wdlo## ulvn## wdnlqj## lv## qrw## lq## wkh## vkduhkroghuvᄊ#lqwhuhvwv/# # # wkh## edqnᄊv# erdug#ri#gluhfwruv#pd|#qrw#eh#dq#hiihfwlyh#vrxufh#ri#ghwhuuhqfh1#Erdug#phpehuv# # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#jhqhudoo|#srruo|#lqiruphg#zkhq#wkh|#duh#wuxo|#lqghshqghqw/#dqg#h{fhvvlyho|# # # # # # # # # # # fr}|#zlwk#pdqdjhphqw#zkhq#wkh|#duh#qrw1#Ohkpdqᄊv#erdug/#iru#lqvwdqfh/#frqvlvwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#yhu|#uhvshfwdeoh#lqghshqghqw#gluhfwruv1#Exw#dw#wkh#wlph#lw#ilohg#iru#edqnuxswf|# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#533;/# # # ri#wkh# # # whq0phpehu## erdug/## qlqh## zhuh## uhwluhg/## zlwk#irxu# # # ryhu## wkh## djh## ri# :# :81 # Rqh#zdv#d#wkhdwhu#surgxfhu/#dqrwkhu#d#iruphu#Qdy|#dgpludo1#Rqo|#wzr#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # gluhfw#h{shulhqfh#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhuylfhv#lqgxvwu|1#Dowkrxjk#dgydqfhg#djh#lv#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # glvtxdolilfdwlrq/## lw## w|slfdoo|## vxjjhvwv## vrph## uhpryh## iurp## wkh## fxw0dqg0wkuxvw## ri# prghuq#ilqdqfh1#Vxfk#d#erdug/#zkrvh#ulvn#frpplwwhh#phw#rqo|#wzlfh#d#|hdu/#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rqo|#olplwhg#delolw|#wr#prqlwru#Ohkpdqᄊv#ulvn#wdnlqj1# # # # # # # # Erdugv## fdq#eh#vwuhqjwkhqhg#e|#uhtxlulqj#pruh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # vhuylfhv## h{shuwlvh#ri# # gluhfwruv/#dv# # # zhoo## dv## e|#gudzlqj#wkhp#iurp#rxwvlgh# # # # # # Zdoo## Vwuhhw1#Ixuwkhupruh/#d# # # erdug#fdq#rewdlq#ehwwhu#lqirupdwlrq#li#wkh#ulvn#pdqdjhuv#lq#wkh#ilup#duh#uhtxluhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#uhsruw#gluhfwo|#wr#lw#rq#d#uhjxodu#edvlv1#Wkh#erdugᄊv#ulvn#frpplwwhh#vkrxog#dovr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## uhjxodu## phhwlqjv## wr## glvfxvv## ilupzlgh## ulvn#zlwk#xqlw#khdgv# # # # # dfurvv## wkh## ilup/# zlwkrxw#wrs# # # pdqdjhphqw#suhvhqw/# # # vr## wkdw#wkh|#kdyh# # # # d## vhqvh## ri#zkdw#lv# # # # jrlqj#rq# # iurp## wkrvh## zkr## duh## forvhvw## wr## wkh## dfwlrq1## Ri## frxuvh/## li## frpshwhqw## erdugv## duh# surshoohg#e|#wkh#vdph#ulvn0wdnlqj#lqfhqwlyhv#dv#wrs#pdqdjhphqw/#zh#zloo#kdyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # orrn#hovhzkhuh#iru#zd|v#wr#glvflsolqh#ulvn#wdnlqj1# # # # # # # # Frxog## edqn## vxshuylvruv## sod|## d## uroh## lq## prqlwrulqj## ulvn## wdnlqj## e|## wrs# pdqdjhphqw/## dv## d## vhfrqg## olqh## ri#ghihqvh# # # eh|rqg## wkh## erdug/## vr## wr## vshdnB## Vrph# frpphqwdwruv/## lqfoxglqj/## idprxvo|/## Dodq## Juhhqvsdq/## zhuh## vnhswlfdo## wkdw# vxshuylvruv#zrxog#eh#deoh#wr#gr#vr1#Vxshuylvruv#duh#w|slfdoo|#ohvv#zhoo#sdlg#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sulydwh0vhfwru## h{hfxwlyhv/## wkrxjk#wkh|#kdyh# # # # pruh## mre## vhfxulw|1## H{fhsw#iru# # # wkrvh# uhdoo|#prwlydwhg#e|#sxeolf#vhuylfh/#vxshuylvruv#whqg#wr#eh#hlwkhu#ohvv#wdohqwhg#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{wuhpho|## ulvn## dyhuvh/## qhlwkhu## ri## zklfk## lv## d## sduwlfxoduo|## khosixo## dwwulexwh## lq# prgxodwlqj## sulydwh## vhfwru## ulvn## wdnlqj1## Qhyhuwkhohvv/## vxshuylvruv## kdyh## wzr# vwuhqjwkv#wkdw#fdq#pdnh#wkhp#xvhixo#fkhfnv#rq#sulydwh#ulvn#wdnlqj1#Iluvw/#wkh|#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # gliihuhqw## lqfhqwlyhv=## wkh|## irfxv## pruh## rq## wkh## vpdoo0suredelolw|#ulvnv# # # ri## glvdvwhu# wkdq#grhv#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru1#Vhfrqg/#wkh|#fdq#ghpdqg#gdwd#iurp#ilupv#dfurvv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqgxvwu|#dqg#rewdlq#d#yhu|#jrrg#slfwxuh#ri#zkhuh#ulvn#frqfhqwudwlrqv#duh#exloglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # #
xs1## Ehfdxvh## wkh## wdlo## ulvnv## wkdw## pdwwhu## prvw## duh## wkrvh## wkdw## wkh## zkroh## v|vwhp#lv# # h{srvhg## wr/## zhoo0lqiruphg## vxshuylvruv## fdq## prqlwru## djjuhjdwh## ilqdqfldo0vhfwru# ;## Wkh# h{srvxuhv#dqg#zduq#ilupv#wkdw#duh#wdnlqj#wrr#pxfk#ulvn#wr#fhdvh#dqg#ghvlvw1 # # # # # # # # # # # # # nh|## lv## wr## eh## qhlwkhu## vr## lqwuxvlyh## wkdw## vxshuylvruv## frqvwdqwo|## vxevwlwxwh## wkhlu# mxgjphqw#iru#wkdw#ri#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#qru#wr#eh#vr#odlvvh}0idluh#wkdw#wkh|#ljqruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhplf#ulvn#exlogxs1# # # Iru#vxfk#d#v|vwhp#wr#zrun/#zh#qhhg#ehwwhu#lqirupdwlrq1#Fxuuhqwo|/#idu#wrr#ihz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv## nqrz## rq#d# # # gdlo|#edvlv# # # zkdw#wkhlu# # # ulvn#h{srvxuhv# # # duh=## zkdw# pljkw#kdsshq#li#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # # # pryh#xs#e|#58#edvlv#srlqwv/#li#Lwdoldq#jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # erqgv## duh## grzqjudghg/## ru## li## d## edqn## lq## Rklr## lv## vhl}hg## e|## uhjxodwruv1## Dv## d# frqvhtxhqfh/#wkh#uhjxodwruv#dqg#vxshuylvruv#gr#qrw#nqrz/#hlwkhu1#Wkdw#DLJ#zdv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghhs## wurxeoh## vhhphg## wr## eh## qhzv## wr## wkh## uhjxodwruv## zkr## zhuh## dwwhpswlqj#wr# # # ghdo# zlwk#Ohkpdqᄊv#lpshqglqj#idloxuhᄇlq#sduw#ehfdxvh#DLJ#kdg#irxqg#lwvhoi#d#zhdn# # # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwru## e|#ex|lqj#d#vpdoo# # # # # vdylqjv#dqg#ordq#dqg#hqvxulqj#lwv#edqnlqj#dfwlylwlhv# # # # # # # # <# zhuh## uhjxodwhg## e|#wkh# # # Riilfh## ri#Wkuliw# # # Vxshuylvlrq1 # Lq#wklv# # # gd|#dqg# # # djh/## iru## d# uhjxodwru## wr#eh#xqlqiruphg#lv#xqfrqvflrqdeoh1#Pxfk#ri#wkh#surfhvv#ri#dftxlulqj# # # # # # # # # # # dqg## dqdo|}lqj## lqirupdwlrq## fdq## eh## dxwrpdwhg1## Uhjxodwruv## fdq## uhtxluh## wkdw## wklv# lqirupdwlrq## eh## vkduhg## zlwk## wkhp## rq## d## frqwlqxrxv## edvlv/## riihulqj## vwdqgdug# surfhgxuhv## dqg## prghov## zlwk#zklfk#wr# # # # fdofxodwh## wkh## h{srvxuhv1## Vwdqgdugl}dwlrq# zrxog#eh#hvshfldoo|#xvhixo#lq#wkh#fdvh#ri#looltxlg#vhfxulwlhv/#dvvhwv/#ru#srvlwlrqv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # iru## zklfk#hdfk#lqvwlwxwlrq#fxuuhqwo|#fdofxodwhv# # # # # # ydoxhv## dqg## h{srvxuhv## lq#lwv# # # rzq# zd|/#vr#wkdw#wkhlu#uhsruwv#duh#qrw#frpsdudeoh1# # # # # # # # Ri## frxuvh/## vxshuylvruv## uduho|## ilqg## wkh## uljkw## edodqfh## ehwzhhq## lqwuxvlrq## dqg# odlvvh}0idluh/#dqg#srolwlfdo#suhvvxuhv#whqg#wr#pdnh#wkhp#h{fhvvlyho|#od{#lq#errpv# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#frqvhuydwlyh#lq#grzqwxuqv/#mxvw#wkh#rssrvlwh#ri#zkdw#wkhlu#ehkdylru#rxjkw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # eh1## Li## wkh## jdwkhuhg## lqirupdwlrq## zhuh## pdgh## sxeolf/## krzhyhu/## lw## frxog## riihu## d# phdvxuh#ri#sxeolf#ryhuvljkw#ryhu#vxshuylvlrq1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#rqfh#wkh#lqirupdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # derxw## djjuhjdwh## h{srvxuhv## dqg## lqglylgxdo## ilqdqfldo0ilup## h{srvxuhv## zdv## sxw# wrjhwkhu/#pxfk#ri#lw#frxog#eh#vkduhg#zlwk#wkh#pdunhwv/#diwhu#vrph#ghod|/#lq#d#zd|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## frxog## eh## hdvlo|## gljhvwhg1## Vxshuylvruv## zrxog## eh## irufhg## wr## h{sodlq## wkhlu# dfwlrqv#+ru#lqdfwlrq,#li#h{srvxuhv#zhuh#vhhq#wr#eh#h{fhvvlyh1# # # # # # # # # # Uhjxodwru|## dxwkrulwlhv## duh## riwhq## xqzloolqj## wr## uhyhdo## wrr## pxfk## ghwdlo## derxw# h{srvxuhv#iru#ihdu#wkdw#wklv#pd|#wuljjhu#wkh#yhu|#sdqlf#wkh|#vhhn#wr#dyrlg1#Fohduo|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#zurqj#wlph#wr#vwduw#uhyhdolqj#h{srvxuhv#lv#zkhq#wkh#sxeolf#lv#dq{lrxv#derxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # edqn#khdowk1#Wkh#uljkw#prphqw#wr#vwduw#lv#lq#qrupdo#wlphv/#zkhq#qr#rqh#lv#olnho|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sdqlf1## Diwhu## wkdw/## li## gdwd## rq#h{srvxuhv# # # duh## pdgh## sxeolf## rq#d# # # uhjxodu## edvlv/## wkh# sxeolf#fdq#h{huw#vwhdg|#dqg#khdowk|#suhvvxuh#rq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#ilupv1# # # # # # # # # # # Sxeolf#h{srvxuh#fdq#uhgxfh#wdlo#ulvn#wdnlqj#lq#lwv#hduo|#vwdjhv/#iru#wdlo#ulvn#lv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vljqlilfdqw#ydoxh#wr#pdqdjhphqw#dw#wkdw#vwdjh#rqo|#li#wkh#sxeolf#lv#xqdzduh#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{whqw## ri## wkh## frpsdq|ᄊv## h{srvxuh## wr## ulvn1## Erqg## kroghuv## zloo## w|slfdoo|## qrw## eh# kdss|#wr#ohduq#wkdw#wkh#kxqguhgv#ri#ploolrqv#lq#grooduv#ri#surilwv#pdgh#lq#wkh#sdvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # txduwhu#fdph#iurp#wdnlqj#rq#wuloolrqv#ri#grooduvᄊ#zruwk#ri#h{srvxuh#wr#sduwlfxodu# # # # # # # # # # # # # uduh#hyhqwv1# #
Wkh#Uhsulflqj#ri#Ilqdqfldo#Fodlpv#dqg#Lqfhqwlyhv# # # # # # #
# Sxeolf## h{srvxuh## fdq#zrun#e|#pdnlqj#wkh# # # # # # ilqdqfldo## fodlpdqwv## rq#d# # # ilqdqfldo# ilup#fkhfn# # # h{fhvv## ulvn## wdnlqj1## Ri## frxuvh/## htxlw|## kroghuv/## zkr## jhw## pxfk## ri## wkh# ehqhilw/#pd|#dfwxdoo|#idyru#wdlo#ulvn#wdnlqj#li#wkh#ilqdqfldo#ilupᄊv#htxlw|#fxvklrq#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wklq#uhodwlyh# # # wr## wkh## vl}h## ri#wkh# # # ilup=## wkh|#kdyh# # # olwwoh## wr## orvh1## Vr## d## odujhu## fdslwdo# fxvklrq#lv#qhfhvvdu|#wr#ghwhu#ulvn#wdnlqj1#Ehorz/#L#vxjjhvw#zd|v#wkdw#vxfk#fdslwdo# # # # # # # # ## # # # # fdq## eh## udlvhg1## Dovr/## dv## L## dujxh## deryh/## pdq|## ghew## kroghuvᄇqrw## mxvw## lqvxuhg# ghsrvlwruv#exw#hyhq#kroghuv#ri#orqj0whup#xqvhfxuhg#ghewᄇwkrxjkw#wkh|#zrxog#eh# # # # # # # # # # # edlohg## rxw#e|#wkh# # # # jryhuqphqw/## vr## wkh## lqwhuhvw#udwh# # # wkh|#ghpdqghg# # # glg## qrw#dgmxvw# # xszdug## dv## wkh## ilqdqfldo## ilup## wrrn## pruh## ulvn1## Exw## ghew## kroghuv## frxog## eh## dq# hiihfwlyh## frqvwudlqw## rq#ulvn|#ehkdylru# # # # li## wkh|#eruh# # # wkh## grzqvlgh## ulvn/## iru## wkhlu# ixwxuh## dqwlflsdwhg## orvvhv## zrxog## eh## uhiohfwhg## lq## wkh## kljkhu## lqwhuhvw## udwh## wkh|# ghpdqghg## iurp#wkh# # # ilqdqfldo## ilup1## Li## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## pryh## xs## vxevwdqwldoo|## rq## d# odujh## sruwlrq## ri## wkh## ilqdqfldo## ilupᄊv## ghew## zkhq## lw## wdnhv## pruh## ulvn/## wkhuhe|# uhgxflqj## surilwv/## erwk## pdqdjhphqw## dqg## wkh## erdug## pd|## eh## ghwhuuhg## iurp## ulvn|# ehkdylru1#Dw#wkh#yhu|#ohdvw/#vxfk#dq#lqfuhdvh#lq#udwhv#sdlg#zloo#eh#d#vwurqj#vljqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#wkh#sxeolf#dqg#wr#uhjxodwruv#wkdw#wkh#ilqdqfldo#ilup#lv#wdnlqj#vxevwdqwldoo|#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn1## Wkhuhiruh/## uhjxodwru|## uhirup## vkrxog## irfxv## rq## hqvxulqj## wkdw## dq## lpsruwdqw# vhjphqw#ri#d#ilqdqfldo#ilupᄊv#ghew#kroghuv#nqrz#wkh|#vkrxog#h{shfw#sdlqixo#orvvhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # li#wkh#ilqdqfldo#ilup#wdnhv#wrr#pxfk#ulvn1# # # # # # # # Exw#qhlwkhu# # # htxlw|#kroghuv#qru# # # # ghew#kroghuv#zloo# # # # zruu|#pxfk#rqfh#ulvn#wdnlqj# # # # # ehfrphv#vr#v|vwhplf#wkdw#wkh#pdunhw#frphv#wr#uho|#rq#jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # surs## xs## pdunhwv## zkhq## wkh## ulvn## klwv1## Lq## wkdw## vlwxdwlrq/## pdqdjhphqw## dqg# vwrfnkroghuv## ru## erqgkroghuv## xqlwh## wr## vhh## ulvn## wdnlqj## dv## d## ydoxh0pd{lpl}lqj# dfwlylw|1#Dqg#li#wkh#ilup#lv#ghhphg#wrr#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#wr#eh#doorzhg#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#wr#idlo/#wkh#ilqdqfldo#ilupᄊv#lqyhvwruv#duh#xqolnho|#wr#hyhu#ehdu#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ixoo## frvw#ri#elj#orvvhv1# # # # # Wklv## lv## d## vlwxdwlrq#wdloru0pdgh# # # iru## hqfrxudjlqj#wdlo# # # ulvn# wdnlqj/## ehfdxvh## wkh## ilup## pdnhv## d## orw## ri## surilwv## lq## jrrg## wlphvᄇhyhu|rqh# sxufkdvhv#wdlo#ulvn#lqvxudqfh#iurp#ilupv#olnh#DLJ#wkdw#zloo#eh#sursshg#xs#e|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqwᄇdqg#DLJ#uxqv#wr#wkh#jryhuqphqw#iru#d#edlorxw#li#wkh#frvwo|#wdlo#ulvn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhu#klwv1#Ohw#xv#wdnh#wkhvh#vlwxdwlrqv#lq#wxuq1# # # # # # # # #
Jryhuqphqw#Lqwhuyhqwlrq#lq#Pdunhwv# # # # # Zlwk#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw#vr# # # khdylo|#lqyroyhg# # # lq#pruwjdjh# # # ohqglqj/## erwk#gluhfwo|# # wkurxjk#wkh#IKD#dqg#Jlqqlh#Pdh#dqg#lqgluhfwo|#wkurxjk#Idqqlh#Pdh#dqg#Iuhgglh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Pdf/## wkhuh## zdv## olwwoh## fkdqfh## wkdw## wkh## pdunhw## iru## krxvlqj## ilqdqfh/## hvshfldoo|# vxesulph## krxvlqj## ilqdqfh/## zrxog## eh## ohiw## xqvxssruwhg## hyhq## li## d## elj## vkrfn## klw1# Vlploduo|/## wkh## Ihg## dqg## Wuhdvxu|#kdyh# # # vxssruwhg## yluwxdoo|#doo# # # wkh## elj#edqnv# # # wkdw# fkrvh#wr#wdnh#oltxlglw|#ulvn1# # # # # Fohduo|/#wkh#zd|#wr#uhgxfh#wdlo#ulvn#wdnlqj#xqghu#wkhvh#flufxpvwdqfhv#lv#wr#edfn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rii## iurp## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq/## wr## wkh## h{whqw## srvvleoh1## Wkhuh## lv## qr## lqkhuhqw# uhdvrq#zk|#wkh#jryhuqphqw#vkrxog#kdyh#vxfk#d#odujh#suhvhqfh#lq#wkh#pdunhw#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvlqj## ilqdqfh/## rwkhu## wkdq## wkh## idfw## wkdw## wkh## plggoh## fodvv## kdv## jurzq## xvhg## wr# lpsolflw## krxvlqj#vxevlglhv1# # # Jryhuqphqw## frqvhuydwruvkls## ri#Idqqlh# # # dqg## Iuhgglh#
jlyhv#lw#dq#rssruwxqlw|#wr#fuhdwh#wuxh#sulydwh0vhfwru# # # # # # # # # krxvlqj#ilqdqfh#e|#euhdnlqj# # # # xs#wkhvh#prqrolwkv#dqg#fuhdwlqj#d#kdqgixo#ri#sulydwh#hqwlwlhv/#qrqh#ri#zklfk#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dq#lpsolflw# # # jryhuqphqw## jxdudqwhh1## Dw## wkh## vdph## wlph/## erwk#wkh# # # IKD#dqg# # # Jlqqlh# Pdh#vkrxog#eh#vkuxqn#vwhdglo|1#Dowkrxjk#vrph#wklqn#wkh#ilfnohqhvv#ri#wkh#sulydwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfwruᄇdv## hylghqfhg## e|## wkh## fxuuhqw## gu|lqj## xs## ri## sulydwh## vxesulph## krxvlqj# ilqdqfhᄇlv## d## uhdvrq## iru## wkh## jryhuqphqw## wr## pdlqwdlq## lwv## suhvhqfh/## lw## lv## wkh# xqvxvwdlqdeoh#ohyhov#wr#zklfk#krxvh#sulfhv#kdyh#ehhq#sxvkhg/#lq#sduw#ehfdxvh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#yhu|#jryhuqphqw#suhvhqfh/#wkdw#kdv#fdxvhg#sulydwh#ilqdqfh#wr#gu|#xs1# # # # # # # # # # # # Vlploduo|/#wkhuh#uhdoo|#lv#qr#uhdvrq#rwkhu#wkdq#srolwlfdo#suhvvxuh#iru#wkh#Ihg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wdnh#xv#iurp#exeeoh#wr#exeeoh#e|#fxwwlqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wr#qhdu#}hur#dqg#iorrglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#pdunhw#zlwk#oltxlglw|1#Lurqlfdoo|/#wkh#ohvvrq#iurp#wkh#Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrqᄇwkdw# # # # # # # # # # # ohwwlqj#wkh#edqnv#jr#xqghu#lv#qrw#d#jrrg#lghdᄇkdv#ehhq#vr#zhoo#devruehg#e|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Ihg#wkdw#lw#lv#sod|hg#iru#d#sdwv|#e|#wkh#edqnv1#Rqh#uhirup#L#glvfxvv#lq#fkdswhu#<#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ## # # # # wr#fuhdwh#d#vwurqjhu#vrfldo#vdihw|#qhw1#Wkdw#zrxog#wdnh#vrph#suhvvxuh#rii#wkh#Ihg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#nhhs#lqmhfwlqj#vwlpxoxv#vr#orqj#dv#mrev#duh#qrw#jurzlqj1# # # # # # # # # # # Lq#dgglwlrq/# # # wkh## h{huflvh## ri#prqhwdu|#srolf|#vkrxog# # # # # eh## uhwkrxjkw## wr## wdnh## lqwr# dffrxqw#lwv#hiihfwv#rq#ulvn#wdnlqj#e|#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru1#Ilqdqfldo#vwdelolw|#vkrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfrph## d## pruh## h{solflw## sduw## ri## wkh## Ihgᄊv## pdqgdwh/## jlyhq## dv## pxfk## zhljkw## dv# hpsor|phqw#dqg#orz#lqiodwlrq1#Wkh#Ihg#rxjkw#wr#dvn#lwvhoi#zkhwkhu#lw#lv#srvvleoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#qrplqdo#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#frxog#eh#wrr#orz/#hyhq#zkhq#wkh#hfrqrp|#lv#lq#wurxeoh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## qlqhwhhqwk0fhqwxu|## hglwru## ri## wkh## Hfrqrplvw/## Zdowhu## Edjhkrw/## zdv## irqg## ri# vd|lqj/#ᄈMrkq#Exoo#fdq#vwdqg#pdq|#wklqjv#exw#kh#fdqᄊw#vwdqg#5#shufhqw1ᄡ#Vlploduo|/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Mrkq#Grh# # # fdqqrw#vwdqg# # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # qhdu## }hur/## dqg## zkhq#wkh# # # Ihg## sxvkhv## vkruw# udwhv## yhu|#orz/# # # hvshfldoo|#zkhq#ghiodwlrq#lv# # # # # qrw#d# # # fohdu## dqg## suhvhqw#gdqjhu# # # exw# mxvw## d## srvvlelolw|/## vdyhuv## pryh## wr## kroglqj#ulvnlhu# # # dvvhwv/## sxvklqj#doo# # # pdqqhu## ri# ulvn## suhplxpv## grzq## dqg## sulfhv## xs1## D#urfn0erwwrp#qrplqdo# # # # vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw# # udwh## surpswv## ulvn## wdnlqj## dqg## pdnhv## sulfh## exeeohv## pruh## olnho|>## lw## lv## xqfohdu/# krzhyhu/#wkdw#lw#lv#pxfk#pruh#khosixo#lq#surpswlqj#frusrudwh#fdslwdo#lqyhvwphqw# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#mre#jurzwk#wkdq#d#vrphzkdw#kljkhu#exw#vwloo#orz#qrplqdo#vkruw0whup#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # udwh1# Pruhryhu/#li#wkh#Ihg#rq#rffdvlrq#kdv#wr#fxw#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#vkduso|/#lw#vkrxog#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # suhsduhg## wr## udlvh## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## kljkhu## wkdq## vwulfwo|## zduudqwhg## e|## hfrqrplf# dfwlylw|#rqfh#wkh#hphujhqf|#lv#ryhu1#Vxfk#lqwhuhvw0udwh#srolflhv#zloo#uhzdug#wkrvh# # # # # # # # # # # # zkr## pdlqwdlq## oltxlg## edodqfh## vkhhwv## dqg## suhyhqw## rwkhuv## iurp## ehfrplqj## ryhuo|# looltxlg## lq## wkhlu## dfwlylwlhv143## Lw## zloo## dovr## riivhw## wkh## rqh0vlghg## glvfulplqdwru|# lqwhuyhqwlrq#e|#wkh#Ihg#wkdw#idyruv#ghewruv#dw#wkh#h{shqvh#ri#vdyhuv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Qhlwkhu## vhw## ri## uhfrpphqgdwlrqvᄇglvhqjdjlqj## iurp## krxvlqj## ru## iroorzlqj## d# pruh## hyhqkdqghg## prqhwdu|## srolf|ᄇzloo## eh## hdv|## wr## dgrsw1## Srzhuixo## jurxsv/# lqfoxglqj## uhdo## hvwdwh## ghyhorshuv## dqg## ilqdqflhuv/## kdyh## dq## lqwhuhvw## lq## vhhlqj# frqwlqxhg## jryhuqphqw## lqyroyhphqw## lq## uhdo## hvwdwh1## Vkrxog## zh## zdlw## iru## wkh## qh{w# ghhs#fulvlv#iru#wkh#jryhuqphqw#wr#glvwdqfh#lwvhoiB#Vlploduo|/#prqhwdu|#hfrqrplvwv# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#fhqwudo#edqnhuv#+riwhq#fxw#iurp#wkh#vdph#forwk,#zloo#wklqn#lw#fud}|#wkdw#lqwhuhvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv## vkrxog## eh## uhodwhg## wr## dq|wklqj## rwkhu## wkdq## uhdo## dfwlylw|ᄇd## srlqw## pdgh# dexqgdqwo|## fohdu## e|## Ehq## Ehuqdqnh## lq## klv## vshhfk## wr## wkh## Dphulfdq## Hfrqrplf# Dvvrfldwlrq#lq#Dwodqwd#rq#Mdqxdu|#6/#53431#Dv#zh#kdyh#vhhq#wkrxjk/#wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru#fdq#diihfw#uhdo#dfwlylw|#zlwk#d#yhqjhdqfh1#Zh#kdyh#pdgh#wkh#plvwdnh#ri#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sd|lqj#dwwhqwlrq#wr#ulvn#wdnlqj#ehiruh>#zh#vkrxog#qrw#pdnh#lw#djdlq1# # # # # # # # # # # #
Holplqdwlqj#ᄈWrr#V|vwhplf#wr#Idloᄡ # # # # # Rqh## uhdvrq#zk|#pdunhwv# # # # glg## qrw#shqdol}h# # # ilqdqfldo## ilupv## wkdw#wrrn#rq#odujh# # # # dprxqwv## ri## wdlo## ulvn## zdv## wkdw## wkh|## wkrxjkw## wkh## ilupv## zhuh## wrr## v|vwhplfdoo|# lpsruwdqw#wr#eh#doorzhg#wr#idlo#e|#wkh#jryhuqphqw1#Khuh#djdlq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxevwdqwldwhg## wkhvh## eholhiv## e|## edlolqj## rxw## qhduo|## hyhu|## odujh## ru## lqwhufrqqhfwhg# edqn/#lqfoxglqj/#prvw#frqwuryhuvldoo|/#odujh#edqnv#wkdw#kdg#erxjkw#lqvxudqfh#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # DLJ1#Wkh#jryhuqphqw#vlpso|#fdqqrw#diirug#wr#eh#vhhq#dv#d#vriw#wrxfk#e|#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilupv#ru#wkh#pdunhw1#Khqfh#rqh#ri#wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw#lwhpv#rq#wkh#uhirup#djhqgd# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#qr#sulydwh#ilqdqfldo#ilup#lv#ghhphg#wr#kdyh#wkh#surwhfwlrq#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw1# Hqwlwlhv#wkdw#duh#zlgho|#nqrzq#wr#eh#wrr#v|vwhplf#wr#idlo#qrw#rqo|#kdyh#zdushg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfhqwlyhv/## exw#wkh|#dovr# # # # kdyh## d## frpshwlwlyh## dgydqwdjh## ryhu## hqwlwlhv## wkdw#gr# # # qrw# hqmr|## vxfk## lpsolflw## surwhfwlrq=## wkh|## fdq## wdnh## rq## frvwo|## wdlo## ulvnv## vhfxuh## lq## wkh# nqrzohgjh## wkdw#wkh|#fdq#dssursuldwh# # # # # wkh## uhvxowlqj#uhyhqxhv# # # lq#jrrg#wlphv# # # # zkloh# sdvvlqj#rq#wkh#ulvn#wr#wkh#jryhuqphqw#lq#edg#wlphv1#Htxdoo|#sureohpdwlf/#pdunhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyhvwruv/#dovr#nqrzlqj#wkdw#wkh|#zloo#eh#nhsw#zkroh#e|#wkh#jryhuqphqw/#kdyh#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfhqwlyh## wr## glvfrxudjh## wkhp1## Lqghhg/## ehfdxvh## wkh## vwudwhj|## riihuv## wuhphqgrxv# srwhqwldo## surilwv## dqg## olplwhg## orvvhv## +wr## wkh## htxlw|## kroghuv/## wkdw## lv,/## htxlw|# lqyhvwruv#zloo#dssodxg#lw=#wkh#prvw#ulvn0orylqj#edqnv#kdg#wkh#kljkhvw#vwrfn#sulfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehiruh## wkh## rqvhw## ri## wkh## fulvlv1## Ehfdxvh## erqg## kroghuv## zloo## qrw## ghpdqg## d## kljkhu# suhplxp## iru## ehdulqj## wkh## ulvn## ri## orvvhv/## edqnv## fdq## grxeoh## xs## wkhlu## ehwv## zlwk# ohyhudjh1#Ilqdoo|/#ehfdxvh#wkhvh#edqnv#hqmr|#d#orzhu#frvw#ri#ilqdqflqj/#wkh|#fdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # jurz#hyhq#odujhu#dqg#pruh#frpsoh{>#dqg#wkh|#kdyh#dq#lqfhqwlyh#wr#gr#vr#wr#pdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhpvhoyhv#hyhq#pruh#v|vwhplf1# # # # Zkhq## d## grzqwxuq## klwv/## wkh## sureohpv## dvvrfldwhg## zlwk## hqwlwlhv## ghhphg## wrr# v|vwhplf#wr#idlo#pxowlso|1#Uhvrxufhv#duh#wudsshg#lq#frusrudwh#vwuxfwxuhv#wkdw#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # uhshdwhgo|#suryhg#wkhlu#lqfrpshwhqfh/#dqg#ixuwkhu#uhvrxufhv#duh#vxfnhg#iurp#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # wd{sd|hu## dv## wkhvh#lqvwlwxwlrqv# # # ghvwur|#ydoxh1#Frqilghqw#lq#wkh#nqrzohgjh#wkdw#wkh# # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw## zloo## frph## wr## wkhlu## uhvfxh/## wkhvh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## fdq## sod|## d## jdph## ri# fklfnhq## zlwk## wkh## dxwkrulwlhv## e|## uhixvlqj## wr## wdnh## dghtxdwh## suhfdxwlrqv## djdlqvw# idloxuh/#vxfk#dv#udlvlqj#htxlw|1# # # # # Shukdsv#mxvw#dv#lpsruwdqw#duh#wkh#srolwlfdo#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#vxfk#uhvfxhv1#Lw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # kdug#iru#wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#wr#uhixwh#doohjdwlrqv#ri#furq|#fdslwdolvp1#Dvlgh#iurp#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vwdwhg#lqwhqw#ri#vdylqj#wkh#hfrqrp|/#wkhuh#lv#qr#glvfhuqleoh#gliihuhqfh#ehwzhhq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # edlorxw#prwlydwhg#e|#wkh#vhqvh#wkdw#lqvwlwxwlrqv#duh#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#dqg#rqh# # # # # # # # # # # # prwlydwhg#e|#wkh#ghvluh#ri#wkrvh#lq#dxwkrulw|#wr#uhvfxh#wkhlu#iulhqgv#ru#wkhlu#rqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## ixwxuh## hpsor|huv1## Hyhq## dv## frqvsludf|## wkhrulvwv## kdyh## d## ilhog## gd|/## sdlqwlqj# hyhu|rqh#uhprwho|#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#wkh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#lqwr#d#zhe#ri#fruuxswlrq/# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#gdpdjh#wr#wkh#sxeolfᄊv#idlwk#lq#wkh#v|vwhp#ri#sulydwh#hqwhusulvh#lv#hqruprxv=#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhqvhv## wzr## vhwv## ri#uxohv/# # # rqh## iru## wkh## v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#dqg# # # # dqrwkhu## iru## wkh# uhvw#ri#xv1#Dqg#wkh#frqvsludf|#wkhrulvwv#gr#kdyh#d#srlqw=# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ohhzd|#diirughg#wr# # # # wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#lq#fkrrvlqj#zkr#lv#wrr#v|vwhplf#wr#idlo# # # # # # # # # # # doorzv#wuhphqgrxv#vfrsh# # # iru#glvfuhwlrq/#dqg#khqfh#fruuxswlrq1# # # # # L#kdyh#dyrlghg#uhihuulqj#wr#lqvwlwxwlrqv#dv#wrr#elj#wr#idlo1#Wklv#lv#ehfdxvh#wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
duh#hqwlwlhv#wkdw#duh#yhu|#odujh#exw#kdyh#wudqvsduhqw/#vlpsoh#vwuxfwxuhv#wkdw#doorz# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp#wr#eh#forvhg#grzq#hdvlo|ᄇiru#h{dpsoh/#d#ilup#uxqqlqj#d#idplo|#ri#uhjxodwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pxwxdo## ixqgv1## E|#frqwudvw/# # # vrph## uhodwlyho|#vpdoo# # # hqwlwlhvᄇh{dpsohv## lqfoxgh## wkh# prqrolqh## erqg## lqvxuhuv## zkr## jxdudqwhhg## pxqlflsdo## erqgv/## dqg## Ehdu## Vwhduqvᄇ# fdxvhg#vxevwdqwldo#vwuhvv#wr#exlog#xs#wkurxjk#wkh#v|vwhp1#D#qxpehu#ri#idfwruv#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq## vl}h## pd|## fdxvh## dq## lqvwlwxwlrq## wr## eh## v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw/## lqfoxglqj## lwv# fhqwudolw|#wr#d#pdunhw/#wkh#h{whqw#wr#zklfk#rwkhu#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#lqvwlwxwlrqv# # # # # # # # # # # # duh#h{srvhg#wr#lw/#wkh#h{whqw#wr#zklfk#lqiolfwlqj#orvvhv#rq#wkh#oldelolw|#kroghuv#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr## lqiolfw## glvsursruwlrqdwh## orvvhv## rq## wkh## dvvhwv/## dqg## wkh## frpsoh{lw|## ri## wkh# lqvwlwxwlrqᄊv## lqwhudfwlrqv## zlwk## wkh## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp/## zklfk## pd|## uhqghu## wkh# dxwkrulwlhv#xqfhuwdlq#derxw#wkh#v|vwhplf#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#lwv#idloxuh#dqg#uhoxfwdqw# # # # # # # # # # # wr#wdnh#wkh#ulvn#ri#ilqglqj#rxw1# # # # # # # Wkhuh#duh#wkuhh#pdlq#zd|v#ri#ghdolqj#zlwk#wkhvh#sureohpv1#Iluvw/#wu|#wr#suhyhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvwlwxwlrqv#iurp#ehfrplqj#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw1#Li#wkh|#gr#ehfrph#lpsruwdqw/# # # # # # # # # # irufh#wkhp#wr#kdyh#dgglwlrqdo#sulydwh0vhfwru#exiihuv#wr#plqlpl}h#wkh#qhhg#iru#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq1## Li/## ghvslwh## wkhvh## exiihuv/## wkh|## gr## ehfrph## wuxo|# glvwuhvvhg/#pdnh#lw#hdvlhu#iru#wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#wr#doorz#wkhp#wr#idlo1#L#glvfxvv#hdfk# # # # # # # # # # # # ## # ri#wkhvh#phdvxuhv#lq#wxuq1# # # # #
Nhhslqj#Lqvwlwxwlrqv#iurp#Ehfrplqj#V|vwhplfdoo|#Lpsruwdqw# # # # # # # D## qxpehu## ri## vxjjhvwlrqv## duh## flufxodwlqj## rq## krz## wr## nhhs## lqvwlwxwlrqv## iurp# ehfrplqj## v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw1## Wkh## prvw## frpprq## lv## wr## vwrs## wkhp## iurp# h{sdqglqj#eh|rqg#d#fhuwdlq#vl}h/#dq#lghd#prvw#forvho|#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#wkh#iruphu# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ihg## fkdlupdq/## Sdxo## Yrofnhu1## Zkloh## sulpd## idflh## dwwudfwlyh/## wklv## sursrvdo## kdv# zhdnqhvvhv1# Dowkrxjk## odujh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## duh## pruh## olnho|## wr## eh## v|vwhplf/## vl}h## lv## qhlwkhu## d# qhfhvvdu|#qru# # # d## vxiilflhqw#frqglwlrq1# # # Ehdu## Vwhduqv## zdv## qrw#frqvlghuhg# # # odujh## e|# prvw#fdofxodwlrqv/#wkrxjk#lw#zdv#frqvlghuhg#frqqhfwhg#hqrxjk#wr#qhhg#vdylqj1#Rq# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## rwkhu## kdqg/## wkh## pxwxdo0ixqg## jurxs## Ydqjxdug## pdqdjhv## pruh## wkdq## d## wuloolrq# grooduv#lq#dvvhwv#exw#zrxog#suredeo|#qrw#txdoli|#dv#v|vwhplf1#Qrw#doo# # # # # # # # # # # # # dvshfwv#ri# # vl}h#duh#htxdoo|#wurxeolqj1# # # # Pruhryhu/## hyhq## li## zh## frxog## eh## vshflilf## derxw## wkh## dvshfwv## ri## vl}h## wkdw## duh# wurxeolqj/## edqnv## zrxog## wu|#wr# # # hydgh## dq|#uhvwulfwlrqv# # # rq#vl}h# # # e|#hfrqrpl}lqj#rq# # # zkdwhyhu#phdvxuh#vhuyhg#dv#d#fulwhulrq/#zkhwkhu#dvvhwv/#fdslwdo/#ru#surilwv1#Fuxgh# # # # # # # # # # # # vl}h#olplwv#zrxog#olnho|#ohdg#edqnv#wr#frqfhdo#d#orw#ri#ilqdqfldo#dfwlylw|#iurp#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhjxodwru/#rqo|#wr#kdyh#lw#frph#edfn#wr#oljkw#+dqg#wr#edodqfh#vkhhwv,#dw#wkh#zruvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wlphv1#Wkhuh#duh#pdq|#ohjdo#zd|v#wr#pdvn#dvvhw#vl}h1#Lqvwhdg#ri#kroglqj#dvvhwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wkhlu#edodqfh#vkhhw/#edqnv#fdq#riihu#jxdudqwhhv#wr#dvvhwv#sodfhg#lq#rii0edodqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # vkhhw## yhklfohv/## pxfk## olnh## wkh## frqgxlwv## ri## wkh## uhfhqw## fulvlv1## Li/## lqvwhdg/## fdslwdo# zhuh#wkh#phdvxuh/#wkhq#zh#zrxog#eh#sxvklqj#edqnv#wr#hfrqrpl}h#rq#lw#dv#pxfk#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # srvvleoh>#wklv#lv#kdugo|#d#uhflsh#iru# # # # # # # # vdihw|1#Dqg#li#lw#zhuh#surilwv/#zh#zrxog#eh# # # # # # # # # lqylwlqj#khdowk|#edqnv#wr#sdun#surilwv#hovhzkhuh#zkloh#uhzduglqj#vlfno|#rqhv#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # doorzlqj#wkhp#wr#h{sdqg#lqghilqlwho|1# # # # #
Dovr/## ehlqj#elj#kdv# # # # vrph## yluwxhv1## Odujhu## edqnv## pd|#eh# # # ehwwhu## dw#glyhuvli|lqj# # dqg## dwwudfwlqj## pdqdjhuldo## wdohqw## +lqfoxglqj## ulvn## pdqdjhuv,1## Dowkrxjk## d## srruo|# pdqdjhg#'5#wuloolrq#edqn#fuhdwhv#lpphqvh#sureohpv#iru#wkh#v|vwhp/#wkh#sureohpv# # # # # # # # # # # # frxog## eh## hyhq## juhdwhu## zlwk## rqh## kxqguhg## edqnv## ri## '53## eloolrq## lq## vl}h/## hdfk## ri# zklfk## kdv## wdnhq## vlplodu## ulvnv1## Zkdw## lv## lpsruwdqw## lv## qrw## vl}h## shu## vh## exw## wkh# frqfhqwudwlrq## dqg## fruuhodwlrq## ri## ulvn## lq## wkh## v|vwhp/## dv## zhoo## dv## wkh## h{whqw## ri# h{srvxuh#uhodwlyh#wr#fdslwdo1#Lqghhg/#lq#wkh#sdvw#uhjxodwruv#kdyh#lqwhuyhqhg#wr#edlo# # # # # # # # # # # # # rxw## d## v|vwhp## ehfdxvh## hqwlwlhv## zhuh## wrr## qxphurxv## wr## idloᄇwkh## iruehdudqfh# glvsod|hg## wr## wkh## X1V1## vdylqjv## dqg## ordq## lqgxvwu|## lq## wkh## hduo|## 4<;3v## ehlqj## rqh# h{dpsoh1# Lqvwhdg## ri#lpsrvlqj#d# # # # eodqnhw#vl}h# # # olplw#rq#lqvwlwxwlrqv/# # # # uhjxodwruv## vkrxog## xvh# pruh## vxewoh## phfkdqlvpv/## vxfk## dv## surklelwlqj## phujhuv## ri## odujh## edqnv## ru# hqfrxudjlqj#wkh#euhdnxs#ri#odujh#edqnv#wkdw#vhhp#wr#kdyh#d#surshqvlw|#iru#jhwwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwr## wurxeoh1## Hqwlwlhv## vxfk#dv# # # wkh## Ihghudo## Wudgh## Frpplvvlrq#douhdg|#kdyh# # # # vxfk# dxwkrulw|1#Dowkrxjk#wkhuh#duh#dozd|v#frqfhuqv#derxw#zkhwkhu#uhjxodwruv#zloo#xvh# # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh## vruwv## ri## srzhuv## duelwudulo|/## wkh|#duh# # # qr## pruh## gliilfxow## iru## ohjlvodwruv## dqg# frxuwv#wr#ryhuvhh#wkdq#duh#srzhuv#edvhg#rq#dqwlfrpshwlwlyh#frqvlghudwlrqv1# # # # # # # # # # Wxuqlqj#wr#sursrvdov#wr#olplw#dfwlylwlhv#e|#lqvxuhg#edqnv#wkurxjk#vrph#prghuq# # # # # # # # # # # # yhuvlrq#ri# # # wkh## Jodvv0Vwhdjdoo## Dfw## ri## 4<66/## wkhvh## djdlq#vhhp#ohvv# # # # dwwudfwlyh## rq# ixuwkhu#uhiohfwlrq1#Reylrxvo|/#vrph#dfwlylwlhv#ri#d#odujh#edqn#dgg#frqvlghudeo|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#dqg#rsdflw|1#Wr#wkh#h{whqw#srvvleoh/#wkhvh#vkrxog#eh#fohduo|#vhsdudwhg#lq#ohjdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hqwlwlhv#wkdw#duh#qrw#diihfwhg#e|#wkh#edqnᄊv#idloxuh1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#edqnv#vkrxog#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dwwhpsw#wr#xvh#folhqw#dvvhwv#wkdw#duh#sohgjhg#wr#wkhp#lq#wkhlu#sulph#eurnhudjh#xqlwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # +xqlwv#wkdw#ohqg#vhfxulwlhv/#riihu#ordqv/#dqg#xqghuwdnh#dvvhw0pdqdjhphqw#ixqfwlrqv# # # # # # # # # # iru## folhqwv/## w|slfdoo|#khgjh# # # ixqgv,## lq#ixuwkhu# # # wudqvdfwlrqv144## Wkh## frpplqjolqj#ri# # folhqw## dvvhwv## zlwk## wkh## edqnᄊv## rzq## ixqglqj## dfwlylwlhv## uhgxfhv## wudqvsduhqf|/# lqfuhdvhv## ulvn/## dqg## zdv## dq## lpsruwdqw## uhdvrq## zk|## pdq|## lqyhvwphqw## edqnv# h{shulhqfhg## uxqv## lq#wkh# # # fxuuhqw## fulvlv/## dv## folhqwv## wulhg## wr## zlwkgudz## wkhlu## dvvhwv# ehiruh#wkh|#jrw#hqwdqjohg#lq#wkh#edqnᄊv#edqnuxswf|1#Ri#frxuvh/#vxfk#d#vhsdudwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # zrxog#lqfuhdvh#d#edqnᄊv#frvw#ri#eruurzlqj/#exw#wkh#ehqhilwv#khuh#pljkw#rxwzhljk# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#frvwv1# # Sursulhwdu|#wudglqjᄇlq#zklfk#wkh#edqn#xvhv#lwv#edodqfh#vkhhw/#sduwo|#ixqghg#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw0lqvxuhg## ghsrvlwv/## wr## wdnh## vshfxodwlyh## srvlwlrqvᄇlv## dqrwkhu## dfwlylw|# wkdw#kdv# # # frph## lq#iru# # # fhqvxuh1## Wkh## uhdvrq#fulwlfv# # # zdqw#wr# # # edq#lw#lv/# # # # lq#p|#ylhz/# # # zurqj/## exw## wkhuh## lv## dqrwkhu## uhdvrq## wr## frqvlghu## olplwlqj## lw1## Fulwlfv## dujxh## wkdw# sursulhwdu|## wudglqj## lv## ulvn|1## Lw## lv## kdug## wr## vhh## wklv## dv## dq## lpsruwdqw## fdxvh## ri## wkh# fulvlv=## edqnv## glg## qrw## jhw## lqwr## wurxeoh## ehfdxvh## ri## odujh## orvvhv## pdgh## rq## wudglqj# srvlwlrqv1#Wkh|#idlohg#ehfdxvh#wkh|#khog#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#wr#pdwxulw|/# # # # # # # # # # qrw#ehfdxvh#wkh|#wudghg#wkhp1#Uhjlrqdo#edqnv#kdyh#idlohg#e|#wkh#gr}hq#ehfdxvh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ordqv## wkh|#pdgh#iru# # # # frpphufldo## uhdo## hvwdwh/#dq#dfwlylw|#wkdw#qr#rqh#lv# # # # # # # # wdonlqj#ri# # surklelwlqj1## Lw#lv# # # d## idoodf|#wr# # # wklqn#wkdw#mxvw#ehfdxvh# # # # # fhuwdlq#dfwlylwlhv# # # duh## sulpd# idflh## ulvnlhu## wkdq## rwkhuv/## nhhslqj## edqnv## iurp#wkrvh# # # dfwlylwlhv## zloo## pdnh## edqnv# vdihu#ryhudoo1#Lq#wuxwk/#li#edqnv#zdqw#wr#wdnh#ulvn/#wkh|#fdq#vlpso|#jr#ixuwkhu#grzq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## vshfwuxp#ri#ulvn#lq#dq|#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # dfwlylwlhv## shuplwwhg## wr## wkhp1## Iru## h{dpsoh/## vr# orqj#dv#wkh|#fdq#ohqg/#wkh|#fdq#iuhho|#pdnh#xqvhfxuhg/#orqj0whup/#ᄈfryhqdqw0olwhᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # # ordqv## wr## khdylo|## lqghewhg## ilupv1## Wkh## irfxv## vkrxog## eh## rq## olplwlqj## wkhlu## ryhudoo# lqfhqwlyh#wr#wdnh#ulvnv#dqg#wkhlu#surshqvlw|#wr#mrlq#zlwk#rwkhu#edqnv#wr#wdnh#ulvnv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
dv## d## khug/## udwkhu## wkdq## wr## edq## d## vshflilf## dfwlylw|/## xqohvv## wkh## dfwlylw|## kdv## qr# uhghhplqj#ilqdqfldo#sxusrvh1# # # Qhyhuwkhohvv/#wkhuh#lv#dqrwkhu#uhdvrq#iru#frqvlghulqj#zd|v#wr#olplw#sursulhwdu|# # # # # # # # # # # wudglqj1#Edqnv#wkdw#duh#lqyroyhg#lq#pdq|#exvlqhvvhv#rewdlq#dq#hqruprxv#dprxqw# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#sulydwh#lqirupdwlrq#iurp#wkhp1#Wklv#lqirupdwlrq#vkrxog#eh#xvhg#wr#khos#folhqwv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # 45# qrw## wr## wudgh## djdlqvw## wkhp1 # Edqnv## hiihfwlyho|## kdyh## dq## xqidlu## lqirupdwlrqdo# dgydqwdjh#ryhu#wkh#uhvw#ri#xv#lq#wudglqj=#wkh|#fdq#xvh#lqvlgh#lqirupdwlrq/#ghvslwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#suhvhqfh#ri#iluhzdoov#zlwklq#d#edqn#wkdw#duh#phdqw#wr#suhyhqw#vhqvlwlyh#folhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ru#pdunhw#lqirupdwlrq#iurp#ehlqj#vkduhg#zlwk#wudghuv1#Wklv#dgydqwdjh#vkrxog#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # uhgxfhg## e|#olplwlqj#sursulhwdu|#wudglqj1# # # # # L#vd|#olplwlqj# # # # ehfdxvh## vrph## ohjlwlpdwh# dfwlylwlhv/## lqfoxglqj## khgjlqj## dqg## pdunhw## pdnlqj/## frxog## eh## kdug## wr## glvwlqjxlvk# iurp#sursulhwdu|#wudglqj1# # # # D#fuxgh# # # ryhudoo## olplw#rq#d# # # # edqnᄊv## wudglqj#iru# # # lwv## rzq# dffrxqw/## qr## pdwwhu## zkdw## wkh## sxusrvh/## lv## rqh## srvvlelolw|/## exw## lw## vxiihuv## iurp#wkh# # vdph#sureohpv#dv#dq|#fuxgh#olplw#kdv1#Shukdsv#dq#lqlwldo#fuxgh#olplw/#uhilqhg#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wlph#zlwk#h{shulhqfh/#dv#zdv#wkh#fdvh#zlwk#fdslwdo#uhtxluhphqwv/#pd|#eh#wkh#zd|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#jr1# # Wkh#ehvw#zd|#wr#nhhs#lqvwlwxwlrqv#iurp#ehfrplqj#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#pljkw# # # # # # # # # # # qrw#eh#wkurxjk#fuxgh#surklelwlrqv#rq#vl}h#ru#dfwlylw|#exw#wkurxjk#wkh#froohfwlqj#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # prqlwrulqj#e|#uhjxodwruv# # # # ri#lqirupdwlrq#derxw#lqwhulqvwlwxwlrq#h{srvxuhv# # # # # # dv## zhoo# dv## ulvn## frqfhqwudwlrqv## lq## wkh## v|vwhp1## Wkh## uhjxodwru## frxog## hqvxuh/## wkurxjk# frppdqg#dqg#frqwuro/#wkdw#wkh#v|vwhp#lv#qrw#ryhuh{srvhg#wr#dq|#vlqjoh#vrxufh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvn/#lqvwlwxwlrq/#ru#fodvv#ri#lqvwlwxwlrqv1#Uhjxodwruv#wkhpvhoyhv#zrxog#qhhg#wr#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # prqlwruhg>## khqfh/## dv## L## vxjjhvwhg## hduolhu/## lqirupdwlrq## rq## h{srvxuhv## vkrxog## eh# uhohdvhg#shulrglfdoo|#dqg#sxeolfo|/#diwhu#wkh#sdvvdjh#ri#dq#dssursuldwh#dprxqw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wlph1## Vxfk#phdvxuhv# # # zrxog## eh## ohvv## gudpdwlf## dqg## sxqlwlyh## wkdq#vl}h# # # ru## dfwlylw|# olplwv#exw#pruh#hdvlo|#hqirufhg#dqg#suredeo|#pruh#hiihfwlyh1# # # # # # # # #
Exloglqj#Ehwwhu#Exiihuv# # # # Ghvslwh#wkh#ehvw#hiiruwv#ri#wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#lq#glvfrxudjlqj#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv# # # # # # # # # # # iurp#ehfrplqj#v|vwhplf/# # # # vrph## lqvwlwxwlrqv## zloo## ehfrph## vr1## Shukdsv## vrph## zloo# kdyh#vshfldo#fdsdelolwlhv#wkdw#hqdeoh#wkhp#wr#grplqdwh#fhuwdlq#surgxfw#pdunhwv#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # fxvwrphu#folhqwhohv>#rwkhuv#pd|#mxvw#eh#kljko|#hiilflhqw#dqg#wkxv#elj1#Zkdwhyhu#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhdvrq/## rqfh## d## v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw# # # lqvwlwxwlrq#ehfrphv# # # vhhq#dv# # # vxfk/## lw## zloo# dxwrpdwlfdoo|#hqmr|#vrph# # # # dgydqwdjhv## lq#ixqglqj#dqg# # # # lq#vhoolqj#lwv# # # # surgxfwv1## Wr# riivhw## wkhvh## dgydqwdjhv/## uhjxodwruv## fdq## uhtxluh## wkhvh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## wr## krog## pruh# fdslwdo1## Htxlw|#fdslwdo# # # lv## frvwo|146## Wkh## lpsolflw## wd{## rq## wkh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## +ehfdxvh# htxlw|#fdslwdo#lv#d#pruh#h{shqvlyh#irup#ri#ilqdqflqj#iru#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghew,#zrxog#vhuyh#wr#riivhw#wkhlu#ilqdqflqj#dgydqwdjh/#dqg/#e|#fuhdwlqj#dgglwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # exiihuv/#pdnh#lw#ohvv#olnho|#wkdw#wkh|#zloo#ehfrph#d#gudlq#rq#wkh#wd{sd|hu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Suhflvho|#ehfdxvh#htxlw|#fdslwdo#lv#frvwo|/#uhjxodwruv#qhhg#wr#wklqn#ri#zd|v#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # dfklhyh## wkh## qhfhvvdu|## vl}h## ri## fdslwdo## exiihuv## zlwkrxw## lpsrvlqj## kxjh## frvwv## wkdw# edqnv## zloo## wu|## wr## hydgh1## Uhjxodwruv## frxog## sxw## ohvv## hpskdvlv## rq## dgglwlrqdo# shupdqhqw0htxlw|#fdslwdo# # # dqg#pruh#rq#frqwlqjhqw#fdslwdo/#zklfk#lv#lqixvhg#zkhq# # # # # # # # # wkh## lqvwlwxwlrq#ru# # # wkh## v|vwhp#lv# # # lq#wurxeoh1# # # Lq#rqh# # # yhuvlrq#ri# # # frqwlqjhqw## fdslwdo/#
v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#edqnv# # # # frxog## lvvxh## ghew#wkdw#zrxog# # # # dxwrpdwlfdoo|#frqyhuw# # 47## Lq#dqrwkhu/# wr#htxlw|#zkhq#wkh#edqnᄊv#fdslwdo#udwlr#idoov#ehorz# # # # # # # # # # d#fhuwdlq#ydoxh1 # # # v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw## ohyhuhg## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv## zrxog## eh## uhtxluhg## wr## ex|# ixoo|#froodwhudol}hg#lqvxudqfh#srolflhv#+iurp#xqohyhuhg#lqvwlwxwlrqv/#iruhljqhuv/#ru# # # # # # # # # wkh#jryhuqphqw,#wkdw#zrxog#lqixvh#fdslwdo#lqwr#wkhvh#lqvwlwxwlrqv#zkhq#wkh|#duh#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # 48# wurxeoh1 Erwk## frqyhuwleoh## frqwlqjhqw## ghew## dqg## fdslwdo## lqvxudqfh## duh## h{srvhg## wr# vljqlilfdqw## grzqvlgh## ulvn## dqg/## li## surshuo|## sulfhg## e|## wkh## pdunhw/## zloo## eh## wkh# suryhueldo## fdqdu|#lq#wkh# # # # frdo## plqh=## wkh|#zloo# # # uhiohfw#wkh# # # pdunhwᄊv## shufhswlrq#ri# # wkh#h{whqw#ri#ulvn#wdnlqj#e|#wkh#ilup1#Ri#frxuvh/#iru#wkh#ulvn#wr#eh#surshuo|#sulfhg/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhu|rqh#vkrxog#nqrz#wkdw#wkh#dxwkrulwlhv#zloo#qrw#edlo#rxw#wklv#fodvv#ri#fodlpv/#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdwwhu## krz## wkh|## wuhdw## wkh## uhvw## ri## wkh## ilup1## Rqh## uhdvrq## wkh## dxwkrulwlhv## edlo## rxw# ilqdqfldo0ilup#fodlp#kroghuv# # # # lv## wkdw#wkh|#gr# # # # qrw#nqrz# # # zkhwkhu## wkhvh## fodlpv## duh# khog## e|## rwkhu## ilqdqfldo## ilupv=## e|## ohwwlqj## wkh## fodlpv## ehdu## orvvhv/## wkh|## frxog## eh# suhflslwdwlqj## d## fdvfdgh## ri## idloxuhv1## Lw## lv## wkhuhiruh## lpsruwdqw## wkdw## uhjxodwruv# surklelw## dq|## ohyhuhg## ilqdqfldo## ilupv## iurp## kroglqj## frqwlqjhqw## frqyhuwleohv## ru# zulwlqj#fdslwdo# # # lqvxudqfh## +ru/## iru## wkdw## pdwwhu/## kroglqj#xqvhfxuhg# # # orqj0whup#ghew# # lvvxhg## e|#rwkhu# # # ohyhudjhg## ilqdqfldo## ilupv,1## Lqvwhdg## pxwxdo## ixqgv/## shqvlrq#ixqgv/# # dqg#vryhuhljq#zhdowk#ixqgv#vkrxog#eh#wkh#kroghuv#ri#fkrlfh1# # # # # # # # # # E|## uhtxlulqj## v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw## hqwlwlhv## wr## kdyh## vwurqjhu## exiihuv## djdlqvw# idloxuh/#uhjxodwruv#zrxog#uhgxfh#wkh#olnholkrrg#wkdw#wkh|#zrxog#wdnh#dgydqwdjh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#vwdwxv1#Li#d#ilup#lv#pdgh#qhdu#idlo0vdih#e|#lwv#htxlw|#fxvklrq/#wkh#survshfw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#surwhfwlrq#djdlqvw#idloxuh#frqihuv#olwwoh#dgydqwdjh1# # # # # # #
Pdnlqj#Ilqdqfldo#Ilupv#Hdvlhu#wr#Uhvroyh# # # # # # # Lq#gluh#fulvhv/#vrph#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#ilupv#pd|#hdw#wkurxjk#wkhlu#fdslwdo# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#eh#forvh#wr#idloxuh#qr#pdwwhu#krz# # # # # # # # # jrrg#wkh#sulru#vxshuylvlrq#ru#krz# # # # # # # dpsoh# wkh## htxlw|#exiihuv1# # # Li## vrph## ri## wkhlu## dfwlylwlhv## duh## hvvhqwldo## wr## ryhudoo## hfrqrplf# khdowk/#zh#qhhg#wr#iljxuh#rxw#krz#wr#ᄈuhvroyhᄡ#wkhpᄇwr#nhhs#wkh#fruh#exvlqhvvhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uxqqlqj#zkloh#lpsrvlqj#dssursuldwh#frvwv#rq#lqyhvwruv1#Rqh#ri#wkh#nh|#remhfwlyhv# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#d#uhvroxwlrq#phfkdqlvp#lv#wr#lpsrvh#dssursuldwh#orvvhv#rq#ghew#kroghuv#vr#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghew#kroghuv#gr#qrw#phuulo|#dftxlhvfh#lq#htxlw|#kroghuvᄊ#wdlo# # # # # # # # # # # ulvn#wdnlqj#zlwkrxw# # # ghpdqglqj#dq#dgglwlrqdo# # # # ulvn#suhplxp/#frqilghqw#wkh|#zloo# # # # # # eh## edlohg#rxw#e|#wkh# # # # jryhuqphqw#li#qhfhvvdu|1# # # Uhjxodwruv## fxuuhqwo|#gr# # # qrw## kdyh## uhvroxwlrq#dxwkrulw|#ryhu# # # # qrqedqn#ilqdqfldo# # ilupv## ru## edqn#kroglqj#frpsdqlhv/#dqg#surfhhglqjv# # # # # # lq#ruglqdu|#edqnuxswf|#frxuw# # # # zrxog#wdnh#wrr#orqj=#wkh#ilqdqfldo#exvlqhvv#zrxog#hydsrudwh#lq#wkh#phdqwlph1#Lw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhuhiruh## hvvhqwldo## iru## uhjxodwruv## wr## rewdlq## uhvroxwlrq## dxwkrulw|/## zklfk## zrxog# hiihfwlyho|## doorz## wkhp## wr## ixqfwlrq## dv## d## edqnuxswf|## frxuw1## Rqh## uhdvrq## wkdw# edqnuxswf|## surfhhglqjv## duh## vorz## lv## wkdw## wkh## frxuw## qhhgv## wr## ghwhuplqh## doo## wkh# dvvhwv#dqg#oldelolwlhv#ri#d#ilup#ehiruh#lw#ghflghv#zkdw#fdq#eh#suhvhuyhg#dqg#zkr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vkrxog#ehdu#wkh#orvvhv1#Zlwk#vlpsoh#edqn#vwuxfwxuhv/#doo#wklv#lqirupdwlrq#lv#uhdglo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # dydlodeoh1#Exw#v|vwhplfdoo|#lpsruwdqw#lqvwlwxwlrqv#jhqhudoo|#kdyh#idu#iurp#vlpsoh# # # # # # # # # # vwuxfwxuhv1## Vrph## ri## wkh## frpsoh{lw|## vlpso|## exlogv## ryhu## wlph/## dv## ilupv## duh## sxw#
wrjhwkhu## wkurxjk#phujhuv# # # ru## vwduw## exvlqhvvhv## dfurvv## erughuv>## vrph## frphv## iurp# dwwhpswv## wr## dyrlg## wd{hv## ru## klgh## dfwlylwlhv## iurp#uhjxodwru|#dxwkrulwlhv>#dqg# # # # # vrph# frphv## vlpso|## iurp## xqwlg|## pdqdjhphqw1## Ohkpdq## kdg## pruh## wkdq## vl{## kxqguhg# vxevlgldulhv#zkhq#lw#ilohg#iru#edqnuxswf|1# # # # # # Ehfdxvh## lw#lv# # # d## qljkwpduh## wr## uhvroyh## vxfk#dq#lqvwlwxwlrq#wrgd|/# # # # # ohw#dorqh# # # gr## lw# txlfno|/#edlorxwv#pd|#vhhp#olnh#wkh#rqo|#sudfwlfdo#rswlrq1#Rqh#zd|#rxw/#krzhyhu/# # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#wr#sxw#wkh#rqxv#ri#wkh#wdvn#edfn#rq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wkhpvhoyhv1#Hyhu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw## lqvwlwxwlrq## vkrxog## phhw## zlwk## uhjxodwruv## shulrglfdoo|## wr# uhylhz## lwv## ᄈolylqj#zloo/ᄡ# # # d## sodq#wkdw# # # zrxog## hqdeoh## lw## wr## eh## uhvroyhg## txlfno|ᄇ# lghdoo|/## ryhu## d## zhhnhqgᄇlq#wkh# # # hyhqw## ri## lpplqhqw## idloxuh1## Vxfk#d# # # sodq#zrxog# # uhtxluh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## wr## wudfn#dqg# # # grfxphqw## wkhlu## h{srvxuhv## pxfk#pruh# # # fduhixoo|# dqg## lq## d## wlpho|## pdqqhu/## suredeo|## wkurxjk## d## pxfk## ehwwhu## xvh## ri## whfkqrorj|1## Wr# suhyhqw#wklv# # # iurp#ehfrplqj#phuho|#d# # # # # fxuvru|#irupdolw|/# # # pxfk#ri#wkh# # # # ghwdlo## lq#d# # olylqj#zloo#frxog#eh#uhohdvhg#wr#wkh#sxeolf#dqg#pdunhwv#lq#d#irup#wkdw#lv#hdv|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # gljhvw1# Ehfdxvh#lw#pljkw#zhoo#eh#lpsrvvleoh#wr#dqwlflsdwh#doo#frqwlqjhqflhv/#wkh#olylqj# # # # # # # # # # # # zloo## pljkw## eh## ri## olplwhg## xvh## lq## jxlglqj## wkh## dfwxdo## uhvroxwlrq## ri## dq## lqvwlwxwlrq1# Qhyhuwkhohvv/## lw## frxog## eh## lpphqvho|#xvhixo# # # lq#vlpsoli|lqj#edqn#vwuxfwxuhv1# # # # # Qrw# rqo|#zrxog#wkh#qhhg#wr#ghyhors#d#sodq#jlyh#vxfk#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#zrun# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#uhjxodwruv# # # wr## plqlpl}h## rujdql}dwlrqdo## frpsoh{lw|#dqg# # # lpsuryh## wkh## hdvh## ri# uhvroxwlrq/#exw#lw#pljkw#lqghhg#irufh#pdqdjhphqw#wr#wklqn#wkh#xqwklqndeoh#gxulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # errpv/#wkxv#khoslqj#lw#dyrlg#wkh#frvwo|#exvwv1#Prvw#lpsruwdqw/#lw#zrxog#frqyh|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## pdunhw## wkh## phvvdjh## wkdw## wkh## dxwkrulwlhv## duh## vhulrxv## derxw## doorzlqj## wkh# v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw## wr## idlo1## Dv## zh## ohdyh## wkh## fulvlv## ehklqg/## wklv## zloo## eh## wkh# prvw#lpsruwdqw#phvvdjh#wr#frqyh|1# # # # #
Uhvlolhqfh # Kdylqj#glvfxvvhg#krz#zh#fdq#uhgxfh#wdlo#ulvn#vhhnlqj/#dv#zhoo#dv#wkh#uhodwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # sureohp#ri#kdylqj#hqwlwlhv#wkdw#duh#frqvlghuhg#wrr#v|vwhplf#wr#idlo/#ohw#ph#wxuq#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#srvvlelolw|#ri#xqnqrzq#xqnqrzqv1#Wkxv#idu/#L#kdyh#dujxhg#iru#zd|v#wr#uhgxfh# # # # # # # ## # # # # # wkh#olnholkrrg#ri#fulvhv#vwhpplqj#iurp#dfwv#ri#frpplvvlrq1#Exw#zh#dovr#kdyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dgguhvv#wkh#srvvlelolw|#ri#fulvlv#vwhpplqj#iurp#hyhqwv#dqg#flufxpvwdqfhv#wkdw#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # rqh#zdv#dzduh#ri#ru# # # # # # frxog#dqwlflsdwh>#zh#pxvw#dfnqrzohgjh#wkdw#hyhq#zlwk#wkh# # # # # # # # # ehvw## lqfhqwlyhv## lq#wkh# # # zruog/## d## frpelqdwlrq#ri#plvwdnhv/# # # # luudwlrqdo## eholhiv/## dqg# vkhhu## edg#oxfn#frxog#soxqjh#xv#lqwr#fulvlv#djdlq1#Zh#kdyh#wr#ilqg#zd|v#wr#pdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#v|vwhp#pruh#uhvlolhqw#wr#dfwv#ri#rplvvlrqᄇlqghhg/#wr#pdnh#lw#urexvw#qr#pdwwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkdw#wkh#vrxufh#ri#wkh#sureohp1#Doprvw#fhuwdlqo|/#wkh#wuljjhu#zloo#qrw#eh#vxesulph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## wkh## qh{w#wlph# # # durxqg149## Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/# # # zh## qhhg## qrw# rqo|#wr#hqirufh# # # # wkh## iluh## frgh## wr#uhgxfh# # # wkh## srvvlelolw|#ri#iluhv=# # # # zh## dovr#qhhg#wr# # # 4:# lqvwdoo#vsulqnohuv1 #
Uhvrxufhv# # Fohduo|/#uhvrxufhv#duh#lpsruwdqw#wr#ghdo#zlwk#dq|#fulvlv1#Lq#wkh#fxuuhqw#fulvlv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # rqh## uhdvrq## lqgxvwuldo## hfrqrplhv## glg## qrw## vxiihu## wkh## w|slfdo## idwh## ri## hphujlqj# pdunhwv## lv## wkdw#wkhlu# # # jryhuqphqwv## frxog## surplvh## wr## jxdudqwhh## edqn#oldelolwlhv# # # wr# txhoo## d## sdqlf/## dqg## wkrvh## surplvhv## zhuh## fuhgleoh1## Krzhyhu/## wkh## fulvlv## kdv# vwuhwfkhg## wkh## ilqdqfhv## ri## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv/## zlwk## d## qxpehu## ri## jryhuqphqwv# kdylqj## orvw## wkhlu## wrs## udwlqjv1## Wr## eh## suhsduhg## rqfh## djdlq## iru## hphujhqflhv/## wkh|# kdyh## wr## uhvwruh## jryhuqphqw## ilqdqfldo## khdowk## e|## sd|lqj## grzq## ghew/## xvlqj## vrph# frpelqdwlrq#ri#wd{#klnhv#dqg#h{shqglwxuh#fxwv#lq#d#pdqqhu#wkdw#grhv#qrw#kdyh#wrr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dgyhuvh## dq## lpsdfw## rq## jurzwk1## L## glvfxvv## X1V1## srolflhv## rq## wkhvh## lvvxhv## lq## pruh# ghwdlo#lq#wkh#qh{w#fkdswhu1# # # # # Dowkrxjk#lw#lv# # # # lpsruwdqw#wr# # # kdyh## uhvrxufhv/## pdnlqj#wkhp#uhdglo|#dydlodeoh# # # # # lv# qrw#dozd|v#d#jrrg#wklqj1#Sursrvdov#duh#fxuuhqwo|#ehlqj#ghedwhg#wkdw#zrxog#pdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # uhvrxufhv## hdvlo|#dydlodeoh# # # wr## wkh## jryhuqphqw## dqg## wkh## fhqwudo## edqn#wr# # # fduu|#rxw# # uhvfxhv/## wkxv## dyrlglqj## wkh## nlqg## ri## xqfhuwdlqw|## wkdw## vhw## rii## d## qhdu0sdqlf## lq## wkh# zhhnv## ehiruh## Frqjuhvv## sdvvhg## wkh## Wurxeohg## Dvvhw## Uholhi## Surjudp## lq# 533;14;Vxfk## d## pryh## zrxog## eh## d## plvwdnh## ehfdxvh## lw## zrxog## ohjlwlpl}h## uhvfxhv1# Zrxog#d#wuhdvxu|#vhfuhwdu|#hyhu#ohw#d#odujh#lqvwlwxwlrq#jr#xqghu#djdlq#li#Frqjuhvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdg#vdqfwlrqhg#uhvfxhv#e|#surylglqj#uhdg|#dffhvv#wr#ixqgvB#Zh#vkrxog#qrw#pdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#surfhvv#ri#dssursuldwlqj#uhvrxufhv#wr#fduu|#rxw#uhvfxhv#dq|#hdvlhu1#Dv#Zdowhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # Edjhkrw## uljkwo|## ihow/## v|vwhplf## ilqdqfldo## ilupv## dqg## pdunhwv## vkrxog## kdyh## vrph# xqfhuwdlqw|## derxw## zkdw## zloo## kdsshq## li## wkh|## jhw## lqwr## wurxeoh1## Kdylqj## Frqjuhvv# ghedwh#uhvfxhv#fhuwdlqo|#dggv#xqfhuwdlqw|#dqg#vrph#ryhuvljkw/#dqg#Frqjuhvv#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # vkrzq## dq## delolw|## wr## dfw## zkhq## qhhghgᄇwkrxjk## lw## pd|## kdyh## wdnhq## wkh## wuhdvxu|# vhfuhwdu|#jrlqj#grzq#rq#ehqghg#nqhh#ehiruh#wkh#Vshdnhu#ri#wkh#Krxvh#wr#pdnh#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdsshq$4<##Kdylqj#rqh#ru#wzr#odujh#ilupv#h{shulhqfh#vhyhuh#glvwuhvv/#ru#hyhq#idlo/# # # # # # # # # # # # ehiruh## wkh## fdydou|#frphv# # # wr## wkh## uhvfxh## lv## qrw## d## edg## lghd## srxu## hqfrxudjhu## ohv#
dxwuhv1
Uhgxqgdqf|# # D## v|vwhp## ehfrphv## iudjloh## li## lw## lv## ryhuo|## uholdqw## rq## dq|## vlqjoh## lqvwlwxwlrq/# pdunhw/#uhjxodwru/#ru#uhjxodwlrq1#Zh#qhhg#uhdo#uhgxqgdqf|#dqg#ydulhw|ᄇpxowlsoh# # # # # # # # # # sdwkzd|v## iru## surylglqj#dq|#ilqdqfldo# # # # vhuylfh/#zlwkrxw#wrr#pxfk#uholdqfh#rq#dq|# # # # # # # rqh## sdwk1## Iru## lqvwdqfh/## dv## wkh## vxesulph## pdunhw## khdwhg## xs/## wrr## pdq|## lqyhvwruv# vwduwhg## ghshqglqj## rq## udwlqjv1## Lw## glg## qrw## pdwwhu## wkdw## gliihuhqw## udwlqj## djhqflhv# surylghg#wkrvh#udwlqjv#ru#wkdw#wkh#lqyhvwruv#zhuh#glyhuvlilhg#dfurvv#d#ydulhw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv=## zkdw## zdv## frpsurplvhg## zdv## wkh## udwlqj## surfhvv# lwvhoi1## Zkhq## vxvslflrqv## urvh## derxw## udwlqjv/## wkh## hqwluh## pdunhw## froodsvhg1## Wr# surylgh#uhdo# # # uhgxqgdqf|#dqg#ydulhw|/#zh#qhhg#qrw#rqo|#pxowlsoh#sod|huv#dw#hdfk# # # # # # # # # # # ohyho#ri#wkh#vhfxulwl}dwlrq#surfhvv#exw#dovr#pxowlsoh#zd|v#ri#ilqdqflqj#pruwjdjhv# # # # # # # # # # # # rwkhu#wkdq#wkurxjk#vhfxulwl}dwlrq1# # # # Rqh#zd|#wr#rewdlq#ydulhw|#lv#wr#lpsrvh#xqlirup#uhjxodwlrq#dfurvv#lqvwlwxwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # irupv1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#edqnv#lq#Hxursh#lvvxh#fryhuhg#erqgv/#zklfk#duh#hvvhqwldoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # erqgv## lvvxhg#djdlqvw#d#srro# # # # # ri#pruwjdjhv1#Wkh|#duh#vlplodu# # # # # # wr#pruwjdjh0edfnhg# # vhfxulwlhv/#h{fhsw#wkdw#wkh#lqyhvwru#lq#wkhvh#erqgv#fdq#dvn#wkh#edqn#wr#sd|#zkdw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rzhg## li#wkh# # # srro## ri#pruwjdjhv# # # suryhv## lqvxiilflhqw#wr# # # fryhu## wkh## erqgv1## Edqnv## lq# wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#fkrvh#wr#vhfxulwl}h#pruwjdjhv#lqvwhdg#dqg#khog#pdq|#ri#wkhp#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rii0edodqfh## vkhhw## yhklfohv## wkdw## fdph## edfn## rq## wkhlu## edodqfh## vkhhwv## lq## wlphv## ri# wurxeoh1#Lq#uhwurvshfw/#fryhuhg#erqgv#pljkw#kdyh#ehhq#d#pruh#wudqvsduhqw#zd|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # kroglqj#pruwjdjhv#dqg#pljkw#kdyh#jlyhq#edqnv#pruh#lqfhqwlyh#wr#eh#fduhixo1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdslwdo## uhtxluhphqwv## idyruhg## rii0edodqfh## vkhhw## yhklfohv1## Oljkwhu/## pruh## xqlirup# uhjxodwlrq#dfurvv#lqvwlwxwlrqdo#irupv#zrxog#doorz#iru#juhdwhu#lqvwlwxwlrqdo#ydulhw|# # # # # # # # # # dqg#pruh#hiilflhqw/#ohvv#uhjxodwru0ghwhuplqhg/#zd|v#ri#xqghuwdnlqj#dfwlylwlhv1# # # # # # # # # Zh## vkrxog/## krzhyhu/## uhfrjql}h## wkdw## zkhq## pruh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## frph## xqghu## wkh# vdph## uhjxodwru|## xpeuhood/## zh## rshq## wkh## grru## wr## d## gliihuhqw## plvwdnh=## li## wkh# uhjxodwru## pdnhv## d## plvwdnh/## vkh## frruglqdwhv## pruh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## lqwr## iroorzlqj## lw1# Iru#h{dpsoh/#ehfdxvh#uhjxodwruv#durxqg#wkh#zruog#uhtxluhg#yhu|#olwwoh#fdslwdo#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # eh## khog## djdlqvw## vxshu0vhqlru## pruwjdjh0edfnhg## fodlpv/## edqnv## durxqg## wkh## zruog# ordghg#xs#rq#wkhp#dqg#wrrn#hqruprxv#orvvhv#wrjhwkhu1#E|#frqwudvw/#d#qxpehu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri# odujh#khgjh#ixqgv#vwd|hg#fohdu#ri#wkhvh#vhfxulwlhv/#sduwo|#ehfdxvh#wkh#khgjh#ixqgv# # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh## qrw## vxemhfw## wr## fdslwdo## uhjxodwlrq1## Uhjxodwru|## plvwdnhv## duh## sduwlfxoduo|# kdupixo## ehfdxvh## wkh## uhjxodwru## frruglqdwhv## wkh## uhjxodwhg## lqwr## iroorzlqj## wkh# plvwdnh=#wkh#zlghu#wkh#dpelw#ri#wkh#uhjxodwru/#wkh#pruh#sureohpdwlf#wkh#plvwdnh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkhuh#lv/#wkhuhiruh/#d#wudgh0rii1#E|#vsuhdglqj#wkh#uhjxodwru|#qhw#xqlirupo|/#zh# # # # # # # # # # # # hqvxuh## wkdw## qr## lqvwlwxwlrqv## duh## idyruhg## ru## glvdgydqwdjhg## dqg## wkdw## wkh## lqvwlwxwlrq# prvw## vxlwhg## wr## dq## dfwlylw|## xqghuwdnhv## lw1## Exw## zh## dovr## lqfuhdvh## wkh## lpsdfw## ri# uhjxodwru|## plvwdnhv1## Rqh## zd|## wr## plwljdwh## wklv## hiihfw## lv## wr## uhgxfh## wkh## h{whqw## wr# zklfk#uhjxodwruv#hpehg#zkdw#duh#hvvhqwldoo|#mxgjphqw#fdoovᄇvxfk#dv#wkh#dprxqw# # # # # # # # # # # ri## fdslwdo## wr## eh## khog## djdlqvw## d## fhuwdlq#dfwlylw|ᄇlq#uhjxodwlrqv1# # # # Oljkw/## hiihfwlyh# uhjxodwlrq#lv#ohvv#oldeoh#wr#kdyh#vhulrxv#frqvhtxhqfhv#lq#wkh#hyhqw#ri#plvwdnhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
Skdvlqj#Rxw#Ghsrvlw#Lqvxudqfh # # # # Ilqdoo|/#wr#hqvxuh#ydulhw|/#zh#vkrxog#qrw#sulylohjh#dq|#sduwlfxodu#lqvwlwxwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # irup1## Dq## hqruprxv## vrxufh## ri## sulylohjh## iru## edqnv## lv## ghsrvlw## lqvxudqfh=## li## dq# lqvwlwxwlrq#kdsshqv#wr#eh#ixqghg#zlwk#d#fhuwdlq#irup#ri#ghpdqgdeoh#ghew/#wkdw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghsrvlwv/## wkh## ghsrvlwv## duh## ixoo|#edfnhg# # # e|#wkh# # # jryhuqphqwᄊv## ghsrvlw## lqvxuhu## rq# sd|phqw#ri#d#qrplqdo#ihh1#Qr#rwkhu#lqvwlwxwlrqdo#irup#kdv#lwv#vkruw0whup#ghew#wkxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqvxuhg1# L## dvnhg## hduolhu## zkhwkhu## wkh## dfwlylwlhv## ri## lqvxuhg## edqnv## vkrxog## eh## uhvwulfwhg1# Shukdsv#d#ehwwhu#txhvwlrq#lv#zkhwkhu#edqnv#vkrxog#kdyh#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh#dw#doo1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wklv## pd|#eh# # # d## vwudqjh## txhvwlrq#wr# # # dvn#dw#d# # # # wlph## zkhq#jryhuqphqwv# # # doo## ryhu## wkh# zruog## kdyh## jxdudqwhhg## doo## wkh## ghew## lvvxhg## e|## wkhlu## edqnv/## qrw## mxvw## wkh## vpdoo/# douhdg|## lqvxuhg## ghsrvlwv1## Exw## wkdw## lv## suhflvho|## wkh## uhdvrq## iru## p|## txhvwlrq1# Ghsrvlw## lqvxudqfh## lv## qrw## phdqw## wr## txhoo## sdqlfv## e|## suhyhqwlqj## edqn## uxqv=## wkh# jryhuqphqw/## dv## zh## kdyh## uhfhqwo|## vhhq/## wdnhv## fduh## ri## wkdw1## Lqvwhdg/## lw## phuho|# surwhfwv## lqglylgxdo## edqnv## iurp#pdunhw# # # glvflsolqh1## Sxw## gliihuhqwo|/## zlwk## lpsolflw# jryhuqphqw#jxdudqwhhv#doo#ryhu#wkh#sodfh/#vkrxog#zh#qrw#vwulyh#wr#uhpryh#h{solflw# # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#jxdudqwhhv#zkhuh#zh#fdqB# # # # # Rqh## uhdvrq#iru# # # lqvxulqj#ghsrvlwv# # # zdv## wr## surylgh## d## vdih## phdqv## ri#vdylqjv# # # wr# krxvhkrogv#zkhuh#qrqh#h{lvwhg1#Wrgd|/#wklv#udwlrqdoh#lv#dufkdlfᄇd#prqh|0pdunhw# # # # # # # # # # ixqg#lqyhvwhg#lq#Wuhdvxu|#eloov#fdq#surylgh#wkdw#vdihw|1#D#zhoo0glyhuvlilhg#prqh|0 # # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw#ixqg#lqyhvwhg#lq#kljko|#udwhg#frpphufldo#sdshu#dqg#pdunhg#hyhu|#gd|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw#lv#doprvw#dv#vdih#dqg#vkrxog#qrw#h{shulhqfh#wkh#nlqgv#ri#uxqv#h{shulhqfhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 53# e|#ixqgv#wkdw#zhuh#qrw#pdunhg#wr#pdunhw#gxulqj#wklv#fulvlv1 # # # # # # # # # # Dqrwkhu#lpsruwdqw#uhdvrq#iru#lqvxulqj#ghsrvlwv#zdv#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#wkh#sd|phqw# # # # # # # # # # # # v|vwhp#zrxog#eh#uhodwlyho|#vdih=#xquhjxodwhg/#xqvdih/#xqlqvxuhg#hqwlwlhv#frxog#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # srooxwh## lw#dqg# # # fdxvh## wkh## v|vwhp#wr# # # iuhh}h1## Exw#qrz# # # wkdw#whfkqrorjlfdo# # # dgydqfhv/# vxfk## dv## uhdo0wlph## jurvv## vhwwohphqw## sd|phqwv/## pdnh## lw## srvvleoh## wr## surwhfw## wkh# sd|phqw#v|vwhp#iurp#wkh#idloxuh#ri#dq|#sd|hu/#hyhq#wklv#udwlrqdoh#lv#zhdn1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh# # # grhv## khos## nhhs## vpdoo/## xqglyhuvlilhg## edqnv## lq#exvlqhvv1# # # Wr# wkh## h{whqw## wkdw## wkhvh## vpdoo## edqnv## duh## lpsruwdqw## lq## pdnlqj## ordqv## lq## wkh## orfdo# frppxqlw|ᄇwr## wkh## orfdo## ednhu|## ru## wr|## vkrsᄇwkh|## kdyh## vrph## hfrqrplf## dqg# vrfldo#ydoxh1#Rqh#srvvlelolw|#lv#wr#uhwdlq#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh#iru#vpdoo#dqg#phglxp0 # # # # # # # # # # # # vl}hg#edqnv# # # lq#uhwxuq#iru# # # # wkhlu## sd|lqj#d#idlu# # # # lqvxudqfh#suhplxp/#exw#wr#uhgxfh#lw# # # # # # surjuhvvlyho|#iru#odujhu#edqnv#xqwlo#lw#lv#holplqdwhg1# # # # # # # # Fohduo|/## li#edqnv# # # duh## vhhq#dv# # # wrr## elj#wr# # # idlo/## holplqdwlqj#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh# # # # lv# prrw/## dv## wkh## edqn## zloo## eh## edlohg## rxw## dq|zd|1## Wkh## Xqlwhg## Nlqjgrp## ghsrvlw# lqvxudqfh#v|vwhp/#zklfk#zdv#sduwldo/#glg#qrw#suhyhqw#Qruwkhuq#Urfn#iurp#jhwwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # lqwr## wurxeoh## ru## wkh## jryhuqphqw## iurp## frplqj## wr## wkh## uhvfxh1## Wkh## srlqw## ri# holplqdwlqj#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh/# # # # krzhyhu/## lv## wr## pdnh## ghsrvlwruv## wklqn#ehiruh# # # wkh|# pdnh## d## edqn#wrr#elj1#Xqolnh# # # # # ghsrvlwruv## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp#+zkhuh# # # # doo## edqn# ghsrvlwv## zhuh## sduwldoo|## lqvxuhg/## dqg## wkhuhiruh## ghsrvlwlqj## lq## d## odujh## edqn## zdv# vljqlilfdqwo|#vdihu,/#ghsrvlwruv#lq#odujh#edqnv#xqghu#p|#sursrvdo#zrxog#kdyh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # fkrlfh## ehwzhhq#ehlqj#ixoo|#lqvxuhg# # # # # lq#d# # # vpdoo## edqn#dqg# # # odujho|#xqlqvxuhg# # # lq#d# # odujh## edqn1## Vxfk## d## phdvxuh## zrxog## sodfh## vrph## frqvwudlqwv## rq## wkh## jurzwk## ri#
vhulrxvo|#plvpdqdjhg#odujhu#edqnv#zkloh#dovr#ohyholqj#wkh#sod|lqj#ilhog1# # # # # # # # # # Skdvlqj## rxw## ghsrvlw## lqvxudqfh## grhv## qrw## phdq## grlqj## dzd|## zlwk## uhjxodwlrq1# Ehfdxvh## wkh## jryhuqphqw#zloo# # # frqwlqxh## wr## vwhs## lq#zkhq#wkh# # # # ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## jhwv# lqwr#ghhs#wurxeoh/#lw#zloo#kdyh#wr#uhjxodwh#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv1#Exw#lw#fdq#uhjxodwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # odujh## lqvwlwxwlrqv## pruh## xqlirupo|/## edvhg## rq#wkhlu# # # fdslwdo## vwuxfwxuh## +wkhlu## fdslwdo# dqg## vkruw0whup## ghew,## dqg## wkh## qdwxuh## ri## wkhlu## dvvhwv## +wkhlu## kroglqjv## lq## looltxlg# vhfxulwlhv#dqg/#lq#looltxlg#ordqv,#udwkhu#wkdq#rq#wkh#edvlv#ri#zkhwkhu#wkh|#kdyh#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnlqj#olfhqvh1# # Lw## lv## qrw## hdv|## wr## frqwhpsodwh## grlqj## dzd|## zlwk## ghsrvlw## lqvxudqfh1## Ihz# ghsrvlwruv#wrgd|#fdq#uhfdoo#d#wlph#zkhq#ghsrvlwv#zhuh#qrw#lqvxuhg1#\hw#xqlqvxuhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # edqnv## h{lvwhg## iru## fhqwxulhv1## Zlwk## dowhuqdwlyh## zd|v## ri## hqvxulqj## wkh## vdihw|## ri# krxvhkrog#lqyhvwphqwv# # # +vxfk#dv# # # prqh|0pdunhw#ghsrvlwv,# # # dqg#vdih# # # sd|phqwv/#dqg# # zlwk#edqnv# # # douhdg|#surwhfwhg# # # hqrxjk#iurp#glvflsolqh# # # # ehfdxvh## ri## uhfhqw## hyhqwv/# shukdsv#lw#lv#wlph#zh#glg#dzd|#zlwk#dq#dufkdlf#sulylohjh1# # # # # # # # # # #
Fdhvduᄊv#Zlih # # Ehiruh#frqfoxglqj/#L#udlvh#d#ilqdo#lvvxh1#L#kdyh#irfxvhg#rq#zd|v#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw# # ## # # # ## # # # # # # wkh## jryhuqphqw## lv## qrw## hdvlo|#gudzq#lqwr# # # # vxssruwlqj#vshflilf# # # pdunhwv## ru## sulydwh# lqvwlwxwlrqv1## L## kdyh## dvvxphg## wkdw## wkh## jryhuqphqw/## olnh## Fdhvdu#ᄊv## zlih/## lv## deryh# vxvslflrq1#Wkh#sxeolf#kdv#zlghvsuhdg#frqfhuqv#wkdw#lw#lv#qrw/#dv#d#txlfn#vxuyh|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#eorjrvskhuh#dqg#fdeoh#qhzv#qhwzrunv#+dgplwwhgo|#qrw#dq#xqeldvhg#vdpsoh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## sxeolf,## vxjjhvwv/## dqg## vrph## ri## wkhvh## frqfhuqv## duh## mxvwlilhg1## Zkhq## d## X1V1# Wuhdvxu|#hpsor|hh#jrhv#gluhfwo|#iurp#uxqqlqj#wkh#eljjhvw#edlorxw#ixqg#lq#klvwru|# # # # # # # # # # # # wr## zrun#iru# # # d## frpsdq|#wkdw#uxqv# # # # wkh## eljjhvw#erqg# # # ixqg## lq#wkh# # # zruog/## dqg## zkhq# dqrwkhu#Wuhdvxu|#hpsor|hh#jrhv#iurp#rujdql}lqj#ilqdqfldo0vhfwru#uhvfxhv#gluhfwo|# # # # # # # # # wr## uxqqlqj#rqh# # # ri#wkh# # # edqnv## wkdw#lv# # # prvw#lq#qhhg# # # # ri#uhvfxh/# # # wkh## sxeolfᄊv## wuxvw#lv# # vwudlqhg1## Qr## pdwwhu## krz## krqrudeoh## wkh## lqwhqwlrqv## ri#wkh# # # lqglylgxdov## lq#txhvwlrq# # +dqg#L#kdyh#qr#grxew#wkdw#wkh|#duh#krqrudeoh,#ru#krz#fduhixo#wkh#qhz#hpsor|hu#lq# ## # # # # # # # # # # # # # dyrlglqj#frqiolfwv#ri#lqwhuhvw/#wkh#ghdov/#wr#sxw#lw#plogo|/#vwlqn1# # # # # # # # # # # Hyhq#dv# # # wkh## sulydwh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## kdv## glvsod|hg## d## wlq#hdu# # # iru## wkh## srolwlfdo# frqvhtxhqfhv## ri#vxfk#ehkdylru/# # # # lwv## doxpql## lq#wkh# # # jryhuqphqw## dssduhqwo|#idlo# # # wr# xqghuvwdqg## wkh## gliilfxow|1## Lq## qrupdo## wlphv/## wkh## uhyroylqj## grru## ehwzhhq# jryhuqphqw#dqg#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#kdv#hqdeohg#jryhuqphqwv#durxqg#wkh#zruog#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # dwwudfw#wuhphqgrxv#wdohqw/#hyhq#zkloh#xqghusd|lqj#jurvvo|1#Dqg#lq#qrupdo# # # # # # # # # # # wlphv/# wkh## frqiolfwv## ri#lqwhuhvw#lqkhuhqw#lq#wkh# # # # # # uhyroylqj#grru# # # duh## vpdoo1## Lq#grzqwxuqv/# # krzhyhu/#wkh|#pd|#eh#hqruprxv=# # # # # # wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#friihuv#duh#ixoo|#rshq/#dqg#d# # # # # # # # vwurnh## ri## d## shq## ru## d## nh|## fdq## vhqg## eloolrqv## ri## grooduv## ri## sxeolf## prqh|## lq## rqh# gluhfwlrq## ru## dqrwkhu1## Wkh## uxohv## jryhuqlqj## wkh## uhyroylqj## grru## kdyh## wr## eh# uhh{dplqhg1# Wkhuh## lv## d## eurdghu## txhvwlrq## ri## zkhwkhu## jryhuqphqw## dfwlrq## lv## lqioxhqfhg# h{fhvvlyho|## e|## Zdoo## Vwuhhw1## L## eholhyh## wkdw## zkhq## Zdoo## Vwuhhw## doxpql## rffxs|# srzhuixo#srvlwlrqv#lq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#ru#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh/#wkh|#gr#zkdw#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # wklqn#lv# # # ehvw#iru# # # wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Exw#zkdw#wkh|#wklqn#dffrugv# # # # # # zlwk#wkhlu# # # Zdoo# Vwuhhw#wudlqlqj#dqg#zlwk#wkh#rslqlrqv#ri#wkh#shrsoh#wkh|#wdon#wrᄇdqg#wkhvh#shrsoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr#duh#doo#odujho|#iurp#wkh#Vwuhhw1#Frjqlwlyh#fdswxuh#lv# # # # # # # # # # # d#ehwwhu# # # ghvfulswlrq#ri# # 54# wklv#skhqrphqrq#wkdq#furq|#fdslwdolvp1 # # # # #Wkh#qh{xv#qhhgv#wr#eh#eurnhq/#srvvleo|# # # # # # # e|## uhfuxlwlqj## wdohqw## iurp## rxwvlgh## Zdvklqjwrq## dqg## Qhz## \run/## dqg## hyhq## iurp# rxwvlgh## ilqdqfh/## wr## vwdii## fulwlfdo## srvlwlrqv## lq## wkh## Wuhdvxu|ᄇiruphu## fduhhu# uhjxodwruv/## frusrudwh## h{hfxwlyhv## zlwk## ilqdqfh## h{shulhqfh/## dqg/## gduh## L## vd|/# dfdghplfv1#Glyhuvlw|#zloo#eh#nh|#wr#lpsurylqj#wuxvw1# # # # # # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Krz## gr## zh## suhvhuyh## wkh## ehqhilwv## ri## wkh## ghprfudwl}dwlrq## ri## ilqdqfh## zkloh# hqvxulqj#wkdw#wkh#v|vwhp#grhv#qrw#shuplw#h{fhvvlyh#ulvnB#Wkh#dqvzhuv#L#sursrvh#lq# # # # # # # # # # # ## # wklv#fkdswhu#duh#qrw#vr#gudpdwlf#dv#grlqj#dzd|#zlwk#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#ru#jdjjlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#elqglqj#lw/#dv#vxjjhvwhg#e|#Surjuhvvlyhv/#ru#grlqj#dzd|#zlwk#doo#jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#uhjxodwlrq/#dv#vxjjhvwhg#e|#wkh#lghrorjlfdo#Uljkw1#Wkh#sureohpv#hpdqdwhg#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#lqwhuidfhv#ehwzhhq#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#dqg#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄇwkh#orfdwlrq#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # idxow#olqhvᄇexw#vlqfh#zh#fdqqrw#gr#dzd|#zlwk#hlwkhu#vlgh/#uhdolvwlf#uhirupv#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#zrun#rq#pdqdjlqj#wkh#lqwhuidfh1#Zh#duh/#krzhyhu/#lq#wkh#srvlwlrq#ri#vrphrqh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dvnlqj#iru#gluhfwlrqv#dqg#jhwwlqj#wkh#uhvsrqvh/#ᄈZhoo/#L#zrxogqᄊw#vwduw#iurp#khuh1ᄡ# # # # # # # # ## # # # Wkh#vxshufkdujhg#ilqdqfldo# # # # vhfwru/#kdylqj#wdnhq#ixoo# # # # # dgydqwdjh#ri#wkh#lpsolflw# # # # jxdudqwhhv## hpehgghg## lq## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## ghvluh## wr## sxvk## krxvlqj## fuhglw## dqg# surprwh#hpsor|phqw#jurzwk/#kdv#hqghg#xs#iodw#rq#lwv#edfn1#Wkh#jryhuqphqw#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhq#gholyhuhg#rq#wkh#jxdudqwhhv#wr#wkh#ehvw#ri#lwv#delolw|#dqg/#lq#idfw/#grqh#pruh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lw#qrz#kdv#wkh#wdvn#ri#frqylqflqj#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#wkdw#lw#zloo#qrw#gr#vr#djdlq1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Exw#wkh#jryhuqphqw#kdv#qrw#zlwkgudzq#iurp#krxvlqj#ilqdqfh=#lq#idfw/#lw#lv#hyhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh## wljkwo|## hqphvkhg## qrz1## Hyhq## li## lw## zhuh## wr## wdnh## fduh## ri## wkh## srolwlfdo# frpsxovlrqv## wkdw#gudz# # # lw#lq#wr# # # # vxssruwlqj#vrph# # # pdunhwv## dqg## khqfh## wkh## ilqdqfldo# vhfwru/#lw#vwloo#kdv#wr#frqylqfh#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#wkdw#qr#hqwlw|#lv#wrr#v|vwhplfdoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwdqw#wr#eh#doorzhg#wr#idlo1#Vr#wkh#nh|#txhvwlrq#lq#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#uhirup#lv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Krz#gr#zh#jhw#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#wr#sulfh#ulvn#surshuo|#djdlq/#zlwkrxw#dvvxplqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrqB#Wkh#sursrvdov#lq#wklv#fkdswhu#riihu#d#sdwk1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## wkuxvw## kdv## wr## eh## xvlqj## wudqvsduhqf|## wr## gudz## wkh## lqwhuhvwhg## sxeolf## lqwr# prqlwrulqj#wkh#uhodwlrqvkls#ehwzhhq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#ru#uhjxodwru#dqg#wkh#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # # vhfwru1## Pxfk#ri# # # zkdw## L## sursrvh## idoov## vkruw## ri## wkh## gudpdwlf## uhphglhv## wkdw## vrph# ghvluh1#Exw#wkh#zrugv#ri#Mxvwlfh#Orxlv#Eudqghlv/#iurp#d#ohwwhu#ri#4<55/#duh#dv#dsw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iru## ilqdqfldo0vhfwru## uhirup#dv# # # hovhzkhuh=## ᄈGr## qrw## eholhyh## wkdw## |rx## fdq## ilqg## d# xqlyhuvdo## uhphg|## iru## hylo## frqglwlrqv## ru## lpprudo## sudfwlfhv## lq## hiihfwlqj## d# ixqgdphqwdo#fkdqjh#lq#vrflhw|#+dv#e|#Vwdwh#Vrfldolvp,1#Dqg#gr#qrw#slq#wrr#pxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # idlwk## lq## ohjlvodwlrq1## Uhphgldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv## duh## dsw## wr## idoo## xqghu## frqwuro## ri## wkh# 55##Klv#sursrvhg#dowhuqdwlyh#zdv# hqhp|#dqg#wr#ehfrph#lqvwuxphqwv#ri#rssuhvvlrq1ᄡ # # # # # # # # # zkdw## zh## zrxog## qrz## fdoo## wudqvsduhqf|/## zklfk## kh## uhihuuhg## wr## dv## sxeolflw|=# ᄈSxeolflw|#lv# # # mxvwo|#frpphqghg# # # dv## d## uhphg|#iru# # # vrfldo## dqg## lqgxvwuldo## glvhdvhv1# Vxqoljkw## lv## vdlg## wr## eh## wkh## ehvw## ri## glvlqihfwdqwv>## hohfwulf## oljkw## wkh## prvw## hiilflhqw# srolfhphq1ᄡ56# L#qrz#wxuq#wr#wkh#uhirupv#wkdw#duh#qhhghg#lq#wkh#X1V1#hfrqrp|/#irfxvlqj#rq#krz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#lpsuryh#dffhvv#wr#txdolw|#hgxfdwlrq#dqg#krz#wr#vwuhqjwkhq#wkh#vdihw|#qhw1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
FKDSWHU#QLQH #
Lpsurylqj#Dffhvv#wr#Rssruwxqlw|#lq#Dphulfd # # # # # #
L## DUJXH## LQ## FKDSWHU## 4## WKDW## wkh## suhvvxuhv## fuhdwhg## e|## uhodwlyho|## vwdjqdqw#
lqfrphv## iru## pdq|#lq#wkh# # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## pluuruhg## wkrvh## lq#wkh# # # w|slfdo## ghyhorslqj# frxqwu|>## wkh|## ohg## X1V1## srolwlfldqv## wr## sxvk## fuhglw## dv## d## sdooldwlyh1## Vxesulph# pruwjdjh#ohqglqj#zdv#wkh#v|pswrp/#gzlqgolqj#hfrqrplf#rssruwxqlw|#iru#pdq|#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # fdxvh1# Qrw## doo## irupv## ri## lqfrph## lqhtxdolw|#duh# # # hfrqrplfdoo|#kdupixo1# # # Kljkhu## zdjhv# vhuyh## wr## uhzdug## wkh## yhu|#wdohqwhg# # # dqg## wkh## kdugzrunlqj/## lghqwli|#wkh# # # mrev## lq#wkh# # hfrqrp|## wkdw## qhhg## wkh## prvw## vnloov/## dqg## vljqdo## wr## wkh## |rxqj## wkh## ehqhilwv## ri# lqyhvwlqj## lq## wkhlu## rzq## kxpdq## fdslwdo1## D## irufhg## htxdol}dwlrq## ri## zdjhv## wkdw# glvuhjdugv#wkh#pdujlqdo#frqwulexwlrqv#ri#gliihuhqw#zrunhuv#zloo#ghdghq#lqfhqwlyhv# # # # # # # # # # dqg#ohdg#wr#d#plvdoorfdwlrq#ri#uhvrxufhv#dqg#hiiruw1# # # # # # # # # Krzhyhu/## zkhq## wkh## rqo|## sdwkzd|v## wr## kljk## zdjhv## duh## vhhq## wr## eh## eluwk/# lqioxhqfh/## oxfn/## ru## fkhdwlqj/## zdjh## gliihuhqwldov## pd|#qrw# # # dfw## dv## d## vsxu## wr## hiiruw1# Zk|## erwkhu## zkhq## hiiruw## lv## qrw## wkh## urxwh## wr## uhzdugvB## Lqghhg/## dv## wkh## srolwlfdo# hfrqrplvwv#Doehuwr#Dohvlqd#dqg#Jhrujh0Pdulrv#Dqjhohwrv#dujxh/#shufhswlrqv#lq# # # # # # # # # d## ghprfudf|## dv## wr## krz## kljk## zdjhv## ru## zhdowk## duh## rewdlqhg## fdq## fuhdwh## vhoi0 4## Li#vrflhw|#eholhyhv# uhlqiruflqj#sdwwhuqv1 # # # # shrsoh## hduq#kljk#zdjhv# # # # dv## d## uhvxow#ri# # wkhlu## wudlqlqj## dqg## kdug## zrun/## lw## lv## ohvv## zloolqj## wr## wd{## kljk## hduqhuv/## wkhuhe|# hqvxulqj#wkh|#kdyh#vwurqj#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#dftxluh#vnloov#dqg#h{huw#hiiruw1#Li#vrflhw|# # # # # # # # # # # # # eholhyhv## shrsoh## hduq## kljk## zdjhv## ehfdxvh## ri## frqqhfwlrqv/## fkdqfh/## ru# furrnhgqhvv/#wkhq#lw#zloo# # # # # wd{#lqfrphv#pruh#khdylo|/#dqg#vlqfh#ihz# # # # # # # # ri#wkh#krqhvw# # # zloo#wkhq#erwkhu#wr#zrun#kdug/#rqo|#wkrvh#zlwk#lqioxhqfh/#wkh#oxfn|/#ru#wkh#fkhdwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo#iorxulvk1# # Lqghhg/## rqh## uhdvrq## zk|## wkh## X1V1## hohfwrudwh## wrgd|## vhhpv## vr## uhfhswlyh## wr# sursrvdov#wr#pdnh#wkh#ulfk#sd|#pxfk#pruh#lq#wd{hv#lv#wkdw#shufhswlrqv#ri#zkr#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulfk## pd|## kdyh## fkdqjhg1## Qrw## vr## orqj## djr/## wkh## surwrw|slfdo## ulfk## shuvrq## lq## wkh# Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv## wkh## orfdo## vhoi0pdgh## hqwuhsuhqhxu## zkr## rzqhg## wkh## fdu# ghdohuvkls## dqg## wkh## prylh## wkhdwhu## dqg## zkr## fdph## iurp#wkh# # # vdph## kljk#vfkrro# # # dv# hyhu|rqh#hovh1#Wrgd|/#lw#lv# # # # # # wkh#glvwdqw/#ryhusdlg#FHR/#wkh#juhhg|#edqnhu/#ru# # # # # # # # # wkh# khgjh0ixqg## pdqdjhu## zkr## wkulyhv## rq#lqvlghu# # # wudghv1## Vwhuhrw|shv## dqg## shufhswlrqv# pdwwhu=#wkh#ulfk#duh#qr#orqjhu#xv/#wkh|#duh#wkhp1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # qhhgv## wr#suhyhqw#ixuwkhu# # # # vrfldo## srodul}dwlrq/#erwk#lq#uhdolw|# # # # dqg## lq#shufhswlrq1# # # Wkh## suhflvh## zd|#ri#grlqj#wklv# # # # # grhv## pdwwhu1## Li#wkh# # # ulvh## lq#wkh# # zdjh## lqhtxdolw|## prvw## shrsoh## h{shulhqfh## vwhpv## iurp## wkh## uhodwlyh## vfduflw|## ri# zrunhuv#zlwk#pruh#kxpdq#fdslwdo/#dv#L#dujxh#lq#fkdswhu#4/#wkhq#wkh#uhvsrqvh#kdv# # # # # # ## # # # # # # # wr## eh## wr## lpsuryh## wkh## txdolw|#ri#kxpdq#fdslwdo# # # # # ri#wkh# # # zrunirufh1## Khdy|#wd{dwlrq# # vroho|## wr## htxdol}h## zdjhv## zloo## gr## olwwoh## wr## wdfnoh## wkdw## sureohp#dqg# # # zloo## uhgxfh# lqfhqwlyhv#wr#zrun#ru# # # # # dftxluh#kxpdq#fdslwdo1#Wklv#lv#zk|#L#zloo# # # # # # ## # wdnh#dv#d#jlyhq# # # # wkdw## wkh## ehvw## zd|## ri## uhgxflqj## xqqhfhvvdu|## lqfrph## lqhtxdolw|## lv## wr## uhgxfh## wkh#
lqhtxdolw|#lq#dffhvv#wr#ehwwhu#kxpdq#fdslwdo1# # # # # # # Htxdol}lqj#dffhvv#fdq#khdg#rii#euhzlqj#frqiolfwv1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#li#ulfk#sduhqwv# # # # # # # # # # # # fdq#sd|#iru#ehwwhu#vfkrrov/#h{wud#wxlwlrq/#dqg#hyhqwxdoo|#jrrg#xqlyhuvlwlhv#iru#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkloguhq#zkloh#srru#sduhqwv#fdqqrw/#wkh#srru#zloo#ehfrph#pruh#lqwrohudqw#ri#kljk# # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfrphv## dqg## zhdowk1## Dsduw## iurp#lqfuhdvlqj#frqiolfw# # # # ehwzhhq#wkh# # # kdyhv## dqg## wkh# kdyh0qhyhuv/## xqhtxdo## dffhvv## pd|#dovr# # # lqfuhdvh## uhvlvwdqfh## wr## hfrqrplf## uhirupv# wkdw#h{sdqg#rssruwxqlw|1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#wkh#srru#xuedq#zrunhu#zkr#grhv#qrw#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # dffhvv#wr#d#xqlyhuvlw|#hgxfdwlrq#pd|#fduh#olwwoh#iru#uhirupv#wkdw#pdnh#lw#hdvlhu#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rshq#vpdoo# # # exvlqhvvhv/## ehfdxvh## vkh## kdv## qr## fkdqfh## ri#rewdlqlqj#wkh# # # # ilqdqflqj#wr# # 5# rshq#rqh1 # Zkdw#zh# # # suhihu## srolwlfdoo|#ghshqgv# # # rq#zkhuh# # # zh## vwdqg=## li#zh# # # vwdqg## dw#yhu|# # gliihuhqw#sodfhv/#lw#lv#kdughu#iru#xv#wr#frph#wrjhwkhu#dv#d#vrflhw|#wr#pdnh#pxwxdoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehqhilfldo## ghflvlrqv1## Dqg## pruh## wkdq## wkh## txdolw|## ri## lwv## lqvwlwxwlrqv/## zkdw# glvwlqjxlvkhv## d## ghyhorshg## frxqwu|## iurp## d## ghyhorslqj## rqh## lv## wkh## ghjuhh## ri# frqvhqvxv## lq## lwv## srolwlfv/## dqg## wkxv## lwv## delolw|## wr## wdnh## dfwlrqv## wr## vhfxuh## d## ehwwhu# ixwxuh## ghvslwh## vkruw0whup## sdlq1## Xqhtxdo## dffhvv/## dqg## wkh## uhvxowlqj## lqhtxdolw|/# ghvwur|v## frqvhqvxv1## Dqg## dowkrxjk#wklv# # # fkdswhu## irfxvhv## rq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## wkh# lvvxhv#dgguhvvhg#khuh#duh#uhohydqw#lq#pdq|#frxqwulhv/#lqfoxglqj#ghyhorslqj#rqhv# # # # # # # # # # # olnh#Fklqd#dqg#Lqgld1# # # # Wkh#sureohp#lv#wkdw#wkh#srolwlfdo#dqg#hfrqrplf#frvwv#ri#dq|#hiiruw#wr#lpsuryh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dffhvvᄇiru## lqvwdqfh/## surylglqj## txdolw|## suhvfkrro## fduh## iru## srru## fkloguhqᄇduh# lqfxuuhg#xs#iurqw/#zkhuhdv#wkh#ehqhilwv#olh#lq#wkh#ixwxuh1#Lw#lv#kdug#wr#jhw#wkh#sxeolf/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## frqvhtxhqwo|## srolwlfldqv/## h{flwhg## derxw## vxfk## xqghuwdnlqjv/## hvshfldoo|## dw## d# wlph#ri#vwudlwhqhg#sxeolf#ilqdqfhv1#Exw#li#qrwklqj#lv#grqh/#lqhtxdolw|#zloo#ihhg#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwvhoi1#Wkh#frvwv#ri#uhguhvvlqj#ghilflhqflhv#zloo#rqo|#lqfuhdvh/#dqg#pdq|#flwl}hqv# # # # # # # # # # # # zloo## eh## ohiw## luuhphgldeo|## loo0htxlsshg## iru## d## surgxfwlyh## olih## lq## vrflhw|1## Sxw# gliihuhqwo|/## wkh## vwdwxv## txr## hqwdlov## xqdffhswdeoh## dqg## jurzlqj#frvwv/# # # dqg## dyrlglqj# wkrvh#yhu|#ylvleoh#frvwv#kdv#wr#eh#sduw#ri#wkh#frvw0ehqhilw#fdofxoxv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Lq## duulylqj## dw## vroxwlrqv## zh## vkrxog## uhvlvw## wzr## vhhplqjo|## dwwudfwlyh## exw# gdqjhurxv## qrwlrqv1## Rqh## lv## wkdw#jryhuqphqw#vshqglqj#zloo# # # # # il{#doo# # # sureohpv1## Wkh# wuxwk## lv## wkdw## prqh|## lv## uduho|## wkh## nh|## plvvlqj## lqjuhglhqw/## dv## zh## vdz## zlwk## wkh# jurzwk#ri#ghyhorslqj#qdwlrqv1#Lqghhg/#jryhuqphqw#odujhvvh#fdq#furzg#rxw/#li#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # fruuxsw/#lqglylgxdo# # # dqg#frppxqlw|#lqlwldwlyh1#Wkdw#grhv# # # # # # qrw#phdq/#krzhyhu/#wkdw# # # # doo## vrflhwdo## sureohpv## zloo## eh## vroyhg## e|## vsrqwdqhrxv## yroxqwdu|## lqlwldwlyh/## wkh# vhfrqg#gdqjhurxv#qrwlrq1#Jryhuqphqw#hiiruw#+dqg#vrphwlphv#prqh|,#lv#qhhghg#dw# # # # # # # # # # # nh|#ohyhudjh# # # srlqwv## wr## frruglqdwh## lqglylgxdo## dqg## frppxqlw|#dfwlrq1# # # Djdlq#dqg# # djdlq/#zh#vhh#wkdw#vxffhvvhv#lqyroyh#d#frplqj#wrjhwkhu#ri#nh|#sod|huv/#d#eurdghu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghilqlwlrq## ri## wkh## sureohp## +dqg## khqfh## vroxwlrqv,## wkdq## zkdw## vhhpv## dssduhqw# lqlwldoo|/## dqg## d## uhvwuxfwxulqj## ri## lqfhqwlyhv## vxfk## wkdw## doo## sod|huv## zrun## wrjhwkhu# udwkhu#wkdq#dw#furvv0sxusrvhv1# # # #
Lpsurylqj#wkh#Txdolw|#ri#Kxpdq#Fdslwdo # # # # # # Kxpdq## fdslwdo/## dv## ghvfulehg## lq## fkdswhu## 4/## uhihuv## wr## wkh## eurdg## vhw## ri# fdsdelolwlhv/## lqfoxglqj## khdowk/## nqrzohgjh## dqg## lqwhooljhqfh/## dwwlwxgh/## vrfldo# dswlwxgh/## dqg## hpsdwk|/## wkdw## pdnh## d## shuvrq## d## surgxfwlyh## phpehu## ri## vrflhw|1# Vfkrrov#dqg#xqlyhuvlwlhv#sod|#d#sduw/#dv#gr#idplolhv#dqg#frppxqlwlhv=#lw#grhv#wdnh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # d#yloodjh#wr#fuhdwh#wkh#ydoxhv#dqg#dwwlwxghv#wkdw#doorz#fkloguhq#wr#jhw#wkh#prvw#rxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkhlu## hgxfdwlrq$## Dqg## rqfh## lqglylgxdov## frpsohwh## wkhlu## irupdo## hgxfdwlrq/# hpsor|huv#sod|#dq#lpsruwdqw#uroh#lq#wudlqlqj#wkhp#ixuwkhu#dqg#hqfrxudjlqj#wkhp#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # frqwlqxh## exloglqj#wkhlu# # # kxpdq#fdslwdo# # # rq#wkh# # # mre1## Vxfk#rq0wkh0mre# # # ghyhorsphqw# zloo## ehfrph## pruh## lpsruwdqw## dv## wkh## ohqjwk## ri## rxu## zrunlqj## olih## lqfuhdvhv=## wkh# w|slfdo## nqrzohgjh## zrunhu## pd|#qrz# # # zrun#iru# # # qhduo|#kdoi#d# # # # fhqwxu|#diwhu# # # irupdo# hgxfdwlrq## hqgv1## Lq## zkdw## iroorzv/## L## ghvfuleh## vrph## ri## wkh## lpsruwdqw## zd|v## wkh# 6# txdolw|#ri#kxpdq#fdslwdo#fdq#eh#lpsuryhg#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1 # # # # # # # # # #
Glvdgydqwdjhv#Ehjlq#Hduo|# # # # Wkh#irxqgdwlrq#iru#vxffhvv#lq#olih#lv#odlg#hduo|1#Zh#fdqqrw#gr#dq|wklqj#derxw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## jhqhv## d## fklog## lv## hqgrzhg## zlwk/## exw#qxwulwlrq#gxulqj#suhjqdqf|#dqg# # # # # # lq#hduo|# # fklogkrrg#pdnhv#dq#hqruprxv#gliihuhqfh#wr#d#fklogᄊv#lqwhooljhqfh#dqg#khdowk#odwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#olih1# # # Srru## qxwulwlrq#lq#d# # # # fklogᄊv## hduo|#|hduv# # # vhhpv## wr## eh## dvvrfldwhg## zlwk#wkh# # hduo|#rqvhw#ri#wkh#ghjhqhudwlyh#glvhdvhv#ri#rog#djh#vxfk#dv#frurqdu|#khduw#glvhdvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## gldehwhv17## Srru## kdelwv## ri#h{shfwdqw#prwkhuv/# # # # vxfk#dv# # # gulqnlqj#dqg# # # vprnlqj/# dovr## frqwulexwh## wr## wkh## orqj0whup## lpsdluphqw## ri## wkhlu## fkloguhqᄊv## khdowk1# Xqiruwxqdwho|/## ehfdxvh## wkhvh## sureohpv## duh## olnho|#wr# # # eh## pruh## vhyhuh## dprqj#wkh# # fkloguhq#ri#wkh#srru#dqg#wkh#srruo|#hgxfdwhg/#wkh|#shushwxdwh#wkh#f|foh#ri#sryhuw|1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Wr## euhdn#lw/# # # pruh## uhvrxufhv## kdyh## wr## eh## ghyrwhg## wr## yhu|#|rxqj#fkloguhq#lq#srru# # # # # idplolhv/#zkhwkhu#lq#wkh#irup#ri#qxwulwlrqdo#vxssohphqwv/#phglfdo#prqlwrulqj#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # wuhdwphqw/#ru#sduhqwdo#hgxfdwlrq1# # # # Hduo|#hgxfdwlrq#dovr#vhhpv#wr#pdwwhu#frqvlghudeo|1#E|#djh#hljkw/#lqwhooljhqfh/# # # # # # # # # # # 8# dv#phdvxuhg#e|#vwdqgdug#phwulfv/#vhhpv#suhww|#zhoo#vhw1 # # # # # # # # #Wkhuhiruh#lw#lv#fulwlfdoo|# # # # lpsruwdqw#wkdw#|rxqj#fkloguhq#kdyh#dffhvv#wr#txdolw|#shgdjrjlf#uhvrxufhv1#Vwxglhv# # # # # # # # # # # vkrz#wkdw#hduo|#fklogkrrg#ohduqlqj#surjudpv#whqg#wr#uhgxfh#wkh#olnholkrrg#wkdw#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # fklog## zloo## gurs## rxw## ri## kljk## vfkrro/## lqfuhdvh## wkh## olnholkrrg## wkdw## wkh## fklog## zloo# hquroo## lq#froohjh/# # # dqg## lqfuhdvh## hduqlqjv19## Wkh|#dovr# # # pdnh## lw#ohvv# # # olnho|#wkdw#wkh# # # fklog#zloo#ehfrph#gholqtxhqw/#d#fulplqdo/#d#guxj#dgglfw/#ru#d#whhqdjh#prwkhu1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Dowkrxjk## hydoxdwlrqv## ri## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## Khdg## Vwduw## surjudpᄇd## qdwlrqdo# surjudp#wkdw#surprwhv#vfkrro#uhdglqhvv#e|#hqkdqflqj#fklog#ghyhorsphqw#wkurxjk# # # # # # # # # # wkh## surylvlrq#ri#hgxfdwlrqdo/#khdowk/#qxwulwlrqdo/#vrfldo/#dqg#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # vhuylfhvᄇduh# vwloo## pl{hg/## lw## lv## kdug## wr## eholhyh## wkdw## pruh## dwwhqwlrq## wr## fuhdwlqj## jrrg## gd|0fduh# fhqwhuv## dqg## suhvfkrro## surjudpv## iru## srru## fkloguhq/## ixqghg## e|## jryhuqphqw# uhvrxufhv/#zlwk#vfrsh#iru#orfdo#h{shulphqwdwlrq#dqg#uhjxodu#hydoxdwlrq/#zloo#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # surgxfh## ehqhilwv1## Ph{lfr## kdv## kdg## wuhphqgrxv## vxffhvv## lq## hqfrxudjlqj## srru# sduhqwv#wr#sd|#pruh#dwwhqwlrq#wr#wkhlu#fkloguhqᄊv#qxwulwlrq/#khdowk/#dqg#hgxfdwlrq#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # #
pdnlqj## zhoiduh## sd|phqwv## frqglwlrqdo## rq## sduhqwv## phhwlqj## fhuwdlq## plohvwrqhv1:# Vlplodu## frqglwlrqdo## fdvk#wudqvihuv# # # duh#ehlqj#wulhg#e|#Pd|ru# # # # # # Eorrpehuj#lq#Qhz# # # \run#xvlqj#grqdwhg# # # # ixqgv/## dqg## dowkrxjk#lw# # # lv## wrr## hduo|#wr# # # whoo## zkhwkhu## wkh|#duh# # hiihfwlyh/## wkh## vxffhvv## ri#vlplodu# # # surjudpv## durxqg## wkh## zruog## vxjjhvwv## wkdw#pruh# # h{shulphqwdwlrq#lv#zduudqwhg1# # # Idplo|#pdwwhuv1#Dv#idu#edfn#dv#4<99/#wkh#lqioxhqwldo#Frohpdq#uhsruw#frqfoxghg# # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#idplo|#edfnjurxqg# # # # zdv## d## juhdwhu## lqioxhqfh## rq#vfkrro# # # dfklhyhphqw#wkdq#dq|# # # phdvxuh## ri## wkh## vfkrro## hqylurqphqw/## lqfoxglqj## vfkrro## glvwulfwvᄊ## shu0vwxghqw# h{shqglwxuhv1;## Qrw## rqo|#duh# # # wkh## lqfrphv## ri## wkh## sduhqwv## lpsruwdqw/## exw## vr## lv## wkh# uhodwlrqvkls#ehwzhhq#wkhp/#dv# # # # # lw#lqioxhqfhv# # # wkh#idplo|ᄊv# # # dffhvv## wr#uhvrxufhv# # # dqg# wkh#nlqg#ri#hqylurqphqw#lw#surylghv1#Ehlqj#eruq#wr#whhqdjh#sduhqwv/#ru#jurzlqj#xs# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwk#rqh# # # ru## erwk#sduhqwv# # # devhqw/#whqgv# # # wr#eh# # # ghwulphqwdo## wr#d# # # fklogᄊv## fkdqfhv## ri# vxffhvv/## dv## lv## glyrufh1## Djdlq/## wkhvh## sureohpv## whqg## wr## eh## pruh## frpprq#dprqj# # srruhu#idplolhv1#Dowkrxjk#wkh#jryhuqphqw#kdv#rqo|#d#olplwhg#uroh/#li#dq|/#wr#sod|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#vwuhqjwkhqlqj#idplolhv#+wkrxjk#lw#fhuwdlqo|#vkrxog#qrw#wd{#pduulhg#frxsohv#pruh/# # # # # # # # # # # # dv#lw#grhv#qrz,/#juhdwhu#frppxqlw|#uhfrjqlwlrq#ri#wkh#kdup#grqh#wr#wkh#fkloguhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|#whhqdjh# # # suhjqdqflhv/## devhqwhh## sduhqwv/## dqg## eurnhq#pduuldjhv# # # fdq#eh# # # d## irufh# iru#fkdqjh1# # Pruh#jhqhudoo|/#dv#wkh#Qreho#odxuhdwh#Mdphv#Khfnpdq#iurp#wkh#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # Fklfdjr#kdv#dujxhg/#pdq|#ri#wkh#gliihuhqfhv#ehwzhhq#fkloguhq#duh#vhw#dw#dq#hduo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwdjh=#prvw#ri#wkh#jdsv#lq#delolwlhv#revhuyhg#dw#djh#hljkwhhq#duh#douhdg|#suhvhqw#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # <# djh#ilyh1 # # Ixuwkhupruh/#d#fklog#lv#prvw#pdoohdeoh#zkhq#|rxqj=#lw#ehfrphv#pxfk# # # # # # # # # # # kdughu## dqg#frvwolhu# # # wr#dowhu# # # delolwlhv## dqg#ehkdylru# # # dv## wkh## fklog#jhwv# # # roghu1#Hduo|# # lqwhuyhqwlrq#lv#lpsruwdqw#iru#fkdqjlqj#rxwfrphv#vxffhvvixoo|1# # # # # # #
Qrqfrjqlwlyh#Vnloov# # # Lqwhuyhqwlrqv## duh## qrw## mxvw## derxw## lpsurylqj## wkh## fklogᄊv## ohduqlqj## delolwlhv1# Vxffhvv## lq## vfkrro/## dv## lq## zrun## olih/## ghshqgv## vljqlilfdqwo|## rq## qrqfrjqlwlyh# delolwlhv/## vxfk## dv## shuvhyhudqfh/## ghwhuplqdwlrq/## dqg## vhoi0glvflsolqh143## Dqg# zkhuhdv## frjqlwlyh## delolwlhv## duh## uhodwlyho|#il{hg# # # hduo|#rq/# # # qrqfrjqlwlyh## delolwlhv# fdq#eh#fkdqjhg#iru#frqvlghudeo|#orqjhu1# # # # # # Jrrg## vfkrrov## lqfxofdwh## ydoxhv## wkdw## vhuyh## vwxghqwv## zhoo## lq## odwhu## olih1## Sdvw# vwxglhv## kdyh## vkrzq## wkdw## vwxghqwv## iurp#Fdwkrolf# # # vfkrrov## whqg## wr## gr## ehwwhu## wkdq# vwxghqwv## iurp## lqqhu0flw|## sxeolf## vfkrrov/## shukdsv## ehfdxvh## wkh|## surgxfh## pruh# glvflsolqhg## dqg## prwlydwhg## vwxghqwv144## Vxevwdqwldo## lpsuryhphqwv## wr## lqqhu0flw|# vwxghqw#shuirupdqfh#vhhp#wr#kdyh#ehhq#eurxjkw#derxw#e|#ᄈsdwhuqdolvwlfᄡ#vfkrrov# # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#lqvlvw#rq#glvflsolqh=#vwxghqwv#zdon#lq#dq#rughuo|#zd|#ehwzhhq#fodvvhv/#phhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # guhvv#frghv/#vlw#xs#vwudljkw#lq#fodvv/#gr#krphzrun/#xvh#vwdqgdug#Hqjolvk/#dqg#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # shqdol}hg## iru## wudqvjuhvvlrqv145## Wkhuh## lv/## krzhyhu/## olwwoh## v|vwhpdwlf## hylghqfh## rq# wkh## vxffhvv## ri## vxfk## vfkrrov/## wkh## nh|## lqjuhglhqwv## wkdw## pdnh## wkhp## zrun/## ru## wkh# hqylurqphqwv## lq## zklfk## wkh|## zrun## ehvw1## Qhyhuwkhohvv/## lw## vhhpv## d## uhdvrqdeoh# k|srwkhvlv## wkdw## erwk## wkh## ohduqlqj## hqylurqphqw## dqg## wkh## ohduqlqj## ri## qrqfrjqlwlyh# vnloov## frxog## eh## lpsuryhg## wkurxjk#dwwhpswv# # # wr## whdfk#ehkdylru# # # dv## zhoo## dv## lpsduw#
nqrzohgjh1# Dv## lpsruwdqw## dv## zkdw## kdsshqv## lq## vfkrrov## lv## zkdw## kdsshqv## rxwvlgh1# G|vixqfwlrqdo## idplolhv## dqg## frppxqlwlhv## pdnh## lw## pruh## gliilfxow## iru## d## fklog## wr# dftxluh## wkh## ydoxhv## wkdw## fdq## khos## wkhp## vxffhhg1## Diwhu0vfkrro## surjudpv## dqg# phqwrulqj#surjudpvᄇsdlulqj#vwxghqwv# # # # zlwk#vxffhvvixo# # # dqg## fdulqj#dgxowvᄇkdyh# # khoshg## uhphg|## vrph## ri## wkh## gdpdjh1## Vr## wrr## kdv## frppxqlw|## ohdghuvkls## dqg## d# vkduhg## vhqvh## ri#sduhqwdo# # # uhvsrqvlelolw|1## Dv## d## X1V1## vhqdwru## vshdnlqj#dw#wkh# # # # 5337# Ghprfudwlf## frqyhqwlrq/## Edudfn## Redpd## vdlg=## ᄈJr## lqwr## dq|## lqqhu0flw|# qhljkerukrrg#dqg#ironv#zloo#whoo#|rx#wkdw#jryhuqphqw#dorqh#fdqᄊw#whdfk#rxu#nlgv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ohduq>#wkh|#nqrz#wkdw#sduhqwv#kdyh#wr#whdfk/#wkdw#fkloguhq#fdqᄊw#dfklhyh#xqohvv#zh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 46## Wklv## nlqg## ri#sduhqwdo# udlvh#wkhlu# # # h{shfwdwlrqv#dqg#wxuq#rii#wkh#whohylvlrq#vhwv1ᄡ # # # # # # # dqg## frppxqlw|## uhvsrqvlelolw|## lv## qhhghg## wr## pdnh## ixoo## xvh## ri## dq|## jryhuqphqw# vxssruw1# Pruh## jhqhudoo|/## fduhixo## orqjlwxglqdo## vwxglhv## lq## Fklfdjr## vxjjhvw## wkdw## idlolqj# vfkrrov## fdq#eh# # # wudqviruphg## wkurxjk#froohfwlyh# # # hiiruw=## e|#ohdghuvkls# # # wkdw#fuhdwhv# # dq#hqylurqphqw#zkhuh# # # # wkh## idfxow|#zrun#zlwk#rqh# # # # # dqrwkhu## wr## fkdoohqjh## vwxghqwv/# zkhuh## wkh## idfxow|#wkhpvhoyhv# # # duh## hqfrxudjhg## wr## ghyhors## wkhlu## vnloov/## zkhuh## wkh# vfkrro#dqg#rwkhu#vrfldo#vhuylfh#rujdql}dwlrqv#zrun#wrjhwkhu#wr#dwwhpsw#wr#lpsuryh# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#vwxghqwᄊv#hqwluh#ohduqlqj#hqylurqphqw#dqg#qrw#mxvw#wkh#rqh#lq#vfkrro/#dqg#zkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 47# sduhqwv#dqg#wkh#frppxqlw|#duh#gudzq#lq#wr#vxssruw#wklv#hiiruw1 # # # # # # # # # #
Dprxqw#ri#Vfkrrolqj# # # # Vwxglhv## vxjjhvw## wkdw## vwxghqwv## iurp## orz## vrflrhfrqrplf## jurxsv## zkr## duh# hquroohg## lq#sxeolf# # # vfkrrov## pdnh## dv## pxfk#surjuhvv# # # rq#pdwk#dqg# # # # uhdglqj#h{dpv# # gxulqj## wkhlu## hohphqwdu|0vfkrro## |hduv## dv## fkloguhq## iurp## d## kljk## vrflrhfrqrplf# edfnjurxqg/#wkrxjk#wkh|#vwduw#dw#d#orzhu#ohyho#ehfdxvh#ri#glvdgydqwdjhv#lqkhulwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#hduo|#fklogkrrg1#Krzhyhu/#wkh#jds#lq#dfklhyhphqw#vfruhv#jurzv#ryhu#wlph/# # # # # # # # # # # # sulpdulo|#ehfdxvh#wkh#dfklhyhphqw#ohyhov#ri#fkloguhq#iurp#orz0lqfrph#idplolhv# # # # # # # # # # idoo## ru## vwdjqdwh## gxulqj#wkh# # # vxpphu/## zkloh## wkrvh## ri#fkloguhq#iurp#kljkhu0lqfrph# # # # 48##Wkh#ohduqlqj#hqylurqphqw#lq#idplolhv#gliihuv/#zlwk# idplolhv#frqwlqxh#wr#lqfuhdvh1 # # # # # # # # # fkloguhq## ri## kljk0lqfrph## sduhqwv## jurzlqj## xs## zlwk## hgxfdwlrqdo## jdphv/## errnv/# sulydwh#wxlwlrq/#dqg#vxpphu#surjudpv/#doo#ri#zklfk#frqwlqxh#wkhlu#ohduqlqj#rxwvlgh# # # # # # # # # # # # vfkrro1## Vrph## hfrqrplvwv## kdyh## wkhuhiruh## vxjjhvwhg## h{whqglqj## wkh## vfkrro## |hdu=# Mdsdqᄊv## vfkrro## |hdu## uxqv## derxw## 573## gd|v/## zkloh## wkh## vfkrro## |hdu## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg# 49##Rwkhuv#kdyh#vxjjhvwhg#riihulqj#yrxfkhuv#wr#srru#idplolhv#vr# Vwdwhv#lv#4;3#gd|v1 # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## wkh|## fdq## hquroo## wkhlu## fkloguhq## lq## vxpphu## surjudpv1## Erwk## dssurdfkhv## duh# zruwk#h{shulphqwlqj#zlwk1# # #
Txdolw|#ri#Whdfklqj# # # # Fohduo|/## wkh## txdolw|## ri## whdfklqj## dovr## diihfwv## d## fklogᄊv## hgxfdwlrqdo# h{shulhqfh14:## Prwlydwhg/## lqvslulqj/## nqrzohgjhdeoh## whdfkhuv## pdnh## dq## hqruprxv#
gliihuhqfh/#dv#pdq|#ri#xv#nqrz#iurp#h{shulhqfh1#Vr#grhv#fodvv#vl}h1# # # # # # # # # # # # Jhwwlqj#jrrg#whdfkhuv#vwduwv#zlwk#klulqj1#Zkhq#rwkhu#rssruwxqlwlhv#iru#zrphq# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#plqrulwlhv#zhuh#olplwhg/#pdq|#wdohqwhg#shrsoh#zhqw#lqwr#whdfklqj#ehfdxvh#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # zdv#d#uhvshfwdeoh#rffxsdwlrq#wkdw#zdv#rshq#wr#wkhp1#Dv#rssruwxqlwlhv#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh# jurxsv## kdyh## h{sdqghg/## lw## kdv## ehfrph## pruh## gliilfxow## wr## dwwudfw## wkh## wdohqwhg## lqwr# whdfklqj1## Sd|## kdv## wr## eh## rqh## frpsrqhqw## ri## d## pruh## dwwudfwlyh## sdfndjh1## Exw## sd|# lqfuhphqwv## vkrxog## eh## wlhg## wr## whdfkhu## shuirupdqfh## lq#dqg# # # rxwvlgh## wkh## fodvvurrp/# zklfk## vkrxog## eh## phdvxuhg## lq## sduw## e|## lpsuryhphqwv## lq## vwxghqw## shuirupdqfh1# Dgglwlrqdo## lqfuhphqwv#vkrxog#eh#jlyhq#wr#wkrvh#zkr#whdfk#gliilfxow#exw#uhtxluhg# # # # # # # # # # # vxemhfwv## vxfk## dv## pdwk## dqg## vflhqfh## dqg## wr## wkrvh## zkr## whdfk## lq## gliilfxow## vfkrro# hqylurqphqwv/## vxfk## dv## wkh## lqqhu## flwlhv1## Whdfkhu## xqlrqv## kdyh## uhvlvwhg## sd|# gliihuhqwldwlrq/#hvshfldoo|#rq#wkh#edvlv#ri#shuirupdqfh1#Krzhyhu/#wkh|#duh#vorzo|# # # # # # # # # # # ehfrplqj#pruh#dphqdeoh#wr#fkdqjh1# # # # # Dv## lpsruwdqw## dv## sd|## lv## d## fduhhu## sdwk## wkdw## pdnhv## ixoo## xvh## ri## d## whdfkhu#ᄊv# h{shulhqfh1## Rqo|## vrph## whdfkhuv## olnh/## ru## duh## vxlwhg## iru/## surprwlrq## wr## vfkrro# dgplqlvwudwlrq1#Rwkhuv#frxog#sod|#dq#lpsruwdqw#uroh#dv#phqwruv#wr#mxqlru#whdfkhuv/# # # # # # # # # # # # dv#pdvwhu#whdfkhuv#frqgxfwlqj#fodvvhv#lq#shgdjrj|/#ru#dv#vxemhfw0pdwwhu#h{shuwv1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkhvh#fduhhu#sdwkv#qhhg#wr#eh#pdgh#fohduhu#dqg#uhzdughg#dssursuldwho|1# # # # # # # # # # # Vxemhfw0pdwwhu## h{shuwlvh## lv## lpsruwdqw/## exw## L## dp## qrw## shuvxdghg## wkdw## whdfkhuv# qhhg#ghjuhhv#lq#krz#wr#whdfk1#Fhuwdlqo|/#pxfk#ri#p|#rzq#ohduqlqj#derxw#whdfklqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # +dgplwwhgo|#rqo|#xqlyhuvlw|#vwxghqwv,# # # # # kdv## frph## iurp#fodvvurrp#h{shulhqfh# # # # dqg# iurp## phqwrulqj## e|## rwkhu## froohdjxhv1## Uhtxlulqj## whdfkhuv## wr## krog## ghjuhhv## lq# hgxfdwlrq## ru## whdfklqj## whqgv## wr## vkulqn## wkh## srro## ri## fdqglgdwhv## iru## whdfklqj## mrev# vxevwdqwldoo|#dqg#olnho|#ghwhuv#pdq|#vxemhfw0pdwwhu#h{shuwv#zkr#zrxog#rwkhuzlvh# # # # # # # # # # ehfrph## whdfkhuv1## Lqvwhdg/## vfkrrov## vkrxog## fuhdwh## d## pruh## irupdo## v|vwhp## ri# phqwrulqj/## zlwk## vwdu## whdfkhuv## dgylvlqj## lqh{shulhqfhg## whdfkhuv## dqg## vkdulqj# h{shulhqfhv1## Ixuwkhupruh/## wkh## vfkrro## v|vwhp#vkrxog# # # ilqg## zd|v## wr## pdnh## xvh## ri# wkrvh#zkr#duh#kljko|#prwlydwhg#dqg#wdohqwhg#exw#duh#xqolnho|#wr#vhh#whdfklqj#dv#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # orqj0whup#fduhhu1#Erwk#wkh#|rxqj#froohjh#judgxdwh#zkr#zdqwv#wr#wu|#rxw#whdfklqj/# # # # # # # # # # # # # dv#lq#wkh#Whdfk#iru#Dphulfd#surjudp/#dqg#pruh#vhqlru#flwl}hqv/#zkr#zdqw#wr#jlyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # edfn#wr#wkh#frppxqlw|#lq#d#gliihuhqw#uroh/#vkrxog#eh#zhofrphg1# # # # # # # # # # # Vpdoo#fodvvhv#khos#wkh#ohduqlqj#h{shulhqfh#ehfdxvh#vwxghqwv#jhw#pruh#dwwhqwlrq1# # # # # # # # # # # Wklv## lv## hvshfldoo|## lpsruwdqw## lq## wkh## hduo|## |hduv/## zkhq## fkloguhq## qhhg## khos## lq# ghyhorslqj#irfxv#dqg#glvflsolqh1#Uhvrxufhv#zloo#eh#qhhghg#wr#uhgxfh#fodvv#vl}h1# # # # # # # # # # # # Uhvrxufhv#duh#dovr#qhhghg#iru#shgdjrjlf#dlgv/#lqfoxglqj#frpsxwhuv/#vr#wudgh0riiv# # # # # # # # # # # kdyh#wr#eh#pdgh#edvhg#rq#d#fduhixo#frvw0ehqhilw#dqdo|vlv1# # # # # # # # # # Rqh## zd|#iru# # # wkh## ehvw## whdfkhuv## wr## uhdfk#pruh# # # vwxghqwv## lv## wkurxjk#whfkqrorj|1# # Whfkqrorj|## fdq## khos## whdfkhuv## vkduh## h{shulhqfhv/## ohvvrq## sodqv/## dqg## krphzrun# txhvwlrqv1#L#dp#d#gluhfwru#ri#d#frpsdq|/#Kh|pdwk/#wkdw#lv#edvhg#lq#Fkhqqdl/#Lqgld/# ## # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#rshudwhv#lq#wkuhh#frqwlqhqwv1#Wkh#frpsdq|#khosv#whdfkhuv#zlwk#wkh#wrrov#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # whpsodwhv## qhhghg## wr## fuhdwh## pdwk## ohvvrqv## dqg## krphzrun/## dv## zhoo## dv## zlwk## wkh# dvvhvvphqw## surfhvv1## Lw## fuhdwhv## d## frppxqlw|#lq#zklfk#pdwk#whdfkhuv# # # # # # durxqg## wkh# zruog## vkduh## ehvw## sudfwlfhv1## Kh|pdwk## dovr## riihuv## vwxghqwv## dvvlvwdqfh## zlwk# sureohpv/## wr## wkh## h{whqw## shuplwwhg## e|## wkh## whdfkhu1## Whfkqrorj|## fdq## wkxv## khos# xsjudgh#wkh#txdolw|#ri#whdfklqj#zlwk#uhodwlyho|#vpdoo#lqyhvwphqwv1# # # # # # # # # Vfkrrov## dovr## qhhg## d## v|vwhp#ri#dffrxqwdelolw|1# # # # D#qdwlrqdo# # # vwdqgdug## ri#vwxghqw# #
dfklhyhphqw/## frxsohg## zlwk## whvwlqj## dw## uhjxodu## lqwhuydov## wr## phdvxuh## shuirupdqfh# djdlqvw#wkrvh#vwdqgdugv/#lv#nh|#wr#dffrxqwdelolw|1#Ehfdxvh#vfkrrov#wdnh#lq#vwxghqwv# # # # # # # # # # # # dw#gliihuhqw#ohyhov# # # # ri#suhsdudwlrq#dqg# # # # fdsdelolw|/## shuirupdqfh## dvvhvvphqwv## pxvw# wdnh## lqwr## dffrxqw#wkh# # # txdolw|#ri#wkh# # # # lqwdnh=## khqfh## shuirupdqfh## lpsuryhphqwv## dv# zhoo## dv## devroxwh## shuirupdqfh## ohyhov## vkrxog## eh## phdvxuhg1## Zh## dovr## qhhg## wr## ilqg# zd|v## ri## sxeolfl}lqj## vfkrro0shuirupdqfh## dvvhvvphqwv## lq## d## pdqqhu## wkdw## lv## erwk# frpsdudeoh## dfurvv## vfkrrov## dqg## hdvlo|## xqghuvwrrg## e|## sduhqwv1## Idlolqj## vfkrrov# qhhg## wr## eh## jlyhq#lqlwldo# # # vxssruw#wr# # # lpsuryh/## exw#qrw#pxowlsoh# # # # fkdqfhv## wr## gr## vr1# Wkh## Qr## Fklog## Ohiw#Ehklqg# # # Dfw#ri#5335# # # # jrhv## vrph## zd|#wrzdug# # # wkhvh## jrdov## exw# qhhgv#wr#eh#vwuhqjwkhqhg1# # # # Ilqdoo|/## sduhqwdo## fkrlfh## fdq## khos## eulqj## wkh## glvflsolqh## ri## frpshwlwlrq## wr# vfkrrov1#Vfkrro#yrxfkhu#surjudpv/#li#surshuo|#dgplqlvwhuhg/#fdq#doorz# # # # # # # # # # vwxghqwv# wr#yrwh#zlwk#wkhlu#ihhw#dqg#suhyhqw#idlolqj#vfkrrov#iurp#kroglqj#wdohqwhg#exw#srru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwxghqwv#krvwdjh1#Fkduwhu# # # # vfkrrov#fdq#dovr#khos1#Wkhvh#duh#txdvl0sxeolf#vfkrrov# # # # # # # # wkdw#kdyh#pruh#iuhhgrp#iurp#uhjxodwlrq#wkdq#sxeolf#vfkrrov#lq#uhwxuq#iru#juhdwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # dffrxqwdelolw|1#Wkh|#rewdlq#wxlwlrq#sd|phqwv#iurp#vfkrro#glvwulfwv#lq#sursruwlrq#wr# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#vwxghqwv#wkh|#dwwudfw#iurp#wkhp1#Hylghqfh#vxjjhvwv#wkdw#vxfk#vfkrrov#fdq#ohdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## vxevwdqwldo## shuirupdqfh## lpsuryhphqw/## hvshfldoo|## uhodwlyh## wr## sxeolf## vfkrrov# 4;# wkdw#idfh#olwwoh#ulvn#ri#forvxuh1 # # # # # Wkh## srruhvw0shuiruplqj## sxeolf## vfkrrov## fohduo|## qhhg## pruh## wlph## wr## fkdqjh/# vlqfh## wkh## sureohpv## lq#wkh# # # vfkrro## dqg## wkh## frppxqlw|#duh# # # ghhshu1## Rujdql}dwlrqdo# fdslwdo## dqg## frppxqlw|## lqyroyhphqw## qhhg## wr## eh## exlow## xs## +pxfk## dv## lq## wkh# ghyhorslqj## hfrqrplhv,1## Li## hyhu|rqh## wklqnv## wkh## vfkrro## lv## olnho|## wr## eh## forvhg/# froohfwlyh## dfwlrq#lv# # # xqolnho|1## Wkhuhiruh/## d## shulrg## lq#zklfk#uhvrxufhv# # # # duh## pdgh# dydlodeoh/## fkdqjh## lv## hqfrxudjhg/## dqg## wkh## wkuhdw## ri## forvxuh## lv## khog## lq## deh|dqfh# pd|## eh## qhfhvvdu|1## Exw## li## wkhuh## lv## qr## uhtxluhphqw## iru## lpsuryhphqwv## lq# shuirupdqfh## dw## wkh## hqg## ri## wkh## shulrg/## dqg## d## shupdqhqw## jxdudqwhh## ri## d## txlhw# xqfrpshwlwlyh#olih/#lw#zloo#eh#htxdoo|#kdug#wr#holflw#froohfwlyh#hiiruw1#Dv#zlwk#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghyhorslqj#hfrqrplhv/#d#frpelqdwlrq#ri#lqlwldo#qxuwxulqj#dqg#surwhfwlrq#iroorzhg# # # # # # # # # # e|#frpshwlwlrq#pd|#zrun#zhoo1# # # # # Wkh## Redpd## dgplqlvwudwlrq## kdv## odlg## rxw## d## sdwk## iru## hgxfdwlrqdo## uhirup## wkdw# lqyroyhv#d#pruh#ghwdlohg#phwkrg#ri#hydoxdwlqj#vfkrrov#wkdq#wkh#sdvv0idlo#v|vwhp# # # # # # # # # # # # ri## wkh## Qr## Fklog## Ohiw## Ehklqg## Dfw1## Lw## sursrvhv## qdwlrqzlgh## whvwlqj## vwdqgdugv/# hydoxdwlrq#ri#whdfkhuv# # # # edvhg#rq#vwxghqw#whvw#shuirupdqfh/#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # hqwu|#ri#pruh# # # fkduwhu## vfkrrov/## xvlqj## wkh## ohyhu## ri## dgglwlrqdo## fdvk## iru## vwdwhv## dqg## glvwulfwv## wkdw# dgrsw## uhirupv14<## Wkhvh## duh## lpsruwdqw## dqg## xvhixo## lghdv## dqg/## li## lpsohphqwhg/# zrxog#eh#d#pdmru#vwhs#iruzdug#lq#lpsurylqj#hgxfdwlrq1#Zh#vkrxog#qrw/#krzhyhu/# # # # # # # # # # # # # xqghuhvwlpdwh#wkh#uhvlvwdqfh#wr#frpprq#vwdqgdugv/#wudqvsduhqf|#rq#shuirupdqfh/# # # # # # # # # dqg## vwxghqw## fkrlfh## iurp#idlolqj# # # vfkrrov## dqg## xqghushuiruplqj## whdfkhuv/## hyhq## li# wkhvh## frqvwlwxwh## wkh## plqrulw|ᄇwkh## dwwudfwlrqv## ri## d## txlhw## olih## duh## lpphqvh## dqg# zruwk#iljkwlqj#iru1# # #
Khos#iru#dqg#lq#Froohjh# # # # # # Rqo|#67#shufhqw#ri#|rxwkv#iurp#krxvhkrogv#lq#wkh#erwwrp#txlqwloh#ri#lqfrph # # # # # # # # # # # #
glvwulexwlrq#hquroo#lq#froohjh/#zkhuhdv#:<#shufhqw#ri#wkrvh#iurp#krxvhkrogv#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wrs## txlqwloh## ri#idplo|#lqfrph# # # # gr## vr153## Pruhryhu/## rqo|#44# # # shufhqw#ri#|rxqjvwhuv# # # iurp#wkh# # # erwwrp#txlqwloh# # # judgxdwh/## zkhuhdv## 86## shufhqw#iurp#wkh# # # # wrs## gr## vr1## Wkh# gursrxw#udwh#lv#wkxv#dovr#glvsursruwlrqdwho|#kljk#dprqj#wkh#srru1# # # # # # # # # # Fohduo|/#wkh#frjqlwlyh#dqg#qrqfrjqlwlyh#vnloov#dftxluhg#hduolhu#duh#d#vljqlilfdqw# # # # # # # # # # # vrxufh## ri#vxfk#gliihuhqfhv/# # # # dqg## L#glvfxvv# # # srwhqwldo## uhphglhv## deryh1## Lq#dgglwlrq# # wkrxjk/#surjudpv#frxog#khos#pdnh#lw#hdvlhu#iru#glvdgydqwdjhg#|rxwk#wr#dsso|#wr/# # # # # # # # # # # # # sd|#iru/#vwd|#lq/#dqg#vxffhhg#lq#froohjh1# # # # # # # # Vwxghqwv## iurp## ehwwhu## vrflrhfrqrplf## edfnjurxqgv## kdyh## dffhvv## wr## vljqlilfdqw# uhvrxufhv#wr#dlg#wkh#froohjh#dssolfdwlrq#surfhvv/#lqfoxglqj#vfkrro#frxqvhoruv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # uhodwlyhv#zkr#kdyh#ehhq#wr#froohjh1#Vwxghqwv#iurp#glvdgydqwdjhg#edfnjurxqgv#gr# # # # # # # # # # # qrw1## Dowkrxjk## d## qxpehu## ri## uhphgldo## jryhuqphqw## surjudpv## h{lvw/## wkhlu# hiihfwlyhqhvv## lv## txhvwlrqdeoh154## Uhfhqwo|/## d## qxpehu## ri## surjudpv## kdyh## ehhq# hvwdeolvkhg## wkdw## olqn## vwxghqwv## zlwk## d## glvdgydqwdjhg## edfnjurxqg## zlwk# xqghujudgxdwh## vwxghqwv## zkr#kdyh# # # uhfhqw#h{shulhqfh# # # zlwk#froohjh# # # dssolfdwlrqv155# Wkhvh#ghvhuyh#ixuwkhu#vwxg|#dqg#h{sdqvlrq#li#zruwkzkloh1# # # # # # # # Ilqdqfldo## dlg## fdq#dovr# # # khos1## Vwxglhv## vxjjhvw#wkdw#'4/333# # # # ri#vxevlg|#lqfuhdvhv# # # froohjh## dwwhqgdqfh## udwhv## e|## urxjko|## 7## shufhqwdjh## srlqwv/## lpsuryhv## judgxdwlrq# udwhv/## dqg## vkliwv## vwxghqwv## iurp## fkrrvlqj## frppxqlw|## froohjhv## wrzdug## fkrrvlqj# 56## D#vxevwdqwldo#qxpehu#ri#froohjh#dlg#surjudpv#duh#douhdg|#lq# irxu0|hdu#vfkrrov1 # # # # # # # # # # sodfh1## Wkh## nh|## wr## wkhlu## hiihfwlyhqhvv## lv## wr## wdujhw## dlg## wr## wkrvh## zkr## zrxog## qrw# rwkhuzlvh## jr## wr## froohjh/## wr## pdnh## wkh## dlg## dssolfdwlrq#surfhvv# # # vlpsohᄇfxuuhqwo|# wkhuh#duh#d#pxowlsolflw|#ri#surjudpv/#pdq|#srruo|#dgyhuwlvhg#dqg#hdfk#uhtxlulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # gliihuhqw#dssolfdwlrqv/#doo#ri#zklfk#srvh#sduwlfxodu#gliilfxowlhv#iru#srru#fkloguhq# # # # # # # # # # # zlwkrxw## Lqwhuqhw## dffhvv## ru## sulqwhuvᄇdqg## wr## pdnh## wkh## frqwlqxdwlrq## ri## dlg# 57# frqwlqjhqw#rq#vwxghqw#shuirupdqfh1 # # #
Mre#Dssuhqwlfhvkls#dqg#Wudlqlqj# # # # # Kxpdq#fdslwdo#fdq#dovr#eh#exlow#wkurxjk#rq0wkh0mre#wudlqlqj1#Dssuhqwlfhvklsv/# # # # # # # # # # hvshfldoo|#lq#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru/#fdq#eh#lpsruwdqw#lq#lqfxofdwlqj#zrun#kdelwv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehkdylru## wkdw## fdq## khos## glvdgydqwdjhg## |rxwkv## krog## d## vwhdg|## mre1## Ehfdxvh## X1V1# zrunhuv#whqg#wr#fkdqjh#mrev#d#qxpehu#ri#wlphv#lq#wkhlu#fduhhuv/#ilupv#zloo#kdyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh#jlyhq#lqfhqwlyhv#wr#riihu#wkhvh#dssuhqwlfhvklsv#wr#frpshqvdwh#iru#wkh#idfwv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#duh#xqolnho|#wr#nhhs#dq#dssuhqwlfh#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq#dqg#wkdw#vxfk#dssuhqwlfhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo#uhtxluh#d#idlu#dprxqw#ri#khos#dqg#vxshuylvlrq1# # # # # # # # #
Ghwhuplqlqj#Zkdw#Zrunv# # # # Pdq|#jrrg# # # lghdv## kdyh## ehhq/## dqg## duh## ehlqj/## sursrvhg## iru## lpsurylqj#kxpdq# # fdslwdo#iru#wkh#glvdgydqwdjhg1#Krzhyhu/#lghdv#wkdw#pdnh#vhqvh#rq#sdshu#riwhq#gr# # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## vhhp#wr# # # zrun#lq#sudfwlfh1# # # # Dowkrxjk#zh# # # vkrxog## wu|#lghdv# # # wkdw## hylghqfh## dqg#
frpprq#vhqvh#vxjjhvw#vwdqg#d#jrrg#fkdqfh#ri#vxffhvv/#lghdoo|/#surjudpv#vkrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # dovr## eh## vxemhfw## wr## shulrglf## hydoxdwlrq1## Wkhvh## hydoxdwlrqv## zloo## khos## lghqwli|# lqhiihfwlyh#surjudpv/#dv#zhoo# # # # # dv#prglilfdwlrqv#wkdw#frxog#pdnh#d#surjudp#zrun# # # # # # # # ehwwhu1# Dv## wkh## txdolw|## ri## wkh## kxpdq## fdslwdo## ri## wkh## glvdgydqwdjhg## lpsuryhv/## zdjh# lqhtxdolw|## vkrxog## glplqlvk1## Wkhuh## lv## qr## fhuwdlqw|/## krzhyhu/## derxw## zkhwkhu## dq|# lqwhuyhqwlrqv#zloo#eh#lpsohphqwhg/#zkhwkhu#wkh|#zloo#zrun/#dqg/#li#wkh|#gr/#krz# # # # # # # # # # # # # pxfk#wlph#wkh|#zloo#wdnh1#Wkhuh#frxog#zhoo#eh#srolwlfdo#suhvvxuh#iurp#wkrvh#zkr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh#idoohq#ehklqg#wr#uhglvwulexwh/#hlwkhu#gluhfwo|#ru#e|#wkh#h{whqvlrq#ri#pruh#hdv|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhglw1#Frxqwhuydlolqj#suhvvxuh#zloo#frph#iurp#wkrvh#zkr#kdyh#wr#sd|#wkh#kljkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wd{hv#ru#zkr#gr#qrw#eholhyh#lq#lqfrph#uhglvwulexwlrq1#Srolwlfdo#vwulih#frxog#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # frqwlqxh## dw## dq#hohydwhg# # # ohyho## iru## d## zkloh1## Zh## pxvw## krsh/## krzhyhu/## wkdw## dv## wkh# glvdgydqwdjhg#vhh#wkh#odgghu#ri#surjudpv#wkdw#zloo#khos#wkhlu#fkloguhq#folpe#wr#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehwwhu## ixwxuh/## wkh## survshfwlyh## uhglvwulexwlrq## ri## rssruwxqlwlhv## zloo## khdg## rii# srwhqwldo#frqiolfw#dqg#wkh#dvvrfldwhg#frvwv#wr#jurzwk1# # # # # # # #
Vhfxulw|#dqg#wkh#Vdihw|#Qhw # # # # # Dv#L#dujxh#lq#fkdswhu#7#dqg#fkdswhu#8/#wkh#devhqfh#ri#d#vxiilflhqw#vdihw|#qhw#wr# ## # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxssruw## zrunhuv## zkr## orvh## mrev## lq## d## surorqjhg## grzqwxuq## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# lqfuhdvhv## sxeolf## dq{lhw|#dqg# # # whqgv## wr## jhqhudwh## d## glvsursruwlrqdwh## prqhwdu|#dqg# # ilvfdo## uhvsrqvh1## Wkh## uhphg|## lv## wr## lpsuryh## zrunhuvᄊ## uhvlolhqfh## wr## hfrqrplf# dgyhuvlw|1## Wklv## lvvxh## lv## qrw## xquhodwhg## wr## wkdw## ri## lqhtxdolw|1## Orz## lqfrphv## jlyh# shrsoh#olwwoh#pdujlq#ri#vdihw|#ru#wkh#delolw|#wr#vdyh#hqrxjk#wr#wlgh#wkhpvhoyhv#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # d#shulrg#ri#xqhpsor|phqw1# # # # Lq#vhdufklqj#iru#uhphglhv/#zh#vkrxog#uhfrjql}h#wkdw#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#ilupv#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hpsor|phqw## uhodwlrqvkls## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## zklfk## hpskdvl}h## ioh{lelolw|## dqg# prelolw|/#pd|#qrw#vlw#zhoo#zlwk#wkh#nlqg#ri#orqj0gxudwlrq#vdihw|#qhwv#dydlodeoh#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frqwlqhqwdo#Hxursh1#Lq#zkdw#iroorzv/#L#h{dplqh#wkh#eurdg#fkdqjhv#wkdw#frxog#pdnh# # # # # ## # # # # # # wkh## X1V1## zrunhu## pruh## uhvlolhqw#lq#grzqwxuqv# # # # zkloh## suhvhuylqj#ioh{lelolw|#lq#wkh# # # # v|vwhp1#
Frqwlqjhqw#exw#Suhghwhuplqhg#Xqhpsor|phqw#Lqvxudqfh# # # # # # Wkh## fxuuhqw## xqhpsor|phqw## vdihw|## qhw## +eh|rqg## wkh## plqlpxp## lq## sodfh,## lv## d# frqwlqjhqw#rqh#zkhuhe|#srolwlfldqv#uhvsrqg#wr#surorqjhg/#pdvvlyh#xqhpsor|phqw# # # # # # # # # e|#whpsrudulo|#h{whqglqj#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv1#Zrunhuv#h{shulhqfh#wuhphqgrxv# # # # # # # # xqfhuwdlqw|#ryhu#zkhwkhu#ehqhilwv#zloo#eh#h{whqghg#dqg#wkh#fulwhuld#iru#uhfhlylqj# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp1#Pruhryhu/#srolwlfldqv#h{sorlw#wkh#sxeolf#ghpdqg#iru#dfwlrq#wr#sxvk#wkurxjk# # # # # # # # # # # # doo## pdqqhu## ri#shw# # # surmhfwv## zlwkrxw## pxfk#vfuxwlq|#xqghu# # # # wkh## jxlvh## ri#hphujhqf|# # ohjlvodwlrq1# Li#X1V1#uhfryhulhv#kdyh#lqghhg#fkdqjhg#lq#qdwxuh#dqg#ehfrph#pruh#mreohvv/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#zruwk#ghedwlqj#zkhwkhu#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv#qhhg#wr#eh#h{whqghg#rq#d#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # shupdqhqw#edvlv1#Orqjhu0gxudwlrq#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv#qrw#rqo|#hqwdlo#frvwv#exw# # # # # # # # # # dovr#pdnh#vrph#ri#wkh#xqhpsor|hg#ohvv#dq{lrxv#wr#ilqg#mrev1#D#ohvv#uhvsrqvlyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # oderu## pdunhw## pd|#dowhu# # # wkh## qdwxuh## ri#wkh# # # hpsor|phqw## uhodwlrqvkls## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv#dv#zhoo# # # # dv#wkh#hdvh#zlwk#zklfk#ilupv#fdq#wdnh#xs#qhz# # # # # # # # # # # rssruwxqlwlhv1#Wkh# # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#pd|#zdqw#wr#jlyh#xs#vrph#frusrudwh#ioh{lelolw|#iru#juhdwhu#zrunhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # vhfxulw|/## exw## wkdw## ghflvlrq/## ehfdxvh## ri#lwv# # # orqj0whup#udplilfdwlrqv/# # # fdq#eh# # # pruh# iuxlwixoo|#dgguhvvhg# # # rqfh## zh## kdyh## d## ehwwhu## dqdo|vlv## ri#zkhwkhu# # # uhfryhulhv## kdyh# lqghhg#fkdqjhg/#dqg/#li#vr/#zk|1# # # # # # Wkhuh## duh/## krzhyhu/## wzr## uhirupv## ri#zklfk#wkh# # # # qhw#ehqhilwv# # # duh## fohduhu1## Iluvw/# wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zrxog## ehqhilw## iurp## suhghwhuplqhg/## frqwlqjhqw## h{whqvlrqv## ri# xqhpsor|phqw## lqvxudqfh1## Lq## rwkhu## zrugv/## lqvwhdg## ri## h{whqglqj## xqhpsor|phqw# ehqhilwv#rq#dq#dg#krf#edvlv#dffruglqj#wr#wkh#srolwlfv#ri#wkh#prphqw/#wkh#ghflvlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frxog## eh## wlhg## wr## d## irupxod1## Wkh## irupxod## frxog## eh## vrph## vlpsoh## ixqfwlrq#ri# # # wkh# h{whqw#ri#ryhudoo#mre#orvvhv#+dv#douhdg|#riihuhg#e|#vrph#vwdwhv,/#wkh#sursruwlrq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # mrev## fuhdwhg#wr#mrev# # # # orvw/#dqg#wkh#wlph#hodsvhg#vlqfh#wkh#uhfhvvlrq#ehjdq1#Pruh# # # # # # # # # # frpsolfdwhg#irupxodv#frxog#wdnh#lqwr#dffrxqw#wkh#vhfwruv#zkhuh#mrev#duh#orvw#+duh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh#lqgxvwulhv#zkhuh#rxwsxw#whqgv#wr#eh#f|folfdo/#ru#gr#wkh#mre#orvvhv#lqglfdwh#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
pruh#shupdqhqw#wudqvirupdwlrqB,/#dv#zhoo#dv#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#mrev#fuhdwhg#+duh#wkhvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ixoo0wlph/## shupdqhqw## mrev## ru## sduw0wlph## dqg## whpsrudu|## rqhvB,1## Wkh## yluwxh## ri# nhhslqj#lw#vlpsoh#lv# # # # # wkdw#h{whqvlrqv# # # frxog#eh#hdvlhu# # # # iru## zrunhuv## wr#iruhfdvw#dqg# # # sodq#iru/#dqg#vxfk#iruhnqrzohgjh#lv#fhqwudo#wr#uhgxflqj#dq{lhw|1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## vhfrqg## duhd## uhtxlulqj## fkdqjh## lv## khdowk## fduh1## Pxfk## ri## wkh## dq{lhw|# vxuurxqglqj## xqhpsor|phqw## kdv## wr## gr## zlwk## hpsor|hhvᄊ## frqfhuqv## derxw## orvlqj# khdowk#lqvxudqfh#iru#wkhpvhoyhv#dqg#wkhlu#idplolhv1#Dv#L#zulwh/#Frqjuhvv#kdv#mxvw# # # # # # # # ## # # # sdvvhg#d#eloo#wr#fuhdwh#qhdu0xqlyhuvdo#khdowk#fduhᄇqhdu0xqlyhuvdo#ehfdxvh#loohjdo# # # # # # # # # # lppljudqwv#zloo#vwloo#eh#ohiw#xqfryhuhg#hyhq#zkhq#wkh#elooᄊv#surylvlrqv#duh#ixoo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsohphqwhg1#Wkh#sdvvdjh#ri#wkh#eloo# # # # # # # lv#mxvw#wkh#iluvw#vwhs#lq#d#orqj#dqg#dugxrxv# # # # # # # # # # surfhvv#wr#dfklhyh#hiihfwlyh#xqlyhuvdo#khdowk#lqvxudqfh1#Lqghhg/#zlwk#pdq|#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # surylvlrqv#ri#wkh#eloo#gxh#wr#eh#lpsohphqwhg#rqo|#|hduv#iurp#qrz/#zlwk#dwwhpswv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # e|## ydulrxv## vwdwh## ohjlvodwxuhv## wr## rsw## rxw## ri## wkh## surylvlrqv## ri## wkh## eloo/## dqg## zlwk# wkuhdwv## e|#frqvhuydwlyhv# # # wr## uhshdo## wkh## eloo## zkhq#wkh|#jdlq#srzhu/# # # # # wkhuh## lv## vrph# vpdoo#xqfhuwdlqw|#vwloo#derxw#zkhwkhu#hyhq#wkh#pdlq#ohjlvodwlyh#kxugohv#kdyh#ehhq# # # # # # # # # # # # ryhufrph1#Hyhq#li#wkh#ohjlvodwlrq#vxuylyhv#fkdoohqjhv/#hiihfwlyh#uhirup#zloo#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # wr#pdnh#vxuh#hyhu|rqh#lv#fryhuhg#hyhq#zkloh#vorzlqj#ru#hyhq#uhyhuvlqj#wkh#udwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#jurzwk#ri#khdowk#fduh# # # # # # frvwv1## Krzhyhu/## wkh## srolwlfdo## fdofxoxv/## dv## uhiohfwhg## lq# wklv#eloo/#lv#wr#hpskdvl}h#wkh#fohdu#dqg#lpphgldwh#ehqhilwv#ri#h{sdqghg#fryhudjh/# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkloh#surylglqj#ohvv#ghwdlo#derxw#frvwv#dqg#frqwurov1#Wkhuh#duh#pdq|#jrrg#lghdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq## wkh## eloo## +dqg## vrph## edg## rqhv,/## exw## rqo|## wlph## zloo## whoo## zklfk## lghdv## jdlq# prphqwxp1## Wkh## ghedwh## derxw#xqlyhuvdo# # # khdowk#fduh# # # dqg## khdowk#fduh# # # frvwv## lv## idu# iurp#vhwwohg/#dqg#lw#zloo#eh#zlwk#xv#iru#pdq|#|hduv#wr#frph>#khqfh#d#forvhu#orrn#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#nh|#lvvxhv#lv#xvhixo1# # # # #
Xqlyhuvdo#Khdowk#Fduh# # # # Wkhuh## lv## olwwoh## dsshwlwh## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## iru## d## udglfdo## ryhukdxo## ri## wkh# odujho|#sulydwh# # # khdowk#fduh# # # v|vwhp1## Wkh## nh|#wr# # # xqlyhuvdo## khdowk#fduh/# # # wkhq/## lv## wr# ghdo## zlwk## wkh## dgyhuvh0vhohfwlrq## sureohp1## Li## dq## lqvxudqfh## sodq## dwwudfwv## d# glvsursruwlrqdwh#qxpehu# # # ri#wkrvh#zlwk#suhh{lvwlqj#khdowk#sureohpv/#zklfk#pdnh# # # # # # # # wkhp#kljkhu# # # lqvxudqfh## ulvnv/## zkloh## dwwudfwlqj## wrr## ihz## ri## wkh## |rxqj## dqg## khdowk|# zkrvh## suhplxpv## duh## qhfhvvdu|## wr## vxevlgl}h## wkh## ohvv## khdowk|/## wkh## hfrqrplfv# vxssruwlqj#lqvxudqfh#euhdnv#grzq/#dqg#lw#ehfrphv#xqhfrqrplf1# # # # # # # # Jlyhq## wkdw## d## qxpehu## ri## wkh## |rxqj## dqg## khdowk|## suhihu## wr## vwd|## xqlqvxuhgᄇwkh# |rxqj#kdyh# # # d## vwurqj#dqg# # # plvsodfhg## vhqvh## ri#wkhlu# # # rzq#lppruwdolw|ᄇwkh# # # nh|#wr# # vxffhvvixo## xqlyhuvdo## lqvxudqfh/## lq#zklfk#qr# # # # sulydwh## sodq#fdq#uhixvh# # # # wkrvh## zlwk# suhh{lvwlqj#frqglwlrqv#dqg#suhplxpv#duh#nhsw#dw#d#uhdvrqdeoh#ohyho/#lv#wr#hqvxuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh#|rxqj#dqg#khdowk|#sd|#lq1#Lqfhqwlyhv#fdq#lqfoxgh#d#pl{#ri#fduurwvᄇvxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dv## uhedwhv## iru## qrw## pdnlqj#fodlpvᄇdqg# # # vwlfnvᄇshqdowlhv## iru## qrw## mrlqlqj1## Wkhvh# kdyh#wr#eh#kljk#hqrxjk#wr#ghwhu# # # # # # # # khdowk|#lqglylgxdov#iurp#sd|lqj#wkh#shqdow|#dqg# # # # # # # mrlqlqj## wkh## v|vwhp## rqo|## zkhq## wkh## qhhg## dulvhv1## Pruhryhu/## sodqv## wkdw## dwwudfw## d# glvsursruwlrqdwh## qxpehu## ri## kljk0ulvn#lqglylgxdov# # # qhhg## wr## eh## frpshqvdwhg## zlwk# wudqvihuv#iurp#wkrvh#wkdw#grqᄊw1# # # # # Xqlyhuvdo## khdowk## lqvxudqfh## zloo## dovr## uhtxluh## vxevlglhv## iru## wkh## srru1## Wklv#
uhtxluhphqw## fohduo|## fuhdwhv## vrph## whqvlrq## zlwk## wkh## Dphulfdq## dyhuvlrq## wr# xqfrqglwlrqdo#uhglvwulexwlrq#wkdw#L#glvfxvv#lq#fkdswhu#71#\hw#lw#lv#lpsodxvleoh#wkdw# # # ## # # # # # # # # pdq|#Dphulfdqv# # # wuxo|#eholhyh# # # wkdw## wkhlu## ihoorz## flwl}hqv## zkr## kdyh## edg## oxfn/## ru# hduq#olwwoh/#vkrxog#sd|#zlwk#wkhlu#khdowk#ru#wkh#khdowk#ri#wkhlu#fkloguhq1#Pruhryhu/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdq|#ri#wkh#xqlqvxuhg#vlfn#hyhqwxdoo|#gr#uhfhlyh#wuhdwphqw/#exw#zlwkrxw#dq|#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehqhilwv#ri#suhyhqwlyh#fduh/#wkxv#h{dfhuedwlqj#erwk#khdowk#sureohpv#dqg#wuhdwphqw# # # # # # # # # # # frvwv1#Ilqdoo|/#wkhuh#lv#d#eurdghu#ehqhilw#wr#xqlyhuvdo#lqvxudqfh1#Wkh#uhgxfwlrq#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # dq{lhw|#dprqj#wkh# # # # srsxodwlrq#lq#grzqwxuqv/# # # # dqg## wkh## dvvrfldwhg## uhgxfwlrq#lq#wkh# # # qhhg## iru## h{sdqvlrqdu|## pdfurhfrqrplf## srolflhv/## zloo## pdnh## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# ehwwhu## deoh## wr## fdoleudwh## ilvfdo## dqg## prqhwdu|## srolf|## wr## lwv## dfwxdo## qhhgv/## zkloh# vhuylqj#qrwlfh#rq#srolf|#pdnhuv#lq#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog#wkdw#wkh|#qhhg#wr#ehfrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh#h{sdqvlrqdu|1# # Wkh## pdmru## sureohp## lq## h{sdqglqj## fryhudjh/## rqfh## wkh## dgyhuvh0vhohfwlrq# sureohp#lv#ghdow#zlwk/#lv#wkdw#X1V1#khdowk#fduh#grhv#qrw#vhhp#frvw0hiihfwlyh1#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## vshqw#48# # # shufhqw#ri#JGS#rq#khdowk#fduh# # # # # # # lq#5339/# # # frpsduhg## wr## 44# shufhqw#lq#Iudqfh#dqg#Jhupdq|/#43#shufhqw#lq#Fdqdgd/#dqg#;#shufhqw#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Nlqjgrp#dqg# # # Mdsdq158## Rq## d## shu## fdslwd## edvlv/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## vshqw## '9/67:/# zkloh#Mdsdq#vshqw#'5/7:71#Wkh#gliihuhqfh#kdv#ehhq#jurzlqj=#lq#4<:3#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv## vshqw## 73## shufhqw## pruh## rq## khdowk## fduh## shu## fdslwd## wkdq## shhu## frxqwulhv>## lq# 5337## wklv## gliihuhqfh## kdg## zlghqhg## wr## <3## shufhqw1## Exw## khdowk#rxwfrphv# # # kdyh## qrw# lpsuryhg#frpphqvxudwho|=# # # hyhu|#frxqwu|#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhvᄊ#shhu#jurxs#kdg#d# # # # # # # # # # kljkhu## lqfuhdvh#lq#olih#h{shfwdqf|#dw#djh#98#ryhu# # # # # # # # # wkh#shulrg#4<:3ᄆ5337/#h{fhsw# # # # 59# Fdqdgd/#zklfk#h{shulhqfhg#wkh#vdph#61:0|hdu#lqfuhdvh1 # # # # # # 5:## Iluvw/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#kdv# Wkuhh#idfwruv#vhhp#lpsruwdqw#lq#gulylqj#xs#frvwv1 # # # # # # # # # # # kljk#sulfhv# # # iru## lqsxwv=## kls## uhsodfhphqwv## lq#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## iru## h{dpsoh/## frvw# wzlfh## dv## pxfk## dv## lq## Fdqdgd1## Sduw## ri## wklv## gliihuhqfh## lv## h{sodlqhg## e|## kljkhu# frpshqvdwlrq## iru## grfwruv## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv15;## Vhfrqg/## ehfdxvh## grfwruv## dqg# krvslwdov## jhw#sdlg# # # iru## vhuylfhv## surylghg## udwkhu## wkdq#iru# # # rxwfrphv/## dqg## ehfdxvh# lqvxudqfh#slfnv#xs#wkh#eloo/#wkh#v|vwhp#whqgv#wr#surprwh#ryhuxwlol}dwlrq#ri#khdowk# # # # # # # # # # # # # fduh1## Ilqdoo|/## wkh## v|vwhp#whqgv# # # wr## dgrsw#lqqrydwlrqv# # # hyhq#zkhq#wkh# # # # hylghqfh## ri# hiihfwlyhqhvv## lv## zhdn1## Iru## lqvwdqfh/## qxfohdu## sduwlfoh## dffhohudwruv/## frvwlqj#pruh# # wkdq#'433#ploolrq/#duh#yhu|#hiihfwlyh#lq#wuhdwlqj#uduh#eudlq#dqg#qhfn#wxpruv>#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#duh#dovr#xvhg#wr#wuhdw#pruh#frpprq#survwdwh#fdqfhuv/#zlwk#olwwoh#dgglwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehqhilw15<## D#jrrg#eloo# # # # zrxog#hqfrxudjh#pruh#frpshwlwlrq/#d#pryh#wr#sd|lqj#iru# # # # # # # # # rxwfrphv## udwkhu## wkdq#lqsxwv# # # +dv## zhoo## dv## vhwwlqj#wkh# # # shu0ylvlw## ghgxfwleoh## frvw## wr# hdfk#xvhu# # # dw## d## ohyho## wkdw## hqfrxudjhv## vrxqg## mxgjphqw## derxw## zkhwkhu## wr## ylvlw## wkh# grfwru,/#dqg#d#juhdwhu#irfxv#rq#xvlqj#rqo|#suryhq#wuhdwphqwv#wkdw#riihu#vljqlilfdqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsuryhphqwv#ryhu#fkhdshu#dowhuqdwlyhv1# # # #
Wkuhh## rwkhu## idfwruv## frqwulexwh## wr## wkh## kljk## frvw## ri## khdowk## fduh## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv#exw#duh#qrw#fhqwudo1#Wkh#iluvw#lv#dgplqlvwudwlyh#frvwv1#Wkhvh#duh#qrwrulrxvo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # gliilfxow## wr## hvwlpdwh## suhflvho|/## exw## rqh## hvwlpdwh## lqglfdwhv## wkdw## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# 63## Fohduo|/#jlyhq#wkdw# vshqw#'798#shu#fdslwd#lq#5339/#zkloh#Mdsdq#vshqw#rqo|#'851 # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#ryhudoo#gliihuhqfh#lq#khdowk#fduh#frvwv#ehwzhhq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#dqg#Mdsdq#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # derxw## whq## wlphv## wkh## gliihuhqfh## lq## dgplqlvwudwlyh## frvwv/## wkh|## duh## qrw## wkh## vroh# h{sodqdwlrq1## Krzhyhu/## phdvxuhv## wr## lpsuryh## frvw## hiilflhqf|#duh# # # lpsruwdqw1## Wkh# lqirupdwlrq#whfkqrorj|#uhyroxwlrq#frxog#ilqdoo|#eh#eurxjkw#wr#khdowk#fduh#e|/#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # h{dpsoh/#vwdqgdugl}lqj#hohfwurqlf#sdwlhqw#uhfrugv#vr#wkdw#wkh|#fdq#eh#wudqvihuuhg# # # # # # # # # # #
hdvlo|#dprqj#gliihuhqw#surylghuv1# # # # Wkh#vhfrqg#lv#rshudwlrqdo#hiilflhqf|1#Krvslwdov#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#frxog#ohduq# # # # # # # # # # # # pruh## iurp## hdfk## rwkhu/## dv## zhoo## dv## iurp## krvslwdov## hovhzkhuh/## lqfoxglqj## Lqgld/# zkhuh## frvwv## kdyh## ehhq## eurxjkw## grzq## e|## eulqjlqj## pdvv0surgxfwlrq## whfkqltxhv# shuihfwhg#lq#pdqxidfwxulqj#wr#khdowk#fduh1#Lqgldq#krvslwdov#kdyh#irxqg#wkdw#huuru# # # # # # # # # # # # udwhv#duh#uhgxfhg#zkhq#wkhlu#grfwruv#vshfldol}h#dqg#shuirup#pdq|#surfhgxuhv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # d#vlplodu#nlqg1#Wkh#wlph#iru#rshudwlrqv#lv#dovr#fxw#grzq/#zlwk#qr#orvv#ri#vdihw|1#D# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # irfxv#rq#holplqdwlqj#xqqhfhvvdu|#iuloov#dqg#rq#xwlol}lqj#h{shqvlyh#uhvrxufhv#olnh# # # # # # # # # # # grfwru#wlph#prvw#hiihfwlyho|#dovr#khosv=#hyhq#wkrxjk#jrrg#vxujhrqv#lq#Lqgld#hduq# # # # # # # # # # # # # derxw#dv#pxfk#dv#vxujhrqv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#wkh#frvw#ri#rshudwlrqv#lv#riwhq#dq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rughu#ri#pdjqlwxgh#orzhu1#Uhjxodwlrqv#wkdw#irufh#krvslwdov#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # eh#ᄈixoo0vhuylfhᄡ#krvslwdov#udwkhu#wkdq#shuplwwlqj#vshfldol}dwlrq#whqg#wr#gulyh#xs# # # # # # # # # # # frvwv1## Juhdwhu## frpshwlwlrq## ehwzhhq## krvslwdov## frxog## dovr## eulqj## grzq## frvwv>## dq# hdv|#zd|#ri#hqfrxudjlqj#furvv0erughu#frpshwlwlrq#lv#wr#dxwkrul}h#Phglfduh#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # Phglfdlg## uhlpexuvhphqwv## iru## surfhgxuhv## shuiruphg## e|#dxwkrul}hg# # # krvslwdov## lq# rwkhu#frxqwulhv/#olnh#Ph{lfr#dqg#Wkdlodqg1# # # # # # Wkh## wklug## idfwru## frqwulexwlqj## wr## wkh## kljk## frvw## ri## khdowk## fduh## lv## wkh## wkuhdw## ri# pdosudfwlfh## vxlwv/## zklfk## fdxvh## sk|vlfldqv## wr## uhfrpphqg## wuhdwphqwv## wkdw## khos# surwhfw## wkhp## djdlqvw## ixwxuh## odzvxlwv/## hyhq## li## wkhvh## wuhdwphqwv## duh## vwulfwo|# xqqhfhvvdu|#iru# # # wkh## sdwlhqwᄊv## khdowk1## H{shqglwxuhv## iru## Phglfduh## ehqhilfldulhv## lq# vwdwhv#zlwk#odujhu#pdosudfwlfh#dzdugv#duh#derxw#8#shufhqw#kljkhu=#wklv#gliihuhqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # lv## vljqlilfdqw/## wkrxjk## qrw## hqrxjk## dorqh## wr## h{sodlq## zk|## X1V1## khdowk## fduh## lv## vr# frvwo|164## Qhyhuwkhohvv/## wkhvh## frvwv## frqwulexwh## wr## wkh## ryhudoo## frvw#ri#khdowk#fduh/# # # # dqg#wruw#uhirup#vkrxog#eh#sduw#ri#dq#hiihfwlyh#eloo1# # # # # # # # # # Lw#lv#hdv|#wr#plqlpl}h#wkh#frpsoh{#fkdqjhv#wkdw#qhhg#wr#kdsshq1#Grfwruv#qhhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#uhfrpphqg#qhfhvvdu|#surfhgxuhv#wr#sdwlhqwv/#lqfoxglqj#suhyhqwdwlyh#rqhv/#exw# # # # # # # # # # vkrxog## qrw## kdyh## dq## lqfhqwlyh## wr## xqghuwdnh## h{fhvvlyh## wuhdwphqw## ehfdxvh## ri## wkh# dvvrfldwhg#ihhv1#Iodw#grfwru#vdodulhv#dqg#iodw#ihhv#shu#sdwlhqw#hquroohg#lq#d#khdowk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdlqwhqdqfh## surjudp## ru## iru## wuhdwlqj## d## sduwlfxodu## dlophqw## vhhp## dwwudfwlyh# vroxwlrqv/## exw## wkh|## duh## qrw## sdqdfhdv1## Iru## lqvwdqfh/## zlwkrxw## rwkhu## vrxufhv## ri# prwlydwlrq/## iodw## vdodulhv## fdq## nloo## wkh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## h{huw## hiiruw1## Vlploduo|/## zlwk# ehwwhu## sxeolf## lqirupdwlrq#derxw# # # wkh## hiihfwlyhqhvv## ri## vshflilf## grfwruv/## krvslwdov/# dqg## surfhgxuhv/## shrsoh## fdq## pdnh## ehwwhu## ghflvlrqv## derxw## zkhuh## dqg## krz## wkh|# zdqw#wr#eh#wuhdwhg1#Xowlpdwho|/#wkrxjk/#prvw#ri#xv#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # pdnh#ghflvlrqv#edvhg#rq# # # # wkh## dgylfh## surylghg## e|## wkh## dxwkrulw|/## rxu## grfwru1## Dv## zlwk## hgxfdwlrq/## pdq|# h{shulphqwv## duh## xqghu## zd|## rq## wkh## uljkw## pl{## ri## lqfhqwlyhv/## wudqvsduhqf|/# frpshwlwlrq/## dqg## rujdql}dwlrqdo## fkdqjhv## wkdw## fdq## eulqj## grfwruv/## krvslwdov/# lqvxudqfh#frpsdqlhv/#sdwlhqwv/#dqg#wkh#jryhuqphqw#wrjhwkhu#wr#fuhdwh#dq#hiihfwlyh# # # # # # # # # # # khdowk#fduh#v|vwhp1#Zh#qhhg#wr#ilqg#rxw#zkdw#vroxwlrqv#zrun/#vfdoh#wkhp#xs/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frqwlqxh## wr## hydoxdwh## wkhp#dv# # # wkh|## duh## uroohg## rxw/## uhfrjql}lqj## wkdw## d## ydulhw|## ri# dssurdfkhv## zloo## pdnh## wkh## v|vwhp## pruh## uhvlolhqw1## Doo## wklv## qhhgv## wr## eh## grqh# txlfno|1#Hiihfwlyh#fkdqjh#zloo#qrw#eh#hdv|/#exw#wkh#ehqhilwv#ri#diirugdeoh#xqlyhuvdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # khdowk#fduh#jr#idu#eh|rqg#wkh#sk|vlfdo#dqg#prudo#khdowk#ri#Dphulfdq#vrflhw|>#wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # h{whqg#wr#wkh#hfrqrplf#khdowk#ri#wkh#frxqwu|1# # # # # # # #
Lpsurylqj#Sruwdelolw|#ri#Ehqhilwv#dqg#Zrunhu#Prelolw|# # # # # # #
# Dq#lpsruwdqw#hohphqw#lq#surprwlqj#wkh#uhvlolhqfh#ri#wkh#lqglylgxdo#zrunhu#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # grzqwxuqv## lv## wkh## sruwdelolw|## ri## vdylqjv## dqg## shqvlrq## sodqv1## Zrunhuv## zkr## duh# ghshqghqw## rq## wkhlu## hpsor|huv## iru## wkhlu## orqj0uxq## vdylqjvᄇiru## h{dpsoh/## li## wkh|# kdyh#xqghuixqghg#ghilqhg0ehqhilw#shqvlrq#sodqv/#ru# # # # # # # krog#odujh#dprxqwv# # # # ri#vwrfn# # lq## wkh## ilup## dv## sduw## ri## wkhlu## sodqvᄇwhqg## wr## vxiihu## d## grxeoh## eorz## zkhq## wkhlu# hpsor|hu## jhwv## lqwr## wurxeoh>## wkh|## orvh## erwk## wkhlu## mrev## dqg## wkhlu## shqvlrqv1# Wkhruhwlfdoo|/#shqvlrq#sodqv#kdyh#wr#eh#nhsw#ixoo|#ixqghg/#exw#wurxeohg#hpsor|huv# # # # # # # # # # # # w|slfdoo|#xqghuixqg#wkhlu#shqvlrq#sodqv1#Dowkrxjk#wkh#jryhuqphqw#slfnv#xs#vrph# # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#wde#wkurxjk#wkh#Shqvlrq#Ehqhilw#Jxdudqwhh#Frusrudwlrq/#d#ehwwhu#orqj0whup# # # # # # # # # # # # vroxwlrq## lv## wr## pdnh## wkh## zrunhuvᄊ## vdylqjv## lqghshqghqw## ri## wkh## ilupᄊv## khdowk## e|# hqvxulqj## wkdw## wkh|## lqyhvw## lq## glyhuvlilhg## ghilqhg0frqwulexwlrq## shqvlrq## sodqv## +lq# zklfk#shqvlrq#dffxpxodwlrqv#duh#lqyhvwhg#e|#wkh#hpsor|hh#lq#glyhuvlilhg#pxwxdo# # # # # # # # # # # ixqgv,1#Pruh#jhqhudoo|/#pdnlqj#wkh#prghudwho|#sdlg#zrunhu# # # # # # # # ᄊv#orqj0whup#ehqhilwv/# # # lqfoxglqj#khdowk#fduh/#lqghshqghqw#ri#d#ilupᄊv#khdowk#uhgxfhv#erwk#zrunhu#dq{lhw|# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#wkh#suhvvxuh#rq#wkh#jryhuqphqw#wr#lqwhuyhqh#wr#edlo#rxw#wkh#ilup#wr#surwhfw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 65# zrunhuv1 Uhvwulfwlrqv## rq## zrunhu## prelolw|## dovr## frqwulexwh## wr## dq{lhw|1## Wkh## zrunsodfh# lqfuhdvlqjo|## ghpdqgv## fuhghqwldov## dqg## fhuwlilfdwlrq=## iru## h{dpsoh/## grfwruv## dqg# odz|huv## qhhg#gliihuhqw#olfhqvhv# # # # wr#sudfwlfh# # # lq#hdfk#vwdwh1#Lw#lv# # # # # # lpsruwdqw#wkdw#wkh# # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## dqg## lqghhg## wkh## zruog/## qrw## eh## edondql}hg## e|## uhtxluhphqwv## wkdw# surihvvlrqdov## uhhvwdeolvk## fuhghqwldov## zkhqhyhu## wkh|## pryh1## Dowkrxjk## wkhuh## duh# lqghhg## ohjlwlpdwh## frqfhuqv## wkdw## whvwlqj## dqg## fhuwlilfdwlrq## uhtxluhphqwv## +dqg## wkh# txdolw|## ri## whvwlqj## surfhgxuhv,## pd|## gliihu## dfurvv## uhjlrqv/## dv## frxog## wkh## vxemhfw# pdwwhu## ryhu## zklfk## pdvwhu|## lv## uhtxluhg/## fhuwlilfdwlrq## lv## vrphwlphv## xvhg## dv## d# phdqv## ri## fuhdwlqj## pruh## surilwv## iru## fhuwlilhg## lqfxpehqwv## e|## nhhslqj## rxw# frpshwlwlrq1## Iru## lqvwdqfh/## lw## lv## kdug## wr## eholhyh## wkdw## wkh## sudfwlfh## ri## phglflqh# gliihuv## zlgho|## lq## gliihuhqw## X1V1## vwdwhv1## Wklv## surfhvv## vkrxog## eh## fduhixoo|# uhh{dplqhg## wr## kduprql}h## uhtxluhphqwv## ru## surprwh## furvv0uhfrjqlwlrq## ri# fhuwlilfdwhv## zkhuhyhu## srvvleoh/## dqg## wr## idflolwdwh## hdv|#whvwlqj#dqg# # # # uhfhuwlilfdwlrq# zkhuh## lw#lv# # # qrw1## Ulfk#surihvvlrqdo# # # rujdql}dwlrqv## kdyh## olwwoh## lqfhqwlyh## wr## jlyh## xs# wkhlu## uhqwv/## vr## sxeolf## suhvvxuh## pd|## eh## uhtxluhg## iru## wkhp## wr## uhh{dplqh## wkhlu# fhuwlilfdwlrq#uhtxluhphqwv1# # Dqrwkhu## idfwru## uhvwulfwlqj#prelolw|/#fhuwdlqo|#lq#wkh#fxuuhqw#grzqwxuq/#lv#krph# # # # # # # # # rzqhuvkls1#Dqhfgrwdo#hylghqfh#vxjjhvwv#wkdw#kdug0wr0vhoo#krphv/#dqg#krphv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # duh## zruwk## ohvv## wkdq## wkh## ghew## wkdw## lv## rzhg/## duh## zhljklqj## grzq## zrunhuv## dqg# suhyhqwlqj#wkhp#iurp#orrnlqj#hovhzkhuh#iru# # # # # # # hpsor|phqw1#D#qxpehu# # # # ri#ilqdqfldo# # lqqrydwlrqv## wkdw## zrxog## doorz## krxvhkrogv## wr## sxufkdvh## lqvxudqfh## djdlqvw## krph0 sulfh#ghfolqhv#kdyh#ehhq#sursrvhg/#dqg#lq#oljkw#ri#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv/#ghpdqg#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhvh## lqvwuxphqwv## pd|## lqfuhdvh166## Wklv## lv## dovr## d## uhdvrq## zk|## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv# irfxv#rq#hqfrxudjlqj#krph#rzqhuvkls#qhhgv#wr#eh#uhylvlwhg1# # # # # # # # # Dowkrxjk#wkh#prghuq#hfrqrp|#qhhgv#vrph#zrunhuv#wr#vshfldol}h/#zrunhuv#olnh# # # # # # # # # # # Edgul/## hqfrxqwhuhg## lq## fkdswhu## 7/## pd|## whqg## wr## jurz## ryhuo|## vshfldol}hg## lq## rqh# lqgxvwu|1#Urehuw#Vkloohu#ri#\doh#Xqlyhuvlw|#kdv#dujxhg#iru#ᄈolyholkrrgᄡ#lqvxudqfh# # # # # # # # # # # ᄇlqvxudqfh#wkdw#zrxog#surwhfw#zrunhuv# # # # # # djdlqvw#d#ghfolqh#lq#lqfrphv# # # # # # ru## mrev## lq# wkhlu## sduwlfxodu## duhdv## ri## vshfldol}dwlrq1## Lq## d## vhqvh/## orqj0whup## xqhpsor|phqw# lqvxudqfh#lv#d#irup#ri#olyholkrrg#lqvxudqfh#surylghg#e|#vrflhw|1#Wkh#grzqvlgh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # #
vxfk#lqvxudqfh# # # lv## wkdw#lw#uhgxfhv# # # # zrunhu## lqfhqwlyhv## wr## nhhs## wkhlu## kxpdq#fdslwdo# # uhohydqw1## Kdylqj## dq## xqsurgxfwlyh## xqghufodvv## wkdw## olyhv## rii## wkhlu## lqvxudqfh# sd|phqwv## lv## ehwwhu## wkdq## kdylqj## d## ghvwlwxwh## xqghufodvv/## exw## lw## lv## ehvw## li## vxfk# sd|phqwv## vlpso|## khos## vxvwdlq## wkhp## zkloh## wkh|## uhwrro## wr## ehfrph## surgxfwlyh# phpehuv#ri#vrflhw|#djdlq1# # # # Dq#dowhuqdwlyh#lv#iru#wkh#zrunhu#wr#uhwdlq#prelolw|#e|#exloglqj#ioh{leoh#kxpdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdslwdo1## Fohduo|/## ilupv## kdyh## olwwoh## gluhfw## lqfhqwlyh## wr## hqfrxudjh## zrunhuv## wr# dftxluh## jhqhudo## vnloov## wkdw## wkhlu## hpsor|huv## fdqqrw## xvh1## \hw## juhdwhu## srwhqwldo# prelolw|#zrxog#pdnh#zrunhuv#ihho#pruh#vhfxuh1#Lq#rughu#wr#dwwudfw#jrrg#zrunhuv/# # # # # # # # # # # # # ilupv#vkrxog#riihu#pruh#rssruwxqlwlhv#iru#kxpdq#fdslwdo#ghyhorsphqw1#Vrph#ilupv# # # # # # # # # # # douhdg|## gr/## exw## pdq|## grqᄊw1## Shukdsv## wkh## sureohp#lv# # # wkdw## |rxqj/## jrrg## zrunhuv# grqᄊw#ihdu#iru#wkhlu#ixwxuh/#dqg#ilupv#grqᄊw#zdqw#wr#dwwudfw#ohvv0vhfxuh#zrunhuv#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # riihulqj#rssruwxqlwlhv#iru#fduhhu#ghyhorsphqw1#Shukdsv#zrunhuv#wkhpvhoyhv/#rqfh# # # # # # # # # wkh|#duh#lq#wkh#ilup/#ghod|#ghyhorslqj#sruwdeoh#vnloovᄇjrlqj#edfn#wr#vfkrro#lv#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hdv|ᄇxqwlo#lw#lv#mxvw#wrr#gliilfxow#wr#gr#vr1# # # # # # # # # Zkdwhyhu## wkh## uhdvrq/## dv## wkh## ohqjwk## ri## zrunlqj## olyhv## lqfuhdvhv## dqg## dv# whfkqrorj|#fkdqjhv# # # udslgo|/## pruh## dqg## pruh## zrunhuv/## hvshfldoo|#lq#nqrzohgjh0 # # edvhg## lqgxvwulhv/## duh## olnho|## wr## ilqg## wkhpvhoyhv## zlwk## rxwgdwhg## dqg## h{fhvvlyho|# vshfldol}hg#kxpdq#fdslwdo1#Dfdghplfv#w|slfdoo|#jhw#d#vdeedwlfdo#|hdu#rqfh#hyhu|# # # # # # # # # # # vhyhq## |hduv## wr## uhqhz## wkhlu## nqrzohgjh1## +Xqlyhuvlw|## ri## Fklfdjr## idfxow|## duh## dq# h{fhswlrq=## wkhuh## lv## d## suhvxpswlrq## wkdw## zh## frxog## qrw## srvvleo|## ohduq## pruh# dq|zkhuh#hovh#rq#hduwk/#vr#zh#grqᄊw#kdyh#vdeedwlfdov1,#Dv#pruh#zrunhuv#frph#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhvhpeoh## dfdghplfv/## shukdsv## hpsor|hh## vdeedwlfdov## vkrxog## ehfrph## pruh# zlghvsuhdg1## Dv## wkh## jryhuqphqw#frxog# # # zhoo## ehqhilw#iurp#wkh# # # # uhqhzdo## ri#zrunhu# # kxpdq#fdslwdo/# # # lw## frxog## frqwhpsodwh## riihulqj#wd{#fuhglwv# # # # iru## zrunhuv## zkr## kdyh# zrunhg#iru#d#qxpehu#ri#|hduv#dqg#ghflgh#wr#wdnh#d#euhdn#wr#vwxg|#ru#uhwrro1#Vxfk# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # d#pryh#zrxog#dovr#sxw#suhvvxuh#rq#hpsor|huv#wr#doorz#vxfk#vdeedwlfdov1# # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlyhuvlwlhv#dovr#qhhg#wr#gr#wkhlu#elw1#Lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#olih#h{shfwdqf|#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqfuhdvhg## e|#derxw# # # 63## |hduv## vlqfh## 4<33/## doprvw## wkh## vsdq#ri# # # dq#hqwluh# # # zrunlqj# 67# fduhhu1 # Dowkrxjk#pruh#shrsoh#wrgd|#dftxluh#dgydqfhg#ghjuhhv/#prvw#vwloo# # # # # # # # # # vwrs# wkhlu## irupdo## hgxfdwlrq## hduo|## lq## olih/## pxfk## dv## wkh|## glg## d## kxqguhg## |hduv## djr1# Hgxfdwlrq#lv#vwloo#jhduhg#wrzdug#wkh#iluvw#mre/#hyhq#wkrxjk#whfkqrorjlfdo#fkdqjh/# # # # # # # # # # # # frpshwlwlrq/#dqg#juhdwhu#mre#prelolw|#phdqv#wkdw#iru#prvw#shrsoh/#wkdw#iluvw#mre/#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhq#wkdw#iluvw#fduhhu/#zloo#qrw#eh#wkh#odvw1# # # # # # # # # D#v|vwhp#ri#irupdo#hgxfdwlrq#wkdw#whuplqdwhv#zkhq#rqh#lv#wzhqw|0ilyh#suredeo|# # # # # # # # # # # # surylghv#wrr#pxfk#lqirupdwlrq#uhodwhg#wr#wkh#iluvw#ihz#|hduv#ri#rqhᄊv#fduhhu#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrr## olwwoh## nqrzohgjh## iru## wkh## kdoi0fhqwxu|#wkdw# # # iroorzv1## Zrxog## lw## qrw## pdnh## pruh# vhqvh## wr## ghhpskdvl}h## hduo|## vshfldol}dwlrq## dqg## riihu## pruh## grvhv## ri## irupdo# hgxfdwlrq#odwhu#rq/#vr#wkdw#lqglylgxdov#fdq#frsh#zlwk#fkdqjhv#lq#hqylurqphqw#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # suhihuhqfhvB# Exvlqhvv#vfkrrov#kdyh#wdnhq#d#ohdg#khuh#e|#riihulqj#rshq0hquroophqw#uhiuhvkhu# # # # # # # # # # # frxuvhv## wr## vhqlru## h{hfxwlyhv## zkr## ihho## wkh## vnloov## rewdlqhg## gxulqj## wkhlu## PED# wudlqlqj#qhhg#xsgdwlqj1#Exw#wkhuh#pd|#eh#d#uhdvrq#wr#uhwklqn#wkh#hqwluh#vwuxfwxuh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # X1V1#kljkhu# # # hgxfdwlrq/#d# # # v|vwhp#ghvljqhg#zkhq#vwxghqwv# # # # # w|slfdoo|#ohiw#xqlyhuvlw|# # # iru## d## olihorqj## fduhhu## zlwk## rqh## hpsor|hu1## Zh## qhhg## pruh## prgxodu## ghjuhhv## dqg# olihorqj## dgplvvlrq## wr## kljkhu## hgxfdwlrq## +dw## ohdvw## iru## jhqhudo## surjudpv,## vr## wkdw#
vwxghqwv#fdq#slfn#dqg#fkrrvh#zkdw#wkh|#zdqw#zkhq#wkh|#qhhg#lw1# # # # # # # # # # # # Dgydqfhv## lq#glvwdqfh# # # hgxfdwlrq#xvlqj#wkh# # # # Lqwhuqhw#zloo# # # khos## lqglylgxdov## nhhs# xs## wr## gdwh## hyhq## zkloh## zrunlqj## ixoo## wlph## dqg## khos## uhgxfh## wkh## frvw## ri## kljkhu# hgxfdwlrq1#D#ihz#xqlyhuvlwlhv#douhdg|#riihu#d#ixoo#PED#ghjuhh#wkdw#uhtxluhv#rqo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # d#ihz#zhhnv#ri#lq0shuvrq#dwwhqgdqfh/#zlwk#pxfk#ri#wkh#qhfhvvdu|#frppxqlfdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg#lqvwuxfwlrq#surylghg#wkurxjk#rqolqh#glvfxvvlrq#jurxsv/#h0pdlo/#dqg#ohfwxuhv1# # # # # # # # # # Wkhvh## nlqgv## ri#surjudpv# # # zloo## h{sdqg1## Rqh## lpsruwdqw#wrro/# # # wkhuhiruh/## lq#khoslqj# # flwl}hqv## frsh## zlwk#wkh# # # juhdwhu## xqfhuwdlqw|#lq#wkhlu# # # # olyhv## zloo## eh## d## uhyroxwlrq#lq# # kljkhu#hgxfdwlrq1# #
Vdylqjv# # Ilqdoo|/## zrunhuv## duh## pruh## uhvlolhqw#lq#wkh# # # # idfh## ri#dgyhuvlw|#zkhq#wkh|#kdyh# # # # # dghtxdwh#vdylqjv1#Iru#wrr#pdq|#Dphulfdq#zrunhuv/#jurzlqj#krxvh#sulfhv#fuhdwhg# # # # # # # # # # # dq#looxvlrq#ri#lqfuhdvlqj#zhdowk1#Lw#zdv#dq#looxvlrq#hyhq#ehiruh#wkh#fxuuhqw#fulvlv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇdiwhu#doo/#|rx#kdyh#wr#olyh#vrphzkhuh/#vr#li#wkh#ydoxh#ri#wkh#krph#|rx#olyh#lq#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ulvlqj/#|rx#uhdoo|#gr#qrw#kdyh#h{wud#glvsrvdeoh#zhdowkᄇdqg#lw#ehfdph#hyhq#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # looxvru|#dv#krxvh#sulfhv#froodsvhg#dqg#eruurzhuv#zhuh#ohiw#vwdulqj#dw#d#prxqwdlq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#ghew1# # Dphulfdqv#qhhg#wr#vdyh#pruh/#dqg#wkh#jryhuqphqw#vkrxog#eh#idu#ohvv#hdjhu#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hqfrxudjh## wkhp## wr## vshqg1## Vdylqjv## udwhv## duh## lqfuhdvlqj## dv## krxvhkrogv## glj# wkhpvhoyhv#rxw#ri#wklv#fulvlv1#D#qxpehu#ri#lqwhuhvwlqj#lghdv#kdyh#ehhq#sursrvhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # hqfrxudjh#vdylqjv#dqg#duh#zruwk#h{sorulqj1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#p|#froohdjxh#Ulfkdug# # # # # # # # # # # Wkdohu## dw## wkh## Xqlyhuvlw|## ri## Fklfdjr## kdv## vxjjhvwhg## lqqrydwlyh## zd|v## e|## zklfk# krxvhkrogv#fdq#eh#qxgjhg#lqwr#vdylqj#pruh1#Lq#klv#ᄈVdyh#Pruh#Wrpruurzᄡ#sodq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghylvhg## zlwk#Vkorpr# # # Ehqduw}l/## zrunhuv## vljq#dq#djuhhphqw#zlwk#wkhlu# # # # # # hpsor|hu# dqg#wkhlu# # # ilqdqfldo## vhuylfhv#surylghu# # # wkdw#wkh|#zloo# # # # sodfh#vrph#sruwlrq#ri#ixwxuh# # # # # vdodu|#udlvhv#lqwr#vdylqjv#sodqv1#Wkh#lghd#lv#wkdw#zkhq#wkh|#frpplw#wr#grlqj#vr/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#h{wud#dprxqw#vdyhg#grhv#qrw#vkulqn#wkhlu#exgjhw#dqg#uhtxluhv#qr#vdfulilfh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fxuuhqw#frqvxpswlrq1# # # Wkxv## wkh|#duh# # # ᄈwulfnhgᄡ## lqwr## vdylqj#pruh/# # # d## ghflvlrq#wkh|# # duh#shuihfwo|#zloolqj#wr#uhvshfw#ryhu#wlphᄇiru#wkh|#kdyh#wkh#delolw|#wr#whdu#xs#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # 68# djuhhphqw#dq|#wlph#wkh|#zdqw1 # # # # Shukdsv## wkh## prvw## lpsruwdqw## vrxufh## ri## ixwxuh## vhfxulw|## iru## prvw## Dphulfdqv## lv# vrfldo#vhfxulw|1#Xqiruwxqdwho|/#wkh#vrfldo#vhfxulw|#v|vwhp/#d#sd|0dv0|rx0jr#v|vwhp# # # # # # # # # # zkhuhe|#fxuuhqw#sd|huv#ixqg#wkh#sd|phqwv#pdgh#wr#fxuuhqw#uhflslhqwv/#lv#fxuuhqwo|# # # # # # # # # # # # surmhfwhg## wr## ehfrph## lqvroyhqw## lq## wkh## orqj## uxq/## dv## wkh## srsxodwlrq## djhv## dqg## wkh# qxpehu## ri#uhwluhhv# # # vzdpsv## wkh#qxpehu# # # ri#sd|huv1#Fxuuhqw#zrunhuv# # # # # zloo## kdyh#wr# # zrun#xqwlo#d#odwhu#djh/#dqg#ixwxuh#uhwluhhv#zloo#uhfhlyh#ihzhu#ehqhilwv1#Wkhvh#uhdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fkdqjhv## fdqqrw## eh## zlvkhg## dzd|/## dqg## zh## vkrxog## qrw## suhwhqg## wkhuh## duh## sdlqohvv# zd|v#wr#uhirup#vrfldo#vhfxulw|#+iru#h{dpsoh/#e|#lqyhvwlqj#lwv#dvvhwv#lq#frusrudwh# # # # # # # # # # # # # htxlwlhv,1#Wkh#v|vwhp#qhhgv#wr#eh#uhiruphg/#prvw#reylrxvo|#e|#h{whqglqj#wkh#djh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#uhwluhphqw#dqg#vorzlqj#wkh#udwh#ri#lqfuhdvh#ri#ehqhilwv>#wkh#vrrqhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#lv#grqh/# # # wkh#pruh#htxlwdeo|#wkh#frvwv#fdq#eh#vsuhdg#dfurvv#jhqhudwlrqv1# # # # # # # # # #
Jryhuqphqw#Fdsdflw| # # Ilqdoo|/## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## ilqdqfhv## kdyh## wr## eh## uhvwruhg## wr## khdowk## diwhu## wkh# hqruprxv#wroo#wdnhq#e|#wklv#fulvlv1#Wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#fdsdflw|#wr#vshqg#lv#dozd|v# # # # # # # # # # # # # d## vrxufh## ri#uhvlolhqfh# # # iru## erwk#edqnv# # # dqg## wkh## sxeolf## lq#grzqwxuqv1# # # Shukdsv## wkh# odujhvw#xqixqghg#oldelolwlhv#ri#wkh#X1V1#jryhuqphqw#kdyh#wr#gr#zlwk#Phglfduh#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # Phglfdlg1## Wklv## lv## rqh## pruh## uhdvrq## zk|## frqwuroolqj## wkh## jurzwk## ri## khdowk## fduh# frvwv#kdv#wr#eh#kljk#rq#wkh#jryhuqphqwᄊv#djhqgd1# # # # # # # # # Uhgxflqj#ghilflwv#e|#fxuelqj#xqqhfhvvdu|#h{shqglwxuhv#dqg#lqfuhdvlqj#wd{hv#lq# # # # # # # # # # dq#htxlwdeoh#dqg#hiilflhqw#zd|#pxvw#dovr#eh#sduw#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # dqvzhu1#Zh# # # zloo## qhhg#d# # elsduwlvdq#hiiruw#wkdw#orrnv#dw#doo# # # # # # # srvvleoh#rswlrqvᄇlqfoxglqj#d#ydoxh0dgghg#wd{# # # # # +d#nlqg#ri#qdwlrqdo#vdohv#wd{,#dqg#d#fduerq#wd{/#rswlrqv#wkdw#kdyh#ehhq#rii#wkh#wdeoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vr## idu1## Wkh## yhu|#srru# # # fdq#eh# # # surwhfwhg## iurp#wkh# # # hiihfwv## ri#wkhvh# # # wd{hv## rq#wkhlu# # frqvxpswlrq#wkurxjk#kljkhu# # # # hduqhg0lqfrph#wd{#fuhglwv1#Krzhyhu/#wkh#qrwlrq#wkdw# # # # # # # rqo|#wkh#ulfk#qhhg#eh#wd{hg#wr#uhvwruh#jryhuqphqw#ilqdqfhv#wr#khdowk#kdv#wr#eh#vhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # djdlqvw#wkh#idfw#wkdw#wkh#lqfhqwlyh#hiihfwv#rq#gxoolqj#wkh#ghvluh#wr#zrun#pd|#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh## kljkhu## iru## wkh## ulfk## +ehfdxvh## wkh|## gr## qrw## zrun## wr## olyh,/## dqg## wkh|## duh## dovr# suredeo|## ehwwhu## deoh## wr## dyrlg## wd{hv## e|## prylqj## wr## wd{## kdyhqv## ru## wkurxjk## wd{# sodqqlqj1#Lq#doo#olnholkrrg/#doo#ri#xv#zloo#kdyh#wr#wljkwhq#rxu#ehowv1# # # # # # # # # # # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Dphulfdq#ryhufrqvxpswlrq#lv#gulyhq#e|#srolflhv#wkdw#zhuh#iudphg#lq#uhdfwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # wr## jurzlqj## sxeolf## shufhswlrqv## ri## lqhtxdolw|## dqg## lqvhfxulw|/## dqg## wkhvh## srolflhv# kdyh#frqwulexwhg#wr#ilqdqfldo0vhfwru# # # # # h{fhvv1#Wkh#uhphglhv#duh#qrw#hdv|#dqg#zloo# # # # # # # # uhtxluh## ixuwkhu## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq1## Jlyhq## wkh## surshqvlw|## iru## jryhuqphqw# dfwlrq## wr## jr## zurqj/## zh## vkrxog## dssurdfk## lqwhuyhqwlrqv## zlwk## fduh## dqg## vrph# vnhswlflvp1#\hw#lqdfwlrq#zloo#pdnh#pdwwhuv#frqvlghudeo|#zruvh1# # # # # # # # Iru#wkh#|rxqj/#wkh#dqvzhuv#olh#lq#eurdghqlqj#wkh#sdwkzd|v#wkdw#doorz# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp#wr# # exlog#kxpdq#fdslwdo1#Iru#wkrvh#zkr#duh#roghu/#zh#kdyh#wr#lpsuryh#zd|v#shrsoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # fdq## uhpdnh## wkhpvhoyhv## wr## vwd|## frpshwlwlyh## hyhq## dv## wkhlu## rog## vnloov## ehfrph# revrohwh1#Iru#wkrvh#zkr#fdqqrw#fkdqjh/#zh#qhhg#wr#xqghuvwdqg#krz#wr#nhhs#wkhp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqyroyhg#dv#surgxfwlyh/#ydoxdeoh#phpehuv#ri#vrflhw|#zkloh#surylglqj#qhfhvvdu|# # # # # # # # # # vxssruw1## Wkhvh## duh## qrw## hdv|## wdvnv1## Dphulfdq## vrflhw|## zloo## kdyh## wr## edodqfh# frpsdvvlrq## dqg## xqghuvwdqglqj## djdlqvw## wkh## ulvn## ri## fuhdwlqj## d## ghshqghqw## dqg# uhvhqwixo#xqghufodvv1# # Vrph#ri#wkh#fkdqjhv#wkdw#duh#qhhghg#wrgd|#pd|#vhhp#wr#jr#djdlqvw#wkh#judlq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Dphulfdᄊv## vhoi0lpdjh## ri## hqwuhsuhqhxuldo## dfklhyhphqw## xqeulgohg## e|## wkh## khdy|# kdqg#ri#jryhuqphqw1#\hw#fhqwudo#wr#wkdw#vhoi0lpdjh#kdyh#ehhq#d#vhqvh#wkdw#dq|rqh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # zkr#wulhv#kdug#fdq#vxffhhg#dqg#wkh#frqilghqfh#wkdw#wrpruurz#zloo#eh#ehwwhu#wkdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrgd|1#Lqhtxdolw|#ri#dffhvv#wr#hgxfdwlrq#dqg#khdowk#fduh/#dqg#prxqwlqj#lqvhfxulw|/# # # # # # # # # # # # hvshfldoo|#gxulqj#surorqjhg#grzqwxuqv/#vwulnh#dw#wkdw#vhoi0lpdjh1# # # # # # # # Dq## dq{lrxv## Dphulfd## lv## d## fdxvh## ri## frqfhuq## iru## wkh## uhvw## ri## wkh## zruog/## iru## lw# xowlpdwho|## phdqv## d## pruh## lqzdug0orrnlqj/## iudfwlrxv## zruog1## Wkh## zruog## qhhgv# Dphulfd## wr## uhirup1## Wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## dozd|v## ehhq#deoh# # # wr## uhpdnh## lwvhoi#lq# # dgyhuvlw|/#dqg#wkhuh#lv#qr#uhdvrq#zk|#lw#fdqqrw#gr#vr#djdlq1#Lw#lv#lq#Dphulfdᄊv#sdvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#zh# # # vkrxog#vhh# # # krsh## iru## lwv## ixwxuh1#Exw#zkdw#ri#wkh# # # # # # zruog#lwvhoiB# # # Wklv## lv## wkh# txhvwlrq#L#wxuq#wr#qrz1# ## # #
FKDSWHU#WHQ #
Wkh#Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv#Uhsod|hg # # # # # #
LQ## 4:47/## EHUQDUG## PDQGHYLOOH/## d## Gxwfkpdq## olylqj## lq## Hqjodqg/## zurwh## Wkh#
Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv=#Ru#Sulydwh#Ylfhv/#Sxeolf#Ehqhilwv1#Sduw#yhuvh/#sduw#survh/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wudfw#zdv#dq#lqglfwphqw#ri#wkh#vkdus#sudfwlfhv/#h{wudydjdqfh/#dqg#k|srfulv|#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ulfk#uxolqj#fodvv1#Iru#h{dpsoh/#klv#sruwudlw#ri#odz|huv#lq#klv#ilfwlwlrxv#ehhklyh/#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wklqo|#glvjxlvhg#doohjru|#iru# # # # # wkh#Hqjodqg#ri#klv# # # # # wlph/#lv# # # rqh#wkdw#vkrxog#vwulnh#d# # # # # fkrug#zlwk#shrsoh#lq#pdq|#frxqwulhv#wrgd|=# # # # # # # Wkh#Odz|huv/#ri#zkrvh#Duw#wkh#Edvlv # # # # # # Zdv#udlvlqj#Ihxgv#dqg#vsolwwlqj#Fdvhv/ᆱ # # # # # Wkh|#nhsw#rii#Khdulqjv#zloixoo|/ # # # # Wr#ilqjhu#wkh#uhwdlqlqj#Ihh> # # # # Dqg#wr#ghihqg#d#zlfnhg#Fdxvh/ # # # # # H{dplqᄊg#dqg#vxuyh|ᄊg#wkh#Odzv> # # # # Dv#Exujoduv#Vkrsv#dqg#Krxvhv#gr> # # # # # 4 Wr#ilqg#rxw#zkhuh#wkh|ᄊg#ehvw#euhdn#wkurxjk1 # # # # # # # # Exw#diwhu#fulwlfl}lqj#wkhp/#Pdqghylooh#zhqw#rq#wr#pdnh#dq#lpsruwdqw#hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # # # srlqw=## wkh#ox{xulrxv# # # olylqj#ri#wkh#ulfk#dqg#srzhuixo/#wkhlu# # # # # # # # fkdqjlqj#idvklrqv# # # dqg# wdvwhv/#kdg#wkh#rqh#hqruprxv#ehqhilw#ri#surylglqj#zrun#iru#wkh#pdq|1#Vr# # # # # # # # # # # # # zklovw#Ox{xu| # Hpsor|ᄊg#d#Ploolrq#ri#wkh#Srru/ # # # # # Dqg#rglrxv#Sulgh#d#Ploolrq#pruh # # # # # Hqy|#lwvhoi/#dqg#Ydqlw| # # # Zhuh#Plqlvwhuv#ri#Lqgxvwu|> # # # Wkhlu#gduolqj#Iroo|/#Ilfnohqhvv # # # Lq#Glhw/#Ixuqlwxuh/#dqg#Guhvv/ # # # # Wkdw#vwudqjh/#ulglfᄊorxv#Ylfh/#zdv#pdgh # # # # # 5 Wkh#yhu|#Zkhho/#wkdw#wxuqᄊg#wkh#Wudgh1 # # # # # # # Lqghhg/## zkhq#wkh# # # yrlfhv## ri#rssrvlwlrq#jurz# # # # orxg## hqrxjk#lq#wkh# # # # ehhklyh## iru# Mryh#wr#sxw#dq#hqg#wr#wkh#fruuxswlrq#dqg#h{fhvvlyh#frqvxpswlrq/#wkh#ehh#hfrqrp|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # froodsvhv1#Pdqghylooh#wkxv#pdnhv#wkh#vlpsoh#srlqw#wkdw#dq#hfrqrp|#ixoo#ri#wkuliw|# # # # # # # # # # # # # vdyhuv## fdqqrw#iorxulvk#iru# # # # orqj#ehfdxvh# # # qrerg|#fdq#hduq#lqfrph# # # # # li#qr# # # rqh## hovh# vshqgv## prqh|1## Zh## h{dow## iuxjdolw|## dqg## h{fruldwh## eruurzlqj/## exw## lq## d## yleudqw# hfrqrp|/#|rx#fdqqrw#kdyh#rqh#zlwkrxw#wkh#rwkhu1# # # # # # # # Lq## uhfhqw## |hduv/## wkh## zruog## hfrqrp|## kdv## frph## wr## uhvhpeoh## Pdqghyloohᄊv# ehhklyh1#Wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#+dqg#d#ihz# # # # # # # # rwkhu## ulfk#lqgxvwuldo# # # frxqwulhv#olnh#Vsdlq# # # dqg#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp,#kdyh#ehhq#vshqglqj#pruh#wkdq#wkh|#surgxfh#ru#hduq#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkxv#eruurzlqj#wr#ilqdqfh#wkh#gliihuhqfh1#Srruhu#frxqwulhv#olnh#Fklqd#ru#Ylhwqdp# # # # # # # # # # # #
kdyh#ehhq#grlqj#wkh#rssrvlwh1# # # # # Hqhuj|#xvh#lv#d#jrrg#lqglfdwru#ri#dfwxdo#frqvxpswlrq#ri#jrrgv1#Hdfk#shuvrq#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#xvhg#:1;#wrqv#ri#rlo#lq#5336/#zklfk#zdv#derxw#wzlfh#wkh#dprxqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # xvhg#shu#shuvrq#lq#Iudqfh/#Jhupdq|/#dqg#Mdsdq>#derxw#:#wlphv#wkh#dprxqw#xvhg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Fklqd>#dqg#48#wlphv#wkh#dprxqw#xvhg#lq#Lqgld1#Ri#frxuvh/#shu#fdslwd#lqfrph#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## lv## dprqj## wkh## kljkhvw## lq## wkh## zruog/## exw## lwv## frqvxpswlrq## lv# glvsursruwlrqdwho|#kljk#uhodwlyh#wr#rwkhu#ulfk#frxqwulhv1#Dqg#ehfdxvh#lwv#vdylqjv# # # # # # # # # # # duh## frpphqvxudwho|## orz/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## ilqdqfhg## lwv## vshqglqj## lq## 5339## e|# eruurzlqj#:3#shufhqw#ri#wkh#zruogᄊv#h{fhvv#vdylqjv1# # # # # # # # Wklv## sdwwhuq#ri#vshqglqj#hphujhg/# # # # # lq#sduw/# # # ehfdxvh## X1V1## srolflhv## hqfrxudjhg# ghew0ixhohg#vshqglqj/#erwk#lq#qrupdo# # # # # # wlphv## dqg#dv# # # d#zd|#rxw#ri#uhfhvvlrqv/#dqg# # # # # # ehfdxvh#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#zhuh#zloolqj#wr#dffrpprgdwh#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhvᄊ## qhhgv1## Frxqwulhv## olnh## Fkloh/## Fklqd/## Jhupdq|/## Mdsdq/## Pdod|vld/## Vdxgl# Dudeld/## dqg## Vrxwk## Nruhd## vxssolhg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## e|## iroorzlqj## d## sdwwhuq## ri# jurzwk## wkdw## hpskdvl}hg## h{sruwv## dqg## ilqdqfhg## lw## e|## ehlqj## zloolqj## wr## krog## X1V1# ghew/## pxfk## dv## wkh## wudghvphq## khog## wkh## LRXv## ri## wkh## vshqgwkuliw## orugv## ri# Pdqghyloohᄊv## wlph1## Iru## pdq|#ri#wkhvh# # # # frxqwulhv/## vxsso|lqj#iruhljq#qhhgv# # # # zdv## d# pruh#vwdeoh#sdwk#wr#jurzwk#wkdq#fuhdwlqj#wkhlu#rzq1# # # # # # # # # Wklv## pxwxdoo|## ehqhilfldo## exw## xowlpdwho|## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## htxloleulxp## kdv## ehhq# glvuxswhg## e|## wkh## ilqdqfldo## fulvlv## dqg## wkh## vxevhtxhqw## grzqwxuq1## Olnh## pdq|## d# ghyhorslqj## frxqwu|## ehiruh## lw/## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## frph## wr## uhfrjql}h## wkdw## wkh# vshqglqj## ilqdqfhg## e|## d## srsxolvw## fuhglw## h{sdqvlrq## lv## w|slfdoo|## xqsurgxfwlyh1# Lqghewhg#X1V1#krxvhkrogv/#zhljkhg#grzq#e|#krxvhv#wkdw#duh#zruwk#ohvv#wkdq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # pruwjdjhv#wkh|#rzh/#kdyh#vwduwhg#vdylqj#pruh1#Wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#vshqglqj#grhv#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # froodsvh/#wkh#X1V1#jryhuqphqw#kdv#vwhsshg#lq#wr#vshqg/#exw#wkhuh#duh#olplwv#wr#krz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pxfk#lw#fdq#gr# # # # # hiihfwlyho|1## Frqvhqvxv## iruhfdvwv## wrgd|#vxjjhvw#wkh# # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# zloo#kdyh#wr#vhwwoh#iru#d#shulrg#ri#uhodwlyho|#vorz#jurzwk1#Iruhfdvwlqj#lv#dozd|v# # # # # # # # # # # # # # gliilfxow#+hvshfldoo|#derxw#wkh#ixwxuh$,/#exw#li#wkhvh#iruhfdvwv#duh#fruuhfw/#vxvwdlqhg# # # # # # # # # # # # kljk#xqhpsor|phqw#zloo#frpsrxqg#xqfhuwdlqw|#iru#d#plggoh#fodvv#douhdg|#klw#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # vwdjqdqw#zdjhv1#Wkh|#zloo#kdyh#wr#idfh#doo#wklv#zlwkrxw#wkh#rsldwh#ri#ulvlqj#krxvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sulfhv#dqg#looxvru|#zhdowk1#Krxvhkrogv#lq#Vsdlq#dqg#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp#duh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#d# # # vlplodu## vlwxdwlrq/## zkloh## vpdoohu## frxqwulhv## olnh## Juhhfh## duh## rq#wkh# # # yhujh## ri# fulvlv1# Suxghqw## pdfurhfrqrplf## pdqdjhphqw## vxjjhvwv## wkdw## odujh0ghilflw## frxqwulhv# vkrxog#eh#pruh#fduhixo# # # # # derxw#vshqglqj#dqg#vdyh#pruh1#Li#wkh#zruog#hfrqrp|#lv# # # # # # # # # # qrw#wr# # # vorz## frqvlghudeo|/## wkh## frxqwulhv## zlwk#wudgh# # # vxusoxvhv## zloo## kdyh## wr## riivhw# wklv#vkliw#e|#vshqglqj#pruh1#Lghdoo|/#wkh#ulfkhu#dprqj#wkhpᄇJhupdq|#dqg#Mdsdq# # # # # # # # # # # # ᄇvkrxog#lpsuryh#surgxfwlylw|#lq#grphvwlfdoo|#rulhqwhg#vhfwruv#olnh#edqnlqj#dqg# # # # # # # # # # uhwdlolqj#vr# # # wkdw#wkh# # # dgghg## jurzwk#ohdgv# # # wr## juhdwhu## lqfrphv## dqg## pruh## vshqglqj/# zkloh## srruhu## exw## idvw0jurzlqj## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## olnh## Fklqd## dqg## Ylhwqdp# vkrxog## judgxdoo|## uhgxfh## wkhlu## hpskdvlv## rq## h{sruwv## dqg## surprwh## grphvwlf# frqvxpswlrq1# Wkhuh## lv## hyhq## vrph## krsh## wkdw## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## zloo## vwduw## uxqqlqj## odujh# wudgh## ghilflwv## rqfh## djdlq## dqg## sxoo## wkh## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv## rxw## ri## wkhlu## jurzwk# voxps/## hvshfldoo|## li## pxowlodwhudo## ohqglqj## lqvwlwxwlrqv## duh## uhiruphg## wr## eh## pruh# vxssruwlyh#ri#eruurzlqj1#Vxfk#d#krsh#lv#xquhdolvwlf#dqg#hyhq#gdqjhurxv/#ehfdxvh# # # # # # # # # # # #
ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## kdyh## klvwrulfdoo|## irxqg## lw## gliilfxow## wr## vdiho|## h{sdqg# grphvwlf#ghpdqg#ilqdqfhg#zlwk#iruhljq#eruurzlqj1#Wkh#sureohp#lv#wkdw#grphvwlf# # # # # # # # # # # ghpdqg## w|slfdoo|## h{sdqgv## udslgo|## dw## wlphv## zkhq## wkh## jryhuqphqw## kdv## srolwlfdo# dlpv## ru## wkh## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## kdv## vnhzhg## lqfhqwlyhv1## Lq## vxfk## vlwxdwlrqv/## wkh# ixqgdphqwdo## doorfdwlrq## ri## uhvrxufhv## lv## glvwruwhg1## Dqwlflsdwhg## ilqdqfldo## vxssruw# iurp## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## rqo|## lqfuhdvhv## zdvwhixo## vshqglqj## ehiruh## wkh# lqhylwdeoh#fulvlv1#Luuhvsrqvleoh#iruhljq#ohqghuv#jhw#d#odujhu#vxevlg|/#dqg#wkh#vl}h# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh# # # kroh## wkdw#wd{sd|huv# # # hyhqwxdoo|#kdyh# # # wr## iloo## lqfuhdvhv1## Wkhuh## lv/## ri#frxuvh/# # vrph#urrp#iru# # # # pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv#wr#lpsuryh#wkh#dydlodelolw|#ri#ordqv#wr# # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## zlwk#uhvsrqvleoh# # # srolflhv/## li#qrwklqj#hovh# # # # vr## wkdw#frxqwulhv# # # gr## qrw#uxq# # wudgh#vxusoxvhv#rqo|#wr#exlog#xs#iruhljq#h{fkdqjh#uhvhuyhv1#Exw#lq#wkh#iruhvhhdeoh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ixwxuh/#wkh#uhvsrqvh#wr#wkh#vxvwdlqhg#uhgxfwlrq#lq#lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|#wudgh#ghilflwv# # # # # # # # # # # vkrxog#qrw#eh#d#frpphqvxudwh#vxvwdlqhg#h{sdqvlrq#ri#ghyhorslqj0frxqwu|#ghilflwv# # # # # # # # # # dqg## ghewv1## Lqvwhdg/## lw#vkrxog# # # uhtxluh## d## qduurzlqj#ri#wudgh# # # # vxusoxvhv## durxqg## wkh# zruog/#dprqj#erwk#lqgxvwuldo#dqg#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv1# # # # # # # Lq#sudfwlfh/#dq|#vxfk#vkliw#zloo#eh#srolwlfdoo|#sdlqixo#lq#wkh#vkruw#whup#erwk#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ghilflw#dqg#iru#vxusoxv#frxqwulhv1#Hyhq#dv#L#zulwh/#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#lv#kroglqj# # # # # # # ## # # # # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv#duwlilfldoo|#orz#+hvshfldoo|#lq#wkh#krxvlqj#pdunhw,#lq#wkh#krshv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # krxvhkrogv## zloo## vwduw## frqvxplqj#pruh# # # djdlqᄇdiwhu## doo/## krxvhkrog## frqvxpswlrq# kdv## ehhq## wkh## sulpdu|## vrxufh## ri## jurzwk## lq## uhfhqw## |hduv1## Fklqd## lv## dfwlyho|# lqwhuyhqlqj## wr## vwdelol}h## wkh## ydoxh## ri## wkh## uhqplqel## djdlqvw## wkh## groodu## vr## wkdw## lwv# h{sruwv## gr## qrw## vxiihu1## Wkhvh## p|rslf## dfwlrqv## zloo## khos## hqwuhqfk## d## orqjhu0whup# sdwwhuq## ri## ehkdylru## wkdw## zloo## pdnh## lw## kdughu## wr## pryh## dzd|## iurp## wkh## fxuuhqw# xqvxvwdlqdeoh#htxloleulxp1# # Ri## frxuvh/## dv## Khuehuw## Vwhlq/## wkh## fkdlupdq## ri## Ulfkdug## Ql{rqᄊv## Frxqflo## ri# Hfrqrplf## Dgylvruv/## rqfh## vdlg/## ᄈLi## vrphwklqj## lv## xqvxvwdlqdeoh/## lw## zloo## vwrs1ᄡ# Iruhljq#lqyhvwruv# # # kdyh## ehfrph## lqfuhdvlqjo|#zdu|#derxw#wkh# # # # # dprxqw#ri#ghew#wkh# # # # X1V1#jryhuqphqw#kdv#kdg#wr#lvvxh#wr#ilqdqfh#lwv#ghilflwv1#Zlwk#wkh#pdmrulw|#ri#X1V1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wd{sd|huv#eholhylqj#wkh|#kdyh#ehqhilwhg#olwwoh#iurp#wkh#errp#|hduv/#wkh#edwwoh#ryhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkr#zloo# # # ehdu## wkh#exughq#ri#dgglwlrqdo# # # # # wd{hv#frxog#wxuq#xjo|1#Xqolnh#wkh#w|slfdo# # # # # # # hphujlqj0pdunhw#frxqwu|/# # # wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## kdv## qrw#vxiihuhg# # # d## ᄈvxgghq#vwrsᄡ# # # ri# fdslwdo#lqiorzv#gxulqj#wklv#fulvlv/#ehfdxvh#lw#kdv#vwloo#ehhq#deoh#wr#dwwudfw#fdslwdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#hdv|#whupv#iurp#wkh#uhvw#ri#wkh#zruog1#Krzhyhu/#li#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#ihdu#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#zloo#eh#xqolnho|#wr#dfklhyh#wkh#srolwlfdo#frqvhqvxv#qhhghg#wr#vhw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv## jryhuqphqw#ilqdqfhv# # # lq#rughu/# # # wkh|#frxog# # # vwduw#zruu|lqj#wkdw#wkh# # # # # jryhuqphqw# zloo## iroorz## wkh## wlph0krqruhg## sdwk#ri#uhgxflqj#wkh# # # # # uhdo## ydoxh## ri#lwv# # # sxeolf## ghew# wkurxjk#d#erxw#ri#kljk#lqiodwlrq1#Li#wkh|#wdnh#iuljkw/#wkh|#zloo#vhoo#wkhlu#kroglqjv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # X1V1## jryhuqphqw## erqgv/## fdxvlqj## wkh## ydoxh## ri## wkh## groodu## wr## volgh## pruh## txlfno|1# X1V1## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## pljkw## kdyh## wr## jr## xs## vxevwdqwldoo|## wr## uhwdlq## iruhljq## lqyhvwru# lqwhuhvw/## wkhuhe|## uhgxflqj## X1V1## jurzwk## hyhq## ixuwkhu## wkdq## dqwlflsdwhg1## Wkdw## vkliw# zloo#eulqj#grzq#wkh#X1V1#wudgh#ghilflw#dqg#vshqglqj/#exw#lq#d#zd|#wkdw#pd{lpl}hv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # sdlq#doo#durxqg1# # # Hyhq#li#wkh#vwdwxv#txr#grhv#shuvlvw#iru#orqjhu#wkdq#zh#h{shfw/#wkhuh#duh#orqjhu0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uxq## frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## pdlqwdlqlqj## wkh## fxuuhqw## sdwwhuq## ri## lpedodqfhv1## Rqh## lv## wkh# lvvxh## ri## hqylurqphqwdo## vxvwdlqdelolw|## durxqg## wkh## zruog1## Xqgrxewhgo|/## dv# ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#jurzq#ulfkhu/#wkhlu#krxvhkrogv#zloo#orrn#wr#frqvxph#pruh1# # # # # # # # # # # Dw#fxuuhqw#ohyhov#ri#whfkqrorj|/#lw#lv#vlpso|#lqihdvleoh#iru#wkh#zruog#wr#dvsluh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
frqvxph## dv## pxfk/## dqg## zdvwh## dv## pxfk/## dv## wkh## dyhudjh## vxexuedq## Dphulfdq# krxvhkrog#grhv=#dv#wkh#iruphu#Lqgldq#ilqdqfh#plqlvwhu#\dvkzdqw#Vlqkd#sxw#lw/#zh# # # # # # # # # # # # # 6# zrxog## wkhq#kdyh# # # qr## zruog## wr## olyh## lq1 # Qr## grxew#whfkqrorj|#zloo# # # # lpsuryh## ryhu# wlph/## pdnlqj## d## xqlw## ri## frqvxpswlrq## surjuhvvlyho|## ohvv## ghvwuxfwlyh## wr## wkh# hqylurqphqw1## Qhyhuwkhohvv/## li## vdfulilfhv## duh## wr## eh## hyhqo|## vsuhdg## dfurvv## wkh# zruog/#lw#pdnhv#vhqvh#iru#frqvxpswlrq#jurzwk#wr#vkliw#iurp#ulfk#ghilflw#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#ghyhorslqj#rqhv1# # # Lw## lv## dovr## lq## wkh## h{sruwhuvᄊ## orqj0uxq## vhoi0lqwhuhvw## wr## dowhu## wkhlu## vwudwhjlhv1# Dowkrxjk## wkh## uholdqfh## rq## h{sruwv## kdv## ehhq## yhu|## vxffhvvixo## dw## erwk## surprwlqj# udslg## jurzwk## dqg## hqvxulqj## vwdelolw|/## wkh## Mdsdqhvh## h{shulhqfh## udlvhv## txhvwlrqv# derxw## zkhwkhu## frxqwulhv## vkrxog## iroorz## lw## xqwlo## wkh|## ehfrph## ulfkᄇdqg## ulvn# vxevhtxhqw#vwdjqdwlrqᄇru# # # wxuq#wr# # # d## pruh## edodqfhg## sdwk#orqj#ehiruh# # # # wkhq1## Iru## d# qxpehu## ri## h{sruwhuv/## olnh## Fklqd## dqg## Pdod|vld/## wkh## lqlwldo## skdvh## ri## exloglqj# fdsdelolwlhv## lv## orqj## ryhu1## Wkh## fkdoohqjh## qrz## lv## wr## eurdghq## wkhlu## vrxufhv## ri# jurzwk/#zlwkgudzlqj#lpsolflw#dqg#h{solflw#vxevlglhv#wr#h{sruwhuv#judgxdoo|#zkloh# # # # # # # # # # h{whqglqj## wkh## glvflsolqh## ri## frpshwlwlrq## wr## wkh## vhfwruv## irfxvhg## rq## grphvwlf# surgxfwlrq1## Odujh## frxqwulhv## olnh## Fklqd## pd|## kdyh## qr## dowhuqdwlyh## exw## wr## zhdq# wkhpvhoyhv## rii## ghshqghqfh## rq## joredo## ghpdqg/## ehfdxvh## wkh## zruogᄊv## delolw|## wr# devrue#Fklqhvh#h{sruwv#zloo#eh#olplwhg#li#Fklqd#grhv#qrw#lpsruw#pruh#jrrgv#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp1## Ri#frxuvh/# # # wkh## zruogᄊv## srolwlfdo## wrohudqfh## iru## ex|lqj#Fklqhvh# # # jrrgv## pd|# zhdu#rxw#orqj#ehiruh#lwv#hfrqrplf#fdsdflw|#wr#ex|#wkhp#grhv1# # # # # # # # # # # Fkdqjh## zloo## wkhuhiruh## khos## joredo## vwdelolw|## dqg## vxvwdlqdelolw|## dqg## zloo## eh# ehqhilfldo#iru#hdfk#frxqwu|#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq1#Exw#fkdqjh#grhv#xsvhw#wkh#fr}|#vwdwxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # txr#dqg#wkh#lqwhuhvwv#wkdw#ehqhilw#iurp#lw1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#wkh#uhdo#hvwdwh#oree|#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#kdv#qr#ghvluh#wr#vhh#jryhuqphqw#vxssruw#iru#krxvlqj#glplqlvk/#hyhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkrxjk#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#suredeo|#kdv#idu# # # # # # # # pruh#krxvlqj#vwrfn#wkdq#lw#fdq#diirug1# # # # # # # Vlploduo|/## wkh## h{sruw## oree|## lq## Fklqd## kdv## qr## lqwhuhvw## lq## vhhlqj## wkh## uhqplqel# vwuhqjwkhq#vljqlilfdqwo|1#Vr#zh#duh#fdxjkw#ehwzhhq#wkh#urfn#ri#d#ilqdqfldoo|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # hqylurqphqwdoo|## xqvxvwdlqdeoh## sdwwhuq## ri## joredo## ghpdqg## dqg## d## kdug## sodfh## ri## d# srolwlfdoo|#gliilfxow#fkdqjh#lq#grphvwlf#srolflhv1# # # # # # Wkhvh## lvvxhv## duh## qrw## qhz1## Wkh## srolwlfdo## vflhqwlvw## Mhiiu|## Iulhghq## ri## Kduydug# Xqlyhuvlw|## zulwhv## ri## wkh## 4<53v/## zkhq## wkhuh## zdv## d## pdfurhfrqrplf## lpedodqfh# ehwzhhq#d# # # juhdw#srzhu# # # uxqqlqj#d# # # vxvwdlqhg## fxuuhqw0dffrxqw#ghilflw#dqg# # # # d## ulvlqj# 7##Wkh#ulvlqj#srzhu#zdv#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#dqg#wkh# srzhu#wkdw#ilqdqfhg#wkh#ghilflwv1 # # # # # # # # # # # # juhdw#srzhu#zdv#Jhupdq|/#zklfk#kdg#eruurzhg#khdylo|#iurp#deurdg# # # # # # # # # # wr#ixho#d#frqvxpswlrq#errp#wkdw/#dprqj#rwkhu#wklqjv/#gdpshqhg#vrph#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#xqghuo|lqj#vrfldo#whqvlrqv#wkdw#ehvhw#wkh#Zhlpdu#Uhsxeolf1#Wklv#zdv#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # vpdoo## pdwwhu=## zlwkrxw## Dphulfdq## ilqdqflqj## wr## vxvwdlq## wkh## g|qdplvp## ri## wkh# Jhupdq#hfrqrp|/#Zhlpdu#vrfldo#dqg#srolwlfdo#lqvwdelolw|#pljkw#kdyh#fdxvhg# # # # # # # # # # vhulrxv#sureohpv#iru#wkh#uhvw#ri#Hxurshᆱ1# # # # # # # Wkh## Jhupdq0Dphulfdq## ilqdqfldo## uhodwlrqvkls## uhvwhg## rq## zhdn## srolwlfdo# irxqgdwlrqv/#dv# # # qhlwkhu## frxqwu|#zdv# # # uhdoo|#suhsduhg#iru# # # # wkh## lpsolfdwlrqv## ri# wkh## fdslwdo## iorzv1## Wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv## qrw## zloolqj## wr## surylgh## dq## rshq# pdunhw## iru## Jhupdq## jrrgv## wkdw## zrxog## idflolwdwh## ghew## vhuylfh/## ru## dq|# jryhuqphqw## phdvxuhv## wr## ghdo## zlwk## hyhqwxdo## ilqdqfldo## glvwuhvv/## dqg## wkh# Jhupdqv## zhuh## xqzloolqj## ru## xqdeoh## wr## pdnh## wkh## vdfulilfhv## qhfhvvdu|## wr#
8 surylgh#surpsw#ghew#vhuylfh1 # # #
# Dv#wkh#Ghsuhvvlrq#klw/#hdfk#frxqwu|#orrnhg#lqzdug/#ljqrulqj#wkh#frqvhtxhqfhv# # # # # # # # # # # iru#rwkhu#frxqwulhv1#Wkh#Vprrw0Kdzoh|#Dfw#sdvvhg#e|#wkh#X1V1#Frqjuhvv#lq#Mxqh# # # # # # # # # # # # # 4<63#udlvhg#wudgh#wduliiv#rq#lpsruwv#lq#dq#dwwhpsw#wr#surwhfw#X1V1#mrev/#pdnlqj#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwloo#pruh#gliilfxow#iru#ghewru#frxqwulhv#durxqg#wkh#zruog#wr#vhuylfh#ghewv1#Wkhvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## hlwkhu## ghidxowhg## rq#wkhlu# # # ghew## ru## ryhuwkuhz## jryhuqphqwv## wkdw## wulhg## wr# dgrsw#wkh#dxvwhulw|#phdvxuhv#uhtxluhg#wr#vhuylfh#lw1#Klwohu#zdv#fduulhg#wr#srzhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wkh#frdwwdlov#ri#hfrqrplf#glvwuhvv/#dqg#rqh#ri#klv#iluvw#dfwv#diwhu#wdnlqj#srzhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#Mdqxdu|#4<66#zdv#wr#ghfoduh#wkdw#Jhupdq|#zrxog#qrw#sd|#lwv#iruhljq#fuhglwruv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Klv#phvvdjh#ri#kdwh#dqg#uhyhqjh#ihoo#rq#uhfhswlyh#hduv#lq#d#Jhupdq|#wkdw#ihow#loo0 # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wuhdwhg#e|#wkh#joredo#hfrqrp|1# # # # # Wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## grhv## qrw## kdyh## wkh## srolwlfdo## zhdnqhvvhv## ri## wkh## Zhlpdu# Uhsxeolf/## exw## wkh## eurdghu## srlqw## lv## wkdw## zlwkrxw## joredo## hfrqrplf## frrshudwlrq# zkhq#fkdqjh#lv#qhhghg/#frxqwulhv#frxog#ghvfhqg#lqwr#rssruwxqlvwlf#qdwlrqdolvp#wr# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ghwulphqw## ri## wkh## joredo## hfrqrp|## dqg## wkh## joredo## srolwlfdo## hqylurqphqw1# Qdwlrqdolvp/## frxsohg## zlwk#juhdw# # # idlwk#lq#wkh# # # # srzhu## ri## wkh## jryhuqphqw## wr## hqdfw# grphvwlf#edujdlqv#ehwzhhq#oderu#dqg#fdslwdo/#kdv#ehhq#vhhq#ehiruh=#lw#zdv#fdoohg# # # # # # # # # # # # # idvflvp#wkhq1#Lw#lv#d#ghyhorsphqw#wr#eh#dyrlghg#dw#doo#frvwv1# # # # # # # # # # # # Rxu## h{lvwlqj#joredo# # # lqvwlwxwlrqv/#olnh#wkh#LPI#dqg#wkh#Zruog#Edqn/#zloo# # # # # # # # # # olnho|# suryh## lqhiihfwlyh## lq#irvwhulqj#joredo# # # # frrshudwlrq#li#wkh|#frqwlqxh# # # # # wr## rshudwh## dv# wkh|## kdyh## lq## wkh## sdvw1## Wkh|## zloo## kdyh## wr## pdnh## udglfdo## fkdqjhv## lq## krz## wkh|# ixqfwlrq/## dsshdolqj## pruh## gluhfwo|## wr## wkh## shrsoh## wkdq## wr## wkhlu## ohdghuv/## wr## vriw# srzhu#udwkhu#wkdq#wr#kdug#srzhu1#L#glvfxvv#krz#vxfk#dq#dssurdfk#gryhwdlov#zhoo# # # # # # ## # # # # # # zlwk#wkh#uhirupv#wkdw#duh#qhhghg#lq#Fklqd1#Fohduo|/#wkh#vriw#srzhu#ri#pxowlodwhudo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rujdql}dwlrqv#fdq#dovr#eh#xvhg#wr#surprwh#wkh#uhirupv/#glvfxvvhg#lq#wkh#suhylrxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkdswhu/#wkdw#duh#qhfhvvdu|#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1# # # # # # # #
Wkh#J053#dqg#wkh#LPI # # # # # Lq## Vhswhpehu## 533</## wkh## ohdghuv## ri## wkh## zruogᄊv## odujhvw## hfrqrplhv## phw## lq# Slwwvexujk#dqg#ghvljqdwhg#wkhlu#jurxs/#wkh#J053/#dv#wkh#sulpdu|#iruxp#iru#joredo# # # # # # # # # # # # # hfrqrplf#frrshudwlrq1#Pxfk#olnh#lwv#suhghfhvvru#rujdql}dwlrq/#wkh#J0:/#wkh#qhz# # # # # # # # # # # vhoi0surfodlphg## jxdugldq## ri## wkh## zruog## hfrqrp|## h{foxghv## pdq|## frxqwulhvᄇ# doprvw## d## qhfhvvlw|## lq## rughu## wr## jhw## gldorjxh## udwkhu## wkdq## d## fdfrskrq|/## exw# xqghprfudwlf#qhyhuwkhohvv1#Zkr#lv#lq#dqg#zkr#lv#rxw#lv#dovr#vrphzkdw#duelwudulo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghflghg=## Dujhqwlqd## lv## d## phpehu/## zkloh## Vsdlq/## zlwk## d## JGS## wkdw## lv## qhduo|## ilyh# wlphv#wkh#vl}h#ri#Dujhqwlqdᄊv/#lv#d#phpehu#rqo|#lqgluhfwo|/#wkurxjk#wkh#Hxurshdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # Xqlrq1#Eh#wkdw#dv# # # # # lw#pd|/#wkh#ohdghuv# # # # # ri#wkh#J053#sdwwhg#wkhpvhoyhv# # # # # # rq#wkh#edfn# # # iru#d#ᄈfrruglqdwhgᄡ#ilvfdo#dqg#prqhwdu|#vwlpxoxv#lq#uhvsrqvh#wr#wkh#fulvlv#dqg#kdg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dq## xqxvxdoo|## eulhi## +iru## dq## riilfldo## frppxqltxー,## ghvfulswlrq## ri## wkh## uhvxow=## ᄈLw# zrunhg1ᄡ#Wkh|#zhqw#rq#wr#vd|=#ᄈWrgd|#zh#duh#odxqfklqj#d#Iudphzrun#iru#Vwurqj/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Vxvwdlqdeoh/#dqg#Edodqfhg#Jurzwk1#Wr#sxw#lq#sodfh#wklv#iudphzrun/#zh#frpplw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # ghyhors## d## surfhvv## zkhuhe|#zh# # # vhw## rxw## rxu## remhfwlyhv/## sxw## iruzdug## srolflhv## wr# dfklhyh#wkhvh#remhfwlyhv/#dqg#wrjhwkhu#dvvhvv#rxu#surjuhvv1#Zh#zloo#dvn#wkh#LPI# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## khos## xv## zlwk## lwv## dqdo|vlv## ri## krz## rxu## uhvshfwlyh## qdwlrqdo## ru## uhjlrqdo## srolf|# iudphzrunv## ilw## wrjhwkhuᆱ1## Zh## zloo## zrun## wrjhwkhu## wr## hqvxuh## wkdw## rxu## ilvfdo/# prqhwdu|/## wudgh/## dqg## vwuxfwxudo## srolflhv## duh## froohfwlyho|## frqvlvwhqw## zlwk## pruh# 9# vxvwdlqdeoh#dqg#edodqfhg#wudmhfwrulhv#ri#jurzwk1ᄡ # # # # # Vr## wkh## J053/## kdylqj#vxffhvvixoo|#frruglqdwhg# # # # uhvsrqvhv## wr## wkh## fulvlv/## lv## qrz# wdnlqj## rq## wkh## eljjhu## fkdoohqjh## ri## pdnlqj## vxuh## qdwlrqdo## jurzwk## vwudwhjlhv## ilw# wrjhwkhu#wr#uhedodqfh#joredo#jurzwk1#Wklv#lv#suhflvho|#zkdw#L#kdyh#dujxhg#pxvw#eh# # # # # # # # # ## # # # grqh1#Jlyhq#lwv#uhfhqw#dfklhyhphqwv#gxulqj#wkh#fulvlv/#krzhyhu/#fdq#zh#kdyh#dq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # frqilghqfh#wkdw#wkh#J053/#zrunlqj#wkurxjk#wkh#LPI/#zloo#eh#hiihfwlyhB# # # # # # # # # # # Xqiruwxqdwho|#qrw1# # # Lw## lv## yhu|#hdv|#wr# # # # jhw## srolwlfldqv## wr## vshqg## lq#wkh# # # idfh## ri#d# # fulvlv## dqg## wr## jhw## fhqwudo## edqnv## wr## hdvh## prqhwdu|## srolf|1## Qr## frruglqdwlrq## lv# uhtxluhg/#dv#hyhu|#frxqwu|#zdqwv#wr#sxps#xs#lwv#hfrqrp|#wr#wkh#h{whqw#srvvleoh=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#J053#ohdghuv#zhuh#sxvklqj#rq#dq#rshq#grru#zkhq#wkh|#fdoohg#iru#frruglqdwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwlpxoxv1## Wkh## uhdo## gliilfxowlhv## hphujh## zkhq## frxqwulhv## qhhg## wr## xqghuwdnh# srolwlfdoo|## sdlqixo## uhirupv/## uhirupv## wkdw## pljkw## hyhq## vhhp#wr# # # eh## pruh## rulhqwhg# wrzdug## khoslqj## rwkhu## frxqwulhv## lq## wkh## vkruw## uxq## udwkhu## wkdq## wkh## uhiruphu## lwvhoi1# Srolwlfv#lv#dozd|v#orfdo=#wkhuh#lv#qr#frqvwlwxhqf|#iru#wkh#joredo#hfrqrp|1# # # # # # # # # # # # L#nqrz/#ehfdxvh#zh#kdyh#ehhq#wkurxjk#dq#dwwhpsw#dw#joredo#srolf|#frruglqdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehiruh/#suhflvho|#wr#ghdo#zlwk#wkh#sureohp#ri#odujh#joredo#wudgh#lpedodqfhv1#Wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # hiiruw#idlohg/#dqg#lw#lv#lqvwuxfwlyh#wr#xqghuvwdqg#zk|1# # # # # # # # # Lq#5339/# # # dv## wkh## X1V1## fxuuhqw0dffrxqw#ghilflw#eurnh# # # # uhfrug## diwhu## uhfrug## dqg## dv# Fklqdᄊv#fxuuhqw0dffrxqw#vxusoxv#vrduhg/#wkh#LPI#ehfdph#ghhso|#frqfhuqhg1#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # pdqdjlqj#gluhfwru/#Urguljr#gh#Udwr/#ghflghg#d#qhz#dssurdfk#zdv#zduudqwhg1#Zh# # # # # # # # # # # # dw#wkh#Ixqg#+L#zdv#vwloo#wkh#fklhi#hfrqrplvw#wkhq,#fdoohg#rq#wkh#ilyh#hqwlwlhv#prvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhvsrqvleoh#iru#wkh#lpedodqfhvᄇwkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#wkh#Hxur#}rqh/#Fklqd/#Mdsdq/# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#Vdxgl#Dudeldᄇwr#frph#wrjhwkhu#wr#glvfxvv#krz#wkh|#zrxog#mrlqwo|#eulqj#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lpedodqfhv## grzq1## Wr## suhsduh## iru## wkh## phhwlqjv/## L## mrlqwo|## khdghg## dq## LPI## whdp/# zklfk#wudyhohg# # # durxqg## wkh## zruog## lq#wkh# # # vxpphu## ri#5339/# # # wu|lqj#wr# # # vhfxuh## vrph#
djuhhphqw#dprqj#wkh#frxqwulhv#wkdw#kdg#ehhq#fdoohg#wrjhwkhu#iru#wkh#frqvxowdwlrq1# # # # # # # # # # # # Zh## zhuh## iroorzlqj## wkh## dgdjh## wkdw## qrwklqj## ri## vxevwdqfh## lv## vhwwohg## dw## prvw# lqwhuqdwlrqdo#phhwlqjv>#doo#lpsruwdqw#lvvxhv#duh#xvxdoo|#vhwwohg#ehiruhkdqg1# # # # # # # # # Wkh#zhdwkhu#udqjhg#iurp#455#ghjuhhv#lq#wkh#vkdgh#lq#Ul|dgk/#Vdxgl#Dudeld/#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # xqvhdvrqdeo|#frro#lq#Wrn|r1#Wkh#uhvsrqvh#iurp#rxu#lqwhuorfxwruv#zdv/#krzhyhu/# # # # # # # # # # # suhww|## xqlirup1## Frxqwulhv## djuhhg## wkdw## wkh## wudgh## lpedodqfhv## zhuh## d## srwhqwldo# vrxufh## ri## lqvwdelolw|/## dqg## hfrqrplf## uhirupv## zhuh## qhhghg## wr## eulqj## wkhp#grzq# # ehiruh## pdunhwv## wrrn## iuljkw## ru## srolwlfldqv## ghflghg## wr## hqwhu## wkh## iud|## zlwk# surwhfwlrqlvw#phdvxuhv1#Exw#hdfk#frxqwu|#zdv#wkhq#txlfn#wr#srlqw#rxw#zk|#lw#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw#uhvsrqvleoh#iru#wkh#lpedodqfhv#dqg#zk|#lw#zrxog#eh#vr#pxfk#hdvlhu#iru#vrph# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # rwkhu#frxqwu|#wr#sxvk#d#pdjlf#exwwrq#wr#pdnh#wkhp#glvdsshdu1# # # # # # # # # # # Iru#lqvwdqfh/#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#dxwkrulwlhv#dujxhg#wkdw#lw#zdv#qrw#wkhlu#idxow#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## uhvw## ri## wkh## zruog## zdv## vr## hdjhu## wr## sxw## wkhlu## prqh|## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv=# lpedodqfhv#zhuh#wkh#idxow#ri#wkh#Fklqhvh/#zkr#zhuh#ex|lqj#grooduv#wr#uhvwudlq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dssuhfldwlrq#ri#wkh#uhqplqel1#Lw#zdv#wkh#suhvvxuh#ri#wkhvh#hqruprxv#lqiorzv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # ohg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## wr## frqvxph1## Wkh## Fklqhvh## dujxhg## wkdw## li## wkh|#doorzhg# # # wkh# uhqplqel#wr#dssuhfldwh#idvwhu/#h{sruwv#iurp#Fklqd#wr#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#zrxog#idoo/# # # # # # # # # # # # # zkloh## h{sruwv## iurp## Fdpergld## ru## Ylhwqdp## zrxog## slfn## xs/## dqg## wkh## X1V1## wudgh# ghilflw#zrxog#uhpdlq#xqfkdqjhg1#Lq#wkhlu#ylhz/#wkh#uhdo#sureohp#zdv#wkdw#wkh#X1V1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frqvxphu## kdg#qr#vhoi0uhvwudlqw1#Pruhryhu/#wkhlu# # # # # # wudgh#vxusoxv# # # zdv## vr#odujh#rqo|# # # ehfdxvh#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#olplwhg#Fklqhvh#sxufkdvhv#ri#kljk0whfk#htxlsphqw1#Dqg# # # # # # # # # # # vr## lw## zhqw1## Hyhu|rqh## srlqwhg## wkh## ilqjhu## dw## vrphrqh## hovh1## Wkh## wuxwk## zdv## wkdw# hyhu|rqh#frqwulexwhg#lq#vrph#zd|#wr#wkh#sureohp/#exw#qr#rqh#zdqwhg#wr#eh#sduw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#vroxwlrq1# # Dw## wkh## hqg## ri## 5339/## L## uhwxuqhg## iurp#wkh# # # Ixqg## wr## wkh## Xqlyhuvlw|## ri## Fklfdjr/# ghmhfwhg## wkdw#zh# # # kdg## dffrpsolvkhg## vr## olwwoh1## Zkhq#wkh# # # frqvxowdwlrqv## hyhqwxdoo|# frqfoxghg## lq## 533:/## wkh## Ixqg## ghfoduhg## wkdw## wkh|## kdg## ehhq## d## vxffhvv=## wkhuh## kdg# ehhq## d## iuhh## dqg## iudqn## h{fkdqjh## ri## ylhzv/## zklfk## lv## exuhdxfudwhvh## iru## wrwdo# glvdjuhhphqw1## Hyhu|## frxqwu|## djuhhg## wr## gr## zkdw## lw## kdg## dozd|v## lqwhqghg## wr## gr/# zklfk#zdv#yhu|#olwwoh1#Wkh#frqvxowdwlrqv#kdg#idlohg#wr#surgxfh#frqfuhwh#dfwlrq1#D# # # # # # # # # # # # # ihz## prqwkv## odwhu/## eruq#sduwo|#iurp#wkh# # # # # dfwlrqv## wkdw## fuhdwhg## wkh## lpedodqfhv/## wkh# fulvlv#ehjdq1# # Wkh#LPI#glg#qrw#idlo#ehfdxvh#rxu#dujxphqwv#zhuh#qrw#frqylqflqj1#Wkh#uhdvrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # hyhu|rqh#srlqwhg#d#ilqjhu# # # # # dw#hyhu|rqh#hovh#zdv#qrw#wkdw#wkh|#glg#qrw#xqghuvwdqg# # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#rzq#uhvsrqvlelolw|#exw#ehfdxvh#qr#rqh#zh#vsrnh#wr#frxog#uhdoo|#frpplw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#dfwlrqv#wkdw#zhuh#qhhghg1#Lqghhg/#wkhvh#zhuh#ghflvlrqv#wkdw#hyhq#wkh#khdg#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#frxog#qrw#wdnh1#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#qr#X1V1#suhvlghqw#fdq#frpplw#wr#uhlqlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#exgjhw#ghilflw=#wkdw#lv#d#ghflvlrq#wkdw#rqo|#Frqjuhvv#fdq#wdnh1#Vlploduo|/#qr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Fklqhvh#suhvlghqw#fdq#xqlodwhudoo|#djuhh#wr#doorz#wkh#uhqplqel#wr#dssuhfldwh=#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # lv#d#ghflvlrq#gholehudwhg#iru#prqwkv#e|#ydulrxv#hfkhorqv#ri#wkh#Vwdwh#Frxqflo#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Frppxqlvw#Sduw|1#Pruhryhu/#wkh#qhhghg#fkdqjhv# # # # # # # # zhqw#eh|rqg#uhlqlqj#lq#wkh# # # # # exgjhw## ghilflw## ru## ohwwlqj## wkh## fxuuhqf|## dssuhfldwh1## Wkh|## uhtxluhg## ghhshu# ixqgdphqwdo#fkdqjhv#wr#wkh#hfrqrp|1#Dqg#wkh#joredo#jrrg#frxqwv#iru#olwwoh#dprqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## srolwlfldqv## lq## wkh## X1V1## Frqjuhvv## ru## wkh## Fklqhvh## Frppxqlvw## Sduw|## zkhq## lw# frphv#wr#frqwhpsodwlqj#ixqgdphqwdo#fkdqjh1# # # # # Wklv#lv#zk|/#ghvslwh#krslqj#iru#wkh#ehvw/#L#kdyh#ghhs#vnhswlflvp#wkdw#dq|wklqj# # # # # # # # ## # # # #
zloo## frph## ri#wkh# # # dpelwlrxv## J053## ghfodudwlrq1## Qru## lv## lw#olnho|#wkdw#wkh# # # # # LPI#zloo# # dfklhyh## dq|wklqj#pruh# # # wkdq#lw#glg# # # # lq#wkh# # # pxowlodwhudo## frqvxowdwlrqv## wkdw#hqghg# # # lq# 533:/#fulvlv# # # qrwzlwkvwdqglqj1#Fkdqjh#zloo# # # # frph#rqo|#zkhq#frxqwulhv# # # # # duh#irufhg# # wr#fkdqjh/#ru#ghflgh#lw#lv#lq#wkhlu#ehvw#lqwhuhvw#wr#gr#vr/#exw#wkdw#surfhvv#pd|#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrr#frvwo|/#ru#wrr#vorz/#iru#wkh#joredo#hfrqrp|1# # # # # # # # # Li#grlqj#qrwklqj#lv#qrw#d#yldeoh#rswlrq/#krz# # # # # # # # # # fdq#zh#jhw#joredo#frrshudwlrqB#L# # # # # # wklqn#dq|#dqvzhu#olhv#lq#d#ixqgdphqwdo#uhpdnh#ri#pxowlodwhudo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#olnh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # LPI#dqg#wkh#zd|v#wkh|#lqwhudfw#zlwk#vryhuhljq#frxqwulhv1# # # # # # # # #
Pxowlodwhudo#Lqvwlwxwlrqv#dqg#Wkhlu#Lqioxhqfh # # # # # Pxowlodwhudo## lqvwlwxwlrqv#kdyh#klwkhuwr#zrunhg#lq#wzr#zd|v1#Rqh#dssurdfk#lv# # # # # # # # # # wkh## txdvl0ohjdo## rqh## iroorzhg## e|## wkh## Zruog## Wudgh## Rujdql}dwlrq## +ZWR,/## zklfk# uhjxodwhv#wudgh#ehwzhhq#sduwlflsdwlqj#frxqwulhv1#Wkh#ZWR#edvhv#lwv#dfwlrqv#rq#d# # # # # # # # # # # # vhw#ri#djuhhphqwv#wkdw#olplw#eduulhuv#wr#wudgh1#Wkhvh#djuhhphqwv#kdyh#ehhq#vljqhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## udwlilhg## e|## phpehu## jryhuqphqwv## diwhu## orqj## dqg## dugxrxv## qhjrwldwlrqv1## Wkh# ZWR#kdv#d#glvsxwh0uhvroxwlrq#surfhvv#dlphg#dw#hqiruflqj#sduwlflsdqwvᄊ#dgkhuhqfh# # # # # # # # # # wr## wkh## djuhhphqwv/## dqg## ehfdxvh## wkh## uxohv## duh## uhodwlyho|#fohdu/# # # dgkhuhqfh## fdq#eh# # mxgjhg#lq#d#txdvl0ohjdo#vhwwlqj1#Shqdowlhv#djdlqvw#ylrodwruv/#xvxdoo|#lq#wkh#irup#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # vdqfwlrqv## rq## wkhlu## wudgh/## duh## hdvlo|## lpsrvhg1## Frxqwulhv## gr## jlyh## xs## vrph# vryhuhljqw|/## vxfk## dv## wkh## iuhhgrp## wr## vhw## lpsruw## wduliiv## ru## vxevlgl}h## idyruhg# lqgxvwulhv/#lq#h{fkdqjh#iru#rwkhuv#grlqj#wkh#vdph/#dqg#wkhvh#frqfhvvlrqv#surprwh# # # # # # # # # # # # pxwxdoo|#ehqhilfldo# # # wudgh1## Zkhq#lqgxvwu|#suhvvhv# # # # qdwlrqdo## srolwlfldqv## wr## surwhfw# wkhp/#wkh#srolwlfldqv#fdq#vlpso|#wkurz#xs#wkhlu#kdqgv#dqg#eodph#wkh#ZWR1# # # # # # # # # # # # # D#vhfrqg#dssurdfk/#rqh#wkdw#lv# # # # # # # idu## ohvv## hiihfwlyh#ehfdxvh#ri#wkh#qdwxuh#ri#wkh# # # # # # # wdvn/## lv## wkh## zd|## wkh## LPI## jrhv## derxw## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## pdfurhfrqrplf## pdqdjhphqw# dqg#frruglqdwlrq=#hvvhqwldoo|#wkurxjk#d#surfhvv#ri#h{kruwdwlrq#wkdw#idlov#wr#pryh# # # # # # # # # # # # dq|rqh## h{fhsw## wkrvh## zkr## qhhg## wkh## Ixqgᄊv## prqh|1## Wkh## sureohp#khuh# # # lv## wkdw## wkh# uxohv#ri#wkh#jdph#duh#qrw#fohdu#dw#doo1#Zkhq#grhv#d#sdwwhuq#ri#dfwlrqv#e|#d#frxqwu|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhdwh#joredo#kdupB#Zkhq#wkh#Ihg#fxwv#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wr#wkh#erqh/#dqg#wkxv#vhwv#rii# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # d## joredo## zdyh## ri#ulvn#wdnlqj/# # # # gr## frxqwulhv## hovhzkhuh## kdyh## wkh## uljkw#wr# # # surwhvwB# Frxog#wkh#Ihg#qrw#vd|#lw#lv#irfxvhg#vroho|#rq#X1V1#hfrqrplf#frqglwlrqv/#zklfk#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv#sulpdu|#uhplwB#Zkhq#Fklqd#lqwhuyhqhv#lq#h{fkdqjh#pdunhwv#wr#krog#wkh#ydoxh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#uhqplqel# # # # djdlqvw#wkh#groodu/#lv#lw#xvlqj#xqidlu#phdqv#wr#jdlq#d#frpshwlwlyh# # # # # # # # # # # # dgydqwdjhB#Vrph#kdyh#dujxhg#wkdw#Fklqdᄊv#kxjh#exlogxs#ri#uhvhuyhv#lv#hylghqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # ri#dq#xqidlu# # # # srolf|1:## Exw#xqolnh# # # ghyhorshg## frxqwulhv/## Fklqd## uhvwulfwv## lwv## flwl}hqv# dqg## sulydwh## ilupv## iurp#kroglqj#iruhljq#dvvhwv/# # # # # vr## lw#lv# # # doprvw#lqhylwdeoh# # # wkdw#lwv# # kroglqjv#ri#iruhljq#dvvhwv#zloo#vkrz#xs#dv#fhqwudo#edqn#uhvhuyhv1#Dqg#hyhq#li#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zhuh#suryhg#wkdw#lw#kdg#d#srolf|#ri#gholehudwh#xqghuydoxdwlrq/#frxog#lw#qrw#fodlp# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw#lv#d#srru#frxqwu|/#xvlqj#h{fkdqjh0udwh#xqghuydoxdwlrq#wr#riivhw#lwv#rwkhu#qdwxudo# # # # # # # # # # # # # glvdgydqwdjhvB;# Xqolnh## wkh## ZWR/## wkhuhiruh/## wkh## LPI## fdqqrw## iudph## d## fduhixo## dqg## xqlyhuvdoo|# djuhhg0xsrq#vhw#ri#uxohv1#Dqg#wkhuh#lv#vrph#yluwxh#wr#uxohv1#Dowkrxjk#hvwdeolvklqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # vxfk#uxohv# # # uhtxluhv## dq#hqruprxv# # # dprxqw#ri#qhjrwldwlrq#dqg# # # # # edujdlqlqj/## pdq|#ri# # wkh#sduwlhv#zkr#zrxog#eh#dgyhuvho|#diihfwhg#e|#vshflilf#dvshfwv#ri#wkhp#dovr#vhh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eurdg## orqj0whup## jdlqv## iurp## wkh## iudphzrun1## Dv## d## uhvxow/## lq## wkh## ZWR/# glvdjuhhphqwv#fdq#w|slfdoo|#eh#sdshuhg#ryhu#gxulqj#wkh#orqj#dqg#wruwxrxv#wudgh0 # # # # # # # # # # # qhjrwldwlrq#urxqgv/#zlwk#vrph#jlyh0dqg0wdnh#srvvleoh#lq#vhwwlqj#wkh#ghwdlohg#uxohv1# # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#sureohp#zlwk#wu|lqj#wr#vhfxuh#dq#djuhhphqw#rq#srolf|#uhirupv#dfurvv#d#vhw#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv## rq#d# # # fdvh0e|0fdvh## edvlv/## dv## wkh## Ixqg## kdv## wr## gr## li#lw#lv# # # # wr## eulqj#grzq# # wudgh## lpedodqfhv/## lv## wkdw#zlqqhuv# # # dqg## orvhuv## duh## fohduo|#lghqwlilhg/# # # erwk#dfurvv# # frxqwulhv## dqg## zlwklq## frxqwulhv1## Hdfk## djuhhphqw## lv## vxl## jhqhulv/## dqg## wkh## Ixqg# fdqqrw## pdnh## frpplwphqwv## dfurvv## djuhhphqwv## wr## wu|## wr## dsshdvh## wkrvh## zkr## ihho# wkh|#pd|#orvh#rxw#lq#d#sduwlfxodu#lqvwdqfh1# # # # # # # # Ri## frxuvh/## frxqwulhv## frxog## glvshqvh## zlwk## uxohv## ru## djuhhphqwv## dqg## jlyh#
glvfuhwlrq#wr#rqh# # # # djhqf|/#vxfk#dv# # # # wkh## LPI/#wr#mxgjh# # # # glvsxwhv## dqg#lghqwli|#srolf|# # # ylrodwlrqv## wkdw## fdxvh## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## kdup## rq## d## fdvh0e|0fdvh## edvlv/## zlwk## vrph# shqdowlhv## iru## qrqfrpsoldqfh1## Exw#ehfdxvh# # # pdfurhfrqrplf## srolf|#fryhuv# # # vxfk#d# # eurdg## duhd/## wklv## zrxog## uhtxluh## frxqwulhv## wr## jlyh## xs## d## wuhphqgrxv## dprxqw## ri# vryhuhljqw|#wr#dq#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#exuhdxfudf|/#dq#xqolnho|#vfhqdulr1#Klvwrulfdoo|/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # zruogᄊv#juhdw#srzhuv#kdyh#ehhq#uhoxfwdqw#wr#vhh#lqghshqghqw/#vwurqj#pxowlodwhudo# # # # # # # # # # # rujdql}dwlrqv## hphujh1## Zkhq## vwurqj/## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## kdyh## qrw## ehhq# lqghshqghqw>## dqg## zkhq## lqghshqghqw/## wkh|## kdyh## ehhq## odujho|## luuhohydqw1## Wkh# jurzlqj#srzhu#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#olnh#Fklqd#dqg#Lqgld#lv#xqolnho|#wr#fkdqjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wklv## vlwxdwlrq## ehfdxvh## wkh|## wrr## kdyh## olwwoh## ghvluh## iru## wkhlu## srolflhv## wr## eh# vfuxwlql}hg1# Hyhq#li#dq#rujdql}dwlrq#olnh#wkh#LPI#frxog#eh#lqghshqghqw#ri#wkh#elj#srzhuv/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdv#d#olplwdwlrq=#d#plqgvhw#gulyhq#e|#d#sduwlfxodu#h{shulhqfh1#Doprvw#lqhylwdeo|/# # # # # # # # # # # # rujdql}dwlrqv## olnh## wkh## LPI## uhfuxlw## vwxghqwv## wudlqhg## lq## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv/# hvshfldoo|## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Prvw## ri## wkh## pdfurhfrqrplf## sulqflsohv## wkdw## duh# wdxjkw## ghulyh## iurp## wkh## h{shulhqfhv## ri## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv/## zkhuh## rujdql}hg# pdunhwv#w|slfdoo|#ixqfwlrq#idluo|#zhoo1#Vr#lw#lv#qdwxudo#iru#wkh#vwdii#wr#idyru#fhuwdlq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # nlqgv#ri#lqwhuyhqwlrq#lq#wkh#ixqfwlrqlqj#ri#pdunhwv/#vxfk#dv#prqhwdu|#srolf|/#zkloh# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehlqj#fulwlfdo#ri#rwkhu#nlqgv#ri#lqwhuyhqwlrq/#vxfk#dv#wkrvh#lq#wkh#iruhljq#h{fkdqjh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdunhw1#Ri#frxuvh/#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv/#zkhuh#ihzhu#pdunhwv#zrun#zhoo# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#d# # eurdghu## vhw#ri#lqwhuyhqwlrqv# # # # pd|#eh# # # zduudqwhg/## pd|#eh# # # dw#d# # # glvdgydqwdjh## zkhq# wkhlu#srolflhv#duh#vfuxwlql}hg#e|#wkh#Ixqg1# # # # # # # Dovr/## hfrqrplf## jurzwk## kdsshqv## lq## p|vwhulrxv## zd|v1## Li## doo## frxqwulhv## kdg# iroorzhg#wkh#suhydlolqj#hfrqrplf#ruwkrgr{|#lq#wkh#4<83v#dqg#4<93v/#zh#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # qhyhu## kdyh## kdg## wkh## Mdsdqhvh## ru## Hdvw## Dvldq## jurzwk## pludfohv1## Li## frxqwulhv## glg# doorz## wkhlu## pdfurhfrqrplf## srolflhv## wr## eh## srolfhg## e|## dq## lqwhuqdwlrqdo# rujdql}dwlrq#zlwk#wkh#srzhu#wr#lpsrvh#shqdowlhv#iru#ghyldwlrq/#lw#frxog#ohdg#wr#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # odfn#ri#glyhuvlw|#lq#srolflhv#wkdw#frxog#olplw#ohduqlqj#dqg#juhdwo|#gdpshq#zruog# # # # # # # # # # # # # jurzwk1# Ilqdoo|/## hyhq## li## wkh## LPI## frxog## frph## xs## zlwk## d## vhw## ri## uhfrpphqgdwlrqv## wkdw# zhuh## wkhruhwlfdoo|#dffhswdeoh/# # # qrw#doo# # # frxqwulhv## zrxog## eh## zloolqj#wr# # # lpsohphqw# wkhp1## Wkh## ZWRᄊv## uxohv## qrw#rqo|#duh# # # # edfnhg## e|#wkh# # # srvvlelolw|#ri#vdqfwlrqv# # # # exw# fdq## dovr## eh## txlhwo|## lpsohphqwhg## e|## jryhuqphqwv## wkurxjk## h{hfxwlyh## rughu=## wkh# frpphufh#plqlvwu|#fdq#uhgxfh#d#wdulii#khuh#ru#uhpryh#d#vxevlg|#wkhuh1#Wkh#LPIᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhfrpphqgdwlrqv## duh## qrw#edfnhg# # # e|#dq|#srzhu# # # # ri#hqirufhphqw=# # # prvw#lqgxvwuldo# # frxqwulhv## dqg## odujh## hphujlqj0pdunhw#frxqwulhv# # # gr## qrw#qhhg# # # LPI## ixqglqj/## zklfk# frqvwlwxwhv## lwv## pdlq## phdqv## ri## shuvxdvlrq1## Pruhryhu/## wkh## nlqg## ri## uhirupv# uhfrpphqghg## duh## w|slfdoo|## wkh## nlqg## wkdw## jr## djdlqvw## d## uxolqj## sduw|ᄊv## hohfwrudo# fdofxoxv/#pdnlqj#lw#lpsrvvleoh#iru#d#ilqdqfh#plqlvwhu#ru#khdg#ri#vwdwh#wr#frpplw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsohphqwlqj#wkhp1# # Lq#vxp/#wkh#LPIᄊv#uroh#lq#pdfurhfrqrplf#srolf|#frruglqdwlrq#lv#txlwh#gliihuhqw# # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#wkh#ZWRᄊv#uroh#lq#wudgh#idflolwdwlrq#ehfdxvh/#iluvw/#wkhuh#duh#qr#fohdu#uxohv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rq#zkdw#lv#shuplvvleoh#dqg#zkdw#lv#qrw/#dqg#dq|#dwwhpsw#wr#irupxodwh#vxfk#uxohv#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # olnho|#wr#eh#xqdffhswdeoh#wr#pdq|#frxqwulhv1#Vhfrqg/#dqg#lq#frqvhtxhqfh/#uhirupv# # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh#wr#eh#djuhhg#wr#rq#d#fdvh0e|0fdvh#edvlv/#dqg#jryhuqphqwv#w|slfdoo|#gr#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## wkh## grphvwlf## srolwlfdo## vxssruw## wr## frpplw## frqilghqwo|## wr## wkh## uhirupv## wkh|# zrxog#kdyh#wr#xqghuwdnh#dv#sduw#ri#dq#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#djuhhphqw1#Wklug/#wkh#lqdelolw|# # # # # # # # # # # # #
wr## frpplw## phdqv## wkdw## judqg## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## djuhhphqwv## uhtxlulqj## ixqgdphqwdo# uhirup#e|#hdfk#frxqwu|#duh# # # # # # kdug## wr## sxoo## rii/## hyhq#zkhq#wkh# # # # uhirupv## duh## lq#hdfk# # frxqwu|ᄊv#orqj0whup#lqwhuhvw1# # # Hyhq#wkrxjk#wkh# # # # Ixqg## lv## qrw#dozd|v# # # uljkw/## lwv## suhvfulswlrqv## riwhq#klw#wkh# # # # pdun# vlpso|#ehfdxvh# # # wkh## Ixqg## lv## dsrolwlfdo1## Krzhyhu/## wkh## Ixqg## zloo## qrw#jdlq#ZWR0 # # olnh#srzhuv#ri#vdqfwlrq#ryhu#vrphwklqj#dv#dpruskrxv#dv#pdfurhfrqrplf#srolf|1# # # # # # # # # # # Qru#lv#ᄈqdplqj#dqg#vkdplqjᄡ#ylrodwruv#lq#iurqw#ri#wkh#frppxqlw|#ri#qdwlrqv#olnho|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## kdyh## pxfk## hiihfw1## Ilqdqfh## plqlvwhuv## fduh## sulpdulo|## derxw## grphvwlf# frqvwlwxhqflhv/## zklfk## w|slfdoo|## sd|## olwwoh## dwwhqwlrq## wr## wkh## zrunlqjv## ri## wkh## LPI1# Wkdw#kdv#pdgh#ilqdqfh#plqlvwhuv#suhww|#vkdphohvv/#dw#ohdvw#wr#gdwh1# # # # # # # # # # # Exw#wkhvh#revhuydwlrqv#vxjjhvw#dq#dowhuqdwlyh1#Udwkhu#wkdq#wu|#wr#lpsrvh#lwv#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # # # ryhu#qdwlrqv#e|#ildw/#zklfk#wkh#LPI#zloo#qhyhu#kdyh#wkh#dxwkrulw|#wr#gr/#lw#vkrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vwulyh#iru#lqioxhqfh#e|#dsshdolqj#pruh#gluhfwo|#wr#d#frxqwu|ᄊv#flwl}hqv1#Wklv#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # idflolwdwh## wkh## jryhuqphqwᄊv## wdvn#lq#exloglqj#vxssruw#iru# # # # # # uhirupv1## Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/# # lqvwhdg## ri## wu|lqj## wr## eh## olnh## wkh## ZWR## dqg## xvlqj## kdug## srzhu/## lw## vkrxog## hpxodwh# R{idpᄊv#phwkrgv#dqg#xvh#vriw#srzhu1# # # # # #
Rewdlqlqj#Joredo#Lqioxhqfh # # # Frqvlghu## wkh## lpshwxv## wr## gr## pruh## derxw#plwljdwlqj#folpdwh# # # # fkdqjh1## Wklv## lv## d# txlqwhvvhqwldo## h{dpsoh## ri## dq## lvvxh## zlwk## vkruw0whup## frvwv## dqg## orqj0whup## jdlqv1# Srolwlfldqv## zrxog## vk|## dzd|## iurp## vxfk## lvvxhv## zhuh## lw## qrw## iru## wkh## judvvurrwv# pryhphqwv#lq#wkhlu#frqvwlwxhqflhv1#Wkh#suhvvxuh#rq#jryhuqphqwv#wr#gr#vrphwklqj# # # # # # # # # # # kdv#lqfuhdvhg#qrw#mxvw#ehfdxvh#ri#prxqwlqj#hylghqfh#wkdw#folpdwh#fkdqjh#lv#d#uhdo# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkuhdw## exw## dovr## ehfdxvh## d## ydulhw|## ri## rujdql}dwlrqv/## iurp#orfdo# # # wr## lqwhuqdwlrqdo/# kdyh## prelol}hg## shrsoh## wr## suhvv## wkhlu## uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv## iru## dfwlrq1## Vlploduo|/## d# srsxodu#pryhphqw#ohg#e|#urfn#vwduv#olnh#Erqr#sxvkhg#ulfk0frxqwu|#jryhuqphqwv# # # # # # # # # # # lqwr## irujlylqj#ghew# # # wr## srru## frxqwulhv## dqg## lqwr## sohgjlqj#wr# # # jlyh## pruh## dlg## dw## wkh# 5338#Johqhdjohv#Vxpplw1# # # Ri## frxuvh/## jryhuqphqwv## kdyh## qrw## vljqhg## xs## |hw## wr## elqglqj## frpplwphqwv## rq# hplvvlrqv/## dqg## wkh|#kdyh# # # edfnwudfnhg## rq#dlg# # # frpplwphqwv/## exw#wkh# # # srlqw#lv# # # wkdw# wkhvh#pryhphqwv#jdlqhg#lqioxhqfh#e|#frqylqflqj#srolwlfdo#ohdghuv#wkdw#wkhuh#zdv# # # # # # # # # # # grphvwlf## vxssruw## iru## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## djuhhphqw1## Dv## wkh## srzhu## ri## wkh## Lqwhuqhw# lqfuhdvhv#wkurxjk#vrfldo#dqg#srolwlfdo#qhwzrunlqj#vlwhv/#dqg#dv#yluwxdo#ghprfudf|# # # # # # # # # # # vsuhdgv/## sxeolf## lqioxhqfh## lv## olnho|#wr# # # eh## dv## pxfk#erwwrp0xsᄇohdghuv# # # dgrswlqj# srsxodu## srvlwlrqvᄇdv## wrs0grzqᄇohdghuv## frqylqflqj#wkh# # # sxeolf## ri#wkh# # # phulw#ri# # wkhlu## ylhzv1#Wkrvh# # # zkr#zrxog#lqioxhqfh# # # # wkh## fdofxodwlrqv## ri#srolwlfldqv# # # pxvw#gr# # vr## qrw#e|#dsshdolqj#wr# # # # # wkhlu## ehwwhu## lqvwlqfwv## exw#e|#frqylqflqj#wkhlu# # # # # pdvwhuv/## wkh# shrsoh/#gluhfwo|1# # Pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## olnh## wkh## LPI## dqg## wkh## Zruog## Edqn## qhhg## wr## gr## idu# pruh#wr#h{sdqg#wkhlu#uhdfkᄇwr#vshdn#iru# # # # # # # # wkh#zruog#wr#wkh#zruog1#Lq#dgglwlrq#wr# # # # # # # # wu|lqj#wr#shuvxdgh#ilqdqfh#plqlvwhuv#dqg#khdgv#ri#vwdwh/#wkh|#vkrxog#jr#gluhfwo|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## sxeolf/## lqfoxglqj## srolwlfdo## sduwlhv/## qrqjryhuqphqwdo## rujdql}dwlrqv/## dqg# lqioxhqwldo#shuvrqdolwlhv#lq#hdfk#frxqwu|#dqg#h{sodlq#wkhlu#srvlwlrq1#Wkh|#qhhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # ehfrph#pxfk#pruh#vrsklvwlfdwhg#derxw#xvlqj#Zhe0hqdeohg#qhwzrunv#wr#uhdfk#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # frqqhfwhg#flwl}hq#dqg#ilqg#zd|v#wr#hqwhu#vfkrro#dqg#xqlyhuvlw|#fodvvurrpv/#zkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # vwxghqwv#fdq#eh#prvw#uhfhswlyh#wr#lghdv#derxw#joredo#flwl}hqvkls1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## sxeolf## kdv## d## orqjhu0whup## krul}rq## wkdq## wkh## jryhuqphqw## lq## srzhu## dqg# w|slfdoo|#pruh# # # lghdolvp#dqg# # # frqfhuq#iru# # # wkh## joredo## jrrg1## Lw#lv# # # dovr## olnho|#wr# # # eh# pruh## uhfhswlyh## wr## shuvxdvlrq/## hvshfldoo|## zkhq## lw## lv## ohvv## dq{lrxv## wkdq## lq## wkh# fxuuhqw#wlphv1#Ri#frxuvh/#uhirupv#zkrvh#ehqhilwv#iru#d#frxqwu|#ryhu#wlph#vzdps# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#frvwv#duh#pxfk#pruh#olnho|#wr#eh#dffhswdeoh#wkdq#rqhv#wkdw#dvn#wkh#frxqwu|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # pdnh#vdfulilfhv#iru#wkh#zruogᄊv#jrrg/#exw#hyhq#wkh#odwwhu#vkrxog#qrw#eh#uxohg#rxw=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # diwhu## doo/## dlg## lq## lwv## sxuhvw## irup#uhtxluhv# # # rqh0vlghg## vdfulilfhv/## dqg## wkh## wklqnlqj# dfwlyh#sxeolf#lq#ulfk#frxqwulhv# # # # # # kdv#sxvkhg#iru# # # # lw1#Wkh#nqrzohgjh#wkdw#flwl}hqv#lq# # # # # # rwkhu## frxqwulhv## duh## ehlqj#dvnhg# # # wr## slwfk#lq#dw#wkh# # # # # vdph## wlphᄇwkdw#vroxwlrqv# # # duh# wuxo|## lqwhqghg## wr## eh## joredo## dqg## pxowlodwhudoᄇvkrxog## eh## lpsruwdqw## lq## pdnlqj# shuvxdvlrq#hdvlhu1#Pruhryhu/#wr#wkh#h{whqw#wkdw#d#grphvwlf#frqvwlwxhqf|#ghyhorsv# # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## fduhv## derxw## d## frxqwu|ᄊv## pxowlodwhudo## uhvsrqvlelolwlhv/## srolwlfldqv## zloo## qr# orqjhu#ihho#lw#srolwlfdoo|#frvwohvv#wr#ylrodwh#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#reoljdwlrqv>#wkxv#qdplqj# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#vkdplqj#pd|#kdyh#pruh#irufh1# # # # # # Wklv## vruw## ri## fdpsdljqlqj## lv## qrw## vrphwklqj## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## duh#
fxuuhqwo|#zhoo# # # htxlsshg## wr## fduu|#rxw1# # # Wkh## LPI/## iru## h{dpsoh/## ylhzv## lwv## sulpdu|# dxglhqfh## dv## ilqdqfh## plqlvwulhv## dqg## fhqwudo## edqnhuv1## Diwhu## |hduv## ri#wu|lqj#wr# # # # qrw# riihqg#dq|rqh#lq#phpehu# # # # # frxqwulhv/#LPI#vwdii#kdyh#ghyhorshg#d#vshfldo# # # # # # # # zd|#ri# # zulwlqj## uhsruwv## wkdw## hqvxuhv## wkdw## hyhu|wklqj## lpsruwdqw## fdq## eh## lqihuuhg## e|## wkrvh# zkr## nqrz## krz## wr## uhdg## ehwzhhq#wkh# # # olqhv## +w|slfdoo|#LPI# # # vwdii## dqg## exuhdxfudwv# iurp## wkh## phpehu## frxqwulhv,/## dqg## dq|rqh## hovh## idoov## dvohhs## uhdglqj## wkh## wxujlg# survh1## Wkh## LPI## kdv## kdg## orqj## sudfwlfh## lq## frppxqlfdwlqj## zlwk## exuhdxfudwv## ru# plqlvwhuv/## exw#idu# # # ohvv## lq#vshdnlqj#wr# # # # qrqjryhuqphqwdo## rujdql}dwlrqv## +QJRv,## ru# wkh#suhvv1#Wkh#Zruog#Edqn#lv#ehwwhu/#exw#qrw#e|#pxfk1# # # # # # # # # # # Pruhryhu/#lw#lv# # # # qrw#fohdu# # # wkdw#srzhuixo# # # phpehu0frxqwu|#jryhuqphqwv# # # zdqw#dq# # lqwhuqdwlrqdo#rujdql}dwlrq#vshdnlqj#zlwklq#wkhlu#erughuv#rq#d#phvvdjh#wkh|#fdqqrw# # # # # # # # # # # frqwuro/#hyhq#li#lw#lv# # # # # # vwulfwo|#rq#hfrqrplfv1#Lw#lv# # # # # # qrw#mxvw#xqghprfudwlf# # # # frxqwulhv# wkdw## uhsuhvv## iuhh## vshhfk>## ghprfudwlf## frxqwulhv## wkdw## suhdfk## lq## sxeolf## derxw## wkh# qhhg## iru## wudqvsduhqf|## dqg## krqhvw## dssudlvdov## duh## riwhq## wkh## rqhv## wkdw## ohdq## prvw# khdylo|#rq#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#rujdql}dwlrqv#lq#sulydwh#wr#dowhu#wkhlu#phvvdjh1# # # # # # # # # # L## uhfdoo## d## Zdvklqjwrq## suhvv## frqihuhqfh## khog## wr## uhohdvh## wkh## vhpldqqxdo## LPI# Zruog#Hfrqrplf#Rxworrn#lq#wkh#vsulqj#ri#53381#Fdpsdljqlqj#zdv#xqghu#zd|#iru# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Eulwlvk#hohfwlrqv1#Lq#uhvsrqvh#wr#wkh#dqwlflsdwhg#txhvwlrq#iurp#d#uhsruwhu#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Ilqdqfldo#Wlphv/#L#uhpdunhg#wkdw#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp#zrxog#qhhg#wr#gr#pruh# # # ## # # # # # # # # # wr## udlvh## uhyhqxhv## ru## fxw#frvwv# # # wr## phhw#lwv# # # rzq#ilvfdo# # # uxohv/## wkxv## lpso|lqj#wkdw#lw# # # pljkw#kdyh#wr#udlvh#wd{hv1#P|#frpphqwv#zhuh#edvhg#rq#lpshffdeoh#dqdo|vlv#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#LPIᄊv#vwdii/#exw#Jrugrq#Eurzq/#wkhq#fkdqfhooru#ri#wkh#h{fkhtxhu/#zdv#ixulrxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh## wkh|#frqwudglfwhg# # # klv## rzq#sxeolf# # # vwdwhphqwv## gxulqj#wkh# # # fdpsdljq1## Wkh# Ixqg## vwrrg## e|#lwv# # # dqdo|vlv## ghvslwh## lpphqvh## suhvvxuh## iurp#wkh# # # Eulwlvk#wuhdvxu|1# # Jrugrq#Eurzq#zdv#dovr#fkdlupdq#ri#wkh#LPIᄊv#jryhuqlqj#frpplwwhh#dqg#kdg#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # suhvv## frqihuhqfh## vfkhgxohg## wkh## qh{w## gd|1## Zlwk## wkh## LPIᄊv## pdqdjlqj## gluhfwru/# Urguljr#gh# # # Udwr/#vlwwlqj#hpeduudvvhg#e|#klv# # # # # # vlgh/#kh# # # odxqfkhg#lqwr#d# # # # eurdgvlgh# +surpswhg## djdlq## e|## wkh## lqhylwdeoh## txhvwlrq,## djdlqvw## wkh## Ixqg## dqg## krz## lw## zdv# zurqj#rqfh#djdlq#derxw#wkh#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp1#Wkh#pdqdjlqj#gluhfwru#srolwho|#vdlg# # # # # # # # # # # # qrwklqj/## exw#lq#grlqj#vr/# # # # # kh## lpsolflwo|#edfnhg# # # klv## vwdiiᄊv## ylhzv1## Wkh## gdwd## vlqfh# wkhq#vxjjhvw#wkh#Ixqg#zdv#uljkw1# # # # # # Rq## wkh## rqh## kdqg/## wkh## yhu|## idfw## wkdw## jryhuqphqwv## duh## frqfhuqhg## derxw## wkh# srvvleoh## sxeolf## lqioxhqfh## ri## dq## lpsduwldo## frpphqwdwru## rq## jryhuqphqw## srolflhv# vxjjhvwv#wkdw#wklv#dyhqxh#lv#jurvvo|#xqghuh{sorlwhg1#Rq#wkh#rwkhu#kdqg/#vxfk#dfwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # # # zloo#uhtxluh#d#fkdqjh#lq#krz#pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#vhh#wkhpvhoyhvᄇdv#ZWR# # # # # # # # # # # zdqqdehv## kdqnhulqj## diwhu## kdug## srzhu## wkdw## wkh|## zloo## qhyhu## jhw/## ru## wkrvh## zkr# uhvshfw#wkh#vryhuhljqw|#ri#hdfk#frxqwu|#dqg#zrun#iru#wkh#joredo#jrrg/#frxqwu|#e|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwu|/#wkurxjk#vriw#srzhu#dqg#shuvxdvlrq1# # # # # #
Uhirupv#wr#Joredo#Hfrqrplf#Jryhuqdqfh # # # # # Li## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## duh## wr## fkdqjh## wkhlu## vwudwhjlhv## ri## shuvxdvlrq/# ixqgdphqwdo## uhirup#lv# # # uhtxluhg1## Wkhvh## lqfoxgh## fkdqjhv## wr## wkh## rujdql}dwlrqv## dv# zhoo#dv#wr#wkh#zd|#wkh|#rshudwh#lq#frxqwulhv1#Wkhlu#jryhuqdqfh#vwuxfwxuh#qhhgv#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh## uhiruphg## vr## wkdw#wkh|#duh# # # # vhhq#wr# # # eh## lqghshqghqw#ri#xqgxh# # # # lqioxhqfh## e|#dq|# # frxqwu|/## dqg## vrph## ri## wkhvh## fkdqjhv## duh## xqghu## zd|1## Wkh|## vkrxog## dovr## pdnh## d# frqvflrxv#hiiruw#wr#eurdghq#wkhlu#lqwhoohfwxdo#iudphzrunv#e|#uhfuxlwlqj#shuvrqqho# # # # # # # # # # wudlqhg#rxwvlgh#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1#Vrph#ri#wklv#zloo#kdsshq#dv#xqlyhuvlwlhv#dfurvv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## ghyhorslqj## zruog## vwuhqjwkhq## wkhlu## uhvhdufk## fdsdelolwlhv## dqg## surgxfh## kljk0 txdolw|#judgxdwhv1#Pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#vkrxog#vhh#hqjdjhphqw#lq#wkh#sxeolf# # # # # # # # # # ghedwh## lq#phpehu# # # frxqwulhv## dv## rqh## ri#wkhlu# # # prvw#lpsruwdqw#wrrov# # # # lq#hqfrxudjlqj# # grphvwlf## srolflhv## wkdw## irvwhu## wkh## joredo## jrrg1## Dqg## ilqdoo|/## wkh## uxohv## jryhuqlqj# phpehuvkls## ri## wkhvh## rujdql}dwlrqv## vkrxog## irufh## phpehuv## wr## dffhsw## vxfk# hqjdjhphqw/#idflolwdwh#lw/#dqg#surwhfw#lw#zkhq#fduulhg#rxw#lq#jrrg#idlwk1#Wklv#pd|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqghhg## uhtxluh## lpsruwdqw## uhylvlrqv## wr## wkh## duwlfohv## ri## djuhhphqw## vljqhg## e|# phpehuv## ri## wkh## LPI/## shukdsv## hyhq## d## qhz## klvwrulf## djuhhphqw## olnh## wkh## rqh## dw# Euhwwrq#Zrrgv#wkdw#fuhdwhg#wkh#LPI#dqg#wkh#Zruog#Edqn1# # # # # # # # # # Wklv## odvw## srlqw## lv## lpsruwdqw1## Qr## odujh## srzhu/## hvshfldoo|## exw## qrw## h{foxvlyho|# frxqwulhv#wkdw#duh#xqghprfudwlf/#zloo#eh#kdss|#jlylqj#pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#d# # # # # # # # # # # sodwirup#wr# # # vrxqg## rii## rq#dq|wklqj#wkh|#zdqw1# # # # # Frxqwulhv## kdyh## wr## xqghuvwdqg## wkdw# wkhuh#duh#lpsruwdqw#froohfwlyh#ehqhilwv#iurp#dgrswlqj#vrxqghu#srolflhv/#dqg#wkdw#li# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#zdqw#d#sodwirup#iurp#zklfk#wr#lqioxhqfh#wkh#srolflhv#ri#rwkhuv/#wkh|#kdyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # doorz## rwkhuv## d## sodwirup## wr## lqioxhqfh## wkhluv1## Lw## vkrxog## eh## xqghuvwrrg## wkdw## wkh# pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrq## zloo## frqilqh## lwvhoi## wr## hfrqrplf## dqg## vrflrhfrqrplf# lvvxhv/## zlwk#lwv# # # ylhzv## duulyhg## dw#wkurxjk#d# # # # idlu/## gholehudwlyh## surfhvv## zlwklq#wkh# # rujdql}dwlrq/## edvhg## sulpdulo|## rq## frqylqflqj## hfrqrplf## uhvhdufk## dqg## gdwd# dqdo|vlv1#Lwv#ylhzv#vkrxog#wkhq#eh#surwhfwhg#e|#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#djuhhphqw/#pxfk#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # hpedvvlhv#dqg#wkhlu#dfwlylwlhv#duh1#Ri#frxuvh/#d#wudqvsduhqw#dqg#idlu#surfhvv#zloo# # # # # # # # # # # # # eh## hvvhqwldo## wr## frqylqflqj## flwl}hqv## lq## hdfk## frxqwu|## wkdw## wkh## pxowlodwhudo# rujdql}dwlrq#kdv#wkhlu#lqwhuhvwv#dw#khduw1#Sxw#gliihuhqwo|/#lqvwhdg#ri#dq#lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # djuhhphqw## derxw## hfrqrplf## srolflhv## ェ## od## ZWR/## zh## qhhg## dq## lqwhuqdwlrqdo# djuhhphqw## derxw## krz## grphvwlf## srolflhv## fdq## eh## lqioxhqfhg## e|## pxowlodwhudo# djhqflhv#wr#lqfrusrudwh#wkh#joredo#jrrg1# # # # # # L#kdyh#udlvhg#wkh#lvvxh#ri#uhirup#lq#wkh#frqwh{w#ri#wudgh#lpedodqfhv1#Exw#wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#pdq|#rwkhu#lvvxhv#rq#zklfk#wkh#zruog#qhhgv#wr#frph#wrjhwkhu#rq#zklfk#lw#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fxuuhqwo|#ehlqj#gudjjhg#dsduw1#Iru#h{dpsoh/#zkhqhyhu#irrg#sulfhv#ulvh/#d#qxpehu# # # # # # # # # # # # ri## frxqwulhv## vwduw## edqqlqj## irrg## h{sruwv1## Dowkrxjk## lq## wkh## yhu|## vkruw## whup## vxfk# phdvxuhv## hqvxuh## wkdw## wkhlu## flwl}hqv## kdyh## dffhvv## wr## fkhds## irrg/## wkh|## ghsulyh# grphvwlf#iduphuv#ri#kljkhu#sulfhv#dqg#pdnh#wkhp#ohvv#hdjhu#wr#jurz#irrg1#Wkh|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr#pdnh#rwkhu#frxqwulhv#ihho#lqvhfxuh#dqg#dwwhpsw#wr#jurz#wkhlu#rzq#irrg/#hyhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # li#lw#lv#jurvvo|#lqhiilflhqw#iru#wkhp#wr#gr#vr=#wkh#ilhogv#ri#judlq#wkdw#qrz#dsshdu#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#plggoh#ri#wkh#Dudeldq#ghvhuw#duh#xqolnho|#wr#eh#wkh#ehvw#xvh#ri#zdwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkdw# # orfdwlrq1## Wkh## qhw#rxwfrph# # # lv## wkdw#wkh# # # p|rslf## dfwlrqv## e|#jryhuqphqwv# # # wr## surwhfw# wkhlu## flwl}hqu|## lq## wkh## vkruw## uxq## uhvxow## lq## joredo## irrg## lqvhfxulw|## dqg## lqhiilflhqw# phwkrgv#ri#surgxfwlrq#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq1#Zh#qhhg#d#joredo#djuhhphqw#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
lqwhuqdwlrqdo## irrg## pdunhwv## zloo## qrw## eh## glvuxswhg## e|#jryhuqphqw# # # dfwlrqᄇexw## qr# jryhuqphqw#wrgd|#zloo# # # # ulvn#ehlqj#dffxvhg#e|#wkh#rssrvlwlrq#ri#vljqlqj#dzd|#lwv# # # # # # # # # # delolw|#wr#hqvxuh#wkdw#lwv#flwl}hqv#kdyh#irrg1#Wkh#pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#qhhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # fuhdwh#wkh#qhfhvvdu|#dzduhqhvv#dqg#prphqwxp#iru#djuhhphqw1# # # # # # # # L## kdyh## qr## looxvlrqv## derxw## krz## hdv|## fkdqjh## zloo## eh1## Wkh## lqvwlqfw## ri## joredo# exuhdxfudwv#lv#wr#suhvv#iru#fohdu#uxohv/#exw#hyhq#lq#wkh#Hxurshdq#Xqlrq/#zklfk#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vrph## uxoh0pdnlqj#srzhu# # # dqg#vrph# # # delolw|#wr#frqvwudlq#wkh# # # # # grphvwlf## srolflhv## ri# phpehuv/## uhodwlyho|## krprjhqrxv## frxqwulhv## kdyh## suryhg## xqzloolqj## wr## dffhsw# vwurqj## h{whuqdo## frqvwudlqwv## rq## wkhlu## srolf|## pdnlqj1## Ryhu## wlph/## uxolqjv## iurp# Euxvvhov## kdyh## frph## wr## eh## vhhq## dv## dq## lpsrvlwlrq## e|## flwl}hqv## ri## HX## frxqwulhv/# ehfdxvh#grphvwlf#srolwlfldqv#eodph#wkhp#iru#hyhu|wklqj#xqsohdvdqw#wkdw#kdv#wr#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # grqh## dqg## wdnh## fuhglw#iru# # # doo## wkh## vxffhvvhv1## Lw#lv# # # qr## vxusulvh/## wkhq/## wkdw#zkhq#wkh# # # shrsoh## duh## dvnhg## li## wkh|## zdqw## d## vwurqjhu## Euxvvhov/## wkh|## yrflihurxvo|## uhvsrqg/# ᄈQr$ᄡ# Zh## pxvw## uhphpehu## wkdw## hyhq## Nh|qhv## zruulhg## derxw## joredo## lpedodqfhv## dqg# sursrvhg## wkh## udglfdo## lghd## ri## shqdol}lqj## frxqwulhv## wkdw## udq## shuvlvwhqw## wudgh# # # # # # # # # # # vxusoxvhv1<##Vxfk#lghdv#duh#xqolnho|#wr#eh#dffhswdeoh#wr#lqghshqghqw#qdwlrqv#wrgd|1# D#glyhuvh#zruog#zloo# # # # # qrw#dffhsw#dq|#irufhixo# # # # # joredo## frruglqdwlrq#ri#srolflhv#wr# # # # eulgjh## wkh## idxow## olqh## ehwzhhq## qdwlrqv1## L## gr## qrw## dgyrfdwh## d## kdow## wr## wkh## pdq|# lqwhuqdwlrqdo## phhwlqjv## wkdw#dwwhpsw#wr# # # # frruglqdwh## uhirupv/## zklfk#kdyh# # # surgxfhg# pxfk#wdon#dqg#olwwoh#dfwlrq#wkxv#idu1#Shukdsv#wkh#J053#zloo#sxoo#rii#d#pludfoh1#Exw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdxvh#wkh#lvvxhv#duh#wrr#lpsruwdqw#wr#eh#ohiw#wr#wkh#exuhdxfudwv#dqg#srolwlfldqv/#L# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh## dgyrfdwhg## rshqlqj## d## vhfrqg## wudfn/## d## wudfn## wkdw## wkh## vpdoohu/## qrq0J053# frxqwulhv#ri#wkh#zruog#vkrxog#edfn/#wr#eulqj#wkh#srolflhv#ri#wkh#elj#srzhuv#lqwr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # olqh1## Pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## olnh## wkh## LPI## vkrxog## suhvhqw## frxqwulhv## zlwk## d# frxuvh#ri#dfwlrq#wkdw#lv#lqglylgxdoo|#dqg#froohfwlyho|#ehqhilfldo#dqg#wkdw#fdq#dyrlg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#srolwlfdo# # # dqg#hfrqrplf#ulvnv# # # # ri#lqdfwlrq1#Wkh#pxowlodwhudo# # # # # rujdql}dwlrqv## zloo# kdyh#wr#pdnh#wkh#shuvxdvlyh#fdvh#lq#frxqwu|#diwhu# # # # # # # # # # frxqwu|#wkdw#wkh#jdlq#lv# # # # # # zruwk# wkh## vkruw0whup## sdlq1## Li## wkhuh## lv## grphvwlf## srolwlfdo## prphqwxp/## lw## zloo## pdnh## lw# hdvlhu## iru## ohdghuv## wr## frqfoxgh## dq#dffhswdeoh# # # sdfw#dw#wkh# # # # lqwhuqdwlrqdo## ohyho1## Sxw# gliihuhqwo|/## joredo## srolf|## glvfxvvlrqv## kdyh## wr## eh## lqwurgxfhg## lqwr## wkh## srolwlfdo# ghedwh## lq#hyhu|#frxqwu|#dqg# # # # # wkhuhe|#pdnh# # # wkhlu## zd|#edfn#lqwr# # # # wkh## forvhg0grru# phhwlqjv## ri#joredo# # # ohdghuv1#Joredo# # # pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## zloo## kdyh#wr#zrun# # # zlwk#joredo#ghprfudf|#udwkhu#wkdq#dyrlg#lw1# # # # # # #
Fklqd#dqg#wkh#Zruog # # # # Wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw#hfrqrp|#lq#wkh#zruog#lq#wkh#qh{w#ghfdgh/#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdq#wkh# # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv/## lv## olnho|## wr## eh## Fklqd1## Pdq|## srolf|## pdnhuv## rxwvlgh## Fklqd## duh# frqfhuqhg## zlwk## wkh## Fklqhvh## fxuuhqf|ᄊv## shj## wr## wkh## groodu1## Iurp#Mxo|# # # 5338/## wkh# Shrsohᄊv## Edqn## ri## Fklqd## +SERF,## doorzhg## wkh## uhqplqel## wr## dssuhfldwh## vwhdglo|# djdlqvw#wkh# # # groodu/## exw#zlwk#wkh# # # # rqvhw#ri#wkh# # # # ilqdqfldo## fulvlv## lq#Rfwrehu# # # 533;/## lw# kdowhg#wkh#dssuhfldwlrq#dqg#shjjhg#wkh#fxuuhqf|#wr#wkh#groodu#djdlq1#Dffxvdwlrqv# # # # # # # # # # # # ri## xqidlu## wudgh## duh## ehlqj## khdug## lq## Zdvklqjwrq## fruulgruv/## dqg## zlwk## X1V1# xqhpsor|phqw#wrxfklqj#43#shufhqw#dqg#Fklqhvh#jurzwk#dovr#wrxfklqj#43#shufhqw/# # # # # # # # # # # wkh#glvsdulw|#vhhpv#reylrxv1#Wkh#prphqwxp#iru# # # # # # # # Frqjuhvv#wr#lpsrvh#vrph#irup# # # # # ri#wudgh#eduulhu# # # # lv## lqfuhdvlqj/#dqg#hyhq#d#uhqhzhg#dssuhfldwlrq#ri#wkh#uhqplqel# # # # # # # # # pd|#qrw#txhoo#lw1# # # # Lv#Fklqhvh#fxuuhqf|#lqwhuyhqwlrq#xqidluB#Dqg#li#vr/#wr#zkrpB#Lq#rqh#vhqvh/#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dqvzhu## lv## reylrxv1## Fklqhvh## h{sruwhuv## douhdg|## hqmr|## vxevlglhv## vxfk## dv## fkhds# fdslwdo/#odqg/#dqg#hqhuj|1#Zlwk#wkhlu#jrrgv#pdgh#hyhq#fkhdshu#e|#dq#xqghuydoxhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # fxuuhqf|/## Fklqhvh## h{sruwhuv## fdq## rxwfrpshwh## ilupv## lq## lqgxvwuldo## frxqwulhv1## Wklv# vlwxdwlrq## vhhpv## eodwdqwo|## xqidlu1## Exw## wklv## ylhz## dvvxphv## htxlydohqfh## ehwzhhq# frxqwulhv#lq#pdq|#rwkhu#uhvshfwv=#wkh#lqiudvwuxfwxuh#lq#hdfk#frxqwu|/#wkh#txdolw|#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv## ohjdo## dqg## frqwudfwxdo## v|vwhp/## lwv## uhjxodwru|## vwuxfwxuh/## wkh## hgxfdwlrq## ri## lwv# zrunhuv/#dqg#vr#rq1#Wkxv#zkhq#rqh#frxqwu|#lqwhuyhqhv#wr#jlyh#lwvhoi#d#ohj#xs/#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhhpv#wr#eh#ylrodwlqj#wkh#uxohv1# # # # # # Exw## wkhuh## duh## rwkhu## zd|v## ri## orrnlqj## dw## frpshwlwlrq1## Prvw## rxwvlghuv# frqwhpsodwlqj#Fklqd#wklqn#ri#wkh#vzdqn|#qhz#sduwv#ri#Ehlmlqj#dqg#Vkdqjkdl/#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#lqwhulru#dqg#zhvwhuq#surylqfhv#zkhuh#frqglwlrqv#duh#idu#pruh#edfnzdug1#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # lqiudvwuxfwxuh#lq#d#ghyhorshg#frxqwu|#lv#w|slfdoo|#pxfk#ehwwhu>#lwv#ohjdo#v|vwhp#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # pruh## hiihfwlyh## dw## hqiruflqj## frqwudfwv>## lwv## uhjxodwru|## vwuxfwxuh## lv## idu## pruh# suhglfwdeoh## dqg## ohvv## fruuxsw>## dqg## lwv## vfkrrov/## qr## pdwwhu## krz## grzqwurgghq## wkh# duhd#wkh|#duh#orfdwhg#lq/#dw#ohdvw#kdyh#edvlf#idflolwlhv1# # # # # # # # # # Dq## dqdorj|## pd|## eh## xvhixo1## Lq## dq## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## dwkohwlf## udfh/## rqh## ri## wkh# sduwlflsdqwv## lv## irxqg## wr## kdyh## wdnhq## dq## hqhuj|## errvwhu1## Kh## lv## glvtxdolilhg## iru# ylrodwlqj#wkh#uxohv1#Exw#rq#forvhu#lqyhvwljdwlrq/#zh#ilqg#wkdw#zkhq#wkh#udfh#ehjdq/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # rqh#vhw#ri#sduwlflsdqwv#kdg#wkh#odwhvw/#vshfldoo|#ghvljqhg#dhurg|qdplf#htxlsphqw/# # # # # # # # # # # vshflilfdoo|## doorzhg## e|## wkh## uxoh0pdnlqj## erg|/## zklfk## lv## grplqdwhg## e|# uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv## ri## wklv## vhw## ri## frxqwulhv/## zkhuhdv## wkh## sduwlflsdqw## zkr## wrrn## wkh# hqhuj|#errvwhu#xvhg#ruglqdu|/#rii0wkh0vkhoi/#fkhds#htxlsphqw1#Zkr#lv#frpshwlqj# # # # # # # # # # xqidluo|#qrzB#Xqghu#wkh#uxohv#ri#wkh#jdph/#lw#lv#vwloo#wkh#frpshwlwru#zkr#wrrn#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hqhuj|#errvwhu1#Exw#wkh#uxohv#wkhpvhoyhv#hqwuhqfk#glvdgydqwdjhv1# # # # # # # # Wkh## whup#xqidlu# # # wdnhv## d## orw#dv# # # jlyhq/## lqfoxglqj#wkh# # # iudphzrun#ri#hydoxdwlrq/# # # dqg#lw#lv#d#whup#wkdw#fxwv#olwwoh#lfh#zlwk#wkh#ohdghuv#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv1#Gdql# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Urguln## dw## Kduydug## Xqlyhuvlw|/## iru## h{dpsoh/## kdv## dujxhg## wkdw## fxuuhqf|# xqghuydoxdwlrq## pd|## eh## wkh## zd|## iru## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## wr## riivhw## wkhlu# lqvwlwxwlrqdo## glvdgydqwdjhv1## Fohduo|/## xqghuydoxdwlrq#lv# # # xqidlu## rqfh## wkh|#il{#wkhlu# # # ghilflhqflhv#+dqg#wkh#Fklqhvh#dwkohwhv#wrgd|#gr#kdyh#vwdwh0ri0wkh0duw#htxlsphqw,1# # # # # # # # # # Lw#lv#dovr#xqidlu#wr#wkh#srruhu#frxqwulhv#wkdw#gr#qrw#kdyh#hyhq#Fklqdᄊv#dgydqwdjhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
exw#kdyh#wr#frpshwh#zlwk#lw#wr#h{sruw1#Qhyhuwkhohvv/#mxgjlqj#zkdw#lv#xqidlu#lv#qrw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hdv|1# # # # # # # # # # # D#vwurqjhu#dujxphqw#djdlqvw#shuvlvwhqw#xqghuydoxdwlrq#lv#edvhg#rq#Fklqdᄊv#rzq# lqwhuhvwv1## Xqghuydoxdwlrq## ri## wkh## fxuuhqf|## lv## d## irup## ri## vxevlg|## wr## d## frxqwu|ᄊv# h{sruw#vhfwru#wkdw#lv#ilqdqfhg#e|#wd{lqj#wkrvh#zkr#lpsruw#dqg#wkrvh#zkr#ilqdqfh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## phfkdqlvp## ri## h{fkdqjh0udwh## lqwhuyhqwlrq1## Wkh## dujxphqw## djdlqvw## frqwlqxhg# Fklqhvh#lqwhuyhqwlrq#lv#wkdw#wkh#vxevlg|#grhv#qrw#khos#wkrvh#zkr#uhfhlyh#lw#dqg#lv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfrplqj#lqfuhdvlqjo|#exughqvrph#rq#wkrvh#zkr#sd|#iru#lw1# # # # # # # # # Pdq|## ri## Fklqdᄊv## lqgxvwulhv## duh## eh|rqg## wkh## vwdjh## zkhuh## wkh|## qhhg## lqidqw0 lqgxvwu|## surwhfwlrq1## Dovr/## ehfdxvh## ri## ilhufh## frpshwlwlrq## dprqj## Fklqhvh## ilupv/# dq|#vxevlglhv# # # wkh|#jhw#duh# # # # sdvvhg## rq#wr# # # lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|#ex|huv# # # lq#wkh# # # irup#ri# # orzhu## sulfhv1#Ehfdxvh#rwkhu# # # # Dvldq#hfrqrplhv#dovr#lqwhuyhqh#lq#wkhlu# # # # # # # fxuuhqf|ᄊv# h{fkdqjh## udwhv## dqg## vxevlgl}h## wkhlu## h{sruwhuv## wr## uhpdlq#frpshwlwlyh# # # zlwk#Fklqd/# # srru## krxvhkrogv## dfurvv## Dvld## duh## hiihfwlyho|## wd{hg## wr## wudqvihu## ehqhilwv## wr# h{sruwhuv## dqg## duh## wkxv## vxevlgl}lqj## wkh## frqvxpswlrq## ri## ulfk## krxvhkrogv## lq# lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv1#Wklv#vlwxdwlrq#lv#qhlwkhu#hiilflhqw#qru#idlu1# # # # # # # # # Pruhryhu/#ilupv#wkdw#lqyhvw#rq#wkh#edvlv#ri#wkh#frpshwlwlyh#dgydqwdjh#rewdlqhg# # # # # # # # # # # # iurp## dq## xqghuydoxhg## fxuuhqf|## duh## fuhdwlqj## dq## dgglwlrqdo## lqhiilflhqw## edvh## ri# surgxfwlrq## wkdw## zloo## uhpdlq## frpshwlwlyh## rqo|## li## xqghuydoxdwlrq## shuvlvwv1## Wkhvh# ilupv#zloo#hyhqwxdoo|#mrlq#wkrvh#wkdw#douhdg|#oree|#iru#xqghuydoxdwlrq1#Olnh#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # lqhiilflhqw#glvwruwlrqv/# # # xqghuydoxdwlrq#lv# # # fuhdwlqj#lwv# # # rzq#frqvwlwxhqf|#lq#Fklqd/# # # # zklfk#zloo#iljkw#kdug#wr#suhvhuyh#wkh#vwdwxv#txr#ehfdxvh#lwv#h{lvwhqfh#ghshqgv#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lw1## Frqwlqxhg## xqghuydoxdwlrq#lv# # # lqfuhdvlqj#Fklqdᄊv# # # ghshqghqfh## rq#wudghg# # # jrrgv# zkloh#uhgxflqj#lwv#urrp#wr#pdqhxyhu1# # # # # # Prvw#lpsruwdqw/#wkrxjk/#wkh#hiiruw#wr#nhhs#wkh#fxuuhqf|#xqghuydoxhg#lv#fuhdwlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # hqruprxv## glvwruwlrqv## lq## wkh## hfrqrp|/## kroglqj## grzq## frqvxpswlrq/## pdnlqj## doo# irupv## ri## surgxfwlrq## h{wuhpho|## fdslwdo## lqwhqvlyh## lq## d## frxqwu|## zlwk## dq## dexqgdqw# 43# vxsso|#ri#oderu/#dqg#ohdylqj#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#xqghughyhorshg1 # # # # # # # #
Wkh#Frvwv#ri#Xqghuydoxdwlrq # # # # Li#Fklqdᄊv#fhqwudo#edqn/#wkh#SERF/#ex|v#grooduv#iurp#Fklqhvh#h{sruwhuv#vr#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#nhhs#wkh#uhqplqel#iurp#dssuhfldwlqj/#lw#kdv#wr#jlyh#wkhp#uhqplqel#lq#h{fkdqjh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Li## lw## lqwhuyhqhv## d## orw/## wkh## dexqgdqfh## ri## uhqplqel## lq## flufxodwlrq## zloo## sxvk## xs# lqiodwlrq1#Wr#dyrlg#lqiodwlrq/#wkh#SERF#lvvxhv#lwv#rzq#ghew#dw#wkh#vdph#wlph#dv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ex|v## grooduv/## vr## dv## wr## prs## xs## dqg## wkhuhe|#ᄈvwhulol}hᄡ# # # wkh## h{fhvv## uhqplqel1## Sxw# gliihuhqwo|/## h{sruwhuv## hiihfwlyho|## h{fkdqjh## grooduv## iru## uhqplqel0ghqrplqdwhg# fodlpv## rq#wkh# # # SERFᄇd## surfhvv## wkdw## lv## nqrzq#dv# # # vwhulol}hg## lqwhuyhqwlrq1## Wkh# SERF#xvhv# # # wkh## h{sruwhu#ᄊv## grooduv## wr## ex|#lqwhuhvw0hduqlqj#X1V1# # # # dvvhwv/## lqfoxglqj# wkh## djhqf|#erqgv# # # glvfxvvhg## lq#fkdswhu# # # 4/## wkxv## hduqlqj## lqwhuhvw## rq## groodu## dvvhwv# zkloh#sd|lqj#lqwhuhvw#rq#uhqplqel#fodlpv1# # # # # # Li#wkh# # # lqwhuhvw#sdlg# # # rq#groodu# # # dvvhwv## lv## orz/## zkloh## uhqplqel## lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # duh# kljk/#wkh#fhqwudo#edqn#zloo#hiihfwlyho|#eh#kroglqj#d#orz0|lhog#dvvhw#zkloh#lvvxlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # d## kljk0|lhog## oldelolw|ᄇzklfk#phdqv# # # lw#zloo# # # lqfxu## d## orvv1## Li#wklv# # # qhjdwlyh## vsuhdg# zhuh## pxowlsolhg## e|#wkh# # # '5## wuloolrq#zruwk#ri#iruhljq#uhvhuyhv# # # # # # +qrw#doo# # # grooduv/## ri# frxuvh,## wkdw## Fklqd## kdv/## lw## zrxog## eorz## d## jljdqwlf## kroh## lq## wkh## Fklqhvh## exgjhw1# Pruhryhu/## d## kljk## uhqplqel## lqwhuhvw## udwh## zrxog## dwwudfw## |hw## pruh## iruhljq## fdslwdo# lqiorzv1## Lq## rughu## wr## vwhulol}h## zlwkrxw## pdnlqj## kxjh## orvvhv/## wkh## SERF## il{hv## wkh# hfrqrp|zlgh#lqwhuhvw#udwh#dw#d#orzhu#ohyho# # # # # # # # wkdq#wkh#groodu#lqwhuhvw#udwh/#erwk#e|# # # # # # # iruflqj#edqnv#wr#sd|#krxvhkrogv#d#orz#udwh#rq#wkhlu#ghsrvlwv#dqg#e|#sd|lqj#d#orz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # udwh#rq#lwv#rzq#eruurzlqj1# # # # # D## gluhfw## hiihfw## ri## vxfk## d## srolf|## lv## wkdw## Fklqd## pluuruv## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhvᄊ# prqhwdu|#srolf|1#Li#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#duh#yhu|#orz/#Fklqd#dovr#kdv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## nhhs## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## orz1## Grlqj## vr## ulvnv## fuhdwlqj## fuhglw/## krxvlqj/## dqg## vwrfn# pdunhw#exeeohv#lq#Fklqd/#pxfk#dv#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv1#Zlwk#olwwoh#iuhhgrp#wr#xvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv#wr#frxqwhudfw#vxfk#wuhqgv/#wkh#Fklqhvh#dxwkrulwlhv#kdyh#wr#xvh#eoxqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wrrov=## iru## h{dpsoh/#zkhq#fuhglw#vwduwv#jurzlqj#vwurqjo|/#wkh#zrug#jrhv#rxw#iurp# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Fklqhvh## edqn## uhjxodwru## wkdw## wkh## edqnv## vkrxog## fxw## edfn## rq## lvvxlqj## fuhglw1# W|slfdoo|/#sulydwh#ilupv#zlwkrxw#vwurqj#frqqhfwlrqv#ehdu#wkh#euxqw#ri#wkhvh#fuhglw# # # # # # # # # # # # fuxqfkhv1#Fklqhvh#lqgxvwu|#jrhv#iurp#fuhglw#ihdvw#wr#fuhglw#idplqh/#zklfk#glvuxswv# # # # # # # # # # # # orqj0udqjh#sodqqlqj1# # Wkh## orz## lqwhuhvw#udwh# # # kdv## rwkhu## dgyhuvh## hiihfwv=## lw#uhgxfhv# # # krxvhkrog## lqfrph# dqg/#vrphzkdw#shuyhuvho|/#pd|#irufh#krxvhkrogv#wr#vdyh#pruh#lq#rughu#wr#exlog#d# # # # # # # # # # # # # # 44## Lw#wkxv#ghsuhvvhv#krxvhkrog#frqvxpswlrq#dqg# vxiilflhqw#qhvw#hjj#iru#uhwluhphqw1 # # # # # # # # # pdnhv#Fklqd#|hw#pruh#ghshqghqw#rq#iruhljq#ilqdo# # # # # # # # # ghpdqg1#Pruh#sureohpdwlf/#lw# # # # nhhsv## wkh## frvw## ri## fdslwdo## xqqdwxudoo|## orz1## Vr## zkhq## edqnv## duh## zloolqj## wr## ohqg/# ilupv## eruurz## wr#wkh# # # klow#wr#ilqdqfh# # # # fdslwdo0lqwhqvlyh## surmhfwv## +dqg#wr#nhhs#vrph# # # # uhvhuyhv## iru## zkhq## ohqglqj## vwrsv,/## zlwk## pdfklqhu|## vxevwlwxwlqj## iru## mrev1## Vr## d# frxqwu|## zlwk## d## oderu## vxusoxv## lqyhvwv## d## wuhphqgrxv## dprxqw## lq## fdslwdo0lqwhqvlyh# lqgxvwulhv/#fuhdwlqj#idu#ihzhu#mrev#wkdq#qhhghg1# # # # # # # Odvw/## exw#qrw#ohdvw/# # # # ghvslwh## ohqglqj#dw#udwhv# # # # wkdw#duh# # # yhu|#orz# # # lq#uhdo# # # whupv## wr# lqgxvwu|/#wkh#hyhq#orzhu#udwh#wkh|#sd|#rq#ghsrvlwv#jlyhv#edqnv#dq#hqruprxv#surilw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vsuhdg1#Wklv#fxvklrq/#dffxpxodwhg#dw#krxvhkrogvᄊ#h{shqvh/#doorzv#wkhp#wr#pdnh# # # # # # # # # # # jljdqwlf## ohqglqj## plvwdnhv## zlwkrxw## jrlqj## xqghu1## Lw## dovr## doorzv## wkhp#wr# # # h{foxgh#
rwkhu#frpshwlqj#vrxufhv#ri#ilqdqfh/#vxfk#dv#frusrudwh#erqg#pdunhwv1#Doo# # # # # # # # # # # # d#edqn# # kdv## wr## gr## lv## wr## fxw#lwv# # # vsuhdg## d## olwwoh## wr## shuvxdgh## ilupv## qrw#wr# # # lvvxh## lq#wkh# # # erqg# pdunhw/#wkxv#nhhslqj#wkrvh#pdunhwv#looltxlg#dqg#xqdwwudfwlyh1# # # # # # # # Wkhuh## duh## rwkhu/## uhodwhg/## glvwruwlrqv1## Rqh## ri## wkh## gdqjhuv## ri## kdylqj## dq# lqhiilflhqw/#edqn0grplqdwhg#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp/#dv#zh#kdyh#vhhq/#lv#wkdw#ilupv#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # # jrrg## frqqhfwlrqv## lq## wkh## v|vwhp## jhw## ordqv/## zkloh## rwkhuv## gr## qrw1## Lq## Fklqd/## wkh# grplqdqw#vwdwh0rzqhg#edqnlqj#v|vwhp#w|slfdoo|#ohqgv# # # # # # # wr#vwdwh0rzqhg#frpsdqlhv# # # ᄇqr#ordq#riilfhu#ulvnv#ehlqj#dffxvhg#ri#fruuxswlrq#li#kh#ohqgv#wr#d#vwdwh0rzqhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ilupᄇdqg#vwduyhv#wkh#sulydwh#vhfwru#ri#ixqgv1#Wkh#Fklqhvh#sulydwh#vhfwru#lv#wkxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # vtxhh}hg## ehwzhhq## d## vwdwh0rzqhg## vhfwru/## zklfk## jhwv## fkhds## orfdo## ixqgv/## dqg# iruhljq#frpsdqlhv# # # lqyhvwlqj#lq#Fklqd/# # # # zkr## fdq#udlvh# # # fkhds## prqh|#rxwvlgh1# # # Qr# zrqghu#vr#ihz#odujh#sulydwh#Fklqhvh#frpsdqlhv#h{lvw/#dv#wkh|#gr/#iru#h{dpsoh/#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lqgld145##Idu#iurp#ehlqj#wkh#eudlqv#ri#wkh#hfrqrp|/#zklfk#lw#zloo#lqfuhdvlqjo|#qhhg# wr## ehfrph## li## Fklqd## lv## wr## doorfdwh## fdslwdo## dqg## uhvrxufhv## ehwwhu/## wkh## Fklqhvh# ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## lv## ehfrplqj#wkh# # # lqhiilflhqw## wrro## ri#vwdwh# # # srolf|1## Wklv## fdqqrw## eh# jrrg#iru#Fklqd#lq#wkh#orqj#uxq1# # # # # # # Fklqdᄊv#xqghuydoxhg#h{fkdqjh#udwh/#gulyhq#e|#d#vwurqj#h{sruwhu#oree|/#lv#olnho|# # # # # # # # # # # # wr#eh#ghwulphqwdo#wr#Fklqdᄊv#ghyhorsphqw1#Wkh#h{sruw0ohg#sdwk#dovr#wdnhv#lw#grzq# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## vdph## urdg## dv## Mdsdq/## dqg## wkdw## urdg/## dv## zh## kdyh## vhhq/## ohdgv## lq#d# # # gdqjhurxv# gluhfwlrq1#
Shuvxdglqj#Fklqd # # Zkhqhyhu## L## eurdfk## wkh## vxemhfw## lq## Fklqd## ri## zkhwkhu## wkh## uhqplqel## zloo## eh# doorzhg## wr## dssuhfldwh/## p|## krvwv## uhplqg## ph## krz## Mdsdq## pdgh## wkh## plvwdnh## ri# djuhhlqj## wr## X1V1## suhvvxuh## lq## 4<;:## dqg## doorzhg## wkh## |hq## wr## dssuhfldwh## vkduso|1# Mdsdqᄊv## zrhv/## dffruglqj#wr# # # wkh## Fklqhvh/## gdwh## iurp#wkdw#shulrg/# # # # iru## wkh|#vorzhg# # wkh#jurzwk#ri#wkh#vxffhvvixo#h{sruw#vhfwru#zlwkrxw#uhsodflqj#lw#zlwk#dq|wklqj#hovh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh## Fklqhvh## zrxog## suhihu## wr## surfhhg## pruh## vorzo|#dqg# # # gholehudwho|/## ᄈfurvvlqj# wkh#ulyhu#e|#ihholqj#wkh#vwrqhv/ᄡ#dv#wkh|#sxw#lw1# # # # # # # # # # Zkdw## wkh|## grqᄊw## vhh## lv## wkdw## wkh## Mdsdqhvh## pd|## kdyh## ohiw## wkh## wudqvlwlrq## iurp# h{sruw0rulhqwhg#jurzwk#wr#pruh#edodqfhg#jurzwk#xqwlo#wrr#odwh/#dqg#qrz#kdyh#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # frqwhqg#zlwk#erwk#wkdw#sureohp#dqg#wkdw#ri#d#udslgo|#djlqj#srsxodwlrq1#Fklqd#fdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # pryh## wr## d## pruh## edodqfhg## jurzwk## sdwk## zkloh## lwv## srsxodwlrq## lv## vwloo## uhodwlyho|# |rxqj#+doehlw#djlqj#dv#d#uhvxow#ri#wkh#rqh0fklog#srolf|,1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh## qhhghg## uhirupv## duh## olnho|#wr# # # eh## dwwudfwlyh## wr## krxvhkrogv/## zklfk#lv# # # zk|# pxowlodwhudo## lqvwlwxwlrqv## pljkw#ilqg# # # dq#dwwhqwlyh# # # dxglhqfh## li#wkh|#h{sodlqhg# # # # wr## wkh# Fklqhvh#shrsoh#zkdw#qhhgv#wr#eh#grqh#dqg#zk|1#D#vwurqjhu#uhqplqel#zloo#doorz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Fklqhvh## plggoh## fodvv## wr## lpsruw## fkhdshu## iruhljq## jrrgv## dqg## hqmr|## ohvv# h{shqvlyh#iruhljq#krolgd|v1#Kljkhu#dqg#pruh#pdunhw0gulyhq#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#vkrxog# # # # # # # # # # jlyh#wkhp#kljkhu#lqfrphv1#Dqg#d#pruh#eurdgo|#edvhg#shqvlrq#ru#vrfldo#vhfxulw|# # # # # # # # # # # # # vfkhph/## vwuhqjwkhqhg## e|#doorfdwlqj#wkh# # # # vkduhv## ri#vwdwh0rzqhg# # # hqwhusulvhv## wr## wkh# vfkhph/#vkrxog#jlyh#wkhp#juhdwhu#frqilghqfh#wr#vshqg1# # # # # # # # Zkhq#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#kdyh#wr#sd|#kljkhu#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#rq#wkhlu#eruurzlqj/# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#pdujlqv#zloo#vkulqn/#dqg#wkh|#zloo#kdyh#ohvv#urrp#wr#riihu#dwwudfwlyh#ghdov#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # idyruhg## vwdwh0rzqhg## hqwhusulvhv1## Vrph## ri#wkhvh# # # zloo## udlvh## prqh|#gluhfwo|#iurp# # # erqg## pdunhwv## dqg## htxlw|## pdunhwv/## iruflqj## wkhvh## ilupv## wr## udlvh## wudqvsduhqf|/# lpsuryh## jryhuqdqfh## sudfwlfhv/## dqg## lqfuhdvh## glylghqg## sd|rxwv1## Frusrudwh## erqg# pdunhwv## frxog## ehfrph## d## yldeoh## dowhuqdwlyh## wr## edqnv/## fuhdwlqj## ixqglqj## fkdqqhov# rxwvlgh#wkh#uhodwlrqvkls#v|vwhp1#Li#wkh|#orvh#wkhlu#ehvw#folhqwv/#wkh#edqnv#zloo#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## jr## eh|rqg## wkhlu## frpiruw#}rqh1# # # Wkh|#pd|#vwduw#ohqglqj#wr# # # # # # vpdoo## dqg## phglxp0 vl}hg#sulydwh#hqwhusulvhv/#wkxv#jlylqj#wkhp#wkh#uhvrxufhv#wr#jurz1#Wkh|#pd|#dovr# # # # # # # # # # # # # h{sdqg## uhwdlo## fuhglw/## wkxv## uhgxflqj#wkh# # # qhhg## iru## krxvhkrogv## wr## vdyh## ehiruh## wkh|# fdq## ex|1## Fklqd## frxog## ehfrph## ohvv## ri## d## surgxfhu0rulhqwhg/## fdslwdo0lqwhqvlyh# hfrqrp|#dqg# # # ehfrph## erwk#pruh# # # sulydwh0vhfwru0rulhqwhg## dqg## idu## ohvv## ghshqghqw# rq#iruhljq#ghpdqg1# # # Vxfk#d#wudqvlwlrq#lv#qrw#hdv|/#exw#wkh#wlph#lv#uljkw1#Ehfdxvh#irrg#sulfhv#duh#kljk/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iduphuv/## vwloo## wkh## prvw## qxphurxv## frqvwlwxhqf|## lq## Fklqd/## zloo## qrw## eh## kxuw# vljqlilfdqwo|#e|#dq#dssuhfldwlrq#ri#wkh#uhqplqel#wkdw#zloo#eulqj#lq#frpshwlqj#irrg# # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwv1## Vwdwh0rzqhg## ilupv## duh## ioxvk## zlwk## fdvk/## vr## wklv## srzhuixo## jurxs## fdq# vxvwdlq#wkh#orvv#ri#surilwv#dv#lqsxwv#olnh#fdslwdo/#hqhuj|/#dqg#odqg#duh#vxevlgl}hg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ohvv1#Wkh|#kdyh#lqyhvwhg#d#orw#uhfhqwo|/#dqg#d#vorzgrzq#lq#lqyhvwphqw#pd|#qrw#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hqwluho|## edg1## Krzhyhu/## uhirupv## zloo## kdyh## wr## ghsduw## iurp## wkh## sdwk## ri## vwhdg|# h{shulphqwdwlrq## dqg## lqfuhphqwdolvp## dqg## zloo## uhtxluh## erog## pryhv## lqwr## wkh# xqnqrzq## rq## pxowlsoh## iurqwvᄇiuhhlqj## h{fkdqjh## udwhv/## lqwhuhvw## udwhv/## dqg## vrph# sulfhv/## iru## h{dpsoh1## Uhjxodwruv## zloo## kdyh## wr## eh## h{wuhpho|## yljlodqw## wkdw## wkh#
edqnlqj#v|vwhp#grhv#qrw#jr#ehuvhun#gxulqj#wkh#surfhvv#ri#fkdqjh=# # # # # # # # # # # # wklv#lv#d#yhu|# # # # lpsruwdqw#ohvvrq#iurp#wkh#idlohg#Mdsdqhvh#wudqvlwlrq1# # # # # # # Wkhuh#duh#wzr#lpsruwdqw#uhdvrqv#zk|#Fklqd#pd|#eh#pruh#rshq#wr#vwuhqjwkhqlqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## dqg## djuhhphqwv## dw## wklv## mxqfwxuh1## Iluvw/## lw## lv## h{wuhpho|# ghshqghqw#rq#h{sruwv/#dqg#wkh#jurzlqj#surwhfwlrqlvw#prrg#lq#ghyhorshg#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # kdv## lw## zruulhg1## Wr## wkh## h{whqw## wkdw## lw## fdq## zdug## rii## vxfk## pryhv## wkurxjk## wkh# shuvxdvlyh## hiiruwv## ri## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv/## lw## kdv## dq## lqfhqwlyh## wr## vxssruw# wkhp1## Vhfrqg/## Fklqd## kdv## pruh## wkdq#'5# # # wuloolrq#zruwk#ri# # # # uhvhuyhv## wkdw## duh## ixoo|# h{srvhg#wr#wkh#edg#pdfurhfrqrplf#srolflhv#ri#wkh#frxqwulhv#zkrvh#ghew#lw#krogv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # Pruh## wkdq## dq|## rwkhu## frxqwu|/## lw## zrxog## ehqhilw## iurp## d## vwurqj## lqwhuqdwlrqdo# hfrqrplf## duudqjhphqw#wkdw#vfuxwlql}hv# # # # frxqwu|#srolflhv1# # # Wklv## dovr## phdqv## wkdw#lq# # rughu#wr#shuvxdgh#Fklqd#ri#wkh#ydoxh#ri#fkdqjh/#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#vkrxog#vkrz# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw#wkh|#wkhpvhoyhv#fdq#dovr#eh#shuvxdghg1# # # # # # # Lq#vxp#wkhq/#wklv#zrxog#eh#d#jrrg#wlph#iru#pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#wr#rewdlq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # d#pdqgdwh#wr#pdnh#wkh#fdvh#pruh#gluhfwo|#wr#wkh#wklqnlqj#plggoh#fodvv#lq#Fklqdᄇ# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#h{sodlq#wkhlu#uhvhdufk/#dqdo|vlv/#dqg#uhfrpphqgdwlrqv#lq#xqghuvwdqgdeoh#survh# # # # # # # # # # gluhfwo|## wr## wkh## Fklqhvh## lqwhooljhqwvld## yld## duwlfohv/## lq## frqihuhqfhv/## dqg## rq## wkh# Lqwhuqhw1## Li## wkh## uroh## ri## wkh## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## fdq## eh## dssursuldwho|# flufxpvfulehg/## wkh## Fklqhvh## ohdghuvkls## pljkw## srvvleo|## dffhsw## vxfk## d## pdqgdwh/# hvshfldoo|## li## d## vlplodu## fdvh## iru## fkdqjh## lv## ehlqj## pdgh## hovhzkhuh## dqg## wkh# dowhuqdwlyh#lv# # # d#glvlqwhjudwlrq#ri#wkh#joredo# # # # # # hfrqrp|#lqwr#surwhfwlrqlvp1#Lqghhg/# # # # wkh## J053## vkrxog## djuhh## wr## shuplw## wkh## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## olnh## wkh## LPI# vxevwdqwldo## ohhzd|## wr## irvwhu## eurdghu## glvfxvvlrq## zlwklq## wkhlu## frxqwulhv## lq## dq# dwwhpsw#wr#dfklhyh#wkh#judqg#remhfwlyhv#ri#joredo#dgmxvwphqw#odlg#rxw#hduolhu1#Li#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # lv#wr#jdlq#zlgh#dffhswdqfh/#wkh#LPI#vkrxog#dovr#eh#hyhqkdqghg#lq#pdnlqj#d#fdvh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iru## srolf|## fkdqjh## lq## rwkhu## frxqwulhv/## deryh## doo## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv1## Lq## jrlqj# eh|rqg#wkhlu#rzq#frpiruw#}rqh/#pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#kdyh#olwwoh#wr#orvh#exw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu#luuhohydqfh#lq#dgguhvvlqj#shukdsv#wkh#prvw#lpsruwdqw#joredo#pdfurhfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # sureohp#ri#rxu#wlph1# # # #
Vxppdu|#dqg#Frqfoxvlrq # # # Wkh## idxow## olqhv## wkdw## kdyh## ohg## wr## wkh## joredo## wudgh## lpedodqfhv## dqg## fuhdwhg# wrgd|ᄊv#Pdqghyloohdq#zruog#duh#ghhs1#Pruhryhu/#ehfdxvh#wkh#lpedodqfhv#duh#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # uhvxow## ri## ghhso|## hpehgghg## vwudwhjlhv/## fkdqjh## zloo## eh## sdlqixo1## Lw## lv## qrw## mxvw## d# pdwwhu#ri#udlvlqj#dq#lqwhuhvw#udwh#khuh/#d#wd{#wkhuh/#ru#dq#h{fkdqjh#udwh#vrphzkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hovh1## Lw## lv## whpswlqj## iru## wkh## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## hvwdeolvkphqw## wr## wuhdw## dgmxvwphqw## dv## d# vlpsoh#pdwwhu#dqg#wkhq#h{suhvv#frqwlqxrxv#vxusulvh#wkdw#fkdqjh#grhv#qrw#rffxu1#Lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # dovr#jlyhv#srolwlfldqv#wkh#gdqjhurxv#lpsuhvvlrq#wkdw#fkdqjh#lv#hdv|#iru#wkh#rwkhu# # # # # # # # # # # # # vlgh/#vr#sxqlwlyh#wudgh#vdqfwlrqv#fdq#khos#shuvxdgh1#Zh#vkrxog#kdyh#qr#looxvlrqv=# # # # # # # # # # # # # fkdqjh#lv#gliilfxow#iru#doo#frxqwulhv/#wkrxjk#wkh|#doo#vwdqg#wr#jdlq#lq#wkh#orqj#whup/# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # qrw## mxvw## iurp#d# # # pruh## vwdeoh## zruog## hfrqrp|## exw## dovr## iurp#d# # # pruh## vxvwdlqdeoh# grphvwlf#jurzwk#vwudwhj|1# # # Jlyhq## wkdw## dfwlrqv## wr## uhgxfh## vxvwdlqhg## wudgh## vxusoxvhv## ru## ghilflwv## uhtxluh# grphvwlf## srolwlfdo## prphqwxp/## lw#lv# # # qrw#vxusulvlqj#wkdw#qrwklqj#uhdoo|#kdsshqv# # # # # # # dw# wkhvh## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## phhwlqjv1## Sodwlwxghv## duh## uroohg## rxw/## exw## hyhu|rqh## nqrzv# qrwklqj#zloo#eh#grqh1#L#kdyh#dujxhg#wkdw#pxowlodwhudo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#olnh#wkh#LPI#dqg# # # # ## # # # # # # # # wkh#Zruog#Edqn#vkrxog#wdnh#d#fxh#iurp#wkh#pryhphqwv#surprwlqj#dfwlrq#djdlqvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # folpdwh#fkdqjh#dqg#vxssruwlqj#dlg#wr#srru#frxqwulhv1#Wkh|#vkrxog#h{sdqg#eh|rqg# # # # # # # # # # # # pdnlqj#wkhlu#fdvh#wr#wkh#wrs#ohdghuv#wr#fuhdwlqj#pruh#srolwlfdo#prphqwxp#zlwklq# # # # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv/#xvlqj#doo#wkh#prghuq#phwkrgv#ri#frqwdfw#wkdw#whfkqrorj|#kdv#sxw#dw#rxu# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frppdqg1## Wkh|## vkrxog## vshdn## gluhfwo|## wr## wkh## lqioxhqwldo## dqg## wkh## frqqhfwhg/# h{sodlqlqj#zk|#fkdqjh#lv#qhfhvvdu|#dqg#krz#lw#fdq#eh#ehqhilfldo#ghvslwh#wkh#sdlq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri## dgmxvwphqw1## Wkh## pxowlodwhudo## djhqflhv## vkrxog## khos## eulgjh## wkh## idxow## olqhv# ehwzhhq#qdwlrqv#dqg#khos#hdfk#rqh#vhh#zkdw#lw#qhhgv#wr#gr1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wklv## lv## qrw#d# # # wdvn#wkdw#wkh# # # # sulydwh## ru## qrqsurilw#vhfwru# # # zloo## xqghuwdnh1## Fxggo|# nrdodv/## udlq#iruhvwv/# # # dqg## ghvwlwxwh## fkloguhq#lqvsluh# # # khduwv/## plqgv/## dqg## grqdwlrqv1# Fdxvhv#vxfk#dv#joredo# # # # # wudgh#lpedodqfhv/#h{fkdqjh#udwhv/#dqg#hyhq#irrg#vfduflw|# # # # # # # # duh#xqolnho|#wr#kdyh#wkh#vdph#sxeolf#dsshdo# # # # # # # # # dqg#zloo# # # qrw#eh#wdnhq#xs#e|#QJRv1# # # # # # Wklv## lv## suhflvho|## zk|## wkh## zhoo0ixqghg## pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## kdyh## wr## jhw# lqyroyhg1## Xqolnh## wkh## QJRv/## wkh|## gr## qrw## kdyh## wr## fkrrvh## h{flwlqj## ru## hprwlrqdo# lvvxhv#wkdw#dwwudfw#ixqglqj=#wkh|#fdq#irfxv#rq#wkh#gulhu#lvvxhv#wkdw#duh#hyhu|#elw#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # lpsruwdqw#wr#wkh#ixwxuh#ri#rxu#joreh1# # # # # # # Ilqdoo|/#fkdqjh/#zkhwkhu#dwwhpswlqj#wr#hqirufh#joredo#glvflsolqh#zlwk#d#vwlfn#ru# # # # # # # # # # # # hqfrxudjlqj## flwl}hqv## wr## sxvk## iru## lw## iurp## ehorz/## zloo## qrw## frph## hdvlo|## iru## wkh# pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv1#Qru#zloo#lw#eh#hdv|#iru#frxqwulhv#wr#frqwhpsodwh#jlylqj# # # # # # # # # # # # pxowlodwhudo#rujdql}dwlrqv#wkh#iuhhgrp#wr#lqioxhqfh#grphvwlf#rslqlrqv1#Fklqd#kdv# # # # # # # # # # qrw## vkrzq## pxfk## wrohudqfh## iru## grphvwlf## glvfxvvlrq/## dqg## hyhq## dv## L## zulwh/## lv# hpeurlohg## lq#d# # # glvsxwh## zlwk#wkh# # # vhdufk#jldqw#Jrrjoh# # # # ryhu## fhqvruvkls1## Exw#hyhq# # Fklqd#lv#ilqglqj#lw#lqfuhdvlqjo|#gliilfxow#wr#frqwuro#glvfxvvlrq#rq#wkh#Zhe1#Wkhuh# # # # # # # # # # # # # lv## pruh## ghprfudf|#lq#Fklqd# # # # wkdq#lv# # # uhiohfwhg#lq#lwv# # # # hohfwlrqv1#Lwv# # # jurzlqj#Zhe0 # frqqhfwhg## plggoh## fodvv## lv## rewdlqlqj## pruh## lqioxhqfh## ryhu## wkh## Frppxqlvw## Sduw|# dqg## wkh## Fklqhvh## ohdghuvkls1## Wkh## uhfhqw#kdp0ilvwhg# # # dwwhpsw#e|#wkh# # # # dxwkrulwlhv## wr# olplw#wkh#ylhzlqj#ri#wkh#zruogzlgh#klw#prylh#Dydwdu/#dqg#wkh#vxevhtxhqw#ixulrxv# # # # # # # # # # # # # sxeolf#uhdfwlrq#surpswlqj#+dq#dgplwwhgo|#uduh,#srolf|#uhyhuvdo/#pd|#eh#lqglfdwlyh# # # # # # # # # # # ri#wklqjv# # # wr## frph1## Dw#dq|#udwh/# # # # gudfrqldq#dwwhpswv# # # wr## olplw#rxwvlgh# # # frqwdfw#pd|# #
zrun#iru#d#zkloh#exw#zloo#hyhqwxdoo|#kxuw#wkh#Fklqhvh#hfrqrp|/#d#nh|#frqfhuq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Frppxqlvw#Sduw|1# # # Pruhryhu/## suhvvxuh## zloo## exlog## erwk#iurp#lqvlgh# # # # dqg## iurp# rxwvlgh#iru#Fklqd#wr#eh#d#uhvsrqvleoh#joredo#flwl}hq1# # # # # # # # # Lq#vxp/# # # pxowlodwhudo## rujdql}dwlrqv## vkrxog## sod|#d# # # juhdwhu## uroh## lq#ghilqlqj#zkdw# # # joredo#hfrqrplf#flwl}hqvkls#phdqv#dqg#dsshdo#gluhfwo|#wr#wklqnlqj#shrsoh#durxqg# # # # # # # # # # # wkh## zruog/## xvlqj## qrw## revfxuh/## xquhdg## sdshuv## exw## prghuq## whfkqrorjlfdo## wrrov1# Ehfdxvh#p|#sursrvdo#grhv#qrw#suhfoxgh#wkh#kroglqj#ri#wkrvh#iuhqhwlf#lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # # # # # # # # # # phhwlqjv#dqg#frqihuhqfhv#wkdw#dfklhyh#olwwoh/#zk|#qrw#wu|#lwB# # # # # # # # # #
Hslorjxh #
Z## H## OLYH## LQ## DQ## DJH## RI## SOHQW\1## Li## L## uhiohfw## rq## mxvw## wkh## fkdqjhv## L## kdyh#
h{shulhqfhg## dv## dq#dfdghplf# # # ryhu## wkh## sdvw#wkuhh# # # ghfdghv## ru## vr/## wkh|#erjjoh# # # p|# plqg1#P|#iluvw#h{shulhqfh# # # # # zlwk#d# # # frpsxwhu## fdph## rqo|#lq#wkh# # # # vhfrqg#|hdu# # # ri#p|# # xqghujudgxdwh## ghjuhh## lq## hohfwulfdo## hqjlqhhulqj1## L## vd|## h{shulhqfh## ehfdxvh## zh# qhyhu## dfwxdoo|#vdz# # # ru## wrxfkhg## wkh## frpsxwhu1## Lw#zdv# # # krxvhg## lq#d# # # p|vwhulrxv## dlu0 frqglwlrqhg#urrp#wkdw#rqo|#wkh#sulylohjhg#zhuh#doorzhg#wr#hqwhu1#Zh#krl# # # # # # # # # # # # # sroorl# xvhg## wr## zulwh## rxu## surjudpv## rq## sxqfk## fdugv## dqg## vxeplw## wkhp#wr# # # wkh## frpsxwlqj# vhuylfhv#ghvn1#Zkhq#wkh#frpsxwhu#zdv#iuhh#ri#pruh#xujhqw#wdvnv/#wkh#fdugv#zrxog# # # # # # # # # # # # # # eh#ihg#lqwr#lw1#Zkhq/#suhjqdqw#zlwk#krsh/#zh#jrw#wkh#vwudqjho|#wklq#rxwsxw#d#ihz# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # gd|v## odwhu/#zh#zrxog#uhdol}h#wr#rxu# # # # # # # fkdjulq#wkdw#zh#kdg#plvsodfhg#d#frppd#rq# # # # # # # # vrph#fdug#lq#wkh#ghfn1#D#vlpsoh#surjudp#wkdw#zrxog#wdnh#d#ihz#plqxwhv#wr#ghexj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wrgd|#wrrn#xv#zhhnv#ri#kdug#oderu#wkhq1# # # # # # # # Wkh## dgyhqw## ri## wkh## shuvrqdo## frpsxwhu## pdgh## dq## hqruprxv## gliihuhqfh## wr## wkh# surgxfwlylw|## ri## dfdghplf## zrun1## Hduo|## zrug## surfhvvruv## ohw## xv## glvshqvh## zlwk# w|shzulwhuv#dqg#fruuhfwlrq#ioxlg/#exw#wkh|#zhuh#gliilfxow#wr#xvh/#hvshfldoo|#zkhq#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdph#wr#irupxodwlqj#pdwkhpdwlfdo#htxdwlrqv=#L#vshqw#pdq|#qljkwv#dv#d#SkG#vwxghqw# # # # # ## # # # # # # wu|lqj#wr#pdnh#htxdwlrqv#orrn#uljkw#rq#wkh#vfuhhq/#rqo|#wr#ilqg#rq#ixuwkhu#dqdo|vlv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## wkh|## zhuh## whfkqlfdoo|## zurqj1## Ri## frxuvh/## frpsxwhu## jdphv## zhuh## xeltxlwrxv# hyhq## wkhq/## wkrxjk## idu## ohvv## vrsklvwlfdwhg1## Dw## ohdvw## rqh## ihoorz## vwxghqw## wrrn## dq# dgglwlrqdo#|hdu#wr#ilqlvk#klv#SkG#ehfdxvh#kh#jrw#krrnhg#rq#d#jdph#fdoohg#Whwulv1#L# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # hvfdshg#dgglfwlrq#rqo|#ehfdxvh#L#zdv#vr#edg#dw#wkh#jdph#wr#vwduw#rii#zlwk1# # # # ## # # # # # # # # # Uhvhdufk#frooderudwlrqv# # # dfurvv## dq|#glvwdqfh# # # zhuh## h{wuhpho|#gliilfxow#zkhq#L# # # # zdv## vwduwlqj## rxw1## Wkh## frvw## ri## lqwhuqdwlrqdo## skrqh## fdoov## zdv## surklelwlyh/## dqg# grfxphqwv#kdg#wr#eh#vklsshg#e|#vqdlo#pdlo/#dgglqj#hqruprxvo|#wr#wkh#wlph#wdnhq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## frpsohwh## surmhfwv1## Wkh## vhdufk## iru## uhohydqw## sdshuv## lqyroyhg## krxuv## lq## wkh# oleudu|/## dqg## w|slfdoo|#zh# # # nqhz## rqo|#ri#sdshuv# # # # wkdw#kdg# # # douhdg|#ehhq#sxeolvkhg/# # # qrw#wkrvh#lq#wkh#slsholqh1#Ehfdxvh#ri#wkh#orqj#ohdg#wlphv#iru#sxeolfdwlrq/#sdshuv#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## odwhvw## mrxuqdov## kdg## w|slfdoo|#ehhq#zulwwhq#|hduv# # # # # ehiruh1## Lpdjlqh## p|#glvpd|# # zkhq#L#irxqg#d#sdshu#lq#wkh#Mrxuqdo#ri#Ilqdqfh/#d#ihz# ## # # # # # # # # # # zhhnv#ehiruh#L#zhqw#rxw# # ## # rqwr## wkh## dfdghplf## mre## pdunhw/## wkdw## frqwdlqhg## wkh## fhqwudo## lghd## lq## p|## wkhvlv1# +Oxfnlo|/#wkhuh#zhuh#hqrxjk#srlqwv#ri#gliihuhqwldwlrq#wkdw#lw#zdv#fohdu#L#kdg#pdgh# # # # # # # # # # # ## # d#frqwulexwlrq/#exw#wkh#h{shulhqfh#zdv#vwloo#yhu|#ghprudol}lqj1,# # # # # # # # # Wrgd|#hyhu|wklqj#kdv# # # # fkdqjhg1#Lqghhg/#wkh# # # # qrwherrn#frpsxwhu# # # rq#zklfk#L#dp# # ## zulwlqj#wklv#errn#kdv#wkrxvdqgv#ri#wlphv#wkh#surfhvvlqj#srzhu#ri#wkh#urrp0vl}hg# # # # # # # # # # # # # pdlqiudph#L#vwduwhg#rxw#zlwk#qrw#vr#orqj#djr/#dqg#frvwv#derxw#rqh0wkrxvdqgwk#wkh# ## # # # # # # # # # # # sulfh1## Wr## p|## fkloguhq/## p|## vwxghqw## olih## rffxuuhg## ELHᄇehiruh## wkh## Lqwhuqhw## hud1# Wkh|#fdqqrw#lpdjlqh#dq|erg|#frxog#eh#wkdw#dqflhqw$#Whfkqrorj|#kdv#fkdqjhg#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # #
olyhv/## dqg## plqh/## gudpdwlfdoo|1## Wkh## pdjqlwxgh## ri#wkh# # # fkdqjh## L#kdyh# # # h{shulhqfhg# ryhu#mxvw#wkh#sdvw#wkuhh#ghfdghv#jlyhv#ph#krsh#wkdw#zh#zloo#eh#deoh#wr#vroyh#pdq|# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#wkh#sureohpv#wkdw#vhhp#lqwudfwdeoh#wrgd|1# # # # # # # Wkrvh## sureohpv## duh## pdq|1## Demhfw## sryhuw|## lv## vwloo## d## vfrxujh## lq## pdq|# ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv1# # # Wkh## srru## vhhp#hvshfldoo|#gdpqhg# # # # e|#qdwxuh1# # # Wkh## uhfhqw# hduwktxdnh## lq## Kdlwl## nloohg## kxqguhgv## ri## wkrxvdqgv## ri## shrsoh1## Htxdoo|## vwurqj# hduwktxdnhv## rffxu## lq#rwkhu# # # sduwv## ri#wkh# # # zruog## zlwkrxw#nloolqj#vr# # # # pdq|/## srvvleo|# ehfdxvh#exloglqjv#duh#exlow#wr#zlwkvwdqg#vkrfnv1#Shukdsv#wkh#urrwv#ri#sryhuw|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#fdxvh#ri#qdwxuhᄊv#vhhplqj#odfn#ri#frpsdvvlrq#iru#wkh#yxoqhudeoh#duh#wkh#vdph=# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#lqdelolw|#lq#pdq|#sduwv#ri#wkh#zruog#wr#fuhdwh#wkh#edvlf#jryhuqdqfh#vwuxfwxuhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkdw## zloo## doorz## shrsoh## wr## fuhdwh## ghfhqw## olyholkrrgvᄇdqg## vdih## exloglqjvᄇiru# wkhpvhoyhv1# Lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#kdyh#wkhlu#rzq#sureohpv1#Hyhq#dv#jryhuqphqw#ghew#prxqwv# # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#diwhupdwk#ri#wklv#fulvlv/#srsxodwlrqv#lq#pdq|#frxqwulhv#duh#djlqj#udslgo|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # frplqj#wr#wkh#uhdol}dwlrq#wkdw#wkhlu#jryhuqphqwᄊv#hduolhu#surplvhv#ri#vhfxulw|#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # khdowk#fduh#lq#rog#djh#duh#olnho|#wr#eh#uhqhjhg#rq1#Dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh|#wljkwhq#wkhlu# # # # ehowv## wr# surylgh#iru#wkh#gliilfxow#suhvhqw/#wkh#ixwxuh/#li#dq|wklqj/#orrnv#eohdnhu1# # # # # # # # # # # Dv## li#wklv# # # zhuh## qrw#hqrxjk/# # # wkh## vlqv## ri#rxu# # # sdvw#duh# # # fdwfklqj#xs# # # zlwk#xv1# # # Wkh# hylghqfh## iru## folpdwh## fkdqjh/## zlwk## srwhqwldoo|## glvdvwurxv## hqylurqphqwdo## dqg# hfrqrplf## frqvhtxhqfhv/## vhhpv## frpshoolqj1## Dowkrxjk## wkhuh## lv## dozd|v## d# srvvlelolw|#wkdw#zh#zloo#ryhuuhdfw/#wkh#ulfkhvw#frxqwulhv#qhhg#wr#wklqn#ri#zd|v#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhgxflqj## xqqhfhvvdu|## frqvxpswlrq## ri## hqhuj|## dqg## pdwhuldov/## dqg## ghyhorslqj# frxqwulhv#qhhg#wr#frqvlghu#pruh#vxvwdlqdeoh#sdwkzd|v#wr#jurzwk1# # # # # # # # # Wkhvh## sureohpv## fdq## dqg## zloo## eh## vroyhg/## surylghg## zh## uhwdlq## idlwk## lq## kxpdq# lqjhqxlw|#dqg#jlyh#lw#vsdfh#wr#h{suhvv#lwvhoi1#Hfrqrplf#uhirupv#lq#Fklqd#dqg#Lqgld# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kdyh#xqohdvkhg#wkh#fuhdwlyh#hqhujlhv#ri#pruh#wkdq#d#wklug#ri#kxpdqlw|1#Ploolrqv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # kljko|#wudlqhg# # # Fklqhvh## dqg## Lqgldq#hqjlqhhuv# # # duh## sxwwlqj#wkhlu# # # eudlqv## wr## zrun#wr# # phhw#wkh#fkdoohqjhv1#Frpsdqlhv#lq#Fklqd#duh#qrz#ohdghuv#lq#ghyhorslqj#hohfwulf# # # # # # # # # # # # fdu## edwwhulhv/## dqg## frpsdqlhv## lq## Lqgld## duh## surgxflqj## diirugdeoh## hohfwulf## fduv1# Zkhq#wkhvh# # # ghyhorsphqwv## duh## frxsohg## zlwk#wkh# # # dgydqfhv## lq#qxfohdu/# # # vrodu/## dqg# zlqg## hqhuj|#wkdw#duh# # # # wdnlqj#sodfh# # # lq#lqgxvwuldo# # # frxqwulhv/## zh## vkrxog## eh## deoh## wr# uhdfk#wkh#jrdo#ri#}hur#dxwr#hplvvlrqv#dw#d#yldeoh#frvw#lq#wkh#qrw#wrr#glvwdqw#ixwxuh1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Li## Fklqd## dqg## Lqgld## fdq## uhyhuvh## fhqwxulhv## ri## ghfolqh## lq## wkh## vsdfh## ri## ghfdghv/# shukdsv#hyhq#Kdlwl#pd|#eh#deoh#wr#xvh#wkh#ihuphqw#fuhdwhg#e|#lwv#uhfhqw#wudjhg|#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ryhufrph#wkh#juhdwhu#wudjhg|#ri#lwv#klvwru|1# # # # # # # Frooderudwlrq#ehwzhhq#frxqwulhv# # # # fdq#khos# # # lq#rwkhu# # # duhdv=## khdowk#pdqdjhphqw# # sudfwlfhv#lq#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#frxog#vkrz#wkh#zd|#wr#pdnlqj#khdowk#fduh#pruh# # # # # # # # # # # # # diirugdeoh## lq## ghyhorshg## frxqwulhv1## ᄈPhglfdo## wrxulvp/ᄡ## zkhuhe|## sdwlhqwv## iurp# ulfk## frxqwulhv## fdq## xqghujr## pxfk0qhhghg## phglfdo## surfhgxuhv## dw## vljqlilfdqwo|# orzhu## frvwv## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv/## ru## ᄈuhwluhphqw## pljudwlrq/ᄡ## zkhuhe|## wkh# hoghuo|## pljudwh## wr## uhwluhphqw## frppxqlwlhv## lq## vdoxeulrxv## exw## ohvv## h{shqvlyh# frxqwulhv/## khosv## eulqj#lqfrphv# # # wr## ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # zkloh## pdnlqj#wuhdwphqw# # dqg#rog0djh#dvvlvwdqfh#diirugdeoh1#Frqyhuvho|/#wkh#pljudwlrq#ri#|rxqjhu#zrunhuv# # # # # # # # # # iurp#ghyhorslqj#wr#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#fdq#surylgh#wkh#wd{#edvh#wr#khos#vxssruw# # # # # # # # # # # # # djlqj## lqgxvwuldo0frxqwu|## srsxodwlrqv## zkloh## dovr## htxdol}lqj## lqfrphv## joredoo|1# Uhplwwdqfhv## iurp#pljudqwv# # # fdq#khos# # # wkhlu## uhodwlyhv## edfn#krph# # # olyh## ehwwhu## olyhv=#
hqwluh## duhdv## lq## Lqgld/## Ph{lfr/## dqg## wkh## Sklolsslqhv## kdyh## ehhq## wudqviruphg## e|# uhplwwdqfhv1#Wzr0zd|#iorzv#ri#shrsoh#fdq/#li#surshuo|#pdqdjhg/#eh#dq#dqvzhu#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # vrph#ri#wkh#zruogᄊv#prvw#suhvvlqj#sureohpv1# # # # # # # Yleudqw#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#fdq#surylgh#wkh#ulvn#fdslwdo#qhhghg#e|#wkh#lqqrydwruv# # # # # # # # # # # # dfurvv#wkh#zruog#dv#zhoo#dv#wkh#vdylqjv#lqvwuxphqwv#qhhghg#e|#wkh#djlqj#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # fxuuhqf|0wudqvihu#idflolwlhv#qhhghg#e|#pljudqwv1#Exw#ilqdqfh#lv#lq#glvuhsxwh1#Fdoov# # # # # # # # # # # wr## vkdfnoh## lw## duh## ehlqj## khdug## iurp## hyhu|## txduwhu1## Pruh## gdqjhurxv## lv## wkh# srvvlelolw|#wkdw#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv/#hvshfldoo|#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#frxog#orvh#idlwk# # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#wkdw#kdv#pdgh#wkhp#zkdw#wkh|#duh1#D#plvehjrwwhq#vhqvh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## lqdghtxdf|#ri# # # pdunhwv## dqg## frpshwlwlrq#lv# # # ohdglqj#wr# # # hyhu## pruh## idlwk#ehlqj# # sodfhg#lq#wkh#jryhuqphqw1#Dowkrxjk#wkhuh#duh#fhuwdlq#wklqjv#jryhuqphqw#fdq#+dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # pxvw,#gr/#ohdglqj#g|qdplf#fkdqjh#dqg#lqqrydwlrq#lv#qrw#dprqj#wkhp1# # # # # # # # # # # Lw## lv## dq## hdv|## vwhs## iru## frxqwulhv## zkrvh## jryhuqphqwv## idlo## wr## phhw## wkh## qrz0 khljkwhqhg## h{shfwdwlrqv## wr## vhhn## wr## nhhs## zkdw## wkh|## kdyh## e|## phdqv## ri## dvvhuwlyh# qdwlrqdolvp#dqg# # # surwhfwlrqlvp1## Lqvwhdg## ri## hpeudflqj## wkh## jurzwk## ri## ghyhorslqj# frxqwulhv#dqg#nhhslqj#wkhlu#grphvwlf#pdunhwv#rshq/#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#frxog#wxuq# # # # # # # # # # # lqzdug/#wr#wkh#ghwulphqw#ri#doo1#Dffruglqj#wr#sroolqj#e|#wkh#Shz# # # # # # # # # # # # # Irxqgdwlrq/#7<# # shufhqw## ri## Dphulfdqv## wklqn## wkhlu## frxqwu|## vkrxog## plqg## lwv## rzq## exvlqhvv# lqwhuqdwlrqdoo|/#d#sursruwlrq#63#shufhqwdjh#srlqwv#kljkhu# # # # # # # # wkdq#zkhq#wkh#txhvwlrq# # # # 4# zdv#iluvw#dvnhg#lq#4<971 # # # # # Htxdoo|/#lqvwhdg#ri#dffhswlqj#juhdwhu# # # # # # uhvsrqvlelolw|#dv# # wkhlu## hfrqrplf## pljkw## jurzv/## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## frxog## surpsw## d## vwurqjhu# uhdfwlrq## e|## ehkdylqj## dv## li## wkhlu## srolflhv## frqwlqxh## wr## kdyh## olwwoh## hiihfw## rq## wkh# zruog1## Zh## frxog## |hw#frqyhuw#krsh# # # # lqwr## frqiolfw/## wkhq#ghvsdlu/# # # dv## wkh## zruog## kdv# grqh#pdq|#wlphv#ehiruh1# # # # Hfrqrplf## vwdjqdwlrq## lv## wkh## euhhglqj## jurxqg## iru## frqiolfw1## Wr## suhyhqw## klvwru|# iurp#plplfnlqj#lwvhoi/#zh#kdyh#wr#xqghuvwdqg#wkh#fdxvhv#ri#wkh#uhfhqw#fulvlv#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # dfw#rq#wkdw#xqghuvwdqglqj1#Ilqdqfldo# # # # # # pdunhwv## dqg#ghprfudwlf#jryhuqphqw#duh#qrw# # # # # lqfrpsdwleoh1#Wkh#uroh#ri#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#lv#wr#doorfdwh#uhvrxufhv#wr#wkrvh#prvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # fdsdeoh#ri#xvlqj#wkhp/#zkloh#vsuhdglqj#wkh#ulvnv#wr#wkrvh#prvw#fdsdeoh#ri#ehdulqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhp1## Wkh## uroh## ri## ghprfudwlf## jryhuqphqw## lv## wr## fuhdwh## d## ohjdo/## uhjxodwru|/## dqg# vxshuylvru|## iudphzrun## zlwklq## zklfk## ilqdqfldo## pdunhwv## fdq## rshudwh1## Krzhyhu/# ghprfudwlf## jryhuqphqw## kdv## rwkhu## urohv/## lqfoxglqj#olplwlqj#wkh# # # # prvw## lqhtxlwdeoh# frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#wkh#pdunhw#hfrqrp|#wkurxjk#wd{hv/#vxevlglhv/#dqg#vdihw|#qhwv1#Lw# # # # # # # # # # # # lv#zkhq#ghprfudwlf#jryhuqphqw#xvhv#wkhvh#rwkhu#wrrov#lqdghtxdwho|/#zkhq#lw#wulhv# # # # # # # # # # # # wr## xvh## prghuq## ilqdqfldo## pdunhwv## wr## ixoiloo## srolwlfdo## jrdov/## zkhq## lw## ehfrphv## d# sduwlflsdqw#lq#pdunhwv#udwkhu#wkdq#d#uhjxodwru/#wkdw#zh#jhw#wkh#nlqg#ri#glvdvwhuv#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zh#kdyh#mxvw#h{shulhqfhg1# # # # Vrph#dujxh#wkdw#lw#zdv#odlvvh}0idluh#lghrorj|#wkdw#ohg#xv#wr#wklv#sdvv=#uhjxodwruv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ehfdph## hqdpruhg## ri## wkh## lghdo## ri## wkh## vhoi0uhjxodwlqj## pdunhw## dqg## vwrrg## rq## wkh# vlgholqhv#dv#lw#vhoi0ghvwuxfwhg1#Wkh|#duh#rqo|#sduwo|#uljkw1#Dowkrxjk#lw#rxjkw#wr#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## gxw|## ri## uhjxodwruv## wr## ohdq## djdlqvw## wkh## suhydlolqj## zlqgv## ri## rswlplvp## +dqg# vrphwlphv## shvvlplvp,/## uhjxodwlrq## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## zdv## gulyhq## e|## wkh# plvsodfhg#ylhz#wkdw#pdunhwv#zrxog#wdnh#fduh#ri#wkhpvhoyhv/#d#ylhz#wkdw#wlph#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wlph#djdlq#pdnhv#wkh#lghrorjlfdo#Uljkw#sod|#lqwr#wkh#kdqgv#ri#wkh#lghrorjlfdo#Ohiw1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # \hw#wkh#exon#ri#wkh#gdpdjh#zdv#grqh#dv#wkh#vrsklvwlfdwhg#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#wulhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # vhhn#dq#hgjh#wkdw#wkh#X1V1#jryhuqphqw/#gulyhq#e|#srolwlfdo#frpsxovlrqv/#zdv#rqo|# # # # # # # # # # # # # wrr#zloolqj#wr#surylgh1# # # #
Surjuhvvlyhv## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## eodph## wkh## edqnhuv/## zkloh## frqvhuydwlyhv# eodph#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dqg#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh1#Wkh#zruu|lqj#uhdolw|#lv#wkdw#erwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # duh#wr#eodph/#exw#qhlwkhu#pd|#kdyh#ehhq#ixoo|#frjql}dqw#ri#wkh#idxow#olqhv#jxlglqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## dfwlrqv1## Fkdqjlqj#wkh# # # dfwruv/## ru## wu|lqj#wr# # # fkdqjh## wkhlu## lqfhqwlyhv## gluhfwo|/# pd|## kdyh## olplwhg## hiihfw=## zh## qhhg## wr## eulgjh## wkh## ghhshu## idxow## olqhv1## Xqohvv## zh# uhhvwdeolvk#wkh#surshu#uroh#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dqg#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru/#dv#zhoo#dv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # il{#wkh#lpedodqfhv#ehwzhhq#qdwlrqv/#zkdw#kdsshqhg#pd|#kdsshq#djdlq1# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru#qhhgv#wr#nqrz#wkdw#lw#zloo#ehdu#wkh#ixoo#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#lwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # dfwlrqv/#zklfk#phdqv#wkdw#lw/#dqg#qrw#wkh#wd{sd|hu/#zloo#kdyh#wr#ehdu#wkh#orvvhv#lw# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # jhqhudwhv1#Wkh#X1V1#jryhuqphqw#kdv#wr#uh0fuhdwh#wkh#dffhvv#dqg#rssruwxqlw|#iru#doo# # # # # # # # # # # # # lwv## shrsoh## wkdw#kdv# # # klvwrulfdoo|#ehhq#wkh# # # # kdoopdun#ri#lwv# # # # hfrqrp|#zkloh# # # khoslqj# wkrvh## zkr## idoo## ehklqg1## Wklv## zloo## uhgxfh## wkh## suhvvxuh## rq## wkh## jryhuqphqw## wr# lqwhuyhqh#lq#ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#ru#wr#vwlpxodwh#wkh#hfrqrp|#h{fhvvlyho|1# # # # # # # # # # Rwkhu#frxqwulhv#kdyh#wr#lpsohphqw#uhirupv#wkdw#zloo#khos#uhedodqfh#wkh#zruog# # # # # # # # # # # # hfrqrp|#zkloh#uhgxflqj#wkhlu#rzq#ghshqghqfh#rq#joredo#jurzwk1#Lq#wklv/#dv#zlwk# # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#rwkhu#fkdoohqjhv#wkdw#wkh#zruog#idfhv/#zh#zloo#qhhg#lqwhuqdwlrqdo#frrshudwlrq1# # # # # # # # # # # # Wkh#zruogᄊv#juhdw#srzhuv/#erwk#wkh#hvwdeolvkhg#rqhv#dqg#wkh#hphujlqj#rqhv/#kdyh# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr## uhfrjql}h## wkdw## wkhlu## srolflhv## gr## qrw## dgg## xs## wr## d## frkhuhqw## zkroh1## Wkh|#kdyh# # ehhq#uhoxfwdqw#wr#fuhdwh#vwurqj#joredo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wkdw#pljkw#lpsrvh#frqvwudlqwv#rq# # # # # # # # # # # # wkhlu## srolflhv1#Wr#frxqwhu# # # # wklv#uhoxfwdqfh/#zh#qhhg#wr#eurdghq#wkh#srolf|#ghedwh# # # # # # # # # dfurvv#wkh#zruog/#shuvxdglqj#flylo#vrflhw|#lq#hdfk#frxqwu|#wr#sxvk#lwv#jryhuqphqw# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#hqdfw#srolflhv#wkdw#ixuwkhu#wkh#joredo#jrrg1# # # # # # # # L#zulwh#wkhvh#odvw#olqhv#lq#d#Oxiwkdqvd#Dluexv/#io|lqj#edfn#wr#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # iurp#d#frqihuhqfh#lq#Prvfrz1#Lw#lv#odwh#lq#wkh#hyhqlqj/#dqg#wkh#jhqwoh#ud|v#ri#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zlqwu|#vhwwlqj#vxq/#wrzdug#zklfk#zh#duh#khdghg/#jolqw#pdjlfdoo|#rii#wkh#sodqhᄊv# # # # # # # # # # # # # jldqw#hqjlqhv1#Wkh# # # # yhqxh## ri#wkh# # # frqihuhqfh## uhplqgv## ph## krz## idu## zh## kdyh## frph1# Wkuhh## ghfdghv## djr/## Prvfrz## zdv## yluwxdoo|#forvhg# # # wr## dfdghplfv## iurp#wkh# # # Zhvw1# Zkhq#L#odqghg# # # # |hvwhugd|/## wkh## pdlq#sureohp#zdv# # # # jhwwlqj#iurp#wkh# # # # dlusruw#wr# # # wkh# flw|/## ehfdxvh## wkh## urdg## zdv## forjjhg/## vhhplqjo|## zlwk## doo## wkh## ploolrqv## ri## fduv# Pxvfrylwhv#kdyh#dftxluhg#vlqfh#wkh#idoo#ri#frppxqlvp1#Wkdw#lv#surjuhvv/#wkrxjk# # # # # # # # # # # # fohduo|#surjuhvv#kdv#eurxjkw#qhz#sureohpv1# # # # # # Vxfk## vfhqhv## vkrxog## uhplqg## xv## wkdw## wkh## sdvw## wkuhh## ghfdghv## kdyh## eurxjkw# lpphqvh#lpsuryhphqwv#wr#frxqwulhv#durxqg#wkh#zruog/#dv#wkh|#kdyh#kduqhvvhg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # srzhu## ri## joredo## pdunhwv## dqg## ilqdqfh## zkloh## rewdlqlqj## hfrqrplf## iuhhgrp1# Xqiruwxqdwho|/#zh#kdyh#doorzhg#srolwlfdo#lpedodqfhv#wr#ghyhors#zlwklq#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # dqg## hfrqrplf## lpedodqfhv## wr## jurz## ehwzhhq## frxqwulhv1## Lq## pdq|## ulfk## frxqwulhv/# lqvhfxulw|## dqg## ghvsdlu## kdyh## uhsodfhg## krsh1## Zh## vkrxog## qrw## ohw## zkdw## kdv## jrqh# zurqj#revfxuh#doo#wkdw#fdq#jr#uljkw/#ru#uhyhuvh#wkh#surjuhvv#zh#kdyh#pdgh1#Exw#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # suhvhuyh## dqg## uhexlog## wuxvw## lq#wkh# # # pdunhw## v|vwhp/## zh## kdyh## wr## pdnh## ixqgdphqwdo# fkdqjhv1## Jryhuqphqwv## kdyh## wr## gr## pruh## wr## khos## wkhlu## flwl}hqv## exlog## fdsdelolwlhv# wkdw#zloo# # # doorz## wkhp#wr# # # eh## surgxfwlyh1## Exw#wkh|#dovr# # # # kdyh## wr## vwhs## edfn#lq#rwkhu# # # duhdv#wr#doorz# # # # wkh#pdunhw#wr#ixqfwlrq#hiihfwlyho|1#Wklv#fulvlv#kdv#uhvxowhg#iurp#d# # # # # # # # # # # frqixvlrq#derxw#wkh#dssursuldwh#urohv#ri#wkh#jryhuqphqw#dqg#wkh#pdunhw1#Zh#qhhg# # # # # # # # # # # # # wr#ilqg#wkh#uljkw#edodqfh#djdlq/#dqg#L#dp#krshixo#zh#zloo1# # # # # # # ## # # #
QRWHV #
Lqwurgxfwlrq# # 4## Iru## h{dpsohv/## vhh## Sdxo## Nuxjpdq/## ᄈKrz## Glg## Hfrqrplvwv## Jhw## Lw## Vr# ZurqjBᄡ## Qhz## \run## Wlphv/## Vhswhpehu## 9/## 533</# zzz1q|wlphv1frp2533<23<2392pdjd}lqh239Hfrqrplfw1kwpo>## Mrkq## K1# Frfkudqh/## ᄈKrz## Glg## Sdxo## Nuxjpdq## Jhw## Lw## Vr## ZurqjBᄡ## Xqlyhuvlw|## ri# Fklfdjr#Errwk#Vfkrro#ri#Exvlqhvv/#idfxow|1fklfdjrerrwk1hgx2mrkq1frfkudqh2# # # # # # uhvhdufk2Sdshuv2nuxjpdqbuhvsrqvh1kwp/#dffhvvhg#Pdufk#8/#53431# # # # # 5## M1## Odkduw/## ᄈPu1## Udmdq## Zdv## Xqsrsxodu## +exw## Suhvflhqw,## dw## Juhhqvsdq# Sduw|/ᄡ#Zdoo#Vwuhhw#Mrxuqdo/#Mdqxdu|#5/#533<1# # # # # # # 6#Vhh#F1#Uhlqkduw#dqg#N1#Urjrii/#Wklv#Wlph#Lv#Gliihuhqw=#Hljkw#Fhqwxulhv# # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#Ilqdqfldo#Iroo|#+Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#533<,#iru#dq# # # # # # # # # # # h{fhoohqw## vwxg|## gholqhdwlqj## wkh## frpprqdolwlhv## ehwzhhq## fulvhv## wkurxjk# klvwru|1# 7## Iru## vxuyh|v/## vhh## P1## Euxqqhuphlhu/## ᄈGhflskhulqj## wkh## Oltxlglw|## dqg# Fuhglw#Fuxqfk/# # # 533:ᄆ533;/ᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri## Hfrqrplf## Shuvshfwlyhv## 56/## qr1## 4# +Zlqwhu## 533<,=## ::ᄆ433>## J1## Jruwrq/## ᄈLqirupdwlrq/## Oltxlglw|/## dqg## wkh# +Rqjrlqj,#Sdqlf#ri#533:/ᄡ#QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu#4797</#Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri# # # # # # # # # # # Hfrqrplf## Uhvhdufk/## Fdpeulgjh/## PD/## 533<>## G1## Gldprqg## dqg## U1## Udmdq/# ᄈWkh## Fuhglw## Fulvlv=## Frqmhfwxuhv## derxw## Fdxvhv## dqg## Uhphglhv/ᄡ## Dphulfdq# Hfrqrplf#Uhylhz#<<#+533<,=# # # # # 939ᄆ431#D#qxpehu# # # # ri#yhu|#jrrg#errnv# # # # # kdyh# ehhq#zulwwhq#rq#wkh# # # # # fulvlv/## lqfoxglqj#Jlooldq#Whww/#Irroᄊv# # # # # Jrog#+Qhz# # # \run=# Iuhh## Suhvv/## 533<,>## Ulfkdug## Srvqhu/## D#Idloxuh# # # ri## Fdslwdolvp## +Fdpeulgjh/# PD=## Kduydug## Xqlyhuvlw|## Suhvv/## 533<,>## Dqguhz## Urvv## Vrunlq/## Wrr## Elj## wr# Idlo#+Qhz#\run=#Ylnlqj/#533<,>#dqg#Gdylg#Zhvvho/#Lq#Ihg#Zh#Wuxvw# # # # # # # # # # # # # +Qhz# \run=#Furzq#Exvlqhvv/#533<,1# # # # 8#D1#Dwnlqvrq/#W1#Slnhww|/#dqg#H1#Vdh}/#ᄈWrs#Lqfrphv#lq#wkh#Orqj#Uxq#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Klvwru|/ᄡ## QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 4873;/## Qdwlrqdo## Exuhdx## ri## Hfrqrplf# Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # # # 9## M1## Dqghuvrq/## ᄈZdoo## Vwuhhw#Zlqqhuv# # # Jhw#Eloolrq0Groodu# # # Sd|gd|v/ᄡ## Qhz# \run## Wlphv/## Dsulo## 49/## 5343/# zzz1q|wlphv1frp2533;2372492exvlqhvv249zdoo1kwpo1# :## Vhh## Vwdfh|## Vfkuhiw/## Dduwl## Vlqjk/## dqg## Dvkoh|## Krgjvrq/## ᄈMreohvv# Uhfryhulhv## dqg## wkh## Zdlw0dqg0Vhh## K|srwkhvlv/ᄡ## Hfrqrplf## Uhylhz/## Ihghudo#
Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv#Flw|#+7wk#txduwhu/#5338,=#;4ᄆ<<1# # # # # # # # # # ;#Lelg1#
Fkdswhu#Rqh1#Ohw#Wkhp#Hdw#Fuhglw# # # # # # # 4#Vhh/#iru#h{dpsoh/#Ulfkdug#Iorulgd/#Wkh#Ulvh#ri#wkh#Fuhdwlyh#Fodvv=#Dqg# # # # # # # # # # # # # Krz#Lwᄊv#Wudqviruplqj#Zrun/#Ohlvxuh/#Frppxqlw|#dqg#Hyhu|gd|#Olih#+Qhz# # # # # # # # # # \run=#Edvlf#Errnv/#5337,1# # # # 5#Vhh#Fodxgld#Jroglq#dqg#Odzuhqfh#Ndw}/#Wkh#Udfh#ehwzhhq#Hgxfdwlrq# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#Whfkqrorj|#+Fdpeulgjh/#PD=#Ehonqds#Suhvv/#533<,/#5641# # # # # # # # 6#Lelg1/#663ᄆ641# # # 7## Rq## hgxfdwlrqdo## dwwdlqphqw/## vhh## X1V1## Fhqvxv## Exuhdx/## ᄈHgxfdwlrqdo# Dwwdlqphqw## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv=## 533;/ᄡ# zzz1fhqvxv1jry2srsxodwlrq2zzz2vrfghpr2hgxfdwlrq2fsv533;1kwpo/# dffhvvhg#Pdufk#8/#53431# # # # 8#Eulqn#Olqgvh|/#ᄈSdxo# # # # # Nuxjpdqᄊv#Qrvwdojldqrplfv=# # # Hfrqrplf#Srolflhv/# # Vrfldo## Qrupv/## dqg## Lqfrph## Lqhtxdolw|/ᄡ## Fdwr## Lqvwlwxwh## zrunlqj## sdshu/# Zdvklqjwrq/#GF/#533<1# # # 9## Dxwkru#ᄊv## fdofxodwlrqv## edvhg## rq## Jroglq## dqg## Ndw}/## Wkh## Udfh## ehwzhhq# Hgxfdwlrq#dqg#Whfkqrorj|/#851# # # # :#X1V1#Fhqvxv#Exuhdx/#ᄈHgxfdwlrqdo#Dwwdlqphqw=#Shrsoh#58#\hduv#Rog#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # Ryhu/## e|## Wrwdo## Prqh|## Hduqlqjv## lq## 533;/ᄡ# zzz1fhqvxv1jry2kkhv2zzz2fsvwdeohv236533<2shulqf2## qhz36b3341kwp/# dffhvvhg#Pdufk#8/#53431# # # # ;## Vhh## Jroglq#dqg# # # Ndw}/## Wkh## Udfh## ehwzhhq## Hgxfdwlrq## dqg## Whfkqrorj|/# 65:1# <#Lelg1/#57<ᄆ831# # # 43#Lelg1/#659ᄆ5;1# # # 44#W1#Slnhww|#dqg#H1#Vdh}/#ᄈLqfrph#Lqhtxdolw|#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#4<46ᄆ# # # # # # # # # # # # # 4<<;/ᄡ## QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## ;79:/## Qdwlrqdo## Exuhdx## ri## Hfrqrplf# Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#53341# # # # 45## Urvv## Grxwkdw## dqg## Uhlkdq## Vdodp/## Judqg## Qhz## Sduw|## +Qhz## \run=# Grxeohgd|/#533;,/#881# # # 46#Vhh#Olqgvh|/#ᄈSdxo#Nuxjpdqᄊv#Qrvwdojldqrplfv1ᄡ# # # # # # 47#Vhh#S1#Jrwwvfkdon#dqg#U1#Priilww/#ᄈWkh#Jurzwk#ri#Hduqlqjv#Lqvwdelolw|# # # # # # # # # # # # lq#wkh#X1V1#Oderu#Pdunhw/ᄡ#Eurrnlqjv#Sdshuv#rq#Hfrqrplf#Dfwlylw|#58/#qr1# # # # # # # # # # # # 5#+4<<7,=#54:ᄆ:51# # # 48#Vhh#Jroglq#dqg#Ndw}/#Wkh#Udfh#ehwzhhq#Hgxfdwlrq#dqg#Whfkqrorj|># # # # # # # # # # # Olqgvh|/#ᄈSdxo#Nuxjpdqᄊv#Qrvwdojldqrplfv1ᄡ# # # #
49## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Qrodq## PfFduwk|/## Nhlwk## Srroh/## dqg## Krzdug# Urvhqwkdo/#Srodul}hg#Dphulfd=#Wkh#Gdqfh#ri#Lghrorj|#dqg#Xqhtxdo#Ulfkhv# # # # # # # # # # +Fdpeulgjh/#PD=#PLW#Suhvv/#533;,1# # # # # 4:#Vhh#Olqgvh|/#ᄈSdxo#Nuxjpdqᄊv#Qrvwdojldqrplfv/ᄡ#431# # # # # # # 4;## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## D1## Dohvlqd## dqg## H1## OdIhuudud/## ᄈSuhihuhqfhv## iru# Uhglvwulexwlrq#lq#wkh# # # # Odqg## ri#Rssruwxqlwlhv/ᄡ# # # QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu# # # # ;59:/# Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#53341# # # # # # # # 4<#Vhh#Doehuwr#Dohvlqd#dqg#Hgzdug#Jodhvhu/#Iljkwlqj#Sryhuw|#lq#wkh#XV# # # # # # # # # # # # dqg## Hxursh=## D## Zruog## ri## Gliihuhqfh## +R{irug=## R{irug## Xqlyhuvlw|## Suhvv/# 5337,/#941# # 53#Lelg1# # 54## Doh{lv## gh## Wrftxhylooh/## Ghprfudf|## lq## Dphulfd## +Qhz## \run=# Grxeohgd|/#4<8<,/#861# # # 55## Urehuw## M1## Vdpxhovrq/## ᄈLqgliihuhqw## wr## Lqhtxdolw|/ᄡ## Qhzvzhhn/## Pd|## :/# 5334/#781# # 56## Wkh## txrwh## lv## iurp#d# # # ghvfulswlrq#e|#Mhqqlihu# # # # Krfkvfklog## rq#zkdw#khu# # # vxuyh|## uhvsrqghqwv## eholhyh/## iurp## Zkdwᄊv## IdluB## Dphulfdq## Eholhiv## derxw# Glvwulexwlyh#Mxvwlfh#+Fdpeulgjh/#PD=#Kduydug#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#4<;4,1# # # # # # # # 57#Vhh#Urehuw#Iudqn/#Idoolqj#Ehklqg=#Krz#Ulvlqj#Lqhtxdolw|#Kdupv#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # Plggoh#Fodvv#+Ehunhoh|=#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fdoliruqld#Suhvv/#533:,1# # # # # # # # 58#PfFduwk|/#Srroh/#dqg#Urvhqwkdo/#Srodul}hg#Dphulfd1# # # # # # # 59## Dulvwrwoh/## Srolwlfv/## errn## Y/## sduwv## 4ᄆ8## +Qhz## \run=## Fdpeulgjh# Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#4<;;,1#Lqghhg/#Deklmlw#Edqhumhh#dqg#Hvwkhu#Gxior#dujxh#lq# # # # # # # # # # # ᄈLqhtxdolw|#dqg# # # Jurzwk=## Zkdw#Fdq#wkh# # # # Gdwd## Vd|Bᄡ## +QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu# # # ::<6/#Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#5333,#wkdw# # # # # # # # # # fkdqjhv#lq#lqhtxdolw|#lq#hlwkhu#gluhfwlrq#whqg#wr#eh#dvvrfldwhg#zlwk#uhgxfhg# # # # # # # # # # # # jurzwk1# 5:## Vhh## U1## Juhhq## dqg## V1## Zdfkwhu/## ᄈWkh## Dphulfdq## Pruwjdjh## Pdunhw## lq# Klvwrulfdo## dqg## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Frqwh{w/ᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri## Hfrqrplf## Shuvshfwlyhv# 4</#qr1#7#+5338,=#<6ᄆ4471# # # # # 5;#Vhh/#iru#h{dpsoh/#Mdphv#U1#Eduwk/#V1#Wulpedwk/#dqg#Johqq#\djr/#Wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # Vdylqjv## dqg## Ordq## Fulvlv=## Ohvvrqv## iurp## d## Uhjxodwru|## Idloxuh## +Orv# Dqjhohv=#Plonhq#Lqvwlwxwh/#5337,1# # # # 5<## Ehwkdq|#PfOhdq/# # # ᄈIdqqlh## Pdhᄊv## Odvw#Vwdqg/ᄡ# # # Ydqlw|## Idlu/## Iheuxdu|# 533<1# 63#Vwhyhq#Krophv/#ᄈIdqqlh#Pdh#Hdvhv#Fuhglw#wr#Dlg#Pruwjdjh#Ohqglqj/ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Vhswhpehu#63/#4<<<1# # # # # # 64## Zd|qh## Eduuhww/## ᄈDqguhz## Fxrpr## dqg## Idqqlh## dqg## Iuhgglh=## Krz## wkh# \rxqjhvw#Krxvlqj#dqg#Xuedq#Ghyhorsphqw#Vhfuhwdu|#lq#Klvwru|#Jdyh#Eluwk# # # # # # # # # # wr#wkh#Pruwjdjh#Fulvlv/ᄡ#Yloodjh#Yrlfh/#Dxjxvw#8/#533;1# # # # # # # # # 65#Qdwlrqdo#Krph#Rzqhuvkls#Vwudwhj|#+Zdvklqjwrq/#GF=#Ghsduwphqw#ri# # # # # # # # # Krxvlqj#dqg#Xuedq#Ghyhorsphqw/#4<<8,/#fkdswhu#71#L#wkdqn#Surihvvru#Mrvhsk# # # # # # # ## # #
Pdvrq## ri## Orxlvldqd## Vwdwh## Xqlyhuvlw|## iru## eulqjlqj## p|## dwwhqwlrq## wr## wklv# grfxphqw#dqg#iru#iluvw#kljkoljkwlqj#wkhvh#lvvxhv1# # # # # # # 66#Vhh#Odzuhqfh#PfGrqdog#dqg#Sdwulfn#Urelqvrq/#D#Frorvvdo#Idloxuh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # Frpprq## Vhqvh=## Wkh## Lqvlgh## Vwru|## ri## wkh## Froodsvh## ri## Ohkpdq## Eurwkhuv# +Qhz#\run=#Furzq#Exvlqhvv/#533<,1# # # # # 67## Qhlo## Ekxwwd/## ᄈJlylqj## Fuhglw## Zkhuh## Fuhglw## Lv## GxhB## Wkh## Frppxqlw|# Uhlqyhvwphqw#Dfw#dqg#Pruwjdjh#Ohqglqj#lq#Orzhu0Lqfrph#Qhljkerukrrgv/ᄡ# # # # # # # # Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Erdug## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 533;ᄆ94/## Zdvklqjwrq/## GF/## 533;1# Dovr## vhh## Shwhu## Zdoolvrq/## ᄈGhuhjxodwlrq#dqg# # # wkh## Ilqdqfldo## Fulvlv=## Dqrwkhu# Xuedq#P|wk/ᄡ# # # Dphulfdq#Hqwhusulvh# # # Lqvwlwxwh/#zzz1dhl1ruj2rxworrn24333;</# # Rfwrehu#533<1# # 68## Jhrujh## Z1## Exvk/## ᄈDphulfdᄊv## Rzqhuvkls## Vrflhw|=## H{sdqglqj# Rssruwxqlwlhv/ᄡ## Mxqh## 4:/## 5337/## jhrujhzexvk0 zklwhkrxvh1dufklyhv1jry2qhzv2uhohdvhv2533723;253373;3<ᄆ<1kwpo1# 69## Jhrujh## Z1## Exvk/## ᄈUhpdunv## e|## wkh## Suhvlghqw## rq## Krphrzqhuvkls/ᄡ# vshhfk#dw#wkh# # # # Ghsduwphqw#ri#Krxvlqj#dqg# # # # # Xuedq#Ghyhorsphqw/# # # Zdvklqjwrq# GF/#Mxqh#4;/#53351# # # # 6:#Lelg1# # 6;## Vhh## Shwhu## M1## Zdoolvrq## dqg## Fkduohv## Z1## Fdorplulv/## Wkh## Odvw## Wuloolrq# Groodu## Frpplwphqw=## Wkh## Ghvwuxfwlrq## ri## Idqqlh## Pdh## dqg## Iuhgglh## Pdf# +Zdvklqjwrq/#GF=#Dphulfdq#Hqwhusulvh#Lqvwlwxwh/#Vhswhpehu#533;,1# # # # # # # 6<#Hgzdug#Slqwr/#ᄈVl}lqj#Wrwdo#H{srvxuh#wr#Vxe0Sulph#dqg#Dow0D#Ordqv# # # # # # # # # # # lq#X1V1#Iluvw#Pruwjdjh#Pdunhw#dv#ri#916313;/ᄡ#Dphulfdq#Hqwhusulvh#Lqvwlwxwh/# # # # # # # # # # # zzz1dhl1ruj2grfOle2#Slqwr0Vl}lqj0Wrwdo0H{srvxuh1sgi/#dffhvvhg#Pdufk#43/# # # # # 53431# 73#Hgzdug#Slqwr/#ᄈKljk#OWY # # # # /#Vxe0Sulph#dqg#Dow0D#Ruljlqdwlrqv#ryhu#wkh# # # # # # # Shulrg## 4<<5ᄆ4<<:## dqg## Idqqlh/## Iuhgglh/## IKD/## dqg## YDᄊv## Uroh/ᄡ## Dphulfdq# Hqwhusulvh## Lqvwlwxwh/## zzz1dhl1ruj2grfOle2Slqwr0Kljk0OWY0Vxesulph0Dow0 D1sgi/#dffhvvhg#Pdufk#43/#53431# # # # # 74#Lelg1# # 75## Dwli## Pldq## dqg## Dplu## Vxil/## ᄈWkh## Frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## Pruwjdjh## Fuhglw# H{sdqvlrq=## Hylghqfh## iurp## wkh## X1V1## Pruwjdjh## Ghidxow## Fulvlv/ᄡ## Txduwhuo|# Mrxuqdo#ri#Hfrqrplfv#457/#qr1#7#+Qryhpehu#533<,=#477<ᄆ<91# # # # # # # # # 76## Shwhu## Zdoolvrq/## ᄈEduqh|## Iudqn/## Suhgdwru|## Ohqghu/ᄡ## Zdoo## Vwuhhw# Mrxuqdo/#Rfwrehu#49/#533<1# # # # 77#Lelg1# # 78## Ri## frxuvh/## vrph## ri## wkh## fkdqjh## lv## dovr## dffrxqwhg## iru## e|## wkh## juhdwhu# zloolqjqhvv## ri## ohqghuv## wr## dffhsw## kljkhu## ordq0wr0ydoxh## udwlrv## dv## wkh## fuhglw# pdunhw## errphg1## Vhh## Mdphv## PdfJhh/## ᄈZk|## Glgqᄊw## Fdqdgdᄊv## Krxvlqj# Pdunhw## Jr## ExvwBᄡ## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Edqn## ri## Fohyhodqg## zhevlwh/# zzz1fohyhodqgihg1ruj2uhvhdufk2frpphqwdu|2533<23<3<1fip/## Ghfhpehu## 5/# 533<1# 79## Qlfrodv## S1## Uhwvlqdv## dqg## Hulf## V1## Ehovn|/## hgv1/## Eruurzlqj## wr## Olyh=#
Frqvxphu## dqg## Pruwjdjh## Fuhglw## Uhylvlwhg## +Zdvklqjwrq/## GF=## Eurrnlqjv# Lqvwlwxwlrq#Suhvv/#533;,/#471# # # # 7:#Wlp#Odqgyrljw/#Prqlnd#Sld}}hvl/#dqg#Pduwlq#Vfkqhlghu/#ᄈWkh#Krxvlqj# # # # # # # # # # Pdunhw+v,#ri#Vdq#Glhjr/ᄡ#suhvhqwdwlrq#dw#Vwdqirug#Xqlyhuvlw|/#533<1# # # # # # # # # 7;## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## LPI## Zruog## Hfrqrplf## Rxworrn## +Zdvklqjwrq/## GF=# Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Prqhwdu|#Ixqg/#Vhswhpehu#5337,/#:91# # # # # # 7<## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Mrvhsk## Vwljolw}/## Iuhh## Idoo## +Qhz## \run=## Qruwrq/# 5343,1# 83## Vhh## Vh|prxu## Olsvhw/## Djuduldq## Vrfldolvp=## Wkh## Frrshudwlyh# Frpprqzhdowk## Ihghudwlrq## lq## Vdvndwfkhzdq>## D## Vwxg|## lq## Srolwlfdo# Vrflrorj|#+Ehunhoh|=#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fdoliruqld#Suhvv/#4<84,1#L#wkdqn#Urgqh|# # # # # # # ## # Udpfkdudq#iru#wklv#uhihuhqfh1# # # # 84## Vkdzq## Froh/## ᄈIl{lqj## Pdunhw## Idloxuhv## ru## Il{lqj## Hohfwlrqv=# Djulfxowxudo## Fuhglw## lq## Lqgld/ᄡ## Kduydug## Exvlqhvv## Vfkrro## zrunlqj## sdshu/# zzz1kev1hgx2uhvhdufk2sgi23<03341sgi/#533;1# # 85#X1V1#Fhqvxv#Exuhdx/#ᄈKrphrzqhuvkls#Udwhv#iru#wkh#X1V1#dqg#Uhjlrqv=# # # # # # # # # # # 4<98## wr## Suhvhqw/ᄡ# zzz1fhqvxv1jry2kkhv2zzz2krxvlqj2kyv2klvwrulf2lqgh{1kwpo/## dffhvvhg# Pdufk#43/#53431# # # 86#Vhh/#iru#lqvwdqfh/#Udjkxudp#J1#Udmdq#dqg#Duylqg#Vxeudpdqldq/#ᄈDlg# # # # # # # # # # # dqg## Jurzwk=## Zkdw## Grhv## wkh## Furvv0Frxqwu|## Hylghqfh## Uhdoo|## VkrzBᄡ# Uhylhz#ri#Hfrqrplfv#dqg#Vwdwlvwlfv#<3/#qr1#7#+533;,=#976ᄆ981# # # # # # # # # #
Fkdswhu#Wzr1#H{sruwlqj#wr#Jurz# # # # # # 4## Vhh## Dqjxv## Pdgglvrq/## ᄈPrqlwrulqj#wkh# # # Zruog## Hfrqrp|/## 4;53ᄆ4<<5/ᄡ# Xqlyhuvlw|## ri## Jurqlqjhq/## Idfxow|## ri## Hfrqrplfv/## zzz1jjgf1qhw2pdgglvrq/# dffhvvhg#Iheuxdu|#53431# # # 5## U1## H1## Oxfdv## Mu1/## ᄈZk|## Grhvqᄊw## Fdslwdo## Iorz## iurp## Ulfk## wr## Srru# FrxqwulhvBᄡ#Dphulfdq#Hfrqrplf#Uhylhz#;3/#qr1#5#+Pd|#4<<3,=#<5ᄆ<91# # # # # # # # # # 6## Odqw## Sulwfkhww/## ᄈZkhuh## Kdv## Doo## wkh## Hgxfdwlrq## JrqhBᄡ## Zruog## Edqn# Hfrqrplf#Uhylhz#48/#qr1#6#+5334,=#69:ᄆ<41# # # # # # # 7#Wkhuh#duh#pdq|#dqwhfhghqwv#wr#wklv#ylhz/#wkrxjk#qrw#qhfhvvdulo|#lq#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # # # suhflvh#zd|#L#kdyh#irupxodwhg#lw1#Rqh#ri#wkh#hduo|#irupxodwlrqv#lv#e|#Doehuw# # ## # # # # # # # # # # Kluvfkpdq## lq#Wkh# # # Vwudwhj|## ri## Hfrqrplf## Ghyhorsphqw## +Qhz## Kdyhq/## FW=# \doh#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#4<8;,1# # # # 8## Vhh## Dqjxv## Pdgglvrq/## ᄈWkh## Hfrqrplf## dqg## Vrfldo## Lpsdfw## ri#Frorqldo# # Uxoh#lq#Lqgld/ᄡ#fkdswhu#6#ri#Fodvv# # # # # # # # Vwuxfwxuh## dqg## Hfrqrplf## Jurzwk=## Lqgld# dqg#Sdnlvwdq#Vlqfh#wkh#Prjkxov#+Qhz#\run=#Qruwrq/#4<:4,1# # # # # # # # # 9## H1## Jodhvhu/## U1## Od## Sruwd/## I1## Orsh}0gh0Vlodqhv/## dqg## D1## Vkohlihu/## ᄈGr# Lqvwlwxwlrqv#Fdxvh#JurzwkBᄡ#QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu#4389;/#Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx# # # # # # # # #
ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#53371# # # # # # :## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Gdylg## V1## Odqghv/## G|qdvwlhv=## Iruwxqhv## dqg# Plviruwxqhv#ri#wkh#Zruogᄊv#Juhdw#Exvlqhvvhv#+Qhz#\run=#Ylnlqj/#5339,1# # # # # # # # # # ;#Iru#lqvwdqfh/#dffruglqj#wr#d#uhfhqw#vwxg|/#83#wr#93#shufhqw#ri#uhvwdxudqwv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # vxuylyh## ohvv## wkdq#wkuhh# # # |hduv=## vhh## K1## Sduvd/## M1## Vhoi/## G1## Qmlwh/## dqg## W1## Nlqj/# ᄈZk|## Uhvwdxudqwv## Idlo/ᄡ## Fruqhoo## Krwho## dqg## Uhvwdxudqw## Dgplqlvwudwlrq# Txduwhuo|#79/#qr1#6#+5338,=#637ᄆ551# # # # # # <## ᄈKlvwrulfdo## Wdeohv=## Exgjhw## ri## wkh## X1V1## JryhuqphqwᄇIlvfdo## \hdu# 5343/ᄡ## Riilfh## ri## Pdqdjhphqw## dqg## Exgjhw/# zzz1zklwhkrxvh1jry2rpe2exgjhw2i|53432dvvhwv2klvw1sgi/## dffhvvhg# Iheuxdu|#53431# # 43## Iurp## Gdqlho## Ghirh/## D## Sodq## ri## wkh## Hqjolvk## Frpphufh## +4:5;,/# ghvfulehg## lq#Kd0Mrrq#Fkdqj/# # # # Nlfnlqj## Dzd|## wkh## Odgghu## +Orqgrq=## Dqwkhp# Suhvv/#5335,/#53ᄆ541# # # 44## Vshhfk#e|#Vkul# # # # V|hg## Pdvxgdo## Krvvdlq#lq#wkh# # # # Lqgldq#Sduoldphqw/# # # Orn# Vdekd## zhevlwh/# sduoldphqwrilqgld1qlf1lq2ovghe2ov442vhv8vs2355:3;<:491kwp/## dffhvvhg# Iheuxdu|#53431# # 45#Vhh#Gdqlho#\hujlq#dqg#Mrvhsk#Vwdqlvodz/#Wkh#Frppdqglqj#Khljkwv=# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#Edwwoh#ehwzhhq#Jryhuqphqwv# # # # # dqg#wkh#Pdunhwsodfh#Wkdw# # # # # Lv#Uhpdnlqj# # wkh#Prghuq#Zruog#+Qhz#\run=#Vlprq#dqg#Vfkxvwhu/#4<<;,/#451# # # # # # # # # # 46## Vhh## Plfkdho## Uhlg/## Wkh## Irujrwwhq## Frqwlqhqw=## Wkh## Edwwoh## iru## Odwlq# Dphulfdᄊv#Vrxo#+Qhz#Kdyhq/#FW=#\doh#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#533:,/#45:1# # # # # # # # # # 47#Vhh#\hujlq#dqg#Vwdqlvodz/#Wkh#Frppdqglqj#Khljkwv1# # # # # # # # 48#Vhh#Urehuw#Zdgh/#Jryhuqlqj#wkh#Pdunhw=#Hfrqrplf#Wkhru|#dqg#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # Uroh## ri## Jryhuqphqw## lq## Hdvw## Dvldq## Lqgxvwuldol}dwlrq## +Sulqfhwrq/## QM=# Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv,/#:<ᄆ;31# # # # 49#Vhh#\hujlq#dqg#Vwdqlvodz/#Wkh#Frppdqglqj#Khljkwv/#4:9ᄆ::1# # # # # # # # # 4:#Vhh#Zdgh/#Jryhuqlqj#wkh#Pdunhw/#;31# # # # # # # 4;#Lelg1/#;41# # # 4<## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Dolfh## Dpvghq/## Dvldᄊv## Qh{w## Jldqw## +Qhz## \run=# R{irug#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#4<;<,/#476ᄆ781# # # # # 53## Iru## Nruhdᄊv## pdlq## h{sruwv## lq## 4<:3/## vhh## Pdun## O1## Foliirug/## Wurxeohg# Wljhu=#Exvlqhvvphq/#Exuhdxfudwv/#dqg#Jhqhudov#lq#Vrxwk#Nruhd# # # # # # # # # +Duprqn/# Q\=#P1#H1#Vkdush/#4<<7,/#931# # # # # # 54#Vhh#Urehuw#Euhqqhu/#Wkh#Hfrqrplfv#ri# # # # # # # # Joredo## Wxuexohqfh## +Orqgrq=# Yhuvr/#5339,1# # 55#Vhh#Klurnr#Wdexfkl/#ᄈMdsdq#Vwulyhv#wr#Edodqfh#Jurzwk#dqg#Vwdelolw|/ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Vhswhpehu#48/#533<1# # # # # # 56#Txrwhg#lq#W1#Wdqljxfkl/#Mdsdqᄊv#Edqnv#dqg#wkh#ᄈExeeoh#Hfrqrp|ᄡ#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Odwh#4<;3v#+Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Fhqwhu#iru#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Vwxglhv/#Surjudp#rq# # # # # # # # # # #
XV0Mdsdq#Uhodwlrqv/# # # 4<<6,/## <1## Dovr## txrwhg## lq#Euhqqhu/# # # Wkh## Hfrqrplfv## ri# Joredo#Wxuexohqfh/#54<1# # # 57#Zk|#glg#wkh#grw0frp#errp#qrw#gr#pruh#wr#sxoo#Mdsdq#rxw#ri#lwv#voxpsB# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # Lq## sduw/## Mdsdq## zdv## khog## edfn## e|## lwv## edqnlqj## vhfwru/## zklfk## zdv## lq## ghhs# wurxeoh1#Lw#zdv#rqo|#diwhu#wkh#edqnv#zhuh#uhfdslwdol}hg#dqg#kdg#fohduhg#wkhlu# # # # # # # # # # # # # edodqfh#vkhhwv#ri#edg#ordqv#lq#wkh#hduo|#5333v#wkdw#wkh|#zhuh#lq#d#srvlwlrq#wr# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhvxph#ohqglqj1# # 58## Vhh## Klurnr## Wdexfkl/## ᄈRqfh## Vodyh## wr## Ox{xu|/## Mdsdq## Fdwfkhv## Wkuliw# Exj/ᄡ#Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Vhswhpehu#54/#533<1# # # # # # # 59#Pdufrv#Fkdprq#dqg#Hvzdu#Sudvdg/#ᄈZk|#Duh#Vdylqjv#Udwhv#ri#Xuedq# # # # # # # # # # # # Krxvhkrogv## lq## Fklqd## UlvlqjBᄡ## Eurrnlqjv## Joredo## Hfrqrp|## dqg# Ghyhorsphqw#Sdshu#64/#Eurrnlqjv#Lqvwlwxwlrq/#Zdvklqjwrq/#GF/#533;1# # # # # # # # 5:## Shwhu## Hydqv## pdnhv## wklv## srlqw## irufhixoo|## lq## Hpehgghg## Dxwrqrp|=# Vwdwhv#dqg#Lqgxvwuldo#Wudqvirupdwlrq#+Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|# # # # # # # # Suhvv/#4<<8,1# #
Fkdswhu#Wkuhh1#Ioljkw|#Iruhljq#Ilqdqflqj# # # # # # 4## Wkurxjk## pxfk## ri## wkh## 4<<3v/## Jhupdq|## udq## fxuuhqw0dffrxqw## vxusoxvhv# ehfdxvh#ri#wkh#hfrqrplf#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#uhxqlilfdwlrq1#E|#wkh#hduo|#5333v/# # # # # # # # # # # lw#zdv#edfn#wr#uxqqlqj#vxusoxvhv1# # # # # # 5## Iru## dq## h{fhoohqw## lqwurgxfwlrq## wr## iruhljq## ilqdqflqj/## vhh## Eduu|# Hlfkhqjuhhq/## Joredol}lqj## Fdslwdo=## D## Klvwru|## ri## wkh## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo# Prqhwdu|#V|vwhp#+Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#4<<9,1# # # # # # # # 6#L#rzh#wkh#whup#ᄈerrp#lq#exvwvᄡ#wr#Jhuu|#Fdsulr#ri#Zlooldpv#Froohjh1# ## # # # # # # # # # # # 7## Pduwlq## Ihogvwhlq## dqg## Fkduohv## Krulrnd/## ᄈGrphvwlf## Vdylqj## dqg# Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Fdslwdo#Iorzv/ᄡ#Hfrqrplf#Mrxuqdo#<3#+4<;3,=#647ᄆ5<1# # # # # # # # 8#Pduf# # # Odfh|/#ᄈNhq|dq#Sduoldphqw#Xqlwhv/#iru# # # # # # Pruh## Prqh|/ᄡ#Qhz#\run# # # Wlphv/## Pd|## 55/## 5338/## zzz1q|wlphv1frp253392382552zruog2diulfd255lkw0 nhq|d1kwpo1# 9## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## U1## Udmdq## dqg## O1## ]lqjdohv/## ᄈZklfk## FdslwdolvpB# Ohvvrqv## iurp## wkh## Hdvw## Dvldq## Fulvlv/ᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri## Dssolhg## Frusrudwh# Ilqdqfh## 44/## qr1## 6## +4<<;,=## 73ᄆ7;>## U1## Udmdq## dqg## L1## Wrndwolglv/## ᄈGroodu# Vkruwdjhv#dqg#Fulvhv/ᄡ#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # # # Mrxuqdo## ri## Fhqwudo## Edqnlqj## 4/## qr1## 5# +Vhswhpehu#5338,=#4::ᄆ553>#G1#Gldprqg#dqg#U1#Udmdq/#ᄈEdqnv/#Vkruw0Whup# # # # # # # # # # Ghew#dqg#Ilqdqfldo# # # # Fulvhv=## Wkhru|/#Srolf|#Lpsolfdwlrqv#dqg#Dssolfdwlrqv/ᄡ# # # # # Fduqhjlh0Urfkhvwhu## Frqihuhqfh## Vhulhv## rq## Sxeolf## Srolf|## 87/## qr1## 4## +Mxqh# 5334,=#6:ᄆ:41# # :## Wduxq#Nkdqqd# # # dqg## Nulvkqd## Sdohsx/## ᄈLv## Jurxs## Diiloldwlrq#Surilwdeoh# # # lq# Hphujlqj## PdunhwvB## Dq## Dqdo|vlv## ri## Glyhuvlilhg## Lqgldq## Exvlqhvv## Jurxsv/ᄡ# Mrxuqdo#ri#Ilqdqfh#88/#qr1#5#+Dsulo#5333,=#;9:ᄆ<41# # # # # # # # # ;#Wkh#ghvfulswlrq#ri#Doskdwhf#lv#gudzq#iurp#Pdun#O1#Foliirug#dqg#Shwhu# # # # # # # # # # # # #
Hqjduglr/## Phowgrzq=## Dvldᄊv## Errp/## Exvw## dqg## Eh|rqg## +Sdudpxv/## QM=# Suhqwlfh0Kdoo/#5333,/#469ᄆ6;1# # # <#Vhh#Vkdohqgud#G1#Vkdupd/#Wkh#Dvldq#Ilqdqfldo#Fulvlv=#Fulvlv/#Uhirup/# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#Uhfryhu|#+Pdqfkhvwhu/#X1N1=#Pdqfkhvwhu#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#5336,/#751# # # # # # # # # 43## Wkh## skrwrjudsk#lv# # # zlgho|#dffhvvleoh/# # # iru## h{dpsoh## rq#wkh# # # zhevlwh## ri# wkh## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Srolwlfdo## Hfrqrp|## ]rqh/# lsh}rqh1eorjvsrw1frp2533:23<2iodvkedfn0fdpghvvxv0vxkduwr0slf1kwpo/# dffhvvhg#Pdufk#43/#53431# # # #
Fkdswhu#Irxu1#D#Zhdn#Vdihw|#Qhw# # # # # # # 4#L#kdyh#frqfhdohg#uhdo#qdphv#khuh1# ## # # # # 5## Wkh## lghdv## lq#wklv# # # fkdswhu## hyroyhg## rxw#ri#dq#lqlwldo# # # # # riilfh## frqyhuvdwlrq# zlwk#Pduwlq#Zroi#ri#wkh#Ilqdqfldo#Wlphv/#wr#zkrp#L#rzh#wkdqnv1# # # # # # # # # ## # 6#Vwdfh|#Vfkuhiw/#Dduwl#Vlqjk/#dqg#Dvkoh|#Krgjvrq/#ᄈMreohvv#Uhfryhulhv# # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh## Zdlw0dqg0Vhh## K|srwkhvlv/ᄡ## Hfrqrplf## Uhylhz/## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh# Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv#Flw|#+7wk#txduwhu/#5338,=#;4ᄆ<<1# # # # # # # # 7## U1## Kdvnlq## dqg## L1## Vdzkloo/## Fuhdwlqj## dq## Rssruwxqlw|## Vrflhw|# +Zdvklqjwrq/#GF=#Eurrnlqjv#Lqvwlwxwlrq#Suhvv/#533<,/#4441# # # # # # # 8#Hulfd#Jurvkhq#dqg#Vlprq#Srwwhu/#ᄈKdv#Vwuxfwxudo#Fkdqjh#Frqwulexwhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # d#Mreohvv#Uhfryhu|Bᄡ#Fxuuhqw# # # # # Lvvxhv## lq## Hfrqrplfv## dqg## Ilqdqfh/#Ihghudo# # Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Qhz#\run/#</#qr1#;#+Dxjxvw#5336,=#4ᄆ:1# # # # # # # # # # # 9## Ndwku|q## Nrhqghuv## dqg## Ulfkdug## Urjhuvrq/## ᄈRujdql}dwlrqdo## G|qdplfv# ryhu#wkh#Exvlqhvv#F|foh=#D#Ylhz#rq#Mreohvv#Uhfryhulhv/ᄡ#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh# # # # # # # # # # # Edqn#ri#Vw1#Orxlv#Uhylhz#;:/#qr1#7#+Mxo|ᄆDxjxvw#5338,=#888ᄆ;31# # # # # # # # # # # :#Vfkuhiw/#Vlqjk/#dqg#Krgjvrq/#ᄈMreohvv#Uhfryhulhv1ᄡ# # # # # # # ;#Orxlv#Xfklwhooh/#ᄈOderu#Gdwd#Vkrz#Vxujh#lq#Whpsrudu|#Zrunhuv/ᄡ#Qhz# # # # # # # # # # # \run#Wlphv/#Ghfhpehu#53/#533<1# # # # # <## Vwxg|## e|## wkh## X1N1## Qdwlrqdo## Frxqflo## iru## Yroxqwhhu## Rujdql}dwlrqv## dqg# Xqlwhg#iru# # # d## Idlu## Hfrqrp|/#flwhg#lq#Doehuwr#Dohvlqd# # # # # # dqg#Hgzdug#Jodhvhu/# # # Iljkwlqj#Sryhuw|#lq#wkh#XV#dqg#Hxursh#+R{irug=#R{irug#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/# # # # # # # # # # # 5337,/#781# # 43## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Mrh## Shhn## dqg## Hulf## V1## Urvhqjuhq/## ᄈXqqdwxudo# Vhohfwlrq=## Shuyhuvh## Lqfhqwlyhv## dqg## wkh## Plvdoorfdwlrq## ri## Fuhglw## lq## Mdsdq/ᄡ# Dphulfdq## Hfrqrplf## Uhylhz#<8/# # # qr1## 7## +Vhswhpehu## 5338,=## 4477ᄆ99>#Wdnhr# # Krvkl#dqg#Dqlo#Ndvk|ds/#Frusrudwh#Ilqdqflqj#dqg#Jryhuqdqfh#lq#Mdsdq=# # # # # # # # # # Wkh#Urdg#wr#wkh#Ixwxuh#+Fdpeulgjh/#PD=#PLW#Suhvv/#5337,1# # # # # # # # # # 44#Vhh#ᄈD#Irun#lq#wkh#Urdg/ᄡ#Ilqdqfldo#Wlphv/#Ghfhpehu#44/#533<1# # # # # # # # # # # # 45## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Fod|wrq## Fkulvwhqvhq/## Wkh## Lqqrydwru#ᄊv## Glohppd# +Qhz#\run=#Kdushu#Sdshuedfnv/#5336,1# # # # #
46## Qdwlrqdo## Vflhqfh## Irxqgdwlrq/## Vflhqfh## dqg## Hqjlqhhulqj## Lqglfdwruv/# fkdswhu## 8/## Dsshqgl{## Wdeoh## 8ᄆ76/## Qdwlrqdo## Vflhqfh## Irxqgdwlrq/# zzz1qvi1jry2vwdwlvwlfv2vhlqg432f82#f8v71kwp/#dffhvvhg#Pdufk#43/#53431# # # # # # 47#Dohvlqd#dqg#Jodhvhu/#Iljkwlqj#Sryhuw|/#4<1# # # # # # # 48## Wdonlqᄊ#ᄊerxw# # # P|## Jhqhudwlrq=## Wkh## Hfrqrplf## Lpsdfw## ri## Djlqj## X1V1# Ede|#Errphuv/#PfNlqvh|#Joredo#Lqvwlwxwh/#Zdvklqjwrq/#GF/#533;1# # # # # # # # 49#Vhh/#iru#h{dpsoh/#Orxlv#Kduw}/#Wkh#Olehudo#Wudglwlrq#lq#Dphulfd#+Vdq# # # # # # # # # # # # Glhjr/#FD=#Kduyhvw#KEM/#4<<4,1# # # # # 4:#Dohvlqd#dqg#Jodhvhu/#Iljkwlqj#Sryhuw|/#4<:1# # # # # # # 4;#Vhh#Wkhgd#Vnrfsro/#Surwhfwlqj#Vroglhuv#dqg#Prwkhuv=#Wkh#Srolwlfdo# # # # # # # # # # Ruljlqv## ri## Vrfldo## Srolf|## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## +Fdpeulgjh/## PD=## Ehonqds# Suhvv/#4<<5,/#831# # # 4<#Vhh#Udjkxudp#Udmdq#dqg#Oxljl#]lqjdohv/#Vdylqj#Fdslwdolvp#iurp#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # Fdslwdolvwv#+Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#5337,1# # # # # # # 53#Vhh#Dohvlqd#dqg#Jodhvhu/#Iljkwlqj#Sryhuw|1# # # # # # # 54## Vhh## Mdfre## V1## Kdfnhu## dqg## Sdxo## Slhuvrq/## ᄈExvlqhvv## Srzhu## dqg## Vrfldo# Srolf|=## Hpsor|huv## dqg## wkh## Irupdwlrq## ri## wkh## Dphulfdq## Zhoiduh## Vwdwh/ᄡ# Srolwlfv#dqg#Vrflhw|#63/#qr1#5#+Mxqh#5335,=#5::ᄆ6581# # # # # # # # # 55## Vhh## fkduw## ᄈXqhpsor|phqw## gxulqj## wkh## Ghsuhvvlrq/ᄡ## PVQ## Hqfduwd/# hqfduwd1pvq1frp2phgldb7948794<62xqhpsor|phqwbgxulqjbwkhbghsuhvvlrq1k#wpo dffhvvhg#Ghfhpehu#53/#533<1# # # # 56#Vhh#Kdfnhu#dqg#Slhuvrq/#ᄈExvlqhvv#Srzhu#dqg#Vrfldo#Srolf|1ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # 57## Vhh## Shwhu## D1## Vzhqvrq/## ᄈYdulhwlhv## ri## Fdslwdolvw## Lqwhuhvwv=## Srzhu/# Lqvwlwxwlrqv/## dqg## wkh## Uhjxodwru|## Zhoiduh## Vwdwh## lq## wkh## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## dqg# Vzhghq/ᄡ#Vwxglhv#lq#Dphulfdq#Srolwlfdo#Ghyhorsphqw#4;#+Vsulqj#5337,=#4ᄆ# # # # # # # # # # 5<1# 58## Vhh## Mrkq## E1## Wd|oru/## ᄈWkh## Odfn## ri## dq## Hpslulfdo## Udwlrqdoh## iru## d# Uhylydo## ri## Glvfuhwlrqdu|## Ilvfdo## Srolf|/ᄡ## FHV## Lqir## Iruxp## 43/## qr1## 5# +Vxpphu#533<,=#<ᄆ461# # # 59#Hol}dehwk#Guhz/#ᄈWkluw|#Gd|v#ri#Edudfn#Redpd/ᄡ#Qhz#\run#Uhylhz#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # Errnv/#Pdufk#59/#533</#zzz1q|errnv1frp2duwlfohv2557831# # # # # 5:#Jhudog#Vhle/#ᄈLq#Fulvlv/#Rssruwxqlw|#iru#Redpd/ᄡ#Zdoo#Vwuhhw#Mrxuqdo/# # # # # # # # # # # Qryhpehu#54/#533;1# # #
Fkdswhu#Ilyh1#Iurp#Exeeoh#wr#Exeeoh# # # # # # # 4## Ehq## Ehuqdqnh/## whvwlprq|## ehiruh## wkh## Vhqdwh## Edqnlqj## Frpplwwhh/# Zdvklqjwrq/#GF/#Vhswhpehu#56/#533;/#edqnlqj1vhqdwh1jry2sxeolf2lqgh{1fipB# # # # # # IxvhDfwlrq@Khdulqjv1Whvwlprq|)KhdulqjbLG@:d74dh<h063e507g:i0;i4e0 7hi5h;dh5;i:)ZlwqhvvbLG@## f85d<gff04he407:7f0d7<60794f;ihi<dig/#
dffhvvhg#Pdufk#5;/#53431# # # # 5## Ehq## Ehuqdqnh/## ᄈDvvhw## Sulfh## Exeeohv## dqg## Prqhwdu|## Srolf|/ᄡ## vshhfk# pdgh## dw## wkh## Qhz## \run## Fkdswhu## ri## wkh## Qdwlrqdo## Dvvrfldwlrq## ri## Exvlqhvv# Hfrqrplvwv/#Rfwrehu#48/#53351# # # # 6#Vhh#Ehq#Ehuqdqnh/#ᄈDq#Xqzhofrph#Idoo#lq#Lqiodwlrq/ᄡ#uhpdunv#pdgh#dw# # # # # # # # # # # # wkh## Hfrqrplfv## Urxqgwdeoh/## Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fdoliruqld/# # # # Vdq#Glhjr/# # # Od## Mrood/# Fdoliruqld/#Mxo|#56/#53361# # # # 7## Vhh## ᄈOhvvrqv## iru## Prqhwdu|## Srolf|## iurp## Dvvhw## Sulfh## Ioxfwxdwlrqv/ᄡ# fkdswhu## 6/## Zruog## Hfrqrplf## Rxworrn## +Zdvklqjwrq/## GF=## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo# Prqhwdu|#Ixqg/#Rfwrehu#533<,1# # # # 8## Mrkq## Wd|oru/## Jhwwlqj## Rii## Wudfn=## Krz## Jryhuqphqw## Dfwlrqv## dqg# Lqwhuyhqwlrqv## Fdxvhg/## Surorqjhg/## dqg## Zruvhqhg## wkh## Ilqdqfldo## Fulvlv# +Vwdqirug/#FD=#Krryhu#Lqvwlwxwlrq#Suhvv/#533<,1# # # # # # 9## Vhh## Dodq## Eolqghu/## ᄈPrqhwdu|## Srolf|## Wrgd|=## Vl{whhq## Txhvwlrqv## dqg# derxw## Wzhoyh## Dqvzhuv/ᄡ## lq## Fhqwudo## Edqnv## lq## wkh## 54vw## Fhqwxu|/## hg1## V1# Ihuqdqgh}#gh#Olv#dqg#I1#Uhvwr|#+Pdgulg=#Edqfr#gh#Hvsdqd/#5339,/#64ᄆ:5/# # # # # # # # # # # # zklfk#flwhv# # # hylghqfh## lqglfdwlqj#wkdw#wkh# # # # Juhhqvsdq#Ihg# # # zdv## pruh## irfxvhg# rq#rxwsxw#dqg#xqhpsor|phqw#wkdq#lqiodwlrq1#Wkh#Ihg#pd|#eh#pruh#frqvflrxv# # # # # # # # # # # # derxw#xqhpsor|phqw#wkdq/#vd|/#wkh#Hxurshdq#Fhqwudo#Edqn1#Iru#h{dpsoh/#vhh# # # # # # # # # # # Mrvhsk## Oxswrq/## ᄈWkh## Fhqwudo## Edqn## Exfnhw## Olvwᄡ## +MS## Prujdq## Hfrqrplf# Uhvhdufk#Qrwh/#Joredo# # # # Gdwd## Zdwfk/#MS#Prujdq/#Qhz# # # # # \run/#Vhswhpehu# # # 44/# 533<,/## zklfk#vkrzv# # # wkdw#wkh# # # X1V1## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## vwduwhg## udlvlqj#udwhv# # # 53# prqwkv## diwhu## shdn#xqhpsor|phqw# # # lq#wkh# # # 4<<3ᄆ<4## uhfhvvlrq#dqg# # # 45## prqwkv# diwhu## shdn#xqhpsor|phqw#lq#wkh# # # # # 5334## uhfhvvlrq1## E|#frqwudvw/# # # wkh## hxur## duhd# qrw#rqo|#fxw#udwhv#ohvv#exw#dovr#zdv#txlfnhu#wr#udlvh#udwhv/#grlqj#vr#:#prqwkv# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # diwhu## shdn## xqhpsor|phqw## rq## dyhudjh## lq## wkh## 4<<4## uhfhvvlrq## dqg## <## prqwkv# diwhu#shdn#xqhpsor|phqw#lq#wkh#5334#uhfhvvlrq1# # # # # # # :## Vhh## Gdylg## Edfnxv## dqg## Mrqdwkdq## Zuljkw/## ᄈFudfnlqj## wkh## Frqxqguxp/ᄡ# Qhz#\run#Xqlyhuvlw|#Zrunlqj#Sdshu/#Qhz#\run/#533:1# # # # # # # # ;## Vhh## Fodxglr## Erulr## dqg## Kdlelq#]kx/# # # ᄈFdslwdo## Uhjxodwlrq/## Ulvn0Wdnlqj# dqg## Prqhwdu|## Srolf|=## D## Plvvlqj## Olqn## lq## wkh## Wudqvplvvlrq## PhfkdqlvpBᄡ# Edqn## ri## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Vhwwohphqwv## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 59;/## Edvho/## 533<># Udjkxudp## Udmdq/## ᄈKdv## Ilqdqfldo## Ghyhorsphqw## Lqfuhdvhg## Ulvn## WdnlqjBᄡ# Surfhhglqjv## ri## wkh## Mdfnvrq## Kroh## Frqihuhqfh## +Ndqvdv## Flw|/## PR=## Ihghudo# Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv#Flw|/#Dxjxvw#5338,/#646ᄆ9<1# # # # # # # # <#L#wkdqn#Udnhvk#Prkdq/#iruphu#ghsxw|#jryhuqru#dw#wkh#Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri# ## # # # # # # # # # # Lqgld/#iru#srlqwlqj#rxw#wklv#wuhqg#wr#ph1# # # # # # # # 43## S1## Jrxulqfkdv## dqg## K1## Uh|/## ᄈIurp## Zruog## Edqnhu## wr## Zruog## Yhqwxuh# Fdslwdolvw=## XV## H{whuqdo## Dgmxvwphqw## dqg## wkh## H{ruelwdqw## Sulylohjh/ᄡ## QEHU# Zrunlqj#Sdshu#44896/#Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/# # # # # # # # # PD/#53381# # 44#E1#Ehuqdqnh/#P1#Jhuwohu/#dqg#V1#Jlofkulvw/#ᄈWkh#Ilqdqfldo#Dffhohudwru# # # # # # # # # # # dqg## wkh## Ioljkw## wr## Txdolw|/ᄡ## Uhylhz## ri## Hfrqrplfv## dqg## Vwdwlvwlfv## :;/## qr1## 4# +Iheuxdu|#4<<9,=#4ᄆ481# # #
45#Vwxglhv# # # xvlqj#ghwdlohg#edqnlqj#gdwd#qrz# # # # # # vkrz## wkdw#orz# # # lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # fdxvh## ulvnlhu## ohqglqj1## Vhh## J1## Mlphqh}/## V1## Rqjhqjd/## M1## Sh|gur/## dqg## M1# Vdxulqd/## ᄈKd}dugrxv## Wlphv## iru## Prqhwdu|## Srolf|=## Zkdw## Gr## Wzhqw|0Wkuhh# Ploolrq## Edqn## Ordqv## Vd|## derxw## wkh## Hiihfwv## ri## Prqhwdu|## Srolf|## rq## Fuhglw# UlvnBᄡ## FHSU## Glvfxvvlrq## Sdshu## Qr1## 9847/## Fhqwhu## iru## Hfrqrplf## Srolf|# Uhvhdufk/## Orqgrq/## 533:>## Y1## Lrqqdgrx/## V1## Rqjhqjd/## dqg## M1## Sh|gur/# ᄈPrqhwdu|#Srolf|/#Ulvn#Wdnlqj#dqg#Sulflqj=#Hylghqfh#iurp#d#Txdvl0Qdwxudo# # # # # # # # # # H{shulphqw/ᄡ## sdshu## suhvhqwhg## dw## LPI## Dqqxdo## Uhvhdufk## Frqihuhqfh/# Zdvklqjwrq/#GF/#Qryhpehu#533;1# # # # 46#Vhh#Udjkxudp#J1#Udmdq/#ᄈLqyhvwphqw#Uhvwudlqw/#wkh#Oltxlglw|#Joxw/#dqg# # # # # # # # # # # Joredo## Lpedodqfhv/ᄡ## uhpdunv## suhvhqwhg## dw## wkh## Frqihuhqfh## rq## Joredo# Lpedodqfhv/#Edol/#Lqgrqhvld/#Qryhpehu#49/#53391# # # # # # 47#Vhh1#D1#Vkohlihu#dqg#U1#Ylvkq|/#ᄈWkh#Olplwv#ri#Duelwudjh/ᄡ#Mrxuqdo#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # Ilqdqfh## 85/#qr1#4#+4<<:,=# # # # # 68ᄆ88/#iru# # # d## wkhru|#dv# # # wr#zk|#duelwudjhxuv# # # # pd|# ilqg## lw#gliilfxow#wr# # # # eulqj#dvvhw#sulfhv# # # # edfn#lq#olqh# # # # hyhq#zlwkrxw#vkruw0vdohv# # # frqvwudlqwv1# 48## Vhh## Fodxglr## Erulr## dqg## Sklols## Orzh/## ᄈDvvhw## Sulfhv/## Ilqdqfldo## dqg# Prqhwdu|#Vwdelolw|=#H{sorulqj#wkh#Qh{xv/ᄡ#ELV#Zrunlqj#Sdshu#447/#Edqn#iru# # # # # # # # # # # Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Vhwwohphqwv/#Edvho/#Mxo|#53351# # # # # 49## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## Ehuqdqnh/## ᄈDvvhw## Sulfh## Exeeohv## dqg## Prqhwdu|# Srolf|1ᄡ# 4:## Dodq## Juhhqvsdq/## vshhfk## dw## wkh## Dphulfdq## Hqwhusulvh## Lqvwlwxwh/# Ghfhpehu/#8/#4<<91# # # 4;#Dodq#Juhhqvsdq/#Wkh#Djh#ri#Wxuexohqfh=#Dgyhqwxuhv#lq#d#Qhz#Zruog# # # # # # # # # # # # +Qhz#\run=#Shqjxlq#Suhvv/#533:,/#4:9ᄆ:;# # # # # # 4<## Dodq## Juhhqvsdq/## ᄈRshqlqj## Uhpdunv/ᄡ## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Edqn## ri# Ndqvdv#Flw|#v|psrvlxp/#Mdfnvrq#Kroh/#Z\/#Dxjxvw#53351# # # # # # # # 53## Ehq## Ehuqdqnh/## ᄈPrqhwdu|## Srolf|## dqg## wkh## Krxvlqj## Exeeoh/ᄡ## vshhfk# gholyhuhg## dw## wkh## dqqxdo## phhwlqj## ri## wkh## Dphulfdq## Hfrqrplf## Dvvrfldwlrq/# Mdqxdu|#6/#53431# # # 54## Pduhn#Mdurflqvnl# # # dqg## Iudqn#Vphwv/# # # ᄈKrxvh## Sulfhv## dqg## wkh## Vwdqfh## ri# Prqhwdu|## Srolf|/ᄡ## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Edqn## ri## Vw1## Orxlv## Uhylhz## <3/## qr1## 7# +Mxo|ᄆDxjxvw#533;,=#64<ᄆ981# # # 55## Krzhyhu/## vwxglhv## kdyh## lghqwlilhg## d## fohdu## uhodwlrqvkls## ehwzhhq## wkh# ohyho#ri#lqwhuhvw#udwhv#dqg#wkh#ohyho#ri#krxvh#sulfhv#dfurvv#frxqwulhv1# # # # # # # # # # # #
Fkdswhu#Vl{1#Zkhq#Prqh|#Lv#wkh#Phdvxuh#ri#Doo#Zruwk# # # # # # # # # # # 4## Wklv## h{dpsoh## uholhv## rq#Shwhu# # # Kriipdq/## Jloohv## Srvwho0Ylqd|/#dqg# # # Mhdq0 Odxuhqw#Urvhqwkdo/#Vxuylylqj# # # # Odujh## Orvvhv=## Ilqdqfldo## Fulvhv/## wkh## Plggoh# Fodvv/#dqg#wkh#Ghyhorsphqw#ri#Fdslwdo#Pdunhwv#+Fdpeulgjh/#PD=#Ehonqds# # # # # # # # # # Suhvv/#533:,/#47<ᄆ841# # #
5## Dgdp## Vplwk/## Dq## Lqtxlu|## lqwr## wkh## Fdxvhv## ri## wkh## Zhdowk## ri## Qdwlrqv# +Fklfdjr=#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjr#Suhvv/#4<:9,/#4;1# # # # # # # 6## Gdq## Dulho|/## Hplu## Ndphqlfd/## dqg## Gud¥hq## Suhohf/## ᄈPdqᄊv## Vhdufk## iru# Phdqlqj=## Wkh## Fdvh## ri## Ohjrv/ᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri## Hfrqrplf## Ehkdylru## dqg# Rujdql}dwlrq#9:/#qr1#6#+Vhswhpehu#533;,=#9:4ᄆ::1# # # # # # # 7#Vhh#Mdphv#Fkdqrv/#ᄈSuhsduhg#Vwdwhphqw=#X1V1#Vhfxulwlhv#dqg#H{fkdqjh# # # # # # # # # # Frpplvvlrq## Urxqgwdeoh## rq## Khgjh## Ixqgv/ᄡ## X1V1## Vhfxulwlhv## dqg## H{fkdqjh# Frpplvvlrq/## zzz1vhf1jry2vsrwoljkw2khgjhixqgv2khgjh0fkdqrv1kwp/# dffhvvhg#Pdufk#43/#53431# # # # 8## Mloo## Ulhshqkrii## dqg## Grxj## Kdggr{/## ᄈUlvn|## Uhilqdqflqjv## Ghhshq# Ilqdqfldo#Kroh/ᄡ#Froxpexv#Glvsdwfk/#Mxqh#5/#533;1# # # # # # # 9## Vhh## Doohq#Iudqnho/# # # ᄈWkh## Ulvn#ri# # # Uho|lqj#rq#Uhsxwdwlrqdo# # # # Fdslwdo=## D# Fdvh## Vwxg|#ri# # # wkh## 533:## Idloxuh## ri## Qhz## Fhqwxu|#Ilqdqfldo/ᄡ# # # ELV## Zrunlqj# Sdshu#5<7/#Edqn#iru#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Vhwwohphqwv/#Edvho/#533<1# # # # # # # # :## Mdphv## U1## Kdjhuw|/## Uxwk## Vlprq/## Plfkdho## Frunhu|/## dqg## Juhjru|# ]xfnhupdq/## ᄈKrph## Vwuhwfk=## Dw## d## Pruwjdjh## Ohqghu/## Udslg## Ulvh/## Idvwhu# Idoo/ᄡ#Zdoo#Vwuhhw#Mrxuqdo/#Pdufk#45/#533:1# # # # # # # ;#Ulhshqkrii#dqg#Kdggr{/#ᄈUlvn|#Uhilqdqflqjv1ᄡ# # # # # # <## Iru## dujxphqwv## dqg## hylghqfh## dorqj#wkhvh# # # olqhv/## vhh## X1## Udmdq/## D1## Vhux/# dqg## Y1## Ylj/## ᄈWkh## Idloxuh## ri## Prghov## Wkdw## Suhglfw## Idloxuh=## Glvwdqfh/# Lqfhqwlyhv#dqg#Ghidxowv/ᄡ#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjr#zrunlqj#sdshu/#533<1# # # # # # # # # 43## Hyhq## wkh## fuhglw## vfruh## ri## d## eruurzhu## frxog## eh## ᄈpdqdjhg/ᄡ## zlwk# duudqjhphqwv#vrphwlphv#ehlqj#pdgh#iru#d#eruurzhu#wr#sljj|edfn/#iru#d#ihh/# # # # # # # # # # # # rq#wkh#ordq#ri#d#vwudqjhu#zlwk#kljkhu#fuhglw#txdolw|1#Vhh#Iudqnho/#ᄈWkh#Ulvn# # # # # # # # # # # # # # ri#Uho|lqj#rq#Uhsxwdwlrqdo#Fdslwdoᄡ>#Gdylg#Vwuhlwilhog/#ᄈLq#Dssudlvdo#Vkliw/# # # # # # # # # # Ohqghuv#Jdlq#Srzhu#dqg#Fulwlfv/ᄡ#Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Dxjxvw#4</#533<1# # # # # # # # # # # 44#Ulhshqkrii#dqg#Kdggr{/#ᄈUlvn|#Uhilqdqflqjv1ᄡ# # # # # # 45#Eudgoh|#Nhrxq#dqg#Vwhyhq#Fkxufk/#ᄈQhz# # # # # # # # Fhqwxu|/#Eljjhvw#Vxesulph# # # Fdvxdow|/## Jrhv## Edqnuxsw/ᄡEorrpehuj1frp/# zzz1eorrpehuj1frp2dssv2qhzvBslg@539343;:)# uhihu@krph)vlg@d[KGVeRfDFkf/#dffhvvhg#Pdufk#43/#53431# # # # # 46#Vhh#Dwli#Pldq#dqg#Dplu#Vxil/#ᄈWkh#Frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#Pruwjdjh#Fuhglw# # # # # # # # # # # # H{sdqvlrq=## Hylghqfh## iurp## wkh## X1V1## Pruwjdjh## Ghidxow## Fulvlv/ᄡ## Txduwhuo|# Mrxuqdo#ri#Hfrqrplfv#457/#qr1#7#+Qryhpehu#533<,=#477<ᄆ<91# # # # # # # # # 47## Iru## d## prgho## ri## krz## yroxph## fdq## vzdps## lqfhqwlyhv/## vhh## Dqguhl# Vkohlihu## dqg## Urehuw## Ylvkq|/## ᄈXqvwdeoh## Edqnlqj/ᄡ## QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu# 47<76/#Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # # # # # # # # 48#Vhh#Iudqnho/#ᄈWkh#Ulvn#ri#Uho|lqj#rq#Uhsxwdwlrqdo#Fdslwdo1ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # 49## Shwhu## Zdoolvrq/## ᄈEduqh|## Iudqn=## Suhgdwru|## Ohqghu/ᄡ## Zdoo## Vwuhhw# Mrxuqdo/#Rfwrehu#49/#533<1# # # #
Fkdswhu#Vhyhq1#Ehwwlqj#wkh#Edqn# # # # #
# 4## Wklv## h{dpsoh## eruurzv## iurp## Mrvkxd## Frydo/## Mdnxe## Mxuhn/## dqg## Huln# Vwdiirug/#ᄈWkh#Hfrqrplfv#ri#Vwuxfwxuhg#Ilqdqfh/ᄡ#Kduydug#Exvlqhvv#Vfkrro# # # # # # # # # Zrunlqj#Sdshu#3<ᄆ393/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533;1# # # # # # 5#Wlp#Ud|phqw/#ᄈWkh#Pdq#zlwk#wkh#Wuloolrq#Groodu#Sulfh#rq#Klv#Khdg/ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # # # Vxqgd|#Wlphv/#Pd|#4:/#533<1# # # # # 6#Lelg1# # 7## Vkduhkroghu## Uhsruw## rq## XEVᄊv## Zulwhgrzqv/## XEV/## ]xulfk/## Dsulo## 4;/# 533;1# 8#Vhh#wkh#froruixo#dffrxqw#lq#Odzuhqfh#PfGrqdog#dqg#Sdwulfn#Urelqvrq/# # # # # # # # # # # D#Frorvvdo#Idloxuh#ri#Frpprq#Vhqvh#+Qhz#\run=#Furzq#Exvlqhvv/#533<,1# # # # # # # # # # # 9## Hulf## Gdvk## dqg## Mxolh## Fuhvzhoo/## ᄈWkh## Uxvk## wr## Ulfkhv## wkdw## Xqglg# Flwljurxs=#Edqnlqj#Jldqwᄊv#Pdqdjhphqw#Idlohg#wr#Prqlwru#wkh#Ulvnv#Wlhg#wr# # # # # # # # # # # Lwv#Ghdov/ᄡ#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Khudog#Wulexqh/#Qryhpehu#57/#533;1# # # # # # # # :## Dqguhz## Hooxo## dqg## Ylmd|## \huudplool/## ᄈVwurqjhu## Ulvn## Frqwurov/## Orzhu# Ulvn=## Hylghqfh## iurp## X1V1## Edqn## Kroglqj## Frpsdqlhv/ᄡ## Lqgldqd## Xqlyhuvlw|# zrunlqj#sdshu/# # # Eorrplqjwrq/## 53431## Dydlodeoh## dw## Vrfldo## Vflhqfh## Uhvhdufk# Qhwzrun/#kwws=22vvuq1frp2devwudfw@48836941# # ;## Uxgljhu## Idkohqeudfk## dqg## Uhqh## Vwxo}/## ᄈEdqn## FHR## Lqfhqwlyhv## dqg## wkh# Fuhglw#Fulvlv/ᄡ#QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu#48545/#Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#Mxo|#533<1# # # # # <#PfGrqdog#dqg#Urelqvrq/#Frorvvdo#Idloxuh1# # # # # # 43## Fdoylq## Wuloolq/## ᄈZdoo## Vwuhhw## Vpduwv/ᄡ## Qhz## \run## Wlphv/## Rfwrehu## 47/# 533<1# 44#Lelg1# # 45## Wkrpdv## Sklolssrq#dqg# # # Dulhoo## Uhvkhi/## ᄈZdjhv## dqg## Kxpdq#Fdslwdo# # # lq# wkh## X1V1## Ilqdqfldo## Lqgxvwu|=## 4<3<ᄆ5339/ᄡ## QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 47977/# Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # # # # # # # 46## Vhh## U1## Udmdq/## ᄈZk|## Edqn## Fuhglw## Srolflhv## Ioxfwxdwh=## D#Wkhru|# # # dqg# Vrph#Hylghqfh/ᄡ#Txduwhuo|#Mrxuqdo#ri#Hfrqrplfv#43</#qr1#5#+Pd|#4<<7,=# # # # # # # # # # # 6<<ᄆ7741# 47#Dqguhz#Urvv#Vrunlq/#Wrr#Elj#wr#Idlo#+Qhz#\run=#Ylnlqj/#533<,/#4781# # # # # # # # # # # # # 48## Plfkl|r## Qdndprwr## dqg## Gdylg## Zljkwrq/## ᄈFlwljurxs## Fklhi## Vwd|v# Exoolvk#rq#Ex|rxwv/ᄡ#Ilqdqfldo#Wlphv/#Mxo|#</#533:1# # # # # # # # 49#Jlooldq#Whww/#Irroᄊv#Jrog#+Qhz#\run=#Iuhh#Suhvv/#533<,/#477ᄆ781# # # # # # # # # # # 4:#Lelg1/#445ᄆ461# # # 4;## L1## Fkhqj/## K1## Krqj/## dqg## M1## Vfkhlqnpdq/## ᄈ\hvwhugd|ᄊv## Khurhv=# Frpshqvdwlrq## dqg## Fuhdwlyh## Ulvn## Wdnlqj/ᄡ## zrunlqj## sdshu/## Sulqfhwrq# Xqlyhuvlw|/#533<1# # 4<#Vwhyh#Ilvkpdq/#ᄈExuqlqj#Grzq#Klv#Krxvh=#Lv#Ohkpdq#FHR#Glfn#Ixog# # # # # # # # # # # #
wkh## Wuxh## Yloodlq## lq## wkh## Zdoo## Vwuhhw## FroodsvhBᄡ## Qhz## \run## pdjd}lqh/# Qryhpehu## 63/## 533;/# q|pdj1frp2qhzv2exvlqhvv2859362lqgh{61kwpo&l{}}3[IF[H|k]1# 53#Vrunlq/#Wrr#Elj#wr#Idlo/#5:61# # # # # # # 54## Dqguhd## Ehowudwwl## dqg## Uhqh## Vwxo}/## ᄈZk|## Glg## Vrph## Edqnv## Shuirup# Ehwwhu## gxulqj## wkh## Fuhglw## FulvlvB## D## Furvv0Frxqwu|## Vwxg|## ri## wkh## Lpsdfw## ri# Jryhuqdqfh## dqg## Uhjxodwlrq/ᄡ## QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 484;3/## Qdwlrqdo# Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#Mxo|#533<1# # # # # # # # 55## Vhh## hglwruldo/## ᄈᄉQr## Olqh## Uhvsrqvlelolwlhvᄊ=## Zkdw## Urehuw## Uxelq#Glg# # iru## Klv## '448## Ploolrq/ᄡ## Zdoo## Vwuhhw## Mrxuqdo/## Ghfhpehu## 6/## 533;/# kwws=22rqolqh1zvm1frp2duwlfoh2VE455;599#653;44:77:61kwpo1# # 56#Vhh#Yludo#Y # # # 1#Dfkdu|d/#Wkrpdv#Frroh|/#Pdwwkhz#Ulfkdugvrq/#dqg#Lqjr# # # # # # # # Zdowhu/#ᄈPdqxidfwxulqj#Wdlo# # # # Ulvn=## D#Shuvshfwlyh#rq#wkh#Ilqdqfldo# # # # # # Fulvlv#ri# # 533:ᄆ3</ᄡ#zrunlqj#sdshu/#Qhz# # # # # \run#Xqlyhuvlw|#Vwhuq#Vfkrro# # # # # ri#Exvlqhvv/# # 533<1# 57## Fdurolqh## Edxp/## ᄈIhg## Vkrxog## Uhdg## Lwv## Rzq## Phpr## rq## Ulvlqj0Udwh# Ulvn/ᄡ## Eorrpehuj1frp/## Mdqxdu|## 4</## 5343/# zzz1eorrpehuj1frp2dssv2qhzvBslg@5393436<)vlg@d|jrbTp<v]<L1# 58## Vhh## Wrp## Eudlwkzdlwh/## ᄈEdqnv## Idfh## Sureh## ryhu## Wudglqj## lq## Wdus# Iuhq}|/ᄡ#Ilqdqfldo#Wlphv/#Iheuxdu|#4/#53431# # # # # # 59#Lelg1# # 5:#Khqu|#Sdxovrq/#Rq#wkh#Eulqn=#Lqvlgh#wkh#Udfh#wr#Vwrs#wkh#Froodsvh#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#Joredo#Ilqdqfldo#V|vwhp#+Qhz#\run=#Exvlqhvv#Soxv/#533<,/#5<61# # # # # # # # # # 5;## G1## Gldprqg## dqg## U1## Udmdq/## ᄈIhdu## ri## Iluhvdohv## dqg## Fuhglw## Iuhh}hv/ᄡ# QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 47<58/## Qdwlrqdo## Exuhdx## ri## Hfrqrplf## Uhvhdufk/# Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # #
Fkdswhu#Hljkw1#Uhiruplqj#Ilqdqfh# # # # # 4## Pdww## Wdleel/## ᄈLqvlgh## wkh## Juhdw## Dphulfdq## Exeeoh## Pdfklqh/ᄡ## Uroolqj# Vwrqh/#Mxo|#5/#533<1# # # # 5#Vhh#wkh#glvfxvvlrq#lq#Grqqfkd#Pduurq/#Frqvxphu#Fuhglw#lq#wkh#Xqlwhg# # # # # # # # # # # # Vwdwhv=## D#Vrflrorjlfdo# # # Shuvshfwlyh## iurp#wkh# # # 4<wk## Fhqwxu|## wr## wkh## Suhvhqw# +Qhz#\run=#Sdojudyh#Pdfploodq/#533<,/#6ᄆ81# # # # # # 6## Ehqmdplq## Iudqnolq/## Wkh## Zd|## wr## Zhdowk/## Zhdowk## Uhdghu/# zhdowkuhdghu1frp2errn2wkhbzd|bwrbzhdowk24/## dffhvvhg## Pdufk## 43/## 5343# +lwdolfv#lq#ruljlqdo,1# # # 7## Vhh## Urehuw## Kljjv/## Fulvlv## dqg## Ohyldwkdq=## Fulwlfdo## Hslvrghv## lq## wkh# Jurzwk#ri#Dphulfdq#Jryhuqphqw#+R{irug=#R{irug#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#4<;:,/# # # # # # # # # 4:<1# 8## Iru## dq## h{fhoohqw## sdshu## rq## wdlo## ulvn/## vhh## Yludo## Y1## Dfkdu|d/## Wkrpdv#
Frroh|/#Pdwwkhz#Ulfkdugvrq/#dqg#Lqjr#Zdowhu/#ᄈPdqxidfwxulqj#Wdlo#Ulvn=#D# # # # # # # # # # Shuvshfwlyh#rq#wkh#Ilqdqfldo#Fulvlv#ri#533:ᄆ3</ᄡ#zrunlqj#sdshu/#Qhz#\run# # # # # # # # # # # Xqlyhuvlw|#Vwhuq#Vfkrro#ri#Exvlqhvv/#533<1# # # # # # 9#Udjkxudp#Udmdq/#ᄈEdqnhuvᄊ#Sd|#Lv#Ghhso|#Iodzhg/ᄡ#Ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # # Wlphv/# Mdqxdu|#</#533;1# # # :## Ghqqlv## Ehupdq/## ᄈZkhuh## Zdv## Ohkpdqᄊv## ErdugBᄡ## Zdoo## Vwuhhw## Mrxuqdo/# Vhswhpehu#48/#533;/#eorjv1zvm1frp2ghdov2533;23<2482zkhuh0zdv0ohkpdqv0 # # # erdug21# ;## Wkh## lghdv## rq#glvforvxuh# # # duh## edvhg## rq#d# # # zrunlqj#sdshu# # # e|#wkh# # # Vtxdp# Odnh## Zrunlqj## Jurxs## rq## Ilqdqfldo## Uhjxodwlrq/## ᄈD## Qhz## Lqirupdwlrq# Vwuxfwxuh## iru## Ilqdqfldo## Pdunhwv/ᄡ## Frxqflo## rq## Iruhljq## Uhodwlrqv/# zzz1fiu1ruj2sxeolfdwlrq24;89;2qhzblqirupdwlrq# blqiudvwuxfwxuhbirubilqdqfldobpdunhwv1kwpo/#Iheuxdu|#533<1# # # <#Vhh#Dqguhz# # # # Urvv#Vrunlq/#Wrr#Elj#wr#Idlo# # # # # # # +Qhz## \run=## Ylnlqj/#533<,/# # 6371# 43#Vhh#G1#Gldprqg#dqg#U1#Udmdq/#ᄈLooltxlglw|#dqg#Lqwhuhvw#Udwh#Srolf|/ᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # # QEHU## Zrunlqj## Sdshu## 484<:/## Qdwlrqdo## Exuhdx## ri## Hfrqrplf## Uhvhdufk/# Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # # 44#Wklv#lv#d#sursrvdo#pdgh#e|#wkh#Vtxdp#Odnh#Jurxs#lq#lwv#iruwkfrplqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # uhsruw/#wr#eh#sxeolvkhg#e|#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv1# # # # # # # # 45#Edqnv# # # vkrxog#ehqhilw#e|#frpplwwlqj#wr#wkhlu# # # # # # # folhqwv## wkdw#wkh|#zloo# # # # qrw# wudgh## xvlqj## wkhlu## lqirupdwlrq## ru## djdlqvw## wkhlu## lqwhuhvwv1## Vrph## erxwltxh# lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#xvh#wkh#idfw#wkh|#kdyh#qr#frqiolfwv#ri#lqwhuhvw#dv#d#vhoolqj# # # # # # # # # # # # # # srlqw1## Shukdsv## wklv## wuhqg## zloo## fdwfk## rq/## lq## zklfk## fdvh## uhjxodwlrq## zloo## eh# xqqhfhvvdu|1# 46## Iru## d## ghwdlohg## h{sodqdwlrq#ri# # # zk|#htxlw|#fdslwdo# # # # lv## frvwo|#lq#edqnv/# # # wkrvh#idploldu#zlwk#wkh#Prgljoldql0Ploohu#wkhruhp#fdq#frqvxow#G1#Gldprqg# # # # # # # # # # dqg## U1## Udmdq/## ᄈD#Wkhru|#ri#Edqn#Fdslwdo/ᄡ# # # # # # Mrxuqdo## ri## Ilqdqfh## 88/## qr1## 9# +Ghfhpehu#5333,=#5764ᄆ981# # #
47#Vhh#wkh#sursrvdo#ᄈDq#H{shglwhg#Uhvroxwlrq#Phfkdqlvp#iru#Glvwuhvvhg# # # # # # # # # # Ilqdqfldo## Ilupv=## Uhjxodwru|## K|eulg## Vhfxulwlhv/ᄡ## Frxqflo## rq## Iruhljq# Uhodwlrqv/## zzz1fiu1ruj2# sxeolfdwlrq24<3352h{shglwhgbuhvroxwlrqbphfkdqlvpbirubglvwuhvvhgbilqdqfld#obilupv1kwp Dsulo#533<1# # 48## Vhh## D1## Ndvk|ds/## U1## Udmdq/## dqg## M1## Vwhlq/## ᄈUhwklqnlqj## Fdslwdo# Uhjxodwlrq/ᄡ## sdshu## suhsduhg## iru## wkh## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv# # # # Flw|# v|psrvlxp#ᄈPdlqwdlqlqj#Vwdelolw|#lq#d#Fkdqjlqj#Ilqdqfldo#V|vwhp/ᄡ#Mdfnvrq# # # # # # # # # Kroh/#Z\/#Dxjxvw#54ᄆ56/#533;1# # # # # 49## Vhh## Ddurq## Zlogdyvn|/## Vhdufklqj## iru## Vdihw|## +Qhz## Euxqvzlfn/## QM=# Wudqvdfwlrq#Errnv/#4<;;,1# # # 4:#Vhh#Wkrpdv#Krhqlj/#suhvlghqw#ri#wkh#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv# # # # # # # # # # # # Flw|/#ᄈShuvshfwlyhv#rq#wkh#Uhfhqw#Ilqdqfldo#Pdunhw#Wxuprlo/ᄡ#vshhfk#dw#wkh# # # # # # # # # # # 533;#Lqvwlwxwh#ri#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Ilqdqfh#Phpehuvkls#Phhwlqj/#Ulr#gh#Mdqhlur/# # # # # # # # # #
Eud}lo/#Pdufk#8/#533;1# # # # 4;## Vhh/## iru## h{dpsoh/## wkh## sursrvhg## Krxvh## Ilqdqfldo## Uhjxodwru|#Uhirup# # Eloo#ri#533<1# # # 4<#Vhh#Vrunlq/#Wrr#Elj#wr#Idlo/#7<31# # # # # # # # 53#Sulph#Uhvhuyhv/#d#prqh|0pdunhw#ixqg/#vxiihuhg#orvvhv#rq#lwv#Ohkpdq# # # # # # # # # # # ghew#kroglqjv# # # diwhu## wkh## Ohkpdq#froodsvh1# # # Ehfdxvh## lw#sdlg# # # rxw#'4# # # iru## hyhu|# groodu## lqyhvwhg## lqvwhdg## ri## wkh## '31<:## ru## vr## wkdw## wkh## lqyhvwphqwv## zhuh## qrz# zruwk/#lqyhvwruv#uxvkhg#wr#wkh#h{lw#wr#dyrlg#ehlqj#irufhg#wr#ehdu#wkh#orvvhv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # # Li#wkh# # # ixqg## kdg## pdunhg## lwv## dvvhwv## wr## pdunhw#dqg# # # sdlg## rxw#rqo|#'31<:/# # # # wkhuh# zrxog#kdyh#ehhq#ohvv#ri#d#sdqlf1#Djdlq/#lq#d#fulvlv/#shukdsv#qr#dvvhw#lv#vdih# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # zlwkrxw## d## jryhuqphqw## jxdudqwhh/## lqfoxglqj## prqh|0pdunhw## ixqgv## wkdw## duh# lqyhvwhg#lq#dq|wklqj#rwkhu#wkdq#Wuhdvxu|#eloov1# # # # # # # 54#L#wkdqn#Yludo#Dfkdu|d#iru#vxjjhvwlqj#wklv#whup1# ## # # # # # # 55## Orxlv## G1## Eudqghlv## wr## Urehuw## Z1## Euxhuh/## Froxpeld## Odz## Uhylhz## 64# +4<55,=#:1# # 56#Orxlv#G1#Eudqghlv/#Rwkhu#Shrsohᄊv#Prqh|=#Dqg#Krz#wkh#Edqnhuv#Xvh# # # # # # # # # # # # Lw#+Zdvklqjwrq/#GF=#Qdwlrqdo#Krph#Oleudu|#Irxqgdwlrq/#4<66,/#951# # # # # # # # #
Fkdswhu#Qlqh1#Lpsurylqj#Dffhvv#wr#Rssruwxqlw|#lq#Dphulfd# # # # # # # # # 4#Doehuwr#Dohvlqd#dqg#Jhrujh0Pdulrv#Dqjhohwrv/#ᄈFruuxswlrq/#Lqhtxdolw|# # # # # # # # dqg## Idluqhvv/ᄡ## zrunlqj## sdshu/## Kduydug## Lqvwlwxwh## ri## Hfrqrplf## Uhvhdufk/# Kduydug#Xqlyhuvlw|/#53381# # # 5## Vhh## U1## Udmdq/## ᄈUhqw## Suhvhuydwlrq## dqg## wkh## Shuvlvwhqfh## ri# Xqghughyhorsphqw/ᄡ#Dphulfdq#Hfrqrplf#Mrxuqdo=#Pdfurhfrqrplfv#4/#qr1# # # # # # # 4#+Mdqxdu|#533<,=#4:;ᄆ54;1# # # # 6## Wklv## vhfwlrq#uholhv# # # h{whqvlyho|#rq#U1# # # # Kdvnlq#dqg# # # L1## Vdzkloo/## Fuhdwlqj# dq## Rssruwxqlw|## Vrflhw|## +Zdvklqjwrq/## GF=## Eurrnlqjv## Lqvwlwxwlrq## Suhvv/# 533<,/#dqg#M1#Khfnpdq#dqg#D1#Nuxhjhu/#Lqhtxdolw|#lq#Dphulfd#+Fdpeulgjh/# # # # # # # # # # # PD=#PLW#Suhvv/#5338,1# # # # 7## Gdylg## Edunhu/## ᄈLq#Xwhur# # # Surjudpplqj#ri# # # Fkurqlf## Glvhdvh/ᄡ## Folqlfdo# Vflhqfh## <8/## qr1## 5## +4<<;,=## 448ᄆ5;>## Gdylg## Edunhu/## ᄈPdwhuqdo## dqg## Ihwdo# Ruljlqv## ri## Frurqdu|## Khduw## Glvhdvh/ᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri## Ur|do## Froohjh## ri# Sk|vlfldqv#5;/#qr1#9#+4<<7,=#877ᄆ84>#Gdylg#Edunhu/#ᄈWkh#Ihwdo#Ruljlqv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # # Dgxow## K|shuwhqvlrq/ᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri## K|shuwhqvlrq## Vxssohphqw## 43/## qr1## :# +4<<5,=#V6<ᄆ771# # 8#Mdphv# # # Khfnpdq/#ᄈOhvvrqv# # # iurp#wkh# # # Ehoo## Fxuyh/ᄡ#Mrxuqdo# # # ri## Srolwlfdo# Hfrqrp|#436/#qr1#8#+4<<8,=#43<4ᄆ4531# # # # # # 9#Kdvnlqv#dqg#Vdzkloo/#Fuhdwlqj#dq#Rssruwxqlw|#Vrflhw|/#4671# # # # # # # # # :## Vhh## Vdqwldjr## Ohy|/## Surjuhvv## djdlqvw## Sryhuw|=## Vxvwdlqlqj## Ph{lfrᄊv# Surjuhvd0Rsruwxqlgdghv## Surjudp## +Zdvklqjwrq/## GF=## Eurrnlqjv## Lqvwlwxwlrq#
Suhvv/#5339,1# # ;## Mdphv## V1## Frohpdq/## Hgxfdwlrqdo## Htxdolw|## ri## Rssruwxqlw|/## X1V1# Ghsduwphqw#ri#Khdowk/#Hgxfdwlrq/#dqg#Zhoiduh/#4<991# # # # # # # <## Mdphv## Khfnpdq/## ᄈVfkrrov/## Vnloov/## dqg## V|qdsvhv/ᄡ## QEHU## Zrunlqj# Sdshu## 47397/## Qdwlrqdo## Exuhdx## ri## Hfrqrplf## Uhvhdufk/## Fdpeulgjh/## PD/# 533;1# 43#Khfnpdq#dqg#Nuxhjhu/#Lqhtxdolw|#lq#Dphulfd/#<8>#V1# # # # # # # # # # Erzohv## dqg## K1# Jlqwlv/#Vfkrrolqj#lq#Fdslwdolvw#Dphulfd#+Qhz#\run=#Edvlf#Errnv/#4<:9,1# # # # # # # # # # 44## M1## Frohpdq## dqg## W1## Kriihu/## Sxeolf## dqg## Sulydwh## Kljk## Vfkrrov## +Qhz# \run=#Edvlf#Errnv/#4<;6,1# # # # 45#Vhh#Kdvnlq#dqg#Vdzkloo/#Fuhdwlqj#dq#Rssruwxqlw|#Vrflhw|/#477ᄆ781# # # # # # # # # # 46#Edudfn#Redpd/#vshhfk#dw#Ghprfudwlf#Qdwlrqdo#Frqyhqwlrq/#txrwhg#lq# # # # # # # # # # Zdvklqjwrq## Srvw/## Mxo|## 5:/## 5337/## zzz1zdvklqjwrqsrvw1frp2zs0 g|q2duwlfohv2D4<:8405337#Mxo5:1kwpo1# # 47## Dqwkrq|## Eu|n/## Shqq|## Ehqghu## Vheulqj/## Hodlqh## Doohqvzruwk/## Vwxduw# Oxsshvfx/#dqg#Mrkq#Hdvwrq/#Rujdql}lqj#Vfkrrov#iru#Lpsuryhphqw=#Ohvvrqv# # # # # # # # # iurp#Fklfdjr#+Fklfdjr=#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjr#Suhvv/#533<,1# # # # # # # # 48#Grulv#Hqwzlvoh/#Nduo#Doh{dqghu/#dqg#Olqgd#Rovhq/#Fkloguhq/#Vfkrrov/# # # # # # # # # # dqg#Lqhtxdolw|#+Erxoghu/#FR=#Zhvwylhz/#4<<:,1# # # # # # 49#Dodq#Nuxhjhu/#ᄈLqhtxdolw|=# # # # # Wrr#Pxfk#ri#d#Jrrg#Wklqj/ᄡ#lq#Khfnpdq# # # # # # # # dqg#Nuxhjhu/#Lqhtxdolw|#lq#Dphulfd1# # # # # 4:## Pxfk## ri## zkdw## iroorzv## lv## edvhg## rq## wkh## uhsruw## ri## wkh## Whdfklqj# Frpplvvlrq/## d## sulydwh## qrqsduwlvdq#jurxs# # # fkdluhg## e|#Orx#Jhuvwqhu/# # # # iruphu# FHR#ri#LEP1#Wkhlu#5337#uhsruw#ᄈWhdfklqj#dw#Ulvn=#D#Fdoo#wr#Dfwlrqᄡ#fdq#eh# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # irxqg#dw#zzz1fvo1xvi1hgx2whdfklqj(53dw(53ulvn1sgi1# # # 4;## Vhh## Dwlod## Degxondglurjox/## Mrvkxd## Dqjulvw/## Vxvdq## G|qduvnl/## Wkrpdv# Ndqh/#dqg#Sdudj#Sdwkdn/#ᄈDffrxqwdelolw|#dqg#Ioh{lelolw|#lq#Sxeolf#Vfkrrov=# # # # # # # # # # Hylghqfh#iurp#Ervwrqᄊv#Fkduwhuv#dqg#Slorwv/ᄡ#QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu#4887</# # # # # # # # # # Qdwlrqdo#Exuhdx#ri#Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # # # # # # # 4<## Vhh## Vdp## Gloorq## ᄈRedpd## wr## Vhhn## Vzhhslqj## Fkdqjh## lq## ᄉQr## Fklogᄊ# Odz/ᄡ#Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Iheuxdu|#4/#53431# # # # # # # 53#Vhh#Kdvnlq#dqg#Vdzkloo/#Fuhdwlqj#dq#Rssruwxqlw|#Vrflhw|/#47<1# # # # # # # # # # 54#Lelg1/#4861# # # 55#Lelg1/#48;1# # # 56#Wklv#sdudjudsk#lv#edvhg#rq#Gdylg#Ghplqj#dqg#Vxvdq#G|qduvnl/#ᄈLqwr# # # # # # # # # # # # Froohjh## dqg## Rxw## ri## Sryhuw|B## Srolflhv## wr## Lqfuhdvh## wkh## Srvw0Vhfrqgdu|# Dwwdlqphqw#ri#wkh# # # # Srru/ᄡ## QEHU#Zrunlqj#Sdshu# # # # 486;:/#Qdwlrqdo# # # Exuhdx#ri# # Hfrqrplf#Uhvhdufk/#Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533<1# # # # # 57## Vxvdq## G|qduvnl/## Wkh## Hfrqrplfv## ri## Vwxghqw## Dlg/## QEHU## Uhsruwhu# Uhvhdufk## Vxppdu|## 533:/## qr1## 4/## Qdwlrqdo## Exuhdx## ri## Hfrqrplf## Uhvhdufk/# Fdpeulgjh/#PD/#533:1# # #
58#RHFG/#Khdowk#Gdwd#533;=#Vwdwlvwlfv#dqg#Lqglfdwruv#iru#63#Frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # # # # +Sdulv=#Rujdql}dwlrq#iru#Hfrqrplf#Fr0rshudwlrq#dqg#Ghyhorsphqw/#533;,1# # # # # # # # 59## Wkh## shhu## jurxs## frqvlvwhg## ri## Fdqdgd/## Iudqfh/## Jhupdq|/## Mdsdq/# Vzlw}huodqg/## dqg## wkh## Xqlwhg## Nlqjgrp1## Vhh## Dodq## Jduehu## dqg## Mrqdwkdq# Vnlqqhu/## ᄈLv## Dphulfdq## Khdowkfduh## Xqltxho|## LqhiilflhqwBᄡ## Mrxuqdo## ri# Hfrqrplf#Shuvshfwlyhv#55/#qr1#7#+Idoo#533;,=#5:ᄆ831# # # # # # # # 5:#Wklv#dqg#wkh#qh{w#sdudjudsk#uho|#rq#Jduehu#dqg#Vnlqqhu/#ᄈLv#Dphulfdq# # # # # # # # # # # # # Khdowkfduh#Xqltxho|#LqhiilflhqwBᄡ# # # 5;## Fkulv## Shwhuvrq## dqg## Udfkho## Exuwrq/## XV## Khdowkfduh## Vshqglqj=# Frpsdulvrq#zlwk#Rwkhu#RHFG#Frxqwulhv#+Zdvklqjwrq/#GF=#Frqjuhvvlrqdo# # # # # # # # Uhvhdufk#Vhuylfh/#533:,1# # # 5<## Dqguhz## Sroodfn/## ᄈKrvslwdov## Orrn#wr# # # Qxfohdu## Wrro## wr## Iljkw#Fdqfhu/ᄡ# # Qhz#\run#Wlphv/#Ghfhpehu#59/#533:1# # # # # # 63## Vhh## Jduehu## dqg## Vnlqqhu/## ᄈLv## Dphulfdq## Khdowkfduh## Xqltxho|# LqhiilflhqwBᄡ# 64## Ndwkhulqh## Edlfnhu/## Hoolrww## V1## Ilvkhu/## dqg## Dplwdek## Fkdqgud/# ᄈPdosudfwlfh#Oldelolw|#Frvwv#dqg#wkh#Sudfwlfh#ri#Phglflqh#lq#wkh#Phglfduh# # # # # # # # # # # Surjudp/ᄡ#Khdowk#Diidluv#59/#qr1#6#+Pd|ᄆMxqh#533:,=#;74ᄆ851# # # # # # # # # 65#Iru#wkh#kljko|#sdlg#zrunhuv#lq#wkh#ilqdqfldo#vhfwru/#L#dujxh#wkdw#kdylqj# # # # # # # # # # ## # # d## vwdnh## lq## wkh## ilup## fdq## lpsuryh## lqfhqwlyhv1## Krzhyhu/## vrph## uhdvrqdeoh# sruwlrq#ri#wkhlu#vdylqjv#vkrxog#eh#lqghshqghqw#ri#wkh#khdowk#ri#wkhlu#ilupv1# # # # # # # # # # # # # 66## Vhh/## iru## lqvwdqfh/## Urehuw## Vkloohu/## Wkh## Qhz## Ilqdqfldo## Rughu# +Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Sulqfhwrq#Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#5336,/#44;ᄆ4<1# # # # # # # 67## Wkh## qh{w## ihz## sdudjudskv## gudz## rq## p|## suhylrxv## errn## zlwk## Oxljl# ]lqjdohv/#Vdylqj#Fdslwdolvp#iurp#wkh#Fdslwdolvwv#+Sulqfhwrq/#QM=#Sulqfhwrq# # # # # # # # # Xqlyhuvlw|#Suhvv/#5337,1# # # 68## Vkorpr## Ehqduw}l## dqg## Ulfkdug## Wkdohu/## ᄈVdyh## Pruh## Wrpruurz=## Xvlqj# Ehkdylrudo## Hfrqrplfv## wr## Lqfuhdvh## Hpsor|hh## Vdylqjv/ᄡ## xqsxeolvkhg# pdqxvfulsw/#Xqlyhuvlw|#ri#Fklfdjr1# # # #
Fkdswhu#Whq1#Wkh#Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv#Uhsod|hg# # # # # # # # # 4#Ehuqdug#Pdqghylooh/#Wkh#Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv#+4:47,#+R{irug=#Foduhqgrq# # # # # # # # # # # Suhvv/#4<8:,1# # 5#Lelg1# # 6## \dvkzdqw## Vlqkd/## vshhfk## dw## Zruog## Hfrqrplf## Iruxp/## Gdyrv/# Vzlw}huodqg/#Mdqxdu|#53341# # # 7## Mhiiu|## Iulhghq/## ᄈJoredo## Lpedodqfhv/## Qdwlrqdo## Uhedodqflqj/## dqg## wkh# Srolwlfdo## Hfrqrp|## ri## Uhfryhu|/ᄡ## zrunlqj## sdshu/## Frxqflo## rq## Iruhljq# Uhodwlrqv/#Qhz#\run/#533<1# # # #
8#Lelg1# # 9## ᄈOhdghuvᄊ## Vwdwhphqw=## Wkh## Slwwvexujk## Vxpplw/ᄡ## Slwwvexujk## Vxpplw/# zzz1slwwvexujk#vxpplw1jry2phgldfhqwhu245<96<1kwp/#Vhswhpehu#58/#533<1# # # # # :## P1## Jrogvwhlq## dqg## Q1## Odug|/## Wkh## Ixwxuh## ri## Fklqdᄊv## H{fkdqjh## Udwh# Srolf|## +Zdvklqjwrq/## GF=## Shwhuvrq## Lqvwlwxwh## iru## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Hfrqrplfv/# 533<,1# ;## Vhh## Gdql## Urguln/## ᄈWkh## Uhdo## H{fkdqjh## Udwh## dqg## Hfrqrplf## Jurzwk/ᄡ# zrunlqj#sdshu/#Nhqqhg|#Vfkrro#ri#Jryhuqphqw/#Kduydug#Xqlyhuvlw|/#533;1# # # # # # # # # <#Vhh#Jhrujh#Prqelrw/#ᄈNh|qhv#Lv#Lqqrfhqw=#Wkh#Wr{lf#Vsdzq#ri#Euhwwrq# # # # # # # # # # # # Zrrgv#Zdv#Qr#Sodq#ri#Klv/ᄡ#Jxdugldq/#Qryhpehu#4;/#533;1# # # # # # # # # # 43#Vhh#Hvzdu#V1#Sudvdg/#ᄈLv#wkh#Fklqhvh#Jurzwk#Pludfoh#Exlow#wr#OdvwBᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # # # Fklqd#Hfrqrplf#Uhylhz#53#+533<,=#436ᄆ561# # # # # # 44## Hfrqrplvwv## zloo## vhh## wkdw## L## dp## dujxlqj## khuh## wkdw## wkh## lqfrph## hiihfw# vzdpsv#wkh#vxevwlwxwlrq#hiihfw1# # # # 45#Vhh#Wduxq#Nkdqqd#dqg#\dvkhqj#Kxdqj/#ᄈFdq#Lqgld#Ryhuwdnh#FklqdBᄡ# # # # # # # # # # # Iruhljq#Srolf|#+Mxo|ᄆDxjxvw#5336,=#:8ᄆ;41# # # # #
Hslorjxh# # 4#Flwhg#lq#ᄈFrxqwlqj#Wkhlu#Eohvvlqjv/ᄡ#Hfrqrplvw/#Mdqxdu|#5/#53431# # # # # # # # # #
LQGH[ #
Wkh## lqgh{## wkdw## dsshduhg## lq## wkh## sulqw## yhuvlrq## ri## wklv## wlwoh## zdv## lqwhqwlrqdoo|# uhpryhg## iurp## wkh## h0Errn1## Sohdvh## xvh## wkh## vhdufk## ixqfwlrq## rq## |rxu## h0Uhdglqj# ghylfh#wr#vhdufk#iru#whupv#ri#lqwhuhvw1#Iru#|rxu#uhihuhqfh/#wkh#whupv#wkdw#dsshdu#lq# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # wkh#sulqw#lqgh{#duh#olvwhg#ehorz1# # # # # #
diirugdeoh#krxvlqj#pdqgdwh# # # Dohvlqd/#Doehuwr# # # Dojhu/#Krudwlr# # # doskd#+h{fhvv#uhwxuqv,# Doskdwhf# Dphulfdq## Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Jurxs## +DLJ,=## edlorxw## ri## frpshqvdwlrq# ri## hpsor|hhv## dqg## pdqdjhuv## ri## fuhglw## ghidxow## vzdsv## ri# fxvwrphuv#ri#ilqdqfldo#sureohpv#ri#Ilqdqfldo#Surgxfwv#xqlw#ri# # # # # # # # # Dqjhohwrv/#Jhrujh0Pdulrv# # dqqxlwlhv# # dqwlwuxvw#uhjxodwlrqv# # # # # # # Dujhqwlqd=#J053#phpehuvkls#ri#vwdwh0rzqhg#hqwhusulvhv#lq# Dulvwrwoh# # # # # # dupᄊv#ohqjwk#v|vwhpv=#ri#hpsor|phqw#ilqdqfldo# Dvld=## hfrqrplf## jurzwk## lq## h{fkdqjhudwh## srolflhv## lq## h{sruwv## ri# ilqdqfldo## fulvlv## ri## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpv## lq## iruhljq## ghew## ri# jryhuqphqwv## lq## uhfryhu|## iurp## fulvlvvdylqjv## lq/## Vhh## dovr# vshflilf#frxqwulhv# # dvvhw0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv1#Vhh#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv# # # # # dvvhw#sulfhv=#ghsduwxuhv#iurp#ixqgdphqwdov#lqfuhdvhv#lq#Vhh#dovr# # # # # # # # # krxvlqj#pdunhw # Dxvwudold/#hfrqrplf#jurzwk#ri # # # dxwrpreloh#lqgxvwu|=#jryhuqphqw # # edlorxwv#ri#lq#Lqgld # # #
Edjhkrw/#Zdowhu# # edlorxwv=#ri#DLJ#ri#dxwrpreloh#lqgxvwu|#ri#edqnv#ri#Idqqlh#Pdh# # # # # # # # # # # dqg#Iuhgglh#Pdf#srolwlfdo#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri#vkruwfrplqjv#ri# # # # # # # # Edqn#ri#Dphulfd# # # # # Edqn#ri#Mdsdq# # # # Edqn#ri#Qruwk#Gdnrwd# edqnuxswflhv# edqnv=## edlorxwv## ri## erdugv## ri## FHRv## ri## frpshqvdwlrq## lq# # # # # # # # # # frpshwlwlrq#dprqj#ghew#ri#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh#iru#ghsrvlwv#lq#lq# ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## idloxuhv## ri## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhp## urohv## ri# ohqglqj## vwdqgdugv## ri## ordqv## wr## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## e|# pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#khog#e|# # # # pruwjdjh## ohqglqj## surfhvv## ri## riiᄆedodqfh## vkhhw## dvvhwv## ri# rujdql}dwlrqdo## frpsoh{lw|## ri## shuirupdqfh## phdvxuhphqw## lq# srzhu## ri## sursulhwdu|#wudglqj#e|#uhjlrqdo#uhyroylqj#grru# # # # # # # zlwk# jryhuqphqw## ulvn## h{srvxuhv## ri## ulvn## pdqdjhuv## lq## uxudo# vkduhkroghuv## ri## vkruw0whup## ghew## ri## vwdwh0rzqhg## vwrfn## sulfhv# ri/## wrr## v|vwhplf## wr## idlo## wudqvsduhqw## vwuxfwxuhv## ri## Vhh## dovr# fhqwudo## edqnv>## ilqdqfldov|vwhpv>## lqyhvwphqw## edqnv># uhjxodwlrqedqnlqj# Edurivn|/#Qhlo# # Ehdu#Vwhduqv# # ehkdylrudo#hfrqrplfv# # Ehqduw}l/#Vkorpr# # ehqfkpdunlqj# Ehuqdqnh/#Ehq# # Eorrpehuj/#Plfkdho# # erqg#kroghuv# # erqgv=#fryhuhg#lqvxuhuv#ri#Vhh#dovr# # # # # # # jryhuqphqw#erqgv>#lqwhuhvw# # # udwhv# Eudqghlv/#Orxlv# # Eud}lo=## hfrqrplf## uhirupv## lq## h{fkdqjh0udwh## srolflhv## ri## ilqdqfldo# fulvlv#lq#lqwhuhvw#vsuhdgv#lq# # # # # eurnhuv/#pruwjdjh# #
Eurzq/#Jrugrq# # exeeohv=#ghyhorsphqw#ri# # # # grw0frp## Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh# # # srolflhv## dqg# lq#Mdsdq/#Vhh#dovr#krxvlqj#pdunhw# # # # # # exgjhw#ghilflwv/#ihghudo# # # exiihuv/#fdslwdo# # exuhdxfudflhv# # # # Exvk/#Jhrujh#K1#Z1# # # Exvk/#Jhrujh#Z1# # # # Exvk#+Jhrujh#Z1,#dgplqlvwudwlrq# # # exvlqhvvhv1#Vhh#ilupv# exvlqhvv#vfkrrov# # Fdorplulv/#Fkduohv#Z1# # # Fdpghvvxv/#Plfkho# # Fdqdgd/## khdowk## fduh## frvwv## lq## fdslwdo=## exiihuv## frqwlqjhqw# rujdql}dwlrqdo## sk|vlfdo## uhtxluhphqwv## iru## edqnv## yhqwxuh## Vhh# dovr#kxpdq#fdslwdo# # # fdslwdolvp=## frpshwlwlyh## pdunhwv## lq## furq|/## iuhh0hqwhusulvh/# uhodwlrqvkls#+pdqdjhg,#vhoi0lqwhuhvw#lq# # # # Fduylooh/#Mdphv# # Fdvvdqr/#Mrvhsk# # Fd|qh/#Mdphv# # FGRv1#Vhh#froodwhudol}hg#ghew#reoljdwlrqv# # # # # fhqwudo## edqnv=## Fklqhvh## ri## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## remhfwlyhv## ri# sxufkdvhv## ri## groodu## dvvhwv## uhjxodwru|## uhvsrqvlelolwlhv## ri# uhvrxufhv## iru## pdqdjlqj## fulvhv## Vhh## dovr## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh># lqwhuhvw#udwhv>#prqhwdu|#srolf|# # # # fkdherov# Fkdqrv/#Mdphv# # fkdulwdeoh#jlylqj# # fkduwhu#vfkrrov# # fkloguhq=## Fklqhvh## rqh0fklog## srolf|## ghyhorsphqw## ri## khdowk## dqg# qxwulwlrq#ri/#Vhh#dovr#hgxfdwlrq# # # # # Fkloh/#hfrqrplf#jurzwk#ri# # # #
Fklqd=#frqvxpswlrq#lq#hfrqrplf#jurzwk#ri#hqhuj|#frqvxpswlrq# # # # # # # # lq#h{fkdqjh0udwh#lqwhuyhqwlrq#e|#h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk#vwudwhj|#ri# # # # # # # # h{sruwv## ri## iruhljq## uhvhuyhv## ri## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## lq## lqyhvwphqw## lq# plggoh#fodvv#lq#rqh0fklog#srolf|#ri#uhirupv#lq#vdylqjv#lq#vwdwh0 # # # # # # # # # # rzqhg#hqwhusulvhv#lq# # # Fku|vohu# # # # Flwljurxs=#erdug#phpehuv#ri# # # # # # # # # # # FHR#ri#riiᄆedodqfh#vkhhw#dvvhwv#ri#ulvn#pdqdjhuv#ri#ulvnv#wdnhq# # # # # # e|#vdodulhv#lq#vwrfn#sulfh#ri# # folpdwh#fkdqjh# # Folqwrq/#Eloo# # Folqwrq#dgplqlvwudwlrq# # # # # FORv1#Vhh#froodwhudol}hg#ordq#reoljdwlrqv# frjqlwlyh#fdswxuh# # Froh/#Vkdzq# # froodwhudol}hg#ghew#reoljdwlrqv#+FGRv,# # # # froodwhudol}hg#ordq#reoljdwlrqv#+FORv,# # # # froohjhv1#Vhh#kljkhu#hgxfdwlrq# # # # Frppxqlw|#Uhlqyhvwphqw#Dfw#+FUD,# # # # frqjorphudwhv# frqvxpswlrq=## lq## Fklqd## lq## ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # glvfrxudjhphqw# ri#ri#hqhuj|#h{fhvv#lq#Mdsdq#ri#plggoh#fodvv#srolwlfdo#suhvvxuh# # # # # # # # # # # iru#hfrqrplf#vwlpxoxv#wr#lq#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # frqwlqjhqw#fdslwdo# # fruuxswlrq# FUD1## Vhh## Frppxqlw|## Uhlqyhvwphqw## Dfw## fuhglw=## ehqhilwv## dqg# frvwv#ri#hdv|#ghilqlwlrq#ri#ghprfudwl}dwlrq#ri# # # # # # # fuhglw#fdug#ghew# # # fuhglw#ghidxow#vzdsv# # # fuhglw## pdunhwv=## dffhvv## wr## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## h{sdqvlrq## ri# jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq## lqirupdo## plfurfuhglw## srolwlfdo# suhvvxuh#iru#hdv|#fuhglw#Vhh#dovr#vxesulph#pruwjdjh#pdunhw# # # # # # # # # fuhglw#udwlqjv/#ri#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv# # # # # fulvhv1#Vhh#ilqdqfldo#fulvhv# # # #
furq|#fdslwdolvp# # fxuuhqflhv1#Vhh#h{fkdqjh0udwh#srolflhv# # # # fxuuhqw0dffrxqw#edodqfhv# # ghew=## frqvxphu## jryhuqphqw## krxvhkrog## qhjdwlyh## ylhzv## ri/Vhh# dovr#fuhglw#pdunhwv>#iruhljq#ghew>#pruwjdjhv# # # # # # Ghirh/#Gdqlho/#D#Sodq#ri#wkh#Hqjolvk#Frpphufh# # # # # # # # ghpdqg=## lq## krxvlqj## pdunhw## lqwhuhvw## udwh## ohyhov## dqg## lq## Xqlwhg# Vwdwhv/#Vhh#dovr#frqvxpswlrq# # # # ghprfudflhv# ghprfudwl}dwlrq#ri#fuhglw# # # Ghqqlv/#Zlooldp# # ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh# # ghuhjxodwlrq# # # # edqnv## ri## frqvxpswlrq## lq## fxuuhqw0 ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv=#fhqwudo# # # dffrxqw#vxusoxvhv#ri# # # # hfrqrplf#jurzwk#ri#h{fhvv# # # # vdylqjv#ri#h{fkdqjh0udwh#srolflhv# # # # ri/#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv#ri# # # iruhljq#ghew#ri# iruhljq# # # # h{fkdqjh#uhvhuyhv#ri#iruhljq# # # lqyhvwphqw#lq#plfurfuhglw# # # # lq#rujdql}dwlrqdo#fdslwdo#lq# # # # sryhuw|#lq#wudgh#ghilflwv# # # # ri#wudgh#vxusoxvhv#ri# # Glprq/#Mdplh# # glvdelolw|#sd|phqwv# # grw0frp#exeeoh# # Grxwkdw/#Urvv# # hduo|#ghyhorshuv# # hduwktxdnh/#Kdlwldq#
hduwktxdnh#lqvxudqfh# # Hdvw#Dvld1#Vhh#Dvld>#vshflilf#frxqwulhv# # # # # # Hdvw#Lqgld#Frpsdq|# # # hfrqrplf## jurzwk=## ri## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## uroh# lq#joredo#srolf|#frruglqdwlrq#iru#ri#lqgxvwuldo#frxqwulhv#ri#odwh# # # # # # # # # # ghyhorshuv#prghudwhg#ioxfwxdwlrqv#lq#prqhwdu|#srolf|#dqg#Vhh# # # # # # # # dovr#h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk#vwudwhjlhv>#uhfhvvlrqv# # # # # hfrqrplvwv=#ghedwhv#rq#fuhglw#dffhvv# # # # # idlolqjv#ri#whfkqrorj|#xvhg# # # # hgxfdwlrq=## dffrxqwdelolw|## fodvv## vl}hv## glvwdqfh## hduo|## fklogkrrg# idplo|## lqioxhqfhv## dqg## irupdo## kxpdq## fdslwdo## irupdwlrq# lpsurylqj## txdolw|## ri## lqfuhdvhg## dwwdlqphqw## udwhv## lqhtxdolw|## lq# lqwulqvlf#zruwk# # # ri#Qr# # # Fklog## Ohiw#Ehklqg# # # Dfw#rqjrlqj#sduhqwdo# # # fkrlfh## txdolw|## ri## uhodwlrqvkls## wr## lqfrphv## vfkrro## |hdu## ohqjwkv# vwxghqw## shuirupdqfh## ri## whdfkhuv## whdfklqj## txdolw|## whfkqrorj|# lq/#Vhh#dovr#kljkhu#hgxfdwlrq# # # # # hiilflhqw#pdunhwv#k|srwkhvlv# # # hohydwru#odglhv# # Hol}dehwk#L/#Txhhq# # # Hpeudhu# Hppdqxho/#Udkp# # hpsor|phqw=## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## srolflhv## dqg## klulqj## surfhvv## dqg# mreohvv## uhfryhulhv## od|riiv## prwlydwlrqv## lq## rq0wkh0mre## wudlqlqj# srolwlfdo## suhvvxuh## iru## hfrqrplf## vwlpxoxv## sruwdeoh## ehqhilwv# vdeedwlfdov## vnloov## qhhghg## lq## whfkqrorjlfdo## fkdqjh## dqg# whpsrudu|#Vhh#dovr#oderu#irufh>#xqhpsor|phqw#udwhv# # # # # # # hpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv1#Vhh#khdowk#lqvxudqfh# # # # # hqhuj|#xvh# # Hqjodqg/#Vhh#dovr#Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp# # # # # Hqurq# hqylurqphqwdo#vxvwdlqdelolw|# # Hxursh=#fryhuhg#erqgv#khog#e|#edqnv#ilupv#lq/#Vhh#dovr#vshflilf# # # # # # # # # # # frxqwulhv# Hxurshdq#Fhqwudo#Edqn# # # Hxurshdq## Xqlrq## +HX,h{fkdqjh0udwh## srolflhv=## ri## Eud}lo## ri## Fklqd# ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#ri#Lqgld#ri#Mdsdq# # # # # # #
h{shfwdwlrqv#k|srwkhvlv# # h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk## vwudwhjlhv=## ri## Fklqd## ghshqghqfh## rq## iruhljq# frqvxphuv/## lq## ixwxuh#ri# # # Jhupdq|#ri# # # Mdsdq## ri## odwh#ghyhorshuv# # pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp## dqg## vxffhvv## ri## wudqvlwlrq## wr## edodqfhg# hfrqrp|#zhdnqhvvhv#ri# # # h{sruwv=#ri#Fklqd/#ri#Lqgld#ri#Mdsdq/#ri#Vrxwk#Nruhd#ri#Wdlzdq/# # # # # # # # # # # # Vhh#dovr#wudgh# # # Wkh## Ideoh## ri## wkh## Ehhv## +Pdqghylooh,## idplo|## lqioxhqfhv## rq# hgxfdwlrq#dqg#kxpdq#fdslwdo# # # # Idqqlh## Pdh## +Ihghudo## Qdwlrqdo## Pruwjdjh## Dvvrfldwlrq,=# hvwdeolvkphqw#ri#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#lq#jryhuqphqw#wdnhryhu#ri/# # # # # # # # ohqglqj## wr## vxssruw## krxvlqj## sulfhv## orvvhv## ri## pdqgdwh## ri# pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## e|/## uhirupv## ri## uroh## lq# vxesulph#fulvlv# # idxow## olqhv=## frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## lq## ixwxuh## jhrorjlfdo## lqfrph# lqhtxdolw|## lq## Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv## dv## lqwhudfwlrq## ri## dupᄊv0ohqjwk## dqg# uhodwlrqvkls0edvhg## ilqdqfldo## v|vwhpv## srolwlfdo## uhirupv## qhhghg# wr#dgguhvv#v|vwhplf#wudgh#lpedodqfhv# # # # # IGLF#Lpsuryhphqw#Dfw#ri# # # # Ihghudo#Ghsrvlw#Lqvxudqfh#Frusrudwlrq#+IGLF,# # # # # Ihghudo#Krph#Ordq#Pruwjdjh#Frusrudwlrq1#Vhh#Iuhgglh#Pdf# # # # # # # # Ihghudo#Krxvlqj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq#+IKD,# # # # Ihghudo#Qdwlrqdo#Pruwjdjh#Dvvrfldwlrq1# # # # Vhh#Idqqlh#Pdh# # # Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh=#Ehuqdqnh#dv#fkdlupdq#ri#Ehuqdqnh#dv#jryhuqru# # # # # # # # # ri## hvwdeolvkphqw#ri# # # Juhhqvsdq## dv## fkdlupdq## ri## Juhhqvsdq## sxw# dqg## khdowk|0hfrqrp|## pdqgdwh## ri## lqghshqghqfh## ri## lqiodwlrq0 iljkwlqj#srolflhv# # # ri## lqioxhqfh#ri# # # lqwhuhvw0udwh#fxwv# # # e|/## lqwhuhvw0 udwh## klnhv## e|## lqwhuhvw0udwh## srolflhv## ri## plvwdnhv## e|## pruwjdjh0 edfnhg## vhfxulw|#sxufkdvhv# # # e|#remhfwlyhv# # # ri## srolwlfdo#suhvvxuhv# # rq## uhirupv## ri## uhjxodwru|## uhvsrqvlelolwlhv## ri## uhvsrqvhv## wr# uhfhvvlrq#ri#Vxuyh|#ri#Frqvxphu#Ilqdqfhv# # # # # # Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Ndqvdv#Flw|# # # # # # Ihogvwhlq/#Pduwlq# # Ihujxvrq/#Qldoo# # IKD1#Vhh#Ihghudo#Krxvlqj#Dgplqlvwudwlrq# # # # #
ilqdqfldo## fulvhv=## ri## Dvldq## +4<<;,## lq## Lqgld## lq## Mdsdq## Ph{lfdq# +4<<7,## uhvlolhqfh#ri# # # v|vwhpv## uhvrxufhv## iru## pdqdjlqj#Vhh# # # dovr# idxow#olqhv# # ilqdqfldo#pdunhwv#Vhh#dovr#vhfxulwl}dwlrq>#vwrfn#pdunhw# # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv=#dupᄊv#ohqjwk/#frpshwlwlrq#lq#ghuhjxodwlrq#ri#ri# # # # # # # # # ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## hfrqrplf## jurzwk## dqg## lqfhqwlyhv## lq# lqqrydwlrq## lq## prqhwdu|## srolf|## dqg## sxeolf## glvwuxvw## ri# uhgxqgdqf|## lq## uhirupv## lq## uhjxodwlrq## ri## uhodwlrqvkls0edvhg# uhvlolhqfh#ri/#Vhh#dovr#edqnv>#lqyhvwphqw#edqnv# # # # # # # ilupv=## frqjorphudwhv## gliihuhqfhv## ehwzhhq## Dphulfdq## dqg## rwkhu# srolwlfdo#srzhu#ri#uhjxodwlrq#ri/Vhh#dovr#edqnv# # # # # # # ilvfdo## vwlpxoxv=## glvfuhwlrqdu|## lq## mreohvv## uhfryhulhv## Nh|qhvldq# grfwulqh#ri#Redpd#dgplqlvwudwlrq#sdfndjh#+533<,#srolwlfdo# # # # # # # suhvvxuh#iru#lq#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # IQPD#+Ihghudo#Qdwlrqdo#Pruwjdjh#Dvvrfldwlrq,1#Vhh#Idqqlh#Pdh# # # # # # # # irrg#sulfhv# # iruhljq## ghew=#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#ilfnohqhvv#ri#ilqdqfhuv/#lq# # # # # # # # iruhljq#fxuuhqflhv/#Ph{lfdq#fulvlv#+4<<7,#uhgxflqj#vkruw0whup# # # # # # # iruhljq#h{fkdqjh#uhvhuyhv=#ri#Fklqd#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv# # # # # # # # iruhljq## lqyhvwphqw=## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## lq## Hdvw## Dvld## lq# pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv#lq#X1V1#jryhuqphqw#erqgv# # # # # # Iruprvd#Sodvwlfv#Jurxs# # # Iudqfh=## dqqxlwlhv## vrog## e|## prqdufk|## dxwrpreloh## lqgxvwu|## lq# hqhuj|## frqvxpswlrq## lq## khdowk## fduh## frvwv## lq## vrfldo## zhoiduh# vshqglqj#lq#vwdwh0rzqhg#hqwhusulvhv#lq#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv# # # # # # # lq# Iudqnolq/#Ehqmdplq# # iudxg# Iuhgglh## Pdf## +Ihghudo## Krph## Ordq## Pruwjdjh## Frusrudwlrq,=# hvwdeolvkphqw#ri# # # iruhljq## lqyhvwruv## lq## jryhuqphqw#wdnhryhu# # # ri# ohqglqj## wr## vxssruw## krxvlqj## sulfhv## orvvhv## ri## pdqgdwh## ri# pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## lvvxhg## e|## uhirupv## ri## uroh## lq# vxesulph#fulvlv# # iuhh0hqwhusulvh#fdslwdolvp# # Iuhqfk/#Nhq# # Iuhqfk#Uhyroxwlrq# #
Iulhghq/#Mhiiu|# # Ixog/#Ulfkdug# # J0:#+Jurxs#ri,# # # J053#+Jurxs#ri,# # # Jhoedqg/#Plfkdho# # Jhqghu/#Urehuw# # Jhqhudo#Prwruv# # Jhupdq|=## edqnv## lq## hqhuj|## frqvxpswlrq## lq## h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk# vwudwhj|#ri# # # khdowk## fduh#frvwv# # # lq## Odqghvedqnv## lq## vrfldo#zhoiduh# # vshqglqj#lq#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv#lq#Zhlpdu#Uhsxeolf# # # # # # # Jlqqlh#Pdh#+Jryhuqphqw#Qdwlrqdo#Pruwjdjh#Dvvrfldwlrq,# # # # # # Jodvv0Vwhdjdoo#Dfw#ri# # # joredo#hfrqrplf#jryhuqdqfh#uhirupv# # # # JQPD## +Jryhuqphqw## Qdwlrqdo## Pruwjdjh## Dvvrfldwlrq,1## Vhh# Jlqqlh#Pdh# # Jroglq/#Fodxgld# # Jrogpdq#Vdfkv# # jryhuqphqw#erqgv=#iruhljq#lqyhvwruv#lq/#ulvn#suhplxp#rq# # # # # # # # jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq=## dwwlwxghv## wrzdug## fruuxswlrq## dqg## lq# fuhglw#pdunhwv#lq# # # # hduo|#ghyhorshuv#h{shfwdwlrqv#ri# # # # # lq## ilqdqfldo# v|vwhpv## lq## krxvlqj## pdunhw## lq## Lqgld## olplwdwlrqv## ri## pdqdjhg# fdslwdolvp## vwudwhj|## lq## pdunhw## hfrqrplhv## sulydwh## vhfwru# lqioxhqfh## rq## uhgxflqj## ulvn## wdnlqj## dqg## uroh## lq## ilqdqfldo## fulvlv# vwdwh0rzqhg#hqwhusulvhv#xqlqwhqghg#frqvhtxhqfhv#ri/#Vhh#dovr# # # # # # # h{fkdqjh0udwh#srolflhv>#h{sruwohg#jurzwk#vwudwhjlhv>#uhjxodwlrq# # # # # # Jryhuqphqw#Qdwlrqdo#Pruwjdjh#Dvvrfldwlrq1#Vhh#Jlqqlh#Pdh# # # # # # # jryhuqphqw0vsrqvruhg## hqwhusulvhv## +JVHv,1## Vhh## Idqqlh## Pdh># Iuhgglh#Pdf>#Jlqqlh#Pdh# # # # Judshv#ri#Zudwk#+Vwhlqehfn,# # # # Juhdw#Ghsuhvvlrq# # juhhg# Juhhqvsdq/#Dodq# # Juhhqvsdq#sxw# #
jurzwk1#Vhh#hfrqrplf#jurzwk>#h{sruw0ohg# # # # # jurzwk#vwudwhjlhv# # JVHv## +jryhuqphqw0vsrqvruhg## hqwhusulvhv,1## Vhh## Idqqlh## Pdh># Iuhgglh# Pdf>#Jlqqlh#Pdh# # # Kdlwldq#hduwktxdnh# # Kduw/#Urehuw#P1# # # Kd|hn/#Iulhgulfk#yrq# # # Khdg#Vwduw# # khdowk## fduh=## frvw0hiilflhqf|## ri## lq## ghyhorslqj## frxqwulhv## phglfdo# wrxulvp# khdowk## lqvxudqfh=## dgyhuvh0vhohfwlrq## sureohp## ri## frvwv## ri# hpsor|phqw0edvhg/## lq## Hxursh## uhirup## dfw## +5343,uhtxluhg# vxevlglhv#iru#xqlyhuvdo#X1V1#v|vwhp#ri# # # # # # Khfnpdq/#Mdphv# # khgjh#ixqgv# # Khqu|#YLL/#Nlqj# # # Kh|pdwk# kljkhu#hgxfdwlrq=#exvlqhvv#vfkrrov#frvwv#ri#hquroophqw#dvvlvwdqfh# # # # # # # # iru#ixwxuh#ri#judgxdwlrq#udwhv#ri#uhodwlrqvkls# # # # # # # wr#lqfrphv# # kljk#vfkrro#judgxdwlrq#udwhv/#Vhh#dovr#hgxfdwlrq# # # # # # # Kloohu|/#Uxwklh# # ᄊv#Ordq#Frusrudwlrq# KROF1#Vhh#Krph#Rzqhu# # # # # # Krophv/#Vwhyhq# # krph#htxlw|#ordqv# # # krph## rzqhuvkls=## diirugdeoh## krxvlqj## pdqgdwh## jryhuqphqw# srolflhv#wr#h{sdqg#udwhv#ri#wd{#fuhglwv# # # # # # # Krph#Rzqhu# ᄊv#Ordq#Frusrudwlrq#+KROF,# # # # # Krulrnd/#Fkduohv# # krvslwdov# Krxvlqj#dqg#Xuedq#Ghyhorsphqw#Ghsduwphqw#ri#+KXG,# # # # # # #
krxvlqj#pdunhw=#errp#lq#exvw#lq#fuhglw#h{sdqvlrq#lq#ghpdqg#lq# # # # # # # # # # # hiihfwv## ri## orz## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## lq## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq/# klvwrulfdo## hyroxwlrq## ri## ryhuvxsso|## lq## sulfh## lqfuhdvhv## lq## wd{# euhdnv#lq/#Vhh#dovr#pruwjdjhv>#vxesulph#pruwjdjh#pdunhw# # # # # # # # Kxdqj/#\dvkhqj# # KXG1## Vhh## Krxvlqj## dqg## Xuedq## Ghyhorsphqw/## Ghsduwphqw## ri# kxpdq## fdslwdo=## dffhvv## wr## frpsrqhqwv## ri## ghilqlwlrq## ri# lpsurylqj## qrqfrjqlwlyh## vnloov## wudlqlqj## ydoxh## ri/## Vhh## dovr# hgxfdwlrq# LPI1#Vhh#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo#Prqhwdu|#Ixqg# # # # # lppljudwlrq=#hiihfwv#rq#lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|#loohjdo# # # # # # lpsruwv=#ri#Lqgld#ri#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv#Vhh#dovr#wudgh# # # # # # # # # lqfhqwlyhv=#lq#exuhdxfudflhv#hiihfwv#ri#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv/#lq# # # # # # # # ilqdqfldo#ilupv#lq#jryhuqphqwv#uhirupv#ri# # # # # # iru#ulvn0wdnlqj# # lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|=#dwwlwxghv#wrzdug# # # # # fdxvhv#ri# # # lqfuhdvhv#lq# # # fuhglw# h{sdqvlrq## dqg## hfrqrplf## ehqhilwv## ri## lqfuhdvhv## lq## srolf|# uhvsrqvhv## wr## srolwlfdo## suhvvxuh## iru## hdv|## fuhglw## dqg## srolwlfdo# suhvvxuh#iru#hfrqrplf#vwlpxoxv#dqg#uhgxflqj# # # # # # lqfrphv=#froohjh#suhplxp# # # # ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrq# # # frpshqvdwlrq## ri# khgjh## ixqg## pdqdjhuv## iurp## lqyhvwphqwv## lq## Nhq|d# rssruwxqlwlhv#iru#lqfuhdvlqj#ri#sk|vlfldqv/#Vhh#dovr# # # # # # # # hfrqrplf# jurzwk>#sryhuw|>#zdjhv# # # Lqgld=#Eulwlvk#uxoh#ri#fhqwudo#edqn#ri#frqjorphudwhv#lq#hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # # jurzwk## ri## hfrqrplf## srolflhv## ri## hqhuj|## frqvxpswlrq## lq# h{fkdqjh0udwh## srolflhv## ri## h{sruwv## ri## ilqdqfldo## fulvlv## lq# jryhuqphqw#lqwhuyhqwlrq#lq#fuhglw#pdunhwv#lq#khdowk#fduh#frvwv# # # # # # # # # lqsk|vlfdo#fdslwdo#lq#uhirupv#lq#wudgh#srolflhv#ri# # # # # # # # Lqgrqhvld=#hfrqrplf#fulvlv#lq#LPI#ordqv#wr# # # # # # # lqgxvwuldo#ghyhorsphqw=#hduo|#ghyhorshuv#lq#Lqgld#odwh#ghyhorshuv# # # # # # # # lq#Wdlzdq# # lqhtxdolw|1#Vhh#lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|# # # # lqidqw0lqgxvwu|#surwhfwlrq# # lqiodwlrq=#lq#dvvhw#sulfhv#h{shfwdwlrqv#ri#Ihghudo#Uhvhuyh#srolflhv# # # # # # # # # dqg/#uhodwlrqvkls#wr#xqhpsor|phqw#lq#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # lqqrydwlrq#Vhh#dovr#whfkqrorjlfdo#fkdqjh# # # # #
lqvwlwxwlrqdo#hfrqrplfv# # lqvxudqfh=#erqg#hduwktxdnh#olyholkrrg#pruwjdjh/Vhh#dovr# # # # # # # khdowk# lqvxudqfh>#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv# # # lqwhuhvw## udwhv=## rq## edqn## ghsrvlwv## lq## Fklqd## frqvhtxhqfhv## ri## orz# hiihfwv## ri## h{shfwdwlrqv## k|srwkhvlv## dqg## lqfuhdvhv## wr## iljkw# lqiodwlrq## lq## Mdsdq## orqj0whup## orz## ohyhov## ri## rq## pruwjdjhv## rq# vdylqjv#vkruw0whup/#vsuhdgv#ri#Wd|oru#uxoh#dqg# # # # # # # Lqwhuqdwlrqdo## Prqhwdu|## Ixqg## +LPI,=## Dvldq## ilqdqfldo## fulvlv## dqg# frqglwlrqdolw|## ri## ordqv## lqioxhqfh## ri## Ph{lfdq## ordqv## +4<<7,# srolf|#frruglqdwlrq#uroh#ri#uhirupv#lq#vwdii#ri/#zduqlqjv#derxw# # # # # # # # # # wudgh#lpedodqfhv# # Lqwhuqhw=#frppxqlfdwlqj#zlwk#sxeolf#wkurxjk#glvwdqfh#hgxfdwlrq# # # # # # # xvh#lq#klulqj# # # lqyhvwphqw=#erqg#kroghuv#errp#lq#lq#Fklqd#lq#Hdvw#Dvld#krxvlqj# # # # # # # # # # # lqfrphv#iurp#lq#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvw#v|vwhpv#lq#sk|vlfdo#fdslwdo# # # # # # # # # uhodwlrqvkls#wr#vdylqj/#Vhh#dovr#iruhljq# # # # # # lqyhvwphqw# lqyhvwphqw#edqnv#Vhh#dovr#edqnv# # # # # lqyhvwphqw#pdqdjhuv/#Vhh#dovr#khgjh#ixqgv# # # # # # Mdfnvrq#Kroh#Frqihuhqfhv# # # Mdsdq=#fhqwudo#edqn#ri#frpshwlwlrq#lq#frqvxpswlrq#lq#hfrqrplf# # # # # # # # # jurzwk## ri## hgxfdwlrq## lq## hohydwru## odglhv## lq## hpsor|phqw## lq# hqhuj|## frqvxpswlrq## lq## h{fkdqjh0udwh## srolflhv## ri## h{sruw0ohg# jurzwk## vwudwhj|## ri## h{sruwv## ri/## ilqdqfldo## exeeoh## dqg## fulvlv## lq# khdowk#fduh#frvwv#lq#nhluhwvxv#lq#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp#lq# # # # # # # # # mreohvv## uhfryhulhv=## srolwlfdo## suhvvxuh## iru## hfrqrplf## vwlpxoxv# gxulqj#lq#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # mrev1#Vhh#hpsor|phqw>#oderu#irufh# # # # # Mrkqvrq/#O|qgrq#E1# # # MS#Prujdq# # Ndw}/#Odzuhqfh# # nhluhwvxv# Nhq|d/#jryhuqphqw#h{shqglwxuhv#lq# # # # Nh|qhv/#Mrkq#Pd|qdug# # #
oderu## irufh=## pljudwlrq## ri## prelolw|## ri/## surwhfwlyh## ohjlvodwlrq## dqg# uhvlolhqfh## ri## vnloov## ri## wudlqlqj## zrphq## lq/## Vhh## dovr# hpsor|phqw>#lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|>#zdjhv# # # # oderu#xqlrqv1#Vhh#xqlrqv# # # # odwh#ghyhorshuv# # Ohh#Nxdq#\hz# # # Ohkpdq## Eurwkhuv=#erdug# # # phpehuv## ri## FHR## ri/## froodsvh#ri# # # ulvnv# wdnhq## e|## vdodulhv## lq## vkruw## vhoolqj## e|## vxevlgldulhv## ri## Ohqlq/# Yodglplu# oltxlglw|#Vhh#dovr#prqhwdu|#srolf|# # # # # oltxlglw|#ulvn# # olyholkrrg#lqvxudqfh# # Oxfdv/#Urehuw#H1/#Mu1# # # # Pdgrii/#Ehuqdug# # Pdod|vld=#hfrqrplf#jurzwk#ri# # # # h{sruw0ohg#jurzwk#vwudwhj|#ri# # # # lqyhvwphqw#lq# # pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvp=## lq## Dvld## fkdoohqjhv## ri## h{sruw0ohg## jurzwk# vwudwhjlhv#dqg#lqyhvwphqw#dqg#vxffhvv#ri# # # # # # Pdqghylooh/#Ehuqdug/#Wkh#Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv# # # # # # # pdunhwv1#Vhh#fdslwdolvp>#ilqdqfldo# # # # pdunhwv>#krxvlqj#pdunhw>#sulfhv>#vwrfn# # # # # pdunhw# pduuldjh# PfFduwk|/#Qrodq# # Phglfdlg# phglfdo#fduh1#Vhh#khdowk#fduh>#sk|vlfldqv# # # # # # phglfdo#pdosudfwlfh# # Phglfduh# Phuuloo#O|qfk# # Ph{lfr=#frqglwlrqdo#fdvk#wudqvihuv#ilqdqfldo#fulvlv#ri# # # # # # #
Pldq/#Dwli# # plfurfuhglw# # plggoh#fodvv# pljudwlrq# # # # # # prelolw|=#hfrqrplf#idfwruv#uhvwulfwlqj#ri#zrunhuv# # prghov/#hfrqrplf# # Prkdpdg/#Pdkdwklu# prqhwdu|## srolf|=## fuhglw## h{sdqvlrq## dqg## ilqdqfldo## vwdelolw|## dqg# # # # # # # # krxvlqj#pdunhw#dqg#lpsuryhphqwv#lq#Mdsdqhvh#Nh|qhvldq#odjv# # # # # # # # # # # lq#srolwlfdo#lqioxhqfhv#rq#uhirupv#ri#ri#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv/#Vhh#dovr# fhqwudo#edqnv>#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # prqh|0pdunhw#ixqgv# # prudo#kd}dug# # Prujdq/#M1#S1/#Vhh#dovr#MS#Prujdq# # # # # # # Pruulfh/#Eudg# # pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv=## fuhglw## ulvn## ri## Idqqlh## Pdh## dqg# Iuhgglh## Pdf## lvvxhv## ihghudo## sxufkdvhv## ri## khog## e|## edqnv# lqyhvwruv## lq## udwlqjv## ri## ulvnv## ri/## vxesulph## pruwjdjhv## lq## wdlo# ulvnv#ri#wudqfkhv#ri# # # # pruwjdjh#eurnhuv# # pruwjdjh#lqvxudqfh# # pruwjdjhv=## ghidxowv## rq## ghuhjxodwlrq## ri## wkuliw## lqgxvwu|## IKD# iruhforvxuhv## ri## klvwrulfdo## hyroxwlrq## ri## lqwhuhvw## udwhv## rq# suhgdwru|## ohqglqj## wudglwlrqdo## ohqglqj## surfhvv## iru/## Vhh## dovr# vxesulph#pruwjdjh#pdunhw# # # prwlydwlrqv# pxowlodwhudo## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv=## lqioxhqfh## ri## ohqglqj## e|# uhirupv#ri#Vhh#dovr#Lqwhuqdwlrqdo# # # # # Prqhwdu|#Ixqg>#Zruog#Edqn# # # # pxwxdo#ixqg#pdqdjhphqw#frpsdqlhv# # # # qdwlrqdo## krph## rzqhuvkls## vwudwhj|/## Vhh## dovr## krph## rzqhuvkls# qdwlrqdolvp# Qhkux/#Mdzdkduodo# # Qhz#Fhqwxu|#Ilqdqfldo# # #
Qhz#Ghdo# # Qhz#\run#Flw|# # # # # # # # Qr#Fklog#Ohiw#Ehklqg#Dfw#ri# # qrqfrjqlwlyh#vnloov# # Qruwkhuq#Urfn# # Redpd/#Edudfn# # Redpd#dgplqlvwudwlrq# # # # Riilfh#ri#Wkuliw#Vxshuylvlrq# # RᄊQhdo/#Vwdqoh|# rssruwxqlwlhv# # rujdql}dwlrqdo#fdslwdo# # # # # rzqhuvkls#vrflhw|/#Vhh#dovr#krph# rzqhuvkls# Sdun#Fkxqj#Khh# # # Sdxovrq/#Khqu|#M1# # # Sdxovrq/#Mrkq# # SERF1#Vhh#Shrsohᄊv#Edqn#ri#Fklqd# # # # # # Shqvlrq#Ehqhilw#Jxdudqwhh#Frusrudwlrq# # # # shqvlrqv# Shrsohᄊv#Edqn#ri#Fklqd#+SERF,# # # # # Shxjhrw# # Skloolsv#fxuyh# # # # # # # # # # sk|vlfldqv=#pdosudfwlfh#vxlwv#dqg#vdodulhv#ri#Vhh#dovr#khdowk#fduh# # Slqwr/#Hgzdug# # # # # # # D#Sodq#ri#wkh#Hqjolvk#Frpphufh#+Ghirh,# # # Sod}d#Dffrug#+4<78,# # # srolwlfdo#idxow#olqhv# # # # # # # # # srolwlfv=#hfrqrplfv#dqg#ri#lppljudwlrq#suhvvxuhv#iru#hdv|#fuhglw/# suhvvxuhv#iru#ilvfdo#vwlpxoxv# # # # Srroh/#Nhlwk# # srsxolvw#fuhglw#h{sdqvlrq# # #
Srsxolvw#pryhphqw# # sryhuw|=#f|foh#ri#lq#ghyhorslqj# # # # # # # # frxqwulhv#idplo|#lqvwdelolw|#dqg# # # # rssruwxqlwlhv#iru#hvfdsh#iurp# # Sudvdg/#Hvzdu# # suhgdwru|#ohqglqj# # # # # # # # # # sulfhv=#irrg#ixqfwlrqv#ri/#Vhh#dovr#dvvhw#sulfhv>#krxvlqj#pdunhw># lqiodwlrq# Sulqfh/#Fkduohv# # surihvvlrqdo#fuhghqwldov# # sursulhwdu|#wudglqj# # surwhfwlrqlvp# udflvp# udwlqj#djhqflhv# # Udwr/#Urguljr#gh# # # uhfhvvlrq## ri=## Ihghudo## Uhvhuyh## uhvsrqvhv## wr## ilvfdo## vwlpxoxv# uhvsrqvh#wr#mreohvv#uhfryhu|#iurp# # # # # uhfhvvlrqv=## ri## ri## fohdqvlqj## uroh## ri## mreohvv## uhfryhulhv## iurp# Nh|qhvldq## srolflhv## dqg## ryhuuhdfwlrqv## wr## srolwlfdo#suhvvxuh# # # iru# hfrqrplf#vwlpxoxv#gxulqj# # # uhgxqgdqf|/#lq#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv# # # # uhirupv=## lq## dffhvv## wr## fuhglw## lq## Eud}lo## lq## Fklqd## lq## ghsrvlw# lqvxudqfh## hgxfdwlrqdo## idxow## olqhv## dgguhvvhg## e|## ri## Ihghudo# Uhvhuyh## ilqdqfldo## lq## joredo## hfrqrplf## jryhuqdqfh## jrdov## ri# jxlglqj#sulqflsohv#ri#ri#khdowk#lqvxudqfh#lq#krxvlqj#ilqdqfh#ri# # # # # # # # # # lqfhqwlyhv#lq#Lqgld#ri#prqhwdu|#srolf|#ri#pxowlodwhudo#ilqdqfldo# # # # # # # # # lqvwlwxwlrqv/## qhhg## iru## uhgxflqj## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq# uhgxflqj#vhdufk# # # iru## wdlo#ulvn# # # uhjxodwru|#wruw#ri# # # # xqhpsor|phqw# ehqhilwv# uhjxodwlrq=## dqwlwuxvw## f|foh0surri## hqirufhphqw## ri## idloxuhv## ri# klvwru|## ri## odlvvh}0idluh## lghrorj|## dqg## lq## Qhz## Ghdo## uhirupv## ri# Vhh#dovr#ghuhjxodwlrq# # # uhjxodwlrq/## edqnlqj=## fdslwdo## uhtxluhphqwv## fhqwudo## edqn# uhvsrqvlelolwlhv## iru## frjqlwlyh## fdswxuh## dqg## Frppxqlw|# Uhlqyhvwphqw## Dfw## hiihfwlyhqhvv## ri## hqirufhphqw## ri## klvwru|## ri#
ri## qhz## surgxfwv## uhirupv## ri## uhvroxwlrq## ri## edqn## idloxuhv## ulvn# prqlwrulqj#dqg#wudqvsduhqf|#ri# # # # uhodwlrqvkls#fdslwdolvp1#Vhh#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp# # # # # uhodwlrqvkls#v|vwhpv=#ri#hpsor|phqw#ilqdqfldo# # # # # uhplwwdqfhv# Uhqdxow# # # # # # uhvhdufk#dqg#ghyhorsphqw/#Vhh#dovr#lqqrydwlrq# Uhvhuyh#Edqn#ri#Lqgld# # # # uhvlolhqfh=#ri#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhpv#ri#zrunhuv# # # # # # uhwluhphqw## vdylqjv## uhwxuqv=## doskd## uhodwlrqvkls## wr## ulvn## ulvn=## edqn# h{srvxuhv## ri## ghidxow## hiihfwv## ri## jryhuqphqw## lqwhuyhqwlrq## lq# ilqdqfldo## vhfwru## lqfhqwlyhv## iru## wdnlqj## lqirupdwlrq## qhhghg## iru# prqlwrulqj## lqwhuhvw## udwh## ohyhov## dqg## oltxlglw|/## lqpruwjdjh0 edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## uhodwlrqvkls## wr## uhwxuq## xqghusulflqj## ri## Vhh# dovr#wdlo#ulvnv# # # ulvn#pdqdjhuv# # Urguln/#Gdql# # Urrvhyhow/#Iudqnolq#G1# # # Urvhqwkdo/#Krzdug# # Uxelq/#Urehuw# # Uxvvld# V)S#rswlrqv#sulfhv# # # vdeedwlfdov# vdihw|#qhw=#frqglwlrqdo#fdvk#wudqvihuv#frvwv#ri#lq#Hxursh#srolwlfdo# # # # # # # # # # dwwlwxghv## wrzdug## vrfldo#vhfxulw|#vwuhqjwkhqlqj#lq# # # # # Xqlwhg## Vwdwhv# Vhh#dovr#khdowk#lqvxudqfh>#xqhpsor|phqw#ehqhilwv# # # # # # Vdodp/#Uhlkdq# # Vdolqdv#gh#Jruwdul/#Fduorv# # # # Vdpxhovrq/#Urehuw#M1# # # ᄈVdyh#Pruh#Wrpruurzᄡ#sodq# # # # vdylqjv=## lq## Dvld/## jryhuqphqw## srolflhv## wr## hqfrxudjh## krxvhkrog# lqfuhdvlqj#lqwhuhvw#udwhv# # # # rq## udwhv## ri## uhodwlrqvkls## wr## lqyhvwphqw# uhwluhphqw/#vkruwdjhv#ri# # #
vfkrrov1#Vhh#hgxfdwlrq# # # Vfkxpshwhu/#Mrvhsk# # vflhqwlilf#uhvhdufk# # vhfxulwl}dwlrq=## ehqhilwv## ri## froodwhudol}hg## ghew## reoljdwlrqv# froodwhudol}hg## ordq## reoljdwlrqv## ri## Iuhqfk## dqqxlwlhv## lqqrydwlyh# surgxfwv/#Vhh#dovr#pruwjdjh0edfnhg#vhfxulwlhv# # # # # vhoi0lqwhuhvw# Vkloohu/#Urehuw# # vkruw#vhoohuv# # Vlqkd/#\dvkzdqw# # vnloo0edvhg#whfkqlfdo#fkdqjh# # # Vplwk/#Dgdp# # vrfldolvwv# # # # # # vrfldo#vdihw|#qhw1#Vhh#vdihw|#qhw# vrfldo#vhfxulw|# # Vrfldo#Vhfxulw|#Dfw#ri# # # # Vrunlq/#Dqguhz#Urvv# # # Vrxwk#Nruhd=#fkdherov#lq# # # # hfrqrplf#jurzwk#ri#hfrqrplf#srolflhv#ri#h{sruwv#ri#lqyhvwphqw# # # # # # # # # lq# Vrylhw#Xqlrq# # Vtxdp#Odnh#Zrunlqj#Jurxs# # # # Vwdolq/#Mrvhsk# # vwdwh0rzqhg#edqnv# # vwdwh0rzqhg#hqwhusulvhv# # Vwhlq/#Khuehuw# # Vwhlqehfn/#Mrkq/#Judshv#ri#Zudwk# # # # # vwhulol}hg#lqwhuyhqwlrq# # vwrfn#pdunhw=#edqn#vwrfn#sulfhv#fudvk#ri#+5333,#grw0frp#exeeoh# # # # # # # # # # lq/## hiilflhqw## pdunhwv## k|srwkhvlv## dqg## ryhuydoxdwlrq## ri## sulfh# yrodwlolw|#ri#vwxghqwv1#Vhh#hgxfdwlrq# # # # # vxesulph## pruwjdjh## pdunhw=## errp## lq/## fodvvlilfdwlrq## ri## ordqv# fuhglw## jurzwk## dqg## ghidxowv## lq## jryhuqphqwvsrqvruhg#
hqwhusulvhv## dqg## krxvlqj## sulfhv## dqg## QLQMD#ordqv/# # # ruljlqdwlqj# frpsdqlhv#sulydwh#lvvxhuv#ri#vhfxulwl}dwlrq#lq#vl}h#ri# # # # # # # # Vxeudpdqldq/#Duylqg# # Vxil/#Dplu# # Vxkduwr# v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrqv=## erqg## kroghuv## ri# idfwruv## lq## lpsruwdqfh## ri## suhyhqwlrq## ri## uhgxflqj## qxpehu## ri# ulvnv#wdnhq#e|# # # Wdleel/#Pdww# # wdlo## ulvnv=## gliilfxowlhv## lq## pdqdjlqj## lqfhqwlyhv## iru## wdnlqj## ri# pruwjdjh0edfnhg## vhfxulwlhv## sxeolf## h{srvxuh## ri## uhgxflqj# vhdufk#iru#v|vwhplf#wdnhq#e|#edqnv# # # # # # Wdlzdq=#hfrqrplf# # # jurzwk## ri## h{sruwv## ri## lqgxvwuldo#ghyhorsphqw# # lq#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvp#lq#vwdwh0rzqhg#hqwhusulvhv#lq# # # # # # # WDUS1#Vhh#Wurxeohg#Dvvhw#Uholhi#Surjudp# # # # # # Wdwd#Vwhho# # wd{hv=## fuhglwv## krxvlqj## vxevlglhv## lqfrph/## lq## pdqdjhg## fdslwdolvw# v|vwhpv#pdujlqdo#udwhv#ri#udlvlqj#uhedwhv#ri#uhglvwulexwlyh# # # # # # # # Wd|oru/#Mrkq# # Wd|oru#uxoh# # whdfkhuv=## hgxfdwlrq## ri## klulqj## shuirupdqfh## phdvxuhphqw## ri## Vhh# dovr#hgxfdwlrq# # Whdfk#iru#Dphulfd# # # whfkqlfdo#fkdqjh/#vnloo0edvhg# # # whfkqrorjlfdo#fkdqjh=#hfrqrplf#jurzwk#dqg#lq#hgxfdwlrq#hiihfwv# # # # # # # # rq#mrev#surgxfwlylw|#lqfuhdvhv#dqg#lq#uhfhqw#sdvw# # # # # # # # Wh{dv#Lqvwuxphqwv# # wh{wloh#pdqxidfwxulqj# # Wkdlodqg/#lqyhvwphqw#lq# # # Wkdohu/#Ulfkdug# # Wrftxhylooh/#Doh{lv#gh# # # wrr#elj#wr#idlo#ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv# # # # # # wrr## v|vwhplf## wr## idlo## lqvwlwxwlrqv1## Vhh## v|vwhplfdoo|## lpsruwdqw#
ilqdqfldo#lqvwlwxwlrqv#wruw#uhirup# # # # wudgh=#ghyhorsphqw#ri#lpsruwv#surwhfwlrqlvp#Vhh#dovr#h{sruw0ohg# # # # # # # # jurzwk#vwudwhjlhv# # wudgh#ghilflwv=#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#ri#Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # # # # # # # wudghuv=#frpshqvdwlrq# # # ri## shuirupdqfh#phdvxuhphqw#ri# # # # srvlwlrq# olplwv#iru#ulvn#pdqdjhuv#dqg#ulvnv#wdnhq#e|#vkruw#vhoohuv# # # # # # # # # # wudgh#vxusoxvhv=#ri#ghyhorslqj#frxqwulhv#ri#h{sruwhuv#ri#Mdsdq# # # # # # # # # wudlqlqj# wudqvsduhqf|=## ri## ilqdqfldo## lqvwlwxwlrq## vwuxfwxuhv/## lq## ilqdqfldo# # # # # v|vwhpv#ri#uhjxodwlrq#ydoxh#ri# # # Wuhdvxu|#Ghsduwphqw/#X1V1# # Wuloolq/#Fdoylq# # # # # Wurxeohg#Dvvhw#Uholhi#Surjudp#+WDUS,# XEV# xqhpsor|phqw## ehqhilwv=## gxudwlrq## ri## lq## Hxursh## h{whqvlrqv## ri# klvwru|## ri## lqfhqwlyh## hiihfwv## ri/## ohyhov## ri## suhghwhuplqhg/# frqwlqjhqw#h{whqvlrqv#ri#uhirupv#ri#lq# # # # # # Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # xqhpsor|phqw## udwhv=## mreohvv## uhfryhulhv## uhodwlrqvkls## wr## lqiodwlrq# lq# Xqlwhg#Vwdwhv# # xqlrqv=#whdfkhu#zhdnqhvvhv#ri# # # # Xqlwhg#Nlqjgrp=#ghsrvlw#lqvxudqfh#lq#ilqdqfldo#v|vwhp#ri#khdowk# # # # # # # # # fduh## frvwv## lq## LPI## dqg## srolflhv## lq## Lqgld## wudgh## ri## zrunhuvᄊ# rujdql}dwlrqv#lq# # Xqlwhg#Surjuhvvlyh#Dooldqfh#+XSD,# # # # xqlyhuvlwlhv1#Vhh#kljkhu#hgxfdwlrq# # # # XSD1#Vhh#Xqlwhg#Surjuhvvlyh#Dooldqfh# # # # # Ydqjxdug# yhqwxuh#fdslwdo# # Yrofnhu/#Sdxo# #
zdjhv=#hiihfwv#ri#lppljudwlrq#lqhtxdolw|#lq#lq#pdqdjhg#fdslwdolvw# # # # # # # # # v|vwhpv#plqlpxp/Vhh#dovr#lqfrphv# # # # Zdoolvrq/#Shwhu#M1# # # Zdoo#Vwuhhw#Mrxuqdo# # # # # Zdqj/#\1#F1# # Zdvklqjwrq#Pxwxdo# zhdowk#Vhh#dovr#lqfrph#lqhtxdolw|# # # # # Zhehu/#Pd{# # Zhlpdu#Uhsxeolf# # zhoiduh#surjudpv1#Vhh#vdihw|#qhw# # # # # Zlooxpvwdg/#Urehuw# # zrphq/#oderu#irufh#sduwlflsdwlrq#ri# # # # # zrun/#prwlydwlrqv#lq/#Vhh#dovr#hpsor|phqw# # # # # # Zruog#Edqn# # Zruog#Wudgh#Rujdql}dwlrq#+ZWR,# # # # \lq/#N1#\1# # # ]hgloor/#Huqhvwr# #
Lqkdowvyhu}hlfkqlv# Dfnqrzohgjphqwv# Lqwurgxfwlrq# RQH#Ohw#Wkhp#Hdw#Fuhglw# # # # # WZR#H{sruwlqj#wr#Jurz# # # # WKUHH#Ioljkw|#Iruhljq#Ilqdqflqj# # # # IRXU#D#Zhdn#Vdihw|#Qhw# # # # # ILYH#Iurp#Exeeoh#wr#Exeeoh# # # # # VL[#Zkhq#Prqh|#Lv#wkh#Phdvxuh#ri#Doo#Zruwk# # # # # # # # # VHYHQ#Ehwwlqj#wkh#Edqn# # # # HLJKW#Uhiruplqj#Ilqdqfh# # # QLQH#Lpsurylqj#Dffhvv#wr#Rssruwxqlw|#lq#Dphulfd# # # # # # # WHQ#Wkh#Ideoh#ri#wkh#Ehhv#Uhsod|hg# # # # # # # Hslorjxh# Qrwhv# Lqgh{#
: ; 5; 8: ;4 <; 44: 46: 484 4:4 4<< 54; 575 579 598